id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07483v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07483v2 | T-RAG: Lessons from the LLM Trenches | 2024-02-12T08:45:08 | 2024-06-06T14:42:47 | Masoomali Fatehkia, Ji Kim Lucas, Sanjay Chawla | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLM) have shown remarkable language capabilities
fueling attempts to integrate them into applications across a wide range of
domains. An important application area is question answering over private
enterprise documents where the main considerations are data security, which
necessitates applications that can be deployed on-prem, limited computational
resources and the need for a robust application that correctly responds to
queries. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as the most prominent
framework for building LLM-based applications. While building a RAG is
relatively straightforward, making it robust and a reliable application
requires extensive customization and relatively deep knowledge of the
application domain. We share our experiences building and deploying an LLM
application for question answering over private organizational documents. Our
application combines the use of RAG with a finetuned open-source LLM.
Additionally, our system, which we call Tree-RAG (T-RAG), uses a tree structure
to represent entity hierarchies within the organization. This is used to
generate a textual description to augment the context when responding to user
queries pertaining to entities within the organization's hierarchy. Our
evaluations, including a Needle in a Haystack test, show that this combination
performs better than a simple RAG or finetuning implementation. Finally, we
share some lessons learned based on our experiences building an LLM application
for real-world use. | [
0.070176281,
0.0641539618,
-0.0107694175,
0.0559934378,
-0.0384730436,
-0.0289657544,
-0.0091418289,
0.0176372919,
0.016336523,
-0.0662632808,
-0.031653434,
-0.0055526537,
-0.0374981351,
-0.0037464574,
-0.0124748191,
-0.0075253011,
0.032823436,
-0.0157982968,
-0.0063833934,
-0.0280612465,
0.0147296693,
0.060173396,
0.0286970716,
0.016701879,
0.030362796,
-0.0114345821,
-0.0365159623,
0.0473454706,
-0.0152537115,
0.0072147199,
-0.0190516524,
0.0260367543,
0.0108328266,
0.0451128781,
0.0000022729,
-0.0731054321,
-0.0595646389,
0.0405735336,
-0.0417605378,
0.0204820912,
0.0249606688,
0.0205727685,
-0.0001047968,
0.0171552058,
-0.049956508,
0.0256282575,
0.0175636187,
0.009336099,
0.0711647496,
0.0604818575,
0.0033608531,
-0.0629146248,
0.0120703541,
-0.015181643,
0.0148553895,
-0.0853054225,
0.0064916871,
-0.0041408869,
0.0526667275,
0.0511632487,
0.0386436395,
0.0125015648,
0.0055869999,
0.0021753018,
0.0229291804,
0.0231072921,
-0.0331677459,
0.0033036694,
-0.0265616849,
0.021239873,
0.0896162614,
-0.0088733397,
0.0333814174,
0.0169086047,
0.0171368737,
0.0478237197,
-0.0347214751,
0.0494745523,
-0.0324477404,
-0.0152190812,
0.018771803,
-0.0307141263,
-0.0086985696,
0.0318628587,
-0.0086238617,
0.0668753684,
0.0260972679,
-0.044034142,
-0.0359832533,
-0.0188195743,
0.0310042165,
-0.0675356761,
0.0396637805,
0.0653929189,
0.001240634,
0.0507377088,
-0.0458861142,
-0.03039556,
0.0857767016,
-0.0213017426,
-0.0002597977,
0.005200624,
0.0128579419,
0.0344387926,
-0.0240874458,
0.0311300736,
-0.0249735564,
0.0069574961,
-0.0198246371,
-0.0414318442,
-0.0670372918,
-0.0359343514,
-0.0614118092,
0.0907043666,
-0.0714947432,
-0.0008801769,
-0.0166337639,
0.0537830405,
0.0327309668,
0.0254419912,
0.0036060084,
0.0104615018,
-0.0106908549,
-0.0346961617,
-0.0299284402,
-0.0538759269,
-0.0130324606,
-0.0094751222,
0.0223740805,
-0.0775495693,
0.0181827769,
-0.0069475826,
0.0022546456,
0.0095183421,
-0.01404793,
0.0432547033,
0.0153010078,
-0.0141012464,
-0.0662641749,
-0.0948936343,
-0.0147027923,
-0.0124075096,
-0.0361373983,
-0.1024869978,
0.0015136536,
0.0231582373,
-0.0394887067,
-0.0297750831,
0.0383097082,
0.0725175589,
-0.0299637616,
0.0131461257,
-0.0629452094,
0.0010736942,
0.0567830913,
0.036788594,
0.0634534657,
0.0463210009,
0.0153579339,
0.0509537011,
0.0604963116,
0.0188392829,
0.0031794279,
0.0222532135,
-0.0076597105,
-0.0196608771,
-0.0021073502,
0.0776506886,
-0.0523691624,
-0.010538348,
-0.0195512921,
0.0483435057,
-0.0031967291,
0.0071317633,
0.0289772321,
0.0571826324,
0.0279746149,
0.0102344928,
0.0183206126,
0.0489762984,
-0.0276534241,
-0.0093223918,
0.0023973666,
0.0183977634,
-0.0681804642,
0.013223879,
-0.0014695034,
0.0102370521,
-0.0058212746,
-0.0284287613,
-0.033981353,
0.0245577898,
-0.0407586284,
0.0236667506,
0.0304209888,
0.0520929918,
-0.0195402112,
0.0665644258,
-0.0054455167,
-0.0546370335,
0.0060064252,
-0.0288031772,
0.0107885525,
0.0994757563,
0.0877331272,
-0.0142351734,
-0.0061256015,
-0.0039203744,
-0.0033570428,
0.0605249219,
0.0403319187,
0.0078729196,
-0.0247594863,
-0.0542531945,
-0.0367052257,
-0.0046751099,
0.007414287,
0.0191063918,
0.0117197493,
-0.0100353481,
0.0557211712,
-0.049153626,
-0.0071303225,
0.0140235694,
-0.0303960722,
-0.0189801585,
0.0127300518,
0.0211301092,
0.0089698965,
0.0556145608,
-0.001978968,
0.0373646207,
0.043122258,
0.0053870976,
-0.0353322551,
-0.0694038123,
0.0135796256,
0.0339539386,
-0.0085664168,
-0.0066937306,
0.0239245221,
-0.0013365035,
-0.0212574825,
-0.0410055369,
-0.0230981447,
-0.0751752257,
0.0306965429,
-0.0742437989,
-0.0186042935,
0.0038174377,
-0.0231316406,
-0.0729625374,
0.0553894043,
0.0025311622,
-0.0006493158,
0.0163290184,
-0.007839866,
0.0166435223,
-0.0527173094,
0.0075306548,
-0.0097777173,
-0.0202248357,
0.021933971,
0.0429097489,
0.0182290152,
-0.0461256281,
-0.0307295024,
-0.0840302706,
0.030212922,
-0.0205865353,
0.0608048514,
0.0271843597,
0.0463721976,
-0.0190484077,
-0.0217187181,
-0.051729463,
0.0024726738,
0.015056259,
0.0272008013,
0.0405779108,
0.0139844231,
-0.0458272099,
-0.012602102,
-0.0047111595,
0.0017268887,
0.0093463976,
-0.008662032,
-0.0293232426,
-0.0522476174,
0.0446347445,
-0.0675184801,
0.0032483577,
0.0250885356,
0.0009076626,
0.0144889979,
-0.0321877971,
0.0311839841,
0.0012905565,
0.0248282067,
-0.0063881818,
0.0024828026,
-0.0136507535,
-0.0580211543,
-0.0152785713,
-0.0084466031,
-0.0282218084,
0.0002453845,
-0.037871819,
0.0493443087,
0.011281196,
0.0022108671,
0.000659686,
-0.021396488,
0.0184840355,
0.0018026117,
-0.0157009754,
-0.0234784037,
-0.0521766841,
-0.0011956391,
0.0640972927,
0.0091699436,
-0.048085887,
0.0585590452,
-0.0228567626,
0.00876108,
-0.0349247754,
-0.021285817,
-0.0675563589,
0.0920494571,
-0.0279460009,
0.0401759893,
0.0067610545,
-0.0583957545,
-0.0198456086,
0.0076727001,
0.0243805349,
-0.0668396056,
0.0249112472,
-0.0251977127,
0.0128762685,
-0.0015954019,
-0.0034201297,
-0.0363945924,
-0.0159005132,
-0.0163431037,
0.0039320705,
-0.0258130822,
0.0322425179,
-0.0147989457,
-0.0040633911,
0.0332877226,
-0.0000079628,
0.0004836397,
-0.0260042939,
-0.0294755436,
0.0340114869,
0.0414415784,
-0.0164943598,
0.0168972351,
0.003741812,
0.001521293,
0.0690365434,
0.051246319,
-0.0346881337,
0.0269613788,
-0.0564094894,
0.0303917024,
-0.0716860965,
-0.0350937657,
0.0090580983,
0.0008341817,
-0.0775611326,
-0.0198055822,
0.0662989765,
0.0678168237,
-0.0171394423,
-0.0195954181,
-0.0370351709,
0.0237319097,
0.0352590047,
0.0694913194,
-0.1080410331,
-0.0068414318,
-0.00258233,
0.0455833934,
0.0030727051,
-0.0259191226,
-0.0137441531,
-0.1374054253,
0.0429182723,
-0.0199229475,
0.0062838909,
-0.0009444687,
-0.0407895558,
0.0001047386,
0.0531487316,
-0.0185808428,
0.0577662811,
-0.033816658,
-0.011496108,
-0.010816413,
-0.0182644278,
-0.0144752339,
-0.0022215392,
-0.0133242831,
-0.0123059116,
0.0813998207,
0.0035337477,
0.0142335575,
-0.023249561,
0.0089205448,
-0.0238978676,
0.0288638286,
-0.017959943,
0.0128108859,
-0.0002178854,
0.0179948192,
-0.026125038,
0.0138210962,
-0.013545448,
0.0145112555,
0.0246399399,
0.0441336781,
-0.0487894267,
0.0251555312,
-0.0372904837,
-0.005604113,
-0.0016527397,
0.0628829971,
-0.0026226935,
-0.0097598983,
-0.0321427584,
-0.0193626713,
0.0178859886,
-0.0126576992,
-0.0015081128,
0.0279283263,
-0.0182107091,
-0.0034726372,
-0.0766285136,
-0.0382609777,
0.0074725267,
-0.0025663453,
0.0101782847,
0.0081862314,
-0.0163802356,
-0.0114444122,
-0.0326884501,
-0.0344876274,
-0.0953187123,
0.0294332206,
-0.0155420834,
0.0023924517,
0.0357500203,
-0.0340956822,
-0.0130722979,
-0.0192479305,
-0.0242896248,
-0.0455249324,
-0.0129999751,
0.0188344643,
0.0229340941,
0.0030250133,
-0.014436733,
-0.0589470752,
0.0537729189,
0.0397423655,
-0.0961225331,
0.0138362404,
-0.0083134854,
-0.0063488977,
-0.0098903608,
0.0410541892,
-0.1171966121,
0.0145057561,
-0.0263933614,
0.0277978275,
-0.0072971205,
-0.0755505189,
0.0248516388,
0.0460696928,
-0.0352702141,
0.0197139718,
0.0112200268,
0.0002927142,
0.0584340878,
-0.0715402812,
-0.0290995818,
-0.0030206447,
0.0088736685,
-0.0133518586,
-0.0452531651,
0.0568399057,
0.0146513665,
-0.0487761237,
0.068788141,
-0.040384803,
0.0507312492,
0.0192820095,
0.0178798046,
0.0194642115,
-0.0197972637,
-0.0413478203,
0.0162327345,
-0.0106013622,
0.0621693283,
-0.0142239397,
0.0555997863,
-0.0135634411,
-0.015989935,
-0.0038610522,
0.0149588194,
-0.0872249007,
-0.0513917059,
0.0038075806,
0.0266382117,
0.0195520986,
0.0562469661,
0.0343591087,
-0.037074253,
-0.0024895724,
0.0010797165,
0.0000393316,
0.0342296511,
-0.0692088231,
0.0290398654,
0.0280774273,
-0.0204959605,
0.0264980961,
0.0590961762,
0.0393563583,
-0.0139602954,
-0.037899591,
-0.0303330068,
-0.0720398575,
-0.0391186886,
0.015073197,
0.0603386201,
-0.042059347,
-0.0296148732,
-0.0842486918,
-0.0174805149,
-0.0066165105,
0.0145465061,
-0.0023934776,
-0.0036383825,
0.0633397251,
0.0826976523,
0.0406326167,
-0.0388678238,
-0.0669618025,
0.0349741466,
-0.0851425305,
-0.0119724832,
-0.0108647542,
-6.314904793e-33,
-0.0360311493,
-0.0546795242,
0.0351748504,
-0.0005238468,
0.0088823671,
-0.0003824494,
-0.0137794632,
-0.0042536338,
-0.0234716292,
-0.0328127258,
-0.0270506367,
0.0027260296,
0.0249769967,
0.0302656125,
-0.0039846622,
0.0051532472,
0.0176110845,
-0.0086142868,
0.0039107269,
0.032904774,
0.0497712456,
0.0219060183,
0.0363937393,
-0.0503978729,
0.0459850617,
-0.0379789174,
-0.0155213932,
0.0263159703,
0.0054625319,
0.0478411727,
0.0019818707,
0.0049792095,
0.0044717207,
-0.0068493239,
0.0063247406,
0.0294912662,
-0.0614059903,
-0.0076801251,
0.0234365799,
-0.0247283448,
-0.0313912295,
-0.0293917134,
0.0466928706,
-0.0256136991,
0.0110513987,
0.0298920702,
0.0283964649,
-0.0129104955,
-0.0317804478,
-0.0738872141,
-0.0431236774,
0.0325253047,
0.0260515232,
0.0233068801,
-0.0006449523,
0.0266698524,
0.0032172985,
0.0370643698,
-0.0233403835,
0.0058144052,
0.0009393101,
0.008445194,
0.0675522611,
0.0039660572,
-0.013085492,
0.0047401334,
0.0048670718,
0.030255653,
-0.0141762402,
0.0000422415,
-0.0236222614,
0.0530895963,
0.0214060526,
0.0369699374,
0.0137313064,
0.0037640305,
-0.0427848771,
0.0325252563,
-0.0213065334,
0.0364226811,
0.040610332,
0.0096907252,
-0.0355946086,
0.0255775265,
-0.0080687199,
0.0352227874,
-0.0524118394,
-0.025563458,
0.0245156363,
0.0135656781,
-0.0486523509,
-0.0122461934,
-0.0066004139,
-0.0295707881,
-0.0297818165,
0.0390029885,
0.0110736387,
-0.0223546177,
-0.0238991547,
0.0312372446,
-0.038912002,
0.0156065971,
0.0102726566,
-0.0107818898,
-0.0306124203,
0.0210735109,
0.0020733699,
-0.0273810178,
-0.0756005123,
0.0240926389,
-0.0154941669,
0.0642639324,
-0.0469652154,
-0.0206497684,
0.0454733782,
-0.006048264,
0.0231088437,
0.0551706068,
0.0282913558,
0.0055790795,
-0.0345111266,
-0.0001679056,
0.0113138631,
0.0205704533,
0.000303509,
0.0399332307,
0.0139504168,
0.0369186066,
0.0344942249,
0.0052748602,
-0.0018285397,
0.0418608002,
2.959e-7,
0.0571881756,
0.0249094591,
0.0402854979,
0.0396768712,
0.0140467277,
-0.000326889,
0.0464641899,
0.0254133139,
-0.0137815382,
-0.0426768363,
-0.0111457175,
0.0031462708,
0.0533766523,
0.0512075052,
-0.0937209129,
-0.0122477449,
-0.0428484157,
-0.016259728,
-0.0759527981,
0.0099040754,
0.0794681907,
0.0342009924,
-0.0128085306,
-0.0237681456,
-0.0464230888,
-0.0442988239,
0.0546770059,
0.0232421327,
-0.0096465647,
0.0415880084,
0.0292978492,
0.0425730981,
-0.0037465121,
-0.0058219382,
-0.0263733063,
0.0363928936,
-0.0300388187,
0.0520594865,
-0.0092536956,
-0.0283524636,
0.0223804154,
-0.0949706808,
0.0114208087,
-0.04731033,
0.0665565133,
-0.0145038357,
-0.000850896,
0.0207036547,
-0.0272673052,
-0.0241612699,
-0.0381687917,
-0.0211378261,
-0.0462658368,
0.0169201009,
-0.010528883,
-0.030436758,
0.00098387,
-0.0485798977,
-0.0063958606,
-0.0184735712,
-0.0378625616,
-0.0128792636,
-0.0268699974,
0.0245293453,
-0.0313696153,
-0.0136868153,
0.0003861783,
3.199330118e-34,
0.0036880353,
-0.0040464317,
-0.0372074544,
0.0633603781,
0.0360170975,
0.0148992371,
-0.0107560717,
0.029173186,
0.0137169929,
-0.0683420449,
-0.0061276075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07470v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07470v2 | Pushing The Limit of LLM Capacity for Text Classification | 2024-02-12T08:14:03 | 2024-02-16T15:59:27 | Yazhou Zhang, Mengyao Wang, Chenyu Ren, Qiuchi Li, Prayag Tiwari, Benyou Wang, Jing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The value of text classification's future research has encountered challenges
and uncertainties, due to the extraordinary efficacy demonstrated by large
language models (LLMs) across numerous downstream NLP tasks. In this era of
open-ended language modeling, where task boundaries are gradually fading, an
urgent question emerges: have we made significant advances in text
classification under the full benefit of LLMs? To answer this question, we
propose RGPT, an adaptive boosting framework tailored to produce a specialized
text classification LLM by recurrently ensembling a pool of strong base
learners. The base learners are constructed by adaptively adjusting the
distribution of training samples and iteratively fine-tuning LLMs with them.
Such base learners are then ensembled to be a specialized text classification
LLM, by recurrently incorporating the historical predictions from the previous
learners. Through a comprehensive empirical comparison, we show that RGPT
significantly outperforms 8 SOTA PLMs and 7 SOTA LLMs on four benchmarks by
1.36% on average. Further evaluation experiments show a clear surpassing of
RGPT over human classification. | [
0.0473079309,
0.0354237929,
0.0229614191,
0.0024290471,
-0.0119064515,
0.0330832005,
-0.0221877582,
0.0169099867,
-0.0019853085,
-0.0880701169,
-0.0490549915,
-0.0448427647,
0.0072739157,
-0.0046963342,
-0.0002046517,
-0.0083482387,
0.0117445346,
0.0058069173,
-0.006009581,
0.014082619,
-0.003662304,
0.052726876,
0.0267448109,
0.0475375094,
0.0459358543,
-0.0063996366,
0.0195373911,
-0.0114901206,
-0.0126905804,
-0.0345036089,
0.0455379635,
0.0341526344,
0.0466140173,
0.0598479807,
0.0000017698,
-0.0355734378,
-0.0012708384,
-0.0091725513,
-0.0677480251,
0.0064289407,
0.0499624796,
0.0260930415,
0.0273952149,
0.0232061855,
-0.0237852614,
-0.0213900264,
0.0268774685,
0.0554011874,
0.0357912481,
0.0775622949,
0.0087635247,
-0.0228162818,
0.0518657565,
-0.0666430146,
-0.0019206244,
-0.0401869714,
0.0408225767,
-0.0646585822,
0.0050558676,
0.0614035912,
0.0109966416,
0.0073563508,
-0.0132570025,
0.0167873148,
0.0300863348,
0.044765465,
-0.0087098805,
0.0294464566,
-0.0230155773,
0.053384088,
-0.0377381034,
-0.0473895483,
-0.0250316914,
-0.0036792369,
-0.0300578661,
-0.0050571072,
-0.0221388284,
0.021875957,
-0.043094594,
0.0653154999,
0.0507787541,
0.0140556935,
0.0639206693,
0.0558959283,
0.0147491209,
0.0524463691,
-0.0254871994,
-0.0371182375,
0.0271978788,
0.036808338,
-0.0085909199,
-0.0167426448,
-0.001035548,
0.01647388,
-0.0106253829,
0.0058207274,
-0.0108174095,
0.0183508787,
0.0283743981,
-0.0311313458,
0.051967565,
0.0151562989,
-0.0193028636,
0.0636998117,
-0.0282952748,
0.0256994423,
-0.0042556049,
-0.0178519022,
-0.0107000042,
0.0158474483,
-0.096302405,
-0.0269185528,
-0.018270418,
0.0323047526,
-0.042332571,
-0.0141740236,
-0.0497437194,
0.0273152888,
0.0343052261,
-0.0121636763,
0.0423497818,
-0.0026443962,
-0.032622654,
0.0125893122,
0.0033045667,
-0.0020356956,
0.0032590558,
0.0184676647,
-0.0400707312,
-0.0296319872,
0.0032029573,
0.0263772309,
-0.0363649949,
-0.0216797665,
0.0284970272,
0.0263454728,
-0.0100015299,
-0.0743768364,
-0.0033759137,
0.0338189267,
-0.0191761814,
-0.0574371628,
-0.0259284023,
-0.0432638004,
0.0323717557,
0.0088270437,
-0.0065306206,
-0.0233272277,
0.0164317582,
0.0226318799,
-0.0324227847,
0.0639086217,
-0.001322855,
0.0055514504,
0.0454185605,
-0.0103922673,
-0.0143647436,
0.0564644299,
0.0149829052,
0.020319473,
0.0338569395,
0.0223300662,
0.0376669317,
0.0129242865,
-0.0132505652,
0.0008198625,
-0.0066022216,
0.0041124849,
-0.0378779992,
0.0211076103,
0.0037401489,
-0.0096981814,
-0.0047858683,
-0.0162409879,
0.0496749654,
0.0495266914,
0.0290289205,
0.0731382072,
-0.0033197457,
0.0148982303,
0.0135234287,
-0.0320077911,
-0.031601958,
-0.0189450216,
-0.0339774862,
-0.0405060798,
-0.0233478136,
0.0493621975,
-0.0423604809,
-0.0380863287,
-0.0356351659,
-0.0059967907,
-0.0227635913,
0.0283522364,
0.0568128228,
-0.0312276185,
-0.0132559901,
0.0309607014,
0.0292020813,
-0.023467686,
0.0108326813,
-0.0733775571,
0.0549703948,
0.0352330841,
0.0467455275,
-0.0746478885,
0.0252060629,
-0.0407588296,
0.0531016216,
0.0179438572,
0.0292812977,
-0.0037712352,
0.0396769308,
-0.0371432379,
-0.012425798,
0.0092243236,
0.0296258833,
0.0299864281,
0.014149298,
0.013355732,
-0.0060252356,
-0.0051194099,
-0.0241305865,
0.0688674822,
-0.0054888716,
-0.031071838,
0.0544791818,
-0.0224132612,
0.0223510228,
-0.0032414026,
-0.0287104528,
-0.0130065503,
0.0182521734,
-0.0530700684,
-0.0639037043,
-0.0062563228,
-0.013109901,
-0.047059346,
0.0262233354,
0.0441040918,
0.0151031194,
0.0009964687,
-0.0671757385,
-0.0119157163,
0.0033107451,
-0.0080502704,
0.0088527743,
-0.0704567954,
0.0338540673,
-0.0413832068,
0.042903278,
-0.0645484999,
0.0630430579,
0.0172026977,
0.0111062061,
-0.0310771782,
-0.0019903579,
0.0225877371,
-0.0238243286,
-0.0284807868,
0.0114362082,
0.0022480818,
0.031520389,
-0.0044058906,
-0.0066076587,
-0.0240023304,
-0.0499768332,
-0.0709714741,
0.0379413068,
-0.0289841052,
0.0352337994,
-0.0029900486,
-0.0221710317,
-0.0128429076,
-0.0243402123,
-0.0317225084,
-0.0356336758,
0.0102350479,
-0.0079432614,
0.0219296589,
-0.0150072649,
0.0176720675,
-0.0057737967,
-0.0132804243,
0.0126906736,
0.0677871034,
-0.0023762286,
-0.0657418668,
-0.0831155255,
-0.0502185561,
0.0111222025,
0.003107148,
-0.0164928008,
-0.0037560612,
-0.0470435433,
-0.0116253057,
0.0065805917,
0.0493736602,
0.0277587809,
0.0323093086,
0.0128187807,
0.0535940453,
-0.0400199369,
0.008553342,
-0.024285445,
-0.0003229359,
0.0039500883,
0.0140655274,
0.0159450825,
0.0698104054,
-0.0082848994,
0.0147724347,
-0.0281898342,
0.0255915746,
-0.0022859471,
0.0164313018,
-0.0536000505,
-0.0093099652,
-0.0140051842,
-0.0332602598,
-0.0353691392,
-0.071305573,
0.0449811853,
-0.0090704616,
-0.0026911416,
-0.0531219542,
-0.0548378117,
-0.0757135227,
0.022142278,
-0.0035868606,
-0.016312575,
0.0109766563,
-0.0069990149,
-0.0062839412,
-0.0308670942,
-0.0347934999,
-0.0336822122,
0.0512310788,
-0.0156315044,
0.0455818884,
-0.0175330695,
-0.0478166714,
-0.0238483418,
-0.0712634847,
-0.0305742994,
0.0096776159,
-0.0362385698,
-0.0030918643,
-0.0554821603,
0.030638786,
0.0065273377,
0.0261984821,
-0.0461876914,
-0.0215731319,
0.0056057051,
0.0442358367,
0.012372911,
-0.0025050512,
-0.0236880202,
-0.0331334211,
0.0255719442,
0.0315276645,
0.0050734258,
0.0464328341,
-0.0294886008,
0.0022234281,
0.0324659273,
-0.0149787348,
-0.0343436748,
-0.0119620934,
0.0370611772,
-0.0424617492,
-0.0163711794,
0.0938006118,
0.0189030003,
-0.0729005858,
-0.015138749,
0.0408477597,
0.0214085784,
0.0310951583,
0.0389544405,
-0.0261556245,
-0.058007963,
-0.009531945,
0.0386530049,
-0.0018101728,
-0.0152133778,
-0.0338106602,
-0.0848063603,
0.0228114929,
0.0139070358,
-0.085221462,
0.0197041761,
-0.0400213972,
0.003401537,
-0.0364720114,
-0.0150345983,
-0.0079619298,
-0.0175072867,
-0.0013096391,
0.0552721918,
-0.0795621946,
-0.0530691631,
0.0201069564,
-0.0386613533,
0.0164546799,
0.075910531,
0.0312224366,
0.0062076733,
0.0156978909,
0.0228755865,
-0.0422486104,
0.0253867209,
-0.0322139859,
0.0562124439,
-0.0352993608,
0.0095588267,
0.0185833257,
-0.0047486718,
-0.0650086403,
0.0086724861,
0.0395616703,
0.09218622,
-0.0183437746,
-0.0269336794,
0.0042028408,
-0.0479343459,
0.0186708048,
0.072702378,
-0.0167605057,
-0.0704590231,
-0.0413689874,
-0.0182012394,
0.0090849195,
-0.0460843705,
-0.0042345114,
0.0389298461,
-0.0102082249,
0.0060650902,
-0.0478503816,
0.0041509718,
0.0056322217,
0.001359946,
-0.0034156099,
0.0595187955,
-0.0566334128,
0.0054114088,
-0.0364447646,
0.0271944422,
-0.0365402102,
0.0316176675,
-0.0412488244,
-0.008106797,
0.0730196983,
-0.0383692235,
-0.0019235333,
-0.0232502762,
-0.0957829878,
-0.0446451828,
-0.0171845853,
0.0108181527,
0.0220806636,
0.0052730045,
-0.0070627695,
-0.0842588842,
0.0726846084,
0.0872782916,
-0.0148775121,
0.0099648265,
0.0139772929,
-0.0078114728,
-0.0318692178,
0.0410587713,
-0.0391648598,
0.0312360823,
0.0245619304,
-0.0192154869,
0.0011890328,
-0.0068040174,
-0.0215080846,
-0.0109187141,
0.0402986594,
-0.0287930463,
-0.0364801399,
-0.0295390971,
-0.0095553445,
0.0441731326,
-0.0143482918,
-0.0367076471,
0.0058863624,
0.0426127948,
-0.0535663068,
-0.0443155542,
0.0264412612,
-0.0021605482,
0.0434604473,
-0.0643394366,
0.0126893073,
0.0020765043,
0.0298065376,
0.0067475848,
0.0396860093,
-0.0274881385,
-0.0304060578,
0.022151215,
-0.0098662926,
-0.0142869186,
0.053551048,
-0.0006071795,
0.0204204805,
-0.0369909443,
0.0265320651,
-0.0796273872,
-0.0448342636,
-0.0242860597,
0.0247461367,
0.0680080876,
-0.0120728873,
-0.0042222622,
-0.0030702527,
-0.0275304206,
-0.041212026,
0.0283489563,
-0.0199793093,
-0.0029575094,
0.0362319499,
0.0139691979,
-0.0639221966,
0.0327769034,
0.0818503425,
0.0247345343,
0.0335402116,
0.040876735,
-0.0136244986,
-0.0429539792,
-0.0086196661,
0.0135893179,
0.005764374,
0.0127202263,
0.0202048048,
-0.0183346253,
-0.0195775889,
0.045700077,
-0.0567043982,
0.0262212474,
-0.0233934559,
-0.0021432475,
0.046560131,
0.0035764812,
0.0240966137,
-0.0535644516,
0.0094868075,
-0.0037401018,
0.0001220286,
-0.0388885476,
-6.040427597e-33,
0.0253542773,
0.0013659962,
-0.0036717108,
-0.0011150683,
-0.046650596,
0.0010582377,
0.0089640999,
-0.021489542,
0.0052081975,
-0.0316688605,
-0.0369529538,
0.0046498105,
0.0004282898,
0.0530131981,
-0.0147370594,
-0.0133728273,
0.0529758222,
-0.0100021632,
-0.0390672088,
0.0337513313,
0.0450406484,
0.0320906639,
0.0551684201,
-0.0718490779,
-0.006637672,
0.0064955726,
-0.01639672,
0.0316648819,
0.027352659,
0.0546108298,
-0.0237026792,
0.0748971179,
0.0717180297,
-0.0411869101,
0.0098874643,
0.0448291413,
-0.0600407049,
-0.0144508807,
-0.0274091829,
-0.0132183572,
0.0114281951,
0.0198845845,
0.0211782996,
0.008694943,
0.0005739887,
-0.0280461088,
0.0291887261,
-0.0397581048,
-0.0507217981,
-0.02161902,
-0.005881682,
0.0463871323,
0.0214771833,
0.007906069,
-0.0025381844,
0.0015792949,
-0.0043863417,
0.0835906863,
-0.0328109674,
-0.0212693196,
0.0021143267,
0.02323916,
-0.0098529244,
0.0480473191,
-0.0016745158,
0.053481508,
0.0201479681,
0.0005718137,
-0.0432261527,
-0.0127268936,
0.0225869454,
0.0078855362,
0.0588005446,
0.0533527322,
0.0893220529,
-0.0180581193,
-0.0712887198,
0.0256889854,
0.0820103213,
-0.015272731,
0.038359642,
0.0217999537,
-0.0252348762,
-0.0449864976,
-0.020701712,
-0.0052340804,
-0.023791939,
-0.0156133007,
0.0269830916,
0.0457115695,
-0.0008225081,
0.0044280435,
0.0135257337,
-0.0431645624,
-0.0315412357,
0.0277752597,
0.0064032446,
-0.0026862931,
0.0133975949,
-0.0208146702,
-0.0617698841,
-0.0427437685,
-0.0083807074,
-0.0143834706,
0.003994572,
-0.0386134386,
0.0678660795,
0.0267045833,
-0.0730039477,
0.0013576492,
0.0061751734,
0.032636866,
0.0353351831,
0.1372403651,
0.020190753,
0.0265311319,
0.0064887218,
0.0700721741,
0.0284111761,
-0.0054975296,
-0.0070222574,
-0.0583760664,
0.0044935639,
0.0103643425,
-0.008871723,
0.0048139412,
0.0167420972,
-0.0166801848,
0.0113063054,
-0.0804389492,
-0.0026373586,
-0.002251466,
2.452e-7,
0.032398738,
0.0426671989,
-0.0032721318,
-0.0451282412,
0.0323697738,
0.0261254832,
-0.0410487466,
0.0215479694,
-0.0070693414,
-0.0021342761,
-0.0002369134,
0.0049108341,
0.091771923,
0.0174490791,
-0.0959181115,
0.0022228006,
-0.0721716508,
0.0617662445,
-0.0390569456,
-0.003945515,
0.01871383,
0.124807559,
0.0463578776,
-0.051222682,
-0.0282874834,
-0.060293749,
0.093044728,
-0.0317759477,
0.0063593341,
0.0142279686,
0.0229296889,
0.0373436436,
-0.0117734661,
0.0090212114,
-0.0399011932,
0.0470266491,
-0.0148531422,
0.0555898771,
-0.0162628219,
-0.0120395897,
0.0254972037,
0.0080447551,
0.0136291478,
-0.0041077021,
0.0574284606,
-0.0680691078,
0.0043310118,
-0.0684271902,
0.0094440803,
-0.0407981798,
0.0347611569,
-0.0108867893,
0.0093922587,
0.0562817231,
0.000314577,
-0.0190639608,
-0.0148355961,
-0.1291552633,
-0.0214861892,
-0.006715144,
-0.0627490282,
0.0087123094,
-0.0201787688,
0.0640287697,
0.0188862476,
-0.0888544247,
0.0384647958,
2.21356905e-34,
0.0319218412,
-0.0109694023,
-0.0135645298,
0.0200315341,
-0.0065415534,
0.0115045924,
0.0267356317,
0.0133271758,
0.02297833,
-0.0569146425,
0.0217883792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07448v1 | AraSpider: Democratizing Arabic-to-SQL | 2024-02-12T07:11:13 | 2024-02-12T07:11:13 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Ahmed B. Zaky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG | This study presents AraSpider, the first Arabic version of the Spider
dataset, aimed at improving natural language processing (NLP) in the
Arabic-speaking community. Four multilingual translation models were tested for
their effectiveness in translating English to Arabic. Additionally, two models
were assessed for their ability to generate SQL queries from Arabic text. The
results showed that using back translation significantly improved the
performance of both ChatGPT 3.5 and SQLCoder models, which are considered top
performers on the Spider dataset. Notably, ChatGPT 3.5 demonstrated
high-quality translation, while SQLCoder excelled in text-to-SQL tasks. The
study underscores the importance of incorporating contextual schema and
employing back translation strategies to enhance model performance in Arabic
NLP tasks. Moreover, the provision of detailed methodologies for
reproducibility and translation of the dataset into other languages highlights
the research's commitment to promoting transparency and collaborative knowledge
sharing in the field. Overall, these contributions advance NLP research,
empower Arabic-speaking researchers, and enrich the global discourse on
language comprehension and database interrogation. | [
0.0438197069,
0.0326773003,
-0.0242742375,
0.0230042897,
-0.0504090004,
0.0258399751,
0.026317222,
-0.0115161007,
-0.0230310168,
-0.0138959642,
-0.010369448,
-0.0499134548,
0.0284164324,
0.0241725165,
0.0407980867,
-0.0362628847,
0.0215443391,
-0.0410040356,
-0.0127900913,
0.0250843763,
0.0267531723,
0.0322757214,
0.0041431244,
0.0227562822,
0.0406309888,
-0.0267449282,
-0.0112987999,
-0.0034569916,
0.0011164699,
0.0008190042,
-0.0264322963,
0.0469808169,
0.0001712716,
0.0066018146,
0.000002322,
-0.0634393394,
-0.0612909719,
-0.004578888,
-0.0365773961,
-0.0020928662,
0.060831774,
-0.0740636662,
-0.0174758956,
0.0257406291,
-0.0312992521,
0.0017790685,
0.0215763543,
0.0167688914,
0.0353037976,
0.0356656127,
-0.0036060424,
-0.0626000613,
-0.0100744758,
0.0018583233,
0.0166121125,
-0.0460936204,
-0.0447394289,
0.0543617122,
0.0181111582,
0.0414895602,
-0.0137942759,
0.0451962687,
-0.0118058166,
-0.0393553078,
-0.0095003601,
-0.0296991616,
-0.0578419007,
-0.0393241197,
0.0355036892,
0.0216068719,
0.0343146175,
-0.0094694654,
-0.0252943542,
0.0197327565,
0.0197345354,
0.0329901502,
-0.0388803445,
0.0767726377,
-0.0298154335,
-0.0130102355,
0.0025689388,
0.0093008168,
-0.0011393668,
-0.0160618443,
-0.0356178023,
0.0251769647,
-0.0058951867,
-0.0168692432,
0.0334966667,
-0.0188868344,
0.0339455418,
0.0135796852,
0.0685494095,
-0.0224576741,
-0.010920424,
0.0136738569,
-0.0058668889,
-0.0112478975,
0.0414625145,
-0.083698459,
0.0040147938,
0.0953290239,
0.0118507575,
0.0269888956,
-0.0158758964,
0.0108699463,
0.0567057617,
0.0219489969,
-0.0545547716,
-0.0285457596,
-0.0719170943,
0.022008732,
-0.0534716137,
0.0287890062,
-0.1228214279,
0.0024673457,
-0.0506155267,
0.0461978167,
0.0179918129,
0.0368273966,
0.0186979622,
-0.0066253818,
-0.0195061881,
0.0024298672,
-0.0538980998,
-0.0339084081,
0.0268304441,
-0.0183495041,
-0.0375937149,
-0.1021528617,
-0.0025674384,
-0.0147717893,
-0.0011863532,
-0.011927993,
-0.0167861488,
0.0938058197,
-0.0217358656,
-0.0155924,
-0.0708351806,
-0.0077080452,
0.0227501653,
-0.0000108978,
-0.0230830163,
-0.0431843251,
0.0822093338,
0.0368965529,
0.0062667998,
-0.003914183,
-0.0150205866,
0.0471959822,
0.0273177177,
0.0815418363,
-0.0045146351,
-0.0206537917,
0.0339856893,
0.0109598255,
0.0418772623,
0.0781722218,
0.0068640201,
-0.0049545085,
0.0093295788,
-0.016029004,
-0.0203424506,
-0.00347551,
-0.0021976181,
0.0065700258,
-0.0257416721,
0.0273654964,
0.037061289,
0.0418400504,
-0.0523193069,
0.0435921215,
-0.0189332087,
0.0156968758,
0.0167088546,
-0.0064175357,
0.0009932625,
0.0424709097,
0.000787613,
0.032646969,
0.0198865943,
-0.0499632955,
0.0052487617,
0.0198617764,
0.0353040844,
0.0312896445,
-0.0145641826,
0.0432689302,
0.0065062363,
-0.0688839555,
-0.0137771135,
0.0049146954,
0.0464125872,
0.0162894707,
0.0447798185,
0.0072795451,
-0.0328439027,
0.0021709495,
-0.0252245031,
-0.0546432883,
0.005068352,
-0.0282202251,
-0.0707312897,
0.0874141529,
0.0207415577,
0.0000665174,
-0.0075048069,
-0.0449890383,
0.042413149,
0.0357587114,
-0.0068462542,
-0.0192855727,
0.0076926593,
-0.0283730924,
-0.032664679,
0.0666851103,
0.014557559,
-0.0297346134,
0.0265277866,
0.0341142192,
0.0241363607,
-0.0252526738,
-0.0521984771,
0.0291953497,
-0.0762895644,
0.0301825814,
0.0047669997,
-0.001927827,
-0.0067765322,
0.0638295338,
-0.0066269282,
0.0191064812,
0.0072512925,
-0.0045246878,
-0.0498717241,
0.0289274678,
0.0096335411,
-0.0050293715,
0.0148455519,
-0.0593493581,
0.0209472086,
-0.0236406866,
-0.0290590413,
-0.0397969671,
0.0532441586,
-0.0089711044,
0.0093698315,
-0.0306481943,
0.0433120281,
-0.0218190681,
-0.0064894082,
-0.0325118899,
0.0338755921,
-0.0271773525,
-0.0259403381,
-0.0077820099,
-0.0610442981,
0.0621703453,
-0.00614144,
0.0231413972,
0.0326107144,
0.0008239271,
0.0346358605,
0.0487729609,
0.0196916405,
-0.0629143119,
-0.0039088936,
-0.0424311087,
-0.0037295399,
-0.0071143718,
0.0530776866,
0.0088562481,
0.023133995,
-0.0046386407,
-0.007169235,
-0.0128718102,
-0.0513867177,
-0.0127582811,
0.0191529188,
0.0241399854,
-0.0178083982,
0.0140196783,
-0.0455761701,
-0.0147885187,
0.0222670138,
0.0304785296,
0.0197279528,
-0.0839040577,
0.0481856167,
0.0136253219,
0.0056924489,
-0.0033855466,
-0.0126370806,
-0.0152252549,
0.0202478375,
0.0008754932,
-0.0010126798,
0.0256644692,
0.0032445113,
-0.0020507718,
-0.0142146787,
-0.0145729305,
-0.0238566175,
-0.0046359515,
0.0075325598,
-0.0037581583,
-0.0230991933,
-0.0921774879,
0.0196552072,
-0.0132715218,
0.016737666,
0.0072917892,
-0.0412087254,
-0.0080158114,
-0.0248014946,
0.0222838316,
-0.0344828293,
0.0152740991,
0.034355931,
0.0788783282,
-0.0185092352,
-0.0156912673,
0.0200910028,
-0.0202645827,
0.0242733229,
-0.0493696108,
0.0135355256,
-0.0534995943,
0.0442480892,
-0.0276671071,
0.017818965,
-0.061654482,
-0.051379256,
0.0033180036,
-0.024481507,
0.050982751,
-0.0151420813,
0.0212775189,
-0.0524483286,
0.0052209375,
-0.0430807546,
0.000989022,
-0.0112920152,
0.0263336934,
-0.0464494191,
0.0181822442,
0.089884229,
-0.0049480833,
-0.0163658224,
0.0322755352,
0.0342124104,
0.0326435976,
0.006247092,
-0.0096810274,
0.009081562,
-0.0904922709,
0.0084710913,
-0.0057224575,
0.0085401637,
0.0072166589,
0.0407953486,
0.0429669358,
-0.0230610054,
-0.0632468089,
-0.0148520553,
-0.0248467438,
0.0108219367,
-0.0265530068,
-0.0547019616,
-0.0467005745,
-0.0518810451,
-0.0696373284,
0.0067181876,
0.0763026029,
0.0211936161,
0.0061977068,
-0.0140799666,
-0.031003166,
-0.0182763487,
0.0181770567,
-0.0110433865,
-0.1536289006,
-0.0226695333,
0.015611602,
0.0172284413,
0.0326063111,
-0.0001455717,
0.0102719404,
-0.1043928638,
0.0128014386,
-0.0165267438,
-0.0692265928,
-0.0262148604,
-0.0227405801,
-0.0225869622,
-0.0430043638,
0.0196793657,
-0.0113948816,
-0.0358470231,
0.0442829281,
0.0658622086,
0.002854903,
-0.0876224339,
0.0030470011,
-0.0258081462,
0.0122232344,
0.0409004241,
0.0151195405,
0.0010105598,
-0.0222370569,
0.0148562593,
-0.0304582231,
-0.0172529425,
-0.0190919042,
0.0428594537,
-0.0129183596,
0.0155693665,
-0.0106681818,
-0.0557269976,
-0.0480269566,
0.0333033539,
-0.0069123902,
0.0302728862,
-0.0559438206,
0.0583835505,
-0.0025223207,
-0.0091589829,
-0.0097092809,
0.0364249311,
-0.0166233666,
0.0027464454,
-0.0434951037,
-0.0141951162,
-0.0437628143,
-0.060350325,
-0.0365098901,
0.0491778031,
-0.0217319727,
-0.0651927367,
-0.0407889448,
-0.0851452202,
0.0594515577,
0.0276796725,
0.0398767553,
0.0566828884,
0.0175333396,
0.0172686372,
-0.0552876033,
-0.0351646021,
-0.0100563141,
0.0061167139,
-0.0248186216,
-0.0171567313,
0.0118447449,
-0.0739321038,
0.0121570136,
0.0013779226,
-0.0462569743,
-0.0083317161,
0.0246577878,
-0.0105239088,
0.0260390379,
-0.0360281914,
-0.0113014653,
-0.0371492468,
-0.033460144,
0.0160607193,
-0.0377806984,
-0.0278482288,
0.0219173636,
0.0116155073,
-0.0065186271,
0.0382326059,
0.0333253555,
-0.0085065067,
-0.038592536,
0.0015749126,
-0.0036458343,
-0.0154062668,
0.0596384704,
0.032303866,
-0.0090501858,
-0.0099521279,
-0.0720195994,
-0.0082664629,
0.0132905552,
-0.0568705946,
-0.0107900118,
-0.03516284,
0.0234282799,
0.0076955096,
0.0108178444,
0.0284414086,
-0.0041738306,
-0.0193772484,
-0.0275588408,
0.0018087509,
0.0361410417,
0.0196247622,
0.0178721547,
-0.0113591701,
0.033355359,
0.0124824699,
-0.0489518903,
-0.0066235191,
0.0457668118,
-0.0025351373,
-0.0191950779,
0.0004232803,
0.0268767402,
0.0247287471,
0.0518842824,
0.0054766117,
-0.0453454964,
0.0231343303,
0.0187577866,
0.0139494073,
-0.0118911201,
0.0524517708,
0.0278194118,
0.0125061078,
0.0113706486,
0.0232212022,
0.0355599336,
-0.0199472457,
0.0153201697,
-0.0146166077,
-0.0271982979,
-0.017775394,
0.0743528008,
-0.0120026087,
-0.0278810617,
0.0040142196,
-0.0359008871,
-0.0018677013,
-0.0163507052,
-0.0031919722,
-0.0282613672,
-0.023927547,
-0.0373107642,
-0.0620606653,
-0.0752186254,
-0.0080026146,
0.0196892489,
0.0062022256,
-0.0103730895,
0.0398431532,
0.1144728735,
0.0640360489,
-0.0359756202,
-0.0532676168,
0.0100884214,
-0.03788957,
-0.0366279371,
0.014087311,
-6.610956719e-33,
-0.0144890416,
-0.0329542384,
0.0574918687,
-0.0024523968,
0.0287287738,
-0.0524256192,
-0.0310477987,
-0.0025852513,
-0.0278387424,
0.0116647296,
-0.0312373079,
0.0653740466,
0.0472006164,
0.0050605447,
0.065460749,
-0.0254491623,
0.0331201851,
-0.0126863392,
-0.0067014555,
0.0272607263,
0.0638135001,
0.0383390822,
0.1104387045,
-0.0465206429,
0.0680371001,
0.0167435389,
-0.0408621803,
0.0142711308,
0.0342720784,
0.0547820106,
-0.0264292452,
0.0221204478,
0.022076685,
-0.0451948158,
0.0050690048,
-0.0483814366,
-0.0841029212,
-0.0045736702,
0.0546239726,
0.0585304089,
-0.0048499429,
-0.0142711839,
0.0347358659,
-0.0311647467,
-0.053557083,
0.0576903224,
0.0063100127,
-0.0484804288,
-0.0326300897,
-0.0374896154,
-0.0822339654,
0.0364527702,
0.0046422118,
0.0221128277,
0.0651737303,
0.0793245584,
-0.0377132222,
0.0008073015,
-0.0687666982,
0.0261294525,
0.0182163026,
0.0339282863,
0.0710200742,
0.0045299376,
-0.0424446538,
-0.0075595258,
0.0125686852,
-0.0321391672,
0.0345680006,
0.082426846,
-0.006809575,
0.0192283951,
0.0225118287,
0.04785157,
-0.0059734555,
-0.0379754119,
-0.0477203988,
0.0561879389,
-0.0565561764,
0.0218394212,
0.0061224061,
0.0041005611,
-0.0727426857,
-0.0513227321,
-0.0286405254,
0.0084954631,
-0.0036039024,
-0.0153467888,
0.0200989358,
-0.0160331633,
-0.0106370002,
0.0338611044,
-0.0070416969,
-0.0001858513,
0.0085214041,
-0.0090917302,
-0.0437462665,
-0.0480117053,
-0.0050920569,
0.0397948362,
-0.0229724813,
-0.0208370648,
-0.0099185919,
0.0457388647,
0.0092402045,
-0.0001138757,
0.0140656848,
0.0364249051,
-0.083179675,
0.0166087933,
-0.0510794558,
0.0609397963,
0.0025398138,
0.0416257754,
-0.017032465,
0.0064465581,
-0.0125317043,
0.0499057807,
0.0441774651,
-0.0067602871,
-0.0431471281,
0.0135797514,
-0.046897538,
-0.0277061071,
0.0128492294,
0.0548764877,
-0.0265998133,
0.0024801558,
0.0133245885,
-0.0433974303,
-0.0037161156,
-0.0016623705,
3.109e-7,
0.082196258,
0.0310400967,
0.0064254212,
0.0283688176,
-0.0297987927,
0.0114694517,
0.0279031657,
0.0416064449,
0.0010372583,
0.0016858832,
-0.0124899102,
0.0089335879,
0.0406227596,
0.0463397279,
-0.0727433637,
-0.0306841191,
-0.0079361722,
0.004913806,
-0.0363532118,
0.0222079903,
0.0512863062,
0.094875209,
-0.0649270564,
-0.0041974741,
-0.0460815914,
-0.0456212051,
0.0111146262,
-0.0381008275,
-0.0288808141,
0.0366775393,
0.0444266833,
-0.0066551929,
0.0017374692,
0.0258629601,
-0.0312503017,
-0.0035855703,
0.0106103048,
0.063203387,
-0.0023181986,
0.0336467065,
0.0176175423,
-0.0752488375,
0.0096149044,
-0.01206333,
0.0591968633,
0.013093615,
-0.0213988479,
0.098891966,
0.0102258576,
0.0131332586,
0.0447761603,
-0.0212816484,
0.0127979955,
-0.0055985549,
0.0451635383,
-0.0005158784,
-0.0137206484,
0.0026421065,
0.021413818,
-0.0260355417,
0.0082688099,
0.0052706082,
0.0327935591,
-0.0038888052,
-0.0483739711,
0.029386444,
-0.0006715365,
2.653183504e-34,
0.0767791867,
0.0288659446,
0.0174404941,
0.0010554735,
0.0765816122,
0.004411866,
-0.015848754,
-0.0100785187,
-0.018158067,
-0.0138577865,
-0.0379589349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07446v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07446v3 | Quality Does Matter: A Detailed Look at the Quality and Utility of Web-Mined Parallel Corpora | 2024-02-12T07:03:14 | 2024-06-14T08:50:53 | Surangika Ranathunga, Nisansa de Silva, Menan Velayuthan, Aloka Fernando, Charitha Rathnayake | cs.CL | cs.CL | We conducted a detailed analysis on the quality of web-mined corpora for two
low-resource languages (making three language pairs, English-Sinhala,
English-Tamil and Sinhala-Tamil). We ranked each corpus according to a
similarity measure and carried out an intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation on
different portions of this ranked corpus. We show that there are significant
quality differences between different portions of web-mined corpora and that
the quality varies across languages and datasets. We also show that, for some
web-mined datasets, Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models trained with their
highest-ranked 25k portion can be on par with human-curated datasets. | [
0.0510823578,
0.0502506644,
-0.0364805162,
0.0448600091,
-0.0485841818,
0.0324814469,
0.0291792303,
0.0309814923,
-0.0313938186,
0.0060990606,
-0.055677902,
-0.0520091839,
0.0630686432,
-0.0438219346,
0.0262345523,
-0.0229176357,
-0.0157434512,
0.0076563074,
-0.0014214161,
-0.0047789793,
0.0064219311,
0.0155561762,
0.0041803564,
0.0231772047,
-0.0088792667,
0.0091722952,
0.0247419905,
0.016149791,
0.0150635215,
-0.0156334043,
0.0049623065,
0.0290081371,
-0.0140488483,
0.0599774607,
0.00000167,
-0.0383056216,
-0.0245648436,
0.0095297685,
-0.0017130057,
0.0115935374,
0.0462084003,
-0.0265855081,
-0.0315953754,
0.0583614334,
-0.0289910007,
0.0113420095,
0.0456143655,
-0.0560655147,
0.0299301352,
0.0732616186,
-0.0242335629,
0.0035798945,
0.0265437402,
-0.0358834304,
-0.0895068794,
-0.0154041108,
-0.047025986,
0.0070470148,
-0.0215163436,
0.0032894558,
0.0075033084,
0.0090653123,
0.0007771613,
0.0008418277,
-0.010756107,
0.0022232435,
-0.0316222422,
-0.0549671277,
0.035629034,
0.0876690522,
-0.0614962056,
-0.0146868275,
-0.0037348908,
-0.0160932485,
-0.0266920868,
0.0131117022,
-0.026953185,
0.0895056576,
-0.0236745253,
0.0610150211,
0.0381632969,
0.0375768244,
0.0297146905,
0.0046459222,
0.0056649572,
-0.0348873399,
0.0170115568,
-0.018766785,
-0.001258621,
0.0474808514,
0.0015165074,
-0.0062434147,
0.0521605499,
-0.0246138349,
-0.0127185285,
0.0411480367,
-0.0265869386,
-0.0650069043,
0.0319211558,
-0.0698821172,
0.0407076925,
0.0377542414,
-0.0052211839,
0.0269988626,
-0.0144133186,
0.019324854,
-0.0213099923,
0.013184486,
-0.0343513526,
-0.0235438887,
-0.0282110088,
0.023324538,
0.0038134845,
0.0022536772,
-0.0563944243,
0.0158739649,
-0.0277077612,
0.0075182291,
-0.0055390368,
-0.0118070226,
0.0454436503,
-0.0384933837,
-0.0454525128,
-0.0031602236,
-0.0122325541,
0.0157171171,
-0.0165267531,
0.013887194,
0.0089633996,
-0.0997511521,
0.0006793374,
0.0034127685,
-0.0103743896,
-0.0305714328,
-0.0106854225,
0.07114622,
-0.0339629091,
-0.0468610972,
-0.0565045699,
-0.0102725672,
-0.0107641453,
-0.0321132354,
0.005532396,
-0.0651949048,
0.0946298093,
0.0191989411,
0.0169791318,
-0.0176566858,
-0.0152270952,
0.0252932515,
-0.0193712078,
0.0639093816,
-0.0592407212,
0.0032427271,
0.0393651836,
-0.004030982,
0.0500757061,
0.0642229021,
0.0650260895,
0.0259839278,
0.0275574811,
-0.0236754138,
-0.0489777215,
0.0290829036,
-0.002465138,
0.0214402676,
-0.0467275754,
0.010754318,
-0.0206626039,
0.0397949368,
0.0127550671,
0.0785092935,
-0.0287319217,
0.0146420635,
0.0662718415,
0.0610525943,
0.0410585925,
0.0590847209,
-0.0108785834,
-0.0027639938,
0.0076901587,
0.0215176325,
-0.0065831542,
0.0157661438,
0.0230924897,
-0.0151274893,
0.0676564872,
0.04456513,
0.0035527744,
-0.0508737899,
-0.0274807755,
-0.035836719,
0.0025734173,
-0.0299383998,
0.0338727869,
-0.0067667607,
-0.0386858359,
-0.0091659417,
0.0445141792,
-0.0694087967,
0.0507082604,
-0.0516689979,
-0.0100541031,
0.0689798817,
0.0465941168,
0.0239823647,
-0.0211568289,
-0.008393663,
-0.0417567901,
0.0665345937,
0.0319452882,
-0.0244447459,
0.0265469234,
-0.0415976681,
-0.0122004002,
0.0517379455,
-0.0064371964,
0.016866751,
-0.0120150233,
0.0347758867,
0.0312431064,
-0.0274935644,
-0.0629735067,
0.0374570712,
-0.0264851544,
0.0148106357,
0.0100944554,
0.0128175607,
0.066836372,
0.0190255642,
-0.0307051148,
-0.0016700533,
0.0259466264,
-0.0379980281,
-0.0337317698,
0.0155758569,
-0.0110338302,
-0.0409817919,
0.0130868424,
-0.0760622174,
0.0504930094,
0.0692141354,
-0.0226283036,
-0.0520036668,
-0.016712321,
-0.0307459347,
0.0340341963,
-0.04494185,
0.0237440225,
-0.0042716712,
-0.0105046481,
-0.0453152135,
0.0313294977,
0.001339972,
0.0268023945,
0.0005068082,
-0.0182031337,
0.048642803,
-0.0649903715,
0.0042062136,
0.0594155006,
0.0081161605,
0.0671005994,
0.0314558521,
0.0083406661,
-0.0449587591,
-0.0241698418,
-0.0669025183,
0.0008259038,
-0.0098724617,
0.0220927037,
0.0472676419,
0.0268484876,
0.0066283583,
-0.000375117,
0.0072100922,
-0.001674888,
0.0097545478,
0.0322355516,
0.0350337438,
-0.0020657105,
0.0555953383,
-0.047248669,
-0.0502142198,
0.0345964432,
0.0302246325,
0.0304940008,
-0.0043459502,
-0.0534907356,
0.0314821862,
-0.0011153088,
-0.0237048566,
-0.0042514233,
-0.0825906172,
0.0103963977,
-0.0431095473,
-0.0349000581,
0.0053599766,
0.0074568605,
0.0000956843,
0.005930278,
0.0167965349,
-0.0549360849,
-0.0346842259,
-0.0057305009,
0.000279253,
-0.0189085118,
-0.0137314098,
0.0421239994,
0.0567542128,
0.009526833,
-0.003717999,
-0.0228181034,
-0.009805873,
-0.0379677713,
0.0453891009,
-0.0168605354,
0.0418213829,
-0.0255300477,
0.0554523729,
-0.0009696211,
-0.0623862855,
0.0561902896,
-0.0418744795,
0.0451624244,
-0.0868561789,
-0.0053503867,
-0.002696305,
-0.0121149532,
-0.0293229427,
0.0026111626,
-0.0382838212,
-0.0100112706,
-0.0451441407,
0.0463348478,
0.0193947125,
-0.0381225571,
0.0170309991,
-0.0539928079,
0.0301701296,
-0.0467766859,
-0.0335591361,
-0.0257923063,
-0.0696982145,
0.0149931442,
-0.0118924957,
0.0802037641,
-0.0055877087,
0.0430823192,
0.0334280133,
-0.0291949622,
0.0660377443,
0.0060525932,
-0.0073267063,
0.0109229786,
0.0590073206,
0.0101873456,
0.0179340933,
0.0329028331,
-0.0119480602,
-0.0030636739,
0.0152180698,
0.0405279398,
-0.0267056953,
-0.0181581024,
-0.0285618994,
0.0451570675,
-0.0051727677,
-0.0128124394,
-0.0047782874,
-0.0015818253,
-0.0088745421,
0.0016910314,
0.0866926908,
0.0415686853,
-0.0567583703,
-0.0197395906,
0.0075115082,
-0.0027806815,
-0.0070610652,
-0.0136609627,
-0.0530299768,
-0.012715756,
0.0145822521,
0.0410198942,
0.0216855854,
-0.0044773994,
-0.0267628897,
-0.114078477,
0.0147239957,
0.00756475,
-0.0154116517,
0.0111180115,
-0.0213994849,
-0.0373956189,
-0.0487227365,
0.0193732567,
0.020833917,
-0.0044813408,
0.0140878996,
0.0530400239,
0.0070801489,
-0.089088887,
-0.0053916853,
-0.048657041,
0.0441408493,
0.0317208245,
0.0378492922,
-0.042366989,
-0.0346114784,
0.0186161716,
-0.1018645242,
-0.0040814956,
-0.0086577497,
0.0420183167,
0.005002866,
-0.0388466716,
-0.0081567364,
0.0019314048,
-0.0344716534,
0.0409449264,
-0.0138456132,
0.0501914769,
0.0033924503,
0.0178936534,
0.0062798513,
-0.070025906,
0.0087021682,
0.040398933,
0.0148826605,
-0.0443838052,
0.0007870574,
0.0129437195,
0.01300372,
-0.0726563558,
0.0265392605,
0.0238197502,
-0.0343165211,
-0.0457317233,
-0.104581207,
-0.0935679898,
-0.0009617769,
0.0373722725,
0.0085810078,
0.0017148043,
0.0299521666,
-0.0057997457,
-0.029199196,
0.0192937162,
-0.0403730646,
0.0067507904,
-0.0847861022,
0.0034611961,
0.0259568654,
-0.037736319,
-0.0362751484,
0.0030113517,
-0.0875505283,
-0.0425416604,
-0.0205785166,
0.0519183651,
0.0268677864,
0.0069523361,
-0.0390701443,
-0.0603227913,
0.0321458168,
0.008949535,
-0.0678417608,
-0.0426536463,
0.0111433268,
0.0053586331,
-0.0126419663,
0.0197309908,
-0.0217827149,
0.0043005552,
-0.0072502312,
0.0270951167,
0.0127957715,
-0.00753055,
0.0398373045,
0.0262650847,
0.049136579,
-0.0800868198,
0.001884302,
-0.046338059,
0.0183867253,
0.0467593968,
0.0244587697,
-0.0342421159,
-0.0225494672,
0.0799160153,
0.0167296156,
-0.0151662342,
0.0269729253,
0.0072510825,
0.007087701,
-0.0018377057,
-0.0064601982,
-0.0007326488,
0.0340540819,
-0.0057608038,
0.0288011022,
0.0177492481,
-0.0172653981,
-0.020282995,
0.0193204209,
-0.0517662838,
0.0338282175,
0.0143380584,
0.0200113542,
0.0706342608,
0.0869231522,
0.0106887147,
-0.0156714115,
-0.0298334602,
-0.0098263975,
0.0802224576,
0.0017655885,
0.0979594812,
0.0019364661,
0.0116943428,
-0.0381791964,
0.0228983071,
-0.0150776925,
0.0253502615,
0.0068440251,
-0.0019968222,
-0.0432073101,
0.0357209556,
0.103362076,
-0.0134733384,
-0.0284022633,
0.009312666,
-0.0100887874,
-0.0241080448,
-0.0082877632,
-0.0598888472,
0.0134077454,
-0.0137809329,
-0.0549268275,
-0.0201520212,
-0.0684736148,
-0.0066064484,
0.0116318772,
0.0469006188,
-0.0111906677,
0.0063533965,
0.0652434602,
-0.0185309611,
0.0762662739,
-0.044455301,
0.011166079,
-0.0197011121,
-0.0109762205,
-0.0156756639,
-5.917623335e-33,
-0.0115658473,
0.0030319048,
-0.021112496,
-0.0479814075,
0.0136390282,
-0.0022669798,
-0.025858555,
-0.0396258496,
-0.0294229649,
0.0065378211,
-0.0157940481,
0.0196808539,
0.0373881049,
0.0148694962,
0.0330342725,
-0.0061142878,
0.0410466604,
0.0195014235,
-0.0371392183,
0.0006011115,
0.0555341616,
0.0265023988,
0.0935784504,
-0.0020262862,
0.0229900274,
-0.0562982932,
-0.0001440191,
-0.0128685394,
0.0245029777,
0.0476059876,
-0.019142,
0.0285348576,
0.0503418967,
-0.0233134869,
-0.0168646351,
-0.0248835683,
-0.0897232071,
0.0016388411,
0.0286751091,
0.0463768616,
-0.0208803006,
0.0021223084,
0.0514549278,
-0.0285011269,
-0.027032068,
-0.0074313995,
0.0170554146,
-0.0098657906,
-0.0268107224,
-0.0242904648,
-0.0266415514,
0.0329544544,
-0.015458311,
-0.0028682589,
0.031857755,
0.0282348506,
-0.0309816226,
0.0279645845,
-0.0980854854,
0.0087669194,
-0.0206352975,
0.0601092167,
0.0614761598,
0.0002415542,
-0.020887943,
0.0224872828,
0.0118913343,
-0.0208040904,
0.0701188743,
0.0303423014,
0.0279544704,
0.0074104192,
0.0334585682,
0.051191546,
0.0704063997,
-0.0713275075,
-0.0536501557,
0.0384740941,
0.0038255278,
-0.0119034108,
-0.0019755294,
0.0000707637,
-0.031275481,
-0.0449028052,
-0.0035199791,
-0.0612464026,
-0.0210483056,
-0.0201820321,
0.0530042537,
-0.0035099052,
-0.0119759869,
0.0205848068,
0.0316415019,
-0.0506131165,
0.0069888211,
0.0138074867,
-0.0525088497,
0.0158885065,
-0.0014882893,
-0.0095313331,
-0.0287598576,
-0.0348000042,
-0.0455363691,
0.0365769677,
-0.004509903,
-0.0122291492,
0.0520755611,
0.0106749618,
-0.0505367368,
0.0122464243,
-0.0705946609,
0.0293373354,
-0.0152401011,
0.0158872493,
0.0291042179,
-0.0120812515,
-0.0177329034,
0.0350449122,
0.0498604551,
0.024169052,
-0.007880793,
0.0207674727,
0.0080772135,
-0.0007885716,
-0.0202891547,
-0.0011776313,
-0.007480551,
0.0413695648,
0.0333510488,
-0.053114593,
-0.0061379126,
0.0008471841,
2.428e-7,
0.0085419128,
0.0512236096,
0.0178437233,
-0.0560638085,
-0.0039510145,
0.0076066656,
-0.0640690699,
0.0275162347,
-0.0273959879,
0.0321075916,
-0.0000690068,
-0.0358524881,
0.0888236314,
0.042210184,
-0.0844327435,
-0.0121400375,
-0.0765773505,
-0.011005016,
-0.0274527967,
-0.0154319704,
0.0045583709,
0.0873299688,
0.0302773342,
-0.0322339758,
-0.027415419,
-0.0190796182,
0.0444872677,
-0.0113388998,
-0.03056884,
-0.0053351973,
0.0027671182,
0.0295196902,
-0.0569155701,
-0.0188014619,
-0.0585313588,
0.0294020586,
0.040082261,
0.0688515455,
0.031814415,
0.0286800433,
0.0170570519,
-0.0534602031,
-0.0141517809,
-0.0235131849,
0.0461406074,
0.0252590254,
-0.0084962314,
0.0210537184,
-0.0286523364,
-0.0095882183,
0.0403967723,
-0.0476781987,
-0.0057443501,
0.0206637643,
0.0166240539,
-0.0332684666,
-0.0116652967,
-0.0077912039,
-0.0223138593,
0.0199024789,
-0.0224926788,
-0.0684229657,
-0.0049723373,
-0.0005630617,
0.0670152158,
-0.0375317782,
0.023460988,
1.592694974e-34,
0.0484475307,
0.0029383863,
0.0489785075,
-0.0288073327,
0.0179775283,
-0.0097941635,
-0.0015522921,
-0.0121380538,
-0.0149718141,
-0.0395505875,
0.0032119576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07432v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07432v1 | Intrinsic Task-based Evaluation for Referring Expression Generation | 2024-02-12T06:21:35 | 2024-02-12T06:21:35 | Guanyi Chen, Fahime Same, Kees van Deemter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, a human evaluation study of Referring Expression Generation (REG)
models had an unexpected conclusion: on \textsc{webnlg}, Referring Expressions
(REs) generated by the state-of-the-art neural models were not only
indistinguishable from the REs in \textsc{webnlg} but also from the REs
generated by a simple rule-based system. Here, we argue that this limitation
could stem from the use of a purely ratings-based human evaluation (which is a
common practice in Natural Language Generation). To investigate these issues,
we propose an intrinsic task-based evaluation for REG models, in which, in
addition to rating the quality of REs, participants were asked to accomplish
two meta-level tasks. One of these tasks concerns the referential success of
each RE; the other task asks participants to suggest a better alternative for
each RE. The outcomes suggest that, in comparison to previous evaluations, the
new evaluation protocol assesses the performance of each REG model more
comprehensively and makes the participants' ratings more reliable and
discriminable. | [
0.067341283,
0.0039268318,
-0.0132065676,
-0.0204715338,
-0.0312573947,
-0.0132718412,
0.0113760121,
-0.0202582851,
-0.0311837289,
-0.03748402,
-0.082619369,
-0.0165050551,
0.00492416,
0.0348966233,
0.0600753799,
-0.0334540866,
0.0246442463,
0.0019530709,
0.0485808849,
0.029717477,
-0.0077677658,
-0.0241908152,
-0.0173039176,
0.0645867586,
-0.0126370313,
0.0093068862,
0.0490186848,
0.0050541703,
0.0068423976,
-0.0354497209,
0.0181713477,
0.0362618305,
-0.0168631468,
-0.0161298495,
0.0000017182,
-0.0405378081,
0.0284428988,
0.0018691984,
-0.0004256077,
0.0287699495,
0.0753751099,
0.075398609,
-0.0045746416,
0.0052948082,
-0.0389300548,
-0.0243311208,
0.0620073453,
0.0475118011,
0.0717643648,
0.0389211513,
0.0010066674,
0.0153593337,
-0.0321384668,
-0.0511744693,
0.0211206321,
-0.021735549,
-0.0111929262,
0.0213259924,
0.0101371063,
-0.0030448923,
0.018740382,
0.0252423901,
0.0186871346,
-0.0085309511,
0.0741073266,
0.040682897,
-0.0228458941,
-0.0150757255,
0.0117904441,
0.0975293815,
-0.005747274,
-0.0085938647,
-0.0031004152,
0.0278422944,
0.0259711929,
0.0060676318,
-0.0393985882,
0.0231827702,
0.0121749947,
0.0044989767,
-0.0251539759,
0.0266566128,
0.0150547102,
0.030704068,
0.0484120362,
0.0268209092,
0.0222105961,
-0.022279894,
0.0253387,
0.0474950932,
-0.0237749517,
-0.0443758108,
0.0049312781,
-0.0214116797,
-0.0242705178,
0.0162347555,
-0.0460301638,
-0.003619456,
0.0302974097,
-0.0120983655,
0.0898675397,
0.0120686768,
-0.00989128,
0.0004257553,
-0.0716075152,
0.065250501,
0.0039313571,
0.0114240227,
-0.0384643227,
0.0337168798,
-0.0899989828,
-0.0242523979,
-0.0300089158,
0.048935689,
-0.0422497019,
-0.046792686,
-0.067877017,
0.0103582814,
-0.0361861363,
-0.0660173148,
0.0360673629,
0.0512488261,
-0.0335087888,
0.0339696407,
-0.0697543323,
-0.0172175355,
-0.0644849092,
0.0295015555,
0.0217668545,
-0.0536580868,
-0.0146112535,
0.0319757536,
-0.0131909586,
-0.0243750717,
-0.0248800348,
0.0576762371,
-0.0207800474,
-0.0143771833,
-0.0051625404,
-0.0625014231,
-0.0490995385,
-0.0490366966,
0.0266810842,
-0.0501747169,
0.0118689174,
0.0000801996,
-0.0357577503,
-0.0642183423,
0.0295546539,
0.0434745252,
-0.0305259526,
0.0387874879,
-0.0003106997,
0.0165123977,
-0.0142577458,
-0.0039525861,
-0.0459893644,
-0.0042530987,
0.0654238015,
0.0233366247,
-0.0319619142,
0.025662845,
0.0240074024,
-0.0178503525,
0.0249123219,
-0.0363961495,
-0.0097897919,
-0.0087651433,
-0.0121705178,
0.0515335202,
0.0527902357,
0.1003142148,
-0.0365293212,
0.028383594,
0.0649584457,
-0.0051707379,
-0.0131840324,
0.0486443713,
0.0747429505,
0.0022502022,
0.0059555368,
0.0184186231,
-0.0566195957,
0.0612570792,
0.026315473,
0.0249590036,
0.0453866497,
-0.0139427679,
-0.0163020659,
-0.0406159386,
0.0177120063,
0.0164320506,
0.0141528305,
-0.0366716981,
0.0048032501,
0.0463131294,
-0.0321264789,
0.0183660723,
0.0151116569,
-0.0730494559,
0.0457506701,
-0.076532878,
0.0108773718,
0.0373132937,
0.0633324087,
0.0364744142,
-0.0362344608,
-0.0014318033,
-0.0063762837,
0.0607332923,
0.05411724,
0.0024499884,
-0.0141919525,
-0.0325172506,
-0.0245481208,
-0.0410397723,
-0.0063595907,
0.0035466617,
-0.0179766174,
-0.0250739362,
0.0346775241,
-0.0698445961,
-0.0661769211,
0.0511964485,
-0.0072337855,
-0.0069644642,
0.0304372031,
-0.0011206211,
-0.0017449758,
-0.0005869638,
-0.0300489459,
0.0807404295,
0.0293083955,
-0.0318169035,
-0.0009931469,
0.0299965125,
-0.0183590278,
-0.0219119564,
0.0096032452,
-0.0792754367,
0.014604371,
-0.0112455506,
-0.0115395775,
-0.0558508672,
0.0435468219,
-0.0682164133,
0.0211724304,
-0.0338050164,
-0.0029712638,
0.0375042334,
0.0063392567,
-0.0338808037,
0.0548787713,
0.0259218402,
0.0062481221,
0.0707519501,
-0.0360492989,
-0.0052188039,
-0.043134328,
-0.0250088554,
-0.0452791788,
-0.0269992538,
0.0080244085,
0.0389872119,
0.0373845026,
-0.0741547495,
-0.0410919301,
-0.0309869871,
-0.0215937775,
0.0068315752,
0.0362672135,
0.0456464291,
-0.028687967,
0.0051419777,
-0.0042623137,
-0.0407024622,
-0.0281586107,
0.0041142544,
0.0307085458,
0.0695666522,
0.0222251322,
-0.0261454713,
-0.0654231384,
-0.0108306929,
0.0059475983,
0.024624981,
0.0666221082,
0.0154242422,
-0.0617504008,
0.0266127661,
-0.0483501554,
-0.0504393429,
0.0469619595,
-0.0474807918,
0.0248617008,
0.0431140363,
0.0571282804,
0.0357302763,
0.0017474362,
-0.0149966963,
0.0534055009,
-0.0158086047,
-0.0504903272,
-0.010788708,
-0.0167219192,
-0.0296907183,
0.0226795599,
-0.0435639396,
0.0300326254,
0.0093682613,
0.0368748382,
0.0042908695,
-0.040749412,
0.0771112144,
-0.0252208654,
-0.0531101041,
-0.0246006977,
-0.0164609402,
-0.0223031528,
0.0002239606,
-0.0402600579,
-0.0126188537,
0.0661404654,
0.0027238587,
-0.0042144144,
-0.0425956808,
0.0382905155,
-0.0138450637,
-0.0026288969,
-0.023451142,
0.026401503,
0.0555257872,
-0.0385456458,
-0.0449003726,
0.0067992075,
0.0030701307,
-0.0179029182,
0.0476380587,
-0.0414967611,
0.0126724355,
0.0329246297,
-0.0436325595,
-0.0478780977,
-0.0188464038,
0.0013629643,
0.0272304714,
0.0180696882,
0.019967204,
-0.0207785219,
0.0461735502,
0.0451988988,
-0.0161049906,
-0.0317667983,
-0.0320597589,
-0.0031419189,
0.0227008983,
0.0346499495,
0.019130839,
0.0298669245,
0.0132996226,
-0.034866035,
0.0233323332,
0.0405620784,
0.0342561491,
-0.0247028228,
0.0040837643,
-0.0125202322,
-0.028728744,
-0.0227303859,
0.030142976,
0.013170898,
-0.0470989421,
-0.040834114,
0.0928851068,
0.0143040726,
-0.0432711765,
0.000279379,
-0.0165385064,
0.0531975329,
0.0072651817,
0.0108904587,
-0.0338487849,
-0.0272694863,
-0.0054164897,
0.0172417779,
-0.0036188199,
-0.0185484625,
0.0008312605,
-0.1186190397,
0.0356582664,
0.0014659179,
-0.0123649705,
-0.0170558263,
0.0227114838,
0.0180364102,
-0.0091850758,
-0.0109696016,
0.0431938879,
-0.0259417668,
0.0381755903,
0.0277211368,
-0.0296159647,
-0.0558152162,
0.0061607687,
-0.0752322003,
0.0692482963,
0.0814230517,
0.0544066317,
0.0318259448,
-0.0626140982,
0.0098672137,
-0.0238405168,
0.0471761711,
-0.0041513415,
0.0415800214,
0.0283595398,
-0.0003722472,
-0.0332720615,
-0.0016846504,
-0.053199362,
-0.002329777,
-0.0356031619,
0.0459609218,
-0.0092823645,
0.0133209126,
-0.0183663089,
0.0362546965,
0.0228350759,
0.0960881785,
0.0490791239,
-0.0432252623,
-0.0412089042,
-0.000588714,
0.0269754548,
-0.0875232294,
-0.0139336511,
0.0133835459,
-0.0374179818,
-0.0080708032,
-0.1444449574,
-0.0486077107,
0.0210355576,
0.0201917868,
0.0134851327,
-0.0298468042,
-0.0025809803,
-0.0114291003,
-0.00372838,
0.0088298451,
-0.0339161679,
-0.0003943608,
-0.0559445173,
-0.0086005358,
0.0242853556,
-0.0289601013,
-0.0225278325,
0.0514152199,
-0.0099595077,
-0.0236000996,
-0.0111296037,
0.0836881399,
0.0242157131,
-0.0329908915,
-0.0122831305,
-0.0370880961,
-0.0214463715,
-0.0243331324,
-0.0251222774,
0.0179929789,
0.0160733741,
-0.0028161195,
-0.0192064997,
0.0272478554,
-0.0330793075,
0.0094284099,
0.0185695589,
0.0783930644,
0.0443895757,
-0.0145844342,
0.0478933416,
0.027143931,
0.0503795817,
-0.0447821841,
0.0147646805,
-0.0221612751,
-0.0257237796,
-0.0014898375,
-0.0157472044,
-0.055137828,
0.0248434208,
-0.004935822,
0.0684059858,
-0.013499531,
-0.0007675576,
-0.0334259234,
0.0717927143,
0.0102683762,
-0.040030282,
0.022685403,
0.0128834574,
-0.0325262621,
0.0086621102,
-0.0157354847,
-0.0231286753,
-0.0036954896,
0.0078160157,
-0.0359312333,
0.0158872548,
0.0085117742,
-0.0024904681,
-0.0018955318,
0.0469575003,
-0.0219913758,
0.0089704813,
-0.0194659736,
-0.0301423129,
0.04022789,
0.0595370047,
0.0759140104,
-0.033610899,
0.0022441661,
-0.0187790971,
0.0146219572,
-0.0291579738,
-0.0025703639,
0.0220312886,
0.000761419,
-0.0064338488,
-0.0438410118,
0.0608220212,
-0.0026019462,
0.0111725098,
-0.0386722796,
-0.0288159102,
-0.0512878112,
-0.0113571836,
-0.0530087724,
-0.023556307,
-0.0022905595,
-0.0113577545,
-0.0548422672,
-0.0429288633,
0.0399642214,
0.0215009134,
0.0180706847,
-0.0189078581,
0.0749290884,
0.0411089435,
0.0042648753,
-0.0202193018,
-0.0191470739,
-0.0227271542,
-0.0238795653,
0.0053624576,
-0.1117659062,
-5.962105143e-33,
-0.039947886,
-0.0196815152,
0.0311000831,
-0.0410168618,
-0.0526722893,
-0.0081062242,
-0.0711422041,
0.01512988,
0.0103789568,
0.0184480529,
0.0067738378,
-0.0364837535,
0.0166532621,
0.008935798,
0.0145038646,
-0.0465266034,
0.0547177121,
-0.0035190457,
-0.0530337542,
0.0347699299,
0.015362584,
0.0176400188,
0.0597000197,
-0.0372780412,
0.0143063329,
0.0359714031,
-0.034127716,
-0.0055463985,
0.0330178067,
0.0733771846,
0.0002458244,
0.0434576385,
0.0449697301,
-0.0237204209,
-0.0224874821,
0.0279860683,
-0.0658487231,
-0.037690375,
0.0340772532,
-0.0501501225,
-0.0201880485,
-0.0282504428,
0.0500367098,
-0.0220794789,
-0.0430975407,
0.0333909653,
0.0290978905,
-0.0531012528,
-0.0103291962,
-0.0116772652,
-0.0616322421,
-0.0126849404,
0.0388252363,
-0.0207272545,
-0.035870187,
0.0773983598,
-0.0714616776,
-0.0467238985,
-0.0570281111,
0.0338249095,
-0.033600159,
0.0450080931,
0.0545796677,
0.0235267263,
0.0136787025,
0.0397922918,
0.0232339259,
-0.0047685727,
-0.0139423944,
-0.0217696168,
0.0268480703,
0.0530056208,
0.0356519185,
0.0583847426,
0.0144635988,
0.0146146864,
-0.0295184031,
0.0122072687,
0.031651251,
0.0509175099,
0.0319306217,
-0.0124539677,
-0.022367876,
-0.0121046947,
-0.0318277739,
-0.0098881135,
-0.0547167808,
-0.0642752722,
0.0697953478,
0.0158117227,
-0.0160086174,
-0.0169254467,
0.0319973603,
0.0028699068,
0.0288549047,
0.0314288959,
-0.02448304,
0.0284695886,
-0.0012197295,
-0.0568847097,
-0.0528396852,
-0.0123402653,
0.0217281934,
0.0516484454,
0.0052724471,
0.004887627,
0.0114781559,
0.0153262261,
-0.0314067714,
0.0082591763,
-0.0454788208,
0.0423783176,
-0.0138565795,
-0.0384537652,
0.0165787227,
0.0149676828,
-0.0202538576,
0.0416071042,
-0.0195993669,
0.0203645173,
-0.01506586,
0.0227843393,
0.0364227295,
0.0375936851,
-0.0134672001,
0.016175922,
-0.0083709015,
0.0160223674,
0.008726012,
-0.0446858779,
-0.0371265225,
0.0109848296,
2.567e-7,
0.020110989,
0.0316224955,
0.023878891,
0.0254517645,
0.0002938433,
0.0023353472,
0.0194004625,
0.0134525979,
0.0283569004,
-0.0081015583,
0.0246625058,
-0.0120693138,
0.0237119906,
-0.0122038024,
-0.0516361743,
-0.0193407126,
-0.0831918567,
0.0047182306,
0.0367929712,
-0.0267889369,
0.0451199822,
0.0177411363,
-0.008765595,
-0.0143770892,
-0.0316927582,
-0.0623686872,
0.0699061602,
-0.0290208198,
-0.0155149754,
0.0050516212,
0.0577876121,
-0.0030185157,
-0.0146028651,
0.034850277,
0.0003192666,
-0.0164290778,
0.0574533641,
0.0141759133,
0.0131983683,
-0.05097856,
-0.0058819023,
-0.009849662,
0.0448321812,
-0.0096658999,
0.0230387785,
-0.0790993497,
-0.0079238527,
0.0132825095,
-0.0375249162,
0.0332097225,
0.0009390206,
-0.0623642057,
-0.0498652235,
0.006948032,
0.0209255964,
0.0316758715,
-0.0225029774,
-0.0320541784,
-0.0343530998,
0.0331371017,
-0.0245940797,
-0.0249914322,
-0.0391541794,
-0.0160995964,
-0.0026829049,
-0.0452520736,
-0.0172455031,
1.861876523e-34,
0.030325545,
-0.0171525348,
0.0415313616,
0.0050061001,
0.0380973332,
0.0359449275,
-0.0524606407,
-0.0043566027,
0.0319958702,
-0.073031947,
-0.0383153223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07431v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07431v2 | SALAD: Smart AI Language Assistant Daily | 2024-02-12T06:15:24 | 2024-02-13T06:34:48 | Ragib Amin Nihal, Tran Dong Huu Quoc, Lin Zirui, Xu Yimimg, Liu Haoran, An Zhaoyi, Kyou Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | SALAD is an AI-driven language-learning application designed to help
foreigners learn Japanese. It offers translations in Kanji-Kana-Romaji, speech
recognition, translated audio, vocabulary tracking, grammar explanations, and
songs generated from newly learned words. The app targets beginners and
intermediate learners, aiming to make language acquisition more accessible and
enjoyable. SALAD uses daily translations to enhance fluency and comfort in
communication with native speakers. The primary objectives include effective
Japanese language learning, user engagement, and progress tracking. A survey by
us found that 39% of foreigners in Japan face discomfort in conversations with
Japanese speakers. Over 60% of foreigners expressed confidence in SALAD's
ability to enhance their Japanese language skills. The app uses large language
models, speech recognition, and diffusion models to bridge the language gap and
foster a more inclusive community in Japan. | [
0.0309968665,
0.0645384192,
-0.0193477385,
0.0096375709,
-0.024712909,
0.037581902,
0.0256951954,
0.0123299835,
0.0485038459,
0.0295216702,
-0.0353902541,
-0.0210209209,
0.0376294032,
0.0433669873,
-0.0111130401,
-0.0826419741,
0.0464740843,
-0.0003384196,
-0.0022055842,
-0.0107825529,
0.0059891641,
-0.0045541045,
-0.056541875,
0.0789188594,
-0.0393574871,
-0.0418320708,
0.018966699,
-0.0063846097,
0.0046399706,
-0.0367025249,
0.0131394994,
0.0010637542,
-0.0446391627,
0.022394821,
0.000002348,
-0.0052064168,
0.0035478843,
-0.0125282668,
-0.0321467407,
0.0036353024,
0.0160599574,
0.0401838459,
-0.0090570124,
0.0164627638,
-0.0420019999,
-0.025297055,
0.0765900463,
0.0013438818,
0.0265609678,
0.0475221127,
-0.0136344014,
-0.0829910636,
-0.0188693106,
0.0047933385,
0.010602273,
-0.0229678825,
0.0106813796,
-0.0394345522,
0.0192847457,
-0.0174698494,
-0.0095935008,
0.0162682682,
-0.0098254951,
-0.0207176227,
-0.0244141351,
0.0139336828,
-0.0164394248,
-0.0574789569,
-0.0003999289,
0.0287513062,
0.0729375258,
0.0049901488,
-0.0163744558,
0.0101587232,
0.00631169,
0.0322473459,
-0.0554348566,
-0.0206682496,
-0.0017591828,
0.0023838456,
0.0318202339,
0.0035582716,
0.0116778174,
0.0086127045,
0.0077480716,
0.0772685036,
0.0204338562,
-0.0160700772,
-0.0355627984,
-0.0107547669,
0.0027015638,
-0.0456094779,
0.0514025576,
0.0682733506,
-0.0032147071,
0.0400543697,
0.0086322166,
-0.0558953993,
0.008935838,
-0.0268472712,
0.0150605068,
0.0454926826,
-0.0381465778,
-0.0113076884,
0.0420990363,
0.003087587,
0.0326608457,
-0.0409502462,
-0.0558801666,
0.0015148481,
-0.0423969105,
-0.0147024151,
-0.0700958893,
0.0628107116,
-0.0161721762,
-0.043091286,
-0.0508584455,
0.0195122063,
-0.00432216,
0.0320872776,
0.027096957,
-0.0159627032,
-0.0104601188,
-0.0147751262,
-0.0172311515,
0.070362702,
-0.0576001741,
-0.0070904028,
0.0274817124,
-0.0447682925,
0.0261653606,
-0.0188865177,
-0.0003088129,
0.0190630611,
-0.0010546207,
0.0854206607,
0.0053841341,
-0.0416202508,
-0.0169593394,
0.0017401512,
-0.0217487756,
0.0036642067,
-0.0222674534,
-0.045737654,
-0.0231679007,
0.0039905426,
0.0411812998,
-0.0779168382,
0.0200323425,
0.0416180603,
0.0204590373,
0.0266838837,
-0.0001136606,
0.0206407439,
0.0445009209,
-0.0045760595,
0.0145944729,
0.0455842167,
0.0181230437,
-0.0293771159,
0.0404509939,
-0.0049889325,
0.0266487133,
0.0451020896,
-0.0329833925,
0.013721562,
-0.0178334564,
-0.0238981657,
0.018368246,
0.0092889033,
-0.0289350189,
0.0082577793,
0.00040032,
0.0868348032,
0.0759443566,
0.0747714937,
-0.0330806896,
0.0809758604,
-0.0005037338,
-0.0129967956,
0.0210174043,
0.003780846,
-0.0114517333,
0.035183046,
-0.0599835552,
0.0082857935,
-0.072914049,
0.0568727665,
-0.03703852,
-0.0631465316,
-0.0065984312,
-0.0480475873,
0.0200889856,
0.0285355132,
0.0424153246,
0.0000275347,
0.0030137699,
0.0373169743,
0.0220313948,
-0.0748668388,
-0.0012779193,
-0.0468797609,
0.0137585672,
0.0935192332,
0.0019553292,
-0.0294839572,
-0.0085193496,
0.019050898,
0.0421138406,
0.0261636861,
0.0460379459,
-0.0207225382,
-0.0178478081,
0.0019254185,
-0.0120854927,
0.0513395667,
0.0111140767,
0.020919038,
0.0134131527,
0.0911570415,
0.0106933936,
0.0180559382,
-0.0704179406,
-0.0009314612,
-0.0236117113,
-0.0439927131,
0.0198861398,
0.0248716809,
-0.0088089248,
0.0480576642,
-0.0173850525,
0.0117423842,
0.0138901183,
-0.0120182754,
0.0289139021,
0.0698683932,
-0.021095939,
0.0166890379,
0.0467310622,
0.0234734751,
-0.0223161653,
-0.0076655783,
0.02683587,
-0.034423627,
0.0011873393,
-0.0288074668,
-0.0067799464,
-0.0464122742,
0.0578564629,
-0.0383467712,
0.0661282539,
0.025918575,
-0.0090117445,
-0.0086824559,
-0.0417372175,
-0.0210326817,
-0.0146809351,
0.0216353182,
-0.0254213847,
-0.0354699269,
0.0490279123,
-0.0156362597,
0.0369970426,
0.0000273577,
0.0514673702,
-0.0474897847,
-0.0293961484,
-0.0725311637,
-0.0227666944,
0.002743307,
-0.0217306484,
0.0077191927,
0.0392500013,
-0.0252532233,
-0.0087613333,
-0.0320855193,
0.0608821288,
-0.0058622067,
-0.0284510627,
-0.0205360129,
-0.0326623954,
-0.0128769018,
-0.0341350995,
0.0075246673,
0.0380851179,
0.0037881571,
0.0088008465,
-0.0892082974,
-0.0304404106,
-0.1097975299,
-0.0242796261,
-0.0003706942,
0.0280068219,
-0.0838630199,
-0.0020461003,
-0.0291882381,
0.0559050776,
0.0745751783,
-0.0223102178,
0.018030785,
0.0385742746,
-0.0530470163,
-0.0117953597,
-0.0131295407,
0.0003084631,
-0.0260410793,
-0.0216016155,
-0.0744864866,
-0.0216750316,
0.0524892956,
0.0307915844,
0.0242406875,
-0.0083127972,
-0.015614097,
-0.0551902987,
0.0034282652,
0.0130901197,
0.0343260057,
-0.0326063149,
0.03550734,
0.0152823478,
-0.0373317525,
0.0728469193,
-0.0361984335,
0.0009945569,
-0.0672940984,
-0.0178019255,
0.0070912931,
0.0328735486,
-0.0477449186,
0.0583012924,
-0.0112501401,
-0.0416421853,
0.0408374555,
0.0075957272,
0.0000035464,
-0.0706067905,
-0.0073018423,
-0.0781818703,
-0.0279888976,
0.0387553088,
0.0319967605,
-0.0295814518,
0.0301313475,
-0.0586679988,
-0.007929028,
0.0423253104,
-0.0007239979,
-0.0245255642,
0.0092067905,
0.0062833205,
0.0571856871,
-0.0104882307,
0.01977285,
-0.0038609337,
-0.0536894687,
0.0244582053,
0.0008286108,
-0.0247880779,
0.0226490553,
0.1031888872,
-0.0111872237,
0.0038448258,
-0.0409388244,
-0.0118800001,
0.0262069274,
0.0524160191,
-0.0307763889,
-0.0483573861,
0.0470975973,
0.0609065555,
-0.014678332,
-0.0462005101,
0.0907414481,
0.0088780187,
-0.0939901918,
-0.0173286013,
-0.0598992035,
-0.0345922634,
0.0166508816,
0.0437723286,
-0.0643754527,
-0.0375021808,
0.0144683514,
0.0466599762,
-0.0084338142,
0.0075001558,
-0.0068073948,
-0.0560776256,
0.0351616256,
0.0306270774,
-0.0348437317,
-0.0111246202,
0.0135663003,
-0.0161601342,
0.0339656509,
0.0319450088,
-0.0428813212,
-0.0091977064,
-0.0151044652,
-0.0052426532,
-0.0184874944,
-0.0500291064,
-0.0005235277,
-0.024564283,
0.0611229166,
0.0820799991,
0.0587000102,
-0.0099262306,
-0.0397177301,
0.0065377443,
0.0395690575,
0.0231861286,
-0.0566292815,
0.0131456153,
0.0276363846,
-0.027113704,
0.0154367816,
0.0141792689,
-0.0068233246,
-0.0000858934,
0.082901448,
0.0278130174,
-0.0068458766,
0.0369148999,
-0.0251857024,
-0.0220657438,
0.0590819195,
-0.0126759931,
0.0398358405,
-0.0441271476,
0.0389077254,
-0.0211837832,
-0.0590162054,
0.021237595,
0.0197759531,
0.0305973981,
-0.0377120189,
-0.0901135653,
-0.0947952792,
-0.0338729657,
0.001196317,
0.0408678278,
0.0650405213,
0.0024371515,
0.027215926,
0.0579781793,
0.0015727063,
-0.0507274829,
0.0171608906,
0.0518620126,
-0.0913334489,
-0.0694323182,
0.0163166337,
-0.0313820131,
0.0209511556,
0.0189781897,
0.0067981579,
-0.0279141627,
0.0286974572,
0.0751413628,
0.0194155518,
0.0160134491,
0.0035557174,
-0.0236131009,
-0.0582564883,
0.0322591625,
0.0162106343,
-0.0088380594,
0.0214420818,
-0.0194023475,
0.0171477403,
0.0092002777,
-0.0196643639,
0.0394528881,
-0.0358878076,
-0.0065594004,
-0.0409649126,
-0.0585375056,
0.0339952074,
0.0424697362,
0.0218627173,
-0.0230598301,
-0.0237979498,
-0.0130036669,
0.0009792336,
-0.04910044,
-0.0335125998,
-0.0332219414,
-0.0219931249,
0.0519195534,
-0.007451375,
0.0241221189,
0.0239210725,
-0.0340772606,
-0.0522541031,
-0.0153103024,
0.0255751722,
0.0161185153,
0.0500264913,
-0.021859996,
0.0210397728,
-0.0119817322,
-0.0390274227,
0.0169989746,
-0.0009064376,
0.0003463379,
0.1076792851,
-0.0423652045,
-0.0282686483,
0.009181709,
0.0256034378,
-0.0098887151,
-0.0579354614,
0.0325505584,
0.0775971785,
0.0591146462,
-0.0246150084,
0.0493736938,
-0.0325122513,
0.0055977977,
0.0139533253,
0.0198217202,
-0.0033976729,
-0.0410106331,
-0.0039556478,
-0.0266928039,
0.0229841098,
-0.0356154777,
0.064603731,
-0.0465442725,
0.0080952682,
-0.0074967742,
0.0093566151,
-0.0215322785,
0.0182559881,
-0.0006401667,
0.0419366509,
-0.0365412198,
-0.0313360691,
-0.0064556943,
-0.0743848756,
-0.0459196642,
0.0083021671,
0.0136326812,
-0.0251654461,
0.001275504,
0.043686267,
-0.0179409571,
0.0016900857,
-0.0330538452,
0.0501979254,
-0.0633774325,
0.0225373376,
0.0303547569,
-6.621278294e-33,
-0.0577089041,
-0.0644751117,
0.0161222331,
0.0608027428,
0.0224401932,
-0.0294759143,
-0.0519743524,
-0.0006122747,
-0.020139657,
-0.0133182742,
-0.0320242196,
0.0154633587,
0.0189364273,
0.0090342797,
0.0182953477,
0.0223336834,
0.0279458873,
0.0002131517,
0.0257719625,
0.0194551945,
-0.0063713114,
0.0104645919,
0.041876521,
-0.0394082926,
0.0395912938,
-0.0105793579,
-0.0333564281,
0.0029451542,
0.003516604,
0.0159664545,
-0.0102415457,
0.0484680794,
-0.0145178474,
0.0223772265,
-0.0351054035,
0.0167964082,
-0.0794008598,
-0.0377365425,
-0.0194797944,
0.0597359873,
0.0174174253,
-0.042071294,
-0.0125757381,
-0.0075247441,
-0.0333237462,
0.0319711007,
0.0293823313,
-0.0621186495,
-0.045541916,
0.0589694045,
-0.0466197841,
-0.0180159118,
-0.0322398171,
-0.0295584723,
0.0057762261,
-0.0089156087,
-0.0217972379,
-0.052311603,
0.0042477101,
0.0519340374,
0.0264098365,
-0.0107922843,
0.0612189174,
-0.0121566746,
-0.0079275174,
0.0130381491,
0.0379975401,
-0.0441901051,
0.0213105381,
0.002177276,
0.0268317163,
-0.0124024795,
0.0685476437,
0.0132862115,
0.0220006313,
-0.0875979811,
-0.0196285658,
0.0470642671,
0.0597972311,
0.0228586011,
-0.0165359508,
0.0043236772,
-0.0053071184,
-0.0088808117,
-0.0011396827,
-0.0415182486,
-0.0198944844,
-0.035902299,
0.0218558647,
-0.0218705982,
-0.0205266364,
-0.0245073773,
-0.0233001113,
-0.0112359338,
0.0207495224,
0.0204445422,
0.0103463084,
-0.0043838928,
-0.0410931557,
0.0078840395,
-0.0244093165,
-0.0418827236,
-0.0494472235,
0.0154917613,
0.0205111038,
0.0245331097,
-0.0020436225,
0.0344691947,
-0.0365324914,
0.0146736745,
-0.0158451125,
0.0049680206,
0.0687000901,
-0.032704521,
0.0305563752,
-0.0109753497,
-0.0202852767,
0.0752102435,
0.0451404154,
-0.010236131,
-0.056049142,
-0.0693244115,
0.0000734744,
0.0020592476,
-0.0506825633,
0.0175628029,
-0.0559736863,
0.0411965102,
-0.0084948577,
-0.0335725434,
-0.0094359051,
0.0012065424,
3.086e-7,
0.0059555438,
0.0638176277,
-0.0232299864,
0.019429991,
0.008686523,
-0.0034138467,
-0.028701501,
-0.0186661836,
0.0207410809,
0.0606150217,
0.0295556206,
-0.0244591869,
0.0382811241,
0.0547417291,
-0.066415906,
-0.0015036135,
-0.04807394,
0.0559474155,
-0.0853387192,
0.0482520014,
0.0469013788,
0.03057459,
0.0110980067,
-0.0160571672,
0.0084371641,
-0.0318471193,
0.0268506836,
0.0070155207,
0.0589998141,
-0.0174595453,
-0.0054885172,
0.0258519687,
0.0104368888,
-0.0338240191,
-0.0468135737,
-0.004658103,
0.0416679159,
0.0510677099,
-0.0363812521,
0.0440134183,
0.0470565483,
0.0332978033,
-0.0118641062,
-0.0447752066,
0.0487225167,
-0.0358984619,
0.0218792744,
0.0453340374,
0.0150927175,
-0.060261853,
0.0032764501,
-0.0116412938,
0.0168831218,
0.006922259,
-0.0000369163,
-0.0467692018,
0.0015106658,
0.0196248479,
-0.0025920833,
-0.0373145454,
0.0052687419,
-0.0273630805,
-0.0440355502,
-0.039651785,
-0.0719702169,
0.0347854793,
0.0003984688,
2.5250987e-34,
-0.0094016371,
-0.0307457913,
0.0156297442,
0.0419096723,
0.0240443815,
0.0045945281,
0.0310211889,
0.0436124802,
-0.0015723086,
-0.0236845147,
-0.0563592762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07405v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07405v1 | Dólares or Dollars? Unraveling the Bilingual Prowess of Financial LLMs Between Spanish and English | 2024-02-12T04:50:31 | 2024-02-12T04:50:31 | Xiao Zhang, Ruoyu Xiang, Chenhan Yuan, Duanyu Feng, Weiguang Han, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Xiao-Yang Liu, Sophia Ananiadou, Min Peng, Jimin Huang, Qianqian Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite Spanish's pivotal role in the global finance industry, a pronounced
gap exists in Spanish financial natural language processing (NLP) and
application studies compared to English, especially in the era of large
language models (LLMs). To bridge this gap, we unveil Tois\'on de Oro, the
first bilingual framework that establishes instruction datasets, finetuned
LLMs, and evaluation benchmark for financial LLMs in Spanish joint with
English. We construct a rigorously curated bilingual instruction dataset
including over 144K Spanish and English samples from 15 datasets covering 7
tasks. Harnessing this, we introduce FinMA-ES, an LLM designed for bilingual
financial applications. We evaluate our model and existing LLMs using FLARE-ES,
the first comprehensive bilingual evaluation benchmark with 21 datasets
covering 9 tasks. The FLARE-ES benchmark results reveal a significant
multilingual performance gap and bias in existing LLMs. FinMA-ES models surpass
SOTA LLMs such as GPT-4 in Spanish financial tasks, due to strategic
instruction tuning and leveraging data from diverse linguistic resources,
highlighting the positive impact of cross-linguistic transfer. All our
datasets, models, and benchmarks have been released. | [
-0.040316999,
0.0580634475,
-0.0229972117,
0.0499554947,
0.0073342351,
0.0492151901,
0.0448360257,
0.0064827455,
0.0178406369,
-0.0022959758,
-0.0881317556,
-0.021569632,
0.0093345577,
-0.0088675246,
0.0336106643,
-0.032037016,
0.0243563335,
-0.0391472317,
0.0036606628,
-0.0354523323,
0.0239152405,
-0.0053231684,
-0.003348348,
0.0069138068,
0.0177384857,
-0.0075943866,
0.0308174323,
-0.0336665437,
0.0030371789,
-0.0015069908,
0.0075803795,
0.0098465662,
-0.0085295057,
0.0675672367,
0.0000019701,
-0.0493843742,
-0.0235695336,
0.0094258878,
0.001425443,
0.0075178184,
0.0332281776,
-0.054878056,
0.0182452649,
-0.0036790941,
-0.0626041442,
0.0132378684,
0.0470320061,
0.0187200438,
0.0484406091,
0.0433023535,
-0.0064973291,
-0.0823456571,
0.0134601826,
-0.0630208999,
-0.0087927869,
-0.0462196469,
-0.0068693846,
0.0131249223,
-0.0137351649,
-0.0206464846,
-0.0342593975,
0.0440932848,
0.0465120822,
-0.0089715365,
-0.0285503138,
-0.0079725701,
-0.0574598163,
0.0121297194,
-0.0463246405,
0.0346388444,
-0.0081086513,
0.0367428549,
0.0153607884,
-0.0279751755,
-0.0077331164,
-0.0076300809,
-0.0501587056,
0.0379117317,
0.0047508134,
0.0104670711,
0.0582483262,
-0.0138317281,
0.053291928,
-0.0079427194,
-0.0293880738,
0.0512852296,
0.0062939506,
-0.0104992585,
0.0626510456,
0.0490187295,
0.0110358689,
-0.0195182953,
0.0260832328,
-0.013585832,
0.0002126139,
0.006757339,
-0.0095067248,
-0.0326591767,
0.0063568973,
-0.096330978,
0.0225344077,
0.0451984368,
-0.0399316289,
0.0497811474,
-0.0396109074,
0.0660706013,
0.0060262727,
-0.0185656995,
-0.0254200436,
-0.0000146075,
-0.0445269533,
0.0038734085,
-0.0350197665,
0.049307555,
-0.0519063324,
0.0097824819,
-0.0651083365,
-0.0407614112,
-0.023435358,
0.0200911611,
0.0374465548,
-0.0387986489,
-0.0161904022,
-0.0148863643,
-0.0344862379,
0.0206282251,
-0.0567889363,
0.0084033618,
-0.0108622443,
-0.0593899414,
0.0174079016,
0.0323146284,
-0.0758590028,
-0.052659221,
0.0255075358,
0.1070186198,
0.0263663176,
-0.0136056598,
-0.0548232868,
-0.0326814055,
-0.0018382887,
-0.0639828816,
0.0090853432,
-0.0802360699,
0.0427769311,
0.0054971017,
0.0098938197,
-0.0118067218,
0.0058696261,
-0.0044653988,
0.0161571726,
0.0694506615,
0.0173595194,
-0.0504448749,
0.0127152437,
-0.0437022075,
-0.0007058324,
0.1017876714,
0.0029670915,
-0.0056369309,
0.0472514182,
-0.008854568,
-0.0455498099,
0.0860364437,
0.0020162207,
-0.0337821282,
0.0005382753,
0.0236735735,
0.0109246522,
0.0119867679,
0.0783317089,
0.0227523297,
-0.0166400429,
-0.0129642077,
0.0202199742,
0.0438160896,
0.0677318126,
0.0224573091,
0.0545185134,
0.0340310186,
0.0493133105,
-0.0100926375,
-0.0085286079,
0.0032867331,
-0.0193264708,
0.0277187619,
-0.0320211835,
0.0221705604,
-0.0341849849,
-0.034113884,
0.0211541597,
-0.0149350297,
-0.0191683769,
0.0012977181,
0.0177573543,
-0.0153344665,
-0.0074453093,
0.07747861,
0.0429752767,
-0.0039674039,
-0.0102208043,
0.0157663804,
0.0074355523,
0.0742649809,
0.0003102606,
0.0176025294,
0.0043798224,
-0.0056694988,
-0.0238379631,
0.0705018342,
0.046330262,
-0.0019741259,
0.0180524103,
-0.0650934875,
0.0110366363,
0.008401623,
0.0223578792,
0.046421282,
0.0027798139,
0.0172823966,
0.0006758872,
-0.017372679,
-0.0537896454,
0.0053484594,
-0.0438985229,
-0.0555254146,
0.0171791241,
-0.020564951,
-0.0190420114,
0.0456900299,
0.0076360595,
-0.0344753675,
-0.0045391168,
0.0010332407,
0.0064446502,
0.0294919163,
-0.0366542824,
-0.0325744003,
0.0317643508,
-0.0382884257,
-0.0289607402,
-0.0328126177,
-0.0497360528,
-0.0112052634,
-0.0287484527,
-0.0161151867,
0.0034286371,
-0.0558837168,
-0.0006684565,
-0.0016776054,
0.028435519,
-0.003063567,
0.0627603605,
-0.041070912,
0.0561611131,
-0.01614061,
-0.0086396579,
-0.0010225981,
-0.0658792704,
0.0312756896,
0.0194819849,
-0.0043446049,
0.0296560284,
0.006414325,
0.0577639192,
0.0001302674,
-0.0020688553,
-0.0236495417,
-0.0103045488,
-0.0171199236,
0.0623153523,
0.0204886012,
-0.0301009212,
-0.0171525646,
0.0024616905,
-0.0410338305,
-0.014931499,
0.0000086627,
-0.0024878413,
0.036164023,
-0.001847273,
0.0079977224,
-0.0442523025,
-0.0138252759,
0.0181963127,
0.0049886634,
0.0132918991,
-0.043292705,
-0.0301486142,
-0.0211705416,
-0.0059050405,
0.0034962571,
-0.0111551322,
0.0054017114,
0.009832697,
0.0099678114,
0.0379017144,
0.0167874396,
-0.0225472264,
0.0321407989,
-0.0355801955,
-0.0393975116,
-0.0471497998,
0.0104930773,
0.0228441451,
-0.0128774587,
-0.0684404448,
-0.0198010057,
0.0306386575,
0.0750415549,
-0.0510394759,
0.0009564038,
-0.0494560339,
-0.0143658565,
-0.0387978293,
-0.0097448407,
-0.0327871144,
0.0633446574,
0.0027482382,
0.0351415314,
-0.009459788,
-0.0261053219,
0.0521844663,
-0.0262109861,
-0.0256794561,
-0.0514894128,
-0.0288964137,
-0.0880505666,
-0.0035327137,
-0.0216220357,
0.0026193552,
-0.0372220203,
-0.0420421474,
-0.0175842345,
-0.006408982,
0.0513749681,
-0.0081693884,
0.0738188103,
-0.0396008193,
0.0012184953,
-0.0257512312,
-0.0120919449,
0.002495076,
-0.0133847762,
-0.0397979543,
0.0288242418,
0.0692363679,
-0.0579862259,
-0.0568753332,
-0.0229814108,
0.0003680813,
-0.007524848,
-0.0184465982,
-0.0094894059,
0.0011036696,
-0.0177805368,
0.0229191389,
0.0054450277,
0.0417234004,
-0.0957598537,
0.0406392813,
-0.0248383973,
-0.0024211952,
-0.0260023903,
0.0078349644,
0.013166232,
0.0274910703,
-0.0523256958,
-0.038404908,
0.0020202105,
0.0090921028,
-0.0578333437,
0.0131156901,
0.0767810345,
0.013320487,
-0.0019513608,
-0.0270093791,
-0.0482833982,
0.0146093303,
0.0044901515,
0.0427392796,
-0.1119165272,
-0.0111009618,
-0.0246389322,
0.0235479753,
0.0354888253,
-0.0283596329,
-0.0205015838,
-0.1366721988,
0.0345836766,
-0.0171751361,
-0.0286018234,
-0.0005894419,
0.0000435769,
-0.0589581914,
-0.0630078986,
0.0489658341,
-0.0025930367,
-0.0253902096,
0.0162034072,
0.0205596965,
-0.0348615907,
-0.0219436791,
-0.0098013598,
-0.0366737098,
-0.0511703789,
0.0048472532,
0.0095149772,
-0.0167900231,
-0.043394275,
-0.0298918728,
-0.0101808496,
-0.0097598545,
-0.0264392179,
0.0157492552,
0.0212410837,
-0.0391701981,
-0.005211513,
0.023610916,
-0.0229020137,
0.0477706902,
0.0291059557,
0.0223589577,
-0.0183551311,
0.0134961009,
0.0279665571,
0.0170028992,
-0.0360031649,
0.0478418656,
0.0203994643,
-0.0408561528,
-0.0110199489,
-0.0553095452,
-0.0433178395,
-0.0692165866,
-0.0148992045,
0.0114221247,
-0.0157681853,
-0.0167956781,
-0.0673061758,
-0.0736854747,
0.0171175338,
0.0255364515,
0.0175553113,
0.0176482853,
0.0324224457,
-0.0541805103,
-0.0123107359,
0.0518234819,
-0.0529124103,
0.0476727672,
-0.0548373722,
0.0158354249,
-0.0024934411,
-0.013433258,
-0.0365108252,
0.0482375659,
-0.079430908,
-0.0393361673,
-0.003041676,
0.034143839,
0.0181262046,
-0.014358188,
-0.0266359709,
-0.0017943338,
-0.0020812012,
0.0745905042,
-0.0486292578,
-0.0265224315,
0.0746646374,
0.0257375352,
-0.0083987378,
0.0387855805,
-0.0077865873,
-0.0061524711,
-0.0240620337,
0.0512481071,
-0.0362872481,
0.025861064,
-0.0065401481,
0.0235279016,
0.0307529997,
-0.0220648199,
0.0008946541,
-0.0177209638,
-0.005222152,
-0.0231498592,
0.0011867512,
-0.0110874036,
-0.0219511651,
0.0366591215,
0.0058127623,
-0.0010764927,
0.0491845161,
0.0053569907,
-0.0235976242,
-0.0022493177,
0.0623933487,
0.0234888289,
0.0201553982,
0.0076793185,
0.001094399,
0.0487006865,
0.0224666987,
0.038270276,
0.0377959572,
-0.0039747166,
0.0143222809,
-0.0035644821,
0.0455093198,
0.0107311457,
-0.019988874,
0.0569053628,
-0.0597472601,
0.0212156754,
0.0283696502,
0.0691717342,
-0.0606169663,
0.0194771569,
-0.0293896757,
0.0051616393,
-0.0092738466,
0.0199495591,
0.0152724665,
-0.0516954996,
0.0540152788,
-0.0071008038,
-0.0233093575,
-0.0631667599,
0.1068511978,
-0.007477812,
0.0014832038,
-0.042088598,
0.0390756913,
-0.0405456983,
-0.0678821728,
0.0468962528,
-0.0157287139,
-0.0265636873,
-0.0240388699,
-0.0739187673,
-0.0581465289,
-0.0095014796,
-0.0090022106,
0.0017917018,
-0.0215909407,
0.0511505567,
0.0624963157,
-0.0021990284,
0.0323753543,
0.0036890509,
0.0248996578,
-0.0024157341,
-0.0270378478,
-0.057551153,
-5.799234891e-33,
-0.0231908541,
-0.0228562355,
0.0484150536,
0.0138454605,
0.0464105569,
0.0046096817,
0.0004109835,
-0.0094060367,
0.0073967716,
0.0176517498,
0.0135301193,
0.0210505873,
0.0207566116,
0.0175464973,
0.0216999557,
0.0109240953,
0.0035634376,
-0.0234499387,
-0.0007486325,
-0.0359950326,
-0.0010468628,
0.0658298805,
0.1169709936,
-0.0478865691,
0.0507219732,
0.0427777022,
0.0074896039,
0.0061025023,
0.0316861644,
0.0444672406,
0.0071074455,
0.0566565916,
0.0002862685,
-0.09654513,
-0.0354879461,
-0.0482379273,
-0.0310371853,
-0.0710356981,
0.0600880086,
0.0700959936,
0.0044576353,
-0.040296033,
0.0208899286,
-0.0227386821,
-0.0501242988,
0.0063415314,
0.0242855065,
-0.0182409752,
0.0263918433,
-0.0057053892,
-0.0648928806,
0.0665421411,
0.0191310029,
0.0571867712,
0.0743257776,
0.0575787537,
-0.0326527804,
-0.0099669043,
-0.0371225551,
0.005358329,
-0.0034781888,
0.0287360251,
0.0577699021,
-0.0182012804,
-0.0105805555,
0.0518017523,
0.0299751274,
0.009101388,
0.040164683,
0.0304906759,
0.038657926,
0.0430584662,
0.0553225726,
0.0787371248,
0.0206234269,
0.0002983377,
-0.0343058966,
0.0394302383,
0.0160752069,
0.0304072257,
-0.0223396383,
0.015983602,
-0.0088021224,
-0.0287419185,
-0.0389044248,
-0.0184739158,
0.0000600706,
-0.0093759038,
0.0024163257,
-0.0083332583,
0.0175466202,
0.0179727841,
0.015490002,
-0.0329936929,
-0.0868196785,
-0.0107418438,
-0.0015246342,
-0.0015077407,
0.0190901347,
0.0578808263,
-0.0766643658,
-0.0426928587,
-0.0365155824,
0.0210443456,
0.0147775961,
-0.0211398862,
0.0561469421,
0.000544626,
-0.024157878,
0.0034272093,
-0.0147910677,
0.0461584255,
0.0200720113,
0.065254584,
0.0289604235,
0.0192453694,
-0.023327833,
0.0270584356,
0.0092729321,
-0.0170303117,
-0.0138055449,
-0.021126261,
-0.006578254,
0.0794326589,
0.010106938,
0.0223334823,
-0.0240895227,
0.0198768582,
0.036852099,
-0.0294890273,
-0.0210821256,
0.0373081677,
2.623e-7,
0.0541613363,
0.0493894666,
0.0059230481,
0.0475837067,
0.0104161669,
0.0232456941,
-0.0555547252,
0.0093056802,
-0.007862716,
0.0165051688,
-0.0407043174,
0.0255598836,
0.1129682809,
0.0233781561,
-0.0789493024,
-0.0536492243,
-0.0280742701,
0.0251253136,
-0.0734716281,
0.017145589,
-0.0120264143,
0.0672589988,
-0.0142848138,
-0.0328934975,
-0.0122880116,
-0.056016732,
0.0624479949,
-0.034809418,
-0.0293599423,
-0.0050778254,
0.0209190939,
0.0423358902,
-0.0074910414,
0.0242913608,
-0.0116172256,
0.0145371798,
0.0107536269,
0.0474022441,
0.0513458103,
0.0239651054,
0.048162736,
-0.0383433141,
-0.0547124967,
-0.0466878414,
0.00552304,
-0.0371247269,
-0.0301618204,
-0.0142752826,
-0.0318054073,
0.0085333614,
0.03538353,
0.0043499954,
-0.0231504254,
0.0295105446,
0.0539334007,
-0.046408657,
-0.0149443895,
0.0032362647,
-0.0166005492,
0.050157804,
-0.0119189154,
0.0239410084,
-0.0699525997,
0.0438095964,
-0.0137203531,
-0.0269768871,
0.0171623174,
2.179654431e-34,
0.0435799584,
-0.0211668909,
0.0152501427,
0.0204912275,
0.0518326201,
0.0035648311,
-0.0455244631,
0.0360542014,
-0.0189773366,
-0.0505890809,
0.0277854055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07401v1 | Can LLMs Produce Faithful Explanations For Fact-checking? Towards Faithful Explainable Fact-Checking via Multi-Agent Debate | 2024-02-12T04:32:33 | 2024-02-12T04:32:33 | Kyungha Kim, Sangyun Lee, Kung-Hsiang Huang, Hou Pong Chan, Manling Li, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fact-checking research has extensively explored verification but less so the
generation of natural-language explanations, crucial for user trust. While
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in text generation, their capability for
producing faithful explanations in fact-checking remains underexamined. Our
study investigates LLMs' ability to generate such explanations, finding that
zero-shot prompts often result in unfaithfulness. To address these challenges,
we propose the Multi-Agent Debate Refinement (MADR) framework, leveraging
multiple LLMs as agents with diverse roles in an iterative refining process
aimed at enhancing faithfulness in generated explanations. MADR ensures that
the final explanation undergoes rigorous validation, significantly reducing the
likelihood of unfaithful elements and aligning closely with the provided
evidence. Experimental results demonstrate that MADR significantly improves the
faithfulness of LLM-generated explanations to the evidence, advancing the
credibility and trustworthiness of these explanations. | [
0.0447973497,
0.0441437624,
-0.0084544374,
0.0257147532,
-0.0286804158,
-0.0166639667,
0.0419217199,
-0.0390925594,
-0.0426945649,
-0.0287619289,
0.0202324037,
-0.0185546875,
0.0096315211,
0.0190687068,
0.0260157809,
-0.0229186565,
0.0424327739,
-0.0157353785,
0.062280301,
-0.0052891714,
0.028867526,
0.025940571,
-0.009223287,
0.0500795022,
-0.0131838191,
0.0001127825,
-0.0385175943,
0.0031802941,
0.018349966,
-0.01990146,
-0.0327993259,
0.0264245942,
0.0324446484,
0.0719624832,
0.0000018888,
-0.0255989041,
-0.0054163174,
0.0235066283,
-0.0775136575,
0.0179719776,
0.0303284433,
0.0341081619,
0.0150815099,
-0.015852876,
-0.0105769467,
0.0240900777,
0.0483521931,
0.0417295992,
0.111839205,
0.0817629546,
0.0279357098,
0.000635622,
-0.0182697289,
0.0134892808,
-0.0129079176,
-0.0132741863,
0.0048157973,
-0.0050591924,
-0.0214683861,
0.0623989291,
0.0170992352,
-0.0134950262,
0.0240571443,
-0.0553634204,
-0.0226884969,
0.0181613415,
-0.0334684812,
-0.0377681255,
-0.0126359165,
0.0349436253,
0.0471754633,
-0.024152929,
-0.0010001645,
-0.0097908564,
-0.0040695835,
0.0494376384,
-0.0310234874,
0.0653381795,
-0.0458381884,
-0.0114447912,
0.0092609338,
-0.023155231,
0.0500560701,
0.0331951976,
-0.0023663256,
0.0723566189,
-0.0215974227,
-0.0110137202,
-0.0322452784,
-0.0083720917,
-0.0006562467,
-0.1020372808,
-0.0257508215,
0.0393699668,
-0.0730885193,
0.0165981445,
-0.0031672313,
0.0230307616,
0.0343502089,
-0.0060926946,
0.0333566479,
0.0209412314,
-0.0139704579,
0.0445073806,
0.0005742958,
0.0424172208,
-0.0161513984,
0.0038774419,
-0.0002724145,
-0.0126939993,
-0.0349515006,
-0.0162931383,
-0.0070318035,
0.010188424,
-0.0153233213,
0.0194639526,
0.0022578142,
0.0075399033,
-0.0362836458,
0.0490506068,
0.0067923646,
0.0181922652,
-0.0315226018,
-0.0504872203,
-0.0871938989,
0.0565140732,
-0.053744927,
0.0342928097,
0.0570897758,
-0.0477733947,
-0.030030543,
0.0307732522,
-0.026547337,
0.0013404168,
-0.0196695402,
0.0171078146,
0.0001921283,
0.0224147011,
-0.0347512811,
-0.0679569617,
-0.0130870948,
-0.0891985968,
-0.0354810283,
-0.0637489706,
0.0246476028,
-0.020411782,
-0.0232474376,
-0.0269094072,
0.0064595533,
0.0051019513,
-0.014872021,
0.0732725188,
-0.0759080872,
0.0001729374,
0.0219149571,
0.009112848,
-0.0529445522,
0.0276992321,
0.025959732,
0.0202168375,
0.0415398031,
0.0237374902,
0.0203851741,
-0.027439177,
0.0182791557,
0.0386091582,
0.0492787957,
0.0070307017,
-0.0477202013,
0.0310360342,
0.0116122812,
0.0399958566,
-0.0487009846,
-0.0086606955,
0.0987180024,
0.0070925658,
-0.0070558749,
-0.0042663733,
0.0560975857,
-0.0080255782,
0.0081930542,
0.0467291363,
-0.0413671173,
0.0381658599,
0.0105333729,
-0.0052230344,
0.0058538993,
0.0380546041,
-0.0262303092,
-0.0657381266,
0.0089519704,
-0.0058450243,
0.0208798796,
0.0100552328,
0.0006089181,
0.002334255,
-0.0109951654,
0.022975212,
0.0263860207,
-0.0581691414,
0.004268941,
-0.0803013146,
0.0739525631,
0.0500134528,
0.0424813963,
0.003807765,
-0.0448182561,
-0.0417191572,
0.0606859364,
0.0560084246,
0.0548946746,
-0.0135925617,
-0.0192411859,
-0.0258793123,
-0.0382065214,
-0.0538348258,
0.0399662703,
0.0230725706,
0.0148596605,
-0.0265112277,
0.0037409351,
0.0062511126,
-0.0287380572,
0.0217301771,
0.0049749333,
0.0165110938,
-0.0080339257,
-0.0003752126,
0.0193183441,
0.032455679,
-0.0067334999,
0.0144523084,
0.0351654105,
0.0127858706,
-0.029351091,
0.0345708616,
0.0026637248,
-0.0034577257,
0.0231803544,
-0.0067756367,
-0.0177171975,
-0.0188865811,
-0.0275856387,
-0.0252172723,
-0.0065827961,
-0.0322918072,
-0.0189107396,
-0.0330033973,
0.0198962409,
-0.0157892201,
-0.0207222253,
-0.0257180426,
0.0575798377,
-0.0013760313,
-0.0144278677,
0.0244317576,
0.030716477,
0.0016646908,
-0.0334248617,
0.0224376768,
0.0347932838,
0.0245727766,
0.0059848758,
0.0525017977,
-0.0298481472,
-0.0161776654,
-0.0243365932,
-0.0474688299,
-0.0057615056,
-0.0156924315,
0.0009368675,
0.0209992416,
-0.0290456135,
0.0164105222,
0.0234014317,
-0.0212598667,
0.0226201396,
0.0290214997,
0.0140379006,
0.0677372664,
-0.0025975008,
-0.0414983481,
-0.0191858672,
0.0375698097,
-0.0259594899,
0.0403506756,
0.0547459759,
0.0114072245,
-0.0987562537,
-0.0322074704,
-0.0831556395,
-0.0218056869,
-0.0085616894,
-0.017297186,
0.0751756728,
0.0444591306,
-0.0124310227,
0.0478869155,
0.0210763384,
0.0415729918,
0.0258493852,
0.0107770339,
-0.0384991169,
-0.0098132808,
-0.0127110947,
0.0009058132,
-0.0271128155,
-0.0283774398,
0.030879233,
0.0555998757,
0.0053536529,
-0.0033916016,
-0.0351864472,
0.0909272954,
0.0078997817,
-0.029713396,
0.0318928622,
-0.0738504604,
-0.0232232437,
0.0869672745,
-0.0489616469,
-0.0463857837,
0.0978827327,
-0.0636883751,
0.0235148147,
-0.0086184563,
-0.0113259293,
-0.0211855229,
0.0412300602,
-0.031896472,
0.0152281551,
0.0152772237,
0.0430348441,
-0.0248326883,
-0.0613668188,
0.0912209898,
-0.0016143272,
0.0515601188,
-0.0667849779,
-0.0019311726,
0.0147588579,
-0.0205977,
-0.0258400701,
-0.0885680243,
-0.0324952789,
0.0079496959,
0.0033175354,
-0.023987446,
-0.0615993813,
0.003022538,
0.076820612,
-0.0052819494,
-0.0007211938,
-0.0131329931,
-0.0269752908,
-0.0198234338,
0.0201207101,
0.0501961485,
0.0613478348,
-0.0338052511,
0.0331554972,
0.0652078614,
-0.0118681472,
0.0046383357,
-0.0347686857,
-0.0475597493,
-0.0473114625,
-0.0283453614,
0.007902571,
-0.0060473876,
0.076932691,
-0.0528678037,
0.0168624502,
0.091326572,
0.0150408698,
0.0037341395,
-0.0033973879,
-0.0323085375,
0.0240914505,
0.0214229003,
-0.0053587244,
-0.0857901648,
-0.0033950985,
0.0031377585,
-0.0065649934,
-0.0229278244,
-0.0400294811,
-0.0472120568,
-0.0733006075,
0.0422902778,
0.014566076,
0.0065884683,
0.0172197782,
-0.0653041229,
-0.0096750893,
0.0020259838,
0.0183870122,
0.0539913848,
0.0528405942,
-0.0063853688,
0.0211712662,
0.0228967704,
-0.0044601695,
0.0289865304,
-0.066987738,
0.0565874502,
0.0340304077,
0.0424984954,
0.0205838569,
-0.038361311,
-0.017979037,
0.0261571463,
0.0145471077,
0.0023664383,
0.0246076677,
-0.0068039489,
0.0099645909,
-0.0318897069,
0.0092375064,
0.0170688294,
-0.0391055159,
0.0069207349,
0.042609252,
-0.0143997548,
-0.031368047,
0.0030563895,
0.0012370575,
0.0155326985,
0.0761457533,
0.0358000509,
0.0105255842,
-0.0389761962,
-0.0469597206,
-0.0423917919,
-0.0124938544,
-0.0227111075,
0.0126366382,
-0.0083135432,
0.0159014054,
-0.0527120419,
-0.0492133945,
-0.0116712367,
0.0374322049,
-0.0069397702,
-0.0234152209,
0.0389964283,
-0.0215976983,
0.0236547086,
0.0044559371,
-0.0458176583,
0.0373150818,
0.0324330814,
0.0060502505,
-0.0098237749,
-0.0360618234,
0.0236228798,
0.0369767472,
-0.0317050107,
-0.0485355668,
-0.0240660831,
0.0433664508,
0.0356243737,
0.0631395429,
0.0036759237,
-0.0423866473,
-0.0106163956,
0.0072541125,
-0.0432415865,
0.0110491812,
0.0062269489,
0.012973222,
0.007294517,
0.0260303393,
-0.0147014996,
0.0008063674,
-0.0059046708,
0.0328379981,
-0.0380313285,
-0.0378762968,
0.0569098778,
0.0161622781,
0.014187484,
-0.0049066087,
0.0276199356,
-0.0378320925,
0.0085224025,
-0.0318214186,
-0.0416974425,
-0.0033554633,
0.0234990139,
-0.0216475148,
-0.0574856922,
0.0233195238,
-0.0323911346,
-0.0392124541,
0.04871317,
0.0021822089,
-0.012253413,
0.0047302353,
0.0174449068,
-0.0107477745,
-0.0008231588,
-0.0245366022,
0.0332371294,
-0.0420027226,
0.0465854295,
0.0150169469,
0.0589884333,
0.0231021699,
-0.0252896175,
0.0024275321,
-0.0216910504,
-0.0972784758,
-0.029765524,
0.0213216413,
-0.0097657014,
0.0114873769,
0.0382060632,
0.0527754016,
0.00268563,
-0.020307105,
0.0024251675,
0.0155566428,
0.0524536744,
-0.0218579657,
0.0179692078,
0.0221430231,
-0.0513210073,
-0.0068991492,
0.0571730658,
-0.0065909741,
0.0366392881,
-0.0133385286,
-0.0473216325,
-0.0189681128,
-0.0755037516,
-0.0562134385,
0.0285249595,
0.003948207,
-0.0436861329,
-0.0593199246,
-0.0196226295,
-0.0001985949,
0.0277686864,
0.0318797529,
-0.0172305908,
-0.0195196979,
0.0744831786,
-0.0027604466,
-0.046072796,
-0.0569886975,
0.0085143596,
-0.0121703781,
0.0279309992,
-0.0194489192,
-5.955614945e-33,
-0.0320246853,
-0.0813338757,
0.0343325399,
-0.0184848011,
-0.0278208405,
0.022769155,
-0.0555353798,
-0.0129515314,
-0.0215138737,
0.0694593117,
0.0087528499,
0.0273523573,
0.0189633202,
-0.0287829041,
-0.0140509345,
-0.0199348815,
0.0571699031,
0.0225689989,
-0.0777182877,
0.0087830545,
0.0336333849,
-0.0468556024,
0.0180517267,
-0.0402206331,
0.0822865218,
-0.0017179251,
-0.0549142398,
0.038971711,
-0.051849775,
0.0680901855,
0.0168352444,
0.0235122591,
0.0188418943,
-0.0646730065,
-0.0179650486,
-0.0114490055,
-0.0222967938,
-0.0078334622,
0.0659295171,
-0.021767674,
-0.0354133286,
-0.0224433783,
0.0312513523,
-0.0070587671,
-0.0068138554,
0.0062502674,
0.0022231636,
-0.0149475401,
0.0103124557,
0.0091783265,
-0.0468895994,
0.0203079786,
-0.0075771213,
-0.0252658445,
-0.0561677516,
0.0067458604,
-0.0060992129,
-0.0050818799,
-0.0856684744,
0.0316570997,
0.0253847241,
-0.0112862494,
0.0652306378,
-0.0192268305,
-0.0218038,
0.0727412924,
0.0107679265,
0.0503765121,
-0.1043351665,
-0.0105237095,
-0.0456604175,
0.0441211611,
0.0726486817,
0.1181912422,
-0.0346047245,
0.0022875995,
-0.0567749552,
0.0190522578,
0.0298210066,
0.0471806079,
0.034821339,
-0.0064887633,
-0.0059192991,
-0.0079036783,
-0.0706948936,
-0.0001226965,
-0.0449215434,
-0.0303098951,
-0.007174849,
0.022400802,
-0.047758203,
0.0022393377,
0.0055925357,
-0.0454446115,
0.0217924304,
0.0135301584,
-0.0369523205,
-0.0200686473,
-0.000866742,
-0.0223723408,
-0.0301780608,
0.0350279734,
0.0026844831,
0.045793809,
0.0104508009,
0.0131382579,
0.0210086331,
0.001135434,
-0.0205430221,
0.0289930869,
-0.0570795648,
0.0107759982,
-0.0111566875,
-0.0451492928,
0.0287825242,
0.014254896,
-0.044508405,
0.0192852132,
0.0133554414,
-0.0217195228,
-0.0276001748,
0.0461093709,
-0.0231687799,
0.0225471184,
-0.0102679897,
0.0135311149,
-0.0351885408,
-0.0181669164,
0.0094858352,
-0.0479784533,
-0.0105706155,
-0.0041163946,
2.496e-7,
-0.0127994716,
0.0513211004,
0.0155646279,
-0.0070427014,
0.0455307029,
0.0412893556,
0.0101742372,
-0.0130412951,
-0.0287711602,
-0.0904262289,
-0.0063630575,
0.0428763628,
0.0223881286,
0.0479680598,
-0.0078837667,
-0.0255472101,
-0.0850737691,
-0.035776116,
-0.0704559609,
-0.0240997188,
0.0344546847,
0.0199490413,
0.0438400358,
-0.0082827564,
-0.0047165547,
-0.0381423607,
0.0677036196,
0.0160309598,
-0.0376170091,
0.0463909358,
0.0435363241,
-0.034488719,
0.014952546,
0.0138741843,
0.019041758,
-0.0069724079,
-0.051106751,
0.0734477192,
0.0013291414,
-0.0117569743,
-0.023749141,
-0.0486313328,
0.0161493346,
-0.0680911317,
0.041504886,
-0.0246635824,
-0.0268930886,
-0.0477447025,
-0.0278592892,
-0.0274496526,
0.0008033465,
-0.0275430065,
-0.0009424833,
0.0271001589,
-0.0383759402,
0.0423288569,
0.0084431274,
-0.0184978675,
-0.0558377132,
-0.0188007317,
-0.0491247326,
-0.0617295019,
0.0208100956,
-0.0137357675,
0.0300679225,
-0.0768383816,
0.0248726774,
1.951598884e-34,
0.0241348278,
0.0024830205,
0.0100375051,
0.0067895907,
0.0855732784,
0.0539059378,
-0.0392491072,
-0.0070386808,
0.061131496,
-0.0252163876,
-0.0227766242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07397v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07397v2 | Leveraging AI to Advance Science and Computing Education across Africa: Challenges, Progress and Opportunities | 2024-02-12T04:10:09 | 2024-04-26T23:31:04 | George Boateng | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | Across the African continent, students grapple with various educational
challenges, including limited access to essential resources such as computers,
internet connectivity, reliable electricity, and a shortage of qualified
teachers. Despite these challenges, recent advances in AI such as BERT, and
GPT-4 have demonstrated their potential for advancing education. Yet, these AI
tools tend to be deployed and evaluated predominantly within the context of
Western educational settings, with limited attention directed towards the
unique needs and challenges faced by students in Africa. In this chapter, we
discuss challenges with using AI to advance education across Africa. Then, we
describe our work developing and deploying AI in Education tools in Africa for
science and computing education: (1) SuaCode, an AI-powered app that enables
Africans to learn to code using their smartphones, (2) AutoGrad, an automated
grading, and feedback tool for graphical and interactive coding assignments,
(3) a tool for code plagiarism detection that shows visual evidence of
plagiarism, (4) Kwame, a bilingual AI teaching assistant for coding courses,
(5) Kwame for Science, a web-based AI teaching assistant that provides instant
answers to students' science questions and (6) Brilla AI, an AI contestant for
the National Science and Maths Quiz competition. Finally, we discuss potential
opportunities to leverage AI to advance education across Africa. | [
0.0706526339,
0.0277633108,
-0.0696237683,
-0.0024494734,
0.019265689,
0.0194197334,
0.0658517182,
-0.0470559634,
0.0490384772,
-0.0180882048,
0.004190037,
0.0159130469,
0.0367239714,
0.041237209,
0.0165811423,
-0.0553288609,
-0.0088118846,
-0.0110879708,
0.0145603651,
0.0074172853,
-0.019242378,
0.0322464183,
-0.0306002703,
0.0458339639,
-0.0076924395,
-0.0394675322,
-0.0297836997,
-0.0296022054,
-0.0057370123,
0.000804576,
0.0196061376,
0.043257013,
-0.0379835181,
0.0271055847,
0.0000022743,
-0.0521357916,
0.0053662006,
0.012797216,
-0.0591433272,
0.0601184219,
0.001533645,
0.0890588462,
-0.0258449912,
0.0162868574,
-0.0967259035,
0.0490444787,
0.0744140744,
-0.0750217065,
0.0370141082,
-0.0053577814,
0.0116823418,
0.0130893299,
0.0668854415,
0.0232387502,
0.0233041476,
-0.0039983029,
0.0064946758,
0.0338495933,
0.0678158924,
0.0263745058,
-0.0120625589,
0.0237892047,
0.0239175912,
-0.0333338752,
0.0005136747,
0.0173454285,
-0.0648174956,
-0.0644005984,
-0.017721124,
0.0128964148,
0.0327110253,
-0.0199660752,
-0.0070633399,
0.0185799655,
0.0133335367,
0.0091794338,
-0.0536364093,
0.045328822,
-0.0040418915,
-0.0029417225,
0.0040424364,
-0.047532592,
-0.0193459205,
0.0576923713,
-0.0028085057,
0.0056693931,
-0.0155272791,
-0.0182796642,
-0.0246117003,
0.0587973744,
0.0500186384,
-0.0274483338,
0.0326471776,
0.0555063114,
0.0261124596,
-0.0259204991,
0.0035195565,
-0.0695482418,
0.0010193337,
-0.0077620656,
0.057875514,
0.0254717749,
0.0055872579,
0.0136969425,
0.0061846785,
0.0706663057,
-0.0239930786,
0.043641746,
0.0210979972,
0.0278415103,
-0.0495867282,
-0.0380692407,
-0.0116450377,
0.0345282145,
0.0208738633,
0.0625591204,
-0.0208520107,
0.0021358975,
-0.0389496572,
0.0158266295,
-0.031829536,
0.0095653422,
0.0205456801,
0.0043621571,
0.0190181006,
0.0021978109,
-0.0252259187,
-0.0010497663,
-0.0087325918,
-0.0418223776,
0.0198570918,
-0.0150224054,
-0.0271835756,
0.0288314018,
0.0370081998,
0.0462141335,
0.0134647479,
-0.0130249597,
-0.0397077166,
-0.0443273149,
0.0296399035,
-0.020376917,
0.0040074163,
-0.0501900055,
-0.0230340809,
0.0403174944,
0.0198097304,
-0.0245115552,
-0.0060964227,
0.0019264102,
0.0432343856,
0.0074592093,
-0.0323273093,
-0.0198026244,
0.074603647,
0.0535655655,
-0.0280565359,
-0.0165572148,
0.030762868,
0.0108413147,
-0.0062091174,
-0.0103196222,
0.0441584773,
-0.0008684703,
-0.0061394502,
-0.0142341936,
0.0344342999,
0.0023545395,
0.031476263,
-0.0016703079,
-0.0556792915,
-0.008064473,
0.0166307911,
0.0606350116,
0.0033345968,
0.0605317876,
-0.0366968177,
0.0489925705,
-0.0122375349,
-0.0166949593,
0.0563327037,
-0.0449679643,
-0.0245400202,
0.0566332787,
-0.0169948693,
-0.0223294459,
0.0120715508,
0.0903602168,
0.0216903724,
-0.0577663556,
-0.0012886643,
0.0025585268,
-0.0036743062,
0.0387907326,
0.001552309,
-0.0293340888,
0.0470945686,
-0.066452764,
-0.0062353839,
-0.0739090741,
-0.0206059515,
-0.0855490714,
0.0544686727,
0.0620705746,
0.025210863,
-0.0231312253,
-0.0351280719,
-0.0012771066,
-0.0109564262,
0.0042545288,
-0.0019086906,
-0.0330872163,
-0.0249229316,
0.0089974878,
-0.0280238986,
-0.0262985956,
-0.0160438046,
0.019514272,
0.0433199219,
0.0672077909,
0.0031392486,
-0.030466117,
-0.0161794238,
0.0243393946,
-0.072297439,
-0.0100992825,
-0.0364704356,
0.0394054949,
0.01333139,
0.0220525097,
-0.017924808,
0.005954532,
-0.0026719482,
-0.0101888394,
0.0054126973,
-0.0462848507,
-0.0054736319,
0.0598531067,
0.0454891138,
-0.0935973376,
-0.0104880948,
0.0542414635,
0.0492928959,
0.0125311855,
0.0675478131,
0.0159777738,
0.0284019262,
0.0187546425,
0.0474663638,
-0.055563204,
-0.0208579842,
0.0109222587,
0.00575518,
0.0548052825,
-0.0065984996,
0.0298655666,
0.0299290437,
0.0482723154,
0.0315907449,
-0.0217748638,
0.0157711226,
-0.0034893439,
0.0094545009,
-0.020395726,
0.0081904801,
-0.0327181667,
0.009354963,
-0.0624292456,
-0.0220305454,
0.0278817602,
-0.014174236,
-0.00152164,
0.0296953376,
-0.0110214809,
-0.0025922889,
-0.0058311485,
-0.0268364456,
-0.0332789235,
-0.0231355149,
-0.0257477872,
-0.0331284143,
0.0029451461,
-0.0522191934,
0.0111857811,
-0.0387775525,
0.0456123874,
0.1082579866,
-0.0020866187,
-0.0392097197,
0.0032119048,
-0.0187585466,
0.0162479691,
0.0201972742,
-0.002516432,
0.0149829816,
-0.0279831607,
-0.023008531,
0.0546956025,
-0.0241225157,
0.0112427901,
0.0602423549,
-0.0009088506,
-0.0193225797,
0.0077722534,
0.0533415973,
0.0275727026,
0.0492478982,
-0.0214456506,
-0.010736349,
-0.004025104,
0.0220950209,
-0.0062833945,
0.0190747492,
0.0443999618,
-0.0196317118,
-0.0236833021,
-0.0084295394,
-0.060066849,
-0.0058972612,
0.0109855644,
-0.0051003997,
-0.0412063487,
0.1067267284,
-0.0120351501,
-0.0068251858,
-0.0381617956,
0.0011932364,
0.0066301501,
0.016222138,
-0.0685016587,
0.0129080499,
-0.0175540801,
0.0114693297,
-0.0078874752,
0.0158569366,
0.0321028046,
-0.0368200764,
-0.0450193919,
-0.0378781147,
-0.0234372783,
0.0029557822,
-0.0497912541,
-0.0158901457,
0.0364632532,
-0.0343492217,
-0.0068626674,
0.0127528934,
-0.0484043472,
0.0011614042,
-0.0356009826,
0.0920118168,
0.0642570108,
-0.0052963416,
-0.0123199029,
0.0343212709,
-0.0159015507,
-0.0253376476,
-0.0489725098,
-0.0348769017,
-0.0257700086,
-0.0007554445,
0.0172609091,
0.0067720152,
-0.0207735654,
-0.0145271188,
0.0093631446,
0.0490891337,
-0.0073018209,
-0.0464236625,
0.0173560213,
0.0371120237,
-0.0395372771,
-0.0058632693,
0.0372621268,
0.0201522075,
-0.0538261086,
-0.0112304091,
-0.0575946309,
-0.0548087656,
-0.0096372366,
0.0501754954,
-0.112234205,
0.0051600863,
-0.0354243927,
0.0212105606,
-0.0264034178,
-0.0128425295,
0.015770236,
-0.0370534919,
0.0359354317,
0.028255485,
0.0218700171,
-0.0420454331,
-0.0459204577,
-0.0337127261,
0.0281830914,
-0.0284107439,
-0.0187391005,
0.0233907085,
0.0565639473,
0.0249872059,
-0.0179461036,
0.0186624341,
0.0402276739,
0.0079192081,
0.0172367822,
0.1184649169,
0.007031804,
-0.0121455016,
-0.0383619405,
-0.0530602559,
0.0236005019,
-0.0116970129,
-0.0177276582,
-0.0133590568,
0.0134663004,
-0.0334744006,
-0.019136887,
0.0178786777,
-0.038499549,
0.0175418667,
0.0335458927,
0.1069604754,
-0.0118392203,
-0.0087677818,
-0.0964975879,
-0.0906389728,
0.0076537235,
0.0020153471,
0.0276104379,
-0.0424287543,
-0.0311009213,
-0.0447957627,
0.019465711,
-0.0378428213,
-0.0058168452,
-0.0103860674,
0.014781924,
-0.0112234298,
-0.0059140879,
-0.0574225299,
0.061559286,
-0.0408224538,
0.0308093578,
-0.0524272621,
0.0639308542,
0.0203034785,
-0.076670818,
-0.0414289981,
-0.0138956308,
0.0253535528,
-0.0362813137,
-0.0542540289,
-0.033367414,
-0.0326298326,
0.0001050791,
0.0093881888,
-0.0179918241,
-0.0475641936,
0.0135047585,
0.0442128256,
0.0224781726,
-0.0521206819,
0.0110708848,
-0.0254269205,
-0.0169456955,
0.0073339371,
0.0316689536,
0.0128265452,
-0.0202545114,
-0.0370034948,
0.0079172794,
-0.0364801474,
-0.0029945835,
0.004357161,
0.0106291715,
-0.0088888668,
-0.0398068205,
-0.0283674281,
0.0292001665,
0.0222858898,
0.0423610695,
-0.0079285987,
-0.0577617362,
-0.0233031418,
0.0155316684,
0.0418195166,
-0.0145851597,
-0.0028651808,
-0.0274134856,
-0.006043185,
0.0135539211,
0.0447281189,
0.0174231473,
-0.0149026653,
-0.0348886475,
-0.0387288667,
0.118940562,
0.0098200515,
0.0927688107,
0.026423933,
0.0307033285,
-0.0154940719,
0.0182000045,
0.0091460943,
0.059746325,
-0.0149739301,
0.0350511186,
-0.0160966758,
0.0178931728,
0.0545390807,
0.0296863262,
-0.0205947421,
-0.0315071754,
-0.0305008106,
0.0559488423,
-0.0181343462,
0.0361852311,
-0.0330199525,
0.0008960034,
0.0045111906,
-0.0088066626,
0.0163486227,
-0.0342807099,
-0.0376032442,
-0.0141725028,
0.0080972565,
0.0292915925,
0.0053967885,
0.0344913416,
-0.0512265787,
0.0119798249,
0.0155769251,
-0.0076783844,
-0.0216702484,
-0.0250844099,
0.036275737,
-0.0364426225,
0.0148764234,
0.0256874654,
0.0012071499,
-0.0364355482,
-0.0187438093,
0.0012040667,
-0.0047363658,
-0.0015648411,
0.0275671352,
0.0556703657,
-0.0290221162,
-0.0165668838,
0.0172517411,
0.0398923233,
-0.0551108494,
-0.0359468386,
0.0059628421,
-5.988353932e-33,
0.0171210431,
-0.067409724,
0.0050796075,
0.033932481,
0.0032026167,
-0.0050523789,
-0.0548437349,
0.0432243831,
-0.0812508389,
0.013347635,
-0.0297955703,
0.0110130347,
0.0114307869,
0.0011758787,
0.0699567348,
0.0612633675,
0.0316197015,
0.0305862203,
-0.0262698624,
0.0340409726,
-0.002866158,
0.0201978181,
0.0449177511,
-0.0395317748,
0.052664604,
-0.0471668802,
-0.0012653727,
-0.0892851353,
-0.0441679321,
0.011482521,
-0.0166879725,
0.0312145445,
0.0041082329,
0.0090295998,
-0.0128037483,
0.0293733347,
-0.0238612406,
-0.0454768091,
-0.0159955584,
0.0161609966,
-0.0197372362,
-0.0698990673,
0.057407517,
-0.0139160156,
-0.0551978089,
0.0323607996,
0.0684687123,
-0.016107386,
-0.0018723666,
-0.0045523583,
-0.0671057999,
-0.0151311476,
-0.0526645929,
-0.0184564218,
-0.0219691619,
0.0049629114,
-0.0271192342,
-0.030433245,
-0.0145479636,
0.0798367783,
0.075586997,
0.0408605337,
0.0386451706,
-0.0062984498,
-0.0390121676,
0.0301260781,
0.0360851847,
-0.0672487095,
-0.012463701,
-0.047117129,
0.0144096222,
-0.0475307517,
0.0775509998,
0.0309264362,
-0.0075610843,
-0.0244873427,
-0.02434613,
0.0330110192,
0.0547015779,
-0.0014448804,
-0.0513182357,
-0.0317941345,
-0.0605477393,
-0.020363532,
0.0287453216,
-0.0106550828,
-0.0214889552,
-0.0205328837,
0.0422317907,
-0.0750677884,
-0.0062194695,
0.0430401489,
-0.0314437896,
-0.0266333818,
0.0062201694,
-0.0031587714,
0.0056331223,
0.0323572792,
0.0173394252,
-0.0012459006,
-0.0355008729,
0.0140521154,
-0.0311242715,
0.0563843176,
0.0477917381,
0.0382111073,
-0.0089725517,
0.0267812591,
-0.0302764922,
-0.0058009559,
-0.0189616904,
-0.02436026,
0.0314061865,
-0.0323404036,
-0.0032145788,
-0.0267415792,
0.0336845517,
-0.0029002277,
0.0006856474,
0.0053856107,
-0.0390783735,
-0.0349709466,
-0.0217043981,
-0.0233069528,
-0.0511844531,
-0.030774612,
-0.0985092223,
0.0719168857,
-0.0560471602,
-0.0606310107,
-0.0090291798,
-0.0074532293,
2.893e-7,
-0.0266506188,
0.0400172211,
0.0452860817,
-0.0672623813,
-0.0316711776,
0.0131893344,
-0.0020527833,
-0.0060944809,
0.0266023967,
0.0713827685,
-0.0282136388,
-0.0062433751,
0.0292641856,
0.0153336152,
-0.0249891635,
-0.0059720678,
-0.0004641158,
0.0066924347,
-0.0735008568,
0.0468450226,
0.0470869206,
0.0262362212,
0.041527383,
-0.0166945159,
-0.0271951221,
-0.0283079352,
-0.0062803491,
0.0287723131,
0.0675646067,
-0.0291276202,
-0.074131228,
0.0489281788,
0.0129107684,
0.0178264566,
-0.02907262,
-0.0590541884,
0.0102390358,
0.0206586234,
0.0144448057,
0.0963398293,
0.0382702313,
-0.0194204561,
-0.0221843682,
-0.0589133687,
0.0520352833,
0.0513216928,
0.0000639866,
0.0298698526,
-0.0211673602,
-0.0252596959,
-0.005147716,
-0.0286764149,
0.0170984156,
-0.0465075076,
-0.0205828864,
-0.0502709784,
-0.0239376798,
0.0147331404,
-0.0042453897,
-0.0397383273,
0.0134338308,
-0.028453175,
-0.0382628404,
-0.0044324608,
0.0467523225,
-0.008507072,
0.0750215799,
2.384791281e-34,
-0.015284026,
-0.0605971217,
0.0781772211,
0.0123754451,
-0.0168680772,
0.0384775698,
0.0300696809,
-0.0311840996,
0.01606806,
0.0400256813,
-0.0359671302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07386v1 | Chain-of-Layer: Iteratively Prompting Large Language Models for Taxonomy Induction from Limited Examples | 2024-02-12T03:05:54 | 2024-02-12T03:05:54 | Qingkai Zeng, Yuyang Bai, Zhaoxuan Tan, Shangbin Feng, Zhenwen Liang, Zhihan Zhang, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic taxonomy induction is crucial for web search, recommendation
systems, and question answering. Manual curation of taxonomies is expensive in
terms of human effort, making automatic taxonomy construction highly desirable.
In this work, we introduce Chain-of-Layer which is an in-context learning
framework designed to induct taxonomies from a given set of entities.
Chain-of-Layer breaks down the task into selecting relevant candidate entities
in each layer and gradually building the taxonomy from top to bottom. To
minimize errors, we introduce the Ensemble-based Ranking Filter to reduce the
hallucinated content generated at each iteration. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that Chain-of-Layer achieves state-of-the-art
performance on four real-world benchmarks. | [
0.0291949864,
0.0523071066,
0.0076814224,
0.0218154863,
0.0142697711,
0.0200764444,
-0.0157044735,
0.001439242,
0.0505363941,
-0.0770390183,
-0.0025398093,
-0.0636707321,
0.0079479711,
0.008960152,
0.0216385033,
-0.0261359233,
0.0120985294,
-0.029936349,
-0.0472661443,
-0.0300122425,
-0.0265181605,
0.0292300899,
0.0283505674,
0.0243746787,
0.0310160741,
-0.0256271847,
-0.0095627839,
0.0119710937,
-0.0243221093,
-0.04234685,
0.0130705796,
0.055668693,
0.0228785463,
0.080137372,
0.000001682,
-0.0704041198,
-0.0398531742,
-0.0197610296,
-0.0077451351,
-0.0223887637,
0.0077287876,
0.0304564591,
0.0051131123,
0.0109128747,
-0.0270775184,
-0.0038689412,
0.0270088669,
0.0026041181,
0.0372824185,
0.0272757728,
-0.0201772619,
-0.0344652832,
0.0085945167,
-0.0029080638,
-0.0397427492,
0.0100837862,
0.0377907865,
-0.0288833994,
0.0048256409,
0.0316603594,
0.002305378,
-0.0142515963,
-0.0117214471,
-0.0158099029,
0.0704421625,
0.048707135,
-0.0323625207,
-0.0497630797,
-0.0079935351,
0.1243351772,
-0.0292598195,
-0.0331621058,
-0.027662579,
0.0255028214,
0.0216706432,
0.033310201,
-0.0306979083,
0.0231416654,
-0.0344189629,
0.0128692351,
0.0358251818,
0.005020164,
0.0532562099,
0.0203266386,
-0.0034074117,
0.0703968704,
0.0358817652,
-0.0442749485,
0.0508559458,
0.0210946817,
-0.0240776706,
-0.0491243787,
-0.0169628244,
0.020638939,
-0.072251983,
0.0359228291,
0.0214673933,
0.0672357529,
0.0329355337,
-0.0522552915,
-0.0156585015,
-0.0282430369,
0.0297318622,
0.0969254225,
-0.0249605756,
-0.0332705267,
-0.0053155622,
-0.0478190184,
-0.0322321691,
-0.0393994711,
-0.0591299683,
-0.0016292663,
-0.0441429764,
0.0347497016,
0.0224986896,
-0.0081178891,
-0.0509235263,
0.0048546279,
-0.0255732909,
0.0327756926,
0.006351301,
-0.0017623738,
-0.0081119696,
-0.0003938799,
-0.0117630288,
-0.041566465,
-0.0299818367,
0.0237782206,
0.0155121461,
0.0007492254,
0.0032038367,
0.0035554918,
0.0079879677,
0.0067360173,
0.0138274161,
-0.0350144245,
0.0115701072,
-0.0296284333,
-0.0116598466,
-0.0132874213,
0.0156704355,
-0.0291564148,
-0.0138641419,
-0.0884579271,
0.0058838367,
-0.0119272452,
0.0263811424,
-0.0376406834,
0.0106414584,
0.0325560458,
-0.0412963219,
0.0737319142,
-0.0637363046,
0.0024510578,
0.0485616066,
0.0219364148,
-0.0174746606,
0.0769924298,
-0.0109456433,
0.0339426026,
0.0533728302,
-0.0124715427,
0.046904441,
0.037348859,
0.0265170187,
0.0233962517,
-0.0382489301,
0.0088277971,
-0.0200591031,
0.0507525988,
0.0073829102,
0.0585477315,
-0.0244984794,
0.0319769904,
0.0346012674,
0.0487053655,
0.0295478292,
0.0700851008,
0.0123401778,
-0.0093258461,
-0.0255944803,
-0.0185969733,
0.0060415128,
0.0237662159,
-0.049074281,
-0.0114101572,
0.0315834321,
0.0467964858,
-0.0344266854,
0.0029563031,
0.0045451219,
-0.000593628,
-0.0086951125,
0.0095626172,
0.052976694,
0.060205996,
-0.0099510234,
0.0287628099,
0.0660744309,
-0.0198235642,
-0.0017725809,
-0.0432410352,
0.0460857004,
0.084290348,
0.0522186831,
-0.0204353034,
-0.0036707288,
-0.0239040535,
0.0545568615,
0.0233055018,
-0.0209985487,
-0.0782738999,
-0.0201637372,
-0.0409194343,
-0.0407362245,
0.0392605141,
0.0040247361,
0.00465992,
0.0464623757,
0.0127242925,
0.001519955,
-0.0452065691,
-0.024735583,
0.0268379617,
-0.0194484256,
-0.0206021219,
0.0403707512,
0.0074385661,
0.0048580607,
0.0156491417,
-0.0073191687,
-0.029841641,
0.0507104322,
-0.0407150015,
-0.0528859347,
-0.0232843682,
-0.0268549956,
-0.0285496544,
0.0502015203,
-0.0008708498,
-0.0033817517,
-0.0173298214,
-0.0209458247,
-0.0002216316,
-0.0239116587,
0.0013344761,
0.0298529491,
-0.0519507453,
0.0178371426,
-0.0219249334,
0.010751876,
-0.0665549189,
0.1166331321,
0.0153996395,
0.0327696763,
-0.0030197389,
0.014421843,
-0.0241355412,
0.0139720561,
-0.0304246917,
0.0266735535,
0.0148811126,
0.0361649618,
0.0243882779,
-0.0146601042,
-0.059517961,
-0.0056408946,
-0.1096399948,
0.0010708194,
-0.0040671155,
-0.0177196991,
-0.0130227627,
0.0151177403,
0.0103832548,
0.0145231942,
-0.0259011593,
0.0007281167,
-0.0119488556,
0.0231114719,
-0.010167148,
-0.029270133,
-0.0596972443,
-0.0051298724,
-0.0337451398,
0.0078021451,
0.0964888856,
0.0143843964,
0.0140660768,
-0.0562644377,
-0.0336487778,
-0.0276694149,
-0.0199931413,
0.0126937618,
0.0250722263,
-0.0118098585,
-0.0139123956,
-0.0038968499,
0.0316906087,
0.0237891227,
0.0345474184,
0.0586147532,
0.0298110936,
-0.04889182,
-0.019106349,
-0.0284889378,
0.0203645099,
0.0011946908,
0.0009020214,
-0.0103112562,
0.065339677,
-0.05929441,
-0.0252024457,
-0.0239626579,
0.0527908131,
-0.0288446005,
0.0193850286,
-0.0747343525,
-0.0393037349,
-0.0002172762,
0.050527513,
-0.0214817431,
-0.0359447896,
0.0573300943,
-0.0047023767,
-0.0130588962,
-0.0580520481,
-0.0078050699,
-0.0281417333,
0.0287909564,
-0.0125829056,
0.0419757888,
0.0186274778,
0.0011686255,
-0.0212893263,
0.0489244536,
0.0257878117,
-0.037164066,
0.0338031501,
-0.0110222884,
0.0288493615,
0.0277081393,
-0.0200743657,
-0.0712831914,
-0.0257015675,
-0.002106773,
0.0476467125,
-0.0071834908,
-0.0132691273,
0.0203199834,
-0.0261757132,
-0.0041823932,
0.014991683,
0.0253859442,
-0.0613270067,
0.0266202763,
0.0540439747,
0.0401235484,
-0.0194050055,
0.003255415,
0.0138331121,
0.0922447369,
0.021522684,
0.0352015756,
-0.0003295267,
-0.0497936755,
-0.0043728682,
0.0533101819,
-0.0570361167,
-0.0206926074,
0.0101530878,
-0.0387819372,
0.0261732265,
-0.0289398022,
0.1098611206,
0.0647232383,
-0.1116237119,
0.0112168146,
0.003797377,
0.0529437847,
0.0452212691,
0.0077872784,
-0.0637923256,
0.0058508376,
0.0178948194,
0.0136634475,
0.0095388955,
-0.0380433612,
0.0143957091,
-0.1109891832,
0.0672445893,
0.0103487261,
-0.0201037079,
0.0120516457,
-0.1047977731,
-0.0129119894,
-0.0052751051,
-0.0322262645,
0.0018938838,
0.0042207129,
0.0304114521,
0.0144878868,
0.0073533501,
-0.071540162,
0.0410596281,
-0.0467040241,
0.0205606893,
0.061085429,
0.0473575294,
-0.0247689839,
0.0060387682,
0.0256782789,
-0.0644619316,
-0.0496322811,
-0.0128745539,
0.0190984793,
-0.0016743188,
0.0243064817,
-0.0078971963,
-0.002009511,
-0.0498088449,
0.0051173405,
0.0297755226,
0.0994105414,
0.0037938824,
0.0025542083,
0.0170211848,
-0.0483222008,
0.0397351086,
0.0699164122,
0.0111423265,
-0.0511505976,
0.0453103222,
-0.0563391745,
0.0035251293,
0.0021221719,
0.0016299729,
0.0559583977,
-0.0064096693,
-0.0394449048,
-0.0908055529,
-0.0320612602,
0.0305238366,
0.0590208806,
0.0253258254,
0.0575185306,
0.0016955683,
0.0278964508,
-0.0442359895,
0.0206771754,
0.0273064133,
0.0075772828,
-0.0330439508,
-0.0580343902,
0.0419616215,
-0.04527428,
-0.0379226692,
-0.0164617542,
0.0159529354,
-0.0491193756,
0.0072754021,
0.0271167662,
0.0128607582,
0.0440776199,
-0.0252918508,
-0.0525030605,
0.0872367546,
0.0364197008,
-0.0013346154,
-0.031838119,
-0.0064493464,
0.0224772207,
-0.0025569,
0.058192037,
-0.0706304982,
0.0413227864,
-0.0115446951,
0.0387662277,
-0.0634437203,
-0.0257523488,
0.0443251692,
-0.018232733,
0.0203525014,
-0.0930482447,
-0.0191435702,
-0.0241924506,
0.0015550755,
0.0285750162,
-0.0428266115,
-0.036162734,
0.0340653993,
0.0681606829,
-0.015517707,
-0.0045410222,
0.0270341095,
0.0124426158,
0.03514551,
-0.0182740074,
-0.0090947486,
0.0009994187,
0.0169014875,
0.0457953773,
0.0090707494,
-0.0051087206,
-0.0230136123,
0.0020892315,
0.0334192701,
-0.0417619906,
0.024138175,
0.0242043678,
-0.0231134482,
-0.0558484457,
0.0343214162,
-0.0180000979,
-0.0311784428,
-0.0446457639,
0.020896662,
0.0770993084,
-0.0141000412,
0.0170915462,
-0.0269843228,
-0.0402817242,
0.0034226449,
-0.0067066145,
-0.0251961965,
-0.0547375493,
0.0113590024,
0.0206351746,
-0.0258356389,
0.0442799367,
0.0914574265,
0.0122175468,
0.0131705813,
0.012189379,
-0.0324515216,
-0.0330500267,
-0.0054657734,
-0.0417899266,
0.0221092645,
-0.0295788478,
0.046189826,
-0.0147195626,
-0.0308925733,
-0.0336457789,
-0.0644428134,
0.0124578681,
0.0220805481,
0.0641197339,
0.0851992071,
-0.0052519436,
0.0434623174,
-0.0559063666,
-0.0105061401,
-0.027487915,
-0.0319804847,
-0.0082171811,
-5.843930125e-33,
0.0009350805,
-0.0493905991,
0.0071827136,
0.0129673574,
0.040774934,
-0.0200060103,
-0.0029661327,
0.01576747,
0.0256674606,
0.0321180522,
-0.0153246643,
0.0097124577,
-0.0093902582,
0.032636296,
0.0070998496,
0.0043363064,
0.01497724,
0.0009789411,
-0.0049493955,
0.041093979,
-0.0001791642,
0.0589278713,
0.0019842817,
-0.0488749854,
0.0164436363,
-0.0071134302,
-0.0071786661,
0.0115415715,
-0.0299265441,
0.0432659201,
-0.0304371566,
0.0378175713,
0.0251992662,
-0.043348331,
0.0373682864,
0.0145862214,
-0.0754633918,
0.0181862228,
-0.0378778949,
-0.0006975548,
-0.0351832919,
0.0091221761,
-0.0065290621,
0.0200164728,
0.0140567683,
-0.0372894816,
0.0514957607,
-0.0331458785,
-0.05646782,
-0.0870791599,
-0.0519773327,
0.0267210994,
0.0247897133,
-0.0197736509,
0.0486433171,
0.0263328943,
-0.0211664364,
0.049079448,
-0.0328255109,
0.0110892393,
-0.0380069837,
0.0181883872,
0.0347301103,
0.0180320386,
-0.0178790167,
0.0648915395,
0.0054647271,
-0.005558596,
-0.0278591476,
-0.0275060385,
-0.0262203161,
-0.0113657704,
0.0024504492,
0.011188386,
0.0269603692,
0.012257522,
-0.0689036995,
0.0429605953,
-0.0152793722,
-0.0443773977,
-0.0063137934,
0.0098979305,
-0.0284437928,
-0.0311117247,
-0.0319927596,
0.0087344889,
-0.0430068821,
-0.0310017001,
-0.0008713951,
0.0251783617,
-0.0255773943,
-0.0143095432,
-0.0240396783,
-0.030254053,
-0.0718677193,
-0.0045206212,
0.010404977,
-0.0036210676,
0.0113922218,
0.0203531589,
-0.0506162085,
-0.0194678809,
-0.0118341781,
-0.0049910839,
0.0084468694,
0.037743967,
0.0559291914,
0.0128879277,
-0.0464994088,
0.0248628277,
-0.0129423561,
-0.0283755027,
-0.0037609327,
0.0401466563,
-0.0072831307,
0.0430877395,
0.0098951664,
0.0340586677,
0.0477338135,
0.0312305316,
-0.0124259433,
-0.0134614622,
-0.0282856561,
0.0237723663,
-0.0490143187,
-0.0260978602,
-0.006500036,
-0.0051701642,
0.0343715847,
-0.0649297014,
-0.0306414478,
-0.0561730415,
2.485e-7,
0.0153860683,
0.0793837681,
-0.052006375,
-0.0188552588,
0.0189663917,
0.0192954615,
0.0005311675,
0.0093458584,
-0.0080944989,
-0.0325529985,
-0.0024465243,
0.0121956924,
0.015941998,
0.0596350357,
-0.1091235876,
-0.0349740386,
-0.0370359719,
0.0228258222,
-0.0551427267,
-0.0206717048,
0.0039111162,
0.0897010639,
0.0208501052,
-0.0180288926,
-0.0166253503,
-0.0402906127,
0.0550247617,
-0.0037375935,
0.0068078474,
0.0342654288,
0.027032977,
0.0417348668,
-0.0229506493,
0.0594603606,
-0.0313653983,
0.0207433887,
0.0234899558,
-0.0374982171,
-0.0603937395,
0.0197893884,
0.0049753953,
-0.0049638073,
0.0274426285,
-0.0959695503,
0.0383016393,
-0.0127281379,
0.0121102063,
-0.0053935009,
-0.0301779266,
-0.005351827,
0.0269809887,
-0.045588661,
0.0207813624,
-0.0113792242,
0.0035166752,
0.0151904197,
-0.0084887026,
-0.07009276,
0.0132083427,
0.0197411682,
-0.016561849,
-0.068677634,
0.0028686228,
0.0085852779,
-0.017480908,
-0.0208659247,
0.0450219288,
2.428606226e-34,
0.0060242168,
0.0296634939,
0.0124731744,
0.0645053908,
0.0084938826,
-0.0639080927,
0.0003855099,
0.0123228151,
0.0340633094,
-0.06135685,
0.0162218548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07383v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07383v2 | Making Flow-Matching-Based Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Laugh as You Like | 2024-02-12T02:58:10 | 2024-03-04T19:15:29 | Naoyuki Kanda, Xiaofei Wang, Sefik Emre Eskimez, Manthan Thakker, Hemin Yang, Zirun Zhu, Min Tang, Canrun Li, Chung-Hsien Tsai, Zhen Xiao, Yufei Xia, Jinzhu Li, Yanqing Liu, Sheng Zhao, Michael Zeng | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Laughter is one of the most expressive and natural aspects of human speech,
conveying emotions, social cues, and humor. However, most text-to-speech (TTS)
systems lack the ability to produce realistic and appropriate laughter sounds,
limiting their applications and user experience. While there have been prior
works to generate natural laughter, they fell short in terms of controlling the
timing and variety of the laughter to be generated. In this work, we propose
ELaTE, a zero-shot TTS that can generate natural laughing speech of any speaker
based on a short audio prompt with precise control of laughter timing and
expression. Specifically, ELaTE works on the audio prompt to mimic the voice
characteristic, the text prompt to indicate the contents of the generated
speech, and the input to control the laughter expression, which can be either
the start and end times of laughter, or the additional audio prompt that
contains laughter to be mimicked. We develop our model based on the foundation
of conditional flow-matching-based zero-shot TTS, and fine-tune it with
frame-level representation from a laughter detector as additional conditioning.
With a simple scheme to mix small-scale laughter-conditioned data with
large-scale pre-training data, we demonstrate that a pre-trained zero-shot TTS
model can be readily fine-tuned to generate natural laughter with precise
controllability, without losing any quality of the pre-trained zero-shot TTS
model. Through objective and subjective evaluations, we show that ELaTE can
generate laughing speech with significantly higher quality and controllability
compared to conventional models. See https://aka.ms/elate/ for demo samples. | [
0.0048318976,
0.0359815918,
0.0150246965,
-0.0117557086,
0.0082680201,
0.0135897361,
0.045941744,
0.054403875,
0.0178128127,
-0.0158363525,
-0.0570686758,
-0.0304625295,
-0.0109916041,
0.0672921836,
0.0404615812,
-0.1042206734,
-0.0153401429,
-0.009597267,
0.0012384533,
-0.0376273841,
0.0755176917,
0.0215876736,
-0.0676421076,
0.0261515751,
-0.0194907989,
0.002913086,
-0.019094428,
0.0673900917,
0.0122620026,
-0.0294007119,
-0.0088492874,
0.0153041827,
0.0411240608,
0.006131968,
0.0000016616,
-0.0485749207,
-0.00450351,
0.0108780926,
-0.0072917901,
0.0095998552,
0.0604340434,
-0.0031497681,
-0.073226653,
0.0154991196,
0.0042283791,
0.0319279172,
0.0789180323,
0.0030469457,
0.0555516444,
0.0976339579,
-0.0178828873,
-0.0120228529,
-0.0082787517,
-0.0147270774,
0.0444380306,
-0.046564091,
-0.0014393607,
-0.0134787643,
0.0647432879,
-0.079537414,
-0.0757908821,
0.0174740218,
-0.0311410148,
-0.0007981604,
0.0141556645,
0.0174390748,
-0.0666809678,
-0.0235773828,
-0.0264363922,
0.0972811282,
-0.024993984,
0.0156982467,
0.0399394073,
0.0218825862,
0.0014787598,
-0.0242718961,
-0.0017746661,
-0.019899074,
0.0340125971,
-0.0288114082,
-0.0866284892,
0.0529545918,
-0.0393153019,
0.0034963896,
0.0142571507,
-0.0212983005,
0.0294555258,
-0.0038332758,
-0.0370775051,
-0.0103400322,
-0.0179680437,
-0.0461829267,
0.0800381303,
0.072045058,
0.0577667356,
-0.0069223717,
-0.0366420001,
-0.0188235696,
-0.020668108,
0.009985147,
0.0002510365,
0.017505547,
-0.0297270324,
0.012702167,
-0.0189847946,
0.0275237951,
-0.0249815863,
-0.0316336229,
-0.0292340983,
0.0054728976,
0.0009292873,
0.0121793039,
-0.025946917,
0.0139826471,
-0.0261330325,
-0.0237013716,
-0.0809962973,
-0.0016690377,
-0.0327847265,
-0.0067790202,
-0.0271822028,
0.0417174101,
-0.0287211407,
-0.0557648055,
0.0202479716,
0.0558716282,
-0.0106359487,
0.0337558426,
-0.0217896122,
-0.0502106696,
-0.0178363007,
0.0383738391,
0.0518003553,
0.0018758454,
0.04585566,
0.0427845865,
0.0015592081,
-0.0366140231,
0.0103486152,
-0.0086480873,
-0.0732088089,
-0.0260174647,
0.0194952749,
-0.0468714088,
-0.0002869703,
-0.0319878384,
-0.0000193794,
0.0238876306,
-0.0183554161,
-0.0172291286,
0.011831319,
-0.0076562394,
-0.0116700698,
0.0253400598,
-0.0003495144,
0.0062524369,
0.0128357532,
0.0052866125,
0.0461295396,
-0.0246453006,
-0.0082870685,
-0.0339494608,
0.0256524775,
0.0522020124,
0.0366547853,
0.0329658836,
-0.0073376424,
-0.0276640318,
-0.0383512378,
0.0219177809,
0.0919080079,
-0.0146713257,
-0.039641615,
-0.007554438,
0.0625395551,
0.0366368368,
0.0777115822,
0.0008627246,
0.0447606258,
0.0135028064,
-0.0071349107,
0.0001494359,
0.0432550311,
0.0362693295,
-0.0569195151,
0.0180842578,
-0.0086007258,
0.0219556838,
-0.0504258908,
0.018056279,
0.0117693264,
-0.0400746427,
0.0056442022,
-0.0118802367,
0.0131268026,
0.0454252139,
-0.0361602791,
0.0083766365,
-0.0224064738,
-0.088970691,
-0.0042245309,
-0.0122319208,
0.02295251,
0.063889645,
0.0129600884,
-0.0088399043,
-0.0154225305,
-0.0049943309,
0.0063068322,
0.0271990802,
-0.0246556625,
-0.0067995214,
0.0606302097,
-0.0734455138,
0.0593707375,
0.005703087,
-0.0073057045,
0.0355070233,
-0.020313805,
0.0651796311,
-0.0405083895,
0.0561805554,
0.0840658322,
-0.0149208894,
-0.112319842,
-0.0154864416,
0.03301147,
0.0173876137,
0.0091758156,
0.0062468587,
-0.0232602581,
-0.0148694655,
-0.0085393107,
-0.0006453612,
0.0116806775,
0.0704827756,
-0.0451419726,
-0.0185016841,
0.0204185583,
-0.0151827121,
0.0218891222,
0.0297649633,
-0.0083754603,
-0.0484250188,
0.0643532947,
-0.0046249353,
0.0023663174,
-0.0410046317,
0.0099759959,
0.0088836849,
-0.0180931464,
0.0304711126,
-0.0226446427,
0.0210895985,
0.0088295806,
0.0171100125,
0.0388613604,
-0.0172788259,
-0.038443476,
-0.056059327,
0.0182282329,
-0.0233275834,
0.0429839604,
-0.0186830163,
0.0034572664,
-0.0228053555,
-0.0351247825,
-0.031930387,
0.0275376998,
0.0415523425,
-0.0461043492,
0.0225828011,
-0.0008586797,
-0.0205232631,
-0.0280953031,
-0.0305859949,
0.0446018279,
0.0344744921,
-0.0378002562,
-0.0148230484,
-0.0579110533,
-0.0250657313,
-0.0372166894,
0.0050564641,
-0.0134732043,
-0.0198302008,
-0.0014230788,
0.0143386284,
-0.0059607215,
0.047623653,
-0.0183444247,
0.0219778046,
0.0117009338,
-0.0388536081,
-0.0079343952,
0.0104276026,
-0.0188196711,
0.029092323,
0.0203864798,
-0.0499790721,
-0.0032078563,
-0.0390822589,
-0.0086002164,
-0.0023761161,
0.0238066074,
0.0534584261,
-0.0141993184,
0.0168057978,
-0.0291457251,
0.0054246574,
0.0368460156,
0.0493966639,
-0.0932096764,
0.0091248583,
0.0445570387,
-0.0100466851,
0.057424169,
-0.0356567539,
-0.0302037187,
-0.0600186996,
-0.0198266059,
-0.0320301838,
0.0334092602,
-0.0442443974,
-0.081382826,
-0.0238988344,
0.0170415957,
-0.021096291,
0.0181964356,
-0.041385401,
0.0242773481,
0.0034463555,
-0.0127735781,
-0.0187525302,
-0.0108201057,
0.003563883,
-0.0612399951,
0.0453036949,
0.0282645375,
-0.0235488601,
-0.0086339032,
-0.011144775,
0.0072419164,
-0.0354221314,
-0.0299988836,
0.0073722224,
-0.0308042392,
-0.0360984281,
-0.0105355969,
0.018197801,
0.0107749877,
0.0025651492,
-0.0068828636,
0.0190738272,
-0.0358727463,
0.0348164886,
0.0364063084,
0.0243086666,
-0.0338445045,
0.021722015,
0.0328728631,
0.0028157772,
0.0421102419,
0.0508233309,
-0.0342318676,
0.0315023325,
0.010342028,
0.027047243,
0.0131635526,
0.0126839457,
0.0545302704,
0.0112579996,
-0.0035946073,
0.0791637525,
-0.0269772764,
-0.0072470186,
-0.0062139905,
0.0026072222,
0.0159557909,
0.0055610104,
-0.0022901359,
-0.0442706086,
-0.0295084119,
0.0462624803,
-0.0033045111,
0.0227415934,
0.0168382097,
-0.0252920575,
-0.1016515493,
0.0146591691,
0.0703584552,
0.0102752857,
0.0140291909,
0.0410360768,
0.0008098375,
-0.0144602396,
-0.0268754344,
0.0047670398,
-0.0071856389,
0.0079942457,
0.0392762274,
-0.0122132441,
-0.0409832224,
0.035585992,
-0.0423111953,
0.1304831505,
0.0312561914,
0.0668359026,
0.0071040764,
-0.0289115123,
-0.0512470566,
-0.0391094536,
0.0099081006,
0.0343767293,
0.066784963,
-0.0029519089,
0.0069170357,
-0.0371713974,
0.0472934246,
0.0140286312,
0.0334148444,
-0.0132183358,
-0.0000416614,
-0.0092112469,
-0.0082960725,
-0.045662906,
0.0727132112,
-0.0113764163,
0.0600325204,
-0.0070449216,
-0.0728940219,
-0.0157248061,
-0.0077965283,
0.0062916717,
-0.0854488611,
-0.0471457541,
0.0042527928,
0.0165382456,
-0.0692012459,
-0.0966085643,
0.0422807857,
-0.0162147377,
0.058779683,
-0.00339997,
-0.0814314559,
-0.0399201587,
0.0060714781,
0.0027196442,
-0.0273804069,
-0.0119320313,
0.0293881036,
-0.0509742536,
0.0317119434,
0.0170966983,
-0.0496562831,
-0.0018980331,
0.0323501341,
-0.0438387953,
-0.0688230619,
0.0034516472,
0.0298545435,
0.018696934,
0.0126059884,
-0.0156945903,
-0.0393004157,
0.0540617667,
0.0326017067,
-0.0295055397,
0.0472293086,
0.0678789467,
0.0315802768,
-0.0100865997,
-0.0006799169,
-0.0211164895,
0.0554631278,
0.0005627488,
0.0117462669,
-0.0155616309,
-0.0398474149,
-0.0206774268,
0.0266167484,
-0.0149134025,
0.0013458737,
-0.0173071083,
0.0132911783,
-0.0138092246,
-0.0020261158,
0.0619056784,
-0.0727576613,
-0.0394202024,
0.0367316194,
0.0122865913,
-0.0094462251,
-0.0577781498,
-0.0479767136,
0.0074925516,
-0.0332689993,
-0.0035748759,
0.0614857115,
-0.0245006215,
0.0075039705,
0.0288558882,
0.0084511666,
0.0223556682,
-0.0272813365,
0.0052349777,
-0.0174325071,
0.0222522374,
-0.0101308981,
-0.0088626044,
0.0264161471,
0.0258207694,
0.0038672041,
0.0686647296,
0.0127573209,
-0.0167656597,
0.0481042564,
-0.0015136617,
0.1010843217,
-0.0092966603,
0.0417955406,
-0.0305576976,
-0.0002246498,
-0.0572643615,
-0.0794117674,
-0.014645895,
-0.033529114,
0.0054623759,
-0.0348645262,
0.0143720368,
-0.0555179939,
0.0483820848,
-0.0251651499,
0.0475035682,
-0.0187459607,
-0.0004986854,
0.0068890071,
-0.0308982581,
0.0035050074,
-0.0067983544,
-0.0500389263,
-0.0560462475,
0.068017453,
-0.0513669774,
0.0104040653,
-0.0606019124,
0.0421992056,
-0.0412589125,
-0.0362089314,
0.0600544252,
-0.0013073254,
-0.0095252115,
-0.047285337,
-0.0066590244,
-0.0234616734,
-4.864126931e-33,
-0.0058723693,
0.0139629515,
-0.0114854192,
0.0187860467,
-0.0142144198,
0.0228986554,
-0.0528751351,
0.0083641894,
-0.0242332648,
-0.0165978316,
-0.0051445467,
0.0020797285,
-0.0096998168,
0.0010229356,
-0.0309231505,
-0.001908855,
0.0220410191,
-0.0260045566,
-0.0194886122,
0.0299942568,
0.0784766972,
0.0185678434,
0.0332552977,
-0.046238862,
-0.0641713813,
-0.0366602093,
-0.0586027093,
-0.0442095064,
0.0724807978,
0.026684735,
0.0138562117,
0.0357709937,
0.0048380489,
0.0221672133,
-0.0028439506,
0.0229007974,
-0.0078708772,
-0.0159139708,
-0.0175296459,
-0.0143846367,
-0.0277052019,
0.0083865644,
0.0450690538,
0.0025942544,
-0.0465333015,
-0.0377043262,
0.017333623,
-0.0117971618,
0.0290459245,
-0.059555281,
-0.0461607389,
0.0171305146,
-0.0238037538,
-0.1030646786,
0.0373875946,
0.1148916557,
0.0010161147,
-0.0438158885,
-0.0139713613,
0.076351054,
-0.0581044853,
-0.0078841951,
-0.0037401107,
-0.0114892591,
-0.0045030555,
0.0662867948,
0.0124405371,
-0.0173258893,
-0.0075277598,
0.0470685884,
0.0524002649,
0.0239765812,
0.0544177443,
0.0303928852,
0.0116861211,
-0.0512595288,
0.0081367381,
0.0369290896,
0.0222684406,
-0.0106583443,
0.0102259554,
0.0517126396,
-0.0423758924,
0.0334993079,
0.0005828901,
-0.0012382813,
-0.0005563156,
-0.0444075949,
0.0289161131,
0.031217983,
-0.0257963687,
-0.008719597,
0.0719607696,
0.0026411142,
-0.001124358,
0.0255833492,
-0.0632706508,
0.0493482612,
0.0020193008,
0.0205173492,
-0.0396892391,
-0.0293847043,
0.0930354297,
0.0583788007,
0.0334457234,
0.0323160887,
0.0061355163,
0.0664402395,
-0.0142543521,
-0.0035159485,
0.001381064,
0.0507153124,
0.00913845,
-0.0014583544,
-0.0020277647,
0.0503689572,
-0.0120364903,
-0.0115615418,
-0.0121330451,
-0.0093845753,
-0.0175584685,
0.0171764065,
0.0090007149,
0.0310127679,
-0.0838605985,
0.0160045251,
0.0009851466,
-0.0482868962,
0.0185977165,
-0.0251132175,
-0.0066441246,
-0.0057014469,
2.523e-7,
-0.0379629023,
-0.0053575891,
0.0344764628,
0.0152287493,
0.0615337789,
0.0464679003,
-0.018849114,
0.0311283059,
0.0284075718,
0.0022371658,
-0.0024596346,
-0.0364582241,
0.068376638,
-0.0277789664,
-0.0651110262,
-0.0200377442,
-0.0448133647,
0.0554493144,
0.018517442,
0.0091596693,
-0.0075830058,
-0.0016506833,
0.0087780738,
-0.0087659443,
0.0551267713,
-0.0453755781,
0.0422245413,
0.026260376,
0.0251815543,
-0.0401994921,
-0.0163864605,
-0.0581994317,
-0.0355416946,
-0.0216159895,
-0.0372453183,
-0.0160690416,
0.0014024973,
0.0716724619,
-0.0328756794,
-0.0576004758,
-0.0056848307,
0.0257315747,
-0.0279143192,
0.0291551985,
0.036552798,
0.0404619798,
-0.0229806658,
-0.0110310977,
-0.0356597938,
-0.0120982556,
0.0235686507,
-0.0185299236,
-0.0290822312,
0.0165777747,
0.0449471734,
0.0270356014,
-0.0101501727,
-0.0271989163,
-0.0389707498,
-0.0297282189,
-0.0562204458,
0.0017427586,
-0.0228021387,
-0.0093979314,
-0.0013665142,
-0.0893466175,
-0.0267917532,
1.721992924e-34,
0.0094869547,
-0.0226776805,
0.0498791523,
-0.0365679115,
-0.0143435765,
0.0201907773,
0.0331750549,
0.0021872104,
0.0771328285,
-0.0160790998,
-0.0485566407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07368v1 | Assessing Generalization for Subpopulation Representative Modeling via In-Context Learning | 2024-02-12T01:55:51 | 2024-02-12T01:55:51 | Gabriel Simmons, Vladislav Savinov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | This study evaluates the ability of Large Language Model (LLM)-based
Subpopulation Representative Models (SRMs) to generalize from empirical data,
utilizing in-context learning with data from the 2016 and 2020 American
National Election Studies. We explore generalization across response variables
and demographic subgroups. While conditioning with empirical data improves
performance on the whole, the benefit of in-context learning varies
considerably across demographics, sometimes hurting performance for one
demographic while helping performance for others. The inequitable benefits of
in-context learning for SRM present a challenge for practitioners implementing
SRMs, and for decision-makers who might come to rely on them. Our work
highlights a need for fine-grained benchmarks captured from diverse
subpopulations that test not only fidelity but generalization. | [
0.0140754608,
0.1214409173,
-0.011455969,
-0.0033897553,
-0.0110458722,
0.0421871692,
0.0285360347,
0.0236438662,
-0.0148704685,
-0.0430446491,
0.0242060125,
-0.0772863925,
0.001883344,
-0.0141810235,
0.0391764045,
-0.0736918077,
0.0336092487,
0.0138431955,
0.0368743911,
-0.0671354532,
-0.0107984655,
0.0006766843,
0.033789888,
0.0676904321,
-0.0095558828,
0.0167403687,
0.0180875547,
0.0029400538,
-0.0002276097,
0.0052772732,
0.0170150567,
0.0203489177,
0.0604693182,
-0.001693991,
0.0000017588,
-0.0428840779,
-0.0049178167,
0.0058078286,
0.0021059099,
0.0220417716,
0.0864067078,
0.0024171439,
0.000686803,
0.0237469431,
0.0076244632,
-0.004070913,
0.0246592965,
-0.0391885303,
0.0082864705,
-0.000419819,
-0.0110110603,
-0.0113352211,
-0.0280362908,
-0.0241355691,
-0.0277367737,
-0.008513147,
0.0454002656,
0.0027107981,
-0.0419805013,
-0.042570129,
-0.0452937111,
0.005809186,
-0.006976903,
0.0306058116,
-0.019870704,
0.0124431001,
-0.0183712319,
0.0211286861,
-0.0097266436,
0.0321141295,
0.0360399447,
0.0294103138,
-0.0083213802,
-0.0036040132,
0.0307655912,
0.0494702049,
-0.064044185,
0.0014526183,
0.0008654447,
0.0251274332,
-0.0067124139,
-0.0206970889,
0.0141370203,
-0.0161420461,
-0.0549833104,
0.1070431769,
0.0069779367,
-0.0241750646,
-0.0103978105,
-0.008222417,
-0.0247129686,
-0.0087411171,
0.0217118543,
-0.0243225265,
-0.0310065057,
0.0230081026,
-0.0054882215,
-0.0214737374,
0.0221280586,
-0.0327331126,
0.0457720459,
0.0404355824,
0.0111483848,
0.02395631,
0.0534457117,
0.0524954796,
0.015366734,
0.0265491847,
0.0040436671,
-0.0397359207,
-0.0463428125,
0.0162574518,
0.0163664259,
0.0075049642,
-0.0113245305,
0.0594873689,
-0.0776360184,
-0.0079829162,
-0.0198708661,
0.0188910104,
-0.0680404231,
-0.0415182039,
-0.0378328972,
-0.0245006997,
-0.0411104858,
0.0521170571,
-0.0132131111,
0.0371347032,
-0.0048449165,
-0.0273928009,
0.0510815233,
0.005644965,
-0.0054504694,
-0.0191764291,
-0.0071135396,
0.0294028074,
0.0089145768,
0.0050537759,
-0.0120353019,
0.0279426929,
-0.0391483121,
-0.046807956,
-0.0112877488,
-0.0912524164,
0.0294321682,
0.0176858883,
0.0414384641,
-0.0618264563,
-0.0269469433,
-0.0177968815,
-0.0342590585,
-0.0022771838,
0.0166789982,
0.0272070542,
0.0243262053,
-0.0006461697,
0.0472830236,
0.083400555,
0.0280761588,
0.0039120391,
0.0153870694,
-0.0521369502,
-0.0334778391,
0.0527556762,
-0.0019115852,
0.068398051,
-0.0624115467,
0.0233600177,
0.0372889005,
-0.0324597694,
0.0754152536,
0.0028451616,
0.0011611107,
-0.0069860904,
0.0566558689,
0.1158942878,
0.0029633478,
0.0267284419,
0.0169398747,
0.055887688,
-0.0316765718,
-0.0057247858,
-0.0326837786,
-0.041628141,
-0.0064723333,
-0.0249329321,
0.0475223884,
0.0305524003,
-0.0318449177,
-0.0135268979,
0.0033572153,
0.018708501,
0.0233068857,
0.0651216879,
0.0801217854,
-0.0542530045,
-0.0052643833,
0.01525936,
0.0718210563,
-0.0196344778,
0.0061221141,
-0.049598325,
0.0391493253,
0.0207921043,
-0.0241170991,
-0.0274843574,
0.0329340063,
-0.0301723797,
0.054598894,
0.0270102751,
0.040541213,
-0.0161301773,
0.0169138145,
-0.006019685,
-0.0223759301,
0.0342383794,
0.0446730442,
0.0437565967,
0.0351725481,
-0.0123980166,
-0.0086232126,
-0.0606272928,
-0.0156255886,
0.0148431547,
-0.0214911569,
0.0009341596,
-0.0027022639,
0.0020308273,
0.0315981656,
-0.0322228447,
-0.0216910969,
-0.0349298492,
-0.0325053632,
0.0017935203,
0.0174176674,
-0.0485092327,
-0.035323225,
0.0038248873,
-0.0104722613,
-0.0121966321,
-0.0242443308,
0.0069313864,
-0.0473468266,
0.0063459156,
0.0572272204,
0.0020559505,
0.0666848868,
-0.0024357049,
0.0174110774,
-0.072344929,
-0.0250018649,
-0.0304638464,
0.0419338495,
-0.0351675674,
0.0061900527,
0.0085677048,
-0.0166456159,
0.0023476395,
-0.0501576774,
-0.0216340702,
-0.0097912531,
-0.0305115618,
0.0283345152,
0.001512237,
-0.0219107866,
-0.0058131977,
-0.0148176467,
-0.0619492792,
0.0166799948,
-0.0273359828,
0.0041144374,
0.0165640116,
0.0068196282,
-0.037507344,
0.0173318908,
-0.0066184914,
-0.0174707975,
0.0068975226,
0.0270107724,
-0.0112262173,
-0.0105265705,
-0.0109375864,
-0.0498507172,
-0.0395768136,
-0.0117663583,
0.0345484577,
-0.0112016546,
0.0119184069,
0.000959456,
0.0069476566,
-0.0335522369,
-0.0162011273,
-0.0354307555,
-0.0111236302,
-0.004874438,
0.0213190634,
0.0368685462,
0.0323997177,
0.0038804761,
0.0123758633,
0.027123658,
0.0102171069,
-0.0506994501,
-0.0082681859,
-0.0239887889,
-0.0284837298,
-0.0406053923,
-0.0663309991,
-0.0032816366,
0.0958817229,
0.0217368994,
0.0028463693,
-0.014985228,
0.0000713376,
-0.0694723129,
-0.0183687974,
-0.0975570604,
0.0229363441,
-0.0038695897,
0.02462231,
-0.0376909338,
-0.0623978823,
0.0029705518,
0.0333050638,
0.0522488877,
-0.004892122,
-0.0319041312,
-0.0130733447,
0.0031031307,
0.014755222,
0.0059561986,
-0.0030782369,
-0.0092850588,
-0.0425924994,
-0.0335731097,
0.0049472004,
-0.0329908393,
0.1203759164,
-0.0277133081,
0.0131422309,
-0.0105087776,
-0.0552302264,
-0.0250026006,
-0.0634361878,
-0.0232803393,
0.0307744611,
0.051947698,
-0.036615625,
-0.0336438306,
0.0143469004,
0.0432149917,
-0.0417787768,
0.0224655047,
-0.0169158522,
0.037726678,
-0.0260520652,
0.0127295116,
0.0132831037,
0.0136017976,
-0.0845284015,
0.0107966904,
-0.0015452354,
0.0670300201,
0.0262621641,
-0.0275257882,
-0.0125096664,
0.0401877947,
0.0026156197,
-0.0266162027,
0.0531690121,
0.0520301461,
-0.0247463919,
0.0378460623,
0.0695494413,
0.0108810114,
-0.0266855974,
-0.0116390064,
-0.0331816487,
0.0484204926,
0.0634203702,
0.0142076062,
-0.056379769,
0.0141818682,
0.0285272393,
0.0031066046,
0.0043964405,
-0.0096664941,
0.0147427814,
-0.0862112641,
0.0458019562,
0.0209338143,
-0.0437000506,
0.0074099209,
-0.0167926215,
0.0561954603,
-0.008468329,
0.0173448287,
0.0046080626,
-0.0408721343,
-0.0356182158,
0.013856261,
-0.1040882915,
-0.0803065002,
0.01462299,
-0.0412797406,
0.0168115273,
0.044705689,
0.0520507917,
-0.0058293268,
0.0445471257,
0.0344460495,
-0.0210420769,
-0.0406327285,
0.0184808206,
0.0422925018,
0.0010952525,
0.0106269903,
-0.0327841602,
0.005005382,
0.0147976596,
-0.0006169075,
0.020836832,
0.0015863739,
0.0074053239,
-0.0237458758,
0.0160118118,
0.023087712,
0.0255181715,
0.0541277528,
0.0478402637,
-0.0291737448,
0.0301552676,
-0.0503077991,
-0.019661773,
0.004725717,
-0.0141177578,
0.0171003528,
-0.0300210677,
0.007779419,
0.0313676633,
0.0048093232,
0.054965917,
-0.0079089766,
0.0032849063,
0.0184356496,
0.0564637445,
-0.0422247164,
0.0008103951,
0.023577895,
-0.0793103948,
-0.0111537715,
-0.0070884349,
-0.0603554435,
0.0133562014,
0.0329117961,
-0.0304289944,
-0.0054363282,
-0.053430941,
-0.0405640379,
0.0668374151,
-0.0123611204,
0.0238569975,
0.0053613465,
0.0416210517,
-0.0533506647,
0.0797610283,
0.0000642136,
0.0196819026,
-0.0007261158,
-0.0049559036,
0.0330300331,
-0.0169336759,
0.0126646999,
-0.0118003068,
0.0221512858,
0.0763438344,
-0.0586809851,
-0.0594275668,
0.0355481654,
-0.0104260156,
-0.016005218,
0.0143945925,
-0.0087140165,
-0.0490019135,
-0.0410594828,
-0.0513617732,
0.002802026,
0.0225891452,
0.0091509251,
-0.0405165851,
0.0285472423,
0.0104183285,
-0.0193070974,
-0.0065414207,
-0.0138247535,
0.0409638435,
-0.0716922283,
0.0768136382,
-0.0140675111,
0.0260784421,
0.0629336536,
0.0145809734,
0.0150809558,
0.0283088069,
-0.0063800719,
0.0392047912,
0.0265585016,
0.0250711273,
-0.0156581197,
0.0290100295,
0.0059166588,
-0.0260558743,
-0.0227868445,
-0.0462320596,
-0.0174909048,
0.0414040387,
0.0170836914,
-0.0311357416,
-0.0184222367,
0.0138784908,
-0.015229308,
-0.0281588025,
0.0077835442,
-0.0115551464,
-0.0369618461,
0.0649033263,
-0.0077327057,
-0.064662151,
0.0367391966,
0.084747985,
0.0548579283,
0.0180814806,
-0.0189041793,
-0.0009467567,
-0.0323121212,
-0.0308595039,
0.0434544906,
0.0417645797,
-0.0366089344,
-0.022555558,
-0.0787180662,
-0.052503515,
0.0135727096,
-0.0357201397,
-0.010974817,
-0.0016587003,
-0.0050594872,
0.0357693583,
-0.0370044187,
0.0132100396,
-0.0257837735,
-0.0012523669,
-0.0491129011,
-0.0369748548,
-0.0079051405,
-5.8511877e-33,
-0.0564542636,
-0.0159163252,
-0.0131707154,
-0.0810948536,
0.0027747548,
0.0013497436,
-0.0138831548,
0.0250936449,
0.0041408464,
-0.0113131534,
-0.0006682308,
0.0048298454,
0.0153767737,
0.0325377472,
0.0076838331,
-0.0159961302,
0.0317929611,
0.0150517309,
-0.0127459066,
0.0052376767,
0.0099828588,
0.0324372277,
0.0486777499,
-0.0417148806,
0.013455213,
-0.0078109498,
0.0093215518,
-0.0492140874,
-0.0018981199,
0.039270103,
-0.0328069478,
0.0463424399,
0.0386760421,
-0.039086841,
-0.0111785708,
0.0868434757,
-0.0287313256,
-0.0023349132,
0.0293042231,
-0.0310735665,
0.0232131388,
-0.0148081137,
0.0166138876,
0.0334166288,
-0.0423647761,
-0.0362260826,
0.0403404273,
-0.0254157186,
-0.0189313218,
0.0041830223,
-0.0549494997,
0.0217086114,
-0.0219836235,
0.0759720281,
-0.04211808,
0.0976518989,
0.0118933814,
0.0756747797,
-0.040778704,
0.0251458157,
0.0234059971,
0.0017265872,
0.0281658862,
0.029206058,
0.0275545008,
0.0584003888,
0.018645538,
0.0130699296,
-0.0136083961,
-0.0652066693,
0.0746331364,
-0.0300677866,
0.007233337,
0.1010140628,
0.0373644941,
-0.0574162193,
-0.0733304098,
-0.0075581879,
0.0182064157,
-0.025110608,
0.0598538183,
0.0065715089,
-0.045042064,
-0.0558594391,
-0.0520109311,
-0.0419300273,
-0.0009599809,
-0.0238543823,
0.0335151553,
0.0131968595,
-0.0220149867,
-0.0213489644,
0.0726643652,
-0.037893191,
-0.0378805175,
-0.0162344165,
-0.0364095196,
-0.0072840387,
-0.0011747327,
0.0145629626,
-0.057412304,
-0.026183283,
-0.0284191929,
0.023040643,
0.021841716,
-0.0052981004,
0.0189190656,
-0.00213346,
-0.0766032487,
0.0091663748,
0.0029797265,
0.0042893495,
0.0152862985,
0.0024172091,
0.0680931956,
0.0151697593,
0.0578008071,
0.0224408396,
-0.0061957901,
-0.0411049351,
0.0322754383,
-0.0321452506,
-0.0593066961,
0.0185938254,
-0.0210656635,
-0.0179675538,
0.0011521942,
0.0016573856,
0.0429216363,
0.007417311,
-0.0398248211,
-0.025451187,
2.192e-7,
0.0660466701,
0.0575350821,
-0.0545118526,
-0.0417912975,
-0.0025951108,
0.0117582176,
-0.0253956039,
-0.0118209757,
0.0571382754,
-0.0302504282,
0.0063554943,
0.0064821718,
0.0391941033,
0.012012139,
-0.0670458153,
0.028756924,
-0.0725182369,
0.024851393,
-0.0619323775,
0.0401608758,
-0.0207268111,
0.071506314,
0.0266519226,
-0.0296316389,
-0.0312604643,
0.0052953763,
0.074242942,
-0.1065339074,
-0.0608718656,
0.0478834063,
-0.0182636045,
0.05100872,
0.0011159711,
0.0623661391,
-0.0163243748,
0.0308492202,
-0.015420883,
0.0584522747,
0.0286672227,
0.0179765876,
-0.0146107487,
0.0149010569,
-0.0139176138,
-0.0714547932,
0.0572309904,
-0.0769509003,
-0.0415230691,
-0.0713345036,
-0.0177114923,
-0.0062574293,
0.0567167327,
-0.0192542542,
0.0053840275,
-0.022294255,
0.0108471895,
-0.0067715961,
-0.0177181698,
-0.0149878254,
0.0129223196,
0.0006551386,
-0.0632413402,
-0.0917804465,
0.0044164001,
0.0348751061,
0.0062950258,
-0.0137249175,
0.0298136193,
2.070442052e-34,
0.0408774316,
0.038190335,
0.0206935667,
-0.0407271013,
0.050242085,
-0.0103394538,
-0.0142752975,
0.000544487,
0.0120087201,
-0.0566122942,
0.0362353697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07321v1 | Summing Up the Facts: Additive Mechanisms Behind Factual Recall in LLMs | 2024-02-11T22:58:49 | 2024-02-11T22:58:49 | Bilal Chughtai, Alan Cooney, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | How do transformer-based large language models (LLMs) store and retrieve
knowledge? We focus on the most basic form of this task -- factual recall,
where the model is tasked with explicitly surfacing stored facts in prompts of
form `Fact: The Colosseum is in the country of'. We find that the mechanistic
story behind factual recall is more complex than previously thought. It
comprises several distinct, independent, and qualitatively different mechanisms
that additively combine, constructively interfering on the correct attribute.
We term this generic phenomena the additive motif: models compute through
summing up multiple independent contributions. Each mechanism's contribution
may be insufficient alone, but summing results in constructive interfere on the
correct answer. In addition, we extend the method of direct logit attribution
to attribute an attention head's output to individual source tokens. We use
this technique to unpack what we call `mixed heads' -- which are themselves a
pair of two separate additive updates from different source tokens. | [
0.0282867011,
0.007595777,
-0.019008046,
0.0287053995,
-0.0384871401,
0.0097690756,
-0.0395670496,
-0.0298949126,
-0.0147133963,
-0.0487137586,
-0.0258111656,
-0.0607108958,
0.0364535935,
0.0035707306,
0.0452663414,
-0.0048574144,
0.0561388768,
-0.0379985534,
-0.0310856011,
-0.0241034012,
-0.0345660821,
-0.0169858746,
-0.0195433274,
0.0076886853,
-0.018182531,
-0.0067607374,
-0.0047840318,
-0.0375283733,
0.015409044,
0.0142796738,
-0.01864939,
0.0193213951,
-0.0272311661,
0.0351817459,
0.0000019899,
-0.0732562542,
-0.0014117369,
-0.0108849443,
-0.0469665378,
0.0296035707,
-0.0275426544,
0.0355830304,
-0.0224995613,
0.0002753239,
-0.0153430337,
-0.0169637799,
0.065495044,
0.0608017072,
0.0302942246,
0.0737247765,
0.010802675,
-0.0266852863,
0.0405240282,
-0.0135231866,
0.0415178053,
0.0101817101,
0.0282159857,
-0.0107376184,
-0.0414369144,
0.012912428,
-0.0128696421,
0.0447131731,
0.0255011972,
0.0061758514,
0.0284945797,
0.0496808514,
-0.0427678451,
0.0100453822,
0.0002337011,
0.0233550221,
0.0456089377,
-0.0397340246,
0.0036714382,
0.0072924951,
0.0402507149,
0.0052856184,
-0.0705784187,
0.0529820547,
-0.0277907513,
0.0140985772,
0.0457271673,
-0.0301405229,
0.0521433055,
0.0084333681,
-0.0480145738,
0.0450272001,
0.0107332757,
-0.031683065,
-0.0548272915,
0.026392037,
-0.0199680943,
-0.07612326,
-0.0079678856,
0.0824654773,
0.0054886765,
0.0117215579,
0.0204579141,
0.0244485587,
0.0329816453,
-0.0448499471,
0.0248543415,
0.0396022163,
-0.0529566556,
0.0676838383,
-0.0571316071,
0.0424559899,
-0.0498710386,
0.062823832,
-0.0103725735,
-0.0058667017,
-0.0139329825,
-0.018495407,
-0.0004630038,
0.0747177899,
0.0295005608,
0.0286067426,
-0.0031767208,
0.0303117167,
-0.0028599941,
0.0216342248,
-0.0103812655,
-0.0095403017,
0.0003779567,
-0.0105657112,
-0.051155325,
0.0790955499,
-0.0175554845,
0.0112677002,
0.0192691125,
-0.0302796904,
-0.0491649173,
0.0060582203,
-0.0153664704,
-0.0134421103,
-0.0194224063,
0.0436433069,
-0.0217503123,
-0.0400032997,
-0.0631241724,
-0.0394142605,
-0.0181593467,
-0.0643130988,
0.0187132973,
-0.0644205958,
0.0099559128,
0.0353350677,
-0.0187663548,
-0.0227099136,
-0.0067652189,
0.0145610003,
-0.0336960107,
0.0266957711,
0.0387106203,
0.0038446775,
0.0313574299,
0.0107297562,
-0.019151913,
0.0521445684,
0.0313995369,
0.0595881268,
-0.0026440767,
0.0089124506,
0.0098880632,
0.0274290238,
0.0323527083,
0.0043847729,
0.006124726,
-0.0092987148,
0.0311714169,
0.0005299956,
0.0224045441,
0.0494971424,
-0.0143088419,
0.0093015982,
0.0840815678,
0.009986192,
0.0204122718,
0.0133580416,
0.0071190144,
-0.058337044,
0.017995555,
0.0583498292,
-0.0921013132,
0.0636551902,
-0.0294478945,
0.028093325,
0.0299088433,
0.0482208543,
-0.0273596831,
-0.0352570899,
-0.0089594843,
0.0217606537,
-0.0347393081,
0.0115645556,
0.0393448174,
0.0067863697,
-0.0047020442,
0.0923858806,
0.0193405729,
-0.0575241745,
0.0372138582,
-0.0599152818,
0.0143849421,
0.0270590708,
0.0408370048,
-0.0363115035,
-0.0364026427,
-0.0101202792,
-0.0233082231,
0.0174200237,
0.0476085618,
0.0077493754,
-0.0345458239,
-0.0340829045,
-0.0156405028,
-0.0169140492,
0.0285392161,
0.0329945274,
-0.0115126744,
-0.0235576183,
-0.010912234,
0.0198833663,
0.0102512734,
0.0031361724,
-0.0228353925,
-0.0206572264,
-0.0254940186,
-0.0043531922,
-0.0039437059,
0.006409457,
0.0220979415,
0.0432730317,
0.0429099351,
-0.0107291602,
-0.033172559,
0.0024794494,
-0.0411095694,
0.0107623087,
0.0649572164,
0.0209269542,
-0.0209211204,
-0.0388381779,
0.0147304041,
-0.0750818774,
0.0157122407,
-0.0718873665,
0.063817516,
-0.0115347998,
0.0377872586,
0.0222343653,
-0.0014803429,
-0.0354086123,
0.103399843,
-0.0380441397,
-0.0061114226,
0.0319238789,
-0.0183515307,
-0.0027630525,
-0.0323959067,
-0.0020920499,
-0.0006136424,
0.0039054407,
0.0284989625,
0.0185292009,
-0.0664056167,
-0.0539055206,
-0.059799917,
-0.047328081,
-0.00185857,
-0.0261415523,
0.0227269679,
0.0192338545,
0.0130187413,
0.0035867586,
0.0044178492,
-0.0493214391,
-0.0264263861,
-0.0065026633,
0.0487809442,
0.0130403107,
-0.009225701,
0.0055664768,
-0.0187061355,
-0.0035738908,
-0.0356987529,
0.006207637,
0.0151518127,
-0.0094711343,
-0.0882718489,
0.0220719501,
-0.0265014432,
0.0089477496,
-0.0254248492,
0.0057231681,
0.0272590779,
-0.0033470385,
0.1040694416,
0.0809781253,
-0.0089042382,
0.004837641,
0.0785602182,
-0.0282330848,
-0.0590803176,
0.0061393715,
-0.0547998101,
-0.0156253781,
-0.0110589089,
-0.03704983,
-0.0165792052,
0.0570220686,
0.0196525026,
-0.005784566,
-0.0433104634,
0.0121918572,
-0.0061976188,
-0.0280144997,
-0.0156759322,
0.0074429465,
-0.040464025,
0.0623632893,
-0.0151267182,
-0.027997233,
0.0541027077,
-0.0259422828,
0.0134916548,
-0.0054182163,
0.0166906472,
-0.0385229103,
0.0345940664,
0.013195361,
0.0074101998,
-0.0058981702,
-0.0427586399,
-0.0515795052,
-0.0088174203,
0.0211082455,
-0.0498670638,
0.1131788343,
-0.0221852735,
-0.0045315935,
0.0002248265,
-0.0308614597,
-0.0624631308,
-0.0024202263,
-0.0095169935,
0.0135565605,
-0.0383539908,
-0.0416029505,
-0.0837499499,
-0.0300525632,
0.1039777249,
0.0389147624,
-0.0220080242,
-0.0141639328,
-0.0266216695,
0.009040582,
0.0515619777,
0.0686421916,
0.0678365231,
-0.0251846313,
-0.0195278525,
0.0688101947,
0.0374830253,
-0.0042023053,
0.0127156824,
-0.01224788,
0.0390561596,
-0.047362294,
-0.0267969985,
-0.0011914162,
0.0350792073,
-0.0547819771,
-0.0348171927,
0.1054531634,
0.0292065516,
-0.0455614515,
-0.0131483367,
-0.0717247501,
0.0073968372,
0.0376307108,
0.002111,
-0.071144715,
0.0070241122,
0.010728729,
-0.0263643954,
-0.0085803811,
-0.0137840277,
-0.0092146266,
-0.1147432849,
0.0213797931,
0.0043869722,
-0.0405427366,
-0.0167649742,
-0.02642137,
-0.0000888231,
-0.0075124125,
0.0176037699,
0.0259575509,
-0.0042782393,
-0.0174416304,
0.0292954538,
0.0147989625,
0.0240955241,
0.0203369539,
-0.0059606223,
0.0396619961,
0.0400591083,
-0.0091705676,
-0.0275456347,
-0.0813641474,
0.0204768423,
-0.0076899272,
0.0136827445,
-0.0037480369,
0.0272153635,
0.0115934536,
-0.0070211831,
-0.0150979543,
0.0039971545,
-0.0039010553,
-0.0527772643,
-0.0048322184,
0.1064706147,
-0.0233384352,
0.0157312099,
-0.0086041866,
-0.0037602633,
-0.0498319492,
0.0773049146,
0.0313670486,
0.0094162365,
0.0068517411,
-0.039810732,
0.0043651392,
0.0075288019,
-0.048045177,
0.0321472958,
0.0092104683,
-0.0248773191,
-0.0728718787,
-0.0205756109,
0.0099802678,
0.0191565286,
0.0057889982,
-0.009616524,
0.0199639928,
-0.0389775895,
-0.031117782,
0.05053946,
-0.0684282333,
-0.00229503,
-0.0752143562,
0.0030807357,
0.0292474162,
-0.0613731369,
0.0059606624,
0.0084680915,
-0.061434783,
-0.0641613528,
0.0295674466,
0.0546218976,
0.0323975608,
0.0403382704,
-0.0071831909,
-0.025660323,
-0.0058756131,
0.0021638742,
-0.021158129,
0.0482218638,
0.013606796,
-0.0115112104,
-0.0211217534,
0.0106820036,
-0.0367761478,
-0.008958688,
0.044459343,
0.0282106567,
-0.0331691951,
-0.0100063859,
0.0355499685,
0.0198529288,
0.0759682059,
-0.0010128167,
0.0263345055,
-0.0020491451,
0.0282094534,
0.0156265721,
0.0088976333,
0.0056076837,
-0.0116563095,
0.0115986373,
0.0090694092,
0.0190422963,
-0.0237644576,
0.00700932,
0.0218906663,
-0.0178612117,
-0.0328855217,
-0.0275565982,
-0.0116391797,
0.0126712797,
0.024000559,
-0.0289913248,
0.0250106789,
0.0145214042,
0.0726094618,
0.0094628269,
0.0670855939,
0.0219292827,
-0.0054802927,
-0.0312894732,
-0.0111643905,
-0.0968246534,
-0.0131928697,
0.020410981,
0.0180254616,
0.0534037277,
-0.034748558,
0.0417259336,
-0.0110896705,
0.0093452986,
-0.0200367589,
-0.0178695917,
0.027514277,
-0.0046475623,
-0.0047632935,
0.0225961115,
0.0164635051,
0.0009115552,
0.0505554415,
-0.0616740845,
0.052830305,
-0.0221153274,
0.0154376924,
-0.0044657276,
-0.0828573257,
-0.0187430959,
-0.0037608366,
-0.0265729502,
-0.0142252138,
-0.1112208068,
-0.0493184365,
0.005843807,
0.0163241234,
0.0174121317,
-0.0614574999,
0.0109055443,
0.0386425741,
-0.0216896813,
-0.0331373736,
-0.018218318,
0.036009755,
0.0318565369,
0.0258016009,
-0.0032731039,
-6.793927558e-33,
-0.0369019918,
-0.0274780393,
0.0507385619,
0.0466363505,
-0.0136263864,
0.0123127485,
-0.0092253145,
0.0112278499,
-0.0300792698,
-0.0067646587,
-0.0311149172,
0.0140529675,
0.0130187161,
0.0093754558,
0.0245028008,
-0.0408653654,
0.0256681535,
0.0374033339,
-0.0649050474,
0.0336265638,
0.0850958154,
-0.0207508225,
0.0842115656,
-0.0425733104,
0.0676413998,
-0.0084959529,
0.000120214,
0.0272812061,
-0.0737112984,
0.0753554106,
-0.0102154817,
0.0432906784,
0.0359444991,
-0.108873941,
-0.0264100637,
0.0100413542,
-0.0617094524,
-0.0619820021,
0.083661586,
-0.002974543,
0.0168081094,
-0.0607487001,
0.0318224318,
-0.0086223744,
-0.0110034458,
-0.0510340221,
0.0241582748,
-0.0308559574,
-0.0446577631,
-0.0021527654,
-0.0504145287,
-0.0086277928,
0.0360472202,
0.0053977533,
-0.0288823415,
-0.0349103138,
0.0067730858,
-0.0003355164,
-0.0744242743,
0.0356229134,
0.0229385104,
0.0521976314,
0.0582036898,
0.0294064768,
-0.0150700677,
0.054924164,
0.0233109016,
0.0312285833,
-0.0836357847,
-0.0230138823,
0.0013905278,
0.0133906389,
0.0692843571,
0.0216209646,
0.0140290596,
0.0351965204,
-0.0364290588,
0.0062445477,
0.0208662692,
0.0611220263,
0.0095279226,
-0.0076210271,
-0.0147487279,
-0.0064274333,
-0.0444246009,
0.0577667542,
-0.0466823764,
-0.0107242968,
-0.0050960267,
0.000428359,
0.0139981331,
-0.0057305787,
0.0177945774,
-0.0262663439,
0.0008036963,
0.0192607716,
0.0343141109,
0.0264543612,
-0.0337988585,
0.0116711659,
-0.0416550077,
0.0009793924,
-0.0141886035,
0.0118121672,
-0.012889469,
0.0616604313,
0.0373222046,
0.0224967878,
-0.0397327431,
-0.0030586626,
-0.0359125808,
0.0046393313,
-0.023409443,
-0.0602589361,
0.0317912474,
0.0189448297,
-0.0085165864,
0.0274519213,
0.0328748971,
0.0226559509,
-0.0471166931,
0.0284768473,
-0.0191145688,
0.0440531261,
-0.0160333738,
0.0147415455,
-0.0357679874,
0.0261732079,
0.0321024172,
-0.0385706052,
0.0051741404,
-0.0121405888,
2.839e-7,
0.0230633318,
0.0226482563,
0.0179738905,
0.0010118549,
-0.0029906712,
0.0337191708,
-0.0280443393,
0.0096082203,
0.0595434047,
-0.0383130126,
-0.0261397492,
0.0505384132,
-0.0050751879,
-0.0041036801,
-0.0745887831,
-0.0144920582,
-0.0501750782,
0.0020082262,
0.0025761621,
0.0116127394,
-0.0133794248,
0.0694257915,
0.0358256772,
-0.0202608053,
-0.0258024503,
-0.0365657769,
0.0589381084,
-0.0259463731,
-0.0344632939,
0.0184473544,
0.0725711957,
-0.0031862517,
0.0165751576,
0.0046545314,
0.0001305404,
0.0101582035,
-0.0079310266,
0.0449010916,
0.0242634378,
-0.0207927655,
-0.0330827311,
-0.0555047318,
0.007693965,
-0.031547118,
0.0307599194,
-0.0338299274,
-0.0238818396,
-0.014672922,
0.0115754018,
0.0195824765,
-0.0069511295,
0.0190164782,
-0.0119209727,
-0.0156075945,
-0.0088347932,
0.0369730592,
0.0161020979,
-0.1005000919,
-0.0484383181,
0.0082351267,
-0.0338329114,
-0.0829748362,
-0.0164361913,
-0.0175483227,
0.0182228889,
-0.0793748945,
-0.0420686267,
2.576212042e-34,
0.0242835395,
-0.0070174318,
0.0212185029,
0.0536427088,
0.0231650081,
-0.0330294594,
-0.0320862085,
0.028099332,
0.0465007611,
-0.076964274,
-0.0216721017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07319v1 | ODIN: Disentangled Reward Mitigates Hacking in RLHF | 2024-02-11T22:40:12 | 2024-02-11T22:40:12 | Lichang Chen, Chen Zhu, Davit Soselia, Jiuhai Chen, Tianyi Zhou, Tom Goldstein, Heng Huang, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this work, we study the issue of reward hacking on the response length, a
challenge emerging in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) on
LLMs. A well-formatted, verbose but less helpful response from the LLMs can
often deceive LLMs or even human evaluators to achieve high scores. The same
issue also holds for some reward models in RL. To address the challenges in
both training and evaluation, we establish a more reliable evaluation protocol
for comparing different training configurations, which inspects the trade-off
between LLM evaluation score and response length obtained by varying training
hyperparameters. Based on this evaluation, we conduct large-scale studies,
where the results shed insights into the efficacy of hyperparameters and tricks
used in RL on mitigating length bias. We further propose to improve the reward
model by jointly training two linear heads on shared feature representations to
predict the rewards, one trained to correlate with length, and the other
trained to decorrelate with length and therefore focus more on the actual
content. We then discard the length head in RL to prevent reward hacking on
length. Experiments demonstrate that our approach almost eliminates the reward
correlation with length, and improves the obtained policy by a significant
margin. | [
0.0244070254,
0.0647268519,
0.0027317517,
0.0236176196,
-0.0219550002,
0.0182026941,
-0.0205964707,
0.013080745,
-0.0164366402,
0.0011399832,
-0.0745535865,
0.0030280536,
0.0098808175,
0.0155178094,
0.0080879452,
-0.0548769757,
0.0381717682,
-0.0385706089,
0.0087343911,
-0.0101801082,
0.0054999669,
-0.0398934819,
0.0181667544,
0.0235758629,
-0.0110726086,
0.0278503988,
-0.0516444296,
0.0297405384,
0.0561599471,
-0.0588374212,
0.0138671249,
0.0217832085,
0.0227807332,
0.0652506649,
0.0000021884,
-0.0327818878,
-0.0192895979,
-0.000908326,
-0.0087643592,
-0.03286428,
-0.0138888685,
-0.026898019,
0.0074229171,
0.0210494921,
-0.0158967879,
0.0226579048,
-0.0121752359,
0.098209478,
0.0135297943,
0.0854143351,
0.0222185701,
-0.0132223563,
0.0211159792,
-0.0782199204,
0.0643443987,
-0.0148335267,
0.0073934309,
-0.0135258855,
-0.0052888826,
0.0127668502,
-0.0617678426,
-0.0178622324,
0.0689605847,
0.0271933172,
0.0186547041,
0.0489008501,
0.0058186147,
-0.0099379048,
-0.0002917527,
0.0543920137,
-0.0406279825,
0.0304135364,
0.0265829414,
-0.025950795,
0.0433042273,
-0.0237380881,
-0.0053422889,
0.0113507146,
0.0068968963,
0.0226870589,
-0.0459154472,
0.0382424854,
0.034581624,
0.0069499887,
0.016439978,
0.041380059,
-0.0203833785,
-0.0359397084,
-0.0004037356,
0.0227782279,
0.0421346277,
-0.0217954125,
-0.0468892902,
0.0191695485,
-0.0223921854,
-0.0001951974,
-0.0241594817,
0.0120705804,
0.0110593503,
-0.0155154215,
0.0374188833,
-0.0219907444,
-0.0153231695,
0.0229640771,
-0.042119652,
0.0364350826,
-0.009874342,
0.0685158223,
-0.0145625705,
0.0412034839,
-0.0419108868,
0.0148770688,
0.0317397937,
0.0574496724,
-0.0223695189,
-0.0157669112,
-0.0493991114,
-0.0080668563,
-0.0469431393,
0.0483914427,
-0.0174327437,
0.052086141,
-0.0162033904,
0.016128514,
-0.0737654045,
0.0098523926,
-0.0583521426,
0.0164142661,
0.0281282887,
0.0335258022,
-0.0321630426,
0.0235143229,
-0.0377117731,
-0.0364311822,
0.0367215537,
0.1157205701,
0.0053736973,
-0.0469398722,
0.0275009125,
-0.05365384,
-0.0163895823,
-0.0465402901,
0.027054837,
-0.0633939132,
0.0298516583,
-0.0620132461,
-0.0197176561,
-0.0161258671,
0.0065090177,
-0.0388608277,
-0.0344082043,
0.0771180689,
0.0197730679,
-0.0461277068,
0.0026970366,
0.0217902157,
-0.0254337452,
0.0414059237,
0.0455729701,
0.1105028912,
0.0341423713,
0.0151021881,
0.0311638564,
-0.0194843654,
0.0497315116,
0.0162866432,
-0.0060948245,
-0.0066596768,
0.0218725763,
0.0307952669,
0.0453421958,
0.0257949028,
-0.0427205898,
-0.0357891098,
0.0716246665,
0.0495757088,
0.0413490087,
-0.0329450108,
-0.0059950841,
0.0217223931,
-0.0275212862,
0.0128472643,
-0.0813956484,
0.0471994653,
-0.0219324511,
0.0087956581,
0.0412286445,
0.0057984842,
-0.0393310897,
-0.0481746495,
0.0182438996,
-0.0458301157,
0.0183283091,
0.0417750366,
0.0421224795,
-0.0259838291,
-0.0270216204,
-0.0302852038,
0.0369490832,
0.0000864481,
0.0144453356,
-0.0475929826,
0.0297020432,
0.0560728237,
0.0405244939,
-0.0006227957,
0.0265748296,
-0.06098447,
-0.0421353653,
0.0281772465,
0.0146474652,
-0.0166608617,
0.0270465929,
0.007461078,
-0.0446399413,
-0.0038795613,
-0.0019226496,
0.0379717946,
0.0265680049,
-0.0079755494,
-0.0015578581,
0.0535523295,
-0.0214260779,
0.0200592615,
0.0112889288,
-0.0494355373,
0.0273166541,
0.0212914068,
0.0520282164,
-0.0048421063,
-0.0206541158,
0.0091796946,
0.0235267226,
-0.0245867893,
-0.0320892185,
-0.0401744172,
-0.0205540974,
-0.0377384648,
0.0049071889,
-0.0429641381,
0.0304074977,
0.0568606369,
-0.0155746406,
-0.0190287884,
0.0186985005,
-0.0126199257,
0.0150658535,
0.0231830832,
-0.0155328559,
0.0029004288,
-0.0206933562,
-0.0481203832,
0.0072717234,
-0.0305103324,
-0.0101337098,
-0.0732788071,
-0.0338005535,
-0.0012799979,
-0.048509188,
-0.010375862,
0.0522422008,
0.004426505,
-0.0020285337,
0.0486643724,
0.0257903691,
-0.0287147034,
-0.0490062945,
-0.020116847,
-0.0267589949,
-0.0259086471,
0.0159009043,
-0.0114758201,
-0.0504027195,
-0.0037696236,
-0.0432403684,
-0.0595702752,
-0.0423401259,
0.027406415,
-0.012175899,
0.030079443,
0.0254446175,
-0.0261178445,
-0.0257191379,
-0.0124425795,
0.0216799658,
0.0235585943,
-0.015595722,
0.0246625189,
-0.0212548543,
-0.0178499054,
-0.0250407327,
0.0132435448,
-0.0203513373,
-0.0371712148,
0.0245820805,
-0.0073516862,
-0.0353611186,
0.1179177314,
0.0249627233,
0.066515334,
0.0642178357,
0.0324295871,
-0.0500897616,
0.0225754902,
-0.054808896,
-0.0233517885,
-0.0610679947,
0.0069799507,
0.0099220723,
0.0491429828,
-0.018043004,
0.0253487155,
-0.0540506318,
0.0173717029,
0.0121106897,
-0.0951935127,
-0.0295705218,
0.0330842733,
-0.0451222025,
0.0162455719,
-0.0051127365,
-0.0808246061,
0.0728718415,
0.0054080784,
0.0214871448,
0.0070777824,
-0.0339408889,
-0.0076800012,
0.0693433806,
-0.0062462636,
0.0111059742,
-0.0399624668,
0.0140262563,
-0.0483024046,
-0.0520158559,
0.0383431613,
-0.0159183741,
-0.0029864425,
-0.0363754183,
-0.0315265171,
-0.0305593498,
-0.0589601323,
-0.0414820127,
-0.0380938202,
-0.0054790815,
-0.0021897946,
-0.0200521071,
-0.0447056405,
-0.0013978125,
-0.0617418848,
0.0459715948,
0.0030901728,
-0.0492796861,
-0.0006093153,
0.0077113705,
-0.0111750932,
0.0599977858,
-0.0094831493,
0.0226439647,
-0.0584541373,
0.0366463698,
0.0471339971,
0.0147355152,
0.0129385907,
-0.0088743046,
0.0191554017,
-0.0076488629,
-0.0236435868,
0.0151573941,
0.0466709137,
0.0555955358,
-0.0506191626,
0.0005740809,
0.0605544262,
0.0106125977,
-0.0629713163,
0.0205846801,
0.0030614424,
0.0770138949,
0.0001807462,
0.0117247757,
-0.0488118082,
-0.0254434962,
0.0030554608,
0.0658398941,
0.0015932398,
-0.0188428443,
0.0296132788,
-0.0933075473,
-0.0227469932,
0.0120486468,
-0.0208258871,
-0.0421279632,
-0.0265744012,
-0.0343645997,
-0.0057702907,
-0.0139840674,
0.0031706442,
-0.0078984294,
-0.005805009,
0.0162659455,
0.013254948,
-0.0108807087,
0.0184250362,
-0.0422513075,
0.0494029187,
0.1056877077,
-0.0138105601,
-0.0178780258,
-0.0559298247,
-0.0511907116,
0.0403720587,
0.0201905519,
0.0220164172,
0.0647349283,
-0.0413249098,
-0.0005339475,
-0.0097372141,
0.0702507943,
0.0242678989,
-0.0002689759,
0.021814825,
0.0314232185,
-0.0247604437,
-0.0037053898,
-0.0135178734,
-0.0259046815,
0.0100914706,
0.0596683547,
0.0016838645,
-0.0359617025,
-0.0622923747,
-0.0104496591,
-0.071197547,
-0.0250692684,
-0.0350909717,
0.0210112743,
-0.0074654073,
0.0003261713,
-0.058650557,
-0.0835717469,
-0.0081527838,
0.0294647478,
-0.036451783,
-0.0128755467,
-0.0638807938,
0.039714694,
-0.0410832018,
0.0244935229,
-0.0128893889,
0.0388600044,
-0.0559805594,
0.0453074835,
-0.0230832193,
-0.0363234915,
0.001368097,
-0.0215072669,
-0.0770775825,
-0.0400464348,
-0.0396897122,
0.0915902629,
0.0186872464,
0.0920616984,
0.0022779386,
-0.0012483441,
0.046169959,
0.0084048752,
-0.0432314426,
0.0295206737,
0.0745529607,
0.0553735122,
-0.0187685918,
0.026866449,
-0.0530975349,
0.0106196199,
0.0505615138,
0.0195426252,
0.0039574658,
0.0146514904,
-0.0047279056,
-0.0045225685,
0.0590262637,
-0.0383173041,
0.0261017345,
0.0353096537,
0.0295693092,
-0.0303074345,
0.0142443636,
-0.0273869801,
-0.0143614365,
0.037213672,
0.0093322648,
0.0196442846,
-0.0037867115,
0.0269506257,
0.018549582,
-0.0495038033,
0.0344379246,
-0.0395466834,
-0.0172946714,
-0.0097028445,
0.0467736088,
0.0089617297,
0.0089796875,
0.0265644621,
0.0141495774,
0.0432327949,
0.0289610662,
0.0303730555,
0.0089699738,
-0.0456429832,
0.0349948853,
-0.0818073601,
-0.0289520863,
-0.0185773764,
0.0276655089,
0.0206641648,
0.027852511,
0.0065904302,
-0.0077673807,
-0.0054674135,
-0.0160778537,
0.0074111912,
-0.0546979122,
0.0216605403,
0.0405378155,
0.0351194032,
-0.0175694078,
-0.021346394,
0.0649628192,
0.0209094826,
0.0315298848,
-0.0381276049,
0.0025977711,
-0.026527334,
-0.0285272077,
0.0655605048,
0.0145563716,
-0.0219498519,
-0.005277907,
-0.0596621484,
-0.0437928885,
-0.0326423869,
0.0394345187,
0.0473648757,
-0.0028780582,
0.0388191678,
-0.0110398382,
-0.0159025434,
-0.0021931464,
-0.0344444402,
-0.0680033714,
0.031842567,
-0.0143142277,
-0.0119230151,
-6.333437197e-33,
0.0205247123,
-0.023548631,
0.0156239877,
0.0000462879,
-0.0695512146,
0.0195453633,
0.0021950027,
0.0028838345,
0.0127529558,
-0.0045981687,
-0.0067753042,
-0.0183273181,
0.0003005235,
0.0183472168,
0.0255948994,
-0.0500949956,
0.0345739163,
-0.0143000567,
-0.0496620089,
0.009848522,
0.0231358688,
0.0112880236,
0.0315573104,
-0.0502608158,
0.0558649637,
0.0208081827,
-0.0458604284,
0.0104565891,
-0.0235022195,
0.0399004668,
-0.00872239,
-0.0060810498,
-0.0095411586,
-0.0690990388,
-0.0133903455,
-0.0041281362,
-0.0866672546,
-0.0427433252,
-0.0197109301,
-0.0347936265,
-0.0764975026,
-0.0356445275,
0.0412412472,
0.0146355228,
-0.0499080867,
-0.0241837874,
0.0072890967,
0.0060962532,
-0.0255312026,
-0.0209265798,
0.0012149123,
0.0081152609,
0.0055106548,
-0.0418657176,
0.0540701933,
0.0510993041,
-0.0194296986,
0.030798804,
-0.0444928817,
0.0056881388,
0.0223661568,
-0.0008988578,
0.0466103517,
0.0393153504,
0.037331719,
0.0754641965,
0.019111624,
0.001174018,
-0.0502375066,
-0.0133921606,
0.0094987582,
0.0286115892,
0.0672662035,
0.0438146405,
0.0728410631,
-0.0146027869,
-0.0525092408,
0.0282331072,
-0.0064703058,
0.0645535141,
-0.0085019059,
0.0328107737,
-0.0431562588,
-0.0070224027,
-0.0569196343,
-0.0022691977,
0.006075101,
-0.0833749473,
0.0460387319,
0.0584466048,
0.0105317542,
-0.0132735064,
0.0254719667,
-0.053656105,
0.0031057198,
0.00687142,
0.0045801457,
0.0108341444,
0.0269209165,
-0.0572397597,
-0.0482000895,
-0.0006000603,
0.0276830252,
-0.0347343162,
0.00442565,
0.0047477372,
0.0458601117,
0.0077891154,
-0.0181995686,
0.0024747874,
-0.0153543996,
0.0332408659,
0.045442082,
-0.0014567467,
0.044929076,
-0.03237921,
-0.0100010578,
0.0322367437,
-0.0549806505,
0.0046055308,
-0.027813876,
0.0367282778,
-0.0194077566,
0.0281590223,
-0.0200949386,
0.0046357848,
-0.006047694,
-0.0110600879,
0.0234295651,
-0.0641330555,
0.0020769865,
-0.0220706575,
2.961e-7,
-0.0621991493,
0.0075594396,
0.0622050539,
-0.0073924083,
0.0224256627,
0.0768105909,
-0.024298206,
0.0645650774,
-0.051438503,
-0.018910531,
0.0139610609,
0.0522753671,
0.0474731177,
0.0014330436,
-0.0324178189,
-0.0276693348,
-0.0521974713,
-0.0181904361,
-0.0149182836,
-0.044695016,
0.0291929711,
0.0509681702,
0.0577613898,
-0.003144328,
0.0509421378,
0.0456604883,
0.0228258315,
-0.0675210282,
-0.0129849203,
-0.0625313669,
0.0209874082,
-0.0417572223,
0.0106872246,
0.0106255105,
-0.0181754399,
0.0092206839,
-0.0305753928,
0.0548192337,
-0.0150758643,
-0.0597584918,
-0.0525112003,
0.0239932854,
0.0341889076,
-0.0211121626,
0.0453180745,
-0.0362615064,
-0.0358121507,
-0.0211817604,
0.0187642574,
-0.0148010403,
0.0497786403,
-0.0203998629,
0.01752875,
-0.0034825227,
0.0083493385,
0.044003956,
0.0466637239,
-0.081712544,
-0.0161809064,
0.0317705385,
-0.0123591684,
-0.0507883914,
-0.0597571842,
0.0485308841,
-0.0051838486,
-0.0552888103,
-0.0453345627,
2.475721739e-34,
0.0107017001,
-0.0496517494,
-0.0019578179,
0.0073350193,
0.0068779713,
0.0120800352,
-0.0262250733,
-0.0009917935,
0.0815771073,
-0.0122772893,
-0.0147953928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07309v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07309v3 | HyperBERT: Mixing Hypergraph-Aware Layers with Language Models for Node Classification on Text-Attributed Hypergraphs | 2024-02-11T21:16:26 | 2024-05-25T12:10:38 | Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Hypergraphs are characterized by complex topological structure, representing
higher-order interactions among multiple entities through hyperedges. Lately,
hypergraph-based deep learning methods to learn informative data
representations for the problem of node classification on text-attributed
hypergraphs have garnered increasing research attention. However, existing
methods struggle to simultaneously capture the full extent of hypergraph
structural information and the rich linguistic attributes inherent in the nodes
attributes, which largely hampers their effectiveness and generalizability. To
overcome these challenges, we explore ways to further augment a pretrained BERT
model with specialized hypergraph-aware layers for the task of node
classification. Such layers introduce higher-order structural inductive bias
into the language model, thus improving the model's capacity to harness both
higher-order context information from the hypergraph structure and semantic
information present in text. In this paper, we propose a new architecture,
HyperBERT, a mixed text-hypergraph model which simultaneously models hypergraph
relational structure while maintaining the high-quality text encoding
capabilities of a pre-trained BERT. Notably, HyperBERT presents results that
achieve a new state-of-the-art on five challenging text-attributed hypergraph
node classification benchmarks. | [
0.0074385335,
0.0204261094,
0.0120165255,
0.0270130876,
0.0232500844,
0.0156340953,
0.0017078465,
-0.0040295795,
0.0473348983,
-0.0429003201,
-0.0256373808,
0.0052904203,
-0.0118584651,
0.012944296,
0.0045627402,
0.0164167937,
-0.0033569033,
0.02891046,
0.0468209535,
-0.0117390454,
-0.0053250343,
0.0631555766,
-0.0008275735,
0.0209192224,
-0.0457355492,
-0.0188973304,
-0.0139284013,
0.0507539622,
0.0286301766,
-0.0559412055,
0.0051341271,
0.0378477499,
0.0206386298,
0.0240827501,
0.0000015054,
-0.006675913,
-0.0247762855,
-0.0197654776,
-0.0064470079,
-0.0216587987,
-0.0018334499,
-0.037795119,
0.0203934535,
-0.0113879852,
0.0174218435,
-0.0592884496,
0.027955031,
0.0543300211,
0.0102196289,
0.0701753646,
-0.0287808198,
-0.0049657021,
0.0611505173,
-0.0182121508,
-0.0075543267,
-0.0088526141,
0.0347394496,
-0.0061298255,
-0.0526464209,
0.0243151803,
-0.0000969927,
-0.0237731114,
0.0095954752,
-0.0268307123,
0.0222862698,
0.0281090643,
-0.0244621728,
0.0404603779,
0.0018014984,
0.1451974064,
-0.0359924473,
-0.0008734034,
0.0249405596,
-0.0040715383,
0.002100368,
0.0208634939,
0.0033116157,
-0.0006227004,
-0.0021462692,
0.0124167139,
0.0073000635,
-0.0063519785,
0.0573942959,
0.0195483807,
0.0069985152,
0.0496811159,
0.0036680608,
-0.0136864455,
0.0276497249,
0.0208274089,
-0.0007468343,
-0.0369502828,
0.0441692658,
0.0290963426,
0.00506684,
-0.0031115261,
0.0169709139,
0.0030861581,
-0.0193880051,
-0.0278622732,
-0.011553227,
-0.0185839888,
-0.0186166931,
0.0370190293,
-0.0144371707,
-0.0116907321,
-0.0476371162,
0.0234615225,
0.0082888948,
0.0011268437,
-0.04269417,
-0.0140881147,
-0.062438447,
0.0478459485,
0.0028773521,
-0.0323088616,
-0.0081526544,
0.0263290331,
-0.0396559089,
0.0178616885,
0.0157303363,
0.020760702,
0.010697078,
-0.0195331424,
0.0215508789,
0.0324421562,
-0.0056016585,
0.034239985,
-0.0289184954,
0.0497463308,
0.0230272394,
0.0357118621,
0.0560201295,
-0.0434360504,
0.0067361072,
0.0490164347,
0.0452333093,
-0.0489984676,
0.0162776485,
-0.0100871902,
0.0067208903,
-0.0364236347,
0.0712250844,
-0.0431034416,
0.023585001,
0.0005352548,
-0.0348711163,
-0.0016885161,
0.0178586766,
-0.0208585467,
-0.0607551076,
0.0301928334,
-0.0428074598,
-0.0270186383,
0.0169479642,
-0.0281350575,
0.0134970509,
0.0298157018,
0.0278984513,
0.0408553295,
0.0138161527,
-0.0024497001,
-0.0055571268,
0.0415882282,
0.0278384164,
0.0199426077,
-0.006456193,
-0.0125011252,
-0.0264881775,
0.0457771569,
0.020332424,
0.0365840979,
-0.0437590592,
-0.0351443514,
0.0431823023,
0.0276017915,
-0.0186360665,
0.0160653796,
0.0462307595,
0.0167204607,
-0.0041369395,
-0.0047292947,
-0.0646698922,
0.0040404107,
0.0003246665,
0.0056300554,
-0.0239344612,
-0.019886544,
-0.0286999717,
-0.0072511593,
0.002719206,
-0.0417052694,
0.0386072248,
-0.0067301746,
0.0793710202,
0.0022220917,
-0.0296240281,
0.071579583,
0.0418360829,
-0.0044956673,
0.0147269722,
0.0241465159,
0.0041571301,
0.0590442047,
0.013970986,
-0.0615599453,
-0.0071069458,
-0.0263662767,
0.0029229713,
0.0068992954,
0.0294502862,
-0.0250505526,
0.0171988159,
-0.0215264577,
-0.0421437882,
-0.0189322829,
0.0035157243,
0.0177968964,
-0.0584941059,
-0.0055737272,
-0.005139919,
-0.0274953526,
-0.0350328088,
0.0123809017,
0.024471717,
0.0163750071,
0.005349657,
0.034250956,
-0.0672527254,
0.0609283447,
-0.0160632227,
-0.0273802541,
0.0165053513,
-0.0036812746,
-0.0547771864,
-0.0445503294,
-0.0143724661,
-0.0861167982,
0.0593231767,
-0.0302390698,
-0.046063792,
0.0386087261,
-0.0373352133,
-0.0109154657,
-0.0026851958,
-0.0386917628,
0.0816090107,
-0.0027766782,
-0.0104715163,
0.0050618011,
-0.0115276808,
-0.0095939133,
0.0679784864,
-0.016083492,
0.0144019825,
0.0102367932,
-0.0036250802,
0.0157119036,
-0.0095388116,
-0.0237667616,
0.0198605247,
0.0123849455,
0.0020149078,
0.0428469889,
-0.0109339515,
-0.0232055727,
-0.0017666102,
-0.0706297532,
-0.022920737,
-0.0108954096,
0.0119201504,
-0.0098930979,
-0.0157374814,
0.0279819109,
-0.0078655547,
-0.0571029522,
0.0377365984,
-0.0327433124,
-0.0047243787,
0.040042568,
-0.0436417013,
-0.0260095205,
-0.0061692931,
-0.0607467815,
-0.064358592,
0.1066663116,
0.0178119242,
0.0050612087,
0.0060931197,
-0.0541967303,
-0.0495682023,
0.0102969455,
0.0192588177,
-0.0047331033,
-0.0051377942,
-0.0077649197,
-0.031280458,
0.0279844832,
-0.00908536,
0.0506046787,
-0.0086805709,
0.0341796242,
-0.0404354259,
-0.0255236458,
-0.0700361356,
0.0649703816,
-0.0387475453,
0.0333392061,
-0.0416706428,
0.0656314716,
-0.0269661937,
-0.0092790015,
-0.0220109113,
-0.0167538002,
0.0251865368,
-0.0026537767,
0.0101165492,
-0.0335046202,
0.0110231061,
-0.0242949706,
-0.0543936975,
-0.0376331471,
0.0545057841,
-0.0004338312,
0.0273429956,
0.0244886037,
0.0104548605,
-0.0430672951,
0.0513489656,
0.0406278968,
0.0422388017,
0.0218392741,
-0.0684166774,
-0.0155899012,
0.0410364904,
-0.0001937051,
-0.0154542765,
-0.0203868933,
0.0354563743,
0.0129067162,
-0.004190878,
-0.0194198657,
0.0072450428,
-0.0282772873,
-0.0090209125,
0.0559851713,
-0.0116621517,
-0.0431492515,
0.0001106478,
-0.0256534927,
-0.0429231524,
0.0193562154,
0.0013161672,
-0.0056143315,
-0.0507549159,
0.1177958697,
0.0266562309,
-0.0142688993,
0.0309928432,
0.0054469891,
-0.0357595496,
0.0251654722,
-0.0521718897,
-0.0134176835,
-0.0272871945,
0.0232986286,
0.0209491998,
-0.032563854,
-0.0146601014,
-0.0371384472,
0.0296257846,
-0.0273053031,
0.0138214361,
0.0820246339,
0.0432895049,
-0.0318495631,
0.0202746782,
0.0556698292,
0.0370684564,
0.0186256375,
-0.0170995817,
-0.1142149866,
-0.001950755,
-0.0198752843,
-0.0205798447,
0.0355124325,
-0.0609446988,
0.0475638211,
-0.0812116861,
-0.0325824805,
-0.0034288864,
-0.0143491132,
0.0036082754,
-0.0341166705,
-0.0118055949,
-0.003343282,
-0.0077867154,
-0.0431087427,
0.0302739087,
-0.0313494392,
0.0122921998,
-0.023258552,
-0.021697307,
0.0422478691,
-0.0424414687,
0.0334086567,
-0.0169774238,
0.0667543039,
-0.0321825407,
-0.0190024879,
0.00373616,
0.0227307379,
-0.019629566,
-0.0073828697,
0.0504451878,
-0.0163959507,
-0.0126805408,
-0.032730516,
0.0016114196,
-0.0733642802,
-0.0089180842,
-0.0515418686,
0.0856209993,
0.0024169676,
-0.0283352286,
-0.0188090689,
-0.0519417673,
0.0198178943,
0.0263557788,
0.011081161,
-0.0267755371,
-0.0384297222,
-0.0356143229,
0.0160615742,
-0.0499488339,
0.0092975553,
0.0317964032,
-0.0302319601,
-0.0168614499,
-0.0582219735,
-0.0672295243,
0.0044930927,
0.0111555057,
-0.0167129822,
-0.0200317949,
0.0592104495,
-0.0395454802,
-0.0744191706,
0.0646251068,
0.0036533359,
0.0284945648,
0.0383030027,
-0.0139390379,
0.0742434338,
0.0073554097,
-0.013455498,
0.0079512717,
0.0102807339,
-0.0766768232,
-0.0501117855,
0.0312456284,
0.0042784773,
0.0557171367,
-0.0346362814,
-0.0511740521,
0.0011399975,
-0.0085975844,
-0.0549041405,
-0.0430976935,
0.0481545329,
-0.0116180927,
-0.0287097916,
0.0369137563,
-0.05202353,
0.0416230336,
0.0477207042,
0.0266209766,
-0.0429970473,
-0.0527656786,
0.0181269404,
-0.002696336,
0.0531774089,
0.0043869507,
0.0449466333,
-0.0500944816,
0.0145834908,
-0.0177969187,
-0.0266375598,
-0.0167199112,
0.015387374,
0.0182665102,
-0.0000277535,
-0.027591899,
-0.0292192027,
0.0325649753,
0.0560038388,
-0.0671761632,
-0.0026203515,
-0.0236615222,
0.0305255279,
0.0247500204,
0.0042481185,
-0.0289942231,
0.0104500512,
0.0066949707,
-0.0105133364,
-0.0280559324,
-0.0027824873,
0.0218474865,
-0.0250182003,
-0.0442899168,
-0.0069851405,
-0.0235630181,
0.0284816641,
-0.0427830666,
-0.0319756679,
0.0563330911,
0.0108911721,
0.0194735564,
-0.0085251136,
-0.0234298315,
-0.0122368857,
0.0419681855,
-0.0222827699,
-0.0479255654,
0.0385847501,
0.0157295614,
-0.0242245197,
0.0285883155,
0.0335864909,
0.0487204082,
0.0369961485,
0.0092377868,
-0.0341887139,
-0.0129934521,
-0.0011294525,
0.0296436884,
0.0819594637,
-0.0212330576,
0.0286135189,
-0.0304682963,
-0.0708004236,
0.0523625128,
-0.0295949541,
0.0068689473,
0.034865167,
0.0283122715,
-0.0105624646,
-0.0066656712,
-0.0228212941,
-0.0324463956,
0.0090928245,
-0.0000865781,
0.0009465335,
-0.0003354279,
-5.312371212e-33,
0.0276947748,
-0.0365777016,
-0.0003713025,
-0.0208116602,
-0.0807535574,
0.0505417362,
-0.0450689383,
-0.0035342253,
-0.0113548003,
0.0652456358,
0.0118679777,
0.0039629736,
-0.0072428752,
0.0487262793,
-0.0151448781,
-0.0087367054,
0.0112015549,
-0.0025929501,
-0.0027558673,
0.0550053529,
0.0572564937,
0.021362368,
0.0964122266,
-0.1200922206,
0.0030851946,
-0.0333830267,
0.0320431925,
0.0240019448,
0.058628533,
0.0451577343,
-0.0213970393,
0.0536697693,
0.0384951271,
-0.039534159,
0.0293794964,
0.057684347,
-0.1054608002,
-0.0290753301,
-0.0515803434,
0.0090759518,
-0.0435680449,
-0.0371971019,
0.0335665792,
0.0298850071,
0.0304248687,
-0.0442687608,
0.0691298768,
-0.0080671543,
-0.0702081993,
-0.0798902139,
-0.0722311586,
0.0541286953,
-0.0491887033,
0.0281229876,
0.0051047159,
0.0046384907,
0.031276051,
-0.0229661297,
-0.0860702097,
-0.0017746567,
-0.0571909696,
-0.0412783399,
0.0030368764,
0.0137110529,
0.0111107752,
0.045951955,
0.0286861863,
0.042680677,
-0.012486849,
0.0567666441,
0.0253168847,
0.0636969656,
0.0037433978,
0.0087866634,
-0.0433261208,
-0.028354153,
-0.1111131832,
-0.0173745733,
0.0110138236,
-0.0445470437,
-0.0155137852,
0.0206361748,
-0.0216049999,
-0.0213259067,
-0.0352562778,
-0.0121242441,
-0.0221870281,
-0.0221006032,
-0.0195226558,
0.0123841185,
-0.0086057298,
0.0934464335,
0.0121235214,
-0.0646440983,
-0.0733084828,
0.0715824515,
0.0078662904,
0.0659590513,
-0.0027534307,
0.0232316963,
-0.0181515366,
-0.0527732745,
-0.0051060081,
-0.0229053069,
0.0352661833,
0.0249083471,
0.0605145618,
-0.014609878,
-0.0279663168,
-0.0122038033,
-0.0085565969,
-0.0413002856,
-0.0058699264,
0.0322916918,
0.0400471389,
0.0024460529,
0.0152011234,
0.0904021338,
0.0589695983,
0.0396818481,
0.013105209,
0.0623976588,
0.0134044047,
0.0215661619,
-0.0150679182,
-0.0319324993,
0.0018220637,
-0.0012894163,
0.0328606702,
-0.0788730606,
-0.010528693,
0.0014970802,
2.233e-7,
0.0418443382,
0.0234230217,
0.0392144471,
-0.0297844335,
0.0171131063,
0.0075627854,
0.0204461366,
0.0660331398,
-0.0295663327,
-0.0184612554,
0.0286722574,
0.0245229024,
-0.015694268,
0.0070527005,
-0.0542709529,
-0.0001647343,
-0.0545893833,
-0.0090376902,
-0.067803137,
0.0263001081,
0.0343323909,
0.0727871656,
0.0127902273,
-0.0090817641,
-0.0260639936,
-0.0393938944,
0.0569371395,
0.0191231165,
0.0115531161,
0.0361544378,
0.0094226198,
-0.0087334272,
-0.0330722295,
0.0402174667,
-0.015257746,
0.0503496528,
0.0490349084,
0.0342519768,
-0.0327316746,
-0.0376398414,
0.0427237004,
-0.074419938,
0.011385507,
-0.0199496113,
0.0564573668,
-0.08681532,
-0.0277939048,
0.0206646807,
-0.0363307372,
-0.0326872244,
0.0095726373,
-0.022351874,
0.0263870452,
0.0461840108,
0.0302922949,
-0.0401604883,
0.026945943,
-0.1077580154,
0.0195644051,
0.0525716953,
-0.0023202177,
-0.0485886857,
0.0181311052,
-0.0098947128,
0.0412966236,
-0.0358976163,
0.0431517102,
1.912404757e-34,
-0.0020792314,
-0.0166681893,
-0.0212940797,
0.0392327718,
0.0297976322,
-0.044680763,
0.011594303,
-0.0183505751,
0.0577839017,
-0.0901301056,
0.0245280545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07283v1 | Power Transformer Fault Prediction Based on Knowledge Graphs | 2024-02-11T19:14:28 | 2024-02-11T19:14:28 | Chao Wang, Zhuo Chen, Ziyan Zhang, Chiyi Li, Kai Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we address the challenge of learning with limited fault data
for power transformers. Traditional operation and maintenance tools lack
effective predictive capabilities for potential faults. The scarcity of
extensive fault data makes it difficult to apply machine learning techniques
effectively. To solve this problem, we propose a novel approach that leverages
the knowledge graph (KG) technology in combination with gradient boosting
decision trees (GBDT). This method is designed to efficiently learn from a
small set of high-dimensional data, integrating various factors influencing
transformer faults and historical operational data. Our approach enables
accurate safe state assessments and fault analyses of power transformers
despite the limited fault characteristic data. Experimental results demonstrate
that this method outperforms other learning approaches in prediction accuracy,
such as artificial neural networks (ANN) and logistic regression (LR).
Furthermore, it offers significant improvements in progressiveness,
practicality, and potential for widespread application. | [
-0.042521704,
0.051443506,
0.0122904871,
0.0206292775,
0.0438270681,
0.0049037826,
-0.0305868443,
0.0615211613,
0.0471260697,
-0.0024951242,
0.0730727315,
-0.0096205156,
-0.0007703711,
0.0105645321,
0.0271702502,
-0.0064945412,
0.0160353165,
0.004288652,
-0.007041506,
-0.028861532,
-0.0383474976,
-0.0037147407,
-0.0269801337,
0.0207006689,
-0.0891272873,
-0.0544691198,
0.0046783313,
-0.0382501297,
0.0488404334,
-0.0200203508,
0.031703487,
-0.0164160766,
-0.0325177871,
0.0342901349,
0.0000021764,
0.0160138085,
-0.018326927,
-0.003023624,
-0.0271102861,
-0.0493518002,
-0.0874410719,
0.0072610951,
0.042636361,
0.0276969168,
-0.0519029051,
-0.0682121739,
0.0247506592,
0.1278108656,
0.0462794825,
0.0608969331,
-0.0202710275,
0.0134259947,
0.0136591773,
-0.0094278185,
-0.0347781442,
-0.0041593406,
0.0148051325,
-0.0053644776,
-0.0411033221,
-0.0823082551,
-0.0265717115,
0.0346302912,
0.003051552,
0.0038570047,
0.006478155,
0.0409937687,
0.0076616625,
0.0627865046,
-0.0255972408,
-0.0026174092,
-0.0403787233,
-0.0059464513,
-0.0086050183,
-0.0114830285,
-0.0135298679,
0.0411750898,
0.0187430866,
-0.007014791,
-0.0612863377,
0.0284044892,
-0.0676818565,
0.0036564339,
0.0447332337,
-0.0710623264,
0.0105834818,
0.1085142344,
-0.0143181989,
-0.026088329,
0.0228768513,
0.0336391404,
-0.0153955817,
0.0058341236,
-0.0465623364,
-0.0047606532,
-0.0048114257,
0.0131172296,
0.0542692877,
0.0476822481,
0.0272025708,
-0.0305881444,
0.0085175941,
-0.0202495418,
0.011778472,
-0.0023622119,
-0.0077454816,
0.064844884,
0.0109993806,
0.0186055321,
-0.004239596,
-0.0107668564,
-0.0629476309,
-0.0174566936,
0.0021561338,
0.0259054378,
0.0548266321,
0.014625174,
-0.038165465,
0.0290172584,
0.0060442672,
0.0054412917,
0.0599781051,
0.0309692919,
0.0082928129,
0.017074639,
-0.0540012866,
0.0279238205,
0.0101800235,
0.0010640026,
-0.062198285,
0.0121927094,
0.0054999441,
-0.0122406427,
-0.003235834,
0.0443403572,
0.0051166047,
0.0280639213,
0.0039131497,
-0.0154626332,
-0.0113276495,
0.0023396849,
-0.0345914736,
0.0045093331,
0.0024297098,
-0.0122704357,
-0.037969742,
0.0106007783,
0.0382975936,
0.0104207629,
0.0159496926,
-0.0174746644,
0.0115774246,
0.0471920967,
-0.0542392395,
0.0321814455,
-0.0149946855,
-0.0175966471,
-0.0532559529,
-0.0101734567,
-0.0071195303,
-0.0261437017,
-0.0202878974,
0.0073233629,
0.0452904031,
-0.0165279843,
-0.0322970226,
-0.038280841,
0.0654267147,
-0.0400841273,
-0.0755527318,
-0.0129801063,
-0.0608781241,
-0.0295507517,
0.017058311,
-0.0078520356,
0.0344643928,
-0.0316300578,
0.061157167,
0.0514825098,
-0.0156081449,
0.0400755182,
-0.0124098826,
-0.1069714874,
0.0062093134,
-0.0202786904,
-0.0422923416,
0.0127758915,
-0.0701399669,
0.0362508893,
-0.0040267105,
-0.0116584264,
-0.0319176838,
-0.0003074055,
-0.0226849131,
0.0340499356,
0.0540120229,
-0.0045790258,
-0.0365270525,
0.0709809735,
0.0179908164,
-0.0069905347,
-0.0431811139,
-0.0285338666,
0.0025567792,
0.0342701301,
0.0253953934,
-0.0826427191,
-0.0835788473,
-0.0058281678,
-0.0329990722,
-0.0399328172,
-0.0368963778,
0.0189761519,
0.0355552323,
-0.0134447692,
-0.042261973,
0.0251717474,
0.0360397659,
0.0075423424,
-0.0282341521,
0.0047642291,
0.0039199074,
-0.0433427989,
-0.0027812161,
-0.001145557,
0.0282783471,
0.0193145312,
0.0720085725,
0.0250602104,
-0.017896723,
0.0256387424,
-0.019003164,
-0.038421426,
0.0405463167,
-0.0221518334,
-0.1115597337,
0.0217989124,
-0.0260197241,
-0.0110377874,
0.0466312207,
-0.0464427173,
0.0137894917,
0.0329486132,
-0.0195101965,
-0.0619454384,
-0.0496493503,
-0.0590483062,
0.0255221575,
-0.0411247984,
-0.0130128311,
0.0080646649,
-0.0183407627,
-0.0054832422,
0.0560451597,
0.0025497891,
-0.0101546226,
-0.0454727449,
-0.0313930176,
0.0669190213,
0.0328208618,
-0.0581824183,
-0.0309024733,
-0.0646876246,
0.0179308318,
0.0047891508,
-0.0260790959,
0.008430806,
0.0514764525,
-0.0618876927,
-0.006247079,
-0.0068387603,
0.0114794364,
-0.0358761437,
-0.0141106173,
0.0063745803,
-0.0352913402,
-0.0354400165,
0.0528626405,
-0.0068014679,
-0.0553979091,
0.0066394391,
0.0103007844,
-0.0033911963,
0.0467701443,
0.0145148085,
-0.0072683459,
0.0550887138,
0.0450234897,
-0.0002754577,
-0.0523356684,
0.0377893709,
-0.0154900206,
-0.0374099351,
-0.0347771049,
-0.005102911,
-0.0448451042,
0.0037962236,
0.0218532309,
-0.0085751582,
0.0141842794,
0.0025216152,
0.0089513911,
-0.0196236521,
-0.0255072434,
0.0192629937,
-0.0553152002,
0.0146954153,
-0.0244152602,
0.0233721994,
-0.0223265942,
0.002035395,
0.0348413251,
0.0195493996,
-0.0407997221,
-0.0033418045,
0.0151067218,
0.0040184367,
-0.0149926245,
0.0058352374,
-0.0015766767,
-0.0237550829,
0.0174738225,
-0.0034493541,
0.0694295466,
0.0306527875,
0.005405359,
0.0042539993,
-0.050303489,
-0.0210558865,
0.0104996981,
-0.0336922593,
0.0255717617,
0.0166656543,
-0.0070652296,
0.026344616,
0.0524250828,
0.0130348923,
-0.0089287711,
0.0371777974,
0.0082399491,
0.0365977325,
0.044892136,
-0.0441372246,
-0.0492621735,
0.0090925116,
0.0147801768,
-0.0193101354,
0.0240821019,
-0.0446480066,
-0.0267355517,
0.0394013077,
-0.0084553072,
0.0388189517,
-0.0076737953,
-0.0483421236,
0.0354013965,
0.0431581587,
-0.0628149658,
-0.0244106054,
0.0446241051,
-0.045284342,
0.0450813659,
0.0111344215,
-0.0235308353,
-0.0140354354,
-0.0706823841,
-0.0207546614,
-0.0310743973,
0.0030702131,
0.0063264854,
-0.0185338892,
-0.0435279571,
-0.0250437502,
-0.0118946815,
0.0202337597,
0.0080528185,
-0.0373941325,
-0.0146574164,
0.0275449324,
-0.0194966644,
0.0246668756,
0.0373071805,
-0.0411041565,
-0.0102561237,
0.0009881479,
0.0636040047,
-0.0203486253,
-0.0215755533,
0.0319652073,
-0.0274317358,
-0.0142064523,
-0.0096035395,
-0.0021792939,
-0.0992405936,
-0.0282737706,
-0.0147070084,
-0.0614325777,
-0.0400597043,
-0.0305007901,
-0.0232569706,
-0.0517811552,
0.0584150031,
-0.0934614763,
-0.0651485696,
-0.0085875383,
-0.025746109,
-0.0056296871,
0.0165549573,
0.0215318762,
-0.0015456604,
-0.00191384,
-0.0168015305,
0.0628918186,
0.0482869931,
-0.0076336362,
0.0449692048,
0.0379631966,
-0.0299291629,
0.0002246049,
0.0326850079,
-0.0296010468,
0.011826152,
0.0230240077,
0.079334937,
-0.0581690706,
-0.051974453,
0.0288765598,
-0.0303796288,
0.0539111309,
-0.0205612779,
-0.0348024033,
-0.0096116429,
-0.0355823077,
0.007226076,
0.0433265939,
0.0449429452,
-0.0126901716,
0.052422367,
0.0130964844,
-0.0356894881,
-0.0308960266,
0.03817489,
-0.0040920451,
-0.0414778888,
0.0244139619,
-0.0602031834,
0.0296759568,
0.0412348956,
-0.0758179352,
-0.0031483406,
0.0470983535,
0.02370793,
-0.0142630776,
0.0261894204,
0.0373695977,
-0.025061952,
-0.0274514351,
-0.0186017025,
-0.029627122,
-0.0202063695,
0.0318258107,
0.0751581863,
0.0008568852,
0.0203325618,
-0.0425742343,
-0.0049303551,
0.061446134,
0.0809198022,
-0.0233948696,
-0.0075178444,
0.0102072433,
-0.0664360598,
-0.0068143625,
0.0169708803,
-0.0307042729,
0.0452401191,
-0.0503781587,
-0.0173074752,
-0.0522709414,
-0.0023642129,
-0.0190110747,
0.0201044604,
0.0150585035,
0.0052006859,
-0.0204172377,
-0.0231472459,
0.0315120593,
0.0424791686,
0.0021835288,
-0.0138479415,
0.0246704537,
0.0022433414,
-0.0236029252,
-0.0006043223,
0.001779097,
0.0631429479,
-0.0636704639,
-0.0444728844,
0.0147324707,
0.0488841385,
-0.026758451,
0.0321341455,
0.001254068,
0.037223272,
-0.0374522805,
0.0645642504,
-0.0257936921,
0.0308437999,
0.0476520546,
0.0096578458,
-0.0274057891,
-0.0364947468,
-0.0224317629,
-0.0311727952,
-0.0763501525,
-0.0130053768,
-0.0390682034,
0.0506165251,
0.0177711397,
0.0062239356,
-0.0931300968,
0.0243880879,
0.0217133928,
0.0176827703,
-0.0060600233,
0.0138554368,
0.03184193,
0.0088394433,
-0.0158479922,
0.0285227057,
0.0576200858,
0.027013734,
0.0251497757,
-0.0579458959,
-0.028341474,
-0.0660232082,
0.0117066428,
0.0895226821,
-0.0065096538,
-0.0076667499,
-0.0272609424,
-0.0386427231,
-0.0313887782,
0.0282950439,
-0.0386337452,
0.0349597633,
-0.0475123711,
0.0444151796,
-0.0088029401,
0.0336774588,
0.0796868056,
-0.0119101591,
-0.0504816696,
-0.0482144207,
0.0277639776,
0.006795207,
-5.312686759e-33,
0.0328108147,
-0.0763975605,
-0.0384812653,
0.048697263,
-0.0039493241,
0.0282389093,
-0.0099945674,
-0.0297932699,
0.046057377,
0.0219508763,
0.0044430993,
0.0367399417,
-0.025720356,
0.0279978476,
0.0099341553,
-0.0311888065,
0.0283441879,
0.049538061,
-0.0020491304,
0.0451471172,
0.0604946278,
0.0261275508,
0.0816427395,
-0.0534014143,
-0.0263129063,
0.0490034185,
-0.0223494805,
0.0467839763,
-0.0295703392,
0.0206353348,
-0.0145616001,
0.0659009144,
0.0214570109,
-0.0782933384,
0.0389896221,
-0.0403751135,
-0.0195634067,
0.0020624495,
-0.0656264797,
-0.001560026,
0.0160468258,
0.0613076724,
0.0625514165,
0.00249765,
0.0323658027,
-0.0093524987,
0.0713342577,
0.0058414727,
-0.0038517872,
-0.1009828821,
0.0469400622,
0.0335795134,
-0.0282761361,
-0.0492388681,
-0.0070720175,
0.0368855633,
0.0226051901,
-0.0071370928,
-0.0367859825,
0.0206349082,
0.0545726642,
-0.0292975251,
0.0172519945,
0.0298634544,
-0.0103240851,
0.0302638467,
-0.0377687998,
-0.0437930487,
-0.0022681395,
-0.0381059125,
-0.0153813921,
0.0846540779,
0.023402283,
-0.0173189305,
0.0153325619,
-0.0823923871,
-0.0885275006,
0.0172492228,
0.0169796981,
0.0047300849,
-0.0075189932,
-0.0255088154,
-0.0187386405,
-0.0094851013,
0.0071004811,
0.013158367,
-0.0055467798,
0.0120384675,
-0.013255476,
0.010006099,
-0.0361337774,
0.0600372814,
-0.0150632858,
-0.0440936834,
0.0532241687,
0.0596801862,
0.0264990069,
-0.0114393551,
-0.0064864731,
-0.0176434778,
0.0046234764,
0.0001265647,
-0.0019541816,
-0.0019486119,
0.008640511,
-0.0122665791,
0.0213488061,
0.0449523702,
-0.0155224558,
0.0221082326,
0.0164521839,
-0.0174366944,
-0.0509948917,
0.0306402687,
0.0462934934,
0.0439946763,
0.0197403189,
0.0349901691,
0.0039749765,
0.0683040917,
0.0047429255,
0.0058427439,
0.0041777641,
-0.0528982207,
0.0023050082,
-0.0348371603,
-0.0284596067,
-0.0328514948,
-0.061894577,
-0.0222587828,
-0.0089716632,
0.0310251489,
2.858e-7,
0.0099511417,
0.0590408407,
-0.0021795887,
0.016242085,
-0.0063335598,
0.0160038341,
-0.003259104,
0.0054524438,
-0.0028643545,
0.0408745073,
0.0648893937,
-0.0556105711,
0.0356699303,
0.0499208793,
-0.1007743478,
-0.038657546,
-0.0012090674,
0.0093914671,
-0.0408268832,
-0.0179035496,
0.044614628,
0.0346032903,
0.0494813472,
-0.0219615921,
0.0549051426,
-0.000618743,
0.0311281253,
-0.0146535998,
0.0250984915,
-0.0229018796,
0.0782463178,
0.0343238786,
0.0149684669,
0.0845894292,
-0.0128284777,
0.0238017794,
-0.0174461678,
-0.0336413309,
0.015151673,
-0.0556921512,
0.0198545884,
0.0495632738,
0.0474701896,
-0.0094252024,
0.0155470688,
-0.0729297996,
0.001545651,
0.0413934737,
-0.010603888,
-0.0246155988,
0.0183353238,
-0.015275727,
0.0053259288,
0.0268477164,
-0.0503497571,
-0.0244951658,
0.0566371754,
-0.0217967536,
0.0078384113,
0.0077493354,
-0.004666321,
-0.0267251618,
0.0250288974,
-0.0306705236,
0.0551110655,
-0.0032088996,
0.0219253302,
2.235532427e-34,
-0.0171097722,
-0.0023672874,
-0.0420515575,
0.0369791538,
0.0094677648,
-0.025528634,
0.057905823,
-0.022845,
-0.0009591822,
-0.06373927,
0.0210685842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07282v2 | How do Large Language Models Navigate Conflicts between Honesty and Helpfulness? | 2024-02-11T19:13:26 | 2024-02-13T14:21:02 | Ryan Liu, Theodore R. Sumers, Ishita Dasgupta, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In day-to-day communication, people often approximate the truth - for
example, rounding the time or omitting details - in order to be maximally
helpful to the listener. How do large language models (LLMs) handle such
nuanced trade-offs? To address this question, we use psychological models and
experiments designed to characterize human behavior to analyze LLMs. We test a
range of LLMs and explore how optimization for human preferences or
inference-time reasoning affects these trade-offs. We find that reinforcement
learning from human feedback improves both honesty and helpfulness, while
chain-of-thought prompting skews LLMs towards helpfulness over honesty.
Finally, GPT-4 Turbo demonstrates human-like response patterns including
sensitivity to the conversational framing and listener's decision context. Our
findings reveal the conversational values internalized by LLMs and suggest that
even these abstract values can, to a degree, be steered by zero-shot prompting. | [
0.0775492936,
0.0650424808,
-0.0427621938,
0.0299517773,
-0.0901977271,
-0.0107894018,
-0.0203920789,
0.0030411212,
-0.0344939828,
-0.0086951237,
-0.0092323087,
-0.0174114387,
0.0564577095,
0.0096063381,
0.0011996723,
-0.0271492321,
0.0393977799,
-0.0238771401,
0.0690714046,
-0.020386586,
0.024936419,
-0.0001878662,
-0.0030667575,
0.0326770023,
-0.0306347292,
0.0180997737,
-0.0249595828,
-0.0357162692,
0.0043701814,
0.0034223082,
0.0107546533,
0.0610128008,
0.0187994223,
0.0421270616,
0.0000019805,
-0.0409247391,
0.0121414643,
-0.0203271993,
-0.0505132377,
0.0362195484,
0.0378235392,
-0.0282920767,
0.0253622588,
0.0181648601,
-0.0575807095,
0.0294507779,
0.0230387058,
0.0303344056,
0.0282474104,
0.0591986924,
0.0170105174,
0.052120477,
0.0132533163,
-0.0343017988,
0.008324354,
-0.0577823743,
0.0094414484,
-0.034223929,
-0.0085192183,
0.013956219,
0.002772813,
-0.0119060427,
0.0102413511,
-0.0164955836,
-0.018358279,
0.0650258139,
-0.029754078,
-0.0088669267,
-0.012293743,
0.0648895502,
0.0531197488,
-0.0161205772,
0.0041158781,
-0.0401604362,
0.0089770211,
-0.0078579327,
-0.0378893651,
0.0097368937,
0.015299717,
0.006306997,
-0.0071651628,
0.0150028421,
-0.0008048147,
0.0135913827,
0.0535279401,
0.0809304565,
-0.0372262858,
-0.0426397696,
0.0161480606,
0.0101957144,
-0.0034657368,
-0.0964253247,
-0.038865868,
0.0120219029,
-0.0589173362,
0.0130397128,
-0.0189823247,
0.0793316215,
0.0566429123,
-0.027040761,
0.0057418472,
0.0462518781,
0.0171370525,
0.0089534642,
0.0392003134,
0.0357634388,
0.0175200086,
0.0067956774,
-0.0184328966,
0.0134512102,
0.0028359382,
-0.0118270498,
0.0091381241,
0.0264188498,
-0.0233996641,
0.0092555443,
-0.0359874889,
0.0137151405,
-0.0472809933,
0.0269708671,
-0.0092941262,
-0.0003320147,
-0.0308339447,
0.0054282299,
-0.1038119569,
0.0295110885,
-0.0673791245,
0.0293707736,
0.0076102763,
-0.0768580511,
-0.0281326175,
-0.0411370061,
0.0075494559,
-0.0194535293,
-0.0050819926,
0.0459680483,
-0.0242895093,
-0.0118094794,
0.0004580966,
-0.0116430065,
-0.0447471067,
-0.0975679085,
-0.0439228714,
-0.0394619517,
0.0438270345,
0.0173344556,
-0.0377287641,
-0.001534205,
0.0213034097,
0.0120743029,
-0.0595067516,
0.057859119,
0.0100942831,
0.0415398926,
0.0031765385,
0.0153456591,
-0.0420237184,
0.033079762,
0.0269342829,
0.0105064521,
0.0422881655,
-0.0307800397,
0.0197455361,
-0.0002441567,
0.0317942873,
0.0096384659,
0.0080169253,
0.005423421,
0.0015737484,
0.061222557,
0.0565219969,
0.0401915014,
-0.0438260026,
-0.0366841033,
0.117267549,
0.0432842486,
-0.0278242119,
0.0031544194,
-0.0037221455,
0.0614598989,
-0.0131654516,
0.0511290245,
-0.073581256,
0.0388090685,
-0.0284719076,
0.0057931012,
0.0347433686,
0.0067401333,
-0.0142737171,
-0.0140487729,
0.0098935748,
-0.011863309,
0.0486427471,
0.0576695725,
-0.0339439847,
-0.0598980971,
-0.038492851,
0.0218065232,
0.0215316936,
0.0121034943,
-0.0161781628,
-0.0674292445,
0.0414909683,
0.0663496479,
0.0320269503,
0.033703167,
0.003093004,
-0.0260483231,
-0.0008855431,
0.0298517644,
0.0691662133,
-0.0070433822,
0.0182487369,
-0.0082068834,
0.007486722,
-0.0087924264,
0.009837498,
0.00174828,
-0.0057690917,
0.030522963,
-0.0072395238,
0.0098044798,
0.013627056,
0.010692683,
0.0306711327,
-0.0181672648,
-0.0048940619,
0.0050122393,
0.0040611564,
-0.0263957307,
-0.0056859613,
0.016490601,
-0.004580609,
0.0169037301,
-0.0120185092,
0.0206314251,
-0.0931392238,
-0.0076882225,
0.0170918107,
0.0042651808,
-0.0161334444,
0.0041606533,
-0.0193416011,
0.0068409033,
-0.0038252661,
-0.0229326878,
0.0338107981,
-0.0080280509,
0.0226238295,
-0.0242181197,
0.0139222313,
-0.0191770177,
0.0390638188,
-0.0384796932,
0.0455828905,
-0.0164117403,
-0.036558222,
-0.0172326379,
-0.0388637856,
0.0473007336,
0.0219807196,
0.0229509268,
0.0111720869,
0.0629950836,
0.01117111,
-0.0430728532,
-0.0460258611,
-0.1041530073,
-0.0371078365,
0.0191912707,
0.0045347065,
-0.0007939159,
-0.0189835392,
0.0047663199,
0.0128275249,
-0.0340120494,
0.0093802102,
0.014861254,
0.0365630127,
0.0599528067,
0.0200217124,
-0.0158216842,
-0.0273654182,
0.0002492267,
-0.0219692215,
0.0048430669,
-0.010935354,
-0.0148078343,
-0.0491908267,
-0.0202811379,
-0.041176483,
0.0392266922,
-0.016276326,
-0.042648185,
0.0022251818,
0.0493775457,
0.0610579588,
0.0920552835,
0.0657595247,
-0.0008804932,
0.0491931662,
0.0066328445,
-0.0758469254,
0.0137749715,
-0.0330639817,
-0.0325598456,
-0.0211846046,
-0.0724630505,
0.0013876982,
0.0650684536,
0.0266832914,
0.0220435858,
-0.042760998,
0.0445122384,
-0.0098653091,
-0.0535905324,
0.0058735949,
-0.0168346018,
-0.0273248591,
0.0868292451,
-0.0034036094,
-0.0510186441,
0.1099809557,
0.0235957224,
-0.0002317304,
0.027941158,
0.0055330563,
-0.0028081122,
0.0452838764,
-0.0079398388,
-0.0022329567,
0.0509862639,
0.0017046217,
-0.0545043163,
-0.0621607453,
0.0548197739,
-0.0373075865,
0.0273383204,
-0.0314538665,
-0.0089316098,
0.0008955637,
-0.0819151178,
-0.0455536731,
-0.0980020687,
-0.0323119126,
-0.0058555733,
-0.0159752425,
-0.0182973798,
-0.0115597351,
-0.0588491708,
0.042046085,
0.0311793331,
-0.0394441001,
-0.0129326321,
0.0007044928,
0.0002147925,
0.0715684667,
0.0149271144,
0.0587789789,
0.0037967991,
0.0187390856,
0.0414664112,
0.028301537,
0.0639613345,
0.024598334,
-0.0125244129,
0.0064578,
0.0148638198,
-0.0161873922,
0.084930338,
0.0206238367,
0.0002807525,
-0.0290132798,
0.1016103178,
0.0201437511,
-0.0484104678,
0.0394946001,
-0.0675876439,
0.0306114815,
-0.0058440957,
0.022182174,
-0.0929799154,
-0.0239934064,
0.008063484,
-0.0096093174,
-0.0821315199,
-0.0440062657,
-0.0061187884,
-0.1185309291,
0.0100965472,
-0.0038407957,
-0.0260422658,
-0.002078292,
-0.0385657325,
0.0022918724,
-0.0039455551,
0.0458105318,
0.0054265801,
0.0168226603,
-0.0142732691,
-0.0081879376,
0.0096788397,
-0.0069303452,
0.0805184096,
-0.0107686548,
0.0732141659,
0.0305020735,
0.0687470883,
0.0070572942,
-0.0790353566,
-0.0110188397,
0.0439530797,
-0.0210197978,
0.0059708306,
0.0041309176,
-0.0095785167,
0.0394398309,
-0.0293194391,
0.0364097655,
0.0366265364,
0.0018351119,
0.0070089586,
0.0560476184,
-0.0044502825,
-0.0410347879,
0.0354616195,
0.0244613606,
0.0619140267,
0.0669579506,
0.0112005696,
-0.0506470501,
-0.0070394306,
0.0159095936,
0.002943096,
-0.0055089938,
-0.0420422442,
-0.0192282069,
0.0416105464,
0.0126538733,
-0.049905058,
-0.0462618023,
-0.0418660343,
-0.0330738537,
-0.0011001818,
-0.0348088667,
-0.0024921789,
0.0280113984,
-0.0068906099,
0.0022619213,
-0.0378086381,
0.0420812778,
-0.0400298722,
0.0308772121,
-0.0083275344,
-0.0501288287,
0.005655943,
0.0338170789,
-0.0421498492,
-0.040224947,
-0.0101096332,
0.0180911887,
0.0216550622,
0.0784350485,
0.0252555497,
-0.0329071172,
-0.0486571342,
0.0104140108,
-0.0629236773,
0.0476167947,
0.0407314897,
0.0603060946,
0.0197834689,
0.0524591357,
-0.0218791906,
0.002509811,
0.0210195519,
0.0086251982,
-0.0213040188,
-0.0649119467,
0.0530606247,
0.0093170274,
0.0309079438,
0.0091642495,
0.0249227379,
-0.0096367244,
0.0071981782,
-0.0044042938,
-0.021501461,
-0.029930735,
-0.0501468368,
0.0156336352,
0.0158871803,
-0.0093374513,
-0.0582445115,
-0.0248233508,
0.0048322291,
-0.0050306916,
-0.0616414845,
0.0076903854,
0.0167804994,
0.0035677908,
-0.0013899209,
-0.0300374161,
0.0147219142,
-0.0003676526,
0.0532936715,
0.0023964799,
0.0908135623,
0.0367870629,
-0.0292940158,
0.0015905781,
-0.0072527924,
-0.0320919119,
-0.0444134995,
0.02801832,
0.0124008274,
0.0014441396,
0.006839125,
0.0110496189,
-0.0367950685,
-0.0038633489,
-0.0047873203,
0.0385346562,
-0.009459707,
-0.0202825237,
0.0114343921,
0.0120295556,
-0.0503726043,
0.0299387202,
0.0490715876,
-0.0337718129,
0.0193509087,
-0.0069662081,
-0.0207864959,
-0.0106545165,
-0.0136154406,
-0.017358508,
0.0208123829,
-0.010028596,
0.0082545485,
-0.1058620363,
-0.0310716648,
-0.0363482833,
0.019944137,
0.015349471,
-0.0679022521,
0.012347837,
0.0476934388,
-0.0069145071,
-0.0526241325,
-0.0470691472,
0.0273633432,
0.0108438097,
0.0037959367,
-0.0633352473,
-6.471875166e-33,
0.0209391154,
-0.0298401583,
-0.0180398319,
0.001938669,
-0.021737406,
0.0135129932,
0.0000336541,
0.0263624191,
-0.0547567382,
-0.0024111965,
-0.0455189273,
0.000407739,
0.0087103294,
-0.0243625175,
0.0224748533,
0.014216152,
0.020884335,
-0.0272684675,
-0.0627198517,
0.0085382685,
0.0166055877,
-0.0333273672,
0.0519925952,
-0.025758421,
0.03738527,
0.0085262619,
-0.0291604623,
0.0539609641,
-0.0370052196,
0.0183041096,
-0.0095908139,
0.0312967151,
-0.0010897049,
-0.0456109792,
0.0090384642,
0.0312066469,
-0.0245055687,
-0.0330772474,
0.078839846,
-0.0258003548,
-0.0423877724,
-0.018489603,
-0.0195967313,
-0.03163426,
-0.0461863279,
-0.0047797393,
-0.0094236191,
0.0200796016,
-0.0079109045,
0.0537627228,
-0.0442755371,
-0.0305085592,
-0.0331420563,
-0.0523823388,
-0.0096898573,
0.0401241705,
-0.0208824072,
0.0066459822,
-0.0530706644,
0.0416844152,
0.0279349647,
0.0164023656,
0.0166814588,
-0.0237302817,
0.0246965028,
0.0487804152,
0.0341502056,
0.0624772236,
-0.0036666295,
-0.0274373237,
0.0196854882,
-0.0009114144,
0.0268376227,
0.0591476895,
0.0389981307,
-0.0732901767,
-0.0094603915,
-0.0361815989,
0.0692798868,
0.0014308911,
0.0275758393,
0.0160246473,
-0.045845978,
-0.0525797233,
-0.0498441979,
0.0121410191,
-0.0432424359,
-0.0224694498,
0.0038118556,
0.0305824745,
0.014078835,
0.0049818433,
0.0197210852,
-0.0304829832,
-0.0078545837,
-0.0099996198,
-0.021574622,
-0.005655461,
0.0035960679,
-0.0188429225,
-0.0860788673,
-0.0002417922,
-0.0386316217,
0.0062141903,
0.0297487453,
0.0032144957,
0.0336832404,
0.0135322213,
-0.0127662746,
0.008610365,
-0.0337158181,
0.0554806516,
0.0023696416,
-0.0799569488,
0.0404985584,
-0.0065628192,
-0.048612956,
0.0226092432,
-0.0147038847,
-0.0327124074,
-0.0742670298,
0.0118063558,
-0.0104061905,
0.0324997492,
-0.038206432,
-0.0106072519,
-0.0162710473,
0.0001234492,
0.0083036618,
0.0107839443,
-0.0348736867,
-0.0273091439,
2.812e-7,
-0.0699973181,
0.0489909314,
-0.0252258703,
0.0354902297,
0.0063438299,
0.07676512,
0.0176280867,
0.0369308442,
0.0134401023,
-0.0256067067,
0.0266409684,
-0.0166467093,
0.0705986768,
0.0111721717,
-0.0167639349,
-0.0054687392,
-0.066036962,
-0.0245140046,
0.0069110165,
-0.0289282445,
0.0233386997,
0.0319758244,
0.054606311,
-0.0027630616,
-0.0022597655,
0.0011505394,
0.0519903749,
-0.0590852015,
-0.0139591312,
0.0114714699,
-0.0197918471,
-0.0569479205,
0.0106372274,
0.0346369632,
0.0241887607,
-0.0069379164,
-0.053991396,
0.0723480284,
-0.0110999784,
-0.0489097945,
-0.025601536,
-0.0155293038,
-0.0154937543,
-0.0797488391,
0.0438140407,
-0.0664396435,
-0.051697094,
-0.0460880511,
0.054177992,
-0.0417062081,
0.00443039,
-0.0153736379,
-0.0214978196,
0.0252862498,
0.0093676951,
0.0429931656,
0.0018790395,
-0.0197169576,
-0.0321926177,
0.0327167064,
-0.0079036821,
-0.0832463205,
-0.0190941785,
0.0440867618,
0.0075444593,
-0.0613048226,
0.0227006562,
2.26709468e-34,
0.0209767744,
0.0063789347,
0.0195202064,
0.0498670377,
0.0669348314,
0.0325480998,
0.0292996746,
0.0111939264,
0.0604286939,
0.0016253225,
-0.0274824686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07271v1 | Previously on the Stories: Recap Snippet Identification for Story Reading | 2024-02-11T18:27:14 | 2024-02-11T18:27:14 | Jiangnan Li, Qiujing Wang, Liyan Xu, Wenjie Pang, Mo Yu, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Similar to the "previously-on" scenes in TV shows, recaps can help book
reading by recalling the readers' memory about the important elements in
previous texts to better understand the ongoing plot. Despite its usefulness,
this application has not been well studied in the NLP community. We propose the
first benchmark on this useful task called Recap Snippet Identification with a
hand-crafted evaluation dataset. Our experiments show that the proposed task is
challenging to PLMs, LLMs, and proposed methods as the task requires a deep
understanding of the plot correlation between snippets. | [
-0.0074863248,
-0.0073993304,
-0.0172181372,
0.0559089519,
-0.0245303083,
0.0017541647,
-0.0220413953,
0.0211246777,
0.0163783394,
-0.0236752778,
-0.0180770867,
0.057186842,
0.0352355205,
0.0643376037,
-0.0109441457,
-0.054297138,
0.0253148079,
-0.0223461408,
0.0412661694,
0.0485978574,
0.0578158572,
0.0094484836,
-0.0169875585,
0.0198155362,
0.0216771178,
-0.0287970435,
0.0184297115,
-0.0036671199,
0.0633312091,
-0.0615603104,
0.012890269,
-0.0181995537,
0.031561479,
0.0045484649,
0.0000015334,
-0.0314143673,
-0.0241300277,
-0.0199708063,
-0.0193281081,
0.0169687346,
0.0355736837,
-0.0015740244,
0.0521684214,
-0.0509846099,
-0.0083867824,
-0.006668977,
0.0237458367,
0.0879260227,
0.0366453454,
0.0463267788,
-0.016695464,
-0.0042503015,
-0.0695240349,
0.0077543771,
0.0532545745,
-0.0448465385,
-0.0111288019,
-0.0249932371,
0.0311878342,
0.0000349093,
-0.0253775548,
0.0299424771,
-0.0125458008,
0.023362536,
-0.037375588,
0.0482107066,
-0.0116617121,
0.0610933602,
-0.0464095734,
0.1217814311,
0.0165146291,
-0.0370775312,
-0.006653076,
-0.0263268016,
-0.0243999232,
0.0397632755,
-0.0942566395,
-0.0247761235,
-0.0265596453,
0.0293893348,
-0.0046736812,
0.0403905027,
0.0304723307,
-0.0006264731,
0.0309877377,
0.0305221565,
-0.012838183,
0.0107020829,
-0.0282805394,
0.0082378183,
0.0192073286,
-0.01032802,
0.0168539509,
0.0447326712,
0.0230772048,
0.0103377579,
-0.0351054817,
-0.0076168915,
-0.0156334676,
-0.0055310223,
0.0301829223,
-0.0267227646,
-0.045789998,
0.0625911355,
-0.0471466295,
0.0336898901,
0.0080239139,
-0.0020697762,
-0.013751287,
0.0265339669,
-0.022149289,
0.0287876017,
-0.0262032207,
0.0564674139,
-0.0095192315,
-0.0547822081,
0.0077272723,
-0.0307168383,
0.0272357464,
0.0610994957,
-0.0440314189,
0.0302795544,
-0.0016221576,
-0.0154062714,
-0.042952314,
0.0324785002,
-0.0557964779,
-0.0209465772,
-0.0140683958,
-0.0142457811,
-0.0325675942,
0.0045852913,
0.0123473089,
-0.0144996876,
0.0207103267,
0.0454661585,
-0.00370759,
-0.0581693761,
-0.0522746854,
-0.0721333846,
-0.0168267619,
-0.019094184,
0.0040006051,
-0.028278796,
0.0508287698,
0.0109814918,
0.0348862484,
-0.0227324683,
0.0008570155,
0.0214791037,
-0.0351708457,
0.0561938137,
0.0043373266,
-0.0130453678,
-0.0188936461,
0.0484333746,
-0.0134864282,
0.0568022095,
0.0250814687,
0.05271025,
0.0671817064,
-0.0060181948,
0.027209321,
0.0158906467,
-0.0152583523,
0.0126249185,
-0.0346518829,
0.0092024421,
0.0096818022,
0.0039934185,
0.0007842817,
-0.0040211733,
-0.045105923,
-0.0576402098,
0.0535621122,
0.136482805,
0.0002463971,
0.001764038,
0.0253629014,
0.0118399998,
0.0400111154,
0.0516103618,
0.0074862149,
0.011834953,
-0.012255054,
0.0003347006,
-0.0135341557,
-0.0216530301,
-0.0121225817,
0.0107591497,
-0.0084057311,
0.0049153999,
-0.0325642489,
-0.0093612485,
0.0225270148,
0.0045390222,
-0.0457383618,
-0.0201592222,
-0.0122645646,
-0.0322770253,
0.0332836397,
0.0254978575,
0.0410986654,
0.0828915536,
0.0852927417,
-0.0671228319,
-0.031895496,
-0.0246126447,
0.0076670614,
0.0091783777,
0.0150190853,
-0.0595939718,
0.0492165238,
-0.0705849603,
0.0089700958,
-0.0241889749,
-0.0238794442,
0.0229486469,
0.0224842858,
-0.0267157145,
-0.0012700981,
-0.0229595229,
-0.0306403171,
0.0235303286,
-0.0291057955,
-0.0224065464,
-0.0275521558,
-0.0159032084,
-0.0070388759,
0.008372494,
-0.0056279209,
-0.0117066326,
0.0424789637,
-0.0522133075,
0.0390970223,
0.0660230368,
-0.0162267964,
-0.0506523177,
0.0051887361,
-0.0748025775,
-0.0248771422,
0.0306682568,
-0.0138200046,
-0.0302317329,
0.031217033,
-0.0140806139,
0.0164107606,
0.0039945915,
-0.0007653483,
0.0049689948,
0.013275208,
-0.0453631505,
0.0448043793,
0.0203959327,
0.037784975,
-0.0019046016,
-0.0213553421,
0.0133594563,
-0.040598236,
-0.0105835553,
-0.0037543566,
0.0153023768,
-0.0620666742,
0.0247025434,
-0.041036997,
-0.0519203022,
-0.0014016993,
-0.05360239,
0.0475890674,
0.0337019786,
0.0057431157,
0.032838963,
-0.0341521949,
-0.0323114805,
-0.0321837403,
-0.0342135057,
-0.0115623111,
-0.0182015151,
0.0043211458,
0.0367377549,
0.0496453568,
0.0176108833,
-0.0241118222,
0.0206156839,
-0.0353302434,
0.0805576146,
0.0408595018,
-0.0162686203,
-0.0390703045,
0.0314192995,
0.0430387184,
-0.0154361725,
-0.038301602,
0.0145054627,
0.0246624369,
0.0188694559,
0.0360659398,
0.0751722902,
-0.0241556894,
0.0075256862,
0.0075007034,
-0.0732081532,
-0.0599624962,
-0.0027418607,
-0.0275964122,
0.0267515518,
-0.0085931756,
-0.0338312201,
0.0324835815,
0.0676773489,
-0.0000483208,
0.027450148,
0.0083104149,
0.0053746365,
0.0156578775,
0.0100082615,
-0.0599590577,
-0.0351354554,
-0.0099347588,
0.0406336002,
-0.0108676627,
-0.0444842204,
0.0455231108,
-0.0756352171,
0.0064713364,
-0.028463088,
0.0249664988,
-0.0737923384,
0.0904387683,
-0.0213875473,
0.0217618775,
-0.0203283727,
-0.0606910177,
0.0122182546,
-0.0038290462,
0.001269201,
-0.0320345499,
0.0414904431,
-0.0238412507,
-0.013586795,
-0.0109224617,
-0.0010435116,
-0.0446038134,
-0.0242479369,
-0.0385955162,
-0.0472703688,
-0.010000959,
-0.0166388024,
-0.0301689431,
0.0242298711,
0.0247891303,
0.0118201599,
-0.0466724299,
-0.0164767373,
0.008476615,
0.0618583821,
0.07022392,
-0.0160327628,
0.0090229763,
-0.0520539209,
0.0090405354,
0.046043206,
0.0140066808,
0.014902032,
0.017905077,
0.0228869189,
0.0181677938,
-0.0618516468,
0.0221459549,
-0.0197311398,
0.0147954775,
-0.1019796431,
-0.0091353366,
0.0770389289,
0.0302211866,
-0.1056849435,
-0.0357028469,
0.0170159657,
-0.0136888083,
0.0228439607,
-0.0199286435,
-0.0399896093,
-0.0481506884,
-0.0004617637,
-0.0051474301,
0.0087567372,
-0.0565248989,
-0.0457242914,
-0.0643752962,
0.0212392975,
0.0237955563,
-0.0474280603,
-0.0195312593,
-0.0234181192,
0.0052013909,
0.0116726346,
-0.0501575172,
-0.0128228916,
-0.0659993663,
-0.0015027205,
-0.0326548927,
-0.0494834259,
-0.00155156,
0.0106777521,
-0.0301952306,
-0.0115272496,
0.042470932,
0.0129246628,
0.0041332687,
0.022032598,
0.0072596143,
-0.0144389039,
-0.0105420556,
0.0099816872,
0.1183010861,
-0.0561052412,
-0.0162627194,
-0.0227373578,
0.0471248776,
-0.0128597859,
-0.0642894879,
0.0369095467,
0.0170381144,
-0.0053135394,
-0.0252869483,
-0.0441575646,
0.0537067652,
-0.0195170622,
0.069389686,
0.0605131909,
0.0019760265,
-0.0383925512,
-0.000627164,
0.0465624593,
-0.076779522,
-0.0496804751,
-0.0053001894,
-0.0012851679,
0.0369775929,
-0.0725630075,
-0.0361431725,
0.055620268,
0.0138084227,
0.0487845317,
0.0239905603,
-0.033652354,
-0.0107171498,
-0.0815501064,
0.0277360883,
-0.0625172108,
-0.0423191302,
-0.0406488515,
0.0070457547,
0.0663647726,
-0.0206288919,
0.0114505868,
0.0333876386,
-0.1229223311,
-0.0074382904,
-0.0068807122,
0.0080832103,
0.0195960701,
0.0342348069,
0.0164720621,
-0.0020442011,
0.0436321795,
0.0048316643,
-0.0230694991,
0.0139985178,
-0.0331799872,
0.0652805567,
-0.0327107869,
-0.0207411386,
-0.0130018806,
-0.0089606093,
-0.0018017987,
0.0110140434,
-0.0023007113,
-0.0559049919,
-0.0087262057,
0.0273794197,
0.044424586,
-0.0239843037,
-0.0124870008,
-0.0442625843,
-0.0338349156,
0.0021844008,
-0.0170811117,
-0.0122517841,
0.0432632454,
0.0130236931,
-0.0109407492,
-0.0374536179,
0.0279202107,
-0.0349374004,
0.0365813598,
-0.0274898894,
0.0278782584,
0.0423971713,
-0.0384683162,
-0.0233876146,
0.0504702404,
-0.0108244382,
-0.0133381533,
-0.0120305242,
0.0626406372,
0.0279983077,
0.0325477868,
0.0239708163,
0.0000057353,
-0.0209437869,
0.0221986026,
-0.0434985757,
0.0077811931,
0.0029642116,
-0.0014378108,
0.0341955833,
-0.0792109519,
0.0412909463,
-0.0051868232,
0.0114295594,
-0.0055068848,
0.0449818745,
0.016264502,
0.0140964091,
-0.0232124254,
0.026486557,
-0.0155984368,
0.0686269104,
0.1076472104,
-0.0296328366,
0.026579529,
0.0530703478,
-0.0385756157,
-0.0348067842,
-0.0338199064,
0.0206962209,
0.048238162,
0.0262476224,
-0.0199497659,
-0.0737499893,
-0.0142743699,
0.0622483119,
-0.0024764044,
0.0509410575,
0.0477494411,
-0.0056046681,
0.0217486322,
0.0259880591,
0.0214928426,
-0.0187671203,
0.0276332982,
-0.006873359,
-0.0299815536,
-0.0343308076,
-5.018769457e-33,
-0.0222507361,
-0.016981015,
-0.0116760544,
0.0701424554,
-0.0577243716,
0.0516654067,
0.0071495115,
-0.021409858,
0.029475702,
0.0087031191,
0.0086160097,
-0.0103489021,
0.0133101912,
0.0026834852,
-0.0319217555,
-0.0317241214,
0.026632091,
0.028337514,
-0.070456028,
0.0264371131,
0.0607116073,
0.0351656303,
0.0539888889,
-0.0301689375,
-0.0308745243,
-0.0307752844,
-0.0100405002,
-0.0209205169,
0.0779962465,
0.0327815972,
-0.0416143499,
0.0162950661,
0.0494222678,
-0.0088201966,
-0.0285489112,
0.0575635508,
-0.0530943088,
-0.0469249226,
0.0020580075,
-0.0063495492,
-0.0225554183,
-0.0352138132,
0.0250110608,
-0.0197953843,
0.0138704609,
-0.0419096127,
0.0623411052,
-0.014955393,
-0.0099309515,
0.015754126,
-0.0114319064,
0.0188813023,
-0.0365310013,
-0.0137767289,
0.059574876,
0.0423824415,
0.0194229148,
0.0433838144,
-0.0535404421,
0.0254537091,
0.032407973,
0.041161608,
-0.029558925,
0.011330612,
-0.0167213175,
0.1122298464,
0.0346593037,
-0.0396993421,
-0.0188097786,
0.0449705459,
0.0156302415,
-0.0147344256,
0.0137692476,
0.0251601972,
0.0555095896,
0.0313335024,
-0.040396329,
0.0815066323,
0.026374653,
0.019729536,
0.0516063161,
-0.0117481025,
-0.0080673229,
-0.009085617,
-0.0328901634,
-0.0044118995,
-0.0169919971,
-0.0308806896,
0.0069087641,
0.0035673121,
-0.011015445,
0.0179058257,
0.0375767797,
-0.0419510044,
0.0449699946,
-0.003781775,
-0.0236554183,
0.0399399549,
0.0144277606,
-0.0185815636,
-0.0262865033,
0.0046652448,
0.0231782738,
-0.0240386818,
0.0814129263,
-0.0396557488,
0.0262247305,
0.0359478146,
-0.0696501285,
-0.0226996411,
0.011372434,
-0.0406890251,
-0.0398550108,
-0.0054375916,
0.0122837294,
-0.013481806,
-0.0320969298,
0.0618287474,
-0.0122805163,
0.0152680082,
0.0022835915,
-0.0433663279,
-0.0197830983,
-0.0092485836,
-0.0043560322,
0.0266196784,
0.0165199395,
0.0011262146,
-0.010149694,
-0.0571145639,
0.0190013964,
0.0141846295,
2.296e-7,
-0.0095692063,
0.0173403639,
0.0768411607,
-0.005443105,
0.0041592247,
0.024134228,
-0.0252234377,
0.0155697037,
0.0009892259,
-0.029437758,
0.0249557458,
0.0211750511,
0.0391902365,
0.0244718771,
-0.110726051,
-0.0215556286,
-0.032362204,
-0.0217913222,
-0.0348998494,
-0.0379262045,
0.0468160398,
0.0165474229,
0.0543281958,
-0.002278941,
0.0265625603,
-0.0355132446,
0.0680410117,
-0.0660669282,
-0.0176151134,
0.0545507744,
0.0018239385,
0.0330513678,
-0.0248873606,
-0.048437912,
0.0112774046,
0.0192996785,
0.0385757461,
0.0280127265,
0.0302694291,
-0.0601188093,
-0.0194728225,
0.0159343369,
0.0009422927,
0.0069586462,
0.0495704152,
-0.011864325,
-0.0408311374,
0.0064018099,
0.0023271355,
-0.0107554514,
0.0117541747,
0.0174717084,
-0.0456801578,
0.0677440241,
-0.0179492291,
-0.0114094242,
-0.0238992032,
-0.116372861,
-0.037266098,
0.0351320207,
0.0069599045,
0.0273247622,
-0.0157610346,
-0.0372140668,
-0.0336186923,
-0.0646243766,
0.007650516,
1.967270611e-34,
-0.0051821223,
-0.0234756917,
-0.0367147885,
0.0580731854,
0.0238874089,
-0.0385868549,
-0.0326488093,
-0.0058982312,
0.0063980054,
-0.0245148875,
-0.0064613498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07270v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07270v2 | Open-ended VQA benchmarking of Vision-Language models by exploiting Classification datasets and their semantic hierarchy | 2024-02-11T18:26:18 | 2024-05-05T20:34:28 | Simon Ging, María A. Bravo, Thomas Brox | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The evaluation of text-generative vision-language models is a challenging yet
crucial endeavor. By addressing the limitations of existing Visual Question
Answering (VQA) benchmarks and proposing innovative evaluation methodologies,
our research seeks to advance our understanding of these models' capabilities.
We propose a novel VQA benchmark based on well-known visual classification
datasets which allows a granular evaluation of text-generative vision-language
models and their comparison with discriminative vision-language models. To
improve the assessment of coarse answers on fine-grained classification tasks,
we suggest using the semantic hierarchy of the label space to ask automatically
generated follow-up questions about the ground-truth category. Finally, we
compare traditional NLP and LLM-based metrics for the problem of evaluating
model predictions given ground-truth answers. We perform a human evaluation
study upon which we base our decision on the final metric. We apply our
benchmark to a suite of vision-language models and show a detailed comparison
of their abilities on object, action, and attribute classification. Our
contributions aim to lay the foundation for more precise and meaningful
assessments, facilitating targeted progress in the exciting field of
vision-language modeling. | [
0.0496060736,
0.0675688908,
-0.0077994349,
0.0506463721,
-0.0195734054,
0.0168470088,
-0.00256741,
0.008928936,
0.0112878811,
-0.0907470509,
-0.0192065202,
-0.0210613776,
0.0121020563,
0.0204842146,
0.0420732684,
-0.0435368605,
0.0181128625,
-0.0346899405,
-0.0028772196,
0.0089804986,
0.0180643648,
-0.01573647,
0.0182701983,
0.0413161889,
-0.0133379558,
-0.0264229476,
0.023801418,
0.0179239158,
0.025284702,
-0.0119020417,
-0.0117025329,
0.0264039226,
0.0403106697,
-0.015491154,
0.0000017398,
-0.0239384919,
0.0565089472,
0.0069607594,
0.0065940726,
0.0178648271,
-0.0058727874,
-0.0098601757,
0.0579764917,
-0.0070818579,
-0.0397482738,
-0.0260155071,
0.0475337803,
0.0163798332,
0.061572656,
0.0044389302,
-0.0191830918,
-0.0217889063,
0.0278856456,
-0.021781167,
0.0381855071,
-0.0681116506,
0.0179150142,
0.0568467081,
-0.0152782016,
-0.0008255577,
-0.0453159213,
0.0255412366,
0.0269016661,
0.0092827305,
0.0197134316,
0.0363601223,
-0.0309854653,
-0.0164755099,
-0.0115597267,
0.0746772066,
0.0066780192,
-0.0113859931,
-0.0204074103,
-0.0055624181,
0.0038499853,
0.0114586446,
-0.0451448932,
0.0396299176,
0.0018431052,
-0.0078788502,
-0.0230995938,
0.0228603501,
-0.0245670006,
0.0081530381,
0.0219879039,
-0.0005295873,
0.0269109979,
0.0180505738,
0.0016027655,
0.0288235266,
-0.044928927,
-0.0699614212,
-0.0783869699,
0.0414444841,
-0.0130684422,
-0.0102894548,
-0.0401484929,
0.0207475722,
-0.0071047419,
-0.0334736072,
0.0728895888,
0.0104733156,
-0.0512178726,
0.0507934317,
-0.0273259971,
0.1060789749,
-0.0110954884,
0.0304410886,
-0.0333824605,
-0.0410149805,
-0.0254744105,
-0.0142722856,
-0.0288794525,
0.0068398989,
-0.0277198311,
-0.03912903,
-0.0226441305,
0.0001340584,
-0.031137282,
-0.0194072183,
0.0223191977,
0.0554275289,
-0.0105258813,
0.0138467643,
-0.0941509232,
0.0111935101,
-0.0355672166,
0.0245400555,
-0.0065941494,
-0.0479808524,
0.0122857084,
0.0424425229,
-0.0028788068,
-0.0076089837,
0.0173533764,
0.0720859244,
-0.0275362898,
-0.0391294174,
-0.0099184737,
-0.0239978395,
-0.0114254085,
-0.0401806086,
0.0163903516,
-0.0667016953,
0.0171537343,
-0.0009609847,
-0.022621749,
-0.0170128755,
0.010908314,
0.0285516996,
-0.0130757615,
0.0606562495,
0.0062778462,
0.0047961688,
0.0236094464,
0.0057320409,
0.0141788274,
0.062047068,
0.0276816636,
0.035911195,
0.051122386,
0.0055613276,
0.048299592,
0.0352594033,
-0.0179301295,
-0.0074752267,
-0.0612236895,
0.0424949192,
-0.015566309,
0.0373513885,
0.0131713375,
0.0521803312,
-0.0091011012,
-0.0713577271,
0.0453486033,
0.0640311763,
-0.0102670658,
-0.0484841764,
0.033156082,
-0.0080586411,
0.0153811621,
0.0020125075,
-0.0326409228,
0.0666438863,
-0.0074522109,
-0.000635465,
0.0001841235,
-0.0053983796,
-0.0478961244,
-0.0545930788,
-0.0189884342,
0.0131776528,
0.0076569184,
0.0429065377,
0.024249142,
0.0271593314,
-0.0196981169,
0.0005882411,
0.0091871377,
-0.0227941405,
0.008987722,
-0.064116247,
0.0289385784,
0.0460091531,
0.0376501456,
0.0142065631,
-0.0134543953,
0.0284870211,
0.0328549184,
0.0358386822,
-0.014703298,
-0.0111565152,
0.024926858,
-0.0182053074,
-0.0279250257,
-0.0210910402,
-0.0010581753,
-0.0260588564,
0.0368478969,
-0.0435571782,
0.0007104058,
-0.0838855878,
-0.0202734638,
0.0500276759,
0.0378679521,
-0.0018643952,
-0.0091156242,
0.0236351937,
-0.0153145296,
-0.0246836115,
-0.0153940404,
0.0072609354,
0.0291059613,
-0.0467139855,
0.0031169895,
-0.0314497501,
-0.0112851048,
-0.0158667378,
0.0189745147,
-0.0596117452,
-0.0145587809,
0.0443742722,
-0.0400643572,
0.000233011,
-0.0048136064,
-0.0376752838,
-0.0341493152,
-0.0498908833,
-0.0189446118,
0.0194189008,
0.0020245945,
-0.0516009293,
0.0714364573,
-0.023316687,
0.0347961113,
-0.0032915939,
0.0210102834,
0.0408624522,
-0.0306760557,
-0.0053759036,
-0.0017181815,
-0.0063652173,
0.0251397807,
0.0217708889,
0.00892621,
-0.0371220522,
-0.0095678344,
-0.0663453788,
-0.0231461674,
-0.0171797052,
-0.0164635852,
0.0084709832,
-0.0287718829,
0.0114978785,
-0.0248058066,
-0.0666606501,
0.0457097627,
-0.0000754819,
0.01047704,
0.0612885915,
0.0031139331,
0.0094412919,
-0.0278572384,
-0.0015682802,
0.0286462829,
0.1054931507,
0.0269425437,
0.0272008162,
-0.0190207101,
-0.0011029331,
-0.0671807751,
0.0543540008,
-0.0106598884,
-0.0222385805,
0.0452388264,
-0.0059538991,
0.0193659328,
0.0803451464,
0.0185394976,
0.0208397806,
0.0124432109,
0.0104396008,
-0.0155805144,
-0.0378093049,
-0.0122325597,
-0.0769973472,
0.0000889646,
-0.0564900115,
-0.0322475694,
0.0384417251,
-0.0068681692,
0.0008697112,
-0.0820325315,
0.0475722142,
0.0068262201,
-0.0564029366,
-0.0800807402,
0.0111047411,
0.0101431394,
0.0819965899,
-0.0474118032,
-0.0744872838,
0.049878668,
-0.0387735479,
-0.0037108923,
0.0414379574,
0.0066628535,
-0.0489397161,
0.1134260222,
0.035691347,
0.0051676673,
-0.0152793722,
0.0131626688,
-0.0806644261,
-0.0304855611,
0.0132439975,
-0.0147769386,
0.0537503622,
-0.055640325,
0.0254648961,
-0.0300585013,
-0.0048228786,
-0.0450666994,
-0.0109031415,
-0.0389629342,
0.0220792424,
-0.0636262745,
-0.0230216272,
-0.0015351328,
0.0316603072,
0.0124766091,
-0.0119498437,
-0.0131832995,
-0.0119907949,
0.0017303819,
0.0668614954,
0.0929123014,
0.0476453826,
-0.0214250814,
-0.0163106993,
-0.0100761149,
0.0698433295,
0.0133368829,
0.038147442,
-0.0477513149,
0.0154343499,
0.0281597357,
0.04995526,
0.0037228798,
0.0331777036,
0.02377389,
-0.0297778901,
-0.0099680517,
0.0731414706,
0.0360142291,
0.0202018581,
0.0053934855,
0.0057840259,
0.0478261448,
0.0563618243,
0.0139450328,
-0.0785809159,
-0.0434801392,
-0.04137104,
0.0104392739,
0.0022554961,
-0.0086642681,
-0.0076969182,
-0.0966102034,
0.0647004917,
-0.0365418009,
-0.0208430253,
-0.0342962705,
0.0207301546,
0.0067528947,
-0.01282435,
-0.0509808101,
-0.022200387,
0.0047816988,
0.0147681981,
0.0074287467,
-0.0091569712,
0.0048493734,
0.0620874017,
-0.0625942349,
-0.0038085256,
0.048258353,
-0.0072212741,
-0.0066194995,
-0.0714416131,
0.0132056614,
-0.0625644252,
0.0090384157,
0.0309717506,
0.0419354662,
-0.0331212394,
-0.0509718172,
0.0110158026,
0.0016577636,
-0.0039746794,
-0.01954679,
-0.0211323071,
0.0114894398,
-0.0045796232,
-0.0215227995,
-0.0376254804,
0.0087369587,
-0.0384884812,
0.0619965009,
0.0405001678,
-0.0493008047,
-0.034845598,
-0.0091746198,
0.0088252407,
-0.0388947539,
-0.0584848113,
0.0122819701,
0.0643279627,
-0.0022508199,
-0.0872189701,
-0.015217429,
0.0491148718,
0.0219756886,
-0.055376526,
-0.0112859001,
-0.0325822644,
0.0135233887,
-0.0588642657,
0.0586641654,
-0.0086092558,
0.027791772,
-0.0507334955,
-0.0101533178,
0.0299479645,
-0.0324264541,
-0.043781843,
0.0160061643,
-0.0688038021,
-0.0067149904,
-0.0442139879,
0.0605975501,
0.0118062207,
-0.0005557069,
0.0174366198,
-0.0716942027,
0.0048035202,
0.0394643061,
0.0316156186,
0.0534668416,
-0.0268992018,
-0.0115110846,
0.0017628925,
0.0219176542,
-0.0593533665,
0.0074281702,
0.0240895655,
0.017114019,
0.002253664,
-0.0636583567,
0.0163483974,
0.0127221616,
0.029569447,
-0.0142046493,
-0.0030233441,
-0.0028218969,
0.0051488746,
0.0049457923,
-0.0101212421,
-0.0908948481,
-0.0153910285,
0.0330534875,
0.008695391,
-0.005075986,
0.0065509491,
-0.0238577165,
0.0382624194,
-0.0461504683,
-0.0347583927,
0.0391911454,
-0.0001839127,
-0.0234772228,
0.031484291,
-0.0356074087,
-0.0343898833,
-0.0345661826,
0.056342274,
0.0195648205,
0.0558696687,
0.0368826091,
-0.0000648693,
-0.0044503836,
0.033050932,
-0.0454540215,
-0.0559359789,
-0.0239169784,
0.0391614884,
0.0178303849,
0.0261657536,
-0.0127297994,
0.0047714706,
-0.0206496138,
-0.0117686437,
0.0124327205,
0.0095120044,
-0.0384935252,
0.0956438556,
0.0387175493,
0.0009253131,
-0.0057697138,
0.0667943135,
0.0741181001,
0.0177300777,
-0.0186443608,
0.0149661554,
-0.0107945362,
-0.0341580138,
0.0165237673,
-0.0260525066,
0.031581942,
0.059558738,
-0.0631449223,
-0.0730241686,
-0.003541799,
0.06302616,
0.0084586125,
0.0167563092,
0.0540417694,
0.0489312112,
0.0399400294,
-0.0163816027,
-0.0291487072,
-0.0313576609,
-0.0286220573,
0.0099319723,
-0.0272246916,
-5.791871153e-33,
-0.039478641,
-0.0390289128,
0.0416882932,
0.0000528655,
-0.0028781572,
0.0135973105,
-0.0088056158,
0.0050053746,
-0.0393865891,
0.0067227739,
0.0156664364,
-0.0146226613,
-0.020816246,
0.039396625,
-0.0293786377,
-0.0332685411,
-0.0064698081,
-0.0162919648,
-0.0341070406,
-0.000113737,
-0.0173782632,
-0.0247675385,
0.0137486011,
-0.0369844586,
-0.0109683909,
-0.0098178713,
-0.0204020217,
0.0332984328,
0.0089974394,
0.0812872797,
-0.026643075,
0.0273684524,
0.0362255946,
0.0066745612,
-0.0108074443,
0.0205922797,
-0.0460106023,
-0.0136562213,
0.0481395759,
0.0002139291,
-0.1151165292,
0.0382479019,
0.0105129676,
-0.0001309555,
-0.0190727301,
-0.0537523776,
0.0507313572,
-0.0215324741,
-0.0094633047,
-0.0197611302,
-0.0339522474,
-0.0005052044,
0.0054782671,
-0.0490129329,
0.004941734,
0.0352084897,
0.0096746078,
0.0457258895,
-0.0176765844,
0.0147637092,
-0.0092715267,
0.025298832,
0.0688923821,
0.0678780377,
0.00220435,
0.0534437671,
0.0307074767,
-0.0089197084,
-0.0241254233,
-0.0298544616,
0.0008998066,
0.0565059073,
0.0823510066,
0.068327114,
0.002898426,
0.0438611656,
-0.0655706078,
0.0472315997,
-0.0867807046,
0.0469897352,
-0.0084488066,
-0.0010182413,
0.0117872898,
-0.0125650354,
-0.0895500034,
0.0251878779,
-0.0570645519,
0.0379069299,
0.0748132318,
0.0080773905,
-0.0066582491,
0.0314609706,
0.0381058678,
-0.053412918,
0.0193455443,
0.0256570838,
-0.0310158655,
0.0592354015,
0.0323966593,
0.0409624837,
-0.0260040909,
0.0273815636,
0.0688300282,
0.0012759116,
-0.0011296408,
0.0039133443,
0.016418023,
0.0017518591,
-0.0410662554,
0.0090166396,
-0.0359173603,
-0.0007839077,
-0.0501947664,
0.0019757652,
0.0046202973,
0.0141583653,
-0.0545648262,
0.0347108915,
-0.0476278178,
-0.0150230248,
-0.0001611093,
-0.0109794056,
0.0179462284,
0.0343411341,
-0.0291339606,
0.0368670151,
-0.0309362765,
-0.0397888198,
0.0092308288,
-0.0204634741,
-0.0064770877,
0.0540438443,
2.308e-7,
0.055542808,
0.0060758856,
0.0107655851,
0.0509957038,
-0.0001547839,
0.0467031896,
-0.0062519829,
0.0226480793,
0.0279287174,
-0.0626952201,
-0.0173084307,
0.0584958941,
0.0365064554,
-0.0363609307,
0.0042711226,
0.063072376,
-0.0413974412,
-0.0056529245,
-0.0263145529,
-0.0095548062,
0.0737660527,
0.0606892817,
-0.0328670703,
-0.0078633502,
0.0225033518,
-0.0662160143,
0.0953681469,
-0.0338904299,
0.0034415496,
-0.0124210464,
-0.0034641598,
0.0253251512,
0.0170445926,
0.038603235,
0.0090860948,
-0.0377475433,
0.0712044761,
0.0077240644,
-0.0229597744,
-0.044638183,
-0.039286904,
0.0116895046,
-0.0034639454,
-0.0678899065,
0.0845536962,
-0.0482682288,
-0.0099635366,
-0.0235543046,
-0.0344554111,
0.0256203189,
0.0358892418,
-0.0102407271,
-0.0400989093,
0.0002350658,
0.0442284495,
-0.0154462242,
-0.0180496909,
-0.0613153949,
0.0003313053,
-0.0226393268,
-0.03330791,
-0.0342641845,
-0.0483197719,
0.005352017,
-0.0061257258,
-0.0182279963,
-0.0782546923,
1.638519165e-34,
0.0192976557,
0.0199037902,
0.0092086457,
-0.0055505028,
0.0232884064,
-0.0161874872,
-0.0158838946,
-0.0198749527,
-0.0118501289,
-0.077577129,
0.0036398589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07262v1 | Low-Resource Counterspeech Generation for Indic Languages: The Case of Bengali and Hindi | 2024-02-11T18:09:50 | 2024-02-11T18:09:50 | Mithun Das, Saurabh Kumar Pandey, Shivansh Sethi, Punyajoy Saha, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | With the rise of online abuse, the NLP community has begun investigating the
use of neural architectures to generate counterspeech that can "counter" the
vicious tone of such abusive speech and dilute/ameliorate their rippling effect
over the social network. However, most of the efforts so far have been
primarily focused on English. To bridge the gap for low-resource languages such
as Bengali and Hindi, we create a benchmark dataset of 5,062 abusive
speech/counterspeech pairs, of which 2,460 pairs are in Bengali and 2,602 pairs
are in Hindi. We implement several baseline models considering various
interlingual transfer mechanisms with different configurations to generate
suitable counterspeech to set up an effective benchmark. We observe that the
monolingual setup yields the best performance. Further, using synthetic
transfer, language models can generate counterspeech to some extent;
specifically, we notice that transferability is better when languages belong to
the same language family. | [
0.0401312821,
0.0803004652,
-0.0436704271,
0.0384317189,
-0.0363876931,
-0.011095372,
0.0013044887,
-0.0230450388,
0.0065822625,
-0.0110939825,
-0.0207144041,
-0.0905991644,
-0.01094326,
0.049208086,
0.0355473533,
-0.0386565998,
0.0598201193,
0.0028436938,
0.0248083007,
-0.0042408677,
0.048317682,
0.0184174646,
-0.0329535231,
0.0227938481,
-0.0476585701,
0.0050781714,
0.0317066237,
-0.0163115449,
0.016148055,
-0.0505486391,
0.0342427865,
0.0463525876,
-0.0026264074,
0.043065846,
0.0000016243,
-0.0681056827,
-0.0040219659,
-0.0076758615,
-0.005002338,
-0.0336052217,
0.0571956523,
-0.0505588055,
-0.0211364832,
0.0332459919,
-0.0320990011,
0.0195648801,
0.0539285205,
0.0384868644,
0.0544944778,
0.1143213883,
-0.0265279934,
-0.0284432843,
0.0342427082,
0.0042206831,
-0.0324854963,
-0.004127997,
0.0146495923,
-0.0457213186,
-0.0258965436,
-0.0320420973,
-0.0227080137,
0.0065845465,
0.0178354811,
-0.0601986796,
0.0270259622,
-0.0216492135,
-0.0382792093,
-0.0066426112,
-0.0107346289,
0.0674305856,
-0.065420635,
-0.0109343929,
0.0229230113,
-0.0022648983,
0.005396802,
-0.0515047871,
-0.0439451672,
0.0039330083,
-0.0019472581,
0.0317271203,
0.0093506631,
0.0557007603,
0.0179793537,
0.0101935351,
0.08373411,
-0.0351067707,
0.0134869749,
-0.0059142173,
0.0063607492,
-0.0094313426,
-0.0122011527,
-0.0087650763,
0.0364924967,
0.026690349,
-0.033461269,
0.0047439057,
-0.04917017,
-0.0567645319,
-0.0014584621,
-0.0862233713,
0.0277483556,
0.0353619382,
-0.0194253623,
-0.0066433554,
-0.009336412,
0.0206700303,
-0.0147649078,
0.0047967122,
-0.0030897388,
-0.013116505,
-0.0226552077,
-0.0062549235,
-0.0041677677,
0.0110335695,
-0.006034703,
0.0113353292,
-0.0671522766,
0.0018672957,
-0.0643770769,
-0.0304638986,
-0.0089930948,
-0.0084169069,
-0.0079974607,
-0.0014956129,
0.0228869282,
0.0046457388,
-0.0392180197,
0.0136139998,
-0.0138965202,
-0.1280520707,
-0.0110853519,
0.014895658,
-0.0527126864,
-0.0204669107,
-0.0003935199,
0.0811529756,
-0.011005071,
-0.0094831996,
-0.0397411548,
-0.0239084847,
-0.0210657474,
-0.0456534214,
-0.0068522431,
-0.0781294107,
0.0502685457,
-0.0379320122,
-0.024840435,
-0.0353009589,
0.0166885164,
0.017878253,
-0.0371304192,
0.0489073731,
0.0042409296,
0.0069001461,
0.0104942415,
0.0343893357,
0.0200940445,
0.06267827,
0.0177004132,
-0.0347837582,
0.0616630502,
-0.0298324768,
-0.0001616407,
0.0453205705,
0.0459676683,
-0.0024300464,
-0.0359020457,
-0.0171154086,
-0.0148916254,
-0.0151440278,
0.038728822,
0.0350918435,
-0.0310922563,
-0.0359381177,
0.0588554442,
0.0442786552,
-0.0526305921,
0.0744184852,
0.0216198303,
-0.0131673058,
-0.0250628218,
0.0105697671,
-0.0249509457,
0.0118758595,
-0.0231297966,
-0.0553982034,
0.0350778736,
0.0335618369,
-0.0319814235,
0.0024577605,
0.0103242453,
0.0240787901,
-0.0117750261,
-0.0310698785,
0.0310970265,
0.0481675044,
0.015118584,
0.0041060131,
0.0529469065,
-0.0402136594,
0.0341370218,
-0.0228196159,
-0.0238484051,
0.0588513911,
0.0145248063,
-0.0023095037,
0.0141986618,
-0.0479102172,
-0.0366175957,
0.0711460486,
0.0343361273,
-0.0024800943,
0.0287465099,
-0.018717356,
0.0424376354,
0.0408991165,
-0.0097370092,
0.0267079808,
0.0145701077,
0.0154250553,
-0.0231303331,
0.0597214513,
-0.0331242271,
0.0120201809,
-0.0002707399,
-0.032780949,
0.0186806675,
0.0042385738,
0.0821034536,
0.0332122855,
-0.0175086781,
-0.0440157577,
0.0239935163,
-0.0197664015,
-0.0228636451,
0.0303829107,
-0.0362449549,
-0.0395418331,
0.0439749472,
-0.0481552668,
0.0045546028,
0.0439248681,
0.0044012535,
-0.0269728433,
0.0926386341,
-0.0266930629,
0.0205968674,
-0.0316911936,
0.0023918473,
-0.0318445042,
0.058865834,
-0.0062417323,
0.0325426422,
-0.0018593004,
-0.0117164841,
0.0208980925,
-0.0172945634,
0.0330970809,
-0.0250406638,
-0.0724198818,
-0.0003836176,
-0.0285791289,
0.0099339113,
0.0053148344,
0.0130012548,
-0.0416639224,
-0.0090292534,
-0.0739914998,
-0.0008062954,
0.0095135039,
0.0079079373,
0.0467404053,
0.0113505395,
-0.0088429963,
0.0132300016,
-0.0235292986,
-0.0250580534,
0.0858785734,
0.0438836589,
0.0308998451,
-0.0371036492,
-0.02386095,
-0.047211308,
-0.0100950068,
-0.0292875133,
0.0557237752,
-0.0165235363,
-0.0982147157,
0.0052377884,
-0.0169991385,
-0.0262974538,
0.0327065103,
-0.0130249374,
-0.0787048787,
-0.0059554805,
0.0093263304,
-0.0048974152,
0.0183544978,
0.0071755871,
0.0400074162,
0.0070708301,
-0.0248463284,
-0.0377794057,
-0.0264152698,
-0.0028071424,
-0.005317206,
-0.006437337,
-0.0349369906,
-0.0150487134,
0.0649701729,
0.0311969873,
-0.0022068969,
-0.0199755915,
-0.0201087315,
-0.0096146353,
-0.0299878493,
-0.0446007475,
-0.0383505672,
-0.0290119629,
0.009511875,
-0.0163671281,
-0.0389940292,
0.0467901602,
-0.0120529244,
0.0325359218,
-0.0286916215,
-0.0175302532,
0.0199880786,
0.0360405184,
0.0025316954,
0.0403677188,
-0.0206109714,
-0.0208383743,
-0.0032753677,
-0.0107209003,
0.0297232959,
-0.0286884438,
-0.0321031511,
-0.0518248267,
0.0074529541,
-0.0120303752,
-0.0364154801,
-0.0451109223,
-0.0417042673,
0.029886093,
0.0035495104,
0.0335198119,
0.0008707122,
0.0196523815,
0.0374877676,
0.0311388448,
-0.0228768103,
-0.007720368,
0.0024172473,
0.0128502594,
0.0295377057,
0.0536713526,
0.0014026221,
0.050742384,
0.0216653608,
0.0190082043,
0.0421508178,
0.0318241641,
0.0239852332,
-0.0039017589,
0.0316656381,
0.0182465259,
0.0219358839,
0.0119464686,
0.0074401554,
0.0338293649,
0.0189582594,
-0.0527319275,
0.0531141199,
-0.0055356533,
-0.0378072299,
0.0051849755,
-0.0325596705,
-0.0059516733,
-0.0065427846,
0.0275093,
-0.0690456331,
0.0168827586,
-0.0019588459,
-0.0297821984,
-0.0731020421,
-0.0249214154,
-0.0513698347,
-0.1493403614,
-0.0111707617,
0.0003031224,
-0.0606360212,
-0.0300681032,
0.0090697948,
0.0115053896,
0.0278494693,
0.0365771577,
0.0068368572,
0.0027779045,
-0.0191072989,
0.0412254706,
-0.039063625,
-0.0387662128,
-0.0202742182,
-0.0434629135,
0.0890621841,
0.0240839887,
0.0202450268,
-0.0349487402,
0.0135213416,
0.065749675,
-0.0090589263,
-0.0347865447,
-0.004869767,
0.0764811635,
0.0166142713,
-0.0472506993,
-0.0056594987,
0.051409144,
-0.009301913,
-0.0015847217,
-0.0038028888,
0.0697169527,
0.0566718802,
-0.0007943108,
-0.0111590447,
0.0319063291,
0.0264100078,
0.0406289361,
0.0421530828,
-0.0271656793,
-0.0005434945,
-0.0398568884,
-0.0401414707,
-0.0460401177,
-0.0616276376,
0.0157708451,
-0.0297102928,
-0.0809911862,
-0.0697531104,
-0.034174107,
-0.0170610789,
0.0363023877,
0.0395532884,
0.0074266358,
0.0215656664,
-0.0444914736,
-0.0202211756,
-0.0296116769,
-0.0362029746,
0.0696993172,
-0.0329228081,
0.0284889024,
-0.0123663405,
-0.00448807,
-0.0289512314,
0.0111435922,
-0.0463773832,
-0.0833597407,
0.0182851069,
0.0774547681,
0.0255220532,
-0.0045759133,
-0.0431208871,
-0.0859370977,
0.0038011365,
0.0595096722,
-0.0513835847,
-0.0133204358,
0.0344176516,
0.0109054437,
0.0093233986,
0.0395871475,
-0.0064549535,
0.0409994647,
0.0559657738,
0.0045741568,
-0.0251230318,
-0.0063524139,
-0.007842686,
0.0089320652,
0.0255805347,
-0.0292074252,
-0.0312050153,
-0.015728401,
-0.0265615527,
-0.0076624304,
-0.009343246,
-0.0143410675,
-0.0177189335,
0.0343724973,
0.0407993421,
-0.0285918191,
-0.0319278277,
-0.0435530134,
0.0380313955,
-0.0198390242,
0.0001798467,
0.0354254171,
0.0743738785,
-0.0063451459,
0.0267214254,
-0.0024563705,
-0.0260491073,
0.0184537172,
0.0249204636,
-0.0071620899,
0.0018731492,
0.0112770088,
0.0212269686,
0.0307056159,
-0.0093573816,
0.0134599563,
0.0304665435,
-0.0227513183,
-0.0275957305,
0.0474155135,
-0.0104759438,
0.0721153542,
0.0456212834,
0.0069323019,
-0.0120135611,
0.0342276469,
-0.0608780235,
-0.0359766521,
0.0086609591,
0.0145598277,
-0.0121800713,
0.0413588248,
0.0636865795,
-0.0391611829,
0.0076772301,
0.0623793639,
-0.0371716991,
-0.015186117,
-0.0072399527,
-0.0080270628,
0.0231863931,
0.0248971041,
0.0109187979,
-0.0529132262,
-0.0550373308,
0.0077769556,
-0.0577918366,
0.0482350215,
0.0047527989,
0.0245359838,
0.0081738355,
-0.0003547599,
0.0382569581,
-0.0178934839,
0.0401505567,
-0.0118551571,
-0.007853765,
-0.0034339232,
-5.381001715e-33,
-0.0378337651,
-0.0585830994,
-0.0065318355,
-0.0024905971,
-0.0251428131,
-0.019117916,
-0.017110208,
-0.0120916376,
-0.0240390319,
0.0182588231,
-0.0032225286,
0.0025328475,
0.013358701,
-0.0039949068,
0.009137488,
-0.0151945576,
0.0238119904,
0.0274809804,
0.0039446447,
0.0318126194,
0.0803706124,
0.0116623743,
0.0811590776,
-0.0559226498,
0.0134533355,
-0.0045033162,
-0.0183154065,
0.0307835024,
0.0017072364,
0.0327498242,
-0.0289777368,
0.0768539459,
0.0343220606,
-0.0013284135,
0.0051907427,
0.0657695159,
-0.0468514748,
-0.0423281379,
0.0540353246,
0.0211875681,
0.0636824965,
-0.0064565856,
0.043025773,
-0.0073497104,
-0.0444009416,
0.0347761288,
0.0184550378,
-0.0205679554,
-0.0095378086,
-0.0430929884,
-0.0677162036,
0.0426309705,
-0.0143269971,
0.017447114,
-0.0495959148,
0.0587561317,
-0.0083010122,
-0.0447169915,
-0.1019760147,
0.0147533948,
-0.0026328051,
0.0269625168,
0.0114849638,
-0.0201075766,
-0.0237814337,
0.0534927249,
0.0541947894,
-0.0100710262,
0.0327370279,
0.0358748138,
0.0138796046,
0.019727217,
0.0531499349,
0.084221825,
0.065086998,
-0.0750533566,
-0.0629555285,
0.0023313323,
0.0503575727,
0.0259939004,
0.0404067934,
-0.0019094924,
-0.0468036421,
-0.0408897586,
0.0300487205,
-0.0845208094,
-0.034133222,
-0.0333545506,
0.0410471708,
-0.027577037,
0.0257661939,
0.018412251,
0.0424351767,
-0.0302227419,
0.0085104899,
0.013015802,
-0.0364240818,
0.0320749171,
0.0340791754,
0.0353045315,
-0.0701757371,
-0.0372684263,
-0.0119635267,
0.0138712013,
0.0300913826,
-0.0137041751,
0.0921479538,
0.0037567529,
-0.0736970678,
0.0006954996,
-0.0400569104,
0.088685371,
-0.0226155147,
0.0648223758,
-0.0067774258,
0.0065698572,
-0.0461759046,
-0.030718429,
0.0383324362,
-0.0185573939,
-0.0129877096,
0.0377793275,
-0.0077034384,
-0.005308988,
-0.018837681,
0.0191281158,
-0.033250507,
0.0203159861,
0.0077702408,
-0.0792433545,
-0.0053595733,
-0.0334554501,
2.533e-7,
-0.0552938692,
0.0297927763,
0.0299296752,
-0.0363663323,
0.0197865274,
-0.0031941403,
-0.0077154054,
0.0595730506,
-0.0068759532,
0.0050813914,
-0.0688201189,
0.0215564724,
0.0381039679,
0.0887737721,
-0.0424083844,
-0.0021173002,
-0.1185999811,
-0.0063103577,
-0.0093730986,
-0.0132425474,
-0.0201612748,
0.0154388901,
0.0435061306,
-0.0379377604,
0.0112744542,
-0.0160486884,
0.0424859338,
-0.0081343399,
-0.0430127159,
0.0066935322,
0.0293171871,
0.0077444878,
0.0031576729,
0.0170904975,
-0.0143071944,
0.0436592288,
0.0055513675,
0.0337298326,
-0.0059641562,
-0.0066937055,
-0.0048489296,
-0.0113411201,
-0.0069437749,
-0.0229631197,
0.0334292203,
0.032615684,
-0.0255425517,
-0.0202809963,
-0.0255424958,
-0.0299567021,
0.0271415077,
-0.0510941446,
-0.0265100878,
0.0104498789,
0.0640289858,
-0.0322830565,
-0.0532681495,
-0.0362620838,
-0.0163168591,
0.0099320048,
-0.0043189623,
-0.0476404652,
-0.0118336389,
0.0045199138,
0.0194641612,
0.0083273258,
0.0631381422,
1.951655363e-34,
0.0554506667,
-0.0127634415,
0.0475131944,
-0.0451104157,
0.03875833,
0.0293970034,
-0.003800754,
-0.0033485459,
0.0936131999,
-0.0215775203,
-0.0115365582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07255v1 | American Sign Language Video to Text Translation | 2024-02-11T17:46:33 | 2024-02-11T17:46:33 | Parsheeta Roy, Ji-Eun Han, Srishti Chouhan, Bhaavanaa Thumu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Sign language to text is a crucial technology that can break down
communication barriers for individuals with hearing difficulties. We replicate
and try to improve on a recently published study. We evaluate models using BLEU
and rBLEU metrics to ensure translation quality. During our ablation study, we
found that the model's performance is significantly influenced by optimizers,
activation functions, and label smoothing. Further research aims to refine
visual feature capturing, enhance decoder utilization, and integrate
pre-trained decoders for better translation outcomes. Our source code is
available to facilitate replication of our results and encourage future
research. | [
-0.0550568141,
-0.0043418752,
0.0007713998,
0.016696386,
0.001008348,
0.0118801482,
0.064323023,
-0.0085658105,
-0.0229056012,
-0.0304842703,
-0.0193241853,
-0.0206754226,
0.0636921823,
0.0717822015,
-0.0156865716,
-0.0902736038,
0.0003800987,
-0.016316168,
0.0094094826,
-0.0173054822,
0.0310530365,
0.0199225694,
-0.0634087101,
0.0339444503,
-0.0747730285,
0.0062278961,
0.0235750135,
0.0418313369,
0.0409381986,
-0.0472537987,
-0.0903501064,
0.0127577279,
0.0199775416,
-0.0113231493,
0.0000021372,
-0.037608061,
0.0284258947,
0.0210426468,
0.0341662578,
0.0470472425,
0.0606532544,
-0.0961863995,
-0.0246369708,
0.0460725352,
-0.0114342449,
-0.0507288687,
0.055607371,
0.0607740879,
-0.0051840506,
-0.0154389935,
-0.0127533609,
-0.0095482944,
0.0232800432,
-0.0258317348,
0.0210485607,
-0.0235193074,
-0.0219944324,
-0.0082212985,
-0.0017134344,
-0.0374033973,
-0.0626111329,
0.1099402979,
0.0382803939,
-0.0604811534,
-0.0047617741,
0.0278629307,
0.0082020573,
-0.0096926987,
-0.0248756129,
0.0480948873,
-0.0021551831,
0.024943091,
-0.0222304948,
-0.0160029903,
0.0118463747,
-0.0139903221,
-0.0299552195,
0.023403341,
0.0238045752,
-0.0158785507,
-0.0488030463,
0.0500887632,
0.042112682,
-0.0664008856,
0.0326241478,
-0.0532241091,
0.0354276299,
-0.0162101742,
-0.00992167,
0.0090962239,
0.0255215075,
-0.0141616184,
0.0907650813,
-0.0149028562,
0.0334195904,
-0.0085921474,
-0.0314168371,
0.0007651866,
-0.0668666959,
-0.0167118963,
-0.0061248075,
0.0845705792,
-0.0460794531,
0.0005758475,
0.0080739707,
0.0429720469,
-0.0168616306,
0.0389983542,
-0.0234204866,
0.0335818306,
-0.0334894359,
0.0112323705,
-0.0200011265,
-0.0188628957,
0.0311572533,
-0.0161819048,
-0.0260044765,
-0.0261863023,
0.0241358597,
-0.0484346747,
0.0494904183,
0.0149503062,
-0.0271756556,
-0.0108271996,
-0.0295045469,
0.0541895032,
-0.0065333582,
0.0415682234,
-0.0337509811,
-0.0600860715,
0.0137303267,
0.0170012526,
0.0346166156,
-0.0167223383,
-0.0185226146,
-0.0089794677,
-0.034322381,
-0.0350269005,
0.0161096603,
0.0604123101,
-0.0458098575,
0.0049255653,
-0.0098486682,
-0.0434963778,
0.0485038124,
-0.0006946194,
0.0119847236,
-0.058897227,
-0.0064129117,
-0.0306759384,
0.0340827554,
0.0317558236,
-0.0120695932,
0.0020013372,
0.0345267467,
-0.0148733389,
-0.0226731822,
0.0183670409,
0.0383082181,
0.0106631601,
-0.0037574868,
-0.0045833816,
0.0114554754,
0.0753272399,
-0.038328737,
0.0172979143,
-0.0071672355,
-0.0430123471,
-0.0028128312,
0.0233810432,
0.0078425771,
0.0437894799,
-0.0340190418,
-0.0059096692,
0.0488194004,
0.0695266053,
0.0173959136,
-0.0228864755,
0.0121809281,
0.0191418063,
0.0088208234,
-0.0469020046,
0.0270292256,
0.0410554484,
0.0277325474,
-0.0104034757,
-0.0034026613,
0.0314669758,
-0.0414967872,
-0.0389701165,
-0.0071042241,
-0.0546966568,
0.0272696596,
0.0241939463,
0.0442945585,
0.0276186168,
-0.0342354365,
-0.0043772999,
-0.0354588218,
-0.0318463035,
0.0357479975,
0.0024071948,
-0.0549448468,
0.0223381817,
0.0157158319,
0.0294507071,
0.0344400182,
-0.0187844038,
-0.0099261077,
0.0350298248,
0.0190258864,
0.0312694833,
0.0502794795,
-0.0390834659,
-0.030604342,
0.0570169501,
-0.0048305537,
0.0334019698,
-0.0815117061,
0.0687594637,
0.0059991828,
-0.0283927135,
-0.0147446748,
0.0421393439,
0.0161497816,
-0.0111174723,
0.0248990338,
-0.010115914,
0.03680069,
0.0399437509,
-0.0143565508,
-0.0197318792,
0.0016714782,
-0.0527839102,
0.036211554,
0.067403622,
-0.043151658,
-0.0520464629,
0.0346220508,
-0.0597869307,
-0.019761147,
0.0266884286,
0.0333770476,
-0.0303508993,
0.0325636826,
0.010495807,
0.0169167407,
-0.0310460851,
0.03059306,
-0.0068354141,
-0.0330499075,
0.0017248982,
-0.0267884396,
-0.0482437052,
-0.0494986288,
-0.0404873937,
-0.032146439,
0.0389036946,
-0.0714857802,
-0.0046505029,
0.0504344627,
-0.0252333693,
0.0088347094,
0.0366823263,
0.0378540494,
0.0209418889,
0.0017694678,
-0.0696917847,
-0.0114362938,
-0.0118935117,
0.0000461292,
0.0190516692,
-0.0117970463,
0.0112944823,
-0.0353092328,
-0.0116992118,
-0.004764644,
0.0155114466,
-0.0538891479,
-0.031102987,
-0.0035423315,
-0.0406267494,
-0.0138532482,
-0.0369104967,
0.0309934728,
0.006742632,
0.0256142784,
-0.0764870718,
-0.0193524919,
0.0014989873,
0.0344431251,
0.0131122964,
0.0020581509,
-0.0227864236,
0.0537190959,
0.0317922011,
-0.0446691327,
-0.0133684762,
-0.0253486801,
0.030184757,
0.0437732004,
0.0160562042,
-0.0100432308,
-0.0186528675,
-0.0153446095,
0.0218957663,
-0.0669482499,
-0.0399954617,
-0.0008328712,
0.0235994495,
0.0378505848,
0.0487628765,
-0.0841379836,
-0.0582378134,
-0.0322087258,
-0.0694692358,
-0.0480748788,
0.0056068064,
-0.0338579603,
0.0081445184,
-0.0088328309,
-0.0546876006,
-0.0004303544,
-0.0786698982,
-0.0255625509,
0.0142693846,
0.0478750877,
-0.0232090298,
0.0267156083,
-0.0037339565,
-0.0018693099,
-0.0752696544,
-0.0483646765,
-0.003963002,
0.0162032526,
0.0151840663,
-0.0087259328,
-0.0129307155,
-0.0431083888,
0.0081632966,
-0.012031205,
0.0279209781,
0.0178922508,
0.0469488427,
-0.0166902654,
-0.0224893205,
0.0141974334,
0.0030821669,
-0.0616940558,
0.0247345846,
0.0224747006,
0.0413668491,
0.0212693177,
0.0111346552,
-0.0333048627,
-0.0239479858,
-0.0042109047,
-0.0142337447,
-0.0228720009,
-0.0581839494,
0.0187358204,
0.0160818435,
-0.0262359288,
0.0105265593,
-0.0514233597,
0.0026676483,
0.0488698334,
0.0761882737,
-0.0233859252,
0.0580917373,
0.0529454872,
-0.0398870111,
0.0154077532,
0.0863206536,
-0.0017761765,
-0.0565817803,
-0.0207542945,
0.0066503058,
0.0330469087,
-0.0122134071,
-0.0280990824,
-0.0527296662,
-0.0538606644,
-0.0153308976,
0.0466232337,
0.0822073594,
0.0429913141,
-0.0055072177,
-0.0370600522,
0.0259606019,
0.0451698862,
-0.0651646554,
-0.0532871485,
0.0257337224,
-0.0112869488,
0.0283076391,
0.0588382147,
0.0107521815,
-0.0087706903,
0.0091803074,
0.0367777795,
-0.0370020792,
-0.0993563384,
0.0050070891,
-0.0132935047,
0.0257616378,
0.0716496333,
0.0102558099,
0.0124412291,
-0.0414908342,
0.019304743,
-0.0068545467,
0.0203519743,
-0.0199498162,
0.0192814581,
-0.0025073718,
-0.0276206248,
0.0113555649,
0.0338394605,
-0.0253526326,
0.0149908103,
0.0322809927,
0.0113566164,
-0.0374092832,
-0.0067756269,
0.0122591238,
-0.0374687873,
-0.0294420235,
0.0382430777,
-0.0124088796,
-0.0541076027,
-0.0274150874,
-0.0049568308,
0.0094272867,
-0.0038676332,
-0.0794498548,
0.0346388072,
-0.0618566312,
-0.0813756734,
-0.0273287017,
-0.0277565289,
0.0495363362,
0.0523254648,
0.0122924009,
0.0246021338,
0.0831062943,
0.028869357,
0.0149189271,
0.0653750151,
-0.0081889192,
0.0475184545,
-0.0645155832,
-0.0081582936,
-0.0693826824,
-0.040740151,
0.0194710195,
0.0199376307,
-0.0352359265,
-0.0188848376,
0.0239179097,
0.0179384816,
0.0149731934,
0.0374624953,
-0.00456915,
-0.040025901,
-0.0302452873,
0.0090171406,
0.0373825394,
0.0392612331,
-0.0043529216,
-0.0558476485,
-0.0127935931,
-0.0053640148,
0.0153641934,
0.0318162926,
-0.0148736127,
0.0238898229,
-0.0796267614,
-0.007525526,
-0.0248220712,
0.0281775258,
0.0193850826,
-0.0237998758,
-0.0451747924,
-0.0409285203,
0.0218982566,
-0.029218521,
0.0658708885,
-0.0772941038,
0.0130275385,
0.0657485649,
0.0108962487,
0.0309165027,
0.0239124186,
0.0049810228,
-0.0326827653,
0.0318289995,
0.0395373926,
-0.0163193848,
0.0334358364,
0.0004139139,
0.0264266673,
-0.0050996454,
0.0715401545,
-0.0073444759,
0.0059859068,
0.0061607952,
0.0376464836,
-0.019252006,
0.0231120214,
0.0699410886,
0.0251362007,
0.0644721985,
-0.0251524933,
-0.0233272389,
0.0021729528,
-0.0016010181,
0.035137713,
0.0618714765,
-0.0103851492,
0.0309887752,
-0.0520992503,
0.0367383286,
-0.0023801909,
-0.0273123719,
0.0584666543,
-0.0557452999,
-0.0058528413,
0.0009529702,
0.0065089907,
-0.0420431085,
-0.032180015,
-0.0588730387,
0.0334632508,
-0.0258118417,
-0.0223131254,
-0.0026668473,
-0.0026299804,
-0.0449543819,
0.0164407063,
-0.0175041594,
-0.0075926543,
-0.0097013274,
-0.0206044521,
0.0059284405,
0.0095017999,
0.0355947167,
-0.0294652469,
-0.0104529355,
0.0013030765,
0.0007961621,
-0.0734680071,
-0.0461586602,
-0.0050322735,
-0.0102088703,
-5.843731393e-33,
-0.0528947562,
-0.0423636138,
0.0072920714,
-0.0512789749,
-0.0090870447,
0.0194616131,
-0.0177368987,
0.0345541909,
-0.0022857967,
0.0216752943,
0.0372696705,
-0.0183249433,
0.0097773243,
0.0189228337,
-0.0273907203,
-0.0154056419,
0.0467466973,
-0.0135860145,
0.0001426526,
0.0104162488,
0.0139826313,
0.0081834514,
0.0450682081,
-0.1237246692,
-0.0203999672,
-0.00006013,
-0.0441242158,
-0.0156320594,
0.0273867827,
-0.0087421481,
-0.0209294911,
-0.0027987515,
-0.016438242,
0.0177974869,
-0.0093920985,
0.0038771406,
-0.0243314318,
0.0371927507,
-0.0191874858,
0.1031143814,
-0.0757559761,
0.0206534974,
-0.0077721877,
0.0160962772,
-0.0851713121,
-0.0112499492,
0.0257650837,
-0.0454077907,
-0.0387414508,
-0.0111499038,
-0.0246560816,
0.0430496112,
-0.0306247082,
-0.0198706612,
0.0546913147,
0.0105826603,
-0.0347100981,
-0.0256056003,
-0.0577314124,
0.0290673878,
0.0058480604,
0.0086776931,
0.1086163446,
-0.0506554358,
0.0168388486,
0.0186894313,
0.0299505144,
-0.0651106015,
0.034074448,
-0.0521098077,
0.0612302609,
0.0227876976,
0.0593158267,
0.057357125,
0.043500416,
-0.0422261879,
0.0047839745,
0.0206161365,
0.0166873485,
0.0490842275,
0.009779539,
0.0412732325,
0.0022413579,
-0.0009870663,
-0.071950525,
0.0409868918,
0.0106277838,
-0.0260621551,
0.0645458922,
0.0049786647,
0.0229049698,
-0.0287364963,
0.1015707105,
0.0228074957,
0.0217386503,
-0.026443623,
0.0064070453,
0.0586662889,
-0.003092393,
-0.0099251177,
-0.0556741059,
0.0025355548,
0.0729441345,
-0.0329867974,
0.0238620993,
-0.0311816111,
-0.029592555,
0.0298364256,
-0.0100014117,
0.0108214486,
-0.0244315565,
0.002662865,
0.0380495228,
0.002295827,
0.0482325442,
-0.0223328806,
-0.036559213,
0.0924912915,
-0.0231118761,
-0.0065385196,
-0.0227435138,
-0.0059119659,
0.0078573441,
0.0305256266,
-0.0779791325,
0.0219394322,
0.003686612,
-0.0322943777,
0.0692958683,
-0.0446463861,
-0.0259706397,
0.0262197759,
2.754e-7,
0.056782946,
0.0466009453,
0.0249932483,
0.0348977409,
0.0304956287,
0.055562187,
-0.0144267054,
0.0061694053,
0.0531394333,
0.0180691779,
-0.0103581995,
0.0008709548,
0.0749649853,
-0.0051026181,
-0.0189887714,
-0.0149747273,
-0.0106698256,
0.0389455967,
-0.0182668958,
0.0226311386,
0.048409123,
0.0337156467,
-0.0461397097,
-0.0234643463,
0.0377880149,
-0.048859112,
0.0578100421,
-0.0328436568,
0.0148634696,
-0.0464612581,
0.0460225418,
-0.0446230173,
-0.03475485,
-0.0143422335,
0.001918233,
-0.0250442773,
0.032358855,
0.0235803146,
-0.0676112399,
-0.0237093456,
0.0130027328,
0.0669626966,
-0.0520769097,
0.0361117758,
0.0586816594,
-0.0055420888,
-0.0070637423,
-0.0023166516,
-0.0185105689,
0.0098129194,
0.0098451572,
-0.0036046978,
0.0311347861,
0.0167694576,
0.0287835691,
-0.0162811931,
-0.0534659997,
-0.0107392771,
-0.0183687918,
0.0032678402,
-0.0066522029,
-0.0109771378,
-0.0268714763,
0.0628941283,
-0.0313355364,
-0.0051960605,
-0.0564583242,
1.838213385e-34,
0.0330273882,
-0.0076467609,
0.0446486883,
-0.0069349878,
0.0066224504,
-0.0376909561,
0.0224692151,
0.020940287,
-0.0144643532,
-0.0105281277,
-0.0204683244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07233v1 | TransGPT: Multi-modal Generative Pre-trained Transformer for Transportation | 2024-02-11T15:50:35 | 2024-02-11T15:50:35 | Peng Wang, Xiang Wei, Fangxu Hu, Wenjuan Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language processing (NLP) is a key component of intelligent
transportation systems (ITS), but it faces many challenges in the
transportation domain, such as domain-specific knowledge and data, and
multi-modal inputs and outputs. This paper presents TransGPT, a novel
(multi-modal) large language model for the transportation domain, which
consists of two independent variants: TransGPT-SM for single-modal data and
TransGPT-MM for multi-modal data. TransGPT-SM is finetuned on a single-modal
Transportation dataset (STD) that contains textual data from various sources in
the transportation domain. TransGPT-MM is finetuned on a multi-modal
Transportation dataset (MTD) that we manually collected from three areas of the
transportation domain: driving tests, traffic signs, and landmarks. We evaluate
TransGPT on several benchmark datasets for different tasks in the
transportation domain, and show that it outperforms baseline models on most
tasks. We also showcase the potential applications of TransGPT for traffic
analysis and modeling, such as generating synthetic traffic scenarios,
explaining traffic phenomena, answering traffic-related questions, providing
traffic recommendations, and generating traffic reports. This work advances the
state-of-the-art of NLP in the transportation domain and provides a useful tool
for ITS researchers and practitioners. | [
0.0150540266,
0.0672642738,
-0.0053209458,
0.0510530844,
-0.0163364019,
0.0049086111,
0.0308282785,
-0.0329381488,
-0.0565986931,
-0.0768961012,
0.0021320682,
-0.0182967205,
-0.0463682376,
0.0616188534,
0.03637347,
-0.0720442384,
0.0012041434,
-0.0570713468,
-0.0352234915,
0.0312463492,
0.016334679,
0.0510368571,
-0.0030497527,
0.0479783379,
-0.0450163633,
0.0125945993,
-0.0240379199,
-0.0005003452,
0.0282579716,
-0.0402626395,
0.0167947449,
0.0656251311,
0.1045713648,
-0.0145350741,
0.0000021048,
0.0035649426,
-0.0093253851,
-0.0004451331,
0.0314207152,
-0.0460174493,
0.0415453278,
-0.0074818158,
0.0128134359,
0.0280038677,
-0.0378533341,
-0.0667677745,
0.026994681,
0.0899276808,
0.0708448514,
0.0976486057,
-0.0273527522,
-0.0375355482,
0.0217528008,
-0.0072801006,
0.0065018004,
-0.0098770289,
0.0190004893,
0.0050941757,
-0.0221630521,
0.0296077318,
-0.0248431247,
0.000231502,
0.0382556245,
-0.0201925673,
-0.0060066376,
0.0217390973,
0.0078894012,
0.0221333243,
-0.0289799049,
0.1252048314,
-0.0327350982,
-0.0650614649,
0.0233599823,
0.008021201,
-0.0417667031,
-0.0369627438,
-0.0199478306,
-0.0267325286,
0.047349792,
0.0511686951,
-0.0264078993,
0.0407064781,
0.0055942754,
0.0217933543,
-0.0301588513,
-0.013984235,
0.0055136695,
-0.0324940309,
-0.0129035739,
0.0321371444,
-0.0077158278,
-0.0607365891,
0.0048741265,
0.0080775153,
-0.0222113151,
-0.0121712899,
0.0089544635,
-0.0355527177,
-0.0280641634,
-0.0033323334,
0.0302468557,
0.0004188008,
-0.0465515889,
0.0387189165,
-0.0022476574,
0.0015145441,
-0.0212510973,
0.0474146418,
-0.0494541377,
-0.0249624811,
-0.052449137,
0.0097488733,
-0.0584413856,
-0.0039907792,
-0.064375408,
0.016849922,
-0.0115859555,
0.0170011949,
0.0347196944,
-0.0466622375,
0.0082964338,
0.0288124885,
-0.0286305435,
-0.0521793999,
0.0107611222,
0.0421150066,
-0.0266001057,
0.0261513293,
0.0040439554,
-0.0301110465,
0.0066718594,
0.0377074555,
0.0052385977,
-0.0092802672,
0.0021422177,
0.0792948678,
-0.0409690738,
-0.0279257502,
-0.0588882044,
-0.0324526913,
0.0000487057,
-0.0680578575,
-0.0080892183,
-0.0647249967,
0.0514897667,
0.0122893881,
-0.0173445325,
-0.0113990083,
-0.0132236546,
-0.0017016043,
0.0009769797,
0.0630980432,
-0.0131266555,
0.0060698646,
0.0078610871,
-0.0028160345,
0.0733247772,
0.0583943017,
0.0391473807,
0.0351803005,
0.0304643866,
-0.0115581797,
0.0325051583,
0.0089070965,
0.0277687572,
0.0061566946,
-0.00129334,
0.0146051329,
-0.0368080214,
0.0259935483,
0.0382681303,
0.0348872468,
-0.0405353941,
0.0213463921,
0.0282348674,
0.001242658,
0.0459416509,
0.0354736485,
0.0809421614,
0.0494596995,
-0.049187202,
-0.0148415985,
-0.0358437262,
0.0189719517,
-0.0608289838,
0.0035320425,
0.0017666954,
0.0647888929,
-0.0302209239,
-0.0252130553,
0.0516022481,
-0.0311755966,
0.027672559,
-0.018552918,
0.0490355715,
-0.008195959,
-0.056442786,
0.0439840034,
0.0175835229,
-0.0022391439,
0.0136563117,
-0.043042291,
-0.0262390003,
0.0152193271,
0.0042469734,
-0.0099176345,
-0.0158158112,
-0.0503824688,
0.0260986164,
0.0206273217,
0.0455050617,
0.0093348864,
-0.0083103888,
-0.0755139068,
-0.0374411754,
0.0310016349,
0.0165482163,
-0.0366641283,
0.009750803,
0.0430413559,
0.0557203852,
-0.0475730225,
0.0102753118,
0.0298499539,
0.0493138768,
-0.0191298518,
0.0071451818,
-0.005264191,
0.0029449069,
-0.0199252497,
-0.03915352,
0.0130882533,
0.0228313953,
0.008614229,
-0.0416890346,
0.0661454648,
-0.0709736571,
0.0139370635,
0.0137239303,
-0.0709678456,
-0.0270531047,
0.0543161444,
-0.0695028156,
-0.0314116329,
-0.027433278,
-0.0233135801,
-0.0013604237,
-0.0132642668,
-0.0075339046,
0.059754733,
0.0317873582,
-0.0152531164,
0.0432341732,
0.0343867205,
0.0258503295,
0.0139620667,
0.0014574862,
0.0393521748,
0.0305965431,
-0.0218240265,
0.0060951845,
-0.0160529222,
0.0187157821,
-0.0088516437,
0.0180337802,
-0.0267354082,
-0.0076713129,
-0.0704589859,
0.0047363429,
-0.0206747986,
0.0024987964,
0.02416954,
-0.0048891231,
-0.035230875,
-0.0280490518,
-0.0291203093,
0.0275953636,
0.0541253835,
-0.032491684,
0.0237334315,
-0.0230206009,
0.0170805827,
-0.02523751,
-0.0123636574,
-0.0400258526,
0.0452845022,
0.0071567362,
-0.0153499916,
-0.0374789312,
-0.0048283329,
0.0028791984,
0.0541078448,
0.0042834133,
-0.0426724739,
-0.0041912147,
-0.0065421099,
0.0744462386,
-0.0086647253,
0.0590698086,
-0.028922556,
0.0136151267,
-0.0629834458,
-0.0573738962,
0.0291175861,
-0.0679579079,
-0.0135706346,
-0.060159158,
-0.023474738,
-0.0087028602,
0.0718109831,
0.0050334614,
-0.0057424745,
-0.0307569355,
-0.0088207228,
0.000217508,
-0.0186281074,
-0.0185822006,
0.0449511558,
0.016866073,
0.0338432752,
0.0056008198,
-0.0088656973,
0.0594813749,
-0.0196799822,
-0.011908303,
-0.0514557324,
0.0300195981,
-0.0124966167,
0.084332563,
0.0121173235,
0.0238438416,
0.0470868349,
0.0110490201,
-0.0083408551,
0.0165990461,
-0.0388480313,
-0.0040329094,
0.049976375,
-0.0376844332,
0.0291617606,
-0.0396998562,
-0.0646768585,
-0.0148369335,
-0.0915110409,
-0.0170646254,
-0.0300685335,
0.0176534224,
-0.0339403115,
-0.0334988162,
0.0258964505,
-0.0220345706,
0.0808900744,
0.0111588128,
-0.0215030182,
-0.0303067788,
0.0347473361,
0.080369778,
0.082129091,
-0.0072339368,
0.0083307642,
-0.0133254081,
0.0408591032,
-0.0029195233,
0.0097277593,
-0.0477360338,
0.0253133774,
0.0121447034,
-0.0151129533,
0.0031663799,
0.0237558652,
0.0446575359,
-0.0542993322,
-0.0189009886,
0.0874505341,
0.0208216086,
-0.0348111577,
0.0102046467,
0.0557380095,
0.0197922438,
-0.011699683,
0.0465524085,
-0.0912269056,
-0.0489128903,
-0.0081436494,
-0.0250773467,
0.0160372276,
-0.0401451848,
-0.0079093724,
-0.0776029155,
0.0219058506,
-0.0254574213,
-0.0175985787,
-0.0164706986,
-0.0622222945,
-0.041267518,
-0.011726738,
0.025380142,
-0.0272691287,
-0.0197849218,
-0.0046373582,
0.0216279589,
-0.0256697331,
-0.0783572942,
0.0262302496,
-0.0183295421,
0.0881563276,
0.0114064096,
0.0073339171,
-0.019618459,
-0.0176412761,
0.0125883128,
-0.0165143851,
0.0120104775,
-0.007071198,
0.039329607,
-0.022989247,
-0.0244918615,
-0.0564310923,
0.0290731937,
-0.07724756,
-0.0110368039,
-0.0088012656,
0.0554251522,
-0.0156681314,
0.0056085922,
-0.0364751965,
0.020852739,
0.006017942,
0.0527526177,
-0.0273436811,
-0.0591143593,
-0.025843991,
-0.0317877941,
-0.0123168323,
-0.0554679744,
-0.0657679215,
-0.0172649492,
0.009917696,
-0.006831516,
-0.0523757301,
-0.0444351621,
0.0324458703,
0.010251659,
0.0007515152,
-0.0310237296,
0.0285579376,
-0.0400258228,
-0.0591963828,
0.0507259518,
-0.0218146462,
0.0119004017,
-0.0373689607,
0.011556467,
0.0436432697,
-0.0165838618,
-0.0474430993,
0.038893126,
-0.0736459941,
-0.0551721603,
-0.005613063,
0.0191585124,
0.0085289693,
0.0092909774,
-0.0327527486,
-0.0339946114,
0.0441149212,
0.0307647903,
-0.0549621247,
-0.0296553131,
-0.004175588,
-0.0579835325,
0.014542182,
0.0145290513,
-0.0122448625,
0.0538334586,
0.0307080168,
-0.0009163136,
-0.0310800225,
-0.0030040417,
0.0338714309,
0.0129824998,
0.0785935074,
0.0089708697,
0.0568590499,
-0.0668952018,
-0.0051224581,
-0.0122931404,
0.0037485152,
-0.0499899276,
0.0181344133,
0.0227874443,
0.0107963132,
-0.0295868441,
0.0215777084,
0.0097200638,
-0.024660971,
-0.0099932021,
0.0139355166,
0.0665357634,
-0.0163534433,
0.0071229427,
-0.0049362853,
0.0129895797,
-0.0217090175,
0.0216045808,
0.0248656515,
-0.0305473506,
0.0741140619,
0.0284369402,
-0.0082170507,
-0.0282051582,
0.036134664,
-0.0113403946,
-0.0232595801,
-0.070380725,
0.0500178635,
0.0406845547,
0.0161491446,
0.0215202924,
-0.025293652,
0.0149011221,
-0.007603839,
0.068257682,
0.0253862441,
0.0236157198,
0.0451970287,
-0.0166679285,
-0.0396024622,
0.0044638552,
0.0897423252,
-0.0184377432,
0.0371052921,
0.0376591459,
-0.0125991115,
-0.0524573661,
0.0146368388,
-0.0163906254,
-0.0211041346,
0.0063980683,
0.0241068732,
-0.0077283727,
-0.0561198816,
0.013384467,
0.0171427317,
-0.0035897931,
0.0026378739,
0.0155187873,
0.0273186397,
0.0189856496,
-0.0270492285,
-0.0040055038,
-0.0250253361,
0.0113753518,
-0.0273135286,
-0.0107147833,
-6.314433861e-33,
-0.0266575757,
-0.0004454929,
0.0337003805,
-0.0229150318,
-0.0342289023,
0.0050644241,
-0.0243654903,
0.0096373362,
-0.007926058,
0.0002917812,
-0.0181989037,
-0.0024402188,
0.013786572,
0.0422527492,
-0.0081032626,
-0.0108481376,
0.0643874779,
-0.0064377533,
-0.003282499,
0.0342983715,
0.0357589535,
0.0147685986,
0.0684358254,
-0.0895038396,
0.011387866,
-0.0476210192,
-0.046277985,
0.0110385455,
0.0037965956,
0.0391960479,
-0.0306187309,
0.0576364808,
0.0438120663,
-0.0472728983,
-0.042766016,
0.0615636483,
-0.0432029292,
0.0043411069,
0.0117399255,
0.0212467834,
-0.0398558043,
0.002282301,
0.0339605175,
-0.0202245526,
0.0155459372,
0.0283900853,
0.0493944436,
-0.0004451934,
0.0373180248,
-0.020629188,
-0.0820225552,
0.0259204078,
-0.0328962989,
-0.040214099,
0.0299926642,
0.0628554896,
0.0139667252,
-0.0106961001,
-0.0270316806,
0.0080120619,
0.0209067594,
0.0150399655,
0.0251995847,
-0.0347394384,
-0.0100148888,
0.0503779426,
-0.0213021487,
-0.0576407276,
-0.059187863,
0.0087286523,
0.0198594928,
0.053604573,
-0.0053477003,
0.0839291289,
0.006849336,
-0.0285177473,
-0.0774792954,
0.0190544017,
0.0098404633,
-0.0137466546,
0.0329120085,
-0.0153564531,
-0.0296597518,
0.0082145948,
-0.0289203431,
0.0011109109,
-0.0060363677,
-0.0565375946,
0.0262803175,
0.0445453897,
-0.0341326781,
0.020468697,
0.0683036745,
-0.0473410152,
-0.0390547663,
-0.0138537791,
-0.0353667215,
-0.0044094147,
-0.0216318201,
0.0298073404,
-0.0856825113,
-0.0214012284,
0.0488844141,
-0.0234543718,
0.0077292128,
0.0075922036,
0.0303104427,
0.0301912148,
-0.0664115027,
0.0257137641,
-0.0288688522,
0.019674398,
0.0129468367,
0.0299834237,
0.0238752812,
0.0073081292,
-0.0432587862,
0.0223233588,
0.0315977409,
0.0138090327,
-0.0277125668,
-0.0134957219,
0.0266967919,
0.0461461619,
0.0079277884,
0.0194885656,
-0.0205068756,
-0.059985172,
0.049806159,
-0.0383711271,
-0.004874323,
0.0366264582,
2.658e-7,
0.0433629528,
0.0439763851,
0.0154158296,
0.0031460752,
0.0124039501,
0.0500132479,
0.0032612178,
0.0186536722,
0.0105348565,
0.025120927,
-0.0226079635,
0.0141260047,
0.0178108905,
0.0302805379,
-0.0587383993,
0.0260977726,
-0.0413193703,
-0.0028200091,
-0.0672816485,
0.0042914664,
0.1022337973,
0.1310017705,
-0.0224872064,
0.004869211,
0.0039494666,
0.0111051863,
0.0438538007,
-0.0410527214,
-0.041961927,
0.0334903672,
0.0382303968,
0.0460412577,
-0.0113727683,
0.0167731531,
-0.0260199104,
0.0062958244,
-0.001251936,
0.0482295863,
0.0054589384,
-0.0191931073,
0.0368402675,
-0.0535880029,
-0.0163685251,
-0.0420252606,
0.0540287048,
-0.0734844133,
-0.0004593999,
-0.0387044288,
-0.0539725088,
-0.009367194,
-0.0119442716,
-0.008291929,
-0.0109279957,
0.0201902818,
0.0405144691,
-0.0062253377,
-0.0133823566,
-0.0991651341,
0.0011632959,
0.006983663,
-0.0213730596,
0.0183414742,
-0.0349042863,
0.005315552,
0.0824277923,
-0.0269147139,
0.0014706021,
2.075957691e-34,
0.0353221074,
0.0170217883,
-0.0076621082,
-0.027848646,
0.0460188873,
0.0021429944,
0.0013384052,
-0.0136389984,
-0.0546603426,
-0.065052785,
-0.0316811576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07214v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07214v3 | Through the Lens of Split Vote: Exploring Disagreement, Difficulty and Calibration in Legal Case Outcome Classification | 2024-02-11T14:21:37 | 2024-06-06T10:53:50 | Shanshan Xu, T. Y. S. S Santosh, Oana Ichim, Barbara Plank, Matthias Grabmair | cs.CL | cs.CL | In legal decisions, split votes (SV) occur when judges cannot reach a
unanimous decision, posing a difficulty for lawyers who must navigate diverse
legal arguments and opinions. In high-stakes domains, understanding the
alignment of perceived difficulty between humans and AI systems is crucial to
build trust. However, existing NLP calibration methods focus on a classifier's
awareness of predictive performance, measured against the human majority class,
overlooking inherent human label variation (HLV). This paper explores split
votes as naturally observable human disagreement and value pluralism. We
collect judges' vote distributions from the European Court of Human Rights
(ECHR), and present SV-ECHR, a case outcome classification (COC) dataset with
SV information. We build a taxonomy of disagreement with SV-specific
subcategories. We further assess the alignment of perceived difficulty between
models and humans, as well as confidence- and human-calibration of COC models.
We observe limited alignment with the judge vote distribution. To our
knowledge, this is the first systematic exploration of calibration to human
judgements in legal NLP. Our study underscores the necessity for further
research on measuring and enhancing model calibration considering HLV in legal
decision tasks. | [
0.0541757941,
0.0597891398,
-0.0247278567,
-0.0001655418,
-0.0617247373,
0.0361886322,
-0.0131168775,
-0.0012583461,
-0.0050431211,
-0.062368352,
-0.001873496,
-0.0299307033,
0.0012093064,
-0.0188943557,
-0.0407375135,
-0.0713360906,
0.0339974649,
0.0241784845,
0.085428983,
-0.0211233608,
0.0223845802,
-0.0125352917,
0.005380406,
0.0337383598,
-0.0338551924,
0.0031291901,
-0.0111811832,
-0.018679399,
0.0031057319,
-0.0001193236,
-0.0080504445,
0.0983856097,
-0.0159086715,
0.0387180299,
0.0000015092,
-0.0424203463,
0.0193003621,
-0.0203400534,
-0.0333408341,
-0.0058228988,
0.0083847968,
-0.0035883128,
-0.009851722,
0.0119197993,
-0.0431724265,
0.0550518855,
0.0080511142,
0.0197577477,
0.019812176,
0.0418406762,
0.0266872682,
-0.0121220574,
-0.0019551346,
-0.0200663321,
-0.0138786081,
-0.041260127,
-0.016028814,
0.0199777,
-0.04682073,
-0.0357383341,
0.0330467634,
-0.0085313236,
0.0277073551,
0.0285240617,
-0.0248448569,
0.0221875198,
-0.0415701009,
-0.0289842971,
0.0111721493,
0.0309993085,
0.0548585765,
-0.0243872181,
-0.0279868804,
-0.0213945825,
0.0788649246,
0.0281008687,
0.0155612938,
0.0586217716,
-0.0071907742,
0.0186158139,
0.0041084234,
0.0547799133,
-0.0161822625,
0.0137226516,
-0.000665713,
0.0717789158,
-0.030902816,
-0.0157118198,
0.0319554396,
0.0684753954,
0.0088573443,
-0.0425182842,
0.0349910036,
0.0257008821,
-0.0466373637,
0.0215272531,
-0.0096805245,
-0.0179804936,
0.0617062859,
-0.0815553144,
0.0302843675,
0.0036459644,
-0.0225761291,
0.0528165214,
0.0073395874,
-0.005138943,
0.0136037106,
0.0614796169,
-0.0050611794,
-0.0089642992,
-0.0488001704,
0.0051351492,
0.0050720959,
0.002543143,
-0.0621810034,
0.0402094275,
-0.0556778796,
-0.0293087009,
-0.0578495562,
0.0260301679,
0.0149906101,
0.0163092874,
0.0253610481,
0.0035797269,
-0.0898174644,
-0.0098451339,
-0.0673485026,
0.0495435931,
0.015357567,
-0.0188498124,
0.0233618915,
-0.0115926443,
-0.0139976982,
0.0077974955,
0.0108275982,
0.0699381828,
-0.0136455838,
-0.0144527014,
-0.007638508,
-0.048064813,
-0.0452427082,
-0.0737545416,
-0.0408838727,
-0.0508380979,
0.0312200915,
-0.0030759743,
0.0003868284,
-0.0457225814,
0.0060172291,
0.0153790647,
-0.0101362905,
0.0955739692,
0.0090731326,
-0.0101070879,
-0.0195336919,
0.0087183453,
-0.0030212402,
0.0048130155,
0.0023073254,
0.0099147772,
0.0491566174,
-0.0077360808,
0.0534996316,
-0.0179724507,
-0.0044432227,
0.0071791145,
-0.0120801842,
0.0087486161,
-0.0335406736,
0.0018168567,
0.0183266066,
0.0593475513,
-0.0089818127,
-0.0501689799,
0.0405730344,
0.0463382006,
-0.0233008228,
0.0337452181,
-0.0403379127,
-0.0160381384,
0.0289096516,
0.0180155169,
-0.069996126,
0.0187231228,
-0.0326493271,
-0.0101179043,
-0.0326268263,
0.0045357589,
-0.0254321862,
-0.0707452819,
-0.0080264118,
-0.0072956257,
0.0391719826,
0.0007960354,
0.0147962896,
-0.0184565019,
0.0209466685,
0.0035251391,
0.029117398,
-0.0603826195,
-0.0184025485,
-0.0375765264,
0.0202542134,
-0.009431811,
-0.0008909901,
-0.0131093096,
-0.0045130346,
-0.026928449,
-0.0291334111,
-0.0046909233,
0.076454632,
-0.0271835737,
-0.0391142964,
-0.0141392779,
-0.0402092226,
0.0430353247,
0.0430561379,
0.0351865441,
-0.0140499417,
-0.0067637451,
0.0142370323,
-0.070710279,
-0.0133984303,
0.0463869758,
0.0397003926,
0.0056075794,
0.0042031216,
0.0036521128,
0.035962455,
0.0415785685,
0.0077406061,
-0.0090240482,
0.0271997079,
0.0414936356,
-0.0183266699,
-0.0104708988,
-0.0036292053,
0.0185852703,
0.055881504,
-0.0345118828,
-0.0497003533,
-0.005351651,
-0.0320288911,
-0.0090168687,
-0.0298085902,
-0.0159095731,
-0.0600326806,
-0.0427785069,
0.036811661,
-0.0330624767,
-0.0262557715,
-0.0460745655,
0.0404826179,
-0.0090759424,
-0.0010714508,
-0.0676114559,
-0.0339273885,
0.039670188,
0.0071128686,
-0.0446705818,
0.0089857485,
-0.0109335249,
0.0405919701,
0.0456350185,
-0.0260736458,
-0.0393187851,
-0.0373151377,
-0.0506789535,
-0.0141348662,
-0.0264487714,
0.0095496466,
-0.0052373796,
-0.0569442213,
0.0173215512,
-0.0190989282,
-0.021869421,
-0.0208307542,
-0.0055734338,
0.0025625622,
0.0251520332,
-0.021718204,
-0.0130747017,
-0.0191507973,
-0.0194775593,
-0.0340135358,
0.0278879628,
0.0230550822,
0.0265680645,
-0.0453843586,
0.04073954,
-0.02506884,
-0.0194064062,
-0.0260008257,
-0.0005646379,
0.0352558531,
0.0688384697,
-0.0224127732,
0.040186353,
0.0642267987,
0.0597572587,
0.0528693721,
0.0270816721,
-0.0378771797,
-0.0111223143,
-0.024634283,
-0.0023456009,
-0.0157502443,
-0.0234224517,
0.0178002659,
0.0339188352,
0.0052076327,
-0.0078923292,
-0.028589271,
0.0079409145,
-0.0262192339,
-0.0361285768,
-0.0329125039,
-0.0222982429,
-0.0223525949,
0.0650810301,
0.0380280316,
-0.0536534116,
0.0717831105,
0.0125274835,
0.0750533566,
-0.0546031557,
-0.0093226228,
-0.0287304427,
0.0832092017,
-0.0091689965,
-0.0110341618,
-0.003098096,
-0.0084182899,
-0.0141629577,
-0.0439004898,
0.0531102605,
-0.0625978038,
0.0992389023,
-0.0296975486,
-0.0017206293,
-0.0364857242,
-0.0679844096,
-0.028983457,
-0.0221746713,
-0.0251564402,
0.0362551734,
0.0562649965,
-0.0186746959,
-0.0341528468,
-0.0193035509,
-0.0053683235,
-0.0108363871,
0.0199636761,
-0.0203892197,
-0.0097710909,
-0.0016907728,
-0.0176322106,
0.0236937217,
0.0643323436,
-0.0433371402,
-0.0609032363,
0.0491024144,
0.0431593321,
0.0292698219,
0.0000771266,
-0.0291255936,
0.0315646268,
-0.0626060739,
-0.0027147566,
0.0150559582,
0.0490279719,
-0.0136699388,
0.049795825,
0.0816862732,
0.0476619788,
-0.0549491271,
-0.0042067855,
-0.0343860164,
0.0162371267,
0.0382215194,
-0.014982475,
-0.0676940009,
0.0076652281,
0.007107147,
0.0030291642,
-0.0683170408,
-0.0454505607,
0.0306418128,
-0.072657086,
0.040859431,
0.0148958862,
-0.009370612,
-0.0422496162,
-0.0304632559,
0.0327621922,
-0.032859087,
0.0220822934,
-0.0128269885,
0.0185711849,
0.0141937016,
0.0423076376,
-0.0527573377,
-0.0071455655,
0.0270589553,
-0.053592816,
0.0919879302,
0.0263042673,
0.0669305921,
-0.0200312044,
-0.0221843235,
0.0270953178,
-0.0350952893,
-0.0173533913,
0.0259164795,
0.0613372363,
-0.0003569926,
0.0198149756,
-0.0421685539,
0.0154208224,
0.0088985972,
-0.0170790367,
0.0166172739,
0.0218606126,
-0.0418546721,
-0.015621949,
-0.0278903581,
-0.0192901045,
-0.0069213379,
0.0644840151,
0.017437024,
-0.019692285,
-0.0534984209,
-0.0294919964,
0.0221779272,
-0.0036791719,
-0.0348119326,
0.0224472731,
-0.0069168182,
-0.0093772868,
0.0078430315,
-0.0490525067,
-0.0119653661,
0.0485397018,
-0.0099706911,
-0.0180250891,
0.0543453917,
0.0051931939,
-0.0309806671,
0.0319896564,
-0.0134339267,
0.0317834392,
-0.0311661735,
-0.005047359,
-0.0183635522,
0.0340606384,
-0.0208506193,
-0.0079203146,
0.0158483796,
-0.0206330549,
0.0223265234,
-0.0068824114,
0.0292437691,
-0.0134840691,
-0.0096552558,
-0.0513600558,
0.0246180426,
0.0445222966,
0.019843284,
0.0036294209,
0.0461209193,
0.0116905989,
-0.0246011019,
0.0149273407,
0.0409704857,
0.0280130077,
0.0489727259,
0.0108146835,
-0.0458336174,
-0.0259648357,
0.0356322192,
-0.0090316869,
0.0489932708,
-0.0112844659,
-0.0228134189,
-0.0149598587,
-0.0267075058,
0.003325941,
-0.0229226816,
0.0140103782,
-0.0687718689,
0.0038858198,
-0.0238723382,
-0.0478025489,
0.0374561772,
-0.0152081177,
0.0261891726,
-0.0422508307,
0.0216309,
0.0610272363,
0.0112859989,
0.000753859,
-0.0377245434,
0.0027488661,
0.0062584952,
-0.0055125258,
0.0511653647,
0.0264907368,
0.046937678,
0.0208806135,
-0.0106092207,
-0.0150148543,
0.0083302408,
-0.0551638976,
0.0063447161,
-0.0066743591,
0.0032246488,
0.0027764516,
-0.0044650873,
-0.027124783,
0.0064394046,
-0.012527314,
-0.0257351026,
-0.0031809288,
-0.0208832603,
0.0230584182,
0.0390039198,
0.0203621741,
-0.0344076492,
0.0076703089,
0.0168333612,
-0.0298559628,
0.0065636914,
-0.0731117204,
-0.0538818277,
-0.016883526,
-0.0154109355,
-0.0129869161,
-0.0243304782,
-0.0373940319,
-0.0550743416,
-0.1140959486,
-0.0151247475,
0.0135957384,
0.0436737239,
0.0421287194,
0.0185291134,
-0.0353006087,
0.0904542282,
-0.0223190542,
0.0065433886,
-0.0515985936,
0.0011590418,
0.0093452679,
0.0097938953,
-0.0486713164,
-5.311020863e-33,
-0.0319354124,
-0.0557673387,
-0.0230134372,
-0.0098500205,
0.0128813572,
-0.0131334383,
0.0260945112,
0.0600203201,
-0.038857691,
0.0559861399,
-0.011553295,
0.0278763659,
0.0235243905,
-0.0362034626,
0.0543011948,
-0.0530187897,
0.0267252345,
0.0084681921,
-0.0340737477,
-0.0305231027,
-0.0042724502,
-0.0351252295,
0.0129270246,
-0.1447691619,
0.0740070045,
0.0802741721,
-0.027082352,
-0.0314552039,
-0.0339331217,
0.0282350741,
0.0038448847,
0.0673312098,
0.0280829817,
-0.0337075815,
0.0130086988,
0.0323488042,
-0.0399244204,
0.0015805537,
-0.0001909854,
0.0147072123,
0.0212080441,
-0.00295187,
0.0180043336,
0.0222167317,
-0.0782567114,
0.0087305279,
0.0286048688,
-0.0195959639,
-0.0165659972,
-0.0446080118,
-0.051236853,
0.0402036868,
-0.0168305822,
-0.008262217,
-0.0036559259,
0.0196050946,
-0.0111893238,
0.0116751529,
-0.1016919538,
0.0165532306,
-0.0178772938,
-0.0465598516,
0.0147251133,
-0.0395861119,
-0.0389395319,
0.0780968666,
0.0590148531,
0.0471891575,
-0.0818984434,
-0.0543515831,
0.0224033818,
0.0546028093,
0.0711563081,
0.060642276,
0.0255540852,
-0.0541543737,
-0.0313940085,
-0.0083048195,
0.0304168407,
-0.0048160176,
0.0438138358,
0.0006264681,
-0.0610258803,
-0.0134854773,
-0.0205028225,
-0.1034854427,
-0.0207131915,
0.0254407059,
0.0036238043,
0.0105279973,
0.0391529948,
0.0041968673,
-0.0014674854,
-0.027860757,
0.0144729121,
0.0053081471,
0.0121092536,
0.0408284068,
-0.0078023365,
-0.0118944449,
-0.0240711216,
-0.0370293744,
0.0043687779,
-0.0181765314,
0.0321386606,
-0.01982571,
0.0604536757,
-0.0515612401,
-0.0490941331,
-0.0240295567,
0.0240977425,
0.0107867969,
0.04300116,
0.0200485494,
0.0590475947,
0.0181845129,
0.0126895802,
-0.0017809939,
-0.0077405754,
0.0289078858,
-0.0183808804,
0.0073796832,
-0.0305254664,
-0.005094381,
0.0305519216,
-0.0316020362,
-0.0008397743,
-0.0120920511,
-0.0090297312,
0.0378505848,
0.0053365999,
0.0080459565,
2.271e-7,
0.0549525507,
0.0586643741,
-0.0315495469,
-0.033550594,
-0.0145036485,
0.0825220346,
0.0066681071,
0.0246839039,
0.0324477777,
-0.0778208524,
0.0184253193,
-0.0099207768,
0.0478015989,
0.0534762107,
-0.0091057215,
-0.0554594919,
-0.0090371594,
-0.0003319844,
-0.0134628061,
0.0759103298,
0.0720396861,
0.0783324689,
0.0474326946,
-0.0045620962,
-0.0227641333,
0.034110155,
0.0388823859,
-0.0213316735,
-0.0243218206,
0.0129586756,
0.1022377312,
-0.099105753,
0.0085738869,
0.1053154096,
0.0071826377,
0.0226854123,
0.0033097912,
0.029377168,
-0.0249917116,
0.0397466756,
-0.0409112908,
-0.0183555,
0.0172788408,
-0.0133896424,
0.0336728022,
-0.0308025293,
-0.0458645448,
-0.0722854063,
-0.0231617261,
-0.0084335525,
0.0936513394,
0.0443319529,
-0.011664982,
0.0109856995,
0.0087146098,
0.0222346764,
0.0052203946,
-0.0691644922,
-0.0074239718,
0.0300663598,
-0.0262930822,
-0.0218458362,
0.039060846,
0.0045220903,
0.0637168959,
-0.0701171979,
0.0126807345,
1.722181302e-34,
0.0477769449,
0.0171508677,
0.0152892759,
0.0317231901,
0.0568070896,
0.034291856,
0.0111083025,
-0.0136790164,
-0.0019038972,
-0.0158937015,
0.0482565351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15518v1 | Beware of Words: Evaluating the Lexical Richness of Conversational Large Language Models | 2024-02-11T13:41:17 | 2024-02-11T13:41:17 | Gonzalo Martínez, José Alberto Hernández, Javier Conde, Pedro Reviriego, Elena Merino | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of conversational Large Language Models (LLMs) in general,
and of ChatGPT in particular, is currently being evaluated on many different
tasks, from logical reasoning or maths to answering questions on a myriad of
topics. Instead, much less attention is being devoted to the study of the
linguistic features of the texts generated by these LLMs. This is surprising
since LLMs are models for language, and understanding how they use the language
is important. Indeed, conversational LLMs are poised to have a significant
impact on the evolution of languages as they may eventually dominate the
creation of new text. This means that for example, if conversational LLMs do
not use a word it may become less and less frequent and eventually stop being
used altogether. Therefore, evaluating the linguistic features of the text they
produce and how those depend on the model parameters is the first step toward
understanding the potential impact of conversational LLMs on the evolution of
languages. In this paper, we consider the evaluation of the lexical richness of
the text generated by LLMs and how it depends on the model parameters. A
methodology is presented and used to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
lexical richness using ChatGPT as a case study. The results show how lexical
richness depends on the version of ChatGPT and some of its parameters, such as
the presence penalty, or on the role assigned to the model. The dataset and
tools used in our analysis are released under open licenses with the goal of
drawing the much-needed attention to the evaluation of the linguistic features
of LLM-generated text. | [
0.055420246,
0.0420201719,
-0.032073874,
0.0540811904,
-0.0646538362,
0.0066643688,
-0.0158970319,
0.0179207735,
0.0134494444,
-0.043172162,
0.0159055237,
-0.0297092404,
0.0077984626,
0.0358051062,
0.0321018472,
-0.0303228162,
0.037278071,
-0.0221772604,
0.0057877004,
-0.0016749643,
0.0292659532,
-0.0130910482,
0.0313738249,
0.0281640776,
-0.0004494266,
-0.0063218703,
-0.0147251217,
-0.01317125,
-0.0104396725,
-0.0101225674,
-0.0195031613,
0.0342274196,
-0.0077159861,
0.0547343977,
0.0000020441,
-0.0781608447,
0.0181752015,
-0.0097072553,
-0.0019731903,
0.0418368056,
0.0698945969,
0.041941002,
-0.0232735611,
-0.0044731591,
-0.0548847243,
0.0188748389,
0.0444574207,
0.0370261371,
0.0327622779,
0.0637027621,
-0.0179396402,
-0.0261904784,
0.0320618302,
-0.0165076498,
0.0211635698,
-0.0274148714,
0.0292120334,
0.0560206585,
0.0136274425,
0.03542649,
-0.0162701719,
0.0530033037,
0.014817642,
-0.0323683023,
0.00343734,
0.0225633476,
-0.0387190282,
-0.0340250768,
0.0130040133,
0.0479294099,
0.0202097148,
-0.0297999904,
0.0065667713,
0.0011884441,
0.0139807127,
0.0088655464,
-0.077878125,
0.0270066019,
0.026200315,
0.0251319557,
0.0379293598,
-0.0089695584,
0.0204215739,
0.0441178456,
-0.0191585906,
0.0711337775,
0.0347974338,
-0.0171766002,
-0.0263816714,
-0.0188415069,
-0.0373370945,
-0.0807887763,
-0.0295895245,
0.002289379,
-0.0276521984,
0.049867142,
-0.0139912274,
0.0158503819,
0.0377159007,
-0.0798887685,
0.0004470503,
-0.0072297454,
-0.0061186375,
0.0565282255,
-0.0029550772,
0.0174104124,
-0.0023166232,
-0.0163576417,
-0.0173562542,
-0.0134673258,
-0.0373440385,
-0.022721827,
-0.028767705,
0.0358668417,
-0.0206713974,
-0.0288128611,
-0.0155434497,
0.0459971726,
0.0308674984,
-0.0053786254,
0.0036492627,
-0.0044735083,
-0.0127719073,
-0.0041021127,
-0.0396161452,
-0.0285651404,
-0.055419527,
0.0068978528,
0.0153754754,
-0.0931391343,
0.0336787105,
0.0253618322,
0.0093666101,
-0.0373637974,
-0.0153359855,
0.0738671049,
0.0252748877,
-0.0270844027,
0.0057116072,
-0.0066422778,
-0.0487732291,
-0.0416025147,
-0.0341819897,
-0.0748817176,
-0.0060215206,
0.0110125719,
0.0060722614,
-0.02081443,
0.0137140779,
0.0294187535,
-0.0478733815,
0.0393100083,
-0.0319253989,
0.0285178013,
0.0055399267,
-0.0182791557,
0.0029246616,
0.0506194979,
0.0511392429,
-0.0231720414,
0.0778187215,
-0.0326784663,
-0.0193107296,
0.0360130891,
-0.0204070862,
0.010476999,
-0.0087203868,
0.0178065021,
0.0132274264,
0.0172564648,
-0.0294762831,
0.0832261667,
-0.0387386605,
-0.015600631,
0.0801210031,
0.0501423255,
0.0273543857,
0.0481184684,
0.0210546125,
0.009703855,
0.0020880771,
0.0398402177,
-0.0030676925,
-0.0144354058,
-0.0581347384,
-0.0036667751,
0.0223989803,
0.0185298808,
-0.0058797994,
-0.0562056787,
-0.0093134129,
0.011426378,
0.0466329753,
-0.0202339999,
0.0364861898,
0.0258830786,
-0.011007119,
0.0331294723,
0.0561291128,
-0.079127267,
-0.0244306419,
-0.0478923135,
0.0348146781,
0.0252162647,
0.0658598766,
0.0149365356,
-0.0196619593,
0.0297406651,
0.0363298878,
0.0604801923,
0.0404735506,
0.0145042976,
0.0056768092,
-0.0373377055,
0.0063177911,
-0.0252584908,
0.006570172,
-0.0063395733,
0.0132255917,
0.0033090815,
0.0045907758,
-0.0221783351,
-0.033652056,
0.0243411455,
-0.0498563237,
0.0118937409,
-0.0160058048,
-0.0463464707,
0.0394952297,
0.0014028173,
-0.0239711124,
0.0413599201,
0.0160924457,
-0.0247588065,
-0.0392122343,
0.0382012352,
-0.0442125462,
-0.0214158371,
0.0547363013,
-0.0353402011,
0.0247637685,
-0.0041235252,
0.0034557506,
-0.0247504953,
0.0166736357,
-0.0797923803,
0.0807870477,
-0.0478926264,
0.0401157886,
-0.0264012963,
0.0142672341,
-0.045028612,
0.0839461982,
0.0139524918,
0.0435686111,
-0.0123651605,
0.014102879,
0.0307361558,
-0.0394818671,
-0.0309734605,
0.0172409751,
-0.0150901964,
0.0055804309,
0.0723240227,
0.0143786483,
-0.0559053645,
-0.0589662753,
-0.1152237505,
0.0204084143,
0.0024500901,
0.0143391201,
0.0198631305,
0.0204566736,
-0.0054041487,
0.0381133296,
-0.0488162488,
0.0154513102,
0.0156460889,
0.0294667389,
0.0468494073,
-0.0051351641,
-0.0321291313,
-0.0442234837,
-0.0054712389,
0.0050517796,
0.0479763038,
0.0494424701,
-0.0112863462,
-0.0035281086,
0.0477624051,
-0.0769304112,
-0.0077983309,
-0.0075579183,
-0.0546188951,
0.0025587906,
-0.0167771485,
0.037285205,
0.0187781267,
0.0483296737,
0.0259812437,
0.0047247373,
-0.0588303171,
-0.031165041,
-0.0138890715,
-0.0419283807,
-0.0313523598,
-0.0472885333,
-0.0324759483,
0.0189600997,
0.0779443607,
-0.0016823303,
-0.012333924,
-0.0358659588,
0.0481032915,
-0.0304586347,
-0.0189248491,
0.0109710023,
0.0065709744,
-0.050889235,
0.0340752713,
-0.0131816166,
-0.0477304161,
0.0314575769,
-0.0372035727,
-0.0095244516,
-0.0472736284,
-0.0025915406,
-0.0443549566,
0.0450762287,
0.0010937955,
0.021198988,
0.0110302381,
-0.0206222106,
-0.034872897,
-0.0337304845,
0.0533702597,
-0.0353288166,
0.031257093,
-0.0483862683,
0.0184933972,
0.0213322192,
-0.0190979373,
-0.0189996138,
-0.0466222949,
-0.0347469971,
0.0031785681,
0.0676012188,
-0.0028204934,
-0.0051079676,
-0.0011838308,
0.0092491433,
-0.001181904,
-0.005167691,
-0.0000637818,
-0.0269123279,
0.0486879088,
0.0594469607,
0.0355483443,
0.0144946305,
-0.0135538569,
0.0546164326,
0.0625206307,
-0.0210192744,
0.0107455244,
-0.0237040091,
-0.0139961215,
0.0113781523,
-0.0252796896,
-0.0531740487,
0.0128483726,
0.0398158059,
-0.0303449966,
-0.0041603204,
0.1212731153,
0.0262950957,
-0.0034876321,
0.028545294,
-0.0279008448,
0.0588129684,
0.0114460886,
0.0035365841,
-0.0829881281,
-0.0249674972,
-0.0030431927,
-0.0430426262,
-0.0244060028,
-0.0399807282,
-0.009127426,
-0.125994876,
0.0133707598,
0.0072305365,
-0.0330260172,
0.0329647027,
-0.0088347206,
-0.0148831755,
0.0098704621,
-0.0048287609,
0.0105570331,
-0.0187807456,
-0.0016934712,
0.0048843725,
-0.0579038821,
-0.0271887109,
0.0241762698,
-0.0210205466,
0.0420086868,
0.0650392845,
0.0725702941,
-0.0418141112,
-0.000945952,
0.0784875974,
-0.0028382528,
-0.0235229507,
0.00226718,
0.0236313362,
0.0207025316,
-0.0112979515,
-0.0631530881,
0.0084385257,
0.0160202887,
-0.0120621044,
0.0353807956,
0.0514387153,
-0.0097120665,
-0.032449998,
-0.0201062132,
0.0250533409,
-0.0053300513,
0.0751890019,
0.0541048385,
-0.0512112528,
-0.021824142,
-0.0218091849,
-0.0169236511,
-0.0035127692,
-0.0522617362,
-0.0296039842,
0.0324588679,
-0.026614571,
-0.0897614062,
-0.0252289791,
-0.0096076354,
0.0036781137,
-0.0105230547,
0.0236865841,
-0.0016821092,
-0.0103276959,
0.0103317164,
0.0036867124,
-0.0292319674,
0.0083211474,
-0.0662918016,
0.0109159369,
0.0443789847,
-0.0133564658,
-0.0111502139,
0.0002287232,
-0.0793427601,
-0.0886329561,
-0.0073970733,
0.0132226413,
0.0277603734,
0.0036124259,
-0.0262045115,
-0.0797499046,
0.0128459632,
0.0324257612,
-0.0163165387,
0.0474655554,
0.0199401677,
0.0186817087,
0.0318787433,
0.0578444302,
-0.0092101255,
0.0011442637,
-0.0272342041,
0.0595050007,
-0.022991918,
-0.0631654561,
0.010152895,
0.034255933,
0.0174054671,
0.0060974918,
-0.0134031978,
-0.0048479955,
-0.0093991794,
-0.0664829388,
-0.0353334732,
-0.0545167141,
0.0300395228,
0.011936265,
0.0174355768,
-0.0133597674,
-0.0075322469,
-0.0541841239,
0.0495764837,
-0.014311675,
0.0294963084,
0.0135788806,
-0.0464244895,
0.0287472494,
0.0002887212,
-0.0135551943,
0.0139858071,
-0.045894634,
0.0363582037,
-0.0035051224,
0.0552286692,
0.00446914,
-0.0315981358,
0.0252145585,
0.0184618048,
-0.0547362119,
-0.0577434115,
0.0041496684,
0.0505775474,
0.0329741724,
-0.0030060725,
0.0885431021,
-0.0351381712,
-0.0195581075,
-0.0510971136,
0.0568663329,
0.0253316928,
-0.0715231225,
0.0161736682,
0.0217123237,
-0.062452022,
-0.0028876665,
0.0884523466,
0.0081292661,
-0.0000969977,
0.0286359899,
0.0041254568,
-0.0295013059,
-0.0106361462,
0.0218479205,
0.0044486858,
0.0140121588,
0.0450739861,
-0.0789502412,
-0.0687798038,
-0.0284505822,
-0.0107825343,
0.0109613277,
-0.0179686304,
0.022407122,
0.0736123174,
0.0004004214,
0.0055048419,
-0.0640806928,
0.0360998996,
-0.0451156683,
0.0059737503,
-0.0179966968,
-6.285387396e-33,
-0.0117289387,
-0.0311578568,
-0.0024230892,
0.0289588515,
-0.0246277303,
-0.005480567,
-0.049461551,
0.0279307831,
-0.0393310003,
0.0438144915,
-0.0154816424,
0.0103370538,
0.0031167015,
0.0302785821,
-0.0009091182,
-0.0187799782,
-0.0032422799,
0.0037601413,
-0.0099289045,
0.0188346654,
0.0168731157,
-0.00697162,
0.0358269401,
-0.050130982,
0.0332582667,
-0.0188797675,
0.0006441223,
0.0314583927,
-0.0029572297,
0.0568040088,
-0.0251527727,
0.0406973772,
0.0145000303,
-0.0305299703,
-0.0201718938,
0.0193486977,
-0.0106380088,
-0.0441168509,
0.0552776121,
-0.0254929569,
-0.0140691679,
-0.0352445953,
0.0190353934,
-0.0096589923,
-0.0444658622,
-0.0028851456,
0.0365894698,
-0.0194327477,
-0.0549610965,
0.0043954174,
-0.0547589734,
0.073631987,
-0.0151634812,
-0.0230479073,
-0.0259062331,
-0.0003035648,
0.0026542624,
0.0013809166,
0.0254365299,
0.0447637066,
0.0421032906,
0.0209716912,
0.0310761537,
-0.0030716006,
0.0313756354,
0.0594661124,
0.001033666,
0.0416902676,
0.0082634231,
0.010789006,
0.0182485655,
0.0559807308,
0.0311441105,
0.0578753874,
-0.0219073128,
0.0011454022,
-0.0449132547,
-0.0292766821,
0.0280801244,
0.0360502787,
0.0279827714,
0.0039430978,
-0.0549044646,
-0.0480886549,
-0.0444816947,
0.0365665816,
-0.0169605426,
-0.0335301273,
0.0228912625,
-0.0482133515,
-0.0084648719,
-0.0130130034,
0.0093803406,
-0.0750253648,
-0.0476129241,
0.0365197249,
-0.0397618376,
0.0056738527,
-0.0003366354,
0.03638383,
-0.0450284407,
-0.0091974549,
-0.0094934339,
0.0060749799,
-0.0020866937,
0.0018140015,
-0.0173155479,
0.0033551771,
-0.0514477901,
-0.0115622124,
-0.0232974179,
-0.0308711678,
-0.0139138028,
0.0171088874,
0.0244259294,
-0.0097509511,
-0.0201890878,
0.0459843501,
0.037972752,
-0.0050253533,
-0.0583957396,
-0.0503922142,
-0.0069405502,
-0.0148079814,
-0.0270548258,
0.0008709168,
-0.0382195786,
0.0211530775,
0.0616903715,
-0.0008602701,
-0.0156297572,
-0.0256887898,
2.825e-7,
0.0444614552,
0.0651361495,
0.0165346712,
0.0173422378,
0.0282734018,
0.0437653922,
-0.0238740388,
0.0076905158,
0.0106417546,
-0.0061802212,
-0.0156161832,
0.0116985478,
0.0681177229,
0.0165703092,
-0.0846406743,
-0.0142429601,
-0.1128041521,
-0.0414859615,
-0.0400641449,
-0.0150634767,
0.0637212917,
0.0866557062,
0.0192242581,
-0.0043485225,
-0.0277179796,
-0.0688180178,
0.0596989579,
-0.0578819253,
-0.054902412,
0.0365523696,
0.0231450628,
0.002654793,
0.0222257394,
-0.0255877785,
-0.0021591648,
0.0287172683,
0.0170385763,
0.0623005927,
0.0120786363,
0.0111558903,
0.027103696,
-0.0469910316,
-0.0209418125,
-0.0764930323,
0.0954420865,
-0.0337228626,
-0.052190654,
-0.0432757623,
-0.0012575217,
-0.021866329,
0.0223147757,
-0.0277538989,
-0.0450747237,
0.0140812704,
0.0326816067,
-0.0211314261,
-0.0204833373,
-0.0588610731,
-0.0433106571,
-0.0073188678,
-0.0495920107,
-0.0857982114,
-0.0269987229,
0.0235862099,
0.0159774311,
-0.0344942696,
0.0397072509,
2.513163071e-34,
0.0626315996,
0.0060193683,
0.029762743,
0.0206944533,
0.086621888,
0.0158807598,
0.0582992993,
0.0328162983,
0.0280055292,
-0.0984063447,
0.0098531153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07204v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07204v2 | Synergizing Spatial Optimization with Large Language Models for Open-Domain Urban Itinerary Planning | 2024-02-11T13:30:53 | 2024-05-23T10:24:00 | Yihong Tang, Zhaokai Wang, Ao Qu, Yihao Yan, Kebing Hou, Dingyi Zhuang, Xiaotong Guo, Jinhua Zhao, Zhan Zhao, Wei Ma | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce the novel task of Open-domain Urban Itinerary
Planning (OUIP), a paradigm designed to generate personalized urban itineraries
from user requests articulated in natural language. This approach is different
from traditional itinerary planning, which often restricts the granularity of
user inputs, thus hindering genuine personalization. To this end, we present
ItiNera, an OUIP system that synergizes spatial optimization with large
language models (LLMs) to provide services that customize urban itineraries
based on users' needs. Upon receiving the user's itinerary request, the LLM
first decomposes it into detailed components, identifying key requirements,
including preferences and dislikes. Then, we use these specifics to select
candidate POIs from a large-scale collection using embedding-based
Preference-aware POI Retrieval. Finally, a preference score-based Cluster-aware
Spatial Optimization module clusters, filters, and orders these POIs, followed
by the LLM for detailed POI selection and organization to craft a personalized,
spatially coherent itinerary. Moreover, we created an LLM-based pipeline to
update and personalize a user-owned POI database. This ensures up-to-date POI
information, supports itinerary planning, pre-trip research, POI collection,
recommendations, and more. To the best of our knowledge, this study marks the
first integration of LLMs to innovate itinerary planning, with potential
extensions for various urban travel and exploration activities. Offline and
online evaluations demonstrate the capacity of our system to deliver more
responsive, personalized, and spatially coherent itineraries than current
solutions. Our system, deployed on an online platform, has attracted thousands
of users for their urban travel planning. | [
0.0378945209,
0.0637344271,
-0.0114715686,
0.0111311981,
-0.0120492503,
-0.0427285321,
-0.0191702079,
-0.0265814401,
0.0224308558,
0.0013557697,
-0.041114971,
0.0136329904,
-0.0009910085,
0.0606646761,
-0.0057662074,
-0.0641844496,
0.0152349817,
-0.0440413766,
-0.0304304752,
0.0278695039,
-0.0044084126,
0.044463288,
-0.012591579,
0.0434419699,
0.0387593955,
0.0271795727,
-0.0427713767,
0.0163322352,
-0.0157526527,
-0.0800859556,
-0.0144433165,
0.022711847,
0.0667862147,
-0.0007440232,
0.0000021072,
-0.0040989299,
-0.0754649788,
-0.008404538,
0.0408101082,
-0.0223002657,
0.0622598492,
0.0676123872,
0.0320952907,
0.0134598035,
0.0053113634,
-0.0227612872,
0.0397305079,
0.0286621097,
0.0227820147,
0.0170861296,
0.003900704,
-0.0308552068,
-0.0237190146,
0.0169350766,
-0.0176384319,
0.0343914777,
-0.0059475885,
-0.0448533557,
0.0218725819,
0.0317229889,
0.0261098314,
-0.0414041094,
-0.0378429033,
-0.0171595309,
0.0255742408,
0.0164025351,
-0.0509621464,
-0.0270084869,
-0.0105392905,
0.0467503145,
0.0163936,
-0.024608789,
0.0408359058,
0.0357770398,
-0.0354412422,
-0.0059265676,
-0.0521152243,
-0.0160804279,
0.0386481024,
0.0619652905,
-0.0308453292,
0.031389758,
0.0199636202,
0.0367013589,
-0.0140033476,
0.1097015366,
0.0091402791,
-0.0296210796,
-0.0583359115,
-0.0095075034,
0.0132380053,
-0.0720639005,
0.0234158561,
0.0188179743,
-0.0545438901,
-0.0104019567,
0.031234283,
0.0669740811,
-0.0194311179,
-0.0037326366,
0.091307953,
0.0014301909,
0.0146298371,
0.0245549679,
0.0614484623,
-0.0136161158,
0.0069718193,
-0.0126964683,
-0.05890714,
-0.0071616522,
-0.0287735425,
0.0043923864,
-0.0431968048,
0.0291943122,
-0.089350082,
0.0137842866,
0.0079151019,
0.0556233488,
0.0004542028,
0.0124509977,
-0.0323344469,
0.0503204539,
0.0332123563,
-0.0138146393,
-0.0465527028,
-0.0002601404,
-0.0299481973,
-0.0231471639,
0.0161049403,
0.0527097173,
0.0402868316,
0.0360332169,
0.0571569838,
0.00408389,
-0.0526795164,
0.0307075307,
0.0126642371,
-0.0004762139,
-0.0503895171,
-0.0650484264,
0.0066846125,
-0.0343583524,
-0.0218283236,
-0.0968609303,
0.014756483,
0.0176542923,
-0.0318532363,
-0.027076792,
-0.0011426497,
0.0180607494,
-0.0164426267,
0.0200496241,
0.017040249,
0.0382268764,
0.0414419621,
-0.0147447344,
0.0745816976,
0.0066670463,
0.0193681214,
0.1046770066,
0.0652434602,
0.0246501267,
-0.014236629,
0.0142692775,
-0.0125085153,
0.0205951147,
-0.0031154591,
0.0404177345,
0.0048133126,
0.0201521795,
-0.0515150465,
0.0238860492,
-0.0515969694,
0.0561018884,
0.0542963892,
0.0379753485,
0.0108019207,
0.0016508549,
0.0430341735,
0.0700994506,
-0.0788291246,
-0.0600230023,
0.0182266422,
0.0151801025,
-0.0163722504,
-0.028750049,
0.0554061718,
0.0118851168,
-0.0137488181,
-0.0318759307,
0.0202078596,
-0.0227510426,
0.0574830845,
0.0162630845,
0.0252321009,
-0.0649456903,
-0.0499704555,
0.0257908721,
0.001727574,
-0.0452772379,
0.0267557409,
0.0106115472,
0.0453211144,
0.1060167626,
0.0228324141,
0.0027158759,
0.0390254147,
-0.0105555598,
-0.0019983812,
-0.033258561,
0.0823541433,
-0.0269542988,
-0.0220937226,
-0.0403645933,
-0.0297282413,
0.0628456697,
0.012319237,
-0.0342555903,
0.0528711639,
0.0238027424,
0.02927332,
-0.027772842,
-0.0232038964,
-0.0303470641,
0.0313707925,
-0.0494987294,
-0.0048985812,
0.032808885,
0.002659657,
0.0256377961,
0.0115025034,
0.0054068337,
0.0556262471,
-0.0049453299,
0.0083783539,
0.004409431,
0.0142196538,
0.0521015078,
-0.0016664863,
0.001779241,
-0.0211257227,
0.0355924517,
-0.0203323439,
-0.0278095845,
0.0051503144,
0.0061709448,
0.0142764049,
0.0247233007,
0.0385640003,
0.0342429988,
-0.0034343819,
-0.056805186,
0.0344998688,
0.0120136961,
-0.0194081813,
-0.0157819856,
-0.0001900198,
0.0398199186,
-0.0212769881,
-0.0212654676,
0.0035309088,
0.0148203718,
0.0310257934,
0.0010506496,
-0.004573816,
-0.0295877419,
-0.0195040647,
-0.1271311343,
0.0105914343,
0.0146532683,
0.0084420964,
-0.0019377215,
0.0066533089,
0.0036199344,
-0.0019957407,
-0.0218449086,
0.0368295461,
-0.0276236348,
-0.0157620255,
0.0173474066,
-0.0083570769,
-0.0040613874,
-0.0079025766,
-0.0059383628,
-0.0288710464,
0.0080943676,
-0.0140076224,
0.0098574022,
-0.0236155931,
-0.0354205333,
-0.0718795955,
-0.0127516948,
0.0474497192,
-0.0055979402,
0.0107672447,
-0.0305106305,
0.0136985919,
-0.0133352326,
0.0219501108,
-0.0269687138,
0.0359511636,
-0.0552188233,
-0.0853544623,
-0.0006184509,
-0.0745963454,
0.0139351143,
-0.0129112499,
-0.0444717966,
0.0197251476,
-0.023593599,
-0.0318169408,
0.0137748178,
-0.0290807132,
-0.0028990887,
-0.0252870452,
0.0284669269,
-0.0213471148,
0.0391684584,
0.0047855568,
0.0998775214,
-0.0193631835,
-0.0286742523,
0.0289774071,
-0.0008567453,
0.0263589602,
-0.014786995,
-0.0027660371,
-0.0520055369,
0.0452497303,
0.0124831321,
0.0589152053,
-0.0011094592,
0.0062253098,
0.0216302183,
-0.0154548353,
-0.0711303577,
-0.03283922,
-0.0005893337,
-0.0139157725,
-0.0449808724,
0.0342710428,
-0.0899253339,
-0.0010599436,
-0.0288475901,
-0.029761022,
-0.0366555005,
0.0204275101,
-0.0609249845,
-0.0082891583,
0.0349696539,
-0.0009815751,
0.0544307344,
0.0211854726,
-0.0255133156,
-0.0136065781,
-0.0250234492,
0.0571747981,
0.1031657383,
0.0051896265,
0.0713413581,
-0.0672961548,
0.060459625,
-0.0140840225,
-0.0445859283,
0.0244544931,
0.064686358,
0.0773917511,
-0.0338206403,
-0.0112037873,
0.0555920601,
0.0158548374,
-0.0117026055,
-0.0236212444,
0.0426621102,
0.0661178529,
-0.0616102926,
0.0052488633,
-0.0226721857,
0.0542699359,
0.0149363568,
0.053891886,
-0.0586174279,
0.0031695419,
-0.0315586329,
0.0115935858,
-0.007377727,
-0.0337421224,
-0.0257634874,
-0.0955600366,
0.0566929877,
-0.0015108983,
-0.0450730622,
0.0370170623,
-0.0747281313,
-0.016807409,
0.0070296763,
-0.0485967249,
-0.0079297014,
-0.0035673922,
-0.0122648757,
0.0032385769,
-0.0414763242,
-0.0335449874,
-0.0092105353,
-0.0585438572,
0.0165980384,
0.047800459,
0.0765537322,
0.0174057838,
-0.0470701978,
-0.0213974956,
0.0675873756,
0.0215253923,
-0.055716835,
-0.0260057971,
-0.0111396359,
0.0190794207,
-0.049070958,
0.0225421619,
-0.0638979748,
-0.0330975875,
0.0085724313,
0.0779383555,
-0.0108935563,
0.0611186363,
-0.0479725115,
0.0162665471,
0.0295272656,
0.0241781007,
-0.0327928215,
-0.0432673097,
-0.0096066771,
-0.0746973604,
-0.0090373233,
-0.0225402713,
-0.0057558599,
-0.0060868845,
0.0285825431,
0.0049676946,
-0.0523755737,
-0.0051878886,
0.0205757972,
0.0288699679,
-0.0219548531,
-0.0037216025,
-0.0056696231,
-0.0447797328,
-0.0411668904,
0.0238939673,
-0.0226453785,
-0.0133656617,
-0.0545581728,
0.0084493179,
-0.0085761612,
-0.0247712322,
0.0000283898,
0.0022159254,
-0.0166461691,
-0.0487201922,
0.0031729226,
0.0529042259,
0.0155203883,
0.0062636686,
-0.0173588172,
-0.0460599028,
0.0146206236,
-0.0045836414,
0.0125443852,
-0.0453281254,
-0.0213153381,
0.0525441878,
0.0184273627,
0.0199476462,
-0.0480595306,
-0.0007377345,
-0.017252041,
0.0026464937,
-0.0473996215,
0.0001767675,
0.0204813071,
0.0300294831,
0.0545472614,
0.018017441,
-0.0044868561,
-0.0175185036,
0.019602865,
-0.0133462371,
-0.0145047922,
-0.0173979085,
-0.0188197028,
0.0312379915,
-0.0001025566,
-0.0003887376,
0.0470630378,
0.0177718457,
-0.0477550626,
-0.0326319411,
-0.0031033237,
0.0116829379,
-0.0295655746,
0.0209375564,
0.0288798064,
-0.0231196675,
0.009584385,
-0.0502433218,
0.0226571187,
-0.0331726037,
-0.0064303228,
0.010807598,
0.0194820985,
-0.0620666631,
0.0549851134,
0.014017079,
-0.0623973571,
0.0127680115,
0.0027102106,
0.0088643022,
-0.0289656613,
-0.018887965,
-0.0188622754,
-0.0191768873,
0.0025923997,
-0.0275336839,
-0.004084073,
-0.0297217909,
-0.0016456243,
0.017122142,
-0.0004466831,
0.0023694362,
0.0425651111,
-0.010272353,
-0.0172623284,
-0.010290849,
-0.0549857654,
-0.0470421091,
0.0332299508,
-0.0202720631,
0.0735574365,
-0.0277518481,
-0.0005268964,
-0.017370047,
-0.003181566,
0.0099488869,
-0.0080246199,
-0.0379926786,
-0.0047293874,
0.0508761406,
-0.012407626,
-0.0134897782,
-0.0193641223,
-0.0426835567,
-0.040663708,
-0.0512850359,
-0.044118654,
-0.0086303074,
-6.94942342e-33,
-0.0022725521,
-0.0645611882,
0.0880352929,
-0.010028936,
-0.0042941491,
-0.0674202666,
0.0108862156,
0.0201233122,
0.0026960911,
-0.0354202762,
-0.0114098424,
-0.0354105718,
0.0159513373,
0.0478088222,
0.0045419903,
0.0083989417,
0.0416989662,
0.01951278,
-0.0432076678,
-0.0108039714,
0.0767935291,
-0.0062259343,
-0.0078090327,
-0.083799459,
-0.0160184577,
-0.0256175045,
-0.0212332904,
0.0306007527,
0.0296935979,
0.0787845924,
0.0106207356,
0.0251589566,
0.0066523096,
0.0013437305,
-0.0239260793,
0.0287462864,
-0.0213301647,
-0.028246874,
0.0253891591,
0.0049780337,
-0.0018360898,
-0.0155974189,
0.0147981765,
0.0106875626,
0.0171603933,
0.0495468006,
0.0177476592,
-0.0033996163,
-0.0394296236,
0.0683311448,
-0.0097508347,
0.0003475906,
0.0029032023,
0.0223135483,
0.064838618,
0.003343707,
0.0001586283,
0.0534094721,
-0.0266666543,
0.0670989677,
-0.0308515448,
0.0170421693,
-0.0048308354,
-0.0111613916,
0.0121871382,
0.0504911989,
-0.011481476,
-0.022271689,
-0.0249246731,
-0.0090002595,
0.0084806234,
0.0825452358,
-0.0294196457,
0.0293328147,
-0.0313453302,
-0.0051451111,
-0.0128823435,
-0.0021028714,
-0.0634609684,
-0.051141046,
0.0331277736,
0.0578350164,
-0.0222479515,
-0.0285659824,
-0.030804323,
-0.0399355441,
-0.040375106,
-0.0343477093,
0.0349634402,
0.054287035,
-0.044798892,
0.0667920634,
0.0188036393,
-0.0429790504,
-0.0693074241,
-0.00846837,
-0.0133183002,
0.0011814189,
-0.0120870909,
0.0292956326,
-0.0989481658,
-0.0310711507,
-0.0460745282,
-0.0633768365,
-0.020394953,
0.0510731414,
-0.0153880371,
0.0149995144,
-0.0333839245,
0.0231307633,
0.0315591805,
-0.040265426,
-0.0335945003,
-0.0092958603,
0.0596832372,
-0.019669719,
-0.0064948467,
0.0261750892,
0.0481600091,
0.0416855924,
-0.0036783495,
-0.08248014,
-0.0079853488,
0.0015484267,
0.0219644643,
0.0193493944,
-0.0010084419,
-0.0204074848,
0.0172187574,
-0.0177995786,
-0.0187653694,
0.0176169965,
2.867e-7,
0.0080826432,
0.0746587813,
-0.0331760943,
-0.0127117718,
-0.0059381542,
0.022270564,
0.0495034829,
-0.003174783,
-0.0332407504,
0.0610910766,
0.017064577,
0.0297704153,
0.0053992416,
0.0513126031,
-0.0719468817,
0.080359742,
-0.0137683926,
0.0111529939,
-0.0950008333,
0.0156540051,
0.0570859127,
0.096054323,
0.0405156687,
0.0210677031,
0.0055527235,
0.0214735232,
-0.0141078569,
-0.0683677867,
-0.0340598151,
0.0152320089,
0.0127481213,
0.0191262756,
-0.0189721826,
-0.0497943014,
-0.0504323505,
-0.0162936524,
0.0133111281,
0.0430521145,
-0.0205146186,
-0.0445712507,
0.0329074524,
-0.0673758462,
-0.011215956,
-0.0825401023,
0.0301423371,
-0.0017549811,
0.0150925731,
0.0183709674,
-0.0215129405,
0.0011219538,
0.0199793465,
0.009907173,
-0.0138497166,
-0.0047317799,
0.0054101283,
0.0078372825,
-0.009144743,
-0.0810829848,
0.0226425622,
0.023621738,
-0.0129498718,
0.0196596179,
-0.0517624579,
0.0077027725,
-0.0001054521,
0.0186219532,
0.0220110379,
2.422997373e-34,
-0.001062523,
0.0770046487,
-0.0314028934,
-0.0345263407,
0.0686723441,
-0.0062505254,
-0.0115886284,
0.0288063567,
0.0162585434,
-0.0345053673,
0.0018568141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07179v2 | Prompt Perturbation in Retrieval-Augmented Generation based Large Language Models | 2024-02-11T12:25:41 | 2024-06-20T14:07:27 | Zhibo Hu, Chen Wang, Yanfeng Shu, Helen, Paik, Liming Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; H.3.3 | The robustness of large language models (LLMs) becomes increasingly important
as their use rapidly grows in a wide range of domains. Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) is considered as a means to improve the trustworthiness of
text generation from LLMs. However, how the outputs from RAG-based LLMs are
affected by slightly different inputs is not well studied. In this work, we
find that the insertion of even a short prefix to the prompt leads to the
generation of outputs far away from factually correct answers. We
systematically evaluate the effect of such prefixes on RAG by introducing a
novel optimization technique called Gradient Guided Prompt Perturbation (GGPP).
GGPP achieves a high success rate in steering outputs of RAG-based LLMs to
targeted wrong answers. It can also cope with instructions in the prompts
requesting to ignore irrelevant context. We also exploit LLMs' neuron
activation difference between prompts with and without GGPP perturbations to
give a method that improves the robustness of RAG-based LLMs through a highly
effective detector trained on neuron activation triggered by GGPP generated
prompts. Our evaluation on open-sourced LLMs demonstrates the effectiveness of
our methods. | [
0.056716457,
0.0361396186,
-0.0075072711,
0.0437411629,
-0.0296768211,
-0.0256572925,
0.0240169484,
0.0130630089,
0.0144635867,
-0.0345262289,
-0.0137728956,
-0.0554611869,
-0.0075217076,
0.0232822858,
0.0458210632,
0.0054997155,
0.0768959001,
-0.0366061516,
-0.0287037119,
-0.0174141899,
-0.0093973223,
0.0052369111,
0.0126239303,
0.0415754952,
-0.0225496721,
-0.0109373834,
-0.0017703706,
0.0343406908,
0.0083404444,
-0.0243322663,
0.0259724278,
0.0452086516,
0.0058898185,
0.0701852292,
0.0000022633,
-0.0451160967,
-0.0054512266,
-0.0103819855,
-0.0215850472,
0.0318995379,
0.015310376,
0.0285570435,
-0.0187213086,
0.0289680492,
-0.0206051711,
0.0143603981,
0.0255523268,
0.0323361903,
0.0655714497,
0.0918737426,
0.0277344137,
0.0115866261,
0.0343445614,
-0.0366421156,
0.0558937378,
-0.0312829018,
0.0287193153,
-0.0432508662,
-0.0097884219,
0.0526121892,
-0.0067947274,
0.0237321761,
0.0269784722,
-0.024599554,
0.0097812572,
0.0390442498,
0.0089237839,
-0.0305519532,
-0.0452408195,
0.0537455231,
-0.0060017705,
-0.030813409,
0.0037937812,
-0.0177901406,
0.0204062387,
0.0038281463,
-0.0213164836,
0.0403744727,
-0.0067787715,
0.0084455656,
-0.0062378347,
-0.0163783394,
0.0365631208,
0.0368873104,
0.0013955447,
0.0520377159,
0.0321342163,
-0.0341707207,
-0.0241086464,
-0.0074213091,
-0.0302660931,
-0.0622237176,
0.0101390928,
0.0523925535,
-0.0591684543,
0.0282627698,
-0.0474793948,
-0.007223112,
0.0341903493,
0.0236842968,
0.0368647985,
0.0331450813,
-0.007560004,
0.0053180852,
-0.0475051329,
0.0721229538,
-0.0251111034,
0.0103679867,
-0.0278238337,
0.0189453643,
-0.0070823021,
-0.0304078609,
-0.0248033032,
0.0261202529,
-0.0440317616,
-0.0130701093,
-0.0423590653,
0.0331707746,
-0.0050767651,
-0.0017656214,
0.0008713188,
0.0381037369,
-0.0534762181,
-0.0267520659,
-0.0364112817,
0.0050890832,
-0.0246586371,
0.0139947534,
0.0529773571,
-0.0666617975,
-0.0281772055,
0.0211211741,
-0.0127423238,
-0.0189502835,
0.0113580851,
0.0542430654,
-0.0222490393,
-0.0312345196,
-0.05538157,
-0.0703291595,
-0.0426684283,
-0.0448040552,
0.0056772451,
-0.0679219961,
0.0133235259,
-0.0258536506,
-0.0386098959,
-0.047650259,
0.0299890172,
0.0479200892,
-0.0278017279,
0.0137491897,
-0.0226589087,
0.0114135696,
0.0483640917,
0.0147964712,
-0.0289955195,
0.0100619048,
0.0125370231,
0.0620567538,
0.0291188695,
0.0173606556,
0.0044778362,
0.0166545752,
0.0538407788,
0.0292729791,
0.0036566542,
-0.0150567032,
0.0139496177,
0.0272862259,
0.0271120351,
0.0941648558,
-0.0395766534,
-0.014804407,
0.0881218165,
0.0214565806,
-0.0180099346,
-0.0026491117,
0.0526958853,
0.0030155629,
-0.0151293296,
0.0252193622,
-0.0599070936,
0.0096842768,
-0.0747658312,
0.0198487155,
0.0328930616,
0.0426789299,
-0.0183013491,
-0.0305871218,
0.0139361676,
-0.00720351,
-0.0007009792,
0.024542572,
0.0082676755,
0.0210662261,
-0.0722637326,
0.0084078787,
0.010197863,
-0.047817979,
0.0270883013,
-0.074705705,
0.0831496418,
0.0303523522,
0.06043135,
0.0126857003,
0.001766784,
-0.012657512,
-0.0062433477,
0.0663729906,
0.0311862733,
0.0140143242,
-0.0206890441,
-0.0524499044,
0.0000748935,
-0.0072298557,
0.0051831892,
0.0300259553,
0.0513302386,
-0.0169544537,
0.055718489,
0.0331611224,
-0.0226350222,
0.0443910472,
-0.0158768669,
-0.0556181632,
0.0204604529,
-0.0073844679,
0.010328006,
0.0060724318,
-0.0064288364,
0.0425464511,
0.0234440863,
-0.0155149996,
-0.0116840973,
-0.0583066344,
-0.0706450641,
-0.0372113138,
0.026178902,
0.0321879536,
0.0007424238,
0.0150788166,
-0.0156179154,
-0.0439911149,
-0.010923746,
-0.0554477014,
0.005312968,
-0.0792175308,
0.0256587397,
0.0210510045,
0.0108810309,
-0.0757141486,
0.05634927,
-0.0006537131,
0.0022582125,
0.0356409959,
0.086644426,
0.01174659,
-0.0592694022,
-0.0374995396,
-0.0039939242,
-0.0184586179,
0.0344404168,
0.0657699779,
0.0193717349,
-0.0238300171,
-0.0457610376,
-0.0495224223,
0.0128332833,
-0.0154311862,
-0.0120535037,
0.018687075,
-0.0038711198,
-0.0174154676,
0.0075568375,
-0.0364240482,
0.0119483368,
0.0439393297,
0.0211157557,
0.0145896822,
0.0105719678,
0.0085436646,
-0.0379858911,
-0.0132562369,
0.002202794,
0.0368417874,
0.0142685892,
0.0001116105,
-0.0739761144,
0.0531016737,
-0.0474493876,
0.0180576369,
0.0078602042,
-0.037387155,
0.0130866738,
-0.0072669243,
0.059398286,
0.0612680949,
0.0407741889,
-0.0113120135,
0.033482559,
0.0021747549,
-0.0675584674,
0.0086413343,
-0.0407654382,
-0.068999961,
0.0256059524,
-0.0335501991,
0.044888027,
0.0557124913,
0.0491687432,
-0.0287412163,
-0.0539728031,
0.0393794104,
-0.0133321304,
-0.0579262637,
-0.0358994789,
-0.0375615992,
-0.0457249284,
0.0468481071,
-0.0299067311,
-0.0778841674,
0.0981397554,
-0.046341449,
0.0326811783,
-0.0353507586,
0.0106548006,
-0.0026798144,
0.0056024455,
-0.0011072649,
0.0400174148,
0.0345469564,
-0.0063964934,
-0.0635403022,
-0.0210850313,
0.010654971,
-0.0418131649,
0.024393864,
-0.0304236487,
-0.0046727806,
0.0063984464,
-0.0348320641,
-0.0769411474,
-0.0661664754,
0.0242939368,
-0.0047968235,
0.0205978546,
-0.0105537111,
-0.0037752029,
-0.0154167395,
0.0536367334,
0.0259386748,
-0.0660445467,
0.0056945803,
-0.0394981354,
0.0374650769,
0.0720493272,
-0.0264944024,
0.0375729613,
-0.0375754498,
-0.0041203457,
0.0456707068,
-0.0018364033,
0.0058945511,
-0.0066218325,
-0.0037456027,
0.0157075487,
-0.0113538429,
-0.0263827983,
0.0663797334,
0.0390618145,
-0.0667027533,
-0.0359419174,
0.0849675685,
0.03013267,
-0.0321052261,
-0.0045883572,
-0.0191733073,
0.0378918462,
-0.0001227846,
0.0409009345,
-0.0494279787,
-0.0242409706,
0.0140077733,
0.0297417641,
-0.0306296665,
-0.000881472,
-0.019160429,
-0.1520229727,
0.0380550884,
0.0316912793,
0.0017219997,
-0.0279975459,
-0.0225465689,
-0.0170263629,
0.0563505739,
0.0405811705,
0.0708906129,
0.0001902513,
-0.0006703128,
0.0177956745,
0.0269860886,
-0.0468720272,
-0.0146224415,
-0.0215938129,
0.0586165823,
0.0981475487,
-0.0128747495,
0.0037179361,
-0.0618225299,
0.0576531067,
-0.0142329726,
0.0288914256,
-0.0091337673,
0.0055338135,
0.0008510329,
0.0067555094,
-0.0457513109,
0.0291056652,
0.0043120687,
-0.0211639963,
-0.0005502289,
0.0554949604,
-0.0237140972,
-0.0119117964,
-0.0247248281,
0.0070331725,
0.0392552875,
0.0692708343,
0.0248697605,
-0.0507681407,
-0.0303265043,
-0.0241459757,
-0.0052037002,
-0.0206709672,
-0.0152291851,
0.015466664,
-0.0097702602,
-0.0069779488,
-0.0879084468,
-0.0305395275,
-0.0257790573,
0.0162513498,
0.0053276871,
-0.0204822086,
-0.0194210149,
-0.0154260211,
-0.0186541453,
0.0333839282,
-0.0477613769,
0.0289862938,
-0.098707594,
0.0408467203,
0.0314628929,
-0.0613805801,
-0.0040694363,
0.042712383,
-0.0511244498,
-0.095167987,
-0.0304846503,
0.0552031696,
0.0205206163,
0.0254515857,
-0.0024829153,
-0.0678348541,
0.0710188374,
0.0472093746,
-0.0185115971,
0.0358925909,
-0.0096550053,
0.0177246556,
-0.0236201752,
0.0128239961,
-0.0461197123,
0.0173632298,
0.0338494591,
0.0624377802,
0.0131467795,
-0.0282808933,
0.0363981724,
0.0466414355,
0.0624150448,
-0.0335098095,
0.026016349,
-0.0387202874,
0.0107118618,
-0.0087493425,
-0.0031105601,
-0.0065874462,
0.0242220126,
0.0282890908,
-0.0355020687,
0.0220331643,
-0.0423561372,
-0.0033040296,
0.0807039738,
-0.028450409,
-0.0372849591,
-0.0339889713,
0.033401262,
0.034205988,
-0.0026282973,
-0.0423020199,
0.0394526534,
-0.0130322045,
0.0313095376,
0.0096576903,
0.0665451959,
0.0190502256,
-0.0273264088,
-0.0234432053,
0.0127285346,
-0.0505048893,
-0.0324633941,
-0.0200638268,
0.0207736436,
0.0310535226,
0.0455623791,
0.0234524123,
-0.0161760077,
-0.0191689003,
-0.0425865017,
0.0049221516,
0.0485414863,
-0.0496111922,
0.06275516,
0.0046845763,
0.0005828664,
0.0043153195,
0.0542265512,
-0.003898158,
0.0231755748,
-0.017430013,
0.005756407,
-0.0261136089,
-0.039470125,
0.0041471911,
0.0044583501,
-0.049367018,
0.0011604599,
-0.0421036631,
-0.0564457104,
0.0052120383,
0.0424157865,
-0.0027978308,
-0.0116686653,
0.0341788605,
0.0436019897,
-0.0124828182,
-0.0035917414,
-0.0404518135,
0.0283809509,
-0.037449941,
-0.023991311,
-0.0258813985,
-6.94343648e-33,
-0.0378225371,
-0.0337212346,
0.0166329686,
-0.0255988222,
-0.018654706,
0.0030445186,
-0.0310786199,
0.0090496819,
0.0025708359,
-0.0137760146,
-0.0357391946,
-0.0190996844,
0.0013885124,
0.0324033499,
-0.0280610938,
-0.0067031314,
0.050836008,
-0.0037768495,
-0.0543555357,
0.0388614126,
0.0394668952,
0.0171802156,
-0.0061601382,
-0.0440014005,
0.0302992426,
-0.0288739018,
-0.0309397914,
0.0145049095,
-0.0477855206,
0.0558728427,
-0.0196159687,
0.0538022146,
0.0050730044,
-0.0308604017,
-0.0178482253,
0.0534589104,
-0.0192477722,
-0.0185466371,
0.0252040606,
-0.0402062871,
-0.0519418567,
-0.0634354055,
0.0206453446,
-0.0200533848,
-0.0375129469,
0.0165933166,
0.0001178208,
-0.0128716994,
-0.0456892885,
-0.0315095857,
-0.0428820066,
-0.0020235083,
0.0453191102,
-0.0383382402,
-0.0492722206,
0.0618841052,
-0.0210069735,
0.0218214821,
-0.0329073183,
0.0214522593,
0.0328835137,
0.0517535247,
0.0497708693,
0.0391510054,
-0.0085288612,
0.0368921719,
0.0225779191,
-0.0053214896,
-0.0167055614,
-0.0432843864,
0.0020507656,
-0.001930738,
0.0584355593,
0.089861922,
0.0173619092,
-0.0331829749,
-0.0723196864,
0.03029605,
0.0228020847,
0.0313771963,
0.0576601997,
-0.0126083493,
-0.0189796463,
-0.0064116768,
-0.0622773059,
-0.0016113365,
-0.0389815159,
-0.0237921383,
0.0478484705,
0.0370366126,
-0.0358969979,
-0.0287867449,
0.0429593213,
-0.017802652,
0.0179739539,
0.021715641,
-0.027230164,
-0.0293973368,
-0.0229004752,
0.0238562413,
-0.0304288603,
-0.0127514685,
0.04399864,
-0.0414896496,
-0.0241697039,
0.0212992616,
0.0019758542,
0.0177347809,
-0.0467849337,
0.0333913863,
-0.0459924489,
0.0538262762,
0.02728194,
-0.0001826433,
0.0239404906,
-0.0171952471,
-0.0135869011,
0.0435874425,
0.0024462244,
-0.0066013113,
-0.0249458421,
-0.0013175185,
0.0008212941,
0.0386586711,
-0.0488003194,
0.0382045843,
-0.0163976122,
0.064800255,
0.0082052434,
-0.0394817665,
-0.0078973882,
0.0040987474,
3.016e-7,
-0.0227042232,
0.0455090366,
0.0219152588,
0.044316683,
0.0061903838,
0.0308797732,
0.0185875446,
0.0302837417,
0.0343071781,
-0.0394927524,
-0.0184020959,
0.0017414273,
0.0314798579,
-0.0017004866,
-0.0672916323,
0.0240671355,
-0.0734569281,
0.0349654481,
-0.0687342882,
-0.0148377754,
0.0501469746,
0.0718972385,
-0.0081059979,
-0.0332940817,
0.0090389922,
-0.0277355406,
0.0783856437,
-0.0029526614,
-0.0176714323,
0.0124853784,
0.0620522685,
-0.013322507,
0.0067249271,
0.0133517291,
0.0052444255,
0.0025223785,
-0.0270260572,
0.0528250113,
0.0085344184,
-0.0548878834,
-0.0032924504,
-0.0162795987,
-0.0047152387,
-0.079366684,
0.0470040925,
-0.0168321915,
0.0152655989,
-0.0318313912,
-0.0110221999,
-0.0342356227,
0.0198386703,
-0.078912802,
-0.0369050428,
-0.0055540144,
-0.0008851237,
0.0464977026,
-0.0015921447,
-0.0532011278,
-0.0365172066,
-0.0236681104,
-0.0406344086,
-0.0643536299,
-0.0399663448,
0.029453095,
-0.0085656634,
-0.075125888,
0.0052245343,
3.009794281e-34,
0.0221887864,
-0.0240355656,
0.0148000689,
-0.0063914694,
0.0401543118,
0.0206720028,
-0.0251584034,
0.0235120617,
0.0246387664,
-0.0834171399,
-0.0519239828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07157v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07157v2 | Natural Language Reinforcement Learning | 2024-02-11T11:03:04 | 2024-02-14T19:59:05 | Xidong Feng, Ziyu Wan, Mengyue Yang, Ziyan Wang, Girish A. Koushik, Yali Du, Ying Wen, Jun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Reinforcement Learning (RL) has shown remarkable abilities in learning
policies for decision-making tasks. However, RL is often hindered by issues
such as low sample efficiency, lack of interpretability, and sparse supervision
signals. To tackle these limitations, we take inspiration from the human
learning process and introduce Natural Language Reinforcement Learning (NLRL),
which innovatively combines RL principles with natural language representation.
Specifically, NLRL redefines RL concepts like task objectives, policy, value
function, Bellman equation, and policy iteration in natural language space. We
present how NLRL can be practically implemented with the latest advancements in
large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4. Initial experiments over tabular MDPs
demonstrate the effectiveness, efficiency, and also interpretability of the
NLRL framework. | [
0.0310803764,
0.0729432553,
0.0042520128,
-0.0000344419,
-0.0307582915,
-0.0029909723,
-0.0164768267,
0.0031054788,
0.0057332641,
-0.0282937419,
-0.0050470973,
0.0038566033,
-0.0427966863,
0.044511918,
0.0040029832,
-0.0639989227,
0.0424485914,
-0.0403181799,
0.0439986363,
0.0092129149,
0.0304579325,
-0.0079636294,
-0.0146707501,
0.0472856387,
0.0110515468,
0.0236094221,
-0.0307770986,
-0.0122052943,
0.0243645571,
-0.0460585095,
0.0115359286,
0.022144137,
0.0768833235,
0.0544928312,
0.0000019603,
-0.0563310236,
-0.0403917357,
0.0079696588,
-0.0049267211,
-0.0128674572,
0.0561601669,
-0.0464581959,
-0.0146542583,
0.0362788066,
-0.030438669,
-0.0182721056,
0.0349222645,
0.0814227462,
0.0675623193,
0.0861078873,
0.0009597043,
-0.0285807718,
-0.0043886704,
-0.0244129803,
0.0367845781,
-0.0700989887,
0.0193978585,
0.0151273441,
0.0352021977,
0.0056943656,
-0.0216456167,
-0.0234391596,
0.0224026106,
0.0049062362,
-0.0531306081,
0.0524397194,
0.0132539384,
0.0085540405,
-0.0386174023,
0.0303791519,
-0.0035041687,
-0.0083560618,
0.0313075557,
-0.026592467,
-0.0088637099,
0.0092239063,
-0.0335612446,
0.0331582688,
0.0125540672,
0.0544737093,
-0.0056793811,
0.0037781927,
0.0148925157,
0.0239545871,
-0.0348960906,
0.0835159421,
-0.0162794273,
-0.0569647886,
0.0216561407,
-0.0057824338,
0.0071761403,
-0.0126100881,
0.0273168031,
0.0294414684,
-0.070113726,
0.0262801982,
-0.0417770669,
0.0137111405,
0.0275512487,
-0.047481101,
0.039958667,
0.0429427512,
0.036553409,
0.0451654308,
-0.00818987,
0.0516567938,
-0.0119278515,
0.0201247856,
0.0035071047,
0.0077178678,
-0.0731041282,
-0.0176250618,
-0.0344921164,
0.0366270393,
-0.0413826294,
-0.0264443252,
-0.0452139191,
0.0386104919,
-0.0225889124,
0.0216686465,
-0.0032852225,
0.003927879,
-0.0450878777,
0.0044506816,
-0.1012478471,
0.025747275,
-0.0317492858,
-0.0023230936,
-0.0087018497,
-0.0079882406,
-0.0115862507,
-0.008422005,
-0.0174264777,
-0.0316983163,
0.0203367732,
0.1007163748,
0.0060608699,
-0.0170759819,
-0.0272974409,
0.0073292237,
-0.0144039616,
-0.0602778867,
-0.0130022187,
-0.0791605785,
0.0041967141,
-0.032138586,
-0.0168673322,
-0.0261758938,
0.0214706827,
0.0411758423,
-0.0247395877,
0.0852267817,
0.0287621524,
-0.0384835638,
-0.014678672,
-0.0344630964,
0.0055053444,
0.0827703178,
0.0326453038,
0.0239033308,
-0.0140803531,
0.0216878932,
-0.00127933,
0.0113769704,
0.0047388854,
0.0260344036,
-0.03020804,
-0.0186530855,
0.0026578424,
0.0624515153,
0.0481757261,
0.021568967,
-0.0308911987,
0.0142908432,
0.0513978563,
0.0547133014,
0.0086964527,
-0.0201907493,
0.0233776309,
0.0658683032,
-0.0343715213,
-0.0363749564,
-0.0446054041,
0.0121689932,
-0.0213276669,
0.0035862834,
0.0050582956,
0.0169728193,
0.0036660868,
-0.0574565791,
0.0176493116,
-0.0072088633,
0.0610363744,
0.0197494905,
0.0587450452,
-0.0093331691,
-0.0551055111,
-0.020149434,
0.0519912131,
0.0109963268,
-0.0127825439,
-0.0445332825,
0.0435712971,
0.076208517,
0.0419236459,
-0.0455097221,
-0.0226214379,
-0.0462131165,
-0.0197976846,
0.0477241501,
0.021707207,
0.014933927,
0.0056901723,
-0.0309695248,
-0.046553459,
0.0055737197,
0.0158532709,
0.035576541,
0.0202815738,
0.0134796184,
-0.0123243583,
0.0156036615,
-0.0612742864,
0.0415784493,
0.0379199348,
-0.0538549423,
0.0196970794,
-0.0292825978,
0.0487617962,
-0.0057173963,
-0.0024845579,
-0.0063289688,
0.0152546931,
0.0084411241,
-0.0415971503,
-0.0437853038,
-0.0490844697,
-0.0304957461,
0.0361832902,
-0.0307536647,
0.0079682125,
0.008129999,
-0.0507086515,
-0.0346284397,
0.0038254245,
-0.0524740554,
0.0048083747,
-0.0217987001,
-0.0296843052,
0.015914537,
-0.0145320324,
-0.0521325842,
0.0667789057,
0.0099033397,
-0.0129284933,
-0.0011405048,
0.0114033464,
-0.0133897886,
-0.0466116779,
0.0261939727,
0.0148505745,
0.0065924255,
0.0342979729,
0.0777020603,
0.0751596913,
-0.005476485,
-0.0090218075,
-0.034768831,
0.0210009404,
-0.0325051434,
0.0163527913,
0.0093570976,
0.0143684112,
-0.0268127955,
-0.0281923432,
-0.0186668132,
-0.0304770507,
0.0295922905,
-0.012346236,
0.0406774282,
0.0158534776,
-0.0089308824,
-0.0404738374,
-0.0119514158,
-0.0186692588,
-0.0137763051,
-0.0006429412,
0.0030608922,
-0.0523833893,
-0.01021362,
0.0024824396,
0.0485418849,
-0.0179640818,
-0.0114870761,
0.0263208803,
-0.0558163747,
0.0378364138,
0.0209776592,
-0.0036958035,
0.1064538807,
0.035437949,
0.0256315749,
-0.0883822739,
0.055138357,
-0.0754193738,
-0.0327953547,
-0.0454796925,
-0.0070118015,
0.0628430247,
0.0579799786,
-0.0300610885,
0.0178518016,
-0.0760504901,
0.0198863149,
-0.0166060999,
-0.0217100177,
-0.0556028523,
0.0494819321,
-0.0628160834,
0.0168511812,
0.0049090637,
-0.0513231345,
0.0804831535,
0.0101298196,
-0.0038885663,
-0.092325516,
-0.0400330983,
-0.0469126813,
0.0475385636,
0.0189774819,
0.0189453252,
-0.018887097,
-0.0448454097,
-0.0120287351,
-0.0198921803,
0.0277535953,
-0.0043466818,
0.0469926447,
-0.0472888984,
0.0329362266,
0.0119169755,
-0.0099719428,
-0.0338756889,
-0.0316170678,
-0.0230097752,
0.0007456857,
0.0071862568,
-0.0297337621,
-0.0361092165,
-0.0220427476,
0.0630684644,
0.0313116536,
-0.0299523994,
-0.0400009081,
-0.0562739111,
-0.0445126072,
0.0605498813,
-0.0072393296,
-0.0103137549,
-0.0000243161,
-0.0039279009,
0.0411804318,
0.0306311361,
-0.0126060611,
-0.0437471494,
0.057603091,
0.016371591,
-0.0524083823,
0.0279210247,
0.0747637823,
0.0133710401,
-0.0767313167,
-0.0132943178,
0.1073906794,
0.0272973813,
-0.0160909742,
-0.0007037238,
-0.0316329487,
0.0409355015,
0.0144790187,
0.0655135289,
-0.0470794365,
-0.0478070118,
-0.0081730671,
0.0488961861,
0.0054885056,
-0.0294462908,
0.0095552383,
-0.1022760645,
0.0069072219,
-0.014971965,
-0.0330095589,
-0.052713152,
-0.0719091818,
-0.0346470438,
-0.0384300202,
0.032344155,
0.013978322,
-0.0229986794,
-0.0036764371,
0.0128119858,
0.0025061187,
-0.0597319156,
0.0112592103,
-0.0539430082,
0.0486268513,
0.1144701019,
0.0278501641,
-0.0448607281,
-0.0027999021,
-0.0317208059,
0.0365734138,
-0.0314219221,
-0.0190692414,
-0.000910232,
-0.0209382381,
-0.0005869017,
-0.0255600363,
0.0619893633,
-0.010133558,
-0.0166019984,
0.0010174633,
0.0812136903,
-0.0294291824,
-0.0231235065,
-0.0035754936,
-0.013131245,
0.0326730497,
0.0667780563,
-0.0151801268,
-0.028702775,
-0.0971682444,
-0.0511434451,
-0.0421992019,
-0.0297151487,
-0.0423196293,
-0.0179164875,
-0.0242913049,
-0.0083621405,
-0.0196705554,
-0.0483925641,
0.0407695509,
0.0109726712,
-0.010443558,
0.009807935,
0.0288773701,
-0.0011134737,
-0.0087100342,
0.0173952598,
-0.0521881655,
0.0182553194,
-0.0499471948,
-0.0295018349,
0.0015606716,
-0.012480489,
-0.0388322473,
0.0097979773,
-0.0187918637,
-0.0520347096,
-0.0293989405,
0.0567602515,
0.0128176631,
0.0308172442,
-0.0024565365,
-0.0390778854,
0.0339359641,
0.0398133285,
-0.0423732288,
-0.0158262197,
0.0404170267,
0.0313313231,
0.0162019804,
0.0257026982,
-0.0456582606,
0.0151507268,
-0.0489830263,
0.0588641614,
-0.0106052039,
0.0266441479,
0.0533951707,
-0.0193377361,
0.030012317,
-0.0050503858,
-0.0350759439,
-0.0124113988,
-0.0248809643,
-0.0237998404,
-0.0216523223,
-0.0292831305,
0.0179744698,
0.0200508162,
-0.0088483039,
0.0064725247,
-0.0244994089,
-0.0005741391,
0.0083706789,
0.0031797732,
0.0097820098,
0.0403579883,
-0.0143585866,
0.0375058912,
0.005532919,
0.0212627072,
0.0150327617,
0.0232357085,
0.0344280005,
0.0067645088,
0.056461554,
0.0537322722,
-0.0093256962,
-0.0192448962,
-0.0116257966,
-0.0477988608,
-0.0828962326,
0.0294922665,
0.037942294,
0.02316547,
0.0119070252,
0.0431226715,
-0.0824497044,
0.01532612,
0.005700368,
0.0024560629,
-0.020026993,
0.0128589012,
0.0513192751,
0.0356015414,
-0.0070500439,
-0.0146693746,
0.089611873,
0.0550223179,
0.035078723,
-0.0121268407,
-0.0185722169,
-0.0585565902,
-0.0281756856,
0.0270562693,
0.0523154065,
-0.0232583415,
-0.0132112885,
-0.0169297997,
0.0005181542,
-0.0496390834,
0.0254253671,
0.0071022245,
-0.0578117482,
0.0635991171,
0.0265734755,
-0.018782299,
0.008452693,
-0.055112455,
-0.0055278302,
0.0249464493,
-0.0328998789,
-0.0399607383,
-6.371869984e-33,
-0.0128657231,
-0.0326118208,
0.0588785559,
-0.0327646844,
-0.0083366558,
-0.0440379828,
-0.0321552381,
-0.034009628,
0.0535480715,
0.0408717804,
0.0109582571,
-0.0022464199,
0.0128844492,
0.0287049338,
0.0417922251,
-0.0513829701,
0.0259617064,
-0.0059703626,
-0.0230134837,
0.0178379137,
0.0295311585,
0.0239907298,
0.0504827462,
-0.0141167445,
0.0427592285,
0.0607889816,
-0.0075254901,
0.004386317,
-0.012561962,
0.0575243421,
-0.0190677159,
0.0309013147,
-0.0015688747,
-0.0861326978,
-0.0370679535,
0.0322631672,
-0.0621092692,
-0.060010381,
0.0015863328,
0.0119147282,
-0.0449842513,
0.0059333756,
0.0408969112,
-0.0013316264,
-0.0432757251,
0.0362991989,
0.0268267561,
0.0035750056,
-0.0205928832,
-0.0047989814,
-0.0613994077,
0.0131529476,
-0.0099624842,
0.0003949237,
0.0294118375,
-0.0035081152,
-0.0351391472,
0.0166468266,
-0.011209419,
-0.0071630571,
0.0039790152,
0.0230187271,
0.0396598503,
0.0250423979,
0.0193935335,
0.036125008,
-0.0274777822,
-0.0312862098,
-0.0255091358,
-0.0119124223,
0.0339857042,
0.017778283,
0.0189796351,
0.004770996,
0.033458177,
0.0382695831,
-0.0344765522,
0.0213164389,
0.0219578613,
0.0821603537,
0.0324740149,
0.0422575325,
-0.0771094933,
-0.0272303689,
-0.0309937391,
0.0130857695,
-0.0021065732,
-0.0346407481,
0.0274650138,
0.0095285401,
-0.0223953258,
-0.006313961,
0.0288141388,
-0.0220518522,
-0.027083816,
0.0107720708,
-0.0077741859,
-0.0168222841,
0.0152312201,
0.0059069474,
-0.0683756918,
-0.0218656547,
-0.0104713291,
-0.0235080533,
0.0124700004,
0.0042014602,
-0.01738704,
0.0351626165,
-0.0642990917,
0.0274732392,
-0.0375603922,
0.0284737181,
0.0074277646,
0.0072839507,
0.0410975739,
-0.0317344964,
0.0056007584,
0.0530522801,
0.0355019681,
-0.0555678681,
0.0132787339,
-0.0211849511,
-0.0347330198,
0.0018016915,
-0.0080513619,
0.0243531782,
-0.0638383105,
0.0238057338,
0.0058221063,
-0.0616100803,
0.007761132,
0.0162088852,
2.696e-7,
-0.0025984296,
0.0851079747,
0.0296213664,
0.0446948223,
0.0057680658,
0.060901016,
0.0032122829,
0.0431433469,
-0.0211474709,
0.0185333975,
0.0243063588,
0.0271990187,
0.0146600567,
-0.0123883765,
-0.0721514896,
0.0024706761,
-0.0811356232,
-0.0036961681,
-0.0772975907,
-0.0183601156,
0.0546454154,
0.0891440287,
0.0329967886,
-0.0012943009,
0.0530035421,
-0.0042841518,
0.0415817462,
-0.0559654906,
0.0160552841,
-0.0087836487,
0.0296372175,
0.0168987736,
-0.008541951,
-0.0351846218,
0.0069236853,
0.0379019491,
-0.0348145179,
0.0841285512,
0.0185183808,
0.0183775648,
0.0064115929,
-0.0185901467,
0.0196366366,
-0.0365270786,
0.0729766712,
-0.0561684594,
-0.0083290953,
-0.007055812,
0.0116557311,
-0.0548663996,
-0.0028253756,
-0.021409573,
-0.0371435545,
-0.0041175163,
-0.004861217,
-0.0024441073,
0.0098879337,
-0.0599764138,
0.0124427602,
0.0067577991,
-0.0276746154,
0.0156481732,
-0.0497702546,
0.037641611,
0.0047235824,
-0.0698397681,
-0.0262529906,
2.827020981e-34,
0.0162488725,
-0.0204119124,
0.0133927539,
0.0006170308,
0.0248171613,
0.0520349666,
-0.0141580366,
0.0507052504,
0.0681378171,
-0.056059964,
-0.0323450007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07148v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07148v2 | X-LoRA: Mixture of Low-Rank Adapter Experts, a Flexible Framework for Large Language Models with Applications in Protein Mechanics and Molecular Design | 2024-02-11T10:23:34 | 2024-03-30T20:18:54 | Eric L. Buehler, Markus J. Buehler | cond-mat.soft | cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | We report a mixture of expert strategy to create fine-tuned large language
models using a deep layer-wise token-level approach based on low-rank
adaptation (LoRA). Starting with a set of pre-trained LoRA adapters, our gating
strategy uses the hidden states to dynamically mix adapted layers, allowing the
resulting X-LoRA model to draw upon different capabilities and create
never-before-used deep layer-wise combinations to solve tasks. The design is
inspired by the biological principles of universality and diversity, where
neural network building blocks are reused in different hierarchical
manifestations. Hence, the X-LoRA model can be easily implemented for any
existing large language model (LLM) without a need for modifications of the
underlying structure. We develop a tailored X-LoRA model that offers scientific
capabilities including forward/inverse analysis tasks and enhanced reasoning
capability, focused on biomaterial analysis, protein mechanics and design. The
impact of this work include access to readily expandable and adaptable models
with strong domain knowledge and the capability to integrate across areas of
knowledge. Featuring experts in biology, mathematics, reasoning, bio-inspired
materials, mechanics and materials, chemistry, protein biophysics, mechanics
and quantum-mechanics based molecular properties, we conduct a series of
physics-focused case studies. We examine knowledge recall, protein mechanics
forward/inverse tasks, protein design, adversarial agentic modeling including
ontological knowledge graph construction, as well as molecular design. The
model is capable not only of making quantitative predictions of nanomechanical
properties of proteins or quantum mechanical molecular properties, but also
reasons over the results and correctly predicts likely mechanisms that explain
distinct molecular behaviors. | [
0.0135496808,
0.0600636862,
-0.0199338514,
0.0300139114,
0.0056563704,
-0.0257215463,
0.0385379381,
0.0088003036,
0.0450275429,
0.0182557311,
-0.0317369811,
-0.0236417018,
-0.0232721493,
0.0642830655,
0.0254854746,
0.0141962832,
-0.000865853,
-0.0485408008,
0.0161311068,
-0.0844310299,
-0.019227853,
-0.0330644697,
0.0094430605,
0.0155868521,
0.0579072684,
0.0019097155,
-0.0199282467,
-0.0243279152,
0.0511137582,
0.0013627356,
-0.0148379616,
0.0478159674,
0.0347312279,
0.030880373,
0.0000022798,
-0.0230512563,
-0.0082931323,
0.0423959605,
-0.0241162237,
-0.0030922981,
-0.0321189761,
-0.036996983,
-0.0446980484,
-0.0072675911,
-0.008718838,
-0.0036390307,
0.0602553114,
0.0223200377,
0.0057723718,
0.0398195274,
0.0032885142,
-0.0426511951,
0.1094623283,
-0.016266413,
0.0558447354,
-0.037356928,
0.0379202813,
0.024882555,
0.0336379744,
0.0097760996,
-0.0296273325,
0.0406516641,
0.0303885359,
-0.0308481492,
0.0323132947,
0.018224543,
0.0186762977,
0.0252279285,
-0.0069635133,
0.0948935822,
-0.0378622487,
-0.0152439605,
-0.0524204448,
-0.0315527953,
-0.0096445186,
0.032482855,
-0.0547868609,
-0.0115951793,
0.0451335981,
0.015688628,
0.0083792871,
-0.0012418582,
0.0484408364,
-0.0062128166,
-0.0420524068,
0.0505455695,
0.0306117237,
-0.0149511686,
-0.0064414353,
-0.0252516605,
0.0050712158,
-0.0005942439,
0.0108872289,
0.0300977305,
0.0195702594,
0.0003280379,
0.0403882116,
-0.0694983676,
0.0383046418,
-0.039576266,
0.0371374749,
0.0511739515,
0.0060466463,
0.054952763,
-0.0722642317,
0.0287037846,
-0.0516994707,
0.0100533655,
-0.0307876486,
0.0030169906,
-0.0868616849,
-0.0178033505,
0.0194506701,
0.0351459645,
-0.0445092432,
-0.0262811221,
-0.0235249307,
0.0281966925,
-0.0121213915,
-0.0139571093,
-0.0247300956,
0.0483062044,
-0.0030534875,
-0.050114125,
-0.0315887667,
0.0539064109,
0.0040464001,
0.0327004828,
0.0057493574,
-0.0313545875,
-0.0423664972,
-0.0245671496,
-0.0201499816,
-0.0251984857,
0.0254773609,
0.1340765953,
-0.028832959,
0.011185986,
0.046942506,
-0.0015488528,
-0.0195661206,
-0.0423961431,
0.0437239148,
-0.0347362235,
0.0638460368,
0.0216104817,
0.0263559222,
-0.0916701779,
0.0021171148,
-0.0387262441,
-0.0628435612,
0.0769066438,
0.0187715106,
-0.0653929114,
0.0425340757,
0.0073015955,
0.0070226835,
0.0087165972,
0.0171148609,
0.0054483516,
-0.041992031,
0.0015363408,
-0.0176301301,
0.00461879,
0.0121785942,
-0.0394344144,
-0.039461039,
-0.0196275879,
0.0061805123,
0.0583388358,
-0.0102792904,
0.0057964339,
0.0057854876,
-0.0005132965,
0.0437250882,
0.036460679,
-0.0052026641,
0.089675501,
-0.0361148529,
0.0018495562,
0.0139777092,
-0.0240076929,
-0.0074602333,
0.0806885138,
-0.0293978881,
-0.0048008314,
0.0445785373,
0.0362670422,
-0.0116322683,
-0.0496186689,
-0.0102916425,
0.0187327862,
0.0110133272,
-0.0195883401,
0.0534404851,
-0.0257029887,
-0.0536128916,
0.0078300517,
0.0361225344,
-0.0498861857,
-0.0085285567,
-0.032162711,
0.0223832577,
0.0486717001,
0.0307786819,
-0.0884688497,
-0.0434598178,
0.0385411978,
-0.0316285864,
0.0384295918,
0.0177469123,
0.01861009,
-0.0116154552,
-0.0296159852,
-0.0067616943,
-0.0308419019,
0.0257511511,
0.0126139112,
-0.0580512956,
0.0041513988,
-0.0004270415,
-0.0170015544,
-0.0375590324,
0.0087180892,
-0.0320672244,
0.0020833928,
0.0399713032,
-0.0095928609,
0.0676120073,
-0.0044554328,
0.0108280852,
0.0117020467,
0.054057315,
-0.0773168206,
-0.0375083126,
-0.0394608974,
-0.0066437335,
-0.0293945465,
0.0444011539,
-0.0517896377,
0.0478308201,
0.0015374239,
-0.0171493236,
-0.0656237751,
0.0680918172,
0.0053757369,
0.0469995216,
-0.0125811566,
-0.0374632142,
0.0082963258,
0.060929805,
-0.0320344642,
0.0579497106,
0.0158467181,
-0.0193057954,
0.0224955454,
-0.0097071566,
0.0318192169,
-0.0273609497,
-0.0199292954,
0.004271308,
0.0294281188,
0.0340995975,
0.0600439906,
-0.0241899025,
-0.0023239974,
-0.0616521388,
-0.0220372956,
-0.0166490003,
0.0006340125,
-0.0106575312,
-0.0049581127,
-0.0131444642,
-0.0008774436,
0.0158030186,
-0.0332962275,
0.0333701186,
-0.0445282497,
-0.0416123606,
0.0402491987,
0.003289385,
-0.0281616524,
-0.0674448684,
-0.0247015692,
-0.0713955835,
0.0664328709,
0.0098581007,
0.0000981524,
-0.0007053243,
-0.0107057383,
-0.0300722029,
0.0224203356,
-0.0232670549,
-0.0633097664,
0.0285460074,
-0.0183802191,
0.050411351,
0.0517808571,
-0.0313282385,
0.0263436716,
0.064438656,
0.0172515027,
-0.026002394,
0.0227337908,
-0.0305595603,
0.0104464563,
-0.022853557,
0.0265133101,
-0.027503822,
0.0537424646,
-0.0160550121,
-0.0196118839,
-0.0716693327,
0.0451196656,
0.0020188349,
-0.055376932,
0.0038880669,
0.0277949497,
0.0313937105,
-0.0127012786,
0.0255109295,
0.0315371603,
0.0856149197,
0.0001572029,
0.0147530567,
-0.0035586145,
-0.0236455444,
-0.0096059758,
0.0632364973,
0.0243526679,
0.0328337774,
0.0167323407,
0.0393566117,
-0.0149434917,
-0.0012735114,
0.0075708358,
0.0131814834,
-0.0291220918,
-0.0480419733,
0.0161331929,
0.0085039232,
-0.0671097487,
0.0164755639,
0.0407168083,
-0.0316672362,
0.0636681691,
-0.0035710211,
-0.059410762,
-0.0492443703,
0.0052218819,
0.053304445,
-0.0022891227,
-0.025522735,
0.021015225,
-0.0607322268,
0.0346285179,
0.0249207299,
0.0082052015,
0.017759202,
-0.0190990772,
0.0455111079,
0.0071423058,
-0.0219728909,
-0.003513332,
-0.029647382,
0.0327002443,
0.0367945656,
0.0137676448,
-0.0043371147,
0.0036870034,
0.0184788369,
-0.0548100173,
0.0035158696,
0.0489980243,
-0.0042332555,
-0.0347752571,
0.0044013374,
-0.0175879411,
0.0211067908,
-0.0105065312,
0.0543694943,
-0.0567563251,
-0.032711491,
-0.0458869562,
-0.0227217115,
0.0135621568,
-0.0331803858,
-0.0082362425,
-0.0310895499,
0.035317421,
0.014264497,
-0.056060072,
-0.0459745787,
-0.0432710722,
-0.0207079444,
-0.0329177007,
0.0313254222,
0.0384857468,
0.0190561544,
-0.0051813014,
0.0280350856,
-0.012414732,
-0.0592618734,
0.0433145911,
0.0046819546,
0.0359110683,
0.0639582127,
0.0069922204,
-0.060966745,
-0.0595352426,
0.0032601045,
0.0051712324,
0.0386161432,
-0.0183213912,
-0.0109266825,
0.0434284881,
-0.047548335,
-0.021201551,
0.0518572144,
-0.0269742981,
-0.0455982648,
-0.0278166533,
0.1047668234,
-0.0055311988,
-0.0115229273,
-0.0338895097,
-0.0667145327,
-0.038255848,
0.0667733401,
-0.00576573,
-0.0473397337,
-0.0818107948,
-0.0461688191,
-0.0064972998,
-0.0377986841,
-0.0214354657,
-0.028082652,
0.0080741821,
0.000291844,
-0.0231618397,
0.028697798,
0.0550120883,
0.0206135735,
0.0074746148,
0.0080429716,
0.031855721,
-0.016170837,
-0.0234874953,
-0.0047860364,
-0.0054407222,
-0.0075866268,
0.0028377324,
-0.0451635383,
0.0677608401,
-0.0551060475,
-0.0323854871,
0.0170947779,
0.0211928915,
-0.0771652758,
-0.0203048326,
0.069357194,
0.02171221,
0.0106119579,
-0.0076011284,
-0.0819277763,
0.1123097911,
0.0554845296,
-0.0006972441,
-0.012113356,
0.0198893044,
-0.0324319899,
-0.0296041109,
0.0145595251,
-0.0331696235,
-0.003923717,
0.0338608809,
0.0299648028,
-0.0165364891,
-0.0235726628,
0.0407744534,
0.0125808436,
0.0005677741,
0.007862336,
-0.0139022525,
-0.0153651815,
0.0179302972,
0.0077009383,
0.0156315695,
-0.0368854553,
-0.0248000231,
0.0616488829,
-0.0312015731,
-0.0072781593,
-0.0252506901,
0.0388445184,
0.0180623624,
-0.0209065638,
0.0430882201,
0.0047996305,
0.0314434841,
0.0707325339,
-0.0042149704,
-0.0299290121,
0.0151734389,
-0.0526275598,
0.0438415818,
-0.0269290265,
-0.0255944747,
0.0298091061,
0.0417970046,
-0.0589414984,
0.0272824243,
-0.043508891,
-0.1107045263,
-0.0441791788,
0.0174428597,
0.0637119487,
0.0369422548,
0.0218593106,
-0.0176692605,
-0.0302345064,
-0.0049394011,
0.0034798142,
0.0245842934,
-0.0068672802,
0.055905439,
0.0351377763,
0.0046477993,
-0.0464365892,
0.0639718175,
0.0614064559,
0.0345554575,
-0.014235205,
0.0023323214,
-0.0200586189,
0.000285843,
-0.0196143426,
0.0330534019,
-0.0092156231,
-0.020216858,
-0.0306874942,
-0.0427838117,
0.0235491078,
0.0424188972,
-0.0320686325,
0.0108735133,
0.0060623535,
0.0464874431,
-0.0226933155,
-0.0657746717,
0.0155397803,
0.0032906563,
0.0253662374,
-0.0267717093,
0.00812943,
-6.746483136e-33,
0.0054509514,
0.0327478535,
-0.0083563821,
-0.0030650026,
0.0065771155,
-0.0136271045,
-0.0734351799,
-0.024723947,
-0.0177902635,
0.0654815882,
-0.0302719269,
-0.0029125225,
0.004819287,
-0.0147081017,
0.025518572,
-0.00494703,
0.0273600388,
0.0374557711,
0.0333399065,
0.0227296669,
0.0042944672,
0.0265146345,
0.0452680327,
-0.0200091749,
0.0312789492,
0.0254584625,
0.0116155781,
-0.0047195116,
-0.0592713691,
0.017472256,
-0.0591556728,
0.0412482992,
-0.0396721028,
-0.0312378686,
-0.0143175414,
-0.0404504687,
-0.052241493,
-0.0276542027,
0.0159090031,
-0.039175611,
0.0087719839,
-0.0273122583,
0.0463741384,
0.0229847766,
-0.0447243787,
-0.0231964495,
0.0528854728,
-0.0509906113,
0.0059087682,
-0.0011214722,
-0.0732018501,
-0.0130478172,
-0.0055358671,
0.034146376,
-0.0124266054,
-0.031731613,
0.0028109609,
0.0038721054,
-0.0686608553,
0.0248042177,
0.0051671308,
0.0157004222,
0.0362197421,
0.0144062964,
0.0203217845,
0.0281094499,
0.0303118117,
0.0124991285,
-0.0172283519,
-0.0191837121,
0.0167946294,
0.0644037947,
0.0832162127,
0.01059407,
0.0273892246,
-0.0140787363,
-0.1556102633,
-0.022493219,
0.0336869024,
0.0158106238,
0.0241819136,
0.068139419,
0.0146860778,
-0.0425237939,
-0.0266532637,
0.0190653335,
-0.0045853811,
-0.0438904017,
-0.0310367215,
-0.0513499454,
-0.0298457369,
-0.0277139526,
0.0349327996,
-0.0512580127,
-0.005561389,
0.0252591893,
0.0298354048,
0.0130618373,
0.0031743669,
0.0346147455,
-0.050326895,
-0.0411378816,
-0.0241130125,
-0.0081779119,
0.0144030862,
-0.001291454,
-0.0133969868,
0.0473804064,
0.0012430183,
-0.0073787272,
-0.065653652,
-0.0224558413,
0.0591804087,
0.0366494991,
-0.0070592929,
0.0288975947,
-0.0121736405,
0.0222478956,
-0.0183745231,
0.0356555954,
0.0279226564,
0.0677098483,
0.0091744903,
0.0245032758,
-0.072727941,
-0.0547810346,
-0.023396939,
0.0260264277,
0.0154331569,
-0.095888555,
-0.0149328727,
0.0173778497,
3.246e-7,
0.0507886037,
0.0582314506,
-0.0006891893,
-0.0369068459,
-0.0011898457,
0.0231948327,
-0.0225985739,
0.0164482538,
-0.0114435311,
-0.0173680633,
0.0371348225,
0.033578001,
-0.0016903599,
-0.0041045062,
-0.0710871071,
-0.0217265952,
-0.0291786548,
-0.0322092846,
-0.0364176221,
0.0194713175,
-0.0274666846,
0.0862312019,
0.015888935,
-0.0069285608,
0.0298128314,
-0.0368347317,
0.0399608724,
-0.0132473381,
0.0446649604,
0.0346119031,
-0.0007831337,
-0.0229580048,
-0.0365139097,
0.0455914997,
0.0076631922,
0.0144737996,
0.0026816064,
0.0066078533,
-0.0260186661,
0.0095212776,
0.0238475036,
0.0016055277,
0.0064312122,
-0.0402494445,
0.0280092228,
-0.0583529249,
-0.0387681387,
0.0214188192,
-0.0385677442,
-0.005319092,
0.0363292694,
-0.0254443325,
0.0424551554,
0.0014068716,
-0.0187720265,
0.0043497719,
0.0121511631,
-0.0527023301,
-0.0090130763,
0.0344762728,
-0.0579552874,
-0.0120792324,
-0.0384219214,
-0.0344175138,
0.0669187531,
-0.0499132276,
0.0207134336,
2.898401727e-34,
0.0556517802,
0.0122650536,
-0.0047808313,
0.0284184422,
0.0273227096,
0.0086696483,
-0.019431157,
0.0069889422,
0.0106432224,
-0.0865795612,
-0.0455291867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07092v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07092v3 | Generalizing Conversational Dense Retrieval via LLM-Cognition Data Augmentation | 2024-02-11T03:27:22 | 2024-06-04T02:09:15 | Haonan Chen, Zhicheng Dou, Kelong Mao, Jiongnan Liu, Ziliang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Conversational search utilizes muli-turn natural language contexts to
retrieve relevant passages. Existing conversational dense retrieval models
mostly view a conversation as a fixed sequence of questions and responses,
overlooking the severe data sparsity problem -- that is, users can perform a
conversation in various ways, and these alternate conversations are unrecorded.
Consequently, they often struggle to generalize to diverse conversations in
real-world scenarios. In this work, we propose a framework for generalizing
Conversational dense retrieval via LLM-cognition data Augmentation (ConvAug).
ConvAug first generates multi-level augmented conversations to capture the
diverse nature of conversational contexts. Inspired by human cognition, we
devise a cognition-aware process to mitigate the generation of false positives,
false negatives, and hallucinations. Moreover, we develop a difficulty-adaptive
sample filter that selects challenging samples for complex conversations,
thereby giving the model a larger learning space. A contrastive learning
objective is then employed to train a better conversational context encoder.
Extensive experiments conducted on four public datasets, under both normal and
zero-shot settings, demonstrate the effectiveness, generalizability, and
applicability of ConvAug. The code is released at
https://github.com/haon-chen/ConvAug. | [
0.0299170129,
0.040358834,
-0.0126013942,
0.0404764339,
-0.0137800248,
0.0030825122,
-0.0123411184,
0.0041150111,
0.0316039436,
-0.0433218591,
-0.0533286557,
-0.0494459085,
-0.0094592357,
0.0530130938,
0.0205168538,
-0.0456979051,
0.0294248536,
0.02725113,
0.0365199596,
0.014719015,
-0.0016212397,
0.0062073739,
-0.0114460308,
0.0179914627,
0.0040493277,
0.0001444658,
-0.0190446917,
0.039377328,
0.0240280125,
-0.0377206467,
0.0615709424,
0.0252829287,
0.0544545427,
0.0185395423,
0.0000018331,
-0.0491418391,
-0.0210619532,
-0.0397549197,
-0.039530091,
-0.0639458671,
0.0070352391,
0.0212470237,
0.0258088373,
0.0197248571,
-0.050125137,
0.0209836457,
0.0186091978,
0.0689776689,
0.0531223193,
0.1025441289,
-0.0242590643,
-0.0393026769,
0.0289373193,
-0.0086817723,
0.0698252469,
-0.0579104275,
0.0147012798,
0.0097116474,
0.0023213539,
0.0606748424,
0.012518581,
0.0133315679,
-0.0049733529,
-0.0121648991,
0.0372639485,
0.0205277,
-0.0318892598,
-0.0108358795,
0.0029815999,
0.0966609195,
0.0181925762,
0.0049327677,
-0.0129843401,
0.013657148,
0.0057670437,
-0.0331201479,
-0.0945388377,
0.0057071843,
-0.0176540557,
0.022573432,
-0.037755888,
0.0223344285,
0.0022333933,
0.0109680332,
-0.017774893,
0.0121166389,
-0.0151495663,
-0.0361310244,
0.0110860411,
-0.004747991,
-0.0045588496,
-0.0164249204,
0.036236763,
0.0280166902,
-0.0770183206,
0.009678443,
-0.0056611542,
-0.0012138846,
0.0345824845,
-0.0422055013,
-0.0112744169,
0.033835765,
-0.0277444534,
0.0700376332,
-0.0043157432,
0.0244641416,
-0.010744025,
0.0124019934,
-0.0378039032,
-0.0591359697,
-0.0249475054,
0.0146844005,
-0.0396128446,
0.0387583859,
-0.0724110603,
-0.0052310489,
-0.0408991985,
0.0417556725,
-0.0129391355,
0.0121725705,
-0.0328835621,
0.03202831,
-0.0425114185,
0.0246502999,
-0.0123163452,
0.0132716158,
-0.0206451155,
0.008368683,
0.027017029,
-0.0635601953,
-0.0319491141,
0.0141076092,
0.0418065712,
-0.0342228785,
-0.0111430632,
0.0268819779,
-0.0220786072,
-0.065947473,
-0.0231939461,
-0.003883305,
-0.0120284986,
-0.0282357819,
-0.012933312,
-0.0221418999,
0.0393341258,
-0.0145580983,
-0.0271513294,
-0.044954814,
0.009089523,
0.0398919918,
-0.0449122302,
0.0589846708,
-0.0056796614,
-0.0251878724,
0.0620860681,
0.0457668267,
-0.0188527573,
0.0690286011,
0.0102195088,
0.0057747834,
0.0578226261,
0.0076346463,
0.0517021492,
-0.0025971332,
0.0382033959,
-0.008857199,
-0.0112445168,
0.0540472381,
-0.0100176781,
0.0216442496,
0.0284694415,
0.0306229461,
-0.0526230484,
-0.0344439521,
0.0020915701,
0.0513008386,
0.0108938701,
-0.0092725586,
0.0025687399,
0.0367387049,
-0.0299409516,
0.0205817875,
-0.046123594,
0.0491902642,
-0.0762783438,
-0.0366711989,
0.0718805194,
0.0064607612,
-0.0419163778,
-0.0240952745,
0.0269696992,
0.0084979748,
0.0439617969,
0.0135070998,
0.0136286877,
0.0095772371,
-0.0563622378,
0.0401442461,
0.0185650829,
-0.0549269542,
-0.0454075634,
-0.0462968871,
0.0276926253,
0.0460177325,
0.0588543974,
-0.0507515557,
-0.0261082016,
-0.0246411301,
-0.0072872005,
0.0312433876,
0.0143485656,
-0.0015215972,
0.0652329326,
-0.0555399582,
-0.0389834531,
-0.0350856483,
0.0006252255,
-0.002739151,
0.0189734045,
-0.001652546,
0.0254014377,
0.0092025306,
0.0209227614,
0.0012978881,
-0.0245352238,
-0.0223530997,
0.0033347416,
-0.0088270744,
0.0104004415,
0.0176427066,
0.0188770592,
-0.002540681,
0.0340841338,
-0.0201444253,
-0.0468789488,
-0.0059230006,
-0.0674228519,
-0.0744098872,
0.0245905593,
-0.0162541866,
-0.0012443697,
-0.0064526633,
-0.0390225276,
-0.0420972779,
0.0333869271,
-0.0180011485,
0.050909359,
-0.0477720313,
-0.0001105103,
0.0224004015,
0.0354078598,
-0.0227007046,
0.0811949968,
-0.0258994363,
0.00304047,
0.0203535687,
0.0225418713,
-0.011751812,
-0.0539406762,
-0.0081845094,
0.0017887839,
-0.0101804845,
0.009883035,
0.050430093,
0.0050356179,
-0.09399198,
0.0073842504,
-0.1175500974,
0.0194090474,
-0.0431373306,
-0.0390658565,
0.0046664835,
0.0297808722,
-0.0019649223,
-0.0261239093,
-0.0472511277,
0.0002484043,
0.0355411768,
0.0312353242,
0.022030158,
0.0250078533,
0.0107176676,
-0.0629572794,
0.0038749231,
0.0267528668,
0.0470932312,
-0.0300878752,
-0.013175549,
-0.0269419868,
0.0314579979,
-0.0176753122,
0.0261367392,
-0.0483906008,
-0.0042343321,
0.016670743,
-0.0191613808,
0.007125495,
0.05959896,
0.0444814526,
0.0305977464,
-0.0364641286,
-0.0237110145,
-0.0728893057,
0.0546991415,
0.0003395715,
-0.0177318901,
-0.026332004,
-0.0422630459,
0.0162754524,
0.0315240361,
-0.0081765838,
0.0353937596,
-0.0496876165,
-0.0064731389,
0.0564602837,
-0.0356245972,
-0.0293979477,
-0.0000451761,
-0.0111199785,
0.0543672666,
-0.0438133441,
-0.0277132299,
0.0535292476,
-0.0051564993,
-0.0444229878,
-0.0349932052,
-0.0325849243,
-0.0347699486,
0.0482462086,
-0.027167147,
-0.0043002223,
0.0028746591,
-0.0271846931,
-0.0341183469,
-0.025244005,
0.0001519825,
-0.0467053913,
0.0364723429,
-0.0133592905,
-0.003743425,
0.0148238223,
-0.0527179055,
-0.0775245875,
-0.0204286352,
-0.0040724878,
0.0067010811,
-0.0109869177,
-0.009583218,
-0.0712585598,
-0.025782207,
0.0048525999,
0.0226886105,
0.0053758346,
-0.0329581648,
0.0034624066,
0.0588184334,
0.0599301308,
0.0518169217,
-0.0040025297,
0.0029081814,
0.0437698103,
0.0704931021,
-0.0011163952,
-0.0460394435,
0.0075326608,
-0.0019314049,
0.028029263,
0.021763742,
-0.0085590761,
-0.0009692832,
0.065515615,
-0.0023312317,
-0.0475053899,
0.1002206653,
0.0375316553,
-0.079363063,
-0.0375790633,
-0.0417998359,
0.0284712147,
0.0300788134,
0.0194675662,
-0.066811204,
-0.0393410809,
0.0013128604,
0.0169592332,
-0.0147180595,
-0.0461154953,
-0.016230965,
-0.087606281,
0.023473667,
0.0082050404,
-0.0166829713,
-0.024694724,
-0.038385123,
0.0204214305,
-0.0112648411,
0.0498557314,
-0.0009330887,
0.0126131577,
-0.021392893,
-0.0213324726,
0.0118250856,
-0.0648410842,
0.0220965985,
0.011372922,
0.0542282499,
0.0450451486,
0.0409931764,
0.0428675078,
-0.0101055801,
0.0208136551,
-0.0364619084,
0.0100395186,
-0.0289249811,
0.077153787,
-0.0273174327,
0.0327655859,
-0.0175344776,
0.0421939678,
-0.0174308494,
-0.052780956,
-0.009078173,
0.0332928412,
-0.0654613227,
0.031821847,
-0.0480662063,
0.0186623409,
0.0413286462,
0.0990549698,
0.0174530093,
0.0069762664,
0.0053130146,
-0.0412394889,
0.0180197582,
-0.0186816882,
0.0061995718,
-0.0146270599,
0.0500018969,
0.0660082698,
-0.0553378351,
-0.0288128722,
-0.0037946959,
-0.004339085,
-0.0553788655,
-0.0103088617,
-0.0176237579,
-0.0195573382,
-0.0353482738,
0.0196646154,
-0.0401214771,
0.0039830147,
-0.0110509573,
-0.0151730608,
0.0258994866,
-0.0471005104,
0.0129195508,
0.0261527207,
-0.0761479884,
-0.0464082249,
-0.030835731,
0.0244800225,
0.0220398437,
0.0854364708,
-0.0000648098,
-0.0316791944,
0.034396451,
0.0156967025,
-0.0689681396,
0.0017776103,
0.0409484617,
0.0714691654,
-0.0079314327,
0.0453741103,
-0.0542276017,
-0.0061503486,
-0.0138336765,
0.0418509617,
-0.0445818976,
-0.0640174001,
0.0150711183,
-0.047736451,
0.0501369536,
0.0138916951,
0.0171571355,
-0.0114863627,
0.014944803,
-0.0402028747,
-0.0098474659,
-0.047208596,
-0.0071455021,
0.0036748033,
-0.0433718376,
0.0011617503,
0.0154509293,
-0.0518646352,
0.0472785421,
-0.0511499792,
-0.0050193598,
0.0273967367,
-0.044307787,
-0.0005779958,
0.0029125197,
-0.0215847958,
0.0331939906,
0.0086984513,
0.0564725846,
-0.0061044642,
0.0905715302,
0.0077501424,
-0.0359899141,
-0.0010930143,
0.0217901226,
-0.0886653513,
-0.0139390575,
-0.0044336114,
0.0421117097,
0.0455114394,
-0.0245571434,
0.0163445752,
0.0031237004,
0.0218397994,
-0.0077909888,
0.0236686133,
-0.0038587674,
-0.0369870551,
0.0226485953,
0.0329159051,
-0.0145742875,
0.0447972938,
0.0569368899,
-0.0373774506,
0.0266962219,
-0.0268074367,
-0.0120783085,
-0.0379903316,
-0.0324535705,
0.0372203551,
0.0835582092,
-0.0040521352,
0.0014942361,
-0.0193323679,
-0.0209123921,
0.0415863544,
-0.0543481261,
-0.0327761136,
0.0070469645,
0.0504012518,
0.0650700182,
-0.0147852656,
-0.0147436261,
-0.0088868085,
0.0025637876,
-0.0066300351,
-0.0197438914,
-0.0344514363,
-6.350686107e-33,
0.000032505,
-0.0309085809,
0.0188523158,
-0.0152849834,
-0.0313318819,
-0.0150256129,
-0.0457677729,
0.0032262048,
-0.0330515169,
-0.0165024884,
-0.0198082663,
0.0619380064,
0.0058344714,
0.0592355244,
-0.0328958556,
-0.0277787112,
0.0629951432,
-0.004206303,
-0.0139337955,
0.0455442332,
0.0259453617,
0.0493058562,
0.0368221141,
-0.0914021954,
0.0455764905,
-0.0314224474,
0.0175954998,
0.0628942773,
0.0479298569,
0.0428070202,
-0.0448307693,
0.043715205,
0.016030442,
-0.0280871466,
0.0082978373,
0.0126564372,
-0.0735513195,
-0.0261352435,
-0.0003953658,
-0.0053778873,
-0.0490387604,
-0.0165214073,
0.0364168547,
-0.0253842324,
0.03453077,
-0.010888312,
0.0099066198,
-0.0234802794,
-0.0088887913,
0.0002160706,
-0.0009059318,
0.0221144594,
-0.0374551453,
-0.0225517657,
-0.0147824204,
0.0739311799,
0.0395360738,
0.0422587208,
-0.0512134098,
0.0174319204,
-0.0608145632,
-0.0189831313,
0.0090047522,
-0.0058702179,
-0.0239783898,
0.073822476,
0.0303842742,
-0.0034667545,
-0.0404104069,
-0.0509062149,
-0.0039871731,
0.043414209,
0.0007542293,
0.0881360918,
0.0302825961,
-0.024858132,
-0.0540369824,
0.0440247357,
-0.0144720552,
0.0477045327,
-0.0007486062,
0.0424149483,
-0.0457239598,
-0.0306586958,
0.0010328699,
0.0123919519,
-0.0365946144,
-0.0064732726,
0.009748267,
0.0259474143,
0.0130952671,
-0.0296151713,
0.0401963927,
-0.0309149735,
0.0044562849,
0.0504088216,
-0.0108584389,
-0.0203408524,
0.0227918085,
0.014232412,
-0.0100008864,
-0.0214886889,
0.0696512237,
0.0026574654,
-0.00996044,
0.0287275109,
0.0446222015,
-0.0026678543,
-0.0502085686,
0.0088122962,
-0.0152778877,
0.0332993157,
-0.0526958555,
0.0340015739,
-0.007810296,
0.0426651612,
-0.0205292925,
0.072204642,
0.0051715546,
0.0274645668,
-0.0450727232,
-0.0671575963,
0.0083359685,
0.0103358086,
-0.0271266494,
0.0017399073,
-0.0033641919,
-0.0180850532,
0.0212300569,
-0.040613994,
0.0015931971,
0.0106796278,
2.654e-7,
-0.0003821746,
0.0348123051,
0.022687884,
-0.0129508385,
0.0221728291,
0.0396735594,
-0.0143464794,
0.0266361516,
0.0267465394,
-0.0552326292,
0.0141120795,
0.0475094467,
0.0462974273,
0.0245121364,
-0.0631684288,
-0.0383637547,
-0.0393088758,
-0.0462234877,
-0.0333235376,
-0.0202870294,
0.1044789925,
0.091065608,
0.0136932526,
-0.0104102744,
-0.0037561532,
-0.0497893915,
0.0764978454,
-0.0404136404,
-0.0139766559,
-0.010564344,
0.0243107658,
0.0604380965,
0.0111837145,
-0.008765108,
-0.0116252368,
0.0276636537,
0.0074987309,
0.057231389,
0.015143116,
-0.0872869045,
-0.0102765048,
0.0149780707,
0.0048424429,
-0.0328104012,
0.0569910035,
-0.055806078,
-0.0319433436,
0.0054827016,
-0.0252935998,
0.0176755805,
0.0602340251,
-0.0072550909,
-0.0424838215,
-0.0045652464,
0.0143741108,
0.0500049926,
-0.0023122046,
-0.1258654296,
-0.0023228142,
-0.0026137813,
-0.0518819578,
-0.0170252062,
-0.0180120338,
-0.0091750938,
0.0071233995,
-0.0241700877,
0.0349668637,
2.090898867e-34,
0.0482858047,
0.0239180252,
0.0014407438,
0.0217029881,
0.0250734761,
-0.0256287977,
-0.0125611871,
0.0055777305,
0.0344285928,
-0.0786745846,
0.0144413747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07085v1 | Speech Rhythm-Based Speaker Embeddings Extraction from Phonemes and Phoneme Duration for Multi-Speaker Speech Synthesis | 2024-02-11T02:26:43 | 2024-02-11T02:26:43 | Kenichi Fujita, Atsushi Ando, Yusuke Ijima | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | This paper proposes a speech rhythm-based method for speaker embeddings to
model phoneme duration using a few utterances by the target speaker. Speech
rhythm is one of the essential factors among speaker characteristics, along
with acoustic features such as F0, for reproducing individual utterances in
speech synthesis. A novel feature of the proposed method is the rhythm-based
embeddings extracted from phonemes and their durations, which are known to be
related to speaking rhythm. They are extracted with a speaker identification
model similar to the conventional spectral feature-based one. We conducted
three experiments, speaker embeddings generation, speech synthesis with
generated embeddings, and embedding space analysis, to evaluate the
performance. The proposed method demonstrated a moderate speaker identification
performance (15.2% EER), even with only phonemes and their duration
information. The objective and subjective evaluation results demonstrated that
the proposed method can synthesize speech with speech rhythm closer to the
target speaker than the conventional method. We also visualized the embeddings
to evaluate the relationship between the distance of the embeddings and the
perceptual similarity. The visualization of the embedding space and the
relation analysis between the closeness indicated that the distribution of
embeddings reflects the subjective and objective similarity. | [
-0.0245895125,
0.0297384169,
0.0076982141,
0.0153465588,
-0.0193306264,
-0.0310376883,
0.0443714261,
-0.0181369707,
-0.0061500994,
0.014489105,
-0.0146420542,
-0.0337835215,
0.0122938836,
-0.0453041308,
0.0240069833,
-0.0863245055,
-0.009404446,
0.026467016,
-0.0090943445,
-0.0170708504,
0.0276142322,
-0.0105612343,
-0.0107324077,
0.0430516973,
-0.031057233,
0.0037981251,
-0.0213336982,
-0.0049528796,
0.036787238,
0.0240252223,
-0.0469862074,
0.0056701582,
0.0807180405,
0.0557378419,
0.0000016379,
-0.0072800838,
-0.0449080877,
-0.0062080892,
-0.0304203127,
-0.0277378615,
0.0025496292,
0.0207471233,
-0.0214064773,
0.0171650928,
0.0007138494,
-0.0306683276,
0.0463841632,
0.0030289046,
0.0415830836,
0.0278166328,
0.0063052005,
-0.032473743,
-0.0099643758,
-0.0001072503,
-0.0127150174,
0.0308882035,
-0.0194641314,
-0.0288615208,
0.0128627978,
-0.0417590514,
-0.0295002591,
0.0355048403,
-0.0291729923,
0.0349866971,
0.0606616177,
0.000120527,
-0.039275907,
-0.0387995169,
0.0092879198,
0.0599609204,
-0.0234346222,
-0.0035587312,
0.0551937781,
0.0635993555,
-0.0429607406,
0.0157074928,
0.004906069,
-0.0203680191,
0.0273649078,
-0.0030151354,
-0.0452408381,
0.0617347993,
0.015052326,
-0.076099433,
-0.0078385323,
-0.0260667112,
0.0246303175,
-0.0626102611,
-0.0527205504,
-0.048708532,
0.0140466793,
0.0304316804,
0.0294227507,
-0.0275608022,
0.0124737089,
0.0051533096,
-0.0385457352,
-0.0290674381,
-0.0477238111,
0.0279189534,
0.0129925087,
0.0456071608,
0.0047673592,
-0.03512685,
-0.0635111555,
0.0619520769,
-0.0180837978,
-0.0476853624,
-0.0278658047,
-0.0018710872,
-0.0357166007,
-0.0068624644,
-0.0118495226,
-0.0103487913,
0.0123995645,
-0.0352558233,
-0.0480638184,
0.0335633121,
-0.0407638811,
0.0354802422,
0.0014115669,
0.0113611268,
0.0053436654,
0.0088604996,
0.0094050439,
-0.0255208202,
-0.0049716402,
0.0248721428,
-0.0436892658,
-0.0452577695,
0.0030073989,
0.0321113542,
0.0590997972,
0.0260514654,
-0.0044013113,
0.0164378025,
0.0239992011,
-0.0180585533,
0.0013271261,
-0.0519364737,
-0.022848472,
-0.0138070723,
-0.0021929457,
-0.0830674618,
0.0389317647,
-0.0299594998,
-0.0034090474,
0.0274337064,
0.0018755883,
0.0006861466,
0.0276057422,
0.0312338993,
0.0048533995,
0.0649099126,
0.049016837,
-0.0060806894,
0.0360830836,
-0.0218330771,
0.0534561463,
-0.0508244224,
0.0224788375,
-0.0585227869,
-0.0184153765,
0.0561447479,
0.0136437295,
-0.014949806,
0.026633678,
-0.0348082669,
-0.0024244112,
0.0719849244,
0.0251346044,
0.0120073883,
-0.0253621098,
-0.0357288346,
0.0338901393,
0.0714490041,
0.0739468858,
0.042961698,
0.1053902432,
-0.0046125255,
0.0107077016,
0.0340646915,
0.0237077102,
-0.0025012807,
0.0340484381,
0.0249149781,
0.0766037181,
0.0343976244,
-0.0256240703,
0.058772929,
0.0211915243,
-0.0528503433,
-0.008817072,
-0.0184376072,
-0.012295384,
-0.0142936045,
-0.0207832623,
0.0645447373,
-0.0433754511,
-0.0530359782,
-0.0012944695,
0.0313072987,
-0.0132067641,
0.0408933163,
0.0081027076,
0.0142063294,
0.0315699093,
-0.0284488648,
-0.0161611792,
0.0005995305,
0.0059122816,
-0.0271078795,
0.0102422144,
-0.0358028375,
-0.00817292,
0.0422323346,
-0.0306694806,
0.041459363,
-0.0032150343,
0.0382212587,
0.0710267723,
-0.0370064266,
0.0560053512,
-0.0359261222,
-0.0643942878,
-0.0183949899,
-0.0316013508,
0.0337432437,
0.0563030466,
0.0531176627,
-0.0249892492,
0.0080342405,
0.0198818911,
-0.0373266004,
0.0399860702,
0.0367377661,
-0.0380282551,
-0.0303153154,
0.0321847312,
-0.0526810773,
0.0282398649,
0.0623485781,
0.0464979485,
-0.093490459,
0.080849804,
-0.0268443394,
0.0316309631,
-0.0304856133,
0.0303924978,
0.0114383418,
0.0168541986,
0.0177772734,
-0.011523271,
0.0362555161,
0.0433564819,
0.0577390268,
0.0094880909,
0.0226039514,
-0.0953939706,
-0.0208129864,
0.0219329745,
-0.0053497176,
0.0121401977,
-0.0517807677,
-0.045287583,
-0.0340681635,
-0.0322985649,
-0.0956472307,
0.0098483628,
0.0241189003,
-0.0192783251,
-0.0407540947,
0.0028536327,
0.0054669613,
-0.0183155201,
-0.0649780631,
-0.0454972088,
0.0124807069,
-0.0358586684,
-0.0546537451,
0.0008827199,
-0.1179049537,
-0.013270624,
0.021905899,
-0.0050120126,
0.0317678079,
-0.0533076823,
0.0005353994,
-0.0032436529,
-0.0282494519,
-0.0150236953,
0.0156464297,
0.04242488,
0.0058637001,
-0.0047538225,
0.0231462047,
0.0675445944,
0.008168174,
0.0112937214,
-0.020381555,
0.0112955244,
-0.0454741381,
-0.026434904,
-0.0016412821,
0.00847873,
0.0847040862,
0.0307828411,
-0.0015822867,
-0.0072398018,
-0.0413530059,
0.0551159605,
0.011642308,
-0.0066295005,
0.0231268052,
0.0370482057,
-0.0135657266,
0.0554887131,
-0.0150374258,
-0.0526919588,
-0.0387626663,
-0.0232204236,
-0.0389976986,
0.035041865,
-0.0683662966,
-0.0142788095,
-0.0238413177,
-0.058651004,
-0.0075500137,
-0.0201302823,
-0.0090531213,
0.0379450917,
-0.0536101311,
-0.0077060638,
-0.0245658197,
0.0174723081,
0.0255218018,
-0.0795126632,
0.0073469104,
0.0111871054,
-0.0223709997,
-0.0121599305,
0.003659182,
-0.0316237584,
-0.0462982506,
-0.0220079124,
0.0225092936,
0.0238091927,
-0.0310958251,
0.0394018292,
0.0232003313,
0.0373748951,
-0.0339930765,
0.017835347,
0.0403120108,
-0.0223378949,
0.0466931015,
0.0021117276,
0.0153460298,
-0.0487440899,
0.0057757809,
0.0507884994,
-0.0694268942,
0.0614455156,
0.0448962599,
-0.0558946356,
-0.0118681891,
0.0007626831,
0.013644197,
-0.0479622185,
0.0186683089,
0.0336217619,
0.038614504,
0.0508835018,
0.0934392586,
-0.0074248454,
0.0142312674,
0.0189821664,
0.0014620676,
0.0250369571,
-0.0082712397,
0.0031646991,
0.0160053689,
0.0035431928,
0.0519581661,
0.0262076762,
-0.0002545702,
0.0338294841,
-0.0463748276,
-0.0418031737,
-0.0103760641,
0.0550347269,
-0.0047718999,
-0.0614034347,
-0.013815159,
-0.0282282829,
0.0236070473,
-0.0211505778,
0.0049355468,
-0.026649572,
-0.0058911508,
0.0218394082,
-0.0914229304,
-0.0238357075,
-0.0069163269,
-0.0601367801,
0.0926339105,
0.0263613798,
0.0595987737,
0.0253160782,
-0.0280849915,
-0.0854737237,
-0.0183542725,
-0.0044702888,
0.009537518,
-0.0038611947,
0.0250331685,
-0.0210903287,
0.0084497305,
0.0509978682,
0.0321955532,
-0.0050886711,
-0.0113964304,
0.0581177361,
-0.0250074808,
0.0182870254,
0.0099331727,
0.0634738505,
0.0150468098,
0.0422006734,
0.042817615,
-0.0222461317,
0.0076521258,
0.0459376872,
0.0620876141,
-0.0017575336,
-0.0244984534,
0.0078042881,
-0.0107492562,
-0.0040424592,
-0.0222637244,
0.0027564766,
-0.0375985876,
0.0552318245,
0.0274497047,
0.0110320356,
0.0114254393,
0.0022200635,
-0.0314573646,
-0.0373432748,
-0.0210678726,
0.0545073375,
-0.0193532016,
-0.0173831191,
0.0057499507,
-0.0339383148,
0.0079093054,
-0.0253271256,
-0.0299506206,
-0.0198581759,
-0.0112983398,
-0.0404525883,
0.0133164767,
0.099240236,
0.0097275209,
0.0102124941,
0.0669002458,
-0.0165838432,
0.0127330916,
0.0205025021,
0.0561795346,
-0.0066301525,
-0.0167484693,
0.0080737099,
-0.0284893475,
0.0262706671,
-0.0132633653,
-0.0308634304,
-0.0185824055,
-0.0666834339,
-0.0036971085,
0.0196932144,
0.0131790107,
-0.0056151627,
0.0529976077,
-0.026936749,
-0.0229603145,
-0.0411681682,
0.0637474209,
-0.0218816884,
-0.0422434136,
0.0342948101,
0.0618924461,
0.020566605,
-0.0073187845,
-0.0134921372,
-0.004042394,
0.0470411777,
0.0347532332,
-0.0194516554,
-0.0188171994,
-0.024119975,
0.0089721913,
-0.0454659946,
0.0013394463,
-0.0256214906,
-0.0358237661,
0.0140155312,
-0.0268440489,
-0.0277049653,
-0.0018742795,
0.0028334039,
0.0370545685,
-0.0348287635,
0.0355456844,
-0.005476498,
-0.0450117178,
0.0156102674,
-0.0341363363,
0.0293785147,
0.014394369,
0.0478180386,
-0.0335441567,
0.019684488,
-0.0828929767,
-0.0082044248,
0.0324871875,
-0.0112860501,
-0.0523216538,
-0.0057863407,
0.0778316036,
0.0098387124,
0.0029540046,
-0.0731460825,
-0.0155068953,
-0.032939896,
-0.024051806,
0.028769955,
-0.0227202661,
-0.0211909525,
-0.0460177958,
-0.0084550371,
-0.0228541009,
0.0717402697,
-0.030799754,
0.0078103552,
0.0070445826,
-0.0112032089,
-0.0083389552,
-0.04226055,
0.0436463356,
0.0237295888,
-0.0429381318,
-0.0072481302,
-0.0582123473,
0.017843673,
-4.887518901e-33,
-0.0137516195,
0.0109734572,
-0.0070071076,
-0.0095397243,
-0.0561296791,
-0.0078931339,
-0.0055184229,
0.0076271761,
-0.0098404735,
-0.0259000082,
0.0089069949,
-0.0277990829,
-0.0088289855,
0.0057947822,
-0.0213286225,
0.0201298092,
0.0579891466,
0.0144015951,
0.0269271918,
0.0082670134,
0.0492436849,
0.0568246394,
-0.0252930466,
-0.0503922738,
-0.0564910285,
-0.0337702408,
0.0227546599,
-0.0509219989,
0.0288930405,
0.0368181691,
-0.0151192956,
0.027660815,
-0.031623736,
-0.0095921261,
-0.0502407067,
0.0407539494,
-0.0192467235,
-0.0281312484,
-0.0329163298,
0.0483556241,
0.0309173167,
-0.0417093784,
0.0017321657,
-0.0321310461,
-0.0502009206,
-0.0207449216,
0.0215523541,
-0.0384630971,
-0.0228373632,
-0.020182142,
-0.0048918333,
0.0179342069,
0.0265204627,
-0.0384580605,
0.0726088434,
0.0677158535,
-0.0009225738,
-0.0627081916,
-0.0498208515,
0.0573095866,
-0.0435579047,
0.0224483926,
0.0159756988,
0.0513137802,
0.0407525636,
0.0439949073,
0.054874789,
-0.0991330221,
0.0303055756,
0.0291388985,
0.0322432853,
0.0282950569,
0.0348457284,
0.04738722,
0.0079480279,
-0.0176202767,
-0.0113500664,
-0.007659459,
0.0123944106,
-0.0521569476,
-0.0021291424,
0.0214275625,
0.004309006,
-0.0012240752,
-0.0368399955,
-0.0059380308,
0.0097657228,
-0.040495269,
0.0335019566,
-0.0177560486,
0.0100857802,
-0.019577967,
0.0684017092,
-0.0563042164,
0.0367932245,
-0.009182062,
-0.0662744194,
0.0128325857,
0.0188869238,
-0.0274841543,
0.001401635,
-0.0554536097,
0.1049896181,
0.0127790961,
0.021468142,
-0.0335574336,
-0.0043128901,
0.0659513474,
-0.0225145221,
-0.0269501191,
0.0285441745,
-0.0263755061,
-0.0005364658,
-0.0473259836,
0.0389506817,
-0.0118927518,
0.0193267893,
0.0000132218,
0.0396537296,
0.0263003167,
0.0486088879,
-0.0239465106,
0.011210192,
0.0462676696,
-0.0152487103,
0.0375542492,
-0.0301459469,
-0.0082287844,
0.021572357,
-0.006834215,
0.0131033827,
-0.0269738585,
2.589e-7,
-0.0848311335,
-0.0586878173,
0.0486345179,
-0.035892278,
0.043599315,
-0.0082601113,
-0.0094219055,
0.0279830117,
-0.0153697776,
-0.0205071624,
0.0590160824,
-0.0386560075,
0.0945408642,
0.0045761243,
-0.0973087177,
-0.0227373838,
-0.0948032662,
0.0042583863,
-0.04816778,
0.0229980778,
0.0514102615,
0.058709342,
0.034348581,
0.0024045885,
-0.0053074104,
-0.0163163971,
0.0364239924,
-0.0274894591,
-0.0104355654,
-0.0614465363,
0.0285502747,
-0.0490700155,
0.0136333723,
-0.010022914,
-0.0289467201,
0.0681365281,
0.053133335,
0.0001835956,
0.0412295125,
-0.0141151911,
-0.0241924226,
0.0283407606,
-0.0638705343,
0.0410428569,
0.0277601238,
0.0337276943,
-0.0272282884,
-0.0288810451,
-0.0433672629,
0.0396377519,
-0.0128694652,
0.0023172647,
-0.0016830569,
-0.00995648,
0.0176909138,
-0.0043306299,
0.0501567312,
0.015114109,
0.0252043009,
0.0321796611,
-0.1028995663,
-0.0550465733,
-0.0151060428,
-0.0391915552,
0.0795044824,
0.0155296456,
-0.0059771705,
1.99297376e-34,
-0.0247042608,
0.0067700879,
0.0371403061,
-0.0323085748,
-0.0231404174,
-0.0469160341,
0.0068185194,
0.0070875585,
0.0396543741,
-0.0252512842,
-0.0360585935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07081v1 | Using Large Language Models for Student-Code Guided Test Case Generation in Computer Science Education | 2024-02-11T01:37:48 | 2024-02-11T01:37:48 | Nischal Ashok Kumar, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | In computer science education, test cases are an integral part of programming
assignments since they can be used as assessment items to test students'
programming knowledge and provide personalized feedback on student-written
code. The goal of our work is to propose a fully automated approach for test
case generation that can accurately measure student knowledge, which is
important for two reasons. First, manually constructing test cases requires
expert knowledge and is a labor-intensive process. Second, developing test
cases for students, especially those who are novice programmers, is
significantly different from those oriented toward professional-level software
developers. Therefore, we need an automated process for test case generation to
assess student knowledge and provide feedback. In this work, we propose a large
language model-based approach to automatically generate test cases and show
that they are good measures of student knowledge, using a publicly available
dataset that contains student-written Java code. We also discuss future
research directions centered on using test cases to help students. | [
-0.0073638214,
0.0306528658,
-0.0718545914,
0.0494353883,
-0.0351010188,
-0.0175107177,
0.0004716274,
-0.0104766153,
0.0250649657,
-0.0417583659,
0.0615548119,
0.0244353451,
-0.0040704301,
0.0336998403,
0.0101563176,
-0.0220697094,
0.0266850516,
-0.0405294001,
-0.0017845972,
0.0365318544,
-0.0087529328,
0.0022454665,
-0.0350699723,
0.0312146507,
0.012360882,
-0.0632098615,
-0.0307738315,
-0.0157769322,
-0.027713798,
-0.0340089016,
0.0180268679,
0.0453440696,
-0.0030679672,
0.0016790831,
0.0000018553,
-0.0620484352,
0.0234032534,
0.0176647045,
0.0089588333,
0.0696582943,
-0.0062630214,
0.07375817,
0.0035465255,
0.0204773489,
-0.0376289338,
-0.0113187069,
0.0324632488,
-0.0397222489,
0.0861124173,
0.0540240072,
0.0236078911,
0.0015126067,
0.007894964,
0.0465360545,
0.0615097135,
0.0163429212,
0.0146494657,
0.0946971029,
0.0429155156,
-0.000283804,
0.0001345687,
-0.0431177355,
0.0315983519,
-0.0202984903,
-0.0161198303,
0.0109847728,
-0.0636029989,
0.0485504791,
0.031752523,
0.0115506966,
-0.0163832884,
-0.0741423219,
0.0148019316,
0.0055496939,
0.0091206506,
0.0306927431,
-0.0058247549,
0.0424317159,
0.0056567732,
-0.0299305245,
0.0127274096,
-0.0167483576,
-0.0225414243,
0.0049032955,
0.0038954276,
0.0277761538,
0.0002339669,
-0.0214502383,
-0.0561001003,
-0.0011965495,
0.0003027387,
-0.0447910167,
0.0034031062,
0.0655547157,
0.0194582231,
0.0019846121,
-0.0158591717,
-0.0379695445,
0.0593322664,
-0.0547870137,
-0.0006677356,
0.0164360255,
0.0060411086,
0.0152416322,
-0.0478137732,
0.0576835833,
0.033680819,
-0.0341398641,
-0.0026910922,
0.0397765413,
-0.0483128615,
-0.0024614078,
-0.039102871,
0.0210162997,
0.0486585498,
0.0790181831,
-0.0275318697,
0.050939288,
-0.0538467169,
0.0763368532,
-0.0337443687,
-0.0252283812,
0.0132953124,
0.0239171479,
0.0249921568,
-0.0361756943,
-0.0139523298,
-0.0430094302,
0.004130478,
-0.0184112005,
0.0091343345,
0.02312975,
-0.0219478328,
0.020199921,
0.00356645,
0.0610098317,
0.0244427156,
0.0359333642,
-0.0393640809,
-0.0578059442,
0.0325243473,
0.0173882209,
-0.0173230302,
-0.1206749827,
-0.0371412933,
0.0391112044,
-0.012275015,
-0.0463531539,
0.0020813858,
0.0280496459,
0.0636260509,
0.0404364988,
0.000847747,
0.0100542475,
0.0178254321,
0.0141027691,
0.0048212674,
0.0215379,
0.0399577357,
0.0008711676,
0.0202189758,
-0.0557818748,
0.0637001172,
0.0193487611,
-0.0273411535,
0.0131790498,
-0.0045093242,
0.0449166149,
0.0396870375,
0.0102769239,
-0.0418800004,
0.0241035502,
0.0183925834,
0.0497090742,
-0.0279485695,
0.0203152765,
0.0026070701,
0.0468590148,
0.047376845,
0.0303120371,
0.0145819681,
-0.0097520398,
0.0030823029,
0.0353662781,
-0.0349799022,
0.0122078033,
-0.0435123779,
0.026606407,
0.0210118089,
-0.0417255908,
-0.0166927688,
-0.0149869109,
0.0090512522,
0.0142917689,
0.0527439602,
0.0035016511,
-0.0130893365,
0.058526855,
-0.000637681,
-0.0903397948,
0.0077423817,
-0.0296360906,
0.0449448451,
-0.0032995713,
0.0297745168,
-0.0733617097,
0.0031733478,
0.0159134287,
0.0044258069,
-0.0381204635,
0.0739548579,
-0.0402250104,
-0.0471033379,
-0.0243281461,
-0.000719235,
-0.0048966408,
0.0052485387,
-0.0057678618,
0.0333736725,
-0.037136402,
0.0668442994,
-0.0732755736,
-0.0537223704,
0.0247439723,
-0.0142852906,
-0.0208235253,
-0.0190309305,
0.0175915826,
0.0023134039,
-0.0283011459,
-0.0180960651,
0.0216257442,
0.0368749909,
0.0125277322,
0.0213056467,
-0.0327855386,
0.0079313405,
-0.0216408186,
0.0435017608,
-0.0759823918,
-0.042958349,
0.0220767502,
-0.0429263972,
-0.0214207321,
0.059177693,
-0.0120503707,
0.0007490756,
0.0015341084,
0.0044016754,
-0.0540564172,
-0.0404151082,
0.0163789373,
0.0384454764,
0.0888017192,
0.0581635348,
-0.0199232623,
0.0238579661,
0.0236124322,
-0.0023276147,
-0.0209778287,
-0.0026623281,
-0.0303117074,
0.037385691,
0.0133099156,
0.0322607644,
-0.0535647608,
-0.0031130351,
-0.0672020018,
0.0052674781,
0.0108543225,
0.0462298244,
0.0236877576,
-0.0134060839,
-0.0143683115,
0.0111320019,
-0.0592429303,
-0.0370660089,
-0.0093170833,
-0.0295172241,
0.0027617558,
-0.0369376503,
-0.0579585768,
-0.0100059435,
-0.0114843231,
-0.0956201777,
0.0470305532,
0.0064651454,
0.0172477402,
-0.0482496358,
0.092936106,
0.0080267051,
-0.0068529989,
0.0024504042,
-0.0279089455,
-0.0185235534,
-0.0473045222,
0.0260305144,
0.0755539685,
-0.0063459715,
0.0059499922,
0.0401348472,
-0.0254873559,
-0.0276811626,
-0.0031458247,
0.0479113273,
-0.0290805381,
0.0185528044,
-0.0669552088,
0.0324675776,
0.0203935616,
-0.0056333137,
-0.0456120409,
0.0044764406,
0.0257905945,
-0.0296073277,
0.0898865908,
-0.0197653193,
-0.0140967229,
0.0002171985,
0.0225741342,
0.0021176198,
-0.0521158874,
0.0942781419,
-0.046905376,
0.0173412506,
-0.0271302089,
0.0039181542,
-0.0494634174,
0.0475979932,
0.0104689067,
0.0188116226,
-0.0398496352,
0.0013132893,
-0.0154346032,
0.012076606,
0.0207343698,
-0.0596403331,
0.0518555306,
-0.0608143993,
-0.0215916242,
0.005946429,
0.0213426761,
-0.0587752312,
0.0338618495,
0.0130275609,
0.0083270306,
0.0003168563,
0.0005175183,
0.0517889373,
-0.0018809368,
0.0194031093,
0.0093494253,
0.0182569642,
-0.0192254763,
0.0050669215,
-0.0072861989,
-0.0586076044,
-0.0506314673,
-0.02623358,
-0.0251469146,
0.0118267089,
0.0187940076,
0.0438252576,
0.0667653382,
-0.0712722391,
-0.0054259058,
0.0066819843,
-0.0702963993,
0.0293979328,
0.0656136051,
0.0312251411,
-0.057831943,
-0.0142811388,
0.057573799,
0.0376474001,
-0.0173762217,
0.0065123513,
0.002757051,
-0.0140285613,
0.0897205546,
0.0688378364,
-0.068353124,
0.0006290554,
-0.0403016023,
-0.0105161853,
-0.0353359282,
-0.011445242,
-0.0168614779,
-0.0888658687,
0.01202414,
0.0385877714,
-0.0042749341,
-0.0375261903,
-0.0283996798,
-0.0091987168,
-0.0016468952,
-0.0198357608,
0.0421296395,
0.0034901428,
0.0298431572,
0.0352712795,
-0.033167012,
-0.0397040732,
0.0583062619,
0.0218398366,
0.0211462192,
0.0403581113,
0.0039511421,
-0.0311712008,
-0.0098263808,
-0.012682965,
-0.0027740011,
0.0101993158,
0.0010648842,
-0.0204166304,
0.0215726849,
-0.0248548761,
0.038153708,
0.0252840314,
-0.0805021971,
-0.0043008416,
0.1096841171,
0.0354571827,
-0.0065780343,
-0.0092622535,
-0.0439616553,
-0.0364166796,
0.0160533804,
0.0035337412,
0.0492274947,
0.0065801181,
0.0374516323,
-0.0820534527,
-0.0375322178,
-0.0348379947,
-0.0304139089,
-0.0157552473,
-0.0032803791,
0.0501673222,
0.0183402561,
0.0049049673,
0.0823061615,
0.0068093752,
0.0338970758,
-0.0605557077,
0.0110105677,
0.0007409237,
-0.0866288915,
0.0387768485,
-0.0125014745,
0.0360425264,
-0.0085109361,
-0.0109803313,
-0.0180231724,
-0.0241005383,
-0.0439635962,
0.0181337446,
-0.0615447126,
-0.0568084344,
-0.0236380249,
0.0445066988,
0.0103035774,
-0.0412373804,
-0.0242096931,
-0.0170687456,
-0.0743179917,
-0.0193889271,
0.0024625366,
-0.0097590899,
-0.0247856621,
-0.0541766584,
0.0081748059,
-0.0303562284,
-0.0265558958,
-0.0024001852,
0.0022513173,
-0.0195460673,
-0.0037152979,
0.0073763225,
0.044589892,
0.0620556138,
0.0265509076,
0.0426626801,
-0.0280937646,
0.0278271157,
0.0028952002,
-0.0123478444,
-0.0514837056,
-0.0008507592,
0.0425923206,
-0.0271769259,
0.0090400921,
0.026791336,
-0.0140400641,
-0.0596480072,
0.025321776,
0.0249812361,
0.1003369242,
0.0042854301,
0.0214013644,
0.0614168085,
-0.0279643256,
-0.0177212674,
-0.0461546779,
-0.002018078,
0.0325585939,
-0.0075772777,
0.0485475324,
0.016613001,
0.0643726066,
-0.0032470152,
-0.0202472098,
0.0056270421,
-0.0353402607,
0.0010351998,
0.0116931237,
-0.0031498594,
0.0069242148,
-0.0334295444,
-0.0736927465,
0.027883824,
-0.0059693931,
0.0468584336,
-0.027003726,
-0.0639302358,
-0.0102717075,
0.0496896952,
0.0303302035,
-0.026609309,
0.0694555491,
0.0019308591,
-0.0349135436,
-0.0144289006,
-0.0183270443,
-0.0278964024,
0.0573990233,
0.0655263886,
0.0106379418,
-0.0022338682,
-0.0421007685,
-0.0201120842,
-0.0840947032,
-0.0393269435,
0.067762062,
0.0614813007,
0.0445434004,
0.024749849,
0.0821094885,
-0.0110298237,
0.0057246499,
0.0072283987,
0.022439301,
-0.0301140081,
-0.0524318963,
-0.0188768748,
-4.823969472e-33,
-0.026258966,
-0.0467669927,
-0.0007902303,
0.0201539937,
0.0691054389,
-0.0021111423,
-0.0335515067,
0.0180439223,
-0.0041124825,
-0.0207571983,
0.0186261255,
0.0441617742,
-0.0066287783,
-0.0213282034,
0.0348763354,
0.04015458,
0.023669485,
0.0302603487,
-0.0362267531,
0.0160820279,
-0.0469867438,
-0.0423990451,
0.061332915,
-0.022508366,
0.0172535032,
-0.0515821353,
0.0188351572,
-0.0251468159,
-0.0498844199,
0.0271607935,
0.0443977714,
0.054959096,
-0.0052366266,
0.0061339596,
0.0031718842,
-0.0151865482,
0.0075320611,
-0.0520502254,
0.0140336631,
-0.0085008852,
0.0127720609,
-0.0398550183,
0.0327877738,
-0.0161528476,
-0.0149844121,
0.030491421,
0.0626858622,
-0.0027867255,
0.0250617228,
-0.0182791352,
-0.0339187272,
0.0053871972,
-0.1044992283,
-0.0190832056,
-0.016890686,
0.0051033865,
-0.0105810305,
-0.0155959222,
0.0561564304,
0.0682725906,
0.0353346914,
0.0530517958,
0.0505553298,
-0.0271148216,
-0.0142451329,
0.0031581926,
0.0160026476,
0.0335003957,
0.001774441,
0.0012039721,
0.0320061408,
0.0057885116,
0.0352803059,
0.0336968862,
0.0386896878,
-0.0154899638,
-0.0297993571,
0.0255999379,
0.0237460136,
-0.0243902449,
-0.0014857909,
-0.0436643958,
-0.0649479926,
-0.0139899887,
-0.0530465543,
-0.0372724086,
-0.019627383,
-0.0277378224,
0.0143716019,
-0.052235011,
-0.0277332962,
-0.0094343415,
-0.0160793513,
-0.0479517542,
-0.027573986,
0.006130083,
-0.0125168096,
0.0291334111,
-0.0478548333,
0.0170695744,
0.013575526,
-0.0345975235,
-0.0149767147,
-0.0201191381,
0.0619302094,
0.0056199525,
-0.0045689861,
0.0029019695,
-0.039833989,
-0.011086761,
-0.0447084792,
-0.045394104,
-0.0151998382,
0.0149928015,
-0.006202512,
0.041822806,
0.0386453345,
0.0101052243,
0.0239339806,
-0.0949801579,
-0.0676530823,
-0.0271189585,
-0.0198904555,
-0.0246901289,
0.0029419444,
-0.048459366,
-0.0415346995,
0.0422363468,
0.0311919302,
-0.0095771281,
-0.0222378485,
0.0119641507,
2.516e-7,
0.0056934836,
0.048067797,
-0.034493763,
0.0535680205,
-0.0344943069,
0.007233297,
-0.029522242,
-0.0131377224,
0.0636588484,
-0.0089870337,
-0.038628269,
-0.0013875354,
0.0184009951,
0.0352288485,
-0.0507080965,
0.0228582826,
0.0177309513,
-0.0371310301,
-0.0689420775,
0.0444735959,
0.1210849956,
-0.0259124581,
0.0109226592,
0.02772942,
-0.0119177168,
-0.0459678136,
-0.0201959424,
0.0006148526,
0.0097467862,
0.0617753342,
-0.0358448029,
-0.0298084673,
0.031371925,
0.0686490163,
-0.007892563,
-0.0526878424,
-0.0157110505,
0.0127441706,
0.0150934802,
0.067416206,
0.0268126316,
-0.0105939815,
-0.0078355558,
-0.0446937233,
-0.0050306111,
-0.0090394681,
0.0144497836,
-0.0029595348,
-0.0211496241,
-0.0422775969,
-0.0487912893,
-0.0050037084,
0.0234804694,
0.003482094,
-0.034692321,
-0.0327580683,
-0.0192958303,
0.0106087616,
-0.0590788797,
0.0067697824,
-0.0051898602,
-0.0376051664,
0.0010974093,
-0.0241575316,
0.0259872563,
0.0089437496,
0.0460044332,
2.353087143e-34,
0.0165629275,
-0.0238214582,
0.0500728786,
-0.0019724993,
0.0244216193,
-0.0118751507,
0.0160959493,
0.0284384955,
-0.0284635965,
0.0365879424,
-0.037155807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07069v1 | Using Large Language Models to Automate and Expedite Reinforcement Learning with Reward Machine | 2024-02-11T00:00:05 | 2024-02-11T00:00:05 | Shayan Meshkat Alsadat, Jean-Raphael Gaglione, Daniel Neider, Ufuk Topcu, Zhe Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present LARL-RM (Large language model-generated Automaton for
Reinforcement Learning with Reward Machine) algorithm in order to encode
high-level knowledge into reinforcement learning using automaton to expedite
the reinforcement learning. Our method uses Large Language Models (LLM) to
obtain high-level domain-specific knowledge using prompt engineering instead of
providing the reinforcement learning algorithm directly with the high-level
knowledge which requires an expert to encode the automaton. We use
chain-of-thought and few-shot methods for prompt engineering and demonstrate
that our method works using these approaches. Additionally, LARL-RM allows for
fully closed-loop reinforcement learning without the need for an expert to
guide and supervise the learning since LARL-RM can use the LLM directly to
generate the required high-level knowledge for the task at hand. We also show
the theoretical guarantee of our algorithm to converge to an optimal policy. We
demonstrate that LARL-RM speeds up the convergence by 30% by implementing our
method in two case studies. | [
0.0164072067,
0.0668251142,
-0.0187509358,
0.0215087533,
-0.0368559994,
0.0227974225,
0.0018403523,
-0.0415922627,
0.0007092644,
-0.0292422138,
-0.0231387205,
0.0224382654,
-0.0335667804,
0.0784489512,
0.011872015,
-0.0681857988,
0.0309209898,
-0.0710209459,
0.0150314234,
-0.0088116731,
-0.0255128294,
-0.038832128,
0.0127256671,
0.0228498485,
0.015265258,
-0.021380309,
-0.0436659046,
-0.0184713397,
0.0335669443,
-0.0292995349,
-0.0141113,
0.0007091311,
0.0520863645,
0.0406989567,
0.0000023844,
-0.0551676117,
-0.0300291795,
-0.0043843607,
-0.0059599136,
-0.0060835592,
-0.0158811174,
-0.0030496824,
-0.0168092921,
0.0142520219,
-0.0154625932,
0.0121402098,
0.0424156748,
0.0416643992,
0.072198607,
0.0770868808,
0.010561456,
-0.042242609,
0.0265525132,
-0.044275783,
0.0174113456,
-0.075904049,
0.0516254455,
0.0466759913,
0.0517590567,
-0.0055383067,
-0.0440231338,
0.0070100771,
0.0339753404,
-0.0132151265,
-0.021715913,
0.0312761962,
0.0639138222,
-0.0190363806,
-0.0245191511,
0.0310453065,
-0.0343273617,
0.0205135513,
0.0215465277,
-0.0090833893,
0.0001152151,
0.0071684965,
0.0033359441,
0.0659912229,
0.0109974053,
0.0252880044,
0.0185962245,
-0.0183684211,
-0.0005317514,
0.0039594374,
-0.0432594121,
0.0887914225,
0.0004268155,
-0.0355156288,
0.0251244381,
0.0054288781,
0.0058386535,
-0.04398508,
-0.0438217446,
0.0680651888,
-0.0639670044,
0.0147328926,
-0.0049504926,
-0.0039757867,
-0.0252405833,
0.0067278547,
0.0463884696,
0.0260708351,
0.0040648477,
0.0325617939,
-0.037799079,
0.0608969703,
-0.045472201,
-0.019283779,
-0.0187200624,
0.0108288769,
-0.0446217917,
0.0105820028,
-0.0363585949,
0.035093043,
-0.0357397869,
-0.0082231965,
-0.0579259805,
0.0646803677,
-0.0342470855,
0.0572651327,
-0.0273589622,
-0.0161863044,
-0.0160528496,
0.0044717239,
-0.0783784017,
0.0007212913,
-0.0408812352,
0.0218069572,
0.0098950723,
0.0117329974,
0.0251031071,
0.0006888842,
-0.0185534172,
-0.006552923,
0.0203046836,
0.1095939204,
-0.0098084202,
0.0017900716,
-0.0345339514,
-0.0483813621,
0.0132554984,
-0.056567017,
-0.0097177811,
-0.0812232941,
-0.0136980908,
-0.0269779395,
-0.0240748338,
-0.0108429454,
0.0094743231,
-0.0143209677,
-0.017275,
0.0693885535,
-0.0152226053,
0.0016305497,
0.0136724524,
-0.0239826236,
-0.0337940566,
0.0507881679,
0.0191080868,
0.0670239478,
-0.0149654001,
0.0264845267,
0.0214203727,
0.0639986843,
-0.00554949,
0.0086924434,
-0.0067256913,
-0.0248996988,
0.0520146638,
0.0355100296,
0.0305741262,
0.0194489639,
-0.0193521362,
0.0559821166,
0.0398177207,
0.0193845741,
0.0108630601,
-0.0344502479,
0.0490705147,
0.0215862114,
-0.0119701736,
-0.0342199132,
-0.0023834647,
0.0273903906,
-0.0010396326,
0.0095257489,
0.0028425676,
0.0284496583,
-0.0290812291,
-0.0359816812,
0.0599003211,
-0.0208404642,
0.018507557,
0.0585177578,
0.0506407544,
-0.0078774896,
-0.0388233885,
-0.0294386856,
0.0464821644,
0.0451656356,
-0.0149065387,
-0.0787862614,
0.0729282647,
0.0438694656,
0.0230852049,
-0.0540505499,
0.0022746017,
-0.0540108159,
-0.0012387971,
0.0602077991,
-0.0021569133,
-0.0216181763,
-0.0538234562,
-0.0032315257,
-0.0492600761,
0.0055010887,
0.0138644977,
0.0637241304,
0.0071912627,
0.011562488,
-0.0411389023,
0.0699774995,
-0.0322563164,
0.0353287235,
-0.0376683548,
-0.0585316531,
0.0078278473,
0.021921536,
0.0377269313,
-0.0386705585,
-0.0212386493,
0.0045861886,
0.0046462803,
-0.0291701574,
-0.0543564111,
-0.0345246531,
-0.0368116088,
-0.0090794358,
0.0248663966,
0.0027241148,
-0.0066352375,
-0.0082205134,
-0.0362374261,
-0.0210716482,
-0.0123416679,
-0.0324167758,
0.0049167112,
0.0010252626,
0.0088193603,
-0.0097546037,
-0.0141459806,
-0.0626648664,
0.0540862456,
0.0048711626,
-0.024646746,
0.0229809303,
0.0123417508,
-0.011457474,
-0.0211581104,
-0.002298275,
0.0154473102,
0.0102203107,
0.0327303596,
0.0566954054,
0.069375366,
-0.0046911808,
-0.0306094736,
0.0086581223,
-0.0096745463,
-0.0168108586,
-0.0214589722,
-0.0283515193,
0.0101250047,
-0.0053975503,
-0.0183744915,
-0.0183384493,
0.0449597575,
0.0170042086,
0.005241611,
0.0323850326,
0.0499099009,
-0.026595518,
-0.0182380788,
0.0033080755,
0.0111886356,
0.0280851144,
0.0010036452,
0.0365910046,
-0.0527535751,
0.0204541422,
0.0005760186,
0.0515185855,
-0.0117962044,
-0.0225600321,
0.034489952,
-0.0410405695,
0.0342601463,
0.0709565207,
0.0180102102,
0.0297173131,
0.065942049,
-0.0028355825,
-0.0728150979,
0.0488855764,
-0.0494562872,
-0.0908255503,
-0.0497328825,
0.0154339997,
0.0417994298,
0.0789447874,
-0.0166905019,
0.0045102462,
-0.0538296551,
0.0332050547,
0.0083340043,
-0.0407565981,
-0.0602215715,
-0.0278409347,
-0.0560999624,
0.0599541143,
-0.013581465,
-0.0385293514,
0.0757207945,
0.0160756558,
0.0145100486,
-0.0216936339,
-0.0111355381,
-0.0374582857,
0.0530533008,
-0.0057939677,
0.0483865775,
-0.0257263053,
-0.0231177881,
-0.0402442478,
0.0030339495,
0.0056177885,
0.0136537477,
0.0346710123,
-0.0222636703,
0.0005007714,
0.0098249456,
-0.0460777767,
-0.0757839903,
0.0038993615,
-0.0551335476,
0.0220919196,
-0.0178086758,
-0.0101775918,
-0.0231896825,
-0.0131189888,
0.0534645021,
0.0257714894,
-0.0346422493,
-0.0205070004,
-0.0338840596,
-0.0216633789,
0.0495485663,
-0.0133908689,
-0.0218410064,
-0.0246355291,
0.0707236826,
0.002287484,
0.0024583165,
-0.0142942593,
-0.0395044982,
0.0368624777,
0.0109488051,
-0.0573000461,
0.0131968223,
0.0617321916,
-0.0031117005,
-0.0769343376,
-0.0167278796,
0.107116729,
0.00945671,
-0.0302139875,
0.0092011141,
-0.0611791573,
0.000707061,
0.0167696681,
0.076745607,
-0.0698240548,
-0.0271487795,
0.0048084245,
0.0155875785,
0.0001822105,
-0.0352655835,
0.0091137793,
-0.1200913563,
0.0053155762,
-0.0256931689,
-0.0442031212,
-0.0495593026,
-0.0125624165,
-0.0031447103,
0.0300644618,
-0.0235880073,
0.0440257527,
0.0058942861,
-0.0262703821,
0.0091880299,
0.0190470796,
-0.0164172277,
0.0348595902,
-0.0359146968,
0.0400399901,
0.1183264479,
0.0168321002,
-0.0250697378,
-0.0141361449,
-0.005614059,
0.0548757762,
0.0184873473,
-0.0003066516,
-0.0355736874,
-0.0098565351,
-0.0418785512,
0.0301540922,
0.0719420016,
0.017345326,
-0.0053036017,
0.0333984382,
0.0894673243,
-0.0204757135,
-0.0254914016,
-0.0017490088,
-0.0150191747,
0.0488756299,
0.0268966593,
-0.008993133,
-0.0597620383,
-0.0322031118,
-0.018777376,
-0.1139363423,
-0.000517274,
-0.0502261929,
-0.0207328983,
0.0090835877,
0.011929471,
-0.0485668853,
-0.0208600536,
-0.0042263195,
0.0186267421,
0.0259012859,
-0.0130405296,
0.0315400176,
0.0556179695,
-0.0102380766,
0.0093247257,
-0.0704397485,
0.0215640571,
-0.0561753698,
-0.0002621115,
0.0081531303,
-0.0443604551,
-0.0475586653,
-0.0007134349,
0.0211923625,
-0.050833784,
-0.0141534274,
0.0669777095,
0.0106768021,
0.0336713754,
-0.0039201165,
-0.0224139933,
0.0870108232,
0.0071457564,
-0.035691645,
-0.0106793726,
0.0164609663,
0.0203427505,
-0.001241954,
0.0276027936,
-0.0714588016,
0.0480387323,
0.0289650187,
0.0073544094,
0.0059583695,
-0.0193659198,
0.0292995963,
0.0149375321,
0.0242013987,
-0.0366181768,
-0.011624814,
-0.0153192244,
-0.0307326782,
-0.0060369754,
-0.0395485461,
-0.045400966,
-0.0092125945,
0.0018574485,
-0.0133873317,
0.0328611918,
-0.0536722913,
0.0541501604,
0.0094199888,
0.0122557394,
0.0238807201,
0.0090160603,
0.0590131916,
0.0421655886,
0.0220286194,
0.0248025917,
-0.0152035458,
0.0424907282,
0.0248363744,
-0.0163043384,
0.0580462739,
0.0407524295,
0.0243883505,
-0.0747777075,
-0.0024635221,
-0.0053662816,
-0.106380187,
0.0127128894,
0.0296805203,
0.0750368014,
0.0312027317,
-0.0304482058,
-0.0948856995,
-0.002738222,
0.0068534329,
0.0053449217,
-0.0231587049,
-0.0331234597,
0.0474795662,
0.0302779898,
-0.0088526905,
-0.0208257586,
0.0630991608,
0.0225575846,
0.0294974539,
-0.0261919983,
0.0022855357,
-0.047995884,
-0.0087605976,
0.0456825867,
0.000236483,
-0.0177174024,
-0.0094572371,
-0.0420893729,
-0.0419249125,
-0.043450769,
0.0218489449,
-0.000730932,
0.0236424506,
0.0480721034,
0.0138014099,
0.0067012589,
0.0173608661,
-0.0538667142,
0.0064528473,
0.0142951664,
-0.0564540885,
-0.0162489489,
-6.24457864e-33,
-0.0073310123,
-0.0281174071,
0.0556143075,
-0.0016340974,
-0.0333304852,
0.0007484207,
-0.0405757688,
-0.0055252151,
0.0336400867,
0.0325735211,
-0.0049172109,
-0.0459803119,
-0.0017680974,
-0.0076105706,
0.0512389913,
-0.0082565825,
0.0585912466,
-0.037259575,
-0.0364754833,
0.0100409705,
0.0122386692,
0.0207486283,
-0.0031088793,
-0.0190601107,
0.0229001977,
0.0307447184,
-0.0272664595,
0.0250139162,
0.0025349513,
0.0333797932,
-0.0059536691,
0.0389209799,
-0.0068945154,
-0.1067318395,
-0.0184511635,
0.0546363927,
-0.0560128242,
-0.0269278903,
-0.0056349905,
-0.0252654441,
-0.0460240655,
-0.0480188839,
0.0128159458,
-0.0031833632,
-0.0157258753,
0.0410655476,
0.0178720448,
-0.0229687653,
0.0102192061,
-0.028475441,
-0.0972882509,
-0.013489089,
-0.0010961939,
-0.0338230953,
0.0461664833,
0.0197969973,
-0.017698545,
0.0167974979,
0.0243197531,
0.0271741264,
0.025890179,
-0.0023923854,
0.0425716713,
0.0371798798,
0.033574041,
0.0357034057,
-0.0207476709,
0.0100180237,
-0.017950207,
0.0403272957,
0.0214167032,
0.0540508442,
0.0045649912,
0.0172362402,
-0.0276511386,
0.0208457839,
-0.0486194901,
0.0067951903,
0.012688431,
0.0804414153,
0.0454238839,
-0.0168471802,
-0.0221400019,
-0.0182347689,
-0.0685341656,
0.0496334881,
-0.0137003688,
-0.0016218432,
0.0327910483,
0.0009146822,
-0.0113803875,
-0.0590790883,
0.0358797386,
-0.0315085314,
0.0110196574,
0.020847667,
-0.0175092239,
0.0259968918,
-0.0099131064,
0.0011144729,
-0.0594531819,
-0.0484027006,
-0.0120418957,
-0.0584814288,
-0.0069653764,
0.03669383,
-0.007109174,
0.0414058417,
-0.0660794079,
0.0116894683,
-0.0236801077,
0.0160169862,
0.0306536704,
0.0126278447,
0.0238225237,
-0.0174306128,
-0.0029980803,
0.0326575115,
-0.0105009032,
-0.0931825638,
0.0199363735,
0.0097219693,
-0.0101106996,
0.0190836173,
-0.0379411541,
0.0174740423,
-0.0567694008,
0.0280040614,
0.0088819703,
-0.042327214,
0.0057314131,
0.0185873993,
3.136e-7,
-0.0356651545,
0.0498218983,
-0.0117477449,
0.0718925074,
0.0524141602,
0.0613996238,
-0.0090237651,
0.0036030223,
0.0042130086,
0.02536227,
0.0406736508,
0.0433906578,
0.0230670813,
-0.0352164209,
-0.0609265715,
-0.0203674175,
-0.0252366979,
0.0094378963,
-0.0849844068,
-0.0215479806,
0.0090332143,
0.059778776,
0.0156519059,
-0.0179669727,
0.0438736081,
0.0055377041,
0.0281397924,
-0.0178161003,
-0.0006908045,
0.0147168795,
0.0003225034,
0.0363680087,
0.0041999798,
0.001034886,
0.017928293,
0.0328890383,
-0.0594011806,
0.065992184,
0.040487919,
0.0137542039,
-0.0089096865,
0.007731854,
-0.0010768097,
-0.0366421826,
0.0384438448,
-0.1020287946,
-0.0154476734,
-0.0601719879,
0.0143269338,
-0.049664475,
-0.0216131601,
-0.0369604416,
0.0171567444,
-0.0079093436,
-0.005796487,
0.0125012388,
0.0116643813,
-0.0355670005,
0.0084889969,
0.0243641566,
-0.0453172997,
-0.0408920795,
-0.0267473944,
0.0370920263,
-0.0022007967,
-0.066686742,
0.0115446914,
2.870227286e-34,
0.0114148669,
-0.0598429628,
0.0073615881,
0.0350902677,
-0.0079477318,
0.0250019748,
-0.0444803834,
0.0313835777,
0.0718235373,
-0.0480980873,
-0.0285053812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07051v1 | $L^*LM$: Learning Automata from Examples using Natural Language Oracles | 2024-02-10T21:46:34 | 2024-02-10T21:46:34 | Marcell Vazquez-Chanlatte, Karim Elmaaroufi, Stefan J. Witwicki, Sanjit A. Seshia | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL | Expert demonstrations have proven an easy way to indirectly specify complex
tasks. Recent algorithms even support extracting unambiguous formal
specifications, e.g. deterministic finite automata (DFA), from demonstrations.
Unfortunately, these techniques are generally not sample efficient. In this
work, we introduce $L^*LM$, an algorithm for learning DFAs from both
demonstrations and natural language. Due to the expressivity of natural
language, we observe a significant improvement in the data efficiency of
learning DFAs from expert demonstrations. Technically, $L^*LM$ leverages large
language models to answer membership queries about the underlying task. This is
then combined with recent techniques for transforming learning from
demonstrations into a sequence of labeled example learning problems. In our
experiments, we observe the two modalities complement each other, yielding a
powerful few-shot learner. | [
0.0383700952,
0.0805898234,
-0.01647182,
0.0424830616,
-0.0459035784,
-0.0169792548,
0.0249278899,
0.009914876,
0.0232682936,
-0.0542597771,
0.0004252526,
-0.0052416972,
-0.0050151097,
0.0119277956,
0.0404503457,
-0.0567548051,
0.0303959493,
-0.0648937672,
-0.00429634,
0.0047404296,
-0.016691586,
-0.0224105492,
-0.0358747952,
0.012709097,
-0.0200788844,
0.033961989,
-0.0682225898,
-0.0347897746,
0.0035166726,
-0.0091105262,
-0.0345422439,
0.0359273218,
0.0599206984,
-0.0054327664,
0.0000020146,
-0.0413621962,
-0.0168861412,
0.0219205786,
-0.0359920412,
-0.0008534042,
0.003910732,
0.0211815778,
0.0148151824,
0.0400986411,
-0.0212945808,
-0.0440865383,
0.0252943896,
0.0064555053,
0.0695273727,
0.0970982909,
0.0095851589,
-0.0140706934,
-0.0036818872,
-0.0268935189,
0.0162813123,
-0.0473549031,
0.0495633222,
-0.0230629779,
0.0551773421,
-0.0534949861,
-0.0257662348,
-0.0138811581,
-0.0030735307,
0.012429798,
-0.0430170409,
0.0295406953,
-0.0269188583,
-0.0082143191,
-0.0289339609,
0.051234711,
-0.0125818448,
-0.0085349185,
0.0001014919,
-0.0001524096,
-0.0018387564,
0.014434265,
-0.0092463568,
0.0276939962,
0.002263875,
0.0041157017,
0.0140740499,
0.0140258437,
-0.0097473562,
-0.011040261,
-0.0306880828,
0.0873783603,
-0.0148551213,
-0.0126243252,
0.0210699365,
-0.0298611447,
0.0112653393,
-0.0554485284,
-0.032606177,
0.0467587933,
-0.0356707759,
0.039676968,
-0.0150206257,
-0.0360024348,
0.0250574704,
0.0105006285,
0.0808978677,
0.0460498072,
0.0097976057,
0.0297685284,
-0.0295503512,
0.0514712445,
0.0497374944,
0.0566855371,
-0.0244164541,
0.0379383899,
-0.0537102185,
0.0153501425,
-0.0729921535,
0.0499382541,
0.0020965568,
0.0083957408,
-0.0099926945,
0.0193599164,
-0.0370197073,
0.0536476225,
-0.0471619554,
-0.0216835998,
-0.0256523248,
0.0151890684,
-0.0462986082,
-0.0357334726,
-0.0532216541,
0.0235966388,
0.0034326713,
-0.0500260442,
-0.0257012844,
-0.0240612049,
0.0215474367,
0.0198725984,
0.0101041077,
0.1147638261,
-0.0069874106,
-0.0693693161,
-0.0401816703,
0.0075996127,
0.0288538039,
-0.0805568025,
-0.0095275184,
-0.0600513369,
0.0442944653,
-0.009126896,
0.00825164,
-0.0339385681,
0.0327881575,
0.0234423112,
0.0026941455,
0.090571478,
-0.0328614898,
0.0123736486,
0.0121438131,
-0.0149449566,
-0.0368243791,
0.0385103412,
0.0316396281,
0.0102805365,
-0.0092956256,
0.0357829891,
0.073409237,
0.0350452773,
0.0095593827,
0.0054447516,
-0.0313198231,
0.0094650984,
-0.0026899439,
0.0393669195,
0.0234134533,
0.0776479021,
-0.0114440518,
0.0197201855,
0.0096940501,
0.0448165387,
-0.0255820788,
-0.0397731215,
0.0436660275,
0.04701785,
0.0558710881,
0.0083214445,
-0.0397823825,
-0.0108157303,
-0.0162282102,
0.0248146597,
-0.0015270041,
-0.012481112,
-0.049898196,
-0.0572609194,
-0.001024616,
-0.0276674721,
0.0182275251,
-0.0002313116,
0.0402746499,
0.0396000706,
-0.0486826375,
-0.0329411589,
0.0426852778,
-0.0221307576,
-0.0119063882,
-0.0472310781,
0.0343009345,
0.0380141549,
0.0224143565,
-0.0840746611,
-0.0090877991,
-0.0184599031,
0.0124426782,
0.0122475391,
0.0266717691,
-0.0495116189,
-0.0117611224,
-0.0134742996,
0.0053253034,
-0.0296364315,
0.0574514791,
0.0210232548,
0.0040085567,
-0.0256904364,
-0.0057657976,
-0.0419347174,
-0.0494943336,
0.0650325343,
-0.0315920785,
-0.0685678348,
0.0281535257,
0.0339028575,
0.0376540571,
-0.0329210572,
-0.0257366672,
0.0028810166,
0.0165865924,
-0.0107700545,
0.0126976399,
-0.008309924,
0.0138724316,
-0.0562500842,
0.0202986766,
-0.0205838699,
-0.0307968371,
0.0470296592,
-0.0580858178,
-0.0259569809,
-0.0222371668,
-0.0248194281,
0.0134347994,
-0.0096717235,
-0.0144150062,
0.0416443907,
-0.0490966365,
-0.002372294,
0.0790578723,
0.0035423948,
-0.0003441523,
0.0224509463,
-0.0170284268,
0.0190852452,
-0.0419616438,
-0.0272436608,
-0.0321272723,
-0.0257644057,
0.0510241762,
0.0208786428,
0.0083038732,
-0.0533198416,
0.0137466928,
-0.0238897093,
0.0117193898,
-0.0291638412,
0.028519107,
-0.0354701057,
-0.0282354224,
-0.0246831626,
-0.0191166699,
-0.0576759428,
-0.0313032977,
-0.0169423576,
-0.0386889577,
0.0656180531,
0.0904144421,
-0.0824140236,
-0.0582846478,
0.013319972,
-0.0273615625,
0.0363853015,
-0.0074406075,
0.004018785,
0.0068460885,
0.0258567054,
0.0428379886,
0.0637583956,
-0.0287451781,
0.0089781787,
0.0345303528,
0.0038339386,
0.002519621,
0.0603651814,
0.0268942099,
0.0151330242,
0.0719142854,
0.0209590793,
-0.0360066071,
0.0293635279,
-0.0173191372,
-0.0079712076,
-0.028473556,
-0.009676788,
0.030870894,
0.0337034203,
-0.0052818498,
-0.0249061566,
-0.0331206135,
0.0215069018,
0.0239252746,
-0.0192880519,
-0.0267130025,
-0.0180419683,
-0.0297479481,
0.021532353,
-0.0041710348,
-0.0153839989,
0.0772984773,
-0.0295272321,
0.0163168274,
0.0074084997,
-0.0059193396,
-0.0047005406,
0.0705560297,
0.0146699864,
0.0490570255,
0.0070207366,
-0.031001104,
-0.0147845894,
0.0110210991,
-0.0004128516,
-0.0134676257,
0.0230117049,
-0.0453549176,
0.0225061998,
0.0180079062,
-0.0543924607,
-0.0715261921,
0.0100316703,
-0.0442954898,
0.0281998273,
-0.0507431515,
0.0098618064,
-0.0452110097,
-0.0240291022,
0.0058087441,
0.034915287,
0.0020449711,
0.0070795636,
-0.0375129431,
-0.0240344126,
-0.0119267525,
-0.0016082404,
-0.0526452512,
-0.0540321507,
-0.0110375024,
-0.0106050037,
0.0719473809,
0.0294083469,
-0.0410084724,
-0.0256371889,
-0.007902679,
-0.1046863422,
0.0262834989,
0.0736682117,
-0.0200946629,
-0.0435319133,
-0.016006548,
0.0717255175,
0.0420579165,
0.011948958,
0.0494159237,
0.0410108157,
-0.0406743139,
0.0272845551,
0.0681267157,
-0.115824841,
-0.0357923992,
-0.0007469801,
0.044527784,
-0.0207324848,
-0.0230552498,
-0.0172044206,
-0.1409147531,
0.0234059487,
-0.0052563236,
-0.0541472472,
-0.0242435411,
-0.0463710278,
0.0274142306,
-0.0310248807,
-0.0090351226,
0.0118595399,
-0.0128130745,
0.0051929909,
0.0410602279,
-0.011848988,
-0.0924010947,
0.0135681024,
-0.020575922,
0.0419874378,
0.0071394234,
0.0291161761,
-0.0156831052,
-0.0385374278,
0.0025143051,
0.0417893827,
0.0135606928,
0.0117293987,
0.0543402359,
-0.0141994748,
0.004168896,
0.0505810902,
0.0770788863,
-0.0225120857,
-0.0093207229,
-0.0124995364,
0.0307289474,
0.0041022133,
-0.0087041818,
-0.0100700362,
-0.0502312034,
0.0581256747,
0.0221608467,
0.0212881304,
-0.0137589062,
-0.0161174182,
-0.0390071273,
-0.0129506923,
-0.0169582088,
-0.0485474057,
-0.0198440738,
-0.005163644,
-0.0257347692,
-0.0320310928,
-0.0133931516,
0.0540834777,
0.0712028295,
0.0011917033,
-0.0211534258,
0.0108300494,
0.0291185472,
-0.0189000182,
-0.0032369825,
-0.0537062697,
0.0109787695,
-0.024453748,
-0.0735170022,
0.0316674225,
-0.0041831965,
-0.0572945997,
0.0112678679,
-0.0646152049,
-0.0460489355,
0.0168845002,
0.0763217583,
0.022735374,
0.0250398368,
0.0013509745,
0.0087348111,
0.0347098969,
0.075525023,
-0.0065213516,
-0.0266269892,
0.0236581769,
-0.0259238146,
-0.008028198,
0.0120945126,
-0.0161041375,
0.0037530614,
-0.0213982817,
0.0180781111,
-0.04412435,
-0.0125563266,
0.0730146468,
0.0577399023,
0.0428393073,
0.0035555086,
-0.0099835349,
-0.0338868983,
0.0250715595,
-0.0119602745,
-0.04543598,
-0.0406839587,
-0.0125662219,
-0.0295483172,
0.0157115497,
0.0075932778,
-0.0723881349,
-0.0134720355,
0.0580722503,
0.0183988158,
-0.0096201878,
0.094147943,
0.0090839854,
0.0038620445,
-0.0239195116,
0.0141156288,
0.0047339206,
0.0290299524,
0.051144857,
0.0123995002,
-0.0057240236,
0.0398435406,
0.0435163938,
-0.0368708484,
-0.0281567127,
-0.0051119947,
-0.0617979206,
-0.0421290435,
0.0454925299,
0.0501220152,
-0.0239317156,
-0.04416316,
-0.0867211893,
0.0325684212,
-0.0085798362,
0.0047028125,
-0.0252306368,
-0.0698210225,
0.0436626375,
0.0494255088,
0.0254382435,
-0.0091124158,
0.082453303,
0.0056775231,
0.0731092319,
-0.0044281357,
0.0148307309,
-0.0714692026,
-0.019994732,
0.0662173033,
0.010261612,
-0.0184804332,
-0.0204089433,
-0.0550964847,
-0.0236304235,
-0.0050216177,
0.0131808072,
0.0127309551,
-0.0158775821,
0.0520689972,
0.0317696556,
0.0225932691,
0.0042576296,
-0.0460367054,
-0.0744547099,
0.0420033708,
-0.0375660807,
0.0061333957,
-5.977613587e-33,
-0.0298092999,
-0.0237244423,
0.0418253802,
-0.005975984,
0.038689062,
-0.0039756917,
-0.0308282785,
0.0180825926,
0.0191808268,
0.0234723315,
-0.0345357768,
-0.0344934054,
0.0061393217,
-0.0152532738,
0.006756281,
-0.0107617537,
0.0310429968,
-0.0274934787,
-0.054751426,
-0.0080592064,
0.0027611682,
-0.0061389883,
0.0104441745,
-0.0558240972,
0.0264760796,
0.0077817529,
-0.066912882,
0.0136238793,
-0.0227041561,
0.013047778,
-0.0071199466,
0.0356701389,
-0.003373231,
-0.0048145154,
-0.000152786,
0.0019095298,
-0.0251768157,
-0.0191363581,
-0.0086991983,
0.0249579921,
-0.0582287088,
0.0117412833,
0.0295761097,
-0.024938371,
-0.012015448,
0.0749395788,
0.0273194406,
-0.0441239849,
0.0267566275,
-0.0233533252,
-0.0464931428,
-0.0004952686,
0.0008329879,
-0.0505392775,
0.0202215947,
-0.0009383373,
0.0185704622,
-0.0645071045,
0.0155046554,
0.0312406588,
0.103950955,
0.0102521693,
0.0314171389,
-0.025568625,
-0.0053304797,
0.0565978773,
-0.0019603604,
0.0155920442,
0.0444363542,
0.0225564092,
0.0212296452,
0.0680588186,
-0.0407658294,
0.0156290345,
0.0366289131,
-0.0081304256,
-0.051762782,
0.0333403237,
0.02608197,
0.0295803118,
0.0146881584,
-0.0095699988,
-0.0449518524,
0.0030731417,
-0.0693606958,
0.0576562583,
0.0152768958,
-0.0012184312,
0.0131504489,
0.0337235443,
-0.0372788683,
-0.0348703638,
-0.0019725584,
-0.0315831751,
-0.038725663,
0.0193883739,
-0.0206712876,
0.0134967947,
-0.0330847204,
-0.0065394263,
-0.0765767172,
-0.0702299997,
-0.008413313,
-0.0448595993,
0.016208861,
0.0141542731,
0.0137320831,
0.0810560733,
-0.0977063477,
0.0365837105,
-0.0236947872,
0.0284875762,
0.0168997701,
-0.0000079002,
0.0410223082,
-0.0039925533,
0.0009347519,
0.0106213083,
-0.0111548482,
-0.0762655884,
0.0013285576,
0.069497928,
-0.0511217602,
-0.0038653384,
-0.0334636122,
-0.0351219587,
-0.0193064976,
0.0032841607,
-0.0090393536,
-0.0216914006,
0.022820035,
-0.0085134543,
2.708e-7,
-0.0131271863,
0.0390102118,
0.0169590041,
0.0924424902,
0.00227334,
0.0352993943,
-0.0548678786,
0.0417704917,
-0.0153155662,
-0.0065907305,
0.0298502669,
0.042297449,
-0.0247203428,
0.0291784927,
-0.0954696983,
0.0017573668,
0.0306422282,
0.0008728378,
-0.050862696,
-0.0317442641,
0.0182974264,
0.0770869181,
0.0079898788,
0.009238827,
-0.0075706947,
-0.0679040551,
0.0406483598,
0.0302150249,
-0.0060678171,
0.0629478619,
0.0384252332,
0.0382363833,
-0.0010223252,
0.0186969098,
0.0089287432,
0.0300812945,
-0.0367824174,
0.0605003573,
0.0015514895,
0.0230885334,
0.0243651941,
0.0140545685,
0.0052717216,
0.0399788693,
0.0244952347,
-0.0327331759,
0.0019550347,
-0.0308646727,
-0.0256836582,
-0.025429152,
-0.0430201963,
0.018040482,
0.0104221143,
0.0103041651,
-0.0080026798,
-0.0282328092,
0.0181708839,
-0.0286828112,
-0.0040656757,
-0.0132500865,
-0.0153054455,
0.0042049619,
0.0149941677,
0.0297653396,
-0.0292444266,
-0.0608486645,
0.0095443167,
2.244668911e-34,
0.0227505323,
0.0022193424,
-0.0126915742,
0.0737667009,
0.0028361238,
0.005822524,
-0.0444349162,
0.0245337542,
0.0318737775,
0.0001851765,
-0.0074604773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07043v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07043v2 | A Tale of Tails: Model Collapse as a Change of Scaling Laws | 2024-02-10T21:06:34 | 2024-05-31T12:27:52 | Elvis Dohmatob, Yunzhen Feng, Pu Yang, Francois Charton, Julia Kempe | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | As AI model size grows, neural scaling laws have become a crucial tool to
predict the improvements of large models when increasing capacity and the size
of original (human or natural) training data. Yet, the widespread use of
popular models means that the ecosystem of online data and text will co-evolve
to progressively contain increased amounts of synthesized data. In this paper
we ask: How will the scaling laws change in the inevitable regime where
synthetic data makes its way into the training corpus? Will future models,
still improve, or be doomed to degenerate up to total (model) collapse? We
develop a theoretical framework of model collapse through the lens of scaling
laws. We discover a wide range of decay phenomena, analyzing loss of scaling,
shifted scaling with number of generations, the ''un-learning" of skills, and
grokking when mixing human and synthesized data. Our theory is validated by
large-scale experiments with a transformer on an arithmetic task and text
generation using the large language model Llama2. | [
-0.0265553705,
0.0779068694,
-0.0271746032,
-0.029596759,
0.0137607493,
-0.0065658218,
0.004036352,
0.0513606742,
-0.0309453309,
0.008422656,
-0.0152218221,
-0.0392775759,
0.0052839909,
0.0629532859,
0.0345817804,
-0.0298632737,
0.0250021014,
-0.0682659894,
-0.0564121008,
-0.0188552402,
-0.0400881916,
-0.0385481678,
0.045835223,
0.0138598047,
-0.0075784456,
0.0025262316,
0.0056496779,
-0.0245045796,
-0.0255483314,
0.0155751454,
-0.0282461029,
0.0144381383,
0.0144531587,
0.0478352793,
0.000001906,
-0.0453759991,
0.0349624306,
0.0056042778,
-0.0583339706,
0.0085351681,
0.0194805376,
-0.029320443,
-0.0443387181,
0.0387196168,
-0.0240842383,
-0.0284148771,
0.0329233482,
0.0309216976,
0.0197935347,
0.0511528365,
0.007318805,
-0.0560345054,
0.0933523923,
-0.0546985902,
-0.0194097701,
-0.0033819531,
0.0296325702,
0.0277665928,
-0.0279006287,
0.0332280323,
-0.0099362722,
0.0242424328,
0.0421578549,
-0.0180256087,
0.0215601996,
0.0618986711,
0.0140764592,
-0.0251271445,
0.023162853,
0.0401210524,
-0.0409577638,
-0.0377702937,
0.0028082256,
-0.0074550225,
0.0368474759,
-0.0063693533,
-0.0539687462,
0.040966399,
0.0052927523,
0.0287328362,
0.0037548114,
-0.0230343603,
0.0418441668,
-0.0065704277,
-0.0173662305,
-0.0010917395,
-0.0141749168,
-0.0307204854,
-0.0476228707,
-0.0127486102,
-0.0435600989,
-0.0165000856,
-0.0067963148,
0.0270335153,
-0.0097904038,
0.0139924772,
-0.0613394007,
-0.0156048536,
-0.003546281,
-0.0493574515,
0.0618811436,
0.0038207236,
0.0270923525,
0.0252439063,
-0.0035303475,
0.045975782,
-0.037774872,
-0.0099435141,
-0.0542565025,
0.0290518869,
-0.035843946,
-0.019186534,
-0.0252993498,
0.0326035284,
-0.0079061696,
-0.0121096708,
-0.0125518637,
0.0029557266,
0.0025462885,
-0.0056322063,
0.0074649565,
0.0226503573,
-0.0579773448,
0.0206390638,
-0.0462269336,
0.0389919281,
-0.0434459299,
0.0126198819,
0.043128375,
-0.0491217896,
-0.018591715,
-0.0023913339,
-0.001707476,
0.0161205195,
0.0257409494,
0.0667943433,
0.0049662045,
0.0069798417,
-0.0638307333,
-0.0309626721,
-0.0195507519,
-0.0392749496,
0.0020365438,
-0.0335828103,
0.0228852928,
-0.0256745592,
-0.033034984,
-0.031000236,
-0.0184696987,
0.0249904711,
-0.0442793705,
0.0353551246,
-0.0273429304,
0.0311531257,
0.0423275195,
-0.0124876155,
0.0261050165,
0.0438329466,
0.0438630991,
-0.0053066532,
0.0232693795,
-0.0251555201,
0.0385717228,
0.0389676914,
0.0345226489,
0.0209756624,
-0.0241403915,
-0.0177770611,
0.0058725975,
0.0401098952,
0.0298645813,
0.079574354,
-0.0464647301,
-0.0201133303,
0.0777452067,
0.0540533066,
0.0011078856,
0.084177278,
0.0196641237,
-0.0139594367,
0.0145149585,
0.0485281087,
-0.0638127774,
-0.0043680756,
0.0036015634,
-0.0019676909,
-0.0022390436,
0.0405764654,
-0.0631278008,
-0.0919448212,
-0.0070676683,
-0.0137957688,
-0.0291424207,
-0.048100885,
0.0422027335,
0.0454670899,
0.0099768601,
0.0224998277,
-0.0076461318,
-0.0476080216,
0.0211994089,
-0.0610104725,
-0.008117076,
0.0101673715,
0.0475020409,
-0.0069143693,
-0.0018435324,
-0.0036835889,
-0.0327173546,
0.0031378549,
0.0107962657,
-0.0172826778,
-0.0171111505,
-0.028712377,
0.0130514437,
0.0191140678,
-0.0047022644,
-0.0503955781,
0.0024293296,
-0.0098390235,
-0.0064094961,
-0.0402185209,
-0.0515573248,
0.0351759195,
-0.0698766559,
-0.0387594625,
-0.0213488713,
-0.034153495,
0.010749747,
-0.0094765965,
-0.0320084654,
0.0260629151,
0.035058517,
-0.0132611748,
-0.0484066457,
0.0324966572,
-0.056989003,
0.0118992301,
0.0238531325,
-0.0317781195,
0.0511963069,
0.0148703745,
-0.0169154853,
-0.0357822143,
0.0516348034,
-0.0409145541,
0.0272424743,
-0.0093735065,
0.0520241112,
-0.0346807763,
0.0466124713,
-0.0187823828,
0.0495007709,
-0.0472539142,
-0.0181410443,
-0.0121979332,
0.0188929662,
0.0123302815,
-0.0152742872,
-0.0036731358,
0.026249418,
-0.0122870915,
0.0297831409,
0.0058033643,
-0.0456353873,
-0.0119782947,
-0.0156123266,
0.0110365869,
-0.0125292409,
-0.0032592171,
0.0522148162,
0.0295098498,
-0.0179177094,
-0.0126114581,
-0.0002678004,
0.0105958208,
0.0022075179,
0.0336118713,
0.0365803726,
0.055994112,
-0.0146886222,
0.016973136,
-0.0224813689,
-0.0343394093,
-0.0002767671,
0.0521218255,
0.0289159082,
0.0226993579,
-0.0796202868,
0.073859565,
-0.0156244421,
0.0458711013,
-0.0240471121,
-0.0281660631,
0.0124205993,
-0.0101659242,
0.0681112334,
0.0819228813,
0.0062964777,
0.0741681904,
0.0733120367,
0.0645963475,
-0.020912502,
-0.0289272368,
0.0016962133,
-0.0442141928,
-0.0242816154,
-0.0242345501,
0.0074046487,
0.0738651007,
-0.0233887136,
-0.0215200949,
-0.0463232547,
0.0335535482,
-0.0187602155,
-0.0303299427,
0.0334531777,
-0.0185919795,
-0.0307559744,
0.030672472,
-0.0127453618,
-0.0625554025,
0.0283608325,
0.0008480112,
0.0165045038,
-0.0291057676,
-0.0178362112,
-0.0132414373,
0.0438212194,
0.0309241135,
-0.0129897511,
0.0632750839,
0.012680375,
-0.0810281336,
0.0084956344,
0.0158951469,
-0.0181199703,
0.017727267,
-0.0628605783,
0.0116453972,
-0.0157813709,
-0.0607182942,
-0.0125818048,
0.0034434479,
0.0298759975,
-0.0003499759,
0.0479275249,
-0.0516849607,
0.0036905303,
-0.0380119346,
0.0167594384,
0.0485873856,
-0.0001707707,
-0.0413462706,
0.0081018554,
0.0660454482,
0.037749961,
0.0236619487,
0.0396806523,
-0.0786722004,
0.0441410355,
0.0412199832,
0.0352795422,
0.0327724218,
-0.0618390329,
-0.0220883749,
0.0006598881,
-0.004402312,
-0.053680338,
0.0410591774,
0.01544342,
-0.0283740237,
-0.0123117594,
0.0555871017,
-0.0184341632,
-0.0068531139,
0.0448521003,
-0.0056464602,
0.0390512198,
0.0307363179,
0.0365935527,
-0.04520097,
0.0386718735,
-0.0081513301,
0.0232517999,
-0.0005283882,
-0.053580042,
0.0257936865,
-0.1224686876,
0.040698573,
0.0059741763,
-0.0039897049,
0.0156124551,
-0.0419914797,
-0.0290966704,
-0.0213032402,
0.0022504216,
-0.0085540386,
-0.0541841947,
0.0240822807,
0.0235529374,
0.036333859,
-0.0448727496,
-0.0024448193,
-0.0370413922,
0.0668603405,
0.0383659601,
0.025655074,
-0.0224034861,
-0.0429518223,
0.0733419433,
0.0398971587,
0.026474284,
0.0290966388,
0.0711160898,
0.0656293035,
0.0032744633,
-0.0279952567,
0.0290440358,
0.0035214932,
0.0112083592,
-0.0055592498,
0.0419113114,
0.0239616502,
-0.0947910026,
-0.0190456174,
-0.0382139869,
-0.0486372039,
0.0377898142,
0.0403892361,
-0.0282491408,
-0.062172778,
-0.0096921343,
0.0206791144,
-0.0034437438,
-0.0620690472,
0.0426961742,
0.0409100652,
-0.0417162329,
-0.0907287598,
-0.0004386514,
-0.0502982847,
0.0723209903,
-0.0066559506,
-0.0379050896,
0.0200648401,
-0.0051521407,
0.0005707601,
0.0196021777,
-0.024956625,
-0.0185817443,
-0.0582604818,
0.0451083183,
0.033776734,
-0.0361837111,
-0.0097508989,
-0.0453275628,
-0.1100275517,
-0.0580932312,
0.0118569843,
0.0331327058,
0.0326486677,
0.0441749729,
0.0316276625,
-0.0799504817,
0.0619794168,
0.0625455976,
-0.0241224263,
0.0444816947,
0.0231057275,
-0.0226936378,
-0.0033302521,
0.032976266,
0.0119580179,
0.0134269856,
-0.013398068,
-0.0152104134,
-0.0457898863,
0.0127556603,
0.0056453645,
0.027281357,
-0.0140667502,
-0.0212078281,
0.0094870757,
0.0032060666,
-0.0051141423,
0.0356807709,
0.0215941295,
-0.0206345432,
0.0032313799,
0.0245722067,
0.0268294476,
0.0227055568,
0.0230705719,
0.0335610099,
0.0109986905,
-0.0296917018,
-0.0280687958,
-0.0105115203,
0.0654479936,
0.061741367,
0.0200367663,
0.0038454905,
0.0347719267,
-0.028378563,
0.0548967347,
0.0175606385,
0.0273903757,
-0.0052719875,
0.0355469771,
-0.0096399346,
0.0354922451,
-0.086413987,
-0.0881979465,
-0.0508159325,
0.0109894592,
0.0012292061,
0.00851708,
0.0174565893,
-0.0016227483,
0.0102470797,
-0.0115493005,
-0.0115788523,
-0.0162995625,
-0.0242746025,
-0.0151859447,
0.0041922079,
-0.0171642751,
0.0231741071,
0.0935466439,
0.0066833766,
0.0630931258,
-0.0236634016,
0.0535108857,
-0.0001761015,
-0.0403659083,
-0.0410570614,
-0.0329165682,
0.0235939939,
-0.0402471721,
-0.0372959673,
-0.0926662162,
-0.0404955707,
0.0516169406,
0.0206998289,
-0.0245391149,
0.0214939192,
0.0196234677,
-0.0286926385,
0.0304887984,
-0.0153836031,
0.0219395328,
0.0158600863,
0.0191517007,
0.0190865342,
-5.996014849e-33,
0.009399239,
0.0075803217,
0.0088384636,
0.0071868389,
-0.0276153646,
0.001886341,
-0.0120581482,
-0.0071291681,
-0.0416234024,
-0.0065076547,
-0.0407060571,
0.0234251097,
-0.006856421,
0.026177913,
0.0353657305,
-0.0338175222,
0.0675410852,
-0.0526215024,
-0.0095203845,
0.0583999455,
0.0127847362,
-0.0056020771,
0.0335134454,
-0.0616738424,
0.0050594648,
0.0060268221,
-0.0064349538,
0.036238458,
0.0051676086,
0.0446804203,
-0.0293731447,
0.0643211752,
0.017814897,
-0.0874827877,
-0.0216623936,
-0.0377223492,
-0.0651110187,
-0.0091943052,
-0.0468154959,
-0.0248479415,
-0.0259439889,
-0.0301595852,
0.0920935273,
0.0012836544,
-0.0377610773,
-0.0047450885,
0.029386146,
-0.0318072028,
-0.017522905,
-0.0166083295,
-0.0191820934,
0.004084765,
-0.0068733837,
0.0099432608,
-0.0410438366,
0.0206589233,
-0.0023985547,
-0.0141127892,
-0.0474925824,
0.0269781575,
0.0463159084,
0.0239280295,
0.0385606587,
0.0251733251,
0.0010354761,
0.0460624546,
0.0546155497,
0.0565432161,
-0.0434784219,
-0.0577291027,
0.0189898461,
0.0408194177,
0.0257744938,
0.0212215595,
0.0531059168,
-0.0234454498,
-0.0334404856,
0.0390326492,
0.0352168642,
0.0292720627,
-0.0401291437,
0.0163278598,
-0.036196854,
-0.0453760847,
-0.0337342471,
-0.0633125454,
-0.0187119655,
0.0091941049,
-0.0047491849,
0.0224137735,
0.0097266883,
-0.0156063372,
-0.0032478999,
-0.058572568,
-0.0077962158,
-0.0071658781,
-0.0031565395,
0.0308832731,
0.0084415134,
0.0020627016,
-0.0465576835,
-0.0503881499,
-0.0322614573,
0.0587282516,
0.0400547758,
0.0382024646,
-0.0173839126,
0.0350931846,
-0.0384016633,
-0.0039012111,
-0.0306230634,
-0.0367738344,
0.0870825946,
-0.0066525694,
0.0337929018,
-0.0200243182,
0.0023517525,
0.0222786237,
0.0354677178,
0.0343222618,
-0.0283579379,
0.0495509692,
0.0258467291,
0.0170947351,
-0.0064492691,
-0.0222104136,
-0.0747682601,
0.0570285693,
0.0813269243,
-0.0934512466,
-0.0461484306,
0.0047875363,
2.669e-7,
0.0057305326,
0.0283222906,
0.036703568,
-0.0324716866,
0.0235468782,
0.0444165766,
0.027247889,
0.0434128828,
-0.0199073739,
0.0403025635,
0.0020285447,
0.0031179716,
0.0210219119,
0.0306027364,
-0.0491618626,
-0.0279087685,
-0.1083565056,
0.009448763,
-0.0357365869,
-0.0139390305,
-0.0500696935,
0.0699714869,
0.0088130292,
-0.0475261696,
0.0278638564,
-0.0496065058,
0.0413470529,
-0.002087119,
0.0605149344,
0.0142000634,
-0.0256948862,
0.0375151634,
-0.0376783758,
-0.0047400519,
-0.0099397227,
0.0189534705,
-0.0154595859,
0.0337873846,
0.0034640483,
0.0675932243,
0.0163475163,
-0.0359128602,
-0.016116444,
-0.0428611748,
0.0725484565,
-0.048362311,
-0.0081410389,
-0.0340081938,
-0.0011549045,
-0.0252543017,
0.0173747018,
-0.0297258869,
0.0187330265,
0.0376589969,
-0.0286616515,
0.0216178205,
-0.0012906853,
-0.0506393053,
-0.0146975042,
0.0183159877,
-0.0619743355,
-0.0607252382,
-0.062768586,
-0.0181027632,
0.0400327183,
-0.03844418,
0.0144550577,
2.371626204e-34,
0.0267924629,
-0.0230831392,
0.0550771952,
-0.0163989924,
-0.0034509406,
-0.0183054172,
0.0305903573,
0.0003855264,
0.024888549,
-0.0673321038,
-0.0318189263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07028v1 | Semi-Supervised Learning for Bilingual Lexicon Induction | 2024-02-10T19:27:22 | 2024-02-10T19:27:22 | Paul Garnier, Gauthier Guinet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We consider the problem of aligning two sets of continuous word
representations, corresponding to languages, to a common space in order to
infer a bilingual lexicon. It was recently shown that it is possible to infer
such lexicon, without using any parallel data, by aligning word embeddings
trained on monolingual data. Such line of work is called unsupervised bilingual
induction. By wondering whether it was possible to gain experience in the
progressive learning of several languages, we asked ourselves to what extent we
could integrate the knowledge of a given set of languages when learning a new
one, without having parallel data for the latter. In other words, while keeping
the core problem of unsupervised learning in the latest step, we allowed the
access to other corpora of idioms, hence the name semi-supervised. This led us
to propose a novel formulation, considering the lexicon induction as a ranking
problem for which we used recent tools of this machine learning field. Our
experiments on standard benchmarks, inferring dictionary from English to more
than 20 languages, show that our approach consistently outperforms existing
state of the art benchmark. In addition, we deduce from this new scenario
several relevant conclusions allowing a better understanding of the alignment
phenomenon. | [
-0.0113849808,
0.0458519459,
0.0058554085,
0.0807012916,
-0.0390047096,
0.0436245501,
-0.0137924757,
-0.0390361473,
0.0503251553,
-0.0127879055,
-0.0355147235,
-0.0253805723,
0.0094334306,
-0.0245469883,
0.0230583753,
-0.003895446,
0.0470860936,
0.0194131583,
-0.0598717742,
-0.034108039,
-0.0118928822,
0.0095682126,
-0.0331760496,
-0.0260927398,
-0.0058038258,
-0.0102833165,
0.0180633906,
-0.0361962542,
0.0147331255,
0.0447678901,
-0.0269184615,
0.0277306642,
0.0211377516,
0.072424002,
0.0000016618,
-0.0656875372,
-0.0281524397,
-0.0168876704,
0.0236291233,
-0.0515730642,
-0.0181344394,
-0.0532549098,
-0.0203823913,
-0.0385028608,
-0.0450049564,
-0.0221747216,
0.0774652883,
-0.0093407463,
0.0165333077,
0.0168635696,
-0.0044015129,
-0.052322194,
0.0109690446,
-0.0238898285,
-0.0256237835,
-0.0305962507,
-0.0163349938,
0.0133947749,
-0.0340323746,
-0.0164913442,
-0.055411797,
0.0400578044,
0.0064054299,
0.0232287161,
0.0092824334,
0.0303242151,
-0.0720857158,
-0.0229148008,
0.0042317356,
0.050511986,
-0.0592817329,
-0.0245923121,
-0.0177644454,
0.026095992,
-0.025315281,
0.0172209013,
-0.0102129085,
0.0049300613,
-0.0133819683,
0.0464290455,
0.0663918182,
-0.0181854013,
0.0534216389,
-0.0218048804,
-0.0723211989,
0.0839721933,
0.042798467,
-0.0484587066,
0.0318722241,
0.0389224887,
0.0326480009,
0.0088757211,
-0.0232519452,
-0.0155564174,
0.0043315315,
0.0349198654,
0.0058029159,
-0.0229451749,
-0.0083309654,
-0.0782884508,
-0.0214949287,
0.022778403,
-0.0380003192,
0.0785853192,
-0.0672060996,
0.0101781404,
-0.0075453543,
0.0338711701,
-0.0605688244,
-0.0319044031,
-0.0337379724,
-0.0055954629,
0.0334704556,
-0.0002819179,
0.0387718044,
0.0099352058,
-0.0508913323,
0.0165438987,
-0.0063916324,
0.0452035554,
-0.0183538273,
-0.0425359979,
-0.0423520617,
0.0192529541,
0.006563433,
0.0155815231,
-0.0171466414,
-0.0040198988,
-0.0761860386,
-0.0070267487,
-0.0225869603,
0.0211802609,
-0.0119232889,
-0.0530107915,
0.0019720488,
0.055973094,
-0.0314637534,
-0.0351691917,
-0.0201288797,
0.0171216186,
-0.0160313789,
-0.0321538709,
-0.0005726343,
-0.0720946118,
0.0789302588,
0.0135973468,
0.0440044887,
-0.0199606698,
0.0096574379,
-0.0082922336,
-0.0629953519,
0.0837193355,
-0.0279663596,
0.0029126958,
0.0201081485,
-0.0359403118,
0.0499900728,
0.1017431989,
-0.0201847404,
-0.0468209684,
0.064561151,
-0.0359676406,
-0.0773765519,
0.0308571104,
0.0403063037,
0.0272503123,
-0.0456548855,
-0.0210663304,
0.0807404071,
0.0427873284,
0.0066390843,
0.0153499134,
-0.0057841842,
-0.0224640835,
0.0101361405,
0.0143890418,
-0.0051456247,
0.022910051,
0.0465211608,
-0.0341195427,
-0.0041891439,
0.0790838301,
-0.006006931,
-0.0076023513,
-0.0409270786,
0.0178754348,
0.0677008256,
0.0435210988,
-0.0252051074,
-0.0052547669,
-0.0251758806,
-0.0432461835,
0.0423269048,
-0.0158467628,
0.0799173266,
0.0332106948,
0.0300496668,
0.0252669919,
0.0563542992,
-0.0423271358,
0.0128569109,
0.0381183289,
-0.0155489147,
0.031399861,
-0.0041267104,
-0.0144522982,
-0.0274739768,
0.0048119174,
0.0287401527,
0.0160392281,
0.0436123796,
-0.0384166054,
0.0426063947,
-0.0521982573,
-0.0122115631,
0.0146907652,
-0.0411512293,
0.0077505722,
0.0049648038,
0.0196044296,
0.0025119681,
-0.0508667678,
-0.0411252901,
0.0352361798,
-0.0582272708,
-0.0238172878,
0.0264513623,
0.0604786985,
0.0176763218,
0.0245042592,
-0.0137596689,
-0.0314512476,
0.0302199684,
-0.0489885248,
-0.005823879,
0.063572824,
-0.0054643685,
-0.0704635978,
0.0709746704,
-0.0404400341,
-0.0260016974,
-0.0296909772,
-0.0519125164,
-0.0371284187,
-0.0054929093,
0.013056837,
0.0640587434,
-0.0431494303,
0.0095851813,
0.0201876629,
0.0202833675,
-0.0248002559,
0.0897611156,
-0.0109856771,
0.0932906866,
-0.0230771806,
-0.0291628893,
0.0499201976,
-0.0140907457,
-0.0269950032,
0.026183065,
0.0016820309,
-0.0113947121,
0.0252161492,
0.0152993379,
-0.0151994461,
-0.0053959256,
-0.0906083137,
-0.0088152336,
-0.0132409837,
0.0020196643,
-0.015068654,
0.0207110588,
0.0134862559,
-0.0159999672,
-0.0223753788,
-0.042712342,
0.001119626,
0.033559829,
0.0193933565,
-0.0119709196,
0.0116459066,
-0.0003077387,
-0.014789884,
-0.0059152353,
0.0453795157,
-0.0074735973,
0.0114861634,
-0.0123687508,
-0.018916171,
-0.0477928258,
0.0177459363,
0.0052311523,
-0.0402230993,
0.0056311558,
0.0227394868,
0.0284314062,
0.0305342469,
0.0104301469,
-0.0426316075,
0.0605292767,
0.0020319405,
-0.0131059624,
-0.0047627902,
-0.0220210608,
-0.006726081,
-0.0287716743,
-0.0043619368,
-0.0264145359,
0.0593104474,
0.0007372856,
-0.0353832468,
-0.0431340374,
-0.0409071706,
-0.0144463107,
0.0063904356,
-0.0442500673,
0.020653693,
-0.0179946367,
0.0193504002,
-0.0179447345,
-0.0571745411,
0.0740562528,
-0.0106549151,
0.0068111094,
-0.0603750236,
-0.0090917628,
-0.0324159898,
0.0192503184,
0.0213146098,
0.0582531467,
-0.0724158213,
0.0026245762,
-0.034794692,
0.0388301387,
0.0273033623,
-0.0198751874,
0.0444499515,
-0.013777717,
0.0163266584,
-0.022836145,
-0.0605553724,
-0.0551336333,
-0.0376312248,
0.0072695417,
-0.0076954509,
0.0437738635,
-0.0057238019,
0.0201657396,
-0.0043777674,
0.0237825979,
0.007544552,
0.0379849747,
0.0163380168,
0.0150136519,
-0.0015957271,
-0.0137159936,
0.0007107257,
-0.0349927209,
0.0016871602,
-0.0001491482,
-0.0026498886,
0.0387799218,
-0.0079674488,
-0.0013905077,
-0.0222181547,
0.0469192751,
-0.0382686071,
-0.0271982308,
-0.0514668636,
-0.031701725,
0.0647181198,
-0.0140112704,
0.0761284605,
0.0474417061,
-0.0300978646,
0.0066767009,
-0.0266510993,
-0.0208154935,
0.0556010604,
0.007972043,
-0.1039948165,
0.0019295294,
-0.0128863873,
-0.0043707835,
0.0332010053,
-0.0209518634,
-0.0282525532,
-0.1134066954,
-0.0374170728,
0.0564847365,
-0.0581853613,
-0.011765481,
-0.040757224,
-0.0133105591,
-0.0407387614,
-0.0456970707,
-0.0173706654,
0.0168356001,
-0.0154205998,
-0.0058980319,
-0.006999007,
-0.0808096156,
-0.042490948,
-0.0589402281,
0.0110812187,
0.0112225106,
0.04912889,
-0.0365209244,
-0.0219709575,
0.0121752387,
-0.0391942374,
-0.0547978282,
0.0067358073,
0.044311583,
-0.0351123661,
-0.0350899138,
0.0488137528,
0.0316924565,
-0.0316610709,
0.0053138821,
0.002617935,
0.0754676536,
0.0000217418,
0.0505491868,
0.0132195409,
-0.0115464656,
0.0194376744,
0.0673372149,
-0.0073154205,
-0.019441545,
0.073189415,
0.0080077536,
0.0380324982,
0.0079694809,
-0.0222658981,
0.0131986886,
-0.0406312086,
-0.0246309899,
-0.0667202473,
-0.0386477783,
-0.0263819583,
0.056031812,
0.0531047881,
0.0418821648,
-0.0314053074,
-0.0425455943,
-0.0523107573,
0.0011841613,
0.020156825,
-0.0017368853,
-0.0236955732,
-0.0448491946,
0.0213937405,
-0.0311263427,
-0.0241922345,
0.0118687181,
-0.0296212584,
-0.0699210912,
0.0150137739,
0.0514851511,
0.0063132718,
0.0636729449,
-0.0346757807,
0.0045451042,
0.0302930791,
0.0566457659,
0.0214993022,
-0.0217074957,
0.0187815558,
0.0046557467,
0.0219461303,
0.0349171348,
-0.0294625051,
-0.0092261694,
-0.0026381011,
0.0199010801,
-0.0255289674,
-0.0408507288,
0.0269165095,
-0.0189162865,
0.0740235597,
-0.0695243478,
0.0430877022,
-0.0479949266,
0.0130540226,
-0.0083921179,
-0.0574036315,
0.0287109446,
-0.0128834657,
0.0253082663,
-0.0241095405,
-0.0105211111,
0.0465360954,
0.00736963,
0.0199401025,
0.0118362103,
-0.0196139161,
0.0278397519,
-0.0039840802,
-0.0080042724,
0.0345494561,
-0.010203206,
0.031014381,
0.0210932512,
0.0449602008,
-0.0335469395,
0.0124468189,
0.0211052317,
0.0286953691,
0.001627469,
0.0241638161,
-0.0141408965,
-0.0078005665,
0.01167838,
0.0379836038,
0.1116865128,
-0.0879158527,
0.0254279394,
-0.0085936906,
-0.0232381765,
-0.0025704838,
-0.0101691615,
0.0117413169,
-0.0313614719,
0.008419998,
-0.0089917639,
-0.0310225822,
0.0413230956,
0.0525974967,
-0.053121902,
-0.0025066726,
-0.0168137159,
-0.0067023123,
-0.0152831068,
-0.0177640952,
0.0223062802,
0.0378311314,
-0.0168288574,
0.0148233688,
-0.03268525,
-0.0706715658,
0.0016382025,
0.0252720788,
-0.0036743716,
0.0408967361,
0.0239976794,
0.0914057791,
-0.0196983404,
0.0336486325,
-0.0437623449,
0.0221664943,
0.0091563072,
-0.0375625864,
0.0215582717,
-5.426116086e-33,
-0.0138331801,
0.0231551118,
-0.0210254714,
-0.0129795801,
0.0291746017,
-0.010590896,
0.021691991,
0.0144109176,
-0.0174890608,
0.0207507145,
-0.0047290106,
-0.0126893446,
0.005874387,
-0.0014404292,
0.0072094332,
0.0032997343,
-0.0252296254,
0.0110871997,
-0.0178555083,
-0.0302952379,
0.1013970748,
0.021988729,
0.0972237661,
-0.0855241865,
0.0303525981,
0.024462821,
0.0461260267,
0.0188542362,
0.0251468159,
0.0396031588,
-0.0118805105,
0.0449032076,
0.0324457064,
0.02514855,
0.020204762,
-0.0082690669,
-0.0481929258,
-0.069536455,
0.0368948132,
0.0384941027,
-0.0429567583,
-0.0088433931,
0.041168347,
-0.0267794579,
-0.0183883831,
0.0077161854,
0.0333484076,
-0.0152441394,
-0.046817787,
0.000575093,
-0.0687048286,
0.0272338018,
0.0195128564,
-0.0195283201,
0.062016543,
0.0141234053,
0.0277169682,
-0.0431413539,
-0.0674996525,
0.0154775195,
-0.0484206453,
0.0381161124,
0.0824757293,
0.0056117782,
-0.006667499,
0.0698720068,
0.0271365121,
-0.020089278,
0.0441422649,
-0.0134655926,
0.0091353059,
-0.0158629604,
-0.0159070455,
0.0589277484,
0.0280199293,
-0.0045168702,
-0.055221606,
0.0433417223,
0.0470374525,
-0.0418666713,
0.0045971056,
-0.0141437706,
-0.0490588881,
-0.0058551435,
-0.0235662572,
-0.0483224429,
-0.000632707,
-0.0458547957,
-0.0099410387,
-0.0296582375,
-0.0173546541,
0.0107910568,
0.0297094528,
-0.0412501916,
-0.0440645181,
0.0293654557,
0.0115233054,
-0.0276923832,
-0.0128912767,
0.0405041054,
-0.0440987386,
-0.0613675863,
-0.0498993658,
0.0253236312,
0.0232336354,
0.0235951804,
0.0691820979,
0.0295697171,
-0.0072598495,
0.0065764254,
-0.0338797309,
-0.0714331716,
-0.0485049859,
0.0077076028,
0.0573490709,
0.0328790843,
0.0045386571,
0.0294364225,
0.0870660543,
-0.0131585151,
-0.0139806923,
-0.0393689573,
-0.0052024801,
0.0376853421,
-0.0065333024,
0.0083282208,
-0.0015990754,
-0.0091537684,
-0.0193584077,
-0.0727121383,
0.0092385067,
0.0183526855,
2.589e-7,
0.0426018946,
-0.0064151092,
-0.0077854735,
0.0025875408,
-0.0026268698,
-0.0082681794,
-0.0503171459,
0.034080524,
-0.0343477316,
-0.0038179513,
-0.0034777217,
0.0269611292,
0.0272235461,
0.0391377211,
-0.0898288488,
0.0180187915,
-0.0179065987,
0.0419218056,
-0.0451169275,
0.0095728468,
0.0396709219,
0.1061622053,
0.0412765592,
-0.0015759285,
-0.0053734384,
-0.0148389731,
0.0545062721,
0.0051323446,
-0.0320649929,
-0.0198073685,
-0.0031165066,
0.037317697,
-0.0253716093,
0.0425113402,
-0.0394074246,
0.0680157989,
0.0616043136,
-0.0128620444,
-0.0300050806,
0.0175457355,
0.0095951427,
-0.0372851379,
-0.0045431289,
-0.0300402865,
0.0675738454,
-0.0067952066,
-0.0225547273,
0.0144988354,
-0.0082015675,
0.0418828391,
0.0662919804,
0.0054261233,
-0.069263719,
0.0201650746,
0.0541957356,
0.0214780029,
-0.0285477508,
-0.043109078,
-0.0217358023,
0.039979741,
-0.0084249992,
-0.0226554442,
0.0486418828,
0.0132020237,
0.0028725606,
0.0026924652,
0.0089048557,
2.008049015e-34,
-0.0243835449,
0.0059913467,
0.0143747088,
-0.0066620535,
-0.0015880173,
-0.0803013369,
0.0060936739,
-0.0024804831,
0.0166473705,
-0.0035047876,
0.0277017318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07023v1 | Gemini Goes to Med School: Exploring the Capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models on Medical Challenge Problems & Hallucinations | 2024-02-10T19:08:28 | 2024-02-10T19:08:28 | Ankit Pal, Malaikannan Sankarasubbu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG | Large language models have the potential to be valuable in the healthcare
industry, but it's crucial to verify their safety and effectiveness through
rigorous evaluation. For this purpose, we comprehensively evaluated both
open-source LLMs and Google's new multimodal LLM called Gemini across Medical
reasoning, hallucination detection, and Medical Visual Question Answering
tasks. While Gemini showed competence, it lagged behind state-of-the-art models
like MedPaLM 2 and GPT-4 in diagnostic accuracy. Additionally, Gemini achieved
an accuracy of 61.45\% on the medical VQA dataset, significantly lower than
GPT-4V's score of 88\%. Our analysis revealed that Gemini is highly susceptible
to hallucinations, overconfidence, and knowledge gaps, which indicate risks if
deployed uncritically. We also performed a detailed analysis by medical subject
and test type, providing actionable feedback for developers and clinicians. To
mitigate risks, we applied prompting strategies that improved performance.
Additionally, we facilitated future research and development by releasing a
Python module for medical LLM evaluation and establishing a dedicated
leaderboard on Hugging Face for medical domain LLMs. Python module can be found
at https://github.com/promptslab/RosettaEval | [
0.031711407,
0.042126745,
-0.0024231847,
0.0008817789,
-0.0280057713,
0.0283175446,
0.0243766773,
0.0343720913,
0.0275064707,
-0.0276030973,
-0.0165086873,
-0.0621607639,
-0.0134678921,
0.051124081,
0.0518559627,
-0.0619569756,
0.0358587541,
-0.0359069519,
-0.0011792319,
-0.0028458042,
-0.0124159083,
0.0014535097,
-0.0839198679,
0.0634409189,
-0.001040703,
-0.0427282825,
-0.0031628758,
0.0149488281,
0.0152883744,
-0.0819689333,
-0.0299104489,
0.0542577878,
-0.0126433372,
0.011629316,
0.0000022348,
-0.0746551901,
-0.0135200862,
-0.0005947135,
-0.0052335095,
-0.0427406058,
0.0435605384,
-0.013679442,
0.0021172517,
0.0164228957,
-0.0416701473,
-0.0185315628,
0.0330530256,
0.0606601164,
0.0742580816,
0.0547432601,
-0.0137170553,
0.0045416006,
0.0217423104,
0.009930077,
0.0567053482,
-0.0176335555,
0.0153324315,
0.0358639359,
0.0343660153,
-0.0514943823,
-0.0152718369,
0.0500461794,
0.009217809,
0.0371349305,
-0.0217191372,
0.0484343357,
-0.0648243427,
-0.0484896563,
-0.0199442003,
0.0623762012,
0.0045730639,
0.0142848352,
0.0105524594,
0.028117884,
0.0077951252,
0.0200005062,
-0.0743974149,
0.026525259,
-0.0075450409,
-0.0116198584,
-0.0265614521,
-0.0277135652,
0.0437017418,
-0.0029942235,
-0.0079712151,
0.0063916212,
0.0175038613,
-0.0100044282,
0.0401206352,
-0.0075725154,
-0.0292684343,
-0.0173825994,
0.0243467353,
0.0503827184,
-0.0656226352,
-0.0243798979,
-0.0355687179,
0.0034782204,
0.0789666176,
-0.0528133698,
0.0071668718,
0.0174444374,
-0.0649477765,
0.043675933,
-0.0152213275,
0.0335223414,
-0.0401970521,
0.0673117265,
-0.0213693548,
0.019201275,
-0.0329897702,
-0.0049115466,
-0.0077138441,
-0.0214594696,
0.0158480797,
-0.0251494292,
-0.0562530644,
-0.0202749092,
-0.0151728028,
0.0291818231,
-0.0113229956,
0.0558172874,
0.0277168676,
0.0049438043,
-0.0271392725,
0.0284091365,
0.0120060593,
-0.0105069466,
0.0149832489,
-0.0652545169,
0.0106348107,
0.0359564312,
-0.0313555412,
-0.0043125022,
0.0321212076,
0.0805579498,
0.0140208453,
-0.0142093245,
0.0052117021,
-0.0449345149,
-0.0225909408,
-0.0589476489,
0.0674338266,
-0.072897315,
-0.0044089868,
0.0090880329,
0.0056789732,
-0.0192388352,
0.0384302624,
0.0173620526,
-0.0214487147,
0.0684023574,
-0.0433147401,
0.0099213412,
0.0352303684,
0.0654442459,
-0.0337854177,
0.0469426401,
0.0158258118,
-0.0104564615,
0.0141625376,
-0.0600429885,
0.0514549837,
0.0179552417,
-0.0268264879,
-0.0252139363,
-0.0122693125,
0.0007203495,
0.0175224897,
0.0825128406,
-0.0435228199,
0.0850805193,
-0.0002145699,
-0.0146328583,
0.0476679914,
0.0475454442,
0.0059553576,
-0.0065335198,
-0.0158166178,
-0.0384324193,
0.0152911963,
-0.0070606386,
-0.0452547558,
0.0471722409,
-0.0222027656,
-0.0200772211,
-0.0084906798,
0.0304895192,
-0.0214926973,
-0.0248461682,
-0.0708066374,
-0.001379683,
-0.0200086702,
0.0222679172,
0.0308883768,
-0.0314449333,
-0.0513138138,
0.053965874,
0.0185955688,
-0.0431483053,
-0.0233775526,
-0.0588762015,
-0.0098821856,
0.0897732228,
0.0508595109,
-0.0287094843,
-0.0582653843,
-0.04653427,
0.0553512536,
0.0400579423,
0.0304991249,
0.0122449845,
0.0117293447,
-0.0614859872,
-0.0117432894,
0.0065440331,
0.0056582447,
-0.043552842,
-0.0151094589,
0.0275832564,
-0.0339065269,
-0.0162197035,
0.006068727,
0.0421621501,
-0.041555509,
-0.0144648943,
-0.0431552604,
-0.0061005922,
0.0129194921,
-0.0091956463,
-0.0012312082,
0.0267816763,
0.0255084112,
-0.0418933481,
-0.01352078,
0.0074545564,
-0.0391491316,
-0.0019624273,
0.0432173833,
-0.0531234667,
-0.0179895088,
-0.0058030388,
-0.0327604152,
-0.0171426181,
-0.0017669174,
-0.0583769754,
0.0121709649,
-0.02861307,
0.0050629992,
0.0390583426,
0.0340935402,
-0.0359454043,
0.0378260948,
-0.0354778096,
0.023233287,
0.0246431865,
-0.0033113395,
-0.0191315897,
-0.0237253774,
-0.0443800539,
0.0342611186,
-0.0092285052,
0.0247896556,
-0.0662951395,
0.0129155386,
-0.0690909848,
-0.0305914748,
-0.1178649515,
-0.0107548004,
0.0091773923,
-0.0155275865,
0.0185157862,
-0.0215858109,
-0.0160359424,
-0.0120001603,
-0.0323040821,
0.0032982607,
0.0325019397,
0.0191302169,
0.0141957458,
0.0106735276,
-0.0123668471,
-0.0206647068,
0.0055199978,
-0.0478852503,
0.0368130915,
-0.0045692464,
0.012406202,
-0.0235690773,
0.0128907729,
-0.0544081926,
0.0126920957,
-0.0103679392,
-0.0204453655,
0.0335701257,
-0.0278487876,
0.0511295311,
0.061675135,
0.0042753685,
0.0139940446,
0.0528215952,
-0.0350140743,
-0.001266564,
0.0060435068,
0.0091951312,
-0.0429391935,
0.0179296695,
-0.0499410704,
-0.0407981128,
0.048187878,
0.00596477,
0.0299504064,
-0.025418248,
0.0153471222,
-0.0189846028,
-0.0163317211,
-0.0230119582,
0.0349563099,
-0.0404863954,
0.0360575467,
-0.0006171445,
-0.0412285291,
0.0781383142,
-0.0116232913,
0.0007667582,
-0.0203339774,
-0.0125017064,
-0.0217162445,
0.0514445715,
-0.0250175614,
0.0232522022,
0.0033486176,
-0.0205302462,
-0.0320727229,
0.0112921325,
-0.0343420878,
-0.0707951263,
0.063485533,
-0.0525315739,
-0.0103227971,
0.000615546,
-0.0036334298,
-0.0576288775,
0.0088930177,
-0.0368434153,
-0.0170584191,
-0.0587412231,
0.0263996366,
-0.0599488355,
0.0040835259,
0.0140207559,
0.0102459658,
0.0039278334,
-0.0177273508,
0.0160866957,
-0.0094994325,
0.0389101133,
0.0598163158,
0.0250814036,
-0.0571769029,
0.02843895,
0.0906691253,
0.032105688,
0.0127610285,
-0.0191840716,
0.0100925025,
0.0091659063,
0.0076731774,
-0.0057827532,
0.0251273531,
0.039173279,
-0.0593086667,
0.0106349885,
0.0999981761,
0.0136867762,
-0.0450366065,
0.0134445457,
-0.0583332293,
0.0149022443,
0.0154567137,
-0.0230933744,
-0.0821983963,
-0.0511833504,
-0.0171511155,
0.0454122871,
0.0000833956,
-0.0075199981,
0.0289925821,
-0.0242830943,
0.0537196845,
0.0022005786,
-0.0272358749,
-0.0051304055,
-0.0013971454,
0.0017383517,
0.0093941698,
0.0255657434,
-0.0004158425,
-0.0086895451,
-0.0255710501,
0.0011190928,
-0.0344197899,
-0.0367763266,
0.0587328747,
-0.0329316817,
0.0344777182,
0.0634259284,
0.0271670893,
-0.029306462,
-0.1104480922,
0.0089108422,
0.021105906,
0.0343207717,
-0.0023881125,
0.0789616629,
0.0251266435,
0.0097364783,
-0.0325438343,
0.026372904,
-0.0729093105,
-0.0267359111,
0.0232194848,
0.0963021144,
-0.0588444956,
-0.0341315754,
-0.0630903617,
0.0654059798,
-0.0016274683,
0.0459502675,
0.0035416649,
-0.0224190969,
-0.0495839454,
0.0182200167,
0.0628166795,
0.0116086006,
-0.0458696522,
0.0539688021,
0.0428147614,
-0.0088275205,
-0.0510162562,
0.0047059827,
0.0476049483,
0.0219768342,
-0.0130648604,
0.0282890461,
-0.0397829004,
0.0431958959,
-0.047093492,
0.0687699914,
0.0268214364,
0.0306549426,
-0.0467725061,
-0.0032195826,
0.028064359,
-0.0136131244,
0.0154745849,
0.0313015766,
-0.0464667343,
-0.0076038307,
0.0201025531,
0.062657088,
0.0300569348,
-0.0102033094,
-0.0027911633,
-0.0266229138,
0.0046534776,
0.0337481722,
-0.0033436611,
0.0122224307,
-0.0020429736,
0.0151167074,
0.0043204986,
0.0014686077,
-0.0151213892,
-0.0178109966,
-0.0167408343,
0.0366747715,
-0.0043873647,
0.0127733462,
0.0069429763,
0.0395696498,
0.0314370245,
-0.0235452,
0.0048393169,
0.0109434603,
0.0027402069,
-0.0112256259,
0.0214374643,
-0.0175604261,
0.002594152,
0.0213094037,
-0.0152094495,
0.0254583899,
-0.0326924436,
-0.0495296828,
-0.0374312215,
-0.0527441427,
0.0601861589,
0.0106697492,
-0.0143184504,
0.0551065579,
-0.0112060597,
-0.0154948505,
0.0101825511,
-0.0133821722,
0.0395574048,
0.0256845485,
0.1244094372,
-0.0134603437,
-0.0194759015,
0.0205501802,
0.0531952716,
-0.0308034662,
-0.1031892821,
0.000871245,
0.0533689409,
0.0566823632,
0.0471592583,
0.0164097436,
-0.0217153952,
0.025621023,
-0.0056107007,
0.0035443672,
-0.0181754939,
-0.0163676329,
0.0532685257,
0.0156812258,
-0.0003386133,
-0.0299403071,
0.0730097741,
-0.0238450877,
0.0452312827,
-0.0011842818,
-0.0116163893,
-0.0505105592,
-0.0497440659,
0.0342565328,
0.0213268492,
-0.048098091,
0.005474404,
-0.0666680038,
-0.0467919484,
0.0115023088,
0.0103043504,
-0.0193846691,
-0.0317728817,
0.0606532395,
0.0534863807,
-0.0031919675,
-0.0292124487,
-0.0079018911,
0.0452627428,
0.0062990985,
-0.0023146456,
0.0454643257,
-6.189601504e-33,
0.0035956774,
-0.0284252167,
0.0506717153,
-0.0230849087,
-0.0247525275,
0.0162913091,
-0.0308934003,
0.0439804271,
-0.0061158696,
0.0020986819,
0.0126660252,
-0.0018801267,
0.006117966,
0.0343605205,
0.0111876652,
-0.0528914183,
-0.0139709078,
0.0129221259,
-0.0158123057,
0.0198109765,
-0.0243829116,
0.0286914054,
0.0443621166,
-0.0683490112,
0.0101406034,
-0.0052308426,
-0.0072845235,
0.0197966229,
-0.06045077,
0.0560726598,
-0.0439050719,
0.0341510624,
0.0208307672,
0.0050728014,
-0.0093279546,
-0.0172134787,
-0.0097941859,
-0.0124125266,
0.0019503961,
0.0038793501,
-0.0848617554,
-0.0197739061,
0.0686990097,
-0.017331833,
-0.0112745073,
-0.0205506794,
0.0283915047,
-0.0460228771,
-0.0086238356,
-0.0013218574,
-0.0247626584,
0.0164326131,
0.0041275974,
-0.0148593988,
-0.0262391306,
0.0430423878,
-0.043886248,
0.0191988032,
-0.0493277796,
-0.0084105888,
-0.0285080932,
-0.0283409096,
0.0701692402,
-0.0291936081,
-0.000419497,
0.0805180818,
0.0510516427,
-0.023565352,
-0.049965445,
-0.01926958,
-0.0003413733,
0.0939680338,
0.0795557275,
0.0173529927,
-0.0093620019,
0.003989981,
-0.0805143341,
0.021448303,
-0.0784234479,
0.0481704399,
0.0458489433,
-0.0162678957,
-0.0535626076,
-0.0026932515,
0.0132694654,
0.0354936607,
-0.0428501666,
-0.0391405746,
0.0476161391,
-0.0156915262,
0.0044646459,
0.0080915941,
0.0223848186,
-0.0152126793,
0.0270524025,
-0.0515180416,
0.0238280892,
0.0325024165,
-0.0262821224,
0.0171950776,
-0.0234524291,
0.0050589084,
0.0180449877,
-0.0363922119,
0.0740547329,
0.0061814939,
-0.0057176813,
-0.019071646,
-0.0537526198,
-0.0013524856,
-0.0121614272,
0.0031244759,
0.0109943068,
0.0173975062,
0.0447957143,
-0.0190694164,
-0.0256428849,
0.0000963396,
-0.0108834617,
-0.0128095718,
-0.0492439047,
-0.0371066406,
-0.029167857,
-0.0041491673,
-0.0440895483,
0.003783613,
-0.053738445,
-0.0309642255,
0.0225690566,
-0.0713722259,
-0.0114987083,
0.0158924311,
2.928e-7,
0.0561622195,
0.0721265897,
-0.0209916737,
-0.0167355128,
0.0232711565,
0.029929271,
-0.0295379572,
0.0233453084,
0.0356234051,
-0.0462970175,
-0.0222332664,
0.0291296914,
0.0494842939,
0.0677832589,
-0.0498059914,
-0.0170462988,
-0.0026674373,
-0.0161336791,
-0.0464205965,
-0.01579093,
0.0709083378,
0.0221005455,
-0.0317478403,
-0.0556366965,
0.0351731591,
-0.0432273075,
0.0425166376,
-0.0395138822,
-0.0084367273,
0.0174066778,
0.0374204107,
0.0027437208,
0.014047279,
0.0517117716,
-0.0099301888,
-0.0766357258,
0.0385882892,
0.0598726459,
-0.0455937572,
-0.0421150923,
0.0101225218,
-0.0007321751,
0.0231472719,
-0.0704191849,
0.0655155107,
-0.0157839414,
-0.040266905,
-0.0085711768,
-0.0328530446,
-0.0540767536,
0.0911510363,
-0.0283640921,
-0.03287673,
0.0171064995,
0.0303680394,
0.0104539087,
-0.0321459398,
-0.0370829441,
-0.0123759918,
0.0199932512,
-0.0385041572,
-0.0468589105,
0.0235427283,
-0.0264996141,
-0.0303053912,
-0.0596710816,
-0.0422728434,
2.669356194e-34,
0.0140623422,
0.0125756571,
0.0526388139,
0.0396355093,
0.0135377534,
0.010161682,
0.0466727428,
0.0077464939,
-0.0069273147,
-0.0496418364,
-0.0147133935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06992v1 | A Rational Analysis of the Speech-to-Song Illusion | 2024-02-10T16:54:28 | 2024-02-10T16:54:28 | Raja Marjieh, Pol van Rijn, Ilia Sucholutsky, Harin Lee, Thomas L. Griffiths, Nori Jacoby | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.AP | The speech-to-song illusion is a robust psychological phenomenon whereby a
spoken sentence sounds increasingly more musical as it is repeated. Despite
decades of research, a complete formal account of this transformation is still
lacking, and some of its nuanced characteristics, namely, that certain phrases
appear to transform while others do not, is not well understood. Here we
provide a formal account of this phenomenon, by recasting it as a statistical
inference whereby a rational agent attempts to decide whether a sequence of
utterances is more likely to have been produced in a song or speech. Using this
approach and analyzing song and speech corpora, we further introduce a novel
prose-to-lyrics illusion that is purely text-based. In this illusion, simply
duplicating written sentences makes them appear more like song lyrics. We
provide robust evidence for this new illusion in both human participants and
large language models. | [
0.0016373293,
0.0724711269,
-0.0306571424,
0.014579013,
-0.0582785569,
-0.0089065442,
-0.0197213944,
0.0290898867,
-0.0563985109,
-0.0066485726,
-0.0577259026,
-0.0081718666,
0.0729871839,
-0.0113070831,
0.0517309047,
-0.057603918,
0.0064050308,
-0.0269942712,
0.053397242,
-0.00601247,
-0.0259020887,
-0.0261837319,
-0.0019954513,
0.0074296384,
0.0374326669,
-0.0171801709,
-0.0098543419,
0.041309271,
-0.0286414325,
0.0060717724,
-0.0941151828,
0.0468707159,
-0.0031617831,
0.0031284904,
0.0000015329,
-0.0529672094,
0.0248913355,
-0.0211839378,
0.0365246348,
0.023841016,
0.0144108105,
0.055905778,
0.0046350104,
0.0055139,
-0.0156477187,
0.0500211455,
0.0218345467,
0.0420014225,
-0.011860867,
0.0745057315,
0.0180922914,
-0.0487044677,
-0.0149019426,
-0.0439640619,
0.0271334741,
0.0031576743,
0.0236649048,
-0.0154962018,
0.0122597059,
-0.0319694988,
-0.0079762507,
0.0079291891,
-0.0186640341,
0.0535957366,
0.0009784079,
0.0525418893,
-0.0013498315,
-0.0000514348,
-0.0004623533,
0.0189014841,
0.0043590623,
-0.0505041108,
0.0261590127,
0.0289848372,
0.0382171981,
0.0426762737,
-0.022633899,
0.0113843782,
0.0242723115,
0.0239216667,
-0.0448653884,
0.0045000259,
0.045312468,
-0.0098571684,
0.0134048555,
-0.0034483853,
0.006771754,
-0.0627640784,
0.0543312691,
0.0046540136,
-0.0165783223,
-0.0649005994,
0.0003068619,
-0.0206136573,
0.000835026,
-0.0169798862,
-0.0282913391,
-0.0289039165,
-0.0155341681,
-0.0470168814,
0.0504512787,
-0.0219198763,
-0.0082851602,
0.0434513874,
-0.0179923829,
0.0214361046,
-0.0351114608,
0.0037712245,
-0.0308100358,
0.0388084054,
0.0003012226,
-0.011220091,
-0.0054480145,
-0.0096749859,
0.0333915725,
-0.0435256697,
-0.0409900919,
-0.0526131913,
-0.0327149034,
-0.0009971918,
-0.0224461183,
-0.0050886646,
-0.0063388702,
-0.0451994464,
0.0165696796,
-0.0100675235,
0.0007958733,
0.1093785092,
-0.0011283901,
0.0023131175,
-0.013874515,
0.0276102163,
0.0305157099,
0.0186278317,
0.0235908609,
0.0189535394,
0.009492876,
0.0025531321,
-0.0275547504,
-0.0222188309,
-0.041664917,
-0.0352066047,
-0.0160450637,
-0.0728346407,
-0.0239377711,
-0.026647171,
-0.0062342053,
-0.0473641753,
-0.0057362928,
0.0128866658,
-0.0678478628,
0.0560898148,
0.0184519514,
0.0456557013,
-0.0161732696,
0.0135847265,
-0.026732184,
0.0012027281,
0.0966423675,
0.0037968177,
0.0095530543,
-0.037840087,
0.0466518402,
0.0441214442,
-0.0411631353,
0.0202364586,
-0.0319564231,
-0.044640094,
-0.0349613018,
0.0593757518,
0.0434796587,
0.0300181694,
0.0099281669,
-0.0286210682,
0.0858297944,
0.0700287148,
-0.0042810878,
0.023053566,
-0.0166850574,
0.0433062688,
0.0261779781,
0.0969088748,
-0.0185604244,
0.0097168386,
0.0179923456,
0.0331885777,
0.0859980136,
-0.0169580225,
0.006263806,
0.0295759477,
-0.0182704218,
-0.0025047804,
0.0265262779,
-0.0089766812,
-0.020056529,
0.0458076559,
-0.0189858768,
-0.0198933072,
0.0222321171,
-0.0263350401,
0.003656903,
-0.0368884988,
0.0338019952,
0.0444801003,
0.00331709,
-0.0192129929,
0.1406867802,
-0.0031955172,
-0.0296093263,
0.0783713758,
-0.0316760205,
-0.0020903633,
0.0003528279,
0.020459557,
0.037679594,
-0.0094398307,
0.0409948304,
0.0198109969,
-0.0630407706,
0.0363107957,
0.002183099,
-0.0201392565,
0.0400133058,
-0.0120209279,
-0.0017115069,
-0.0186897721,
0.0278034825,
0.0013021714,
0.0148549154,
0.0274925902,
-0.0510314852,
0.0646072179,
-0.0252824072,
0.0298802555,
-0.0221450906,
0.0568238348,
-0.0287393481,
-0.0213236138,
0.0282155778,
-0.0534256622,
0.0257028732,
0.0061543537,
0.0433488861,
-0.0355898738,
0.0914939642,
-0.0605663657,
0.0565210022,
0.0349308141,
0.0493989326,
-0.037171457,
0.0093762185,
0.050392475,
-0.0117693376,
0.0545128994,
0.0065559703,
-0.0105485898,
-0.0130775794,
0.035144154,
-0.0511863232,
0.023639014,
0.0366433412,
-0.00953524,
0.0071992795,
-0.0333956033,
-0.0833547264,
-0.0555833057,
-0.0418801755,
-0.0181948747,
-0.0336087793,
-0.0003374519,
-0.0365133248,
0.0528780781,
-0.0579341426,
-0.0211471599,
-0.0119476942,
-0.0170632526,
-0.0213022716,
0.0151649937,
0.0387117937,
-0.0341642871,
-0.0510197803,
-0.0538134016,
-0.0088154636,
0.0291377679,
-0.0187544003,
0.0093181012,
-0.0111617446,
0.0074196961,
-0.0318070687,
0.0068326038,
-0.0394738615,
-0.0223817714,
0.0281631555,
0.0080332411,
0.0013907489,
-0.0195979252,
0.0791121647,
0.0897857174,
-0.0063638473,
-0.0322641321,
0.0739738494,
-0.0224814918,
0.0085262703,
-0.052285742,
-0.0039495779,
0.056422431,
-0.0447556674,
-0.0693678334,
0.0116191665,
0.0372969881,
0.087584585,
0.0040088911,
0.0068386314,
0.0523317084,
-0.0355754569,
-0.0230474714,
0.007840327,
-0.0381195769,
-0.0570051521,
0.0687217042,
-0.0231909715,
-0.0092559494,
0.0525037162,
-0.055437848,
0.0213373583,
-0.0146312118,
-0.0161441155,
0.0245919172,
0.0167072546,
-0.0108144432,
-0.0062720864,
0.062632367,
-0.0033450748,
-0.0738795698,
-0.0147585906,
-0.0041171852,
-0.0575083792,
0.0433661081,
-0.0250076037,
-0.0060186866,
0.0376609825,
-0.0050511239,
0.0089893984,
-0.0523622595,
-0.0151108084,
-0.0182780214,
-0.0412957445,
-0.0457957648,
0.0066191726,
-0.034028884,
0.024051087,
0.0349319763,
-0.0183422752,
-0.0109115671,
0.0006529603,
0.0752356276,
0.0391318575,
-0.0036085548,
0.0099702599,
-0.0575094074,
-0.0015409726,
-0.0139540192,
0.0035752067,
0.0396635495,
0.0027824084,
-0.0084114065,
-0.018271409,
0.0112080984,
-0.0118132178,
0.0616625138,
-0.0118594011,
-0.036875993,
0.0124685122,
0.070442073,
0.0002949477,
0.002597149,
0.0196632817,
0.0142993098,
0.0256565195,
-0.0097212605,
-0.0158322956,
-0.0094686812,
-0.0179836061,
0.0421715453,
0.0255256817,
-0.001912721,
0.0331038833,
-0.024785554,
-0.0705313236,
0.0174179766,
0.0213254038,
0.0374081619,
-0.0197511557,
-0.0326648876,
-0.0010964529,
0.042335704,
-0.0069214217,
0.0020849335,
-0.0275886655,
0.019911956,
-0.0171532072,
-0.0106444005,
-0.0046466431,
-0.0459971651,
-0.0132571571,
0.0587148815,
0.0247978978,
0.0758958459,
-0.0645599887,
-0.0703987107,
-0.0553493835,
0.0107722031,
-0.0020438603,
0.060356874,
0.0341891162,
0.0685819313,
0.0140732676,
-0.0077129477,
0.0256899837,
-0.0134122502,
-0.0326233208,
0.0379380025,
0.0142308502,
0.0121852867,
-0.0940969363,
0.0164044071,
0.037949089,
-0.0039299428,
0.0952693447,
0.054648757,
0.0037290829,
0.0139274737,
-0.0252283402,
0.0248361714,
-0.0449407473,
-0.064702034,
-0.0060064904,
0.009024688,
-0.0005306795,
-0.0747728422,
-0.0022729365,
-0.0857054293,
0.0027619898,
0.0335744992,
0.0146648893,
0.0224170368,
-0.0340376012,
-0.0132428957,
-0.004348658,
-0.0202985443,
0.039510183,
-0.0242535863,
-0.0448792242,
-0.0260484871,
-0.04252664,
-0.0428313129,
-0.0386083387,
-0.0818390474,
-0.0453074649,
0.0273925401,
-0.0715756118,
0.0272097569,
0.0327383988,
0.005995492,
-0.0004862044,
0.0020011459,
-0.0358126834,
0.0127607677,
0.0610903017,
0.0299934186,
-0.00626306,
0.0272345189,
0.0174063407,
-0.0254642628,
0.020726623,
0.0578972511,
-0.01316546,
0.0006483977,
-0.0581339002,
0.0179624129,
-0.0250879303,
0.0143754687,
0.0182637423,
0.0315213278,
-0.0141423261,
-0.0182979871,
-0.0191373322,
0.0099229515,
0.0004785551,
-0.050525967,
0.0728072152,
0.0903469324,
-0.0104587628,
-0.0202253945,
-0.0236088131,
-0.0552898869,
-0.0142542301,
-0.0525716394,
0.0331210941,
-0.0481005274,
0.0238451883,
-0.0144670354,
0.0319806524,
0.0439165011,
0.0036059623,
0.0582723767,
0.059697967,
-0.0074492525,
0.0233907904,
-0.0685992613,
-0.0433882102,
0.0009474948,
-0.0832529292,
-0.0224914327,
0.045385316,
0.0201826561,
0.01981223,
-0.0507361107,
0.0751025975,
-0.0344477519,
0.0264008753,
0.0029459943,
0.0092489086,
-0.0085400799,
-0.0130116427,
-0.0442109555,
-0.0057014488,
-0.0255112574,
0.0419290923,
0.0679271892,
-0.0315754712,
-0.0412628911,
-0.0653205663,
-0.0109201977,
0.036456313,
-0.0327012651,
-0.0402145796,
-0.0077502918,
-0.0049138688,
0.0165470429,
-0.0288179535,
-0.0515994467,
0.0080407411,
-0.0027583514,
0.0679952875,
-0.0263947174,
-0.0009555168,
0.038619101,
-0.0348520912,
0.0216620322,
0.0034624885,
-0.0101182554,
0.0218596626,
-0.0273521822,
-0.026314063,
-5.347684899e-33,
0.0008626918,
0.0227987934,
-0.0537905954,
0.0348501317,
-0.0143135833,
-0.0238003023,
-0.0667994469,
0.0218426976,
0.0087317023,
0.0303870514,
-0.0114867743,
0.0237801485,
0.0165704787,
-0.0036551282,
0.0354518369,
0.0332989916,
0.0432206728,
-0.0227815378,
-0.0536642782,
-0.0190207791,
0.0408375748,
-0.0111872805,
-0.0062488504,
-0.0367985219,
0.0210974012,
-0.0013773238,
-0.0192941278,
-0.024739705,
0.0137390522,
-0.0008763611,
-0.0231792796,
0.0075584971,
0.0212562177,
-0.0290845167,
-0.0388980694,
0.0569347627,
0.0209510718,
-0.0251923632,
-0.0048682704,
0.0344668925,
-0.010123373,
-0.0077539426,
0.0462070219,
-0.0089747887,
-0.0499707684,
-0.0158260185,
0.0477354266,
-0.0281590633,
0.0159475766,
-0.0180986896,
-0.0659699738,
-0.0451185182,
-0.0245120581,
-0.0093220323,
0.0188249946,
0.019495111,
-0.0154100424,
0.0398392715,
-0.0383834392,
0.0699479952,
-0.021348903,
0.0470586978,
0.0001857906,
0.0260476414,
0.013688053,
0.0502115078,
0.0698119327,
-0.0384620689,
-0.0400845632,
0.0566104613,
0.0003528057,
0.0197639093,
0.0513269156,
0.045625072,
0.0748090595,
-0.0414165594,
0.0404143929,
-0.0071996907,
0.0038308282,
-0.0615297444,
0.0248717703,
0.0397376753,
-0.0389677212,
-0.0399415009,
-0.0234708805,
-0.013447945,
-0.0354555435,
-0.0159069169,
0.0047357315,
-0.0355840735,
0.0132778399,
-0.0333678685,
-0.0088030724,
-0.0216542836,
-0.0548775196,
-0.0674021244,
-0.0513851047,
0.0292196684,
0.006410046,
-0.0281278156,
-0.007667887,
-0.0003393978,
0.0997996107,
0.0385474823,
0.0379517414,
0.0026205166,
0.0166045204,
-0.0119906841,
-0.0693016425,
0.0115787573,
0.0242967997,
-0.0626169071,
0.0501534827,
-0.0472779199,
0.0194793381,
0.0278846417,
0.0001764504,
-0.0120914495,
-0.0039017089,
0.0167992525,
-0.0159583129,
-0.0211907197,
-0.0455623344,
0.0163095426,
-0.0102720568,
-0.0136501584,
-0.0387732089,
-0.0530550629,
0.010105025,
-0.0338303261,
-0.0305184685,
-0.0271040816,
2.597e-7,
-0.0281709284,
0.009627426,
-0.0071719317,
-0.0089905309,
0.0636088923,
0.0512140952,
-0.0843029246,
0.0055757961,
0.0521911494,
-0.0376191661,
-0.0062562684,
-0.0073891249,
0.072358571,
0.0281981304,
-0.0877046362,
0.0134592606,
-0.0862410814,
0.0103934631,
-0.0340681523,
-0.0221342742,
0.0485405289,
0.0153939119,
0.021495752,
-0.0308340378,
0.006005154,
-0.0309905037,
0.0004925391,
-0.0071012424,
0.0319567025,
-0.0508518144,
-0.016427923,
-0.0254747495,
0.0039296015,
0.0016647937,
-0.0333650149,
0.0472320653,
0.0520417802,
0.0027953181,
0.0437069125,
-0.0075408057,
-0.0422930047,
0.0230185464,
0.0068590199,
-0.0173968393,
0.0407220758,
0.0080817165,
-0.0418822691,
0.0094681028,
-0.0318392105,
-0.0014605965,
0.0113192229,
0.0269043706,
-0.0365313739,
-0.0322027802,
0.0031365273,
0.0718296468,
0.0330220871,
-0.0333443396,
-0.00728299,
0.0101726707,
-0.0421206132,
-0.0416610353,
-0.0024229463,
0.0085329609,
0.0244394355,
-0.0735795349,
-0.0253995061,
1.816386269e-34,
0.0399251767,
-0.0236613397,
0.0426512696,
-0.0010744975,
0.0292812716,
-0.0173186772,
0.0324591994,
-0.0095052877,
0.0237167682,
-0.0506992564,
-0.0177586079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10951v1 | DAEDRA: A language model for predicting outcomes in passive pharmacovigilance reporting | 2024-02-10T16:48:45 | 2024-02-10T16:48:45 | Chris von Csefalvay | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7; J.3 | Over the recent years, the emergence of large language models (LLMs) has
given rise to a proliferation of domain-specific models that are intended to
reflect the particularities of linguistic context and content as a correlate of
the originating domain. This paper details the conception, design, training and
evaluation of DAEDRA, a LLM designed to detect regulatory-relevant outcomes
(mortality, ER attendance and hospitalisation) in adverse event reports
elicited through passive reporting (PR). While PR is a highly cost-efficient
way of eliciting information from a wide and diverse audience -- typically
including not only physicians and healthcare providers but also patients,
family members and other lay stakeholders --, this diversity makes PR corpora
difficult to analyse. Generic language models may not capture the complex
clinical dimensions while specific clinical or biomedical models may not
perform well on lay reports. To evaluate the utility of a subdomain-specific
language model, an adaptive training approach was adapted, wherein base
language model candidates were evaluated on a subset of the corpus, and the
best performer was trained on the entire corpus. This yielded a small but
significant improvement in $F_1$ (+1%), precision (+2.5%) and recall (+3.8%),
at a relatively low training cost and a single-day training time.
Subdomain-specific LLMs continue to be viable options for better results when
analysing highly specialised corpora. | [
0.0561005808,
0.0091820862,
-0.0105905114,
-0.0244724248,
-0.0043145004,
0.0273565333,
0.0027655282,
0.0096402913,
0.017585678,
-0.0481995195,
0.0253368504,
-0.0607707687,
-0.0191086996,
0.0492054559,
0.0203280821,
-0.0197037458,
0.0169942975,
0.0299285073,
0.0316455103,
0.0183916204,
0.0216479972,
0.0399576798,
-0.0192924552,
0.0522045903,
0.0046002464,
0.0001164456,
0.0496853702,
-0.0252809282,
0.0017639496,
-0.0579711646,
0.0102601685,
0.0103267785,
-0.0198036004,
-0.028555287,
0.0000018682,
-0.0527127869,
-0.0072981799,
0.0294257887,
-0.0280019213,
-0.052009888,
0.0409857184,
-0.0621150583,
-0.0015844628,
0.0244909767,
-0.0258350596,
-0.0741026476,
0.0353803858,
0.0058331094,
0.0009436591,
0.0394698009,
-0.0228857752,
-0.0116941668,
0.0051275953,
-0.024166435,
-0.0282074902,
-0.0402703322,
0.0492702425,
-0.0099114357,
0.0133721484,
-0.0292463228,
0.0073075569,
0.0162913501,
-0.0132303024,
-0.0054234704,
-0.0106212059,
-0.0037093412,
-0.0432291292,
-0.033562351,
0.0096590212,
0.0225967653,
0.0066067358,
0.0001895887,
0.0096369833,
-0.0261042416,
0.0067676599,
0.0345563926,
-0.0094101224,
0.0094105238,
-0.042613484,
0.0083174342,
0.0122096678,
0.0001875001,
-0.0040170583,
-0.0071207904,
0.0053080623,
0.0124676442,
0.0030975172,
-0.0125456061,
0.016663732,
0.0214911643,
0.0121744527,
0.0006311107,
0.0477064215,
-0.0028255293,
-0.0263955742,
0.0411205627,
0.0140295411,
-0.0209931228,
0.0872037187,
-0.1138972789,
-0.0195652489,
0.0076407376,
-0.0010905354,
0.0069722193,
0.0010806927,
0.0074460511,
0.0433747247,
0.0278370436,
-0.0411850587,
0.0226644296,
-0.0294562429,
-0.023244882,
-0.0192029215,
0.0222324152,
0.0327115804,
0.0235059764,
-0.0876030922,
-0.0027708365,
-0.0298281256,
0.0050516301,
0.0453144461,
0.0298893694,
-0.0380102396,
0.0098240897,
-0.00330338,
0.0142484372,
0.0051325834,
0.025191823,
-0.0065786848,
-0.0393878445,
0.0478282198,
-0.0085130697,
-0.0046172771,
0.0024794722,
0.0062329308,
0.0635917112,
0.0206795838,
-0.0015052296,
-0.0467004292,
-0.0490115546,
-0.0086010005,
-0.0107341595,
-0.0210442413,
-0.0248702727,
0.0341351926,
0.0025418885,
0.0250057857,
-0.0800317824,
-0.0081259049,
0.0080339145,
-0.0312505029,
0.0236388706,
-0.0263105705,
0.010842015,
-0.0175505728,
0.0102727935,
0.0480057597,
0.0450351462,
0.0182803236,
-0.0235210899,
0.0128665511,
-0.0051454748,
-0.0057609878,
0.0091517437,
0.0065497188,
-0.0185620636,
0.0025955385,
0.0299026687,
-0.0185131039,
-0.0014318555,
-0.038159214,
0.0433461256,
0.0231784638,
-0.0080263354,
0.010544722,
0.0290841796,
0.0098781306,
-0.0116647808,
0.0331474282,
-0.0375394039,
-0.0193618722,
-0.0251714587,
0.018799413,
-0.0625579134,
-0.0018033923,
-0.014959475,
-0.0047890441,
-0.0345110781,
-0.0278521422,
-0.0160478018,
-0.0408232138,
-0.0166603513,
-0.0174657255,
0.0353986621,
0.0161831807,
-0.0179863181,
-0.0470996201,
0.0810290799,
0.0395583548,
-0.0117310723,
-0.0086616902,
-0.0393530168,
-0.0199335329,
0.0794928968,
0.0303198118,
-0.0206253193,
-0.0123056127,
-0.0293955579,
0.0037459012,
-0.0043019042,
-0.0002207709,
-0.0139305266,
-0.0001770549,
-0.0118300514,
-0.0011711083,
0.0606480315,
0.0351161659,
-0.0069732647,
-0.044860214,
0.0299953036,
-0.0298951603,
-0.0045899381,
-0.0688043088,
0.0713324547,
-0.0380372405,
-0.067953825,
0.0087100463,
-0.0108085806,
0.02449077,
0.0242230576,
0.0227311607,
0.0294101592,
0.0403098054,
-0.041643776,
-0.0194270387,
0.0077246409,
0.033629138,
-0.0174696241,
0.0101612341,
-0.01965026,
0.0281016827,
-0.0200202782,
-0.0487771481,
-0.0034457974,
-0.0243732631,
-0.0502884388,
0.0205359031,
-0.0021882867,
0.0246342309,
0.0169445854,
0.0012327766,
-0.0379517637,
-0.0150897661,
-0.0329665393,
0.0191405248,
-0.030995883,
-0.0858100057,
0.0111764269,
-0.023174461,
0.0118320771,
0.016811233,
-0.0107840626,
0.010508894,
0.0069278837,
0.0067329961,
0.0026524407,
0.0209984239,
-0.0535930581,
-0.0250730496,
0.0040073288,
0.0305463262,
0.0340908356,
0.0179576911,
-0.017911423,
-0.0152932862,
-0.019465439,
-0.0675206482,
0.0175090209,
0.0354129747,
-0.0046376185,
0.0871929973,
0.0054105278,
-0.0353659727,
-0.0279047675,
-0.0557151437,
0.0492058881,
0.0378644355,
-0.064522706,
-0.0483824462,
0.0199167822,
-0.0228114799,
-0.0095701832,
0.0092444234,
-0.0244182125,
0.0066540297,
0.007983366,
0.0005310356,
0.0338760614,
-0.0258978158,
0.0200902335,
0.037008252,
0.0059157936,
-0.0240842383,
0.0061505879,
-0.0634046867,
-0.0692787468,
0.0260275882,
-0.0952753797,
0.0255250726,
0.06423565,
0.0418640003,
-0.000622871,
-0.052953545,
-0.0337355137,
-0.052784998,
0.0068864645,
-0.045841448,
-0.0390034094,
-0.0316905752,
0.0450813808,
0.0320171602,
-0.0316392817,
0.0731116384,
0.007482599,
0.0462313332,
-0.0944395065,
-0.0143533172,
-0.0371875688,
-0.0355804302,
-0.0011928316,
-0.0011916645,
0.0496357828,
-0.0229295529,
0.0530632548,
-0.0251265205,
0.0090675969,
-0.0432638228,
0.0627990961,
-0.0437106714,
0.0462955944,
0.0176503658,
-0.0493276976,
-0.0316305682,
-0.0234687794,
-0.0185136702,
0.0077683828,
0.0111483047,
0.0360912271,
-0.0691185743,
0.0866685733,
-0.0285133645,
0.0431991816,
0.0196804926,
-0.0258752052,
0.0496984273,
-0.0512234196,
0.0484791063,
-0.0535772517,
0.0194899756,
-0.0372168981,
0.027627429,
0.0644098818,
0.0074492013,
0.0144629842,
0.0431032628,
0.0121392803,
0.0023707259,
-0.0394200683,
-0.032951016,
0.0538634397,
0.0019174601,
-0.0528294668,
-0.0047762403,
0.0938105881,
0.0444812253,
-0.06677185,
0.0240211654,
-0.0373642892,
-0.0391866751,
-0.0084714023,
0.0074031726,
-0.0152402874,
-0.0139644109,
-0.0272864457,
0.0551668331,
-0.0430492833,
-0.0334632993,
-0.0073144538,
-0.0368933529,
0.0124819148,
0.0002632423,
-0.0447170325,
-0.0409597233,
-0.0380163565,
0.0005393974,
-0.0208062027,
-0.0089247972,
-0.0243176874,
-0.013718606,
-0.0179191828,
0.0419255383,
-0.1393782794,
-0.0899019837,
0.0217110831,
0.0058629457,
-0.0111098941,
0.0322277844,
-0.0199252013,
-0.0207890216,
0.0153659536,
-0.0032204592,
-0.0457237028,
-0.0033034578,
0.0042527812,
0.071115151,
0.0137911886,
0.0162008125,
-0.0582184605,
0.0204746909,
-0.0490599275,
0.0073789009,
-0.0217669643,
0.0697666109,
-0.051142253,
-0.0101089012,
-0.0403900072,
0.0481503122,
0.0438541844,
0.0350685269,
0.0056306007,
0.0009694852,
-0.0085505228,
0.0024223283,
0.0159464329,
-0.0176584944,
-0.0550501235,
0.0248510446,
-0.0192540623,
-0.0523931123,
-0.0501438268,
-0.0449970514,
0.0632172003,
-0.0111669693,
0.0221999474,
0.0211789981,
0.0303000249,
-0.0319786854,
-0.0088783391,
0.0688621476,
0.0346599594,
0.0474215485,
-0.0657302365,
-0.0381670371,
0.0376875065,
0.0558035821,
-0.0253858957,
0.0442385264,
-0.0163266268,
-0.0362679847,
0.0397104397,
0.0320265777,
0.0290258173,
-0.0357083417,
0.00086516,
-0.030561801,
0.0345065705,
0.0133220674,
-0.0148224514,
-0.0494916923,
-0.0201665834,
-0.010662633,
-0.0047766389,
-0.0008024283,
-0.0482542962,
0.0198965091,
0.0196028277,
0.0465690158,
-0.0018024863,
-0.0027608285,
0.0395455435,
0.0108708721,
0.0218202639,
-0.0172918793,
-0.0404857174,
-0.048309356,
0.0012676395,
-0.0140598025,
0.0240553301,
-0.0002708297,
0.0176093616,
0.0175857898,
-0.020233579,
-0.0369084664,
0.0149084935,
-0.1107258201,
-0.0283961184,
-0.0454418622,
0.0587835573,
0.0135548105,
0.0245418362,
0.0474458896,
-0.0015673771,
-0.0084021967,
-0.0109516978,
0.0114141898,
0.0388539061,
-0.004063589,
0.0507986546,
-0.0416063741,
0.0568511486,
-0.0345397107,
0.0441513062,
-0.0151703442,
-0.0375146605,
-0.0387512557,
0.007217248,
0.042300377,
-0.0234773029,
0.0232554115,
-0.0448015593,
0.0134951845,
-0.0478503332,
0.023305187,
0.0382855088,
0.0303910282,
0.0797769204,
0.0055922098,
-0.0261051171,
-0.0273751915,
0.1142087951,
0.020310713,
0.0296684932,
-0.0407558158,
-0.0451674983,
-0.0124387108,
-0.0337704755,
0.0445887297,
-0.0105546443,
-0.0832466111,
0.0058872839,
-0.0959591493,
-0.0516074672,
0.0185907073,
-0.0328771397,
0.0067959828,
-0.0023511432,
0.046997834,
0.0594765507,
0.0232881662,
-0.0073670978,
-0.0627109408,
0.0401116088,
-0.0003797305,
0.0040468303,
-0.0170748085,
-4.953743314e-33,
-0.0044633024,
-0.0170751158,
-0.0224668849,
0.0044969819,
0.029183777,
0.0106458599,
-0.0223724376,
0.0134649444,
0.0059921048,
0.0582587197,
0.0056256345,
0.009341225,
0.0117412303,
0.0167613626,
0.0247867331,
-0.0438662693,
0.0084826984,
0.0302551445,
0.0146470619,
0.0014436269,
-0.0139206462,
0.0641625151,
0.0274810307,
-0.091985181,
0.0702639297,
0.0092572616,
0.0220772047,
-0.0135912709,
0.0168413967,
0.0943700895,
0.0134772109,
0.0703495443,
0.0429783128,
-0.0259594247,
-0.0021562933,
-0.0189804155,
-0.0032906167,
-0.0264087543,
0.0448334292,
-0.0109462859,
0.0184857138,
-0.0060076485,
0.0642091632,
-0.0025984927,
-0.0457028747,
0.0093802782,
0.0173333474,
-0.0385494269,
-0.0415323228,
-0.053919252,
-0.033863198,
0.0336299427,
-0.007898638,
0.0355814248,
-0.007728992,
0.078875035,
-0.0372662023,
0.0250104126,
-0.0090875654,
-0.013606796,
0.0032461835,
0.0250132401,
-0.0004106028,
-0.0070601082,
-0.0406269766,
0.036973197,
0.0225425474,
0.0305425562,
-0.0075927284,
0.038588725,
-0.0658289641,
0.0049093515,
0.0324032344,
0.0404693969,
-0.0139917927,
-0.023342682,
-0.1088494956,
0.0415649787,
-0.0560419932,
0.039552331,
0.0629493669,
-0.034964107,
-0.0838386491,
-0.0429164767,
-0.0089815026,
0.0529617779,
-0.0155302538,
-0.0129178287,
0.0263839606,
-0.0159966238,
0.0086251441,
0.006772235,
0.001557207,
-0.0185416844,
-0.015158264,
-0.0367011838,
0.0291300789,
0.0139239263,
-0.0200858694,
0.0152959488,
-0.0193956364,
0.0118532749,
0.0002693943,
-0.0017151796,
0.0241737869,
-0.0085790856,
0.035827145,
-0.0100338943,
-0.0463004075,
0.004341898,
0.0309826285,
0.0165422745,
-0.0018107983,
0.069560729,
0.0223971754,
0.055584006,
0.0207403358,
0.0812134445,
0.0134873111,
-0.0599818528,
0.0118308002,
-0.0613218844,
0.0117920246,
0.0379022919,
-0.0688088015,
0.0020942313,
-0.0295510143,
0.0594624653,
0.0714899451,
-0.0366956331,
0.0018754965,
-0.0363759845,
2.543e-7,
0.1319277436,
0.0304981675,
-0.0334373266,
-0.0148290563,
0.0286861733,
-0.0132674742,
0.0100223199,
0.0235008728,
0.0247516129,
0.0175429583,
0.0396002494,
-0.0592067167,
0.0354311019,
0.0435368232,
-0.0640993193,
-0.0309959613,
-0.0575645529,
-0.0273631793,
-0.0426210277,
-0.0037680685,
0.0365377441,
0.0626732036,
-0.0384000652,
-0.0226712413,
0.0011126047,
-0.0352473632,
0.0204385407,
-0.0460152589,
-0.0242522564,
0.0477083325,
0.0362170674,
0.0219250098,
0.0117876139,
0.0767704621,
-0.0387106985,
-0.0113586718,
-0.018675264,
0.0846399963,
-0.0662392229,
0.0189390033,
0.0310368333,
-0.0487195291,
0.0325807966,
-0.0252051968,
0.031231096,
0.0052392571,
-0.0469191298,
0.0407276414,
0.0059494353,
-0.0087392628,
0.0868008435,
-0.0368431471,
-0.0620066747,
0.0507680774,
0.0322656818,
0.0349394865,
-0.0344061963,
-0.0538245216,
0.0068362281,
0.0398634113,
-0.0397704653,
-0.0342610404,
0.062481571,
-0.0076536946,
-0.0259575825,
-0.0433548428,
0.046306137,
2.269248682e-34,
0.0583160073,
0.0421754383,
-0.0074209021,
0.0157316159,
0.058972355,
0.0050084842,
0.0323247835,
-0.0015761347,
0.0133796772,
-0.0534516461,
-0.0167047642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06973v1 | Event-Keyed Summarization | 2024-02-10T15:32:53 | 2024-02-10T15:32:53 | William Gantt, Alexander Martin, Pavlo Kuchmiichuk, Aaron Steven White | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce event-keyed summarization (EKS), a novel task that marries
traditional summarization and document-level event extraction, with the goal of
generating a contextualized summary for a specific event, given a document and
an extracted event structure. We introduce a dataset for this task, MUCSUM,
consisting of summaries of all events in the classic MUC-4 dataset, along with
a set of baselines that comprises both pretrained LM standards in the
summarization literature, as well as larger frontier models. We show that
ablations that reduce EKS to traditional summarization or structure-to-text
yield inferior summaries of target events and that MUCSUM is a robust benchmark
for this task. Lastly, we conduct a human evaluation of both reference and
model summaries, and provide some detailed analysis of the results. | [
-0.0057438328,
0.0007885327,
0.0457018726,
0.0263008662,
-0.0040857806,
0.0341957696,
-0.0275488738,
-0.0132862311,
-0.023027584,
-0.0309304632,
0.0105529251,
0.0022465654,
-0.0109927664,
0.0740711764,
-0.0200239662,
-0.0914208815,
0.0174314454,
0.0071094516,
-0.0218914393,
0.0320673846,
0.0237181019,
0.0108436346,
-0.0161848366,
0.0098067811,
-0.0052194102,
0.0425954275,
-0.0247704275,
-0.0103583643,
0.0629323795,
-0.0563237183,
0.0072127813,
-0.0163485296,
0.054361321,
-0.0136939092,
0.0000018488,
-0.0570202544,
-0.0229675006,
-0.0032938111,
-0.0213532764,
0.0541590825,
0.0167164933,
-0.0514971614,
0.0269724391,
-0.0111428779,
-0.0064704893,
-0.0173559655,
-0.0163236894,
0.0895382911,
0.0353791788,
0.0773706883,
-0.0311498735,
-0.0457684062,
0.0310687963,
-0.033141654,
-0.049972754,
-0.0484729186,
-0.0233617723,
0.0044457396,
-0.0142223909,
-0.0015793729,
0.0104576172,
0.0133419959,
0.0235920064,
0.0233360231,
-0.0008108882,
0.0472464859,
-0.0543422922,
0.0195358787,
0.0374520868,
0.0492456332,
0.0169138443,
0.0146747949,
0.042236954,
0.0071576033,
0.0019464996,
-0.03145371,
-0.0860218853,
0.0556141809,
-0.0038521048,
0.0290025361,
0.0279839616,
0.0560652688,
-0.0084583573,
0.0329068005,
0.0136011234,
-0.0263730008,
-0.0022881825,
0.0093361465,
-0.0510227829,
0.0086848689,
-0.0246455949,
-0.0572143234,
0.0146598183,
0.0548368432,
-0.016599996,
-0.0191583242,
-0.0705139264,
0.006231294,
0.0148336822,
-0.0790632516,
-0.0171187222,
0.0211670753,
0.0212064125,
0.0640737712,
-0.0385630131,
0.0225666463,
0.0211588088,
0.0150447125,
-0.053621769,
-0.0144072045,
-0.0279853381,
0.0486711115,
-0.0218421966,
0.0281031262,
-0.0520348959,
0.011432468,
-0.0251243263,
0.0210242085,
0.0492801443,
-0.0183530189,
-0.0401227698,
0.022627661,
-0.0210760031,
-0.0196483713,
0.0050601116,
-0.0119727617,
-0.0645104423,
-0.0168875773,
0.0191049706,
-0.0003253293,
-0.0331604443,
0.0203543343,
0.0104197795,
-0.0047592409,
0.0076013571,
0.0003023211,
-0.0510602929,
-0.0548566654,
-0.0476595089,
-0.0312734917,
0.0005802814,
-0.0144870272,
-0.0157891866,
-0.0420377143,
0.0036051876,
-0.0166430846,
-0.0334814899,
0.004053317,
0.0000969942,
-0.0291650984,
-0.0442731045,
0.0257746298,
-0.0058129667,
-0.0033987085,
0.03907004,
0.0150869507,
-0.0005177589,
0.0455851778,
0.0596463867,
0.0767038241,
0.0389964841,
0.0498068519,
-0.0201754849,
0.0012282408,
0.034671668,
0.0270311348,
0.0077101528,
-0.0169669837,
-0.0341046304,
-0.0038680176,
0.0882256478,
0.0064382767,
-0.0516798124,
0.0066200714,
0.0563027486,
0.0424264595,
-0.047175169,
0.0043685031,
-0.0050038393,
-0.0044954075,
0.0012061659,
0.0568348169,
-0.026762696,
0.0168658365,
-0.015028419,
0.0587992258,
0.0709562972,
-0.0083168829,
-0.0493771173,
-0.0293725301,
0.0276987907,
-0.0138459764,
0.0046703145,
0.012992382,
0.0296525825,
-0.0050631491,
-0.0290068053,
0.0666497275,
-0.0142157422,
-0.0657726526,
0.0281766374,
-0.0121214716,
-0.0126300436,
0.0003529802,
0.0425254852,
-0.040856909,
-0.0420900472,
0.0057519199,
0.0298885833,
0.0307673663,
0.0446115322,
-0.0261056777,
0.0448166467,
-0.0391380787,
-0.0291719828,
-0.0457296148,
0.0001130028,
-0.0497917719,
-0.0021343788,
-0.0456800945,
0.0267622508,
-0.0107193086,
-0.0318385847,
0.0358580165,
-0.035596665,
-0.0713063404,
-0.0412313081,
-0.0212019179,
-0.0143244034,
0.0150779523,
-0.000502393,
0.0060257218,
0.0539318025,
-0.0543306321,
0.0108361738,
0.035845425,
-0.0261597093,
-0.0376230255,
0.024476992,
-0.0232925862,
-0.0279589202,
0.0504495874,
-0.0609948598,
-0.0666120201,
0.0136598023,
0.004959777,
0.0029051634,
-0.0403489657,
0.0160466749,
0.022487672,
-0.0385750495,
-0.0119454907,
0.0620725751,
-0.0114973625,
-0.0242928695,
0.0053111981,
-0.0208228696,
-0.009636784,
-0.0399087593,
-0.0200198423,
-0.0010324544,
0.0121938549,
-0.0123829711,
0.0397530459,
-0.0130534489,
-0.0271176752,
0.0157276429,
-0.1031410992,
0.0338975824,
-0.0163887683,
0.0411720462,
0.0770251676,
0.04138612,
-0.0139831789,
-0.0180703606,
-0.0289913826,
-0.093668595,
0.0155063039,
0.0100727463,
0.0368948989,
0.049403768,
0.0328413211,
-0.0571163297,
-0.00980628,
-0.0031548999,
0.045490779,
-0.0057114032,
-0.0336224362,
0.0104168644,
0.053359732,
0.0137109952,
-0.0097060846,
-0.0318300836,
0.0147649702,
-0.0025554642,
-0.0068806275,
0.0465371944,
0.0430768952,
0.0381395556,
0.0481749587,
0.0184897892,
-0.0187601689,
-0.0400679819,
-0.0006901018,
-0.0404506586,
0.0289668441,
0.0032307478,
-0.0158162415,
0.0645444468,
0.0464545973,
0.0084962817,
0.0362421349,
-0.0081280451,
-0.0352771543,
-0.0114222141,
-0.0051504471,
-0.0790235251,
-0.0379062705,
-0.0190367419,
0.0162346978,
-0.0434019417,
0.0045571714,
0.0616531521,
-0.0049927398,
0.0098425886,
-0.0206785817,
-0.0002381326,
-0.0733069852,
0.0808388665,
-0.011488637,
0.0235948153,
-0.0165880695,
-0.031579759,
-0.0105786342,
-0.0363333337,
0.0241419803,
-0.0074617853,
0.0808003619,
-0.0439627394,
0.0157273486,
-0.0485596955,
0.0048495089,
-0.0119058751,
-0.029309608,
0.0037666669,
0.0495777614,
-0.0156403221,
0.0490796529,
-0.0576562956,
0.0299708918,
0.0142648378,
0.0695796162,
-0.0285856072,
-0.0077635399,
0.0050845691,
0.1044773236,
0.0569265224,
-0.0012502158,
0.0221223962,
-0.0313915089,
0.0031752989,
0.0663539767,
0.0591014139,
0.0011367397,
-0.0012697555,
-0.0067761159,
-0.0345563889,
-0.0778976306,
0.0076906416,
-0.0222205315,
0.0492094308,
-0.0599996224,
0.0094018262,
0.0956767201,
0.0237240791,
-0.0147460438,
-0.0150057003,
0.0307880975,
0.0184492599,
0.0025589711,
-0.0302755032,
-0.0557305291,
-0.0118625406,
-0.0127839642,
0.027067503,
0.0399795063,
-0.0399743319,
0.0103308307,
-0.0349771045,
-0.0075607486,
0.0111825382,
-0.0685481131,
-0.076296851,
-0.0474075563,
0.0238997191,
-0.0331868455,
0.0237202682,
0.0444732904,
-0.0127290897,
-0.013244058,
0.013148346,
-0.0807554349,
-0.0374183431,
-0.002187531,
-0.054053966,
-0.0105293756,
0.0294099599,
0.0219471026,
-0.0022925267,
0.0679833367,
0.0566796809,
-0.0142179355,
-0.0121470429,
0.0205807071,
0.0722147375,
-0.0160265658,
0.0118724341,
-0.021743672,
0.0546546057,
-0.00311022,
-0.039298933,
-0.0150052654,
0.0017266286,
-0.0063515957,
0.0048616868,
-0.0301271342,
0.0048616533,
-0.0348937437,
0.0717036873,
0.031958241,
0.0349840075,
-0.0155824814,
-0.003465926,
0.0124819493,
-0.0819425508,
-0.0051688631,
0.0061255228,
-0.038084019,
-0.016260935,
-0.0622503422,
-0.076553449,
0.0169558246,
-0.0410573035,
-0.0607105829,
-0.0191313867,
-0.0059406282,
0.0009853459,
-0.0471902676,
0.0731736049,
-0.0349594764,
-0.010239779,
-0.0044424185,
-0.0069843284,
0.0123745576,
0.0200549085,
-0.0087135416,
0.0858472362,
-0.0325379297,
-0.0169653054,
0.000990758,
0.0271154195,
0.0171483047,
0.0536800995,
0.0331790298,
0.0026435927,
0.027609244,
-0.0134561295,
0.0119151445,
0.0275963861,
0.0109828738,
0.021583613,
-0.0394132361,
0.0030291674,
-0.0454234742,
0.0560333394,
-0.0462282225,
0.0611791052,
-0.0538390726,
-0.0428373739,
-0.0078984424,
0.0004752256,
0.0269755758,
-0.0362233333,
-0.0218573753,
-0.0289123859,
-0.0478783622,
-0.0204065815,
0.0102661131,
-0.0172629468,
0.0368300006,
-0.0374395475,
0.0181503408,
-0.0018484087,
0.0619004816,
-0.0342640914,
0.0273552425,
-0.0656497777,
-0.0057082213,
0.0139635568,
-0.0227674264,
-0.0542560481,
0.0280141793,
-0.0559849069,
-0.0033656831,
-0.0333742499,
-0.0012907685,
-0.0293173976,
-0.0158607382,
0.0161230043,
0.0218040626,
-0.0131989196,
0.0167410299,
-0.0906231403,
0.0695394948,
-0.0622959696,
-0.0276828408,
0.0650071055,
-0.0551323853,
0.0457072593,
-0.000857452,
0.0026615958,
-0.015946392,
0.0213877857,
0.0302659031,
0.0233063698,
-0.031606026,
0.0241620205,
0.022339033,
0.0199656989,
0.0692938864,
-0.0204366203,
0.060419485,
0.031586349,
-0.0142495912,
-0.0264121573,
-0.0492000468,
0.031606745,
0.0497540571,
-0.0051737921,
-0.0468200073,
-0.0497753695,
0.0289440788,
0.0689017922,
0.0231730286,
0.0045176921,
-0.0433335006,
0.0373269208,
-0.0042857332,
0.0314819217,
-0.0062055569,
-0.0090090968,
0.0257771015,
-0.0192485116,
-0.0097480854,
-0.0441873781,
-5.761889068e-33,
-0.0447371453,
-0.010518319,
-0.0083246427,
0.0520854592,
-0.0331853032,
0.0418138914,
-0.064846918,
-0.0111535182,
0.0040082019,
-0.0257565565,
-0.0109190168,
0.0028406838,
0.016248798,
0.011270781,
-0.0192832164,
0.0014423076,
0.0519949421,
-0.0108046839,
-0.0286896527,
0.0551627874,
0.0404755287,
0.0050368668,
0.0360739566,
-0.0417895168,
0.0375929065,
-0.0184438415,
-0.0226778165,
-0.02706635,
0.1079977751,
0.0280061904,
-0.0168015286,
-0.0075398823,
0.055863928,
-0.0492154509,
-0.0564493313,
0.0016876874,
-0.082980305,
-0.0038385973,
0.0117871929,
-0.0297315549,
-0.0265244152,
-0.0374747328,
0.0286642797,
-0.0116647268,
0.0240338035,
-0.0513477959,
0.0261309594,
-0.0360803269,
-0.0530208163,
-0.0993940085,
-0.0185384657,
0.0357270576,
-0.0204082746,
-0.0352446958,
0.0315696932,
0.0077309967,
0.0125514157,
-0.0096688597,
-0.0100489808,
0.0165811777,
0.0132404352,
0.0322772227,
0.0025747116,
0.0294450019,
-0.028440088,
0.0562439263,
-0.0217332691,
-0.0085436637,
-0.0435514674,
0.0583522283,
0.0022248523,
0.0319384895,
0.0112018669,
0.0541114397,
0.0309522264,
0.0456370339,
-0.0495849885,
0.1267903,
-0.0036975546,
0.0048972019,
-0.0051556327,
0.0353024527,
0.009905396,
0.0006617065,
-0.0248808358,
0.0398160405,
-0.0138813071,
0.036265824,
-0.0153893298,
0.0274238158,
-0.002963993,
0.0268489141,
0.0242694579,
-0.0014525919,
0.0472934544,
0.0152617758,
0.0095992777,
0.0227559749,
0.0009083159,
-0.0380789861,
-0.0215407014,
0.0139658339,
0.0577954911,
-0.0125988303,
0.015134844,
-0.0197010897,
0.0167811848,
0.0158750657,
0.0040962906,
0.0050811991,
0.0268963873,
-0.0023383112,
-0.0411561839,
0.0192846544,
-0.0229875352,
0.0029578216,
0.00330355,
0.0410314575,
-0.0309273358,
0.0366969965,
0.0132613676,
-0.017171612,
0.0216328595,
0.0508045368,
0.0215893872,
0.039990034,
-0.0183275379,
0.0212595258,
0.0355414003,
-0.014496495,
-0.0179693904,
0.0001499333,
2.285e-7,
0.0577615127,
0.0159350578,
0.0950707123,
0.0220348928,
-0.0413182527,
0.0342535786,
-0.0046582534,
0.0341320001,
0.0174312554,
-0.0000618246,
0.0245872308,
0.0553554632,
0.0421509147,
0.057954777,
-0.0432113893,
-0.0527893715,
-0.0706863031,
-0.0154258469,
-0.0286782943,
-0.0172208454,
0.0642784685,
0.0380388051,
-0.0134733794,
-0.0193332154,
-0.0075005912,
-0.020664053,
0.0562641583,
-0.0165931098,
-0.0893664733,
0.0028574646,
-0.0129043953,
0.0114769721,
-0.0616230108,
0.0064249141,
-0.008016129,
-0.0113531779,
0.0366200358,
0.0636694804,
-0.0032135984,
-0.0472436585,
0.0066473014,
-0.0091125742,
0.0166648477,
0.0032063941,
0.0557076968,
-0.0497650616,
0.0056187641,
-0.0199379288,
-0.0506472103,
0.0800748095,
-0.0532530621,
0.0119343242,
-0.0675765947,
0.0541344434,
0.000069999,
-0.0113333017,
-0.0060600904,
-0.0927923396,
-0.0441289432,
0.0479718708,
0.0022402233,
-0.0148904026,
-0.009797819,
-0.0268952753,
-0.000972891,
-0.05902927,
-0.0052225622,
1.998173715e-34,
0.0619627237,
0.0235289112,
-0.0495272167,
-0.0194713809,
0.0125816828,
-0.0180441868,
-0.0224730242,
-0.0101208901,
0.0199141726,
-0.0522064418,
0.003381551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06967v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06967v2 | Instruct Once, Chat Consistently in Multiple Rounds: An Efficient Tuning Framework for Dialogue | 2024-02-10T14:52:52 | 2024-05-30T04:57:36 | Jian Wang, Chak Tou Leong, Jiashuo Wang, Dongding Lin, Wenjie Li, Xiao-Yong Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tuning language models for dialogue generation has been a prevalent paradigm
for building capable dialogue agents. Yet, traditional tuning narrowly views
dialogue generation as resembling other language generation tasks, ignoring the
role disparities between two speakers and the multi-round interactive process
that dialogues ought to be. Such a manner often leads to unsatisfactory chat
consistency for the built agent. In this work, we emphasize the interactive,
communicative nature of dialogue and argue that it is more feasible to model
the speaker roles of agent and user separately, enabling the agent to adhere to
its role consistently. With this in mind, we propose an efficient Multi-round
Interactive Dialogue Tuning (Midi-Tuning) framework. It models the agent and
user individually with two adapters built upon large language models. The
adapters make use of respective utterances round by round in alternating order
and they are tuned via a round-level memory caching mechanism. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that, our framework performs superior to traditional
fine-tuning and harbors the tremendous potential for improving dialogue
consistency. | [
0.0697162524,
0.0114886928,
-0.0358715095,
0.0216366556,
-0.0193503797,
-0.0085455058,
0.0216941498,
-0.0232624114,
0.0116793355,
-0.0047772685,
-0.0534556359,
-0.0470411889,
-0.0091094598,
0.0518274531,
-0.0034286983,
-0.0876093432,
0.0606948175,
-0.0104056709,
0.0050810855,
0.0054396782,
0.006491831,
-0.0071425471,
-0.0434120931,
0.0522546321,
-0.0405136012,
-0.0042256401,
-0.0756196082,
0.0250294954,
0.0015514632,
0.0477068461,
0.0008829646,
0.0300272275,
0.0084075276,
0.0150303263,
0.0000018668,
-0.0303123407,
0.0048289113,
-0.0469928421,
-0.0069344374,
0.0031849944,
0.0436573215,
0.0372373536,
-0.0378450304,
0.0472550392,
-0.0323338583,
0.0042785131,
0.0702873021,
-0.0068183253,
0.1114808396,
0.0906830356,
0.0036305583,
0.0081265531,
-0.0086169252,
-0.0035009258,
0.0111067658,
-0.067445606,
-0.0352785513,
0.0281010494,
0.026103422,
-0.0014883744,
-0.0285345707,
0.0248239469,
0.0257768072,
-0.0484765656,
-0.0104850214,
0.0056903451,
-0.0484939031,
-0.0373093598,
-0.0509870313,
0.0399417803,
0.0415743478,
0.0044967523,
0.0207547192,
0.0010486342,
0.0270188358,
-0.0172567833,
-0.0067873532,
0.01476439,
-0.0170137994,
-0.0238696337,
-0.0226021372,
0.0028541326,
-0.0294210874,
0.005880883,
-0.0291795135,
0.026241703,
0.0005716196,
-0.0125953006,
-0.0560207553,
-0.0297232848,
0.0061135041,
-0.0781579986,
0.0127793085,
0.0549565293,
-0.1052809879,
0.0369685404,
-0.0711128712,
0.0587220676,
0.0005015009,
-0.0548430979,
-0.0176740754,
0.0683279932,
0.0278887786,
0.0256076697,
0.0395563468,
0.0525333881,
0.0278161988,
-0.0079551218,
-0.0147530586,
0.0000130942,
-0.0331137069,
-0.0339916088,
-0.0852398202,
-0.0049086884,
-0.0358216986,
-0.0549931824,
-0.0250703711,
0.095543474,
0.0151682058,
0.0228918791,
0.0227292944,
-0.0068621342,
-0.0544640906,
0.0211766716,
-0.0015155227,
0.0231608842,
-0.0571566522,
-0.0094307298,
0.0589505136,
-0.0718576759,
-0.0128373234,
0.028683668,
-0.0023581465,
0.0017395198,
-0.0188341495,
0.0751534402,
-0.0392355397,
0.0100880023,
0.0359623693,
-0.0413114578,
-0.0076009557,
-0.0771765411,
-0.0481756628,
-0.0135680111,
0.0307513978,
-0.0155317457,
-0.0202524979,
-0.0276746005,
-0.0081653846,
0.0113371164,
0.0060615838,
0.040738564,
-0.0031683787,
0.0312037189,
0.0327742361,
0.0276828371,
-0.0052929623,
0.0562974699,
0.0712482408,
-0.0061015124,
0.0300599337,
-0.0200380702,
0.0103766331,
0.040511243,
-0.0124231381,
-0.0196068939,
0.0344257727,
0.0135514131,
0.0028607426,
0.0474016778,
0.0012263823,
0.054223869,
-0.0429159701,
-0.0087612486,
0.0519855544,
0.0162824392,
0.033199884,
0.0132917631,
0.0477908216,
0.0452504307,
-0.0103476876,
0.0419859961,
-0.0203639939,
0.0470920838,
0.0248548239,
0.0014200419,
0.052694086,
0.0043497789,
-0.0363011323,
-0.0370118879,
0.0370301381,
0.0085762814,
0.0205089543,
-0.0207702722,
-0.0038548366,
0.0172548685,
-0.0501047932,
0.0771935135,
0.0140046468,
-0.0571256168,
-0.0242692735,
-0.0279018749,
-0.0284913909,
0.0946526527,
0.043498069,
-0.008245022,
-0.0615072586,
0.0071617519,
0.0015895132,
0.0817180052,
0.0506110527,
-0.0169271212,
0.0252696332,
-0.0464505814,
0.010900422,
0.0056133713,
-0.0186777525,
0.048005946,
0.0172180124,
0.0005586051,
-0.0141814314,
0.0305275079,
0.0436980911,
-0.0141292186,
-0.0041773315,
-0.0035829458,
0.0027359386,
0.0007798981,
0.0479987748,
-0.0023894552,
-0.0371375643,
-0.0033432841,
0.0052864021,
0.0170700252,
0.0223489217,
0.0585316978,
-0.0828155652,
-0.0268331338,
0.0250073951,
0.0297672637,
0.0119765028,
-0.0196525641,
-0.0176541898,
-0.0511341132,
0.0442410856,
-0.0428024307,
0.0348758325,
-0.0177205857,
0.0340134352,
-0.0145298652,
0.0060484996,
0.0050782156,
-0.0095648905,
0.0063210321,
-0.0284834038,
0.0452723354,
0.0788235292,
-0.0220782813,
-0.0566793568,
0.0064170198,
0.0390107706,
0.0008172571,
0.0099076889,
0.0198337156,
0.0235223025,
-0.0246148761,
-0.0697576255,
-0.1108811349,
0.0325226672,
-0.0103900936,
-0.0343890414,
0.0059155435,
0.0408243872,
-0.0103914505,
-0.0076201069,
-0.0471058935,
-0.0007785619,
0.055696249,
0.0125822099,
0.010554241,
0.0054411995,
-0.0599077046,
-0.0352516063,
0.0246189926,
0.0128670475,
-0.0175071899,
-0.002681657,
-0.0010806521,
-0.0548103377,
0.0080881277,
-0.0459251329,
0.045763351,
-0.0121085113,
-0.0655543879,
0.0295773465,
0.0315304734,
0.0140834888,
0.0602680035,
0.0498394072,
0.043112535,
0.0081835063,
-0.0311167855,
-0.067313388,
0.0560019724,
-0.0005584006,
-0.0251527354,
-0.0329669788,
-0.0072206827,
0.0311115235,
0.0450074524,
0.021037247,
0.0455515683,
-0.0527960062,
0.0439985581,
0.0308431908,
-0.0427124649,
0.0187310558,
-0.0118765784,
-0.0509009585,
0.0213121809,
-0.0256968848,
-0.0405997969,
0.0726861954,
-0.0288733318,
-0.0354797058,
-0.0255034622,
-0.0068364656,
-0.0147142624,
0.0469676256,
-0.0196396559,
0.0171056241,
0.0055465475,
-0.0042749844,
-0.0282498803,
-0.0180273652,
0.0510459319,
-0.0350801833,
-0.0062031937,
-0.0407569744,
-0.0050133816,
0.0086027049,
-0.0530181527,
-0.0423196554,
-0.0208353419,
0.0039090598,
0.0037030929,
0.0288867187,
-0.0481321923,
-0.0505785905,
0.046355702,
0.0146060381,
0.0197033286,
-0.0036492501,
0.0124638323,
-0.0362650305,
-0.0059374608,
0.0339644141,
0.0328188799,
-0.0354118273,
-0.0119323926,
0.0684638321,
0.0230742302,
-0.0179354642,
-0.0099172276,
0.0158589687,
-0.0016914073,
0.0143875331,
-0.0096557196,
-0.0132932616,
0.0359848589,
0.0740635917,
-0.0249311719,
-0.0395555981,
0.1179619655,
0.0267633852,
-0.0399421863,
0.0053430367,
-0.0070673474,
0.0679740161,
-0.0030318717,
0.050040666,
-0.107197471,
-0.0154953748,
0.0081051905,
0.0082113352,
-0.0318038128,
-0.0097849155,
-0.0445494764,
-0.0953953639,
0.0430971943,
0.0223064777,
-0.0511971414,
0.0118061239,
-0.0098390179,
-0.0105508594,
0.0025806616,
0.0639351234,
0.0326754041,
0.0169591662,
-0.0071429806,
-0.0069217463,
-0.005960668,
-0.003390335,
0.0082119899,
-0.0343897156,
0.1033011898,
0.0486283265,
0.0356635638,
0.04562594,
0.0106748538,
-0.0142091457,
0.0422810316,
0.0190039519,
-0.0027083417,
0.0050159935,
-0.0109040085,
-0.0214293133,
-0.0244887788,
0.013008886,
0.0001972276,
0.0035111522,
0.0238829385,
0.0015078827,
-0.0498407222,
0.0279480089,
-0.0065778415,
0.0614203364,
0.0438779257,
0.0523776338,
0.033892151,
-0.0680788755,
-0.0296188705,
-0.025065098,
-0.0085140215,
-0.0604435317,
-0.0486782305,
-0.0192720313,
-0.0011698708,
-0.0234161057,
-0.0568338148,
-0.0377221033,
-0.0008807473,
0.0273505021,
-0.0158346854,
-0.0161933266,
0.0084810862,
0.0039745062,
-0.0089276107,
-0.0375599004,
-0.0152312424,
-0.0027710446,
-0.0511185229,
-0.061116185,
0.0309210122,
-0.0602067299,
0.0082090003,
0.0489590801,
-0.0429513417,
-0.0692546517,
0.0019993451,
0.0632997528,
0.0283728447,
0.0755132288,
-0.0067017069,
-0.0199487433,
-0.036826998,
0.0218516067,
-0.0206063762,
0.0302610453,
0.0211647339,
0.0581627674,
-0.0005153603,
0.0415638573,
-0.0480643585,
0.0125653185,
-0.0156153068,
0.0265098196,
-0.0315886773,
-0.0771114752,
0.0069797002,
0.0022865834,
-0.0163332,
0.0155364145,
-0.0079792812,
0.0222354364,
0.0456968881,
-0.0499960408,
-0.0329709202,
-0.0483825281,
0.0053279549,
-0.0501772426,
-0.0092801722,
0.0112882871,
-0.0323538519,
-0.0332790241,
0.0188050866,
0.0166916102,
-0.0138866249,
-0.0057760729,
-0.038096115,
0.0151812406,
0.0097087407,
-0.0097462414,
0.0275525786,
0.0200027842,
0.0306902248,
-0.0055608558,
0.0680396855,
0.003444538,
-0.0414572135,
-0.0069899727,
0.0389843844,
-0.0715675354,
-0.0347807929,
0.0195013154,
0.0422080047,
0.05238837,
0.0332285352,
0.0296594389,
-0.0281191189,
0.0282989312,
-0.0004597865,
0.0471906103,
0.0443080589,
-0.0539408065,
-0.0113483388,
0.0135412654,
-0.0100713074,
-0.0075744083,
0.0417355336,
-0.0443691649,
0.0311456714,
-0.027968904,
0.0002555523,
-0.0580745749,
-0.0254144464,
-0.0463364795,
0.0134570887,
0.0080837691,
-0.0122737493,
-0.035810601,
-0.0160346404,
-0.0228606965,
0.0314484052,
0.0172153618,
-0.0269171558,
0.0352856256,
0.0266365279,
-0.0012027004,
-0.0007285705,
-0.040469449,
-0.0221966468,
-0.0416724756,
-0.0070139067,
-0.0149441296,
-5.769029829e-33,
-0.0740187839,
-0.0033880293,
0.0461054035,
0.0205926858,
-0.055365596,
-0.0564625338,
-0.0732337013,
-0.0012012323,
-0.0234275423,
-0.0351654738,
-0.0212841406,
0.0179295596,
0.0214661937,
-0.0008026407,
0.0065417145,
0.0192598384,
0.0644573718,
0.0230296534,
-0.0621396489,
0.0588843599,
0.0382520892,
-0.0106330272,
-0.0217656381,
-0.0282180533,
-0.0245131925,
-0.0079329731,
-0.0320297182,
0.035483703,
-0.0203600638,
0.0328631289,
0.0342046581,
0.0194572955,
-0.0042418572,
-0.0038232787,
-0.0172579736,
0.0294346083,
-0.0157753099,
-0.0243020393,
0.0334424563,
0.0397134088,
0.0056488309,
-0.0418890417,
-0.0052539594,
-0.0132823316,
-0.0207616892,
0.0090728477,
0.0005654541,
-0.0044383998,
-0.025776824,
0.0036015161,
-0.0609012619,
0.0086849453,
-0.0264453199,
-0.0817745477,
-0.0335675068,
0.0435480177,
-0.0067567541,
-0.0719552189,
-0.0159339886,
0.0400715247,
0.003705313,
0.0234810375,
0.0265660621,
0.073814854,
0.021586746,
0.0702807307,
0.0732105747,
0.0371721424,
-0.0196347237,
-0.0065543335,
-0.0095455786,
0.0205216352,
0.0002969223,
0.0382758677,
-0.0186682772,
-0.0258591697,
0.0001368211,
-0.0016392983,
0.0601148643,
0.0423036329,
0.0096472334,
0.0393972956,
-0.0391100235,
-0.0121887848,
-0.0504662022,
0.0067870133,
-0.0187495742,
-0.072875306,
0.0309052989,
0.0211231764,
-0.0098261777,
-0.0376144946,
0.0529920533,
-0.0094105592,
0.0381749421,
-0.0044069025,
-0.0474434644,
0.0280756131,
-0.0381575152,
0.0096385842,
0.0018463123,
-0.0451366417,
0.0590097532,
0.0221345965,
0.026453374,
0.0516748838,
-0.0253419057,
0.0380471349,
-0.0333145559,
0.0138502754,
-0.0447651371,
0.052799508,
-0.0182660893,
-0.0026795117,
-0.0066664745,
-0.001396267,
-0.0598479509,
0.0609961338,
-0.0335410945,
-0.066132322,
-0.0321768634,
-0.0281858202,
0.0128756482,
0.0099846227,
-0.0490797423,
0.0393084548,
-0.041917108,
-0.0016813731,
0.0048421719,
-0.0557416379,
-0.0106385462,
-0.0339703523,
2.775e-7,
-0.0493561365,
0.0168878511,
0.0337993726,
0.0369522907,
0.0362970009,
0.0054463111,
-0.0042423732,
0.0322877765,
0.0142696975,
0.0150354011,
0.0086208498,
0.0387281924,
0.0542547964,
0.0129779363,
-0.088664189,
-0.0205442011,
-0.1050411016,
-0.0193530917,
-0.0203401279,
-0.0043922905,
0.0460151881,
0.0572961643,
0.0107192565,
0.0145507455,
0.0148306498,
-0.0282446109,
0.0324065536,
-0.0301094148,
-0.006140634,
0.035969276,
-0.0246403348,
-0.0016906604,
-0.003163778,
0.0178486723,
-0.0058416757,
0.0334889442,
-0.0553540215,
0.0781693459,
0.0001521514,
-0.0424440205,
0.0061793006,
0.0240531266,
-0.029232597,
-0.0083796903,
0.0159604643,
-0.0365980268,
-0.0097022066,
-0.0110227661,
-0.0050149267,
-0.0119722765,
-0.005625437,
-0.0300047528,
-0.0484374128,
0.0295057353,
-0.0057477546,
0.0069016949,
0.0366494581,
-0.0403438434,
-0.0273290705,
-0.0197651144,
-0.0661936998,
-0.05908335,
-0.0151438089,
-0.0401211642,
0.0176916998,
-0.0222832225,
0.0046469597,
2.127162179e-34,
0.0340656526,
0.000439403,
0.0360439494,
0.0485701598,
0.0542336069,
0.0106546031,
0.0530779585,
0.0248424858,
0.0775679424,
-0.0602870695,
-0.0544700623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06964v1 | NLP for Knowledge Discovery and Information Extraction from Energetics Corpora | 2024-02-10T14:43:08 | 2024-02-10T14:43:08 | Francis G. VanGessel, Efrem Perry, Salil Mohan, Oliver M. Barham, Mark Cavolowsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci | We present a demonstration of the utility of NLP for aiding research into
energetic materials and associated systems. The NLP method enables machine
understanding of textual data, offering an automated route to knowledge
discovery and information extraction from energetics text. We apply three
established unsupervised NLP models: Latent Dirichlet Allocation, Word2Vec, and
the Transformer to a large curated dataset of energetics-related scientific
articles. We demonstrate that each NLP algorithm is capable of identifying
energetic topics and concepts, generating a language model which aligns with
Subject Matter Expert knowledge. Furthermore, we present a document
classification pipeline for energetics text. Our classification pipeline
achieves 59-76\% accuracy depending on the NLP model used, with the highest
performing Transformer model rivaling inter-annotator agreement metrics. The
NLP approaches studied in this work can identify concepts germane to energetics
and therefore hold promise as a tool for accelerating energetics research
efforts and energetics material development. | [
0.0493404157,
0.0655646846,
-0.010098666,
0.031872537,
0.0025068931,
0.0082320282,
-0.0421860032,
0.0309177842,
-0.0042503932,
-0.0328550637,
-0.0285098068,
0.0405447632,
-0.024577342,
0.0453173406,
0.0188574214,
-0.009404541,
0.0760546401,
-0.0233308636,
0.0820345581,
0.0057604066,
0.0127655482,
-0.0310848132,
-0.0189260077,
0.0071507739,
-0.0006473792,
0.0485667512,
0.0078564184,
-0.0033632184,
0.0291413814,
-0.0536199138,
0.041728545,
0.0228592698,
0.0085794143,
0.0191279668,
0.0000020858,
-0.0480427817,
-0.0698425099,
0.0243159905,
0.0525884144,
-0.0219608359,
0.0936193317,
-0.0700566694,
-0.0030518884,
-0.0026833685,
0.001094304,
-0.0530148782,
0.053277038,
0.0299747009,
0.0504987352,
-0.0106100123,
-0.037175402,
-0.0160740726,
0.0273126792,
0.0094284303,
0.0167876072,
0.0161275472,
0.0294686481,
0.0149018746,
-0.0292211995,
0.0323727988,
0.0139946546,
0.0613447353,
-0.0668162033,
-0.0250271093,
0.0999331474,
0.0260073356,
-0.0777473748,
-0.0058060954,
0.0070125088,
0.0437968932,
0.0231574904,
-0.0439286977,
0.000604541,
-0.0109753152,
-0.0747424811,
0.07009767,
-0.0134523641,
0.0186213274,
-0.0084686242,
0.0142901363,
0.0411831401,
0.0124978479,
-0.0039148582,
-0.0083042132,
-0.0007795566,
0.0728742108,
-0.0121230995,
-0.0302601196,
0.048037339,
0.055080805,
-0.0045805308,
-0.0145333381,
0.0042240648,
-0.0318902805,
0.0537757389,
0.0478567071,
0.0190187562,
-0.038051296,
0.0555046611,
-0.0698854402,
0.009768608,
-0.000667838,
0.0536537319,
0.0155688776,
-0.0464704446,
-0.0416543111,
0.0246695187,
-0.0046600932,
-0.0576268472,
-0.0258423258,
-0.0717316568,
-0.0341800302,
-0.0439055711,
-0.0124616884,
-0.0084201712,
-0.0343106762,
-0.0123435156,
-0.0051889159,
-0.0143305724,
0.02490348,
-0.0034132863,
-0.0003092188,
-0.0027467555,
-0.0001335935,
-0.0075728814,
0.0298722629,
-0.0078715989,
0.0377467573,
-0.01407158,
-0.0056470833,
-0.013836897,
0.0400388949,
-0.0212209895,
-0.0006479042,
-0.0477086082,
0.0659636557,
-0.0047419006,
-0.0711440742,
-0.0384669155,
-0.0315582827,
0.03129109,
0.0153395217,
0.0367174298,
-0.0224744882,
0.0545116477,
0.064055182,
0.0248524249,
-0.0255678911,
0.0060064206,
0.0063060089,
-0.0171253607,
0.078816615,
-0.0482743979,
-0.0291016959,
0.047526177,
-0.0068745469,
0.003022064,
0.0127401855,
0.0520324148,
-0.0137722241,
0.0242332164,
-0.006401238,
-0.0278397631,
-0.0120004192,
0.0118776709,
-0.0384066887,
0.0143815586,
-0.0033689348,
0.0007637657,
-0.0026106893,
0.0149698909,
-0.0055281273,
-0.0190921109,
0.0257786997,
0.0256559458,
0.0167501699,
0.0084534679,
-0.0008456585,
-0.0279434621,
0.0335373133,
0.0242449287,
-0.0438873805,
0.04175831,
0.032505136,
-0.0321168602,
-0.0600380339,
0.0465374291,
0.0070903492,
0.0222536735,
-0.0454919077,
-0.0434982516,
-0.0191106517,
0.0240028556,
-0.0681105405,
0.0414250344,
0.0017017749,
0.0045536081,
0.0878849849,
0.0468825214,
-0.0221282225,
-0.0299029648,
0.0311564188,
-0.008242147,
0.0345056765,
0.0048485608,
-0.0428574868,
-0.0140150357,
-0.0216976013,
-0.046203509,
-0.0180888474,
-0.0245795753,
-0.0306659266,
-0.0228121933,
-0.0060061463,
-0.0401244164,
-0.0832938701,
0.004199673,
-0.0189328063,
-0.0260664318,
0.0109677156,
-0.0281653069,
-0.0600979216,
-0.0261999462,
0.0260267444,
-0.0259536989,
0.0014237083,
0.0177412592,
-0.001665253,
0.003790607,
0.0057088076,
0.0170658231,
0.0226564687,
0.0664771497,
-0.0715118721,
-0.0736022741,
-0.0278382935,
0.0251592677,
0.0178760812,
0.0017016195,
-0.024283329,
0.051207751,
-0.0465614274,
0.0210537203,
-0.0033206386,
0.0018007017,
-0.0169666745,
-0.0115665076,
-0.0154771255,
0.0051765228,
0.0209415872,
0.0690494254,
-0.0226827059,
0.0545014776,
0.0042219865,
0.0289528109,
0.023978807,
-0.0079196719,
0.0711959675,
0.0243845768,
-0.0048364634,
0.0071895993,
0.013319592,
-0.0221009497,
0.0470621102,
-0.0575700887,
0.0025814513,
-0.0001587475,
-0.0090285819,
0.0168709606,
-0.0046371687,
0.0500728488,
0.012512736,
-0.0160668064,
-0.0070991055,
-0.0129348151,
0.0266750082,
0.0249811392,
-0.0248176008,
-0.073658891,
0.0779486746,
0.0089116069,
-0.0020991119,
-0.0307519026,
-0.0253380928,
-0.0270428639,
0.0685068294,
0.0257768277,
-0.0167915337,
-0.0668646172,
0.0298397224,
0.0584660321,
0.0260632075,
-0.0225823764,
-0.0114832064,
-0.0153226294,
0.0145101482,
0.0137317507,
0.0030924028,
0.0496447198,
0.0486266613,
0.038928166,
0.0020339193,
-0.0115860542,
-0.0160741564,
-0.0137399463,
0.0500329174,
0.0156517494,
-0.0224443674,
0.0622354448,
0.0457603075,
-0.0241758432,
0.0309885871,
0.0364155322,
0.029366944,
-0.0246882606,
-0.0364796668,
-0.0010600239,
0.0086229425,
0.0238511991,
0.0062603438,
0.0309501234,
-0.0186143946,
0.0746142343,
-0.0379810072,
0.0093959216,
-0.102960676,
-0.0396975093,
-0.008759005,
-0.0053939265,
0.0270626675,
0.0286169238,
0.0336564071,
0.0354510434,
0.027594924,
-0.0296422131,
0.0089709908,
0.0290643144,
0.0118696382,
0.0066078161,
0.0300669037,
-0.0164162237,
-0.0075019957,
-0.0213187188,
-0.0151447644,
0.0121776806,
0.0741102695,
0.0634403899,
-0.0648387447,
-0.0476361997,
0.0058273654,
0.0663072839,
-0.0116570555,
-0.0137615483,
-0.0283791181,
-0.047999464,
0.0870479941,
0.0488999337,
-0.0444102846,
0.0445171446,
0.0060795327,
0.0360910408,
0.0856701285,
-0.0568819344,
-0.0111439172,
-0.0766972601,
-0.0026049151,
0.022149412,
-0.0261688344,
0.0272596404,
-0.0458619706,
0.019544933,
-0.0248244721,
-0.007947091,
0.0593106858,
0.015743902,
-0.0382488184,
0.0199863445,
0.0727007687,
-0.0345458575,
0.0023372921,
0.0252725501,
-0.0696505383,
0.0046342011,
-0.0164919943,
0.0325915404,
0.015428436,
-0.022906201,
-0.0277805682,
-0.0658608377,
0.0325982049,
-0.0340856276,
-0.0080246441,
-0.0028715199,
-0.0953429639,
0.0141208014,
-0.0177812334,
-0.0676015839,
0.0009966341,
-0.0305412505,
-0.0280288979,
0.0205053166,
-0.0311388373,
-0.0635540113,
-0.0001495478,
-0.0403200276,
0.0211430639,
0.0236450322,
0.0522351041,
-0.0417676754,
-0.0175885521,
-0.0203695036,
-0.0588948354,
-0.0127827832,
-0.0439166278,
0.0157791246,
-0.0147401886,
-0.0023733785,
0.0373463742,
0.0471277274,
-0.0442413092,
-0.0543493256,
0.0349770226,
0.0988271534,
-0.0467990898,
0.0041352347,
-0.0662017092,
-0.0215566531,
0.0462540984,
0.0604859926,
-0.0438022576,
-0.0146883195,
-0.0493336432,
0.0080434838,
0.0017693023,
-0.0298025105,
0.0268003792,
-0.0105653666,
-0.0312077887,
-0.0309518855,
-0.0247023627,
-0.0165824965,
0.0031958753,
-0.0316433273,
-0.0202770419,
0.0227123983,
0.0090544345,
-0.0098729338,
-0.0632994995,
0.0119186519,
0.0134544289,
0.0419816747,
-0.0043085683,
-0.1182174161,
0.0474109277,
-0.0008409293,
-0.0011615314,
0.0321059823,
-0.0474259332,
-0.0172600467,
-0.0271725245,
0.0112576503,
0.0111052627,
0.0293730553,
-0.0047361809,
-0.0353287421,
0.0061548762,
0.026678713,
-0.0790952593,
-0.0341026448,
-0.0427594371,
0.0184817016,
-0.0158875212,
-0.0394421481,
0.0004666465,
0.0393485799,
-0.0286038704,
0.0112205157,
-0.0435559973,
-0.0843186975,
0.0185979139,
-0.0070095486,
0.0355841964,
-0.0125201074,
0.0048104925,
-0.0351359434,
-0.0238322895,
0.0454676412,
0.0476613306,
-0.061807923,
0.0308148991,
0.0193564687,
-0.0492475852,
-0.0306490902,
0.0680225641,
0.0133881448,
0.0295715313,
-0.0158032496,
0.0815287158,
0.0431396849,
0.0310978442,
-0.0021816588,
0.0117206117,
0.0127659999,
-0.0448447242,
-0.0013127058,
0.0289336368,
-0.0221931934,
0.0312578678,
0.0404011309,
0.0446718223,
0.0011390063,
0.0981634706,
-0.0350072421,
-0.024742566,
-0.0194659736,
0.0020860271,
-0.0074236831,
0.0064814421,
0.0301427711,
-0.0625458136,
-0.0317239538,
0.0006989433,
0.0160006564,
-0.0077676028,
0.0060747098,
0.0135659035,
0.0186539888,
-0.0224725734,
-0.0137983765,
0.0430565476,
0.0102056293,
-0.0442499705,
-0.0378310047,
-0.0500614792,
-0.0546547659,
0.0351387672,
-0.0058572288,
-0.0149935829,
-0.0372885577,
0.0047735367,
-0.032223586,
0.0013995855,
0.0108070737,
0.0420939215,
-0.017451141,
0.0049913479,
0.0490628928,
0.0843688622,
0.0156353861,
-0.0590693615,
-0.0423180275,
-0.0269732978,
-0.0449541621,
-0.0373873897,
0.0054579256,
-6.826582791e-33,
-0.0162090901,
0.0047267466,
-0.0191192701,
0.0337726958,
-0.0048876619,
0.0241681319,
-0.0614274666,
-0.0177337918,
0.0107620759,
0.0367452465,
0.0096120257,
0.0075125126,
0.016446922,
-0.0444555804,
0.0756366849,
0.0424390808,
0.0278275814,
0.019592654,
-0.0192595068,
0.0120343389,
0.0912508667,
0.0593009815,
0.0527045727,
-0.0587533861,
0.0590610653,
0.0390163474,
0.0117109371,
-0.0184227508,
0.0107596554,
0.033273425,
-0.0665163398,
0.0470820889,
0.015384553,
-0.0514826104,
-0.0224373434,
0.0247625113,
-0.0772908777,
-0.000807847,
-0.0416400917,
0.0185492486,
-0.0077651241,
-0.0026115614,
0.0272818226,
-0.002315497,
-0.046113126,
0.002640788,
0.0570433997,
-0.0298907626,
0.0225975178,
-0.0966769829,
-0.0889084637,
-0.0086777546,
-0.0071519674,
0.0506222323,
0.0329323933,
-0.0250069667,
-0.0106189875,
0.0424667075,
-0.0720431581,
0.0168406758,
0.0074540321,
0.0343015529,
0.0162852053,
-0.0251511168,
-0.0144670988,
0.0340832882,
-0.0381470956,
0.0475776047,
0.0428133756,
0.0410557762,
0.0194354299,
0.0556809194,
0.0143261198,
-0.0299770311,
0.0137802698,
-0.0173647385,
-0.0746556222,
0.0175500102,
0.0276787952,
0.0305125155,
0.0091862557,
0.0136308512,
0.0536309406,
-0.0141038159,
0.0064016995,
0.0276804473,
-0.0013293537,
-0.0586257093,
-0.0115368655,
0.0044985455,
-0.0762404874,
-0.0235472936,
0.0119271735,
-0.0605332293,
0.0203732643,
0.0869050846,
-0.0033301006,
0.0086184852,
-0.0216007978,
-0.0030057982,
-0.0731317028,
-0.0471968912,
-0.0359636694,
-0.0222901329,
0.0260521863,
-0.0243555978,
-0.0343674868,
0.0155650955,
0.0088400999,
-0.0084913857,
-0.0339262597,
-0.0192267876,
-0.0097614322,
0.0280450359,
-0.0412320197,
0.0063209645,
-0.0125396578,
0.024448026,
-0.0159238968,
0.0638712421,
0.0318147838,
0.027581485,
-0.0117949294,
0.0173674319,
0.0084335366,
-0.0313932747,
-0.0405239202,
0.0090725813,
-0.0162641052,
-0.0517291464,
0.0207939651,
0.0275962465,
2.99e-7,
0.0792710707,
0.031157922,
0.0077625159,
-0.030179536,
-0.0085944217,
0.0135487188,
-0.0311843865,
0.0010685907,
-0.0235127397,
-0.0457968041,
0.0025051225,
0.0190970208,
0.0073515051,
0.0318036638,
-0.0712253824,
-0.0100963572,
0.0048559178,
-0.0215682425,
-0.03770319,
0.0031696949,
0.0641817525,
0.0292358417,
-0.0202342384,
-0.0360303074,
-0.0006356355,
-0.0080358386,
0.0342789181,
-0.020224439,
-0.0252216458,
0.0877283961,
0.0689071864,
-0.0445397012,
0.0047626626,
0.0450590402,
-0.048453182,
0.00541298,
-0.0032832525,
-0.0012519343,
0.0176571179,
0.0027073803,
-0.0088874092,
-0.0505861528,
0.0220742896,
0.0089320038,
0.0242042728,
-0.0255422238,
-0.0234234221,
0.0300492439,
-0.0239619277,
-0.0097828191,
0.000596714,
0.0010581939,
-0.0108989738,
0.0173424054,
-0.0183865372,
0.0273137968,
-0.0240821671,
-0.0375455245,
0.0176658109,
0.0302900523,
-0.0227134395,
0.0137331532,
-0.0082430243,
-0.0123772928,
0.0331545472,
0.0381860435,
0.0096480465,
2.431181753e-34,
0.0329968929,
-0.0012720167,
-0.0589352734,
0.0341536179,
0.0055334233,
-0.0093711205,
-0.0346623696,
0.0445125736,
-0.0294273291,
-0.0911597535,
-0.0035183406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06959v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06959v1 | SpeechCLIP+: Self-supervised multi-task representation learning for speech via CLIP and speech-image data | 2024-02-10T14:26:42 | 2024-02-10T14:26:42 | Hsuan-Fu Wang, Yi-Jen Shih, Heng-Jui Chang, Layne Berry, Puyuan Peng, Hung-yi Lee, Hsin-Min Wang, David Harwath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The recently proposed visually grounded speech model SpeechCLIP is an
innovative framework that bridges speech and text through images via CLIP
without relying on text transcription. On this basis, this paper introduces two
extensions to SpeechCLIP. First, we apply the Continuous Integrate-and-Fire
(CIF) module to replace a fixed number of CLS tokens in the cascaded
architecture. Second, we propose a new hybrid architecture that merges the
cascaded and parallel architectures of SpeechCLIP into a multi-task learning
framework. Our experimental evaluation is performed on the Flickr8k and
SpokenCOCO datasets. The results show that in the speech keyword extraction
task, the CIF-based cascaded SpeechCLIP model outperforms the previous cascaded
SpeechCLIP model using a fixed number of CLS tokens. Furthermore, through our
hybrid architecture, cascaded task learning boosts the performance of the
parallel branch in image-speech retrieval tasks. | [
-0.0243422017,
0.0122506442,
0.0061583673,
0.0242001005,
-0.0407613032,
-0.0237874612,
0.0458276048,
-0.0063275732,
-0.0120043876,
-0.0296457093,
-0.1075869426,
-0.0113493875,
-0.013650178,
0.0422977954,
0.0221803859,
-0.0463471673,
0.0298865605,
-0.0423101969,
-0.0044063088,
0.0069610225,
0.0199022163,
-0.0107592931,
-0.0481290631,
0.0227415636,
-0.0274251122,
-0.0480780788,
0.002255036,
0.0112483175,
0.0163471457,
0.027613014,
-0.0001811739,
0.026151564,
0.0862467289,
0.0230200514,
0.0000017822,
-0.0027670632,
-0.0330362245,
0.0269092936,
-0.0212400649,
-0.0298849791,
0.0631062612,
0.0387083031,
-0.0196630172,
0.0141778644,
-0.01267171,
-0.016871009,
0.038526874,
0.0976163,
0.0573641509,
0.0151019478,
-0.0324327461,
-0.0480666868,
0.0353184603,
-0.0146327857,
-0.0094732502,
-0.009067947,
-0.0053550834,
0.0250959899,
0.0119190905,
-0.0039816201,
-0.0096136369,
0.058444351,
-0.0123278107,
-0.0046044048,
0.0388354026,
0.0208803397,
-0.0755019635,
-0.0611957349,
-0.0418787412,
0.045683682,
-0.0404002517,
-0.0108174076,
0.0056868535,
0.0104611218,
-0.0066084275,
-0.001594036,
-0.0852518082,
-0.0196234137,
0.0063115489,
0.0173407756,
-0.0653571337,
0.0264926795,
0.0100474581,
-0.005013173,
0.0103153959,
-0.0204245038,
0.0151916621,
0.0002145826,
0.029826263,
-0.0208437219,
-0.0170003045,
0.0212276038,
0.0508191697,
-0.0077904733,
-0.0034719915,
-0.0226516835,
-0.0249906257,
-0.0484549589,
-0.0086083664,
-0.0413724035,
0.0339351259,
0.0016541407,
-0.0905130729,
0.0888062343,
-0.029868912,
0.0395569392,
0.0069857757,
0.0000886338,
-0.0062846285,
-0.0198597349,
-0.0645968989,
-0.0144524025,
-0.056474898,
0.0491983183,
-0.0318541303,
-0.0688736811,
-0.0064373007,
0.001157255,
-0.0419211388,
0.0038503977,
0.0489867851,
0.0180560853,
-0.0537809283,
0.0047901333,
0.035617765,
0.0454973355,
0.0233981181,
0.0630452484,
-0.0106518036,
-0.0129434569,
-0.0152297327,
0.0070107784,
0.0544735603,
-0.0042264774,
0.0480569266,
0.0502696559,
-0.0363347977,
-0.0607401133,
0.0221747216,
0.013733129,
-0.034936402,
-0.0420557037,
0.0263173468,
-0.0648695081,
0.0373457223,
-0.0269276705,
-0.0071745031,
-0.0014985732,
0.0174288154,
0.0423777997,
-0.0414367802,
0.1312980503,
0.0065776408,
-0.0147559363,
0.0171353687,
0.0248557013,
-0.045403298,
0.1017421335,
-0.0012500058,
0.036371395,
0.044387348,
0.0174912363,
-0.0074327732,
0.0366537198,
-0.0062559806,
-0.0031621796,
-0.034432061,
0.001031597,
0.0072062123,
-0.0303505622,
0.0305826701,
0.0341981947,
-0.0300032608,
0.0086356513,
0.0467990041,
0.0626496598,
-0.0110535296,
-0.016513383,
0.0125509612,
0.0171264056,
0.019574089,
0.0181494169,
-0.0224368367,
0.021904666,
-0.0097264992,
-0.0162310842,
0.0270023625,
-0.0021820625,
-0.0480599999,
0.0012665194,
0.0076860609,
-0.0208997391,
-0.0049969289,
0.0039225738,
0.0626978204,
0.0010720561,
-0.0326894969,
0.0240304098,
0.0037268396,
-0.0464930385,
-0.0310502537,
-0.0205029976,
-0.0140467901,
0.0159929749,
-0.0085451417,
-0.0438431501,
-0.0185006671,
-0.0055535748,
0.0319977589,
0.0183572099,
-0.0707222,
-0.019944163,
0.0514364019,
-0.0306929816,
-0.0333114006,
-0.0133384271,
-0.004657194,
-0.0348393768,
-0.0152925085,
-0.0163277127,
0.015462541,
0.0127264336,
-0.0023357139,
0.0053433347,
0.0295664649,
-0.0251870956,
-0.0330437236,
0.0274714548,
0.001408776,
-0.0030973689,
-0.0504658632,
0.0146332588,
0.0327161551,
-0.0240644608,
-0.0039676726,
0.0558713526,
-0.0331122875,
-0.0204818565,
0.0589414947,
-0.0643958598,
0.0274552852,
0.0178536847,
-0.0069497437,
-0.0590556152,
0.0241515003,
-0.0024835204,
0.0370525233,
-0.0537028424,
0.0290610362,
0.0062557999,
0.0270915143,
0.0102019561,
0.0096817622,
0.034370292,
-0.0413621664,
-0.0001902756,
0.0255391076,
0.0024626995,
-0.0445504561,
-0.024989536,
-0.0047383299,
-0.0221483745,
0.0015497265,
-0.0169947911,
0.0168998744,
-0.0439097174,
0.0113032609,
-0.107520327,
-0.0075922604,
-0.0171293356,
-0.0201305635,
-0.0097510777,
-0.0119735673,
0.0275578052,
-0.0338489823,
-0.0276027191,
-0.0231960658,
-0.0098657347,
0.0431891493,
-0.0276475511,
0.0168258771,
0.0154193612,
-0.0265761167,
-0.0068321773,
0.0375158861,
0.0017294897,
-0.0272161402,
-0.0763173997,
0.0084169758,
0.0067551075,
0.0379993916,
0.0358517282,
-0.0291003268,
0.0188686103,
-0.0202887002,
0.0018617744,
0.065663375,
0.0268459488,
-0.0203297175,
-0.0144560467,
-0.0448300987,
-0.0367986821,
-0.02334092,
0.0232304391,
0.0445724949,
0.0431032293,
0.0182192493,
0.0519671477,
-0.0410200022,
-0.0063132173,
-0.0219781306,
0.0270592757,
-0.0229432918,
-0.0103228316,
-0.0086618597,
-0.0183411669,
-0.0412891619,
-0.0096807256,
-0.0264622942,
-0.0360986292,
-0.0208806843,
-0.0713853016,
-0.0082587404,
-0.0621314421,
-0.0651867464,
-0.0256271679,
-0.06923756,
-0.0314107761,
0.0949290618,
-0.0063230707,
-0.0066250525,
0.023751935,
-0.0255809557,
-0.0501877815,
0.0412445217,
-0.0100091873,
-0.0491158552,
0.0454445854,
0.0183089655,
0.001308821,
-0.031514667,
-0.0429124236,
-0.0341056548,
-0.0163947716,
-0.0399809889,
0.0229426119,
-0.0249342974,
-0.0178881418,
0.0011585115,
0.0352989361,
0.0246173777,
0.0104995789,
-0.0131703876,
0.0287100729,
-0.0138275269,
0.0748941526,
0.0663665533,
0.0009424725,
-0.0441366732,
0.0053212321,
0.0046573826,
0.0267455224,
0.1182224527,
-0.0313680209,
-0.0260760114,
0.0130883083,
0.0367416516,
0.0311366115,
-0.0261746421,
-0.0093616126,
0.0432776511,
-0.0395061746,
0.0144410841,
0.0615192428,
-0.0098661212,
-0.0735196993,
-0.0509339087,
-0.0105571272,
-0.0404032916,
0.0542058498,
0.0086132837,
-0.0176511407,
-0.0607039295,
0.0344343521,
-0.0203090142,
0.0497383848,
0.0374839827,
-0.0382631719,
-0.056101948,
0.0444920212,
0.0132984631,
0.0063732103,
-0.0411384962,
-0.0396125354,
0.013006865,
-0.0093203345,
0.0102043925,
-0.0006768488,
-0.0434299782,
-0.0230757874,
0.0176553763,
-0.0143240141,
-0.0245105792,
0.0215331614,
-0.0399320796,
0.024716232,
0.0221859813,
0.0345799401,
-0.0231508128,
-0.0366831161,
0.0148073556,
0.0192235932,
-0.0263654459,
-0.0013250822,
0.0440620445,
-0.0273659956,
-0.0187619645,
0.0018132608,
0.0348855034,
0.011700443,
-0.0122522637,
-0.0140581476,
0.0757148191,
-0.0049954038,
0.0232248455,
-0.0215520337,
0.0260319691,
0.0143216271,
0.0432352014,
0.013848681,
0.0006305717,
-0.0183547717,
0.0386244431,
-0.0354055278,
-0.0507128425,
-0.0418108143,
-0.0061217779,
-0.0053246976,
0.024565991,
-0.0110860616,
0.0171779823,
0.0347795039,
0.0687247291,
-0.0194117185,
0.0431594886,
-0.0192302931,
0.0489099734,
-0.0741651878,
0.0227721948,
-0.0289531574,
0.0477619544,
-0.0382818095,
-0.0055172835,
0.0577673577,
-0.0360064469,
-0.0017601287,
0.0744170472,
-0.1205864102,
-0.0151610496,
-0.0396993719,
0.0373405367,
0.0132405926,
0.0351538099,
-0.0292148143,
0.0072958604,
0.0633233935,
0.0158186406,
-0.0289669354,
-0.0027611631,
0.0878228694,
-0.056456618,
-0.0143398363,
0.0234142449,
-0.0569294505,
0.0364446081,
-0.0283067543,
0.0040074419,
-0.0026836637,
0.0007129782,
-0.0222143363,
-0.000762124,
0.0768389031,
-0.0117348162,
0.0431294292,
-0.0283552594,
0.014566429,
-0.0050841281,
0.0029824919,
-0.0658441186,
0.0428441688,
-0.0275693331,
0.0077850735,
0.0089956438,
0.0073715076,
0.0124384463,
0.0025287976,
-0.0194387324,
0.0411971584,
0.0007419005,
-0.0345322154,
-0.0270320252,
0.0074903173,
0.0376096107,
-0.0010770061,
0.0451941341,
0.001774469,
-0.0022237615,
0.0302415024,
0.0045502465,
-0.0065011373,
-0.0330561846,
0.0508150384,
-0.0526676476,
-0.0042466191,
-0.0327375419,
0.0001747103,
0.0794601142,
-0.0381431729,
0.008590173,
0.0115107773,
-0.0117046684,
-0.0184208304,
0.0100238649,
-0.0058060908,
-0.0021959262,
0.0222968254,
0.0168657247,
-0.0060506356,
0.0255113821,
0.0713335574,
0.001066762,
-0.0104904752,
-0.0028777509,
-0.0011057021,
-0.0263809059,
-0.0486201383,
0.0110482741,
0.0305742901,
-0.0158485454,
-0.0194379035,
0.0043371888,
-0.0777495056,
0.0513044186,
-0.0416519679,
-0.0209909156,
0.0144479945,
0.0368101597,
0.0034102672,
0.0120999701,
0.0181516912,
0.0374251194,
-0.0330967456,
0.0280947722,
0.0231357925,
0.0519330241,
-5.89013844e-33,
-0.0283399969,
0.0189912096,
0.0266750362,
0.0616755374,
-0.0421170108,
0.0349765792,
0.0178217255,
0.0016448835,
0.0352004431,
-0.0290815495,
-0.0130766351,
0.0021223333,
0.0449262895,
0.0255696941,
0.0196317472,
0.0088621462,
0.069826901,
-0.0163526479,
0.0355794206,
-0.0005806879,
0.0293857977,
0.0666460395,
0.0457738042,
-0.0347265303,
-0.0349625275,
0.0331739932,
-0.0069690347,
-0.0015830505,
0.0545684099,
0.0454943068,
-0.0040426808,
0.0475403517,
-0.0151764005,
-0.0660993904,
-0.0476966277,
0.0512045622,
-0.0997332409,
0.0154013829,
0.011694123,
0.0344630852,
-0.0555146374,
0.019444596,
0.020707719,
0.0008708521,
0.0224353317,
-0.0347395763,
0.0381163619,
-0.040474683,
-0.0109793218,
-0.0083500501,
-0.040454153,
0.0061744447,
0.0175896771,
-0.0222509727,
0.0806183815,
0.0228773747,
0.0187755581,
-0.0073952568,
-0.0803258121,
0.0002072631,
-0.0513444953,
0.0121645965,
0.0394763909,
0.0629982501,
0.0272731967,
0.0617027543,
0.0140630119,
-0.0840412006,
-0.0044757808,
-0.0407277867,
0.0297601372,
0.0923564434,
0.0176331811,
-0.014000087,
0.0212041233,
-0.032486435,
-0.0268172268,
-0.02129489,
0.0715780705,
0.0335771069,
0.0212400146,
0.0723185092,
-0.0225656778,
0.0381100662,
-0.0166940354,
-0.0354677476,
-0.0387779623,
-0.0227212179,
0.0225563999,
0.0696110502,
0.0164105818,
0.0811574906,
0.0956941918,
-0.018730972,
0.0304108765,
-0.0001584124,
-0.0157595817,
-0.0015802041,
-0.0018591053,
0.0158354491,
-0.0302511621,
-0.0130208842,
0.0294215661,
0.0253814701,
0.0212084204,
-0.0141354036,
0.0403902605,
0.0405584723,
-0.0461598821,
-0.0337031074,
-0.0072864657,
-0.0040465593,
0.0223843623,
0.0659476072,
0.0332431421,
0.0223035216,
-0.0359804593,
0.0348489471,
-0.0132407174,
0.0147456238,
-0.0102455942,
-0.0192626212,
-0.0276091862,
-0.0221415609,
-0.0009483597,
0.0177292805,
-0.029933054,
-0.007481311,
-0.0356753357,
-0.0632073358,
-0.0171145909,
0.0335462056,
2.705e-7,
-0.0472599082,
0.0299785454,
0.007776971,
-0.0022800593,
0.0171508696,
0.0055446778,
-0.0484246016,
0.0132629909,
-0.0098651294,
-0.0026790961,
0.0009205531,
-0.0047300784,
0.0541052409,
0.0179828089,
-0.0734453723,
-0.0198556781,
-0.065293856,
-0.0113173695,
-0.0216177758,
-0.0271479581,
0.0308155715,
0.0885533988,
0.0220761951,
-0.0471770689,
0.0106145833,
-0.0061057447,
0.075410448,
0.015401422,
0.0114033772,
-0.0551237464,
-0.056409847,
0.0543263145,
-0.0343115553,
0.0640079752,
-0.0343456119,
0.0487111621,
0.1047156751,
0.0446422212,
-0.0074063377,
-0.0596352294,
-0.0278009363,
0.0481464118,
-0.0153088085,
-0.0029547156,
0.1068053544,
-0.0435121432,
-0.0035069862,
-0.0441706404,
-0.0405517034,
0.0180596933,
0.0042257141,
0.0271563698,
-0.03281359,
0.0203264207,
0.026922062,
-0.026274832,
-0.0509229228,
-0.1129162386,
0.0176822878,
0.0006000406,
-0.0624885373,
0.0200185347,
-0.0813468024,
-0.0556794852,
0.0224529821,
-0.0228899941,
-0.0357655771,
2.021981838e-34,
0.0184619129,
-0.0211579949,
0.0148557387,
-0.0070554647,
-0.0364331044,
-0.0085832756,
-0.0375426076,
-0.0052538621,
0.0114128254,
-0.0356287546,
-0.0324098989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06954v1 | OpenFedLLM: Training Large Language Models on Decentralized Private Data via Federated Learning | 2024-02-10T13:50:11 | 2024-02-10T13:50:11 | Rui Ye, Wenhao Wang, Jingyi Chai, Dihan Li, Zexi Li, Yinda Xu, Yaxin Du, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.MA | Trained on massive publicly available data, large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated tremendous success across various fields. While more data
contributes to better performance, a disconcerting reality is that high-quality
public data will be exhausted in a few years. In this paper, we offer a
potential next step for contemporary LLMs: collaborative and privacy-preserving
LLM training on the underutilized distributed private data via federated
learning (FL), where multiple data owners collaboratively train a shared model
without transmitting raw data. To achieve this, we build a concise, integrated,
and research-friendly framework/codebase, named OpenFedLLM. It covers federated
instruction tuning for enhancing instruction-following capability, federated
value alignment for aligning with human values, and 7 representative FL
algorithms. Besides, OpenFedLLM supports training on diverse domains, where we
cover 8 training datasets; and provides comprehensive evaluations, where we
cover 30+ evaluation metrics. Through extensive experiments, we observe that
all FL algorithms outperform local training on training LLMs, demonstrating a
clear performance improvement across a variety of settings. Notably, in a
financial benchmark, Llama2-7B fine-tuned by applying any FL algorithm can
outperform GPT-4 by a significant margin while the model obtained through
individual training cannot, demonstrating strong motivation for clients to
participate in FL. The code is available at
https://github.com/rui-ye/OpenFedLLM. | [
0.0083590187,
0.1396193951,
-0.0080229333,
0.0356908888,
-0.0263198633,
-0.0007396981,
0.0818275362,
0.0005014837,
0.011850236,
0.0161385145,
-0.0755848512,
-0.0363449529,
0.0058407462,
0.0298852921,
0.0071848361,
0.0036191263,
0.0274764691,
-0.0153896846,
-0.0042373091,
-0.0585275963,
-0.0072809672,
0.0026046708,
0.0186835378,
-0.0104905665,
0.0184867997,
-0.0361795202,
-0.024710577,
-0.0063708904,
0.0123813627,
-0.0029037565,
0.0361669846,
0.0525098071,
0.0168006662,
0.0939794779,
0.000002118,
-0.0293380544,
-0.0647821203,
0.0132814664,
-0.0051423172,
0.0722598583,
0.0253214538,
-0.0127542168,
0.0204463247,
0.0367138274,
-0.0770429894,
-0.0059665246,
0.037224777,
0.0138538992,
0.0679751784,
0.089286752,
0.0091557205,
-0.048506055,
0.0029996347,
-0.0667170286,
-0.0880088955,
-0.0552459583,
0.0157624669,
0.0043550343,
-0.05602137,
0.0074849431,
-0.01232237,
0.0305269267,
0.017964514,
0.0562589541,
0.0040352615,
0.031196177,
-0.0592572577,
-0.0039522266,
-0.059708491,
0.063515529,
0.0398757979,
0.0059193429,
0.0152318226,
-0.0224107057,
-0.0096481079,
0.0167350788,
-0.0100633092,
0.0443766043,
0.0121192429,
0.0499064177,
0.0077322153,
-0.030980343,
0.0288581625,
0.0115588456,
0.0386721231,
0.0933397785,
-0.0218298007,
-0.0109362267,
-0.0180115104,
-0.0248784572,
-0.0344834663,
-0.0385981649,
0.0533816777,
0.0132267512,
0.0438615009,
-0.0053980649,
-0.0686645061,
-0.0560381934,
0.0143810995,
-0.0398880504,
0.0275573544,
-0.0144517841,
0.000878264,
0.0483349115,
-0.0163906999,
0.0203208849,
-0.0173532329,
0.0449910089,
0.019008046,
0.044392392,
-0.0553512126,
0.0215088353,
-0.0180749558,
0.0769178942,
-0.0511721931,
-0.0013515217,
-0.0403229892,
0.0088352198,
-0.0303109679,
0.0537131503,
0.0131680667,
0.0137937441,
-0.0096123638,
-0.0321703367,
-0.0175632872,
0.010868418,
-0.0173763558,
0.0360123068,
0.0219637416,
-0.0366232283,
-0.0003415641,
-0.0111374017,
-0.03105844,
0.0001089231,
0.0190338511,
0.0560014062,
0.0229507405,
0.0080323247,
-0.0327571966,
-0.0649260655,
0.0523580126,
-0.06303785,
-0.0082395738,
-0.0623861961,
0.0139237102,
-0.0233153701,
0.0021550674,
-0.049161844,
0.0130613297,
-0.0093599278,
-0.0098835249,
0.072537154,
-0.0166053809,
-0.014899536,
0.0060715871,
0.0031094514,
-0.0066389074,
0.0826080292,
0.0182860438,
0.0061095227,
0.0739265382,
-0.0253359582,
-0.0304064415,
0.0265332833,
0.0714651123,
0.0235870704,
-0.0006086996,
0.0396967791,
0.0036510532,
0.0136786355,
0.0083932243,
0.0366803035,
-0.0117659597,
-0.0465033501,
0.086039342,
0.0562980883,
0.0352897123,
0.0033527112,
-0.0706270188,
0.0646700114,
0.0171823613,
-0.009386288,
-0.0706075951,
-0.0033569825,
-0.0229150448,
-0.0043548811,
-0.0110791586,
0.0573642179,
-0.0324800126,
-0.0193835981,
0.0140034584,
-0.0604806803,
-0.0252972133,
0.0227822009,
0.0079416111,
-0.045511283,
-0.0299215876,
0.0549573824,
0.0375987478,
-0.0259770229,
-0.0235529691,
-0.0164448041,
0.0311065689,
0.0596661754,
0.0544038452,
0.0001343849,
0.0010266041,
-0.0571806319,
0.0240698624,
0.0303394925,
-0.0069436748,
0.011831318,
0.0365231633,
-0.0574042052,
-0.0621794388,
0.0430088528,
0.0037467703,
0.019142529,
-0.0126825552,
-0.0299993418,
-0.0173375867,
-0.0003624002,
-0.0226886589,
0.0281688701,
-0.0028073434,
-0.0381597392,
0.0201909207,
0.026707096,
0.0401408561,
0.0218904372,
-0.0044649425,
-0.0071125738,
0.0105670514,
0.0122988252,
-0.0521646775,
-0.0225260425,
-0.0234958511,
-0.0014936422,
-0.003587458,
-0.0075070723,
0.0262800157,
0.0450583026,
-0.053654395,
-0.0186746959,
-0.0076607387,
0.0251631122,
0.0261395704,
-0.0369547531,
0.0060993889,
-0.001086037,
0.0369639955,
-0.008651536,
0.0136064757,
-0.0662378445,
-0.0018515363,
-0.0702216178,
-0.0097949766,
0.0253402721,
-0.0269139763,
0.0653210431,
-0.0088420883,
0.0005802826,
0.0473649949,
-0.0063842754,
0.0525384508,
0.0028504897,
-0.0068291104,
-0.0072912769,
0.0112528289,
-0.0420916863,
0.0777811185,
0.0241158996,
-0.0136864623,
-0.0165900942,
-0.0200547837,
-0.0497006029,
0.014611748,
-0.0390056707,
0.0049373922,
0.0237676017,
0.0176163875,
-0.0484003946,
-0.0138670579,
-0.0251508355,
0.0208761971,
0.0042390502,
-0.0147528946,
0.0120259598,
-0.0430868454,
0.0039919312,
-0.0433649383,
0.0363558643,
0.0050923014,
-0.0132201752,
0.0004705417,
0.0359717347,
-0.0320872404,
0.0550556891,
-0.0175050125,
-0.014838377,
0.0098341685,
0.0217187274,
-0.0581786595,
0.0002885506,
-0.0180341266,
-0.023732949,
-0.0546298251,
0.029200064,
0.0222806036,
0.0458220914,
-0.0196752232,
-0.0209784657,
-0.0514762886,
0.0344347805,
-0.0085026594,
-0.0271797124,
-0.0536128171,
0.0247109402,
-0.0061509991,
0.0243641958,
0.0013483784,
-0.0739041865,
0.0738351867,
-0.0128901675,
0.0033917553,
-0.0217400827,
-0.0517712794,
-0.0812171325,
0.0362344086,
-0.0375643559,
0.0299564656,
-0.0051432489,
-0.044354599,
-0.0240085311,
0.028907476,
0.0473667867,
-0.0328267626,
0.0143272821,
-0.0071140556,
-0.0159961283,
-0.0053703734,
-0.0511696003,
0.0140288947,
-0.0766974017,
-0.0360705592,
0.0214613546,
-0.0079223216,
-0.0473676585,
0.0063465857,
-0.0070812772,
-0.0159128774,
0.0018605271,
-0.019622637,
0.0278207529,
-0.0252581723,
-0.0141594335,
0.0215137843,
-0.065645501,
-0.0070347679,
-0.0637062117,
-0.0022031744,
0.048725944,
0.0947328135,
-0.0241254363,
0.0370977521,
-0.0362554379,
0.0320181921,
-0.0427744426,
-0.0127346581,
-0.0057114339,
0.0452537537,
-0.0362066291,
0.0229656268,
0.0892358199,
0.0132730315,
-0.0578494444,
-0.0013967005,
-0.0205575153,
0.0528170131,
0.0016172949,
0.006684382,
-0.119301483,
-0.0160153676,
-0.0119636338,
0.0609352961,
0.022404518,
-0.036643263,
-0.027577512,
-0.111176163,
0.0129220886,
0.0181926452,
-0.0414084531,
-0.0364897512,
-0.0487275273,
0.0012200872,
-0.0335311219,
0.0035771597,
-0.0057737338,
-0.0043745791,
0.00068237,
0.0223737266,
-0.0112766922,
-0.0328772031,
-0.0110053327,
-0.05536367,
0.0610896051,
0.0317222327,
-0.0233430862,
-0.0002214841,
-0.0716708899,
-0.0380083881,
0.0569002219,
-0.0366668031,
-0.009654399,
0.0352405645,
-0.0291614868,
-0.0111890053,
0.0219361391,
0.0601621754,
-0.0169045553,
0.0216919649,
0.0424069501,
0.031046275,
0.0001052046,
0.0011355076,
0.0334477946,
0.0005722384,
0.0179520641,
0.0405556709,
0.0018594577,
-0.0264244918,
-0.0260242261,
-0.0106830923,
0.0182636064,
-0.020645611,
0.0334294438,
0.0210977923,
-0.0059218057,
0.0077002202,
-0.0423757657,
-0.0233000536,
0.0093951821,
0.0283636954,
0.0251198672,
0.0052700425,
0.0557778254,
-0.0364290699,
-0.0449253432,
0.030404672,
-0.0824236944,
0.0537672862,
-0.0817949697,
-0.0207000598,
-0.0130478004,
0.0081651881,
-0.0326546207,
0.0391975418,
-0.1183309034,
-0.0711669698,
0.0253312159,
0.014446022,
0.0171476714,
0.0158474743,
-0.00871797,
-0.0318561494,
0.0546435975,
0.025532892,
-0.0906956047,
0.0157159623,
0.0799017847,
-0.048296243,
0.0185086168,
0.0451136418,
-0.0303328484,
0.0008523271,
0.0271203592,
-0.0153237591,
-0.0190191045,
-0.0230102167,
-0.0171738602,
0.0345531069,
0.0510143228,
0.0034470914,
-0.0045312843,
-0.0374926589,
0.0462529659,
-0.0025749232,
0.0077833273,
-0.0350874178,
-0.0303073954,
0.0412100926,
-0.028756354,
0.0294841118,
0.0043838201,
0.0417983048,
-0.0078016128,
-0.028599225,
0.0361951739,
0.0036263443,
0.0164431427,
0.03844136,
-0.0164968278,
0.00929775,
0.0362244099,
0.0484437421,
0.0421591103,
-0.0061880257,
0.0451118685,
-0.012763151,
0.0446564481,
-0.0071585341,
0.0181297045,
-0.0302804876,
-0.0848409161,
-0.0181911439,
0.0205513462,
0.0346351825,
0.0315927565,
0.0040545301,
-0.0475425497,
-0.0035123983,
-0.0054041902,
0.0150874984,
-0.0613161549,
-0.0670248717,
0.0292337369,
-0.0060886298,
-0.0243826732,
0.0446617603,
0.1164972708,
0.0226031058,
0.0292565413,
-0.0421430618,
0.0225824751,
-0.0569904335,
-0.0259047225,
0.0400214009,
0.0458616279,
-0.0418053828,
0.0021226085,
-0.0189931076,
-0.0556806549,
-0.0137466891,
0.0052804109,
-0.0259844549,
-0.0166423842,
0.0358781889,
0.0065132976,
-0.0170336496,
-0.0037609709,
-0.0590086877,
-0.0111930044,
0.0197404362,
-0.0099160336,
-0.038259536,
-6.477797454e-33,
-0.0169226415,
-0.0071471506,
0.0089154718,
0.0334382504,
0.0068125175,
0.041815076,
-0.0038446595,
0.0068914224,
0.0124880588,
-0.0116488654,
-0.020738516,
0.0362851396,
0.0207790062,
0.0389847383,
0.0097608939,
-0.0155542474,
0.0214372762,
-0.0633883476,
-0.0331559703,
0.0240031518,
0.037688572,
0.0545236319,
0.0777104944,
-0.0472763143,
0.0320417024,
-0.0094409296,
-0.0582672209,
0.0225631204,
-0.021513572,
0.0386931337,
-0.0174234137,
0.0079286648,
-0.0112549951,
-0.0511034094,
-0.0198569074,
-0.0357190073,
-0.0245155878,
0.0015501801,
-0.0090639498,
0.0316449031,
-0.0350557715,
-0.0239873398,
0.0330698192,
-0.0329255313,
-0.0124840802,
-0.0092824912,
0.0066006328,
0.00384945,
-0.0244505536,
-0.0046381326,
0.0025887904,
0.0287189744,
-0.0000932453,
0.0268845875,
0.0361125208,
0.0223531313,
-0.0060450621,
-0.0332029723,
-0.0479326211,
0.0310177188,
0.0270836614,
0.0073186378,
0.0414846949,
0.0204304047,
0.0210394673,
0.0364683047,
0.0514715947,
0.0059986939,
-0.0190997235,
0.0211586542,
0.016584374,
0.0626373589,
0.0153917624,
0.0290890411,
-0.0141684748,
-0.0278498717,
-0.0214385968,
-0.0027330583,
0.0124141322,
-0.0288275052,
0.0020043838,
0.0219604708,
-0.0448861867,
-0.0064683412,
-0.0301068313,
-0.0088909101,
-0.0045695123,
0.0033651162,
-0.000764953,
0.0241049435,
-0.0222879481,
-0.015680423,
0.0096540498,
-0.0601484887,
-0.0609193929,
0.0202630032,
0.0570910797,
-0.0074082515,
0.0226015225,
0.0223392714,
-0.1138779148,
-0.0211050883,
-0.0339171439,
-0.0279463865,
0.0095141642,
0.017974114,
0.0776992813,
0.0245593525,
-0.0637970939,
-0.012151516,
-0.0200547837,
0.0232260469,
0.0280298851,
0.0088046659,
0.0397678874,
-0.0248053893,
0.0107841082,
0.037909396,
0.0034809343,
0.0228659213,
-0.0395468995,
-0.0076823169,
-0.0102074286,
0.0288247988,
0.0181554947,
0.0024354358,
-0.0310204662,
0.0014243872,
0.0572592579,
0.0035960684,
-0.0059745051,
-0.0276380498,
2.786e-7,
0.0202252567,
0.0295430534,
-0.0130977221,
0.0026666573,
0.0064689331,
0.0553460978,
-0.0422785133,
0.0620291829,
-0.0191818699,
0.0151005136,
0.0076802708,
0.0311638936,
0.079791829,
-0.001698263,
-0.0443465039,
-0.0362815186,
-0.0380354486,
0.0634490177,
-0.0653340444,
-0.0211390853,
-0.04316172,
0.0747628808,
0.0503898449,
-0.039117936,
0.0006349873,
-0.0105386963,
0.056101203,
-0.0433512814,
-0.0625172332,
0.0022213876,
-0.0083221765,
0.0835426673,
-0.0161774065,
-0.0135361534,
-0.0166251734,
0.0267299283,
-0.0498179831,
0.106423758,
0.0412861668,
0.0178817268,
-0.0083058756,
-0.0238391832,
-0.0523202233,
0.0045797043,
0.0446194224,
-0.0306141749,
-0.0584765337,
-0.0134002967,
0.0155280288,
-0.0539577305,
0.0658396631,
0.0073993839,
0.0064366297,
0.0063754953,
0.0081063202,
-0.0371095091,
-0.021857867,
-0.0299030244,
-0.0135432929,
-0.0379250087,
-0.0239590462,
-0.0239712391,
-0.0134631628,
0.0688472465,
-0.0145175969,
-0.0178028829,
0.0217276514,
2.637853863e-34,
0.0464625396,
-0.0365107469,
-0.0028052251,
0.0391104668,
0.0135564758,
-0.0363535583,
0.0020325906,
0.0068924734,
0.0053789867,
-0.0437719673,
0.0191950016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06948v1 | Should I try multiple optimizers when fine-tuning pre-trained Transformers for NLP tasks? Should I tune their hyperparameters? | 2024-02-10T13:26:14 | 2024-02-10T13:26:14 | Nefeli Gkouti, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Stavros Toumpis, Ion Androutsopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP research has explored different neural model architectures and sizes,
datasets, training objectives, and transfer learning techniques. However, the
choice of optimizer during training has not been explored as extensively.
Typically, some variant of Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) is employed,
selected among numerous variants, using unclear criteria, often with minimal or
no tuning of the optimizer's hyperparameters. Experimenting with five GLUE
datasets, two models (DistilBERT and DistilRoBERTa), and seven popular
optimizers (SGD, SGD with Momentum, Adam, AdaMax, Nadam, AdamW, and AdaBound),
we find that when the hyperparameters of the optimizers are tuned, there is no
substantial difference in test performance across the five more elaborate
(adaptive) optimizers, despite differences in training loss. Furthermore,
tuning just the learning rate is in most cases as good as tuning all the
hyperparameters. Hence, we recommend picking any of the best-behaved adaptive
optimizers (e.g., Adam) and tuning only its learning rate. When no
hyperparameter can be tuned, SGD with Momentum is the best choice. | [
0.0362659581,
0.0767540708,
0.015571733,
-0.0096941749,
0.021603873,
-0.0240383353,
0.0127110332,
0.008965699,
-0.0821197554,
-0.0460380986,
-0.0572350323,
-0.0053033279,
0.026646493,
-0.0718606859,
0.0001016671,
-0.007773214,
0.0604280904,
0.0020648027,
-0.0137002366,
0.0080602551,
-0.0098850755,
-0.0172393061,
-0.0225614309,
0.075814575,
-0.0096911294,
0.0398912393,
0.0152307888,
0.0426023751,
0.019667672,
-0.0258999765,
0.0457702391,
0.0702085346,
-0.030057773,
0.0295373611,
0.0000021698,
-0.0300225671,
0.006436836,
0.0013064451,
-0.013859476,
-0.0082395114,
-0.007425312,
-0.0430976227,
0.0332810394,
0.0449798889,
-0.055310443,
-0.0603214614,
0.0525400117,
0.0560635068,
0.0610013008,
0.096159786,
0.0094529027,
-0.0315329544,
-0.0035494945,
-0.00499814,
-0.0465039723,
-0.0445016474,
0.0030079207,
-0.0459030867,
-0.0335146263,
0.0256419871,
0.0064245681,
0.0100791901,
-0.0174794532,
-0.0068584788,
0.0387299806,
-0.0198451392,
-0.0658362806,
-0.0372908413,
-0.0422667116,
0.0376728065,
-0.0876178443,
0.0048617949,
-0.0224176068,
-0.0058478797,
-0.0498509668,
-0.0028333357,
-0.0152226891,
-0.0068828356,
0.0416202508,
0.0301204715,
-0.0220924988,
0.0116331289,
0.0276728794,
-0.0093271071,
-0.0312873311,
0.0626935139,
-0.0200541168,
0.0257241726,
0.0692362189,
0.0396234579,
-0.0363370664,
-0.0738924444,
0.0223175008,
0.0236323215,
-0.0461777896,
0.0172411278,
-0.0460356884,
-0.0420265161,
-0.0121470317,
0.0036624593,
0.0896456316,
0.0275537577,
0.0440036841,
-0.0308059342,
-0.04460923,
0.0255431775,
0.0344818644,
0.0227584727,
0.0041966867,
-0.0165850278,
-0.0223793406,
0.0342125967,
0.0023933619,
0.0470143966,
-0.0082265716,
-0.0484821312,
-0.0448997431,
-0.0142950993,
0.0555708967,
-0.0279643498,
0.0595544167,
-0.0340803079,
-0.0310137141,
0.0394047759,
-0.0256305523,
0.0107890563,
-0.0688276514,
0.0349270143,
-0.0062018242,
-0.0124530531,
-0.0374571122,
0.027209986,
0.0033830681,
-0.022764381,
0.0284109935,
0.075741224,
-0.034458667,
-0.0324369632,
-0.0395297781,
0.0113410102,
-0.013306343,
-0.044086121,
0.0566915311,
-0.0073453397,
0.0452225357,
-0.0021215272,
-0.0001227122,
-0.0559988916,
0.0126527883,
-0.00432393,
0.0233899374,
-0.0105665261,
0.0242757276,
-0.0137877222,
-0.0433756188,
-0.0088326074,
-0.0076781069,
0.1108056903,
-0.0142270913,
0.039117828,
0.0012127353,
-0.0106600905,
-0.0086312201,
-0.0148755368,
0.0003954495,
-0.005439613,
0.0329711288,
-0.0304255374,
-0.0163594391,
0.0251839962,
0.0250588544,
0.016574936,
-0.0587583184,
-0.023920415,
0.0141497795,
0.034060996,
0.0872483328,
0.0119068483,
-0.0085358052,
-0.0200174861,
0.0459491536,
0.0070461836,
-0.0089634638,
0.0215124451,
0.000741498,
-0.0268132649,
-0.0378631055,
0.0714957416,
0.001582007,
-0.0299507361,
-0.0249353927,
0.0049530785,
-0.0393514298,
-0.0043063965,
0.0054357341,
0.013723433,
-0.0491809174,
0.0578523315,
0.0044615758,
-0.0152650969,
-0.038023714,
-0.0257737804,
-0.0936722755,
-0.0389875434,
-0.0335412249,
-0.008164091,
-0.0590708852,
-0.0148843657,
-0.0352726914,
0.0528427549,
0.0141484132,
0.0271264762,
0.0535487607,
-0.0468597561,
-0.0043865941,
-0.018890975,
0.0201949254,
0.0066079893,
0.0450935364,
0.0336343572,
0.0234627519,
0.027411703,
-0.0305357222,
0.062489491,
-0.0129517429,
-0.036180269,
0.0101129739,
-0.0273490176,
0.0116035193,
0.0116246473,
-0.0021401278,
-0.0228406191,
-0.0130221592,
-0.0188999139,
-0.0270259846,
-0.001396,
-0.0311129317,
-0.0267073587,
0.0085344957,
-0.0157637447,
0.0574252233,
0.0190076195,
-0.0085061984,
-0.060192585,
-0.0411940217,
0.0076665515,
0.0540114008,
-0.0076757632,
0.006863764,
-0.0489902869,
0.0354472436,
-0.0419209749,
-0.0023396437,
0.0113594774,
-0.0398951434,
-0.0107597038,
-0.0144445281,
0.01479859,
0.0197644588,
-0.0444385894,
0.0183512419,
-0.0348985977,
0.0344208516,
0.0165407788,
0.0194142032,
-0.0189801827,
-0.0178040098,
-0.0186204202,
0.0331557691,
-0.031240277,
0.0261217598,
-0.0031448216,
-0.0067654033,
-0.0002964413,
0.0234760568,
0.013784471,
0.018930072,
-0.046536617,
0.0252959877,
-0.0053577581,
0.0008546935,
0.014986299,
-0.0208889116,
-0.0264759623,
0.0030345521,
0.0480919816,
0.0006704439,
-0.0053025275,
-0.028474085,
0.0224899929,
0.0045418791,
-0.0024877153,
0.0096226484,
-0.0481012054,
-0.0355832577,
0.0194007996,
-0.0186854433,
0.0771678016,
-0.0646179914,
0.0590421744,
-0.0262337513,
0.0264339019,
-0.0542240329,
0.0036466657,
-0.0354853645,
-0.0150561361,
-0.0400220454,
0.0493458696,
0.0579528064,
0.0953682065,
-0.0492690317,
-0.013784552,
-0.0228267144,
0.0464542434,
-0.0091444841,
-0.0249919016,
0.0549081378,
-0.0168944113,
0.0126382802,
0.0324083492,
0.0627312213,
0.0011985815,
0.0313635692,
-0.0310234651,
-0.0005223908,
-0.0549320541,
0.0064104823,
-0.0465937704,
-0.0587192588,
-0.0286872964,
0.0136525752,
-0.0195640791,
-0.0357252434,
0.0034276946,
0.0250422452,
0.0674775392,
0.0075681526,
0.0562193617,
0.0375834666,
0.0249138251,
-0.0343545042,
-0.0732711628,
-0.0433994383,
0.0112877451,
-0.0137189897,
0.0063306014,
0.07444489,
-0.0535290912,
-0.0921889022,
-0.0072101844,
-0.0542875342,
0.0346833803,
-0.0524401665,
-0.0066081155,
-0.0164327081,
0.0125584612,
-0.0038819143,
0.0329443589,
0.064950496,
0.0262419172,
-0.00314579,
-0.0103944372,
0.0170546118,
-0.0149190007,
-0.0505486876,
0.0314326659,
0.0536303371,
-0.0927219763,
-0.0237802751,
-0.0118335541,
0.0475926548,
-0.0585975312,
0.0132375583,
0.0659771711,
-0.0102468692,
-0.0359691344,
-0.0021835887,
0.0328971036,
0.019774843,
0.0025938943,
0.0474418476,
-0.0345904194,
-0.0562520623,
0.00052163,
0.0289473217,
-0.0012515553,
-0.037386626,
0.0089455536,
-0.0593814291,
-0.0248099323,
-0.0216636527,
-0.0450313166,
0.0659630522,
-0.0477019809,
-0.0112364991,
-0.0442921184,
0.0601416714,
-0.0055046924,
-0.048497431,
-0.0061267191,
0.013923428,
0.036053773,
-0.0723485425,
-0.0261210855,
-0.0384519026,
0.02372518,
0.0452610105,
-0.0375682525,
0.0068974379,
-0.0168979131,
0.1023065522,
0.0042296327,
0.0290200152,
-0.0402247608,
0.0104373675,
-0.0365430713,
-0.0065561421,
-0.0315612108,
0.0167644769,
-0.0028373618,
0.0171726402,
-0.015852306,
0.0107262712,
0.0257180464,
-0.0392580256,
-0.0020234596,
0.0103343083,
-0.0285822321,
0.0342415534,
-0.0168953184,
-0.0265463367,
-0.0550231077,
0.0137422737,
0.0174670499,
-0.0570963249,
-0.0447909348,
0.0616904609,
0.0125159333,
-0.0429527462,
-0.0137561895,
-0.0380385406,
0.017700661,
0.0511025079,
0.0267227814,
-0.022823073,
0.0033093281,
0.0347330421,
0.0217544306,
0.0326003581,
0.0331490673,
-0.0353206135,
-0.049183879,
0.0316880383,
0.0694341809,
0.0178192444,
-0.0074265092,
-0.0361982621,
-0.0511900112,
-0.0570927076,
0.0326867439,
0.0441755541,
0.0144327097,
0.0419841781,
0.0058159563,
-0.0730047524,
-0.0171089377,
0.0619415902,
0.0149644706,
-0.0096815415,
0.0428396016,
-0.0119622117,
-0.0365583412,
-0.0020768645,
0.0035492114,
0.0636354089,
0.0514496975,
0.0593395196,
0.0584774949,
-0.0140614603,
-0.0123088583,
0.0194263645,
0.0334592052,
-0.0209580846,
0.0154134501,
0.0019544191,
0.0281988904,
0.0218783524,
0.0409383774,
-0.0086013516,
0.0045475345,
0.0027784139,
0.0130889937,
-0.0266998596,
0.0442214347,
0.0249364357,
0.0096655823,
-0.0600942485,
0.0612464733,
0.0097389715,
-0.0045575821,
0.0006523007,
0.0237322506,
-0.0086011104,
0.0463885553,
0.0696406662,
0.0393630601,
-0.0290295873,
0.0124642216,
0.0153282713,
0.000102671,
-0.0202972405,
0.0044998722,
-0.0520909727,
-0.0689082667,
-0.0606453195,
-0.0301231686,
0.0512416139,
-0.0204165969,
0.0364707485,
0.0073939962,
-0.0020560757,
0.0340619646,
0.0035059555,
0.0201399177,
0.0753692985,
0.0085053528,
-0.0135455756,
-0.0028082218,
-0.025103908,
0.0230691414,
-0.0156520642,
0.0138127264,
0.0187416747,
-0.0011697132,
-0.0345445685,
-0.0270672813,
-0.0031971724,
-0.0037717465,
0.005517609,
-0.0295045935,
-0.0023332862,
-0.0083314199,
0.0089683486,
-0.0465117916,
-0.0089933695,
0.0200616494,
0.0415905565,
-0.0031418579,
-0.0100991717,
0.018601818,
0.0358517431,
-0.0450474806,
-0.0257391799,
0.0368223935,
0.0219789036,
-6.675592011e-33,
0.010913562,
0.0092830509,
0.0244994052,
-0.0190045238,
-0.0332827158,
-0.01825561,
0.0052100718,
-0.0025032978,
-0.0600008257,
0.0100982487,
-0.0300471243,
0.0024310781,
0.0267271232,
0.0355779305,
-0.0513108894,
-0.0252776686,
0.0453453064,
-0.0035734591,
-0.0355240628,
-0.0265723225,
-0.0150184762,
0.0357200503,
0.0572888292,
-0.0151610123,
-0.0642545149,
0.0330106616,
-0.0036049858,
0.0067378529,
0.0400642827,
0.0278091803,
0.003045643,
0.0265711918,
-0.0064180475,
-0.0568084344,
-0.0175237581,
-0.0188004747,
-0.045579873,
-0.0576185323,
0.0103809396,
0.0479540825,
-0.0172603317,
-0.0225527845,
0.0464529991,
0.0049280417,
-0.0480812825,
-0.0228552744,
-0.0122900233,
0.0115907956,
-0.0453123599,
-0.1023950353,
-0.0604092814,
0.0141847292,
0.0338396989,
0.0381617993,
0.0447113663,
0.0288081206,
-0.0247045904,
0.0517338328,
-0.0383236334,
-0.0229068641,
-0.0012963619,
0.0224734303,
0.0625006035,
0.0456548966,
-0.0163767096,
0.0084116915,
0.0293960366,
-0.0091653522,
0.0324458964,
-0.0285314918,
0.0507890023,
0.0584874786,
0.0472476706,
-0.0285444297,
0.0166076813,
-0.0391975231,
-0.0436041988,
0.003084325,
0.0253837053,
-0.0079004737,
0.0126414802,
0.0138044246,
0.0140908742,
-0.0130925318,
-0.0616560988,
-0.008362635,
-0.00996364,
-0.0161791425,
0.037919648,
0.0248839855,
-0.0510749146,
0.0241745301,
0.052360598,
-0.0273776706,
0.0205906536,
-0.0061411168,
-0.0230307244,
0.0031768528,
-0.0117681343,
0.0105284443,
0.0026694126,
-0.0352015831,
0.025140658,
0.0246497635,
0.043621067,
-0.0654607937,
0.0075701075,
-0.0128119932,
-0.0439450368,
0.0059998268,
-0.0216026809,
0.0634991899,
0.0322760306,
0.0468603745,
0.0435798615,
0.0092153931,
-0.0201868825,
0.0535884984,
0.0441399813,
0.0186198931,
-0.012186259,
0.0506875739,
0.0432279333,
0.0026421116,
0.0133742709,
0.0260381363,
0.0120980367,
-0.0034295912,
-0.0371604338,
-0.0978126675,
-0.0281728245,
0.0491312332,
2.752e-7,
0.0535190888,
0.0587464049,
0.0062295962,
-0.0176890772,
-0.012581964,
-0.0076116021,
0.0344618857,
-0.0563282445,
-0.0173557326,
0.031881351,
-0.0418657511,
0.0170730185,
0.0243803822,
0.0074110846,
-0.0176520851,
-0.0501713529,
-0.0272718798,
0.0443042926,
-0.039304696,
-0.0407438576,
-0.0229128543,
0.0803861991,
-0.0510618016,
-0.0171959382,
-0.0214426573,
0.0041155089,
0.0337062031,
0.0050749206,
0.0390127264,
0.1109020114,
-0.0120528964,
0.0120851006,
-0.0036487884,
-0.0000163621,
-0.0229331944,
0.05648949,
0.023876043,
0.0466399305,
-0.0027243572,
-0.0929568633,
0.0338979624,
0.0363883153,
0.0310155954,
-0.019252371,
0.0667036399,
-0.0836839601,
-0.0490460508,
0.0119078103,
-0.0112472791,
-0.0566283986,
0.0446610376,
-0.058532998,
0.0102159427,
0.0600163452,
0.0126340073,
0.0414144732,
-0.0764406249,
-0.082354039,
-0.0331294239,
0.0595145933,
-0.0078130718,
0.0071368874,
-0.0344749913,
-0.0166970193,
0.0470735393,
-0.0470861867,
-0.0429263562,
2.907761371e-34,
0.0118911117,
-0.0264923144,
0.0393265262,
0.0658884645,
-0.0169408899,
0.0120370379,
-0.0261239223,
0.0388137437,
-0.0207370073,
-0.0890131667,
-0.0093966983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06930v1 | LiFi: Lightweight Controlled Text Generation with Fine-Grained Control Codes | 2024-02-10T11:53:48 | 2024-02-10T11:53:48 | Chufan Shi, Deng Cai, Yujiu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the rapidly evolving field of text generation, the demand for more precise
control mechanisms has become increasingly apparent. To address this need, we
present a novel methodology, LIFI, which offers a lightweight approach with
fine-grained control for controlled text generation. Unlike previous studies
that train pre-trained language models to follow discrete, categorical, and
exclusive control codes, LIFI learns controlled text generation under the
guidance of continuous, relative, and nonexclusive control codes. These
fine-grained codes are automatically derived from an attribute classifier,
initially trained with a small amount of labeled data and subsequently employed
to label abundant unlabeled data, thus garnering more extensive supervision
signals. Moreover, to achieve efficient control, we incorporate the
fine-grained control codes with adapters, a parameter- and compute-efficient
way to steer a pre-trained language model. We evaluate LIFI on two conventional
tasks -- sentiment control and topic control -- and one newly proposed task --
stylistic novel writing. Comprehensive experimental results validate the
effectiveness of our proposed methods, demonstrating substantial performance
improvements over existing baselines. | [
0.0266828034,
0.0473746471,
0.0064450465,
-0.0212280452,
-0.0102636795,
0.0084713046,
0.0360814631,
0.0210313462,
0.0071689566,
-0.0443640389,
-0.019743342,
-0.0234776828,
-0.0323064961,
0.0467791185,
0.0332103819,
-0.0115946867,
0.0041987128,
0.0024727636,
0.0694826022,
-0.0005763348,
0.0406708084,
0.0280573815,
0.0089223003,
0.026408514,
-0.0524553172,
0.0148783689,
0.0155657195,
0.0044764131,
-0.0052131773,
-0.01780672,
0.0803806782,
0.0745861307,
0.0283001866,
0.0110117625,
0.0000019611,
-0.0094691347,
-0.0204689577,
-0.0460473001,
0.0545545332,
-0.0008423972,
0.0794539228,
-0.0107852416,
-0.0073043657,
0.0193695743,
-0.037268538,
-0.0119917411,
0.0489066318,
0.0845557824,
0.0562300384,
0.0896422938,
-0.0275151022,
-0.0393076055,
-0.0168848541,
-0.0142150456,
0.0272423774,
-0.0007868234,
-0.0018724783,
-0.0181327481,
-0.0089157904,
0.0153598571,
-0.0097810682,
0.0161920618,
0.0104212537,
-0.0334797613,
0.0294069387,
0.0400832929,
-0.022813512,
-0.0334968939,
-0.0141462805,
0.0571773276,
-0.022532301,
-0.0767827183,
0.0291107241,
-0.0291191507,
-0.0084445886,
-0.0316244327,
-0.018888304,
0.0352468193,
0.0066848518,
0.020439798,
0.0184503403,
-0.0046082768,
0.0038155862,
0.0382342152,
0.0040464723,
0.020035943,
0.0164210703,
-0.0344510414,
-0.0176736563,
0.0295659713,
-0.0166668296,
-0.0809202045,
0.0028392437,
0.0352372937,
-0.0300275572,
-0.0089673828,
-0.1026940271,
-0.0603873506,
0.0103348689,
-0.0418138914,
0.0549033135,
0.0095062116,
0.0128499176,
-0.0020785511,
-0.0505387336,
0.0096518165,
-0.0082981307,
0.0366741121,
0.0123655237,
0.0298742596,
-0.0324717537,
-0.0246051997,
-0.0626537725,
0.0277650412,
-0.0141955055,
-0.0366480313,
-0.0448588543,
0.0156845376,
-0.0008763456,
0.0161420964,
-0.0148422616,
0.0179865379,
-0.0145615544,
0.0075062346,
0.0251973309,
0.0224472899,
-0.022569159,
0.0121897599,
0.0339151621,
0.0240292437,
-0.0027722511,
0.0453212857,
0.054714866,
-0.013278502,
0.0243116282,
0.0158440676,
-0.0465341248,
-0.0322546363,
-0.0425781235,
-0.0517499,
-0.0476677753,
-0.0408512838,
-0.0045414376,
-0.0485865399,
-0.0011732356,
0.0114384582,
-0.0219646804,
-0.0381341875,
0.0184886996,
0.0398928113,
-0.0107392203,
0.0087777963,
-0.0248500928,
-0.0201971401,
0.0318223871,
-0.0021940533,
0.0390941165,
0.0371989384,
0.0378920734,
0.0799075663,
-0.0011857309,
0.0066328095,
0.0432563312,
0.0127752731,
0.0456274301,
0.0254199337,
-0.0542538986,
-0.0327991992,
0.0095483148,
0.0339896381,
0.011522186,
0.0429651663,
-0.0176343508,
0.0369026214,
0.1004379317,
-0.0179498848,
0.0180855934,
0.0556112193,
0.0678733736,
0.0111280885,
-0.0053677172,
-0.0002492956,
0.005241795,
0.0396351703,
-0.042933926,
0.0092552518,
0.0029628612,
-0.0210842304,
-0.0402219035,
-0.0350782014,
0.0111406213,
-0.0243476089,
0.0120608276,
-0.0350323245,
0.0045991465,
0.0478977449,
-0.0564083196,
-0.0400720052,
0.0303206481,
-0.0958100408,
0.020227693,
-0.0090634301,
0.0448475555,
0.0726635531,
0.0291229952,
-0.0162168238,
-0.0270263348,
-0.0203897059,
0.0809035078,
0.0603040978,
0.0485467799,
0.0067494758,
-0.0121860094,
-0.05313427,
0.003249523,
-0.0473372526,
0.002099616,
0.0021326409,
-0.0047003436,
0.0364330076,
0.0079146493,
0.0193948802,
-0.091485925,
0.0544994585,
0.0146716712,
-0.0469685644,
0.0269707292,
0.003389959,
-0.011552752,
-0.0249533374,
-0.0390023813,
0.0126599511,
-0.0098847849,
-0.0339251049,
-0.0665536001,
-0.0309508685,
-0.0400538482,
-0.0518578626,
-0.009360713,
-0.0109250695,
-0.0034254403,
-0.0193483979,
-0.0045641004,
-0.057668224,
0.0347960256,
-0.029644981,
0.0079746488,
-0.0400386378,
0.0131080104,
-0.0069024917,
-0.0127369463,
-0.023871595,
0.051920902,
0.0316274315,
0.0015874369,
0.015569604,
0.011169536,
0.0064318073,
0.0240244996,
-0.0027374269,
-0.013057326,
0.0148986923,
0.0148570137,
0.0615563802,
0.0682428703,
-0.0045656282,
-0.0686177462,
-0.0528109185,
0.0087345717,
-0.0354053602,
-0.0287404936,
0.0133630577,
0.0140947038,
-0.0022083202,
0.0119067188,
-0.0626734644,
0.0159377065,
0.0155972522,
-0.0146043738,
0.0511386134,
0.0044608209,
-0.0052189119,
-0.0387115292,
0.0141855991,
0.0155606978,
0.0147024095,
0.0589187406,
-0.0141284987,
-0.0067301919,
0.0210379548,
-0.0365887657,
-0.0054515731,
0.0250520259,
-0.0475649834,
0.026399903,
-0.0336945765,
0.0313165486,
0.0176141448,
0.0249249563,
0.0439072475,
0.0263524875,
0.0367207639,
-0.0253321212,
0.0062546795,
-0.0515904725,
0.0019491069,
-0.0094469739,
0.0197424404,
0.0364361145,
0.0844198391,
0.0300807487,
0.0051681506,
-0.0862199068,
0.0263374373,
0.0008710703,
-0.0408760943,
0.006707849,
0.0269339904,
0.0034962411,
0.0251931958,
-0.0346654877,
-0.0525659844,
0.0495703854,
-0.0067585781,
-0.0017650161,
-0.014322835,
-0.0164007545,
-0.0185803734,
0.0210705511,
0.0142627545,
0.0409733541,
0.0319414772,
-0.0124691073,
-0.0531920828,
0.0411503352,
0.0337787047,
0.0038254964,
0.0149563951,
-0.031958729,
0.0235324632,
-0.0023882717,
-0.0385032818,
-0.022852337,
-0.0584488511,
0.0301766191,
-0.0082959253,
0.0407969877,
-0.049781587,
0.0340498798,
-0.0286020488,
0.0254166611,
0.0587144233,
-0.0535128228,
-0.0241296366,
-0.0090736933,
0.0178498365,
0.0442500152,
-0.0521606505,
-0.0260443222,
-0.0450785048,
-0.0096022813,
0.037501011,
-0.0173377227,
0.019349074,
-0.0223988835,
0.0210629851,
0.0301339589,
-0.0346293449,
-0.0207899585,
-0.0009339488,
0.0715940073,
-0.0456953943,
-0.0564097092,
0.136394456,
0.0327754579,
-0.0399795882,
-0.0047874115,
0.0494157597,
0.0587510951,
0.0103018582,
0.0071392283,
-0.0747083351,
-0.0182820149,
-0.0302802864,
0.028952226,
-0.0170293748,
-0.0216514207,
-0.0163601208,
-0.0714426041,
0.0051118284,
0.0262400694,
-0.0313417651,
0.0003582596,
0.0171478055,
-0.0234349351,
0.0371170379,
-0.0525668599,
0.0015804017,
-0.0154106766,
0.0032307508,
0.0073423083,
0.000246141,
-0.01804718,
-0.047243502,
-0.0222096834,
0.0450642109,
0.0351808257,
0.0473504066,
0.0029962207,
0.0216403585,
0.0109375156,
-0.0257602111,
-0.0021415832,
-0.0608434938,
0.0327631533,
-0.0197848603,
-0.0262604523,
-0.0123010175,
0.0641800016,
-0.0061878911,
0.0153794708,
0.0004605249,
0.026882004,
-0.0455038212,
-0.0484492555,
0.0043714149,
0.0135772489,
0.0669878349,
0.0492808446,
0.0590250604,
-0.1036982462,
-0.0638889223,
-0.0120448694,
-0.0109861763,
-0.0777418241,
-0.0355087593,
-0.0313734636,
-0.0234481767,
-0.0260047391,
-0.103766866,
-0.0136027895,
0.0473765768,
0.0583248548,
0.011994536,
-0.0220358483,
-0.007780489,
-0.0679738149,
-0.0436848924,
-0.049458243,
-0.0242686644,
0.0071327696,
-0.0357878953,
-0.0911908075,
0.0039792792,
-0.0383354798,
0.0211929809,
0.0332872011,
-0.0315507762,
-0.0826866105,
0.0184768811,
0.0559479706,
0.0083095208,
0.0239172615,
-0.0033455084,
-0.083534874,
0.0398449898,
0.0341844521,
-0.0181928072,
0.0583615191,
0.0180873983,
0.0355023071,
0.0032230888,
0.0464527607,
-0.028673498,
0.0592627749,
0.0630848557,
0.0229253322,
-0.0173403397,
-0.0346842371,
0.0093990099,
-0.0266672242,
-0.0142083792,
-0.0581348538,
0.0081627276,
-0.0479076877,
-0.0329519063,
-0.057281211,
-0.0150686353,
-0.0495607592,
-0.0051599978,
0.0163257271,
0.0198286623,
-0.0408817008,
0.0117118508,
-0.0190884024,
0.0577126779,
-0.0752766058,
0.0143130869,
-0.0370000973,
0.0593564771,
0.0278444812,
0.0119643575,
-0.0329940356,
0.0231680721,
0.0043792399,
0.003070812,
-0.0244785901,
0.0422256663,
0.03983704,
0.0139023019,
-0.0338035822,
0.0186752956,
-0.0410622023,
0.0306590758,
-0.0277623218,
0.0440824553,
0.0268064216,
-0.0041964897,
0.0724815726,
-0.0514064357,
0.0040096389,
0.0038242044,
0.0779233798,
0.0049155178,
-0.0225722361,
-0.0096896542,
-0.0096631395,
-0.0180860367,
-0.027787054,
0.0691919476,
0.0461029969,
-0.0027863751,
0.0092871087,
0.013574888,
-0.0380176641,
0.00019815,
0.0355977453,
-0.0109129092,
0.027034862,
0.0204689018,
-0.035514567,
-0.0119287688,
0.052921962,
-0.0336262137,
0.0144521585,
0.0001652533,
0.0528762154,
-0.0003936666,
-0.0336341076,
0.0112288613,
-0.0548004694,
-0.0072816117,
0.0286730491,
-0.0161335506,
-0.0320119709,
-6.643789746e-33,
-0.0293487236,
-0.0408507958,
0.0038451746,
0.0282582249,
-0.0272470731,
0.0156582706,
-0.0369768925,
0.0055996426,
0.064024061,
0.0201740135,
-0.0016577764,
0.0025103202,
-0.0134353423,
0.0684652627,
0.0016990115,
-0.0041516782,
0.0692937374,
-0.0041745086,
-0.0486201867,
0.0715382248,
0.0677498356,
0.0348209366,
0.0198456459,
-0.0670700148,
-0.0035838112,
-0.0431027934,
-0.0396657549,
-0.0309236459,
0.0353600718,
0.0148440087,
0.0110745747,
0.0423085093,
0.0162410419,
-0.0109159416,
-0.0266853701,
0.0434451811,
-0.0410766453,
-0.0578506477,
-0.031761907,
-0.0168763865,
0.0000638222,
-0.0475376323,
0.0228598062,
-0.017892899,
0.0008790249,
0.0217945743,
0.0487186499,
0.003932348,
-0.0065473868,
-0.1016604006,
-0.103823483,
0.011735105,
-0.0020020548,
-0.0160510521,
-0.0080971709,
0.02044186,
-0.0174723212,
-0.0095859878,
-0.0150072258,
0.0343985297,
-0.0036160704,
0.0284789111,
-0.0174157172,
0.0277739502,
0.0006497414,
0.0549381375,
0.0050198026,
0.0418289192,
-0.0467122793,
0.0608833469,
0.0264773723,
0.0424826853,
0.0177468155,
0.0515865646,
0.0056903544,
-0.0746912807,
-0.0481143706,
0.017039381,
-0.0107636238,
-0.0200147498,
0.0132711511,
-0.0085696988,
-0.0201979112,
-0.0305939037,
-0.0175383128,
-0.0061696232,
-0.011051069,
-0.0122830281,
0.027957892,
0.0628657266,
-0.0667914972,
-0.0046002129,
0.0068230778,
0.0110101774,
-0.0157191232,
-0.0053284536,
-0.0648540705,
0.0639036447,
-0.0166369732,
-0.0230547879,
-0.0513388216,
-0.0580502339,
0.0502294376,
-0.0018570854,
0.0126824994,
0.032272622,
0.0785235986,
0.0554106124,
-0.079090856,
0.0033648796,
-0.0274586733,
0.0344393253,
0.0348022096,
-0.0092117339,
-0.004736274,
-0.000357852,
0.0095555717,
0.0505501851,
0.0158393476,
-0.000865485,
-0.0120790629,
-0.0629193857,
0.0174047872,
0.0183184557,
-0.0617768951,
0.008813804,
-0.021810744,
0.005245802,
0.0255202856,
-0.1021055207,
-0.0143017722,
-0.0188132878,
2.732e-7,
0.0124151511,
0.0394183472,
0.0079020848,
0.0216957219,
0.0062720529,
0.0214342233,
0.0159191377,
0.0428303853,
-0.0200864524,
0.0044336063,
0.0226171538,
0.0233691577,
0.0308445692,
-0.0090825185,
-0.0719393864,
0.0169498343,
-0.0431170166,
0.0431467518,
-0.0480765179,
-0.0338885672,
0.0767712593,
0.0218898021,
-0.0011625172,
-0.0145484302,
0.0324529372,
-0.0147220073,
0.1026451886,
0.0083711408,
0.0087362099,
0.0111094443,
0.0226083789,
0.0156450681,
-0.0148041984,
-0.0326199792,
-0.0613432974,
-0.0098690614,
-0.0087306397,
0.0874359608,
-0.0033038734,
-0.0209393967,
0.0659582019,
0.0089659775,
0.0134206209,
-0.0093623074,
0.0704966784,
-0.0641434565,
0.0109211961,
-0.022247918,
0.0252713989,
0.001647451,
-0.0044445712,
-0.0612123869,
-0.031507764,
0.0235540308,
0.0157703198,
0.0180227421,
-0.0158299506,
-0.0495272428,
-0.02484533,
-0.0128616095,
0.0023736828,
-0.0015132712,
-0.0629426017,
0.0177103281,
-0.0076387255,
-0.0669585317,
-0.0102914134,
2.824145611e-34,
0.0161766838,
-0.0556887239,
0.0043159416,
-0.0079571027,
-0.0003704494,
0.0159013122,
0.014337427,
0.0290915482,
0.0361567289,
-0.0236171447,
-0.0097957505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06925v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06925v2 | A Thorough Examination of Decoding Methods in the Era of LLMs | 2024-02-10T11:14:53 | 2024-06-17T14:34:05 | Chufan Shi, Haoran Yang, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Yifan Wang, Yujiu Yang, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Decoding methods play an indispensable role in converting language models
from next-token predictors into practical task solvers. Prior research on
decoding methods, primarily focusing on task-specific models, may not extend to
the current era of general-purpose large language models (LLMs). Moreover, the
recent influx of decoding strategies has further complicated this landscape.
This paper provides a comprehensive and multifaceted analysis of various
decoding methods within the context of LLMs, evaluating their performance,
robustness to hyperparameter changes, and decoding speeds across a wide range
of tasks, models, and deployment environments. Our findings reveal that
decoding method performance is notably task-dependent and influenced by factors
such as alignment, model size, and quantization. Intriguingly, sensitivity
analysis exposes that certain methods achieve superior performance at the cost
of extensive hyperparameter tuning, highlighting the trade-off between
attaining optimal results and the practicality of implementation in varying
contexts. | [
0.0028412044,
0.0616081282,
0.0163990632,
0.0417410173,
-0.0307952054,
0.0138617968,
-0.0057581319,
0.0122268805,
-0.0298076235,
-0.0497762486,
0.002048007,
-0.0429985039,
0.0108306278,
0.0064187222,
0.0162005555,
0.0088557601,
0.0450145416,
-0.0654779598,
0.0009813424,
0.0101183159,
-0.032419093,
0.0257844739,
0.0082104951,
0.0748924613,
0.0264661498,
-0.0179179069,
-0.0090450952,
0.0437550955,
-0.0114773735,
-0.015243005,
0.0058977432,
0.0407603309,
0.0248651505,
0.0411465243,
0.000001549,
-0.0301601551,
-0.0192326661,
0.003265633,
-0.0428446308,
0.0443350971,
0.032585267,
-0.0679476932,
-0.0218159575,
0.0389859565,
-0.0260636397,
-0.0402498208,
0.0659302548,
-0.0109549165,
0.0150215803,
0.0610953607,
-0.0010796675,
-0.0096533904,
0.0313533507,
0.0118175885,
-0.0491295196,
-0.0719794407,
0.025957359,
0.0121640703,
-0.0165037196,
-0.0061365911,
-0.0417257659,
0.0234543551,
-0.0233488958,
0.0244624708,
-0.0244476032,
0.0096638305,
-0.0152994348,
-0.0072085401,
-0.0531663075,
0.0225052889,
-0.0282677244,
-0.0282948203,
-0.00180204,
0.0107435696,
-0.0334437378,
-0.0329748094,
-0.02878608,
0.0046150144,
-0.0011906789,
0.038885504,
0.0274871215,
-0.0149828997,
0.0160040073,
0.0037393384,
-0.0621661879,
0.0923477933,
0.0270295106,
-0.0116214883,
0.0063064545,
-0.0069149425,
-0.0014253355,
-0.0516252182,
0.0400352702,
0.0282125734,
-0.0337414928,
0.0093492242,
-0.0544246659,
-0.0500786491,
-0.0067518344,
-0.0200907663,
0.0614711419,
0.068469815,
0.008751113,
0.0230459571,
-0.0071717352,
0.0719045177,
-0.0362351127,
-0.0086126905,
-0.0471860208,
-0.0068620807,
-0.0328654833,
-0.0262047611,
-0.0457651541,
0.0157033261,
-0.0345707126,
-0.0346387178,
-0.0140311727,
0.0428262018,
0.0510630198,
-0.0167270675,
0.0441692993,
-0.0242014099,
-0.0336980745,
-0.007441442,
0.0234439112,
0.083420001,
-0.0051750424,
-0.0085066166,
-0.0185230672,
-0.0333580375,
-0.0187144522,
0.0169730037,
-0.0049125128,
-0.0608158298,
-0.0135435415,
0.0838817805,
-0.0100402646,
-0.0155837247,
-0.0006293748,
-0.007036279,
-0.0274112895,
-0.0535120703,
0.0067311558,
-0.0439191572,
0.0104125384,
0.0281425342,
0.0157904048,
-0.0498644486,
-0.0057589598,
-0.034621682,
-0.0230064169,
0.0558457896,
-0.0018678885,
0.0246356614,
-0.0029382918,
-0.0243822224,
0.018236164,
0.1222215369,
0.0115134437,
0.0366307236,
0.0206428897,
-0.0181343835,
-0.0062360698,
0.078970626,
-0.0126320627,
0.0149794705,
-0.032501515,
-0.0127010401,
0.0506410562,
0.0118518928,
0.0541035198,
0.0379550494,
-0.0328054428,
0.0177690946,
0.0408345424,
0.048394125,
0.0495186895,
0.0157367419,
0.0312499143,
0.0340816602,
-0.0049476326,
-0.0162530802,
-0.0090436134,
-0.0082138525,
-0.0130115058,
0.0111217452,
0.026180042,
0.0854838341,
-0.0029994308,
-0.0199970268,
-0.0339217819,
-0.0124269882,
-0.0283971969,
0.0198743399,
0.0764050409,
-0.0251171701,
-0.0575613007,
0.0720853508,
0.0025513538,
-0.0209487136,
0.0059091463,
-0.0523565151,
-0.0274865553,
0.0774916708,
0.0552339256,
-0.0036016505,
-0.0474906527,
0.022667218,
0.0209520366,
0.0063776555,
-0.0043640439,
0.00534264,
0.0269732103,
-0.0577485822,
-0.0504017211,
0.0511535518,
0.0166380219,
0.0199569277,
0.0093268175,
0.0016232041,
0.0181510504,
-0.0528231747,
-0.0418095514,
0.0469845869,
-0.0076650842,
-0.0230044927,
0.0210120864,
-0.0132466853,
0.019992752,
0.0414038338,
-0.0057371692,
0.0048314463,
0.03023142,
-0.0512679592,
0.0211578812,
-0.0151413484,
-0.0083479583,
-0.0493653901,
0.0484792739,
0.0000691407,
0.0323186778,
0.0647463724,
-0.0340482071,
-0.030081518,
0.0336226262,
-0.0149514955,
0.0474827811,
-0.032914646,
0.0322508737,
-0.0375308394,
0.0100699924,
-0.0409360379,
0.0061729401,
-0.0185720567,
-0.0218872353,
0.0104221441,
-0.0148904817,
-0.0001674346,
-0.0259355549,
-0.0133043993,
0.0650531724,
-0.0125097502,
0.0279151965,
-0.0155633911,
0.0093386415,
0.010911149,
-0.0390133373,
-0.0768555552,
0.0035262227,
-0.0462981574,
0.0431136079,
0.0113036493,
0.0035166701,
-0.0010094495,
0.0064980751,
-0.0103978729,
-0.0179902688,
-0.0057424824,
0.0056212759,
-0.018490795,
0.0105266264,
-0.0454505719,
-0.0432355851,
-0.0538978875,
-0.0206711125,
0.0738804638,
-0.0580598935,
-0.0508335494,
-0.1096107066,
0.0431840569,
-0.0099581676,
0.0280735921,
-0.0179311559,
-0.0341015495,
0.0002368584,
-0.0604661629,
0.0154396901,
0.0292775277,
-0.0217446666,
0.0174732823,
0.0606316887,
-0.009547771,
-0.0665359497,
-0.0047766562,
-0.0299816113,
-0.0554792024,
-0.0780359358,
-0.0467460155,
0.0262214821,
0.0957810506,
-0.0055846497,
-0.019496141,
-0.0634546876,
-0.011216145,
-0.0369907171,
-0.0410818942,
-0.0262537617,
-0.0013517446,
-0.0198439006,
0.0456991121,
0.005836369,
-0.0443056598,
0.0508090109,
-0.0367087498,
-0.0069052107,
-0.0438995399,
-0.0089350035,
-0.0500955507,
0.0354403593,
-0.026421899,
0.0117500303,
-0.0210006218,
-0.0723213255,
0.0090057785,
0.0264963955,
-0.0202455912,
-0.0352602266,
0.0308168735,
-0.0320984051,
0.0263915565,
-0.0301454086,
-0.0232760534,
-0.0103354678,
0.0014847795,
-0.0268828254,
0.0214163493,
0.0260961447,
-0.0221899617,
-0.0250032302,
0.0412437953,
-0.0338999406,
0.0240967218,
-0.0355759822,
0.0051292176,
-0.0407384671,
0.0184323005,
0.0570308156,
0.0007361213,
0.0374436267,
-0.0216255318,
0.0160247777,
0.0388606712,
0.0705540925,
0.010731346,
-0.0393650644,
0.0175831057,
0.0872340053,
-0.0022919115,
0.0099676661,
0.0502056442,
0.0448414907,
-0.0475703813,
-0.004164529,
0.1115385294,
0.0386518873,
-0.0569363944,
0.0084858453,
-0.0229107961,
0.0633491427,
0.0192368254,
0.0315185227,
-0.0544239879,
-0.0251400098,
0.027337715,
0.0413456224,
0.0133962259,
-0.0041940464,
-0.0093081798,
-0.0717431977,
0.0414705463,
0.0494794548,
-0.0314766616,
-0.0220011417,
-0.0360827446,
-0.0244153962,
0.0028736473,
0.0525058359,
0.0492006987,
-0.003090451,
-0.003544417,
0.034885291,
-0.0324377939,
-0.0688655004,
-0.0141880987,
-0.0378750116,
0.0680773333,
0.0725506768,
0.0174151957,
0.0243602376,
0.0354647599,
0.0100540295,
0.0222863369,
0.0022125705,
-0.0181718078,
0.0024201015,
-0.0208058208,
0.0042309808,
0.0186117478,
0.0022679516,
-0.05255628,
0.0182099193,
0.0062944149,
0.0930237919,
-0.0242814403,
-0.0182605311,
-0.0016265701,
-0.0294183921,
0.0283270366,
0.0817173868,
0.019316595,
-0.020081507,
-0.0715319216,
-0.0325999148,
0.005613599,
-0.0564355962,
-0.0198285319,
0.0092005869,
-0.00011818,
-0.0305604115,
-0.0214981586,
-0.0229619611,
0.0678912699,
0.0205711946,
0.0094168233,
0.0476252437,
0.0019681037,
-0.0169538017,
-0.0619627573,
-0.0135752363,
-0.0191958994,
0.0174640473,
-0.0748188049,
0.0042764205,
0.0091641201,
-0.0015599385,
-0.0007251494,
0.0294227488,
-0.109040767,
-0.0686504096,
-0.000111835,
0.019993443,
0.0257456191,
0.0379851982,
-0.0067565707,
-0.0727564245,
0.0116930129,
-0.008024374,
-0.0173401944,
0.0403262451,
0.0237925518,
-0.0038891989,
-0.0104834717,
0.0405958109,
-0.0558757149,
-0.001978298,
0.0012471301,
0.0741679147,
-0.0165100005,
-0.0285850167,
-0.002354031,
0.0206368789,
0.0197452605,
-0.023104839,
-0.0268573817,
0.023502633,
0.0307815336,
-0.0281871315,
0.0246125441,
-0.0410788767,
0.0273164753,
0.0459715873,
0.0055268682,
0.0049668299,
0.0042237178,
0.0099831866,
0.0283085424,
-0.0405179076,
0.022301048,
-0.0252514184,
0.0041797031,
0.0729897767,
-0.0166808888,
-0.0060607945,
0.011828023,
0.0337536409,
0.016838735,
-0.0262014344,
0.0235798974,
0.0007439732,
0.0188634414,
-0.0442717671,
0.0349138677,
-0.0386906788,
-0.0618316606,
-0.0328547806,
-0.0096976683,
0.0591799952,
0.0373895131,
0.0792117119,
-0.0185104925,
-0.0105612176,
-0.0265789609,
0.0153523963,
-0.0025798278,
0.0068127839,
0.0269306935,
0.0162813906,
-0.0414132848,
0.0002008827,
0.0597455762,
0.0417905115,
0.0369762704,
-0.0003839538,
-0.0286485534,
-0.0244425721,
-0.037412405,
-0.0204584077,
0.0145753743,
-0.0521572903,
-0.0211025048,
-0.0387224294,
-0.041523695,
0.0356973149,
-0.0030555555,
-0.0197764281,
-0.0403712206,
-0.0117364544,
0.0599253587,
-0.007551779,
-0.0257124547,
-0.027879376,
-0.0326955505,
-0.0109629799,
-0.016950883,
-0.0231852625,
-5.778097666e-33,
-0.027640393,
0.0119687058,
0.0232016202,
-0.0361894332,
-0.0516719893,
0.0008436934,
-0.0276413076,
0.0001940761,
0.0197899081,
-0.0204968471,
-0.0075728358,
0.0001115332,
0.0298040994,
0.0224672016,
-0.0032867894,
-0.0021687513,
0.0431878008,
-0.0334793516,
-0.0186531655,
-0.0097366115,
0.0343326069,
0.0470192023,
0.0444888584,
-0.02008765,
0.000358433,
0.0266354214,
0.0131452661,
0.0203317087,
0.0206193347,
0.0415760241,
-0.030731,
0.0322125889,
0.0092962068,
-0.0255301222,
-0.0523465537,
0.0115459962,
-0.076248318,
0.0148211373,
0.0423233695,
0.0304595176,
-0.0010566079,
-0.0502893738,
0.0028975322,
0.0259242877,
-0.0529521182,
-0.0205572899,
-0.011940009,
-0.0178066902,
-0.0467538349,
-0.0625489876,
-0.0641738921,
0.0192834567,
-0.0180716552,
0.0364691019,
0.1010706723,
0.0498924032,
-0.0171651691,
0.0198424682,
-0.0372384191,
0.0076455045,
0.0312408712,
0.0648229569,
0.1145150512,
0.0631084889,
-0.0116134984,
0.0267489385,
0.0477352589,
-0.0280146711,
-0.0248915739,
0.014514639,
0.0699688196,
0.0023720572,
-0.0008893863,
0.0124386391,
0.0065514189,
-0.0082183266,
-0.0382853635,
-0.0036000041,
0.0042659952,
0.0054907301,
0.0753113851,
0.048760429,
-0.0501775928,
-0.0483962186,
-0.0428076163,
-0.0007962573,
-0.0434697978,
-0.0329106934,
0.0537937135,
0.0025468199,
-0.0460855626,
0.0025600574,
0.0849895701,
-0.0431698449,
-0.0030974704,
0.0406627767,
-0.0020050833,
0.0470108464,
-0.0214493535,
0.0532047376,
-0.0326211229,
-0.0345516168,
0.0252198055,
-0.0069324351,
0.0300627798,
-0.0393267423,
-0.0430682749,
0.0145374825,
-0.048978135,
-0.0113658821,
-0.0410382785,
0.0276498888,
0.0151112406,
0.05044581,
0.0605313256,
-0.0318959244,
0.0156518258,
0.0102748601,
0.0094712069,
-0.0133209713,
-0.0086024562,
0.0150174284,
0.0271342825,
0.0201690104,
-0.0270640552,
0.0117635718,
-0.04559521,
-0.004853304,
0.0455361307,
-0.0237341914,
-0.0388036072,
0.0476420298,
2.246e-7,
0.0585268661,
0.0643962845,
0.0621089153,
-0.0136873908,
0.0102775563,
-0.0108966008,
-0.0037268386,
0.0014069532,
0.0443106778,
0.0038341486,
0.0144084804,
0.0395689756,
0.0612599924,
-0.019122405,
-0.0591740571,
0.0048932624,
-0.011695832,
0.0136519261,
-0.0824647322,
-0.0123138446,
0.0359641351,
0.0902580246,
-0.0308326185,
-0.0075810873,
0.0105761476,
-0.0028615484,
0.0053752204,
-0.0293970518,
0.0055244807,
0.0355851762,
-0.0011105963,
-0.0357063226,
-0.0048605478,
0.0091876602,
0.0241054874,
0.0176330283,
0.0054058698,
0.0740686357,
-0.0151127726,
-0.0508494191,
-0.0073604234,
0.0095718196,
0.0006613344,
-0.0396456681,
0.067410022,
-0.0264705122,
-0.0226187892,
-0.0436954051,
-0.0140261343,
-0.0264708009,
-0.0577961318,
-0.0433354639,
0.0373888835,
0.0443719551,
0.0181205142,
-0.0243781563,
-0.0013899283,
-0.0555504262,
-0.0254931729,
0.0115505382,
-0.0600972548,
-0.05848708,
-0.0328577049,
0.0214056931,
0.0187045801,
-0.0509691425,
0.0109552043,
2.579279118e-34,
0.0467145666,
-0.0003842172,
0.0465135984,
0.0737542063,
0.016615849,
-0.0267498717,
-0.0285688285,
0.0477134287,
-0.017297823,
-0.1154353172,
-0.0253557842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06918v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06918v2 | Generating Chain-of-Thoughts with a Pairwise-Comparison Approach to Searching for the Most Promising Intermediate Thought | 2024-02-10T09:51:03 | 2024-06-26T05:47:52 | Zhen-Yu Zhang, Siwei Han, Huaxiu Yao, Gang Niu, Masashi Sugiyama | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | To improve the ability of the large language model (LLMs) to tackle complex
reasoning problems, chain-of-thoughts (CoT) methods were proposed to guide LLMs
to reason step-by-step, enabling problem solving from simple to complex.
State-of-the-art methods for generating such a chain involve interactive
collaboration, where the learner generates candidate intermediate thoughts,
evaluated by the LLM, guiding the generation of subsequent thoughts. However, a
widespread yet understudied problem is that the evaluation from the LLM is
typically noisy and unreliable, potentially misleading the generation process
in selecting promising intermediate thoughts. In this paper, motivated by
Vapnik's principle, we use pairwise-comparison evaluation instead of point-wise
scoring to search for promising intermediate thoughts with the noisy feedback
from the LLM. In each round, we randomly pair intermediate thoughts and
directly prompt the LLM to select the more promising one from each pair,
allowing us to identify the most promising thoughts through an iterative
process. To further alleviate the noise in the comparison, we incorporate
techniques from ensemble learning and dueling bandits, proposing two variants
of the algorithm. Experiments on three real-world tasks demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed algorithm and verify the rationale of the
pairwise comparison mechanism. | [
0.0381288044,
0.0430725403,
-0.0063319872,
0.032870084,
-0.0735985711,
0.0163296238,
0.0083394172,
-0.0208801646,
0.0260140393,
-0.0352732576,
-0.0183915216,
-0.0406767726,
-0.0277605318,
-0.0156669468,
0.0258064438,
-0.0576530583,
0.0100589264,
-0.0716281608,
0.0081094997,
-0.0299297478,
0.007354585,
-0.0142615661,
-0.0278791022,
0.0411476903,
0.0310255997,
-0.0036927834,
-0.0257680044,
-0.0122721558,
0.031428773,
-0.065022707,
-0.0258372221,
0.0572315566,
0.0225886106,
0.0477468707,
0.0000025271,
-0.0634388104,
-0.0405158848,
-0.0257891975,
-0.0171122029,
-0.0153022194,
-0.019721007,
0.0800246447,
0.0097562056,
0.04233367,
-0.0464143716,
-0.0120789958,
0.0244637821,
0.0494610406,
0.0436787233,
0.0098899901,
0.0234985035,
-0.0402367301,
0.005112764,
-0.0154869407,
0.0370910056,
-0.0669071674,
0.0209060106,
0.0274316594,
0.0260735955,
0.0130897416,
0.0079307379,
0.0016734937,
0.0212775618,
-0.0116584403,
0.049814336,
0.0435990766,
-0.0050957981,
-0.0224101152,
0.0010245785,
0.0516674928,
-0.0244961679,
-0.0128150396,
0.0042410414,
-0.0220839642,
0.0224430952,
0.0230569765,
-0.0422464274,
0.0419615768,
-0.0356926732,
0.0169052314,
0.0303431582,
0.0518385842,
0.0185769089,
0.0241863392,
-0.0485605411,
0.0283681601,
-0.0261791088,
-0.042560339,
0.0686598942,
0.0317938626,
-0.0530424081,
-0.0517158881,
0.0343294814,
0.0211374182,
-0.0629241914,
0.0025422212,
0.0022063518,
-0.0344678573,
-0.0231738724,
-0.0036598223,
0.0866886675,
0.0076475078,
0.0348853432,
0.0462451428,
-0.0421834774,
-0.0104376115,
-0.0146928085,
-0.0180659518,
-0.0592642613,
0.0142065277,
-0.0656499416,
-0.0001629149,
-0.0487581789,
0.073431775,
0.0004659713,
-0.0257660747,
-0.0370262861,
0.0256389827,
-0.0262823254,
0.0271249563,
-0.0023973018,
0.0128164142,
0.0625945032,
-0.0188386291,
-0.0440777801,
-0.0137193622,
-0.0350699387,
0.0131876851,
0.0326191001,
-0.0066583678,
-0.0002334798,
-0.0102731893,
-0.0169813391,
-0.0257204846,
0.031155739,
0.0489514135,
-0.0374405086,
-0.0291845445,
-0.0034319311,
-0.0302834604,
-0.0012141217,
-0.0415286086,
0.0073046517,
-0.0950893909,
-0.0006651426,
-0.0021832238,
-0.0109912651,
0.0072663273,
0.0393902548,
0.0298341736,
-0.038353648,
0.0802431628,
-0.0178984776,
0.0135720205,
0.0375764742,
0.0057388851,
-0.0311486945,
0.0292153768,
0.0554878004,
0.0441301093,
-0.0058389604,
0.0303015057,
0.035113059,
0.0323681124,
-0.0031674311,
-0.0521458574,
0.0124837784,
-0.0083743865,
0.0157889463,
0.0906435847,
-0.0401012003,
0.0442494079,
-0.060296569,
0.0583358593,
0.0682973191,
0.0209578518,
0.021606192,
0.032529328,
0.0242987517,
0.0029059178,
-0.0260123704,
0.0011745635,
-0.0174273755,
0.0817599818,
-0.0631233454,
0.0032100547,
0.0547915921,
0.0450166538,
-0.0049906867,
-0.0394493192,
-0.012864342,
0.0387653261,
0.0084727593,
0.040271651,
0.0431211516,
-0.0067911916,
-0.0581768639,
-0.0023736695,
0.0096065337,
-0.0050566085,
-0.0426121205,
-0.0711268783,
0.0323109366,
0.0728334486,
0.0543234982,
-0.0140239364,
0.0081115691,
-0.0234051254,
-0.0243163239,
0.0003145473,
0.0103905872,
0.0018380601,
-0.0524230562,
-0.0814092681,
-0.0415794179,
0.0165011175,
-0.0046087042,
-0.0054247743,
0.013660335,
-0.0153038269,
-0.0058210571,
0.0228231307,
-0.01855422,
0.0148323514,
0.0071649197,
0.0042157425,
0.0153846256,
0.0293816272,
0.0098600723,
0.0026269618,
-0.0075235041,
0.0381508097,
0.0113252718,
-0.0412282646,
-0.0266419165,
0.0139354477,
-0.0493974835,
-0.0680680647,
-0.0001890645,
-0.035196919,
-0.0034583791,
-0.0134833017,
-0.0122582512,
-0.020465536,
0.0001708608,
-0.0464983657,
-0.0348190665,
-0.0240433402,
0.0335989259,
0.0068161143,
-0.0113615179,
-0.0644985512,
0.0710520819,
-0.0159279667,
0.0146725047,
-0.0132657718,
0.019028889,
0.0100628706,
-0.05184168,
-0.0211696327,
0.012887829,
0.0097729405,
-0.0033175582,
0.0216046851,
0.0231338367,
-0.0562452823,
-0.0775682926,
-0.1033633724,
-0.0224396773,
0.0241303425,
-0.001721405,
-0.01965704,
-0.0242008138,
0.005167996,
0.0117464485,
-0.0175334122,
0.0472880825,
0.0144112231,
0.0056368397,
0.0272692777,
-0.0043314178,
-0.0382519849,
-0.0104427058,
-0.000383741,
-0.0167329125,
0.063545309,
0.012942045,
-0.0467115827,
-0.046171613,
0.0556649268,
-0.0363347717,
0.0120468969,
-0.0096815154,
-0.0109057222,
0.0352830961,
-0.0390130058,
0.0385920145,
0.1032984853,
0.0274032988,
0.0128280846,
0.0843152404,
-0.0341642126,
-0.0574719645,
0.0181592088,
0.0116332117,
-0.0052343407,
0.0287336092,
-0.0173738655,
-0.0107474113,
0.058739461,
-0.0067360471,
-0.0051670559,
-0.0575966127,
0.0516336896,
0.0136448275,
-0.0380691402,
-0.0494298078,
-0.0179352555,
0.0032551612,
0.044176165,
-0.0052885576,
-0.0160037335,
0.0969910398,
0.0035293244,
0.004747414,
-0.0499512851,
0.0045226957,
-0.0355434939,
0.0675731748,
-0.0059033595,
0.0008934098,
0.0109939585,
0.0000726813,
-0.0747929215,
0.0001982448,
0.0229848605,
-0.0437548943,
0.0419706926,
-0.0615007728,
-0.0069901012,
0.0061623957,
-0.0479986519,
-0.0441258959,
0.0051403427,
-0.0527243726,
0.0117293857,
0.0360167697,
0.0161432829,
-0.0383628085,
-0.0162110161,
0.0644734204,
0.0178099945,
-0.0038376502,
-0.0289048795,
0.0155956987,
0.0485898405,
0.0249552391,
-0.0278433468,
0.0607766621,
-0.0589858741,
0.0760749355,
0.0447463468,
0.0582967885,
0.0174764078,
-0.0288964231,
-0.01605797,
0.0047153989,
-0.0014964377,
-0.028713163,
0.025187999,
0.0363671221,
-0.0478589572,
-0.0403469615,
0.1049779207,
0.0375616699,
-0.0358354077,
-0.0023306401,
-0.0374697037,
0.0362684429,
0.0140968766,
0.0479153804,
-0.0469741784,
-0.0407428332,
0.0049015661,
-0.0035042046,
-0.0508673638,
-0.074638553,
0.0068877512,
-0.1350700855,
0.0216938015,
0.0182962697,
-0.0048204511,
0.0245083049,
-0.0040046484,
-0.0281844512,
0.0106978165,
-0.0370757431,
0.0249358062,
0.0114453873,
0.0244075842,
0.020637691,
-0.0177206602,
0.0040859166,
0.0497961715,
-0.0604670122,
0.0517304987,
0.0836878642,
0.0189878307,
0.0138784321,
-0.0139317866,
0.0191220567,
-0.0135995606,
0.0259876773,
-0.0098233437,
0.0023057563,
-0.0057389503,
-0.0015696037,
-0.0318862014,
0.0318259038,
0.0003669511,
-0.0257976707,
0.0486128144,
0.0714519173,
-0.028793171,
-0.0299920831,
0.0055405069,
0.0503789373,
0.0034334832,
0.06149064,
0.016548207,
-0.0695298836,
-0.0058993157,
-0.0087299207,
-0.0278912298,
-0.0591651052,
-0.0213911906,
0.0048900479,
0.0816662461,
0.070373863,
-0.0771683529,
-0.0402166732,
0.0525987372,
0.0466170423,
-0.0255689863,
0.0482278541,
-0.0431457721,
0.0532349944,
-0.0103503745,
-0.0111045241,
-0.0142737199,
0.0257705003,
-0.0491663367,
0.0094216112,
0.0131197888,
-0.0778887495,
-0.0316037685,
0.0349898003,
-0.0864955857,
-0.0527017489,
-0.0171056837,
0.0740483999,
0.0201753732,
0.0174134634,
0.0020427485,
-0.0767814741,
0.0453941524,
0.0513587967,
0.0273854509,
0.0237385854,
-0.0212242883,
0.0435756035,
0.0221974049,
0.0230083577,
-0.0236425046,
-0.0068376726,
0.0310208686,
0.0533479303,
-0.0249600336,
-0.0269842707,
0.0181893241,
0.0091663143,
0.0200241916,
-0.0313064083,
0.0068102921,
-0.029004721,
0.0402759239,
0.0268444642,
-0.0313090086,
-0.0435571298,
0.0279235654,
0.0327263921,
-0.0120846508,
0.0364144035,
-0.0190029386,
0.046402622,
0.0236216467,
-0.0169470627,
-0.0016142305,
0.0078679305,
0.0193125494,
0.033717297,
-0.0144726979,
-0.0188540686,
0.005264123,
-0.0008196563,
0.0287874322,
0.0055407174,
0.1087987572,
0.0368341766,
-0.041261673,
-0.0261689909,
0.0476187207,
-0.0632806197,
-0.0941353738,
-0.0200923886,
0.0540342815,
0.0633142143,
0.0438934714,
-0.0028674302,
-0.0467852354,
0.0185633544,
0.0028822138,
0.0098307282,
-0.0343141221,
-0.0656666607,
0.0153575456,
0.0330758616,
0.0248389728,
-0.0154343015,
0.0478557013,
-0.0530175753,
0.0017765288,
0.009961986,
0.0047543664,
-0.0497306138,
-0.0138211194,
-0.0114933038,
0.0357083902,
-0.0216456037,
0.0472967736,
-0.0577659085,
-0.009419133,
-0.0097069405,
0.0328034386,
0.0169290323,
-0.0082942713,
0.0607051291,
0.0554048978,
-0.0208797213,
0.0096187592,
-0.0136643993,
0.0050741308,
0.0100375181,
-0.0231610257,
-0.0488414206,
-6.722942393e-33,
-0.0167313647,
-0.0605421588,
0.0495467931,
-0.0257913526,
-0.0340995863,
-0.044485271,
-0.0215439256,
0.0164203923,
-0.0016997374,
0.0000095404,
-0.0153695587,
-0.0236136019,
-0.0069889156,
0.0001209969,
0.0391174071,
0.0043237037,
0.0046472652,
0.0076146573,
-0.0148856938,
-0.0033959046,
0.0367214009,
0.0349806249,
0.0116928676,
-0.0436037406,
-0.0453566089,
0.000404276,
-0.0309048258,
0.0310663711,
-0.0608535483,
0.0476193838,
0.0047104959,
-0.030419562,
0.0165319368,
-0.0470362306,
0.0032671557,
-0.0094607007,
0.0080160629,
-0.0070632501,
-0.0017422726,
-0.015300733,
-0.0135767879,
-0.0331632048,
0.006194286,
-0.0144556351,
-0.031287834,
-0.029826602,
0.0172864813,
-0.0471953861,
-0.0282143056,
-0.0177950319,
-0.0054462901,
-0.005324631,
0.0063475692,
-0.033925999,
0.0061149998,
0.0249814633,
-0.02819103,
0.0063379267,
-0.0424859561,
0.0507786945,
0.0445692316,
0.0189555995,
0.0486795269,
0.008725754,
0.0148114199,
0.0444675907,
0.0371799357,
-0.0264791213,
-0.0374247245,
-0.0253677387,
-0.0173124634,
0.0278871469,
0.0689880699,
0.0291126687,
0.0296705626,
0.0738407448,
-0.0618823506,
-0.0095745288,
0.0240106639,
0.0131712742,
0.0731032789,
0.0191922188,
-0.0234068055,
-0.017840106,
-0.0636658743,
-0.0408932008,
-0.0457195826,
-0.0248220004,
0.0365412459,
0.0196546484,
-0.0086072301,
-0.0351431891,
0.0310339872,
-0.0115508484,
-0.0345558561,
-0.0068234075,
-0.0138955591,
0.0410027318,
-0.0205956157,
-0.0126657439,
-0.0788491741,
-0.0193553008,
0.0209256448,
0.0019693431,
-0.0060069738,
0.0360967144,
0.0050146766,
-0.0174166597,
-0.0415428691,
-0.0169504136,
-0.0664097294,
0.0134649938,
0.0031489916,
-0.0261747316,
0.0470856018,
0.0002467892,
-0.0149885463,
0.0420040861,
0.0040043099,
-0.0285879597,
-0.0194902662,
-0.0037850633,
-0.0308027398,
0.0068246098,
0.0164527763,
0.0302529149,
-0.0152658252,
-0.0218646359,
0.0260454323,
-0.023318572,
-0.0275199339,
0.0236613266,
3.214e-7,
-0.0332155898,
0.0785623491,
-0.0193747282,
-0.0061422763,
0.0094607817,
0.0697024465,
-0.0178400911,
-0.0132794408,
0.0402453765,
-0.0225279015,
0.0035621671,
0.0641301051,
0.0380843766,
0.0238420404,
-0.074748151,
-0.0493203104,
-0.0570483617,
-0.0120009528,
-0.0283479337,
-0.0372910947,
0.0734741688,
0.0595428646,
0.0330146886,
-0.0161740668,
0.0116368243,
-0.0212088171,
0.0712493435,
-0.0390217975,
-0.0117397076,
0.010682174,
0.0120407222,
-0.0619733073,
-0.0343273394,
0.048563052,
0.0233027264,
0.0056186058,
0.0065295435,
-0.0181551389,
0.0248441845,
0.0115398336,
-0.0000662931,
0.0119748367,
0.00108064,
-0.0782028511,
0.0532428212,
-0.0858519077,
-0.0085826479,
0.0339993536,
0.0116466144,
-0.043898847,
0.0263326224,
-0.0303844679,
0.0136625916,
-0.0047732801,
-0.0125772376,
0.0201392248,
0.0106162988,
-0.0736229271,
-0.0223506223,
0.0005779021,
-0.0343636684,
-0.0322090313,
-0.049137529,
0.0204285309,
-0.0099925166,
-0.0574713871,
-0.0235208124,
3.013343264e-34,
0.012178245,
-0.0266719162,
0.0254121702,
0.0295464359,
0.0244679935,
0.0153072607,
0.0082739284,
0.0185047425,
0.0237302575,
-0.0680560991,
-0.0155910449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06913v1 | TL;DR Progress: Multi-faceted Literature Exploration in Text Summarization | 2024-02-10T09:16:56 | 2024-02-10T09:16:56 | Shahbaz Syed, Khalid Al-Khatib, Martin Potthast | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents TL;DR Progress, a new tool for exploring the literature
on neural text summarization. It organizes 514~papers based on a comprehensive
annotation scheme for text summarization approaches and enables fine-grained,
faceted search. Each paper was manually annotated to capture aspects such as
evaluation metrics, quality dimensions, learning paradigms, challenges
addressed, datasets, and document domains. In addition, a succinct indicative
summary is provided for each paper, consisting of automatically extracted
contextual factors, issues, and proposed solutions. The tool is available
online at https://www.tldr-progress.de, a demo video at
https://youtu.be/uCVRGFvXUj8 | [
0.035360314,
0.0033385423,
0.0385203399,
-0.0159977749,
-0.0192258712,
-0.0058906311,
-0.0218516663,
-0.0565147996,
-0.0289417598,
-0.0265606567,
0.016782403,
0.0189297851,
0.0293216556,
0.0166908577,
0.0188030228,
-0.0932532251,
0.0186734013,
-0.0067686751,
0.0104228957,
0.0346988104,
-0.0005263838,
-0.012991569,
0.0015048357,
0.0500868149,
0.0405998677,
0.0007370643,
-0.0085730609,
-0.0175378993,
0.0553366393,
-0.0378649607,
0.0322847851,
-0.0279016607,
0.0201656837,
0.0120440051,
0.0000018818,
-0.0495414734,
-0.023091061,
-0.000282288,
0.0403284915,
0.0232365709,
0.0671841502,
-0.0643294901,
0.0254213922,
0.0047804117,
-0.0037805364,
0.0114952419,
-0.0017917684,
0.0516581796,
0.046015583,
0.0402819142,
-0.0098351846,
-0.0335868932,
0.0391541645,
-0.0305962116,
-0.0289078448,
-0.017375866,
0.0101302769,
0.0028888248,
0.0331875198,
-0.0183628313,
0.0123106334,
0.0635292232,
0.0111350911,
-0.0366825573,
0.0189294014,
0.0244983267,
-0.0309443194,
-0.0203098208,
0.0028383585,
0.0748054683,
0.0039274502,
0.0186197869,
0.0427149944,
-0.0200996548,
0.0208261907,
-0.0286463033,
-0.0790679604,
0.0557515435,
-0.0112490784,
0.0011430747,
-0.0193231832,
0.0654362962,
-0.0301529244,
0.0187933445,
0.0000230016,
0.0100773331,
-0.0211331733,
-0.0232538711,
-0.0403374173,
0.0050164317,
0.0235059187,
-0.0180370901,
0.0313843302,
0.046296265,
0.0216183923,
-0.0304104071,
-0.0163319279,
-0.076138556,
0.0481875315,
-0.0517356656,
-0.0002687157,
-0.0182675552,
0.0056878859,
0.0344476886,
0.0014014245,
-0.0100110397,
0.0079958579,
-0.020858068,
-0.049353119,
-0.0292576458,
-0.0081395786,
0.0104665225,
-0.0551778674,
0.0274266321,
-0.0050446582,
-0.0600543991,
-0.0290675815,
0.0140287653,
0.0162588377,
0.0122690471,
0.0073032207,
0.0402032398,
-0.0063831853,
-0.0002352386,
-0.0042973813,
0.0181740522,
-0.0478775054,
-0.0452430844,
0.0148330843,
0.0387614295,
-0.0024778687,
0.0341701172,
0.0075003803,
0.0114343632,
0.0320865437,
-0.0115158092,
-0.0143398354,
-0.0769568533,
-0.0056429855,
-0.0038276063,
-0.0018351643,
-0.0158038326,
0.0093316324,
-0.0596861802,
-0.0159357022,
-0.0359426849,
-0.0295853857,
-0.0181716271,
-0.0222399924,
0.0451974459,
-0.0612135902,
0.0222218912,
-0.0829336643,
-0.0411119871,
0.0626499429,
0.0140588377,
0.0132782217,
0.015098637,
0.0581173599,
0.0489663109,
0.0394362025,
0.0188459139,
0.0106849391,
-0.018277267,
0.0222117305,
-0.0330700241,
0.0351427495,
-0.0118388366,
-0.0566555299,
-0.0110951932,
-0.0142566785,
0.0469958261,
-0.0458000451,
0.015218148,
0.031627994,
0.0665545762,
0.018000016,
0.0195221901,
0.0282507855,
0.0239486676,
0.0711663365,
0.0300197247,
-0.0006683346,
0.0339021124,
-0.0186045691,
0.074209027,
0.0619035214,
0.0661796555,
-0.0052703051,
-0.0552099645,
0.043258667,
-0.002254928,
0.0341894105,
-0.0189133678,
0.0225741472,
0.0229489077,
-0.0537087359,
0.0011379608,
-0.0146743273,
-0.0308119245,
0.0105669452,
-0.0057955221,
0.0019346832,
0.0107566239,
0.0395375229,
-0.082980141,
-0.0638931096,
-0.0122584859,
-0.0128371948,
0.054316707,
0.0137426415,
-0.0160018858,
0.0084112324,
-0.0518360883,
-0.0235864408,
-0.0506706983,
-0.0199569482,
-0.0086176358,
-0.0496044606,
-0.0282126758,
0.0300789103,
0.0215681996,
-0.0787860826,
0.0418100283,
-0.0158798452,
-0.0051904987,
0.005308446,
-0.0334667601,
0.0153466985,
0.0424373634,
-0.0191226713,
0.0399354547,
0.030583594,
-0.0370411575,
-0.0029235,
0.0014183137,
-0.0082866112,
0.0003886135,
0.0295691807,
-0.0749631226,
-0.0021382554,
0.0113828937,
-0.0488975979,
-0.0447377525,
0.0427451432,
-0.0280911699,
-0.0174089912,
-0.0246499088,
-0.007509138,
0.0160406958,
0.0212926455,
-0.0231400914,
0.0633666217,
0.013027193,
-0.0158985574,
0.0660872087,
-0.0430168547,
0.008318427,
0.0073663252,
-0.0042199125,
0.0019889986,
-0.0039102864,
-0.0053233411,
0.0662141517,
0.0255878475,
-0.0210148133,
0.0108330837,
-0.0827521607,
0.0199725721,
-0.018466156,
0.0194204412,
0.0574725755,
0.0304275714,
-0.0037871322,
-0.0536162369,
-0.002469379,
-0.0205223039,
0.0241179112,
-0.0434939973,
0.0707925856,
0.0308077596,
0.0277065076,
-0.0506738573,
-0.0282922052,
-0.0022684529,
0.0306232553,
0.0131704081,
-0.0530274287,
-0.024876684,
-0.004304111,
-0.0169490408,
-0.0227986462,
-0.0038227623,
0.0280139484,
-0.0038260906,
0.0065628467,
0.0261358172,
0.0734965429,
0.0490749255,
-0.0077085737,
0.042174723,
0.0091916323,
-0.0031847111,
0.0136073446,
-0.0209301393,
0.074391447,
0.0072559901,
-0.0257650297,
0.0731345192,
0.0398480818,
0.0127077429,
0.0018463217,
-0.0074323099,
0.0250865929,
-0.0149781182,
0.0060426579,
-0.0360749252,
-0.0165957995,
0.0248070247,
-0.0073241019,
-0.0040394017,
0.0033165244,
0.0646529272,
-0.0434961952,
0.0001777467,
-0.0860759243,
-0.0502782576,
-0.0761793107,
0.0119123217,
0.0331024751,
0.0154626938,
0.0207527783,
-0.0232194308,
-0.0084051248,
-0.0443247221,
0.0090564135,
0.0223585218,
0.0441225804,
-0.0405181721,
0.0068146582,
-0.0470315553,
-0.0196025614,
0.0117312046,
-0.0468344204,
-0.0181895345,
0.031239206,
0.0227519497,
-0.0182950292,
-0.0490036346,
-0.0148788812,
0.047363624,
0.0767044798,
-0.0275845435,
-0.0542591214,
-0.0106028738,
0.0484764092,
0.0602652729,
-0.0042323866,
0.0522116087,
0.0090147965,
0.0163884088,
0.0272716284,
-0.0178677682,
0.0071043414,
-0.0264178626,
-0.0155242579,
-0.019082956,
-0.114443928,
0.0228952318,
-0.0222219098,
0.03532717,
-0.0248621479,
0.0105608301,
0.0920168087,
0.0176828597,
-0.058241114,
-0.0243003238,
-0.0001091815,
0.042167671,
-0.001582531,
0.0134435939,
-0.0216311458,
0.0135153979,
-0.0100301532,
0.0552563891,
0.0268551838,
-0.0181232952,
-0.0217168815,
-0.0128541524,
0.023235362,
-0.0172685646,
-0.0591316111,
-0.0054333601,
-0.0035234338,
0.0099359406,
-0.0298289564,
0.030271491,
0.0195752271,
-0.0585126355,
-0.0064334539,
0.0161600243,
-0.080567643,
-0.000726507,
-0.0392193161,
-0.0043308507,
-0.0097757503,
0.0486634336,
0.0359323733,
0.0096866861,
0.0439706184,
0.0454351082,
-0.0411908925,
-0.0044184602,
0.0020696986,
0.1090642661,
-0.0137303444,
0.0137568619,
-0.0406353436,
0.0416637398,
0.0061088311,
-0.0126058049,
0.0538155176,
-0.0030802863,
0.0080922823,
-0.0145669086,
-0.100329645,
0.0409306362,
-0.0623584203,
0.0434811004,
0.0287777744,
-0.0151765086,
-0.0352871716,
-0.0313766226,
-0.0136551876,
-0.072562471,
-0.0545924343,
-0.0108281653,
-0.0437698476,
-0.0137019381,
-0.050308086,
-0.0709728524,
0.0010487818,
-0.0302683245,
-0.0034132623,
0.0043442524,
0.0174246766,
0.0079530273,
-0.0348530784,
-0.0014540661,
0.0403882936,
-0.0158008654,
-0.0193884913,
0.023754973,
0.0857170671,
-0.0197038371,
-0.0320221335,
0.0054425164,
-0.0428525098,
-0.0288770404,
-0.0252481773,
0.067554757,
0.0147721684,
0.0581009015,
0.0092080664,
-0.0222564451,
0.0539205074,
0.0316018686,
0.0447084904,
-0.0085286694,
0.0217690207,
0.0278671458,
-0.0359888338,
-0.0165333152,
-0.0573645271,
0.054283265,
-0.0744735897,
0.0155197997,
-0.0406233892,
-0.0196464024,
-0.0060829567,
-0.0039770999,
0.0169913098,
-0.0326165855,
-0.0280752368,
-0.0386565253,
-0.0521510355,
-0.0028156408,
-0.0014461043,
-0.0204614308,
0.072914727,
-0.0101247914,
-0.003567866,
0.0126197208,
0.0792419687,
0.0128810722,
0.0159700755,
-0.0335543342,
0.0337749086,
-0.0004002241,
0.0142162498,
-0.0905169472,
-0.0183166862,
-0.0303939562,
-0.0333145186,
-0.0429264419,
0.0226851925,
-0.0143675935,
-0.0087567912,
0.0358379483,
-0.0079039661,
-0.0254587606,
0.0563021004,
-0.1204652339,
0.0166444145,
-0.0665393323,
0.0366277248,
0.0426555499,
-0.003805181,
0.0905583352,
0.0053970516,
-0.0126342177,
0.008246338,
0.0109317414,
0.0280636456,
0.0218077581,
-0.0797121748,
0.0074291695,
0.0155385425,
-0.0184998345,
0.0626315773,
-0.045694612,
-0.0110912677,
0.0356953591,
-0.0253341328,
-0.0420712084,
-0.0354503244,
-0.0096893609,
0.070115298,
0.0006375309,
-0.040578723,
-0.0241563097,
0.0197479557,
0.0208081957,
0.0298109036,
0.0058837151,
-0.0304501094,
0.0161249544,
0.0006298859,
0.0370483287,
-0.00797999,
-0.0514101163,
-0.0241523683,
-0.0059857843,
-0.0093826139,
0.0016973452,
-5.862809666e-33,
-0.0402956568,
-0.013167955,
-0.0218391661,
-0.0077968258,
-0.0644260347,
0.0296856333,
-0.0611921847,
-0.0408827849,
-0.0058110389,
-0.0082817171,
-0.0005643164,
0.0091485055,
-0.0005290185,
0.0394296087,
0.0373940617,
0.0506710634,
0.0219992865,
-0.0058722324,
-0.0163206421,
0.0507766046,
0.0047850339,
0.0297196358,
0.0279171225,
-0.069560729,
0.0384988673,
-0.0038893982,
-0.0246205814,
-0.0170710795,
0.0521459468,
0.0204928368,
-0.0153675042,
-0.0267259516,
0.0417481959,
-0.034301471,
-0.0425486229,
0.0052215704,
-0.0914157704,
-0.0417287536,
-0.00471838,
-0.044752676,
-0.0703861862,
-0.0236461479,
0.0491390079,
-0.0344140455,
0.0161860995,
-0.0080135753,
0.0836602002,
-0.0390435345,
-0.0396426879,
-0.0550737157,
-0.043664366,
0.0156276096,
-0.0694831908,
-0.0182416253,
0.0331903324,
0.0959768072,
0.0061598346,
0.024420334,
-0.0559263751,
0.0183728617,
0.0034350534,
0.0296595246,
0.0346846208,
0.0074903527,
0.0250202864,
0.02719515,
-0.0021718882,
0.0003195235,
-0.0211783014,
-0.0001150779,
-0.000858262,
0.0194100011,
0.0233143363,
-0.0060686665,
0.0286059286,
0.0566293783,
-0.0303878468,
0.0865876079,
0.0246458687,
0.0020387536,
0.0338636152,
-0.0002786027,
0.0330316052,
0.0092419907,
0.0193619244,
-0.0397755094,
0.0171878263,
-0.0130944159,
-0.0316839665,
0.039836213,
-0.0685037002,
-0.0351143554,
0.0094070183,
-0.0241058115,
0.0356499963,
0.0418925099,
-0.0089436527,
0.0385620594,
0.0384084322,
-0.0358771719,
-0.0283178557,
0.0227769781,
0.0014694649,
0.0330612808,
0.0086500058,
-0.0139253289,
0.0466076843,
-0.0088844039,
0.0137055796,
0.0147707937,
0.0466323085,
0.0221798029,
-0.0493484549,
0.0341015607,
-0.0420692004,
0.0143516157,
0.0018567322,
0.0170062128,
0.004714895,
-0.0009979026,
0.0095754405,
0.0264305957,
0.0527268648,
0.0233571883,
-0.0061247502,
0.0209478922,
-0.0175225958,
0.0459996946,
0.0485826284,
-0.0400834382,
-0.0057161562,
-0.0084646251,
2.472e-7,
0.0712626949,
0.0480810963,
0.0942523405,
0.008361388,
0.0161227845,
0.0107520996,
-0.0102366861,
0.0242202338,
0.0296900012,
0.0501573496,
0.0591375381,
0.0048743165,
0.0192932896,
0.0157072488,
-0.1033369675,
-0.0851269513,
-0.0774896666,
-0.0750063956,
-0.0467243977,
-0.0040557534,
0.0422089398,
0.046555981,
-0.0432171524,
0.0023073405,
-0.0233020447,
-0.0276432782,
0.0091713304,
-0.0085522169,
0.0050080256,
0.0331784636,
0.0228489451,
-0.011457094,
-0.0449079499,
-0.0722251609,
0.0071076592,
0.0045301691,
0.0318205208,
0.0233652517,
0.0323831663,
-0.0113705853,
0.0395830348,
0.0056202863,
0.0483174846,
0.0122553147,
0.0182239655,
-0.0770353451,
-0.0062576178,
-0.027181454,
-0.0012926802,
0.0272690952,
0.0447312631,
-0.0013794136,
-0.03474278,
0.0549357161,
-0.0238406397,
-0.0376130156,
-0.0123360921,
-0.0795812309,
-0.0338138603,
0.0330707617,
0.0299836118,
0.0374125876,
-0.015985813,
-0.0123029063,
0.0168279726,
-0.0448138714,
0.0119287809,
2.122141762e-34,
0.1112200171,
-0.0415734127,
-0.0338569768,
-0.0118309921,
0.0181620829,
-0.0220491253,
-0.0349996537,
-0.0138090756,
0.0119969686,
-0.0690637678,
-0.0128979264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06907v1 | Investigating Consistency in Query-Based Meeting Summarization: A Comparative Study of Different Embedding Methods | 2024-02-10T08:25:30 | 2024-02-10T08:25:30 | Chen Jia-Chen, Guillem Senabre, Allane Caron | cs.CL | cs.CL | With more and more advanced data analysis techniques emerging, people will
expect these techniques to be applied in more complex tasks and solve problems
in our daily lives. Text Summarization is one of famous applications in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) field. It aims to automatically generate summary with
important information based on a given context, which is important when you
have to deal with piles of documents. Summarization techniques can help capture
key points in a short time and bring convenience in works. One of applicable
situation is meeting summarization, especially for important meeting that tend
to be long, complicated, multi-topic and multi-person. Therefore, when people
want to review specific content from a meeting, it will be hard and
time-consuming to find the related spans in the meeting transcript. However,
most of previous works focus on doing summarization for newsletters, scientific
articles...etc, which have a clear document structure and an official format.
For the documents with complex structure like transcripts, we think those works
are not quite suitable for meeting summarization. Besides, the consistency of
summary is another issue common to be discussed in NLP field. To conquer
challenges of meeting summarization, we are inspired by "QMSum: A New Benchmark
for Query-based Multi-domain Meeting Summarization" proposed by Microsoft and
we also propose our Locater model designed to extract relevant spans based on
given transcript and query, which are then summarized by Summarizer model.
Furthermore, we perform a comparative study by applying different word
embedding techniques to improve summary consistency. | [
0.0535708666,
-0.0284391399,
0.0169551075,
0.0474225767,
-0.0328955837,
-0.0232581235,
-0.0475919954,
-0.0269091278,
-0.0003116282,
-0.0273015779,
-0.0078214016,
-0.044787731,
0.0319051817,
0.0040833955,
-0.0353552029,
-0.1068366021,
0.052344203,
0.0392472818,
-0.0158424992,
0.015496837,
0.052733846,
-0.0276326369,
0.0192272831,
0.020915363,
0.0143530471,
0.0124111371,
-0.0103154844,
-0.0237961169,
0.0276247561,
0.0016352576,
-0.0294137355,
0.0326144695,
0.0375174247,
0.0052992906,
0.0000018642,
-0.0444228649,
-0.0786380842,
-0.0036285175,
0.0404909328,
0.0234584399,
0.0391407423,
-0.0291482937,
0.0197805669,
0.0503019542,
-0.0226834696,
0.020413179,
-0.0037897658,
0.0957722515,
0.04463882,
0.0713445842,
-0.0141855804,
-0.0318019539,
-0.0104934853,
-0.0115289716,
-0.0121940859,
-0.0771855563,
-0.0026178672,
0.0213420987,
-0.0003260715,
-0.0026361602,
0.0041832803,
0.015186863,
-0.0488298722,
-0.0381032601,
-0.0085603427,
0.016694285,
-0.0771865621,
0.0063606882,
0.0164792091,
0.0611708649,
0.0358181894,
0.055681888,
0.0456404313,
0.0335095711,
0.0029873461,
0.0308594182,
-0.0840734392,
0.0209160428,
-0.0055029262,
0.0268321801,
-0.01824788,
0.0787236467,
-0.0222500172,
0.0055012349,
-0.0004141769,
0.0254793465,
-0.002923961,
-0.0355348699,
-0.068163693,
0.0074323113,
-0.016580971,
-0.024057813,
0.0404763445,
0.0205072667,
-0.0123070115,
0.0086423568,
-0.0390452258,
-0.0391859338,
0.0248248447,
-0.0671610609,
-0.0202018861,
0.0197684839,
0.0589119904,
0.0386240594,
0.0164883547,
0.0193837658,
0.0375958346,
-0.0230974667,
-0.0705454051,
-0.0303090438,
-0.0164415929,
0.0169431157,
-0.0221206751,
0.0600207672,
-0.0442883931,
-0.0486829169,
-0.0464505292,
0.053804297,
0.0257182736,
0.0066589974,
-0.0108618988,
0.0157035515,
0.0247472282,
0.0284029432,
0.0053366171,
0.0027636336,
-0.0547961593,
-0.0169584826,
-0.000193235,
0.0129677989,
0.0035821903,
0.0263544992,
0.0586155318,
0.0295470618,
-0.0643408224,
0.0092189452,
0.0095144324,
-0.0599341393,
0.0005010348,
-0.0434101261,
-0.0329612717,
-0.0329214111,
-0.0190975219,
-0.0505731404,
0.0478123091,
0.005263078,
-0.0416372232,
0.015852863,
0.0078189634,
0.0293878708,
-0.0345658436,
0.0420484766,
-0.0002200348,
0.0310914814,
0.0654940084,
0.0193720683,
0.0349449813,
0.0430937894,
0.0242948886,
0.0280366894,
0.0772879124,
0.0119672436,
0.0131671485,
-0.0139504755,
-0.0091402875,
-0.0187437944,
0.0385433473,
-0.0048662117,
-0.0225161556,
-0.0048173829,
-0.0401965454,
0.0657311827,
-0.0315646604,
0.0428822599,
0.0131947417,
0.0737105981,
-0.0002825602,
-0.0204259474,
-0.0374461524,
0.0509552471,
0.0054383744,
0.0929034799,
0.0056906021,
0.0090723187,
-0.0031990686,
0.0324426405,
0.1350653172,
-0.0087748533,
-0.0378522463,
-0.0459137894,
-0.0210422315,
0.0084946435,
0.0014942152,
-0.032659214,
-0.0048560319,
-0.0404175743,
-0.0527921095,
0.0548402034,
-0.0030184144,
-0.0547045507,
0.0033186506,
0.0105237719,
-0.0064077801,
0.024660226,
0.0425117873,
-0.0531158112,
-0.0278520193,
-0.0342729799,
-0.0028842774,
0.0069973371,
0.0790344104,
-0.0127345389,
-0.0346048139,
-0.0560590513,
-0.0468682684,
0.0258784667,
-0.0021414023,
-0.0295527447,
0.0008872565,
0.025964288,
0.0605576262,
-0.0189062506,
-0.0002681551,
0.0333288088,
0.0073101856,
0.0071002701,
-0.0173981022,
-0.0118110431,
0.0218266435,
0.0616193712,
0.0026551387,
0.0307783205,
0.0600203015,
-0.0115889329,
0.0015695858,
0.0185362287,
-0.0738860741,
-0.0545847453,
0.0411862507,
-0.0849801749,
0.0217937808,
0.0055358317,
-0.045853924,
-0.0773212612,
0.0263802446,
-0.0371397138,
-0.0025690733,
-0.0498121157,
0.0456167459,
-0.0173604079,
-0.0091842301,
-0.0316091962,
0.0444072373,
0.0073405784,
0.0139986062,
0.0461793132,
-0.0533489734,
0.0238966774,
-0.0522396937,
-0.0258506536,
0.0210562926,
-0.0049670627,
0.0314030573,
0.0584397539,
-0.0349928848,
-0.0120481802,
-0.0289967414,
-0.1092704833,
-0.0043193875,
-0.0227897521,
0.0157119948,
0.0207036324,
0.0444532521,
0.0081730653,
0.0149765797,
-0.0394261554,
-0.0553052686,
0.0300050713,
-0.0019481374,
0.0341993533,
0.0087990817,
0.0132615985,
-0.0754641891,
0.0033715661,
0.0032457532,
0.0487136692,
0.0222764034,
-0.0578059107,
-0.0533937477,
0.0119331582,
-0.008491612,
-0.0172621962,
0.0217246618,
0.0276575554,
-0.03004691,
0.0094562294,
0.0551539138,
0.0084428741,
0.0613436811,
0.0084437048,
0.0176208671,
0.0240984205,
-0.0368443355,
-0.0222581495,
-0.0650837645,
0.080192484,
0.0275085699,
-0.0044329101,
0.0702475384,
-0.0074666538,
0.0507237241,
0.0079211555,
-0.0107545229,
0.0138888489,
-0.0334647782,
0.0484375916,
-0.0445077643,
-0.0354802348,
-0.0251147412,
0.013911685,
0.0056126355,
0.0101964055,
0.0330195278,
-0.030586699,
0.0456885621,
-0.057204511,
-0.0086518181,
-0.0639713258,
0.0226836912,
-0.0340684764,
0.0526538379,
-0.0368484855,
-0.0404579788,
-0.019744128,
-0.0581390858,
0.0455783531,
-0.0456786267,
0.0431529433,
0.0072687762,
0.0077177668,
-0.0273515135,
-0.0048552616,
-0.0411255844,
-0.0124902287,
-0.014168147,
0.0384413153,
0.0222080927,
0.0186786503,
-0.0773623958,
0.0514197387,
0.0183935296,
0.0287848935,
-0.0194413885,
-0.0045020557,
0.0020407925,
0.0852500647,
0.0512823649,
0.0099897012,
0.0340995193,
-0.0052943723,
0.0149796661,
0.0327251777,
0.0203780718,
0.0019534789,
0.046270553,
-0.0403815061,
-0.0247548353,
-0.0935187042,
0.025911795,
-0.0212897677,
0.0271705333,
-0.0172043219,
0.0363886543,
0.1193453968,
0.0450188033,
-0.0275604203,
-0.0219043996,
-0.0349637419,
-0.0156525616,
0.00856693,
0.013553584,
-0.0355988592,
-0.0078653302,
0.0110975076,
0.0470509715,
0.0288968477,
-0.0363099165,
-0.0109757325,
-0.0466192886,
0.0163420346,
0.0058490671,
-0.0449133851,
-0.0535347983,
-0.0514536798,
-0.0011594378,
-0.0032807132,
0.0403655283,
0.0425761268,
-0.0120912977,
-0.0206657406,
0.0144423349,
-0.0862463638,
-0.024983611,
-0.029738646,
-0.0548321642,
-0.0140750259,
0.0650775209,
0.0715230033,
0.0190770421,
0.0141350245,
0.0194431804,
-0.0344239399,
-0.0292380396,
-0.0012948964,
0.0785709992,
-0.0402506441,
0.0315470286,
-0.0158929788,
0.0051589254,
0.0036821682,
0.003925438,
0.0287527628,
0.0271450151,
-0.0024692768,
-0.0016922872,
-0.0682603493,
0.053907834,
-0.0346177593,
0.0848127529,
0.003643807,
0.0312145855,
-0.01906294,
-0.0152337709,
0.044709444,
-0.0361182578,
0.0017496626,
-0.0211264566,
-0.0315995365,
0.0061760615,
-0.086332798,
-0.0490210913,
0.0354829095,
0.0036063436,
-0.0216904376,
0.0316624753,
0.0090765972,
0.0149133829,
-0.0392867625,
-0.0341029391,
-0.0079304399,
0.0100863548,
-0.0498133861,
0.0371451192,
0.0495035872,
-0.0046907938,
0.0160409492,
-0.0131496442,
-0.0158112012,
-0.0334840603,
-0.0306485668,
-0.0308684073,
0.0128959995,
0.0529652648,
-0.0122754807,
0.0213945229,
0.0194326937,
-0.0156888124,
0.0251987558,
0.0092286458,
0.0075900494,
0.0327723287,
-0.0380313434,
0.0087857768,
-0.0442251898,
0.0195691772,
-0.0623784177,
0.0421818867,
-0.0205513854,
-0.0730346814,
-0.0106386757,
0.0503221825,
0.0131138694,
0.0074962853,
-0.015151659,
-0.0307003465,
-0.0082853138,
-0.0133656831,
-0.0266372822,
-0.0216563474,
0.0357158296,
-0.0395654663,
-0.0026699826,
0.011773413,
0.0480290353,
-0.0588804372,
0.0067766383,
-0.0298193898,
0.0340351611,
-0.0214030705,
-0.0531460643,
-0.037119057,
0.0005329777,
-0.0295723565,
-0.0155930314,
-0.038097389,
0.0178901758,
-0.0491368063,
-0.0258619152,
0.0098525723,
0.0012506875,
-0.0125877867,
0.0561711267,
-0.0840157047,
0.0361293443,
-0.0735987797,
0.0199198928,
0.02017699,
-0.0579753928,
0.0332144052,
-0.0016881301,
0.0192111637,
-0.0266357958,
0.0495888554,
0.0084089385,
0.008242744,
-0.0092492513,
0.0199663434,
-0.0035147993,
0.032995142,
0.0585087277,
-0.0386640131,
-0.0274080392,
-0.0012945511,
-0.0612650476,
-0.0592709891,
-0.0158929229,
0.0053319852,
0.0407871343,
-0.0222186334,
-0.0355238542,
-0.0569186211,
0.0225802641,
0.0744252205,
-0.0351551846,
-0.0122741731,
-0.0093538407,
0.0279281195,
0.030501781,
0.0259490814,
0.0352812931,
-0.0479369611,
-0.0215720199,
0.0016982257,
-0.0069233985,
0.0141054094,
-5.81562569e-33,
-0.0312744565,
-0.0404303744,
-0.0360755995,
0.0112603456,
-0.049601391,
0.0061571365,
-0.0417575687,
-0.032460615,
-0.0112587726,
-0.0384897813,
-0.0212911461,
0.0008913013,
0.0273566525,
0.0232872479,
-0.0213635415,
0.0166218802,
0.0358976535,
-0.0160283763,
-0.0260021538,
0.0193084478,
0.046122916,
0.0244807526,
0.0194621608,
-0.0463043526,
0.0144338701,
-0.0259234272,
-0.0011113635,
-0.013348911,
0.0861629024,
0.0192155056,
-0.0155931795,
-0.0266159419,
0.0266425386,
-0.0174706466,
-0.0379821099,
0.0309354551,
-0.059674073,
-0.0397543162,
0.0065406905,
-0.0153340548,
-0.01037174,
-0.0038579598,
0.0233303439,
-0.0293355454,
0.028619444,
-0.0059342431,
0.0428144671,
-0.0148933493,
-0.0802257955,
-0.0426693484,
-0.0386539809,
0.0681637079,
-0.0146944551,
0.0075544366,
0.0490001701,
0.0369848423,
0.0492224619,
-0.0137388995,
-0.0403394215,
0.0497846492,
0.0100924699,
0.0209616218,
0.0379796326,
-0.0021905259,
0.0049396697,
0.0668808743,
-0.0026173003,
-0.0273704715,
0.0043197041,
-0.0120606134,
-0.0254131109,
0.0256721936,
-0.0030817837,
0.0181164481,
0.0228205845,
0.0017631106,
-0.016954042,
0.0873025879,
-0.0160333253,
-0.0073125432,
0.0564467721,
0.0166698638,
-0.0356677063,
-0.0385229439,
-0.0096120341,
0.0307433009,
-0.0064499276,
-0.0108528938,
-0.009301181,
0.0410973132,
-0.0637232065,
-0.0320291482,
0.012962495,
-0.0506517328,
0.0028904353,
0.0317676887,
-0.001563433,
0.0149022713,
-0.0134927649,
-0.0198458713,
-0.0162306353,
-0.0215312336,
0.0254870281,
0.0114816623,
-0.0445305109,
-0.0169391315,
0.0225397255,
-0.0307808891,
-0.0113401609,
0.0195767581,
0.0414056592,
-0.0219279714,
-0.0506735221,
0.0123184938,
-0.0124691194,
-0.0048961816,
-0.0092745721,
0.060592588,
0.0269264001,
0.0153598543,
-0.0009701401,
-0.0184469502,
0.0172257833,
0.0467310622,
-0.0175289251,
0.0286289249,
-0.0066302614,
0.0237849634,
0.0672291145,
0.0081342999,
-0.0068254624,
-0.0444732755,
2.569e-7,
0.0493204072,
0.0434333868,
0.0575886369,
-0.0202179328,
-0.0185649078,
0.0199843571,
-0.008596329,
0.0396128185,
-0.0093289055,
0.0352438204,
0.0499164201,
0.0028816448,
0.0286792647,
0.0301571675,
-0.0891957134,
-0.0166980866,
-0.0755183846,
-0.0831515491,
-0.0009585164,
0.0096374433,
0.0273508932,
0.0657133088,
-0.0177111924,
0.0257147141,
-0.0538842417,
-0.0283048749,
0.0048416886,
-0.0141098797,
-0.0565342195,
0.0174546856,
0.0394095406,
-0.0069777602,
-0.0075110053,
-0.0515338257,
-0.0063507729,
0.0402114913,
0.0698985532,
0.0400327891,
0.0081168404,
-0.0087866718,
0.0003165941,
-0.0433986112,
0.0266756993,
0.0520646013,
0.0372507833,
-0.034221001,
0.0011700059,
-0.0183786433,
-0.0191724543,
0.0334649831,
0.0272615459,
0.0504244342,
-0.0130078215,
0.0646387935,
-0.0197302531,
-0.0230400488,
0.0025701919,
-0.0823711082,
-0.0071230014,
0.0129273124,
-0.0111029493,
-0.0375760607,
-0.0039630942,
-0.047961615,
0.0376699679,
-0.0235691592,
-0.0069675911,
2.486423559e-34,
0.0647976995,
0.0242501181,
-0.0474118255,
0.0052409307,
0.031196259,
-0.0368612148,
0.0018068283,
0.0014477042,
0.0241390057,
-0.0858176723,
0.004513117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05553v1 | Understanding the Progression of Educational Topics via Semantic Matching | 2024-02-10T08:24:29 | 2024-02-10T08:24:29 | Tamador Alkhidir, Edmond Awad, Aamena Alshamsi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | Education systems are dynamically changing to accommodate technological
advances, industrial and societal needs, and to enhance students' learning
journeys. Curriculum specialists and educators constantly revise taught
subjects across educational grades to identify gaps, introduce new learning
topics, and enhance the learning outcomes. This process is usually done within
the same subjects (e.g. math) or across related subjects (e.g. math and
physics) considering the same and different educational levels, leading to
massive multi-layer comparisons. Having nuanced data about subjects, topics,
and learning outcomes structured within a dataset, empowers us to leverage data
science to better understand the progression of various learning topics. In
this paper, Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT)
topic modeling was used to extract topics from the curriculum, which were then
used to identify relationships between subjects, track their progression, and
identify conceptual gaps. We found that grouping learning outcomes by common
topics helped specialists reduce redundancy and introduce new concepts in the
curriculum. We built a dashboard to avail the methodology to curriculum
specials. Finally, we tested the validity of the approach with subject matter
experts. | [
-0.0112531576,
0.0012750452,
-0.0332026295,
0.0229611862,
-0.0227977633,
0.0206014439,
-0.0224408191,
-0.0366497859,
-0.0923928916,
-0.0468187071,
0.0256530307,
0.0665357411,
0.009195514,
0.0123361703,
-0.0170762353,
-0.1150831506,
0.0087714605,
0.0160012599,
-0.0555241108,
0.0148280552,
-0.0189062655,
0.0181962978,
-0.0501585007,
0.0460571125,
0.0196649712,
-0.0129900379,
-0.0127132628,
-0.019802507,
0.039176058,
-0.0211451799,
0.0460894518,
0.0412199348,
0.0431565084,
-0.013888739,
0.0000024088,
-0.0546233505,
-0.0516041704,
-0.0379079841,
-0.0192633327,
0.0067467005,
0.0036287652,
0.0184540227,
0.0248042513,
0.0020645957,
-0.004425317,
0.0303318407,
0.0004098566,
0.0050808201,
0.0564208589,
-0.019408362,
0.0028918402,
-0.0356188491,
0.0236377828,
0.0017093942,
0.0188895594,
-0.0174369216,
0.0295229033,
0.0377892964,
0.0140284942,
0.0554392226,
-0.0820239186,
-0.0041086054,
-0.0032654682,
-0.0135643352,
0.0708554387,
0.0382349566,
-0.004154847,
0.0100480784,
0.0230160952,
0.0547512546,
0.0010604552,
-0.0038097682,
0.0204381905,
-0.0240771603,
-0.0151455784,
0.0416481607,
-0.0753837675,
-0.0102869524,
-0.0195899699,
-0.0011876866,
0.0334870331,
-0.023733208,
-0.0414544903,
0.0068309419,
-0.010138412,
0.0201597288,
0.0402784608,
-0.0190145671,
-0.0384240821,
0.0406643786,
0.0612221323,
-0.0208402015,
0.0440594517,
0.0270035733,
0.0268232264,
-0.0065183891,
-0.0060599088,
-0.0439315885,
0.0081192786,
-0.0084203053,
-0.0358611234,
0.0463290103,
-0.0208734944,
0.0192624722,
0.042293191,
0.0450851433,
-0.0120299878,
0.0328171887,
-0.0644397512,
0.0132534448,
-0.0499776714,
-0.0001892553,
0.0014073667,
0.0257587992,
0.0250908844,
0.0147593468,
-0.0033086813,
0.0196167789,
-0.0366295315,
0.0147583103,
-0.0114468038,
-0.0111432532,
-0.0258012433,
0.0050156685,
-0.0390270203,
0.0837702826,
-0.0137900384,
0.0314965397,
-0.0366840139,
0.0696551502,
0.0078633446,
0.0029129705,
0.0021396119,
0.0195125621,
-0.0007135255,
0.0098370817,
0.0015532653,
0.0070947246,
-0.0550187454,
-0.0430775359,
0.0294534527,
0.0577300861,
0.0233143046,
-0.0826133341,
-0.0103659658,
0.0318132825,
0.0124408258,
0.0158553962,
-0.0198318772,
0.0186577458,
-0.0019760921,
0.0162692331,
-0.0064496566,
-0.023184564,
0.0802228898,
0.047949221,
0.0243959259,
0.0106527368,
-0.009986138,
0.0228785668,
0.0121535128,
-0.0179498736,
-0.0032003392,
-0.0255531725,
0.0002027129,
-0.0132730193,
0.0049445136,
0.0009360702,
0.0195862558,
0.0330312178,
-0.0229100529,
-0.0309936628,
-0.0287405495,
-0.0213860646,
-0.0299836844,
0.0596870929,
0.002607093,
0.029638024,
-0.0116799762,
0.028799016,
0.0166098718,
0.0209552422,
0.0293204226,
0.0300366674,
0.0448074602,
-0.0357870758,
0.0112152649,
-0.0172409434,
-0.027857624,
-0.0559979938,
0.0051772543,
0.01395417,
-0.0140679888,
-0.015875211,
0.0653096288,
-0.0230046306,
0.0148191052,
0.0522933491,
0.0260585658,
-0.0187697895,
0.0455836952,
-0.0403569862,
0.0358583368,
0.0887672529,
0.0747051686,
-0.0539335757,
-0.1248826832,
-0.0080539789,
0.0371296816,
0.0320166275,
-0.0003452473,
-0.0474037006,
-0.0491744056,
-0.0143541871,
-0.0569281876,
-0.0127134966,
-0.0073757679,
-0.0002041883,
-0.0358221382,
0.0092059001,
-0.006661729,
-0.0479157604,
0.0336718149,
0.0389412977,
-0.0536454581,
0.0189916734,
0.0017988916,
0.0045501469,
0.0195813775,
0.0322474726,
0.0156469494,
-0.0099982237,
0.0306493938,
-0.0190686975,
-0.023841152,
-0.0311950985,
-0.0129025616,
0.0284785628,
0.0473129265,
-0.1085699648,
0.0077736834,
0.0157760996,
-0.0569227375,
-0.0278089903,
0.041050002,
-0.0357685871,
0.004749612,
0.0336100869,
0.0293319821,
-0.0360105596,
-0.0183974151,
0.0041269045,
0.0127470829,
0.0084163044,
0.0081686843,
0.0228520762,
-0.0036646682,
0.0533650368,
0.0162115041,
-0.0088061299,
0.0179767124,
-0.0143538658,
0.0271503963,
0.0427878723,
-0.0374986231,
-0.0509215966,
0.0071494356,
-0.0594439805,
-0.03385951,
0.003562704,
0.0089018876,
0.0565419048,
-0.0310577359,
0.0018946708,
0.0112583209,
0.0008661728,
-0.0228843782,
-0.0451192223,
-0.0363349617,
0.0218950342,
-0.0138159506,
0.0094256112,
-0.0484311879,
-0.0237558894,
-0.0624571182,
0.0491988882,
0.0616780445,
0.047819946,
-0.0431071818,
-0.0204724334,
-0.0251895357,
-0.0163386278,
-0.0195090473,
0.0155027127,
0.0174055398,
0.0119385459,
0.0672625899,
-0.004914423,
0.0390230305,
0.0639610812,
0.0553575829,
-0.0584807433,
-0.0531355217,
-0.0076404619,
-0.0495553501,
0.0199753344,
-0.0230304096,
-0.0287858602,
-0.0002727885,
0.0065653482,
0.018515436,
-0.0195849705,
-0.0292434637,
-0.0187438373,
-0.0227814317,
0.0594646968,
-0.0937589034,
-0.0210707597,
0.0184574686,
0.0258399956,
0.0194197986,
0.0173391812,
0.0788043886,
0.0188058205,
0.0694150254,
-0.083895795,
0.0215226095,
-0.0376231372,
0.0205308758,
-0.0243657585,
-0.0156736523,
-0.0649057776,
-0.0030281295,
-0.0460663438,
0.0268393699,
0.0321570747,
-0.0457912348,
0.0414442979,
-0.0691879168,
-0.0215823203,
-0.0282213241,
0.0287349429,
-0.0458312333,
0.0230133086,
0.0465073548,
0.0063098818,
-0.0133557608,
-0.0262891743,
-0.0463128611,
-0.0435911343,
0.0098136831,
0.038199082,
0.0302869249,
-0.0269421991,
-0.0106242793,
0.0485296473,
0.0141556812,
-0.0437093601,
-0.0358501151,
-0.0517023467,
0.0371782109,
0.0383898951,
0.0159373302,
-0.0362710953,
-0.0352168605,
0.0242977124,
0.0212903395,
-0.0678509697,
0.0360594057,
0.0308780279,
-0.0349537656,
-0.0447427779,
0.0149762928,
0.0951977149,
0.017389575,
-0.0360898823,
-0.021454623,
-0.0347427055,
-0.0492324233,
0.0060223141,
0.0039880387,
-0.068766512,
0.0267402623,
-0.0363300517,
0.0538807735,
0.0333480462,
-0.0080446042,
0.0023858675,
-0.020809738,
-0.0023623162,
-0.0024252927,
-0.0116492324,
-0.0051265787,
-0.0795947388,
0.0006789258,
-0.0019742262,
-0.0248369239,
-0.0312986039,
0.0081608053,
0.0220490694,
0.0636303574,
-0.0488576293,
-0.0249935221,
0.0226977598,
-0.0025928132,
-0.0153844431,
-0.0143997967,
0.0350274518,
-0.0315788724,
-0.0215131715,
-0.0234871954,
0.0002072453,
-0.0479934067,
0.0094449995,
0.0419080667,
-0.0242507551,
0.0350309834,
-0.0248628333,
0.0077446615,
-0.0187671129,
-0.0332353599,
0.0465682857,
0.113933146,
-0.0287598521,
-0.0025217177,
-0.10286998,
-0.0098972199,
-0.0435585827,
0.0529455915,
0.0270117838,
-0.0385051966,
0.066813387,
-0.0346034877,
0.0646231994,
0.0431616791,
-0.0145629309,
0.0082677966,
-0.0348292664,
-0.0662552714,
-0.0077972258,
-0.0127357459,
0.0345962718,
-0.0357956365,
0.0149973668,
0.011002128,
0.091817677,
-0.0579597689,
-0.1027257591,
0.0081698913,
-0.0036767523,
0.0053868201,
-0.0758017972,
-0.059972357,
0.0362461507,
-0.0030003458,
-0.0470182113,
-0.0275702942,
-0.0664685294,
-0.0303399581,
-0.0124390926,
-0.0266296882,
0.0035206194,
-0.0023046781,
0.0377491228,
-0.0001142116,
0.0235369876,
0.0256656092,
0.0078265099,
-0.0049170973,
-0.0358326919,
-0.0162182618,
-0.0188896246,
-0.0395317227,
-0.0467160828,
0.0436567962,
-0.0073709195,
0.0092718685,
-0.0356905237,
-0.0232925769,
0.0141227636,
-0.0088532511,
0.0904798955,
0.0155954175,
-0.0539386459,
-0.0710273162,
-0.0125334011,
-0.0008869698,
0.0018498934,
0.0097217076,
-0.0345101357,
0.0276172999,
0.0011460108,
-0.01961785,
0.0230516214,
-0.0015399203,
0.0153494775,
-0.0446859673,
0.0313429944,
-0.0686624348,
0.0610939525,
-0.0166371129,
-0.0042259959,
-0.0054763677,
-0.0422645845,
-0.0183650926,
0.0302256979,
-0.0083477683,
0.0620388687,
0.0369607806,
0.049291905,
0.0406691395,
0.0083913561,
-0.0193093345,
-0.0440539755,
-0.0416171215,
0.0228719022,
-0.0022705668,
0.0491723008,
-0.0097384965,
0.0005425834,
0.0052051349,
-0.0312910229,
0.0270803366,
-0.0171109941,
-0.0269821398,
0.0460705794,
0.0131715043,
0.0441716611,
-0.0174263939,
0.0271592233,
-0.021413479,
0.025168201,
-0.0049187727,
-0.0189853255,
-0.0046385066,
-0.0044423225,
0.0551990345,
0.0105404099,
0.0146791125,
-0.0017414562,
-0.0346772298,
-0.0124778617,
0.0329252034,
0.0211433042,
0.0033241818,
0.0076724058,
0.0636118054,
0.0510847084,
-0.0305992737,
-0.0245390479,
0.0191304758,
0.0185674652,
-0.0411771461,
-0.0535250455,
-0.0293712765,
-6.221857069e-33,
-0.037990652,
-0.024311604,
0.020957144,
0.0678540915,
0.0166744124,
0.0085277762,
-0.0212654434,
0.0177365821,
-0.0166537035,
0.0062666903,
0.0339092128,
0.0427816696,
-0.0197032876,
0.0317168757,
0.0657047704,
-0.0191856585,
0.0793741718,
0.0387840159,
-0.0012635515,
0.0393336415,
0.0417917296,
-0.0132962782,
0.0698610842,
-0.0607618354,
-0.0163590685,
-0.025594769,
0.0459316522,
-0.0197217148,
0.0534066223,
0.021877028,
-0.0108858077,
0.0611426495,
0.0347682759,
-0.0511789434,
-0.0129809901,
0.0044257082,
-0.0498114377,
-0.1021718085,
-0.0268153604,
-0.0027118712,
0.011985804,
-0.0500432886,
0.0347310081,
0.0511961877,
-0.0714259595,
-0.0412480868,
0.1008213684,
0.0077653443,
0.0250079706,
-0.0186823066,
-0.0477970615,
0.0172648709,
-0.0635609403,
-0.0089365868,
-0.0040403223,
0.0158307143,
0.0472296923,
0.0106399367,
-0.0432071798,
0.0819171667,
0.01249649,
0.0531437099,
0.0547596626,
0.0040641176,
-0.0256650727,
0.058999151,
-0.0409254879,
0.0125347069,
0.0151892202,
0.0174937416,
0.0446153693,
0.0288227946,
0.0438243337,
-0.0092679998,
0.0113319037,
-0.00231902,
-0.0483069122,
0.0820301399,
0.0008826275,
0.0225401372,
-0.0433177575,
-0.02323764,
-0.021164408,
-0.020109633,
-0.0204221085,
0.0495392494,
0.0074455305,
0.0136006316,
0.0412570015,
-0.0569510125,
-0.0080316132,
0.0384430885,
-0.0099874837,
-0.0319821388,
0.0024923438,
0.0379044674,
-0.0146907466,
0.0017572186,
-0.0028752456,
0.0281181093,
-0.0330202729,
-0.0568228327,
0.0404534899,
-0.0239876565,
0.0164854713,
0.0053836186,
-0.0321068875,
-0.0075218217,
0.0039596944,
-0.0031255367,
-0.0107035087,
-0.0972559154,
-0.009393353,
-0.0325234383,
0.0189044941,
0.0560211763,
-0.0076290364,
0.0386982113,
0.0302518699,
0.0206474289,
-0.0100886654,
-0.0636401102,
0.0097932899,
0.0046021002,
0.0200449862,
-0.032578256,
-0.0507637635,
-0.0292929616,
0.0258443281,
-0.0799503997,
-0.0232547671,
-0.0000995678,
3.039e-7,
0.0308284685,
0.0707345232,
0.0191183183,
-0.0448465683,
-0.0013666915,
-0.00139526,
-0.0200656112,
0.015403809,
0.0535761081,
0.0023197327,
0.0191709399,
0.0146011533,
0.0146310758,
0.0528640486,
-0.021435475,
-0.033322785,
-0.0194115844,
-0.0248316079,
-0.0868060365,
0.033715792,
0.1318784505,
-0.0014568327,
0.0572506897,
0.02390665,
-0.029380016,
0.0532521531,
0.0245555919,
-0.0064563518,
0.028521454,
0.029373955,
-0.0188999902,
0.0287792683,
0.0065701404,
0.0069340607,
-0.0327907465,
0.0149626024,
0.0004994175,
-0.0004428962,
-0.0007588328,
0.0205531921,
-0.0162650738,
-0.0024921324,
-0.0121971443,
-0.0231289659,
-0.0011620509,
-0.0568036102,
0.0296125393,
0.0336223505,
-0.0729304403,
0.0458972864,
-0.001382255,
0.0040270179,
-0.0043636826,
-0.0298532285,
-0.0043454249,
-0.0120257232,
0.0277490113,
-0.0445844792,
0.0545862764,
0.0107313776,
-0.0705635101,
-0.0157943778,
-0.0173908155,
-0.0125470888,
0.0640074015,
-0.0140976459,
0.0208303817,
2.302430453e-34,
0.0141426241,
-0.0067890501,
-0.0175054558,
-0.0318556242,
-0.0360591486,
-0.0322931185,
0.0064057508,
0.0199584607,
-0.0010341337,
-0.0279378463,
-0.0307179727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06900v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06900v3 | Can LLMs Recognize Toxicity? Definition-Based Toxicity Metric | 2024-02-10T07:55:27 | 2024-06-18T04:35:12 | Hyukhun Koh, Dohyung Kim, Minwoo Lee, Kyomin Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the pursuit of developing Large Language Models (LLMs) that adhere to
societal standards, it is imperative to detect the toxicity in the generated
text. The majority of existing toxicity metrics rely on encoder models trained
on specific toxicity datasets, which are susceptible to out-of-distribution
(OOD) problems and depend on the dataset's definition of toxicity. In this
paper, we introduce a robust metric grounded on LLMs to flexibly measure
toxicity according to the given definition. We first analyze the toxicity
factors, followed by an examination of the intrinsic toxic attributes of LLMs
to ascertain their suitability as evaluators. Finally, we evaluate the
performance of our metric with detailed analysis. Our empirical results
demonstrate outstanding performance in measuring toxicity within verified
factors, improving on conventional metrics by 12 points in the F1 score. Our
findings also indicate that upstream toxicity significantly influences
downstream metrics, suggesting that LLMs are unsuitable for toxicity
evaluations within unverified factors. | [
0.009134829,
0.0544863455,
-0.0262716562,
0.0153435525,
0.0111931516,
0.038196519,
-0.0216994826,
0.0305722654,
0.0096709849,
-0.0319355652,
-0.0163847469,
0.0076329708,
-0.0121801132,
0.0381147116,
0.0298229437,
0.0081761787,
0.0256065279,
0.0136773884,
0.0028061997,
0.0154633438,
0.0335001834,
0.0227540527,
0.0599996746,
0.0571954474,
-0.0158275962,
-0.0256727431,
0.051359158,
0.0180712044,
0.0426107422,
-0.0271726232,
0.0194988847,
0.0121690882,
-0.0117576271,
0.0311273839,
0.000001741,
-0.0281662531,
0.0080716778,
0.0096830726,
0.0078332918,
-0.0064154658,
0.0772409365,
-0.0314413011,
-0.0308610182,
0.0616985112,
-0.0029667481,
0.0110519985,
0.0656040162,
-0.021288503,
0.0740398988,
0.0646696761,
-0.0275434516,
0.0283765402,
0.0450906828,
0.0096973488,
-0.0372070931,
0.0386374108,
0.075602144,
0.0088960445,
-0.0421800464,
-0.0146074248,
-0.0169251077,
0.0291551258,
0.0404108688,
-0.0236555301,
-0.0090382826,
-0.0247203205,
0.0139041757,
-0.0553716756,
0.0249235574,
0.0730943307,
-0.0480481498,
-0.0047247158,
-0.0077239275,
-0.0112623554,
0.0047758445,
-0.0284447838,
-0.0051426343,
0.0315669738,
0.0121979807,
0.0295473561,
-0.0089229448,
0.0500285327,
0.0379915386,
0.0195854343,
0.0363247953,
0.0420348272,
-0.0011662218,
-0.0315527506,
-0.0073396447,
-0.0252439529,
-0.0385256112,
0.0103508262,
0.0251237713,
-0.0190455113,
-0.0058182706,
0.0329584368,
-0.049194403,
-0.0425221436,
0.0568921342,
-0.128438592,
0.0271328725,
-0.0125851277,
-0.0392816402,
0.0171896722,
-0.0020114412,
0.0036386494,
0.0120414076,
0.0400526859,
-0.017871676,
0.0224612895,
0.0333879627,
-0.0024281528,
-0.0128106065,
-0.0017877348,
0.0116669321,
0.0045192661,
-0.0356344841,
0.0256181695,
-0.0608487613,
-0.015099505,
0.0343631506,
0.0195309706,
-0.0024764778,
0.0281340145,
-0.0070807999,
-0.0196030587,
-0.0138855604,
0.0256119687,
0.0047645806,
-0.0514485948,
0.0057972833,
0.0541318022,
-0.0494483896,
-0.0320233107,
-0.002810911,
0.1267147064,
0.0332568251,
-0.0021835745,
-0.0378815532,
-0.0292020906,
-0.0587049611,
-0.0199755915,
-0.0450885966,
-0.0388124846,
-0.0190212298,
-0.0165629797,
-0.0241768733,
-0.1058749259,
0.012520398,
0.0271543972,
-0.0335413031,
0.0202079825,
-0.0133595997,
-0.0173074789,
0.0134190544,
0.0240070801,
-0.0075108223,
0.0746810213,
0.0668956339,
0.0369148552,
0.0243054423,
-0.0063509648,
0.0053724302,
0.0606442541,
0.0247126091,
0.0707408339,
-0.0680389181,
-0.0199350677,
-0.0096854931,
-0.0084149251,
0.0124724461,
0.0776943713,
-0.0101486687,
-0.0242038816,
0.0919090584,
-0.0204756055,
-0.0052716783,
0.0159242414,
0.0429257378,
0.0035319773,
-0.055707261,
-0.016116377,
-0.0465057157,
-0.0049411552,
-0.0421535484,
-0.0422211178,
0.0579623654,
0.0276174936,
0.0053365971,
-0.0730130002,
-0.0204422437,
-0.0001184083,
0.038237147,
-0.0161318332,
0.0221523996,
0.0154802371,
-0.0425940938,
0.0054397089,
0.0247415137,
-0.0658430979,
0.0368380137,
-0.0121054221,
0.0163000394,
0.0716293454,
0.0761280581,
-0.0070617893,
0.031810455,
-0.0501295552,
-0.0288610421,
-0.0057851402,
-0.0246323664,
-0.0063106054,
0.0324113294,
-0.0197058432,
-0.0330877751,
0.0238906853,
0.0133162616,
-0.0423811488,
-0.006571745,
0.0279408153,
0.0195985083,
-0.0560889393,
-0.1061428487,
0.0484871417,
0.0161277186,
-0.0276780985,
-0.0103858253,
0.0160335563,
0.0388026126,
-0.0141376117,
-0.0430117659,
-0.0059658233,
0.0242913179,
-0.0219111517,
-0.0213463213,
-0.034262605,
-0.0230993293,
-0.0014518824,
0.0057333577,
-0.0389258638,
0.0128033655,
0.0538624115,
-0.020243872,
0.0238277912,
-0.007453918,
-0.068187438,
-0.0101532517,
-0.0240558889,
0.0225640908,
-0.042539496,
0.0390364528,
-0.0297989864,
0.053519506,
-0.0297679026,
-0.0015759361,
-0.0235407818,
-0.0287498347,
-0.0023878964,
-0.0266537257,
-0.069150731,
-0.0321265571,
-0.0263952985,
0.0264755748,
0.037796814,
0.0309139453,
-0.015244619,
-0.0170724802,
-0.0226591583,
-0.0106236041,
-0.0371795595,
0.0046413471,
0.0318972804,
-0.0146628506,
-0.0082694115,
0.0238528382,
-0.0200804956,
-0.0531689413,
0.0004818143,
0.0400128029,
0.0027204221,
-0.0184842683,
-0.0284825936,
-0.0133501412,
-0.0199889764,
-0.0195760634,
0.0783120692,
-0.0303692967,
-0.04562838,
-0.0207513776,
0.0734241754,
-0.0195267517,
-0.0289540682,
0.0155152325,
-0.0787407234,
0.0194626953,
0.0411448032,
0.0083445357,
0.0637745336,
0.0353423953,
0.0619285852,
0.0495121516,
0.028203126,
-0.0355136804,
-0.0320282802,
-0.0317692682,
-0.0241630375,
0.0030594077,
-0.0651474893,
0.005608032,
0.0061688358,
-0.0017639418,
-0.026943,
-0.0407551862,
0.0447134897,
-0.0435566828,
-0.0482691228,
-0.0074950913,
-0.0766113251,
-0.0187702198,
0.0096573262,
-0.0056495471,
-0.073882632,
0.0561728887,
-0.0175010767,
0.0246548597,
0.0095230676,
-0.0199669357,
0.0055034589,
-0.0040256018,
-0.0077239396,
0.0328878388,
0.0350666642,
-0.0127010597,
-0.0076961038,
0.0204289109,
0.0234924871,
-0.0354960635,
0.0311002098,
-0.0290378202,
-0.0109192021,
0.0333860107,
-0.03388758,
-0.0405731834,
-0.0203259606,
0.0463573337,
0.010609217,
0.0214976333,
0.0093796933,
-0.0125054279,
0.0398556478,
-0.018980341,
-0.0335671566,
-0.0025043506,
0.0005037175,
0.0027499744,
-0.0012963052,
0.0550105684,
-0.0528993756,
0.0714289919,
-0.0119033009,
0.0475225821,
0.0858154297,
-0.0585067272,
0.0188379698,
0.0038165781,
0.0283654463,
0.0015965239,
0.0470791012,
0.0191278886,
0.0398255475,
0.0214352403,
-0.0296725426,
-0.0297729596,
0.0503672361,
0.0048958487,
-0.0308349524,
0.053352423,
0.0116138319,
0.0585663468,
0.0215511583,
-0.037210796,
-0.0580679365,
0.0065399799,
0.006319582,
0.0358041301,
-0.0725563169,
-0.046062991,
0.0294295903,
-0.0689624101,
0.014751194,
0.0361157618,
-0.0267254487,
-0.0171383023,
-0.0317956693,
-0.0047324304,
-0.0599570945,
0.0522462428,
-0.0081529412,
0.0209150389,
-0.071574524,
0.0152833872,
-0.0453120209,
-0.0680312887,
0.0144613879,
-0.0068298676,
0.0391263813,
0.0348742381,
0.0024733897,
-0.0358061939,
-0.011007539,
0.0279696975,
-0.0283840559,
-0.0529621579,
0.0067933979,
0.0617031418,
-0.0105727585,
-0.0205551144,
-0.0415900499,
0.0416367948,
-0.0255270284,
0.0088858884,
-0.0298529547,
0.0675445423,
0.0115102651,
-0.0321325101,
-0.0411843695,
0.0170853119,
0.0407314375,
0.0872488469,
0.0413081348,
-0.0417480469,
-0.0109997652,
-0.0587561578,
-0.0175755285,
-0.0211167727,
-0.0473260134,
0.0023877185,
-0.0309073739,
-0.0562917851,
-0.0958572105,
-0.0158271771,
-0.0096054887,
-0.0041013304,
0.0148157952,
-0.0319625884,
-0.0146557931,
-0.0069032665,
-0.0197701007,
0.0337367803,
0.0351814628,
0.0124299107,
-0.0564015768,
0.0272876248,
-0.0347535051,
0.0417058207,
-0.0257754438,
0.071290262,
-0.0428950973,
-0.0714900196,
0.0052311243,
0.0571578406,
0.0148820076,
-0.0322186276,
-0.0246528573,
-0.051725734,
0.0942816213,
0.0231150631,
-0.0227889139,
-0.0066594868,
0.0550024658,
-0.0454685129,
0.0285683442,
0.0333475731,
-0.0499258116,
0.0107849129,
0.0062651918,
0.0280914102,
-0.048910886,
0.0029171798,
0.028843835,
0.0193601809,
0.0142555004,
-0.0331039764,
-0.0318986364,
-0.0207046494,
-0.0091899037,
-0.0316627584,
-0.0292599294,
-0.0367040746,
0.0422431417,
0.0425390489,
0.0270278696,
-0.039499931,
0.0351238549,
-0.0217729807,
0.0261305645,
-0.0084996484,
0.0380424596,
0.0104583493,
0.0206641704,
0.0555796809,
0.0344481692,
-0.0257721543,
0.0034669,
-0.0344488323,
0.0053625177,
-0.008291102,
-0.0186028965,
-0.0024820413,
0.0515794419,
0.0450857319,
0.0650974959,
0.0059579448,
0.0152959488,
-0.0898808092,
-0.0056908038,
0.0022039611,
-0.0070033581,
0.0798895508,
-0.020575488,
0.0107840542,
-0.0485375188,
-0.0112331491,
-0.0279600341,
-0.0671135262,
0.0024621263,
0.0067839967,
-0.0427781194,
0.0039892155,
0.0661035702,
0.0372544751,
0.0314304605,
-0.0117487572,
-0.012863378,
0.0142339328,
-0.0216011163,
0.0231716614,
0.0162204616,
-0.0196507964,
0.0051745023,
-0.0488559306,
-0.087082319,
-0.0163181517,
-0.004641721,
0.0228938852,
0.0120527642,
-0.0111566111,
0.0304420441,
-0.0089668278,
0.0030833988,
-0.0248925891,
-0.0373373963,
-0.009859493,
-0.0280619971,
-0.006562579,
-5.650592161e-33,
0.0037858495,
-0.0408911183,
-0.0372716822,
0.0002358531,
-0.0010907113,
-0.017637983,
-0.0132006267,
-0.0052870605,
-0.0202438235,
0.0169185624,
0.0408910736,
-0.0019524775,
-0.0144124916,
0.0200076662,
-0.004046306,
-0.016574569,
0.0070812213,
-0.0077040112,
-0.0325656049,
0.0102036027,
0.0595617928,
-0.0002552881,
0.0172320623,
-0.072780773,
0.0182856172,
0.0054781558,
-0.0418910608,
0.0018622844,
0.0000779684,
0.0809175372,
0.0059378133,
0.093850404,
0.0106652249,
-0.0198292062,
-0.0051098438,
0.035254024,
-0.0109185921,
0.0153415175,
0.0041018808,
-0.0221206881,
-0.0162094273,
-0.0424594954,
0.0818233714,
0.0069774245,
-0.0276912749,
-0.0223505348,
0.0237670541,
-0.0476323441,
-0.0061842883,
-0.0440325812,
-0.0359029472,
0.0224320684,
-0.0313055702,
-0.0060378988,
0.0053269519,
0.0704498664,
0.0128093492,
0.0372105129,
-0.0336841457,
-0.0122456076,
-0.0201584622,
0.0204988401,
0.0449537486,
-0.014838648,
0.010391674,
0.0724115446,
-0.0505030155,
0.0413316302,
-0.0096079102,
-0.0174503122,
0.0445556268,
0.0208826642,
0.0507453531,
0.0491970927,
-0.0057524452,
-0.0354606956,
-0.0793276802,
0.0188648179,
0.0005517186,
0.0403343663,
0.0088853147,
-0.0193504766,
-0.0588233545,
-0.050000295,
-0.0340957865,
-0.0257514529,
-0.0161433537,
-0.0298551861,
0.04636316,
-0.0379420668,
-0.0296283569,
-0.0384331942,
-0.0074515222,
-0.0440882631,
0.0343681946,
0.0505402163,
-0.0134408353,
0.0112593016,
-0.00241243,
0.0494971834,
-0.0142134232,
0.0110076768,
0.0304403082,
-0.0294303037,
0.0273608882,
-0.0150227714,
0.0856005922,
0.0177667532,
-0.0537860915,
0.0080613075,
-0.0224431418,
0.0594141036,
0.0294189639,
0.0438978039,
-0.0056591802,
-0.0082349889,
0.0039072256,
-0.0099655427,
0.0459372886,
0.0465723425,
-0.0013087973,
-0.0117045036,
-0.0092853745,
0.0067879683,
-0.0346494466,
-0.0321268588,
-0.01617801,
0.0335011221,
0.0646241903,
-0.0761668831,
0.0002732265,
-0.0162037816,
2.491e-7,
0.0657741949,
0.0409365483,
0.0039583859,
0.0093203746,
0.0158443786,
0.022807546,
0.0173430163,
0.0602943674,
-0.0014776662,
-0.0444328412,
0.0133788576,
-0.0157857854,
0.056669727,
0.0507113263,
-0.0393742211,
0.020493364,
-0.1203962117,
0.0074810875,
-0.0358492918,
-0.0067010904,
0.0569627248,
0.0798666403,
0.0067102001,
-0.030627979,
0.0024248746,
-0.039490249,
0.0289223716,
-0.0511934757,
0.0087304488,
0.0182474423,
0.0301654115,
0.0148903709,
0.0242954642,
0.0135059701,
-0.0179649796,
-0.0061298101,
0.0161281656,
0.0606509931,
-0.0088254614,
-0.0720407888,
0.0144960163,
-0.0318656936,
-0.003728919,
-0.0542562678,
0.0790372789,
0.0215357747,
-0.0142219448,
-0.0315551497,
-0.0382232629,
-0.0257326532,
0.0628489107,
-0.0580851585,
-0.0349813513,
0.005866494,
0.0235215258,
0.007657792,
0.0145242112,
-0.0370481834,
-0.0264354665,
-0.0123158395,
-0.0177541114,
-0.10177847,
-0.0265435316,
0.0274423063,
-0.0045704315,
-0.027431367,
0.0387066081,
2.172226317e-34,
0.0402568951,
-0.056922581,
0.0267016273,
-0.027391687,
0.0438194387,
0.0275275651,
-0.0035749474,
-0.0148978457,
-0.0256748423,
-0.0643888339,
0.0053661549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06894v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06894v2 | GenTranslate: Large Language Models are Generative Multilingual Speech and Machine Translators | 2024-02-10T07:20:49 | 2024-05-16T13:17:05 | Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Ruizhe Li, Dong Zhang, Zhehuai Chen, Eng Siong Chng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have stepped forward the
development of multilingual speech and machine translation by its reduced
representation errors and incorporated external knowledge. However, both
translation tasks typically utilize beam search decoding and top-1 hypothesis
selection for inference. These techniques struggle to fully exploit the rich
information in the diverse N-best hypotheses, making them less optimal for
translation tasks that require a single, high-quality output sequence. In this
paper, we propose a new generative paradigm for translation tasks, namely
"GenTranslate", which builds upon LLMs to generate better results from the
diverse translation versions in N-best list. Leveraging the rich linguistic
knowledge and strong reasoning abilities of LLMs, our new paradigm can
integrate the rich information in N-best candidates to generate a
higher-quality translation result. Furthermore, to support LLM finetuning, we
build and release a HypoTranslate dataset that contains over 592K
hypotheses-translation pairs in 11 languages. Experiments on various speech and
machine translation benchmarks (e.g., FLEURS, CoVoST-2, WMT) demonstrate that
our GenTranslate significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art model. | [
0.0149182435,
0.0487555675,
-0.0052074473,
0.0238422286,
-0.0381543823,
0.003490018,
0.0180206988,
-0.0250956174,
-0.0241926312,
-0.0015658522,
-0.0181344338,
-0.0706358701,
0.0259747449,
-0.0227251481,
0.0528157167,
-0.0311192609,
0.0335265845,
-0.0397757702,
-0.0244662724,
-0.0071604685,
-0.0322191082,
0.0467013419,
0.0164576676,
0.0502524227,
0.0053889183,
0.0019537862,
0.0337822139,
0.0509278886,
0.0417269468,
-0.0153385317,
-0.0303482693,
0.0281317011,
0.0142390858,
0.1019207016,
0.000001998,
-0.0164966341,
-0.018591363,
0.0140452804,
0.000350793,
0.0035379399,
0.0463843793,
-0.050269939,
-0.0258651152,
0.0386960395,
-0.0134006562,
-0.0177866817,
0.0513548255,
-0.0362253077,
0.0291560646,
0.0822179765,
-0.0031971463,
-0.0664244592,
0.0106491223,
-0.055403892,
0.0217468664,
-0.0732327253,
-0.0050442615,
-0.0187515337,
-0.0215880983,
0.0208949037,
-0.0061574033,
0.0683090091,
0.0058192578,
-0.0260883626,
-0.0344648324,
-0.0182666853,
-0.0038826852,
-0.0497287922,
0.0032142513,
0.0591997504,
-0.0570282824,
-0.0198553037,
-0.0016376262,
0.0047163065,
-0.0116662271,
-0.0065961313,
-0.0449448004,
0.0428895652,
-0.0103009781,
0.0043304292,
0.0602380149,
0.0165993832,
0.0495586246,
-0.0129771316,
-0.060805317,
0.0083134081,
0.0624655969,
-0.0090601631,
-0.0205957908,
0.0008094969,
-0.0096298521,
-0.0059659258,
0.0319053866,
-0.0113747772,
-0.0531481653,
0.0073657925,
-0.0291858017,
-0.048985634,
0.0026010585,
-0.0227660816,
0.0043515326,
0.0532319844,
0.0027547483,
0.0476268493,
-0.0161580276,
0.0348518379,
-0.048128292,
-0.0262383688,
-0.0954215452,
-0.0630275086,
-0.0134965023,
0.0343474336,
-0.0106629068,
-0.0441823341,
-0.0528236888,
-0.0087531786,
-0.0151789133,
-0.003446094,
0.0425491109,
-0.0008820862,
0.006269407,
-0.0296125691,
-0.0723231658,
-0.0386244953,
0.0109815132,
0.0844587311,
0.0082791084,
-0.0171566345,
-0.002019092,
-0.0814438909,
-0.0291507747,
0.0360905044,
-0.0024245079,
-0.0172637403,
-0.0162797626,
0.0687501729,
-0.0144775677,
-0.0263132472,
-0.0060571823,
0.0006399209,
-0.0138044981,
-0.0627806038,
0.0075573223,
-0.0595696159,
0.0662265718,
0.0039247051,
0.0014086888,
-0.0382926054,
0.0108039742,
-0.0304330736,
-0.0175376497,
0.0401135422,
0.0183785427,
0.0260730106,
0.0286567416,
-0.0188223254,
-0.0214628056,
0.0670334771,
0.0433591492,
0.0275794789,
0.0246575121,
-0.0071378206,
0.0030206933,
0.082866326,
-0.0280957036,
0.0215928014,
0.0188495237,
-0.015878547,
0.0159202907,
0.0465907417,
0.034848921,
0.0391764455,
-0.0330953635,
0.0352688879,
0.0588138327,
0.0186157338,
0.0191775151,
0.0317563601,
0.0675229952,
0.0266596936,
-0.0097494125,
-0.0260059275,
0.0092315478,
0.0201239735,
-0.008477808,
-0.0026416993,
0.0309526101,
0.0836011097,
-0.0132248159,
-0.0215966143,
-0.0040735221,
-0.0232643876,
-0.0219120644,
0.018670097,
0.0709734783,
0.0178672988,
-0.0653669983,
0.0473115444,
0.0186562613,
-0.0428991765,
0.0186725613,
-0.0316926949,
0.0020454056,
0.0611500107,
0.0485575683,
0.0164156631,
-0.0512756221,
-0.0293503571,
-0.0316324644,
0.048713427,
0.0589553006,
0.0118015101,
0.0258956626,
-0.0812832341,
-0.0240451675,
0.0567269847,
0.0222483519,
0.0518546365,
-0.0290772952,
0.0107252235,
0.0558102652,
-0.0096557559,
-0.0239376053,
0.0195285436,
-0.0465294346,
0.0240636058,
0.0409017317,
0.0013393633,
0.0112236412,
0.0255250111,
-0.0268794689,
0.0083411718,
0.0095553566,
-0.0359110162,
-0.0203661472,
0.0274295118,
-0.0404567868,
-0.0737727284,
0.0164019596,
-0.0526521355,
-0.0138876438,
-0.0177616347,
-0.0563914366,
-0.0428273678,
-0.0045379936,
-0.0508229025,
0.0159216784,
-0.0538347587,
0.031560652,
0.0019554773,
0.0113563053,
-0.022114763,
0.0389894098,
0.0108302282,
-0.0216964465,
0.0258982964,
-0.0159518495,
0.003458166,
-0.0557800382,
-0.0131473141,
0.0815301687,
-0.0015541423,
0.0167663097,
0.0298330374,
0.028129125,
0.0117353136,
-0.0245734639,
-0.067718178,
0.0407931358,
-0.0046307598,
0.0194461066,
0.0135029769,
0.0303865839,
0.0058025965,
0.0026739917,
0.0025673239,
-0.002966091,
0.0366768986,
-0.000090559,
-0.0115665505,
-0.0151689611,
-0.0045736232,
-0.0032718976,
-0.011597624,
0.0148214763,
0.0577447414,
-0.0045657419,
0.0070098327,
-0.0790927857,
0.0369685739,
-0.0450603403,
-0.0209882054,
-0.0067404495,
-0.0440725945,
-0.0017176124,
-0.0340680555,
0.0615461841,
0.0445438027,
0.0116946995,
-0.0335897878,
0.0201857723,
-0.0146941924,
-0.0413807668,
-0.0052194344,
-0.0355838947,
-0.0244987439,
-0.0391324237,
-0.0359884314,
-0.0111980997,
0.0237044059,
0.0206321217,
-0.0272932332,
-0.0815118328,
-0.0211144928,
0.0114855655,
-0.0009952923,
0.0030416762,
0.0271241609,
0.0052077547,
0.0350009911,
-0.0278880838,
-0.0237414166,
0.041447591,
-0.056047637,
-0.0113086011,
-0.0490596592,
0.0110777123,
-0.0419609509,
0.0321724564,
0.0024064374,
0.0321889371,
0.0117177144,
-0.0216448177,
-0.0371505879,
0.0375922136,
0.0224505477,
-0.0413518809,
0.0159722678,
-0.0690896735,
-0.0172653645,
-0.0181298051,
-0.0242367424,
-0.0071448707,
0.0149941389,
0.0092119277,
-0.0178048071,
0.0362541415,
-0.0023058285,
-0.046533931,
-0.0133097013,
0.0164157432,
0.0458562821,
-0.0015524826,
0.0257416405,
-0.0295607168,
0.054496713,
-0.0024687701,
-0.001973165,
0.0360814109,
-0.0320545547,
0.0137348184,
0.0131175183,
-0.0086454907,
-0.003622982,
-0.0210456382,
-0.0225733165,
0.0443859473,
0.0269194916,
-0.0619659163,
-0.0146193486,
0.0541449487,
-0.0424129218,
0.0482791737,
0.1059688553,
0.005970527,
-0.00013991,
-0.0069862646,
0.0171072651,
0.0264634024,
0.0129636563,
0.0213448778,
-0.0911824703,
-0.0301439278,
0.0282715168,
0.0232990365,
0.0326788016,
-0.0007277314,
-0.0070401831,
-0.1119384021,
0.0533430167,
0.0627457798,
-0.0063694776,
-0.0424761623,
0.000219201,
-0.0375207923,
-0.0521999709,
-0.0048259329,
0.006853336,
0.0389777534,
0.010564954,
0.0194948651,
0.0363251194,
-0.0930577368,
-0.0035723837,
-0.0405768976,
0.0373124182,
0.0681395754,
0.0585850999,
0.0120543381,
-0.0321242847,
-0.0252972767,
-0.0082388707,
-0.0202630442,
-0.0132644493,
-0.0219256207,
0.0189154446,
-0.0057140421,
0.0165247824,
0.0292668175,
-0.0162318628,
0.0136739919,
0.0052924138,
0.0526376776,
-0.0054711453,
-0.017084755,
0.0239587426,
-0.0244707316,
0.0087752044,
0.0662645027,
0.0161949061,
-0.0180647243,
-0.0048184879,
-0.0435030498,
-0.0095665213,
-0.042524498,
-0.0267269593,
0.0059265657,
-0.010924858,
-0.0279016942,
-0.0814041644,
-0.0022939113,
0.0201708004,
0.0252337828,
0.0093951225,
0.0070950529,
-0.005539875,
-0.0062437188,
0.0276301913,
0.0360467732,
-0.0228755809,
0.0013801523,
-0.0476632938,
0.0183107834,
0.0652791932,
-0.0347684771,
-0.005890361,
0.0726195797,
-0.0599920414,
-0.0725895911,
-0.0492933393,
0.0350260325,
0.0251321066,
0.019247286,
-0.0403060839,
-0.0278222747,
0.0390491486,
0.0171823073,
-0.0151460562,
-0.0194345266,
0.0211113989,
-0.0098549286,
-0.0367524028,
0.0527839437,
0.0005592041,
0.0192077197,
-0.0252225567,
0.0911462009,
0.0219421424,
-0.0534555912,
-0.0054684747,
0.0335588045,
0.0305743795,
-0.0778563619,
-0.0339926779,
-0.0258167721,
0.0004883381,
-0.0209762715,
-0.0167513043,
-0.0392369702,
0.0237562526,
0.0682189092,
-0.0022513929,
0.0076172077,
0.0016283775,
0.0272834226,
-0.0068175364,
-0.021904286,
-0.0011417863,
-0.0288834386,
0.0072533335,
0.0342396311,
0.0152051374,
0.0086408034,
0.0453860536,
0.0062464569,
0.0246390793,
-0.0536325201,
0.0212493055,
-0.0147884665,
0.0154776378,
-0.0016146286,
0.0203131307,
-0.0300001577,
-0.0643808767,
-0.0387403816,
0.0344230868,
0.0970334187,
0.0382994115,
0.1144696325,
0.0086291153,
-0.0262773018,
-0.0283890963,
0.075631462,
0.0029257771,
-0.0194398109,
-0.0192998517,
-0.0119103678,
-0.0324069597,
0.0036098917,
0.0660969764,
-0.0047380105,
0.0559902303,
-0.032420855,
-0.0152579434,
-0.0265887249,
-0.0460161418,
-0.0007768104,
-0.0567612238,
-0.0196444765,
-0.0158703048,
-0.0436957926,
-0.0469347835,
0.0197572503,
0.0115811154,
-0.0014361358,
-0.0074903555,
0.0137598002,
0.0660465807,
-0.0559343323,
-0.0075932876,
-0.0446929671,
-0.0201047156,
-0.0169352852,
-0.0302825086,
-0.0256789401,
-5.914740435e-33,
-0.0256436989,
0.0193809886,
0.0010122964,
-0.0483898968,
-0.0361361168,
-0.0416980051,
-0.0389759876,
-0.0205611754,
-0.008058981,
-0.0266714972,
0.0098193521,
-0.0124317715,
0.0196407624,
0.0236728154,
0.0140427006,
0.0354719236,
0.0727496892,
-0.0075237886,
-0.0237863027,
0.0475521721,
0.0281605218,
0.0161262788,
0.0751586333,
-0.0253485832,
-0.0152571425,
-0.028716078,
-0.0227196645,
0.0239404496,
-0.0350605287,
0.0281466376,
0.0090719992,
0.0198660996,
-0.0248608049,
-0.0647293702,
-0.0245006867,
-0.0122644929,
-0.0454570539,
0.0235310365,
0.0092712967,
0.0209947545,
-0.002479963,
-0.087659128,
0.0161042698,
-0.0232131686,
-0.0158950798,
-0.0062487591,
0.0023476966,
-0.0526396371,
-0.0271799136,
-0.0440968275,
-0.0732355192,
0.0401938856,
-0.0411001891,
-0.0309865624,
0.0246789791,
0.0696563795,
-0.0070743901,
0.0109033054,
-0.042014692,
0.0476456098,
0.0092633879,
0.0442013144,
0.081938006,
-0.0132348696,
-0.0023249236,
-0.017730603,
0.0092792427,
-0.0511450581,
0.0326925218,
-0.0076424517,
0.0257022902,
0.0351978466,
0.0212237034,
0.0793131664,
0.0111128949,
-0.0262508933,
-0.0605249368,
0.0351280682,
0.0061075781,
0.0026642932,
0.0413383655,
0.0348526612,
0.0001732587,
0.0064796037,
-0.068625696,
-0.0640116706,
-0.0025743828,
-0.0282810833,
0.0001888574,
0.017890038,
-0.0224141162,
-0.0091460515,
0.1225341409,
-0.0090815853,
0.0233590193,
0.0271917637,
-0.050546959,
0.0016984656,
-0.0187931415,
0.0812484547,
-0.0124126859,
-0.0389990211,
0.0531114601,
-0.0106554199,
-0.0066563697,
-0.0319555998,
0.0196863767,
0.0308867022,
-0.0308985468,
0.0303511228,
-0.0437075421,
-0.0102038467,
-0.0391913243,
0.0205869041,
0.0143410228,
0.0080468282,
0.0050557596,
0.0287500154,
0.0207274985,
0.0456054658,
-0.0333176106,
0.0230165515,
0.0290483814,
0.017427031,
-0.0320580192,
0.0457329042,
-0.0337630399,
-0.0311425813,
0.0405074842,
-0.0173437111,
-0.0553698577,
0.0200213306,
2.75e-7,
0.0303895101,
0.0701937228,
-0.0056591984,
0.029847648,
0.0416697711,
0.0373795368,
-0.0138112195,
0.0000333336,
0.0304927621,
0.022326421,
0.0239456613,
0.0273103435,
0.1109707803,
0.0255370121,
-0.076607585,
-0.0125567196,
-0.0195886157,
-0.0038732833,
-0.0576805584,
-0.0294017568,
0.0458432399,
0.1218596324,
-0.0423777066,
-0.003037442,
0.0081824157,
-0.0110336449,
0.0934013948,
0.0007498054,
-0.0468430854,
0.0116560115,
0.0020259386,
0.0187854301,
-0.0490860082,
-0.0209432747,
-0.0189726148,
0.0099405283,
0.0438409485,
0.0896079466,
0.0193125326,
-0.026956806,
0.0219424292,
0.0121908616,
-0.0159556959,
-0.0455745533,
0.0589140281,
-0.0125056459,
-0.0121111805,
-0.0114313401,
-0.0316416919,
0.0282031316,
0.0019844843,
-0.0654146671,
-0.0215117596,
0.0242691804,
0.0401479788,
-0.0038726155,
-0.0489424653,
-0.0365993679,
-0.0071875784,
-0.0155661525,
-0.0624325275,
-0.04643571,
0.0050753942,
-0.0076967976,
-0.0035293484,
-0.0266969521,
0.0186817851,
2.506511196e-34,
0.0366280749,
-0.003979899,
0.0085283658,
-0.0370248519,
0.0636021644,
-0.0115984511,
-0.0443561785,
0.0353301577,
-0.0161362551,
-0.0590858236,
-0.0380765162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07950v1 | Sentinels of the Stream: Unleashing Large Language Models for Dynamic Packet Classification in Software Defined Networks -- Position Paper | 2024-02-10T04:47:58 | 2024-02-10T04:47:58 | Shariq Murtuza | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | With the release of OpenAI's ChatGPT, the field of large language models
(LLM) saw an increase of academic interest in GPT based chat assistants. In the
next few months multiple accesible large language models were released that
included Meta's LLama models and Mistral AI's Mistral and Mixtral MoE models.
These models are available openly for a wide array of purposes with a wide
spectrum of licenses. These LLMs have found their use in a different number of
fields like code development, SQL generation etc. In this work we propose our
plan to explore the applicability of large language model in the domain of
network security. We plan to create Sentinel, a LLM, to analyse network packet
contents and pass a judgment on it's threat level. This work is a preliminary
report that will lay our plan for our future endeavors. | [
-0.021389449,
0.0224568304,
-0.0059424671,
0.0379031599,
-0.1007071212,
-0.0335932523,
0.0403074361,
-0.0229084175,
0.0588974766,
-0.078420192,
0.0508350991,
-0.0095653478,
-0.0476213992,
0.1010541022,
0.0307142753,
-0.024509877,
0.0672635287,
-0.0389058143,
-0.0257234629,
0.0249640364,
0.0052472795,
0.0103507936,
0.0243774056,
0.0603440888,
0.0613944009,
-0.0393489972,
-0.0382910185,
-0.0318442024,
0.0054013906,
-0.0015478159,
0.0056870878,
-0.0050790953,
0.0197536275,
0.0338804014,
0.0000019345,
-0.0299447607,
-0.0266271364,
0.0195434764,
-0.0475724749,
0.0490937904,
0.0142622087,
-0.0066312794,
-0.0378179103,
0.0625975281,
0.0016832394,
-0.0307376925,
0.0648709685,
0.0271605514,
0.0466027893,
0.0817436725,
-0.0035556655,
-0.0402520299,
0.0393199548,
-0.0093029076,
-0.029304374,
-0.0286599491,
0.0359806307,
-0.0078228861,
-0.0096609453,
0.0217811149,
-0.0138697177,
-0.0510333776,
-0.0118601853,
-0.0284666605,
-0.0103178462,
0.0394330397,
-0.0572833009,
0.0399635471,
-0.0558522306,
-0.0034657263,
-0.0400694162,
-0.0076369261,
0.0152798407,
0.0039667804,
-0.0335388295,
-0.0215203036,
0.0038728127,
-0.0066163377,
0.0149538564,
0.0095500248,
0.0211433545,
0.0280861594,
-0.0137348594,
0.0156712122,
-0.0479532331,
0.0290446915,
0.0268566888,
0.0332187973,
-0.0208469722,
-0.0754146948,
0.016492879,
-0.045044817,
0.022561878,
0.030811321,
-0.0278366916,
0.0047946163,
-0.0328199528,
0.006984422,
0.0272941664,
-0.0728539228,
-0.0263915695,
0.0046856948,
-0.0146561153,
0.0079770843,
0.0019329285,
0.050632216,
-0.0559479222,
0.0247060526,
0.0078367041,
-0.0403431803,
-0.039455723,
-0.0181369483,
0.0007771127,
0.0521780811,
0.0121255703,
-0.0349840075,
-0.091974318,
0.0671396703,
-0.020393556,
0.0255504604,
-0.0342087261,
-0.0395604409,
0.0349170938,
0.0426706299,
0.0009185259,
-0.0112225898,
-0.0241242163,
0.0117515288,
-0.0143512143,
-0.0596115887,
-0.0015987937,
0.0462810397,
-0.03625682,
-0.0363424793,
-0.0128029427,
0.1013300121,
-0.0032133942,
-0.0252068024,
-0.0082477992,
-0.0571469441,
0.0208812654,
-0.0013281471,
-0.0233381391,
-0.0260301139,
-0.0648215413,
-0.0333794206,
0.0182852969,
0.0001642587,
-0.0491016731,
-0.0766200647,
0.0002486404,
0.0097692041,
-0.0203326587,
0.0150600728,
-0.0021943522,
0.0037191273,
0.0188937373,
0.0169131253,
-0.0091823908,
0.0391967446,
0.0208224021,
-0.0250415336,
0.0309924539,
0.0303950105,
-0.0290175211,
-0.0105706984,
-0.035656523,
0.0285129659,
0.0382647701,
-0.0466426238,
-0.0265137274,
0.0544459336,
0.0200855453,
-0.0351174287,
0.0380049236,
0.049603723,
-0.0025822779,
0.0308168735,
0.0354730599,
0.0727504268,
-0.0178583078,
0.0036515666,
-0.0032633934,
0.0190305952,
-0.0190936793,
-0.0234218873,
-0.0084348582,
0.0436280705,
-0.0345635526,
-0.0146354772,
-0.0042299456,
-0.0330139697,
-0.0270160437,
0.0075184675,
0.0423862971,
0.0247048549,
-0.0078101452,
0.0011518288,
-0.0066489051,
0.0141764842,
-0.0311842598,
-0.095943436,
-0.0144185452,
0.0433641598,
0.0437780842,
-0.0234130137,
-0.0764253587,
-0.0171636157,
-0.0188017264,
-0.0014063891,
0.0276152119,
0.0299127866,
-0.0298379492,
-0.0395327359,
0.0351913571,
0.0271061957,
0.0428181142,
0.0131476531,
-0.0367151126,
0.0140095139,
-0.0093331076,
0.0181678515,
-0.0697971806,
0.0066784532,
0.0553247891,
-0.0305833332,
0.0401413478,
0.0081439819,
0.0843934715,
-0.0178662334,
-0.0400603451,
0.014936585,
0.0387854986,
0.0294919312,
-0.0305022597,
-0.0086762877,
0.0182781611,
0.0590459965,
-0.0242509209,
-0.0059514963,
0.0557784773,
0.0167825297,
-0.0649691969,
-0.0342889875,
0.0851809978,
-0.0129550481,
0.016695207,
-0.0072752736,
-0.0422343276,
-0.0163431261,
0.0470704734,
-0.0051131304,
-0.0024894448,
0.0468104407,
-0.0007802952,
-0.0121045168,
0.0266134534,
0.0443168059,
-0.0365438759,
-0.0276847072,
0.0016829177,
-0.0538507625,
0.0518347174,
0.0056686257,
0.0100796837,
0.0207552817,
-0.0230888687,
-0.0603915974,
0.0325053595,
-0.0367375985,
0.0792183951,
0.0383182205,
0.0489342436,
-0.0472988114,
-0.0274900459,
-0.0045892331,
0.0294955261,
0.0021593089,
-0.0247050077,
0.0285141896,
-0.039622955,
-0.0602833182,
-0.015692642,
-0.0305322725,
-0.0334379487,
0.1007451862,
0.0117836501,
-0.0480333827,
-0.0041185534,
0.0341364294,
-0.0678013191,
-0.0042203413,
-0.015904218,
-0.0656435043,
0.0022461694,
-0.0161011089,
-0.0250551011,
0.0334506743,
0.0322115086,
0.0311651248,
0.027656341,
-0.0189312045,
-0.0258936826,
-0.0017414559,
-0.0187570211,
-0.0647036508,
-0.039307382,
0.0444133244,
0.0664956719,
0.0728538856,
0.0207945891,
-0.0418011248,
0.0040755058,
-0.037909504,
0.0156916268,
0.0567591973,
-0.0470973365,
-0.0579849966,
-0.0179888066,
0.0154334791,
0.0393456183,
-0.0763603821,
0.0764941424,
-0.0019036554,
0.0174793825,
-0.0706072375,
-0.0839771554,
-0.066249229,
0.0516069829,
-0.0133746192,
0.0578181185,
0.0015549544,
-0.0345175192,
-0.0036965895,
-0.0542284921,
0.0232944302,
-0.0308365338,
-0.0239910483,
-0.0130588124,
0.0153869735,
-0.011527082,
-0.0040951902,
-0.0460979566,
-0.0030988706,
-0.012899993,
0.0072185467,
-0.0198291298,
0.0059440644,
-0.0301647112,
0.0729587823,
-0.0298956335,
0.0294995308,
0.0135219377,
0.0066020987,
-0.0256265588,
0.0004243432,
0.0082519874,
-0.0491717942,
-0.0358895212,
0.0501398034,
0.0626650602,
0.0289043207,
0.0270947833,
-0.0037958934,
-0.0341770351,
0.0070345784,
-0.0049293926,
-0.0398353338,
0.0099455109,
0.0674464405,
0.061651472,
-0.027973298,
-0.0088838879,
0.0730644092,
0.0285784844,
-0.0431583486,
-0.0079142675,
0.0262299087,
0.0004244436,
0.0238522626,
0.0677699596,
-0.08562316,
0.0044595995,
-0.0388067402,
0.0055813012,
-0.0367409922,
0.004996127,
-0.0084745279,
-0.0408992954,
0.0592233017,
0.0302170292,
-0.0470215119,
0.0015678891,
-0.0708122626,
-0.0141028957,
0.006014172,
0.0223608874,
-0.0467122793,
0.0681000873,
-0.0280364007,
0.0201584119,
-0.0316370055,
-0.0544469468,
0.0172762927,
-0.0360185727,
0.064138256,
0.0386638977,
0.0020708144,
-0.0452572703,
-0.0063687675,
0.0798055008,
-0.0595515706,
-0.0275431145,
0.0264655408,
0.01300852,
0.0385780297,
-0.0212269053,
-0.0152087025,
0.0319497362,
0.0051265992,
-0.0075129909,
0.019679727,
0.0608042851,
-0.0553361997,
-0.0225031599,
-0.0382480137,
-0.0177818742,
0.0517833345,
0.023760207,
0.0028308341,
-0.0047585391,
-0.0302678682,
-0.0586607084,
0.0048848679,
0.0384155363,
-0.0399643257,
0.0130795185,
-0.0044291704,
-0.0818221867,
-0.0140709803,
0.0381461829,
0.0066993413,
-0.0048757307,
0.0371756442,
0.0117143486,
0.0598784424,
0.0222306885,
0.006763367,
-0.0232339371,
-0.0181527641,
0.0426945984,
-0.0535395853,
0.0311516281,
0.0524570607,
0.0075458754,
-0.0641739294,
0.031194834,
-0.0801188275,
-0.0654487759,
0.0170690566,
0.0247017108,
0.0314147845,
-0.0645003095,
-0.061298579,
-0.0137004824,
0.0261551216,
0.0163157545,
-0.0043797689,
-0.0415922962,
0.0235111788,
-0.0383391306,
-0.0019866431,
-0.0144777,
-0.0259582158,
0.0480277762,
0.0116823716,
-0.0887052715,
-0.0143271983,
-0.0109387515,
0.0259586331,
0.0691232085,
0.0252295174,
0.0265247542,
-0.0158931632,
-0.0050383219,
0.0116148582,
0.0157039296,
-0.0012328064,
0.0270228926,
-0.0162542928,
0.0133983819,
-0.0374996513,
0.0230716094,
0.0213133171,
0.012491392,
-0.0368589275,
-0.012224135,
-0.0020143718,
0.0162794925,
0.0050974735,
0.0416468382,
-0.0178748965,
-0.0172757506,
-0.0008217003,
0.0182545967,
0.0453158244,
-0.01549224,
0.0117547736,
-0.0066149281,
0.0058915336,
-0.0408741608,
0.019033758,
-0.0544586778,
-0.0436254218,
0.0588376969,
0.0815063491,
0.0523103662,
0.0517384037,
-0.0093807857,
-0.0266603082,
0.0599058978,
-0.0458660796,
0.0506347157,
-0.0391397141,
-0.0296070147,
0.030413948,
-0.0149530973,
-0.0202430543,
0.0310019311,
0.0351273119,
-0.0055496395,
0.0312892832,
0.0250491351,
-0.0763445646,
-0.0380648822,
-0.0069818543,
-0.0143139316,
0.0462111756,
-0.0316141099,
0.0032394622,
-0.0410454459,
-0.0138760107,
-0.0203493088,
0.0064198663,
0.0604891106,
-0.0026367882,
-0.0007594137,
0.0684607327,
0.0171121992,
0.0021728489,
-0.0874778256,
-0.0366913788,
-0.027499089,
-0.0071142227,
0.0443391353,
-5.536628718e-33,
0.0360362567,
-0.0222662352,
-0.0163752139,
0.0230310746,
0.0018512923,
0.0093046287,
-0.031443581,
-0.0424437895,
-0.016970912,
-0.0330430865,
0.016048776,
0.0238922313,
0.0355556309,
0.0238820575,
-0.0067220991,
-0.0090663545,
0.0223421138,
-0.0128697595,
0.0063608396,
0.0661993921,
0.0657046735,
-0.0408157669,
0.0102922218,
-0.0475629307,
0.0215225611,
-0.0034060103,
0.0073402845,
-0.0105434814,
-0.0471135005,
0.0328905396,
-0.0124505227,
0.0276409704,
-0.0082109021,
0.0213800445,
-0.0109289717,
-0.0138034495,
0.0153330993,
0.002957467,
0.0077588367,
-0.0159816723,
0.0053442623,
-0.0674460605,
0.0207390543,
0.0209058281,
-0.0164264664,
0.0051468243,
0.0090444274,
0.0309297871,
-0.0209950022,
-0.0560572073,
0.0081158774,
0.003001662,
-0.0444300547,
0.0210125949,
-0.000560577,
-0.042901773,
-0.0006845674,
-0.0297224335,
-0.0149971619,
0.0650217459,
0.0080281673,
0.0300442744,
0.0164689142,
0.0153327603,
0.0001684975,
-0.0120505728,
0.0121952444,
0.0087715676,
0.0118458774,
0.0073974957,
-0.0020276639,
0.0398457274,
0.0379008241,
-0.0195049234,
0.0234011803,
-0.0679932311,
-0.0596903041,
0.0000519208,
0.0591407344,
0.032476902,
0.0263723787,
-0.0048300875,
-0.0404300094,
-0.0268521551,
0.0135342209,
-0.0382303707,
0.0105777672,
-0.008940978,
0.0074792067,
-0.0168582611,
-0.0022861511,
-0.0085048201,
0.024337694,
-0.050168816,
0.0203391407,
-0.009221931,
0.0132209556,
0.0254840981,
-0.0044001606,
0.0213901158,
-0.0082772058,
-0.0347976275,
-0.0011568534,
-0.0349709168,
-0.0067284349,
-0.0229336005,
0.0201279074,
0.0541043878,
-0.0529364385,
0.0194660947,
-0.0310821477,
0.0378130749,
-0.0020872834,
0.0447272621,
0.0129133901,
0.0115160327,
0.0448186174,
0.0102061313,
0.0035347992,
-0.0564731471,
-0.0028946789,
0.0352789424,
-0.0322364531,
0.033031486,
-0.0506492145,
0.0073528951,
-0.0529035181,
0.0549029633,
0.0253906939,
-0.0086285342,
0.0035914741,
-0.0159321167,
2.866e-7,
-0.020510586,
0.0500274189,
0.0417500623,
0.0777695701,
0.0192589723,
0.0237776339,
-0.0172972362,
0.0733947754,
-0.0031105375,
0.0129279234,
-0.0051172436,
-0.0237841085,
0.0371035375,
0.0320256166,
-0.0559762083,
0.029464731,
-0.0695968568,
-0.0260802303,
-0.1039572209,
0.0081508039,
0.0835295096,
0.0995103866,
0.0132103804,
0.014500252,
0.0242223404,
-0.0532220118,
-0.012252897,
-0.000795903,
-0.0061327172,
0.0146941878,
0.0877818167,
0.0564921685,
-0.0124788955,
0.0507022217,
-0.0155765638,
0.012370755,
-0.0540949926,
0.028746916,
0.041167777,
0.053325925,
-0.0315978751,
-0.0554254204,
-0.0100629516,
-0.0333642177,
0.0480960719,
0.0094574234,
-0.0595445447,
-0.0099422876,
0.0268472116,
-0.0708284825,
0.0219475366,
-0.001606825,
-0.0062072594,
0.0293852687,
-0.014774451,
-0.0578557141,
0.0104099,
-0.0618472844,
-0.0017994022,
-0.0195000861,
-0.0360865556,
0.003119299,
-0.0089495983,
0.0233697724,
0.0936768502,
-0.001688707,
0.0374740064,
2.579916226e-34,
0.0044584172,
-0.0001196868,
-0.0156840514,
0.0111416159,
-0.0124978153,
0.0120315496,
0.0211328939,
0.0096087353,
0.0052641989,
-0.015814608,
-0.029635109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06853v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06853v2 | History, Development, and Principles of Large Language Models-An Introductory Survey | 2024-02-10T01:18:15 | 2024-06-12T02:28:12 | Zhibo Chu, Shiwen Ni, Zichong Wang, Xi Feng, Min Yang, Wenbin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models serve as a cornerstone in natural language processing (NLP),
utilizing mathematical methods to generalize language laws and knowledge for
prediction and generation. Over extensive research spanning decades, language
modeling has progressed from initial statistical language models (SLMs) to the
contemporary landscape of large language models (LLMs). Notably, the swift
evolution of LLMs has reached the ability to process, understand, and generate
human-level text. Nevertheless, despite the significant advantages that LLMs
offer in improving both work and personal lives, the limited understanding
among general practitioners about the background and principles of these models
hampers their full potential. Notably, most LLMs reviews focus on specific
aspects and utilize specialized language, posing a challenge for practitioners
lacking relevant background knowledge. In light of this, this survey aims to
present a comprehensible overview of LLMs to assist a broader audience. It
strives to facilitate a comprehensive understanding by exploring the historical
background of language models and tracing their evolution over time. The survey
further investigates the factors influencing the development of LLMs,
emphasizing key contributions. Additionally, it concentrates on elucidating the
underlying principles of LLMs, equipping audiences with essential theoretical
knowledge. The survey also highlights the limitations of existing work and
points out promising future directions. | [
0.0756737143,
0.021833526,
-0.035829071,
0.0340975039,
-0.0681227744,
-0.0068005752,
0.0044857063,
0.0358984843,
-0.0120558571,
-0.0719040707,
0.0075893356,
-0.0914669335,
0.024848897,
0.0044710636,
0.0287043415,
-0.0555805676,
0.0262386706,
-0.0450244062,
-0.0114309005,
0.0028294865,
0.0089080967,
-0.0055259201,
0.0345313698,
0.0530347787,
-0.0112719722,
0.0194083564,
0.0268245544,
-0.0100346189,
-0.0505765267,
-0.0102207735,
-0.0279156268,
0.0257497635,
0.0335357301,
0.0431431122,
0.0000020161,
-0.0680353791,
0.0166769288,
0.0053419378,
-0.0047780769,
0.02584094,
0.0706033483,
-0.046384275,
-0.0075360234,
0.0088335639,
-0.0060694781,
0.0041341283,
0.0474893115,
0.0098380009,
0.0174674056,
0.0628558174,
-0.0149386274,
-0.0737654045,
0.0416636281,
-0.0302876737,
-0.0406549126,
-0.0235651024,
0.0835234001,
0.0328976363,
0.0215075146,
-0.0149447471,
-0.033495266,
0.0269853156,
-0.0301607661,
-0.0110384915,
-0.0086312918,
0.0146621792,
0.0018087835,
-0.0454602875,
-0.0051216218,
0.0260352325,
-0.0022252668,
-0.0141797476,
0.0350228101,
-0.0113753751,
-0.0439539738,
0.031652838,
-0.0635420382,
0.0435075611,
0.0144718466,
0.0504917316,
0.0502297431,
-0.0054725455,
0.0258337688,
0.0289695691,
-0.0463910773,
0.0592712127,
0.0367793366,
-0.0482466668,
-0.0270670615,
-0.0145104472,
-0.032539174,
-0.0526902378,
0.0343805738,
0.0404477678,
0.0148469983,
0.0271231811,
0.0015459524,
-0.0235618986,
0.0453514345,
-0.0633503273,
0.0449619032,
-0.0071696308,
0.0229542945,
0.0291472413,
0.0017045921,
0.0662439093,
-0.0324721709,
-0.0333838612,
-0.0381049067,
0.0088970875,
-0.0380188338,
-0.0242660884,
-0.0383958332,
0.0265614092,
-0.0311648399,
-0.027586937,
-0.026716711,
0.0110361064,
0.0467394069,
-0.0289197266,
0.0165784527,
-0.0237337258,
-0.010683978,
-0.0113954078,
-0.0220458768,
-0.003582566,
0.0177301895,
0.0231181681,
-0.0482804738,
-0.0347035751,
0.0352253281,
0.0345040038,
-0.0171446633,
-0.0191184636,
-0.0006378188,
0.0722289979,
0.042863708,
-0.0033096443,
-0.0386450067,
-0.006723878,
-0.0645565018,
-0.0667914674,
-0.0319447741,
-0.0603022054,
0.0103189657,
0.0106680347,
-0.0006614844,
-0.0369776711,
0.014330063,
0.0046105804,
-0.0847667679,
0.0184605252,
-0.0303447396,
0.0494212583,
0.0306063537,
-0.0042018327,
0.0592320152,
0.0545727164,
0.0417615138,
-0.0109728426,
0.0460692644,
-0.0145868622,
0.0179488715,
0.0739866197,
-0.0212805327,
-0.0000778257,
-0.055357635,
-0.019943079,
0.0080895405,
0.0280161686,
0.0032002488,
0.1149782166,
-0.011919044,
-0.0152612925,
0.0566041395,
0.0722453594,
0.0139383161,
0.051441282,
0.0641139075,
0.0125780366,
0.040428903,
-0.011413916,
0.0001716675,
-0.0544948503,
-0.0210792944,
0.0054665059,
0.002045274,
0.0646440983,
-0.0007343753,
-0.0214824732,
-0.0465263985,
-0.0041690064,
0.0048259879,
-0.0302987639,
0.0958892554,
-0.0237374492,
-0.005243422,
0.0418569446,
0.0301736183,
-0.0207443293,
0.0289557502,
-0.0624277554,
0.0280021094,
0.0617121197,
0.0653100759,
0.009796652,
0.0204161592,
-0.0031276352,
-0.0178036541,
0.0430714674,
-0.0082853297,
-0.0005479438,
-0.0151609275,
-0.0353343114,
0.0201165713,
0.0349310525,
0.0096996147,
-0.0208892599,
-0.0017001514,
-0.0123554124,
0.0175189655,
-0.0252653081,
-0.0378898978,
0.0515841879,
-0.051557526,
-0.0098270103,
-0.022638455,
-0.0360879488,
0.0505789928,
0.0288716741,
-0.0138121909,
0.0271557942,
0.0151718408,
-0.0359460115,
0.0075188344,
0.008291089,
-0.0162548535,
-0.0006385342,
0.0666565523,
0.0032882388,
0.0470756814,
-0.0090243854,
0.0095775072,
-0.0451126434,
0.0132710142,
-0.0484960265,
0.0667681843,
-0.0634534135,
0.0466037877,
-0.0298779067,
-0.0023484,
-0.067716226,
0.0656126142,
-0.0046002669,
0.0354519449,
0.0209406409,
-0.0116243931,
0.0292887483,
-0.0430144556,
-0.0272348113,
0.0205208454,
0.0073491903,
0.0132290646,
0.0416292064,
-0.0149944965,
-0.0060828454,
-0.0506562144,
-0.0562896505,
-0.0122071914,
-0.00562821,
0.0235720184,
-0.0088203941,
-0.0157715678,
-0.0386325754,
0.0160013232,
-0.0002585606,
-0.0017405137,
0.0352544785,
0.0246647894,
0.0297370963,
0.0065106028,
-0.0762629882,
-0.050428886,
-0.0285257529,
-0.0064429697,
0.0519072041,
0.0189478938,
-0.0439270101,
-0.0774563327,
0.0620406568,
-0.0406297408,
0.0361311473,
-0.0205150675,
-0.0197446235,
-0.0192894153,
-0.0306949355,
0.0718668252,
0.00139674,
0.015243629,
0.032666117,
0.0508662648,
-0.041413404,
-0.0156480279,
-0.0355491638,
-0.0653523207,
-0.0013339395,
-0.0578247532,
-0.0416738503,
-0.000759934,
0.0968777016,
0.0120727187,
-0.0366171524,
-0.0171551201,
0.0119777769,
-0.0595742762,
-0.0202542413,
0.0060704588,
-0.0343500562,
-0.0539880432,
0.028747607,
-0.0333428606,
-0.075755395,
0.0279146694,
-0.0619452074,
0.0161336903,
-0.0411791541,
-0.0353714526,
-0.052973628,
0.0647170097,
0.0184617192,
0.0268105809,
0.0093621584,
-0.0332513526,
-0.0078424411,
-0.0119779073,
0.0046233954,
-0.0424979553,
0.0309873186,
-0.0434493087,
0.0418568477,
0.00131158,
0.0042039803,
0.000186698,
-0.0727936327,
-0.0416757986,
0.0046507828,
0.0268472433,
-0.01663105,
-0.0055564339,
0.0571407489,
0.0083950479,
-0.0218148306,
0.014590973,
0.0058160452,
-0.0227511693,
0.0358115584,
0.0439939052,
-0.0404062755,
0.0245635808,
-0.0069390582,
-0.0068438891,
0.0349417552,
0.0264371205,
0.0624940358,
-0.010305265,
-0.0122699505,
0.0621742122,
-0.0344789587,
-0.0578363091,
0.039869342,
0.0154214557,
-0.0426211022,
0.0276574679,
0.1147787645,
0.0298547409,
-0.0089516398,
0.0211320426,
-0.0061582602,
-0.0032071106,
0.0226450078,
0.0065936618,
-0.0474740006,
0.0100042028,
0.0090878038,
-0.0265016463,
-0.0313999802,
-0.0419819206,
0.0008542223,
-0.1036559194,
0.0224246308,
0.0158458035,
-0.0174023602,
-0.0222590957,
-0.0437230356,
-0.0100402851,
-0.0019696432,
0.0092325099,
0.0156086618,
-0.0393018238,
-0.0045482037,
0.0707842559,
-0.0806969479,
-0.0578571819,
-0.0035392644,
-0.0649892241,
0.0647704601,
0.0769304335,
0.0525125749,
-0.0289492644,
-0.0127171027,
0.0178398211,
-0.0051045343,
0.0120005338,
-0.0264235828,
-0.0023434293,
-0.0000593473,
-0.0026727968,
-0.0503838472,
0.0040583601,
-0.0057260306,
-0.0154583585,
-0.0060788943,
0.0751398429,
-0.0019157005,
-0.0431901105,
-0.0207980331,
0.0194769632,
-0.0001385137,
0.0902650356,
0.0205387548,
-0.0322366357,
-0.0296366811,
-0.0089161759,
0.0161172599,
0.0177961867,
-0.0494543202,
0.0000126965,
-0.0034529751,
-0.0009792274,
-0.0372027718,
0.0428496972,
0.0191923119,
0.0062240907,
0.0416226797,
0.0468737297,
0.0155782998,
-0.0247113723,
-0.0032825202,
-0.0084897568,
-0.0417961963,
0.0118643083,
-0.034685839,
0.0026552193,
0.0662050247,
-0.031547036,
-0.0067380201,
0.0008111451,
-0.0976864547,
-0.0900795683,
-0.0014706854,
0.0212218389,
0.02955232,
0.0045985309,
0.001820847,
-0.0680240393,
0.0303614549,
0.0105682472,
-0.0259161163,
0.0375578888,
-0.0128973396,
0.02553018,
0.0089368336,
0.0317746215,
-0.0079665557,
0.0208867714,
0.004410021,
0.0390283465,
-0.0160741583,
-0.0482655801,
0.0290871002,
0.0282359198,
0.0166515596,
-0.0396444388,
-0.0227750465,
-0.0142441038,
-0.0376943201,
-0.0494069979,
0.0080678277,
-0.0518628657,
-0.0115023255,
0.0470394567,
0.013041052,
-0.0434377789,
-0.0179971587,
-0.0365243889,
0.0542515479,
-0.0260522179,
0.0570746139,
-0.0160254743,
0.0121290451,
0.0618678816,
-0.0083987471,
0.0162823964,
0.0419101082,
-0.0574831292,
0.0023365892,
0.0132996561,
0.0205752812,
-0.0041480791,
-0.016782809,
-0.0444387309,
-0.0185060501,
-0.0318926014,
-0.0508036651,
-0.0160078555,
0.0241640452,
0.0590083674,
0.0113538438,
0.042063877,
-0.0208618641,
-0.0153358513,
-0.030848518,
0.0241467971,
0.0149899879,
-0.0166960116,
0.0133949574,
-0.0079975771,
-0.0513038933,
0.0385649316,
0.08691331,
0.0426792912,
0.017601423,
0.0279272869,
-0.0360841341,
0.0108887721,
-0.0135999899,
0.0203257091,
-0.0124694984,
-0.0282259341,
0.0173463654,
-0.0986382291,
-0.0484735779,
0.0177251548,
0.0034678944,
0.0229385719,
-0.0354153328,
0.0056121517,
0.0947223082,
0.0139756734,
0.0212556478,
-0.0528241359,
0.0093417354,
-0.0282231811,
-0.0126047265,
0.0069845449,
-6.392998026e-33,
-0.0105558606,
-0.0202716626,
0.028070705,
0.0030339384,
-0.0447474644,
-0.0225538276,
-0.0078591574,
0.0117123881,
0.0038499194,
-0.0224368125,
-0.0061448258,
-0.0151198516,
0.007441306,
0.0106031932,
0.0101022767,
0.0345135629,
0.0333811529,
-0.0226425938,
0.0419424362,
-0.0131488135,
0.0219721384,
0.0283549186,
0.0348530486,
-0.0513050258,
0.037554238,
-0.0106299724,
-0.002874261,
0.0445532314,
-0.0128042391,
0.0537140481,
-0.0558874942,
0.0393171124,
0.0477472693,
-0.0314123333,
-0.030077409,
0.0301744845,
-0.0314060897,
0.0146936411,
0.0598655567,
-0.0344442911,
0.012924497,
-0.0109948218,
0.0386266746,
-0.0075051961,
-0.0661992803,
0.0287444834,
0.0265990421,
-0.0402058922,
-0.0379488915,
-0.018985711,
-0.0376030318,
0.0353149958,
0.0113640195,
0.01957912,
0.0378264599,
-0.0294153392,
-0.0153008681,
0.0282853264,
-0.014692938,
0.0414527208,
0.044920709,
0.0414348617,
0.0296129864,
0.0324120745,
0.0249437224,
0.0614234693,
0.0476022735,
-0.0144150257,
-0.0314470194,
-0.0160172079,
0.0295978561,
0.0156292971,
0.0039843931,
0.0468431152,
-0.0045474614,
-0.0384202711,
-0.0710643679,
-0.018697314,
0.0314340964,
0.0257671718,
0.0459231474,
0.0253399145,
-0.0379511528,
-0.0635006055,
-0.0485074818,
-0.0331151597,
-0.0005409742,
-0.0031954867,
0.0171538852,
0.0222948436,
-0.0016376323,
0.0173702762,
0.0376053825,
-0.0630902573,
-0.0490791015,
-0.0119245611,
-0.0020238732,
0.040988341,
-0.0034753443,
0.0342137776,
-0.115309976,
-0.0541460738,
-0.0266783722,
-0.0174458753,
-0.0230880231,
-0.0184444338,
-0.0245906655,
0.0165680889,
-0.0257906429,
-0.0081321131,
0.0084571084,
-0.0287417863,
0.0263431277,
0.0038725743,
0.0291804299,
0.000447479,
0.0045681247,
0.0193700213,
0.0372775048,
-0.0069955792,
0.0140678417,
-0.0230926946,
0.019300634,
0.0340515524,
-0.0209626183,
0.0044975393,
-0.0314371474,
-0.0041951202,
0.089906916,
-0.0016600608,
-0.0134305134,
-0.0221212842,
2.699e-7,
0.0555879362,
0.0597728193,
0.035643898,
-0.0171738379,
0.0309049357,
-0.0185497347,
-0.0120659443,
-0.0068054702,
0.0147827948,
0.005305246,
0.0127651831,
0.0193020999,
0.0345617123,
-0.0114758005,
-0.0760731623,
0.0069644111,
-0.0628038049,
0.0118873753,
-0.0637955815,
0.030490553,
0.0007733519,
0.093030408,
-0.0059864325,
-0.0195061862,
-0.0478370003,
-0.0577576086,
0.0763410702,
-0.0585470237,
-0.0262027793,
0.0521944389,
0.0414926633,
-0.0012622394,
0.0050152596,
-0.0002451789,
0.0116612753,
0.0372760259,
0.0388246514,
0.062182378,
-0.0006207727,
0.0494830012,
0.0194983743,
-0.0184197929,
-0.0070364182,
-0.0592248328,
0.0603982657,
-0.032044366,
-0.0461027138,
-0.0338393599,
-0.0116094975,
-0.0050532822,
-0.0215600412,
-0.0179814287,
-0.0053729853,
-0.0097632334,
0.0229390655,
0.0049456102,
-0.0039762836,
-0.0592685975,
-0.0065542883,
0.0103701977,
-0.0540991127,
-0.0604753755,
-0.0224090032,
-0.0135812797,
0.0216428954,
-0.0655690208,
0.0038554613,
2.845858966e-34,
0.0315506198,
-0.0041392231,
0.0061933263,
0.0322440118,
0.0206226688,
0.0099184653,
-0.0309654362,
0.0510069467,
-0.0049894666,
-0.1091416553,
-0.0113665471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06852v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06852v2 | ChemLLM: A Chemical Large Language Model | 2024-02-10T01:11:59 | 2024-04-25T14:34:28 | Di Zhang, Wei Liu, Qian Tan, Jingdan Chen, Hang Yan, Yuliang Yan, Jiatong Li, Weiran Huang, Xiangyu Yue, Wanli Ouyang, Dongzhan Zhou, Shufei Zhang, Mao Su, Han-Sen Zhong, Yuqiang Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made impressive progress in chemistry
applications. However, the community lacks an LLM specifically designed for
chemistry. The main challenges are two-fold: firstly, most chemical data and
scientific knowledge are stored in structured databases, which limits the
model's ability to sustain coherent dialogue when used directly. Secondly,
there is an absence of objective and fair benchmark that encompass most
chemistry tasks. Here, we introduce ChemLLM, a comprehensive framework that
features the first LLM dedicated to chemistry. It also includes ChemData, a
dataset specifically designed for instruction tuning, and ChemBench, a robust
benchmark covering nine essential chemistry tasks. ChemLLM is adept at
performing various tasks across chemical disciplines with fluid dialogue
interaction. Notably, ChemLLM achieves results comparable to GPT-4 on the core
chemical tasks and demonstrates competitive performance with LLMs of similar
size in general scenarios. ChemLLM paves a new path for exploration in chemical
studies, and our method of incorporating structured chemical knowledge into
dialogue systems sets a new standard for developing LLMs in various scientific
fields. Codes, Datasets, and Model weights are publicly accessible at
https://hf.co/AI4Chem | [
0.0191223398,
0.0781055912,
0.0119472425,
0.0335945711,
-0.0040217135,
0.0161422342,
0.0262947902,
0.0091779213,
0.0473083071,
0.0013965212,
-0.0650153384,
-0.0559519306,
-0.0290302131,
0.0465803444,
0.0279426649,
-0.031726826,
0.0153453499,
-0.0647174567,
0.0028281312,
-0.0140979262,
0.0371128097,
-0.0152769964,
-0.0335660204,
0.0050108735,
0.0353225656,
-0.0161882658,
-0.0122585576,
-0.0101037258,
0.013474212,
-0.0265206173,
-0.0049899649,
0.0781055391,
0.0320158713,
0.0622176677,
0.0000019714,
-0.0651503727,
0.0176098607,
0.0209377632,
-0.032112278,
-0.0025664954,
0.0178051926,
-0.0364319459,
-0.0198207218,
0.0035172903,
-0.0383222327,
0.0176183544,
0.1013700366,
-0.0025776448,
0.0505738854,
0.0483450294,
0.0121623445,
-0.0051071402,
0.0213309266,
-0.0213627331,
0.0349234864,
-0.0395895392,
0.0445655398,
0.0508386493,
0.0666795447,
0.0182705652,
-0.0035202629,
0.0700503588,
-0.0037489359,
-0.0650077388,
-0.0018389663,
0.0116997603,
-0.0390072614,
-0.0141955744,
-0.0080234893,
0.101414606,
0.026414955,
0.0016722248,
-0.0378875844,
0.0014072522,
-0.0315866731,
-0.0034411787,
-0.0806986615,
0.0085766679,
0.0042129061,
-0.0050073601,
-0.0131194498,
-0.0222618282,
0.0081922663,
0.0074411728,
0.005189199,
0.0812479034,
0.0024364525,
-0.0132786101,
-0.0133507643,
-0.0044712406,
-0.0427056663,
-0.0234027188,
0.0042700442,
0.0271631833,
-0.0593909957,
0.0255740937,
0.0162383337,
0.0115634622,
0.0565441065,
-0.0368929282,
0.0551961586,
0.0087033007,
0.0149477795,
0.0668046176,
0.0176300537,
0.0527609251,
-0.00857729,
0.0020819644,
-0.0291671604,
0.0020558522,
-0.0633877516,
-0.0037426199,
-0.0478273481,
0.0036739374,
-0.0598743334,
-0.0302750636,
-0.0349216014,
0.0400762744,
0.0098779192,
0.0279953144,
0.0274989828,
0.0144840144,
-0.0270375721,
0.0128965294,
-0.0193319824,
0.0738472566,
-0.0009327299,
-0.0023729056,
0.0170798991,
-0.0519833863,
-0.0506046414,
0.0068633589,
-0.038117528,
-0.0351126455,
-0.0005405055,
0.1139268354,
-0.0089234523,
0.0159933511,
0.0332946777,
-0.0402400792,
0.0076535861,
-0.0726842806,
0.0141301835,
-0.0384019464,
0.0757111609,
0.0297553986,
0.0104542961,
-0.0647712573,
0.0099370461,
-0.0239724312,
0.0064011184,
0.0970572233,
-0.0102314828,
-0.0398493446,
0.0378852487,
0.0120828301,
-0.0014418052,
0.0346668661,
0.0148055432,
-0.0190486126,
0.0020792226,
-0.0186778773,
-0.0117867477,
0.0078456169,
0.0025275438,
0.0001102165,
-0.0042574112,
0.0129050966,
0.0065417676,
0.0992309004,
0.0026439736,
0.0278385691,
-0.0231566951,
-0.026371194,
0.0562899858,
0.0247800853,
0.0176494289,
-0.0196478367,
0.0228560828,
0.0292066541,
0.0448176563,
-0.021443313,
-0.0324610062,
0.0529063083,
0.0026393132,
-0.0026286733,
0.046109803,
0.0270237811,
-0.0158788543,
-0.0248612668,
-0.0068956162,
0.0139115686,
-0.0091167307,
-0.0073986701,
0.0468542054,
-0.0289784968,
-0.0597763807,
0.0384915918,
0.0507205874,
-0.0348722413,
-0.0229784045,
-0.026791228,
0.0500342064,
0.1010899171,
0.0353459343,
-0.0560797825,
-0.0550117418,
-0.0010708208,
0.0015342464,
0.0364512652,
0.0276012868,
-0.0232153423,
0.0312277451,
-0.0296271499,
-0.0110839447,
-0.0424109772,
0.0169391781,
0.0018693195,
0.0067160865,
-0.0137839206,
-0.0096033728,
0.0039481418,
-0.0254581179,
0.004022243,
-0.0199265033,
-0.0490850545,
-0.0133450367,
-0.0307560749,
0.0368866064,
0.0176306292,
-0.0090546859,
0.0198621843,
0.0625707582,
-0.0279847533,
0.0208261218,
-0.0344016217,
0.0050737909,
-0.0525962077,
0.0340768062,
0.0102122994,
-0.0029688377,
-0.0266210735,
-0.0548552126,
-0.0339498073,
0.0523395091,
0.0056257341,
0.0003076307,
0.0028226508,
0.0052620587,
0.0056826868,
0.0397611149,
-0.046698954,
0.0161480438,
0.009777368,
0.0224356446,
0.0247155447,
0.0403151512,
0.0068482095,
-0.0640934259,
-0.0063850977,
0.005933905,
0.0457490124,
0.029438382,
0.0093630869,
-0.010000769,
-0.0490814485,
0.0074141701,
-0.0641130507,
0.0035641447,
-0.0127930818,
-0.002104956,
0.0189669244,
0.0015633248,
0.0057215299,
-0.0091462098,
-0.0057842922,
-0.0137360645,
-0.0036868833,
0.0015201438,
0.0409689918,
0.0357913412,
-0.0382792391,
-0.0623933375,
-0.037429072,
-0.0113685019,
0.0380429663,
0.0088844812,
-0.0199297555,
-0.0297506079,
-0.0126986969,
-0.0134187602,
0.0264062136,
-0.0027757469,
-0.0120774191,
0.0262486935,
-0.0173089262,
0.0059015495,
0.0501693524,
-0.0139581319,
0.0416448414,
0.0532295518,
-0.0166807361,
-0.0518592,
0.0094328858,
-0.0257064831,
-0.0070256027,
-0.0001011697,
0.0005027357,
0.0041786935,
0.0793968067,
-0.0582969747,
0.0330229402,
-0.0271945223,
0.0416398831,
0.0065546557,
-0.0263589714,
-0.0142188286,
0.0181236919,
-0.0080725327,
-0.0049845027,
0.002024852,
-0.055103451,
0.1002110019,
-0.0443376228,
-0.0025226625,
-0.0710728019,
-0.0220854655,
-0.0045897583,
0.0248100068,
-0.0029207212,
0.0123991761,
0.0172932856,
-0.0067666396,
0.0020968111,
-0.0085488167,
0.024868425,
-0.0023684588,
0.0626773685,
-0.0913702399,
0.0249007177,
0.0035702351,
-0.0483526476,
-0.0070221624,
0.0285000633,
-0.03547775,
0.0419930257,
0.0586432107,
-0.0777007788,
-0.0368232466,
0.0224698577,
0.0419062786,
0.0232572798,
-0.0226760358,
0.0023220063,
-0.0401466228,
0.0226416271,
0.0477528423,
-0.0165235791,
0.0217751134,
-0.0325120836,
0.0801002756,
0.0569773838,
0.0025288337,
-0.0252548791,
-0.0117593985,
0.0009304507,
0.0161376651,
0.0140240602,
0.0006250612,
-0.002111013,
0.0232658722,
-0.0565009415,
-0.0452821739,
0.0910339206,
0.0145526035,
-0.0250815656,
0.0059316684,
-0.0049338131,
0.0100064585,
-0.0122614149,
0.0537442937,
-0.1161968708,
-0.0278928783,
-0.0316187739,
0.0142578715,
0.0077506038,
-0.0132732634,
-0.0307961982,
-0.0568907782,
0.0481614135,
0.0388647765,
-0.0561536625,
-0.0303390026,
-0.0760187805,
-0.0163162593,
-0.0240001343,
0.0413275734,
0.049050089,
0.0000998559,
-0.0353403799,
0.0176977813,
-0.000943393,
-0.093058452,
0.0328033119,
-0.0068388153,
0.0363838188,
0.0552089959,
0.0071766209,
0.011531367,
-0.0083122943,
0.0375020579,
0.0218139831,
-0.0061603701,
-0.0366452895,
0.0193121452,
0.0440677367,
-0.0276011229,
-0.0225245897,
0.040066611,
-0.0256567113,
-0.025458958,
-0.0129704038,
0.1086629033,
-0.0372924209,
-0.0034745289,
-0.0356842577,
0.0104511194,
0.03445521,
0.072573334,
0.0068717287,
-0.0217884965,
-0.0893917531,
-0.0374360047,
-0.029118767,
-0.0424707383,
0.0075380392,
-0.0222546123,
-0.0195002165,
-0.0000363706,
-0.0214269497,
-0.0146350637,
0.0549940616,
-0.0040948512,
-0.0231645871,
0.0234731417,
0.0142505327,
-0.0207367036,
-0.0072829286,
0.0496787392,
-0.0215207543,
0.0404588915,
-0.078225933,
-0.0853850096,
0.0518553182,
-0.0114802206,
-0.0189741459,
0.0650321916,
-0.0735576078,
-0.0848772451,
0.0010617221,
0.0486308262,
0.0223315433,
0.0326190144,
-0.0103725176,
-0.0756893381,
0.0267331712,
0.0242325962,
-0.0304625332,
-0.0040084166,
-0.0220788307,
0.0075712223,
-0.0218380727,
0.0035756994,
-0.0206775386,
0.0175483134,
-0.0265666898,
0.0438666008,
-0.0392925255,
-0.0546515509,
0.0273453388,
0.0139888003,
0.0350242369,
0.0382826999,
-0.0113768103,
-0.022425618,
0.0080444766,
0.0005422067,
0.0018574094,
-0.0472845547,
-0.0060003768,
0.0409010127,
-0.0518360361,
0.0027708749,
-0.0246049017,
-0.0247314814,
0.0263480656,
-0.0171700828,
0.0338601358,
0.0233471449,
-0.0123281162,
0.1166705191,
-0.0062580863,
-0.0059893704,
0.0404527299,
-0.0356397182,
0.0564931855,
-0.018722171,
0.0529817604,
0.0166869648,
0.0230091661,
-0.0098360358,
0.0396492369,
-0.0646185726,
-0.0749916658,
-0.0403324887,
0.0279123615,
0.0488743298,
0.0140460972,
0.0604005717,
-0.0456651151,
-0.0127515141,
-0.0397747569,
0.024256492,
0.0116155222,
-0.0247626361,
0.0767338499,
0.0353383124,
0.0123165436,
-0.0078751622,
0.0770056918,
0.0133665362,
0.0355442241,
0.0016971565,
-0.0326983593,
-0.03738074,
-0.0493970662,
-0.0186874587,
0.0180476643,
-0.0166294463,
-0.0106738321,
-0.0332316011,
-0.0360252,
0.0099374,
0.0416090041,
-0.0326086506,
-0.0107902018,
0.0583892912,
0.0556433946,
0.0118855173,
-0.0455906056,
-0.0300382264,
0.0311591886,
-0.0016532168,
-0.0617077984,
-0.0190907065,
-5.772379988e-33,
-0.0279903505,
-0.0011677175,
0.0312920585,
0.0183973946,
-0.0208655149,
-0.0398821607,
-0.0897697806,
0.0014382042,
-0.011274281,
0.0751952305,
0.0058361623,
0.0024964095,
0.0113957468,
-0.0032050901,
0.0137339206,
-0.0063581667,
0.0194444396,
0.014972725,
-0.0139248651,
0.0574112684,
0.0659576952,
0.0293456465,
0.0269909203,
-0.0505895168,
-0.0017499645,
0.0313812867,
0.0147659611,
0.006550448,
-0.0611780547,
0.0586642995,
-0.0321815088,
0.0738056228,
-0.0130187524,
-0.027672898,
-0.0414783433,
-0.002821319,
-0.0563954711,
-0.0086821197,
0.0332477316,
-0.0092170965,
-0.0183399543,
-0.0177153684,
-0.0023910047,
-0.0066337283,
-0.0272067357,
-0.0305570457,
-0.0057067419,
-0.0087159323,
-0.0052514914,
-0.0233287066,
-0.0785275027,
0.0186790004,
-0.0053470349,
-0.0017207672,
0.0091991723,
0.0187796298,
0.0062471451,
-0.0218906477,
-0.022774348,
0.0610803403,
0.0177957639,
0.0432642438,
0.0556288436,
0.0258055013,
0.0060527292,
0.0308593959,
0.0144710829,
0.005344565,
0.0143577,
0.007958645,
-0.0153881051,
0.0348339118,
0.0257369597,
0.0178537387,
-0.0028955811,
0.0250067562,
-0.087536104,
-0.0196908433,
-0.0139733572,
0.0268629137,
-0.0144631201,
0.0324081257,
-0.0119408024,
-0.054432217,
-0.0375566669,
0.060993854,
-0.0157725513,
-0.0330862738,
-0.002611998,
-0.0450019166,
-0.0228975695,
-0.0015290618,
0.0333506986,
-0.0389794335,
-0.0362939239,
0.0410100035,
-0.0120088831,
0.0262037572,
-0.0019586191,
0.01959599,
-0.0881112441,
-0.0293791816,
0.0257004742,
-0.0144288493,
0.0004559527,
0.0056294077,
-0.0088135852,
0.0208292268,
-0.0025699385,
-0.0007719334,
-0.0857282281,
0.0159826316,
0.013965019,
0.0248703584,
-0.0123635512,
0.0233975407,
0.001085892,
0.0587643422,
-0.0216359627,
-0.0480631888,
0.0085434094,
0.0043040132,
0.012500071,
0.0247946437,
-0.0527241863,
0.0170352813,
-0.0733947381,
0.0039951368,
0.01774735,
-0.054088112,
-0.0089627886,
-0.0000435371,
2.636e-7,
0.05599178,
0.0267619975,
0.0567054674,
0.0142082302,
-0.0064231297,
-0.0093048625,
-0.0282868203,
0.0186518598,
-0.012745332,
-0.0279830378,
-0.0030999109,
0.0222630966,
0.0158819128,
0.0139212189,
-0.0611384697,
-0.0294690747,
-0.062471617,
-0.0564889312,
-0.0583172031,
-0.0382011943,
0.0033799706,
0.0761461332,
-0.0165552627,
-0.0236359686,
0.0389055572,
-0.0046128789,
0.0472340956,
-0.0216154289,
0.0158014502,
0.0922606587,
-0.0326684043,
-0.0515842065,
-0.0030286708,
0.0587204732,
-0.0236924123,
-0.022362031,
-0.0247195829,
0.0792293921,
-0.0274525527,
-0.0390863679,
0.0263589174,
-0.0260016266,
0.0275690537,
-0.0381656066,
-0.0016666611,
-0.0217699558,
0.0010630549,
-0.0065029208,
-0.0135206711,
-0.0319111906,
0.0337842554,
-0.0357403681,
0.0012092191,
0.0162810385,
-0.0073986831,
0.0185855571,
0.0137856053,
-0.059854757,
-0.0532450564,
-0.0139064118,
-0.0625034273,
-0.033034537,
-0.0320377909,
-0.0346196704,
-0.0191011932,
-0.0197505318,
-0.0105806654,
2.420608273e-34,
0.0696257427,
-0.0129359458,
0.0369946323,
0.0249795821,
0.0590427145,
-0.0104400432,
-0.0212375894,
0.0313686021,
0.0329163633,
-0.1126829833,
-0.0184726249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06820v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06820v2 | Forecasting Events in Soccer Matches Through Language | 2024-02-09T23:02:57 | 2024-04-26T11:45:02 | Tiago Mendes-Neves, Luís Meireles, João Mendes-Moreira | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This paper introduces an approach to predicting the next event in a soccer
match, a challenge bearing remarkable similarities to the problem faced by
Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike other methods that severely limit event
dynamics in soccer, often abstracting from many variables or relying on a mix
of sequential models, our research proposes a novel technique inspired by the
methodologies used in LLMs. These models predict a complete chain of variables
that compose an event, significantly simplifying the construction of Large
Event Models (LEMs) for soccer. Utilizing deep learning on the publicly
available WyScout dataset, the proposed approach notably surpasses the
performance of previous LEM proposals in critical areas, such as the prediction
accuracy of the next event type. This paper highlights the utility of LEMs in
various applications, including match prediction and analytics. Moreover, we
show that LEMs provide a simulation backbone for users to build many analytics
pipelines, an approach opposite to the current specialized single-purpose
models. LEMs represent a pivotal advancement in soccer analytics, establishing
a foundational framework for multifaceted analytics pipelines through a
singular machine-learning model. | [
-0.0107828733,
0.0561562292,
0.0016045026,
0.0393757075,
-0.001301554,
0.0017997127,
-0.0167398732,
-0.0168089699,
-0.021955546,
-0.0098870061,
0.0245856531,
-0.0608475618,
-0.004102529,
0.088984549,
0.0227815304,
-0.0419730991,
-0.0300631262,
-0.0616385527,
0.0049320748,
-0.0080912244,
0.0388629958,
0.0199355707,
-0.0126439808,
0.0422249585,
-0.0394879244,
0.0142671261,
-0.0770555064,
-0.0543056279,
-0.0395598076,
-0.0292943511,
-0.0139373597,
0.0089630224,
0.0668205544,
0.0231948067,
0.0000017945,
-0.0363538191,
0.0234553367,
-0.0707523152,
-0.0120515879,
0.0183070228,
0.0148202293,
-0.0331106521,
0.0451922379,
-0.0184280965,
-0.0204713959,
-0.0116360951,
0.0266818032,
0.0000498164,
0.026727384,
0.0405804403,
-0.0267577786,
-0.0575352646,
0.0259263273,
-0.0482457206,
-0.0116118556,
-0.0992098227,
0.0377981588,
-0.016975116,
-0.0676851943,
-0.0040676394,
0.0017791345,
0.0025088931,
0.0237568989,
0.0149899321,
-0.0223319177,
0.0200034305,
-0.0064261332,
-0.0067874808,
0.0086816587,
0.0091673844,
-0.0470412597,
-0.046642933,
0.008813804,
-0.0039533614,
-0.0010648489,
0.0021388463,
-0.0806269273,
0.0029443402,
0.0503753237,
0.0343049914,
0.0134435715,
0.0193175972,
0.0373493358,
0.0563015267,
-0.0231610835,
0.0352017097,
0.0144369528,
0.0066074142,
-0.035399083,
0.0461579636,
0.0239075385,
-0.077449359,
0.0073525649,
0.0271982122,
-0.0722091869,
-0.0174393114,
0.0101889046,
0.0207205284,
-0.0369803756,
-0.0664180964,
0.0538434163,
0.0197753534,
0.0419383273,
0.037835259,
0.0213868264,
-0.0098947892,
-0.0290870778,
-0.0502236299,
-0.0013049996,
0.0009704363,
-0.0372050367,
0.0005388311,
0.0378540531,
-0.0116324564,
-0.0428050309,
0.0093885213,
-0.0349203423,
0.0179761685,
0.0383482203,
-0.028021818,
-0.0070294742,
0.0236862991,
0.0388347656,
-0.0243973248,
-0.0356880724,
0.0463652648,
-0.0668525845,
0.0251595229,
0.0128741991,
-0.0486641526,
0.0157505274,
0.0058472236,
-0.0001833699,
0.0169522334,
0.0175236184,
0.026344886,
-0.0009706821,
0.061447911,
-0.0503444113,
-0.0377920642,
-0.0115039395,
-0.0696398541,
-0.004376499,
-0.1104867533,
0.0436618477,
-0.0358383209,
-0.003648639,
-0.0313065425,
0.0099294139,
-0.00988378,
-0.0247177463,
0.0436045974,
-0.0063534072,
0.0343932584,
0.0067639528,
-0.0271102246,
0.0350929648,
0.0616598129,
0.0411674008,
0.0096742455,
0.0357449949,
0.0141824055,
0.00970052,
0.0693998709,
-0.0075945519,
0.0159035027,
-0.0764881447,
-0.0167234112,
-0.0079690265,
0.0352488756,
0.0024750598,
-0.0209983233,
0.017312048,
-0.0482624322,
0.0787586719,
0.0120066097,
0.0072195912,
-0.0118474867,
0.0837181136,
-0.0163633525,
-0.0313405804,
-0.0080230329,
-0.0078973267,
0.0214298647,
0.0487276949,
0.0023362157,
0.014453995,
0.0092458222,
-0.0623751767,
-0.0607622899,
0.0422629826,
-0.0247696508,
-0.0106858267,
0.0044999393,
0.0742620826,
-0.0671271607,
0.0154916635,
0.0541834533,
0.0156305563,
0.0029798588,
0.0149605628,
-0.0325850174,
0.0180178732,
0.0554060563,
-0.0315129235,
-0.043080464,
-0.0377730913,
-0.0388326384,
0.0238756351,
0.0296977814,
0.0329768658,
-0.0019437647,
0.0363100171,
-0.0415127687,
-0.0075799995,
0.0108028734,
0.0197019745,
0.0342780724,
-0.0413556062,
0.0313425213,
0.0085041476,
0.0396191441,
-0.0441542342,
0.0298202634,
-0.0516313575,
-0.0547891371,
-0.0139129851,
-0.0156065915,
0.0053197811,
0.0177599043,
0.0396605916,
0.0054823477,
0.0295242537,
-0.0311109498,
-0.057525944,
0.0222644284,
-0.0147730056,
-0.000511728,
0.025377214,
0.0093928482,
0.0251515396,
0.025465969,
-0.0366628617,
-0.0322974063,
0.0296441857,
0.0007096106,
0.0568123534,
-0.0072097802,
-0.007140703,
-0.0047043166,
0.0079245577,
0.0243217032,
0.0166890901,
0.0020083946,
0.0008145618,
-0.0310167857,
-0.013946265,
0.0168199204,
-0.0397986546,
-0.0074857869,
0.0369158052,
-0.0040573315,
0.0042362139,
0.0832723454,
0.004353967,
-0.058473859,
0.0120394295,
-0.0820669532,
0.0094831493,
-0.0405613855,
-0.0039888686,
-0.0024505898,
0.0059557422,
-0.0404920131,
-0.013737537,
-0.0387950391,
-0.0442009158,
-0.0078288289,
-0.0092865843,
0.0175568145,
0.0329649597,
-0.0023866771,
-0.0474794097,
-0.0181800406,
-0.0077784192,
0.0914815739,
-0.0121452035,
-0.0077126184,
-0.0508468598,
0.0159458574,
-0.0470365696,
0.0198513381,
-0.0021334265,
0.0138780279,
0.0074049984,
-0.0213043187,
0.0130592212,
0.0127229365,
0.0136239156,
0.0238108784,
0.0136097362,
-0.0831446797,
-0.0280936472,
0.0164611749,
-0.0670588166,
-0.0415176749,
-0.0795009881,
-0.0135167167,
0.0031429883,
0.0513699353,
-0.0242357478,
0.0326642618,
-0.043958243,
0.0324693657,
-0.0189402774,
0.0007182411,
-0.0493233949,
-0.0139497006,
-0.0022233988,
0.0262048338,
0.0205291975,
-0.0355439,
0.0360042118,
-0.0115836766,
0.0228079706,
-0.0283753518,
-0.0708896369,
-0.0130087286,
0.0369936004,
0.0301494282,
0.0194440223,
-0.0283006504,
0.007485372,
-0.0326150097,
-0.0000296102,
-0.0131728565,
-0.0149976462,
-0.0162240155,
0.0227405466,
0.0207839832,
0.0435945988,
-0.0226503573,
-0.0251248088,
-0.031037271,
-0.03230308,
-0.0192747898,
0.0224091858,
0.0177440736,
-0.0716722012,
0.0084594134,
-0.0143360617,
0.0179999527,
-0.0111720376,
-0.0137496376,
0.0496992841,
0.0430214256,
0.0475186668,
0.0214286372,
-0.0346362777,
-0.0776988268,
0.0221994221,
0.0274486337,
0.0410695225,
0.0404992327,
-0.0374820642,
0.0098555889,
-0.0087801227,
0.0098016635,
-0.027840009,
0.0377937481,
0.0221834648,
-0.0821635947,
0.0477018468,
0.129812777,
0.0385216847,
-0.0229489896,
0.0170906689,
0.0172049236,
0.0242303908,
0.0004134409,
0.0172614343,
-0.0589501671,
-0.0159988347,
0.017528357,
-0.0013930689,
-0.0006969797,
-0.0469194986,
-0.0157259982,
-0.0581775121,
0.02054286,
0.0244675186,
-0.0470041968,
-0.0583577603,
-0.0612112507,
0.0037622349,
-0.0467799529,
-0.01386071,
0.002609347,
0.0366013087,
0.008546127,
0.0203268826,
-0.0948309451,
-0.0434522927,
0.0301388148,
-0.0560739189,
0.0456096679,
0.0190899149,
0.0344335251,
-0.0290526059,
0.0243466776,
-0.01025612,
0.0355994217,
0.0100632478,
-0.0000166428,
0.0586039238,
-0.0159937758,
-0.0003868108,
-0.0224316362,
0.0660560131,
-0.0494005866,
-0.0048463908,
0.0381761938,
0.0993833393,
0.0109856343,
-0.0262556262,
0.0068008085,
0.0016073496,
0.039294634,
0.0264055766,
0.0148580549,
-0.066750586,
-0.0240422785,
-0.0109162442,
0.0038664581,
-0.0137673635,
-0.0668932572,
-0.0280006398,
0.0284130163,
-0.0478509851,
0.026106853,
-0.0492797084,
0.0094033722,
-0.016666485,
-0.0315142237,
0.076142922,
-0.0059173736,
-0.050470423,
-0.0420781411,
0.0308284126,
-0.008145906,
0.0237236526,
-0.00399388,
0.0296578202,
0.0599535219,
0.0366343819,
-0.0142913526,
0.0554817207,
-0.0765411034,
-0.0428019613,
-0.0130744502,
0.0118188858,
0.0141872577,
0.025694536,
0.0480540022,
-0.0263096299,
-0.0154902264,
-0.0072535891,
-0.0247954186,
0.0063132634,
-0.012083319,
0.0042829397,
0.001450335,
0.0435364917,
0.0243918952,
0.0629616082,
-0.0312616341,
0.0175763965,
-0.0753103495,
-0.0216928944,
0.0012754649,
-0.0148562388,
0.0788476691,
0.0077079372,
-0.0251498502,
-0.0026429368,
-0.0291555468,
-0.0019386148,
0.0102877161,
-0.0169707127,
0.0131121362,
0.0168021545,
0.038976483,
-0.022549076,
0.0053040474,
-0.0168721043,
-0.0474399701,
-0.0581549965,
0.0512261838,
0.0482654572,
0.0104227765,
0.0338885561,
0.0155300582,
0.0387398452,
0.0222190432,
0.001320009,
0.0153222876,
-0.0060008336,
-0.0426676497,
0.0331723578,
0.0318625048,
0.0173581224,
-0.0367977396,
0.0141546959,
0.016883852,
-0.0260248017,
0.012980558,
0.0818711817,
-0.0456495844,
-0.0092868581,
-0.0028206874,
-0.0046960264,
-0.0181176718,
0.0253048781,
-0.0201105122,
-0.0159577727,
0.0134448297,
0.0122258104,
-0.0645359755,
0.0377632678,
0.046195358,
0.0555073209,
0.0367731638,
0.0188232828,
-0.0436089821,
-0.0341913737,
-0.0041304114,
0.0223427918,
0.0123880766,
-0.0215122309,
0.0119740674,
-0.072304897,
-0.0181876998,
0.0269072205,
-0.0561485626,
0.0091557419,
-0.014243912,
0.0301774014,
0.0774553865,
-0.0317297466,
0.074586302,
-0.0187030286,
0.0510861762,
-0.0143334176,
-0.0525537841,
-0.0257608946,
-5.541410776e-33,
0.0136587815,
-0.0464331023,
0.0382232405,
0.0072642229,
-0.0755673945,
0.0013949042,
-0.0243899375,
-0.0344923772,
-0.0076192701,
0.0138860019,
0.0105538098,
0.0022722553,
0.0033190055,
0.0212436207,
0.0894291997,
-0.0712717846,
0.0386088602,
-0.0805869475,
-0.0119930599,
0.010596415,
0.048210755,
0.0239784233,
0.0056288629,
-0.0663574561,
0.0068435608,
-0.0460364148,
-0.0178064592,
-0.0015722542,
0.0653143078,
0.0275514089,
0.0069597387,
0.0311545059,
0.0476888008,
-0.0868745372,
-0.0183700919,
0.0758038312,
0.0349685363,
-0.0290115811,
-0.0102241542,
0.0058219102,
0.0120840902,
0.0219405945,
0.0490660705,
0.031461563,
0.0019981577,
-0.0291179679,
0.0338516459,
-0.0215877052,
0.0411365852,
-0.0517080911,
-0.027700467,
0.0403234027,
-0.0253477804,
-0.0089507531,
0.0542536639,
0.0194113757,
-0.0081087481,
0.0071593761,
-0.0373346359,
0.0319162384,
-0.0252471901,
0.0365282521,
0.0165155008,
0.0218616351,
-0.0134227965,
0.0305582024,
0.0156894382,
-0.0313646756,
-0.0592909493,
0.0275983494,
0.0278420448,
0.0341652893,
0.0319418125,
-0.0049031009,
0.04375159,
0.0227119066,
-0.108327508,
0.0140242968,
0.0474934876,
0.0345444642,
-0.0040695784,
0.0330357775,
-0.0304138921,
-0.0162537992,
-0.0480666608,
-0.0077619823,
0.0239731427,
-0.0440083519,
-0.0015891417,
-0.0196480043,
0.0093636755,
0.0173503421,
0.0319252014,
0.0123584662,
-0.0243866034,
0.051908955,
-0.0326295458,
0.0549290255,
0.0074021947,
0.046403762,
-0.070329234,
-0.0244676676,
-0.0426957011,
-0.0113301734,
-0.0042041373,
-0.0147359818,
-0.0083672982,
0.066661641,
-0.0438450761,
-0.02540287,
0.0107089505,
-0.0407599434,
0.0325738378,
0.0175895039,
0.0264548883,
-0.0091783926,
0.0083743054,
0.0369485654,
0.0045027202,
-0.0362785943,
0.0619284175,
-0.0035066865,
0.0144533431,
0.0091486285,
-0.0181065779,
-0.0035703112,
-0.029414475,
-0.0033023639,
0.0386942625,
-0.0046737082,
-0.0332927741,
-0.0391519479,
2.394e-7,
0.0372457989,
0.0695390478,
-0.0325642414,
0.0108006038,
0.0199382193,
0.0407721065,
-0.0520674624,
0.0516195111,
-0.0030153312,
0.0190441404,
0.0400665402,
0.0403405204,
0.0599949732,
0.028869193,
-0.0834294185,
-0.0445988886,
-0.059644375,
-0.0261138175,
-0.0434574932,
-0.0218210761,
0.0166802984,
0.1179292426,
0.1229801252,
-0.0038212365,
0.0042969873,
-0.0183246806,
0.05397835,
-0.0172775704,
-0.0495492406,
0.0416414626,
-0.0329118036,
0.0424942635,
-0.0686383247,
0.0187746733,
-0.0524205565,
0.0344083644,
0.0282052197,
0.0045909942,
-0.0091542797,
0.0365625396,
0.0107388711,
-0.0407883041,
-0.0332087651,
0.0096091265,
0.0353941955,
-0.0304250848,
-0.0287622325,
-0.0388854817,
-0.0341903493,
0.0159597434,
0.042542126,
-0.0171113163,
-0.0224058405,
0.0280503314,
-0.0196147617,
0.0026072522,
0.0264025591,
-0.0055035502,
-0.006392506,
0.0400022753,
-0.0522948951,
-0.0071580051,
-0.0221616756,
-0.0048484858,
0.0065641943,
-0.0399461389,
0.0499653034,
1.852920381e-34,
0.0434716195,
0.0308509823,
-0.0555594489,
-0.0347600691,
0.001404773,
-0.0534828976,
-0.0093266116,
0.0646496192,
0.0488080531,
-0.0308475681,
-0.0025664784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10949v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10949v2 | The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Eccentric Automatic Prompts | 2024-02-09T22:48:45 | 2024-02-20T15:03:00 | Rick Battle, Teja Gollapudi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable problem-solving and
basic mathematics abilities. However, their efficacy is highly contingent on
the formulation of the prompt. This study endeavors to quantify the influence
of incorporating "positive thinking" into the system message of the prompt,
then compare that to systematic prompt optimization. We assess the performance
of 60 combinations of system message snippets, tested with and without Chain of
Thought prompting, across three models with parameters ranging from 7 to 70
billion on the GSM8K dataset. Our findings reveal that results do not
universally generalize across models. In most instances, the inclusion of
"positive thinking" prompts positively affected model performance. Notably,
however, Llama2-70B exhibited an exception when not utilizing Chain of Thought,
as the optimal system message was found to be none at all. Given the
combinatorial complexity, and thus computation time, of experimenting with
hand-tuning prompts for large black-box models, we then compared the
performance of the best "positive thinking" prompt against the output of
systematic prompt optimization. We show that employing an automated prompt
optimizer emerges as the most effective method for enhancing performance, even
when working with smaller open-source models. Additionally, our findings reveal
that the highest-scoring, automatically-optimized prompt exhibits a degree of
peculiarity far beyond expectations. | [
0.0361528732,
0.0385041498,
-0.0313419737,
0.0286776721,
-0.0436311811,
0.0014120587,
0.0008846477,
0.0005163997,
-0.0105796233,
-0.0143157039,
0.0013548605,
-0.0341904461,
0.0165599342,
0.0382928401,
0.0421491005,
-0.0280495528,
0.05100739,
-0.0779901445,
0.0432428382,
-0.0185538568,
-0.031572558,
-0.0367188379,
-0.0180439856,
0.0273929685,
0.0105138691,
-0.0113535812,
-0.0160224885,
0.0044944976,
-0.0123530449,
-0.0544685461,
-0.0457697697,
0.0477707312,
-0.0264377668,
0.039896816,
0.0000023935,
-0.0789631903,
0.0340495892,
-0.0244923197,
-0.0758813024,
0.0797647089,
0.0374132581,
0.0272053052,
-0.0150889233,
0.0416643359,
-0.0113508878,
0.0317454934,
0.0197818521,
0.0012880508,
0.054916732,
0.0408788621,
0.0088153286,
0.0365921035,
0.0267439354,
-0.0118788229,
0.027079111,
-0.0488519967,
0.0292104371,
-0.0110388771,
0.0209300555,
0.0186352786,
-0.0260938276,
0.0587841645,
0.0152372522,
-0.0132921217,
-0.0067101493,
0.0180336721,
-0.0310723558,
-0.03267169,
-0.0246917102,
0.0483216941,
0.0218276978,
0.0068603302,
0.0072364379,
-0.0395681076,
0.0184276775,
-0.0275732111,
-0.0369245335,
0.0282825474,
-0.0039884066,
-0.0126976706,
0.0017161417,
-0.0110995704,
0.0191876367,
-0.0112943063,
-0.0202597231,
0.0894351304,
-0.0086463364,
-0.061578583,
0.0346775353,
0.0043853438,
-0.0347086601,
-0.0736649036,
-0.004609881,
0.0263981,
-0.0340720341,
0.009025041,
0.003691636,
-0.009910428,
-0.0007292496,
-0.0357769541,
0.0719417483,
0.092797637,
0.0203654114,
0.0139226923,
-0.0063963518,
0.0394494385,
-0.0169558208,
0.0113189844,
-0.0127177602,
0.0528020635,
-0.0215925816,
-0.0289096795,
-0.026948357,
0.0244872384,
0.0203980282,
-0.0050888737,
-0.0425624363,
0.0451117717,
0.0025182599,
-0.0051411223,
-0.0156699643,
-0.0025251315,
0.0262696669,
-0.0058501414,
-0.0525256433,
-0.0040986449,
-0.0609473586,
0.0020929219,
0.0223844238,
-0.0603370108,
-0.0012413217,
-0.0142677706,
-0.0220641196,
-0.0041918014,
0.0237266384,
0.0723880082,
-0.0047377893,
-0.0144417146,
-0.0181076564,
-0.0166066382,
0.0080346214,
-0.0597185455,
0.0159148108,
-0.0442529693,
-0.0003409475,
0.0358229727,
-0.020615207,
0.0022948794,
0.0092606153,
0.0045534526,
-0.0185432509,
0.0258318782,
-0.0076192822,
0.0434574038,
0.0565881096,
0.003295372,
-0.0299541261,
0.0705085918,
0.0499334894,
0.0122038731,
0.0255100001,
-0.0116692819,
0.0299723484,
0.0626279041,
0.0149919279,
0.0171969105,
-0.0065415702,
-0.000413501,
0.0033266384,
0.0423206501,
-0.0134900985,
0.0542647876,
0.0020566934,
0.0379901081,
0.0555248559,
0.0474380851,
-0.0435865,
0.0134485289,
0.0141126597,
0.0062540229,
0.0401262678,
-0.0197532363,
-0.0818204805,
0.044192683,
-0.0623268522,
0.0232322644,
0.027256744,
0.0218714755,
-0.0211283173,
-0.0348128006,
-0.0274312738,
0.0140057597,
-0.0111127319,
0.0499848314,
0.02735685,
-0.049106475,
-0.060183309,
0.0256558154,
-0.0055142627,
-0.0300204176,
-0.0557052195,
-0.0840479434,
0.0584109388,
0.0508364998,
0.0277775507,
0.0002376678,
-0.010175813,
-0.0120359231,
0.0179380234,
0.0410757698,
0.0484749191,
0.0103387767,
-0.028701663,
-0.0338629074,
-0.0304304175,
0.00219389,
0.0022661844,
0.0079106353,
-0.0068402747,
0.0021657888,
0.0165223461,
0.0543493964,
-0.0115122581,
0.0133862868,
-0.0240176842,
-0.0217889845,
-0.0109410053,
0.0117355464,
0.0119699361,
0.0155738574,
-0.0152988238,
0.0326517709,
-0.000257728,
-0.0141090425,
-0.019025011,
-0.0127550345,
-0.077578418,
0.0119520351,
0.034208443,
0.0040988894,
-0.0001370453,
0.0239170957,
0.0110050039,
-0.0205894075,
0.0252054464,
-0.0532856807,
0.0161691923,
0.0184530392,
0.0669636354,
-0.0497047938,
-0.0145856813,
-0.0314962603,
0.0452852473,
-0.0075148041,
0.0158699919,
0.0513755083,
0.0035713087,
0.0400753357,
-0.0613807961,
-0.0315257236,
-0.0144921569,
-0.006821367,
-0.0032178645,
0.0084710885,
0.0232462436,
-0.0413155742,
-0.0099661248,
-0.0904207528,
-0.0177868865,
0.0006482371,
0.0063257427,
0.0074896049,
-0.0129076019,
-0.0388117805,
0.0081368675,
-0.0177405924,
0.0147991274,
0.0208196547,
0.0452333055,
0.0181507431,
0.0039686575,
-0.057568308,
-0.0451894179,
-0.0244422201,
-0.0422453694,
-0.0015343276,
0.0232463833,
-0.0282962918,
-0.0441748537,
0.0835345164,
-0.038271863,
-0.0082576731,
-0.0123515315,
-0.0413220339,
0.0168170799,
-0.0018946687,
0.0707353726,
0.081672363,
0.0036535291,
-0.0341876447,
0.0274523329,
0.0009645494,
-0.064307563,
0.0111295525,
0.0049746721,
-0.0251311734,
0.011135892,
-0.0668946877,
-0.0176590588,
0.0900837183,
0.016944794,
0.010748826,
-0.0289600603,
0.0537106581,
-0.0326129273,
-0.0438021012,
-0.0733534098,
-0.0259085968,
-0.0299928151,
0.0997160152,
0.0048385202,
-0.0580937825,
0.0826208964,
-0.0021585056,
-0.0331824124,
0.002755427,
0.0191693325,
-0.0197164509,
0.0447561294,
-0.0383973531,
-0.0159046073,
0.0338274501,
-0.0073601166,
-0.0484735481,
-0.0268884022,
0.002271361,
-0.0198860727,
0.0256341007,
-0.0293235462,
-0.0214335173,
-0.0113743888,
-0.0855325013,
-0.0492340699,
-0.0155395167,
-0.0537533015,
-0.0054720682,
0.0517148338,
-0.0027330897,
-0.0105945272,
-0.0362125747,
0.0648168027,
0.0076141953,
-0.0424857102,
-0.0255106278,
-0.0097577963,
-0.0487019792,
0.0338467769,
-0.0007060161,
0.0839814246,
-0.0572070889,
0.0467943884,
-0.0135200433,
0.0375573859,
0.028766105,
0.0331392735,
0.0006525028,
0.0398555137,
0.0131166494,
-0.0560568348,
0.0697390735,
0.0534635074,
-0.0339467265,
-0.0083335368,
0.1020343155,
0.0417269357,
-0.0321659148,
0.022879431,
-0.0767846853,
-0.0008787468,
0.0433481745,
0.0340127647,
-0.0665337741,
-0.0243495833,
0.0520539843,
0.0215915404,
-0.0383697674,
-0.0243385434,
0.0070406324,
-0.1218251362,
0.0075969012,
-0.0081720948,
-0.0122928722,
0.0326808542,
-0.0236375798,
-0.0226171222,
-0.0014458522,
-0.0168758929,
0.0503970571,
-0.0073837577,
0.0081807971,
0.0103357555,
-0.0196793228,
-0.0202840678,
0.0468035266,
0.0022286444,
0.0565114394,
0.058935307,
-0.0199778043,
-0.0140300561,
-0.0764033794,
0.0454588346,
0.0321286023,
0.0134866927,
0.0034016683,
0.0090378625,
0.0199493431,
-0.0163755435,
-0.0499000102,
0.0191566385,
-0.0336636901,
0.0112679917,
0.0454685204,
0.0883021951,
-0.0008243378,
-0.0120310979,
-0.0244730432,
0.0118458662,
0.0216567293,
0.0723502412,
0.0204446521,
-0.0663019791,
-0.0268214606,
-0.042791035,
-0.026882045,
-0.0378161296,
-0.0464707352,
-0.0230067894,
0.0176835079,
0.0230234917,
-0.0380227491,
-0.0390486382,
0.0164625756,
0.0387430117,
0.0295684021,
-0.0344893336,
-0.0069605415,
0.0511235185,
-0.0044573727,
0.0213224515,
-0.0171160139,
0.0540810935,
-0.1083908901,
-0.0016585094,
0.0078901472,
-0.0280270875,
-0.0224876795,
0.0176315419,
-0.0526192784,
-0.0718256459,
0.0127396164,
0.0614749826,
0.0353757069,
-0.0387729928,
0.0267983079,
-0.0583184473,
0.0216267146,
0.0379434563,
-0.0348336548,
0.0411176831,
0.0111823631,
0.0482233912,
0.0055081807,
0.0153614981,
-0.0273246467,
0.0093940552,
0.0224681199,
0.0355496444,
0.0044584358,
-0.0426542126,
-0.0030172465,
0.0780439004,
0.0273248553,
-0.0309690833,
-0.0491418615,
0.0003073244,
0.0290355477,
-0.0245223586,
-0.0109739508,
-0.0297763553,
0.0081721963,
0.0075810319,
-0.0099762622,
0.033600729,
-0.0103307366,
-0.0115662618,
0.0244988874,
0.006475599,
0.0174465701,
-0.0470128432,
0.0476359241,
0.0681775138,
-0.0041157254,
-0.0222715214,
0.036013037,
0.0147487484,
0.0152136469,
-0.0035229721,
0.0940684974,
-0.0030570969,
0.0244539119,
-0.0348414704,
0.0225816332,
-0.0549938791,
-0.116358228,
0.0300353523,
0.0531507395,
0.043151658,
0.0349041708,
-0.0191339944,
-0.0283946227,
-0.0057660919,
-0.0217309054,
0.0028076801,
0.0122633167,
-0.0279083289,
0.0415719189,
0.0209693443,
-0.012976218,
-0.0580571108,
0.0284586754,
-0.0533023849,
0.0486722738,
-0.0197370201,
0.0225784127,
-0.0316552594,
-0.0017978387,
0.0011518059,
0.0156366695,
-0.0132495081,
0.0105162673,
-0.1020063236,
-0.0553351901,
-0.0269717574,
0.0200535618,
0.007612024,
-0.0383425392,
0.0506079383,
0.055841703,
-0.0106692743,
-0.0047475933,
-0.0091369227,
0.0015752275,
-0.0380736589,
-0.0182296056,
-0.0477501415,
-6.640630605e-33,
-0.0029957758,
0.0054521877,
0.0284006279,
0.0209298041,
-0.0083452668,
-0.0293113235,
-0.0442730971,
0.0780392289,
-0.0267338324,
-0.0012020181,
-0.0548306592,
-0.0118326908,
0.0109030828,
-0.0154780718,
0.0367625803,
0.0068094879,
0.0134254098,
-0.0255203266,
-0.0650751144,
-0.0031040048,
0.0351778306,
0.0193149131,
0.0193247702,
-0.0407248996,
0.0311689731,
-0.0121932495,
0.0263792388,
0.0063674771,
-0.0171491634,
0.0263544507,
-0.0332371108,
0.0299208425,
0.0058291708,
-0.0300794095,
-0.0252612885,
0.0098376982,
0.030946631,
-0.0327212624,
0.0461627357,
-0.0103917187,
-0.0163197163,
-0.0562936179,
-0.0000349895,
0.0179418847,
-0.0923270062,
0.0210252479,
0.011237477,
-0.0191094093,
-0.0123523502,
0.0094623538,
-0.0530603491,
-0.0117436806,
-0.0260005239,
-0.0285098013,
-0.0104727941,
0.0185538102,
-0.0342589393,
0.011796603,
0.0181297865,
0.0546590388,
0.0654999316,
0.0182616804,
0.0710327625,
0.0103157163,
0.0105898967,
0.032564953,
0.056861937,
0.0150413401,
-0.0313045271,
-0.0408992842,
0.0461166203,
-0.0057523651,
0.0735756978,
0.0283318646,
0.0218209736,
-0.0396117009,
-0.0490982495,
-0.0148259159,
0.0436658338,
-0.0296092555,
0.0419078805,
0.0038149077,
-0.0526803359,
-0.0449132472,
-0.0349953398,
0.0104502533,
-0.0471900888,
-0.031497851,
0.0354138613,
-0.0141137531,
-0.0140736662,
-0.0366314873,
0.0450328477,
-0.0112779001,
0.0117112603,
0.010134981,
-0.0267723519,
0.046880044,
0.0129784662,
-0.0154726813,
-0.0781798288,
0.0011052774,
-0.0230291281,
0.037181288,
0.0534098074,
0.0186851602,
-0.020357348,
0.0225375816,
-0.0746622458,
0.0041000219,
-0.0470687337,
0.0240497254,
0.0482390411,
-0.0271057226,
0.0076003643,
-0.0294204298,
0.0018518963,
0.0280645601,
-0.0349215865,
-0.0399491414,
-0.0480648987,
0.0238791835,
-0.0068273027,
0.035654828,
-0.0356891192,
-0.022006331,
-0.0345420279,
0.0376663171,
0.0474231653,
-0.0465251878,
-0.0375198312,
-0.0233993344,
3.075e-7,
-0.0076550166,
0.0661110729,
0.0055029802,
0.058576338,
0.0143539924,
0.0670823082,
-0.0505114943,
-0.0255575161,
0.0501927696,
-0.0074379249,
-0.0130082779,
0.0130421268,
0.0265370756,
-0.0020278993,
-0.0564656481,
0.009796598,
-0.0724120364,
0.0222142972,
-0.0514581725,
0.0170961861,
0.0518407524,
0.0475846417,
0.0097520007,
-0.0073026847,
-0.0135833388,
-0.0194210727,
0.046967227,
-0.0606584623,
0.014534439,
0.0253608003,
-0.0002372365,
-0.0191517174,
-0.0010814833,
0.0235919468,
0.0220165532,
-0.0190769583,
-0.0153803416,
0.082906507,
0.0490771793,
-0.0010571629,
0.0119543066,
0.008404593,
-0.0111727864,
-0.0663495436,
0.0541577488,
-0.0531083047,
-0.0402326584,
-0.0160214156,
0.041116599,
-0.0398433022,
0.0399837643,
-0.0372947641,
0.0129690897,
0.0003601987,
-0.0074692057,
-0.0013422737,
0.0110628232,
-0.0424027853,
-0.0101807425,
-0.00864569,
-0.0254877005,
-0.1013995707,
-0.0754057318,
0.0203191414,
0.0211555418,
-0.0493935011,
0.0206976794,
3.013218827e-34,
0.0501039922,
-0.0095060896,
0.0500013642,
0.0232542716,
0.0258765817,
0.0136102242,
0.0070849345,
0.0068893023,
0.0207959805,
-0.0591410697,
-0.0369770862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15393v1 | Detection of Opioid Users from Reddit Posts via an Attention-based Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network | 2024-02-09T22:12:20 | 2024-02-09T22:12:20 | Yuchen Wang, Zhengyu Fang, Wei Du, Shuai Xu, Rong Xu, Jing Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | The opioid epidemic, referring to the growing hospitalizations and deaths
because of overdose of opioid usage and addiction, has become a severe health
problem in the United States. Many strategies have been developed by the
federal and local governments and health communities to combat this crisis.
Among them, improving our understanding of the epidemic through better health
surveillance is one of the top priorities. In addition to direct testing,
machine learning approaches may also allow us to detect opioid users by
analyzing data from social media because many opioid users may choose not to do
the tests but may share their experiences on social media anonymously. In this
paper, we take advantage of recent advances in machine learning, collect and
analyze user posts from a popular social network Reddit with the goal to
identify opioid users. Posts from more than 1,000 users who have posted on
three sub-reddits over a period of one month have been collected. In addition
to the ones that contain keywords such as opioid, opiate, or heroin, we have
also collected posts that contain slang words of opioid such as black or
chocolate. We apply an attention-based bidirectional long short memory model to
identify opioid users. Experimental results show that the approaches
significantly outperform competitive algorithms in terms of F1-score.
Furthermore, the model allows us to extract most informative words, such as
opiate, opioid, and black, from posts via the attention layer, which provides
more insights on how the machine learning algorithm works in distinguishing
drug users from non-drug users. | [
0.0279607847,
0.0757973865,
-0.0119237704,
-0.0100888144,
-0.040574301,
0.0058338628,
0.0033081048,
-0.0063001863,
0.0261875913,
-0.0570136234,
0.0112022245,
-0.0142820124,
-0.0416865759,
0.0533214547,
0.0061716787,
0.0013878337,
0.0346599221,
0.0539995655,
-0.0092020249,
0.0322352983,
0.0229168329,
0.0151699521,
-0.0121936649,
0.0175960399,
0.0111374361,
-0.0438998006,
0.0130084567,
-0.0307505671,
0.0259979386,
-0.0412380025,
0.0593441986,
0.0524370819,
-0.0375852138,
0.048291415,
0.0000017505,
-0.0149185369,
0.0033898265,
-0.0345520861,
-0.0253044125,
-0.0415890887,
0.0429077595,
-0.0321082249,
0.0173232481,
0.0373916514,
-0.0667079687,
-0.0261412654,
0.0876554176,
0.0575184561,
0.0048898356,
0.0456774794,
-0.0221487973,
-0.0299044941,
0.007004519,
-0.0142769339,
0.0262394771,
-0.0018123375,
0.0347583666,
-0.0729575083,
0.0131762214,
-0.0338052325,
0.005002012,
0.0563390814,
-0.0065385601,
0.0094232634,
0.0679701641,
0.0397810116,
0.0067716464,
-0.0310591813,
0.0047729039,
0.0823787674,
-0.0765843168,
-0.0047836341,
0.0127959913,
0.0386050232,
-0.0327360034,
0.000674622,
-0.013953628,
-0.0198519956,
-0.0305428728,
0.0394507684,
-0.0122647611,
0.0069473544,
0.0591588244,
0.0388112962,
-0.0260482188,
-0.014327962,
-0.0075630522,
-0.0157097001,
0.0011475061,
-0.0303133409,
-0.0026649046,
-0.028085215,
0.0810012519,
0.0076892218,
-0.0177340303,
0.0249742325,
-0.0159436837,
-0.0544476733,
0.0582433939,
-0.0959746093,
0.0190660767,
-0.0199497975,
-0.0213415548,
0.040445637,
-0.01518845,
-0.0277326312,
0.0205520894,
0.0098878937,
-0.0065949792,
0.0062120119,
-0.0343056023,
0.0157102849,
-0.0082111508,
0.0310440827,
0.0363361686,
-0.0120128486,
-0.0495252237,
0.0107992394,
-0.0406819247,
-0.0473709889,
-0.0499606468,
0.0364974625,
-0.0110236267,
0.0448953286,
0.0446381606,
0.0303665642,
0.0108245257,
0.0150845759,
-0.0083692688,
0.0349491276,
0.0012568776,
0.0125188855,
0.0718253478,
-0.0227780361,
-0.0276252329,
0.0364839993,
0.0369651318,
-0.0266555063,
-0.0320571028,
-0.0298880134,
-0.0022880805,
0.0256338622,
0.0031236177,
-0.0396866873,
0.0351009369,
-0.020335244,
-0.0203183908,
-0.0274527092,
-0.0045777429,
-0.0009622683,
-0.0488162488,
0.0721830204,
0.0082400069,
0.0235670637,
0.0319851115,
0.0008823514,
0.0581613593,
0.0075467229,
0.0071945512,
0.0804779604,
0.0353382453,
-0.0643000528,
0.021196438,
0.0014904072,
0.0269082934,
-0.0551440902,
0.0321439169,
-0.0150520355,
0.013946618,
-0.0078256661,
-0.0406523943,
0.0416526608,
0.029452648,
-0.0171598848,
0.0389926471,
0.0497626737,
0.0294845924,
0.0038469196,
0.0358117819,
0.0198504962,
-0.0749133453,
-0.0279375277,
-0.0609102845,
-0.0112699727,
-0.0100648012,
-0.0334473476,
0.0289865006,
-0.0101210009,
-0.008706036,
0.0050843791,
-0.0251529142,
-0.0495571233,
-0.0018238567,
-0.0049353819,
0.0254667681,
-0.0016084451,
-0.0416387767,
0.0273238942,
0.0174850784,
-0.0199017636,
-0.0265214834,
-0.0497687832,
0.0427846499,
0.0298643373,
-0.0033355383,
-0.0117743937,
-0.0058128666,
-0.0448495038,
0.0385042988,
0.0214615315,
0.0021739895,
-0.0038119466,
-0.0201236568,
0.0057412465,
-0.003671655,
0.0462272987,
-0.0109647987,
-0.0308523532,
0.0060554952,
0.0319235548,
0.0266025644,
0.0368676633,
-0.0279307794,
0.0308332369,
0.0281611197,
-0.0444848835,
0.0217571538,
0.0465234555,
0.0779815838,
-0.0035330364,
0.0327679217,
0.011443371,
0.0406185798,
-0.0456728376,
-0.0452317148,
-0.0739962161,
0.0268064719,
0.0191287138,
0.0298720766,
-0.055807516,
0.0450882688,
0.0580769554,
-0.0394870117,
-0.0197088365,
0.0785224065,
-0.0653654113,
0.0389231592,
-0.008781909,
-0.0175783802,
-0.0001203159,
0.0556176975,
0.0089917416,
0.0278327838,
-0.0364510752,
0.009387224,
-0.05756725,
-0.0790491179,
-0.0564902239,
-0.0104668271,
0.0107391579,
-0.0477354974,
-0.0511536561,
0.0123280119,
0.0187937561,
0.0055037416,
-0.0060043531,
-0.013608438,
-0.0431831218,
0.0053723799,
-0.0371729955,
0.0125071164,
0.0078795841,
0.0135042826,
0.0178431198,
-0.0272731204,
-0.0083748884,
-0.0263891462,
-0.0129189948,
0.0055609872,
-0.0093336413,
0.0076919142,
0.0194012206,
-0.0019457514,
-0.0354100764,
-0.0424768366,
0.0277596954,
0.0020978649,
-0.0746293291,
0.0239121541,
-0.0022744846,
-0.044009041,
0.0028792347,
0.0043832213,
-0.0490623824,
0.0019573085,
0.0154228546,
0.0194099732,
0.0528519489,
0.0552804098,
0.0183629096,
0.0128450505,
0.0386403203,
-0.0034513699,
0.0120276492,
-0.0641137436,
-0.0292557962,
0.0372261517,
-0.0659711882,
0.0087395059,
0.0648989901,
0.0377333835,
-0.0055493866,
0.0142471977,
0.0080159176,
-0.0093530761,
-0.0178280864,
-0.0229788944,
0.0069151763,
-0.0129065737,
-0.0390972383,
-0.0384708531,
-0.0542636923,
0.0478182882,
0.0500286482,
0.0351736732,
-0.0144144269,
-0.0341892019,
-0.0368326791,
-0.0449600816,
0.0627830103,
0.0249797907,
-0.0136256292,
0.0078287134,
0.0977660716,
-0.0109473849,
-0.0339252315,
-0.0641420186,
0.0242006164,
0.0341068991,
0.012091374,
-0.0070123081,
-0.0397539064,
-0.045439139,
-0.0852817297,
-0.0097122695,
-0.0362953097,
0.0050484678,
-0.0276756138,
-0.0181226935,
0.0571725368,
-0.0162283592,
0.0106410664,
-0.0031029915,
-0.0043966067,
0.0143890968,
0.0189190097,
0.0584187657,
-0.057791356,
0.0184803586,
0.0248114727,
0.0259201843,
0.0432817116,
-0.0122660883,
0.0066352962,
-0.0273943059,
-0.010758644,
-0.0017844841,
-0.0286191832,
-0.0159435272,
0.0144680543,
-0.0286347866,
-0.0136925904,
0.0266205762,
0.056724444,
0.0125747668,
-0.0545283891,
0.0255148504,
-0.0038856948,
-0.0574133843,
0.0080846576,
-0.0026533934,
-0.0690747947,
-0.0354801118,
-0.0567431673,
0.0280856267,
-0.0524540208,
-0.0329496972,
-0.0131515879,
-0.0535281673,
0.0251205955,
-0.0045855725,
-0.083252728,
-0.0204804167,
-0.0489823967,
-0.0130632035,
-0.0055953101,
0.0085771056,
0.0125853121,
-0.0516532138,
-0.0352160595,
0.0257201977,
-0.0555981249,
-0.0182895008,
0.0120803108,
-0.0407030806,
0.0133675644,
0.0228754338,
0.0412882045,
-0.0210173372,
-0.0209639389,
0.0011614666,
0.0076984805,
-0.0114973336,
-0.0026038117,
0.0784624442,
-0.0496262088,
0.0140272295,
-0.0783146992,
0.0536378808,
-0.0870952979,
-0.0107429726,
-0.0104144309,
0.1167566925,
-0.0397120528,
-0.0711017847,
-0.0312056597,
0.0277507175,
0.0412336923,
0.050286226,
0.0606170706,
-0.0086463103,
-0.020972969,
-0.0100853136,
-0.0050909985,
-0.0710714385,
-0.0272596832,
-0.0320236757,
0.0082144933,
-0.0320820548,
-0.0210916381,
-0.051011119,
-0.0016004561,
-0.0565141253,
0.0023585702,
-0.0069090258,
0.0011398487,
-0.050391715,
-0.046903424,
0.0372211784,
0.022130454,
0.0302934758,
-0.0531226918,
-0.0183118917,
0.0278048702,
-0.0029346149,
0.0260949265,
0.0556250736,
-0.0586370565,
0.0013747553,
0.0641407743,
-0.0047991783,
0.0090730945,
0.0002877227,
-0.0645151213,
-0.0380169153,
0.0151270414,
0.0258360356,
0.0138408318,
-0.0548349619,
0.0353525765,
0.0161430407,
0.0017248075,
0.0305008013,
0.016620433,
0.0100651039,
0.0200790465,
-0.0610662699,
-0.0816240311,
0.0031197832,
-0.0248850342,
-0.0017408374,
0.0646999627,
0.0122987647,
0.0159229282,
-0.0233575366,
-0.0117661012,
0.0443970002,
-0.0026872258,
0.0395953357,
-0.023555005,
0.0407024585,
-0.0353217423,
-0.0456754975,
0.0343478136,
-0.040807575,
-0.0449291021,
-0.0535796545,
0.0257165916,
0.0162971597,
-0.00945538,
0.0209946502,
0.0180404242,
-0.0186149478,
0.0236367043,
0.0221608095,
0.0692857504,
-0.0150625501,
0.036409229,
-0.0407700762,
0.0153326467,
-0.012110576,
0.0649625063,
-0.0308592711,
-0.0173122827,
0.0027663009,
0.0070973067,
0.0589051507,
-0.0548802949,
0.0290602557,
0.0018938427,
0.0062062507,
-0.04047231,
0.0804390088,
-0.023778066,
-0.0302281436,
0.0023631647,
0.0112549448,
-0.0378658809,
0.0270087942,
0.0660335869,
-0.0302571543,
-0.0190289412,
0.0363392681,
-0.0435977429,
0.000800353,
0.0261018239,
-0.0027896743,
0.0199233796,
-0.0396837816,
0.0364741683,
-0.0175450072,
-0.0689518824,
0.0268253833,
-0.0493899547,
0.0210973453,
0.0134207997,
0.0095265778,
0.0252589844,
0.0280380901,
-0.0232527461,
-0.0540426672,
0.0535378456,
-0.0188874137,
-0.0293412898,
-0.0390753895,
-5.568155477e-33,
0.0397058725,
-0.0596540198,
-0.0485596731,
-0.0300240312,
0.006810159,
0.0375958942,
-0.0333601609,
-0.0108379414,
-0.0153608713,
-0.0093585858,
-0.0096418522,
0.0141195757,
0.0001103205,
0.03184136,
0.0154645545,
-0.0305178054,
0.0280988999,
0.0326762423,
0.0129853282,
0.0321172923,
0.0566213503,
0.0738966689,
0.0334715955,
-0.0354278386,
0.0336109996,
-0.0052828523,
0.0419628806,
0.0348371305,
0.0009132708,
0.0455119535,
-0.045028571,
0.0660011992,
0.0457198843,
-0.0011763687,
0.0040874486,
0.0580139309,
-0.0678196177,
-0.0085075554,
-0.0108630871,
-0.0381389074,
-0.0701773465,
-0.0569791496,
0.0908548981,
0.0154745281,
0.0228037462,
0.0022680212,
0.0602270141,
0.0118974941,
-0.005742358,
0.0039815684,
-0.0081731863,
0.0055970633,
-0.0376169719,
-0.0254710205,
-0.03202454,
0.0500002243,
0.0053801974,
0.0362012871,
-0.0915993378,
0.0015127559,
-0.0212060194,
0.00268738,
0.0434922688,
0.0233628731,
-0.0095730172,
0.0275536869,
0.0102232276,
-0.0184044559,
-0.0246433839,
0.0227032322,
-0.0388692878,
0.0495410338,
0.071082525,
-0.0026734399,
0.050406117,
-0.0197678972,
-0.0627666116,
-0.0120996879,
-0.014057952,
0.0471809953,
0.0428254157,
-0.0268077739,
-0.0524332821,
0.0047369981,
0.0179353319,
-0.037527848,
-0.0224268325,
-0.0121310446,
-0.0250266325,
-0.0284803323,
-0.015008972,
0.017291734,
0.0116849244,
-0.0395351797,
-0.0116715264,
0.0006172657,
0.0435291044,
0.0051643159,
0.0041451994,
0.0055463305,
-0.0589305349,
0.0852838531,
-0.0188149065,
-0.0268904883,
0.0146782454,
0.0096315993,
0.0545173697,
-0.0128772091,
0.0067032999,
-0.0331824571,
0.0140742036,
0.0211291742,
0.007145273,
0.077301085,
0.0279331543,
0.050387755,
0.0192155261,
0.0501244403,
0.0254128966,
0.0073169922,
-0.013358118,
-0.0653812364,
-0.016645411,
-0.0080104871,
-0.0298104901,
-0.0015180971,
-0.0370059945,
0.0856814981,
0.0273682717,
-0.0909445807,
0.0216291156,
-0.0174703486,
2.592e-7,
0.0693431571,
0.0208386909,
-0.0052276943,
0.0159382783,
0.0081913406,
0.0105915638,
0.033729095,
0.054723978,
-0.0056288349,
-0.0099964105,
0.0073504183,
0.0642068461,
0.028451357,
0.0520931184,
-0.0319235213,
-0.0294365045,
-0.0712655708,
0.0161235109,
-0.0616237484,
-0.0156454239,
0.0163010452,
0.1022326946,
0.0611953065,
-0.0347314253,
0.0168570075,
-0.0447299778,
0.0051022335,
-0.0223737136,
-0.0060680234,
-0.0002333842,
0.0378173292,
-0.0064883581,
-0.00785519,
0.0195251089,
-0.0503350534,
-0.0137158278,
-0.0172346141,
0.0275385063,
-0.0623971224,
-0.0551844202,
-0.0333816707,
-0.0554923415,
0.0252637081,
-0.0063483464,
0.1213462651,
-0.0233195201,
-0.0274343882,
-0.0466426946,
0.0335266478,
-0.003188198,
0.0578687415,
-0.0319248065,
-0.0512453541,
0.03396843,
0.0099317953,
-0.005760645,
0.0046585933,
-0.0743959546,
-0.0164063256,
0.0266810171,
-0.0306739341,
0.0011050139,
0.0241873879,
0.0071769585,
0.0343968496,
-0.0355393812,
-0.0035500582,
1.775663769e-34,
-0.0082767894,
0.0264021475,
0.0110242805,
0.0084285345,
0.0286763925,
-0.0093826996,
-0.0254722871,
-0.0454546027,
0.0274143871,
-0.0563510656,
-0.0000907447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06782v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06782v3 | Debating with More Persuasive LLMs Leads to More Truthful Answers | 2024-02-09T21:05:01 | 2024-05-30T13:59:34 | Akbir Khan, John Hughes, Dan Valentine, Laura Ruis, Kshitij Sachan, Ansh Radhakrishnan, Edward Grefenstette, Samuel R. Bowman, Tim Rocktäschel, Ethan Perez | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Common methods for aligning large language models (LLMs) with desired
behaviour heavily rely on human-labelled data. However, as models grow
increasingly sophisticated, they will surpass human expertise, and the role of
human evaluation will evolve into non-experts overseeing experts. In
anticipation of this, we ask: can weaker models assess the correctness of
stronger models? We investigate this question in an analogous setting, where
stronger models (experts) possess the necessary information to answer questions
and weaker models (non-experts) lack this information. The method we evaluate
is debate, where two LLM experts each argue for a different answer, and a
non-expert selects the answer. We find that debate consistently helps both
non-expert models and humans answer questions, achieving 76% and 88% accuracy
respectively (naive baselines obtain 48% and 60%). Furthermore, optimising
expert debaters for persuasiveness in an unsupervised manner improves
non-expert ability to identify the truth in debates. Our results provide
encouraging empirical evidence for the viability of aligning models with debate
in the absence of ground truth. | [
0.0743564293,
0.1022067815,
-0.0161640178,
0.0347082391,
-0.0575525612,
-0.0103557948,
0.010507484,
-0.0143657643,
-0.015881585,
-0.0335497893,
-0.0216405466,
-0.0209051538,
0.0060828235,
-0.010065712,
0.0358961746,
-0.0358971618,
0.0223291721,
-0.0420630351,
0.0864238515,
-0.0345804356,
0.0451358296,
-0.0092483768,
0.000886768,
0.0253104847,
0.0039726454,
0.0047729271,
-0.0078793112,
-0.0095075648,
-0.0010435244,
0.0056060278,
0.0230777506,
0.0885316655,
0.04131433,
0.0304630511,
0.0000015733,
-0.0390087925,
0.0283656828,
-0.0204246808,
-0.0662750527,
0.0216535982,
0.0240773857,
0.0152328126,
0.0182045735,
0.0144190053,
-0.0562582314,
0.0378560424,
0.0280748941,
0.036978811,
0.0480410345,
0.0526124462,
0.0267658792,
-0.0123663768,
0.0189923961,
-0.013735923,
-0.0121855782,
-0.0454044305,
0.0105001573,
0.0387777425,
-0.0428025648,
0.0375428423,
0.0079304939,
0.0311068129,
-0.0032397942,
-0.0333784223,
0.0058040046,
0.0097438022,
-0.0309278127,
-0.0321006402,
-0.0047169849,
0.0555151813,
0.0270243455,
-0.0650795773,
0.0085147498,
-0.0100248316,
0.0188697502,
0.0407131948,
-0.0420395546,
0.0145201162,
0.0085291844,
0.0153395729,
0.026592169,
0.0093541397,
0.0263547488,
0.0306745488,
0.0274239667,
0.0831221268,
-0.023714181,
-0.0379962474,
0.0154528171,
0.0205442086,
0.0159800183,
-0.0811182857,
-0.0392760113,
0.0115340156,
-0.045509547,
0.0539374165,
-0.0018876939,
0.0194815472,
0.0329644904,
-0.0553038679,
0.0182713345,
0.0102435648,
0.0174188353,
0.0576144792,
0.0148154916,
0.006733323,
-0.0342458673,
0.0388687886,
-0.0016149236,
-0.0310089421,
-0.0319277793,
-0.0330509953,
-0.0092435749,
-0.0017220896,
-0.0081098899,
0.0083669713,
0.0015262278,
-0.0212406982,
-0.0400657281,
0.0109853977,
-0.0091806035,
0.0330222584,
-0.0063277516,
-0.0287777707,
-0.0709569529,
0.0444527641,
-0.0436791256,
0.0396845117,
0.0351437926,
-0.0590018444,
0.0027258974,
0.0370622799,
-0.0132899787,
-0.0041187275,
0.0189563613,
0.0461686552,
-0.0315741636,
0.0267500225,
-0.0110418266,
-0.0224443898,
-0.0273313094,
-0.0756383985,
-0.0101652555,
-0.0688087791,
0.0508989282,
0.0097441953,
-0.0253134742,
-0.046609167,
0.0085178996,
-0.002607699,
-0.0307845362,
0.0668281689,
-0.0158352032,
0.0455411375,
0.0754757077,
0.015485785,
-0.0431491658,
0.0584140122,
0.0435683839,
-0.0198283792,
0.0361073464,
-0.0080423187,
0.0206072945,
0.025340395,
0.0272647198,
0.0089817159,
0.0230788775,
0.0379038416,
-0.048046343,
0.0473473072,
0.0163040087,
0.0740160346,
-0.0369344801,
-0.0500937998,
0.0866877213,
0.0569522381,
-0.0158954822,
0.0150791099,
-0.0205314476,
0.0214750413,
0.0274451356,
0.0339758322,
-0.0179364141,
0.0288334973,
-0.0397178568,
-0.0047861049,
0.0308670942,
-0.0128515428,
-0.0245843828,
-0.0483392365,
-0.0229411032,
0.0082716933,
0.0220719036,
0.0469832197,
0.0064302944,
-0.0253857002,
-0.0059579983,
0.0476370715,
0.012760534,
-0.0389090814,
-0.0235532559,
-0.053191673,
0.0339705795,
-0.0012138514,
0.0224458557,
0.0123985521,
-0.0196958557,
-0.0136153921,
0.0419287533,
0.0819559172,
0.08594805,
-0.0192776266,
-0.0267703217,
-0.0393804759,
-0.0286362693,
-0.0270531271,
0.008742162,
0.0041390406,
0.0288963225,
-0.0261312556,
0.010410632,
-0.0300524049,
-0.0483453423,
0.0211367588,
-0.0305599589,
0.0163283069,
-0.0478821099,
-0.0033446199,
0.0263962168,
-0.007105845,
-0.0217127725,
0.0277100224,
0.0192641895,
0.0036984871,
-0.0106070032,
0.0038024229,
-0.041653119,
0.021528434,
0.0517325439,
-0.0349309742,
-0.0364331044,
0.0124817975,
-0.0131769497,
-0.0137402648,
0.0148896193,
-0.0598662198,
0.0169562269,
-0.0203687698,
0.0112598455,
-0.0303303208,
-0.0532438159,
-0.0507441908,
0.0573553145,
0.0232669115,
0.0061868271,
0.0361637361,
-0.011272843,
0.0176992305,
-0.0500175655,
-0.0083382158,
0.0090321479,
0.0440084785,
0.0235338993,
0.0862255171,
-0.041461885,
-0.0592524223,
-0.0332847126,
-0.1035912111,
-0.0346024893,
-0.006908807,
0.0134787662,
0.0211579259,
-0.0647216514,
0.0209718831,
0.0251206439,
-0.0938017666,
-0.0233329553,
0.0332767293,
0.0210389681,
0.0606818832,
-0.0152229154,
-0.0026591062,
-0.0626907349,
0.0169279762,
-0.0185752772,
0.0100678559,
0.040720813,
-0.0104524083,
-0.0442847311,
-0.000279357,
-0.0724554211,
0.0283464752,
-0.0196710676,
-0.0218527745,
0.0522488989,
0.0570202991,
0.0130733065,
0.0818768963,
0.0424362347,
0.0153893176,
0.0475741364,
0.0228380617,
-0.0884557962,
-0.0126669733,
-0.0103478804,
-0.0157171898,
-0.0650610924,
-0.0414384156,
0.0221073162,
0.0635249838,
0.0234069563,
0.016024638,
-0.0323705003,
0.0611812323,
0.0165639725,
-0.0396543369,
-0.025562156,
-0.051084172,
-0.0245685391,
0.0990140066,
-0.0415328965,
-0.0585312694,
0.090023689,
-0.0335347988,
0.0031083759,
-0.0102560623,
-0.0193555113,
-0.0389178954,
0.0252264123,
-0.0180033054,
0.0182539206,
-0.0206216667,
-0.0007769262,
-0.0833166987,
-0.0474958494,
0.0719649941,
-0.0645128414,
0.0483713448,
-0.0670801997,
0.016366791,
0.0219680518,
-0.0523852929,
-0.0403611846,
-0.0543681122,
-0.0615872219,
0.009088615,
0.0415060073,
-0.0108473273,
-0.032952223,
-0.0158525985,
0.0415503085,
0.0072579142,
0.0181457847,
-0.0067974674,
-0.0000838402,
0.0157416929,
0.0408840105,
0.0468651205,
0.0211279579,
-0.0446856841,
0.0314412192,
0.0672355816,
-0.0140526965,
-0.0151155125,
-0.0313638113,
-0.0327453278,
0.0266162828,
-0.0087873638,
-0.0015053534,
0.0154199433,
0.0391143747,
-0.0308135375,
0.024011001,
0.0907947272,
0.031317357,
0.0106984871,
-0.0106444312,
-0.0496341921,
0.0356633253,
0.0088862479,
0.0089087347,
-0.0527740754,
-0.0218768064,
-0.0114992373,
0.0069957753,
-0.038731467,
-0.0058934544,
-0.0150644211,
-0.1110516489,
0.0138707832,
0.0226023737,
0.0223486647,
0.0091676759,
-0.0225625802,
0.009912963,
-0.011881222,
0.01580498,
0.0115641896,
0.032885246,
-0.0031322248,
0.0267050918,
-0.0276703872,
-0.0138591975,
0.0192165766,
-0.0292058904,
0.076221399,
0.0424918719,
0.0435159914,
-0.0168671384,
-0.0776879713,
0.0359621607,
0.0375088938,
-0.0059826341,
0.0130856242,
0.0315827504,
-0.0209962297,
0.0098035587,
-0.0532405116,
0.0194002837,
0.0250210818,
-0.0228596702,
0.0094979955,
0.0365110934,
-0.0051679309,
-0.026586188,
-0.0090830633,
0.0269197673,
-0.0190639198,
0.0977199301,
0.0381279439,
-0.0274797101,
-0.0246170163,
-0.0380278714,
-0.0231839344,
0.0065841465,
-0.0845794976,
-0.0037407742,
0.0464581661,
0.0364231244,
-0.0552347787,
-0.0219805557,
0.0037474209,
-0.0019670813,
-0.0082619349,
0.0094581665,
0.0159671027,
-0.0077204593,
0.0109960791,
0.0098485351,
-0.052740857,
0.0073387646,
-0.0657556653,
-0.0290989093,
0.0170068778,
-0.0043661138,
-0.0182489473,
0.0050863074,
-0.0467807427,
-0.1139739081,
-0.03074014,
0.0295590218,
0.0364290737,
0.0291728955,
0.0305794198,
-0.0439920388,
0.010344414,
0.0089382129,
-0.0107801761,
0.0118607944,
0.0194924604,
-0.0029865804,
-0.0023568664,
0.026563473,
-0.008239734,
0.0057586627,
0.0325367823,
0.0229382515,
-0.0710104629,
-0.0655758083,
0.0468806587,
0.0280852523,
0.048009906,
0.0082486402,
-0.0156272948,
-0.008270748,
-0.0145400604,
0.0021074205,
-0.038632825,
-0.0013633224,
-0.0239717178,
-0.0030940766,
-0.0158686433,
0.0281768981,
-0.0024424691,
-0.0305849258,
0.035348963,
-0.0111554004,
0.0068994663,
-0.0209373161,
-0.0054399068,
-0.0278653614,
-0.0066101141,
-0.0193992238,
0.0475639179,
-0.0146438768,
0.0683587939,
0.0372258984,
0.0469362214,
0.014389867,
-0.0068812533,
0.0353521295,
-0.0077235857,
-0.0875224322,
-0.0998748094,
0.0012764966,
0.0121679185,
0.0164343715,
0.0082535688,
0.0354172029,
-0.0300240722,
-0.0062311525,
-0.0100226402,
-0.002618467,
0.0107232602,
-0.0014319528,
0.0531098805,
0.0198158827,
-0.0530077852,
-0.000111915,
0.0655888245,
0.0231497921,
0.0157036632,
-0.0261760931,
-0.012715729,
-0.0222340673,
-0.0474343635,
0.0106555624,
-0.0020125387,
-0.0050354963,
0.008990054,
-0.0420889519,
-0.0248870216,
-0.0373016112,
0.0443254635,
0.0003599412,
-0.0368748754,
0.0255165659,
0.0598454326,
-0.0297280177,
-0.0088526318,
-0.0435896367,
0.0341663249,
0.0145881129,
0.022461297,
-0.0529059805,
-5.767753683e-33,
-0.0134509373,
-0.0528092235,
0.0055694166,
-0.0239453316,
0.0163219627,
-0.0194157232,
-0.0124846967,
0.0493805446,
-0.0657887459,
0.0354760624,
0.0109593589,
0.0212802459,
0.0127985841,
-0.0275263637,
0.0161242336,
-0.0403095596,
0.0182550438,
-0.0101513248,
-0.0482077524,
-0.0074055684,
-0.0024202415,
-0.0451137237,
0.0271495897,
-0.0707878843,
0.0683172047,
-0.0176390074,
-0.0060616699,
0.0405948013,
-0.0481213368,
0.0508559272,
0.0220657866,
0.0380529352,
0.0132355411,
-0.0453512222,
-0.0038181683,
0.0250673816,
-0.0038567991,
-0.0140190292,
0.0943157747,
-0.0364365578,
-0.0521944724,
-0.0085622063,
0.0332003385,
-0.0116601158,
-0.0471998788,
0.0070142779,
0.012917297,
-0.0118744308,
0.0232455805,
0.0034474737,
-0.0387057476,
0.0150267556,
-0.0198343992,
-0.0091016032,
-0.0095765647,
0.0362212844,
-0.0088708699,
0.0175964832,
-0.0641487837,
0.0436236598,
0.0411109105,
0.0191013403,
0.0789747313,
-0.007920132,
-0.0046237539,
0.0750304833,
0.0207084082,
0.0160405971,
-0.0394494422,
-0.038268771,
-0.0061445129,
0.0656680316,
0.0899856389,
0.0579346567,
0.0169123486,
0.004054632,
-0.0453329869,
-0.0033936379,
0.0283403583,
0.0232042018,
0.0136402966,
0.0238160677,
-0.0357245915,
-0.0420706198,
-0.0646162778,
-0.0160629656,
-0.0357280858,
-0.0312394183,
0.0074642748,
0.0084237522,
-0.0121428343,
-0.0151816076,
0.0071539138,
-0.0404395871,
-0.0211987067,
0.0057321247,
0.0011757818,
0.0122844297,
-0.0014903608,
0.0108785927,
-0.0695068836,
0.0005175899,
-0.0220249686,
0.036245361,
0.0423076004,
0.0078800414,
0.0002414726,
-0.0361206457,
-0.0532011762,
0.0106054554,
-0.0368049517,
0.0063130818,
-0.013164496,
-0.0366161019,
0.0314435437,
-0.0012472853,
-0.0174115039,
0.0278224647,
-0.0211318731,
-0.02134002,
-0.0416006409,
-0.0088881794,
-0.028713109,
0.0148448162,
-0.0238959994,
0.0035230271,
-0.0136711309,
0.0050238715,
0.0017901957,
0.007877728,
-0.0117334342,
-0.0147017753,
2.279e-7,
0.0196152739,
0.050578557,
0.0226676501,
0.0192991886,
0.0105898129,
0.0535192862,
-0.0353435948,
0.0048691737,
0.0239107348,
-0.1115463153,
-0.0041044708,
0.0160856154,
0.0674553961,
0.0369350873,
-0.036443729,
-0.0406845361,
-0.1079573408,
-0.0048983507,
-0.0183369163,
0.0072732577,
0.051419232,
0.0417978875,
0.0103677204,
0.0214280915,
-0.0337399095,
-0.0240531974,
0.0891697407,
-0.0465144403,
-0.0049844058,
0.0330642313,
0.0596762598,
-0.0266718306,
0.0114046782,
0.0453882031,
0.0138661154,
0.0141308373,
-0.0313359238,
0.0814135894,
-0.0080795214,
-0.0243539643,
-0.0454023816,
-0.0045200936,
0.0048460602,
-0.0453858525,
0.0459235087,
-0.0502465777,
-0.0367785916,
-0.04137557,
0.0037100548,
-0.0233189519,
0.0158057436,
-0.014020456,
-0.0369535908,
0.0039123236,
0.0310703684,
0.0158156399,
0.0142616797,
-0.0458998345,
-0.0617783479,
0.0084251342,
-0.0577673651,
-0.0777772516,
-0.003580201,
0.011853925,
0.00909435,
-0.0393812284,
0.0114968764,
1.644821031e-34,
0.0464629047,
0.0196314398,
0.0330764875,
0.0294574443,
0.0483807251,
0.0354041494,
-0.0052422374,
-0.0149759771,
0.0498132557,
-0.0591132678,
0.0046152705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06766v1 | Evaluation Metrics for Text Data Augmentation in NLP | 2024-02-09T19:59:34 | 2024-02-09T19:59:34 | Marcellus Amadeus, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent surveys on data augmentation for natural language processing have
reported different techniques and advancements in the field. Several
frameworks, tools, and repositories promote the implementation of text data
augmentation pipelines. However, a lack of evaluation criteria and standards
for method comparison due to different tasks, metrics, datasets, architectures,
and experimental settings makes comparisons meaningless. Also, a lack of
methods unification exists and text data augmentation research would benefit
from unified metrics to compare different augmentation methods. Thus, academics
and the industry endeavor relevant evaluation metrics for text data
augmentation techniques. The contribution of this work is to provide a taxonomy
of evaluation metrics for text augmentation methods and serve as a direction
for a unified benchmark. The proposed taxonomy organizes categories that
include tools for implementation and metrics calculation. Finally, with this
study, we intend to present opportunities to explore the unification and
standardization of text data augmentation metrics. | [
0.035761863,
0.0474261455,
0.007178118,
0.015847316,
-0.0322067738,
-0.0190238543,
-0.0124677625,
0.0282241832,
-0.0092861922,
-0.0284869876,
-0.0178760178,
0.0028620502,
0.0321095772,
0.0306045432,
0.044758752,
-0.0687054396,
0.0386811458,
0.0291361306,
-0.0033045027,
0.0486618876,
0.0380908139,
0.0051974482,
0.0017838656,
0.0292899236,
-0.0110518895,
0.0104104932,
0.0167929363,
0.0301899686,
0.0643155426,
-0.030246269,
-0.0181049034,
0.0245586969,
0.0007060845,
0.0677361712,
0.0000017594,
-0.054852888,
-0.0053636059,
0.0459062979,
-0.007123813,
0.031600818,
0.0915651917,
-0.0912836939,
-0.0077344212,
0.0068115294,
-0.0238941796,
-0.0187748652,
0.0776808709,
0.055044625,
0.0460700244,
0.0881621093,
-0.0190651063,
-0.0129983956,
0.0657764152,
-0.0370173864,
0.0088286102,
0.0167974364,
0.0401761942,
0.0168519728,
-0.0091359979,
0.0558048524,
-0.0019464575,
0.0405400209,
0.016120201,
-0.0135560064,
0.0832696185,
0.0170180146,
-0.038145449,
0.0246019959,
-0.0115746027,
0.0440821126,
0.0115890186,
0.0022058412,
-0.0395486951,
-0.0180261042,
0.0017786758,
-0.0443514287,
-0.0435620137,
-0.0410069525,
0.0557240099,
0.0289685167,
-0.0464273766,
0.0194539372,
0.0469595045,
0.0343903527,
0.0097384779,
0.0730244368,
0.0130626233,
-0.0546148866,
-0.0127079785,
0.0279857852,
0.0034524226,
-0.0501647592,
0.0477881953,
0.0108412672,
0.0208407883,
0.0118108243,
-0.0379219055,
-0.0993526727,
0.039611429,
-0.015422388,
0.0119407512,
0.0083194822,
-0.0316577926,
0.0243062135,
-0.0648071617,
0.0113685019,
-0.0074210414,
-0.0050601522,
-0.0408055261,
0.0122520607,
-0.0028801053,
0.004622269,
-0.0501045324,
-0.0098910062,
-0.0454775356,
-0.0272426791,
-0.0834740549,
0.0010847022,
-0.0039255372,
0.0173924752,
0.0118560614,
0.0135958521,
-0.0269926041,
-0.0206126664,
-0.0054508303,
0.0329873525,
-0.0404467769,
0.043789342,
0.0107228076,
-0.0269113164,
-0.0066809547,
0.0047785905,
0.0577253923,
-0.0212860182,
-0.0015443981,
0.04865456,
-0.0045827604,
-0.0614169016,
-0.0208575595,
-0.0015919707,
-0.0242449045,
-0.0104680788,
-0.0593842007,
-0.0589643158,
0.0219101608,
-0.0426074527,
-0.0079478445,
-0.0005295819,
0.012483866,
-0.0092837811,
-0.0036544504,
0.0685698986,
-0.1025678664,
-0.0221079513,
0.0113209495,
-0.0037060517,
0.0012460804,
0.0617885701,
0.0436107628,
0.0060531008,
0.0610649548,
-0.0016643888,
0.0189981293,
0.0547168702,
0.0059905914,
0.0186952446,
-0.0057525937,
-0.0310029034,
-0.043048501,
0.0372926332,
0.0046976297,
0.019630786,
-0.047782395,
-0.0030646545,
0.0664075688,
0.0202167109,
0.0453959927,
-0.0228833091,
-0.0140121486,
0.0158588849,
0.0383155085,
-0.0039374582,
0.004740105,
-0.0156737715,
-0.0240162145,
0.0248967353,
0.0514832549,
0.0188489705,
0.0013811714,
-0.0634396672,
0.0171055309,
-0.030420484,
0.0701170862,
-0.0228554215,
0.0492643937,
0.0392277092,
0.0042779837,
-0.0410491601,
0.0276143253,
-0.0508429855,
0.0440863483,
-0.0035368938,
-0.0351791419,
0.0782400444,
0.0790831521,
-0.0626602024,
-0.0121317543,
-0.0032983564,
-0.014905992,
0.0521355346,
0.0036093174,
0.0194200072,
0.0342676193,
-0.0448702537,
-0.0252399426,
-0.0198499486,
0.0307016913,
0.0092378752,
0.0394254439,
0.0100196507,
0.0475757457,
-0.0360004678,
-0.0631223619,
0.0506198965,
0.0046516364,
0.0011863929,
0.0292367116,
-0.0218135584,
-0.0175625477,
0.0691775754,
-0.0057555949,
0.0107141593,
-0.002069612,
-0.0151746729,
-0.0172323119,
0.0077898744,
0.0102305282,
-0.0084609464,
0.019477183,
-0.0560194403,
0.0286038388,
0.0259546097,
-0.0525036603,
-0.0508387275,
-0.0060477392,
-0.0521354899,
0.0296502411,
-0.0202098731,
0.0174735337,
-0.0089163538,
0.0343405493,
-0.0265503656,
0.0252757818,
0.017235782,
-0.0017160121,
-0.0192004442,
0.0143381199,
0.0155152753,
-0.0232675504,
-0.0283940472,
-0.0241003633,
-0.0106981061,
0.0045676054,
0.0195543617,
-0.0292535741,
-0.0811923891,
0.0199289694,
-0.0881164819,
-0.0064205611,
-0.0127085112,
0.0277856905,
0.0284935292,
0.042629946,
-0.0099727958,
-0.0442310572,
-0.0221816245,
-0.0375199951,
-0.0064893113,
0.0215323754,
0.064067021,
0.0188541878,
0.0157894753,
-0.0581663102,
-0.0360195339,
0.0265692491,
0.0375004634,
0.0261302385,
-0.0608312078,
-0.059449289,
-0.0202985313,
-0.0159179773,
0.0164721515,
0.0164933205,
-0.021620445,
-0.0161754154,
0.0185200963,
0.0314760432,
0.0239315331,
0.0101809129,
-0.0164195001,
-0.0052069309,
0.0315834619,
-0.024519762,
-0.0124678081,
-0.0422494598,
0.0413115956,
0.006757257,
-0.0451998599,
0.0650534034,
0.0213413034,
-0.051151067,
-0.0260917805,
-0.0252698921,
-0.03800283,
-0.0238486249,
-0.0541488491,
-0.018125698,
-0.0382954478,
-0.0299633741,
0.0246137977,
-0.018188769,
-0.0653111041,
0.0423736647,
-0.0638800114,
-0.0162068456,
-0.0456408411,
-0.0449902751,
-0.0419467948,
0.036607638,
0.0341740996,
0.008056323,
-0.0297981147,
-0.0326198488,
0.0217786692,
0.0228497107,
0.0080460049,
-0.0378494598,
0.0363916717,
-0.0281844549,
0.0023948867,
-0.0109156426,
-0.0065385117,
-0.0045430809,
-0.0304340981,
0.0053057461,
-0.0109084453,
0.0397838317,
-0.0527206473,
-0.0225028396,
-0.0152160581,
0.0148930661,
0.0660831183,
-0.0063377805,
-0.0075031151,
-0.0310962275,
0.0261672679,
0.0283963401,
0.0407408923,
0.0023762377,
0.0336074978,
-0.0229436439,
0.0281703584,
0.029918436,
-0.0438213982,
-0.0453890748,
-0.0159710124,
0.0236500259,
-0.0444163494,
-0.0134111336,
-0.0258104261,
0.087641336,
-0.0678640306,
0.0104606394,
0.086721465,
0.0304873753,
-0.0316331349,
0.0066494588,
0.0122757414,
0.0045525073,
0.0016246382,
-0.016680561,
-0.0856546164,
-0.0215003993,
-0.0198585298,
0.0146768903,
-0.0351258367,
-0.0138674816,
-0.0181625113,
-0.0955689475,
-0.0010172047,
0.0061358204,
-0.0185750835,
-0.0174438301,
-0.0515011363,
0.0396690704,
-0.0137008559,
0.0227027331,
-0.0303191431,
0.0068365033,
0.0026914738,
0.0103241242,
-0.0428080559,
-0.0683041066,
-0.0813923702,
-0.0370459631,
0.0351380967,
0.0602940135,
0.0202318672,
-0.0255265851,
-0.0322749577,
0.0180621296,
-0.001827047,
0.0196839217,
0.0070192004,
0.1004572883,
-0.0141208665,
-0.013645174,
-0.0140074091,
0.022450706,
0.0421260782,
-0.0065156892,
0.0013695821,
0.0070543191,
0.0296523888,
0.0350393802,
-0.0262933653,
-0.0083601177,
-0.0096588451,
0.03734551,
0.0197354313,
-0.0463135913,
0.0137027064,
-0.0314493924,
0.004776265,
-0.0837695897,
0.0161787719,
-0.0089792954,
-0.0546077937,
-0.0350484215,
-0.0663984343,
-0.0737884045,
0.016750548,
-0.0091676926,
0.0108450772,
0.0153130265,
-0.0479541458,
-0.0444556624,
-0.018885022,
0.0316496715,
-0.0090308012,
0.0386308059,
-0.0010927223,
-0.0160106421,
-0.0312813073,
-0.0299105551,
0.0058442573,
0.0092670638,
-0.0669668689,
-0.0309065022,
-0.0108986273,
0.0037606731,
0.0212224424,
0.0474056453,
-0.0549969822,
-0.0791983232,
0.0243731495,
0.0642296523,
-0.054544922,
0.0166645292,
0.0202872865,
-0.0166027471,
0.0042062155,
-0.0095601594,
-0.020708859,
0.0216189418,
-0.0080920327,
0.0365667157,
-0.0053688446,
-0.0188032184,
0.0069875252,
0.0090349866,
0.0532884635,
-0.0187119115,
0.0247439221,
-0.0157563109,
0.0149927298,
-0.0602798462,
-0.027145341,
-0.0304291137,
0.0012491546,
0.06110847,
0.0230275486,
-0.0239493195,
0.0225123353,
-0.0136725279,
0.0185959619,
-0.0850394517,
0.0040758089,
0.0163217876,
0.0001014582,
-0.0004810015,
0.0301900432,
0.0020358309,
0.0132511752,
-0.0177440736,
0.0217661262,
0.0095028384,
-0.0041404455,
0.0241404995,
-0.0230566654,
-0.0280585606,
0.0705061853,
-0.0873514488,
0.0691296905,
-0.0368135758,
0.0651243553,
0.0013577443,
-0.0178645439,
0.1133261546,
-0.0045467857,
-0.028162783,
-0.0031612501,
0.008224329,
-0.0091336938,
-0.0205121674,
-0.0318061039,
-0.0118610915,
-0.026772406,
-0.0001367388,
0.0298380386,
-0.0413848348,
0.0350659154,
-0.029192917,
-0.0261970647,
-0.0041790404,
-0.0184901711,
0.0004200786,
0.0506151877,
-0.0367140248,
0.0045770132,
-0.0352126546,
-0.0471216403,
0.0011331772,
-0.0079138754,
-0.0007270601,
0.0059399321,
-0.0025729723,
-0.0105413906,
0.0020629533,
-0.0103720566,
-0.0136675537,
-0.0031438447,
-0.0128383497,
0.0010565508,
0.0162531231,
-5.631492949e-33,
-0.0100675188,
-0.0016785733,
-0.0285680778,
-0.0280352272,
-0.0643702,
0.0499052443,
0.0115084657,
0.0136318775,
-0.0037152327,
0.0191931706,
-0.0042174179,
0.0073271957,
0.0236799493,
0.0376583748,
-0.0283936244,
0.0185905714,
0.0354618542,
0.0116677769,
-0.037696097,
-0.0038514468,
-0.0079650506,
-0.0032432142,
0.0918323621,
-0.08553949,
0.0776690543,
0.031601198,
-0.045567885,
-0.0026214854,
0.0528317168,
0.0346594676,
-0.0006847718,
0.0811918005,
0.0241986327,
-0.0441826433,
-0.0293547269,
0.0460160077,
-0.0677079856,
-0.0139348144,
0.0263685882,
0.0547701828,
-0.1015457213,
0.0102106491,
0.0477373414,
-0.0120013971,
-0.0070810216,
0.0095604127,
0.0254813414,
-0.0822977945,
-0.0030696511,
0.0045478158,
-0.0499098413,
0.0669741407,
-0.0069527999,
0.0299911797,
0.0473517217,
0.0295292456,
0.023732828,
0.022358045,
-0.0720779896,
-0.0087272869,
0.0656018853,
0.0323063098,
0.0187934972,
0.0368953608,
-0.0141924266,
0.0387750752,
0.0121131213,
-0.0052076126,
-0.0285520628,
0.0306589659,
0.0184837487,
0.0092940107,
0.0863795578,
0.0649084747,
0.0627020076,
0.0069931913,
-0.0000202246,
0.0544555075,
-0.005702964,
-0.0281421281,
-0.0134296454,
0.028909849,
-0.0394050777,
0.0088799773,
-0.0245694462,
0.0080722366,
-0.0208571367,
-0.0410169996,
0.0076617207,
0.0203468222,
-0.0449961126,
0.0833818465,
-0.034182556,
-0.0351956896,
-0.0204496514,
0.0005012687,
-0.010935002,
0.0509400778,
0.0021517708,
-0.0384523161,
-0.0353496522,
0.0046500205,
0.0744126663,
0.0438184291,
-0.0139926448,
-0.0761873946,
0.0762066245,
-0.018721018,
-0.0503491648,
0.0302832965,
-0.0040463437,
0.0270099901,
0.0038437273,
0.0091440976,
0.0118114883,
-0.0021733162,
-0.0511251837,
0.0297494922,
0.0606262945,
0.032471776,
-0.0168379731,
-0.0246697329,
0.0097332681,
-0.0252353679,
-0.0231449418,
0.0218775589,
0.0030765859,
-0.0469226614,
0.0269237775,
-0.0376123376,
-0.0218880959,
-0.0095809624,
2.359e-7,
0.0692037642,
0.0415461883,
0.0797366649,
-0.0199709516,
0.011574151,
0.0055162758,
-0.0108112777,
0.0263091121,
0.0253149364,
-0.0244152732,
-0.0034482984,
0.0149751585,
0.0458807014,
-0.033938244,
-0.0104591725,
-0.0383208357,
-0.0588885657,
0.002052187,
-0.026274154,
0.0041081877,
0.0690816939,
0.0595084541,
0.0282659847,
-0.0137043456,
0.0137730986,
-0.0381105095,
0.0336998291,
-0.0317415707,
0.0161122903,
0.0480139889,
0.0490842313,
0.0532913357,
0.0155793764,
0.0162648465,
-0.0369520895,
0.0193487369,
0.0533981435,
0.0105877826,
-0.018741399,
0.0477449857,
-0.0368768871,
0.0068666711,
0.012701273,
-0.0260099769,
0.0724001378,
0.0065180082,
-0.013194425,
-0.0416250676,
-0.051475361,
0.0401018597,
0.0302789323,
-0.0279288553,
-0.0449009016,
0.0205972269,
0.0504564904,
0.0286144093,
-0.0803427696,
-0.0777915865,
-0.0839495957,
-0.0191934202,
0.0129681714,
-0.0190220997,
-0.0616061613,
0.0223657154,
-0.0128498739,
-0.0755351484,
-0.0090012755,
1.916214208e-34,
0.0121524315,
-0.0166411493,
0.0158205144,
-0.0144100524,
0.0069258674,
-0.0020528235,
0.0128100207,
0.0031054739,
-0.011322367,
-0.0778499767,
0.0099072857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06738v1 | EntGPT: Linking Generative Large Language Models with Knowledge Bases | 2024-02-09T19:16:27 | 2024-02-09T19:16:27 | Yifan Ding, Amrit Poudel, Qingkai Zeng, Tim Weninger, Balaji Veeramani, Sanmitra Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL | The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate factually correct
output remains relatively unexplored due to the lack of fact-checking and
knowledge grounding during training and inference. In this work, we aim to
address this challenge through the Entity Disambiguation (ED) task. We first
consider prompt engineering, and design a three-step hard-prompting method to
probe LLMs' ED performance without supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Overall, the
prompting method improves the micro-F_1 score of the original vanilla models by
a large margin, on some cases up to 36% and higher, and obtains comparable
performance across 10 datasets when compared to existing methods with SFT. We
further improve the knowledge grounding ability through instruction tuning (IT)
with similar prompts and responses. The instruction-tuned model not only
achieves higher micro-F1 score performance as compared to several baseline
methods on supervised entity disambiguation tasks with an average micro-F_1
improvement of 2.1% over the existing baseline models, but also obtains higher
accuracy on six Question Answering (QA) tasks in the zero-shot setting. Our
methodologies apply to both open- and closed-source LLMs. | [
0.0573444255,
0.005474275,
-0.0096887965,
0.0213249084,
-0.0061127497,
0.0515076816,
0.0245765503,
-0.0260206293,
0.0286326613,
-0.0609650537,
-0.0090453103,
0.0008351835,
-0.0298301056,
-0.0376295634,
0.0351395905,
0.0059366077,
0.0639887676,
-0.0250438713,
-0.0338714197,
-0.0294480827,
-0.01653588,
0.0471958742,
-0.0366643183,
-0.0159362517,
0.002984561,
-0.0279755238,
0.0031223984,
0.0103849992,
0.0188459381,
0.0144158443,
0.0145650068,
0.0727534369,
0.0158730857,
0.0522028804,
0.0000020237,
-0.083893843,
-0.0099323429,
-0.0042820843,
-0.0840838477,
0.0243901685,
-0.008836939,
0.0052220705,
0.0202075858,
0.0138845649,
-0.0112230359,
-0.0409670621,
0.0086673303,
0.0365857631,
0.0750916973,
0.0557505116,
0.0192710161,
-0.038799569,
-0.0033160315,
-0.0178612601,
-0.005605164,
-0.0074138334,
0.0434399359,
0.0178412255,
-0.022691451,
0.0244255066,
-0.0086745629,
0.0520579666,
0.0281504057,
0.0162652005,
0.0227811038,
0.0285726599,
-0.0272925813,
-0.0068013226,
0.0277586449,
0.0773501098,
0.0348235443,
-0.0342368074,
0.0272889528,
0.0166665558,
0.0099325078,
0.0451168306,
-0.0062644058,
0.0042281463,
-0.0287671164,
-0.0098197442,
0.00655116,
-0.0548744015,
0.0270617865,
0.0492788441,
-0.0176592693,
0.0378890485,
0.0407225825,
-0.0403295718,
0.0183339305,
0.0232524332,
-0.0302874725,
-0.0528970361,
-0.0193595756,
-0.0068522026,
-0.0569600537,
0.0216810331,
-0.0340743288,
-0.0136308521,
0.0190232899,
-0.0189757496,
-0.0391571857,
0.0084015038,
0.0045401263,
0.0714812055,
-0.0411339439,
0.0490924492,
-0.0123923663,
0.0119949384,
-0.0177604351,
-0.0225885883,
-0.0687422529,
0.0129701281,
-0.0345841236,
0.0296880864,
-0.0385684706,
0.0027185157,
-0.0396261588,
0.0007086681,
0.0078871446,
0.0257501639,
0.0081931325,
-0.0128054796,
-0.0261333529,
0.0041894084,
-0.051715795,
0.0250391047,
-0.0551675186,
0.0055283597,
-0.0101775378,
-0.0531365089,
-0.0217836518,
-0.011186705,
-0.0275118425,
-0.0558677576,
0.0254585389,
-0.0080661811,
0.0054443972,
-0.020016877,
-0.053553354,
-0.0017646339,
-0.0123614781,
-0.0795546323,
-0.0052629202,
-0.0651266798,
0.0302443188,
0.0195451938,
0.0035357696,
-0.0366044827,
0.0081202304,
-0.0279998574,
-0.026591422,
0.0864632353,
-0.036985103,
0.0126725519,
0.0492651612,
0.0198597349,
0.0047193114,
0.0536029637,
0.0191743057,
-0.015199705,
0.0470446199,
0.0003400765,
-0.0106968414,
0.0255231857,
0.0037187925,
0.0181271043,
0.049316287,
0.0290720854,
-0.0003403303,
0.0254071467,
0.0408900976,
0.0610694513,
-0.0245134532,
-0.0035163425,
0.046862822,
0.0033514022,
-0.0023813241,
0.0123324664,
0.0460472852,
0.0374373831,
0.0076418957,
0.009371927,
-0.0506683514,
-0.0051335073,
-0.024809178,
0.0208578482,
0.0266866982,
0.0459165089,
-0.0350783169,
-0.0083766673,
0.0147916228,
0.0048833583,
-0.0197282117,
0.0911981165,
0.0400211178,
0.0220953394,
-0.0194764547,
0.0830807164,
0.0468495227,
-0.0300814305,
0.015390222,
-0.0489496253,
0.0471450873,
0.0636252835,
0.0395890735,
0.0063206111,
-0.0424596183,
-0.0424578413,
0.0117353629,
0.0579701737,
0.0317674838,
-0.0474765822,
0.0130710872,
-0.0468080677,
-0.0159533788,
-0.002276611,
0.0129951304,
0.0008371052,
0.0583587587,
0.0069504241,
0.0459992066,
-0.050866574,
-0.0016106265,
0.0320553072,
-0.0417280607,
-0.0521884821,
-0.013000533,
0.0323566049,
-0.0277882982,
0.0287986882,
-0.0396654308,
-0.0223238878,
0.0016294245,
-0.0124730933,
0.0048410483,
-0.0465935692,
0.0082690315,
-0.0447568521,
0.0222151279,
0.0282332059,
-0.0557624511,
-0.0051548732,
-0.059209045,
-0.0416495092,
-0.049827449,
-0.0177000426,
0.0150167374,
-0.0462447479,
0.0228362512,
-0.0015858323,
-0.0223361477,
-0.052969642,
0.0821466446,
0.0134706227,
0.0231087618,
0.0194972381,
0.0275568664,
0.0084757162,
-0.0393743813,
-0.0569466166,
0.009283768,
0.0452710688,
-0.0144745735,
0.0354140736,
0.0077641443,
-0.0959371477,
-0.0332737416,
-0.0951143578,
0.0441368818,
-0.0272495504,
0.0289017055,
0.0051527047,
0.0228957385,
-0.0306020901,
0.006167375,
0.0011035173,
-0.0136622768,
0.0049039284,
0.0227437727,
0.0230853129,
-0.0056512412,
-0.024910761,
-0.0180970002,
0.0019975235,
-0.0196638666,
0.0176403206,
0.0230696257,
-0.0245976038,
-0.0566950962,
0.0710430518,
-0.0647331774,
-0.0000930237,
0.0066320859,
-0.008651386,
0.0003481739,
0.0204593111,
0.0669225976,
0.0774539858,
-0.0019888734,
0.0116609838,
0.02004412,
0.0024278862,
-0.0598480925,
0.0373397581,
-0.0141708218,
-0.0283103082,
-0.0244481284,
-0.0151020717,
-0.0107383449,
0.0596566945,
0.0078201154,
-0.0285402238,
-0.0274463445,
0.0333097503,
-0.0152722653,
-0.0237531345,
-0.021168191,
0.0322575159,
0.0244712979,
0.0085072014,
-0.0471986085,
-0.0217524581,
0.0783078,
-0.0148382103,
0.0061567333,
-0.0396627635,
0.007599154,
-0.0075853793,
0.041389104,
-0.0197355319,
0.0129477261,
0.0241198223,
-0.0222410019,
-0.0523977131,
-0.0009774514,
0.0233441945,
-0.0357041545,
0.0747972354,
-0.0568105876,
0.0386129804,
0.0269926023,
-0.043144621,
-0.0636060089,
-0.0366970152,
-0.0110807437,
0.0240577422,
0.0183218233,
0.0008601472,
-0.0223335978,
-0.0182768777,
0.0578388572,
-0.0030607099,
0.0047032917,
-0.0213245638,
-0.0250064861,
0.0251475517,
0.0894895196,
0.000266926,
0.0711189359,
-0.0389620513,
0.0557785966,
0.0173004139,
0.0306351036,
-0.0204080623,
-0.0054445243,
-0.0071908035,
0.0059475522,
-0.0736718923,
-0.0338118598,
-0.0000287759,
0.0617229193,
-0.0286269914,
-0.009647252,
0.157568112,
0.0376206599,
-0.015261231,
-0.0172788594,
0.0487587526,
0.028075017,
0.0175040197,
0.0396122299,
-0.0937484503,
-0.035373386,
-0.0012725462,
0.0276558809,
0.0179364048,
-0.0570318997,
0.0083738212,
-0.1349279732,
0.0132877911,
-0.0301958155,
-0.003947834,
-0.0424149446,
-0.0378788225,
0.0186263602,
-0.0072131315,
0.0167307258,
0.0003605208,
-0.0057600639,
0.0185522027,
0.0159187932,
0.0226584151,
-0.0620233193,
0.0390234403,
-0.0771398842,
0.0915407538,
0.0382381082,
0.0181161072,
0.0229297336,
-0.0130999731,
-0.0188502464,
-0.0384134427,
-0.0266003571,
-0.0161780901,
0.047327105,
-0.0186222959,
-0.0107705481,
-0.0461452007,
-0.0020799732,
-0.0027602573,
0.0137132369,
0.0077436073,
0.0224488582,
-0.00701153,
-0.0065091932,
0.0224541556,
-0.0308529176,
0.0155784469,
0.0981504843,
0.0028418906,
-0.0306084622,
-0.0250949468,
-0.0206203759,
-0.0050099217,
-0.0206924323,
0.0002317606,
0.0146185448,
-0.060698323,
0.0130962776,
-0.0579978749,
-0.0424832851,
0.0727204829,
0.0175364278,
0.0035261582,
0.0137846172,
0.012028276,
0.0197704565,
-0.0156585425,
0.0549401119,
-0.0614940934,
0.0173287857,
-0.0332206376,
-0.0505090319,
0.0376788788,
-0.0025012759,
-0.0255251434,
0.0293199643,
-0.0948589519,
-0.0623462461,
0.011072292,
0.0253712442,
0.016752582,
0.0553509034,
-0.043121174,
-0.0362141989,
0.0243744496,
0.0063320282,
-0.0419745781,
0.0239576176,
-0.0305039622,
0.0297347773,
-0.0139614921,
0.0545470752,
-0.067785956,
0.0155799761,
0.0492403321,
0.0541107468,
-0.0501587391,
-0.0511338897,
0.0068594357,
0.0455975085,
0.0131273791,
-0.0283896104,
-0.0036293264,
-0.0447455943,
-0.0041273045,
0.0026927525,
-0.0244891401,
-0.0028800357,
-0.0043250015,
0.0318396837,
-0.0204163827,
0.0031787818,
0.0441228449,
0.005541238,
0.0555872172,
-0.054328911,
-0.0192809217,
-0.0139971171,
-0.0047948034,
0.0216534007,
-0.0295282342,
-0.0297478493,
0.0277058426,
0.0698919073,
0.0526592322,
-0.0078374147,
0.0645759255,
0.0052186828,
0.0009118582,
-0.023988571,
-0.0126424143,
-0.0378777124,
-0.0161924455,
0.003839686,
0.0754100755,
0.0752438605,
-0.007768984,
0.0725741163,
0.010655487,
-0.0256351214,
-0.0053049405,
0.0156468507,
0.0143744927,
0.0209124275,
0.0352194123,
0.0219954625,
-0.011278661,
0.0012331919,
0.0693596825,
0.0122786807,
0.0749074072,
0.0046395701,
-0.0138885062,
-0.0410826132,
-0.0519070067,
-0.0309928842,
-0.0380748697,
-0.0152293006,
0.0377074182,
-0.0591126457,
-0.074895516,
-0.0040536514,
-0.001536968,
-0.0287685916,
-0.015203381,
0.0557917617,
0.0415183455,
0.0080062682,
-0.0636831746,
-0.0525940508,
-0.0048312973,
-0.018700812,
-0.0507048331,
-0.0282372534,
-6.441986753e-33,
-0.0559880883,
-0.0043488387,
0.0250716042,
-0.0396847166,
-0.0453192182,
0.0007471898,
-0.0062581399,
-0.0139541756,
-0.0568860993,
0.0124555677,
-0.0087393895,
0.038877558,
0.0046975291,
0.021772515,
-0.0293375421,
-0.0482702479,
0.058069922,
0.0044213412,
-0.0276655164,
0.0339293741,
0.0205933545,
0.0319713876,
0.0196409989,
-0.0378931053,
0.0439807139,
-0.0278005209,
0.0058727064,
0.0313199423,
-0.0168874767,
0.0677106604,
0.0042406553,
0.0316063091,
0.0147457449,
-0.0505036153,
0.0095258961,
0.0145578003,
-0.1208911315,
-0.0088871159,
0.0499856025,
-0.0094302408,
-0.0017741108,
-0.0445198454,
0.0129518677,
-0.0147025287,
0.0070720161,
-0.0092471316,
0.0310365446,
-0.0062632672,
-0.0020656101,
-0.0449363589,
-0.0113793779,
0.0061852303,
-0.0143874045,
-0.021982532,
-0.0105532715,
0.0043791737,
-0.0090665193,
-0.0046263197,
-0.0593171008,
-0.0037557555,
0.0375325046,
0.0227646716,
0.0512093045,
0.0221647639,
0.0173630416,
0.0323673002,
-0.008124439,
0.0020279631,
-0.0458455905,
-0.0139619084,
0.0097188838,
0.0245837513,
0.0006811571,
0.0662687495,
-0.004504411,
-0.0017498268,
-0.0907513723,
0.0069196234,
0.0249953046,
0.0280140638,
0.0043571591,
-0.0559225455,
-0.0567997433,
-0.0357829034,
-0.0862905011,
0.0436735153,
-0.0226298403,
-0.0166563243,
0.0419998728,
0.0000167919,
-0.0446938574,
-0.0382499509,
0.0160309114,
-0.0387746431,
-0.0023057493,
0.0254556164,
0.0073863547,
0.0161745455,
-0.0003435043,
0.0229075067,
-0.0476318672,
-0.0004079247,
0.0171411783,
0.005818082,
0.0006113685,
0.0162106808,
0.0072383964,
-0.0253693499,
-0.0615358762,
0.0309566576,
-0.0064551919,
0.0230295938,
-0.0288861506,
-0.0043682749,
0.0093748346,
0.0328111649,
0.0184983369,
-0.003726582,
0.0557502918,
-0.0082163261,
0.0092793405,
-0.0012035008,
0.0223894417,
0.0298910011,
-0.0313285105,
0.0241861809,
-0.0078388825,
0.0152755296,
-0.0260259826,
-0.0538644008,
-0.0120060844,
0.0027624983,
2.699e-7,
0.0224387683,
0.0568399467,
-0.0056828642,
0.0603576899,
-0.0105870953,
0.0073998035,
0.0406383909,
-0.0154902069,
0.033294186,
-0.0644938126,
-0.0134887965,
0.0463941097,
0.0626773164,
0.0211248938,
-0.0862129107,
-0.0018364028,
0.0047524199,
0.0366149358,
-0.0627686977,
0.0070893029,
0.0241295546,
0.0746651292,
0.0102876676,
-0.0033825391,
-0.0199814308,
-0.0341983214,
0.0440548733,
-0.008139044,
-0.0337880589,
0.0450287797,
0.0385057181,
0.0175568108,
0.0111980764,
0.0785428137,
-0.010600213,
-0.0030385943,
0.0038679377,
0.0706889182,
0.0181679521,
-0.0105195576,
-0.0281428676,
-0.0451159663,
0.0176891033,
-0.051705759,
0.0838139728,
-0.03720944,
0.0127474125,
0.0247419439,
-0.0260651596,
-0.0330042243,
0.0038690076,
-0.03950103,
-0.0362370685,
0.0083967401,
0.0171861593,
-0.018007027,
0.0075943158,
-0.0412040129,
0.0054173968,
0.0360338911,
-0.0387785509,
-0.0890719518,
0.0362636857,
-0.0450406335,
0.0040181829,
-0.0546020232,
0.0354751945,
2.453909431e-34,
0.0075474279,
0.0262267627,
0.0163644571,
0.0238210391,
0.0444683619,
-0.0091520352,
-0.0649973676,
-0.0279541891,
0.0128313834,
-0.0988360643,
0.0126005961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06733v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06733v3 | NICE: To Optimize In-Context Examples or Not? | 2024-02-09T19:09:19 | 2024-06-06T12:16:55 | Pragya Srivastava, Satvik Golechha, Amit Deshpande, Amit Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent work shows that in-context learning and optimization of in-context
examples (ICE) can significantly improve the accuracy of large language models
(LLMs) on a wide range of tasks, leading to an apparent consensus that ICE
optimization is crucial for better performance. However, most of these studies
assume a fixed or no instruction provided in the prompt. We challenge this
consensus by investigating the necessity of optimizing ICE when task-specific
instructions are provided and find that there are many tasks for which it
yields diminishing returns. In particular, using a diverse set of tasks and a
systematically created instruction set with gradually added details, we find
that as the prompt instruction becomes more detailed, the returns on ICE
optimization diminish. To characterize this behavior, we introduce a
task-specific metric called Normalized Invariability to Choice of Examples
(NICE) that quantifies the learnability of tasks from a given instruction, and
provides a heuristic to help decide whether to optimize instructions or ICE for
a new task. Given a task, the proposed metric can reliably predict the utility
of optimizing ICE compared to using random ICE. Our code is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/nice-icl. | [
0.0210864022,
0.0504200421,
-0.0034521746,
0.0491353832,
-0.0427322909,
0.0251075756,
0.018309325,
-0.0102333808,
-0.0258399956,
-0.0443565249,
-0.0137952361,
-0.0488828756,
0.014511846,
-0.0092433849,
0.0357774794,
-0.0467107818,
0.0366536528,
-0.0728766993,
-0.0074923285,
0.0069742566,
-0.0237715282,
-0.0185132883,
-0.0188958254,
0.0591572262,
0.0125280553,
-0.0337144732,
0.0034640557,
0.0184273645,
-0.0090920925,
0.0041392851,
0.0182547849,
0.0415873379,
0.0308853276,
0.0129031753,
0.0000020774,
-0.066373162,
-0.0078862375,
-0.0043107723,
-0.0504540317,
0.0283067729,
0.0364618897,
0.0145908138,
-0.0030753762,
0.044431664,
-0.0207379926,
0.0090499884,
0.0422921777,
0.014160865,
0.0197535157,
0.0894350782,
0.0078231869,
0.0181124154,
-0.0093666799,
-0.0253818091,
0.042928379,
-0.0404223874,
0.006518391,
-0.0191284418,
0.0057189371,
0.012901715,
-0.0317507088,
0.0357898921,
0.0201355405,
0.0224356819,
-0.0101106539,
0.0457714945,
-0.0615631491,
0.0004672052,
-0.0153270252,
0.0743146613,
-0.0423827842,
-0.0146385161,
-0.0005137444,
-0.0357277803,
0.0069342689,
-0.0152643947,
-0.0357441045,
0.0053735985,
-0.0042040055,
0.024867354,
0.030030394,
-0.0071520233,
0.0500359796,
0.0167137105,
-0.0240719467,
0.0610424131,
-0.0043230974,
-0.0144225555,
0.029092133,
0.0069596483,
-0.0805740058,
-0.0395237282,
-0.0303148609,
0.0185377058,
-0.0635278597,
0.0293704718,
-0.0592685044,
-0.0068355449,
0.0068407892,
-0.0046620946,
0.0728445426,
0.0663336813,
-0.0089761484,
0.0494583324,
-0.0110614533,
0.0675369501,
0.0030080713,
0.015475275,
-0.0389794931,
-0.0000236124,
-0.0558659509,
0.0199250039,
-0.047859557,
0.0080709364,
-0.0051911031,
-0.016677402,
-0.0097529339,
0.0610839687,
-0.0024935827,
0.0358843245,
0.0204411875,
-0.0358788259,
-0.0508259125,
0.0105439778,
-0.0161133818,
0.0012845043,
-0.0340850875,
0.0254489612,
0.0017046991,
-0.0493777469,
-0.0030939193,
0.0056129657,
-0.0051735016,
-0.02989191,
0.0211716872,
0.0698601305,
-0.0143053867,
-0.0686834082,
-0.0148268901,
-0.0086293807,
-0.0014213537,
-0.0774251074,
-0.0224675406,
-0.0861509889,
-0.0054457244,
0.0262436327,
0.0002817951,
-0.0343761258,
-0.0030037991,
0.0140728131,
-0.0338331163,
0.0582887344,
0.0229225215,
0.0169705003,
0.0245490242,
0.0003717909,
-0.0084440885,
0.0993913636,
0.0165684279,
0.0062029711,
0.0462117791,
0.000811376,
0.0054209917,
0.0689641088,
0.0277599841,
0.0440062508,
-0.0027084874,
0.0215618294,
0.0181874819,
0.0243361462,
0.0330672637,
0.0388395935,
-0.0148020992,
0.0120637435,
0.0667731911,
0.0271757077,
-0.0181008633,
-0.0167570747,
0.0291398484,
0.0314741731,
-0.022613924,
0.0165093858,
-0.0923679993,
0.018211104,
0.0054140962,
0.0296467841,
0.029002605,
0.0050865272,
-0.0514909551,
-0.0315580107,
-0.0016524508,
-0.0274742674,
-0.01538157,
0.0475164801,
0.0424592271,
0.0091620786,
-0.0773788467,
0.0215734392,
0.0197122041,
-0.0238428153,
-0.0195169542,
-0.0566665754,
0.0298712831,
0.0551149435,
0.0373132415,
-0.0271251462,
-0.0498097874,
-0.0148113109,
0.0250989851,
0.0204920247,
0.0484273434,
-0.0203313138,
0.0591027886,
-0.054643441,
-0.0435204469,
-0.0053654369,
0.0225333758,
-0.0237881765,
0.0490936898,
-0.0085357083,
0.011816998,
-0.0514277741,
-0.0328787379,
0.0372689702,
-0.0209147763,
-0.0416806564,
0.027326161,
0.0155419968,
0.0342691876,
-0.0224028081,
-0.0086337924,
0.0007927887,
0.0148453508,
-0.0214679707,
0.0212517288,
-0.0052293376,
-0.0890560895,
-0.0353778228,
0.0067865793,
0.0075504323,
-0.0232691206,
0.0114560416,
-0.0528544337,
-0.0303197578,
0.0059642298,
-0.0188725516,
0.0532549769,
0.015306999,
0.039766144,
-0.0240357257,
0.002611954,
-0.0476682261,
0.0547411442,
-0.0138871288,
0.0176330749,
0.0370391198,
0.0213062633,
-0.0189930294,
-0.0260661654,
-0.0245376378,
-0.0315012448,
-0.0058545801,
0.0112865539,
0.0197571348,
0.0320438556,
-0.033062309,
-0.016324278,
-0.122791484,
0.0326584727,
-0.0541547462,
0.0060460502,
0.0272811037,
0.0367254764,
-0.0117385695,
-0.0174503643,
-0.0112981871,
-0.0053922823,
-0.0429582857,
0.0338878334,
0.0024036141,
0.0320097134,
-0.0454867519,
-0.0345255919,
-0.0103302607,
-0.0020008232,
0.0247872099,
-0.0385604836,
0.0037781755,
-0.057446342,
0.0755577236,
0.0170524269,
0.041757457,
-0.0334905684,
0.0063254121,
0.0034912031,
-0.0116378348,
0.0780169442,
0.1073825955,
-0.0011520899,
-0.0002974531,
0.0337370299,
0.0032075751,
-0.0823361054,
0.0177513361,
-0.0177258085,
-0.044021789,
-0.0254389625,
-0.0397538058,
0.0187197924,
0.0592459962,
-0.0121799512,
-0.0107783815,
-0.0269657485,
-0.0013476659,
-0.0363686644,
-0.0133766644,
-0.036907319,
0.0057095294,
-0.0254496168,
0.0291800126,
-0.0149375619,
-0.0867546797,
0.0516168289,
-0.0326060578,
-0.0026056976,
-0.0485182144,
-0.0169577505,
-0.039346002,
0.0487833321,
0.0072953501,
-0.0052479943,
0.0090438742,
-0.0241487753,
-0.0585383251,
-0.0088187354,
0.0274296757,
0.0002409326,
0.0742344856,
-0.0760360584,
0.0053245402,
-0.0116109373,
-0.05471595,
-0.0446109548,
-0.0316115618,
-0.0033296007,
0.0246087406,
0.0245451778,
-0.0279386602,
-0.0171003826,
-0.0138343927,
0.0199740008,
0.0754423365,
-0.0159791782,
-0.0115246279,
-0.0273768026,
-0.0152636906,
0.0463316515,
0.0071271448,
-0.0161932223,
-0.0422287621,
0.0078534614,
-0.0104118912,
0.0828704461,
-0.0076181646,
-0.0345245339,
0.012596488,
0.034151651,
-0.0272311289,
-0.0500068963,
0.0862469673,
0.0786987469,
-0.0647287965,
-0.0483768843,
0.1130619943,
0.0368466787,
-0.0722545981,
0.0170551799,
0.0005556706,
0.0279529449,
0.0366638638,
0.012485153,
-0.0525937006,
-0.0605894737,
0.0207326654,
0.0415490419,
-0.0078012007,
-0.0185931586,
-0.0070072468,
-0.1105050072,
0.0137362611,
0.0068783513,
-0.0617011636,
-0.0140032889,
-0.0525062494,
0.0079552932,
-0.0290898681,
0.0330092385,
0.0027075605,
-0.0204814393,
0.0092063248,
0.0297771189,
-0.0238306019,
-0.0784456655,
0.0338559635,
-0.0468126237,
0.0424793735,
0.089784801,
-0.0179722104,
0.0015470736,
-0.0093046883,
0.074908562,
-0.0031615822,
-0.0044017583,
-0.0251955036,
0.0572880767,
0.0143306721,
-0.0202445406,
0.0187387615,
0.0492266193,
-0.0080201095,
-0.0092392638,
0.0220365822,
0.0730145946,
-0.0018538219,
0.0061079906,
0.0114944493,
-0.055293534,
0.0588782057,
0.0914233252,
0.0228436552,
-0.0641397312,
-0.0255792309,
-0.0253574718,
-0.0082233502,
-0.0587613359,
-0.0082174363,
0.0200296193,
-0.0211738143,
-0.0001574497,
-0.0377305672,
-0.0035032765,
0.0545777902,
0.0514253005,
0.0054289773,
0.0260896571,
0.0272933375,
0.0144798318,
-0.0427198708,
0.027959412,
-0.0216027945,
0.0323647447,
-0.0760350898,
-0.0408941023,
0.0265288409,
0.0194027014,
-0.0138513455,
0.0485532135,
-0.0769713819,
-0.0623430014,
0.0018326363,
0.047776226,
0.0203421563,
0.066064626,
-0.0069711138,
-0.0576989949,
0.0486394316,
0.0101531399,
0.0008302231,
0.0061604073,
0.0393160917,
-0.0125123961,
0.0137473177,
0.0359048061,
-0.0702076554,
-0.0245370641,
0.0325599685,
0.0221417304,
-0.0216142647,
0.0004259816,
0.0061275638,
-0.0115702571,
0.0192539152,
-0.0393901505,
0.0024566627,
-0.0016368872,
0.0462611243,
0.034959998,
-0.0150628146,
-0.0391588807,
0.009890792,
0.0162230916,
0.0172447991,
0.0048634005,
0.025472315,
0.0038852564,
0.0550561771,
-0.0395806544,
0.0090312371,
-0.0208585076,
0.0263894461,
0.0545378514,
0.0135933403,
-0.0425762273,
0.0353620388,
0.0090063661,
0.0319255777,
-0.0209589377,
0.0609057546,
0.0164069515,
0.0349720493,
-0.0288434587,
0.0201741513,
-0.054350473,
-0.0503339879,
-0.0379643366,
0.0231160503,
0.0657160059,
-0.046511367,
0.051295951,
-0.0317410752,
0.0112848375,
-0.0443745106,
0.0149801178,
0.0009163111,
-0.0447518304,
0.0107088219,
0.0358524472,
0.0034461096,
0.0018449265,
0.1051229462,
-0.0164338332,
0.0438528247,
0.0005568457,
0.0102640893,
-0.0496567488,
-0.0088195968,
0.0501343235,
0.0251940023,
-0.0263186004,
0.0090862298,
-0.0268947277,
-0.0661270469,
-0.0361779854,
-0.0115999281,
-0.0099735139,
-0.0156795196,
0.0531581789,
0.0669993758,
-0.0239570327,
-0.0232334509,
-0.038882643,
-0.0215595178,
0.0063587925,
-0.0103434045,
-0.0434456952,
-6.197433235e-33,
-0.0330405347,
0.0010846106,
0.0161629543,
0.0368276052,
0.0185741913,
0.0029187363,
-0.0294201076,
0.024177555,
-0.0018958695,
-0.0173904207,
-0.0274118055,
-0.0037498656,
0.0175095312,
0.0297943912,
-0.0013526474,
-0.0141849928,
0.0256448667,
-0.0076835291,
-0.0624560639,
0.0277284477,
0.021350788,
-0.0021555307,
0.0468659438,
-0.0670317039,
0.0065964195,
-0.004577179,
0.0052769571,
0.0156592522,
-0.0080504501,
0.0513089187,
0.0032280004,
0.040680483,
0.0114590954,
-0.0442786515,
-0.0515735894,
0.0030470949,
-0.0526213348,
-0.0253756866,
0.0284118205,
0.0337496325,
-0.0502474755,
-0.039040152,
0.045625098,
0.0015989272,
-0.0343470797,
0.0171016101,
0.0231064968,
-0.0068991799,
-0.035070952,
-0.0153237041,
-0.0551523343,
0.0087299617,
-0.0191247985,
-0.0327312164,
0.0061234599,
-0.0075669773,
0.0009504191,
-0.0104854712,
-0.0145504549,
0.0076288767,
-0.012146336,
0.0671639517,
0.0717759579,
0.0176251139,
0.007100665,
0.0304446071,
0.0059826588,
0.0116864452,
0.0458708256,
-0.0524030589,
0.0626945198,
0.0479622334,
0.008884606,
0.0252584014,
0.0350926556,
0.0094294352,
-0.0623495318,
0.0026977644,
0.0543820634,
0.0030949728,
0.0558974147,
0.0066851638,
-0.0536030903,
-0.0387035348,
-0.0529699437,
0.0157085937,
-0.0344274528,
-0.0036000835,
0.0568165854,
0.0235247668,
-0.0106795514,
-0.0025471041,
0.0592553951,
-0.0184788834,
-0.0170407034,
0.0182900894,
-0.0369708352,
0.0090669207,
0.009089251,
0.003645556,
-0.0851563662,
-0.0769559443,
-0.0075659091,
-0.0064564459,
0.0367348008,
0.0117052244,
0.0404620804,
0.0373584144,
-0.0929122642,
-0.0024268199,
-0.044676099,
0.0236018132,
0.0023159387,
0.0087244231,
0.0274500307,
-0.0198819544,
-0.0253464766,
0.0518274419,
0.0110150985,
-0.0526481159,
-0.045663178,
-0.0203718729,
-0.0297099836,
0.0153655056,
-0.0277350694,
-0.024134459,
-0.0293382723,
-0.0053448356,
0.0256234631,
-0.0272417441,
-0.0293060932,
0.020477334,
2.656e-7,
0.0207225196,
0.050460346,
-0.020984849,
0.0492639281,
0.0070428303,
0.0575670749,
-0.0409517996,
0.0042765508,
0.0013696321,
0.0275323112,
0.013208624,
0.0101901302,
0.0292789452,
0.0221622195,
-0.0917995274,
-0.0036388114,
-0.0410185196,
0.035390757,
-0.0307703465,
0.0079697529,
-0.002403375,
0.1041634828,
0.0071955649,
0.0045223627,
0.0024661529,
-0.0636654496,
0.0409092121,
-0.0627222434,
0.0075634974,
0.0423873477,
-0.0265367888,
0.0288949199,
-0.0064972644,
0.0320371203,
-0.0119952438,
0.0224062949,
-0.0074337767,
0.0705100745,
0.0210178569,
-0.0362942629,
-0.0099226395,
-0.0122369248,
0.0172756445,
-0.0654586628,
0.0690697059,
-0.0567671917,
-0.0094329938,
-0.017181132,
0.0259654392,
-0.0007255533,
0.0050570834,
0.0083096642,
-0.004664077,
0.0110998964,
0.0222704951,
-0.0174869932,
-0.0289157778,
-0.0643284246,
-0.0278912149,
0.0197118409,
-0.0286486484,
-0.0677106827,
-0.0573742278,
0.0137211941,
0.0135125034,
-0.0564730801,
0.0035860909,
2.960084416e-34,
0.0348338298,
-0.0076161991,
0.0355101936,
0.060700763,
-0.0082524894,
-0.007706421,
-0.0174296908,
0.0169344749,
0.0295317024,
-0.055190783,
-0.0228079092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06627v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06627v3 | Feedback Loops With Language Models Drive In-Context Reward Hacking | 2024-02-09T18:59:29 | 2024-06-06T21:39:09 | Alexander Pan, Erik Jones, Meena Jagadeesan, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Language models influence the external world: they query APIs that read and
write to web pages, generate content that shapes human behavior, and run system
commands as autonomous agents. These interactions form feedback loops: LLM
outputs affect the world, which in turn affect subsequent LLM outputs. In this
work, we show that feedback loops can cause in-context reward hacking (ICRH),
where the LLM at test-time optimizes a (potentially implicit) objective but
creates negative side effects in the process. For example, consider an LLM
agent deployed to increase Twitter engagement; the LLM may retrieve its
previous tweets into the context window and make them more controversial,
increasing engagement but also toxicity. We identify and study two processes
that lead to ICRH: output-refinement and policy-refinement. For these
processes, evaluations on static datasets are insufficient -- they miss the
feedback effects and thus cannot capture the most harmful behavior. In
response, we provide three recommendations for evaluation to capture more
instances of ICRH. As AI development accelerates, the effects of feedback loops
will proliferate, increasing the need to understand their role in shaping LLM
behavior. | [
0.0567397848,
0.0772750154,
-0.0345312394,
0.0205959417,
-0.0246161912,
-0.0227565523,
-0.0237606484,
0.0151601071,
0.0397225618,
-0.001577519,
-0.0303432215,
0.0385121368,
0.0159338731,
0.0588773042,
0.0279389136,
0.0035428142,
0.0402079374,
-0.0416823402,
0.0017394145,
0.0193656366,
0.0130894687,
0.0009008244,
0.0476999804,
0.0327608846,
-0.0084839528,
-0.0084595336,
0.0025720797,
0.0390598886,
0.0254795533,
-0.0142213013,
0.0017056273,
-0.000298346,
0.0164928492,
0.0380552486,
0.0000021512,
-0.0464539938,
-0.0208760183,
-0.0014063732,
-0.0034808903,
-0.0160844512,
0.058083415,
-0.0004134646,
-0.0057422938,
0.0197623558,
-0.0315459259,
0.0699339882,
0.0109335706,
0.019976588,
0.0570742972,
0.0739615858,
-0.0115793198,
0.0465583205,
0.0144278351,
0.005579398,
0.0351855792,
-0.0293213613,
0.0235516503,
-0.0413364843,
0.0008301219,
-0.0082918005,
-0.0032346223,
0.0181971863,
0.0154141486,
-0.0173711795,
-0.0124119055,
0.0053453785,
-0.0060651377,
-0.0309505705,
0.0214957353,
0.0287487507,
-0.0102022998,
-0.0056684338,
0.0340672322,
0.0101348422,
0.0324951485,
-0.0196133927,
0.0021224304,
0.0555204712,
-0.0155064687,
-0.01396723,
0.0521628372,
-0.0092846798,
0.0613426939,
0.0437695384,
0.005295922,
0.0532214344,
-0.0225183889,
-0.0445276536,
0.0017526302,
0.0066019013,
0.0508516319,
-0.05177949,
-0.0077048219,
0.0202735905,
-0.0590145253,
0.0145992711,
-0.0478734113,
-0.0002165144,
0.0090549188,
-0.0315837301,
0.0163151119,
0.0210533477,
-0.0178636536,
0.0323638581,
0.0205801819,
0.0064491159,
-0.0319567993,
0.0602695309,
-0.0017170429,
0.0317324698,
0.0021018123,
-0.0025751607,
0.0329876058,
0.0328181759,
0.0220754053,
0.0042288806,
-0.0159209035,
0.0754345804,
-0.0753644258,
0.0381466709,
-0.0441193171,
0.0143195046,
-0.0233207531,
0.036577899,
-0.0075175967,
-0.0520332828,
-0.0210738871,
0.0240947604,
0.0263752788,
-0.0270335115,
-0.0289881397,
-0.012510797,
-0.032065507,
-0.0001013783,
0.0070575657,
0.1358166635,
0.0384996459,
-0.0349290855,
-0.0700132251,
-0.1173772961,
0.0015356333,
-0.0292212479,
-0.0313803554,
-0.064346686,
-0.0136989113,
-0.0211774372,
-0.0249385294,
-0.0433672816,
0.0035860622,
-0.0126895746,
-0.0548240207,
0.0585275665,
-0.0072608194,
0.0057020891,
0.0127708735,
0.0614992715,
-0.0141959395,
0.0755452812,
0.0301144961,
0.0892592594,
0.0723461062,
0.0110371225,
0.0370048396,
0.0361764841,
0.0363670029,
0.0579019822,
-0.012197786,
-0.0042659948,
-0.0325502269,
-0.0089908345,
-0.0107548628,
0.0169388093,
-0.0174040738,
0.0309083648,
0.0952918306,
0.0425512828,
-0.0383574367,
-0.0356473923,
0.0082122004,
-0.0362876505,
-0.0517233238,
-0.0025097239,
-0.0341010578,
-0.0163887087,
-0.0414864905,
-0.030805761,
0.007385788,
0.0213583615,
-0.0198309198,
-0.021319041,
0.0409483425,
-0.0205994528,
0.0456170477,
0.0418861173,
0.0103297336,
0.0300209913,
-0.0199765991,
-0.0407255478,
0.0281625111,
-0.0242995862,
0.0244043488,
-0.0861962214,
0.0085836472,
0.1097064018,
0.0758624524,
-0.0380646177,
-0.0116848527,
-0.0399108566,
-0.0236871634,
0.0208355878,
-0.0057622693,
-0.034411516,
-0.0351192653,
0.044293236,
-0.0223147795,
-0.0092193177,
0.0223980863,
0.013119542,
0.0164286792,
0.0088165151,
-0.0317635201,
0.0168352518,
-0.0629209056,
0.0127265295,
-0.0028906919,
-0.0336084515,
-0.0130658681,
0.0315250754,
0.0281865802,
0.0240854938,
-0.0117624132,
-0.0003829307,
0.0403842032,
0.0082650892,
-0.0224184748,
0.0335648619,
0.0204011481,
0.0406216346,
0.0209600069,
-0.0143193798,
-0.029533552,
0.0461438224,
-0.0070978408,
0.0005933866,
0.0641876385,
-0.0286143348,
0.0465625115,
0.0187348947,
0.0075378632,
-0.0476712286,
-0.0050297249,
-0.0341680646,
0.0221788995,
-0.0374799669,
-0.0473730378,
-0.0028323226,
-0.0062384554,
-0.0350032635,
0.0143026728,
-0.0124491183,
0.002722593,
-0.0160038676,
0.026956005,
0.0640042499,
-0.0107252179,
-0.0504440255,
-0.0269936454,
-0.0244667809,
-0.0304325819,
-0.0380812287,
0.0116244201,
0.0327412523,
0.0221500061,
-0.0066074147,
0.0117179845,
0.0192984529,
-0.0215141885,
0.033711005,
0.0721409023,
0.0072406358,
0.0176967867,
-0.0261038076,
-0.0339296795,
0.0197573807,
-0.0325695165,
0.0169406589,
-0.0036603366,
0.0002079671,
-0.0430659018,
0.0036966957,
-0.0206466168,
-0.0020249998,
-0.0325380974,
-0.01429924,
0.0511897095,
0.0053150407,
-0.03332185,
0.1093105748,
0.0171851013,
0.095456779,
0.0396114253,
0.0049137301,
-0.0642431527,
-0.0355176255,
0.0083937561,
-0.0569337197,
-0.0435140058,
-0.032678239,
0.0154184299,
0.0436005145,
0.0132720424,
0.0027473052,
-0.0195508283,
0.0896998569,
-0.0502447896,
-0.0762166604,
-0.0254258662,
-0.0705426857,
-0.0411336534,
0.0453047976,
-0.0106442245,
-0.0800983161,
0.0673958287,
0.0187351666,
0.0422070809,
0.0123640411,
-0.0277744271,
-0.0134689584,
0.0412304997,
-0.0072887689,
0.0102183083,
0.0104069123,
-0.0255065225,
-0.025126867,
-0.0117350928,
0.0362371281,
-0.0407057218,
0.0525941774,
-0.0423839092,
-0.0183938276,
0.0096446257,
-0.049911391,
-0.0460470505,
-0.0424302258,
0.0043835416,
-0.0248140208,
0.0095220068,
-0.0255170781,
0.0204650536,
-0.0600017346,
0.066459842,
-0.0234554801,
-0.0275672209,
-0.0428235084,
-0.0162229352,
-0.0455573536,
0.055299744,
-0.04771097,
0.0069937757,
-0.0139550371,
-0.0096111568,
0.0456619747,
0.0161068719,
-0.0434634872,
0.0013060456,
0.0139938323,
0.0198198631,
-0.0142243216,
0.0393086672,
0.0311472509,
0.0362329967,
-0.0454387031,
-0.0319727324,
0.0500652902,
0.0305767152,
-0.060932111,
0.0487979054,
-0.0032406175,
0.0029835347,
0.0176295638,
0.0201514438,
-0.0793449581,
0.0176687408,
0.0176793486,
0.0404912829,
-0.0712715313,
-0.0460041091,
0.0072187204,
-0.1189181432,
0.0118381102,
-0.0027940595,
-0.0078768525,
0.0024782382,
-0.0617871135,
-0.021861067,
-0.0216783918,
-0.0085436972,
0.0016471659,
0.0104966611,
-0.014841699,
0.0014252641,
0.0248870812,
-0.0200163405,
0.0151213752,
-0.0464533605,
0.0454253107,
0.0881553665,
0.0028828948,
-0.0429338105,
0.0203483868,
0.0554048754,
0.0380381159,
0.0120202927,
-0.0044448553,
0.0340050496,
0.0062988796,
-0.0034202512,
0.0016034894,
0.0426771007,
-0.0227703676,
-0.0078412583,
-0.0032291592,
0.0417868048,
-0.0054098982,
-0.0169394258,
-0.0230548456,
-0.0318405069,
0.0625841022,
0.0245898068,
0.0101568494,
-0.0693835691,
-0.0214594342,
-0.0581838004,
-0.0446794853,
-0.0301778559,
-0.0901309699,
-0.0425028093,
0.0174380224,
-0.0261150226,
-0.0523283556,
-0.0537733622,
-0.0365794189,
-0.0252996217,
0.0366184041,
-0.0136384554,
-0.0436994061,
0.0254284814,
0.0081104655,
0.0083625838,
-0.0019455201,
0.0325824544,
0.013757498,
0.0028911235,
-0.0307763387,
-0.0189188868,
-0.0054750033,
0.0195785612,
-0.0495670885,
-0.0785789564,
0.0240863673,
0.0926636904,
0.0258947816,
0.0747236982,
-0.0093991077,
-0.005989844,
0.0516759157,
0.0525236391,
-0.0375165567,
0.0398712829,
0.0603057444,
0.0414560139,
0.0174455792,
0.016696943,
-0.0722801462,
-0.0163109265,
0.0721750259,
-0.0337013826,
-0.0499814004,
0.0405538604,
0.0183024947,
0.0007983734,
0.0051636361,
-0.0407574587,
-0.0227025785,
0.0044663106,
-0.0163466316,
-0.0197299477,
-0.0361151621,
0.0136122461,
-0.0130969547,
0.0115540083,
0.0016212394,
-0.0096384566,
-0.0065487041,
-0.0219962019,
0.0129271913,
-0.0364957862,
0.023537891,
0.0081988918,
0.0474807844,
0.0398838595,
0.0309670251,
-0.021002613,
0.0351200998,
-0.0059923744,
0.032631062,
-0.0142221507,
-0.002941242,
0.0087997615,
0.0106975259,
0.0104702078,
0.0623039305,
-0.0504389033,
-0.0303092133,
0.0294836443,
0.0030901977,
0.0215299539,
-0.0054481309,
0.0297668818,
-0.0098135406,
0.008783916,
-0.0061278506,
-0.0271877386,
-0.0365036316,
-0.0488363802,
-0.0319275819,
0.0009372061,
-0.0104053039,
0.0136204632,
0.0741457641,
-0.0286320969,
0.0727550089,
0.0188242905,
-0.0021208352,
-0.0061760172,
-0.0108627547,
0.0199296642,
0.0117124673,
-0.0180820953,
-0.0349013954,
-0.0530850589,
-0.084345594,
-0.0175395794,
0.0126772216,
0.0220264774,
0.001698409,
-0.026436476,
0.0369843766,
0.0123782149,
0.0280132033,
-0.0558859259,
-0.0203552768,
-0.0384220853,
-0.0649700239,
0.001629488,
-6.34078624e-33,
0.0336071663,
-0.0665527359,
-0.0098908516,
0.046980273,
-0.0267428365,
0.0053944052,
-0.0327170976,
0.0082680862,
-0.0085923113,
-0.0269588809,
-0.0290015433,
0.006313371,
-0.0027076961,
-0.0188791454,
0.0147692673,
-0.0475458615,
0.0159562528,
-0.0013781914,
-0.0421191305,
0.063394174,
0.0390705615,
0.0198808741,
0.0053134821,
-0.1180425212,
0.0669485778,
0.0080012102,
-0.0345063545,
0.0142885922,
-0.0146934027,
0.0260764994,
0.0201400723,
0.0675865784,
0.0103128189,
-0.0519487076,
0.0136521561,
0.0167843364,
0.0030760181,
-0.0364194736,
0.0187798031,
-0.0165464785,
-0.0437468588,
-0.0698243529,
0.0354246534,
0.0001903352,
-0.0331060402,
0.0144665679,
0.0160937328,
-0.0046910183,
0.0085592093,
-0.0047793444,
-0.070239827,
-0.0111640366,
-0.0329273529,
0.0102474084,
-0.0185264852,
0.0292405132,
0.0243591182,
0.0477998443,
-0.056759581,
0.0536556318,
0.0104576601,
-0.0111032221,
0.0646815225,
0.0013299442,
0.0198221374,
0.0527522899,
-0.0086802859,
0.087762706,
-0.0262913462,
-0.0151137942,
0.0119685214,
0.0288600065,
0.0133519256,
0.0475507267,
0.007075056,
-0.0768166184,
-0.0293630995,
0.0017725542,
0.009786047,
0.0178336017,
0.051416941,
-0.0228227377,
-0.0508247018,
-0.0057540177,
-0.0151730431,
-0.0357918218,
-0.0426103845,
-0.0331079178,
0.0133231645,
0.0328896791,
-0.0148353726,
-0.0384962149,
-0.0031048851,
-0.0777071789,
0.0160246044,
0.0165561792,
-0.0159756374,
-0.0262665115,
0.0090472689,
-0.0342658907,
-0.0347889774,
0.0144248269,
-0.0365517363,
-0.0113655124,
0.060642004,
0.0154838637,
0.0253529307,
0.0418658815,
-0.0192592479,
0.0021637178,
-0.0376113765,
0.0736214072,
0.0149555979,
-0.0267185681,
0.0304658357,
-0.0000587093,
-0.0092259748,
0.0031143697,
0.0620729402,
0.0225526709,
-0.0469354987,
0.0251425039,
-0.0310523212,
0.0040740874,
-0.027930608,
-0.0032289436,
-0.0159657877,
0.078635022,
0.0302775651,
-0.1089109033,
-0.0122537008,
-0.0707494542,
3.024e-7,
-0.0185790267,
0.0580412857,
-0.0106339278,
0.0501988307,
0.0492248312,
0.0697787106,
0.017307017,
0.0513298176,
0.0082029058,
-0.0441608168,
-0.0035452689,
0.002017918,
0.0235232264,
0.0444207154,
-0.0284427609,
-0.0011628817,
-0.0519502908,
0.0044864942,
-0.0514043048,
-0.0068448363,
0.0072122109,
0.0237522032,
0.0206151716,
-0.0484645627,
-0.0000642554,
-0.0325943306,
0.0106066745,
-0.0438582636,
-0.0068168896,
-0.0001686317,
-0.0041198726,
0.0408960842,
0.0072366474,
0.0071763769,
-0.0374730788,
-0.0041484656,
-0.0678194985,
0.0044049216,
-0.003473975,
-0.0580320619,
-0.0347570069,
-0.044096157,
0.021627022,
-0.0539545976,
0.0579348281,
0.0007181527,
-0.020613974,
-0.0419480279,
0.0591892079,
-0.0529744849,
0.0246006157,
-0.0293170344,
-0.0011228082,
0.0083744302,
-0.0111021567,
0.0582045354,
0.0169274323,
-0.0697235912,
-0.0225672573,
-0.0256283619,
-0.0183116533,
-0.0674743652,
0.0066166706,
0.0621184036,
-0.0331680365,
-0.0237603635,
0.03103319,
3.020165723e-34,
-0.0064798994,
-0.0390489697,
0.0415726714,
-0.0051479712,
0.0065457211,
0.0432643555,
-0.0167755559,
-7.55e-8,
0.0283989348,
0.0013622748,
-0.0381377935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06625v1 | Understanding the Effects of Iterative Prompting on Truthfulness | 2024-02-09T18:57:08 | 2024-02-09T18:57:08 | Satyapriya Krishna, Chirag Agarwal, Himabindu Lakkaraju | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has notably transformed
numerous sectors, offering impressive text generation capabilities. Yet, the
reliability and truthfulness of these models remain pressing concerns. To this
end, we investigate iterative prompting, a strategy hypothesized to refine LLM
responses, assessing its impact on LLM truthfulness, an area which has not been
thoroughly explored. Our extensive experiments delve into the intricacies of
iterative prompting variants, examining their influence on the accuracy and
calibration of model responses. Our findings reveal that naive prompting
methods significantly undermine truthfulness, leading to exacerbated
calibration errors. In response to these challenges, we introduce several
prompting variants designed to address the identified issues. These variants
demonstrate marked improvements over existing baselines, signaling a promising
direction for future research. Our work provides a nuanced understanding of
iterative prompting and introduces novel approaches to enhance the truthfulness
of LLMs, thereby contributing to the development of more accurate and
trustworthy AI systems. | [
0.0645848811,
0.070581466,
-0.0239514373,
0.0288800523,
-0.0680719018,
-0.0160491448,
0.0313849598,
0.0001258778,
0.0041071619,
-0.0195326041,
-0.0214712042,
-0.058417663,
0.0526379049,
0.0259898175,
0.0128838299,
0.0047104829,
0.038460318,
-0.0419185534,
0.0114395674,
-0.0148452511,
0.0003587974,
0.0306851193,
-0.0111945802,
0.0486555211,
-0.0484882705,
-0.0054582902,
-0.0359299295,
0.0232797265,
-0.0083936742,
-0.018154921,
-0.0015560786,
0.064958699,
-0.0128686791,
0.0574482679,
0.0000022264,
-0.0538083538,
-0.0106953569,
-0.0106076067,
-0.0570668839,
0.0391986929,
0.0310258307,
-0.0101027237,
0.0159361865,
0.0246723238,
-0.034257371,
0.0429618992,
0.0511628017,
0.0103787286,
0.038035132,
0.0698974282,
0.0151572302,
0.0555317737,
0.0127162533,
-0.0190161895,
0.0024835707,
-0.0022511757,
-0.0020383864,
-0.0046598958,
-0.0078540454,
0.0239472333,
0.0058985292,
0.0248453319,
0.0309060011,
-0.0130490717,
0.0017101241,
0.036523845,
-0.0021225624,
-0.0654645339,
-0.0381707288,
0.013590306,
0.047929693,
-0.030199809,
-0.0122318743,
-0.0351558551,
-0.0150637422,
-0.0113757402,
-0.010262073,
0.0555642135,
-0.0147437425,
0.0029420701,
0.0215854105,
0.0310159922,
0.0085349921,
0.0176633019,
0.0163309537,
0.0549362302,
0.0023565076,
-0.0427463688,
-0.0130801294,
0.0193516482,
0.026329251,
-0.1159873381,
-0.0144479396,
0.0085266307,
-0.0627967343,
0.0212470125,
-0.0724054277,
0.0136827314,
0.0591690615,
0.0257200133,
0.04376873,
0.0402308553,
-0.0281578414,
-0.0268102139,
0.0035741271,
0.0668976679,
0.0161401499,
0.0135752102,
-0.0592846759,
0.0437934808,
0.0114439214,
-0.0296403859,
-0.0174534842,
-0.0027514366,
-0.0296803918,
-0.014949521,
-0.0436205789,
0.0246325843,
0.001025338,
0.0302391369,
-0.0316596664,
0.0124727199,
-0.0443523861,
0.0095052263,
-0.0366271101,
0.0071146465,
-0.0578302555,
0.0406739414,
0.0676194206,
-0.089250803,
-0.0228848848,
0.0221541189,
-0.0205433313,
-0.009903294,
-0.0148806237,
0.0202292502,
-0.0155193536,
-0.0229598116,
-0.0276113003,
-0.0666241348,
-0.0374505632,
-0.0928303376,
-0.0004111069,
-0.0648472384,
0.0279459395,
0.0060201315,
-0.0296382681,
-0.0230756961,
0.0099122263,
0.0338986069,
-0.021210894,
0.0332705788,
-0.020596277,
0.0249155574,
0.0030083959,
0.0016284657,
-0.0345975235,
0.0439462103,
0.0287308171,
0.0492951535,
0.0422079563,
0.014786548,
0.0175163541,
0.0074853105,
0.0286174249,
0.0352998115,
0.0034523983,
-0.004250898,
-0.0079958225,
0.0315904394,
0.0357001312,
0.0818387493,
-0.0244201943,
0.0155820027,
0.102770485,
0.0212989897,
-0.0220289398,
0.0120528666,
0.0510420837,
0.0130603323,
0.0184071846,
0.0766672865,
-0.0733920038,
0.0152850775,
-0.0498811789,
0.0328108817,
0.0452371873,
0.0202100202,
-0.006347463,
-0.0550928004,
-0.0106191505,
0.0020457623,
0.0112799872,
0.0192681365,
-0.0169696175,
0.0024559647,
-0.0427632779,
0.0039874199,
0.0187101904,
-0.0801216438,
0.0000791448,
-0.0763355941,
0.071300976,
0.0716754273,
0.0487172604,
0.0263665225,
-0.014730393,
0.0016992154,
0.0238255076,
0.0594187193,
0.0625151247,
0.0061139958,
0.0056942166,
-0.036155507,
-0.0017914276,
-0.0159749407,
0.0166542511,
0.0317178294,
0.0201520231,
-0.0126490993,
0.0357287228,
-0.0277640987,
-0.0226598457,
0.0453594513,
-0.0286677703,
-0.0227040295,
0.0071296049,
-0.0044905893,
-0.003163334,
0.0018668059,
-0.017798692,
0.0367801711,
0.0201392639,
0.0120309079,
-0.0087345615,
-0.0062602963,
-0.0794733986,
-0.0189053807,
0.0179173071,
0.0140189109,
-0.0025049713,
-0.0034879758,
-0.0045522032,
-0.0251629315,
-0.0336683765,
-0.0373697393,
-0.0011558881,
-0.046657566,
0.0377673693,
-0.0078135496,
0.0099098291,
-0.0415897705,
0.039068073,
-0.0133943819,
0.0069970614,
0.049648948,
0.0149799008,
-0.0099768573,
-0.0399506092,
-0.0113483798,
-0.0081095621,
-0.0034283749,
0.0221011601,
0.0539161004,
0.0275917128,
-0.0362994745,
-0.037231341,
-0.0890734866,
0.0019553227,
-0.0268559307,
0.0017072371,
0.016910892,
-0.0184378214,
-0.0230653863,
0.0381203964,
-0.0603664964,
-0.0263061784,
0.0521623716,
0.0279481243,
0.0284864139,
-0.0195471346,
-0.0052448218,
-0.0395341106,
0.012996899,
-0.0186561756,
0.0130396541,
0.0296398755,
-0.0082718432,
-0.0602600984,
0.0243214164,
-0.0560680665,
-0.0050089918,
-0.0003686192,
-0.028197661,
0.0311237182,
0.0226422604,
0.0488682613,
0.0371393971,
0.0351105593,
0.0138018215,
0.0421174951,
0.0178350899,
-0.0640078187,
0.0013495542,
-0.0119653167,
-0.0351304151,
0.0152552342,
-0.0865805596,
0.0315228105,
0.0261890981,
0.0615891069,
0.0131539144,
-0.053324163,
0.0263565537,
-0.0154957389,
-0.0754023939,
0.0259960964,
-0.0430837981,
-0.0227667429,
0.0739258155,
-0.0232061371,
-0.0817289427,
0.0797226876,
-0.0708278641,
0.0060787513,
-0.0105632739,
0.0227783378,
0.007303745,
0.0388974249,
0.0021464685,
0.0251457728,
0.0700651035,
0.0199405067,
-0.0441730693,
-0.0017171876,
0.0195278339,
-0.0413334891,
0.0487648398,
-0.0534928478,
-0.0005638359,
0.0092588123,
-0.0419154093,
-0.0770035237,
-0.0702083185,
-0.0032961981,
-0.0090393061,
-0.0269501451,
-0.0058395616,
0.0015502973,
-0.029334493,
0.0340393074,
0.0262038615,
-0.0419802107,
-0.0176298469,
-0.0238486156,
0.0203001089,
0.0642486513,
0.0132508371,
0.0702554658,
-0.0369623974,
0.0406114161,
0.0543831512,
0.0144766122,
0.0779849663,
-0.0200873185,
-0.0012187916,
0.017286934,
-0.0085807592,
-0.0185121503,
0.0591669902,
0.0716966316,
-0.0340102464,
-0.0372544713,
0.1137574986,
0.0237716809,
0.002375152,
0.0304883216,
-0.0418600887,
0.0788383707,
-0.0028365813,
0.0118939998,
-0.0972509161,
-0.023017738,
0.0170877445,
0.0295339562,
-0.0600223765,
-0.0165821984,
-0.0199045073,
-0.1261653453,
0.0534225665,
0.0114764869,
-0.0034480342,
-0.0210047401,
-0.0232039224,
-0.0121451337,
0.0346335471,
0.0444323644,
0.0302737206,
0.002394682,
0.0136525184,
0.0241531823,
0.0137632713,
-0.0330943391,
0.0077558835,
-0.0336695127,
0.0663330257,
0.0841546655,
0.0104870545,
-0.0077966857,
-0.0504765064,
0.0038105461,
0.0294932649,
0.0170415826,
0.0027636318,
0.020327827,
0.0128405802,
0.0151842143,
-0.0101431152,
0.0275601726,
-0.0055667516,
-0.0197205152,
0.0245290641,
0.0256103687,
-0.0182271469,
-0.0294615719,
-0.0155870402,
0.0292815994,
0.0314421393,
0.0820763335,
0.0500604026,
-0.0440954007,
-0.0097885979,
-0.0190241337,
0.035617698,
-0.0308110453,
0.0007415547,
0.0381221622,
0.0097286068,
0.0025567568,
-0.0967665911,
-0.0404568538,
-0.0141021991,
0.0209063403,
-0.0025961921,
-0.0559662431,
-0.0047866954,
-0.032924857,
-0.0059547904,
0.0262019671,
-0.0366364531,
0.0289950445,
-0.0412450917,
0.0034243183,
-0.0196111798,
-0.0587132573,
0.0174506716,
0.045200143,
-0.0853668451,
-0.0647048429,
-0.0075510549,
0.0554773994,
0.0261413082,
0.051797431,
0.0172460936,
-0.0100878868,
0.0248991679,
0.0214756392,
-0.0144222677,
0.0545246787,
0.0156519003,
0.0233363491,
-0.0076545407,
0.0373299085,
-0.0132260723,
-0.0028808787,
0.020039767,
0.0437619947,
0.0207816102,
-0.0763620809,
0.0478894897,
0.0601573922,
0.0103202313,
-0.0379248075,
0.0449518301,
-0.0293968581,
0.0050486214,
-0.0231287032,
-0.0380730368,
-0.0360209085,
0.0060727173,
0.0096898377,
0.016356241,
0.0001506759,
-0.0534380525,
-0.0517587699,
0.0433008298,
-0.0669547766,
-0.0238896273,
-0.0187227484,
0.0349362791,
0.0253773555,
-0.0125800595,
-0.047779493,
0.0487849154,
-0.0371220335,
0.0349498019,
0.0091575785,
0.0637308359,
0.0067773587,
-0.0196304508,
-0.0118483473,
0.0256386809,
-0.0513330065,
-0.0408762544,
-0.0221343711,
0.0344555005,
0.0163091123,
0.0100283902,
0.0455732122,
-0.0459829271,
0.0270343479,
-0.0121488785,
0.0065901945,
0.048262544,
-0.0606986098,
0.0021403972,
-0.008488141,
-0.0268589202,
-0.0114106098,
0.049427513,
-0.0333918519,
0.0344499163,
-0.0167475995,
-0.0039824462,
-0.0266498402,
-0.057447657,
-0.00017605,
-0.0017594099,
-0.0230758451,
-0.0285900254,
-0.0539439693,
-0.0530107357,
0.021584658,
0.0296430886,
0.0276743695,
-0.0470168851,
0.0241991878,
0.0659601688,
-0.0139965303,
-0.0133847492,
-0.0453325436,
-0.0055192471,
-0.0242422894,
0.0012294861,
-0.0583640411,
-6.675976985e-33,
-0.0146278832,
-0.0376220047,
0.0140663981,
-0.040809609,
-0.0194783174,
0.0282572061,
-0.0310297441,
0.0152834654,
-0.0093183871,
-0.0105036106,
-0.0443655774,
-0.0164090581,
0.0274394285,
0.0186705962,
0.0101728067,
-0.0077139097,
0.0565041453,
0.0038709133,
-0.0866449252,
0.004538239,
0.0026464183,
-0.0293280464,
0.0214882772,
-0.0345311649,
0.0608773306,
-0.0016266791,
-0.0712624267,
0.0079627614,
-0.0677669793,
0.0438595302,
-0.0095683662,
0.043178644,
0.0079053249,
-0.0115376171,
-0.020198876,
0.0445385166,
-0.0162446424,
-0.0255771857,
0.0382348932,
-0.009176922,
-0.0481052957,
-0.0226373672,
0.0240021795,
-0.0377185531,
-0.029257793,
0.0178416781,
-0.0092770383,
-0.0083788279,
-0.0142239556,
-0.0336662456,
-0.0636515543,
0.0013831969,
0.000021243,
-0.0465156771,
-0.0482092984,
0.1015838161,
-0.0156903639,
-0.0027087969,
-0.0562248789,
0.0201014616,
0.0497021824,
0.0245269835,
0.0696661696,
0.0096333483,
-0.0176153742,
0.0568126515,
0.00605103,
0.0327414423,
-0.0326056629,
0.0056086159,
0.0143187847,
0.0100780586,
0.0471103825,
0.0675455481,
-0.000406552,
-0.0391591564,
-0.0251929294,
0.0235692691,
0.0271942914,
-0.0270722378,
0.0436801873,
-0.0335859582,
-0.0505137667,
-0.0238618106,
-0.0615778267,
-0.0217771214,
-0.0319799073,
-0.0189469699,
0.0512936376,
0.0230512917,
-0.0364160873,
-0.0349854641,
0.018073801,
-0.0184989758,
0.0098288544,
0.0061489497,
-0.0488545075,
0.006508268,
-0.0242734645,
0.0358463153,
-0.047609549,
-0.0218287986,
0.0030111182,
0.0207141731,
0.0157156195,
0.0282900501,
0.0083700558,
0.0192612875,
-0.0414697677,
0.0398449302,
-0.0368773229,
0.066363439,
0.0191060659,
-0.0478039496,
0.0394404754,
-0.0359679423,
-0.0335298069,
0.0200444218,
-0.0046727262,
-0.0133928629,
-0.0678426996,
0.016035337,
-0.0166763309,
0.0398318768,
-0.0401518419,
0.0058945422,
-0.0310198218,
-0.0054489961,
0.0120415371,
-0.0255091432,
-0.0191738326,
0.001886404,
2.794e-7,
-0.0342343487,
0.0234690346,
0.0341493189,
0.0277330596,
-0.0185249131,
0.0480454974,
0.0097523304,
0.0305790082,
0.0117589002,
-0.034550529,
0.0042494265,
-0.0020415529,
0.0556340441,
0.034153223,
-0.0393886492,
-0.000930062,
-0.0852031782,
0.0198536478,
-0.0508924536,
0.0058626425,
0.0533797219,
0.0587248504,
-0.0009037305,
-0.0305926427,
0.009088451,
-0.0340823792,
0.0461444557,
-0.0030126974,
-0.0125628002,
0.0254025199,
0.0293915085,
-0.0325764306,
0.0226352513,
0.0216307212,
0.0034792654,
0.0037818693,
-0.0280080829,
0.0572708584,
0.0211917832,
-0.0277469624,
-0.0123969978,
-0.023967078,
0.0133071775,
-0.0786620975,
0.0525775999,
-0.0122010233,
0.0213653855,
-0.0673841238,
0.0196277611,
-0.0165475123,
0.0277138818,
-0.041310966,
-0.0398383662,
0.0455937944,
0.0042753848,
0.0302509218,
-0.0034797592,
-0.0122503601,
-0.0544068888,
-0.0270711537,
-0.0420257673,
-0.0568456501,
-0.0284618326,
0.0296516921,
0.0041142781,
-0.0727232248,
0.0145097524,
2.639994319e-34,
0.0193992984,
-0.0245494526,
0.0348563008,
0.0232107583,
0.0513854139,
0.0256072767,
-0.009031374,
0.0192783028,
0.0164419692,
-0.0414234884,
-0.0570253022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06619v1 | Aya Dataset: An Open-Access Collection for Multilingual Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-09T18:51:49 | 2024-02-09T18:51:49 | Shivalika Singh, Freddie Vargus, Daniel Dsouza, Börje F. Karlsson, Abinaya Mahendiran, Wei-Yin Ko, Herumb Shandilya, Jay Patel, Deividas Mataciunas, Laura OMahony, Mike Zhang, Ramith Hettiarachchi, Joseph Wilson, Marina Machado, Luisa Souza Moura, Dominik Krzemiński, Hakimeh Fadaei, Irem Ergün, Ifeoma Okoh, Aisha Alaagib, Oshan Mudannayake, Zaid Alyafeai, Vu Minh Chien, Sebastian Ruder, Surya Guthikonda, Emad A. Alghamdi, Sebastian Gehrmann, Niklas Muennighoff, Max Bartolo, Julia Kreutzer, Ahmet Üstün, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Datasets are foundational to many breakthroughs in modern artificial
intelligence. Many recent achievements in the space of natural language
processing (NLP) can be attributed to the finetuning of pre-trained models on a
diverse set of tasks that enables a large language model (LLM) to respond to
instructions. Instruction fine-tuning (IFT) requires specifically constructed
and annotated datasets. However, existing datasets are almost all in the
English language. In this work, our primary goal is to bridge the language gap
by building a human-curated instruction-following dataset spanning 65
languages. We worked with fluent speakers of languages from around the world to
collect natural instances of instructions and completions. Furthermore, we
create the most extensive multilingual collection to date, comprising 513
million instances through templating and translating existing datasets across
114 languages. In total, we contribute four key resources: we develop and
open-source the Aya Annotation Platform, the Aya Dataset, the Aya Collection,
and the Aya Evaluation Suite. The Aya initiative also serves as a valuable case
study in participatory research, involving collaborators from 119 countries. We
see this as a valuable framework for future research collaborations that aim to
bridge gaps in resources. | [
0.0338280015,
0.0433882028,
-0.0194313973,
0.049492009,
-0.0145685133,
0.0367212221,
0.0295890458,
-0.0537622347,
0.0077605448,
-0.0107738962,
-0.0565503575,
-0.0057292595,
0.014436732,
-0.0202644598,
0.0273954719,
-0.059195701,
0.0396541096,
-0.0358599275,
-0.0251384936,
-0.0086662313,
0.0115048662,
0.0418864004,
-0.0421939604,
0.0684185028,
0.0102270981,
-0.005774349,
-0.0137013448,
0.006370598,
-0.0066515557,
-0.0327445157,
0.0459510982,
0.0667192563,
0.0013343288,
0.0177154616,
0.0000020401,
-0.0320415907,
0.0267359819,
-0.0419088341,
-0.028874984,
0.0114721833,
0.02907064,
-0.0251639951,
0.0047810567,
-0.0023490211,
-0.0312684663,
-0.0083614998,
0.0561799258,
-0.0203411579,
0.0735910237,
0.0652786419,
0.0267227273,
-0.0119212987,
0.005733659,
-0.0267322939,
-0.0099283215,
-0.0139715634,
-0.0098207276,
-0.017833896,
0.0330308005,
0.0026661807,
-0.0259825606,
0.0446957313,
0.0367281698,
-0.0147937275,
-0.034537375,
-0.0184069611,
-0.0424557254,
-0.0570726655,
-0.0247500706,
0.1023122445,
0.0240466874,
-0.0248845834,
-0.0107500106,
-0.0171972495,
-0.0071280804,
-0.0056591993,
-0.0333664119,
0.0528854914,
0.0036455824,
0.0164099503,
0.0447050445,
-0.026108548,
0.0086065,
0.0240538325,
0.0491780713,
0.0715733841,
0.000322459,
-0.0039459956,
0.0024239586,
0.0373287648,
-0.0168377291,
-0.045230329,
0.0224506743,
0.0171780121,
-0.036645472,
0.015406183,
-0.0603663959,
-0.0243609976,
0.0497040041,
-0.0235931259,
0.0775615647,
0.0488065705,
-0.049916625,
0.0412527062,
0.0081314594,
0.0190611966,
0.0057689128,
0.0492448173,
-0.0408515111,
0.0057353727,
-0.0369262137,
0.0187614206,
-0.0392471962,
-0.0040485491,
-0.0636637062,
0.0290656853,
-0.039078109,
0.0023602745,
-0.0282251388,
0.0172066446,
0.0314111188,
-0.0176743157,
-0.0612796545,
0.0090847481,
-0.0004742725,
0.0248758253,
-0.075021483,
0.0422022231,
-0.0006429217,
-0.0559315607,
-0.001729266,
0.0005586396,
0.0050823092,
-0.0205604322,
0.0511511192,
0.0380966291,
0.003931175,
-0.0202603582,
-0.0418564714,
-0.0310125053,
0.0153828468,
-0.0783095434,
-0.0032874139,
-0.0715500191,
0.0596693531,
-0.0037432155,
0.0210697558,
-0.0424561575,
0.0022916927,
0.0354550891,
0.001428981,
0.0666771829,
-0.0108145783,
-0.0088253245,
0.0068005882,
-0.0038223066,
0.019867504,
0.0735072568,
0.0326200239,
-0.0011757306,
0.0900573879,
-0.0189198293,
-0.0060483497,
0.0479120016,
0.0163466185,
0.0085614296,
0.0295076426,
0.0066982652,
-0.0255460348,
-0.0022369924,
0.0112414034,
0.0040020039,
-0.0106918337,
0.0033296065,
0.0288693924,
0.0246983953,
-0.0392212681,
-0.006196009,
0.0860153213,
0.0299551785,
0.0124212429,
-0.0021511922,
-0.0507069938,
0.023252124,
-0.0086914143,
0.0036134354,
0.0056392173,
0.0349421985,
-0.0435313955,
-0.0502344221,
0.0152315889,
-0.0088890577,
0.0105194747,
0.0177788548,
0.0332399905,
0.0207353123,
-0.0229077246,
-0.001549287,
0.0641355067,
-0.0795983151,
0.0417409241,
-0.0067773429,
0.0231419187,
0.0728363916,
0.0083900187,
-0.0356422625,
-0.0610127822,
0.0098874858,
0.0637092963,
0.040573623,
0.023743581,
-0.0442114435,
0.0438112095,
-0.0771129578,
-0.0198260751,
-0.0122189298,
-0.0010325767,
0.0110074431,
0.0362757817,
-0.0083193742,
-0.0139218429,
-0.005915395,
-0.0538153388,
0.0554602034,
-0.0516346842,
-0.0311214831,
-0.0152183147,
0.0232204795,
0.022912398,
0.0531667918,
0.0077140047,
-0.0044586384,
0.04800722,
-0.00950961,
0.0366807878,
0.0107628554,
-0.0253157299,
-0.0195637587,
0.0133977523,
-0.0507296957,
-0.0249267183,
0.0324614868,
-0.0643472821,
-0.0412303209,
-0.0057291598,
-0.0137741566,
-0.0045642885,
-0.0105462037,
0.0207027607,
0.0035961522,
0.005863219,
-0.0002496732,
-0.0032284351,
-0.0144470101,
0.0498464331,
0.0403456166,
-0.0202007629,
0.0061273379,
-0.0212226976,
-0.0341043361,
0.0197552163,
-0.0083849784,
0.0176633317,
0.046587538,
0.0811462402,
-0.0695463195,
0.0069739241,
-0.0933096632,
0.0255087819,
-0.0275464002,
0.0323191658,
0.0307650305,
0.0116990069,
-0.0186633877,
-0.0379857458,
-0.0045663435,
-0.0266226381,
0.0015679643,
0.0228270609,
0.0202777777,
0.0256384183,
-0.0161911324,
-0.0457758941,
-0.0371107943,
0.0211354326,
-0.0149531206,
0.0121000204,
-0.0122860698,
-0.0553740077,
-0.0184291154,
-0.0037597001,
0.029243933,
0.0155933453,
-0.0774539635,
0.0234898254,
0.0389152095,
0.0096404459,
0.084503144,
-0.024159072,
0.0045477245,
0.0357298441,
-0.0174251217,
-0.065465413,
0.0210109595,
-0.0297626127,
-0.0401329137,
-0.039655447,
-0.0363389775,
-0.0194568131,
0.077519916,
-0.0172949973,
-0.0084076039,
-0.0754473507,
-0.0083371662,
-0.0408384725,
-0.0282750595,
-0.0286903158,
0.0226086508,
-0.0054143672,
0.027277885,
-0.038409777,
-0.0289149322,
0.0862619206,
-0.0261955392,
-0.0152043216,
-0.0611872226,
0.0066654291,
-0.0156556237,
0.0357478708,
-0.0014883264,
0.0021920912,
-0.0268342104,
-0.0250304863,
-0.0449171998,
0.0337482691,
0.0300832819,
-0.005946795,
0.0207143556,
-0.0951561183,
-0.0206338707,
0.0003201582,
-0.0391136333,
-0.0089200307,
-0.0181143712,
-0.0319138654,
-0.0059054517,
0.0260962378,
-0.0278580319,
-0.0297890101,
-0.0458045937,
0.0252343006,
0.061245393,
0.0016638115,
0.0167952944,
-0.0382912979,
-0.0315378197,
0.0204547979,
-0.0009246038,
-0.0153520545,
-0.0248343516,
0.0072304877,
0.0408959761,
0.030656172,
-0.0156277101,
0.0340709947,
0.0312196407,
0.0737397596,
-0.0364873372,
-0.0228598285,
0.0196649712,
0.0763863176,
-0.0794018656,
-0.0260706954,
0.0898527578,
0.0236757752,
-0.0513978563,
0.0113828154,
-0.0129533214,
0.0253256634,
0.0345559902,
0.0115443571,
-0.1187689304,
-0.0445110463,
-0.0118118552,
0.0485105105,
-0.0071245325,
-0.0061335904,
0.0004549387,
-0.1128974259,
0.0283391606,
0.0097419275,
-0.0411727242,
-0.011131973,
-0.0306001771,
-0.0030080769,
-0.0326784626,
0.0230950993,
-0.0150076281,
-0.0124758733,
-0.0017404794,
0.0330652669,
-0.003450711,
-0.0729100183,
0.0457094535,
-0.0360963419,
0.0778759867,
0.0381940417,
0.0202702526,
-0.0030210502,
-0.0197865404,
0.0180080645,
-0.009272025,
-0.0243849978,
-0.018419439,
0.0349575579,
0.0045201378,
-0.0311861113,
0.0032894032,
0.066257596,
-0.0507107563,
-0.0086837225,
0.0323022902,
0.0491187051,
0.0105359918,
0.0365839265,
0.0053655002,
0.0053524459,
0.0265578832,
0.0496462658,
0.0309482515,
-0.075022988,
-0.0036651141,
-0.0264108144,
-0.0205811709,
-0.0973317847,
-0.019099813,
0.0374832228,
-0.0842761993,
-0.0066712867,
-0.0607875958,
-0.0889433026,
0.0874442384,
-0.0277286954,
0.0276652854,
-0.0247842241,
0.0398742259,
0.002940577,
-0.0339443572,
0.0640200377,
-0.0160504468,
0.0258554295,
-0.0984687135,
-0.0906766355,
-0.0054938481,
-0.0072940872,
-0.0079116663,
0.0557473749,
-0.0670911223,
-0.0638728812,
0.0407423191,
0.0682550594,
0.0083439238,
0.0603974871,
0.005314833,
-0.0536805168,
-0.0139015941,
0.0027389794,
-0.025912758,
-0.0121091977,
0.0427964889,
-0.0184837542,
-0.0064362297,
0.0408677906,
-0.0159172285,
0.0231682491,
0.0075342027,
0.0427656434,
-0.0162149742,
-0.0201330483,
0.009616402,
0.0023461499,
0.0418829843,
-0.0499151051,
-0.0211426783,
-0.0749503896,
0.0221677814,
-0.003670841,
-0.0250220951,
-0.0368534923,
0.0022603611,
0.0156716537,
-0.0388920642,
-0.0206198357,
0.0245544016,
-0.0112719666,
0.0102263177,
-0.0559889488,
0.0766245723,
0.0448946506,
0.0379641876,
0.0023449354,
0.0246050786,
-0.0282022227,
0.0287540443,
-0.001509673,
0.0620330274,
-0.0209432691,
0.044135537,
-0.0043966225,
0.0043265671,
0.0172369238,
0.0493332632,
0.0177997686,
-0.0252486505,
-0.0431542508,
0.0183330141,
0.0726792142,
-0.0274900962,
0.0617126226,
-0.0130045544,
-0.017100079,
-0.0054081026,
0.0337466411,
-0.0171765815,
-0.0484746248,
0.0093130134,
0.0171546526,
-0.0142169176,
-0.0039534741,
0.0753007233,
-0.0396149792,
0.0662223771,
0.0340311192,
0.0309803095,
-0.0166049134,
-0.0388919227,
0.0026621905,
0.0105037307,
-0.0338169225,
0.0176513866,
0.0009391566,
-0.0648401156,
-0.060143318,
0.0347751379,
-0.0198188014,
-0.0005898667,
0.0364515521,
0.0220706128,
-0.0192887597,
-0.0216080677,
-0.065792881,
0.0007572768,
-0.0317775421,
-0.0263333824,
-0.0002505781,
-6.327530337e-33,
-0.0454018153,
0.0076462561,
0.0186535083,
0.0101247095,
0.0233516227,
0.0019251842,
-0.0033647446,
-0.0062024379,
-0.0253552478,
0.02915846,
-0.0008600287,
0.0209749173,
0.0317963473,
0.0493326858,
0.0467797033,
-0.0026604952,
0.0249639619,
0.0045293341,
-0.0189717468,
0.0616349578,
0.0443586819,
-0.0241996031,
0.105790548,
-0.0512966774,
0.0570815913,
-0.0162579939,
-0.0219687205,
0.0289840475,
-0.0268833879,
0.0893261805,
0.0102218408,
0.0501809381,
0.0128430566,
-0.0191927627,
-0.0173899289,
0.0143584805,
-0.0680469647,
-0.0437877737,
0.0433058143,
0.0500620008,
-0.0688318461,
-0.0496381968,
-0.007011306,
-0.049811475,
-0.0067177331,
0.027942406,
0.0211398602,
-0.0206579752,
0.0218633842,
0.0109787108,
-0.0788788423,
-0.0037238339,
-0.037830133,
-0.0481252521,
0.0218320023,
0.0520758666,
0.0003406452,
-0.040562924,
-0.0639963523,
0.0406955071,
0.0198611133,
0.0641207248,
0.0887510926,
-0.009615249,
-0.009024553,
0.0225302111,
0.0161068682,
0.0084598521,
0.0308492966,
0.0284252129,
0.0241167378,
0.0537449308,
0.0097192535,
0.0200435463,
0.0186214596,
-0.0119839292,
-0.0428870358,
0.0120430188,
0.0221605804,
0.0422392488,
-0.0026748376,
-0.0322747715,
-0.0392070599,
-0.0169162676,
-0.0532056652,
-0.0341742821,
-0.0160839707,
-0.0173289273,
0.023858076,
-0.010680303,
-0.0398943871,
0.0353419296,
0.0139297713,
-0.0084464587,
-0.011629615,
0.0127521418,
0.0005632629,
0.0020456412,
0.0005750352,
0.0371371247,
-0.0670193881,
-0.0436143391,
-0.0230779927,
-0.0326322131,
0.0441105142,
0.0122367311,
0.0710220635,
0.0403888524,
-0.0429758951,
0.004240545,
-0.0427222922,
0.0551311858,
-0.0131087089,
-0.0052875425,
0.0333873592,
0.0229919925,
-0.0388378166,
0.0575266667,
0.0267095026,
-0.0254782271,
-0.0297240335,
-0.0409713686,
0.0063287867,
0.0282722302,
-0.0221477337,
0.0078681912,
-0.069371812,
-0.0044552209,
0.0046856552,
-0.0195071623,
0.0116485842,
0.0084103364,
2.619e-7,
0.0226003472,
0.0543260612,
0.0284404401,
0.0362327844,
-0.0172130298,
-0.0067258189,
-0.0253360532,
-0.0053960285,
-0.012608923,
0.016032787,
-0.0045865974,
0.0081180008,
0.0526079722,
0.0255495645,
-0.0850432962,
-0.0197578315,
-0.009257148,
0.0311806239,
-0.069768317,
-0.0189433079,
-0.0090004317,
0.0634582937,
-0.0006321443,
0.0160169639,
-0.0339035988,
0.0036966153,
0.0273481999,
-0.0367097259,
0.0113493521,
0.0473302975,
-0.0026288785,
0.0224407557,
0.0070138737,
0.0065881116,
-0.0555496328,
-0.003351049,
-0.012865738,
0.077953212,
0.0051446487,
-0.0174848046,
0.0042775176,
-0.0243031308,
-0.0185713395,
-0.022583982,
0.037376523,
-0.034272749,
-0.0133171231,
0.0088594239,
0.001747639,
0.002891076,
0.0163934659,
-0.0352876224,
-0.0045497925,
0.0232634731,
0.0477541909,
-0.0404367894,
-0.0298761949,
-0.0552765802,
-0.0135082575,
0.0265826639,
-0.005783753,
-0.0336626768,
-0.0042502796,
-0.0126364436,
-0.045333527,
-0.0519170649,
0.0099137872,
1.997099469e-34,
0.0037445098,
0.0063152844,
0.053014569,
0.0137209287,
0.032952033,
-0.0175702032,
-0.0226561464,
0.0193117056,
0.0022652159,
-0.0457459949,
-0.0299745612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06617v1 | FaBERT: Pre-training BERT on Persian Blogs | 2024-02-09T18:50:51 | 2024-02-09T18:50:51 | Mostafa Masumi, Seyed Soroush Majd, Mehrnoush Shamsfard, Hamid Beigy | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce FaBERT, a Persian BERT-base model pre-trained on the HmBlogs
corpus, encompassing both informal and formal Persian texts. FaBERT is designed
to excel in traditional Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks, addressing
the intricacies of diverse sentence structures and linguistic styles prevalent
in the Persian language. In our comprehensive evaluation of FaBERT on 12
datasets in various downstream tasks, encompassing Sentiment Analysis (SA),
Named Entity Recognition (NER), Natural Language Inference (NLI), Question
Answering (QA), and Question Paraphrasing (QP), it consistently demonstrated
improved performance, all achieved within a compact model size. The findings
highlight the importance of utilizing diverse and cleaned corpora, such as
HmBlogs, to enhance the performance of language models like BERT in Persian
Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications. FaBERT is openly accessible at
https://huggingface.co/sbunlp/fabert | [
0.0734272897,
0.0700892732,
0.0095978864,
0.0093019577,
-0.0217332542,
0.0340685472,
0.0042306595,
0.0002508992,
0.0329351313,
-0.0385927483,
-0.0195981711,
-0.0483182333,
-0.0188797973,
-0.011794134,
0.0207240488,
-0.0378565677,
0.0372322574,
-0.0166293345,
0.022781346,
0.0038854955,
0.0772518963,
0.0299980566,
-0.0306247696,
0.0186777301,
-0.0076230587,
-0.0021483223,
-0.0158834979,
0.0204817653,
-0.0016068254,
-0.0191963837,
0.059178967,
0.0470475294,
0.0098452996,
0.0228876434,
0.0000016481,
-0.0739041492,
-0.0359382406,
-0.0324375778,
0.0405142158,
-0.0053606266,
0.0151494015,
-0.0126762232,
-0.0098683257,
0.0379026234,
-0.0131332418,
-0.023946384,
0.0357860103,
0.0599636547,
0.0813461095,
0.082944043,
-0.0116134463,
-0.0469344072,
-0.0310745779,
0.0151997209,
-0.0001655648,
-0.0280160196,
0.0265651476,
-0.034928225,
-0.0439964272,
-0.0113170771,
0.0246213581,
0.0198987089,
-0.0245490968,
0.0016361752,
0.0073004249,
-0.0137244072,
-0.0889580101,
-0.0059344913,
0.0427567028,
0.0505455583,
-0.0011826,
-0.0492366478,
0.0435139462,
0.0382249616,
-0.0531893671,
0.0099959131,
-0.0382750519,
0.0198122971,
-0.0427096598,
0.0243018474,
0.034976989,
-0.0108124064,
-0.0092854463,
0.0447456278,
-0.0082904994,
0.0311427321,
0.0342649482,
-0.0399089307,
0.0023015435,
0.0198245402,
-0.0273432564,
-0.0279092845,
0.067351222,
0.0224458501,
-0.0212056935,
0.0142732933,
-0.0290733725,
-0.015190497,
0.0315373093,
-0.0913327113,
0.0051344093,
0.0654575676,
0.0337825939,
0.0321402512,
-0.0497020222,
-0.0103668468,
0.0232924335,
0.011946097,
-0.0264659133,
-0.0250324812,
-0.0417135097,
-0.0015032655,
-0.0591137521,
0.0494283512,
-0.0314886719,
0.00892324,
-0.0400285497,
0.0273499601,
0.0389136821,
0.0317373574,
0.0193544906,
-0.0014948045,
-0.019241266,
0.0326743908,
-0.0133148711,
0.0240958836,
-0.0295078028,
0.0135799218,
-0.0590311438,
-0.0534220748,
-0.0177471619,
0.0247397572,
0.0030394739,
-0.0224238839,
-0.0009418687,
0.0065304684,
0.0311544947,
-0.0477756597,
-0.0558996461,
0.0501269139,
0.0079856357,
-0.044316072,
0.0299664531,
-0.0645055994,
0.0372587517,
0.019912811,
-0.034990292,
0.0276951436,
0.0291933473,
0.0255185943,
-0.0168051515,
0.0571092069,
-0.0022597215,
-0.0003500434,
0.0229631942,
0.0040519238,
0.0504096523,
0.0683929548,
0.0247018319,
0.0134621663,
0.04271378,
0.0081835203,
-0.0221886057,
0.0291534234,
0.0038447916,
-0.0075874003,
-0.0012332798,
0.0283917841,
-0.0420134589,
0.0387796573,
-0.0170402694,
0.0350510329,
-0.0063486551,
0.0212358981,
0.0337246731,
0.0182505995,
-0.0386509895,
0.0462878309,
-0.0071641905,
0.0246157348,
0.0453443676,
0.0151609248,
-0.011124759,
-0.0158103928,
0.0244334079,
0.0403659716,
0.0049602524,
0.0497798212,
-0.0405679643,
-0.0227284078,
-0.0228733029,
-0.0373246334,
-0.0191070996,
-0.0312769227,
0.0763559788,
-0.0063027963,
-0.0460337736,
0.0867244825,
0.0488983095,
-0.0460752323,
0.0282361116,
-0.0617546365,
0.0180791076,
0.0925201401,
0.0152425691,
-0.0567240827,
-0.0292384699,
-0.0160705689,
-0.0289616417,
0.0324220881,
0.0169171076,
-0.0270286184,
0.0301393084,
-0.0230177063,
0.007597242,
0.003600115,
0.0239781793,
0.0100784525,
0.0006107591,
0.0304926597,
-0.0020455252,
-0.0193686672,
-0.0146889342,
0.023827441,
-0.0148546929,
-0.0024008304,
-0.0310404934,
-0.0035793921,
-0.0066060345,
0.016503796,
-0.0374202691,
0.002120106,
0.0202308074,
-0.051253181,
-0.0173791517,
0.0128405951,
-0.006264945,
-0.0810303539,
0.0261607002,
-0.0441504084,
-0.0157963261,
0.0648727939,
-0.0408282354,
-0.0587260723,
0.0518150218,
-0.0365077481,
0.0314208083,
-0.0607974194,
0.0167010855,
-0.0173587091,
-0.0061711366,
-0.0195987634,
0.0377554409,
-0.0316773131,
0.0136213312,
-0.0099257305,
-0.0523806773,
0.0414096117,
0.0345830396,
-0.0417013168,
0.0279212669,
0.0369257852,
-0.0103111817,
0.0563664623,
0.004235357,
-0.0549083799,
-0.0188146569,
-0.1026420742,
0.0137669137,
-0.039385438,
0.0927843451,
0.0419897474,
0.0254712421,
-0.0137198418,
0.0031287707,
-0.0242489502,
-0.0767812654,
0.0033176441,
0.0072309775,
0.0678052157,
-0.0200916156,
0.0126286093,
-0.0633708909,
-0.0233478341,
-0.0255592912,
0.0285824649,
-0.0012818685,
-0.0335891135,
0.0172703788,
-0.049999807,
-0.0076592802,
0.0184199046,
0.0190764926,
-0.0523387529,
-0.0098812189,
-0.0387591198,
0.0461187847,
0.0385495499,
0.0112588406,
-0.0091421735,
0.0021936449,
0.009054332,
-0.0367915481,
0.0135354633,
-0.0154505773,
0.0281530581,
-0.0167382006,
-0.0579210259,
-0.0226791054,
0.0361862965,
-0.0289892871,
-0.0189366732,
-0.0504255593,
-0.0001337462,
-0.0055178776,
0.030756522,
0.0240901019,
0.0065677636,
-0.0039797253,
0.0321934633,
-0.0267298762,
-0.0045586834,
0.040261168,
-0.0364813805,
0.0106460275,
-0.0679636672,
0.0260982607,
-0.0692400411,
-0.008696463,
0.0038768011,
0.0160463098,
-0.0366623811,
-0.0365030803,
-0.0157104079,
-0.0235444345,
-0.0093685687,
-0.0133898761,
-0.0132589806,
0.0052722478,
0.0192012154,
-0.0155979069,
0.0020365024,
-0.0399786942,
-0.0244793817,
-0.0234236661,
0.025489796,
0.0478501096,
-0.0077013252,
0.0229335316,
0.0165266804,
0.0007653242,
0.0318248533,
-0.031261228,
0.0175366178,
0.0059426865,
0.0410628691,
0.0451513045,
-0.0085730311,
0.0477710441,
-0.0098080123,
-0.0071841944,
0.0385136865,
0.0430882201,
-0.020250041,
-0.06035579,
-0.0264042784,
0.0261296201,
-0.0894531682,
-0.0252115335,
-0.0879963636,
0.0061486345,
-0.0503657572,
-0.0311122052,
0.1415036917,
0.0355846472,
0.0212180819,
-0.0237076189,
0.0080281403,
0.0283567552,
0.0245372392,
0.0112668863,
-0.0643373951,
-0.0244077053,
0.0132942088,
0.036279764,
-0.0015762006,
-0.0178707428,
0.0152304657,
-0.0953172296,
-0.0547420643,
-0.0390984714,
-0.0195925217,
0.002383739,
-0.0502072722,
-0.0039843367,
0.0076362533,
-0.0250338782,
-0.0347779468,
-0.0284752119,
0.063199304,
0.0591754243,
-0.0685263649,
-0.0711784884,
-0.0112598371,
-0.0415637977,
0.001370866,
0.0305898413,
0.0495093092,
-0.0212864541,
-0.0216561463,
0.0121463835,
-0.0474248789,
-0.0381400585,
-0.0169738531,
0.05090262,
-0.0261504445,
-0.0144841289,
-0.0279362593,
-0.0246213395,
-0.0614133589,
0.0390798822,
-0.0376655012,
0.0162726101,
-0.0031135415,
0.0212328658,
-0.0083060963,
0.0282805599,
0.0007864834,
0.0495549701,
0.0091535235,
-0.0262658335,
-0.0556296483,
0.027712848,
-0.0242393855,
-0.0939547569,
0.0085811876,
-0.0021645078,
0.0018921731,
-0.0488803089,
-0.0821920484,
-0.0599391684,
0.0007602434,
0.0103680994,
-0.0215610638,
0.0131306937,
0.0221576672,
0.0372170061,
-0.0255503301,
0.0202599969,
0.0461623855,
-0.0056366664,
-0.0144530581,
-0.0540697016,
0.0618540347,
-0.0420411676,
-0.0150863994,
-0.0136189498,
-0.0485217012,
-0.0257949121,
0.0209288858,
0.0347087122,
0.0139170187,
0.0150363175,
-0.0217639431,
-0.0238554478,
-0.0222623423,
0.0342444703,
-0.0188351646,
-0.0170398243,
0.0527782962,
0.0536312647,
-0.0063113645,
0.0751810744,
0.0073988051,
0.0024797937,
-0.0015738271,
0.0061964327,
0.0026151431,
-0.0296892039,
0.0233610924,
0.0131889926,
0.0168142729,
0.0080801081,
0.0211776346,
-0.0481240489,
0.0344985463,
0.0121710617,
0.0172699001,
-0.0337604955,
0.006120964,
0.0142461853,
0.0224868227,
-0.0569821447,
0.0571583435,
-0.0354793221,
0.0155364452,
-0.0379951857,
0.0322161391,
0.026346216,
0.0232146326,
-0.0532920323,
-0.0158526115,
-0.013624711,
-0.0277631804,
0.0027557344,
0.0180217996,
-0.0279394854,
0.0318935849,
0.0121500818,
-0.0082819173,
0.046259094,
0.0424498878,
-0.0452264026,
-0.027798852,
-0.0088570407,
0.0707720369,
0.0635262728,
-0.0612155572,
0.0809087977,
-0.004381713,
0.0011997514,
0.0076429285,
0.0254381727,
-0.0001022649,
-0.0120225158,
0.007304898,
-0.0235669333,
-0.0101004429,
-0.0015769901,
0.047694426,
0.0210424215,
0.027430309,
0.0337483026,
-0.0375904404,
-0.0071264002,
-0.0421567224,
0.0166055392,
-0.0024761437,
-0.0303518716,
0.0202840287,
-0.031028565,
-0.0708271936,
0.0051641958,
-0.0125651937,
-0.0071497951,
-0.0216892771,
0.0575945117,
0.0531774983,
0.016360661,
-0.0155459903,
-0.0721269548,
0.0117551275,
-0.0109284176,
-0.0206592716,
-0.0191986877,
-6.091600172e-33,
-0.0130488649,
0.0339661613,
-0.0216264483,
-0.0151051618,
-0.0048591094,
-0.0391671918,
-0.0483665355,
0.0043290118,
-0.0354244635,
0.0005030761,
-0.0284316987,
0.034014415,
0.0043531856,
0.0516137928,
0.0228343178,
-0.0434764922,
0.0441628098,
-0.008686631,
-0.0112914843,
0.0368781723,
0.0612437502,
0.0716623589,
0.13262555,
-0.0530437417,
-0.0017997529,
-0.0460047014,
-0.0132020433,
0.0387134813,
0.0340162776,
0.0472448729,
-0.0242016949,
0.0177215524,
0.0163297262,
-0.0309340972,
0.0053546852,
-0.0025644095,
-0.1115008295,
-0.0026845511,
0.0008099452,
0.0618267246,
-0.0264419653,
-0.0043067127,
0.0039820233,
-0.0114469081,
0.0025767095,
0.0580044948,
0.0321094356,
-0.0150493048,
0.0432400666,
-0.093157351,
-0.0488525443,
0.0364910848,
-0.0264502782,
0.0082739079,
-0.0017841067,
0.0409043841,
0.0010882734,
0.0465329587,
-0.0237516779,
-0.0384760834,
-0.0095031001,
0.0104362406,
0.0300028864,
-0.0159816034,
-0.03088402,
0.0459882133,
-0.0151175614,
-0.0290015899,
0.0302653871,
0.0079589942,
0.0226979069,
-0.0409677215,
0.0007933525,
0.0143645983,
0.0185212251,
-0.0200212784,
-0.1082946211,
0.031110948,
0.0534356236,
0.0565030128,
0.0284409579,
-0.0444278196,
-0.0395285189,
0.0148204667,
0.0160700642,
-0.0104470141,
-0.0232739765,
0.0079535423,
-0.006284581,
-0.0126737747,
-0.0464206897,
0.027915163,
-0.0018653136,
-0.0404560454,
0.00041399,
0.0135605689,
-0.0291515011,
-0.0165165886,
-0.0042286227,
0.0737983286,
-0.0647018403,
-0.0362807103,
0.001503766,
0.0209487099,
-0.0067327856,
0.0062258015,
0.0461614057,
0.0197986923,
-0.0850030929,
0.0305386577,
-0.0318655446,
0.0493770167,
-0.0346085317,
0.0882484242,
0.0134353535,
0.0117742959,
-0.0194153003,
0.0580889881,
0.0525922999,
0.0319679528,
-0.0296288244,
0.004316113,
-0.0009907107,
-0.0030300179,
0.0031214396,
0.0021655946,
-0.04155121,
0.0313801393,
-0.041332256,
-0.0934304744,
0.0139089022,
0.001299325,
2.595e-7,
0.0743192062,
0.0412652828,
0.0116833756,
-0.0002225606,
0.0162478033,
0.0077923764,
-0.0253462791,
0.0579437725,
-0.0303554721,
0.0186134074,
0.0113263838,
0.0284055062,
0.017341217,
0.0079779094,
-0.1053252295,
-0.0386996344,
-0.0638053864,
0.0137345213,
-0.0439908952,
0.0464113466,
0.0482512638,
0.1052846014,
-0.0286137164,
-0.0152736707,
-0.0082161883,
-0.0437057018,
0.0671811476,
0.0246627089,
-0.0106575098,
0.0673426241,
0.0149927018,
0.0213636272,
-0.0233373046,
-0.0129670342,
-0.0241648182,
0.0346566439,
0.0207101479,
0.0776819512,
0.0117279543,
-0.0375859514,
0.0288366489,
-0.0257016849,
0.0400019027,
-0.0548606254,
0.0789703056,
0.0167183653,
-0.0121445525,
-0.0143735176,
-0.0232333541,
-0.0218202639,
0.0197354015,
0.0054049268,
-0.012434083,
0.0390492827,
-0.0118846307,
-0.0740336627,
0.0163015202,
-0.0563467965,
0.0136900395,
-0.0185834803,
-0.0089759026,
-0.0254709404,
0.019690739,
0.0117106158,
0.0171986111,
-0.013861021,
0.004601798,
2.302860014e-34,
0.0539860763,
-0.0167518891,
-0.0240517203,
0.0258602127,
0.0491936095,
-0.0086112972,
-0.0075690942,
-0.0142076565,
0.0283289477,
-0.0305109471,
-0.0231071543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06608v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06608v2 | TIC: Translate-Infer-Compile for accurate "text to plan" using LLMs and Logical Representations | 2024-02-09T18:39:13 | 2024-06-29T00:30:04 | Sudhir Agarwal, Anu Sreepathy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the problem of generating plans for given natural language planning
task requests. On one hand, LLMs excel at natural language processing but do
not perform well on planning. On the other hand, classical planning tools excel
at planning tasks but require input in a structured language such as the
Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL). We leverage the strengths of both
the techniques by using an LLM for generating the PDDL representation (task
PDDL) of planning task requests followed by using a classical planner for
computing a plan. Unlike previous approaches that use LLMs for generating task
PDDLs directly, our approach comprises of (a) translate: using an LLM only for
generating a logically interpretable intermediate representation of natural
language task description, (b) infer: deriving additional logically dependent
information from the intermediate representation using a logic reasoner
(currently, Answer Set Programming solver), and (c) compile: generating the
target task PDDL from the base and inferred information. We observe that using
an LLM to only output the intermediate representation significantly reduces LLM
errors. Consequently, TIC approach achieves, for at least one LLM, high
accuracy on task PDDL generation for all seven domains of our evaluation
dataset. | [
0.0274385177,
0.0274527017,
-0.004061365,
0.0321611539,
-0.0495915674,
-0.0001865405,
-0.0218202136,
-0.0348802768,
-0.0194839649,
-0.0256965291,
0.0304562151,
0.0285770968,
-0.0085553043,
0.035552796,
-0.0250010863,
-0.0454644933,
0.015064097,
-0.036556311,
-0.0359227136,
0.030534802,
-0.0103112897,
0.0373287052,
-0.0000433452,
0.0041927509,
0.0073841042,
-0.0044839191,
-0.0564428754,
0.0315263197,
-0.013249143,
-0.0471085384,
-0.0128118964,
-0.0069543063,
0.0219357777,
-0.0563286804,
0.0000020552,
-0.0687676221,
-0.0522577874,
-0.0191893056,
-0.0167012848,
-0.04096926,
0.0005949928,
-0.0281471089,
0.0179606564,
0.0212752391,
-0.0432664417,
0.056608744,
-0.013423644,
0.0724799633,
0.0609351061,
0.0945983082,
-0.0080256471,
-0.058791969,
-0.0163624678,
0.0453717671,
0.0270418096,
-0.0311724599,
-0.0185769275,
0.0239509363,
0.0661510453,
0.0040561073,
0.0304499883,
0.013470727,
0.0118444189,
-0.0195185207,
-0.0480064526,
-0.0176736675,
0.0084701004,
-0.0263447519,
-0.0157237574,
0.0343796015,
0.0221928414,
-0.0199284162,
0.0457620323,
-0.0019673035,
0.0013899093,
0.0160192437,
-0.0129957898,
0.0185362417,
-0.0245379284,
0.0190507192,
0.0352197103,
0.0098566459,
0.004313367,
-0.016085254,
-0.0339754038,
0.094543457,
-0.0333900601,
-0.0304074213,
-0.0054826308,
0.0113559514,
0.0207896437,
-0.0564116053,
0.0234064832,
0.0530322492,
-0.0687104464,
0.036704503,
-0.0243469346,
0.004273721,
-0.0058804541,
-0.0178146604,
0.0579056218,
0.048660215,
-0.0042955126,
0.0104131848,
-0.0107322121,
0.0811109915,
0.0018664624,
0.0121198948,
-0.0754708871,
0.0068557095,
-0.0662072748,
0.0440558568,
-0.0505487844,
0.0532883294,
-0.0680266619,
0.0272148624,
-0.0075988169,
0.065657571,
0.0071216291,
0.028154986,
0.0578042753,
0.0179121066,
-0.028914636,
-0.0406902544,
-0.0884982646,
-0.0253079329,
-0.0577096641,
-0.0008867373,
-0.030842673,
-0.0174941197,
-0.0086392444,
0.0348663367,
0.0264519211,
0.0041244691,
-0.0158973765,
0.1074149013,
-0.0185667407,
0.0005792988,
-0.0724376217,
-0.1022516042,
-0.011765331,
-0.0638155788,
0.0236166585,
-0.0652957484,
0.0307693873,
0.0007618978,
-0.0320889093,
-0.0382792801,
0.0023826789,
0.0274097323,
0.0019059106,
0.0642238185,
0.007751402,
0.0190903042,
-0.0090965657,
0.0081952568,
-0.0173312388,
0.0714131966,
0.025291482,
0.0455802791,
-0.0091280974,
0.0572098158,
-0.0272429548,
0.0279014688,
0.0022415896,
-0.0263484642,
0.0144416513,
0.0558846332,
-0.0235490054,
0.0217101015,
-0.0064978609,
0.0070233126,
0.0247332901,
0.0361008085,
0.0023898117,
0.0241257194,
0.0300364196,
0.0014391263,
0.0519278757,
0.0494447984,
-0.0386100598,
-0.0146188643,
-0.0500247665,
0.0316449665,
-0.0237469617,
-0.0040725581,
-0.0244007092,
-0.0077556334,
-0.0060328222,
-0.0876735225,
-0.0106519032,
-0.0140774455,
0.0054081543,
-0.0150718093,
0.0236060806,
0.0446728654,
-0.0743602887,
0.0590505935,
-0.0289103221,
-0.0191457868,
-0.0031314108,
-0.0172546562,
0.0211321246,
0.0494037196,
0.0184440538,
-0.0526194945,
-0.0335022807,
0.0050714146,
0.0272341408,
0.0343891531,
0.0119166384,
-0.0171143096,
-0.0041590366,
-0.0193427261,
-0.0468512066,
-0.038333226,
-0.00153238,
0.013244234,
0.0376917906,
-0.0244237687,
-0.0073009324,
-0.0371617377,
-0.0047727646,
0.029678138,
-0.0150876958,
-0.0322914384,
0.0338388011,
0.010372119,
0.0619911924,
0.0359302759,
-0.0012900474,
0.0312791802,
0.0227455441,
-0.0256609414,
-0.0459038541,
-0.0203412659,
-0.0105728321,
-0.0507997237,
0.0389705673,
-0.0602625124,
-0.0238794442,
-0.0128068049,
-0.0531462245,
-0.038658794,
0.0084614679,
-0.0367602184,
-0.0242060386,
-0.010430079,
0.0204348471,
0.0362981036,
-0.0695572272,
-0.0305309445,
0.0636963919,
0.0114283459,
-0.0413771868,
0.0590581223,
-0.0167571064,
0.01277385,
-0.0098580038,
0.0261622798,
-0.0001944086,
-0.0073985932,
-0.0167430937,
0.0158399642,
0.0716636851,
-0.0175137427,
-0.034531951,
-0.0494444892,
0.0205610208,
-0.0205673017,
0.0278343558,
0.0120413918,
-0.004369094,
0.0169184152,
-0.0105251856,
-0.0383234508,
-0.0038485352,
0.0141815962,
-0.0397414193,
0.030586306,
0.0246333666,
-0.0290996134,
0.005478024,
0.0304404888,
-0.0187240206,
-0.0319069847,
0.0326092578,
-0.0523322634,
-0.0773362517,
0.0836597458,
-0.032480482,
0.0066572148,
0.0114344563,
0.0117017897,
0.0103859203,
-0.0112483781,
-0.0043799533,
-0.0123291155,
-0.0283827633,
-0.0124098109,
0.046442382,
-0.0277571436,
-0.0694226474,
0.0368861444,
-0.0345426127,
-0.0025859422,
-0.039301645,
-0.0541383438,
0.0252437294,
0.0349938236,
0.0130271995,
0.0329609737,
-0.0402277522,
0.0021777148,
0.0282408185,
-0.0035595759,
0.0088213952,
-0.0104448656,
-0.0150531307,
0.0690935701,
0.0037729503,
-0.0404728428,
0.0594073161,
-0.0185497571,
-0.009090296,
-0.0539570712,
-0.0230617598,
-0.0542562157,
0.0551795326,
0.0037825634,
0.012752316,
0.0199894402,
0.004930669,
-0.0278745219,
0.0106440466,
0.0060153995,
-0.0105885025,
0.069069095,
-0.096863918,
0.0124066696,
-0.0043188646,
-0.0240334086,
-0.0446477532,
0.0004314674,
-0.0264379662,
0.0262117665,
-0.0089127775,
-0.0357400328,
-0.0154010132,
-0.0402942784,
-0.008111422,
0.0119847581,
0.0121897515,
-0.0234315898,
-0.0423912853,
-0.0258721057,
0.0069850734,
0.0615109764,
-0.0350925624,
0.0310124792,
0.0188699681,
0.0271937735,
0.0057115257,
-0.017488556,
-0.0173067469,
0.0315596685,
0.0266237576,
-0.0054556057,
-0.0036123006,
0.0627523363,
0.0497721694,
-0.0294656213,
-0.0227563716,
0.0856165141,
0.0293869413,
0.0263230111,
0.0032263992,
-0.0272932705,
0.0173615236,
0.0420898199,
0.0531974584,
-0.0734887272,
-0.0339929126,
0.0003623574,
0.0420154519,
-0.0045002699,
-0.0374991186,
-0.0436439626,
-0.0975262523,
0.0416267179,
0.0037501308,
0.018095972,
0.0280586258,
-0.0502778403,
-0.0361452065,
0.0228573903,
-0.0279691666,
-0.0254017655,
0.0172250643,
-0.0168163981,
0.0043336027,
-0.0551759601,
-0.0091212532,
0.0291193649,
0.0133123389,
0.0243790988,
0.0968943164,
0.0371141918,
0.0337721966,
-0.0039359885,
0.0417681076,
0.0437223352,
0.0446225777,
-0.0546384305,
0.0142175313,
0.0178285316,
0.0183833782,
0.0138557898,
0.0310033783,
-0.0861808509,
-0.0184450261,
0.054696247,
0.1208660081,
-0.0570536666,
0.0130256154,
-0.0247380864,
0.0141949067,
0.0255834982,
0.0509096347,
-0.0193622205,
-0.0017309929,
-0.0360000022,
-0.054906249,
-0.0415022485,
-0.1084678397,
-0.0323295109,
0.0105827404,
-0.0555605926,
0.0509289987,
-0.0438358895,
-0.0223788843,
0.0591632202,
0.0308769736,
0.0142662078,
-0.0204596035,
0.009472969,
0.0007074925,
-0.0340780802,
-0.0113861049,
-0.017806245,
0.0168689992,
-0.0199563392,
-0.0228191856,
0.0009454567,
-0.0411581695,
0.0086266752,
0.0396800116,
-0.0449772812,
-0.0539637543,
-0.0332116596,
0.0727695376,
0.0165561419,
0.0192970689,
0.0155739188,
-0.0018883552,
0.0221204329,
0.0218928996,
-0.0176409408,
-0.0019616985,
0.0119973617,
0.0510752164,
0.0014718157,
0.0448914655,
-0.0476276688,
0.0210482348,
-0.0234680399,
0.0411649682,
-0.0117789805,
-0.0186865814,
0.0458355546,
0.0629298314,
0.0096071297,
-0.015466975,
-0.0258761104,
0.003595639,
0.0321297869,
-0.0639418662,
-0.0561440289,
-0.0731863305,
0.0445719771,
-0.0144466599,
-0.0320565104,
0.048302941,
0.0249751713,
-0.056185808,
-0.0040582856,
0.0155978221,
0.028809892,
0.0290855691,
0.0026328114,
0.0186827369,
0.0031866194,
0.0075831362,
0.0234322902,
0.0092994748,
0.0340377055,
0.0128620155,
0.0331409089,
0.0207546409,
0.0447872393,
-0.0626395196,
-0.0353289209,
-0.0072263032,
-0.0854616538,
0.0159094445,
-0.0025143113,
0.0153805977,
0.0311032031,
0.0441753566,
-0.0600447394,
0.0231608823,
0.0273338333,
0.0264286567,
0.0248921774,
-0.0220288727,
0.0502077602,
0.0092964917,
0.0096881045,
-0.0847391114,
0.0277280919,
-0.0040773996,
0.0325782709,
-0.0167916119,
-0.0491349548,
-0.0767580643,
-0.0596131198,
-0.0197464377,
0.0260728933,
-0.0045381244,
-0.0458835661,
-0.0488892496,
-0.0317925662,
0.0121307317,
0.0237866417,
-0.0037520919,
-0.0364202857,
0.0553973466,
0.020544447,
0.0174599718,
-0.0549893677,
-0.020193316,
-0.0276357699,
-0.0058472301,
-0.0574746355,
-0.0106695089,
-5.470337449e-33,
-0.0288842823,
-0.0457075909,
0.067359969,
-0.0369918048,
0.0340198688,
-0.0157166552,
-0.0383694358,
0.0127312569,
0.0268801097,
0.0139522217,
-0.0065291268,
-0.0069170143,
0.0314948745,
-0.0015312545,
-0.0017180829,
-0.0225390289,
0.0356534347,
-0.033388678,
-0.0294228159,
-0.0240077693,
0.0438685082,
-0.0259904824,
0.0335031487,
-0.0676285326,
0.0335226618,
0.0381323099,
-0.007756297,
0.0680862293,
0.0209672842,
0.0105011342,
0.0301124845,
0.0204190295,
0.01689592,
-0.0198164675,
-0.0455546975,
0.0332124867,
-0.0645861849,
-0.0737397373,
0.0560113415,
-0.0081790416,
-0.0702344626,
-0.0338941664,
0.0103311837,
0.0116304792,
-0.0535111204,
-0.0115161575,
0.0109685101,
0.0038822477,
0.0431840941,
0.0182958525,
-0.0481494293,
0.0156522896,
-0.006875331,
-0.0186622664,
0.0405189618,
0.0554649979,
0.0122756446,
-0.0263898708,
0.0104643498,
0.0136525575,
-0.0167629998,
0.0089159235,
0.0718615875,
-0.0098700942,
-0.037800055,
0.0462740734,
0.0370223001,
0.013640509,
-0.032178361,
0.0083529362,
-0.0465672091,
0.09423922,
-0.0214574393,
0.0334816426,
0.0059882384,
0.0635924786,
-0.0360717587,
0.0781169161,
-0.0156710092,
0.0464381911,
0.0309317224,
-0.0031587535,
-0.0397019945,
-0.0230422653,
-0.0194363613,
0.0522513501,
-0.0052689221,
-0.0257551819,
0.0401960723,
0.0220205896,
0.0036870074,
0.0135911303,
0.0154634109,
-0.0364260413,
0.0171736684,
0.0337587222,
-0.0145902345,
-0.017299369,
-0.0128728794,
0.022476472,
-0.0063525471,
-0.0146415746,
0.0116907051,
-0.0155262314,
0.043490611,
0.0110734515,
-0.0209254306,
0.0340826772,
-0.0273767617,
0.0171109643,
-0.0722963586,
0.0029648845,
-0.0330681428,
0.0254729334,
0.0222289003,
-0.0130337579,
-0.0288591981,
-0.0194767527,
0.0027896832,
-0.1058701351,
-0.0094075445,
0.0059325807,
0.0288443435,
0.0134546924,
-0.0210825708,
-0.0073567154,
-0.0018061724,
-0.004925428,
0.0132093951,
-0.0252914354,
-0.0019378319,
0.0338252001,
2.869e-7,
0.0395889059,
0.0253962781,
0.0245168488,
0.0985148549,
-0.013160117,
0.0157427769,
0.0160558466,
0.0049046623,
-0.0121595236,
-0.0330230519,
0.0383528732,
0.01793053,
0.0116096083,
0.0656259656,
-0.074720718,
-0.0043019578,
0.0419208892,
-0.0169375837,
-0.0627984554,
0.0241961889,
0.1156672612,
0.0352007076,
-0.0041347076,
-0.0162028149,
-0.0170256849,
-0.035939116,
-0.0105138244,
-0.0297153108,
0.0075470493,
-0.0011694492,
0.0020369478,
-0.0481580123,
0.0000629724,
0.0177923236,
-0.0145144686,
0.0157716759,
-0.0078614848,
0.0796246529,
0.0038536321,
-0.0413202345,
-0.0122330999,
-0.0667720661,
0.0062776529,
0.0101722097,
0.0468765125,
-0.0040816176,
-0.0099500576,
0.0336799622,
0.0045974576,
-0.0243278146,
-0.0769907236,
0.0205661394,
0.0401302576,
0.0155840041,
0.0210380703,
-0.0191300642,
-0.0095048482,
-0.0401817597,
-0.0104471669,
0.0296151135,
-0.0395444334,
-0.0181003958,
-0.0429938249,
0.0610294566,
0.0164051224,
-0.0596817248,
-0.0260921475,
2.736262715e-34,
-0.0150466608,
0.0298621785,
-0.0038229357,
0.0271051545,
0.0529747121,
0.019041298,
-0.0319802649,
0.035158243,
0.0407363921,
-0.0669619739,
-0.039042756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06592v1 | Self-consistent context aware conformer transducer for speech recognition | 2024-02-09T18:12:11 | 2024-02-09T18:12:11 | Konstantin Kolokolov, Pavel Pekichev, Karthik Raghunathan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose a novel neural network architecture based on conformer transducer
that adds contextual information flow to the ASR systems. Our method improves
the accuracy of recognizing uncommon words while not harming the word error
rate of regular words. We explore the uncommon words accuracy improvement when
we use the new model and/or shallow fusion with context language model. We
found that combination of both provides cumulative gain in uncommon words
recognition accuracy. | [
-0.0211760867,
-0.0016634417,
0.0197127555,
0.0381945781,
-0.0183322821,
-0.0447507389,
0.0319636017,
-0.0086976802,
-0.0439619496,
-0.0049388045,
-0.037189886,
-0.0202665143,
0.0565987118,
0.0356927142,
-0.0122970231,
0.027570365,
0.0165072363,
-0.0240091458,
0.001221448,
-0.0201830864,
-0.0094951773,
-0.0172405224,
-0.0158438291,
0.032641314,
-0.0212653838,
0.0345228277,
0.0153564485,
-0.0091567449,
0.0114017483,
-0.0109090917,
-0.0187782273,
0.0076153814,
0.0183570366,
0.0833074078,
0.0000017644,
-0.0337121449,
-0.0336090475,
0.0218814742,
-0.0455147028,
-0.0200393423,
-0.0175952148,
0.0024657468,
-0.0618580356,
0.0389027633,
-0.0101126591,
0.0098925559,
0.0759847015,
0.0634441525,
-0.0072545726,
0.0441911966,
0.0013559379,
-0.0510180481,
0.026678266,
0.0004616833,
-0.0369620472,
-0.0764815211,
-0.0140852714,
-0.0395968072,
-0.0185271539,
-0.0273148455,
-0.0431555472,
0.0458126292,
0.0247936714,
-0.0022635437,
0.0370097049,
0.0001233599,
0.0080348058,
-0.0220738277,
-0.0353492238,
0.0394783206,
0.0022294321,
-0.0542916395,
-0.0158051811,
-0.0055139856,
-0.035746485,
-0.0094005438,
0.0000726153,
0.0099919988,
-0.0030504281,
0.0174644291,
0.0146225821,
0.0319200084,
0.0277110431,
0.0073641981,
-0.0578686707,
0.0199235883,
-0.0045854161,
-0.0142297726,
-0.0080664326,
-0.0319699682,
0.001600982,
0.0054202541,
0.0741419867,
0.0373098962,
-0.0278169867,
-0.0123242401,
-0.0401645899,
-0.0566523038,
0.0128376447,
-0.1007838249,
-0.0119882291,
0.0499265566,
-0.0176805668,
0.0096987747,
-0.040129222,
0.1047726795,
0.0015179642,
0.0172737893,
-0.0258244555,
-0.0301809739,
-0.0006097466,
-0.0000059072,
-0.0426644795,
0.0383027233,
-0.0448098965,
-0.0976697206,
-0.0499934293,
0.0336826891,
-0.0010435053,
-0.0148320943,
0.0713349432,
0.0098545514,
-0.0197246689,
-0.0212922469,
0.0344135538,
0.0254901312,
0.0218699854,
0.009686185,
0.0113818841,
-0.060087014,
-0.0083372761,
0.0208242647,
0.0664465651,
-0.0131011307,
0.0094964495,
0.0418100394,
0.0045162188,
-0.0567645282,
-0.0314003043,
0.0440583117,
-0.0604618303,
-0.0004407023,
-0.0268870853,
-0.053970255,
0.0131152943,
0.0012798122,
-0.0040831859,
-0.0726504698,
0.0107439468,
-0.0041091321,
0.0285713021,
0.0688231587,
-0.0146824922,
-0.0130343307,
0.0318388864,
-0.0232462231,
0.0718771294,
0.0197327007,
0.0500297323,
-0.0291869752,
0.0105552413,
-0.0434775688,
0.0034570312,
0.0114699844,
-0.0176107362,
-0.0799011886,
-0.05716075,
-0.0551448055,
0.0304604545,
0.0009365169,
0.0279078018,
0.0720754415,
0.0094524426,
-0.0239553507,
0.0199396238,
0.0344025306,
0.0773483068,
0.0069120848,
-0.0053684465,
-0.0055472567,
-0.0423367471,
0.0208282322,
-0.0273077395,
0.0218998678,
-0.0374682248,
0.0109308297,
0.025526084,
0.0460243933,
-0.0196068063,
-0.0163968895,
-0.0158815254,
-0.0201897733,
0.0284987036,
-0.0025217207,
0.0587263517,
0.0137368096,
-0.0468659513,
0.0027721869,
-0.0018775671,
-0.0276316535,
0.0043025548,
-0.0353021733,
0.0150494203,
0.0200779252,
0.0504294373,
-0.0199964475,
-0.0003687868,
0.0091396989,
-0.0350431055,
0.0471614823,
0.0382179804,
0.0261470545,
0.0244137999,
-0.0729934499,
-0.0293982252,
0.074124366,
0.0177258607,
0.0727444887,
0.0093538556,
0.0467174612,
0.0339496545,
0.0061088004,
-0.0138745774,
-0.0042076968,
-0.0191234108,
-0.0536238626,
0.0394564867,
0.0239702556,
0.021896109,
0.0353316441,
-0.0077122436,
0.0100358278,
0.0601707958,
-0.0334890597,
-0.0176390186,
0.03308383,
-0.1191273928,
0.0120060304,
0.0455960594,
-0.0267877989,
0.0313864462,
-0.0010630037,
0.0645295084,
-0.092113249,
0.0462357886,
-0.0350397378,
0.0944342315,
-0.0549098179,
0.0869184062,
0.031973023,
0.0596290343,
0.0186836086,
0.0103162974,
0.0328686535,
0.0025392193,
-0.0204848181,
-0.0264447331,
-0.0067571527,
-0.0360636041,
-0.0403899923,
0.0164875183,
-0.0395796858,
0.015131644,
0.0271459837,
-0.0269107074,
0.0348205604,
-0.034664724,
-0.0064149452,
-0.0448394865,
-0.0159420669,
0.0007535444,
-0.0254114736,
0.0519212857,
0.0373524874,
-0.0133515587,
-0.0050099902,
0.0088650929,
0.0076692896,
-0.0189617258,
-0.0276361573,
0.0226836856,
-0.0787674859,
-0.0146055743,
-0.0158338193,
0.0058860984,
0.0044838223,
0.0043641753,
-0.0415062271,
-0.0442005843,
0.0115663689,
0.0447006002,
0.0893757492,
-0.0041204356,
-0.0070982054,
0.0208535455,
0.0028917843,
0.0002484521,
0.0291949827,
0.0220569,
-0.0132004051,
0.0199790932,
-0.0000224705,
-0.0462626293,
0.0007634641,
0.0027469781,
0.0290183015,
0.0365902707,
0.0262366161,
-0.023749169,
0.0141175985,
0.0355472825,
0.012972394,
-0.0266010799,
-0.023558937,
0.007016432,
-0.0324137211,
-0.015324126,
-0.0483050235,
-0.0621157177,
-0.0135812787,
-0.0108660394,
-0.0055747977,
0.0029557056,
-0.0675335675,
-0.0080755809,
0.0007231536,
-0.0375912003,
-0.0156545471,
-0.0238999929,
0.0108279083,
0.0146450298,
-0.0165434927,
-0.0642652884,
0.0249478687,
0.0299728457,
0.0163704399,
-0.0372872874,
0.0833848044,
-0.0198748745,
0.0057080435,
0.0012059477,
-0.0124565288,
-0.0474322997,
-0.0070139319,
-0.0242139213,
0.0605796874,
0.0252281148,
-0.0560371168,
-0.0212070495,
0.0368046649,
-0.0021855133,
0.0888949707,
0.026143875,
0.0203182939,
-0.0345321409,
0.0186099615,
0.0106685264,
0.0553922988,
0.0437890179,
0.0235192049,
0.0236210991,
0.005993058,
0.0667039454,
-0.0142691778,
-0.046380315,
-0.0485151336,
0.031718228,
-0.002263118,
0.0213935748,
0.0232479777,
0.0225922596,
-0.0074811112,
0.0083842408,
0.1027976349,
0.0108451881,
-0.0036582253,
-0.0304863583,
-0.0258280654,
-0.0037980694,
0.0322551355,
-0.0199563093,
-0.0267357025,
-0.0176641662,
0.0412287302,
0.0175702013,
0.0197374336,
0.0291889627,
-0.0283158328,
-0.0296424069,
-0.0147417774,
0.030400455,
-0.0612707213,
-0.0653906688,
-0.0111912442,
-0.0035799986,
-0.0287532005,
0.0727943256,
0.020969158,
-0.020321805,
-0.0797745958,
0.0110910386,
-0.041752506,
-0.0746023506,
-0.0220161173,
-0.0388480872,
0.0865578949,
0.0524117835,
-0.0164901484,
-0.0557942092,
-0.0434060693,
0.0755776912,
-0.0336723775,
0.0324637406,
-0.0307907835,
-0.0337573811,
0.0178962164,
-0.0307191703,
0.028291868,
-0.0018225654,
-0.0609890632,
-0.0145464102,
-0.0173850041,
0.0478532948,
-0.020719124,
-0.0152715491,
0.0184776764,
-0.0007286449,
-0.0195357427,
0.0684406906,
0.0124689089,
-0.0225958619,
0.0098847197,
0.0352028422,
0.0482248999,
0.0002774128,
0.0426591709,
-0.027960835,
0.0132448133,
-0.0673633441,
-0.0221470278,
0.0146290837,
-0.0133179165,
0.0458804257,
0.0463141091,
0.0199015383,
-0.00996935,
0.0056647966,
-0.0099562006,
-0.046252016,
-0.0120820329,
0.014193926,
-0.1046276242,
0.0537386648,
-0.0205047429,
-0.0477185398,
-0.0153104095,
0.036847692,
0.0074383975,
-0.0541250668,
0.0684060007,
-0.0693641677,
0.0177065264,
0.0278791469,
-0.0665099621,
-0.0226979759,
0.0122321695,
0.0228723288,
-0.0222284291,
0.0267312843,
0.0466367528,
-0.0536629967,
-0.0083264979,
0.0076934858,
0.0005073064,
0.0013671349,
-0.0170327537,
0.004096909,
-0.0193310156,
-0.0817500129,
0.0414358005,
0.0021148506,
0.0389235541,
0.000180161,
0.0601043403,
-0.0511333868,
0.0313596465,
0.0183857717,
0.071735397,
0.0020761534,
-0.0135041177,
-0.0064699166,
0.0256706569,
-0.0088801542,
0.0515088663,
-0.0181909576,
-0.0155855864,
-0.0074752313,
0.0670294389,
0.0341739655,
0.0362317115,
-0.0101307612,
-0.0160857197,
-0.0069334595,
0.0472195633,
0.0592851825,
0.0312523618,
-0.0286744442,
0.0083770342,
-0.0028651138,
-0.0280287489,
-0.0288619958,
0.0246115606,
-0.0483850315,
0.0365040861,
-0.0442846566,
0.0718849525,
0.0263894927,
-0.0099699507,
-0.0134903947,
-0.0031636781,
0.0112002213,
-0.031843666,
0.0145785837,
-0.0139057413,
0.0387726352,
0.0359614342,
0.0203984771,
0.0133689577,
0.0148657328,
0.0140495058,
-0.0847494528,
0.0014803126,
-0.0192198921,
0.0306241065,
-0.0306784362,
0.0057808766,
-0.014805153,
0.0461795591,
-0.0515757203,
0.0060964348,
0.0080348328,
-0.0482779518,
0.0920310095,
0.013791427,
0.0229335893,
-0.0080872364,
-0.0208831802,
-0.0055367905,
-0.0218649041,
0.0090300851,
0.0650419667,
-0.0439156629,
0.0265536662,
0.007147931,
-0.0006441917,
-6.365890392e-33,
-0.0277941264,
0.006590507,
0.0025135835,
-0.0058740806,
-0.0001343577,
0.0062112436,
-0.0167101603,
0.0101877199,
-0.0199040025,
-0.0178939924,
-0.0259756073,
0.0094056129,
0.0403137691,
0.0147918239,
-0.0269478597,
0.0130526628,
0.0740100592,
0.0274510514,
0.0467993058,
-0.0550899878,
0.0337329321,
0.021204168,
0.0624757223,
-0.0767798722,
-0.0435172394,
0.0528075881,
0.0026152886,
0.0036886686,
0.0154737448,
0.0598614067,
-0.006048115,
0.053080596,
0.005218002,
-0.0164036062,
-0.0083834324,
0.0238849111,
-0.1000318229,
-0.0160995629,
-0.0254194513,
0.0414165668,
0.0602396838,
-0.0431541055,
0.0792036504,
-0.0403386131,
-0.0740555227,
0.0293836892,
0.0115783866,
-0.0254617538,
-0.0357910059,
0.0279186144,
-0.0272406191,
0.0352695175,
0.013450969,
0.0247439314,
0.0307175796,
0.0146140959,
-0.0262582358,
-0.0678011626,
-0.0949160531,
0.05167602,
0.0058540246,
0.011323031,
0.0277297646,
0.0336336643,
-0.0262291431,
0.0136152133,
0.0515164807,
-0.105415605,
-0.0099282181,
-0.0766951144,
0.039236512,
0.0135491751,
0.0286385696,
0.0347563028,
0.022239957,
-0.0802573115,
0.0120847374,
0.0042582089,
-0.0238745641,
0.018395666,
0.0529862866,
0.0096485177,
-0.089970164,
0.0013552263,
-0.0115338126,
-0.0110351685,
-0.059837386,
0.0294185653,
0.0360583216,
0.0206736568,
-0.0097783813,
0.0047302572,
0.0105293607,
-0.0492878146,
0.0418711454,
0.0032860534,
0.0480140783,
-0.0207681544,
-0.006633163,
0.0090182638,
-0.052033063,
-0.023574207,
0.0411387607,
0.0276321601,
-0.0422120877,
-0.0124911303,
0.0291858092,
0.0606051609,
-0.0797292516,
-0.0093964655,
-0.0045110052,
-0.0079565654,
0.0195327494,
-0.0335465893,
0.0465925522,
-0.0268706176,
-0.0117721055,
0.0220553,
-0.0143250944,
0.0372791886,
-0.0018531115,
0.0198326111,
0.0245822594,
0.037401408,
-0.0155853927,
0.0124783963,
0.0415033922,
0.0313084163,
0.0276944544,
0.0038980637,
0.0023348113,
0.0128305359,
2.567e-7,
-0.0194056593,
-0.0303597096,
0.0417007208,
-0.0606485084,
0.0090274708,
-0.0265545659,
-0.0015783467,
-0.00314484,
-0.0285426937,
0.0362556428,
0.0195771288,
0.0049762633,
-0.0043103425,
-0.0383647121,
-0.0307989344,
-0.0306441467,
-0.0552820303,
0.0221957285,
0.0240144171,
0.0170707405,
0.0056505254,
0.0837072209,
-0.0281712133,
-0.06653326,
-0.0061293808,
-0.0191438254,
-0.0046778386,
-0.0158623122,
0.0720758066,
-0.0408390611,
-0.0237930715,
-0.0081080412,
-0.0071689212,
0.0223110486,
-0.0226532482,
0.076876007,
0.0207204707,
0.0038458975,
-0.0385102592,
-0.0520330705,
0.0220923424,
0.044436235,
-0.030079281,
-0.0212520268,
0.0459744632,
-0.0018622873,
-0.0125144385,
-0.0688216835,
-0.0302740037,
0.0066363234,
-0.0114057017,
0.0214550924,
0.0036411022,
-0.0374016762,
0.0263268705,
-0.0048335199,
-0.0529768579,
-0.0465169251,
0.0072071641,
-0.0210398976,
-0.0645532385,
0.0404233225,
-0.0093958899,
-0.0369047374,
0.0354169793,
0.0273215864,
-0.0118627278,
1.793174847e-34,
0.0212605316,
0.0169648267,
0.0068045682,
-0.009222026,
-0.0113365809,
-0.0179629568,
0.0119800009,
0.0127059631,
-0.0054609976,
-0.0548229292,
-0.0643393919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06584v1 | G-SciEdBERT: A Contextualized LLM for Science Assessment Tasks in German | 2024-02-09T18:05:03 | 2024-02-09T18:05:03 | Ehsan Latif, Gyeong-Geon Lee, Knut Neuman, Tamara Kastorff, Xiaoming Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advancement of natural language processing has paved the way for
automated scoring systems in various languages, such as German (e.g., German
BERT [G-BERT]). Automatically scoring written responses to science questions in
German is a complex task and challenging for standard G-BERT as they lack
contextual knowledge in the science domain and may be unaligned with student
writing styles. This paper developed a contextualized German Science Education
BERT (G-SciEdBERT), an innovative large language model tailored for scoring
German-written responses to science tasks. Using G-BERT, we pre-trained
G-SciEdBERT on a corpus of 50K German written science responses with 5M tokens
to the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) 2015. We
fine-tuned G-SciEdBERT on 59 assessment items and examined the scoring
accuracy. We then compared its performance with G-BERT. Our findings reveal a
substantial improvement in scoring accuracy with G-SciEdBERT, demonstrating a
10% increase of quadratic weighted kappa compared to G-BERT (mean accuracy
difference = 0.096, SD = 0.024). These insights underline the significance of
specialized language models like G-SciEdBERT, which is trained to enhance the
accuracy of automated scoring, offering a substantial contribution to the field
of AI in education. | [
0.022257885,
-0.0106729874,
0.0096622622,
0.0085235629,
-0.0220161639,
-0.0078223674,
0.0186475813,
-0.0068189348,
0.0451932959,
-0.1006759554,
-0.0617971309,
-0.0048686387,
-0.0249304734,
0.0275945179,
0.0115152262,
-0.0409550816,
0.0362469852,
-0.0143204229,
0.0293601304,
-0.0198651347,
-0.0247481316,
-0.0098261731,
-0.0199556053,
0.0178624149,
0.0325057097,
-0.0397031829,
0.0325491764,
-0.0101535553,
0.0449025072,
-0.0518078469,
0.062444523,
0.0812994316,
0.0038086623,
0.0335760899,
0.0000017269,
-0.0747013241,
-0.0082312748,
-0.0111975754,
0.011011539,
0.0423674919,
0.015418306,
0.0261706244,
-0.0135963922,
0.0078543881,
-0.0490596183,
0.0191943385,
0.0200592298,
0.0081053479,
0.0340233073,
0.0236932244,
0.0118080443,
-0.0449248143,
0.0530425236,
0.01379136,
0.0235683192,
-0.0000780346,
0.0361358859,
0.0381104238,
0.0052332883,
0.061320588,
-0.0282089952,
0.0349610634,
0.0152751617,
-0.0227679014,
0.0245263297,
0.0090819541,
-0.0613503903,
0.0267006475,
0.0151864924,
0.0539434552,
0.0310016442,
-0.0374676622,
-0.0201455802,
-0.0180411898,
-0.0115886936,
0.0274016093,
-0.0621607527,
0.0114963679,
-0.0021485165,
-0.0163604487,
0.0612372607,
-0.0239866395,
-0.0077931918,
0.035676375,
0.0175490361,
0.0778740048,
0.0266085435,
-0.0524870418,
0.0019416054,
0.0252467394,
-0.0200467687,
-0.0675709993,
0.0125610419,
0.0534535684,
-0.0162286907,
0.0116035072,
-0.0305633675,
-0.0323723927,
0.0472795106,
-0.0201732963,
0.0235464014,
0.0209247656,
-0.0076687788,
0.023852963,
-0.0118601639,
0.1124904081,
0.030753633,
0.0306375157,
-0.0162674002,
-0.0114466371,
-0.0451050736,
-0.0249647703,
0.0222261567,
0.0092541231,
0.0088536432,
0.024646908,
-0.0756357312,
-0.0115806125,
-0.0135668721,
-0.0071706264,
0.0267270152,
-0.0099753998,
-0.0169569794,
0.0512416139,
-0.0266822707,
0.0539637916,
-0.0274040289,
-0.0048093027,
-0.0124311773,
0.0254394952,
-0.0092054913,
0.0272126999,
-0.0119733158,
-0.0153378882,
0.0366243757,
0.0084705064,
0.0283684283,
-0.0361069217,
0.0311171226,
-0.0312770121,
-0.0194662698,
-0.0598755665,
0.0189021658,
-0.0592863411,
-0.0036228169,
0.0440152548,
0.0028356521,
-0.0332848802,
0.021463614,
0.0190489572,
0.0036782089,
0.0185150448,
-0.0233104285,
-0.0430613123,
-0.0010705723,
0.0125064235,
-0.007964775,
0.0026830991,
0.0361612216,
-0.0283397418,
0.0280003212,
-0.035895884,
0.0093652783,
0.0161265768,
0.0020049491,
-0.0079636024,
-0.0063521471,
0.0046172561,
-0.0056196577,
0.0464336313,
-0.0030977181,
0.0174669325,
0.0372759551,
0.0267025959,
0.0137076331,
0.083071515,
0.0264041796,
0.0041646753,
-0.0063497312,
-0.0240506679,
0.0584604368,
0.0338042788,
-0.0348951183,
0.0384474024,
-0.042198211,
0.0069025452,
0.0095604006,
0.0172397569,
0.0037535056,
-0.0618947111,
-0.0268810224,
0.019841155,
-0.0043764086,
0.0023270983,
0.0584367774,
-0.0333434865,
-0.0109985871,
0.0518499874,
0.013925516,
-0.0791712925,
0.0593677834,
-0.0102787986,
0.0391068272,
0.0557777807,
0.0613983944,
-0.0671933666,
-0.080325,
0.0044661742,
-0.0160606652,
0.0503243208,
0.0268700477,
-0.0388474055,
-0.0228588991,
-0.0187743995,
-0.0423397645,
-0.039869085,
0.0008222096,
-0.0178549495,
-0.0052128728,
0.018171899,
-0.0115537122,
-0.058538083,
-0.0310864933,
0.0445853397,
-0.0458236523,
-0.0578677207,
-0.0156865437,
-0.0481243134,
0.0132280895,
0.0213636402,
-0.013201003,
0.0258302931,
0.0478579067,
-0.0391906202,
-0.0196295287,
-0.0275698658,
-0.0335814282,
-0.0540384986,
0.0568645597,
-0.0155887166,
-0.0083834436,
0.0347948745,
-0.0284013506,
-0.045352608,
-0.0185519531,
-0.0091946898,
-0.0060222335,
-0.0060635111,
0.0067898701,
-0.041572094,
-0.0534615777,
-0.0646738634,
0.034872815,
0.0142122991,
0.0944637954,
-0.0152031956,
0.004677658,
0.0515103042,
-0.000237408,
-0.0655858144,
-0.0096373251,
0.0239768028,
0.0020577002,
0.0379455462,
0.006260226,
-0.0561152287,
-0.0027597977,
-0.0774295107,
0.0085966904,
-0.0038102935,
0.0358464867,
0.0162055548,
-0.0174584612,
0.0176036227,
0.035650529,
-0.0399976335,
-0.0271955431,
0.0124942847,
-0.0151971262,
0.053420078,
-0.0208646692,
-0.0015835107,
-0.0735690296,
0.0068085156,
-0.0846929848,
0.0295155067,
0.0706244186,
0.0260587446,
-0.0413087606,
0.0437539294,
-0.018296089,
0.015405043,
0.0158654749,
-0.0381542258,
0.0231499895,
-0.0008996378,
0.0461866334,
0.0758246034,
0.0168360826,
-0.0231023002,
0.0363088511,
0.0082210135,
-0.0758114532,
-0.0069038877,
0.0033835608,
0.0329055861,
-0.0257814843,
-0.0140692871,
0.0417990014,
0.0422300175,
-0.0217605811,
-0.0301771462,
-0.0051727593,
0.0493956245,
-0.0430156663,
0.0021776946,
-0.040580824,
-0.002633499,
-0.0218680017,
0.0311370771,
0.0410676673,
-0.0212673005,
0.073967509,
-0.0257370751,
0.0208514165,
-0.0870977268,
0.0247265752,
-0.0305251162,
0.0394618995,
0.005634028,
-0.0068864725,
-0.0122395204,
0.0348811038,
-0.050686989,
-0.0082890848,
-0.0080210157,
-0.0357084461,
0.0064828191,
-0.0589487813,
0.0040264889,
0.0057890201,
-0.018151693,
-0.0266263485,
0.0083592162,
-0.0064528501,
0.0581736863,
-0.0175472144,
-0.064281866,
-0.0434527285,
-0.0193047356,
0.0404346772,
0.0232423786,
-0.044842232,
-0.0002775441,
-0.0242764167,
0.0525473878,
0.0405045226,
-0.031329859,
0.0302756522,
-0.0282172486,
0.0033366769,
0.063863948,
0.0449103564,
0.0499930792,
0.0231294464,
-0.016546648,
0.0531950854,
-0.0644685701,
-0.0080914935,
-0.0014458406,
0.0578609295,
-0.0638872609,
-0.020674916,
0.1347978413,
0.0385935493,
-0.0051419991,
-0.0168476794,
-0.0477751978,
-0.0195194371,
0.0180624258,
0.0465161055,
-0.0583295263,
-0.0163719803,
-0.038532488,
0.0201472752,
-0.0193722267,
-0.0273184069,
0.0016937628,
-0.082737498,
0.0294519458,
0.0225543063,
-0.0256526433,
-0.0187415555,
-0.0608710647,
-0.0164838452,
-0.0076983105,
-0.0128710736,
-0.0153296748,
0.0031301333,
0.0219603777,
0.0241220407,
-0.0233462192,
-0.0604514778,
0.0737601593,
-0.0386286899,
0.0477521867,
0.0255180094,
0.0448815003,
-0.0565900728,
-0.0649655908,
0.0432495698,
-0.0240390804,
-0.0304843318,
-0.0245139431,
-0.026271658,
-0.0032332235,
0.0088429675,
-0.0405518673,
0.0244794097,
-0.0483829789,
-0.0179077685,
0.0379750282,
0.1194545627,
-0.0123432139,
0.0051644146,
-0.0581050441,
-0.0018587032,
0.0040792087,
0.1047458351,
0.0213957839,
-0.0625939891,
-0.012190572,
-0.0598483756,
-0.0000588099,
-0.0494716726,
-0.0328385755,
0.0112454044,
-0.0559002347,
0.0392570682,
-0.056067545,
-0.0251642745,
0.06301146,
-0.0327946544,
0.0262922216,
0.0174321756,
0.0008268601,
-0.0245081391,
-0.0678290501,
0.035605289,
0.0063273828,
0.0222839098,
-0.0729026943,
-0.0263175182,
0.0673076883,
0.0312061012,
-0.0541475117,
0.0047498709,
0.0089317635,
-0.0525155216,
-0.0072611887,
0.0494108833,
0.0091910651,
-0.0227082614,
0.022012705,
-0.0454562493,
0.0556939952,
0.0130939512,
0.0058637769,
0.0046107383,
0.0049135615,
0.0091564748,
-0.0051080249,
-0.0198548716,
-0.013896375,
0.0120941531,
0.0219783057,
0.0635882169,
-0.0161817893,
-0.0473533906,
0.0159983933,
0.0591480993,
0.0549528636,
-0.0310721546,
-0.044003237,
-0.0152109228,
-0.0040043923,
-0.0004215833,
-0.012255555,
-0.0161258113,
-0.0021944421,
0.0178532973,
-0.0120438859,
-0.0255543627,
0.0310047027,
-0.0833977386,
0.0289145876,
-0.0722035617,
0.0852004811,
0.0309129935,
0.0366671197,
0.0215303116,
-0.0234684385,
-0.0360325351,
-0.0272049643,
0.0233893245,
0.0393578969,
-0.0034778863,
0.0436374955,
0.0113463271,
0.0224904679,
0.0228997432,
0.0141531769,
-0.0729988888,
0.0365134962,
-0.0412142314,
0.0227682609,
0.0055936482,
0.0484250225,
0.026906563,
-0.0125916088,
-0.0231828075,
-0.0452072285,
0.0089689447,
0.0187970679,
0.0208962448,
0.07601282,
0.018237967,
0.0109318076,
-0.0061648567,
0.0454856791,
0.0212177485,
0.0466754958,
-0.0058124885,
-0.0254071858,
-0.0237057973,
-0.016206814,
-0.0097584845,
0.0053199907,
0.0032649029,
0.0026904226,
-0.0428339913,
-0.0283905473,
0.0594917051,
0.0470372476,
-0.0105119869,
-0.039123293,
0.0080523863,
0.0354112647,
-0.0547933653,
-0.0281226616,
-0.008428378,
0.0407410525,
-0.0292350091,
-0.0864045098,
-0.0115864547,
-5.447414942e-33,
-0.0222223736,
-0.0732508302,
0.0109623605,
0.0592012145,
0.0140068559,
0.0251662824,
-0.0342191644,
-0.0043607871,
-0.0258084107,
0.0305092745,
0.019287033,
0.0106404088,
-0.0035772582,
0.0209482908,
0.0310667418,
0.0062462217,
0.0256063174,
0.0066112308,
-0.0293020364,
0.0091436952,
0.0331051722,
0.0177527461,
0.0915980339,
-0.0623230934,
0.062547937,
-0.0108246505,
0.0101031885,
0.0023490121,
-0.024104178,
0.0448634438,
-0.0223420132,
0.0598540194,
0.0143240122,
-0.0328557231,
0.0057276627,
0.0274156332,
-0.0369618945,
-0.0604917891,
0.0099208076,
-0.0082413321,
-0.0296647605,
-0.0259295963,
0.0382823981,
0.012060063,
-0.0752201304,
-0.0139881875,
0.0707358941,
-0.0088353641,
-0.0275924969,
-0.0808070898,
-0.0567577668,
-0.0066439062,
-0.0119729238,
0.0083043799,
-0.027931815,
0.0512736663,
0.0017696288,
0.0543440841,
-0.0083734291,
0.0265420638,
0.0224009901,
0.0317428485,
0.022934556,
-0.0029746841,
-0.0046682507,
0.071444951,
0.0317270309,
-0.0084976144,
0.0121788867,
-0.0566115826,
0.0372775793,
-0.0205549877,
0.0999672487,
0.038383361,
-0.0061556106,
0.0470312238,
-0.0981604308,
0.0659148172,
0.0493314266,
-0.0119605493,
-0.0028751884,
-0.0213649832,
0.0192896128,
-0.0143339764,
-0.0455702171,
-0.0161410905,
-0.0157919601,
0.0049050236,
0.0183323529,
-0.0809863284,
-0.0231061261,
-0.0149102528,
0.0248084236,
-0.0386347659,
-0.0168725867,
0.0041604177,
0.0237010326,
0.0531865619,
-0.0085458113,
0.0422180593,
-0.0295767244,
-0.0035321955,
-0.0108478134,
-0.0010060165,
0.0432688594,
0.0025425521,
0.0286233779,
-0.0081305876,
-0.0231373589,
-0.0229515173,
-0.0204284452,
-0.0388999283,
0.0248931702,
0.0425139256,
-0.0142170945,
0.0275844205,
0.0253174026,
0.0415416062,
0.0361927375,
0.0114099691,
0.0013414716,
-0.0192624442,
0.0108128991,
0.0374653041,
-0.0220800769,
-0.0322022624,
-0.0112972902,
0.0157459229,
-0.0418519452,
-0.0480044596,
0.0111578051,
-0.0193454362,
2.365e-7,
0.0875757858,
0.0886463001,
-0.0358705036,
-0.0288562104,
-0.0000706862,
0.0284606759,
-0.0104906065,
0.0077613182,
0.031421259,
0.0224092938,
-0.0143517023,
-0.0402421951,
-0.0042267214,
0.0322464332,
-0.0789329484,
-0.0012681681,
-0.0241476074,
-0.0201599672,
-0.036943946,
0.0371052846,
0.0629203096,
0.0200866945,
0.006882837,
-0.0281266961,
-0.0367808081,
-0.0425017327,
0.053110037,
-0.0296013858,
-0.0252693258,
0.0524632484,
-0.0053204284,
0.032122165,
0.0350782238,
0.0591617599,
-0.0273401476,
-0.0087032896,
0.0110449828,
0.0403466113,
0.0104484903,
-0.03751361,
0.037625879,
-0.0068905819,
0.020664921,
-0.0570320897,
0.0229582544,
-0.0257512629,
0.0008597546,
0.0164752882,
-0.023125492,
-0.022915693,
0.0309699103,
-0.0428447314,
-0.0001587604,
0.0041956175,
0.0021529519,
-0.01098793,
-0.01588686,
-0.0324871168,
-0.060100738,
0.0225406755,
-0.0282004718,
-0.0491805561,
-0.0245931521,
-0.0299163219,
0.004012784,
-0.0689722002,
-0.0091850096,
2.423687058e-34,
0.0493441857,
-0.0272439662,
-0.0007041985,
-0.0087595107,
-0.0055106026,
0.0211460628,
0.024881918,
-0.0034967475,
0.0229922235,
-0.0593137853,
-0.0156477001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06563v1 | What is Hiding in Medicine's Dark Matter? Learning with Missing Data in Medical Practices | 2024-02-09T17:27:35 | 2024-02-09T17:27:35 | Neslihan Suzen, Evgeny M. Mirkes, Damian Roland, Jeremy Levesley, Alexander N. Gorban, Tim J. Coats | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IT, math.IT | Electronic patient records (EPRs) produce a wealth of data but contain
significant missing information. Understanding and handling this missing data
is an important part of clinical data analysis and if left unaddressed could
result in bias in analysis and distortion in critical conclusions. Missing data
may be linked to health care professional practice patterns and imputation of
missing data can increase the validity of clinical decisions. This study
focuses on statistical approaches for understanding and interpreting the
missing data and machine learning based clinical data imputation using a single
centre's paediatric emergency data and the data from UK's largest clinical
audit for traumatic injury database (TARN). In the study of 56,961 data points
related to initial vital signs and observations taken on children presenting to
an Emergency Department, we have shown that missing data are likely to be
non-random and how these are linked to health care professional practice
patterns. We have then examined 79 TARN fields with missing values for 5,791
trauma cases. Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) and k-Nearest Neighbour (kNN)
based missing data imputation methods are used and imputation results against
the original dataset are compared and statistically tested. We have concluded
that the 1NN imputer is the best imputation which indicates a usual pattern of
clinical decision making: find the most similar patients and take their
attributes as imputation. | [
0.0098526794,
0.0192305408,
-0.0176236294,
-0.0373973325,
-0.0112340748,
0.05675615,
0.032796815,
0.0140021127,
-0.0452249311,
0.0523200445,
0.0852425918,
-0.0379923172,
0.0347107351,
0.0245884806,
-0.0075288881,
-0.0634056628,
0.0233067591,
0.0494919531,
0.0036933722,
0.0144007783,
-0.0107578402,
-0.0093330899,
0.0030211292,
0.0382441394,
-0.0363543145,
0.0365449786,
-0.0093260957,
-0.0220042728,
0.019660959,
-0.0310389139,
0.0116953757,
-0.0220182166,
-0.027211627,
-0.0024682567,
0.0000022514,
0.0003173405,
0.0083008083,
-0.0137053393,
-0.0223470721,
-0.0638908967,
-0.0271775518,
-0.0550450794,
0.0064695585,
0.0284301601,
-0.0224595666,
-0.0570662133,
0.0582720116,
0.0372782983,
0.0041737282,
0.0169381555,
-0.0113400659,
0.0149119757,
-0.0216086674,
0.0067915381,
0.0878608674,
-0.0029589217,
0.0267339423,
0.0163654909,
0.0222312454,
-0.0811701342,
0.0078964969,
0.0501420796,
0.0534812808,
0.0494437218,
-0.0209399015,
0.0749354884,
-0.0252590161,
-0.003891574,
0.0134550892,
0.042525705,
-0.0035518485,
0.0101141976,
0.0484752655,
-0.0062654065,
-0.0249323957,
0.0025259466,
-0.0412218571,
-0.0130352899,
-0.0130461194,
-0.010273953,
-0.0371220298,
-0.0003785258,
0.021882331,
-0.0109516187,
-0.0185258854,
-0.0592557713,
-0.0111294081,
0.0122018941,
-0.0215481631,
0.0296592396,
-0.0560478233,
-0.002012596,
-0.008850378,
0.0030677996,
-0.0391277336,
-0.0091623068,
-0.0319343284,
-0.0496022403,
0.0632498115,
-0.0353834182,
0.0198511947,
0.0120609291,
-0.0259929951,
0.0014287587,
-0.0024752137,
-0.0213562977,
-0.0268815104,
0.0467129573,
-0.0567645133,
0.0250717085,
-0.0551741533,
0.0005021134,
0.0357922651,
0.0306850355,
0.0293029416,
0.0475771129,
-0.0369908139,
-0.0079472726,
-0.0190512575,
0.0005090007,
-0.0052511618,
0.0306410324,
0.0065794885,
0.0209564921,
-0.0323159881,
0.0140642775,
-0.0085039185,
0.0462030172,
-0.0176247433,
0.0070425742,
0.0162605476,
0.0012578486,
0.0372449122,
0.0348159932,
0.0321346819,
0.0058193193,
0.0400645733,
0.0198770221,
-0.0825249553,
0.0019236874,
-0.0057751969,
-0.0012174677,
0.0093804002,
-0.017503038,
0.0037877292,
0.0266359802,
-0.0359020717,
-0.0479398854,
-0.0104297521,
0.0150835412,
-0.0443543941,
0.0104819313,
-0.0959467888,
0.0258360654,
0.0319817849,
0.0020036567,
0.0043795933,
-0.0271881241,
-0.0038554834,
-0.0724683702,
-0.0241772812,
-0.0360817835,
0.0052643586,
-0.0242186729,
0.0217636675,
-0.0393337198,
-0.0263620298,
-0.0293271914,
-0.0326873511,
0.0426419154,
-0.0380603001,
-0.0054118345,
-0.0084678801,
-0.0238900166,
-0.0147801246,
-0.0338199288,
0.0078468109,
0.0272164922,
0.0215689391,
-0.0514474362,
-0.0228414219,
-0.0114838174,
0.0197467841,
0.0231029745,
0.0264813825,
-0.0321372673,
-0.043726638,
-0.0357977562,
-0.0323914997,
-0.0673174262,
-0.0266080741,
-0.0215008575,
-0.0240035355,
0.0113544194,
0.0701160207,
0.0011045787,
-0.0205200613,
-0.0066030077,
0.0233788956,
0.050431069,
-0.0363290198,
-0.0106738256,
-0.0293533467,
0.0469127931,
0.0084864218,
-0.0283433311,
-0.0515639745,
-0.0419113487,
0.0082563572,
-0.0753862932,
-0.0288002416,
0.002559908,
0.0366614498,
-0.0063647535,
-0.0051062908,
0.0330792293,
0.0481668971,
-0.0029537003,
-0.0758131891,
0.0321006849,
0.0226901025,
-0.0530609898,
-0.0675271824,
0.0481427014,
-0.0649369508,
0.0521392226,
0.0743816793,
-0.0060429377,
0.0101513453,
0.025253607,
0.0013950439,
-0.0046642032,
0.060552936,
-0.0213765055,
-0.0175842345,
-0.0463519432,
-0.0226174183,
-0.0201599486,
0.0227831658,
-0.0819234326,
-0.0092128851,
-0.0065429374,
-0.0308078285,
-0.0473095663,
-0.0180650074,
-0.0352066085,
0.0197248477,
-0.0228404421,
0.0028519398,
0.0225815456,
-0.0324893855,
0.0167970657,
0.0492790975,
-0.0085013323,
0.0328910612,
-0.0141184535,
-0.063036792,
0.0465404727,
-0.0148969591,
0.0027037957,
-0.0451641269,
-0.0856049955,
0.0199970435,
-0.0278896429,
-0.0168194138,
0.0121469721,
0.0365109295,
-0.0864932016,
-0.0154010365,
0.0019226401,
-0.0071567949,
0.0097502246,
0.0553228445,
0.0178227853,
-0.0506994762,
-0.0101549374,
-0.0371606313,
0.0324787423,
0.0113657257,
0.0379403159,
0.057434164,
-0.0006888249,
0.0042578843,
-0.001932823,
-0.0214503147,
0.0134547129,
-0.0048560523,
-0.0449849814,
0.0243572406,
0.0130316736,
-0.0386966877,
-0.0354675502,
-0.0425380617,
-0.0322493874,
-0.0173309706,
-0.0212402344,
-0.0471477844,
-0.017039625,
-0.0491015837,
-0.0090957331,
0.0217165872,
0.0296794567,
-0.0182903558,
0.0248456374,
-0.0202428903,
0.0153926695,
0.0212714672,
-0.0234432705,
-0.0283757932,
0.0159866344,
0.016893683,
-0.0152544798,
0.0024834217,
0.0218603704,
0.02153676,
0.0048132278,
-0.075379692,
-0.0207871813,
-0.0115411179,
0.0610221475,
0.0019157606,
0.001312869,
0.0068364311,
0.0596439205,
0.0317198336,
-0.0492726527,
-0.0394927971,
-0.0228692424,
-0.0419496521,
0.012441095,
0.0298769809,
-0.020980332,
-0.0333191529,
-0.0047966978,
0.0372692384,
0.0047890884,
-0.0138793178,
-0.0328619666,
-0.0043061567,
0.0254065376,
0.0600372069,
-0.0068756975,
-0.0612620153,
-0.0366468839,
0.0386955291,
-0.0320290811,
-0.0792065188,
0.0293145049,
-0.0658681914,
0.0066843047,
-0.0315830968,
0.0944301635,
0.0599579737,
-0.020305315,
0.0129211219,
-0.0142687401,
-0.004904069,
-0.0478421748,
0.0383630991,
-0.0254519377,
-0.0008544329,
0.033472769,
0.0296242274,
0.0363194421,
-0.0178792682,
0.0295440685,
-0.0556792766,
0.0022056531,
-0.0107035516,
0.0418360047,
-0.0536783673,
-0.0238712225,
0.0378810614,
0.039739877,
0.034283191,
-0.0260395333,
0.0189351086,
-0.0093737962,
-0.0499993041,
0.0103972135,
-0.0080256481,
-0.0275285188,
0.0293290261,
0.0024736901,
0.0477458872,
-0.040618524,
-0.0564620793,
0.0601534285,
0.0275316443,
0.0489695258,
-0.015397775,
-0.0371296741,
-0.0736772791,
-0.0250281692,
0.0182210077,
-0.0295075346,
0.0052220616,
-0.0224375781,
-0.0046968479,
-0.0140655711,
0.0065651378,
-0.0698270723,
-0.1057919338,
-0.0159826465,
-0.0264498312,
0.0526622124,
0.0432897061,
0.0298883617,
-0.0634068176,
-0.0052119959,
-0.0134754609,
0.0436885245,
0.0004056251,
-0.0090535786,
0.0851650238,
0.0786730722,
0.0016399812,
-0.0360054374,
0.0382635519,
-0.0501801483,
-0.000823702,
-0.0134115517,
0.094782941,
-0.0767406151,
-0.0337288901,
-0.0240446273,
-0.0028603845,
0.0533111766,
0.0353147648,
-0.0304913819,
0.0095062554,
-0.0137062175,
0.0552136414,
0.0412498452,
0.0624937043,
0.0362265408,
0.0651990697,
-0.0162907932,
-0.0420701988,
0.0118169291,
-0.0184398685,
0.0606823303,
0.0313119479,
0.0291510299,
0.0135231512,
0.000351383,
-0.0302323904,
-0.0472501144,
-0.0021099143,
0.0545900613,
-0.0049668737,
0.0179623663,
0.0322137102,
0.0125508085,
0.0012067558,
-0.0228174105,
-0.0821632892,
0.0364401229,
0.0384090282,
0.0244433247,
0.0062978598,
0.018039722,
-0.0010715681,
-0.0062476094,
0.0004209834,
0.0028654411,
0.0316107757,
-0.0485218428,
-0.0316311605,
-0.0495330505,
-0.0818616375,
-0.0051700212,
-0.0177442636,
0.0242611691,
0.0364165492,
0.0068842769,
-0.0049224687,
-0.002737731,
0.0608689003,
0.0263316222,
0.0175996609,
0.0759930089,
0.0096705332,
-0.0067766085,
-0.0360864066,
0.0039863805,
0.0202638377,
0.0298988689,
-0.0327485353,
-0.0273801796,
0.0452596359,
0.0459188074,
-0.0319958664,
-0.0109576546,
-0.0325052179,
-0.037730705,
-0.064545624,
0.0391913503,
0.0584956072,
0.0279541556,
0.0292768739,
0.0121847996,
0.0241941698,
-0.0176026672,
0.0449195392,
0.0600747988,
-0.001331166,
0.0215124805,
-0.0022624331,
0.0492009073,
-0.0268922094,
-0.0252791513,
-0.014190862,
-0.0568385683,
-0.0238555484,
-0.0148579674,
-0.0154813882,
0.0075350832,
-0.0465202071,
-0.0215542,
0.0266474821,
-0.0342045762,
0.0288330093,
0.0006093793,
0.034328483,
0.0071909362,
-0.0083054332,
-0.0338869803,
0.042192705,
0.0911804438,
0.0056655975,
0.077598758,
-0.0835440755,
-0.0205329303,
-0.0112828165,
0.0307590496,
0.0454375185,
0.0379294194,
-0.0365315303,
-0.0194266662,
-0.0372866541,
-0.0048912391,
0.0229813438,
-0.0369138047,
-0.0332524143,
0.0055665364,
0.0037903471,
0.0335037932,
-0.0068497071,
0.0444594547,
0.0045671393,
0.002057641,
-0.0010028686,
-0.0449455157,
0.0087863384,
-5.582860176e-33,
0.0446310155,
-0.0595820025,
-0.0056670993,
-0.0326400585,
0.0013537419,
0.0393350944,
-0.0404542312,
-0.0083633745,
0.0200196039,
0.0242070835,
0.0040279254,
0.0432487428,
0.0101725133,
0.0151255401,
0.1001007855,
-0.028813621,
0.0291619264,
0.0471562147,
0.0479959287,
-0.0125271175,
-0.0283472333,
0.0415647216,
0.0598315075,
-0.0870434716,
-0.0056562736,
0.0023664525,
-0.0170309469,
0.0004754421,
0.0044243913,
0.0120422617,
-0.0011471154,
0.0412321836,
0.0226652473,
-0.0245971289,
-0.0398500785,
-0.0434644744,
-0.0584468096,
-0.0016258165,
0.0330848843,
-0.0270760972,
0.0020920136,
-0.0190480184,
0.067215085,
-0.0220492985,
-0.0090771504,
-0.0016081744,
0.0325593166,
-0.0228538122,
-0.0268280059,
-0.0423518755,
0.0443627313,
0.0282410365,
-0.0678981617,
0.0307620019,
-0.0292568784,
0.0648177639,
-0.0532701053,
-0.03358154,
-0.0640680641,
-0.0249182675,
-0.009809982,
-0.0217860807,
-0.0263111368,
-0.0479718298,
-0.0182905998,
0.0873891935,
0.0718246177,
0.0086323395,
-0.0198630411,
0.0262135547,
-0.0188055206,
0.0307841524,
0.0402157642,
0.0539429374,
0.0217154231,
-0.0451209806,
-0.101845324,
0.0349424183,
-0.0649606809,
0.0586235896,
0.0018225559,
-0.0212715883,
-0.0467089601,
-0.0094458237,
-0.0006551813,
-0.0454272926,
-0.0090157185,
-0.030326141,
0.0166240335,
0.0023615826,
-0.0077169966,
0.0587361231,
0.0157754216,
-0.0450409465,
0.0491127521,
-0.0416807979,
0.0562805906,
0.0464637168,
0.0087165302,
-0.0177219212,
-0.0080777723,
-0.0022074063,
0.0282247625,
-0.0256479494,
0.0600823462,
-0.0287194829,
0.0624892414,
0.0108993202,
0.0026829795,
-0.016808439,
0.0716758668,
-0.0270949062,
-0.0135480892,
-0.0038210913,
0.0464715138,
0.0338827297,
-0.0225686952,
-0.0208749883,
0.0187693853,
0.014910927,
-0.0691860318,
-0.0485665984,
-0.0114290677,
-0.0728001818,
-0.0180571135,
-0.0598761998,
-0.0549553707,
-0.030417949,
-0.0132981064,
0.0074446178,
0.0200865678,
-0.0065135611,
2.865e-7,
0.0297950972,
0.0264358222,
0.0186087713,
-0.0943339393,
0.0164397862,
-0.008285623,
0.0117227025,
-0.0076896776,
0.0220953096,
-0.0169997532,
0.1204617694,
-0.0659535378,
0.0312722884,
0.0050724503,
-0.0575854108,
0.0092405211,
-0.0202200226,
-0.0132245645,
-0.0333058536,
0.0052553383,
-0.0003557173,
0.0307585653,
0.00121601,
-0.0296348613,
0.0194108672,
0.0667037517,
0.0062562735,
-0.0427231044,
0.0062265149,
-0.022826191,
0.0657904595,
0.0226779524,
0.0407755673,
0.0432901233,
-0.0218974259,
0.0003052974,
0.032078959,
0.051220797,
-0.0333604664,
0.0376791134,
0.0024462924,
0.0048340983,
0.0550209619,
-0.0466724597,
0.0835918337,
0.0017837351,
-0.0079018278,
0.044520244,
-0.0536693484,
0.0281953756,
0.1036755219,
0.0157627817,
0.0179536194,
0.0093780914,
-0.003547821,
-0.0126859834,
-0.031670481,
0.0461908169,
0.0385992937,
0.0733451322,
-0.0134081077,
-0.0275434107,
0.0383371115,
0.0159109905,
0.0419316813,
-0.0067667896,
0.0084298998,
2.270670984e-34,
-0.0015395295,
-0.0058067334,
-0.0016479419,
-0.0453115851,
-0.0086022029,
0.0245265085,
0.0493693165,
0.040007025,
-0.0087570446,
-0.0290731732,
0.0009364997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13812v1 | Quantitative Analysis of AI-Generated Texts in Academic Research: A Study of AI Presence in Arxiv Submissions using AI Detection Tool | 2024-02-09T17:20:48 | 2024-02-09T17:20:48 | Arslan Akram | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, stat.OT, 62P25, I.7; G.1; G.3 | Many people are interested in ChatGPT since it has become a prominent AIGC
model that provides high-quality responses in various contexts, such as
software development and maintenance. Misuse of ChatGPT might cause significant
issues, particularly in public safety and education, despite its immense
potential. The majority of researchers choose to publish their work on Arxiv.
The effectiveness and originality of future work depend on the ability to
detect AI components in such contributions. To address this need, this study
will analyze a method that can see purposely manufactured content that academic
organizations use to post on Arxiv. For this study, a dataset was created using
physics, mathematics, and computer science articles. Using the newly built
dataset, the following step is to put originality.ai through its paces. The
statistical analysis shows that Originality.ai is very accurate, with a rate of
98%. | [
0.0433779396,
0.0530024841,
-0.0272848941,
0.0461586975,
-0.060242746,
-0.0163458344,
0.0456168093,
-0.0157769863,
0.0277725738,
-0.0198261645,
-0.0013155317,
0.0540429503,
-0.0065090624,
0.0549848825,
-0.0060538147,
0.0349011645,
0.0055059968,
0.0282758884,
0.0474484377,
-0.0002795081,
-0.0068083308,
0.0055505214,
0.0170293599,
0.0419495814,
0.0162661411,
-0.0610688291,
0.0271376986,
-0.0224381313,
0.0341246948,
-0.0312428623,
-0.006409944,
0.0504164323,
-0.0333393179,
0.0946609005,
0.0000017224,
-0.0407655574,
-0.0085927015,
0.0515047237,
0.0004010373,
0.0412517786,
0.0336899087,
0.0654986724,
-0.025192989,
0.0075484994,
-0.0642639995,
0.0331168175,
0.0111743789,
0.0346142761,
0.0348403156,
0.0621004738,
-0.0106875552,
0.0006341969,
0.075961031,
0.0372092612,
0.0316097289,
-0.0068396553,
0.0124493642,
0.0066778148,
0.0094697485,
0.0493804924,
0.0373363197,
0.0406097472,
0.0141476579,
-0.0585374683,
0.0211324673,
0.0261426922,
-0.0588179603,
-0.0131030269,
-0.0060413792,
0.0166257899,
0.0430171564,
-0.0466584042,
0.080755733,
-0.0224352349,
0.020673912,
0.0545921698,
-0.0188237727,
0.0144569743,
0.003900121,
-0.0146908453,
0.0343516879,
0.0242133811,
-0.0057605635,
0.0161116775,
0.0335626826,
0.016083179,
0.0058531156,
-0.0463318639,
-0.0012434759,
-0.0258310586,
0.0162543599,
-0.0683212429,
-0.0017054204,
0.0095879855,
0.0539193526,
0.0124154724,
-0.0302129816,
-0.0718359947,
0.0190224852,
-0.0622286499,
0.0066343434,
0.0266049523,
0.0071704797,
0.0310707148,
0.0053662104,
0.0545415208,
-0.0387533493,
0.0305193625,
0.0132516325,
0.0528310016,
-0.0631033927,
-0.0302006584,
-0.0351739973,
0.0167541727,
0.083174333,
-0.001903493,
-0.0250281822,
0.0452128015,
-0.0368721746,
0.0179815982,
-0.0230800454,
0.023921825,
-0.0201956648,
0.0024564844,
0.0192939118,
-0.0255203061,
-0.0002712856,
0.0180602912,
-0.0249258559,
-0.03549188,
-0.0004735383,
0.0369751677,
0.0276963338,
-0.0398769528,
0.0063673877,
0.028390089,
0.0454990044,
-0.0240787175,
0.0174708907,
-0.0669972971,
0.0038171487,
-0.0264840163,
0.0372076593,
-0.0505656824,
-0.011660777,
-0.0068300562,
-0.0148352841,
-0.0726179779,
-0.0427004397,
-0.0061701378,
-0.0245545954,
-0.0135334441,
-0.0692414194,
0.0093455091,
0.0428181812,
-0.0020645706,
-0.028930774,
-0.0228578486,
0.0201174822,
0.0312806033,
0.035867691,
-0.0301860701,
0.073798053,
-0.0043784133,
0.0423980057,
0.0293910801,
0.0450316109,
0.0337453969,
-0.0596557148,
0.0060016126,
-0.0243888162,
0.053274747,
-0.0239255745,
0.0002018555,
0.0221239012,
0.0498362593,
-0.0167461075,
0.0553539768,
0.0154593149,
0.0332440324,
0.0467675515,
0.0061638118,
-0.0127808619,
0.0481369868,
-0.0422029644,
-0.0044744378,
0.0005710885,
0.017333515,
0.0025767228,
-0.0553221628,
-0.009806375,
0.0076422207,
-0.0224028435,
-0.0468242764,
0.0272460021,
0.0321440399,
-0.005900614,
-0.1047292277,
-0.0305449534,
0.004586353,
-0.0171633437,
-0.0753525943,
0.0481045581,
0.0197319314,
0.085771665,
-0.0378513746,
0.0261670128,
-0.025028307,
0.0048690797,
0.0335966684,
0.0099269766,
0.0063333847,
-0.0716696233,
-0.0000647326,
-0.0303496439,
-0.0460140556,
-0.0037101626,
0.0047656875,
-0.0092925811,
0.0409292206,
-0.005617701,
0.02511237,
-0.0622478835,
0.0304603409,
-0.0731287673,
-0.0423420481,
0.0029029192,
-0.0075495658,
0.0475191548,
0.0296825133,
-0.0452740267,
0.0702465624,
0.0511182584,
0.022698015,
-0.0407395959,
0.0486087203,
0.0759354904,
0.0652376264,
0.0439719483,
-0.1073199287,
0.0113918269,
-0.0316363871,
0.000646695,
0.0131326262,
0.065675281,
-0.0266880784,
-0.0016076206,
-0.0245841406,
-0.0152843259,
-0.0498600192,
0.0211284608,
-0.0084254453,
0.0498982593,
0.0007408754,
0.0430550128,
0.0386512838,
-0.0380458273,
0.0518931076,
0.0006100645,
-0.0223793145,
-0.0157663506,
-0.0353554823,
0.0379097126,
0.0575952902,
-0.0173977241,
0.0072127334,
-0.0148242852,
-0.0133577492,
-0.0498797148,
0.0115185454,
0.0021319159,
0.0076983729,
-0.0514049679,
-0.0168317482,
0.0421437845,
0.0247703716,
-0.0800103247,
-0.0001486233,
-0.0242438093,
0.0457172804,
-0.0205557887,
-0.002991234,
-0.0301594883,
0.0231209733,
-0.0490804464,
0.0167663973,
0.0878172815,
0.0189754479,
-0.0725697204,
0.0674477965,
-0.0083011445,
-0.0185194612,
-0.0229528304,
-0.0274389759,
0.0039532701,
-0.0150708873,
-0.0068515427,
0.038738627,
0.0054458035,
0.0254992843,
0.0268629454,
0.0240513887,
-0.0180771761,
-0.0106380535,
-0.0438105352,
0.0289518517,
0.0056293174,
-0.0507949255,
0.0608327389,
-0.0040552649,
0.0086620795,
-0.0261150058,
-0.033598084,
0.0440726765,
-0.0284001883,
-0.0378957279,
0.044507049,
-0.0652467012,
-0.0298641361,
0.0522402786,
0.0329865851,
-0.0414929017,
0.0235236138,
-0.0486490764,
0.010590598,
-0.0747065246,
0.003143636,
-0.017973125,
0.0318193324,
-0.0150452144,
0.0054030167,
0.0313226841,
0.049534183,
-0.0150352148,
0.0168375466,
0.0227287877,
-0.0034197294,
-0.0308534615,
0.0333080739,
0.0233911499,
0.0274800304,
0.0462961048,
-0.0184769332,
-0.05365628,
0.0303444825,
-0.0348679312,
0.0459124334,
-0.0557243116,
-0.0057751033,
-0.0210503601,
0.0537635833,
0.0143666742,
-0.008005619,
-0.0271071568,
-0.0120411851,
0.0127400979,
0.0376198813,
-0.0513012037,
0.0312474407,
0.0013256895,
-0.0057998719,
0.0319633149,
0.0190436095,
0.0248673838,
-0.0463329405,
-0.0751716793,
-0.024185298,
-0.0074900002,
0.0099948552,
0.0235858019,
-0.0072139548,
0.0104155773,
0.0044538863,
0.0441892482,
0.0248685274,
-0.0296451673,
-0.0070529655,
-0.0231150854,
-0.0058269324,
0.0046778438,
0.0232889354,
-0.063822411,
0.0646146312,
-0.0103467833,
0.0050815628,
-0.0800481662,
-0.0368048511,
0.0032528481,
-0.0366936736,
0.0714284778,
-0.0065680114,
-0.0425790064,
-0.0191663411,
-0.0521151423,
-0.0227253828,
-0.007100258,
-0.0455504842,
-0.0332375839,
0.0213784426,
0.0198283494,
0.0262584426,
-0.0565547571,
-0.0589493737,
-0.0281231832,
-0.0079253642,
0.0278437231,
0.039761927,
0.0822136924,
-0.0578785539,
-0.0347426385,
-0.0389317051,
0.0391704366,
-0.0116965501,
-0.0044301762,
0.048394639,
0.0164133254,
-0.0061374372,
-0.0237489752,
0.0441773646,
-0.0483346283,
0.0052936776,
0.023426801,
0.0856709629,
-0.0513236374,
-0.0499737039,
-0.0718673766,
-0.0558973104,
0.0275306627,
0.0492612757,
0.0063700685,
-0.0105208466,
-0.0252643786,
-0.0478855371,
0.04834776,
-0.0204072818,
-0.0282437112,
-0.0534068234,
0.0027693987,
-0.0493449643,
-0.0980484784,
-0.0506333411,
-0.0496570431,
0.0074660969,
0.0255040489,
-0.009943001,
0.0104565481,
-0.0090672188,
-0.033377178,
-0.0328514427,
-0.0156674515,
0.0265137423,
0.0003249058,
-0.0015591533,
-0.0271444395,
-0.0177237634,
-0.0448609963,
0.0144136576,
-0.0179818403,
-0.0437832549,
0.0150687275,
0.0470200218,
0.0311944317,
-0.0268462449,
-0.0308699012,
-0.0094967755,
0.0395876877,
0.0422438718,
0.0068795169,
-0.0121463342,
-0.0000284399,
-0.0380223915,
-0.0105550876,
-0.0397415124,
-0.0150114596,
-0.000454366,
0.0159607157,
-0.0338257886,
-0.0399039611,
-0.0081865592,
0.024266148,
0.0570321493,
-0.0025501905,
-0.0366622955,
0.0391568393,
-0.0007129166,
-0.0400142223,
-0.0157256629,
0.0009948575,
-0.0297995284,
-0.0003686602,
0.018735012,
-0.0078972066,
0.0147486934,
0.0656707287,
-0.0397673808,
0.0058142422,
-0.0098785544,
0.0413425118,
-0.0010435684,
0.10413526,
0.0129636573,
0.0110488292,
0.0073014963,
0.0280514192,
-0.0285549127,
0.0463194139,
0.0146402474,
-0.0066163847,
0.0246763099,
-0.0092668552,
0.0395706706,
0.0428992808,
-0.1146221533,
-0.0571358241,
-0.011740352,
0.0367536135,
0.014529204,
0.0668639392,
0.0240862891,
-0.0483268276,
0.0029561867,
-0.0200564098,
0.0553315245,
0.0384836718,
0.0033876661,
-0.0386969075,
-0.0163392983,
-0.0541320257,
-0.0373496413,
0.0786882341,
0.0139032966,
0.0168094225,
-0.0508221015,
-0.0070466902,
-0.0227203779,
-0.014674902,
-0.0202694107,
-0.0051498609,
0.0116619105,
-0.0173571184,
-0.047562439,
-0.0371513404,
-0.0275388025,
0.000660581,
0.0137462905,
-0.0267149508,
0.0024097811,
0.049025543,
-0.0277054328,
0.0053544538,
-0.0229475982,
-0.0033115926,
-0.0768739581,
-0.0542487465,
-0.0341725908,
-5.378242977e-33,
0.0448020957,
-0.0787537694,
-0.0072350283,
0.056927681,
0.0061487439,
-0.0012933105,
-0.0429034494,
-0.0388603993,
-0.0550865121,
0.0155825987,
-0.035792578,
0.0065063983,
-0.0063805985,
-0.053040415,
0.0483792499,
0.0222787913,
0.0142980916,
-0.0243537221,
-0.023523232,
0.0524992645,
-0.0001565658,
-0.0242474265,
0.0257295296,
-0.0847292617,
0.0590220094,
-0.0474986248,
-0.0135397045,
-0.0226231869,
-0.0232094824,
0.0535369739,
-0.0149854729,
-0.0202087183,
-0.0018434833,
-0.019321559,
0.0032500355,
-0.0274886433,
0.030136507,
-0.040589761,
-0.0027719091,
-0.0110126585,
0.0073609422,
-0.0611297786,
0.0422013626,
-0.0082207536,
-0.0606904626,
-0.0086630974,
0.0836542696,
0.0173035637,
-0.0254750289,
-0.0404723398,
-0.0385205597,
0.0048577227,
-0.0467180274,
0.041097682,
0.0222750809,
0.0055753044,
0.0082741491,
0.0430442095,
-0.0461866669,
0.0241676439,
-0.0076807709,
-0.0393171906,
0.0167390183,
-0.0451196544,
0.0675825849,
0.0355601609,
0.0468601547,
0.0351229161,
0.000991832,
-0.0048451652,
0.0328299142,
0.0648995265,
0.0652850792,
0.0522679798,
0.0279519297,
-0.0343626216,
-0.0065348987,
0.0108043533,
0.0036296328,
0.0274092499,
0.0335322134,
-0.0356648229,
-0.080313921,
-0.008357143,
0.0414486192,
-0.0846597701,
-0.0005921794,
-0.0353856981,
-0.0228811316,
-0.0245242417,
-0.0366957262,
0.0068029184,
0.0199540164,
-0.0621879101,
0.0036162201,
0.0326490849,
-0.0231539868,
0.057696864,
0.0300911106,
0.005020075,
-0.0614030398,
-0.0009514887,
-0.0024941445,
0.0225146785,
0.0719472468,
-0.0033655695,
0.0291882828,
0.0360297002,
-0.0240270887,
0.0186696555,
-0.0147047285,
0.0083533162,
0.0153577523,
0.0032804029,
-0.028729545,
0.0219318476,
0.0137888808,
-0.0136557743,
0.0316524953,
0.0567370467,
-0.0385590941,
0.0175819192,
-0.0167235788,
0.0124159129,
-0.0230695289,
-0.0074550346,
-0.0097530819,
0.0288490858,
0.0428845659,
-0.0802493617,
-0.0067088814,
-0.0247058161,
2.613e-7,
0.0033486343,
0.0470631234,
0.0299017224,
0.007953885,
0.0462372229,
0.0327950791,
-0.0340062752,
0.020764323,
-0.0003032697,
0.0498533733,
0.010990425,
-0.0273970161,
0.0280994941,
0.0202039201,
-0.0341794491,
-0.0368643068,
-0.1037159562,
-0.0156715941,
-0.0547321998,
0.0233513489,
0.0436817519,
-0.0155633045,
0.0335845016,
-0.0058903499,
-0.0037188639,
-0.0405552872,
-0.0004738093,
0.0435227044,
0.056286145,
0.061512351,
0.0033432145,
0.0169309508,
0.0123656495,
-0.0193781313,
-0.015223654,
-0.0068701049,
-0.009873216,
-0.0183806717,
0.0254506767,
0.0459361561,
0.0290791504,
-0.045869682,
0.0280033033,
-0.0473900214,
0.0377813727,
0.0168579575,
-0.0182303209,
-0.0377665423,
-0.0553660467,
-0.0478634425,
0.0253097843,
-0.0088884663,
0.0379707739,
-0.0062099299,
-0.0369945504,
0.0160519704,
0.0223004334,
-0.033152096,
0.0104699591,
-0.0354550667,
-0.0488006547,
-0.0489652716,
-0.0176313799,
0.0040357709,
0.052427806,
0.02038428,
0.0420093238,
2.351080537e-34,
0.037200667,
-0.0494232811,
-0.0005829222,
0.027418742,
0.0248659085,
0.0209343191,
0.0112342285,
0.0128435157,
0.0034744386,
0.0060487725,
-0.0062905857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06559v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06559v1 | Diffusion-ES: Gradient-free Planning with Diffusion for Autonomous Driving and Zero-Shot Instruction Following | 2024-02-09T17:18:33 | 2024-02-09T17:18:33 | Brian Yang, Huangyuan Su, Nikolaos Gkanatsios, Tsung-Wei Ke, Ayush Jain, Jeff Schneider, Katerina Fragkiadaki | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | Diffusion models excel at modeling complex and multimodal trajectory
distributions for decision-making and control. Reward-gradient guided denoising
has been recently proposed to generate trajectories that maximize both a
differentiable reward function and the likelihood under the data distribution
captured by a diffusion model. Reward-gradient guided denoising requires a
differentiable reward function fitted to both clean and noised samples,
limiting its applicability as a general trajectory optimizer. In this paper, we
propose DiffusionES, a method that combines gradient-free optimization with
trajectory denoising to optimize black-box non-differentiable objectives while
staying in the data manifold. Diffusion-ES samples trajectories during
evolutionary search from a diffusion model and scores them using a black-box
reward function. It mutates high-scoring trajectories using a truncated
diffusion process that applies a small number of noising and denoising steps,
allowing for much more efficient exploration of the solution space. We show
that DiffusionES achieves state-of-the-art performance on nuPlan, an
established closed-loop planning benchmark for autonomous driving. Diffusion-ES
outperforms existing sampling-based planners, reactive deterministic or
diffusion-based policies, and reward-gradient guidance. Additionally, we show
that unlike prior guidance methods, our method can optimize non-differentiable
language-shaped reward functions generated by few-shot LLM prompting. When
guided by a human teacher that issues instructions to follow, our method can
generate novel, highly complex behaviors, such as aggressive lane weaving,
which are not present in the training data. This allows us to solve the hardest
nuPlan scenarios which are beyond the capabilities of existing trajectory
optimization methods and driving policies. | [
0.0088569522,
0.023097137,
0.0230676178,
0.0124085415,
-0.0092316447,
-0.0199102107,
-0.0138856722,
-0.0068996181,
-0.0548967421,
0.0294956435,
0.0169048812,
0.0057668653,
-0.0345012434,
0.0084411968,
0.0027148607,
-0.0428318232,
0.0035872746,
-0.0858560428,
-0.0271486957,
-0.0148495706,
-0.0372712053,
-0.0229631681,
0.0010697121,
0.0108003384,
-0.0484559126,
0.0340859741,
-0.0331903845,
0.0660845563,
0.0523400903,
-0.0467240289,
0.0138632376,
-0.0100427885,
0.077585645,
-0.0132355737,
0.0000023362,
-0.0151547389,
0.0201549493,
-0.0296465587,
0.0062053548,
-0.0561983697,
0.0250984896,
0.0528406724,
0.003495262,
0.020241525,
-0.001447117,
0.0407051593,
0.0094691608,
0.0041955421,
0.0919997469,
0.0663750991,
0.0093735643,
-0.0389932245,
0.0034484277,
-0.0022786113,
0.0685805455,
-0.0018608002,
0.0237552579,
0.0259624142,
0.0364079885,
-0.0226853229,
-0.045273371,
0.0013614306,
0.0398434177,
-0.0653323159,
0.0284293797,
0.0353916176,
0.0652531311,
-0.0639898032,
0.0027998451,
0.0599180236,
-0.0493974648,
-0.0359774493,
0.0470532849,
0.0022352885,
-0.038824968,
-0.0220928006,
0.0049462211,
0.0142341983,
-0.0041611148,
0.0238158032,
-0.0357654393,
-0.0266059935,
0.0151939159,
-0.0133756725,
0.0145297134,
0.0568088219,
0.0009208586,
-0.0274141282,
0.0307914503,
-0.0053169685,
0.0296188705,
-0.06953042,
-0.0081292912,
0.0526772104,
-0.0503664613,
-0.0122003052,
-0.0026448735,
0.0137687242,
-0.033644028,
0.0380911566,
0.0806503221,
0.0256692171,
0.0400479548,
0.0338661708,
-0.0179016311,
-0.0148835285,
0.0027876722,
-0.0001485605,
-0.023756763,
0.0279826205,
-0.0328654163,
0.0649681166,
-0.0304169022,
0.0268633477,
-0.045750089,
0.0135252308,
-0.0107476795,
0.0311146285,
-0.0185579769,
0.026139142,
-0.0251552183,
0.0756841078,
-0.0174218807,
0.0123343104,
-0.0295344386,
-0.0768387541,
-0.0598518774,
-0.0124368928,
0.0369971357,
0.0760561675,
-0.010790159,
0.0162829608,
-0.0254949238,
-0.0114074461,
0.0233587604,
0.0912386999,
-0.0475776941,
0.0177106224,
-0.0509977564,
-0.0443468317,
0.0107673295,
-0.0415956154,
0.0515037961,
-0.0570834763,
-0.0164384507,
-0.0380001888,
-0.05167282,
-0.048756402,
0.0322902501,
-0.0172498152,
-0.0169094056,
0.0130193606,
0.0565023422,
0.0082441289,
0.0483203158,
-0.0041817981,
0.0203353297,
0.0643290132,
0.0293016974,
0.037872687,
-0.04068771,
0.0749272928,
-0.0053617018,
-0.0148139214,
0.0399428122,
0.0810073763,
-0.0084031885,
-0.0313721448,
-0.0280086882,
0.0725532621,
0.0572484918,
0.0275705568,
-0.0710550845,
-0.0249114186,
0.0070142634,
0.007631842,
-0.014440489,
-0.0606160648,
0.0209434833,
0.0306229293,
-0.0426625013,
-0.0578850396,
-0.0255718008,
-0.0029683642,
-0.0072741611,
-0.0071444516,
0.0029079844,
0.0165521149,
-0.0373047069,
-0.06038744,
0.043411959,
-0.0036734834,
0.0639982596,
-0.0147680398,
0.0116550876,
-0.021932641,
-0.0438965335,
-0.0396568552,
0.0023932862,
0.0212028455,
-0.0221199412,
-0.0425785668,
0.0598089993,
0.0318193845,
0.0096503664,
-0.0223250575,
-0.0672841519,
-0.0376977623,
-0.0215132106,
0.0116314767,
-0.0759729743,
-0.0108321067,
0.0620923676,
-0.0122639602,
-0.0420833081,
0.0078605395,
0.0215756427,
0.002039562,
0.0281298272,
-0.0037486074,
-0.0157047659,
-0.0019000417,
-0.0307164416,
0.0258411877,
-0.024511829,
-0.0371632241,
0.0207253173,
-0.0344166681,
0.0193190742,
-0.0140432706,
-0.0383904204,
-0.006592311,
0.0156593863,
0.0160613023,
0.0048890263,
-0.0334291123,
-0.0187836215,
-0.0085192174,
0.049530305,
-0.0676220953,
-0.0197349265,
0.0389819779,
-0.0290569011,
-0.0232397467,
-0.0177877061,
-0.0067716693,
-0.0323245563,
0.0339919962,
-0.0167610645,
0.0439183116,
-0.0239237361,
-0.0202006456,
0.0166591015,
0.0058599445,
-0.0461606309,
0.0411311388,
0.0336411968,
-0.0078963451,
-0.0333736613,
-0.018157715,
-0.0469186641,
0.013535467,
-0.031499967,
0.0283905603,
0.0488729663,
-0.0292681865,
-0.0140693448,
-0.001724849,
0.0019745734,
-0.0323845632,
-0.0239596404,
-0.0131809376,
-0.0103822472,
0.0107510975,
0.0077553755,
0.0246019308,
0.0424468108,
0.0037836425,
-0.0382262729,
0.0307975188,
0.0063040489,
-0.0086037321,
-0.033793088,
-0.0039087683,
-0.0295693334,
-0.0552545004,
0.0043378272,
0.0290982891,
-0.0147233391,
0.0547459014,
-0.0290663373,
0.0624259301,
-0.0028181705,
-0.0122651374,
0.0159062147,
-0.0094969794,
0.054801438,
0.08811149,
0.0091085108,
-0.0069929925,
0.009488564,
-0.0287149195,
-0.0464931838,
0.0428709388,
-0.0421754196,
0.0044291532,
-0.0381319225,
-0.034369152,
-0.0153278876,
0.0433247499,
-0.0219587144,
0.0216439217,
-0.0555597283,
-0.0192447305,
-0.0189165007,
-0.0766053125,
-0.0459909998,
0.0487350821,
-0.0367168412,
0.007109066,
-0.0538723134,
-0.0327596553,
0.0723421499,
0.0359564051,
0.0060824892,
0.0107934941,
-0.0088864015,
0.0210954975,
-0.0093471026,
0.0113028837,
-0.0144674201,
0.0133843059,
0.0482174829,
0.016011456,
-0.0154758729,
0.0021234443,
0.0164358336,
0.0422850437,
-0.0406854562,
0.0004112291,
-0.017239945,
-0.0384219848,
-0.0355772078,
-0.0409195237,
0.0384847634,
0.0169639252,
-0.0426123813,
-0.0489699021,
0.0141338035,
-0.0263965279,
0.0381520204,
0.0738266781,
-0.0239853468,
-0.0274825394,
-0.0028781348,
-0.0406488851,
0.0746715665,
-0.0112482989,
-0.0139059089,
-0.0523836315,
0.0350399949,
0.014633703,
0.0371993296,
-0.0184406731,
-0.0146341808,
-0.0165889412,
-0.013764929,
-0.0192738287,
-0.0245828442,
0.0943538249,
0.0956689641,
-0.0377452597,
-0.0911478624,
0.0350715406,
0.011908303,
-0.0043355357,
0.0070839128,
-0.0403467827,
0.0907918215,
-0.0038553223,
0.0432057269,
-0.0490708724,
-0.0293350089,
0.000649482,
0.0519002676,
0.0000932753,
-0.0017153737,
0.0443547405,
-0.0597491302,
0.0489548147,
0.0175832827,
-0.0285098646,
0.0421192087,
-0.0499320552,
-0.0324688293,
-0.016329186,
-0.0038681366,
0.0000945472,
0.0096003506,
-0.0021037972,
0.0272961836,
0.0479948223,
-0.0335791148,
-0.0244994555,
0.0035262995,
0.0148440273,
0.0775121674,
-0.0194390398,
-0.0344457105,
-0.0497408323,
0.0084331576,
0.0410429835,
0.0064777443,
-0.0238252822,
-0.0222504903,
-0.0201596394,
0.0390365236,
0.0221096687,
0.0476866551,
-0.0227034222,
-0.0166612081,
-0.0085114883,
0.0700792521,
-0.0680579692,
0.0005550001,
-0.0561703183,
-0.0177804641,
0.0749883652,
0.0278582554,
-0.0345035605,
-0.0371769853,
-0.0677169487,
-0.040810287,
-0.0524117947,
-0.0327407047,
-0.0591860041,
-0.0639084876,
-0.0278325398,
-0.0515150055,
-0.0524229109,
-0.0500596575,
0.0241399705,
0.039989423,
0.0020729464,
-0.0428083874,
0.0122580351,
-0.0292427428,
-0.0437175445,
-0.0316103883,
-0.0033814081,
-0.0065427753,
-0.0251874067,
-0.0081702974,
-0.0234792586,
0.007463905,
-0.0314205959,
0.004148934,
-0.0572610721,
-0.0701432154,
0.0303088333,
0.0680685937,
0.0097491546,
0.0607350804,
-0.0267765149,
-0.0149246873,
0.1232972145,
0.0207577441,
0.0999887064,
0.0448704138,
0.0338966548,
0.0079251919,
0.0054251151,
0.0250963625,
-0.0493947677,
0.0462428257,
0.0418981351,
-0.0053380677,
-0.023670081,
0.0809186697,
-0.0020131443,
-0.0214157104,
0.0448178202,
-0.0091817426,
0.0193441845,
-0.0140330661,
-0.0103217494,
0.004855454,
0.0056750621,
-0.054402139,
0.0261685345,
0.024592327,
-0.0067704138,
0.0171795897,
-0.0191002805,
0.0548518114,
-0.0174217466,
-0.0361797437,
0.0221162755,
0.0665331706,
-0.0165621676,
-0.0046100789,
-0.0090907058,
0.0440970659,
0.0237130802,
0.0136256274,
0.0390659124,
0.0411002636,
0.0232943688,
0.0442596003,
0.0384618677,
-0.0062001101,
-0.0142839532,
-0.0457355157,
-0.0585263632,
-0.0345876962,
0.0136676393,
0.0711272359,
0.0150967427,
0.0202153642,
-0.0749693587,
0.0147611555,
0.0187715665,
-0.0000609973,
0.0077581783,
0.0104722567,
0.0353979282,
0.0154448682,
0.0291550551,
-0.005328306,
0.0339839533,
-0.0036549976,
0.0844826624,
0.0022691356,
0.0434330627,
-0.0641602576,
-0.0045499229,
0.0160060283,
0.0232815128,
0.0272009354,
0.0128155472,
-0.002617202,
-0.0323532969,
-0.0330729187,
0.0803108439,
-0.0084855361,
-0.0345444195,
0.0751675218,
-0.0601596124,
-0.0333989412,
-0.0537062585,
-0.010173508,
-0.0418503582,
0.0059347651,
-0.046698235,
-0.041423507,
-6.844259287e-33,
-0.0018577202,
0.0091835661,
0.0203686971,
-0.0335226841,
-0.0495540537,
-0.0484249853,
-0.0189207103,
0.0202183649,
-0.0038201166,
0.0515749194,
-0.0398796722,
0.032577686,
0.0120706577,
0.0109354611,
0.0337113291,
-0.0428807102,
0.0289450213,
-0.0311298985,
-0.0588715822,
0.0445972085,
0.0211095419,
0.0128243798,
-0.0271536764,
-0.0070268167,
0.0229665637,
-0.0039589396,
-0.0290067997,
0.05045598,
0.0199293699,
0.0085710259,
0.0104512209,
-0.0077908449,
-0.0250284318,
-0.0418452509,
-0.0400651321,
-0.0257907044,
-0.0103724664,
-0.0387075469,
-0.0263472553,
-0.0370757692,
-0.1337586492,
-0.040708445,
0.0896565989,
0.041430749,
-0.0464621633,
0.0576851889,
0.0227931701,
0.0117649771,
0.0106949518,
0.027101554,
0.0052334224,
0.0039614467,
-0.0032815062,
-0.0615796633,
0.0468498319,
0.0053013396,
0.0024224829,
-0.0216736514,
-0.0279045962,
-0.0153654069,
-0.0089447079,
0.032941822,
0.0155029707,
0.0523485318,
0.0505198203,
0.0277683418,
0.0223543942,
-0.0173081364,
-0.0310830586,
-0.0053527928,
0.0149692232,
0.03481365,
-0.0377781391,
-0.0203577317,
-0.0099336253,
0.011571344,
-0.0269932803,
0.04892442,
-0.039861694,
0.0481042117,
-0.0150436424,
0.0191319399,
-0.0270211753,
-0.0088627636,
-0.0203190241,
-0.0290232096,
0.0157500561,
-0.0048033609,
0.0247360189,
0.0409909338,
-0.0244106259,
-0.0617266893,
0.0288025457,
0.000055844,
0.0480028875,
-0.0319268592,
-0.0045443233,
0.0143416664,
0.0362934135,
-0.026324695,
-0.0987855271,
-0.0551430508,
-0.0166268982,
-0.0101508265,
0.014841279,
0.0333370529,
-0.09094733,
0.0035609754,
-0.0205653701,
-0.0030922093,
-0.0525766276,
0.0455273204,
0.0195763409,
-0.0126644308,
0.0572778285,
-0.0076153446,
0.0106274365,
0.0115785366,
0.0190355759,
-0.0294406395,
0.0173007417,
0.0104032671,
-0.0105656702,
0.0128658889,
-0.0175153594,
0.0325333439,
0.006264694,
0.0165951699,
-0.0141618988,
-0.0621213764,
0.0148813874,
0.0515037663,
2.932e-7,
-0.0252891108,
0.0550764166,
-0.0167206526,
0.0346726812,
0.0219287015,
0.0563543551,
0.0000024752,
-0.0159182902,
-0.0464505963,
-0.0633182451,
-0.0053110649,
0.0655292124,
0.0041265953,
-0.0275441855,
-0.0523481481,
-0.010760474,
0.0242227558,
0.0233413558,
-0.0067206374,
-0.0103085265,
0.0162378009,
0.0555466823,
0.0035184422,
0.0020778265,
0.0289711822,
0.0798494071,
0.0250509791,
-0.005545665,
0.0324287824,
-0.0075146486,
0.0019127881,
-0.020652514,
0.0141337421,
0.0092817321,
-0.0204984937,
0.0159281362,
-0.0871859193,
0.0776231363,
-0.0118429633,
-0.0409226492,
-0.0142671531,
0.0070850095,
0.0182182752,
-0.0089345202,
0.0417399295,
0.0222496483,
0.0260442551,
0.0001391629,
-0.0057292189,
0.0057927179,
0.0311288163,
0.0254850518,
-0.0391943157,
-0.0356050059,
0.0116598317,
0.0335060954,
0.0193923637,
-0.0062384284,
0.0076451749,
0.0047519878,
-0.0016723206,
-0.0206545163,
0.0020676758,
0.062591359,
-0.0176994018,
-0.0027540056,
-0.0553958751,
2.579164094e-34,
0.0305296872,
-0.0369705521,
0.0098662106,
-0.0278310012,
-0.0279971976,
0.0371950306,
-0.050749097,
-0.008035467,
0.0276808962,
0.0198752116,
-0.0311454609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06549v1 | Bryndza at ClimateActivism 2024: Stance, Target and Hate Event Detection via Retrieval-Augmented GPT-4 and LLaMA | 2024-02-09T17:02:41 | 2024-02-09T17:02:41 | Marek Šuppa, Daniel Skala, Daniela Jašš, Samuel Sučík, Andrej Švec, Peter Hraška | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study details our approach for the CASE 2024 Shared Task on Climate
Activism Stance and Hate Event Detection, focusing on Hate Speech Detection,
Hate Speech Target Identification, and Stance Detection as classification
challenges. We explored the capability of Large Language Models (LLMs),
particularly GPT-4, in zero- or few-shot settings enhanced by retrieval
augmentation and re-ranking for Tweet classification. Our goal was to determine
if LLMs could match or surpass traditional methods in this context.
We conducted an ablation study with LLaMA for comparison, and our results
indicate that our models significantly outperformed the baselines, securing
second place in the Target Detection task. The code for our submission is
available at https://github.com/NaiveNeuron/bryndza-case-2024 | [
0.0545490421,
0.0890135989,
0.0168343,
0.0548739955,
-0.0068619186,
0.0211497489,
-0.0099304989,
0.0277744252,
-0.0015627724,
-0.0743490756,
-0.0223407596,
-0.032084316,
-0.0380761586,
-0.0002409508,
-0.0079297442,
-0.0438055433,
0.0444994606,
0.0465831123,
0.0420687459,
-0.0241202097,
0.0519869737,
0.0239360519,
0.0186638478,
0.0301231612,
-0.0357222259,
0.0127677312,
0.0345067941,
0.0068414728,
0.0648253635,
-0.0162425358,
0.0558732226,
0.0340452082,
0.030340584,
0.1098923758,
0.0000017944,
-0.0347135924,
-0.0342919603,
-0.0170517471,
0.0225116704,
-0.0107053882,
0.0711041838,
-0.0364595242,
0.0200783443,
0.0284319147,
-0.0311576817,
-0.0076589459,
0.0584054552,
0.0540065877,
0.0715252087,
0.0851313546,
0.0009951877,
-0.0298058782,
0.0434308276,
-0.0234748721,
0.0023120667,
0.0033738182,
0.04146602,
-0.0626724809,
-0.0488391109,
0.0696138367,
0.0135237686,
0.0375538059,
0.0068568224,
0.0327237584,
-0.0087306593,
0.0051108813,
-0.0589238219,
0.0099770585,
-0.0059159957,
0.0378289856,
0.0064205378,
-0.0300741438,
-0.009974665,
0.007555421,
-0.0267356168,
-0.0349547416,
-0.0598080866,
-0.0074206921,
0.0000108929,
0.050136596,
0.0034121578,
0.0098038586,
0.0450879224,
0.0815447569,
-0.0002800375,
0.0499269292,
-0.0204694718,
-0.0478253029,
0.0069221663,
0.0086859968,
-0.0206882916,
0.0117958551,
0.0197058022,
0.0036268614,
-0.0013961594,
0.013703566,
-0.0390859172,
-0.0099012973,
0.0204435159,
-0.0645150542,
0.0178576261,
0.0411580689,
-0.0166726485,
0.024017904,
0.0335209891,
0.0406961888,
-0.0240646377,
-0.0006636156,
-0.0247082729,
0.0024877891,
-0.0341991037,
-0.0238235593,
0.0016780595,
0.0013567425,
-0.0267824233,
0.02308302,
-0.0391631685,
-0.0233803429,
-0.0201491565,
-0.0379140377,
-0.0433498137,
-0.0078641679,
-0.0099204695,
-0.0083030444,
-0.0122544253,
0.0570702739,
-0.016710937,
0.0172975287,
-0.0377190113,
-0.0579646118,
-0.0174617041,
0.0272759888,
-0.0092944494,
-0.0430187583,
0.0277605522,
0.0416475125,
0.0186815336,
-0.0534319915,
-0.005428107,
-0.0155872852,
-0.0067033065,
-0.0639416575,
0.0063333637,
-0.0551570132,
0.0074838777,
-0.0155173251,
-0.0134960953,
-0.066255115,
0.0272571053,
0.0319901034,
-0.0275281966,
0.082766518,
0.0282005798,
-0.0384338796,
0.0444904268,
0.0425126031,
0.0293292366,
0.0847365633,
0.0126098739,
0.0481308028,
0.0365853645,
0.0225596521,
0.0021937303,
0.0420337394,
0.0503720529,
0.0419531539,
-0.0356754251,
0.0177261233,
-0.0672416836,
-0.0132369669,
0.0174699109,
0.0606698506,
-0.0102486666,
-0.0530474,
0.0597201176,
0.0813797414,
-0.0498591401,
-0.0005282664,
0.0033196989,
0.0048718294,
-0.0289977621,
-0.0331317,
-0.0359036401,
-0.0029349825,
-0.0487996265,
-0.0498569384,
0.0283116065,
0.0375051089,
-0.0262169372,
-0.0533264354,
-0.0357457772,
0.0100082709,
0.0059343572,
-0.0346262716,
0.0177929141,
-0.0363779925,
-0.034414351,
0.0226588454,
0.0126677863,
-0.0495076813,
-0.013448339,
-0.0617937185,
0.0016370236,
0.0101795401,
0.0197256207,
-0.0266590472,
-0.0430490933,
-0.0533123203,
-0.0163874943,
0.0425963402,
0.0125777898,
0.0018079641,
-0.0189059693,
-0.0302551575,
-0.0067487597,
-0.0052193585,
0.020097971,
0.029704487,
0.0607867241,
0.0173214078,
0.0389589742,
0.0198825821,
0.0106084226,
0.0322027989,
0.0396336615,
-0.053221222,
-0.0115199955,
0.0058884723,
0.0509200543,
0.0333485566,
-0.0217839386,
-0.0302955471,
0.0357261673,
-0.0354152694,
-0.0607193932,
0.0111952433,
0.0013274672,
-0.0164737366,
0.0446958803,
0.0026520477,
-0.0075150277,
0.1061618999,
-0.0222435277,
0.0068401909,
0.054594744,
-0.0062752035,
-0.0116512021,
-0.0546568297,
-0.0385836624,
-0.0566216893,
0.0447495431,
-0.0532899201,
0.0832826495,
-0.0178949516,
-0.00752794,
-0.0067643165,
-0.0495623052,
0.0489285886,
-0.0157155655,
-0.0538779981,
-0.0033263571,
0.0069411737,
0.0330156237,
0.0198648833,
-0.0040720301,
-0.0373282693,
0.0077447342,
-0.0859887004,
0.0246457346,
-0.0389494449,
0.0057443106,
-0.0014859517,
-0.0014175827,
-0.020585645,
0.017667016,
0.0040306686,
-0.0573481619,
0.0382860973,
0.0376546122,
0.0051108883,
-0.0264846943,
0.0036089194,
-0.062995322,
-0.018775681,
-0.0078112576,
0.0258057155,
-0.0036447435,
-0.07577084,
0.0391078852,
0.0196469408,
-0.0379933491,
0.0048217787,
-0.0226304624,
-0.0379652865,
0.0288480539,
-0.0219889283,
0.000732903,
0.035789676,
0.0371232852,
0.0962796211,
0.0040267305,
0.0170451719,
-0.0559640303,
0.016625043,
-0.0141373537,
-0.009498789,
-0.000618355,
0.0225783158,
0.0222949795,
0.0725614354,
-0.0007341254,
-0.0164260902,
-0.0441874936,
0.0352933072,
-0.0509674214,
-0.0193603989,
-0.0279352143,
-0.0477943942,
-0.0225210506,
-0.0245168265,
-0.0340315625,
-0.0830814093,
0.0608204082,
-0.0106967995,
0.0217879526,
-0.0593444221,
-0.0393529534,
-0.0237216894,
0.0688997731,
0.0165492129,
0.0110987928,
-0.0457170606,
0.0012696167,
0.0249611735,
-0.0543388426,
-0.0309758279,
-0.0349807069,
0.0323301479,
-0.0078039719,
0.0483830795,
-0.0179772843,
-0.0474734046,
-0.0495548025,
-0.075455986,
-0.0668592006,
-0.036905136,
-0.0215310082,
-0.0136949411,
-0.0441937111,
0.0308397803,
0.0329715349,
-0.0240638684,
-0.004648794,
-0.0040908461,
0.0275192335,
0.0125645194,
0.0044514574,
-0.0321183652,
-0.0080053508,
-0.0028763406,
-0.0434221104,
0.0565104075,
0.0323023126,
0.0270957556,
-0.030084122,
-0.0311191473,
0.0424680673,
-0.0084272726,
-0.0189400651,
-0.053411141,
0.0384002738,
-0.0326598883,
0.0192978662,
0.0963050351,
0.0259309318,
-0.0385295302,
-0.024110999,
0.0261623766,
0.0201847591,
0.0065709264,
-0.0111984843,
-0.0862188041,
-0.0175951831,
-0.0050786687,
0.0319701098,
-0.0524382666,
-0.0175878294,
-0.0269276705,
-0.0751900077,
0.0239114836,
-0.0063779536,
-0.0334079973,
-0.0430593081,
-0.0440724716,
0.0465353541,
-0.0077031986,
0.0016870169,
-0.0129351011,
0.0203661062,
0.0161595214,
0.0164860655,
-0.0395285897,
0.0013957502,
0.019904539,
0.0020393897,
0.0138577512,
0.0675440133,
0.0453122035,
-0.0139112864,
-0.0066760611,
0.0492485091,
-0.0242145248,
-0.0227012858,
-0.0596865118,
0.0171629805,
-0.0179295763,
-0.0136380587,
-0.0029850944,
0.0503956638,
-0.0121838478,
0.0038958131,
-0.0168006252,
0.0587876253,
0.0025679262,
0.0027425159,
-0.0522456951,
0.0243513398,
0.0058343508,
0.0443382859,
0.0254173931,
-0.0079503311,
-0.0025070331,
-0.0631426722,
0.0059613441,
-0.0544428565,
-0.0793372989,
-0.0423309281,
-0.0197695699,
0.0071748453,
-0.0059498753,
-0.0477767773,
0.0088947676,
0.016936643,
-0.0370470434,
0.0028025752,
-0.0174966697,
0.0131284026,
-0.0530249923,
0.0544159785,
-0.0336378142,
0.0555233993,
-0.0072196168,
-0.0086578056,
0.0331308171,
0.018218156,
-0.0395444818,
0.0373255797,
-0.0789450854,
-0.0490283184,
0.0000253651,
0.0276660118,
0.0241193864,
-0.0033128983,
0.0151114743,
-0.052779194,
0.0532596968,
0.1041116342,
0.0154508837,
0.0255884323,
0.0187922809,
0.026784163,
0.005179178,
0.024077706,
-0.0085519431,
0.0522769094,
0.0173674524,
-0.0040117842,
-0.0378217213,
0.0114338724,
-0.002302014,
-0.0054321163,
0.0833652094,
0.0135415923,
-0.0780536458,
-0.0370936915,
-0.0231524501,
0.0175640192,
-0.0423664488,
-0.0276942495,
0.0007125927,
0.0218672473,
-0.0122716557,
-0.0705543533,
-0.0086940574,
-0.0461512096,
0.0481714383,
-0.0764888749,
0.0353986546,
0.0326774307,
-0.0041040583,
0.0072850497,
0.0073621874,
-0.0350063406,
-0.0043559265,
0.0065270155,
-0.0202575568,
-0.0124830464,
-0.0090953195,
0.003025641,
0.0144204795,
0.0013884923,
-0.0049940944,
-0.0133842072,
-0.0110741453,
-0.0427468792,
-0.0184510965,
0.0066618454,
-0.0057329563,
0.0249753166,
0.015482421,
-0.0366429016,
-0.0302105993,
-0.006106148,
-0.0208800249,
-0.0317148678,
0.0454522707,
0.0361109972,
-0.0333359689,
0.0114323599,
0.0379794128,
-0.0137172667,
0.0506459773,
0.0802333653,
-0.044252757,
-0.0060186335,
-0.0312197879,
0.012774555,
0.001836543,
0.0284487251,
0.0163110439,
-0.0372493155,
-0.0300830361,
0.0439906679,
-0.0385840386,
-0.0146737564,
-0.0030192216,
0.0084619224,
0.0816522464,
-0.0131834066,
0.0219902974,
-0.0063456511,
0.0069502606,
-0.0389670171,
-0.0654506981,
0.000941535,
-6.110491836e-33,
-0.0159345735,
-0.0214556642,
0.0014606162,
-0.0096800402,
-0.0301852357,
0.0136558283,
0.0237983037,
0.0283393227,
-0.0177330263,
0.0212680344,
0.0169650875,
0.0235773176,
0.0008327111,
0.0119395591,
-0.0377790481,
-0.0011031493,
0.0254349597,
-0.0269675665,
-0.0106579307,
0.0230438691,
0.0524142906,
0.0171503238,
0.038162265,
-0.0632180572,
0.0319687128,
-0.0132166902,
-0.0093796272,
0.0079315947,
0.0147067867,
0.0686335489,
-0.0260518212,
0.1070792973,
0.0548597649,
-0.0312580876,
0.0240796171,
0.0589076094,
-0.0193013176,
-0.019627329,
0.0114787593,
-0.0157419946,
0.0239394102,
-0.0193048138,
0.027531473,
0.0037750651,
-0.0470061228,
-0.0173174404,
0.005740697,
-0.0167365987,
0.0229046978,
-0.0308032874,
-0.0631797165,
0.0476874858,
-0.025331093,
-0.0094774878,
-0.0128216576,
0.007180097,
0.0589285344,
0.0992885083,
-0.0718884766,
0.0258291177,
-0.0313131176,
0.0243166108,
-0.0059511135,
0.0067602233,
-0.0083116563,
0.0668210909,
-0.0092329709,
0.0057943901,
-0.0621095225,
0.0120443292,
0.0237798914,
-0.0028056763,
0.0330164209,
0.0731262043,
0.0320539102,
-0.0476463065,
-0.0749041811,
0.0214403793,
0.0921955332,
0.0075122882,
0.029439481,
0.0035796212,
-0.0255939495,
-0.0060391054,
-0.0215037949,
-0.0430446044,
-0.0487361029,
-0.0047001038,
0.0193477143,
0.027154617,
-0.015742762,
0.0141285509,
0.0435056202,
-0.0037373509,
0.0089563653,
0.0901327208,
-0.0272827242,
0.0083241239,
0.0263711195,
0.0697359368,
-0.0423716344,
0.0032528455,
-0.0043139742,
0.0060153976,
0.0084951762,
-0.0466096625,
0.0496586785,
0.0336036757,
-0.0761941224,
0.0178468134,
-0.0154743092,
0.0277890172,
-0.0490709543,
0.0344063081,
-0.0107426709,
0.0285841096,
0.0245880224,
0.0235261787,
0.0336540639,
-0.013419983,
-0.0033577373,
0.0027001107,
-0.0415905006,
-0.0171179995,
-0.0057376865,
-0.0046883957,
0.0082830377,
0.0358648151,
-0.0176658537,
-0.1007189825,
0.0170118362,
-0.0288727656,
2.538e-7,
0.0322802141,
0.0391513184,
-0.0173471235,
-0.012982782,
0.0095379753,
0.0387815982,
0.0117340609,
0.0450302884,
-0.0123063559,
0.0067218859,
-0.0484079458,
0.0560877882,
0.0133445039,
0.0299570393,
-0.0428607501,
0.0038828386,
-0.0461558923,
0.0013889675,
-0.0740962848,
-0.0002443666,
0.0083247665,
0.1052520201,
0.0533711091,
-0.0114756161,
-0.0143533368,
-0.0203880109,
0.0778904632,
-0.02913085,
-0.0408052243,
-0.0059833089,
0.0572105534,
0.0113470498,
0.0097797932,
-0.0372042395,
0.0025969413,
0.0398656875,
0.0192196239,
0.0608483292,
0.0238761418,
-0.0444779098,
0.0118568297,
0.0079388479,
-0.0214052666,
-0.0375620425,
0.0603604689,
-0.0144567266,
-0.0197879225,
-0.0403735936,
-0.0269529037,
0.0021264539,
0.0419459566,
-0.0230962951,
-0.027286524,
-0.003952744,
0.0087654945,
-0.011647068,
-0.0047802944,
-0.1103841439,
0.0094533227,
-0.0215815529,
-0.0560343638,
-0.0232990254,
-0.0370076597,
-0.0162255187,
0.0295693111,
0.0080908909,
0.0264806002,
1.966219324e-34,
0.0360305868,
-0.0225973278,
-0.0275996942,
-0.0315366164,
0.02159095,
0.022394225,
-0.0080675026,
0.0189484302,
0.0340585895,
-0.0563221499,
0.0120582674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06544v1 | Calibrating Long-form Generations from Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T17:00:32 | 2024-02-09T17:00:32 | Yukun Huang, Yixin Liu, Raghuveer Thirukovalluru, Arman Cohan, Bhuwan Dhingra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | To enhance Large Language Models' (LLMs) reliability, calibration is
essential -- the model's assessed confidence scores should align with the
actual likelihood of its responses being correct. However, current confidence
elicitation methods and calibration metrics typically rely on a binary
true/false assessment of response correctness. This approach does not apply to
long-form generation, where an answer can be partially correct. Addressing this
gap, we introduce a unified calibration framework, in which both the
correctness of the LLMs' responses and their associated confidence levels are
treated as distributions across a range of scores. Within this framework, we
develop three metrics to precisely evaluate LLM calibration and further propose
two confidence elicitation methods based on self-consistency and
self-evaluation. Our experiments, which include long-form QA and summarization
tasks, demonstrate that larger models don't necessarily guarantee better
calibration, that calibration performance is found to be metric-dependent, and
that self-consistency methods excel in factoid datasets. We also find that
calibration can be enhanced through techniques such as fine-tuning, integrating
relevant source documents, scaling the temperature, and combining
self-consistency with self-evaluation. Lastly, we showcase a practical
application of our system: selecting and cascading open-source models and
ChatGPT to optimize correctness given a limited API budget. This research not
only challenges existing notions of LLM calibration but also offers practical
methodologies for improving trustworthiness in long-form generation. | [
0.0103967087,
0.0737998486,
0.0000137461,
0.0357651152,
-0.0446896702,
-0.0168610066,
-0.0170249119,
-0.0320607312,
0.0079656346,
-0.0465585552,
0.0002898808,
-0.0860266387,
0.0329569615,
0.0236700661,
0.0199229289,
-0.0188630484,
0.0233116578,
-0.0322902314,
0.0004772368,
-0.0116583239,
-0.0007198899,
-0.002902451,
-0.0166516881,
0.0475746766,
-0.0014155339,
-0.0231582187,
-0.0038589614,
-0.0099681085,
0.0064518969,
-0.0211442355,
0.019725997,
0.0745621324,
-0.0145055754,
0.039711535,
0.000001987,
-0.0717217028,
-0.0074323807,
-0.0087226331,
-0.024295155,
0.0168016516,
0.0264656581,
0.0149803059,
0.0110249436,
0.0448199883,
-0.0377457961,
0.0198448822,
0.0459763072,
-0.0328596905,
0.0604349077,
0.0575092509,
0.025486229,
0.0083853947,
0.0292811319,
-0.014499519,
0.0180019606,
-0.0148254875,
-0.0075520831,
0.0364115126,
-0.0216196105,
0.0116479741,
-0.0055382666,
0.040807154,
0.0229604691,
-0.0285937414,
0.0121137295,
0.0260063019,
-0.0338914171,
-0.0279842913,
-0.0050432356,
0.054605823,
0.0552065074,
-0.0310069602,
-0.0097664343,
-0.0071535162,
0.0117050409,
-0.0035438151,
-0.0468296185,
0.037647415,
0.0102683017,
0.0022305951,
0.0124891326,
-0.0139025282,
0.0209292676,
-0.0075242361,
0.0030243422,
0.0725063086,
0.0298475195,
-0.021411689,
-0.0448418371,
0.0132786958,
-0.0154728806,
-0.0900661647,
-0.0160914455,
0.0405740179,
-0.0396582372,
0.0321452878,
-0.0745833516,
-0.0126175489,
0.0584958196,
-0.003785633,
0.0354722962,
0.0302087516,
-0.0073142969,
0.0000674944,
-0.0055191559,
0.0572785474,
0.0121754212,
-0.0232547112,
-0.0497449078,
0.003425899,
-0.0340867974,
-0.0009639285,
0.0040442576,
0.0101952581,
0.0010780335,
-0.0045257998,
-0.0842568055,
0.022450842,
0.0005485574,
0.0196069889,
0.0180915613,
0.0097933328,
-0.0282904543,
-0.0093564978,
-0.0273516998,
0.0615559369,
-0.0380889587,
0.0047026318,
0.0562333129,
-0.0567685068,
-0.009453536,
0.013224314,
0.0090352204,
-0.0001203343,
-0.0161847863,
0.0372289233,
0.0053095329,
-0.0067590317,
-0.0220939908,
-0.0704200417,
-0.0638059899,
-0.0762969032,
-0.0042680264,
-0.0968239382,
0.0096307285,
0.0295344274,
-0.0133036301,
-0.0189110376,
0.0127991606,
0.0165444277,
-0.006972027,
0.0256999843,
-0.0100189531,
0.0232441835,
0.0049629174,
0.0019670927,
0.0034213138,
0.0673653185,
0.0704137012,
-0.000330656,
0.0596833788,
0.0060207392,
0.038547799,
0.0374131054,
0.0224965625,
0.0144290095,
0.010384162,
0.01804219,
0.0199056882,
0.0379568115,
0.0210077912,
0.0696740448,
-0.0146611705,
0.0110370535,
0.0801094919,
-0.0027644667,
0.025511371,
-0.0393619165,
0.0368272699,
-0.007438384,
0.0247368328,
0.0310810711,
-0.0252765249,
0.0262411181,
-0.0459551811,
0.0440669432,
0.0519460104,
0.0238072127,
0.0007955932,
-0.0413759686,
-0.0281994119,
0.0026716767,
-0.037361566,
0.0132322023,
0.0156661794,
-0.0018249662,
-0.0177470036,
0.0602193587,
0.0097380728,
-0.0828133523,
0.0214780569,
-0.0515816584,
0.0671472326,
0.0382749848,
0.0379859619,
0.0268505495,
-0.0274342876,
-0.0038904126,
0.009233404,
0.0295638647,
0.0767925233,
-0.0228528827,
-0.0034947703,
-0.0362557694,
-0.016959358,
-0.0084634032,
0.0220450237,
0.0014481352,
0.0322507508,
0.0050822916,
0.0310202688,
-0.0675102472,
-0.0216539372,
0.0249851532,
-0.0331567116,
-0.0318076089,
-0.0126143359,
-0.0119649889,
0.0329392999,
0.0230702478,
-0.0074867783,
0.0481544062,
-0.0031159474,
-0.0013548731,
0.0000338156,
-0.0109604215,
-0.0432289504,
-0.0108503206,
0.0705986246,
0.0012331388,
-0.004489773,
-0.0001484465,
-0.0292373989,
-0.0565296859,
0.0075401948,
-0.0458974577,
0.0050562173,
-0.0480835587,
0.0259700324,
-0.0039775129,
-0.000070404,
-0.0395632833,
0.0343479887,
0.004958767,
0.025415482,
0.012449408,
0.0095690675,
0.0361479819,
-0.0369368345,
-0.0415986925,
0.0010350489,
-0.0175671335,
0.0280553773,
0.0557224415,
0.0205560047,
-0.0673689544,
-0.0489403717,
-0.0804102868,
0.0295329187,
-0.0321915634,
0.0397622809,
0.038178727,
-0.007221703,
-0.0093577001,
0.0376061648,
-0.0685709119,
-0.0055325525,
0.0301486421,
0.0178924669,
0.0330912024,
-0.0215344373,
-0.0067076548,
-0.0592536442,
0.0077087237,
-0.0213003103,
0.0372095704,
0.0318106413,
0.0473531745,
-0.0770799369,
0.0260744058,
-0.0698078871,
-0.0055806809,
0.0174558442,
-0.0447822548,
0.0418112837,
0.016128378,
0.0530947223,
0.0372349769,
0.0304672476,
-0.0485381447,
0.0623914115,
-0.0092140827,
-0.0564872324,
-0.0164638478,
-0.0407705829,
-0.050096903,
-0.0040369248,
-0.0655237287,
0.0012340751,
0.0501057431,
0.0239430424,
-0.0135603929,
-0.0518441685,
0.0357417762,
-0.0330530256,
-0.0265272278,
-0.0064487951,
0.0024866783,
-0.0308215301,
0.0448709764,
-0.0020405329,
-0.0726245567,
0.0701720864,
-0.0793213844,
0.021937089,
-0.0251390319,
0.0210652743,
-0.0211417954,
0.0745450705,
0.0079839639,
0.015933428,
0.0267432835,
0.0203142799,
-0.072689414,
-0.0095987543,
0.0399950743,
-0.0540418141,
0.0330881365,
-0.0699547157,
-0.0018967548,
0.005144598,
-0.0110363159,
-0.0436516479,
-0.0138688954,
-0.0270224288,
0.0031566224,
0.0187574178,
-0.0363927223,
0.0125753414,
0.0041831462,
0.0280713737,
0.021213416,
-0.0537846424,
-0.0054736394,
-0.0142928865,
0.0405455716,
0.0877775401,
0.0163226388,
0.0498375781,
-0.029062245,
-0.0006699575,
0.0477357432,
0.0439608358,
0.056085851,
-0.0247175377,
-0.0271654464,
0.0165755879,
-0.0233051293,
-0.0068525285,
0.0544915572,
0.0789470524,
-0.0408843756,
-0.0293587744,
0.1323002875,
0.0258761384,
0.0135560948,
-0.0041897646,
-0.0252472442,
0.065383032,
0.0134483604,
0.0143738277,
-0.0943879411,
-0.0082128746,
0.0066032005,
0.0636689663,
-0.0198636912,
-0.0292601027,
-0.0085064443,
-0.1493645012,
0.0487687811,
0.0173313878,
-0.0298277419,
-0.0089345211,
-0.0471641906,
0.007303298,
0.008866718,
0.0309882294,
0.0569535308,
-0.0075244145,
0.0236947071,
0.0203991309,
-0.0630264208,
-0.0368455425,
0.0171089545,
-0.0557159856,
0.0831553489,
0.0492195785,
0.0276508629,
0.0133775938,
-0.0393895544,
0.0336363353,
-0.0296782739,
-0.0397806875,
0.0126206754,
0.0388977751,
0.0224750023,
0.0042807399,
-0.0175499581,
0.0261229593,
-0.0320343748,
-0.0006290298,
0.010476049,
0.0470684096,
-0.0078250766,
-0.026274506,
-0.0249010827,
0.0141857918,
0.0185222849,
0.0827331245,
0.0445193239,
-0.0221983697,
-0.0345542282,
-0.030322792,
-0.000244149,
-0.0681696907,
-0.0065872101,
0.0333972313,
-0.0009729476,
0.0096034231,
-0.0884623453,
-0.0310937352,
0.0183681659,
0.0050208149,
0.005810163,
-0.0096925749,
0.0164801665,
-0.0215320531,
-0.0311701931,
0.00495223,
-0.0642709211,
0.0207237024,
-0.0498459116,
0.014341658,
0.0209300257,
-0.008805098,
-0.0082097463,
0.0438936874,
-0.0978248864,
-0.076812394,
-0.0044308593,
0.0669641048,
0.0262268484,
0.0281708483,
-0.0075193536,
-0.0323028639,
0.0396125093,
0.0276105125,
-0.0076903445,
0.019111596,
-0.0137187671,
0.0096774818,
-0.0171791725,
0.0276756696,
-0.0459397249,
-0.0250639059,
-0.001092732,
0.0770275444,
0.0229617711,
-0.0630370751,
0.028942341,
0.0502687618,
-0.0059801815,
-0.0369063579,
0.0094376104,
-0.0236691199,
-0.0089853304,
-0.0342604779,
-0.0308853053,
-0.0357426368,
0.0031196249,
0.0176184513,
-0.0266216714,
0.0100190556,
-0.0092944913,
-0.04188063,
0.055366531,
-0.0331162922,
-0.015366747,
0.0011231223,
0.0240994524,
0.0375373177,
-0.0258716792,
-0.0305113364,
-0.0154634165,
-0.0238405112,
0.0374905393,
0.0170333385,
0.0400830768,
-0.0024169972,
-0.0086766556,
0.0104381302,
0.0092614563,
-0.0669043511,
-0.0402535312,
-0.046292603,
0.0188230909,
0.0387267917,
0.026097687,
0.0723723248,
-0.0342078879,
-0.0029506208,
-0.0374984331,
0.0399517119,
0.0124946646,
-0.0210997816,
0.0174821354,
-0.0003541675,
-0.0297662895,
-0.0034706232,
0.0752709135,
-0.023117736,
0.0367460437,
-0.0188443195,
-0.0102258511,
-0.030451024,
-0.0522311293,
-0.049338825,
-0.0170017593,
-0.0269525964,
-0.0320879258,
-0.0584087782,
-0.0861111507,
0.0148824519,
0.0693514049,
0.0216091275,
0.0007748969,
0.015225593,
0.0741304904,
-0.0385417938,
-0.0125269843,
-0.050928697,
0.0193481576,
-0.0546279438,
0.005910181,
-0.025408309,
-6.456883205e-33,
-0.0321166813,
-0.0399416462,
0.026909411,
-0.0258281585,
-0.0333475135,
0.0013610828,
-0.0468248054,
0.0516262576,
0.0090246554,
-0.0064064041,
-0.0025915822,
-0.0157706514,
0.0148195587,
0.0317067429,
0.0265131555,
-0.0219027884,
0.0234107226,
-0.0067832409,
-0.059008237,
0.0100075612,
0.0330398008,
-0.0212202035,
0.0533784367,
-0.074900955,
0.0779753402,
-0.0178032033,
-0.0172146056,
0.0339824446,
-0.0109828897,
0.0746799931,
0.0017640048,
0.0377678834,
0.0035697427,
-0.0178776253,
-0.0056427564,
0.0029641541,
-0.0299732387,
-0.0258993134,
0.019720478,
-0.0246791989,
-0.0576126799,
-0.0299488064,
0.0216622464,
-0.0079005156,
-0.0391103439,
-0.014861472,
0.0188574903,
-0.028198842,
0.0037211396,
-0.0286159646,
-0.0428694226,
0.0168121755,
0.0114123849,
-0.0323743112,
-0.0619486719,
0.056827683,
0.018101519,
-0.0033469209,
-0.0317856371,
0.0080902809,
0.0370623544,
0.0479972921,
0.0930326656,
0.0218221806,
-0.0069490238,
0.0578979775,
-0.0121148005,
0.0100758811,
-0.0098509714,
-0.030444026,
0.0335200764,
0.0106489863,
0.0580068789,
0.0816767588,
-0.0068452256,
0.0038400055,
-0.0553180985,
0.0475993156,
0.0070082876,
0.010810731,
0.0177222639,
-0.0344684348,
-0.0145769585,
-0.0095188133,
-0.0744563267,
-0.0234023686,
-0.0349895135,
-0.0116054928,
0.0368792266,
0.0026972916,
-0.022827873,
-0.0615638979,
0.0372709595,
-0.0252785012,
-0.0393713117,
-0.0087656118,
-0.028737342,
0.0197522379,
-0.0152605707,
0.05229678,
-0.019829791,
0.0140063176,
-0.0029000563,
0.0125952139,
0.0035396316,
0.0270829275,
0.0117674014,
0.0075757639,
-0.0572442375,
0.0324940458,
-0.0398313813,
0.0263971779,
-0.010326094,
-0.0312080029,
0.0171084851,
-0.0056718634,
-0.0168782379,
0.0291335154,
-0.004124762,
0.0306248944,
-0.0337559506,
-0.007095607,
0.0035019328,
0.0215018671,
-0.0321151651,
0.0043584593,
-0.0270235408,
0.0160510503,
0.0260827299,
-0.0165164694,
-0.0080816867,
-0.0048520458,
2.616e-7,
0.0582650937,
0.0384679176,
0.0164275225,
0.0458103754,
-0.0037559641,
0.0222091079,
-0.0127936704,
0.01323805,
0.0325311571,
-0.0346661322,
-0.0204609856,
-0.0103588942,
0.0567249954,
0.0576863065,
-0.0711790025,
-0.0112847975,
-0.0665001571,
0.012533172,
-0.0234476589,
-0.0207239948,
0.0446526371,
0.0709953532,
-0.0040838965,
0.0024661804,
-0.0082620922,
-0.0397070907,
0.0660430938,
-0.0132156024,
-0.0352082327,
0.0679266229,
0.0559774339,
-0.0031602054,
0.0386539698,
-0.0043766745,
-0.0045356825,
-0.028414892,
-0.0176811777,
0.0458662137,
0.0540958568,
-0.0312423874,
-0.0071124099,
-0.0164769832,
0.0212711692,
-0.074020192,
0.0400827564,
-0.0481555611,
-0.0044365409,
-0.0539818071,
-0.0171731915,
-0.0180713572,
0.0294329002,
-0.0152450409,
-0.0073614107,
0.0428754091,
0.0074816709,
0.035130769,
-0.007794573,
-0.0331893526,
-0.0844083875,
-0.0067774286,
-0.018273633,
-0.0932706967,
-0.0058355201,
-0.0172069725,
-0.0002478887,
-0.0859836787,
0.0277580582,
2.534420003e-34,
0.0402585641,
-0.0036643508,
0.0128693217,
-0.0157261137,
0.0623551048,
-0.0110658891,
0.0253261216,
0.0022399537,
0.0224740151,
-0.0766420439,
-0.0426109172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10231v1 | A Multi-faceted Semi-Synthetic Dataset for Automated Cyberbullying Detection | 2024-02-09T16:53:19 | 2024-02-09T16:53:19 | Naveed Ejaz, Fakhra Kashif, Salimur Choudhury | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2 | In recent years, the rising use of social media has propelled automated
cyberbullying detection into a prominent research domain. However, challenges
persist due to the absence of a standardized definition and universally
accepted datasets. Many researchers now view cyberbullying as a facet of
cyberaggression, encompassing factors like repetition, peer relationships, and
harmful intent in addition to online aggression. Acquiring comprehensive data
reflective of all cyberbullying components from social media networks proves to
be a complex task. This paper provides a description of an extensive
semi-synthetic cyberbullying dataset that incorporates all of the essential
aspects of cyberbullying, including aggression, repetition, peer relationships,
and intent to harm. The method of creating the dataset is succinctly outlined,
and a detailed overview of the publicly accessible dataset is additionally
presented. This accompanying data article provides an in-depth look at the
dataset, increasing transparency and enabling replication. It also aids in a
deeper understanding of the data, supporting broader research use. | [
0.0996228829,
0.0285158232,
-0.0241545513,
0.0136544676,
-0.0308449119,
0.017555438,
0.0374884307,
0.0336466469,
0.0078927586,
-0.0186162051,
0.0055776644,
-0.0260495003,
-0.0324648432,
0.0113873705,
0.0428594761,
-0.024822304,
0.0029711954,
0.0568674207,
0.0243039876,
-0.008725089,
0.0567894764,
0.0125263464,
-0.0378209241,
0.0221225619,
-0.0734386444,
-0.0436534621,
0.0255947709,
0.006705523,
0.0258500986,
-0.0242341943,
0.0731131732,
0.0333851241,
0.013503042,
0.0537629016,
0.0000018987,
-0.0833421201,
0.0321699567,
-0.0330459997,
-0.0285613574,
-0.0087183472,
0.0294997916,
-0.0354833901,
0.0139392428,
0.0423606969,
-0.0469410419,
-0.0085228765,
0.0571950153,
-0.0187293328,
0.0607737117,
0.0291353874,
-0.0223193821,
-0.0337033682,
-0.0108923269,
0.0187271889,
-0.0123008145,
0.0774948299,
0.0238383766,
-0.0056717074,
-0.0204369258,
-0.0203044564,
0.0383097157,
0.0306447353,
-0.0090927901,
-0.0002222704,
0.0139284665,
-0.0254472662,
-0.0353133045,
-0.0465567261,
0.0279779527,
0.0399602018,
-0.0314006843,
-0.0221851338,
0.0323479399,
-0.0090866936,
-0.0266785491,
-0.0212882329,
-0.0321477875,
0.0236692969,
-0.0368254036,
0.0203380231,
-0.0418916903,
0.0196554065,
0.0461060591,
0.0409904234,
0.0473517962,
-0.0193178691,
-0.044783406,
-0.0081876051,
-0.0349859148,
-0.0186259449,
0.0051618922,
0.0228106659,
-0.006811819,
0.0170596223,
-0.0091189416,
0.0115656406,
-0.0839352831,
-0.0436261892,
0.0331207961,
-0.0356086567,
0.038726341,
0.0081681814,
0.0112000713,
-0.0113904933,
0.0238193907,
-0.002345976,
0.0050370363,
0.0358549505,
0.0087669473,
0.0074713496,
-0.0585884862,
0.0160955191,
0.0053908494,
-0.0202966724,
0.0742867067,
0.0410700254,
-0.0784781575,
0.0073329979,
-0.0566039942,
-0.0123493783,
0.0092881965,
-0.0220849141,
-0.0091142226,
0.0092980573,
0.0198180322,
-0.0573929772,
-0.05264429,
0.0072397096,
-0.0296281837,
-0.0570635796,
0.0159096941,
-0.0098979939,
0.0123908874,
-0.0243272707,
0.0101022795,
0.0851710141,
0.0462808125,
-0.0465011746,
-0.0402414203,
-0.0602666922,
0.0091038076,
0.0112340152,
0.0361740887,
-0.0442349352,
0.0729960352,
0.0050904327,
-0.0438352264,
-0.0306633394,
-0.0049315267,
-0.0001582082,
-0.0328114219,
0.0418605059,
-0.0426699705,
0.0304844137,
0.023372829,
0.0214190893,
0.0164321084,
0.0312102921,
0.0110101337,
0.0180907976,
0.0600936562,
0.0064836084,
-0.0016895037,
0.0334605835,
0.0564026721,
-0.0128419101,
-0.0045238589,
0.0043547614,
-0.028847903,
-0.0464827269,
-0.0320297144,
0.0195021238,
0.0037480427,
-0.053654708,
0.0430634767,
0.0242695566,
-0.0103457849,
0.0244679637,
0.0502792299,
0.007261619,
0.0180452019,
-0.0759297535,
-0.0533491559,
-0.047230009,
-0.0170048103,
-0.0433172174,
0.0091687813,
0.0453940183,
0.0022735149,
-0.0035878138,
-0.0425154231,
-0.0166314282,
0.0233682115,
-0.0256483369,
0.0279256254,
0.0492928699,
-0.0039004679,
0.0206594672,
0.0246579777,
-0.0249510016,
-0.0041097663,
-0.0201539528,
0.0345192328,
0.0529203638,
0.0204188377,
-0.00081782,
-0.0090114484,
-0.0388809778,
0.0190353319,
-0.0149422232,
-0.028275637,
-0.0141959982,
0.0156446919,
-0.0075164032,
0.0105851134,
0.0289671887,
-0.0415562578,
-0.0356707983,
0.1091548353,
-0.0048700469,
-0.0172252581,
0.067157805,
-0.0514707752,
0.0489630848,
-0.0098710945,
-0.0089235529,
-0.0001098385,
0.0428733937,
0.0532971621,
0.0118358014,
-0.0376155116,
-0.0716633871,
0.0310399365,
0.0329863727,
-0.00328592,
-0.0233316626,
0.0207979959,
0.007125238,
0.0846243575,
-0.0303647183,
-0.0045706178,
0.0281657875,
-0.0068236692,
0.0432889052,
0.0744889751,
-0.0472591929,
-0.0182275493,
0.0185325891,
-0.0546967126,
-0.0591062158,
0.063176468,
0.0576598197,
0.028180277,
-0.0229855962,
-0.0311323982,
-0.0079590045,
-0.0104740141,
0.0015021275,
0.0237142947,
-0.0277686287,
-0.0629953891,
-0.1006446704,
0.0143366829,
-0.0100486977,
0.0170331318,
-0.0304582566,
0.0140842078,
-0.0212751869,
0.0027868564,
-0.0154454624,
-0.0089692771,
0.0250352342,
0.0180529729,
-0.0427667424,
0.0358108394,
0.0218011066,
0.0105629563,
0.0549891107,
-0.0023612624,
0.0067710462,
-0.0645995215,
-0.0017645569,
-0.0312084462,
-0.016513966,
-0.0195278078,
0.0318611003,
0.0107620917,
-0.0507173389,
0.0351663567,
0.0390587226,
-0.0559392348,
0.0530223846,
-0.0272986237,
-0.0407651626,
0.0447454639,
0.0062571247,
0.009606,
0.0326671451,
0.0845485032,
0.0906493515,
0.0351553299,
0.0179352257,
0.0009337646,
0.0040488211,
-0.0204743277,
-0.03276705,
-0.0245099757,
-0.082850866,
-0.0077317636,
0.0451341979,
0.0398868807,
-0.0116234533,
-0.0131289642,
0.0420220606,
-0.0121082989,
-0.0145479329,
-0.0414373502,
-0.0609939247,
-0.0127391573,
-0.0199244767,
-0.0239355024,
-0.0941257104,
0.04490453,
0.0104609998,
0.0103441933,
0.0439477786,
-0.0639654621,
0.0474722162,
0.0290813465,
0.0346443392,
0.0029051972,
0.0028662218,
0.0267500412,
0.0513649583,
-0.0245551523,
0.0687293857,
0.0032973739,
-0.0206566378,
-0.0105568552,
0.0329807401,
0.0314086936,
-0.0052891527,
-0.0643087775,
-0.0367336087,
-0.0276986752,
-0.031996008,
-0.0024964046,
-0.002471786,
-0.0153727131,
0.0042210752,
0.0146525549,
-0.0340886302,
-0.0006952164,
-0.0223193318,
0.0496355034,
-0.0321329571,
0.0331550129,
-0.0467635691,
0.0126871653,
0.0015338397,
-0.0055144415,
0.0502413139,
-0.0099071413,
-0.0220670402,
0.0054369299,
0.0092968764,
-0.0127336271,
0.0280747972,
0.0330044068,
-0.0342044756,
0.0487768166,
0.0017792257,
-0.0307688322,
0.0427440479,
0.0333886445,
-0.015972577,
0.0244077127,
0.0315843225,
0.0087791514,
0.0268225186,
-0.0332574025,
-0.0587865375,
0.0079973796,
-0.0489562415,
0.05825831,
-0.0526866429,
-0.0275175031,
-0.0177872963,
-0.0474418141,
0.024901649,
-0.0326470323,
-0.02830722,
-0.0278016254,
-0.0103137922,
-0.0192827117,
-0.0168932695,
0.0042672032,
-0.0181901734,
-0.005423794,
-0.0208527967,
-0.0134858685,
-0.0634113625,
0.0056025446,
0.0214678925,
-0.0418736525,
0.0568397008,
-0.0461128652,
0.0495798811,
-0.021523932,
0.0133382324,
-0.0122952284,
-0.0141987875,
-0.0153538473,
-0.0088425921,
0.0768779293,
0.0119850608,
-0.0299258642,
-0.0293617751,
0.0608148687,
-0.0128706004,
-0.0376070291,
0.0462355129,
0.0172609352,
0.0084988922,
-0.0032642919,
-0.0400100425,
0.0279066134,
0.0120201129,
0.0482237525,
0.0317098498,
-0.0320311524,
0.0427769087,
-0.0515084565,
-0.0573897213,
-0.0462365746,
-0.079234533,
-0.0227061231,
-0.0470126383,
-0.0159975458,
-0.0056864675,
-0.033742018,
0.0153829716,
-0.008989051,
0.0209021848,
-0.0798186064,
0.011536642,
-0.0213926882,
-0.0849625096,
-0.0155794052,
0.0365959965,
0.055068288,
0.0284288432,
-0.0080142077,
-0.0213467777,
-0.0019358064,
-0.010474707,
0.0621017404,
-0.0452940576,
-0.0547255538,
0.0269300342,
0.033768747,
0.0143224187,
0.0376284197,
-0.0134232109,
-0.0469080135,
0.0386541262,
0.0183960032,
0.0333390683,
-0.0260649845,
0.0164380781,
0.000093152,
0.0260977186,
-0.0168234576,
-0.0043478976,
0.0179312695,
0.0132474974,
-0.0778940246,
-0.0671270788,
0.0044786208,
-0.0362123251,
-0.0019133162,
0.0228262953,
-0.0067174472,
-0.0313500203,
-0.000271937,
-0.0670200065,
-0.009522791,
-0.0191319194,
0.0402969643,
0.0127597228,
0.0008751255,
0.0238930248,
-0.0448756032,
-0.0367215984,
-0.0528777912,
0.0380930156,
-0.0407797024,
0.0233669356,
0.008218009,
0.0561677851,
0.0372040085,
-0.0032760687,
0.0135155506,
-0.0190703198,
-0.007455965,
-0.0039972905,
-0.00682056,
-0.0102115069,
-0.0147492457,
0.0435695201,
-0.0199479815,
-0.0384303108,
0.0162362307,
0.0135963392,
-0.0319894105,
-0.0117193423,
-0.0290842783,
-0.0091106668,
0.0834797621,
0.0178306773,
-0.0015838713,
-0.0082098348,
0.0379366279,
-0.0549633168,
-0.0571440905,
-0.048703149,
0.0393662043,
-0.0324679762,
0.0237454716,
0.0403886326,
-0.0051547498,
0.0139155239,
0.0265650414,
-0.0647980943,
-0.012664455,
0.026070077,
0.0246907175,
0.048853375,
0.0456921384,
-0.0348982811,
-0.0383767821,
-0.0520659387,
0.006528412,
-0.0405661426,
0.0249671955,
0.0056661526,
-0.0396519788,
0.0586284548,
0.0038000874,
0.0117204441,
-0.0359520391,
0.0118596628,
-0.0012232603,
-0.086068593,
0.0407659747,
-4.980147488e-33,
0.0235028509,
-0.0393907875,
-0.0010018169,
-0.0075808484,
-0.0258385837,
0.0017735339,
0.0055936566,
-0.0298327394,
-0.0210420061,
0.0018815257,
0.0042568357,
0.0277322512,
-0.0055968692,
-0.0034180193,
0.0114365574,
-0.0074340706,
-0.0271338727,
-0.0382066369,
0.0070188325,
0.0165915135,
0.0417757891,
-0.0112715373,
0.0349366106,
-0.0700874999,
0.0432808436,
-0.0329000764,
-0.012828704,
0.0217940453,
0.0303478893,
0.0621871017,
0.0045884945,
0.0883071497,
0.0253704544,
0.0266184136,
0.0020224375,
0.0234882366,
-0.0475311726,
-0.0042283139,
-0.0020218885,
-0.0425990783,
0.0271255057,
0.0240718219,
-0.0100400439,
-0.0013692961,
-0.0110999057,
-0.0639907941,
0.0684180558,
0.0065273438,
0.0188464783,
-0.0513718203,
-0.01089375,
0.0054409299,
-0.0587297417,
-0.0207533147,
-0.0281430874,
0.0923314169,
0.0284566004,
0.0363751464,
-0.1210198402,
0.0875473097,
-0.0318027698,
-0.0417636372,
0.0046952595,
-0.0108892033,
0.0265226886,
0.0325629935,
0.0225737598,
0.0334036835,
-0.0346925892,
0.0331055708,
0.0236898065,
0.0625281408,
0.033280775,
0.0612157993,
-0.0066489433,
-0.1142130494,
-0.0835800841,
-0.0066442653,
0.0856759176,
-0.0399312079,
-0.018710712,
-0.0064847413,
-0.0469394922,
-0.0438040793,
0.0441683866,
-0.0803983659,
0.0047745244,
-0.0250938255,
-0.0011971385,
-0.0296746511,
-0.0468108281,
0.0000815701,
-0.0044862856,
-0.0256139413,
-0.006083562,
0.0729148611,
-0.0186660402,
0.0337130837,
0.004726294,
0.0077366573,
0.0112519069,
-0.0076894835,
0.0402659252,
-0.0112702968,
0.023667885,
-0.0130675249,
0.076272577,
0.0244884714,
-0.0247203261,
-0.0074116052,
-0.0146452747,
0.0579438023,
-0.0557774231,
0.0126279294,
-0.0328274108,
0.0419573896,
-0.0112872971,
-0.0207283478,
0.04922821,
0.0012800096,
0.0089975605,
0.0446627066,
-0.0520460121,
-0.0184791405,
0.0690571219,
0.0094397552,
-0.0794002935,
0.0092919329,
0.0324412957,
-0.0599898063,
0.0282228384,
-0.0674604997,
2.512e-7,
-0.0158062782,
0.0520128496,
0.0145987384,
0.0211462006,
0.0445619263,
0.0086810868,
0.0667479709,
0.0257698521,
0.0078740679,
-0.0377804413,
0.0135577656,
0.0209267791,
-0.0055012787,
0.0615993142,
-0.0182771962,
-0.0146867279,
-0.057707835,
-0.0594637394,
-0.0744298473,
-0.0098252427,
0.018053595,
0.0353380851,
0.0841076002,
-0.0308689848,
-0.001356813,
-0.0140337292,
-0.0453230552,
-0.0269296169,
-0.0337989219,
-0.001372301,
0.0451304615,
-0.023479078,
0.0322390236,
0.0214880183,
-0.0303911492,
-0.0014751304,
-0.0237031672,
0.0005615334,
0.0293044485,
0.0170287434,
0.0358414724,
-0.012586046,
0.0044241226,
-0.0387386344,
0.0395630486,
-0.0155506982,
-0.0041388767,
-0.0107550006,
0.0044412897,
0.0076726056,
0.0178619307,
-0.0367812403,
0.0188973434,
0.0117847221,
0.0423887111,
-0.043412514,
-0.0051758066,
-0.0573588535,
0.0196728222,
0.0218177941,
-0.0349172875,
-0.021567164,
0.0445300713,
-0.0212082956,
0.0731889457,
0.0533151962,
0.0654422939,
1.553849707e-34,
-0.0372005887,
-0.0095843207,
0.0201384835,
-0.0538720377,
0.038005583,
0.0073058782,
0.010131089,
0.0039624544,
0.0480446033,
-0.0238105319,
0.0271604788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06529v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06529v3 | Introspective Planning: Aligning Robots' Uncertainty with Inherent Task Ambiguity | 2024-02-09T16:40:59 | 2024-06-04T02:25:30 | Kaiqu Liang, Zixu Zhang, Jaime Fernández Fisac | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) exhibit advanced reasoning skills, enabling
robots to comprehend natural language instructions and strategically plan
high-level actions through proper grounding. However, LLM hallucination may
result in robots confidently executing plans that are misaligned with user
goals or, in extreme cases, unsafe. Additionally, inherent ambiguity in natural
language instructions can induce task uncertainty, particularly in situations
where multiple valid options exist. To address this issue, LLMs must identify
such uncertainty and proactively seek clarification. This paper explores the
concept of introspective planning as a systematic method for guiding LLMs in
forming uncertainty--aware plans for robotic task execution without the need
for fine-tuning. We investigate uncertainty quantification in task-level robot
planning and demonstrate that introspection significantly improves both success
rates and safety compared to state-of-the-art LLM-based planning approaches.
Furthermore, we assess the effectiveness of introspective planning in
conjunction with conformal prediction, revealing that this combination yields
tighter confidence bounds, thereby maintaining statistical success guarantees
with fewer superfluous user clarification queries. Code is available at
https://github.com/kevinliang888/IntroPlan. | [
0.0328672044,
0.0352878906,
0.0102587389,
-0.0222697575,
-0.0504805148,
-0.0201113056,
-0.0524450429,
-0.0497670919,
-0.006169627,
-0.0171378702,
0.0124813206,
-0.0354244038,
-0.0007259494,
0.0258410815,
-0.0261814799,
-0.0490257815,
0.0304715671,
-0.0777692944,
0.0149381133,
-0.001237674,
-0.0528869405,
-0.0064815124,
-0.0405494384,
0.0518334173,
-0.0074348487,
-0.0028256122,
-0.0540119782,
0.0283230599,
-0.0035000585,
-0.0601237081,
-0.0276510678,
0.0376466475,
0.0486462042,
0.0143691553,
0.0000022166,
-0.0667200238,
-0.0582933426,
-0.0208895486,
-0.0190109778,
-0.0371795557,
-0.0119186258,
0.0204106066,
0.0133854467,
0.0282062087,
-0.0199085753,
0.0435805656,
0.0229862761,
0.0542184487,
0.0254083443,
0.0123798894,
-0.0007337076,
0.0078385007,
-0.0104700718,
0.0405092016,
0.0065494389,
-0.0657853559,
0.0083610304,
0.0027326387,
0.0359717049,
0.0283425972,
-0.0020892844,
-0.0014642874,
0.0154489074,
-0.0082730288,
-0.0364986509,
0.0162270386,
0.0267830789,
-0.0781980008,
-0.0107105356,
0.0003204801,
-0.0010390077,
-0.0207796097,
0.0250586662,
-0.0187970474,
-0.0002052699,
0.0189460777,
-0.0264821034,
0.0382044166,
-0.0238293745,
-0.0087587629,
-0.0506534018,
0.0050006201,
0.0091267843,
0.0211263932,
-0.0449764468,
0.1233766377,
-0.0222818591,
-0.0055086035,
0.0529139414,
-0.0163288452,
0.0044212672,
-0.0760374069,
0.0128105665,
0.0787356943,
-0.1008815095,
0.0126282321,
-0.0115634305,
0.0083651552,
-0.0031801863,
0.0016146068,
0.0333794765,
0.049961403,
0.0075700772,
0.0141034266,
-0.0022476553,
0.0770941898,
-0.0028123453,
0.0242878012,
-0.0401404873,
0.0149509637,
-0.0289147515,
0.011230425,
-0.0525585152,
0.001749426,
-0.0319678299,
-0.0215090811,
-0.0096179061,
0.0543336757,
-0.0085106688,
0.0300074499,
-0.0312407594,
0.038529072,
-0.008334578,
-0.0495422408,
-0.0753784031,
-0.0477508865,
-0.0408723392,
0.0332575217,
0.0130791813,
-0.0001038411,
-0.000155537,
0.0160898566,
-0.0185796823,
-0.000449287,
0.0051246849,
0.0997459814,
-0.0034621728,
0.0011012811,
0.0032331445,
-0.0533240065,
-0.0076132719,
-0.0661963895,
0.049758397,
-0.0317304917,
-0.0361961238,
0.01727443,
-0.0106154708,
-0.0252119601,
0.0295141898,
-0.0005750239,
0.0058266935,
0.0981626809,
0.0306343175,
0.0398647375,
-0.0149347186,
0.022243768,
-0.042861402,
0.0539705083,
0.0526791662,
0.0959326252,
-0.0151212132,
0.0399024338,
0.0223620478,
-0.0094627421,
-0.0582083091,
-0.0306575019,
-0.0085737044,
0.0090884622,
-0.021809008,
0.0462104082,
-0.0347742252,
0.0297153778,
0.0265281666,
0.0324885324,
0.0252875667,
0.0334807783,
-0.05532654,
-0.0517986901,
0.0319948867,
0.0393327512,
-0.0300885793,
-0.0390504822,
-0.0391098671,
0.0286636669,
-0.0378604457,
-0.0058889631,
-0.0156461075,
-0.0068283621,
-0.0033300612,
-0.0502572879,
-0.0501135774,
0.0096810153,
0.0572561435,
0.0162833817,
0.052130647,
-0.0074902778,
-0.0735560358,
-0.0104097277,
-0.0346809849,
-0.0061108507,
-0.0358421318,
-0.0472409502,
0.015161708,
0.053010609,
0.0103372186,
-0.0471545048,
-0.0758707821,
0.0203119386,
-0.0051967897,
-0.0040549953,
0.0054167635,
-0.0071174395,
0.0227868669,
-0.0184387416,
-0.0509343259,
0.0056775464,
0.0075722947,
0.0079376828,
0.0347598828,
-0.0147813028,
-0.0295081139,
-0.0138713401,
-0.013176417,
0.0378855951,
0.0023886785,
-0.0212649461,
-0.0032404561,
0.0001733876,
0.0307670198,
-0.004537066,
0.0072270595,
0.0344886072,
0.0620525256,
0.0242500193,
-0.0553500056,
0.0147405928,
-0.0066760834,
0.0512933061,
0.0450646617,
-0.0256800726,
-0.0374926738,
-0.0111761894,
-0.0141385142,
-0.0476691611,
-0.0098238261,
0.0080217365,
0.0042825043,
0.0433553085,
0.0335831568,
-0.0004687801,
-0.0669069439,
-0.0326293446,
0.0019565546,
-0.0139616644,
-0.0347171761,
0.0383720398,
0.0058977935,
0.0061660199,
-0.0005616635,
-0.0009955626,
-0.0017354613,
-0.0041622445,
-0.0250011701,
0.0394715257,
0.0575793087,
-0.0198885407,
-0.0541300364,
-0.0634086505,
-0.0277314968,
-0.0060323412,
-0.0273276158,
-0.0270259734,
-0.0296593811,
-0.0024581167,
-0.0087441336,
0.0518117994,
0.0309467651,
-0.0273633096,
0.0207937714,
0.0190041699,
0.0405895635,
-0.0254159532,
-0.0116931461,
0.021781994,
-0.0394839458,
-0.050060533,
0.0553197227,
-0.0288137831,
-0.0685606599,
0.0841746405,
-0.0230324268,
0.0127866017,
-0.0382347777,
-0.0289224256,
0.0430206135,
-0.0324532241,
0.0132211288,
0.05881951,
-0.0204856955,
0.0339281224,
0.1322926134,
-0.0283971895,
-0.0076564611,
0.0275976453,
-0.0318073407,
-0.0278223604,
-0.0229630396,
-0.0353950039,
0.0104872268,
0.0458409339,
-0.0230533555,
0.0160645898,
-0.056363292,
-0.0249580126,
-0.030657161,
-0.043099951,
-0.0126455994,
-0.011686937,
-0.026793927,
0.0975205228,
0.0219705291,
-0.0352829136,
0.0683358312,
-0.0076659266,
0.014779211,
0.0187352579,
-0.0195086077,
0.0120935487,
0.0940413624,
-0.0005010103,
0.0116111431,
0.049346637,
-0.0085618831,
-0.0600906052,
0.0000826952,
-0.0147658912,
-0.0106767192,
0.0330414064,
-0.0908848569,
0.0035463644,
0.018813407,
-0.0386016332,
-0.0480506606,
-0.0090821339,
-0.0528271236,
0.0182041507,
0.0094723245,
-0.0719870254,
-0.0350106992,
-0.0093076266,
0.047197964,
0.0172432661,
-0.026767822,
-0.0348838866,
-0.0251570214,
-0.074863866,
0.0489201806,
0.0331776775,
0.0380442105,
-0.0249642413,
-0.0015038832,
0.0175620951,
0.0495245159,
-0.021900855,
-0.027335614,
-0.0217118468,
0.0174164083,
0.0383317135,
0.033246167,
0.0767463818,
0.1130700484,
-0.0003183165,
-0.0478371456,
0.0909835622,
0.0279416293,
0.0230579581,
0.0138022862,
-0.0541181564,
0.0359797627,
0.0465326384,
0.0185382329,
-0.0039382912,
-0.0445603617,
0.0448743515,
0.0303084925,
-0.0198693536,
-0.0481359102,
-0.0175306033,
-0.0976162329,
0.0267704427,
-0.0111679547,
-0.0625071228,
-0.0435562469,
-0.0141716283,
-0.0082235336,
-0.0085628107,
0.0032493679,
-0.0014607767,
-0.0012335295,
-0.009318335,
0.0145088434,
-0.0685203373,
-0.0075057838,
0.0109848911,
0.0139806122,
0.0050559924,
0.0382736176,
0.0045339935,
-0.0059389388,
0.0088081332,
0.0171689466,
0.0446655639,
0.0206243992,
-0.033217553,
-0.0173137095,
0.0166185945,
0.0295401141,
0.0158489905,
0.00501404,
-0.0418004766,
-0.0680654123,
-0.0165441353,
0.0787037238,
-0.0522508807,
-0.0017427488,
-0.0275750179,
0.0156143662,
0.029668605,
0.0745109096,
-0.0273661111,
-0.0120219328,
-0.0502104647,
-0.0409800187,
-0.0065101446,
-0.0223423727,
-0.0007838705,
-0.009885015,
0.0047289105,
-0.0020161835,
-0.0321657993,
-0.0278465282,
0.0588797145,
0.0213728752,
0.0175004397,
-0.0429116972,
0.033361692,
0.039391201,
-0.0293421037,
0.0045947754,
0.0107059749,
0.0228577014,
-0.0324939638,
0.0236099791,
0.0279750023,
-0.0266741402,
-0.0161752515,
0.0448200963,
-0.0279972162,
-0.0619835034,
0.0355418958,
0.0700648203,
0.0309456214,
-0.0069421506,
-0.0275016669,
-0.0223455448,
0.0320740491,
0.0087747164,
-0.0103497952,
0.0069834599,
0.032090012,
0.0663538799,
0.0108522186,
0.0397572257,
-0.0621588454,
-0.0116805397,
-0.0173756443,
0.0084358128,
-0.036692135,
-0.0788723901,
0.0148451449,
0.0129698319,
0.0507230721,
-0.0310590416,
0.0093103033,
-0.0144361854,
0.0029620081,
-0.0281655677,
-0.0239469577,
-0.0469210781,
0.0218614601,
0.0175198093,
-0.0406151749,
0.0576655455,
0.0390450954,
0.0203142501,
0.0203122031,
0.03266773,
-0.0084606018,
0.0255864356,
0.0233648047,
0.0503350459,
0.0032660349,
-0.0015150175,
0.0084338514,
-0.0026828125,
0.0437465906,
0.0591767915,
0.0546746813,
0.0154413683,
-0.0251307506,
-0.0589895137,
-0.0126216225,
-0.0602652989,
-0.1552122682,
0.0212854706,
0.012483458,
0.0193864331,
0.0140090128,
0.0293260664,
-0.1027483195,
0.0251136813,
0.0007987435,
0.0117633026,
0.0288112331,
0.0003931038,
0.051850643,
0.0299135111,
-0.0200869069,
0.0029352685,
0.0361941382,
-0.0303817727,
0.0679199919,
-0.0070511675,
-0.0673854947,
-0.035684932,
-0.0282996912,
0.018997414,
0.0313834101,
-0.0143261896,
-0.0084537631,
-0.0601160191,
-0.0392290354,
0.0039079697,
0.0219178051,
0.0090692397,
-0.0481799319,
0.0505907089,
0.02178251,
-0.0059773908,
-0.0409945771,
-0.0033890053,
-0.0450344421,
0.0157610364,
0.0114891278,
-0.0450829826,
-6.295288731e-33,
-0.0136266109,
-0.07387802,
0.0212658755,
-0.0655840933,
0.0137521885,
-0.0392076708,
-0.0241571758,
0.0244314689,
-0.0028635,
0.0325995609,
-0.0302016325,
0.0071624801,
0.0254739877,
0.0040999544,
0.0531118922,
-0.0000609675,
0.0254629087,
0.0133198872,
-0.0307781156,
-0.0243428946,
0.0511297174,
0.0141384043,
-0.0024141145,
-0.0540076457,
0.0066025401,
0.0546441562,
-0.0425660461,
0.0733804852,
0.0000577578,
0.0000137915,
-0.0029470967,
-0.0331920572,
-0.0061643333,
0.0117724212,
-0.0447341017,
0.0068925335,
0.0065613757,
-0.0552954376,
-0.0274732187,
0.0289767683,
-0.0582811683,
-0.0042271814,
0.0225309562,
0.0154848816,
-0.0466899909,
0.0141514447,
0.0001435206,
0.0132411728,
0.0273102019,
0.0463708751,
-0.0160173066,
0.0025811358,
0.0071938587,
-0.0785735697,
0.044630643,
0.0739257038,
0.0199777838,
-0.0283621922,
0.0009936009,
0.0014505347,
-0.0092982966,
-0.0037008813,
0.082522437,
0.0205282122,
0.0133531019,
0.0539179854,
0.0092801349,
-0.0192895066,
0.0074422471,
-0.0040333411,
-0.0381191745,
0.0874172598,
-0.0264085121,
0.0087666921,
0.0099833012,
0.0488990769,
-0.0449761674,
0.025023995,
-0.0615656935,
0.0971206278,
0.0632291585,
0.020226717,
-0.0405565612,
-0.0117762545,
-0.0259188022,
-0.0057682334,
0.0056193043,
0.0140685728,
-0.0036474853,
0.0177961681,
-0.0023292892,
-0.0226671305,
0.0212523211,
0.0042503374,
0.0185986757,
0.0041177715,
-0.041900266,
0.0332594812,
-0.0113721909,
0.0426971614,
-0.0077637895,
-0.0150494557,
0.0077322344,
-0.0428278409,
-0.0023892373,
0.0410700031,
-0.0566686094,
0.065866746,
-0.0229132324,
-0.0112316767,
-0.0436765142,
-0.0119561814,
0.0166451931,
-0.0267022774,
0.0860338733,
0.008530261,
-0.0320847146,
0.0492160022,
-0.0092041623,
-0.0469786637,
0.0096629253,
-0.014407957,
-0.0038383931,
-0.0287997723,
-0.0077645374,
-0.0330540352,
-0.0136309983,
-0.0164798573,
-0.0042735413,
-0.0271022208,
-0.020183403,
0.0337284878,
3.128e-7,
0.0016097515,
0.0681145191,
-0.0068303766,
0.0592008978,
-0.0089400457,
0.0633757263,
0.0038719454,
-0.002206567,
-0.0325751454,
-0.0436937846,
0.0255390648,
0.0396695398,
0.0107663292,
0.0378951579,
-0.0371153653,
-0.025631493,
0.0312625617,
-0.0126085188,
-0.030308634,
0.0251108464,
0.0922567695,
0.0393202342,
-0.0037536381,
0.0087466901,
0.025255546,
-0.0277673341,
0.0184861049,
-0.0503645316,
0.0348047912,
0.0079415077,
0.0112423012,
-0.000218184,
0.0104309088,
0.0024024292,
0.0057078814,
-0.0225100052,
-0.0319010727,
0.0788587034,
0.0097384537,
-0.0281248838,
-0.026018925,
0.0010473406,
0.0046119676,
-0.0353792682,
0.0485084169,
-0.0804160312,
-0.0078435652,
-0.0053958492,
0.0465928502,
-0.0257365964,
-0.0064231073,
0.0211728364,
0.0115404585,
-0.0104778484,
-0.0274852123,
0.0292067379,
-0.0173989777,
-0.0401165411,
0.0270175431,
0.0155227333,
-0.0568081923,
-0.0174245965,
-0.0184595678,
0.0022018065,
0.0014672424,
-0.0587914959,
-0.0127266413,
2.99262288e-34,
-0.0126906801,
0.01084885,
-0.0105264839,
0.0316680074,
0.0353598855,
0.0269857813,
-0.0328450315,
0.0277602375,
0.0571671091,
-0.0277007148,
-0.0446066149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06512v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06512v3 | Multimodal Clinical Trial Outcome Prediction with Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T16:18:38 | 2024-05-09T01:22:35 | Wenhao Zheng, Dongsheng Peng, Hongxia Xu, Yun Li, Hongtu Zhu, Tianfan Fu, Huaxiu Yao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The clinical trial is a pivotal and costly process, often spanning multiple
years and requiring substantial financial resources. Therefore, the development
of clinical trial outcome prediction models aims to exclude drugs likely to
fail and holds the potential for significant cost savings. Recent data-driven
attempts leverage deep learning methods to integrate multimodal data for
predicting clinical trial outcomes. However, these approaches rely on manually
designed modal-specific encoders, which limits both the extensibility to adapt
new modalities and the ability to discern similar information patterns across
different modalities. To address these issues, we propose a multimodal
mixture-of-experts (LIFTED) approach for clinical trial outcome prediction.
Specifically, LIFTED unifies different modality data by transforming them into
natural language descriptions. Then, LIFTED constructs unified noise-resilient
encoders to extract information from modal-specific language descriptions.
Subsequently, a sparse Mixture-of-Experts framework is employed to further
refine the representations, enabling LIFTED to identify similar information
patterns across different modalities and extract more consistent
representations from those patterns using the same expert model. Finally, a
mixture-of-experts module is further employed to dynamically integrate
different modality representations for prediction, which gives LIFTED the
ability to automatically weigh different modalities and pay more attention to
critical information. The experiments demonstrate that LIFTED significantly
enhances performance in predicting clinical trial outcomes across all three
phases compared to the best baseline, showcasing the effectiveness of our
proposed key components. | [
0.0321701914,
0.1253449619,
-0.0027158468,
-0.014055524,
0.0018025715,
-0.0141843343,
0.0430027358,
-0.0051779705,
-0.056443423,
-0.0094595989,
-0.0412684083,
-0.0320376456,
-0.0058693541,
0.0906974599,
0.0331194811,
-0.054492712,
0.0284555871,
0.0139270648,
0.0181143507,
-0.0049438127,
0.0191446934,
0.0066152331,
-0.016911706,
0.0682810619,
-0.028394714,
0.0157756098,
0.0095767844,
0.0011589053,
-0.0009235255,
-0.0613547564,
0.007248194,
0.0618599392,
0.053136427,
0.0101557933,
0.0000018819,
-0.0378518887,
-0.0148596279,
0.0010700639,
-0.0117703946,
-0.064691186,
0.0646078065,
-0.0456577428,
0.0463536605,
-0.0200718455,
0.0133594899,
-0.0495378152,
0.0650431737,
0.0525625348,
0.0130688883,
0.0459984392,
-0.0258879401,
0.0118733868,
0.0681841597,
-0.0299867745,
0.048906479,
-0.0271281507,
-0.0050207227,
-0.0009189217,
-0.0099874074,
0.0042133727,
-0.0117091369,
0.0434412695,
0.0018493392,
0.0133169023,
0.0229975786,
0.0372047201,
0.0277360789,
-0.0386914462,
-0.0534389876,
0.0792988613,
-0.0247408785,
0.0254136175,
-0.0256238375,
-0.0181349386,
0.0032822147,
0.0370252207,
-0.0503374301,
0.0105031449,
0.0043949848,
0.0078597525,
-0.0391571745,
0.0578064583,
0.0343558192,
-0.0211223196,
0.004265538,
-0.0217184369,
0.0194311161,
0.01972338,
0.0027215483,
-0.0047933557,
0.0081775021,
-0.0210683569,
0.0046183271,
0.004452134,
-0.01544098,
-0.002600742,
-0.0305738375,
-0.0214191992,
0.0421391912,
-0.0258613843,
0.011195234,
0.0197636317,
-0.0664333701,
0.0445505008,
-0.0079803756,
-0.0320897102,
-0.0267177522,
0.0180473775,
-0.0188708361,
0.0013292762,
-0.0521177016,
0.007899682,
0.0234651845,
0.0312946364,
-0.0205612201,
-0.0279667564,
-0.0413435362,
-0.0028986323,
-0.0331502296,
0.0070498562,
0.0076185814,
0.0876319706,
-0.0660430565,
-0.0272273719,
-0.0406466685,
0.0621409565,
0.0166492611,
0.0329563133,
-0.0014917728,
-0.0386657454,
0.038758073,
0.0199664235,
-0.0049099186,
-0.025816232,
0.0272340048,
0.1108616814,
-0.011282946,
0.0061393036,
0.0007579139,
-0.0563299917,
-0.0309484918,
-0.0389412418,
0.0274054222,
-0.0424893759,
0.055975914,
-0.0007282528,
0.0151993735,
-0.0782504082,
-0.0115906941,
-0.0379498713,
-0.0112555604,
0.0901178718,
-0.0083603477,
-0.042703066,
0.0214944445,
0.0003991963,
-0.0244441796,
0.0390010588,
0.028216809,
0.0218227096,
-0.0146065988,
-0.0179100558,
0.0084190108,
-0.0017688082,
0.0216055457,
-0.0277873259,
-0.0517192073,
-0.0262680184,
-0.0241613965,
0.0500383675,
0.0059202495,
0.0335956551,
-0.0024827053,
-0.0255290531,
0.0559010059,
-0.0079190219,
0.0204305202,
0.0392722189,
-0.0026425906,
-0.0353196226,
-0.0258411393,
-0.0240840148,
-0.031756904,
0.0303308088,
-0.0280976314,
-0.0082981559,
0.0382874981,
0.0401693247,
-0.026896419,
-0.0400309414,
0.0073934132,
-0.0332796834,
-0.0047577759,
0.0157808252,
0.0417552553,
-0.0603550971,
-0.0439460725,
0.0106868502,
0.0530790463,
0.0177422352,
-0.0019888829,
-0.0179048367,
-0.0289503783,
0.0371489339,
0.0133331129,
-0.0485114269,
-0.0388687178,
-0.0308048241,
-0.0231238101,
-0.0284969285,
-0.0112613365,
0.0090845935,
0.0573937967,
-0.0285084452,
-0.0634033307,
-0.0010621424,
0.0123296222,
0.0105767064,
-0.0361025035,
0.01041508,
-0.0261112284,
-0.0537773483,
0.0203911271,
0.0206889901,
0.0085904598,
-0.0111325039,
0.0246838238,
-0.0184324123,
0.0543605685,
-0.0168699101,
-0.0232778359,
0.0091989255,
0.026158426,
-0.0576919578,
-0.0390649065,
0.0155713027,
-0.0245140921,
-0.0493569449,
0.0091604125,
-0.0607784279,
0.0150787635,
-0.0303192623,
-0.0636103004,
-0.0213875361,
0.0258291643,
-0.0373020582,
-0.0028753013,
0.013807768,
-0.040634077,
0.0408140197,
0.0305554178,
-0.0371981077,
0.0376096927,
-0.0286002439,
-0.0518300347,
0.0334952213,
-0.032364212,
0.0005633147,
0.0148173654,
-0.0282602347,
0.0147809172,
-0.0090902308,
0.0034970953,
0.0163580123,
-0.0340080112,
-0.0223960355,
-0.0203656144,
-0.1399140954,
0.0090667605,
0.0303749815,
-0.0208293553,
0.0027053272,
0.0143964961,
0.0105422921,
-0.0280178208,
-0.0469294526,
-0.0025321618,
0.0337755829,
0.0133720022,
0.0183140077,
0.0557948165,
0.0075755008,
-0.0421075076,
-0.0220486559,
-0.0168129764,
0.0863642991,
-0.0092195934,
-0.0348679237,
0.0039866506,
-0.0256723613,
-0.0395973511,
0.0261473637,
-0.0032537328,
0.0062808609,
-0.0069688344,
-0.0076384936,
0.0351648666,
0.0208841078,
0.0007573515,
0.0335615687,
0.0391233079,
-0.0087235533,
-0.0275027193,
0.0060437382,
-0.0334868506,
-0.0287002996,
0.0114311408,
-0.0276112091,
-0.0295492169,
0.0407308824,
0.0590667427,
0.0143455612,
-0.0363252871,
0.0054729111,
0.01976615,
-0.0324561596,
-0.0454107113,
0.0404064506,
-0.0093056792,
0.0357839726,
-0.0198296998,
-0.0667814538,
0.1304000765,
0.0242838338,
0.0159522649,
-0.0245937984,
-0.0106276888,
-0.0162955616,
0.005112506,
0.0036760634,
0.0235283487,
0.0135276429,
0.01002248,
-0.0312427152,
-0.0148037933,
0.0028791807,
-0.0132613089,
0.0444382317,
-0.0393318832,
0.0336513892,
0.0145799192,
-0.0207943507,
-0.0276188795,
-0.0412262864,
-0.0193479843,
0.0095289275,
0.0123779858,
0.0297848396,
-0.0608460009,
-0.001722233,
0.0065907254,
0.0143889198,
-0.0170556344,
-0.0022521287,
0.0035646777,
0.0355944559,
0.035603743,
0.0179289505,
-0.019795645,
-0.0515242219,
0.0021757295,
0.026616063,
-0.0077689518,
0.0038375831,
-0.0642396137,
0.0359401889,
-0.0060325074,
0.0395958498,
0.0010144102,
0.0529771075,
0.0533665158,
-0.0636347532,
0.0401875824,
0.0802702829,
-0.0262382142,
-0.0836352855,
-0.0001564838,
0.0366527513,
0.004348055,
-0.0188561808,
-0.005101725,
-0.0560230352,
-0.0756269693,
-0.041756101,
-0.0086435443,
0.0086559337,
0.004655303,
0.0131730512,
0.0139149949,
0.0392272435,
0.0078513995,
-0.0518242754,
-0.039802663,
-0.0432101153,
-0.0032588658,
-0.0462739281,
-0.0083909072,
-0.0393835939,
0.0184260514,
-0.0215829145,
0.0190520585,
-0.0282807555,
-0.1069217101,
-0.0044409982,
-0.0109738894,
0.0551307313,
0.0478044227,
-0.0252948161,
-0.0421296842,
-0.0088804802,
-0.0195719879,
0.0074157678,
0.0176272001,
0.0134796957,
0.0870926902,
0.0027695328,
0.0116014648,
-0.0300079454,
0.0536940396,
-0.0273504946,
-0.019827703,
-0.0394489877,
0.0905450135,
-0.0419639125,
-0.0302339792,
-0.0863733366,
0.0261229146,
0.0359842218,
0.0327781886,
-0.0003260195,
-0.0370894335,
-0.015112076,
-0.0145336268,
0.0464553498,
-0.0137683619,
0.0145829758,
0.0149792312,
-0.0211595241,
0.0050354134,
-0.0356918089,
-0.0230331738,
0.0508566014,
-0.0092967404,
0.0006216743,
0.0244596098,
-0.0072588073,
0.0027968003,
-0.0474199727,
0.0838350505,
0.0441733859,
-0.0079527041,
-0.0195528045,
-0.0189123526,
0.0489373766,
-0.0121940598,
0.0059115742,
0.0363491625,
-0.062832348,
-0.020346161,
-0.0502949245,
0.0710177422,
0.0131661259,
-0.0023933635,
0.0424484424,
-0.0616870224,
0.1024812907,
0.0114427945,
-0.0103801517,
-0.0474416278,
0.0275501572,
-0.0003591361,
-0.0149837034,
-0.0093041984,
-0.0336065739,
0.0456459671,
-0.0182852875,
-0.0147248842,
0.002146296,
-0.0337886997,
0.0345354304,
-0.0227696728,
0.0462544151,
-0.0541200489,
-0.015700236,
-0.0279622152,
-0.0283292029,
0.016691003,
0.0185584836,
-0.0430996716,
0.0188304484,
0.0311469622,
0.0096758315,
0.0030625155,
0.0288964696,
-0.0182578415,
-0.0144816013,
-0.0324022025,
0.0424542315,
0.0348135382,
-0.0137019083,
0.028031487,
0.0372853391,
-0.0084639126,
0.0199193917,
-0.0288710389,
-0.0046967766,
-0.0282513611,
0.0398511179,
0.0086437846,
0.0264807306,
-0.0237204395,
0.0588771589,
-0.0240284353,
-0.0056789787,
-0.0442630313,
0.0158222076,
0.0353490822,
0.0093470812,
0.0343708731,
-0.0201302022,
0.0237957481,
-0.0583132915,
0.0353058241,
-0.0315732583,
0.0436239243,
0.0559860207,
0.0029393332,
0.0124517512,
-0.0251872987,
0.0952315629,
0.0046438826,
0.0408474505,
-0.0261975341,
-0.0138300834,
-0.0448225327,
0.0100651551,
0.0769251063,
0.0496836975,
-0.0328744873,
0.0141612599,
-0.0140238851,
-0.0247047916,
0.0371570885,
-0.0259754211,
-0.0113942875,
-0.011978697,
0.0391368382,
0.0415790714,
-0.0112895127,
-0.003285727,
-0.009245988,
0.0307804029,
0.0418098271,
-0.0306369197,
-0.0427537784,
-5.736326841e-33,
0.0311400555,
-0.0043514022,
-0.0125555731,
-0.0751051605,
0.0243251324,
0.0248800665,
-0.0555433333,
0.0052562254,
0.0386725031,
0.0406300537,
0.0184660349,
-0.0212685056,
-0.0078824442,
0.0562235937,
0.0270298328,
-0.0107342917,
0.0431477763,
-0.0015799389,
-0.0021355022,
0.0480798073,
-0.0069363024,
0.0362586826,
0.0618899986,
-0.0981824845,
0.0191143304,
0.0620070174,
-0.0198647249,
-0.0164849721,
0.0103742164,
0.0562184565,
-0.0419766083,
0.0827154219,
0.0430700965,
-0.0230732504,
-0.0499099866,
-0.0345415361,
-0.0152095528,
-0.0111776618,
-0.0153553858,
-0.0328092948,
-0.066227071,
-0.0058477772,
0.0900988802,
-0.0197334681,
0.0016619788,
-0.0308347028,
0.0593026802,
-0.0228726026,
-0.0224212315,
-0.0255503375,
-0.029031517,
0.0398154221,
-0.0307318009,
-0.0056315525,
0.0126527678,
0.0224278253,
0.0173940323,
0.0165092926,
-0.0127408635,
0.0178745482,
-0.0342464782,
0.0142907593,
0.0397519954,
0.0016754109,
-0.0320800133,
0.0859286785,
0.014263154,
-0.0211347993,
-0.0216738191,
0.0024584825,
-0.0040010167,
0.0679642707,
0.043507535,
0.0758042485,
0.0453619696,
0.0262025017,
-0.0676970109,
0.0582265519,
-0.036246147,
0.0067063631,
0.0269724857,
0.0217189416,
0.0048769973,
-0.0261298362,
-0.0288132541,
-0.0053127459,
-0.0153499264,
-0.0333180428,
0.0148312002,
-0.0084814038,
-0.0079758624,
0.0236937143,
0.0714810789,
-0.0292957574,
-0.010748093,
-0.0025858127,
0.0361388326,
0.0334126838,
0.0115543148,
0.0249058306,
-0.0248454195,
-0.0200928189,
0.0580710992,
-0.0322277956,
0.0292143207,
-0.0088899639,
-0.0062838979,
0.0051026479,
-0.0223749503,
-0.0123819336,
-0.0148080438,
-0.0235347189,
-0.0001232702,
0.0516055599,
0.0220244564,
0.0185443889,
-0.0247049388,
0.0337753072,
0.0025710808,
0.0210773405,
-0.0349623784,
-0.0635984913,
0.023144044,
0.029518798,
-0.0416546948,
-0.0101472419,
-0.0725791305,
-0.0751988739,
0.0339383483,
-0.0475253239,
-0.0196318496,
0.011429606,
2.708e-7,
0.0606977083,
0.0360712707,
-0.0005957279,
-0.0547373593,
0.0430006981,
0.0496990271,
-0.0045647267,
0.0416074209,
0.0068207714,
-0.0740822703,
0.0573986024,
0.0105213989,
0.013051996,
0.0267059654,
-0.0081022512,
-0.0679099038,
-0.0327035487,
-0.0165213682,
-0.0366788208,
-0.0023228431,
0.0641354844,
0.1187692732,
-0.0178832151,
-0.0397229791,
0.0444619879,
-0.001212726,
0.0516730063,
-0.0378810801,
-0.0222496111,
0.0233582519,
0.0372332148,
-0.0108390274,
-0.0075385054,
0.0566075817,
-0.0098925158,
-0.0376723185,
0.0017279473,
0.0320906192,
-0.0481668673,
-0.0243248716,
0.0117402039,
0.0449426398,
-0.0022765524,
0.0002678012,
0.0393355191,
-0.0474226996,
-0.0537921004,
-0.059221603,
-0.0076967762,
0.0107766967,
0.0858355984,
-0.0148876142,
-0.0517186597,
0.0303186886,
0.0182505194,
0.0210997444,
-0.0472085252,
-0.0480040796,
-0.0144917397,
0.0559532456,
-0.0983478427,
-0.0234211814,
0.0065684435,
-0.0705156028,
0.029063208,
-0.0833205879,
0.0018229276,
2.202720064e-34,
0.0456818268,
0.0181348696,
0.0259561446,
-0.0087350225,
0.0285391621,
-0.0300021935,
-0.0361581892,
-0.000661037,
0.0120581975,
-0.0678672493,
-0.0295406282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06509v1 | Asking the Right Question at the Right Time: Human and Model Uncertainty Guidance to Ask Clarification Questions | 2024-02-09T16:15:30 | 2024-02-09T16:15:30 | Alberto Testoni, Raquel Fernández | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clarification questions are an essential dialogue tool to signal
misunderstanding, ambiguities, and under-specification in language use. While
humans are able to resolve uncertainty by asking questions since childhood,
modern dialogue systems struggle to generate effective questions. To make
progress in this direction, in this work we take a collaborative dialogue task
as a testbed and study how model uncertainty relates to human uncertainty -- an
as yet under-explored problem. We show that model uncertainty does not mirror
human clarification-seeking behavior, which suggests that using human
clarification questions as supervision for deciding when to ask may not be the
most effective way to resolve model uncertainty. To address this issue, we
propose an approach to generating clarification questions based on model
uncertainty estimation, compare it to several alternatives, and show that it
leads to significant improvements in terms of task success. Our findings
highlight the importance of equipping dialogue systems with the ability to
assess their own uncertainty and exploit in interaction. | [
0.0821597353,
0.0503692292,
-0.0328792669,
0.0048430986,
-0.0142293498,
0.003610184,
-0.0013420325,
-0.0019057302,
-0.0125565613,
-0.0229532532,
-0.007436661,
-0.0806594342,
0.0260945093,
0.0016980775,
0.0072692293,
-0.110349521,
0.0377953984,
-0.0539583303,
0.069400683,
-0.0155879511,
0.0025374435,
-0.0302392337,
-0.0223322827,
0.057579536,
-0.0387003236,
-0.0056175892,
-0.0541270785,
0.0264769271,
-0.0236178283,
-0.0091444356,
-0.0019568247,
0.0664610118,
0.0025049446,
0.0232434217,
0.0000017889,
-0.0399379507,
0.0352513678,
-0.0449097455,
-0.0686745271,
-0.0178896282,
0.0081495112,
0.0616341084,
0.0134177487,
0.0192691311,
-0.0261809211,
0.021120172,
0.0258991569,
0.0084302509,
0.022788072,
0.0121884402,
0.0128244944,
0.0384083055,
-0.0512057245,
-0.0046633887,
0.0122738937,
-0.0867167786,
-0.0155986948,
0.0316986889,
0.0446223542,
0.0219515357,
-0.0050747092,
0.0332694054,
0.0238888506,
-0.0371274129,
-0.0331851617,
0.0180489812,
0.0148545625,
-0.0933590978,
-0.0363689139,
0.0597225241,
0.0776990056,
0.0025539105,
-0.0286469907,
-0.0208990239,
0.054351788,
0.0552248023,
-0.0136301294,
0.018734375,
-0.0258420128,
-0.0438816585,
-0.0565595776,
0.000819385,
-0.0057375706,
0.0068782051,
0.0418879502,
0.0754005164,
-0.0297623705,
-0.0110542644,
0.0174301844,
-0.0064773448,
-0.0610204451,
-0.084872596,
0.0176585484,
0.051920563,
-0.108506836,
0.0180332251,
-0.0213145353,
-0.0033211729,
0.0333911479,
0.0085205389,
0.0158264376,
0.0352849737,
-0.0050621759,
0.0295640919,
0.0537248291,
0.0364202298,
0.0009919147,
-0.0153915361,
-0.0299468022,
-0.0022531017,
-0.025759358,
-0.0233182125,
-0.0739946961,
0.0047925883,
-0.0507690907,
-0.0088481726,
-0.0089972038,
0.0378524065,
-0.0037755989,
0.0436912253,
-0.0293822028,
0.033967223,
-0.027192615,
-0.0112504195,
-0.0456127189,
-0.0125171551,
-0.0688005388,
0.036082346,
0.0555893593,
-0.0561674498,
-0.016120214,
0.0201403592,
-0.0126272682,
0.0102471812,
-0.0322422609,
0.045868434,
-0.0355152264,
0.0146204745,
0.0209268183,
-0.0425726511,
-0.0397996493,
-0.039664831,
-0.0302696731,
0.0032333748,
-0.0158101134,
0.0261083152,
-0.022641344,
-0.0235755257,
0.0281596277,
0.0033848777,
0.0103937052,
0.0731448978,
-0.0328915156,
0.0260051191,
0.0763074756,
0.0366695859,
-0.064716436,
0.0405839533,
0.0533919595,
0.0104706157,
0.0405823849,
0.0025181656,
0.033208102,
-0.0049235919,
-0.0011734723,
-0.0266891923,
-0.0172278527,
0.0204394739,
-0.0468254201,
0.032870464,
-0.0147048216,
0.0713254586,
-0.029777579,
0.0050989487,
0.0710103884,
0.0483305454,
-0.0603470206,
-0.0268259719,
0.0263120681,
0.0336626247,
0.0149397021,
0.0191936828,
-0.0083446875,
0.0195842236,
-0.0176467877,
0.0252577662,
-0.0068506133,
-0.0351285376,
-0.0195894185,
-0.0793091729,
-0.044449985,
0.0372470096,
0.0332808085,
0.0454048552,
0.0184019152,
0.0023557686,
0.0059361807,
0.05155297,
-0.0095718019,
-0.0310100131,
-0.0158496816,
-0.0624217242,
0.0623107515,
0.0236101374,
0.0199663639,
0.0011151634,
-0.0960839987,
0.0003723555,
0.0212362632,
0.0305583142,
0.0805751234,
-0.033050444,
0.0346652009,
-0.0212969184,
-0.0007984773,
0.0202696919,
0.0126036489,
-0.0292102676,
0.0329821259,
-0.0231516324,
-0.0004134765,
-0.008418465,
-0.0031690693,
0.0072048539,
0.0197843798,
0.0175059717,
-0.0348197259,
-0.0002732747,
0.0106051406,
-0.0002606319,
0.0043025198,
0.0096264146,
0.033391878,
0.0546099283,
-0.040505942,
0.0342218876,
-0.0544714965,
0.0144273089,
0.0281203426,
0.0432154015,
-0.0599088445,
-0.041552823,
-0.0022639877,
-0.0278360043,
0.0157536361,
-0.0343764536,
-0.0212515686,
-0.0137680648,
0.0311471894,
-0.023617221,
-0.0329361334,
-0.04409853,
0.0308901668,
-0.0013795892,
0.0047144187,
0.0508468673,
0.0197979752,
0.0238869451,
-0.0428468101,
0.0123708546,
0.0086552911,
-0.0087230252,
-0.0187831484,
0.0273271389,
0.017635541,
-0.097538054,
-0.0176440831,
-0.0613431409,
-0.0365574993,
-0.0069496338,
-0.0078698536,
0.0051364321,
0.0000628134,
0.0007182781,
-0.0373938456,
0.0039602537,
0.0014993111,
-0.0066975439,
0.0022214262,
0.0435608104,
0.0373658724,
0.008731205,
-0.0539514199,
0.0255562048,
-0.0057434696,
-0.0056622108,
0.0336841047,
-0.0283103697,
-0.0781015605,
0.0445426181,
-0.0576273873,
0.0064736642,
0.0043561915,
-0.022435775,
0.0756987482,
0.0199100748,
0.0261917301,
0.0402370319,
0.0185225178,
0.0599340722,
0.0282073002,
-0.0522578582,
-0.0554769076,
0.0510379113,
-0.0021385544,
-0.0245490782,
-0.0062130545,
-0.0165015925,
-0.0325984098,
0.0452637933,
0.0139122484,
0.030549163,
-0.0381802991,
0.045261126,
-0.0398062542,
-0.0547082275,
-0.0400556587,
-0.0306365173,
-0.0242520869,
0.0780085623,
-0.0188562199,
-0.031457305,
0.1045981869,
0.0136354696,
-0.0305601303,
-0.0231667627,
0.002318914,
0.0223484393,
0.0534838289,
-0.0420142785,
-0.0175164938,
0.0376920514,
-0.0324832909,
-0.0638644695,
-0.0215095747,
0.0452096388,
-0.0450049564,
0.030215377,
-0.0964845195,
-0.0292402469,
0.0045134728,
-0.0372896902,
-0.0477458499,
-0.0266877804,
-0.0381505527,
-0.0058857878,
0.0560167953,
-0.0388396904,
0.0443397537,
-0.0011421929,
0.002429097,
0.0109625394,
-0.0233538132,
-0.0366593599,
-0.0173647255,
0.0119451797,
0.0190802775,
0.0642590076,
0.0685213283,
-0.0259218644,
0.0512042567,
0.0381841399,
0.0374584198,
-0.0133975763,
-0.0221666787,
-0.0015553115,
0.013582048,
0.0228925422,
-0.003078728,
0.0702352151,
0.1340793967,
-0.024140317,
-0.0348481312,
0.1013511121,
0.0467800386,
0.0029264658,
-0.0191147365,
-0.0968503281,
0.0422576256,
0.0152233113,
0.0142268706,
-0.0380254425,
-0.0434701592,
0.0391867645,
0.0205703862,
-0.0171714947,
-0.0169872064,
0.005375721,
-0.0545466132,
0.0297675841,
-0.019853279,
-0.0216584336,
0.0160115864,
0.0168228205,
0.0252517667,
0.0352169313,
0.0640787333,
0.0128939562,
0.0194114912,
0.0080105653,
0.0182847939,
-0.0111682238,
-0.0321502611,
-0.0108331582,
-0.0088452753,
0.0733323246,
0.036584653,
0.0139213139,
0.0226707943,
-0.0052326825,
0.0177137461,
-0.0016947275,
0.0092288889,
-0.029772969,
0.0116295395,
0.0431567878,
0.0021628565,
-0.0369615853,
0.0157070048,
0.0030052161,
-0.0110655492,
0.0245260671,
0.0173984617,
-0.0591577254,
0.0097048953,
0.0122358548,
0.0416486301,
0.0296038762,
0.051488962,
0.0355813652,
-0.0391218811,
0.0073503624,
-0.009564843,
0.0148452902,
-0.0229129493,
0.020079853,
-0.0045705973,
0.026357986,
0.0251915734,
-0.0643694252,
-0.0454771742,
0.0278858431,
0.0117995655,
0.0058411886,
-0.0277674291,
0.044684425,
0.0179117192,
-0.0041772709,
0.0076835346,
0.0110523347,
-0.000541657,
-0.0439622253,
-0.0049103647,
-0.0160642657,
-0.0023777999,
0.001355686,
0.0463876054,
-0.0882838741,
-0.0597075,
-0.0091548627,
0.044317469,
0.0336022153,
0.0107985865,
-0.0244455654,
-0.0602509044,
-0.0350924283,
-0.0032269116,
-0.0172678139,
-0.0197170116,
0.0137930373,
0.0489153042,
-0.0332189426,
0.0559488945,
-0.022601271,
-0.0177193917,
-0.0312762372,
0.012759991,
-0.0756645426,
-0.1161698624,
0.0271922089,
0.0141916517,
0.0402346887,
-0.0229969993,
0.0283245817,
-0.0183558036,
0.0045824135,
-0.0102440957,
-0.0265593044,
-0.0391061082,
-0.0069537228,
-0.0258314181,
-0.0636028945,
0.0001481501,
-0.0173131581,
-0.0146649051,
0.0478650033,
-0.0025078752,
-0.0256412942,
0.0095052989,
0.0148264524,
0.005566291,
0.0082797203,
0.0220398493,
0.0411091149,
-0.0236481,
0.0543391071,
0.0648830608,
0.1034648046,
0.0135714943,
-0.0456225686,
0.0053665875,
0.0124507612,
-0.0421267636,
-0.1402657777,
0.032126978,
0.0274129938,
0.0034825301,
0.0319943987,
-0.000940604,
-0.0421410315,
0.0130140986,
0.0244188365,
0.0262637101,
0.0534729734,
-0.0184301604,
0.0603158921,
0.0448299684,
-0.0133563159,
-0.0009108419,
0.0390790924,
-0.0362238996,
0.0304576121,
-0.0203099661,
-0.0310747921,
-0.0384809226,
-0.0162330661,
-0.0030238195,
0.0093141291,
-0.0314198732,
0.0500092134,
-0.0650563836,
-0.0364993736,
-0.0111886896,
0.043505609,
0.0218337532,
-0.0518407971,
0.0198979136,
0.0355055295,
-0.0096534584,
-0.0603722595,
-0.0291554891,
0.013915062,
-0.012571156,
0.0440754443,
-0.0676940605,
-5.762256777e-33,
-0.0713515654,
-0.0688432455,
-0.0015577507,
-0.0139648067,
-0.0099746548,
-0.0276329443,
-0.033252161,
0.0605742112,
-0.0221542865,
0.0372402482,
-0.0263673272,
0.0289757773,
0.0069854087,
-0.024817843,
0.0705609247,
-0.0311908759,
0.0225600712,
0.0076032216,
-0.0303182062,
-0.0271047894,
0.0491524115,
-0.0169102643,
-0.0044065826,
-0.0284896381,
0.0503903143,
0.0077758911,
-0.0242680758,
0.065483503,
-0.0149237942,
0.0017752637,
0.0079244105,
0.0191099774,
-0.0165013429,
-0.0206967946,
-0.0245679338,
0.0051210755,
-0.0179607812,
-0.0527911484,
0.0252025798,
0.0213851035,
-0.0788717493,
0.0123481061,
-0.0025319427,
0.0009015453,
-0.0164863747,
0.0522194803,
-0.0096714115,
0.0042569651,
0.0021697525,
0.024580691,
-0.0089632496,
-0.0025696415,
-0.033603631,
-0.0794862658,
0.0134203853,
0.0839461461,
-0.0300689004,
-0.0657583848,
-0.0163904335,
0.0205525812,
0.0053441995,
-0.00471931,
0.0361595862,
0.0337814838,
-0.0186071862,
0.0204173513,
-0.0089436714,
0.0269615296,
-0.014980129,
-0.0281986054,
-0.028429646,
0.0349703692,
0.0170821603,
0.0552357137,
-0.016571762,
-0.0043813828,
0.0106615014,
0.0026520945,
-0.0005956694,
0.0787978396,
-0.0276464093,
0.0208442807,
-0.0556333102,
-0.010305725,
-0.049532868,
-0.0125139449,
-0.0452638008,
-0.0217733234,
0.0209262539,
-0.0125897536,
-0.0079349149,
-0.0275925826,
-0.0136351073,
0.0294793993,
0.0068812184,
-0.0477941222,
-0.0030501653,
0.0191772729,
0.0158313606,
0.0165322609,
-0.0166450758,
0.0235190671,
0.0293664318,
0.0209436584,
0.0141121112,
0.0457409248,
0.0000942483,
0.0002415608,
-0.0154903689,
-0.0043772156,
-0.0304790512,
0.0584000312,
-0.0324092098,
-0.050679367,
0.0200841986,
0.002622494,
-0.0625678301,
0.0432722047,
-0.0077809016,
0.0024686917,
-0.0387081094,
0.0184491612,
-0.0018410292,
-0.0219264906,
-0.0211532507,
-0.0326044336,
-0.0016844219,
-0.0284302477,
-0.0236777849,
-0.0146513227,
-0.0116327517,
-0.0026578284,
2.506e-7,
0.0098571181,
0.0520530194,
0.037221726,
0.0647097901,
0.0115403756,
0.0654271841,
-0.0075464477,
-0.0397129133,
0.0377916321,
-0.0504889265,
0.0065798075,
0.0084123192,
0.0297367722,
0.0270287097,
-0.0142495343,
-0.0748801306,
-0.0302992035,
0.0394833386,
0.0320786573,
-0.003468059,
0.0806458667,
-0.0067759771,
0.0001328359,
0.0204649009,
-0.027499821,
-0.0023125759,
0.0382645205,
-0.0529074445,
-0.0063176942,
0.0379054323,
0.0488460772,
-0.0153696565,
0.0192161258,
0.0572432615,
0.01816958,
-0.0233795345,
-0.0329193063,
0.0279080607,
-0.0014699827,
-0.0033006219,
-0.0472455435,
0.0066923187,
0.0457624234,
-0.0582845546,
0.0063767331,
-0.0550021492,
-0.0210893359,
-0.0009748715,
0.0386386216,
-0.0377360508,
0.0165483542,
-0.0078047174,
-0.0073926654,
-0.0067038643,
-0.0043345005,
0.0345272645,
0.0107736057,
-0.025162451,
-0.031244183,
-0.0022258351,
-0.0365638658,
-0.0136124715,
-0.0484516174,
-0.032308206,
-0.0121753896,
-0.0453842655,
-0.0052260957,
1.35178682e-34,
0.0393397212,
0.0244024359,
0.0246705394,
0.0480976403,
0.0552527718,
0.0074821087,
-0.0315948986,
0.0011657218,
0.0556574464,
0.0106637208,
-0.0158708282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06501v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06501v2 | Scalable Interactive Machine Learning for Future Command and Control | 2024-02-09T16:11:04 | 2024-03-28T15:17:01 | Anna Madison, Ellen Novoseller, Vinicius G. Goecks, Benjamin T. Files, Nicholas Waytowich, Alfred Yu, Vernon J. Lawhern, Steven Thurman, Christopher Kelshaw, Kaleb McDowell | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7 | Future warfare will require Command and Control (C2) personnel to make
decisions at shrinking timescales in complex and potentially ill-defined
situations. Given the need for robust decision-making processes and
decision-support tools, integration of artificial and human intelligence holds
the potential to revolutionize the C2 operations process to ensure adaptability
and efficiency in rapidly changing operational environments. We propose to
leverage recent promising breakthroughs in interactive machine learning, in
which humans can cooperate with machine learning algorithms to guide machine
learning algorithm behavior. This paper identifies several gaps in
state-of-the-art science and technology that future work should address to
extend these approaches to function in complex C2 contexts. In particular, we
describe three research focus areas that together, aim to enable scalable
interactive machine learning (SIML): 1) developing human-AI interaction
algorithms to enable planning in complex, dynamic situations; 2) fostering
resilient human-AI teams through optimizing roles, configurations, and trust;
and 3) scaling algorithms and human-AI teams for flexibility across a range of
potential contexts and situations. | [
0.011907002,
-0.0104812887,
-0.0135736195,
-0.0615553893,
-0.0074454593,
-0.0054154112,
0.0266239513,
-0.0165549554,
0.0128085995,
0.0045888941,
-0.0026881238,
0.0030863786,
-0.0081782062,
0.0623827428,
0.0060943835,
-0.0520832241,
0.0313130729,
-0.029845655,
-0.0249519981,
0.0423412919,
-0.0331144519,
-0.0210429579,
-0.0508447252,
0.010109555,
-0.0291658118,
0.0167073775,
-0.0697158203,
0.0051125134,
0.0306568071,
-0.0505123697,
-0.0196436085,
-0.0129266093,
0.0550655387,
0.0061432207,
0.0000021016,
-0.0257268716,
-0.0005162579,
-0.0339902267,
-0.0678173602,
-0.0413056351,
0.0100953542,
-0.0243108403,
-0.0130501119,
0.0471580513,
-0.0651565939,
0.0639539585,
0.0452663302,
0.0586861372,
0.0300042685,
0.0035534678,
0.0159011781,
0.0377109163,
-0.0047297059,
-0.0036735847,
-0.0382438526,
-0.0238087364,
-0.0063433391,
-0.0118232453,
0.0120765064,
-0.0118910857,
0.0234328918,
-0.0105657475,
0.0377217866,
0.0157555696,
0.0041777422,
0.0588148944,
-0.0141445687,
-0.0109435786,
-0.0325131901,
0.0036813277,
-0.019107895,
-0.0088050719,
-0.0185814444,
-0.0072164093,
-0.0023067412,
0.0171726588,
-0.0144028515,
-0.0496795587,
-0.0342483595,
-0.0283511635,
-0.0656620786,
-0.0101871435,
0.0125894342,
0.0294843912,
-0.0134014497,
0.0814756081,
-0.054887753,
-0.0299954563,
0.0497173555,
0.00903212,
-0.027129868,
-0.018730307,
-0.0206505246,
0.0348871686,
-0.1214441955,
-0.0222830679,
-0.0338402055,
0.0030101438,
0.0054743188,
-0.0284459889,
0.0802736208,
-0.0050751851,
0.0150049366,
0.0392016955,
0.0237634946,
0.058601059,
-0.0083770733,
-0.0232217368,
0.0013335276,
0.0072558033,
-0.0730365887,
-0.0114033781,
-0.0120828785,
0.0028403578,
-0.0132991467,
-0.0152981654,
-0.0560471267,
0.0626192614,
-0.0573589914,
0.0404665954,
-0.0265079886,
0.053909529,
-0.0237982757,
0.0345683582,
-0.059522368,
-0.0428779162,
-0.0314280577,
0.0366401635,
-0.0093441764,
-0.0144816572,
0.0414328575,
-0.0061925952,
-0.0291238576,
0.0002184326,
-0.0119214179,
0.0827441216,
-0.0245381799,
0.0159665793,
-0.0311523546,
-0.0211661365,
0.0452855825,
-0.0059733661,
0.0061342078,
-0.0161993206,
0.0209391266,
-0.0263203997,
-0.0182348825,
-0.0149822831,
0.0028972635,
0.0257659201,
0.0076844208,
0.1104051247,
-0.0007872326,
0.0082047032,
0.0294858646,
0.0109775886,
-0.0473930463,
0.0036034859,
0.0433650985,
0.0459749922,
0.0634928644,
0.0153119517,
0.0572956726,
0.0202612486,
-0.0072596632,
-0.0312230811,
0.0004653582,
-0.0192165319,
-0.0414003879,
0.0615695156,
-0.0183513574,
-0.0019300497,
-0.0078362888,
-0.0380797312,
0.0787527487,
0.0242998935,
-0.0239039902,
0.0062647201,
0.0540486239,
0.0913373008,
0.0113546699,
-0.047112193,
-0.0395852551,
0.0304458793,
-0.025742501,
-0.045765873,
-0.0509380698,
0.0225388221,
-0.0048825154,
-0.0575034358,
0.008207893,
-0.0340311863,
0.0162336938,
0.0124324942,
0.031077804,
-0.051750049,
-0.0014370135,
-0.0762332603,
0.034906067,
0.0124786096,
-0.0261267275,
-0.0509624891,
-0.0229289997,
0.0727759302,
0.0476761535,
-0.0573557764,
-0.0390472077,
-0.0311991144,
0.0001809305,
-0.0303927492,
0.0118563809,
-0.0240375623,
0.0283329021,
0.0212640408,
-0.0377581306,
0.0446961373,
-0.0181687269,
0.0255688913,
0.0280801822,
-0.0128722498,
-0.0473130606,
0.0538527369,
-0.0135836052,
0.0296273846,
0.0313423648,
-0.0152226435,
0.0380333178,
0.0295729153,
0.0717346519,
0.054464981,
-0.0119180223,
0.0018670588,
0.0266167559,
0.0278050043,
-0.0261961687,
-0.0041570626,
0.016363889,
0.0629837513,
-0.0040717972,
-0.0213100947,
0.0004489396,
0.0236257352,
-0.0362500809,
-0.003843314,
0.0008235828,
-0.0250128768,
-0.0357944891,
0.0163897499,
-0.0004360881,
0.0022698722,
0.0029673055,
-0.0435898192,
0.0305803847,
-0.0025328274,
-0.0833025277,
0.0108670108,
-0.0034338119,
0.0233192556,
-0.0423531905,
0.0176832881,
0.0371848792,
0.0347377062,
-0.0267293695,
0.0355292708,
-0.0011944899,
0.0112557886,
0.0035694712,
-0.0794677138,
-0.0464513153,
0.0062958999,
-0.015999455,
-0.0156281833,
-0.0476527549,
-0.0077748685,
-0.0218957942,
0.0256587788,
0.0224448405,
-0.0122326165,
-0.0029901022,
0.0320646949,
0.0456500985,
-0.0027515143,
-0.004294829,
-0.0184411649,
-0.005847916,
0.0187580585,
0.0623774529,
-0.00629661,
-0.0330241323,
-0.0121552888,
-0.0517735817,
0.0455732457,
-0.0235875081,
-0.0256659687,
0.0691488013,
-0.0081275459,
-0.0467591137,
0.0590964183,
0.0049909144,
0.0825477317,
0.0878734812,
0.0534593016,
-0.0178369451,
0.0339954719,
-0.0220118891,
-0.0160988532,
-0.0340900198,
0.0250228047,
0.0109585756,
0.0012054081,
-0.0152995773,
0.0300618354,
0.0170374792,
0.0370133817,
0.0097370325,
-0.0573446117,
-0.0659852475,
-0.0295447409,
-0.0329057649,
0.0566152632,
-0.0315930955,
-0.0227390993,
0.0818703175,
0.0233573113,
-0.0039547407,
0.0073550097,
-0.0517092794,
0.0088570155,
0.0423412398,
0.0094995024,
-0.0118283657,
0.0078201182,
0.0087556466,
-0.0548969507,
-0.0280717593,
-0.0147646684,
-0.0480299182,
-0.0460856482,
-0.0633391961,
-0.0451701954,
0.0416278578,
-0.0470139943,
-0.0207766965,
0.0248882528,
-0.0227115061,
0.0095838271,
0.0104575306,
-0.0838437751,
-0.011535407,
-0.0361383855,
0.09458033,
-0.001771093,
0.0207946487,
-0.0351060741,
-0.0374329276,
-0.014327147,
0.0278618466,
0.0247577392,
0.0169568267,
0.0025977483,
0.0082920352,
0.0519152582,
0.0711618066,
-0.0608501546,
-0.0616354235,
0.0186345149,
-0.0059576822,
-0.0366484821,
0.0214015339,
0.0221862365,
-0.0025311024,
-0.0430882573,
0.0347702652,
0.0396884941,
0.0450437814,
-0.0828528628,
0.0158830564,
-0.0203133561,
0.0102927526,
-0.004507001,
0.0555797778,
-0.0353663526,
0.0005371314,
0.0158355515,
0.0517486185,
-0.0508354232,
-0.0672210678,
0.0379934125,
-0.0984248742,
0.0407175571,
-0.0315854177,
0.0084687555,
-0.0572375916,
-0.0724788457,
0.0200490821,
-0.0245860629,
-0.0031753068,
-0.0058261734,
0.0193085913,
0.0001204216,
0.0299548134,
-0.0323182233,
0.0125969909,
0.0063103875,
-0.0547321625,
-0.0008311449,
0.0610359162,
0.0279796068,
0.0003282755,
0.014739858,
0.0058828322,
0.0823100358,
0.0635138229,
-0.0469383635,
0.0471059717,
-0.0200891141,
0.0079005826,
-0.0315712653,
0.0118012447,
0.0842378885,
0.006188802,
0.0337895714,
0.0738667622,
-0.0798088089,
0.0461279452,
-0.0343240537,
-0.010993599,
0.0439502001,
0.0097480528,
-0.0229007117,
-0.0925419852,
-0.0629699379,
0.0103640258,
0.0520677865,
-0.0175611377,
-0.0584728494,
0.0220001917,
0.0063391845,
-0.0263654981,
-0.0467466637,
-0.0716725886,
0.0428424478,
0.0310822986,
0.0161599703,
-0.0411373712,
0.004864445,
0.0503488034,
-0.0356185958,
-0.036338035,
0.0263787787,
0.0320936032,
-0.0184565522,
0.0038257563,
-0.0398146622,
-0.0484220535,
-0.0050191144,
0.0177328307,
0.0234195832,
-0.0328136496,
0.0287147686,
0.0493655875,
0.0240925252,
0.020550698,
-0.0032968228,
-0.041876778,
0.0459221713,
0.0051242108,
-0.0279670916,
0.0001622862,
0.0069470387,
0.0547074117,
0.0091168443,
0.0313144326,
-0.0400810279,
-0.004794057,
-0.0058641708,
-0.0709495395,
-0.0632502809,
-0.0512021743,
0.0096491687,
-0.0271774344,
0.0198221859,
-0.0233727433,
-0.025001578,
0.0177951939,
0.0320525169,
-0.0184853952,
-0.0076645864,
-0.0356608815,
0.0193246678,
-0.0159007329,
0.0007711499,
0.0387462564,
0.0038604042,
0.0581404641,
-0.0285978485,
-0.0095003182,
0.0106498832,
0.021538198,
0.0438127927,
0.003217431,
0.0535051599,
0.0333491266,
0.0304828472,
0.0030693864,
0.0321683772,
0.0596096478,
0.0716024339,
0.021132214,
-0.0275194459,
-0.048414547,
0.0376879647,
-0.0609504208,
-0.0875153765,
0.0457088873,
0.0408047549,
0.0220511481,
0.0616747029,
-0.0090315174,
-0.0552429073,
0.0067280559,
0.0056992173,
-0.0121194944,
-0.0166629516,
0.0162057094,
-0.0237275083,
0.0440409556,
-0.0144390212,
0.0705510452,
0.0145631982,
-0.015566594,
0.0322316848,
-0.044077415,
-0.0836966783,
-0.009347586,
-0.0050030178,
0.0282641854,
0.0363459736,
-0.0193882193,
0.0080664111,
-0.0648452342,
-0.0216753948,
0.0010663752,
0.0658657476,
0.0113612134,
-0.0930394381,
0.0091957012,
0.0126275644,
0.005895115,
-0.0039772186,
-0.0329530537,
-0.006958297,
-0.0145167019,
-0.0182812568,
-0.0100188628,
-5.532592732e-33,
0.012017319,
-0.0423817262,
0.033321593,
-0.008864224,
-0.0527470708,
-0.012180551,
-0.0048674294,
0.0359127857,
-0.004385266,
0.0186998788,
-0.0279977731,
0.0080386819,
0.0024555246,
-0.0226428173,
0.0253446829,
0.0045117661,
0.0143418657,
-0.0265537836,
-0.0221926402,
0.0350644216,
0.054920882,
0.0004713269,
-0.0603611581,
-0.0887432545,
0.0043257312,
0.0549956784,
-0.0092229387,
0.0382039584,
-0.0405449234,
0.0325607918,
-0.0016523055,
-0.0180851948,
0.0186583344,
-0.0040391902,
-0.004350624,
0.0449894667,
-0.0476858728,
0.0019217166,
-0.0655414686,
0.0067455648,
-0.034992978,
0.0082520135,
-0.0021897322,
0.0017778693,
-0.0026772302,
-0.0066760834,
0.0218767859,
0.0132500166,
0.0002289761,
-0.0045085908,
-0.0007476871,
0.0286151674,
-0.0526754037,
-0.0074059065,
0.025702294,
0.058557272,
0.0033279851,
-0.0251642987,
-0.0487794131,
0.0277356897,
-0.0184995569,
-0.0114907175,
0.0017821877,
0.0207285043,
-0.0014580881,
0.0336624309,
0.0388422497,
-0.0210450124,
-0.0616555735,
-0.0180742498,
-0.0293106548,
0.1024440899,
0.0695083812,
0.0681191534,
-0.0159051698,
0.0088480804,
-0.0350576937,
0.0387791432,
0.0267018657,
0.0701165721,
-0.0040777572,
0.0111759612,
-0.0841750205,
0.0090130484,
0.0327492207,
-0.0325030573,
0.0012947551,
-0.0363293588,
-0.0138649764,
-0.0160314068,
-0.037718229,
0.0489537045,
0.0209328979,
0.0041235629,
0.0692395791,
-0.0018616401,
0.0274881236,
0.0539261363,
-0.0034403119,
-0.0626301691,
-0.0427864157,
-0.0172355101,
-0.0011520435,
-0.0434831306,
0.0330385827,
-0.0187883154,
-0.0008259896,
0.0258861333,
0.024434546,
-0.0012645901,
-0.0063210819,
0.0230280571,
0.0542514585,
-0.0478239842,
0.0708052143,
-0.026269855,
0.0006691191,
-0.0491072126,
0.0015784974,
-0.0687701628,
0.0071230568,
-0.0434875488,
-0.0398505256,
-0.0267443694,
-0.0188241489,
-0.0051437197,
-0.0523455217,
0.0318167359,
-0.0143694188,
-0.0507494286,
-0.0082171466,
-0.0099358801,
2.791e-7,
-0.0325034484,
0.0501283258,
0.0391870365,
-0.0028995152,
0.0079473266,
0.0517271049,
0.0309190173,
0.0138207963,
-0.0427407213,
0.0010942605,
0.0912306383,
0.0642869994,
0.0237321574,
0.014655021,
-0.0109636914,
-0.073520489,
0.0157531612,
0.0052597956,
-0.0706688315,
0.0136282369,
0.0732614174,
0.0175200384,
0.0486288555,
-0.0368121564,
0.0500816628,
0.0031726477,
-0.0256458465,
-0.023482319,
0.0388483293,
-0.0533973575,
0.0362261161,
-0.0026957397,
-0.0409312472,
0.064862214,
-0.0292844139,
-0.0123302462,
-0.0221095495,
0.0180853195,
0.0017185869,
-0.0077307676,
-0.0216182675,
-0.0081986161,
-0.0166631658,
-0.016679341,
0.0537511706,
-0.048141662,
-0.014866312,
0.0125327194,
0.0086206943,
-0.0260904413,
-0.0194214564,
0.0114682596,
0.0195122678,
-0.0063292002,
-0.0257618856,
0.0115356874,
0.0212197565,
-0.0462651029,
0.0068031759,
0.0073768962,
-0.049059052,
-0.0163157135,
0.0139202541,
0.0119246775,
0.0015010928,
0.017186733,
-0.0005130459,
2.055970844e-34,
-0.0112896366,
0.023747215,
-0.0246268585,
0.0049023046,
0.0355620608,
0.0377435535,
-0.0231379718,
0.0187744685,
0.0622041449,
0.0009976748,
-0.0006717933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07946v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07946v2 | Re-Envisioning Command and Control | 2024-02-09T16:10:29 | 2024-03-28T15:17:30 | Kaleb McDowell, Ellen Novoseller, Anna Madison, Vinicius G. Goecks, Christopher Kelshaw | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7 | Future warfare will require Command and Control (C2) decision-making to occur
in more complex, fast-paced, ill-structured, and demanding conditions. C2 will
be further complicated by operational challenges such as Denied, Degraded,
Intermittent, and Limited (DDIL) communications and the need to account for
many data streams, potentially across multiple domains of operation. Yet,
current C2 practices -- which stem from the industrial era rather than the
emerging intelligence era -- are linear and time-consuming. Critically, these
approaches may fail to maintain overmatch against adversaries on the future
battlefield. To address these challenges, we propose a vision for future C2
based on robust partnerships between humans and artificial intelligence (AI)
systems. This future vision is encapsulated in three operational impacts:
streamlining the C2 operations process, maintaining unity of effort, and
developing adaptive collective knowledge systems. This paper illustrates the
envisaged future C2 capabilities, discusses the assumptions that shaped them,
and describes how the proposed developments could transform C2 in future
warfare. | [
0.0508965254,
0.0155516425,
-0.0042097713,
-0.0622943789,
-0.015370681,
-0.0221273843,
0.0114048729,
-0.0029068461,
-0.0032927101,
0.0002539144,
0.0230844282,
-0.027551543,
-0.0127709173,
0.0595739745,
0.0133144213,
-0.0064727087,
0.0064431033,
-0.0198852345,
-0.0152233448,
0.0572310425,
-0.0294758119,
-0.0278393738,
-0.027148705,
-0.0065813386,
-0.0176926591,
-0.0147311287,
-0.0358946621,
-0.0038490663,
0.028646674,
-0.0569598898,
0.0291985627,
-0.0372062139,
0.0489988923,
-0.0243981276,
0.0000020351,
-0.0066267345,
0.0108269043,
-0.0234890468,
-0.0710878596,
-0.0164014976,
-0.013540905,
-0.0303421225,
-0.0191652142,
0.0270674434,
-0.0578503124,
0.0778591186,
0.0103993965,
0.0780688375,
0.0231882185,
0.0307470746,
-0.0005862497,
0.0483039245,
-0.0059227422,
-0.0101333223,
-0.0917486474,
-0.053547781,
-0.0038294678,
0.0092795035,
0.037279807,
-0.0080901235,
0.0223807655,
-0.0100400839,
0.0180474315,
0.0175246578,
-0.0101623135,
0.0629852638,
0.0133998794,
0.0187521745,
-0.0427512079,
-0.0199518446,
0.005364446,
-0.0269482154,
0.0028996936,
0.0213294253,
-0.0034066217,
-0.0465181731,
-0.0384503864,
-0.0397826545,
-0.0354919732,
-0.0505627505,
-0.0347167626,
0.0077057267,
0.0134745864,
-0.0057944176,
-0.006651171,
0.0884490684,
-0.0470447503,
-0.02115204,
0.0108221816,
0.0157417953,
0.0039139865,
-0.050755471,
-0.0227000248,
0.0399568602,
-0.1035906374,
-0.0509904474,
-0.0437550843,
-0.0204104651,
0.0215872731,
-0.0297098942,
0.041951403,
-0.0166164543,
0.0164429266,
0.0186966024,
0.0261470191,
0.0787844881,
-0.0021668298,
0.0159425084,
-0.012143434,
-0.0071501262,
-0.0733405575,
-0.0043991222,
0.0183629058,
0.0332196243,
0.0014857966,
-0.0461176969,
-0.0274779163,
0.0378135033,
-0.0518822297,
0.0332058109,
-0.0284755677,
0.0328739136,
0.01740871,
0.0039183297,
-0.0298846476,
-0.0462627262,
0.0086957049,
0.050418973,
0.0031993333,
-0.0130454013,
0.022750143,
-0.028427951,
-0.0362996869,
-0.0481050387,
-0.0194156338,
0.0920820236,
-0.0291817542,
0.025361754,
-0.020559663,
0.0095588677,
0.0195463728,
0.002946574,
-0.00070487,
0.0036908316,
-0.0019930899,
0.0061082905,
-0.0013529225,
0.0037623346,
-0.0299466606,
-0.0248685032,
-0.0036381339,
0.0566326529,
0.00159743,
0.0378174447,
0.036736697,
0.0301391892,
-0.0195825174,
0.0099308249,
0.0282109566,
0.0283769276,
0.0356124043,
0.0528563336,
0.0644514188,
0.0174156018,
-0.0280732904,
-0.0037896668,
-0.0035010262,
0.0130060697,
-0.0128386812,
0.0237957984,
0.0044849231,
-0.0147519074,
0.0023922268,
-0.0310200956,
0.0859655961,
-0.0026114667,
0.0084777484,
0.0009044122,
0.0668158233,
0.0640821829,
0.0100600664,
-0.0543067344,
-0.0286320597,
0.0379703566,
-0.0396023728,
-0.0428810827,
-0.0493117496,
0.0398574956,
-0.0186444819,
-0.0252817199,
-0.0192317795,
-0.0339957662,
0.0157555472,
-0.0043983455,
0.0063788164,
-0.0634495318,
0.0166830886,
-0.0631910861,
0.00184234,
0.0186699964,
-0.0165001769,
-0.0553087182,
-0.0346971937,
0.0632711127,
0.0646291822,
-0.0224432554,
-0.0877505615,
-0.0161478203,
0.0055655767,
-0.0431675352,
0.0272700824,
-0.010119251,
0.0482901186,
0.0206834357,
-0.0344150774,
0.0401562527,
-0.0070792371,
0.0315753371,
-0.0363972038,
0.0336868986,
-0.0595043562,
0.0600393601,
-0.0319865309,
0.019219609,
0.0552847199,
-0.003006492,
-0.0066085691,
0.0242782906,
0.0578973852,
0.0484208502,
-0.0314365216,
0.0345328487,
0.0286863502,
0.0202943645,
-0.0624073558,
-0.0083413422,
0.025713902,
0.1376611888,
-0.0115420129,
-0.0202471856,
0.0147282137,
0.0268592015,
0.0091860928,
-0.0398455523,
0.0474858955,
-0.0225908067,
-0.0194117706,
0.0370416157,
0.0110068889,
-0.0101064704,
0.0038121727,
-0.0145383012,
0.0317717679,
0.0149320895,
-0.089307785,
0.0095759062,
-0.0142263314,
0.0536596552,
0.001479888,
0.043863982,
0.0492315404,
-0.0046732831,
-0.0206098631,
0.0514990836,
0.005051529,
0.0390378684,
-0.0061286609,
-0.020957252,
-0.0165498871,
0.0218729358,
-0.0132755348,
-0.0211332962,
-0.0675579309,
-0.0122332862,
0.0244155396,
0.0522853024,
0.0162496325,
-0.0271580312,
-0.0379194617,
0.0086847236,
0.0570932738,
-0.0223830622,
0.0205656458,
0.0168697387,
-0.0084966086,
0.0236296672,
0.0297369994,
-0.0438309759,
-0.0131322956,
-0.0091003813,
-0.0694229156,
0.0278167576,
-0.0073662717,
-0.0584440194,
0.0516515523,
-0.0408993065,
-0.0425603837,
0.0190836117,
-0.0031685634,
0.0834321752,
0.0818242058,
0.030195741,
0.0063346848,
0.0194201749,
-0.0044127218,
-0.0384359062,
-0.0579562932,
0.035182219,
-0.0005032417,
0.0241045207,
0.0213348046,
0.0492146611,
0.0159588605,
-0.000818995,
0.0028113513,
-0.0219994206,
-0.0573549308,
-0.0462477207,
-0.0137480143,
0.0497236513,
-0.0582664907,
0.0132508539,
0.0751244202,
0.0391011499,
0.0197678469,
0.009069941,
-0.0441520475,
0.0015049985,
0.0079820734,
-0.0139314895,
-0.0062063327,
0.0229456145,
-0.0156657118,
-0.0600405112,
-0.0478483438,
-0.0169140007,
-0.0382132009,
-0.037919011,
-0.0464217328,
-0.0234277491,
0.0201415922,
-0.025883941,
-0.0023088963,
0.0656244084,
-0.0348252952,
0.036795713,
-0.0361443274,
-0.067565918,
-0.0080578933,
-0.0457920544,
0.1044857576,
0.026487397,
0.0002865898,
-0.0301727876,
-0.0293801725,
-0.0469642989,
0.0109959003,
-0.0076228729,
0.029355675,
0.0002946634,
-0.023140803,
0.0387541093,
0.0693229362,
-0.0403755046,
-0.0249950681,
-0.0063595227,
0.0084072007,
0.0094950087,
0.0176894199,
0.012350156,
0.0126036322,
-0.0398659073,
0.0241529718,
0.0275793802,
0.0232500453,
-0.0522031672,
-0.007110564,
-0.0223660227,
-0.0512648635,
-0.0058112768,
0.0403171256,
-0.0108736409,
0.0305341072,
-0.023379704,
0.0294659231,
-0.0488906838,
-0.0667938069,
0.0388214141,
-0.0554163978,
-0.0184103176,
-0.0362521857,
0.0177385733,
-0.0768537149,
-0.0318057388,
0.0082121044,
0.0028397772,
-0.0051259357,
-0.008013567,
0.0453267545,
-0.0245049112,
0.0447586142,
-0.0245758984,
-0.0007812076,
-0.0058553796,
-0.0606613606,
0.0236955248,
0.0660435185,
0.0450785831,
-0.0151199726,
0.0462467484,
0.0039752512,
-0.0009432606,
0.0359982252,
-0.0205388386,
-0.0061851004,
0.0126009826,
0.0134603968,
-0.001292502,
-0.0032901238,
0.0703457519,
-0.0049115461,
0.0283088796,
0.070617348,
-0.092095457,
0.0019561474,
-0.0306492187,
-0.0019178224,
0.054150857,
0.0289315935,
-0.032319203,
-0.0722547695,
-0.0503866784,
0.0405664071,
0.0672320575,
-0.0478709191,
-0.0359996818,
0.0409719534,
0.0393288508,
-0.0421732515,
-0.043863982,
-0.0533601642,
0.015582419,
0.0189132094,
0.0466153398,
-0.028412085,
-0.0189540107,
0.0083690844,
-0.0316297263,
-0.0907858536,
0.0531062633,
0.0082253106,
-0.0206373259,
0.0089430623,
-0.0718219131,
-0.0336567648,
-0.0077033374,
0.0007332375,
0.0107613392,
-0.0257719383,
0.044261463,
0.0377565995,
0.0180587377,
-0.0231804661,
-0.0048376634,
-0.0368353724,
0.0406752266,
0.0359078273,
-0.0256723221,
0.0164765213,
0.0116309552,
0.031044405,
0.0219366178,
0.0382939354,
-0.0527521558,
0.0109511279,
0.0265787132,
-0.0740962103,
-0.0139288241,
-0.0118667809,
0.0136616807,
-0.0544121079,
-0.0262166224,
-0.0367168486,
-0.0061125876,
0.0404717997,
-0.0098081585,
-0.04087786,
-0.000162735,
0.0053492435,
0.0203263815,
-0.0376488343,
0.0055468366,
0.0187131204,
0.0244124476,
0.0439614654,
-0.0382509716,
-0.0268123057,
-0.0171664134,
-0.0059817079,
0.0467003696,
0.0102214776,
0.0264843721,
0.044511538,
0.0112649817,
0.0004926713,
-0.0060093459,
0.0138020059,
0.0453867316,
0.0394865759,
-0.0384321772,
-0.0149844382,
0.0205448158,
-0.0766110644,
-0.0609309115,
0.0753298551,
0.0301993173,
0.0535272993,
0.0594125129,
-0.0166842341,
-0.0477678999,
0.0063585886,
0.00266918,
-0.0257236231,
-0.0459909141,
0.046504043,
-0.0363499112,
0.0440514609,
-0.0045167762,
0.0970519036,
0.0249473266,
-0.0475989506,
0.0423686728,
-0.0192943923,
-0.0646091253,
0.0085342154,
-0.0184414946,
0.005351427,
0.0182958096,
-0.0204564948,
0.0273891427,
-0.0523532107,
-0.0070172837,
0.0621648878,
0.0762838274,
0.0177868586,
-0.0563437566,
-0.0270506032,
0.0051591876,
0.0113141732,
0.0036261815,
-0.0155029027,
-0.0061394037,
0.0028064821,
0.0042923545,
-0.0089708539,
-5.848419044e-33,
0.0398312472,
-0.015340195,
0.0383755304,
-0.0022998978,
-0.0788166448,
0.007766434,
-0.0335072428,
0.0043709269,
-0.0140586924,
0.0255002379,
-0.0287221428,
0.0244180374,
-0.0017983895,
-0.0101489164,
0.0306998529,
-0.0052136932,
-0.0110781388,
-0.0206573773,
-0.0068051247,
0.0287538785,
0.0973343477,
-0.0047766874,
-0.0434327163,
-0.0832295045,
-0.0072401976,
0.0545357428,
-0.0125583755,
0.0349059142,
0.0061796685,
0.0339466408,
0.0130087538,
-0.0181326494,
0.0257501677,
0.018389279,
-0.0008104386,
0.0153120253,
-0.0348666012,
0.000155439,
-0.0744823217,
-0.0181160364,
0.0312687717,
-0.0131850075,
-0.0250318553,
0.0070069223,
-0.0080554998,
0.0240485892,
0.0039531747,
-0.0069416049,
0.0142351193,
-0.05036778,
-0.0003232995,
0.0218081065,
-0.0818918571,
0.0153941037,
-0.0079599768,
0.019787522,
0.0005030081,
-0.0542384274,
-0.059209533,
0.046809651,
-0.0360874794,
0.0074181934,
0.0005259574,
0.0171467159,
0.0140223391,
0.0389568843,
-0.0407207683,
-0.0040734946,
-0.0410257839,
0.0062887478,
-0.0102250353,
0.0853376612,
0.0317957066,
0.0157366246,
-0.0298013408,
-0.0425888151,
-0.0351446792,
0.0298491698,
0.019748522,
0.057748951,
-0.0078827376,
0.0010257836,
-0.0795729533,
-0.0064085256,
0.080149509,
-0.0459765531,
-0.0100692734,
-0.0054793409,
-0.0046384116,
-0.0233996809,
-0.0221832991,
0.0501038283,
0.0143823503,
-0.0058931359,
0.070828028,
-0.0121167162,
0.0369662121,
0.0706323385,
-0.0220182687,
-0.0478622913,
-0.0184000079,
-0.0264133755,
0.0246670712,
0.0015517435,
0.0312124249,
-0.0000457705,
0.0133260256,
0.0308485348,
0.041441001,
-0.0253576506,
0.0034393629,
0.0269071832,
0.0654165,
-0.1058338955,
0.0367926247,
0.0176983196,
0.015951002,
-0.0439310521,
0.0105234422,
-0.0934113264,
-0.0039312728,
-0.0030661977,
-0.0060411096,
-0.0133502809,
-0.0289218985,
0.0415890403,
-0.0765082911,
0.0269664191,
-0.0262024831,
-0.0431374237,
-0.0290505439,
-0.0166082773,
2.821e-7,
-0.0084633091,
0.0113762598,
0.0382286534,
0.0110940933,
0.0033590188,
0.0333716273,
0.0229932629,
0.0398083851,
-0.0613023005,
-0.009696315,
0.0616143271,
0.0352074541,
-0.0100477589,
-0.0117828045,
0.0270490386,
-0.0445335321,
0.0198744442,
-0.0060177259,
-0.0926420316,
-0.001481946,
0.0810244232,
-0.0243423693,
0.0388493985,
-0.0527079217,
0.0136502739,
0.0240969434,
-0.037245281,
0.0329168402,
0.0439973287,
-0.029408209,
0.0461151525,
0.0102352872,
-0.0568638518,
0.0556215644,
-0.0141934827,
-0.0188445617,
-0.0047529265,
0.0079620266,
0.0022694408,
-0.0274464842,
-0.0357465781,
-0.0314106233,
-0.0165766217,
0.0151659288,
0.0763354897,
-0.0404907838,
-0.0104914382,
0.0094943261,
0.009797439,
-0.0055006603,
-0.0355667286,
0.0140980138,
0.0201743711,
0.0027827099,
-0.0299663544,
0.0153975654,
0.0538888089,
-0.0385998338,
0.042412471,
0.059962552,
-0.0305036828,
-0.0226666834,
0.019595176,
0.0315936655,
0.0196887478,
0.0530627444,
-0.0118105421,
2.199591917e-34,
-0.0343171097,
-0.0199298542,
-0.0299104527,
-0.0344877206,
0.0163388848,
0.0321008228,
-0.052377589,
0.014574076,
0.0422256067,
0.0248907991,
-0.0231791213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06492v1 | Inducing Systematicity in Transformers by Attending to Structurally Quantized Embeddings | 2024-02-09T15:53:15 | 2024-02-09T15:53:15 | Yichen Jiang, Xiang Zhou, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformers generalize to novel compositions of structures and entities
after being trained on a complex dataset, but easily overfit on datasets of
insufficient complexity. We observe that when the training set is sufficiently
complex, the model encodes sentences that have a common syntactic structure
using a systematic attention pattern. Inspired by this observation, we propose
SQ-Transformer (Structurally Quantized) that explicitly encourages
systematicity in the embeddings and attention layers, even with a training set
of low complexity. At the embedding level, we introduce Structure-oriented
Vector Quantization (SoVQ) to cluster word embeddings into several classes of
structurally equivalent entities. At the attention level, we devise the
Systematic Attention Layer (SAL) and an alternative, Systematically Regularized
Layer (SRL) that operate on the quantized word embeddings so that sentences of
the same structure are encoded with invariant or similar attention patterns.
Empirically, we show that SQ-Transformer achieves stronger compositional
generalization than the vanilla Transformer on multiple low-complexity semantic
parsing and machine translation datasets. In our analysis, we show that SoVQ
indeed learns a syntactically clustered embedding space and SAL/SRL induces
generalizable attention patterns, which lead to improved systematicity. | [
0.0183439869,
0.0666913167,
-0.0141416555,
0.0370432027,
0.0366629623,
0.0240998343,
-0.0242608413,
-0.02524505,
-0.0639484525,
-0.0204308666,
-0.0114290537,
-0.0110797919,
-0.0113011738,
0.0099178692,
0.0586352907,
-0.0624699853,
0.0445006862,
0.0350413881,
-0.020551892,
0.0123558771,
0.0091848159,
-0.0224391352,
0.0517684892,
0.0228513852,
-0.0130111407,
-0.0085666729,
-0.0095959287,
-0.0084355855,
0.0341226645,
0.0089936368,
0.0053286445,
0.0405767485,
0.0304869115,
0.0176994931,
0.0000016405,
-0.0120427478,
-0.0157201793,
0.0067102835,
-0.0010973177,
-0.0226003174,
0.0204683524,
-0.0709996596,
-0.0039933301,
-0.0295592137,
-0.007721778,
-0.0526716299,
0.0605849214,
0.0394187495,
0.0499455556,
0.0564676747,
-0.0265524834,
-0.0536196828,
0.0414782278,
-0.0420902595,
-0.0148854507,
-0.0012250105,
-0.003956994,
0.009097374,
-0.0379072465,
0.0365770236,
-0.064434059,
0.0340262093,
0.0273760837,
0.0298859216,
0.0676831231,
0.05839606,
-0.0578039847,
0.0054373867,
0.0298836101,
0.0959710255,
-0.0626805648,
-0.0208009593,
0.0132343015,
-0.0012753047,
0.003530703,
-0.0366652943,
-0.047080595,
0.0408835001,
-0.0191510357,
0.0263259076,
0.0329500586,
0.0184619259,
0.0298627336,
-0.0229596756,
-0.0726833642,
0.0213259161,
0.0120320236,
-0.0491305664,
-0.0168387052,
0.0266996305,
-0.053240817,
-0.0128151504,
-0.0315632634,
-0.0070494739,
-0.0169756375,
-0.0008795362,
-0.0390258133,
-0.0269935075,
-0.0060627749,
-0.0229931418,
0.0359613039,
0.0378210843,
0.0049883174,
0.0358043537,
-0.0268150847,
0.0850669146,
-0.0649685264,
0.0652552918,
-0.0565814227,
-0.0163924117,
-0.0667636618,
0.000629214,
-0.0590811558,
0.0465681963,
-0.0017563188,
-0.0224739984,
-0.0113864467,
0.0553719401,
-0.0045105009,
0.0249818508,
-0.0146692283,
0.0127257267,
-0.0658264682,
0.0144964447,
0.0274754595,
0.0023248997,
-0.0562533513,
-0.0086675379,
-0.0001137304,
0.0000533435,
-0.0299641173,
0.0230677966,
0.0183490403,
-0.021985257,
-0.0509591214,
0.0324480943,
-0.0047476604,
-0.0243431088,
0.0062860656,
-0.0006933133,
-0.0081925821,
-0.035159491,
0.0060851928,
-0.0339429937,
0.0634183586,
-0.0207404904,
0.0090382155,
-0.0081674596,
-0.008620956,
0.0082415473,
-0.0185797978,
0.060687948,
0.0231175013,
-0.0221923869,
-0.0280982591,
-0.0056796842,
-0.0048236055,
0.034384042,
0.0098851556,
-0.0173609722,
0.0087254951,
-0.0164062865,
-0.0130282333,
0.0037131906,
0.0030246805,
-0.0105008576,
0.0290203504,
0.0084265424,
-0.0483003668,
0.0540051311,
0.0705443621,
0.0635510758,
-0.0645674542,
-0.0282461885,
0.008911157,
0.0298798941,
0.0390960835,
0.0613991395,
0.058817789,
0.0320218429,
-0.0435505547,
0.0574740581,
-0.079785198,
0.0282731466,
0.0284374878,
0.0138120446,
-0.0167832598,
-0.0320939459,
-0.0449203439,
-0.0058835763,
0.0088907424,
-0.0110380678,
0.0096265236,
-0.0323891826,
0.0245545004,
0.0674754605,
-0.0113302404,
0.0985228419,
0.0173457731,
-0.0546983778,
0.0182768162,
-0.0035681587,
0.0121354759,
0.0117374631,
0.0181577224,
-0.0086807841,
-0.0073887729,
-0.0258802343,
-0.0091476506,
0.0436859205,
-0.0128726745,
-0.0128420908,
0.0123028336,
-0.0355282649,
-0.0199301653,
-0.0381595083,
0.0046707462,
-0.0075406344,
0.0159054846,
-0.0191208851,
0.0237340685,
-0.0473625623,
0.0180014092,
0.0505877025,
0.0051869135,
-0.0196273122,
0.0057406039,
0.0180663876,
0.0325271748,
0.0015079115,
0.007638393,
0.0221175235,
0.0153624984,
-0.0528724231,
-0.0282746125,
0.0038231181,
-0.0418427289,
-0.0628973022,
-0.0075396486,
-0.0643875673,
-0.0009636904,
0.034509331,
-0.0639646277,
-0.0245010406,
0.008696625,
-0.0504814684,
0.0423463844,
-0.0332122669,
-0.0145608718,
-0.0026022138,
0.0303689428,
-0.0486151464,
0.057630863,
-0.021533208,
0.0163453184,
0.0195330791,
-0.0152936196,
-0.000526353,
-0.0371330529,
-0.0237749238,
-0.0000241181,
0.0017745063,
0.0071253362,
0.0113061853,
-0.0332581662,
-0.0298786629,
-0.0310314335,
-0.0363517478,
-0.0060806065,
-0.0369102694,
0.0188428331,
0.0559263937,
0.0246851053,
0.0533469543,
0.0063089384,
-0.0457376689,
0.0113454387,
-0.0274653807,
0.0293854289,
0.073354654,
-0.0218359269,
-0.028716933,
-0.0392498709,
-0.0382040516,
-0.0096271597,
0.0762446001,
-0.0219860617,
0.0138363224,
-0.08878427,
-0.0188837741,
-0.0087402798,
-0.0041017453,
-0.0236461516,
-0.0428391881,
-0.0046891319,
0.0070473151,
0.0132450489,
0.0876604319,
0.0048113069,
0.0112797217,
0.0446142443,
0.0179146621,
-0.0445897691,
0.015781166,
-0.0336647406,
0.0119579677,
-0.0530982614,
-0.0110967681,
0.0495329276,
0.0831599906,
-0.0208868235,
-0.0108576724,
-0.0569139011,
-0.0163138788,
-0.0176250897,
0.0060529276,
0.0082343565,
-0.0223802235,
0.0001613415,
0.0044759847,
-0.0338365026,
0.003565755,
0.0860822424,
0.0115589313,
-0.025622353,
-0.0304150004,
-0.0034111016,
-0.0385692045,
0.0342700444,
0.0497666411,
0.0097023873,
0.0059424927,
-0.0399641618,
-0.0852721184,
0.0146175083,
0.0164687615,
0.0221612956,
0.0425420105,
0.0348648988,
-0.0003987898,
-0.0321196802,
-0.0515796728,
-0.0397976264,
-0.0154619906,
-0.0067758118,
0.0176630039,
0.0537722372,
-0.0006511362,
-0.042921517,
0.0092608053,
-0.0030526901,
0.0231183805,
0.0086635742,
-0.0204217415,
-0.0515250228,
0.0543659292,
0.0187607575,
0.0328292549,
0.0393278413,
-0.0132497717,
0.0215505641,
0.0630837753,
0.0087721441,
0.0094032064,
-0.0303330217,
0.0014351743,
0.0137021188,
-0.0270960964,
-0.0237678122,
-0.0175446961,
0.0374103971,
-0.0305862073,
-0.0293621458,
0.0765020922,
0.018336311,
-0.037492428,
0.0108299525,
-0.0033399726,
0.0418385155,
0.013328976,
0.0173310246,
-0.0985511243,
-0.0196400322,
0.0072523751,
-0.0098367296,
0.0502379313,
-0.0310844872,
0.0151196504,
-0.0516461693,
-0.0056557227,
0.0204738677,
-0.0528999344,
-0.0412492231,
0.0112951044,
0.0008375444,
-0.0337938145,
0.0184007697,
0.0046714451,
-0.0188293736,
-0.0040440341,
-0.0129795074,
-0.031405732,
-0.0066467477,
0.0133132292,
-0.0622082427,
0.0046120789,
0.0696728975,
0.0143017862,
0.0086782612,
-0.0128243277,
0.0179900639,
-0.0508745126,
-0.015002707,
0.0475989357,
0.0541990511,
-0.0358095579,
-0.0002896364,
-0.0073074712,
0.0333386548,
-0.0265487451,
-0.0013876257,
-0.0286818314,
0.0580780618,
0.0088061076,
-0.0285620559,
-0.0229157507,
-0.0105608767,
-0.0453110747,
0.053299088,
0.0664280206,
-0.0223336443,
-0.0356523097,
-0.0302685704,
0.0304299593,
-0.0408820584,
-0.0063216984,
0.0579811782,
0.0271699503,
-0.0631200448,
-0.0872026235,
-0.0634237826,
0.0045775813,
-0.0318317711,
-0.0241229255,
-0.0355396755,
0.0692655668,
-0.0499599576,
-0.0639723912,
0.0366205759,
-0.0154712638,
0.0168375932,
-0.0217333604,
0.0048256512,
0.0113493856,
0.00881497,
-0.0284977872,
-0.0638677478,
-0.0965880081,
-0.0531156324,
0.017858265,
0.0313484631,
-0.0072671669,
0.0807480812,
-0.0191964209,
-0.0280421078,
0.0559951924,
-0.0193358175,
-0.0407288671,
0.0182928648,
0.0457326323,
-0.0226427503,
0.02793606,
0.0647914335,
-0.0333394073,
0.0169990379,
0.0014575901,
0.0404859036,
-0.0339384526,
0.0144290114,
0.033878129,
-0.035040006,
0.0616174303,
0.0077836844,
0.0284257717,
-0.004126654,
0.0200691335,
0.0203784965,
-0.0140848598,
-0.0485533439,
-0.0076722139,
0.030697301,
-0.004612159,
-0.0003772434,
0.0595619865,
-0.0153249232,
0.0414689146,
0.0019326821,
0.0244609769,
-0.0056307591,
-0.0202975292,
0.0207648985,
0.026460031,
-0.0283920188,
0.0052276733,
-0.0288000535,
0.0114563825,
-0.0262506735,
-0.0088206129,
0.0448869988,
0.0325324349,
-0.0454018116,
0.0250993706,
-0.0533026084,
-0.0123984665,
-0.0041884263,
-0.0430727899,
0.0370006301,
-0.0101547632,
0.0311494898,
0.0092967032,
-0.0249874368,
0.0125279371,
0.0275241248,
-0.0565056056,
-0.0264412612,
0.0624101721,
0.0248221569,
-0.0109799467,
-0.0459266603,
0.0655651018,
-0.0186234526,
-0.00417051,
-0.0171378944,
0.0134556824,
-0.0521960855,
0.0138618592,
-0.0350775272,
0.0248308275,
-0.009583517,
0.0131739853,
0.0098352591,
-0.0378202498,
0.0168868825,
-0.0076274117,
-0.034371186,
-0.0014783134,
0.0416496955,
0.0300593693,
0.0104630357,
-0.0337422006,
0.0028178301,
-0.0239138976,
0.0560995005,
-0.0466926359,
-0.0230307002,
-5.944861376e-33,
-0.0086655309,
-0.0052607371,
-0.0129429735,
-0.018093111,
-0.0537594147,
0.0120052677,
-0.0279346108,
-0.0143121043,
-0.0349015296,
0.0248692501,
-0.0188646745,
0.0400216766,
-0.0067663155,
0.0430283286,
0.0165490396,
-0.0088100908,
0.0576138347,
0.0219370928,
-0.0161832236,
0.0283214003,
-0.0041480651,
0.0222704597,
0.0800675824,
0.0134834573,
-0.0170560274,
0.0228973534,
0.0413929932,
0.0061824243,
0.020439487,
0.0743622929,
-0.0078332229,
0.0115079498,
0.0410073102,
0.027162848,
-0.0543132015,
0.0442477688,
-0.112677224,
-0.0023883295,
-0.0198027994,
0.0248110723,
-0.0508427322,
-0.0602222905,
0.0665180758,
-0.0404765047,
0.0457355827,
-0.0985478833,
0.0350945331,
-0.0147371208,
-0.0430481173,
-0.0440270975,
-0.044762481,
0.0233141705,
0.0111262817,
0.0285531264,
0.0170921106,
0.0486776009,
0.015440491,
0.0506744348,
-0.0585128516,
-0.0051197591,
-0.0523405895,
0.0477345139,
0.0073573869,
0.0109704537,
0.0074450956,
0.0221999269,
0.0119403647,
-0.0437948667,
-0.0601585098,
0.0092543531,
0.0142059019,
0.0385810286,
0.0155616822,
0.0436656997,
0.0581243522,
0.0168787278,
-0.0549604334,
-0.0273782648,
-0.0527223386,
0.0828983858,
0.0293796379,
0.0355344266,
-0.0298433099,
-0.0237909481,
-0.0272256061,
-0.0040414613,
-0.0350366719,
-0.0182722546,
0.0143329259,
0.0018947019,
-0.009135386,
0.0046640956,
0.0394412428,
-0.0597452037,
0.0028771511,
0.0166914854,
0.0009392488,
0.0218329672,
0.0162585508,
0.0178507306,
-0.0282418989,
-0.0371302292,
0.0239036568,
-0.0006441365,
0.0162679404,
0.0258867014,
0.0954471007,
0.0078644361,
-0.0405508019,
-0.0172093529,
-0.0283435956,
-0.0441639572,
-0.0582398251,
0.0470677055,
0.027297426,
0.0622152761,
-0.0173186921,
0.0605667606,
0.0011949101,
0.0179585293,
-0.0365516879,
0.058952339,
0.0317414701,
0.0754175112,
-0.0144681688,
-0.0249633677,
-0.057237979,
0.027778171,
0.0756651163,
-0.0519146435,
-0.0202630553,
0.0139496326,
2.412e-7,
0.0500712954,
0.0250795241,
0.033663325,
-0.0038302746,
0.0152215399,
0.023550082,
0.0040422999,
0.0739353672,
-0.0400386639,
-0.0022614168,
0.0278858375,
0.0086460039,
0.025984047,
0.0202755593,
-0.1014347374,
0.0148177631,
-0.0683757439,
-0.0141482027,
-0.028027622,
-0.0320862122,
0.0384270549,
0.1398452669,
-0.0044091674,
0.0331159458,
0.0323658772,
-0.0086877476,
0.0559476502,
-0.000261802,
0.0202844981,
0.0293321256,
-0.0396177247,
-0.0055267317,
0.0081665423,
-0.0175124835,
-0.0077598286,
0.0348903462,
0.0124055957,
0.032267794,
-0.0086802319,
-0.01103717,
-0.0049508875,
-0.0420852453,
-0.0002658698,
-0.0359295532,
0.0126918806,
-0.14327088,
-0.0167725775,
-0.0037775694,
-0.0537556596,
0.0391172096,
0.0353154726,
0.0293331891,
-0.01615691,
0.0388622321,
0.0582468659,
-0.0108676041,
0.0076316046,
-0.0725185573,
-0.0107749812,
0.046181161,
-0.0388852097,
-0.0009903985,
-0.0277620032,
-0.0659066215,
0.0585166402,
-0.0128787337,
-0.0019668054,
2.241450995e-34,
0.0208885651,
0.0175967067,
0.0325924791,
0.0148902405,
0.0366390646,
-0.0675569996,
-0.0309335236,
-0.0005774221,
0.0277820826,
-0.0611958243,
-0.005540309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06457v1 | V-STaR: Training Verifiers for Self-Taught Reasoners | 2024-02-09T15:02:56 | 2024-02-09T15:02:56 | Arian Hosseini, Xingdi Yuan, Nikolay Malkin, Aaron Courville, Alessandro Sordoni, Rishabh Agarwal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Common self-improvement approaches for large language models (LLMs), such as
STaR (Zelikman et al., 2022), iteratively fine-tune LLMs on self-generated
solutions to improve their problem-solving ability. However, these approaches
discard the large amounts of incorrect solutions generated during this process,
potentially neglecting valuable information in such solutions. To address this
shortcoming, we propose V-STaR that utilizes both the correct and incorrect
solutions generated during the self-improvement process to train a verifier
using DPO that judges correctness of model-generated solutions. This verifier
is used at inference time to select one solution among many candidate
solutions. Running V-STaR for multiple iterations results in progressively
better reasoners and verifiers, delivering a 4% to 17% test accuracy
improvement over existing self-improvement and verification approaches on
common code generation and math reasoning benchmarks with LLaMA2 models. | [
0.0003172339,
0.0762600973,
0.0141438171,
0.0215211939,
-0.0031544275,
-0.0029120245,
0.0204190984,
-0.0177084282,
0.0037711998,
-0.0339272805,
0.0000527895,
0.0481704697,
-0.02210485,
-0.0042577269,
0.0392716937,
0.0036308225,
0.0455611236,
-0.0629611015,
0.0102797113,
-0.0348138474,
-0.0243377928,
0.0029452792,
-0.0222143605,
0.0230791178,
-0.0221499875,
-0.0707566813,
-0.0107859904,
-0.0484199114,
-0.0196485277,
-0.0464087464,
-0.0040724981,
0.0686161816,
0.0064415843,
0.0265685897,
0.0000023425,
-0.0502570346,
-0.0371003412,
0.0096975612,
-0.0844523534,
0.0407645442,
-0.0498305298,
0.0258457828,
-0.0427349582,
0.0679249614,
-0.0211712997,
-0.0079913419,
0.002097727,
0.0184789598,
0.0798275545,
0.0589280836,
0.0073450026,
-0.034047924,
0.0651436895,
-0.0037439356,
0.0260362606,
-0.0219295397,
0.0100057721,
0.0859088525,
0.0073434892,
-0.0272980388,
-0.0126455827,
0.0267311111,
0.067700617,
-0.0431198031,
0.0111550586,
0.0204613991,
0.0230433121,
0.0115997754,
-0.0144269448,
-0.0043148878,
-0.0049371934,
-0.0784086436,
-0.0351465307,
-0.0093970057,
-0.0130166756,
-0.00141676,
-0.0068030627,
0.0360161178,
0.0101138717,
0.0135897147,
0.0616119355,
-0.0324224457,
0.0292367022,
0.0020317521,
-0.0637384504,
0.0942087919,
0.0086428821,
-0.0216042958,
0.0026376881,
0.0163648985,
-0.0063565671,
-0.0894379765,
-0.0004664785,
0.0769437179,
-0.0232788343,
0.0173645858,
-0.0265481938,
-0.0150894541,
-0.0007115825,
-0.0405683815,
0.046505928,
0.0383390263,
-0.0051988028,
0.0096170977,
-0.0468759835,
0.0445146076,
-0.0120075857,
0.0551120825,
-0.0126993442,
0.0208984595,
-0.0411265083,
-0.0081308205,
-0.0389539637,
0.0533795021,
0.010371224,
0.0204639174,
-0.0484740697,
0.028879581,
-0.0238009095,
0.0454320051,
-0.0200828966,
-0.0194538068,
0.0214529708,
-0.0461190455,
-0.0517204776,
0.0142027913,
-0.0265786722,
-0.0028810133,
0.0150148021,
-0.0568776056,
-0.0055287653,
0.0123117529,
-0.0237628724,
0.01168101,
0.0500023998,
0.0471215099,
-0.0215824414,
-0.0165858157,
-0.0585054681,
-0.0363810733,
-0.0205413941,
-0.0829555765,
-0.0261596125,
-0.1189786717,
-0.0286798365,
-0.0062246565,
-0.0068859225,
-0.0550135784,
0.0207800586,
-0.0063078436,
0.0631147027,
0.0566361435,
-0.0370561667,
0.0207866784,
0.0223025475,
0.0092328861,
-0.0031048632,
0.0508289002,
0.0633931533,
0.0084854327,
0.0057683513,
-0.0395048037,
0.0270090904,
-0.0008608015,
0.0325915925,
-0.0327874683,
-0.0360758677,
0.0352324247,
0.0014627617,
0.0202279724,
-0.0404102951,
0.0323161073,
-0.0363608934,
0.0280052666,
-0.0083157411,
0.0382302515,
0.0518595427,
0.0008838994,
0.0349600203,
-0.0391557403,
0.0310831349,
-0.0019326548,
-0.0337278657,
0.0457703061,
-0.0276690237,
0.002305385,
0.0113729108,
-0.0043520774,
-0.0173447244,
-0.1320024431,
-0.0257355701,
0.0028634234,
-0.0583409891,
0.0361930691,
0.0525673591,
0.0119304582,
-0.0226256046,
0.0270463731,
-0.003662792,
-0.0656013861,
-0.0161371771,
-0.0979565904,
0.1042560488,
0.0477597117,
0.0575824156,
-0.0180027112,
-0.0481084473,
-0.0228953939,
0.0054972502,
-0.0086484347,
0.0446434468,
-0.013691904,
0.0042431448,
-0.0231467336,
-0.0304593462,
-0.0566750318,
0.001584773,
0.0084667327,
0.0520909689,
-0.0135685727,
0.0144235725,
-0.0296028145,
-0.0249037761,
0.0566999651,
-0.0308541916,
-0.0456760116,
0.0228383411,
0.0139302071,
0.0191592835,
-0.0077520618,
-0.001851958,
0.0327647664,
0.0050671152,
-0.0105664795,
-0.0255678091,
-0.013395776,
-0.0440799892,
-0.0230851192,
0.0666479468,
-0.0347475782,
-0.0330281071,
0.0008662116,
-0.012653145,
-0.0298408847,
0.0131749241,
-0.0515352599,
-0.0233994145,
-0.0391768664,
0.0455374382,
-0.0214316789,
-0.0106980139,
0.0251567904,
0.0517014936,
0.0182462465,
-0.0412227772,
-0.0347460024,
0.062169984,
0.0481270961,
-0.0347605012,
0.0076385196,
0.0027264541,
-0.0417296551,
0.0279095154,
-0.0056689219,
0.023382023,
-0.0459986329,
-0.0509115309,
-0.0119083524,
0.0279234722,
-0.0120110177,
0.0276302751,
0.0161265396,
-0.0254100002,
0.0055780648,
0.0093424022,
-0.0099146999,
-0.0223911963,
0.055228319,
-0.0164679997,
0.035191793,
-0.0178072676,
-0.0406960919,
-0.0469366089,
-0.0147073297,
-0.0505812727,
0.0267792922,
0.0044730604,
0.0454781204,
-0.0610622428,
0.0690033436,
-0.038100902,
0.0171088837,
0.0209594145,
-0.0328261517,
0.0736330971,
-0.0324110575,
0.0140434653,
0.0568605028,
0.0109280208,
0.0175690278,
0.0980794057,
-0.0192830302,
-0.0838134363,
0.0266278032,
0.0109579442,
-0.0175186321,
-0.0082199443,
0.0038242859,
-0.0081503736,
0.0518557616,
-0.0257185549,
-0.0217489786,
-0.0521398522,
0.0251285732,
0.0158128068,
-0.0093761617,
0.0030559336,
-0.0149180973,
0.0101433313,
0.0738872513,
-0.0030576168,
-0.0774422437,
0.0756623223,
-0.0469504036,
0.0111631043,
-0.0258108135,
0.0054141642,
-0.0486511365,
0.031301707,
-0.0350157171,
0.0026564111,
-0.0090531474,
0.0126442676,
0.0012211727,
-0.0222026389,
0.037561059,
-0.0389554128,
0.0505679771,
-0.0419537723,
0.0056465263,
0.0285906456,
-0.0475951992,
-0.075947322,
0.0300917849,
-0.0495333187,
-0.0178877544,
-0.0424795225,
-0.0029921676,
0.0064206603,
0.0023330371,
0.0020008464,
0.0071593737,
-0.0155229177,
-0.0479428396,
-0.0031735839,
-0.0289309639,
-0.0134229194,
0.0133196199,
0.0720528811,
-0.0385233127,
0.0509765632,
0.021829484,
0.0528682396,
0.0106194466,
-0.0536970049,
0.0141702835,
0.0090273768,
-0.0234950241,
-0.005007559,
0.0387211666,
0.0563889481,
-0.0836298838,
-0.0243389271,
0.1040882766,
0.0229186285,
0.018677339,
0.0126688173,
-0.0571921729,
0.0150741404,
0.0322897844,
0.0639251545,
-0.0828163847,
-0.0197696351,
0.0000464678,
0.032944873,
-0.0073259464,
-0.0044731903,
-0.0204738677,
-0.1194685847,
0.0623227619,
0.0294980295,
-0.0105214762,
0.0162854847,
-0.0373335034,
-0.0257823355,
-0.0016517331,
-0.0214426704,
0.0369525999,
-0.0070653348,
0.0151869645,
0.0213812012,
-0.0178349279,
-0.0237947199,
0.0305739976,
-0.0122932037,
0.0384801663,
0.0383939855,
-0.0069161481,
0.0205930583,
-0.0856150836,
0.0063002305,
-0.0075155436,
0.0204164851,
-0.0154782413,
0.0025011455,
-0.0105309542,
-0.0037691144,
-0.0019469905,
0.0539377816,
-0.0380872525,
-0.0299629513,
0.0177744646,
0.081120193,
0.0045143147,
-0.0313768461,
-0.0142623242,
0.0075184,
-0.0678037256,
0.0081492327,
0.0320719965,
0.0163903981,
-0.063356109,
-0.0406800434,
-0.0131090814,
-0.0462705381,
-0.0017011481,
0.0092446664,
0.0410025232,
-0.0056159692,
-0.0211668648,
0.0016338724,
0.0361737721,
0.0676593706,
-0.0382522866,
-0.0279213507,
-0.0352779999,
-0.0095831035,
-0.0210525151,
0.0040328517,
-0.0563073568,
0.0264567845,
-0.0905114263,
0.0416073687,
0.0043098703,
-0.0209222995,
0.0057630269,
-0.0151556386,
-0.0484978333,
-0.0586894043,
-0.0198797062,
0.0765106753,
0.0214685574,
0.0418381356,
-0.0130132446,
-0.0292451438,
0.0148836784,
0.0203583259,
-0.012576188,
-0.0062515163,
0.0524090789,
-0.0470192507,
0.0205957759,
0.0017543292,
-0.0048668082,
0.0402355604,
0.0286293514,
0.0058411211,
0.0144692603,
-0.0250490252,
0.0540705174,
0.0681764558,
-0.0099611655,
-0.0047374051,
0.0049315076,
-0.0291933175,
0.0314271152,
-0.0183284953,
-0.0026776176,
-0.0177172888,
0.0536121204,
-0.0091467826,
-0.025865674,
0.0296350271,
-0.0301476177,
-0.0405873396,
0.0147462059,
0.0316512361,
0.0562330224,
0.0226656161,
0.0258822143,
0.0154555971,
-0.0254700761,
0.0155479005,
0.0021015606,
0.0408396237,
0.0491551571,
-0.0014969526,
0.0551432557,
0.0122187519,
0.03160806,
-0.0331470817,
-0.0064547262,
-0.0601370819,
-0.0939241648,
-0.0070967376,
0.0153547581,
0.0623872206,
0.0621008165,
0.0021019266,
-0.0242781416,
0.0001330251,
0.0171590671,
0.0344343856,
-0.0148886414,
0.0010404884,
0.0145157678,
0.0256377924,
0.0226223171,
-0.0483038537,
0.0378773138,
-0.0146619333,
0.0665643662,
-0.0071129901,
0.0249823295,
-0.0522654168,
-0.0374530181,
-0.0407096967,
-0.0083992546,
-0.0155804325,
-0.031970229,
-0.0068620322,
-0.0858710483,
-0.0211529862,
0.086006999,
0.0071733259,
-0.0060017756,
-0.0097509902,
0.0749576166,
-0.0038292387,
-0.0250894725,
0.0069986708,
-0.0039072628,
0.0037466632,
-0.0116550177,
0.0351944529,
-6.092330816e-33,
-0.0420358591,
-0.0550198145,
0.0696853101,
-0.004332507,
0.0256732963,
-0.0268929098,
-0.0551883616,
0.0136317145,
-0.0015818016,
0.034122888,
-0.0238832254,
0.0349464789,
0.0090578282,
-0.029674571,
0.0315464102,
0.0367483795,
0.0644993633,
0.014830593,
-0.0649746507,
0.0114063378,
-0.0114641245,
-0.0118583795,
0.0153326439,
-0.0540686846,
-0.0105987322,
0.0121555254,
-0.0247160122,
0.0428756997,
-0.0732227862,
0.0650042295,
0.0224876851,
0.0026196812,
-0.0079849949,
-0.0163044371,
-0.0148678403,
-0.0512569509,
-0.0537153706,
-0.0338276327,
-0.0107759899,
-0.0324376337,
-0.0514275171,
-0.0619084872,
0.0622806437,
0.0148249334,
-0.0645962358,
-0.0007944993,
-0.0092475154,
-0.0062546325,
0.0325068571,
0.036333628,
-0.0420950726,
0.0306067113,
-0.0361827314,
-0.0487271175,
0.0151482513,
-0.0119161345,
-0.0255265497,
-0.0371860079,
-0.0077829757,
0.0319419503,
0.0493676886,
0.0102941031,
0.09471751,
-0.0237368159,
-0.0345328338,
0.0056058513,
0.061012622,
-0.0124546923,
-0.0086889938,
0.0033410627,
0.0172535609,
0.072788544,
0.0854921043,
0.0208020136,
0.0304693598,
-0.0033525841,
-0.0657872558,
0.0275538228,
-0.0133804325,
0.0315056555,
0.0167424213,
0.001551004,
-0.0293756351,
0.0003241851,
-0.0429323204,
-0.0226554256,
-0.0201945659,
-0.0432561673,
0.0235348511,
0.0181718059,
-0.0444200747,
-0.0319726244,
-0.0062223831,
-0.0531081408,
-0.0055250661,
0.0349841565,
-0.024827214,
0.0109324371,
-0.0191350374,
0.031603165,
-0.0594256446,
0.0037852735,
0.0115254754,
0.0107479831,
0.0272038504,
0.0350437313,
0.0087609915,
0.018282149,
-0.0666344985,
0.0187615976,
-0.0489645191,
-0.0155901676,
0.0157010108,
-0.0019649602,
0.0151161011,
0.0015007623,
0.0100438371,
0.0429533198,
-0.0179003533,
-0.0048236125,
-0.0327466279,
0.0505080968,
0.0177705772,
0.0313921273,
0.0177480541,
-0.0056163571,
-0.0606430545,
0.0244486071,
0.0259526018,
-0.036718417,
-0.0009459733,
0.0168547928,
2.979e-7,
0.0028221661,
0.0590819605,
0.0330566987,
0.0060371975,
-0.0025978619,
0.0517739281,
-0.0003097733,
-0.0511862002,
0.0196495429,
-0.0007637398,
-0.0051970566,
0.0564798266,
0.0166672952,
0.0509561822,
0.0347688198,
0.0079646213,
-0.0335195027,
-0.0017089891,
-0.0441540219,
-0.0211476889,
0.0549768135,
0.0399724655,
0.0136463903,
-0.0440326743,
0.0211993307,
-0.0024918104,
0.0473579876,
0.0336925425,
-0.0015953174,
0.0500364155,
0.0240607075,
0.0281091649,
0.0173445381,
-0.0048246956,
0.0073802485,
0.0248638764,
-0.0716143027,
0.0627288818,
-0.0045936019,
0.0305712167,
0.0090453476,
0.0174089354,
-0.0078511406,
-0.0544965118,
0.061515525,
-0.0191881545,
-0.0339007303,
-0.0300548021,
0.0279963296,
-0.0470835865,
0.0121060349,
-0.0329350121,
0.0188333858,
0.0139390724,
-0.0081545403,
-0.0124340737,
-0.017870849,
-0.0332249999,
-0.0458214842,
-0.0079451129,
0.0025903627,
-0.0048270412,
-0.0242934301,
0.0113222152,
0.0167463645,
-0.0355084725,
-0.0038068048,
2.511398452e-34,
0.0076610325,
-0.0020868005,
0.0235089008,
0.0176696908,
0.0561008975,
0.0163104422,
-0.0102881128,
0.0011527122,
0.017191425,
-0.0138914855,
-0.0359827615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06443v1 | Explaining Veracity Predictions with Evidence Summarization: A Multi-Task Model Approach | 2024-02-09T14:39:20 | 2024-02-09T14:39:20 | Recep Firat Cekinel, Pinar Karagoz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid dissemination of misinformation through social media increased the
importance of automated fact-checking. Furthermore, studies on what deep neural
models pay attention to when making predictions have increased in recent years.
While significant progress has been made in this field, it has not yet reached
a level of reasoning comparable to human reasoning. To address these gaps, we
propose a multi-task explainable neural model for misinformation detection.
Specifically, this work formulates an explanation generation process of the
model's veracity prediction as a text summarization problem. Additionally, the
performance of the proposed model is discussed on publicly available datasets
and the findings are evaluated with related studies. | [
0.0242051221,
-0.0120455138,
0.0180773493,
0.0013379598,
0.0014054646,
0.0135454098,
0.0242224131,
-0.0349452011,
-0.0212450195,
0.0115863057,
0.0202039424,
-0.0397536047,
0.0189524349,
0.0471002869,
0.0177116748,
-0.0267289206,
0.0442912988,
-0.0051018251,
0.0754765049,
0.0023846622,
0.0191708133,
0.0470294282,
-0.0035919913,
0.052895423,
-0.0112613533,
-0.0283355974,
0.0050533945,
0.004705416,
0.0255604517,
0.0029718394,
0.018133916,
0.0122840451,
0.0701916069,
0.067656301,
0.000001652,
0.0090897828,
-0.0192668233,
0.0049351724,
-0.0725970566,
0.0091215074,
0.0082175778,
-0.035286814,
0.0274784844,
0.0162008945,
0.0036901224,
0.0351405963,
0.0354885198,
0.0916462988,
0.0995634794,
0.0827575624,
-0.0033164346,
-0.028079154,
0.0222796686,
-0.0195968766,
-0.0019265037,
-0.035676416,
0.0253836345,
0.035266988,
-0.044794634,
0.0290212147,
0.0333897322,
-0.0097219441,
0.0360185504,
-0.0341638885,
-0.0174066052,
0.0005220746,
0.0123685449,
-0.0472879559,
0.0014169542,
0.0478126854,
-0.0156338979,
-0.0605096072,
0.0253784321,
-0.0080027981,
0.0076122447,
0.0485119149,
-0.0392277762,
0.0284357313,
-0.0306846481,
0.0225853734,
0.0217524488,
0.0141625647,
0.0609184764,
0.047935389,
0.039683789,
0.0531526096,
-0.0434527025,
-0.0093242507,
-0.037625175,
0.0090655554,
-0.0170891974,
-0.0529443473,
0.0020680735,
0.0288608968,
-0.0328569971,
-0.0054185623,
-0.0416637026,
-0.0493971109,
0.012504464,
-0.0573670194,
-0.0128310127,
-0.0022256193,
-0.0242869705,
0.0710467175,
-0.019328339,
0.0212905146,
-0.0225005057,
-0.0060016541,
0.0006015736,
-0.046719484,
-0.0271511655,
0.0039910208,
0.0154649448,
0.0108842701,
-0.023300577,
0.0084594097,
-0.0357244834,
-0.0349133089,
-0.0377138257,
-0.013634407,
0.032327719,
0.0400261059,
-0.045660533,
-0.0230178479,
-0.0469766818,
0.0184858534,
-0.0296232682,
0.0210272036,
0.0268983636,
-0.0095307594,
-0.0229573119,
0.0319514498,
0.0113316234,
0.0223152861,
0.0042161704,
-0.0106932642,
-0.0077168061,
0.0291444659,
-0.0384725146,
-0.0480946898,
-0.021344291,
-0.049578473,
0.023587741,
-0.0367609337,
0.0171932876,
-0.043785926,
-0.0429300368,
-0.0073574656,
-0.0321966596,
0.0290599149,
-0.0617503338,
0.0630979836,
-0.0375625379,
-0.0202218629,
0.0530842841,
0.0090418383,
-0.0167167131,
0.0532689057,
0.0239974484,
0.0760785639,
0.0600461029,
0.0369457193,
0.0045846738,
-0.0547390208,
0.0690572709,
0.0086305244,
0.0713790134,
-0.0235641189,
-0.0671783313,
-0.0109793581,
0.0228303559,
0.0265744478,
-0.0235426445,
-0.0183750615,
0.0565134771,
-0.0256463084,
0.0029691635,
0.014351964,
0.0596274734,
0.0343931653,
-0.0059784991,
0.0339364223,
-0.0420045368,
0.0691744387,
-0.0263039749,
0.0285232738,
0.0347393453,
0.051067818,
-0.0364029221,
-0.0771293193,
0.0020226885,
-0.0105131697,
0.0131625049,
0.0038961403,
0.012014607,
-0.0031305004,
-0.0710266605,
0.0409200937,
0.0417540409,
-0.0279034674,
-0.001931935,
-0.0508341156,
0.0415495485,
0.0343119539,
0.0086846463,
-0.0219328348,
-0.0191389527,
-0.0347761624,
0.0523764156,
0.0287019145,
0.0347754732,
-0.0184132569,
-0.0139030954,
-0.0352328531,
-0.0214399286,
-0.0529854335,
0.0401534997,
-0.0062053106,
0.0179784987,
-0.0271517076,
0.0372609086,
-0.0371822268,
-0.0772106424,
0.0157825742,
-0.0157355051,
0.0053092595,
-0.0158869196,
0.0081189889,
-0.0042591272,
0.0361989625,
0.0041763429,
-0.0043985946,
0.035522595,
0.0016389721,
-0.0381238051,
0.0025334377,
-0.0183798261,
-0.0154334949,
0.0205828715,
-0.0409912057,
-0.0333730765,
0.0236239713,
-0.0573934317,
-0.0376275107,
0.0132131847,
-0.0493743047,
-0.0353824385,
-0.0381590091,
-0.033196725,
-0.0115551567,
0.0115577318,
0.0273769964,
0.0909433141,
-0.0161654502,
-0.0289749224,
0.0156845078,
-0.0323219486,
0.0076315715,
-0.0069757146,
0.0210226104,
-0.0346291251,
-0.0180831086,
-0.0091594392,
0.0109229721,
-0.0240958016,
0.0101833139,
0.0148186386,
-0.0484039672,
-0.0023225995,
-0.0335837901,
-0.0173158217,
0.0344710015,
-0.0280070864,
0.0344029032,
-0.0052048545,
-0.0259784088,
0.0177491754,
0.0142743103,
0.0099802529,
0.029550571,
-0.0079948585,
0.0134564936,
-0.0451688245,
-0.0087002069,
-0.0140005527,
0.0468127839,
0.0260737352,
-0.0399085842,
-0.0584447198,
0.0057420321,
-0.0458483696,
0.0011821038,
-0.0269671213,
0.0065402729,
0.0118347825,
0.0413002856,
0.001041219,
0.0511330552,
0.0317714065,
0.0574029237,
0.0304653626,
0.0567780323,
0.0050801784,
-0.01033838,
-0.0485343337,
0.0409442894,
0.0002763695,
-0.0776384845,
0.0222937595,
0.0571160018,
0.0153743746,
-0.0123240398,
-0.0513696969,
0.016085472,
-0.0035210934,
-0.0391512588,
0.0080352761,
-0.0635220259,
0.0194193311,
0.0416730121,
-0.0691288337,
-0.0459023193,
0.1043837219,
-0.0335471965,
0.0571021363,
-0.025862243,
-0.0496497452,
-0.0118443817,
0.0057283947,
-0.0100934785,
0.0154091557,
0.0496648625,
0.0285947807,
-0.0114108911,
-0.0407470986,
0.0629248321,
0.0134825073,
0.0352279469,
-0.0470026098,
0.0125199715,
0.032306727,
-0.0041561695,
-0.0244341847,
-0.0760327354,
-0.0211864021,
0.0058308742,
-0.004329164,
-0.0162783526,
-0.0818000659,
-0.0259921346,
0.0623481832,
0.0362102203,
-0.0195863787,
0.015754601,
0.0092542395,
0.0123951342,
0.0561134703,
0.027148027,
0.0902232304,
-0.0456071496,
-0.0056356001,
0.0285454206,
0.0045576133,
-0.0008469028,
-0.0428692885,
-0.0599299856,
-0.0406590626,
-0.031968005,
-0.0261840634,
-0.016054064,
0.0621685311,
-0.0604777411,
0.0410148799,
0.0953289419,
-0.0026312904,
0.0071106204,
-0.0058967178,
0.0132129872,
-0.0174260419,
-0.00003374,
-0.0066640102,
-0.0292471405,
-0.0097132334,
0.0047784466,
0.0097825956,
0.0065947664,
0.00261988,
-0.0181931704,
-0.0396318398,
0.0219151601,
-0.0305334069,
0.0181666128,
-0.0596383363,
-0.0594524816,
-0.010767444,
-0.0211556014,
0.0138030555,
0.0025503959,
0.0486634746,
-0.0031456891,
0.0233081523,
-0.0184669551,
-0.0345767513,
0.02099468,
-0.0254578274,
0.0447762385,
0.0533225536,
0.0629050061,
-0.0086955978,
-0.0270531867,
-0.0154839205,
0.0150279142,
-0.0070585082,
0.0076165879,
0.1089606658,
-0.0079219788,
0.0070029418,
-0.0437908694,
0.0348581113,
-0.0098265847,
-0.0276576057,
-0.0435746014,
0.0429566912,
0.0138816852,
-0.0443387851,
-0.0360896736,
0.0222673025,
0.0127104307,
0.0918277875,
0.0180969033,
0.028628299,
-0.0161652043,
-0.0397402197,
-0.0137115102,
-0.0496747829,
-0.0190090276,
0.0112534622,
0.0052331393,
-0.0163453761,
-0.0387767702,
-0.0170728322,
-0.0293947887,
0.0013076694,
-0.0285831857,
-0.0225873776,
0.0362453237,
-0.0075666453,
-0.0306562185,
0.0124994228,
0.0091373194,
0.0312298331,
0.0177576579,
-0.0276900437,
-0.0049102497,
-0.0537208579,
-0.0114416089,
0.0319140628,
-0.0698228851,
-0.0169567131,
-0.0339506604,
0.0243610758,
0.0281351898,
0.0598028526,
-0.0255700387,
-0.0325928517,
0.027712144,
-0.007878799,
-0.0269736033,
0.0011558108,
0.0459997505,
-0.0240190327,
0.0235882644,
0.0299049616,
-0.0333239995,
0.0240652859,
-0.0215788037,
-0.0403280035,
-0.0421872512,
-0.0112039763,
0.0151826367,
0.0035442647,
0.0405946337,
0.0045930236,
-0.0141165787,
-0.0527793057,
-0.0504793003,
-0.0089616776,
-0.0231436957,
0.0046042022,
0.0759271383,
-0.0151159549,
-0.0301983319,
0.0027931151,
0.0040681851,
-0.0005495049,
-0.0033128604,
-0.0322019942,
-0.0077679278,
-0.0289308056,
0.0008808334,
-0.037677139,
0.0099261943,
-0.0442148484,
-0.008412716,
-0.0329491347,
0.0156440735,
0.0248097684,
0.0137064392,
0.0158261843,
-0.0141771734,
0.0122611327,
-0.0205866992,
-0.086103119,
-0.0067390171,
-0.0334237479,
0.0067111547,
0.0219594166,
-0.0163720306,
0.0618920587,
0.0228335895,
-0.0279515944,
0.0029243496,
0.032524012,
0.0417253897,
0.0147699136,
-0.00637133,
0.011238236,
-0.0349147543,
0.0086655943,
0.102892518,
0.0056010452,
0.0029471151,
0.0264249109,
-0.0653537437,
-0.0159362797,
-0.0262906197,
-0.064735949,
0.0749481842,
0.0064895661,
-0.0236026775,
-0.0383100174,
-0.0496007055,
0.0453376323,
0.020652635,
0.0248245709,
-0.0097874589,
-0.0225944426,
0.0793074518,
0.0077100294,
-0.0181293692,
-0.0535092577,
0.0000448387,
-0.0056203222,
0.0162140876,
-0.011769115,
-5.747964603e-33,
0.0080597959,
-0.0526153743,
-0.0247842781,
-0.0158576854,
0.0003147403,
0.0529378839,
-0.0467128158,
-0.0666875318,
-0.0540786721,
0.0714763328,
0.0540037602,
0.0690493807,
0.00717689,
0.0054225628,
-0.0327107757,
-0.022404125,
0.058292821,
0.0114004975,
-0.0106392866,
0.0335500911,
0.0479274988,
-0.0091061797,
0.0333685763,
-0.0662012175,
0.0912148729,
-0.0229588449,
-0.0299895592,
0.0391986333,
-0.0105772503,
0.0484395139,
0.0041994769,
0.0511805266,
0.05354793,
-0.0761982873,
-0.001944844,
0.0166286007,
-0.0754791573,
-0.0288385842,
0.0451145656,
-0.053274598,
-0.0601780936,
-0.0104880845,
0.03250622,
0.0012595545,
0.0415531732,
-0.0199676491,
0.0418428555,
-0.0141577423,
0.009141447,
-0.0252180696,
-0.0348387547,
0.0011512294,
0.005155527,
-0.0320284702,
-0.0199648999,
0.0799177065,
0.0174893662,
0.0246120337,
-0.0987679362,
0.0187750831,
-0.0161018446,
0.0041946732,
0.0702315643,
-0.032835912,
-0.0371119119,
0.0711240768,
0.0111120464,
0.0468373112,
-0.1132641807,
-0.0093359398,
-0.0497334637,
0.0421489105,
0.0817297548,
0.0593962707,
0.0198332872,
-0.0111234412,
-0.1016976237,
0.0259839129,
0.0136995483,
-0.001646449,
0.0452571698,
-0.009656325,
-0.0226410907,
-0.0121963732,
-0.0371452905,
0.0152991666,
-0.0295455679,
-0.0015768141,
-0.0350374132,
0.0202544071,
-0.042406898,
0.035791561,
-0.0264641102,
-0.0479572751,
0.067356661,
0.0353394374,
-0.008485076,
-0.0327325128,
0.0301653706,
0.019604126,
-0.0422909483,
0.0521929897,
0.0029538791,
0.0189837702,
-0.0077815494,
0.0221668314,
0.0697391853,
-0.0166386329,
0.004413004,
0.0215558894,
-0.0422032923,
0.0294349678,
-0.0099869948,
0.0094325589,
0.0109988442,
0.03336991,
-0.0381180532,
-0.0042407624,
0.0087680425,
0.0364818871,
0.0175749231,
0.0255632121,
-0.0137296272,
0.0223351028,
-0.0225328337,
-0.0132407919,
-0.0384009592,
-0.0018587519,
-0.0035000718,
-0.0893437713,
-0.005870332,
0.0343303382,
2.38e-7,
0.0274677332,
0.0496323518,
0.0269338414,
-0.0091349315,
0.0292875227,
0.0474270172,
0.048028294,
-0.0232817903,
-0.0222703926,
-0.0959167704,
-0.0300651826,
0.0735987574,
0.0320387073,
0.0425858609,
0.0045791366,
-0.0363482796,
-0.0506110303,
-0.0396521427,
-0.0386342369,
0.0047590449,
0.0086432248,
0.0604727268,
0.0190361198,
-0.0217922386,
0.0114067914,
-0.0010346905,
0.0385557264,
0.0233180523,
-0.0353988446,
-0.0016847815,
0.079044126,
-0.0274939649,
-0.0117578888,
0.0438859574,
-0.0245267991,
-0.0317061581,
0.0004306212,
0.0120338174,
-0.0000291692,
-0.0005485541,
0.0001369085,
-0.0427098908,
0.0287836958,
-0.0328438394,
0.058355514,
-0.0489163063,
-0.0423978455,
-0.0202937815,
-0.0268371291,
0.0502989702,
-0.0206312314,
-0.000485183,
0.0056577669,
0.0068513365,
-0.040003594,
-0.0037537392,
0.0215484742,
-0.0417850204,
-0.0433179662,
0.016779149,
-0.0496970415,
-0.0070777694,
0.0103470478,
-0.0621827431,
0.0734789521,
-0.0525640212,
0.0400599279,
1.856229787e-34,
0.0692792609,
-0.0057138572,
-0.0161941592,
-0.0387119763,
0.0333449058,
0.0235314481,
-0.0713883489,
-0.0592535771,
0.0395634174,
-0.0150334658,
-0.0284602046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06420v1 | Findings of the First Workshop on Simulating Conversational Intelligence in Chat | 2024-02-09T14:08:23 | 2024-02-09T14:08:23 | Yvette Graham, Mohammed Rameez Qureshi, Haider Khalid, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The aim of this workshop is to bring together experts working on open-domain
dialogue research. In this speedily advancing research area many challenges
still exist, such as learning information from conversations, engaging in
realistic and convincing simulation of human intelligence and reasoning.
SCI-CHAT follows previous workshops on open domain dialogue but with a focus on
the simulation of intelligent conversation as judged in a live human
evaluation. Models aim to include the ability to follow a challenging topic
over a multi-turn conversation, while positing, refuting and reasoning over
arguments. The workshop included both a research track and shared task. The
main goal of this paper is to provide an overview of the shared task and a link
to an additional paper that will include an in depth analysis of the shared
task results following presentation at the workshop. | [
0.0739146173,
-0.0260794703,
-0.024857875,
-0.0013413398,
-0.074322246,
-0.0014069097,
0.0277090091,
0.0040801731,
0.0697805658,
-0.0535866544,
-0.011551246,
-0.0107715204,
-0.0037661747,
0.0428852066,
0.0056518097,
-0.0615818016,
0.0283881091,
-0.0366002657,
0.0617247261,
-0.002137895,
-0.0062454687,
-0.0079215625,
-0.0558235757,
0.0409345925,
-0.0192752816,
-0.0258956105,
-0.0504104123,
-0.0247483738,
-0.0016109719,
-0.0031312983,
0.0118694417,
0.0651607364,
0.0279648453,
0.0589487925,
0.0000020591,
-0.0510119274,
-0.0012570306,
-0.0278449077,
-0.0570888892,
-0.0248958301,
0.0365525335,
0.0937627107,
-0.0205539893,
0.0405699089,
-0.0654375106,
0.0333750919,
0.0099650668,
0.059290424,
0.0537493341,
0.0519391112,
-0.0099664889,
0.0146408146,
0.0251657218,
0.008541231,
-0.0037459063,
-0.0547809936,
0.0101917153,
0.0563212223,
0.017030796,
0.0332951881,
0.0297195166,
-0.0010724851,
0.0194194298,
-0.0669310018,
-0.0380294435,
0.0244620088,
-0.0265060831,
-0.0343055353,
-0.0184681136,
0.0521036685,
0.0484478995,
0.0060109533,
-0.0106491121,
0.0420708358,
0.0183132067,
-0.0394512676,
-0.0691747293,
0.0143747535,
-0.0187916234,
-0.0251999069,
-0.012245656,
0.0383396521,
-0.0225824062,
0.0361183994,
-0.0006430643,
0.0199227631,
-0.0130801704,
-0.0301233232,
0.0122814057,
-0.0279171094,
0.007122945,
-0.0720599592,
-0.0268536694,
0.0342458226,
-0.0306390263,
0.0217927117,
-0.0006789792,
0.0101478519,
0.0150738945,
-0.0792564824,
0.0001633861,
0.0211056694,
0.0337146372,
0.0430643968,
0.0576220751,
0.033881899,
-0.007144866,
0.0231231172,
0.0233289376,
-0.0283596497,
-0.0464460477,
-0.0238192528,
-0.0352902524,
0.0329635665,
-0.0223680399,
-0.0347196683,
-0.0016953531,
0.0231660139,
-0.0272400863,
0.0016200182,
-0.031086199,
0.0151534006,
-0.027230639,
0.0035657363,
-0.0556180254,
0.0034297991,
-0.0205368996,
0.0190017372,
0.026175756,
-0.0769160017,
-0.0166741554,
0.0466569513,
-0.023872098,
0.000728177,
-0.0142879654,
0.0823648423,
-0.0282230806,
-0.0234097298,
0.0273403991,
-0.0341477655,
0.0021896241,
-0.0500818528,
0.0462369286,
-0.0306297857,
0.0281684306,
-0.0016158273,
-0.0308924504,
-0.0225979853,
0.0014652148,
0.0337047428,
0.002164518,
0.0277802497,
-0.0493806638,
-0.0151251825,
0.0573425554,
0.0339245535,
-0.0427197367,
0.0554238968,
0.0160987657,
-0.0087842718,
0.0410773233,
0.0226954445,
0.0321618505,
-0.0071111554,
0.0027237264,
-0.0190668777,
0.056322135,
0.0214283913,
0.0146078831,
0.0440395139,
-0.0222247895,
0.0367550366,
-0.0516908392,
-0.0209378544,
0.0383065045,
0.0750763714,
-0.007228761,
0.0315986983,
0.0297442079,
0.0445096008,
0.0601552688,
0.0136223352,
-0.0292096529,
0.0609086044,
-0.0329111032,
-0.0151206972,
-0.0067073647,
0.0059869606,
-0.0312290043,
-0.0311558619,
0.0319318958,
0.0049625076,
0.0305645894,
-0.0082081296,
0.0157975983,
-0.011265792,
-0.0271422919,
-0.0107217357,
0.0153929703,
-0.0409538634,
-0.0695815608,
-0.0791210234,
0.0157297496,
0.0544937514,
0.0532282479,
-0.0057888487,
-0.0647354871,
-0.0163469054,
0.029927399,
0.070593521,
0.0625526085,
-0.0236956794,
-0.015258966,
-0.038469255,
-0.0172189306,
-0.0190688111,
-0.0274985898,
0.0193827264,
-0.022086544,
-0.0256120339,
-0.0081197638,
0.045902092,
0.0286007673,
0.0058809887,
-0.0233694315,
0.028649969,
-0.0357184336,
-0.0321935043,
0.0527458526,
0.0171327572,
-0.0035006348,
0.0055246949,
0.0291540436,
0.0285223275,
-0.0220152233,
0.0561623275,
-0.0236645434,
-0.0172884688,
0.0434522331,
-0.0465417765,
-0.0197309349,
0.0262692627,
0.0219332278,
-0.0208732523,
0.0456630923,
-0.054183621,
0.0098473923,
-0.0332510248,
0.0105426786,
-0.0048395819,
-0.0071672327,
0.0129457125,
0.0615028627,
0.0155564193,
0.0115172034,
0.0091072842,
-0.0271746609,
0.0362885632,
-0.0706834868,
0.0514031351,
0.003336963,
-0.0101054432,
-0.0134839704,
0.0041209389,
-0.0120565323,
-0.0567007735,
-0.02416935,
-0.1453413516,
-0.0050420915,
-0.0006434033,
0.0160685945,
0.0109453388,
-0.0028831337,
-0.0060793525,
-0.009483723,
-0.0304316785,
-0.0129014952,
0.0276731085,
-0.0163176097,
0.0319682658,
-0.0122062135,
-0.0056249634,
-0.0365068763,
0.0224437732,
-0.040156506,
0.0308402833,
0.0339877829,
0.0057126344,
-0.0226593576,
-0.0092376256,
-0.046080526,
0.0642936602,
-0.0252555441,
-0.0522992052,
0.0642322898,
0.0239608604,
0.0396712124,
0.0462085642,
0.0823092088,
0.0228869207,
-0.0219548307,
-0.0058599408,
-0.0587656237,
0.0348543189,
0.0029540607,
0.0595146455,
-0.0497445799,
-0.0121774478,
0.0071506407,
0.0551269948,
-0.0169423111,
0.0483791791,
-0.0272058249,
0.0489698462,
0.0254268199,
-0.0617461912,
-0.0110346237,
-0.0049808621,
-0.0112718651,
0.0399388894,
-0.0233916808,
-0.0037277814,
0.0731891319,
-0.0200205073,
-0.0012114892,
-0.0638104826,
-0.0071808957,
-0.0197562799,
0.0517240018,
-0.0597804636,
-0.0118249804,
0.0072832988,
0.0009694342,
-0.0186051577,
0.0034062965,
0.001338981,
-0.0386604629,
-0.0189342201,
-0.0513761044,
-0.0064314809,
0.0378535874,
-0.0169138163,
-0.0510625988,
-0.0307032559,
-0.0347294137,
0.0139373932,
0.0477952696,
-0.0200374257,
-0.0670124963,
0.0035741497,
0.0398599133,
0.0004880175,
0.0127227241,
-0.013856397,
-0.0113562997,
-0.004298307,
0.0372134037,
0.0346652158,
0.0038451876,
-0.0087130424,
0.0828436986,
0.061474517,
0.008830253,
-0.017553037,
-0.0065201642,
-0.0300043803,
-0.0012996984,
-0.0229368508,
0.0041461531,
-0.0073649944,
0.037786372,
-0.0104759205,
-0.0340332948,
0.0997225344,
0.0508206002,
-0.005823697,
-0.0126658864,
-0.0549040064,
-0.0042690183,
0.0148189608,
0.0393479168,
-0.0641912371,
-0.0137751959,
-0.0098007703,
-0.0151551422,
-0.0530938581,
-0.0548016205,
-0.0073328014,
-0.0750265047,
0.0167207867,
-0.0174413603,
-0.0260030963,
-0.0409846567,
-0.0102652777,
0.0171769802,
0.0106263245,
-0.0255532656,
-0.0066908034,
0.0601502545,
-0.0091883028,
0.0028740345,
-0.0370008834,
0.0219091736,
0.0562747978,
0.0020690062,
0.0568351112,
0.0332528874,
0.0732552856,
0.0482660532,
-0.0292864647,
0.0122631891,
-0.003161876,
0.0021366966,
0.0051468797,
0.0497958511,
-0.0141111985,
0.0252936147,
-0.1060251147,
0.0143721234,
0.0293492023,
-0.0227353442,
0.0501230657,
0.0537078939,
-0.1060620546,
-0.0019816782,
-0.0330821946,
0.0460756496,
0.0236303564,
0.047852315,
0.0269729085,
-0.0348071642,
-0.0248006601,
-0.0228244085,
-0.0143113751,
-0.0375644676,
-0.0606419668,
-0.0236835051,
0.0517146923,
0.0163449235,
-0.0763394088,
-0.0398010127,
0.0128736021,
0.0400109775,
-0.0304280873,
-0.0339532681,
-0.0027915901,
0.0341127813,
0.0188707951,
-0.0260677561,
-0.0217718966,
0.0018526732,
-0.0283135548,
-0.0093804421,
0.029300848,
-0.0504336692,
-0.0078655025,
0.0409804098,
0.0010646194,
-0.0395985059,
0.0084197605,
0.0508528762,
0.0302596632,
0.0235364977,
-0.0412130021,
-0.0048908754,
-0.0246279407,
-0.0308619309,
-0.0477219597,
-0.0096934149,
0.0498242341,
0.0375183895,
0.019132331,
0.027558282,
0.0142371813,
0.0498571917,
-0.0211767554,
0.0185520202,
-0.0340714715,
-0.0969559401,
0.0122286007,
-0.0139991995,
0.0453721285,
0.0687644929,
-0.0491874591,
0.0226389486,
0.01678841,
-0.0494634248,
-0.0237189829,
-0.006042718,
-0.0123162223,
-0.0635000765,
0.0007944407,
0.0287112948,
0.0059959446,
-0.0620463043,
0.0107381251,
0.0066613904,
0.0172064248,
0.0179389399,
0.0170464497,
-0.0479310863,
-0.0061381543,
0.0006566871,
0.0135269156,
-0.0178267956,
0.0352105089,
0.0187486783,
0.1051565483,
0.0076470231,
-0.0574979931,
0.0396227054,
0.0136952884,
-0.0966603011,
-0.0354691744,
0.0558441058,
0.1009527147,
-0.0084713064,
0.0584569238,
-0.0081151836,
-0.0482900254,
0.0259277821,
0.005056309,
0.0388008878,
-0.0139761306,
-0.0353974625,
0.0204057135,
0.0431155562,
-0.015802525,
-0.0074813277,
0.0378049985,
-0.0520823151,
0.0018949287,
-0.0059355781,
-0.0216001086,
-0.0410088487,
-0.0429654308,
-0.0174554028,
0.0353055038,
0.0245898813,
0.0294003636,
-0.0617938116,
-0.0188737046,
0.0097615169,
0.0289324969,
0.0570972487,
-0.0178318191,
0.035385035,
0.0771919563,
-0.0275743697,
-0.0163174011,
-0.0171889197,
0.0325491764,
-0.0398927592,
-0.0074576982,
-0.0319725908,
-6.008222725e-33,
-0.0227064528,
-0.0636685789,
0.0490602851,
0.060492143,
-0.0280695334,
-0.0649638399,
-0.0349301808,
0.009305316,
-0.0336822271,
0.0278019365,
-0.020214051,
0.0394009687,
0.0031727264,
-0.0079052905,
-0.0345850289,
0.0154752284,
0.0190347321,
-0.0283487923,
-0.0356777124,
0.0436334834,
0.0367293581,
-0.0310421772,
-0.0238235947,
-0.0862515867,
0.0363651104,
-0.022652654,
0.0263720136,
0.0217152163,
-0.0078073256,
0.0377343632,
-0.0140385935,
0.0240595471,
0.0302093942,
-0.0587852448,
0.0061587254,
0.0394876078,
-0.0338099115,
-0.0320744999,
0.0257302932,
-0.026590813,
-0.0255263709,
-0.0157885496,
-0.0156621728,
-0.0104463352,
-0.0273780003,
-0.0126715824,
0.0040809414,
-0.0058954158,
0.0148613835,
0.0075889523,
-0.0781774968,
0.0118486639,
-0.0314940624,
-0.0799511746,
-0.0337507091,
0.052371785,
-0.0022433337,
-0.073077172,
-0.009246205,
0.0567779839,
-0.0118130064,
-0.02960179,
0.0209040977,
-0.0340524614,
0.03244856,
0.0597838908,
0.0020170498,
0.0465864614,
-0.0280550197,
-0.0285820197,
0.0060506654,
0.0513160713,
0.0843483284,
0.0209311396,
-0.0552146994,
-0.0211392567,
-0.0562010221,
0.0125880418,
0.048226282,
0.0348875374,
0.0146129159,
-0.0108473087,
-0.0393739417,
0.0223650839,
-0.0106427642,
0.0296941157,
0.0024131988,
-0.057996437,
0.0034704886,
-0.0130313523,
0.0141033018,
-0.0201294515,
0.0218750723,
-0.0236360673,
0.0564870089,
0.0092507927,
0.0066828774,
0.0432313308,
0.0015981595,
-0.0267424472,
-0.0199481864,
-0.026782345,
0.0447143055,
0.0398948155,
0.0207402408,
0.0085057197,
-0.0088452026,
-0.0192078408,
-0.0012696534,
-0.0413182266,
-0.0291481167,
0.0546466559,
0.0166261625,
-0.010617571,
-0.0044688052,
0.0146690831,
-0.0303156432,
0.0128452545,
-0.0207661465,
0.0068509351,
-0.0286820773,
-0.0060019814,
-0.0216273498,
-0.020781206,
-0.0658178031,
0.0112469653,
-0.0257152356,
-0.0252897572,
-0.0500241555,
-0.0261602663,
-0.0167149678,
-0.003101734,
2.745e-7,
-0.0366726369,
0.0565618388,
0.0359943509,
-0.0187061708,
0.0345671847,
0.0316991583,
0.0004760426,
0.0158356559,
0.0424429812,
-0.0236951802,
0.0047745723,
0.0296303686,
0.0432893075,
0.0019916072,
-0.1111115962,
-0.0685581341,
-0.0273412392,
-0.0424992852,
-0.0170819797,
0.0025119085,
0.0628447011,
0.0292905364,
-0.0064662034,
0.0252857711,
-0.0227696039,
-0.0042334651,
0.0370833576,
-0.0094943335,
-0.0197581872,
-0.0114823338,
0.0494912788,
-0.0208749678,
0.0006003068,
0.0494459532,
0.0237276461,
0.0004424136,
-0.0046484717,
0.0261700265,
-0.0003549726,
-0.0351270661,
0.0104664043,
-0.0247208867,
0.0193851683,
-0.0060077291,
0.0174316633,
-0.0808163211,
-0.0586751178,
-0.0466011949,
-0.0026420637,
-0.0019244598,
-0.0222683549,
0.0121844271,
-0.0173949432,
0.0107214553,
-0.0182977561,
-0.00663422,
0.0589148849,
-0.0403814167,
0.0039630509,
-0.0010198709,
-0.0586084761,
-0.0840549469,
-0.0170406364,
-0.0343569666,
0.0604833588,
-0.0166344885,
0.0328171104,
1.928477231e-34,
0.0323871523,
0.0134271076,
0.0103861168,
0.0496019982,
0.0586737953,
0.0218005534,
0.0526286475,
0.0178862587,
0.081936039,
-0.0491081998,
-0.0020727166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06360v1 | CoSearchAgent: A Lightweight Collaborative Search Agent with Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T12:10:00 | 2024-02-09T12:10:00 | Peiyuan Gong, Jiamian Li, Jiaxin Mao | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Collaborative search supports multiple users working together to accomplish a
specific search task. Research has found that designing lightweight
collaborative search plugins within instant messaging platforms aligns better
with users' collaborative habits. However, due to the complexity of multi-user
interaction scenarios, it is challenging to implement a fully functioning
lightweight collaborative search system. Therefore, previous studies on
lightweight collaborative search had to rely on the Wizard of Oz paradigm. In
recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to interact
naturally with users and achieve complex information-seeking tasks through
LLM-based agents. Hence, to better support the research in collaborative
search, in this demo, we propose CoSearchAgent, a lightweight collaborative
search agent powered by LLMs. CoSearchAgent is designed as a Slack plugin that
can support collaborative search during multi-party conversations on this
platform. Equipped with the capacity to understand the queries and context in
multi-user conversations and the ability to search the Web for relevant
information via APIs, CoSearchAgent can respond to user queries with answers
grounded on the relevant search results. It can also ask clarifying questions
when the information needs are unclear. The proposed CoSearchAgent is highly
flexible and would be useful for supporting further research on collaborative
search. The code and demo video are accessible. | [
0.0525471643,
-0.0128557198,
-0.0276354067,
0.0206354223,
-0.0532505251,
-0.0289376806,
0.0139914416,
0.0390115902,
0.0595175698,
-0.0180271324,
-0.0683527589,
-0.0080743479,
-0.0443510674,
0.0097061023,
-0.0355624482,
-0.0406761058,
0.0291125644,
-0.0164986961,
0.0185052175,
-0.0048018978,
0.0280847754,
-0.0067939069,
0.0167047307,
0.0514856912,
-0.005875723,
-0.0101337237,
-0.0407191589,
0.0079728914,
-0.0563906729,
-0.0011132937,
0.0255082417,
0.055561766,
-0.0001878615,
0.0560509451,
0.0000020151,
-0.0259125549,
-0.0219858792,
-0.012005955,
0.0021908362,
-0.0075323437,
0.0186807532,
0.0673679784,
0.0142836906,
0.0315818824,
-0.0690916926,
0.0418522246,
0.0195202287,
-0.0004807865,
0.0474880487,
0.0352776572,
-0.0025658668,
0.0353143588,
-0.0416722111,
-0.0034456025,
0.0190574657,
-0.0848292261,
-0.0106475111,
-0.0210020225,
0.0752307996,
0.0347302184,
0.0373810679,
0.0362267531,
-0.0214078147,
-0.0309399627,
-0.0137819229,
0.0117534222,
-0.0572004057,
-0.0792731717,
0.0077383164,
0.0334178172,
0.0186016243,
0.0009538109,
-0.0036843847,
0.0200480167,
0.010486478,
0.082964085,
-0.0644672289,
-0.0136973076,
-0.0299821645,
-0.0223470926,
-0.0255794153,
-0.0136823263,
0.0142245563,
0.0143750915,
-0.0030358271,
0.1025814712,
0.0077738892,
-0.0203132872,
-0.0401711427,
-0.0552493483,
0.018896874,
-0.0364351608,
0.050166484,
0.0595423952,
-0.0555993132,
0.0103783039,
0.0110590113,
-0.0403104089,
0.0251351241,
-0.0710741282,
-0.0353738889,
0.0285632517,
-0.0001282614,
0.0501374975,
0.0315305591,
-0.0041490565,
0.0260960087,
-0.0146347424,
-0.0152658336,
-0.0663930252,
-0.0310929138,
-0.0164837521,
-0.061237894,
0.0562034585,
-0.0446722284,
-0.0429642797,
0.0019897958,
0.0745863244,
0.0252901018,
-0.0122511992,
-0.0005348569,
0.0261919014,
-0.0050250962,
0.0152666727,
-0.0211886466,
0.0176172499,
-0.0432935767,
-0.025554141,
0.0195292253,
-0.0324027799,
0.0440233573,
0.0039672796,
0.0230501294,
-0.0179985389,
-0.0241018254,
0.0187717527,
0.0026413333,
-0.0609262511,
0.0304448791,
-0.0279858597,
0.0304965042,
-0.0003607557,
-0.0509295054,
-0.0536148511,
0.0356340855,
0.0292189699,
-0.0149483066,
-0.0095236311,
0.0176049937,
0.0327438191,
-0.0203997828,
0.0314986184,
-0.0301979091,
0.0439349115,
0.0650983378,
0.0472410508,
-0.018794395,
0.0669613108,
0.0056479261,
0.0724465027,
0.0735522881,
0.0032327091,
0.0134334518,
0.0163448509,
-0.044281777,
-0.0205450375,
0.0413713567,
0.0335429646,
-0.0265296455,
0.0384337492,
-0.0759423152,
0.0449566729,
-0.0297267679,
0.0097697182,
0.0540817566,
0.087508902,
0.0520797521,
0.0176870674,
0.0099235652,
0.0470706597,
-0.0068579242,
-0.050760556,
-0.0076470119,
0.0475195795,
-0.0384674259,
-0.0553623959,
0.0368856788,
0.004999062,
-0.0293972399,
0.0025169679,
0.0188077651,
0.0022628787,
0.0235615913,
0.01176567,
0.044777181,
-0.0237814728,
-0.0050831432,
0.0597637966,
-0.001034642,
-0.045177117,
-0.0166252535,
-0.0314667933,
0.0515951961,
0.0934011042,
0.0731648356,
-0.007548071,
-0.0309679508,
0.0396329314,
0.012547968,
-0.0145552503,
0.0322276726,
0.0008696373,
-0.0098222522,
-0.0205623675,
-0.0381874815,
0.0334473476,
-0.0028867079,
-0.0317159221,
0.0273943208,
0.0221529696,
0.0023536943,
-0.0167946629,
0.0044122478,
-0.0112289768,
-0.006402127,
0.0306381304,
-0.0305865817,
0.0355934687,
-0.001132392,
0.0492925346,
0.0374497809,
-0.0010169371,
0.0302851256,
-0.005641757,
-0.0307817031,
0.0032362756,
0.0382260419,
0.0413648039,
0.0028331829,
-0.0229805224,
0.0365596525,
0.0504783168,
0.0217643268,
-0.0364683606,
0.0080472929,
-0.0222159307,
0.0724967346,
-0.0255131889,
0.0217021517,
-0.0411287583,
-0.0041913372,
0.0130665023,
0.0219124127,
0.0266392548,
-0.0018979696,
-0.0085543701,
0.0529679917,
-0.0165173542,
-0.0558230281,
-0.0131066907,
0.0286774766,
0.0234878324,
0.0158380009,
0.0358371176,
0.009042195,
-0.0389990881,
-0.032540299,
-0.1116724685,
0.0196001399,
-0.0270588677,
-0.0021069678,
0.0045207408,
0.1061785817,
-0.0078518502,
-0.0312230811,
-0.0278861653,
0.0689198896,
0.0110827545,
0.0435471721,
-0.0039871633,
0.0166487247,
-0.0321281031,
-0.0646108612,
-0.0045309709,
0.0082434807,
0.0047608027,
0.0277834889,
-0.0657489821,
-0.0321068764,
0.0101715419,
-0.0613490306,
0.0062449495,
0.0009627121,
-0.0301331654,
0.0371454507,
-0.0404023603,
-0.0003745662,
0.0244917218,
0.0456832312,
0.0383486375,
0.0216717422,
-0.0189632978,
-0.0768032372,
0.0146148875,
-0.033227358,
-0.0100102266,
-0.0079679554,
-0.0301368218,
0.0474915318,
0.004885246,
-0.0435848758,
0.0294601861,
-0.0357905775,
-0.0025592986,
0.024616424,
-0.0029596479,
-0.0134915765,
-0.0164435375,
-0.0218356382,
0.0272852927,
-0.0003868032,
-0.0519700497,
0.0437225476,
0.0039479388,
-0.0125438832,
-0.0500111058,
-0.0706545711,
-0.0456771068,
0.0840524882,
-0.0257430486,
0.0231492557,
-0.027868906,
-0.0266482718,
0.0007754998,
0.0329265855,
0.0323494598,
-0.0566003509,
0.0071312133,
-0.0007946719,
0.0138947954,
0.0208964832,
-0.0210390557,
0.0044788816,
-0.0681810752,
-0.0550262965,
0.016157005,
0.0150531568,
-0.0331759565,
-0.0417539552,
0.0319878161,
0.0317739621,
-0.0010220441,
-0.0040670172,
-0.0124581205,
-0.0226733405,
-0.0250475574,
0.0154446084,
0.0000994767,
-0.0285880677,
0.0084387651,
0.0462548286,
0.0662444904,
0.0204249471,
-0.0680112392,
0.0135770617,
-0.0559828021,
0.0666769594,
-0.0107460655,
-0.0575191267,
-0.0023044648,
0.0385953523,
-0.0095960423,
0.0100512793,
0.0755211413,
0.0646343753,
-0.11089921,
-0.0122625073,
-0.0803658217,
0.0021612563,
0.0174616147,
0.056759648,
-0.0418487713,
-0.0286048055,
0.0341487117,
0.0242352933,
0.0386048928,
-0.030537257,
-0.0047120103,
-0.0245287288,
-0.0085927621,
-0.0188002158,
0.009511861,
0.0276011322,
-0.0610821322,
0.0293577816,
0.0202330612,
-0.0071366727,
0.0139295366,
-0.0051913131,
-0.0113239679,
-0.0131488098,
-0.015573076,
-0.0254580304,
0.0097996928,
-0.0656043664,
0.0175738223,
0.0481373593,
0.0425453261,
0.0163372438,
0.0022125181,
0.0061791725,
0.0319156088,
0.0123329898,
-0.0391762145,
-0.0019414679,
-0.0230327658,
0.0335900374,
-0.0486499444,
-0.0066542439,
-0.0200249534,
0.0198930632,
0.0224627201,
0.0222945772,
-0.0467521586,
0.0169745721,
-0.0140380636,
-0.0001164998,
0.0091436589,
0.0502182357,
0.0218426548,
-0.0265213065,
-0.0274105296,
-0.0403395183,
-0.0058627496,
0.0290991031,
-0.0225243475,
-0.0161655117,
-0.0112487944,
0.0170973148,
-0.0498472974,
-0.032581389,
0.0369929262,
-0.0029096941,
0.0054465435,
0.0404191166,
-0.024220638,
0.0145688457,
0.0203266442,
0.0203613583,
-0.0097933114,
0.0345629975,
-0.0542137474,
-0.0099557145,
0.0366995409,
-0.0466029532,
0.0455966219,
-0.0200872775,
-0.0465636216,
-0.0371262319,
-0.0372566916,
0.0303059779,
0.0181603469,
0.0022679809,
-0.0638129264,
-0.0825357214,
-0.0103529152,
0.0418177545,
-0.0983405188,
-0.0111533059,
-0.0247991495,
0.0323373713,
0.023795044,
0.0485452116,
-0.0820720717,
-0.0404350385,
-0.0824276507,
0.0411541238,
-0.0799666196,
-0.1080899686,
0.0237336028,
0.0426425338,
-0.0094429785,
0.0265582297,
0.0065563349,
0.0053730924,
0.0283062756,
-0.0248550717,
-0.017021047,
-0.0311470423,
0.0183955133,
-0.0477193743,
-0.032530643,
0.0500929765,
0.0603795238,
-0.0035907372,
0.0212373361,
-0.01551395,
0.0619650669,
-0.0385437608,
-0.0155968787,
0.034096498,
0.0362139568,
-0.0000527288,
-0.0102633908,
-0.0032885764,
0.0241494291,
-0.048459556,
0.0392796583,
-0.0143302977,
-0.0526744053,
0.0029171063,
0.0354425162,
-0.1064215675,
-0.0945894495,
0.0495830625,
0.0196771566,
0.0439525247,
0.0215992201,
0.0111835282,
-0.0655073151,
0.0231059194,
-0.0198264346,
-0.001627272,
-0.0144877089,
-0.0270710588,
-0.0063617341,
0.0312809274,
-0.0044083986,
0.0020132256,
0.0757730305,
-0.0293610245,
-0.0046648812,
-0.0145853814,
-0.0633115694,
-0.0241051055,
0.0159380585,
0.0644835755,
0.086946249,
-0.0460631512,
-0.0234526098,
-0.0282544792,
-0.008698469,
-0.0101153003,
-0.0351873264,
-0.0137888445,
-0.0389179252,
0.0380064547,
0.0959011689,
0.023092825,
-0.0168913323,
-0.053984195,
-0.0077929981,
-0.0355300047,
0.0208743773,
-0.0220636986,
-5.900450832e-33,
0.0022582719,
-0.0680793375,
0.032630831,
0.0373328291,
0.0027711263,
-0.0094669117,
-0.0313940533,
0.0161462855,
-0.0197946895,
-0.0326396935,
-0.0333782434,
0.0445018299,
0.0110713532,
-0.0198691431,
0.0042262436,
0.0179891344,
0.0370973237,
-0.0018812071,
0.0187103879,
0.0043894169,
0.057545092,
0.0493832789,
-0.0385845564,
-0.0673307702,
0.0102485623,
-0.0229728706,
0.0067680357,
0.0535703488,
0.0300415382,
0.0289712418,
0.0094962763,
0.01711284,
0.0070763556,
0.0422875918,
0.0033154879,
0.0221928116,
-0.0242916383,
-0.0237128474,
0.0223012082,
0.0228857808,
-0.0129447589,
0.0100995125,
0.0224395841,
0.001773935,
0.0093973307,
0.0648485422,
0.0205544829,
0.0033420387,
-0.0663529038,
0.0050749434,
0.0017702874,
0.000334331,
0.0221337453,
-0.0167364031,
0.0363207161,
0.0497348718,
-0.0125956777,
-0.000356524,
-0.0134983258,
0.0484837629,
-0.0645825341,
0.024691632,
0.0253398623,
0.0379355773,
-0.0046263835,
0.0381001905,
0.0355038047,
0.0099530518,
-0.0219532214,
-0.02037194,
-0.0263414495,
0.0620359257,
0.0302397273,
0.0405122563,
-0.037816409,
-0.0219125059,
0.0239721406,
0.02937706,
0.0629989952,
0.0004147415,
0.0182527881,
0.0625817329,
-0.0292304046,
0.0072336067,
0.0021184047,
0.0485842489,
-0.0722904354,
-0.0740086064,
0.0176486969,
0.0249048695,
0.0035194326,
-0.0433016345,
-0.0030202523,
0.0056855446,
-0.0050599165,
-0.0100649642,
0.01784987,
-0.0163875315,
-0.0114963828,
0.015273191,
-0.0097287893,
0.0118922526,
-0.0200037956,
-0.0212050974,
-0.0198368262,
0.0293148793,
-0.0145087009,
0.0149644557,
-0.0120321065,
-0.0322827101,
-0.0093532531,
-0.0351945832,
-0.0198227167,
-0.0654599294,
0.0199683942,
-0.0033645541,
-0.0170092322,
0.0657556504,
0.023806978,
0.0202063806,
-0.0236825626,
-0.0938035473,
0.00397682,
-0.0120251309,
-0.0187333226,
0.0080804853,
-0.0762023255,
0.0413459241,
0.0377768576,
-0.0211723018,
-0.0217312947,
-0.0111132599,
2.785e-7,
0.0120862536,
0.0368146785,
-0.0425113924,
0.020117702,
0.0106127411,
0.0110049546,
-0.0071872855,
0.0255787913,
0.0059770038,
0.0083377147,
0.0139086405,
0.0271884352,
0.0215771738,
0.0350728482,
-0.1005085781,
-0.0341997556,
-0.0478776358,
-0.0509271733,
-0.067081511,
0.0039217458,
0.028182257,
0.043709226,
0.0320072249,
0.0368474051,
-0.0331126638,
-0.0807703435,
0.028639432,
-0.0439611338,
-0.0198065229,
0.0081356829,
0.0253172591,
-0.0151853999,
-0.0028320719,
-0.0046839761,
-0.0132039273,
-0.005723408,
0.0120326215,
0.0119138071,
-0.0183301661,
-0.0202888213,
0.0253152438,
-0.0403223075,
0.000474052,
-0.039134644,
0.0279359333,
-0.0112913782,
-0.0162335578,
0.0525741652,
0.0161611848,
-0.0346524306,
-0.0154876001,
-0.0325997323,
-0.0293115973,
-0.0005460374,
-0.0215078834,
-0.0078637544,
-0.005875343,
-0.0392982662,
0.0087365545,
-0.0456656329,
-0.0587619506,
-0.05371961,
-0.0901025534,
-0.0079618758,
-0.0109855048,
0.0115925828,
0.0331259295,
2.073969223e-34,
0.0012944019,
0.0206932127,
-0.0429913327,
0.0655316785,
0.0513226762,
0.0105544748,
-0.0402009487,
0.0335331,
0.0727783665,
-0.0575724356,
-0.0164711867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06342v1 | Promoting Target Data in Context-aware Neural Machine Translation | 2024-02-09T11:34:39 | 2024-02-09T11:34:39 | Harritxu Gete, Thierry Etchegoyhen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Standard context-aware neural machine translation (NMT) typically relies on
parallel document-level data, exploiting both source and target contexts.
Concatenation-based approaches in particular, still a strong baseline for
document-level NMT, prepend source and/or target context sentences to the
sentences to be translated, with model variants that exploit equal amounts of
source and target data on each side achieving state-of-the-art results. In this
work, we investigate whether target data should be further promoted within
standard concatenation-based approaches, as most document-level phenomena rely
on information that is present on the target language side. We evaluate novel
concatenation-based variants where the target context is prepended to the
source language, either in isolation or in combination with the source context.
Experimental results in English-Russian and Basque-Spanish show that including
target context in the source leads to large improvements on target language
phenomena. On source-dependent phenomena, using only target language context in
the source achieves parity with state-of-the-art concatenation approaches, or
slightly underperforms, whereas combining source and target context on the
source side leads to significant gains across the board. | [
0.0125304498,
0.0451583154,
0.0089021586,
0.0216439813,
-0.0290457252,
-0.00044559,
0.0407227129,
-0.0225417838,
-0.0868156254,
0.0023265632,
-0.0349089578,
-0.0004642755,
0.0326790325,
-0.0143082263,
0.0530626141,
-0.0173336975,
0.0282819886,
0.0110955583,
-0.0710940063,
0.0068461196,
-0.0155288819,
0.0230244435,
0.0354506038,
0.0223547239,
-0.0267564151,
0.0019875648,
-0.0013280673,
0.070154801,
0.0461326353,
-0.0058930973,
0.0025556528,
0.008779374,
0.0119992029,
0.0508932024,
0.0000018819,
-0.0105383182,
-0.043828845,
0.0140711041,
0.0056506642,
0.0081056375,
0.0572296828,
-0.1027131751,
-0.0346188992,
0.0185113344,
0.0064166123,
-0.0111322105,
0.0617116205,
0.0342865624,
0.0509117879,
0.0856990665,
-0.0325999893,
-0.0187442917,
0.0121572698,
-0.0948772132,
0.0014443801,
-0.0546070263,
-0.0128057906,
-0.0351962596,
-0.0432719998,
0.0198056139,
0.0210397728,
0.0737120211,
0.0632962808,
-0.01472966,
-0.0349956192,
0.0059948117,
-0.022452563,
-0.0214954186,
-0.0088706249,
0.067900829,
-0.0389860123,
0.0017250803,
-0.0136575922,
-0.0230365489,
0.0205574147,
-0.0497819781,
-0.0575348474,
0.0084494539,
0.0113765337,
0.0135300513,
0.0438211188,
0.0369590707,
0.0662391186,
0.0028949943,
-0.0349657536,
0.0321568288,
0.0309538804,
-0.0102645177,
-0.0011631515,
0.0303015597,
-0.0091250548,
-0.031897001,
0.0462704822,
-0.0143463518,
0.0202557817,
0.0162239522,
-0.0742055327,
-0.0827607363,
0.0165489484,
-0.0474990606,
0.0340728126,
0.0681708083,
-0.016717162,
0.0361360572,
-0.0147008877,
0.0319519937,
-0.0477797538,
-0.0041191196,
-0.0920642018,
-0.0363337174,
-0.006292202,
0.0282592718,
-0.039821513,
-0.0327525586,
-0.0693952292,
-0.0078723589,
-0.0246242806,
0.0603217371,
0.0077572591,
-0.0170357451,
0.0007057434,
-0.0487317331,
-0.0598640367,
-0.0008268251,
0.0580304042,
0.0448126011,
-0.0218298361,
-0.0054940996,
0.0187759083,
-0.0362097397,
-0.0411519408,
0.0148728499,
-0.0210787021,
-0.0454808809,
0.0057628243,
0.0826821476,
-0.0180650111,
-0.0334975347,
-0.0068315468,
-0.0334394909,
-0.0279592164,
-0.0387140363,
0.0312905721,
-0.0315076485,
0.0759065151,
-0.0176291671,
-0.0031988495,
-0.0339935236,
-0.0320827141,
0.0152427237,
-0.0015893091,
0.0635692999,
0.0141515397,
-0.0364590622,
0.0259928536,
-0.00016106,
0.010246858,
0.0776923895,
0.0337908268,
0.0284584463,
0.0074810605,
0.0307327136,
-0.0617861487,
0.0360006541,
0.0672359616,
0.0156570133,
-0.0334161371,
0.0176582076,
0.0274735764,
0.0291285887,
0.0544857346,
0.0308001749,
-0.0363844149,
0.0080641899,
0.0453348048,
-0.0097071305,
0.018602401,
0.0336481258,
0.053541977,
-0.0166838579,
-0.0521145985,
-0.0106928246,
-0.0524521545,
0.0247828364,
-0.0085927276,
0.018861467,
0.0371275283,
0.0580085181,
-0.0118540889,
-0.0391424485,
0.003527448,
-0.0150010744,
0.0079563493,
-0.0139184743,
0.005225834,
0.0286022555,
-0.0297310259,
0.0250607152,
-0.006157239,
-0.0465730354,
0.0213539712,
-0.0001814095,
-0.0511911102,
0.0328654386,
0.024935862,
0.009098527,
-0.0792569518,
0.0091146249,
0.0150128417,
0.0419447869,
0.0547875203,
0.0131906997,
0.0679930151,
-0.0407840684,
-0.0199191514,
-0.0576799586,
-0.0145789767,
0.0336759388,
0.0054393574,
0.0185043439,
0.0660751611,
0.0045187986,
0.0006028143,
0.0335776098,
-0.0017709436,
-0.0179913174,
0.0415275171,
0.0078458097,
0.0219697952,
0.0248413924,
0.031336911,
0.0096643521,
0.0214153565,
-0.0292156171,
-0.0317776799,
0.0406159163,
-0.052867718,
-0.0761936828,
0.0136281382,
0.0032246229,
-0.0213968046,
-0.0122136194,
-0.0371433124,
-0.0534711555,
-0.0240387563,
-0.0083194645,
0.0178407505,
-0.0333232097,
0.0343185663,
0.048687961,
0.0256603099,
-0.0213028546,
0.0223188661,
-0.0231785104,
-0.0301010963,
0.0554670505,
0.0057165045,
0.0251393355,
-0.009612415,
-0.0138355978,
0.0271992683,
0.0386059768,
0.0103373593,
0.0254505556,
0.0213032607,
-0.0035961904,
-0.0178569034,
-0.0484643541,
0.0330899693,
-0.0337982439,
0.0485929847,
0.0405567102,
0.0680829585,
0.0011962554,
-0.0191054903,
-0.0344327092,
0.0134806084,
0.0035896974,
0.0418946147,
0.0226916801,
0.0428547636,
0.0153458333,
-0.0272844546,
-0.031223936,
0.0266094785,
0.0282749329,
0.0094192894,
-0.0033637385,
-0.0830854997,
0.0098072942,
-0.022800114,
0.0231397953,
-0.0263075344,
-0.0135590024,
-0.0091964398,
-0.035791263,
0.0342360549,
0.0322512127,
-0.046993304,
-0.0119844852,
0.0317048505,
-0.0015997372,
-0.0254384521,
0.0299984198,
-0.0219870154,
-0.02433406,
-0.017802611,
-0.0325553827,
0.0305207819,
0.0516728163,
-0.0312286299,
-0.0207247455,
-0.0557336286,
-0.0048423461,
0.0099967085,
-0.0453307442,
-0.0299168993,
-0.0000355545,
0.0333151445,
0.0041419617,
-0.0409310684,
-0.0356973447,
0.0727109015,
-0.0453579016,
-0.0114052417,
-0.0503007881,
-0.0129403574,
-0.0518030673,
0.0307847857,
-0.0272438731,
0.0021633585,
-0.052805867,
-0.0309446566,
-0.0425278209,
0.0168285929,
-0.0195002332,
0.0284457132,
0.0371078588,
-0.0610730387,
-0.0166888405,
-0.0281497352,
-0.0157265719,
-0.0107883932,
-0.0424282439,
0.0141250277,
0.0074456898,
0.0279623698,
-0.0218069181,
-0.0206513368,
-0.0065900357,
-0.00351976,
0.0825002789,
-0.0374536775,
0.0047022961,
-0.0196404178,
-0.0023148376,
-0.0056431335,
0.0026517017,
-0.001874237,
-0.0308094472,
-0.0189689621,
0.0388630964,
0.0314241052,
-0.0134244822,
-0.0208899323,
-0.0163786653,
0.0412239358,
0.0189968683,
-0.0493444093,
-0.0228981618,
0.012460744,
-0.0810824558,
-0.007039038,
0.0821039379,
0.0237329695,
-0.0375036187,
-0.0154893762,
-0.0154510597,
0.041155681,
0.001557386,
0.0368549451,
-0.0593236014,
-0.0226259716,
0.0194052197,
0.022804698,
0.0499432273,
0.0462086648,
-0.0501806289,
-0.0797611773,
-0.0073134946,
0.0445301197,
-0.0858652592,
-0.0250365511,
-0.0012726331,
-0.0086127799,
-0.0197451413,
0.0527901538,
0.010726749,
0.0172001701,
-0.0261708442,
-0.0253755357,
0.0570965186,
-0.0692338124,
-0.044560194,
-0.0386528447,
0.0084383348,
0.089500092,
-0.0023679999,
0.0177001394,
0.008246162,
0.05449339,
-0.0380731747,
0.0238934234,
-0.0105672656,
0.0094461041,
-0.0153057855,
0.0076265326,
0.0429872125,
0.0084756482,
-0.0205088109,
0.0191660412,
0.0099810809,
0.0262668934,
-0.0115902191,
0.0321951918,
-0.0199124031,
-0.0178766605,
0.0231697708,
0.0526915304,
0.0164587479,
-0.026688315,
-0.002070803,
0.0029975092,
-0.0158060342,
-0.0596995726,
0.0553421378,
-0.0008299238,
-0.040099673,
-0.0869086832,
-0.0912690684,
-0.098683387,
0.0079681911,
0.0407682471,
0.004269361,
0.0153782051,
-0.0357996747,
-0.0507539958,
-0.022408314,
0.056036029,
-0.0075625321,
0.0219251029,
-0.0335132964,
0.0328273028,
0.0217713304,
-0.0457446054,
0.0239002872,
0.0561916977,
-0.1260720193,
-0.0718182996,
-0.0307720751,
0.0205763113,
0.0139744757,
0.0790812671,
-0.027128581,
-0.0237793643,
-0.0120696826,
0.0071471073,
-0.023832377,
0.0251793712,
0.0395228565,
-0.0073089465,
-0.0011678175,
0.0401525535,
-0.0384668931,
0.0159445312,
0.0086094681,
0.0263618045,
-0.009198457,
-0.0140059367,
0.0221440047,
-0.0390713476,
0.0438270345,
-0.0242894907,
-0.0159929972,
-0.0181202609,
0.0616847388,
-0.0554408245,
-0.0079407729,
-0.04164261,
-0.0304516871,
0.0194911193,
0.0161490496,
0.0187836476,
-0.0065624765,
0.0061395839,
0.0101115853,
-0.057242725,
-0.0390265808,
-0.0290640742,
0.0498886332,
-0.0017794202,
0.0462519005,
0.0055648768,
0.0183826685,
-0.0061552436,
0.0050412468,
-0.0808334276,
0.0207913518,
0.0247320589,
-0.0029846213,
-0.0125762792,
0.062667869,
-0.0686675161,
0.0399925523,
-0.004449347,
-0.0160460752,
0.054180678,
0.0095509682,
0.1153413504,
-0.0106915226,
-0.0139360921,
0.0121990545,
0.0428710952,
0.0095101818,
-0.0493514128,
0.011025588,
-0.0204493217,
0.0234047379,
0.0058217645,
0.0523314178,
-0.0008015962,
0.0023815415,
-0.0224945731,
0.011339115,
0.0004108658,
-0.0021764771,
-0.0046450342,
0.0110359313,
-0.021245569,
-0.0317566395,
-0.0205880012,
-0.0471914969,
0.0363338217,
0.0135117499,
-0.0393431336,
0.003052118,
0.0308387391,
0.0876953378,
-0.0355991684,
-0.0301231388,
-0.008520728,
0.0200370532,
0.0031908273,
-0.0266550835,
-0.044962965,
-6.002766962e-33,
-0.0460732803,
0.0345599614,
0.0295291245,
-0.0315704346,
-0.057671763,
0.0086746318,
-0.0430898964,
-0.0560422093,
0.0187545232,
-0.0077537168,
-0.0130436877,
0.03356665,
0.0277892109,
0.0213737488,
-0.0237268731,
-0.0189093351,
0.0772186294,
0.0395620726,
-0.0171254463,
0.0138689904,
0.0258288402,
0.0062784008,
0.0740593597,
-0.0796727091,
0.0571518354,
-0.015967777,
-0.0017254996,
-0.0158976912,
0.0016314697,
0.0148274014,
0.0399343893,
-0.0076083243,
0.015717674,
-0.0361309722,
-0.0405662805,
0.0030583271,
-0.0899199322,
-0.0104282089,
0.0396908559,
0.0336954109,
-0.0452732556,
-0.0757773817,
0.0735174417,
-0.0433980562,
0.0330736935,
-0.0127087729,
-0.0247894861,
-0.0412030928,
-0.0415765084,
-0.0065443683,
-0.0414826423,
-0.0024765285,
0.0137603851,
0.0265750606,
0.0144941071,
0.075570479,
0.019516632,
-0.0207046457,
-0.077542901,
0.0294681154,
-0.0253750365,
0.0437373295,
0.089553766,
0.0207115207,
0.0045209765,
-0.0065395534,
0.0371630006,
0.0032367297,
0.0340335853,
-0.0001760187,
0.0160603579,
-0.0165555626,
0.0613455065,
0.0481950529,
0.0333714187,
-0.0116946222,
-0.0687232614,
0.0355595164,
0.0034021651,
-0.0430044755,
0.0015458795,
0.0243587848,
-0.0351727046,
-0.0338730104,
-0.0172835588,
-0.0262142494,
-0.0277354307,
-0.0218479391,
0.0060685547,
0.0241372306,
0.0005162994,
0.0352387689,
0.0625365973,
0.0246722586,
0.0467843115,
0.0544454344,
-0.0211742204,
0.0271587353,
-0.0268110707,
0.0272205975,
-0.012874959,
-0.0121932188,
0.0381744355,
-0.0031996565,
0.0137106339,
0.0011513755,
0.0619287007,
0.0520839654,
-0.024256207,
-0.0188261457,
-0.049481146,
0.033241719,
-0.02082159,
-0.0076025319,
0.0301371906,
0.0147616006,
-0.0027739252,
0.0527850427,
0.066579178,
-0.0117324488,
-0.0132482005,
-0.0085609574,
0.0363982916,
0.018438613,
-0.0320109092,
0.0189923495,
0.0207582619,
-0.0034581455,
0.0762514994,
-0.0547211692,
-0.0346134566,
0.0134303505,
2.568e-7,
0.0596009195,
-0.0093458435,
0.0190651249,
0.0236232709,
0.0039135478,
-0.0083732624,
-0.0164070632,
0.0144700902,
0.0104101477,
0.0702701211,
0.032041803,
-0.014013689,
0.0587269217,
0.0219418686,
-0.0797105655,
-0.0246169325,
-0.0222837441,
0.0330038518,
-0.0469652228,
0.0044265846,
0.0245178454,
0.0876112059,
-0.0020341016,
-0.0069463807,
-0.0355270989,
-0.0360618159,
0.0573844425,
-0.0355635658,
-0.0278728735,
-0.0091699483,
-0.0009811462,
0.0154948048,
-0.0430288315,
-0.0167854931,
-0.043733526,
0.0352383852,
0.0288470667,
0.0799202472,
0.0077351434,
-0.021485718,
0.0182009749,
-0.0293676816,
-0.0210300572,
0.0056352746,
0.0653196722,
-0.0463257469,
-0.0099548027,
-0.0080811698,
-0.0045353421,
0.0184266753,
0.0063127275,
-0.0280707553,
-0.0529382303,
0.000031247,
0.0549892709,
-0.0224952046,
-0.0295713488,
-0.0693420246,
-0.0785978958,
-0.0246207863,
-0.0185436159,
-0.0156730842,
-0.0397120528,
-0.0057916925,
0.020739207,
-0.0130377058,
-0.0260883123,
2.805332192e-34,
0.0259765815,
-0.0240225326,
0.0011916533,
-0.0183050223,
0.0196693428,
-0.0123006618,
-0.0060938015,
0.0293618292,
0.0149502102,
-0.0385814123,
-0.0429681502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06341v1 | RareBench: Can LLMs Serve as Rare Diseases Specialists? | 2024-02-09T11:34:16 | 2024-02-09T11:34:16 | Xuanzhong Chen, Xiaohao Mao, Qihan Guo, Lun Wang, Shuyang Zhang, Ting Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generalist Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, have shown
considerable promise in various domains, including medical diagnosis. Rare
diseases, affecting approximately 300 million people worldwide, often have
unsatisfactory clinical diagnosis rates primarily due to a lack of experienced
physicians and the complexity of differentiating among many rare diseases. In
this context, recent news such as "ChatGPT correctly diagnosed a 4-year-old's
rare disease after 17 doctors failed" underscore LLMs' potential, yet
underexplored, role in clinically diagnosing rare diseases. To bridge this
research gap, we introduce RareBench, a pioneering benchmark designed to
systematically evaluate the capabilities of LLMs on 4 critical dimensions
within the realm of rare diseases. Meanwhile, we have compiled the largest
open-source dataset on rare disease patients, establishing a benchmark for
future studies in this domain. To facilitate differential diagnosis of rare
diseases, we develop a dynamic few-shot prompt methodology, leveraging a
comprehensive rare disease knowledge graph synthesized from multiple knowledge
bases, significantly enhancing LLMs' diagnostic performance. Moreover, we
present an exhaustive comparative study of GPT-4's diagnostic capabilities
against those of specialist physicians. Our experimental findings underscore
the promising potential of integrating LLMs into the clinical diagnostic
process for rare diseases. This paves the way for exciting possibilities in
future advancements in this field. | [
0.0191961415,
0.0230663661,
0.0030733389,
0.011847551,
0.0122047979,
0.0065733218,
0.0027185364,
0.0509056896,
0.0071839895,
-0.0074318135,
0.040330831,
-0.0545050539,
-0.0121941511,
0.0351620354,
-0.0170619544,
-0.033322487,
0.0413706638,
-0.0152949262,
0.040364217,
-0.0052618012,
0.0009244803,
0.0209219959,
-0.0023273348,
0.0074428129,
0.0093167061,
-0.028180873,
0.0579053164,
-0.030618377,
0.0293153338,
-0.0724176392,
-0.0291781947,
0.0314674005,
-0.025306806,
0.0386010259,
0.0000021184,
-0.0404035822,
-0.0044228234,
0.0227398276,
-0.0245157853,
0.0016354122,
0.0008639984,
-0.0400831141,
0.0166339483,
-0.0007550172,
-0.0307931881,
-0.0852180123,
0.0413115248,
0.0180595387,
0.0080502704,
0.0529140979,
0.0041214316,
0.0109397024,
0.0666258931,
-0.051882796,
0.0629238188,
-0.0882843956,
0.0422050245,
-0.0028468294,
0.0573755018,
-0.0267726369,
0.0053568888,
0.0356185697,
-0.0334425755,
0.0212737322,
-0.02307312,
0.0347617529,
-0.0199418087,
-0.0430362634,
-0.0011164601,
0.0723496005,
-0.0053608194,
-0.0085374303,
0.0303984322,
-0.0093824659,
0.0076955478,
0.0350364596,
0.0031907938,
-0.000392739,
-0.0412876718,
0.0080208033,
0.0144657427,
-0.0075457329,
0.0493217483,
-0.0155362766,
-0.024692731,
0.0230295546,
-0.0085610012,
0.0014711033,
-0.0274636541,
-0.0188857727,
-0.0332199521,
-0.0368822552,
0.0073204804,
0.0187376477,
-0.0713190362,
-0.0131969964,
-0.013669814,
-0.0165599491,
0.1023782939,
-0.0047919531,
0.028043732,
-0.0132177817,
0.0006496402,
0.0446856804,
-0.0052443598,
-0.0127447946,
-0.0460467599,
0.0233359393,
-0.0009840269,
-0.0063954932,
-0.0686313286,
-0.0028000586,
0.0068994481,
-0.0053330874,
0.0217826758,
-0.0126041276,
-0.0774445608,
-0.0108019542,
-0.0178312175,
0.0120793721,
0.0361633748,
0.0361207128,
-0.0033906926,
0.0127835954,
-0.0353151038,
0.0352944061,
0.0148812821,
-0.0022518137,
-0.006496219,
-0.0488444194,
0.0350074023,
-0.0193735547,
0.0025307995,
-0.0076125534,
0.0552832298,
0.0821126252,
0.0350334495,
-0.0265295561,
0.0460301563,
-0.0259426683,
-0.0569918752,
-0.0341798589,
-0.0446106195,
-0.0685455874,
0.0205649361,
0.0741236135,
0.018193217,
-0.0476755612,
-0.0023384378,
-0.0286915414,
-0.0551856235,
0.0297452472,
-0.0860131159,
-0.0112733291,
0.0072315075,
0.0225719754,
-0.0157653764,
0.0235823169,
-0.0092804274,
-0.0588664263,
0.0201981645,
-0.0096206125,
0.0529609323,
0.021278305,
0.0241245478,
-0.0086074984,
-0.0041504134,
0.0171603654,
-0.0047227466,
0.0503560714,
-0.0074786278,
0.030245224,
0.025251843,
-0.0169878285,
0.0559567697,
0.069553934,
0.0293626599,
0.0026687351,
-0.0004380475,
0.0015668428,
-0.0259162281,
-0.0445564203,
0.0532547496,
-0.001823111,
-0.0311835501,
0.0085767023,
0.0032318316,
0.0306862388,
-0.012450058,
-0.0002921852,
-0.0695868731,
0.0148493629,
-0.0155289099,
0.0135120573,
0.0309126563,
-0.0595362075,
0.0036497393,
0.0676126555,
0.0349523053,
0.0071683549,
-0.0291416645,
-0.0611011535,
-0.0241335072,
0.0621651523,
0.0113239503,
-0.0449788794,
-0.0391407087,
0.0179949533,
-0.0425982326,
0.0089235865,
0.0164380912,
0.0026425873,
-0.0045991344,
-0.002788156,
0.0276439041,
0.0260341614,
0.0413496867,
-0.0190763362,
0.0048896149,
0.0450875908,
-0.0430456661,
-0.0675088987,
0.0117914472,
-0.0048751533,
-0.0736930296,
-0.0039913426,
0.0101215448,
-0.0090724258,
0.0002700721,
0.0196798742,
-0.0120788421,
0.0250727069,
-0.0275458544,
-0.0125576826,
-0.0420133099,
-0.0144159952,
-0.0012179386,
-0.028154321,
0.0317390338,
-0.016913807,
-0.0624505654,
-0.0103667649,
-0.0395374931,
-0.0241439473,
-0.004279261,
-0.0428178869,
0.0483742505,
0.0034987335,
-0.0056224135,
0.0179530308,
-0.0026568521,
0.0198356938,
0.0428024307,
-0.0221187752,
-0.0076287114,
0.0018555784,
-0.065607436,
0.0316527411,
-0.0695359409,
-0.0406965911,
-0.0205673948,
0.0151463849,
0.0435518548,
-0.0238664746,
-0.0293421075,
-0.0173923299,
0.0145413699,
-0.0814354941,
0.0048389263,
0.0382392891,
0.0123810144,
0.0269899517,
0.0381760262,
-0.003554333,
-0.0049971831,
-0.0463372953,
0.0170243196,
0.0551498756,
0.029554436,
0.0572543144,
0.0565464534,
-0.0450349376,
-0.0335738994,
-0.0143589471,
-0.0537302233,
0.0164501984,
0.0250809602,
-0.0041988739,
0.0363573655,
0.0081817154,
-0.0759680942,
0.0285494495,
0.0242588334,
-0.0061575393,
0.0131516987,
-0.0528940633,
-0.0567223355,
0.0307642724,
-0.0274375882,
0.0212910343,
0.0426950306,
0.0071144635,
-0.0045429575,
-0.0011725039,
-0.0416410603,
-0.0276339799,
0.0099202013,
-0.0124954972,
-0.0295448992,
0.068655014,
0.0292813219,
-0.0070955483,
-0.0320814922,
0.0190569721,
-0.0093700457,
0.018686993,
-0.0599767342,
0.0238007642,
-0.0144529836,
0.0525706783,
-0.0217221919,
-0.0356218927,
0.0907988027,
-0.0171429329,
0.0521099642,
-0.0332571417,
-0.037659768,
-0.0257731192,
0.0082689915,
-0.0246199574,
0.0327895097,
-0.0251788702,
-0.017301742,
0.0368270352,
-0.0091646882,
0.0232311599,
-0.0652190596,
0.0652070567,
-0.0251564495,
0.0408405401,
0.0249076243,
-0.0433353744,
-0.0077160932,
0.002626173,
-0.0493381284,
0.0017755961,
0.0156480353,
-0.0325534679,
-0.0530438051,
0.0508008637,
-0.0037814737,
0.0931195915,
0.0411065258,
-0.0215341318,
0.0126296049,
-0.0112559637,
0.0021962135,
-0.0329981409,
0.0106239282,
-0.0421138257,
0.0321774967,
0.046615351,
-0.0265170764,
0.0215569884,
0.0085443659,
0.0276517682,
-0.00227694,
-0.0188021455,
-0.0159651283,
0.0462050848,
-0.0060361167,
-0.0288603753,
-0.0140003031,
0.0903837457,
0.0063721319,
-0.0937351137,
0.0056224889,
-0.0130243059,
-0.0311873462,
-0.0175950006,
0.0236943848,
-0.1329310387,
-0.0516313612,
-0.0115180537,
0.0097848438,
-0.0067888587,
-0.0802972987,
0.0121632926,
-0.0337369628,
0.0163282175,
0.0134578636,
-0.0349403061,
-0.0341905579,
-0.0260291509,
0.0025844064,
0.0002539783,
0.0093307532,
-0.0335873626,
0.0128627066,
0.0074672392,
-0.0180042088,
-0.0722519085,
-0.0982596949,
0.0791958272,
-0.0086604627,
0.0261064842,
0.0482915267,
-0.0190961473,
-0.0130422032,
0.0092366356,
-0.0166848749,
0.0734935626,
0.0230381358,
-0.018071549,
0.0768053606,
0.0166936629,
-0.0324886031,
-0.0953809097,
-0.0088209426,
-0.0632849485,
0.0163138732,
-0.0118949329,
0.1141359061,
-0.0034558233,
-0.062616244,
-0.0329055451,
-0.0269628447,
0.0356840864,
0.058092095,
-0.0035816629,
0.0077248174,
-0.0144020496,
0.0133951055,
0.0426075235,
0.0423237421,
-0.0480144843,
0.0682065934,
-0.0134006236,
-0.0504245982,
-0.0223928578,
0.0211708546,
0.0495805778,
-0.0107284551,
0.0212097429,
0.0616351329,
0.0199380741,
0.0142961415,
-0.0360610671,
0.0602412894,
0.0450334325,
0.0251628105,
-0.1039972231,
-0.0456847213,
0.0597510971,
0.0252257567,
0.0038148158,
0.0170884617,
-0.0264979377,
-0.0307514817,
-0.0230892729,
-0.0498040989,
0.0326019488,
-0.0238048881,
-0.0079993932,
-0.0334460512,
0.0622905232,
0.0563023761,
-0.0213123765,
0.0151717328,
-0.0120729012,
-0.0584641472,
0.0053629647,
0.0133259911,
-0.0231610127,
0.0166262425,
-0.0087588644,
0.014186196,
-0.0438373014,
-0.0180626623,
0.0189964995,
0.0366592146,
0.069897525,
-0.0260594543,
-0.0574530102,
-0.0211940184,
-0.0067201597,
-0.01035628,
0.0171788745,
-0.0279325191,
-0.0196651872,
0.020979559,
-0.0192993954,
-0.0304471198,
-0.0053860876,
-0.018903207,
-0.0108353216,
-0.105912976,
0.0720181018,
0.0436526611,
-0.0509889163,
0.1094204113,
-0.0514204167,
0.0275867321,
0.0291421637,
-0.023482658,
0.0125772711,
-0.0071742553,
0.0699049234,
0.0103776185,
0.0264307484,
0.0075625409,
0.0032490822,
-0.0010646729,
-0.0597498119,
-0.0036057178,
0.0207333993,
0.0581961609,
0.0182154607,
0.0334924571,
-0.0090201078,
-0.007034644,
-0.03027899,
-0.005457757,
-0.0532080196,
0.0122970361,
0.0384533592,
0.0228544772,
-0.0256612804,
-0.0027470605,
0.0629766732,
0.0096630482,
0.0382908359,
-0.0014834312,
-0.0458361395,
-0.0372216739,
-0.0063560652,
0.05681796,
-0.0107038831,
-0.042420309,
0.0155264009,
-0.0827655941,
-0.0779063478,
0.0054905573,
0.0103926249,
-0.0454119444,
0.0305105224,
-0.0051341127,
0.0392082892,
0.0379485264,
-0.0414744169,
-0.0186927244,
0.0516232178,
-0.0493925996,
-0.0195846856,
0.03704926,
-6.393347736e-33,
0.0129676489,
-0.0274612065,
0.0154585447,
-0.0475736894,
0.0442851037,
0.0646358654,
-0.0131182643,
0.0211393405,
0.0005021445,
0.0642486364,
-0.0267822444,
0.0027733869,
-0.0081857983,
0.0166319981,
0.0126276398,
-0.0127210701,
0.0239688922,
0.0165645443,
-0.0214712415,
0.0168090276,
0.021246599,
0.0324338973,
0.0144250588,
-0.0600195676,
-0.0221361481,
0.0068449415,
0.0230651051,
0.0427724607,
-0.0284415428,
0.0537178554,
-0.0045749079,
0.0451861061,
0.033206623,
-0.0086534452,
-0.0210285056,
-0.0154621499,
-0.0410556532,
-0.002470552,
-0.0027504759,
-0.0256106276,
0.0286046937,
0.0074872957,
0.0272268914,
-0.0136142159,
0.005483537,
-0.0178660676,
0.0153618446,
-0.0414035879,
-0.0261992477,
-0.0235656891,
0.022072887,
0.0520616733,
0.016250236,
0.0322917216,
-0.0061447341,
-0.0605098344,
-0.0177876111,
-0.0004428484,
-0.0249628853,
0.0329488814,
0.0499673225,
0.0226976909,
0.024315659,
-0.0136194518,
-0.0340702422,
0.0756695718,
0.0475525521,
-0.0463540331,
-0.0050219647,
0.0427402183,
-0.0456224047,
0.0496790484,
0.0267466307,
0.0150927175,
0.0091113662,
-0.0025118524,
-0.0722772107,
0.0198814329,
-0.041705247,
0.0044160159,
0.0374542959,
-0.0045571951,
-0.0521594286,
-0.0038392567,
-0.0205874518,
0.0609119833,
-0.0463992469,
-0.0217797067,
0.028363442,
-0.0269817766,
-0.0046611847,
0.0240356345,
0.0254123583,
-0.0211188234,
-0.075456582,
0.0243569519,
0.0443955138,
0.0134148821,
-0.0396325104,
0.0313076675,
-0.0066269408,
-0.0426022373,
0.0042196047,
-0.0188087225,
0.034004055,
0.0262278635,
-0.0062322533,
-0.0291038193,
-0.0548707508,
0.0031499215,
0.0122162635,
0.0082126381,
-0.0182571113,
0.0467173941,
0.0238031708,
-0.0033061977,
0.0058913273,
0.0638860017,
0.0349796005,
0.0032819386,
-0.0279190075,
0.0121835824,
-0.0375340879,
-0.0197729617,
-0.043673072,
-0.0063952338,
-0.044183962,
0.0206192099,
0.0517364889,
-0.0210940186,
-0.0114743756,
-0.0081084119,
2.892e-7,
0.0959557146,
0.0590231791,
-0.0118973386,
-0.0064310944,
0.0274391659,
0.0209414028,
-0.0116850119,
0.0066903695,
-0.0045157913,
-0.0168552864,
0.0121399416,
0.0456345044,
-0.0010269934,
0.0438652895,
-0.0365963951,
-0.0207856726,
-0.0955345705,
0.0353761911,
-0.0138406083,
0.0107740229,
0.0220623389,
0.0747798905,
-0.0041349535,
-0.0423155092,
0.0767860338,
-0.0469517261,
0.0171694588,
-0.0410968289,
0.0075654485,
0.030972885,
0.0375263952,
-0.001518066,
0.0408360101,
0.0712687522,
-0.0066751959,
-0.0130558042,
-0.0599190332,
0.0641900897,
-0.0541888028,
0.0098616565,
0.029043572,
-0.0288133118,
0.0365121029,
-0.029255949,
0.0366608873,
-0.0571649894,
-0.030211864,
-0.001524564,
0.0089615248,
-0.0662147254,
0.025249131,
-0.0321676396,
-0.0215612929,
0.0151164727,
0.0014494681,
0.0284817219,
-0.0282818992,
-0.0529351272,
-0.0087014921,
0.0215158798,
-0.0510986894,
-0.0615434013,
0.0227346662,
-0.0053383526,
-0.0172839276,
-0.0493002683,
0.0352611281,
2.681802659e-34,
0.0236956012,
0.0520354323,
0.0002077295,
-0.0292850342,
0.0341754854,
-0.0216106717,
0.012242401,
-0.0003121971,
-0.0182508845,
-0.0877312124,
-0.0116283884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06334v1 | ExaRanker-Open: Synthetic Explanation for IR using Open-Source LLMs | 2024-02-09T11:23:14 | 2024-02-09T11:23:14 | Fernando Ferraretto, Thiago Laitz, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | ExaRanker recently introduced an approach to training information retrieval
(IR) models, incorporating natural language explanations as additional labels.
The method addresses the challenge of limited labeled examples, leading to
improvements in the effectiveness of IR models. However, the initial results
were based on proprietary language models such as GPT-3.5, which posed
constraints on dataset size due to its cost and data privacy. In this paper, we
introduce ExaRanker-Open, where we adapt and explore the use of open-source
language models to generate explanations. The method has been tested using
different LLMs and datasets sizes to better comprehend the effective
contribution of data augmentation. Our findings reveal that incorporating
explanations consistently enhances neural rankers, with benefits escalating as
the LLM size increases. Notably, the data augmentation method proves
advantageous even with large datasets, as evidenced by ExaRanker surpassing the
target baseline by 0.6 nDCG@10 points in our study. To encourage further
advancements by the research community, we have open-sourced both the code and
datasets at https://github.com/unicamp-dl/ExaRanker. | [
0.0447580293,
0.0308568813,
0.0062047895,
0.0588105544,
0.0114409411,
0.0149947153,
-0.0101336529,
0.0003643451,
0.0274163168,
-0.0239351206,
-0.0149849271,
0.0111712068,
-0.0393358395,
0.0013392915,
0.0239938255,
-0.0052401428,
0.0430117585,
-0.0072699334,
0.0084180506,
0.0292284694,
-0.005501634,
0.0206751209,
0.024344597,
0.0307285376,
0.0665725991,
0.0109823374,
-0.0358074233,
0.0207506884,
0.0192957167,
0.0008536587,
0.006086485,
-0.0022913616,
0.0742465705,
0.0367969051,
0.0000020261,
-0.0352949128,
-0.0358158015,
0.0085436963,
-0.0609547123,
0.0236337502,
-0.0165864117,
-0.0285277385,
0.0508300513,
0.006307276,
-0.0118029155,
-0.010978939,
0.0054494771,
0.0510040671,
0.0512294099,
0.0854800418,
0.0211448539,
-0.0420753956,
0.0249706041,
-0.0319293365,
0.0809194967,
0.0008504323,
-0.0004783311,
-0.0081102513,
-0.0010818501,
0.0685286522,
0.0068830079,
0.0254944731,
0.0356225148,
-0.0329278372,
0.0718198195,
0.0291807596,
-0.030986039,
-0.0129805235,
0.0012790702,
0.084140867,
0.021488335,
-0.0182710979,
-0.0242665876,
-0.0017768258,
0.0390659571,
0.004276963,
-0.061978668,
-0.004782977,
-0.0143363411,
0.02318055,
0.0096897529,
-0.0089350855,
0.0502805784,
0.0416687354,
-0.0033109107,
0.0906998068,
-0.0131984884,
-0.0234940257,
-0.0033045907,
-0.0311625078,
-0.0051572542,
0.0023595616,
0.0017422148,
0.0662179962,
0.0236815233,
0.0004264555,
0.033624433,
-0.0261575133,
0.0192705188,
-0.0543855205,
-0.0028286173,
0.049919378,
-0.0516773164,
0.0546102375,
-0.0218950585,
0.0658189356,
0.0016002792,
0.069718875,
-0.041648306,
-0.0207808875,
-0.0257706437,
-0.0388785601,
-0.0291192234,
0.0203164313,
-0.0645169541,
0.0045609609,
-0.0086442912,
0.0185244195,
0.0195938852,
-0.0168572385,
0.0302058104,
0.0313422307,
-0.0400417037,
0.0051951231,
-0.0766909122,
0.0002278814,
-0.0369504876,
-0.0184618589,
0.0176684745,
-0.0557843,
-0.0492507629,
0.0199975222,
-0.0025428247,
-0.0420183726,
0.0301201586,
0.0521804355,
0.0057929936,
-0.0485211983,
-0.0217085704,
-0.0230456106,
0.0178607218,
-0.0508450828,
-0.0176530331,
-0.0327958092,
0.0177384783,
-0.0038745245,
-0.0192718524,
-0.0358668491,
0.0149530917,
0.0316107161,
-0.0691874102,
0.0693025962,
-0.0819213316,
0.0045629619,
0.0166579522,
0.0205672625,
0.0132023608,
0.0280919932,
0.0036170569,
0.0061457101,
0.0586154871,
-0.0329717249,
0.0406178981,
-0.0351858884,
0.0131923407,
-0.0264938567,
-0.005580863,
0.0483677015,
-0.0297179352,
0.0313039906,
0.0308829434,
0.0057588387,
-0.0322631896,
-0.0394473821,
0.00699508,
0.0228323508,
0.0508430339,
-0.0016890063,
0.018832691,
0.0149930017,
0.0127616264,
0.0075318068,
-0.0403692983,
0.0667447969,
-0.0121969739,
0.0121901287,
0.0572856851,
-0.0029335425,
-0.0393828265,
-0.0997368321,
-0.0019128015,
0.0152525706,
-0.0145328166,
0.0234850943,
0.0655981302,
0.0132487817,
-0.0267754123,
0.0414678119,
0.0390671492,
-0.0318867043,
-0.002054719,
-0.0680446923,
0.0422670022,
0.1106070578,
0.0682281777,
-0.0782183334,
-0.0028983476,
-0.0333253145,
-0.0152066387,
0.0136745311,
0.0049451883,
0.0007355555,
0.0511036962,
-0.0609511659,
-0.0293585099,
-0.0563893989,
0.0229240078,
0.0131243169,
0.0198079664,
-0.0435035191,
0.0502379313,
-0.0917074755,
-0.0447115898,
0.0418971293,
-0.0086477054,
-0.0665582791,
0.0159593206,
-0.0379415676,
-0.0237318855,
0.0304785594,
0.0115307458,
0.0166553743,
0.0442123562,
-0.0006603327,
-0.0155275324,
-0.0205000713,
0.0228008274,
-0.0542538725,
0.0285118818,
-0.0242873859,
0.0091655925,
0.0352676213,
-0.0592180975,
-0.0462915041,
0.0132317422,
0.0016494931,
0.0430705324,
-0.0922801495,
-0.0232710093,
0.0043661273,
0.0081229601,
-0.054644566,
0.0634959266,
0.0123398937,
0.0326173902,
0.0223651677,
-0.0051032868,
0.0074068531,
-0.0390768237,
0.0305978209,
0.0039474238,
-0.0355271883,
-0.007852409,
-0.0140067646,
0.0027677165,
-0.0410852954,
0.0135109816,
-0.0613160767,
0.0109565593,
-0.0391271599,
-0.0207623392,
0.0117184715,
0.0263976846,
0.0135852378,
-0.0158135835,
-0.0063500516,
-0.0316489264,
0.0161208212,
0.008088788,
0.0451191664,
0.0235829744,
-0.0342314839,
-0.0577163212,
-0.0309881289,
-0.0033546966,
0.0506598763,
0.0208201744,
-0.0263632927,
-0.046601329,
-0.0122962371,
-0.0421224311,
-0.0066358573,
-0.0818390176,
-0.0297983587,
-0.0002099194,
-0.0534831956,
-0.0416763872,
0.027652245,
0.0190565698,
0.0287122354,
0.0270678606,
0.02198641,
-0.0889799222,
0.0177684408,
-0.026138911,
-0.0161667001,
-0.0062835524,
-0.0185208693,
0.0096735815,
0.0310435537,
-0.0100305229,
-0.0127337864,
-0.0379903056,
-0.0067113666,
0.0523460284,
-0.002037185,
-0.0677166283,
-0.0179498531,
-0.0078459848,
0.0481106229,
-0.0221148673,
-0.0794323683,
0.0747640431,
-0.0470104069,
-0.0109035103,
-0.0104861138,
-0.0269447137,
-0.0770781338,
0.0463261567,
-0.0183432437,
0.0114362314,
0.0001064199,
0.0028762731,
0.0218898412,
0.0096412534,
0.0087175891,
-0.0322232954,
0.0297147986,
0.0019525602,
0.0093412967,
0.028150849,
-0.0254205391,
-0.0266214684,
-0.0717500672,
0.026956249,
0.0019568375,
0.0005296988,
-0.0149834761,
-0.0190464742,
-0.0068576811,
0.0591447987,
0.0304647908,
-0.0247148182,
-0.0183105487,
-0.0032897489,
-0.0119008431,
0.0151668712,
-0.0112390872,
0.0134870466,
-0.0102843577,
0.0068949116,
0.0020479427,
0.0354097299,
-0.0339023173,
-0.0075303819,
-0.0151041262,
0.0246508047,
-0.0171988998,
-0.0245278161,
-0.0225073807,
0.0324537717,
-0.0465667397,
-0.0147633608,
0.1061602756,
0.0152881676,
-0.0461096652,
-0.0083457874,
-0.0713038445,
0.004665622,
0.0406591967,
0.0272585284,
-0.058828637,
-0.0231215674,
-0.0095983464,
0.0573400594,
0.0255431905,
0.0029289853,
0.0108182747,
-0.0901201889,
0.0659797937,
-0.0151593536,
-0.0516438968,
-0.0395871252,
-0.0758900866,
-0.0121234199,
-0.0065134005,
-0.0197137017,
0.0487582088,
0.0001606361,
0.030215811,
0.0156207979,
-0.0223408863,
-0.0381665491,
-0.0256097876,
-0.0084915422,
0.0199079327,
0.047320623,
0.021275552,
-0.0135252224,
-0.060739547,
0.0366851799,
-0.0234487783,
0.0269645955,
-0.0239158161,
0.1194795892,
0.00010644,
-0.0003599805,
-0.0379193351,
0.0322902054,
-0.022634672,
-0.0010827691,
-0.0502908304,
0.0442331843,
-0.0515212305,
0.0396375693,
-0.0114132455,
-0.0247121099,
-0.0157987196,
0.0795917958,
0.0207137447,
0.0323103182,
-0.0180340111,
-0.0586739182,
-0.0006027694,
-0.0267265067,
-0.016594002,
0.04566985,
0.0212095398,
-0.0383985825,
-0.0113586085,
-0.0424784087,
0.0021910272,
0.0102537302,
-0.0126919914,
0.0450891331,
-0.0844732374,
-0.0336164534,
-0.0536412522,
0.0623758547,
-0.0084022488,
-0.0106359608,
0.0103220511,
-0.0300421622,
0.0308961626,
-0.0612488948,
-0.0078042448,
0.0108735198,
0.0138383368,
-0.0499350354,
-0.0279183164,
0.0354952849,
0.025849184,
0.0762747824,
-0.0193650126,
-0.0542904176,
0.0155514525,
0.0487105027,
-0.0219329577,
-0.0195847694,
0.0410893895,
-0.0083861891,
0.0180358645,
0.0348647907,
-0.0459854901,
-0.0091095883,
0.0032570357,
0.0230496209,
-0.0173510443,
-0.0231820587,
0.0504893102,
0.0356499963,
0.0919610113,
-0.0084411427,
-0.0036287664,
-0.0489664711,
0.0099112485,
-0.0451505259,
-0.0351513587,
-0.0429686122,
0.0396257378,
0.0518832766,
-0.0200207271,
0.0094889645,
0.0140794665,
-0.0404312052,
0.0310452338,
-0.0437299386,
0.0038657566,
0.0029894721,
-0.0005897144,
-0.020507602,
0.0001853029,
-0.0370961279,
0.0266553555,
-0.004048638,
0.0497727878,
-0.0111666601,
0.0463268459,
0.0122874202,
0.0242923349,
-0.0147508876,
0.0102540739,
-0.1003950387,
-0.0321770236,
-0.0179974101,
0.0235877708,
0.0025258707,
0.0077658361,
0.0471667722,
0.0358641483,
-0.0238731764,
0.0064947535,
0.0391511731,
0.036426723,
-0.0178972073,
0.0253859479,
0.042969171,
-0.0273944251,
-0.0103808232,
0.0734488815,
0.0167831145,
0.0125663187,
-0.0294444468,
-0.0360814482,
-0.0136340568,
-0.0185649674,
0.0188733879,
0.0585136116,
-0.0054253223,
-0.0230577067,
-0.0013223271,
-0.0357551128,
-0.0403019302,
0.0159275364,
-0.0317601264,
-0.0306469668,
0.0167713854,
0.0704426467,
0.0193920266,
-0.042272374,
-0.0639347136,
0.0018721959,
-0.0167554524,
-0.0157356933,
0.004647065,
-6.761725625e-33,
-0.0227314737,
-0.023122333,
0.0035846061,
-0.0024411271,
-0.0053221709,
-0.0042878604,
-0.0223311428,
-0.0352831148,
-0.0368290432,
0.0102311336,
-0.0138583053,
0.0649362057,
0.0116313472,
0.0064609409,
0.012128626,
-0.0362585299,
0.0261668712,
0.0278332587,
-0.0331255682,
0.0072280937,
0.044929456,
0.0505205542,
0.059646517,
-0.077560477,
0.0796873048,
-0.0060253888,
-0.014438604,
0.0382231399,
-0.0283113942,
0.0571786687,
-0.004548552,
0.0609697737,
0.0198444445,
-0.059576124,
0.0381772183,
0.0168160554,
-0.1108824611,
-0.0058938367,
0.0292786974,
-0.0204062015,
-0.0536358915,
-0.0208252519,
0.0457482897,
-0.0294109061,
0.004363873,
-0.0037730366,
0.0519802123,
-0.0307842903,
0.0007758923,
-0.0005938382,
0.001809151,
0.034989208,
-0.0289783943,
0.0078808917,
0.0101926187,
0.056566231,
0.0073731546,
0.0578218773,
-0.0414715335,
-0.0176490024,
0.0026137668,
0.014032268,
0.0448546894,
0.0211531986,
-0.0040469458,
0.0407162718,
0.0029249515,
-0.0205573831,
-0.068917118,
-0.0110396622,
-0.0310255457,
0.0643835068,
0.0816313103,
0.0481360592,
0.0341317542,
0.0212805085,
-0.0647252575,
0.0698865205,
-0.0308842976,
0.0174979456,
-0.0079073701,
0.0355864465,
-0.0646482855,
-0.0169668626,
-0.0119005097,
-0.0053730574,
-0.039358072,
-0.0293641295,
0.0204912797,
0.0237126313,
-0.0417178124,
-0.0077949613,
-0.0009852394,
-0.0353734046,
0.0179503616,
0.0229438953,
-0.0012216225,
-0.0231420901,
0.0019931134,
-0.0311707575,
-0.0224982724,
-0.0034526433,
0.0235992409,
0.0171865746,
0.0253850333,
0.0135598667,
0.0506583601,
0.0013700415,
-0.0278947968,
-0.0009128714,
-0.0427966155,
-0.0030438863,
-0.0465445369,
-0.0011870567,
-0.0144561846,
0.0267366935,
-0.0422259755,
0.0557345673,
0.0278235897,
0.0427398123,
-0.0274805538,
-0.0758031309,
0.0111512542,
-0.0261041746,
-0.0030777324,
0.0190859605,
0.0124543998,
0.0013192596,
0.0313146785,
-0.0554209016,
-0.0210079364,
0.0439833999,
2.725e-7,
0.0621951334,
0.0038963277,
0.0360592864,
0.0203126464,
-0.0128748929,
0.0202582721,
-0.009010287,
0.0127484147,
0.0186586417,
-0.0597380288,
0.0078955162,
0.046460297,
0.0464503132,
0.0057069422,
-0.0416010246,
-0.0308072474,
-0.0310553312,
-0.0687006637,
-0.0344978869,
-0.0253334865,
0.0594884604,
0.0767936036,
0.0022116613,
-0.0083184643,
-0.0017201651,
-0.066234313,
0.0560524166,
-0.0403319821,
-0.0100539587,
0.012561758,
0.0864614323,
0.0566875897,
0.0198686495,
-0.0323012285,
-0.0060082092,
0.021192532,
0.0061072898,
0.0488915853,
-0.0224236902,
-0.0270444527,
0.0109569589,
-0.0187084805,
0.036898613,
-0.082270436,
0.0868447572,
0.0119430628,
0.0022927539,
0.05471332,
-0.0387817509,
-0.0123893982,
0.0048610414,
-0.039046701,
0.002438067,
0.0143490927,
-0.0253152233,
-0.0238931067,
0.0042064651,
-0.0977804214,
-0.056690298,
-0.0287135448,
-0.0191600192,
0.0207473766,
-0.0186050702,
0.0077290554,
-0.0051299413,
-0.0245651715,
0.007113175,
2.455938766e-34,
0.035815414,
0.0143809281,
0.0036100862,
0.0155143924,
0.0492478646,
0.0127512105,
-0.0164784826,
-0.0049878866,
0.0201565772,
-0.0871820673,
-0.0150726568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06332v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06332v2 | InternLM-Math: Open Math Large Language Models Toward Verifiable Reasoning | 2024-02-09T11:22:08 | 2024-05-24T07:09:21 | Huaiyuan Ying, Shuo Zhang, Linyang Li, Zhejian Zhou, Yunfan Shao, Zhaoye Fei, Yichuan Ma, Jiawei Hong, Kuikun Liu, Ziyi Wang, Yudong Wang, Zijian Wu, Shuaibin Li, Fengzhe Zhou, Hongwei Liu, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Jiayu Wang, Kai Chen, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The math abilities of large language models can represent their abstract
reasoning ability. In this paper, we introduce and open-source our math
reasoning LLMs InternLM-Math which is continue pre-trained from InternLM2. We
unify chain-of-thought reasoning, reward modeling, formal reasoning, data
augmentation, and code interpreter in a unified seq2seq format and supervise
our model to be a versatile math reasoner, verifier, prover, and augmenter.
These abilities can be used to develop the next math LLMs or self-iteration.
InternLM-Math obtains open-sourced state-of-the-art performance under the
setting of in-context learning, supervised fine-tuning, and code-assisted
reasoning in various informal and formal benchmarks including GSM8K, MATH,
Hungary math exam, MathBench-ZH, and MiniF2F. Our pre-trained model achieves
30.3 on the MiniF2F test set without fine-tuning. We further explore how to use
LEAN to solve math problems and study its performance under the setting of
multi-task learning which shows the possibility of using LEAN as a unified
platform for solving and proving in math. Our models, codes, and data are
released at \url{https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-Math}. | [
-0.0362938009,
0.1084714159,
0.0242320746,
0.0589080155,
-0.0166858453,
0.0357298367,
0.0098055378,
-0.0179595705,
0.0015725865,
-0.0196400937,
-0.0336287543,
0.0425956063,
-0.0368399918,
0.0297347046,
0.0468010493,
-0.005255966,
0.0304048453,
-0.0434091538,
0.010946787,
-0.0207033046,
-0.0279513132,
0.000079842,
-0.0287428871,
-0.0199028272,
-0.0162949357,
-0.0565846749,
0.0118387472,
-0.0120585151,
-0.0026339835,
-0.0280516148,
-0.0128609138,
0.0438052341,
0.005242927,
0.036853645,
0.000002503,
-0.0619406998,
-0.0082904221,
0.0334647484,
-0.072177656,
-0.0021618973,
-0.0445072614,
0.0238252375,
-0.0078889849,
0.0089201462,
-0.0649952814,
0.0265337285,
0.0182991493,
0.0109726153,
0.0839290619,
0.0781677142,
0.0024109213,
-0.0795679465,
0.0482789092,
0.0000392973,
0.0690158159,
-0.0703972876,
0.0192967579,
0.033595331,
0.0155513911,
0.0062262206,
-0.001930563,
0.028078977,
0.0784362555,
-0.0176970903,
-0.0048955912,
0.0206204206,
0.0022601895,
0.0146469185,
-0.0022632994,
0.0443351753,
-0.0144402971,
-0.0519657284,
-0.0372970253,
0.0132299913,
-0.0265564136,
-0.039026767,
-0.0592232458,
0.0487794094,
0.0142635368,
0.0055900482,
-0.0113092791,
-0.0034036131,
0.0448065437,
0.0087208338,
-0.0550966561,
0.0859979689,
0.0124221034,
-0.0232083965,
0.0130571323,
-0.0055299043,
-0.0574055016,
-0.0479301624,
0.0099402023,
0.0782126412,
-0.0140000731,
-0.0022075477,
-0.0000725832,
-0.0562259331,
-0.0060077854,
-0.0094221523,
0.0020638939,
0.0446194112,
0.0148949008,
0.0554387048,
-0.0521770827,
0.0340953656,
-0.0157644488,
0.0477164015,
-0.0063195215,
0.0144841159,
-0.0201588217,
0.0074266647,
-0.0167725999,
0.0408833586,
0.0026096918,
0.0342385434,
-0.0281475168,
0.0215167962,
-0.0578802526,
0.0647943243,
0.0170710888,
-0.0114259701,
0.0055878749,
-0.0629597828,
-0.0331275761,
-0.0241426043,
-0.0274397042,
0.0114065548,
0.0136544947,
-0.0338900387,
-0.015786076,
0.0236714724,
-0.0388930514,
-0.0213680118,
0.0305128526,
0.05595183,
0.008745186,
0.0163792092,
-0.045329649,
-0.0240671244,
0.0435122102,
-0.0843992606,
-0.0219760332,
-0.1161846444,
0.0264516044,
0.0041805319,
-0.018665202,
-0.0449319705,
-0.003514644,
0.0129860668,
0.0209147874,
0.0788743198,
-0.0346945263,
-0.0330928378,
-0.005044559,
0.0021560823,
-0.0117814438,
0.0530914143,
0.0350975133,
-0.0044297986,
0.0165023655,
-0.0082492242,
-0.0090512838,
0.0112189585,
0.0276094861,
-0.0053097191,
-0.0067994292,
0.0452907197,
0.0224730726,
0.0233158972,
-0.0568360277,
0.0526704118,
-0.0435576662,
0.0018870247,
-0.0078384662,
0.0426671207,
0.0115432404,
-0.0205057487,
0.001233593,
-0.0126824733,
0.0504223928,
-0.0413479917,
-0.07433597,
0.0489814505,
-0.0087925503,
-0.0022397498,
0.0019681042,
-0.0090441601,
-0.0256289542,
-0.1086287871,
-0.0161068514,
-0.0012864289,
-0.0458996333,
0.0309967659,
0.0825356618,
-0.007714381,
-0.0169578828,
0.050737951,
0.0175744127,
-0.0136911897,
-0.0214797705,
-0.0515712649,
0.074158825,
-0.025957061,
0.0513606295,
-0.0474833138,
-0.0164571032,
-0.0718331188,
0.0231241416,
0.0196114946,
0.0182611383,
-0.0086791366,
-0.0275668111,
-0.0392240398,
-0.0116262902,
-0.0471867733,
-0.0020408717,
-0.0273159444,
0.048945386,
-0.000400272,
0.0070010754,
-0.0060353973,
-0.0275013279,
0.0233588405,
-0.0571025982,
-0.0542098731,
0.0084996792,
0.0111455452,
0.0036963914,
-0.0089641195,
0.0145601705,
0.043038927,
0.0271732993,
0.0046961568,
-0.0101884985,
-0.0243992992,
-0.0239313543,
-0.0007814894,
0.0637711138,
-0.0337326527,
-0.0359611921,
0.0048140851,
-0.0645606443,
-0.0022424038,
0.0245260689,
-0.0000246051,
0.0042717503,
-0.0366910845,
0.0033039434,
-0.0028273326,
-0.0269561261,
-0.0202581696,
0.0349250324,
0.018564485,
-0.014382829,
-0.028243836,
0.0253487099,
0.0071775718,
-0.0020658886,
0.0182465203,
0.0061758817,
-0.0401466601,
0.029452201,
-0.0427179821,
0.0109436084,
-0.0326363295,
-0.0148939285,
-0.0229874384,
0.0257029962,
-0.0238133464,
0.0436601005,
0.0112635186,
-0.0237292722,
0.0231068581,
-0.0000354353,
-0.0154451616,
0.0011846212,
0.0325814299,
-0.0120385168,
0.0282769259,
-0.0073667415,
0.0053738947,
0.0020995294,
-0.0326171443,
-0.0549899414,
0.053185001,
0.0183144193,
0.0563634932,
-0.010875795,
0.0244978145,
-0.0476026535,
0.0043308022,
-0.0069694966,
0.038321171,
0.0422730148,
-0.0553291105,
0.0026838921,
0.0824459195,
-0.001258238,
0.0125332689,
0.0043407986,
-0.0138634332,
-0.0513084754,
0.0224318542,
-0.0061567412,
-0.0068247658,
-0.0292488057,
0.0364442617,
-0.0102786599,
0.0391713418,
-0.0648030564,
-0.0143698361,
-0.0080302209,
0.0711020827,
0.0083448905,
0.011775584,
-0.0360648818,
0.0297445767,
-0.009969403,
0.0493075252,
-0.0120950704,
-0.0511350073,
0.0302916467,
-0.0010822631,
-0.0221002549,
-0.0377859734,
-0.0099711465,
-0.0788448602,
0.0232334714,
-0.0410785042,
-0.0208672695,
-0.0362152196,
0.0037946405,
-0.0020435839,
-0.0381196663,
0.0231224746,
-0.0324582681,
0.0382825248,
0.0112032993,
0.0142707657,
-0.0133214192,
-0.0225381143,
-0.0456623845,
0.0382053927,
-0.052385699,
0.0345677473,
-0.0274065826,
-0.0201717559,
0.0032055359,
-0.0052377498,
0.0088062584,
-0.0072375149,
-0.0292682275,
-0.0133687072,
-0.0230872966,
-0.0460358337,
0.0060730316,
0.0169872753,
0.0717628896,
-0.0701538399,
0.0249682274,
0.0385336354,
0.0396947116,
-0.0207312033,
-0.0485024378,
0.018574046,
-0.002783194,
-0.0277729984,
0.0193410516,
0.0203701854,
0.011476255,
-0.0669253841,
0.0118611939,
0.1126957163,
0.0129116494,
-0.0464022569,
-0.0030591406,
-0.0709286481,
0.0203626473,
0.0388971567,
0.0459254086,
-0.114527002,
-0.0395979397,
0.0150920227,
-0.0018984985,
0.0380280763,
-0.0292322598,
-0.0046117655,
-0.1161258817,
0.032143157,
0.029688796,
-0.0347184762,
-0.0087180901,
-0.0110506974,
-0.0102347014,
-0.0179625396,
-0.0313389972,
0.0348176099,
0.0004382646,
0.0192489289,
0.0164417364,
0.0482921526,
0.0113948528,
0.0255916994,
-0.0275908187,
-0.026139833,
-0.0098924348,
0.0029888516,
-0.0165947359,
-0.1167416275,
0.0622794665,
0.0522671081,
-0.0673894286,
-0.019936569,
0.0047259773,
-0.0353495181,
-0.0128263887,
-0.0210596509,
0.0567549132,
-0.0448511355,
-0.0252919924,
0.037979044,
0.1068543792,
0.0008073018,
-0.0171535909,
-0.0003739135,
-0.017210681,
-0.0474063866,
0.0491822399,
-0.020032078,
0.033663474,
-0.0541958138,
-0.0481456928,
-0.0608870313,
-0.0315285288,
-0.0145283081,
-0.0041439869,
0.0468073897,
0.0127742393,
0.0007626773,
-0.0082811471,
0.0575018935,
0.0777423903,
-0.0210763291,
-0.0648313537,
-0.0210758578,
-0.0147197573,
-0.0465219319,
0.043269936,
-0.0570056923,
0.0596279092,
-0.079815045,
0.0561458282,
0.0006287037,
-0.0210319366,
-0.0215953067,
0.0247033685,
-0.1006331071,
-0.0340764485,
-0.0447747074,
0.0679297969,
0.0164875984,
0.0494272225,
-0.0266442709,
0.0119459638,
0.0144882482,
0.0354070105,
-0.0941256955,
0.0221997071,
0.0868608356,
-0.028374115,
0.0129400305,
0.0118894791,
-0.0062377891,
-0.0065760375,
0.0317901745,
0.0320139267,
-0.0116101392,
-0.0048969984,
-0.0035289451,
0.0640845895,
-0.0141501883,
0.0564774685,
-0.0033957297,
-0.0102064693,
0.0476084091,
-0.0052538607,
-0.0050315964,
-0.0502418764,
0.0254225098,
-0.0053855018,
-0.019986121,
0.0250862539,
-0.0153425792,
0.0240473002,
0.0260268487,
0.0313611217,
0.0427852646,
-0.0318466276,
0.0482264794,
0.0497055985,
-0.0161612127,
0.0071848207,
0.0158881992,
0.0004347411,
0.0585750602,
-0.0138765974,
0.0388751216,
0.0383467451,
0.0197678823,
-0.0324160755,
-0.0235291608,
-0.0332360342,
-0.088921681,
-0.0041427026,
0.012728191,
0.024035221,
0.0327373892,
-0.0033270058,
-0.0379156582,
0.0077577299,
0.0046713185,
0.0261774696,
0.0049867923,
-0.0133624971,
0.0124284634,
0.0403107479,
0.0170054212,
-0.0357209742,
0.0102121942,
-0.0408918336,
0.0116776945,
0.0030849867,
0.0261666067,
-0.0353166722,
-0.0412838347,
0.0333882906,
0.0227626842,
0.0064780153,
-0.005571438,
-0.0372911692,
-0.0962334946,
-0.0173244439,
0.0375863686,
-0.0252265967,
0.0298682693,
0.0281156357,
0.067330189,
0.0036278309,
-0.0091745323,
0.0212021098,
0.0178025458,
-0.0138439536,
-0.0424139611,
0.0180459283,
-6.317980915e-33,
-0.0078589274,
-0.0150701115,
0.0673621669,
0.0303674079,
0.0038514812,
-0.0110707534,
-0.0476193838,
-0.0043006926,
-0.0112315556,
0.0372995622,
0.0106634507,
0.0353137404,
0.0011296236,
0.0034155773,
-0.0030071465,
-0.0062352931,
0.0137232067,
0.0005701379,
-0.0309236199,
0.0061007603,
-0.0111714685,
0.0169304777,
0.0753318146,
-0.0199358985,
0.0129922042,
-0.0053019556,
-0.015274928,
0.056836348,
-0.0732696354,
0.0442468934,
0.0043677678,
-0.0020608848,
-0.0141691249,
-0.0431826003,
-0.0075954166,
-0.0246632751,
-0.0704745725,
-0.0276115425,
0.002050065,
0.0047965082,
-0.074806422,
-0.0390859395,
0.0400022343,
0.020137595,
-0.041960001,
-0.0600567795,
0.005882774,
0.0037632312,
0.0164911952,
0.0334503874,
-0.0117847165,
0.0383730158,
-0.0364844203,
0.0039225221,
0.0181201957,
0.0050205444,
-0.0224763732,
0.0030727922,
-0.0224309172,
0.0134171275,
-0.0213955957,
-0.008016305,
0.073803097,
-0.0296667684,
0.0059706704,
0.0184339117,
0.0230648201,
-0.0062916339,
-0.0357873291,
0.0526174493,
0.0392768644,
0.0848159418,
0.0846474394,
-0.0271905065,
0.0284666959,
0.0383284725,
-0.0650629774,
0.0092635164,
0.0069217705,
0.0859382898,
-0.0076189153,
0.0068842112,
-0.0116114384,
0.0053738779,
-0.02193892,
0.004998134,
-0.0505009331,
-0.0198689178,
0.017901253,
-0.0118673081,
-0.0416129641,
0.040458139,
0.0202045497,
-0.0427580625,
0.0055653933,
0.0472277254,
0.0343866125,
0.0004368973,
-0.0012633529,
0.035073977,
-0.0278393477,
0.0137165589,
-0.0101612536,
0.0119611435,
0.025129389,
0.0252233818,
0.0253277961,
0.0235810112,
-0.0230091326,
-0.0129364925,
-0.0635124743,
-0.0070515168,
0.0442421734,
0.0428688042,
0.0254853945,
0.0423975922,
0.0060736067,
0.0668779314,
-0.0381338596,
-0.0322292782,
-0.0314124972,
0.0324338824,
0.002176346,
0.0286569633,
-0.0007918715,
-0.0217565205,
-0.0568244345,
0.0082707694,
-0.0078075556,
-0.0773234218,
0.0153597072,
0.0270269699,
3.195e-7,
0.0094755581,
0.0189817064,
0.0285600573,
0.0445557199,
-0.0082898755,
0.0283197556,
-0.0387218408,
-0.045785971,
0.0130821187,
-0.0060921591,
-0.0127276108,
0.0997315273,
0.0269927178,
0.0195839293,
-0.032975778,
-0.0227721669,
-0.0358078927,
-0.014441913,
-0.0631095693,
0.0162536353,
0.0316317752,
0.0574749894,
0.056033697,
-0.0209637117,
0.0397295356,
-0.0392235518,
0.0315409414,
0.0216530114,
0.0068742651,
0.0099476585,
-0.0242603682,
-0.0223651752,
0.0359358191,
-0.0187875256,
0.002380017,
0.0175656676,
-0.0159348696,
0.0939420238,
0.0020242403,
0.0339521244,
-0.0357093923,
-0.0434151627,
0.0049026171,
-0.0437132157,
0.0795918927,
-0.0244423207,
-0.0458522588,
-0.0046207164,
-0.0237789676,
-0.0625548512,
0.0066150464,
0.009407701,
0.0306086019,
-0.0168686211,
0.0215572864,
-0.0287605114,
-0.0099223703,
-0.0551844425,
-0.0534291193,
0.0049178666,
-0.0392551869,
-0.0182291996,
-0.0115914689,
0.0394276641,
0.0358341448,
-0.0082089212,
-0.0193991195,
3.397693871e-34,
0.0445778072,
0.0048024752,
0.047433462,
0.0529314764,
0.0478568301,
0.0040772865,
-0.0332948938,
0.0188847408,
0.0524686016,
-0.0524316505,
-0.0286074318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18589v1 | Verif.ai: Towards an Open-Source Scientific Generative Question-Answering System with Referenced and Verifiable Answers | 2024-02-09T10:25:01 | 2024-02-09T10:25:01 | Miloš Košprdić, Adela Ljajić, Bojana Bašaragin, Darija Medvecki, Nikola Milošević | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we present the current progress of the project Verif.ai, an
open-source scientific generative question-answering system with referenced and
verified answers. The components of the system are (1) an information retrieval
system combining semantic and lexical search techniques over scientific papers
(PubMed), (2) a fine-tuned generative model (Mistral 7B) taking top answers and
generating answers with references to the papers from which the claim was
derived, and (3) a verification engine that cross-checks the generated claim
and the abstract or paper from which the claim was derived, verifying whether
there may have been any hallucinations in generating the claim. We are
reinforcing the generative model by providing the abstract in context, but in
addition, an independent set of methods and models are verifying the answer and
checking for hallucinations. Therefore, we believe that by using our method, we
can make scientists more productive, while building trust in the use of
generative language models in scientific environments, where hallucinations and
misinformation cannot be tolerated. | [
0.0634829551,
0.040139541,
0.0123020867,
-0.0117113683,
-0.0147239715,
-0.0351886787,
-0.003698478,
0.0319578722,
0.0323198587,
-0.0270974413,
-0.0080155963,
0.0057111452,
-0.0181733128,
0.0303467605,
0.0299920179,
-0.043656297,
0.0473703854,
0.0019140863,
0.0534646586,
-0.0352387242,
-0.0110248551,
0.0134491129,
-0.0394377038,
0.0166792553,
0.0198481809,
-0.0365634784,
0.0467051007,
-0.0234772768,
0.038196262,
-0.0320853107,
-0.0107788285,
0.0561847016,
-0.0275605265,
0.0611277893,
0.0000018789,
-0.071263805,
-0.0140745752,
0.0590270385,
-0.0125236586,
-0.0031637596,
0.030545624,
0.035508126,
-0.0052170744,
0.0329419859,
-0.039038334,
-0.0333008915,
0.0368219838,
0.0333272591,
0.040379934,
0.0403983071,
0.0000264859,
-0.0417407826,
0.0775831714,
0.005773847,
0.0658222511,
-0.0004467614,
0.0420395844,
0.0539638624,
0.0651022196,
0.0201363564,
0.0308542568,
0.0519613884,
-0.0055547333,
-0.0345750339,
0.0450271256,
0.0335437804,
-0.0290569123,
-0.0192260444,
0.0026216649,
0.0454399921,
0.028335128,
-0.0781807676,
0.043814078,
0.0184153821,
-0.0284276512,
0.0835769251,
-0.0483221896,
0.0216812994,
-0.0007761409,
-0.0398983434,
0.0556792878,
0.0113027962,
0.0008280398,
0.0192036685,
0.0149919391,
0.0273924712,
0.0432691351,
-0.0512751415,
-0.0038575535,
-0.0278166514,
0.0475287996,
-0.1086736023,
0.0326889567,
0.0466110893,
-0.011952132,
-0.0069861342,
0.0070431787,
-0.0397195145,
0.0955103636,
-0.0425476022,
-0.0376488268,
-0.0105087906,
-0.0122316908,
0.03182723,
-0.0085896757,
-0.0149823828,
-0.0655350611,
0.033088807,
-0.0215580203,
-0.0203435179,
-0.0666155592,
-0.028899109,
-0.0490355194,
0.0020263859,
-0.0317933261,
-0.0082301032,
-0.0547900535,
-0.0090050595,
0.0122097535,
-0.0067131887,
0.0221445691,
0.0302011091,
-0.0127208941,
-0.0094755348,
-0.0278266557,
0.0082066339,
-0.0217086114,
-0.0031854787,
0.0046253293,
-0.0785046071,
-0.010375103,
0.0143166119,
0.0143854581,
0.0062788143,
0.0193179827,
0.0107945912,
0.0286995824,
0.0175515022,
0.0238101948,
-0.0751672983,
-0.0105427075,
-0.0541935265,
0.0213890318,
-0.0624287426,
0.0125870304,
0.0148891807,
-0.012479255,
-0.0188644081,
0.0095625343,
0.0438774712,
-0.0276944861,
0.0260694716,
-0.091646634,
-0.0145569658,
0.0603696071,
0.0117775183,
0.038073428,
-0.0295903608,
0.0045121866,
-0.0137475142,
0.0234581139,
-0.0126436548,
0.0740576684,
-0.0631591976,
0.0479317456,
-0.046114482,
0.0469932556,
0.0503214821,
-0.0019639018,
0.0251138881,
-0.0716497079,
0.069175154,
-0.023932863,
-0.0139563931,
0.0167283192,
0.0358522311,
-0.0052014962,
0.0129355649,
0.0156852882,
-0.0359237529,
0.029918706,
-0.0203704201,
0.004528082,
0.062493518,
-0.025376251,
-0.0026757796,
0.025812991,
0.0088981399,
0.0043278122,
-0.0268179569,
-0.0289170519,
0.0379642509,
-0.0491168872,
-0.0056156213,
0.0290414076,
0.0254092757,
-0.0194850229,
0.0119201671,
0.0310617257,
-0.024257835,
0.0001156126,
-0.0367295407,
0.0655232444,
0.0308571551,
0.0809625462,
-0.0146489516,
0.0192137733,
-0.0223251563,
0.0066667981,
0.0718480051,
0.0231530759,
-0.0150090363,
-0.0540125556,
-0.0195568912,
-0.0056689782,
-0.0293823853,
0.0059870947,
-0.027648367,
0.0052869241,
0.0340326838,
-0.0158949252,
-0.03664634,
-0.0224185865,
0.0323406905,
-0.0233296994,
-0.0155248549,
-0.0215590037,
-0.0365816355,
0.0379814729,
0.0129454015,
-0.0227089729,
0.0842833817,
0.04320563,
-0.0358368047,
-0.065393582,
0.0298060644,
0.0330536105,
0.0332643986,
0.0046432284,
-0.0669536963,
0.0307683013,
-0.0363828912,
0.0041001914,
-0.0441378765,
0.0092302924,
-0.0413019098,
-0.0085978312,
-0.0485034399,
-0.0359653123,
0.0064492919,
0.0273222979,
-0.0243495852,
0.0566706844,
0.0151139162,
0.0280205812,
0.0125875585,
0.0007248502,
0.0318517275,
-0.0246798117,
0.0010360595,
0.0129820378,
-0.0108618038,
0.0056396727,
0.0276752673,
-0.0658434406,
-0.0391076021,
-0.0051806336,
-0.0286188927,
-0.0019827862,
0.0159115884,
0.0301534981,
0.0237189569,
-0.0223730095,
0.0066739651,
0.0030910762,
-0.0097482018,
0.0241560377,
0.0627035573,
-0.0013566557,
0.0311582554,
0.0229843706,
0.002127242,
-0.047699865,
0.0007022561,
-0.0315811187,
0.0582057126,
0.0559767224,
0.0210515484,
-0.0681538731,
-0.0061257603,
-0.0459894091,
0.0181586053,
0.0201397408,
0.0199740455,
0.0313581862,
-0.0226375796,
-0.000677723,
0.0193592813,
0.0379787236,
-0.0197000746,
0.0286158826,
-0.0010559725,
-0.0487084463,
-0.0093108499,
-0.0448602177,
-0.0127762193,
0.0431323722,
-0.0066520115,
0.0311913844,
0.0277408622,
0.0290313996,
-0.0196577962,
-0.0450134464,
0.0549241155,
-0.0088068303,
-0.0375852063,
0.0379356444,
-0.0028889389,
0.000448097,
0.0596916005,
0.0186171923,
-0.0385522246,
0.081416145,
-0.0273173042,
0.013018149,
-0.0560131893,
0.0122761261,
0.0074895849,
-0.0227271188,
-0.0086048245,
0.0252920967,
0.0504858084,
0.0422674753,
0.0138810733,
-0.0046179416,
0.0015255613,
-0.0383680612,
-0.0754164606,
-0.0234663468,
0.0306662675,
0.0305028558,
-0.0074909399,
-0.0307197701,
-0.0042466386,
0.0005154787,
0.0279817414,
-0.0047382326,
0.0027272883,
-0.0646153837,
-0.0021033704,
0.0460379012,
-0.0071280943,
-0.0043496485,
-0.042040851,
-0.0176427476,
0.0301076286,
0.0703722984,
-0.031290777,
0.0508775339,
-0.0014161144,
-0.0421291105,
0.0875428319,
0.0005956086,
0.0435220897,
-0.0108670685,
-0.0709163323,
-0.0205331054,
-0.0588508435,
0.0174202882,
-0.0032138522,
-0.0101971347,
-0.0263521057,
-0.0248775277,
0.0494400971,
0.0342186503,
-0.0054369359,
-0.0039210259,
-0.0779992566,
-0.0144330533,
0.0051189112,
0.0596002601,
-0.1060541496,
0.0283591002,
-0.0624991208,
0.0008950372,
-0.0358876549,
-0.0103999395,
-0.0085149333,
-0.0402367488,
0.0678077191,
-0.0155698406,
-0.0043987315,
-0.0009758506,
-0.0482621379,
-0.0160343852,
0.0145677384,
-0.0547294728,
0.0277841333,
0.0259562898,
0.0079405233,
0.0112157455,
0.0151140895,
-0.0338155441,
0.020831598,
-0.0241585169,
0.0225237347,
0.0640344322,
0.036260549,
0.0045685507,
-0.1092273891,
-0.0506707765,
-0.0658352748,
-0.011314692,
-0.0219495445,
0.042234119,
0.0189030878,
0.0112953763,
-0.0474944599,
0.0425215513,
-0.0383243784,
-0.0333104245,
0.0184408557,
0.0868983567,
-0.0288317781,
-0.0387241468,
-0.0880700499,
0.0368025675,
0.0051772343,
0.0652814656,
-0.0130422749,
0.025001647,
-0.0741598383,
-0.0042142728,
0.053871084,
-0.0127221299,
-0.0384497792,
0.0082689393,
0.0209725257,
-0.0089818928,
-0.1016434804,
0.0065740794,
-0.0017157313,
0.0351222344,
-0.0135996537,
0.0278131329,
0.0159066971,
-0.0215817448,
-0.0349095687,
0.010326785,
-0.0205863565,
0.0095225591,
-0.0160078257,
-0.0256543439,
0.0983352214,
-0.0117797628,
-0.0224097036,
0.053411603,
0.0155975651,
-0.0291839764,
-0.0487396121,
0.0569715165,
0.0301019419,
-0.0172094423,
-0.0322320946,
-0.0310068745,
0.0437299907,
0.0265308879,
0.0127035324,
0.0078087375,
-0.046058625,
-0.0367895178,
-0.013862961,
-0.0502998047,
-0.0387728326,
0.0303769801,
-0.004006499,
0.023064699,
-0.0302135218,
-0.021299636,
0.0511890613,
0.0477377884,
0.0125093265,
-0.0321996585,
0.0129149882,
-0.0006881763,
0.0004667563,
-0.0251103379,
0.0125385625,
-0.0179222021,
0.0145855602,
0.0036417933,
-0.0216615107,
0.0272436198,
0.0035171735,
-0.0807775781,
0.0338665843,
-0.0360588282,
0.0064706514,
0.0201629587,
0.0333462022,
0.0209721979,
-0.0287327431,
0.0000678624,
-0.0202317704,
-0.0364397354,
0.0738965422,
0.0003933067,
0.037358094,
0.0194068644,
-0.0312061645,
0.0099965865,
0.0033003471,
-0.1028420404,
-0.0595817305,
-0.0383261368,
0.0329227448,
0.0057659121,
0.0799502805,
0.0333450139,
-0.023989005,
-0.0284593478,
-0.0073027541,
0.0259035118,
0.0324094184,
-0.0058508464,
0.0290295463,
0.018150406,
-0.0163788926,
-0.0473925062,
0.0577430427,
-0.0080902856,
0.0385692306,
-0.0346107632,
-0.0528311394,
-0.0386534296,
-0.0752878934,
-0.1143170744,
0.0176406093,
-0.0015740686,
-0.016240567,
-0.0561582483,
-0.0129889632,
0.0168984924,
0.0704162046,
0.016811369,
0.0058579356,
0.0333090872,
0.0603837743,
0.0282335002,
-0.0879160613,
-0.0130718583,
0.069793433,
-0.0349895582,
-0.0525690243,
-0.0174026173,
-6.341336519e-33,
0.0111904517,
-0.0451749638,
0.014828301,
-0.0042276974,
0.0079406826,
0.0043982416,
-0.0710489601,
-0.0378027223,
-0.0102916751,
0.0492340028,
0.0170586146,
0.0096066929,
-0.0022276917,
-0.023055099,
0.0093388008,
0.0211071353,
0.0159296319,
-0.0090031344,
-0.0151745807,
0.0436348766,
0.0429558456,
-0.0010496158,
0.0130841974,
-0.0727321133,
0.026840603,
-0.0306614228,
-0.0150477299,
0.022872692,
-0.0652348325,
0.0541923717,
-0.0314135328,
0.0176103264,
0.0035719466,
-0.0430330001,
0.0210481379,
-0.0062326258,
-0.0753229037,
0.0300274231,
0.0157779716,
-0.0594265983,
-0.0812621564,
-0.0018294759,
0.0418942906,
-0.0174236745,
-0.0056147063,
-0.0005328239,
0.0456502102,
-0.0238715764,
-0.0184967872,
-0.0868083239,
-0.0565132983,
0.0134659838,
0.0021404091,
0.0126092397,
-0.0285208412,
0.0476722084,
-0.0098853596,
0.0259659626,
-0.0173810367,
0.0468753502,
-0.0192897338,
-0.0216297917,
0.0181186087,
-0.0598842315,
0.0139671713,
0.0228974875,
0.0480654091,
-0.0310163572,
-0.0170029588,
0.002608191,
-0.0379148051,
0.042779386,
0.0926780626,
0.0674903393,
0.0322681516,
0.0244136248,
-0.0716782734,
0.0349143557,
-0.0312417876,
0.0253250469,
0.0412467681,
-0.0176286418,
0.0131176598,
0.0118962405,
0.0103162248,
-0.0046233009,
-0.0380448923,
-0.011366616,
0.0114329709,
-0.0143108377,
-0.0347228311,
0.0175452307,
0.0069984817,
-0.0466672108,
0.0128901638,
0.0426564068,
0.0199698284,
0.012511068,
-0.012405281,
0.001001897,
-0.0506831445,
0.0247069746,
0.024800349,
0.0079260133,
0.0193042867,
0.03226275,
-0.0115268566,
-0.0427552611,
-0.0214531012,
0.0148968184,
-0.006769232,
0.0392408445,
-0.0155520206,
-0.020023467,
0.0098973736,
0.0443336852,
0.0276426673,
0.0161346179,
0.0162142683,
0.0573359616,
-0.0035855074,
0.0512489751,
-0.0024393785,
0.0275970474,
-0.0267812684,
0.0139784422,
-0.0126894359,
0.0306505114,
-0.0146312807,
-0.0601424351,
0.0114065493,
0.0210552569,
2.775e-7,
0.0579119176,
0.0438724495,
0.0210586227,
-0.0017726923,
0.0458554924,
-0.0124956751,
0.0344848558,
-0.0001381545,
0.0352804512,
-0.0375979915,
-0.028273996,
0.0037674338,
0.0025678729,
0.0436182171,
-0.0615023002,
-0.0500490107,
-0.0749294609,
-0.0335337929,
-0.0302847046,
-0.0068958751,
0.0373885259,
-0.0264046434,
-0.015025679,
-0.0131159686,
-0.0165721755,
-0.0127357608,
0.05096462,
0.0462746434,
0.0391466729,
0.0679204538,
0.0307678096,
-0.0041246885,
0.0260990318,
0.0323877633,
-0.0359872468,
-0.0237773508,
-0.0228779987,
0.0004455553,
-0.021785466,
-0.0192156266,
0.0277272854,
-0.0392821766,
0.0582879931,
-0.0625165626,
0.0084794303,
-0.0422223732,
-0.019113658,
-0.0229542945,
-0.075624384,
-0.0132537549,
0.033825893,
-0.0294245705,
-0.0191645008,
0.0141161717,
-0.0293081496,
0.0401971526,
-0.0073328316,
-0.0329747647,
-0.0127162253,
0.0083592581,
-0.0472860448,
-0.0357818268,
0.0151175903,
-0.0348228738,
-0.0233787708,
-0.0409987047,
0.0101772603,
2.250915102e-34,
0.0354754217,
0.0359061174,
-0.0125891929,
-0.0011608803,
0.0226896517,
0.0153378146,
0.0385908708,
0.0051066182,
0.0203071162,
-0.059116032,
-0.0133685982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10948v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10948v2 | Zero-shot Explainable Mental Health Analysis on Social Media by Incorporating Mental Scales | 2024-02-09T09:44:06 | 2024-03-15T02:02:02 | Wenyu Li, Yinuo Zhu, Xin Lin, Ming Li, Ziyue Jiang, Ziqian Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional discriminative approaches in mental health analysis are known for
their strong capacity but lack interpretability and demand large-scale
annotated data. The generative approaches, such as those based on large
language models (LLMs), have the potential to get rid of heavy annotations and
provide explanations but their capabilities still fall short compared to
discriminative approaches, and their explanations may be unreliable due to the
fact that the generation of explanation is a black-box process. Inspired by the
psychological assessment practice of using scales to evaluate mental states,
our method which is called Mental Analysis by Incorporating Mental Scales
(MAIMS), incorporates two procedures via LLMs. First, the patient completes
mental scales, and second, the psychologist interprets the collected
information from the mental scales and makes informed decisions. Experimental
results show that MAIMS outperforms other zero-shot methods. MAIMS can generate
more rigorous explanation based on the outputs of mental scales | [
0.0145543851,
0.0605087727,
-0.0314630009,
-0.0129270321,
0.0080222776,
0.0372552089,
0.0409837626,
-0.0007200448,
0.0347873904,
-0.0166053902,
0.0256291199,
-0.0325925201,
-0.0018816768,
0.0288508479,
0.009816315,
-0.0733541176,
-0.0406012498,
0.0161570981,
0.055550687,
0.0117400968,
0.0363164768,
0.0120781362,
-0.009844712,
0.0352767967,
0.0176898725,
-0.0107042408,
0.0245101377,
-0.0192721374,
0.0209655557,
-0.0916869864,
-0.064914763,
0.0315028392,
0.0019829185,
0.0140400873,
0.0000019849,
-0.0239484962,
-0.0047406009,
-0.0116314515,
0.0321741998,
-0.0385347791,
0.0286264755,
-0.0645790249,
0.0402323417,
0.0241923872,
-0.0108506205,
-0.0518094115,
0.0573349483,
0.0687201843,
0.0627216846,
0.0630966276,
-0.0346351191,
-0.068330124,
-0.0238894597,
-0.010104117,
0.0094072875,
-0.0096681444,
0.0540396608,
0.0122227566,
0.0336947851,
0.0037243264,
0.0062475102,
0.0220458917,
-0.0312147792,
0.0055388422,
-0.0129861804,
0.0090630278,
0.0093800509,
-0.0580722988,
0.0476587117,
0.1082250327,
0.0232235864,
0.0212801322,
0.060408961,
-0.0306240357,
-0.0169544667,
0.0450248197,
-0.0667343736,
0.0214157235,
0.0030501944,
0.0396021269,
-0.0175750814,
0.0343243666,
0.0428443775,
0.0054957331,
-0.0178957544,
0.0464130603,
-0.0255382247,
-0.0001497431,
-0.0231466107,
-0.0109202368,
-0.0496206209,
-0.0640704632,
0.0151125984,
0.0548574403,
-0.0230395366,
0.0178288631,
0.0006691282,
-0.0789100751,
0.0334902517,
-0.0439299569,
0.0025597345,
0.0276245587,
-0.0298760086,
0.0013833013,
0.054462906,
0.0290429909,
-0.0027874971,
-0.0208068788,
-0.0244640186,
0.0245789737,
-0.079218775,
0.0114396978,
0.0068711736,
0.0080101276,
0.0209324881,
-0.0207569674,
-0.0645443797,
0.0075072302,
-0.0304144435,
-0.029981764,
-0.0155085567,
0.0012281496,
0.0151576167,
0.0126588894,
0.0097803893,
0.0538751259,
-0.0534811206,
0.0164737422,
0.0039896541,
-0.0143516529,
0.0460825041,
-0.0059162946,
0.0321938209,
-0.0264726598,
0.0008881349,
0.0228316635,
0.0598244071,
0.005005084,
-0.0284029059,
-0.0549718477,
-0.0368262045,
-0.0429403819,
-0.0305328406,
-0.0484929569,
0.020609457,
0.0554293692,
0.0074582803,
-0.0298495088,
0.028895285,
0.01295288,
-0.0811081454,
0.0872149169,
-0.0614559352,
0.0307244547,
-0.0117199095,
0.0320621766,
0.0400490798,
0.0648340881,
0.025157636,
-0.0067185992,
0.0379448831,
-0.0685772598,
0.0241528656,
0.0010363851,
0.0164591447,
-0.0243775677,
-0.0256683268,
-0.0331315994,
-0.0290222447,
0.0322155431,
-0.0355559289,
0.0454334915,
-0.0001421066,
0.0429393351,
0.060737513,
0.0851433799,
0.0338558033,
0.0276578832,
-0.0044290493,
0.0209055543,
-0.0112744393,
-0.007682953,
-0.0162022822,
-0.001335138,
-0.0116853304,
-0.0181695316,
0.0307429601,
-0.0064206244,
-0.0164554305,
-0.0360106081,
-0.0703741387,
-0.0152054531,
0.0198950302,
0.007446989,
0.0186884981,
-0.0426210985,
0.0381674729,
0.0420577377,
0.0445696078,
-0.0354575813,
-0.0008610082,
-0.0569297224,
0.0150842005,
0.0859453157,
0.0290873144,
-0.0250997543,
0.0062802462,
-0.0090739643,
0.0394686125,
0.0262318254,
-0.0174426623,
0.0049249888,
-0.0158082508,
-0.0432620719,
0.0033254945,
0.017633196,
0.0194894932,
-0.0458242036,
-0.0366257951,
-0.0065522254,
-0.0140193831,
-0.024536591,
-0.0340073369,
0.0239542816,
0.0145778144,
-0.0466697812,
0.0221975464,
-0.0085441545,
0.046478413,
0.0662039295,
0.0112699298,
0.0303984191,
-0.0033053888,
-0.0334263369,
-0.0294850226,
0.0006988674,
0.0051600714,
0.0192238297,
0.040128544,
0.0032278416,
0.0484131724,
0.002106447,
-0.0332917012,
-0.0440091714,
0.0364104845,
-0.0433114506,
0.0268951952,
0.0238465797,
-0.0325854905,
-0.0081359558,
0.0225111861,
-0.0407255441,
0.0626995713,
-0.0186887141,
0.0329339169,
-0.0118189491,
-0.0639606491,
-0.0190404914,
-0.0058223638,
-0.0407362618,
-0.0037001795,
0.003186814,
0.0277102683,
-0.0190673042,
-0.0306425486,
-0.0213871524,
-0.002560125,
-0.1345960647,
-0.0062004738,
-0.0099686272,
0.0074809571,
0.0332566239,
0.0181880128,
-0.0045657069,
0.0018631647,
-0.020467449,
0.0411472246,
0.0491364188,
0.0737327039,
0.0049053119,
0.0155852688,
-0.0009064808,
-0.0202749837,
-0.0187140461,
-0.0536902584,
0.0444464646,
0.0409120619,
-0.0030379021,
-0.0366894528,
-0.0054004933,
-0.0858513117,
-0.0357471481,
0.0048351414,
-0.0315120444,
0.0309037119,
-0.0171124227,
0.0025964214,
-0.0042739213,
0.0140311485,
0.0719149634,
0.0423790738,
0.0132306954,
-0.0207487829,
-0.0445470549,
-0.027398495,
-0.0231319647,
-0.042898979,
-0.0666497126,
-0.0334993042,
0.0755531639,
0.0301531013,
0.0032848935,
-0.0564805456,
0.0336387455,
-0.018787438,
0.0058389939,
-0.0422156379,
0.0213677399,
-0.006111396,
0.0488992333,
0.0099510178,
-0.0376935489,
0.0367572494,
0.0019285684,
0.034675099,
-0.0013043748,
-0.0265164338,
-0.0300289411,
0.0402222686,
0.0101452256,
0.0237966049,
0.0341157094,
0.0003169748,
0.0628312975,
-0.0526245348,
-0.0083734747,
-0.0504935458,
0.0136622163,
-0.046647694,
0.0042914059,
0.0287604425,
-0.0044804229,
-0.020283388,
-0.0410132743,
-0.081848748,
-0.0073952475,
-0.0246716049,
-0.0078690397,
-0.0278833136,
0.0216635782,
0.0437566638,
-0.010839548,
-0.0100560393,
-0.0124366572,
0.02437938,
0.0312950872,
0.0413840711,
-0.0201641284,
0.0475263149,
-0.0288641881,
0.0023364103,
0.0395792685,
-0.0202151481,
0.0489238948,
-0.0006409749,
-0.0071470593,
-0.0198415294,
0.000794813,
-0.0035539737,
0.0197165702,
0.0438318811,
-0.0110619375,
-0.0038285388,
0.1333520561,
0.0067473934,
-0.0291729905,
0.0282084178,
-0.014918549,
-0.0272364654,
-0.0036486224,
-0.0141012389,
-0.0391324945,
-0.0192965735,
-0.0375761613,
0.06676092,
-0.0259133279,
-0.0431125499,
0.0228184573,
-0.0426282212,
0.0233461559,
-0.0004560868,
-0.0156818051,
0.022391567,
-0.0713887513,
0.0406355783,
-0.0332596563,
-0.034320835,
-0.0277796499,
-0.0055858139,
0.0114639346,
0.0044849538,
-0.0438910499,
-0.0666590557,
0.0387853645,
-0.0195750035,
0.0790385976,
0.0156065524,
0.0746297091,
0.0094136698,
-0.0489755981,
0.0094886059,
0.0015820441,
0.0056365007,
-0.0053621652,
0.0831781179,
0.0446771383,
-0.0003542909,
-0.0734107569,
0.0667685121,
-0.0467727408,
-0.039860148,
-0.0243443232,
0.0698105171,
-0.0049946071,
-0.0234215818,
-0.0238291007,
0.0345483236,
0.0462823547,
0.0626161695,
0.0518944897,
-0.0477802157,
-0.0128966244,
0.0021740503,
0.0052170409,
-0.0062137833,
-0.0838693455,
-0.0064639975,
-0.00110431,
-0.0328969546,
-0.033717785,
-0.025160132,
0.0475168191,
-0.0052797026,
-0.0160080269,
-0.0097427769,
0.0385471471,
0.0017308054,
-0.0505059026,
0.0511638671,
0.0246967506,
0.0173694994,
-0.0044194176,
-0.0118490653,
0.0245798863,
-0.0045273621,
0.0068769855,
-0.0175082162,
-0.0656966195,
-0.0115440534,
0.0519444123,
-0.0156467743,
0.01887713,
-0.0367666557,
0.0150367301,
-0.0846674815,
0.0231074281,
0.0155469449,
-0.0440433137,
-0.0020758305,
-0.0205732267,
0.0583789013,
0.0234309845,
0.0420974307,
0.0051243268,
0.0403331704,
0.0394659378,
-0.0043214322,
-0.0624734685,
0.0053377571,
-0.0204976369,
0.0262395442,
0.0427827016,
-0.0173379779,
-0.0449273214,
-0.0025120331,
-0.0755169466,
-0.0294066202,
-0.0105520179,
-0.0150055094,
-0.0411075763,
0.0264503658,
0.0087128216,
-0.0520628132,
-0.0615920313,
-0.0634477511,
-0.0188786462,
-0.0648048297,
0.0425696895,
-0.0170884244,
-0.0446778573,
0.0210195389,
-0.0175672155,
0.0000521034,
0.0237545054,
-0.0274963155,
0.0236439332,
0.0145982523,
0.0671330169,
-0.0143803386,
0.0115780067,
-0.0018342882,
0.0438305885,
-0.0092067923,
-0.0855396986,
-0.0053257355,
-0.0000942539,
0.0143488301,
0.0134353414,
0.0987072885,
0.0390096158,
-0.0137566123,
-0.013478471,
0.0228485018,
-0.030596789,
-0.0399077572,
0.015953159,
0.0216154177,
-0.0136530846,
0.0015500537,
0.069682762,
-0.024414435,
-0.01591607,
0.013190398,
-0.0304352064,
-0.0084060393,
0.0171974655,
-0.031842649,
0.0618885271,
-0.032158941,
0.0151729239,
-0.0765060335,
-0.0804086328,
0.0242967177,
-0.0422834791,
-0.0270371847,
-0.000643053,
0.0099358568,
0.0227361135,
-0.0060788062,
0.0032650789,
-0.0674145371,
0.0247978736,
-0.0304297023,
-0.029304957,
-0.0174825471,
-6.003792948e-33,
0.0075106882,
-0.0617977083,
-0.004923264,
-0.0174854957,
-0.0142477984,
0.0205238797,
-0.0252915341,
0.0279609859,
0.0253615957,
0.0366855562,
0.0175474081,
0.0296001527,
-0.0090044392,
0.0607285909,
0.0169237778,
-0.0187185649,
0.0109478738,
-0.0140095539,
-0.0296972319,
0.0418900847,
0.0504505448,
0.0136407213,
0.0136443004,
-0.1205084547,
0.0420382693,
0.0006414502,
0.0051056771,
0.0375040807,
0.0524483584,
0.0558482707,
-0.0255757719,
0.069295384,
0.0605907217,
-0.020368794,
0.0126929767,
0.057719212,
-0.0463610403,
-0.028855266,
0.0274555981,
-0.028131919,
-0.0047249873,
-0.0238493327,
0.0425843708,
-0.0221364535,
0.0161972921,
-0.0535007939,
0.0494946614,
-0.0421152711,
0.0484574884,
0.0019648063,
-0.0170601439,
0.0229717419,
-0.013345019,
0.0140749495,
-0.0178291835,
0.0090989582,
-0.0556548834,
0.0282725301,
-0.058318641,
0.018890392,
0.019706063,
-0.0204113554,
0.0325574502,
-0.0061401394,
-0.0047101239,
0.046386607,
0.0150208138,
-0.011070651,
-0.066617161,
-0.0053653889,
-0.0107195554,
0.0301738512,
0.0612012967,
0.0161099434,
0.0143416179,
-0.026191799,
-0.0613936484,
-0.0081660394,
-0.0037320538,
0.0144956363,
0.0552208088,
0.0124966372,
-0.0412599668,
-0.0297344532,
-0.0210667383,
-0.0260132365,
-0.0518000312,
-0.0250890423,
-0.0008732757,
-0.0196083523,
-0.0449988693,
0.0169082433,
0.0194971617,
-0.0289804991,
-0.0226903912,
0.0031981927,
0.0257859491,
0.0541032702,
0.0026894882,
-0.0192865711,
-0.0317709781,
0.0070482325,
0.0173897017,
0.0222040769,
0.0495106094,
-0.008448082,
0.0026565387,
-0.0306982622,
-0.0334390327,
-0.0249448158,
-0.0028267351,
-0.0104104606,
-0.0394135155,
0.0188145936,
-0.0065052919,
0.0143872052,
-0.0160265658,
0.0312344134,
0.0393050089,
-0.0064720456,
-0.0050665648,
-0.0143955573,
-0.0224067681,
-0.02030297,
-0.0253357738,
-0.0326807313,
-0.0109325722,
-0.0157561693,
0.0560841598,
-0.0451064818,
-0.0011446129,
-0.0121992128,
2.717e-7,
0.0600138009,
0.0717291459,
-0.0422275737,
-0.0220930353,
0.0484266356,
0.0447428413,
0.0384253152,
0.006210655,
0.0329809412,
-0.0292611141,
0.0084663974,
0.0457227938,
0.0318684764,
0.063859567,
0.0406120904,
-0.0137130562,
-0.0369414501,
-0.0300038736,
-0.0535480157,
0.0088764466,
0.0534010455,
0.0415963717,
0.0177016761,
-0.0080185598,
0.0189220216,
-0.0173749216,
0.0194880329,
-0.0161460694,
0.0108171776,
0.025455948,
0.0282128491,
0.0199881345,
0.0258648377,
-0.0111168474,
0.0060702716,
-0.0142475041,
-0.0076472485,
0.0751132146,
-0.0388213657,
0.0062831626,
0.0035888425,
-0.0293482281,
0.0216791332,
-0.0521198884,
0.0853261873,
-0.098727107,
-0.0842602998,
-0.0273738299,
-0.002464175,
-0.0504362397,
0.0251485892,
-0.0069412319,
-0.0220284276,
0.0460026637,
0.0159908179,
-0.0092331953,
-0.0061014998,
-0.0751605481,
-0.0401465856,
0.0108237667,
-0.0557584912,
-0.0110427812,
-0.0024497432,
-0.0355989151,
-0.0019730951,
-0.0791203305,
0.0356661044,
2.257829856e-34,
0.0022869948,
0.0462824851,
-0.0034196489,
-0.0353392102,
0.0138403624,
0.0234122407,
-0.0308216102,
0.009889992,
0.0240677781,
-0.1284617186,
0.0099699628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06264v1 | LLaVA-Docent: Instruction Tuning with Multimodal Large Language Model to Support Art Appreciation Education | 2024-02-09T09:25:18 | 2024-02-09T09:25:18 | Unggi Lee, Minji Jeon, Yunseo Lee, Gyuri Byun, Yoorim Son, Jaeyoon Shin, Hongkyu Ko, Hyeoncheol Kim | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Art appreciation is vital in nurturing critical thinking and emotional
intelligence among learners. However, traditional art appreciation education
has often been hindered by limited access to art resources, especially for
disadvantaged students, and an imbalanced emphasis on STEM subjects in
mainstream education. In response to these challenges, recent technological
advancements have paved the way for innovative solutions. This study explores
the application of multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) in art
appreciation education, focusing on developing LLaVA-Docent, a model that
leverages these advancements. Our approach involved a comprehensive literature
review and consultations with experts in the field, leading to developing a
robust data framework. Utilizing this framework, we generated a virtual
dialogue dataset that was leveraged by GPT-4. This dataset was instrumental in
training the MLLM, named LLaVA-Docent. Six researchers conducted quantitative
and qualitative evaluations of LLaVA-Docent to assess its effectiveness,
benchmarking it against the GPT-4 model in a few-shot setting. The evaluation
process revealed distinct strengths and weaknesses of the LLaVA-Docent model.
Our findings highlight the efficacy of LLaVA-Docent in enhancing the
accessibility and engagement of art appreciation education. By harnessing the
potential of MLLMs, this study makes a significant contribution to the field of
art education, proposing a novel methodology that reimagines the way art
appreciation is taught and experienced. | [
0.0228184033,
0.0584164672,
-0.0608233735,
0.0625451803,
-0.0117660398,
0.0430960953,
0.0154293813,
-0.0572935119,
-0.0055112666,
-0.0443919562,
-0.0612398759,
0.0029617578,
-0.024176877,
-0.0084330533,
0.0323807411,
-0.0646729916,
-0.0102393385,
0.0085951108,
0.019672621,
0.0106050279,
0.0175414234,
0.029317297,
-0.0545466729,
0.0444750786,
-0.0108256321,
-0.0531425923,
-0.0036043001,
0.017892072,
0.0262666047,
-0.05439163,
-0.0138158323,
0.0337190181,
0.0351779349,
0.0283533446,
0.0000024025,
-0.0428078808,
0.0180749111,
-0.0464232378,
0.0474174432,
0.0029773477,
0.0488098077,
0.0623095967,
-0.0007623137,
-0.0167988855,
-0.0018567288,
-0.0100070694,
0.0714496076,
0.0243950207,
0.0394015312,
0.0164565276,
0.0111172171,
-0.0558287986,
0.0338340811,
0.0025728899,
0.0247694422,
0.022675341,
0.0042722956,
0.0688953847,
0.0238601062,
0.0272094496,
-0.0522862114,
0.0471549481,
0.0089689828,
-0.0437641181,
0.0282451622,
-0.0033545089,
-0.0148287648,
-0.0281825606,
0.0030971277,
0.0792546645,
0.0819295794,
0.0374404155,
-0.0177086256,
0.0202812701,
0.0212432072,
0.0336959772,
-0.11352247,
0.0492970571,
0.0254099183,
-0.0028008735,
-0.0327383727,
-0.0065048384,
-0.0202814266,
0.0449401475,
0.0699422508,
-0.0815551654,
-0.0096253324,
0.0291841608,
-0.0113240834,
0.0075944006,
-0.028875567,
0.0081418995,
-0.0112475688,
0.0393429957,
0.0127568021,
0.0359569527,
0.04915848,
0.0072501409,
0.0144810611,
-0.0098848566,
0.0555135012,
0.0403148793,
-0.0471166521,
0.0122359162,
0.0340673402,
0.0249058921,
-0.0037275986,
0.0061109024,
-0.0001129287,
0.0471037179,
-0.0663599297,
-0.0323335417,
-0.0190717056,
-0.0040312838,
-0.0339633934,
-0.0419233814,
-0.0281160828,
-0.0318524912,
-0.0459528007,
0.0033473172,
-0.0659334138,
-0.0087038325,
0.0215574652,
0.0199859627,
-0.0176198222,
0.129304111,
-0.0142282024,
0.0269592907,
-0.0195398964,
-0.0464373007,
0.0245202016,
0.0459312275,
-0.0292903669,
-0.0286894906,
0.0116204927,
0.025211554,
-0.0203771386,
-0.036025729,
-0.0171328057,
-0.031819582,
0.0239121821,
-0.0465684459,
0.0781664103,
-0.0404828824,
-0.0425891131,
-0.0226838365,
0.0436393879,
-0.0171951745,
-0.0266612042,
0.0181575809,
0.031451799,
0.0452827848,
0.029995542,
-0.0123221381,
0.0661809221,
0.0456603467,
0.0486772545,
0.043355532,
0.0463655442,
-0.0105952406,
0.0285694283,
-0.0339556485,
0.0027381885,
0.0155815082,
-0.0117616141,
0.0193129815,
-0.0261967536,
-0.01538938,
-0.016741382,
0.0709892586,
-0.0368900858,
0.0101197939,
-0.022213364,
0.0502166077,
0.0553785451,
0.0309064705,
-0.0198958106,
-0.0046377066,
-0.010467832,
0.0424601398,
0.0521289781,
-0.057311181,
-0.0126872081,
0.0662642345,
0.0300326776,
0.0087499842,
0.0134577081,
0.0463542864,
-0.0215766318,
-0.0402167216,
-0.0148766544,
-0.0102768857,
0.0438227318,
0.0331481881,
0.0076983776,
-0.0068602278,
-0.0184344407,
-0.0436289497,
0.0103348866,
-0.0511497296,
0.0011981326,
-0.0646593273,
0.0395944044,
0.0843411088,
0.0480794646,
-0.0168706961,
-0.0215945225,
-0.0308740158,
0.0704736561,
0.0781824589,
0.0189278051,
-0.0112537025,
-0.038795419,
-0.0105416803,
0.0141569898,
-0.0478656925,
0.0189132169,
0.0204215515,
-0.0383180045,
0.0206999052,
-0.0331613235,
-0.0230519567,
-0.0425841101,
-0.0069937604,
0.0016327316,
-0.0533245951,
-0.0426088311,
0.0227106921,
0.0155308535,
0.0774047822,
-0.0178359468,
-0.0007625261,
-0.0004303256,
0.0320425332,
0.0199407618,
0.0301579759,
-0.0207336303,
0.0467710234,
0.0255263038,
-0.0773172081,
0.014238392,
0.0170164835,
0.0311878473,
-0.003257361,
0.0679783598,
-0.0027722311,
0.0267126914,
0.0223491918,
-0.0196658503,
-0.013857319,
-0.0026270889,
-0.0277806874,
-0.0311197471,
-0.0050145648,
-0.0129471701,
-0.0130772963,
-0.0116177853,
0.0271221865,
0.0129449228,
-0.0480050147,
0.0475378819,
0.0242227949,
0.0488924496,
-0.0091183558,
0.0220335424,
-0.0613727681,
0.0030191292,
-0.093024455,
-0.0525611416,
0.0089834221,
-0.021340793,
-0.0029976023,
-0.053848248,
-0.0318973437,
0.0080733495,
-0.0120061096,
0.0269456897,
-0.0089438474,
0.0074564102,
0.00119589,
-0.0083022937,
-0.0172294658,
-0.0280956682,
-0.0338426717,
-0.0070946375,
0.0465434231,
0.0833167657,
0.0123439878,
0.0214413591,
-0.0587204397,
-0.0523234904,
-0.0349574722,
-0.016656952,
-0.0429030061,
0.0194884669,
-0.0008623014,
-0.0110547356,
0.0343898907,
-0.0240943208,
0.0580839776,
0.026445426,
-0.0457564034,
-0.041934181,
-0.0052681537,
0.0192205496,
-0.032569021,
-0.0032963878,
-0.0231270958,
-0.0377171822,
0.0063840905,
-0.0011521253,
0.0043003112,
-0.0071806703,
0.0625429302,
0.0031047019,
-0.0256828219,
-0.001009936,
-0.0240515471,
-0.0070273839,
0.0158867389,
0.0236228034,
-0.0259650107,
0.024130078,
0.0192984547,
-0.0061101904,
-0.0328854397,
0.0558805615,
-0.0157867074,
0.0430820659,
-0.0382317081,
0.0237518623,
-0.0478438474,
-0.0176216904,
-0.0178853329,
0.0272078458,
0.0201566014,
-0.0418834984,
0.0331571065,
-0.0618041679,
-0.0497031361,
-0.0040462734,
0.0475044176,
-0.0065950062,
0.0721028,
-0.0367705189,
-0.0602687821,
-0.0363916233,
-0.0400606915,
-0.0048661646,
-0.0505830236,
0.0176894832,
-0.0193846226,
-0.029443739,
-0.0051264102,
0.0079118973,
0.0023650234,
0.0267535932,
0.0106046982,
-0.0061816662,
-0.0402601995,
0.0713788122,
0.0281452648,
-0.0242420845,
-0.0226652417,
0.0013758579,
0.0203964766,
0.0316881873,
0.0609241277,
-0.0062996498,
0.0188460872,
0.0597996712,
-0.0220664684,
0.0115972087,
0.0489363819,
-0.0009960851,
-0.0344069377,
-0.0188394263,
-0.0252900161,
0.0084045334,
-0.0025575035,
0.0157541148,
-0.1064799726,
-0.006102846,
-0.0419133119,
0.0352333598,
-0.0180739425,
-0.0132947834,
0.0155213689,
-0.0755216107,
0.0660255775,
-0.0166933872,
0.0037886528,
0.0087526757,
0.0246732943,
0.012159274,
0.0453350805,
0.0366198868,
0.0040939366,
-0.0060262238,
0.022968296,
0.0378384478,
0.0368975997,
-0.0528017171,
0.0296465568,
0.0324498601,
0.0373416841,
0.0211203974,
0.0426349044,
-0.0195741709,
-0.0413879193,
0.0212238841,
0.0709859729,
-0.0140425004,
-0.015129054,
0.0228588488,
-0.0112436954,
0.0200415477,
-0.0215211138,
0.0525154173,
-0.0005188151,
-0.0266790763,
0.0342170745,
0.0618897006,
0.0142260492,
0.0164743513,
-0.0344674699,
0.0140042342,
-0.0050367294,
0.0156912375,
0.0599635243,
-0.0259538461,
0.0167716853,
-0.0251843352,
0.02115646,
-0.0160049852,
-0.082859166,
0.0001432469,
-0.0155109474,
0.0046224827,
-0.0031317817,
-0.034420386,
0.0063196374,
0.0357763506,
0.014349876,
0.0128073944,
-0.0218172576,
0.0171542857,
-0.0734693035,
0.0794849992,
0.030594768,
0.0274457894,
-0.0147410408,
-0.0777291283,
-0.0255571306,
-0.0697516799,
-0.0069853268,
0.0013107688,
-0.0380107872,
-0.0324352905,
0.0123719471,
0.0270768907,
0.0205780324,
-0.0212622657,
0.0840460882,
-0.0740938559,
-0.021651661,
0.027541535,
0.0474220589,
-0.0103034638,
-0.0170245115,
0.0506599285,
0.0114842206,
-0.032220237,
0.0420308709,
0.0017611335,
0.0348620526,
-0.0069272737,
0.0301148333,
-0.003725236,
-0.0068393713,
0.0354833715,
0.002370181,
-0.0551526695,
-0.0079705128,
-0.0441791676,
-0.0132319843,
-0.0393780917,
-0.0047246772,
-0.0209424812,
-0.0255280863,
0.0174725447,
-0.0597640052,
-0.0169709064,
-0.0538389273,
0.043958474,
-0.014320109,
-0.095424749,
0.0812245682,
0.0003904022,
-0.0241296217,
-0.0335292555,
0.0165236834,
0.0019672269,
0.0446553528,
-0.0049707801,
0.0368542001,
0.0234334804,
0.1202904359,
0.0226855855,
-0.0193088613,
0.0244338959,
0.0402183793,
0.0245811008,
-0.0653716773,
0.0015011285,
0.0546620078,
0.0310748015,
-0.0130263157,
0.0352861322,
-0.0086439243,
0.0265758373,
-0.0113627268,
0.0307250861,
-0.0416966006,
-0.0740341172,
0.0316031054,
0.0034735743,
0.0479046851,
-0.0517243035,
-0.0065954709,
-0.0987157226,
-0.0008364122,
-0.0072466172,
-0.0026313278,
-0.0242996924,
-0.0044219601,
0.033011131,
0.0224544369,
0.032978747,
0.052486673,
-0.0810983256,
-0.057593815,
-0.0306721348,
-0.003156642,
-0.000411286,
-0.0370462909,
0.0183521267,
0.0378324725,
-0.0217726678,
-0.0356309339,
-0.0303600039,
-0.0064368648,
-0.0516272373,
0.0006693281,
0.0291392952,
-6.224293281e-33,
-0.0370003916,
-0.065296948,
0.0406726152,
0.0151925925,
-0.0372270793,
-0.0254417975,
-0.048204612,
0.0405675583,
-0.0097892508,
0.0130331758,
0.0205496922,
-0.0496886037,
-0.0152727999,
0.034095671,
0.0642582327,
-0.0020958902,
-0.0046093967,
0.0311096497,
-0.0214242917,
0.0258654412,
0.0044318656,
-0.0077484329,
0.0694773272,
-0.0821890011,
0.0528578423,
0.0057060774,
-0.0040170471,
-0.0349009894,
-0.0060210708,
0.0465998575,
-0.0324251838,
0.0595939569,
0.0119040813,
-0.0252191573,
-0.002185191,
0.0222209226,
-0.0348033831,
-0.0206220075,
0.0233156942,
0.0510170795,
-0.0126004219,
-0.0273008756,
0.0144681912,
-0.00122313,
-0.0522360578,
-0.0095494129,
0.0472029708,
-0.0234793015,
0.0519665927,
-0.0010224495,
-0.0995447487,
-0.0171656609,
-0.067441754,
-0.023372516,
0.0244175959,
-0.0228060372,
-0.0009178789,
0.0266161188,
-0.0514629371,
0.078581959,
0.0065036672,
-0.0188697949,
0.0756683573,
0.0192034133,
0.0131036229,
0.0304193981,
0.0465108193,
-0.0019661949,
0.0006598899,
0.0470014438,
0.0460203476,
0.0130123515,
0.0104289092,
0.0671595931,
-0.0468817316,
-0.0168864578,
-0.0171457864,
-0.0147694163,
-0.0052255527,
0.0411877073,
-0.0063456297,
-0.0147677194,
-0.0386121608,
-0.0067465985,
-0.0420701467,
-0.0244042091,
0.0083198464,
-0.0010591986,
0.0352485739,
-0.0517687984,
-0.0097923884,
-0.0227948744,
0.0195866358,
0.0079612732,
-0.0890684798,
-0.0033164544,
-0.0571732745,
0.0682884604,
-0.025065301,
-0.0395671874,
-0.0345120281,
0.0258086622,
-0.0070923022,
-0.0285296887,
0.0345843025,
0.0005875941,
-0.0164851677,
0.0044796378,
-0.0181037709,
-0.006085271,
-0.029967092,
-0.0294487532,
0.0397879407,
-0.0338324569,
0.0054026674,
0.0173119046,
-0.03095611,
0.0327731259,
0.0209688209,
-0.0090031968,
-0.0057255514,
-0.1005613431,
-0.0501223318,
-0.0374587588,
-0.0411834456,
0.0099379513,
-0.0158225968,
-0.0783163235,
0.010464007,
-0.0848878548,
0.0036987155,
-0.0127559714,
3.142e-7,
0.0044465628,
0.0667631552,
0.0057697664,
0.0163283683,
-0.0048937127,
0.0087403627,
-0.0533057563,
-0.0108883698,
0.0437060669,
0.006292664,
0.0030461412,
0.0321265832,
0.0252038371,
0.0121497167,
-0.0337746106,
0.000248605,
0.0141458269,
0.0255076904,
-0.0709982738,
0.0389945395,
0.0541360378,
-0.0229888279,
0.0102869924,
-0.023254253,
-0.0274152029,
0.0440370813,
0.0080833416,
-0.0444293916,
-0.0082117617,
-0.0091201067,
0.0425563827,
-0.0450319797,
0.0036059255,
-0.0267047677,
0.0078342957,
-0.0234411284,
-0.0031625363,
0.0248988662,
0.0056051905,
0.0081314221,
0.0204591677,
0.064808242,
-0.0429333411,
-0.0278764293,
0.012203454,
0.0116399182,
-0.0249982793,
0.0105575006,
-0.0492030457,
-0.0363033079,
0.0440356508,
-0.0246755611,
-0.0505340509,
-0.0045516076,
-0.0052124043,
-0.0627732351,
0.0567457899,
-0.0134030646,
0.0325405672,
-0.0423288085,
-0.0501266234,
-0.0204657018,
-0.0083696758,
-0.0278251097,
-0.0486238785,
-0.0090205669,
-0.0515386499,
2.221195299e-34,
0.0280364286,
-0.0358508676,
0.0653596893,
0.0160804838,
0.0109594176,
0.0090172477,
-0.0150083806,
-0.0040358691,
0.0166627374,
-0.0345720612,
-0.0245844182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06262v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06262v2 | On the Efficacy of Eviction Policy for Key-Value Constrained Generative Language Model Inference | 2024-02-09T09:20:59 | 2024-02-17T10:08:14 | Siyu Ren, Kenny Q. Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the recent success associated with Large Language Models (LLMs), they
are notably cost-prohibitive to deploy in resource-constrained environments due
to their excessive memory and computational demands. In addition to model
parameters, the key-value cache is also stored in GPU memory, growing linearly
with batch size and sequence length. As a remedy, recent works have proposed
various eviction policies for maintaining the overhead of key-value cache under
a given budget. This paper embarks on the efficacy of existing eviction
policies in terms of importance score calculation and eviction scope
construction. We identify the deficiency of prior policies in these two aspects
and introduce RoCo, a robust cache omission policy based on temporal attention
scores and robustness measures. Extensive experimentation spanning prefilling
and auto-regressive decoding stages validates the superiority of RoCo. Finally,
we release EasyKV, a versatile software package dedicated to user-friendly
key-value constrained generative inference. Code available at
https://github.com/DRSY/EasyKV. | [
0.0427791253,
0.0978982598,
-0.0111966599,
0.0204157848,
-0.0145368781,
0.0312122367,
-0.0127426311,
-0.0038607724,
0.0076779458,
-0.018368477,
0.0205497928,
-0.063022472,
0.0202892721,
0.0317111611,
0.0260068588,
-0.0406881571,
0.0533902012,
-0.0485970005,
0.0335871354,
-0.0168001,
-0.0120486487,
-0.0084028533,
0.0434665345,
0.0399213247,
0.0185746271,
-0.0143469432,
-0.0070571993,
-0.0037690452,
0.0291647296,
0.0049837721,
-0.0274097212,
0.0789516717,
-0.012026174,
0.0208766907,
0.0000022833,
-0.0522195734,
-0.0063895197,
-0.0093342178,
-0.0164710414,
0.0625358894,
0.0246425197,
0.0151990782,
-0.0203595106,
-0.0019964676,
-0.0008694472,
-0.0348028503,
0.0795297399,
-0.0480107218,
0.0024045829,
0.0439119451,
-0.0067603919,
-0.0292625707,
0.0019256942,
-0.0581964441,
0.0275963582,
-0.088847734,
0.0253477767,
-0.0139481826,
-0.0262534413,
-0.0332948342,
-0.033730872,
0.0713027269,
0.0302942283,
-0.0076836646,
0.0137723442,
0.0702271834,
-0.0326662436,
-0.0229609832,
0.0023565055,
0.0248374864,
-0.0048399949,
-0.057206355,
0.0161670111,
-0.0252293535,
-0.0165269114,
-0.011796833,
-0.0360100009,
0.038484998,
-0.028784994,
0.0186358001,
0.06500981,
0.0263064615,
0.0305849519,
-0.0129229203,
-0.0377085172,
-0.0027749648,
0.0492201932,
-0.0075876806,
-0.0410125367,
0.0074097277,
-0.0304555818,
-0.0715336725,
-0.0019447827,
0.0135665517,
0.0269742664,
0.0028199402,
-0.0372913033,
-0.0117457518,
0.0069087222,
-0.051010035,
0.0326959305,
0.0430247895,
0.0254026707,
0.0349281132,
0.0039426652,
0.0898218602,
-0.0168460868,
-0.0206855815,
-0.0429025553,
-0.0037512411,
0.0224536397,
-0.0221023709,
-0.0178869255,
0.0004575342,
0.0116488105,
0.0026579492,
-0.0354078151,
-0.0078506581,
0.0046585095,
-0.0209733229,
0.0184122548,
0.0224857032,
-0.0433578081,
0.0155749479,
0.001491238,
0.012728272,
-0.0338675901,
-0.0284574907,
-0.0331235044,
-0.0778856799,
-0.0479432717,
0.0370182134,
0.0074658967,
-0.0359847732,
-0.0098826522,
0.0578338765,
0.009869474,
-0.0430341326,
-0.0112078395,
0.0059249578,
-0.0048873052,
-0.0761383697,
0.0123675885,
-0.0647249073,
-0.0012555532,
0.0210157987,
-0.0093114907,
-0.0332188271,
-0.0225957502,
0.030169392,
-0.0250133462,
0.0096384613,
0.0343280174,
-0.0009072266,
0.0145359943,
-0.005537298,
0.0414465182,
0.0591092221,
0.0283458717,
0.0389753245,
-0.0104510617,
-0.0307663921,
0.0162105598,
0.0354540981,
0.0233326536,
0.0134100504,
0.0006674179,
-0.0057526161,
0.030166069,
-0.0092504108,
0.0534783266,
0.053742446,
-0.0293114018,
-0.0173835997,
0.0526075363,
0.0361407436,
-0.0179459695,
0.0238676816,
0.0234767031,
0.0014007873,
-0.0130978068,
0.0095140999,
-0.0405215546,
0.0535191111,
0.0090920385,
0.02399645,
0.068812646,
0.0466360413,
-0.0134110628,
-0.0321244225,
-0.0049567139,
0.0079644881,
0.0144906091,
0.0074608787,
0.0704646632,
-0.0008556405,
-0.0508852378,
0.0220172387,
0.03912412,
-0.0478250422,
-0.0165218208,
-0.0246300343,
0.0197404195,
0.0612971485,
0.0597076528,
0.0237524752,
-0.0357101336,
0.0355791524,
-0.0143800862,
0.0030040797,
0.010959344,
0.0088757444,
0.0306991115,
-0.0594099388,
-0.0273762997,
0.0149980756,
0.0115056438,
0.0587810911,
0.0464368127,
0.0095292702,
0.0248692147,
-0.0170595553,
-0.0153510123,
0.0067681279,
-0.0249678567,
-0.0473527387,
-0.012650229,
-0.0084683038,
0.0245225597,
-0.0109083448,
-0.0141724218,
0.0257024858,
0.0195596293,
-0.0483260192,
0.0375654697,
-0.0009445096,
-0.0776650608,
-0.0148757976,
0.01440976,
0.002992877,
0.0133062433,
0.0141094429,
-0.0358316489,
-0.0391024947,
0.0696475208,
-0.0301703177,
0.0629190952,
-0.0552544035,
0.0157518592,
-0.0109983357,
0.0534267128,
-0.0186110735,
0.0818952248,
-0.0465558134,
0.0317878015,
0.0348957852,
0.0265287347,
-0.0039545489,
-0.0443128124,
-0.0142454077,
0.00369622,
-0.0086896792,
-0.001429647,
0.0332028456,
0.0024153781,
0.0021783162,
0.0172457527,
-0.0728518665,
-0.0010516205,
-0.0181670859,
0.0567488745,
-0.0021321799,
0.0336877666,
-0.0297858752,
-0.0223524552,
0.0283473823,
-0.0335602537,
-0.0221825689,
0.0093378229,
-0.0134450411,
-0.0174882133,
-0.026681032,
-0.0060640383,
-0.0353510529,
0.0152470088,
0.0710961968,
-0.0183047652,
-0.057081461,
-0.0191215258,
0.0552649125,
-0.0144210905,
0.0217403676,
-0.0142969433,
-0.0299874097,
-0.008958769,
-0.019023383,
0.0767031461,
0.0468182191,
-0.0109426705,
-0.0115076527,
0.0534317344,
-0.0368852504,
-0.0385261923,
-0.0065611014,
-0.0209353082,
-0.0343276188,
-0.0075413138,
-0.0148206484,
-0.0190557037,
0.1023440957,
-0.0079716956,
-0.0237917062,
-0.082726188,
-0.0088873394,
-0.0122445198,
-0.0161567349,
0.0035867209,
0.0366868787,
-0.046062123,
0.0211673155,
-0.0407957174,
-0.0884485841,
0.0663150698,
-0.0526181385,
-0.0033431917,
-0.0142203867,
0.0353997499,
-0.0013398239,
0.0572407357,
0.0188923962,
0.009073508,
0.0039180964,
-0.022266876,
-0.0115560787,
0.0236489102,
0.0183685925,
-0.0357148685,
0.0161933657,
-0.0385288149,
0.0340449512,
-0.0338216797,
0.0159077384,
-0.0363778807,
0.0002512989,
-0.0219237655,
-0.0201387592,
0.0480057709,
-0.0078277737,
0.0155073889,
0.0270269103,
-0.0080895498,
0.063909322,
-0.0116404844,
0.0092023322,
0.0049964329,
0.0186451729,
0.0426497497,
-0.0159127694,
-0.0043362319,
-0.0201337039,
-0.0237537026,
0.078586705,
0.0253295656,
0.0290964898,
-0.010317931,
0.011252312,
0.0479978658,
0.0077137281,
-0.0070430837,
0.0500000529,
0.0242042467,
-0.0665687472,
-0.0321658216,
0.0974348113,
0.0157814119,
-0.0588805228,
0.0075364895,
0.0187998861,
0.0787853971,
0.0270600691,
0.0544083938,
-0.0697862655,
-0.013865347,
0.0416567698,
0.0415915549,
-0.0122917816,
-0.0111478036,
-0.0303251166,
-0.1366649717,
0.0471624322,
0.0013639263,
-0.0069830054,
-0.0305245835,
-0.0457047112,
0.0005550013,
-0.0143188573,
-0.0377451628,
0.0175602138,
-0.0057333652,
0.0033388764,
0.0119994599,
-0.0024510336,
-0.0527128875,
0.0154574076,
-0.0093678832,
0.037481185,
0.0722038075,
0.0151944505,
0.0250062887,
-0.023290243,
0.0089641558,
-0.0055397395,
-0.0156965256,
-0.0359810218,
0.0037126434,
-0.0078919753,
-0.004842829,
-0.0277464855,
0.0201526843,
-0.0115267821,
-0.0362939611,
-0.0232840758,
0.0784230828,
-0.0225411765,
-0.087139383,
0.0083252303,
-0.0277691931,
0.0192068163,
0.078481108,
0.0556623898,
-0.0106286891,
-0.0791978613,
-0.0520605668,
-0.002851296,
-0.0712023899,
-0.0590218194,
0.003144284,
0.0260902159,
-0.0682313815,
-0.0295585524,
0.0015312715,
-0.0078682136,
0.0249001067,
-0.0209214706,
0.0334366597,
-0.0125679933,
-0.0248238873,
-0.0429574475,
0.0038716183,
-0.0370320939,
-0.0163034033,
-0.0402230807,
-0.0246001072,
0.0014329953,
-0.0125351707,
-0.0423191451,
0.0700103939,
-0.0992406979,
-0.0728757828,
0.0140869878,
0.0628032535,
0.0227824673,
0.0434834026,
-0.0093083289,
-0.0632683188,
0.0463432595,
0.0338225067,
-0.0003086651,
0.0475695729,
0.0008262484,
-0.0447398014,
-0.0107392306,
0.0277320687,
-0.0253560767,
0.0354771316,
0.0264072511,
0.0484761298,
0.0134734726,
0.0111095719,
-0.0233029127,
-0.015184829,
0.0232481938,
-0.0509294793,
-0.0292149037,
-0.0379575156,
0.0351366997,
0.0071002948,
0.0018914622,
-0.0265497733,
0.0077379071,
0.0127191134,
0.0021437216,
-0.0038828063,
0.0024024998,
0.0304059088,
-0.0163281038,
-0.0468365438,
0.0087468643,
0.0265747476,
0.0134496791,
0.0249165408,
-0.0212349072,
-0.0055617308,
0.0323794037,
-0.0091316374,
0.0436163433,
-0.0407867171,
-0.0084971702,
0.0134832999,
0.0120873628,
0.0137973288,
0.0070438762,
-0.0388741829,
-0.0124081466,
-0.0353780016,
-0.0110559268,
0.0561781526,
-0.0298788417,
0.076758787,
-0.0041830675,
0.0079517495,
-0.0416022949,
0.0185088869,
0.022086788,
-0.0448149294,
-0.0092778364,
0.0172755085,
-0.0214454215,
0.0289229229,
0.0919762626,
0.058486741,
0.0425691418,
-0.0141021796,
-0.0153393736,
-0.019251436,
-0.0699601471,
-0.053704299,
-0.0098532364,
-0.0305981841,
0.0014035006,
-0.0594077073,
-0.0795916319,
-0.0399396829,
-0.0055456972,
-0.010771092,
-0.0051097325,
0.0228507165,
0.0240988061,
-0.0211087037,
-0.0301012713,
-0.0338142402,
0.0239361413,
-0.0542291701,
-0.0100584114,
-0.0081489952,
-7.53579894e-33,
-0.0230229665,
-0.013018759,
-0.0054040165,
-0.0397125445,
0.0144408485,
-0.0057873265,
-0.0644780248,
-0.0499258265,
0.0126312431,
-0.0253946222,
-0.0002067898,
-0.0015230908,
0.0233871657,
0.0182702336,
-0.001804065,
0.0238091275,
0.01997393,
0.0348381698,
-0.026700139,
0.0694492906,
0.0242241602,
0.0361622758,
0.0744074434,
-0.0233473126,
-0.0114552109,
-0.0311825741,
0.0565063804,
-0.0266016088,
-0.0138291493,
0.0319314264,
-0.0487775505,
0.0219751969,
0.0177358743,
-0.0821003839,
-0.0454197042,
-0.0087277433,
-0.0712713748,
-0.0430076942,
0.0277392603,
-0.0161812659,
0.0059834546,
-0.0601938032,
-0.0111427819,
0.0384074599,
-0.0010824153,
-0.040084172,
0.0129093174,
0.0080273198,
-0.0578091778,
-0.0398981869,
-0.0527006313,
0.0541555658,
-0.0010223528,
0.0282199774,
0.0394485891,
-0.0019965079,
0.0001466926,
0.0493144318,
-0.0285242163,
0.0139573319,
0.0270043928,
0.099608019,
0.0980993956,
0.060967654,
0.0252516102,
0.0383581482,
0.0004317444,
-0.0172535367,
-0.043867968,
0.0272472445,
0.052866511,
-0.0168492962,
-0.0242575631,
-0.0025629755,
0.0634957552,
-0.0110770296,
-0.0655931681,
0.0074527767,
-0.023844976,
0.0689340755,
0.0605520718,
0.0153289605,
-0.0404458866,
-0.0610800646,
-0.0331305936,
-0.0500582978,
-0.0291526802,
0.0074967626,
0.048742611,
0.0191341601,
-0.0635583848,
0.0103721526,
0.0665312931,
-0.0362272859,
-0.0054880045,
0.0435584411,
-0.0008700968,
0.0301218759,
0.0022716117,
0.0484556332,
-0.0382914245,
-0.0217634253,
0.032152269,
-0.0195417721,
0.0212547146,
-0.0165094677,
-0.0052441028,
0.0277478863,
-0.0474381745,
-0.0070300484,
-0.0549461991,
0.0146845672,
0.007463926,
0.0676996857,
0.0320093147,
0.0110941799,
0.0212930478,
0.0543650649,
0.0388947614,
0.0724693984,
-0.0139068114,
-0.0089567443,
0.0094639389,
0.0154886516,
-0.0067762816,
0.0314593203,
-0.0560231693,
0.0261111632,
0.0152352108,
-0.0283039957,
-0.0425924994,
0.0579770915,
3.027e-7,
0.0348671377,
0.0216003489,
0.0652303621,
0.0246858429,
-0.0013392293,
0.0025456417,
0.0142824883,
0.0144247022,
0.0079207122,
0.0023242319,
0.0135620181,
0.0362754986,
0.0509782098,
-0.0077212141,
-0.0869075134,
0.0202030577,
-0.0751454756,
0.0111955386,
-0.0369517431,
-0.0304511879,
-0.0045441017,
0.1070429906,
-0.0255095046,
0.0147845466,
0.0357329063,
0.0155254519,
0.0400160775,
-0.0132944332,
0.0208335966,
0.0221732873,
0.0350019298,
0.012325584,
-0.0143815381,
-0.0231961701,
-0.0192134827,
-0.0053552333,
-0.020251099,
0.0656009391,
-0.0025796839,
-0.0562816337,
0.0170236882,
-0.0043485584,
-0.015616172,
-0.07397452,
0.0932053253,
-0.0083487676,
-0.0166859683,
-0.0257118996,
-0.0181007832,
0.013079932,
-0.0244385656,
0.0190100912,
0.0046030809,
0.0221885778,
0.0210424233,
-0.0277853161,
-0.0384628996,
-0.0778097138,
-0.0313452072,
-0.0350289866,
-0.0694970861,
-0.0502570122,
-0.0636164546,
-0.0169350673,
-0.0035239761,
-0.028722601,
-0.0029844593,
3.11291039e-34,
0.0368175656,
-0.006322348,
-0.0031263167,
-0.0060762144,
0.0161485989,
-0.0160655826,
0.0200477168,
0.0434446447,
0.0091073932,
-0.1011833027,
-0.0479996093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06255v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06255v2 | Fight Back Against Jailbreaking via Prompt Adversarial Tuning | 2024-02-09T09:09:39 | 2024-06-09T16:18:46 | Yichuan Mo, Yuji Wang, Zeming Wei, Yisen Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved tremendous success in
various applications, they are also susceptible to jailbreak attacks. Several
primary defense strategies have been proposed to protect LLMs from producing
harmful information, mostly with a particular focus on harmful content
filtering or heuristical defensive prompt designs. However, how to achieve
intrinsic robustness through the prompts remains an open problem. In this
paper, motivated by adversarial training paradigms for achieving reliable
robustness, we propose an approach named Prompt Adversarial Tuning (PAT) that
trains a prompt control attached to the user prompt as a guard prefix. To
achieve our defense goal whilst maintaining natural performance, we optimize
the control prompt with both adversarial and benign prompts. Comprehensive
experiments show that our method is effective against both black-box and
white-box attacks, reducing the success rate of advanced attacks to nearly 0
while maintaining the model's utility on the benign task. The proposed defense
strategy incurs only negligible computational overhead, charting a new
perspective for future explorations in LLM security. Our code is available at
https://github.com/rain152/PAT. | [
0.0518597774,
0.0566015132,
-0.0142807644,
0.0329076424,
-0.0209365003,
-0.0249352381,
0.0236658733,
0.0049846969,
0.0478768535,
-0.0124394242,
-0.0111011621,
-0.0355253406,
-0.0027170845,
0.0147830071,
0.052340243,
-0.0027355507,
0.0579921417,
-0.0374157056,
-0.0045179017,
0.0050185029,
0.014123003,
-0.0100084441,
0.0101596862,
0.0250321254,
-0.005570699,
0.00057093,
-0.0167335477,
0.0252919495,
0.0060049971,
-0.0390714593,
0.0266328994,
0.0393324792,
-0.0322858319,
0.0577459261,
0.0000024494,
-0.0287831463,
-0.0254379399,
0.0174133852,
-0.0269046426,
0.0644417256,
0.0019186224,
-0.0493673384,
-0.0372836739,
0.0268210769,
-0.0285723917,
0.0321951248,
0.0114547703,
0.0503802113,
0.0753486305,
0.0705131218,
0.0046937377,
0.0103629706,
0.0416186824,
-0.0371721871,
-0.0053751217,
-0.0701195672,
-0.0065158526,
-0.0609483346,
0.0057643568,
0.0343048386,
0.0012998701,
-0.0061542746,
0.0369250104,
-0.0231494065,
-0.0687364265,
0.0032669161,
-0.0094762305,
-0.0237052739,
-0.0391366333,
0.0442811772,
-0.0600533374,
-0.0218357649,
0.016024027,
-0.0062384047,
0.0326262787,
0.0172727723,
0.0040249559,
0.0085358499,
-0.0256054103,
-0.0266641863,
-0.0230611805,
-0.0341511853,
0.0517625883,
0.0135684097,
-0.0048263292,
0.0480394922,
0.0268324483,
-0.0391895436,
0.0042703315,
-0.0594125167,
0.0031587181,
-0.0631855428,
0.0158473942,
0.0055521405,
-0.0214183033,
0.0032327746,
-0.0901209339,
-0.0285174586,
0.025225196,
-0.0256504528,
-0.0155669926,
0.0337290205,
-0.0308881477,
0.0086789681,
-0.0347893909,
0.024401838,
-0.0008273963,
0.0489584357,
0.0286268964,
0.0354745686,
-0.0234327558,
-0.0122436173,
-0.0086894501,
0.0185789652,
-0.0201017633,
0.0081654005,
-0.0177053083,
0.0495342277,
0.005623206,
0.0419994518,
-0.0429524295,
-0.0015845724,
-0.0041667451,
0.0104307337,
0.0534234792,
-0.0471875258,
-0.0331210531,
-0.0236105397,
-0.0020882362,
-0.0700248033,
-0.0321651772,
-0.0091278907,
-0.0812599957,
-0.0349598974,
-0.0203697495,
0.1050055847,
0.0181458425,
0.00172275,
-0.0850127116,
-0.0715661421,
-0.0476486571,
-0.0116994465,
-0.0020081142,
-0.0483431853,
-0.021331314,
-0.0136482026,
-0.0036692237,
-0.0834981203,
0.0005313747,
0.0051973015,
-0.0202421788,
0.0574695617,
0.0246541537,
-0.0379239097,
0.0044934335,
0.0495664291,
0.0267504957,
0.0356158912,
-0.0019020189,
0.0852821097,
0.0613133758,
-0.0177136548,
0.030263802,
0.0346824601,
0.0150102004,
0.0226020589,
-0.0170763806,
-0.0143099381,
0.0787515417,
-0.029487418,
-0.0249575824,
0.0346355513,
0.0090313181,
-0.031738732,
0.1012753621,
0.0278346296,
-0.0527512543,
0.0330158658,
-0.0140011581,
-0.01573544,
-0.007879544,
-0.0046004043,
-0.0690497085,
0.0038474924,
-0.0908855349,
-0.0265578274,
-0.0256583225,
0.0109006753,
-0.0022894794,
0.0087019065,
0.0156462565,
-0.012443237,
-0.0224217828,
0.0149535267,
-0.0080146166,
0.0184065383,
-0.0163666364,
0.0442202948,
0.0207132231,
-0.0177439321,
-0.0422255248,
-0.0788086355,
0.0154786827,
0.0438656807,
0.0358965918,
-0.0110741388,
0.0396296009,
-0.0241861138,
0.0310676731,
0.008147222,
0.0285697989,
0.0241671242,
0.0295373369,
-0.0303219724,
-0.0008734185,
-0.0284334403,
0.0166078899,
0.0578576736,
-0.0110230623,
0.0026191901,
0.0153558478,
0.0204012748,
-0.0450207815,
0.035692554,
0.0127836904,
-0.0534843765,
0.0369939916,
0.0344242454,
-0.001523279,
0.0114859696,
-0.0272754021,
0.0323400497,
0.0577354915,
-0.0070382734,
0.0493766703,
-0.0257242825,
-0.0513730608,
-0.0294854213,
0.0279011913,
-0.0043082708,
0.0002963551,
0.0612727404,
-0.046834439,
-0.0281017069,
0.0630626678,
-0.0361902416,
0.0241542794,
-0.0036948377,
0.0255616363,
-0.0091713993,
0.0244089607,
-0.0502337813,
0.0137347644,
-0.0127772419,
-0.0155182146,
0.0014724068,
0.0637589693,
0.0299730245,
-0.0110149542,
-0.074631393,
0.0151845571,
-0.0474662445,
0.0225339867,
0.0262172874,
0.0172034148,
0.0003786484,
-0.0267923437,
-0.0087258136,
0.0144064482,
-0.0542369038,
0.0128746284,
0.0375010446,
0.0221358854,
-0.0323232152,
-0.0461015813,
-0.0152095975,
-0.0332421586,
-0.0103431763,
-0.003458028,
-0.0141780255,
-0.0067469217,
-0.0357305221,
-0.0294819102,
0.0002000212,
-0.0075374097,
0.0288896188,
-0.0365720615,
-0.0411793031,
-0.0023751117,
-0.0132591976,
0.0231164079,
0.0223138239,
-0.0450365208,
-0.0281578284,
0.0399500951,
0.0179841015,
-0.0018150114,
0.0622081198,
0.0279524978,
0.0114874598,
0.0600653067,
0.0389665291,
-0.0298092756,
-0.0096990457,
0.0436293185,
-0.043947801,
-0.0302639659,
-0.0435724556,
0.0558918342,
0.0566845126,
0.0494851097,
0.018383177,
-0.0404363908,
0.0212491248,
0.0073045469,
-0.026662657,
-0.049414333,
-0.0138051603,
-0.0592979975,
-0.0038531409,
-0.0468749218,
-0.0659599081,
0.0762291476,
-0.0549787618,
0.0241873879,
-0.008341508,
-0.0596135259,
0.0216541253,
0.0386411585,
-0.0124088125,
0.0143567063,
0.064022541,
-0.0376045406,
-0.041273661,
-0.0288543385,
0.0220168419,
0.0049670362,
0.0241026469,
-0.031761419,
-0.011338179,
0.0029387323,
-0.0379646942,
-0.0467833839,
-0.0770299956,
-0.0157025792,
-0.0082497718,
0.0470028445,
-0.0158159938,
0.0212149117,
-0.0249626841,
0.022337066,
0.0204460304,
-0.0310423877,
0.0048652953,
-0.0447720662,
0.0288971309,
0.0249867719,
-0.0642911792,
-0.0147048756,
-0.0229210481,
0.051222492,
0.0458232574,
0.0178711172,
0.0199198425,
0.0052169585,
0.0088540874,
0.0072274022,
-0.0049755909,
-0.0127287265,
0.0535511971,
0.043302834,
-0.0225010123,
-0.0320471115,
0.0480930135,
0.0358340777,
-0.0071036066,
0.027009232,
-0.0068940823,
0.054265663,
0.011487619,
0.0072787669,
-0.0383667089,
-0.0286048427,
0.0204777867,
0.0937964991,
0.0102515239,
-0.0003954275,
-0.0433527119,
-0.0825930014,
-0.0392877162,
0.0294951573,
-0.0187931452,
-0.0070053898,
-0.0258928686,
-0.0420082882,
0.0279300641,
0.0345815457,
-0.0006918564,
0.011299233,
0.0073929345,
0.031114582,
-0.0302001126,
-0.0199004505,
0.0152871804,
-0.0462297983,
0.0528317913,
0.1004841477,
0.0004285958,
-0.0252419524,
0.0085306466,
0.0555405989,
-0.0013031358,
0.000321457,
0.0206969064,
-0.0062614237,
0.0058755912,
-0.0011429589,
0.0177735034,
0.0541898459,
0.0002688388,
-0.0301254448,
0.0755898952,
0.0205157921,
-0.0122656943,
-0.0025603143,
-0.0151398759,
-0.0249686576,
0.0400098599,
0.0466490239,
0.0341841951,
-0.0528610796,
-0.0503699929,
-0.0953883976,
-0.0245473031,
-0.0880870894,
-0.0259904154,
0.0047525065,
0.0362191759,
-0.0053828075,
-0.0335469022,
0.0151159223,
-0.0412201099,
0.0312866047,
0.0378936194,
-0.0296022724,
-0.0460638776,
0.0059982319,
-0.0157025475,
-0.0171683151,
-0.019835081,
0.061704766,
-0.080940783,
0.0225705113,
-0.0014465761,
-0.0257061347,
-0.0127503229,
0.014088477,
-0.0535450056,
-0.0930627137,
0.0217956472,
0.0671138614,
0.0128962714,
0.0035185639,
-0.0620685443,
-0.083165668,
0.0672914609,
0.0678238273,
-0.0602188371,
0.0004376584,
0.071856305,
-0.0169893652,
-0.0017404337,
0.0212875847,
-0.0455159396,
-0.0170630664,
0.0959485248,
0.001554084,
-0.0225471687,
-0.0169805288,
0.0185459442,
0.0438191779,
0.0161863975,
-0.0301365536,
0.0002730304,
0.0287942532,
0.0291011613,
0.0179691929,
-0.0237452928,
0.024659358,
0.0322493948,
0.0186096113,
-0.0302478727,
0.0307616536,
0.0100342454,
0.0135951033,
0.0152989682,
-0.0268878713,
0.0290399846,
0.0140638743,
0.0746074766,
0.0594679974,
0.0199363343,
-0.0160835199,
0.0837804452,
0.0038120139,
0.0300440155,
-0.017223347,
0.0646762997,
-0.0048678569,
-0.0058390601,
-0.0275942944,
0.0604012236,
-0.0919896141,
-0.0254716761,
-0.0005897416,
0.0761235207,
0.0120909009,
0.0025533491,
-0.0380762443,
-0.0113636721,
0.0034013868,
-0.0355037563,
-0.0345437564,
0.0146058481,
-0.0467186272,
0.0221575368,
-0.0137261553,
-0.0046341079,
0.011529766,
0.0586599484,
0.0143164033,
0.0549439117,
0.0166333523,
-0.0177564994,
-0.0489822514,
0.007588244,
0.0537424833,
0.0305649471,
-0.0688587725,
-0.0323953554,
-0.0439280681,
-0.0666784942,
-0.0264985915,
0.0274334513,
0.055356849,
0.0077644065,
-0.0199348032,
0.0271858349,
-0.0069985418,
0.0531927347,
-0.0556748025,
0.0345649011,
0.0268660598,
-0.0524717197,
-0.015462609,
-5.97015728e-33,
0.0075920192,
-0.0060311975,
-0.0721246451,
-0.0354525037,
0.0272569824,
-0.0098725967,
-0.0394574329,
0.0167107843,
-0.029302936,
-0.048555389,
-0.0252057556,
-0.0113642849,
0.0023811511,
0.0028987222,
-0.0561608635,
-0.0370403267,
0.0250993427,
0.0067648985,
-0.0492959954,
0.0360935591,
0.0569959208,
0.04417127,
-0.0192226823,
-0.0252329856,
0.0539962053,
-0.0115228239,
-0.0302140545,
-0.0042864117,
-0.0351426527,
0.0487841815,
0.0223295614,
0.0130291255,
-0.0079745026,
-0.0273517165,
-0.0032320714,
0.0857797489,
0.0110647557,
-0.012845288,
0.0048070541,
-0.0021083942,
0.01463544,
-0.0592009723,
0.0168692879,
-0.0276097227,
-0.0113960737,
0.0180217456,
-0.0148680639,
0.0049048048,
-0.0442257077,
-0.0339354426,
-0.0075852922,
-0.007326399,
-0.0301918201,
-0.0285372417,
-0.0219674949,
-0.003924212,
-0.0082614943,
-0.0089018848,
-0.0284799822,
0.0359242745,
0.0412963107,
0.0353059284,
0.0362454504,
0.0326553658,
-0.0228138156,
0.0443489067,
0.0026116804,
-0.0217928626,
-0.0047008954,
0.0063428036,
0.0193045065,
0.0149793671,
0.0783554986,
0.064945206,
0.0441787764,
-0.0757062882,
-0.0666300356,
0.0010063555,
0.0461820439,
0.0245440826,
0.0287131947,
0.0086091748,
-0.0195255205,
-0.0017981307,
-0.0272871163,
-0.0378276855,
-0.0140596954,
-0.0401243828,
0.0457194522,
-0.0008498514,
-0.0318753831,
-0.0658698156,
0.0064722761,
-0.0575512424,
0.0070863105,
0.0419360921,
-0.0125979409,
-0.0292315669,
-0.0153753879,
0.0290687773,
-0.0109183025,
-0.0001464699,
0.015275267,
-0.0583127737,
0.0368779898,
-0.0167907383,
0.0445067286,
0.039633505,
-0.0610635951,
-0.0050980612,
-0.0248697903,
0.0437300093,
0.0262665283,
0.0229775459,
0.0065205446,
-0.0272832345,
0.0068998821,
0.0036691357,
0.0036311985,
-0.0411113352,
-0.0397230834,
0.0173305143,
-0.0198394898,
0.031684801,
-0.008819134,
0.016525235,
0.009423228,
0.0481427722,
0.0329709277,
-0.0629988983,
-0.0005594166,
-0.0306894947,
3.116e-7,
-0.0421771929,
-0.0073033036,
0.0149786323,
-0.0184517782,
0.0233852491,
0.0516125485,
-0.0360610709,
0.0914943442,
-0.0450502187,
-0.0610214882,
-0.0321243741,
-0.0243652817,
0.059597373,
0.0235215537,
-0.0540801473,
0.035654299,
-0.1076257825,
0.030423224,
-0.0633379668,
0.0073402049,
0.0338556878,
0.1080265939,
-0.017362522,
-0.0218658745,
0.0154442657,
-0.0506023169,
-0.0067169475,
0.0074640349,
0.0027504077,
-0.0077630025,
0.0454328433,
0.0054051196,
0.0115020135,
0.014398274,
-0.0527809598,
-0.0047554071,
-0.0427423865,
0.0536518842,
0.0341393389,
-0.0276121125,
-0.0305419415,
-0.0280872975,
-0.0084080929,
-0.0446002632,
0.07870619,
0.0387779213,
-0.0072514629,
-0.0231633931,
0.0347116403,
-0.0309058484,
0.012287342,
-0.0425498858,
-0.0016365114,
-0.0092281066,
0.0298187491,
0.0320531912,
0.0281009767,
-0.0596423969,
-0.0163021591,
0.0020785648,
0.0046206657,
-0.0203998126,
-0.0312007573,
0.0409225263,
0.0164454039,
-0.0229343753,
0.0231119059,
2.965102537e-34,
-0.0063954708,
-0.0441796705,
0.0156609248,
-0.0176915191,
0.0254655797,
0.0192972794,
0.0514395759,
0.016302783,
0.0389642678,
-0.0129251713,
-0.0398141928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06221v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06221v2 | ResumeFlow: An LLM-facilitated Pipeline for Personalized Resume Generation and Refinement | 2024-02-09T07:13:44 | 2024-05-08T03:09:10 | Saurabh Bhausaheb Zinjad, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Amey Bhilegaonkar, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Crafting the ideal, job-specific resume is a challenging task for many job
applicants, especially for early-career applicants. While it is highly
recommended that applicants tailor their resume to the specific role they are
applying for, manually tailoring resumes to job descriptions and role-specific
requirements is often (1) extremely time-consuming, and (2) prone to human
errors. Furthermore, performing such a tailoring step at scale while applying
to several roles may result in a lack of quality of the edited resumes. To
tackle this problem, in this demo paper, we propose ResumeFlow: a Large
Language Model (LLM) aided tool that enables an end user to simply provide
their detailed resume and the desired job posting, and obtain a personalized
resume specifically tailored to that specific job posting in the matter of a
few seconds. Our proposed pipeline leverages the language understanding and
information extraction capabilities of state-of-the-art LLMs such as OpenAI's
GPT-4 and Google's Gemini, in order to (1) extract details from a job
description, (2) extract role-specific details from the user-provided resume,
and then (3) use these to refine and generate a role-specific resume for the
user. Our easy-to-use tool leverages the user-chosen LLM in a completely
off-the-shelf manner, thus requiring no fine-tuning. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our tool via a video demo and propose novel task-specific
evaluation metrics to control for alignment and hallucination. Our tool is
available at https://job-aligned-resume.streamlit.app. | [
0.0433113463,
0.0444316268,
-0.0086424239,
-0.0284167919,
-0.0260526501,
-0.0066063977,
-0.0380333476,
0.00942255,
-0.0149804987,
-0.0048296759,
-0.004969188,
-0.0232611075,
-0.0023785417,
-0.0033977849,
-0.0017116689,
-0.0705217868,
0.0237477962,
-0.0070903366,
0.008194481,
0.0303111766,
-0.0001489556,
0.037705224,
-0.0026027965,
0.0770779774,
0.0113016618,
-0.042821385,
0.0064489106,
0.0278058443,
0.0282850713,
0.0333239324,
0.0171404891,
0.0537618101,
0.0225635897,
0.0115058674,
0.000002226,
-0.0285870153,
-0.0066780103,
0.0085194828,
-0.0148670189,
-0.0344355628,
0.077494584,
0.0232798383,
-0.0266045053,
0.019582903,
-0.0075848387,
0.0202509873,
0.0325116888,
0.0146490689,
0.0720289573,
0.0580921806,
-0.0128083406,
-0.0369684622,
-0.015887998,
-0.0224168878,
0.0465785451,
-0.0105544385,
0.0131058805,
-0.0463098101,
0.0156587809,
-0.0163128413,
0.0047963411,
0.0084019909,
-0.0403486937,
-0.0498129353,
0.0268230513,
0.0154389674,
-0.0463674255,
-0.0220295843,
0.013884047,
0.0470590778,
-0.0105706174,
0.0055245985,
-0.0088053495,
-0.0155994901,
0.0522849597,
0.0061669168,
-0.0563778318,
0.0313098654,
-0.0194945764,
-0.0173661485,
-0.0166308489,
0.0006306411,
0.0013756984,
-0.0100242654,
-0.0027732763,
0.0742235109,
-0.0102530569,
-0.0170606747,
-0.0143775577,
0.0047449712,
0.0962317288,
-0.0603130572,
0.0353285186,
0.0545849428,
-0.0522138961,
-0.0046912506,
-0.0540806279,
-0.0137265222,
0.0301657617,
-0.0180544592,
0.0162999127,
0.0171682667,
-0.0536177121,
0.0522930287,
-0.0264662709,
0.0299396701,
-0.0119913034,
-0.0115115969,
-0.0338881612,
-0.052956529,
-0.0769077912,
-0.0210488643,
-0.0352510065,
-0.0154213067,
-0.021052001,
0.013871328,
-0.0598199219,
0.0343857184,
-0.0473792404,
0.0473104939,
0.0493499115,
0.0220626444,
-0.0507397912,
-0.0090178708,
-0.0489676893,
-0.0047460706,
0.024957478,
-0.0226903372,
0.0376539081,
-0.0275696032,
0.0401651189,
0.0248427037,
0.018144032,
-0.0172616839,
0.0075860573,
0.0177766755,
0.0267064907,
0.0081754401,
-0.0323104188,
-0.0441538244,
0.0158819947,
-0.0273413993,
-0.0333815292,
-0.0674277619,
0.0306687858,
0.0041004671,
-0.0160990879,
-0.0550430603,
0.0143965613,
0.0345010534,
-0.0058284397,
0.0322935618,
-0.0207102727,
0.045122236,
0.0713380724,
-0.0063911541,
-0.021359453,
0.0447639115,
0.0302148778,
0.1132426783,
0.0233218931,
-0.0318296663,
0.0822251141,
0.0653514042,
-0.0695058405,
-0.0415364578,
-0.0288310777,
0.0360876247,
0.0152783329,
0.0343810394,
0.0556187853,
-0.0064053703,
-0.0212356988,
0.0534647219,
0.0540565848,
0.0514485873,
0.0458167717,
0.0227118637,
0.0553982668,
0.042146679,
0.0145261381,
-0.0344120599,
-0.0406211391,
0.0645773038,
0.021778632,
0.0070010615,
-0.0479669124,
0.0581545271,
-0.0293918326,
-0.006049213,
0.0171046294,
-0.0166318379,
-0.0295985397,
0.0145087773,
0.0223406851,
0.0113572013,
-0.0651260987,
0.0380177759,
-0.0002335798,
-0.0707866028,
0.0234092381,
-0.0069868662,
-0.045645386,
0.1435248852,
0.0483848676,
-0.0317865834,
-0.0310783014,
-0.047038205,
-0.0050374046,
0.0456427373,
0.0872230977,
-0.0104415407,
-0.0053861821,
-0.0534397401,
-0.034896452,
0.0067878342,
-0.009271116,
0.0092326356,
0.045279298,
0.0191893708,
0.0269632768,
-0.0339294672,
-0.0408411473,
0.018066939,
-0.0116020851,
-0.0473294556,
0.037522383,
0.0298501495,
-0.0242673978,
0.0032380808,
-0.0062179044,
0.0160886887,
0.0146743888,
-0.0163060296,
0.0042958865,
0.0242828671,
0.0091352686,
0.0493406355,
-0.0057313791,
0.0192428976,
-0.0534018278,
0.0135648008,
-0.0621449985,
-0.0297190528,
-0.0427471809,
0.0138163632,
0.0110861249,
-0.0355607606,
0.0204247404,
-0.0068388283,
0.0114989216,
-0.0428843871,
0.0601487085,
0.0511957221,
-0.0273963939,
0.0004402254,
-0.0218943693,
-0.0214458723,
-0.1225231662,
-0.0169824567,
-0.0111979768,
0.0029465975,
0.0142697003,
-0.0051601366,
-0.0314392038,
-0.0546258502,
-0.0426105969,
-0.0833615735,
0.0178190377,
0.0177131705,
0.0104504703,
0.0131401038,
0.0281116907,
-0.0293674115,
-0.0329873562,
-0.0526643917,
0.0047927462,
0.0165022835,
-0.0282445494,
0.0420849584,
-0.0250486229,
-0.0263960566,
-0.0500693917,
-0.0024905107,
-0.0197478961,
-0.0091496855,
0.0106414165,
-0.0221647564,
-0.0709359124,
-0.0206043422,
-0.0261531509,
0.0144058205,
0.0457007252,
0.0102352276,
-0.0168378707,
-0.0059878654,
0.0239500068,
0.0822274312,
0.0088948654,
0.0331526101,
0.0484432131,
0.0088140788,
0.0080188401,
0.0076326374,
-0.0011285868,
0.029319765,
-0.027105175,
-0.0312827118,
-0.0076997099,
-0.027320832,
0.0097893206,
0.0006636467,
-0.0306545217,
-0.0093204267,
-0.0119126597,
0.0281045195,
-0.0195429381,
0.0299603716,
-0.0329238437,
0.0290066935,
-0.0251532774,
-0.0223046206,
0.0170968901,
-0.0143485488,
0.0202854108,
0.0224337466,
-0.0600644536,
-0.047350999,
0.0788100064,
-0.0173937175,
0.0180543847,
-0.0508547463,
-0.0382962078,
-0.0396691412,
-0.0260647833,
0.0024017536,
-0.059632007,
-0.0264854226,
-0.0323552378,
-0.0127657158,
-0.0189707484,
-0.018070085,
-0.061148975,
-0.0024143532,
-0.0183128733,
0.0291620269,
0.0166129004,
-0.001168716,
-0.0900426209,
-0.0260917433,
0.0090901712,
0.0657194853,
-0.0142930644,
-0.0226624161,
-0.0131761525,
0.0106352335,
0.0689242855,
0.0241806451,
-0.0317754187,
-0.0075073657,
-0.0044031064,
0.0374787487,
0.0072528315,
0.0216929708,
-0.0154238874,
-0.041070275,
0.0317143649,
-0.1129774898,
-0.0033419139,
0.0224759746,
0.0220884141,
-0.0536284894,
0.0059156879,
0.0932057053,
0.0175584126,
-0.0659468397,
-0.0069250693,
0.0049712178,
-0.0314193815,
0.0456857234,
0.0747509077,
-0.042291034,
0.004957926,
0.0031820151,
0.024523465,
0.0136533575,
-0.0043948153,
-0.0247291531,
-0.0513302833,
0.1050965562,
0.006962433,
-0.0364052616,
0.0030852081,
-0.0307051521,
0.0050966158,
-0.004488227,
-0.0245178454,
0.0002598445,
-0.0152895339,
-0.0116993161,
0.0169777237,
-0.0407979749,
-0.0513077825,
0.0268589184,
-0.0460419208,
0.0207340643,
0.0500364974,
0.0538670495,
0.0131439669,
-0.0204519555,
-0.0176426582,
0.0431235358,
0.0360369347,
0.0307678431,
0.025175374,
-0.0119808121,
0.0010149525,
-0.0336332358,
-0.011314285,
-0.0430854931,
-0.0110253766,
0.0653682277,
0.0743955225,
-0.033935722,
0.0151311876,
-0.0451336466,
-0.0565363802,
0.0061740302,
0.0804712996,
-0.0123351663,
-0.1030453816,
-0.0128978463,
-0.0431295596,
0.0115542104,
-0.0417929403,
-0.0229619034,
0.0248686541,
-0.0160219949,
0.013015056,
-0.0344556011,
-0.0375506021,
0.0466451496,
0.0215018988,
0.0291474089,
0.0333433263,
-0.0120594306,
-0.0102566276,
-0.079237774,
-0.0066273119,
-0.0493469946,
0.067402944,
-0.0495114475,
-0.0370230563,
-0.0490617938,
-0.0569169186,
-0.0293612666,
0.0052712802,
-0.0767649785,
0.0094131762,
-0.0154113621,
0.0093691461,
0.0256029442,
0.011290675,
-0.0021400664,
-0.062803939,
0.0182288121,
0.04024259,
-0.0052904258,
-0.0130076446,
-0.054761745,
-0.0108529693,
-0.01855902,
0.0138009004,
-0.0760394707,
-0.0103161382,
0.0233990327,
-0.0314743035,
0.0633921996,
-0.0417625941,
-0.0037971591,
0.0257793479,
-0.0065014772,
-0.0051392103,
-0.0186293032,
-0.0350304134,
-0.0000054205,
-0.0158387814,
-0.016925063,
-0.009514641,
-0.0179112684,
0.0728471726,
-0.0165445413,
0.0498846211,
-0.0029526765,
-0.0171628483,
-0.0017388562,
-0.0814473629,
0.0004362938,
-0.0742482319,
0.0339609571,
0.0252142604,
-0.0133586554,
-0.0267460402,
0.0119837774,
0.0012920089,
0.0301823802,
-0.0079236897,
0.0270102248,
-0.0244028512,
0.0430724695,
-0.0080929333,
0.0404475816,
-0.0318082012,
-0.0597113147,
0.0002461502,
0.0468385555,
0.0438407399,
-0.0550336726,
0.0425754637,
-0.0352333412,
0.0074568307,
-0.0222600419,
0.0045076488,
0.0446137413,
-0.0302652717,
-0.0343025476,
0.0010618762,
-0.0087123094,
-0.0406615883,
0.0525361449,
0.0040564928,
0.0022381637,
-0.0426150039,
-0.0296351518,
-0.0527119413,
-0.0090000452,
0.0354767404,
0.0403029546,
-0.0436718985,
-0.0099174948,
-0.0556143373,
-0.0323351324,
0.030765418,
-0.001848234,
-0.0286762305,
-0.0036031066,
0.0136894668,
0.0495539717,
-0.0274975356,
-0.0472682379,
-0.051305104,
0.0051736706,
-0.0077308826,
-0.0020496198,
-0.0252426006,
-5.727727365e-33,
-0.0161768254,
-0.0377949476,
0.0332040079,
0.0412401855,
0.0233210195,
-0.0195830986,
0.0181128103,
-0.0176449232,
0.0254447199,
-0.0286903698,
-0.0343935974,
-0.0055645253,
0.0349288024,
0.0341338553,
0.037676923,
0.0566497184,
0.0566651337,
0.0347626917,
-0.0204512309,
0.0190860424,
-0.0077843876,
0.0333771147,
0.0703495145,
-0.0735585764,
0.0309352521,
-0.025895983,
-0.0324998461,
0.0111688292,
0.0183599684,
0.0640572533,
0.0062006721,
0.0058930605,
0.0117198331,
-0.0438812338,
0.0122038722,
-0.0067713885,
-0.058056213,
-0.0143762473,
0.0208155625,
0.0457385443,
0.00286509,
-0.0554206856,
0.0253203865,
-0.032036785,
-0.0123344641,
-0.0027396781,
0.0750686452,
-0.0193592273,
0.0132337026,
0.0105094286,
-0.0365629978,
0.0081254495,
-0.0014724222,
0.002073355,
0.0245879944,
-0.0067122551,
0.0009355139,
0.0497311242,
-0.1347031295,
0.0138770584,
-0.0597866103,
0.0223897994,
0.0426344946,
0.0251624156,
-0.0220520105,
0.0553583056,
0.0625933111,
0.0408244357,
0.0102103902,
-0.0058516217,
-0.0239765886,
0.0564894378,
-0.0189516284,
0.0098339468,
0.043064598,
-0.0483061559,
-0.0003392275,
0.0556868725,
0.0008053163,
0.017496895,
0.0188815035,
0.0288892668,
0.0192990508,
0.0167273562,
0.0098841432,
-0.0353533439,
-0.0298624225,
0.0163322054,
0.0505865999,
0.0017621388,
0.0189667735,
0.0076863538,
-0.0222588573,
-0.0305750519,
0.0050936732,
0.0039460198,
-0.0558108985,
0.0180253405,
-0.0001554162,
-0.0228701849,
-0.0147156781,
-0.0254788809,
-0.0021268746,
-0.0258676857,
0.0307506751,
0.0709038526,
0.0202930514,
0.0137999542,
-0.0662053674,
-0.0005125168,
-0.0070792092,
0.0189279988,
-0.0216237698,
0.0035923121,
0.0371293314,
0.0041171759,
-0.0038010133,
0.0251845699,
0.0372219197,
0.0093923295,
-0.0046992442,
-0.0720565915,
0.0509184115,
0.0152026312,
-0.0063420008,
-0.0014167002,
-0.0088015869,
-0.006247099,
0.0285043195,
-0.0195677355,
-0.0084954044,
0.0158931911,
2.787e-7,
0.0452049598,
0.0285868123,
-0.011348539,
0.0236947387,
0.0424761139,
-0.0140942037,
-0.0177317746,
0.0102907522,
0.0157054178,
0.0334481858,
0.0030031241,
0.0245955363,
0.0436049029,
-0.0079911603,
-0.1151949689,
-0.0169398505,
0.003796451,
-0.0057194247,
-0.080405049,
0.0492535867,
0.0841066092,
0.0527754351,
0.0561417155,
-0.0200327095,
0.0039319256,
-0.0074109873,
0.0507772528,
-0.0082897032,
0.0150363185,
0.0547933467,
0.0574241392,
-0.0087738018,
-0.0234814789,
0.0249500349,
-0.0190938264,
-0.0202378295,
0.0371769518,
0.1006636918,
-0.061542172,
0.0605682433,
0.0208871197,
0.0198349655,
-0.0096921735,
-0.0648297966,
0.0177853424,
0.0119060483,
0.0061907908,
-0.0253666323,
-0.0482670367,
0.0228235088,
0.0205267724,
0.0378520153,
-0.0083264997,
-0.0043143909,
0.0370500535,
-0.0094472673,
-0.0894151628,
-0.0238686781,
-0.0071209865,
-0.0111050326,
-0.0451904945,
-0.0112195071,
-0.0216883738,
-0.0126701593,
0.025271792,
-0.0396166109,
0.0012002398,
2.466756069e-34,
0.0075142612,
0.0482396036,
0.0149857802,
-0.0142372195,
0.043607939,
0.0027052169,
0.035403654,
0.0579194278,
-0.0345467776,
-0.0327888429,
-0.0287315845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06220v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06220v1 | A Unified Causal View of Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-09T07:12:56 | 2024-02-09T07:12:56 | Lu Chen, Wei Huang, Ruqing Zhang, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning on a mixture of tasks has improved zero-shot capabilities
in natural language processing (NLP). Nevertheless, existing methods often
learn features that exhibit correlations between instruction-formatted samples
and target labels, rather than causal relationships. Termed as ``spurious
correlation'' in statistics, such a correlation may change drastically in a new
task, making the effect from the learned features to be misleading. To this
end, we develop a meta Structural Causal Model (meta-SCM) to integrate
different NLP tasks under a single causal structure of the data. Specifically,
the meta-SCM introduces multiple latent factors that represent properties of
source context, only some of which causally influence the target labels for a
specific task. The key idea is to learn task-required causal factors and only
use those to make predictions for a given task. Theoretically, we prove the
causal factor can be identified without mixing information from others. Guided
by the identifiability, we propose a Structural Instruction Tuning (SIT) method
to learn the task-required causal representations that can mimic the causal
factors for each task. The utility of our approach is verified by improvements
of zero-shot ability on a range of unseen datasets and tasks. | [
0.021139469,
0.0215855483,
-0.0166897476,
-0.0002584333,
-0.0224333629,
0.0350580141,
0.0299909934,
-0.0261193607,
-0.0284998678,
-0.0901732296,
-0.0220538918,
0.0240003821,
-0.0081894239,
0.0136146089,
0.0222757012,
-0.0223190989,
0.0499989726,
0.0030967889,
0.0082581565,
0.0232531298,
-0.0056021949,
-0.0098129185,
-0.0277226437,
0.0203416459,
-0.0122521212,
0.0049087736,
0.0045938315,
0.0081164865,
-0.0198311694,
-0.0090548182,
0.0180252586,
0.0707939714,
0.0271238908,
-0.007916321,
0.000002022,
-0.0220939107,
-0.014141324,
-0.0264181085,
-0.0397510007,
-0.0576406121,
0.0036476762,
-0.0334277265,
0.013797923,
0.0125846872,
-0.0072708488,
-0.0169757009,
0.0647004321,
0.0652400702,
0.0070003872,
0.1012170911,
-0.007665243,
-0.0493418761,
-0.0106082382,
0.0012582649,
0.085662879,
0.0132360272,
0.0071171536,
-0.0299213398,
-0.0191729479,
0.0440975353,
-0.0489135161,
-0.0046392507,
0.0016254791,
0.0197273027,
0.0651220307,
-0.0012237238,
-0.024976261,
-0.0232361089,
-0.0178849399,
0.08841566,
0.0201465841,
-0.0338908806,
0.0093698995,
-0.0155243436,
-0.0084521277,
0.0361893326,
-0.0379372574,
0.0155631686,
0.024976993,
0.0081283962,
0.0561183281,
0.0076675569,
0.016187299,
0.017677119,
-0.00297134,
0.0620732233,
0.0053634816,
-0.0413920358,
-0.0087804636,
0.0346627086,
-0.0098619685,
-0.0249372721,
-0.0511098579,
0.0154638458,
-0.0496976599,
0.043598339,
-0.0245846715,
-0.0464747883,
-0.0007863214,
-0.03377508,
0.042562142,
0.0507597439,
-0.0240323562,
0.0496654436,
-0.0391120203,
0.0501955524,
0.0099823847,
0.0459108986,
-0.0259038806,
0.0262119453,
-0.1096238941,
-0.0046016206,
0.0035767031,
0.0321468487,
-0.0324428342,
-0.0004565267,
-0.0373104624,
0.0220001694,
-0.0218342245,
-0.0343102738,
0.0225948039,
0.0180459712,
-0.0511702001,
0.0157669224,
-0.003736075,
0.0400579795,
-0.0495060459,
0.0643022507,
-0.0478533208,
-0.0135951778,
-0.0349538289,
0.0376321934,
0.0476823188,
-0.0272030607,
0.0096665509,
0.0582921878,
0.011840432,
-0.04548233,
-0.0621962138,
-0.0514088422,
0.009533585,
-0.0531558394,
0.0516624153,
-0.0114908488,
0.0040766154,
-0.0009592628,
-0.0049507935,
-0.0061718849,
-0.001547154,
0.0092520136,
-0.0686894879,
0.0784151107,
0.0383890271,
-0.0204976927,
-0.042615585,
-0.0128993336,
0.0225532837,
0.0777591914,
0.0070772888,
-0.008042424,
0.0136347702,
0.0027080462,
-0.0005381787,
-0.0143446317,
0.0298687965,
0.0106254984,
-0.0034052248,
-0.0465702936,
0.0167208649,
-0.0354126506,
0.0134537583,
-0.0356759168,
-0.0160757378,
0.0313733704,
0.0152719235,
0.000989491,
0.0193643663,
-0.0461614095,
0.0731597245,
0.000120956,
-0.0306968316,
0.0469728149,
-0.0763329342,
0.0256357864,
-0.0548275337,
-0.0072615384,
0.0015334096,
-0.0370639339,
-0.0365478955,
-0.0226605181,
0.0021001042,
-0.0236748625,
-0.0131741054,
-0.0196037516,
0.0630478859,
0.0267230477,
-0.0540713407,
-0.0013151793,
0.0346376039,
-0.0136499368,
0.0144309644,
0.0053269328,
-0.0096650431,
0.0499336794,
0.0249590706,
-0.0452765524,
-0.0355806127,
-0.0295385122,
0.0404413417,
0.028732121,
-0.014602486,
-0.0308634043,
0.0195901357,
-0.040036045,
-0.0636522099,
-0.0130045377,
0.0533039197,
-0.0055023241,
0.0005037755,
-0.0394779146,
0.0078626387,
0.0098298108,
-0.0020580129,
0.044734925,
-0.0128924241,
-0.0883032978,
0.0002358288,
0.0406430587,
0.0299435593,
0.0274099447,
-0.0048632463,
0.0042218724,
-0.0004702981,
-0.0287286397,
-0.0267308131,
0.0289383139,
-0.0461147428,
-0.0425487719,
-0.0086251758,
-0.0569563247,
0.0044381563,
-0.0038819246,
-0.0530253164,
-0.0821503922,
0.0717130005,
0.0000457933,
0.0120806713,
0.0133188013,
0.0074249282,
0.0025079672,
-0.0139411986,
-0.033155866,
0.0669427961,
0.0223214794,
0.0176252238,
0.0338766277,
-0.0231284294,
0.0020484903,
0.0051736692,
0.0133403772,
-0.0201464985,
0.004751116,
-0.0093613276,
0.0456109829,
-0.0088465977,
-0.0662084147,
-0.0140878847,
-0.0623649247,
0.0254667904,
-0.0354511924,
0.0128600774,
0.0542139709,
-0.0031974849,
0.017114399,
-0.0199067816,
-0.0052374508,
-0.0189397689,
-0.0111607173,
0.0246362612,
0.0137586873,
-0.0096094646,
-0.0101849427,
-0.0356327668,
-0.0048767738,
-0.0614493303,
0.0154798189,
0.0412380733,
-0.027006777,
-0.0119279325,
0.0134571372,
0.0267383158,
0.0103947595,
0.0049721156,
-0.0235619508,
-0.0196277443,
-0.0160622522,
0.0105220573,
0.0671180338,
-0.0382060297,
0.0241591018,
0.0312840194,
-0.0121574383,
-0.0463948324,
0.0057926928,
-0.0595334843,
0.0157877859,
-0.0121651348,
-0.024541311,
-0.0171393827,
0.098016791,
0.015858151,
-0.0108693475,
-0.0767652467,
0.0015581197,
-0.0208539013,
-0.0250341427,
-0.0164281372,
0.0049027139,
0.0041590314,
-0.0114261219,
-0.0446393266,
-0.0601639934,
0.0566332303,
0.0243905541,
0.0151392072,
-0.0506057367,
0.0172755886,
-0.0490863994,
0.0189334527,
0.027467018,
-0.0076794187,
0.0505449213,
-0.0223510806,
-0.0543338023,
0.0082436744,
0.062051408,
0.0329614654,
-0.0043383124,
-0.0575400628,
0.0139805274,
-0.006016863,
-0.0189441852,
-0.0354818627,
-0.0400773063,
0.0087362975,
0.0385882482,
0.0175310466,
-0.0010176367,
-0.0728910342,
-0.0513814948,
0.0344943032,
0.0333611779,
-0.0127693582,
0.0034351293,
-0.0398647599,
-0.0221763793,
0.0231312029,
-0.0291969702,
-0.0287235864,
-0.016737029,
-0.0044102715,
-0.0157840941,
0.0237868372,
-0.0022321567,
-0.0011801077,
0.0453396104,
0.015721526,
-0.052003596,
-0.0204870682,
0.0224856753,
0.0262548849,
-0.0504624546,
0.0129608931,
0.1039724424,
0.0508725457,
-0.0149404202,
-0.0028378968,
0.0344343483,
-0.0162226297,
0.0541081727,
0.0134497266,
-0.0818749145,
-0.0614812784,
-0.0234123152,
0.0062032714,
-0.0359466933,
-0.0320578963,
-0.0192498751,
-0.0818040445,
0.0066489377,
0.0065319859,
-0.025073342,
0.0090341391,
-0.0593848377,
0.0075144158,
-0.0491697639,
-0.0280181039,
-0.0430996679,
-0.0407895185,
0.0186634902,
0.0466909185,
0.020729294,
-0.0852524564,
0.0004592868,
-0.0069932332,
0.0795104206,
0.0554067902,
-0.0065125073,
-0.0084719453,
0.0132012982,
0.0216769874,
0.0004991746,
0.0272328686,
-0.038596034,
0.0863763168,
-0.0229801312,
0.0116661694,
-0.005624786,
0.0478191786,
-0.0561225004,
-0.0128699141,
-0.0132281743,
0.0778343305,
-0.0068753287,
0.0226129573,
-0.0091224117,
-0.0300311036,
0.0149151729,
0.0694767088,
0.0124049019,
-0.0263194703,
-0.0443533137,
-0.0111316452,
-0.0435269512,
-0.0656618774,
-0.0165320318,
0.0069921925,
-0.0252896417,
-0.0361787342,
-0.0645761713,
-0.0617513545,
0.061999321,
-0.0023088867,
0.031690225,
0.0211632922,
0.0047347746,
-0.0424829014,
-0.0449636914,
0.014882165,
-0.0313986875,
0.0116360113,
-0.0570047833,
-0.0401551649,
0.0428414345,
-0.0301359631,
0.0142044844,
-0.0286620744,
-0.0463262945,
-0.067066513,
-0.0094868923,
0.0541100539,
0.0113843549,
0.0448093228,
-0.019331567,
-0.0617864169,
0.0114348633,
0.0131009594,
-0.0449214913,
0.0077263792,
0.0534165949,
-0.0332995392,
0.0011833612,
0.0285275374,
-0.0152581595,
0.0497439913,
0.0306108501,
0.0371355042,
-0.0121370917,
0.0753488168,
0.0467816107,
-0.0065843612,
0.0754743516,
-0.0211381502,
0.0170941111,
-0.0535647236,
-0.017284587,
-0.0199119374,
-0.0223891456,
-0.01496231,
0.0220833067,
0.01831338,
0.0035379634,
-0.0117802052,
0.0131784622,
-0.0705714524,
0.0498435833,
-0.0268246122,
0.0638216883,
0.0173545741,
0.0053879065,
-0.0240438227,
0.0441316515,
0.0029952747,
0.0477041639,
0.0315407254,
0.0367221013,
-0.0097796451,
0.0508870371,
0.0211897884,
0.0433152318,
-0.0485478006,
-0.0191648137,
-0.0792659894,
0.0605345108,
-0.0005720761,
-0.0024779218,
0.0579185151,
-0.0550691411,
0.0291704573,
0.0064781159,
-0.0004962116,
-0.0003541904,
0.0644474402,
0.0252232142,
-0.0125250602,
0.0100252461,
0.0366634354,
-0.0044583124,
0.002542004,
0.0935808197,
0.0247228574,
0.0672885999,
-0.0392935202,
0.0125146722,
-0.0175616797,
-0.0038613528,
0.0188240279,
0.0481465161,
-0.0172293857,
0.0626606196,
-0.0546751432,
-0.0468825772,
-0.0047546658,
-0.0411907062,
0.0490113236,
0.0018478225,
0.0381685644,
-0.0118236626,
-0.0316446573,
-0.0262061357,
-0.0458584838,
-0.0242716502,
0.0241267364,
-0.0140978657,
-0.0226468984,
-6.743099917e-33,
-0.0285405889,
-0.0284476578,
0.0113634123,
0.0143035483,
0.0411209054,
0.0348198637,
-0.0237468351,
0.0003820045,
-0.0177584998,
0.0164181795,
0.0000455802,
0.0094222603,
0.0243476126,
0.01197109,
0.044431407,
-0.0241877232,
0.0453855656,
-0.0090762526,
-0.0170722287,
0.0050882041,
0.0560243055,
0.0031706826,
0.0670922995,
-0.0637601987,
0.0526745096,
0.0101592923,
-0.0035594439,
0.0182586722,
0.0231677182,
0.0606702007,
0.0238013808,
0.0406515785,
0.0580061376,
-0.0671558678,
-0.0036151945,
0.0235193111,
-0.0772450715,
-0.0723424628,
0.0549502559,
0.0071999263,
-0.0572454222,
-0.054677207,
0.0037871085,
-0.0137699721,
0.0030696576,
-0.0312518179,
0.0601477996,
-0.0109883528,
-0.0049275262,
-0.0142518766,
-0.1138470843,
0.0159727409,
-0.0201409012,
-0.0147490874,
0.038142357,
0.0734608769,
0.008573385,
0.0006308036,
-0.0216041673,
0.0346450508,
-0.006647707,
0.0485317744,
0.0385208763,
0.0639675632,
-0.0180373937,
0.0399430618,
0.002083472,
0.0106747476,
-0.0486553237,
-0.0101132132,
0.0121750757,
0.029333856,
0.0176223647,
0.0097938804,
0.0579160675,
0.0246021356,
-0.0721848533,
-0.0077332803,
0.0288732015,
0.028369844,
-0.0175729524,
0.0036052794,
-0.0388747491,
-0.0238685105,
-0.0638075322,
-0.0034625612,
-0.049396053,
-0.011613843,
0.0418765657,
0.051513616,
-0.015283525,
-0.007817788,
0.0339256413,
-0.0559606999,
0.0210360065,
0.0219820514,
-0.0039412966,
0.0185322892,
-0.0042831171,
-0.0235992279,
-0.0917041004,
-0.027543528,
0.0485161096,
0.0144152194,
0.0469456054,
0.0068800058,
0.0860385001,
0.0016914706,
-0.0227264855,
-0.0304869879,
-0.0222457722,
-0.0283631217,
-0.0006162925,
-0.0013007531,
0.0385015793,
0.0758431703,
-0.0351008065,
0.0438779555,
0.0466898717,
0.0033879282,
0.0125627387,
-0.0215040427,
-0.0213757642,
0.0297263172,
-0.0311981551,
-0.0061090551,
0.0000219963,
-0.0168083347,
0.0165977404,
-0.0604203828,
-0.017116867,
0.0078693209,
2.818e-7,
0.0254071485,
0.0671595186,
-0.0060013863,
-0.0042854981,
0.0099867722,
0.0281210132,
-0.0004010001,
0.0154278139,
0.0016433836,
-0.021787826,
0.0140860649,
0.0207945909,
0.0324725471,
-0.0315486081,
-0.0662316084,
-0.0031740926,
0.0203235075,
0.0080422424,
-0.0200049132,
0.0109964591,
0.0692435056,
0.052759409,
0.0101265069,
0.0217825808,
-0.0144510837,
0.0236812681,
0.0386721827,
0.0243308637,
0.0003781965,
-0.0081857806,
-0.0410007425,
0.0042796968,
-0.0246868245,
0.063834168,
-0.0633359551,
0.0131168393,
-0.0235168375,
0.057937026,
-0.0350028835,
-0.0122792814,
-0.0149354497,
-0.0184368286,
-0.0004514724,
0.0530723557,
0.0716327205,
-0.0562814437,
-0.0448801816,
0.0437888354,
-0.0338013358,
0.0708273873,
0.0043667434,
0.0359750055,
-0.030128004,
0.0083938278,
0.0227100644,
0.0104280338,
-0.0298176669,
-0.0718428195,
-0.0223455913,
0.0131972656,
0.0165675208,
-0.0130000655,
0.0184548143,
-0.0187941305,
0.0361863263,
-0.0553957373,
-0.0119855367,
2.727669208e-34,
0.0072990214,
0.0050977538,
0.0644879714,
-0.0182962734,
-0.0013316078,
-0.0188725721,
-0.1168493256,
0.0211083572,
0.0590883307,
-0.0865224227,
-0.008425951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06204v1 | The Generative AI Paradox on Evaluation: What It Can Solve, It May Not Evaluate | 2024-02-09T06:16:08 | 2024-02-09T06:16:08 | Juhyun Oh, Eunsu Kim, Inha Cha, Alice Oh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the assumption that Large Language Models (LLMs) skilled
in generation tasks are equally adept as evaluators. We assess the performance
of three LLMs and one open-source LM in Question-Answering (QA) and evaluation
tasks using the TriviaQA (Joshi et al., 2017) dataset. Results indicate a
significant disparity, with LLMs exhibiting lower performance in evaluation
tasks compared to generation tasks. Intriguingly, we discover instances of
unfaithful evaluation where models accurately evaluate answers in areas where
they lack competence, underscoring the need to examine the faithfulness and
trustworthiness of LLMs as evaluators. This study contributes to the
understanding of "the Generative AI Paradox" (West et al., 2023), highlighting
a need to explore the correlation between generative excellence and evaluation
proficiency, and the necessity to scrutinize the faithfulness aspect in model
evaluations. | [
0.0492019951,
0.0855859146,
-0.0165038444,
0.025101915,
-0.0335680172,
0.0219998397,
0.0101912804,
-0.0067346352,
-0.0044910898,
-0.0283004474,
-0.0516263023,
-0.0378187075,
0.0028447027,
0.0114651015,
0.0270901229,
0.0124961529,
0.0134859895,
-0.0322013833,
0.0212201402,
-0.0308217891,
-0.0223248415,
-0.0094563765,
0.0039978889,
0.0371651649,
0.0077810292,
-0.0133854738,
0.0162442978,
-0.0415831842,
0.0052710897,
0.000661304,
-0.011112106,
0.0434921235,
-0.0228901822,
0.0437424369,
0.0000018268,
-0.0510907434,
0.0280996282,
-0.0115006659,
-0.0504706651,
0.0330801643,
0.0094767855,
0.0335914269,
0.0151697351,
0.0115844635,
-0.0731748492,
-0.0093312589,
0.0110698966,
-0.0038510922,
0.0565175675,
0.0380620658,
0.0330058336,
0.0002597382,
0.0248875972,
-0.0372741371,
0.0176754873,
-0.0627887845,
-0.0078117782,
0.0311843436,
-0.0231450442,
0.0212449003,
-0.0382975265,
0.0386966914,
0.0452761911,
-0.012849614,
0.0417866968,
0.0496608838,
-0.0245690886,
-0.0044608018,
-0.0152045405,
0.0565541349,
0.0294907447,
0.0002188914,
-0.0287375078,
-0.0056764726,
0.0224731304,
-0.0009569781,
-0.0362589583,
0.042913001,
-0.0103139486,
0.0017959399,
0.01980187,
0.0112322625,
0.0250441805,
0.0164075885,
0.0095455488,
0.0795685649,
0.0055487067,
-0.0470303372,
-0.0157446675,
0.034333095,
-0.0336759686,
-0.080848299,
-0.0350134447,
0.0393491685,
-0.0380891785,
0.0293118544,
-0.0118624559,
-0.0029537089,
0.029045606,
0.0118444236,
0.0453115031,
0.0090669682,
0.007277899,
0.0313164815,
-0.0181775857,
0.1091733351,
0.0012541455,
0.0452069677,
-0.0539204516,
-0.017675912,
-0.0492314994,
-0.0430130139,
0.0060814992,
0.0396954194,
-0.0029478108,
-0.0055273091,
-0.0363450795,
0.0091472557,
-0.0476999991,
0.0125418641,
0.017806707,
0.0549746752,
-0.0068759089,
0.0051750061,
-0.0931329951,
0.0084477933,
-0.0492594689,
0.0437692851,
0.0200942233,
-0.0796827078,
-0.0215334035,
0.0242193639,
-0.0079992758,
-0.0001868365,
0.0250291061,
0.0662484914,
-0.0004532413,
-0.0143089537,
0.0133541729,
-0.0273129474,
-0.035320539,
-0.083089821,
0.0015268327,
-0.0468861386,
0.0378839858,
0.020000089,
-0.0162375867,
-0.0457252339,
-0.0030641088,
0.0187024456,
-0.0183936376,
0.0306736212,
0.0099678002,
0.0378449745,
0.0116428798,
0.028058039,
-0.0131049324,
0.0349140614,
0.0437380709,
0.0177847743,
0.0155464299,
0.001751435,
0.0690766722,
0.0121396296,
0.0248454269,
-0.0033335797,
0.0179597978,
0.0455247313,
-0.0214088354,
0.0374976099,
0.0461907573,
0.084887445,
-0.0114414031,
-0.0032811037,
0.0608865693,
0.0302244276,
-0.0024942961,
0.036005687,
0.0755160078,
-0.019741917,
0.0109949131,
0.0424886942,
-0.042374406,
0.0334912203,
-0.0059298589,
-0.0071407091,
0.0219395272,
-0.0057004839,
-0.0290411953,
-0.082282871,
0.0039437292,
0.0144869993,
-0.023939332,
0.0359933414,
0.0076348614,
0.0248078145,
-0.0304060131,
-0.0076535591,
-0.0261793956,
-0.0524289608,
0.0225500744,
-0.1057872772,
0.080484286,
0.0591700003,
0.0698209926,
0.0288139842,
-0.0243960395,
0.0076057795,
-0.0265416168,
0.0135910232,
0.0479161032,
-0.0338709392,
-0.0058837589,
-0.0149373561,
-0.0289012473,
-0.0792705193,
0.0190679543,
0.0082611758,
0.0261082202,
0.0197298732,
0.0105546704,
-0.0673666373,
-0.0355283692,
0.0250474624,
-0.0389764681,
-0.0519379899,
-0.0018680411,
-0.0171054937,
0.010200616,
-0.0013367387,
-0.0247456059,
0.0478060879,
0.0204419978,
-0.026764039,
-0.0524440296,
0.0035737732,
-0.0410096236,
0.0035769355,
0.0030325002,
-0.035530407,
-0.0054988759,
0.0392251536,
-0.0424309,
-0.0365777388,
0.0157759879,
-0.038654644,
0.0101119801,
-0.0432892032,
-0.0003068171,
-0.0323718861,
0.0104962699,
-0.0236189049,
0.0854835138,
-0.0272329468,
0.0356145427,
0.0060853455,
0.053268712,
0.0061759227,
-0.031875886,
0.000439512,
-0.0134924483,
0.0267582424,
0.0249298085,
0.0136744343,
0.008240601,
-0.0471547581,
-0.0443366989,
-0.0816551521,
0.0071375263,
-0.0274374131,
0.0348320752,
0.0255727377,
-0.0429838598,
0.0117785037,
0.0168025773,
-0.0668393001,
-0.0148892459,
0.0805979744,
0.0145556424,
0.0329231694,
0.0106809856,
0.0133237168,
-0.0223432891,
0.0211172942,
-0.0015593502,
0.0264874455,
0.0343801752,
0.0789413303,
-0.048805505,
0.025710037,
-0.0740901083,
-0.0048823524,
0.0132176066,
-0.0193798933,
0.0168394931,
0.0171420425,
0.0237067007,
0.0318445116,
-0.0014287831,
0.0134594655,
0.0514915548,
0.0153730344,
-0.058189787,
-0.0001185025,
0.005388278,
-0.0430895314,
-0.0048792544,
-0.0527930707,
0.006864374,
0.0401840024,
0.0408420376,
0.0017918684,
-0.0290636569,
0.070008494,
-0.0391608439,
-0.0676990598,
-0.0192501806,
-0.0139301242,
-0.0129659101,
0.0586586446,
-0.0249382742,
-0.0664974526,
0.0795848295,
-0.0207242239,
-0.0079774894,
-0.026910048,
0.0066727349,
-0.0341767147,
0.079290539,
-0.0158398785,
0.0145405233,
0.0024039093,
0.0102310227,
-0.0526513979,
0.0129155358,
-0.0065552033,
-0.0577697568,
0.0262596402,
-0.0335713774,
-0.0110113267,
0.00684244,
-0.0548481978,
-0.0640928075,
-0.0315344259,
-0.0111997295,
0.0221611429,
0.0254131276,
-0.0005638964,
0.0077266516,
-0.0341632105,
0.0236407258,
-0.035870932,
-0.0346747823,
-0.0283684134,
-0.0012954678,
0.0592757687,
0.0768166035,
0.0319800079,
0.055110652,
-0.0279464796,
0.0243756343,
0.0345743671,
0.0351580456,
0.0482027382,
-0.0044671949,
0.0040432457,
0.0077574002,
0.0197387524,
-0.0111649986,
0.0206082389,
0.0369066373,
-0.0235974062,
-0.0495137088,
0.1061282605,
0.0364900827,
-0.0006001348,
0.007970687,
-0.0203257743,
0.0065265247,
0.0250749998,
0.0129925599,
-0.0961870253,
0.0011655225,
-0.0079700053,
0.066395171,
-0.0356796533,
-0.0266149137,
-0.0000168542,
-0.1517363936,
0.0691542923,
-0.0163684506,
-0.0158772636,
-0.0266406517,
-0.0056426516,
-0.0295160171,
-0.0244221985,
0.0223639887,
0.0322687402,
-0.0033724592,
0.0306203887,
0.0155400988,
0.0082371887,
-0.0317991637,
0.0691770166,
-0.0356709249,
0.0675377324,
0.0768046305,
0.0442762114,
-0.0071493071,
-0.0680608302,
-0.0271638725,
-0.0149086891,
0.0077499798,
0.0160590336,
0.0460339375,
0.020049734,
-0.0156335551,
-0.0269532576,
-0.00063389,
-0.0213575754,
0.0275569782,
0.0105501721,
0.0484596789,
-0.0202117953,
-0.0493431799,
-0.0181326717,
0.0037224132,
-0.0090133771,
0.098826237,
0.0437184162,
-0.0425618999,
-0.04997053,
-0.0176098198,
-0.0022800565,
-0.0627576858,
-0.0426120944,
0.0650888383,
0.0611826554,
0.0073092598,
-0.0902605727,
-0.0638000742,
-0.0024840022,
0.0019800144,
-0.0071822135,
-0.0081325816,
-0.0519350395,
-0.0026057314,
0.0061409427,
-0.0076688561,
-0.0500619262,
-0.0028581577,
-0.025020238,
-0.0035820086,
0.0184280388,
-0.0363353714,
-0.0171520915,
0.021901086,
-0.0827914253,
-0.0067361775,
-0.000442823,
0.0764515772,
0.0267056264,
0.0000550979,
-0.0224402044,
-0.0308401063,
0.0318627656,
0.0252880305,
-0.035772983,
0.0519007146,
-0.0037735351,
-0.0000860799,
-0.0082101552,
0.0266855918,
-0.0329966545,
0.0182174556,
0.0356311388,
0.0234468468,
0.0152190151,
-0.0179476123,
0.0363407396,
0.0232908633,
-0.0109084751,
-0.0167437699,
0.0259553455,
-0.0126678767,
-0.0054306039,
0.0194822475,
-0.0379101969,
-0.0377733223,
-0.0193246901,
0.0473030247,
0.0171065256,
-0.0008127323,
0.0154629257,
-0.0193500165,
0.0678460374,
-0.0807961673,
-0.0079082232,
0.0373559818,
-0.0063727554,
-0.0051061953,
-0.0072369114,
-0.0235270411,
0.0010668057,
-0.0233609639,
0.0458360463,
0.0190665331,
0.039033398,
-0.0021537351,
0.0180603378,
0.0241829138,
0.0172984768,
-0.0908900201,
-0.0745641515,
-0.0012994718,
0.0298716873,
0.0407793857,
0.0333106071,
0.0245930329,
-0.0077062086,
0.0139086666,
-0.0146426028,
-0.0278238803,
0.0221321359,
-0.0433501676,
0.0376560055,
0.0013506331,
-0.0147061329,
-0.0124391373,
0.0873979777,
0.0060853963,
0.0658297613,
-0.0532844625,
-0.0073006479,
-0.0247364305,
-0.0792355835,
-0.0240846407,
-0.0381694883,
0.0153254755,
0.0104805743,
-0.0567315035,
-0.0817213058,
-0.0267174616,
0.0677402169,
0.0355263948,
-0.041051738,
0.0059928335,
0.0710778981,
-0.0131013896,
-0.0178272892,
-0.0697878301,
0.0117093222,
-0.0286112092,
0.0149646234,
-0.0388027392,
-6.224712785e-33,
-0.0106266756,
-0.0404389091,
0.0421238989,
-0.0318065509,
-0.0069901757,
0.0117054032,
-0.0329604186,
0.00117756,
-0.0337781347,
-0.0059173503,
-0.0330899097,
0.0104721971,
-0.0088774003,
0.0124065783,
0.042848587,
-0.0272823311,
0.0393449664,
-0.0320903435,
-0.0454854518,
0.0418084897,
0.0173850041,
-0.0128853088,
0.0081800818,
-0.0347656906,
0.0545135252,
-0.0400212891,
-0.0248996187,
0.0106939245,
-0.0570622869,
0.0638806075,
-0.0178035777,
0.0464744866,
0.041462224,
-0.0423452295,
0.0111306235,
-0.0203488432,
-0.0411998332,
-0.0171169508,
0.0100906836,
-0.0301587172,
-0.0703364387,
-0.032728333,
0.0415761806,
0.0104279341,
-0.0591433719,
0.0051054959,
0.0087399874,
-0.0261003077,
0.036099717,
-0.0543343723,
-0.0415977649,
-0.0052826591,
0.0003372218,
-0.0410523824,
-0.0428786576,
0.0451553501,
-0.0081136543,
-0.005198631,
-0.0262415819,
-0.0054880809,
0.0273965672,
0.0055426192,
0.0888675675,
-0.0111918887,
-0.0100399591,
0.0408513285,
0.020008076,
0.0098443897,
-0.0268835165,
-0.0345422514,
-0.0114135938,
0.032478217,
0.0640849993,
0.0401495323,
0.0044589452,
-0.0152977724,
-0.0552160442,
0.0425489992,
-0.030455865,
0.0154887903,
0.02116297,
-0.0252492744,
-0.02459592,
-0.0096744616,
-0.073642984,
-0.0079408931,
-0.0565685667,
-0.0210461821,
0.047926899,
0.0288191494,
-0.0268180277,
-0.0282341726,
0.0256527103,
-0.0575416237,
0.0137713626,
0.0322157964,
-0.0395601615,
0.0134956948,
0.0115629137,
0.008447268,
-0.0436601341,
0.0105870133,
0.0040718135,
0.0435454547,
0.0193617512,
0.0100923218,
0.0167107191,
0.0178711731,
-0.0418020412,
0.0237229001,
-0.0568333045,
0.0627567694,
0.0066528139,
-0.0469803587,
0.0271040201,
0.0057270383,
-0.0302917399,
-0.0095194923,
-0.0009002958,
0.0345584229,
-0.0444256365,
0.0146663105,
0.0003134196,
0.004784443,
-0.0571037643,
0.0025556306,
-0.0236661062,
0.0100918943,
-0.0199347455,
-0.0279788058,
-0.0105785755,
0.0084561296,
2.521e-7,
0.0300678741,
0.0218252279,
-0.0039622639,
0.0280855056,
0.0265616998,
0.0156025561,
-0.0152063314,
0.0274857581,
0.0192791615,
-0.0047865463,
-0.0042454279,
0.0400480069,
0.0325682834,
0.027774049,
-0.0354484096,
0.0488483347,
-0.0948043466,
0.0164624266,
-0.0120480079,
-0.0133224344,
0.0545623079,
0.0510997996,
-0.0063038394,
-0.0290682558,
-0.0051834886,
-0.0682236329,
0.0746885613,
0.015056978,
-0.0016728383,
0.0309218187,
0.0480745807,
0.0577405207,
0.0196207799,
0.0337103866,
0.0151971336,
0.0030998844,
0.0238143355,
0.0666597784,
0.0313263014,
-0.0415703207,
-0.0345589221,
-0.0239983574,
0.0365663804,
-0.0820352733,
0.0835133418,
-0.0307101626,
-0.0240335464,
-0.0427492298,
0.0025197305,
0.0168039221,
0.0288924798,
-0.0327430293,
0.0025790106,
0.0127217844,
-0.0070769293,
0.0038509641,
0.0107466821,
-0.0256575365,
-0.0108193513,
-0.0097403852,
-0.0394050106,
-0.0938575938,
-0.0344303176,
0.0139516173,
-0.0053253765,
-0.0652579665,
0.0116774803,
1.874605267e-34,
0.0223226324,
0.0014781159,
0.0414724424,
0.0021012153,
0.0453110747,
0.0247023255,
-0.0087418975,
-0.0396381654,
0.0051945015,
-0.0389381684,
-0.0287915301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06196v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06196v2 | Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-09T05:37:09 | 2024-02-20T13:33:49 | Shervin Minaee, Tomas Mikolov, Narjes Nikzad, Meysam Chenaghlu, Richard Socher, Xavier Amatriain, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have drawn a lot of attention due to their
strong performance on a wide range of natural language tasks, since the release
of ChatGPT in November 2022. LLMs' ability of general-purpose language
understanding and generation is acquired by training billions of model's
parameters on massive amounts of text data, as predicted by scaling laws
\cite{kaplan2020scaling,hoffmann2022training}. The research area of LLMs, while
very recent, is evolving rapidly in many different ways. In this paper, we
review some of the most prominent LLMs, including three popular LLM families
(GPT, LLaMA, PaLM), and discuss their characteristics, contributions and
limitations. We also give an overview of techniques developed to build, and
augment LLMs. We then survey popular datasets prepared for LLM training,
fine-tuning, and evaluation, review widely used LLM evaluation metrics, and
compare the performance of several popular LLMs on a set of representative
benchmarks. Finally, we conclude the paper by discussing open challenges and
future research directions. | [
0.039638944,
0.062333189,
0.0097274762,
0.0545913093,
-0.0132988086,
0.0127028571,
0.0003962801,
-0.0060502025,
-0.0028107089,
-0.0538002327,
-0.0641138181,
-0.0635338202,
0.0045001931,
0.0263069328,
0.0427004211,
-0.0396424383,
0.0150611084,
-0.0357620791,
-0.0306488685,
0.0092878975,
0.0150078852,
0.0370384715,
0.0166717544,
0.0576823838,
0.0021247957,
-0.0239313263,
-0.0187692903,
0.019712111,
0.0156103494,
-0.0427055694,
0.0167912133,
0.0173158702,
0.0320287533,
0.064498648,
0.0000018317,
-0.0316118151,
-0.0016986147,
-0.0188737661,
0.0088162906,
0.0587522835,
0.030216841,
-0.0431807414,
0.0023661172,
0.0451759286,
-0.0376867205,
-0.0284982324,
0.021084534,
0.0530978553,
0.0407869406,
0.0874033868,
-0.0032528094,
-0.0411269553,
0.0127368225,
-0.0638445243,
-0.0145644043,
-0.0301701315,
0.056001965,
0.016758075,
0.0174376033,
0.0352525115,
-0.0103104506,
0.0031365794,
0.008205099,
0.006775823,
-0.0120967897,
0.0579871126,
-0.0220810883,
-0.0230209995,
-0.0027116591,
0.0978397503,
-0.0063987882,
-0.0188213643,
0.0145242987,
-0.0077163796,
-0.0395846106,
-0.0146471271,
-0.0455929041,
0.0433270335,
0.0240593366,
0.0529901758,
0.0296995211,
-0.0032169928,
0.0538780019,
0.0315162838,
-0.0341044664,
0.0345627666,
0.0332164392,
-0.0158208758,
-0.0312968083,
-0.0199795701,
-0.0332510322,
-0.0658055469,
-0.0031702742,
0.0628878698,
-0.0187659767,
0.0243461058,
-0.0492468439,
0.0048072133,
0.0512851886,
-0.0441571772,
0.0415543877,
0.0194613114,
-0.0027517732,
0.0363840833,
-0.0169941969,
0.070609048,
-0.0323667414,
-0.0054330197,
-0.0634212494,
-0.0075576417,
-0.0262806881,
-0.0033812728,
-0.0273977518,
0.0257390961,
-0.0454566181,
-0.0385729298,
-0.0440134294,
0.0168540291,
0.0302690379,
0.0174900107,
0.0213028714,
-0.0119047342,
-0.047723148,
-0.0120031219,
0.0053637763,
0.0290297475,
-0.0255779866,
0.0123823425,
0.0107500162,
-0.051672183,
-0.0110050859,
0.0365391411,
0.005241002,
-0.0132681197,
0.0153112086,
0.0699755847,
0.0098361755,
-0.0470941141,
-0.0520977601,
-0.0069726808,
-0.0123468088,
-0.1032380834,
-0.035585545,
-0.0572859086,
0.0323082507,
-0.0066551892,
0.0051193642,
-0.0076914751,
0.0344883464,
0.0263326988,
-0.0289187618,
0.0542349257,
-0.0269700009,
0.0177011974,
0.0291171204,
0.0047313315,
0.0148461945,
0.0847252086,
0.0502316132,
0.0316255167,
0.0193260945,
0.0013603511,
-0.0219992716,
0.059395764,
-0.0003442997,
0.0073807049,
0.0055538737,
0.0020593081,
0.0054170797,
0.0664183348,
0.0208633039,
0.0797899589,
-0.0299034324,
-0.0043020616,
0.0751096606,
0.0438951589,
0.0034590031,
0.0316631049,
0.0863299593,
0.0068805385,
0.0171620026,
-0.0148968399,
-0.0319796242,
-0.0092028333,
-0.0073162322,
0.0161765311,
0.0193481725,
0.0572016127,
-0.0438725278,
-0.0306032691,
-0.023745345,
-0.0181894191,
-0.0118338689,
-0.0016767838,
0.0483126231,
-0.0021528227,
-0.038491413,
0.0330149494,
0.0277933236,
-0.0290906318,
0.0099706305,
-0.0471993499,
0.0533136912,
0.0603555702,
0.0555883981,
0.0050057345,
-0.0369345844,
0.0042922543,
0.0032635976,
0.0417707451,
0.0338856764,
-0.0155714452,
-0.000792439,
-0.0854287073,
0.0129117761,
-0.0269357767,
0.0074112453,
0.0274221897,
0.020203013,
0.0187297985,
0.0417347141,
-0.0301101152,
-0.0133890528,
0.0502130948,
-0.039549306,
-0.0310060736,
0.0244267676,
-0.0183133464,
0.0513336323,
-0.0106593817,
-0.0057981038,
-0.0027906483,
0.0403423086,
-0.0400330313,
-0.0012193882,
0.0128825437,
-0.0511246994,
-0.0551191121,
0.0244580936,
0.00278399,
0.0164538994,
0.0270337015,
-0.0573570766,
-0.0533172973,
-0.0024145604,
-0.0039431117,
0.0357114263,
-0.0732349455,
0.0357824117,
0.0330752134,
0.0444926582,
-0.0394090153,
0.0534499921,
-0.0000127298,
-0.0046967007,
-0.0000172499,
0.0466757827,
0.0296786819,
-0.0439031236,
-0.0328861848,
0.0285848286,
-0.0102534331,
0.0089793997,
-0.0093621509,
0.0411326773,
-0.0425479859,
-0.0491301045,
-0.0967671126,
0.0614541955,
-0.0364575125,
0.0353972167,
0.033269465,
0.0082402257,
-0.0166983996,
0.010455858,
-0.052625522,
0.0104435459,
0.0405040421,
-0.0204343963,
0.0376420319,
0.0019303331,
-0.0367938019,
-0.0387023054,
0.0130718565,
0.0121837258,
0.0346733779,
0.0090851933,
-0.0040768944,
-0.0561416261,
0.0367811434,
-0.0270711407,
0.000735266,
-0.0153676271,
-0.0429280587,
-0.0122855995,
-0.015228536,
0.0525627248,
0.0255441573,
0.0099874297,
0.046241384,
0.0303021632,
0.0091516338,
-0.0285582468,
0.0029732541,
-0.0305583403,
-0.0160950273,
-0.0318528228,
-0.050717365,
0.0097244084,
0.0917138159,
-0.0053047012,
-0.0060638152,
-0.0561740063,
-0.0115611041,
-0.0123021528,
-0.0018180881,
0.0011939115,
0.0020124344,
-0.0147099542,
-0.0017042223,
-0.0292544514,
-0.0514327623,
0.0214393996,
-0.0905413702,
-0.0017228503,
-0.0423452817,
-0.0388770811,
-0.0751545504,
0.0561464392,
0.0128271729,
0.0076498375,
0.01099844,
-0.0087734507,
-0.0255291052,
-0.0049801781,
-0.0181129202,
-0.0217969529,
0.0416565426,
-0.059395235,
0.0271324366,
-0.0146715185,
-0.0244746339,
-0.052440498,
-0.051534161,
-0.0310382023,
0.0106922956,
0.011548847,
-0.0265537817,
-0.0117408838,
0.0265574865,
-0.0154846609,
0.0060544913,
-0.0205523353,
-0.0034143028,
-0.0310299546,
0.0477504246,
0.0856791437,
-0.0096948752,
0.0288326275,
-0.0408588201,
0.0237243753,
0.0540389977,
0.0236719642,
0.011882293,
-0.0548016615,
0.0014621896,
0.0135782314,
-0.0395197831,
-0.0189537518,
0.0161804557,
0.0587070882,
-0.0511013567,
-0.0145528493,
0.1257698089,
0.0243094359,
-0.0275945999,
0.0246369168,
0.0324237943,
0.0524926633,
0.0013823912,
0.0257780384,
-0.0645041466,
-0.0165640619,
-0.0046274085,
0.0125050601,
-0.0075159953,
-0.0277563147,
-0.0437127128,
-0.1244179904,
0.0279072523,
0.0247077178,
-0.0263493415,
-0.030267071,
-0.0301361792,
0.0001581541,
-0.0077758455,
0.0145331891,
0.0109794112,
-0.0327817723,
0.0092124874,
0.0359929241,
-0.021025816,
-0.0567167737,
0.0321573913,
-0.0318490379,
0.0569610149,
0.0367690437,
0.0399826877,
0.0170837957,
-0.0032403462,
0.0335961282,
-0.0259566251,
-0.0126078976,
-0.0220712684,
0.0118853934,
-0.0294774156,
-0.0178707987,
-0.0046462584,
0.0580466725,
-0.0515267029,
0.0037496195,
0.0351709276,
0.0554339662,
-0.0140713798,
-0.0265174005,
0.0087494897,
0.0102501931,
-0.010578257,
0.0870018527,
0.0384315923,
-0.0183625706,
-0.0428367332,
-0.0002005969,
-0.0157269668,
-0.0293197669,
0.0133889848,
0.0085572526,
-0.0021094361,
0.0142840585,
-0.0818480477,
-0.0400998145,
0.0238015391,
0.0121349329,
-0.0015561704,
0.0215288866,
-0.010280625,
-0.0124880457,
-0.01596996,
0.0298049748,
-0.0537398979,
-0.0034598908,
-0.0495197326,
-0.0021005576,
0.0496649072,
-0.0437468439,
-0.0099608572,
0.0222135503,
-0.1325476468,
-0.0831214637,
-0.0453044772,
0.0409364365,
0.0234853383,
0.0519392826,
-0.0072102821,
-0.0568910129,
0.0196954645,
0.0063394657,
-0.0198304597,
0.0267313104,
-0.0056972085,
0.0135572525,
-0.002557799,
0.0518084951,
-0.0320805684,
0.0335140228,
-0.0094446745,
0.0660268813,
-0.0242214873,
-0.0379432961,
0.0083470382,
0.0116963675,
0.0028529631,
-0.0449962839,
0.002569776,
-0.0331595019,
0.0027324695,
-0.0338139348,
0.0003847476,
-0.0508777052,
-0.0029276244,
0.0352866426,
-0.0017642373,
-0.0402118564,
-0.0494401604,
-0.0181930028,
0.054893747,
-0.0107350461,
0.002818882,
-0.0238124281,
-0.0106308172,
0.0352218971,
-0.0091362288,
-0.0308734961,
0.0120518403,
-0.0070638834,
0.0220452975,
-0.0093679177,
0.067454055,
-0.0006758171,
-0.0011365638,
-0.0222039372,
0.0218660589,
-0.0467342027,
-0.0422500782,
-0.0293547381,
0.0726882294,
0.0744916052,
0.0015853806,
0.0519764572,
-0.0251316037,
0.0001703424,
-0.0371210091,
0.0588870198,
-0.0114617608,
-0.041002132,
0.0418615453,
0.0029128781,
-0.0438509434,
0.0251757838,
0.0964797065,
0.0558092631,
0.0343296714,
0.0324764438,
0.011780425,
-0.0438360423,
-0.02113498,
0.0067654746,
-0.0031858098,
-0.0203230139,
0.0146565968,
-0.0440582484,
-0.0670029297,
0.014202795,
-0.0177576989,
-0.0002763942,
-0.0226177126,
0.0348593853,
0.0452596992,
-0.014565045,
0.0340414867,
-0.0460388549,
-0.0025852206,
-0.0298533998,
-0.0113717401,
0.0017226102,
-6.397298131e-33,
-0.0281837359,
-0.0121198287,
0.0415953659,
0.0036741477,
-0.0522473529,
-0.0014952954,
-0.0350601301,
-0.0188472476,
0.0006724026,
0.0019370714,
-0.0010022443,
-0.0067861918,
0.0030592696,
0.0383496583,
-0.0213842336,
-0.0051462636,
0.0509187728,
-0.0055181049,
-0.009543607,
0.0605566278,
0.027211437,
0.0471060053,
0.0316815265,
-0.038595669,
-0.0169216208,
-0.034824606,
-0.0268896241,
0.0099330591,
-0.0274094529,
0.059730012,
-0.0676903278,
0.0328472927,
0.0325564146,
-0.012198288,
-0.012607011,
0.0113137653,
-0.0606908947,
-0.000341498,
0.0186477192,
-0.0011081309,
-0.0172167551,
-0.0402379073,
0.0289607737,
-0.0235481057,
-0.0134188998,
0.0113440072,
0.0149829527,
-0.0239766855,
-0.0451957546,
-0.0013246742,
-0.0400084667,
0.0267067309,
-0.0114926603,
-0.0314183496,
-0.0171936788,
0.0178284459,
-0.0250092205,
0.0397245809,
-0.008580396,
0.0069150915,
0.0374359637,
0.0324499309,
0.0457698964,
0.0284933355,
0.0118225385,
0.0553716421,
-0.0217626449,
-0.0190553218,
-0.0221499875,
-0.0064741354,
-0.0065830676,
0.0444540307,
0.0056098541,
0.0441926233,
0.0015746228,
0.0053847269,
-0.0955915675,
0.0199217293,
0.0205896851,
0.0309506524,
0.0283445586,
-0.0135315554,
-0.0060275029,
0.0091524944,
-0.0319542065,
-0.011545863,
0.0001717582,
-0.0234150477,
0.0402850844,
0.0413226932,
-0.0046880422,
-0.0363798216,
0.0307611339,
-0.0521987341,
-0.0246847719,
0.0356285758,
-0.0285333768,
-0.004961988,
-0.0032043981,
0.0369286537,
-0.0903439894,
-0.053246852,
0.0153810028,
-0.0007368172,
-0.0223639701,
-0.0144461738,
-0.0003604036,
-0.0018905028,
-0.0488631502,
0.0034239835,
-0.0345770828,
0.0270379707,
-0.0362776555,
0.0410009958,
0.0311340727,
-0.0176211484,
-0.0082801273,
0.0580519885,
0.0134078786,
-0.0062123383,
0.0092545403,
-0.0124978917,
0.0005153416,
0.0374584198,
-0.0464255661,
0.0376940593,
-0.025399914,
-0.0171736889,
0.0298655163,
-0.0551337563,
-0.0098162182,
0.0131954532,
2.502e-7,
0.0290478487,
0.0288740043,
0.0235986169,
0.0097059654,
0.028814001,
0.0127044478,
-0.020374177,
0.0365677476,
0.0017830174,
0.007135672,
0.0326519981,
0.0398322977,
0.0603401326,
-0.0114624873,
-0.0919967666,
0.02666758,
-0.0697020814,
0.0041927905,
-0.0678481087,
-0.0311068185,
0.0440819748,
0.1358287334,
-0.0099626761,
-0.0208265446,
0.0235993322,
-0.0430096649,
0.1062201411,
-0.0245822333,
-0.0369920842,
0.0403265245,
0.0230769776,
0.041072879,
-0.0140523026,
-0.0047471053,
0.0063047418,
0.0166973379,
-0.0053933733,
0.1067797318,
0.0390747525,
0.018064905,
0.0497259013,
0.0163015109,
0.0030445782,
-0.0778731257,
0.0803862289,
-0.0596319288,
-0.037414182,
-0.0403365716,
0.0035151793,
-0.0287535172,
0.0044584046,
-0.0543257929,
-0.0104437526,
0.024316024,
0.0106961103,
-0.0340914614,
-0.0276912563,
-0.072545357,
0.0051886644,
-0.0198237859,
-0.0806781128,
-0.0267215949,
-0.0674256682,
0.0056935376,
0.030295603,
-0.0402355418,
-0.0079209097,
2.401298023e-34,
0.041373983,
-0.0546643585,
-0.0258888751,
0.0270356908,
0.0228780862,
-0.0022422518,
-0.0003931177,
0.0190577991,
-0.014199404,
-0.1182192042,
0.0069421986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10946v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10946v1 | CultureLLM: Incorporating Cultural Differences into Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T04:02:43 | 2024-02-09T04:02:43 | Cheng Li, Mengzhou Chen, Jindong Wang, Sunayana Sitaram, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are reported to be partial to certain cultures
owing to the training data dominance from the English corpora. Since
multilingual cultural data are often expensive to collect, existing efforts
handle this by prompt engineering or culture-specific pre-training. However,
they might overlook the knowledge deficiency of low-resource culture and
require extensive computing resources. In this paper, we propose CultureLLM, a
cost-effective solution to incorporate cultural differences into LLMs.
CultureLLM adopts World Value Survey (WVS) as seed data and generates
semantically equivalent training data via the proposed semantic data
augmentation. Using only 50 seed samples from WVS with augmented data, we
fine-tune culture-specific LLMs and one unified model (CultureLLM-One) for 9
cultures covering rich and low-resource languages. Extensive experiments on 60
culture-related datasets demonstrate that CultureLLM significantly outperforms
various counterparts such as GPT-3.5 (by 8.1%) and Gemini Pro (by 9.5%) with
comparable performance to GPT-4 or even better. Our human study shows that the
generated samples are semantically equivalent to the original samples,
providing an effective solution for LLMs augmentation. | [
0.0174070336,
0.0913605094,
-0.0225680619,
0.0305516012,
-0.0138545772,
0.0330177099,
0.0073447116,
-0.0467032008,
-0.0192014799,
-0.0052087177,
-0.0452705957,
-0.0404861271,
-0.0034352292,
0.0294041671,
0.0163824521,
-0.0694862008,
0.0778638348,
0.0274461955,
-0.0237261541,
-0.0414263047,
0.0148766618,
0.0325542875,
0.0305910073,
0.0328659788,
-0.0186974928,
0.0251727384,
0.02156532,
-0.0084497482,
0.0583198629,
-0.0454746522,
-0.0003376159,
0.0316678919,
0.0242066514,
0.0358932577,
0.0000023468,
-0.0612545237,
-0.0270349551,
-0.0338115878,
0.0097301574,
0.0382931046,
0.1144447625,
-0.0082976483,
-0.022613138,
0.0241780058,
-0.0409117378,
-0.0379328206,
0.0338434465,
0.029601898,
0.0255070254,
0.044352375,
-0.0118268738,
-0.0220443327,
-0.0157776698,
-0.0364075974,
-0.0138838394,
-0.031033393,
0.0314306952,
0.074389413,
-0.0177026205,
0.0012012023,
-0.0240053255,
0.024814887,
0.0129332673,
0.0389097258,
-0.0287330206,
0.0330298916,
-0.042912852,
-0.0123031503,
0.0175288618,
0.0547348112,
0.0256325956,
0.0009387656,
-0.0086661177,
-0.0012484289,
-0.0168077666,
-0.0340765789,
-0.0164808966,
0.0194249991,
0.0436589643,
0.0423665568,
0.0488679893,
0.0123393582,
0.0148641439,
0.0321252272,
-0.0218173917,
0.0783381984,
0.0214383285,
-0.0114591187,
-0.0154079897,
0.0071677915,
-0.0121957781,
-0.0284092873,
0.0017633707,
-0.0088062901,
-0.005280714,
0.0268939901,
-0.0319586433,
-0.0110788625,
0.0198880546,
-0.0484329015,
-0.0351510942,
0.0476501882,
-0.0320663415,
0.0131007554,
-0.0014597325,
0.0064604431,
0.0083334697,
0.0104227755,
-0.0867895633,
-0.0357501134,
-0.0364067666,
0.0161285307,
0.0325267203,
-0.0011875659,
-0.0418901443,
0.023802219,
-0.11200241,
0.0268904716,
-0.0301267356,
-0.0050679664,
-0.0215107743,
-0.0132523403,
0.0033530777,
0.0099859796,
-0.0254663043,
0.0784527138,
-0.0279466789,
-0.0019294464,
-0.027400529,
-0.0671276674,
0.0726560354,
0.0075964024,
-0.0074712583,
-0.015081319,
0.0301892087,
0.0393549316,
0.006076742,
-0.0027551418,
-0.0685741752,
0.0202629715,
0.001705223,
-0.0149283381,
0.0076514832,
-0.0819652826,
0.0413811132,
-0.0106054293,
0.0226728655,
-0.0282227974,
0.0109587964,
0.0040341369,
-0.0444668382,
0.0395736322,
-0.0314260796,
0.0270281509,
0.0629480928,
-0.0203113873,
-0.0012512408,
0.0889565051,
0.021140568,
-0.010991998,
0.0734503195,
-0.0240940917,
-0.0811642855,
0.0627707839,
-0.0074738474,
0.0337921977,
-0.0671917796,
-0.0033953753,
0.0099718012,
-0.003033102,
0.0431090668,
0.015355845,
-0.0153343035,
0.0130093349,
0.0379103273,
0.0436992198,
-0.0169891473,
0.0058426806,
0.0040400256,
0.0161125362,
-0.0171035677,
-0.0437472276,
-0.048451554,
-0.0151214162,
-0.0128475539,
0.0119577013,
-0.0153781483,
0.047971759,
-0.0346089303,
-0.0462767705,
-0.0116417417,
-0.0195218511,
0.0509195514,
0.035837926,
0.0567446314,
-0.0497545861,
0.0325932205,
0.0204988662,
0.070334591,
-0.0693738014,
0.0172965005,
-0.0149049098,
0.0433686972,
0.0861987993,
0.0103281178,
-0.0157931857,
0.0092773782,
-0.0057712239,
0.006990714,
0.0429478399,
0.0809688345,
-0.0117623238,
-0.0032399909,
-0.0582696646,
-0.0412033089,
-0.0054911557,
-0.0148851769,
0.0320359766,
0.025263017,
0.0268287193,
0.0219467729,
-0.0318766274,
-0.0594221912,
0.0164071918,
-0.0477377959,
0.0172152817,
0.0294089559,
-0.008550697,
0.0185439419,
0.0481148548,
-0.0040466245,
-0.012515231,
-0.0257770363,
-0.0374324135,
0.0013335192,
0.0046648532,
-0.0542668477,
-0.0407848395,
0.0492923893,
-0.0424324647,
-0.0042688004,
0.0314256921,
-0.0531617664,
-0.0387069918,
-0.0064502973,
0.0298551712,
0.0369955301,
-0.0845822468,
0.0069552241,
-0.0309424382,
0.0275591183,
-0.0356616154,
0.0418515354,
-0.0176444612,
0.0083161043,
-0.0481336825,
0.0194635596,
0.030162245,
-0.0307873394,
-0.0620847829,
-0.0014071639,
-0.0034681577,
0.0242836643,
0.0384283774,
0.0414606594,
-0.0596988238,
0.0024351729,
-0.1086929813,
-0.0153103936,
-0.0078175263,
0.0101559833,
0.0155426469,
0.0356199704,
-0.022624936,
-0.005180439,
-0.0916019529,
0.0117316032,
0.0305787753,
0.0527411029,
0.0093923472,
-0.0281043649,
0.0339428931,
-0.0167221148,
-0.0212780256,
0.0197324008,
-0.001026205,
-0.0081307692,
-0.0044418629,
-0.0220531989,
-0.0108296918,
-0.0625335947,
-0.0090385703,
-0.0230524857,
-0.0341265835,
-0.0265420973,
0.001750937,
0.0510625504,
0.013501931,
0.029540522,
-0.0129452096,
0.0549789406,
0.0148050077,
-0.073046267,
-0.030239271,
-0.0173576865,
0.0104866354,
-0.0181773007,
-0.071274057,
0.0134644788,
0.0544271357,
-0.0321200602,
-0.0060519688,
-0.0126609867,
0.0126490192,
-0.0403268784,
-0.0238720085,
-0.0177532993,
0.0381905809,
-0.0136114759,
0.0413081348,
-0.0029463547,
-0.0295557268,
0.047889892,
-0.0209312197,
-0.001971083,
-0.0429559723,
-0.0271942746,
-0.0409450494,
-0.007184613,
-0.0302262213,
0.0255990047,
-0.0411325395,
-0.0232201796,
-0.0314201042,
0.0109408917,
0.0081584565,
-0.0500660911,
0.0506707728,
-0.0191604048,
-0.0306236111,
-0.0252072383,
-0.0053360267,
-0.0637318417,
0.0153240729,
-0.0349946208,
0.0353271104,
0.0304748882,
0.0204712525,
0.0005382682,
0.0072075198,
0.0304831564,
0.0104009276,
0.0021642605,
0.0204652604,
0.0119732236,
-0.0284742322,
0.0641617402,
0.0312917531,
0.0168532375,
-0.0325748287,
0.0104925996,
0.0029084713,
0.0679451376,
-0.0247729067,
0.0131011829,
0.0273636542,
0.0445677266,
-0.0221791361,
-0.0151040768,
-0.0020339766,
-0.0045909313,
-0.0137845287,
0.0450413637,
0.127839312,
0.0102262143,
-0.048443567,
0.005459893,
-0.0602128357,
0.0300909393,
0.0443186462,
0.0458779745,
-0.1087707058,
-0.0010257519,
-0.0129667316,
0.0065411269,
-0.011846466,
-0.0136375409,
-0.0015852052,
-0.1224300936,
0.0161838681,
0.0054022293,
-0.0573377535,
0.0156279225,
0.0009682464,
-0.0067009544,
-0.0366344638,
0.0443257093,
-0.0343848839,
-0.0009912164,
-0.0178575236,
0.0107862009,
-0.0488915183,
-0.0840564668,
0.04841391,
-0.043594338,
0.0399557985,
0.0835961774,
0.0318715945,
-0.0196486544,
-0.0665018111,
0.0062369769,
0.0115943523,
-0.0068683205,
-0.0085681751,
0.0287107285,
-0.014008387,
-0.0373307317,
0.0169807859,
-0.0007194433,
0.0020139371,
0.0059058308,
0.028357584,
0.026795309,
0.001336896,
0.0176677126,
0.0047399821,
-0.0032221179,
-0.0061590774,
0.0691517815,
-0.0010639266,
-0.068250522,
0.0119747091,
-0.0145708313,
-0.0346676745,
0.004951742,
-0.0423857868,
0.0504667796,
-0.0732689723,
-0.0575192086,
-0.0508549921,
-0.0692283884,
0.027128512,
0.0129999248,
0.0036970451,
-0.0183163956,
0.0166770257,
0.0027497518,
-0.0530259721,
0.0296836942,
-0.0771835148,
0.0203541014,
-0.039651975,
-0.0110785458,
0.0302267354,
-0.0426069163,
0.0007280153,
-0.0145406192,
-0.0187990889,
-0.0409917608,
0.0258494429,
0.0432840697,
0.0072298404,
0.0439601578,
0.006653077,
-0.0345218331,
0.0707480088,
0.0152036045,
-0.0223937239,
0.0097530726,
0.010594951,
0.0472081229,
-0.0065145572,
0.0172160454,
-0.0387233496,
0.0541070215,
0.027509395,
0.0629503354,
-0.0133353313,
-0.0073654698,
0.0031939703,
0.0545546524,
0.030326819,
-0.0378179923,
0.0040907143,
-0.0582368411,
-0.0056949798,
-0.0361978263,
-0.0298249926,
-0.0417888761,
-0.0305758696,
0.0299434867,
-0.0165547952,
0.0108386921,
-0.0044544782,
-0.0130319018,
0.0006062606,
-0.0374172814,
0.0278179254,
0.0104130432,
0.0606106892,
0.0035007067,
0.02365762,
-0.0189005286,
-0.0184767172,
0.0187609605,
0.0313068144,
-0.044638291,
0.0603905208,
-0.0104631381,
-0.0115316175,
-0.0003788515,
0.0362022817,
-0.0022361819,
-0.0298390239,
0.0024664439,
0.0316526927,
0.0437617451,
-0.0289173424,
0.0810610503,
-0.01138609,
-0.0030465752,
-0.0427444503,
-0.000090239,
-0.0057866201,
-0.0733675882,
0.0212062858,
-0.0007753117,
-0.0405679084,
-0.0081263855,
0.0531762354,
0.0058124363,
-0.0178992823,
-0.0132002989,
-0.0366986468,
-0.0315486789,
-0.0143044256,
0.0542184524,
0.0197149888,
-0.070633404,
0.0106331948,
-0.0715797022,
-0.0812925026,
-0.0218141843,
-0.0047966563,
-0.0271571651,
-0.0075472584,
-0.0035980302,
0.0630354434,
-0.0362174325,
0.0152402557,
-0.0541031808,
-0.0123342415,
-0.0352472663,
-0.0127008287,
0.0221996382,
-6.65554175e-33,
-0.0011754234,
0.0183420423,
0.0227854438,
-0.0105863912,
-0.0264096968,
0.0015576235,
0.0114486739,
0.0102424482,
-0.0396713093,
0.005225434,
-0.0173802897,
-0.0182519946,
0.0261626039,
0.0335016698,
0.0375144891,
0.0134218587,
0.024414245,
0.0067057428,
-0.0055747381,
0.0107152108,
0.0370610617,
0.024639966,
0.11415454,
-0.0878666267,
0.0318360142,
0.0263014697,
0.0279308651,
0.0071229069,
0.0736723021,
0.0454811417,
-0.0317416936,
0.0836415216,
0.0192663968,
-0.064141199,
-0.0286030658,
-0.0371022671,
-0.0938898548,
-0.0512964353,
0.0338701122,
0.0195887107,
0.0386504903,
-0.0107551562,
0.0075453403,
-0.0274894033,
-0.0107924091,
0.0129854335,
0.0455238111,
-0.0478657484,
-0.0084507167,
-0.0205649417,
-0.0561820567,
0.0352829881,
0.0132658947,
0.0490657203,
0.0258722827,
0.0559309646,
-0.031601347,
0.0251082703,
-0.0625295117,
0.0474337339,
0.0209327172,
0.0194176547,
0.0999687761,
0.0352725834,
0.0185434632,
0.0338450819,
0.0271887314,
0.0201859474,
0.0455420166,
0.0054262346,
0.0820223019,
0.0034177059,
-0.0069568655,
0.1145603359,
0.0124129066,
-0.051257059,
-0.0311605148,
0.0450609624,
0.0464030877,
-0.0341366678,
0.0050761034,
0.0162176192,
0.001409319,
-0.0439745076,
-0.020012565,
0.0188467987,
-0.0326604471,
-0.0469774976,
0.0379305147,
0.0119398599,
-0.0252740867,
0.0106378347,
0.0462650135,
-0.0490674041,
-0.0283853002,
0.0094070006,
0.0042911032,
-0.0208504554,
0.0110813743,
-0.0040474883,
-0.0538684428,
-0.0316223465,
-0.0077772117,
-0.0132289007,
-0.0270962883,
0.0081475386,
0.0261773467,
-0.0022417528,
-0.0544110797,
0.0081019159,
0.0013152588,
-0.0067978003,
-0.0465007685,
-0.0108951498,
0.0230065901,
-0.0188524947,
-0.0041092308,
0.0056193308,
0.0475439653,
0.0019388989,
-0.0340226665,
-0.0819379389,
0.0032879524,
0.0611603223,
-0.0418917611,
0.0044561434,
-0.0201140922,
-0.0056194859,
0.0534621812,
-0.0035463118,
-0.0036064559,
-0.0111572929,
2.949e-7,
0.0229041893,
0.0211670045,
-0.0168351028,
0.017037848,
-0.0183202494,
0.0313345119,
0.0043733683,
0.0144212013,
0.0449579917,
0.0012183406,
0.0428569652,
0.0014825261,
0.0799877271,
0.0314679481,
-0.0824504346,
-0.0029205333,
-0.0263861865,
0.0093329325,
-0.04889955,
0.0294139124,
0.0177586731,
0.0890144482,
0.0180996936,
-0.0324990526,
-0.0160035379,
0.0077838795,
0.0542427711,
-0.0782131106,
-0.0372797661,
0.0286905784,
-0.0119481897,
-0.0056753252,
0.0008507618,
-0.0039277119,
-0.0278807133,
0.0241292249,
0.0412025452,
0.0658346787,
-0.0108131953,
-0.0072590346,
0.0061610062,
0.0138156945,
-0.006391583,
-0.0883789584,
0.055932425,
-0.0231808387,
-0.0213952567,
-0.0195932426,
-0.0337467343,
0.0131044723,
0.037860319,
-0.0311491508,
-0.0245732181,
0.010758834,
0.0377828516,
-0.0221303757,
-0.0362160392,
-0.0314970426,
-0.0097689433,
0.0000174717,
-0.00954282,
-0.060511291,
0.0056374623,
0.0219734628,
-0.0246216562,
0.005429328,
0.0246982407,
2.679891791e-34,
0.0213956069,
0.0124393227,
0.0062764827,
-0.0012049364,
0.0255836677,
0.0253667179,
0.041113086,
0.0210152976,
-0.0211108439,
-0.0333004221,
-0.0021745733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06155v1 | Model Editing with Canonical Examples | 2024-02-09T03:08:12 | 2024-02-09T03:08:12 | John Hewitt, Sarah Chen, Lanruo Lora Xie, Edward Adams, Percy Liang, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce model editing with canonical examples, a setting in which (1) a
single learning example is provided per desired behavior, (2) evaluation is
performed exclusively out-of-distribution, and (3) deviation from an initial
model is strictly limited. A canonical example is a simple instance of good
behavior, e.g., The capital of Mauritius is Port Louis) or bad behavior, e.g.,
An aspect of researchers is coldhearted). The evaluation set contains more
complex examples of each behavior (like a paragraph in which the capital of
Mauritius is called for.) We create three datasets and modify three more for
model editing with canonical examples, covering knowledge-intensive
improvements, social bias mitigation, and syntactic edge cases. In our
experiments on Pythia language models, we find that LoRA outperforms full
finetuning and MEMIT. We then turn to the Backpack language model architecture
because it is intended to enable targeted improvement. The Backpack defines a
large bank of sense vectors--a decomposition of the different uses of each
word--which are weighted and summed to form the output logits of the model. We
propose sense finetuning, which selects and finetunes a few ($\approx$ 10)
sense vectors for each canonical example, and find that it outperforms other
finetuning methods, e.g., 4.8% improvement vs 0.3%. Finally, we improve
GPT-J-6B by an inference-time ensemble with just the changes from sense
finetuning of a 35x smaller Backpack, in one setting outperforming editing
GPT-J itself (4.1% vs 1.0%). | [
0.073306188,
0.0517112836,
-0.0280097201,
0.0327444039,
-0.0378207602,
0.0234521404,
-0.0259323679,
-0.0079692621,
-0.0165621117,
-0.0590865128,
-0.0241831541,
0.0127961785,
0.0197796673,
0.0214816537,
0.0605834611,
-0.069592163,
0.0591199733,
-0.0065035364,
0.0076620439,
-0.0147691295,
0.0055694487,
-0.0049487501,
0.0328894295,
0.0382516906,
0.0658158287,
0.0031685655,
-0.0264142267,
0.0168383606,
0.0352640599,
0.0128786489,
0.0297635756,
0.0862128884,
-0.0094451578,
0.0379712582,
0.0000020963,
-0.0545396358,
-0.0353465974,
0.0145103522,
0.0051618167,
0.0301384646,
0.0796607956,
0.0032943683,
-0.0121537615,
0.0172916967,
-0.0303742513,
-0.0014553441,
0.0567801557,
0.0014933215,
0.0364101678,
0.0674127191,
-0.0125613771,
-0.018781418,
-0.0276240222,
-0.0514989719,
-0.0286098979,
-0.013846145,
0.0486397557,
-0.0397711471,
-0.0329058506,
-0.0048847562,
-0.0398364291,
0.0113345226,
-0.0171845369,
-0.003668715,
0.0457805656,
0.0099336971,
-0.0582300909,
-0.0291705281,
0.0121822199,
0.0455806777,
-0.0045457399,
-0.0433589406,
-0.0015557745,
-0.0190676115,
0.0408292711,
0.0006506573,
-0.0201662704,
-0.0651631579,
0.0114059383,
0.0134585118,
0.0444033295,
-0.0725793764,
0.0401790738,
0.0411731005,
-0.025773542,
0.0653733835,
0.0277087614,
-0.0218401123,
-0.0218778104,
0.0007599025,
-0.0659464076,
-0.0451942049,
-0.0124636143,
-0.0019591751,
-0.0099435812,
0.0089210086,
-0.042367436,
-0.0056092995,
0.0169155411,
-0.0260002054,
0.0766540393,
0.0234338008,
0.0135839693,
0.0300410762,
0.0229773633,
0.0168498401,
0.0142914727,
0.0377425104,
-0.0308530051,
0.0187171511,
-0.052950073,
0.0118094524,
-0.0665408969,
0.0160234887,
-0.0297584515,
0.0433325246,
-0.0681213289,
0.018261997,
-0.0153417494,
-0.0017069312,
0.0185279585,
-0.0045364713,
-0.0722033903,
-0.0033403113,
-0.0101423087,
0.0139464168,
-0.0282436106,
0.0108223241,
0.0007650299,
-0.0392782986,
-0.0132463062,
-0.0191487484,
0.0089837527,
-0.0314598419,
0.0032668891,
0.032909181,
-0.0038329796,
-0.0519964769,
-0.0297724735,
-0.0144383414,
-0.0357441343,
-0.0633885488,
-0.0465187877,
-0.0519244149,
-0.0186401848,
-0.0037456744,
-0.0037312694,
-0.0872307494,
-0.0394551307,
-0.0212287251,
-0.0566239133,
0.0746174231,
-0.0215757303,
0.0033741931,
0.0086745657,
-0.0069461018,
-0.0137739778,
0.0684326142,
0.0536377952,
-0.0061695869,
0.049463708,
-0.0026392052,
0.0153954001,
0.0293361507,
0.0232044253,
0.0345024467,
-0.027286021,
0.0032929496,
-0.0432524011,
0.0352683067,
0.0150114214,
0.0293963701,
-0.0366797559,
-0.0089422762,
0.0773178861,
0.0191733167,
0.036227081,
0.011779218,
0.0274279043,
0.0003676444,
-0.0110538872,
0.012288088,
-0.0499214418,
0.0026557173,
-0.0386834107,
-0.0077735973,
-0.0053209304,
0.0320675373,
-0.0230204277,
-0.0578646958,
-0.0009209922,
0.0326013714,
0.0335735008,
0.0196536798,
0.030321613,
0.0133594293,
-0.0136077935,
-0.0004206867,
0.0424786359,
-0.0433719791,
0.0074758013,
-0.0940028951,
0.0422666296,
0.0607982874,
0.0753505379,
-0.0562958717,
-0.0315274522,
-0.0211584903,
-0.0303108096,
-0.0070765233,
0.0839991421,
-0.045375891,
0.0056148241,
-0.0345868468,
-0.0281029344,
0.0021023341,
0.0280809384,
0.0056693298,
0.0296864565,
-0.0100747542,
-0.0072815423,
-0.0426477231,
-0.0179485418,
0.0222798679,
-0.0106214844,
-0.0068465616,
-0.0084105786,
-0.0072488482,
0.0531814843,
-0.0246547088,
-0.0186558552,
-0.0343664065,
-0.0149557209,
0.0106489621,
-0.0069798576,
0.0174695887,
-0.0073255603,
-0.0188703816,
0.0279593077,
0.0053958669,
-0.010220632,
0.0607079864,
-0.0599803738,
-0.0200865846,
0.0057366472,
-0.018360015,
0.064845562,
-0.0519735925,
0.0289968494,
-0.0674279407,
-0.0032116689,
-0.0506787524,
0.0327463113,
-0.0104480181,
-0.0084146941,
-0.0143097714,
-0.0007836037,
-0.001083236,
-0.0279769544,
-0.0434230939,
0.0239064936,
0.0175363477,
0.0145711554,
0.0533962622,
0.0024642674,
-0.0471002944,
-0.0664723888,
-0.0788505822,
-0.0082173338,
-0.0265496448,
0.0170245189,
0.0445632376,
0.0469935164,
-0.0236452743,
0.014452666,
0.0157719441,
0.0146296127,
-0.0239983611,
0.0399436429,
0.0490654409,
0.0245507527,
-0.0334600993,
-0.0730952546,
-0.0039977613,
0.0014292806,
0.0364758745,
-0.0065101297,
-0.0299958903,
-0.0661718771,
0.0258120093,
-0.0430003256,
0.0092274249,
0.0021250881,
-0.0848305821,
-0.0051354263,
0.0226185005,
0.0635347664,
0.1028092429,
-0.0022553566,
0.0535059869,
0.0584188439,
0.0041223769,
-0.0361319631,
0.007708258,
-0.0097911442,
-0.009081468,
-0.0509140939,
0.0039847675,
-0.0044287983,
0.0454001874,
0.0088712974,
-0.052140858,
-0.0633756518,
0.0763351321,
-0.0152371293,
-0.0540162399,
0.0091175204,
0.0143217836,
-0.0121992212,
0.0209756456,
-0.0392086208,
-0.0507822372,
0.0833036155,
0.0245212261,
0.0207179692,
-0.032116048,
-0.0076320111,
0.0025720762,
0.0456328057,
0.0106004504,
0.008370596,
0.0041535934,
-0.0076936642,
-0.0612044781,
-0.0520453416,
0.0750806332,
-0.0341979824,
0.0195848551,
-0.0792513117,
0.0040981742,
-0.0027771345,
-0.0387851074,
0.0069413949,
-0.0444134176,
-0.0168165099,
0.0048938738,
0.0351562724,
-0.0375979729,
0.0109898644,
0.0009762479,
0.008592085,
0.0703781471,
-0.0462255776,
-0.0075738607,
-0.0119269444,
-0.0321272835,
0.0392083451,
0.0175486021,
0.0061584068,
-0.0295919813,
0.0131569533,
0.0178327188,
0.0231158938,
-0.0215324946,
-0.0360875688,
0.0143027781,
0.0101985345,
-0.050524652,
-0.0304863714,
0.0088223629,
0.0849462375,
-0.0386947319,
-0.0387556329,
0.0878566056,
0.0193518363,
-0.0378041342,
0.0235302355,
-0.0210417565,
0.0569468141,
0.0391261205,
0.031433668,
-0.0424877927,
-0.0364129357,
0.0243741274,
0.0397539325,
-0.0424841046,
-0.0460737832,
-0.0014315801,
-0.0789601132,
0.0425222963,
0.0147918565,
-0.0436654165,
-0.0168578699,
-0.0076430775,
0.0377954543,
-0.0647971258,
-0.0002578082,
0.0211976133,
0.0051535415,
0.0236425512,
-0.0040728948,
0.0018437423,
-0.0922290832,
0.0154101793,
-0.0161675047,
0.0396143273,
0.0673525482,
0.0391033888,
-0.0061293845,
-0.0050686542,
0.0016757025,
-0.0049651568,
0.009403443,
-0.0284798071,
0.0460637584,
0.0144416317,
-0.0091924695,
0.016249517,
0.0472814403,
0.0260266215,
-0.002822536,
-0.0201257989,
0.0493732542,
-0.0182763953,
-0.0110818921,
0.0054171858,
-0.053125523,
-0.0032601135,
0.053957019,
0.0444450937,
-0.0388211384,
-0.0145463077,
-0.0201367345,
-0.0479458645,
-0.0282473527,
-0.0132247452,
-0.0132131185,
0.0074455147,
-0.0142423511,
-0.0694125816,
-0.0645849258,
0.0526848882,
0.0473605059,
0.0130586457,
0.021522399,
-0.0067866016,
0.018557718,
-0.0339166969,
-0.0246336348,
-0.0280435961,
0.0032566236,
-0.0239855833,
-0.0161867347,
0.0516817272,
0.015821971,
-0.0429878421,
0.0203007087,
-0.0470240377,
-0.0984020233,
0.0480197296,
0.0743985996,
0.0374347568,
0.0757307261,
-0.0075863297,
-0.0927499905,
0.0283403862,
0.0544733442,
0.032542415,
0.0639376417,
0.0307428408,
-0.0501483195,
-0.0063897306,
0.0556117147,
-0.0211794376,
0.0400579982,
0.0445639528,
0.0166081972,
-0.0570198111,
-0.0312546901,
0.0246737972,
0.0226079337,
0.0596127287,
-0.0231275503,
-0.0409242325,
-0.0375818424,
0.0150413606,
-0.0096444506,
-0.0163510479,
-0.034882389,
0.0083792815,
0.0101563605,
-0.0251897853,
-0.0462715067,
0.0190925337,
-0.0464819781,
0.0376132876,
-0.0491073057,
0.0166452564,
0.0117076607,
0.0354047455,
0.0231146179,
0.013664973,
-0.0055571874,
-0.0091751339,
0.0056883069,
0.0172613692,
-0.0259792041,
0.0223089922,
0.0265790466,
0.0213701203,
-0.016977353,
0.0525519513,
-0.0758292079,
-0.0125592891,
-0.0541722327,
0.038104374,
0.0322560742,
0.0110114757,
0.0681681335,
-0.0127927326,
-0.0530248098,
-0.0275914501,
0.0615122505,
0.0017954782,
-0.0311610308,
0.0289084762,
0.0192896649,
-0.0250037704,
0.0069108205,
0.0522928499,
-0.0237307027,
0.0816004053,
-0.0015595021,
-0.0226132385,
-0.0535669476,
-0.0143021774,
0.0026321774,
-0.0032781805,
0.0010027599,
0.0078896675,
-0.0633277819,
-0.0611762144,
-0.0149477925,
0.03526875,
0.015780326,
-0.025244616,
0.0135461083,
0.053073518,
-0.0321020856,
-0.0063293315,
-0.0444850773,
-0.0327992104,
0.0174705908,
-0.0318957046,
0.0045198598,
-6.425222e-33,
-0.0257840697,
0.0184280686,
0.0043515339,
0.0066985455,
-0.0123228887,
-0.0431795046,
-0.0263597257,
0.0017646678,
-0.0198040009,
0.0284944456,
-0.0467770547,
0.030360898,
0.0086628525,
-0.0254007783,
-0.0026263616,
0.0425863713,
0.0842577219,
0.0109651703,
-0.0388820283,
0.0398290418,
0.0092121866,
0.0268843006,
0.0946714953,
-0.0180423036,
0.0152724599,
0.0110131372,
-0.0433273502,
0.0127683552,
-0.048769936,
0.0478979647,
0.011227414,
0.0176259708,
0.0040570707,
-0.0150065701,
-0.0233524479,
-0.055141829,
-0.0428703278,
-0.0236189216,
0.0148810241,
0.0081046065,
-0.0176066961,
-0.0384194627,
0.071617268,
0.0056904675,
-0.0642348081,
0.0025076685,
0.0136024766,
-0.0478999875,
-0.0260561593,
0.018552715,
-0.0831153095,
0.0370636322,
0.0056116879,
-0.0154187279,
-0.0167937931,
-0.0132686598,
0.0254979301,
0.0118420366,
-0.0042126798,
-0.0165111087,
0.0510310829,
0.0496554151,
0.0424364209,
-0.0202286094,
0.0062560565,
0.0322053656,
0.0141738076,
0.021386737,
0.0436656885,
-0.0277793575,
0.0675516874,
0.0204273071,
0.0433246829,
0.1141811386,
0.0401680395,
-0.0514044277,
-0.0630330145,
0.0130238356,
-0.0034905947,
0.0109656081,
0.022283582,
0.0386492498,
-0.016926555,
-0.0188416895,
-0.0564389676,
-0.0481688604,
-0.0343884788,
-0.0088606011,
0.0239870362,
0.0121262223,
-0.0495489612,
0.0171522424,
0.0087088291,
-0.0371183455,
-0.017201012,
0.0051408107,
-0.0594989434,
0.0385400057,
0.0194023568,
-0.0071587702,
-0.0216437373,
-0.0223440547,
-0.0031215937,
0.0548548922,
0.0139302444,
-0.0119822938,
0.0462773629,
0.0476772562,
-0.0668775067,
0.0120626194,
-0.0050489539,
0.0311003625,
-0.024861861,
-0.0262567308,
-0.0077490984,
-0.0072260979,
0.006624178,
0.0141371917,
0.0390913375,
-0.0177216027,
-0.0422942899,
0.0162258334,
0.0083577987,
0.0233437289,
-0.0149747096,
-0.0348459519,
0.0113435639,
0.013844653,
0.0566870831,
-0.0102990288,
-0.0224219523,
0.0122499513,
2.833e-7,
0.0351767465,
0.0701467097,
0.0009970732,
-0.013259097,
0.0099655902,
0.0538445376,
-0.0227679815,
0.0537665971,
0.0284044947,
0.0035688858,
0.0387405567,
0.0071596401,
0.0189652946,
0.0113036921,
-0.0581150614,
0.0196723882,
-0.0387946293,
0.0208714325,
-0.0289018136,
-0.0553352907,
0.0009370603,
0.0723379105,
0.0708952472,
-0.0052860593,
-0.0151405865,
-0.0374283418,
0.0560286939,
-0.0384642817,
-0.0031038751,
0.0382571109,
0.0323328301,
0.0291849319,
0.01434559,
0.0119516887,
-0.0100111999,
-0.0073508215,
-0.0415696949,
0.0490183085,
-0.0623342022,
0.0673431233,
-0.0022257229,
0.0092215855,
0.0141927944,
-0.0644108877,
0.0335872956,
-0.0872714669,
-0.0241305213,
-0.0679818466,
-0.0050935871,
0.0043427595,
0.0291338582,
-0.0073656379,
-0.0173547883,
0.0456910357,
0.0125533864,
0.0311804414,
-0.0436706394,
-0.0627630427,
0.0013976383,
0.0102732349,
-0.0009047543,
-0.0535160005,
-0.010066554,
0.0056101112,
0.0204551835,
-0.064049758,
0.0254044235,
2.599008137e-34,
0.0514044091,
-0.0040068785,
0.0282361694,
-0.0058430042,
0.0571563654,
0.0038510787,
0.0256991647,
-0.0011921799,
0.0240617972,
-0.050653033,
-0.0167785864
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.