id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10171v1 | Data Engineering for Scaling Language Models to 128K Context | 2024-02-15T18:19:16 | 2024-02-15T18:19:16 | Yao Fu, Rameswar Panda, Xinyao Niu, Xiang Yue, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Yoon Kim, Hao Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the continual pretraining recipe for scaling language models'
context lengths to 128K, with a focus on data engineering. We hypothesize that
long context modeling, in particular \textit{the ability to utilize information
at arbitrary input locations}, is a capability that is mostly already acquired
through large-scale pretraining, and that this capability can be readily
extended to contexts substantially longer than seen during training~(e.g., 4K
to 128K) through lightweight continual pretraining on appropriate data mixture.
We investigate the \textit{quantity} and \textit{quality} of the data for
continual pretraining: (1) for quantity, we show that 500 million to 5 billion
tokens are enough to enable the model to retrieve information anywhere within
the 128K context; (2) for quality, our results equally emphasize \textit{domain
balance} and \textit{length upsampling}. Concretely, we find that naively
upsampling longer data on certain domains like books, a common practice of
existing work, gives suboptimal performance, and that a balanced domain mixture
is important. We demonstrate that continual pretraining of the full model on
1B-5B tokens of such data is an effective and affordable strategy for scaling
the context length of language models to 128K. Our recipe outperforms strong
open-source long-context models and closes the gap to frontier models like
GPT-4 128K. | [
-0.0127198026,
0.0590025708,
-0.0097879292,
0.0469326898,
-0.032285478,
0.0102087846,
0.049619209,
0.0180823132,
-0.0672324896,
-0.0488836356,
-0.0373013541,
-0.0591570921,
0.005436358,
0.037159428,
0.0252181925,
-0.0607689656,
0.0258914419,
-0.0455417745,
-0.0587826706,
-0.0056251423,
-0.0240065996,
-0.0095447181,
0.0255309734,
0.0033246519,
-0.0116014415,
-0.0084165093,
-0.0139798,
-0.01525719,
0.009501664,
-0.0225486513,
-0.0064877369,
0.0282686278,
0.0572333373,
0.0316613689,
0.0000020893,
-0.0470241345,
-0.0206796285,
-0.0053939344,
-0.0376635268,
0.0646324381,
0.0564725809,
-0.0508447476,
-0.0172202177,
0.0020821667,
-0.007574894,
-0.0245694444,
0.0175111666,
0.0382495262,
0.0258938912,
0.0683616325,
-0.0089011164,
-0.0543980151,
0.0456540138,
-0.0555192269,
-0.0163118616,
-0.0490515791,
0.0297285747,
0.0260950867,
-0.0007831486,
0.0556722395,
-0.0475425348,
0.0458501466,
0.0465733521,
0.0414519832,
-0.0107416343,
0.0601735376,
-0.0246162191,
0.0052397475,
0.0235237535,
0.0460094661,
-0.0106114103,
-0.0054960372,
-0.0119294031,
-0.0145091666,
-0.0197020583,
-0.0354635529,
-0.0443985313,
0.0174409952,
0.0228503104,
0.0179963838,
-0.0111967791,
0.0050075757,
0.0500918217,
-0.0008179054,
-0.0639853105,
0.0097433124,
0.0236785542,
-0.0211091265,
-0.0124922339,
-0.0203283709,
-0.0585713573,
-0.0482215695,
-0.0119892834,
0.0115612606,
0.0072145602,
0.0300548766,
-0.0520965531,
-0.0311494544,
0.0064783557,
-0.0239971634,
-0.0102759758,
0.0424912535,
-0.025869213,
0.0399598666,
0.0081082545,
-0.0080819866,
-0.0423919298,
0.0013136347,
-0.0519163199,
-0.003527117,
-0.0217743702,
0.003766228,
-0.0837595835,
-0.0059188623,
-0.069410637,
-0.0261658281,
-0.0515655875,
0.0169237461,
0.0372162722,
-0.0205132049,
0.0143592861,
-0.006507766,
-0.0571212545,
-0.0173201803,
0.0278398301,
0.0312359184,
-0.058646284,
0.0161874183,
0.0099661686,
-0.0466968007,
-0.0018677972,
0.0012208214,
0.003821627,
-0.0782847106,
0.020754274,
0.0670824796,
0.019160144,
-0.0460447297,
-0.0636386946,
-0.0237107463,
-0.0212330613,
-0.0695349351,
-0.0333594419,
-0.0621631257,
0.0084278053,
0.0140690757,
0.028818585,
-0.031695798,
-0.0294719413,
0.0009853265,
-0.0134926755,
0.0770688131,
-0.015739955,
0.0111958422,
0.0187787265,
0.0059333798,
0.0155999456,
0.0994463786,
0.0257619843,
-0.0041421838,
0.056553971,
-0.0148296058,
-0.0251036342,
0.0501727387,
0.0559229441,
0.0477143861,
-0.0405217707,
0.0190369692,
0.0609721616,
0.0265048519,
0.0308398288,
0.0376882665,
-0.0522461422,
-0.028079642,
0.0407219455,
0.0499186777,
0.0454998612,
0.0443816409,
0.0424938463,
-0.0278159045,
-0.0043514608,
0.0068086986,
-0.0506907851,
-0.0084356405,
0.0126764923,
0.0179044101,
0.0617595017,
0.056869667,
-0.0410877429,
-0.0173792262,
-0.0181165356,
-0.005657143,
-0.0043560956,
0.0053820219,
0.0674080998,
-0.0105873048,
0.0108723026,
0.0590905286,
0.0467303172,
-0.0440887548,
0.0256071575,
-0.0265830122,
-0.0162395071,
0.0686905384,
0.0202349685,
-0.0285646096,
0.0120082218,
-0.0019015311,
0.075579226,
0.0117703183,
0.0444843359,
-0.0047363839,
0.0440085046,
-0.0558796488,
-0.0340059623,
-0.0098550702,
0.0105846301,
0.0152195692,
0.049587436,
0.057585001,
0.0239070114,
-0.0703254938,
0.0111997575,
0.0269488264,
-0.0920989066,
-0.0461765863,
-0.0132615995,
0.0129664475,
0.0153377773,
0.0190314837,
-0.0151133677,
-0.0089644194,
0.0176713914,
-0.0342827216,
0.0123925703,
-0.0204560272,
-0.0822748765,
-0.0147330808,
0.0504245423,
0.0130944457,
0.0298913401,
-0.0155714694,
-0.0299646836,
-0.0439547598,
0.0186483655,
0.0025852225,
0.0720045045,
-0.0316166468,
0.0216883887,
-0.029512519,
0.0257683899,
-0.0411232598,
0.0338519551,
0.0216429047,
0.023272505,
0.0164258853,
0.0223706756,
0.0331810303,
-0.0170098394,
-0.0229605176,
0.0097753992,
0.0144862244,
0.0203619935,
0.0140675055,
0.002547933,
-0.0312083457,
-0.0084514525,
-0.0921351239,
-0.0010175229,
-0.0411626138,
0.0217939522,
0.0221078675,
0.0587642528,
-0.0129650394,
0.0053343503,
-0.0281591415,
-0.0168270525,
-0.0197565537,
0.0486983247,
-0.0009923379,
0.0451679304,
-0.0323792621,
-0.0161410198,
-0.0485643186,
0.0122215552,
0.0574024506,
-0.0090967128,
-0.0037596037,
-0.0635249913,
0.0432385094,
0.0060823928,
0.0324851349,
-0.034069322,
-0.0213170238,
-0.0049851378,
-0.027612973,
0.0386281013,
0.041811727,
0.0055531696,
0.0168369617,
0.0384158306,
-0.0107413232,
-0.0415582284,
0.0041084928,
-0.0180746764,
-0.0408950038,
-0.0447556674,
0.0220908541,
-0.0134624308,
0.0618770011,
-0.0482247397,
-0.02195655,
-0.0349355265,
-0.0133594889,
-0.0235392358,
-0.0058938819,
-0.0190633163,
0.0062131886,
-0.0210407451,
0.0655989572,
0.0069151088,
-0.0403221697,
0.0436148979,
-0.016163284,
0.005148957,
-0.0347911716,
-0.0257427543,
-0.0347029157,
0.0826734602,
-0.0178579949,
0.0165589843,
0.0068232818,
0.0028878276,
-0.0573274679,
-0.0035858832,
-0.0087939342,
0.0021614006,
0.0648231879,
-0.0396730117,
0.0344437845,
-0.0203204397,
-0.0642754063,
-0.0372351184,
-0.0140084187,
-0.0197506379,
0.006606414,
0.0083011715,
-0.0253683347,
-0.0138352569,
0.0199559908,
0.017825963,
0.0693563744,
0.0055536828,
-0.0036381853,
0.0015932564,
0.036818102,
0.04596892,
-0.0289420038,
0.0122945821,
-0.0510072,
-0.0134764174,
0.0204573013,
0.0326256789,
0.0124657331,
-0.0310389679,
0.0077091507,
0.0191819333,
-0.0297507085,
-0.0364778638,
0.0221690051,
0.0660983473,
-0.0462452583,
-0.0394602604,
0.1003589258,
0.0018105002,
-0.0781902,
0.0148091447,
0.0128233368,
0.0341383182,
0.0077875289,
0.0073978882,
-0.0937379077,
-0.0208085869,
0.0101883756,
-0.0083972877,
0.0326629058,
-0.0054084207,
-0.0204296764,
-0.1180869266,
-0.0203952342,
0.0356328301,
-0.0768847391,
-0.0165483281,
-0.0374197699,
0.004621584,
-0.0235750973,
0.0463957451,
0.029081177,
-0.0344623327,
0.0004515834,
0.0037421638,
0.0375367925,
-0.0766171366,
0.0446313657,
-0.0524267703,
0.0537247248,
0.0166565534,
-0.0007550435,
0.0015612158,
-0.0030804242,
0.074372448,
-0.0276788734,
0.0062669669,
0.01549049,
0.0615906306,
-0.0151778897,
-0.0038906126,
0.0300132371,
0.0171249192,
-0.0477774255,
-0.0197840631,
0.0271736253,
0.0635735914,
0.0053064777,
0.0183477756,
-0.0219899677,
-0.0493209548,
0.0144552272,
0.0643369928,
0.0253287889,
-0.0434760302,
0.0002021364,
-0.0024811502,
-0.0152130993,
-0.035860721,
0.0061543244,
0.004975745,
-0.0118632223,
-0.0255498774,
-0.0334039852,
-0.0358369313,
0.0171301104,
0.064288795,
0.0264597591,
-0.0177536681,
0.0008932036,
0.0236508623,
-0.0747873113,
0.0375846848,
-0.0688001961,
0.0449765511,
-0.0801858753,
-0.0126767801,
0.0218104739,
-0.0115000568,
-0.0064122067,
0.0085002482,
-0.0789503977,
-0.0650358796,
0.0131136868,
0.003907661,
0.0268608127,
0.0973033309,
0.0106805386,
-0.0452470742,
0.0706884861,
0.0316729136,
-0.0683604255,
0.0455728099,
0.0234762914,
0.0012696498,
0.0110437926,
0.0538579449,
-0.0460558198,
0.0291424394,
0.0351203755,
0.0223629232,
-0.006096188,
-0.0189141426,
-0.0114795594,
-0.0149220843,
0.0247332752,
-0.0287555605,
0.0016381014,
-0.0176488273,
0.0287535675,
-0.0338358916,
0.0118128723,
-0.0245288592,
0.0210299697,
0.0211653151,
0.0066833654,
-0.0077118236,
0.0093871364,
0.0406790152,
0.0362685621,
-0.0217389725,
0.0099586034,
-0.0227809604,
0.0207368638,
0.06771373,
0.0230746511,
-0.0181911997,
-0.0292420238,
-0.0185019299,
0.0464376658,
-0.0528881475,
0.0182905253,
0.0331947021,
0.0094555952,
-0.0482076854,
0.0388557278,
-0.0794351175,
0.0149534345,
-0.0334464423,
0.0116966171,
0.0337569416,
-0.0216933433,
0.0372551978,
-0.0110783186,
-0.0301955696,
-0.0357310474,
0.0122458991,
0.0095199049,
-0.0166234355,
0.0111522609,
0.0383506417,
-0.0203350335,
0.0180880334,
0.054194048,
0.0070639895,
0.0450124256,
0.0230356231,
0.0195210166,
-0.002019736,
0.0071303649,
-0.0243457556,
0.0348369405,
-0.011681743,
0.028427342,
-0.0510256961,
-0.0768342614,
-0.0122438297,
-0.0051350584,
-0.0323413536,
0.0076511996,
0.0469134264,
0.0624359362,
-0.0088586248,
0.012009033,
-0.003340919,
0.0351589546,
0.0156022869,
-0.0208935887,
-0.0014643312,
-6.174378852e-33,
0.0107772183,
0.0233768225,
0.0282474328,
-0.0444496349,
-0.0512695611,
0.0147494366,
-0.0172320809,
-0.0095298029,
-0.0163494963,
0.0015591431,
-0.0339121707,
0.0026935758,
0.0090538785,
0.0477759913,
-0.0131885624,
-0.0005179917,
0.0687825009,
-0.0056003043,
-0.010904992,
0.0444494672,
0.0312332418,
0.0235137306,
0.0616015308,
-0.0494814776,
-0.0105584878,
0.0029705742,
0.0167895705,
0.0039080745,
0.0148843853,
0.0685344487,
-0.0381759852,
0.0430145115,
0.0139090726,
-0.0631065816,
-0.0143100098,
0.0006980178,
-0.116087921,
-0.0285404306,
0.0166704189,
0.0265845507,
0.00898223,
-0.0205146745,
0.0231253617,
-0.0099386955,
-0.013417202,
-0.0349250473,
0.0188949164,
-0.0350949131,
-0.0275925435,
-0.0322092995,
-0.0481757671,
0.032223206,
0.023271665,
0.0044297958,
0.0362004377,
0.0056648497,
0.0023513022,
-0.00001506,
-0.0256368238,
0.0094948038,
0.0514556915,
0.0496775024,
0.0261790659,
0.0423209108,
0.0297139101,
0.0513737537,
0.0112601742,
-0.0135108177,
-0.0074595856,
0.0011188643,
0.0513563678,
0.007276447,
-0.0118551888,
0.0561239906,
0.0532762334,
-0.0334036686,
-0.075120531,
-0.0186060593,
0.0002737816,
-0.0140635306,
0.0225949232,
0.0266296808,
-0.0273394268,
-0.038446378,
-0.0418637283,
-0.0195916109,
-0.0319584012,
-0.034628626,
0.0367862433,
0.0346447863,
-0.0079308227,
0.0245143156,
0.0396631882,
-0.0596758984,
-0.0743662342,
0.04193075,
-0.007368125,
0.0114736017,
0.0022955933,
0.0247195642,
-0.0037284035,
-0.0372019149,
0.0167582463,
0.0281570125,
0.0015670552,
-0.0151795577,
0.0511180386,
0.0447788052,
-0.0817904621,
-0.0269318372,
-0.0479273424,
-0.0009278297,
0.0232717022,
0.0429227613,
0.0421939231,
0.0306334309,
0.006120747,
0.0679746196,
0.0187962502,
-0.0343451463,
-0.0190386549,
-0.0301215723,
0.0077389218,
0.0431044772,
-0.050297901,
-0.021439746,
-0.0298475903,
-0.0075258631,
0.08175648,
-0.0667754188,
-0.0348689295,
-0.0028614043,
2.659e-7,
0.0392706841,
0.0128500098,
0.0311665051,
-0.0344230458,
0.0152181601,
0.0080175269,
-0.0072331731,
0.0229859352,
-0.0148584759,
-0.0212668348,
-0.0021539347,
0.0264645182,
0.0166248884,
0.0212413669,
-0.0840928108,
0.0116910134,
-0.0302976724,
0.0205940474,
-0.056368798,
-0.000875912,
0.0159990788,
0.142871812,
0.0283290893,
-0.0265384968,
0.0265082382,
-0.0508752875,
0.0441745594,
-0.0501940213,
0.0246107727,
0.014118108,
-0.035489995,
0.0446768254,
0.0264796522,
-0.004699125,
0.0000724094,
0.0236907229,
-0.0204325896,
0.0683051124,
-0.0090454388,
0.0013961442,
0.0058716177,
-0.0263724439,
-0.0405500419,
-0.0500722863,
0.0783441588,
-0.0500705913,
-0.0189867765,
-0.0309184752,
-0.0066277767,
-0.0391867384,
0.0064852238,
0.0025552616,
-0.0083777718,
0.0427875184,
0.0253544487,
0.0163252726,
-0.0010163587,
-0.118461892,
-0.024813991,
0.0080608902,
-0.0387214273,
-0.0516789779,
-0.0510823056,
0.0029974519,
0.0448166989,
-0.0577056818,
0.0087650148,
2.62202946e-34,
0.0723581091,
-0.0166955292,
0.016900694,
-0.010856065,
-0.0046378267,
-0.0415952802,
0.026275523,
-0.0029282297,
0.0121616712,
-0.0754844323,
-0.024276033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10153v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10153v2 | Knowledge-Infused LLM-Powered Conversational Health Agent: A Case Study for Diabetes Patients | 2024-02-15T18:00:02 | 2024-02-28T19:40:13 | Mahyar Abbasian, Zhongqi Yang, Elahe Khatibi, Pengfei Zhang, Nitish Nagesh, Iman Azimi, Ramesh Jain, Amir M. Rahmani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Effective diabetes management is crucial for maintaining health in diabetic
patients. Large Language Models (LLMs) have opened new avenues for diabetes
management, facilitating their efficacy. However, current LLM-based approaches
are limited by their dependence on general sources and lack of integration with
domain-specific knowledge, leading to inaccurate responses. In this paper, we
propose a knowledge-infused LLM-powered conversational health agent (CHA) for
diabetic patients. We customize and leverage the open-source openCHA framework,
enhancing our CHA with external knowledge and analytical capabilities. This
integration involves two key components: 1) incorporating the American Diabetes
Association dietary guidelines and the Nutritionix information and 2) deploying
analytical tools that enable nutritional intake calculation and comparison with
the guidelines. We compare the proposed CHA with GPT4. Our evaluation includes
100 diabetes-related questions on daily meal choices and assessing the
potential risks associated with the suggested diet. Our findings show that the
proposed agent demonstrates superior performance in generating responses to
manage essential nutrients. | [
0.0619049966,
0.0603973232,
0.0087575931,
0.0260291956,
0.0187209994,
0.0044255792,
-0.0182048865,
0.0256978683,
0.0814415216,
-0.0145563101,
0.0204228479,
0.0068047857,
-0.02541559,
0.0576744713,
-0.0080713267,
-0.0171453673,
0.0086538922,
-0.0072995266,
0.0393891744,
0.0088898716,
0.0341291241,
-0.0025927657,
-0.0520815887,
0.0549927354,
-0.0066329292,
-0.02136641,
0.0002136642,
-0.0174936336,
0.0099400543,
-0.073082082,
0.0098040476,
0.0557417013,
-0.0557670891,
0.0106060477,
0.0000019617,
-0.0558227226,
-0.0125267981,
0.03681821,
-0.0571122207,
-0.0265370235,
0.055445496,
-0.0074443123,
-0.0022245401,
0.0305848587,
-0.0641990751,
0.0275977887,
0.0726777464,
0.045053985,
0.056505803,
0.0337320454,
-0.0154314302,
-0.0316981822,
0.0020064018,
-0.0131849712,
0.0136674419,
-0.0241275094,
0.0259130672,
0.0213045888,
0.0369618721,
-0.0031941859,
0.0379393809,
0.027905073,
-0.0066653811,
-0.0027664725,
-0.0045875367,
0.0270444937,
-0.0093368012,
-0.0347014777,
-0.0225962475,
0.094097957,
0.0637633801,
0.0551911667,
0.0162384156,
0.0249891896,
0.0145209534,
-0.0012970372,
-0.0245291032,
-0.0209977869,
-0.0264411438,
0.014467394,
-0.0348330513,
0.0026979046,
0.0212029535,
-0.0087012323,
-0.0282926019,
0.0583092868,
-0.0045373109,
-0.0071394644,
-0.0099384701,
-0.0361030959,
-0.00008149,
-0.071880579,
-0.007601406,
0.0746427029,
-0.0215407461,
0.0172356572,
0.0311942995,
0.0394787639,
0.0746931508,
-0.0462906435,
0.021698609,
0.0670449585,
-0.006231186,
-0.0015679578,
0.053194955,
0.00720267,
-0.0073235608,
0.0115144541,
-0.0522997454,
-0.0004302663,
-0.0594949909,
-0.0196828526,
-0.0350527503,
0.0516631044,
-0.0349651352,
-0.0227282085,
-0.064207837,
0.0306764301,
-0.0045477576,
0.0007489235,
0.0104035204,
0.0263231471,
0.0235208645,
0.0198725387,
-0.085398443,
0.0443514921,
-0.0117557663,
0.0133966077,
0.0284639541,
-0.0461127385,
0.0367735028,
-0.003763356,
-0.0036768538,
0.025113415,
0.0037445719,
0.1013616025,
0.0077146073,
-0.0297833085,
-0.0028328379,
-0.0445455499,
-0.0629627928,
-0.0465433635,
-0.047319781,
-0.0817473084,
0.0424849167,
-0.0021362761,
0.0099514239,
-0.0454020835,
0.0523113422,
0.0394198708,
-0.0195912477,
0.0716508701,
-0.0265185572,
-0.0031196733,
0.0478311777,
0.034827292,
0.0109144421,
0.0579156615,
0.0087205712,
-0.0041284021,
0.012457069,
0.0107536931,
0.0051050796,
0.0286941417,
0.0195978489,
-0.0234980956,
0.0465917215,
0.0219344944,
-0.006617377,
0.0491327643,
-0.0822921544,
0.0690217242,
-0.0191368517,
0.0372799374,
0.0896063671,
0.0800456256,
0.0187657326,
-0.0011834574,
0.009931365,
0.0167184267,
0.0255427193,
-0.05269517,
-0.0035376423,
0.0262340903,
-0.0613327548,
-0.019324515,
-0.0236563273,
0.0066202283,
-0.0425212458,
-0.0509954616,
-0.0116114048,
-0.0591819733,
0.0297732316,
-0.0190374199,
0.0381313786,
-0.0154823456,
-0.0087659257,
0.0792572722,
0.0215045512,
-0.0510469526,
-0.050268881,
-0.0362923071,
0.0399496928,
0.0681027994,
0.0385422222,
-0.0250957683,
-0.0198806413,
0.0004607258,
-0.0009597749,
0.031697236,
0.0233190861,
-0.0270116273,
0.007492614,
-0.050830178,
-0.0036473523,
-0.0085957078,
0.0042544999,
-0.0256512742,
-0.0150173251,
0.0614288338,
-0.0171537977,
0.0438693613,
0.0073287594,
0.0020595456,
0.0124764368,
-0.0425398946,
0.0255475827,
-0.0107716555,
0.020859912,
0.058978498,
0.0561031848,
0.0489648841,
0.0104535045,
-0.0163928773,
-0.0339359418,
0.0166840982,
0.0191013813,
-0.023569528,
0.0313207731,
0.0078087002,
0.008922549,
-0.0404227674,
-0.0141407717,
-0.0322141387,
-0.0288995542,
-0.0458100215,
0.0411861427,
-0.0294371806,
-0.0151065234,
0.0493742973,
0.022217175,
-0.0314125046,
0.0298475083,
0.0081847478,
-0.0303419903,
0.0171481371,
-0.018128613,
-0.0201124977,
-0.0323637314,
0.010415718,
0.0055198376,
-0.0038325854,
0.0289381742,
-0.0067203082,
0.0249777958,
-0.0534852892,
-0.011425565,
-0.0988776311,
0.0031449485,
-0.0012237246,
-0.0032818001,
0.0106728701,
0.0579801314,
0.0246708095,
-0.021768529,
-0.0452950709,
0.0270943362,
0.0175864976,
0.0282282308,
0.0211401582,
0.0488890111,
0.0090931524,
-0.0047700088,
0.0346411914,
-0.0090327645,
-0.0010799305,
-0.0067539667,
0.001917502,
-0.0228528921,
-0.0317412838,
-0.0689683929,
-0.0069761151,
0.0059890496,
-0.0209930819,
0.0088506257,
0.0168182142,
0.0184507687,
0.0031117615,
-0.0100380322,
0.01325991,
0.0248658862,
-0.0276636481,
-0.0484466776,
0.0014843646,
-0.0592488907,
-0.00890831,
-0.0342867412,
-0.0467475727,
0.0211138614,
0.0566309243,
0.0212945305,
0.0687084273,
-0.0198703632,
0.0346678868,
-0.0011510461,
-0.0039903582,
-0.046412468,
0.0534593351,
-0.0271485429,
0.062470004,
0.0092733158,
-0.017572606,
0.0662083626,
-0.0248641968,
-0.0054922579,
-0.0386907607,
-0.0432754159,
-0.0451833457,
-0.0078172283,
-0.0184651949,
0.0317351259,
0.0413989127,
-0.0063350662,
0.0031592511,
-0.0212384854,
-0.0173220523,
-0.0514419675,
0.0798075125,
-0.052230753,
0.0139961485,
0.007900835,
-0.0358978771,
-0.0391786955,
0.0060052099,
-0.0619749166,
0.0038258703,
-0.0095060058,
-0.0019705095,
-0.0586113855,
0.0195264947,
-0.0095674954,
0.0318827108,
0.0292242374,
-0.0362010784,
0.0030033165,
-0.0123950774,
0.0465216339,
0.0104393056,
-0.0085076429,
0.0132117616,
0.096378468,
0.0883908644,
-0.0356046446,
-0.0458357781,
0.0248114988,
-0.005160803,
-0.0023993638,
-0.0085492646,
0.0416919552,
0.0214867387,
0.016031146,
-0.0008078989,
0.01459789,
0.1073434278,
0.0184585452,
-0.0560436398,
0.0309176985,
-0.0367421769,
-0.0404653735,
-0.0165600535,
0.0231102277,
-0.133720383,
-0.0306001231,
-0.0296300184,
0.0319841839,
-0.0523169823,
-0.0216355864,
-0.0105917137,
-0.0353437439,
0.0088543268,
0.0134780938,
-0.0145417368,
0.0005095956,
0.0154759325,
0.007456698,
-0.0237706043,
-0.002349267,
-0.0024074549,
-0.0106956055,
-0.0085397987,
-0.0211952124,
-0.08386489,
-0.0312408395,
0.0229688827,
0.00836844,
0.0341713354,
0.0858779922,
0.0534027219,
0.0337633155,
-0.0100796064,
-0.0042340243,
-0.0164215919,
-0.0111997547,
-0.0419807769,
0.0493924506,
0.0291827414,
-0.0056181019,
-0.0578341559,
0.0506312735,
-0.0502281375,
-0.0261672009,
0.0201498233,
0.0872524381,
-0.0093325283,
0.0077066356,
-0.0303736906,
-0.0048019872,
0.0534251593,
0.0344081931,
-0.0068562748,
-0.0088957315,
-0.031166615,
-0.0363355689,
-0.0397793278,
0.0422072001,
-0.0300891548,
0.0350595042,
-0.0123679675,
-0.0085947923,
-0.0484822653,
-0.0173473042,
0.0332789309,
0.0002995731,
0.0002448097,
0.0347115435,
0.0447983854,
0.0450952686,
-0.0030175208,
0.019959515,
-0.0155305266,
0.0187045466,
-0.0426764786,
-0.047365129,
0.0477305241,
-0.0249919426,
0.0012047946,
0.0282430109,
-0.023846671,
-0.0447286107,
-0.0339558534,
0.0736032352,
0.0316500515,
0.0107131116,
-0.0174697395,
-0.0088323979,
-0.0044268607,
0.0267771501,
-0.0571130663,
-0.0155935893,
-0.0128889112,
0.0578984655,
0.0434058793,
0.0201314557,
-0.0258521941,
0.0115367221,
-0.0585793816,
0.0096200714,
-0.0583813861,
-0.0602638423,
0.0099859834,
0.0208385848,
-0.0037104394,
0.0416152626,
-0.0127339335,
0.0031803292,
0.0489891581,
-0.0671857148,
-0.0163414963,
-0.050959751,
-0.0071213036,
-0.0201954804,
-0.0099618044,
0.0195442382,
-0.0310631394,
-0.0628780201,
-0.0220230147,
-0.0260348916,
0.0398197435,
0.0037239853,
0.0261552688,
0.0415546745,
-0.013776538,
0.007341139,
0.020087691,
-0.0139407078,
-0.0006624187,
-0.013665597,
0.0855165273,
-0.039217785,
-0.0115302261,
-0.0081602018,
0.0185901597,
-0.0518655218,
-0.0801796615,
0.0073908335,
0.0177838653,
-0.0000248882,
0.0340468176,
0.0292706173,
-0.0330481119,
0.0038088541,
-0.0198215861,
0.01704235,
0.0163412578,
-0.0161593631,
0.0707922876,
-0.0046877493,
-0.0158304907,
-0.0754713714,
0.0671380758,
-0.0403942391,
0.0190053489,
-0.0304972883,
-0.0447308384,
-0.0589549318,
-0.0260604247,
0.0262984782,
0.0102466606,
-0.0685117841,
-0.0358022973,
-0.0590538308,
-0.0577404685,
0.0192049425,
-0.0266852491,
-0.0499399081,
-0.0206995197,
0.0419986621,
0.0076308637,
0.0259556025,
-0.0382960327,
-0.0422139801,
0.0239715669,
-0.0801442042,
-0.0002452869,
0.0331147164,
-5.861188586e-33,
-0.0007889887,
-0.0435352847,
0.03772581,
0.0575593375,
0.0355289094,
-0.0122915031,
-0.0434743389,
0.0026054699,
-0.0040730988,
0.0207933895,
0.0267852899,
0.0004690352,
0.0132505931,
0.0148106124,
-0.0141081363,
-0.0463774577,
0.0283485167,
0.0090181865,
-0.0105413375,
0.0211579613,
0.0089008193,
0.0393549427,
-0.0047456818,
-0.0700828806,
0.0510783903,
0.0112080146,
0.0152212959,
0.0241936836,
-0.0081533669,
0.0764509067,
-0.0425821915,
0.0871902555,
0.0179084651,
0.0299288724,
-0.0163598247,
0.0312258843,
-0.0201504342,
-0.0627166852,
0.0019721426,
-0.0511697195,
-0.0382396132,
-0.0391628407,
-0.0053271642,
-0.0241885763,
-0.0442112535,
0.0474381745,
0.0196110867,
-0.0502067357,
-0.0045684678,
0.0187830087,
-0.0577609651,
0.0173573866,
0.0097065503,
0.008035548,
-0.0249486975,
0.0492570736,
-0.0100685591,
-0.0213878397,
-0.0004601438,
0.0236074142,
0.016107494,
-0.0120817022,
0.0083147688,
0.0037363933,
-0.0248786081,
0.0212331936,
0.0032445476,
-0.0240073372,
-0.0512433536,
-0.0200837869,
-0.0799451768,
0.0580774322,
0.0656401962,
0.0393401608,
-0.0567108504,
-0.0150251202,
-0.068360284,
0.0302265249,
0.0014805711,
-0.0023851348,
0.0058631082,
0.0131730577,
-0.0074449219,
-0.0203347616,
-0.0095826061,
0.0820518434,
-0.0654901266,
-0.0636947379,
0.0207408816,
-0.0057843309,
0.0168453362,
0.0026475822,
-0.0208030511,
0.004356964,
0.0282655153,
0.0234688837,
0.0553994998,
-0.0177379288,
-0.0194323435,
-0.0210827515,
-0.0752366632,
0.0165115558,
-0.0025120131,
0.0118907811,
0.0174524896,
0.0285793915,
-0.030043669,
-0.0137862125,
-0.0085971355,
-0.0188726485,
-0.0111762928,
0.0315207839,
-0.0105434665,
-0.0113104545,
-0.0188935865,
0.0030187245,
-0.0058719129,
0.1050412059,
-0.0214747563,
-0.0159112532,
-0.0696428493,
0.0027859686,
0.0388238467,
-0.0344003774,
-0.0495159887,
-0.0123199541,
-0.0348119065,
0.0438795798,
-0.0051669721,
-0.0217216499,
0.0199306719,
-0.0375398211,
2.682e-7,
0.0793236941,
0.0178320706,
-0.0312434305,
-0.0119980071,
0.0215625111,
0.0175514482,
0.0118805533,
-0.0061618006,
-0.0276069492,
0.0070996466,
0.0246661454,
-0.001514798,
0.026831679,
0.0669092461,
-0.0312098842,
-0.0446538478,
-0.0384903364,
-0.0426018089,
-0.0568169393,
-0.0053449366,
0.0742743909,
0.0491177514,
-0.0182571504,
-0.0183262061,
-0.0099551212,
-0.0197028834,
0.0459926911,
-0.0435067974,
0.0036416634,
0.0171426497,
0.0067949495,
-0.0166347884,
0.0361812487,
-0.0130610904,
-0.0132955881,
-0.02995825,
-0.0191906374,
0.0883102566,
-0.0431668796,
-0.0176145323,
0.0235586278,
-0.0164033324,
0.0168439448,
-0.0524681471,
0.0321339816,
-0.064137198,
-0.068943806,
0.0122780688,
0.0347721949,
-0.0628477633,
-0.0039383359,
-0.0156800561,
-0.0325417109,
0.0033554924,
0.0044019618,
0.0159341767,
0.0145248892,
-0.0219921358,
-0.025242094,
-0.0022186071,
-0.0427185558,
-0.0655435324,
-0.0165429972,
-0.0290389825,
-0.0403206423,
-0.0547297932,
0.040981628,
2.132814425e-34,
0.0090643242,
0.0355250835,
0.0036355131,
0.0612702817,
0.0399533249,
0.0284845028,
0.0224995669,
0.0102744587,
0.0367724001,
-0.0988540053,
-0.0272027925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10151v1 | ControlLM: Crafting Diverse Personalities for Language Models | 2024-02-15T17:58:29 | 2024-02-15T17:58:29 | Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Shengping Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | As language models continue to scale in size and capability, they display an
array of emerging behaviors, both beneficial and concerning. This heightens the
need to control model behaviors. We hope to be able to control the personality
traits of language models at the inference-time so as to have various character
features, on top of which the requirements of different types of tasks can be
met. Personality is a higher-level and more abstract behavioral representation
for language models. We introduce ControlLM, which leverages differential
activation patterns, derived from contrasting behavioral prompts in the model's
latent space, to influence the model's personality traits at inference. This
approach allows for the precise, real-time adjustment of model behavior. First,
we demonstrate ControlLM's capacity to elicit diverse persona behaviors without
any training, while precision control allows personality traits to closely
match average human values. Subsequently, we showcase improved reasoning and
question answering through selective amplification of beneficial attributes
like conscientiousness and friendliness. We hope that this work will inspire
research on controlling human-like behaviors of language models and provide
insights for future research. Our code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/wengsyx/ControlLM. | [
0.0596366338,
0.0799580663,
-0.0440750569,
0.0317475237,
-0.0303857457,
0.0033760176,
0.0182458591,
-0.0354105942,
-0.011057104,
0.0284016114,
-0.0195376351,
-0.0205918625,
-0.0432376824,
0.0503922775,
0.0422454439,
-0.0633303225,
0.0621287748,
-0.0219747946,
0.0496057905,
-0.0403973311,
-0.0015461501,
0.042487964,
0.0048679244,
0.0435509272,
0.0084572155,
-0.024884358,
-0.0131618911,
-0.0131919309,
0.0400747731,
0.0123714786,
0.0502109118,
0.0508705862,
0.0312879048,
-0.0066787908,
0.00000209,
-0.0403521024,
-0.0000636987,
-0.0270769466,
0.0252485052,
-0.0354025662,
0.0700059161,
0.0484119169,
0.0040490464,
0.0107636517,
-0.0596254542,
0.0025042349,
0.0324703529,
0.0511453673,
0.05333459,
0.0458355993,
0.0043438701,
-0.0149529204,
-0.020326972,
-0.0000800696,
0.035382174,
-0.0084439022,
0.0075216787,
-0.02140674,
0.0193366017,
0.0050515397,
-0.0128090056,
0.0125982994,
0.0328259282,
-0.0021236786,
0.0129551897,
0.0028527668,
-0.0012998021,
-0.0324761681,
-0.0067225951,
0.0662771985,
-0.0097126253,
-0.0484435856,
-0.0026772826,
-0.0095400512,
0.0320113637,
-0.0028927177,
-0.0069981162,
0.0209034327,
0.0107875513,
0.0028796555,
0.025725875,
0.0212278161,
-0.0037361514,
0.0121955778,
-0.024051765,
0.0465446003,
0.0082117235,
-0.0134166507,
-0.0261975601,
-0.0092025315,
-0.0022766807,
-0.049610924,
0.0111624608,
0.0283503495,
-0.0491949357,
0.0181424432,
-0.0631999671,
-0.0021908497,
0.0259939842,
-0.0102517828,
0.0234732013,
0.0380086452,
-0.008554142,
0.017949773,
0.0464400835,
0.0478927642,
-0.0028398694,
0.0394867584,
-0.0088039106,
-0.0297997072,
-0.0391890742,
-0.0270443149,
-0.0257622395,
-0.0030291791,
0.0146092167,
-0.0046837837,
-0.0270265397,
0.0572620928,
-0.043060407,
-0.0231441222,
-0.0067285863,
0.0370189361,
-0.0242568478,
0.0057989904,
-0.054835014,
0.006344012,
-0.0890228227,
-0.035354387,
0.0230978653,
-0.0320440643,
0.002036955,
-0.0237092488,
0.0230788719,
-0.0474842489,
0.0196291283,
0.0423646271,
0.005815546,
-0.0262892582,
-0.0114901541,
-0.0274933502,
-0.0130701065,
-0.0557476133,
0.0185717195,
-0.0499126799,
0.0209105127,
-0.0246987939,
-0.0168912765,
-0.0853762776,
-0.0053331838,
0.0161662772,
0.0019795913,
0.0595742017,
-0.0139320893,
0.012103322,
0.0029516215,
0.0094195642,
-0.0117160743,
0.0699643195,
0.0213522185,
-0.0071412562,
0.0274956599,
-0.0145560959,
0.0414866433,
0.0453349724,
0.0183590539,
-0.0028938667,
-0.037990164,
-0.004672084,
0.0034683368,
0.002306032,
0.0660795718,
0.044382602,
-0.026987819,
-0.0277390238,
0.0835473537,
0.0706675723,
-0.0175339077,
0.0274950732,
0.030637078,
0.0411253087,
0.0163625348,
-0.0099903615,
-0.0533679575,
0.0458130576,
-0.0077131386,
0.0131659256,
-0.048190888,
0.0516636036,
-0.0111545501,
-0.0367953517,
0.0034340397,
-0.0014824058,
0.0592828169,
0.0399636887,
-0.0126723517,
0.0126105724,
0.0174449999,
0.0221022498,
0.0514665619,
-0.0647869557,
-0.0294701792,
-0.0715977252,
0.0380741432,
0.0957046077,
0.0246956386,
-0.0140354326,
-0.0392200798,
-0.0049726483,
-0.0253996532,
0.0525200069,
0.056133166,
-0.0214594863,
0.0134240398,
-0.0213947613,
0.0028064225,
-0.0086952085,
0.0006913846,
0.0071878508,
0.0307487883,
0.0122618061,
-0.0353654139,
0.0092062913,
-0.012390512,
0.0101730311,
-0.0718249902,
-0.0229072757,
-0.003662837,
0.0289619695,
0.0103951693,
0.0096528511,
0.0159525089,
-0.0162117966,
0.0055687218,
-0.0068616066,
-0.0262371432,
0.0546091869,
-0.0210018568,
-0.0012102679,
0.0378388092,
-0.0154399611,
-0.0516264141,
0.0528760664,
0.0063845352,
-0.0050768494,
0.019376196,
-0.043895267,
0.0476615876,
-0.0252762381,
-0.0225067642,
-0.0463251248,
0.0486511178,
-0.0216927361,
0.0558125526,
-0.0215032976,
-0.0188021306,
0.0401420072,
0.034519501,
-0.0405845158,
-0.0540820621,
-0.0104489243,
-0.0254803319,
0.0164762158,
0.0204620529,
0.0262813885,
0.0268267952,
-0.0451384895,
-0.0495943241,
-0.0343479738,
-0.0181963779,
-0.0102921529,
-0.0208736472,
0.0190601032,
0.0257467497,
-0.0302622505,
-0.0044561015,
-0.0586739033,
-0.0056961128,
0.0182267968,
0.0139375562,
0.0439771414,
-0.0211960822,
-0.045470681,
-0.0568701476,
-0.0038567097,
-0.0164931025,
0.0174014457,
-0.0444362573,
0.0536544621,
-0.0225043446,
-0.0403303467,
-0.049397774,
0.0362816826,
-0.0088986289,
-0.0654878169,
0.0361536145,
-0.0318168998,
0.0203557797,
0.0781176463,
0.0406364426,
0.0370631553,
0.038370423,
0.0123548387,
-0.0834510103,
0.0334168673,
-0.0244992319,
0.0255975965,
-0.0364918821,
-0.0418663584,
-0.0246138703,
0.0764987096,
-0.0072135092,
-0.0049813907,
-0.0915815607,
0.0620713532,
0.0217764657,
-0.0826682597,
0.0405466296,
0.0316753462,
-0.0339864232,
0.0412713997,
0.0014134631,
-0.0365037881,
0.1100343391,
0.0200344864,
-0.0230938885,
-0.0348915607,
-0.0278753433,
-0.0061255167,
0.0859238505,
0.0078852344,
0.0015446553,
0.0509288087,
-0.0007538166,
-0.0442131758,
-0.0176683236,
-0.007309984,
-0.0286917668,
0.0403440297,
-0.0264070258,
-0.0427624434,
0.0470930226,
-0.0259064753,
-0.0520738736,
-0.0363913812,
-0.0497589,
-0.0087484168,
0.0026227217,
-0.0390049294,
-0.0234513301,
-0.0520438775,
0.0108554848,
-0.0086951107,
-0.0590325072,
0.0047626048,
-0.0377415009,
-0.0535385944,
0.1026336923,
0.0509773865,
0.0140008209,
-0.0443480313,
-0.0187032484,
-0.0028396898,
-0.0342165157,
-0.0157908704,
-0.0064695296,
0.0222833324,
0.0390691981,
-0.0081668282,
0.0106609389,
0.0279131941,
0.0731504634,
-0.0384549759,
-0.0379132591,
0.1321550459,
0.0227191076,
-0.0310039353,
0.0380041301,
-0.0256307386,
0.0830471516,
0.0344862156,
0.0684323236,
-0.0481536984,
-0.0279824827,
-0.010018643,
0.0270864479,
-0.0276890825,
-0.0225691963,
-0.0209669638,
-0.0876731277,
0.0285608303,
0.0106144408,
-0.0506114401,
-0.0136095975,
0.0036862541,
-0.0060201362,
-0.0170410965,
0.0226654075,
-0.0102592641,
0.0099324742,
-0.0145257311,
-0.0271205399,
-0.0079113692,
-0.0412672125,
0.0778774023,
-0.0405419916,
0.0677132085,
0.0402201526,
0.0322406553,
0.0019681845,
-0.0605907589,
-0.0534478277,
0.0318275653,
0.0073071504,
0.0204306394,
0.0307879485,
-0.0105245681,
0.0027640946,
-0.0552750863,
0.0515818708,
-0.0149443904,
-0.0124367997,
-0.0229335539,
0.0734508336,
0.0008564773,
-0.0490437187,
-0.0495510735,
0.0121085914,
0.060615968,
0.0587832034,
0.0395618752,
-0.1169808134,
-0.0261396151,
-0.017426068,
-0.045568455,
-0.0463728346,
-0.0776611418,
-0.0152180949,
0.0237082019,
-0.0326914974,
-0.0436287634,
-0.0793082416,
0.0109895878,
0.0125590032,
-0.020177206,
-0.0522822477,
0.0043421639,
0.0295752566,
-0.0215689708,
0.0322138816,
-0.0276863985,
0.0282025095,
-0.0314627476,
-0.0522151105,
0.0321980268,
-0.0589215197,
-0.0072325543,
0.0026428481,
-0.060190592,
-0.0796605274,
0.0526562296,
0.0488986224,
0.0256437529,
0.059891358,
-0.0162299834,
-0.0901748613,
0.0090927072,
0.0012696084,
-0.0152608948,
0.0418377519,
0.0262529179,
0.0177756567,
-0.0049298187,
0.0486838371,
-0.0381462127,
0.0421171114,
-0.0031672921,
-0.004116728,
-0.0323903114,
-0.0684916526,
0.0109409615,
-0.0034953889,
-0.0145283183,
-0.0007014393,
-0.0362907164,
-0.0262670107,
-0.0252453182,
-0.0228053536,
-0.0308400858,
-0.0146051645,
-0.0347472653,
-0.0143503146,
-0.0190489702,
0.0014033235,
-0.0506822802,
-0.0237286724,
0.0194786042,
-0.0471394472,
0.002720281,
0.0239716154,
0.0316035263,
0.0077981525,
0.0304995421,
-0.0179944523,
0.0060695889,
-0.0199635047,
0.050259199,
-0.0010575252,
0.041742146,
0.0038053996,
-0.0073624505,
-0.0256929677,
0.0278732851,
-0.0881836414,
-0.0395449735,
0.0274039023,
-0.0147403236,
0.0213176329,
0.0225183237,
0.0658238158,
-0.0378506705,
-0.0009732256,
-0.0019079689,
0.0226164758,
0.0188705847,
-0.0289687179,
0.0108713284,
0.0127395121,
-0.0043708826,
-0.0573312007,
0.0299643744,
0.0054577179,
0.0379032791,
-0.0264418293,
0.0246289354,
-0.0357852466,
0.0037391223,
-0.0013263241,
0.0195829608,
-0.0166294929,
0.0060188072,
-0.0722304806,
-0.0799462721,
0.0495109186,
0.0461267866,
-0.015050021,
-0.0246703587,
0.0240235534,
0.0196365081,
-0.0081140473,
-0.0405267216,
-0.043228481,
0.0208753999,
-0.0119336108,
0.0037230127,
-0.0280901641,
-6.127074021e-33,
-0.0271269549,
-0.0052888584,
0.0231579877,
-0.0132258357,
-0.0130321942,
-0.0443811379,
-0.0475491509,
0.0335409828,
-0.044612322,
0.0138021009,
-0.0479265377,
0.0079153143,
0.0054500382,
0.00213983,
0.0184221976,
0.0116383852,
0.0468157493,
-0.0088355122,
-0.0108433682,
0.0309651643,
0.0252548736,
0.0148362182,
0.0507082753,
-0.0573763773,
0.0184255578,
-0.0216885023,
-0.0142544098,
0.0133647826,
-0.0103002191,
0.0729765445,
0.0025754359,
0.0237640161,
0.000861369,
0.0175729301,
-0.0410795249,
0.0281898994,
-0.070934169,
-0.0570902191,
0.0119934641,
0.0079781134,
-0.0399436429,
-0.0698953941,
0.0189166255,
-0.0250616614,
-0.0141453734,
-0.0208776351,
0.0428530835,
0.003594355,
0.0477371141,
0.0172236208,
-0.0726419017,
-0.0078252191,
-0.0095273163,
-0.0130039956,
-0.0117479172,
0.0188249759,
-0.0075176382,
0.0060657472,
-0.0453962199,
0.0500423275,
-0.0144014535,
-0.027099913,
0.0391860306,
0.0417863466,
0.0294675734,
0.0489077754,
0.0547867157,
0.0565319322,
-0.0015733385,
-0.0039321049,
0.0755991265,
0.0325542577,
0.0228963755,
0.0649158731,
0.0105877928,
-0.0319184661,
0.0055429093,
-0.0045500733,
0.0780458599,
-0.0088057732,
0.0326515883,
0.0173695646,
-0.0418101214,
-0.0140750511,
-0.0235192273,
0.0224946402,
-0.0148892719,
-0.0371196307,
0.0144845275,
-0.0057700565,
-0.0565226115,
-0.0355619825,
0.0266986303,
-0.0637089014,
-0.0075939349,
0.0390457921,
-0.0383881852,
0.0165003389,
0.0141893663,
0.0014911868,
-0.0254665464,
-0.0002925429,
-0.0024866932,
0.0001972757,
0.039447993,
0.0721315742,
0.0209964439,
0.0478551872,
-0.0521974675,
-0.0026175878,
-0.0113632381,
0.0354413874,
-0.0186634585,
0.030039141,
0.0071816198,
0.0172427185,
-0.0139897903,
0.0156237967,
0.0107294917,
-0.012636058,
-0.0594384857,
0.0371477045,
0.0257517267,
0.0156081859,
-0.0396912061,
-0.0205496158,
-0.0802417696,
0.0400207825,
0.0219455063,
-0.049024608,
0.0176999848,
0.0138357962,
2.684e-7,
-0.0173856337,
0.0375790894,
-0.0039452678,
0.0944038108,
0.0408733487,
0.0384286977,
0.0093578659,
0.0267871823,
0.0269649476,
-0.0317609198,
-0.0101152742,
0.0411716178,
0.0333308391,
0.0400447175,
-0.0893803686,
0.0177959315,
-0.0264585968,
0.0234294105,
-0.0112974383,
-0.006710812,
0.0478236377,
0.0785720646,
0.0480284877,
-0.0062412433,
0.0298204198,
0.0242591631,
0.0304113403,
0.0016493825,
0.0135291526,
0.0086070513,
-0.0398554243,
-0.0144393239,
0.0076317322,
0.0073294458,
-0.0174204595,
0.0175294019,
-0.0436600335,
0.0870396048,
-0.0440212786,
-0.0457377806,
-0.0086895721,
-0.0192218348,
-0.0268103648,
-0.0386673771,
0.0632438883,
-0.0121368654,
-0.0166971255,
-0.0260071512,
0.0202286653,
-0.0231475513,
-0.011064047,
-0.0248625055,
-0.0383108892,
0.0168986078,
0.0142176021,
-0.0177316554,
0.00913289,
-0.0812440738,
-0.0113732219,
-0.0293203183,
-0.0445683971,
-0.0591768622,
-0.0172582231,
0.0038922229,
0.0174563937,
-0.0405073725,
0.0235901847,
2.362148092e-34,
0.006541227,
0.0622255541,
0.0211576503,
-0.0010935306,
0.0393051393,
0.0029695432,
0.0257340595,
0.0269421358,
0.0713315085,
-0.0472204201,
-0.0465512425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10137v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10137v3 | TOAD: Task-Oriented Automatic Dialogs with Diverse Response Styles | 2024-02-15T17:40:02 | 2024-06-06T20:18:11 | Yinhong Liu, Yimai Fang, David Vandyke, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL | In light of recent advances in large language models (LLMs), the expectations
for the next generation of virtual assistants include enhanced naturalness and
adaptability across diverse usage scenarios. However, the creation of
high-quality annotated data for Task-Oriented Dialog (TOD) is recognized to be
slow and costly. To address these challenges, we introduce Task-Oriented
Automatic Dialogs (TOAD), a novel and scalable TOD dataset along with its
automatic generation pipeline. The TOAD dataset simulates realistic app context
interaction and provide a variety of system response style options. Two aspects
of system response styles are considered, verbosity level and users' expression
mirroring. We benchmark TOAD on two response generation tasks, and the results
show that modeling more verbose responses or responses without user expression
mirroring is more challenging. | [
0.0614725761,
-0.0033461917,
-0.0245744195,
0.0273562074,
-0.0008260678,
-0.0070513622,
0.0189102273,
-0.0205786172,
0.0306256879,
-0.0634464547,
-0.0476633832,
-0.0516521409,
-0.0368433781,
0.0420943908,
0.0177776217,
-0.0734174699,
0.0174170882,
-0.0339790098,
0.0005115299,
0.0106841065,
0.0280081593,
0.0351101197,
-0.0245964583,
0.0845889524,
-0.0174751356,
-0.0515072346,
-0.025731856,
0.0366810337,
-0.0053862734,
-0.0352024212,
0.0115905348,
0.061122857,
0.0075780037,
0.0279980544,
0.0000017766,
-0.0345107727,
0.0307231545,
-0.0011663889,
-0.0387289263,
0.0145791918,
0.0460599624,
0.044667799,
-0.0126239527,
0.0480458438,
-0.0506297648,
-0.0341531932,
0.0490544625,
0.0233935174,
0.0785621777,
0.0582588091,
-0.0258612111,
0.0199066754,
-0.0012196562,
-0.0140902912,
0.0047500613,
-0.0410019755,
-0.0337796174,
0.001822579,
0.027311299,
0.0169351473,
0.0525275655,
0.0048445705,
0.013120628,
-0.0284260139,
-0.0319578648,
0.0006109206,
-0.0314365439,
-0.0314505324,
-0.0361751355,
0.1066810414,
0.0371095352,
0.0207964201,
0.0140986275,
0.0008199145,
0.0097770644,
-0.0161011685,
-0.0413752832,
-0.0088081686,
-0.0331130885,
-0.0204569567,
-0.0168281235,
0.0276816227,
-0.0207107086,
-0.0072806906,
-0.0203406215,
-0.0042209462,
0.0094038378,
-0.010738669,
-0.0190067682,
-0.013775168,
-0.0092069814,
-0.0456197448,
-0.0104299719,
0.0058942465,
-0.0999619812,
0.0049242564,
-0.0709087104,
-0.042685397,
0.020104181,
-0.0220429078,
0.0728338137,
0.0373511054,
-0.0294555463,
0.0065750792,
0.0166248567,
0.0481419899,
-0.0178992338,
-0.0124407159,
-0.0244360175,
-0.0220074877,
-0.0263522789,
0.0041981237,
-0.038160786,
0.0314220637,
-0.0662129596,
-0.0265048258,
-0.0194660872,
0.0779322982,
-0.0193016995,
0.0131687047,
0.019180093,
0.0545729324,
-0.0464868583,
0.008069858,
-0.0129655013,
0.007551386,
-0.0316769741,
0.0236815121,
0.0329577364,
-0.0738625899,
0.0022723663,
0.0248941965,
0.0282210615,
-0.0181847177,
-0.0178614054,
0.0368265249,
-0.0140932854,
-0.0050576362,
0.0168809202,
-0.016212035,
-0.0372758172,
-0.054275658,
-0.0223643873,
-0.0302221514,
0.0320520513,
0.0057379454,
-0.0338611789,
0.0124346782,
0.0218389351,
0.0501006693,
-0.0063669747,
0.0397867449,
-0.0239140224,
0.0339411274,
0.0146836611,
-0.0101332935,
-0.0361544788,
0.0700303167,
0.0265778489,
0.0393252298,
0.0341172442,
-0.0067522847,
0.0204284638,
0.0493175238,
0.0090134609,
-0.0049315966,
0.0204410776,
0.0305280276,
-0.0364447832,
0.003302752,
0.0246421285,
0.0639447868,
-0.0140276896,
-0.0098016448,
0.0566414408,
0.0657469779,
-0.0124570364,
0.0087826997,
0.026629949,
0.0538343899,
0.0134377722,
-0.0215786658,
-0.0380097814,
0.0327044241,
-0.0095221335,
0.0090832859,
0.0337304734,
0.024529893,
-0.0541465096,
-0.0263532922,
-0.0030873697,
0.0013504744,
-0.015933793,
-0.0012118724,
0.011383364,
0.0271637887,
-0.047133252,
0.0316496715,
-0.0057689375,
-0.0576042123,
-0.0804277509,
-0.0373499691,
0.0443336219,
0.0785170123,
0.0515112318,
-0.025236506,
-0.0429006107,
-0.0179867428,
0.0043153018,
0.0593544841,
0.0547380224,
-0.0081178928,
0.0476738214,
-0.0316530056,
0.011166201,
-0.0092629436,
0.0082230195,
0.0157825034,
-0.0207323823,
-0.0211539585,
0.025981741,
-0.0102513852,
-0.0063289474,
-0.0073142955,
0.0179045405,
-0.0347617045,
0.0628136545,
0.0078880452,
0.0495900922,
0.0561715066,
-0.0089926561,
-0.0079920478,
0.0160594638,
-0.0099546909,
0.0247903671,
0.0335069597,
-0.050516028,
-0.0442220457,
0.0248432234,
-0.0108727431,
0.0000490718,
0.0431003645,
-0.0234072246,
-0.0535820574,
-0.003269858,
-0.0251367465,
0.0351793207,
-0.034811426,
0.0210113525,
0.0416810438,
0.0263328589,
0.0024936772,
0.0165457949,
0.0029981711,
-0.0081689376,
0.0461882539,
0.0358219184,
-0.0055824504,
-0.0174644329,
-0.0103419907,
-0.0050524618,
-0.0390849896,
0.0125935934,
0.009680449,
0.0143446205,
-0.0302456394,
-0.0231966451,
-0.1247914359,
-0.0031056486,
-0.0281705279,
0.0022281199,
0.0145280575,
0.051568795,
-0.0218889918,
-0.0310072154,
-0.0444939472,
0.0187777076,
0.0650374815,
0.0265733711,
0.025432976,
-0.0130103836,
-0.0016905837,
-0.0650707185,
0.0320966356,
-0.0062215282,
0.0047167824,
-0.0228375979,
0.0058623925,
-0.0396441631,
0.0208856352,
-0.0107923709,
0.0478045121,
-0.0186690353,
-0.0512770824,
0.0348596349,
0.0019987272,
0.0768667608,
0.031500075,
0.0224128254,
0.0318261124,
0.0107509857,
-0.0096628517,
-0.074106358,
0.0486743972,
-0.0015340933,
-0.0279170386,
-0.0251998007,
-0.0620983578,
0.0508560464,
0.0513620079,
-0.0048205941,
0.0265110414,
-0.0397643484,
0.020973308,
0.0173820611,
-0.0345143564,
0.0405970737,
-0.0002261498,
-0.0536291897,
0.0404497348,
-0.0061214892,
-0.0302232094,
0.0422585346,
-0.0314434357,
-0.0412070937,
-0.0459801517,
-0.0026701223,
-0.0149894916,
0.0947560444,
-0.0226041079,
0.0116532966,
0.0224062838,
-0.0166926719,
-0.0270498153,
0.0165547784,
0.0168242957,
-0.0382143669,
0.0646321848,
-0.0576678999,
-0.0168203712,
-0.0292728078,
-0.0478636362,
-0.0335116796,
-0.0423022769,
-0.0271233004,
-0.0232753251,
0.0302575603,
-0.0403715968,
-0.0237606987,
0.0110800965,
-0.0074336459,
0.0637300462,
-0.0257485043,
-0.0041534812,
-0.0358651094,
0.0089325421,
0.0794485211,
0.0498065613,
-0.0305996891,
0.0112142041,
0.065980643,
0.0324950442,
0.0828408152,
-0.0199211352,
-0.0084222825,
-0.0511016361,
0.0481821224,
0.019421678,
-0.0082821809,
0.0559435673,
0.0539640822,
-0.0306855254,
-0.00663218,
0.1241821349,
0.0233366806,
-0.0401758924,
0.0077873203,
-0.0725947171,
0.0378516167,
0.0238372497,
0.0299753249,
-0.1023565605,
-0.0391841456,
-0.0070559089,
0.0122663975,
0.0132159861,
-0.0195864365,
0.0047098678,
-0.1117927507,
0.0561837293,
-0.0208784807,
-0.0179315414,
-0.0074546402,
-0.004652868,
0.017535327,
-0.0071210153,
0.0301914755,
-0.0273716301,
-0.014222689,
-0.0060774363,
0.0188418776,
-0.0370591097,
0.0038234633,
0.0449918173,
-0.0441288576,
0.0695042536,
0.0565376468,
0.0412398875,
0.0460538231,
-0.0081137056,
-0.0351142511,
0.0045270775,
0.0082671558,
0.0011149311,
0.0336867273,
0.0094656609,
-0.0011574086,
-0.0163977221,
0.0403345898,
-0.04704592,
0.0018119237,
0.0475619808,
0.0288742445,
-0.0547585934,
0.019244384,
-0.0381380171,
0.0107667465,
0.0586277172,
0.0577085204,
0.0259366278,
-0.0644172877,
-0.0522875711,
-0.0141545963,
0.0125842365,
-0.0653652996,
-0.0155851711,
-0.028160546,
0.0038020865,
-0.0094832694,
-0.0659760088,
-0.0429573059,
0.0074489121,
0.0428328775,
-0.0063417447,
-0.0161933992,
0.0246233754,
0.0089574475,
-0.0022997223,
0.0322714113,
0.0022596696,
0.026645191,
-0.0262979139,
-0.0142858606,
0.0377928317,
-0.0296435207,
-0.0015156138,
0.029503569,
-0.0416363999,
-0.0551005714,
-0.0140333259,
0.0817324445,
0.0193456057,
0.0504786074,
-0.0028944395,
-0.0278129783,
-0.0124057345,
0.0122510577,
-0.0610947795,
-0.0269531347,
0.0502695628,
0.0467058383,
-0.0209963005,
0.0467624441,
-0.0780666173,
0.0104553169,
-0.0224586204,
0.0327361301,
-0.0037738474,
-0.0761051029,
0.0020741192,
0.0278339088,
0.0363569446,
0.0107442066,
-0.0090823676,
0.0001107895,
0.0559833944,
-0.0413496904,
-0.0090890788,
-0.069274053,
0.0138806822,
-0.04720008,
-0.0437796935,
0.0161837805,
-0.0101775583,
-0.0465938821,
0.0464116558,
-0.0305776726,
0.0030059861,
-0.0092080282,
0.0097429249,
0.0201558825,
-0.0101361712,
-0.0306424908,
0.0271917153,
0.0315332823,
0.0387819335,
-0.0053345035,
0.0779431462,
-0.0081454171,
-0.0208024569,
-0.0093302093,
0.0622168109,
-0.0298302565,
-0.0532531142,
-0.0147682317,
-0.000748201,
0.0257758908,
-0.0057530026,
0.0953510702,
-0.043973539,
0.0288243573,
-0.0298883058,
0.0496091694,
-0.0101089422,
-0.0199079178,
0.0249388441,
-0.001291764,
-0.0227693431,
-0.0182464495,
0.0758267716,
-0.0348014906,
0.0161105357,
0.0021342863,
-0.0012263911,
-0.0670843497,
-0.0465359278,
0.0133825075,
0.0297398344,
0.0064009731,
-0.0256378725,
-0.059983775,
-0.030211987,
-0.0089646792,
-0.0177691728,
-0.0270487275,
-0.0445546433,
0.0394151807,
0.0656152889,
0.0254010111,
-0.0246169213,
-0.0383535698,
-0.0216984861,
-0.0486725084,
-0.0148727931,
-0.0576912165,
-5.454711088e-33,
-0.0281167161,
0.0054472955,
0.0126948217,
-0.0339122638,
-0.0139234383,
-0.0101989489,
-0.0381296948,
0.0191902127,
-0.0289507695,
-0.0204844736,
-0.05290135,
-0.0010117887,
0.0202672686,
0.0549749769,
-0.0169195477,
0.0081286216,
0.0500410907,
-0.0347122848,
-0.0127458489,
0.0731446445,
0.0183918346,
-0.0286057871,
-0.0084672589,
-0.0887025967,
0.0249344222,
-0.0025225838,
0.0158275478,
0.0094788829,
0.0143549666,
0.0592185967,
-0.0267888866,
0.053677056,
-0.0048045423,
-0.0244447235,
-0.0231536608,
0.0348782465,
-0.0035446137,
-0.0209412985,
0.0370370597,
0.0066898875,
-0.0448956303,
-0.021813985,
-0.0304091051,
0.0117640644,
-0.0113210184,
0.0291305743,
0.0115179522,
-0.0039405464,
-0.0150325922,
-0.0210617688,
-0.0780523792,
-0.0013351279,
-0.0098322462,
-0.0712151304,
-0.0234023053,
0.1068853885,
0.0050217099,
-0.0425886065,
-0.0284984317,
0.0039060793,
-0.0153798219,
-0.0132601215,
0.0680475235,
0.0360736251,
0.0139153441,
0.0398834944,
0.0438516513,
0.0338031426,
-0.0559549034,
-0.02353682,
-0.0244070832,
0.0831060559,
0.0005037466,
0.0377955362,
-0.0116680553,
-0.0083889645,
0.0088782627,
0.040911153,
0.0531918332,
0.0298578534,
0.025059687,
0.0050452254,
-0.0427642055,
0.0066969539,
-0.0006007039,
0.0242186096,
-0.0251697544,
-0.0432597622,
0.044077225,
0.0062987139,
0.002557477,
-0.0448497646,
0.0416138694,
-0.0126964897,
0.0002102908,
0.0069596958,
-0.0320560262,
0.0269958414,
-0.0165231433,
0.011426704,
-0.0200919677,
0.0025526923,
0.0435637049,
0.024623869,
0.0151555371,
0.0476711206,
-0.0173043478,
0.0050899009,
-0.072185874,
0.0095105609,
-0.0353148542,
0.0634251237,
-0.0587351993,
0.0264037829,
0.0200421121,
-0.0366404019,
-0.0293903816,
0.0940808058,
-0.039340619,
-0.0320611745,
-0.0389667228,
-0.0452287309,
0.0333425403,
-0.0147730103,
-0.0238492656,
0.0103114983,
-0.0252629239,
-0.0319869258,
0.0022712266,
-0.0086196875,
-0.0207244717,
-0.0334297642,
2.463e-7,
-0.0211080927,
0.027065374,
0.0168342926,
0.0488467105,
0.0125603611,
0.0605625585,
0.0442480594,
0.0430093817,
0.0140858889,
0.0062731174,
0.0093966061,
-0.0151207475,
0.0633575022,
0.0288459957,
-0.080950886,
-0.002699896,
-0.0841228366,
0.0129108168,
-0.0494578481,
0.0147726182,
0.0722583532,
0.0774335265,
-0.020866761,
-0.000694123,
0.0162382219,
-0.0075890785,
0.0087841982,
-0.0446390733,
0.004332521,
0.028540073,
0.0486432686,
-0.0125364494,
0.0065714358,
-0.010561984,
-0.0158474762,
0.0124219246,
-0.0170249008,
0.0504531674,
0.0010867373,
-0.0566992015,
0.0091962554,
-0.0120971734,
0.0301251784,
-0.0591885298,
0.0512744039,
-0.0480904989,
-0.0373293459,
-0.0499221869,
-0.0030452029,
-0.0094478922,
-0.0359727703,
-0.031833604,
0.0106090307,
0.0235981233,
0.0036130094,
-0.0347672515,
-0.0143025322,
-0.0655584559,
-0.0399665199,
0.0041822679,
-0.0439331122,
-0.0446664095,
-0.0724802241,
0.0270562097,
0.0027188815,
-0.0267778561,
0.0206226874,
2.140518964e-34,
0.0161901377,
-0.008068054,
0.0186960921,
0.0646335632,
0.0069006411,
0.0090505322,
0.0396234356,
0.0108918156,
0.0622806624,
-0.0735732839,
-0.0285760909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10110v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10110v2 | Selective Reflection-Tuning: Student-Selected Data Recycling for LLM Instruction-Tuning | 2024-02-15T17:06:21 | 2024-06-07T20:23:21 | Ming Li, Lichang Chen, Jiuhai Chen, Shwai He, Jiuxiang Gu, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction tuning is critical to large language models (LLMs) for achieving
better instruction following and task adaptation capabilities but its success
heavily relies on the training data quality. Many recent methods focus on
improving the data quality but often overlook the compatibility of the data
with the student model being finetuned. This paper introduces Selective
Reflection-Tuning, a novel paradigm that synergizes a teacher LLM's reflection
and introspection for improving existing data quality with the data selection
capability of the student LLM, to automatically refine existing
instruction-tuning data. This teacher-student collaboration produces
high-quality and student-compatible instruction-response pairs, resulting in
sample-efficient instruction tuning and LLMs of superior performance. Selective
Reflection-Tuning is a data augmentation and synthesis that generally improves
LLM finetuning and self-improvement without collecting brand-new data. We apply
our method to Alpaca and WizardLM data and achieve much stronger and top-tier
7B and 13B LLMs. | [
0.0435102507,
0.0451632813,
-0.0330890231,
0.0469140224,
-0.0121827768,
-0.0015491523,
-0.0187950619,
-0.0149994604,
-0.0627411231,
-0.0507644787,
-0.0763399675,
0.0282111,
0.0011239586,
-0.0194722805,
0.0158342514,
-0.0607229769,
0.0717171431,
-0.0465737954,
-0.0620217174,
0.0181545205,
-0.0118098957,
0.0098193372,
-0.0134575358,
0.0276909489,
0.0276910271,
-0.00178372,
-0.0265606008,
0.0147169773,
0.0012269666,
-0.0060533159,
0.0309139267,
0.0687406734,
0.0139840674,
-0.013661691,
0.0000021957,
-0.0542994551,
-0.0172802303,
-0.0106788967,
-0.0332236886,
0.0511346981,
0.0441618934,
0.021360578,
-0.0188062638,
0.0321846493,
-0.0173537768,
0.0401580967,
0.0207886081,
-0.0100061074,
0.0821168348,
0.0626839846,
0.0377724953,
-0.0089829955,
-0.0052876328,
0.0203865394,
0.0338390246,
0.0199311152,
0.0181806609,
0.0127405524,
0.0320738815,
0.0444391482,
-0.0516188741,
0.0081777992,
0.0130981039,
-0.0309827849,
-0.0122806029,
-0.0262275636,
-0.0537229404,
-0.0105906194,
-0.0114945006,
0.0483347401,
0.0421936512,
-0.0347084664,
-0.0327490345,
-0.0234928597,
0.025851937,
0.0167482179,
-0.0512444861,
0.0053444454,
0.0263530556,
0.0422125645,
0.0359645635,
-0.0419824496,
-0.0120981401,
-0.0130744241,
-0.0099875638,
0.030486498,
-0.0002923909,
-0.0324601047,
-0.0228361636,
0.006207597,
0.0194479693,
-0.0030027337,
-0.0076973033,
0.0644191653,
-0.0231343471,
0.0169965141,
-0.0601654761,
-0.0572597422,
0.0155272596,
0.0467576571,
0.1208484918,
0.0455569923,
-0.0411073118,
-0.0179486927,
-0.0085138669,
0.0336585268,
0.0504006334,
0.0258273557,
-0.0407317467,
0.0121403439,
-0.065931052,
0.0211142339,
-0.026108548,
0.0119185764,
-0.0202058982,
0.0717502087,
-0.0360823013,
0.0417505614,
-0.0133500695,
-0.0224586539,
0.0349699967,
-0.0408497341,
-0.0585148633,
0.0263372995,
-0.0480414368,
0.0320955142,
-0.0041057309,
0.0182494167,
0.0067785005,
-0.0748369545,
0.0083572473,
-0.0078597767,
-0.0112855928,
-0.0088567566,
0.0295927506,
0.0454485752,
-0.0109498389,
-0.0275657326,
-0.0645182729,
-0.0165323373,
0.0171704311,
-0.0493060388,
0.0094843553,
-0.0493454263,
0.0070076012,
-0.011225732,
-0.0077271014,
-0.0057032397,
-0.014090796,
-0.0034379105,
0.0003288351,
0.0295208078,
-0.045042254,
0.0338887237,
-0.011730453,
0.0021707874,
-0.0101605933,
0.0732959956,
0.0266090203,
0.0064612734,
0.0131622655,
-0.0542775653,
0.0115103815,
0.014616671,
0.0033383081,
0.0078459894,
-0.0359701179,
-0.0052229417,
0.0237272307,
-0.0027244317,
0.0446758382,
0.0176570732,
-0.026670495,
0.0534055233,
0.0632395968,
0.0202546697,
0.03168514,
0.0294384249,
0.0205384325,
0.0357753932,
0.0285894349,
0.0341681093,
-0.0529813319,
0.0431437232,
0.0274307262,
0.0069758943,
-0.0187937152,
0.0821473077,
0.0051785577,
-0.0817861035,
-0.0105837695,
0.0049966695,
-0.0113562299,
0.0266324747,
0.0427900404,
0.0076885754,
-0.0346505567,
0.0261366423,
0.0435562879,
-0.0491450764,
0.0069562499,
-0.0936182886,
0.0247657131,
0.0879932195,
0.0276766568,
-0.0315093063,
-0.0564841814,
-0.0001703314,
0.0406916514,
0.0061475886,
0.0632874519,
-0.0266919807,
0.0084142387,
-0.0503794216,
-0.0445605852,
-0.0068350276,
0.0112770312,
0.0035252911,
-0.0085020829,
-0.0109355142,
0.0011045744,
0.0077367942,
-0.0795455351,
0.070833765,
-0.0269819815,
-0.0391642824,
-0.0134494826,
-0.0015763022,
0.0094845425,
0.0168336537,
0.0026805617,
-0.0067990501,
0.0511109568,
0.0169283338,
0.0456448346,
-0.0108362939,
-0.0487747863,
-0.0237293411,
0.0404619463,
-0.0159180574,
-0.02870363,
0.014332992,
-0.0485862903,
-0.0579721294,
-0.0079097617,
-0.024144154,
0.0484281555,
-0.0285521317,
0.0532123707,
-0.052892223,
-0.0166871138,
-0.0451618433,
0.0086326906,
0.0141607616,
-0.006170081,
0.0219042432,
-0.0043655657,
0.0170735475,
-0.0400646627,
-0.005848601,
-0.0025253219,
-0.019141579,
0.0394361839,
-0.0154162766,
0.064440608,
-0.074666068,
-0.0428969301,
-0.035432063,
-0.0226861797,
-0.0204106234,
0.0446669385,
0.0268567465,
-0.0287653375,
-0.0299117938,
-0.0069131455,
-0.0032751784,
-0.0129891317,
-0.0068879607,
0.004630513,
0.0203706175,
-0.0086451992,
-0.0487951785,
-0.037040595,
0.0002073478,
-0.0000707873,
-0.0222517829,
-0.0079266196,
0.0078317858,
-0.0822154731,
0.0376352966,
-0.0005952239,
0.013772985,
0.0090245977,
-0.0510424636,
0.0238230545,
0.0144337425,
0.0068297782,
0.0694177374,
-0.0468001477,
-0.0084166015,
0.0746742263,
-0.0193116833,
-0.0822213143,
0.01185524,
-0.0012829517,
-0.0326093994,
-0.0502085537,
-0.0265408959,
-0.0115050068,
0.047919102,
-0.0112770312,
-0.0353902951,
-0.0270115267,
0.003846711,
-0.0065832115,
-0.0166290216,
-0.0088155949,
-0.0092316549,
-0.0244265534,
0.0019538952,
-0.0216740854,
-0.0803301632,
0.0654761419,
-0.007972138,
0.0023741531,
-0.0786972865,
-0.0150421942,
-0.0155071262,
0.0112506235,
-0.0187737923,
-0.0088079842,
-0.00343336,
0.0054599363,
-0.0636642277,
0.0191678721,
0.0471819118,
-0.0347752683,
0.0438726135,
-0.0867578685,
-0.0082273548,
-0.016062431,
-0.0173431803,
-0.0463123284,
0.0441069193,
0.0104040448,
0.0043663559,
0.0095040929,
-0.0312624238,
-0.0234217457,
-0.0373494998,
0.0218552481,
0.0197151992,
-0.0315513946,
0.0035620262,
-0.0080077266,
-0.0598989129,
0.0119849835,
0.0035817751,
-0.01413792,
-0.0421601795,
0.0331723168,
0.0159229897,
0.0623775274,
-0.0177456941,
0.0004887893,
0.0239362177,
0.0490274727,
-0.0201482605,
-0.0019283578,
0.0521369763,
0.0760585666,
-0.0821411684,
-0.0227489285,
0.0869284198,
0.0304283984,
-0.0282225404,
-0.0019614331,
-0.0375851318,
0.022052044,
0.0325462297,
0.0638855174,
-0.0317183994,
-0.021438688,
-0.0054531805,
0.0607462488,
-0.0054929038,
-0.0018364697,
-0.0089612398,
-0.1147435382,
0.0499794744,
0.0278834738,
-0.0579537936,
-0.00775749,
-0.0462976284,
-0.0008718462,
-0.0166936088,
0.0671968386,
0.0207998361,
-0.0559523702,
0.026950594,
0.07301379,
0.0205285698,
-0.0688932091,
-0.0200153869,
-0.0167519487,
0.0717644989,
0.0276129991,
-0.0021781167,
0.0047410722,
-0.0332223698,
0.0462876633,
-0.0094460538,
0.015955409,
-0.0167747997,
0.0318568535,
0.0004875464,
0.009356508,
0.0058879978,
0.0445564799,
-0.0189488418,
0.0028909429,
0.0240681618,
0.0810008049,
-0.0214145239,
0.0202438198,
-0.0169235263,
-0.0373175517,
0.0110857813,
0.0578161813,
0.0874755979,
-0.046675045,
0.009950296,
-0.0341739096,
-0.0566995218,
-0.0695268512,
-0.0057820734,
0.0661821216,
-0.0797093511,
0.0372789241,
-0.0392942838,
-0.0619096309,
0.0781581774,
0.0064460593,
0.0262181759,
0.0408421755,
-0.0377302729,
-0.0384181254,
-0.0266160127,
0.0455339104,
-0.0197183546,
0.0080474978,
-0.093897976,
-0.068030484,
0.0195163339,
-0.0011072112,
0.0164078586,
0.0027315207,
-0.0699112862,
-0.0732237399,
0.0397392437,
0.075402908,
0.0248475615,
0.03135309,
0.0434947386,
-0.0542550422,
0.0244324692,
0.0311459526,
-0.009245106,
0.0282888729,
0.0318161957,
-0.0316946171,
-0.0012337824,
0.0004850466,
-0.017974779,
0.0213777479,
0.0423361212,
0.0241018832,
-0.0044254134,
-0.0275777951,
0.0232915692,
0.031086402,
0.0213717259,
-0.0054319543,
-0.0247645434,
-0.052228868,
0.0400746167,
-0.0111376541,
0.010388704,
-0.0365771987,
0.0043055718,
-0.0065881698,
0.0128378831,
-0.0004907759,
-0.0087137651,
-0.0296338424,
0.0536042787,
-0.0352036282,
0.0520373471,
-0.0303007849,
0.0088311667,
0.0175769906,
0.031743709,
-0.0099749425,
-0.0087592863,
0.0491331294,
0.0498595126,
0.0178320799,
0.0574797951,
0.0022100741,
0.0375536978,
-0.0058984836,
0.0370855108,
-0.0242160261,
-0.0181665253,
-0.0585272387,
0.0174338575,
0.0098631056,
0.0052818283,
0.0475761816,
-0.0052418923,
-0.0001734495,
-0.0057059568,
0.0366112515,
-0.035419181,
0.0076918798,
0.0128473602,
0.0027968208,
-0.0069176587,
-0.0364023671,
0.0514170974,
-0.0112443483,
0.0617854707,
-0.0385691673,
0.040920943,
-0.0108240601,
-0.0190343075,
0.0206689239,
-0.0186054669,
-0.004827925,
-0.0234746542,
-0.0308701787,
-0.0700714886,
-0.0226241387,
0.0280958507,
0.0111498628,
-0.0369024947,
0.0199901275,
0.0238460843,
-0.0352090523,
-0.0111046582,
-0.0178022832,
-0.0315193124,
0.0347628891,
-0.0319010653,
-0.0130037339,
-6.285751799e-33,
-0.0511455536,
0.006110026,
0.0317303538,
0.025556406,
-0.0115573369,
-0.0008034306,
-0.0064136679,
-0.005039236,
-0.010577606,
-0.0169179775,
-0.0147291012,
-0.0056711743,
0.0204810724,
0.0094218766,
0.0511706918,
0.0268004369,
0.0414055921,
-0.0107654547,
-0.0250457861,
-0.0000399449,
0.013757294,
0.0397220515,
0.0979793221,
-0.025582701,
-0.0050196843,
0.008861158,
0.0157785844,
0.0106327636,
-0.0747293457,
0.0675751045,
0.0247307327,
0.0260071848,
0.0258586202,
-0.0368047878,
-0.06481608,
-0.0271400958,
-0.0598780736,
-0.085234493,
0.0196882542,
0.0014914339,
-0.0144247254,
-0.0339149833,
0.0435384102,
-0.005428697,
-0.0426950604,
-0.0022451167,
0.0211294927,
-0.0540078878,
-0.0276661236,
0.0374682695,
-0.0718466416,
-0.0017613519,
0.0069051096,
-0.0205245186,
0.006091807,
0.0419553183,
-0.004488192,
-0.023483634,
-0.0311686639,
0.0524534769,
0.0923966318,
0.070983842,
0.0921832547,
0.0610507764,
-0.0111765033,
0.0260019209,
0.0338025652,
0.0325411409,
0.0477257036,
-0.0227277838,
0.0794620365,
0.0502256416,
0.0277678501,
0.0307375509,
0.0291284025,
-0.0093883965,
-0.0424493477,
0.0450289734,
0.0463230014,
0.0295752045,
-0.0231315456,
0.0180326067,
-0.0183751471,
-0.0222420413,
-0.054106608,
0.0271292347,
-0.0028009263,
-0.023949042,
0.0509464704,
-0.0141646499,
-0.0572119541,
-0.0138860755,
0.0291756969,
-0.0134075936,
-0.0218361057,
-0.0471936278,
-0.0453295931,
0.0096207773,
-0.0073140436,
-0.0128540406,
-0.0647405311,
-0.0768346712,
0.0320001356,
-0.0227154475,
0.0311922058,
-0.0096082343,
0.0635828227,
0.0331857987,
-0.0508323982,
0.0189581346,
-0.0525789,
0.0074828546,
0.033617232,
-0.0105825458,
0.0033060927,
0.0057128742,
-0.0108532328,
0.0798827857,
0.0321548767,
-0.0295631737,
-0.0536719784,
-0.0219215602,
0.0086785154,
0.0082622822,
0.0039157895,
-0.0041679852,
-0.0262747742,
-0.006104711,
0.0221566912,
-0.0308443159,
-0.0045480761,
0.0165399145,
2.892e-7,
0.0472409204,
0.0429126844,
-0.0006855936,
-0.0067866989,
-0.0028433457,
0.0120773371,
-0.048125688,
-0.0099146739,
0.0409407876,
0.0059238663,
0.0213750061,
0.0172408689,
0.0593917184,
0.020654602,
-0.0494926795,
-0.0270590037,
-0.0149876261,
-0.0248504654,
-0.0708606094,
-0.0067860484,
0.0010635942,
0.0551643483,
0.0116415434,
-0.0178159047,
-0.0092704883,
0.0171636995,
-0.0081040859,
-0.0681961253,
-0.0199832562,
0.0481452718,
0.0545454957,
-0.0132271321,
-0.0000800835,
0.0017286916,
-0.0381438881,
0.0005780673,
-0.0600525774,
0.0492267422,
-0.0235851575,
-0.0176476426,
0.0637144744,
0.0031592536,
-0.0307807662,
-0.0069885557,
0.032809604,
-0.0337078534,
0.0122428499,
0.0148341674,
0.0040630712,
-0.0302277654,
-0.0030061989,
-0.049558863,
0.0289026275,
0.036304187,
0.0000668173,
-0.0109130191,
-0.0479877256,
-0.030945098,
0.0067611057,
-0.023857668,
-0.0279485062,
-0.0706477985,
-0.0361500569,
-0.0355833173,
-0.0158950984,
-0.0416992009,
0.019877933,
2.796905137e-34,
0.0120838322,
-0.0263393372,
0.0718498975,
0.0444045737,
-0.0053858086,
0.0067559732,
0.0044240234,
0.0638182834,
0.0068844398,
-0.0528044961,
-0.0357084125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10109v2 | Towards Reducing Diagnostic Errors with Interpretable Risk Prediction | 2024-02-15T17:05:48 | 2024-03-19T16:43:09 | Denis Jered McInerney, William Dickinson, Lucy C. Flynn, Andrea C. Young, Geoffrey S. Young, Jan-Willem van de Meent, Byron C. Wallace | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Many diagnostic errors occur because clinicians cannot easily access relevant
information in patient Electronic Health Records (EHRs). In this work we
propose a method to use LLMs to identify pieces of evidence in patient EHR data
that indicate increased or decreased risk of specific diagnoses; our ultimate
aim is to increase access to evidence and reduce diagnostic errors. In
particular, we propose a Neural Additive Model to make predictions backed by
evidence with individualized risk estimates at time-points where clinicians are
still uncertain, aiming to specifically mitigate delays in diagnosis and errors
stemming from an incomplete differential. To train such a model, it is
necessary to infer temporally fine-grained retrospective labels of eventual
"true" diagnoses. We do so with LLMs, to ensure that the input text is from
before a confident diagnosis can be made. We use an LLM to retrieve an initial
pool of evidence, but then refine this set of evidence according to
correlations learned by the model. We conduct an in-depth evaluation of the
usefulness of our approach by simulating how it might be used by a clinician to
decide between a pre-defined list of differential diagnoses. | [
-0.0041405796,
0.082420826,
-0.0027790663,
-0.0472062081,
0.0313151032,
0.0305982828,
-0.0235473327,
0.0204437375,
0.0124836219,
0.0530345067,
0.0498819314,
-0.0405144729,
-0.0205736458,
0.0450253598,
-0.0021492697,
-0.0194510128,
0.0553583205,
0.0060430155,
0.0490196534,
0.0162687637,
-0.0303313471,
-0.0303278565,
-0.0213180669,
0.0299409777,
-0.023656087,
-0.0067633572,
0.0144579671,
-0.0057707895,
0.032616023,
-0.0902457461,
0.0191002954,
-0.0190801304,
-0.0090621114,
-0.0244825929,
0.0000020709,
-0.0430026837,
-0.0293888357,
-0.0210375339,
-0.0666001365,
-0.0627144203,
-0.0268324669,
0.0046524392,
0.0368063711,
0.0112719312,
-0.0251886155,
-0.0559896827,
0.0311892275,
0.0566792153,
0.0373752303,
0.0565684959,
-0.0057680528,
0.0274576657,
0.0448483787,
-0.0526314378,
0.0664530322,
-0.0475989655,
0.0544951037,
-0.026379738,
-0.0103253471,
-0.0260380972,
0.0141981263,
0.0460092165,
0.0274996925,
0.0375528522,
0.0068509462,
0.0664026961,
0.0573594198,
-0.0043230769,
-0.0195647534,
0.055463288,
-0.0047824746,
-0.010709431,
0.0274542794,
-0.0494182967,
0.0249956511,
-0.0192665067,
-0.0135276634,
-0.0247906409,
-0.0330739915,
0.0177295972,
0.0296631753,
0.0208957661,
0.0774528384,
0.0190772619,
0.0117548993,
0.0291842353,
-0.0260481238,
-0.0197582077,
-0.0168021303,
0.0148866223,
0.0434139781,
-0.0428250879,
0.0081159594,
0.0592987947,
-0.0249061529,
0.0190262087,
0.0226224158,
-0.0042486344,
0.0695932731,
-0.0444749929,
0.0350432582,
-0.0075924592,
-0.0086630955,
0.0350735635,
-0.0121431109,
-0.0293189567,
-0.0501070656,
0.0250069704,
-0.0002721779,
0.0258689392,
-0.0202674754,
-0.0039931918,
0.0103905685,
0.0139998468,
0.0647506788,
0.0374886952,
-0.0450479053,
0.0021240273,
-0.0239919759,
0.0238104127,
0.0250784568,
0.0300426893,
-0.0183958318,
0.0134756854,
-0.0690707788,
-0.0198615715,
0.0019316332,
0.0324242376,
0.0263590999,
0.0003505353,
-0.0108810095,
0.0167354792,
0.0183373187,
-0.001335273,
0.0356230214,
0.0663045421,
0.0247067977,
-0.0088218274,
-0.0635459274,
-0.0403586924,
-0.0401039869,
0.0243308954,
-0.0030700716,
-0.0385659188,
0.01303788,
0.019204231,
-0.0053230831,
-0.0817416385,
-0.0030378157,
-0.0504864193,
-0.01931208,
0.0287819114,
-0.0659883171,
-0.0145680588,
0.0128455944,
0.0280151069,
-0.036202997,
0.012044332,
0.02420564,
0.0037193249,
-0.0139098251,
-0.009668747,
0.0323732235,
0.0147547107,
0.0663210973,
-0.0095296428,
-0.0152071584,
-0.0256459396,
-0.0447125398,
0.0484026335,
-0.0292540751,
0.0106972,
0.0147118233,
-0.0111818491,
0.0513391756,
-0.0140564013,
0.0534452014,
-0.0209044404,
0.0194524508,
-0.0493022911,
-0.0334381349,
-0.0269036088,
-0.011105096,
0.0153468521,
-0.003696833,
-0.0068763951,
-0.0250811987,
-0.0407204516,
-0.0258224271,
-0.0970144197,
-0.0370334871,
-0.017219929,
-0.0210921597,
0.0127008483,
0.0273983981,
-0.0252926592,
-0.0153156379,
0.0596516542,
0.0605592988,
0.0179015379,
-0.0122800451,
-0.0883639157,
0.0154910283,
0.0690642223,
0.0004494943,
-0.0253946651,
-0.0516997948,
-0.0352053717,
-0.0123991407,
-0.0630867481,
0.0131473793,
-0.0058522541,
0.0556496345,
-0.0083353547,
0.0040229345,
0.0231944863,
0.0427612886,
-0.0176044218,
-0.0243769027,
-0.0170013756,
-0.0246572662,
-0.0301698111,
-0.0517877564,
0.0472090058,
-0.0490819849,
-0.0327253453,
0.0212229658,
0.029717952,
0.0591207929,
-0.0294107683,
0.0137865869,
0.0251725335,
0.0346292444,
-0.010660843,
-0.0737928823,
0.0085019134,
-0.0147718033,
-0.0082588419,
0.0182240084,
-0.0021414869,
-0.0215158537,
-0.0594409592,
-0.0730161667,
-0.0246907063,
-0.0358240306,
-0.0480682217,
-0.0205977764,
0.0042488133,
-0.0192830376,
0.0667728558,
-0.0192218367,
-0.0200814065,
0.0472788513,
-0.057938464,
-0.0337518975,
-0.0179325975,
-0.0507906526,
0.0033469335,
-0.0393980742,
-0.0183948819,
-0.0470129438,
-0.0096757766,
-0.0052481727,
-0.0177216828,
-0.0346150883,
-0.0218806397,
-0.0197011288,
-0.0489416532,
-0.0070681819,
0.0107621402,
0.0126874493,
-0.0075314338,
-0.0057755085,
-0.0047329641,
-0.0440339968,
-0.0157240704,
0.0123068169,
0.0431514494,
0.0245072804,
0.0764130726,
0.0743167773,
-0.0033799519,
-0.0268156081,
-0.0198189784,
-0.0394925699,
0.0263697226,
0.0226859115,
-0.0401535667,
-0.0210385397,
-0.0374980494,
-0.0287286676,
0.0080788685,
-0.0138236107,
-0.0078298887,
-0.0403856896,
-0.0546693765,
-0.0597808734,
0.0742983744,
-0.0105325403,
0.0238182694,
0.0301322285,
-0.0034516698,
-0.0513850451,
0.023088349,
-0.065607138,
0.0019202036,
0.010083192,
-0.0286462773,
0.0045382939,
0.0698139369,
0.0035497134,
-0.0169224646,
-0.0360757932,
0.031005444,
0.0087271733,
-0.0185022783,
-0.0414648019,
-0.0085761882,
-0.0202960894,
0.0334922858,
-0.0315161496,
-0.0728192106,
0.1022047922,
0.033063367,
0.0684508011,
0.0059491065,
-0.0589210391,
-0.0346650854,
-0.015996391,
-0.0029129062,
-0.0081630396,
0.0298251379,
-0.0049790116,
-0.0120798629,
-0.0092825033,
0.0148694897,
-0.0318167023,
0.0619978718,
-0.0478366576,
0.0374493226,
0.0301907603,
-0.0148147363,
-0.0492982306,
-0.037140999,
0.0033866134,
-0.0001439814,
-0.0445855893,
0.0418972224,
-0.0705682114,
-0.0355661884,
-0.047219146,
0.0740021914,
0.0059212125,
-0.0052440516,
0.0037868726,
-0.0356284343,
-0.0143956244,
-0.0234681908,
0.0205304511,
-0.077900812,
0.024632968,
0.0214294232,
-0.017456146,
0.0214051884,
-0.0454543717,
0.0323130526,
-0.0496400744,
-0.0204926562,
0.0020841854,
0.0619214922,
-0.0156637914,
-0.0703734234,
0.0042491825,
0.0557616875,
-0.0048685358,
-0.0545764454,
0.0037741035,
-0.0131545747,
-0.0399079062,
-0.0393838398,
-0.0124436915,
-0.0231771674,
-0.0136734461,
0.0134231625,
0.0116666239,
-0.0311617032,
-0.0469775461,
0.0400935411,
0.0299732778,
0.0048231953,
0.0110073779,
0.0213570483,
0.0244676098,
-0.038014438,
-0.0148770148,
-0.0425517261,
-0.0146199362,
-0.0421218984,
0.0198758561,
-0.0059895655,
0.0266623348,
-0.077774331,
-0.0708544776,
0.0266180318,
0.0106670968,
0.0336612649,
0.0571012646,
0.0066187051,
-0.038025286,
-0.0439278595,
0.0088120569,
0.0221657306,
0.0255372189,
0.0043747881,
0.1109878644,
0.0211426821,
0.004227086,
-0.0427695997,
0.0273076352,
-0.013265036,
-0.0046533812,
0.0049821497,
0.0915214494,
-0.0472783223,
-0.0288094468,
-0.0164426696,
0.0010379286,
0.050830543,
0.0198741388,
-0.0116701359,
-0.0170849133,
-0.0073061734,
0.0547364913,
0.0433054231,
0.0081901122,
0.0275788177,
0.0341861024,
-0.0145775629,
-0.0193827059,
-0.0346118361,
-0.0158786159,
-0.0452133194,
-0.0191947035,
0.0232769419,
-0.0099298442,
-0.0022395414,
-0.0123890396,
-0.080314666,
0.0856992677,
0.0517832227,
0.0131051354,
-0.0663406625,
0.0224679317,
0.0406159125,
0.0022910358,
-0.0139674023,
0.0299911816,
-0.0682712644,
-0.0238308068,
-0.0033533084,
0.0659694895,
0.0261462741,
0.0060216291,
-0.0127966637,
-0.0637926832,
0.0528585277,
0.0282508302,
0.0046593472,
-0.0152820982,
0.0358627699,
-0.0217582658,
-0.0256245062,
0.0013773006,
-0.0295829065,
0.0302047487,
0.0135727292,
-0.0378814004,
-0.057550732,
0.0007879743,
0.0325156376,
-0.0158911496,
0.0794535875,
-0.0270972122,
-0.038164936,
-0.0268271267,
0.0236776527,
0.0474370271,
0.0312683396,
-0.0073180557,
0.0028992663,
0.0152400015,
-0.0164845176,
-0.0199103728,
0.0003964767,
-0.0063619353,
-0.0396288186,
-0.0725835115,
0.0484168567,
0.0217665285,
-0.0084929112,
0.0390413776,
0.005817723,
-0.0047206623,
0.008319892,
0.0178454276,
0.0126163065,
0.0358461477,
0.0157931056,
0.0171363987,
0.0631101131,
-0.0141986711,
-0.0043384098,
-0.0486572236,
-0.0680243745,
-0.0139222685,
0.0049654939,
0.0324051082,
0.0394646265,
0.0279880445,
-0.0152490614,
0.0139561249,
-0.0193128847,
0.0365915,
-0.008080231,
0.0084273592,
0.063747324,
0.016450718,
-0.0154559044,
-0.0214507189,
0.0822902694,
-0.0009739261,
0.05931817,
-0.0444828495,
0.0108624222,
-0.0320611,
0.0005561297,
0.0334096178,
0.0217805728,
-0.0652938336,
0.001179819,
-0.0524712317,
-0.0433641411,
0.0538624935,
0.0168819185,
0.0079949982,
0.0025301359,
-0.0101438873,
-0.0055000642,
-0.003479263,
-0.0121069318,
0.0038218566,
0.0241022259,
-0.0113043366,
-0.0021699611,
-0.0270875487,
-6.043253926e-33,
0.002099091,
-0.0262799039,
0.0061783851,
-0.0099204024,
0.0237314813,
0.0762959495,
-0.0682559088,
-0.014772282,
0.0207071733,
0.022110071,
0.0045298487,
0.0326363631,
0.0110145314,
0.0299335476,
0.0154999048,
-0.0494308695,
0.0471420847,
0.0435870141,
-0.0111376084,
0.0042106914,
0.0113859111,
0.043598637,
0.0062684244,
-0.0899510905,
0.0299797598,
0.0401549526,
-0.0234251432,
0.0254849773,
-0.052649878,
0.0579338185,
0.0111192781,
0.0136033911,
0.0411597751,
-0.0046242215,
-0.0236392319,
-0.0041608582,
-0.0740420446,
-0.0500903018,
-0.0156360883,
-0.0477324538,
-0.0113153784,
-0.0288441461,
0.053516455,
0.0028434484,
-0.0072122999,
0.0074573038,
0.0266484823,
-0.0370281041,
-0.0055212537,
-0.0687881932,
0.0605410226,
0.0592109971,
-0.0047770292,
0.017869154,
0.002479136,
0.0121643227,
-0.0255896058,
0.004186397,
-0.0733847246,
-0.0100324862,
0.0366735496,
-0.0005050965,
0.0045898259,
-0.0077609606,
-0.0480238087,
0.0805574879,
0.0442637578,
-0.0120076966,
-0.0598693937,
-0.0185245797,
-0.0625109598,
0.0021887501,
0.039049685,
-0.0015945616,
0.0566523038,
-0.0266175549,
-0.118507728,
0.0365194827,
-0.0345110819,
0.0734695494,
0.0364624597,
-0.0104504097,
-0.0350563824,
-0.0028968982,
-0.0461853407,
0.0019623176,
-0.0281860586,
-0.0065856804,
0.0287035294,
0.0485150479,
0.0284786802,
0.007559997,
-0.0018904218,
-0.0079399459,
0.0200986005,
-0.0095945876,
0.078728199,
-0.0282275844,
-0.0026128946,
0.0072439914,
-0.0063751955,
-0.0258661788,
0.012553608,
-0.0416872539,
0.0466037728,
0.0058953324,
0.0501718298,
-0.0122667737,
-0.0350585133,
-0.0044881678,
0.0210582837,
0.0259468369,
-0.0039050072,
0.0023351561,
0.0535638742,
0.0102975946,
-0.0217469614,
0.0852936506,
0.0186507683,
0.0396129824,
0.003361217,
-0.004824399,
-0.0094568944,
0.0274044033,
-0.0266265739,
-0.0256406274,
0.0071786535,
-0.0156261679,
0.0482580811,
-0.0593466274,
0.0059584323,
0.014135005,
2.959e-7,
0.0800695047,
0.0173697229,
0.0392656624,
-0.0077206348,
0.0451068282,
0.0146542732,
-0.0383053534,
-0.0140545284,
0.0090756826,
-0.0169194844,
0.0648211911,
0.0139319887,
0.0392895341,
0.0238230862,
0.0005214541,
-0.0549794026,
-0.0646358505,
0.0047188574,
0.0177866407,
-0.0294112526,
0.0703662559,
0.0501820557,
0.0061187153,
-0.0423740484,
0.0114074545,
0.012298611,
0.0559915118,
-0.0454782955,
0.0251192991,
-0.0031561588,
0.0690332651,
-0.0057202573,
0.0144909183,
0.0799810067,
-0.0437113419,
-0.0142424302,
-0.0645628721,
0.0744824111,
-0.0460655093,
0.0068950551,
-0.0158729739,
0.0037860721,
0.0538193174,
-0.0035847935,
0.0508384258,
-0.0867444798,
-0.0435018688,
0.0140377823,
-0.0140843578,
0.0150430258,
0.0447852127,
-0.0069102631,
-0.0178858992,
0.005080774,
0.0042860014,
0.0539430566,
-0.0096907988,
-0.0828247741,
-0.0396160185,
0.0691536143,
-0.0128358034,
-0.0436471477,
0.0301938951,
0.0139481425,
0.0164488722,
-0.1070215702,
0.0167800467,
2.477796762e-34,
0.0358642787,
0.003670153,
-0.0318086594,
0.0073768185,
0.0127015933,
0.0032018938,
0.0010602971,
0.0186090544,
0.0522730276,
-0.0400384329,
-0.031177463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10107v1 | Quantized Embedding Vectors for Controllable Diffusion Language Models | 2024-02-15T17:02:48 | 2024-02-15T17:02:48 | Cheng Kang, Xinye Chen, Yong Hu, Daniel Novak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improving the controllability, portability, and inference speed of diffusion
language models (DLMs) is a key challenge in natural language generation. While
recent research has shown significant success in complex text generation with
language models, the memory and computational power are still very demanding
and fall short of expectations, which naturally results in low portability and
instability for the models. To mitigate these issues, numerous well-established
methods were proposed for neural network quantization. To further enhance their
portability of independent deployment as well as improve their stability
evaluated by language perplexity, we propose a novel approach called the
Quantized Embedding Controllable Diffusion Language Model (QE-CDLM). QE-CDLM
builds upon the recent successful controllable DLMs by remodeling the
task-specific embedding space via quantization. This leads to a gradient-based
controller for the generation tasks, and more stable intermediate latent
variables are obtained, which naturally brings in an accelerated convergence as
well as better controllability. Additionally, the adaption fine-tuning method
is employed to reduce tunable weights. Experimental results on five challenging
fine-grained control tasks demonstrate that QE-CDLM compares favorably to
existing methods in terms of quality and feasibility, achieving better
perplexity and lightweight fine-tuning. | [
-0.0070142415,
0.0371458195,
-0.0031600599,
0.0243799761,
-0.0075164079,
0.0012703073,
0.0455538593,
-0.0317637026,
0.0175248142,
-0.0028824315,
0.0093776155,
-0.0591244958,
-0.0155336829,
0.0388090275,
0.0681323782,
-0.0078795301,
0.0180689432,
-0.0078366725,
-0.0083514694,
-0.0102759665,
-0.0021525577,
-0.0226116385,
0.039304696,
0.0284311585,
0.00736085,
-0.0068772887,
-0.0245154239,
0.0083266217,
0.0027172959,
-0.0187749639,
0.018531369,
0.0699587986,
0.0943941399,
0.0103165815,
0.0000020815,
0.0126835378,
-0.0122142099,
-0.0018210866,
0.0298179183,
0.0071387351,
0.0570825003,
-0.016701242,
-0.027137585,
0.016220469,
-0.0106812585,
-0.0166047737,
0.0668711439,
0.0308327116,
0.0752908364,
0.0762358755,
-0.013309991,
-0.0347136296,
0.0218952205,
-0.0477073789,
0.0054706824,
-0.0195332952,
0.0011597751,
0.0689091086,
0.0332666337,
0.0050693299,
-0.062167462,
0.0440120101,
0.0255259983,
-0.013580516,
0.0064777476,
0.0407606401,
-0.0015931251,
-0.0325010978,
-0.0235379227,
0.0820271,
-0.0771109238,
-0.0224119723,
0.0364778973,
-0.0270470586,
-0.0190809965,
-0.0255050082,
-0.0435501598,
0.0126162907,
0.0445059203,
0.0516851917,
0.0039455262,
-0.035764806,
0.0505934171,
0.0131923929,
-0.0319041386,
0.0360370949,
0.020075649,
-0.0119404253,
-0.0377302952,
-0.0016549657,
-0.0674335212,
-0.0471479855,
0.0231492687,
0.0311060715,
-0.0112359412,
-0.0017401769,
-0.0903292075,
-0.0607219748,
-0.0175729413,
-0.0193313193,
0.0559289269,
0.0386439376,
0.0362369977,
0.0056359908,
-0.0365252197,
0.0713579282,
-0.0566212609,
0.0020311589,
-0.0342968702,
0.0542198047,
-0.0378289595,
-0.0073258565,
-0.0528687201,
0.0312237572,
-0.0134411771,
-0.0366767049,
-0.0723070502,
0.0488603562,
-0.026059987,
-0.0039867996,
0.0219013449,
0.0257763751,
-0.0225388873,
0.0212318134,
0.0413327254,
0.0152808977,
-0.0178840104,
-0.0125949774,
0.0588155463,
0.0150337229,
-0.0315763019,
0.0175858922,
0.0405728593,
-0.0133340312,
-0.0103707258,
0.0206436198,
-0.0182085801,
-0.0027786612,
-0.0111326464,
-0.0315139815,
-0.0436278991,
-0.0473977402,
0.0255125593,
-0.066753678,
0.0262996834,
-0.0325720385,
-0.0152370688,
-0.055058904,
0.0107709132,
0.0002379032,
-0.0296341032,
0.0467585176,
-0.0333519056,
-0.0074167699,
0.0433034413,
0.0021688254,
0.0289366301,
0.0640349314,
0.0488183163,
0.0521739088,
0.0020354106,
0.0093230149,
0.0030595846,
0.0112692155,
0.0560195036,
-0.0112737548,
-0.0376122221,
-0.0551985465,
-0.0384915061,
0.0628200844,
0.0627952665,
0.0670680627,
-0.0536388643,
0.022717813,
0.0607717037,
0.0354474448,
0.0386905521,
-0.0049736374,
0.0800901428,
0.0229449049,
-0.0563999675,
0.00929935,
0.0149247181,
0.0339543186,
0.0612109229,
0.0222873501,
0.0398079045,
0.0263304263,
-0.041761227,
-0.0305468217,
0.00412302,
-0.021513721,
0.0359848216,
-0.0266136117,
0.0250135157,
0.0306203887,
-0.046431087,
0.0507628471,
0.0096380189,
-0.0665877163,
0.0259079821,
-0.050909631,
0.0198308639,
0.0726881847,
0.0408366956,
0.0170860402,
-0.0272864718,
-0.0104324501,
0.0389249288,
0.0423412509,
0.0104967281,
0.0147380307,
-0.0192430094,
-0.0682479441,
-0.0103455,
-0.0050410493,
0.018849168,
0.0219714399,
-0.0247082897,
0.0384664461,
0.0295665208,
-0.0130300401,
-0.0319505073,
0.0230093244,
-0.0214730818,
-0.0307239052,
0.0327893645,
-0.0048636971,
0.0197533369,
-0.0019894557,
-0.0181469806,
0.0245610252,
-0.0046664299,
-0.0602210388,
-0.024959961,
-0.0160944555,
-0.0275843181,
-0.0674976707,
0.0058193658,
0.0054190992,
0.0402380563,
-0.0129767079,
-0.034031298,
-0.0475326888,
0.0637878329,
-0.0375825427,
-0.0011418208,
-0.0367284305,
-0.0032125316,
0.0148679484,
0.0338254683,
-0.0278538205,
0.0410644002,
-0.0295280609,
0.0058620432,
0.0168691147,
0.0643235072,
-0.0249429047,
-0.0280760173,
-0.0351262055,
-0.0084489463,
0.0138652148,
0.0410272107,
-0.0001418843,
0.0190727375,
0.007855583,
-0.0500595346,
-0.0574567169,
0.0096230879,
-0.0517300442,
0.0071541998,
0.0254166201,
0.012748911,
0.0103587601,
0.0251156073,
-0.0752928108,
0.0205581132,
0.011022076,
-0.0057590441,
0.0302008111,
-0.0142438328,
-0.0192910079,
-0.0467178896,
-0.0230141431,
0.0210575815,
0.0370703936,
-0.0347194076,
-0.003010036,
-0.0666420311,
0.0229693241,
-0.0425866432,
0.0044467957,
-0.0228583682,
-0.0307563208,
-0.0012021683,
-0.0095943203,
0.0674301609,
0.0337737575,
0.0073488303,
0.0371817648,
0.0556846783,
-0.0082624583,
-0.0090478854,
0.0222974941,
-0.0466298275,
0.0141295353,
0.0003485363,
-0.0225720741,
0.0064100525,
0.0750748068,
0.0025502143,
-0.0362199694,
-0.0853355825,
0.053581927,
-0.0329097472,
-0.0320441276,
-0.018349139,
-0.0095081758,
-0.0090144761,
-0.000846507,
-0.0391401388,
-0.064533323,
0.053722728,
-0.0307282582,
0.0294948369,
-0.0223216917,
-0.0360257439,
-0.0091235768,
0.0062184408,
0.030188296,
0.0302998796,
0.0047304747,
-0.0019924112,
-0.0538799316,
0.0019534761,
-0.008121104,
-0.0300399568,
0.0148793142,
-0.0161700454,
0.0170413144,
-0.0179715157,
-0.0040941704,
-0.0063456753,
-0.0487818345,
0.039173197,
0.0296988171,
0.0391644053,
-0.0132028786,
0.0443304069,
0.0532991402,
0.0157341529,
0.0214669183,
-0.0482847318,
0.003120051,
-0.0349520221,
0.0430231877,
0.0678120255,
0.0050833947,
0.0011326832,
-0.0197366364,
-0.0066769836,
0.0134190693,
0.0209346171,
0.0258168522,
-0.0357289314,
0.0398158915,
-0.0110244276,
0.0031250208,
-0.0184648819,
-0.0057518794,
0.0864791721,
-0.0497054234,
-0.0475580841,
0.0899489969,
0.0082489559,
-0.0294997375,
0.0106260972,
0.0248995479,
0.081322141,
-0.0145214619,
0.0244747512,
-0.0601588748,
0.0055607664,
-0.0073973811,
0.0347956568,
0.0222483631,
-0.0083118947,
-0.0457588881,
-0.0430171862,
0.0348785557,
0.0592520609,
0.0035165227,
-0.0344463699,
0.002379121,
-0.0550409406,
0.0220478904,
0.0442649759,
0.0085508479,
0.012489846,
0.0062145796,
0.027789101,
0.0066856514,
-0.0888102427,
-0.0368397757,
-0.0477129444,
0.0370006002,
0.0663291365,
0.0405250788,
0.0185735188,
-0.0072841314,
0.0252152793,
-0.0223641619,
-0.0265861209,
0.0054523032,
0.0002500805,
0.0141968345,
-0.0457566381,
0.0124956323,
0.0361476317,
-0.0241426453,
-0.0153074907,
-0.040876545,
0.0789660364,
-0.0089523084,
-0.0429267511,
-0.0199764669,
-0.012353057,
0.0371583514,
0.0496593453,
0.0630618483,
-0.0751765966,
-0.0659371689,
0.0072224652,
0.0145339835,
-0.0385926738,
-0.0270282757,
-0.0317581408,
-0.0183157232,
-0.0769083127,
-0.1170297638,
-0.0195042044,
0.0029084128,
0.0583881885,
-0.0139087904,
0.006435581,
0.0462100096,
-0.0420206338,
-0.0735812411,
-0.0002620227,
0.0110361679,
0.0138949957,
-0.0234471764,
-0.0239795931,
0.016092822,
-0.0276719071,
-0.0072138193,
-0.0159034971,
-0.1167955026,
-0.1079306155,
-0.0186054613,
0.0306654088,
0.0045361668,
0.0145388301,
-0.0079433667,
-0.0723899007,
0.1014424786,
0.0168996975,
0.0213909801,
0.0414034277,
0.0039433418,
0.0028397501,
-0.0028682782,
0.0353320055,
-0.0333971605,
0.0401965529,
-0.0078509664,
0.0715163127,
-0.0288322512,
0.0257689375,
-0.0262434464,
-0.0481469929,
-0.0123719117,
-0.0190682523,
0.0322360508,
-0.057158716,
-0.0255997591,
-0.0325865895,
0.0016173692,
-0.0824928135,
-0.0037048988,
0.022806881,
0.0063475915,
-0.0334873162,
-0.0318308696,
0.0378494076,
0.0028201924,
0.0024711797,
-0.0025533945,
-0.0625023842,
0.0305771269,
0.0254448969,
0.0161214415,
-0.0214845203,
0.0028768792,
-0.0574648306,
0.0119265523,
-0.038317468,
0.0430843122,
0.0072405408,
0.0128597673,
-0.0354876556,
0.0565775707,
-0.0347428396,
-0.0088027669,
-0.0159210078,
0.0080887936,
0.0770449713,
0.038070064,
0.0802175626,
-0.006444165,
-0.0127344886,
-0.0092611238,
0.035949897,
-0.0058372994,
-0.0192686319,
0.0617001168,
0.0138959531,
-0.019839352,
-0.0205693766,
0.0628139228,
0.0414208397,
-0.0382590741,
-0.0141497636,
0.0049998197,
-0.0082017807,
-0.0077332677,
-0.0473543666,
0.0109291598,
0.0022632778,
0.0141334189,
-0.0185703579,
-0.0730433613,
0.0081031304,
0.0307504646,
-0.0114571592,
0.0002256749,
0.0239114985,
0.0362078547,
-0.0064052665,
0.0036592593,
-0.0511657521,
0.0069029462,
-0.0096179238,
-0.022836009,
-0.0253003612,
-6.770225183e-33,
-0.0420665592,
-0.0368930399,
0.0200212635,
-0.0535355099,
-0.0760176703,
0.0047147418,
-0.0664368272,
0.0088578342,
0.0151693197,
0.0001799015,
-0.0000345912,
0.0139313992,
-0.0045664427,
0.0484742075,
-0.0301019736,
0.0214928668,
0.0495950282,
-0.0149752358,
-0.0042080889,
0.0370507464,
0.0227451175,
0.0476213917,
0.0009825875,
0.0111273332,
-0.0016718399,
0.0097468598,
0.0229818542,
-0.0266725514,
0.0363121666,
0.0221910477,
-0.0326987989,
-0.0013240783,
0.0223087352,
0.0319105908,
-0.0583487861,
0.0322880186,
-0.0303172916,
-0.0213213246,
-0.0323063433,
-0.0144763151,
-0.0210399106,
-0.0508697182,
0.0887769833,
-0.0288136099,
0.0099704154,
0.0093146265,
0.0038631235,
0.0141068818,
-0.0365904793,
-0.0578308403,
-0.0423340686,
0.0328094587,
0.0248501468,
0.0105210505,
0.0175608117,
-0.0017149893,
-0.0243076496,
-0.0015552827,
-0.0603401251,
-0.0019383521,
-0.0146935834,
0.0708088204,
0.0527537949,
0.0290863216,
0.0416640416,
0.0412897542,
0.0417460799,
0.0263128653,
-0.028582355,
0.0359187983,
0.0343466401,
0.0118209673,
0.0464892909,
0.0163955446,
0.0492061749,
-0.0276486389,
-0.0503174402,
-0.0336233675,
-0.0334616452,
-0.01296377,
0.0766985863,
0.0362464823,
-0.0119379554,
-0.0391331837,
-0.0274583641,
-0.0138582401,
-0.0147782816,
-0.0591070689,
0.0330836214,
0.0323636159,
-0.0283016674,
-0.0642659068,
0.0311054438,
-0.0232694913,
-0.0195101891,
-0.02341846,
-0.0176091008,
0.0299636181,
0.0087661287,
0.0255791526,
-0.056022577,
-0.0354001857,
-0.004181684,
0.0246365368,
-0.0157972276,
0.0228461027,
-0.0039008153,
0.0301846806,
-0.0457469821,
-0.0107456697,
-0.0470111631,
-0.0004517636,
-0.0150815472,
0.0617598966,
0.0384747423,
0.0006929582,
-0.0056554121,
0.0257552583,
0.0234996397,
-0.0092731696,
0.0283901934,
0.0094985953,
0.0237723924,
0.0678182021,
-0.038027104,
0.0164578874,
-0.0426743515,
0.1130782515,
0.0576969162,
-0.0842460468,
-0.0192174204,
0.0244809687,
2.922e-7,
0.0204944517,
0.0186748952,
-0.0110707795,
0.0233285371,
0.0192301907,
-0.0090972418,
-0.0219390709,
0.0337765515,
-0.0123071587,
-0.0194334779,
0.0189293567,
0.02689269,
0.0229074955,
-0.0155892847,
-0.0759662688,
0.0087077683,
-0.0307067372,
0.0459500737,
-0.0169035885,
-0.0625715926,
0.0364240818,
0.0790197849,
0.0095093325,
0.0254538041,
0.0332411975,
-0.0015883058,
0.0741311163,
0.0069763986,
0.0106318528,
0.0088833626,
0.0136712817,
0.0197660662,
-0.0399986319,
-0.0501041748,
-0.0297481623,
0.0243341234,
-0.0104969479,
0.058332745,
0.0112037556,
-0.0419067293,
0.0208995417,
-0.0050814198,
-0.0139923096,
-0.0257836897,
0.0450660214,
-0.095385313,
-0.0223252568,
-0.0477148183,
-0.0060267407,
0.0008002367,
0.02874179,
-0.0279464629,
-0.0496927537,
0.0171387494,
0.0292809326,
0.003372692,
0.0160630215,
-0.0756548941,
0.0053603267,
0.0258498341,
-0.050331898,
-0.0379746407,
-0.0736931637,
-0.0129769184,
0.0284682158,
0.0012355248,
-0.009614476,
2.884710662e-34,
0.0280964151,
-0.0480629206,
0.0149550699,
-0.0095959287,
-0.0035956097,
-0.0136225168,
-0.0109331384,
-0.002783499,
0.034635704,
-0.0516492128,
-0.044854138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10104v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10104v2 | GeoEval: Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs and Multi-Modal Models on Geometry Problem-Solving | 2024-02-15T16:59:41 | 2024-05-17T11:42:09 | Jiaxin Zhang, Zhongzhi Li, Mingliang Zhang, Fei Yin, Chenglin Liu, Yashar Moshfeghi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) and multi-modal models
(MMs) have demonstrated their remarkable capabilities in problem-solving. Yet,
their proficiency in tackling geometry math problems, which necessitates an
integrated understanding of both textual and visual information, has not been
thoroughly evaluated. To address this gap, we introduce the GeoEval benchmark,
a comprehensive collection that includes a main subset of 2,000 problems, a 750
problems subset focusing on backward reasoning, an augmented subset of 2,000
problems, and a hard subset of 300 problems. This benchmark facilitates a
deeper investigation into the performance of LLMs and MMs in solving geometry
math problems. Our evaluation of ten LLMs and MMs across these varied subsets
reveals that the WizardMath model excels, achieving a 55.67\% accuracy rate on
the main subset but only a 6.00\% accuracy on the hard subset. This highlights
the critical need for testing models against datasets on which they have not
been pre-trained. Additionally, our findings indicate that GPT-series models
perform more effectively on problems they have rephrased, suggesting a
promising method for enhancing model capabilities. | [
-0.0165900439,
0.0675930828,
-0.0177335441,
0.0550941303,
-0.0736076683,
0.0445078574,
0.0273082741,
0.0035469581,
-0.0019362052,
-0.0522921607,
-0.0048043337,
-0.0315560959,
0.018375976,
-0.0193399098,
0.0238092877,
-0.0696370155,
0.0115416264,
-0.0712373704,
-0.0266955793,
0.0004200083,
-0.0461523309,
-0.0087413192,
-0.0608821362,
0.0038338755,
-0.0479460917,
-0.0619422421,
-0.0231141392,
-0.0339834057,
0.0015164081,
-0.0341484696,
-0.0290523469,
0.0284243692,
0.0374769568,
0.0410368294,
0.0000023411,
-0.0340627171,
0.0005276403,
0.0166336428,
0.0134823797,
0.0335440189,
-0.0111458814,
-0.0027392341,
-0.0004835986,
-0.0256727468,
-0.0428797156,
0.0232354179,
-0.0044162786,
0.0384649038,
0.0457794778,
0.0645644739,
-0.0028224797,
-0.041496329,
0.0453041121,
-0.0131491488,
0.0487141684,
-0.0550262667,
0.0046226233,
0.0576717556,
0.0258429032,
0.0293516275,
-0.0522420891,
0.0376861244,
0.0263594091,
0.0392149314,
-0.0697643459,
-0.0038858964,
0.0104253823,
0.0471132211,
-0.0139919454,
0.049198065,
0.0307073891,
0.0113355657,
-0.0271423683,
-0.0040899799,
-0.0234509353,
0.0722412318,
-0.0919814333,
0.0253402069,
-0.0278148931,
-0.0054097679,
-0.0291461851,
-0.0563706234,
0.012834236,
0.0115638338,
-0.0355961211,
0.0654037818,
0.0283371676,
-0.0382489823,
-0.0098327091,
0.0188360829,
-0.0395691358,
-0.0262355488,
0.0043959864,
0.063587144,
0.0008909137,
0.0017629672,
0.0227918718,
-0.0205399916,
-0.010317211,
-0.0162143167,
0.0740881637,
0.0689122677,
0.0253149029,
0.0506518371,
-0.0711482689,
0.0838323981,
-0.0314611383,
0.0414453782,
-0.0158234462,
0.0304019097,
-0.0447292402,
-0.004909419,
-0.0356614292,
0.0030291765,
0.0015381041,
0.0084935194,
-0.0229580738,
-0.0045768172,
0.0109050814,
0.0180284195,
-0.0139930127,
0.0090852436,
-0.0002707073,
-0.0586566888,
-0.0400149636,
0.0129654929,
-0.0346996486,
0.0519453734,
-0.0208992325,
-0.0115112979,
0.0071429103,
0.0008908267,
0.0070077749,
-0.0230289288,
0.0381088816,
0.0838199332,
-0.0162133146,
-0.0015587771,
-0.0525058731,
-0.0301765781,
0.0009940179,
-0.0836373121,
0.031950213,
-0.0651674792,
0.0011557278,
0.0143494187,
-0.0059287981,
0.0024970789,
-0.0086683827,
0.0038104418,
-0.0038870184,
0.0348127075,
0.0551394559,
0.0125346975,
0.0541424043,
0.0316176899,
-0.0095459744,
0.0666679665,
0.0603729524,
0.031452436,
0.0032438415,
0.0014556547,
0.0006871452,
0.0388102867,
0.0101381857,
0.0234376285,
-0.0748589784,
-0.0003859606,
0.0285179615,
0.0650592968,
-0.0368159451,
0.0534199849,
-0.0204885621,
0.0150186112,
0.0532768033,
0.0485469662,
0.0204909761,
0.0385856777,
0.0331008025,
-0.025044268,
0.0337588638,
0.0001641009,
-0.0780245289,
-0.0016275634,
-0.0395306312,
0.0268073604,
-0.0134054013,
0.0376037583,
-0.0044318228,
-0.0446179919,
-0.0310784597,
-0.0052146073,
-0.0354341865,
-0.0051766853,
0.0922376961,
-0.0281510707,
-0.0135240573,
0.0177644212,
-0.0071940157,
-0.0332321525,
-0.0271777567,
-0.0128416941,
0.0274653025,
-0.0134203359,
0.0527514666,
-0.041863624,
-0.0679093748,
-0.0002994388,
0.044856865,
-0.0026415319,
0.0551864579,
0.0296916179,
-0.0032229549,
-0.0298267137,
-0.0391603783,
-0.0294416733,
0.0320587792,
0.0113932285,
0.0424828902,
0.0286319964,
0.0219835248,
-0.0418180488,
0.0479058474,
0.0256405175,
-0.0588732995,
-0.0237188358,
-0.0594787933,
0.012964909,
-0.0139758727,
-0.0240504909,
0.0162339639,
-0.0047344668,
0.022670418,
-0.0348214656,
0.002003571,
-0.0211244058,
-0.0901754051,
-0.0233730413,
0.0728702769,
-0.0656657442,
-0.0272470042,
0.0077457856,
-0.027968524,
-0.0272587929,
0.0458716191,
-0.0296182819,
0.0236175358,
0.0010653182,
0.0210129172,
-0.0032887636,
-0.0497235097,
-0.0331426412,
0.0759044886,
-0.0045035887,
0.0575577803,
-0.0061991462,
-0.0213908479,
0.0313679948,
0.0095365094,
0.0056196237,
-0.0312418081,
0.0079385126,
0.0160316397,
-0.0565260574,
0.0344614163,
-0.026271088,
-0.05693179,
-0.0752627924,
-0.0004375121,
-0.005404416,
0.049202811,
0.0138205253,
-0.0423263423,
-0.0444011092,
-0.0181674827,
-0.0258740187,
0.006411301,
0.0192425512,
-0.0011554672,
0.0038827937,
0.0022827454,
-0.0007806649,
-0.0124183362,
-0.0170196593,
-0.0548294224,
0.041418571,
0.0305090491,
0.0403349176,
-0.0138828084,
0.0251755472,
-0.0357515216,
0.0082079563,
-0.0277851168,
-0.0073448052,
0.0246427711,
-0.0412880555,
0.0515260473,
0.0165453386,
-0.0029142946,
-0.0075871022,
0.01645381,
-0.0590170138,
-0.0429714248,
0.0162904654,
-0.0320420563,
-0.0198387373,
-0.0509782396,
-0.0394984409,
-0.0300587695,
0.0663945302,
-0.0268692188,
-0.0044951965,
0.0209618434,
0.0435095914,
-0.0048254975,
-0.0082459552,
-0.042055741,
0.0154902823,
0.0096003888,
0.0401827656,
0.0087738018,
-0.0286316052,
0.0499839559,
-0.0323809497,
-0.0083332658,
-0.0269226748,
0.0352649167,
-0.075989306,
0.0513756499,
0.004123121,
0.0142502626,
-0.044197958,
-0.0152272023,
-0.0445511751,
-0.0142704304,
0.0441119112,
-0.0065048747,
0.0707536936,
-0.0730879828,
-0.0096314866,
-0.0193653274,
-0.0520412549,
-0.0191344228,
0.0246794932,
-0.0211586114,
-0.000287357,
-0.0294526946,
-0.0373884365,
-0.0537286811,
0.0261047576,
0.0297171865,
0.011056615,
-0.0588293299,
-0.0188161042,
-0.0230832454,
0.0293508638,
0.0174004231,
0.066269353,
0.0076853954,
-0.0766372904,
0.0095233293,
0.0395618081,
0.0347167216,
-0.0307904854,
-0.0036331194,
0.063697122,
0.0219217278,
-0.0170080997,
-0.0379971564,
0.0144904796,
0.0268467758,
-0.0709187761,
-0.0202200767,
0.0880394801,
0.0469240509,
-0.0337423459,
-0.0253089797,
-0.0608452931,
-0.0042831367,
0.0015407561,
-0.0152452132,
-0.0459241457,
-0.0236521624,
0.0276214089,
-0.0342518464,
0.0432472415,
-0.0396520793,
0.0370903425,
-0.1035143137,
0.0412832424,
0.0243261885,
-0.0454085059,
-0.0015584911,
-0.0172046069,
-0.0134003563,
0.0127275586,
-0.024697978,
-0.0206436049,
-0.0254229344,
0.013211485,
0.0317514688,
0.0010287986,
-0.0002970604,
0.019655047,
-0.0150284078,
-0.0392792411,
-0.028410919,
0.037095435,
-0.0251146555,
-0.1082331762,
0.0632662773,
0.0634910539,
0.0228215624,
-0.0109844049,
0.0197781287,
0.0306668114,
0.0076356735,
-0.0033401584,
0.0011257447,
-0.0448832102,
-0.0463403687,
0.0404784009,
0.0998792946,
-0.0015829066,
0.046411328,
-0.0257357024,
-0.0068899402,
-0.0206992049,
0.0285134111,
0.0086507685,
-0.0042610359,
-0.0860692859,
-0.0472692586,
0.0153733743,
-0.0203787871,
-0.0413807631,
0.0134179117,
0.0634307489,
0.0197178163,
-0.0256855935,
0.0076552611,
0.0343579277,
0.082677491,
0.0195667297,
-0.0426255204,
-0.0085516209,
0.007612492,
-0.0306113195,
0.0613920018,
-0.0271447618,
0.04724098,
-0.0740849748,
0.0542878211,
-0.0111988485,
-0.0473180525,
-0.0359511748,
-0.0029004992,
-0.105086334,
-0.0234211013,
-0.0129312668,
0.0442059264,
0.0262574274,
0.0083058253,
0.0111326585,
0.0074125687,
-0.0021378712,
-0.0116034802,
-0.0489460491,
0.0190769695,
-0.0103326757,
0.0163632929,
0.0074933777,
-0.0114252027,
0.0293841008,
0.0043652081,
0.0225573163,
0.0233918242,
0.0038757147,
-0.0066290586,
-0.0075946534,
0.037806239,
0.0498417355,
0.0251643062,
0.0211439021,
-0.0044661872,
0.0246950779,
-0.049533274,
-0.0039284015,
-0.0174469464,
0.0264274385,
0.0210403726,
-0.0066313618,
0.0079765404,
-0.0230243541,
0.0393915586,
0.0405238271,
-0.0411339402,
0.0458702818,
0.0170485154,
-0.0073055201,
0.040586628,
0.0119033139,
-0.0048239739,
0.0051557496,
-0.0142823765,
0.0637087673,
-0.0177022312,
0.0695403144,
-0.006944824,
0.0001647976,
-0.070425123,
-0.0132231768,
-0.0566639304,
-0.1021875292,
-0.038687285,
0.0545006506,
0.0513217933,
0.0140835373,
-0.0185025278,
-0.0382563509,
-0.0100672571,
0.0058302032,
0.0086401384,
0.0253323484,
0.0076157474,
0.0341336131,
0.0305311345,
0.0108006708,
-0.025953779,
0.0316193588,
-0.0126606124,
0.0414909422,
0.011108391,
-0.0198749024,
-0.028789999,
-0.0316312499,
0.0263163149,
0.0351497531,
0.0046981541,
0.0021873023,
-0.0888691097,
-0.069720082,
-0.009967179,
0.0337035991,
-0.0193979312,
0.0093118958,
0.0324264988,
0.0738857538,
-0.0127978818,
-0.0234323777,
0.0034879521,
0.0495929755,
-0.0346620865,
-0.0159892309,
-0.023999704,
-5.622922126e-33,
-0.0232254751,
-0.0132367667,
0.085363932,
-0.0163172483,
-0.0056800474,
-0.029008314,
-0.0163789541,
0.0505672805,
-0.0129553229,
-0.0036880381,
0.0017363894,
-0.0192324966,
0.0021462538,
0.0133367749,
0.0084151868,
0.0287334006,
-0.0164360199,
-0.0030360622,
-0.0284954906,
-0.0082048224,
0.0214453004,
-0.0024375094,
0.0660274103,
-0.0849031806,
-0.0239827801,
0.0039467197,
-0.002681839,
0.0170924794,
-0.0689582676,
0.0770896077,
-0.0256368704,
0.0021695481,
0.0325958915,
0.001946253,
-0.0064388006,
-0.0129193561,
-0.0197992679,
-0.0431309901,
0.0077805901,
0.0265882406,
-0.0229229312,
-0.0270039421,
0.0015073613,
0.0192817114,
-0.0442122594,
-0.0215525515,
0.0406852365,
-0.0359122679,
-0.0307533257,
0.0470730662,
-0.0538061149,
0.0248295236,
-0.0217585154,
-0.018264534,
0.0121188676,
0.0382905826,
-0.0026525874,
0.0320533291,
0.0111077139,
0.0306582898,
0.0519301184,
-0.0076552969,
0.046453435,
0.0035098821,
-0.016851889,
0.0485343672,
0.0358589254,
-0.0541440435,
-0.0357279181,
-0.0277695227,
0.0566715673,
0.0813678503,
0.032015156,
0.0573470965,
0.009250056,
0.0298762731,
-0.0480251908,
0.0139866015,
-0.0274651889,
0.0480474867,
-0.0007319018,
-0.0124785556,
-0.036453221,
-0.0064034867,
-0.057359267,
0.0255184174,
-0.0278350841,
0.0247247498,
0.0303740855,
-0.0076766689,
0.0534233861,
0.0236986335,
0.0201127082,
-0.0330131426,
-0.0362985656,
0.0392827429,
-0.0019969991,
0.0393637531,
-0.0104710776,
0.0557763539,
-0.054498747,
-0.0317125395,
-0.0108650653,
0.0136468904,
0.0189758707,
-0.0209158547,
0.0083178282,
0.0190477744,
-0.0601634569,
-0.0100105274,
-0.0490714125,
-0.0483655259,
0.04008618,
0.0256326571,
0.0633914322,
-0.0287974644,
-0.0162210148,
0.035244368,
-0.0356530137,
-0.0372076854,
-0.0102789858,
-0.038332358,
-0.0264073033,
0.0242959913,
0.0181719549,
-0.0129728569,
-0.0069421032,
-0.0542819053,
0.0565549247,
-0.0431247167,
-0.0006104133,
0.0290210359,
2.9e-7,
0.059542302,
0.0565338321,
0.0332690775,
-0.008574089,
0.0369095877,
0.0540006831,
-0.0727856159,
-0.0337347202,
0.0307146534,
0.0476402454,
0.0162940472,
0.049898278,
0.0441759937,
0.049345348,
-0.0284945033,
0.0621180534,
0.0102458661,
-0.0143585177,
-0.0816553608,
0.0372779779,
0.0507134646,
0.006904922,
0.0142088206,
-0.0276140906,
-0.0181402601,
-0.057243146,
0.0581176691,
-0.0397803225,
-0.024634596,
0.0238389242,
0.0162749551,
0.0033625329,
0.0104155894,
0.0008753089,
0.0180765372,
0.0126372147,
0.0074400455,
0.04980921,
0.0187934786,
0.0217656698,
-0.0049570212,
-0.0269832313,
-0.0189403761,
-0.0522045307,
0.0494265109,
-0.0204075631,
-0.0140907718,
-0.0151269436,
-0.0134320399,
-0.0171602778,
0.0218995064,
0.0028708293,
0.0282613859,
-0.0055030496,
0.025109712,
-0.0207226537,
-0.0105398335,
-0.0834834725,
-0.0050728638,
0.0652984306,
-0.0510388128,
-0.0441885069,
-0.0464904755,
0.0221413318,
0.0537233837,
-0.0425562561,
-0.0545156002,
2.819370625e-34,
0.0088592181,
-0.0270585306,
0.0322129838,
0.0174696911,
0.0039112042,
-0.0078955684,
0.0397041067,
-0.0051153037,
-0.016644787,
-0.0584501997,
0.0032865275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10076v1 | QUICK: Quantization-aware Interleaving and Conflict-free Kernel for efficient LLM inference | 2024-02-15T16:38:41 | 2024-02-15T16:38:41 | Taesu Kim, Jongho Lee, Daehyun Ahn, Sarang Kim, Jiwoong Choi, Minkyu Kim, Hyungjun Kim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce QUICK, a group of novel optimized CUDA kernels for the efficient
inference of quantized Large Language Models (LLMs). QUICK addresses the shared
memory bank-conflict problem of state-of-the-art mixed precision matrix
multiplication kernels. Our method interleaves the quantized weight matrices of
LLMs offline to skip the shared memory write-back after the dequantization. We
demonstrate up to 1.91x speedup over existing kernels of AutoAWQ on larger
batches and up to 1.94x throughput gain on representative LLM models on various
NVIDIA GPU devices. | [
-0.0107050454,
0.0627934411,
-0.0156746283,
0.0880371258,
-0.0106934682,
0.0081627155,
0.026595816,
-0.0002265932,
0.0076258779,
-0.0300225411,
0.007720103,
-0.0452640466,
0.0206643958,
-0.0089592021,
0.0236310959,
0.0285417326,
0.0485940166,
-0.0550334342,
-0.025520362,
-0.0349305794,
-0.0024856557,
0.0261721257,
-0.003458065,
-0.001883293,
-0.0283528045,
-0.0610403195,
-0.000161981,
-0.0081439149,
0.0267070867,
0.0307004005,
0.0237914901,
0.0412331223,
0.0304410923,
0.0530504845,
0.0000022214,
-0.0324519388,
-0.0049220501,
-0.012800144,
-0.0192974936,
0.0564806275,
-0.0021335774,
-0.0013648225,
-0.0329505317,
-0.0006912382,
-0.0070375348,
0.0126336459,
0.0427711345,
-0.0207232926,
-0.0084288772,
0.0127962409,
-0.003450522,
-0.0350950994,
0.0465303101,
-0.0169975143,
-0.0188634023,
-0.0435687155,
0.0209090319,
0.0419844724,
-0.0129351355,
-0.0368410833,
-0.0240224376,
0.035606835,
0.0137540177,
0.0000818674,
-0.0347805433,
0.0249416344,
-0.0547807552,
-0.0230772793,
-0.0012570265,
0.0376101099,
-0.0953210816,
-0.0404834002,
0.0249186773,
-0.0057285456,
-0.0257689022,
-0.0422314219,
-0.0076898597,
0.0705759823,
-0.0257220343,
0.0292643048,
0.0207162593,
-0.0028940148,
0.0443390906,
0.0205802564,
-0.0553301573,
0.082078822,
0.0427187532,
0.0438700207,
-0.0373433158,
-0.0194489975,
-0.0856607407,
-0.0329265222,
-0.0106798895,
-0.0038819266,
0.0004733606,
0.0062228283,
-0.0842614695,
-0.0375799276,
0.0102897054,
-0.0758971572,
0.0398264714,
0.0694650114,
-0.0081469426,
0.0120953899,
-0.0361062773,
0.0381824858,
-0.0204393119,
0.0237292498,
-0.0221432894,
0.0146162566,
0.0384295434,
0.0059653013,
0.0023891958,
0.0306005739,
-0.0330451168,
-0.0191425793,
-0.0534695089,
0.0383536443,
-0.0292440746,
-0.0034002771,
-0.0162376426,
0.0137673039,
-0.0029278654,
0.0104688033,
0.024687428,
0.0068148212,
0.0126406364,
0.0078793932,
-0.0619595498,
-0.0590816513,
0.0077025504,
0.0325238965,
0.025741227,
-0.051482942,
0.0528164767,
0.0348724835,
0.0048996834,
-0.096449025,
-0.0186383128,
-0.0033398431,
-0.0247095469,
-0.0634700283,
-0.0203279182,
-0.0746357813,
0.0598372407,
0.0378064215,
0.0121333897,
0.0075393408,
0.0269510671,
0.0404486619,
-0.0147698065,
0.0591200478,
-0.0008568387,
-0.0138270939,
0.0375509672,
-0.0082356827,
0.0557352118,
0.0772951916,
0.0138100516,
0.0416429043,
0.011080143,
0.0245671012,
-0.0150201824,
0.0317918174,
0.0044375123,
0.0081987074,
-0.0444946177,
0.0162368715,
0.028792832,
0.0419265255,
0.0927501544,
0.0997546613,
-0.048852969,
-0.0628752485,
0.0315055326,
0.0652865171,
-0.0111252088,
0.0157279763,
0.0034455885,
-0.0031240962,
0.0314466357,
-0.0004733234,
0.0044288072,
0.0111117549,
-0.0020336187,
-0.0038473532,
0.1223492026,
0.0671613291,
-0.0093416926,
-0.0067111314,
-0.0154282488,
-0.0109203532,
-0.0480470844,
0.0173037127,
0.0193917546,
-0.0293175485,
-0.0239041224,
0.0444739647,
0.0391724594,
-0.0558899492,
-0.0528737344,
-0.0462118015,
0.0381040089,
0.0238415301,
0.0324356146,
0.0163187124,
-0.0224711802,
0.0142887421,
-0.0382438563,
-0.0127505045,
-0.0442896076,
0.0030568915,
0.005307375,
-0.057971552,
0.0261359122,
-0.0212447736,
-0.0032114943,
-0.0032485446,
0.0522191003,
0.0303778891,
0.0152776008,
0.0004555197,
-0.034873765,
-0.0079828287,
0.0009119089,
-0.0198955219,
0.0069264756,
-0.0101165185,
0.0026192113,
-0.0023493043,
-0.0107767731,
0.0051287096,
0.0353993513,
-0.0544663779,
0.0123936823,
-0.0422607996,
-0.0274076704,
-0.0444989875,
0.0611774996,
0.0211197119,
0.0008331603,
0.0068280641,
-0.0454278402,
-0.0281853974,
0.0262995251,
-0.0026981842,
0.0176082421,
-0.0671129972,
0.0211067759,
0.0252078138,
0.0401573889,
-0.0305888001,
0.0467494018,
-0.0553852245,
0.0339281969,
0.0223832354,
0.0153757688,
0.0083698314,
-0.0226984303,
-0.0375443064,
0.0269480404,
0.0008556902,
0.0506014265,
-0.0339133143,
-0.0511212386,
0.02871201,
0.0071095633,
-0.0838770494,
0.0218968373,
-0.0319791399,
0.0185771435,
0.0192381553,
0.0180191472,
0.0109287659,
-0.0061507183,
0.0051471172,
0.0126868086,
-0.011489436,
0.0158631671,
-0.0325222909,
0.0036064752,
-0.0189378206,
-0.0297691319,
-0.0421079583,
-0.0183777008,
0.0685171187,
-0.048930075,
-0.0424672626,
-0.042325221,
0.0061120018,
-0.0133416066,
0.0542621575,
-0.0281699859,
0.0113135977,
0.0154007506,
-0.0209019184,
0.0737180412,
0.0392569527,
0.010664098,
0.0010356311,
0.0357718468,
-0.0219990928,
-0.0221423134,
0.0351630896,
0.0064528254,
-0.0575678498,
-0.003725339,
-0.0263859574,
-0.0691132396,
0.087591745,
-0.0034055489,
-0.0432348363,
-0.0218372103,
-0.0267881993,
0.0013183979,
0.0032414761,
-0.0608402751,
-0.0121590625,
0.0022260852,
0.0285800826,
0.0006542192,
-0.0634364337,
0.0197767429,
-0.0586844012,
-0.0060823928,
0.0014709343,
-0.0213137474,
-0.0367521234,
0.0602283664,
0.0234912392,
0.0207226444,
-0.086388424,
0.0099872965,
0.0270275529,
0.0288586766,
-0.0178770553,
-0.0560313538,
0.046733208,
-0.0320732035,
0.0414831787,
-0.0455049649,
-0.0105853332,
-0.0074940729,
0.0208266508,
-0.0449581072,
-0.014928895,
0.0330591053,
-0.0476094373,
0.0607044213,
0.0823434666,
-0.0183696449,
0.0594044738,
-0.0146288723,
0.0260260738,
-0.0228051133,
0.0134879109,
0.0469195507,
0.0057080369,
-0.0042289253,
-0.0061422559,
-0.0194018297,
0.0263064019,
0.0415140986,
0.019724261,
-0.0534246191,
-0.0174502581,
0.052650582,
0.0222679842,
-0.0097076967,
0.0130497916,
-0.0046362071,
-0.0548046082,
0.0040851263,
0.0519303568,
0.0347737819,
-0.0541735515,
-0.001537168,
0.0162575133,
0.0046651484,
0.0129911639,
0.0423965752,
-0.1189586893,
-0.0302557014,
0.019854065,
-0.0262193829,
0.0216183178,
-0.0065257694,
-0.018868722,
-0.0827490762,
0.0240599755,
0.0044951485,
0.0268488787,
-0.0409407504,
-0.0175493993,
-0.0099112391,
-0.0070565129,
0.0084370552,
0.0225583743,
0.0004123476,
0.021524623,
-0.0115254847,
0.0112401256,
0.0138433436,
0.0158738233,
0.0014382498,
0.0166031029,
0.0435880125,
0.0143734831,
0.0099423118,
-0.0648543611,
0.015362082,
-0.043101564,
-0.0286715105,
-0.0216366872,
-0.0056951661,
-0.0384330451,
-0.0233997256,
-0.0170235168,
0.0027071333,
-0.0018768436,
-0.0254338793,
-0.0431322753,
0.0649994463,
-0.0291850176,
-0.0233915839,
0.0027793683,
-0.0249854736,
-0.024204582,
0.0516423993,
0.0097909598,
-0.0145229343,
-0.0468957983,
-0.0339872092,
-0.0619258396,
-0.0028453544,
-0.0443238392,
-0.0093229795,
0.0202405136,
-0.0331467651,
0.0113121541,
0.0350556709,
0.0302903075,
0.0048699146,
-0.0489175133,
0.0050322535,
-0.003868416,
-0.0179189611,
-0.1094451621,
0.014930916,
-0.0374347642,
0.0611864328,
-0.0641288534,
0.0287997387,
0.0178955682,
0.0137026599,
-0.0026613574,
0.0441368409,
-0.1365561634,
-0.0731739178,
-0.0059415395,
0.0185388532,
0.015421777,
0.0506467074,
0.0295397006,
-0.0258512869,
0.0291006994,
0.0370178632,
0.0112467501,
0.0714394525,
0.0063087055,
-0.0197384674,
-0.0111939199,
0.0361407623,
0.0216570534,
-0.001803509,
-0.0074202837,
0.031552624,
-0.0184808038,
-0.0787550062,
-0.0369852036,
-0.0114145214,
0.0331661999,
0.0092762262,
0.0049682413,
-0.0170487054,
0.0465301462,
0.0241288785,
0.0019471813,
-0.0346880071,
-0.0098741576,
0.03134837,
0.0054229684,
-0.0400123596,
-0.0132746417,
0.060689006,
-0.0056381179,
0.0131562119,
-0.0191023499,
-0.0265216567,
-0.0023992492,
0.0491977446,
-0.0390493013,
-0.0182651412,
0.0173506439,
0.0142013989,
0.0594912209,
-0.0174396988,
-0.0087553663,
-0.017304929,
-0.0239503738,
-0.0199497398,
0.0255601276,
-0.0104963239,
-0.0976192653,
-0.0510970578,
-0.0010853356,
0.053964179,
-0.0091744224,
0.0514108166,
-0.0070754532,
-0.0101215485,
-0.0215679836,
0.0272105373,
-0.0085507501,
0.0168454461,
0.0538766235,
0.0301963799,
-0.0298780669,
0.0327954069,
0.0504532978,
0.026042372,
0.034181796,
0.0186242908,
-0.0035942164,
-0.0059058978,
-0.0503362864,
-0.0285402033,
0.0102694603,
-0.0140399011,
0.0004905211,
-0.0128211984,
-0.0383069739,
0.0338475332,
0.0226753708,
-0.0384630188,
-0.0141809508,
-0.0155381132,
0.0454769172,
0.0250220206,
-0.0177752022,
-0.0235546101,
0.0166761726,
0.0390262865,
-0.0117458478,
0.0031057538,
-6.435129948e-33,
-0.009418671,
-0.0200419277,
0.0324479081,
-0.0254231635,
0.0093351072,
0.0168772414,
0.0046576648,
-0.0127264671,
-0.0044975253,
-0.0245081782,
-0.0043049231,
0.0321799926,
0.0168162361,
-0.01135052,
-0.0110203056,
0.023567535,
0.0464340076,
0.0226288512,
0.0348539203,
0.0315602161,
-0.0002682722,
0.0493363813,
0.0316934139,
0.0139165139,
-0.0286916904,
-0.0243578386,
0.0548495539,
-0.013721576,
-0.022591712,
0.0007595236,
-0.0818322822,
0.0312095769,
0.0090913782,
-0.0036430664,
-0.0060534733,
-0.0227780454,
-0.0734844729,
0.0087848166,
0.0670233443,
0.0268498994,
-0.029892059,
-0.0410890318,
-0.0011153242,
0.052160427,
-0.0142419636,
-0.0230524447,
-0.0428315401,
0.0142952921,
-0.0402090251,
-0.0392620675,
-0.0241749007,
0.0394303389,
0.0585404821,
0.0310610477,
0.087510027,
-0.045607172,
-0.0145767787,
0.0065291133,
-0.0748723596,
-0.0134876939,
0.0069854134,
0.0756309256,
0.0720450878,
0.0393820368,
0.0101716081,
0.0485809185,
0.020529069,
-0.017328009,
0.0091758147,
0.0528035983,
0.0311894361,
0.0311589893,
-0.0041698008,
0.0405310877,
0.0633303896,
0.0072480291,
-0.0736917555,
-0.0049136248,
0.0095417192,
-0.0204198752,
0.0518908054,
0.0225604363,
0.0014828871,
-0.0571181886,
-0.0220281295,
0.035749685,
-0.0467574149,
0.0195036028,
-0.0040001413,
0.0176352784,
-0.0484980792,
0.0134136612,
0.0198238958,
-0.0221824534,
-0.0114257531,
-0.0104051307,
0.0088174231,
0.0089246212,
0.0269175582,
0.071302563,
-0.0276643578,
-0.0399809778,
-0.0158778969,
-0.0417962223,
0.0393008292,
0.0087744528,
0.0385280922,
0.0253799781,
-0.0718752742,
-0.0194464475,
-0.0509464704,
-0.009967451,
0.0048553706,
0.066483289,
0.019856289,
0.0494173504,
0.0223147124,
0.0211274866,
-0.0075217807,
0.0314996243,
-0.0189304575,
-0.0458750464,
-0.0172602069,
0.0319025666,
-0.0255394056,
-0.0098389667,
-0.0324991867,
0.0606339052,
0.0017612658,
-0.091019541,
-0.0307497587,
0.0168220196,
2.957e-7,
0.0334055535,
0.0022469491,
0.0111935744,
-0.011064712,
0.004220143,
-0.0160971526,
0.0261255335,
0.0270836037,
0.0190694854,
-0.0343232378,
0.0076905694,
0.0333258994,
0.0184644274,
-0.0015666791,
-0.0304965209,
0.0214446764,
-0.0347055197,
0.018062165,
-0.0635494217,
-0.0357508771,
-0.0117957927,
0.0999834314,
-0.0327300914,
-0.0091083655,
0.0649020001,
-0.0266456548,
0.0221356228,
0.0277520604,
-0.0008800445,
0.0028742189,
0.0659567118,
-0.0100106662,
-0.0157156307,
-0.0029522053,
0.0257166047,
0.0033152872,
-0.0561747402,
0.0554256514,
-0.0003155732,
-0.0171220191,
0.0199338831,
-0.0424517319,
-0.0342761055,
-0.0309241284,
0.0788354799,
0.0207825303,
0.0048298636,
-0.1012075841,
0.0420737639,
-0.0102648856,
0.0211503822,
0.0116391797,
0.0612073392,
0.0414322801,
0.0272016823,
-0.0367066972,
-0.0026455009,
-0.0761229545,
-0.0501860157,
0.0319074467,
-0.0601095334,
-0.0735202283,
-0.0916893929,
-0.0406097732,
-0.0009343749,
-0.0416423306,
0.0019527109,
2.90887304e-34,
0.0460969806,
0.0470712185,
0.0148329828,
0.044060722,
0.023363268,
-0.0578655005,
-0.0407792591,
0.0306360982,
-0.0548917949,
-0.0930364355,
-0.0467898212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10073v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10073v3 | Both Matter: Enhancing the Emotional Intelligence of Large Language Models without Compromising the General Intelligence | 2024-02-15T16:36:04 | 2024-06-12T04:13:17 | Weixiang Zhao, Zhuojun Li, Shilong Wang, Yang Wang, Yulin Hu, Yanyan Zhao, Chen Wei, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotional Intelligence (EI), consisting of emotion perception, emotion
cognition and emotion expression, plays the critical roles in improving user
interaction experience for the current large language model (LLM) based
conversational general AI assistants. Previous works mainly focus on raising
the emotion perception ability of them via naive fine-tuning on EI-related
classification or regression tasks. However, this leads to the incomplete
enhancement of EI and catastrophic forgetting of the general intelligence (GI).
To this end, we first introduce \textsc{EiBench}, a large-scale collection of
EI-related tasks in the text-to-text formation with task instructions that
covers all three aspects of EI, which lays a solid foundation for the
comprehensive EI enhancement of LLMs. Then a novel \underline{\textbf{Mo}}dular
\underline{\textbf{E}}motional \underline{\textbf{I}}ntelligence enhancement
method (\textbf{MoEI}), consisting of Modular Parameter Expansion and
intra-inter modulation, is proposed to comprehensively enhance the EI of LLMs
without compromise their GI. Extensive experiments on two representative
LLM-based assistants, Flan-T5 and LLaMA-2-Chat, demonstrate the effectiveness
of MoEI to improving EI while maintain GI. | [
0.0462100506,
0.0478213727,
-0.0333968326,
0.012622349,
0.0166228525,
0.0383096412,
0.0201852676,
-0.0119874747,
0.0276664216,
-0.0391943641,
-0.1055361852,
-0.0218899343,
-0.0117833186,
0.0047376063,
0.0334861167,
-0.0799463391,
0.0412415452,
-0.0188444294,
0.0465329811,
-0.0323435068,
0.0165320579,
-0.0067270752,
-0.0279590748,
0.0093657682,
-0.0370943807,
-0.0041689784,
-0.0436197557,
-0.0046005147,
0.0031209639,
-0.0092554875,
0.0070531005,
0.0428866968,
0.0139081627,
-0.0182839092,
0.0000025422,
-0.0338136293,
0.0143203093,
-0.0275562964,
-0.0121523356,
0.011371145,
0.0915590376,
0.0424363129,
-0.024602145,
0.0245775636,
-0.0112487599,
0.02783476,
0.0643550903,
0.0688678026,
0.0595175885,
0.0734100565,
-0.02715482,
-0.0098340232,
0.0496241711,
-0.0112791518,
0.0452664942,
-0.0444894433,
0.0046470976,
0.0123478603,
0.016085932,
-0.0028965364,
-0.0161846764,
0.0199206974,
0.0235290583,
-0.0303032193,
0.0227072928,
0.0033626475,
-0.0008744995,
-0.0312106945,
-0.0644593462,
0.0540725514,
0.012746565,
0.0035402195,
-0.0312147979,
0.0458365977,
0.0228147432,
-0.0208310187,
-0.0461781025,
-0.0026411815,
0.0314724334,
-0.0244759955,
0.0146889035,
0.0202931929,
-0.0056208163,
0.0334341452,
-0.0424168147,
0.0380173214,
-0.0058730673,
-0.0402527191,
0.0448207743,
-0.018522935,
-0.0463513136,
-0.0030958401,
0.0261889677,
0.0462904237,
-0.0178063549,
0.011106085,
-0.040968433,
-0.0453346111,
-0.0365558416,
-0.0554990098,
0.0297075808,
0.052043274,
0.0051675714,
0.0196683593,
-0.0112721315,
0.0862949863,
0.0011121243,
0.0148588484,
-0.0256338511,
-0.0159406662,
-0.0240341201,
-0.0036278516,
-0.0514115132,
0.0392760113,
-0.0471811555,
-0.0498877354,
-0.061084915,
0.0342308208,
-0.030459119,
-0.0158832874,
-0.0330217741,
-0.004713716,
-0.0313030109,
-0.0030639919,
-0.0082944538,
0.0377813466,
-0.0072464859,
0.016101731,
0.0146735767,
-0.0447263867,
-0.0104120141,
0.0343931019,
0.0076434221,
0.0165922735,
0.0329739116,
0.0840652511,
-0.0170887671,
-0.0511610173,
-0.0208956916,
0.0410771631,
-0.002633685,
-0.0550863855,
0.0379677564,
-0.0119829224,
0.002573343,
-0.0145837683,
-0.0203156695,
-0.0344747417,
0.0027517995,
-0.028395297,
-0.0300908312,
0.0156986378,
-0.0253031682,
0.0164948199,
0.0230367202,
0.0026909551,
-0.0093077775,
0.0508881323,
0.0384506732,
0.0204621926,
0.0198975541,
0.0172998887,
0.0582294166,
0.0418122634,
-0.0143634044,
0.0044803643,
0.0098873498,
-0.0724787638,
-0.0234406982,
0.0188949779,
0.056629777,
0.0508584753,
-0.0162591059,
0.0256151855,
0.084800452,
0.024684187,
0.0085834321,
0.0682411045,
0.0036874677,
0.0350413248,
0.0216247272,
0.0108274333,
-0.0625683963,
0.0765047744,
-0.0653864071,
-0.0249811597,
0.002497714,
0.0264427941,
-0.0522350334,
-0.05622603,
0.020737743,
-0.0384242944,
0.0166021977,
0.0239353422,
0.0280433018,
-0.0185223389,
-0.0430624485,
-0.0244251266,
0.0409362204,
-0.0810967535,
-0.0091272816,
-0.048485864,
0.0197349116,
0.0704283863,
0.0036221927,
-0.0366385877,
-0.0307340678,
0.01280702,
-0.0099702086,
0.0515431128,
0.0305281244,
-0.0025248786,
0.0362717919,
-0.0643962845,
0.0112816328,
0.0059069074,
0.0114315804,
0.0065157595,
-0.0065940241,
0.019719027,
0.0002639337,
-0.030079715,
0.0118104536,
0.0085070953,
-0.0186490901,
-0.0047623748,
-0.0340461396,
0.0186580364,
0.0102563575,
0.0224125534,
-0.012961247,
-0.0339719914,
0.0152858514,
-0.0110519761,
-0.0119110858,
0.0282314271,
-0.0133943027,
0.0033048585,
0.0203725006,
0.0303005744,
-0.0009777219,
0.0211122334,
0.0020063003,
-0.0262429491,
0.0420581065,
-0.0411428064,
0.0261131637,
-0.0173508096,
0.0645311028,
-0.019966919,
0.0301656947,
0.0058777216,
0.0197504964,
-0.0131046986,
-0.037440829,
0.0309013259,
0.0219293144,
-0.0212653354,
-0.0404016934,
-0.0353007466,
0.073656261,
0.0446317978,
0.0064425091,
-0.0080782808,
-0.0084732482,
-0.05865198,
-0.089659676,
-0.1163710207,
-0.0081255184,
0.0031550319,
-0.0065272697,
0.0085500712,
0.03260234,
-0.0296204593,
0.0445741564,
-0.0298914351,
0.0050352691,
0.0148868253,
-0.0083761876,
-0.0089065498,
0.0076099667,
-0.0309607368,
-0.0389700979,
0.0167289954,
0.0061613,
-0.0074131852,
-0.003218529,
-0.0310932975,
-0.0534050614,
0.0045327214,
-0.0446210057,
0.0405581854,
-0.0323412828,
-0.1009828076,
-0.0135005675,
-0.0158793498,
0.0446629561,
0.1133980155,
0.0056357314,
0.057483118,
0.0293991007,
-0.0010769715,
-0.0455623418,
0.05898932,
0.0180211756,
0.0164127257,
-0.0288945679,
-0.003854688,
0.0124459332,
0.0533857718,
-0.0324687287,
0.0264785588,
-0.0453566052,
0.0195962097,
0.0161410514,
-0.0863961577,
0.038728144,
-0.0256776959,
-0.0214948338,
-0.0337855592,
-0.0113569098,
-0.0569513775,
0.0259928703,
-0.0080398154,
-0.0468255915,
-0.0897146389,
-0.0161417089,
-0.001579491,
0.0348762125,
-0.067828998,
0.0240627993,
-0.043308422,
-0.0096401731,
-0.0395358205,
0.0028113669,
-0.0452115424,
-0.0330893435,
0.0327392593,
-0.0451830365,
-0.0385384485,
0.036034625,
-0.0198139343,
-0.0259109288,
0.0184634533,
-0.0319553316,
0.0079323929,
0.0514774248,
-0.0375533737,
-0.0402092785,
-0.0308667012,
0.0599318519,
-0.0209156871,
-0.0401515849,
0.0119219879,
-0.0168462489,
-0.0140495924,
0.0504731983,
0.0367486961,
0.015759103,
-0.0428210981,
0.08949022,
0.0266407561,
0.0304556098,
-0.0615091175,
-0.0043161782,
0.0232232157,
0.0156591795,
0.0157987271,
-0.0521124899,
-0.006054047,
0.0562383458,
-0.0349187367,
0.0147320898,
0.1115284786,
0.0230176821,
-0.0600208417,
0.0160879716,
-0.0308076758,
0.0432243869,
-0.0060128607,
0.0310849231,
0.0003280271,
-0.0314690247,
0.0223201439,
0.0020634332,
-0.0199134815,
0.0077611203,
-0.007694704,
-0.1020123288,
0.0406452194,
0.024389131,
0.0076030209,
-0.0593562275,
0.0082450919,
0.0544022992,
0.0481237844,
0.0398781411,
-0.0019989158,
0.0051815547,
-0.0279600229,
0.0176540241,
-0.0037056261,
-0.0295732003,
-0.0224792808,
0.0036000849,
0.072062552,
0.0316554233,
0.0505560786,
-0.0215124041,
-0.0114850979,
0.0521698743,
0.0117067397,
0.0166423973,
-0.018423019,
0.0915967673,
-0.0168598425,
0.0162788704,
-0.0280796736,
0.0280494504,
0.0206727907,
0.0128603876,
-0.0233532786,
0.0221365355,
-0.0628914982,
-0.0143905887,
-0.0042110034,
0.0212074891,
0.0001845785,
0.0404018052,
0.0098702954,
-0.0997384638,
0.0011284836,
0.0037781026,
-0.0011695371,
0.0081947837,
-0.0127482684,
0.0073412834,
-0.0127869723,
-0.0252306163,
-0.0711317211,
-0.0752360001,
0.0182708651,
0.0481687076,
0.0044329851,
-0.0151562914,
-0.0062101916,
0.0024174729,
0.0422627181,
-0.0080660312,
-0.0176526811,
0.0049629221,
-0.0377662294,
-0.0207034089,
0.0262300372,
-0.0472879969,
0.0258542206,
0.008799864,
-0.007261809,
-0.0735906959,
0.0183682851,
0.0508323126,
0.0243920777,
0.0449064784,
0.0067831646,
-0.0638561472,
0.0475126915,
-0.0313157514,
-0.0060424488,
0.0553334802,
0.0499876961,
0.0381197706,
-0.0082064271,
0.0391236767,
-0.0403967574,
0.0464608781,
-0.0001732795,
0.0238556936,
-0.016848186,
-0.0604300015,
-0.0059449612,
0.0286304727,
-0.0023084919,
0.0303441137,
0.0032530089,
-0.0206291527,
0.0165437069,
-0.0722337812,
0.0117398007,
-0.0613452718,
-0.0104714874,
-0.0046126079,
0.0443974175,
0.0021183824,
-0.0436620079,
0.0246680658,
-0.0896305591,
0.0068012131,
0.0174903516,
-0.061850626,
0.0110832034,
-0.0174281038,
0.0585317612,
-0.0200669132,
0.0058682244,
0.0063808663,
0.024349682,
0.0159201883,
0.0891397372,
0.0108659547,
-0.0790708363,
-0.0362227485,
0.0557730198,
-0.0376202539,
-0.0307207089,
0.0143813053,
0.0911446959,
0.0382000208,
0.0072656875,
0.0684727728,
-0.0460296758,
0.0333569758,
-0.0105711529,
0.0062447777,
0.0146358777,
-0.0438118689,
-0.002701218,
-0.0137700075,
-0.0053096702,
-0.0031938178,
0.0152985612,
-0.0550329722,
0.0620615482,
-0.0519728623,
0.0239879414,
-0.0374491997,
-0.0274268407,
0.0808203816,
-0.0227965135,
0.0014640508,
0.0221937876,
-0.0271321088,
-0.0333662666,
0.0346438177,
-0.04129491,
-0.0059238202,
-0.0918719769,
0.0402408354,
0.0388540924,
-0.038227804,
-0.0144691272,
-0.0102333166,
-0.0567243397,
-0.065951407,
-0.0147809135,
-0.0186905395,
-7.10402958e-33,
-0.0404939465,
0.0222869962,
-0.0185102802,
0.0235829409,
-0.0598096922,
0.0089066364,
-0.0366438404,
0.0322241969,
-0.0256618839,
0.031516891,
-0.0226207469,
0.039655257,
0.0029284048,
-0.0161923654,
-0.0335213616,
0.0182744935,
0.0382676795,
-0.014073018,
-0.0366875455,
0.0303966887,
0.014710187,
0.0094182938,
0.0222069751,
-0.0958548859,
-0.0025779267,
0.0158973653,
-0.0244514924,
0.0097178584,
0.0233645923,
0.030285107,
-0.0013960637,
0.0553764626,
-0.0076189153,
0.0292230099,
-0.0116351992,
0.0300004426,
-0.0092530558,
-0.021588333,
-0.0218053013,
0.0006661326,
-0.021424301,
-0.0695664212,
0.0234078132,
0.016296681,
-0.0339575931,
-0.0063182861,
0.0193140917,
-0.0210482702,
0.0218856875,
-0.009159795,
-0.0526888371,
0.0013064924,
-0.0170888528,
-0.0399411693,
-0.0025510695,
0.0377564728,
-0.0235319864,
-0.0149628054,
-0.0079389913,
0.0364350341,
-0.009567162,
0.0054537016,
0.0101357233,
-0.0018278983,
0.0276340358,
0.0428978093,
0.011967645,
0.0171742812,
-0.005762741,
0.0022484406,
0.0480760187,
0.0523615256,
0.0395221375,
-0.0034796665,
-0.0231904332,
-0.0172641724,
0.0123812733,
0.0299342535,
0.0491634831,
0.0554733239,
0.0166630633,
0.0267584492,
-0.0724605769,
0.0040257042,
-0.0103454106,
0.0127103953,
-0.0212158952,
-0.0508670136,
0.0339421034,
-0.0006758517,
0.0166383367,
-0.0683788806,
0.0201055221,
-0.0038434553,
0.0314914659,
0.0113277212,
-0.0667539313,
0.0934757888,
-0.0149284434,
-0.0076577137,
-0.0274702068,
-0.0393552519,
0.0623350553,
0.0193867423,
0.0235395115,
0.0278181043,
-0.0001643337,
0.0496578887,
-0.0443910696,
-0.0045412541,
-0.0122550726,
0.0243468061,
0.0499385707,
-0.0228366591,
-0.0291467514,
-0.0264088921,
-0.0129743638,
-0.0038093573,
-0.0039786515,
0.050946448,
-0.0412800424,
-0.0417559743,
-0.0014243493,
0.018129291,
-0.0875713974,
0.0251091383,
-0.0446090996,
-0.0621712767,
-0.0347504131,
-0.0695346221,
-0.0333614945,
-0.0015573966,
3.424e-7,
-0.0404050127,
0.0577149875,
0.0047013466,
-0.0143244099,
0.0061940285,
0.0388982482,
-0.0184665136,
0.0032059422,
0.0540441982,
0.0153992977,
0.0353850275,
0.0595066138,
0.050823912,
-0.0474499129,
-0.0473292246,
-0.0178129748,
0.0329356082,
0.031188868,
-0.0287693087,
0.0228625741,
0.069179073,
0.0674916655,
0.0245255232,
0.016212929,
-0.0147062894,
-0.0435808338,
0.0570304394,
-0.0289730616,
-0.0143150091,
0.0272755139,
0.0343640484,
0.0048156711,
-0.0237780102,
0.012337422,
0.0100157429,
0.0307441708,
0.0011063872,
0.0658845901,
-0.0376945436,
-0.0198864732,
0.0296143498,
0.0538403504,
-0.030071713,
0.000169963,
0.0445341133,
-0.0447817147,
-0.0414412022,
-0.0141860964,
-0.0125429109,
-0.0184276607,
-0.0045177606,
-0.0215443969,
-0.0413990095,
0.0134787941,
-0.0043822653,
-0.0327808522,
-0.0098488471,
-0.0511110649,
0.0184634328,
-0.0023381428,
-0.0399712734,
-0.0710646063,
-0.0351055227,
-0.0084501104,
0.0151416985,
-0.0244099665,
0.0266717374,
3.007426762e-34,
0.0265211966,
-0.0332125053,
0.0260432661,
0.0504515655,
0.0663351566,
-0.0008953385,
-0.0310589671,
0.0072168009,
0.0553344898,
-0.0817321762,
0.0154347494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10058v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10058v2 | Towards Safer Large Language Models through Machine Unlearning | 2024-02-15T16:28:34 | 2024-06-05T04:57:09 | Zheyuan Liu, Guangyao Dou, Zhaoxuan Tan, Yijun Tian, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated their
vast potential across various domains, attributed to their extensive
pretraining knowledge and exceptional generalizability. However, LLMs often
encounter challenges in generating harmful content when faced with problematic
prompts. To address this problem, existing work attempted to implement a
gradient ascent based approach to prevent LLMs from producing harmful output.
While these methods can be effective, they frequently impact the model utility
in responding to normal prompts. To address this gap, we introduce Selective
Knowledge negation Unlearning (SKU), a novel unlearning framework for LLMs,
designed to eliminate harmful knowledge while preserving utility on normal
prompts. Specifically, SKU is consisted of two stages: harmful knowledge
acquisition stage and knowledge negation stage. The first stage aims to
identify and acquire harmful knowledge within the model, whereas the second is
dedicated to remove this knowledge. SKU selectively isolates and removes
harmful knowledge in model parameters, ensuring the model's performance remains
robust on normal prompts. Our experiments conducted across various LLM
architectures demonstrate that SKU identifies a good balance point between
removing harmful information and preserving utility. | [
0.0151852109,
0.0648726225,
-0.0061499407,
0.0592363253,
-0.0211361907,
0.0226998366,
-0.0070633492,
-0.0009897498,
0.0383195393,
-0.0041670981,
-0.0620359294,
-0.0029431274,
-0.033765845,
0.0367631391,
0.0092452783,
0.0021984985,
0.0536531061,
-0.0709268823,
0.0211103577,
-0.0182424653,
0.0195206422,
0.0037112902,
0.0156971086,
0.0089772055,
-0.0063887001,
-0.0400363207,
-0.0112401461,
0.0173789766,
-0.0006550595,
-0.0187582187,
0.0367351621,
0.0246251933,
0.013847447,
0.0772004202,
0.0000023968,
-0.0322343633,
-0.0226351246,
-0.0030043854,
-0.0667155609,
0.0102291508,
0.0255826153,
-0.0270873699,
-0.0244769659,
0.0268981718,
-0.0279429201,
-0.0023812312,
0.0473983921,
0.0468763001,
0.0677223578,
0.0943895355,
0.012761889,
-0.0053526363,
0.0104765231,
-0.0324517339,
-0.0246460326,
-0.0441284627,
0.061091654,
-0.0350591503,
-0.0547171049,
-0.0062966822,
-0.015009488,
0.0506567284,
0.0003438359,
-0.0164833609,
-0.0102598341,
0.0214929581,
0.0015366549,
-0.0552336276,
-0.0117762182,
0.0853969902,
-0.0584352948,
-0.0077878647,
0.0294267014,
-0.0253039449,
0.0148279434,
-0.0100554833,
-0.0148086548,
0.030187577,
-0.0074777659,
0.0295844935,
-0.0211176164,
-0.0217901655,
0.076398544,
0.0227916259,
0.0132703297,
0.0732812807,
0.0130287912,
-0.0346488878,
0.0489501581,
-0.0314952657,
-0.0108753406,
-0.0455191322,
0.0029927036,
0.0292777121,
-0.040782515,
0.0401256904,
-0.0307222418,
-0.0102980854,
0.0269368179,
-0.0575442277,
0.0549921207,
0.0078021754,
-0.001203835,
0.0505005829,
0.0034136451,
0.0018102501,
0.0061768657,
0.0361937433,
-0.0308818892,
0.0239759553,
0.0253142081,
-0.0230455622,
-0.0029348237,
0.0508752614,
-0.0221389364,
0.0360206328,
-0.0050544511,
0.0202141423,
-0.0401723124,
0.0257013272,
0.0092928978,
0.0133774783,
-0.028359795,
-0.0288940091,
-0.0303740744,
0.0155108683,
-0.0143443076,
0.0166623984,
0.0079612862,
-0.0559896566,
-0.0129267322,
0.012533593,
-0.0125949103,
-0.0144406697,
0.0111146662,
0.0804491788,
-0.0082635824,
-0.0083543072,
-0.057313215,
-0.0404317565,
-0.018993549,
-0.087225765,
0.0198217779,
-0.0436393432,
0.0149659151,
-0.0410742797,
-0.0239834003,
-0.0950021818,
0.0190633815,
0.0213580448,
-0.0574809685,
0.0505732521,
-0.0394433141,
-0.0061193504,
0.0101200538,
0.0290959328,
-0.0549894124,
0.0623758435,
-0.0179801974,
0.0563144274,
0.0371022373,
-0.0075839371,
0.0264244657,
0.041989971,
0.0527736992,
0.0199908018,
-0.0205920339,
0.0073058135,
0.0209963769,
-0.0103139011,
0.0184489824,
0.0683868229,
-0.0074313125,
-0.0363075733,
0.0859096125,
-0.0154650081,
-0.044539988,
0.0224933047,
0.0267879795,
0.0288035721,
-0.0007504346,
0.0151536055,
-0.079647705,
-0.025583446,
-0.0854840428,
0.0024965149,
-0.0109884422,
0.0274988841,
-0.0319834799,
-0.0335681289,
0.0193640888,
-0.0528579727,
0.0435832255,
0.0430720188,
0.0384071283,
0.032195393,
-0.0491549931,
0.0291178171,
0.0542514734,
-0.0509973764,
0.0103975208,
-0.0415533967,
0.0679433048,
0.0611319914,
0.0544404835,
-0.0385288224,
-0.0365463123,
-0.0239079408,
-0.0074656904,
0.0105020516,
0.0091675827,
-0.0118490057,
0.0673063323,
-0.0665799305,
-0.0414212532,
0.0385415442,
0.0075548878,
0.0056630601,
0.0362544619,
-0.0196551792,
0.0157817788,
-0.0128470762,
-0.0354552753,
0.0337484106,
-0.0401606113,
-0.0667629987,
0.0256715454,
0.0129701756,
0.0234360956,
-0.0093515255,
-0.0154633569,
-0.0066391262,
0.0569578223,
0.0018721072,
-0.020962419,
-0.0494342782,
-0.0926558152,
-0.0101349838,
0.0350495838,
0.0248038992,
-0.026189521,
0.0491578765,
-0.0404954851,
-0.0103779808,
-0.0057327962,
-0.0105941435,
0.0506068394,
-0.0363605618,
0.0237906352,
-0.0162140578,
-0.0063839746,
-0.0218200833,
0.0771933123,
-0.0252668876,
-0.0265377276,
0.0203907881,
-0.0322345458,
-0.0241431408,
-0.0112559628,
-0.0712452307,
-0.0090140002,
-0.0025248809,
0.0442427061,
0.0237418544,
-0.0066050207,
-0.0230917949,
-0.0129001969,
-0.0567097031,
-0.0078688683,
-0.0284684356,
0.0219224617,
0.0018887914,
0.0032875843,
-0.0202444904,
-0.0468964577,
0.0012825958,
0.0097203841,
-0.0049048662,
0.0193775389,
-0.0119866356,
0.0143248765,
0.0002400348,
-0.0116486037,
-0.0018350653,
0.013608655,
0.0345037915,
-0.0369228013,
-0.0031318085,
-0.012340568,
0.0655664206,
-0.027909115,
0.0524625964,
-0.0119781876,
-0.0244669504,
-0.0111195343,
-0.0003716106,
0.0043253945,
0.0478444248,
0.013467934,
0.0107486397,
0.0740073845,
-0.0025693027,
-0.0488247573,
0.0178824626,
-0.0180829205,
-0.0495529473,
-0.0109706931,
0.0136339124,
-0.0004146482,
0.0503032133,
0.0115400171,
-0.0160362087,
-0.0315898396,
0.0305833574,
-0.0171481874,
-0.0717675164,
-0.0690657273,
-0.0414446555,
-0.0393140912,
0.0197395161,
-0.0228974707,
-0.0664038509,
0.0838575363,
-0.0076131807,
0.0257476922,
-0.020071093,
-0.0027192468,
0.0155445524,
0.0353420451,
0.0068706088,
0.0400490537,
0.0651908293,
-0.0222481154,
-0.0251656249,
-0.0356468968,
0.0192787759,
-0.0367811024,
0.0576600991,
-0.066457279,
-0.0105679482,
0.006499825,
-0.0665708408,
-0.0791923925,
-0.064667359,
0.0119897313,
-0.015392432,
-0.0019427163,
-0.0041676257,
-0.0141414264,
-0.0443814695,
0.038203381,
0.0079270815,
-0.0172287114,
0.0150460582,
-0.02601883,
0.0273312591,
0.0693264902,
-0.0311469026,
0.0043354128,
-0.0205284599,
0.0295427777,
0.0828171596,
-0.0101031149,
0.0026766129,
0.0072614215,
-0.0046375678,
0.0059190067,
-0.0137686087,
-0.0106929038,
0.0486461483,
0.0139239859,
-0.0493625775,
-0.0133692203,
0.1032485217,
0.0013873059,
-0.0260295495,
0.0132746622,
0.0157391392,
0.0466194674,
0.0046612369,
0.0077639832,
-0.0832109526,
-0.0247226581,
0.0232613198,
0.0351459123,
0.0023247367,
-0.0503848903,
-0.0008561935,
-0.12321309,
0.0090362746,
0.0279743355,
-0.0303361714,
-0.0343455225,
-0.0337553918,
-0.0132050058,
-0.0127952769,
0.0430446155,
0.0179596264,
-0.0250695255,
-0.0197167043,
0.0163519476,
-0.0385966748,
-0.0692489073,
0.0141000254,
-0.0331601016,
0.0419701934,
0.063620694,
0.0051142923,
-0.0288399253,
-0.0065548774,
0.0376360752,
0.0123133035,
0.0091804015,
-0.0073549659,
0.0334581733,
-0.0169405621,
-0.0193519257,
-0.0163060389,
0.0362941399,
-0.0036493819,
-0.0237307865,
0.0269374344,
0.0798594356,
0.0005984426,
-0.0364791192,
-0.0148043102,
-0.0313967466,
0.0376415104,
0.0816342458,
0.0056213583,
-0.0590705015,
-0.0112837087,
-0.0341125503,
-0.007189841,
0.0226259585,
-0.0136170741,
0.0193032399,
-0.0012173351,
-0.0206752159,
-0.0601983778,
-0.0407602936,
-0.00193548,
-0.0120782536,
0.0294716377,
-0.0117474776,
0.0278201792,
0.0219487138,
-0.0283393804,
-0.0008531769,
-0.0546235442,
-0.0029691595,
-0.0460360721,
0.0339390934,
0.0063701756,
-0.0076287473,
-0.0201558787,
0.0091971764,
-0.0610306859,
-0.091815047,
0.0148123046,
0.0853644535,
0.0199447013,
0.0589916185,
-0.0236986578,
-0.0460967608,
0.1062613428,
0.0597751066,
-0.0239261519,
0.0016596774,
0.0382208899,
-0.0336316936,
0.0124477865,
0.0495714284,
-0.0512817353,
0.0002140531,
0.0624076538,
0.0062219719,
-0.0377155058,
-0.0117309401,
0.0013671165,
0.0336727053,
0.0355113931,
0.0011232495,
0.006425289,
-0.028560536,
0.0229369756,
-0.0055540507,
-0.0426906608,
-0.0111028841,
0.0308101755,
0.0475050174,
-0.0104944678,
0.0051756548,
0.0083543481,
0.0023604224,
0.0417127945,
-0.0197115745,
-0.0149040576,
0.0327983685,
0.0331220292,
0.0470803715,
-0.0035879251,
-0.0406233817,
0.057673119,
0.0140718454,
0.0109694339,
-0.0201888345,
0.0444933772,
0.0020108612,
0.0084181139,
-0.0107722506,
0.0203448553,
-0.0097450763,
-0.0604380704,
-0.039055448,
0.0307590961,
0.0337128714,
-0.0090881782,
0.0192112662,
-0.0116844978,
-0.0078862598,
-0.0568902977,
-0.011479619,
0.0209185183,
-0.0411906019,
0.0297731981,
0.0177387036,
-0.0292118881,
0.0330493972,
0.0931005776,
-0.0127780242,
0.0661986098,
0.0167480558,
-0.0016289167,
-0.0624924824,
-0.0379597507,
0.0298823323,
0.0074628498,
-0.0440574139,
0.0122240968,
-0.0246246252,
-0.0704954565,
-0.0279458128,
0.0109652141,
0.0009826742,
-0.0154655045,
0.0400501117,
0.0387568884,
-0.0080637261,
-0.0267469808,
-0.0494357236,
0.0070450823,
-0.0037827403,
-0.0131603656,
-0.0234212652,
-6.958187465e-33,
0.0203838609,
0.0076139625,
-0.0173699521,
0.0152741242,
0.0138787907,
-0.0027611991,
0.0070606251,
-0.0066075092,
-0.0357818045,
0.0124119129,
-0.0359856002,
0.0021271894,
0.0069278083,
0.0218377449,
-0.0318174362,
-0.013667535,
0.058972165,
-0.0191646051,
-0.0294212382,
0.0561972186,
0.0433357805,
0.0549729131,
0.0435826555,
-0.1005372852,
0.020066997,
-0.0244611707,
-0.02965956,
0.0268995296,
-0.0244349632,
0.0539611503,
-0.033547122,
0.0458090194,
0.0003570177,
-0.0314088501,
-0.0256657843,
0.0288216751,
-0.0410088301,
0.0012169441,
0.0151476841,
-0.0027905621,
-0.0357612483,
-0.0620101653,
0.0524806529,
-0.0117486296,
0.0029724797,
-0.0060450868,
-0.0046076686,
-0.0072591049,
-0.0333844759,
-0.0124738356,
-0.0455241315,
0.0095524415,
0.0153704612,
-0.0580372289,
0.0166958719,
0.0149651021,
-0.0012108823,
-0.0290504675,
-0.0643269196,
0.0111505883,
0.0461070687,
0.0193504486,
0.0670508519,
0.0150232073,
-0.0055742715,
0.0739498287,
0.0114565277,
-0.011429444,
0.0047290293,
-0.031641081,
0.0184489582,
0.045717407,
0.0152436411,
0.0323146433,
0.0425623171,
-0.0504158475,
-0.0791741982,
0.0075098388,
0.0018277557,
0.0599297807,
0.0263558067,
0.0162826944,
-0.0203646254,
-0.0304047242,
-0.0548884049,
-0.0100425687,
-0.0330479927,
-0.0192085169,
0.0376070775,
0.0180592015,
-0.033448685,
-0.0086003933,
0.0004759715,
-0.0500964746,
0.0029226951,
0.0645235851,
0.0288287103,
-0.0310011711,
0.0117349103,
0.0196753796,
-0.0806617886,
-0.0025290805,
0.0178262684,
-0.0493220836,
0.0026691142,
0.0182583034,
0.0493993163,
0.0649933591,
-0.0575197935,
0.0065372502,
-0.0357641019,
0.0513238646,
0.0432113893,
0.0421184599,
0.0474756025,
-0.0090384921,
0.0141020073,
0.0243614037,
0.0351232253,
0.0198005252,
-0.051168669,
0.0196345318,
0.0016878536,
0.0159989633,
-0.01012283,
-0.0231596641,
0.0075042956,
0.0199097991,
0.0321819037,
-0.061577905,
0.0157755334,
0.0100669777,
3.012e-7,
-0.0038159236,
0.0257463921,
0.0202037618,
0.0182722677,
0.021960808,
0.0804624707,
-0.015181032,
0.0402898341,
0.0051566008,
-0.0169089083,
0.0164862033,
0.0062599354,
0.0440380685,
0.0388824679,
-0.1008653939,
-0.0090411929,
-0.0873214304,
-0.0211237036,
-0.0507113375,
-0.0351843722,
0.0295781624,
0.1187824085,
-0.00523873,
-0.0355430804,
0.0118162818,
-0.0407377258,
0.04973308,
-0.0374707393,
-0.0033220055,
-0.0004558369,
0.0459576584,
0.0264147986,
0.002045254,
0.014285109,
-0.0128036188,
0.0029889969,
-0.0285454858,
0.1042933166,
-0.0029233389,
-0.0445572101,
0.0014485357,
0.011518213,
-0.0047850423,
-0.0435405299,
0.0912647843,
-0.0134453001,
-0.0122448476,
-0.030305123,
-0.0118562821,
-0.0216089282,
0.0131956367,
-0.0349744037,
-0.0478754789,
0.0228443909,
0.0203016419,
0.005225189,
-0.0346026868,
-0.0613108166,
-0.0229665581,
-0.0097098704,
-0.0312133562,
-0.0740013793,
-0.0117805749,
0.0119241197,
-0.0243125465,
-0.0915719271,
0.0543312542,
2.6167092e-34,
0.0128995581,
-0.0526361912,
0.0019283991,
-0.0124826385,
0.0179616194,
0.0156043125,
-0.0355041176,
0.0051400615,
-0.0043911682,
-0.0570206158,
-0.0183642954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10052v1 | Unmemorization in Large Language Models via Self-Distillation and Deliberate Imagination | 2024-02-15T16:21:14 | 2024-02-15T16:21:14 | Yijiang River Dong, Hongzhou Lin, Mikhail Belkin, Ramon Huerta, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While displaying impressive generation capabilities across many tasks, Large
Language Models (LLMs) still struggle with crucial issues of privacy violation
and unwanted exposure of sensitive data. This raises an essential question: how
should we prevent such undesired behavior of LLMs while maintaining their
strong generation and natural language understanding (NLU) capabilities? In
this work, we introduce a novel approach termed deliberate imagination in the
context of LLM unlearning. Instead of trying to forget memorized data, we
employ a self-distillation framework, guiding LLMs to deliberately imagine
alternative scenarios. As demonstrated in a wide range of experiments, the
proposed method not only effectively unlearns targeted text but also preserves
the LLMs' capabilities in open-ended generation tasks as well as in NLU tasks.
Our results demonstrate the usefulness of this approach across different models
and sizes, and also with parameter-efficient fine-tuning, offering a novel
pathway to addressing the challenges with private and sensitive data in LLM
applications. | [
0.0127046471,
0.1109775528,
-0.0233285632,
0.0571699999,
-0.0461260788,
-0.0020652318,
0.0391020589,
-0.028532261,
0.0256277826,
-0.0176259074,
-0.0148688229,
-0.0349314027,
-0.0262947511,
0.0288204774,
0.0086955344,
0.0128532136,
0.0232088957,
-0.0620360374,
0.0044720494,
-0.0149003062,
-0.0181602482,
0.0202791113,
0.0138830366,
-0.0066588619,
0.0220029913,
-0.0309386272,
-0.0195285212,
0.0090990122,
-0.0146569517,
-0.0257095452,
-0.0160958152,
0.0556168444,
0.0394232236,
0.0614487864,
0.0000022186,
-0.0536503829,
-0.0559578873,
-0.0052273748,
-0.045407854,
0.0251860153,
0.0354523063,
-0.006572919,
0.0227281619,
-0.0044540348,
-0.0575336553,
0.0285130944,
0.007351771,
0.0192909688,
0.0722815022,
0.069125168,
0.0083100442,
-0.033963792,
-0.0306733828,
-0.034554448,
0.0092508132,
-0.0387644246,
0.0274167806,
-0.0511615351,
-0.0435665846,
-0.010615861,
-0.0001177305,
0.0418924652,
0.0263360869,
0.0159290954,
-0.0054496205,
0.0356575996,
-0.0188280195,
-0.040185038,
-0.0008725037,
0.0564503446,
0.016236458,
-0.0189952385,
0.0430741496,
0.0085393647,
0.0136726787,
0.0030420676,
-0.0311113093,
0.0342729427,
-0.0126778847,
0.033409398,
0.0136464965,
0.0004032253,
0.0448243916,
0.0225207787,
-0.0233851653,
0.0532058701,
0.0083140209,
-0.0062881997,
-0.0308492109,
-0.0314470157,
-0.0010208085,
-0.0680685937,
0.0500080921,
0.0390320271,
-0.00211515,
0.0343474112,
-0.0670305416,
-0.0351052247,
0.0080558658,
-0.0129990242,
0.0452096947,
0.0035631033,
0.0263011996,
0.0386608541,
-0.0049453448,
0.0363963954,
0.0001294983,
0.0193265695,
-0.0283260997,
0.0173633341,
-0.0235117655,
-0.0297384337,
-0.0269437842,
0.0713307858,
-0.0295555312,
0.0032798555,
-0.0077288197,
0.0294152293,
-0.0203799866,
0.00575912,
-0.0070651677,
0.0322120264,
-0.0569212623,
-0.0282026883,
-0.0329337679,
-0.013458835,
-0.029410867,
-0.011441933,
0.0411979891,
-0.0609888546,
-0.0260590166,
-0.026621718,
0.0108026359,
-0.0115503268,
-0.0089203594,
0.0877569392,
-0.006631651,
-0.015779715,
-0.0536905192,
-0.0765054151,
0.014248143,
-0.084941417,
0.0321062542,
-0.0575775318,
0.0311914533,
-0.0274575986,
-0.0144717237,
-0.1026925668,
0.0257179998,
0.0162755214,
-0.0403396413,
0.0797620714,
-0.0040771435,
-0.0042348178,
0.0032977159,
0.0455579124,
0.0168201793,
0.0667722449,
0.0062216525,
0.0511950441,
0.0267549772,
0.0008376752,
0.0614561699,
-0.0028983185,
0.0538355708,
0.011496556,
-0.0434134416,
0.0045283753,
-0.0334086791,
0.0029758634,
0.0273744334,
0.075233303,
-0.0238798019,
-0.0034792144,
0.0751331821,
0.0251586344,
-0.0033291001,
0.0427533425,
0.0112196552,
0.0258314461,
-0.0157389771,
0.0660518259,
-0.0524542108,
0.0226003453,
-0.0412477963,
0.0080596032,
0.0166243427,
0.0502739437,
-0.0286451411,
-0.0302060228,
0.021298334,
-0.0478434078,
0.0469997898,
0.0151823955,
0.0095832953,
0.0693162531,
-0.0013931557,
0.0792570785,
0.0137581043,
-0.0659976378,
0.0378470793,
-0.0460081175,
0.0332952887,
0.0908118486,
0.0680356324,
-0.0170602873,
-0.0020093624,
-0.0221052133,
-0.0061803595,
0.0060904706,
0.0130600175,
-0.0003313209,
0.0512263551,
-0.0468928516,
-0.0313598439,
-0.0439339541,
0.0294446144,
0.0014302497,
-0.005972906,
-0.030457858,
0.0439699404,
-0.0611838549,
0.0116003919,
0.0267219879,
-0.0619914681,
-0.0691023245,
0.0358066522,
-0.0088247126,
0.0027165823,
0.0368542522,
0.0011263954,
0.0258653089,
0.0366542675,
-0.0210494436,
-0.0184673946,
-0.0152277965,
-0.069642283,
-0.0364085101,
-0.0035283668,
-0.0251542926,
0.0160384737,
0.0410096943,
-0.0312527344,
-0.0394037254,
0.0279134121,
-0.0125676785,
0.0503224172,
-0.0578178577,
0.0404517166,
-0.0071637756,
0.0199951287,
-0.0092718359,
0.059610527,
-0.0426602364,
-0.0277848393,
-0.0029772792,
-0.0110767642,
-0.0162071325,
-0.0301112905,
-0.019483557,
-0.0069038356,
0.0017677367,
0.0226728134,
0.019914411,
-0.0080629522,
-0.0439264849,
-0.0430196971,
-0.0274366979,
0.0076339189,
-0.0261237696,
0.007532774,
0.0275527351,
0.0253743771,
-0.0151865799,
-0.0329374224,
-0.0390544906,
-0.0145364469,
-0.0086383382,
0.0157304984,
0.0307035092,
0.0086541753,
-0.0084847668,
0.0102142617,
0.0087540783,
0.0172387678,
0.0349810906,
-0.0440639332,
0.0085605029,
-0.0137271499,
0.0524266548,
-0.0637148097,
0.0264251959,
0.004144839,
-0.0061588753,
-0.0043528271,
-0.0027129229,
0.0113659073,
0.0321254581,
0.0149877286,
0.0214780364,
0.0672954246,
-0.034033522,
-0.0295245703,
0.0054869624,
-0.0379233696,
-0.0017132927,
-0.0128629534,
-0.0021273473,
0.0164823271,
0.0419985987,
0.0142465988,
-0.0194626357,
-0.007727264,
0.0736811608,
-0.0012458828,
-0.0738343,
-0.0099168904,
-0.0051353173,
-0.0270540863,
0.0297389701,
-0.0119832009,
-0.0626070574,
0.084400624,
-0.0265209917,
0.0311967656,
-0.0281213298,
-0.0011344582,
-0.0235093106,
0.0758083463,
-0.0099890465,
0.0339300632,
0.0514420234,
-0.022899298,
-0.0297893956,
-0.0060750837,
0.0105482331,
-0.0388405137,
0.0332922265,
-0.0564030521,
-0.0251743607,
0.0266317632,
-0.0462728739,
-0.0739501864,
-0.0838639289,
0.0132736303,
0.0012790549,
0.0192839969,
-0.001810401,
-0.0295334682,
-0.0465475842,
0.0211657304,
0.0084500462,
0.0054130303,
0.0078450423,
-0.0380250327,
0.042720627,
0.0574610084,
-0.0178086814,
-0.0050885975,
-0.0205089543,
0.0345426835,
0.0818359256,
0.0361943319,
0.0000504089,
0.0158229321,
0.0064177914,
0.00138899,
-0.0013299111,
-0.0039333208,
0.026571447,
0.0554363206,
-0.0527325906,
-0.0345920995,
0.1042392179,
0.0218060166,
-0.0166983847,
0.0035393683,
0.0322968774,
0.0306107979,
0.0115564093,
0.0014772342,
-0.0869526938,
-0.0039753844,
0.0208208673,
0.0346252173,
-0.0120303277,
-0.0721186399,
-0.0475544594,
-0.1020102501,
0.0095681362,
0.0252173338,
0.0087980377,
0.0001508915,
-0.0319652371,
-0.0196775738,
0.007580271,
0.0371341482,
0.0076991967,
-0.0033699514,
-0.0020223188,
-0.0075246822,
-0.0234532487,
-0.062054798,
0.0006477028,
-0.0220583398,
0.0571095124,
0.0456792749,
0.0492394418,
0.0110518532,
-0.0356219038,
-0.0008596237,
0.002542319,
0.0209027305,
-0.00215911,
0.0442896709,
0.0255486295,
-0.0023840468,
-0.0005103985,
0.0632433817,
-0.0263196621,
-0.0446495973,
-0.0066141537,
0.0241391733,
-0.0379541032,
-0.0357765332,
-0.0013460391,
-0.0249512494,
0.0193934347,
0.0852725133,
0.0326811559,
-0.027535418,
-0.0291857868,
-0.0228274409,
0.0151798911,
-0.036193639,
0.0110699013,
0.0063504125,
0.0231597461,
0.0064024124,
-0.0626424178,
-0.013902422,
-0.0063530896,
0.03529872,
0.0104094027,
0.0334790535,
0.0104193622,
-0.0184422284,
-0.0295848772,
-0.0131087583,
-0.087612763,
-0.0151144573,
0.0209939573,
-0.0347680636,
0.0008473456,
-0.0267196707,
-0.0054274476,
0.0469903313,
-0.1125889122,
-0.0818273276,
0.0305589307,
0.034193214,
0.0248699915,
0.0780659318,
-0.0042262687,
-0.0624297895,
0.1114549786,
0.0562186763,
-0.0710863024,
0.0176428314,
0.0142150186,
0.0244883373,
0.0132808052,
0.0607577004,
-0.0139723159,
-0.008766843,
0.0291976649,
0.018926749,
-0.0090608178,
-0.0179720614,
0.0139055578,
0.0361629762,
0.0123857884,
-0.006999094,
0.0519984066,
-0.0474442206,
0.0094230911,
-0.0332301706,
-0.0325325541,
-0.0309593473,
0.0123960981,
0.0551697053,
-0.0111127384,
0.0222301278,
-0.0147359241,
0.0045460346,
0.0331911743,
-0.0272381268,
-0.0233920161,
0.031763956,
-0.0123266932,
0.0366765372,
-0.0054248325,
-0.0142025957,
0.070201382,
-0.0160083994,
0.0351065733,
-0.0287625641,
0.0519712158,
-0.0112221288,
0.015715735,
-0.0502697304,
0.0258474369,
-0.0592736416,
-0.0651356205,
-0.0426054187,
0.0403813049,
0.0098540299,
0.0223820619,
0.0168315675,
-0.022932725,
-0.0027418076,
-0.0161230285,
0.0204496104,
0.0101543702,
-0.0398157127,
-0.0058053052,
0.0060076541,
-0.044515267,
0.0382693969,
0.0842326581,
-0.0098615643,
0.0464354344,
0.0118434997,
0.0261336993,
-0.0712615326,
-0.0381952301,
0.0002730821,
0.0337951891,
0.0011794118,
-0.0083364341,
-0.0392529443,
-0.0796291381,
0.0044538327,
-0.0036769672,
-0.0005883861,
-0.0265427064,
0.0394684523,
0.0371024236,
-0.0226514097,
-0.0137037756,
-0.0604728237,
-0.0038701915,
0.0048620389,
-0.0281786881,
-0.0127697783,
-6.833319108e-33,
-0.0029199009,
-0.0151165184,
0.0163043812,
-0.0166739784,
-0.001378943,
0.004619549,
-0.0327002555,
-0.0050202091,
0.0091703543,
-0.0215508286,
-0.0424186736,
-0.0045970054,
0.016848132,
0.0419735163,
-0.0391028412,
-0.0162029881,
0.0743663236,
-0.0261891708,
-0.0313581638,
0.0538562089,
0.0538129844,
0.0551856421,
0.0138090514,
-0.0781431943,
0.0162596516,
-0.0231443122,
-0.0582611412,
0.0394879766,
-0.0112418076,
0.0338883549,
-0.0601758063,
0.0148613099,
0.0008912388,
-0.0019259149,
-0.0516424738,
0.0180370621,
-0.0505265221,
-0.0183396302,
-0.0076541454,
-0.0358900428,
-0.0268642101,
-0.0630884841,
0.0436574407,
-0.0330063701,
0.0036782536,
0.0078167729,
-0.0151773859,
-0.0065624863,
0.0005507902,
-0.0146222515,
-0.0182295963,
-0.0110529317,
-0.0266088657,
-0.0379287302,
0.0580366254,
-0.0180158298,
-0.0054291347,
-0.0281457137,
-0.0674099177,
0.026945591,
0.0464394875,
0.0112263476,
0.0887017846,
-0.0054396871,
0.0189417135,
0.0673809722,
0.0588315651,
0.0306004994,
-0.0047490299,
-0.0109603172,
0.0117374174,
0.0569002666,
-0.0251272991,
0.0530527905,
0.0306861699,
-0.0371865444,
0.0025791747,
0.0090393517,
-0.0432475954,
0.008930454,
0.0404579006,
0.0232503004,
-0.0075380336,
-0.0321903676,
-0.0626086965,
0.0054230853,
-0.0452020951,
0.0054011694,
0.0191682111,
0.0363434888,
-0.0703795552,
-0.0214122832,
0.0159516316,
-0.0471655987,
-0.0193262361,
0.0437557958,
0.0089078899,
-0.029390106,
0.0023823371,
0.0028105967,
-0.0389039442,
-0.0224082656,
0.0180406831,
-0.0046895603,
0.0004081881,
0.0168839078,
0.018744085,
0.0369239599,
-0.0591897704,
0.0024668258,
-0.0658429861,
0.0529187582,
0.0268814154,
-0.0089458097,
0.040606644,
-0.0101678772,
-0.0286401846,
0.0016846115,
0.0479754023,
-0.0028322174,
-0.0434879884,
0.051957272,
0.0076951748,
0.0190008823,
0.0033386122,
-0.021506438,
0.0086270161,
-0.0091795856,
0.0989911854,
-0.0266524293,
0.007996669,
-0.0030874407,
2.87e-7,
-0.0065899943,
0.0079313274,
0.0258297436,
0.0008875725,
0.0322701558,
0.0489179678,
-0.0165156163,
0.0339728035,
-0.0127903102,
-0.0255367924,
0.0004659461,
0.0303349271,
0.0602912307,
0.049820777,
-0.0907240137,
0.0499501713,
-0.0334347263,
-0.0023557916,
-0.0564150326,
-0.0536274984,
0.022103345,
0.0847315341,
0.0296274014,
-0.0289665349,
0.0050526271,
-0.0690497905,
0.0666977242,
-0.0303051639,
-0.0186060593,
0.0191428754,
0.0176805519,
0.0646911412,
-0.0015693174,
-0.0282754954,
-0.0191267338,
0.0041805385,
-0.0351404287,
0.0800771862,
0.0444394611,
-0.063747108,
0.0063634724,
-0.0228295084,
-0.0080057429,
-0.0385743193,
0.0552480556,
-0.0418175794,
-0.0463379361,
-0.019461887,
0.0283397622,
-0.0286002867,
0.0223490521,
-0.0061872187,
0.0000138936,
0.0373225212,
-0.0122795822,
0.0276076663,
-0.0218256712,
-0.0615628064,
-0.0441993214,
-0.0531533547,
-0.079154171,
-0.0296637192,
-0.0254173391,
0.0113929873,
-0.0051412997,
-0.0705681071,
0.0588299632,
2.626127159e-34,
0.0039837505,
-0.0258257929,
-0.0179031678,
0.0271239728,
0.0358433761,
-0.0025268702,
0.0061995434,
0.0201461222,
-0.0046462142,
-0.0615862757,
-0.0234567188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10051v1 | SwissNYF: Tool Grounded LLM Agents for Black Box Setting | 2024-02-15T16:15:38 | 2024-02-15T16:15:38 | Somnath Sendhil Kumar, Dhruv Jain, Eshaan Agarwal, Raunak Pandey | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated enhanced capabilities in
function-calling, these advancements primarily rely on accessing the functions'
responses. This methodology is practical for simpler APIs but faces scalability
issues with irreversible APIs that significantly impact the system, such as a
database deletion API. Similarly, processes requiring extensive time for each
API call and those necessitating forward planning, like automated action
pipelines, present complex challenges. Furthermore, scenarios often arise where
a generalized approach is needed because algorithms lack direct access to the
specific implementations of these functions or secrets to use them. Traditional
tool planning methods are inadequate in these cases, compelling the need to
operate within black-box environments. Unlike their performance in tool
manipulation, LLMs excel in black-box tasks, such as program synthesis.
Therefore, we harness the program synthesis capabilities of LLMs to strategize
tool usage in black-box settings, ensuring solutions are verified prior to
implementation. We introduce TOPGUN, an ingeniously crafted approach leveraging
program synthesis for black box tool planning. Accompanied by SwissNYF, a
comprehensive suite that integrates black-box algorithms for planning and
verification tasks, addressing the aforementioned challenges and enhancing the
versatility and effectiveness of LLMs in complex API interactions. The public
code for SwissNYF is available at https://github.com/iclr-dummy-user/SwissNYF. | [
0.0199284106,
0.0670852661,
-0.0200004727,
0.0204706509,
-0.0630984157,
-0.0250623301,
-0.0334186368,
-0.0142650055,
0.0387661904,
-0.022440061,
0.0008232465,
0.0548513681,
-0.0126497922,
0.0615174696,
0.0024926912,
0.008786073,
0.0134516181,
-0.0119998902,
-0.0484165177,
0.0231551137,
-0.0309953801,
0.0185772944,
0.005071471,
0.051316157,
0.0397671759,
-0.0035779842,
-0.0267313048,
0.0528657958,
-0.0086635416,
0.0381436124,
0.0031768829,
0.0248012859,
-0.0298431441,
0.0384786502,
0.0000024411,
-0.0613361597,
-0.0186065845,
0.0100633623,
-0.0540266372,
-0.0052246889,
-0.0372391976,
-0.0337702744,
-0.0432244316,
0.0273851696,
-0.0292619336,
0.0065535987,
0.0255009271,
-0.0387596525,
0.0768361092,
0.0524320602,
0.0104350941,
0.0464275144,
0.0151379658,
0.0343061239,
-0.0471165404,
0.0038016287,
-0.0202729832,
-0.0137028899,
0.0575231351,
-0.0112459771,
0.0313240848,
0.0059520318,
0.0584151149,
-0.0207661148,
-0.0274334531,
-0.003445131,
-0.0601626262,
-0.0398548767,
-0.0074578202,
0.012924131,
-0.0269969087,
-0.057103131,
0.0357670374,
0.0125443134,
-0.0421077684,
-0.0014549161,
-0.0264719166,
0.0259850807,
0.0197564792,
-0.0232333001,
0.0041294112,
-0.057354942,
0.0130565027,
-0.0222314093,
0.0139892008,
0.0940310881,
0.0070434306,
0.0083328914,
-0.0025428692,
-0.0388727896,
0.0576255508,
-0.0916579887,
0.0089602582,
0.0918876827,
-0.0428534113,
0.0117595503,
0.0146544129,
0.0252528712,
0.0378571376,
-0.0357166566,
0.0113973236,
0.0449626297,
-0.0267913546,
0.0058715371,
-0.0382448509,
0.0283461604,
-0.0023749464,
0.0312139951,
0.000742163,
-0.0039605759,
-0.015019225,
0.0053034234,
-0.0339347161,
0.0180309713,
-0.0392037965,
0.0127733489,
-0.0089797312,
0.0525916331,
-0.007996263,
0.0889983699,
-0.0274834782,
-0.0305380989,
-0.0003470761,
-0.0545645468,
-0.001615253,
-0.0478256233,
-0.0215661917,
-0.0280132368,
-0.0391730778,
-0.0515684225,
-0.020110622,
0.0157021992,
-0.043718528,
-0.0079379585,
0.0203264244,
0.121627301,
-0.0096887387,
0.0443362258,
-0.0531599112,
-0.0800111666,
0.0794322267,
-0.053963609,
-0.0121325646,
-0.099011153,
-0.0106294677,
0.0110814339,
-0.0334449783,
-0.0089465268,
-0.0110786678,
-0.0257259328,
0.0240327045,
0.0295023117,
0.0004772343,
0.0160409529,
-0.0110125644,
0.0362041555,
-0.0105632339,
0.0658090413,
0.004772834,
0.0250901096,
-0.0050255135,
0.0060984259,
0.0222412329,
0.0696070269,
-0.0231639016,
-0.0131960716,
-0.040475376,
0.0232716389,
0.041859895,
-0.006969823,
-0.0298178382,
-0.0317752138,
0.0064391764,
-0.0118922563,
-0.0044748406,
0.0360751003,
-0.0184069593,
-0.0047988999,
0.0458760671,
0.0162298139,
-0.0219507013,
-0.0123382155,
-0.0572464615,
0.0278091505,
-0.0301368665,
0.0081515051,
-0.0657192692,
0.0567922555,
0.0049954117,
-0.0424705148,
-0.0005102382,
0.0019312716,
-0.0216287896,
-0.0194502305,
0.0255183671,
0.028579589,
-0.0256660189,
0.0563765168,
0.0037372774,
-0.0073413514,
-0.0582387261,
-0.0836233944,
-0.0136374002,
0.0572639927,
0.1080513149,
-0.0423496924,
-0.0639682114,
0.0231640227,
0.0032483258,
0.0296862926,
0.0096453391,
-0.0165805928,
0.0029500956,
-0.0077709551,
-0.0486400872,
0.005352742,
0.0244747475,
0.0689410046,
0.0240869932,
-0.0207787845,
-0.021684343,
-0.0179513376,
-0.0123406714,
0.0174641218,
-0.0407960415,
-0.0702340752,
-0.0115280459,
0.008917693,
0.0182003062,
-0.0080730058,
-0.0328278616,
-0.0002976125,
0.0503881574,
-0.0066153784,
-0.0279419478,
-0.014135438,
0.0144934403,
0.0577537455,
0.0195632279,
0.0055674678,
0.0039011841,
0.0247109272,
-0.0364413671,
-0.0130995596,
0.0698672161,
0.0256719943,
0.0437861793,
0.0288538504,
0.0436622053,
-0.02034075,
-0.0144375516,
-0.0201382097,
-0.0149443652,
-0.0084809102,
-0.0340047851,
0.012101477,
0.0123004988,
0.0170475729,
0.0454276986,
0.003128734,
0.0370031781,
-0.0069921678,
0.029448634,
-0.0082897227,
0.0700353757,
0.0136465924,
-0.006413755,
-0.0911510363,
0.045108214,
-0.0340895653,
0.0167294722,
-0.0052921511,
0.0614601858,
-0.0018829898,
-0.0262733139,
0.0300591569,
0.0217464212,
0.0011653461,
0.0053924597,
-0.0044948701,
0.0071041598,
-0.0810542256,
0.0038260459,
-0.0091951098,
-0.0018226856,
0.0331896394,
-0.0233502612,
-0.0161419529,
-0.0574849546,
0.0356214568,
0.0020747627,
0.0253562257,
-0.0230904166,
-0.0223281886,
0.0244659372,
-0.0201233458,
-0.0514884368,
0.0346989669,
-0.0821669176,
-0.0102653792,
0.0720849782,
0.0128400121,
-0.0904738531,
0.005785095,
0.0276474953,
-0.0310059171,
-0.0114305429,
-0.0082985442,
0.0448273271,
0.0341284238,
-0.0263791773,
0.0149992369,
0.0116810463,
-0.0065140324,
0.0636754707,
-0.0334508158,
0.0334776826,
-0.0463023819,
-0.0314775594,
0.0375951789,
-0.035884656,
-0.0869650319,
0.0316863731,
-0.0430566035,
-0.04678436,
0.0194490943,
-0.0673196688,
-0.0319246612,
0.0978622735,
0.0225910284,
-0.0042109201,
-0.0248900093,
-0.002981019,
-0.0352782048,
-0.0130169261,
-0.0045600906,
-0.0234683938,
0.028700836,
-0.0810761377,
-0.0108324084,
-0.0200226102,
-0.0147559345,
-0.0193687733,
0.0512530468,
-0.0421936549,
0.0156511161,
-0.0489099696,
-0.0149071431,
0.0216344241,
-0.0001109867,
0.0082388883,
0.0600407682,
0.0290154722,
-0.0115893669,
-0.0389126912,
-0.0820557699,
-0.0133684566,
-0.0417915359,
-0.0227269139,
0.0382397734,
0.0190540403,
0.0365365669,
0.0644084662,
-0.0213547964,
-0.0393238962,
-0.0342661403,
0.0373969786,
-0.0016536814,
-0.018063955,
0.0193469506,
0.0093694376,
-0.0628031194,
-0.038202852,
0.0433411822,
0.0291309599,
-0.015252701,
0.0297818203,
-0.0207985267,
0.0465627201,
0.0284014232,
0.0889391303,
-0.0855159536,
-0.0249490868,
-0.0025351511,
0.0134518687,
-0.0294547919,
-0.010478558,
-0.0365723819,
-0.1196865812,
0.0465970784,
0.0183816217,
0.0299884379,
0.0183133483,
-0.0356762446,
0.0036441304,
0.0208542012,
-0.0014647262,
0.0283001233,
0.0394418538,
-0.013085017,
-0.0212882236,
-0.0513379723,
0.0074940869,
0.032336887,
0.0064870971,
0.0163398962,
0.0353398137,
-0.0076880991,
0.0252646003,
0.0490786396,
0.0862934217,
0.0500293449,
0.0186642613,
-0.0421227813,
-0.0139159132,
0.0384863019,
0.0015834427,
0.0347508676,
-0.0010203713,
-0.0590244569,
-0.059254054,
0.0101382565,
0.0763085186,
-0.061035201,
0.0049208319,
-0.0264962669,
-0.0211919677,
0.0040680896,
0.0280652586,
-0.0102408491,
-0.0067492346,
-0.0810811818,
-0.0274712816,
-0.05522063,
-0.0707088783,
-0.0279844552,
-0.0133532276,
-0.0142127285,
-0.0008782558,
0.0054656081,
0.0141088581,
0.0404498689,
0.0377326608,
0.0177808627,
-0.0234682616,
0.0115987128,
-0.0043428042,
-0.0500133522,
-0.0068365941,
-0.0458157025,
0.0296232086,
0.0135815339,
-0.0411918163,
-0.0012145062,
-0.0090943649,
-0.0119365491,
0.0512562096,
-0.0031622981,
-0.0682776049,
0.0211272277,
0.0921933502,
0.0348253287,
0.0383801721,
-0.0225818884,
-0.0399721786,
0.0318287425,
0.0604667328,
-0.0169143714,
-0.0023793885,
0.0035714852,
0.0348632634,
0.0206122603,
-0.0005928586,
-0.0983682349,
-0.006504694,
0.0528422631,
-0.0075784442,
-0.0336021222,
0.0111175543,
-0.0127559518,
0.0344779566,
-0.0449284017,
0.0137269711,
0.008834633,
-0.0042950418,
0.0533084162,
0.0066597457,
-0.022627743,
-0.0426568203,
0.0457075424,
-0.0542224757,
-0.0415363088,
0.0625858977,
-0.0421964228,
-0.0256425664,
0.0417183526,
-0.0083094453,
0.0267969705,
0.0051503326,
-0.000805822,
0.0863237008,
0.001801391,
0.0144136203,
0.0678645596,
0.016709365,
0.0496801436,
0.0018337129,
0.0073734969,
0.0028962363,
0.0395132229,
-0.0407613069,
0.0214791093,
-0.03501717,
-0.1168552861,
-0.0062332442,
0.0210873969,
0.0196127258,
-0.000702025,
-0.0008750409,
-0.0477998406,
0.0075833835,
-0.0093797864,
-0.0066819931,
-0.0000940421,
-0.0020152146,
-0.019380359,
0.0183937214,
0.0017755437,
-0.0499247871,
0.0403065309,
-0.0244714711,
0.0581483059,
-0.0162262265,
-0.0366173424,
-0.0907195359,
-0.0744656026,
0.0358597897,
-0.006644832,
-0.0029861236,
-0.0313045084,
-0.0811679065,
-0.0266374219,
-0.0223003272,
0.0303422082,
-0.0223398209,
-0.0341982543,
0.0125088077,
0.0512321591,
0.0728803799,
0.0185156222,
-0.0194689967,
-0.0207615048,
-0.0228877626,
-0.0538721867,
-0.0113074733,
-5.972470799e-33,
-0.0315362178,
-0.0669340566,
0.0317298956,
-0.0049698493,
0.0370932855,
-0.0146154631,
-0.0388700441,
-0.0066510099,
0.0342584848,
-0.0113204475,
0.0204574522,
-0.0154868634,
0.0213122126,
-0.0394799262,
0.0246143248,
0.0387587324,
0.0100060757,
-0.0009030201,
-0.048675973,
0.0062116152,
0.0384764783,
0.0048455284,
0.0161678884,
-0.0502034798,
0.0007208755,
0.0168283321,
0.0212319717,
0.049397435,
-0.029924104,
0.0524270013,
0.0237082317,
0.0227074884,
-0.0121091288,
-0.0155947478,
0.000401922,
-0.0037714092,
0.0125629539,
-0.0281766038,
0.0345746726,
0.0206864905,
0.0079098763,
-0.0368791632,
0.0584329888,
0.0279773157,
-0.0244395602,
0.0259702876,
-0.0206139572,
0.0119414795,
0.0249574315,
-0.0015893049,
-0.05670055,
0.0225338917,
0.0055997395,
-0.0059438753,
-0.0022730294,
-0.0157609079,
0.0106250364,
-0.0459849499,
0.0045356848,
-0.0144260023,
0.0108883241,
-0.0087055042,
0.0837201774,
0.0346815288,
0.0053162691,
0.0225479212,
0.0250780936,
0.0110270772,
0.0209090784,
0.0183957145,
0.0073801554,
0.0621568225,
-0.0070506777,
-0.0109908348,
-0.0416894071,
0.0257086009,
0.028365247,
0.0238952618,
0.040087834,
0.021818677,
0.0349627286,
0.0077759833,
-0.0282350834,
0.0015842539,
0.0075525003,
-0.0004247603,
-0.0388561413,
0.0099471891,
-0.0055098655,
0.0277300421,
0.004894386,
-0.039682027,
-0.0043283496,
-0.0133003676,
0.0521495156,
0.0108563229,
-0.0377426185,
-0.0242905188,
0.0299783275,
0.0150817288,
0.0293910876,
0.0066995295,
-0.0405035727,
-0.032478936,
0.05274681,
0.0205182116,
-0.0294820666,
0.0506357066,
-0.0584402308,
0.0309547763,
-0.0865288004,
0.0471830517,
0.0107086748,
0.0018364382,
-0.0128507307,
-0.0355987549,
0.0105401604,
0.0240182411,
-0.002304923,
-0.0746679008,
0.0201566182,
0.0604041517,
0.021584088,
-0.0116689103,
-0.0601558685,
-0.005943086,
0.022525996,
0.009606069,
0.0593947768,
0.008849211,
-0.0041302047,
0.0049065421,
3.268e-7,
0.0113331033,
-0.0134585146,
0.0241432991,
0.0843065679,
0.0236169156,
0.0502385944,
-0.015185466,
0.0136173368,
-0.0253922939,
-0.033413209,
-0.0209639184,
0.0140549578,
0.0630253777,
0.0114205014,
-0.0385310538,
0.0055160867,
0.0151247112,
-0.0154192802,
-0.075115867,
-0.0212994739,
-0.0031460531,
0.0342264287,
0.0257057175,
-0.0629752502,
-0.0044590728,
-0.0521728657,
-0.036216855,
-0.0487075336,
-0.0072376863,
0.0244507808,
-0.0571257286,
0.029746674,
0.0164194778,
0.0200982317,
-0.0257900152,
-0.0095547428,
-0.0472895056,
0.1123029441,
-0.0183107834,
-0.030287208,
0.0197193902,
-0.0728984028,
0.0004339084,
-0.0026027134,
0.027486207,
0.0282044001,
-0.0224373881,
-0.0318548605,
0.0213119704,
-0.0190274362,
-0.04327555,
-0.0141993025,
0.0230540968,
0.0325228274,
-0.0089337593,
-0.0044864295,
-0.0060142973,
-0.0384760164,
-0.0570963994,
0.0249665361,
-0.0254053399,
-0.0605657846,
-0.0218691155,
0.0086168293,
-0.0246672463,
-0.0541447252,
0.0137164397,
3.936691092e-34,
0.0242394861,
0.0189976413,
0.0071924222,
0.0698406622,
0.0380841941,
0.0262403414,
0.0100840945,
0.0412731245,
0.0446424671,
-0.001573203,
-0.0203651395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10038v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10038v2 | RS-DPO: A Hybrid Rejection Sampling and Direct Preference Optimization Method for Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T16:00:58 | 2024-03-30T16:10:47 | Saeed Khaki, JinJin Li, Lan Ma, Liu Yang, Prathap Ramachandra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has been extensively
employed to align large language models with user intent. However, proximal
policy optimization (PPO) based RLHF is occasionally unstable requiring
significant hyperparameter finetuning, and computationally expensive to
maximize the estimated reward during alignment. Recently, direct preference
optimization (DPO) is proposed to address those challenges. However, DPO relies
on contrastive responses generated from human annotator and alternative LLM,
instead of the policy model, limiting the effectiveness of the RLHF. In this
paper, we addresses both challenges by systematically combining rejection
sampling (RS) and DPO. Our proposed method, RS-DPO, initiates with the
development of a supervised fine-tuned policy model (SFT). A varied set of k
responses per prompt are sampled directly from the SFT model. RS-DPO identifies
pairs of contrastive samples based on their reward distribution. Finally, we
apply DPO with the contrastive samples to align the model to human preference.
Our experiments indicate that our proposed method effectively fine-tunes LLMs
with limited resource environments, leading to improved alignment with user
intent. Furthermore, it outperforms existing methods, including RS, PPO, and
DPO. | [
0.0569083095,
0.0377489403,
-0.0084568728,
0.004853677,
-0.0273211859,
0.0109253107,
-0.0479579568,
-0.0055036074,
0.0048281578,
-0.0253796894,
-0.0554102175,
-0.0467257053,
-0.0061975149,
0.0119382553,
-0.015921887,
-0.0879650563,
0.025871316,
-0.0465045087,
0.0145522309,
-0.0152049558,
0.0230202358,
0.0177046582,
-0.0033182022,
0.0600007512,
0.0540965684,
-0.0044715633,
-0.0058932528,
-0.0011067895,
0.0399849862,
-0.0409647785,
0.0340723693,
0.0683707073,
0.0303050745,
0.0386023223,
0.0000021863,
-0.0552515909,
-0.0220625382,
-0.0175346956,
-0.0070341253,
-0.0177866556,
0.0667359531,
0.0317858607,
-0.0102669243,
0.0145459399,
-0.0163709242,
0.0391032211,
0.058822453,
0.0436578467,
0.0310874265,
0.0354827046,
0.0219342224,
0.0005368118,
-0.0042639324,
-0.0282785166,
-0.0143702105,
-0.0010204102,
0.0210123062,
-0.0194133949,
0.0351825431,
0.003419287,
-0.0193640627,
-0.0001385761,
-0.0128912637,
0.007508304,
-0.0189475752,
0.0198616385,
0.017811507,
-0.0220594592,
-0.0284169167,
0.0784540772,
-0.0080972286,
-0.0096520036,
0.0114120413,
-0.0500117913,
-0.0064724474,
0.0095265908,
-0.0124983722,
-0.0190580189,
0.0109647568,
0.0353997499,
0.0270277672,
-0.0023358942,
0.0319499299,
0.0339790694,
0.0042166552,
0.0539635569,
0.0211485196,
-0.033549916,
0.0365957953,
0.0106462818,
-0.0253778007,
-0.0457539596,
0.0198971275,
-0.0125710852,
-0.084796235,
0.0144071579,
-0.0597633533,
-0.0024299826,
0.03438925,
-0.0165885873,
0.0569751374,
0.0529145896,
0.0055902172,
0.0250994638,
0.0520622544,
0.0574128665,
-0.0483917445,
0.0118789636,
-0.0310287215,
0.0344342962,
-0.0274752621,
0.0009582092,
0.0001559041,
0.0412140302,
-0.0558846816,
-0.0225028098,
-0.0583480895,
0.0318193138,
-0.0284626614,
0.0208548438,
-0.0054725599,
0.0057469392,
-0.0697695538,
0.0032855561,
-0.0743111297,
0.0675669014,
-0.0397923253,
0.0120840287,
0.0126108248,
0.0123618292,
0.0103122806,
0.010584767,
-0.0268088877,
-0.0517458245,
-0.003756643,
0.0783543885,
-0.0016655829,
-0.0089359721,
-0.0111139398,
-0.0137561569,
-0.0442245826,
-0.0333560258,
-0.0540796258,
-0.0733534992,
0.0104588,
-0.0055538346,
-0.0202643704,
-0.0495491959,
0.0143512553,
0.025036402,
-0.0291380547,
0.0698508322,
0.0018441956,
-0.0122445878,
0.004090481,
-0.0417547971,
-0.0504278466,
0.0647863597,
0.0289390404,
0.0419158489,
0.0056872009,
0.0056218905,
-0.0085494546,
0.0556391366,
0.0055338708,
0.0361431167,
-0.0475831293,
-0.0041334354,
0.0101244748,
0.0508505404,
0.0782219619,
0.0401211306,
-0.0122583928,
-0.0046850089,
0.0669688582,
0.0446694866,
-0.0161261093,
-0.0321690626,
0.0224694461,
0.0573850647,
-0.0434837528,
0.0047891466,
-0.0558719151,
0.0225178264,
-0.0218072087,
0.0262270477,
0.0548963547,
0.0275048465,
0.0055864858,
-0.0289816502,
0.0105999783,
0.0075708274,
0.0082822097,
0.0579010472,
0.0591307096,
-0.026612144,
-0.0561358482,
-0.004463152,
0.0579314455,
0.0092119323,
0.0171902701,
-0.0361781195,
0.0505333133,
0.0946384892,
0.0315188132,
-0.0412450321,
-0.004196011,
-0.0277964827,
-0.0464609154,
0.0608745925,
0.0598744228,
-0.0174922217,
-0.0183352493,
-0.0294510573,
-0.0675107017,
0.0252178274,
-0.0231210478,
0.0349464454,
0.0142729962,
-0.0082039889,
-0.0069161956,
0.0040827519,
-0.0505704135,
0.0253147837,
-0.0013612765,
-0.0426805988,
0.001781889,
0.027495129,
0.0539805666,
0.0189711582,
0.0244782232,
-0.0020711031,
-0.0030026899,
-0.0015413814,
0.0212141201,
-0.0480885543,
-0.0377802514,
-0.0463591553,
0.0531557575,
-0.0157623701,
-0.0394289866,
0.0619929209,
-0.0259622503,
-0.0295559224,
-0.0023536647,
0.0026190025,
0.0392705724,
-0.024019843,
0.0098441998,
-0.0153770819,
-0.0289191287,
-0.0849423483,
0.0389965922,
0.0001016226,
0.0019977195,
0.0438942835,
-0.0046530808,
-0.0021421548,
-0.089719668,
-0.0426578335,
0.0209226646,
-0.014897598,
0.0144443018,
0.0555766001,
0.0373994485,
-0.0587151013,
-0.0145204365,
-0.0180520471,
0.0185660291,
-0.0078991344,
0.0046949778,
0.0115646562,
0.0242226645,
-0.018550504,
-0.0258527938,
-0.0119968485,
-0.0336296707,
-0.0097253174,
0.0156779923,
0.0300228838,
0.0020260033,
-0.0163994785,
-0.072535105,
-0.0082911598,
-0.0022559259,
-0.0296150576,
-0.0211949907,
0.0366108567,
-0.0259003006,
0.0254988801,
-0.0166591518,
0.0227975119,
-0.000059593,
-0.0299119838,
0.0221764073,
-0.019563416,
-0.0014337456,
0.0641002133,
0.0184303503,
0.0275840722,
0.0652880371,
0.016045237,
-0.098852098,
0.0151733235,
-0.0500887372,
-0.0295419954,
-0.0284335949,
-0.0025220814,
0.0316009559,
0.0719069764,
0.0125249252,
0.0137423221,
-0.0836127996,
-0.0151532246,
-0.0139714461,
-0.0073951734,
-0.0109335193,
0.0164827034,
-0.0663850233,
0.0169930402,
-0.0272565354,
-0.0442099869,
0.1053277776,
-0.0009185648,
0.0334205404,
-0.0639811456,
-0.0074842745,
0.0028967781,
-0.0012019639,
-0.023507189,
0.0237416346,
-0.0200666152,
-0.0152518786,
-0.0649002865,
-0.0452825204,
0.0369199812,
-0.0383312702,
0.0579012595,
-0.037355613,
0.0188700762,
-0.0168693438,
-0.0677760616,
-0.0587018616,
-0.0678247958,
-0.0456121974,
-0.0050879428,
0.0069920169,
-0.0227248911,
-0.0153736658,
0.0103030894,
0.0248265341,
0.0272394884,
-0.0037078063,
-0.0117680887,
-0.0301224999,
-0.0161338598,
0.1119995192,
0.0184419099,
-0.0063976757,
-0.017428631,
0.0172702577,
0.0011370087,
0.0463257879,
-0.0008159141,
-0.0047226558,
0.0253876988,
0.0637138411,
-0.0363767818,
0.009354475,
0.0593107045,
0.0416826233,
-0.0242752563,
-0.0108134234,
0.0953666717,
0.0222446956,
-0.0735719427,
0.0115035763,
-0.0207558107,
0.0779467449,
0.0239960868,
0.0439525358,
-0.0341549329,
-0.0424201079,
0.0119090052,
0.0818953961,
-0.0025441358,
-0.0014477334,
0.0177687369,
-0.158877477,
-0.0088685825,
0.011603592,
-0.0733837336,
-0.0175627489,
-0.0343205854,
0.0497235507,
-0.0167804267,
0.0283232927,
2.086e-7,
0.004282481,
0.0033759838,
0.0093904994,
0.0308579393,
-0.0248935651,
0.0224644616,
-0.0319091752,
0.0510567166,
0.0847787336,
0.020393867,
0.0179783814,
-0.0020293128,
0.0062253391,
-0.0061679818,
-0.034830492,
-0.0231801253,
-0.0068527088,
-0.0142033575,
0.0093008652,
-0.032030195,
0.0793430656,
-0.0244446192,
-0.037000414,
-0.0113191344,
0.0787198097,
-0.0140991695,
0.0330820009,
-0.0184162818,
0.0217312705,
0.0692181066,
0.0681210309,
0.0084513286,
-0.0960111693,
-0.008119287,
-0.0346136764,
-0.0508635379,
-0.0545833893,
0.0071258717,
-0.0086666178,
-0.0218990259,
0.0355314352,
-0.0610390119,
-0.0236122049,
0.0109130684,
0.0252923071,
0.0144168362,
0.018683929,
0.0086502498,
-0.0287262872,
0.0201669056,
0.0308685973,
-0.0417175256,
0.0329539031,
-0.069517009,
-0.0215764921,
-0.0172535609,
-0.0500030853,
-0.0244217422,
0.00052952,
-0.0172524564,
-0.086058341,
0.0073537459,
0.0677943304,
0.0134067582,
0.0450715311,
0.0035070763,
-0.0583396889,
0.0162789244,
0.0346650444,
0.0135162091,
-0.022189131,
-0.0083065201,
0.0452937111,
-0.0275371801,
0.0371250808,
-0.0478636548,
-0.016628921,
0.0374064445,
0.0571752861,
-0.0099586928,
-0.0559559874,
0.0166206006,
-0.0064714169,
0.0504970253,
-0.0461741202,
-0.0166908,
-0.0331825167,
-0.0151597289,
0.0215987507,
-0.0303857215,
-0.0161976628,
-0.0322049111,
0.026992891,
-0.0514272302,
0.0090011945,
-0.0370635353,
-0.0205297712,
0.0182260592,
-0.0243973006,
-0.0057893815,
0.0496595949,
0.0167207811,
0.0373319276,
0.0240190309,
0.0043931659,
0.0346602239,
0.0230042581,
0.0649855658,
0.0129731419,
0.0742456615,
0.0388797484,
-0.0005027949,
-0.0001959374,
-0.0055201156,
-0.025613429,
-0.0389863215,
-0.0337887518,
-0.0132146468,
0.0503192507,
-0.0366277285,
0.029682057,
-0.015150574,
-0.0141610289,
-0.0215751138,
0.028397901,
-0.0383180119,
-0.003695721,
0.0492130257,
0.022542676,
-0.0085216314,
0.0332107879,
0.044769831,
0.0081033921,
0.0235073343,
-0.0264665633,
0.0110906325,
-0.0293908082,
-0.0038921628,
0.0064939689,
0.0406712778,
-0.0566011518,
-0.0231962781,
-0.0475763418,
-0.0531757995,
-0.0086074285,
0.0251076519,
-0.0407456122,
-0.0150673594,
0.063505888,
0.0032585291,
-0.0476388708,
-0.0213483907,
-0.042054534,
0.0137680192,
-0.0230439473,
-0.0314150192,
-0.0561107211,
-6.622541951e-33,
-0.0343182124,
-0.0427496806,
0.0041556014,
-0.0260736942,
-0.0425926484,
-0.0483075678,
0.0053802039,
0.0042171045,
0.0085543878,
-0.0125000821,
-0.0194226652,
-0.0282196738,
0.0127787711,
0.0266068839,
0.0187513698,
-0.0003492392,
0.0342327952,
-0.0099113118,
-0.0696413666,
0.0035287817,
0.0420622043,
0.007532977,
0.0070147673,
-0.0575629398,
0.0415651873,
0.0209326856,
-0.0017933699,
0.011691289,
-0.0023878308,
0.0939522311,
-0.0128237186,
0.0294598043,
-0.0160271507,
-0.0427260846,
-0.0096589252,
0.0381179489,
-0.0307210442,
-0.0323302969,
0.0291802641,
-0.0073979422,
0.0065966616,
-0.0378541648,
0.0435018539,
0.0052089724,
-0.0463393293,
0.0261345152,
0.0196297877,
-0.0175444186,
-0.0319222547,
0.0266638026,
-0.0733710155,
0.001298566,
-0.015406359,
-0.0223651994,
0.0264850538,
0.0235600267,
-0.009643456,
0.0509970598,
-0.0132420287,
0.0223675277,
0.0141188297,
0.0254830047,
0.100029476,
0.0708158091,
0.0148061486,
0.0394086055,
-0.0360799953,
-0.0302075204,
0.0496634841,
-0.0477845743,
0.0259132441,
0.0244289897,
-0.0104793319,
0.0664364323,
0.015458948,
0.001576342,
0.0000422541,
0.0395257771,
0.0029212979,
0.0123242605,
0.0490684472,
0.0321236812,
-0.0403573737,
-0.0173560306,
-0.0620580129,
-0.0452529453,
-0.0289237332,
-0.041817639,
0.0403035358,
0.0074687186,
-0.0218636226,
-0.0189049169,
0.03332166,
-0.046915371,
-0.0425161272,
-0.0212399457,
-0.0311776977,
0.0169571098,
0.0050115297,
-0.0016475549,
-0.075645864,
-0.0323359817,
-0.0101908958,
-0.0245728325,
-0.0260392837,
0.0210831929,
-0.0120490352,
-0.0125308679,
-0.0449787378,
0.0354320109,
-0.0066542514,
0.009380918,
-0.0133686056,
0.030068608,
0.0671018958,
-0.0363940671,
0.0061314316,
0.0570306443,
0.0198435243,
-0.0461906195,
-0.0065003196,
-0.026447678,
-0.0213035103,
0.0060724691,
-0.0275178477,
0.0288724452,
-0.0067425133,
0.022603536,
-0.0170270521,
-0.0225728657,
-0.0186663847,
0.0000687087,
2.804e-7,
0.0111584952,
0.0401152112,
0.0181375965,
0.0131369876,
-0.0325853899,
0.060585048,
0.0131236371,
0.0188054517,
0.0233698152,
0.0155856982,
0.0259883981,
-0.0003046627,
0.0399683304,
-0.0202072766,
-0.0802041441,
0.034595903,
-0.0532989167,
0.0448399745,
-0.0506565534,
-0.0113996407,
0.0374383405,
0.0893866196,
0.0210874118,
-0.0117010623,
0.0119298249,
0.0230622347,
0.0510701388,
-0.0488226563,
-0.0001801834,
0.0076601049,
-0.0027107431,
-0.0214673057,
-0.0181734357,
-0.0004492293,
-0.0014826754,
0.0492684096,
-0.0194237866,
0.0823761001,
0.0052271704,
-0.0688015446,
-0.0239904448,
0.0258062985,
0.0288668741,
-0.0660142675,
0.0421908014,
-0.0495721363,
-0.0036177372,
-0.010731061,
0.0070743896,
-0.0465844162,
0.0112250857,
-0.0620423071,
-0.0125850551,
0.0035430545,
0.0086926101,
0.019768687,
-0.0338616557,
-0.0252204277,
-0.0057225451,
0.0240001809,
-0.0300061032,
-0.0359178372,
-0.0464799888,
0.036685586,
-0.0070220162,
-0.0440913849,
0.0149901882,
2.507732379e-34,
0.0254429597,
-0.0333538204,
0.0151967285,
-0.018325936,
0.0028950074,
0.0454692692,
0.0100123733,
0.0360216089,
0.0827367306,
-0.0863602608,
-0.0162282493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10024v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10024v2 | Self-Augmented In-Context Learning for Unsupervised Word Translation | 2024-02-15T15:43:05 | 2024-06-05T13:38:42 | Yaoyiran Li, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recent work has shown that, while large language models (LLMs) demonstrate
strong word translation or bilingual lexicon induction (BLI) capabilities in
few-shot setups, they still cannot match the performance of 'traditional'
mapping-based approaches in the unsupervised scenario where no seed translation
pairs are available, especially for lower-resource languages. To address this
challenge with LLMs, we propose self-augmented in-context learning (SAIL) for
unsupervised BLI: starting from a zero-shot prompt, SAIL iteratively induces a
set of high-confidence word translation pairs for in-context learning (ICL)
from an LLM, which it then reapplies to the same LLM in the ICL fashion. Our
method shows substantial gains over zero-shot prompting of LLMs on two
established BLI benchmarks spanning a wide range of language pairs, also
outperforming mapping-based baselines across the board. In addition to
achieving state-of-the-art unsupervised BLI performance, we also conduct
comprehensive analyses on SAIL and discuss its limitations. | [
-0.0107641313,
0.0255600121,
0.0076013249,
0.0524174273,
-0.05317555,
0.0258947425,
0.0577167012,
-0.0450349972,
0.0328764915,
-0.0290432405,
-0.0713254735,
-0.0271201599,
0.0329205804,
-0.0361132473,
0.0266544279,
0.029618239,
0.0468109809,
-0.0273725148,
-0.0821167901,
-0.0214924682,
-0.0462940298,
0.0175557137,
-0.0106065581,
-0.0128277484,
0.0185771622,
-0.0174445529,
0.0220967047,
0.0371484943,
0.0123295132,
-0.0353529863,
-0.039507091,
0.0540033691,
0.0352837965,
0.0733958557,
0.0000019936,
-0.0556614734,
-0.0326055735,
0.0029330133,
-0.0026836067,
0.043688491,
0.0321240798,
-0.0441780798,
-0.021408001,
0.0112466607,
-0.0485060737,
-0.0151505051,
0.0482700169,
-0.050778769,
0.0213233773,
0.0519986786,
-0.0166262276,
-0.0326313302,
-0.0099036163,
-0.0620471686,
-0.0098118884,
-0.0226948857,
0.0197204743,
-0.009044854,
-0.0727111623,
0.0176597424,
-0.0326685645,
0.0709087998,
0.0077352021,
-0.0169648491,
0.0065706568,
0.0342013091,
-0.0147943487,
-0.0350473002,
-0.0202334113,
0.0655061603,
-0.0468518287,
-0.0344229341,
-0.0290705245,
0.0048257373,
-0.0259984825,
0.0047154343,
-0.0277219191,
0.0142866876,
0.0301349983,
0.0270422231,
0.0400119461,
0.0247105118,
0.0668534636,
-0.017603606,
-0.0640914589,
0.038939327,
0.0549051464,
-0.0083431778,
-0.0100761922,
0.0246955361,
0.0064836284,
-0.0113105644,
-0.0226531606,
0.0222534072,
0.0025824769,
0.052514106,
-0.014724941,
-0.016239455,
0.0075971112,
-0.0346864872,
0.0476192981,
0.0576749742,
-0.0234425068,
0.0884404778,
-0.0654775798,
0.007670539,
-0.0144330999,
0.0042987969,
-0.0501740798,
-0.0077164038,
-0.0008330865,
0.0284419023,
-0.0460886881,
-0.0276720952,
-0.0532695614,
0.0001834724,
-0.0092940563,
0.0249241721,
0.010443408,
0.0216050427,
0.0106462073,
-0.065786548,
-0.0629355982,
-0.0289804768,
0.0262915902,
0.0422756895,
0.0148984045,
-0.0124020977,
0.0063419398,
-0.0635213852,
-0.0296426024,
0.0130918631,
0.0049441997,
-0.0232654717,
0.0007448082,
0.0502594486,
-0.0254817028,
-0.084571369,
-0.0519953407,
-0.0001285647,
-0.043420285,
-0.0597109385,
-0.0149472887,
-0.0832774118,
0.0510349981,
0.0114894593,
0.0283443276,
-0.0085421195,
0.0250072647,
0.0045166048,
-0.0124089252,
0.0767984316,
-0.0146360109,
0.0160140134,
0.0235014595,
-0.0226796195,
0.04400203,
0.0956780985,
-0.0037432234,
0.0016219289,
0.0435709283,
0.0045936876,
-0.0168019533,
0.064995043,
0.0511721708,
0.0758476108,
-0.0504548438,
0.0001838147,
0.0686439797,
0.0381126814,
0.026663227,
0.0236959755,
-0.0181139074,
0.024769051,
0.0655270219,
0.0510157123,
0.0062088347,
0.0407993793,
0.0438202769,
-0.003483902,
-0.0027683498,
-0.0142219644,
-0.0407529138,
0.0246984605,
-0.0336617492,
-0.0122118248,
0.0517334901,
0.0345576927,
-0.033026021,
-0.0206895843,
-0.0128298439,
-0.0227610655,
-0.0040827827,
0.0029756292,
0.0450050756,
0.0623994172,
-0.0194652732,
-0.021415377,
0.0311209429,
-0.0320814624,
0.0344963185,
0.0071859304,
-0.0086208247,
0.0541725643,
0.0605065301,
0.0208739564,
-0.0209796745,
-0.0277194399,
0.0372631624,
0.0764149129,
0.0299811959,
0.0055588675,
0.0356423259,
-0.0411277935,
-0.0167582296,
0.0004547825,
-0.0149649158,
0.019087119,
0.0126561271,
0.0233964063,
0.0106260553,
-0.0367970876,
-0.0426424555,
0.027306214,
-0.0701632276,
-0.0596007109,
0.0608035624,
0.0191734433,
0.0085625034,
0.0011980685,
-0.003313544,
-0.0106338337,
-0.0014762906,
-0.0457215682,
-0.0219636764,
0.0310042948,
-0.0744490921,
-0.0898833945,
0.0247556288,
-0.0034850722,
-0.0037809666,
-0.0602412783,
-0.0126347318,
-0.0505440943,
-0.0270727556,
-0.0001058748,
0.0219993033,
-0.0525507107,
0.0496463925,
0.0035623545,
0.0184143018,
-0.0327897556,
0.0375474319,
-0.0046443883,
-0.0254226234,
-0.0121378433,
0.0314724371,
0.0200368222,
-0.0076450557,
-0.0311355926,
0.0024417096,
0.0181527063,
-0.0020878492,
-0.0037364603,
0.0266029425,
-0.0269555319,
0.0023089065,
-0.0881967545,
0.0016613514,
-0.0237615332,
0.012477831,
0.0218979008,
0.0428306684,
0.0027841886,
-0.0133871697,
-0.0095158322,
0.0025069721,
0.0120378695,
0.0413060524,
0.0073346887,
-0.0117358528,
0.0123049058,
-0.0246351734,
-0.0113606313,
0.0074815024,
0.0345278829,
0.0310195498,
-0.0116546424,
-0.0517202504,
0.0254713017,
-0.0038351547,
-0.003821281,
0.0045540952,
-0.0400187932,
-0.0084141055,
-0.031852264,
0.0520699397,
0.0499824099,
0.0030968646,
-0.0460343063,
0.0599251054,
-0.0156790353,
-0.0524417348,
-0.0126912966,
-0.0223196447,
-0.037691623,
-0.0217480287,
0.0224663857,
0.0042857099,
0.0328510478,
-0.0029624214,
-0.0118913827,
-0.0406788923,
-0.0193431377,
-0.0093713775,
-0.017939603,
-0.041735068,
0.0255702417,
0.0117856469,
0.0502035506,
-0.017336268,
-0.0606277175,
0.0425856039,
-0.0581326261,
-0.0117288381,
-0.0551152267,
0.025029568,
-0.0279759001,
0.0222831722,
-0.0147318942,
0.0369722545,
-0.0607787706,
-0.0009655122,
-0.0262289513,
-0.0018662027,
0.0321668983,
-0.0141819287,
0.0432658829,
-0.0354449265,
0.0263932738,
0.0083959093,
-0.0403327681,
-0.0427745059,
-0.0332747437,
0.0026533841,
-0.0221018698,
0.0024198694,
-0.0222292859,
0.0200417489,
0.0015212916,
0.0281570386,
0.0632297248,
-0.0005585281,
-0.0265556946,
-0.0035967277,
0.0057975524,
0.0097101126,
-0.0273678005,
0.034685161,
-0.0122811608,
0.0474095233,
0.0066627632,
0.0137621611,
-0.0159935188,
-0.0260963701,
-0.0058334749,
0.0383223332,
-0.0105893081,
-0.0132501135,
-0.0154656451,
0.0405929014,
-0.0159051791,
-0.0488568917,
0.1034017652,
0.023921147,
-0.0862877816,
-0.0138320914,
-0.0347706005,
-0.0104466826,
0.0481319688,
0.0200710371,
-0.0959662125,
-0.0203514714,
-0.0063239094,
0.0291427262,
0.0287389215,
-0.0151783908,
-0.0404835753,
-0.1429185569,
0.032358218,
0.071670711,
-0.0516796112,
-0.0206653196,
-0.0439666659,
-0.0002336531,
-0.0416132435,
0.003368262,
0.0026596945,
-0.0011874163,
-0.0225243773,
-0.0282144286,
0.0274748299,
-0.0677506626,
-0.0101282122,
-0.0629394054,
0.0375793986,
0.0549813546,
0.0123136993,
0.0016415463,
-0.0015441623,
0.0438052528,
-0.0368951783,
-0.005819248,
-0.0202628002,
0.0164791476,
-0.016936386,
-0.0113213928,
0.0399489701,
0.054787837,
-0.0477702692,
0.0043176832,
0.0116579002,
0.0594015941,
-0.0256785527,
0.0458566062,
0.0352172069,
-0.0216927081,
0.0471191071,
0.070792675,
0.0095040835,
-0.0478288271,
0.0426237211,
0.0090417247,
-0.0036021168,
-0.0076880543,
-0.0192274172,
0.0033287427,
-0.01683948,
-0.0187003668,
-0.0924380571,
-0.0361289941,
0.0060533881,
0.0889241397,
0.024504764,
0.031282831,
-0.020874314,
-0.0247266777,
0.0006772437,
0.0104503054,
-0.0730305463,
0.0076746158,
-0.0594586134,
-0.0016869142,
0.0238527693,
-0.0517900102,
0.0224605836,
0.035768874,
-0.0618843399,
-0.0649678707,
-0.0028836364,
0.0473187789,
0.0107049029,
0.062024273,
-0.043469552,
-0.0211115703,
0.1115846038,
0.0417416357,
0.0031037466,
0.000600139,
0.007290618,
0.0406851918,
0.0037685968,
0.040296454,
0.0124319885,
-0.0006076886,
0.016633654,
0.0661210045,
-0.0071025644,
-0.0500722304,
0.0210771468,
-0.02107572,
0.0740765408,
-0.0840647072,
0.03412861,
-0.0230690222,
0.0206199419,
-0.0241012499,
-0.0162294023,
-0.0187752899,
-0.0080696,
0.0552006625,
-0.0206136853,
0.0079388134,
0.0346269757,
-0.0095859692,
-0.0121541731,
0.018163003,
-0.0247914121,
-0.023726929,
0.0253643095,
0.0009103846,
0.0291062351,
-0.0071666585,
0.0444394946,
0.0051812739,
0.0270756949,
-0.0388482027,
0.0635157004,
0.0228498951,
0.0002651547,
-0.0145209087,
0.0274503753,
-0.0186656583,
0.0086105904,
-0.0301234312,
0.0406734422,
0.1076128185,
-0.0240299124,
0.0852439702,
-0.0349173136,
-0.0269563068,
-0.0238899067,
0.0032067068,
-0.0216013994,
-0.0272925384,
0.0070342892,
-0.0050848555,
-0.0044012568,
0.063971661,
0.0464983024,
-0.026803432,
0.0230438355,
0.0157855265,
0.0475926921,
-0.0121882269,
-0.0135166673,
0.0153738875,
0.001238249,
-0.0294734556,
-0.015876323,
-0.0277202725,
-0.0473668426,
-0.0090164347,
0.0146949822,
-0.0491547249,
0.0065327287,
0.0067368802,
0.080521889,
-0.02898583,
0.0119964685,
-0.0340350792,
0.0267751943,
0.0198502,
-0.029729398,
-0.0008982972,
-6.468724841e-33,
-0.0207097363,
-0.0225246269,
0.0363590196,
-0.0219755061,
0.0389737301,
-0.0303964335,
-0.03039019,
0.0060805595,
0.0007303879,
0.0135196075,
-0.0207986161,
-0.0114696994,
0.0114018954,
0.0411199555,
0.0084954491,
0.0177301876,
0.0566958301,
0.0134753212,
-0.0393870324,
0.0305480827,
0.0383082516,
0.0078860465,
0.0554490238,
-0.0614979081,
0.0042461087,
-0.0247308202,
-0.0026742599,
0.0282177571,
0.0020269877,
0.0080269352,
-0.0078981025,
0.0119135091,
-0.0026185149,
-0.006292976,
-0.0172778461,
-0.0154441763,
-0.090736419,
-0.0102539975,
0.0068111802,
0.0099712405,
-0.0341665521,
-0.0199816395,
0.0221090373,
-0.0338351279,
-0.0204805639,
-0.0230192319,
0.0011092558,
-0.0275661126,
-0.0442663841,
-0.0142979408,
-0.0736439154,
0.0185581855,
0.0270688925,
-0.0261433665,
0.0358886495,
0.0207617041,
-0.0127003212,
-0.0027121184,
-0.0753142089,
0.0284452997,
-0.0454099104,
0.0313532911,
0.1032173559,
0.0178981256,
0.0081005841,
0.004422476,
0.0332312062,
-0.0102730133,
0.04205079,
-0.0304104798,
0.0392194279,
-0.0168591663,
0.0217171535,
0.0945460871,
0.0216096379,
0.0115438187,
-0.0534518287,
0.039525561,
0.009352115,
-0.0255511142,
0.0291764867,
0.0066706748,
-0.0239037555,
-0.0170440339,
-0.0552725494,
-0.0751120374,
-0.0167028047,
-0.0340079851,
0.0146979354,
0.0132412547,
-0.0173887424,
0.0080827866,
0.0953892544,
-0.0128455441,
-0.0311350748,
0.0109562175,
0.0146469632,
-0.0186580401,
-0.0425229259,
0.0642540008,
-0.0443694331,
-0.0413165241,
-0.0008381081,
0.025392767,
-0.0152717726,
-0.0003426777,
0.0561123788,
0.0341313258,
-0.0632244423,
-0.0053785467,
-0.0371171981,
-0.0195322912,
-0.0134973228,
-0.0018006612,
0.0377898589,
-0.0125613902,
-0.0041719624,
0.0600860827,
0.0492321663,
0.0117968982,
0.0081477007,
-0.0084072677,
-0.0280959345,
0.0195660852,
-0.0255856849,
0.0251360722,
-0.0271773916,
-0.0111537483,
0.0308137741,
-0.0614750385,
0.000609789,
0.01678483,
2.81e-7,
0.0276965871,
0.0632312968,
-0.0107999472,
-0.0305256154,
0.024005644,
0.0136903357,
-0.0413682386,
0.0149662849,
0.001062316,
0.0078285793,
0.0419211909,
0.0401193425,
0.071333386,
0.0060006143,
-0.0459828451,
0.010720511,
-0.0274465792,
0.0719848499,
-0.0553526208,
-0.0281714164,
0.0100508388,
0.0875193998,
0.0077416147,
-0.0137339728,
0.0118759964,
-0.0467372946,
0.0993617326,
-0.0114530064,
-0.0405155942,
0.0014268587,
-0.0269749761,
0.0724080354,
-0.0321460664,
-0.0054041017,
-0.0360906497,
0.0511651374,
-0.0003595841,
0.0455142483,
0.0068351994,
-0.0131059429,
0.0158668216,
-0.0080611389,
-0.0095851207,
-0.0669268072,
0.0705936998,
-0.087568529,
-0.0112657743,
-0.0119240684,
-0.0125231678,
0.0276386458,
0.0476556458,
-0.0278202817,
-0.0566897914,
0.0308805034,
0.0702307373,
0.0189164151,
-0.0596392974,
-0.0455955192,
-0.0183977485,
-0.0183751918,
-0.009769449,
-0.0164269228,
-0.025063552,
0.0276777316,
-0.0071232659,
-0.029262282,
0.0027503648,
2.513121515e-34,
0.0083884522,
-0.0294733886,
0.0291964561,
-0.0325000137,
0.0026518807,
-0.0197555665,
-0.0208469126,
0.0089982655,
0.0121153453,
-0.0693385303,
0.0106308889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10013v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10013v2 | Bridging the Empirical-Theoretical Gap in Neural Network Formal Language Learning Using Minimum Description Length | 2024-02-15T15:25:30 | 2024-06-06T16:16:12 | Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Roni Katzir | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | Neural networks offer good approximation to many tasks but consistently fail
to reach perfect generalization, even when theoretical work shows that such
perfect solutions can be expressed by certain architectures. Using the task of
formal language learning, we focus on one simple formal language and show that
the theoretically correct solution is in fact not an optimum of commonly used
objectives -- even with regularization techniques that according to common
wisdom should lead to simple weights and good generalization (L1, L2) or other
meta-heuristics (early-stopping, dropout). On the other hand, replacing
standard targets with the Minimum Description Length objective (MDL) results in
the correct solution being an optimum. | [
0.0321610235,
0.0485716313,
0.0078554014,
0.0041224617,
-0.0241659805,
0.0124347564,
-0.030590713,
0.0153111275,
-0.0575339086,
-0.0043770084,
0.0417951085,
-0.0503234379,
0.0170416869,
0.0575025268,
0.022499295,
-0.0279233716,
0.0107263764,
-0.0001779923,
0.0536509864,
-0.0530413389,
-0.0028737455,
-0.0136809759,
-0.0102028036,
0.0077392957,
-0.0227125976,
0.0402261727,
-0.048306793,
-0.0183338393,
-0.04124384,
0.0053852447,
0.0097402362,
0.0120107112,
-0.0038456111,
0.0646000504,
0.0000017972,
-0.0659855083,
0.0422096327,
-0.0113834767,
-0.0432785228,
-0.0267249048,
-0.0229587108,
-0.0262124818,
0.0288766678,
-0.0011715261,
-0.0248683281,
-0.0864840895,
0.0685245767,
0.050689809,
0.0201975033,
0.0897829533,
0.0040401388,
-0.011975809,
0.0167864598,
-0.0538935438,
-0.0140823284,
-0.0430793762,
0.0086513162,
0.0109946737,
-0.0045097885,
-0.0443334281,
-0.0173840597,
0.0246494394,
0.0305869505,
0.0400599577,
0.006095625,
0.0491030067,
-0.0159052927,
-0.0208718367,
0.015477105,
0.077264443,
0.0071069854,
-0.0107347472,
-0.0017277785,
-0.0131049128,
0.0281904601,
-0.0460346788,
-0.0131200701,
-0.0036246059,
-0.0116528897,
-0.000254904,
-0.0202110168,
-0.0306255426,
0.0564666912,
-0.007508669,
-0.0259870552,
0.1087968498,
-0.0166687332,
-0.0121767111,
0.0312792584,
-0.0408040956,
-0.0081497086,
-0.0094352672,
-0.0067473608,
0.0313540101,
0.0044075758,
-0.0037389037,
-0.0015140187,
-0.0157339461,
0.0044110259,
-0.0623455793,
0.0264319461,
0.0148210116,
0.0228674058,
0.0067153098,
-0.02232516,
0.0169092678,
0.0406472161,
0.0388076156,
-0.0825733095,
-0.0063801226,
-0.0504772812,
0.0110537484,
-0.0498438627,
0.0569202416,
-0.0089637041,
-0.0418644361,
-0.0301977452,
-0.0329363905,
-0.0001319445,
0.0599702038,
-0.0121422447,
0.0072267647,
-0.0337135196,
0.0020313335,
-0.0280982498,
-0.0331356749,
-0.0637752563,
0.0022409274,
-0.0033953858,
0.007155078,
-0.0209699888,
0.0054342849,
0.0165000595,
-0.0016574684,
0.0011908135,
0.0786488205,
-0.0040124627,
0.0141347237,
0.023657592,
-0.0125651294,
-0.01410551,
-0.0627993643,
0.0089647491,
-0.0595615283,
0.0245426707,
-0.0132080177,
0.0249603707,
-0.0839363337,
-0.0096851252,
-0.0220182072,
-0.0212008245,
0.0551454537,
-0.0354741961,
-0.0198346488,
0.0407065079,
0.0040466497,
0.0091745518,
0.0446853489,
0.0173061136,
0.0338108316,
0.0257681906,
-0.0108032282,
-0.0172166489,
0.033619903,
0.0383620784,
-0.0089157233,
-0.0499564931,
-0.0080213677,
-0.0042120358,
0.0639402494,
0.0106173111,
0.0582546294,
-0.0424207374,
-0.0299516562,
0.0228034686,
0.0328407139,
0.0464344099,
0.0151061611,
0.0743100196,
0.025256414,
0.0142706726,
0.0358300917,
-0.0399892256,
-0.0203133505,
-0.0739458948,
0.006269061,
-0.0489115156,
-0.0420020111,
-0.0493521802,
-0.0387764648,
-0.0218833853,
-0.0731777027,
0.0104703475,
-0.0133854356,
0.0451124012,
0.0180852171,
-0.0144013893,
0.0440052859,
0.0370726809,
0.0119952578,
0.0141328946,
-0.0069176848,
0.0164530892,
0.0177486856,
0.0022370922,
-0.0313402116,
-0.0612407215,
-0.0106399124,
-0.0139228338,
0.0743101165,
0.0876005888,
-0.0400556289,
0.0448715873,
-0.0278766658,
0.0058615557,
-0.002251223,
0.0374635644,
-0.0261155944,
-0.0194888245,
0.0036455614,
0.0416877642,
-0.055881694,
-0.0806457102,
0.0577357635,
-0.0069004921,
-0.0661512241,
0.0227587,
0.0292376447,
0.0483390614,
-0.0352827907,
0.021710977,
0.0166708045,
0.001627348,
-0.0200920515,
-0.0049806619,
-0.028963726,
-0.0646406189,
-0.0041021015,
0.082810156,
-0.0426016822,
0.0446565896,
0.074763447,
-0.0428302363,
-0.0727401227,
0.0173094627,
-0.0440778844,
0.0137920668,
-0.0030714488,
0.0012018253,
0.0030050278,
0.0169160701,
0.0002855356,
0.0232234411,
-0.0152715119,
-0.0097311251,
-0.0256553423,
-0.0478372164,
0.0277091321,
-0.016354315,
-0.0607575141,
0.0193741415,
-0.0081018517,
0.0230074599,
0.0385902114,
0.0097423084,
-0.0346615911,
0.0171345249,
-0.0114250686,
-0.0597464815,
0.0097631812,
0.0038913134,
0.008151588,
-0.016171027,
0.0345952995,
-0.0219624359,
-0.0708333924,
0.0593665428,
-0.0307225864,
-0.0469731838,
0.0681575164,
0.0682643205,
-0.0689611658,
-0.0243233014,
-0.0337248966,
-0.0040431102,
0.035997808,
-0.0306606926,
0.0138589302,
-0.0352494754,
-0.029561555,
-0.0569435991,
0.0498526916,
-0.0341105759,
0.0013470278,
-0.0181142073,
-0.0409984924,
-0.0626392961,
0.0340385027,
0.005920907,
0.008997445,
0.0425338745,
0.0492155775,
-0.0649588183,
0.0227090828,
-0.0394037217,
0.0268560573,
-0.0356207006,
-0.0418499634,
-0.00149412,
0.0942519903,
-0.0334463678,
0.0068483287,
-0.068705149,
0.0073629045,
0.0096403575,
-0.0189639274,
-0.0504282676,
0.0005353155,
-0.0232925359,
0.0584187247,
-0.011826708,
-0.0524446517,
0.0546667427,
-0.0177217219,
-0.003715697,
-0.0030595358,
-0.0211040415,
-0.0160961263,
0.055311054,
0.0313253663,
0.0293866228,
0.0324048586,
-0.0037437608,
-0.0337453261,
-0.0669375658,
0.0517102741,
0.017329298,
0.0439234674,
-0.0201321263,
0.0260869898,
-0.023547383,
-0.020808192,
-0.0217504948,
-0.0060217124,
-0.0337310992,
0.0276271924,
-0.039001625,
-0.0302129481,
-0.0281248037,
0.0047578188,
-0.0383798294,
0.0697141364,
0.0075484049,
0.0030943737,
-0.0082133356,
0.0189649668,
0.0398785993,
-0.0058116489,
0.0334041342,
-0.0315910876,
0.0380324535,
0.0006368567,
0.0277062692,
0.0513713844,
-0.0632845089,
-0.0334687345,
0.0374117754,
-0.0536123775,
-0.0448613316,
0.0437993929,
-0.0221671481,
-0.0243186317,
-0.048713997,
0.081987761,
-0.0029211631,
-0.0233083256,
0.0295218155,
0.0201485381,
0.0458814502,
0.0024137741,
0.0361889638,
-0.0390005037,
0.0006524887,
0.0254976247,
0.0442037024,
0.0025707409,
-0.0241004433,
-0.0340340398,
-0.0700239837,
-0.0735710412,
0.0409037098,
-0.0476383567,
0.0201445445,
0.0067860973,
-0.0368861519,
-0.0151987048,
0.0523586646,
0.0311556216,
0.0248037204,
-0.0365711749,
0.0114277648,
-0.0095202774,
-0.0034904922,
0.0450618453,
-0.0097357351,
0.0665651709,
0.020991426,
0.0396806337,
-0.0641176999,
-0.0148705281,
0.0974651426,
0.0897769406,
-0.018432131,
-0.0066803675,
0.0472505763,
0.0169354267,
0.0003017987,
0.0353855304,
0.0219316445,
-0.0288610943,
0.0300069842,
0.0034612459,
0.0577386282,
0.0031245195,
-0.0650900751,
0.0068168635,
0.0117923757,
-0.0339817703,
0.0090276096,
0.0289245807,
-0.0401721187,
-0.0173768885,
-0.0474142842,
-0.0006788644,
-0.0599574521,
-0.0050286511,
0.0165126026,
0.0298670679,
-0.0635942742,
-0.0702779666,
-0.0580969714,
0.0097904308,
0.0846640244,
0.0056482893,
0.0083757853,
0.0104460642,
0.0001772045,
-0.0140199531,
0.0197649486,
-0.0260593779,
-0.031786371,
-0.0184229799,
-0.0168652106,
0.0026798646,
-0.0221033394,
-0.0201833341,
-0.0208294597,
-0.0769808367,
-0.0499562286,
-0.015201265,
0.0662204102,
0.0215577763,
0.0122861434,
-0.0251442734,
-0.0296530593,
0.0396447331,
0.0231751539,
0.0121800806,
-0.0436895117,
0.0823840275,
-0.0570849553,
0.0082277153,
0.0591279864,
-0.0227911267,
0.0374593996,
0.0256465096,
0.0201789942,
0.0489769615,
0.0205710344,
0.0693787411,
0.0665676296,
0.0092353942,
-0.0256073978,
-0.0470135808,
-0.0135855582,
-0.014320394,
0.0332478471,
-0.0096320389,
-0.0321564227,
0.0455833487,
0.004321795,
0.0330515057,
0.0104368245,
-0.0411739387,
0.0152684012,
0.0313699357,
-0.0168613605,
-0.0143136336,
0.0544060357,
0.0164362546,
0.0523984171,
-0.022783706,
-0.0366778709,
0.0395488292,
0.0011263542,
0.0186092518,
-0.0137364427,
-0.0027497364,
0.052827768,
0.0838937908,
-0.0792366415,
-0.0176023431,
-0.0007972471,
-0.0508664548,
-0.0086234696,
0.0338288322,
0.0821195319,
-0.0134686884,
-0.0102111902,
-0.0253414847,
0.0187938493,
-0.018926315,
-0.0071497699,
-0.006254294,
-0.0596314222,
0.0034218985,
0.0228820071,
0.0072541335,
0.0100012254,
0.0787299499,
0.0025367015,
0.0603071526,
0.0152103091,
0.0359068848,
-0.0720607936,
-0.0358105525,
-0.0290033612,
0.0819078609,
-0.0607185289,
0.0045641405,
-0.0152796376,
-0.0765743703,
0.0069217733,
-0.0046815379,
-0.0010248751,
0.0017605225,
0.0485986881,
0.0401419699,
0.017458735,
0.0289839283,
-0.0146470247,
-0.0522294194,
0.0645507574,
0.029733574,
-0.0297479704,
-5.928268171e-33,
0.0123764416,
-0.0072298925,
0.0017792677,
0.017486522,
-0.0060388255,
0.0037534323,
-0.0132037709,
-0.0012684354,
-0.0260017775,
0.0178716779,
-0.0181030333,
0.0047746194,
-0.0048275231,
0.0167346783,
-0.0030852435,
0.009092561,
0.0000868584,
0.0054769749,
-0.0398838185,
-0.0235790592,
0.0031743294,
0.0273203105,
0.0511477403,
-0.0174291078,
0.0446642861,
0.0313809589,
-0.0124667352,
0.0327981524,
-0.033203423,
0.0209094081,
0.0096404962,
0.0566302501,
0.0230402481,
0.0517996103,
-0.0128399851,
-0.0418301113,
-0.0804234594,
-0.0413203612,
0.0298449676,
0.0084776292,
-0.0439880006,
0.0077694692,
0.0714083984,
-0.040724989,
-0.0225180592,
0.018533051,
0.0452274382,
-0.0129528502,
-0.0528590158,
-0.0284093134,
-0.0471419692,
0.0137711009,
0.0146987904,
-0.0022577334,
0.0155921225,
0.0313165784,
-0.0269737877,
-0.0640300587,
-0.0234327316,
-0.0032596416,
-0.0117832208,
0.0052548423,
-0.0059440341,
0.0255463924,
0.0156477001,
0.04353071,
0.0598551482,
0.0006761032,
0.0242185164,
-0.0167927314,
0.0462318063,
-0.0124978544,
0.0129982447,
0.0115458211,
0.0747891292,
-0.040336702,
-0.0571297705,
-0.027711425,
0.0162116326,
0.0714851618,
0.014295185,
-0.0147293843,
-0.0389750004,
-0.0341101624,
-0.0690336525,
0.0204761438,
-0.007672959,
-0.0117743919,
-0.0062365066,
0.0317547545,
-0.0092565482,
-0.0622718558,
-0.0340403058,
-0.023451779,
0.0273212176,
-0.0048702965,
0.0049017575,
-0.0100951074,
0.0069194739,
0.0284216572,
-0.0678254291,
-0.0576850995,
-0.0602673627,
-0.0242535342,
0.0059308745,
0.0149719333,
0.0591355525,
0.0125286141,
-0.024718605,
-0.0110106263,
-0.048184678,
-0.0283771809,
0.021181602,
0.0453928597,
0.0805209801,
0.0126239164,
-0.010093295,
-0.0276664495,
0.016898755,
-0.0395328216,
-0.0013217957,
0.0483877286,
0.0244800672,
0.0335548706,
-0.0216435008,
-0.0288653821,
-0.0116817197,
-0.0362157822,
0.0726853013,
-0.0402813405,
0.0154221319,
-0.011493138,
2.504e-7,
-0.0034368255,
0.0063105202,
0.0486815684,
0.0271935277,
0.0016966091,
0.0025836823,
-0.0380098373,
0.005243659,
-0.0524142385,
0.010626018,
0.0526196696,
0.0190196615,
0.0141734472,
0.0231885538,
-0.1022040695,
-0.0080524413,
-0.044821009,
0.0498191305,
0.0154862776,
0.0034365703,
-0.0311473254,
0.080456838,
0.04219497,
-0.0033324887,
-0.0013771465,
-0.0945626199,
0.0185136404,
-0.0413926318,
0.0718963072,
0.0464445874,
0.0039225454,
0.0209498163,
-0.0166773368,
0.0338862538,
0.0281529613,
0.0312994905,
-0.0116243213,
0.0702939853,
-0.0244811326,
0.0013720283,
-0.0186869632,
-0.0433860049,
0.0032690244,
0.0207459629,
0.0285392795,
-0.041494105,
-0.0362485424,
-0.0206164103,
-0.0055606356,
0.0089002037,
0.001142748,
0.0094863996,
0.0022448869,
0.00407595,
-0.0024120463,
-0.0396858677,
0.0214514676,
-0.0445399322,
-0.0150630996,
0.0300825294,
-0.0206088945,
-0.0143755693,
-0.0098326392,
-0.0069805835,
0.0221220907,
-0.0428978167,
0.0424507521,
1.737726411e-34,
0.0561133325,
-0.008643996,
-0.0019345606,
0.0181802493,
0.0090712374,
-0.0458731614,
-0.0074923909,
0.0023119166,
0.0548305623,
-0.0126214195,
-0.0151696587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03676v1 | Neural Information Organizing and Processing -- Neural Machines | 2024-02-15T15:15:11 | 2024-02-15T15:15:11 | Iosif Iulian Petrila | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG | The informational synthesis of neural structures, processes, parameters and
characteristics that allow a unified description and modeling as neural
machines of natural and artificial neural systems is presented. The general
informational parameters as the global quantitative measure of the neural
systems computing potential as absolute and relative neural power were
proposed. Neural information organizing and processing follows the way in which
nature manages neural information by developing functions, functionalities and
circuits related to different internal or peripheral components and also to the
whole system through a non-deterministic memorization, fragmentation and
aggregation of afferent and efferent information, deep neural information
processing representing multiple alternations of fragmentation and aggregation
stages. The relevant neural characteristics were integrated into a neural
machine type model that incorporates unitary also peripheral or interface
components as the central ones. The proposed approach allows overcoming the
technical constraints in artificial computational implementations of neural
information processes and also provides a more relevant description of natural
ones. | [
-0.0211667549,
0.0106396256,
-0.0218236279,
-0.0042504664,
-0.0179562792,
0.0194753613,
0.0015530714,
0.0053612776,
-0.0343590155,
0.0070249485,
-0.0729468316,
-0.0365657434,
0.0031434407,
-0.0070393635,
0.0572046153,
-0.0339909345,
0.0235516373,
0.0354029238,
-0.0124712978,
-0.0202733763,
-0.0360437967,
-0.0669967607,
0.0110530695,
0.0043390803,
-0.0303115603,
0.0133294668,
-0.0341147371,
-0.0177545045,
0.0156441145,
-0.0323818289,
-0.0320946015,
-0.0068594771,
0.0319645628,
0.0160820019,
0.0000022658,
-0.0078094252,
0.0259824321,
0.0188870169,
-0.0350831971,
-0.0490804613,
0.0102515398,
-0.0139858527,
-0.032886304,
-0.0325961448,
-0.0142291337,
-0.0048767095,
0.0552604087,
0.021330541,
-0.0051514627,
0.0580411106,
-0.0088249044,
-0.0610593446,
0.1018584594,
-0.0042236168,
-0.0143543975,
0.0540903099,
0.0170600899,
-0.0028109413,
-0.0216462277,
-0.0171518233,
-0.0065909652,
0.009723735,
0.0577845387,
0.0145240072,
0.0452933051,
0.0028789684,
0.0461125672,
-0.0323123448,
-0.0163027514,
-0.0140317967,
-0.0464130901,
0.0136484914,
-0.0083843386,
-0.003718866,
0.0034458241,
-0.0449238569,
-0.0452420823,
0.0322214663,
0.028959915,
0.0299335849,
0.0082097575,
0.0358045585,
0.0463937819,
-0.025206646,
0.0283895154,
0.0119236708,
0.0107618142,
-0.0198517945,
0.0123445299,
-0.0722194016,
0.0202545766,
0.0204280131,
-0.0058182771,
0.0593057275,
0.0469869673,
-0.0278236363,
-0.0056739938,
-0.0354021527,
0.0066487454,
-0.1058904678,
0.0350556895,
0.0114055192,
0.0173400249,
-0.0024209577,
-0.0048355823,
0.06680087,
-0.0681304038,
0.0268109087,
-0.0564929359,
0.0188013986,
-0.0598043874,
-0.0200064518,
0.0495035276,
0.1107928604,
0.0273980349,
-0.0237753559,
-0.0310628768,
0.0410318114,
-0.026782712,
-0.0834122077,
-0.045620583,
0.0196363684,
0.0228495821,
0.0096528577,
-0.0748429373,
-0.0025096077,
-0.0079279756,
0.014627411,
-0.0195531752,
0.0204927363,
0.0365955643,
0.0246472787,
-0.0478237644,
0.042747736,
-0.0133460211,
0.0658213943,
0.0046648481,
-0.0042811609,
-0.0846917629,
-0.0049613276,
0.0660872683,
-0.0231501814,
0.0587947741,
0.0052584205,
0.0449385159,
-0.0167993773,
-0.0186523926,
-0.0437346771,
-0.0350698195,
-0.0147033026,
0.0231157932,
0.0237330459,
-0.0297192466,
-0.0051983637,
0.0498356335,
-0.0053629074,
0.0477261394,
0.0147302998,
0.0424998663,
-0.0026859373,
-0.0306983888,
-0.0297574643,
0.0015929275,
0.0044390415,
0.0171741676,
-0.0831103474,
-0.0203190502,
-0.085695222,
-0.0401119292,
-0.0042372295,
0.0104500698,
0.0495799594,
-0.0099979844,
-0.006626517,
0.0211160369,
0.0421097316,
0.0811989382,
0.0943498686,
0.0497376025,
-0.0459834076,
0.0256083123,
0.0367924832,
-0.0336788371,
0.0555677041,
-0.045734264,
-0.0207032971,
0.0046718004,
0.0123816598,
-0.0324518271,
-0.0688222647,
0.0499513745,
-0.0120868636,
0.0029980363,
-0.0499471352,
0.0197871681,
-0.0244999398,
-0.0136873899,
-0.0042820531,
-0.0040529463,
0.0389725082,
0.0095730107,
-0.018544212,
0.021775445,
0.0069534951,
-0.0053493646,
-0.0534152538,
0.0222549923,
0.0197420996,
-0.0828156322,
0.0165406559,
-0.0045019244,
-0.0104874736,
-0.0301102959,
-0.0328314044,
0.0038653298,
-0.0047971066,
0.0105286064,
0.0321543217,
-0.0693631619,
-0.0274950601,
0.0054727132,
0.0719699413,
-0.0622744486,
-0.0126827126,
0.0150116775,
-0.0426527113,
-0.0363740548,
-0.0083273333,
0.01688,
-0.002068273,
0.0162004847,
0.0126709128,
0.0446230136,
-0.0857355148,
-0.0328013115,
-0.0292159226,
-0.0238067601,
0.0543274768,
0.0235010665,
0.0206540916,
0.0702267289,
-0.0079050688,
0.0336120389,
-0.0885091349,
0.0363485888,
0.0060440819,
0.0354280323,
-0.0177823193,
0.0278514381,
0.0323658511,
0.004464685,
0.0138538154,
0.0542389341,
-0.0004546907,
-0.007806492,
0.0145999976,
-0.0025967136,
0.0087634539,
-0.0164538044,
-0.0046493118,
0.0363440849,
-0.0539306588,
-0.005511845,
0.0140243517,
-0.0193740595,
0.0106396098,
-0.0054972288,
-0.0264481138,
-0.0149943754,
0.0160451829,
0.0252722595,
0.0022594237,
-0.0142712407,
0.0420697853,
0.05121167,
-0.0090443138,
0.1096566319,
-0.0223546308,
-0.0440153368,
0.0572867468,
0.0013584283,
0.0152075104,
-0.0438873693,
-0.0303698014,
-0.0587703139,
0.0618845895,
0.0558318682,
-0.0670948178,
-0.0258014668,
0.0503686145,
0.0014016017,
0.0401755013,
-0.0086760484,
-0.0642348006,
0.0044969572,
-0.0191019159,
0.0291057434,
0.0738987252,
0.0400233939,
-0.0210200157,
0.0310629271,
0.0545106344,
-0.0016093156,
0.035866715,
-0.0413618498,
0.0643947124,
-0.0185910761,
0.0031168098,
0.0087989867,
0.0460222438,
0.0425118282,
-0.0056779571,
-0.0235476438,
0.043290481,
-0.0246204492,
-0.0288963616,
-0.0296919029,
-0.030171819,
-0.0140908891,
-0.0048811329,
-0.0236280579,
-0.0154824546,
0.0204773266,
0.0322721601,
0.0407319441,
0.006421098,
-0.0408147015,
0.0276115127,
0.0484610014,
0.0451051705,
0.0217992999,
0.0254509263,
0.0031012923,
-0.0349296108,
-0.0007603021,
-0.0515941456,
0.0058264923,
-0.033122208,
-0.0103737246,
-0.0173273683,
-0.0159312151,
0.008737728,
-0.0389418937,
0.0374519192,
0.0412176661,
0.0676632822,
0.042769555,
-0.0100418022,
0.0179884247,
0.0159964953,
0.0503036566,
0.0039426889,
-0.0239781961,
-0.0029398585,
-0.027814826,
-0.0055495249,
-0.0319825448,
0.0185164399,
0.0020644777,
0.0403379351,
0.0471915007,
-0.0215184242,
0.0020576185,
0.033671096,
-0.0477897674,
0.0032604251,
-0.0170174241,
0.0182350576,
-0.0083760889,
-0.012478061,
0.0107335132,
-0.0172273405,
-0.0004768766,
0.0477990359,
0.0102905901,
-0.0869684219,
-0.0106313499,
-0.02274842,
-0.0954540595,
0.0047961716,
0.008056378,
0.0333663151,
0.0366059542,
-0.0384132117,
-0.0556305312,
-0.0097081931,
-0.0091666309,
0.0154820113,
-0.0229991004,
-0.0170246884,
0.0212505329,
-0.0519642569,
-0.070873186,
0.0376193784,
-0.0377748497,
0.0220866948,
-0.0008898895,
0.0323441364,
0.006475206,
-0.0113278115,
0.0224349648,
-0.0299232434,
0.0141331591,
-0.0310856868,
-0.0463776588,
-0.0062237652,
0.0700984374,
0.0141839152,
-0.0446702801,
-0.0035053252,
0.0183001198,
-0.0230538361,
0.044333633,
-0.0203840714,
-0.0125695569,
0.0677305236,
-0.0280768909,
-0.0398996696,
0.0085762413,
0.00188173,
0.0126975607,
-0.0573205389,
0.0240609609,
-0.0458980612,
0.0144521026,
-0.0233746059,
-0.0310385916,
-0.0351598151,
0.0261809416,
0.0210214052,
-0.0407838486,
-0.0013472372,
0.0032778047,
0.0299162436,
-0.0300466716,
-0.0336650945,
0.0133065311,
0.030845046,
-0.0634671375,
-0.0683281049,
0.0149169927,
-0.0347753987,
0.0635563061,
0.0632438958,
-0.0510674417,
0.0801289305,
-0.079077132,
-0.0365321599,
-0.0168617666,
0.0333317406,
-0.0609604828,
-0.0224642232,
-0.0414994806,
0.0561073497,
-0.0127693675,
-0.0053971251,
-0.0085282,
0.0225593019,
-0.0247230045,
0.0177993979,
0.058949016,
0.0118187787,
-0.0481292754,
-0.0098409979,
-0.0498063862,
0.0697956756,
0.0197986662,
-0.0091867615,
0.0276117753,
0.0030327046,
0.007585227,
-0.0197237171,
0.0024115259,
-0.0175854489,
0.0525629371,
0.0084183309,
-0.0045830207,
-0.0369849838,
0.0375588499,
0.0539336242,
0.0206146035,
0.0202894043,
0.051094383,
0.0165786184,
-0.0151282186,
-0.0134914275,
0.0419125482,
0.0061208396,
-0.0297069643,
-0.0069922279,
0.0325087421,
0.0534885786,
0.0087199761,
-0.0496371612,
0.1025607213,
-0.0606751069,
0.0221405216,
-0.0335812159,
0.0089123454,
0.0535085239,
-0.073505275,
0.039353352,
0.0044424762,
0.0298575945,
-0.074978523,
-0.0001522004,
0.0058956011,
0.0084768245,
-0.0108876256,
0.0313920565,
-0.0685955659,
0.0311187971,
-0.0118108513,
-0.0385355279,
-0.0004528419,
-0.0051945802,
0.0649773777,
0.03377565,
-0.0536295436,
-0.0139774028,
0.0240418278,
-0.0022006154,
-0.042269595,
0.0000369809,
0.0506098382,
0.0119116819,
0.0405042656,
0.0010782827,
-0.0706366226,
0.0319579951,
-0.0444239751,
0.0189344231,
-0.0556667373,
0.0467838719,
0.0009292584,
0.0476558208,
-0.0264476314,
0.0624486543,
0.0003489086,
-0.0261397678,
-0.0070073074,
-0.0092057772,
0.0125846164,
0.0482615381,
0.0494165346,
-0.0127958916,
0.0405549258,
-0.0135869179,
-0.007857888,
-0.0261933301,
0.0454558358,
-0.0221518911,
-0.0181486104,
0.0223626532,
-0.0298162941,
-6.451968904e-33,
-0.0222889334,
0.0006987221,
-0.0046647941,
0.0076033762,
-0.0345053524,
0.0146674775,
0.0016917351,
-0.036493443,
-0.0201401617,
-0.0272671115,
-0.0006462475,
0.0205365252,
-0.0095249033,
0.0080359709,
0.0343836956,
-0.0186148267,
-0.0172663163,
-0.0376491509,
0.0253993869,
-0.006333793,
0.0640869141,
0.0329549126,
0.0439975671,
-0.0349247791,
-0.0101236859,
0.0130936233,
0.0346970037,
0.0433063917,
-0.0238341894,
-0.0105922427,
-0.0415235497,
0.009928247,
0.0349579081,
-0.0341667719,
-0.0017142576,
-0.004615088,
-0.0103473328,
-0.0389334224,
-0.0073784464,
-0.0396215692,
-0.031294018,
-0.0653656945,
0.1105620861,
-0.0312204901,
-0.018619664,
0.0374029428,
-0.0019717454,
-0.0175946485,
0.0131210303,
-0.0411565527,
-0.0014195454,
-0.0244191159,
-0.0000069176,
0.0010237059,
-0.0009941711,
-0.0223878361,
-0.0457614698,
-0.0024372239,
-0.0839499012,
0.0273346398,
0.0033490201,
0.048986394,
-0.012621806,
0.0658527538,
0.0763112158,
0.0365858451,
0.089410916,
0.0093657225,
-0.0612995364,
0.0146752661,
-0.0162850227,
0.0321968049,
0.0989122167,
-0.027040951,
0.0794755965,
-0.0239906833,
-0.0687505081,
0.0411231481,
0.0433532372,
0.0105074244,
-0.0084762359,
0.0213414524,
0.0043757837,
-0.0187947806,
0.0404615737,
-0.0275412463,
-0.0228815731,
-0.0132230157,
0.0051754066,
-0.0451845974,
0.0212586056,
0.0000318159,
-0.0280804671,
-0.0369132198,
0.0882381126,
0.0202809665,
0.0699928403,
0.0419732779,
0.01313968,
-0.0326888151,
-0.0407186411,
-0.0289185494,
-0.0393652543,
0.051964622,
0.0084834965,
0.0341256894,
-0.0642606691,
0.0681624785,
0.0550569296,
-0.0321493372,
0.0191030614,
-0.0538670309,
0.0337173007,
-0.0550648682,
0.0051711267,
-0.0176922847,
-0.0207510795,
-0.0169248879,
0.0135653736,
0.0319873504,
0.014310834,
0.0208512135,
-0.0113310367,
0.0576952323,
0.0089536831,
-0.0249271672,
-0.0385452956,
0.0258793179,
0.0047440594,
-0.0434571318,
-0.0029947776,
0.028554339,
3.196e-7,
-0.0133045409,
-0.0272415467,
0.0233028531,
-0.0069285007,
0.0506241098,
-0.0158011448,
0.0166744683,
-0.0016151709,
-0.0077762934,
-0.0778480768,
0.0369259603,
0.0429297462,
-0.0547225252,
-0.0150131024,
-0.0602821037,
-0.0605386458,
0.0255238954,
-0.0112893963,
-0.0003907862,
0.0232183319,
-0.0119041419,
0.0469510555,
0.0031220212,
-0.0162704848,
0.0124742575,
-0.049980972,
-0.0101881064,
0.0120593086,
0.037706133,
-0.0210245028,
0.0318380632,
-0.0099645853,
-0.0142977228,
0.0556841902,
0.0382746793,
0.0271165557,
-0.0251895729,
-0.0363889746,
-0.0089011062,
0.0014591031,
0.0167390592,
-0.0187711883,
0.0037352655,
0.0360022224,
-0.00137192,
-0.067286469,
-0.0572057925,
0.0250745304,
0.0091005387,
0.0178669877,
-0.013488966,
-0.0125107728,
0.0206193179,
-0.036515329,
-0.0565744303,
-0.0241663512,
-0.0022642324,
-0.0137031348,
0.0185695942,
0.0704353973,
-0.0203678925,
-0.0142875174,
-0.0464037023,
-0.0617899895,
0.0674261227,
0.0102857202,
0.0069300029,
2.247063522e-34,
-0.0242221653,
-0.018405214,
-0.0005401434,
0.0191511959,
-0.0213222522,
0.0045300303,
-0.0951007158,
-0.0526319519,
-0.0158526041,
-0.035230957,
-0.03497779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09997v1 | LoraRetriever: Input-Aware LoRA Retrieval and Composition for Mixed Tasks in the Wild | 2024-02-15T15:02:46 | 2024-02-15T15:02:46 | Ziyu Zhao, Leilei Gan, Guoyin Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Hongxia Yang, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) provides an effective yet efficient solution for
fine-tuning large language models (LLM). The modular and plug-and-play nature
of LoRA enables the integration of diverse domain-specific LoRAs to enhance the
capabilities of LLMs. Previous research on exploiting multiple LoRAs either
focuses on specific isolated downstream tasks or fixes the selection of LoRAs
during training. However, in real-world scenarios, LLMs receive diverse prompts
covering different tasks, and the pool of candidate LoRAs is often dynamically
updated. To bridge this gap, we propose LoraRetriever, a retrieve-then-compose
framework that adaptively retrieves and composes multiple LoRAs according to
the input prompts. LoraRetriever contains three main components: firstly,
identifying and retrieving LoRAs relevant to the given input; secondly,
formulating strategies for effectively integrating the retrieved LoRAs; and
thirdly, developing efficient batch inference to accommodate heterogeneous
requests. Experimental results indicate that LoraRetriever consistently
outperforms the baselines, highlighting its practical effectiveness and
versatility. | [
0.0370858349,
0.0500865839,
-0.0155443838,
0.0352389067,
-0.0108124148,
0.0184244942,
0.0050401674,
-0.0140662761,
0.0156025887,
-0.0446027406,
-0.0818692967,
-0.0418675356,
-0.0011425131,
0.0018425755,
0.0511336215,
-0.0304281451,
0.0338052996,
-0.075541392,
-0.0226234403,
0.0009222673,
-0.0076472689,
0.035126131,
0.0046138265,
0.0636753067,
0.0765981674,
-0.0135068614,
-0.0071087717,
0.0373541899,
0.0068635405,
0.0202006064,
0.0409673862,
0.0495853536,
0.0649781227,
0.0366371647,
0.0000019548,
-0.0259469412,
-0.0304138269,
-0.012143828,
-0.0242330804,
-0.031796705,
0.035293933,
0.0216718651,
0.001672289,
0.0496613495,
-0.0223873854,
-0.0595828667,
0.0279893242,
0.0035465339,
0.0359349363,
0.0873469636,
0.009904949,
0.0195645578,
0.0018895777,
-0.0607590489,
-0.0040695462,
-0.0328593664,
0.0275413059,
-0.0496408381,
-0.0134643763,
-0.0046392018,
-0.01487948,
0.0288626887,
-0.0006497524,
-0.014494651,
-0.029839851,
0.0102269249,
-0.0429388843,
-0.0226286147,
-0.0315667465,
0.0585404523,
-0.0507276729,
0.0143058728,
0.0187457968,
-0.0177257005,
-0.0056233499,
-0.0319193378,
-0.0562607013,
0.0051134322,
-0.005408301,
0.0012626061,
-0.0221566129,
-0.0159022305,
0.0119113307,
-0.0013400534,
-0.0517497435,
0.0125064179,
0.0470729247,
-0.0298045836,
0.0001238756,
-0.0219015814,
-0.0045635514,
-0.0492779501,
0.00422855,
0.0255566742,
-0.0356728435,
0.0108502666,
-0.0663112551,
-0.0278173666,
0.0327557437,
0.019689342,
0.098465547,
0.0343219936,
-0.051126685,
0.0521242321,
-0.0420078002,
0.054046791,
-0.0293071549,
-0.0126143694,
-0.0533290096,
-0.0011768222,
-0.0225375965,
-0.012750023,
-0.0018723801,
0.0319195352,
-0.052710969,
-0.0191752408,
0.0059000552,
0.0391668417,
-0.0049145487,
0.0094320728,
0.0184982363,
0.0038121017,
-0.0456726775,
-0.0114353988,
-0.0046368451,
0.0727519691,
0.0394415967,
0.0393757708,
0.0367060751,
-0.0617770888,
-0.0309922695,
-0.000341087,
0.0359509885,
-0.0536806211,
0.0331079587,
0.0650954992,
-0.0140038375,
-0.0314837135,
-0.0209442992,
-0.0027905721,
0.001333577,
-0.071176894,
0.0234302916,
-0.0472957306,
0.0381300598,
-0.0037793354,
0.0166469757,
-0.0128376,
-0.0115811657,
0.0469740108,
-0.0407201461,
0.0505738035,
0.0411759876,
0.0038946993,
0.0298920963,
-0.0010281791,
0.0058704782,
0.0752692521,
0.0159931295,
0.0513870232,
0.0150784897,
-0.0143872844,
-0.014209372,
0.0578507446,
-0.0135966372,
0.0011524118,
-0.0038573218,
0.0162920412,
0.0108958241,
-0.0081399996,
0.053080827,
0.0235450733,
-0.0076289452,
0.0297427475,
0.0685772672,
0.0463074073,
0.0718789846,
-0.0156732481,
0.0610149801,
-0.0202815216,
-0.005598126,
0.0161814354,
-0.0491896011,
0.0512200668,
-0.0297807381,
0.0182826053,
0.0295643117,
0.0702848658,
-0.022137396,
-0.0295669399,
-0.0331390426,
-0.0038489867,
-0.0408086404,
0.0357413031,
0.0671868101,
0.0193346757,
-0.0677936971,
0.0328222215,
0.0398615636,
-0.0516699851,
0.0261391588,
-0.0552660152,
0.0295202639,
0.0585266016,
0.028153412,
-0.0465490073,
-0.0494214408,
-0.0050141416,
0.04036792,
0.0328972079,
0.0157054942,
0.0049678516,
0.0106595447,
-0.0813149065,
-0.0402740128,
-0.0126442499,
0.0186817124,
0.02599377,
0.0177743994,
0.0053022038,
0.0232724082,
-0.018578548,
-0.0127525665,
0.034254346,
-0.048766844,
-0.001959522,
0.0158103649,
0.0085624056,
0.0240228325,
-0.0068643186,
-0.0022720608,
0.0053512575,
0.0280662365,
-0.0470076427,
0.004567571,
-0.0354225002,
-0.0450538024,
-0.0393907726,
0.0126733044,
0.0407504588,
-0.0012458987,
0.0469500422,
-0.0469181128,
-0.0344277546,
0.0080941413,
-0.0232684817,
0.0088213868,
-0.0258915592,
0.0045850384,
0.0334514976,
0.0262790937,
-0.039448753,
0.023569921,
-0.0000227285,
0.0014742884,
0.0323216282,
0.0006531311,
0.0046874606,
-0.0621002093,
-0.0426724851,
0.0026574188,
-0.0298717488,
0.0189777818,
0.0117118983,
0.0313028321,
-0.0194985904,
-0.0572544709,
-0.0413597487,
0.023570573,
-0.0307700317,
0.031529516,
0.0056176255,
0.0299837515,
0.0000637368,
-0.0292501524,
-0.0153173711,
0.0150045818,
-0.0192011818,
0.041786205,
-0.0153713115,
0.0043701776,
-0.0189402457,
-0.06778685,
-0.0174867213,
-0.0057320809,
0.0445121787,
-0.053374514,
-0.0204818286,
-0.0505356938,
0.0330961794,
-0.02562996,
0.0334565714,
-0.0474101417,
-0.0219467971,
-0.0081442827,
-0.0427329466,
0.067831248,
0.0588133521,
-0.0025351103,
-0.0137096057,
0.0640599057,
-0.0125535503,
-0.0543143339,
0.0332057849,
-0.0131653324,
-0.0633464977,
-0.037123818,
-0.0013382089,
0.0004677991,
0.0371093899,
0.0088462671,
0.0028829908,
-0.0527246073,
-0.0177392028,
-0.0157433599,
-0.0127460519,
-0.0342898257,
0.0045679361,
-0.0183577444,
-0.0020537972,
-0.0388770439,
-0.0243964773,
0.0592869557,
-0.032476306,
-0.0320220999,
-0.0116569558,
-0.0278836489,
-0.0711686313,
0.0544820838,
-0.0091771707,
0.0016246286,
-0.0084369546,
-0.048521176,
-0.0777062476,
0.0156592038,
0.0034735689,
-0.050267376,
0.0600060858,
-0.0463097654,
0.0081355153,
-0.0545171201,
-0.0751422942,
-0.0044680391,
-0.0264999159,
0.0124007538,
0.0299373772,
-0.0120072691,
-0.017742103,
-0.0289951786,
-0.0047945748,
0.0282078087,
0.0817431435,
-0.0239299368,
0.0201614778,
-0.0382629745,
0.0354849845,
0.0822766498,
0.0654145777,
-0.0098949708,
-0.024905026,
0.0081577254,
0.0141362334,
0.0535135455,
-0.0080042826,
-0.0082915444,
0.044279702,
0.0665867701,
0.010732376,
0.0117727797,
0.0212712921,
0.0168930665,
-0.0684745312,
-0.0108755995,
0.0645104647,
-0.0185079481,
-0.0793919787,
-0.0368118994,
-0.030283438,
0.0397278257,
0.045405712,
0.0328177586,
-0.045705609,
-0.0251433495,
0.0271396935,
0.0292523801,
0.0144262491,
-0.0011545967,
-0.0065025399,
-0.1332884133,
0.0341109447,
-0.0071266512,
-0.0189125128,
-0.0187958423,
-0.0368181877,
0.0197923556,
0.0080768215,
0.0402100608,
0.0194578003,
-0.0260300115,
-0.0196904782,
0.0326242149,
-0.0126150688,
-0.0554746352,
0.0095731225,
-0.0109611079,
0.0577279292,
0.0777493045,
0.0086641768,
0.0071008364,
-0.0076280367,
0.0271790512,
-0.0181805305,
0.0127247693,
-0.0125931688,
0.0150610143,
-0.0037439635,
-0.0296894908,
0.0023169839,
0.0246838629,
-0.0256983433,
-0.0033105018,
0.0151270293,
0.0595951974,
0.0124115488,
-0.0000475975,
-0.0152472081,
-0.0305229593,
0.0284940694,
0.0677214712,
0.0553337038,
-0.0212964118,
0.0075025088,
0.0111767864,
-0.0324627161,
-0.0377903171,
-0.0260704663,
0.0200371984,
-0.0297141597,
0.0327404365,
-0.015373731,
-0.0024784191,
0.0633569211,
0.0250542406,
-0.0113820517,
0.0251278486,
-0.0148726329,
-0.0056521758,
-0.0508704782,
0.0564331561,
-0.0343588963,
-0.0056703798,
-0.0531252697,
-0.0255155116,
0.0334110074,
-0.0314313136,
-0.0334616378,
0.0355597548,
-0.10305015,
-0.0475480109,
-0.0127052413,
0.0687512606,
0.0152395079,
0.0120675331,
0.0059623923,
-0.080351837,
0.0709378272,
0.0254197624,
-0.0091350693,
0.0464560613,
0.0175687578,
-0.0215861984,
-0.031189587,
0.0499469638,
-0.0981139019,
-0.0127935801,
0.0476129167,
0.0641420484,
0.0384962671,
-0.0379808992,
-0.0071505392,
0.0036665776,
0.0155536849,
0.0011596441,
-0.0311775804,
-0.0509884953,
0.0621141233,
0.0031571072,
-0.0160343945,
-0.0568517633,
-0.0149488216,
0.0210673437,
-0.0342433453,
-0.0056236014,
0.021735182,
0.0319181569,
0.0295582414,
-0.0734396353,
0.0026149889,
0.0316885822,
0.0082061803,
0.0622526705,
0.0066433074,
-0.0437473841,
0.0236176308,
0.0022376596,
0.0021978868,
-0.0367193259,
0.0097847758,
-0.0034354555,
-0.01883398,
-0.0384446606,
0.0538202152,
-0.0419312641,
-0.0743402988,
-0.0304394942,
-0.0074714203,
0.0584547482,
0.0111952582,
0.077481173,
0.0453123003,
-0.0171001591,
-0.0244481135,
-0.0300987028,
0.0092506437,
0.0076505034,
0.0227048304,
0.0161521584,
-0.0024140924,
0.0187363923,
0.0843765661,
0.0211848188,
0.0619973764,
-0.0238869563,
0.0255025569,
-0.0242956262,
-0.0268600676,
0.041479934,
0.0121132983,
-0.0230866522,
-0.0439582355,
0.0030705677,
-0.0605343878,
0.0152844498,
-0.0062843375,
-0.0302078016,
-0.0073881177,
-0.0009510586,
0.067791231,
-0.0213045031,
-0.010721961,
-0.0105004404,
-0.0145978518,
0.0024460033,
-0.0149314171,
-0.0194690824,
-6.680180847e-33,
-0.0554301254,
0.0019203186,
0.0475078896,
-0.014656987,
-0.0062236544,
0.0244740881,
-0.0313294977,
-0.0258356351,
-0.001836907,
-0.0335658751,
-0.0073413495,
-0.0083357245,
0.0181392487,
0.0222677737,
0.0339065939,
-0.0015551753,
0.0583328046,
0.0090906601,
-0.0118071437,
0.0137972981,
0.0288476218,
0.0529129617,
0.0622304492,
-0.0290058739,
-0.0107995803,
0.005091276,
-0.0062022666,
-0.0001306456,
-0.043236237,
0.0743522719,
-0.0079447851,
0.0574402027,
0.0190906525,
-0.0248350538,
-0.0378474668,
0.0311385747,
-0.0729021952,
-0.0299360827,
0.0290765911,
-0.0255467407,
0.0064827846,
-0.030389443,
0.0550812148,
-0.006705808,
0.0256162602,
-0.041850701,
0.0356276706,
0.0014197245,
-0.0239111651,
-0.0224630442,
-0.0502796657,
0.0024505788,
0.0245952513,
-0.0263011269,
0.0224687923,
0.0341013595,
0.0165513158,
0.0376872309,
-0.0663187355,
0.0067891884,
-0.0449103601,
0.0987459868,
0.0569807142,
0.0257248357,
-0.0338695832,
0.0358953401,
0.0058653518,
0.0145483026,
0.0304530635,
-0.0509647354,
0.0302538332,
0.0537489094,
0.0158650056,
0.0512701422,
-0.0087196995,
0.0192833804,
-0.0606283583,
0.0026095875,
0.0099559492,
0.0360267423,
0.0359168686,
0.0280054566,
-0.0008908802,
0.0041319709,
-0.0398194939,
-0.0034923805,
-0.0636266246,
-0.0030366245,
0.0529612191,
0.0482283831,
0.0164270308,
-0.0151711861,
0.0584437512,
-0.0096882302,
-0.008116642,
-0.0212254692,
0.0035226413,
0.0057059075,
-0.0019243865,
0.0600134619,
-0.0278825592,
-0.0618310645,
0.0512885042,
-0.0163119342,
-0.0082481867,
0.001815524,
0.0240925085,
0.0465874262,
-0.0686621815,
-0.0139611065,
-0.0460948497,
0.0237604305,
-0.0052420166,
0.075008288,
0.0379257165,
0.0116986418,
-0.0113143232,
0.0473610461,
0.0072146249,
-0.0252213962,
-0.0304846298,
-0.0294980947,
0.0161810592,
0.0200400427,
-0.024024209,
0.0061931824,
-0.0299104564,
0.0101990644,
0.0213081464,
-0.0112670064,
0.0025761472,
0.0261484459,
2.786e-7,
0.0067157904,
-0.000010713,
-0.0134489648,
-0.0222769901,
-0.0119849201,
-0.0008319331,
-0.0380016789,
0.0479149595,
0.0366138257,
0.0228469782,
-0.0182298403,
0.0018904596,
0.0532914773,
-0.0142836673,
-0.0876415521,
-0.0085806297,
-0.0777741224,
0.0024863733,
-0.0588742197,
-0.0395155847,
0.0195469894,
0.0911955386,
0.0084443148,
-0.0292705465,
-0.0099432608,
-0.0290566906,
0.0516156666,
-0.0174034815,
-0.0354148112,
0.0041231439,
0.0487704501,
0.0174670294,
-0.0039174072,
-0.0189989526,
-0.0192948841,
0.0599874891,
-0.0016712104,
0.0709296912,
-0.0230577476,
-0.0453097932,
0.0160297994,
0.0148244705,
-0.0059154406,
-0.0409403443,
0.0678374395,
-0.0578129366,
0.0154203353,
-0.030208854,
-0.0132935131,
-0.0188273899,
-0.0010047774,
-0.0290951934,
0.0003184349,
0.0113058565,
0.0230056848,
0.0099064065,
-0.0213301666,
-0.1236855164,
0.0122985439,
-0.0009686632,
-0.0702745393,
-0.0376611203,
-0.0571922623,
-0.0100686848,
0.017463183,
-0.086205177,
-0.0052006268,
2.872049761e-34,
0.0085324403,
0.0158273745,
0.0172779169,
0.0557735488,
0.0264885239,
-0.0059496341,
-0.0500669517,
0.0315907486,
-0.0241688062,
-0.1184268668,
-0.0442644767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09989v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09989v4 | LLMs as Bridges: Reformulating Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-15T14:54:33 | 2024-05-29T16:59:59 | Jinyuan Li, Han Li, Di Sun, Jiahao Wang, Wenkun Zhang, Zan Wang, Gang Pan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (GMNER) is a nascent multimodal
task that aims to identify named entities, entity types and their corresponding
visual regions. GMNER task exhibits two challenging properties: 1) The weak
correlation between image-text pairs in social media results in a significant
portion of named entities being ungroundable. 2) There exists a distinction
between coarse-grained referring expressions commonly used in similar tasks
(e.g., phrase localization, referring expression comprehension) and
fine-grained named entities. In this paper, we propose RiVEG, a unified
framework that reformulates GMNER into a joint MNER-VE-VG task by leveraging
large language models (LLMs) as a connecting bridge. This reformulation brings
two benefits: 1) It maintains the optimal MNER performance and eliminates the
need for employing object detection methods to pre-extract regional features,
thereby naturally addressing two major limitations of existing GMNER methods.
2) The introduction of entity expansion expression and Visual Entailment (VE)
module unifies Visual Grounding (VG) and Entity Grounding (EG). It enables
RiVEG to effortlessly inherit the Visual Entailment and Visual Grounding
capabilities of any current or prospective multimodal pretraining models.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that RiVEG outperforms state-of-the-art
methods on the existing GMNER dataset and achieves absolute leads of 10.65%,
6.21%, and 8.83% in all three subtasks. | [
0.0486970469,
0.0509585179,
0.0385694988,
0.0437521674,
0.0184156578,
0.0257510394,
-0.016334407,
-0.0040233987,
-0.0035400407,
-0.0651086941,
-0.0308714118,
0.007120301,
-0.0184050053,
0.0010565582,
0.0423959903,
-0.0343844816,
0.0311630741,
-0.0041976292,
-0.0278525129,
0.0411771797,
0.0424519479,
0.0284560639,
-0.0255704727,
0.0318260007,
-0.0290383175,
0.0069564641,
0.0128006153,
0.0302835796,
0.0365547985,
-0.0734905601,
-0.0128901443,
0.0308276787,
0.057359077,
0.0047415383,
0.0000019447,
-0.029123731,
-0.0019511777,
-0.0073316968,
0.0033978745,
-0.0075172232,
0.0038051999,
-0.0361481607,
0.0123590855,
-0.0189107638,
0.0055871755,
-0.0324415118,
0.0472658426,
0.087273486,
0.0562620461,
0.0241340864,
-0.027979441,
-0.0051569794,
0.0288181882,
-0.0149814216,
0.0098747397,
-0.0523314141,
0.0030731582,
0.0273157451,
-0.0432191268,
0.0226889048,
-0.0378909521,
0.0352138467,
-0.0015519692,
0.016668614,
0.0300194211,
0.0567476489,
-0.0247799791,
-0.0038307814,
-0.0190681238,
0.1128003374,
-0.0226495545,
-0.0098278932,
0.0056147669,
-0.0024912315,
-0.0235432442,
0.0098899417,
-0.0373187028,
0.0322345011,
-0.0538712554,
0.0210281629,
-0.048801098,
-0.0074957563,
0.0124039957,
0.0349480547,
-0.0115039898,
-0.0018080812,
0.0077655241,
-0.000417647,
0.0393135212,
0.0521229543,
-0.0564057007,
-0.0532550514,
0.0274367016,
0.0215383209,
0.0164109524,
0.0157860033,
-0.0436256379,
-0.0196128469,
-0.0159084685,
-0.0345555507,
0.0077209156,
0.017417727,
-0.0657807887,
0.0709504783,
-0.0712762326,
0.0121761598,
-0.0603200309,
0.0222968664,
0.0227604974,
-0.0185658634,
-0.0198695902,
0.0034100607,
-0.040819373,
-0.0008323286,
-0.0625321791,
-0.0457585678,
0.0004376265,
0.0180082731,
0.0039079287,
-0.0094355838,
-0.0160329882,
0.0103717363,
-0.0203482416,
-0.006545831,
-0.0194992181,
0.0485910401,
-0.0374651849,
0.0088909287,
-0.0211254824,
-0.0486925207,
-0.0007531866,
0.0348665714,
0.041938521,
-0.0432583205,
0.0407744907,
0.0487300158,
-0.0088203996,
-0.0904950351,
-0.0590859167,
-0.0262248479,
-0.0220601447,
-0.0577599481,
0.0467318483,
-0.031242175,
0.0346655622,
0.0027730272,
0.0014805038,
-0.0195344314,
0.0256679114,
0.0108080199,
-0.0339534841,
0.0905117169,
-0.0065395823,
0.0063816435,
0.0206276588,
0.0088564996,
0.0257765613,
0.0609178357,
0.0491093919,
0.0497093722,
0.032676015,
-0.0005350297,
-0.0001544708,
0.0188170467,
0.0319939964,
0.022416465,
-0.0141952895,
-0.0002141042,
-0.0276186001,
-0.0051544635,
0.0473462753,
0.0200411826,
-0.0060879285,
-0.0044234162,
0.0739049762,
0.0402824394,
-0.0540979691,
-0.0355471037,
0.0469465069,
-0.0056740539,
-0.011046404,
0.0017011799,
-0.0793470889,
0.0403436683,
-0.0189984757,
-0.0012360213,
0.0224188901,
0.0607291237,
-0.0222042874,
0.0148357674,
0.0084450655,
0.0019067555,
0.0210405812,
0.0084392186,
0.0599123165,
0.0370813347,
-0.1044795886,
0.0599438585,
0.0317585208,
-0.0425458811,
-0.0002607034,
0.0069386777,
0.0063592349,
0.0279446356,
0.0321019888,
0.0137075884,
-0.0403261334,
-0.0246011931,
0.0672260374,
0.0710023642,
-0.0354920514,
0.0168666169,
0.0391454697,
-0.051183328,
-0.0486140288,
-0.0071873018,
0.0025168676,
0.0196528044,
0.046044834,
0.0370866209,
0.0251589585,
-0.0718370974,
0.0211773757,
0.0563065559,
0.0464227684,
0.017592391,
-0.0510295369,
0.0427046493,
-0.0195406787,
0.0180244483,
-0.0185762551,
-0.0324849896,
0.0122762583,
-0.0439970568,
0.0028243337,
0.0028597047,
-0.0192222148,
-0.0179596748,
-0.0066659497,
-0.0547353551,
-0.0304486565,
-0.0205223821,
-0.0434695147,
-0.0203417744,
-0.011348295,
-0.0031665028,
0.028119171,
-0.0230728332,
-0.0049906932,
0.0114076678,
0.036460042,
-0.0191468652,
0.0602942966,
-0.0265438929,
-0.0049702688,
-0.0176306311,
0.0005779694,
0.0002990049,
-0.0218030848,
-0.0224892106,
-0.0158779994,
-0.0068874015,
-0.0300431661,
-0.0074888072,
0.0068113054,
-0.0388013981,
0.0010815059,
-0.1178101897,
-0.0217701513,
-0.0209078491,
0.0100502074,
-0.0015117615,
0.0157222021,
-0.0236936212,
-0.054147508,
0.0223629791,
0.0169298425,
0.0244916528,
0.0132617159,
0.0107030319,
-0.0012119093,
-0.0136035737,
-0.0158038791,
0.018112028,
-0.0184713304,
0.0479007773,
0.0266851895,
-0.0864033848,
-0.0432025194,
0.0250223447,
-0.0509602055,
0.0176131781,
-0.0048583425,
-0.0012279673,
0.0189306177,
0.0149928052,
0.068382673,
0.0472014509,
-0.0148692643,
0.0400405079,
-0.0233247261,
-0.0394228809,
-0.0261211712,
0.0263085812,
-0.0055977823,
-0.015648609,
-0.0118019022,
-0.0043452936,
0.0106920572,
0.0583156347,
-0.0132249705,
0.0397958383,
-0.0358555205,
-0.0005179229,
0.0238562543,
-0.0137929767,
-0.0364639424,
0.010622086,
0.0153749147,
0.0222485401,
-0.06186416,
-0.0563780293,
0.0311740302,
-0.0691662431,
-0.0267241783,
0.0222774744,
-0.0151612218,
-0.0398254581,
0.0678919405,
0.0279021505,
0.0211125147,
0.0067493604,
-0.0507080443,
-0.0189405233,
0.0160288922,
-0.013018379,
0.0041089216,
0.0693041757,
0.0032251698,
0.043508999,
-0.0149162402,
0.002094202,
-0.0317444094,
-0.0134254526,
-0.067599155,
-0.0448060408,
-0.055758141,
0.0030064231,
-0.0128294053,
0.0677432045,
0.0256808326,
0.0104601104,
0.0036648915,
-0.0033883739,
-0.0315040611,
0.0189253967,
0.0501271077,
0.0263157282,
-0.016636394,
-0.0367339067,
-0.0286773872,
0.0229021292,
-0.0060184384,
-0.0258427523,
-0.0268376488,
-0.0004043069,
-0.0022116825,
0.003452346,
0.0126734609,
-0.0234345924,
0.0629622117,
-0.033408124,
-0.0032701972,
0.0798894912,
-0.0048980382,
-0.0162320789,
-0.0086822109,
0.0295964405,
0.0276997816,
0.0358356051,
-0.0035274485,
-0.0814113319,
-0.0782135576,
0.0088124927,
-0.023279475,
0.0525476523,
-0.0296703447,
-0.012594115,
-0.1008882001,
0.0328937657,
-0.018579999,
-0.0702115595,
-0.0245482065,
-0.0238171723,
0.0062838867,
-0.0052160197,
-0.0100005064,
-0.0161967259,
-0.0252785366,
-0.0039928886,
-0.0049505518,
0.0291905329,
-0.0427191481,
-0.0031544331,
-0.084010601,
-0.0191346388,
0.030302519,
0.0155746844,
0.0174894985,
-0.0562425926,
0.0192894749,
-0.0111005986,
0.0020359734,
-0.0188344978,
0.0569956489,
-0.0784960389,
-0.0324745737,
-0.0248112809,
0.0110863112,
-0.0066545727,
-0.02551312,
-0.0099012684,
0.0580974743,
-0.0245406758,
0.0192371253,
-0.0220951103,
0.0103212288,
0.026373079,
0.0665855408,
0.0379765779,
-0.0319877788,
-0.0304383505,
0.010431543,
0.0278733578,
-0.039219074,
-0.0138322059,
-0.0005750751,
-0.050493259,
0.0181942824,
-0.0390067846,
-0.0097137149,
0.0591763221,
0.0509339646,
-0.0039536059,
0.0037994781,
0.029441284,
0.0040381416,
-0.0807032734,
0.0970559493,
-0.0280685648,
0.034882471,
-0.042537827,
0.0004083051,
0.0281469766,
-0.0047695749,
-0.0330197476,
0.0525267459,
-0.076868996,
-0.019966105,
-0.0413533375,
0.0210368671,
0.0117349438,
0.0201568026,
0.0086509623,
-0.0214651879,
0.0082775187,
0.0173462238,
-0.0264134519,
0.0359882303,
-0.0180746615,
0.0102798147,
-0.00082666,
0.0182299912,
-0.0467895307,
0.036644917,
0.031134529,
0.0563915335,
-0.0057325806,
-0.0260984469,
-0.0312236641,
0.0007517418,
0.07129962,
-0.0276741572,
0.0002729497,
-0.0563523807,
0.0035912327,
0.0559443384,
-0.0051348712,
-0.0670559928,
0.0156979784,
0.0058031199,
0.0298969261,
0.0133691104,
0.0306720063,
0.0183189735,
0.076393418,
-0.014361457,
0.0122005865,
-0.0137857432,
0.0086233523,
0.0009271667,
0.0027919542,
0.0071573448,
0.0443867408,
0.02826971,
0.0313104168,
-0.0134180104,
0.081601955,
0.0185906254,
-0.0258857403,
-0.0410408191,
0.0226491094,
-0.0011546914,
0.0263283085,
-0.0470431224,
0.0790534541,
0.0630421415,
0.0098883873,
0.0556438342,
0.0055600326,
-0.021819666,
0.0264711194,
0.0269963183,
-0.0382649451,
-0.0276530553,
0.0650894269,
0.0064382395,
-0.0296225846,
0.0159997996,
0.0280884746,
0.0114655504,
0.0445830822,
0.0301550832,
-0.0133557729,
-0.0380908325,
-0.0298466869,
0.0225221179,
-0.0002211883,
0.0069108605,
0.0556958094,
-0.0226232968,
-0.054414127,
0.0312432386,
-0.0302680898,
-0.069946155,
0.0203739516,
0.0270284452,
0.008559146,
0.0448128395,
-0.0315473452,
-0.0265392531,
0.0028605156,
-0.0238603521,
-0.0243894476,
-0.0128340358,
-6.313781462e-33,
-0.0655710101,
-0.0584702678,
0.0407673754,
-0.0285687428,
-0.0519824177,
0.0461017787,
-0.0347619578,
0.0097554782,
-0.0104680741,
0.0054360749,
0.0331705101,
-0.0118953744,
0.0200040545,
0.031138353,
-0.023051966,
-0.0179613493,
0.0319522135,
0.0264996868,
-0.0273300838,
0.0092135165,
0.0264320504,
0.0555528775,
0.0941858366,
-0.0932445899,
-0.007534266,
0.0199784711,
-0.0238741226,
0.0171191487,
0.0301145893,
0.069448106,
-0.0449439846,
0.0053812941,
0.0049389638,
-0.0267109144,
-0.0004194968,
0.0538587309,
-0.1375876069,
0.0293858908,
0.0010257936,
0.0365243144,
-0.0427208841,
0.0053311568,
0.0521250032,
-0.0268178284,
0.0294653121,
0.0065923906,
0.0397504233,
-0.0020007142,
0.0333004259,
-0.0034885965,
-0.077424407,
0.0323099047,
0.0155219343,
0.010928547,
0.0125429677,
-0.0096273953,
0.0434573852,
0.0272303876,
-0.0735439286,
-0.0111389821,
-0.0231770482,
-0.0499806739,
0.0614670254,
0.052805949,
-0.0042940532,
0.0630273521,
-0.0013384698,
-0.0284157619,
-0.0783188716,
-0.0021784524,
0.0534771718,
0.0638827235,
0.014545884,
0.0324740149,
0.0096321851,
0.0116645899,
-0.0630927682,
0.0118545964,
-0.0321428664,
0.05534463,
0.0039792159,
0.0044618663,
-0.0266852155,
0.0025300218,
0.0013216004,
-0.0356383473,
-0.0493439659,
-0.01410414,
0.0607573725,
0.0257869698,
-0.0597965159,
0.0792417228,
0.0887988508,
-0.0066172997,
-0.0355591439,
0.0252128597,
0.0306567345,
0.051720269,
0.0059808916,
-0.0065335426,
-0.0535782725,
-0.0380261838,
0.0507611111,
-0.0275553465,
0.0082863197,
-0.0093990155,
0.0463313684,
-0.0266448725,
-0.0521587916,
0.0106273033,
-0.0212695114,
0.0079411976,
-0.0440907218,
0.0443975143,
0.0426195189,
-0.0075837709,
-0.0503696725,
0.032030195,
0.0342682004,
-0.0102754422,
-0.0070342813,
-0.033649575,
0.0158266556,
0.0479403995,
-0.0097170053,
0.0066825817,
-0.0191484261,
-0.0466784127,
0.0206229351,
-0.0977448747,
-0.0092526022,
0.0233999845,
2.705e-7,
0.0391566828,
0.0172394682,
0.031816259,
-0.0088672955,
-0.0216594487,
0.0205886178,
0.0177292451,
0.0331856608,
-0.0232997052,
-0.0635888055,
-0.0110958181,
0.0352408104,
0.0219837073,
-0.0045029414,
-0.0341022871,
0.0133315725,
-0.0366987027,
-0.0193772819,
-0.0687087253,
0.0231154077,
0.0017659456,
0.058152657,
0.0011504259,
-0.0299748722,
0.0134709021,
-0.0685625449,
0.0701363608,
-0.0095576225,
0.0142235775,
-0.011046947,
0.0172078479,
0.0563794449,
-0.0433200635,
0.0166218746,
0.0273390599,
0.0023561765,
0.0704884231,
0.0348098986,
-0.0154233342,
0.0120386137,
-0.051077351,
-0.0167886093,
-0.0050663892,
-0.0264461674,
0.0715942457,
-0.057249736,
-0.0233001653,
-0.0305497181,
-0.0329592451,
-0.0218265764,
-0.0031182736,
0.001486016,
-0.0358874016,
0.0098002125,
0.0438316129,
-0.0247932225,
-0.0660053715,
-0.1073267013,
-0.0024461413,
0.0233898256,
-0.0138565917,
-0.0028317343,
-0.0346431844,
-0.0160129443,
0.0211178791,
-0.057785172,
-0.0495998934,
2.435472996e-34,
-0.0123678856,
-0.0083013903,
0.006244103,
0.0138579765,
0.0357016847,
0.0047600181,
-0.0765002742,
-0.0321403556,
-0.0359403417,
-0.0533869155,
0.0080535831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09977v1 | Fast Vocabulary Transfer for Language Model Compression | 2024-02-15T14:37:07 | 2024-02-15T14:37:07 | Leonidas Gee, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Paolo Torroni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Real-world business applications require a trade-off between language model
performance and size. We propose a new method for model compression that relies
on vocabulary transfer. We evaluate the method on various vertical domains and
downstream tasks. Our results indicate that vocabulary transfer can be
effectively used in combination with other compression techniques, yielding a
significant reduction in model size and inference time while marginally
compromising on performance. | [
-0.0243047979,
0.1167781502,
-0.0397788472,
0.042025283,
-0.053888265,
-0.0007026905,
0.0119818794,
0.0406204462,
-0.0549773276,
-0.0156305581,
-0.0121077765,
-0.0493835695,
0.0297536366,
0.0405121632,
0.0279207211,
-0.0137113761,
0.0357353315,
-0.0536273941,
-0.0284530167,
-0.0099260816,
-0.0319348089,
0.0138382176,
0.0425788052,
0.0127799511,
0.0086989133,
0.0103225121,
0.0114134848,
0.0103254039,
-0.0425878465,
0.0397497006,
-0.007927699,
0.0552616827,
0.0442823358,
0.0245351922,
0.0000019849,
-0.0160489604,
-0.0504373126,
0.0182688739,
-0.0519537143,
0.044442527,
0.0995417237,
-0.0251244567,
0.0068720337,
0.0286347531,
-0.0188488513,
-0.0133297229,
0.0608560964,
0.0118481712,
0.0258513875,
0.0249430947,
-0.0176081266,
-0.0121671706,
-0.0140236961,
-0.0428235307,
-0.0734477639,
-0.0636400208,
0.027546417,
0.0373711549,
-0.0310226195,
0.0021535472,
-0.038438417,
0.0567307994,
-0.0068551954,
0.0016406385,
-0.022296736,
-0.0010790442,
0.0382159986,
0.0106407916,
0.0117005352,
0.018966591,
-0.0205464568,
-0.0209518094,
-0.0238158982,
0.0103990277,
-0.0079942551,
0.0245069005,
-0.065799512,
0.0392025262,
0.0309270825,
0.0287719779,
0.0153271733,
-0.0242665708,
0.0246140119,
-0.0294807293,
-0.0284637045,
0.0322245061,
0.0508738458,
0.0064546559,
0.0009553182,
-0.0058670263,
-0.0142479409,
-0.0549709909,
-0.0020532238,
-0.0180925913,
0.0212303139,
0.018590074,
-0.065411754,
-0.0052584941,
-0.0139066037,
-0.0469132885,
0.0616297424,
0.0265663564,
0.0355187468,
0.01605835,
-0.0425545089,
0.0391100571,
0.0014210329,
-0.0159218535,
-0.0602650419,
-0.0513855517,
-0.0237263367,
0.0050507071,
-0.0706329942,
0.0222041514,
-0.0313589871,
-0.0240934938,
-0.0369512588,
-0.0022957386,
0.0150168817,
-0.023615418,
0.0079316655,
-0.0426184647,
-0.0319268852,
-0.0150695676,
0.0112677896,
0.038194824,
-0.0049611954,
0.0324231498,
-0.0100167347,
-0.0290815439,
-0.0199683085,
0.0101514664,
0.0030286543,
-0.0172993429,
-0.0168416109,
0.0519269258,
-0.0051175486,
-0.0191782769,
-0.0437557362,
0.0071088211,
0.0241714586,
-0.0336076245,
-0.0192790087,
-0.0754290968,
0.0342337862,
-0.0228871237,
0.0086134383,
-0.0797538757,
-0.0199702512,
0.0005193634,
-0.0652444512,
0.0668077022,
-0.0236360356,
0.0161432885,
0.0188843813,
-0.0115630962,
0.0433616862,
0.1000195965,
0.0190455113,
0.0039365906,
0.0429857299,
-0.0615178607,
-0.0384325832,
0.059017349,
0.0534704141,
0.0228513144,
-0.1028759331,
-0.032987874,
0.0287128147,
-0.0327384397,
0.0514341407,
0.0576086044,
-0.0275409631,
0.0072723064,
0.0357869007,
0.0753479972,
0.0278189257,
0.0416158698,
0.0240653697,
-0.0074901646,
-0.0411186442,
-0.0142870825,
-0.0187844466,
-0.0205360334,
-0.0244735312,
-0.0031279104,
0.0331367441,
0.0444248877,
-0.0139585268,
0.0098961694,
-0.0202482697,
-0.0258492082,
0.0589404516,
-0.0050806417,
0.0197394118,
0.0195417497,
-0.0033326845,
0.1288217455,
0.0479549505,
-0.04865757,
-0.021291757,
-0.0403825417,
-0.0525458641,
0.029461123,
0.0191878024,
0.0381570272,
-0.0119299442,
0.0090365186,
-0.0042039789,
0.0225531347,
0.0429380424,
-0.0262302235,
0.0178648867,
-0.0422326364,
-0.0100418245,
0.0221664738,
0.0211298447,
0.0175311547,
0.0341268145,
0.0412727892,
0.0508249253,
-0.0523819886,
-0.0231854897,
0.0050690179,
-0.0907288715,
-0.0199640524,
0.0186465923,
-0.0016931402,
0.0278061759,
-0.0303670987,
-0.0128955198,
-0.0136595024,
-0.0028436957,
-0.0517546982,
-0.014521881,
-0.0351641923,
-0.0198646504,
-0.0196826104,
0.0419622622,
0.0143417232,
0.0579199791,
0.0606264062,
-0.0219982956,
-0.0063747265,
0.0216058455,
-0.0239898562,
0.0465967357,
-0.032099627,
0.0396829844,
-0.0190755296,
0.0599602647,
-0.0102218268,
0.0224172082,
-0.0050408347,
0.0145511571,
-0.0103605557,
-0.008390869,
-0.0175573509,
0.010448657,
0.023645753,
0.0399336331,
-0.0165261533,
0.0115122097,
0.0448478162,
-0.0079309894,
0.0268660188,
0.0009168183,
-0.0651323497,
0.018960828,
0.01672264,
0.0317585729,
0.0240337923,
0.0471964851,
0.0072448705,
0.0175175965,
-0.041709844,
0.0477846228,
0.0037580633,
0.0492025763,
-0.0122090979,
-0.0122354068,
-0.0514798202,
-0.0277620088,
-0.0370566212,
0.0277798865,
0.0835409611,
-0.0602949485,
-0.0528749302,
-0.0704136863,
0.0528731272,
-0.0377804898,
0.0414380617,
0.0133071989,
-0.0376699641,
-0.0589638874,
-0.0149495956,
0.0186079945,
0.012585354,
0.0043918737,
0.013936298,
0.0727267191,
-0.0351581797,
-0.0510273837,
-0.0054235333,
-0.028367402,
-0.0390501842,
-0.0410276204,
-0.0779358149,
-0.0197370984,
0.0940327793,
-0.0173593499,
-0.0255718157,
-0.05661989,
-0.0392685346,
-0.0257078633,
0.0060155392,
-0.0270837396,
0.0054865531,
-0.00356789,
0.0568542816,
0.007730688,
-0.0404341072,
0.0239512101,
-0.0533400513,
0.0266025141,
-0.0182147771,
-0.0451157354,
-0.022238005,
0.048909612,
-0.0031840107,
0.036194995,
0.0114140091,
-0.0010455004,
-0.0353444256,
0.0081116753,
0.0128304614,
-0.0297730025,
0.0299541447,
-0.0573944412,
0.026709199,
-0.0229106657,
-0.0137787135,
-0.0104542272,
-0.0073042172,
-0.0079638921,
0.0550854467,
0.0790660307,
-0.0079419464,
-0.0288678482,
0.0437492207,
-0.017959265,
0.0407517031,
0.0212664362,
0.0046742838,
0.0059710653,
0.0160742421,
0.0573927835,
0.0318261273,
0.0384754241,
-0.0321243778,
0.000652444,
0.0283882003,
0.0053015053,
0.0260642339,
-0.0144076608,
-0.0232167877,
0.0502423123,
-0.015649762,
-0.0234704949,
0.0291919429,
-0.0025036864,
-0.0199136734,
-0.0104388148,
0.0887940302,
0.0037091617,
-0.0138078462,
0.0151333027,
-0.027772326,
0.0644081682,
0.000449749,
0.0609083287,
-0.0550281629,
-0.0284719374,
0.0356194004,
0.0086851167,
0.0469401442,
-0.0271964427,
-0.0605269149,
-0.1145223454,
0.0339849778,
0.0211214833,
-0.0261448752,
-0.0151614211,
-0.072401017,
0.0267579835,
-0.0095817018,
-0.0076495581,
-0.0023023589,
0.0021437309,
-0.0296746232,
0.0007698692,
-0.0193038154,
-0.0493063144,
0.0128229223,
0.0039763227,
0.0458666347,
0.0127515793,
0.0158289988,
0.0097820209,
-0.002436867,
0.0376138389,
0.0118647506,
-0.0138499998,
-0.0167550668,
0.037176542,
0.0218851231,
0.0065285242,
0.0779661536,
0.0063566952,
-0.0406374037,
-0.0089185666,
0.0153760137,
0.0715499893,
0.0543866642,
-0.0399764851,
0.0029950095,
-0.0036067676,
0.0170859285,
0.0709798262,
0.0376843959,
-0.0193664599,
0.0026755307,
-0.0036678866,
-0.0575439036,
0.0109388577,
-0.0592356734,
0.0078656804,
-0.0345272385,
-0.0917471126,
-0.0558135733,
0.0139529547,
0.0094151087,
0.0381744057,
0.0143585848,
0.0229285453,
0.0140983379,
-0.0014130821,
-0.0582373179,
-0.0318183079,
-0.0742382556,
0.0032775046,
-0.0552045852,
0.0235127229,
-0.0129619082,
0.0101614706,
-0.0276755858,
0.0169895235,
-0.108342059,
-0.0501906648,
-0.0056968736,
0.0156080127,
0.0110595543,
0.0532969162,
0.0169031918,
-0.0321047306,
0.0205867719,
0.0164645743,
-0.0501807407,
0.0505588576,
0.028397955,
-0.0576966368,
0.0148817915,
0.0799680054,
-0.0450977422,
0.0271543562,
-0.0012312478,
0.0290589146,
0.0048114965,
-0.0659204349,
-0.0061231698,
0.0635222718,
0.0169913303,
0.0014601678,
-0.0275226235,
0.0019180314,
0.0429526493,
-0.0378517397,
-0.0229781959,
-0.05998246,
0.0085775331,
0.0095148738,
0.0051680319,
0.0372451767,
-0.0183946434,
0.0371395685,
-0.0022653423,
0.0167118311,
-0.0206795298,
-0.0379171148,
0.0043299845,
0.0600565076,
0.0240382235,
-0.012899532,
-0.0562905744,
0.0105011268,
0.0427366011,
-0.0849336609,
-0.0005220529,
-0.0020313757,
0.0332968906,
-0.0485257506,
0.0038373235,
0.0159251615,
-0.0637867749,
-0.0278283004,
0.0050650183,
0.0133835692,
-0.0342406668,
0.0489079319,
-0.0616740845,
0.0066023101,
-0.037242908,
0.0327590071,
-0.0032948235,
-0.0106082531,
0.0063597462,
-0.0079698265,
-0.0064417212,
0.0073728911,
0.0904425979,
0.038631238,
0.0186945666,
-0.0338977054,
-0.0124973394,
-0.0286339447,
-0.0259493552,
0.025541503,
0.00038632,
0.0152928401,
0.0075574964,
-0.0280453097,
-0.0799625367,
-0.041892428,
-0.0510545708,
-0.0155763971,
0.0167053137,
0.0269327629,
0.0863344148,
0.0167240184,
0.0079159234,
-0.0483388826,
0.0041930648,
-0.0147737581,
-0.0240446292,
0.019749485,
-6.265437052e-33,
-0.0540196411,
0.0212234445,
0.0260257497,
-0.0279934257,
-0.031558942,
0.0233582575,
-0.0144086536,
-0.0068969629,
0.0104326643,
0.0149181355,
-0.0318761021,
0.0078629684,
0.0120865284,
0.0250828657,
-0.0076780827,
0.0501848236,
0.0573413558,
-0.0068361256,
-0.0263413433,
0.0316886045,
0.0433094874,
0.0305055007,
0.0546870194,
-0.0557024032,
-0.0330093056,
0.0340775289,
0.0310990177,
0.0033188502,
0.0599862635,
0.0118960543,
-0.0189374536,
0.0210383125,
-0.0082466677,
-0.0980138332,
-0.0365197472,
0.0108368145,
-0.0389969647,
-0.0315322988,
0.0559887663,
-0.0048686583,
-0.0102020148,
-0.041502703,
0.0202048607,
-0.0051969527,
0.024067143,
-0.0356561355,
-0.025958294,
-0.058903724,
-0.0426849499,
-0.0076986975,
-0.0880879238,
0.0217497051,
-0.0024406551,
-0.0024609687,
0.0926913321,
0.0264094975,
-0.0278809536,
-0.0221649725,
0.0320690162,
0.023253303,
0.0507193729,
0.1011313573,
0.0730473474,
-0.0043599885,
-0.0179411098,
0.0189563781,
-0.0262420122,
-0.0256706402,
0.0078709582,
0.0104350196,
0.0550612845,
0.0364452153,
0.0220369026,
0.0299951695,
0.0498078763,
-0.041881375,
-0.0536165051,
0.0200809762,
-0.0229232684,
0.0120866736,
0.0276221391,
0.0137548447,
-0.0193857346,
-0.0509829782,
-0.0362573117,
0.0166471731,
-0.0217486452,
-0.0366001017,
0.0210520364,
-0.0049301912,
-0.0454033054,
-0.0337111391,
0.0756114945,
-0.0631682649,
-0.0708400011,
0.028456144,
-0.0039944439,
-0.0295187756,
-0.0053222217,
0.0260380302,
-0.0368960947,
-0.0250537936,
-0.0178918112,
-0.0049373065,
0.0145360688,
-0.0092955763,
-0.0084362598,
0.0331497155,
-0.0644452572,
0.0012099446,
-0.0252101589,
-0.0086670164,
0.0172999632,
0.0448883735,
0.0361993685,
0.0038507106,
0.0274233185,
0.0303989649,
0.0362054631,
-0.0567835793,
0.0050275307,
0.0100937393,
0.0248667542,
0.0398240089,
-0.0367963128,
-0.0066394103,
-0.0569857173,
0.0035224687,
0.0646287128,
-0.0176429357,
-0.0349588171,
0.0139447777,
2.597e-7,
0.0268300157,
0.0548652112,
-0.0210324656,
0.0041209245,
0.0022050978,
0.0130833434,
0.0089326445,
0.0216529183,
-0.0016316328,
0.0224149358,
0.0110650416,
0.0373063609,
0.0555152968,
0.0468615815,
-0.0654998869,
-0.0140784783,
-0.0259985533,
0.0259014033,
-0.0160341002,
-0.0143981259,
0.0156414583,
0.0958022252,
0.0028535116,
-0.030231405,
-0.0179583225,
-0.0314102322,
0.0208827797,
-0.0488792434,
0.0154008288,
0.0457568169,
-0.0078512961,
0.0010631334,
-0.0197774619,
0.0181316491,
-0.0191845968,
0.03202812,
-0.010578041,
0.0616726205,
0.0087214084,
0.0249344967,
0.0163110383,
-0.0381269157,
-0.037988171,
-0.0453262329,
0.0415907316,
-0.0388242677,
-0.0274405796,
-0.0682330728,
-0.0066484348,
0.0054973401,
-0.0229378175,
0.0081463866,
0.0101195369,
0.0053775394,
0.026769843,
0.0111858295,
-0.0395584553,
-0.0502857976,
0.0020142531,
0.0089701861,
-0.0314850844,
-0.0370357223,
-0.0232940689,
-0.0116907181,
0.0124834618,
-0.0028765879,
0.052803997,
2.519037558e-34,
0.0193060264,
0.0170894191,
0.0081417905,
0.05989445,
0.0104390653,
-0.0540860668,
0.0150104724,
0.0327982344,
-0.0302736051,
-0.0776279718,
-0.0169603359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09967v1 | Case Study: Testing Model Capabilities in Some Reasoning Tasks | 2024-02-15T14:21:30 | 2024-02-15T14:21:30 | Min Zhang, Sato Takumi, Jack Zhang, Jun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in generating personalized content and
facilitating interactive dialogues, showcasing their remarkable aptitude for a
myriad of applications. However, their capabilities in reasoning and providing
explainable outputs, especially within the context of reasoning abilities,
remain areas for improvement. In this study, we delve into the reasoning
abilities of LLMs, highlighting the current challenges and limitations that
hinder their effectiveness in complex reasoning scenarios. | [
0.0330749787,
0.0479817055,
-0.0232118964,
0.0773553997,
-0.0455193147,
0.0138104111,
0.0349081047,
-0.0084840171,
0.0227210894,
-0.0296238437,
-0.0064559919,
-0.0144391451,
-0.010977787,
0.0264022499,
0.0107805608,
-0.0499555916,
0.0223989338,
-0.0671447143,
0.0207553897,
-0.0121315895,
-0.0131141748,
0.0339498818,
-0.0160419159,
0.0435641855,
0.0286612343,
-0.0392401032,
-0.0183788519,
-0.0062800618,
-0.0082082981,
-0.0255656447,
-0.0500319973,
0.0318520181,
0.009066687,
0.0293701533,
0.0000020357,
-0.0556499287,
-0.0040285764,
0.0067578061,
-0.0674919933,
0.0150474235,
0.010689578,
0.0385652594,
-0.0182684921,
0.0361610427,
-0.0270705651,
0.0385048538,
0.0246783067,
0.0509413108,
0.0543245189,
0.0593949333,
-0.0095552569,
-0.0377530679,
-0.0031164596,
-0.0008369285,
0.0286782887,
-0.0477119014,
0.0005961021,
0.0493306965,
0.0640923902,
-0.0030230107,
0.026019251,
0.0278296005,
0.0531946123,
-0.0513502173,
-0.0117279002,
0.0195024125,
-0.0065524117,
-0.026826648,
0.0218560286,
0.0491176397,
0.0287297517,
-0.0018032214,
-0.0213055275,
-0.0017692493,
-0.0021918903,
-0.0072500585,
-0.0363356806,
0.0419231206,
-0.005666092,
0.0173077099,
0.0116148498,
0.0012714171,
0.0536278412,
0.0220405143,
-0.0736335739,
0.1025473848,
0.0189712252,
0.0035842096,
-0.032582812,
-0.0105794491,
-0.0320597626,
-0.0562121421,
0.0094948448,
0.0727020949,
-0.0574000366,
0.0288868528,
-0.0020012695,
0.0412485301,
0.027196832,
-0.027819572,
0.0352525488,
0.0287720039,
0.0179927517,
0.0783006251,
-0.0187806934,
0.0490287952,
-0.0361294486,
0.0472009145,
-0.0186870657,
-0.0300045088,
-0.0773805752,
-0.0325988121,
-0.0028010027,
0.0265655499,
-0.0314288661,
-0.0075350557,
-0.0080039073,
0.0555346645,
-0.0121451756,
0.0285364706,
0.0142457401,
-0.0049000173,
0.0050281249,
-0.0468071066,
-0.0724528134,
0.0031410125,
-0.0434485562,
0.0049421173,
0.0201395638,
-0.0580195896,
0.0156793408,
0.0132268984,
-0.0062147737,
-0.0369437449,
-0.0209499579,
0.0782194361,
0.0119820284,
-0.002468002,
-0.0544123761,
-0.0605676025,
-0.0014226912,
-0.0986808911,
-0.0039752768,
-0.0497676171,
-0.0030722935,
0.034845192,
0.0046386779,
-0.0467761382,
0.0112905568,
-0.006666651,
-0.0008185172,
0.0827438012,
-0.0102718258,
0.0101240287,
0.0147314072,
0.0400058739,
0.0098477388,
0.0688810349,
0.0378044136,
0.0073134387,
0.02499507,
0.0096116457,
0.0146527784,
0.0153241903,
-0.0077590868,
-0.0082327165,
-0.039021004,
0.0385640152,
-0.0313228108,
0.032068789,
-0.0332418494,
0.0362228826,
-0.0178526677,
0.0053195939,
0.0579585992,
0.0469594039,
0.0119722337,
0.0251062792,
0.0328049585,
-0.0149583174,
0.0040483363,
-0.0082710003,
-0.0460444801,
0.0397106744,
-0.0207001753,
0.003234799,
0.0108495122,
0.0054459344,
-0.0203992184,
-0.0810019895,
-0.0356977694,
0.0012486812,
-0.0033788879,
0.0192742683,
0.035976246,
0.0079735583,
0.0026237788,
0.0605129302,
0.0156596601,
-0.0511079952,
-0.0079727927,
-0.0909082294,
0.0615744554,
0.0932218507,
0.0659522489,
-0.0245378856,
-0.0424215794,
0.0047631254,
-0.0095013194,
0.0339672901,
0.0513764769,
0.0040735942,
-0.0052382816,
-0.0338616483,
-0.0224153996,
-0.0393998623,
0.0204858296,
0.0172972362,
0.0176258571,
-0.0118729863,
0.0120223416,
-0.0322886109,
-0.0016602286,
0.0047729015,
-0.0683443174,
-0.0098057827,
-0.0206665043,
0.0088635618,
0.0162250176,
0.0238491725,
0.0199694503,
0.0348774455,
0.012991217,
-0.025888687,
-0.0206030589,
0.017343482,
-0.0255514439,
-0.0007732188,
0.0326466374,
-0.0083782692,
-0.0104767308,
0.0165790822,
-0.0032357757,
-0.0281375553,
0.0344644748,
-0.0334517136,
0.0453755073,
-0.0378087424,
0.0306827854,
-0.0130388113,
-0.0004846451,
-0.0166895296,
0.0672556534,
0.0077653038,
-0.0116909584,
0.0183874648,
0.0341932476,
0.0162302535,
-0.0489022285,
-0.0138985161,
0.0421276167,
0.0034998192,
-0.0120576927,
-0.0094257668,
-0.0127515122,
-0.0510659888,
-0.0306501798,
-0.0531005412,
-0.012069419,
0.0013235391,
0.0133493776,
0.0155408047,
0.0143423248,
0.0075500603,
0.009393272,
-0.0269730501,
-0.0120269312,
0.0379274748,
0.013064024,
0.0515556373,
0.0116560925,
-0.0468428843,
-0.025068162,
-0.0066250479,
-0.0285002701,
0.0721731484,
0.0186729748,
0.0354811363,
-0.054249838,
0.0117934365,
-0.0644218326,
0.0180117935,
0.006610339,
-0.0227985457,
0.0432603657,
-0.0214263443,
-0.000435372,
0.0673218891,
-0.0101359561,
0.0582001805,
0.0362456031,
-0.0100650955,
-0.0583686009,
0.0022971036,
-0.0226324685,
-0.0002077741,
-0.059784092,
-0.0288186427,
-0.0477437079,
0.0652473047,
-0.0066489768,
0.0041531292,
-0.0553809702,
0.0682400391,
0.0059244349,
-0.0080973329,
-0.0137194451,
-0.0239540115,
0.0113679832,
0.0894901529,
-0.0221223235,
-0.0279253684,
0.0663590431,
-0.0353695303,
0.0070127095,
-0.0194706302,
-0.0141693316,
-0.0552414432,
0.0967968106,
-0.0391836017,
0.0002360452,
-0.0057699052,
-0.0161982793,
-0.005283854,
-0.0440122522,
0.0250832364,
-0.0275548529,
0.037317697,
-0.0598148927,
-0.0084165437,
0.0073948926,
-0.024524197,
-0.0434995629,
-0.0015298836,
-0.0617950521,
0.0255786423,
0.0238333978,
-0.0162941422,
-0.0264292657,
0.0234809797,
0.0214829389,
-0.0091529768,
-0.020312177,
-0.0231877863,
-0.0414321311,
-0.0064511956,
0.0323184766,
0.0509399883,
0.0420631692,
-0.0504356511,
0.0744981095,
0.0453380086,
0.0114096059,
-0.0025856367,
-0.035911791,
0.0121825105,
0.0046861982,
-0.0223055296,
-0.0057082078,
-0.0007926968,
0.0620196089,
-0.0807088614,
-0.0173134003,
0.1389596462,
0.0435718969,
-0.0192899574,
0.0108922757,
-0.0461679772,
0.0332028009,
0.0383331217,
0.0427543372,
-0.064779371,
-0.0148990378,
0.0096452981,
-0.0098487856,
-0.0174509306,
-0.0244730152,
-0.0257667005,
-0.1159640178,
0.0631272271,
0.001692691,
0.0078608822,
-0.0290977508,
-0.0325618535,
-0.0045918757,
0.0090419333,
0.0268188342,
0.0256871302,
0.0237840507,
-0.0177164208,
0.0133558819,
-0.0233531836,
-0.0421843454,
0.0519188382,
-0.0217388794,
0.0411756486,
0.0465800464,
0.0471820422,
0.0267073885,
-0.0508483946,
0.020095937,
0.0292472523,
0.0228612553,
-0.0167018119,
0.0195115954,
0.0327938199,
-0.0076683541,
-0.0387737453,
0.0085054319,
-0.0220797043,
-0.0421505012,
0.0057771751,
0.1043979302,
-0.040715903,
-0.0150525011,
-0.0153753543,
0.0123443371,
-0.0319688208,
0.0763768479,
0.0443759374,
-0.020099245,
-0.054396715,
-0.0381985679,
-0.0503884219,
-0.0463788547,
-0.0455029048,
0.0189140216,
0.0522884578,
0.0024758871,
-0.0272144042,
-0.0252098124,
0.0269981697,
0.0413283147,
-0.0060874969,
-0.0054120589,
-0.013447349,
0.0004112311,
-0.0031343144,
0.0291261375,
-0.0565136112,
0.0226887837,
-0.0547881201,
0.0176931564,
0.0211797245,
-0.0705117807,
-0.0061001172,
-0.0422024168,
-0.0493839681,
-0.0639060885,
-0.0155340293,
0.0276978444,
0.0397722125,
0.035505455,
-0.0307624135,
-0.075983569,
0.0087672072,
-0.023641644,
-0.0402877741,
-0.0208642688,
0.0379100107,
0.024442289,
0.0231575314,
0.0468689092,
-0.0183635559,
0.0127544384,
-0.0145176342,
0.0109411664,
-0.0220179986,
-0.0583649836,
0.0203714166,
0.0363889895,
-0.0283818431,
0.0421579741,
-0.0243326202,
-0.0249290224,
0.0588057823,
-0.044325646,
-0.0253613088,
-0.0371266268,
0.0234184973,
0.0064304853,
-0.00738608,
0.0101105552,
-0.0682655647,
-0.029584296,
0.0342630185,
-0.0018371638,
0.0439345092,
-0.0003061987,
-0.0217096601,
0.0167598203,
-0.008182995,
-0.009854625,
0.0235031173,
-0.0362833925,
0.0455111265,
-0.0024114531,
0.0814741477,
-0.0014821006,
-0.0229710881,
-0.0406281874,
0.0042729592,
-0.0655259937,
-0.1046480164,
0.046745427,
0.0255051833,
0.0334013514,
0.0026262291,
0.0071020704,
-0.0336871371,
-0.0037249692,
0.0111993235,
0.0335675813,
0.0368167087,
-0.0414816253,
0.0283707157,
0.0375724807,
-0.0150273023,
-0.0182860401,
0.0360640921,
-0.0111874407,
0.0114068445,
0.004406218,
-0.0181652121,
-0.0363820978,
-0.0397194475,
0.0033157703,
0.0130158123,
-0.0075989272,
0.0136769433,
-0.0563886911,
-0.0869181305,
-0.0019815764,
0.0399927348,
-0.0299558491,
-0.0093262726,
-0.0212483406,
0.0646807477,
0.003388141,
-0.0294257291,
-0.0535373315,
-0.0193961207,
-0.0326476097,
0.018587023,
0.0168152656,
-6.15135202e-33,
-0.0374537818,
-0.0498584136,
0.0473326147,
-0.0407563671,
-0.0012398544,
-0.0455511883,
-0.0761817917,
0.013509661,
-0.0175598487,
0.0263399649,
-0.0252402443,
0.0197902471,
0.0082185585,
0.0199196059,
-0.0090121841,
-0.0197030753,
0.0290629063,
0.0324936919,
-0.0107674086,
0.0354670882,
0.0352672078,
-0.0148918675,
0.0076003843,
-0.064024061,
0.0358805805,
-0.0038336054,
-0.0172072072,
0.0381425284,
-0.0819064453,
0.0903580338,
-0.0115542617,
0.0032918695,
0.0219391324,
-0.0408267342,
-0.0000163646,
-0.0085053369,
-0.0345853381,
-0.0141215893,
0.050000336,
-0.0033173964,
-0.0467459112,
-0.0481582284,
0.0139744217,
-0.0099024167,
0.0100395316,
-0.0291603189,
0.0310400575,
-0.0425568447,
0.020382639,
0.0396940149,
-0.0498467349,
0.0309453942,
-0.0306254067,
-0.0095607312,
0.0205521844,
-0.005277345,
-0.0154397581,
0.0216679033,
-0.0134602347,
0.0170175266,
0.036071606,
0.0093070697,
0.0803445578,
-0.0003611082,
-0.0117170857,
0.0496917181,
0.0145305321,
0.0194549914,
-0.0445071235,
-0.0025087215,
-0.0093529141,
0.0767154992,
0.0756301284,
0.0232156347,
-0.0290953927,
0.0315773077,
-0.0478770584,
-0.0126756942,
-0.0014668542,
0.0230005756,
0.0712011307,
0.0197204966,
-0.0362858102,
0.0063538174,
-0.0473668613,
0.024421189,
-0.0524610281,
-0.0291493963,
0.0279164948,
-0.0397054031,
-0.0364900194,
-0.0241003577,
0.0106434999,
-0.056844566,
-0.0441550203,
0.0242013279,
0.0063408976,
-0.0014776988,
-0.0157597642,
0.0245630741,
-0.0110012377,
-0.0111361379,
-0.0082662012,
-0.0251072682,
0.0015194151,
0.0020294965,
0.0060606403,
-0.0011779568,
-0.0426974446,
-0.0191286057,
-0.0869225711,
0.0241577365,
-0.0007629172,
0.0303247217,
0.020536378,
0.003184384,
-0.0186398774,
0.0383194536,
0.0091176862,
-0.0087980963,
-0.0270170979,
0.019370269,
-0.0128387678,
0.0037528016,
-0.0146112777,
-0.0375988521,
-0.0504663624,
0.0237176977,
0.0241825804,
-0.0444401316,
-0.007710414,
0.0166195147,
2.608e-7,
0.0320406817,
0.0527333766,
-0.0008844275,
0.0331463516,
0.0355704539,
0.0281398911,
-0.0307582542,
-0.0495613851,
0.0238790065,
-0.0188252628,
0.0009696144,
0.0871210843,
0.0549653322,
0.0463311933,
-0.0406310596,
0.0098845875,
-0.0564331859,
-0.0244832635,
-0.0681205913,
0.000466908,
0.0662225261,
0.0839813575,
0.0294273105,
0.0004536865,
0.0146740479,
-0.0620814487,
0.0128588891,
-0.0365063064,
0.003149613,
0.0274682939,
0.0353998803,
-0.0047520297,
0.0289369803,
0.0205125455,
0.0141500495,
0.0142147494,
-0.0390141644,
0.0772230104,
-0.0032555333,
-0.0355783589,
-0.0258274842,
-0.0367357507,
0.0177987721,
-0.0686824843,
0.0961475447,
-0.0292512923,
-0.0590711646,
-0.0086709615,
0.028887881,
-0.0473151579,
-0.0120570464,
-0.0123653002,
0.0142540056,
0.0114158336,
-0.0120871719,
-0.0592909083,
0.026148729,
-0.0810512975,
-0.0254229531,
-0.019370513,
-0.0576337464,
-0.0377333052,
-0.0495024845,
0.0043397802,
0.039797388,
-0.0374876633,
0.0047954908,
2.535717868e-34,
0.0348860659,
0.0223212708,
0.0247137137,
0.0529696606,
0.0923420489,
0.0144485151,
-0.0026009937,
0.0105044516,
0.0495061651,
-0.0803252608,
-0.0100607742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09954v2 | Crafting a Good Prompt or Providing Exemplary Dialogues? A Study of In-Context Learning for Persona-based Dialogue Generation | 2024-02-15T14:03:33 | 2024-02-17T06:11:58 | Jiashu Pu, Yajing Wan, Yuru Zhang, Jing Chen, Ling Cheng, Qian Shao, Yongzhu Chang, Tangjie Lv, Rongsheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Previous in-context learning (ICL) research has focused on tasks such as
classification, machine translation, text2table, etc., while studies on whether
ICL can improve human-like dialogue generation are scarce. Our work fills this
gap by systematically investigating the ICL capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) in persona-based dialogue generation, conducting extensive
experiments on high-quality real human Chinese dialogue datasets. From
experimental results, we draw three conclusions: 1) adjusting prompt
instructions is the most direct, effective, and economical way to improve
generation quality; 2) randomly retrieving demonstrations (demos) achieves the
best results, possibly due to the greater diversity and the amount of effective
information; counter-intuitively, retrieving demos with a context identical to
the query performs the worst; 3) even when we destroy the multi-turn
associations and single-turn semantics in the demos, increasing the number of
demos still improves dialogue performance, proving that LLMs can learn from
corrupted dialogue demos. Previous explanations of the ICL mechanism, such as
$n$-gram induction head, cannot fully account for this phenomenon. | [
0.0340897255,
0.0747101456,
-0.0113727134,
0.0415567569,
-0.0320109278,
-0.0132461935,
0.0397685282,
-0.0071001672,
0.0110195642,
-0.0230998397,
-0.044049561,
-0.079346776,
0.0424336977,
-0.0031805213,
0.0534590408,
-0.0764699355,
0.0311155096,
-0.0053614164,
-0.0001532238,
-0.0054532513,
-0.0182417817,
-0.0028043231,
-0.0367877074,
0.0390027352,
-0.0248149373,
-0.0127037568,
-0.0299541075,
0.0315013193,
0.0384124257,
-0.0318527333,
0.0010280142,
0.0418354496,
0.022834396,
0.0144305546,
0.0000017896,
-0.0365571491,
0.0026958385,
-0.0203855187,
-0.0102483919,
0.0153646749,
0.0420289896,
0.0175132137,
-0.0066444725,
0.0395496488,
-0.0600514375,
-0.0209495965,
-0.0045499816,
0.0736066252,
0.0803972706,
0.0940625072,
-0.002518507,
-0.0158315003,
-0.0018515764,
-0.0471196398,
0.0184246302,
-0.0274895877,
-0.0087052342,
-0.0338571221,
0.0105429124,
0.0066719307,
-0.0140070952,
0.01040038,
0.0286607165,
-0.0207933579,
-0.0287026558,
0.0537590683,
-0.039190691,
0.0040328954,
0.001925341,
0.0863000229,
0.0431807898,
0.0216902737,
0.0022161661,
0.0111407097,
0.0520557575,
-0.0487108231,
-0.0297246762,
0.0459049046,
-0.0187695287,
-0.0064318064,
-0.003040002,
0.0093948767,
-0.004671419,
0.0224449653,
-0.0119116083,
0.0061849342,
0.0077452627,
-0.0288916659,
-0.0093135936,
-0.0046059885,
-0.0113478042,
-0.0403162278,
-0.0331309214,
0.0032423523,
-0.0976780802,
0.0367010459,
-0.0543607511,
0.0340179391,
0.0140626952,
0.0150248799,
0.019994393,
0.0426844321,
0.0206769556,
0.0004073646,
0.0169922449,
0.051274471,
-0.0016909948,
0.0259838142,
-0.0187190454,
0.0201411992,
-0.0429558866,
-0.014453914,
-0.0715528652,
0.0308866035,
-0.022558311,
-0.0358357616,
-0.0289081205,
0.037692599,
-0.0107962545,
0.0279565826,
-0.0331394933,
0.0080095315,
-0.0612635091,
0.0024929058,
-0.0336684585,
0.0199475586,
-0.0182576403,
0.0079929354,
0.0562195741,
-0.0546183325,
-0.025042342,
0.0234300829,
0.011389914,
0.0003310041,
-0.0127309514,
0.0421310514,
-0.0499848686,
-0.0465360098,
-0.005819527,
-0.0579192452,
-0.0412383266,
-0.0573940054,
-0.0335685387,
-0.0370933153,
0.028195722,
-0.0152690075,
-0.0023959016,
-0.0425279699,
0.0233430751,
0.0313909613,
-0.0035688207,
0.0244783126,
0.0368902907,
0.0323251672,
0.0452818461,
0.0242609624,
-0.0412619747,
0.0389425382,
0.0309728403,
0.0028157723,
0.0224636868,
0.0141749755,
-0.0044516521,
0.0265501272,
0.0367567539,
0.0162165631,
0.0040571513,
-0.0013770597,
0.0285860077,
0.0507385917,
0.0312847197,
0.082035467,
-0.0638828278,
0.0173802823,
0.0782504901,
-0.0012015111,
-0.0313585103,
0.0026477287,
0.0595936254,
0.0399382189,
0.0072587077,
0.0314135402,
-0.0353861898,
-0.0114425514,
0.0111565171,
0.018642107,
0.0461876504,
0.008678061,
-0.0335098654,
-0.0420854725,
0.0393351763,
0.0061306814,
-0.0075846193,
-0.007311631,
0.0004048316,
0.0447591729,
-0.0761974528,
0.0198805034,
0.0086012585,
-0.0491260551,
0.0103842765,
-0.0276939776,
0.002942696,
0.0477738678,
0.05256043,
0.0097792326,
-0.0239068698,
-0.0387783088,
0.0234312434,
0.0706299171,
0.0396720506,
-0.052858714,
0.0154243764,
-0.0446902327,
0.0094190231,
-0.0294771511,
0.0040453905,
0.0372754782,
0.0224051643,
-0.003882213,
0.0295451377,
0.0167100374,
0.0029723819,
0.0188231021,
-0.0635116622,
-0.0038832601,
0.0372813381,
0.0266490094,
0.0160127301,
0.0161434691,
-0.0122579569,
-0.0041934359,
0.0230878741,
-0.0263884589,
0.0127680879,
0.0302422661,
-0.0850865319,
-0.0926203728,
0.0144419027,
-0.0129479654,
-0.0142592974,
-0.0120551614,
-0.019248616,
-0.0390479267,
-0.0230173916,
-0.050935328,
0.0405118391,
-0.0311666261,
0.010264297,
0.0351886004,
0.0205645114,
-0.0293397103,
0.0695722923,
-0.0094009442,
-0.0023768288,
0.0845251307,
0.081157051,
-0.0059213624,
-0.0907148719,
0.0032563393,
-0.0140300151,
-0.0078002624,
0.021873014,
0.02273071,
0.0277569089,
-0.0609120056,
-0.0395141132,
-0.1164720207,
0.0181527883,
-0.0183591414,
-0.0183859617,
0.0165717788,
0.0040845573,
-0.0216721781,
-0.0038546284,
-0.059876442,
-0.0155302659,
0.0278662592,
-0.010772936,
0.0443239808,
0.0220271405,
-0.0161327366,
0.0084593398,
0.0317824744,
0.0147569375,
0.0476948097,
-0.027769275,
0.0135882171,
-0.0347692966,
0.0281567127,
0.002097683,
-0.0056547243,
-0.016381301,
-0.0252492968,
0.0381520949,
0.0265368223,
0.074957706,
0.0781371742,
0.0525198095,
0.0385686383,
-0.0323305205,
0.0004771767,
-0.0590086319,
0.0297257341,
0.0011571221,
0.0059607797,
-0.0256595723,
-0.031287998,
0.0301303547,
0.0060880617,
0.0465638451,
0.030627761,
-0.0620774701,
0.0338052697,
0.0212842226,
-0.0486069806,
0.00541043,
-0.0063467617,
-0.0404567458,
0.0001912289,
-0.0371961072,
-0.0322519541,
0.0495536104,
-0.0258685369,
-0.0150870783,
-0.0245902427,
0.0155758383,
-0.0241110697,
0.0449066311,
-0.0083392356,
0.0414453,
-0.0104415854,
-0.0423114076,
-0.0657318607,
0.0179649275,
-0.0001811417,
-0.0235366952,
0.0449410938,
-0.0391945317,
-0.0244400259,
-0.0015259319,
-0.0641648993,
-0.087343052,
-0.0540015474,
0.0299963206,
0.0035908809,
-0.0012179185,
-0.0093072029,
0.0041386606,
-0.0024201579,
0.0143206818,
0.0146615282,
-0.032538563,
-0.0100094704,
-0.024477588,
0.0024597945,
0.0223498344,
0.0246762112,
-0.0104359677,
-0.0616737045,
0.0809457526,
0.0222228896,
0.034592934,
0.0049234261,
-0.0027480971,
-0.0035555488,
-0.0022205224,
-0.0030590806,
-0.0365491621,
0.0403391682,
0.0705022141,
-0.0226435345,
-0.0530182533,
0.1087412089,
0.0120535819,
-0.0428229198,
-0.0031630276,
0.0473619401,
0.0479016937,
0.0030880745,
0.0113635669,
-0.0563460402,
-0.002738528,
0.003455291,
0.0455249883,
-0.0112680765,
-0.0266815163,
-0.0409846194,
-0.1612312496,
0.0655386448,
0.0286641717,
-0.084985882,
-0.0419858769,
-0.0213666968,
-0.0104017593,
0.0062078331,
0.0611529537,
0.0241518151,
-0.0068921116,
0.0181664471,
0.0256265476,
0.0160678308,
-0.0901767835,
-0.0276384689,
-0.0305017922,
0.0563519709,
0.0609352216,
0.0552702434,
0.0416859128,
-0.0032098512,
-0.0092381127,
0.0006558681,
0.005208455,
-0.006997122,
0.0766348317,
-0.0076951915,
-0.0134097086,
-0.0078874566,
0.0699549094,
-0.0249093566,
-0.0281647313,
0.0099719856,
-0.0065278262,
-0.0364788696,
0.016230898,
0.0119376751,
0.0279632695,
0.0477028564,
0.1005060226,
0.0226321183,
-0.0573324412,
0.015654061,
-0.0112513155,
0.0105143068,
-0.049713403,
0.0221750345,
0.0195658319,
-0.0143256616,
-0.0116869379,
-0.1078858003,
-0.0432092063,
0.0074083093,
0.0909564197,
-0.010538945,
-0.012815549,
-0.045328591,
0.0199936572,
-0.0071436269,
-0.0080758883,
-0.0398430899,
0.0188125707,
-0.0907151848,
-0.0472994782,
0.0364873707,
-0.066575259,
0.0024581468,
0.0106863575,
-0.0590087622,
-0.0687867403,
-0.0194175541,
0.036646165,
0.0177545138,
0.0966872126,
0.0212514419,
0.0041518644,
0.0301533267,
0.0478446707,
-0.0147968046,
0.010459858,
0.0102456892,
0.0349230692,
-0.0327728316,
0.0152260037,
-0.0021023829,
-0.0016785072,
0.0042427792,
0.0434448048,
-0.034421511,
-0.0885442942,
0.0378835239,
0.0038638932,
0.0187598169,
-0.0374457315,
-0.0122323381,
-0.0188129898,
0.0102461046,
-0.0320345871,
-0.0489534326,
-0.04196769,
-0.0226662904,
0.0323708393,
0.0092837242,
-0.0027274261,
-0.0121052712,
-0.0212371219,
0.0659731254,
-0.0128316842,
-0.0505906418,
-0.0028609987,
-0.0003940198,
0.0098620802,
0.0075659845,
-0.0172552951,
-0.001434767,
0.0004361568,
0.0537509359,
-0.002965939,
0.0946086794,
0.037452966,
-0.0079365922,
0.0155698722,
0.0226489585,
-0.0577000491,
-0.0173567627,
-0.0207182709,
0.0355389826,
0.0270553026,
-0.0032216776,
0.0246537495,
-0.0464422479,
0.0244964156,
-0.0218497068,
0.0323204808,
0.0025302228,
-0.0562735721,
0.0334220789,
0.0045831813,
-0.0185439568,
0.0147860022,
0.0720893666,
-0.0318614393,
0.0194943566,
0.002500939,
0.0203507766,
-0.0658308268,
-0.0349928848,
0.0524108261,
0.0192140155,
0.0005840518,
0.0012646409,
-0.0664388761,
-0.0286140107,
-0.0195121113,
0.0140538272,
-0.0057575884,
-0.00338144,
0.0374619029,
0.0336123481,
-0.0175039712,
0.0079543395,
-0.0507902764,
0.0024522678,
-0.0206206664,
-0.0292909741,
-0.0255948547,
-5.571870039e-33,
-0.0743973851,
-0.0233024415,
0.038056314,
-0.0089902682,
-0.0539998561,
-0.0289182495,
-0.0599432886,
0.0046597291,
0.0071708621,
0.0061392575,
-0.0197294764,
-0.0207090396,
0.0004069251,
0.0439361148,
-0.0334285684,
-0.0094591519,
0.0562484935,
0.0018974356,
-0.0521660596,
0.0617817454,
0.0228475183,
0.0147866039,
-0.0328565538,
-0.0370621346,
-0.0141465459,
-0.0358344503,
-0.0278425626,
0.019755967,
0.0004563185,
0.0494191721,
-0.0060592424,
0.0219874326,
0.0157245286,
-0.0222659688,
-0.0205719136,
0.0403747819,
-0.060810864,
-0.0056412164,
-0.0205531679,
0.0132176466,
-0.0146500273,
-0.039758686,
0.0014971668,
-0.0321877748,
0.0184272118,
0.0143566998,
0.0088526532,
-0.0153498137,
-0.0230526496,
-0.0212054644,
-0.0441319905,
0.0106009003,
-0.0099194255,
-0.0562242679,
-0.0328472108,
0.0447996445,
0.0073137009,
-0.0327598341,
-0.0332226641,
0.0386584438,
-0.0168333631,
-0.0004662402,
0.0230570715,
0.0373677872,
0.0050603435,
0.0534282364,
0.0245912094,
0.0403272174,
0.0274098311,
-0.0266856886,
0.0163022745,
0.0408595949,
-0.0244226195,
0.0850269198,
0.0063520651,
-0.0138981119,
-0.0544247515,
0.0555111393,
0.0365290605,
-0.0155615443,
0.01534684,
-0.0017821909,
-0.0260158461,
-0.0259522647,
-0.0277056359,
-0.0158928875,
0.0038900683,
-0.0421667956,
0.0344723947,
0.030093953,
-0.0322132669,
-0.0452905633,
0.0446921177,
-0.0418041572,
-0.0315751471,
0.0332891643,
-0.0657165125,
0.0001544817,
-0.0375202373,
0.0143460482,
-0.0562570393,
-0.0767330155,
0.0570884086,
0.0260017347,
0.0035285049,
0.0376731865,
0.0346184857,
0.0236556791,
-0.0645042583,
0.0099015292,
-0.0306758042,
0.0686540529,
-0.0070860106,
0.0015925299,
-0.0018570395,
-0.0004099715,
-0.0268509928,
0.0466656797,
0.0080632288,
-0.0304776914,
-0.0312817059,
-0.0040361551,
-0.0171859227,
-0.0175929908,
-0.0392760299,
0.025697615,
0.0034138944,
0.0148826018,
0.0365400612,
-0.0390114449,
-0.0187733565,
-0.0223789066,
2.522e-7,
-0.0317384228,
0.0257136449,
0.0335571766,
0.0556020178,
0.0280511212,
0.0380558334,
-0.0306866597,
0.0506147854,
0.0189686455,
-0.0205389503,
0.0487114005,
0.0224850513,
0.0740144029,
0.001563009,
-0.114304468,
-0.013863177,
-0.0285076164,
0.000274249,
-0.0413632095,
0.0045950124,
0.054050751,
0.0554135479,
-0.0140913315,
-0.0064833453,
0.0323057547,
-0.0007304341,
0.0876902491,
-0.0061470731,
-0.0317347758,
0.0409447886,
0.0233164728,
-0.0058423178,
0.0019687831,
0.0501666628,
-0.0085037202,
0.0413287431,
-0.0074594361,
0.0458839424,
0.0205748528,
-0.0407584198,
0.0045945914,
0.0095364703,
0.0235495884,
-0.0245386977,
0.041119501,
-0.0417982228,
-0.0090608969,
0.0026660941,
0.0004454673,
-0.0091949012,
0.0099129984,
-0.0261659436,
-0.0377420299,
0.0355470851,
0.0236924943,
-0.016254019,
0.0188930631,
-0.0562684797,
-0.0230999123,
-0.0166851636,
-0.065220207,
-0.0532644577,
-0.0045544622,
0.0317473039,
-0.0207408797,
-0.0355324931,
0.0032957094,
2.249302241e-34,
0.0130837876,
-0.0169804059,
0.0209036432,
0.0221302751,
0.0432602279,
-0.0158062056,
0.0305482093,
0.0135914283,
0.0368198007,
-0.053435605,
-0.0224903319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09949v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09949v2 | Multi-word Tokenization for Sequence Compression | 2024-02-15T13:52:23 | 2024-04-04T22:50:25 | Leonidas Gee, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Ernandes, Andrea Zugarini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models have proven highly successful at modelling a variety of
tasks. However, this comes at a steep computational cost that hinders wider
industrial uptake. In this paper, we present MWT: a Multi-Word Tokenizer that
goes beyond word boundaries by representing frequent multi-word expressions as
single tokens. MWTs produce a more compact and efficient tokenization that
yields two benefits: (1) Increase in performance due to a greater coverage of
input data given a fixed sequence length budget; (2) Faster and lighter
inference due to the ability to reduce the sequence length with negligible
drops in performance. Our results show that MWT is more robust across shorter
sequence lengths, thus allowing for major speedups via early sequence
truncation. | [
-0.0063479096,
0.0898096338,
-0.0112944962,
-0.031166276,
-0.0703353733,
-0.0270024054,
0.0377804711,
0.0457521863,
-0.0628782362,
-0.043941386,
0.0608909167,
-0.0157547817,
0.0201053526,
0.0344637334,
0.0647470281,
-0.0210641082,
0.0598902181,
-0.0225733947,
0.0155600095,
0.0328385085,
0.0003799063,
0.0052838754,
0.0441560149,
0.0737231597,
-0.0473724082,
-0.0001101597,
-0.0187415555,
-0.0123123312,
-0.0534479506,
-0.0121519128,
-0.0293831043,
0.0527308844,
0.0373242199,
0.016213635,
0.0000018544,
-0.0285496432,
-0.0525391549,
0.0074180881,
-0.006850482,
0.07473059,
0.0632071197,
-0.0417848714,
0.0171665866,
0.0361058228,
0.0018216864,
-0.0045808451,
0.0535453185,
0.0307640564,
0.0391320884,
0.0458280556,
-0.0140918288,
-0.010072018,
0.0011081122,
-0.0221245419,
-0.0315063521,
-0.0128405439,
0.0232372675,
-0.0394381545,
0.0263591744,
-0.031908039,
-0.0389140882,
0.0213410463,
0.000964998,
0.0252678301,
-0.0365502611,
0.0264923871,
-0.0667948797,
-0.0273703672,
-0.004747184,
0.021140676,
-0.0834006369,
-0.0295930021,
0.019382827,
0.0093548475,
0.0163410194,
-0.0431829058,
-0.0610072911,
0.0379867256,
0.0044501536,
0.0213177893,
-0.010507633,
-0.0020510647,
0.0297499262,
0.0005424464,
-0.0541315041,
0.0574860647,
0.0259257965,
-0.0248489529,
-0.059042424,
-0.0296392273,
-0.0099189533,
-0.0632842332,
0.0274912789,
-0.0080749122,
-0.0162807275,
0.0075071473,
-0.0739554912,
-0.0438412987,
0.0364234932,
-0.0246358998,
-0.0248154663,
0.0434395075,
0.0084165884,
-0.0002106469,
-0.0384931639,
0.0279494263,
0.0190732647,
-0.0190989226,
-0.0351762809,
-0.0099606356,
0.0019637528,
-0.0184721164,
-0.0632171407,
0.0441230685,
-0.0345384292,
-0.0403729118,
-0.0304625779,
-0.0109641422,
0.0252120439,
-0.0484663434,
0.0095587689,
-0.0091379676,
0.007953451,
0.0184611343,
0.0350194834,
0.0148043428,
-0.0295162853,
0.0219159834,
0.0282815453,
-0.0464136004,
-0.0497765727,
0.0447903723,
0.034638457,
-0.0045646438,
0.0061653224,
0.0758464113,
0.0053475648,
-0.0577404425,
0.0065857265,
-0.0476296991,
-0.0280469786,
0.0097282901,
-0.0199166909,
-0.0760123581,
0.0465205833,
-0.0004752727,
-0.0102214729,
-0.0122906798,
0.0030103973,
0.0260254573,
-0.0416717939,
0.0468007587,
-0.0085533503,
-0.0238943193,
-0.0037441121,
-0.0010852583,
0.0334472768,
0.0392500758,
0.0452956222,
0.0239195656,
0.0472238772,
-0.0393367447,
-0.0159273501,
0.0650814176,
0.0207201894,
-0.0322356336,
-0.0319037773,
-0.0370114483,
0.0221293326,
0.0206148457,
0.064838022,
0.0972741693,
-0.0564586595,
-0.012731405,
-0.0173238646,
0.0966420546,
0.009932044,
0.0290956236,
0.0610816479,
0.0279435683,
-0.0344031714,
-0.0044897092,
0.0124375038,
-0.0124086868,
0.0203304347,
0.0282838494,
0.1129367054,
0.0379374549,
0.0142270587,
-0.0021439791,
-0.0345662534,
-0.0342191495,
0.0441401601,
-0.0528831445,
0.0163917504,
-0.0212953556,
-0.0575722456,
0.0923789069,
0.023793852,
-0.0700016096,
-0.0229535997,
-0.0593794994,
-0.0247510411,
0.0329570435,
0.063945882,
0.0167059191,
0.0066485619,
-0.0186245739,
-0.0039680596,
0.0053812414,
0.0037763892,
0.006079508,
0.0217560828,
-0.0571311004,
0.013262284,
0.0283450875,
0.002893548,
0.0197003875,
0.0084475409,
0.0028620544,
0.0347079895,
-0.0275647119,
-0.0104772709,
0.0283357967,
0.0075601269,
-0.0082616722,
0.0375581607,
-0.0010256895,
0.0394809432,
0.0257690009,
-0.0012301208,
0.0595109947,
0.0483370386,
-0.0395002775,
-0.0229735076,
-0.0099544758,
-0.04131433,
-0.0431145392,
0.0555832349,
-0.0078330887,
0.0085459342,
0.01760187,
-0.0027939407,
-0.0574599728,
0.0279530846,
-0.0599416718,
0.0623848327,
-0.0253616069,
0.0192136168,
0.0207284801,
0.0565055683,
-0.0234134868,
0.0022262158,
-0.0072008804,
0.0337451063,
-0.0075010885,
-0.0287772827,
0.0015390627,
-0.0327215195,
-0.0274200514,
0.0077147367,
-0.0301380772,
-0.0055596209,
0.0376244336,
-0.0024160733,
0.0217675846,
0.0035335233,
-0.0926872417,
0.0035061194,
-0.0016844864,
0.0151954228,
-0.0350244343,
0.0492430665,
0.0078793298,
-0.0011288493,
-0.0151324999,
-0.0242737625,
0.0145795951,
0.0290211905,
0.0334072635,
-0.0056904168,
-0.0608112514,
-0.0320785306,
-0.0347224437,
-0.0219895616,
0.0756922364,
-0.0462529622,
-0.0514049269,
-0.0434690714,
-0.0260842331,
-0.0166174509,
0.0225773584,
0.0037410485,
-0.0385440104,
0.0039421902,
-0.0250400454,
0.0762367472,
0.0015864818,
0.0336646475,
0.0174675006,
0.0301149599,
-0.0077485694,
-0.0381348655,
0.0156199867,
0.0004125759,
0.0285119154,
0.016460022,
-0.0236676335,
0.0215841569,
0.076619409,
0.0201944597,
0.0026628762,
-0.0478466302,
-0.03331789,
0.0105487956,
-0.0294557251,
-0.0337702669,
-0.0336918868,
-0.0306860134,
0.000948356,
0.0164444204,
-0.0434299223,
0.0531410575,
-0.0680990592,
-0.0003492368,
-0.0051048868,
-0.0046365797,
-0.0342694074,
0.0546124838,
-0.0069095739,
0.0296474285,
0.0009874695,
-0.0404304117,
-0.008335175,
0.0370812863,
-0.0340767018,
-0.0323763043,
0.0130254487,
-0.053175047,
0.0038322282,
-0.0303317886,
-0.002727913,
0.0165343508,
-0.0382417515,
-0.0134382779,
0.041680634,
0.0747647136,
-0.0094734579,
-0.0624527782,
0.0675593615,
0.00117105,
0.0458420068,
0.0035455418,
0.0400243774,
0.0055836295,
0.0336717218,
0.0398955159,
-0.0067007244,
0.0177510269,
-0.0024156871,
-0.0037639712,
0.0444863476,
0.0326768644,
0.0284239277,
-0.0071884017,
-0.0043490743,
0.0137834884,
-0.0409920253,
-0.0286972485,
0.0389448814,
0.0330675207,
-0.0367887504,
-0.0004460395,
0.1348348409,
0.0321683176,
-0.0079552531,
0.0298973937,
0.0057619,
0.0368911438,
-0.0113342265,
0.006205162,
-0.077925764,
-0.0470088124,
0.0249400903,
0.0033474306,
-0.0031953643,
-0.0324212387,
-0.02068609,
-0.0949914902,
0.0132110761,
0.0116217211,
-0.0464968011,
-0.0035564899,
-0.0745810792,
-0.0330409519,
0.0159100872,
0.0282260962,
0.0306300428,
0.0098716589,
-0.006512891,
0.0283461921,
-0.0670038983,
-0.0146245388,
0.015239072,
-0.0111393156,
0.0463262014,
0.0196738187,
0.0128488652,
0.0027699771,
-0.0282837562,
0.0478108674,
0.0404117517,
0.0109570064,
-0.0307460334,
-0.011128529,
-0.0241654478,
0.0069757421,
0.0183244888,
0.0219858382,
-0.0339275301,
-0.0140719172,
-0.0167792607,
0.0676894337,
0.0407703109,
-0.0183099341,
-0.0453738347,
-0.0247630589,
-0.0225160066,
0.0666452125,
0.0431345142,
-0.0399310999,
-0.0513984524,
-0.0290761553,
-0.036724627,
-0.036899399,
-0.0085343933,
-0.0484684035,
-0.0199470446,
-0.0531213619,
-0.0431767739,
-0.0045686844,
0.0475241356,
0.0399075858,
-0.0533857495,
0.006643997,
-0.0109528415,
0.0202519633,
-0.0676950812,
-0.0231002681,
0.0031753187,
0.0196513794,
-0.0976753384,
0.0427958705,
0.0033454995,
0.0320732258,
-0.0284134895,
0.0506574772,
-0.0981225893,
-0.049185358,
-0.037731532,
0.0324307866,
0.0185867622,
0.017196279,
0.0089198546,
-0.0173120704,
0.0187692493,
0.0813283548,
-0.0652949885,
0.023149725,
0.0018055029,
-0.0246645138,
-0.0147559522,
0.0279251989,
-0.0304744914,
-0.0040530716,
-0.0501901843,
0.0723369718,
0.0222342741,
-0.0391264744,
0.0090727564,
0.0480850972,
0.0578009337,
-0.0305055194,
0.0117900874,
0.0389697105,
-0.0070244465,
-0.0424798615,
-0.0189370513,
-0.0251522139,
0.0426667444,
-0.0136300689,
0.0054752333,
-0.0116280392,
-0.0423992649,
-0.0069104331,
0.010831438,
0.0143249426,
0.0038340371,
-0.0419632196,
-0.010442473,
0.0253643412,
-0.0288971197,
-0.015458826,
-0.0427445732,
-0.019389499,
-0.0270434618,
-0.0729105845,
-0.037591394,
-0.0192041826,
0.045996774,
-0.0490778014,
0.0255184341,
-0.0215211026,
0.0050192508,
-0.0393704958,
0.0370875672,
0.0012166601,
-0.0042639095,
0.0291887671,
0.0057684532,
-0.0053001987,
-0.0181741826,
0.0483592786,
0.0033101435,
0.0015596385,
0.0168612506,
0.0110291298,
-0.0638547391,
-0.0240928177,
0.0951842368,
0.0339402929,
0.0281007756,
-0.0244651847,
-0.037241485,
-0.0396388061,
-0.0227459762,
0.0185708869,
0.0448887348,
-0.0097642858,
-0.0030586196,
-0.0414524786,
-0.0279455502,
0.0049712136,
0.0344670974,
0.0250145625,
0.0235808846,
0.0245607216,
0.0693177432,
0.010856227,
-0.0094075128,
-0.0090681864,
0.009301872,
0.0209813416,
-0.0518394895,
0.0076042931,
-5.888670909e-33,
-0.0161333494,
0.0082170451,
0.0110142492,
-0.0246517155,
-0.0156734511,
0.019669516,
-0.0109935394,
0.0054410468,
0.0428772718,
-0.0352759324,
-0.0277279168,
0.0015588024,
0.0072795213,
0.0113265328,
0.0320478752,
0.0512569323,
0.058068499,
-0.0079764519,
-0.0190259889,
-0.0061836326,
0.0390238538,
0.0291322954,
0.0356783383,
0.0403262153,
-0.0253480747,
0.0191482212,
0.0005456242,
-0.0410214663,
0.0459116399,
0.0592214093,
-0.0113465507,
0.0118669001,
0.0132853286,
-0.0251413807,
-0.0324663445,
0.0653801709,
-0.074171111,
-0.0065694489,
0.0346034914,
-0.0222085118,
-0.0090286508,
-0.0629598051,
0.0538469143,
0.0068314057,
-0.0124535467,
0.0139038004,
-0.0053229816,
-0.0102271615,
-0.0703557655,
-0.0502882265,
-0.0216200761,
0.0405277088,
-0.0180092528,
0.0091010546,
0.0286032613,
0.041540347,
-0.024348041,
0.0045353444,
-0.0074470742,
0.0314090028,
0.0020577598,
0.0776765272,
0.0619795173,
-0.0150484331,
0.0218468886,
0.0225317422,
0.0063268635,
-0.0355195776,
0.011852623,
0.0556555539,
0.0308586806,
0.0083258813,
0.0208159015,
0.0103846053,
0.0731607825,
-0.0393953137,
-0.0534601659,
0.0083191609,
0.0163562223,
0.0238029584,
0.0383051373,
0.0433815345,
-0.0236685667,
-0.0268271919,
-0.0125791132,
0.0056046811,
-0.0181270074,
-0.0307333991,
0.022695886,
0.0330939852,
-0.0317652225,
0.0106688924,
0.0618951507,
-0.0015757766,
-0.0356767252,
0.015049303,
-0.0023712942,
-0.0134724788,
-0.0121137192,
0.0159497503,
-0.0348859504,
-0.0233407486,
0.0404902883,
-0.00949925,
0.0283774957,
-0.0318249799,
0.0030960455,
0.0303015523,
-0.0867715329,
-0.0211327951,
-0.0161148887,
-0.0200247131,
-0.0012136897,
-0.0252979975,
0.0624901764,
0.0074434686,
0.0256695636,
0.0212350395,
-0.0122038862,
-0.0587835833,
-0.0072649131,
-0.01033998,
0.0289863609,
0.0201919824,
-0.0236713439,
-0.010021776,
-0.0418296866,
0.0214985274,
0.0565077476,
-0.0469161719,
-0.0398420617,
0.0307942145,
2.521e-7,
0.0203496441,
0.0622702539,
0.0661220104,
-0.0271561146,
0.0217823647,
-0.009907715,
0.0104069859,
0.0358038135,
-0.0519266315,
0.0458407886,
0.0053746002,
-0.0309943166,
0.0162814576,
-0.0038953803,
-0.0866783112,
0.0062875492,
-0.0839957595,
0.014979979,
-0.0805466622,
-0.0178977456,
0.0616327524,
0.1310435086,
-0.0146527365,
0.0086983219,
-0.0140259769,
-0.047253415,
0.014509121,
-0.0077919923,
-0.0135542816,
-0.0162724126,
0.0111014051,
-0.0120795369,
0.0108397398,
-0.0363214873,
-0.0253479313,
0.0271553006,
0.0436993204,
0.0806371644,
-0.0016588758,
0.017471049,
0.0454736426,
-0.0548733138,
-0.0215319376,
-0.0280898567,
0.0611900836,
0.0052171405,
-0.0073698699,
-0.06405323,
-0.0109970588,
0.0174994022,
-0.0335751735,
0.0043231975,
0.0048153815,
0.0431489646,
0.0294843186,
-0.0012107203,
0.010660423,
-0.0861557722,
-0.0327293873,
-0.0055445884,
-0.052867189,
-0.0013383459,
-0.0467749909,
0.0046596378,
0.0390834585,
-0.0247690305,
-0.0304685812,
2.741844706e-34,
0.0368700475,
-0.0289247353,
0.0039176554,
0.0508741885,
0.0297228619,
-0.0588363521,
-0.0123358313,
0.046888262,
-0.0071469364,
-0.0892105252,
-0.0626340881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09939v1 | Generative AI in the Construction Industry: A State-of-the-art Analysis | 2024-02-15T13:39:55 | 2024-02-15T13:39:55 | Ridwan Taiwo, Idris Temitope Bello, Sulemana Fatoama Abdulai, Abdul-Mugis Yussif, Babatunde Abiodun Salami, Abdullahi Saka, Tarek Zayed | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | The construction industry is a vital sector of the global economy, but it
faces many productivity challenges in various processes, such as design,
planning, procurement, inspection, and maintenance. Generative artificial
intelligence (AI), which can create novel and realistic data or content, such
as text, image, video, or code, based on some input or prior knowledge, offers
innovative and disruptive solutions to address these challenges. However, there
is a gap in the literature on the current state, opportunities, and challenges
of generative AI in the construction industry. This study aims to fill this gap
by providing a state-of-the-art analysis of generative AI in construction, with
three objectives: (1) to review and categorize the existing and emerging
generative AI opportunities and challenges in the construction industry; (2) to
propose a framework for construction firms to build customized generative AI
solutions using their own data, comprising steps such as data collection,
dataset curation, training custom large language model (LLM), model evaluation,
and deployment; and (3) to demonstrate the framework via a case study of
developing a generative model for querying contract documents. The results show
that retrieval augmented generation (RAG) improves the baseline LLM by 5.2,
9.4, and 4.8% in terms of quality, relevance, and reproducibility. This study
provides academics and construction professionals with a comprehensive analysis
and practical framework to guide the adoption of generative AI techniques to
enhance productivity, quality, safety, and sustainability across the
construction industry. | [
-0.0050102696,
0.1242524609,
-0.0423484705,
-0.0045829578,
-0.0308145005,
-0.0078170076,
0.000774837,
-0.0071206521,
-0.0333977304,
0.0038219632,
-0.0039203791,
0.00341607,
-0.0391571485,
0.042970486,
0.0104996031,
0.0052823224,
-0.0174924023,
0.0051998789,
-0.0232950337,
0.0168584026,
-0.0368966497,
0.0180755667,
-0.0032722447,
0.041670002,
-0.0761785656,
0.0230970308,
-0.037545599,
-0.0118768672,
-0.0010659284,
-0.0273709893,
-0.0132166324,
0.041310329,
0.0496691652,
0.0587724671,
0.0000020184,
-0.0375590846,
-0.0489568263,
0.0022857541,
-0.0062924661,
-0.018855311,
0.0437579155,
-0.0149596455,
-0.0420271978,
0.0138693629,
-0.0576288924,
-0.0016898973,
0.0539092422,
0.0372845083,
0.0011662847,
0.0429405123,
-0.0131950779,
-0.0723660737,
0.019640537,
-0.0360806249,
0.0085972408,
-0.0289359093,
0.0002083985,
0.0388328806,
0.032830283,
0.0334818959,
0.0096533876,
0.0187780801,
0.0261979513,
-0.0255480763,
0.0433129705,
0.0390270688,
-0.0097418521,
0.0225739758,
0.0003315577,
0.0227151643,
0.0261210334,
-0.0215154421,
0.0260843933,
-0.0329672024,
0.0132805081,
-0.007955323,
-0.0667851791,
0.0490624011,
0.0090196365,
0.0261107367,
-0.0283840802,
-0.0093830889,
-0.0075210421,
-0.0194620881,
-0.0180576239,
0.0122313835,
-0.0089996522,
-0.0188149232,
-0.0425202847,
0.0151536176,
0.046010334,
-0.0184392221,
-0.0148303546,
0.0495944247,
0.0041017318,
0.0214998778,
0.003843083,
-0.0393941104,
0.0510184616,
-0.0385893434,
0.0115584703,
0.0182781164,
-0.0193111189,
0.0378595926,
-0.0308557302,
0.0535439402,
-0.005440922,
0.0135027571,
-0.0456420407,
0.0130002713,
-0.0727525279,
-0.0252035148,
-0.0474278592,
0.0101883952,
-0.0494051799,
-0.0184509121,
-0.0069352225,
0.0659027249,
-0.0096925227,
0.0383362658,
0.0340783633,
0.06198119,
-0.0254134834,
-0.0173143465,
-0.0524074659,
-0.0721114427,
-0.0151234474,
0.027540531,
-0.0170275848,
-0.0378883258,
0.0149192335,
0.0247971546,
0.0280475449,
0.0181016661,
-0.0027689291,
0.0392942205,
-0.0029601881,
0.0003764657,
-0.060901206,
-0.0504682288,
0.0291264411,
-0.0076767798,
0.0177136343,
-0.0487684011,
-0.0008782678,
-0.0285241902,
-0.0547464527,
-0.0426780246,
0.0022990359,
0.0019735331,
0.0146210352,
0.018958794,
-0.0733065829,
0.0330828615,
0.0537604019,
-0.0116920397,
0.0378422998,
0.0457528494,
0.0295557845,
0.0913763568,
0.0190687682,
0.0094188433,
0.0554582663,
0.011198693,
-0.0241055414,
-0.0232763533,
-0.0024738538,
0.0165334512,
0.00217141,
-0.0106206099,
-0.0137714418,
-0.003922387,
-0.0059249578,
0.0476035513,
0.0403675586,
-0.0050318432,
0.0321949944,
0.0443632007,
0.0650429949,
0.0661306977,
-0.0086644553,
-0.066035524,
0.0331674516,
0.0190363955,
0.0203573555,
0.0241421815,
-0.0455746837,
0.0295252223,
-0.0127447229,
-0.0687523112,
0.0296396501,
-0.0052647041,
0.0002853085,
0.0179222673,
0.0709668845,
0.0438063815,
-0.0461379178,
-0.0523988046,
-0.0163088683,
-0.0389406383,
-0.0222679805,
-0.0463658422,
0.004386303,
0.082182847,
0.0446807444,
-0.0364312753,
-0.0247217584,
0.0146315889,
-0.0436711721,
0.0377590768,
0.0134796454,
-0.0219609216,
-0.0126943579,
-0.0369244367,
-0.0465194285,
-0.0454185754,
0.0102729797,
0.0116785187,
-0.011760354,
-0.0120718861,
0.0205974746,
-0.0373209119,
-0.0597749166,
0.0389821678,
-0.000462262,
-0.0638856739,
0.0066410443,
0.0080558946,
-0.0117670912,
0.0365468934,
-0.0184518546,
0.0012489002,
0.0886494294,
-0.0048368792,
-0.0864510164,
0.0253594667,
-0.0183581635,
0.0798951089,
-0.0143216513,
-0.0435523018,
0.0334378667,
-0.0239566825,
-0.0628965199,
-0.0327061675,
0.0015919028,
-0.024490634,
0.0564417876,
-0.0532699712,
0.0406153798,
-0.0222648252,
-0.0180203076,
-0.0734098181,
0.0693484321,
0.0199955851,
-0.0248844251,
-0.0017647044,
0.0188887864,
0.0631052852,
-0.0339790247,
-0.0230693948,
0.0359882973,
-0.0166044049,
0.0477378406,
0.0380795486,
0.0338974632,
-0.0100087859,
-0.0077660717,
-0.1085583568,
-0.041722957,
0.0030046862,
0.0168920457,
0.0179333277,
-0.0193842184,
-0.0341883637,
-0.0127705745,
-0.0248958226,
0.0056083156,
-0.0020910767,
-0.029705273,
0.0342622809,
-0.0065255049,
-0.0120779574,
-0.0180634577,
-0.0153328488,
0.0012659892,
0.0292352829,
0.0955376998,
0.0122319963,
-0.0637177452,
0.059912283,
0.0064766225,
-0.0107051339,
-0.0006985987,
-0.0353626683,
0.0329030268,
-0.006372117,
0.0459550135,
0.0001170958,
-0.0080289496,
0.0077093928,
0.0246793889,
-0.0307768155,
-0.0701313391,
0.0058218017,
-0.0453596339,
-0.0039480492,
0.0198120121,
-0.0134613207,
0.034210097,
-0.0144080175,
-0.0001483934,
0.0012196051,
-0.0103115207,
0.0546766035,
0.0149587356,
-0.0417647995,
0.0101097832,
-0.0256769285,
0.0142072877,
0.0801454931,
0.0240866654,
-0.0538138226,
-0.0042207805,
-0.0155952452,
0.023798788,
-0.0253971256,
-0.0066732997,
-0.0473721512,
0.079571709,
0.0201509949,
0.0106545985,
-0.0088878041,
-0.0105962269,
-0.0289628338,
0.0705570132,
0.0260425434,
-0.0109041147,
-0.0137849124,
-0.0347233228,
0.0001958109,
0.0176118109,
-0.0347637758,
-0.0736245364,
0.0424183719,
0.0004326245,
0.0208542962,
0.0721890628,
-0.0199741106,
-0.0256654192,
0.0308393408,
-0.0020298837,
0.027742289,
0.0169738736,
-0.0254268143,
-0.0220796037,
0.0044165906,
0.0220986865,
0.0379423425,
-0.0062078694,
0.0327852294,
-0.0446810685,
-0.0076150293,
0.011156844,
-0.0095148087,
-0.089370802,
-0.0017227582,
-0.0070240544,
-0.0178493951,
0.0253168195,
-0.0039875251,
-0.0527107008,
-0.0511344671,
0.0102755679,
0.0059293853,
0.0326901674,
-0.0022208742,
0.0070540681,
-0.0067153382,
-0.0113515351,
0.0039156559,
0.0141202034,
-0.0618135259,
0.0411160402,
0.0050195199,
0.0339530557,
-0.0205758847,
-0.0130629148,
0.0005460302,
-0.1147471517,
0.122159481,
-0.0336050466,
-0.0012773612,
-0.013557517,
-0.0266087689,
0.0105384784,
-0.0018397876,
-0.0703109726,
0.0176310968,
0.0042653182,
0.0081401728,
0.050566595,
-0.0042101583,
-0.056248039,
-0.0373225063,
-0.0142119005,
0.0335750766,
0.0935406834,
0.0198648721,
0.0261340681,
-0.0041453168,
0.0014850151,
0.0300343409,
0.0287730601,
-0.0110654235,
0.0296586938,
0.0464507453,
0.0136032235,
0.0126316324,
-0.004453355,
-0.0677736774,
-0.0108515779,
0.0449949801,
0.0710211545,
-0.0520082489,
0.0282230489,
-0.0775180086,
-0.031645406,
0.0255764723,
0.0051097395,
-0.0260809399,
-0.0169209801,
-0.0325300023,
-0.0275415443,
0.0161299016,
-0.0507097989,
-0.0018136109,
0.0134568615,
-0.0334060714,
-0.0343101099,
-0.0539654158,
-0.0455624498,
-0.001623565,
0.0234428812,
0.0152878175,
-0.0346914344,
0.0113057932,
-0.024226483,
-0.0632857308,
-0.0431091115,
-0.0047172485,
0.000956637,
-0.0203411169,
-0.015403077,
0.0383061208,
-0.107484825,
-0.0240352433,
-0.0166018661,
-0.0559209324,
0.0045581041,
0.0006633998,
0.0460500196,
0.0208145138,
-0.0250276793,
0.012234034,
-0.0086669074,
0.0336690433,
0.0639177412,
-0.0473136157,
-0.0283618718,
-0.0151316468,
0.0020191816,
-0.0126839951,
-0.0374783501,
-0.0293684024,
0.0558963008,
-0.0050599948,
0.032608103,
-0.0115157356,
0.0043840078,
0.0262081008,
0.0400950424,
-0.0474969298,
0.0088294465,
0.0181359127,
-0.035617508,
0.0228945799,
-0.0352196135,
0.0052618035,
-0.0254032612,
0.0351137519,
0.0135748191,
0.0043571875,
0.0292396992,
0.0559077188,
-0.0074457917,
0.0621844679,
-0.0373560898,
0.0064677834,
-0.0059078685,
0.0334636047,
0.0077629955,
0.0032445712,
0.0194723308,
0.0264960211,
0.0024433266,
0.0511326566,
0.0176560264,
0.0046693226,
0.0185178351,
0.0087579545,
-0.012555873,
0.0233026836,
-0.0128728841,
-0.0843722001,
-0.0369655751,
0.0236630552,
0.0363576822,
0.0441223644,
0.0116883479,
-0.0468378477,
0.0381496586,
-0.0085221902,
-0.0048775505,
0.0544851534,
-0.0387638137,
-0.0579922423,
0.019350253,
-0.0432910472,
-0.0232157372,
0.0603546798,
0.0119597847,
0.0028869873,
-0.0901661441,
-0.0292170551,
-0.0427516028,
-0.0381100439,
0.0448550656,
0.0169165563,
-0.0097218342,
-0.025863938,
-0.0534767136,
-0.0070791752,
-0.0118974606,
0.0232609212,
0.0162854996,
-0.0375578515,
0.0279849879,
0.1124150753,
-0.0121802343,
-0.0410249829,
-0.0183456149,
-0.0267297719,
-0.0194496084,
0.0100689679,
-0.0306683127,
-5.593805498e-33,
0.0188296977,
-0.0797398537,
0.0742637962,
-0.0101776151,
0.0131711755,
-0.0123057095,
0.0131600406,
-0.0375455283,
0.0115241259,
-0.0549309216,
-0.0448805727,
0.0149953216,
0.0158931147,
0.0237981528,
0.0777817592,
0.0389007106,
0.0679350868,
-0.0239723697,
-0.0136311669,
0.0319794044,
-0.0050604241,
0.0009884387,
0.0421669967,
-0.0902084857,
-0.0003589756,
-0.0219879746,
-0.0290348288,
-0.0186080653,
0.0504025221,
0.0494825244,
-0.0186662171,
0.0232612211,
0.0409780666,
-0.0368882641,
-0.0055787195,
0.0028103963,
-0.0700337738,
-0.0052504553,
-0.0379528366,
-0.0024854164,
-0.0006178481,
-0.0479380041,
0.0419178493,
-0.0119298613,
-0.0542504042,
0.0179868881,
0.066926375,
-0.0177282225,
0.0004321202,
-0.0535272919,
-0.1171721295,
0.0216774028,
-0.0107965237,
0.0220202822,
0.0226961877,
0.0126198865,
0.0312505104,
0.0476559438,
-0.0792782381,
0.0189842694,
0.0298566483,
-0.0183815081,
0.0922724828,
-0.0100866687,
0.006323142,
-0.006905925,
0.0436736345,
0.0184456035,
-0.0369588844,
-0.0359445736,
0.0236540474,
0.1148773134,
-0.0123929158,
0.0556677729,
0.0347454399,
-0.0201617628,
-0.0479797497,
0.0600237772,
-0.0239473023,
0.0571889468,
0.0700309873,
0.0147532048,
-0.0192125235,
0.007676153,
-0.0197282527,
-0.0132224513,
0.0076176552,
0.0101280669,
0.0255096685,
0.0477619991,
0.0018888746,
-0.0012399652,
-0.0047106049,
-0.0371299572,
0.0146739008,
0.0464318618,
-0.0653214306,
0.0098822638,
0.0070638619,
0.0276740231,
-0.0433413051,
-0.0152547853,
0.0390224047,
0.0501142107,
0.0058684619,
0.0034800717,
-0.0200876929,
0.0413715541,
-0.0195288174,
0.0184341259,
-0.0243406631,
0.0080120619,
-0.0041023623,
-0.0473069735,
0.0164144561,
-0.0000957642,
-0.0035392672,
-0.0103149582,
0.0332967006,
0.0538749173,
-0.0171117838,
-0.0285648033,
-0.0380115137,
-0.0004992461,
-0.0037210241,
0.014326049,
-0.0237241313,
-0.0286317766,
0.0641947836,
-0.055191353,
-0.0289281327,
0.0589553304,
2.771e-7,
0.0057001808,
0.0434443019,
0.0080619361,
0.0750463977,
-0.0129697621,
0.0254728124,
0.0236354414,
-0.0057907822,
-0.0067133936,
0.0421797857,
0.0643363222,
0.0141026927,
0.0115424236,
0.0140534807,
-0.0576273277,
-0.0104163466,
-0.0228189211,
-0.0413792245,
-0.1044645384,
0.0031537802,
0.0644801408,
0.029904658,
-0.0291274842,
-0.0363485664,
0.0373543426,
-0.038197387,
-0.0194758121,
-0.0081114825,
0.0202455651,
0.0470997281,
0.0337392576,
0.0345036425,
-0.0242995676,
-0.0209929645,
-0.0148729421,
0.0106792571,
0.0378295518,
-0.0137698418,
-0.004517402,
0.0072132125,
0.051212959,
-0.0667938888,
0.0177444201,
-0.0336276405,
0.0088540455,
-0.0148818316,
0.0160468929,
0.0245329291,
-0.0381550714,
0.0084156655,
-0.0305910762,
-0.0070369835,
0.0024015035,
-0.0257606469,
0.0067108972,
-0.0190689601,
-0.004729623,
-0.0219423659,
0.0839234963,
-0.0031419869,
-0.0736325309,
-0.0328357145,
-0.0186373033,
0.0026094087,
0.0052901311,
0.026462445,
0.0244903099,
2.119584144e-34,
-0.0017217352,
-0.0054161958,
-0.0383455195,
0.0242666714,
0.0555078201,
0.0280766953,
-0.0222768523,
0.0215107333,
-0.0149463182,
-0.0794138312,
-0.016925849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09934v1 | Paying Attention to Deflections: Mining Pragmatic Nuances for Whataboutism Detection in Online Discourse | 2024-02-15T13:34:19 | 2024-02-15T13:34:19 | Khiem Phi, Noushin Salek Faramarzi, Chenlu Wang, Ritwik Banerjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Whataboutism, a potent tool for disrupting narratives and sowing distrust,
remains under-explored in quantitative NLP research. Moreover, past work has
not distinguished its use as a strategy for misinformation and propaganda from
its use as a tool for pragmatic and semantic framing. We introduce new datasets
from Twitter and YouTube, revealing overlaps as well as distinctions between
whataboutism, propaganda, and the tu quoque fallacy. Furthermore, drawing on
recent work in linguistic semantics, we differentiate the `what about' lexical
construct from whataboutism. Our experiments bring to light unique challenges
in its accurate detection, prompting the introduction of a novel method using
attention weights for negative sample mining. We report significant
improvements of 4% and 10% over previous state-of-the-art methods in our
Twitter and YouTube collections, respectively. | [
0.0556126907,
0.0178601891,
-0.01758001,
0.026154168,
-0.0241522323,
0.0021994531,
-0.032663621,
0.025730269,
-0.0079955291,
-0.0728947818,
0.0007026013,
-0.018689692,
0.013494988,
0.0238613263,
0.0192498732,
-0.0263203513,
0.0175664239,
0.0692529529,
0.0451229438,
-0.0137489978,
0.0691818297,
0.0296293087,
-0.016588971,
0.0253958348,
-0.0085563762,
-0.0285978988,
0.0303108785,
0.0302093476,
0.0469157286,
-0.0066125672,
0.0328074917,
0.0187660474,
-0.026194619,
0.0318057276,
0.0000015457,
-0.029742578,
0.0194347613,
-0.0101816123,
0.0109614283,
0.0171399172,
0.0763038546,
-0.0108365472,
0.0149392951,
0.0427675396,
-0.0341017321,
0.0238784477,
0.0471138358,
0.0678635761,
0.058829926,
0.0836348161,
-0.0034394283,
0.0076757479,
-0.041117318,
-0.0191790275,
-0.0199808609,
-0.0239347853,
0.0280503016,
-0.0255126543,
-0.0253686942,
0.014208911,
-0.0170450341,
0.0236846227,
0.0079543618,
0.0102534434,
-0.082372956,
-0.0148473149,
-0.0299358554,
-0.0096101537,
0.0066039674,
0.0632648319,
0.0177119747,
-0.0346869119,
0.0229274202,
-0.0129709365,
0.0117189493,
0.0266386718,
-0.0251160227,
0.0189016201,
-0.0095083341,
0.0181850158,
0.0446347557,
0.0088382661,
0.0133611839,
0.032460507,
0.0471929386,
0.0040344265,
-0.027042577,
-0.0233782176,
0.0180396661,
-0.0238230024,
0.0084366594,
-0.0133982981,
0.0245930124,
-0.0136242956,
0.0418182053,
0.013128493,
-0.0455331765,
-0.0311535913,
0.045106072,
-0.1077430621,
-0.0296746399,
0.0078771263,
-0.0114323525,
0.044349093,
0.0219152495,
0.0120554203,
-0.0259953439,
0.0159801338,
0.0250457395,
0.0013776807,
-0.0450137891,
0.0203246772,
0.0079734689,
0.002647223,
-0.0019632226,
0.0368321836,
0.0081659993,
-0.0347771309,
-0.0802750066,
-0.024512982,
-0.0447484925,
0.0192904901,
0.0189605728,
-0.0125496937,
-0.0301197171,
0.0740112364,
-0.0686022118,
0.0255317967,
-0.0423002355,
-0.0774766654,
-0.021186728,
0.0437736586,
-0.0209709015,
0.0013693202,
-0.0225997232,
0.0446582697,
0.0169550795,
0.0024492934,
0.0093469359,
-0.0501145162,
-0.0411635786,
-0.0095106261,
0.0045529194,
-0.0580320954,
0.0054782731,
0.0048644147,
-0.0054495651,
-0.0730748922,
0.029627705,
0.0384801477,
-0.0427657142,
0.0259515364,
0.0695541576,
-0.0000988698,
0.0276789069,
0.0313142203,
-0.0291171782,
0.0827429518,
-0.0206640717,
0.0145207336,
0.0482130572,
0.0276338682,
0.0174604896,
0.0335971713,
0.0542895757,
0.0272720475,
-0.0474471711,
0.0324941054,
-0.048419062,
-0.0337379836,
0.0293958224,
0.0241004582,
-0.0118013881,
-0.0737316161,
0.0452941395,
0.0194998905,
-0.0652729496,
-0.0054955552,
-0.0044292789,
0.0721170604,
-0.01141275,
0.0069468054,
-0.0144065302,
0.0120013291,
-0.0395805538,
-0.0630327761,
0.0153309405,
0.0451742448,
-0.0299089365,
-0.0184311476,
-0.0162041225,
0.0227215234,
0.0435779765,
-0.0452320389,
0.0132857887,
0.0243146997,
-0.0390190259,
0.0670020282,
0.0767730549,
-0.0078933742,
0.0007052939,
-0.0247387644,
0.013141714,
0.010055243,
0.0228597783,
0.0033457575,
0.0029647753,
-0.0530065335,
0.0610930473,
0.0820849687,
0.0327209122,
-0.0258231238,
-0.0174945295,
0.0091891559,
-0.0237966143,
-0.0344812982,
0.0016705631,
0.0037678091,
0.0531644933,
0.0136284279,
0.0117844362,
-0.0201654937,
-0.0665661842,
0.0194494352,
0.0433671437,
-0.0029570339,
-0.0079365717,
0.0299438797,
0.0439250208,
0.0337324776,
0.0025487647,
-0.034417998,
0.0403239205,
-0.0194036365,
-0.021351248,
0.0047814469,
0.0204318203,
-0.0242353715,
0.0232376009,
-0.0779823661,
-0.0273446105,
0.0220545698,
-0.0188210849,
0.0150032938,
0.087911211,
-0.0458733141,
0.043526426,
-0.0251985509,
-0.0074609146,
-0.0338897109,
0.0065989126,
-0.0207702126,
0.1012205705,
-0.0479605533,
0.0357657932,
-0.0200322904,
-0.0395301431,
-0.0001484948,
0.0174021125,
0.0091845328,
-0.0014416655,
-0.0125822593,
0.001808383,
0.0385310613,
-0.0384006649,
-0.0733838752,
0.0007314277,
-0.0200462434,
0.0027738183,
-0.033451777,
0.0105475597,
0.0735218897,
-0.023377521,
0.0052667363,
-0.0008033447,
-0.0109395748,
-0.0838525221,
-0.0512891002,
0.0108300475,
0.0082711428,
0.0085973153,
0.0178625956,
-0.0053505548,
0.0140734278,
-0.0268225856,
0.0074451305,
0.0012663987,
-0.0057702605,
0.00909229,
-0.0105550168,
-0.0280575193,
-0.0181258265,
-0.0426689424,
-0.0489102416,
0.0283635855,
0.0544798039,
-0.0140823498,
0.0072447904,
0.0340947546,
0.0521638654,
0.0146290511,
0.028166648,
-0.0310444646,
-0.010057929,
-0.0186034869,
-0.0095376866,
-0.0113719422,
-0.0677223951,
-0.0051197675,
0.0491352379,
0.0264794677,
0.0291621592,
-0.0730611086,
0.020999169,
-0.049751047,
-0.0210304428,
0.0020587295,
0.0243490227,
-0.033759743,
-0.0030653938,
-0.0490365699,
-0.0025745193,
0.0659722611,
0.013206658,
0.0132999681,
-0.0186751448,
-0.0139735965,
0.0121044964,
0.0186582562,
-0.0010331377,
0.0212152991,
0.0369316153,
-0.0300710183,
-0.0142118819,
-0.0583709106,
0.0226029232,
-0.005601468,
0.0128516238,
-0.0097024459,
-0.0060727536,
0.0187315922,
-0.0106925126,
-0.0540133379,
-0.1304163933,
-0.0070095952,
-0.0645361245,
-0.0496808849,
-0.0361785814,
-0.0386573002,
0.0050475337,
0.0296625011,
-0.0362564884,
-0.0088504003,
0.0177273192,
0.0280688927,
0.0226166286,
0.0396099836,
0.0297356509,
0.0246340297,
0.0002339896,
-0.0123363091,
0.0737434924,
0.0082381992,
0.0083093913,
0.0310267508,
-0.0783198997,
0.0015461779,
-0.0099699441,
-0.0009917355,
0.0074407337,
0.0499043912,
-0.0319150947,
0.0186471958,
0.0809183493,
0.038182985,
-0.0015274599,
-0.0013639906,
0.0149210067,
-0.0008617382,
0.0360919684,
-0.0342057161,
-0.0787644684,
-0.0409018211,
-0.030652212,
0.0368066505,
-0.0484515466,
-0.0289006401,
-0.0184921157,
-0.1017031223,
-0.0187467039,
-0.0165899545,
0.0026764129,
-0.005274056,
-0.0762669742,
0.0323538929,
-0.0017896449,
-0.030853942,
-0.0081743347,
0.0036711039,
0.0093596317,
-0.0064196102,
-0.0453117192,
-0.0300942808,
0.0249129031,
0.0084044673,
0.0203988161,
0.0198781192,
0.068812117,
-0.0341053195,
-0.0284717157,
0.0092346212,
-0.0622403994,
-0.0433184803,
-0.0339773707,
0.0835849419,
-0.0029453794,
-0.0315646268,
-0.0138930846,
0.0527045801,
-0.0511156321,
0.0038542191,
-0.0161886532,
0.0600049719,
0.0128158145,
-0.0167346764,
-0.028152233,
0.0296467524,
0.053748142,
0.0797046572,
0.034611553,
-0.0238914918,
0.0012611367,
-0.0400202088,
-0.0137294,
-0.033644177,
-0.037947841,
-0.0109585226,
0.0172971766,
-0.0352529697,
-0.0499103963,
-0.0708869249,
0.0064505762,
-0.0064183646,
0.0204032212,
-0.009021299,
0.0366235338,
-0.0094768554,
-0.0528271385,
0.0111361677,
-0.0158435106,
0.024228828,
-0.0101138698,
-0.0410846956,
-0.0013467519,
0.0198501833,
-0.0077165859,
0.0585089326,
-0.0564920902,
-0.0539906062,
0.007731088,
0.0029477917,
0.0126837837,
0.0260624103,
-0.036141552,
-0.0025720079,
0.0264587663,
0.0445076674,
-0.0272136386,
0.021223072,
0.0422877744,
-0.0290633179,
0.0275854766,
0.0578940734,
0.004554613,
-0.0112656774,
0.032232549,
-0.0048772339,
-0.1058650389,
0.0336154997,
0.0066806925,
-0.0422181487,
0.0555159412,
0.0098647336,
-0.0553447045,
-0.0400759131,
-0.0394667946,
-0.0140497833,
-0.0311324634,
0.0097890757,
0.004569205,
0.012913161,
0.0095185041,
-0.0141430795,
0.0327088162,
-0.068962194,
0.034813799,
-0.0044878586,
0.0282947272,
0.0206424184,
0.0343376398,
-0.0305525512,
0.0035289354,
-0.0157896541,
0.0031895963,
0.0211319663,
0.0176136568,
0.0080107795,
0.0335727483,
0.0256391373,
-0.0017017931,
0.0470038652,
-0.0270650275,
-0.0159115065,
-0.0074075656,
0.0330132395,
0.0077372454,
-0.0180975217,
-0.058013007,
0.051649075,
0.0480420925,
-0.0216816738,
-0.010124634,
0.0063699875,
-0.0452517681,
-0.0520424768,
0.0241895467,
0.0294176247,
-0.0496981367,
0.0173040647,
0.0508176349,
-0.0374947339,
0.0294471942,
0.0666510388,
-0.0476467721,
-0.0054641352,
-0.0567350909,
-0.0171894282,
0.0705672652,
0.0153107094,
0.0550510436,
-0.107505478,
-0.0436357632,
0.004570188,
-0.0274606869,
0.0032560246,
-0.0060127354,
0.0154510457,
0.0407436788,
0.0060832417,
0.0294819418,
-0.0485801063,
0.0002092569,
-0.0154013066,
-0.017109625,
-0.0294681527,
-6.11287111e-33,
0.00774576,
-0.0862781107,
-0.0514237247,
0.0168634616,
0.0164338965,
0.0185832419,
-0.0031173178,
0.0028994768,
-0.0404108353,
0.0540377721,
0.0295190457,
0.0838227198,
-0.0056093056,
0.0125957429,
-0.0135736531,
-0.0420238152,
0.0264239609,
0.0029049483,
-0.0443595387,
0.0065731741,
0.0853364021,
-0.01194249,
0.0400147289,
-0.0751595646,
0.0622328594,
-0.0264491085,
-0.0226183608,
0.0029787607,
0.0429532081,
0.0413341224,
-0.0003288251,
0.0888719112,
0.038763497,
-0.0083342185,
0.025213141,
0.0275697503,
-0.0418665931,
-0.058876235,
0.075133048,
-0.0045904764,
0.0010388861,
0.0018250612,
0.0312664211,
0.015235126,
-0.0275332499,
0.0270976368,
0.0520065054,
-0.0098593719,
0.0311763082,
0.0408935547,
-0.0516910292,
0.0163125433,
-0.0426953174,
-0.0096919043,
-0.0288156681,
0.0372796692,
0.036415834,
0.0365026966,
-0.081644699,
0.0293818414,
-0.0522520393,
-0.0038490654,
0.0096449349,
-0.0130529609,
0.0192285702,
0.088639535,
-0.0160991754,
0.0380692296,
0.0227566604,
-0.0170391239,
-0.0268402901,
-0.0061230082,
0.0363872908,
0.0898252651,
0.0307619926,
-0.0355687439,
-0.0642561913,
-0.0194705743,
0.0373915881,
0.0504201427,
0.0179069806,
-0.0502154157,
-0.0622391552,
-0.008756659,
-0.0017529222,
-0.0574890375,
-0.0210614428,
-0.0182979684,
-0.0267840587,
-0.0025451051,
-0.0195861384,
0.0332695879,
0.0048623178,
-0.0270582251,
0.0487182625,
0.0379373394,
-0.0302098226,
-0.0214252137,
0.0664697364,
0.0532711707,
-0.0562596694,
0.0337665416,
-0.0024284653,
-0.0234798063,
0.0244122632,
-0.021763958,
0.0561847389,
0.0166834164,
-0.0743088722,
-0.0007292126,
-0.0021138927,
0.0436613038,
-0.0928206891,
0.0063887881,
0.0394856781,
0.0583081841,
-0.0299562979,
-0.0158491563,
0.0549215637,
-0.0108369784,
-0.0145379435,
0.0046567325,
-0.0304132383,
-0.0016142558,
-0.0506081916,
-0.0583679229,
-0.0100254482,
0.0293733217,
0.0474227965,
-0.0808327347,
-0.0207590368,
-0.05166642,
2.474e-7,
0.0355009288,
0.0251177829,
-0.0131631773,
-0.0048877355,
0.0428936481,
0.0621944033,
0.0179100987,
0.0221725702,
-0.0332382098,
-0.0732108876,
-0.0395670868,
0.0253796708,
0.0198265854,
0.0164742954,
-0.0632575899,
0.0414315425,
-0.0189444255,
0.0061115073,
-0.0172148254,
0.0007318797,
0.0309559666,
0.0734492913,
0.0631265417,
0.0037634354,
-0.0475753695,
-0.0236935653,
0.0538835898,
-0.006901375,
-0.0365967304,
-0.0086459881,
0.0095867561,
-0.0112945344,
-0.0036633422,
0.0084468657,
-0.0123699699,
0.030723067,
0.0094809672,
0.0439102538,
0.027022263,
-0.0705739409,
-0.0442549698,
-0.0348460898,
-0.0066808318,
-0.0303838961,
0.032010138,
-0.0299442448,
-0.05370887,
-0.0510279611,
-0.0139971487,
0.0214056596,
0.0190912224,
-0.007512616,
-0.0443956144,
-0.0250623766,
-0.0156642199,
-0.0080434959,
0.0042148917,
-0.0524020232,
-0.0099357469,
-0.0045012548,
-0.0143652689,
-0.0162285864,
0.0087306425,
-0.0304486528,
0.0468931124,
0.014092111,
0.0388686582,
2.063879257e-34,
0.0385387167,
-0.0115640918,
-0.0071293591,
-0.0346849486,
0.0283714067,
0.0046789753,
-0.014069315,
-0.0156638231,
0.0345576964,
0.0031049077,
0.0085740127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09923v1 | A Dataset of Open-Domain Question Answering with Multiple-Span Answers | 2024-02-15T13:03:57 | 2024-02-15T13:03:57 | Zhiyi Luo, Yingying Zhang, Shuyun Luo, Ying Zhao, Wentao Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multi-span answer extraction, also known as the task of multi-span question
answering (MSQA), is critical for real-world applications, as it requires
extracting multiple pieces of information from a text to answer complex
questions. Despite the active studies and rapid progress in English MSQA
research, there is a notable lack of publicly available MSQA benchmark in
Chinese. Previous efforts for constructing MSQA datasets predominantly
emphasized entity-centric contextualization, resulting in a bias towards
collecting factoid questions and potentially overlooking questions requiring
more detailed descriptive responses. To overcome these limitations, we present
CLEAN, a comprehensive Chinese multi-span question answering dataset that
involves a wide range of open-domain subjects with a substantial number of
instances requiring descriptive answers. Additionally, we provide established
models from relevant literature as baselines for CLEAN. Experimental results
and analysis show the characteristics and challenge of the newly proposed CLEAN
dataset for the community. Our dataset, CLEAN, will be publicly released at
zhiyiluo.site/misc/clean_v1.0_ sample.json. | [
0.0296675693,
0.0546758994,
0.0201520827,
0.0525274128,
0.014384008,
0.0074763661,
0.017151894,
-0.0057616234,
0.0049656476,
-0.0031772773,
-0.0110780597,
-0.0468784831,
-0.0283440296,
0.0026543983,
0.007181013,
-0.0492441282,
-0.0006430756,
0.024401933,
0.0113323368,
-0.007966673,
0.0223252475,
0.0391816236,
0.0052805231,
0.0099608134,
0.0292259157,
-0.0509145297,
0.0014541557,
0.003686303,
0.0464069024,
-0.022385193,
0.0509181023,
0.0618235469,
0.0122663369,
-0.0381497294,
0.0000017833,
-0.0529959686,
-0.0284779277,
-0.0092266165,
-0.0325599872,
0.0216824822,
-0.0196780916,
0.0212059766,
0.0526444577,
0.0074776728,
-0.0405286849,
-0.023899693,
-0.0042458223,
0.0749546736,
0.0643129796,
0.0140458886,
0.0045024902,
-0.0100943353,
0.0056575416,
0.0010637932,
0.0096045574,
-0.0533479452,
0.0264145248,
0.0076607522,
0.0061413543,
0.0074869106,
-0.0294427127,
0.0077036824,
0.02843537,
0.0321946442,
-0.0290793274,
0.03984119,
-0.0324909277,
0.028920617,
0.0233868845,
0.1485079825,
0.0452226214,
0.0223179348,
-0.0000574883,
0.0067727696,
-0.001484628,
0.0147786606,
-0.047097709,
0.0301692281,
-0.0432033688,
-0.0127158994,
-0.0369214863,
-0.0046312916,
0.0017751723,
0.0122687547,
-0.0268122237,
0.0305094458,
0.0053531961,
-0.0336266123,
0.0061745951,
0.0023643265,
-0.0352702849,
-0.0473117717,
-0.001082721,
0.0394075513,
-0.0187378936,
0.035479866,
-0.0091784094,
-0.0328962915,
0.0204756074,
-0.0223344229,
-0.0231183376,
-0.0177944433,
-0.0570293702,
0.0346007682,
-0.0146268327,
0.0067856763,
-0.0352631286,
-0.0127353352,
-0.0587862991,
-0.0455334596,
-0.0040795794,
-0.0295277201,
-0.0271341782,
0.0754745305,
-0.0324656442,
0.0080345571,
-0.015720997,
0.0003371233,
-0.0096507287,
-0.0049969964,
-0.014198848,
0.0592815019,
0.0059112441,
-0.0079178968,
-0.0358895771,
0.056143906,
-0.0869294479,
0.0249556899,
0.0035457858,
-0.0360459834,
-0.0329458714,
0.0038777245,
0.0395288616,
-0.059024252,
0.0126780365,
0.0233673938,
-0.003661043,
-0.0060909027,
-0.0218854118,
-0.0344470404,
-0.0075363074,
-0.0313961245,
-0.0077559622,
-0.0675426051,
0.0251313541,
0.027972322,
-0.0208360124,
-0.0180560537,
0.028531054,
0.0373937078,
-0.011738657,
0.0192143004,
-0.0102736801,
-0.0325122625,
0.0013390646,
0.0217079185,
0.0678540766,
0.0578671061,
0.0153226946,
-0.0270286445,
0.0824092254,
0.011858942,
-0.0028458282,
0.0275933687,
0.0412027314,
-0.0029180043,
0.0326188989,
0.0857761502,
0.02362982,
0.0078662736,
0.0317755118,
0.0037004899,
-0.0218988061,
-0.0448246673,
-0.0001005821,
0.0421901308,
-0.0020137746,
0.0041686515,
0.0162763316,
-0.0086516226,
0.0431812033,
0.0349140354,
0.0036666177,
0.0412597284,
-0.0105659515,
0.020598812,
0.0358759612,
0.0466885306,
-0.0441889465,
-0.0259163845,
-0.0139035303,
-0.0036079369,
-0.031733159,
0.0466271862,
0.035215687,
0.0154562946,
-0.0100492248,
0.0898561478,
0.0288486723,
-0.0467383899,
0.0126672992,
0.0059100445,
0.0431779735,
0.0415142663,
0.0183779337,
-0.0565585196,
-0.0175722167,
-0.0133357923,
0.0480045937,
0.0216732193,
0.0228311568,
-0.0413642265,
0.036057733,
-0.0206128247,
0.0023932932,
-0.0215568356,
-0.0111696497,
0.0002059474,
0.0518252626,
-0.001391649,
-0.0194032434,
-0.0494010523,
-0.0077202716,
0.0396376885,
-0.0375377275,
-0.020634735,
0.0205689277,
-0.0068987194,
0.002279039,
0.0589236058,
-0.0387807228,
0.0079740109,
0.0298998933,
-0.0235137828,
-0.0536930449,
-0.0107752746,
-0.0572887585,
-0.054242827,
0.0376572348,
-0.0443419665,
-0.0370920971,
0.0376694426,
-0.0371530429,
-0.0469247289,
-0.0214918554,
0.0232193507,
-0.0260752998,
-0.0538503081,
-0.0219930168,
0.0330041982,
0.0326493159,
-0.0349348895,
0.0762302652,
-0.0011430252,
0.0501305535,
0.0303730201,
0.0072689806,
0.033961039,
-0.0116856694,
-0.0318299644,
0.0065399469,
-0.0056272396,
0.0121100917,
0.0271705259,
0.0268010255,
-0.0666969344,
0.0046869516,
-0.0582876727,
0.0337942578,
-0.034577705,
0.02283106,
0.0471060127,
0.0351181105,
0.0030274482,
-0.0102405576,
-0.0701872259,
-0.0113592036,
-0.0318106264,
-0.0029699982,
0.0479326732,
-0.0000083931,
0.0434546471,
-0.0125185782,
-0.0164657068,
-0.0114280637,
0.0611305311,
-0.0230161715,
0.0165031701,
0.0007834989,
-0.0227121916,
-0.0342019275,
0.0218815189,
0.0087585384,
-0.0029044822,
-0.0119321467,
-0.0079785502,
0.0419855565,
0.0312629044,
0.0297962334,
-0.0055990699,
-0.0023454507,
0.0093517024,
-0.0345892049,
0.032017678,
-0.0119934455,
0.009941048,
-0.010732865,
-0.0411533788,
0.0172814317,
0.034021385,
0.0212899372,
-0.0110901771,
-0.0212338343,
-0.0563859977,
0.0150132673,
-0.0096739242,
-0.0596514717,
0.0472228117,
-0.0423439257,
0.0304094534,
-0.0259430055,
0.0320456326,
0.0667695552,
0.0027918098,
-0.0244175307,
-0.018087633,
0.0261473823,
-0.0799051672,
0.0631820112,
-0.0445755459,
0.0146318404,
0.0070416797,
-0.012619636,
-0.039544329,
0.0180871859,
-0.01024043,
-0.0431937873,
0.0439375751,
-0.0492371656,
0.000064924,
-0.0455140918,
-0.0251038745,
-0.0372273996,
-0.0553967357,
0.0018395268,
0.0233043656,
-0.0347631276,
0.0036042307,
0.0224462692,
-0.0037939253,
0.0217875913,
0.0100172032,
-0.0240709987,
0.015128958,
-0.0103197023,
0.0892575756,
0.0804879889,
0.0904022679,
0.0162464343,
-0.0103884153,
0.0469825678,
0.0825059861,
0.0284081865,
0.0221536327,
0.0384166017,
-0.0010555729,
0.0299660563,
-0.0358982384,
0.0051913173,
0.0043871296,
0.0715401545,
-0.0323762,
-0.0221797768,
0.087862201,
0.0262358673,
0.0143571999,
0.0029790211,
-0.0159198884,
0.0211651567,
0.0099507719,
0.0067167133,
-0.136432454,
-0.0230543278,
-0.0568109527,
0.0209847372,
0.0175657533,
-0.0479668044,
0.012869603,
-0.1229042485,
0.0112956921,
-0.053882692,
-0.0560430139,
-0.0349346921,
-0.015957633,
0.0163214933,
-0.0004665202,
0.0183129963,
0.0080586532,
-0.00313947,
0.0135235116,
0.0389588811,
-0.0085553508,
-0.00988915,
0.078959994,
-0.0432362631,
0.0072349962,
0.0272774193,
0.0277972147,
-0.0293007325,
0.0073899911,
-0.0280614551,
-0.0939807519,
-0.0486205071,
0.0084439935,
0.0742712244,
0.0130724264,
-0.0154841822,
-0.023517672,
0.0664623156,
-0.0562652536,
-0.0126965437,
0.0769421607,
0.0467515811,
0.0058720713,
-0.0156924445,
-0.0038521211,
0.0201659538,
-0.0404704846,
0.0945987478,
0.022518808,
-0.0593908988,
-0.0375483409,
-0.028038701,
-0.0422028229,
-0.1100160182,
-0.0462987684,
0.0351990424,
-0.0181145053,
0.0388975888,
-0.0793242231,
-0.0603238344,
0.0523705333,
0.0102321859,
-0.0304866768,
0.0070393807,
0.0036031632,
0.0345082656,
-0.0283017419,
0.0051923292,
-0.0125406086,
0.0111233201,
-0.0025128,
-0.0188141987,
0.0068477904,
-0.052340325,
-0.0194526017,
0.0006338973,
-0.0567702763,
0.002362693,
0.0044171675,
-0.0277291853,
0.0002389164,
0.0052279728,
-0.0195322279,
-0.0116601186,
0.0233659949,
0.0068920869,
-0.0485916995,
-0.0011638924,
0.0205132589,
0.0354826972,
-0.0077251429,
0.0331244953,
-0.0558185913,
-0.0071074618,
0.0244533941,
0.0423530005,
-0.0148286615,
-0.034314964,
0.0338920131,
0.021311542,
-0.0107308747,
0.0361795947,
-0.0259837694,
-0.0576042756,
0.023317866,
-0.0375456661,
-0.025085479,
-0.021382926,
0.0288179424,
0.0091755735,
-0.0688520968,
-0.0249027107,
0.0527400151,
0.0276177973,
0.0351510867,
-0.0747782737,
-0.0053742146,
0.0446556248,
0.015352021,
-0.0267574508,
-0.0232230183,
-0.0326967202,
-0.0174931791,
-0.0034133061,
0.0430866592,
0.0080867372,
0.0310797002,
0.0113198496,
-0.0115941102,
0.0414618142,
-0.0102491369,
-0.0739310682,
0.0281737391,
-0.0265190341,
0.0263010357,
0.0354560427,
0.0208518934,
0.047907453,
0.0227345433,
-0.0124819269,
-0.0043095313,
-0.0041660205,
-0.008012265,
0.0040577389,
0.0479639582,
0.0349954888,
-0.0329135992,
-0.0207246039,
0.1064257994,
-0.0023933467,
0.0604842938,
0.0107864896,
0.0266914498,
-0.0288725011,
-0.032877259,
-0.0250443462,
0.0213053375,
0.0070291529,
-0.0068465392,
-0.0732047185,
-0.0424474776,
-0.0061376919,
0.0044512399,
-0.0141754486,
0.0039174836,
0.012277171,
0.0494672023,
0.0460504815,
-0.0524164699,
-0.0514295101,
0.015086324,
-0.0330206528,
0.0046277256,
-0.0055864104,
-6.408422716e-33,
-0.0263867415,
-0.0339575894,
0.0222192444,
-0.0122757563,
-0.0136796655,
0.0050070644,
-0.0264419336,
-0.0008650509,
-0.0813859329,
-0.0064834058,
-0.0065875603,
0.0187800843,
-0.0030705032,
0.0732553452,
-0.0058947201,
-0.0489195921,
-0.0065491502,
-0.0238665808,
-0.0195890907,
0.021336766,
0.0712187961,
0.0120415334,
0.0614195764,
-0.0327722691,
0.0517890193,
-0.0432685427,
-0.0116368122,
0.0213733055,
0.0108409952,
0.0715680942,
-0.0257660504,
0.0589859486,
0.0540720895,
-0.0466498323,
0.0051213088,
0.0205097534,
-0.1412799358,
-0.0518330932,
0.0034252491,
-0.0134922005,
-0.0727551281,
-0.0232328735,
-0.006066917,
-0.002082611,
0.0677130073,
-0.0313651673,
0.056376636,
-0.0487230495,
0.0303486958,
-0.0434221476,
0.0004784692,
0.0231078435,
-0.0271693226,
0.02675616,
-0.0491002798,
0.0631877556,
-0.0172958113,
0.0481739528,
-0.021848999,
-0.0075707729,
0.0060825343,
0.0121774375,
0.0082699414,
0.0022830521,
0.0060704695,
0.0342839994,
-0.0023196808,
-0.0344310813,
-0.0378719307,
-0.0029030629,
-0.0325435176,
0.0242068376,
0.0237677675,
0.0800398514,
-0.0055241897,
0.0251914635,
-0.1018566117,
0.0584558211,
-0.0003866648,
-0.0077386671,
-0.0089792991,
-0.0463346504,
0.0291798189,
-0.0054900446,
-0.0320744887,
0.0353209525,
-0.0214021411,
-0.0037504178,
0.0202533919,
-0.0252451114,
-0.0421511084,
0.014563066,
0.0171469431,
-0.0327063873,
-0.0064878701,
0.0590294264,
-0.007866228,
0.0099178785,
0.0364286043,
0.0451074466,
-0.0534362718,
0.0241066702,
0.0144997211,
-0.0253611654,
-0.0108838482,
0.020459488,
0.044919949,
-0.0252089165,
-0.0549557768,
0.0044399295,
-0.0331831649,
-0.0059012226,
-0.0428344607,
0.0382530726,
-0.0080600958,
0.0200753193,
-0.004744065,
0.0253780056,
0.0369602852,
0.0120986095,
-0.0622137599,
-0.0141703589,
0.0095958188,
0.0050099064,
-0.0066612479,
0.0283528157,
-0.0220864043,
0.0018729478,
-0.0020185257,
-0.0250927918,
-0.013580339,
0.0342550054,
2.3e-7,
0.0669121072,
-0.0361481421,
0.0536404476,
0.064156875,
-0.0054525421,
0.0058377353,
0.0102535943,
0.0441272743,
-0.0203553494,
-0.0124420552,
-0.0074280361,
0.023492761,
0.0521469451,
0.0428008288,
-0.0775266737,
0.0011056194,
-0.0334305763,
-0.0316723324,
-0.0192212965,
-0.0024036879,
0.0762513131,
0.0389062539,
-0.0401592515,
0.0223330427,
-0.0173534825,
-0.0103990966,
0.0322019607,
0.0084213205,
-0.0018135919,
0.0443206131,
0.0120046698,
0.0056126257,
0.0094428509,
-0.0006664337,
-0.0118273068,
0.0171176437,
0.0552362539,
0.0635849535,
0.0349918641,
-0.0940291658,
-0.0304488111,
-0.0574883968,
0.0342987999,
-0.0254703872,
0.0933496654,
0.0104390224,
-0.0385773778,
0.012624993,
-0.0279158857,
0.006037428,
-0.0088044349,
-0.0133625064,
0.0313763283,
0.0150376623,
-0.0068005947,
-0.0119896373,
-0.0023251385,
-0.0650658533,
-0.0359595343,
0.0272880085,
-0.0437785089,
-0.0623514503,
0.0268892664,
-0.0303173419,
-0.0069860881,
-0.0690672025,
0.0090263756,
1.973169205e-34,
-0.0048190234,
-0.0025200448,
-0.0259161443,
0.049430117,
0.0209968034,
-0.0637515262,
-0.0568104349,
-0.0415631868,
0.0133274309,
-0.0934237391,
-0.0156464186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09916v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09916v1 | BUSTER: a "BUSiness Transaction Entity Recognition" dataset | 2024-02-15T12:39:57 | 2024-02-15T12:39:57 | Andrea Zugarini, Andrew Zamai, Marco Ernandes, Leonardo Rigutini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Albeit Natural Language Processing has seen major breakthroughs in the last
few years, transferring such advances into real-world business cases can be
challenging. One of the reasons resides in the displacement between popular
benchmarks and actual data. Lack of supervision, unbalanced classes, noisy data
and long documents often affect real problems in vertical domains such as
finance, law and health. To support industry-oriented research, we present
BUSTER, a BUSiness Transaction Entity Recognition dataset. The dataset consists
of 3779 manually annotated documents on financial transactions. We establish
several baselines exploiting both general-purpose and domain-specific language
models. The best performing model is also used to automatically annotate 6196
documents, which we release as an additional silver corpus to BUSTER. | [
0.0313947536,
0.0722761899,
0.0325208157,
0.0412663184,
0.0098239016,
0.0326685682,
0.034098234,
0.032303337,
0.0100101316,
-0.0483872369,
-0.0604270361,
-0.0315389372,
-0.0113583971,
0.0432396829,
0.0199494958,
-0.0400710329,
0.0105260266,
0.004407784,
0.0329778083,
0.0336270705,
0.000678993,
0.0199321955,
-0.0016389018,
0.0027672458,
-0.0062369606,
-0.0121461721,
0.0211623479,
-0.0051546143,
0.023031801,
-0.0173366386,
0.0416850112,
0.0720996112,
0.012470575,
0.0351663716,
0.0000017872,
-0.0523816645,
-0.0388935655,
0.0034846303,
-0.0713381246,
0.0305004511,
0.0001382533,
-0.0459936932,
0.0165277608,
-0.0084579904,
-0.0586185716,
-0.043755915,
0.0089633176,
0.0895846337,
0.0341811478,
0.0769317448,
-0.0302585661,
-0.0556556024,
-0.0010414476,
-0.0567448661,
-0.0127134854,
-0.0702167079,
0.0368111171,
0.012616598,
-0.0114330789,
0.0057608001,
0.0177872404,
0.0107003869,
-0.0089547737,
-0.0267214719,
0.0234136581,
0.0124775851,
-0.0387217551,
0.043490991,
-0.0308761578,
0.0831113011,
0.0230374187,
0.0394370742,
0.0375994854,
-0.022885818,
-0.006291769,
-0.0401771106,
-0.0387045778,
0.0270015001,
-0.0136434929,
-0.0404267013,
-0.0141734621,
0.0153279323,
0.0359219573,
0.0357333086,
-0.0133285839,
-0.024150297,
0.0026470355,
-0.0306676272,
0.0327536054,
0.0279537793,
-0.0301319044,
-0.0435814708,
0.0240169819,
0.0040777638,
0.0229954496,
0.0090522086,
-0.0073213619,
-0.0085659148,
0.0040326957,
-0.0520636253,
0.0077986484,
-0.0111297676,
-0.0034173802,
0.0997579545,
-0.0427315906,
0.0181601942,
-0.005810603,
-0.032594718,
0.0142368907,
0.0294569824,
-0.0358985402,
0.0257928111,
-0.0445656218,
0.0563274547,
-0.0408187546,
-0.0225193445,
-0.0672280416,
-0.0125578763,
-0.0117855445,
0.0393412486,
0.0007244052,
-0.0266368017,
0.0211136006,
-0.0351439603,
-0.0076556527,
-0.0156920347,
-0.0292686243,
0.037633732,
-0.0066260449,
-0.0149119962,
-0.0010224888,
-0.0008168399,
0.012861968,
-0.0429996699,
0.0113065867,
0.0552678108,
0.048682306,
-0.0952246636,
-0.0563328862,
-0.0063354056,
0.0271881074,
-0.0428196639,
-0.0252502728,
-0.0164887477,
0.0381665491,
-0.0146617116,
-0.0288415458,
-0.0155596146,
0.0089325365,
-0.0115647772,
-0.0113578765,
0.1013110504,
-0.0129995262,
-0.0305755083,
0.0161907971,
-0.0278255362,
0.0450523198,
0.0153768286,
0.0406548977,
0.0058533307,
0.0279940218,
-0.0011265093,
0.0018983216,
0.0556484051,
-0.0184200201,
-0.0529115945,
0.0448243767,
0.0203883331,
-0.0135507053,
0.0101461578,
0.0421231762,
0.0105489064,
-0.0279916897,
-0.022000676,
0.0306212399,
0.0316169038,
-0.0067078648,
-0.0000710114,
-0.008484764,
0.0299140289,
0.0241760053,
-0.0210263915,
-0.0082863802,
-0.0224245246,
0.0066118282,
0.0046927305,
-0.0543388315,
-0.0032038803,
-0.0345787667,
-0.0034585504,
-0.0391978808,
-0.0071021481,
-0.0120965028,
-0.0133870887,
0.0697797984,
0.0143920956,
-0.061284814,
0.0557601564,
0.0066300593,
-0.0413586162,
0.0009533323,
0.019104762,
0.0073558763,
0.0576906912,
0.0608886145,
-0.0565216839,
0.0201455746,
-0.0349710062,
-0.0144622922,
0.0735391155,
0.067802906,
-0.0213615503,
0.0035766175,
-0.0586687773,
-0.0194151029,
0.053225752,
0.0128639685,
0.0163471494,
0.0190947987,
0.0040144715,
0.011284749,
0.0002309373,
-0.0257256776,
0.0587572008,
-0.013375991,
-0.0758120194,
0.0412619673,
-0.0004444502,
0.0038846722,
0.0336963087,
-0.020768756,
-0.0173702538,
0.0266021341,
-0.0114442129,
0.0013298609,
-0.0076624183,
-0.0152856428,
0.0007811375,
0.0172947068,
0.0009524292,
-0.0213787742,
-0.0192088634,
-0.0725959837,
-0.0405527838,
-0.0179018266,
0.0173698179,
-0.0203602239,
-0.0507580936,
0.0127236405,
0.038289316,
0.0408284664,
-0.0138512766,
0.0433931984,
-0.0043866606,
0.0219096858,
-0.0380478017,
-0.0275862198,
0.03046377,
-0.0307765976,
0.0031897246,
0.0053537358,
-0.0532473326,
0.0281816106,
0.0327083431,
0.0095789153,
-0.0229651723,
0.0108005647,
-0.0550672039,
-0.0052926838,
0.0067031076,
0.0536152497,
0.0025771721,
0.0463416316,
-0.0246145781,
-0.0484049544,
-0.0094761094,
0.0001584928,
-0.0229985192,
-0.0223118681,
0.0820196494,
0.0050161602,
-0.004133652,
-0.0375378728,
-0.013357589,
-0.0157517046,
0.0234574303,
0.0156126097,
-0.0771409273,
-0.0483880676,
-0.008996441,
0.0263532605,
0.0206352789,
0.0018346113,
0.0248738192,
-0.032507889,
0.0248104818,
-0.0087500475,
0.0647353753,
-0.0105990618,
0.0546403527,
-0.0422883965,
-0.0087192701,
-0.0343841612,
0.0116513558,
-0.0239245221,
0.0759835094,
-0.0002259074,
-0.0265930127,
0.0223706644,
0.0910029411,
-0.031859763,
0.0095933266,
-0.0265855342,
-0.0321691483,
-0.0098657459,
0.028467657,
-0.054480575,
-0.0092158848,
-0.0270756111,
0.0391727425,
-0.0221216474,
0.011375647,
0.0419079587,
-0.01375823,
-0.0008287561,
-0.0057801367,
0.0092906654,
-0.0475806557,
0.0634355396,
-0.0186164919,
-0.0037984627,
0.0109866913,
-0.0838551521,
0.0057375133,
0.0146515816,
0.0583886243,
-0.0014745207,
0.0529960133,
-0.0464083776,
0.0646400973,
-0.0297840033,
-0.0187795497,
-0.0354982279,
-0.0351496488,
-0.0194018818,
0.033757668,
0.0304616913,
-0.0149165401,
-0.0572113581,
0.0297686197,
-0.0432465971,
0.085408859,
0.0102514839,
-0.0136247333,
-0.0028579633,
0.032074485,
0.020151617,
-0.0195883717,
0.0560575649,
-0.0069480725,
0.0166958533,
0.0184608363,
-0.0203237776,
-0.0052056075,
-0.0030064667,
-0.0125796702,
-0.0138098272,
-0.0968196392,
0.0182835124,
-0.0294806622,
0.0006731561,
-0.0693224445,
-0.0153824836,
0.0844945908,
0.0097800652,
0.0149181187,
-0.0111774886,
0.0376226306,
0.0069537931,
0.0000356455,
0.0378244482,
-0.1391714364,
-0.0313245989,
-0.0043200427,
0.0056853178,
0.0504289344,
-0.0824460834,
0.0011051508,
-0.1036453471,
0.0490092672,
-0.0189893134,
0.0166564099,
0.0128915105,
-0.0567879044,
-0.0154740484,
-0.0750571489,
0.0148459459,
-0.0114942566,
-0.0333011858,
-0.0286147296,
0.0266253836,
-0.0409557372,
-0.0402037352,
0.0225767922,
-0.0318063311,
-0.026354339,
0.0234077964,
0.027243536,
-0.0016056789,
0.0242035165,
-0.0107246842,
-0.0355371535,
-0.060614109,
-0.0009955859,
0.0777753294,
-0.0156047409,
-0.0256612655,
0.0234358404,
0.0391709059,
-0.0954218879,
0.0146570848,
0.0084898537,
-0.0067956159,
-0.0025758073,
-0.0169070996,
0.0044729356,
-0.0180961266,
-0.0048172832,
0.0909338295,
-0.0013400111,
-0.0277523678,
-0.0183606558,
-0.0127339857,
-0.0010913358,
-0.0245843884,
0.0250315219,
-0.0088132489,
-0.040398214,
-0.0504381508,
-0.0891223028,
-0.0992607921,
0.039222721,
0.0191013869,
0.0250035916,
0.0133176316,
0.0320464782,
-0.0142813781,
-0.0609995089,
0.0362914875,
-0.0513634644,
0.029367229,
-0.042751275,
0.0426142402,
-0.0323200822,
0.0225577541,
-0.0755824,
0.0229911413,
-0.0623191223,
-0.0226679072,
-0.0027490566,
-0.0147427516,
0.014648024,
0.0014405035,
-0.0448808521,
-0.0044586328,
-0.0235486254,
0.0453537218,
-0.077419661,
-0.0710493997,
0.0427868627,
-0.0408508964,
-0.035485331,
0.015613636,
-0.0365325026,
0.0446278527,
0.0130734304,
0.0213357229,
-0.060828764,
0.0024764759,
-0.0057296106,
0.0034879134,
0.0329349786,
0.0118800076,
-0.0109352702,
-0.0875273496,
-0.0060771657,
0.0228982195,
-0.0039988994,
-0.0328220278,
-0.0248743836,
0.0402145647,
-0.014480806,
-0.0339881591,
0.050315734,
-0.0302628614,
-0.007074405,
-0.0117304958,
0.0367842279,
0.0258985069,
0.056408871,
-0.0088832872,
-0.0484023802,
0.0130671635,
0.0393659882,
0.0282639861,
0.0376249142,
0.0033724525,
-0.0041434411,
0.0121451002,
0.0149858315,
0.0250564069,
-0.001126453,
-0.0103142625,
0.0699044764,
-0.0315806083,
0.034703739,
0.0410791337,
-0.0624085218,
0.0301639251,
-0.0655032992,
0.0037797661,
-0.0106843924,
0.0347006992,
-0.0031656756,
0.0047737183,
0.0055074883,
0.0215314925,
-0.0426567458,
0.0117173111,
0.0882438347,
-0.0148737514,
0.0527188815,
0.0175349358,
0.0115158437,
-0.0688403472,
-0.0310700294,
0.0492710583,
0.010651716,
-0.0125249047,
-0.0034784882,
-0.0516535081,
-0.0160934329,
0.0091677522,
-0.0262743812,
0.0023286988,
0.0105970791,
0.0060301134,
0.0310303774,
0.0130469259,
0.0300510898,
-0.0169327445,
-0.0018718395,
-0.0296433084,
-0.0302558281,
-0.0730968341,
-5.411503589e-33,
-0.0305355135,
-0.0183851328,
0.0143353892,
0.0032883375,
0.0408265851,
0.0377837159,
-0.0130867101,
-0.0366765969,
0.0102287522,
0.0100837834,
-0.0218351707,
0.0200025868,
0.0323450789,
0.0091414498,
-0.0018112394,
0.0081405845,
0.0534290411,
-0.0181687251,
-0.0195962675,
0.0021422042,
0.0075621917,
0.058500357,
0.1185957342,
-0.0625434145,
0.0668184087,
-0.0035086016,
-0.0175633896,
0.0142660877,
0.0692791641,
0.0349296816,
-0.0458239913,
0.0006931727,
0.0072720228,
-0.0481397621,
-0.0058243866,
0.0081747174,
-0.112779364,
0.0127865551,
-0.0333604813,
0.073154524,
0.0162565019,
0.0032785882,
0.0218397398,
-0.0263330471,
-0.0331428461,
0.0072615626,
0.0198794454,
-0.0336562395,
-0.015926145,
-0.0135923596,
-0.066770874,
0.0710902214,
0.0124109322,
0.0308493245,
0.0742933452,
0.0189684574,
0.0028112268,
-0.0057405573,
-0.0621693283,
-0.0085893422,
0.0224857908,
-0.0020098123,
0.0244836435,
-0.0299144033,
-0.0003532375,
0.0408726931,
-0.012960963,
0.0090910252,
0.0226312708,
-0.0053921784,
0.0131610958,
0.052482564,
0.028288506,
0.0338811278,
0.0309777055,
0.0120057352,
-0.0462754071,
0.0472796112,
0.0135227498,
0.0297888387,
-0.0073060882,
-0.0203502569,
-0.0499284491,
-0.0082021644,
0.0003472588,
-0.0430617593,
-0.0116584171,
0.0132484697,
0.0160190333,
0.0166276339,
0.002067066,
0.0399556607,
0.0123800253,
-0.036256887,
-0.0996533781,
0.0096919546,
0.0223143511,
0.001360126,
0.0352477059,
-0.0081536546,
-0.0736132488,
-0.0355917402,
0.0049491064,
0.0146801509,
0.0025729907,
-0.00631148,
0.068970114,
-0.0337900259,
-0.0499260612,
0.0112352408,
0.0070698224,
0.0460480489,
-0.0240844786,
0.0836194307,
0.0112812715,
0.0153533611,
0.0088195438,
0.060865391,
0.0158479866,
0.010076263,
0.0084002782,
-0.0020481534,
0.0064816866,
0.0720979273,
0.0348142609,
0.0045096264,
0.0022116972,
0.0141636478,
0.0461254381,
-0.0035336062,
-0.0005965804,
0.0212814175,
2.344e-7,
0.0395937264,
0.0656162128,
0.0288398545,
0.0228158291,
-0.0074396404,
0.0368052609,
0.0163274631,
0.0309538469,
-0.0414145738,
-0.0021553829,
0.0126854898,
-0.029358238,
0.0780048221,
-0.0261387937,
-0.0864702836,
-0.0572329313,
-0.0442378148,
0.0034360108,
-0.0779038072,
0.0028011776,
-0.0053253816,
0.0934982523,
-0.0059993877,
-0.0462886393,
-0.0168928709,
-0.0420640633,
0.0454025157,
-0.0593984276,
0.010312208,
0.0344279632,
0.0466644354,
0.0255254414,
-0.0122619737,
0.0230494365,
-0.0155711388,
0.0301184654,
0.016323451,
0.0520323589,
0.0065074554,
0.054801207,
-0.0094496664,
-0.023068497,
-0.0077031255,
-0.0176731944,
0.0247574467,
-0.0376396514,
-0.0267883111,
-0.0072858301,
-0.0469911359,
-0.0099101318,
0.011145344,
0.0270263124,
0.0253182296,
0.0079175318,
0.062127132,
-0.0448303558,
-0.0116951019,
-0.0538155101,
0.051832974,
0.0231533386,
0.0037352396,
0.0452626608,
-0.0289572421,
-0.0179693978,
-0.0052094315,
-0.0431757309,
0.0104589621,
2.02862361e-34,
0.0182194505,
-0.0044946182,
-0.0225241743,
0.06378185,
0.045242805,
-0.0067236577,
-0.0000221332,
0.025158748,
-0.0057832398,
-0.0845129937,
0.0419167392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09911v1 | Enhancing Large Language Models with Pseudo- and Multisource- Knowledge Graphs for Open-ended Question Answering | 2024-02-15T12:20:02 | 2024-02-15T12:20:02 | Jiaxiang Liu, Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mitigating the hallucinations of Large Language Models (LLMs) and enhancing
them is a crucial task. Although some existing methods employ model
self-enhancement techniques, they fall short of effectively addressing unknown
factual hallucinations. Using Knowledge Graph (KG) enhancement approaches fails
to address the generalization across different KG sources and the enhancement
of open-ended answer questions simultaneously. To tackle these limitations,
there is a framework that combines Pseudo-Graph Generation and Atomic Knowledge
Verification proposed. The enhancement of LLM using KG in an open-ended
question-answering setting is implemented by leveraging the Pseudo-Graph
Generation. Atomic Knowledge Verification utilizes atomic-level knowledge
querying and verification to achieve generalizability under different KG
sources. Compared to the baseline, this approach yields a minimum improvement
of 11.5 in the ROUGE-L score for open-ended questions. For precise questions,
we observe a minimum accuracy improvement of 7.5. Moreover, there is also
demonstration that this framework exhibits generalizability across different KG
sources. In summary, our results pave the way for enhancing LLMs by
incorporating Pseudo- and Multisource-KGs, particularly in the context of
open-ended questions. | [
0.0699872896,
0.0294677243,
-0.0032273233,
0.0537674278,
-0.0304898787,
0.0005489243,
-0.0307966601,
0.012669553,
0.0360819586,
-0.0372243896,
-0.0236006938,
-0.0164862387,
-0.0542683713,
0.0141103044,
0.0421756059,
0.0079519637,
0.0592514686,
-0.0380680412,
0.0010073512,
-0.0569010675,
-0.0005560382,
0.0025620761,
0.0003256859,
-0.0342734084,
0.0056354087,
-0.0342312381,
-0.0267633852,
0.0148211606,
-0.0086220978,
-0.0113443015,
-0.026813712,
0.0117792422,
-0.0136877187,
0.0022238104,
0.0000020874,
-0.0459410511,
0.00058135,
-0.0049654013,
-0.0451862365,
-0.0011980903,
-0.0022733749,
0.0144835152,
0.0257244017,
0.021732375,
-0.0459239148,
-0.0015606045,
0.0304607991,
0.050186228,
0.0788096562,
0.0676844791,
0.0033792895,
-0.0235685483,
0.0317371376,
0.0229499973,
0.0164578632,
-0.0104511809,
0.0486251973,
0.0737453476,
0.0501524322,
-0.0115097687,
-0.0106085325,
0.0581272729,
0.0322011858,
-0.0058813677,
0.0474528149,
0.0273400247,
-0.065733999,
0.0165211149,
0.0249813162,
0.1080492958,
0.0079497537,
-0.0415353775,
-0.0164287779,
0.0089197969,
0.0076568639,
0.0583702065,
-0.0623830929,
0.0100021511,
0.0074756676,
-0.0073905345,
0.0108238515,
-0.015990328,
0.043775972,
0.0208109021,
-0.0327577963,
0.1366089135,
0.0279019363,
-0.051645156,
0.0443772264,
-0.004384038,
-0.0670757741,
-0.0434516221,
-0.0083153378,
0.0591557138,
-0.0066621667,
0.0405254066,
-0.0051294668,
0.0099529149,
0.0246596914,
-0.0660635829,
0.0294989217,
0.0028484827,
-0.0259204358,
0.0516602062,
-0.0371669829,
0.0197041593,
-0.0345500633,
0.0352363959,
-0.0718623847,
-0.0251516346,
-0.0326562226,
-0.0220623743,
-0.0819056258,
0.0474575013,
-0.0228685625,
-0.0255307816,
-0.0067214142,
0.0483568572,
-0.0147851566,
0.012995366,
0.016795842,
0.0309525318,
0.0428228863,
-0.0424637198,
-0.0389704742,
0.0343599059,
-0.0523251854,
-0.0129706785,
-0.012592135,
-0.0216710921,
-0.0295541901,
0.0133201964,
0.0101060979,
-0.0013466824,
-0.0012160483,
0.0000938646,
0.0103221359,
0.0254968069,
-0.0206016786,
-0.0390336514,
-0.0266933292,
-0.069711782,
0.0009012474,
-0.0871041715,
0.0190123282,
0.0084820613,
-0.0277530961,
-0.0173725691,
0.0334441587,
-0.004965852,
-0.0365264341,
0.0489720032,
-0.0673326999,
0.0130537059,
0.0119952308,
0.0140507864,
0.0043365136,
0.055218596,
0.0078620296,
-0.0215397738,
0.055696588,
-0.0151223643,
-0.0118229259,
0.0299721565,
0.0642205402,
0.0152872447,
0.0026556677,
0.0580678694,
0.0222493224,
0.0036153758,
-0.0342261046,
0.0520340912,
-0.0047666216,
-0.0492868349,
0.0306277443,
-0.0090621719,
-0.0050615086,
0.0105749546,
0.0174748246,
0.0261845831,
0.0318332165,
0.0463145077,
-0.0099914214,
0.0098724123,
-0.0717582479,
0.0418846309,
0.0053450712,
0.0043863775,
-0.0299408883,
-0.0470596552,
-0.0347025059,
0.0187963769,
0.0215058681,
0.0590422489,
0.0493166782,
0.0092255939,
-0.031008061,
0.0703774393,
0.0450322293,
-0.0274429414,
0.0316426344,
-0.0441182479,
0.039330069,
0.0876615047,
0.055300869,
-0.0459228307,
-0.0646861568,
0.0049404288,
-0.0054102372,
0.0413581431,
0.0047451067,
-0.0422843657,
-0.0228159111,
-0.039412003,
0.0089777922,
-0.0304966103,
-0.0099605629,
-0.0209639929,
0.0152523033,
-0.0064246147,
0.008621702,
-0.0853111967,
0.0072813737,
-0.0095114699,
-0.0196456332,
-0.0095783472,
-0.0068267682,
-0.0098086372,
-0.0021768995,
0.0205324441,
-0.0061865421,
0.0413663797,
0.0279098786,
-0.0185356811,
-0.0733333454,
-0.0248184744,
-0.0305555593,
-0.0664540604,
0.0474852324,
0.0201623123,
-0.0035985697,
0.0050081648,
-0.0309302136,
-0.0463055335,
-0.0038652415,
-0.0310875811,
0.0613516644,
-0.0474428236,
0.0036571573,
0.0192375928,
-0.0112285707,
-0.0285798684,
0.0695664212,
-0.0093824333,
0.0166859608,
0.0220975596,
-0.0025251184,
0.0093964376,
-0.0304073542,
-0.0201341305,
0.0077757505,
0.0028610048,
0.0297303628,
0.0339361541,
-0.0403460525,
-0.0892072767,
-0.0119976401,
-0.1163669601,
0.0236748178,
-0.0114600258,
0.0078399135,
0.0342274085,
0.0109327631,
-0.002547127,
-0.0230969265,
-0.0366918929,
0.0327871516,
0.0366192199,
0.0002019724,
0.0102403834,
0.0142840995,
-0.0209521912,
-0.0033852146,
-0.0265919156,
-0.0198357999,
0.0617332682,
-0.0300403684,
0.019657528,
-0.033932317,
0.0495650135,
-0.0773604661,
0.0209463406,
0.0029674079,
-0.0131444028,
-0.0109586455,
-0.0252496433,
-0.0033710066,
0.0353224874,
-0.0051057767,
-0.0028244648,
0.0526789501,
-0.0367869884,
-0.0299287122,
0.0157253426,
-0.0129468543,
-0.0037675265,
-0.0229967609,
-0.0148253432,
0.0078145638,
0.0340065584,
0.0126898708,
-0.0447343998,
-0.0551289245,
0.0178797357,
-0.0132253608,
-0.0333197676,
-0.0369175598,
0.0009858391,
0.0217190068,
-0.0003431142,
-0.0356490351,
-0.0010177055,
0.0687447339,
-0.0122255329,
0.0095594795,
-0.0119910631,
-0.012821517,
-0.0051368419,
0.0660490617,
0.0131661203,
0.0182701033,
0.0134980585,
0.0133299818,
-0.0372465402,
-0.0439996384,
0.0063291145,
-0.0443486944,
0.0362395011,
-0.0277953465,
0.0235283338,
0.0473919995,
-0.0033760308,
-0.0528389066,
-0.0541846566,
-0.0137174735,
0.0301928483,
-0.0423200689,
0.0115443869,
0.0129977027,
-0.0035535709,
-0.0073723048,
-0.0067780507,
-0.0444534346,
0.0144563643,
-0.0123035396,
0.0808401406,
0.0977713242,
-0.0167631973,
0.0164080374,
-0.0149864256,
0.0480758473,
0.0669230521,
0.0340203829,
0.0052704317,
-0.0032188487,
-0.0180803388,
0.0046719895,
-0.0414815322,
-0.0243966095,
-0.0026262,
0.0445048586,
-0.0642472357,
-0.0009125817,
0.1243879199,
0.0507615432,
0.0400278233,
-0.0038562552,
-0.0367857479,
0.032957539,
0.007967039,
0.0516727343,
-0.0801994503,
-0.0120174233,
-0.0404754281,
-0.0047655031,
-0.0187046658,
-0.0280974377,
-0.0032737828,
-0.1161168292,
0.0042910906,
0.0185138118,
-0.0437804013,
-0.0255965088,
-0.0142191676,
0.0037563397,
0.0391521454,
-0.0218634866,
0.0324051902,
0.0015864462,
-0.0179102775,
0.0071529984,
-0.0010633795,
-0.0163114816,
0.0281504299,
-0.0069237887,
0.0415205024,
0.0104306703,
0.0297567137,
-0.0029804849,
-0.0272672288,
0.0292544588,
-0.0142308185,
0.0135311326,
-0.0186444093,
0.0257443916,
0.0063255858,
0.0056744711,
-0.0199347343,
0.0123952394,
-0.0118283909,
-0.0112597384,
0.0079031968,
0.1235730648,
-0.0133923134,
-0.0484466776,
0.0097958017,
0.0101332041,
-0.0078311954,
0.0576679409,
0.0189716611,
0.0082179504,
-0.0188869741,
-0.0142217148,
-0.0119759887,
-0.0316975415,
0.0213887189,
0.0534524135,
0.0148624377,
0.0253846906,
-0.0734653994,
-0.0375503004,
0.0278365724,
0.0117733432,
-0.0318437666,
0.0224009193,
0.0388175286,
-0.022205716,
-0.022631621,
0.0171376243,
-0.0831831619,
0.0017922572,
-0.0053958576,
-0.0125095015,
0.0384307168,
-0.0176106393,
-0.0183828399,
0.0157459453,
-0.0706290454,
-0.0835483819,
-0.0086732795,
0.0364800505,
0.0122811561,
0.0375587419,
-0.0183414239,
-0.0442653932,
0.0562648289,
-0.001694578,
-0.0339424461,
0.0052556759,
0.0246994849,
-0.0326294787,
-0.0083625792,
0.0430708043,
-0.05778585,
-0.0029594109,
0.017927656,
0.0650197119,
-0.0286784023,
-0.0651101023,
0.0470891073,
0.0696189478,
-0.027325321,
0.0380500853,
0.0375096574,
-0.0252413545,
0.0351379253,
-0.0415939204,
-0.0187460836,
-0.0165981427,
0.009911906,
0.0216514189,
-0.0633304566,
0.0156177096,
-0.0490919128,
-0.0408815183,
0.0504667498,
-0.0229442492,
-0.0321639515,
0.021064844,
-0.0260026082,
0.0551462397,
-0.0289753675,
-0.0330092981,
0.009599681,
0.0232689548,
0.0410649851,
0.0000625796,
0.0547043681,
0.0116349161,
-0.0447787233,
-0.037689399,
0.0074514742,
-0.0748427361,
-0.0519110709,
-0.0207502004,
0.0588561743,
0.0406508781,
0.0300839189,
0.0232595652,
-0.0126083298,
-0.0318656303,
-0.0170927588,
0.0230383836,
0.0259664822,
-0.0594984777,
0.0526302382,
0.0355546288,
0.0001368645,
0.0206694249,
0.050411474,
0.0111942338,
0.0574920662,
-0.0024687347,
-0.0291882437,
-0.0208162423,
-0.0265986342,
-0.0624621063,
0.0351998545,
-0.0158168133,
0.0448657311,
-0.0593972467,
-0.088294208,
0.0095938202,
0.0323488489,
-0.0252390821,
-0.028370047,
0.0512364097,
0.0360055044,
0.0392834917,
-0.0518839397,
-0.0193739086,
0.0401416458,
-0.013990175,
0.0234239865,
0.0183242559,
-6.807632352e-33,
-0.0295562763,
-0.0457009934,
0.0283454694,
-0.0524246991,
-0.0659477338,
-0.0247271992,
-0.0387698598,
0.0002914346,
-0.023983201,
0.0114604495,
-0.0246206634,
0.0298539307,
-0.0057040565,
0.0371438004,
-0.0221858136,
-0.0241307989,
0.0290109273,
0.023889862,
-0.0117506506,
0.0202298947,
0.0304313339,
0.0029822218,
0.041509822,
0.0054616872,
0.0385818891,
-0.0491080582,
0.013871179,
0.0301511884,
-0.0544085614,
0.0541735142,
-0.0126426509,
0.0719871521,
0.025887657,
-0.0297097918,
-0.0031288725,
0.0089898501,
-0.0811744332,
-0.0427009426,
0.0601179376,
-0.0092394641,
-0.0408232138,
-0.0258835703,
0.0226969682,
0.0002567838,
0.0474881902,
-0.0303318854,
0.01885329,
-0.0322530493,
-0.0186480824,
-0.0061992873,
-0.0238612108,
0.0249846205,
-0.0012552155,
0.0017432441,
-0.0233337171,
0.0445265844,
-0.0011579432,
-0.0386246555,
-0.0275780298,
0.0121759297,
0.009895782,
0.0145659726,
0.0564369671,
0.0061272569,
0.0225982741,
0.0098775132,
-0.0041979873,
0.0106457872,
-0.0533644445,
-0.0189199913,
-0.0193704776,
0.0376154929,
0.0307621397,
0.0039039766,
-0.0021332416,
0.0070766001,
-0.0754853114,
-0.0217732862,
-0.0083389785,
0.0339716524,
-0.0124816755,
-0.0044779158,
-0.0257568453,
-0.0418164171,
-0.0598337911,
0.0217812788,
-0.0204817727,
-0.0403086171,
0.0272269212,
-0.0345709138,
-0.0356903188,
-0.0047329278,
0.0140791712,
-0.083114624,
0.0318097882,
0.0474634618,
-0.0179688707,
0.0393037163,
-0.0124842804,
0.0458419137,
-0.0253110714,
0.021029992,
0.0006879054,
-0.0391782373,
-0.0158120785,
0.0463546552,
-0.0082308333,
0.0016272133,
-0.0367097259,
0.0147499852,
-0.0352701135,
-0.0031555579,
-0.0216615777,
-0.0400027856,
0.0308072604,
0.0577523522,
0.0037001276,
0.0518698134,
0.0207607746,
0.0347899981,
-0.0043860055,
0.0247889757,
0.0059702792,
0.0105670886,
-0.019706849,
0.0316956379,
-0.0306776967,
0.0103592677,
-0.0344611257,
-0.0589511916,
-0.0146017047,
0.0366121382,
2.83e-7,
0.0391475409,
0.0156058203,
0.0378350243,
0.0801931247,
0.0045299833,
0.0141570438,
0.0023322317,
-0.0407073349,
0.0292623173,
-0.0663704276,
0.0032260292,
0.0604175143,
0.0103668729,
0.0604450256,
-0.063552171,
0.0349135846,
-0.0441174097,
-0.0338536389,
-0.0253118016,
0.0041530496,
0.0495006926,
0.0384859592,
0.0224841721,
-0.0014134819,
-0.0429730043,
-0.0664045662,
0.0651582032,
0.034876965,
-0.0681388229,
0.0330292843,
0.0499065556,
0.0062314277,
0.0028157937,
0.0736115798,
-0.0065455553,
0.0232176911,
-0.0035960206,
0.0241352357,
-0.0134630287,
0.0007208408,
-0.0158546213,
-0.0699448511,
0.0289696418,
-0.0586333945,
0.1021079198,
-0.0246235114,
-0.0116721448,
-0.0078248922,
-0.0216922648,
-0.0333894826,
-0.0022531624,
-0.0581076033,
0.0029100818,
-0.001579688,
0.0180451944,
-0.0064404053,
0.0335593373,
-0.0217802152,
-0.018321,
0.0297449231,
-0.0065694917,
-0.0643928126,
0.0244795084,
-0.0006389376,
0.0123703172,
-0.0647604987,
0.0305982847,
2.39956922e-34,
0.0519410633,
0.0277538821,
0.0109377215,
0.0017663413,
0.0224652234,
-0.0302466229,
-0.0417221189,
-0.0164538287,
0.0404821448,
-0.1202600896,
-0.0258048214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09910v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09910v2 | DE-COP: Detecting Copyrighted Content in Language Models Training Data | 2024-02-15T12:17:15 | 2024-06-25T10:33:41 | André V. Duarte, Xuandong Zhao, Arlindo L. Oliveira, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2 | How can we detect if copyrighted content was used in the training process of
a language model, considering that the training data is typically undisclosed?
We are motivated by the premise that a language model is likely to identify
verbatim excerpts from its training text. We propose DE-COP, a method to
determine whether a piece of copyrighted content was included in training.
DE-COP's core approach is to probe an LLM with multiple-choice questions, whose
options include both verbatim text and their paraphrases. We construct
BookTection, a benchmark with excerpts from 165 books published prior and
subsequent to a model's training cutoff, along with their paraphrases. Our
experiments show that DE-COP surpasses the prior best method by 9.6% in
detection performance (AUC) on models with logits available. Moreover, DE-COP
also achieves an average accuracy of 72% for detecting suspect books on fully
black-box models where prior methods give approximately 4% accuracy. The code
and datasets are available at https://github.com/LeiLiLab/DE-COP. | [
0.0622132719,
0.047535114,
-0.0308464635,
0.0961751491,
-0.0635810718,
0.0112404004,
0.0255484041,
0.0560743809,
0.0163838454,
-0.0490441881,
-0.001725751,
0.0327114724,
-0.0415004455,
-0.0185666177,
0.0071000978,
0.0479203686,
0.0298974607,
-0.0071885642,
-0.0125941122,
-0.0155316135,
0.0145677123,
0.0328581631,
0.0421356596,
0.0236145835,
0.0251155738,
-0.0486561619,
0.0080028055,
0.0007254195,
0.0303044152,
-0.0028550562,
0.0235328674,
0.0384070538,
-0.0059599578,
0.0760241002,
0.0000014566,
-0.0824849755,
-0.0583440959,
0.000274658,
-0.019143492,
0.0555454344,
0.0798691511,
0.0521274209,
0.0149152773,
0.0109148826,
-0.0312401727,
0.0517059006,
-0.0107832914,
0.0476880036,
0.059212666,
0.0656092837,
-0.0230517145,
0.0329957865,
0.0072918925,
-0.0008199723,
-0.0033144993,
0.006542454,
0.032888595,
0.028453704,
0.0282235779,
0.0297009069,
-0.0096342415,
0.0658349767,
0.00033588,
-0.0020630327,
-0.0398965701,
-0.0295899566,
-0.0085690795,
0.0112619558,
0.0160368849,
0.0375170596,
-0.0243472774,
-0.0528052822,
0.0403896794,
-0.0159932487,
0.0417260639,
0.0385094769,
-0.0208220184,
0.0521151349,
-0.0064548836,
0.0325681344,
0.0074691065,
-0.0423446335,
0.0303554386,
0.0154386135,
0.0411253758,
0.0445122607,
0.0234368257,
-0.036359068,
0.0222100671,
-0.011077662,
0.0003799659,
-0.0374165326,
0.0527003892,
-0.0096067451,
0.034458749,
0.0054815402,
-0.0802924037,
-0.0297851805,
0.0290161036,
-0.0436427519,
0.0161631424,
-0.0052563529,
-0.0183901973,
0.050813403,
-0.0465873927,
0.0307232607,
-0.0208305046,
0.0829715952,
-0.0281703845,
0.0130277798,
-0.0109507442,
-0.0267525148,
-0.0284750126,
0.0508900322,
0.0084750196,
-0.0088166567,
-0.0426495224,
0.0228517987,
0.0119842971,
0.0129826441,
-0.0172031559,
0.0011282871,
0.0214379821,
0.0151601871,
0.0274845585,
-0.0518279895,
0.0246767309,
0.0451633744,
-0.0171005372,
-0.0593154356,
-0.0081264162,
0.0303024668,
0.0068397457,
-0.0298835598,
0.0364418551,
0.0631078184,
0.0195716545,
-0.0437817834,
-0.0162224602,
-0.0699194446,
-0.0152777424,
-0.0211232528,
0.0150139527,
-0.0549857877,
-0.0185382124,
-0.0270833038,
0.016657114,
-0.0511757843,
-0.0026734248,
0.0314277858,
-0.0699036866,
0.0176383257,
0.0001818453,
-0.0011633696,
-0.0075663589,
0.0111388424,
-0.0279374048,
0.0350699835,
0.0350714549,
0.0201478191,
0.0878828838,
0.0070024715,
0.0263020173,
0.0840990171,
0.0287198294,
0.0307697766,
-0.0062178313,
-0.0249552149,
0.0237916876,
-0.0169868432,
0.0195791777,
0.0403097011,
-0.0003832384,
-0.0555529557,
0.0895169154,
0.0859432146,
-0.0292008072,
0.0255188346,
0.01696839,
0.03257633,
0.0308736004,
0.0237638969,
-0.0300508495,
-0.041373536,
-0.0526682511,
-0.0062840567,
-0.0176811386,
0.0137806442,
0.0443310142,
-0.0116376197,
-0.0308900122,
-0.001378341,
0.0026833273,
0.0130589083,
0.0094967475,
0.0207204744,
-0.029350413,
0.0426390581,
-0.0181572996,
-0.0381776802,
0.0139403436,
-0.0392895602,
0.0497592576,
0.0187014043,
0.0870431438,
-0.0114970487,
0.0550931059,
-0.0546954535,
-0.0293264575,
0.0322562605,
-0.0023308389,
-0.0175904706,
0.0154625848,
-0.0239074305,
-0.0431750193,
-0.0384757146,
0.01221673,
-0.0161743518,
0.0283888336,
0.0244791191,
0.0267974343,
-0.0259595122,
-0.0786773264,
0.052233465,
-0.0339184664,
-0.0246574152,
-0.0106466357,
-0.012717302,
0.0222263504,
0.0171787087,
-0.0170806907,
0.0016192485,
0.0242278073,
-0.0172096211,
-0.0415619574,
0.0202180855,
0.036554575,
-0.0374203883,
0.0869588479,
-0.0432153381,
-0.0104065044,
0.0640594885,
-0.0326799229,
0.0104947714,
-0.0277923252,
-0.0188972261,
0.031498652,
-0.0590275638,
0.0293217245,
-0.0524883233,
0.0272450447,
-0.0347885005,
0.0206940044,
-0.0031626811,
0.0426172763,
0.0652197674,
-0.072877571,
0.0631701127,
-0.000096723,
-0.0565407164,
-0.0027061794,
-0.0340641104,
0.0195517559,
0.0023291085,
0.0176134184,
-0.0396254547,
-0.0039560022,
-0.0266446006,
-0.000233746,
0.000427309,
0.0049663763,
0.008934903,
-0.036057774,
-0.0368998311,
0.0067600552,
-0.0145522095,
-0.0628239214,
0.010905602,
0.0079704421,
0.01402645,
-0.0218648594,
-0.03691734,
-0.0118965218,
0.0148221059,
-0.0151880356,
0.0326631814,
0.0084819328,
0.024384696,
-0.0579116382,
0.0625021383,
0.000813661,
-0.0060884263,
0.0078311563,
-0.008308433,
-0.0282244179,
-0.0201766081,
-0.0522044897,
0.0449232683,
0.0066087563,
-0.0289968383,
0.0461014025,
0.0069194711,
-0.0865978897,
-0.0147100892,
-0.0133801363,
-0.036609821,
-0.0436137468,
-0.0454728305,
0.0445793979,
0.006973377,
0.0110929562,
-0.0282009356,
0.0021896497,
0.0144889858,
-0.0315697975,
-0.0407146811,
-0.0154352328,
-0.0336339287,
-0.0519313738,
0.0356294215,
0.012849167,
-0.0504827201,
0.0487024337,
-0.0609661639,
0.0149600254,
-0.0268792603,
0.0134639218,
-0.0121059977,
0.0189128071,
0.0020776691,
0.0307641905,
0.0327392146,
-0.0232259762,
-0.0530340634,
0.0156985037,
0.0790922269,
-0.0451484546,
0.0190015957,
-0.0079834191,
-0.0030298776,
0.0059439456,
-0.0028000386,
-0.0446023829,
-0.0598132722,
-0.010516691,
-0.0196737032,
0.0073427144,
0.0038647291,
-0.0056587677,
-0.047227148,
0.0049889078,
0.0140783098,
-0.0240777172,
0.0067733503,
-0.0064418013,
0.0881952867,
0.0609504357,
-0.0237572473,
0.0211122278,
-0.0418888107,
-0.0287165996,
0.0469329171,
0.0001189735,
0.0438982546,
0.0209905468,
0.0025733637,
0.0242231619,
-0.0224642269,
0.0167537127,
0.0164470188,
0.0153665682,
-0.0426932722,
0.0042280382,
0.0860044658,
0.0099023208,
-0.0167526118,
-0.026965756,
-0.0214508269,
-0.0074862493,
0.0151415337,
-0.0053960849,
-0.0950035378,
-0.0100870058,
0.0010509941,
0.0276339334,
-0.012907018,
-0.0199131388,
-0.0069729933,
-0.1009751037,
0.0039555822,
-0.0019878508,
-0.0243094396,
-0.0012626663,
0.0041033467,
-0.0355630219,
-0.0199340284,
-0.0294951219,
-0.0484690592,
-0.0171459503,
0.0109594315,
-0.0167208575,
-0.0058492525,
-0.0216575284,
0.0162682682,
-0.0499837846,
0.0230179727,
0.0448072813,
0.0169456787,
-0.035231404,
-0.0225218292,
0.0333348736,
-0.0270596128,
-0.0518536568,
-0.0001410556,
0.0627221391,
-0.0292628389,
0.0140859811,
0.0148562118,
0.04385297,
0.0002281404,
-0.0093561159,
0.0359318703,
0.0624083169,
0.0242476389,
-0.0297743101,
-0.0290717054,
0.017602291,
0.0099396193,
0.0969252661,
0.0377774872,
-0.0272016618,
-0.0190003216,
-0.034068618,
-0.0258944612,
-0.0634155497,
-0.0344068669,
0.0072177895,
-0.0230449475,
0.001240737,
-0.0882900953,
0.0029039851,
-0.0380487703,
-0.0207917001,
0.048891928,
0.0457192957,
0.0175866708,
-0.0114128515,
-0.0372777767,
-0.0337442383,
-0.0637139305,
0.0051398017,
-0.0454861447,
0.0333467536,
0.0107795056,
0.0250336137,
-0.0197238978,
0.0035325992,
-0.1104489341,
-0.0671894848,
0.0215327889,
0.0324988253,
0.0202405024,
0.0443759225,
-0.0189371053,
-0.0233441703,
0.064412728,
0.0422935411,
-0.0331881493,
0.0416309759,
0.0549753606,
-0.0268343017,
-0.0204697177,
0.0458445549,
-0.0546821542,
-0.0188989211,
0.0438718759,
-0.031838309,
-0.0405556709,
-0.0195598397,
0.0083627654,
0.0377023518,
0.0008004292,
-0.0373828784,
0.0246868506,
-0.038814012,
0.0194356311,
0.0163348671,
-0.028126847,
-0.0370102562,
0.0297744516,
0.0394680239,
-0.0327775702,
-0.0040467186,
0.0387749523,
-0.0324898623,
0.072014533,
-0.0149980709,
0.0175033677,
0.0169472713,
-0.0024133103,
0.0069525177,
0.0002298618,
0.0129808262,
0.042648904,
-0.0074734716,
0.0598889738,
0.0190831926,
0.0610536374,
0.0296042766,
0.0043406701,
0.0407048538,
0.0350590348,
-0.0589801148,
-0.0035698593,
-0.0211266465,
0.0104747936,
0.0263743494,
-0.042027317,
0.0689499527,
-0.0363417156,
-0.0251335762,
-0.0161343422,
0.0263946373,
-0.0483849868,
-0.045188874,
-0.0029078526,
0.0010842056,
-0.0270857811,
0.0642748326,
0.0695036799,
0.0367105901,
0.0432648994,
0.0049960599,
-0.0490572937,
-0.0344594866,
-0.0269475393,
0.053562548,
-0.0103910044,
-0.0123807378,
0.002294793,
-0.0511204451,
-0.0692157447,
-0.0077410205,
0.0279511102,
0.019719094,
0.0062924922,
-0.0219222531,
0.0456236899,
-0.0094790161,
-0.0152313346,
-0.0559104048,
0.0414795242,
0.0240780301,
-0.0424921736,
-0.036248289,
-4.533112497e-33,
0.0155615658,
-0.0433370247,
-0.0419215485,
0.0464387089,
-0.00369247,
-0.0073277461,
-0.012417322,
-0.0196542013,
-0.016286198,
-0.0031457318,
-0.0249556676,
0.0162184481,
-0.0035495276,
-0.0020905787,
0.0139785334,
-0.028768016,
0.0243498124,
-0.0098433448,
-0.0581690222,
-0.0215079021,
0.0235838089,
0.0268115513,
0.0476792008,
-0.0614135116,
0.0462142676,
-0.0595516264,
-0.060834378,
-0.0218786914,
-0.0669347122,
0.0602771565,
-0.0078953542,
-0.0039780992,
0.0172953848,
-0.0428827442,
-0.001568794,
-0.0234855153,
-0.0113073792,
-0.0053997035,
0.0283027347,
0.0100303106,
0.0219036099,
-0.0438419469,
0.0572002903,
-0.016629599,
-0.0175794698,
-0.0178868957,
0.0537315905,
-0.0477645434,
-0.021193916,
-0.0516446978,
-0.0294545833,
0.0027992867,
-0.0185813643,
0.0298151094,
0.0557107739,
0.0527618974,
0.0126039032,
0.0411530733,
-0.0391852967,
0.0144414334,
0.0397823937,
0.0197975691,
0.0365647599,
-0.009586622,
0.0113547258,
0.0487158373,
-0.0048668478,
-0.0490528531,
0.0590683371,
0.0086584697,
0.0367636047,
0.0020549262,
0.0394658335,
0.1001278311,
0.0424764901,
0.0099926023,
0.0028263929,
0.0373837575,
-0.016772192,
-0.0110769309,
0.005607856,
-0.022158036,
-0.0277503449,
-0.0116652166,
-0.0386903435,
-0.0512027517,
-0.0163860209,
-0.0222473629,
0.0381898917,
-0.0053908308,
-0.0492441133,
-0.025192067,
0.0283051413,
-0.0706512034,
-0.0376317613,
-0.0035349876,
-0.0337701105,
0.0097721657,
0.0228229817,
0.0274631884,
-0.0298412945,
0.0269543082,
0.0138802482,
-0.0540068522,
0.0541604906,
-0.0169972144,
0.0711243078,
0.0286801234,
-0.06163726,
0.0254495516,
0.0076469332,
-0.0029078072,
0.0071094162,
0.0459675342,
-0.016754292,
0.0019439325,
0.0152440313,
-0.0103713768,
0.0242779795,
0.0121371746,
-0.0712338686,
-0.0136098498,
0.019672852,
0.0020621445,
-0.0313645899,
-0.0292316508,
0.0184546392,
0.0526004285,
0.044962436,
-0.0587771721,
0.0074183331,
0.0136707174,
2.17e-7,
0.0368997529,
-0.009194578,
0.0107722152,
-0.0178666431,
-0.0060071391,
0.0716835558,
-0.0186940767,
0.0477416404,
0.0079477914,
-0.0231765062,
-0.0083325393,
-0.01813595,
0.0685170367,
0.0052557471,
-0.1369369328,
-0.0294835288,
-0.0355408229,
-0.0210629795,
-0.0577871799,
-0.0100213597,
0.0342018791,
0.0701667964,
0.0709983706,
-0.0465608723,
-0.0156529564,
-0.0405162051,
0.0226659793,
-0.049861446,
-0.0199919455,
0.0026706026,
0.0570640825,
0.001532215,
0.0001635684,
-0.0274427198,
-0.0248673074,
0.0421905257,
0.0024718279,
0.0343620516,
0.0692044944,
-0.0181598328,
-0.0479798615,
-0.0514232814,
-0.0080639319,
-0.0617977194,
0.0627470985,
0.0566537529,
0.026858395,
-0.0373705998,
-0.0092102755,
-0.0697001964,
0.0209530164,
-0.0490899496,
-0.008812462,
0.0128955254,
-0.0133372005,
0.0051080985,
0.0085719759,
-0.0690261871,
0.0005991784,
-0.0521108434,
-0.0360228196,
-0.0178563446,
-0.0089478642,
0.0080718817,
0.0121017704,
-0.094949685,
0.0514009893,
2.172357641e-34,
0.0331997015,
-0.0463075861,
0.0077031325,
0.0390775204,
0.0212558191,
0.0129819596,
0.0502737761,
0.0128287552,
-0.0584709011,
-0.0406178236,
0.0045648697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09906v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09906v2 | Generative Representational Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-15T12:12:19 | 2024-04-17T17:12:05 | Niklas Muennighoff, Hongjin Su, Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Furu Wei, Tao Yu, Amanpreet Singh, Douwe Kiela | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | All text-based language problems can be reduced to either generation or
embedding. Current models only perform well at one or the other. We introduce
generative representational instruction tuning (GRIT) whereby a large language
model is trained to handle both generative and embedding tasks by
distinguishing between them through instructions. Compared to other open
models, our resulting GritLM 7B sets a new state of the art on the Massive Text
Embedding Benchmark (MTEB) and outperforms all models up to its size on a range
of generative tasks. By scaling up further, GritLM 8x7B outperforms all open
generative language models that we tried while still being among the best
embedding models. Notably, we find that GRIT matches training on only
generative or embedding data, thus we can unify both at no performance loss.
Among other benefits, the unification via GRIT speeds up Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) by > 60% for long documents, by no longer requiring separate
retrieval and generation models. Models, code, etc. are freely available at
https://github.com/ContextualAI/gritlm. | [
0.0143153658,
0.0797019526,
0.0277485177,
0.0419233702,
-0.0192883071,
0.0303317495,
0.0303444173,
-0.0059568598,
-0.0083191562,
-0.0452400558,
-0.003877396,
-0.008589264,
-0.0290778335,
0.0097371461,
0.0715047345,
-0.0146719627,
0.0363347679,
0.0085942429,
-0.008102159,
0.0192890447,
-0.0051607881,
0.0369765125,
0.0233288463,
0.015321211,
-0.0136501603,
-0.0253886282,
0.0090175746,
0.0132172089,
0.0251405146,
-0.0041709812,
0.0034254172,
0.0288035106,
0.0604136474,
0.0468374491,
0.0000019008,
-0.000987714,
-0.0106979655,
-0.0033527154,
0.0008306046,
0.0353946015,
0.0659422427,
-0.0433291607,
0.0001035711,
0.0433128774,
-0.0142527083,
-0.0570303835,
0.0251205191,
0.0464303941,
0.037514329,
0.1028298363,
-0.0112162521,
-0.0613544807,
0.0482574701,
-0.0542031452,
0.0364754349,
0.0031426051,
0.0025649762,
-0.0030225844,
-0.005498698,
0.0725823864,
-0.0276608095,
0.0395992063,
0.0378792323,
-0.0165436063,
0.0331912041,
0.0494349264,
-0.0243644286,
0.0187088847,
0.0059769722,
0.0759112164,
-0.0180465132,
-0.0289675295,
-0.0079570431,
-0.0034822451,
0.0009478789,
-0.0282031912,
-0.0103338053,
0.0414841175,
0.0309249926,
0.0406672135,
0.0034240892,
-0.0005816092,
0.050289169,
-0.0054290118,
-0.0140531184,
-0.0114604961,
0.0370655656,
-0.0252903737,
-0.0247070845,
-0.0053816955,
-0.0280828979,
-0.0048298612,
-0.0146016888,
0.0062708128,
-0.0221395232,
0.0176120996,
-0.0545836724,
-0.0296251141,
0.0400819145,
-0.0258737523,
0.0517238714,
0.0576222017,
0.0010610197,
0.045484174,
-0.0499988906,
0.0486009829,
-0.0096586673,
-0.0012997887,
-0.0436986461,
0.0089847408,
-0.0327772126,
0.0062217517,
-0.0521770716,
-0.0213853717,
-0.0705808923,
-0.0367482863,
-0.0076538688,
0.0550415553,
0.0037411891,
0.0088861901,
-0.0083519518,
0.028249789,
-0.0326551683,
0.0026391596,
0.0014913114,
-0.0065241493,
-0.053450916,
-0.0205498319,
0.0298370179,
-0.0279224142,
-0.0314182118,
0.0377466828,
0.027637979,
-0.0203661304,
0.001367476,
0.0235457048,
-0.0285128672,
-0.0189474225,
-0.0613377392,
-0.0171316285,
-0.0011171834,
-0.0707938224,
-0.0089414325,
-0.0533306412,
0.038362354,
-0.0102197295,
-0.0261084344,
-0.0590233803,
-0.000363065,
0.0347297825,
-0.0147884209,
0.0417685881,
0.0368271656,
-0.0267192684,
0.023901796,
0.0193076152,
0.0356657729,
0.0530425496,
0.0141387573,
0.0152538745,
0.0087452792,
0.0136036128,
-0.0175012369,
0.0021721425,
0.0525762662,
0.0288206507,
0.0099385567,
0.0222172718,
0.0281325225,
0.0515324809,
0.0744784102,
0.0658566579,
-0.0567191876,
-0.0476039201,
0.0207020696,
0.018689068,
0.0287797805,
0.0306673348,
0.0909058899,
0.0384106487,
-0.0322804339,
0.0073678293,
-0.016696196,
0.0157856811,
-0.0042788028,
0.0175711773,
0.0748265088,
0.0123800961,
-0.0520369709,
-0.0184889846,
-0.0033920582,
-0.0243140925,
0.0053917514,
-0.0262010172,
0.0008291021,
0.0222247411,
-0.0891113281,
-0.004766426,
0.0290516205,
-0.063656956,
-0.000462942,
-0.0310353264,
0.0327194259,
0.0720772445,
0.0678976551,
0.0168280508,
-0.0159840398,
-0.0151692843,
0.0180952586,
0.0369271077,
0.0294506643,
-0.0147298202,
0.0136776427,
-0.0889437944,
-0.0267936066,
-0.0661954209,
0.0112538505,
0.02927831,
0.0280912351,
0.0078797527,
0.0643555224,
-0.0154518373,
-0.0286843143,
0.0414809808,
-0.0567927212,
-0.0669106469,
0.0052015036,
0.0109778102,
-0.0109031694,
-0.0003850287,
-0.0251162462,
0.0156996939,
0.0225703232,
-0.0309368372,
0.0043851594,
-0.037407577,
-0.0759797171,
-0.0661287829,
-0.0079813348,
-0.0262319166,
0.0107714226,
0.0053964183,
-0.0517481044,
-0.0340991355,
0.0294198319,
-0.0359314233,
0.0411068983,
-0.0742905959,
-0.0023810768,
0.0259626098,
0.0163022149,
-0.0421189442,
0.050811328,
-0.0288385618,
0.0055911229,
0.0369343385,
0.0499099344,
0.0173566267,
-0.0506333485,
-0.0040400708,
-0.0147018712,
0.0281667821,
0.0367768109,
0.0075093769,
0.025080502,
-0.049484469,
-0.035283871,
-0.0883932039,
0.0268347487,
-0.0401578508,
0.0091826757,
0.0298535638,
0.0150451576,
0.0039990805,
-0.0054767323,
-0.039228227,
0.0006125731,
0.0036178718,
0.0064803772,
0.0141834915,
-0.0005239454,
0.0097150179,
-0.0248696581,
-0.0096563753,
0.0154658975,
0.050326243,
0.0022587972,
0.0600689836,
-0.0536399595,
0.0416728258,
-0.0188680124,
0.0074960832,
-0.0109097045,
-0.0172079299,
-0.0022786174,
-0.0430641584,
0.0940499976,
0.0533913039,
0.0083318688,
0.0486666895,
0.035925515,
0.0103823896,
-0.0704021901,
0.0178715643,
-0.0306461975,
-0.0044075763,
-0.0047342884,
-0.0324762315,
-0.004530625,
0.052042108,
-0.0085753258,
-0.0209479388,
-0.0568961687,
0.0093444828,
-0.0075844214,
-0.0264614541,
-0.0210374743,
0.0131877493,
0.009233146,
-0.0255328733,
-0.0368505307,
-0.0665849894,
0.0449861698,
-0.0331453755,
-0.0154316006,
-0.0712231174,
-0.0081750546,
-0.0314648114,
0.0319121778,
0.006795513,
0.0382658653,
0.0085293986,
-0.0050650141,
-0.0459050722,
0.0276317503,
0.0016579984,
-0.0038784491,
0.002552192,
-0.0112645719,
0.0077392338,
-0.0240152162,
-0.0306231156,
-0.0520625971,
-0.0549504831,
0.0649922639,
0.023405673,
0.0599238127,
-0.0279864129,
-0.0395601764,
-0.026319351,
0.0147672668,
0.0465068556,
-0.0134532107,
-0.026256986,
-0.0304858573,
0.017527245,
0.0502816029,
-0.0258404836,
-0.0216783602,
-0.0280338526,
-0.0142892012,
0.0478783995,
0.028148951,
-0.0119269881,
-0.041305922,
0.0168861561,
0.011735131,
-0.0109591708,
-0.0120957,
0.0124057354,
0.0315536149,
-0.0366860814,
-0.0467807762,
0.1124752238,
0.0484287292,
-0.0543307252,
-0.0152713405,
0.0006062733,
0.0504915006,
-0.0080506476,
0.0439239219,
-0.0719289556,
-0.0073885033,
-0.0122161144,
0.0419962592,
0.0383484103,
0.0111886319,
-0.0265796445,
-0.0899764746,
0.0484068878,
0.0308367051,
-0.0152976178,
-0.0601489618,
-0.011442543,
-0.0523990095,
0.019340001,
0.0289428551,
0.0245494619,
-0.0338440202,
0.0212675948,
0.0150772436,
0.0480828471,
-0.0678716302,
-0.0050494056,
-0.0355655588,
0.0276489761,
0.051804278,
0.0253142007,
0.0659864992,
-0.0449371673,
-0.0037757186,
-0.0106378701,
-0.0264592376,
-0.0239267834,
0.0710719004,
-0.0180041846,
0.0156615078,
-0.0107237566,
0.038946934,
-0.0273398086,
0.0093549173,
-0.0005404059,
0.0475065783,
-0.0019271182,
-0.0024700193,
-0.021370247,
-0.0186885726,
0.0303316824,
0.0736355111,
0.0476233996,
-0.0324105546,
-0.0529497825,
-0.0366392136,
0.0296387281,
-0.0910219103,
-0.004832719,
-0.0187207963,
0.0151753668,
0.0094131129,
-0.0925243944,
-0.0776253939,
0.003317853,
0.0357149951,
-0.0179196242,
-0.0390446261,
-0.0484780036,
-0.0561738871,
-0.074118495,
0.0142478021,
-0.0320314467,
-0.0115245953,
-0.0606391989,
-0.0552709103,
0.0293072928,
-0.0156882275,
-0.0253511146,
-0.0030013029,
-0.0774180889,
-0.0587927885,
-0.0458685346,
0.0295007154,
-0.000044156,
0.0574826822,
-0.0080246311,
-0.0355501994,
0.0766467452,
0.0216938015,
-0.0538578406,
0.0184885636,
0.0292109493,
-0.0041804076,
-0.0045261723,
0.0447537266,
-0.0229127314,
0.0227981973,
-0.0019895989,
0.0504387394,
0.0197765436,
0.0315830708,
-0.0033783847,
-0.0290410705,
-0.0037958855,
-0.0240146481,
0.0110973353,
-0.0662500709,
0.0136604225,
-0.0332574435,
-0.0110128345,
-0.0443294384,
0.0173329264,
0.0481401756,
-0.0153230103,
-0.0096085416,
0.051246047,
0.0208561625,
0.0604645088,
-0.0504254885,
0.0118607683,
0.0002538842,
0.0090943072,
0.0149443122,
0.0286766421,
-0.0346715041,
0.0044386266,
-0.0302046221,
0.0355376862,
-0.0453488491,
0.0499877594,
0.011621709,
0.0168827511,
-0.0160229132,
0.0155014303,
-0.0449953824,
0.0114152376,
-0.0238077026,
0.0187768731,
0.053440243,
-0.0180861223,
0.0783295631,
-0.0100681102,
-0.0173697602,
-0.0303417612,
0.0309136659,
-0.0024737588,
-0.0552113019,
-0.0063604373,
0.0223216191,
-0.027129814,
-0.0051721721,
0.085274525,
0.0348024592,
0.0390600078,
-0.0218554586,
0.0123070693,
-0.0554367751,
-0.0327057168,
0.0264000352,
0.0356926285,
-0.0107093034,
0.0364580229,
-0.0017549718,
-0.0604552217,
-0.0336901657,
0.0237357821,
-0.0296670459,
0.0170044284,
0.0505283996,
0.0370561294,
-0.0326145813,
-0.0106267203,
-0.0566435456,
0.0250718687,
-0.0207123123,
-0.0548728183,
-0.0403809175,
-6.269271368e-33,
-0.0098297717,
0.0005788613,
0.0330215506,
-0.041376017,
-0.0229897946,
0.0149551369,
-0.0476257615,
-0.0240677334,
-0.0078183534,
0.0112921447,
-0.0046904171,
0.0017423243,
-0.0081771715,
0.0794842318,
-0.0302911159,
0.0271094479,
0.0586736873,
-0.0209823567,
-0.0278592091,
0.0826611593,
0.0573296212,
0.0292772874,
0.001329574,
-0.0196230318,
0.0038861479,
-0.0178014021,
0.0085311765,
-0.0127654085,
0.0300116632,
0.0603889115,
-0.0517219454,
0.0278731957,
0.0014070992,
-0.0125618251,
-0.0458047949,
-0.0018493661,
-0.1013591513,
-0.0178546961,
-0.0135657992,
-0.0181668326,
-0.085625276,
-0.0546711944,
0.0237129945,
-0.0251299478,
-0.0048040841,
-0.0410430878,
0.02089612,
0.0122415284,
-0.0244985633,
-0.012778257,
-0.0860496387,
0.0099964272,
0.0132513708,
-0.0172586441,
0.0317134336,
0.0097152647,
0.0382679068,
0.0193262361,
-0.0409321152,
-0.0016149313,
-0.0259506144,
0.0605306588,
0.0296495464,
0.0242178012,
0.0043696235,
0.0367597789,
-0.012988287,
-0.0211683922,
-0.0264997706,
-0.0004614872,
0.0305077899,
0.0321740434,
0.0052043293,
0.0266019832,
0.0146604255,
-0.0014280233,
-0.0792140588,
0.0357659459,
-0.0028249347,
0.0046565565,
0.0594366156,
0.0366784595,
-0.0273926519,
-0.0169300493,
-0.0359468162,
-0.0022422399,
-0.0272032432,
-0.0310162138,
0.0505811758,
0.0619213134,
-0.024540212,
-0.0296845026,
0.0438984223,
-0.030909339,
-0.0012799485,
0.0644301847,
-0.0336416513,
-0.0172862262,
0.0049227956,
0.023079928,
-0.0612706058,
-0.0420550779,
0.0633131638,
0.003264677,
-0.0173118357,
0.0015167866,
0.0464966409,
0.0234634131,
-0.072218217,
0.02356226,
-0.0576949492,
0.0190699454,
-0.0083493125,
0.023477003,
0.0086584594,
0.0121505894,
0.001675657,
0.0288165938,
0.0171481557,
0.0210200511,
-0.0054645743,
-0.0385803059,
0.0083064111,
0.0264165904,
-0.0357027054,
0.046306055,
-0.0318645388,
0.0412278473,
0.0382352881,
-0.0504251681,
-0.0062922915,
0.0104342001,
2.42e-7,
0.0311908107,
0.0251754727,
0.0378055163,
0.0250931196,
0.0093274433,
0.0117135961,
0.0181998555,
0.0501792207,
0.0089937784,
0.0209926628,
0.0199643169,
0.0292364359,
0.0428608432,
-0.0055208085,
-0.0722524151,
0.0706145614,
-0.0522554666,
0.0183692276,
-0.0371624082,
-0.0350220688,
0.0522243753,
0.0960111544,
-0.0190437511,
0.0151340384,
0.0378384292,
-0.0448024608,
0.0938985646,
-0.0110812346,
0.002991596,
0.0037455577,
-0.0067796079,
0.0527990311,
-0.0121809784,
-0.0666779131,
-0.0407559536,
0.0223092642,
-0.0069945618,
0.0889316052,
0.0225202069,
-0.0341698192,
0.0288944338,
-0.0123465555,
-0.0219754521,
-0.0405612886,
0.0621849597,
-0.0267854594,
-0.003975634,
0.0126423668,
-0.0054548224,
0.0119394064,
0.0286416877,
-0.0229231697,
-0.0406633057,
0.0288022049,
0.0298296027,
-0.0205243658,
-0.0043979418,
-0.103143461,
-0.0102408361,
-0.0079316227,
-0.0394912772,
-0.0189507231,
-0.0460525528,
0.0166016538,
0.0244281292,
-0.0309658684,
-0.007328108,
2.630183763e-34,
0.0336008184,
-0.0044406066,
0.0061918884,
-0.0286970269,
0.0268726107,
-0.0024720295,
-0.0139447683,
0.0141812628,
0.0122319506,
-0.0954827815,
-0.0452879928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09894v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09894v2 | Not Just Novelty: A Longitudinal Study on Utility and Customization of an AI Workflow | 2024-02-15T11:39:11 | 2024-05-31T16:00:05 | Tao Long, Katy Ilonka Gero, Lydia B. Chilton | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Generative AI brings novel and impressive abilities to help people in
everyday tasks. There are many AI workflows that solve real and complex
problems by chaining AI outputs together with human interaction. Although there
is an undeniable lure of AI, it is uncertain how useful generative AI workflows
are after the novelty wears off. Additionally, workflows built with generative
AI have the potential to be easily customized to fit users' individual needs,
but do users take advantage of this? We conducted a three-week longitudinal
study with 12 users to understand the familiarization and customization of
generative AI tools for science communication. Our study revealed that there
exists a familiarization phase, during which users were exploring the novel
capabilities of the workflow and discovering which aspects they found useful.
After this phase, users understood the workflow and were able to anticipate the
outputs. Surprisingly, after familiarization the perceived utility of the
system was rated higher than before, indicating that the perceived utility of
AI is not just a novelty effect. The increase in benefits mainly comes from
end-users' ability to customize prompts, and thus potentially appropriate the
system to their own needs. This points to a future where generative AI systems
can allow us to design for appropriation. | [
0.0643350109,
0.0577879101,
-0.030685978,
-0.0597253516,
-0.0216091871,
0.0132508334,
0.0542557277,
-0.0070854011,
0.0386247449,
0.0409188084,
-0.0186812095,
0.0310687106,
-0.0290004481,
0.0748409554,
-0.0371132679,
-0.0748753697,
-0.0081547974,
-0.0044107968,
0.0494545698,
0.0162463747,
-0.0260803495,
0.0049132663,
-0.0190710295,
0.0658795312,
0.0056329486,
-0.0474635214,
0.0116588166,
-0.0045687291,
0.0484429821,
-0.0464320295,
0.0180259068,
0.0733256564,
0.0245903451,
0.0543737821,
0.0000020898,
-0.0608746074,
0.0512571707,
0.0232902616,
-0.0880089998,
-0.0108124614,
0.0666891262,
0.0824172869,
-0.0273585171,
-0.0027100195,
-0.0420059673,
0.0265460201,
0.0800926089,
-0.031436149,
-0.0094122142,
-0.0172860473,
-0.0128171621,
-0.0015940065,
0.008789585,
-0.000555748,
0.0603476316,
0.008708396,
-0.0137340091,
-0.0261804406,
0.0794766098,
-0.0063461596,
0.0305204224,
0.0621360652,
0.021654442,
-0.0508289561,
0.0554088131,
0.05851781,
0.0627044141,
-0.0519905947,
-0.0208476353,
0.0572206937,
0.029410176,
0.0096156066,
-0.0042685149,
-0.0146547277,
0.026128646,
0.0334950313,
-0.0811428726,
0.002884117,
-0.0239104908,
-0.0488050096,
-0.0370058715,
0.0230400506,
-0.0185210053,
-0.0070197051,
0.0209627356,
0.032778915,
-0.0034072585,
0.0028094905,
-0.0037030743,
0.0128587708,
0.0708278492,
-0.0692219436,
0.0239528883,
0.0450290479,
-0.0086677205,
0.0003988993,
0.0139779113,
-0.0572435856,
0.0036591878,
0.0140928132,
0.0403924324,
0.0254713204,
0.0058518634,
0.0147191929,
0.0223254003,
0.029570058,
-0.017079398,
0.0114846602,
0.0198481753,
0.0405691862,
-0.088819325,
-0.0502919294,
-0.0110060405,
0.0076664737,
-0.0188236032,
-0.0122438576,
0.0246193856,
0.0317035466,
-0.0216973331,
0.0120499562,
-0.016562216,
0.0288170967,
-0.0291333664,
-0.0108849742,
-0.0495008491,
0.0131803816,
-0.0722281411,
0.0258416738,
0.0332345143,
-0.033197809,
0.0005256252,
0.0125915213,
0.0269212648,
0.0159323514,
0.0140668694,
0.0105778426,
0.0117040873,
-0.001427399,
-0.0211831145,
-0.0608174093,
0.0346113332,
-0.0160014164,
0.0229224488,
-0.0229535513,
0.0523949005,
0.0537434667,
-0.0286619458,
-0.0537871309,
-0.028769549,
0.0110742822,
-0.0060005155,
0.0258859619,
-0.0172783695,
0.025800813,
0.0508830436,
0.0404575989,
-0.0003228361,
-0.0287719797,
0.0185047742,
0.0422156937,
-0.0103468075,
-0.0091324281,
0.0663310438,
-0.0093165403,
-0.0570164286,
0.0041676154,
0.0254016183,
0.0129598603,
-0.0726480708,
0.0156465061,
0.0207044054,
0.0023924212,
-0.0336936787,
0.0740541816,
0.0383704342,
0.0575712062,
0.0139530022,
0.0118192043,
0.024693165,
-0.0266390219,
0.0247158986,
-0.0304455757,
0.019909529,
0.1019719839,
-0.0065799919,
-0.0238279179,
-0.0681675076,
0.0279387236,
-0.0390541404,
-0.0505201705,
0.0082475962,
0.000955546,
0.0170072559,
0.0172367226,
0.0146973534,
0.0525673069,
0.0064573791,
-0.0775465146,
-0.0411604792,
-0.0701257139,
-0.0331560075,
-0.0599131063,
0.0608416162,
0.1207272112,
0.0511239134,
-0.0106982915,
0.0050508063,
-0.0245303903,
-0.0190859865,
0.0474032946,
0.0242493823,
-0.0156550184,
-0.0622578003,
-0.0048367064,
-0.035477303,
-0.0567471273,
-0.0109969275,
0.0423029177,
0.001616283,
0.0379353985,
-0.0189693645,
0.0014741415,
-0.0166960582,
0.0134113524,
-0.0688559487,
-0.0523559973,
-0.0261477083,
0.0068185581,
0.0221765265,
0.0329097621,
0.0188873373,
0.0358099453,
0.0310753752,
0.0019651458,
-0.0397868454,
0.0538719073,
0.009144241,
0.0651963502,
-0.0270387996,
-0.0381750613,
-0.0079281302,
-0.0150895305,
0.0096818004,
-0.0020182759,
0.0363625921,
0.0069747679,
0.0055232043,
0.0005643322,
-0.0116569512,
-0.0180317946,
-0.0177778993,
-0.0273280162,
0.0374562256,
0.0222385284,
-0.0526391007,
0.0044347369,
-0.0037831024,
0.0090207886,
-0.014971707,
-0.0039735371,
0.0048999269,
0.0123314476,
-0.0059843063,
0.0167036727,
-0.0423080958,
-0.0387740321,
-0.0197770018,
-0.0464960523,
-0.0254096612,
0.0106197055,
0.0043370859,
0.0194505043,
-0.0070822164,
-0.0096613299,
-0.0261861105,
-0.0308356658,
0.0020105946,
-0.0124905389,
0.0030129617,
0.0442134142,
0.0457115844,
0.0052380441,
-0.0245122313,
0.0155310491,
-0.012107159,
0.0153348781,
0.1012070999,
0.0016002045,
-0.096615389,
-0.015472535,
-0.0200192034,
-0.0449151099,
0.0109982267,
0.0197394416,
0.0464089103,
-0.0149879772,
0.0781646669,
0.0306248348,
0.0063123112,
0.0493935272,
0.0624278039,
0.0021176494,
-0.03656587,
0.0182973463,
-0.010112701,
-0.010485528,
0.0579674132,
-0.0115100257,
0.0489552356,
-0.013294735,
-0.0262002032,
0.0245344881,
0.0084251473,
0.0866497308,
0.0283375327,
-0.0454812758,
0.0135935508,
-0.0541264489,
-0.0186359808,
0.0470749028,
-0.0003930518,
-0.0465362631,
0.0571788512,
0.0583738349,
-0.0270845648,
-0.0391339287,
-0.0142098404,
0.0045062257,
0.0676439255,
-0.0608900636,
0.0314042047,
0.035083171,
0.0008990177,
-0.02136904,
0.0197230652,
-0.0218734518,
-0.011824524,
-0.0333205163,
-0.0203396156,
-0.0242643487,
0.0194693506,
-0.0031918928,
-0.0298029818,
0.0126199098,
-0.0238079559,
-0.0103714084,
0.0310769733,
-0.0607482679,
-0.0104056764,
-0.0316082425,
0.0900225714,
0.0466753729,
0.0104656592,
-0.0447128937,
-0.0006560049,
-0.0048022172,
0.0209480226,
0.0107026286,
-0.0166733898,
0.0119240955,
-0.0089816265,
0.0321025737,
0.0045561823,
-0.024101574,
-0.0446632355,
-0.0384371206,
0.0193935763,
-0.0094844243,
0.0137600452,
0.0239261836,
0.042571906,
-0.0259502828,
0.0191485658,
0.0309552345,
0.0236178078,
-0.0463433415,
0.0254176799,
-0.0284392349,
0.0016938112,
0.010250248,
0.0598808825,
-0.0750250295,
0.0282834601,
-0.004826053,
0.024546843,
-0.0500699505,
-0.0485234596,
0.0028831691,
-0.0377455242,
0.0796314925,
-0.0103802755,
-0.0333078168,
0.0062644281,
-0.0352839045,
0.0008209725,
0.0408892371,
-0.0144386534,
0.0149386534,
0.0046868962,
-0.0014755251,
0.0034182759,
-0.0230097957,
-0.0511766337,
0.0301598608,
0.0373051576,
0.0343829505,
0.0905556157,
0.0176982433,
-0.0004946064,
-0.0764266104,
-0.0444813333,
0.0545710176,
0.0509049222,
0.0022300484,
0.0449189804,
0.0238219574,
0.006740571,
-0.0593988635,
0.0550170839,
-0.0365301855,
-0.0286993794,
0.0275162123,
0.070783034,
-0.0173781794,
-0.0681469962,
-0.0639357939,
-0.0556043796,
0.0612809584,
0.0175164193,
0.0279617608,
-0.0426955074,
-0.0393844321,
-0.0359938703,
0.0573491789,
-0.0221072529,
-0.0227582902,
-0.0278733559,
0.011112242,
-0.0234789699,
-0.0689915568,
-0.0373177007,
0.0422571674,
0.0251728836,
0.0034336564,
-0.0642734095,
-0.0273254048,
0.017312428,
-0.0088460362,
0.0045667007,
0.0168191046,
0.0049217055,
-0.0482496321,
-0.0662787631,
-0.0048275711,
-0.0070476523,
-0.0019867297,
0.0137342215,
0.0049184812,
-0.0063605867,
0.0058950111,
0.0518184043,
0.0367319845,
-0.0513246022,
0.0034214836,
-0.0271280725,
0.0118302964,
0.0502971299,
0.014868143,
-0.0268836096,
-0.0369656719,
0.0514166988,
-0.0213098861,
-0.0519402251,
0.008764836,
0.013694346,
0.0088515934,
0.0034619097,
-0.0135107702,
-0.0303803887,
0.0102872569,
0.0600055903,
-0.0093995603,
-0.0285289567,
0.0220391881,
-0.0092340335,
-0.0161091592,
0.002722448,
0.0135440743,
-0.0203387775,
-0.0122257881,
-0.0225042291,
0.0128472373,
0.0514076501,
0.0073847384,
-0.0490298383,
0.0170589089,
-0.0855371282,
0.0364981107,
-0.0020200186,
0.052598089,
0.0175979696,
0.0162832495,
-0.0331288278,
0.0311386082,
-0.0176167041,
0.0394734405,
0.0465018526,
0.035871122,
-0.0110937161,
-0.0077957609,
0.0085776392,
0.0564151667,
-0.0727380663,
-0.1109656096,
0.0066376585,
0.0538084656,
-0.0047221514,
0.0513462946,
-0.0227803197,
-0.0477067567,
-0.0059150457,
-0.0382916927,
-0.0065254583,
0.0146644423,
-0.0081610214,
-0.030375652,
0.0226767268,
-0.0232783724,
-0.0830756649,
0.0311108064,
-0.0611289106,
0.0555692986,
-0.0821223035,
-0.0241340231,
-0.0419863276,
-0.0257211253,
-0.0182818007,
-0.0157592669,
0.0010009338,
-0.0364196785,
-0.0659819096,
-0.0145114297,
-0.0093404902,
-0.030718999,
-0.0062777982,
-0.0352748409,
0.0407727659,
0.0496805906,
-0.054093428,
-0.0577127673,
0.0410062745,
0.0189608056,
-0.0447805338,
-0.0345803052,
-0.0634239614,
-5.957442472e-33,
0.0456060544,
-0.051055707,
0.0035508347,
0.0037272447,
0.0562939495,
-0.0440282412,
-0.0549272485,
0.0221916996,
0.0042496943,
0.0212152358,
-0.0307235103,
-0.0590919629,
0.0026935791,
-0.0577582195,
0.0384840444,
0.0297853891,
0.0939683914,
0.0215871464,
-0.0409692563,
0.0566250719,
0.0320093967,
-0.0073438864,
0.002263895,
-0.0764769167,
0.0140586672,
0.0030924554,
-0.0035896846,
-0.0197521783,
-0.0209902041,
0.0055380161,
0.0050236355,
0.0067969933,
0.0227498338,
-0.0012487029,
-0.0334252492,
0.0780159011,
-0.0366292968,
-0.0282590892,
-0.0139288101,
-0.04879684,
-0.0608552322,
-0.053381864,
0.0083930539,
-0.0184077583,
-0.0652248785,
0.0158653129,
0.0450862609,
0.0066739335,
0.0038161243,
-0.0291830506,
-0.0553882234,
-0.0083443625,
0.0044330847,
0.004216216,
-0.0322215371,
0.0436669402,
-0.0251076743,
-0.0020844943,
-0.0593785495,
0.0656494647,
0.0270661432,
-0.0501408391,
0.0303265881,
-0.0124113355,
0.0175263435,
0.0128235817,
0.0342132747,
0.0215358846,
-0.0499114469,
0.0115859387,
-0.0157622807,
0.0084026782,
0.0314936489,
0.011630768,
0.015117581,
-0.0509559624,
0.0147238765,
0.0541484207,
-0.0069705378,
0.0186454803,
0.0332607403,
0.0345440656,
-0.0274752285,
-0.0057427175,
0.0164518356,
-0.0044282,
-0.0270912908,
-0.0492685214,
0.0003465796,
-0.0033831948,
-0.009728062,
-0.0357734151,
-0.0122674871,
0.0049090581,
0.0096869236,
0.0061055864,
-0.0114098443,
0.0580949225,
0.0176674575,
-0.0366138816,
-0.0497778393,
0.013788579,
0.0129669728,
0.0468137003,
0.0454585217,
0.0291861705,
0.0075870915,
0.0312086008,
-0.0249368548,
-0.0159808639,
-0.0159426015,
0.033944238,
0.050836131,
-0.056439478,
0.0023288559,
-0.0022345108,
0.0080502564,
-0.0184961595,
-0.010673644,
0.0202918388,
-0.0444021598,
0.0165876485,
-0.0508585311,
-0.0315972008,
-0.0416910984,
-0.0274652559,
-0.0232592523,
0.0241808277,
0.0461567529,
-0.0018600851,
-0.0139613627,
-0.0383884422,
2.839e-7,
-0.0069382819,
0.0102093192,
0.009948845,
-0.0000455627,
0.0462668017,
-0.0085607227,
-0.0123727657,
0.0061215479,
0.0145185636,
0.0210285578,
0.0301648472,
0.0066297809,
0.0085593285,
-0.0000655967,
-0.0731645823,
-0.0819446295,
-0.0416889153,
0.0465831198,
-0.0560508817,
0.0113222888,
0.0734523162,
-0.0603781231,
0.0085805729,
-0.0039936453,
0.0145114427,
0.0065635503,
0.0156639013,
-0.004016391,
0.0895653665,
0.0000996386,
0.0097000357,
0.0335520059,
0.0232658349,
-0.0030577979,
-0.014423606,
-0.0633994788,
-0.0361451581,
0.0643663332,
-0.0156146269,
-0.0101095801,
0.0409624837,
0.0316858664,
0.0472646877,
-0.0491949618,
-0.0127938008,
-0.0556939803,
-0.022660885,
0.0022990936,
-0.0195207503,
-0.0084969113,
0.0062031588,
-0.0259953588,
-0.0036540788,
-0.0190723576,
-0.0332055539,
0.0175340492,
-0.0133313872,
-0.0212856364,
0.0174042825,
-0.0022307022,
-0.0344924778,
-0.0482341982,
-0.0593277253,
-0.028295951,
0.0211730972,
-0.0032860991,
0.0151517289,
1.894030311e-34,
-0.0013732534,
0.0386477895,
0.0074300356,
0.008608995,
0.0222979728,
0.0317752808,
0.0268064905,
0.0150512783,
0.0683569387,
0.0109168952,
-0.0445871092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09880v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09880v1 | Inadequacies of Large Language Model Benchmarks in the Era of Generative Artificial Intelligence | 2024-02-15T11:08:10 | 2024-02-15T11:08:10 | Timothy R. McIntosh, Teo Susnjak, Tong Liu, Paul Watters, Malka N. Halgamuge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | The rapid rise in popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs) with emerging
capabilities has spurred public curiosity to evaluate and compare different
LLMs, leading many researchers to propose their LLM benchmarks. Noticing
preliminary inadequacies in those benchmarks, we embarked on a study to
critically assess 23 state-of-the-art LLM benchmarks, using our novel unified
evaluation framework through the lenses of people, process, and technology,
under the pillars of functionality and security. Our research uncovered
significant limitations, including biases, difficulties in measuring genuine
reasoning, adaptability, implementation inconsistencies, prompt engineering
complexity, evaluator diversity, and the overlooking of cultural and
ideological norms in one comprehensive assessment. Our discussions emphasized
the urgent need for standardized methodologies, regulatory certainties, and
ethical guidelines in light of Artificial Intelligence (AI) advancements,
including advocating for an evolution from static benchmarks to dynamic
behavioral profiling to accurately capture LLMs' complex behaviors and
potential risks. Our study highlighted the necessity for a paradigm shift in
LLM evaluation methodologies, underlining the importance of collaborative
efforts for the development of universally accepted benchmarks and the
enhancement of AI systems' integration into society. | [
0.0279039666,
0.0767632648,
-0.0304287169,
0.0127228051,
-0.0761478469,
0.0028637541,
0.0293523427,
-0.0142466808,
0.0044314475,
-0.0253400598,
-0.0138158379,
-0.0462225005,
0.0087424535,
0.0526926853,
0.0362848639,
0.0199642163,
0.0472008996,
-0.0395066589,
0.0047001266,
0.0071698334,
-0.0052574053,
0.0150536569,
0.0160233993,
0.0592727587,
0.0047565429,
0.0147208022,
0.0159708932,
-0.0106620351,
0.0142562548,
-0.0203791019,
-0.0345251635,
0.0161920674,
-0.0115008615,
0.0876993909,
0.0000021462,
-0.0928309634,
-0.0123083638,
0.0450381078,
-0.0100915665,
0.0444592759,
0.0561770499,
0.0117511349,
-0.0395451449,
0.0272834413,
-0.043513,
0.0259298682,
0.042627342,
-0.0074571101,
0.0019511636,
0.0667339638,
-0.0056963176,
-0.0202929415,
0.0490033403,
-0.0122993849,
-0.050444942,
-0.0523050204,
0.0309296791,
0.0257250369,
-0.0064278725,
-0.0263604373,
0.006649985,
0.0281926095,
0.027781086,
-0.0293255206,
-0.0379939601,
0.0151943257,
-0.0417642258,
-0.0281620044,
0.0110250134,
0.0327265896,
0.0018898594,
0.0060679014,
0.015590013,
-0.0079671852,
-0.0289210398,
-0.0102083385,
-0.0094628772,
0.0380732827,
0.0154379634,
0.0158559475,
0.0444084816,
0.0210068021,
0.0618092827,
0.0321400911,
-0.0280935951,
0.0915324017,
0.0199170802,
-0.0202145167,
0.0087749967,
-0.0458441749,
0.0176695231,
-0.0595476329,
-0.0183149707,
0.03325155,
-0.0322660357,
0.0365005694,
-0.02019733,
-0.0262047146,
0.045784466,
-0.0456741974,
0.0591809973,
0.0445724577,
0.0309582986,
0.0307132509,
0.0005267237,
0.0859591514,
-0.0268729813,
0.0258146804,
-0.0204052422,
0.0044132401,
-0.0504439548,
-0.0121978093,
0.0290871039,
0.0166260861,
-0.0053491043,
-0.0186227951,
-0.0269559342,
0.0380549505,
-0.0327997208,
0.036002446,
-0.0242046621,
-0.0457553603,
0.0149235316,
-0.0065566022,
-0.0272614658,
-0.0211643875,
-0.0505749136,
0.0181259476,
0.0061044921,
-0.0916735306,
0.0370294452,
0.0226638578,
-0.0466334037,
-0.0234948527,
0.0088259047,
0.0889893323,
0.0091087893,
-0.0164150987,
-0.0402709432,
-0.0229593199,
-0.0292522516,
-0.0667785853,
-0.0079792337,
-0.0666065514,
0.011899896,
0.015972523,
-0.0275150724,
-0.0557682104,
0.0009073867,
0.0029245378,
-0.0182535164,
0.0326216482,
-0.0141013199,
0.021972293,
0.040000014,
0.0328359604,
0.0052777631,
0.0633840561,
0.0298239775,
0.0208534151,
0.0360591188,
0.019801693,
0.0376544669,
0.0429288633,
-0.0354228467,
0.0142507106,
-0.0353053436,
0.0251649115,
-0.0050959783,
0.0063726711,
0.0087508485,
0.0947011635,
0.0039342553,
-0.0306656715,
0.0620561093,
0.0901573449,
-0.0305843633,
0.0372125879,
0.0550047532,
-0.0019700723,
0.0333544426,
-0.0369695015,
-0.0412204005,
-0.0161950197,
-0.054036051,
-0.0117170615,
-0.0089685116,
0.0472651832,
-0.0033073865,
-0.0633699223,
-0.0337170735,
-0.0072098002,
0.0300934315,
0.0045248293,
0.0430166125,
-0.0214147139,
-0.0139410086,
-0.013248547,
-0.0067974925,
-0.0558741167,
-0.0233703591,
-0.1158528551,
0.0010906035,
0.0796856731,
0.0621041544,
-0.0195438992,
-0.0271453559,
0.0175864473,
-0.0300423168,
0.0429520346,
0.0485516191,
-0.0027596022,
0.0029166557,
-0.0161091983,
-0.0043285545,
-0.0184630565,
-0.0003937935,
0.0238670595,
-0.0013654489,
0.0127891693,
0.0047022803,
-0.0412403718,
-0.0623453185,
0.0489698574,
-0.0657273084,
-0.0028009049,
-0.037891306,
-0.0104603097,
0.0457184874,
0.0172223076,
-0.0472752824,
0.0368716754,
0.0286141075,
-0.0097915269,
-0.0073028849,
0.0172195192,
-0.0203560628,
0.0826696157,
0.0399895199,
-0.028018808,
0.0206060819,
0.0402124263,
-0.0057862806,
-0.0248523504,
0.0293704905,
-0.0263980702,
0.0068494915,
-0.0457133912,
0.0400109328,
-0.0724019483,
0.0075374157,
-0.0390613675,
0.0528806858,
-0.0394161195,
-0.0033000673,
0.0040673218,
0.0234031044,
0.0572455376,
0.0008018591,
-0.0833427459,
0.0319077335,
-0.0231185146,
0.0203285888,
0.0375177301,
0.0126108248,
-0.0357184708,
-0.0413052365,
-0.0770314559,
-0.0157061312,
-0.0194677748,
0.0250151902,
0.00634031,
-0.0284910612,
-0.017368339,
0.033759892,
-0.0345889442,
-0.0292020533,
-0.0079717124,
0.026862029,
0.0343423039,
0.0019911316,
-0.0703296512,
-0.0478374474,
-0.0112673901,
-0.0139757069,
0.0523119308,
-0.0000914933,
0.01848628,
-0.0329746008,
0.0280576572,
-0.0449613407,
0.0114506278,
-0.0387001373,
-0.044790823,
0.0442580245,
0.0129692517,
0.0447738841,
0.0617762543,
0.0209273677,
0.0068174982,
0.0620488897,
0.0323779508,
-0.0446426719,
-0.0309291631,
0.0179265346,
-0.0251975134,
-0.0450487882,
-0.0522261336,
0.0032239803,
0.0242590029,
-0.0164602678,
0.0046564769,
-0.0316732191,
0.0384447277,
-0.0497176498,
-0.0853658617,
-0.0249254145,
-0.0498801358,
-0.0261838809,
0.0621937439,
-0.0274319313,
-0.0718857646,
0.0404847562,
-0.0495582819,
0.021616675,
0.0016944201,
-0.0302854907,
-0.0257436298,
0.0672901869,
0.004982871,
0.0456626192,
0.0134958448,
-0.006326599,
-0.0542829633,
-0.0085404441,
-0.0084016509,
-0.0473744161,
0.0416109636,
-0.0428369567,
0.0245854743,
0.0007561303,
-0.0201588441,
-0.0391296707,
-0.0118665034,
-0.0277109649,
0.038544938,
0.0567958802,
-0.0428447276,
0.0109205311,
0.0235233027,
0.0404348783,
0.0100340368,
0.0305654649,
-0.0240576938,
-0.0029147547,
-0.045772396,
0.0187409464,
-0.0149475131,
0.0573018268,
0.0207586251,
0.0327350162,
0.0409733839,
0.0556678548,
0.012522243,
-0.0429157801,
0.0105764689,
0.0206774641,
-0.0393095948,
-0.0075867237,
0.0367350951,
0.0402160026,
-0.0442627184,
0.0080725066,
0.104975678,
0.0266175307,
-0.0195788108,
0.024644848,
-0.0104440339,
-0.0102263121,
0.0355470665,
0.0261137709,
-0.0702939406,
0.0295896828,
0.0153081827,
0.0424381122,
-0.0648436248,
-0.040848732,
-0.0023983545,
-0.1183111221,
0.0267609432,
-0.0127571281,
-0.023934491,
0.0028907098,
-0.045466315,
-0.0162498523,
-0.0035747322,
0.0468248837,
0.0055554882,
0.0162709169,
-0.036645636,
0.015752228,
-0.0926650316,
-0.071179226,
0.0558374859,
-0.0524393879,
0.0835037827,
0.0871776342,
0.0295806862,
-0.0252737887,
-0.0203321036,
0.0284870267,
0.0249380004,
0.0041468139,
0.0214444287,
0.0205703825,
0.0288333297,
-0.0084417025,
-0.0181072913,
-0.008631085,
-0.009067771,
-0.0223080888,
-0.0048424257,
0.0422240645,
-0.0157375969,
-0.0003118157,
-0.0293411743,
-0.0247923285,
-0.0110896258,
0.0797634795,
0.0166250225,
-0.03998667,
-0.0426674411,
-0.0113775842,
-0.0129380161,
-0.0480538234,
-0.0534543507,
0.011602236,
0.0325808115,
-0.0318918787,
-0.0520411171,
-0.0281778313,
-0.0431315191,
-0.0109932637,
0.038825091,
-0.0132785635,
0.0253124051,
-0.012993318,
-0.0331659019,
-0.0305235814,
-0.0140461707,
0.0444289707,
-0.0545061156,
0.0111036077,
0.0078668427,
-0.0068938676,
-0.0061500585,
0.0235207826,
-0.0420679301,
-0.0606683232,
0.0423446372,
0.0424240604,
0.0278159343,
-0.0221286453,
-0.0378953107,
-0.0511737391,
0.048556421,
0.0153909177,
-0.0081743784,
0.0231497101,
0.030844273,
-0.0085427109,
0.001482304,
0.0197912492,
-0.0352670439,
0.0068666828,
0.0182671826,
-0.0111938938,
-0.0219721012,
-0.0332366824,
0.0117221074,
0.0661450103,
-0.0216179397,
-0.0442298949,
0.0161061864,
0.0175563637,
-0.0399610586,
-0.0428206474,
-0.0230159219,
-0.0251703002,
-0.0311796032,
0.0461647958,
0.0270896088,
-0.006486766,
0.0475541092,
0.0013842571,
0.0050982628,
-0.0302005466,
0.0485192463,
0.0002543967,
0.0763097629,
0.0086937221,
0.0093068033,
-0.0278914813,
0.0272818077,
-0.0413540527,
0.041287031,
-0.0133241797,
0.0406343639,
-0.0068260939,
0.0223803781,
0.0042193802,
0.0678977817,
-0.0736279711,
-0.0778416991,
0.0289311484,
0.0418233946,
0.0469205156,
0.0324005783,
0.0584819615,
-0.0107494611,
-0.0005002906,
-0.0418533422,
-0.0115773845,
0.0008049435,
-0.0409964882,
-0.0292568468,
0.0201555621,
-0.0436869785,
0.0176260248,
0.0578312688,
-0.0056433529,
0.0318579003,
0.0072013759,
-0.003728308,
-0.0174687542,
-0.0494097099,
-0.0172898788,
-0.0174988899,
-0.0357434638,
-0.0633821562,
-0.0948904231,
-0.0733391792,
-0.0019299183,
0.0347445309,
0.0463765375,
-0.0053017591,
0.0054446035,
0.0769601539,
0.0092567857,
-0.0064729424,
-0.0548598655,
-0.0419692509,
-0.032277748,
-0.000255142,
-0.0041511781,
-6.445798293e-33,
0.0161626302,
-0.0170580912,
0.0207238868,
-0.0280413553,
-0.0413338244,
0.0066354796,
-0.0296575241,
0.008546574,
-0.066907838,
-0.0168076698,
-0.0257556718,
0.007386351,
0.0043630018,
-0.0018966689,
-0.0008149828,
-0.0013314133,
0.0067047221,
-0.0151193915,
-0.0323797949,
0.0098447111,
0.0360093899,
-0.0345946886,
0.0114979334,
-0.0885128975,
0.0419224128,
0.0091602644,
-0.035304036,
-0.0081268316,
-0.0130039044,
0.0554456487,
-0.0122868698,
0.0231239013,
0.015656542,
-0.0316073932,
-0.0119083067,
-0.0025990116,
-0.0096832989,
-0.0003283252,
0.0196842775,
-0.0106677841,
0.0178727601,
-0.0389206484,
0.0445430465,
-0.009689305,
-0.067397058,
0.0250810627,
0.011536777,
-0.0373793803,
-0.0076796818,
-0.0373222493,
-0.0667362139,
0.0342792608,
-0.0296389684,
0.0382622629,
0.006168894,
0.0025557815,
-0.0061808252,
0.0035611722,
-0.0708472356,
0.0279690232,
0.0135370716,
-0.0068854759,
0.1046147123,
0.0169019848,
0.0070073791,
0.0589692742,
0.0531327054,
0.0306814257,
-0.0188232362,
-0.0212863926,
0.0387131199,
0.0568284094,
0.0578624122,
0.0554380231,
0.0023805916,
-0.0360087603,
-0.0581295304,
0.0205685869,
0.0301118996,
0.0009809139,
0.0540038422,
0.0285063256,
-0.0862891674,
-0.0297254976,
-0.0482258536,
0.0222821627,
-0.0220405795,
-0.0186614431,
0.0512267984,
-0.0353017002,
-0.0142855486,
-0.0236936882,
0.0184285752,
-0.0735488683,
0.0243460406,
0.0142388865,
-0.0130570466,
0.0218328703,
0.0182577316,
0.0417830497,
-0.0611152276,
-0.0230398923,
-0.0033992827,
0.0427359417,
0.0406960398,
-0.0254798066,
-0.0061228443,
0.0322774872,
-0.0467934571,
0.005376732,
-0.0207840987,
0.0112700546,
0.0141910361,
-0.0038538068,
0.0279429369,
-0.0226932876,
-0.0034690762,
-0.0185816176,
0.0423808731,
0.032559216,
-0.0327392891,
0.0199036151,
-0.0052235685,
0.0150386868,
-0.010486979,
0.0081209177,
-0.0582147539,
0.0582361221,
0.0570998937,
-0.0123535963,
-0.0101072434,
0.0171701629,
2.966e-7,
0.0540391691,
0.0211902782,
0.0130568836,
0.0488205925,
-0.0058450247,
0.0323414728,
-0.0162181892,
0.0276001301,
-0.0090958681,
0.0132869063,
0.005238323,
0.0304598976,
0.0637921914,
0.0335010029,
0.0008998656,
-0.0132108089,
-0.0649671108,
0.0025696428,
-0.0647075325,
0.0207723919,
0.0391028225,
0.0534673333,
0.0003813244,
-0.013919441,
-0.02555985,
-0.0846601278,
0.0133179352,
-0.03947464,
0.0061851093,
0.0307701752,
0.0288330261,
0.0587293543,
0.0293799434,
0.0134692248,
0.0028561396,
0.0132280635,
-0.0067010787,
0.052042421,
0.0067159291,
-0.0322094783,
0.0006148519,
-0.0376502573,
0.0013916806,
-0.080679141,
0.0669907182,
0.0080355536,
-0.0385248661,
-0.0320956297,
-0.0224909913,
0.0026441205,
0.0390615687,
-0.0219774954,
-0.0069953995,
0.0258225724,
0.0044349772,
-0.0155449053,
0.01463803,
-0.0564729646,
-0.0032327243,
-0.0305484552,
-0.0153892962,
-0.060432028,
-0.037017066,
0.0302584674,
0.0057156957,
-0.007186525,
0.011998334,
2.867764487e-34,
0.0115761217,
-0.0269872565,
0.0124677289,
-0.0094234683,
0.0474813245,
0.0605957843,
-0.0363571458,
0.0142364483,
-0.0109896585,
-0.0651914179,
-0.0045305551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09874v1 | Camouflage is all you need: Evaluating and Enhancing Language Model Robustness Against Camouflage Adversarial Attacks | 2024-02-15T10:58:22 | 2024-02-15T10:58:22 | Álvaro Huertas-García, Alejandro Martín, Javier Huertas-Tato, David Camacho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adversarial attacks represent a substantial challenge in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). This study undertakes a systematic exploration of this
challenge in two distinct phases: vulnerability evaluation and resilience
enhancement of Transformer-based models under adversarial attacks.
In the evaluation phase, we assess the susceptibility of three Transformer
configurations, encoder-decoder, encoder-only, and decoder-only setups, to
adversarial attacks of escalating complexity across datasets containing
offensive language and misinformation. Encoder-only models manifest a 14% and
21% performance drop in offensive language detection and misinformation
detection tasks, respectively. Decoder-only models register a 16% decrease in
both tasks, while encoder-decoder models exhibit a maximum performance drop of
14% and 26% in the respective tasks.
The resilience-enhancement phase employs adversarial training, integrating
pre-camouflaged and dynamically altered data. This approach effectively reduces
the performance drop in encoder-only models to an average of 5% in offensive
language detection and 2% in misinformation detection tasks. Decoder-only
models, occasionally exceeding original performance, limit the performance drop
to 7% and 2% in the respective tasks. Although not surpassing the original
performance, Encoder-decoder models can reduce the drop to an average of 6% and
2% respectively.
Results suggest a trade-off between performance and robustness, with some
models maintaining similar performance while gaining robustness. Our study and
adversarial training techniques have been incorporated into an open-source tool
for generating camouflaged datasets. However, methodology effectiveness depends
on the specific camouflage technique and data encountered, emphasizing the need
for continued exploration. | [
0.0370084085,
0.0570791885,
-0.0416772887,
0.0561895818,
-0.0233283695,
0.0162407681,
0.0198833458,
0.0041363155,
-0.0223916378,
-0.0766219124,
0.0082583344,
0.0073771095,
0.0336714499,
0.02636775,
0.0476018973,
-0.0380949415,
0.0337537415,
-0.0102471877,
-0.0199363362,
-0.012656467,
-0.0271936487,
-0.0152083253,
0.0117687583,
0.0379208103,
0.0183142461,
-0.0041064657,
0.0160652101,
-0.0046517225,
0.0242304001,
0.0113786552,
0.0453786813,
0.0361932665,
0.0015181291,
0.0757474378,
0.0000020171,
-0.0175170712,
-0.0205251779,
0.017446626,
-0.0270213671,
0.0098013449,
0.0646813139,
-0.1031320319,
-0.0336991549,
0.0407293551,
-0.0344059803,
-0.0224030428,
0.0365284085,
0.0651893169,
0.0549294502,
0.1040646955,
-0.0067070201,
-0.0682817176,
0.056286931,
-0.0031472093,
-0.0734593198,
-0.0222700164,
0.0309049077,
-0.0331197977,
-0.0720938742,
-0.0041686608,
-0.0313297473,
0.017021386,
0.0314989015,
0.0194567069,
-0.0584814399,
0.0120331934,
0.0051645199,
-0.0146329394,
0.0020286764,
0.0374789052,
-0.096247904,
-0.0266139656,
-0.0205140095,
-0.005452659,
0.0111941295,
0.0223275591,
0.003411646,
0.0036874358,
0.0213083494,
0.0007038605,
-0.0216034614,
-0.0061986046,
0.0414613485,
0.0100200744,
-0.0140147023,
0.0108452654,
0.0132479109,
-0.0157572255,
-0.0189755149,
-0.0433831252,
-0.0188188534,
-0.0364941657,
0.0117577203,
0.0106333587,
0.0107671078,
0.0059257159,
-0.0881445631,
-0.1042360514,
0.0186000038,
-0.045552887,
0.0397232994,
0.0189526565,
-0.0189527925,
-0.0115997456,
-0.0418585539,
0.0878935829,
-0.0460088551,
0.0512473397,
-0.0014788919,
-0.0299164504,
-0.0156616829,
-0.0185640827,
-0.0163459592,
0.0077444273,
-0.0346067622,
0.0337498374,
-0.0325299725,
0.0001520893,
-0.0344150662,
0.0020570129,
-0.0028770349,
0.0110100918,
-0.0323571302,
0.0002855102,
0.0272509661,
-0.0165447891,
0.0149272159,
0.0119831683,
-0.0152501902,
-0.1271560192,
-0.0210167151,
0.0166939925,
-0.0386912264,
-0.0608938374,
-0.0163382515,
0.0808264092,
0.0231925026,
-0.0530499816,
-0.0319220126,
-0.0105371056,
-0.0128945159,
-0.0029885254,
0.0217695087,
-0.0440068096,
-0.0115290154,
-0.027309902,
-0.0002094005,
-0.0885249004,
-0.0171430781,
0.010118247,
-0.0318813026,
0.0810166672,
0.0178164449,
-0.0358424522,
0.0270972997,
0.020315215,
-0.0128045976,
0.0684440732,
0.0342657343,
0.0184503607,
0.0483024567,
-0.0242025722,
0.0401336662,
0.028002806,
0.0185539667,
0.0090134451,
0.0038415256,
0.0031263358,
-0.0072222129,
-0.0419488885,
0.0237621795,
0.0526610278,
-0.0106704645,
-0.1012460217,
0.0799559429,
-0.0034311819,
-0.0186511409,
0.0348081887,
0.0119608045,
0.0151496083,
-0.0085334433,
0.015334798,
-0.0405626744,
-0.0073743886,
-0.0933269486,
-0.0393340662,
-0.0515845008,
0.061673034,
-0.0079333894,
-0.0355466828,
-0.0317531303,
-0.0231478438,
0.073334001,
-0.0212935787,
0.0460834913,
0.070079498,
-0.0503911488,
0.0123104202,
0.0008053181,
-0.0146893999,
-0.002946151,
-0.0815991089,
-0.0544243082,
0.0014738423,
0.0658659413,
-0.0004302903,
0.0376910418,
-0.0488564707,
-0.0237074941,
0.0255315918,
0.0116623519,
0.0077572404,
0.0301316176,
-0.0284019914,
-0.0101273768,
-0.0476994887,
0.0186599158,
0.031107733,
0.0352916196,
0.0156664029,
0.0030592531,
-0.0144895921,
-0.0314727947,
0.0501397289,
0.0147700626,
-0.0534849726,
0.0034031477,
0.017350696,
0.0394117422,
0.0026912433,
-0.0212939177,
0.0166012086,
0.0402309224,
-0.0121513344,
-0.0213183481,
-0.0022594435,
0.001664245,
-0.033904694,
-0.0038030441,
-0.0438912176,
0.0023532859,
0.10663113,
-0.0386101753,
0.0148115708,
0.0513241701,
-0.0587407723,
0.0163567662,
-0.0040010689,
0.0129006123,
-0.0248516593,
0.0840207487,
-0.0116816554,
0.0516843759,
-0.0340294726,
0.0055940486,
-0.0214216784,
-0.0002373569,
0.0146798994,
-0.0128415478,
-0.0273822471,
0.0151350023,
-0.0370128378,
0.0031014713,
0.005511032,
-0.0362882204,
0.0101843411,
-0.0161211155,
0.0014150154,
-0.0241550524,
-0.0410072878,
-0.0013593349,
0.0379914567,
-0.0099929571,
0.0025380177,
0.0053719911,
0.0277313311,
-0.0139489872,
0.0010757183,
0.0397163145,
-0.0065385718,
-0.0367195792,
-0.0305489562,
0.0003796669,
-0.0153235123,
0.0099049387,
0.0831944421,
-0.0183980148,
-0.0478716865,
-0.0406859964,
-0.011307328,
0.0193875078,
0.0676836669,
-0.0429740772,
-0.077413857,
0.0089282962,
0.0667749494,
0.0028616604,
0.0660552531,
0.0442750268,
0.0683513433,
0.0477184467,
0.0349659212,
-0.0052810828,
-0.0237247832,
-0.0136175239,
-0.0350977033,
-0.0579885989,
-0.0449441522,
0.0255233664,
0.0873690099,
0.0477043577,
-0.0261209533,
-0.0235675368,
0.019034721,
-0.0154989911,
-0.0522634983,
-0.0084444173,
-0.0580054149,
-0.021309549,
0.0091647897,
-0.0283928253,
-0.0269001722,
0.0939391479,
-0.0301097222,
0.0097622303,
-0.0235915501,
-0.0208845586,
0.0228900798,
0.0362072662,
0.0137605947,
0.0069845454,
0.05041885,
-0.0296300855,
-0.0390260629,
-0.0285205208,
0.034166012,
-0.0434137657,
-0.0103560593,
-0.0210379642,
-0.0074856472,
0.0105524696,
-0.020657612,
-0.0741377324,
-0.0387849286,
0.0205942933,
0.0263008736,
0.0383385606,
-0.0174557883,
-0.0589147694,
-0.0085441498,
0.0075207711,
0.0320784785,
0.0130613837,
0.0032227365,
-0.0158128943,
0.0309424717,
0.0249286462,
-0.0173562765,
0.0527817011,
-0.0092905704,
0.0257882327,
0.0687719807,
-0.0220211949,
0.0064138677,
-0.0116870748,
-0.0112008024,
0.0309873391,
0.00466609,
0.0120467441,
0.0135632996,
0.0258711129,
-0.0469135791,
-0.0228034537,
0.0635293946,
0.0128173847,
0.0097523509,
0.025740549,
0.0002835742,
0.0217698123,
0.018759422,
-0.0149463499,
-0.0569607615,
0.0121610314,
0.0271677449,
0.0476446338,
-0.0624449216,
-0.0206866022,
0.002964722,
-0.1082180664,
-0.0009875669,
-0.0164608993,
-0.0226548556,
-0.0615612529,
-0.0543789528,
-0.0285725258,
-0.0133302296,
0.0677330047,
-0.0172819216,
0.0457720496,
-0.0274383537,
0.0093039898,
-0.0267730113,
-0.0742523819,
0.0049671736,
-0.0142691871,
0.02080396,
0.0678631738,
0.0314918123,
-0.0270667281,
-0.040740829,
0.0523631275,
-0.016664058,
-0.0019870938,
0.0017783717,
0.0695406273,
-0.0086161299,
-0.0184403118,
0.0162424967,
0.0216473695,
-0.0154366754,
-0.0168770961,
-0.0107294284,
0.0148141077,
0.0110115232,
-0.0233932044,
-0.0171074457,
-0.0204838384,
0.0162092,
0.0618507825,
0.0101184659,
-0.0181804784,
-0.0161578078,
-0.0686267987,
0.0191744119,
-0.0567263737,
-0.0597159527,
0.0508177467,
0.0281374399,
-0.0531528071,
-0.0706233308,
-0.0218990315,
-0.0187589899,
0.0008250653,
0.0138896471,
-0.0163906291,
-0.0039945086,
-0.0103369858,
-0.0662736222,
-0.0196622554,
-0.0041017113,
0.0414760634,
-0.0145621169,
-0.0101523995,
0.0068880776,
-0.0143837128,
-0.0264742263,
-0.0163880158,
-0.0670210123,
-0.0677885935,
0.0543067046,
0.0456596613,
0.0192266237,
0.0359472893,
-0.0517011806,
-0.0786031634,
0.0591234006,
0.0361110866,
-0.015452873,
0.0150083387,
0.0805159584,
-0.0587838143,
0.0138466703,
0.0254232418,
-0.0203438327,
0.0046990868,
0.0540451519,
-0.0190668274,
-0.0362414233,
-0.0036559196,
0.0244449433,
0.0117483558,
0.0755909532,
-0.013000478,
-0.0139315147,
0.0241679288,
0.0076120356,
-0.0348687135,
-0.0093150316,
-0.0004953815,
0.0234626941,
0.0362094156,
0.0287917741,
0.0000215697,
0.0463273153,
-0.0258884933,
-0.0049175583,
-0.0299326871,
0.0344978347,
0.0128916921,
0.042477604,
0.008720384,
0.0385808609,
-0.0124269193,
0.0201892722,
0.0173380673,
0.0252317768,
0.0194867346,
0.0243732221,
0.0027587367,
0.0168296508,
-0.0133475987,
0.0092593068,
-0.0486349985,
0.0207557008,
-0.0311826561,
0.0008246608,
0.0061250627,
0.010511646,
0.0273261368,
-0.0081794104,
-0.0131043978,
-0.0116463844,
-0.0149463098,
-0.0034972262,
-0.0332749784,
0.0461847335,
0.0039177006,
-0.0018974232,
0.0274467431,
0.0826235265,
0.0367735885,
0.060089469,
-0.0075703636,
-0.0217419062,
-0.0319219753,
-0.021151213,
0.0073477174,
0.0023950606,
-0.0112626562,
0.0324027613,
-0.0358914733,
-0.0878439769,
-0.0075873844,
0.0058049429,
0.0786253288,
-0.0107352547,
-0.0117066,
0.0473588668,
0.0051382496,
0.0188327506,
-0.0660958737,
0.0283160005,
0.0408287868,
-0.0408418775,
0.0117747067,
-6.128378085e-33,
-0.0155659551,
-0.0401932187,
-0.0386985615,
-0.0447050631,
0.0212167185,
0.0147322062,
-0.0017113476,
-0.02103935,
-0.0659291893,
0.0054156515,
0.020743344,
0.012925595,
-0.0157971811,
0.0411360562,
-0.0615981668,
-0.024108164,
0.0331099331,
-0.0005543474,
-0.0378557593,
-0.0543318875,
0.0509281568,
0.0029645348,
0.0333899818,
-0.0783359781,
0.0440859124,
0.0073339958,
-0.0400565974,
0.0018487429,
-0.0252739266,
0.0489830188,
0.0090668974,
0.0411675908,
0.0240276251,
0.0038892883,
-0.0118995532,
0.0291199591,
-0.0624879003,
0.0194376633,
0.0037905443,
0.0502703935,
-0.0079402905,
-0.0370917916,
0.0565967113,
-0.0247889757,
-0.0271804258,
-0.0219750591,
0.0118309921,
-0.0278021805,
-0.0081607867,
-0.0278727021,
-0.038626913,
0.011952959,
-0.0185401477,
-0.0131792305,
0.0092004407,
0.0466319025,
0.0384346917,
0.0473237038,
-0.1176237613,
-0.0161694475,
0.0023454309,
0.0151183736,
0.0468346849,
0.0074918196,
0.0093652932,
0.0577605963,
0.0123214731,
0.0196890794,
-0.0099568926,
0.0016821151,
0.0288071111,
0.0036431353,
0.1097719595,
0.0616603941,
0.0628371239,
-0.0580006391,
-0.055220753,
0.0046734805,
-0.0090683782,
-0.0038173683,
0.0517542809,
0.0224794764,
-0.0546037517,
-0.0073286486,
-0.0247569513,
-0.0448265225,
-0.0260944795,
-0.0151890526,
0.0194895491,
0.0126174893,
-0.0395881981,
0.0112549691,
0.0011212878,
-0.0552852079,
0.033495903,
0.0205656774,
-0.0048265508,
0.0079060057,
0.0117396973,
0.0396557823,
0.0045254435,
-0.0015145203,
0.0489431433,
-0.0036007694,
0.0449484177,
-0.0168696996,
0.0764520094,
0.037694566,
-0.0645255148,
-0.0080639664,
-0.021463681,
0.0540830828,
0.0302248895,
0.0235182662,
0.0276593007,
0.0226726774,
-0.0343978666,
-0.0206620414,
0.0398607813,
-0.0282942895,
-0.0337817967,
0.0558862351,
-0.0145525197,
0.0119702704,
-0.0148552964,
-0.0429595932,
0.0033871529,
0.0410087295,
0.0590528995,
-0.0708628595,
-0.0172556359,
-0.0247787721,
2.844e-7,
0.0292724669,
0.0516375341,
0.0137257967,
-0.0076536294,
0.0414901003,
0.0395253859,
0.0021524087,
0.0507331304,
0.0050456314,
-0.0233022235,
-0.0583618097,
0.0011702472,
0.0371922739,
0.0261931904,
-0.0173736271,
-0.0136121325,
-0.0658215135,
0.0030537334,
-0.0157142952,
-0.0035640516,
0.0450941995,
0.1101831868,
0.0222183801,
0.0021563177,
-0.021246735,
-0.0255041923,
0.0224649943,
-0.0016933472,
0.0205437876,
-0.0305404477,
0.0302136429,
0.0330518335,
0.0403064974,
0.0189701468,
-0.0398236774,
0.0062756743,
-0.0042757387,
0.0290169008,
-0.0055175005,
-0.0254585072,
-0.0163240954,
-0.0496908538,
-0.0402970463,
-0.0575890504,
0.0699298307,
-0.0392991528,
-0.0423312262,
-0.0024550019,
-0.0630914345,
0.0141407354,
0.0258692484,
-0.0411235988,
-0.0271040127,
0.0098591298,
0.0287469346,
0.0225554928,
0.0176809803,
-0.0533849932,
-0.0155219957,
-0.0020281947,
-0.0137363095,
-0.0004057372,
0.0038946944,
-0.0020540629,
0.053958483,
0.0036596209,
0.0116111254,
2.626389579e-34,
0.0267181918,
-0.0180634949,
-0.0099223871,
-0.0037519075,
0.0565898642,
-0.0106312986,
0.0190882422,
-0.0001874905,
0.0074191238,
-0.021720333,
-0.028271744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09841v1 | LAPDoc: Layout-Aware Prompting for Documents | 2024-02-15T10:00:49 | 2024-02-15T10:00:49 | Marcel Lamott, Yves-Noel Weweler, Adrian Ulges, Faisal Shafait, Dirk Krechel, Darko Obradovic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Recent advances in training large language models (LLMs) using massive
amounts of solely textual data lead to strong generalization across many
domains and tasks, including document-specific tasks. Opposed to that there is
a trend to train multi-modal transformer architectures tailored for document
understanding that are designed specifically to fuse textual inputs with the
corresponding document layout. This involves a separate fine-tuning step for
which additional training data is required. At present, no document
transformers with comparable generalization to LLMs are available That raises
the question which type of model is to be preferred for document understanding
tasks. In this paper we investigate the possibility to use purely text-based
LLMs for document-specific tasks by using layout enrichment. We explore drop-in
modifications and rule-based methods to enrich purely textual LLM prompts with
layout information. In our experiments we investigate the effects on the
commercial ChatGPT model and the open-source LLM Solar. We demonstrate that
using our approach both LLMs show improved performance on various standard
document benchmarks. In addition, we study the impact of noisy OCR and layout
errors, as well as the limitations of LLMs when it comes to utilizing document
layout. Our results indicate that layout enrichment can improve the performance
of purely text-based LLMs for document understanding by up to 15% compared to
just using plain document text. In conclusion, this approach should be
considered for the best model choice between text-based LLM or multi-modal
document transformers. | [
0.0439968668,
-0.0114599122,
0.0238039624,
0.0318790711,
-0.0205310341,
0.0063303672,
0.0256418325,
0.0357790254,
0.0219657738,
-0.0608762056,
-0.0591581203,
-0.0226018615,
0.0022863143,
0.0042913649,
-0.0034594429,
-0.0338904895,
0.0248758122,
-0.0592569634,
-0.0111316899,
0.0369840153,
0.0045104092,
0.0053450628,
0.0067111459,
-0.0133815063,
-0.0165797062,
-0.0461162776,
-0.0583329387,
0.0217343122,
-0.003398956,
-0.0114128422,
-0.0134786759,
0.0368270464,
0.0424386524,
0.0606673099,
0.0000019631,
-0.040511243,
-0.0265998505,
0.01611243,
-0.0232468043,
-0.0081737181,
0.0671567917,
-0.0723009184,
-0.0063003106,
-0.017243674,
-0.0011780112,
-0.0100171911,
0.0266384557,
0.1247384995,
0.0310335048,
0.0892701745,
-0.0347765684,
-0.0141528388,
0.0304873791,
-0.0191309471,
0.0403702781,
-0.002212774,
0.0069060009,
-0.0038978597,
0.0310430229,
0.0237203147,
-0.0053535723,
0.0138742048,
0.0195687469,
-0.0524150059,
-0.0078531764,
0.0354545712,
-0.0083933352,
-0.0059472229,
-0.0511894301,
0.0552041009,
0.0017590473,
0.0157753974,
0.0064392523,
-0.0138824424,
0.0149856266,
0.0142180528,
-0.0601716898,
-0.0104947081,
-0.0517837815,
-0.018872723,
-0.0091323266,
0.0038425932,
0.0082071386,
-0.003948797,
-0.0436934233,
0.0253964327,
0.0155261038,
-0.0505310148,
0.0154189421,
0.0020545039,
0.0102885924,
-0.0317937918,
0.0550091565,
0.0433216207,
-0.012227702,
0.0111471424,
-0.0566570498,
-0.0422942378,
0.0197862368,
-0.0237694327,
0.0101733878,
0.011090694,
-0.0321468338,
0.0598671548,
-0.0429158472,
0.0724149793,
-0.0365410782,
0.0391174182,
-0.0628772452,
0.0197862312,
0.0015689912,
-0.0102634374,
-0.0482299328,
-0.0102846911,
-0.0529229753,
-0.0591007024,
0.0161854606,
0.0586055033,
0.0419669896,
0.0357292667,
0.0536489412,
-0.0350516438,
-0.0531334952,
-0.0623940043,
0.0267353412,
0.0161079895,
0.0101950234,
0.0020116032,
0.006634525,
-0.0462821387,
0.0022947411,
0.028976867,
0.0174765401,
-0.0069687651,
-0.0131007694,
0.091023542,
-0.0369346775,
-0.0386961326,
-0.0349420607,
0.0168570392,
-0.0025826748,
-0.0518988259,
0.0165482461,
-0.035890393,
0.0098002767,
0.0057597756,
0.0078190789,
0.0225227363,
-0.0111271823,
0.0155076887,
-0.011049428,
0.0589697175,
0.0095259659,
0.0089605981,
0.0597481206,
-0.0108091943,
-0.0378085524,
0.0538727231,
0.0196996816,
0.0536819659,
0.0261918921,
-0.0141624967,
0.007344455,
0.0815350637,
-0.0492502823,
-0.0314202383,
0.0453830287,
-0.0034233232,
0.0203673076,
-0.0023366646,
0.0095219314,
0.0321673192,
-0.029684661,
0.0034180759,
0.066936262,
0.0566829853,
0.0356510133,
0.0251761992,
-0.0008892013,
0.0204198919,
0.0104193091,
0.0310392827,
-0.0622563772,
-0.0056579392,
-0.0120452754,
0.0389832444,
-0.015838258,
0.013140562,
-0.0262821782,
-0.0290281959,
-0.0226185545,
-0.0073845019,
-0.0027636341,
-0.0163472909,
0.0940139219,
0.0269699749,
-0.073334679,
0.047680106,
-0.0058017313,
-0.0492448099,
-0.0347464271,
-0.0095755626,
0.032968089,
0.0531094559,
0.0709350258,
-0.0575954951,
-0.0291318353,
-0.0218684748,
0.0139435017,
0.0553098395,
0.0606923103,
0.0004363968,
0.0140261846,
-0.0822241232,
-0.0153280124,
0.0074436618,
-0.0077337185,
0.0250850748,
0.0312429108,
-0.0130221983,
0.009387617,
-0.0603168793,
-0.0269351937,
0.0714519545,
0.0032514371,
-0.0408271588,
0.0035910101,
0.005643941,
0.0111999186,
0.0191579033,
-0.0057740547,
-0.0253638774,
0.026235329,
-0.0201890655,
0.0315606929,
-0.0184943657,
-0.054964833,
-0.0380918048,
-0.0066073327,
0.017522851,
-0.0249944739,
0.0000757886,
-0.0418445654,
-0.0319373012,
-0.0743344799,
-0.0246755574,
0.0328716896,
-0.0309565701,
0.0231954679,
0.0176004767,
-0.0108736912,
-0.0532588474,
0.046407707,
0.022026293,
0.0007036711,
0.0454598144,
0.0141796637,
0.016238112,
-0.031729646,
-0.0397635289,
0.0018832664,
-0.0167430211,
-0.0255957022,
0.0055446471,
0.0587332472,
-0.0259568766,
-0.0753054246,
-0.1032691449,
0.0061593866,
-0.0306181218,
0.035203144,
0.0169325583,
0.024156522,
-0.021573972,
-0.0545616597,
-0.0342474133,
-0.0022364494,
0.0078757312,
-0.0025435868,
0.0176557191,
-0.0014725223,
0.0030149661,
0.005800759,
-0.0294047892,
0.0080342647,
0.0170824267,
0.0451737605,
-0.0262879469,
-0.0720147416,
0.0498146378,
0.0404467657,
0.0253404193,
-0.0289418958,
0.0103446646,
0.0084075611,
-0.0426584147,
0.0676399842,
0.1073602885,
0.020485159,
0.0201133974,
0.0026084019,
0.0016084871,
-0.0538782179,
0.0144280987,
-0.0102247726,
-0.0034043428,
-0.0195391849,
-0.010343831,
0.0237717107,
0.059341535,
-0.037117295,
0.0411010012,
-0.0242453907,
-0.0533409752,
-0.0120667182,
-0.0304099564,
-0.0340004601,
-0.0197731908,
-0.0180545747,
0.020615533,
-0.0176031087,
-0.0554990172,
0.0354949236,
-0.0745609179,
-0.0515584722,
-0.0284417272,
0.0131556066,
-0.0473195873,
0.0440898165,
0.0196826197,
0.0070611504,
0.0090631088,
-0.0547066145,
-0.0418954492,
0.0238609128,
-0.0030202095,
-0.0217857286,
0.0654985309,
-0.0350396186,
0.0586685091,
-0.0537853837,
-0.0348042436,
-0.0320006236,
-0.0403644033,
0.0166286863,
-0.0397050455,
-0.023648655,
-0.0269675981,
-0.0522361584,
0.0647253245,
0.0174673609,
0.1127811968,
-0.035261482,
-0.0251462068,
-0.0311538856,
0.0839329362,
0.022109367,
0.0104022706,
0.0018520572,
-0.0632245094,
0.0317840837,
0.0340539403,
-0.0048829024,
-0.0345739685,
-0.0114653446,
0.0212647393,
0.0338379256,
-0.0314192139,
-0.0033917499,
0.0024828466,
0.0354158916,
-0.0930782855,
-0.0172661841,
0.1134533882,
0.0190179422,
-0.0744735897,
-0.0738415867,
-0.0412894189,
0.0165301505,
-0.0138714174,
0.039938882,
-0.0626799241,
-0.0182773639,
0.0152393319,
0.0128625529,
0.0230005682,
0.0351745747,
-0.0121526131,
-0.0724433213,
0.0512666218,
0.0101554096,
-0.0376891345,
-0.021157749,
-0.0247953869,
0.0009229865,
-0.0069178976,
-0.0022532425,
0.0090834312,
-0.0391901508,
-0.0599170253,
-0.0057395892,
-0.0042861681,
-0.0150603289,
-0.0277531091,
0.0075448072,
-0.0065892427,
0.0466336906,
-0.0000735065,
0.0018626556,
-0.0322487429,
0.0393351428,
0.0440622382,
0.0276552513,
-0.0272981804,
0.0406260751,
-0.0116967885,
0.0297706667,
-0.0491119921,
0.0361711085,
-0.0275933873,
-0.0120332232,
0.009319175,
0.0324802622,
-0.0235206913,
-0.0146836378,
-0.0136637921,
-0.0315391198,
-0.0145905064,
0.0699447319,
0.0088818101,
-0.0327312648,
-0.0610978454,
-0.0359734185,
0.0249168891,
-0.0120081846,
0.038451381,
0.0128444973,
-0.0645881891,
-0.058344312,
-0.0400980152,
-0.0193094201,
0.0162174758,
0.0282811578,
0.0270684082,
-0.0247576013,
-0.0162209123,
0.0094287582,
-0.0269736666,
0.0494233854,
-0.0102694929,
0.002472712,
-0.0827416852,
0.0198602416,
0.042063266,
-0.0531121641,
-0.0041801729,
-0.0105502727,
-0.0588899292,
-0.0310627483,
0.0017974509,
0.0346866213,
0.0221959893,
0.0827052072,
-0.0137619562,
-0.0245417375,
0.0443456583,
0.0237574913,
-0.0289764255,
-0.0165881049,
0.0325913131,
-0.0117999753,
-0.0225526746,
0.0016192222,
-0.043170765,
0.0159558859,
0.0045569204,
-0.0217895862,
-0.0201724172,
-0.0481412224,
0.000948775,
0.007118308,
0.0006876573,
0.0037794989,
0.022333229,
-0.0498899147,
0.0599550009,
-0.0105177322,
-0.0041592889,
-0.0442058928,
-0.0008379402,
-0.001944788,
-0.0057845404,
0.0170311481,
0.0372208916,
0.0083366791,
0.0413187444,
-0.040418759,
0.0299967732,
0.0020063471,
-0.0102356104,
0.03484983,
-0.0026196134,
-0.0130768986,
0.0185296573,
0.0193557292,
0.030111229,
-0.010533005,
0.1109888405,
0.0275491755,
-0.0229121931,
-0.0046874923,
0.0519991852,
-0.06786336,
-0.0129606314,
-0.044677712,
0.0474971719,
0.0074194963,
-0.0229501054,
0.0380352959,
-0.0284115057,
-0.0025286998,
-0.0126372436,
0.0101261316,
0.0724897236,
0.0019439752,
-0.0008092973,
0.0306957308,
0.0343518145,
-0.0064125657,
0.080981724,
-0.0117469467,
0.0023978879,
-0.0117429765,
-0.0247103237,
-0.0615686215,
-0.0028803332,
0.048438929,
0.0098428875,
-0.0248222016,
-0.0178106949,
-0.0235405806,
0.0122891543,
0.014481782,
0.0137431445,
-0.0270519368,
-0.0180769674,
0.0359048471,
0.0644785613,
-0.0116998246,
-0.0182221401,
-0.0160776451,
0.0226413216,
-0.0073403763,
-0.016056262,
-0.0291242581,
-5.474706615e-33,
-0.0335541293,
-0.0274139158,
0.0126654208,
0.0403124467,
-0.0233321842,
0.0137997679,
-0.0163422078,
-0.032721322,
0.0306195021,
-0.0021466673,
-0.0565497503,
-0.0184834618,
0.0428502373,
0.0335701331,
-0.0078808693,
0.0003234346,
0.0798555091,
-0.0089147855,
-0.038077563,
0.0018395745,
0.0076482934,
0.0251442511,
0.0369783305,
-0.0416073427,
0.0221631154,
-0.012379121,
-0.0021923839,
0.0082453946,
0.0060408227,
0.0455672778,
-0.0037701046,
-0.0001434689,
0.0372075252,
-0.0290059578,
-0.0199534893,
0.1179885045,
-0.1046722308,
0.008093236,
-0.0030376769,
0.0717900321,
0.0005405228,
-0.0297707748,
0.0240083747,
-0.0255368538,
0.0185105801,
-0.0083476231,
0.0381621681,
-0.0216425844,
-0.0198581535,
-0.0215378869,
-0.0465101227,
0.0343335122,
0.0069886623,
-0.0274149962,
0.0500684008,
0.0395634808,
-0.0035942176,
0.0451807939,
-0.0460386947,
-0.0027815024,
0.0361906253,
0.0405477844,
0.0515338704,
0.0477666147,
-0.0296810511,
0.0036433737,
-0.002516554,
0.0164249223,
-0.0073097139,
-0.0419453159,
0.0086874794,
0.0257379096,
0.0120925885,
0.0184078738,
0.0418003686,
0.0449385941,
-0.0042370055,
0.0707079917,
0.004525044,
0.0435269699,
0.0439665951,
0.0138370413,
-0.0186879709,
0.0106412359,
-0.0029196846,
0.0112610003,
-0.0272340197,
-0.0151144955,
0.0381075814,
0.0338775069,
0.0221448988,
-0.030038856,
0.062582016,
0.003142213,
0.010775418,
0.0083765611,
0.0100475959,
0.0503969006,
-0.0467211753,
-0.0269046668,
-0.0251359809,
-0.0575241223,
0.0361767784,
0.0018320995,
-0.0290509313,
0.0049903849,
0.037884485,
0.0178091917,
-0.064403221,
0.0100314533,
0.0005974681,
-0.0017088728,
0.0222812649,
0.064219147,
0.0374305844,
-0.0322546884,
-0.0291593596,
0.0646822527,
-0.0179348662,
0.0017761984,
-0.036758244,
-0.0293632802,
-0.0074670156,
0.0071695829,
-0.0244168453,
0.0082208132,
-0.019328583,
0.0036789523,
0.0346435048,
-0.0159840081,
0.0270542074,
0.0544421636,
2.524e-7,
0.0300857462,
0.0258430168,
0.052000802,
-0.0031604285,
0.0207059644,
0.0262559019,
0.00357915,
0.0025181831,
0.0021564558,
-0.0073783565,
0.0228096768,
-0.0087560173,
0.0763809085,
-0.0055217836,
-0.1230636165,
-0.0242237207,
-0.0577573851,
0.0012240227,
-0.0688116848,
-0.0061249393,
0.0540450178,
0.0737674311,
-0.0511177406,
-0.0362221859,
0.0071616927,
-0.0328209996,
0.0491168052,
-0.0405014269,
0.0107407002,
0.0269676391,
0.0739231855,
-0.0140067618,
-0.0309508685,
0.0342928246,
-0.0068934304,
0.0139482748,
0.0238553453,
0.0665984377,
-0.0020669953,
0.0414794683,
0.0234019756,
-0.0019197162,
-0.0249097068,
-0.0656660944,
0.0490638427,
-0.0377955325,
0.008458944,
-0.0457220189,
-0.0249980371,
-0.0651070327,
-0.0323336162,
-0.0237941593,
0.0093497066,
0.0620953701,
0.0315869898,
-0.0469514243,
-0.0091028307,
-0.0658560246,
-0.0169146173,
-0.0314901657,
-0.0280211233,
-0.0135563603,
-0.0584090352,
-0.0113238953,
0.011442285,
-0.05663592,
-0.0414506271,
2.465640268e-34,
0.0252599642,
-0.0001651407,
-0.0029574367,
0.0611310713,
0.016016094,
-0.0006472356,
0.0161271319,
0.0170151535,
-0.0171125066,
-0.1328971833,
0.0045355083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09808v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09808v2 | Knowledge of Pretrained Language Models on Surface Information of Tokens | 2024-02-15T09:14:53 | 2024-02-22T15:11:57 | Tatsuya Hiraoka, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do pretrained language models have knowledge regarding the surface
information of tokens? We examined the surface information stored in word or
subword embeddings acquired by pretrained language models from the perspectives
of token length, substrings, and token constitution. Additionally, we evaluated
the ability of models to generate knowledge regarding token surfaces. We
focused on 12 pretrained language models that were mainly trained on English
and Japanese corpora. Experimental results demonstrate that pretrained language
models have knowledge regarding token length and substrings but not token
constitution. Additionally, the results imply that there is a bottleneck on the
decoder side in terms of effectively utilizing acquired knowledge. | [
0.0308085717,
0.0387487374,
-0.0102743953,
0.0397441834,
-0.0142205888,
0.0057378234,
-0.0075448863,
0.0278217383,
-0.0552931465,
-0.0449030548,
-0.0605213754,
-0.0213312861,
0.0085835522,
0.0442752205,
0.0435726605,
-0.0586373545,
0.0614082702,
-0.0193419512,
0.0162303913,
0.0009449469,
0.015747631,
-0.0033461642,
-0.0142157124,
0.0331280679,
-0.0751795471,
-0.0028787318,
-0.009811189,
-0.0148242069,
-0.0378708988,
0.0059387935,
-0.0318632424,
0.0391418636,
0.024312567,
0.0445700176,
0.0000016248,
-0.0313160792,
-0.0025141137,
-0.012285064,
-0.0540278293,
0.0413174219,
0.0688215792,
-0.0348840952,
-0.0192340948,
0.0148719531,
-0.0173679553,
-0.0524281599,
0.0542236567,
0.0503875315,
0.0141253471,
0.0314452201,
-0.0106372312,
-0.0150952246,
0.0429134294,
-0.0030186658,
-0.0232712273,
-0.0422142632,
0.0079518845,
-0.0291674361,
-0.0449908264,
-0.0105288811,
-0.0513407364,
0.0045919637,
0.011329799,
0.0329812504,
-0.0101686493,
0.0577519163,
-0.0281154662,
-0.0257950537,
-0.0204146281,
0.0436180606,
-0.0301257391,
-0.0254945923,
-0.0565287694,
-0.0008796589,
0.0072297086,
-0.0090695675,
0.0003795577,
0.0063101389,
0.0044825003,
0.0256616864,
0.0349097252,
0.0160471089,
0.0226448774,
-0.006673872,
-0.0699149072,
0.0787397623,
0.0286628138,
-0.0575282499,
-0.0121323587,
-0.0364081338,
0.0055184253,
-0.0515351221,
0.0217690878,
0.0044172094,
0.0155562228,
0.0613041073,
-0.0324018672,
-0.0517224297,
0.0035170466,
-0.0200848617,
-0.0077480967,
0.0422633477,
-0.014320232,
0.0073201917,
-0.0477469638,
0.0550498441,
-0.0040091602,
0.0325985812,
-0.0539740808,
-0.0147400675,
-0.011655557,
-0.0552916899,
-0.0934990942,
0.0729887858,
-0.0394129418,
-0.0311031099,
-0.0072206403,
0.0106229223,
0.0445818454,
-0.0206254367,
-0.0191702973,
-0.0064239437,
-0.0274663921,
0.005234383,
-0.0325207263,
-0.0057480736,
-0.0423647426,
0.0240278523,
-0.013451363,
-0.0489077084,
0.0132872574,
-0.0290868245,
0.0155663462,
-0.0229172111,
0.0040583941,
0.0639365166,
-0.0096231354,
-0.0467226356,
-0.0246459339,
-0.0189662501,
-0.0174716692,
-0.0376424268,
-0.030063834,
-0.0270899776,
0.0281127058,
0.0129400594,
0.013520807,
-0.0212605428,
-0.0103487354,
-0.0025993369,
-0.0251973774,
0.099263072,
-0.0347770937,
0.0058714114,
-0.0068616685,
-0.0084642973,
0.0269625969,
0.0592117384,
0.0074810628,
0.040504992,
0.0408194661,
-0.0484124906,
-0.0190694481,
0.0301901344,
0.0614442863,
-0.0301768202,
-0.0164843518,
-0.0140098557,
0.0371443219,
0.0285413675,
0.0247718114,
0.0514389016,
-0.0391244851,
-0.0079425815,
0.0215096287,
0.109575592,
-0.0026669828,
0.0419442207,
0.0720528513,
-0.0181680676,
0.0294451192,
0.0565098003,
-0.0188512877,
-0.0533895344,
0.0069221607,
0.0417520069,
0.0280358288,
-0.0193589125,
-0.0314948298,
-0.0390954725,
-0.0395432971,
-0.0380873233,
-0.0113389129,
-0.0557570904,
0.0609403402,
0.0313626416,
-0.0638078079,
0.0630046576,
0.0152220996,
-0.0483438447,
0.0239713583,
-0.0048265401,
0.0018447178,
0.0629498512,
0.0199343655,
-0.0231969226,
-0.0067726704,
0.0415278114,
0.0250360649,
0.0124077778,
0.0676110089,
-0.0185801275,
0.0296635795,
-0.0045344778,
0.0129065122,
0.0230203047,
0.0211822148,
0.0439262278,
-0.0145596769,
0.0224577896,
-0.0049955053,
-0.0957233086,
-0.0029116003,
0.068264544,
0.0037785477,
-0.0105503071,
-0.0462049693,
0.0292618573,
0.0485202074,
0.0211871918,
-0.0107059218,
0.0354905501,
0.0566253588,
-0.0514591858,
-0.0053102016,
0.0382124856,
-0.0709816292,
-0.0147310439,
0.0327750184,
0.0088803973,
0.0326287113,
0.0070715384,
0.0070098201,
-0.0133300535,
0.0371500887,
-0.0116561903,
0.1421438456,
-0.0472884066,
0.0073168692,
-0.000909586,
0.0225405097,
0.0063376101,
0.0421110988,
-0.032304395,
0.0314161777,
-0.0266970657,
-0.0050020008,
0.0160587337,
-0.0162437763,
-0.0094256336,
0.0042194002,
-0.0308492333,
-0.0268456247,
-0.0183108896,
-0.0208214708,
-0.0160362683,
0.0047011278,
-0.0911690369,
-0.0521911345,
-0.0062930621,
0.0241030585,
-0.0237495974,
0.0019602349,
-0.0228136107,
-0.0132603534,
0.0196044743,
-0.0103559289,
-0.0237673242,
0.0272372682,
0.0281897616,
0.0202753786,
-0.0052735046,
-0.0446036234,
-0.0210231636,
-0.0216298923,
0.0536505058,
0.0008880393,
-0.0192399267,
-0.0291525051,
0.0218660347,
-0.0049294075,
0.043183919,
0.0188261755,
-0.1023832113,
0.0301302653,
-0.0009950158,
0.0730021223,
0.0412053429,
-0.0094665131,
0.0633081645,
0.0160348862,
-0.013582834,
-0.0376667567,
-0.0066892733,
-0.010790851,
-0.0193178989,
-0.0647902638,
0.0073364368,
0.0283490214,
0.0974733904,
0.0231811143,
-0.0052230605,
-0.0674438849,
0.0335885435,
-0.0566066802,
-0.0447937734,
-0.0063837045,
-0.0356634855,
-0.0354946181,
0.0351064205,
-0.032592807,
-0.0596994199,
0.0642116219,
-0.0788621232,
-0.0087853028,
-0.0182440877,
0.0311199017,
-0.0119059635,
0.0595468059,
0.0191214774,
0.0392303728,
-0.0131269991,
-0.0891738608,
0.0026694501,
0.023753887,
-0.0362365022,
-0.0292513911,
-0.0309703089,
0.0063657849,
-0.0031020183,
0.0062915417,
-0.0145516759,
-0.0397233777,
-0.0329964086,
-0.0311725698,
0.0307093356,
0.0498828292,
-0.005928061,
0.0322755426,
0.0577623956,
-0.0122079263,
0.0144059546,
0.0148730818,
0.0203168076,
-0.020474568,
0.0027937551,
-0.0009590881,
-0.0248120017,
-0.0156884734,
-0.0144671425,
0.0309619531,
0.0078801578,
0.0727309063,
-0.0124727516,
-0.0170301739,
0.0012467495,
0.0415834822,
-0.0308723971,
-0.0053206705,
0.0035656344,
0.0361033753,
-0.0161407199,
-0.0175395031,
0.1245026588,
0.0582852885,
-0.030635817,
0.036517784,
-0.0122871706,
-0.0106589943,
0.0221204553,
-0.0082576256,
-0.0641009733,
-0.023123024,
0.0181945097,
-0.0194673091,
0.0181123465,
-0.0142458631,
-0.0078724166,
-0.1011787876,
-0.0169768501,
-0.0029885294,
-0.1127425283,
-0.0638551712,
-0.0290978029,
-0.021158034,
0.0219461005,
0.0604377761,
-0.0011241119,
-0.0313150547,
-0.0162506588,
0.0314518772,
-0.05313728,
-0.0543667302,
0.0041132956,
-0.0518700518,
0.0277127028,
0.0508339517,
0.0249873977,
-0.0350842774,
-0.0294318646,
0.0277145542,
-0.0125589417,
0.0296416208,
-0.0237712413,
0.0306973178,
-0.0580012873,
-0.0174842756,
0.0355528146,
0.0143041853,
-0.0043251626,
-0.0066059548,
-0.0463825911,
0.0381407514,
0.0312857479,
-0.0006180754,
0.0089233844,
-0.0460124724,
-0.0154042235,
0.092246227,
0.0645935908,
-0.0275413916,
-0.0065475316,
-0.0153034488,
0.0548955388,
-0.0228362251,
0.0193616059,
-0.0067509916,
-0.0111297071,
0.0017193104,
-0.0797582269,
-0.0238565728,
0.0597785749,
0.0501226075,
0.0123980893,
0.0356161036,
-0.0263141822,
-0.0310414452,
-0.0568898097,
0.0252292771,
-0.0057337764,
0.0113851931,
-0.0756476223,
-0.0170290545,
-0.0011535145,
-0.0109962141,
-0.0249734446,
-0.016582977,
-0.001665523,
-0.0397944748,
0.026668204,
0.0354848504,
0.0220668614,
0.0395048074,
-0.0585703626,
-0.0486095324,
0.0340869799,
-0.0228099097,
-0.0697690472,
-0.0163999796,
0.0392596014,
-0.024843974,
0.0142202675,
0.0143259261,
-0.010231371,
-0.0168823097,
0.027123386,
0.0068260198,
0.0420919769,
0.0211190041,
0.0489365421,
0.0125805801,
0.0526433252,
-0.0242921859,
0.0152350944,
-0.0408020616,
0.0254865084,
-0.0282584634,
0.0296546668,
-0.0157279689,
-0.030006066,
0.0323145688,
-0.001038753,
-0.0131198997,
-0.0372541621,
-0.0361390524,
0.043444898,
0.0398412049,
-0.0038468351,
0.0209357645,
0.0410503857,
0.0421557873,
0.0064580617,
-0.0117977895,
-0.0270196497,
-0.042407468,
-0.0197270773,
-0.0580467433,
-0.0215626266,
0.0013472188,
0.024972314,
-0.047840789,
0.0439229906,
-0.0002850302,
-0.0205666367,
-0.0082793199,
0.0298967399,
0.0331637859,
-0.0446952693,
-0.035657037,
-0.0345581695,
0.0098311473,
-0.0054180976,
-0.0111534782,
-0.0325940251,
-0.0052059027,
0.0626748204,
0.021395836,
-0.0350587852,
-0.0304798856,
0.0888197944,
0.0804592147,
0.0453993678,
-0.0325471312,
-0.007482518,
-0.0177957956,
0.0509502403,
0.026482407,
0.055751197,
-0.0582654253,
0.0389929563,
-0.0908468217,
-0.0730364397,
-0.0012745974,
0.0324097201,
0.0080202864,
0.0424005911,
0.016478559,
0.0735353306,
-0.0028470939,
-0.0172936618,
0.0046259379,
0.012536536,
0.0334167033,
-0.0154606709,
0.0075940345,
-5.853993826e-33,
-0.0542485565,
0.0019297614,
0.0003159973,
-0.0139987953,
-0.0328238346,
0.0307096709,
-0.0125564476,
-0.0099537438,
-0.0345557071,
0.0198950972,
-0.0323144719,
-0.0022074236,
0.0262527689,
-0.0002267739,
-0.007819538,
0.001362229,
0.0515402928,
-0.0132585913,
-0.0105000297,
-0.0360135436,
0.0290545002,
0.0353595987,
0.0725812316,
0.0314394385,
-0.0011250643,
-0.0090338383,
0.0312508605,
0.0286157746,
0.0070287189,
0.0709022805,
-0.0501485355,
0.0285073947,
0.0267444998,
-0.0121976333,
-0.0370786972,
0.0384777188,
-0.1065260991,
-0.0268417019,
0.068849206,
0.0435608402,
0.0063350038,
-0.0301037505,
0.0215684846,
-0.0203816853,
-0.0011964098,
0.0568834022,
0.0012214937,
0.0029465954,
-0.016902674,
0.0186246336,
-0.0933964774,
0.0021631431,
0.0125347814,
0.0082648797,
0.0701607466,
-0.0472652093,
0.0227258876,
-0.0232627168,
-0.0212654695,
0.0212400723,
0.0136217922,
0.0567901358,
0.0297801271,
0.012698045,
0.0002663699,
0.0358690694,
0.0543559827,
-0.0336576439,
-0.0026968052,
0.0297044124,
0.086286366,
0.0034817276,
0.0074892049,
-0.0042834003,
0.0339355543,
-0.0594395362,
-0.0101425229,
-0.0447351336,
-0.0359223969,
0.0578111522,
0.0075348923,
0.0089717042,
-0.0256667193,
-0.0130977714,
-0.0489838459,
-0.0267632045,
-0.0260304455,
-0.015223043,
0.0364123769,
0.0139334239,
0.0018414452,
-0.0419475585,
0.0200988948,
-0.0131940711,
-0.0210004766,
0.0102369655,
0.0677281842,
0.0077736294,
-0.0390744768,
0.0439353846,
-0.0656537488,
-0.0495290123,
-0.0099515887,
0.0020905565,
-0.0005963095,
-0.0177298319,
0.0222577248,
0.0127184493,
-0.0437605344,
0.0006579676,
-0.0364146829,
-0.0224839617,
-0.0084953364,
-0.0121933417,
0.0730781779,
0.0461408198,
-0.0147806248,
0.0035325075,
0.0125588244,
-0.0324148722,
-0.0216244813,
-0.0165490452,
0.0151454723,
0.0571882986,
-0.0254057422,
-0.0348236486,
-0.0346679613,
0.0146272629,
0.0469533838,
-0.0084065525,
-0.0085057551,
0.0574027076,
2.396e-7,
0.0619531535,
0.0452550426,
0.0750046819,
-0.0131604848,
0.009119831,
-0.0058408985,
-0.0240126047,
-0.0011005574,
-0.0137209762,
-0.0037430592,
0.0061951377,
0.0020892094,
0.0084082382,
-0.0083056586,
-0.1015096307,
0.0038571365,
0.0024328372,
0.006959917,
-0.0670296997,
0.0303431768,
0.012538828,
0.0893742144,
0.0053960094,
0.010208196,
-0.0289800651,
-0.0405834205,
0.026124496,
-0.0260870606,
-0.0029072969,
0.0050796526,
0.0043259156,
0.0386021584,
0.0300692189,
0.0578561723,
-0.0297980364,
0.0310512297,
0.0286978949,
-0.0067294515,
-0.0387132987,
-0.0083957277,
-0.0118669989,
-0.0262332261,
-0.0580298156,
-0.0300032534,
0.0491038784,
-0.0418920629,
0.0055493065,
-0.0271623079,
-0.0010032958,
0.0293252207,
-0.0197011065,
-0.0169934295,
-0.0404182449,
0.0430861935,
0.0448592864,
0.0052948655,
-0.0024429408,
-0.0443635099,
0.0046943254,
0.016388515,
-0.0194435138,
-0.0290453359,
-0.0184126329,
-0.0135712726,
0.0550640821,
-0.0571980812,
-0.0286540966,
1.955910331e-34,
0.027945457,
-0.0057640285,
0.0263621733,
0.0645180345,
0.0332600474,
-0.0395518541,
0.0164832771,
0.0154738352,
-0.0071359472,
-0.0312972404,
0.0078060608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09801v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09801v2 | EFUF: Efficient Fine-grained Unlearning Framework for Mitigating Hallucinations in Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T08:58:03 | 2024-06-24T00:50:58 | Shangyu Xing, Fei Zhao, Zhen Wu, Tuo An, Weihao Chen, Chunhui Li, Jianbing Zhang, Xinyu Dai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have attracted increasing attention
in the past few years, but they may still generate descriptions that include
objects not present in the corresponding images, a phenomenon known as object
hallucination. To eliminate hallucinations, existing methods manually annotate
paired responses with and without hallucinations, and then employ various
alignment algorithms to improve the alignment capability between images and
text. However, they not only demand considerable computation resources during
the finetuning stage but also require expensive human annotation to construct
paired data needed by the alignment algorithms. To address these issues, we
borrow the idea of unlearning and propose an efficient fine-grained unlearning
framework (EFUF), which can eliminate hallucinations without the need for
paired data. Extensive experiments show that our method consistently reduces
hallucinations while preserving the generation quality with modest
computational overhead. Our code and datasets will be publicly available. | [
-0.0059950389,
0.0982073992,
0.017613912,
0.0985440537,
-0.020349171,
0.037431825,
0.0164347831,
-0.0085010491,
-0.0123924855,
-0.0529568344,
-0.0334885269,
-0.04136011,
0.0278096963,
-0.0141160758,
0.0487085022,
-0.065795131,
0.0266099572,
-0.0667975545,
-0.0526330881,
-0.0223893169,
0.0343271457,
0.0195734669,
-0.0249548219,
0.0204825643,
-0.0287005175,
-0.0756975934,
-0.0227326564,
0.0157663617,
0.0048821829,
0.0046226578,
-0.0174001772,
0.0778069869,
0.0075970823,
0.0363323279,
0.000001947,
-0.0282891747,
0.0025336221,
0.0105575901,
0.0503914878,
0.007613569,
0.0399443209,
-0.0261008982,
0.0104508959,
-0.018672321,
-0.0096802013,
-0.0288372431,
0.099284634,
0.0626375899,
0.0522325672,
0.0439128838,
-0.0158142559,
-0.0477070585,
-0.005931871,
0.012882513,
0.0399562567,
0.0013188161,
0.0295262467,
0.0005392564,
-0.0401602574,
-0.0524560362,
-0.0418521874,
0.0399908349,
0.0029063802,
0.0036421961,
0.0145558324,
0.025137106,
-0.0588813201,
-0.0366177857,
-0.0097587127,
0.1056355312,
-0.0299559049,
-0.0282542333,
0.005606289,
0.0062791952,
-0.0065687108,
0.0050219377,
-0.0340757445,
0.032635577,
-0.0157865379,
0.0294183008,
-0.0380952954,
-0.030017402,
0.0245244224,
-0.0026837911,
-0.0094817225,
0.0211099703,
0.0373500995,
-0.0025506078,
-0.0249611363,
0.0215265546,
-0.038654469,
-0.0612425804,
-0.0030268149,
0.0135597279,
-0.0202678628,
-0.0110342838,
-0.0702957213,
-0.0275963005,
0.0177754089,
-0.0225895792,
0.039319139,
-0.0171741713,
-0.0758285597,
0.0606206916,
-0.0204800274,
0.017266307,
-0.0342734307,
0.0397200063,
-0.02851074,
0.0068514096,
-0.0084957192,
0.0053963596,
-0.0273522735,
0.0088039627,
-0.0155519256,
-0.0323100537,
0.0020171101,
0.0033981395,
-0.0326064564,
0.0278807152,
-0.0552270338,
0.0193466414,
-0.0334574915,
-0.0234064143,
0.0015225221,
0.050297942,
0.004503184,
-0.0172219556,
-0.0054558166,
-0.0551388226,
-0.0140324729,
0.0572818182,
0.0251302905,
-0.024290666,
-0.0345279947,
0.0620494671,
-0.0109449374,
-0.0139008565,
0.0016560527,
-0.0286563318,
-0.0416550189,
-0.0698235333,
0.0278875045,
-0.0700581968,
0.0552538261,
-0.0085289767,
0.0026823473,
-0.0414587967,
0.0200795326,
0.0100953951,
-0.0390511081,
0.1011780202,
-0.0545214526,
0.0070755137,
-0.0030015013,
0.0023380925,
0.0134514263,
0.0827730522,
0.003368258,
0.0375452973,
0.020276878,
-0.0341933332,
0.0414963439,
0.0708124414,
0.0072472165,
0.0109362239,
-0.0486571863,
-0.0224607661,
0.0430492498,
0.025074888,
0.0420643613,
0.0464917608,
-0.0246917736,
-0.0079595316,
0.0801186785,
-0.0011725969,
-0.0131764375,
0.0036975611,
0.0029264668,
-0.004390561,
0.0015047607,
0.0643891618,
-0.0569988899,
0.0567772128,
-0.0322017036,
0.0323830545,
0.0576342568,
0.0442180336,
-0.0369916596,
-0.0011604611,
-0.0126059959,
-0.0283010919,
0.0246569496,
0.0176945273,
0.0377001949,
0.0383900329,
-0.0598851629,
0.0362549461,
0.0559864677,
-0.0397962444,
0.0178960022,
-0.006063804,
0.0138026271,
0.0707841218,
0.0532229729,
-0.0044446825,
-0.0204135738,
-0.0161812808,
0.0610686541,
0.0888469443,
0.0063583762,
0.0062569063,
0.0514331385,
-0.0625530779,
-0.0238568466,
0.0127817933,
-0.0011842034,
-0.0154800294,
-0.0028826643,
-0.0308275912,
0.0034396623,
-0.0153275589,
-0.0163495857,
0.0487216301,
0.0149679938,
-0.0016257467,
-0.0454386473,
0.0127554219,
0.0068900213,
-0.0131812971,
-0.0154088885,
0.0016875209,
0.0066745933,
-0.0237471871,
0.0200675204,
0.0035614169,
-0.0244115051,
-0.0356667154,
0.0477707796,
-0.0195576809,
-0.0368944965,
0.0149414055,
-0.0271921605,
-0.014437492,
-0.0152354771,
-0.0175020676,
0.0178591534,
-0.0477557071,
0.0311848875,
0.0142696062,
0.0393160433,
-0.029036453,
0.0627031103,
-0.0200610925,
0.0053462135,
0.0006302103,
0.003196561,
-0.027587926,
-0.0339348204,
-0.0525784716,
0.0339713246,
0.0044732154,
0.0414714776,
-0.0296538454,
-0.0248867534,
-0.0544700585,
-0.0235346518,
-0.0736993402,
0.0005762598,
-0.002874041,
-0.0204876754,
0.0299159382,
-0.0074577155,
0.0115772039,
-0.0259002317,
-0.030083159,
0.0562450923,
-0.0101768365,
0.0320996568,
0.0179977082,
-0.0189539641,
-0.0262806769,
-0.0159309767,
-0.0006202752,
0.0083604353,
0.0545600504,
-0.003285028,
-0.047721073,
-0.0789846629,
0.022711046,
-0.0686588213,
0.0395620875,
0.0162352771,
-0.0115462318,
-0.0078014634,
-0.0198183004,
0.0305597428,
0.0607937202,
0.005042925,
0.0298704263,
0.0477335006,
-0.0248970017,
-0.0230422765,
-0.0112677393,
-0.016279798,
-0.0114454478,
0.023008503,
-0.01485682,
-0.0197626594,
0.0433502682,
-0.002002304,
0.0261358004,
-0.0469117612,
0.0263083894,
0.0030853599,
-0.0536984839,
-0.0380918831,
0.0211431943,
-0.0196136907,
0.0082669621,
-0.0528057367,
-0.0564104579,
0.0380481482,
-0.0474628136,
-0.0101309679,
0.0094228648,
0.0435353816,
0.0160535537,
0.0375996158,
0.0397955365,
0.0459985435,
-0.0107843587,
-0.0042956304,
-0.0519448034,
0.0005766581,
-0.0085969167,
-0.0408165678,
0.0422604382,
-0.0437318422,
0.0192822032,
-0.0192858856,
-0.0194450337,
-0.0121445423,
-0.0456495211,
-0.0044916761,
-0.0486521721,
-0.0616436675,
-0.0097678136,
-0.0337794162,
0.0265502539,
0.000961074,
0.0022923171,
-0.0309576392,
0.002755804,
-0.0274420083,
0.0585151613,
0.0906184763,
-0.0040740864,
-0.0118802423,
-0.0844554156,
0.0015657553,
0.0675309002,
0.0206481703,
0.0468870588,
-0.0394887552,
-0.0121954335,
0.0159738008,
0.0410803556,
-0.0087043028,
0.019144224,
0.0499945879,
-0.0290855803,
0.0028226371,
0.0914097577,
0.0096308393,
-0.0670481622,
-0.0191152766,
0.0137302876,
0.0829964578,
-0.006582275,
-0.0098205628,
-0.0803283677,
-0.0520314649,
-0.0059935469,
-0.0192098822,
0.0442617685,
-0.0172493532,
-0.0016445116,
-0.0823240727,
0.0393512771,
0.0459767468,
-0.0436772816,
-0.0389886685,
0.0273560341,
0.0255684257,
0.0161571745,
0.034891367,
0.008051347,
0.0027838286,
-0.0006148698,
0.0240470786,
0.0022517452,
-0.0333503895,
-0.0059701903,
-0.0550568365,
0.0461262539,
0.0576543026,
0.0348948613,
0.0038145774,
-0.0608102903,
0.0374553688,
0.0086004045,
-0.0055406429,
0.0162044,
0.05968602,
-0.0069668805,
-0.0380026773,
0.0116231386,
0.0270489361,
-0.0162858553,
-0.0311910696,
-0.0085018156,
0.0378417857,
-0.0106426626,
-0.0103543093,
-0.0101468926,
0.0252518822,
0.0087930206,
0.0726122931,
0.0356287807,
-0.0595567822,
-0.0137230027,
0.0016692341,
0.0365005657,
-0.0181917977,
-0.0192557964,
0.042321872,
0.0151483743,
-0.0157936811,
-0.0834368467,
-0.0336505473,
0.0388276279,
0.0306666233,
0.0118021565,
0.0322926193,
-0.0378925018,
-0.0185670909,
-0.0311419498,
0.0570552759,
-0.0602869801,
0.0088247713,
-0.0158690941,
-0.0006964206,
-0.0003213431,
-0.0219552703,
0.0110056754,
0.0517965257,
-0.1072813123,
-0.0651272088,
0.0005391862,
0.037691664,
0.017975267,
0.0620314963,
0.0001545968,
-0.0688048974,
0.0043287938,
0.0695734397,
0.0219853017,
0.0379108414,
-0.0299201906,
0.0016358548,
0.0020640027,
0.0314858221,
-0.0216905493,
-0.0070996261,
0.0227157827,
0.0208510719,
0.0180728715,
-0.0264490135,
0.0175288077,
0.0093409801,
0.0478433035,
-0.0404384658,
0.0086638257,
-0.0250137243,
-0.0181162637,
-0.0065591838,
-0.0556728505,
-0.059435375,
-0.0111600738,
0.0113220587,
0.0062906654,
0.0133601651,
-0.0117585585,
0.0215277076,
0.0183463413,
-0.0442987271,
-0.0439250693,
0.0111312084,
-0.0522674546,
0.037853159,
0.0220678169,
-0.0093158493,
0.0385606401,
-0.0112722721,
0.0213861112,
-0.000645912,
0.0735294372,
0.0114799729,
-0.009339056,
-0.0427301861,
0.0189257171,
0.030969752,
-0.0513856336,
-0.0818107203,
0.0303929709,
0.0536210053,
-0.0029076615,
0.0770078972,
-0.0093249539,
-0.0213689599,
-0.0347470641,
0.0595048107,
0.0157818459,
-0.0409608632,
0.0355580375,
0.0166368429,
-0.0252579395,
-0.0090999817,
0.0774675235,
-0.0070836223,
0.0300298091,
0.0017491038,
0.0122473072,
-0.0433401763,
-0.0400412045,
0.0084448596,
-0.0216874704,
-0.0145969847,
-0.0150317801,
-0.0026141382,
-0.0600431375,
-0.0270627737,
0.0191673879,
-0.0003750217,
0.0194101799,
0.048496861,
0.0440896749,
-0.0338984579,
-0.0007466457,
-0.0258559585,
-0.0114146089,
0.0505003855,
-0.0209645089,
-0.0007075398,
-6.14904401e-33,
-0.0310993679,
-0.0330857895,
0.0019754586,
-0.0297014285,
-0.0177848134,
-0.0048451801,
-0.0032626318,
0.0281218346,
0.0195437539,
0.0134064639,
0.035145998,
-0.0170834996,
0.0160705,
0.032644596,
-0.0171554796,
-0.0032228243,
0.0317945518,
-0.0148570668,
-0.0207866915,
0.0152853001,
0.0132854367,
0.0126880817,
0.0440731943,
-0.0749138147,
-0.0034891113,
-0.0282440986,
-0.0641369149,
0.0178744979,
0.0070560505,
0.0394531414,
-0.0641831905,
0.021393124,
0.0094829081,
0.0202810038,
-0.0523740388,
0.0231242366,
-0.0504162274,
0.0411400981,
0.0006483285,
0.059615463,
-0.073303923,
-0.0167827718,
0.0621239953,
-0.0388534702,
-0.0033317872,
-0.0343251638,
0.0518698357,
-0.0295890179,
-0.0284715258,
0.0429760478,
-0.0695110857,
-0.0045843036,
-0.0078105237,
-0.0420584306,
0.0508874133,
0.0298371222,
0.0073424582,
0.0152115207,
-0.0676401258,
0.0077863545,
-0.0149448896,
0.023464784,
0.0887693763,
0.036445383,
0.0110868188,
0.0913384855,
0.0991642252,
-0.0053429804,
-0.0167807732,
-0.0076080007,
0.0263969209,
0.0495509841,
0.0204424635,
0.0612132289,
0.0474513248,
0.0208870284,
-0.0153852794,
0.0146066891,
-0.0942872465,
0.0104422271,
0.0548275597,
0.024464082,
0.0035250478,
-0.0116665112,
-0.0216876045,
-0.0015219568,
-0.0557798035,
-0.0017602403,
0.0277621783,
-0.0070156422,
-0.0478380434,
0.00353742,
0.0695155337,
-0.0271184258,
-0.0229052622,
-0.0058259135,
-0.0285194665,
0.057663992,
-0.0143055888,
-0.0123140085,
0.0071827066,
-0.0483200327,
0.0379172713,
-0.0061974269,
0.037234582,
0.0238637086,
0.0573603287,
0.0128222974,
-0.0626769736,
0.0156222908,
-0.0630755499,
-0.0055420334,
0.0244272202,
0.0054508331,
0.0595092177,
-0.0330112763,
-0.0299238637,
0.0309007093,
0.0430415235,
-0.0038168509,
-0.011669185,
-0.0188626647,
-0.0330824889,
-0.0034164935,
-0.0181955099,
0.0172112361,
-0.0219517387,
-0.0819927976,
0.0395959169,
-0.0532030202,
-0.0059223981,
0.0060080625,
2.54e-7,
0.0109758517,
0.0284381434,
0.0275035109,
-0.0138612036,
0.0408074819,
0.0374601781,
-0.0063268314,
0.0341619886,
0.0081786653,
-0.0505662858,
-0.0145256547,
0.0249052271,
0.069407396,
0.0066124275,
-0.0528097153,
0.0181942713,
-0.0410232879,
0.0311726537,
-0.0535204448,
-0.0346053503,
0.0160360523,
0.0545680784,
-0.0131367464,
-0.0309790708,
0.0380345881,
-0.0476259962,
0.0812563747,
-0.0292840526,
-0.0162610356,
0.0008700764,
0.010642644,
0.0122371148,
0.001648606,
0.0251546185,
-0.001732175,
-0.0534094945,
0.0658997223,
0.0316875055,
-0.0267049056,
-0.01329289,
-0.022835739,
0.0084810276,
-0.0180719718,
-0.0444003493,
0.0753667206,
-0.0354246423,
-0.0375857279,
-0.0238285381,
-0.0308588836,
-0.0147549724,
0.0368271321,
-0.0130656399,
-0.0211908612,
0.0471957996,
0.0457456969,
0.0073243729,
-0.0640569255,
-0.0386708528,
-0.0517863221,
-0.0067913905,
-0.0384943746,
-0.0212230682,
-0.0088896323,
-0.0197360385,
-0.0139966095,
-0.1063983589,
-0.0225060042,
2.365279453e-34,
0.0040197168,
-0.0060715289,
0.0448193103,
0.0115489913,
0.0264219083,
-0.0333892889,
0.0040544886,
0.0109738363,
-0.0318760462,
-0.0553279072,
-0.0032547337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09773v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09773v2 | NutePrune: Efficient Progressive Pruning with Numerous Teachers for Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T08:03:12 | 2024-06-27T04:49:11 | Shengrui Li, Junzhe Chen, Xueting Han, Jing Bai | cs.CL | cs.CL | The considerable size of Large Language Models (LLMs) presents notable
deployment challenges, particularly on resource-constrained hardware.
Structured pruning, offers an effective means to compress LLMs, thereby
reducing storage costs and enhancing inference speed for more efficient
utilization. In this work, we study data-efficient and resource-efficient
structure pruning methods to obtain smaller yet still powerful models.
Knowledge Distillation is well-suited for pruning, as the intact model can
serve as an excellent teacher for pruned students. However, it becomes
challenging in the context of LLMs due to memory constraints. To address this,
we propose an efficient progressive Numerous-teacher pruning method
(NutePrune). NutePrune mitigates excessive memory costs by loading only one
intact model and integrating it with various masks and LoRA modules, enabling
it to seamlessly switch between teacher and student roles. This approach allows
us to leverage numerous teachers with varying capacities to progressively guide
the pruned model, enhancing overall performance. Extensive experiments across
various tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of NutePrune. In LLaMA-7B zero-shot
experiments, NutePrune retains 97.17% of the performance of the original model
at 20% sparsity and 95.07% at 25% sparsity. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Lucius-lsr/NutePrune. | [
0.0098492773,
0.0860462487,
-0.0146695683,
0.0528271981,
-0.0273990855,
-0.0100637944,
0.0474488065,
0.0255191978,
-0.0252526477,
0.0057180878,
-0.025611626,
-0.0407233723,
-0.0120368404,
0.0003085867,
0.0016818428,
-0.0562860891,
0.0238671433,
-0.0794612318,
-0.0106325112,
-0.0275407843,
0.0030133822,
0.0152735617,
0.0169856437,
0.0146190524,
0.0187705755,
-0.0201654211,
-0.0196862835,
0.0048783207,
-0.0118552232,
-0.0011766789,
0.003319829,
0.0588435121,
0.01889221,
0.0344373733,
0.0000024017,
-0.0126083493,
0.0063570989,
0.0122005045,
-0.0635156333,
0.0800014585,
0.0672001392,
0.0049355957,
-0.0063465228,
0.023661986,
0.0037803855,
-0.0055496218,
0.0428687893,
-0.0345352367,
0.0532783195,
0.0444386192,
0.0148179159,
-0.0326002911,
-0.0172493067,
-0.0322645754,
-0.0260601342,
-0.0291350614,
0.026609607,
-0.0206367765,
-0.0040276665,
-0.0181614198,
-0.0240753945,
0.0371299349,
0.0424482152,
-0.0025556516,
-0.0412621945,
0.020981485,
-0.0228384249,
-0.0535878763,
0.0135797011,
0.0230068453,
-0.0269416217,
-0.0463364013,
0.0393383428,
-0.0041500437,
-0.0370844081,
-0.0385798477,
-0.0554993637,
0.0404778831,
-0.0026452949,
0.032922145,
-0.0024137939,
-0.0241792947,
0.0247063395,
0.009826269,
-0.0293600317,
0.0313112959,
0.0453429036,
0.0030250072,
-0.0236477368,
-0.0001529206,
0.0029314868,
-0.0542201512,
-0.006960955,
0.02413279,
-0.0072009298,
0.0233672094,
-0.0697492361,
-0.0154140424,
0.0356519707,
-0.0172593892,
0.041983515,
0.0497732051,
0.0118153328,
0.0480841845,
-0.0026525669,
0.0329645462,
0.0108513143,
0.0041513033,
-0.0258706249,
-0.0167570207,
-0.0080864206,
-0.0000618671,
-0.0170803275,
0.0362473764,
-0.0378660224,
-0.0121723684,
-0.0334748365,
-0.0146945408,
0.0007205786,
-0.025963217,
0.0416934155,
-0.0124592939,
-0.0416007265,
0.012671846,
0.0124186641,
0.0494737811,
-0.0299727395,
0.0006826405,
-0.0167189203,
-0.07755775,
-0.0303830598,
0.0179582275,
-0.0070232726,
-0.0439309888,
0.0273369998,
0.0362419076,
0.0032229286,
-0.0699981824,
-0.0476869829,
-0.0205535572,
0.0066365707,
-0.088909857,
0.0156307351,
-0.0820952281,
0.0423101932,
-0.0344511569,
0.0085551208,
-0.0705897808,
-0.0021658633,
0.017092362,
-0.0368270613,
0.0367595926,
0.0077811554,
0.018746173,
0.018101234,
0.0333769284,
0.0188334435,
0.1104400232,
0.013230416,
0.0420566127,
0.0058707786,
-0.0079059843,
-0.0429309681,
0.0590653941,
0.0508120395,
0.0324519426,
-0.0414654464,
-0.019834701,
-0.004850884,
-0.0018666725,
0.0712310523,
0.0639318675,
-0.0392799415,
-0.0119784055,
0.0534721576,
0.03458561,
0.0156081282,
0.0188275464,
0.0180551484,
-0.0015010455,
0.0304999463,
-0.0089766784,
-0.0413816497,
0.0218934063,
-0.0122766439,
-0.0059369504,
0.0279111546,
0.0845227391,
-0.0354684256,
-0.0109967748,
-0.0250651296,
-0.0147531973,
-0.0020555444,
0.0430203043,
0.0618850552,
-0.0070413994,
-0.0128135979,
0.0923430845,
0.0691973343,
-0.0645662248,
-0.0012331725,
-0.0742920265,
0.0022603562,
0.0302516017,
0.0156456046,
-0.0215146355,
-0.0344999954,
0.0626380295,
0.024574643,
0.0059281844,
0.0115473038,
-0.0024265421,
0.0378971957,
-0.0471445732,
-0.0132106533,
-0.0081811398,
0.0248277299,
0.0069272388,
0.060564369,
0.0192776192,
0.0104644811,
-0.0194062851,
-0.0040155598,
0.0428452827,
-0.0610759333,
-0.0071850326,
-0.0177767184,
-0.0116291316,
0.0233891979,
-0.0216494035,
-0.0174251832,
-0.0236716755,
0.0674895942,
-0.0421983935,
0.0546681844,
-0.0552753694,
-0.0265437923,
-0.0605864972,
0.0606404357,
0.028179802,
0.0327170715,
0.043793533,
-0.058358103,
-0.0447279438,
0.024131326,
-0.0252126791,
0.0345958062,
-0.029738158,
0.0393666402,
-0.0195878111,
0.0435283706,
0.0075765494,
0.0307945944,
-0.030438479,
-0.005726865,
0.0363192186,
-0.0360294655,
0.0039255926,
-0.0430926308,
-0.0458494164,
0.0148321185,
0.0031050767,
0.0089236209,
-0.0236699656,
0.0299141873,
-0.0097129997,
-0.0091480026,
-0.0562209077,
0.0225277245,
-0.0397280194,
0.0481206253,
0.0173556935,
0.0337061584,
0.0089600515,
-0.0154169733,
0.0239261575,
-0.0100804605,
-0.005337487,
0.0325310342,
-0.0440537669,
-0.0168009698,
-0.0701122582,
-0.0242930278,
-0.0547482036,
0.0324733518,
0.0556730106,
-0.0297935326,
-0.0363509282,
-0.0273990519,
0.0473359115,
-0.0343757756,
0.0494669639,
-0.0131340586,
-0.032662794,
0.0030811555,
-0.0099068247,
0.0038577993,
0.045267161,
-0.0520269983,
0.0368909314,
0.0972668082,
-0.0032945052,
-0.0331445746,
0.0041618519,
0.008781394,
-0.0122525012,
-0.0261064507,
-0.0364281535,
-0.0514472164,
0.0635133982,
-0.013866174,
-0.010668057,
-0.0477996729,
-0.01157251,
-0.0268946514,
-0.0564042367,
-0.0252598543,
-0.0051009501,
-0.0326307677,
0.0176278986,
-0.0144130001,
-0.0494574234,
0.0379996188,
-0.0495092347,
-0.0221711472,
-0.0082726572,
-0.0332165472,
-0.0301200468,
0.0713201836,
0.0304003153,
0.0189090148,
-0.004401932,
0.0112306699,
-0.0439603962,
0.023878254,
-0.00710211,
-0.0255333744,
0.0168521497,
-0.090576455,
0.020861024,
-0.0229576826,
-0.0425600149,
-0.0034439047,
0.0065279328,
-0.0265364219,
0.0311472695,
0.0163729358,
-0.029922843,
-0.0179163236,
0.0185034294,
0.0283490121,
0.0461702347,
0.0228778217,
0.035046339,
-0.0158942044,
0.0151151558,
0.0511247627,
0.0078990301,
0.0103084799,
-0.0450766943,
0.0114984522,
0.0604760982,
0.0598791093,
0.0066577648,
-0.0363159329,
-0.0129095772,
0.0509230383,
0.0007739288,
-0.0218510721,
0.0280403364,
0.0516383015,
-0.0743044615,
-0.0164281614,
0.0663747564,
0.0206725933,
-0.0372779854,
0.0081473915,
0.0067271357,
0.0879635289,
0.0136557156,
0.041040048,
-0.0647247359,
-0.0292529222,
0.0318704732,
0.0070258128,
0.0237432197,
0.0010842667,
-0.0182018541,
-0.1102231219,
0.0261986759,
0.004410109,
-0.0325512365,
0.0147472313,
-0.0549648851,
0.0019631099,
-0.0221537855,
0.0186396427,
0.0243548602,
-0.0243632514,
0.0119203208,
0.0232274346,
-0.0118534965,
-0.0477848276,
0.0335115865,
-0.0008909689,
0.0410562456,
0.0238299593,
0.0007558394,
0.0130109685,
-0.0406568013,
0.0192862265,
-0.0150158601,
-0.0184495319,
-0.0255877059,
0.0479703806,
0.0382395387,
-0.0125280125,
0.0227597766,
0.014185586,
-0.0229502618,
-0.0220078379,
-0.0139329294,
0.0784297884,
0.0098751513,
-0.0231556073,
-0.0029599622,
-0.0323920324,
-0.0211718194,
0.0617155209,
0.0593730733,
-0.0084824543,
-0.0416224375,
-0.0047371802,
-0.0532643907,
-0.0285269674,
-0.0246851686,
0.0312058832,
-0.0326402895,
-0.0237433538,
-0.0050784405,
0.0131057585,
0.0633860752,
0.0297361221,
-0.0136800297,
0.0045381193,
-0.0108942948,
0.0176805984,
-0.0435440242,
-0.0020358181,
-0.0499905124,
0.0198375825,
-0.0560330376,
-0.0091153048,
0.0007481501,
0.0157269761,
-0.0318557434,
0.0287230592,
-0.1432540715,
-0.0844170824,
0.0156441461,
0.0748265386,
0.0312385,
0.0361754857,
0.0164307207,
-0.0797582194,
0.0558967069,
0.0131091317,
-0.0415344983,
0.078828074,
0.0216023605,
-0.0613440424,
0.0085444963,
0.0582301803,
-0.0238092709,
0.021490695,
0.0130203934,
0.0344650336,
-0.0076827658,
0.0081812805,
-0.0241155773,
0.0469510183,
0.0131050656,
-0.0175751243,
-0.022492921,
-0.010325416,
0.0558362603,
-0.002897206,
0.0117219975,
-0.0442556925,
0.0192628168,
-0.0061037461,
0.0183956753,
-0.0076872814,
0.0018072792,
0.0518228821,
-0.0036181579,
-0.0205998886,
0.0231461022,
0.0401275866,
-0.0273471586,
0.0827001855,
0.0055204951,
-0.0014373992,
0.0149699887,
-0.0200126693,
0.0211953484,
-0.0512381569,
-0.0194920748,
0.0029743651,
0.0290509481,
-0.0617935769,
0.0248617399,
-0.0104049891,
-0.0790063068,
-0.0346702039,
0.0229441877,
0.0452416651,
0.0274026915,
0.063799791,
-0.0182772484,
-0.0186476354,
-0.0253749825,
0.0177004989,
-0.0093287369,
-0.0078474777,
0.0299973711,
0.0122184716,
0.0005445828,
0.0010051951,
0.0960545838,
0.0477582999,
0.0678991005,
0.0037364683,
0.0140419956,
-0.0297421198,
-0.0513374284,
-0.0062813866,
0.0157851223,
-0.0069529125,
-0.036182493,
-0.0280780382,
-0.0672467649,
-0.0008098893,
-0.0111589059,
-0.0170337819,
-0.0262885299,
0.045223657,
0.0353366211,
0.0056287469,
0.0043787253,
-0.0062409672,
-0.0358080417,
0.0084441081,
-0.0486945063,
0.0402097553,
-7.225654307e-33,
-0.0201264974,
0.013972247,
0.0374645367,
-0.0029058859,
-0.0261528827,
0.0089257834,
-0.0467150062,
-0.0332663208,
-0.0024238506,
-0.0015272569,
-0.0360425115,
0.0071881311,
0.0256274492,
0.0120928567,
-0.0056715575,
0.0213414468,
0.069299534,
-0.0074005029,
-0.0125273569,
0.046182137,
0.021956088,
0.0446686931,
0.0678035542,
0.0102871219,
-0.0458816737,
0.0195635837,
0.0004830605,
-0.0026980443,
-0.0526459441,
0.037526086,
-0.0433084629,
0.0467674732,
0.0037343397,
-0.0388793014,
-0.0189743284,
-0.0199809205,
-0.0709840506,
-0.0158664342,
0.0381200761,
0.0085058883,
-0.0331870466,
-0.0271981061,
0.0373743102,
0.0231810436,
0.0040613459,
-0.0052892766,
-0.0008644463,
-0.011500949,
-0.0574950725,
0.0071180272,
-0.0442679226,
0.0255892742,
0.0216017235,
-0.0137550579,
0.0576098859,
-0.0302041937,
-0.022127144,
0.0136956749,
-0.0469776541,
0.0043371194,
0.0579885431,
0.0995697454,
0.0763192624,
0.0411877483,
0.0017244803,
0.054122135,
0.0200425461,
-0.0220639966,
0.008467732,
0.0006979713,
0.0588508658,
0.0411622226,
0.0228488538,
0.0221759919,
0.0590886921,
-0.0142630767,
-0.0963240415,
-0.0337211415,
0.029725099,
0.0446382761,
0.0081618661,
0.0426563658,
0.0189510267,
-0.0467260964,
-0.0237573814,
-0.0240551364,
-0.0444832481,
-0.0150122521,
0.0245441049,
0.0235572029,
-0.0729138106,
-0.0025114471,
0.0468179248,
-0.03814983,
-0.0214655753,
0.0238464195,
-0.0098028509,
0.0228469111,
0.0086359642,
0.0420239493,
-0.0773688108,
-0.0370538905,
0.0014136116,
-0.0288435854,
0.0257145781,
-0.0190720763,
0.0127984686,
0.0454447083,
-0.0625625849,
0.0107168527,
-0.0680973455,
0.0262657087,
0.0359999761,
0.0532095768,
0.0300984588,
0.0066280421,
0.0124064647,
0.0100890556,
0.0459374748,
-0.0510555655,
-0.0364886113,
0.0050028609,
0.020090105,
0.0125073465,
-0.0395435281,
-0.003529049,
-0.0505397022,
0.0072925761,
0.0499957316,
-0.0544149093,
-0.025523372,
0.0263241064,
2.984e-7,
0.0172965508,
0.0142900897,
-0.0203293003,
-0.009182347,
-0.0017481177,
-0.0160728525,
-0.0155823445,
-0.0068297251,
-0.0129602375,
-0.0240920354,
-0.0148816612,
0.0341606252,
0.0602895804,
0.0361515768,
-0.0731269643,
0.0275793765,
-0.0604616404,
-0.0320823453,
-0.0487171896,
-0.0685299933,
-0.0352726988,
0.1142566428,
0.0359703861,
-0.0531109273,
-0.0119522512,
-0.0149193918,
0.0123670138,
0.0108378297,
0.0071047279,
0.0091818701,
0.0060972981,
-0.0326176137,
-0.0225644354,
-0.0026623474,
0.0054382691,
-0.01557332,
-0.0338769108,
0.0828208253,
-0.0069829337,
0.0076570855,
0.0442852154,
0.0084927306,
-0.0459830239,
-0.0298186783,
0.0651273057,
0.0056206561,
0.0108077219,
-0.0125252493,
0.0213181637,
-0.0342395119,
-0.0091096126,
-0.0124287801,
0.0273457952,
0.0492435209,
0.0033385095,
-0.0386308879,
-0.0357489064,
-0.0677566901,
-0.0376943573,
-0.0386500284,
-0.0713721365,
-0.062881127,
-0.0553116649,
-0.0171614066,
-0.0135384854,
-0.0628613755,
0.0025458082,
3.164042099e-34,
0.0231134258,
-0.0094430912,
-0.0010136188,
0.0605679192,
0.0142364576,
-0.0359382518,
-0.0213050898,
0.0229310133,
-0.0395346172,
-0.0866973177,
-0.0294808019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09760v1 | Grounding Language Model with Chunking-Free In-Context Retrieval | 2024-02-15T07:22:04 | 2024-02-15T07:22:04 | Hongjin Qian, Zheng Liu, Kelong Mao, Yujia Zhou, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | This paper presents a novel Chunking-Free In-Context (CFIC) retrieval
approach, specifically tailored for Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems. Traditional RAG systems often struggle with grounding responses using
precise evidence text due to the challenges of processing lengthy documents and
filtering out irrelevant content. Commonly employed solutions, such as document
chunking and adapting language models to handle longer contexts, have their
limitations. These methods either disrupt the semantic coherence of the text or
fail to effectively address the issues of noise and inaccuracy in evidence
retrieval.
CFIC addresses these challenges by circumventing the conventional chunking
process. It utilizes the encoded hidden states of documents for in-context
retrieval, employing auto-aggressive decoding to accurately identify the
specific evidence text required for user queries, eliminating the need for
chunking. CFIC is further enhanced by incorporating two decoding strategies,
namely Constrained Sentence Prefix Decoding and Skip Decoding. These strategies
not only improve the efficiency of the retrieval process but also ensure that
the fidelity of the generated grounding text evidence is maintained. Our
evaluations of CFIC on a range of open QA datasets demonstrate its superiority
in retrieving relevant and accurate evidence, offering a significant
improvement over traditional methods. By doing away with the need for document
chunking, CFIC presents a more streamlined, effective, and efficient retrieval
solution, making it a valuable advancement in the field of RAG systems. | [
0.0384031013,
0.0210441593,
-0.0012230257,
0.0095412806,
-0.033829771,
-0.0148928752,
-0.0116451336,
0.0246131178,
-0.0334927514,
-0.0554013886,
0.0074623311,
-0.0189200975,
-0.0189916547,
0.0443422981,
-0.0023340653,
-0.000195697,
0.0533789136,
0.0104949307,
0.00046979,
0.030452555,
0.0318919495,
0.0121704973,
0.029150676,
0.0378191173,
-0.015233458,
-0.0109296031,
-0.0282322168,
0.0242116991,
-0.0184387118,
-0.0278735347,
-0.0044606603,
0.0127788829,
0.0251232404,
0.0326541029,
0.0000019569,
-0.048320327,
-0.0765517503,
0.0201833341,
-0.0164724253,
-0.0089502828,
0.0503193028,
0.0119370865,
-0.0173348449,
0.0383647531,
-0.0429038964,
0.005704477,
0.0390104093,
0.0426679514,
0.0453352593,
0.0655706674,
-0.0186465438,
-0.0306508653,
0.0382656269,
-0.0108087994,
0.0270192493,
-0.0120438384,
0.0013183529,
-0.0140242875,
0.047184065,
0.0331657454,
0.0071648336,
0.0412472039,
0.0089482572,
-0.026676314,
-0.0150259975,
0.010084901,
-0.0420311391,
-0.000739149,
0.0104813157,
0.0436445884,
0.0441481769,
-0.0497234911,
0.025933167,
0.0030447226,
0.004597812,
0.0320260487,
-0.0588131286,
0.0610365234,
-0.0292496961,
0.0315623246,
0.0297490694,
0.0308213122,
-0.0053774277,
-0.0019741668,
-0.0300089028,
0.0673443004,
0.0075928676,
-0.0487539172,
-0.0232677795,
-0.0020674374,
0.0195632204,
-0.0138778025,
0.0265101343,
0.0188719239,
-0.0058783609,
0.0291534681,
-0.0422127917,
-0.0521825291,
0.0440928042,
-0.0246275626,
-0.0344006196,
0.0353780203,
-0.0267833788,
0.0391047224,
-0.0374550782,
0.003724715,
0.0076589412,
-0.0466474071,
-0.0528521463,
-0.018422354,
-0.0242509861,
-0.0428968407,
-0.056145981,
0.0362027623,
-0.0888997838,
-0.0392782912,
0.0100266812,
0.0236697141,
0.0071460502,
-0.010113515,
-0.0039695576,
0.0289134979,
-0.0560260266,
0.0123293372,
0.021977501,
0.0113691129,
-0.0167543907,
0.0120375846,
0.0451790281,
-0.0634987354,
-0.013346388,
0.048900526,
0.0450646468,
0.0261147507,
-0.0229294989,
-0.0083234552,
0.0039134985,
-0.038441021,
-0.0373436101,
-0.0798751414,
-0.005945859,
-0.0031111503,
-0.0142026758,
-0.0618165359,
0.0219030939,
0.0190017913,
-0.0212871432,
-0.0061888839,
0.0106796306,
0.0762056112,
-0.0283948127,
0.0380149297,
-0.0479361191,
-0.0151815228,
0.0434562899,
0.0290843472,
0.0654602125,
0.0776324496,
0.0167623386,
0.0583034791,
0.0699446797,
0.0358526111,
0.0036865305,
0.0059749074,
0.0424993597,
0.0173456706,
-0.040463645,
0.0359536111,
0.0221794788,
-0.0238841493,
0.0137937311,
0.0611278228,
-0.0446299687,
0.0044454602,
-0.0017263589,
0.0341580994,
0.013215078,
-0.0274035539,
0.0216646846,
0.047954917,
-0.008611111,
0.0113999527,
0.0208125841,
-0.0223850124,
-0.0354414396,
0.0290579908,
0.0497340038,
0.002837511,
-0.022454448,
-0.0292672478,
-0.0213785991,
-0.015805969,
0.007143429,
-0.0050540785,
0.0175267309,
0.0331417173,
-0.0646129549,
0.0078622438,
0.0189798474,
-0.0667545497,
0.0192051064,
-0.0437747389,
0.0439650156,
0.0299268104,
0.1005902365,
-0.0233523976,
0.0163133051,
-0.0000571215,
0.011480405,
0.0325129852,
-0.0169123393,
-0.0145019554,
-0.0364715382,
-0.0647349656,
-0.0322176516,
0.0085281488,
0.0035785006,
0.005316901,
0.0007331893,
0.0218412448,
0.0695968792,
-0.020564789,
0.0028108186,
0.0253899805,
-0.0180265587,
-0.0365639143,
0.0135705359,
-0.0144097395,
0.028781442,
0.0278481971,
-0.0138140721,
0.0403345563,
0.0433759466,
-0.0118874181,
-0.0043073315,
-0.0102745974,
-0.0273886453,
-0.0466467552,
-0.0295802727,
-0.0067500961,
0.0471126512,
-0.0005344521,
0.0129320519,
-0.0675361082,
-0.038684573,
-0.0554526821,
0.0541684851,
-0.0751826018,
0.0047816457,
0.0191278029,
0.0142667731,
-0.0725965574,
0.0638959929,
0.0187424943,
-0.0045407815,
0.0162501615,
-0.0049314313,
0.0298988782,
-0.0503851362,
-0.0081658754,
0.0356506258,
-0.0248648915,
0.0003586235,
0.0624347553,
-0.0030069794,
-0.0261333678,
-0.0037278996,
-0.0937431231,
0.0098781884,
-0.0274472628,
0.0171399135,
0.0068322304,
0.0359746292,
-0.0363536254,
-0.0342286713,
-0.0443029106,
-0.0233928021,
0.0410711505,
0.0310560521,
-0.0035328476,
0.0412824564,
0.009377203,
-0.0371704884,
-0.0272415187,
0.0058033601,
0.0457874909,
0.0040132017,
-0.007171934,
-0.0716060475,
0.0624165088,
-0.0082867248,
0.0066610877,
-0.0210523196,
-0.0013888227,
0.0105681401,
-0.0467920154,
0.0482246391,
0.0342405215,
0.0416966565,
0.0319854617,
0.0279510785,
-0.0132435681,
-0.0641337484,
0.0051898989,
-0.0420464501,
0.0253060125,
0.0399040617,
-0.0047052414,
0.0749246329,
-0.02084109,
0.0413028039,
0.0067884526,
-0.0307033211,
-0.0144331641,
-0.0126096234,
-0.0281125996,
-0.0597041324,
-0.0391990505,
-0.0106703471,
0.0538402572,
-0.0073570549,
-0.0528190434,
0.055093769,
-0.0395968668,
0.0149132032,
-0.075288333,
0.0037319665,
-0.0383838825,
0.0478264317,
-0.0109408591,
0.0177307539,
-0.0088487417,
-0.0506789908,
0.0181276929,
-0.0113318628,
0.0022196376,
-0.0663881153,
-0.0186965335,
-0.0009148017,
0.0227503404,
-0.0177585669,
-0.0232508276,
-0.0430086143,
-0.0508219339,
0.0270392131,
-0.01664358,
0.0111542409,
-0.0004654433,
-0.0243718047,
0.0336638913,
0.0354480259,
0.0548185371,
-0.0473327264,
0.0040647658,
-0.0193890799,
0.0442041196,
0.0604074858,
-0.0328874961,
0.0215895176,
-0.0054183099,
0.0063453056,
0.0708767027,
0.0563974902,
-0.0188156348,
0.0326556526,
-0.0365841165,
0.030994799,
-0.0339557491,
-0.0200336631,
0.031857837,
0.0148801068,
-0.0588485859,
-0.0435204692,
0.0792738423,
0.0701389238,
-0.0371346883,
-0.0232544094,
-0.0432655066,
0.014042397,
0.0013195239,
0.0531427413,
-0.0811919793,
-0.0334580541,
0.0317716189,
0.0681816787,
-0.002693,
-0.0068620066,
-0.0125582702,
-0.1108401492,
0.071191363,
0.0017714363,
0.0033511964,
-0.0342387632,
-0.0546248406,
-0.0089772716,
0.0483244546,
-0.0166643709,
0.0543585494,
-0.0211277604,
0.0061827926,
-0.0008059605,
0.0022416469,
-0.054410167,
-0.0449423157,
-0.0249331985,
0.019069152,
0.0802458152,
0.0073894928,
0.0349526927,
-0.0505750142,
0.0046584136,
-0.0616152696,
0.0057165013,
-0.0278320555,
0.0169429798,
-0.0234186947,
0.0196797475,
-0.0343903191,
0.0124310786,
-0.00190928,
-0.0209979471,
0.0035061729,
0.0393331982,
-0.047356233,
0.0374735706,
-0.0676990226,
-0.0099577634,
0.0463532545,
0.0792814642,
0.0136443675,
-0.0035074961,
-0.0329882801,
-0.0282313563,
0.0389549881,
-0.0150891254,
0.0092026014,
-0.0007509355,
-0.0067957416,
-0.0230197757,
-0.0951529592,
-0.0506526716,
0.0055628065,
0.0402377136,
-0.0249405354,
0.0375358462,
0.020146938,
-0.0130780395,
-0.069182381,
0.0013862664,
-0.0353971943,
-0.0024907312,
-0.0630061179,
0.0208237581,
0.0298603047,
-0.0664430112,
-0.0020694535,
0.0136440052,
0.0121985609,
-0.0277471077,
0.0162909217,
-0.01258511,
0.0235016663,
0.0309890117,
-0.0263415128,
-0.0484547578,
0.049787838,
0.0579289459,
-0.0600949787,
-0.013035479,
0.0074219615,
-0.0034673887,
-0.0225492641,
0.0157320406,
-0.0735592991,
0.0228973981,
-0.0419670604,
0.0428789631,
-0.005291488,
0.0335941017,
0.0392010994,
0.0104697123,
0.0126940897,
0.010836876,
0.0176364258,
-0.0303101745,
0.0096755121,
-0.0693436563,
-0.021650508,
-0.0244393088,
0.0579628274,
-0.0129631385,
-0.0331863835,
0.022483943,
0.0445235334,
-0.0452373698,
0.0644636005,
-0.0140959797,
0.0245859697,
-0.0178340822,
0.0351624005,
0.0060229478,
-0.0239988733,
-0.0203640983,
-0.0168524906,
-0.0128466692,
0.0413344614,
-0.0512602776,
0.0483207926,
0.0275391284,
-0.017436685,
0.0015867108,
0.0545791499,
-0.0887413621,
0.0551733151,
-0.0297977924,
-0.0166816264,
0.0004560607,
-0.0025396917,
0.0300576203,
-0.0201060884,
-0.0037131191,
-0.0141750704,
0.0128306337,
0.0436663106,
-0.0357334651,
0.0084052533,
0.0350375101,
-0.0412496515,
0.0347247869,
0.0513052717,
0.0110847047,
0.0066132615,
-0.0371260606,
-0.0511057824,
-0.0380763747,
-0.0201574918,
0.0121228015,
0.0734444335,
-0.0361380093,
-0.0173853319,
-0.029928783,
-0.0100700548,
-0.0240400545,
0.0169857461,
-0.0082006259,
0.0078467587,
0.0375079848,
0.0831539482,
0.0126897069,
-0.026680937,
-0.0458019041,
0.0365267806,
-0.0409431309,
-0.0272417888,
0.0038410015,
-6.388734655e-33,
-0.0241782609,
-0.0260073636,
0.0176278893,
-0.0235944577,
-0.0014578679,
0.0184624419,
-0.0438585803,
-0.0400256254,
0.0084019005,
-0.0127628846,
-0.0372417755,
0.0206332915,
0.0289364066,
0.0455685593,
-0.0386900753,
0.021483805,
0.0414755791,
0.0021223708,
-0.0264466088,
0.0559694953,
0.0875476897,
0.0268920809,
-0.0041356762,
-0.055078499,
0.025031073,
-0.0376852006,
0.0016967303,
-0.0026537969,
0.0195562709,
0.0628946498,
-0.0146824121,
0.0258276407,
0.0155781526,
-0.0221358147,
-0.0060532466,
0.0676359087,
-0.0927444175,
-0.0111151626,
0.0027773771,
-0.0261566136,
-0.0132737653,
-0.0229807906,
0.02092967,
-0.0264599919,
-0.0060577202,
0.0589569956,
0.0064027165,
-0.0231737532,
-0.0134695508,
-0.092707932,
-0.0586731657,
0.0499271229,
0.0331522152,
0.0128300386,
-0.0145039074,
0.0666615143,
0.0135181583,
0.0479919836,
-0.0685307533,
0.0330170281,
-0.0105920322,
0.0436485112,
0.0319080539,
0.0056606187,
-0.0126434937,
0.0401840806,
-0.0335927792,
-0.018849954,
-0.0330812596,
-0.0152865732,
0.0261336528,
0.0039885035,
0.0094616432,
0.0330161303,
0.0739840642,
-0.0386273116,
-0.067339167,
0.0475115888,
0.0048978049,
0.0331519209,
0.0342888795,
-0.0033533592,
-0.0886339843,
-0.0214511137,
-0.0076872711,
0.0057700947,
-0.0299113952,
-0.0172436908,
0.0597123243,
0.0455420502,
-0.0554588065,
0.0020745094,
0.0540217645,
-0.0199228302,
0.0297507197,
0.0505272821,
-0.0244085696,
0.0026541415,
-0.0307262372,
0.0282891002,
-0.0186118484,
-0.0112368651,
0.0559408814,
-0.0237645358,
-0.0483206809,
0.0066075833,
0.0073214122,
0.017668115,
-0.0756363943,
0.0251306631,
0.0151258949,
0.0297815166,
-0.0263289064,
-0.0317987762,
0.0436118543,
0.028257098,
0.0202283021,
0.0580317564,
0.0234692004,
0.0204590186,
-0.0359845161,
-0.1002817228,
-0.0070549995,
0.0196428224,
-0.0032921841,
0.0338734575,
-0.0086272256,
0.0473201871,
0.0390306562,
-0.0251168031,
0.019890992,
0.0622902587,
2.697e-7,
0.0165990256,
0.0358287916,
0.0627955422,
-0.0290085301,
-0.0067905802,
-0.0009513934,
0.0547976568,
0.026780948,
0.0134926718,
-0.00461108,
-0.038374342,
-0.0155706899,
0.0343264379,
0.0125176096,
-0.1083538756,
0.0057226806,
-0.0597429834,
-0.049522236,
-0.0657190681,
-0.0152364327,
0.0707637593,
0.0809531882,
-0.0247313157,
0.0071131503,
-0.0100571699,
-0.0271812174,
0.0285358839,
0.0353693813,
-0.0125195542,
0.0098958705,
0.0300199147,
-0.0009115478,
0.0082776779,
-0.0447134562,
-0.0114084072,
0.0690032989,
-0.0097495439,
0.016780341,
0.0218574889,
-0.0463493317,
0.0062490432,
-0.0311478227,
0.0056518256,
-0.0377121307,
0.0841176063,
0.0153196231,
-0.0031839153,
-0.0127253141,
-0.0463651642,
-0.0159100015,
-0.0191250611,
-0.0046409741,
-0.0326905772,
0.0117643205,
0.0008657561,
9.108e-7,
-0.0063052475,
-0.0822485685,
-0.001356273,
-0.0340493806,
-0.0384891443,
-0.0115657318,
-0.0254463535,
0.0097935637,
0.0119010927,
-0.0765978023,
0.0245422274,
3.044806793e-34,
0.0359697454,
0.0040505286,
-0.0244087558,
0.0101933815,
0.0345372856,
0.0053246119,
-0.0088293003,
0.0310469251,
0.0255803149,
-0.1089029759,
-0.0403607972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09759v1 | Efficient Language Adaptive Pre-training: Extending State-of-the-Art Large Language Models for Polish | 2024-02-15T07:17:10 | 2024-02-15T07:17:10 | Szymon Ruciński | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study explores the potential of fine-tuning foundational English Large
Language Models (LLMs) for generating Polish text. The first step involves
Language Adaptive Pre-training (LAPT) on a high-quality dataset of 3.11 GB,
consisting of 276 million Polish tokens. The LAPT is followed by additional
fine-tuning aimed at solving nine KLEJ challenges. Our trained model
Curie-7B-v1 not only generates Polish text with the lowest perplexity of 3.02
among decoder-based Polish models but also closely rivals the performance of
the best Polish encoder-decoder models with a less than 2% gap on 8 out of 9
tasks. Curie-7B-v1 used approximately 2-3% of a typical dataset size to learn
Polish. The LAPT was completed in less than five days using a consumer GPU,
highlighting the method's efficiency. The proficiency of the model in Polish
was significantly enhanced, demonstrating the viability of this approach for
adding new languages to existing LLMs by training just 1.2% of its parameters.
To contribute to the community's collaborative progress, the model has been
released as open-source. | [
0.0035448233,
0.0701622143,
0.0165618099,
0.0171412621,
-0.0156726614,
0.047419481,
-0.012764819,
-0.007468536,
-0.0372740142,
-0.0235479791,
-0.0046001198,
0.0175670423,
-0.0137619358,
0.0262250565,
0.0299207903,
-0.0361526944,
0.0432996787,
-0.045196116,
-0.0121591361,
-0.0237722993,
0.0119872112,
0.0168342069,
-0.0070915371,
0.0364995487,
0.0045926739,
0.0077663362,
-0.015896406,
0.0251357388,
-0.027669875,
-0.0253978185,
-0.0052170274,
0.0508793704,
0.0366861336,
0.062866874,
0.0000023209,
-0.0483850837,
-0.0228787735,
-0.036161039,
-0.0052729235,
0.0131164296,
0.0535819009,
-0.0794404671,
-0.013903372,
0.0142791048,
-0.0201942623,
-0.0603161305,
0.0642936528,
0.0252012927,
0.0462357253,
0.0626905486,
-0.0074000228,
-0.0610066392,
0.0221382901,
-0.0282258429,
-0.0378814787,
-0.0375836082,
0.0264812447,
-0.0294472519,
-0.0524991043,
-0.0227126945,
-0.0296470989,
0.0192811284,
0.0284350496,
-0.0146347508,
-0.0063961744,
0.0156961121,
0.0249265879,
-0.0447605588,
-0.0371017419,
0.0337397829,
-0.0735345036,
-0.0500031449,
-0.0286857821,
-0.0179638844,
-0.0125808883,
-0.0319684818,
-0.0433386751,
0.0454217605,
0.0244063251,
0.0321229286,
0.0592699423,
0.0143235009,
0.0304704383,
0.0072953696,
-0.0255750995,
0.0755176619,
0.0613956116,
-0.0255686454,
0.0550158471,
0.0075145117,
0.0187506881,
-0.0135816317,
0.029495338,
0.0299993195,
-0.0486242436,
0.0119417161,
-0.0613829046,
-0.0258082524,
0.0226045884,
-0.0389195532,
0.0299958475,
0.0593370795,
0.0101896608,
0.0406502783,
-0.0546512194,
0.0616325252,
-0.0022834509,
0.0019764511,
-0.0534991287,
-0.0349642187,
-0.0225405544,
-0.0009911357,
-0.0657773912,
0.0030318259,
-0.0858908296,
-0.0147714149,
-0.0188501291,
0.0046576555,
0.0550982915,
-0.0024687382,
0.0308652315,
0.0014602599,
-0.048517134,
0.0005931457,
0.0190368723,
0.0732667521,
-0.0386072956,
0.0137009472,
-0.0342313722,
-0.0503959656,
0.0168542303,
0.0041649351,
0.0141837196,
-0.0536019839,
0.0537486039,
0.0328971259,
-0.0140977604,
-0.0227804352,
-0.0078289276,
0.0074882023,
-0.016965026,
-0.0486343838,
-0.0030026657,
-0.0623979084,
0.0587651953,
0.0205193758,
0.0198827516,
-0.0519107804,
-0.0035303836,
0.0078758812,
-0.0357943289,
0.0313004702,
-0.0744720548,
0.0234907027,
0.021766834,
-0.034471184,
0.0448680595,
0.0639546514,
0.0190333314,
0.0197037198,
0.0278981421,
-0.0380900018,
-0.0094107399,
0.0711370856,
0.0229227524,
0.0268234964,
0.0008934128,
0.0141521832,
-0.0170830674,
0.0018478525,
0.0886570215,
0.0485159121,
-0.016691111,
0.0060769944,
0.0286314618,
0.0251510423,
0.0403811522,
0.0794001594,
0.0560582019,
-0.0061725732,
0.0119144125,
-0.0377570279,
0.0066938438,
-0.0152172269,
-0.0458529294,
0.0412805751,
0.0086336192,
0.0536106266,
-0.0268881656,
0.0092965299,
0.0265063383,
-0.0344818272,
0.0494792834,
-0.0134620806,
0.0621169582,
0.0054152147,
-0.0697321221,
0.0279812105,
0.0757077858,
-0.0602206104,
0.030897731,
-0.0407367311,
0.0084137227,
0.0679609552,
0.0322035216,
0.0028708109,
-0.0116088521,
-0.0090888124,
-0.008814048,
0.0342319161,
0.023002537,
-0.0143219465,
0.0210603271,
-0.0563954227,
-0.0046092444,
-0.0121220248,
-0.0026960217,
0.0447140597,
-0.0108462749,
0.0323892273,
0.0042099939,
-0.0128998822,
-0.045297198,
0.0353357233,
-0.0303369518,
-0.0281091239,
0.0056852927,
-0.0106524928,
0.0131451227,
0.0392658263,
0.0048566163,
0.0032730612,
0.0652457103,
-0.0550632402,
0.0249932632,
0.0458927639,
-0.0654649809,
-0.0608258657,
0.0568429157,
-0.0044871308,
0.0183773804,
0.0075307894,
-0.0266329013,
-0.0313476138,
0.0338459015,
-0.0323980413,
0.0276699457,
-0.0601515174,
0.0299561452,
-0.0124296695,
0.0201284885,
-0.0196145829,
0.0428232029,
0.0099561643,
0.0157054849,
0.0065641198,
0.0222352967,
0.0154276304,
-0.0425184146,
-0.0118501736,
0.0466435812,
-0.0110508874,
-0.0062800148,
0.0158862025,
0.0479351208,
-0.0207781754,
0.0157340579,
-0.0869640335,
0.009440287,
-0.0258375499,
0.0082500754,
0.0210006703,
0.0110933995,
0.0040114205,
-0.0334263742,
-0.0176264402,
-0.0431642979,
0.0376447141,
0.0089054257,
-0.010939518,
0.0123581765,
0.0182984788,
-0.0184560586,
-0.0166967381,
0.0422629267,
0.0315537788,
0.0048003215,
-0.0127700726,
-0.0660428777,
0.0712208748,
-0.0191727653,
0.0291076489,
0.0134950262,
-0.0625293851,
-0.0144279115,
-0.0178744532,
0.0816350132,
-0.006141766,
-0.0130142644,
-0.0017074242,
-0.003362864,
-0.0140528912,
-0.0318060331,
-0.0109963091,
-0.032551419,
-0.0131221525,
-0.0425222144,
-0.0270745922,
0.0015219128,
0.0585933328,
-0.0388510078,
0.009820383,
-0.0882184282,
0.0038249195,
-0.0332356654,
-0.03798059,
-0.0550633185,
-0.0100997994,
0.0172742698,
0.0146380998,
-0.0144439396,
0.0017195136,
0.0279464368,
-0.0610748306,
-0.0244881473,
-0.049191691,
-0.0184258185,
-0.0329332091,
0.0531530194,
0.0296495538,
0.0279856697,
-0.0557196662,
-0.0296975132,
-0.0048210593,
0.0117697874,
-0.0107275965,
-0.006780772,
0.0035464661,
-0.0246157907,
-0.0009319304,
-0.0257576481,
-0.0510868914,
-0.0119702732,
-0.0513534732,
-0.0274698604,
-0.0067879781,
0.0231362581,
0.0028763299,
0.0171348248,
0.0279373582,
0.012767842,
0.0452049747,
-0.0101433983,
0.0210794471,
-0.0291556511,
0.0150281889,
0.0299458243,
0.011402322,
0.0072471406,
-0.0756298304,
-0.0119919972,
0.0047075525,
0.0547420681,
-0.0331936702,
-0.0365390144,
0.0264706835,
0.024993619,
-0.0123120677,
0.0024685932,
-0.0131491739,
-0.0053371596,
-0.0473473929,
-0.0268501043,
0.1111898869,
0.0171640795,
-0.045941174,
0.0013704672,
-0.0193905402,
0.0146974642,
0.0053782682,
0.0316259786,
-0.062855497,
-0.032293573,
0.0169997215,
0.013477223,
0.0030982897,
-0.0216827244,
0.0032414442,
-0.1412766129,
-0.0110406205,
0.0458532497,
-0.0581169836,
-0.0686788335,
-0.0298189819,
-0.0589034259,
-0.0098365601,
0.0257307868,
0.0455115661,
-0.0155255012,
0.0172300693,
0.0351247154,
0.0050329277,
-0.0588051751,
-0.0306439269,
-0.04194225,
0.0291824788,
0.0685564652,
0.0073324046,
-0.0255865324,
0.0047033695,
0.0240345877,
-0.017810693,
0.0029927834,
-0.055616226,
-0.0017623166,
0.0372119062,
-0.0166230556,
-0.0103963418,
0.0209422372,
-0.0301254839,
-0.0180420373,
0.0224485788,
0.0520290248,
0.0067897169,
-0.0200143438,
0.0705048889,
-0.0351451188,
0.0203477126,
0.0543680191,
0.0308658741,
-0.0226018745,
-0.0365558304,
-0.0302181114,
0.0113346456,
-0.0809044167,
-0.0106949192,
0.040835835,
0.0060389042,
-0.0109139485,
-0.0545400865,
-0.0158177055,
0.0498758927,
0.0418904461,
0.00725511,
0.0142440256,
-0.0310020521,
-0.0051931804,
-0.0455927365,
0.0377332121,
-0.0270140599,
-0.0270136055,
-0.1003635153,
-0.0197561644,
0.0060030436,
-0.0467092395,
-0.0015775613,
-0.0106610553,
-0.0245421752,
-0.0364808813,
0.0230877902,
0.0362425037,
0.0207930151,
0.0443752557,
0.0111951688,
-0.0782666653,
0.0178937241,
0.0218637101,
-0.0603212863,
0.0223198459,
0.0221355911,
-0.0125166504,
-0.0004695622,
0.0371094681,
-0.0267674364,
0.0010892597,
0.0044270349,
0.0325171724,
0.0414273962,
-0.0668929666,
0.0086348886,
0.0527250059,
-0.0047255973,
-0.0603769645,
-0.033294268,
-0.0404811688,
0.0113853682,
-0.0257827658,
0.0043212087,
-0.0246741809,
-0.0014991343,
0.0241714641,
-0.0003416484,
-0.0089424234,
0.0179583915,
0.0151723158,
0.0082896557,
-0.0868953913,
0.0104221832,
-0.0263869874,
0.0319317244,
0.0742409304,
0.0111097815,
-0.0302733704,
0.0260122344,
0.0151626859,
0.0101024034,
-0.050096985,
-0.000753174,
-0.0002228615,
-0.0151659176,
-0.0347146913,
0.0245997049,
0.0300599542,
-0.0124132643,
-0.0306501891,
0.010930907,
0.1083542332,
0.0114995409,
0.0804958642,
-0.0203937553,
-0.0148637854,
-0.0349177308,
0.0215375051,
-0.011030064,
-0.0249677133,
0.0126472684,
-0.0054541011,
-0.0319524556,
0.0144805107,
0.0327430479,
0.0293825716,
0.0417752415,
0.0169454664,
0.0423504002,
-0.0435753912,
-0.0004282932,
-0.0360590667,
-0.0155377127,
-0.0495953299,
0.0098994505,
-0.0102225961,
-0.0564077608,
-0.0126659013,
0.0049039451,
-0.0415449627,
0.0160689317,
0.0359391868,
0.0036839643,
-0.035439007,
0.0117446249,
-0.0156866442,
0.0666848123,
0.0121822571,
-0.0298457909,
0.0023827057,
-6.552671301e-33,
-0.0224420968,
-0.0032139495,
0.037715666,
-0.0302718058,
-0.0225712229,
-0.03256635,
-0.0238148551,
-0.0339290686,
0.0139608337,
-0.0202577114,
-0.0225445684,
-0.0496016443,
0.0271247122,
0.041272372,
0.0038451469,
0.0274486765,
0.0599760897,
-0.0104476148,
0.0156244282,
0.0541368984,
0.0217696279,
0.0495756157,
0.0505821928,
-0.0247990489,
-0.0654924065,
-0.0265933797,
-0.0222535525,
0.0071009444,
0.0159930345,
0.0458238982,
-0.0134824421,
0.0328802504,
0.0001531317,
-0.0265749265,
-0.0236131568,
0.003990123,
-0.0641643405,
-0.0141351717,
0.0034018997,
0.0573224612,
-0.0045900303,
-0.064418301,
0.0347348079,
0.0114125339,
-0.0355888903,
0.0576875843,
-0.0020647692,
-0.0404831059,
0.0003868005,
-0.0070319669,
-0.0706454366,
0.0167912748,
-0.0074932221,
0.016825363,
0.0509428829,
0.0321252458,
-0.0065441215,
0.0118320975,
-0.0553845651,
0.0363944061,
0.0715555921,
0.0337622501,
0.0432854816,
0.0084086489,
0.0193589833,
0.0020426591,
0.0588984266,
-0.0579721592,
0.0519413203,
0.0679072738,
0.0507152006,
0.0064838496,
0.0446277894,
0.0699142739,
0.0250569656,
-0.0193392653,
-0.0946564674,
0.0008306568,
0.0453561135,
0.0091826348,
0.0319165811,
-0.0000472575,
0.0082324389,
-0.0296851993,
-0.023774622,
0.0124969278,
-0.0192710515,
-0.0282212701,
0.0565798022,
0.0081546605,
0.0089814849,
0.0052684378,
0.0529690385,
-0.009742327,
-0.0234673601,
-0.001259535,
-0.033951655,
0.0194133576,
-0.0502842665,
0.076195471,
-0.0640628785,
-0.080259949,
0.025599258,
-0.0274929665,
0.0110151973,
-0.0029721477,
-0.0148677407,
0.0319755226,
-0.0596587919,
0.0387595519,
-0.0145456921,
0.0451733023,
0.0512020402,
0.0610961169,
0.0226573125,
-0.0116425445,
-0.0000890753,
0.0498807132,
0.0358020402,
-0.0396207087,
-0.0298320521,
-0.0833923668,
0.0791490749,
0.0396346822,
-0.0123651735,
0.0405767635,
-0.0102138529,
-0.0095710224,
0.007685761,
-0.0066195312,
-0.0100395428,
0.0099424012,
2.98e-7,
0.0465685651,
0.0679066181,
0.0128927194,
-0.0206293799,
0.0139485607,
-0.0037139752,
-0.0456320345,
-0.0064937505,
0.0124003813,
0.081786707,
0.0126196239,
0.002340989,
0.051459603,
0.0102928644,
-0.0816981643,
0.0107100373,
-0.0614240728,
0.0354172625,
-0.0481945574,
0.0027001156,
-0.0146348085,
0.1095839292,
-0.0089323623,
-0.0407195725,
-0.0026944021,
-0.0514086448,
0.0672794878,
0.0128510389,
-0.0344523303,
0.006592643,
-0.0306771938,
0.0402809046,
-0.0324646533,
0.0167798698,
-0.0076327324,
0.0373175927,
-0.0100806262,
0.0566785559,
-0.0369214974,
-0.0318806581,
0.0657064319,
-0.0021120328,
-0.0286474265,
-0.0578941815,
0.0639472082,
-0.0282259546,
0.0009281933,
0.0392348208,
-0.022611443,
0.0184373073,
-0.0142716067,
-0.0730170459,
-0.0150677534,
0.0145648429,
0.0476171225,
-0.0069742426,
-0.0354699641,
-0.0257150009,
-0.0081654787,
-0.0237657111,
-0.0282215532,
-0.0423972793,
-0.0617331043,
-0.0083064884,
-0.0088033741,
-0.0428331718,
0.0282575339,
2.93024316e-34,
0.0157854948,
0.0118194707,
0.0173120927,
0.0062408242,
0.0008983891,
-0.0436010398,
-0.0077306796,
0.0437251814,
-0.0168425161,
-0.0722854584,
-0.0355697684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09748v1 | Model Compression and Efficient Inference for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-15T06:58:30 | 2024-02-15T06:58:30 | Wenxiao Wang, Wei Chen, Yicong Luo, Yongliu Long, Zhengkai Lin, Liye Zhang, Binbin Lin, Deng Cai, Xiaofei He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF | Transformer based large language models have achieved tremendous success.
However, the significant memory and computational costs incurred during the
inference process make it challenging to deploy large models on
resource-constrained devices. In this paper, we investigate compression and
efficient inference methods for large language models from an algorithmic
perspective. Regarding taxonomy, similar to smaller models, compression and
acceleration algorithms for large language models can still be categorized into
quantization, pruning, distillation, compact architecture design, dynamic
networks. However, Large language models have two prominent characteristics
compared to smaller models: (1) Most of compression algorithms require
finetuning or even retraining the model after compression. The most notable
aspect of large models is the very high cost associated with model finetuning
or training. Therefore, many algorithms for large models, such as quantization
and pruning, start to explore tuning-free algorithms. (2) Large models
emphasize versatility and generalization rather than performance on a single
task. Hence, many algorithms, such as knowledge distillation, focus on how to
preserving their versatility and generalization after compression. Since these
two characteristics were not very pronounced in early large models, we further
distinguish large language models into medium models and ``real'' large models.
Additionally, we also provide an introduction to some mature frameworks for
efficient inference of large models, which can support basic compression or
acceleration algorithms, greatly facilitating model deployment for users. | [
0.0068907687,
0.069349736,
-0.0233715381,
0.0344570912,
-0.0432826281,
0.0103183426,
-0.0000162957,
0.0259803031,
-0.053834822,
0.0027508538,
0.0016202941,
-0.0259437952,
0.0179934502,
-0.003920191,
0.0237211138,
-0.039262671,
0.0270571038,
-0.0473515466,
-0.0153372064,
-0.0175314788,
-0.0220604185,
-0.0049616448,
0.0597591214,
0.0358472504,
0.028371051,
0.0028368803,
-0.0324013755,
0.0005959128,
-0.0183123201,
0.0297282599,
-0.0364874713,
0.0454318784,
0.0364562385,
0.0379291587,
0.0000019858,
-0.0031254818,
-0.0100376066,
0.0080462173,
-0.0550684221,
0.0273511559,
0.0567668937,
-0.0227968991,
-0.0024414062,
0.0061196475,
-0.0024877747,
-0.0682890341,
0.0928789601,
0.0151682375,
0.0366133749,
0.0492860191,
0.0065203104,
-0.0762069747,
0.0061867838,
-0.0425544977,
-0.0632700175,
-0.0262478441,
0.0231815651,
0.0230124835,
-0.0070799799,
0.0069610458,
-0.0429245979,
0.023382185,
0.0438436568,
0.0359793939,
-0.0266072266,
0.0228067208,
-0.032779526,
-0.0475323685,
0.0173940174,
0.0235459898,
-0.0555270985,
-0.0563018508,
0.0104297241,
0.0151492953,
-0.0099367881,
-0.0010288587,
-0.0636590198,
0.0513258949,
0.0120725734,
0.0276102051,
0.0114941029,
-0.0190132745,
0.0547941588,
0.000898438,
-0.0626284108,
0.0299456455,
0.0329496227,
0.0211763587,
-0.0490024686,
-0.0252783932,
-0.0416500196,
-0.080978848,
-0.0107633034,
0.0384316035,
0.0259389933,
0.0004587811,
-0.0568861365,
-0.0235318355,
-0.0141910221,
-0.0414112546,
0.0418782681,
0.0384620912,
0.032847546,
0.0171597712,
-0.0344758704,
0.0467703491,
-0.0471604131,
-0.0156808347,
-0.0609138422,
-0.0175800901,
-0.016984567,
-0.0074524535,
-0.0621041246,
0.0535127111,
-0.0056045856,
-0.0244362373,
-0.0577873178,
0.001988135,
0.0132023646,
-0.0067561795,
0.0277370438,
-0.0056678951,
-0.026648296,
-0.0160808247,
0.0300268643,
0.0614025705,
-0.0289361253,
0.0028793151,
-0.0096591208,
-0.0684062093,
-0.0111286687,
0.0217326432,
0.0057586697,
-0.0366344303,
0.0191204492,
0.0403713584,
0.0230801627,
-0.0398536846,
-0.0232198332,
0.0002824137,
-0.003944268,
-0.0744449943,
0.0118642123,
-0.0854064897,
0.0245884992,
-0.0080763949,
0.0230107941,
-0.0409190245,
0.0024086579,
-0.0025325646,
-0.0626837164,
0.0183407497,
0.0059439144,
0.0222499352,
0.007611475,
0.0028852338,
0.0343293659,
0.0895141065,
0.0398932956,
0.0368193649,
0.0106815509,
-0.0292456578,
-0.0250909198,
0.05659578,
0.0437366217,
0.0041767471,
-0.0611704402,
-0.0266332813,
0.0030783128,
-0.0104240244,
0.0302025806,
0.0918139219,
-0.0601758808,
-0.0238747932,
0.0368828587,
0.0261177551,
0.052735392,
0.0565199219,
0.0541004501,
-0.0021919482,
0.0080525009,
0.0158281811,
-0.0359975211,
0.0053318581,
-0.0071435985,
0.0168438684,
0.0127349626,
0.0733170807,
-0.0445733666,
-0.0304554775,
-0.0203528218,
-0.0275855847,
0.0251726024,
0.0122098783,
0.0796722695,
0.0250030942,
0.0080073029,
0.1053724065,
0.053138759,
-0.0363290049,
-0.0323570296,
-0.0932610929,
-0.0056396858,
0.0125369607,
0.0252481513,
0.0042903004,
0.0086808326,
0.0237722583,
-0.0101895109,
-0.0303711481,
0.0152340252,
-0.0120376488,
0.008081615,
-0.0453177765,
0.0019629684,
0.0194989499,
0.0294674244,
0.0040244884,
0.046796035,
0.0214346461,
0.0253905822,
-0.0458392538,
-0.0159809291,
0.0079300273,
-0.0207425058,
-0.0089863678,
0.0171716902,
0.0093014725,
0.023883922,
-0.0224380251,
-0.0355897322,
-0.008310087,
0.0345342942,
-0.0521889813,
0.0074899914,
-0.0142180603,
-0.0198167376,
-0.0312358309,
0.0343316495,
0.0023778148,
0.0498633161,
0.0452723168,
-0.0455435179,
-0.0296332333,
0.0365785584,
-0.0298236497,
0.0665158555,
-0.0385616384,
0.0320050605,
-0.0355546996,
0.0283724237,
0.0071566734,
0.0558712929,
-0.025419103,
0.0130764665,
0.0267779157,
-0.026898779,
-0.0104895541,
-0.0240995735,
-0.0596129112,
0.0379375368,
-0.0210339576,
-0.00180651,
0.0129241608,
-0.0425068922,
0.0356560834,
-0.0233524013,
-0.0773474649,
0.0055127922,
-0.0367371067,
0.0302713364,
0.0201851595,
0.0618227385,
0.025557125,
-0.003375032,
0.0117049105,
0.0140918279,
-0.0000488774,
0.039701961,
-0.0251173191,
-0.0039400924,
-0.0434937365,
-0.0109305587,
-0.0790871829,
0.0185490921,
0.1070004106,
-0.0528221354,
-0.0300416686,
-0.0495440736,
0.0164972097,
-0.0261432417,
0.0413693935,
-0.0195349809,
-0.0448879488,
-0.0146514047,
-0.0266790651,
0.0393191837,
0.0747930333,
-0.0023662539,
0.0260269884,
0.0628562942,
-0.004258893,
-0.0157080349,
0.0035532659,
-0.0397697166,
-0.0372805819,
-0.0348334834,
-0.0523154512,
-0.0393356606,
0.1031044647,
-0.0256546512,
-0.0318402238,
-0.0576558374,
-0.0320627876,
-0.024118809,
-0.0141459946,
-0.0132981287,
-0.0064258454,
-0.0012054294,
0.0232461113,
-0.0139060905,
-0.045357056,
0.0408263952,
-0.0422508121,
0.0155936824,
0.0158295594,
-0.0348674878,
-0.018260289,
0.0811031088,
0.0433990881,
0.0542828217,
0.0130352434,
0.0200382378,
-0.0468679629,
0.0078187026,
0.0213277638,
-0.0320341848,
0.0300734639,
-0.0373813286,
0.0256705657,
-0.0172350444,
-0.023534881,
0.0056666858,
-0.0100781163,
-0.0281684436,
0.0373317823,
0.0289745703,
-0.0253768414,
-0.0262589585,
0.069133237,
-0.0061131502,
0.0496463999,
0.0040991064,
0.0239293743,
0.0020797285,
0.0362318866,
0.0498755053,
0.0044150129,
0.0267024841,
-0.0467737131,
0.0127863949,
0.0322007239,
0.0184275862,
0.0294255,
-0.06847471,
-0.023365194,
0.0251574405,
-0.0072800028,
-0.0288496893,
0.0275214445,
0.0370723233,
-0.0569068156,
-0.0066826609,
0.0990839154,
-0.0044601732,
-0.0013736968,
0.0263704807,
0.0275525711,
0.041303046,
0.0016210999,
0.031856928,
-0.0828878954,
-0.0143937012,
0.0310667939,
-0.0185394976,
0.0036804266,
-0.0086882105,
-0.0091937706,
-0.08638338,
0.0318497606,
0.0231819842,
0.0125633581,
-0.0232908037,
-0.0281646606,
-0.0022673986,
-0.0250186231,
-0.0092332847,
0.0145026902,
-0.0157377943,
-0.005835,
-0.0070962962,
-0.0299857091,
-0.0510894209,
0.0045921574,
-0.0073615946,
0.0398612544,
0.0338967107,
0.0122559061,
-0.0046817567,
-0.008190508,
0.0206153058,
0.0132775409,
0.0019303039,
-0.0171505138,
0.0260261707,
0.0331956856,
-0.0171673857,
0.0147599345,
0.0153366681,
0.0030531078,
-0.0156040331,
-0.0281454083,
0.0664167851,
-0.009782861,
-0.0607605353,
0.0188828036,
-0.0398363024,
-0.0310803205,
0.0664682686,
0.0332474709,
-0.0110865245,
-0.0470619686,
-0.003408608,
-0.057698749,
0.0164099317,
-0.0411564969,
0.012126619,
0.0057722917,
-0.0725766569,
-0.0244429298,
0.0412736684,
0.0065024421,
0.025096966,
-0.0088374373,
-0.0134246536,
0.065980278,
0.0105249546,
-0.0792089552,
-0.0119176507,
-0.0336525477,
0.0088314721,
-0.0266176239,
0.0163897444,
0.0261064284,
-0.0078441314,
-0.0284429099,
0.0039085788,
-0.1437927037,
-0.0660802126,
0.0120313736,
0.0387730002,
0.030870609,
0.048274003,
-0.0089651858,
-0.051593937,
0.0295468681,
0.0286396779,
-0.0243199393,
0.0583053641,
0.0284083914,
-0.0606956631,
0.0079886792,
0.06670589,
-0.0172474105,
0.0514859818,
0.0067135864,
0.0190486163,
-0.0390790999,
-0.0296495501,
0.0010541609,
0.0100711426,
0.0024307505,
0.0114105865,
-0.0210370757,
0.002107834,
0.0366580598,
-0.0038922152,
-0.0106581012,
-0.0580589138,
0.0253710579,
0.0250605512,
0.0469713919,
0.0128955301,
-0.010960157,
0.0740380436,
-0.0179717224,
-0.028589597,
0.0022889047,
-0.0198268984,
-0.004814575,
0.0698631555,
-0.0005508884,
-0.0028469511,
-0.0154919187,
0.0023311493,
0.0375359617,
-0.0496182889,
0.0150548685,
0.0233552363,
0.0185039155,
-0.0704576075,
0.0168068986,
-0.0459356643,
-0.0665277243,
-0.0311008636,
0.0479039364,
0.0370439701,
0.0069945571,
0.0233840533,
-0.0320048779,
-0.0179505274,
-0.0248737987,
0.0265918206,
0.0059789624,
-0.0144250523,
0.018240802,
0.0138751818,
-0.0239488687,
0.0045804824,
0.0764672682,
0.0205749013,
0.0407425798,
-0.0088385828,
-0.0157079194,
-0.0325804465,
-0.0530545041,
-0.0572801158,
0.0021130571,
-0.0028285997,
0.001594687,
-0.0290333852,
-0.0748033896,
-0.0273125786,
0.0078647006,
0.0053496719,
-0.0288461279,
0.022296017,
0.0517521687,
0.0211709831,
-0.020281842,
-0.0215710662,
-0.0002747966,
-0.0083525153,
0.0000603752,
0.0151845925,
-6.361489635e-33,
-0.0061861873,
0.0408776291,
0.0141571285,
-0.0476894788,
-0.0414033122,
0.0134216277,
-0.0270950738,
-0.0260244496,
-0.0509153046,
0.001926097,
-0.0016441138,
0.0238771234,
0.0094924131,
0.0229409318,
-0.0210402962,
0.0141524421,
0.0843281597,
0.0092361281,
-0.012113763,
0.0462488309,
0.0147194834,
0.0090929801,
0.0360688344,
-0.008511859,
-0.0478098467,
-0.0029253357,
0.0165210646,
0.009294373,
-0.0065830573,
0.0380722284,
-0.0187942758,
0.0044190725,
0.0082420064,
-0.0480899438,
-0.0128368773,
0.0187904555,
-0.0827118754,
0.0054612644,
0.0288342573,
0.009491696,
-0.0081114499,
-0.0375047252,
0.0628313869,
0.0299808607,
0.0067294161,
-0.0338496231,
-0.0127882129,
-0.0301531851,
-0.0264759716,
-0.0353324711,
-0.0377674773,
0.0246757809,
0.0180371758,
-0.0062547303,
0.0475250892,
0.0082692942,
-0.0496704876,
0.013418776,
-0.0234302301,
-0.0000585378,
0.0542445853,
0.0929781646,
0.0654901788,
0.0246811565,
0.0242844876,
0.026205482,
-0.0004743464,
-0.0167873539,
-0.0357323401,
0.0380515493,
0.0480208285,
0.0628093109,
0.0225459263,
0.018539317,
0.0661947578,
-0.0077590775,
-0.0714748874,
-0.0289623346,
0.0077755242,
0.0596390516,
0.0529380366,
0.0151083805,
0.0002603203,
-0.0395925976,
-0.0505600907,
-0.0105742309,
-0.0262289103,
-0.0152852172,
-0.0052325721,
0.0274372008,
-0.0590472259,
-0.0000920941,
0.0409826264,
-0.1001659781,
-0.0206780154,
0.0208919048,
-0.0112191541,
0.023756912,
0.0075795772,
0.0437030606,
-0.0263680629,
-0.0392668061,
-0.0027055107,
-0.0034073635,
0.008129173,
-0.012257563,
0.0129318079,
0.0610460527,
-0.0505606867,
-0.0194638483,
-0.0313103758,
-0.0224581733,
0.0049611321,
0.0530241169,
0.0569504462,
0.0464340225,
0.0048791412,
0.0049880962,
0.0165691022,
0.005637167,
-0.0145999892,
0.0147798257,
0.0439641215,
0.0311277602,
-0.0247328728,
-0.0044432599,
-0.0718709007,
0.0373948738,
0.05134115,
-0.06161483,
-0.0501473546,
0.0600982755,
2.733e-7,
0.0204899851,
0.0043906001,
0.0224426743,
-0.0067139664,
0.0220800061,
0.0012988034,
0.0268384516,
-0.000758282,
0.0165490825,
-0.014466566,
0.0236253869,
0.050106477,
0.0358531401,
0.0065174974,
-0.0748992413,
0.0252945386,
-0.0706049353,
-0.0221825987,
-0.02148531,
-0.0294120759,
-0.0067907823,
0.1472703964,
0.0143826995,
-0.0078255953,
0.0201053787,
-0.0094527844,
0.0233298782,
-0.0022502071,
0.0304976664,
0.0141598657,
-0.0051342673,
0.0174229592,
-0.027248973,
-0.0023168528,
0.0133446502,
0.0169918649,
-0.0280841421,
0.0776028484,
-0.0219988432,
0.0575604104,
0.0094555998,
-0.0409070402,
-0.0488516204,
-0.0576381162,
0.0762631446,
-0.0607903637,
-0.0224554222,
-0.0674203485,
0.0040225568,
-0.0105649326,
-0.0315870307,
0.0026387835,
0.0389851071,
0.0312532373,
0.0243032128,
-0.00966758,
0.0004765224,
-0.0706281215,
-0.0185192712,
0.0201427881,
-0.0549115688,
-0.0685428679,
-0.0386795811,
-0.0426719598,
0.0330466628,
-0.0342175402,
0.015277924,
2.639243794e-34,
0.0280721933,
0.0020946038,
-0.0036652179,
0.0255175568,
-0.0036038118,
-0.0501795672,
-0.0271972977,
0.0082799476,
-0.0319909863,
-0.107793875,
-0.0460607521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09742v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09742v4 | AI Hospital: Benchmarking Large Language Models in a Multi-agent Medical Interaction Simulator | 2024-02-15T06:46:48 | 2024-06-28T03:11:48 | Zhihao Fan, Jialong Tang, Wei Chen, Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Jun Xi, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence has significantly advanced healthcare, particularly
through large language models (LLMs) that excel in medical question answering
benchmarks. However, their real-world clinical application remains limited due
to the complexities of doctor-patient interactions. To address this, we
introduce \textbf{AI Hospital}, a multi-agent framework simulating dynamic
medical interactions between \emph{Doctor} as player and NPCs including
\emph{Patient}, \emph{Examiner}, \emph{Chief Physician}. This setup allows for
realistic assessments of LLMs in clinical scenarios. We develop the Multi-View
Medical Evaluation (MVME) benchmark, utilizing high-quality Chinese medical
records and NPCs to evaluate LLMs' performance in symptom collection,
examination recommendations, and diagnoses. Additionally, a dispute resolution
collaborative mechanism is proposed to enhance diagnostic accuracy through
iterative discussions. Despite improvements, current LLMs exhibit significant
performance gaps in multi-turn interactions compared to one-step approaches.
Our findings highlight the need for further research to bridge these gaps and
improve LLMs' clinical diagnostic capabilities. Our data, code, and
experimental results are all open-sourced at
\url{https://github.com/LibertFan/AI_Hospital}. | [
0.0567110553,
0.0336262211,
-0.0136455866,
0.0116875572,
-0.0285256486,
-0.0049778931,
-0.0043215682,
0.0423085093,
0.0284153037,
0.0081323441,
-0.0184793063,
-0.0765247568,
0.007059921,
0.0199028198,
-0.0077965334,
-0.0324135385,
0.0244450271,
0.0029559368,
0.0655903742,
-0.0050083357,
-0.01526062,
-0.0021676505,
-0.0529184937,
0.0581019856,
-0.0202349853,
-0.0117826052,
-0.0026730392,
-0.0244137142,
0.0341261998,
-0.0841036439,
-0.023853112,
0.0258847699,
-0.0236357655,
0.005108749,
0.0000021239,
-0.0369742773,
0.0078717703,
0.0263912585,
-0.0333021507,
-0.0301928557,
0.0580570251,
-0.0235919077,
-0.0109400628,
0.0211734697,
-0.0563247837,
-0.0515486076,
0.0044157938,
0.0443135984,
0.0674623325,
0.0773550943,
-0.0077570509,
0.0170135926,
-0.0066089085,
-0.020012239,
-0.0153704267,
-0.0910205022,
0.0375362858,
0.0261658244,
0.0812402368,
-0.0597101301,
-0.0101440977,
0.0331788771,
0.0173572004,
-0.0128728868,
-0.0465647765,
0.073915571,
-0.017327819,
0.0129561126,
-0.0059234751,
0.0651231259,
0.014728073,
0.0145775806,
0.0240803193,
0.0153571581,
0.0183978938,
-0.0009780971,
-0.0225750804,
0.0007688347,
-0.0357397683,
-0.0070076985,
0.0232152157,
0.003660298,
0.0438835733,
0.0138643011,
-0.0034522538,
0.0047252169,
0.0008532164,
-0.0418826342,
0.0045481315,
-0.01142014,
0.0109760128,
-0.0458717607,
0.0354259312,
0.0564016886,
-0.1284747869,
0.0160080735,
0.0058255587,
0.0148959355,
0.0493393876,
-0.0815934166,
0.0216431171,
0.0013049989,
0.0337488279,
0.0643636659,
0.0335173085,
0.0089543685,
-0.0250638835,
0.038680438,
-0.0428663045,
-0.0203787815,
-0.0455022193,
-0.0132799093,
-0.0301218349,
0.0363349468,
0.0250076931,
-0.0200553853,
-0.0523045696,
-0.0039976859,
-0.0264909063,
0.0258826725,
0.0474512205,
0.0468253568,
0.0014792689,
0.0309574008,
-0.0400899686,
0.0227431525,
-0.0400356725,
-0.0059910547,
-0.0098746931,
-0.0520756841,
-0.0014298339,
-0.0054172305,
-0.0113470117,
0.0090624401,
0.0203947071,
0.0561804399,
-0.0010158764,
0.0027828398,
0.0486495048,
-0.041780781,
-0.0320971832,
-0.0528945066,
-0.0148648908,
-0.070695214,
0.0587285906,
-0.0017734068,
0.0128941676,
-0.0587441847,
0.0307852346,
0.0058830762,
-0.0382966436,
0.0622785911,
-0.0195757281,
0.0295183286,
0.0094320895,
0.0575502627,
-0.0283547323,
0.0185899194,
0.0355200395,
-0.0521312542,
0.0068160812,
-0.0181962084,
0.0493265353,
0.0168561954,
0.0195892826,
-0.016127862,
0.0382157378,
0.013503449,
0.010654903,
0.1098609492,
-0.0750363022,
0.0789598897,
-0.0298571233,
-0.0415378585,
0.0221333131,
0.0600222349,
0.0012287274,
-0.0022850314,
0.0145074688,
-0.0382999144,
0.0062687118,
-0.0199453235,
-0.0016594279,
0.0203677267,
0.0051969383,
-0.0368761756,
-0.0237247702,
0.0003559857,
-0.0211492795,
-0.0548826233,
-0.0298090912,
-0.0146392519,
-0.0278099161,
-0.0065830373,
0.0130082592,
-0.0220577884,
-0.0204754267,
0.0361407027,
0.0344772041,
-0.0296545327,
-0.0327643268,
-0.0636250824,
0.0083307642,
0.1171634942,
0.0845243186,
-0.0419130623,
-0.046333883,
-0.0005000802,
-0.0165698435,
0.0157341398,
0.0609855242,
-0.0304519534,
0.0213732254,
-0.0296210833,
0.0019457205,
0.0409625024,
-0.0007050006,
0.0008248492,
-0.01476386,
0.0207487736,
-0.0291626938,
-0.0144628389,
-0.0433151536,
0.0204107817,
-0.0699647292,
0.0085687442,
-0.0175961982,
-0.0036512555,
0.0594350807,
0.0365798548,
-0.0338910744,
0.02745975,
0.031677451,
-0.0210822709,
-0.0367410332,
0.0369641818,
-0.033820238,
-0.0310275201,
0.0314053893,
-0.0269983523,
-0.0204553753,
-0.0119895041,
-0.0192307755,
-0.0381498113,
-0.0249018651,
-0.0439499803,
0.0077613685,
0.0057081836,
0.0340314433,
0.0283509567,
0.0061533167,
-0.0170693994,
0.0155625558,
-0.0271785147,
0.0088786976,
0.0319364369,
0.0104000093,
-0.0176488552,
-0.027783623,
-0.0237254687,
0.0255086701,
0.0153851705,
0.0254339371,
-0.005235191,
-0.0003941258,
-0.0236874633,
-0.0423748493,
-0.1476505846,
-0.0275222529,
0.0069978647,
-0.0224263035,
0.0118599366,
0.0213242956,
-0.0056069898,
-0.0101959044,
-0.0550980978,
0.0068232543,
0.0513231307,
0.0071458113,
0.0239079986,
0.0594090447,
-0.0263931416,
-0.035418421,
0.0100912368,
-0.0590745136,
0.0187650807,
0.0195037164,
0.0066201086,
-0.0038655023,
-0.0323474556,
-0.0500075966,
0.0126941185,
-0.0048817801,
-0.037869826,
0.0346948169,
-0.0458300784,
-0.0252237953,
0.0430595204,
-0.0113771427,
0.0441788323,
0.0430072211,
-0.0265725255,
-0.0595742501,
0.0383395627,
0.000418578,
0.0011565121,
-0.0259954538,
-0.0596506372,
0.0006533237,
0.0872063115,
0.0084369779,
0.0109307449,
-0.0257435571,
0.0100044683,
-0.0114580002,
-0.0159642398,
-0.0027191848,
-0.0013446843,
-0.0238006953,
0.0292326212,
0.0004200925,
0.008111096,
0.1126423478,
-0.0290552787,
0.0270036682,
-0.0774082467,
-0.0094555449,
-0.0460671969,
0.0362454765,
-0.0155246863,
0.0232227426,
-0.0207390226,
0.0026782509,
0.0072959494,
0.0065955766,
-0.0056150067,
-0.0692715272,
0.0320306942,
-0.0395000465,
0.0268615037,
-0.0002973003,
-0.0488399155,
-0.0206740052,
-0.0249498542,
-0.0308266301,
0.0147612095,
-0.0054023759,
0.0168968476,
-0.0495120101,
0.0481309891,
-0.019510271,
0.0570168644,
0.0345969573,
-0.0192648005,
0.0002686546,
0.0028268825,
0.0107011842,
0.0389776044,
-0.0012066646,
-0.0163249094,
0.0619861037,
0.0831284747,
0.0231889021,
0.0186270978,
0.0026236235,
-0.025510801,
-0.0176499523,
-0.0207912829,
0.0018063148,
0.018808756,
-0.0154952314,
-0.0705216676,
-0.0193854161,
0.1160733625,
0.045799613,
-0.0592127554,
0.0225279834,
-0.0283004064,
-0.0207419377,
-0.0140774129,
0.0177683197,
-0.0673226938,
-0.0118140429,
-0.0147786168,
0.0154062342,
-0.0152096469,
-0.059112139,
0.0362367667,
-0.0687326193,
0.0156189529,
-0.0272244364,
-0.0164546389,
-0.0104228482,
-0.0296298098,
0.0056517189,
-0.0092112357,
-0.0026713305,
-0.0073171826,
0.0431518666,
-0.0239960663,
-0.0230924319,
-0.0335912704,
-0.0366959237,
0.059029907,
-0.0508626327,
0.076309517,
0.0616183393,
0.0665364414,
-0.0049896589,
-0.0020839733,
-0.0161829311,
0.0449172407,
0.0235654619,
-0.011924848,
0.0637842342,
0.0099353911,
0.0063916836,
-0.0332365781,
-0.0109188817,
-0.0336599015,
-0.0015291744,
0.0360983908,
0.0778914765,
-0.0503846779,
-0.0352981314,
-0.0351249464,
0.0516864955,
0.0348120444,
0.0490469187,
-0.0004736934,
-0.0114932796,
-0.0478815213,
0.0171179399,
0.0342460759,
-0.0033008619,
-0.0263009816,
0.0126173189,
0.0028413327,
-0.0050896853,
-0.061628297,
-0.065221563,
0.0315634049,
0.0055221766,
-0.0024021785,
-0.0033194069,
0.0310404636,
0.0157005005,
-0.0162742771,
-0.0002137092,
0.0216764864,
0.0323173366,
-0.0555395633,
-0.0224720631,
0.0725935027,
0.0075974017,
0.0113395741,
0.009108223,
0.007434621,
0.0016405944,
0.0154589685,
0.0614600144,
0.0146264145,
0.0009302293,
-0.0417229384,
0.0154260406,
-0.00174817,
-0.0182330143,
-0.0508408137,
0.000898886,
-0.0029595655,
-0.0152902948,
-0.0093778148,
0.0239588022,
-0.0204416774,
0.0290399846,
0.0009150534,
0.0580991879,
-0.0423310697,
-0.060966108,
0.0228517465,
0.0287682712,
0.0038054686,
0.0254938006,
-0.0131806536,
-0.0001896205,
0.0409961641,
-0.0744843259,
0.003495777,
-0.0043465928,
-0.0177241378,
0.0180610083,
-0.0189414099,
0.0269575566,
0.0342535004,
-0.0486743376,
-0.0435636118,
-0.0237129815,
0.0279856343,
0.0326606296,
-0.0236755982,
0.0352586955,
-0.0220995378,
0.0188282374,
0.0083281854,
0.0208935142,
0.028364012,
0.0016345023,
0.0709009767,
-0.0052255536,
-0.0009564729,
-0.001423733,
0.0525475629,
-0.0501019433,
-0.062130224,
0.0162152331,
0.0503514446,
0.0439087339,
0.0325877443,
0.0112207308,
-0.0437562354,
0.0290854741,
-0.0102239829,
-0.0361823998,
-0.0049995985,
-0.0253574587,
0.0605047867,
0.0273218621,
0.0244617909,
0.0036086792,
0.0966283157,
-0.0325705074,
0.0449144766,
0.0101342425,
-0.0432482436,
-0.0537821241,
-0.0396020859,
0.0117325429,
0.0059043244,
-0.074884668,
0.0105333328,
-0.0678329542,
-0.0201457795,
-0.0078168921,
0.0005220995,
-0.0268014502,
-0.04223077,
0.0542924814,
0.0515416861,
0.0366849266,
-0.0035441907,
-0.0311889611,
0.0498549417,
-0.0392072648,
-0.0171706509,
0.0193343349,
-5.907876283e-33,
-0.0153665729,
-0.0469819941,
0.0530176833,
-0.0417283401,
-0.00220937,
0.0249079205,
-0.0490501188,
-0.0010676077,
-0.0334133208,
0.029132206,
-0.0405648574,
0.0343894698,
0.0086551215,
0.0293680206,
0.0081088757,
-0.0459880233,
0.0296853315,
0.0076035252,
-0.0359188318,
0.018216176,
-0.0366131291,
0.0147191314,
-0.0059762821,
-0.082273677,
-0.0129132923,
0.0033395418,
0.0181531888,
0.0150026847,
-0.0601150915,
0.0739078224,
-0.0082393037,
0.0308119394,
0.0524190776,
-0.0184897818,
0.022816278,
0.0077905795,
-0.0681305528,
-0.0036744368,
0.002972008,
-0.0016505875,
-0.0462251417,
-0.0295292698,
0.0138746491,
0.0031865109,
-0.0169451814,
-0.004047967,
0.0126451515,
-0.0406623632,
-0.0043907594,
-0.0174231697,
-0.0273449719,
0.0438151695,
-0.0151335001,
-0.0194700677,
-0.0190253668,
-0.0049243039,
-0.0384013094,
0.0183850303,
-0.0604783818,
-0.0071705831,
0.0109064272,
0.0071342122,
0.0128168762,
-0.0287826844,
-0.0217900183,
0.042629227,
0.0570894368,
0.0118540442,
-0.0555842519,
-0.0208524894,
-0.0593699105,
0.0302982293,
0.0576886423,
0.0422756411,
-0.0172969121,
-0.0109770261,
-0.0618308112,
0.0440135039,
-0.0017700737,
0.0761401802,
0.0399238206,
-0.0173711907,
-0.0710534081,
-0.0134441741,
-0.0309885517,
0.0165085588,
-0.0307360012,
-0.0470751785,
0.0317183919,
0.0054535111,
0.0184286088,
-0.0101115806,
0.0145059815,
-0.0298781563,
0.0068986714,
-0.0012718295,
0.0563438535,
0.0224867035,
-0.0398925915,
0.0108485762,
-0.0403436199,
0.0061030346,
0.014155197,
-0.0071032322,
0.0409550183,
0.04162452,
0.0049529681,
-0.0356489494,
-0.031660758,
-0.0102838827,
0.0299950577,
-0.0124132084,
-0.0068901624,
0.0322714821,
0.0206296183,
0.003470731,
-0.0063057845,
0.0132354777,
0.0199916065,
0.0183057748,
-0.060107328,
-0.0227517895,
-0.0112126004,
-0.0430793725,
-0.0572553575,
0.0013828946,
-0.0733226314,
0.0365759768,
0.0242062137,
-0.0475780852,
-0.0157587323,
-0.0201005768,
2.839e-7,
0.0715308785,
0.0545718893,
0.0252185315,
-0.001600844,
0.0424323827,
0.001698976,
-0.0212146044,
0.0187670104,
0.0021795246,
-0.0226972066,
0.0504340418,
0.021077605,
0.0381748639,
0.0779392347,
-0.0660890266,
-0.0251419097,
-0.1001990288,
-0.0116253411,
-0.0324995369,
-0.0370933823,
0.032432422,
0.0658548027,
-0.0402840562,
-0.0228138156,
0.0066227708,
-0.0207713824,
0.0351864547,
-0.0173556078,
-0.007659093,
0.0720453858,
0.0202525444,
-0.0294814184,
0.0303374194,
0.051251512,
-0.0005948136,
0.0085343085,
0.0075597749,
0.0834127516,
-0.0626443401,
0.0035337002,
0.0215945672,
-0.0381070189,
0.0406470224,
-0.0393748134,
0.0628225431,
-0.0523794964,
-0.0536900386,
-0.0004359591,
-0.0069909017,
-0.0328910723,
0.0647865757,
-0.0172121488,
-0.0362988897,
0.0443513244,
0.0015881007,
0.0311115049,
-0.0011407587,
-0.051357273,
-0.0389038883,
0.0044173244,
-0.0266833398,
-0.0506638214,
0.0569853634,
-0.0588421859,
-0.0112330336,
-0.0724683031,
0.0138440738,
2.263666231e-34,
0.0423808284,
0.0225583836,
0.0097181043,
0.0671908036,
0.0573924892,
-0.0009999628,
-0.014537924,
0.0131185791,
0.0413558632,
-0.0603454746,
-0.0159315672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09739v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09739v2 | QuRating: Selecting High-Quality Data for Training Language Models | 2024-02-15T06:36:07 | 2024-06-13T18:55:23 | Alexander Wettig, Aatmik Gupta, Saumya Malik, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Selecting high-quality pre-training data is important for creating capable
language models, but existing methods rely on simple heuristics. We introduce
QuRating, a method for selecting pre-training data that can capture human
intuitions about data quality. In this paper, we investigate four qualities -
writing style, required expertise, facts & trivia, and educational value - and
find that LLMs are able to discern these qualities, especially when making
pairwise judgments of texts. We train a QuRater model to learn scalar ratings
from pairwise judgments, and use it to annotate a 260B training corpus with
quality ratings for each of the four criteria. In our experiments, we select
30B tokens according to the different quality ratings and train 1.3B-parameter
language models on the selected data. We find that it is important to balance
quality and diversity. When we sample using quality ratings as logits over
documents, our models obtain lower perplexity and stronger in-context learning
performance than baselines. Our best model is based on educational value and
performs similarly to a model trained with uniform sampling for 50% more steps.
Beyond data selection, we use the quality ratings to construct a training
curriculum which improves performance without changing the training dataset. We
extensively analyze the quality ratings and discuss their characteristics,
biases, and wider implications. | [
0.0553444102,
0.0666881651,
0.0173370317,
0.0200519357,
-0.0330272056,
0.020640038,
-0.0042293165,
0.008978202,
-0.0062389816,
-0.1028259397,
-0.043049369,
-0.0490251407,
-0.0101408819,
0.0009874986,
0.025328096,
-0.0369390845,
0.0254678875,
-0.0298540127,
0.0416529253,
0.0045134057,
0.032625895,
0.0449174903,
0.0069726836,
0.02561263,
-0.034423776,
-0.0186214373,
0.036087621,
0.0105509469,
-0.0098865516,
-0.0180855431,
0.0508859418,
0.0865574181,
0.0004841347,
-0.0060077542,
0.0000020921,
-0.0503036231,
-0.0028466545,
-0.0067013307,
-0.029666556,
0.0157872997,
0.0596158057,
0.0153429955,
-0.0242710635,
0.0329419076,
-0.0404245146,
-0.0085063353,
0.0017079402,
0.0327414535,
0.0735793114,
0.0764040574,
-0.0005862613,
-0.0120495846,
0.0236749705,
-0.0104336292,
-0.0123920869,
-0.0131920604,
0.0230937283,
0.0392167829,
-0.0190966539,
0.0460401252,
0.0018745144,
0.0127094798,
-0.0019480453,
-0.0284783803,
0.0355094858,
0.0099547235,
-0.0299530365,
-0.0173784867,
-0.0014012167,
0.0614966117,
-0.0086591905,
-0.0501856059,
0.0066762161,
-0.0062752985,
0.0023104288,
0.0046263137,
-0.0073559708,
0.0186330266,
-0.0156902038,
0.0283875074,
0.0290678293,
-0.0178152584,
0.0343964547,
0.0308084935,
0.0071849823,
0.018167099,
-0.0108803194,
-0.0427229516,
0.0078704199,
0.0133566102,
-0.0130652748,
-0.0400067344,
-0.0062576178,
0.0051927357,
0.0007255385,
0.0241446029,
-0.0416737311,
-0.0134124691,
0.0510726459,
-0.0399522036,
-0.0027454095,
-0.0002535428,
-0.0226826593,
0.0536909476,
-0.0102687525,
-0.0069953473,
0.0587447956,
0.0626995265,
-0.0331635885,
-0.0096893385,
-0.0398279913,
0.0227309968,
-0.0075791315,
0.0519517139,
0.0067740516,
0.0023988888,
-0.0459347963,
-0.0163985416,
-0.0086513711,
0.0093837325,
0.0411199741,
-0.0160857607,
-0.0307473671,
-0.0078625567,
-0.0399575904,
-0.008081723,
-0.0038330741,
0.0340137891,
0.0032197528,
-0.0486789122,
0.0092968578,
0.0229310691,
0.0173944067,
-0.0289299935,
0.0323984772,
0.0283005722,
0.0094415965,
-0.0578188337,
-0.0653106049,
0.0039701052,
-0.0130980043,
-0.0573312268,
-0.0024983927,
-0.0758381933,
0.0069354731,
0.0142594222,
-0.01170561,
-0.0549851507,
-0.0091217421,
0.0325060114,
-0.0157086905,
0.0535096638,
-0.0387151986,
0.001211866,
0.0151639758,
-0.004340413,
-0.0192458704,
0.0616578571,
0.054729864,
0.0061374642,
0.048397135,
0.014186657,
0.0205994565,
0.0197066609,
-0.0014316076,
0.0248770975,
-0.0010333962,
0.0098682502,
-0.0083769346,
0.0329711623,
0.0220634509,
0.0710749552,
-0.02400277,
0.0251700841,
0.0863500535,
0.0299641155,
0.05326619,
0.0027280618,
0.0402268507,
0.0290723778,
0.0240671616,
0.0119311847,
-0.0389164425,
0.0143009312,
0.0220087972,
0.0012102381,
0.0279084295,
0.0046898774,
-0.0104280263,
-0.090766497,
-0.0408507958,
-0.0263799541,
0.0117952786,
-0.0026850405,
0.0272849184,
0.0099401465,
-0.0472704098,
0.0293251351,
0.0311994813,
-0.0821726918,
0.0342264548,
-0.0314944945,
0.0547822118,
0.081210047,
0.0419840477,
0.0070587257,
0.0086247576,
-0.0562638789,
0.0183813442,
0.0021266241,
0.048209697,
-0.0184814744,
0.0237960778,
-0.0825534388,
-0.0292028449,
0.0005520593,
0.036958307,
-0.0150931571,
-0.0118671367,
0.0011136241,
0.0171395075,
-0.0686022341,
-0.0723043829,
0.0744141191,
-0.0372431912,
-0.0274291821,
-0.0047756461,
0.0030579006,
0.0187113844,
0.0072007375,
-0.0080514848,
0.0073098806,
0.0252667554,
-0.0306317192,
0.0410927981,
-0.0105740307,
-0.0446715765,
-0.0301801153,
0.032392785,
-0.0460183695,
-0.0059446814,
0.0319208354,
-0.0375164449,
-0.0355171002,
-0.0452668332,
-0.0515551977,
0.0009085862,
-0.0837112367,
-0.0075384318,
-0.011772627,
-0.0421940722,
-0.0441824943,
0.0533170551,
-0.0131297801,
0.0239556711,
-0.0104677677,
-0.0156640038,
0.0262234453,
-0.0351858251,
-0.036306832,
-0.0020996088,
0.0141725726,
0.0576894246,
0.0332479402,
0.0539081469,
-0.0504490659,
-0.0301019717,
-0.0666289851,
-0.0047843289,
-0.0470213778,
0.0064925062,
0.0034184151,
-0.064076677,
0.0034463762,
0.0140379984,
-0.0597965047,
-0.0565095469,
-0.0094309114,
-0.0058671888,
0.0744326189,
0.0053002047,
0.0156558696,
-0.0401744545,
-0.013864629,
-0.0015676121,
0.0428990349,
0.0276435856,
0.001245467,
-0.0412178524,
0.0536981486,
-0.0215352047,
-0.0228599403,
0.011608826,
-0.0447586998,
0.0086690905,
-0.0086056301,
-0.017300183,
0.0736689866,
0.0307910349,
0.0073563722,
0.0463170782,
0.0364242494,
-0.0588593446,
-0.012153862,
-0.0096644657,
0.0502853766,
-0.0181902256,
-0.0332352519,
0.0316157006,
0.0275104139,
0.0011132768,
-0.0260867514,
-0.0510102026,
0.0456821062,
-0.0165037662,
-0.001719115,
0.0170895103,
-0.0065920618,
-0.008645541,
0.0497624911,
-0.0356450565,
-0.0465154387,
0.0646833405,
-0.0240918137,
0.0240793116,
-0.0465934761,
0.0056086401,
-0.0431515425,
-0.0027715124,
-0.0152280433,
0.024986323,
-0.0180365127,
-0.0149111766,
-0.0478535034,
-0.0230874866,
0.0497644804,
-0.0524488762,
0.0408176444,
-0.0351102948,
0.0180282034,
0.017397413,
-0.0280331392,
-0.0313957632,
-0.0146877058,
-0.0067259828,
0.0116453394,
0.029969329,
0.039754305,
0.0032993376,
-0.0286238361,
-0.0074266908,
0.0571540035,
-0.0201527197,
0.0012946003,
0.0051194937,
0.0095504243,
0.0216321871,
0.0146632828,
0.0288211703,
-0.0617538914,
0.0057863961,
0.0389043503,
-0.006220053,
0.0105928387,
-0.0141132325,
-0.0114453379,
0.0268412717,
-0.0395640768,
-0.0416025184,
0.0042444989,
0.0570987128,
-0.0626985878,
-0.0212829355,
0.1328501999,
0.014941806,
-0.0347168706,
-0.0063498449,
0.0119443964,
0.0005764795,
0.0119501874,
0.0032498878,
-0.0876683742,
-0.037818864,
-0.0043608965,
0.0429234505,
0.0044022896,
-0.0184513852,
-0.001012711,
-0.0985273048,
0.0398715809,
0.0056736064,
0.003761153,
0.0010071718,
-0.053350646,
-0.0245927572,
-0.0517744459,
0.0616267771,
-0.0069566397,
-0.0156562068,
0.0213486273,
0.0501441248,
-0.0105265761,
-0.0957216322,
0.0139775136,
-0.0448287241,
0.0465015806,
0.0296167936,
0.0707735866,
-0.0262247585,
-0.0795297846,
0.0144931767,
-0.0175464507,
-0.0125638526,
-0.0050819297,
0.0645097941,
-0.0415035859,
0.0131776482,
-0.0293787252,
0.020535348,
-0.0033103081,
0.0029067828,
-0.0293681156,
0.010270711,
-0.012926125,
-0.0000054826,
-0.025164023,
0.0033478658,
0.0029157975,
0.1095789671,
0.036338646,
-0.0822965652,
-0.0216567814,
-0.0370382518,
0.0092075653,
-0.0740262941,
-0.0062295338,
0.0433409028,
-0.0202113669,
0.0018764635,
-0.088586919,
-0.0525365211,
0.0287877172,
0.0224978719,
0.0121472366,
0.0396656767,
-0.0093440535,
0.0089932475,
-0.0032981415,
0.0594279617,
-0.0336789824,
-0.0170490555,
-0.1060528979,
-0.0050038639,
0.0244261455,
-0.0440125652,
-0.0211159885,
-0.0210963804,
-0.0469527692,
-0.0489445589,
0.0141122267,
0.0519948937,
0.0209779963,
0.0614090487,
0.0019653004,
-0.063028872,
0.0205267128,
0.044144541,
-0.0398131646,
0.001291832,
0.0574453622,
0.004020046,
-0.0031306599,
0.0343352482,
-0.0507162362,
0.0377746522,
0.0326790698,
0.0149514908,
-0.0343616419,
-0.0029535848,
0.0201179069,
0.0366652235,
0.0297118258,
-0.0211699139,
-0.0116021456,
-0.0651988983,
0.0054192496,
0.0036798355,
-0.0176489092,
-0.0514945425,
0.0318481736,
0.0057210377,
-0.0026933444,
-0.0396637544,
0.0058915829,
-0.0304844752,
0.0629351139,
-0.0403908193,
0.0420731679,
-0.0302118938,
0.0052204477,
0.0053628366,
-0.0201885868,
-0.0488917716,
0.0062969709,
-0.0130873965,
0.0334206112,
0.0059157461,
0.0011343034,
0.0175329261,
0.0132722147,
0.0331471041,
0.0379898921,
-0.0645227209,
-0.009098391,
-0.0525457487,
0.0063955756,
0.0603568256,
-0.0351449251,
0.0696028322,
-0.0254173968,
0.0028545302,
-0.0420930348,
0.05131758,
0.0366652757,
-0.008470756,
0.0110659255,
0.0163244307,
-0.0311682168,
-0.0138267167,
0.0812550858,
0.0074868915,
0.0109941447,
-0.0018091128,
-0.0041401242,
-0.0554216504,
0.0020129622,
0.0106740408,
0.0267493259,
-0.0103352331,
0.0048993784,
-0.0491772257,
-0.0518918782,
0.0015728212,
0.027828943,
-0.013938251,
-0.0341483839,
0.0425421931,
0.0667569116,
-0.0317918919,
0.0407137796,
-0.075940989,
-0.0506759025,
0.0327571146,
-0.0079027042,
-0.0234077051,
-6.610232321e-33,
0.0087471148,
-0.0079916762,
-0.008366718,
0.0064006299,
0.0220380742,
0.0164673366,
-0.0063945404,
-0.0239391755,
-0.0536939614,
0.0185586922,
-0.0128353694,
0.0000221911,
0.001818917,
0.0380912684,
0.0016049086,
-0.0035425406,
0.0566236116,
-0.0138155054,
-0.0525106601,
-0.0078122211,
0.0367822647,
0.0254074968,
0.0758792758,
-0.0634797737,
0.0449488498,
-0.0148208262,
-0.0434654877,
0.0225584935,
0.0077128555,
0.0879491121,
0.0200983286,
0.0403792113,
0.0197109431,
-0.0438271239,
-0.0105649512,
-0.0058004991,
-0.0546222851,
-0.0174951889,
0.0289270096,
-0.0066304533,
-0.0116014909,
-0.0524935834,
0.0459200479,
-0.0132662095,
-0.0417124964,
0.0028986849,
0.0603460446,
-0.031624563,
-0.0398952775,
-0.0402338877,
-0.0154865719,
0.0464885421,
0.002233254,
-0.0244096536,
0.021951044,
0.0200294238,
-0.0316487141,
0.0418804213,
-0.083315827,
0.0295818429,
0.0046477085,
0.0313764364,
0.0305669867,
-0.0043517603,
-0.0204217341,
0.0839318335,
-0.015604536,
0.0354566611,
0.042225413,
-0.029788373,
0.0538990758,
0.04792431,
0.0471143015,
0.0588518493,
0.0418196581,
-0.0422237776,
-0.0723432675,
0.0468035042,
0.0086050602,
0.006575569,
0.0114588588,
-0.014046602,
-0.0537937097,
-0.037344262,
-0.0662686005,
-0.0221681464,
-0.0147632323,
-0.0090526873,
0.0170842372,
0.0218449607,
-0.029853262,
-0.0211603809,
0.0114184953,
-0.0171761364,
-0.0574355274,
0.0184629168,
-0.0467810109,
0.0016609917,
-0.006247622,
0.0216670707,
-0.0664782524,
-0.0043916521,
-0.0075352388,
0.0075370446,
0.0199453291,
0.0106641669,
0.0792638436,
0.0152051877,
-0.0756568834,
0.003167277,
-0.0098069301,
0.0353593417,
-0.0071904822,
0.0130400211,
0.0305708833,
-0.0042367848,
0.0116071701,
0.0543086864,
0.0101090223,
0.0097288517,
-0.0357835703,
-0.0360810719,
-0.0024823744,
0.0311528761,
-0.0359200686,
-0.0309087858,
-0.0078910319,
-0.0350986645,
0.042232614,
-0.0384549014,
0.0011786759,
0.0241882969,
2.707e-7,
0.0473264195,
0.0729334205,
-0.0196809303,
0.0088699972,
-0.011242914,
0.0511192158,
-0.0221489742,
0.0206121672,
0.018828813,
-0.0195676964,
-0.0125812022,
0.0185897686,
0.0663888529,
0.033083573,
-0.128645435,
-0.006524289,
-0.062907055,
0.0055067898,
-0.0299550388,
-0.0036671616,
0.0528636985,
0.0713742822,
-0.0049865544,
-0.0299707092,
-0.0092923166,
-0.0332466513,
0.0722772256,
-0.0607237928,
-0.0140475463,
0.0391221903,
0.0943315402,
0.0151434401,
0.0057833982,
0.0294485334,
-0.0526804179,
0.0083303303,
0.0146215716,
0.0919958204,
0.0115780132,
-0.0423338376,
0.0269152205,
0.0008422578,
0.015620607,
-0.0477209166,
0.0851336569,
-0.0087452559,
-0.0190021414,
-0.0301243644,
-0.0206948742,
-0.008507153,
0.0190962069,
-0.0214354917,
-0.0254791118,
0.0220410284,
0.0230363086,
-0.0240108855,
-0.0010299074,
-0.0336115286,
-0.0133680506,
0.0005222829,
0.0079675131,
-0.0769226775,
-0.0069419215,
-0.0130761424,
0.0255831406,
-0.0802565739,
0.0230400879,
2.584701085e-34,
0.0730244741,
-0.0400047824,
0.0402435847,
0.0291730873,
0.018234048,
0.0367995799,
0.0090218252,
-0.0208817888,
0.0050701285,
-0.0222805757,
0.023606725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09738v1 | Align before Attend: Aligning Visual and Textual Features for Multimodal Hateful Content Detection | 2024-02-15T06:34:15 | 2024-02-15T06:34:15 | Eftekhar Hossain, Omar Sharif, Mohammed Moshiul Hoque, Sarah M. Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal hateful content detection is a challenging task that requires
complex reasoning across visual and textual modalities. Therefore, creating a
meaningful multimodal representation that effectively captures the interplay
between visual and textual features through intermediate fusion is critical.
Conventional fusion techniques are unable to attend to the modality-specific
features effectively. Moreover, most studies exclusively concentrated on
English and overlooked other low-resource languages. This paper proposes a
context-aware attention framework for multimodal hateful content detection and
assesses it for both English and non-English languages. The proposed approach
incorporates an attention layer to meaningfully align the visual and textual
features. This alignment enables selective focus on modality-specific features
before fusing them. We evaluate the proposed approach on two benchmark hateful
meme datasets, viz. MUTE (Bengali code-mixed) and MultiOFF (English).
Evaluation results demonstrate our proposed approach's effectiveness with
F1-scores of $69.7$% and $70.3$% for the MUTE and MultiOFF datasets. The scores
show approximately $2.5$% and $3.2$% performance improvement over the
state-of-the-art systems on these datasets. Our implementation is available at
https://github.com/eftekhar-hossain/Bengali-Hateful-Memes. | [
0.0493227653,
0.0257425606,
-0.0264078695,
0.0538501367,
-0.0018699942,
0.0392210633,
0.0173742771,
0.0212856084,
0.020469455,
-0.0717556253,
-0.028167624,
-0.0212332606,
0.0099316174,
0.0400796607,
0.0186774544,
-0.0624315143,
0.010730138,
0.0683641583,
0.0088616759,
0.0106484517,
0.0903320238,
0.0170135107,
0.0086365789,
0.0488759093,
-0.0953272283,
-0.0148674455,
0.0422706343,
0.0412590653,
0.0441301316,
-0.0027400085,
0.0345381014,
0.0181390401,
-0.0052423971,
0.0437617078,
0.0000018814,
-0.023434354,
0.0113630211,
-0.0161144901,
0.0457082987,
-0.0587513633,
0.0800339207,
-0.0481461771,
-0.0181344561,
0.015061371,
-0.0189047884,
0.0503825098,
0.0888314247,
0.0587590821,
0.0951434895,
0.0587352104,
-0.0178385973,
-0.0339671224,
0.0028467025,
0.009126612,
0.00643215,
0.0109673264,
-0.0106926849,
-0.034609478,
-0.0304395016,
-0.0028908879,
-0.0428504124,
0.0350862183,
0.0162667111,
0.0058055613,
0.0192738865,
-0.0155557133,
-0.0229421034,
-0.0378610641,
0.0181403775,
0.0748126805,
-0.0658487082,
-0.0064833583,
-0.0242157374,
-0.0012642464,
0.0050049797,
-0.0567225888,
-0.0317404605,
0.0107266186,
-0.0300340541,
0.029629644,
-0.0087137492,
0.0129905492,
0.0248899478,
0.033114478,
0.0144466897,
-0.0283321068,
-0.0188632067,
-0.0122039067,
-0.0002250668,
-0.0100207021,
-0.0509881191,
0.0099574151,
0.0162906758,
0.0194681343,
0.0142621845,
-0.0056086998,
-0.0905397758,
-0.0819200873,
0.0067985435,
-0.0812985897,
0.0081135985,
0.039195016,
-0.0788202509,
0.04523509,
0.0238746032,
0.048158709,
-0.0327175856,
0.0192166846,
-0.0050879335,
-0.0136764497,
-0.0006258005,
-0.008120019,
0.0208410081,
-0.0168177169,
-0.0255314466,
-0.0001545022,
-0.0406731814,
0.009674768,
-0.0652855411,
-0.0202573799,
-0.0250866879,
0.0132460687,
0.0097105317,
-0.0109555917,
-0.0136657953,
0.0407574326,
-0.0225779749,
0.0224076118,
-0.0373668037,
-0.0889348835,
-0.0110080456,
0.0649601668,
-0.0301773623,
-0.0253857058,
0.0252257492,
0.066727519,
0.0143133439,
-0.0161783602,
-0.0261025168,
-0.0252418593,
-0.0629223213,
-0.0525936969,
0.0089820335,
-0.052627366,
0.0428913534,
-0.020108968,
-0.0287389848,
-0.0422494374,
-0.000908678,
0.0027975282,
-0.0188624058,
0.0811005235,
0.0149865886,
-0.0378094316,
0.0293038841,
0.0306759626,
0.0003867521,
0.048616007,
-0.0106847631,
0.041247569,
0.0494197048,
-0.0085406927,
-0.0199905764,
0.0458033048,
0.0352566317,
0.0028807165,
-0.0486936644,
0.0279886518,
-0.0370014496,
-0.0227869246,
0.0277570952,
0.0237218086,
-0.0093205022,
-0.0631339848,
0.0494994521,
0.0188121926,
-0.0366002694,
0.0386809856,
0.015973147,
0.0182543788,
-0.0282041449,
-0.0006533784,
-0.0756048858,
0.0463208072,
-0.0452554747,
-0.0183767732,
0.0664310232,
0.0831066296,
-0.0250133052,
-0.0227108113,
-0.0138478754,
-0.041992683,
0.0340072252,
-0.0319927409,
0.0268480312,
0.017510768,
-0.0245174468,
0.0169960558,
0.0579091348,
-0.0411147587,
0.0023193748,
-0.0028626993,
-0.0005854815,
0.0265185479,
0.0269064121,
-0.0317732021,
-0.0165001303,
-0.03735964,
-0.011829908,
0.0122116571,
-0.0411914885,
0.0288660433,
0.0036200038,
-0.0404213406,
-0.0280183479,
0.0123922471,
-0.0269574728,
0.0054220199,
0.0027233099,
0.0453205034,
0.0085116876,
0.0516729131,
-0.0019205485,
0.0160359312,
0.0796937123,
0.0000886057,
-0.0350083224,
0.0500918999,
0.0810017064,
0.0205432158,
-0.0180677213,
-0.0429383181,
0.0071418858,
-0.0367921442,
-0.0140279457,
0.0348754451,
-0.0521710664,
-0.0362754017,
0.038471058,
-0.0972173586,
-0.0276677329,
0.0723678023,
0.0040656035,
0.0279568508,
0.0605834834,
-0.0427722484,
-0.0039467518,
-0.0406193696,
-0.0146208573,
-0.0212828666,
0.0414489172,
-0.0033445833,
0.0873011798,
-0.0319980904,
-0.0123533895,
0.0258577503,
-0.0224117115,
0.0469209999,
0.0368512087,
-0.0424768105,
-0.0135983787,
-0.0141425254,
0.0051861252,
-0.012025441,
0.007988276,
-0.034668602,
0.0095900521,
-0.1252634376,
-0.0141419107,
-0.0257067271,
-0.02693896,
0.0147707136,
0.0110342698,
-0.0019061592,
-0.0258009285,
-0.042517785,
0.0119923772,
0.0332709849,
0.0166635606,
-0.012188728,
-0.0481806062,
0.0404164046,
-0.0502767079,
-0.0050735278,
0.0063878209,
0.0369184278,
0.0206822269,
-0.0487753451,
0.0297958814,
-0.0317376964,
-0.0380958132,
0.0364101417,
-0.0127280839,
-0.0664352402,
0.0266801827,
0.0156992767,
0.0023678422,
0.0530040078,
0.0524615198,
0.0690038651,
0.0006053376,
-0.0039357315,
-0.0252658818,
0.0363028497,
0.0074581965,
0.0466918349,
0.0003916657,
-0.0332850292,
0.0113920886,
0.0520881452,
0.011547952,
0.0232822634,
-0.0548582338,
0.0014887777,
0.0013375924,
-0.0275851879,
-0.0461532101,
-0.0258795805,
-0.0021891298,
-0.0307897683,
-0.0661667809,
-0.0700819865,
0.0722330436,
-0.0096485391,
-0.0281448159,
-0.0116825169,
0.0231119674,
-0.0171433501,
0.0520154722,
0.000797832,
0.0618135631,
-0.0512622595,
-0.0133550027,
-0.0010347641,
-0.0138866259,
0.031468533,
0.0073977765,
0.0045743813,
0.0054016486,
-0.0037577529,
-0.0120070931,
-0.0147007173,
-0.056743294,
-0.0821840316,
-0.0183101539,
-0.0666869506,
0.0056701885,
-0.0150556304,
-0.0366334245,
0.0229100306,
0.0514927395,
-0.038060803,
0.0092650671,
0.0048238458,
0.0436700508,
0.0103029646,
0.0269273017,
0.0233337302,
0.0057158978,
-0.0011238131,
-0.0385587402,
0.0785891116,
-0.014379127,
-0.0153517229,
-0.0047292509,
-0.017195059,
0.0404473543,
0.076885052,
-0.0009338323,
-0.0314440653,
0.0376147926,
-0.0030022834,
0.0220205486,
0.0657884479,
-0.0088133886,
-0.0422043987,
-0.0051167076,
-0.0044184346,
0.0101617631,
0.0169368833,
-0.0257433075,
-0.0470573418,
-0.0561268032,
-0.0494479686,
0.0004815089,
-0.0156530105,
0.0122845685,
-0.0127154877,
-0.0594021939,
-0.0062215868,
0.013266826,
-0.0345841646,
-0.0523900166,
0.0343125463,
0.0254068319,
0.0161366779,
0.0293399282,
-0.029949706,
0.0172192827,
-0.032752201,
-0.0099090897,
-0.0019251297,
0.0009710818,
-0.0257388745,
-0.0323905125,
0.0146705825,
0.0317243077,
0.0410697535,
-0.0050299661,
-0.0801714137,
0.0191830397,
-0.0086457795,
-0.0075798994,
-0.0463304967,
0.050740514,
-0.0247089863,
-0.0457332358,
-0.0255330876,
0.000274182,
-0.0076676565,
0.0091406675,
-0.0122338142,
0.0649362728,
0.0149919679,
0.0343185663,
-0.0874464065,
0.0375605971,
0.0084066493,
0.0497916825,
0.0327034779,
-0.0674681365,
0.0063560875,
-0.015204153,
-0.0089054303,
-0.0153809981,
-0.0476347879,
0.0222417843,
-0.0332824029,
-0.0407189392,
-0.0269489959,
-0.0552307256,
0.0031170917,
0.0351204015,
0.0160535369,
-0.0222104136,
-0.0323176086,
-0.0062615345,
-0.0378127918,
0.0426614098,
0.0226819012,
0.0493180566,
-0.0319300331,
0.0295686759,
-0.0354039222,
-0.0408509448,
-0.008357374,
0.0214065183,
-0.0623085424,
-0.0343937352,
0.010797332,
0.0633411556,
0.0062389132,
0.022234723,
-0.0152037228,
-0.05222442,
0.0093681831,
0.0271985978,
-0.0143127954,
-0.0154762128,
0.0375006273,
-0.0352319628,
0.024513837,
0.0227439143,
-0.0248175729,
0.0348069817,
0.0289775487,
-0.0535952002,
-0.0532143526,
-0.0239165388,
-0.022224443,
-0.0392609984,
0.0435866714,
-0.0285835322,
-0.0247707777,
-0.0045566144,
-0.0175572373,
0.032306537,
-0.0345352516,
-0.0208591614,
0.0060209068,
-0.0036932803,
0.0013940032,
-0.0027908834,
0.0011616185,
-0.0179801695,
-0.0145711629,
-0.0189837608,
0.0408070832,
0.0404292122,
0.0056238095,
0.0058851219,
0.0325322933,
-0.015857365,
0.0209736731,
0.0131756766,
-0.0251756366,
-0.0120837996,
0.0750594959,
0.0054341629,
-0.0435828641,
0.0337112471,
0.0270714853,
0.0705661774,
0.0558382683,
-0.0230576061,
-0.0536716953,
0.0322805233,
-0.0244920366,
0.0240417719,
0.0260195043,
-0.0040461668,
-0.0228977315,
0.0062505258,
-0.0479031615,
-0.0540848449,
0.0113599431,
0.0181041788,
-0.0124273356,
-0.0068956884,
0.0306056682,
-0.0569424219,
-0.0258399453,
0.0458551124,
-0.0263658017,
-0.0304703247,
0.0175132491,
0.0367827229,
0.0537880808,
0.0038292159,
0.0721361786,
-0.0319803357,
-0.0496446565,
0.0271499753,
-0.0540448613,
0.0028547097,
0.0437296517,
0.050442148,
0.0568940714,
0.0168195199,
0.0263524987,
0.0210289285,
0.0141082322,
-0.0099414596,
-0.0324286297,
0.0254803635,
-5.896494926e-33,
-0.0195342042,
-0.0364979133,
-0.031542521,
-0.0531529896,
-0.0142676625,
-0.0118235936,
0.0178034604,
0.016226843,
0.0068009254,
0.0159015786,
0.0228507221,
0.0135933617,
-0.0135663468,
-0.0087396195,
-0.0232860837,
-0.0125680892,
0.0134310694,
0.0464178622,
-0.0045256056,
-0.001980491,
0.0651609451,
0.0015669517,
0.060791336,
-0.056847252,
0.0270202085,
-0.0331295952,
-0.0502491631,
0.0091509977,
0.0200199187,
0.0851828232,
-0.0084358118,
0.083621785,
0.0474738479,
0.0311775748,
-0.0304192211,
0.0647554621,
-0.0393633805,
-0.004393653,
0.0485769138,
0.0408915393,
-0.0423418619,
-0.0311205257,
0.0772698745,
0.0013216896,
-0.0131436316,
-0.0279838219,
0.0383506082,
-0.0187097304,
0.0245732982,
-0.0046676416,
-0.0864697248,
0.0220602676,
-0.0235634279,
0.0078512561,
0.0012798852,
0.0360503756,
0.0506595075,
-0.0131095983,
-0.0723106638,
0.0257064048,
-0.0422742404,
-0.0297591276,
0.0349742584,
0.003662067,
0.0051112561,
0.0801197216,
-0.0120535996,
-0.0087693436,
-0.0343871601,
0.0150683429,
0.0262026936,
0.0398029722,
0.0446606614,
0.0667621866,
0.0035740952,
-0.0386398844,
-0.0483818315,
0.0142472051,
-0.011933119,
0.041364029,
0.0203845277,
-0.0089738229,
-0.0761706829,
0.0154149653,
0.050077077,
-0.0238533579,
-0.0477128439,
-0.0426251106,
0.022801334,
-0.0179559123,
-0.0024173611,
0.0104731936,
0.0449143238,
-0.0120508056,
0.0354230814,
0.0362519659,
-0.0107813925,
0.0250627715,
0.0559824891,
0.042655278,
-0.0144364182,
0.0231658481,
0.0448647887,
-0.0442316197,
0.0177780986,
0.007125454,
0.0813155174,
0.0206177738,
-0.0711787418,
-0.0088773752,
-0.0245843809,
0.0404448807,
-0.0289013349,
0.0585841909,
0.0165624712,
0.0306283273,
-0.0588951968,
-0.0154179828,
0.0176989622,
-0.016654795,
-0.0547309145,
-0.0187846981,
-0.0197769422,
0.0010610141,
-0.0120390737,
-0.0181632359,
-0.0319867246,
-0.0241629127,
0.0072047617,
-0.0821449757,
-0.0086173452,
-0.0232756361,
2.525e-7,
-0.0160388015,
-0.0019662473,
0.0063245106,
-0.0074908929,
0.0430878475,
0.0603819825,
-0.0013093608,
0.0298541002,
-0.0181063749,
-0.0024212836,
-0.0176558178,
0.0371685661,
0.0158971939,
0.0274753943,
0.0085749403,
-0.0008960267,
-0.0390581563,
0.0005451483,
-0.0305305496,
0.0229416452,
0.0329673402,
0.1021836028,
0.0479294248,
-0.0435850099,
-0.0022123589,
-0.0056652976,
0.0235066917,
-0.0148302009,
-0.0127594704,
-0.0664880723,
0.0382005572,
0.0038466554,
-0.0078788726,
-0.0301916879,
0.0219338723,
-0.023595307,
0.0403269418,
0.0256605539,
-0.0306037236,
-0.0488209277,
-0.0031303426,
0.0281870458,
-0.0180490967,
-0.0447673388,
0.0410206057,
0.040379256,
-0.0226725247,
-0.0687653944,
-0.0169746894,
-0.0093817785,
0.0556713305,
-0.0064471783,
-0.0122916326,
-0.0161591396,
0.0472541638,
-0.0439003482,
-0.0193087049,
-0.0983927324,
-0.0267377179,
0.0197664239,
-0.0299514141,
-0.0010378372,
-0.0560226962,
-0.0041308687,
0.087974824,
0.0184986796,
0.0154429544,
1.761671598e-34,
0.0207323097,
-0.0404890999,
0.0527179874,
-0.0415483378,
-0.0076691373,
0.0109890746,
-0.0457158498,
-0.021945959,
0.0657751858,
-0.0173263922,
-0.0066267285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09733v1 | Do LLMs Know about Hallucination? An Empirical Investigation of LLM's Hidden States | 2024-02-15T06:14:55 | 2024-02-15T06:14:55 | Hanyu Duan, Yi Yang, Kar Yan Tam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can make up answers that are not real, and this
is known as hallucination. This research aims to see if, how, and to what
extent LLMs are aware of hallucination. More specifically, we check whether and
how an LLM reacts differently in its hidden states when it answers a question
right versus when it hallucinates. To do this, we introduce an experimental
framework which allows examining LLM's hidden states in different hallucination
situations. Building upon this framework, we conduct a series of experiments
with language models in the LLaMA family (Touvron et al., 2023). Our empirical
findings suggest that LLMs react differently when processing a genuine response
versus a fabricated one. We then apply various model interpretation techniques
to help understand and explain the findings better. Moreover, informed by the
empirical observations, we show great potential of using the guidance derived
from LLM's hidden representation space to mitigate hallucination. We believe
this work provides insights into how LLMs produce hallucinated answers and how
to make them occur less often. | [
0.0322987325,
0.0441314243,
-0.0567665137,
0.0465385243,
-0.0345919766,
0.0002968864,
-0.0280845873,
0.0499226004,
0.0017879253,
-0.0337017253,
-0.0149903037,
-0.0508627631,
0.0053206636,
-0.0073601063,
0.0401536599,
-0.0172878318,
0.0428730436,
-0.0604864024,
0.0084130839,
-0.0488230176,
-0.036784593,
-0.0148560833,
0.0060963659,
0.0154329604,
0.0179778244,
-0.028425768,
-0.0205849167,
-0.0217962135,
-0.0239156578,
0.0082966713,
-0.0163822901,
0.0383262001,
-0.0068060816,
0.0871936753,
0.0000019576,
-0.0512688123,
0.002426442,
-0.0330027379,
-0.0379345864,
0.0368166417,
-0.0086441534,
-0.0035916138,
-0.0129346456,
0.0115838638,
-0.0471592285,
0.0017129843,
0.0390361995,
0.0433142446,
0.0238208845,
0.0477169678,
0.0188049674,
-0.0291209314,
0.0526285693,
0.0009516704,
0.064726308,
0.004904916,
0.0476239026,
0.0323859267,
-0.0029783004,
-0.0246330034,
-0.0366241373,
0.0267802086,
0.0373549908,
-0.0063823257,
-0.0385922901,
0.0066250819,
-0.0330923349,
-0.0238209255,
0.0134322597,
0.0291738994,
-0.0070756194,
-0.0494389422,
0.0065623475,
0.0028935575,
0.0220988579,
0.0237207543,
-0.0202052351,
0.0285887476,
-0.0010586843,
0.0024119262,
0.0413336232,
0.0195135605,
0.0460466929,
-0.0266209729,
-0.0244918019,
0.1019224748,
0.0087822489,
-0.0188939292,
-0.0464874506,
-0.016875796,
-0.0016629077,
-0.0854161456,
0.0137366625,
0.036406938,
-0.028460104,
0.0120828738,
-0.0020102109,
0.0221840162,
0.0506407022,
-0.0723251998,
0.0339840353,
0.0240761284,
-0.0354269929,
0.027840415,
-0.0277298391,
0.0355382562,
-0.0825719088,
0.063359499,
-0.0285117272,
0.0239034202,
-0.0284982547,
-0.051202517,
0.0128513705,
0.0439682864,
0.0172659718,
-0.0013127532,
-0.0101278797,
0.0100087943,
-0.0439150669,
0.0056638173,
-0.0696390644,
0.0262264945,
0.0131448293,
-0.0095320651,
-0.0732278824,
0.0451169536,
-0.0379410982,
0.0261509307,
0.0051119006,
-0.0845421702,
-0.015108387,
-0.0099597648,
-0.016906308,
0.0239932723,
0.0078525953,
0.0401933193,
0.030169297,
0.0020393941,
-0.0097048413,
-0.0278383698,
-0.0078223785,
-0.0627071932,
0.0453299955,
-0.0528175235,
0.0168639682,
0.0257141422,
-0.0017472152,
-0.0313151777,
0.019141769,
0.0006629187,
0.0103354445,
0.07247141,
0.0146696735,
0.0206723586,
0.0402265787,
0.0226935353,
-0.0053165918,
0.0706165135,
0.0166676585,
0.0322251432,
0.0187884141,
-0.0189731661,
0.0640332848,
0.0063173198,
0.0073265326,
-0.000116525,
-0.0276625026,
0.0233302768,
0.0186503921,
0.0305410046,
0.0179116391,
0.0464291535,
-0.012932823,
-0.047631301,
0.047021348,
0.0440987647,
-0.0259377807,
0.021106286,
0.0212397166,
-0.0362856053,
0.0290528405,
0.072158739,
-0.0489689857,
0.0331106782,
-0.0613773875,
-0.0042687817,
0.0291016325,
-0.0253851637,
-0.0102420086,
-0.0532980002,
-0.0182232186,
0.0042406199,
-0.0216296446,
0.0280201808,
0.0130075626,
0.0049614012,
-0.0293675568,
0.0542315021,
0.0140079409,
-0.0068134195,
0.0104755731,
-0.1010337621,
0.0465187989,
0.0389564857,
0.0320262276,
-0.035332609,
0.0405153558,
-0.0100581553,
-0.0087576639,
0.0521007553,
0.0459249578,
0.0074921413,
-0.0351257958,
0.0086807553,
0.0233984385,
-0.0481676161,
0.0656810924,
-0.0014532955,
-0.0551281124,
0.0084018791,
-0.0082438188,
-0.0322389714,
-0.0081015769,
0.038675312,
-0.0367464051,
-0.0201800615,
-0.0473887399,
-0.0308342967,
0.0239075311,
-0.0119863981,
-0.0098571042,
0.0643789172,
0.0156353377,
-0.0284541044,
-0.0450439118,
-0.024612885,
-0.0653554946,
-0.0044550868,
0.0326027647,
-0.0224280003,
0.0042027724,
0.0210425779,
0.037713822,
-0.008045488,
0.0358709022,
-0.0583549514,
0.0734590665,
-0.0342796296,
0.0432081185,
-0.0385881588,
0.0323316418,
-0.0062236479,
0.0952219293,
-0.0343102664,
0.0502308719,
0.0061971913,
-0.0208363552,
0.003609993,
-0.0180200953,
0.0179634448,
0.0313811339,
0.0009594046,
0.011166526,
-0.0235530455,
-0.0697662756,
-0.0553309172,
-0.0212960839,
-0.037888974,
-0.0085220812,
0.0049300538,
0.0070253601,
0.0217135884,
-0.0559305139,
-0.0062120818,
0.01341685,
-0.0212355535,
0.0024097343,
0.0327095091,
0.042131573,
0.0017169256,
-0.0004779699,
-0.0100699095,
-0.0332468189,
0.0023933942,
-0.0190999359,
0.0458487645,
-0.0208509378,
-0.0255346429,
-0.0726424009,
0.0120097613,
-0.0755407512,
0.0112795364,
-0.0145864366,
-0.0254409239,
0.0453076437,
-0.0070983339,
-0.0009848389,
0.0458258241,
0.0214577988,
0.0372333415,
0.0834739432,
0.0054435669,
-0.0444772728,
-0.0318547562,
-0.0130029172,
-0.0066018105,
-0.03622628,
-0.0659135953,
-0.0203866884,
0.0787274837,
0.0376188084,
0.0008193646,
-0.0565345027,
0.0489951745,
-0.0396604948,
-0.0740826279,
0.025894979,
-0.0225564279,
-0.0304126348,
0.0886972547,
-0.0124917049,
-0.0626931638,
0.0776138529,
-0.002950371,
-0.0075064618,
0.0156354215,
0.033352904,
-0.0004634629,
0.0422725268,
0.0176945198,
-0.0099332044,
0.0219887923,
0.0164545383,
-0.0446806177,
-0.0247393567,
-0.0166659597,
-0.0669645965,
-0.0135165052,
-0.0216720793,
-0.0100997919,
0.0048915022,
0.0075568962,
-0.0644473061,
-0.0193070192,
-0.0456658266,
-0.0095116496,
-0.0535235777,
0.0027919142,
-0.0191618688,
-0.0206019133,
0.0180980843,
-0.014714838,
-0.0189650748,
-0.0086326785,
-0.0299026351,
-0.0091849873,
0.0780371279,
0.0252093785,
0.0899346992,
-0.0634872168,
0.0246345513,
0.0773208588,
0.0211690571,
0.0668057576,
0.0060080206,
-0.0153019717,
0.0310047343,
0.0064181471,
-0.0298884939,
0.0408861935,
0.0154864015,
-0.032219965,
-0.0166868083,
0.0669353902,
0.0443124361,
-0.0135670006,
0.0371136703,
-0.0894483924,
0.0338348523,
0.0260680765,
-0.0036671632,
-0.0637982637,
0.0083955936,
-0.0013330751,
-0.0445357263,
-0.0520329662,
-0.0219574347,
-0.0096667334,
-0.0958860219,
0.002724115,
0.0305545218,
0.0101258624,
-0.0076545621,
-0.010694501,
0.0156289246,
0.0606379732,
0.0386886559,
0.016550079,
0.0066949418,
-0.0092645632,
0.0053355279,
0.0030608692,
0.0005786335,
0.0408750325,
0.0173459612,
0.0668808147,
0.0522605777,
0.0246032197,
-0.0225685742,
-0.1194103658,
0.009786047,
-0.0080025978,
-0.0153718935,
0.0024042334,
-0.0155324582,
0.0530434102,
0.0094655789,
-0.0071465205,
0.0063336715,
-0.037101429,
-0.0058499384,
0.0137008857,
0.082992062,
-0.0516007878,
-0.102689527,
-0.0020189369,
0.0138377752,
-0.010431136,
0.0538934246,
0.0524944328,
-0.0290743709,
-0.0513045564,
-0.0425587483,
0.007448189,
0.0287304632,
-0.07988704,
0.0473193042,
0.0919191614,
0.0072301095,
-0.0718516409,
-0.0126564549,
-0.0149727864,
-0.0057796543,
0.0091575356,
0.026988076,
-0.0041695461,
-0.0480799749,
0.0016166649,
0.0060972353,
-0.0539855883,
0.0258292835,
-0.018490335,
-0.0048322873,
0.0217137039,
-0.0250374414,
0.0046496759,
-0.01618715,
-0.0689518601,
-0.0609424338,
0.0606293753,
0.0280544087,
0.0378199331,
-0.022630807,
0.0194990616,
-0.0477424674,
0.0279626343,
0.0140964724,
-0.0080835139,
0.0571615472,
0.0256080553,
0.009007208,
0.0060761571,
0.045067586,
-0.0008216872,
-0.0123384614,
0.0105523653,
0.0145411529,
-0.0395839885,
-0.0136709893,
0.0265330691,
-0.012775003,
-0.0231681038,
0.0223393273,
-0.021200493,
0.0160169676,
0.0177465249,
-0.0160765462,
0.0036793409,
0.0017271104,
-0.043115329,
0.0388778187,
0.0056167734,
0.0331944861,
-0.0493648499,
-0.0375756249,
-0.0083853202,
0.0001645975,
-0.0040956684,
0.0318245329,
0.0014861205,
0.0201021824,
0.010463574,
-0.0059837596,
0.0507704467,
-0.0173931159,
0.0696723089,
0.0352753587,
0.0498489998,
-0.0061917244,
-0.0182601195,
-0.0473786779,
0.0076592667,
-0.0501922928,
-0.0899461135,
0.0376442224,
0.0337549448,
0.0285977013,
0.00772487,
0.0171293821,
-0.0179950576,
0.0086105885,
-0.0140331173,
0.007449802,
0.0477439128,
-0.0493591465,
0.0166776609,
0.0179667845,
-0.027268609,
-0.0117642386,
0.0481305905,
0.0026327581,
0.0598987415,
-0.0243662447,
0.0225936696,
-0.0158349909,
-0.0537720546,
-0.0473813266,
0.0086104544,
-0.0244054664,
-0.0182500463,
-0.0890880823,
-0.0720555857,
-0.025754286,
0.0083438708,
-0.0164603908,
-0.0474280566,
-0.0181553308,
0.0450025946,
0.0134549933,
-0.0136837317,
-0.0339402556,
0.0175739862,
0.0583308488,
0.0250721406,
-0.0043670554,
-6.192510852e-33,
-0.0021428149,
-0.0659228414,
-0.0006387577,
-0.0433158502,
0.0162251424,
-0.0171129405,
-0.0272209123,
0.0151961977,
-0.0255281162,
0.0030076569,
-0.0215691961,
0.0165276565,
0.0110695288,
0.0050444193,
0.0190600473,
-0.0479429811,
0.0115833692,
-0.0075449189,
-0.0259223431,
-0.0093685593,
0.0200969297,
-0.0202202331,
0.0445821844,
-0.0505430736,
0.0715069175,
-0.0410575978,
-0.014185939,
0.0238095187,
-0.0868618414,
0.0334432386,
-0.0629988089,
0.045680277,
0.009413504,
-0.0328360088,
-0.026558565,
-0.0078188535,
0.0126645239,
-0.0190573949,
0.0566001944,
0.0049978672,
-0.0481709242,
-0.0333844237,
0.0346230865,
-0.0081645418,
-0.0110872909,
0.0182414055,
0.0020916502,
-0.0447188765,
-0.0030674567,
0.0412585065,
-0.0603097826,
-0.0296631884,
0.0160081927,
-0.000357065,
-0.0007171265,
0.0118302675,
-0.000551185,
-0.0224274918,
-0.0613550469,
0.0184538141,
0.0247129034,
-0.0047774427,
0.0505908839,
0.0081876246,
0.0248064864,
0.0671233684,
0.0587406382,
0.0457221083,
-0.0263811983,
-0.0341934524,
0.0103163617,
0.04332342,
0.0611949079,
-0.0018888032,
0.0374384969,
-0.0074097021,
-0.014648906,
-0.0260218121,
-0.0129317343,
-0.0006583922,
0.0710838661,
-0.0003891825,
-0.0244554412,
-0.0131486319,
-0.039916642,
0.0066234181,
-0.0370242149,
-0.0075044585,
-0.0027250079,
-0.0079045193,
-0.0235920027,
-0.0336718522,
0.0395016931,
-0.0633690506,
-0.0317416489,
-0.0194647647,
-0.0025244746,
0.0119923055,
0.0319215097,
0.0211880915,
0.0218187906,
-0.0077787652,
-0.0071246098,
-0.0099899005,
0.0284298006,
0.0000923267,
-0.0139776478,
-0.0128994184,
-0.0526873618,
0.0251721572,
-0.0374899916,
-0.0035641915,
0.0272474717,
-0.0274518635,
0.0524920262,
-0.0160520226,
-0.0263320226,
-0.0525233038,
0.0245788731,
0.0031044621,
-0.0501130447,
0.0847085044,
-0.0607711971,
0.0453364402,
-0.0431275144,
-0.0356688648,
-0.0617936999,
0.0639010072,
0.0586145669,
-0.0510739423,
-0.0186422504,
-0.0380734019,
2.646e-7,
0.0231507346,
0.0385703593,
-0.0017252908,
0.0248216484,
0.0799448565,
0.0491035022,
0.0042964555,
0.0197590906,
0.0532101169,
-0.0855277106,
-0.0427021943,
-0.0077747162,
0.0475078635,
0.0456977673,
-0.048890464,
-0.0122712273,
-0.0357971936,
0.0241255276,
-0.037559282,
-0.0195914172,
0.0108331488,
0.062803857,
0.0246014372,
-0.0029260241,
-0.0037346368,
-0.0219157059,
0.0652573407,
-0.0057993159,
0.0131512843,
0.0253663342,
0.0114677604,
0.0085298391,
0.0424813479,
0.0115111498,
0.0251390468,
-0.0254872143,
-0.0113240983,
0.0279724058,
0.0145385917,
-0.0585392378,
-0.0360823683,
-0.02095397,
0.0123939486,
-0.0763578117,
0.072742939,
-0.0176856387,
-0.0234540086,
-0.0234669354,
0.0222345833,
-0.0367970876,
0.0313596651,
0.0107799508,
-0.0084814085,
0.0445881188,
-0.0154687194,
0.0460781492,
0.0149240904,
-0.0362439156,
-0.0432514995,
-0.0205661561,
-0.0630511343,
-0.0427963696,
-0.0306619834,
0.0141082564,
0.0151625937,
-0.0674259514,
0.0161228459,
2.472341274e-34,
0.0136724561,
0.0217826907,
0.0470287688,
0.0503605157,
0.0106770955,
-0.014893841,
0.0553593524,
0.0195631664,
0.0576627888,
-0.0488139912,
-0.0241003577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09727v2 | A Human-Inspired Reading Agent with Gist Memory of Very Long Contexts | 2024-02-15T05:40:21 | 2024-02-23T18:21:28 | Kuang-Huei Lee, Xinyun Chen, Hiroki Furuta, John Canny, Ian Fischer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Current Large Language Models (LLMs) are not only limited to some maximum
context length, but also are not able to robustly consume long inputs. To
address these limitations, we propose ReadAgent, an LLM agent system that
increases effective context length up to 20x in our experiments. Inspired by
how humans interactively read long documents, we implement ReadAgent as a
simple prompting system that uses the advanced language capabilities of LLMs to
(1) decide what content to store together in a memory episode, (2) compress
those memory episodes into short episodic memories called gist memories, and
(3) take actions to look up passages in the original text if ReadAgent needs to
remind itself of relevant details to complete a task. We evaluate ReadAgent
against baselines using retrieval methods, using the original long contexts,
and using the gist memories. These evaluations are performed on three
long-document reading comprehension tasks: QuALITY, NarrativeQA, and QMSum.
ReadAgent outperforms the baselines on all three tasks while extending the
effective context window by 3-20x. | [
0.0107020177,
0.0031546876,
-0.0296816025,
0.0229857154,
-0.0488234945,
0.0183306243,
0.0282216072,
0.0151968608,
0.0458099581,
-0.0417641513,
-0.0037596119,
-0.0545001775,
-0.0049332744,
0.0375047475,
-0.0241613761,
-0.0643496662,
0.0588360243,
-0.0415301509,
0.0517718382,
0.0119556561,
-0.0063611441,
-0.04039317,
-0.000690901,
-0.0093734721,
0.0060481266,
-0.0315198004,
-0.0362102762,
-0.031449955,
0.0150312008,
-0.0532668643,
-0.0077137761,
0.0108146444,
0.0214742161,
0.0032174503,
0.0000020122,
-0.0490062423,
-0.0003470879,
-0.0152538745,
-0.0531589389,
0.0160167143,
0.0471377932,
-0.0055362987,
0.0034781811,
-0.0316557027,
-0.020969335,
0.0111050969,
-0.0169187542,
0.0558840185,
0.0314706825,
0.0716686174,
0.0081254402,
-0.0136107523,
0.046028778,
0.0003863459,
0.0686781704,
-0.0608473159,
0.0146463457,
-0.0043230839,
0.0628752708,
0.0390311144,
-0.049825497,
0.0448235087,
0.0502442569,
0.0260486156,
-0.0068373228,
0.0637571514,
0.0253818799,
0.0091206711,
-0.010775649,
0.0415110514,
0.0458373576,
-0.0196932759,
-0.0099019567,
0.0025024365,
-0.0047199503,
0.0146566238,
-0.0579536967,
0.0268126912,
-0.0374555998,
0.0036561743,
0.0212150645,
0.0034041444,
0.020888526,
0.0035535144,
-0.0529494546,
0.0344309136,
-0.003757454,
-0.0528225042,
-0.0028322607,
-0.0179716107,
-0.0032377122,
-0.0058953757,
0.0177972857,
0.0578937046,
-0.0212982111,
0.0427959189,
-0.0343558751,
-0.0323423669,
0.0380677544,
-0.0443508402,
-0.0280528385,
0.0470850356,
-0.0154220741,
0.0652575716,
-0.0355757363,
0.0668019876,
-0.0098225465,
0.0105206631,
-0.0468095765,
0.0213999227,
-0.0252104905,
-0.0039333897,
-0.0451329425,
0.0326121561,
-0.0326351561,
-0.0479866527,
-0.0037879758,
0.0433177799,
0.0564009733,
0.0271837655,
-0.0278884359,
0.0053824116,
-0.0088698119,
-0.0173710808,
-0.050080575,
-0.0171871614,
-0.0812491924,
-0.0200358499,
0.0354500338,
-0.0142349955,
0.000560198,
-0.0081344144,
-0.0095142312,
-0.0392540284,
-0.0239709076,
0.06995821,
-0.0139031336,
-0.0645787269,
-0.0741083175,
-0.0201239362,
0.0117440009,
-0.0705683008,
-0.0258168317,
-0.0320833623,
0.0294533838,
0.0195647329,
-0.0023587237,
-0.0382501185,
0.0010057992,
0.0481481552,
-0.0195670482,
0.0665729716,
0.0143887363,
-0.0122585613,
0.0565375052,
0.0488336645,
-0.0123991743,
0.040302027,
0.0342190377,
0.0294342153,
0.0427119397,
0.006800964,
0.0045900331,
0.0015224647,
-0.0185649563,
-0.0081073456,
0.0310018193,
0.0149412602,
0.0204273704,
0.0380638167,
0.0170993246,
0.0682272688,
-0.0328669772,
-0.0668940991,
0.0551866814,
0.0814188942,
0.0088114254,
-0.0045635141,
0.0230092183,
0.0254090223,
0.0054384572,
0.0505209453,
-0.0495616458,
0.0466848016,
0.010547067,
0.0301163942,
0.0078505967,
-0.0016144122,
-0.0216567926,
-0.0129266419,
-0.0029904044,
0.0019358977,
0.0143376198,
0.0037468374,
0.037301451,
-0.0390587598,
-0.0543618202,
0.0018016463,
0.0039107585,
-0.0383855961,
0.0150636993,
-0.0427797474,
0.0702441931,
0.1077492908,
0.057341408,
-0.0389850773,
0.0006240226,
-0.0030937977,
0.0113756256,
0.0164191425,
0.0105091315,
-0.0008797661,
-0.0026158846,
-0.0565398596,
0.000868441,
0.0061701997,
-0.0029936456,
0.0154772447,
0.0073015238,
0.0500102043,
0.0213751141,
-0.0181053746,
0.0063665523,
0.0356199592,
-0.0819778144,
-0.0491868369,
-0.0577102564,
-0.0102567095,
0.0139298793,
0.0114411991,
0.0129350442,
0.006647733,
0.0534526147,
-0.0351562835,
0.0018849639,
0.0086862035,
-0.0835026056,
-0.0118698012,
0.005205201,
0.0192794055,
0.0309384111,
-0.0222824365,
0.0399390496,
-0.0613523535,
-0.0304462593,
-0.0485078916,
0.0428144298,
-0.0235050321,
0.0107680792,
-0.0004520694,
-0.0142043047,
-0.0417063348,
0.0660474449,
-0.0096497778,
0.0050593466,
0.0475357287,
0.0501814298,
-0.012483635,
-0.0505231954,
-0.0014237239,
0.0229473114,
0.0334149338,
-0.0092573399,
0.0260031633,
-0.0273293313,
-0.0797408149,
-0.0321357101,
-0.0897593051,
0.0176703483,
0.009492022,
-0.0111943251,
0.0056861104,
-0.0133076552,
-0.0276530199,
0.0206312425,
-0.0333205499,
0.0288129058,
-0.0055355062,
0.0466472469,
-0.0053952704,
0.035437908,
-0.0104707899,
-0.0289230905,
-0.0111444788,
-0.0139555298,
0.0396081991,
0.0134164263,
-0.021421751,
-0.0663509369,
0.0330935419,
0.0253777038,
0.0196180921,
-0.04712037,
-0.0137171494,
0.0268178657,
-0.0393434353,
0.0910754427,
0.1271893829,
0.0261497665,
0.0125081288,
0.0323167965,
-0.0474208184,
-0.0617704988,
0.0263201017,
-0.0222056974,
0.0044356352,
-0.0129509745,
-0.0175026767,
-0.0043723881,
0.0449152701,
0.0033719977,
0.0253209472,
-0.0252517853,
0.018929176,
-0.01971424,
-0.0448780134,
-0.0290791281,
-0.0033203533,
-0.0555837639,
0.0522553772,
-0.0227126162,
-0.0308250263,
0.0641567633,
-0.0278625414,
0.0006853558,
-0.0172158442,
0.016910404,
-0.0346091017,
0.0873093456,
-0.0012279442,
0.0052507832,
-0.0545948148,
-0.016165182,
-0.0274806116,
0.0080895405,
-0.0189358499,
-0.0238806512,
0.0241973698,
-0.0242268592,
0.0142849367,
0.0024170757,
-0.0159521662,
-0.0603857152,
0.0097358758,
-0.0275785625,
-0.0279363282,
-0.0112324879,
0.0185316335,
-0.0537360273,
0.0143294837,
0.0601625778,
0.0530659743,
-0.0159503222,
-0.0041787559,
-0.0029852849,
0.0375402309,
0.0171086434,
-0.0090952972,
0.0236342568,
-0.0612693243,
0.0710264146,
0.0701489747,
0.0136408508,
-0.0187200457,
0.0279425252,
-0.0069063734,
-0.0040498222,
-0.0591252148,
-0.008246717,
0.0137907108,
0.0423198491,
-0.1114604846,
-0.0301941354,
0.1086149588,
0.032217741,
-0.0945481956,
-0.0184706971,
-0.0474781655,
0.0212096442,
-0.0096439524,
0.0092421724,
-0.0581850894,
-0.0225270055,
0.0240894612,
0.0102747204,
-0.0146205546,
-0.0423697755,
0.0013277292,
-0.0623930804,
-0.0004841859,
0.0202254299,
-0.0169969704,
-0.0079401266,
-0.0367154889,
-0.0091242054,
0.039645385,
0.0107798632,
0.085505262,
-0.0069465674,
-0.0142992223,
-0.0456973612,
0.0359317325,
0.0244688299,
0.0264140405,
-0.016672343,
0.0411202982,
0.0418447256,
0.0059649567,
0.0216112044,
-0.0264566224,
0.0334477425,
-0.0550037511,
0.0286771953,
0.0022047281,
0.0528988391,
-0.0430424549,
0.0281894822,
-0.0500217155,
0.0451747254,
-0.0152365072,
-0.0415055342,
0.039717149,
0.055243358,
-0.0060613453,
-0.0277922731,
-0.0389853716,
-0.003952167,
-0.0272069853,
0.0806688964,
0.0062131044,
-0.0377660394,
-0.0696582422,
-0.0119576519,
0.0026142208,
-0.0569803305,
0.0023756013,
0.0235969312,
-0.003755735,
0.0291755758,
-0.069993481,
-0.0985973924,
0.0194889028,
0.01172606,
0.0285543706,
0.0550262965,
0.0198026486,
-0.0016879941,
-0.0478638038,
0.0038899679,
-0.0363930278,
-0.0017939057,
-0.0772286877,
-0.0166184381,
0.019456353,
-0.047574345,
0.0202711876,
0.0206371918,
-0.0644803271,
-0.0305182487,
0.0280002095,
0.0064970911,
0.0179422796,
0.0478208475,
0.0185017772,
-0.0095137395,
0.0596705526,
-0.0229071174,
-0.0717393011,
0.0437704846,
-0.0199495181,
0.0569315217,
0.0011248416,
0.0139938146,
-0.0253319852,
-0.0080737295,
-0.0164948646,
0.0210864171,
-0.0345622115,
-0.017415069,
0.0094379056,
0.0025865319,
-0.0266865827,
0.0088323606,
0.0114598693,
-0.0270644967,
0.0155890966,
-0.0335792974,
0.0232499447,
-0.0023687382,
0.018275803,
0.0187611952,
-0.0338885002,
0.0127915572,
-0.0105979554,
0.0023191706,
-0.0017605441,
-0.0207528025,
0.0306592509,
-0.0013594707,
-0.0090527125,
0.0266202018,
0.0206403583,
-0.0338472538,
0.0058590099,
-0.057342492,
0.0698821321,
-0.0037201028,
0.1104214713,
0.0319219977,
-0.0421013311,
-0.004277823,
0.0113446945,
-0.0843767524,
-0.0012543609,
0.025632374,
0.0384220295,
0.0109821409,
0.0004018388,
0.0042072982,
-0.0291769858,
0.0143140331,
-0.0350014828,
0.0034377952,
0.038155999,
-0.0108137745,
-0.0351567008,
0.045283217,
0.0095746871,
0.0063767564,
0.0524886623,
-0.0175151769,
0.0302624013,
0.0152281532,
0.0069448105,
-0.0267227776,
-0.0143919913,
-0.0161152389,
0.047140412,
-0.0193565879,
-0.0061347173,
-0.0527601726,
-0.0195199959,
0.0259797908,
0.0142372223,
-0.0017707729,
-0.0403573588,
0.0194196515,
0.0391588844,
-0.0144146634,
-0.0241266564,
-0.0184309036,
0.0414146408,
-0.0491119772,
-0.0248731039,
-0.0102348281,
-5.980182042e-33,
-0.0247252285,
-0.0308897514,
0.0556716211,
0.0115434797,
-0.046050813,
0.0012474704,
-0.0314550027,
-0.0161156431,
0.0255993232,
-0.0115978289,
-0.0360161699,
-0.0011783529,
0.0054741972,
0.0101661142,
-0.0063800537,
-0.0079849958,
0.0329122953,
-0.0091186771,
-0.0186278261,
0.0340179242,
0.0524276271,
0.0438395739,
-0.0252045076,
-0.0297247227,
0.0292191301,
-0.0346983261,
0.0513157919,
0.0222408548,
0.0146518014,
0.0448998362,
-0.0574797913,
0.0199317392,
0.0574471205,
-0.0151760858,
-0.0284724142,
0.0766737387,
-0.0965067893,
-0.0038448651,
0.0176498909,
0.0114615122,
-0.0250985026,
-0.0483910851,
0.0078417966,
-0.0182509646,
0.0073464001,
-0.0118027478,
0.0225651208,
-0.0369189233,
-0.0423406325,
0.0053624543,
-0.0623941757,
0.0266713966,
0.0259858649,
-0.0040097786,
0.0275086127,
0.0241986178,
0.0145986807,
0.0485049635,
-0.0417962708,
-0.014497729,
0.0054270346,
0.0242821407,
0.0011911559,
0.0214573946,
0.005984846,
0.0536534712,
0.0362332612,
0.0088390289,
-0.0562192872,
0.0058174585,
0.0397159308,
-0.0143583063,
0.01036062,
0.0410234369,
0.0319589786,
-0.0294414926,
-0.0223785974,
0.0286209304,
0.0401243679,
0.0475640334,
0.0536381863,
0.0194379818,
-0.0594104379,
-0.0175729152,
-0.0382059328,
0.0321247987,
-0.0406577587,
-0.0385967866,
0.058468923,
0.0276901349,
0.0148957875,
-0.0684944093,
0.0492917076,
-0.0011271561,
0.0484624095,
0.0339270048,
-0.0192480534,
0.0244289245,
-0.026357621,
0.0247349925,
-0.0248067193,
-0.0082671484,
0.0080775926,
0.0096648075,
0.003400329,
0.016621206,
-0.007212155,
0.0059114238,
-0.0587275848,
-0.0077667632,
-0.0302871708,
0.0051668468,
0.0112217069,
-0.0198084023,
0.0295383912,
0.0093424171,
-0.0036152415,
0.0883148611,
-0.0296046492,
-0.0071076336,
-0.0417718627,
-0.0204658937,
-0.0185797643,
0.001485015,
-0.0256642792,
0.0051783849,
-0.0333168916,
0.0515260063,
-0.0054267528,
-0.0650190189,
0.0519589782,
0.0521791838,
2.705e-7,
-0.0348036811,
0.0405238084,
0.0357671939,
-0.0091585917,
0.0164062995,
0.0052064662,
-0.0025233168,
0.0106359338,
-0.0053693946,
-0.0591062978,
0.0021548583,
0.0451382957,
0.0006559883,
0.0199417528,
-0.1186054349,
-0.0353135318,
-0.0159804206,
0.0048727053,
-0.0556780733,
-0.0033916989,
0.0991379321,
0.0564627461,
0.0055152122,
-0.006218065,
0.0237658843,
-0.0915438905,
0.0505677126,
-0.0387114994,
-0.0144571569,
0.0013636606,
-0.0120030465,
0.0343618803,
0.006722094,
-0.0011053304,
0.0211135391,
0.0030603935,
-0.0376840867,
0.0700185448,
0.042470146,
-0.0594069175,
0.0237144474,
0.0029025062,
-0.0257271323,
-0.0352660641,
0.0624844246,
-0.0193397105,
-0.0119049838,
0.0306138154,
-0.0393834747,
-0.0355606675,
-0.0428437106,
0.0168464817,
-0.0204424784,
0.0091335904,
-0.0145214638,
-0.0165132489,
0.0265202168,
-0.1105379388,
-0.0014763366,
0.0035682595,
-0.0632640272,
-0.0335569419,
-0.074275896,
-0.0127560971,
0.0206976142,
-0.0817982629,
-0.0165005717,
2.160546219e-34,
0.0301744621,
-0.0185471922,
0.0111119775,
0.0633353367,
0.0115363533,
-0.0073911878,
0.0153092947,
0.0126467384,
0.0530256145,
-0.0918084607,
-0.0413235761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09725v1 | Improving Non-autoregressive Machine Translation with Error Exposure and Consistency Regularization | 2024-02-15T05:35:04 | 2024-02-15T05:35:04 | Xinran Chen, Sufeng Duan, Gongshen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Being one of the IR-NAT (Iterative-refinemennt-based NAT) frameworks, the
Conditional Masked Language Model (CMLM) adopts the mask-predict paradigm to
re-predict the masked low-confidence tokens. However, CMLM suffers from the
data distribution discrepancy between training and inference, where the
observed tokens are generated differently in the two cases. In this paper, we
address this problem with the training approaches of error exposure and
consistency regularization (EECR). We construct the mixed sequences based on
model prediction during training, and propose to optimize over the masked
tokens under imperfect observation conditions. We also design a consistency
learning method to constrain the data distribution for the masked tokens under
different observing situations to narrow down the gap between training and
inference. The experiments on five translation benchmarks obtains an average
improvement of 0.68 and 0.40 BLEU scores compared to the base models,
respectively, and our CMLMC-EECR achieves the best performance with a
comparable translation quality with the Transformer. The experiments results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.0251645818,
0.0965619087,
-0.002521578,
0.0043742866,
-0.0522709377,
0.0003814057,
0.0071902745,
0.0138582215,
-0.0378630459,
-0.0126784639,
0.0108127827,
-0.0746766925,
0.0383962207,
0.0143394098,
0.0476319864,
-0.035542123,
0.0191497151,
-0.022544764,
-0.0204375423,
-0.0079976274,
-0.0071348376,
-0.0223204438,
0.0406657159,
0.0373462625,
-0.0167446937,
0.0233464036,
0.0358829722,
0.0194234531,
0.0158187971,
-0.0644716546,
0.0177004319,
0.0514516048,
0.0261767041,
0.0739489272,
0.0000024803,
-0.0190227311,
-0.0407641642,
0.0044729649,
0.0078108055,
-0.0323713794,
0.0131101012,
-0.0983134285,
-0.0059130508,
0.0244772565,
-0.0056208684,
-0.0361746512,
0.0523285419,
0.011756218,
0.0446313769,
0.081320636,
-0.0106981406,
-0.0547248088,
-0.0331531949,
-0.045925051,
-0.0547853783,
-0.0477902181,
0.0160319023,
-0.0382828303,
-0.0731113181,
-0.0134463087,
-0.0251096375,
0.0589001551,
0.0135203851,
0.0009805075,
-0.0192660056,
0.0316933766,
-0.0367937535,
-0.0411357246,
-0.0180518702,
0.015974991,
-0.0762480423,
-0.0453753732,
0.0120699434,
0.0047176476,
-0.0274292082,
-0.045189552,
-0.0251612552,
-0.0011243847,
0.0224350411,
0.0102857193,
-0.0030966292,
0.0172312818,
0.0288878791,
-0.0144855864,
-0.095496051,
0.0163178202,
0.0214339029,
-0.0220307633,
-0.0735093802,
-0.0262680445,
-0.0167998057,
-0.0315225497,
0.0190247316,
0.0136483405,
-0.0081471354,
0.0241054706,
-0.0465861596,
-0.0824599192,
-0.016464591,
0.0438709483,
-0.0158281364,
0.0498183928,
-0.0008099345,
0.0069829277,
-0.0588375591,
0.0701741874,
-0.0003353074,
0.0273560379,
-0.0432436913,
-0.0316903368,
0.0044465088,
0.0024391827,
-0.0213484578,
0.0061563575,
-0.0192037504,
0.0114249801,
-0.0172914416,
-0.0098487539,
0.014348831,
0.0375791118,
0.0160959009,
-0.055751387,
-0.0897861943,
-0.0174388029,
0.0209926441,
-0.0021066775,
0.0346101485,
0.0002945392,
0.0181295257,
-0.0713457912,
-0.0281043779,
0.0015557871,
0.0039838315,
-0.029628465,
-0.0146118831,
0.0947242081,
-0.0143318987,
-0.0191531871,
0.0018586917,
-0.0072228536,
-0.0152498316,
-0.0574070625,
-0.0071457969,
-0.0599854067,
0.0142479567,
0.0000172527,
0.0329615213,
-0.0350531079,
0.0111604435,
-0.0183190554,
0.0171783213,
0.0652727038,
-0.0019493715,
-0.0335499942,
0.0251443386,
0.0104190335,
-0.01789972,
0.0495706797,
0.0172801558,
-0.0174974054,
0.010593012,
-0.0000872615,
-0.0249243286,
0.048273176,
0.0478532054,
0.0056240745,
-0.0029694601,
-0.0305553637,
0.0290020406,
-0.0093380157,
0.002917666,
0.0527458265,
-0.0157059971,
-0.0077369851,
0.0373605043,
-0.0061936085,
0.0020288546,
0.0252003074,
0.0259267818,
0.0237746723,
-0.0242704786,
0.0562790334,
0.0135687003,
0.0008583232,
-0.0016088586,
0.0139611997,
0.0028875517,
0.0446548834,
-0.0342455208,
-0.0350063778,
-0.0057825563,
-0.0200997442,
-0.0002451275,
-0.0450362526,
0.0630187988,
0.0175065342,
-0.0668229684,
0.0026653432,
-0.0100624887,
0.0038925915,
0.0221229605,
-0.0403754227,
-0.011146795,
-0.0302510671,
0.0261119064,
-0.0131275998,
-0.0112638567,
-0.0344702415,
-0.0242247079,
0.0178184044,
-0.013238268,
0.0486607179,
0.002553304,
-0.025546426,
-0.0106731392,
0.0551652983,
-0.0028800762,
0.0642583519,
-0.0447644964,
0.0335266367,
0.0635386109,
0.0004112668,
-0.0286769513,
0.049991291,
-0.0417350419,
-0.0294583607,
0.0527436361,
0.0063140513,
0.0662008747,
-0.000177986,
-0.0219941102,
0.033544898,
0.0336625762,
-0.055954434,
-0.0485406667,
0.0151166674,
-0.070620276,
-0.0602850802,
0.0444929451,
-0.0625336543,
0.0047150161,
0.06933707,
-0.0141879609,
-0.0881368145,
-0.0055210385,
-0.0214645416,
0.0306738093,
-0.0410451964,
0.0559789874,
0.0242688246,
0.0327591524,
-0.0350806862,
0.0066375439,
-0.0395090207,
0.0170194041,
0.0382834226,
-0.048727043,
0.0295618065,
-0.0305999927,
-0.0189205129,
0.0045254654,
0.0025714757,
0.0047855554,
0.0394686982,
0.0073414291,
-0.0025249235,
-0.0120411571,
-0.0290035829,
-0.0208369996,
-0.0438868925,
0.0232091639,
0.0041867322,
0.0371877365,
0.0076016979,
-0.026790699,
-0.0105842594,
-0.0588609837,
0.0009084773,
-0.0046294266,
-0.0047866651,
0.0293659195,
-0.0248341057,
-0.0036673839,
-0.0042996197,
0.011512612,
0.0431356952,
-0.0120339561,
-0.0620067716,
-0.0841301605,
0.0198203661,
-0.0265850425,
0.0430189483,
-0.0251591578,
-0.0192319304,
-0.0041726753,
-0.0103028584,
0.050462231,
-0.0297537781,
0.0103865825,
-0.049658712,
-0.0018873207,
0.0084229587,
-0.0478613377,
-0.0138476714,
-0.0435231589,
-0.0341259465,
-0.002618199,
-0.0420977324,
0.0223734491,
0.0587265939,
0.0196366087,
-0.0223301519,
-0.0488916524,
0.0053733145,
-0.0035288723,
-0.037303634,
-0.0102128591,
0.0269446317,
-0.0082719307,
0.024717832,
-0.0180105362,
-0.0426634811,
0.0786950588,
-0.0721401498,
0.0064088716,
-0.0407832861,
-0.0189345349,
-0.0121140881,
0.0003595092,
0.0212665461,
0.0189614035,
-0.0073606712,
-0.0289968699,
-0.0422538854,
0.017659232,
0.0019443382,
-0.0048122802,
-0.0037205988,
-0.0393264405,
0.0056168595,
0.0183454715,
0.0031080095,
-0.0321663655,
-0.0618109554,
0.0125888456,
0.0021593659,
0.0633354485,
-0.0068083652,
-0.0039836057,
0.0715234876,
-0.0084877163,
0.081475243,
0.0274456926,
0.0086174915,
-0.0171275157,
0.0074220751,
0.03007669,
-0.0162668619,
0.0143001629,
-0.0250446871,
0.0350778811,
0.008770382,
0.0571609624,
0.0174939036,
-0.0126353521,
-0.0317974016,
0.0357773714,
0.0058903699,
-0.0239198115,
0.0080386912,
0.034009777,
-0.0349472389,
-0.0121772103,
0.1104764789,
-0.0005117563,
-0.0102190506,
0.0188670829,
-0.0338771492,
0.0992736146,
0.0286076721,
0.0133199319,
-0.0677307695,
0.0037482134,
0.0083827497,
0.0431316309,
-0.0147045758,
-0.0018760699,
-0.0161426533,
-0.1003304645,
0.0171289705,
0.0468091555,
-0.0837171599,
-0.0513341725,
-0.0440748632,
-0.0224274658,
-0.0052157608,
0.0486906506,
-0.0032944009,
0.0364909917,
-0.0339868665,
0.0552048162,
-0.0334436186,
-0.0953013003,
-0.0478458777,
-0.0451309979,
0.0305239893,
0.0187777467,
0.0123131657,
-0.0055992771,
-0.0536609665,
0.039339155,
-0.0117417183,
0.0106978575,
-0.0266338307,
0.0013357825,
-0.0211211629,
-0.0195009056,
0.0391451642,
0.0188282523,
0.0361018367,
0.0079721725,
0.0145075871,
0.0568614826,
0.0021318411,
-0.0096213045,
0.0371619016,
-0.0460150763,
0.0364907272,
0.03976864,
-0.0018502527,
-0.0366480015,
0.0101906089,
-0.0102404943,
0.0264610592,
-0.018630309,
0.0066686645,
0.0087204594,
-0.0573971048,
-0.0414572842,
-0.0750801489,
0.0036223212,
0.0109570473,
0.0843311101,
0.0040897569,
0.0254469551,
0.0186542049,
-0.0295948405,
-0.0135544762,
-0.0070521189,
-0.0284664445,
0.0291943066,
-0.0436394364,
0.008344952,
-0.0186581258,
-0.0126655446,
-0.0141815441,
0.0552885458,
-0.0941657722,
-0.066671297,
-0.0081732906,
0.0532244928,
0.0160063878,
0.0546289869,
0.0012468391,
-0.0246835984,
0.0472439043,
0.0094714919,
-0.0166828148,
-0.0076370174,
0.0409735888,
-0.0748049766,
-0.0117628137,
0.0152281495,
-0.0203224141,
-0.0128939645,
0.0151609993,
0.0793705955,
0.0017676332,
-0.0052626817,
0.0418400802,
0.0315299891,
0.0650761276,
-0.0727438107,
-0.0099825757,
-0.0055592218,
0.0391449034,
-0.010413602,
-0.0205136407,
-0.0074590682,
0.0219874978,
0.0260337275,
0.0126361735,
-0.0090783508,
0.025545951,
-0.0537598431,
-0.0044914861,
-0.0191614162,
-0.0220991354,
-0.009409612,
0.0504833311,
0.0139909815,
-0.0061857905,
-0.0012734495,
-0.0040473365,
0.0315323509,
0.0051085232,
-0.0177088212,
0.0034868543,
0.0205088407,
0.0345365517,
-0.0153317219,
-0.0010442298,
-0.0390315987,
0.012329787,
-0.017136585,
-0.0318656713,
0.0452307984,
0.0023896485,
0.0556616187,
-0.0063536391,
0.0020947838,
-0.0216428246,
0.0367275849,
0.0147230364,
-0.0269339122,
0.0339931361,
-0.02496765,
-0.0283984765,
0.0695364177,
0.0661431625,
0.0306534879,
0.0156451333,
-0.0490858257,
-0.0049195155,
-0.0413254164,
0.0102088973,
0.0593389012,
0.015946975,
-0.007926533,
-0.0247086361,
-0.0028312122,
-0.0745297298,
0.0371215679,
-0.0171914548,
0.0195980296,
0.0085333958,
-0.0006970242,
0.0456480421,
-0.0372407101,
-0.0100954538,
-0.0471832715,
0.0082282657,
0.0597173907,
-0.0175390039,
-0.0090596247,
-7.292146879e-33,
-0.0260749906,
-0.0297188926,
-0.0284762774,
-0.0132539365,
0.014676339,
0.0162324421,
-0.023124123,
-0.0267283935,
0.0353556238,
-0.0158654936,
-0.0103471912,
-0.0189536475,
0.0290034413,
0.0169857591,
-0.0415944196,
0.0260982681,
0.0756178573,
0.0334327407,
-0.0237716604,
-0.0173239894,
0.0177558511,
0.0660633892,
0.0752666667,
-0.1004605517,
0.0281381998,
-0.028017357,
-0.0154515821,
0.0216602162,
0.0225775093,
0.0190412626,
0.0053152679,
0.0074005313,
0.0110197971,
-0.0791028887,
-0.0500531867,
-0.0496591032,
-0.0826345608,
0.0141701885,
0.0320736505,
0.0486089736,
-0.0245365575,
-0.0106070256,
0.0293802619,
-0.0418461934,
-0.0219950918,
0.0261891373,
0.0215170253,
-0.0255675968,
-0.0298711136,
-0.0332111903,
-0.0347028337,
0.0431706496,
0.0081678424,
0.0206816271,
0.006691976,
0.0637348145,
-0.0046781218,
-0.0226599444,
-0.1048172042,
-0.0160846934,
0.0035333137,
0.0930556208,
0.0998947546,
0.0714152604,
0.0143494997,
-0.0151098063,
0.0156586785,
0.0243648347,
0.0225262009,
0.0240994468,
0.046870783,
-0.0322577767,
0.0589453615,
0.0121971499,
0.0264540408,
-0.0376119688,
-0.0598093085,
0.0422010832,
-0.0564019345,
0.0463331379,
0.0364696532,
0.0451312624,
0.0009294698,
-0.0045683319,
-0.0601816885,
-0.0358156227,
-0.0152850254,
0.0281292237,
0.0194116179,
0.0429551788,
-0.0438604988,
0.0224030837,
0.085910283,
-0.0057543446,
-0.0415356867,
0.0029695858,
-0.0108668068,
-0.0238596946,
-0.0413407572,
0.0553573444,
-0.0391310677,
-0.0462255776,
0.0551584288,
0.0373652615,
0.0258305445,
-0.040730495,
0.0512443706,
0.0568531752,
-0.0531078018,
-0.0104037439,
-0.0505894758,
0.0166425947,
0.0151588544,
0.0085414359,
0.0334576815,
-0.0122001953,
-0.0086593274,
0.036041338,
0.0341081209,
-0.0205934439,
0.00123887,
0.0692093968,
0.0417265594,
0.0373216309,
-0.0470296852,
0.009144566,
0.0049552796,
0.0278250743,
0.0597010069,
-0.0293477662,
-0.027262995,
-0.0016016836,
3.206e-7,
0.0024684197,
0.0213391874,
0.0232031476,
0.0005241653,
-0.0140034016,
0.0014989811,
-0.0234262012,
0.028270267,
-0.016478939,
0.0129154781,
0.0267879218,
-0.0407855883,
0.0693172291,
0.0136572411,
-0.0735321268,
-0.065198414,
-0.0395635813,
0.0234230384,
-0.0315662585,
0.012384207,
0.0624925457,
0.1320787519,
-0.0015143012,
-0.0012358591,
0.0105047263,
-0.0134397782,
0.0401338227,
0.0040240712,
-0.0232983511,
-0.0006003065,
0.0806381181,
0.0552194938,
-0.0003061861,
-0.0076079695,
-0.0287744664,
0.0135468459,
0.0536973886,
0.0427176952,
-0.0125550246,
0.0309776962,
0.0441756397,
0.0395950824,
-0.0336395092,
-0.0339425057,
0.0346316323,
-0.0333924182,
0.0002962899,
0.0116512151,
-0.037270356,
0.0284370016,
-0.0028817093,
-0.0385823101,
-0.0281503778,
0.0385356657,
0.0636425838,
0.0348252133,
-0.0206186045,
-0.0376373418,
-0.0404200144,
-0.0162927508,
-0.0540591888,
-0.0051212888,
-0.0172450654,
-0.001915991,
0.0054894406,
-0.0442513973,
-0.0083733415,
3.314065254e-34,
0.0317947753,
-0.0376438275,
-0.0259557497,
0.0108780293,
0.0412407629,
-0.0322930478,
-0.0001867247,
0.0462405533,
-0.0014659254,
-0.0465209521,
-0.0312547125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09723v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09723v3 | Efficient Prompt Optimization Through the Lens of Best Arm Identification | 2024-02-15T05:31:13 | 2024-05-30T19:40:21 | Chengshuai Shi, Kun Yang, Zihan Chen, Jundong Li, Jing Yang, Cong Shen | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The remarkable instruction-following capability of large language models
(LLMs) has sparked a growing interest in automatically finding good prompts,
i.e., prompt optimization. Most existing works follow the scheme of selecting
from a pre-generated pool of candidate prompts. However, these designs mainly
focus on the generation strategy, while limited attention has been paid to the
selection method. Especially, the cost incurred during the selection (e.g.,
accessing LLM and evaluating the responses) is rarely explicitly considered. To
overcome this limitation, this work provides a principled framework, TRIPLE, to
efficiently perform prompt selection under an explicit budget constraint.
TRIPLE is built on a novel connection established between prompt optimization
and fixed-budget best arm identification (BAI-FB) in multi-armed bandits (MAB);
thus, it is capable of leveraging the rich toolbox from BAI-FB systematically
and also incorporating unique characteristics of prompt optimization. Extensive
experiments on multiple well-adopted tasks using various LLMs demonstrate the
remarkable performance improvement of TRIPLE over baselines while satisfying
the limited budget constraints. As an extension, variants of TRIPLE are
proposed to efficiently select examples for few-shot prompts, also achieving
superior empirical performance. | [
0.0479300059,
0.0087769683,
-0.008234391,
0.026961429,
-0.0486067198,
0.004861284,
0.0375578739,
-0.0026006482,
0.0199533142,
-0.0331818946,
-0.0475992039,
-0.0495159626,
-0.0216309633,
-0.0280943476,
-0.002749918,
-0.0149018737,
0.053971827,
-0.0899856091,
0.0216424018,
-0.0220658164,
-0.0183510613,
-0.0096860118,
-0.0229243543,
0.0196898822,
0.066947937,
0.0122412769,
-0.0309331883,
0.0006919916,
-0.0018322908,
-0.0507449955,
0.0080134114,
0.0397113897,
-0.0092746168,
0.0390509106,
0.0000023599,
-0.0803434253,
-0.0656111017,
-0.0407011695,
-0.081406422,
0.0405209698,
0.0685745031,
0.0347680598,
0.009649381,
0.0191444736,
0.0206963085,
-0.0001468786,
0.0463314876,
0.0059040217,
0.0257339608,
0.0365649536,
0.0285556223,
0.006023231,
-0.0103792846,
-0.0321517363,
-0.0004695216,
-0.0640665218,
0.0278025437,
-0.0642335117,
0.0546807237,
0.0341985673,
-0.0108835297,
-0.0001506236,
-0.012184727,
-0.014583,
-0.0151339881,
0.0070148073,
-0.0581087768,
0.007048252,
-0.058812432,
0.0473494753,
-0.0182362068,
-0.0079091704,
0.023724148,
-0.0434094742,
0.0328487866,
-0.0109941019,
-0.0219758824,
0.0508776866,
-0.0426030904,
-0.0132966181,
0.0123440791,
0.0088796578,
0.0104631493,
0.0247779042,
-0.0253553707,
0.0371923111,
0.0082014138,
-0.0331513993,
0.0323683731,
-0.0281614736,
-0.0698016584,
-0.0326715298,
0.0071142283,
0.029845804,
-0.0817056969,
0.010113447,
-0.0316392854,
0.007178592,
-0.0017167663,
0.0369422957,
0.0739464536,
0.0331002139,
-0.0303569231,
0.0511593111,
-0.0327565484,
0.070205085,
-0.0207836255,
-0.0185609199,
-0.0340495259,
0.0186482333,
-0.0080225719,
0.0032910302,
-0.0549605526,
0.0395711623,
-0.0046350891,
-0.0200374927,
-0.027948508,
0.0437855385,
0.012764887,
0.0143415527,
-0.0197976138,
-0.0097537562,
-0.0162945092,
0.0154188685,
-0.0109160282,
-0.0268553738,
-0.0295813195,
-0.0012918721,
0.0167890172,
-0.0476536192,
-0.0142011577,
0.0435655378,
-0.0244983714,
-0.0598910823,
0.027351588,
0.0714275911,
0.0043502999,
-0.0408896878,
-0.0464481935,
-0.033126343,
-0.0269970912,
-0.0143296793,
0.0117870271,
-0.0423614495,
0.0172360372,
-0.0177752618,
-0.0076636286,
0.0462399311,
0.0212317593,
0.0021519093,
-0.0084469626,
0.0365783945,
0.0429714099,
0.007593133,
0.0184769519,
-0.022078285,
-0.0109762186,
0.0528642461,
-0.0118857874,
0.0625270605,
0.0571011454,
-0.0195843037,
0.0046084272,
0.0503133759,
0.0008656524,
0.0088503109,
0.0357371494,
-0.0008126517,
0.0780754536,
0.0324824415,
0.0187668838,
0.0067113987,
-0.0352120027,
-0.0091123879,
0.0469057597,
0.0174521338,
0.0003929322,
-0.0399984233,
0.0422902219,
0.0075675938,
-0.0121557266,
0.0040241419,
-0.0220215805,
0.0146865509,
-0.067740202,
0.0006935479,
0.0256517958,
0.0122366846,
-0.0060646115,
0.0246217344,
0.0048163179,
-0.0147240274,
-0.0561226495,
0.0466421433,
0.0288428366,
-0.0473731607,
-0.0797006935,
0.0101502789,
0.0151636256,
0.0092735942,
-0.0435391665,
-0.0475312099,
0.0119637186,
0.0158487447,
0.057681337,
-0.0148132909,
0.0137807922,
-0.0272929482,
0.0290885326,
0.0213789884,
0.0723145679,
-0.0238887146,
0.0442281924,
-0.0587697327,
-0.0461875796,
0.0115456469,
-0.0235938989,
0.0728213862,
0.0159737077,
-0.0261543244,
-0.0018260251,
0.0211400054,
0.0068780622,
0.0211058408,
-0.0094939675,
-0.0906579718,
0.0502751097,
0.028048737,
0.0351277068,
0.0138210794,
-0.0077846702,
0.0195593052,
0.0040879254,
-0.0229992308,
0.0293414649,
-0.0463530533,
-0.0406558104,
-0.0360077918,
0.0104613649,
0.0186779071,
0.0174516272,
0.0092072496,
-0.0278855432,
-0.0460989475,
-0.0216714423,
-0.0426680855,
-0.0019682012,
-0.0193117093,
0.0521093011,
-0.0080747437,
-0.0035685296,
-0.0707552359,
0.0544077083,
-0.0035897924,
0.0493315123,
0.0574909337,
0.0288962927,
0.0284780059,
-0.1429955065,
-0.0008635968,
0.0176831074,
-0.0054499838,
-0.0249261782,
0.0498231128,
0.0103880307,
0.0178953316,
-0.0366779491,
-0.0950905085,
0.0189481284,
-0.0113824541,
-0.0108155431,
-0.0024755076,
-0.0001780668,
-0.0262040012,
-0.0283566155,
0.0059367656,
-0.0133428108,
-0.0067816814,
0.0331270993,
0.0097396886,
0.011807574,
-0.0316354148,
-0.0317814834,
-0.0225280449,
-0.0042090076,
0.02153375,
0.0203076266,
-0.0447739251,
-0.0435782075,
-0.0177014619,
0.0124948183,
0.0265328772,
-0.0066108708,
0.0037261976,
-0.0035937105,
-0.0274249036,
0.0130714746,
0.0878245682,
0.0091647431,
-0.0018088071,
0.0367070474,
0.0070654247,
-0.0514610037,
0.0121368524,
-0.0198348239,
-0.0472140759,
0.0116317784,
-0.0373928621,
0.0825161263,
0.0652868524,
0.0257911682,
0.016017843,
-0.0342478305,
-0.0185161587,
0.0402018651,
-0.0137597425,
-0.0708563402,
0.0027005216,
-0.0300023649,
0.0397078395,
-0.0186219513,
-0.0393229648,
0.0692211688,
-0.0400217995,
-0.0054736384,
-0.0267513264,
-0.0008224141,
-0.0200699233,
0.0039426805,
0.0116209285,
0.0359630138,
0.0511509441,
-0.030867096,
-0.0335584655,
0.0110353883,
0.0614083037,
-0.0115874689,
-0.0059414976,
-0.0292394999,
0.002973428,
-0.0300494619,
-0.0574264154,
-0.0179203395,
-0.0748905614,
0.0063974666,
0.0006017796,
0.0361581035,
0.0217622705,
-0.0440823287,
-0.0040868428,
0.0405836292,
0.0541646071,
-0.0256781317,
0.0181937609,
-0.0377215557,
0.0461032093,
0.0550899208,
-0.0430861227,
0.0361609384,
-0.0444348902,
0.0612196885,
-0.0082564056,
0.0551542155,
0.0279861093,
0.0208239555,
0.0361453928,
0.0653002113,
-0.0625520572,
-0.0411882065,
0.0486800224,
0.0309376679,
-0.0201775432,
-0.0028996416,
0.087525256,
0.0385801718,
-0.0500583164,
-0.0068412335,
-0.0048319823,
0.0161899477,
0.0124530289,
0.0374144726,
-0.0656488687,
-0.0569842905,
0.0140256211,
0.0814635828,
-0.0574528985,
-0.0511470288,
-0.0062700231,
-0.1500903666,
0.0483666696,
-0.0089197895,
-0.0154534429,
-0.0015022977,
-0.0296973176,
-0.0051252837,
-0.0042412621,
-0.0183302686,
0.0592479184,
-0.0190398283,
0.0033482951,
0.0238454472,
0.0027081897,
0.0039816787,
0.0225554369,
-0.0165416822,
0.0362529643,
0.0800113827,
-0.0288164634,
0.006189941,
0.0118158907,
0.0206944644,
-0.041986458,
-0.0157224182,
0.009626288,
0.0122213801,
-0.0155638279,
-0.001288636,
0.0187489148,
0.0451567508,
0.0017170474,
-0.015796354,
0.0533725135,
0.0337885953,
-0.0285208393,
0.0269988067,
0.00964553,
-0.023346711,
0.0393164195,
0.075495936,
0.0133057963,
-0.0497435778,
-0.0112731438,
-0.0396685004,
-0.0419614539,
-0.0718003586,
0.0283193029,
0.0252351426,
-0.0254946686,
0.0004040352,
-0.0584477223,
-0.0198304597,
0.0110783614,
0.0628434643,
0.0033505256,
0.0123521108,
-0.0537637547,
0.0022309977,
-0.0066297818,
-0.0027129888,
-0.0606970638,
0.0233005974,
-0.1241081133,
0.0212497916,
0.0345342457,
-0.0663958266,
-0.0206936225,
0.0507834777,
-0.0537407771,
-0.0574791469,
0.0020580422,
0.0511493348,
0.0144796334,
-0.0041397545,
-0.0217358693,
-0.0450916104,
0.048615627,
0.014993987,
0.0202202387,
0.0323823653,
-0.0047844802,
0.0114811445,
-0.0467687733,
0.0001778363,
-0.0450193658,
0.0124894856,
0.0473183207,
0.0199906118,
-0.0016508555,
-0.030292118,
0.023752667,
0.0479063466,
0.0354475938,
-0.0299326479,
-0.0268384106,
-0.0001808522,
0.0255587492,
0.0327469073,
-0.0149635915,
-0.022519378,
-0.0010587509,
0.0264875665,
-0.0455592684,
0.0453976169,
-0.0369142182,
-0.0000668619,
0.0478130318,
-0.0337137245,
0.0180152263,
0.0209723208,
0.0468466319,
0.0140981125,
-0.023247866,
-0.0051002023,
0.0709232017,
0.022649629,
0.0558543056,
0.0044485223,
0.1313420683,
0.0096033551,
-0.0089141969,
0.0189536102,
0.0174673088,
-0.0524946041,
-0.0583176948,
-0.036707446,
0.0464805625,
0.0351885967,
-0.0294890217,
-0.0172634646,
-0.0018300918,
-0.0092118774,
-0.0523264669,
0.0112939291,
0.018362876,
-0.0651862845,
0.0459639132,
0.0345639698,
-0.0000414085,
0.0107334517,
0.0597001128,
0.0175438691,
0.050403595,
0.0032534192,
0.0000138921,
-0.0491919219,
-0.0397703238,
0.0694324449,
0.0273463205,
-0.0394741036,
0.0262890831,
-0.0404781401,
0.0094743753,
0.0030740276,
-0.0030520528,
0.0229197312,
-0.0002155465,
0.0484115668,
0.0299962461,
-0.0242550578,
0.0247882158,
-0.0600589029,
0.0272920113,
-0.0457594357,
-0.0201897174,
-0.0464604385,
-6.05726288e-33,
-0.0518024266,
-0.0102911806,
-0.0051090871,
-0.078956686,
0.0218839496,
-0.0148588987,
-0.0192560907,
0.0192245804,
0.004629029,
-0.0664083287,
-0.0203552749,
-0.0477067567,
0.0205532201,
0.0068846666,
0.0090940604,
0.0036613024,
0.0203943048,
-0.0007749485,
-0.0849931911,
0.0127975428,
0.0163918063,
0.0246165991,
-0.0004455524,
0.026038168,
0.0091619976,
-0.0097520314,
-0.0030956939,
0.0232894104,
0.01458418,
0.0702671632,
-0.0085118609,
-0.0004500107,
-0.0118936831,
-0.0661237538,
0.0107947681,
0.0063030678,
0.0077608586,
-0.0426283628,
0.0124006327,
0.008438265,
0.0250732582,
-0.0646869466,
-0.0327778049,
-0.047622785,
-0.0151127707,
0.0255496055,
0.001839235,
-0.0162778776,
-0.0586621314,
-0.0026159554,
-0.0068158591,
0.010635714,
-0.00376618,
-0.0067040757,
0.0300535243,
0.0709393248,
-0.0104880091,
0.0260032266,
0.0136979353,
0.0519513674,
0.0571104884,
0.0416450948,
0.0511149764,
0.0502615571,
0.0109106721,
0.0181597881,
0.0177306999,
-0.0215588212,
0.0554376133,
-0.0083331754,
-0.0152337532,
0.0098141218,
0.026396824,
0.0679387897,
0.0121326763,
0.0161771365,
-0.0429240502,
0.0255763642,
0.0816901922,
-0.0210022647,
0.0415060893,
0.0043559773,
-0.0481812693,
-0.024580624,
-0.0438856818,
-0.0402219072,
-0.0258883853,
-0.0027747534,
0.0587759279,
0.0065659513,
-0.0452363901,
-0.0342409723,
0.0888978168,
0.0095724817,
-0.0092310729,
-0.0179394316,
-0.0018925983,
0.0436682291,
-0.0054647019,
0.0282933302,
-0.0466281101,
-0.047728084,
0.0370337069,
-0.0524309464,
0.0348649882,
0.0164487511,
-0.0133300051,
0.025526261,
-0.0633643866,
0.013730213,
-0.0268082637,
0.0139885256,
-0.0176907051,
0.0304852538,
0.0287151523,
-0.0271148011,
0.0054297829,
0.0450775512,
0.0111704925,
-0.0697452947,
-0.0140921008,
-0.0272298735,
-0.0183522273,
0.0305699985,
-0.0277979877,
0.0321827121,
0.0026516241,
0.0356431752,
-0.0121996971,
-0.0056403843,
-0.0050804913,
0.0063092327,
2.929e-7,
-0.0073269387,
0.008622759,
0.0066566099,
0.0133741843,
-0.0118039306,
0.0448774397,
-0.0083653443,
0.021324113,
0.0104049351,
0.0003549808,
0.0044526509,
-0.0017975908,
0.0276294872,
-0.0153816789,
-0.1005799249,
0.0309505593,
-0.0151195358,
0.0519212373,
-0.072571978,
-0.0029239713,
-0.001272412,
0.0715878755,
-0.0246789698,
-0.01091203,
0.0017135087,
-0.0604069643,
0.0213608611,
-0.0401377231,
-0.0202168673,
0.0200175047,
0.0425201282,
-0.0032460885,
-0.05963514,
0.0087255146,
0.0037985854,
0.0148118101,
0.0022057381,
0.0653199255,
0.0390583538,
-0.0260561313,
0.013462252,
-0.0011549386,
-0.003432391,
-0.045335345,
0.0684880018,
-0.0054023713,
0.0036318088,
-0.0500188544,
-0.0092191203,
-0.0509369448,
-0.0221728254,
-0.0509907007,
0.0242613479,
0.0033516777,
-0.0099200541,
0.0067068967,
0.0087797828,
-0.0365052149,
0.0196921509,
-0.0112159848,
-0.013610852,
-0.0508558676,
-0.040622618,
0.0099831335,
0.0086722104,
-0.1306083947,
-0.0007470372,
3.062697037e-34,
0.0071896845,
-0.0226162691,
0.0160958804,
0.028914623,
0.0324391425,
0.008873078,
-0.0238753129,
0.0234491359,
0.0387513041,
-0.0642114431,
-0.0252735242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09696v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09696v2 | An Analysis of Language Frequency and Error Correction for Esperanto | 2024-02-15T04:10:25 | 2024-02-16T02:19:49 | Junhong Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current Grammar Error Correction (GEC) initiatives tend to focus on major
languages, with less attention given to low-resource languages like Esperanto.
In this article, we begin to bridge this gap by first conducting a
comprehensive frequency analysis using the Eo-GP dataset, created explicitly
for this purpose. We then introduce the Eo-GEC dataset, derived from authentic
user cases and annotated with fine-grained linguistic details for error
identification. Leveraging GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, our experiments show that GPT-4
outperforms GPT-3.5 in both automated and human evaluations, highlighting its
efficacy in addressing Esperanto's grammatical peculiarities and illustrating
the potential of advanced language models to enhance GEC strategies for less
commonly studied languages. | [
0.04523734,
0.0694966093,
-0.0392362922,
0.0268094633,
0.0069389623,
0.0159772784,
-0.0555949584,
-0.0207034647,
-0.0132495705,
-0.0196501501,
-0.0293253679,
-0.0418257043,
0.0621131659,
-0.0259406045,
0.0322474688,
-0.0445512906,
0.0395713188,
0.0063549378,
-0.0061510708,
0.0233368706,
0.0509328768,
0.0123283584,
-0.025503071,
0.0402902067,
-0.0464681722,
-0.005328428,
0.0116504412,
0.0222348291,
0.033320982,
-0.0182192978,
0.0389560908,
0.0682221204,
-0.0666489005,
0.0837588012,
0.0000018031,
-0.0322313234,
-0.0164718535,
-0.0077126212,
0.0076374998,
0.0500640199,
0.0143986661,
-0.0157499295,
-0.0938042104,
0.0340271555,
-0.0059186863,
-0.0523450151,
0.0684521124,
-0.0188248735,
0.0501541793,
0.0659330115,
-0.0125795137,
0.009453279,
0.0194852315,
-0.0202553794,
-0.0203649737,
0.0320762992,
0.0278369486,
-0.0401984416,
-0.0492469147,
-0.034693405,
-0.0038989738,
0.0191783477,
0.0079908855,
-0.0442473516,
-0.0618725233,
-0.0306162462,
-0.0689514801,
-0.0258650724,
-0.0125008728,
0.005287895,
0.0280072447,
-0.0409235731,
-0.006562572,
0.0118423989,
0.0054535293,
0.0017093256,
-0.0332490392,
-0.0202283859,
-0.0035341477,
0.0142651778,
0.0762992278,
-0.0456130914,
0.0269982386,
-0.0037889318,
0.0358273499,
0.0572349802,
0.0418414921,
-0.0370570384,
-0.0078291371,
0.0386640914,
-0.040485505,
-0.0234653894,
0.0364524499,
-0.0121463379,
0.0001017671,
-0.0035512738,
-0.0493601523,
-0.0686103478,
0.0476273857,
-0.0332516693,
0.0221359488,
0.0157444794,
-0.010932995,
-0.0057805451,
0.0138774756,
0.0611829571,
0.0434334725,
-0.0285242777,
0.0006391838,
-0.007560221,
-0.0271329992,
-0.0096283918,
-0.0574698225,
-0.0125134839,
0.0106574381,
0.0700937733,
-0.0664120764,
0.0140797328,
-0.0263886973,
0.0443767533,
0.0232363902,
-0.0370967016,
-0.0389688984,
-0.0251539126,
0.0115171373,
0.0367444158,
-0.026570322,
0.0376160368,
-0.0083338358,
-0.0863782838,
0.0083094742,
0.0267494619,
-0.0177171696,
0.0089368438,
-0.0141040822,
-0.0102607599,
0.0245364942,
-0.0333236419,
-0.0042400002,
-0.0218301862,
-0.04282571,
-0.0457967967,
-0.0503486171,
-0.0642788708,
-0.0101619354,
0.0057272338,
0.0324259363,
-0.042901665,
-0.01813972,
0.002577771,
0.017099414,
0.0454594083,
-0.0285827275,
0.0176630579,
0.0227123424,
-0.0446659699,
0.0342478864,
0.0552832,
0.0419308804,
-0.0727620497,
0.058192078,
-0.0039192247,
0.0331843644,
0.0521573797,
-0.0314824916,
0.0067980401,
0.0501701832,
-0.0418996029,
-0.0250748582,
0.0427458063,
0.057481546,
0.071426183,
0.0059135258,
0.0396069176,
0.0782941133,
0.0382412337,
-0.0064511043,
0.0285229664,
0.0467071719,
-0.0354571231,
0.0263133366,
0.0255066473,
-0.0200438816,
-0.0364062674,
-0.0590644851,
0.0070468965,
0.0001364893,
0.0310274549,
-0.0184562597,
-0.0333107524,
-0.0122909201,
0.0183209199,
-0.0037897381,
-0.041025959,
0.0476886109,
-0.0010721231,
-0.0003604206,
0.035187237,
0.0036606374,
-0.0722049549,
-0.0058918856,
-0.0471175872,
0.0070166448,
0.0269150008,
0.0599050485,
-0.0227717273,
-0.0077334647,
0.0199641772,
-0.0140507594,
0.0231364127,
0.063614592,
-0.0066040168,
-0.0163141042,
-0.0320743024,
0.006492449,
0.0260840375,
0.0473919287,
0.0112842359,
0.0101645915,
0.027885519,
0.0313407108,
-0.055931557,
-0.0179658718,
0.0138331689,
0.0149750337,
0.0069577699,
-0.0246321559,
-0.01127089,
0.0082810856,
0.0387869552,
-0.0139552141,
0.0001485962,
-0.0196326002,
0.0060035489,
0.0292294361,
0.0176834594,
0.0038760202,
-0.0277074091,
0.0476267375,
-0.0310223978,
-0.0756379515,
0.0497423336,
-0.0253965296,
-0.041841127,
0.001165946,
-0.0491690822,
0.0347139537,
-0.0854463428,
0.0442402959,
-0.0248724278,
0.0295021459,
-0.0092518032,
-0.0060393452,
0.0092473179,
0.0290502217,
-0.0283015706,
-0.0138056679,
0.0469290353,
-0.0614781417,
-0.053754434,
0.0154438978,
0.003019162,
0.0275260676,
0.0129295951,
0.0370322317,
-0.0373569094,
-0.018712135,
-0.098923713,
0.0074360827,
-0.0438316278,
0.0514529496,
0.0560665503,
0.0032887275,
-0.0287266374,
-0.0097939139,
0.0225301813,
0.0094048772,
0.0350332893,
-0.0129193254,
0.0565835536,
-0.0235124324,
-0.0410220996,
-0.066564545,
0.0133461598,
-0.005083797,
-0.0177342612,
0.0069078542,
-0.030885417,
-0.0805933699,
0.0374468453,
-0.0334841013,
0.0090909367,
0.0630381927,
-0.0784511194,
-0.0004714425,
0.0304534063,
0.0430669375,
0.0084017189,
-0.0405834652,
0.0361587666,
0.0146334367,
-0.0066083022,
0.0143047851,
-0.0354071073,
0.0017239689,
-0.0473934934,
-0.0094889784,
-0.016246967,
0.0494333282,
0.0850192606,
0.0112813357,
-0.0471450388,
-0.0448978283,
-0.0040920321,
-0.0357964896,
0.0105184894,
0.0235641208,
-0.0082378648,
-0.0060674921,
0.0226699878,
-0.0152544575,
-0.0300848596,
0.0825558901,
-0.0253266804,
-0.0010543414,
-0.0478730723,
0.0143088978,
-0.013002824,
-0.0205932148,
0.038019266,
0.0038778023,
0.016334692,
-0.0690121576,
-0.0170185007,
0.0010260354,
0.068938911,
-0.0189017057,
0.0392731838,
-0.1041162014,
0.0200885795,
0.0102084326,
-0.0765519068,
0.0156148719,
-0.0173100848,
-0.0162309129,
-0.0270586424,
0.0041694785,
0.0021214557,
-0.0198145024,
-0.0243899468,
-0.0094736181,
0.062424764,
-0.0288325008,
-0.0131129753,
0.0126487715,
0.0239805337,
-0.0142760696,
-0.0343345143,
0.0221161544,
-0.0331778675,
-0.009459245,
0.0596655086,
0.0372281261,
0.0358311087,
-0.0073713213,
0.0208437145,
0.0452433713,
-0.0072734873,
-0.0638628751,
-0.0140807191,
0.0568664446,
-0.0296816602,
-0.0273637678,
0.0911971256,
0.0380705185,
-0.0243150145,
0.0018252234,
-0.0508448891,
0.0488468632,
-0.0038182787,
0.0415461957,
-0.0508293211,
0.0009301574,
0.0521658286,
0.0467866585,
-0.0409184657,
0.011572619,
-0.0007545975,
-0.1173815653,
0.0527507477,
0.0423399508,
-0.037714567,
-0.0500499904,
-0.0170263574,
0.0269669853,
-0.0097031388,
0.0355626382,
0.0441423506,
-0.0057244799,
0.0050694859,
0.0403245836,
-0.0992871299,
-0.0946435034,
-0.0110186897,
-0.0133509841,
0.0390886851,
0.0563791059,
0.0021561219,
-0.0063443584,
-0.0082528349,
0.0499266572,
-0.0085914982,
-0.0411214344,
0.0036880006,
0.0083588446,
0.0334551632,
-0.0359471031,
-0.0426911563,
0.0571700186,
-0.0389064625,
-0.0008620572,
-0.0079582669,
0.0848870873,
0.0005827735,
0.032057628,
0.0249223262,
-0.031185396,
-0.0010986623,
-0.0072621969,
0.0386815481,
-0.0158212706,
-0.0181708019,
-0.063105844,
0.0045361202,
-0.0332228206,
0.0320689417,
0.0392301604,
-0.0039331759,
-0.0429188646,
-0.0554886125,
-0.1028809249,
0.0287311506,
-0.0364987254,
0.0247851983,
-0.0273003969,
-0.0249729138,
-0.0204244554,
0.0433961377,
0.0094822589,
0.0156609844,
0.0310774818,
-0.0920598581,
0.0001247915,
-0.0168829989,
0.0549436025,
-0.0071442467,
0.0198133234,
-0.0587322265,
-0.0550039485,
0.0190573726,
0.0451528952,
0.0220190547,
-0.0060751732,
-0.0022178921,
-0.0682879165,
-0.0184488818,
0.0490929335,
-0.0047623166,
0.031580057,
0.0009502922,
-0.0636600628,
0.0056317607,
0.0319658965,
0.0191505533,
-0.0175764225,
-0.0082058357,
0.043587476,
-0.0128709422,
-0.0141214291,
0.0466510318,
0.0094377818,
0.0770938098,
-0.0383940488,
0.0061036251,
-0.058925271,
0.0033369686,
-0.0135814054,
0.0175283104,
-0.0050706649,
0.005630115,
0.0261274502,
-0.0226640664,
-0.0465742536,
-0.0205153264,
-0.0612896048,
0.0148399565,
-0.0289080963,
-0.0292704199,
0.0185916275,
0.0097059747,
-0.0025336021,
0.0214790497,
0.0003046458,
-0.0162429996,
0.0286676902,
0.0306066088,
-0.0221662931,
0.0356023088,
-0.0131781744,
0.0229328629,
0.020564761,
0.0146839544,
0.0338655859,
0.0017089543,
-0.0326646268,
0.0077126329,
0.1117265895,
-0.0001882532,
0.0865323097,
-0.0350170508,
-0.0052230032,
-0.0453566611,
0.068115294,
0.0008433066,
-0.0015324919,
0.0033415372,
-0.0238496512,
-0.0024802801,
-0.002311579,
0.061358735,
-0.0006712843,
0.0329832584,
-0.0146526909,
-0.0073724207,
0.0084227789,
-0.0086870342,
-0.0265850928,
-0.0631219819,
-0.0491654985,
-0.0710914731,
-0.046598386,
-0.0928915888,
-0.0570237711,
0.0530979596,
0.0140667381,
-0.0137321679,
-0.0051438054,
0.0590118021,
-0.0463120006,
-0.0108378986,
-0.0439521819,
-0.0318791382,
-0.0077671218,
0.0188075453,
-0.015275551,
-5.417831422e-33,
-0.0636125207,
0.0011570902,
-0.0301306006,
0.0093178116,
0.0045151352,
-0.0369338132,
-0.0452220216,
0.0170530826,
0.0555473752,
0.0392827988,
-0.0211492907,
0.0226234868,
0.0166098028,
-0.0055738529,
0.0739905611,
0.0557944775,
0.0405525006,
-0.0039040791,
-0.0237860326,
-0.0403878465,
0.0151513154,
0.0240340065,
0.0868870541,
-0.0551385805,
0.0569499955,
0.0194741879,
-0.0158829056,
0.0036373767,
0.014303105,
0.0470338054,
0.0410181992,
0.0544216484,
0.0000326813,
-0.0041298331,
-0.0448005833,
-0.0336068161,
-0.047769554,
-0.0500456803,
0.0389334373,
0.0560023226,
0.0315077417,
-0.0098334653,
0.0303602982,
-0.0301842187,
-0.020713361,
0.0015643213,
0.0013123743,
-0.0562536791,
0.0071958001,
0.0225254819,
-0.029421024,
0.0302308574,
-0.0079858983,
0.0070158509,
-0.0056210933,
0.0401157402,
-0.0366794989,
-0.0600823611,
-0.0296310596,
0.0096698673,
0.0212446917,
0.0266987123,
0.0287912004,
-0.0427821353,
-0.0236971416,
0.0154027836,
-0.0088147111,
-0.0273440499,
0.0339891724,
0.0199955851,
0.022231834,
-0.0314353034,
0.0241443738,
0.0528320335,
0.0409968197,
-0.0628964156,
-0.0395614058,
0.0373810567,
-0.0311725903,
0.0410474986,
-0.0089373626,
-0.0226438642,
-0.047934927,
-0.0352396332,
-0.0185841806,
0.0050067781,
-0.0109793721,
-0.0395209454,
0.0218116287,
-0.0338955745,
0.0116738454,
-0.0288855173,
-0.0144825932,
-0.0162759144,
-0.036462035,
-0.0277069565,
-0.0304711312,
0.0483803861,
-0.022628855,
0.0473064929,
-0.0051485277,
-0.020554455,
-0.019393906,
0.0322322845,
0.0243304316,
-0.0089216204,
0.0556407347,
0.0360372327,
-0.0671607405,
0.048845958,
-0.0224845409,
0.0313801207,
-0.0241385736,
0.0125303157,
0.0070694238,
0.0029504399,
0.0150544355,
0.0301122125,
0.0120116239,
-0.0001694095,
-0.0437543429,
-0.019947743,
-0.0070636775,
0.0210457165,
-0.0224278849,
-0.0252236947,
-0.0171515178,
-0.0210890546,
0.0320198573,
0.0145061053,
-0.0013613454,
-0.0609108731,
2.469e-7,
0.0359261222,
0.0493817292,
0.0035316744,
-0.0060463706,
0.0201776456,
0.0043011811,
-0.0385557227,
0.0329351649,
0.0226518791,
0.0919755921,
0.0324601829,
-0.0297053624,
0.0770758092,
0.020057762,
-0.0369705223,
-0.0203182884,
-0.0258879233,
-0.0002775226,
-0.0357335173,
-0.0177651756,
0.0013091082,
0.0572532788,
0.0206105467,
0.0063284626,
-0.0330717042,
-0.0208519455,
0.0787125006,
-0.007292042,
-0.0422740132,
0.0188641772,
0.0611074232,
0.046444051,
0.0290274546,
0.0044658324,
-0.0150725543,
-0.022167908,
-0.0171940327,
0.0363261588,
-0.0201724023,
0.0383640453,
0.0439213887,
-0.0130989021,
-0.0345260315,
-0.0687373281,
0.0256410334,
-0.0083642974,
0.0046162438,
0.0294552557,
-0.0244413149,
-0.0395688005,
0.0088374708,
-0.0467682667,
-0.0569773614,
0.0243627112,
0.0328369699,
-0.0038630927,
-0.0209164321,
0.004946603,
-0.0077494006,
0.0474191383,
-0.0039709075,
-0.0463850312,
0.0106975045,
0.0267110188,
0.0080243452,
0.0097539304,
0.0256816857,
1.812452954e-34,
0.0338927843,
0.0001573325,
0.0331261121,
-0.0213841554,
0.0354273282,
-0.0023040783,
0.0285892189,
0.0435308032,
-0.0226031411,
0.0139181009,
-0.0067176777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09674v1 | PAL: Proxy-Guided Black-Box Attack on Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T02:54:49 | 2024-02-15T02:54:49 | Chawin Sitawarin, Norman Mu, David Wagner, Alexandre Araujo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have surged in popularity in recent months, but
they have demonstrated concerning capabilities to generate harmful content when
manipulated. While techniques like safety fine-tuning aim to minimize harmful
use, recent works have shown that LLMs remain vulnerable to attacks that elicit
toxic responses. In this work, we introduce the Proxy-Guided Attack on LLMs
(PAL), the first optimization-based attack on LLMs in a black-box query-only
setting. In particular, it relies on a surrogate model to guide the
optimization and a sophisticated loss designed for real-world LLM APIs. Our
attack achieves 84% attack success rate (ASR) on GPT-3.5-Turbo and 48% on
Llama-2-7B, compared to 4% for the current state of the art. We also propose
GCG++, an improvement to the GCG attack that reaches 94% ASR on white-box
Llama-2-7B, and the Random-Search Attack on LLMs (RAL), a strong but simple
baseline for query-based attacks. We believe the techniques proposed in this
work will enable more comprehensive safety testing of LLMs and, in the long
term, the development of better security guardrails. The code can be found at
https://github.com/chawins/pal. | [
0.0168686975,
0.0974535495,
-0.012965274,
0.0568817705,
-0.0338619389,
-0.021519538,
0.0213905666,
0.0295317732,
0.0075836275,
-0.0371165983,
-0.0085158646,
-0.0379558057,
0.0012757066,
0.0146680735,
0.0935452282,
0.0295175128,
0.0380242281,
-0.0315310135,
-0.0410223939,
-0.0313989259,
-0.01495519,
-0.0121934908,
0.0309433099,
0.0141546233,
0.0297649186,
0.003605827,
-0.019110173,
0.0240880214,
-0.0002485756,
-0.0393777899,
-0.0049588336,
0.0150311869,
0.0028196671,
0.0698788837,
0.0000023836,
-0.0125004724,
-0.0427250043,
0.0503051914,
-0.0462679304,
0.0671649873,
0.0214218143,
0.0071251839,
-0.0522909835,
0.0416907333,
-0.0062932465,
0.0070576486,
0.028717136,
0.0227400418,
0.0768447444,
0.1192300618,
0.0063368357,
-0.008308202,
0.0482181907,
-0.0421431251,
0.0025026214,
-0.0522151776,
0.0263229255,
-0.0188433528,
0.0192826614,
0.04872071,
0.0170688536,
-0.0120214587,
0.0057758093,
-0.0188538916,
-0.0898656696,
0.0033430143,
-0.0297548119,
0.0048027681,
0.0284021329,
0.0303516351,
-0.0526723899,
-0.0058171353,
0.0244585034,
0.0277449396,
-0.0117282886,
-0.0120082954,
-0.0115438057,
0.0452326648,
0.0126771992,
-0.0010613856,
0.0242968332,
-0.0437921621,
0.065339461,
-0.0062206513,
-0.0033497594,
0.047355324,
0.041711513,
-0.0246627312,
0.0150657604,
-0.0570779331,
-0.0212934036,
-0.0526993908,
-0.0093634604,
-0.013708666,
0.0071604783,
0.0267306771,
-0.0522999503,
-0.0374950692,
0.0425171852,
-0.0597665869,
0.032999225,
0.0296423472,
0.0018783151,
0.0273071676,
0.0044485163,
0.0307578091,
-0.074052617,
0.0514881313,
0.0164084733,
0.0190622546,
0.0216906965,
-0.0111202206,
0.0026022322,
0.0449867919,
-0.0150022106,
0.0170617569,
-0.0475569218,
0.0253603067,
-0.0176239368,
0.0473510362,
-0.0113794021,
-0.0115964301,
0.0153944483,
0.0015304361,
0.0357069299,
-0.0323096663,
0.003457909,
-0.0314345546,
-0.0100389533,
-0.0848692134,
-0.0380352139,
0.0238226317,
-0.0481221527,
-0.0390090421,
0.0092311148,
0.1318684369,
0.0156828798,
-0.0385531969,
-0.0635412857,
-0.0932190642,
-0.0012655196,
-0.0151713099,
0.0006885089,
-0.0577433966,
-0.0319909081,
-0.0226539727,
-0.0220671669,
-0.0675229281,
0.0009312325,
0.0065422892,
-0.0186898839,
0.0391675048,
0.0151974214,
-0.0248814635,
0.0038365235,
0.030023003,
-0.0151174422,
0.0898181349,
-0.0166341569,
0.0389097221,
0.0285083633,
0.0106978845,
0.0158897024,
0.0593857951,
0.0166680031,
0.0534389168,
-0.0476883762,
0.0103887813,
0.0613037236,
-0.0079309307,
-0.0218703765,
0.07994093,
-0.0343511887,
-0.09025231,
0.0845268369,
0.0203475449,
-0.0413194373,
0.0431370959,
-0.012320755,
0.0150237838,
0.001302098,
-0.0296000838,
-0.056976106,
-0.0217091776,
-0.0837071463,
-0.0321993716,
0.022584049,
0.0374674425,
-0.0036387518,
-0.001431644,
-0.0018726181,
-0.0262843538,
0.0023165017,
0.0078955488,
0.0280308854,
0.0126180248,
-0.0210729353,
0.0297376607,
0.0309133846,
-0.0237393249,
-0.0129650738,
-0.0842999518,
-0.0194674954,
-0.0004276266,
0.0795781016,
-0.0135915028,
-0.0157313608,
-0.0082130656,
-0.0245075151,
0.0313720964,
-0.0148832537,
0.0543115251,
-0.0079793595,
-0.0113370828,
-0.008005525,
0.0031044821,
0.0330286697,
0.0070751109,
0.0496741235,
0.0137739722,
0.0167020783,
-0.0292518865,
-0.0372505151,
0.0064704916,
0.0048656007,
-0.0518099666,
-0.0037793713,
0.0061291461,
0.0217438303,
-0.0171440113,
-0.0370413885,
0.0227104258,
0.0560942404,
-0.0009147835,
-0.006371323,
-0.0421914719,
0.0033221347,
0.0394272096,
0.027657859,
-0.0232492406,
0.0319108628,
0.0640978664,
-0.0368111953,
-0.0037670929,
0.0573612414,
-0.0500334278,
0.0442122631,
0.0128902523,
0.0195099562,
-0.013910057,
0.0339282006,
-0.0388244465,
0.0020334471,
0.0061016427,
0.0026499191,
-0.0026137035,
0.0166509002,
0.0227900762,
-0.0160051826,
-0.0617506132,
0.0326954275,
-0.0320568532,
0.0218939167,
-0.0069845133,
0.0240298677,
-0.0112178177,
-0.0273520667,
-0.0416461267,
0.0220751539,
-0.0311147589,
0.0537054576,
0.0227296986,
0.0186436661,
-0.0435898453,
-0.009855493,
-0.0016289398,
-0.0343337841,
-0.030169908,
0.0146724312,
-0.0055393144,
-0.0060377652,
-0.0405860953,
-0.011349041,
-0.0344671756,
-0.0029067087,
0.0777526796,
-0.0241445918,
0.00276114,
-0.0088241743,
0.0260713343,
-0.0110080652,
0.0397373103,
-0.0278752148,
-0.078424342,
0.0230392553,
-0.0214687865,
-0.0506024212,
0.0712000132,
0.0400156602,
0.0297448095,
0.0522266626,
0.0081155151,
-0.0563444644,
-0.0154091762,
0.0133217573,
-0.0742154419,
-0.0615108833,
-0.01290859,
0.0275289007,
0.063281253,
0.020395508,
-0.0078226682,
-0.0333484039,
0.015021258,
-0.0036788082,
0.006784779,
0.0012619052,
-0.012193962,
-0.026856605,
-0.0306722876,
0.0222513098,
-0.0719502792,
0.0489938669,
-0.0507137254,
0.0199882407,
-0.0040678144,
-0.0413691252,
0.0078793829,
0.0232810639,
-0.0167424269,
0.0411472134,
0.0057155564,
-0.004091599,
-0.0318299979,
-0.0111011444,
0.0536834337,
-0.0480312705,
0.0039747935,
-0.0354516096,
0.0067248638,
-0.0110811125,
-0.0294069126,
-0.0411399081,
-0.0273782499,
-0.0375469998,
-0.0251210909,
0.011077065,
-0.0535534285,
-0.0141962115,
-0.0156941619,
0.0415734909,
0.0105500082,
-0.0420527495,
0.0005061991,
-0.0145704187,
-0.0204875879,
0.0412992686,
-0.0699527636,
0.0172294844,
-0.0044684182,
0.0252366252,
0.107403405,
0.0626744032,
-0.0121292984,
-0.017621167,
0.004126342,
0.037636891,
-0.0062781498,
-0.0144425388,
0.0396038145,
-0.0047272816,
-0.0485941358,
-0.0216461532,
0.0357821174,
0.0159931257,
-0.0544917062,
0.0046670176,
-0.0008258392,
0.0403660014,
0.0124948723,
0.0489417873,
-0.0819387808,
-0.0280756112,
0.0265896451,
0.0562740713,
-0.02629227,
-0.0214414522,
-0.0178992059,
-0.116917409,
0.0097029973,
0.0404637419,
-0.009731668,
0.0124488259,
-0.0469579324,
-0.0076763183,
0.021033952,
0.0557104833,
0.0144001888,
0.0124942884,
-0.022843454,
0.0067220689,
0.0118905986,
-0.0192824807,
0.0183272697,
-0.0307009984,
0.0484205037,
0.0483148582,
-0.0258210413,
-0.025255641,
0.0113918604,
0.0897617191,
-0.0162321981,
-0.0542695113,
0.0173412766,
0.0027362769,
0.004658191,
-0.0279686376,
0.0350593068,
0.0050647031,
-0.0264180079,
0.0144114997,
0.0110327033,
0.0415073037,
-0.0139973015,
-0.0034340215,
-0.0105631612,
-0.0104121426,
0.015006558,
0.053531304,
-0.0055680186,
-0.0270339809,
-0.034898404,
-0.0930168331,
-0.005689308,
-0.0176870022,
-0.0620051548,
0.0216233656,
0.0111464858,
-0.0015240955,
-0.0133074662,
0.0569309965,
-0.0306770764,
0.0284879673,
0.0199524797,
0.0111741116,
0.0140811754,
-0.0143637313,
-0.0285867639,
-0.0194776002,
-0.0453330502,
0.0305609833,
-0.0900482386,
0.0280203503,
0.0220191386,
-0.0117315911,
-0.0355257578,
0.022162281,
-0.0793355554,
-0.1003773436,
0.0052368706,
0.0538429357,
0.0248188842,
-0.0084714349,
-0.0255699959,
-0.0665183365,
0.0489033721,
0.031233158,
-0.0244059246,
0.0315642916,
0.0644665211,
-0.0535752587,
0.0146485036,
0.0249538086,
-0.0524628274,
-0.0353318527,
0.0675525814,
-0.0086098965,
-0.0160549898,
0.0166516267,
-0.0002954223,
0.0749247596,
0.0134852435,
-0.0136552416,
0.0169086605,
0.0298562832,
0.0637706295,
-0.0317192338,
-0.0066602216,
0.0039086244,
0.0190939941,
-0.0073378603,
-0.0285482015,
0.0172204319,
-0.023972936,
0.0201730542,
0.0253738631,
-0.0050081168,
0.0210959725,
-0.0191177186,
-0.0237663649,
0.0942915604,
-0.012351797,
0.0122089395,
0.0305710323,
0.0398959666,
0.0601431243,
-0.031944111,
0.0111396369,
0.0067614727,
-0.0251250658,
-0.0067609004,
0.0415210687,
-0.0335995778,
-0.0495035537,
0.0034847485,
0.0443259403,
0.0271602999,
0.0147009855,
0.0142820673,
-0.0213834941,
0.0096430145,
-0.0327161551,
-0.029371148,
-0.0269265398,
-0.0313082449,
0.0323887095,
-0.0057595153,
0.0113671208,
0.0560649335,
0.0516646802,
0.0562983267,
0.0590174496,
0.0262585189,
-0.011362737,
-0.0176055599,
-0.0383181609,
0.0159707423,
0.0321029164,
-0.0403603576,
-0.0602381602,
-0.0489343591,
-0.0807104707,
-0.0374131724,
-0.006586181,
0.0120603899,
0.0132302698,
-0.0087394956,
0.0469243973,
0.0129331835,
0.0325862393,
-0.0672870427,
0.0194630213,
-0.0207762066,
-0.0638996288,
0.0728472024,
-6.809248657e-33,
0.0221927688,
-0.0351830944,
-0.0418793187,
-0.0240383446,
0.0008514695,
-0.0033121982,
-0.0106243109,
-0.001603948,
-0.0179419797,
-0.0343194753,
-0.0210137349,
0.002446068,
0.007468984,
0.0418276004,
-0.0409519486,
-0.0268185567,
-0.0279387124,
0.0127028869,
-0.0230475329,
0.0341208987,
0.0629287139,
-0.0024741013,
0.0142606907,
-0.0287313499,
-0.0169149265,
-0.0058266521,
-0.0249901153,
0.0137843601,
-0.0424246341,
0.0648629144,
0.0203290861,
0.0333453305,
-0.0155379167,
-0.0152893243,
0.0280037299,
0.004137618,
0.0169856846,
0.0122058326,
-0.0040395479,
-0.0086087771,
0.0257280786,
-0.0730193928,
0.0321596488,
0.0127406437,
0.0093353726,
0.000690855,
-0.0328781195,
-0.0199001525,
-0.0255248994,
-0.0083041666,
0.0202486683,
0.0188767556,
-0.028900357,
0.0389917977,
0.0061687464,
-0.0265783723,
0.0354991034,
0.0171936397,
0.0021648121,
0.033714097,
0.0259231981,
0.0433527716,
0.0545237884,
0.0300634913,
0.015853975,
0.0386166908,
-0.0211869795,
-0.0109384703,
0.00021667,
0.0049009048,
0.0067894501,
0.0037937015,
0.0171625596,
0.0299648978,
0.0237929914,
-0.0411795601,
-0.0667635351,
0.0135646453,
0.0106967269,
0.0324112512,
0.0642853901,
-0.0033247583,
-0.0685667098,
-0.0105169034,
-0.0339697897,
-0.014220844,
-0.0318567827,
-0.029309826,
0.006616699,
0.0328574367,
-0.0370196551,
-0.0380468965,
0.0035939154,
-0.0388784297,
0.0108092641,
0.0375186093,
-0.0346627012,
-0.0299398322,
-0.0173886549,
0.0144973146,
0.0429781079,
-0.0156668779,
-0.0197794586,
-0.0825253502,
0.0076149483,
-0.0042499774,
-0.0214170665,
0.0288148485,
-0.0803540498,
-0.0145581365,
-0.0385877155,
0.0486470871,
0.0180674288,
0.0017513763,
0.0004553829,
-0.0081921658,
0.0208705701,
0.0043672235,
0.0490098782,
0.0224016272,
-0.0360176563,
0.0187158603,
-0.0240755994,
0.0178314764,
-0.0063422211,
0.0266837794,
0.0104917856,
0.0651782006,
0.0603556484,
-0.0684799775,
-0.0043317964,
-0.0266963895,
3.27e-7,
0.0191278793,
0.0378354155,
0.0121778408,
0.0505344048,
0.0012570502,
0.0673545301,
-0.0052817622,
0.0616004206,
-0.0172259267,
-0.0260466654,
-0.0290129501,
0.0020738908,
0.0465234071,
0.0002643077,
-0.0524986871,
0.0453504138,
-0.0703776404,
0.0030869893,
-0.0807738528,
-0.0416985601,
0.0316054188,
0.1187331602,
0.0093888137,
-0.0439388007,
-0.0277715083,
-0.059053693,
0.0317788497,
-0.0332042389,
-0.0354894474,
0.0021045504,
0.0301968958,
0.05525361,
0.0046946309,
0.0253166612,
-0.0380049758,
-0.0117007066,
-0.0451142788,
0.063027285,
0.0457627475,
-0.0474559404,
-0.0133344494,
-0.0585652366,
-0.0015903233,
-0.032209225,
0.0678807274,
0.0558878668,
-0.0128243128,
-0.0180611722,
-0.0152683919,
-0.072024554,
0.0310589094,
-0.0719787553,
-0.0028516522,
0.0289276112,
-0.0076128314,
-0.0034146397,
0.0396698229,
-0.0669042468,
-0.0461360924,
-0.0073924027,
-0.0258611199,
-0.0543322451,
-0.019312311,
0.0464857183,
-0.0060034008,
0.0295928214,
0.0142751653,
3.406418014e-34,
-0.0111671602,
-0.0548938923,
-0.0028781879,
0.0128108384,
0.0544753931,
0.0050709173,
0.0025455402,
0.0138116637,
-0.0230209157,
-0.0566735044,
-0.0309843812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09668v1 | How to Train Data-Efficient LLMs | 2024-02-15T02:27:57 | 2024-02-15T02:27:57 | Noveen Sachdeva, Benjamin Coleman, Wang-Cheng Kang, Jianmo Ni, Lichan Hong, Ed H. Chi, James Caverlee, Julian McAuley, Derek Zhiyuan Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The training of large language models (LLMs) is expensive. In this paper, we
study data-efficient approaches for pre-training LLMs, i.e., techniques that
aim to optimize the Pareto frontier of model quality and training resource/data
consumption. We seek to understand the tradeoffs associated with data selection
routines based on (i) expensive-to-compute data-quality estimates, and (ii)
maximization of coverage and diversity-based measures in the feature space. Our
first technique, Ask-LLM, leverages the zero-shot reasoning capabilities of
instruction-tuned LLMs to directly assess the quality of a training example. To
target coverage, we propose Density sampling, which models the data
distribution to select a diverse sample. In our comparison of 19 samplers,
involving hundreds of evaluation tasks and pre-training runs, we find that
Ask-LLM and Density are the best methods in their respective categories.
Coverage sampling can recover the performance of the full data, while models
trained on Ask-LLM data consistently outperform full-data training -- even when
we reject 90% of the original dataset, while converging up to 70% faster. | [
0.0012099148,
0.0897126347,
0.009520269,
0.0332677178,
-0.0332525596,
0.0171417538,
0.0062423348,
0.013047534,
-0.0262791831,
-0.0668589249,
-0.0455482155,
-0.0570006184,
-0.0107131228,
-0.0132448524,
0.0192701612,
-0.0207782947,
0.0355742425,
-0.049125161,
-0.0205367468,
-0.018445408,
-0.0127755133,
0.0411102027,
-0.014872469,
0.0016897009,
0.0052467478,
0.0017528732,
-0.0123243351,
0.0225916877,
-0.0184414517,
-0.0229597911,
0.0145241693,
0.0607927069,
0.0334203988,
0.0044267923,
0.0000020771,
-0.0437836833,
-0.0100342724,
0.0118374117,
-0.0631216466,
-0.0049928976,
0.043714378,
-0.0105313407,
0.0138342464,
0.0275909472,
0.0020759746,
-0.0090536196,
0.0347135402,
0.0193074122,
0.0246884245,
0.1004996076,
0.0044794977,
-0.0172408912,
0.0087884655,
-0.0213084668,
0.0089513566,
-0.0127314935,
0.0004259807,
0.0163304936,
0.0164015498,
0.0186159685,
-0.0284005422,
0.0354157388,
0.0182891414,
0.0313650332,
-0.004557794,
0.0285729263,
-0.041515585,
-0.021168083,
0.0081327725,
0.062334504,
-0.0415656157,
-0.012950086,
0.0004560209,
-0.0282280315,
-0.0387762301,
-0.0068517723,
-0.044474382,
0.0207742061,
0.0405800417,
0.048471842,
-0.0093822097,
-0.0029224963,
0.061002247,
0.0324654803,
-0.0532972403,
0.0328148976,
0.0151268514,
-0.0185216032,
0.0239327867,
0.0222115777,
-0.029203346,
-0.0432812572,
-0.0431054942,
0.0280284975,
-0.0505087748,
0.0307347141,
-0.042120792,
-0.029449055,
0.0242521036,
0.0115467487,
0.0483502597,
0.0144405821,
-0.0372030102,
0.0521035977,
-0.00353306,
-0.0048118816,
0.0314784087,
0.0330826305,
-0.0311951432,
-0.025360534,
-0.0484435149,
0.0271082185,
-0.021495115,
0.0452623889,
-0.0138564333,
-0.0043859002,
-0.0358244851,
0.0105955973,
-0.0061418978,
-0.0074590952,
0.0279936288,
-0.0021476338,
-0.0400801487,
-0.0182813741,
-0.0194483716,
0.0189060159,
-0.0247448478,
0.0329230167,
0.0052162074,
-0.0696574375,
-0.0261957869,
0.0376473814,
0.0081845885,
-0.0415505171,
0.0481536426,
0.0654647797,
0.003304732,
-0.087506406,
-0.0648510754,
0.0073379362,
-0.0147521105,
-0.0786251798,
-0.0119681498,
-0.095583491,
0.029414732,
-0.0041842074,
0.0194439385,
-0.0266977083,
0.0031922732,
0.0278391708,
-0.0157225318,
0.0643625632,
-0.0128834462,
0.041356694,
-0.0168589484,
-0.0199266467,
-0.0053296383,
0.1250358969,
0.0331895202,
-0.0138332034,
0.0269129816,
0.0166402869,
0.0152988341,
0.0311671123,
0.0275060702,
0.0452377796,
-0.0122771971,
0.0239807684,
-0.0177038722,
0.016297292,
0.0476141647,
0.0391638391,
-0.0509171896,
-0.0065281834,
0.0495920256,
0.0355950892,
0.0210687891,
-0.0352357887,
0.0389218293,
0.0209020991,
-0.0268186741,
-0.0222900622,
-0.0418954454,
0.0034828486,
-0.0122122029,
0.014835895,
0.0324276723,
0.0171856992,
-0.0482365452,
-0.0331570879,
-0.0454040654,
-0.0185637325,
0.0028184317,
0.0675695166,
0.06813813,
-0.0014280286,
-0.0252462942,
0.099285692,
0.0389784463,
-0.0271795858,
-0.0104983253,
-0.050385993,
0.0247080475,
0.0402426012,
0.0342985466,
-0.0247280616,
-0.0194026642,
-0.0182412192,
0.0506121442,
0.0074721184,
0.027466923,
-0.0068631545,
0.0565976687,
-0.0745917335,
-0.0453456007,
-0.0111141875,
0.0294501539,
0.0180204865,
0.0420436077,
0.0132233026,
0.0245334078,
-0.0806057602,
-0.0667634606,
0.0374789573,
-0.0402603075,
-0.0304173119,
0.022404952,
0.0135644535,
0.0336197242,
0.0008268811,
-0.0295649711,
-0.0066236407,
0.0021282085,
-0.0334825963,
0.0117349429,
-0.0350508317,
-0.041536659,
-0.0508311167,
0.011354221,
-0.0388289653,
-0.0126981838,
0.036672283,
-0.0636013299,
-0.047451742,
-0.0112547977,
-0.0224430077,
0.0047450303,
-0.0830365345,
0.0215357896,
-0.0066561638,
0.0164304636,
-0.0411900729,
0.0621016696,
-0.0203267168,
0.0241035968,
0.0191521011,
0.0030363149,
0.0363581777,
-0.0722598284,
-0.0370729752,
0.0107075507,
-0.0130037479,
0.0404277407,
0.0223342981,
0.0332076624,
-0.029886527,
-0.0039477921,
-0.097131677,
0.0240798425,
-0.0587399267,
0.0057175644,
-0.0013443993,
0.0080997767,
-0.0078334101,
-0.0086682327,
-0.0272672921,
-0.0260780361,
0.0204175748,
0.0233580973,
0.0125870183,
0.0099857859,
-0.0025110631,
-0.0221787784,
-0.0210262556,
0.0166475587,
0.0352251232,
-0.0555957332,
0.0204657335,
-0.0321414024,
0.0436836518,
-0.0165718459,
0.0064744498,
0.00241835,
-0.0289814305,
-0.0017750412,
-0.0384065174,
-0.0388081037,
0.038425561,
-0.0076198876,
0.0001525619,
0.0552971885,
0.0143988384,
-0.0628903434,
0.0226065032,
-0.0157382041,
0.0081985947,
-0.0267326236,
-0.0270857904,
0.0079223523,
0.061365068,
-0.0128227742,
-0.032310009,
-0.0422162861,
-0.0347726941,
-0.0182610508,
-0.0145212673,
-0.0237662513,
0.0481149741,
-0.0014029953,
0.0287899505,
-0.0441853143,
-0.0452338904,
0.0449857526,
-0.0420629419,
0.0011400762,
-0.0400053598,
0.0009381609,
-0.0383687019,
0.0560795851,
0.0197174102,
-0.0051567326,
0.0155818919,
-0.0108143473,
-0.0666025653,
-0.0256490782,
0.016402958,
-0.0112019759,
0.0666839033,
-0.0590852536,
0.0311003868,
-0.01009141,
-0.0296076927,
-0.0437812991,
-0.0203964524,
-0.0350894481,
0.0335493796,
-0.0115647167,
0.0055505368,
-0.0328448899,
-0.0223128181,
-0.0153051279,
0.0591748357,
-0.0004517165,
0.0144694271,
-0.0074310028,
0.000940755,
0.0622346476,
0.0028018865,
0.0021442648,
-0.0555732138,
0.006125072,
0.0249812994,
0.0142182996,
0.0336374268,
-0.0280623864,
0.0141567029,
0.0423909724,
-0.0109078623,
-0.0194747839,
0.0359804891,
0.0725789741,
-0.0266551003,
-0.0090132914,
0.1328770071,
0.0007566297,
-0.0216844268,
0.0108032599,
0.0248227287,
0.0444181785,
0.0428300016,
0.0262082927,
-0.0875213072,
-0.0464365669,
0.0068197348,
0.0251258761,
-0.0095168268,
-0.0101662371,
0.0006780784,
-0.1378017366,
0.0399340168,
-0.001069047,
-0.0227999706,
0.0017072668,
-0.0357597955,
0.0162286106,
-0.0412440933,
0.0517667606,
-0.01914059,
-0.0084040202,
-0.0074218595,
0.0456220619,
-0.0002481068,
-0.0928552672,
0.0487386771,
-0.0312957279,
0.039352648,
0.0669771954,
0.0132083511,
-0.0060928846,
-0.0248314776,
0.0139402291,
0.0073869377,
-0.0029102152,
0.0012099673,
0.0614887476,
-0.0014584273,
-0.007045113,
0.0503122918,
0.0411652587,
-0.0176117998,
0.0036859587,
0.0022385854,
0.0664481521,
-0.032883808,
0.0049246675,
0.0091265328,
-0.035851147,
0.0324912369,
0.0803855136,
0.0463886373,
-0.0174932051,
-0.0229864791,
0.0029845312,
-0.0409158543,
-0.0887353793,
-0.0050247908,
0.0638277903,
-0.0300244223,
-0.0308973249,
-0.0347822942,
-0.0228779782,
0.0566584542,
0.0594216511,
-0.0222603716,
0.000315282,
-0.0205838066,
0.0100205494,
-0.0217243787,
0.0422160253,
-0.0738499388,
0.022115089,
-0.0648730099,
-0.0286825169,
-0.0147598879,
-0.0161784198,
-0.0068464605,
-0.0131028155,
-0.0994162187,
-0.0648672134,
-0.0084468443,
0.0625580847,
0.0192822348,
0.0676630363,
-0.0089275781,
-0.0657250732,
0.0799898133,
0.0247014966,
-0.0281516835,
0.0206850991,
0.0461501591,
-0.0525690205,
-0.0061589349,
0.0540258363,
-0.0601431392,
0.0265286043,
0.0420334712,
0.0413346477,
-0.0320783779,
0.0120631438,
-0.0061493646,
0.0204754192,
0.0321199261,
-0.0300641488,
0.0020278806,
-0.0277732424,
0.0320479833,
0.0121650565,
0.0059688264,
-0.0496029146,
0.0097984802,
0.0141777107,
-0.0270186681,
-0.0164687242,
0.0037479696,
-0.0249314792,
0.0489825495,
-0.0196174812,
0.0201577116,
0.0018818825,
-0.0254475083,
0.0343737416,
0.0020342292,
-0.0216187313,
0.0092791785,
-0.0036545203,
0.0172442049,
0.0091612665,
0.0328140929,
0.0028829302,
0.0436250828,
-0.0292008594,
-0.0116049349,
-0.0485294536,
-0.0552501343,
-0.0190995466,
0.0324749313,
0.0702347979,
-0.0557770319,
0.0391850807,
-0.0089259297,
-0.0039851018,
-0.0351457782,
0.0322547071,
-0.0067145629,
-0.0126221711,
0.0177823231,
0.041282922,
-0.0041000117,
-0.0073358142,
0.0922526866,
0.021264527,
0.0592768006,
-0.0042243013,
0.0060710302,
-0.0418181568,
-0.0233932827,
0.0199883394,
0.0192530975,
-0.0214504097,
0.0165169053,
-0.0205877051,
-0.0973815471,
0.0213606674,
-0.0009882478,
-0.0155685535,
-0.0122262677,
0.0594025888,
0.0581062734,
-0.0119773978,
0.0312198084,
-0.041989699,
-0.0240541138,
-0.0008122621,
-0.0130097913,
-0.016683368,
-6.498468522e-33,
0.0068702972,
0.0246939808,
0.0282728914,
-0.0641315952,
-0.0119224703,
0.0140031567,
-0.0151264332,
-0.0061578951,
-0.0442131273,
0.0129602756,
-0.0089684147,
0.0228531584,
0.0149219241,
0.0659830645,
0.0061962642,
-0.0130245602,
0.0448306054,
-0.0161952693,
-0.0263902191,
-0.0079234075,
0.0090200081,
0.0319710933,
0.0555342846,
0.0007267443,
-0.0139611689,
0.0066957562,
0.0022933329,
0.0325506851,
0.0057395822,
0.0627910793,
0.0149209481,
0.0424659438,
0.0121920547,
-0.0549238585,
-0.0338074565,
-0.0322454423,
-0.0626897961,
-0.0570896789,
0.0205913112,
0.0247946996,
-0.0153428977,
-0.0145133613,
0.0194383133,
-0.0156776011,
0.0208926052,
-0.0259798393,
0.0048061837,
-0.0424835198,
-0.0494502224,
-0.0169087891,
-0.0181187633,
0.0427499637,
0.0019982359,
-0.0325010158,
0.0356066041,
0.00175274,
-0.0177804623,
0.0321285725,
-0.0101982122,
-0.018089544,
0.0423510261,
0.0547268987,
0.0420323312,
0.0491203889,
0.0081105158,
0.0742378831,
-0.0187511612,
-0.0092316587,
0.0029913082,
0.0062992899,
0.0537740402,
0.0586700737,
-0.0147473086,
0.0534042232,
0.0466095135,
0.0055957376,
-0.1058208421,
0.0208197013,
0.0047334353,
0.0231676716,
0.0171129629,
0.0105854711,
-0.0291370396,
-0.0409852453,
-0.057178013,
-0.0044553312,
-0.0213958044,
-0.0317658186,
0.020943936,
0.0337870978,
-0.0379640423,
-0.0142678618,
0.06101631,
-0.047584787,
-0.0415994152,
0.0120044155,
-0.0273286216,
-0.0049162535,
0.0117903119,
0.0304805133,
-0.0512996092,
-0.0474391952,
-0.0056256326,
-0.0056607616,
0.0186921582,
-0.0135064339,
0.0683470964,
0.0377527326,
-0.0513248183,
-0.0173115004,
-0.039839372,
0.0245381203,
-0.0249958001,
0.0678833872,
0.0185808167,
0.0290914997,
0.0045119757,
0.0795911029,
-0.0129099563,
-0.0492133647,
-0.0158052817,
-0.009778915,
-0.0116237365,
0.0256763212,
-0.0400151126,
0.0008327274,
-0.041750133,
-0.0595174618,
0.0382410772,
-0.0421290882,
-0.0147605287,
0.0228995942,
2.671e-7,
0.0424841903,
0.0084019369,
-0.0258522462,
0.049240049,
-0.0203360319,
0.0151432268,
-0.0290219989,
-0.00032076,
-0.0170007423,
-0.0429267511,
0.0216990896,
0.0537043549,
0.0819286406,
0.0429603718,
-0.1203297973,
0.0339395367,
-0.0357550532,
-0.0024305864,
-0.0387567468,
-0.0359577574,
0.0359142795,
0.1036829352,
0.0103043457,
-0.0278680641,
0.0154856686,
0.0000335532,
0.0531490892,
-0.0206343681,
0.0004774153,
0.0180464182,
0.0405562967,
0.032126531,
0.0202802662,
0.0099713365,
-0.0269684568,
0.0172069203,
-0.0198992379,
0.0815343559,
-0.0051721493,
-0.0442236513,
0.0004124549,
-0.0267123748,
-0.015533071,
-0.0199372396,
0.1051403061,
-0.0375498943,
-0.0146426903,
-0.0582881011,
0.0025246982,
-0.0108455792,
0.0168392546,
-0.0157341622,
-0.0000404795,
0.0190126486,
0.028714478,
-0.0453148261,
-0.0073105181,
-0.0730807632,
-0.0029534022,
-0.0020534371,
-0.0246871077,
-0.0406494252,
-0.0282304883,
-0.0224619582,
0.0316440687,
-0.0576816723,
0.0105832666,
2.512297521e-34,
0.0822162107,
0.0031760908,
0.003221248,
0.016346043,
0.0018930264,
-0.0138642024,
-0.0148217352,
-0.0166386366,
-0.0127368364,
-0.0593617707,
-0.0075971754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09666v1 | EntailE: Introducing Textual Entailment in Commonsense Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-02-15T02:27:23 | 2024-02-15T02:27:23 | Ying Su, Tianqing Fang, Huiru Xiao, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Commonsense knowledge graph completion is a new challenge for commonsense
knowledge graph construction and application. In contrast to factual knowledge
graphs such as Freebase and YAGO, commonsense knowledge graphs (CSKGs; e.g.,
ConceptNet) utilize free-form text to represent named entities, short phrases,
and events as their nodes. Such a loose structure results in large and sparse
CSKGs, which makes the semantic understanding of these nodes more critical for
learning rich commonsense knowledge graph embedding. While current methods
leverage semantic similarities to increase the graph density, the semantic
plausibility of the nodes and their relations are under-explored. Previous
works adopt conceptual abstraction to improve the consistency of modeling
(event) plausibility, but they are not scalable enough and still suffer from
data sparsity. In this paper, we propose to adopt textual entailment to find
implicit entailment relations between CSKG nodes, to effectively densify the
subgraph connecting nodes within the same conceptual class, which indicates a
similar level of plausibility. Each node in CSKG finds its top entailed nodes
using a finetuned transformer over natural language inference (NLI) tasks,
which sufficiently capture textual entailment signals. The entailment relation
between these nodes are further utilized to: 1) build new connections between
source triplets and entailed nodes to densify the sparse CSKGs; 2) enrich the
generalization ability of node representations by comparing the node embeddings
with a contrastive loss. Experiments on two standard CSKGs demonstrate that our
proposed framework EntailE can improve the performance of CSKG completion tasks
under both transductive and inductive settings. | [
0.0110682268,
0.0089613879,
0.0044036987,
0.0709226876,
-0.0176710375,
0.0117900996,
-0.0753435269,
0.0010134592,
0.044375129,
-0.0138946157,
0.0404897667,
0.0710044801,
-0.0070294812,
0.0089027034,
0.0313845687,
0.007797956,
0.0208379384,
0.0388023183,
-0.0344436578,
0.0116627449,
0.0164714232,
0.0586868338,
-0.0060285372,
0.0373669975,
-0.0132351946,
0.0142126083,
0.0016086254,
-0.0050856671,
0.0185842421,
-0.015455937,
-0.0410092957,
0.0144186113,
0.0283306427,
-0.0256554149,
0.0000019317,
-0.0253411364,
0.0247965585,
-0.0096318172,
-0.02407258,
-0.0380790681,
-0.019522097,
-0.0442306437,
0.0571599454,
-0.0214303993,
-0.0267996378,
-0.0110196564,
0.0341034979,
0.0585136861,
0.0025104764,
0.0243878141,
-0.0266468599,
-0.0178780332,
0.0204178989,
-0.0018105224,
0.0322862081,
-0.0276724081,
0.0246613137,
0.0193509646,
0.002035619,
-0.0231613852,
-0.0270879567,
0.0102381669,
0.0340099111,
0.0036747789,
0.0307517722,
0.0555400625,
-0.0578656271,
0.0114464099,
0.0378973037,
0.0985396877,
0.0190202612,
-0.0408118963,
0.0069221011,
-0.0232565831,
0.0176028684,
0.0513556264,
-0.0182162561,
0.002634892,
-0.0429155938,
0.018560227,
0.0229409207,
-0.0238892511,
0.0393128283,
0.0271589942,
-0.0232943185,
0.0601921603,
0.0164344236,
0.0036875603,
0.0058614085,
0.0361603163,
-0.0755211711,
0.010586773,
0.024623638,
0.0183165446,
-0.0225057937,
0.0207001455,
-0.0379877687,
0.0085446639,
-0.0166466031,
-0.0308551937,
-0.0205768328,
0.0542852059,
0.0003280225,
0.0383153223,
-0.0512470603,
-0.000172084,
-0.0200591907,
0.0259775091,
-0.0513213873,
-0.0540043563,
-0.0323923193,
0.0277562179,
-0.0544748679,
0.0477684662,
-0.0041535855,
-0.0304081757,
-0.0040199594,
0.0107416417,
-0.0123986211,
0.0230243262,
0.0221960861,
0.0117369192,
-0.0467976294,
-0.0259214006,
-0.0143415593,
0.0340204239,
-0.0562187396,
0.0461084843,
-0.000984228,
0.0145372469,
-0.0202581733,
-0.0067592994,
0.0794790238,
-0.0373150073,
0.0049937675,
0.011241571,
0.0188066885,
-0.0163009614,
-0.0686678961,
-0.0325230621,
0.0139408195,
-0.0210111272,
-0.0204241946,
-0.0713442266,
0.0289640706,
0.0183324963,
-0.0225849003,
0.0191505495,
0.0216962583,
0.0088544581,
-0.0443270206,
0.0782843307,
-0.0357480235,
-0.0227806251,
-0.0202709492,
0.0109538212,
-0.0239067543,
0.0344504192,
0.0227592587,
0.0087088505,
0.0241607334,
0.0098483292,
-0.0503775217,
-0.0030325141,
0.0452605784,
0.0091390954,
0.0196467973,
-0.0008757437,
-0.0313059017,
0.0360645913,
0.02244265,
0.020996958,
-0.0392237678,
-0.0124597857,
0.0259798225,
0.0518220216,
-0.0160489473,
-0.0098169567,
0.0457222201,
0.0248498097,
-0.0389464572,
0.0454571508,
-0.062220946,
0.0168344881,
-0.059528023,
0.0088665625,
0.0027257132,
-0.0008027452,
-0.0140400631,
0.0017352108,
0.0106537463,
-0.0336248092,
0.067850247,
-0.0076976065,
0.074009642,
0.0429736115,
-0.0286247712,
0.0437678657,
0.079281345,
-0.0380503908,
0.023437297,
0.0233845674,
0.0277424455,
0.0326266252,
0.0348014235,
0.0162897035,
-0.0521810018,
0.0068294075,
0.0001013357,
0.0458175018,
-0.0221781228,
-0.0335977338,
0.0135548711,
-0.0569645874,
-0.026769707,
0.0317675099,
-0.0160368197,
-0.0062866509,
0.0198465288,
0.0277426504,
0.0304010212,
-0.0693405271,
0.0139094256,
0.0146830287,
-0.0114205964,
0.0107840858,
-0.0176478792,
0.0136069441,
0.0241598524,
0.0025415227,
0.0369375758,
-0.0007972234,
0.014055307,
-0.0263579972,
-0.0696506277,
0.006105111,
-0.0142260343,
-0.114235647,
0.0391463898,
-0.0674222261,
-0.0426244475,
0.028450476,
-0.0506700948,
-0.0477276593,
0.0117972046,
-0.0462786481,
0.0550714135,
-0.0333402492,
-0.0615742207,
0.014047144,
-0.0367542058,
0.0169376153,
0.1000548601,
-0.0039367788,
0.035174448,
-0.034847945,
-0.0185480863,
0.0302433595,
0.0060957265,
-0.0142847495,
-0.0183602888,
-0.0120797781,
-0.0171141736,
0.0453911945,
-0.0149348052,
-0.0423447825,
0.0265757293,
-0.0931959376,
0.0174591988,
0.0267349482,
-0.0021247528,
-0.0077413372,
0.0193161368,
0.0434796773,
0.0077084173,
-0.0160581209,
0.0192077905,
0.0008838334,
0.0270966925,
0.0328624472,
-0.0138898874,
-0.0172684789,
0.0017329575,
-0.0285135154,
-0.0358522236,
0.0793746486,
0.017043611,
0.0112699391,
-0.0064187222,
0.0361110084,
-0.0410096273,
0.0112099024,
-0.0204233658,
-0.0125144236,
0.0082859127,
-0.0066456567,
0.0145667493,
0.018705247,
-0.0358898975,
0.0014977931,
0.0192070771,
-0.0048426944,
-0.0352039188,
0.0099494513,
-0.0571404546,
0.0007216994,
-0.0095560383,
-0.0038740619,
-0.0374444053,
0.0233663302,
0.0171661414,
-0.0195528474,
-0.0982014164,
-0.0259019043,
0.0049590087,
0.0345489681,
-0.0235108361,
-0.0094157839,
0.0169108417,
0.0189363565,
-0.0349376202,
0.0012533069,
0.0967217386,
-0.0083558224,
0.0033795948,
-0.0236160718,
-0.0099462168,
-0.0238402206,
0.064129822,
0.0033145691,
0.0107804807,
0.0357353128,
-0.0216857269,
-0.0307275243,
-0.0017287062,
0.0559805781,
0.0032654961,
0.04906426,
0.0140425647,
0.0334915109,
0.0068152873,
-0.0123425536,
-0.015006627,
-0.0202982761,
-0.0077864169,
0.0056930375,
0.0191371851,
-0.0187949222,
0.0033132203,
-0.0138866398,
-0.001610924,
0.0056722062,
0.0130022997,
-0.0256493744,
-0.0393798538,
0.0463167243,
0.0547917224,
0.0091156112,
0.0208807793,
0.0315885693,
-0.0354849473,
0.0535778962,
-0.0009143826,
-0.0314741321,
-0.0196886286,
0.0115523282,
-0.0167232957,
-0.0195225049,
-0.0224317964,
-0.0074490686,
0.0206679571,
-0.0379982069,
-0.007753504,
0.0652898699,
0.0058711749,
-0.0039295596,
0.0324979722,
0.0056837942,
0.0384980589,
0.0160280969,
-0.0320956074,
-0.102443479,
-0.0505317897,
0.0073382342,
-0.0046905405,
0.0195250586,
-0.0804276541,
0.0215052627,
-0.0971864462,
0.0063590761,
0.0081687886,
-0.0479468964,
-0.0619521551,
-0.0967744961,
-0.0013718936,
-0.002741578,
-0.0418889485,
-0.020400852,
0.0237965491,
0.0073646288,
-0.0112735815,
-0.0069749928,
-0.0487587787,
0.0339372605,
-0.0465074293,
0.0147919208,
-0.0271692127,
0.0551395752,
0.0128689688,
-0.0313023664,
-0.0377393961,
-0.0622150414,
-0.03452098,
-0.0084778462,
0.0090536755,
0.007118504,
0.0040673972,
-0.0491238236,
0.0467999615,
-0.0728616416,
-0.0355007537,
-0.0033019108,
0.1207567975,
-0.008871844,
-0.0388974361,
-0.0108410716,
-0.0067106374,
0.0073102927,
0.0795296133,
0.0393167101,
0.0444512852,
-0.0000618627,
-0.0155417854,
0.0107062431,
-0.016913157,
-0.0045794831,
0.015470624,
-0.0015951921,
0.0247305501,
-0.0499834642,
-0.039777752,
0.0418295041,
0.0133408345,
-0.0271658208,
0.0384011269,
0.0591980591,
-0.0414456092,
-0.0654575154,
0.0772461072,
-0.0443522222,
-0.0028404638,
0.0680324882,
0.0078573357,
0.0238677394,
0.0103620123,
-0.0285273548,
0.037267264,
-0.0226483457,
-0.0403941125,
-0.0875617191,
-0.0111108525,
0.0070661637,
0.0523216464,
-0.0506246872,
0.0143555878,
0.0432678536,
0.0391608849,
-0.0645297244,
-0.0107552856,
0.033425469,
0.0075123203,
0.0267894156,
0.0746617243,
-0.0555033982,
-0.0025339886,
-0.0071619367,
0.074763909,
-0.0295224432,
-0.0348141566,
0.008051279,
0.0208263341,
0.0421171486,
0.0035434053,
0.0394328125,
-0.0467711873,
-0.0197944157,
-0.0154523207,
-0.035093043,
-0.0460606888,
0.0051428829,
0.0395375751,
0.0083708297,
-0.0147638656,
-0.0121521279,
-0.0059396657,
0.0333048888,
-0.024033891,
-0.0316543207,
0.0512995906,
-0.0124354092,
0.0596328117,
-0.03022095,
-0.0397901088,
-0.015709199,
-0.0043227426,
-0.0181287732,
-0.0423098505,
0.0277099535,
0.0468197018,
-0.0201891866,
-0.0255180169,
-0.024179291,
-0.0355455764,
0.0229692329,
-0.0110577717,
0.0265463591,
0.0479872376,
0.0001316714,
0.0201222654,
-0.0152173704,
-0.0171076674,
0.0196034461,
0.0747994184,
-0.0120201772,
-0.0413164087,
0.0670376122,
0.0091544921,
-0.0173517261,
0.0110968249,
0.0448776931,
-0.0270724855,
0.0720273852,
0.0152309053,
-0.0351619311,
-0.028057633,
-0.0712263659,
0.0127674183,
0.0707134977,
-0.0129032712,
0.0412855074,
-0.0353321657,
-0.0759173185,
-0.0146735935,
-0.012691142,
-0.0201957002,
0.0000841156,
0.0323596336,
0.0229947865,
0.0398781896,
-0.0665029287,
0.02095991,
0.0249586366,
-0.0829360858,
-0.0115686515,
-0.0140073597,
-6.544771244e-33,
-0.0396311879,
-0.0597808063,
0.0201553237,
0.0543957949,
-0.0237198547,
0.0049636178,
-0.0622103959,
-0.0212709531,
-0.0316921286,
0.0526033826,
0.0093887988,
0.0445657261,
-0.015180598,
0.0174871329,
-0.0122103607,
-0.00687447,
-0.0070877974,
0.0482963026,
-0.0066726296,
0.0307718348,
0.0540690832,
-0.0080415197,
0.0743285939,
-0.0662899539,
0.0191676859,
-0.0312963352,
0.0255364254,
0.0244986881,
-0.0036364694,
0.0444867536,
-0.0063945674,
0.0763218701,
0.0151282996,
-0.0059947791,
0.0207056068,
0.0272244457,
-0.0969661176,
-0.0720108971,
0.0380486511,
-0.0120903682,
-0.0383367315,
-0.0064689815,
0.0394299291,
-0.005244418,
0.0356729664,
-0.0421741456,
0.0494179577,
-0.0058721281,
-0.0478939563,
-0.0365539268,
-0.0531181209,
0.0318917818,
0.0040399651,
-0.0219158344,
-0.0385995805,
-0.0013842996,
0.0069765802,
-0.031162072,
-0.0462986529,
-0.0140008004,
-0.0368882976,
-0.0041145654,
-0.0086453268,
-0.0329950675,
-0.0001725947,
0.0285820272,
-0.0541450009,
-0.0372923799,
-0.0634431541,
0.0204396453,
0.0246857628,
0.0666993707,
0.0357242599,
0.0498253219,
0.0369701721,
0.0134531343,
-0.0861774236,
0.0432769656,
-0.0160452202,
0.0508778691,
-0.0086765327,
-0.00285038,
-0.0473682918,
-0.0519661158,
-0.0356142521,
-0.0176661834,
-0.0359609723,
-0.0207959991,
-0.0115906438,
-0.0356448554,
-0.0123733487,
0.0559968762,
-0.0062166103,
-0.0470675901,
-0.00233272,
0.0828402936,
0.000218637,
-0.022114994,
-0.0003406363,
0.0381077752,
-0.0520874523,
-0.0386608727,
0.0253967457,
-0.0126660615,
0.01008562,
0.0484814793,
0.0664725602,
-0.008535441,
0.0127444826,
-0.0170160402,
-0.0274256337,
-0.0537187196,
-0.0600970276,
-0.0286705419,
0.0785664096,
0.0467991196,
0.0092145428,
0.0352410004,
0.0228191596,
0.0350415148,
-0.0101526659,
0.0203335565,
0.025451757,
0.0033554868,
0.0030309227,
-0.0081737842,
-0.0604577996,
-0.0111150183,
0.043056231,
-0.0510558262,
-0.0289367121,
0.0182673112,
2.761e-7,
0.018760182,
0.0054722931,
0.0248626973,
0.0374206714,
-0.039497871,
0.0532424226,
0.0210278574,
0.0302891526,
-0.0069547161,
-0.0446692556,
0.0225757118,
0.0378578529,
0.0042515513,
0.0569536872,
-0.0644249022,
0.0012323739,
-0.0613659397,
-0.0290064067,
-0.0489028655,
0.0024841528,
0.0848295018,
0.0540183298,
0.0714446455,
-0.0144224148,
0.0182672217,
-0.0855304897,
0.0488218889,
0.0015583353,
0.0041782078,
-0.0179603826,
-0.0064525036,
0.0354012586,
0.0018765286,
0.0707150251,
0.0073104305,
0.0291179977,
0.0262873881,
0.0158065353,
-0.0315449871,
0.0206458066,
-0.0112413606,
-0.0637790412,
0.0177102685,
-0.0358752497,
0.0924962759,
-0.0974474251,
-0.0183678437,
0.0271463133,
-0.0386422984,
-0.0070837666,
-0.0035612585,
0.0158289429,
-0.0093770679,
-0.0280294586,
0.0485646725,
-0.0005542118,
-0.0277525615,
-0.0653299391,
0.0233964194,
0.0417825654,
-0.0068182619,
-0.0458396636,
-0.0048454483,
-0.0258172881,
0.0409318171,
-0.036969725,
0.0295133479,
2.570927598e-34,
-0.0140886959,
0.0120503679,
0.0198392663,
-0.0317894742,
0.050405141,
-0.0253147241,
-0.0087306779,
-0.0017728327,
0.0448265821,
-0.0786797851,
0.0077448683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09664v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09664v4 | CodeMind: A Framework to Challenge Large Language Models for Code Reasoning | 2024-02-15T02:24:46 | 2024-04-03T06:23:48 | Changshu Liu, Shizhuo Dylan Zhang, Ali Reza Ibrahimzada, Reyhaneh Jabbarvand | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | Solely relying on test passing to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) for
code synthesis may result in unfair assessment or promoting models with data
leakage. As an alternative, we introduce CodeMind, a framework designed to
gauge the code reasoning abilities of LLMs. CodeMind currently supports three
code reasoning tasks: Independent Execution Reasoning (IER), Dependent
Execution Reasoning (DER), and Specification Reasoning (SR). The first two
evaluate models to predict the execution output of an arbitrary code or code
the model could correctly synthesize. The third one evaluates the extent to
which LLMs implement the specified expected behavior.
Our extensive evaluation of nine LLMs across five benchmarks in two different
programming languages using CodeMind shows that LLMs fairly follow control flow
constructs and, in general, explain how inputs evolve to output, specifically
for simple programs and the ones they can correctly synthesize. However, their
performance drops for code with higher complexity, non-trivial logical and
arithmetic operators, non-primitive types, and API calls. Furthermore, we
observe that, while correlated, specification reasoning (essential for code
synthesis) does not imply execution reasoning (essential for broader
programming tasks such as testing and debugging): ranking LLMs based on test
passing can be different compared to code reasoning. | [
-0.0399927534,
0.0769825354,
-0.0110240765,
0.0373210385,
-0.0484572053,
0.005066182,
-0.0234609582,
-0.0148249036,
0.0304549951,
0.0068094512,
0.0313605294,
0.0265542492,
0.0193304233,
0.0120070186,
0.0213437155,
0.0036624381,
0.0476632826,
-0.0874400586,
-0.024609236,
0.0100194672,
-0.0338584408,
0.0065407548,
-0.0101146605,
0.029810233,
0.0387239829,
-0.0512571149,
0.0022717144,
0.0440594405,
-0.0155853191,
-0.0031500899,
-0.0409644991,
0.0075036599,
-0.0110988002,
-0.0170085859,
0.0000023758,
-0.0591123402,
0.0251973476,
0.0509796254,
0.0102834348,
0.0604785047,
-0.0647787675,
0.009611561,
0.0154973669,
0.0437748879,
-0.0104122544,
0.0025480809,
0.0114816111,
-0.0353434347,
0.0502118804,
0.0426055938,
0.0214308742,
-0.020351626,
0.0045963707,
0.0226966981,
0.0478238203,
-0.0300885253,
-0.0068840049,
0.032722313,
0.0118357381,
-0.0302113686,
0.0132416924,
-0.0136550749,
0.0383325592,
-0.0044306424,
-0.0282551609,
0.0426334478,
-0.0136616053,
-0.0168040004,
0.0171012729,
0.0015648147,
-0.0583329909,
-0.0290067047,
0.020123221,
0.0101466086,
-0.0524427332,
-0.0352205709,
-0.0170286857,
0.0320675746,
-0.0160336718,
-0.0277757272,
0.0230227746,
-0.0089912871,
0.0372577049,
-0.0007486352,
-0.0710792094,
0.0911849663,
-0.0095682405,
-0.0100630764,
-0.0247232001,
-0.0251291804,
-0.0078438781,
-0.0384726934,
-0.0200403575,
0.0595729798,
-0.0091186576,
0.011247254,
0.021811299,
0.0054256408,
0.0514171235,
-0.02607405,
-0.0066615408,
0.0544368736,
-0.003761776,
0.0288945585,
-0.0648994073,
0.0859646499,
-0.0306609068,
-0.0025589981,
-0.0194910802,
0.037250936,
-0.018374607,
-0.016546743,
0.0123360036,
0.0537667386,
0.0313315727,
0.0373729728,
-0.0296716206,
0.0166353993,
-0.0384135656,
0.1052291989,
-0.0488970354,
-0.0133936182,
0.0197919123,
-0.0114910584,
0.0224803835,
-0.0311974827,
-0.0297302566,
-0.042168621,
-0.0092302999,
-0.0411296859,
-0.0151103875,
-0.0042718467,
-0.0721521452,
-0.0050433353,
0.0168878902,
0.0738357455,
0.0121335825,
0.0545903742,
-0.0158713013,
-0.0416909605,
0.0276981518,
-0.0553019755,
0.0241318792,
-0.1139672622,
-0.0375914834,
0.0391222425,
-0.000446836,
-0.0379957184,
-0.0072674709,
-0.0361871608,
-0.0068160119,
0.0397449061,
0.0356203243,
0.0150584709,
-0.0052430891,
0.0642544925,
-0.0157118794,
0.0394807346,
0.0443839505,
-0.0197372809,
-0.011377384,
-0.0290788952,
0.0585137159,
0.003392654,
-0.0206742492,
-0.0029931695,
-0.0144770993,
0.0497749038,
0.0118798409,
0.0042155078,
-0.0204401445,
0.0595068112,
0.0076412293,
0.0239801742,
-0.0368744843,
0.0173587315,
-0.0204856675,
0.0105580296,
0.0630750656,
0.0130803054,
0.0156788118,
0.001608303,
-0.0513380058,
0.0595597476,
-0.0225439258,
0.0087618846,
-0.0112885814,
0.030405432,
0.0020179446,
-0.0590506159,
0.0051605618,
0.0117850536,
0.012559779,
0.0367260054,
0.0307461061,
-0.0139538785,
-0.019233318,
0.0508380309,
0.0107222507,
-0.0611322075,
-0.033805199,
-0.0643205047,
0.0380552746,
0.0425185524,
0.04765407,
-0.0518000796,
-0.0216969345,
-0.0009046806,
0.0027957074,
-0.0347611904,
0.0405548327,
0.0225446373,
0.0098376498,
-0.0220604129,
0.0097759748,
-0.0095046619,
0.0128301894,
0.0463007875,
0.0150235603,
-0.0352416523,
0.0339161083,
-0.0296950042,
-0.0602017641,
0.014734569,
-0.0029365898,
-0.0063521382,
0.0041480227,
0.0190565623,
0.0007594781,
-0.024825925,
-0.0320001878,
0.0303305164,
0.0409182683,
-0.0175040048,
-0.0072725546,
-0.0279686805,
-0.0597610436,
-0.0111837639,
0.000989943,
-0.0284388289,
-0.0331648923,
0.0349104851,
-0.0581337139,
-0.0081996042,
0.1033321097,
-0.0052842046,
0.0105809513,
0.0233558137,
0.0350803211,
-0.0523514077,
-0.0396589004,
0.0051744613,
0.0461395122,
0.0234292094,
0.0227676816,
0.0066466657,
0.1004389077,
-0.0051437658,
0.0690091997,
-0.0032456317,
0.0442669615,
-0.0347626843,
0.0051288195,
-0.0216644667,
0.0343953036,
-0.0232069977,
-0.0261021126,
-0.0629122406,
0.0376653112,
-0.0127051119,
0.0486353636,
0.0135893961,
0.0375725552,
0.0266074445,
0.022057049,
0.0037148122,
-0.0261417273,
0.0115638431,
0.0110288123,
0.0092306007,
-0.0099238008,
-0.0717217624,
-0.000184798,
-0.0022981034,
-0.0612195246,
0.0680160448,
-0.0348654464,
0.0359660164,
-0.0554126613,
0.0511373803,
-0.0297276806,
-0.000907565,
-0.0443999469,
-0.0246912669,
0.0094559379,
-0.0601835847,
-0.0046029394,
0.0876216888,
-0.0196662433,
-0.0219962467,
0.042740982,
-0.0012221651,
-0.0580333769,
0.034499485,
0.0614374466,
-0.0202389546,
-0.0043959245,
-0.0362257622,
-0.0161173567,
0.0733856112,
-0.0178499427,
-0.0069444641,
-0.027771581,
0.030265782,
-0.0215497036,
0.0166404787,
0.009539092,
-0.0478936993,
0.0006643009,
0.0309261065,
-0.0345514826,
-0.096476078,
0.0617802851,
-0.0488461554,
-0.0186135545,
-0.0126516726,
0.0034238594,
-0.0385805406,
0.0796793178,
-0.0340630934,
0.0179763306,
-0.0208663736,
-0.0256862547,
-0.0057389308,
-0.0234775059,
0.0072818277,
-0.0438244492,
0.0792247504,
-0.0794618875,
-0.0222605504,
-0.0075041601,
-0.0280033313,
-0.0424939618,
0.014696056,
-0.0343606845,
0.0092568332,
0.0098848678,
-0.0190842766,
0.069676213,
-0.0154024772,
0.018668849,
0.0020934332,
-0.0100541292,
-0.0329451226,
0.0052331928,
-0.0627096668,
-0.0538353287,
-0.0701552331,
0.0127379624,
-0.0224462431,
0.0447936058,
0.0273582786,
0.0564523004,
0.0487280302,
-0.0736704096,
0.0092214569,
0.0044875783,
0.0047692843,
-0.0347602256,
0.0461319312,
0.0588935614,
-0.0743745714,
-0.0421593413,
0.0618392304,
0.0269296002,
0.0031028213,
0.0239795018,
-0.0249786042,
0.0555347353,
0.0657959059,
0.0661444739,
-0.058543358,
-0.0345987193,
0.0088531971,
0.0313137062,
-0.0171595812,
-0.0132586192,
-0.0205889717,
-0.0998413935,
0.018197814,
0.0317360908,
-0.0082331402,
-0.0309827533,
-0.0416656919,
-0.009409341,
0.0422648154,
-0.0649231225,
0.0543974936,
0.0115662683,
-0.0077773589,
0.0131282741,
-0.0434899367,
0.0322321467,
0.1178737506,
-0.0185524635,
-0.0078470586,
0.0703395531,
0.0031953161,
-0.0161938705,
-0.0274577979,
0.0532627068,
-0.0321681052,
0.0297655724,
-0.0517954491,
-0.0136715192,
0.0440466367,
-0.0016828477,
0.0335165374,
0.0118566649,
-0.0288766045,
-0.016228199,
0.0552722886,
0.0530860648,
-0.0141460067,
-0.0659467503,
-0.0077284374,
0.0028856345,
-0.0381589457,
0.0423058942,
0.0125316484,
-0.0024581554,
-0.0433063656,
-0.0777131915,
-0.0563443787,
-0.0414414927,
-0.0158083811,
-0.0180312973,
0.0508533604,
0.0066325581,
0.0333696157,
0.059118636,
0.0446567871,
0.0101067796,
0.0285048075,
-0.058846008,
0.0178717095,
0.0010772439,
-0.0524066538,
0.0211198777,
-0.0098206615,
0.0442462415,
0.0171502661,
0.0300680082,
0.001079404,
0.0026632634,
-0.012121723,
0.0261199735,
-0.0574516766,
-0.0510921627,
-0.0262669548,
0.0802580938,
0.0239633396,
0.0386937894,
-0.0328019299,
-0.0188059714,
-0.0443485156,
-0.0103097474,
-0.0113019776,
0.020197846,
0.0197627302,
-0.0143093318,
0.0448822789,
-0.0216496009,
-0.0618157871,
0.0036762769,
0.0451547652,
-0.0390221849,
-0.0146031594,
0.0095515363,
-0.0029778942,
0.0450381115,
-0.0020571551,
0.0307031665,
-0.016466232,
0.0114898775,
0.0203120504,
-0.0055227405,
-0.0514465123,
-0.0337460414,
0.0313569382,
0.0154137071,
-0.0008506249,
0.009274045,
0.0082856994,
-0.0047505246,
0.0307823177,
0.0267273039,
0.0508720726,
-0.0189823322,
0.0259903558,
0.0962947235,
-0.0211087782,
-0.0274977405,
-0.0173925348,
0.0006677357,
0.0373801552,
-0.0145203834,
0.0399586484,
0.0206660889,
0.0542986654,
-0.0142687056,
-0.0238066614,
-0.0352198742,
-0.1070905328,
0.0542787164,
-0.0085238125,
-0.004493562,
0.0215837453,
0.0019320215,
-0.0314111635,
0.0333306678,
-0.009695515,
0.0118445903,
-0.0243406612,
-0.0545246936,
0.0091583738,
0.0540801808,
0.0041259206,
-0.0493689217,
0.0666829497,
-0.0140804006,
-0.0006222061,
-0.0277474336,
-0.0061792624,
-0.0280016176,
0.005420927,
0.0150937028,
0.0010551041,
-0.0035531193,
-0.0381421447,
-0.0605556518,
-0.0775229409,
-0.0051369956,
0.0136483321,
0.0398668535,
-0.0121603142,
0.0113493046,
0.0790508687,
0.0299712177,
-0.0443167016,
-0.0036749977,
-0.013481413,
-0.0024045927,
-0.0438337252,
0.004545372,
-6.021454751e-33,
-0.0061594108,
-0.0135266231,
0.0095770778,
-0.0071418323,
0.0139358938,
-0.0125674997,
-0.0714488328,
-0.0049089305,
-0.0100604193,
-0.014511968,
0.0183950048,
0.0276743099,
-0.020122882,
-0.0317497291,
0.0293829888,
0.0009556683,
0.0012156202,
0.0328114517,
-0.0647117347,
0.0163555965,
-0.0155850099,
0.0120491451,
-0.0078038424,
-0.039604634,
-0.0182487108,
-0.0342721269,
0.0136585198,
0.0063148602,
-0.0667803064,
0.0201841854,
0.0366941504,
-0.0267774593,
-0.0158142727,
-0.0155901229,
0.0081292978,
-0.0085407821,
-0.0019179013,
-0.0201764852,
0.0416815355,
-0.0177000407,
-0.0282209497,
-0.059116099,
0.0593387671,
0.0653652772,
-0.0081839962,
-0.0312280878,
-0.025060283,
-0.00332707,
0.0475148782,
-0.0082069738,
-0.0401095785,
0.0230429135,
-0.0872206837,
-0.0171226412,
-0.0245472807,
0.0307896044,
-0.0350964963,
0.0368261524,
0.0441801287,
0.0161557663,
0.0058294511,
0.0035799739,
0.0651005805,
0.0030104211,
0.0013911367,
0.025103718,
0.036926344,
0.0215780232,
-0.0391816236,
0.0309117921,
0.0130955158,
0.0619214028,
0.0408499613,
-0.0190121625,
0.0065710363,
-0.0055182716,
-0.0715227947,
0.0010576292,
-0.0067986008,
0.0379413888,
0.0223781746,
-0.011889033,
-0.0481281616,
-0.031144632,
-0.0601794831,
0.0239733513,
-0.0455410928,
0.008545504,
0.0118975462,
-0.0150685292,
-0.0535006374,
-0.0147419618,
-0.0242016818,
-0.0342116803,
0.0119795939,
0.0286720339,
-0.0493960008,
-0.0048653483,
-0.01430202,
0.0389424451,
0.0114503037,
-0.0270868167,
-0.0203120429,
-0.0254932288,
0.0921365917,
0.007551983,
-0.0059153708,
0.0161512829,
-0.0506655201,
-0.0179182887,
-0.0831856653,
-0.0053684898,
-0.0081061516,
0.0023854852,
0.0017512784,
0.0378174782,
0.0264310148,
0.0050728191,
0.005660383,
-0.0285762027,
-0.0413290113,
0.0223054867,
0.0048717661,
0.0399522558,
-0.0156276785,
-0.0534491874,
-0.0305033699,
0.0317405425,
0.0256789532,
-0.0486405306,
-0.0542667843,
0.0644598007,
3.188e-7,
0.0049741049,
0.0302394256,
-0.0482203551,
0.0726606473,
0.0196803957,
0.053640049,
-0.0536985584,
-0.0339980423,
0.0484803505,
0.0012161266,
-0.0427500717,
0.0543649606,
0.0549545512,
0.0272475276,
-0.0240494087,
0.0322761275,
0.0156066157,
-0.0181612726,
-0.0613824502,
0.0117643746,
0.0301441438,
0.0088316947,
-0.0048892447,
-0.0016013115,
0.0399260633,
-0.0539926179,
-0.0177256819,
0.0093893278,
0.0144300088,
0.0247601029,
-0.0734044611,
0.0154132536,
0.0259043947,
0.023732027,
-0.0042208736,
-0.052182816,
-0.0156278834,
0.0745995343,
0.0229798462,
0.0617663004,
0.0133350044,
-0.0294274744,
0.0218726713,
-0.0627279207,
0.0662826821,
0.0346588604,
-0.0073944242,
-0.0121284109,
0.0155327739,
-0.0292889979,
-0.0193938017,
0.0172493458,
0.0318722464,
0.0115433801,
-0.0137070352,
-0.0375712924,
-0.0192863643,
-0.0185856074,
-0.1014416665,
-0.0013280162,
-0.0176819004,
-0.0540866964,
-0.0389455743,
0.0540541485,
-0.0086342013,
-0.0264502596,
0.0112832328,
3.345168559e-34,
0.006771178,
-0.0181763619,
0.0230378881,
-0.0110346256,
0.0589103438,
-0.01606014,
-0.0227340944,
0.0238729436,
-0.0119350003,
0.0201839544,
-0.0183453187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09654v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09654v2 | GPT-4's assessment of its performance in a USMLE-based case study | 2024-02-15T01:38:50 | 2024-03-26T20:12:18 | Uttam Dhakal, Aniket Kumar Singh, Suman Devkota, Yogesh Sapkota, Bishal Lamichhane, Suprinsa Paudyal, Chandra Dhakal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MA, stat.ML | This study investigates GPT-4's assessment of its performance in healthcare
applications. A simple prompting technique was used to prompt the LLM with
questions taken from the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE)
questionnaire and it was tasked to evaluate its confidence score before posing
the question and after asking the question. The questionnaire was categorized
into two groups-questions with feedback (WF) and questions with no feedback(NF)
post-question. The model was asked to provide absolute and relative confidence
scores before and after each question. The experimental findings were analyzed
using statistical tools to study the variability of confidence in WF and NF
groups. Additionally, a sequential analysis was conducted to observe the
performance variation for the WF and NF groups. Results indicate that feedback
influences relative confidence but doesn't consistently increase or decrease
it. Understanding the performance of LLM is paramount in exploring its utility
in sensitive areas like healthcare. This study contributes to the ongoing
discourse on the reliability of AI, particularly of LLMs like GPT-4, within
healthcare, offering insights into how feedback mechanisms might be optimized
to enhance AI-assisted medical education and decision support. | [
0.0402105898,
0.0045072474,
-0.0446643718,
-0.0382186659,
-0.0540644191,
0.0277460441,
-0.0141831776,
0.0168825313,
0.0381191187,
-0.0035595223,
0.0042570061,
-0.0076675895,
-0.0007701985,
-0.0077654277,
0.0124875279,
-0.0210452452,
0.0106141223,
0.026803406,
0.0210300088,
0.0202218294,
-0.0093713412,
-0.0115561644,
-0.059538465,
0.0337180756,
0.0089265266,
0.0147836627,
-0.0285524745,
-0.0085119642,
0.0190632436,
-0.0988259241,
0.0079664774,
0.0149567034,
-0.0085437065,
-0.0333307236,
0.0000022012,
-0.0687258169,
-0.0345895514,
0.0120141432,
-0.0600627251,
-0.0192896258,
0.0022688224,
0.0472190008,
0.0141775906,
0.0405474342,
-0.0296452213,
0.0358423889,
0.0127854012,
0.0035844573,
0.015848171,
0.0179786179,
-0.0218789075,
0.0187620707,
0.0193839446,
-0.0042329356,
0.017801797,
-0.0384200402,
-0.0065046595,
0.0172687043,
0.0254114792,
-0.0177174117,
0.0207095146,
0.0035603924,
0.0213716161,
0.037119925,
-0.0168413948,
0.0240283292,
0.0035830189,
-0.0054937662,
-0.0178365074,
0.0171328094,
0.0959110186,
0.0156903323,
-0.0347267836,
-0.0254170578,
0.0894615576,
0.0248176884,
-0.0542825237,
-0.0219212659,
-0.0022132739,
-0.0098729245,
-0.0276890565,
-0.0142067317,
0.0207518172,
-0.0249250159,
0.0129107218,
0.0347727425,
0.0022456667,
-0.0507147871,
0.0540512428,
0.0408727117,
0.0153843025,
0.0114260288,
0.0079325698,
0.0678770542,
-0.0517005809,
0.0149344373,
0.0360033587,
0.0574834198,
0.0573826507,
0.0054983618,
0.0368913673,
0.0241161734,
0.0052779326,
-0.0177179743,
0.0130914683,
0.0590185076,
-0.0013656376,
0.0310489815,
-0.030171033,
0.0428040586,
-0.063910909,
-0.0008133067,
0.0243284851,
0.0417183153,
0.0395371281,
0.037523143,
-0.0896955878,
-0.0043005431,
-0.0136549221,
0.0497103669,
-0.0131173218,
0.0134923533,
0.0180538576,
0.0516126193,
-0.0773495883,
0.0213842504,
0.0150844622,
0.0247377455,
-0.0006727675,
-0.0205517244,
0.0422612838,
0.0130672213,
-0.0059364405,
0.0382175669,
0.0139779476,
0.0411653817,
0.0064776139,
-0.0261635501,
-0.0548755266,
-0.033816725,
0.0056931339,
-0.0444729142,
0.0238629915,
-0.0145982746,
-0.0376071222,
0.0215172358,
-0.0012714578,
0.0047225035,
0.0280434508,
0.0180120654,
0.000685747,
0.0599382333,
-0.024608003,
0.0450298004,
0.0240707621,
0.0282042325,
-0.0112250606,
-0.0243116356,
0.0354890227,
0.0107707931,
0.0195545293,
-0.0464069471,
0.0516557395,
0.0044651697,
-0.0201395564,
-0.0054709804,
0.0262772739,
0.0275340192,
-0.0644911081,
0.0405920744,
-0.0739974007,
0.0430418663,
-0.0038491557,
0.0656079873,
0.0620038174,
0.0598735474,
0.0276566483,
-0.021810323,
-0.0238268133,
-0.0225936435,
0.0015158546,
0.0053881197,
-0.0146653624,
-0.0028483502,
-0.040229708,
0.0108612217,
-0.0346603356,
-0.0305541549,
-0.0267827213,
-0.0653988421,
-0.0531496331,
-0.017341245,
-0.0309036747,
0.0561973229,
0.0284713861,
-0.0771326646,
-0.0521763638,
0.0218093749,
-0.0049636196,
-0.0143372705,
-0.0273012258,
-0.1100239977,
0.0613015741,
0.0744967461,
0.0241554044,
-0.02157465,
-0.0506858751,
-0.0483512506,
-0.0571120642,
-0.0287544392,
0.0497920997,
-0.0309756547,
-0.0298905056,
-0.0080763791,
-0.0534251519,
0.0148660112,
-0.0082308343,
0.0311570894,
-0.0213343967,
0.042035263,
-0.0149793727,
-0.0130224619,
-0.0137963174,
0.0264290348,
-0.0147577059,
-0.0494908057,
-0.016141694,
-0.0048929611,
0.0659329444,
0.0492493771,
0.02295807,
0.0280981194,
0.0362226777,
0.0556412786,
-0.0324740298,
-0.0185486451,
-0.0087973289,
0.024994161,
0.020789165,
0.007137415,
0.0053115906,
-0.0021458385,
-0.0235115066,
-0.0271189585,
-0.0155817214,
-0.0344558731,
-0.0034897204,
-0.0185510088,
0.0281170085,
-0.0212328564,
-0.0434444398,
-0.0739229992,
-0.0113688977,
-0.0182058942,
-0.0064089159,
0.0107972063,
-0.0045475806,
0.0369229764,
-0.001184058,
0.000370154,
0.0079958215,
0.0014725827,
0.0127849346,
0.0089418972,
0.0183234569,
-0.0575831681,
0.0016808701,
-0.0934606716,
-0.0045375023,
0.0254693441,
0.0230675992,
0.0233695079,
-0.0250817295,
-0.018779736,
0.003537247,
-0.0452703796,
-0.022026822,
0.0351070054,
0.0164144076,
0.0214658752,
0.0315802246,
0.0151199754,
-0.0283037331,
0.0228120778,
-0.0338517874,
-0.0508343987,
0.0724039152,
0.0193101596,
-0.0299853291,
-0.0060163108,
-0.0194522273,
-0.0283096749,
0.0214349255,
-0.0079740817,
0.0378483124,
-0.0237033516,
-0.0316943638,
0.0270408746,
-0.0451948904,
-0.0046420963,
0.0438225716,
0.0072895219,
-0.0316457786,
0.016605122,
-0.0253714938,
-0.0445570908,
0.0205619913,
-0.0469300672,
-0.002221629,
-0.014907388,
0.042009443,
0.0245299172,
0.0064419406,
0.021833159,
-0.0419805609,
0.0399141647,
-0.0316679589,
0.0040479987,
-0.0407901928,
0.1080945581,
0.0261972081,
-0.0541551486,
0.0340626463,
0.0190054942,
0.0520830825,
-0.0651935712,
-0.0129228905,
-0.026109755,
0.0164705869,
-0.0293969512,
-0.0111610433,
-0.0033045304,
-0.0246750414,
-0.0301133487,
-0.0258046314,
-0.0186578091,
-0.0573869832,
0.0529071763,
-0.0495082438,
-0.0078708455,
-0.005267581,
-0.0057291584,
-0.0583409853,
0.0297652557,
0.0069826501,
-0.0032617869,
-0.0187497921,
0.010237799,
0.0023849953,
-0.0354853198,
0.0236052647,
0.0420177579,
-0.0344889276,
-0.0308405161,
0.0239218939,
-0.0016185615,
0.0070659961,
0.0187970884,
0.0632552505,
-0.011929146,
0.0170209277,
0.0236468818,
0.0159098506,
0.0120248003,
-0.0379476324,
-0.0036937408,
-0.010353528,
-0.0182509664,
0.000325794,
0.0480506532,
0.0405444168,
-0.0001010174,
0.0137605201,
0.0966535211,
0.0128538301,
-0.0328519754,
0.0006168745,
-0.0350600742,
-0.0455337092,
0.0101744011,
0.0023027305,
-0.0239438489,
0.0001402892,
-0.0131365042,
0.0910356417,
-0.0674783364,
-0.0146387108,
0.0471707769,
-0.068055518,
0.0755315199,
-0.0265507791,
-0.0066305446,
-0.0569252707,
-0.0002899846,
0.0278956592,
0.0137063852,
0.0362921767,
-0.0083261831,
0.0187080204,
0.0153945489,
0.0066971774,
-0.0880172327,
-0.0450939611,
0.0427321009,
0.019771304,
0.0111244703,
0.0962526053,
0.0114160804,
-0.0479647033,
-0.0585968681,
0.007970321,
-0.0083422232,
0.0027746544,
-0.0145733906,
0.0448059104,
0.038060341,
0.0434973314,
-0.0511992984,
0.0193872117,
-0.01846724,
0.0431252606,
0.0727331713,
0.0862141773,
-0.0644270629,
-0.0113241514,
-0.0294436552,
0.0071518556,
-0.0066770678,
0.015722679,
0.0219068341,
-0.0071852389,
0.0231105592,
-0.004460155,
0.0424134284,
0.0238981526,
-0.0043024039,
0.0079915784,
-0.0010789924,
0.0517213494,
-0.0335179307,
-0.0422026627,
0.0469108857,
-0.0291853957,
0.011917254,
0.0036281364,
0.0251513999,
0.0082486337,
-0.0244815834,
-0.0133418823,
0.042619165,
0.0203055646,
-0.0295896251,
-0.0018663533,
0.0480050668,
-0.0074504926,
0.0100988979,
-0.0193804447,
0.0145205958,
0.0086485427,
-0.011803275,
0.0861790776,
0.0327710174,
-0.0450669378,
0.0108804293,
0.0262780469,
0.0246096328,
-0.0128428033,
-0.0006882917,
-0.0255367719,
-0.008554332,
0.063627027,
-0.0341566019,
-0.0254609827,
0.0069901748,
-0.0019890149,
0.0155341346,
-0.0135221044,
-0.0068226052,
-0.0611219592,
0.017555315,
0.0666993782,
0.0446033254,
-0.0211677663,
0.0140414601,
-0.0058332551,
0.0169787109,
-0.0387297012,
0.024929814,
-0.007492919,
-0.0293380655,
0.0503578261,
-0.0411083959,
-0.0212187786,
-0.085456565,
-0.0829467699,
-0.0423926786,
-0.0791941136,
0.0376268327,
0.0044917348,
0.0490569957,
-0.0014805264,
-0.0268683657,
-0.0309522878,
-0.0239056703,
0.028447371,
0.0226398837,
0.0461536273,
0.1180514842,
-0.0494293123,
0.0007261105,
0.039612174,
0.0217019636,
-0.0317102261,
-0.0800112337,
-0.0123565402,
0.0197381768,
-0.0119375866,
0.0448481217,
-0.0314050615,
-0.0331791528,
0.0127597358,
-0.0134065757,
-0.0172666367,
0.0028438908,
0.0397898667,
0.0541084595,
-0.0033358689,
-0.0178312175,
-0.0224754419,
0.0226459056,
-0.0339528359,
0.0409328341,
-0.0701892674,
-0.0358728431,
-0.062966086,
-0.0379397087,
0.0479278713,
0.0121384868,
-0.0513556525,
-0.0103369812,
-0.0570702665,
-0.0146301091,
-0.0135685671,
-0.0078278612,
0.0176535882,
-0.0767868459,
0.0070709479,
0.0322274975,
-0.01788201,
-0.0353186578,
-0.0302419644,
0.0157080125,
-0.0514204241,
0.0380251333,
-0.0084382221,
-5.982704212e-33,
-0.0085991658,
-0.0445862561,
0.0265267435,
0.025253715,
-0.0032017918,
-0.0294228774,
-0.0106217843,
0.058765091,
0.0047722817,
-0.0081493175,
-0.0019193669,
-0.0109145306,
-0.0033943267,
0.0243225545,
0.0647799075,
-0.0520709492,
0.0051916679,
-0.0072318856,
0.001054031,
0.0263276566,
-0.0896417573,
0.0009406683,
0.0317492187,
-0.0595611334,
0.0538249202,
0.0011784883,
-0.0057293233,
-0.0140521638,
-0.0884923339,
0.0400489047,
0.0284268185,
0.0198257975,
0.0422363393,
-0.0251857899,
0.0254046563,
0.0271819662,
0.005061226,
-0.0570312813,
-0.0041770241,
-0.0258540008,
-0.0293995459,
-0.0162563305,
0.028090328,
-0.0200959574,
-0.0790231228,
0.014924936,
0.0244335234,
-0.0279162917,
0.0260109492,
-0.0414100364,
-0.0208127573,
0.0038140044,
-0.0242616963,
0.0136784567,
-0.0728489757,
0.0965751559,
-0.0369385406,
0.0234548729,
-0.0237653498,
-0.0058111283,
0.0557649806,
-0.0423396863,
0.0450544544,
-0.0311509836,
-0.0191801358,
-0.0103971232,
0.0104202488,
-0.0128105478,
-0.0407229662,
-0.0223169327,
-0.0351353213,
0.0271877218,
0.0957970843,
0.0296492148,
-0.027870385,
-0.0075380658,
-0.0849597752,
0.0615547858,
-0.0359718464,
0.0431058034,
0.0128676808,
-0.0307456441,
-0.0866951793,
-0.0108259423,
-0.0249867607,
-0.0471682735,
-0.015438159,
-0.0455787554,
0.0581393987,
-0.0341728069,
0.0055494895,
0.0178329945,
-0.0159085765,
0.0093371347,
0.0245979242,
-0.0822370574,
0.0195442047,
0.0487014353,
-0.0206352752,
0.0057149525,
-0.0619305819,
0.0398062617,
-0.0215552039,
0.014072787,
0.0578224063,
0.0154127441,
-0.0087051392,
-0.0231742729,
-0.0380681045,
0.0021066661,
0.0094057452,
0.0169740245,
-0.000674861,
-0.019951269,
-0.0076727695,
0.014882843,
0.0103286244,
0.0523028523,
-0.041046191,
-0.0148231285,
-0.0542268381,
-0.0610821471,
-0.0252200402,
-0.0199851301,
-0.023766065,
0.0030696313,
-0.0052480963,
0.0517804585,
-0.0112039801,
0.0006822713,
0.0014047737,
-0.0190022625,
2.846e-7,
0.0534040295,
0.0432456136,
-0.041743353,
-0.0066755931,
0.0072171618,
0.0119724134,
-0.0282232091,
-0.0485457741,
0.0719771162,
-0.0151960226,
0.0962874517,
-0.0388623178,
0.0149845425,
0.0374283455,
0.002124449,
-0.0489393286,
0.0345481373,
-0.0023871686,
-0.0206137933,
0.0613835603,
0.1072453335,
-0.0139566269,
-0.0170425139,
-0.0426290706,
-0.0122154839,
0.0366051458,
0.0114917625,
-0.0499324575,
-0.0057766405,
0.0048011737,
0.0676875934,
0.0312375221,
0.0292597394,
0.0726620033,
-0.0209575407,
-0.0414050817,
-0.0367134735,
0.0712741464,
-0.0312416852,
-0.0164728984,
0.0383181982,
-0.0005752349,
0.0725456104,
-0.0595888533,
0.0546621494,
-0.0190694556,
-0.0326022469,
0.0146338893,
-0.0134911854,
-0.0548930541,
0.0892069563,
-0.0198459178,
-0.0197124854,
-0.0134554654,
-0.0006900396,
0.0152577423,
-0.020579949,
0.0139317466,
0.0587385371,
-0.0015582946,
-0.013819159,
-0.0586201474,
0.0473958179,
-0.0405625254,
-0.0419935957,
-0.0663806573,
0.0003304303,
2.460121643e-34,
0.0092465961,
-0.0040551848,
0.0496649928,
0.0148242814,
0.0328738391,
0.0342900492,
0.0211222991,
0.0076765367,
0.0158790182,
-0.0031209365,
-0.0191489551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09642v1 | Answer is All You Need: Instruction-following Text Embedding via Answering the Question | 2024-02-15T01:02:41 | 2024-02-15T01:02:41 | Letian Peng, Yuwei Zhang, Zilong Wang, Jayanth Srinivasa, Gaowen Liu, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work aims to build a text embedder that can capture characteristics of
texts specified by user instructions. Despite its tremendous potential to
deploy user-oriented embeddings, none of previous approaches provides a
concrete solution for it. This paper offers a new viewpoint, which treats the
instruction as a question about the input text and encodes the expected answers
to obtain the representation accordingly. Intuitively, texts with the same
(implicit) semantics would share similar answers following the instruction,
thus leading to more similar embeddings. Specifically, we propose InBedder that
instantiates this embed-via-answering idea by only fine-tuning language models
on abstractive question answering tasks. InBedder demonstrates significantly
improved instruction-following capabilities according to our proposed
instruction awareness tests and instruction robustness tests, when applied to
both large language models (LLMs) (e.g., llama-2-7b) and smaller encoder-based
LMs (e.g., roberta-large). Additionally, our qualitative analysis of clustering
outcomes, achieved by applying different instructions to the same corpus,
demonstrates a high degree of interpretability. | [
0.0299283862,
0.0115019493,
-0.0183213837,
0.0463191122,
0.004164163,
0.019889079,
-0.0167407207,
0.000610928,
0.0433525406,
-0.026326796,
-0.000469162,
0.022819791,
-0.0461306609,
-0.002614781,
0.0489432029,
-0.0460357442,
0.0285949595,
-0.0069028046,
-0.0165959243,
-0.0155954016,
0.0400885977,
0.0172553416,
0.0280547868,
0.0387333706,
0.0170802921,
-0.0281502064,
-0.0305897817,
-0.018474739,
-0.0150720524,
0.007762596,
-0.0003558422,
0.0092978729,
0.0529418848,
0.0042868447,
0.0000019957,
-0.0114302859,
0.0007862892,
0.0015619701,
-0.0346536711,
0.0019728765,
0.0178937484,
-0.0164760184,
0.0358594283,
0.0333459228,
-0.0435359292,
-0.0002550477,
0.0276875794,
0.0273479093,
0.1097124517,
0.0438310206,
0.0053701401,
-0.0149404947,
0.0371327922,
0.0138260499,
0.0271063596,
-0.0099291196,
-0.0177450441,
0.003216228,
0.0272211656,
0.0726878196,
-0.0316269547,
0.0497159697,
0.0544236377,
0.0086660692,
0.0045826877,
0.0302966051,
0.0076547661,
0.0087621119,
-0.0174176544,
0.0813167021,
0.0099803293,
-0.020704234,
-0.0036773675,
0.0178266279,
0.0124098603,
0.03796345,
-0.0578589104,
0.0028582774,
0.0182436984,
-0.0005277066,
0.0314497575,
0.0427059941,
-0.0062548253,
-0.0019342896,
-0.0184970126,
0.0401232354,
0.0185889546,
-0.0432770364,
-0.0141773866,
0.014872143,
-0.0443369113,
-0.0508626774,
0.0307074524,
0.0726077333,
-0.0088259187,
0.0232973602,
-0.06680803,
-0.0085490737,
0.0421303287,
-0.0365177244,
0.0604446679,
0.0656366274,
0.0095412629,
0.0508522615,
-0.0602997169,
0.0586684383,
-0.0210275371,
0.0256311968,
-0.0559420548,
-0.0190812871,
-0.0614326596,
-0.0470991321,
-0.0404035561,
0.0388147198,
-0.0292037092,
-0.0168025494,
0.0135151111,
0.0935571119,
-0.0027134281,
0.0275079422,
-0.0292054061,
0.016851278,
-0.0098015461,
-0.0021083027,
-0.0405159481,
-0.0072143436,
-0.0997607633,
0.0059822346,
-0.016103413,
-0.021072641,
-0.0268204641,
0.0261835232,
0.0234811157,
-0.0053931782,
-0.000433248,
0.0437256433,
-0.0087506892,
-0.0072341841,
0.0041449796,
-0.0585783236,
0.0068181907,
-0.0187387355,
-0.0327858627,
-0.0638960749,
0.0600357428,
0.0276124775,
-0.0087691862,
-0.0268163551,
0.0020645123,
0.0575032979,
-0.0180742405,
0.0692266226,
0.0275571644,
-0.0082562715,
0.0436808206,
0.0295828022,
0.0117067527,
0.0342534743,
0.0250955522,
0.0099684261,
0.0510743484,
-0.0153968669,
0.0026673295,
0.0142179234,
0.0289907083,
0.0135720326,
0.033208698,
0.0728316233,
0.0034852882,
0.0134818451,
-0.0148728788,
0.0619770586,
-0.0166663863,
-0.0471345894,
0.036714524,
0.0781621337,
-0.0199655816,
-0.0077472962,
0.0550145619,
0.0378079191,
-0.0129141528,
0.0321057476,
-0.0272619631,
0.0454433784,
-0.0294695999,
-0.0010795123,
0.0546570979,
-0.0111426925,
-0.0553950556,
-0.0479154475,
0.0114528462,
-0.0236674305,
0.0292728078,
0.0118116681,
0.0099805947,
0.0261106826,
-0.0457404666,
0.0293239746,
0.010390359,
-0.0311203841,
0.0303164814,
-0.043319121,
0.0570640191,
0.036937058,
0.0485063791,
-0.0065692579,
0.007217838,
-0.0106580751,
0.0531976521,
0.0189514626,
0.0173336696,
-0.042315986,
-0.0013952515,
-0.0496946089,
-0.0089057349,
-0.0189821906,
-0.0046133548,
-0.0141316345,
0.0189485345,
0.0020506943,
0.0128799789,
-0.0446049348,
0.0045103054,
0.0478069223,
-0.0184592102,
-0.0357526354,
-0.0146534685,
0.0097828582,
-0.0014039667,
0.0321086794,
0.0216331873,
0.0273737144,
0.0413534343,
-0.0479456373,
-0.0207200311,
-0.0426372103,
-0.066239439,
-0.0719537884,
-0.0250315312,
-0.0382682197,
-0.0263806339,
0.0044456003,
-0.0402413979,
-0.0273961853,
-0.0155466152,
-0.0621908084,
0.0577208735,
-0.0455801114,
-0.0319425799,
0.0186438076,
-0.0319937505,
-0.0475007556,
0.0526184216,
-0.0093653798,
0.0201635286,
0.015414577,
0.0173461623,
0.0064078029,
-0.033217214,
-0.0404664427,
-0.0294061061,
0.0091484217,
0.0222965311,
0.0198259316,
0.0023347316,
-0.0241870079,
-0.0336077847,
-0.0726748928,
-0.0051870728,
-0.0376465619,
0.0230887886,
0.0473903269,
0.0238676555,
0.0265178196,
-0.0447749831,
-0.0648509488,
-0.0191179644,
0.0103465924,
0.0495498143,
0.0523463972,
0.0016377105,
0.0162081867,
-0.0312234592,
-0.0119030504,
-0.0103476308,
0.0350105576,
-0.0013088087,
0.0595200807,
-0.0887854323,
-0.0182323866,
-0.0145158647,
-0.0182958245,
-0.0027726889,
-0.0191507787,
0.0162558351,
-0.0011411179,
0.0310567319,
0.0741480589,
0.0046734773,
0.0469873399,
0.0308110714,
0.0255934335,
-0.0854154602,
0.0015847207,
-0.0316316411,
-0.0239257123,
-0.0065031983,
-0.052557826,
0.0384697616,
0.0645851642,
0.0332677737,
-0.0156664327,
-0.0903032497,
0.0064523807,
-0.0405940376,
0.0018981916,
-0.0597283393,
-0.0271599814,
-0.0036908025,
0.0012335458,
-0.0115444763,
-0.0512469262,
0.1066401526,
-0.022631919,
-0.0321949087,
-0.0525399223,
-0.0446708836,
-0.0473830327,
0.0165612828,
0.0191984512,
0.0237193573,
-0.0103647364,
-0.0130300187,
-0.0579462238,
0.0117447311,
0.0002875833,
-0.0283627119,
0.0484238788,
-0.0127704618,
-0.0221709479,
0.016584957,
-0.0195929687,
-0.0537508577,
-0.0767682791,
0.0086993081,
0.0145808067,
0.0197615363,
0.0216800645,
-0.0081264907,
0.0140884202,
0.0295488089,
0.0010199812,
-0.0166343004,
-0.0245958976,
-0.0618603751,
0.043393638,
0.0718407556,
0.0000951137,
-0.0145903528,
-0.0495169349,
0.0477497913,
0.078871727,
0.0184279643,
-0.0403947271,
-0.0056115231,
0.0013670683,
0.0126519706,
-0.0484836958,
0.0068821055,
0.0329221897,
0.0730336308,
-0.0180035867,
-0.0293766744,
0.1151477769,
0.060992498,
-0.0366843492,
0.015234096,
-0.0204799306,
0.0526840985,
0.0148138041,
0.05758968,
-0.0508168302,
-0.0344733484,
-0.0088184038,
0.0378201753,
0.0213479884,
-0.00474776,
0.0000224958,
-0.0782693699,
-0.009138112,
-0.0071271858,
0.0102584129,
-0.040826574,
-0.036925368,
-0.0090908539,
0.0275899749,
-0.0037104972,
-0.0023387293,
-0.0100629767,
0.0250499267,
0.0197007582,
-0.0285410229,
0.0076740459,
0.014671375,
-0.0411195196,
0.0209463071,
0.0672636554,
0.0036188867,
0.0181429014,
-0.0131277917,
-0.0365297459,
-0.0570599735,
-0.0167530496,
-0.0050287563,
0.0448915623,
-0.0251214523,
0.0198609326,
-0.0328450911,
0.0487661771,
-0.0352314301,
0.0154523514,
0.0470503233,
0.0877597854,
-0.017935114,
0.0022288801,
-0.0497754291,
-0.0084052105,
0.0008186462,
0.089593932,
0.04392986,
-0.0464623459,
-0.0231600031,
-0.0660984665,
0.0241296869,
-0.0276157707,
-0.036968261,
-0.0251099244,
-0.0068839057,
0.0697923899,
-0.0688316375,
-0.0674351081,
0.063232623,
0.0123341503,
0.0079456763,
-0.0244141389,
0.0336351059,
-0.0471350849,
-0.040997602,
-0.0068943016,
-0.0254525058,
0.0236110501,
-0.0423244014,
-0.0440459326,
0.0433895737,
-0.0040351637,
-0.0238748845,
-0.024156373,
-0.0327667259,
-0.03214968,
-0.0401593596,
0.0394510888,
0.0107428515,
0.0347597077,
-0.0353850201,
-0.0299069267,
0.079872787,
-0.0390388109,
-0.0577962399,
-0.007721439,
0.0126780709,
0.0034602752,
0.0128646167,
0.0480366014,
-0.0549167916,
0.0049616639,
-0.0194239058,
0.0338770337,
-0.0829146728,
-0.0289464444,
0.0283852834,
-0.0179656669,
-0.0300124567,
0.0459716246,
0.0037619625,
-0.0006513824,
0.0235110261,
-0.0120407166,
-0.0246049166,
-0.0359230153,
0.0041634804,
0.0195062421,
-0.0428414643,
0.0021503523,
0.0204325393,
-0.0117176706,
0.03777989,
-0.0167688169,
0.0406191498,
0.0233910773,
0.0296998117,
-0.0019436384,
0.0251239277,
-0.0457678884,
-0.0186183769,
-0.0156104155,
0.0617834441,
-0.0291810576,
0.0737496093,
0.0078067109,
-0.0043209167,
-0.0126637425,
0.0452760644,
-0.0560651496,
-0.0308295935,
0.0003814152,
0.0125476122,
-0.0253648832,
-0.0056621544,
0.0022053225,
-0.001982694,
-0.015514412,
-0.0050298898,
0.019823201,
0.0172123853,
-0.0436091609,
0.0767271593,
0.0320760049,
-0.0097233215,
-0.0155548938,
0.0536639169,
-0.0207938161,
0.0204611178,
0.0060724081,
0.0006315569,
-0.0578361377,
0.0041806637,
0.0539704673,
0.054065153,
-0.0239001252,
0.0072650854,
-0.0119671477,
-0.0600738153,
-0.0192501973,
0.0064443317,
-0.055746112,
-0.0130068529,
0.0313027166,
0.0260904096,
0.0149342939,
-0.0306329262,
-0.0496518351,
0.0325589068,
-0.0522561148,
-0.0601020269,
-0.0278117564,
-6.129431989e-33,
-0.0341595039,
-0.0211087912,
0.0010206914,
-0.0422330275,
0.0240145493,
0.0004100602,
-0.0429081134,
-0.0150958002,
-0.0239212662,
0.0002229611,
-0.0057838452,
-0.0052488502,
-0.0092829596,
0.0304335039,
-0.0038427901,
-0.0390327349,
0.0164011084,
-0.0136515573,
-0.0258237254,
0.0504965223,
0.0288935173,
-0.0223745611,
-0.0049857548,
-0.0130776083,
0.0455991775,
-0.0244911741,
0.0204387009,
0.0183937866,
-0.0059947446,
0.0884527415,
-0.0490799285,
0.0420658886,
0.0166721642,
-0.0026963351,
-0.0323585682,
0.0609691851,
-0.086044848,
-0.0610040016,
0.0186772794,
-0.0197695363,
-0.0944594666,
-0.0346196145,
0.0307843406,
-0.0491709337,
0.0358057842,
-0.00761538,
0.0427080505,
0.028885806,
-0.0032326484,
0.0478472896,
-0.0440525599,
0.0054660249,
-0.0220751576,
-0.0449758023,
0.007538151,
0.0531781986,
0.0456289649,
0.0076978905,
-0.0663530827,
0.0174816754,
-0.0292323697,
0.0145577863,
0.0317910612,
-0.0098271165,
-0.0316941403,
0.0362961702,
-0.0216062162,
-0.0269523449,
-0.0207998361,
0.011796454,
-0.0252842624,
0.0155817531,
0.0566576384,
0.0173325818,
-0.0023702509,
0.0322166942,
-0.0228948742,
0.0571835525,
0.0256567337,
0.0117879566,
0.0402006805,
0.0076817605,
-0.0990447178,
-0.0288719032,
-0.0358282477,
0.027361894,
-0.0296949632,
-0.0506820716,
0.0346086472,
0.0070822001,
-0.0573693067,
-0.0029929797,
0.0303823296,
-0.0454462469,
0.0132998973,
0.0070955511,
0.0066505191,
0.0110644205,
0.0185746253,
0.0599962845,
-0.0305599049,
0.0223180726,
0.0345527381,
-0.0603308082,
-0.004655323,
0.0436186828,
0.0148671204,
-0.0098044863,
-0.0727509633,
-0.0012761311,
-0.0204827003,
-0.0243103169,
-0.024297649,
-0.0178654082,
0.0281753056,
0.0442091376,
-0.0151716461,
0.0450223871,
-0.0220378228,
-0.0228138715,
-0.0357661471,
-0.0185452271,
0.0130641554,
0.009983507,
-0.0328577049,
0.0236242693,
-0.0422964953,
0.0416799225,
-0.0204214416,
-0.0574891791,
0.0042849849,
0.0152155301,
2.495e-7,
0.0572123714,
0.0205162484,
0.0423744656,
0.0198090561,
0.0001335885,
0.0355797671,
0.0171077494,
0.0376235954,
0.0147079388,
-0.0132024903,
-0.0067025088,
0.0417849831,
0.0212714281,
0.025438685,
-0.066030167,
0.0209147222,
-0.0303243138,
0.0163492654,
-0.0441773012,
0.0089840693,
0.1099033728,
0.0676388294,
-0.0046156351,
0.0491991267,
-0.0317181051,
-0.0248025674,
0.04517892,
0.0059096669,
-0.0077113197,
0.0134276086,
-0.017522065,
0.0095386812,
0.0119586065,
0.0115737459,
-0.0146558415,
0.0064655193,
0.0059292004,
0.0629769266,
0.0086369887,
-0.062404234,
-0.0469136983,
-0.0346848182,
0.0185582265,
-0.0584350154,
0.0823700801,
-0.0568187982,
-0.0361291878,
0.0206467733,
-0.0247713719,
-0.0274260417,
-0.0040156064,
0.0196940284,
-0.0517171361,
0.0097831581,
0.0382610746,
-0.0091791498,
-0.0050691995,
-0.075931862,
0.0140098045,
0.008578307,
-0.047170829,
-0.0393107235,
-0.0566262938,
0.0417851955,
0.0349279232,
-0.0544882193,
0.0054388088,
2.452849649e-34,
-0.0071114604,
0.0292445589,
0.0414965674,
0.0405431762,
0.0344005711,
-0.0140301473,
-0.0157105252,
0.0003480267,
0.0881538317,
-0.1162466258,
-0.0292123239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09631v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09631v5 | Representation Surgery: Theory and Practice of Affine Steering | 2024-02-15T00:20:30 | 2024-06-25T13:00:08 | Shashwat Singh, Shauli Ravfogel, Jonathan Herzig, Roee Aharoni, Ryan Cotterell, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY | Language models often exhibit undesirable behavior, e.g., generating toxic or
gender-biased text. In the case of neural language models, an encoding of the
undesirable behavior is often present in the model's representations. Thus, one
natural (and common) approach to prevent the model from exhibiting undesirable
behavior is to steer the model's representations in a manner that reduces the
probability of it generating undesirable text. This paper investigates the
formal and empirical properties of steering functions, i.e., transformation of
the neural language model's representations that alter its behavior. First, we
derive two optimal, in the least-squares sense, affine steering functions under
different constraints. Our theory provides justification for existing
approaches and offers a novel, improved steering approach. Second, we offer a
series of experiments that demonstrate the empirical effectiveness of the
methods in mitigating bias and reducing toxic generation. | [
0.025994055,
0.05705579,
-0.0451293401,
0.0394636579,
-0.0257272311,
0.0124162771,
0.0144643141,
-0.0015541122,
-0.0448680669,
-0.0462841652,
-0.0398697555,
-0.0306178555,
0.0277598798,
0.0436345339,
0.0700105801,
-0.0366042592,
0.0312682651,
-0.0499689355,
-0.0062485314,
-0.026271278,
0.0095579196,
-0.0073424028,
0.0144985504,
0.0461687967,
-0.0490868241,
-0.03582507,
0.0616763644,
0.0231434703,
-0.0097514614,
0.0310254674,
0.0253293775,
0.0079567675,
0.0094616571,
0.0371417031,
0.0000022109,
-0.0112777548,
-0.0218495093,
0.0054073548,
0.0321254209,
-0.0028708482,
0.0718719736,
-0.0250533726,
-0.0396859907,
0.0223846845,
-0.0026514295,
-0.0113819363,
0.0554412045,
0.0380374976,
0.0682888106,
0.0929282531,
-0.0239287317,
-0.024717804,
0.0091293789,
-0.0034687114,
-0.0127592823,
0.0152592249,
0.0492840037,
-0.0365924723,
-0.0523046926,
0.0268775467,
-0.055504065,
0.0382111147,
0.0091025643,
-0.0177198537,
0.0285385586,
0.0291324407,
-0.0020243125,
-0.0390734524,
-0.000184296,
0.0573813654,
-0.0361615345,
-0.0104123764,
0.0097917104,
-0.0044329045,
0.0036968177,
0.0006621464,
-0.030345127,
0.012195982,
0.0463590063,
0.0226009693,
0.0008286776,
-0.0066708522,
0.0367663652,
0.0315353125,
0.0105228247,
0.0523039736,
0.027809063,
-0.0374700911,
-0.0025592947,
-0.0147448881,
0.0018089807,
0.0047916155,
0.0279054027,
0.004890291,
0.0061639315,
0.0325659253,
-0.0455874689,
-0.0403248966,
0.0061692214,
-0.1329360455,
0.0536615662,
0.03522937,
-0.0143999076,
0.0046043312,
-0.0654124022,
0.0593426861,
-0.0170170665,
0.0879702568,
-0.0410319418,
0.014422046,
0.0211774427,
-0.0361231714,
-0.0483312532,
-0.0053790892,
-0.0147920325,
0.0058140396,
-0.0291140582,
0.023609791,
-0.0610053465,
-0.0343076251,
-0.0044884128,
0.0638780892,
-0.0230389815,
0.0210986547,
-0.0120052285,
0.0099686896,
-0.0484479778,
0.0136187859,
-0.0339105353,
0.0035964241,
-0.0186255984,
0.0479526632,
-0.0292756576,
-0.0503394566,
-0.0279583056,
0.1240746081,
0.0133033339,
-0.0094060693,
-0.0324543864,
-0.0127980141,
-0.0593322366,
-0.0101693906,
0.0179471523,
-0.0313428976,
0.0024371245,
-0.0126078976,
-0.0330015793,
-0.1041547433,
0.0018315975,
0.0221291557,
-0.0763066411,
0.0289093778,
0.0316644944,
-0.0011440334,
0.0586991198,
0.0063088806,
-0.011406973,
0.0686324388,
0.0737826526,
0.0385694057,
0.0127848899,
-0.0128821367,
-0.0182333998,
0.0439759046,
0.0714275539,
0.0212005917,
-0.0596709996,
-0.0310628414,
0.0346594341,
0.047477182,
0.0337115526,
0.0705183223,
-0.015798714,
-0.0729861781,
0.0892733186,
0.051039461,
0.006861419,
0.0346910357,
0.0523723066,
-0.0652846023,
-0.0275960229,
0.0181817599,
-0.0712392628,
0.0092111323,
-0.0540624857,
-0.030444717,
-0.0153867332,
0.0486465544,
-0.0143815652,
-0.0416350178,
0.011251403,
-0.0116982544,
0.0524413772,
-0.0324166976,
0.0347477943,
0.0392415784,
-0.0330490172,
0.0288806055,
0.0314545669,
-0.0346359164,
0.0136297913,
-0.0471597351,
-0.0074201571,
0.0095113805,
0.0286164042,
-0.029267339,
-0.0271450039,
-0.0171147995,
-0.0316229649,
0.0428840071,
0.0246018078,
0.0041577606,
-0.007205653,
-0.0253848322,
-0.0117548341,
0.0481249355,
0.0111775463,
0.0049137189,
-0.0105907377,
0.0312152542,
0.0027229786,
-0.0139634795,
-0.0894744769,
0.0559741408,
0.0151736764,
-0.0539770126,
0.0295820367,
0.0135602532,
0.0103485547,
-0.0087459115,
-0.0192227028,
0.0224703047,
0.0307232887,
-0.0218398049,
-0.0239752047,
0.0162960999,
-0.0802298933,
-0.0051790094,
0.0119199632,
-0.0619656406,
0.016142346,
-0.0039509288,
0.0019158178,
-0.02156239,
0.076663889,
-0.0654278398,
0.0150344493,
-0.0020084267,
0.0245490931,
-0.0076701106,
-0.0035391334,
-0.0457279831,
0.0328804404,
0.0108792698,
-0.0139214965,
-0.002489038,
0.0001859218,
-0.0150466459,
-0.0472079143,
-0.0296192411,
0.0082017574,
0.0030890566,
0.021702785,
0.0297455844,
-0.0058585382,
0.0171902068,
-0.0268325694,
0.0090668872,
-0.0619206168,
0.0060536643,
-0.0289684031,
0.0264777746,
-0.0271476097,
0.0074495878,
0.01279011,
-0.036323972,
0.0206793156,
-0.0177288949,
0.0086645205,
0.0424598791,
-0.0159486141,
-0.0166047625,
-0.0354386307,
-0.024868764,
-0.0405962057,
0.0587116815,
-0.0060607321,
-0.0132071618,
-0.0776878446,
0.0239307564,
-0.0226744115,
0.0216440074,
0.002958752,
-0.0675865486,
-0.0018674847,
0.0051920293,
0.0242829304,
0.0975884423,
0.0170322228,
0.0550458468,
0.0843919814,
0.0438240953,
-0.040224798,
-0.0274426434,
-0.0188140497,
0.040219292,
-0.0023672022,
-0.047120627,
0.0276844446,
0.0584953912,
0.0347503833,
-0.0093861762,
-0.0543736257,
0.0417261943,
-0.0398531668,
-0.0406808145,
-0.0166229513,
-0.0517563261,
-0.0448718555,
-0.004221153,
-0.0549597852,
-0.0483873487,
0.0617665201,
-0.0098787639,
0.0160879511,
-0.0226520728,
-0.0038991559,
-0.0161076188,
0.0157033931,
0.0268249698,
0.0556371137,
0.0555456728,
0.0094833104,
-0.0752702057,
-0.0330528505,
0.02567208,
-0.0197281465,
0.0256082248,
-0.0333065316,
0.0162321832,
0.0241093561,
-0.0178464707,
-0.0335812755,
-0.0857566297,
0.0621758252,
-0.0037351341,
0.0386163518,
-0.0080112498,
-0.0185592137,
0.0210092962,
-0.0012700714,
0.0258759651,
-0.0462996475,
0.0132202376,
0.0024631706,
-0.0146768317,
0.0612373427,
-0.0188480057,
0.0212649163,
-0.0040439526,
-0.0175812077,
0.0619686954,
-0.044524774,
0.0115189934,
-0.0404720083,
0.0308903456,
0.0207561497,
0.0009556215,
-0.0031767602,
-0.0152141796,
0.0073017948,
-0.0252513811,
-0.0503080525,
0.0685461015,
0.0123730013,
-0.0560146347,
0.0483673997,
0.0176409185,
0.0548352785,
0.0062400266,
0.0199606325,
-0.0389438197,
0.0056544342,
-0.004521485,
0.0013739842,
-0.0252372529,
-0.0210747998,
0.0279356148,
-0.1119971126,
-0.0168958399,
0.0472248159,
-0.0376851298,
-0.0514284186,
0.0167775247,
-0.0011499963,
-0.0199346375,
0.0254965965,
0.0023136947,
-0.0252481811,
-0.0284890849,
0.0197369251,
-0.0071924976,
-0.0321413726,
-0.0369395241,
-0.0411272943,
0.0759655833,
0.0634687841,
0.0532225929,
-0.0101711405,
-0.0414114371,
0.0357537791,
0.0323140472,
0.0090477802,
-0.0199227314,
0.04650243,
-0.0180458203,
-0.0110286325,
0.0116342464,
0.0106060999,
0.0026008354,
-0.0020548915,
-0.0408838317,
0.0586701818,
-0.0014680113,
-0.0251185335,
-0.047291927,
0.00925708,
0.0314150378,
0.0911030397,
0.0262579806,
-0.0454695448,
-0.0222212169,
-0.0594330952,
0.0040139281,
0.0129747624,
-0.0667782798,
-0.0133756995,
0.0062649869,
-0.0250539258,
-0.1041973904,
0.0074872603,
0.0104022622,
0.0265377276,
0.0295727775,
-0.0524126664,
0.0012172633,
-0.0480169654,
0.0106804939,
-0.0039750729,
0.0096905986,
0.0202229004,
-0.0148108751,
-0.004675502,
0.0128681185,
-0.0232674014,
-0.0279782414,
0.0239178203,
-0.0195483621,
-0.1000531465,
0.0268588047,
0.0725614056,
0.0209539644,
0.0233989861,
-0.020723857,
-0.0657887906,
0.0413837768,
0.0345490687,
-0.0109507451,
0.0251000635,
0.0255575571,
0.0016286508,
-0.0146831246,
0.0398841724,
-0.0367048159,
0.0222843755,
0.0290444903,
0.0264151823,
-0.0311045479,
0.0074488637,
0.0093886787,
0.0033382762,
0.0364948548,
-0.0241149832,
0.0083374763,
-0.0381911173,
-0.0139048416,
-0.0514711067,
-0.020510748,
-0.0042745052,
0.0256517213,
0.0392837003,
0.0042767585,
-0.033907745,
-0.0233196821,
-0.0211913642,
0.0008845871,
-0.0289185904,
-0.0176575091,
0.0554449596,
0.0169866458,
0.0014394254,
0.0757874846,
0.0062277764,
0.049629271,
-0.0335894339,
0.0161047354,
-0.0254400279,
-0.0163333211,
0.033727441,
0.0300630592,
-0.0558127128,
0.0109613743,
-0.04645155,
-0.0110310381,
-0.0531902276,
-0.0127480375,
-0.0069007427,
-0.0306419116,
0.0698989555,
-0.0114241811,
-0.0232372545,
0.0024305191,
-0.0077696564,
0.0137335276,
-0.0000985674,
0.0150065124,
0.0005949805,
0.0008209138,
-0.0567645766,
0.0542224571,
0.0158030801,
0.0315892734,
-0.0241125319,
0.0032615145,
-0.0163058322,
-0.0119619109,
0.0376846381,
-0.0315818079,
-0.0289004222,
-0.0099240104,
-0.071943365,
-0.0697876588,
-0.0121546639,
-0.0165681653,
0.055577673,
-0.0026801468,
0.0408510417,
0.0126368115,
0.0058580115,
0.009288257,
-0.0104405209,
-0.0299220104,
0.0151533447,
-0.0230768397,
-0.0434146374,
-6.614241491e-33,
-0.0208926406,
-0.0081584398,
-0.0345752053,
-0.0079173651,
-0.0100397775,
-0.0189726688,
0.0072888015,
-0.0059364969,
-0.0037711095,
-0.0020101487,
0.030848382,
0.008253349,
-0.0073219528,
0.0100677824,
-0.0291268565,
0.0095711742,
0.0425318219,
-0.0438199155,
-0.0280966517,
0.0035605726,
0.0410837643,
0.029499013,
0.0266536996,
-0.0774692148,
0.0448456779,
0.0221677255,
-0.0278612189,
0.0221162103,
-0.0331537388,
0.0545825958,
-0.0115904026,
0.0578387007,
0.0167436041,
-0.0229788423,
-0.009565088,
0.028884232,
-0.033881221,
-0.0312197097,
0.0084163835,
-0.0123890834,
-0.0199555047,
-0.0451313406,
0.1046487093,
-0.0030206945,
-0.053501863,
-0.0300321598,
0.0405714214,
0.0003125678,
-0.0060842149,
0.0391212925,
-0.0979736298,
-0.0077548595,
-0.0158883557,
-0.0160076115,
0.0238728914,
0.0303153154,
0.0092383679,
-0.0399759859,
-0.0449508466,
0.0286353119,
-0.0240868032,
0.0165161341,
0.0204827692,
0.0456112325,
0.0245288331,
0.0615157932,
0.0336718261,
0.0324354433,
-0.0304387957,
-0.0435477719,
0.0548520796,
-0.0231563896,
0.0555849001,
0.0178432912,
0.0391039401,
-0.0655286685,
-0.0600644536,
-0.0092847729,
-0.019727461,
0.0359597541,
0.0283769444,
-0.0072599957,
-0.0357431546,
-0.0521953702,
-0.0407402553,
-0.1012379527,
-0.0198892206,
-0.0024720586,
-0.0046039578,
0.005584714,
-0.0578154474,
0.0001896513,
-0.0143531067,
-0.0412802286,
0.0139965974,
0.0245175455,
-0.0102249803,
-0.0056646578,
0.0297976956,
0.0249598473,
-0.0278346948,
-0.0137955751,
-0.0046042143,
0.0243856516,
0.0388589688,
0.0025991309,
0.0385183021,
0.0202803519,
-0.0505666658,
-0.0035280043,
-0.0287730061,
0.000705175,
0.0541564636,
0.039335452,
0.017623296,
0.0184713546,
-0.0116839716,
0.0114454627,
0.0280648246,
0.021316573,
-0.0126748281,
-0.0043864469,
-0.0161070433,
0.0347409509,
-0.0454581566,
-0.0023513706,
0.0276129078,
0.0676585659,
0.1031709835,
-0.1051148698,
-0.0186006594,
-0.0381809063,
2.941e-7,
0.0436321646,
0.0679782405,
0.0321301147,
0.0335321575,
0.0286306273,
0.0271411892,
-0.0000563192,
0.0626801476,
0.0276152268,
-0.0199633446,
-0.0261510517,
0.028980786,
0.0090572955,
0.027312329,
-0.0527462177,
0.049371101,
-0.1010635197,
0.0352722108,
-0.0109962141,
0.0116069214,
0.0436518043,
0.0692841858,
0.0070521398,
-0.0478322729,
-0.0181473009,
-0.0102883959,
0.0558849089,
-0.0321659707,
0.0454587936,
-0.0196781736,
-0.0620988794,
0.0088846767,
0.0134309372,
0.0022834237,
0.0185246523,
-0.0096624931,
0.0146985585,
0.0395903885,
-0.0623669773,
-0.0369801931,
0.0003477107,
-0.0072538313,
-0.0062043369,
-0.0128819887,
0.0522206761,
-0.0322938636,
-0.0091200275,
-0.0245050304,
0.024368247,
0.0312785544,
0.0581845902,
-0.0306910686,
-0.0315008871,
0.0067498945,
0.0042506047,
0.0403102636,
0.0136001604,
-0.060579069,
-0.0163673945,
0.0025459116,
-0.0065549761,
-0.0389743634,
-0.025973659,
0.0533199236,
-0.0057242787,
-0.0504880548,
-0.007978362,
2.816437169e-34,
-0.0034941551,
-0.0353999473,
0.0244709551,
-0.0064051589,
0.008079242,
0.0061358311,
0.0362830497,
-0.0083551686,
0.0362621918,
-0.0319594033,
-0.0490392856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09615v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09615v4 | API Pack: A Massive Multi-Programming Language Dataset for API Call Generation | 2024-02-14T23:09:15 | 2024-06-03T22:38:04 | Zhen Guo, Adriana Meza Soria, Wei Sun, Yikang Shen, Rameswar Panda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce API Pack, a massive multi-programming language dataset
containing more than 1 million instruction-API call pairs to improve the API
call generation capabilities of large language models. By fine-tuning
CodeLlama-13B on 20,000 Python instances from API Pack, we enable it to
outperform GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in generating unseen API calls. Fine-tuning on API
Pack also facilitates cross-programming language generalization by leveraging a
large amount of data in one language and small amounts of data from other
languages. Scaling the training data to 1 million instances further improves
the model's ability to generalize to new APIs not used in training. To
facilitate further research, we open-source the API Pack dataset, trained
model, and associated source code at https://github.com/zguo0525/API-Pack. | [
0.0046376209,
0.0932579562,
-0.0086756945,
0.0293880738,
-0.003191306,
0.0011364358,
-0.0300827194,
-0.0031071329,
0.0243065674,
-0.0130240731,
-0.0346067809,
0.0053391834,
0.0021877182,
0.0431982838,
0.0478611961,
-0.0351471417,
0.0348852612,
-0.019351203,
0.005738683,
0.0271515194,
-0.0252636317,
0.0557212569,
0.0251715649,
0.0634509698,
-0.0005463115,
-0.0519260876,
-0.0113772703,
0.0219857637,
0.0091858217,
-0.0229670778,
0.0381576046,
0.0003355817,
0.0178947393,
0.0549945161,
0.0000019071,
-0.0060605379,
0.000354533,
0.0141730085,
-0.0141054923,
0.0075851846,
-0.007114185,
-0.0304459762,
0.0142465178,
0.040983066,
-0.030503707,
-0.0266140569,
0.0389411561,
-0.0464514159,
0.0880514979,
0.0824701861,
0.0177880656,
-0.002215323,
-0.0187445469,
-0.0170786772,
-0.0381428748,
-0.0032594057,
-0.0370899104,
-0.0242338032,
-0.0158400442,
-0.014975504,
0.0034394972,
-0.0192438867,
0.0427204967,
0.0231756922,
-0.0510382988,
0.0483504906,
-0.1034881473,
-0.0236409213,
-0.0139507009,
0.0620553419,
-0.0719775259,
-0.0522756837,
-0.0092993565,
0.0033076864,
-0.0057184342,
-0.0751548856,
-0.0450087972,
0.0337144285,
0.0211474057,
-0.0044437116,
0.0396462381,
-0.0051188306,
0.0227043368,
-0.0273154024,
0.0032370011,
0.0534732267,
0.0370139778,
0.0213248674,
-0.028218193,
-0.0097232787,
-0.0023767145,
-0.0559136868,
-0.0173191093,
0.0368906595,
-0.0431743376,
0.0155191729,
-0.0518956818,
-0.0410163924,
0.0325796306,
-0.0196897816,
0.0358940773,
0.0556928255,
-0.0547591187,
-0.0207250807,
-0.0525279455,
0.0253705792,
0.0063452828,
0.0047581196,
-0.0114924936,
-0.0000830405,
-0.0214380249,
-0.0025679497,
-0.0485996827,
0.0353043452,
-0.0471017845,
0.0066393972,
-0.0278160237,
0.0444169901,
0.0190198626,
0.0182230454,
-0.0071218321,
-0.0050114319,
-0.0588051938,
-0.0194524825,
0.0334008038,
0.0171360523,
-0.024448365,
-0.0347175486,
0.0155144548,
-0.0862125158,
-0.0245933849,
-0.0033660997,
-0.0132101579,
-0.030013077,
0.0205602739,
0.0819383413,
-0.0151537741,
0.0136373406,
-0.0440582931,
-0.0588461608,
0.0719537064,
-0.0696139634,
0.0006675115,
-0.0888315365,
0.0065520424,
0.0162018705,
0.0207308214,
-0.0042939601,
0.0126121407,
0.0272740647,
-0.0037625085,
0.0508084521,
-0.0283769984,
-0.0056985272,
0.029295871,
0.0173852276,
0.0101108784,
0.0661015213,
0.0208307281,
0.0041183205,
0.0485031046,
-0.0290437378,
0.011931845,
0.0567321964,
0.0065568942,
-0.0121427793,
0.0275096018,
-0.0023201187,
0.0369499698,
-0.0026080487,
0.0454806425,
0.0112028942,
-0.0157385878,
-0.0282945987,
-0.0059739375,
0.0118821235,
0.0049688402,
0.0171044562,
0.1121387705,
0.0298169348,
-0.0048923893,
-0.0311902855,
-0.0563895032,
0.0281329695,
0.0135572348,
0.038310919,
0.0201103035,
0.0633540004,
-0.020577332,
-0.0165611487,
0.0326709338,
-0.0322597064,
-0.0567856804,
-0.0246884916,
0.0213543642,
0.0078258682,
-0.0615100712,
0.0540207922,
0.0213707797,
-0.0441293158,
-0.0209113043,
-0.069427982,
0.0062571424,
0.0210972577,
0.0540098324,
-0.0223838408,
-0.0493366718,
0.0033942575,
-0.0075408244,
0.0358361304,
0.0314218588,
-0.0167957768,
0.0472480468,
-0.0430899896,
0.0035850434,
-0.0138775762,
0.0179589223,
0.0448690355,
0.0497197546,
0.0190651622,
0.0608631112,
-0.0266176574,
-0.0470700152,
0.0265176445,
-0.01036165,
-0.0438552983,
0.0298025571,
-0.0038917898,
0.0239352379,
0.0093568256,
-0.0132001154,
0.0063774097,
0.0291646142,
-0.0100140972,
0.0441456474,
0.0001872825,
-0.050033547,
-0.0018625632,
0.0414271243,
0.0069843987,
-0.0273418948,
0.0333453566,
-0.0498317704,
-0.0517258756,
0.0614300556,
-0.0116284313,
0.0847181156,
0.0118465861,
0.0194951445,
0.031104574,
0.0297111291,
0.029674707,
0.0254531074,
0.0089061167,
0.0206347425,
0.0212062914,
0.0815692618,
0.0250130408,
0.0180335101,
-0.0117626106,
0.030873429,
-0.04170895,
0.0275352765,
0.0017024156,
0.0639747605,
-0.0289740954,
0.0167885944,
-0.1159391627,
0.0204854812,
-0.0246198103,
0.0222028717,
0.0202064496,
0.0316032171,
0.0075066751,
-0.0421923995,
-0.0133583946,
-0.0181172248,
-0.0179076493,
0.0299204364,
-0.0267347042,
-0.0126510086,
-0.0705189109,
-0.0295408424,
-0.0155182416,
-0.0025519235,
0.0471369028,
-0.0323818289,
-0.0091886679,
-0.0560443886,
-0.0163385198,
0.0104265464,
0.0390409492,
-0.0246982481,
-0.072984606,
0.0125072161,
-0.0201873314,
0.005729327,
0.0182092711,
-0.0428884774,
-0.0283949338,
0.0173146818,
-0.0116406111,
-0.0735760182,
0.0292673055,
-0.0028447893,
-0.0778361261,
0.0125285508,
-0.0579880998,
0.0105820531,
0.0741519406,
-0.0130415931,
-0.009794578,
-0.0512291342,
-0.0368148759,
0.0083447741,
-0.0166446548,
0.037857566,
0.0192337837,
-0.0185047518,
0.0175428689,
-0.0247604679,
-0.0977044702,
0.0432072058,
-0.0273062102,
-0.0274514277,
-0.0585559607,
-0.0149985179,
-0.0264594629,
0.0972665846,
0.0250549354,
0.0313492827,
-0.0026288023,
-0.0455886312,
-0.0262968484,
0.039344199,
-0.0473802239,
-0.0166767035,
0.0862250552,
-0.067015022,
-0.0023542547,
-0.0093759699,
-0.0309069417,
-0.0292007122,
0.0506276451,
-0.0375454836,
0.0192007404,
-0.0121770762,
-0.0526309535,
0.0399359465,
-0.0237125605,
-0.000771742,
0.0763852969,
-0.0008477239,
-0.0016377446,
-0.0081716273,
-0.0331596136,
0.0378587954,
-0.0148973977,
-0.0647458285,
0.0345535651,
0.0193607323,
-0.005090151,
0.0681057647,
0.0233501941,
-0.0575853772,
0.0116904369,
0.0269408952,
-0.0183957927,
-0.0419751927,
0.0528889969,
0.0278948806,
-0.0718011707,
-0.0237744693,
0.0681412295,
0.0216740351,
-0.0488846079,
0.0022099395,
-0.0257581677,
0.0581065118,
0.0420467556,
0.0658060163,
-0.073321037,
-0.0328358859,
-0.0171573851,
0.0321810879,
-0.0222097654,
0.0126455035,
-0.0290918462,
-0.1543223411,
0.0362455696,
0.0114931054,
-0.0359973349,
-0.0529126152,
-0.0566044487,
-0.0305675641,
0.0026749689,
-0.0021951166,
0.0024163893,
0.002263516,
0.0111492379,
0.0055872686,
-0.0245130043,
-0.0102970842,
0.0105904415,
-0.0158014148,
0.0202399436,
0.0812030509,
0.0106757972,
0.0014338555,
0.0194732957,
0.056231916,
-0.0236024167,
-0.0283459891,
-0.0012321892,
0.0286084469,
0.018351851,
-0.040306095,
0.0516863465,
0.0196881462,
-0.0671430901,
-0.0106833996,
-0.0017322664,
0.0714534894,
-0.0015703958,
0.0178700853,
-0.0154975886,
0.0102506131,
0.0039313301,
-0.004294632,
0.0312898308,
-0.0112300282,
-0.0327798091,
-0.0565905645,
0.0010210531,
-0.0717879757,
0.0178253073,
0.0327269472,
-0.0395894758,
-0.0576236472,
-0.0261679199,
-0.0025555808,
0.0542596839,
0.0150391627,
0.0298070461,
0.0177429169,
0.0085452581,
0.0049142428,
-0.0546445884,
0.0148973912,
-0.0048738406,
0.0138479527,
-0.0573294871,
-0.1016026288,
0.0513297357,
0.012428266,
-0.0137103973,
0.08158575,
-0.0476143211,
-0.0738070458,
-0.0206573885,
0.1099396795,
0.0180513039,
0.0548619665,
-0.0325074196,
0.000660701,
-0.0447771922,
0.1057974845,
-0.0391361713,
-0.0244018175,
0.020390017,
0.0055126818,
0.0025670507,
0.0193850715,
-0.0647360906,
-0.0159530211,
0.017201189,
0.0158652253,
-0.0325387008,
0.0252110381,
0.0235676542,
0.021170238,
-0.0133918487,
-0.0218239222,
-0.0073105269,
-0.0092142718,
0.0111238165,
0.0081936726,
-0.010671231,
-0.0456190929,
0.0327254422,
0.0036720817,
-0.0342296809,
0.0311976075,
-0.0344719663,
0.0039380807,
0.036148183,
0.0031095769,
0.0218250565,
-0.0013029146,
0.0553213432,
0.0388386175,
-0.0112320185,
-0.0303714108,
-0.0271759108,
-0.0145704979,
0.0445640646,
-0.0392750874,
0.0250074398,
-0.0012305225,
0.018669568,
0.0188448727,
0.0320442729,
-0.0097525017,
-0.099235177,
-0.058560282,
-0.0119444923,
0.017474208,
-0.0257340409,
0.0534744039,
-0.0238681529,
0.019368045,
-0.0076731499,
0.053902857,
0.0080881966,
-0.0238608066,
-0.0102139702,
0.0085126925,
-0.0140209664,
-0.0393015742,
0.0958255529,
-0.0265019499,
0.0584342889,
0.0279451832,
0.0051114606,
-0.0486390926,
-0.0161134973,
0.0494999364,
-0.005020502,
-0.0112637281,
0.0130058387,
-0.0053007733,
-0.062790893,
-0.0439963862,
0.0274432469,
0.0392236486,
0.019949859,
0.0372572541,
0.0746935979,
0.0026643679,
-0.0323854014,
-0.0460881628,
0.0114463735,
-0.0195873436,
-0.0467002727,
-0.0096802954,
-5.556488695e-33,
-0.0414683111,
0.0030864335,
0.0116633661,
-0.0003593232,
-0.0222338773,
0.0158015229,
-0.0300264917,
-0.0257893093,
0.003993602,
-0.0238820985,
-0.0000458665,
0.0003763523,
0.0210999046,
0.0160325058,
0.042877458,
0.015235574,
0.023766065,
0.0004542367,
-0.0182535984,
0.0770383254,
0.0010113886,
0.0253056288,
0.0741514862,
-0.0660998002,
-0.0332776755,
0.0043782331,
0.0117756445,
-0.0239214506,
0.0104773538,
0.0409316979,
0.0045136968,
0.0130683007,
0.0171190463,
-0.0381195024,
-0.0196145996,
-0.0038863646,
-0.0233336836,
-0.0366182551,
0.0348231196,
0.0410458036,
-0.0163078532,
-0.0444551855,
0.019483218,
-0.0111731524,
0.0216500349,
0.0098097846,
0.0144527592,
0.0050276932,
-0.0043368554,
0.0098836021,
-0.0708710179,
0.0103073409,
0.0159980282,
-0.0171128679,
-0.007097905,
0.0169987064,
-0.0177135263,
0.0085806074,
-0.006615804,
-0.0135504734,
0.0121382847,
0.0884700641,
0.0725540966,
0.0340761766,
0.0055506034,
0.0082491348,
0.0202571861,
-0.0099918898,
0.0120068667,
0.0372613706,
0.0071048895,
0.0654780641,
-0.0106253754,
-0.0227802359,
0.0073553789,
-0.0076508005,
0.0143319322,
-0.0041744723,
0.03641418,
-0.003283784,
-0.000296525,
-0.0249314252,
0.0094816294,
-0.0001410913,
-0.0315655209,
-0.0268018544,
-0.0296051875,
-0.0164920092,
0.0252566487,
0.0095128119,
0.0036683227,
0.0043689837,
0.0347217396,
-0.0268380735,
0.0136566497,
-0.0111786574,
-0.0359020121,
0.0147646656,
-0.0063116807,
0.012581531,
0.0004766439,
-0.0618758388,
-0.014965157,
-0.0366819203,
0.0630073622,
0.0085745584,
0.0256535616,
0.0282177255,
-0.0409930274,
0.0249317046,
-0.0846927688,
0.0269189794,
-0.0123816682,
0.0393798389,
0.0124090239,
-0.0028754817,
-0.0199763123,
0.0252238791,
-0.0111615974,
0.0088355578,
-0.0187491626,
-0.006382972,
-0.0026119961,
0.0437443368,
-0.0706401914,
-0.0034445368,
-0.0505902134,
0.0035091084,
0.0007434739,
-0.0134254843,
-0.0425733253,
0.022720471,
2.589e-7,
-0.0056507788,
-0.00444951,
0.0245001726,
0.0803379267,
-0.0005283596,
0.0258727577,
-0.0000302212,
0.0396935605,
0.0051373476,
-0.0207830761,
-0.0503045171,
-0.0473484509,
0.0270633642,
0.0157713257,
-0.0836509764,
0.0151085863,
-0.0193461403,
-0.012447698,
-0.0824311897,
-0.0128566427,
-0.0050015366,
0.1085547283,
0.0044372031,
-0.0220745001,
0.0334271491,
-0.0070429659,
-0.031272985,
-0.0229208171,
0.0053669494,
0.0596000738,
-0.043671865,
0.0648632348,
0.0087189833,
-0.0058830334,
-0.0548933744,
-0.034251567,
0.0194499586,
0.0551431738,
0.0021981334,
0.0055981055,
0.0462934785,
-0.0147325778,
-0.0001109705,
-0.0593758896,
0.0138677694,
0.0125237266,
-0.0071964799,
-0.0159045495,
-0.0030250004,
0.028875526,
-0.0358941481,
-0.0490145721,
0.0164060313,
0.0392280892,
0.0170592908,
-0.0261319615,
-0.0114742042,
-0.0469917804,
-0.0443214588,
0.0197671633,
-0.0244823266,
-0.0320932046,
-0.0589038022,
-0.0285329279,
-0.0056807096,
-0.015449605,
0.0007759426,
2.633763051e-34,
0.0316060632,
-0.0360955894,
0.0416385494,
0.0717055723,
0.0378262401,
-0.0196769554,
0.0183440484,
0.0455533303,
-0.007558397,
0.0022404897,
-0.0428316407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09614v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09614v2 | Probabilistic Reasoning in Generative Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T23:05:44 | 2024-06-17T05:13:33 | Aliakbar Nafar, Kristen Brent Venable, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | This paper considers the challenges Large Language Models (LLMs) face when
reasoning over text that includes information involving uncertainty explicitly
quantified via probability values. This type of reasoning is relevant to a
variety of contexts ranging from everyday conversations to medical
decision-making. Despite improvements in the mathematical reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, they still exhibit significant difficulties when it comes
to probabilistic reasoning. To deal with this problem, we introduce the
Bayesian Linguistic Inference Dataset (BLInD), a new dataset specifically
designed to test the probabilistic reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We use BLInD
to find out the limitations of LLMs for tasks involving probabilistic
reasoning. In addition, we present several prompting strategies that map the
problem to different formal representations, including Python code,
probabilistic algorithms, and probabilistic logical programming. We conclude by
providing an evaluation of our methods on BLInD and an adaptation of a causal
reasoning question-answering dataset. Our empirical results highlight the
effectiveness of our proposed strategies for multiple LLMs. | [
0.0384190083,
0.1008336917,
-0.0034967167,
0.0180495549,
-0.0647894889,
0.0423032269,
0.0161878224,
-0.0192518402,
0.0080683287,
-0.0388482884,
0.0445007533,
-0.0255006365,
0.0037806169,
0.0363717452,
0.0161060244,
-0.0483235605,
-0.0017675251,
-0.0667714253,
0.0777132511,
-0.0371194966,
-0.012573381,
0.0252489038,
-0.0375642553,
0.0372497514,
0.0004241116,
0.001857413,
0.0295627136,
-0.0146026136,
0.0065681669,
-0.0244959854,
-0.0278407633,
0.044921618,
0.0053682197,
-0.0099414829,
0.0000018587,
-0.0574714728,
0.0030612927,
-0.0168367624,
-0.0380791277,
-0.0273936428,
0.0241308268,
0.0167674664,
0.0014075454,
0.0479197837,
-0.0526348054,
0.0048731212,
0.0415950641,
0.018466115,
-0.0008020654,
0.0352982916,
-0.0068542133,
-0.0270232186,
-0.0072011719,
-0.0096208863,
0.0638944134,
-0.0497419424,
0.0398455486,
0.0447175391,
0.0127329836,
0.0001307683,
0.008206293,
0.0319963545,
0.0400718823,
-0.0032606451,
-0.0200631116,
0.0472592972,
-0.0090408465,
-0.0328138843,
0.0017760403,
0.0364576019,
0.0441758707,
-0.0332189649,
0.005962701,
-0.0195727665,
-0.0142895393,
0.0463616848,
-0.0447969511,
0.0674306825,
-0.0348305106,
0.0372578204,
0.0117431339,
0.0065242248,
0.0516870804,
0.0155191217,
-0.0387235358,
0.1184856966,
0.031588316,
0.0184585024,
-0.0124644488,
0.0083502224,
-0.0232983511,
-0.0592750423,
-0.0077895946,
0.0206794534,
-0.0283920933,
0.0571115687,
-0.0205341335,
0.0126773398,
0.0295334943,
-0.0281363968,
0.0043901517,
0.0170756876,
0.0101597793,
0.0668626055,
-0.0049703913,
-0.0330288261,
-0.0024972183,
0.0019433964,
-0.001967093,
-0.011278647,
-0.0509682782,
-0.0055486895,
-0.0042341468,
-0.0217125174,
0.0069450052,
-0.006497175,
-0.0300799105,
0.0271910373,
-0.0216222573,
0.023684768,
0.0243258588,
0.0299378075,
-0.0308939964,
-0.0438832492,
-0.0762250572,
-0.009640066,
-0.0414652005,
0.0413616449,
0.0020159315,
-0.0465722233,
-0.0019168631,
0.0068266108,
0.009500985,
-0.0416109636,
0.0057993955,
0.0454687364,
0.0124668004,
0.015160528,
-0.0374017917,
-0.0310740843,
-0.0294982791,
-0.0604142584,
-0.0196437854,
-0.085697189,
-0.0041886307,
0.0426158682,
-0.0139587028,
-0.0519299172,
0.0198919065,
0.0131355943,
-0.0442921706,
0.1118039116,
0.0157060567,
0.0235034507,
0.0186512731,
0.0003599786,
-0.0069569023,
0.0841165558,
0.0435809009,
-0.0057080057,
0.0271906201,
0.013451919,
0.0021933301,
0.0183240511,
-0.0116351824,
0.0040938361,
-0.0300571714,
0.0137381619,
0.0103156557,
0.0160829145,
-0.018720014,
0.0429605655,
-0.0193649884,
-0.0161244646,
0.0425855815,
0.0269285422,
-0.0242315382,
-0.0470264293,
0.0368129499,
-0.0251465887,
0.0082979565,
-0.0120287435,
-0.0366800576,
0.0169093683,
-0.0182009451,
0.0064330776,
0.0301662888,
0.0134990048,
0.001257758,
-0.0730571151,
-0.0427848026,
-0.0098952446,
0.0089350324,
0.0435593165,
0.1122797653,
-0.0098505644,
-0.0106204404,
0.0108975526,
0.0356317349,
-0.0370580629,
-0.0330833159,
-0.0556343608,
0.0612301342,
0.0515821278,
0.071046263,
-0.0326425619,
-0.0077216621,
0.0011689534,
-0.0117641222,
0.0252238885,
0.0251399726,
-0.002440274,
-0.0085929744,
-0.0435241833,
-0.0233889278,
0.0160114933,
0.0217857715,
0.0083804773,
0.040153157,
0.0011863554,
0.0025748983,
-0.0293116514,
0.0032702393,
0.0285757259,
-0.0108974427,
0.0011659974,
0.0280936733,
-0.0247300919,
0.0437744074,
-0.0136080831,
-0.0171975605,
0.0473098308,
0.0075078621,
-0.0077606617,
-0.0270607136,
0.0079837348,
0.0069662333,
-0.0039349641,
0.0539819859,
-0.0168715492,
-0.0467521735,
-0.0433415249,
-0.0477676541,
-0.0327602327,
0.0292864274,
-0.0085244896,
0.0267516952,
-0.0207862873,
-0.0136443162,
0.0308260676,
-0.0035829272,
-0.0263076779,
0.0779234022,
0.0167397074,
0.0033509196,
0.0143374717,
0.0318214037,
0.0126721812,
-0.0698136836,
-0.0018632327,
-0.0027449471,
0.0010909399,
-0.0061935815,
0.04060366,
-0.0275936332,
-0.0240877531,
-0.0199539736,
-0.0731965899,
-0.0048872456,
-0.0011997883,
0.0285612792,
-0.0055251531,
0.0002190367,
-0.0123107927,
-0.0156087298,
-0.031890858,
-0.013602634,
0.0064218105,
0.0379043445,
0.0272563212,
-0.009800693,
0.013534585,
-0.0186206736,
-0.0115962513,
-0.0274663754,
0.0478154235,
0.0525081046,
0.0196813494,
-0.0361099429,
0.0110963481,
-0.0495035909,
0.0101512643,
-0.0122927101,
0.0070110951,
0.0052324468,
-0.0548755154,
0.0561435334,
0.0732698441,
-0.011635839,
0.0236191899,
0.0886661336,
-0.0176620167,
-0.0331982896,
-0.0056432723,
-0.0458602607,
-0.0357415527,
-0.0286738388,
-0.0696275383,
-0.0672134981,
0.0176077504,
0.023452837,
-0.0329009071,
-0.0459482558,
0.0578638464,
0.0091024721,
-0.0139964987,
-0.0344704054,
0.0132197645,
0.011427097,
0.0927853063,
-0.0044486285,
-0.0559858717,
0.0709785596,
-0.0143040232,
0.0297485832,
-0.046086397,
-0.0018567751,
-0.0162161309,
0.06525141,
0.0162569247,
-0.0117109446,
0.0226441901,
-0.0028548418,
-0.030038463,
0.0041280896,
0.0364152417,
-0.0294432193,
-0.0046907552,
-0.1051891893,
0.0367493406,
0.0224851444,
-0.0034261472,
-0.0404364467,
-0.035259001,
-0.0802251771,
-0.022903895,
-0.0082077142,
-0.0128057403,
-0.0177080724,
0.012831294,
-0.0054391613,
0.0137688294,
-0.0137453917,
-0.0071097985,
-0.005269296,
0.0041068327,
0.0478122495,
-0.0119806221,
0.0277149603,
-0.0112128565,
-0.0171681941,
0.0301267076,
0.0208867993,
0.0213523619,
-0.035395503,
0.0008663794,
-0.0022215978,
-0.008493566,
0.0056216209,
0.0410085432,
0.009156472,
-0.0433164127,
-0.0056890831,
0.1103104725,
0.0435710885,
-0.0162739549,
-0.0079441527,
-0.0388161466,
0.016895311,
-0.0035151907,
0.033581879,
-0.0982142687,
-0.0467819013,
0.0146718342,
0.0088999793,
-0.0353279971,
-0.0433587767,
0.0127991745,
-0.1047175676,
0.0447081886,
-0.0258911345,
0.0437312834,
-0.0240933001,
-0.0704554766,
-0.0023043151,
-0.0325188302,
-0.0161268059,
-0.0105608376,
0.0143332286,
0.0384452231,
-0.0001372742,
-0.0168287884,
-0.0635664389,
0.0270462595,
0.0114865368,
0.0470756553,
0.058323089,
0.0012912244,
0.0146924546,
-0.0085018314,
-0.0124089848,
0.0067207017,
-0.0445362367,
-0.0080094822,
0.0415330864,
0.0418854952,
-0.0151450895,
-0.016578326,
0.0416433886,
-0.0562417507,
-0.0545676313,
0.0228427928,
0.0713984445,
-0.039217826,
-0.0432291254,
-0.0183211137,
0.0308342446,
0.0140671488,
0.0961755216,
0.0064909235,
0.011370033,
-0.0370820835,
-0.0729455799,
-0.026034154,
0.0036247156,
-0.0007970323,
0.0049446025,
0.0236614272,
-0.0629258081,
-0.0488752387,
0.0152348252,
0.0589641295,
0.0129155843,
-0.0057488629,
0.0061941221,
0.0330405943,
0.0240576863,
-0.0413916521,
0.0341767222,
-0.044102408,
0.0235174838,
-0.0160445254,
-0.0259694159,
0.0325076506,
-0.0289949924,
-0.0307305939,
0.0322309099,
-0.0991073325,
-0.0737378225,
-0.0239343159,
0.0301926956,
0.0369735099,
-0.0036294109,
-0.0283480138,
-0.0696459711,
0.0023022406,
0.0152024375,
-0.0088522369,
-0.0163275693,
0.0161639098,
0.0293377526,
0.0198520124,
0.0372558907,
-0.0318165272,
0.0059000989,
-0.0059980177,
0.0555778332,
-0.0390873998,
-0.0339419693,
-0.0017235985,
0.0153149152,
0.0306166392,
-0.0044607902,
-0.0202813074,
-0.0306728519,
0.0081959134,
-0.0419960879,
-0.0461615697,
-0.0110055488,
0.0449379608,
0.0168206766,
-0.0240687355,
-0.0188572034,
-0.0224684495,
-0.0387876593,
0.0085598668,
0.0138938408,
0.0112182582,
0.0548680723,
-0.0052516321,
0.0634130239,
-0.0645440444,
0.0188794006,
0.0184256062,
-0.0023820589,
0.0528011508,
0.0181792695,
0.0461417064,
0.0418523066,
-0.0236608125,
-0.0085707251,
-0.0523578674,
-0.0730788782,
-0.1013119593,
0.0388208851,
0.0564449653,
0.0276302509,
0.0226628687,
0.0415499359,
-0.0711182579,
-0.0189768858,
0.0025659737,
0.0285439268,
0.0645238534,
-0.0017626567,
0.0745728835,
0.0132453721,
-0.0404578745,
-0.0083454493,
0.0869492218,
0.0058379029,
0.0390618034,
-0.003282303,
-0.0570248105,
-0.0103406589,
-0.0636486262,
-0.013997132,
0.0290115662,
-0.0071539422,
0.0242912006,
-0.0512314439,
-0.0861341506,
-0.0385617651,
0.038482964,
-0.0202291608,
-0.016711466,
0.0111309718,
0.0521815233,
0.0032450471,
0.0029169135,
-0.0372193642,
0.0364858843,
-0.025260102,
-0.0129006198,
-0.0499738194,
-6.467571388e-33,
0.0030927947,
-0.0523873344,
0.0200861339,
-0.0294932872,
0.0475977249,
-0.0412636288,
-0.0448229462,
0.0143917361,
-0.011539178,
0.0471564606,
-0.0055519938,
0.0458129086,
0.022654647,
0.0505413115,
0.0239064693,
-0.0394788831,
-0.0113816066,
0.005779169,
-0.0056148302,
0.0097115804,
0.0426361337,
-0.0225241967,
0.0097919432,
-0.0509543791,
0.0324511714,
0.0032379604,
0.0037370736,
0.062102925,
-0.037325535,
0.0279927533,
-0.0016733879,
0.0319094397,
-0.0008847544,
-0.020636538,
0.0081381518,
0.034169957,
-0.051788263,
-0.0342573859,
0.0348689444,
-0.0157111101,
-0.0352763161,
-0.0470473208,
-0.0073898849,
0.0294974744,
-0.0034331637,
-0.0133204777,
0.0507317819,
-0.0470197499,
-0.0106408559,
-0.0177776944,
-0.0160008464,
0.0605499633,
-0.0120008113,
0.0039414885,
-0.0105666118,
-0.0032363678,
-0.0295386668,
0.0179530475,
0.0255053714,
0.0374737307,
0.0262868349,
0.0164847653,
0.0697476566,
0.002541787,
0.0177336223,
0.0242805127,
-0.0141394278,
-0.0185056683,
-0.0548080355,
-0.0113576939,
-0.0313802883,
0.0306899883,
0.0183197502,
0.031053463,
0.0281867813,
0.045568984,
-0.0884055793,
0.0175785851,
0.0417361856,
0.0252399314,
0.0580382161,
-0.0011599701,
-0.0260633789,
-0.0504011437,
-0.0614814609,
0.0030478374,
-0.0260860082,
-0.0040741451,
-0.0035677273,
-0.0308332872,
-0.0148019698,
-0.0096263131,
0.0031586699,
-0.0459540933,
-0.0404750891,
0.0265400782,
0.0139240883,
-0.010275824,
-0.017767977,
0.0542785414,
-0.0279179178,
0.0286542233,
0.0181256887,
-0.0281580649,
-0.0041425228,
0.0249927472,
0.0035227283,
-0.0200676024,
-0.0448662192,
-0.0105399461,
-0.0619940013,
0.0151337404,
-0.017837666,
0.0291130375,
0.026518723,
0.0445441417,
0.0232014153,
0.0318709761,
-0.0021525817,
-0.0002900993,
0.0010513945,
-0.0111030899,
-0.0122523019,
-0.0200222228,
-0.0471552275,
-0.0092592798,
-0.0526499972,
-0.0080981972,
0.022928156,
-0.0131460577,
-0.0143900197,
0.0474891849,
2.595e-7,
0.099782601,
0.0518230721,
-0.0008492399,
0.0759769827,
0.0356593728,
0.0260688253,
-0.0014559254,
-0.033466626,
0.041089166,
-0.0123818303,
0.0091767684,
0.0582937896,
0.0547920056,
0.0424692631,
-0.0581049882,
-0.0183386914,
-0.0516976453,
-0.0265838914,
-0.0270115193,
-0.01534223,
0.1010787264,
0.0914726481,
0.0282411333,
0.0207075942,
0.0250624586,
-0.0395083353,
0.0343683511,
-0.0361051224,
0.0038226373,
0.0346215889,
-0.0090768477,
-0.0170967598,
0.0159582943,
0.0395589843,
-0.0183006451,
-0.0370430239,
-0.0303796027,
0.0861856118,
-0.0011949734,
-0.0162495207,
-0.0350799859,
-0.0359398462,
0.0310982857,
-0.05192063,
0.107601963,
-0.0692600012,
-0.0559231266,
0.0126605062,
0.0068398481,
-0.0421717949,
-0.0071332362,
0.0087775504,
-0.0419453233,
-0.0032634684,
0.00003003,
-0.0070473277,
0.0074735079,
-0.0715896487,
-0.0147229517,
-0.0029837519,
-0.0508305579,
-0.0632008538,
0.0127208689,
-0.0054814671,
0.0290335063,
-0.0702809915,
0.0071680476,
2.602521763e-34,
0.0555077568,
0.0323328599,
-0.0381106846,
-0.0108018303,
0.0734906569,
-0.0070194248,
-0.0135479271,
0.025790425,
0.0441280343,
-0.1095411107,
-0.0172728933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09611v1 | Towards Privacy-Aware Sign Language Translation at Scale | 2024-02-14T22:57:03 | 2024-02-14T22:57:03 | Phillip Rust, Bowen Shi, Skyler Wang, Necati Cihan Camgöz, Jean Maillard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | A major impediment to the advancement of sign language translation (SLT) is
data scarcity. Much of the sign language data currently available on the web
cannot be used for training supervised models due to the lack of aligned
captions. Furthermore, scaling SLT using large-scale web-scraped datasets bears
privacy risks due to the presence of biometric information, which the
responsible development of SLT technologies should account for. In this work,
we propose a two-stage framework for privacy-aware SLT at scale that addresses
both of these issues. We introduce SSVP-SLT, which leverages self-supervised
video pretraining on anonymized and unannotated videos, followed by supervised
SLT finetuning on a curated parallel dataset. SSVP-SLT achieves
state-of-the-art finetuned and zero-shot gloss-free SLT performance on the
How2Sign dataset, outperforming the strongest respective baselines by over 3
BLEU-4. Based on controlled experiments, we further discuss the advantages and
limitations of self-supervised pretraining and anonymization via facial
obfuscation for SLT. | [
-0.0174346715,
0.0701591223,
-0.03925585,
0.0420541316,
0.0013644132,
0.0292207338,
0.0953060687,
-0.0129262004,
0.0647694543,
-0.0420219898,
-0.0398380831,
0.0217079781,
0.001712287,
0.0340326056,
0.0173306856,
-0.0558996797,
0.0279676113,
-0.0155889727,
-0.0296556614,
-0.0253258795,
0.0188980084,
0.0198127273,
-0.0226851422,
0.020312842,
-0.0531175658,
0.0041952631,
0.0013378608,
0.0361943543,
0.0587672554,
-0.0194893274,
-0.0422777198,
0.0559012033,
0.0810983256,
0.0411525667,
0.000001917,
-0.0298158266,
-0.0093309516,
0.0232271925,
0.0013071802,
0.0266599096,
0.0353126675,
-0.0767029673,
-0.0035026348,
0.0268482398,
-0.0501953363,
-0.0532054007,
0.0444821455,
0.0229931045,
0.025296241,
0.0219826326,
-0.0216802545,
-0.016321335,
-0.013219934,
-0.0477651954,
-0.0121745924,
-0.0350911915,
-0.0204411764,
-0.0505500175,
-0.0635356084,
-0.0208034217,
-0.0418048166,
0.0901135579,
0.0192134641,
-0.0374876857,
-0.0174692608,
0.0090712979,
-0.0569559336,
-0.0210573301,
0.0059323106,
0.0708099976,
-0.0252629686,
0.0139124617,
0.0238635112,
-0.0044287569,
0.0365488008,
0.0160939135,
0.0022160239,
0.0611181036,
0.0335418545,
-0.0125775961,
-0.0419297069,
0.0288281012,
0.0185098182,
-0.0228636302,
0.0140593993,
-0.0381382108,
0.0251809638,
0.0468988828,
-0.0401829965,
-0.0311773717,
0.0128433891,
-0.0461611189,
0.0782381892,
-0.0214050654,
0.0309792385,
-0.0057870829,
-0.0439596921,
-0.0213983729,
-0.0232995749,
-0.0068376036,
-0.0359537601,
0.0444162898,
0.0022963386,
0.0174351484,
0.0298006572,
0.0397558697,
-0.0264467448,
0.0544997454,
-0.0163993817,
0.0390137769,
-0.0060911267,
0.017798949,
-0.0484796166,
-0.0279711597,
-0.0476082563,
0.0050091315,
0.0110792527,
-0.0145589402,
-0.0098548969,
-0.0357077755,
-0.0236728918,
0.0056580384,
-0.0220035799,
-0.0041098725,
0.0278820656,
0.0160710625,
0.0020933857,
0.0200995281,
-0.0155979637,
-0.0707873777,
-0.0165738221,
-0.0076830722,
0.0164682232,
-0.0083254138,
-0.0059787631,
0.0363353826,
-0.0247819964,
-0.0204287916,
0.0145355621,
-0.0275951009,
0.0013240814,
-0.0311564654,
-0.0015116162,
-0.0325670987,
0.0473340377,
-0.0287832767,
0.0042605218,
-0.0553446449,
-0.0134938015,
0.0056568119,
0.0231457725,
0.071848616,
0.0009648216,
-0.0127310706,
0.0212474745,
0.0340844728,
-0.0049300506,
0.021005895,
0.0349202268,
0.0293483716,
0.033207491,
-0.0139996773,
0.0212080032,
0.047223188,
0.0529877208,
0.0291573126,
0.0070025227,
-0.0075173588,
0.0367860571,
0.0006368314,
-0.0211597383,
0.0352441408,
-0.016478939,
-0.0629446432,
0.0469229221,
0.0927007049,
-0.0275974963,
-0.0056348853,
-0.0384819582,
0.0585677922,
-0.0095611475,
-0.0445524417,
-0.0567482263,
0.034582179,
-0.0285452157,
-0.0636144951,
-0.0640932024,
0.0341725424,
-0.0514333323,
0.0058255214,
0.0128216753,
-0.0663027093,
0.0549716167,
0.0398923345,
-0.0003342532,
0.038488429,
0.0000023256,
0.0025475239,
-0.0352577753,
-0.0365492329,
0.0128760263,
-0.0181094948,
-0.0382269584,
0.0438424051,
0.0026450078,
0.0198415387,
-0.020693114,
-0.0281758644,
0.0061118025,
0.0018869106,
-0.0039298139,
-0.0007414258,
0.1043409929,
-0.0348433368,
-0.0440094769,
0.0392138958,
-0.0048761959,
0.0314473845,
-0.0377262384,
0.0307766385,
0.0421519764,
-0.0133101065,
0.0160927251,
0.033863157,
-0.0012966018,
-0.046694275,
0.054525312,
0.0363496505,
0.058740966,
0.0323855802,
-0.0069578844,
-0.0337889567,
0.0203857608,
-0.0068385149,
0.0058173984,
0.0397483222,
-0.0322971717,
-0.0507583879,
0.0148147326,
-0.0488064513,
-0.0198376197,
0.0450723805,
-0.0297510885,
-0.0448190272,
0.0254542045,
0.0102958893,
0.0269647483,
-0.0252636094,
0.003438344,
0.015948711,
0.0168795884,
-0.0290867537,
-0.0294202529,
-0.0070709134,
-0.0697648451,
-0.0531830825,
-0.0278501045,
0.0545292012,
-0.0461800247,
-0.0053888387,
0.021848375,
-0.0023277106,
0.0334583968,
0.0316575542,
0.0415765569,
-0.0191753842,
0.0142239258,
-0.0492915288,
-0.0009724562,
-0.0283523668,
0.0205467846,
-0.0018003088,
0.0130687179,
0.0114241298,
-0.0525958166,
-0.0495166071,
-0.0114147253,
-0.0231337305,
-0.0233323574,
-0.0243601464,
0.0083150845,
-0.0382771529,
0.0067135342,
-0.0321370438,
0.018271273,
-0.005001239,
0.0105176521,
-0.0018056862,
-0.0130081978,
-0.0019495311,
0.0082666064,
0.0357280113,
-0.0320750289,
-0.0254321098,
0.0128132999,
0.0229900051,
-0.0686360896,
-0.0020202633,
0.0042985617,
-0.0075779581,
0.0277897511,
-0.0023556096,
-0.0185235124,
-0.0216263458,
-0.0119498689,
-0.0020811541,
-0.0607452765,
-0.0086320015,
-0.012239242,
-0.0243344177,
0.0222882442,
0.0002543237,
-0.0828702524,
-0.0186799746,
-0.0038529811,
-0.0557401553,
-0.0042015011,
0.026503833,
0.0009850293,
-0.011197309,
0.003304224,
-0.0627674982,
0.0344593041,
-0.045059476,
-0.0229923073,
0.0522327051,
0.0199222323,
-0.0064164284,
0.0965150744,
0.0070666308,
0.0539989732,
-0.0238741785,
-0.0764612108,
-0.0186959356,
0.0214506984,
0.0438249484,
-0.0269258656,
-0.0121427672,
-0.0273153652,
-0.0208523851,
-0.0288619455,
-0.012852245,
0.0034624145,
-0.0766489953,
-0.0070952396,
-0.0181031469,
0.0093606971,
-0.0598227717,
-0.0065805931,
-0.014327026,
0.0046384069,
0.0307939667,
0.0183005016,
0.0095615862,
-0.007300565,
-0.0444979928,
-0.0126436101,
0.0059670284,
0.0042241961,
-0.0198232252,
0.0051214513,
0.0465461835,
0.029943049,
-0.0110555971,
0.0022086655,
-0.0217147991,
0.033285249,
0.0474204384,
-0.0260953475,
0.0103946161,
0.0535319783,
-0.0166732706,
0.0412076935,
0.0707276911,
-0.0054804753,
-0.040724773,
-0.0065854094,
0.0763715729,
0.0136993974,
0.0046910499,
-0.0345324092,
-0.1011401638,
-0.0400696285,
0.0026694746,
0.0814111978,
0.0206900071,
0.0067685116,
-0.0468875356,
-0.012553419,
0.0264578816,
0.04615229,
-0.064494133,
-0.0051650424,
0.0315843783,
0.006181126,
-0.0108755436,
0.016239563,
-0.0238395985,
-0.0275411438,
-0.0146429799,
-0.0020098768,
-0.0053176666,
-0.0752950236,
0.0327492133,
-0.0192672424,
0.0603481643,
0.0180891361,
0.0108980937,
0.0109447911,
-0.0634860322,
0.0105758375,
-0.0135229286,
0.0111868549,
-0.0405727103,
0.0753678828,
-0.0178791638,
-0.0053466582,
-0.007301786,
0.0752909556,
-0.0319679752,
-0.0070314421,
0.0363335498,
0.012028168,
-0.0233027264,
-0.0044782939,
0.028711075,
-0.073890768,
-0.0096604964,
0.0220673196,
-0.033325959,
-0.0062429374,
0.023653293,
-0.0023643016,
0.0320720561,
0.0652766898,
0.0046019638,
0.030551156,
-0.0283997189,
-0.1135118604,
-0.0190740731,
0.0018342272,
0.0364317521,
0.0385051593,
0.0222182684,
-0.0051069586,
0.0948411152,
0.0051516951,
-0.0359343626,
0.0523263998,
-0.0655180812,
0.0417120755,
-0.0241233204,
0.0040531885,
-0.0031992244,
-0.0285569914,
0.0287235621,
0.0190487392,
-0.0739656985,
-0.0780948997,
0.0189146828,
0.0177161191,
0.0087781651,
0.0588238575,
-0.0283945575,
-0.051265046,
0.0163316336,
0.0640718117,
-0.0171196889,
0.0028457453,
0.0669366568,
-0.0847776607,
-0.0269517042,
0.016647784,
0.0350646935,
-0.0069732238,
0.0239945855,
-0.0433133543,
-0.0828207135,
-0.0214681514,
-0.0360965542,
0.0553159565,
0.0225524064,
-0.0259414613,
0.0255972072,
-0.0439140424,
0.0248259604,
-0.0446660668,
0.0436510257,
-0.0672373325,
-0.015651131,
0.0552971028,
-0.0169324651,
0.0493430011,
0.026195582,
-0.0069261836,
-0.0001677387,
-0.0180080961,
0.0247769486,
-0.011913755,
0.0234543923,
0.0178014282,
0.0432303809,
-0.0017239791,
0.098633714,
0.022162145,
0.0168702994,
-0.0149790114,
0.0207828283,
0.0041326107,
0.0221568383,
0.0367776453,
0.051760722,
0.0202343557,
-0.0775066912,
-0.0408204794,
0.0210211966,
-0.0209602732,
0.0481924303,
0.0438224897,
-0.0309541933,
0.0269429758,
-0.0219210368,
0.0371377878,
-0.0252585355,
-0.0749242231,
0.0294053052,
-0.0508461446,
-0.0263596065,
0.0539331771,
0.0280142464,
-0.0303548742,
-0.0290843435,
-0.0088596521,
0.0070108217,
-0.0450685211,
-0.0324514546,
0.0086184377,
0.0052870456,
-0.0454391837,
0.0180125181,
-0.0079789655,
-0.0389038362,
-0.0448016487,
-0.0160673857,
-0.017464295,
0.0160003863,
0.046442885,
-0.0138056166,
-0.0262024533,
-0.0406472683,
-0.0248775426,
-0.0289733801,
0.0111009898,
-0.0095526055,
-0.0017048899,
-5.849680129e-33,
-0.0152926836,
-0.0240231305,
-0.0135345478,
-0.0011790664,
0.0135615123,
0.0260168463,
-0.0142598553,
0.0430946052,
-0.0064186198,
0.0063068308,
-0.0164707359,
0.0069189859,
0.0022358515,
0.0294573978,
-0.0207439736,
-0.031935703,
0.0574940816,
-0.0331733078,
-0.0068937186,
0.0632110238,
0.0405806825,
0.0024761036,
0.0701100826,
-0.1407815963,
0.0114952503,
-0.0395918451,
-0.0807812884,
-0.0039636455,
-0.0421670601,
-0.0046954202,
-0.0125306882,
-0.0364421383,
-0.0042857588,
0.0385691151,
-0.0041881981,
0.0027375116,
-0.0413876064,
0.0088300761,
-0.0377903692,
0.0852247551,
-0.0185955819,
0.0053910869,
0.018325679,
-0.0489989929,
-0.060242705,
0.0030885073,
-0.0057102176,
-0.0142680397,
0.0163246486,
-0.0396337397,
0.009672055,
0.0231315363,
-0.0424875766,
-0.0548131205,
0.0542507693,
0.0114591075,
-0.0143666202,
-0.0578141473,
-0.0272209253,
0.0176500957,
0.0075647533,
-0.0511516742,
0.1042372882,
-0.0412231199,
0.0577952862,
0.0089158705,
0.0254324153,
-0.0332620777,
0.040548604,
-0.0387301259,
0.0564652272,
0.0404656082,
0.021884514,
0.047107894,
0.0327265449,
-0.0671210364,
-0.0234406088,
0.012078641,
0.0038112423,
-0.0121664638,
-0.0066705798,
0.0267810393,
0.0052051395,
0.0121494038,
-0.0928853899,
0.0017642024,
0.0163102932,
0.0086777555,
0.0140281199,
0.0356886536,
-0.0171843152,
0.0017997791,
0.0711961314,
-0.0197108444,
-0.039340701,
0.0126646357,
0.0142228464,
0.0168555044,
0.0101053873,
0.0279228855,
-0.0362879299,
-0.0473896973,
0.0900834426,
-0.0436283015,
0.0363995843,
-0.0135790836,
0.0360190719,
0.0614140481,
-0.0285480134,
-0.0092553729,
-0.0154648013,
0.0695686862,
0.0228625946,
-0.0163286962,
0.0605702586,
-0.0252468158,
-0.0142871756,
0.0461469516,
0.0306449812,
0.0145262172,
-0.0243439041,
0.0568014123,
0.0022578125,
0.0244749915,
-0.0332374424,
-0.0076259202,
0.0239572562,
-0.067271091,
0.1010104567,
-0.0397868603,
0.0034583376,
0.0069914623,
2.613e-7,
-0.005400259,
0.013448962,
-0.0018591604,
-0.0125423549,
0.0132015953,
0.0904850885,
0.0156575926,
0.0699980184,
0.0085062161,
0.0132790292,
0.0085134935,
0.0137590794,
0.0449168198,
0.0334881879,
0.0008439353,
0.0258500371,
0.0343851671,
0.0391264819,
-0.0502457581,
0.0329032876,
0.0292930771,
0.0697449222,
0.0260255244,
-0.0204273816,
0.0367843062,
-0.0670780689,
0.0467720255,
-0.0341408886,
-0.015573035,
-0.0416072272,
0.0339722745,
0.0392716676,
-0.0413617529,
-0.0018487202,
-0.024098346,
0.0027032979,
-0.0405380987,
0.0541799963,
-0.0578146018,
0.0200776011,
0.0186171327,
-0.0316499583,
-0.0613002479,
0.0106025049,
0.043409247,
-0.012903288,
-0.0332732797,
-0.0145698143,
-0.0125358896,
-0.0273753218,
0.0526931807,
-0.0004981051,
0.0266176276,
0.0497915335,
0.0504445769,
-0.0357961319,
-0.0334754661,
-0.0892065465,
0.0018704138,
-0.0471720472,
-0.0027379245,
0.0135455634,
0.0052810423,
0.0408323109,
-0.0068221702,
0.0276739728,
0.0021620311,
1.812033611e-34,
0.001703472,
-0.0020206238,
0.0099850772,
-0.0370645933,
0.0359522775,
-0.0151435584,
0.0209928341,
0.0057264976,
-0.0075510326,
-0.0242117643,
-0.0230129752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09609v1 | LogicPrpBank: A Corpus for Logical Implication and Equivalence | 2024-02-14T22:36:07 | 2024-02-14T22:36:07 | Zhexiong Liu, Jing Zhang, Jiaying Lu, Wenjing Ma, Joyce C Ho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Logic reasoning has been critically needed in problem-solving and
decision-making. Although Language Models (LMs) have demonstrated capabilities
of handling multiple reasoning tasks (e.g., commonsense reasoning), their
ability to reason complex mathematical problems, specifically propositional
logic, remains largely underexplored. This lack of exploration can be
attributed to the limited availability of annotated corpora. Here, we present a
well-labeled propositional logic corpus, LogicPrpBank, containing 7093
Propositional Logic Statements (PLSs) across six mathematical subjects, to
study a brand-new task of reasoning logical implication and equivalence. We
benchmark LogicPrpBank with widely-used LMs to show that our corpus offers a
useful resource for this challenging task and there is ample room for model
improvement. | [
-0.0010891038,
0.0973655581,
-0.0174941923,
0.03203924,
-0.05045259,
0.0136666819,
0.0117443902,
0.0167995337,
0.0190362036,
-0.0186239481,
0.0071244272,
0.067441687,
-0.018303832,
0.0124616819,
0.0281636156,
-0.0431999825,
0.0533076487,
-0.0014583288,
0.0402817912,
0.0005826979,
0.0273842867,
0.0271141063,
-0.0363426991,
-0.0017164536,
-0.0152948331,
-0.0420678332,
0.042574998,
-0.0321344212,
0.024717886,
-0.0419634171,
-0.0321719162,
0.0542953722,
0.0108402846,
0.0039106053,
0.0000019936,
-0.0472141057,
-0.0044810907,
-0.0104720332,
-0.0147742955,
0.0000355704,
0.0335511267,
-0.011114914,
0.0258070398,
0.0060543483,
-0.05875393,
-0.013998,
0.0591083728,
0.0269075874,
0.0344079509,
0.0341209546,
-0.0179092716,
-0.0453422852,
-0.0104733901,
-0.0213191248,
-0.0117200408,
-0.0420558862,
0.0142932124,
0.0641780496,
0.0170236528,
-0.0082185315,
0.0090660015,
0.0253306702,
0.036586646,
-0.0007309598,
-0.0476682223,
0.0192102827,
-0.0368889645,
-0.001984759,
0.0275709461,
0.0440429896,
0.0309533514,
-0.0839721859,
0.0129371397,
0.0092699174,
-0.0131009556,
0.0058379131,
-0.013611923,
0.0471410044,
-0.0586375371,
0.030773459,
0.0345221572,
0.0353462659,
0.014558902,
0.0237764288,
-0.0365369804,
0.1190937385,
0.0155540323,
-0.023942057,
-0.0173679516,
0.0005376421,
-0.0878852755,
-0.0806906074,
0.0449006967,
0.0073192893,
0.0193238985,
0.0120308278,
-0.0287234075,
-0.0424743332,
0.0326094329,
-0.0582045577,
0.0184759293,
0.0601555482,
0.0170337595,
0.049127087,
-0.0569874682,
0.0193061177,
-0.0123315156,
0.0425951928,
-0.0558434948,
-0.0117157958,
-0.0607786775,
0.0020591547,
-0.0029611783,
0.0100345071,
-0.0006152763,
0.0360013582,
-0.0319280215,
-0.0107197808,
-0.0476805829,
0.0213620048,
-0.0153349526,
-0.0428175107,
-0.004811069,
-0.0341473967,
-0.0719706267,
0.0188755207,
-0.0615635514,
0.0420057289,
-0.0519523099,
-0.0507263914,
-0.0421541706,
0.0018208747,
-0.021874845,
-0.0283591524,
0.0358077697,
0.0488818623,
0.0115488134,
0.0486291237,
-0.0280933455,
-0.0102781728,
0.0464252084,
-0.0085300412,
-0.0086058155,
-0.0866587609,
0.0582378395,
0.0199183114,
-0.0228652395,
-0.0217384789,
-0.0023077161,
0.0616294034,
0.0384572782,
0.0486415513,
0.0084552905,
0.0112658544,
-0.0065224082,
-0.0243855361,
-0.0638387352,
0.0077258735,
-0.0005575035,
-0.0375477411,
0.014890708,
0.015439841,
-0.0259780642,
0.0177676696,
0.0306642167,
-0.0183068365,
-0.0187249836,
0.0272292774,
0.0167312715,
0.027599901,
0.0237871613,
0.040660914,
-0.0385641493,
-0.0393297672,
-0.0023093906,
0.0722930506,
-0.0035689673,
-0.0056204647,
-0.0055765449,
-0.0225721374,
0.0057310755,
-0.0051330156,
-0.0538152978,
0.0180766005,
-0.0028647566,
-0.0129402978,
-0.0358474217,
0.0270767473,
0.0181230437,
-0.0389477909,
-0.0406041034,
0.0002415129,
0.0101276869,
0.0006241593,
0.0168558918,
0.0211349335,
0.0357543193,
0.0977629945,
0.0621509403,
-0.0657831877,
-0.0306716301,
-0.0214758273,
0.0246810429,
-0.0168579277,
0.0025577897,
-0.0511904471,
-0.0222362988,
-0.0018166165,
0.0059044315,
0.0501981713,
0.0511367768,
-0.0099285785,
-0.0212791692,
-0.0246050321,
0.0267293211,
0.0114462255,
0.0369139463,
0.010687991,
0.0237018783,
0.0085566668,
0.0012078206,
-0.0475569442,
0.0278492365,
0.0252460185,
-0.0242261831,
-0.0051706717,
-0.0171062872,
-0.0231096689,
0.0092960801,
-0.0107094962,
0.0060484926,
0.0634838715,
-0.0215157438,
-0.0390918851,
-0.0147839887,
0.0420856401,
-0.036263749,
-0.0429884978,
0.0696737468,
-0.0708665848,
-0.0628848746,
0.0211913679,
-0.0657733753,
-0.0195022859,
0.0350425467,
-0.0332621001,
0.0403218456,
-0.0074571176,
-0.0213702898,
-0.0083942395,
-0.0303131472,
-0.0249184947,
0.0873835087,
0.0320512168,
0.0112895332,
-0.0253222547,
-0.0156582501,
0.0540786646,
-0.0093497932,
0.0221695527,
-0.0285906289,
-0.0090115368,
-0.0104671093,
0.0078636855,
0.0070319786,
-0.0096962564,
0.0105020255,
-0.0643477589,
0.0100536486,
0.0260351207,
0.0391956195,
0.0504923947,
-0.0300928783,
-0.0055794525,
-0.0291459449,
-0.0216356982,
-0.01786617,
0.0155967614,
0.0225479212,
0.0366688482,
-0.0318037197,
0.0138322469,
-0.0436367206,
-0.0360719152,
-0.067058064,
0.0261752717,
0.0309460592,
0.0134047223,
0.0524329133,
0.0133303264,
-0.0288319848,
0.0230510104,
0.0012727462,
0.0342941396,
0.0030166754,
-0.0209946223,
-0.0082828989,
0.0622325838,
-0.0030153303,
-0.0097988518,
0.0353521146,
-0.0282794423,
-0.0757135376,
-0.0044834493,
-0.0131692514,
0.0130903963,
-0.027339302,
-0.0431449004,
-0.0209631976,
0.0232879966,
0.0222850088,
-0.0108512221,
-0.0413580053,
0.0166281816,
-0.0362003967,
0.0122659225,
-0.0296989307,
0.0069834697,
0.0098345252,
0.0539226495,
-0.0079780389,
0.00269354,
0.076415427,
0.0009753383,
0.0258794203,
-0.0847262964,
-0.0120901838,
-0.0703652874,
0.0441404954,
0.0030897725,
-0.0035027615,
-0.0122833382,
-0.0100143077,
-0.0023341151,
-0.032905668,
0.0572143309,
-0.0178665593,
0.0447218642,
-0.0508228391,
0.0288416278,
-0.041931577,
-0.0598477125,
-0.0145241246,
-0.0366007723,
-0.0629621819,
-0.0057421862,
-0.0300430395,
-0.008895712,
-0.0300462283,
0.0048701102,
-0.0163576882,
0.0109922849,
0.0176279116,
-0.0096526919,
-0.0206586029,
-0.0165679902,
0.0114414683,
0.0623465106,
0.0440855101,
0.0079037864,
-0.031024674,
0.0422355011,
0.0075739566,
0.0223991778,
-0.0270420592,
0.0329133607,
-0.0137125002,
-0.0509590283,
0.003645832,
-0.0088388585,
-0.0085856589,
-0.0521919131,
0.0171495304,
0.0900475979,
0.0271316916,
0.0199848227,
0.0075612091,
-0.0698291287,
0.0220688824,
0.0036625804,
0.0014288784,
-0.0984498039,
-0.0458782278,
0.0020199309,
-0.028519284,
0.0021268991,
-0.0439775586,
0.0126710692,
-0.0924685076,
0.0098129287,
0.0073006242,
-0.0168105382,
0.0033921215,
-0.0543022193,
0.0280507002,
-0.0478471294,
-0.0570993349,
0.0132913841,
-0.0085519832,
0.03537466,
0.0130216759,
0.0133311758,
-0.022076901,
0.0444604978,
-0.0623656586,
0.0014122701,
0.0307439342,
0.033271011,
-0.0249535963,
-0.0650862381,
-0.0061361007,
0.0035500398,
-0.0609503463,
-0.0194332693,
-0.0290483218,
0.0082730604,
0.0071200402,
-0.0546103641,
0.048169475,
-0.0786622912,
-0.0472889878,
0.0372275263,
0.0664167777,
0.0141270161,
-0.0088562006,
-0.058851324,
0.0385008864,
-0.0464650393,
0.0945428982,
0.0047959336,
0.0552953593,
-0.045526199,
-0.0065971273,
-0.0405750237,
-0.0479382947,
-0.0042016981,
-0.0033907436,
0.0416978821,
-0.0174602102,
-0.0425139479,
0.0100475959,
0.0161636695,
-0.0152855963,
-0.0191751532,
-0.0245937631,
0.0713599473,
-0.0407740362,
-0.0491821766,
0.0640408769,
-0.0276854988,
0.0153242238,
-0.0080564506,
0.0163635612,
0.012765144,
0.0315192752,
-0.0733052567,
0.0323508568,
-0.0647874027,
-0.0132961636,
-0.0113274641,
-0.0086957794,
0.0211800486,
-0.0034398341,
-0.0250789095,
0.03931183,
-0.0101406425,
0.0506111458,
-0.0287456959,
0.0377335772,
0.0353364013,
0.0004310813,
0.0300962068,
0.0061072125,
0.0237648375,
0.0322674662,
0.0219156723,
0.0383526832,
-0.0264797155,
-0.0523908064,
0.0200656075,
0.0526905842,
-0.0227752179,
0.0544225872,
0.0005490009,
-0.004096854,
-0.0089894449,
-0.015577266,
-0.0182109252,
-0.0092094131,
0.0286317226,
0.0287487451,
-0.0182155166,
-0.0185932517,
0.0068050958,
0.0004625276,
0.0263857692,
0.047040157,
0.0348694921,
0.0783121884,
0.0007438755,
-0.0068635922,
-0.0705771521,
-0.0079621989,
-0.0106819281,
-0.0484637432,
0.0523312017,
-0.0408651382,
0.0312106051,
0.0509457588,
-0.0014295503,
-0.0227247793,
0.0155215682,
-0.0462114215,
-0.0625756234,
0.0271759704,
0.0316470899,
0.0199752469,
-0.000645733,
0.0231220294,
-0.0326401405,
-0.0040519601,
0.0123256641,
0.0228991676,
0.0257382486,
-0.0179032106,
0.0675056055,
-0.0068692719,
-0.0056916992,
-0.0401227176,
0.0411488451,
-0.0962956399,
0.0453909077,
0.0338325873,
0.005729741,
-0.0122763859,
-0.061475601,
-0.0170340631,
-0.0129347537,
0.0070564705,
0.0210501291,
-0.0675102025,
-0.0578154251,
0.030169962,
0.0431032218,
0.0237634405,
0.0243853442,
0.0158203859,
0.0742712989,
0.0352600254,
-0.0632430539,
0.0027610487,
0.0660454109,
-0.0598885901,
-0.0266742483,
-0.0792005435,
-5.849353929e-33,
-0.0593379624,
-0.0031502845,
0.029463483,
-0.0270859599,
0.0237844214,
-0.0388838351,
-0.0528457798,
-0.0251209848,
-0.0430649631,
0.0269888565,
0.0094679333,
0.0610010885,
0.0135017019,
0.0092324084,
0.0340105183,
-0.0048800898,
0.0101020001,
0.011570639,
-0.0255547985,
-0.0310160145,
0.0391359329,
-0.0489726774,
0.0165501069,
-0.0462953076,
-0.013489305,
0.0018750844,
0.0012001417,
0.0293923318,
-0.0774282888,
0.0580932721,
-0.0205759723,
-0.0001454486,
0.0173482113,
0.0141232722,
-0.0087172268,
0.062630035,
-0.0483243428,
-0.0382150374,
0.0421433002,
-0.0299938414,
-0.0083600143,
-0.0103309052,
0.0142528052,
0.0191900823,
-0.016924873,
-0.0474721305,
0.0468551777,
-0.035614796,
0.0330296308,
-0.0014587719,
-0.0518031716,
0.0443589091,
-0.0217534397,
0.0066352068,
-0.0102306008,
0.0213268735,
-0.0217280779,
0.0152107701,
-0.0340108611,
0.0292321015,
-0.0061118901,
0.023728881,
0.0386844203,
-0.0602270588,
0.0042360751,
0.0216223467,
-0.041148413,
-0.0564059876,
-0.0093891816,
0.0896956027,
0.0337388478,
0.0665650591,
0.0658331513,
0.0502702035,
0.0659451261,
0.0203650035,
-0.0496454723,
0.0197661947,
0.0047922777,
0.0649254844,
-0.0077958778,
0.0074098418,
-0.022429524,
-0.0038687878,
-0.0521016866,
-0.0106873354,
-0.037427295,
-0.0082838656,
0.0083564827,
-0.0653234348,
0.0056246058,
0.0183564778,
0.0103488769,
-0.0345415995,
-0.0326504856,
-0.0105166733,
0.0289807618,
-0.0174539518,
0.0135201542,
0.0807443857,
-0.0445810035,
-0.0102037527,
0.0011102305,
0.0156286564,
0.03955153,
0.0159835462,
0.0185542852,
-0.029182924,
-0.0026539478,
-0.0159979723,
-0.0105394172,
-0.0399469212,
-0.0281501953,
0.0429825783,
0.0365326405,
0.0772662386,
0.0375605673,
0.0140218381,
-0.0068567744,
-0.0009126945,
-0.0304785147,
0.0427921601,
0.002155341,
0.0448254049,
0.0071997731,
0.001239559,
-0.058173053,
0.0000462082,
0.0156924222,
-0.0390511751,
0.0201199464,
0.0335619114,
2.674e-7,
0.0469252057,
0.0114463279,
0.035706412,
0.0584907047,
-0.000575467,
0.0588830002,
0.0160851683,
0.0147634707,
0.0149408616,
-0.0218605455,
-0.0251356978,
0.0369439274,
0.0200491771,
0.0465144999,
-0.0147025213,
0.0215306561,
-0.0884315744,
-0.0385561362,
-0.0478400365,
0.0304109994,
0.1319587976,
0.0505622998,
0.0599425733,
-0.018489141,
0.0091730952,
-0.0410184264,
0.0374239981,
0.0049661738,
-0.0054038949,
0.020121133,
0.0108653707,
-0.0458645858,
0.0404177792,
0.0496343598,
-0.00436666,
0.0091282642,
0.0050704503,
0.0618937425,
0.0194060802,
0.0077749877,
-0.062792927,
-0.042623397,
0.0042099436,
-0.0521282293,
0.0662514195,
-0.0725656375,
-0.0219717342,
-0.0240384787,
-0.0272131953,
0.0108918492,
0.0119645754,
0.0172470398,
-0.0299992245,
-0.005074665,
0.0529217534,
-0.0063024261,
-0.0382410698,
-0.0511603765,
-0.0162489135,
0.0166708324,
-0.0556201786,
-0.0181110241,
-0.029358983,
0.0466390774,
0.0344486311,
-0.0556688346,
-0.0267619044,
2.503557078e-34,
0.0101936786,
0.0006646823,
0.0083815046,
-0.0067642066,
0.0728467703,
0.010611577,
-0.0407195278,
0.0318677723,
-0.0010961592,
-0.0634014234,
0.0037384694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09588v2 | Emerging Opportunities of Using Large Language Models for Translation Between Drug Molecules and Indications | 2024-02-14T21:33:13 | 2024-02-16T20:55:08 | David Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Chengxi Zang, Junmei Wang, Lianjin Cai, Jan Zawala, Yanshan Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | A drug molecule is a substance that changes the organism's mental or physical
state. Every approved drug has an indication, which refers to the therapeutic
use of that drug for treating a particular medical condition. While the Large
Language Model (LLM), a generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) technique, has
recently demonstrated effectiveness in translating between molecules and their
textual descriptions, there remains a gap in research regarding their
application in facilitating the translation between drug molecules and
indications, or vice versa, which could greatly benefit the drug discovery
process. The capability of generating a drug from a given indication would
allow for the discovery of drugs targeting specific diseases or targets and
ultimately provide patients with better treatments. In this paper, we first
propose a new task, which is the translation between drug molecules and
corresponding indications, and then test existing LLMs on this new task.
Specifically, we consider nine variations of the T5 LLM and evaluate them on
two public datasets obtained from ChEMBL and DrugBank. Our experiments show the
early results of using LLMs for this task and provide a perspective on the
state-of-the-art. We also emphasize the current limitations and discuss future
work that has the potential to improve the performance on this task. The
creation of molecules from indications, or vice versa, will allow for more
efficient targeting of diseases and significantly reduce the cost of drug
discovery, with the potential to revolutionize the field of drug discovery in
the era of generative AI. | [
0.0423451811,
0.0587179177,
-0.0110250199,
0.0228752233,
-0.013341235,
0.0011285247,
0.0272904523,
0.0193159953,
0.0353252478,
-0.0249004122,
0.0132782683,
-0.0308277979,
-0.0115866233,
0.0571333319,
0.0386427641,
-0.0101035181,
0.0142364688,
-0.0117316451,
-0.0209408458,
-0.0112831118,
-0.0261174608,
0.0043163304,
0.0323674753,
0.0106359189,
0.0217550546,
-0.0156883188,
0.0424492173,
-0.0119938934,
0.022455167,
-0.0370169804,
-0.0419830419,
0.0217385441,
0.0007761901,
0.0519046485,
0.0000014875,
-0.0631141886,
-0.0466852821,
0.0347122438,
0.0128772445,
-0.0400961339,
0.0800202042,
-0.0689801425,
-0.0109411543,
-0.0050768205,
-0.0376450643,
-0.0080470145,
0.0591618828,
0.0216396172,
0.0018418945,
0.0745860934,
-0.0087202471,
-0.060194511,
0.0537677929,
-0.0275603496,
0.0675295368,
-0.0451677814,
0.069988817,
0.0258589406,
0.026565738,
0.0167956837,
-0.0055347374,
0.0338885225,
-0.0424413942,
-0.0358811021,
0.0399480797,
0.0121259112,
0.0094915982,
-0.0462817587,
0.0020393864,
0.0817126185,
-0.0394075029,
-0.0419214927,
-0.0206473544,
0.0277429596,
-0.0169318654,
0.0207012165,
-0.0235679112,
0.0221631788,
-0.0014520496,
0.0302213673,
0.0639830753,
0.0004239451,
0.0398297086,
-0.0118502285,
-0.0223579966,
0.0213587303,
0.0194156282,
-0.0122974329,
-0.0072631133,
-0.0278560501,
-0.0507288687,
-0.0231701657,
0.0436160415,
0.0018023448,
-0.003609386,
0.0384055562,
-0.013615679,
-0.031648118,
0.052668415,
-0.054074686,
0.0316123888,
0.0022178325,
0.0225736052,
0.0555649213,
-0.041227825,
0.0217051972,
-0.0441611223,
0.0105927223,
-0.094785288,
-0.000178414,
-0.0761523172,
0.0058991024,
-0.0502560996,
0.0040040654,
-0.0250099879,
-0.0518587828,
-0.0718508437,
0.032312464,
0.0053026523,
-0.0092271846,
0.0187537987,
0.0149277216,
-0.0351248384,
0.0146186426,
-0.0158081409,
-0.0006752482,
0.0112599516,
-0.009669194,
-0.0327403359,
-0.0232283566,
-0.0117463442,
0.0016208718,
-0.0121695166,
-0.0229952447,
-0.0078180209,
0.1144375354,
0.0140453056,
-0.0212135464,
0.003318527,
-0.0593542941,
-0.0096307108,
-0.0548144318,
0.0367746726,
-0.0536702275,
0.0698376298,
0.0043162336,
0.0029785559,
-0.069043979,
0.0243628845,
-0.0119879711,
-0.0490348563,
0.1068875864,
-0.0272816438,
-0.0257700551,
0.0548544489,
-0.0108152013,
-0.0125728119,
-0.0226297304,
0.0262188055,
0.0289391279,
0.0220946688,
0.0089520123,
0.0151886679,
0.009364197,
0.0035108225,
-0.0541733578,
0.004487969,
-0.0090747308,
0.033238098,
0.0809123218,
-0.0340866596,
0.0311220326,
-0.0033649029,
-0.0006896367,
0.0558965132,
0.0664605573,
0.0613917299,
0.0389634259,
0.0318650305,
-0.0171945915,
-0.0275555272,
-0.061397396,
0.0011577829,
0.0121141765,
-0.0453091934,
0.0159106702,
0.0356077515,
0.023531951,
0.0306726713,
0.0028590795,
-0.0140239876,
-0.0186730698,
-0.0028267761,
-0.0368029475,
0.0388096012,
-0.0257261749,
-0.0751365572,
-0.0045730555,
0.0526571237,
-0.0064031468,
-0.0098916134,
-0.0269233976,
0.0099441251,
0.0829432979,
0.0555127636,
-0.018809801,
-0.0071076197,
0.0069995481,
-0.059009023,
0.0469388589,
0.0154803582,
-0.0296653379,
-0.0397373997,
-0.0094827134,
-0.0055600377,
0.0014268775,
-0.0090860268,
-0.0110663315,
-0.0199798793,
0.0159503464,
-0.0004769182,
-0.0482160449,
-0.0126247751,
0.0263509061,
-0.0227126125,
-0.0296437424,
0.022054594,
-0.0022043702,
0.0259707607,
0.0166793931,
0.0096076187,
0.0466685146,
0.0528202467,
-0.0864131972,
-0.0306228716,
-0.0255592726,
0.0358682945,
-0.0485015772,
0.0240676682,
-0.0428687483,
0.0481482893,
-0.0366520844,
-0.0516029447,
-0.0351002403,
0.0514605753,
-0.0130914431,
0.0018991076,
0.0008138443,
0.0357334875,
0.0194475241,
0.0540316701,
-0.0566765293,
0.037833672,
0.0329168588,
-0.0270423889,
0.0092452168,
-0.0242899321,
0.01596931,
-0.009592141,
0.0261992738,
0.050966952,
0.0525083095,
0.0165397432,
0.0056616687,
-0.0167503878,
0.0020509255,
-0.0334180072,
-0.0138598783,
-0.0071124677,
0.0448676161,
0.0226223785,
0.0103643257,
0.0041241585,
0.0167600773,
0.014282193,
-0.0321027115,
-0.0078610284,
-0.0280691534,
-0.0136562046,
0.0120487707,
0.0419320501,
-0.0823536292,
-0.0503391959,
-0.0299368128,
-0.0320916586,
0.0780695751,
0.0003664636,
-0.0563609935,
-0.0313318036,
0.0046774298,
-0.0160189662,
0.0270070471,
0.0052784709,
0.0040549454,
-0.0075131766,
-0.0086453585,
0.0283762831,
0.0158259273,
-0.0139868464,
0.0165948961,
0.070698306,
0.0195965096,
0.0063375565,
-0.0045598559,
-0.0398553014,
-0.0229546968,
0.0261550508,
-0.0518409424,
-0.0212403238,
0.0523330085,
0.0236215424,
-0.001122441,
-0.029068891,
0.0150592597,
-0.0157881621,
-0.035506431,
-0.0356391594,
0.0237475168,
-0.0133783324,
0.0368708894,
0.0057089427,
-0.0638309345,
0.0778639689,
-0.0296070501,
0.0417005718,
-0.0760188997,
0.0091514932,
-0.0030805406,
-0.0134610301,
0.0378558002,
0.0310799498,
0.0115248375,
0.0376013666,
0.042933818,
-0.0000857106,
0.0134633919,
-0.026322512,
0.0613641702,
-0.0364032052,
0.0342027284,
0.0096328892,
-0.0191242304,
-0.0088742999,
0.0219322443,
0.0021965317,
0.0209082849,
0.0741051883,
-0.0322954319,
-0.0158085153,
0.0489419885,
-0.0183673259,
0.010067421,
-0.0005997947,
-0.0062283641,
-0.011801118,
-0.0384019092,
0.0344215371,
-0.0897642896,
0.0060981894,
-0.0203601606,
0.0634461641,
0.0151046235,
-0.0330404155,
0.0214422736,
-0.0074915932,
0.0361975953,
-0.0020479187,
-0.0094790347,
-0.0398388766,
0.0062515913,
-0.0210445765,
-0.0256368686,
-0.0272732954,
0.1071072519,
0.0422155298,
-0.023059113,
0.0407356732,
-0.0071381736,
-0.08451996,
-0.0444901027,
0.0635449588,
-0.1203886792,
-0.0281458404,
-0.0442775376,
0.023520736,
-0.0196703002,
-0.0325615443,
-0.031070672,
-0.0444997102,
0.0530749373,
0.0412840284,
-0.0505016111,
-0.0161917675,
-0.057881128,
-0.0390157141,
-0.0209985841,
-0.0084876092,
0.0094075212,
0.0260845944,
-0.0137731349,
-0.0074728164,
0.0037795939,
-0.0906539634,
0.0181919634,
-0.0118200155,
0.020516634,
0.0606757775,
0.0413926914,
0.0273146741,
0.0002526009,
-0.0261842012,
0.0291762408,
0.0115559353,
-0.0182638429,
0.0376344658,
0.0308077708,
-0.006784596,
-0.036113441,
0.0330478884,
-0.0670403317,
-0.032328397,
-0.0606954321,
0.1040143818,
-0.024957709,
-0.0417026207,
-0.0593363494,
0.0112823183,
0.0010397288,
0.0794668943,
-0.0042768097,
-0.0088990582,
-0.0502882376,
-0.0275770035,
-0.0050757001,
-0.0584229901,
-0.0084379148,
-0.0112741524,
-0.0431307182,
-0.0197416171,
-0.0832790136,
-0.0141554642,
0.062517412,
-0.0172553211,
0.0121126696,
0.0362288728,
0.0322946161,
-0.0631550252,
-0.0274734665,
0.0116630532,
0.029644791,
0.0414939597,
-0.0464601554,
-0.0696490109,
0.0406554788,
-0.023132829,
0.006508464,
0.045765806,
-0.0643919483,
-0.058453273,
-0.014859586,
0.0079600774,
0.0270736832,
-0.0217463188,
-0.0291722622,
-0.0172543973,
0.043430645,
0.0428704843,
0.0318362601,
-0.048824802,
-0.0449375957,
0.0104583669,
-0.0199774522,
0.0087531283,
-0.0202559009,
0.0435265712,
-0.0097686695,
0.0371552482,
0.015967438,
-0.0209621601,
0.0787659362,
0.0417015217,
0.0022917797,
-0.0278062038,
-0.0118991695,
-0.0264621358,
-0.0039278031,
-0.0326249003,
0.0040680952,
-0.0106426338,
-0.02943887,
0.0635783523,
-0.0194672551,
0.0024479853,
0.0019134496,
-0.050715059,
-0.0479706042,
-0.0065471889,
0.007176965,
0.0004584359,
0.01118044,
0.0810556933,
-0.0075107045,
0.0203644,
0.0135348774,
-0.0518132076,
0.0175965354,
-0.0458252877,
0.0362144224,
-0.0054365471,
0.0475949161,
-0.0361093543,
0.0406441167,
0.0039043967,
-0.0473766364,
-0.0556289926,
0.0503455997,
0.0857298747,
0.0094235912,
0.0727855712,
-0.0189636946,
-0.0255982764,
-0.038816575,
0.0203933958,
0.0198035222,
-0.0125243524,
0.0401099548,
-0.000570783,
-0.0210906677,
-0.0495701954,
0.0784023106,
0.0082591008,
0.0412574336,
-0.0145605048,
-0.0528486669,
-0.0273286346,
0.0014543075,
0.0021818157,
-0.0376237482,
-0.047474198,
0.0180916451,
-0.0349994823,
-0.0445392169,
0.0235280488,
0.0264721531,
0.0043750498,
0.0349106938,
0.0027840475,
0.0670660883,
0.0247300211,
-0.0751170516,
-0.0479258113,
0.0230539665,
0.0051437905,
-0.0488611832,
-0.0383894891,
-4.913163412e-33,
0.0198009312,
-0.0163618438,
0.0023375815,
-0.0050833668,
0.0254512709,
-0.0145869981,
-0.0768900961,
-0.0289278142,
0.0443256088,
0.0550312065,
0.0280764028,
-0.0245995317,
0.0007099909,
-0.0197205935,
-0.0057771057,
0.0181273688,
0.0214894116,
0.0072158752,
0.0135927657,
0.0215384625,
0.0447261818,
0.0407350175,
0.0398766622,
-0.0182951875,
0.0203088559,
0.0128830764,
0.0112472214,
-0.0143001843,
-0.0315138213,
0.0552109368,
-0.0317138322,
0.045345407,
-0.0123095391,
-0.0360020846,
-0.0230076145,
-0.0174268167,
-0.0278358608,
0.0280593541,
0.0254436489,
-0.0207171384,
-0.0147022624,
-0.0431992598,
0.0274379626,
-0.0022340894,
-0.0315700322,
0.0135759534,
0.0166025423,
-0.0498853289,
-0.0332021378,
-0.0536432154,
-0.0995199978,
0.0182870757,
0.0140307592,
-0.0005187849,
0.0000882905,
-0.0341088809,
-0.001409227,
0.0241368264,
-0.0007639657,
0.0550020188,
0.018809421,
0.0219776742,
0.0608438924,
-0.0045073582,
0.0004746441,
0.0376336984,
-0.0086195497,
0.0033441873,
0.0454626195,
0.0020776105,
-0.0172160473,
0.0506756455,
0.0120392367,
0.0223323554,
0.0283533689,
0.0040013618,
-0.0711617693,
0.0197458584,
-0.0457371064,
0.0012458082,
0.0188749656,
0.0380497314,
-0.0050469353,
-0.0175299849,
-0.0263520982,
0.0348436683,
-0.0212319605,
-0.0294351857,
0.0015561634,
-0.0349383689,
-0.0385541096,
0.0191848613,
0.0244872551,
-0.0622911938,
-0.0204933137,
-0.0053197779,
0.0041213362,
0.0196462646,
-0.0508485213,
0.0036387499,
-0.0451997668,
-0.0544425957,
0.046857141,
-0.0372280702,
0.0150183234,
0.0170140471,
0.0108405584,
-0.0140613131,
-0.0161687732,
0.0172651354,
-0.0559988394,
-0.0059453198,
0.0243326072,
0.016915733,
0.0084361928,
0.0302128755,
0.0147359744,
0.0389161408,
0.0372907929,
-0.0205179285,
0.0172876138,
0.0205675047,
0.0336708277,
0.0233141221,
-0.1006110013,
0.0289071165,
-0.0387254059,
0.0222817771,
0.0472825803,
-0.0650050342,
-0.0462989546,
0.0030524426,
2.463e-7,
0.0857931077,
0.0549983904,
0.0106367078,
0.0416916162,
0.0081379795,
0.0132740568,
0.0020704146,
0.0515301563,
-0.0337495022,
0.0081795873,
0.0353622399,
-0.0042172777,
0.0292327367,
-0.009713958,
0.001510796,
0.0249397084,
-0.0223356243,
-0.0313873924,
-0.0654532313,
-0.0007061554,
0.0476115644,
0.0902021304,
0.016221514,
-0.0256939605,
0.0260920208,
-0.0296367295,
0.0268994048,
-0.0466704704,
-0.0206500031,
0.066247724,
-0.0107065653,
-0.0220016763,
-0.012148683,
0.0557484664,
-0.0171508044,
-0.020936124,
0.0066217408,
0.043575231,
-0.0561687686,
0.0288896635,
0.0236818492,
-0.0404898226,
0.0250212234,
-0.025796786,
-0.0084025823,
-0.0447302014,
-0.0551824942,
-0.0006825606,
-0.0115499534,
0.0086021675,
0.014660676,
-0.0229117293,
0.0148315206,
0.0444167852,
0.0177159756,
0.0533927344,
-0.0060067335,
-0.0454849005,
0.0156461261,
0.0313421115,
-0.0355719402,
0.0164706744,
-0.003941894,
-0.0064396849,
0.0214532036,
-0.0671303421,
-0.0008765553,
2.115513995e-34,
0.0572620779,
0.0045536105,
0.009856849,
0.000521515,
0.0729537457,
-0.0122041199,
0.0260783955,
0.0100397058,
-0.0333316661,
-0.1047059372,
-0.0274959467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09573v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09573v2 | Changes by Butterflies: Farsighted Forecasting with Group Reservoir Transformer | 2024-02-14T20:48:58 | 2024-06-13T21:22:02 | Md Kowsher, Abdul Rafae Khan, Jia Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In Chaos, a minor divergence between two initial conditions exhibits
exponential amplification over time, leading to far-away outcomes, known as the
butterfly effect. Thus, the distant future is full of uncertainty and hard to
forecast. We introduce Group Reservoir Transformer to predict long-term events
more accurately and robustly by overcoming two challenges in Chaos: (1) the
extensive historical sequences and (2) the sensitivity to initial conditions. A
reservoir is attached to a Transformer to efficiently handle arbitrarily long
historical lengths, with an extension of a group of reservoirs to reduce the
sensitivity to the initialization variations. Our architecture consistently
outperforms state-of-the-art models in multivariate time series, including
TimeLLM, GPT2TS, PatchTST, DLinear, TimeNet, and the baseline Transformer, with
an error reduction of up to -59\% in various fields such as ETTh, ETTm, and air
quality, demonstrating that an ensemble of butterfly learning can improve the
adequacy and certainty of event prediction, despite of the traveling time to
the unknown future. | [
-0.0441724472,
0.0837196335,
-0.0188837592,
-0.0205818377,
-0.0392198674,
-0.0115238242,
-0.0098702675,
-0.0164224617,
-0.0395683348,
0.033637464,
0.0328124873,
-0.0202940684,
-0.0074643772,
0.0258361939,
0.0318377689,
-0.054301478,
0.0516128093,
0.0173661709,
-0.0785647556,
-0.0212018434,
-0.0155809093,
-0.0619446039,
0.0270140022,
0.0408692919,
0.0060433499,
-0.0006993805,
-0.0738790408,
0.00177376,
0.0496491976,
-0.0459677652,
0.0145309521,
-0.0054699392,
0.0302835517,
0.0565990806,
0.0000022606,
-0.0006900142,
-0.0208195113,
-0.0111220861,
0.0312157311,
-0.0267903041,
-0.0018672288,
-0.0259877481,
0.0239963662,
0.0105977375,
-0.0655013472,
0.0164208431,
0.0204785205,
0.0003551185,
0.0920499489,
0.0235539936,
-0.0099285832,
-0.0105931154,
0.068958126,
-0.0367628261,
0.0442308933,
-0.0379854776,
-0.0067215748,
-0.1038236097,
0.0325026885,
-0.0313419849,
-0.0451230556,
0.0454261489,
0.0144164888,
0.0236167293,
0.0236538928,
0.0353625715,
0.0259310212,
-0.0154505689,
-0.0538169183,
0.001814434,
-0.0258628894,
-0.004877897,
-0.0203614645,
0.0200848076,
-0.0158677436,
0.0595707633,
-0.0615594387,
-0.034615092,
0.0296291504,
0.0202068575,
-0.0017882828,
0.0270067882,
0.0011634722,
0.0141864251,
-0.050199084,
0.067088984,
-0.0019299134,
0.0082229674,
-0.0689159781,
0.0035107469,
-0.0024246708,
0.0274778437,
-0.0172633044,
0.0426767133,
-0.0240490027,
-0.023144776,
0.0237257909,
-0.0108629651,
-0.0272873808,
-0.0029690792,
0.0320945531,
0.0368230902,
0.0009546794,
-0.0007231987,
-0.0470466353,
0.0327374823,
-0.0847149566,
0.0157158617,
0.0275393613,
-0.0027908576,
-0.067910485,
0.0040316107,
0.0284125395,
0.0090567684,
0.0067817243,
0.0043350845,
-0.0299854707,
-0.0001777436,
-0.0410323367,
0.0267131571,
0.0349724256,
0.0506901816,
0.015178252,
-0.0223055705,
-0.0066866698,
0.0012910531,
0.0229997598,
0.0248273127,
0.0328672789,
-0.0286311507,
-0.0462637693,
-0.0446544886,
0.01084112,
0.0644568056,
-0.0006712509,
0.0578840114,
0.029602712,
0.0027325661,
-0.0701442808,
0.060457401,
-0.0012174451,
-0.0106230276,
0.006657484,
-0.0043647913,
-0.0131272469,
-0.0386872515,
0.0385360755,
0.0459690988,
0.010889763,
-0.0364375003,
-0.0283972602,
0.0519577824,
0.0022366347,
-0.0255934503,
0.0083121574,
-0.0070956456,
0.0119077275,
0.0427774228,
0.0467911437,
0.019272618,
-0.0028826257,
0.0041935318,
0.0240651648,
-0.0080577685,
0.0073919068,
-0.0095726959,
-0.0214251801,
-0.0291040968,
-0.0244381242,
-0.0184940565,
-0.0233836994,
-0.0195030812,
0.0078070611,
-0.035725113,
0.0456879213,
-0.0293879695,
-0.0055042184,
0.0550554506,
0.0355386063,
-0.0192871504,
-0.0640545338,
-0.0324079245,
-0.0412709303,
0.0793175176,
-0.0339839011,
-0.0001246211,
-0.0042816973,
0.0324720405,
-0.0356628746,
-0.0116082933,
-0.0074446579,
-0.0217821095,
0.0102090035,
-0.0501615442,
0.0106551396,
0.0141393123,
-0.0415922068,
0.0880171731,
0.0075219567,
0.0018339904,
-0.001151035,
-0.004221722,
0.0116940681,
0.0404942222,
-0.0056506852,
-0.0375014022,
-0.0475789644,
-0.0545464754,
-0.0084437113,
-0.0084548974,
-0.0034173178,
0.0499396957,
-0.0095459726,
-0.0141132344,
-0.045368351,
0.0999269187,
0.0150629329,
-0.0016407749,
0.0009509967,
0.0622443371,
-0.0010649678,
0.0230988748,
0.0096390024,
-0.0113651147,
-0.0269049834,
-0.0246844999,
0.0179349706,
-0.0022584836,
0.0470494814,
-0.0362960845,
0.0075143678,
0.0018582507,
0.036424391,
-0.023911817,
-0.0808622539,
0.0329409651,
-0.0706911236,
0.009665072,
-0.0185573883,
0.0293888394,
0.0596888997,
0.0362210348,
-0.0434175692,
-0.0687954426,
0.0787985474,
-0.0140777119,
0.0271951295,
-0.0405740961,
0.006579828,
-0.0131284511,
0.0501303189,
0.0032813051,
-0.018281078,
-0.0247359518,
-0.0372806899,
-0.1151527911,
0.0810353085,
-0.0222376883,
-0.0106754117,
-0.0186316893,
-0.013063889,
0.0247217901,
-0.0299856439,
0.0340770073,
-0.0169657636,
0.0018274232,
-0.03037869,
0.0021069599,
-0.0026441857,
-0.0308210105,
0.0384148397,
0.0033982764,
-0.0198078118,
0.0078520821,
-0.0208734944,
0.0244816802,
0.0649862438,
-0.0220066905,
-0.0177750494,
0.0263572428,
-0.0130522782,
-0.0559729412,
0.0027178347,
-0.0016748988,
-0.0105993012,
0.0708139986,
0.0389462449,
-0.0354510024,
-0.0048962943,
-0.0330975242,
-0.036412023,
-0.0544568114,
-0.0132894199,
-0.0027422267,
-0.0538694337,
-0.0336972401,
0.0228995942,
0.0087834671,
0.0537159964,
-0.0089274868,
-0.0246575326,
0.0116468286,
-0.0234774295,
0.0318387598,
-0.0670854971,
-0.0301865824,
-0.0370842852,
0.0278479829,
-0.0274146963,
0.0353298597,
-0.0434222259,
-0.0164454896,
-0.0388136022,
0.0313541777,
0.0168613754,
0.0020222808,
-0.0070201387,
-0.0251300391,
-0.035245467,
-0.0042511402,
-0.0034131324,
-0.0531151369,
0.0177072883,
0.0163111426,
-0.0040534684,
-0.002805718,
-0.0013861104,
-0.0468900874,
-0.0032525358,
0.0098408414,
-0.0088461265,
-0.0397662297,
0.0405287594,
-0.0087242704,
0.0106267333,
-0.0330579691,
0.0130413277,
-0.0562319644,
-0.0189491939,
0.0176374521,
0.0293751825,
-0.0104216915,
-0.0321662873,
-0.0040552462,
-0.0059052226,
0.0187393408,
0.0301060695,
-0.0334008448,
-0.0196173154,
0.0263950042,
0.0292117335,
0.0088705644,
-0.033337757,
-0.0182807781,
0.0223377869,
0.0249001477,
0.0031389596,
-0.0030979388,
0.0673643053,
-0.0277964063,
0.0604130998,
-0.0238187313,
0.1020744964,
-0.0160873588,
-0.0574631318,
0.0367246568,
-0.0302741006,
-0.0245620199,
-0.0287357755,
0.0058290884,
-0.0805410594,
-0.0407734811,
-0.0023030222,
0.0400315225,
-0.0189613905,
-0.0270031076,
0.0120983906,
0.0114409011,
0.0199585892,
-0.0091379452,
-0.0308383685,
-0.0156578626,
0.0146128116,
0.0222317465,
-0.0125227943,
-0.0016445387,
-0.0481229238,
-0.0000645548,
-0.0216643326,
0.0614029914,
0.0359601043,
-0.0061462629,
0.0142804645,
-0.0605733991,
0.0199567731,
-0.0804530531,
-0.0076422482,
-0.0195087884,
-0.0043517854,
-0.0065224329,
0.049266167,
-0.045031108,
-0.0261091627,
0.0052335807,
0.0271783452,
-0.0527519956,
0.0459283069,
-0.0043792352,
-0.0157877505,
-0.0328374468,
-0.0144218812,
0.0441709906,
0.0561322011,
0.0120947519,
0.0073834714,
0.0451449156,
-0.0122869099,
0.0357664861,
0.0382522009,
-0.0253253151,
0.0193334091,
-0.0103663374,
0.0769120604,
-0.0357581452,
-0.0334407873,
0.0204216912,
-0.0158796832,
0.0394010209,
-0.0250399411,
-0.0149959251,
-0.0146153988,
-0.0736223534,
0.0236821175,
0.0022724418,
-0.0399706326,
-0.0245923176,
-0.0149056762,
0.0386175625,
-0.0299054664,
-0.0114255808,
0.004493292,
-0.0434883982,
0.055754818,
0.0181650277,
-0.0006042183,
0.0991963968,
0.0115877176,
-0.0237273388,
-0.0206169989,
0.0158126578,
0.0271713063,
0.0047664652,
0.0014303575,
0.0584380701,
0.0286562778,
-0.0451298431,
0.0396383516,
-0.1298086196,
-0.036764469,
0.0966287926,
0.0312175136,
0.0135182114,
0.0090052783,
0.0493777469,
0.056703981,
0.1124347895,
0.0595930442,
0.0311365277,
0.0097616687,
0.0307666492,
0.0081715444,
-0.028320631,
0.0336145982,
0.0437835567,
0.0357044935,
0.0099667124,
-0.0154083222,
-0.0362526476,
-0.009149028,
-0.0509116389,
-0.0082329866,
0.0825504661,
-0.0005084772,
-0.0088494122,
0.0505249687,
0.0254388563,
0.0305239614,
0.0484160855,
-0.0060485788,
-0.0226084609,
0.0136582917,
-0.0242095757,
-0.0355054885,
0.0280035231,
0.1226154417,
-0.103306897,
-0.0188492313,
0.0398385301,
-0.0211593136,
0.0056538591,
-0.0020644527,
0.036193423,
0.0167805403,
-0.0155598465,
0.0363572463,
0.0127125718,
0.0228467193,
0.0554901548,
-0.0243147854,
0.0524099171,
-0.0149111124,
-0.0184978489,
-0.1345027685,
-0.0441954285,
-0.0231347065,
0.0251436289,
0.0162783153,
0.0126681924,
0.0110644391,
-0.0593219362,
0.0135645773,
0.0052236463,
0.0227423795,
-0.0534981154,
0.005545787,
0.0055400301,
-0.0264089871,
-0.0642753541,
0.0466121584,
0.0136329411,
0.002908913,
0.0484920368,
0.0078037265,
0.0204150937,
-0.0327384807,
0.0165971965,
0.0238185544,
-0.018921189,
0.0486538634,
-0.0166158117,
-0.020847369,
0.0477094203,
0.0744988173,
-0.0420393832,
0.020182712,
-0.0287568048,
0.0069352263,
-0.0155402049,
-0.0359824449,
0.040523164,
0.0353084244,
0.0070544011,
-0.0286463797,
-0.0114865107,
-0.0711224154,
-6.377007629e-33,
-0.0367525481,
-0.0164197367,
-0.013871205,
-0.0239962898,
-0.0047050565,
0.0053444058,
-0.0174077339,
-0.0369452685,
0.005917008,
0.0072254674,
-0.047503598,
0.027602829,
0.0017573455,
0.0264899023,
0.0561423041,
-0.0362187289,
0.0621193685,
-0.0122233601,
0.0430256203,
0.055145435,
0.0792387128,
0.0534990132,
0.0566082969,
-0.03010213,
-0.0430422872,
0.040718548,
-0.0523643903,
-0.0350068957,
-0.0424163528,
-0.0325000286,
0.0294406451,
0.0095269894,
-0.0167162064,
-0.0785493031,
-0.0354021601,
-0.0491195805,
-0.012686491,
-0.0201566555,
-0.0551573932,
-0.0202672072,
0.0591461062,
-0.0185124762,
-0.0077830604,
-0.0074520698,
-0.0538616441,
-0.0036614139,
-0.0038746335,
0.010354856,
0.0125948442,
-0.0460210852,
0.0028771374,
0.0293774679,
-0.0239270441,
0.0065675965,
-0.0425247252,
0.0167916454,
-0.0232270174,
0.0439188071,
-0.0497673862,
0.0481815711,
0.017269779,
-0.0055832379,
0.0102456901,
0.0253370516,
0.0443701409,
0.0449580625,
0.0540062189,
0.0031674129,
-0.0508181937,
0.0149985896,
0.0125365462,
0.0376845524,
0.0418465473,
0.0164627284,
0.040171884,
-0.0543350913,
-0.0271017496,
0.0428632796,
-0.0567533895,
0.0251833685,
0.0406348519,
0.0227514356,
0.0263450611,
-0.0140019236,
0.0263021085,
0.0098186024,
0.0195645187,
0.02151764,
-0.0128519535,
0.0065454692,
0.0041172709,
0.0472519547,
0.0159404464,
-0.0400583595,
0.0432856381,
0.0457782261,
0.0249842033,
-0.0048323083,
0.038351167,
-0.0002583107,
-0.0186891723,
-0.0330513008,
-0.0043347892,
0.0132009694,
-0.0022086899,
-0.0314374045,
0.0138097135,
0.0776791424,
-0.05332857,
-0.0177129358,
-0.0066425065,
0.0110333962,
0.0114829326,
-0.0524590835,
0.0611686036,
-0.0284878425,
0.005111224,
-0.0121188136,
-0.0157809313,
0.0511033572,
0.0218731668,
0.0329432301,
-0.023122387,
0.0211805664,
0.0080458522,
0.0052366238,
-0.02247479,
-0.0237300619,
-0.0549898036,
-0.0461063497,
-0.0112704737,
0.0177837089,
3.086e-7,
-0.0172569845,
0.0673454776,
0.0363149382,
-0.0590681098,
0.0231619291,
-0.0132698659,
-0.0570572391,
0.0018534171,
-0.0422920063,
0.0306464247,
0.0584831461,
0.0184233785,
0.0316205285,
0.0015988747,
-0.023040982,
-0.0617595389,
-0.0817509741,
0.0308762044,
-0.0121010384,
-0.0408966765,
0.0381523594,
0.0852108225,
0.0249014441,
0.0142836878,
0.0740562156,
-0.0392737612,
0.0415738374,
-0.0045216675,
-0.0029718436,
0.0147215622,
-0.0104782712,
0.0159144029,
-0.0082785944,
-0.0077936603,
-0.0259183217,
0.0247924626,
-0.0728649646,
-0.0466823243,
-0.0300438553,
-0.0224406328,
-0.0066039716,
0.0521444976,
0.0025051795,
-0.0668479726,
0.0133677702,
-0.0381019041,
-0.0135902977,
-0.0126127563,
-0.0486395545,
0.0543243103,
0.0735622942,
0.0237425454,
0.0160857476,
0.0356633961,
-0.0343342163,
0.0061434158,
0.0152836088,
-0.0670757741,
0.0010784487,
0.0411342606,
-0.0534048826,
-0.0407686308,
-0.0592549033,
0.032701835,
0.0680387169,
-0.0066668177,
-0.0385838486,
2.668929618e-34,
0.0303050764,
0.0046634846,
-0.0297378264,
-0.00893756,
-0.0122379484,
0.0013186851,
-0.0312466733,
0.0041069738,
0.03377169,
-0.027316995,
-0.0322346576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09552v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09552v2 | STEER: Assessing the Economic Rationality of Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T20:05:26 | 2024-05-28T16:27:56 | Narun Raman, Taylor Lundy, Samuel Amouyal, Yoav Levine, Kevin Leyton-Brown, Moshe Tennenholtz | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | There is increasing interest in using LLMs as decision-making "agents." Doing
so includes many degrees of freedom: which model should be used; how should it
be prompted; should it be asked to introspect, conduct chain-of-thought
reasoning, etc? Settling these questions -- and more broadly, determining
whether an LLM agent is reliable enough to be trusted -- requires a methodology
for assessing such an agent's economic rationality. In this paper, we provide
one. We begin by surveying the economic literature on rational decision making,
taxonomizing a large set of fine-grained "elements" that an agent should
exhibit, along with dependencies between them. We then propose a benchmark
distribution that quantitatively scores an LLMs performance on these elements
and, combined with a user-provided rubric, produces a "STEER report card."
Finally, we describe the results of a large-scale empirical experiment with 14
different LLMs, characterizing the both current state of the art and the impact
of different model sizes on models' ability to exhibit rational behavior. | [
0.0084573897,
0.0714015514,
-0.0196179859,
0.0429632887,
-0.0439910367,
0.0025008938,
0.0095375953,
0.0478324741,
0.0198150929,
-0.0383924097,
-0.0212954488,
0.0083616897,
0.0012146535,
0.0418701507,
0.0148896389,
0.0010289921,
0.0224135723,
-0.0410235599,
0.0595521778,
-0.0318208896,
-0.020009594,
-0.0115587031,
0.0087671503,
0.0458445512,
0.0351472348,
0.0003064641,
0.0003638256,
-0.0165570304,
0.0068254182,
-0.0128655462,
-0.0197109897,
0.0221231952,
0.0167459156,
0.0316537991,
0.000002053,
-0.0984036922,
-0.0268642623,
-0.0111258682,
-0.0296675395,
0.0446468033,
0.0374832936,
0.0382501855,
-0.0017823636,
0.0054984782,
-0.0557450205,
0.0787633732,
0.0187821109,
0.0122116096,
0.0129958652,
0.0345053822,
0.0019529536,
-0.0225513428,
0.0042874776,
-0.0161574818,
-0.0403743275,
-0.0399549045,
0.0190136749,
0.0182289183,
-0.014784582,
0.0171597134,
-0.0059971646,
0.040769428,
0.0024469809,
-0.0303180441,
-0.0271768104,
0.0290730763,
-0.0087027606,
-0.0242957212,
-0.0266807247,
0.0338407904,
0.0405399464,
0.0110983932,
0.0368899629,
-0.0309804808,
0.019104369,
0.0010543349,
-0.0386857688,
0.0326620974,
0.0181530453,
0.0493570045,
0.0566882752,
0.010052098,
0.0454219952,
0.0429480262,
-0.040991053,
0.0843305066,
-0.0346888788,
-0.0231465027,
0.0203487854,
0.024562154,
0.0027076504,
-0.0767330676,
-0.0488863997,
0.026171552,
-0.0362999551,
0.0419712588,
0.01490336,
0.0600870661,
0.0198132675,
-0.06456016,
-0.0034207285,
0.0321356393,
0.0418933965,
0.0394683257,
-0.0135969445,
0.0325345546,
-0.0206141043,
0.0230774861,
0.02986167,
0.0442446284,
-0.0204920266,
-0.0106014423,
-0.0090028327,
0.0373951234,
-0.0252668541,
-0.012568824,
-0.0458166748,
0.0031928548,
-0.0354728885,
0.0739104599,
0.0313131958,
0.0001142607,
0.0323301181,
-0.0439533331,
-0.0916653275,
0.0091081522,
-0.014710837,
0.0304785799,
-0.0000386127,
-0.0366432145,
0.0505470037,
0.0182780772,
-0.0370808281,
-0.0076025804,
0.0222060978,
0.1187223792,
0.0030287893,
-0.0112578496,
-0.0876057521,
-0.0390464179,
-0.0013850078,
-0.0770340636,
-0.0447255895,
-0.0579631925,
-0.0265159328,
0.007459078,
-0.0122304345,
-0.0632312298,
-0.0031007526,
-0.024993496,
-0.0521359518,
0.0322542787,
-0.0074648177,
0.0150131518,
-0.0016888543,
-0.0150687192,
-0.0109738698,
0.0836346522,
0.058579687,
0.0343825631,
0.0564905815,
-0.0083472282,
-0.0027079629,
0.0379695594,
-0.048936855,
0.0404976085,
-0.0573635399,
0.0142083168,
-0.0580629706,
0.0136229908,
0.0115298582,
0.030835079,
-0.0118720932,
0.0030672904,
0.0766327307,
0.0742599741,
0.049234502,
-0.0047577736,
0.01931387,
0.0298905876,
-0.020734854,
-0.0199357904,
-0.0017137433,
0.0107380021,
-0.0384122618,
0.0102731297,
0.0297775175,
-0.002955873,
-0.0018830735,
-0.081248045,
-0.0076276949,
-0.0090982728,
0.0270087458,
0.0608974993,
0.0382188596,
-0.0714574158,
-0.0363411903,
0.0213531405,
0.0031787506,
-0.0156016573,
-0.0274508856,
-0.0753962249,
0.0668828934,
0.0727263018,
0.0419580229,
0.0102699138,
0.0142843109,
-0.0089528924,
-0.0252603237,
0.0584140457,
0.0657708719,
-0.0071490831,
-0.0171180163,
-0.0543167852,
-0.0265688412,
-0.0072285789,
0.0161358416,
0.0448347703,
0.0021006956,
0.0277754199,
-0.0332355499,
-0.0322065912,
-0.0243018419,
0.0086302254,
-0.028825298,
-0.0389561579,
-0.0363931246,
-0.0071581206,
0.0448086597,
0.0037713358,
0.0036778762,
0.0213189535,
0.0102319084,
0.0033685986,
-0.0269473977,
0.0081358626,
0.0210068412,
0.0705751181,
0.015289288,
0.0008077387,
-0.0041270391,
-0.0410833955,
-0.0137695391,
-0.02600668,
0.0320144035,
-0.0329371579,
0.0450558774,
-0.0376155488,
0.0319234543,
-0.0567952283,
-0.0171077419,
-0.0383699164,
0.0553648174,
-0.0126059139,
0.0156765189,
0.0292284731,
-0.0092569478,
0.0055827014,
-0.0517604724,
0.025231136,
0.0627756715,
0.0213458706,
0.0351893008,
0.0374209285,
0.0345025249,
0.0037813338,
-0.0230062474,
-0.0044892114,
-0.0295605566,
0.0108345617,
0.0211156048,
0.0002233631,
-0.061062254,
-0.0036489151,
0.0442261025,
-0.0182694159,
0.0335760973,
0.0450345054,
0.0371630453,
0.0398945995,
-0.0214008354,
-0.0457646251,
-0.0408284739,
-0.0026328713,
0.0128610227,
0.0154087013,
0.0356355794,
-0.0008480492,
-0.0814565569,
0.0199650489,
-0.0396421514,
-0.0078804111,
-0.0147430487,
-0.0488676429,
0.0132372361,
-0.0026038855,
-0.0031885102,
0.0356843509,
-0.0120308641,
0.01539292,
0.0473957025,
-0.0170157459,
-0.1038737446,
-0.0087197246,
-0.0016355859,
0.0034009658,
-0.0878936648,
-0.0372087769,
0.0300018173,
0.087679103,
-0.0117343375,
0.0172741022,
-0.0419948734,
0.0379844345,
-0.0147597324,
-0.040766675,
-0.032681331,
-0.0062024174,
-0.0088702636,
0.1396162957,
0.0338721275,
-0.0591276288,
0.0459309928,
-0.0300762393,
0.0075541763,
-0.0035905258,
-0.0401059836,
-0.0619083941,
0.031036986,
-0.0548841543,
-0.0128352921,
-0.0209259056,
-0.0175034646,
-0.0428341329,
-0.0402259305,
0.0339296646,
-0.0132073043,
0.1027804464,
-0.0664650351,
0.0250092708,
0.000573999,
-0.005475238,
-0.0110224448,
-0.0397535525,
-0.0713833049,
-0.020578891,
0.0698624253,
-0.0524610318,
-0.0313929953,
0.0161324646,
0.0616240427,
0.0053833337,
0.0120288897,
-0.01620006,
0.0053315554,
-0.0266252216,
0.0004568775,
0.0501551218,
0.0691440105,
-0.0400227048,
0.0646872148,
0.024483446,
-0.0219744686,
-0.0219130721,
-0.0084735285,
-0.0024620651,
0.0442499891,
-0.0269179568,
-0.0191379078,
0.077548705,
0.0262106527,
-0.0488597043,
0.0035921817,
0.0882492736,
0.0086848792,
-0.0107746469,
0.0099751689,
-0.0524090752,
0.0388556458,
0.0249176417,
0.0206259359,
-0.0360715576,
-0.0170275383,
-0.0031715364,
0.0131876869,
-0.0232619066,
-0.0414579436,
-0.0028665704,
-0.0956620425,
0.0588472076,
-0.026193846,
0.0263246205,
0.0164390244,
-0.0113327038,
-0.0160328429,
-0.0532750152,
0.0198940709,
0.0120612262,
-0.0294502974,
-0.0275940448,
0.0107612694,
-0.0556182526,
0.0201702174,
0.0178232025,
0.000750643,
0.0054684742,
0.0293722861,
0.042514354,
-0.0238896143,
-0.0690462366,
-0.0111661851,
-0.0113118887,
-0.002393371,
0.0068041133,
0.0124700628,
0.0182210281,
0.00909115,
-0.0078283707,
-0.0090677859,
-0.0101095131,
0.0079317018,
0.0337353386,
0.0301478412,
-0.045485273,
-0.0336193442,
0.0312227271,
0.0266648289,
-0.0401667543,
0.0727522373,
0.003310197,
-0.0467162877,
-0.0628556684,
-0.0582834706,
-0.0679455698,
-0.0494319573,
-0.0455120988,
0.0051635769,
-0.013381714,
0.0000843858,
-0.0523432679,
-0.0375044979,
-0.0032735611,
0.0097319381,
0.0042340285,
-0.0039415075,
0.0243579503,
0.0234285444,
0.0253175218,
-0.0086637717,
-0.0370260552,
0.0148654012,
-0.0759432986,
0.0491606817,
0.0230111722,
-0.0424649417,
-0.0068019824,
0.0076392177,
-0.0194538999,
-0.077084586,
-0.0001876924,
0.0277037695,
0.0392019935,
-0.0055459095,
-0.0064041051,
-0.00534525,
0.0151525661,
0.0061059026,
-0.0274430104,
0.0201512985,
0.0556039326,
0.0727954209,
-0.005315728,
0.0426937118,
-0.0346336253,
-0.0006916689,
-0.0117868464,
0.0413540192,
-0.0874356404,
-0.0570978187,
0.0029676026,
0.0048471284,
-0.023216607,
-0.0490200967,
0.0128002893,
-0.0206853412,
0.0107853841,
-0.007143761,
-0.0017943712,
-0.0277283713,
-0.0293092169,
0.0295473579,
-0.0050117108,
0.010237298,
0.0317465402,
-0.0328958035,
-0.005447052,
0.0255187713,
0.0596956871,
-0.023952052,
0.0082992986,
0.0404886305,
-0.0179012269,
0.0016524086,
0.0274874792,
-0.0352665633,
0.0288625602,
0.0459320731,
0.0743594319,
-0.0042895456,
-0.0225679707,
0.0186046865,
0.0069868746,
-0.0224733576,
-0.1108332947,
0.0518076867,
0.030965155,
0.0328642912,
-0.0002589442,
0.0453517288,
-0.0593557507,
0.0086502004,
0.0251004267,
0.0174677167,
-0.000731895,
-0.0293266904,
0.0155266309,
0.0243276712,
-0.074589096,
-0.0109270094,
0.06923002,
0.0173627902,
0.0016790625,
-0.0497911945,
-0.0000795307,
-0.0453444086,
-0.0712298751,
0.0210036542,
-0.0180508103,
-0.0075514847,
-0.0218522195,
-0.0999120325,
-0.0350427032,
-0.049108725,
0.0220000111,
-0.0219930708,
-0.0512865558,
-0.0026619746,
0.032556396,
0.0183512811,
0.0453830585,
-0.0460197777,
-0.0112772956,
-0.0606220365,
0.0078240894,
-0.0396840349,
-5.931228947e-33,
0.0202617552,
-0.0414189696,
0.0442340225,
-0.0270368103,
0.0241555572,
-0.0214046016,
-0.0227733701,
0.0193516705,
-0.0250305235,
-0.0096724927,
-0.0120761134,
-0.0097270226,
0.0247606523,
-0.0272487216,
0.0588883571,
-0.0152057642,
0.0091207307,
-0.004119718,
-0.0026529853,
-0.0461939648,
0.0068417154,
-0.0171302594,
0.0598463453,
-0.0137775652,
0.0557973646,
0.0055698715,
-0.0268414617,
0.0256665647,
-0.0156579893,
0.0627949461,
-0.0064748242,
-0.0033594163,
0.0124332989,
-0.0843798369,
-0.0208908506,
-0.0000546072,
0.0108791552,
-0.012478698,
0.0272584073,
-0.0176549237,
-0.0054722321,
-0.0256299246,
0.0275075193,
0.0243185814,
-0.070899874,
0.013826712,
0.0133549105,
-0.0344719514,
-0.0177435186,
0.0183105059,
-0.0479390547,
0.0404094346,
-0.0259983763,
0.0494008958,
0.0174883977,
0.0566875227,
-0.0313259289,
0.0342110097,
-0.0320603698,
0.0445997752,
0.0189329218,
-0.0149302697,
0.0805541575,
-0.0234639402,
-0.0005203713,
0.0695685744,
-0.0132431155,
0.0095876278,
-0.019345073,
-0.0034233227,
0.0139948949,
0.0681969225,
0.0315422155,
0.058384195,
-0.0235873926,
-0.0004559023,
-0.0348735563,
0.0299824588,
0.0410655029,
0.0308641922,
0.0251713321,
0.0348412097,
-0.0340491161,
-0.0425123423,
-0.0166189801,
-0.0071982695,
-0.0026506623,
-0.0267945733,
0.0351704843,
-0.0096156811,
0.0070622228,
-0.0135155609,
0.0427697077,
-0.0346869305,
-0.0484931134,
-0.0060708299,
-0.0168225598,
0.0294158254,
0.0181629341,
0.0275009256,
-0.0663277581,
-0.0191462152,
-0.0315274075,
0.0210588761,
0.0170180053,
-0.0012994335,
-0.030066764,
-0.0100409351,
-0.0444887057,
0.0157570876,
-0.0253646895,
0.0340926163,
0.0120737236,
-0.0068299812,
0.0160400663,
-0.0279123448,
0.0091655273,
0.0123948604,
-0.0369194038,
-0.035385903,
0.0042859814,
-0.0122782802,
-0.0114752967,
0.0376292057,
-0.0307002906,
-0.0110996934,
-0.0345546529,
0.0596072339,
0.0576768182,
-0.0159774795,
-0.0120803947,
0.0085957227,
2.736e-7,
0.0243665446,
0.0486679599,
-0.031525474,
0.0226856414,
-0.0128370421,
0.0678477809,
-0.0425888784,
-0.0258055162,
-0.0007237978,
-0.0406512246,
0.0398752429,
0.0061542606,
0.0446380042,
0.0309296791,
-0.0550820827,
-0.0307723507,
-0.0621602684,
-0.009956318,
-0.0541100018,
-0.0178101584,
0.0225195233,
0.0226690527,
0.0262048189,
-0.0138180014,
-0.024611555,
-0.0259546097,
0.0195584577,
-0.0862054229,
-0.0018605893,
0.0108148251,
0.0202630684,
0.0181479268,
-0.0067312913,
-0.0125242388,
0.0119795864,
0.0319805928,
-0.0356670246,
0.0961455628,
0.0286647025,
-0.046749711,
-0.0161926132,
-0.0559824184,
0.0115070865,
-0.0487819724,
0.0356148779,
-0.0223276969,
-0.0518407784,
-0.0202793144,
0.0121214762,
-0.0153948618,
0.0115342783,
-0.0273136962,
0.0152982045,
0.0312532037,
-0.0093662329,
-0.0344313569,
0.0244225115,
-0.0258690957,
-0.0094219018,
0.0258167051,
-0.044244837,
-0.0700586662,
-0.0205867607,
0.064955987,
0.0096989451,
-0.0588671304,
-0.0039991126,
2.323309713e-34,
0.0319000408,
-0.0051425803,
0.0104028042,
0.034280248,
0.0654500425,
0.0607580431,
-0.0102618895,
0.0200802032,
0.0362651832,
-0.0629729256,
0.0015071471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09404v1 | AQA-Bench: An Interactive Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs' Sequential Reasoning Ability | 2024-02-14T18:59:33 | 2024-02-14T18:59:33 | Siwei Yang, Bingchen Zhao, Cihang Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces AQA-Bench, a novel benchmark to assess the sequential
reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in algorithmic contexts,
such as depth-first search (DFS). The key feature of our evaluation benchmark
lies in its interactive evaluation protocol -- for example, in DFS, the
availability of each node's connected edge is contingent upon the model's
traversal to that node, thereby necessitating the LLM's ability to effectively
remember visited nodes and strategize subsequent moves. We comprehensively
build AQA-Bench with three different algorithms, namely binary search,
depth-first search, and breadth-first search, and to evaluate the sequential
reasoning ability of 12 different LLMs. Our investigations reveal several
interesting findings: (1) Closed-source models like GPT-4 and Gemini generally
show strong sequential reasoning ability, significantly outperforming
open-source LLMs. (2) Naively providing interactive examples may inadvertently
hurt few-shot performance. (3) A very limited number of predecessor steps
following the optimal policy can substantially boost small models' performance.
(4) The scaling correlation between performance and model size is not always
significant, sometimes even showcasing an inverse trend. We hope our study can
catalyze future work on advancing the understanding and enhancement of LLMs'
capabilities in sequential reasoning. The code is available at
https://github.com/UCSC-VLAA/AQA-Bench. | [
0.0304990783,
0.0638886616,
-0.0021651185,
0.0296836384,
-0.071830526,
-0.0072231623,
-0.0083123418,
-0.0204782281,
-0.0029267273,
-0.0233248882,
-0.005570366,
-0.0331321508,
-0.0182223562,
0.0315006636,
-0.024756439,
-0.0354948267,
0.0463540666,
-0.0651571825,
-0.0020774605,
-0.0372598097,
-0.0310156867,
-0.0084772734,
-0.0180648547,
0.0328085087,
0.0431903899,
-0.0146077443,
-0.0693090633,
0.0033808176,
0.0331855603,
-0.0622615144,
-0.01796294,
0.0416247509,
0.0150085278,
0.0517656058,
0.00000214,
-0.0583918206,
-0.0196112543,
-0.0124054067,
-0.0364838578,
0.0075243437,
-0.0492609031,
0.0071263625,
0.009072734,
0.0131604979,
-0.0312177483,
-0.0129664354,
0.0285473354,
0.0051108738,
0.0547645167,
0.0700409189,
0.0085259555,
-0.0492676757,
0.0279206503,
-0.0192936696,
-0.0206610169,
-0.0572826006,
-0.0041966694,
-0.0042067245,
0.0524046607,
0.0009857333,
-0.0053406674,
0.009852414,
0.0486271046,
0.03774371,
-0.0344813727,
0.0338024609,
0.0015487083,
-0.0052245227,
-0.0010794828,
0.0595169179,
-0.006566091,
-0.0045657996,
0.0014407324,
-0.0123739243,
-0.0385875106,
-0.010544179,
-0.0447570756,
0.0453698114,
-0.0261083692,
0.0094220955,
0.0112633053,
-0.0029075958,
0.064237386,
0.0143180536,
-0.0622854978,
0.1368142664,
-0.0067840209,
-0.0330167115,
0.0259318445,
-0.0396061018,
0.0116618946,
-0.0669113696,
0.0142225949,
0.0720961094,
-0.0537910387,
0.034433078,
0.0185628124,
0.0464020856,
0.0056739193,
-0.0027398339,
0.0328597538,
0.0599308088,
-0.0010278518,
0.0551289879,
-0.0175920334,
0.065948993,
-0.0162756685,
0.0355051085,
-0.0122323744,
0.0004743114,
-0.025531603,
-0.0076193595,
-0.0456863344,
0.0365620479,
0.0069231181,
-0.0218106173,
-0.0350942947,
0.0336482823,
-0.0084797749,
0.0260490999,
0.0217859223,
-0.0292079244,
0.0281754863,
-0.0279374328,
-0.0626889914,
-0.0084828613,
-0.0366043523,
0.0069977501,
0.0123639954,
-0.0077547831,
-0.0157301724,
-0.0251810458,
-0.0146964742,
-0.0394569486,
0.0164199676,
0.0937215835,
0.0143127507,
-0.0462172367,
-0.0435088687,
-0.0290867928,
0.0248676389,
-0.0956128985,
0.0279270522,
-0.0610049106,
0.0137037812,
0.0185007863,
-0.0370647348,
0.0025124846,
0.0161059275,
0.0330627933,
-0.0135349408,
0.0545166172,
0.0073619662,
0.0199466422,
-0.0381955877,
0.0371994637,
0.003776117,
0.0708629414,
0.013546329,
0.0500523075,
0.0260252878,
0.0158255771,
-0.0502165444,
0.0351104736,
0.0110169463,
-0.0049696444,
-0.0240754075,
0.0400183089,
-0.0372805186,
0.0425549373,
-0.0168834906,
0.0407600552,
-0.0503561795,
-0.016145885,
0.0091293985,
0.069462575,
0.0193346813,
-0.0138334548,
0.0517755114,
-0.0052902396,
0.0003007968,
-0.0047179428,
-0.0831042975,
0.0370832197,
-0.005074352,
0.0283394456,
0.0285342559,
0.0130010005,
-0.0008130997,
-0.0420124643,
-0.0398575589,
0.0262178816,
0.0081835613,
0.0165443439,
0.0439984091,
-0.0013920825,
-0.0478227362,
0.0274419561,
0.0013867629,
-0.0114661232,
-0.053120885,
-0.0550552905,
0.0032693269,
0.0620640554,
0.0646322966,
-0.0265524462,
-0.0568743274,
0.0518413335,
-0.0201071426,
0.0141407596,
0.0221424326,
0.0064328853,
0.0074923686,
-0.0269410647,
-0.0465777852,
-0.0109724402,
0.0000781371,
0.0387505814,
0.0362118371,
0.0170706008,
0.0036634898,
-0.0287285931,
0.0328725912,
0.0114836507,
-0.0140444618,
0.0119107785,
-0.0152273141,
0.0012664087,
0.0408994406,
0.0055755866,
0.0124820517,
0.0110340957,
0.0098477099,
0.0163377728,
-0.0270962808,
0.0073388489,
-0.0635548234,
-0.026289111,
0.0234708562,
0.0020212014,
-0.0226085614,
0.0597754605,
-0.0643473715,
-0.0534246005,
0.0207012594,
-0.0103681367,
0.0273157582,
-0.0371899866,
0.0252516139,
0.0048797037,
-0.0338745639,
-0.0005421813,
0.0745634437,
-0.0417797342,
0.0356515571,
0.0172752738,
0.0270264558,
0.01616822,
-0.0768728852,
-0.0120624006,
0.0457458533,
-0.0247675311,
-0.0216624849,
-0.0131676709,
0.0093622245,
-0.0391233303,
0.0002453205,
-0.0826101452,
0.0190372933,
-0.0313562527,
0.0206775647,
-0.0085623078,
0.0073860716,
0.0101686819,
-0.0126747685,
-0.0222681928,
0.0243991092,
0.0229583047,
0.0339506939,
0.0115675237,
0.0235739518,
-0.0438357219,
-0.0453136377,
-0.0331069119,
-0.0334180743,
0.0085767331,
-0.023593219,
-0.0027334588,
-0.0116531029,
-0.0083909854,
-0.0425186381,
0.0278441347,
-0.0486304685,
-0.0072894176,
0.0480218381,
-0.0406499095,
0.0067940019,
0.0627089143,
-0.0215878114,
0.0322382711,
0.053379152,
-0.0319686532,
-0.0274695698,
0.0534829795,
-0.0063005635,
0.0421265252,
-0.0472348221,
-0.0059653665,
-0.0232345816,
0.0837157816,
-0.033373639,
0.0125555517,
-0.0237637665,
-0.0046146302,
0.0107745016,
0.0125374766,
-0.0290555004,
-0.0070697772,
-0.0037190963,
0.071098879,
-0.0112709887,
-0.0453831479,
0.0760540739,
-0.0231674388,
0.0022649646,
-0.0018050758,
-0.0001766667,
-0.0514883138,
0.1185552627,
0.0220578182,
-0.0037053048,
-0.0552655794,
-0.0240368936,
-0.0433456972,
-0.0002383278,
0.0353651531,
-0.0155907897,
0.0431529991,
-0.0551058017,
0.0171885788,
-0.027941728,
-0.0574416257,
-0.0454680808,
0.0004289557,
-0.0747345388,
0.0312346015,
0.0021921687,
-0.0397944301,
-0.0404154249,
0.0282342974,
0.0058536329,
0.04340709,
-0.0038149811,
0.0074435901,
-0.0169857144,
-0.0068257283,
0.02528584,
0.0176235698,
0.0373294801,
-0.0315678045,
0.067527853,
0.0413796008,
0.0255417097,
-0.0606837049,
-0.0396645851,
0.0133699756,
0.011967361,
-0.0414780527,
-0.0561667494,
0.0347652361,
0.0189177431,
-0.0744645596,
-0.0371784493,
0.0893304721,
0.025227325,
-0.0092575932,
0.0056380443,
-0.038025748,
0.0412946604,
0.0219130218,
0.03287654,
-0.0804977342,
-0.0506073907,
0.0320257209,
0.0271932315,
0.0013042266,
-0.0342522226,
-0.0094060898,
-0.1066481993,
0.0276240129,
-0.0080356114,
-0.0431614108,
0.0200980213,
-0.0377933197,
-0.02451469,
0.016192615,
-0.0124609629,
0.0505417623,
0.0036666885,
-0.0162075553,
-0.0276477076,
-0.0343795978,
0.0104629556,
0.0869032592,
0.0187541582,
0.0125713553,
0.0269278307,
0.0028046295,
0.0231244322,
-0.0370140709,
0.0549404807,
0.0025185549,
0.019502908,
-0.0278260559,
-0.0071676611,
-0.0062185661,
0.00587779,
-0.0170850027,
-0.0049248217,
-0.0012001273,
-0.0401506461,
-0.0021204918,
0.0677496865,
-0.0537054464,
-0.0302079581,
-0.0390028954,
0.0025906274,
-0.0543574281,
0.0509490557,
0.0003376579,
0.0105090747,
-0.1207102463,
-0.0159501284,
-0.0326153636,
-0.0617990606,
-0.0284515116,
0.0155846821,
0.0269860104,
0.0367393605,
-0.0217671189,
-0.0375131778,
-0.0073706089,
0.0352564231,
-0.0380016901,
-0.0012176748,
-0.0071344776,
0.013069856,
-0.0298099536,
0.0036659592,
-0.0077542835,
0.0433827788,
-0.0748752058,
0.0257238317,
0.0157204922,
-0.0132945254,
-0.0314127617,
0.022091601,
-0.0647623464,
-0.0342768617,
0.0014062935,
0.0435077287,
0.0291318391,
0.0337665938,
-0.0229399595,
-0.0190010443,
0.010408082,
-0.0072848704,
0.0118328985,
-0.0043401476,
0.061425548,
0.0181150418,
-0.0049130628,
0.0401406698,
-0.0467807017,
0.0274119657,
-0.0071216146,
0.0798997506,
-0.0175381992,
-0.0322347097,
-0.0019033417,
0.0079368176,
0.0511445254,
0.0234007463,
0.0110735325,
-0.0146149462,
0.073792249,
-0.0382727347,
-0.0158115905,
-0.0304705817,
0.0137582151,
0.0212277677,
-0.0034742523,
0.0196160898,
-0.0460575111,
0.009227708,
-0.0040138592,
-0.0117541756,
0.0100319134,
0.0479291975,
0.0090001905,
0.0347261056,
-0.041310221,
-0.0308258235,
0.0114636077,
0.0087679988,
0.050863035,
-0.0088247284,
0.0660348088,
0.0296791513,
-0.0119997114,
-0.0345710963,
0.0111984769,
-0.1079827398,
-0.0583119318,
0.0278222505,
0.0100912107,
0.0952162221,
0.0169512834,
-0.0130377961,
-0.0413976759,
0.0249949284,
0.0044174753,
-0.0004762502,
0.021230666,
-0.0634874329,
0.0574933589,
0.0548380874,
0.0085015753,
0.0202743877,
0.044211816,
0.0522851609,
0.0317238793,
0.020868361,
0.003437445,
-0.0212983135,
-0.0936581269,
-0.008253091,
0.0472857021,
-0.0227403976,
-0.0098170983,
-0.0773289651,
-0.0666324049,
0.0033481063,
0.0410191193,
0.0099990079,
-0.0190380663,
0.043538969,
0.0532192737,
0.0249004699,
-0.0424367338,
-0.0150437066,
-0.0066639087,
-0.0318336636,
-0.0118003748,
-0.0034901584,
-6.190315617e-33,
-0.013703268,
-0.0226805266,
0.0850655884,
-0.0276223496,
-0.0223338902,
-0.0216652043,
-0.0568778813,
0.0093642035,
-0.0198751371,
0.0141896354,
-0.0305682756,
0.0249342993,
0.0051852372,
0.0071944064,
0.0015149221,
0.0048339851,
0.0133322766,
0.0235894285,
-0.0246994346,
-0.0015020741,
0.0315661468,
0.0025078936,
0.0038673487,
0.020340221,
-0.0024957054,
-0.0078814095,
-0.0105205225,
0.0363875404,
-0.079410851,
0.060281869,
0.013450061,
-0.0302888472,
0.0288506392,
-0.0275678504,
-0.0114017408,
-0.0128159439,
-0.0528838597,
-0.037540786,
0.0271766093,
-0.002282304,
-0.0719169974,
0.014810659,
-0.0062033986,
0.0166598689,
-0.0122387428,
-0.0316117257,
-0.0103744585,
-0.0152958762,
-0.0516604446,
-0.0150285615,
-0.0226981565,
0.0428385474,
-0.0014665971,
0.0023988194,
0.029274933,
0.0218074899,
-0.0178823452,
-0.0062733511,
-0.0173573401,
-0.002006622,
-0.0003644269,
0.0068386905,
0.0650136322,
0.0358148329,
0.0118890572,
0.0442765132,
0.0242286325,
-0.0118761817,
-0.0038730816,
0.0348423421,
0.0003789653,
0.0870664269,
0.0159161966,
-0.0174855888,
0.0130866505,
0.0486576594,
-0.0915607363,
-0.0100869918,
-0.0003027319,
0.0734569058,
0.0301499031,
0.0124878222,
-0.0363820679,
-0.0184178129,
-0.0492804162,
0.007065305,
-0.024608992,
-0.0167801287,
0.0446575433,
0.007266623,
-0.0013704175,
-0.0432126336,
0.0280852821,
-0.0188368708,
0.0150896162,
0.0530136451,
-0.0340813734,
0.0152977258,
-0.0022294405,
0.0812888741,
-0.0479175113,
-0.0310231559,
-0.0236802287,
-0.0093382411,
0.0028622281,
-0.012763232,
-0.0206669588,
0.0287214275,
-0.0413729995,
-0.0210221019,
-0.0427274816,
0.0270747133,
-0.0323248617,
0.0112701701,
0.0654571876,
-0.0160702579,
0.0110051045,
0.0680587366,
-0.0096362764,
-0.0080617312,
-0.0328139924,
0.0333252177,
-0.019317599,
0.0207053907,
0.004068729,
0.0032208073,
-0.0484940112,
0.0274829622,
-0.0236229599,
-0.0485731363,
0.0040086606,
0.0916778073,
2.848e-7,
-0.0086297607,
0.0389157459,
0.0226988494,
0.0548302904,
0.01972083,
-0.0042009708,
-0.0506552458,
-0.0354438163,
0.0081447661,
0.0014436877,
0.0346988961,
0.0635772198,
0.030663766,
0.0281593595,
-0.0699862912,
0.0278546512,
-0.0721635148,
-0.0393999033,
-0.0597476289,
-0.0023713647,
0.0213837083,
0.0614578202,
0.0088309124,
-0.0022092727,
0.0081223901,
-0.0577282384,
0.0468948036,
0.0159090813,
0.0256665479,
-0.0090738852,
0.013807972,
0.0093071721,
-0.0111894431,
0.004581179,
0.0155702606,
0.0423744619,
-0.0351769738,
0.0896720886,
0.0176392179,
-0.0552827008,
-0.0001335334,
-0.0448071584,
0.0097552035,
-0.0561154746,
0.1044788584,
-0.0362879336,
-0.0372529812,
0.0231965054,
0.0100338366,
-0.0326349474,
-0.0035961343,
0.0281325653,
-0.0231054034,
0.0056979703,
0.0013365706,
-0.0239079352,
0.0148698855,
-0.1079270914,
-0.0132955275,
0.0023520775,
-0.0159748122,
-0.0495139174,
-0.0563604236,
0.0100292005,
0.0320690461,
-0.0092189685,
-0.0369469449,
2.835358037e-34,
0.0673946291,
-0.0440274253,
0.0022958906,
0.0069760201,
0.0358346589,
0.0046228794,
-0.0029462925,
0.024437312,
0.0387944505,
-0.086614348,
-0.0205051899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09401v1 | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback with Active Queries | 2024-02-14T18:58:40 | 2024-02-14T18:58:40 | Kaixuan Ji, Jiafan He, Quanquan Gu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC, stat.ML | Aligning large language models (LLM) with human preference plays a key role
in building modern generative models and can be achieved by reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF). Despite their superior performance,
current RLHF approaches often require a large amount of human-labelled
preference data, which is expensive to collect. In this paper, inspired by the
success of active learning, we address this problem by proposing
query-efficient RLHF methods. We first formalize the alignment problem as a
contextual dueling bandit problem and design an active-query-based proximal
policy optimization (APPO) algorithm with an $\tilde{O}(d^2/\Delta)$ regret
bound and an $\tilde{O}(d^2/\Delta^2)$ query complexity, where $d$ is the
dimension of feature space and $\Delta$ is the sub-optimality gap over all the
contexts. We then propose ADPO, a practical version of our algorithm based on
direct preference optimization (DPO) and apply it to fine-tuning LLMs. Our
experiments show that ADPO, while only making about half of queries for human
preference, matches the performance of the state-of-the-art DPO method. | [
0.0524456017,
0.0741401985,
0.0098308902,
0.0039683143,
-0.0114206141,
0.0272003748,
-0.0300572794,
0.0112409545,
0.0029463645,
-0.027480213,
-0.0604481064,
-0.0627410635,
-0.0103160441,
0.0124213276,
0.0379683003,
-0.0566253662,
0.0161497798,
-0.0535227023,
0.0161051191,
-0.0433089547,
0.0167799871,
-0.0052515678,
-0.0107806623,
0.0447221622,
0.0490380265,
0.0386714898,
-0.0165279433,
0.0344949923,
0.0216704197,
-0.0250709839,
0.0191178527,
0.0293319039,
0.0202758648,
0.0450505428,
0.0000020945,
-0.0424961783,
-0.0328285433,
-0.0178226251,
0.0130562028,
-0.006339951,
0.0504137091,
0.0663840324,
-0.0023134695,
0.030329302,
-0.0354545526,
-0.0260808859,
0.0479701534,
0.0314948,
0.028638199,
0.0594132654,
0.0184556935,
-0.0110003464,
0.0095970891,
-0.0642161444,
0.0459793322,
-0.0636836588,
0.0294429939,
-0.0559594035,
0.0175994672,
-0.009682484,
-0.0008440067,
-0.0100742085,
-0.0047728685,
0.0071849818,
-0.0044053337,
0.0292026252,
0.0052023511,
-0.0182981975,
0.0011371258,
0.0557172596,
-0.0044356696,
-0.0062256171,
0.0250975844,
-0.0410497189,
0.004071699,
-0.0018578804,
-0.0096382163,
-0.0082368171,
0.0055461279,
0.0579982176,
0.0170123409,
-0.0224522948,
0.0437274128,
0.0340211503,
-0.0346929617,
0.033645723,
-0.0111769009,
-0.0430465378,
0.0630487874,
0.0120720733,
-0.0566067547,
-0.0299553908,
0.0010019633,
-0.018653404,
-0.1172481626,
0.0059178541,
-0.0375718363,
0.0098258052,
-0.0010339998,
-0.0097769201,
0.0358711891,
0.0211192928,
0.0126936426,
0.0475548841,
0.0509315506,
0.0771662444,
-0.0367016755,
0.0147377849,
-0.0518565215,
0.0005953701,
-0.0130044799,
-0.0119845113,
-0.0152824325,
0.0344119705,
-0.0299941488,
-0.0084284218,
-0.0486695617,
0.0215843283,
-0.031009417,
0.0341021121,
0.0021863142,
0.0361000299,
-0.0633904561,
-0.0183304194,
-0.0615598969,
0.0148675833,
-0.02602656,
0.0156101668,
0.0161514543,
0.001090492,
0.0235496666,
0.044175148,
-0.0243925452,
-0.0452137925,
-0.0046310732,
0.073608011,
-0.021704834,
-0.0192234684,
-0.0184245333,
-0.0021365758,
-0.0053692381,
-0.0215453841,
-0.0405312218,
-0.0639245585,
0.0080647897,
-0.0392184891,
-0.0007992841,
-0.0791597143,
0.0033513696,
0.0156690087,
-0.0355027355,
0.0488071106,
0.0354884863,
-0.003730939,
0.0264686998,
-0.0355405957,
-0.0070494148,
0.071285136,
0.05058055,
0.0688673556,
0.0274512433,
0.0290820673,
-0.0400909707,
0.0184293631,
0.028753154,
0.0203527249,
-0.061101079,
0.0244747866,
0.0050088712,
0.0705899075,
0.0212164372,
0.0358845405,
-0.0397065729,
-0.0307450928,
0.0400695689,
0.0071063139,
0.0058856136,
-0.0373343639,
0.0054199253,
0.0440025814,
-0.0333566889,
-0.0078777727,
-0.0346855782,
0.020801479,
-0.0266473982,
0.0032017305,
0.0589673109,
0.0155845871,
-0.0138216987,
-0.042137675,
0.0238978937,
0.0049933484,
-0.0341234878,
0.0717569962,
0.0246380884,
-0.0300264601,
-0.0585051849,
-0.0440358818,
0.051516138,
0.0014019598,
-0.0067028017,
-0.0322768539,
0.0092303818,
0.0625424311,
0.034988679,
-0.0279134717,
0.0045995899,
-0.0022821557,
-0.0454940274,
0.0098147849,
0.0515471213,
-0.0512831509,
-0.0005475103,
-0.0326230079,
-0.069104068,
0.0348406285,
0.000288296,
0.0264862198,
0.0431446955,
-0.0103829885,
-0.0153777571,
0.0042204764,
-0.0099654449,
0.0108199203,
-0.0086710267,
-0.0671303049,
0.0527189001,
0.0349197872,
0.0501972213,
-0.0082715694,
0.0017243577,
0.0077810045,
0.0195662696,
-0.0017347249,
-0.0183864869,
-0.0133277196,
-0.0113961166,
-0.0307768285,
0.0233945493,
-0.0283293538,
-0.0270154942,
0.0281206463,
-0.0389354937,
-0.0251792036,
-0.043436259,
-0.0126434416,
0.0385087468,
-0.049671486,
-0.0009276471,
-0.0125583885,
-0.0438669324,
-0.084659718,
0.0507340916,
-0.0221186765,
0.0188905057,
0.0244178865,
-0.0148961553,
-0.0093563776,
-0.1003699377,
-0.01256923,
0.0261988994,
0.0151084224,
0.0011018576,
0.0482370667,
0.0484826267,
-0.0362368971,
-0.0207410548,
-0.0525046252,
-0.0005817437,
-0.0144475903,
-0.0029817419,
0.0036429386,
0.0307807196,
-0.0167590193,
-0.0314884856,
-0.0304883346,
-0.0067028278,
-0.0213975776,
0.0252594389,
0.0307950191,
0.0463858359,
0.0092593078,
-0.0681338161,
-0.0211671535,
0.026126245,
-0.0033486576,
-0.0363045149,
0.0360247605,
0.0073787812,
0.0199482609,
-0.0031724763,
0.0269382186,
-0.0001626167,
-0.0010909957,
0.0158032645,
-0.0686648637,
0.0064624897,
0.0779806301,
0.0415258631,
0.0365209989,
0.0452944264,
0.0178032517,
-0.0854438096,
0.0215131715,
-0.0556784756,
-0.0742526874,
-0.0462382995,
-0.0042693685,
0.0438886173,
0.0528554767,
-0.0112787681,
0.0171757396,
-0.0667390451,
0.0112078292,
0.0042311265,
-0.0403968878,
-0.0597868934,
0.0592768788,
-0.0347326398,
0.0390659198,
-0.024049079,
-0.0371001326,
0.105949603,
0.018706182,
0.0066554756,
-0.0366200432,
-0.0226530619,
-0.0122296773,
0.0053718579,
0.0228968337,
0.0302681047,
-0.0447891466,
-0.028270226,
-0.094712548,
-0.0424751267,
0.0375449359,
-0.0306885764,
0.0149069121,
-0.0348971002,
0.0278658401,
0.0001685685,
-0.1020801365,
-0.0513745397,
-0.061631538,
-0.005495029,
-0.0211295392,
0.031263385,
-0.0577366762,
-0.040136084,
-0.0179319251,
0.012703415,
0.0176371671,
0.0181118995,
-0.0421756208,
0.0074159135,
0.0090428377,
0.0891574025,
0.0204408132,
-0.0189946629,
-0.0251838658,
-0.0212678928,
0.0376014411,
0.0801011994,
-0.0220270846,
0.0258226488,
0.0306369141,
0.0655920282,
-0.0263409466,
-0.0080563081,
0.048450835,
-0.0070780222,
0.0141644161,
-0.0067628943,
0.086135,
0.0251619015,
-0.0812605917,
0.0087312385,
0.0047471384,
0.0814297646,
0.0222430807,
0.0689292476,
-0.0374305137,
-0.0419972204,
0.0016292345,
0.1170367151,
-0.0012177376,
-0.0314138234,
0.0021145288,
-0.1301947236,
-0.0022628065,
0.0046900818,
-0.0458867662,
-0.0111699263,
-0.0128138643,
0.0131742479,
-0.0642902106,
-0.0123207793,
0.0186130796,
0.0053685382,
0.0235232357,
0.00830168,
0.0421739705,
-0.0221040025,
-0.002296743,
-0.0137062045,
0.0084596174,
0.082512781,
0.0130287558,
0.0481281877,
-0.00619291,
-0.0093320105,
-0.003008293,
-0.026280513,
-0.0261789635,
-0.018952176,
-0.0460988842,
0.0008467325,
-0.0093696369,
0.0745869577,
-0.0135642132,
-0.0008544683,
-0.0054378207,
0.04634884,
-0.0112184128,
0.0398075581,
0.0124033522,
-0.0103611453,
0.0434882082,
0.0476863533,
-0.0209038034,
-0.0545376129,
-0.0182992201,
-0.0331397541,
-0.0225758553,
-0.0371408947,
-0.0238141473,
-0.0134543413,
0.0210614875,
0.0026497373,
-0.0648282468,
0.0026867574,
0.003607518,
0.0750872493,
-0.0143854851,
0.0045984294,
-0.0088149281,
-0.0038345882,
-0.0022896416,
-0.0100907665,
-0.0185011756,
0.0244239941,
-0.0723126084,
-0.0436200686,
0.0134845283,
-0.0426535681,
-0.0363428108,
-0.0182977319,
-0.0524323434,
-0.0678561181,
0.017875215,
0.0517981276,
0.0124183688,
0.0411340818,
0.0008281079,
-0.0561259277,
0.0291248653,
0.0922394171,
-0.0049408432,
0.0082151974,
0.0159857497,
0.0132841757,
-0.0008082216,
0.0491758287,
-0.0609372035,
-0.0465391316,
0.0158091541,
0.0363635719,
-0.0146997226,
-0.0284991655,
0.0232205708,
-0.0101107033,
0.0526899472,
-0.0463816226,
-0.0142216943,
-0.0379498452,
0.0236292668,
0.0413826331,
-0.0409331657,
-0.0189475715,
-0.0245161932,
0.0307132769,
-0.0266666319,
0.0189494099,
-0.0103544323,
0.0161125138,
0.0445309393,
-0.0306180082,
-0.0049617328,
0.062745817,
0.0283142645,
0.0389356278,
0.0302247927,
0.0261159074,
0.0477902666,
0.0325186141,
0.0836005658,
-0.0054703248,
0.0269372687,
0.0476108119,
-0.0011470369,
-0.0111236535,
-0.010634725,
-0.0571382307,
-0.0779121071,
-0.0401166417,
0.0323936567,
0.0552427918,
-0.0239134207,
0.0274054408,
-0.0317329094,
-0.0026442336,
-0.0133260181,
0.0022463039,
-0.0191999916,
-0.0216478575,
0.0257369708,
0.0450972319,
0.0105906948,
0.0508784577,
0.0949902236,
0.0597272962,
0.0453088395,
-0.0362326391,
0.0070252079,
-0.0284092296,
-0.0391056985,
0.0475010574,
0.0536612049,
-0.0321062356,
0.0105316741,
-0.025595706,
-0.030906206,
-0.0499222986,
0.0231772009,
-0.0113626402,
-0.0119399549,
0.0749477595,
0.0343007222,
-0.0193112381,
0.0233891625,
-0.047034435,
0.0148764625,
-0.0224076994,
-0.0230119247,
-0.0249414705,
-6.603509228e-33,
-0.0457344614,
-0.0465689339,
0.0083666369,
-0.050254412,
-0.0339459181,
-0.045920413,
0.0086058648,
-0.0091878977,
0.0229992513,
-0.0113234213,
-0.0153948665,
-0.0246288199,
0.0049176803,
0.0242740121,
-0.0000473324,
-0.0019004057,
0.041899614,
0.0062099341,
-0.0427378975,
0.0045237597,
0.0276006367,
0.0213223193,
-0.0271085706,
-0.0469329581,
0.0080804611,
0.0072618476,
-0.0369943529,
0.0388449095,
-0.0038861562,
0.0606204197,
0.0256734826,
0.0035653983,
-0.0293984972,
-0.0346556045,
0.0023448255,
-0.0237588231,
-0.049426198,
-0.0269934554,
0.0011205339,
0.0111493245,
0.0254930016,
0.0121111702,
0.0073807118,
0.0013675072,
-0.019680718,
0.0196212865,
0.0032741344,
-0.0136259701,
-0.0577631593,
-0.004517314,
-0.0110458275,
0.0000650575,
-0.0189971458,
0.0324281007,
0.0262698941,
0.0338539518,
-0.0107007436,
0.0358518064,
-0.0196489524,
0.0389987193,
0.0015170795,
0.039133653,
0.0466271117,
0.0666165575,
0.0274409633,
0.0150219258,
0.0231703371,
-0.021199489,
0.0315998346,
-0.0126627767,
-0.0118036643,
0.017495634,
-0.0422778949,
0.0758937374,
0.0401345268,
0.0145792179,
-0.0284700077,
0.0527441278,
0.0065745665,
0.0090127531,
0.0215284172,
0.0598295815,
-0.0566820204,
-0.0358170941,
-0.0560023449,
-0.0102746775,
-0.0307372753,
-0.0300212111,
0.022853462,
0.0425095148,
-0.0352554433,
-0.0252181459,
0.0105103515,
-0.0337557644,
-0.032387279,
-0.0078052799,
-0.0290992819,
-0.0049098623,
-0.0082041696,
0.0078414967,
-0.0649274141,
-0.0517373011,
0.0011768689,
-0.009072775,
-0.0286028627,
0.016548017,
-0.0057813413,
0.0322309136,
-0.0476763919,
0.0203985237,
0.000764772,
-0.0043491414,
-0.0220241491,
0.018194126,
0.0496980697,
-0.0285319593,
0.0065987566,
0.07481011,
-0.0013923361,
-0.0413625091,
-0.0104726674,
-0.0691553652,
-0.0195434261,
-0.0056743287,
-0.0101720216,
0.0470283367,
-0.0039725341,
0.0014152114,
0.0014818923,
-0.0230099615,
-0.0200913604,
0.0036389269,
2.761e-7,
-0.0218784679,
0.0428647324,
-0.0046315864,
0.0065657054,
-0.0200598557,
0.0810681507,
0.0006877488,
-0.0019481864,
0.0144059975,
0.0406657159,
0.0645759031,
0.0226440895,
0.0374993309,
-0.0028480592,
-0.0899214447,
0.015150751,
-0.0660293549,
0.0270673167,
-0.0431146957,
-0.0262256265,
0.0410593897,
0.0828081891,
0.0313326865,
-0.0263865311,
0.0362431109,
0.002722363,
0.0581315644,
-0.0496603213,
-0.0034768591,
-0.0382738635,
0.0040897387,
0.0022588524,
-0.0248968881,
-0.0404974744,
-0.0155638373,
0.0207347814,
0.0017003539,
0.0615539737,
0.019019939,
-0.0682090819,
-0.0092963651,
0.0299944934,
0.0233940482,
-0.0536494665,
0.0683276877,
-0.0203198474,
0.0083682667,
0.0061571193,
0.0371495001,
-0.0374061465,
0.0139725851,
-0.0562112406,
-0.0279012155,
-0.0264709834,
0.0057445946,
0.0280965101,
-0.0038589621,
-0.0528481603,
0.0024321629,
0.0148349898,
-0.018497603,
-0.0212102253,
-0.0460401699,
0.1006863788,
-0.0114573054,
-0.0136582805,
-0.0084093632,
2.419577419e-34,
0.0417012945,
0.014148361,
-0.0023331847,
-0.025878178,
0.0102310823,
0.0409269296,
0.0208809562,
0.0051246183,
0.0615236014,
-0.0674475804,
-0.0198532306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09394v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09394v2 | Long-form evaluation of model editing | 2024-02-14T18:45:14 | 2024-03-29T21:17:23 | Domenic Rosati, Robie Gonzales, Jinkun Chen, Xuemin Yu, Melis Erkan, Yahya Kayani, Satya Deepika Chavatapalli, Frank Rudzicz, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluations of model editing currently only use the `next few token'
completions after a prompt. As a result, the impact of these methods on longer
natural language generation is largely unknown. We introduce long-form
evaluation of model editing (LEME) a novel evaluation protocol that measures
the efficacy and impact of model editing in long-form generative settings. Our
protocol consists of a machine-rated survey and a classifier which correlates
well with human ratings. Importantly, we find that our protocol has very little
relationship with previous short-form metrics (despite being designed to extend
efficacy, generalization, locality, and portability into a long-form setting),
indicating that our method introduces a novel set of dimensions for
understanding model editing methods. Using this protocol, we benchmark a number
of model editing techniques and present several findings including that, while
some methods (ROME and MEMIT) perform well in making consistent edits within a
limited scope, they suffer much more from factual drift than other methods.
Finally, we present a qualitative analysis that illustrates common failure
modes in long-form generative settings including internal consistency, lexical
cohesion, and locality issues. | [
0.0294730347,
0.079978846,
-0.0063353223,
-0.0308464449,
-0.0429671817,
-0.0112208603,
0.0113888206,
-0.0372119136,
-0.0357453115,
-0.0330174007,
-0.0154156629,
-0.0390815735,
0.0519363321,
0.0418378413,
0.0394371226,
-0.0972201303,
0.031766139,
-0.0061774924,
0.0043536196,
0.0183332879,
-0.0146243908,
-0.0167985056,
-0.0169673674,
0.0604798011,
-0.0138533665,
-0.0240667481,
-0.0329303704,
0.0024823234,
0.0071808603,
-0.0260969363,
-0.0297389962,
0.0810829177,
-0.0300499815,
0.0281318631,
0.0000021101,
-0.0751581341,
-0.019006202,
0.0312135052,
-0.0114557566,
0.0403983742,
0.0475674421,
0.0313234925,
-0.0413983539,
-0.0119116474,
-0.0083316015,
0.0175618492,
0.0949733332,
0.0116579672,
0.0606569387,
0.0348636247,
-0.0117915245,
-0.0178885777,
0.000284632,
-0.0485266857,
0.0075336318,
0.0123958727,
-0.0098865656,
0.0077616819,
0.0200752001,
-0.0162872169,
-0.0225450657,
0.0479334816,
0.0282580014,
-0.0426356904,
0.0343845822,
0.0269835852,
-0.0109736463,
-0.0324383415,
0.0071251877,
0.051889535,
0.0393651128,
0.0097257504,
-0.0228343848,
-0.0041431938,
0.0363861732,
0.0033702459,
-0.0398928039,
0.0222794302,
0.0263471901,
-0.0168870464,
-0.0107775694,
-0.0383167379,
0.0129925543,
-0.0139306942,
0.0015781315,
0.0294009708,
0.0505342148,
-0.0333873704,
-0.0396228097,
0.0104656424,
-0.0147509957,
-0.1145366281,
0.0066695465,
-0.0035612073,
-0.0327290073,
-0.000070651,
-0.0641375333,
0.0203292966,
0.0206400789,
-0.0277562421,
0.0680702254,
0.0222716611,
-0.0245707855,
0.00652351,
-0.0071494617,
0.0313956551,
0.0189330969,
-0.0234198608,
-0.0247701183,
0.0655764416,
-0.0713088587,
-0.0222949702,
-0.0525117852,
-0.0030181191,
-0.0456865132,
-0.0132507263,
-0.0747599453,
0.0147779305,
-0.0006080994,
-0.0019653831,
0.0068872669,
0.0135790091,
-0.0128602656,
0.0257662702,
-0.0279014036,
0.0220508501,
-0.053277079,
0.0159774441,
0.0571070015,
-0.0286261775,
-0.0163602233,
-0.0093312282,
0.0110635664,
-0.0217453856,
-0.0201498456,
0.0389312878,
-0.0145164067,
0.0016902279,
-0.0071716788,
-0.0708046854,
-0.0384999774,
-0.0565262586,
-0.026550116,
-0.0651702285,
0.0095668947,
-0.0266046263,
-0.0148429722,
-0.0602242686,
-0.0069702561,
0.0017142046,
-0.018007176,
0.0524060912,
-0.0405907705,
0.0243576858,
0.0265868921,
-0.0108302077,
-0.0014013691,
0.0304405447,
0.0613284893,
0.0237491224,
0.0503657162,
-0.005888137,
0.0487961285,
0.0239939578,
-0.009619277,
-0.0098858615,
-0.0329509042,
0.0039745634,
-0.0162187945,
0.0591117106,
0.0252113678,
0.0538741909,
-0.0278664511,
0.0421566665,
0.0905414447,
0.0048453854,
0.0531223342,
0.0206574667,
0.0840420946,
-0.0097759934,
-0.0007199214,
0.0340170637,
-0.0184179023,
0.0055241231,
-0.0285729021,
0.0548868813,
0.0265812371,
0.0072910176,
0.0107372031,
-0.0563144982,
-0.000754985,
0.0331257097,
0.039705079,
-0.0203749239,
0.0234315041,
0.0547982715,
-0.02381563,
0.0321116373,
0.00967927,
-0.0753191486,
0.004807346,
-0.0471802689,
0.0225195121,
0.1047987267,
0.0695950761,
0.0235525239,
-0.0475139432,
-0.0136366049,
0.0038743317,
0.0317432061,
0.0570355281,
-0.0145048667,
0.0041833129,
0.0030229788,
-0.0131963501,
-0.0359395966,
0.0267071277,
0.0117541645,
0.018383706,
-0.0014147181,
0.0434456654,
-0.050759647,
-0.0225252006,
0.0308835432,
-0.0402086489,
-0.021215478,
-0.0106160576,
0.015788231,
0.0005640215,
0.0006468634,
-0.0555740371,
0.0220816713,
-0.0209771991,
0.0306065474,
-0.010494845,
0.0310452357,
-0.0294642281,
-0.0016927745,
0.0416164584,
-0.0107107013,
-0.0236329846,
-0.0044517852,
0.0122059379,
-0.0360801704,
-0.0067342911,
-0.0723933652,
0.0304448698,
-0.0500846207,
0.063839227,
0.0008230296,
-0.0072128745,
-0.0206487179,
0.0188155565,
0.0148243802,
-0.0214861277,
0.0412762538,
0.0094721308,
-0.0062032067,
-0.0588231534,
-0.0260437746,
0.0409752056,
0.0074579436,
-0.0301066581,
0.0226769187,
0.0339708254,
-0.0524705835,
-0.0512720272,
-0.0832872093,
-0.0135171982,
-0.0177189298,
0.0015662607,
0.0318364687,
0.0152585907,
-0.0356546342,
0.0352927558,
-0.0125190569,
-0.0544837601,
-0.0013068934,
0.0279010106,
0.0429655612,
0.0175689757,
-0.0557087101,
-0.0486594848,
0.0118894037,
0.0227582827,
0.049680192,
0.0512253903,
0.0120541668,
-0.0587193817,
0.0196610224,
-0.0677964091,
-0.0407275371,
0.0459307171,
-0.0537882783,
0.0225366969,
0.0295541845,
0.0837186277,
0.0223726109,
0.0185506344,
0.0151660787,
0.0618422441,
-0.0358527191,
0.0072309063,
-0.0106282486,
0.0063867248,
-0.0280217659,
0.0014870707,
-0.0373935141,
0.0124484533,
0.0584156923,
0.0070834686,
-0.0077537964,
-0.0257326979,
0.0575716868,
-0.0180812348,
-0.0692617148,
0.004874954,
-0.0167689081,
-0.0246809721,
0.0308942273,
-0.0105440421,
-0.0585290007,
0.0785414428,
-0.0398182012,
-0.0032337273,
-0.0113379518,
0.0204085652,
0.0048102667,
0.0655944869,
-0.0090859011,
0.0163055621,
0.0325430743,
-0.0038374758,
-0.0422249623,
0.0085777296,
0.0249787662,
-0.0001734778,
-0.0061678346,
-0.0804511309,
-0.0237225555,
0.0098728333,
-0.0012040329,
-0.0296003632,
-0.0320570171,
-0.0083021969,
0.0307474453,
0.0597528629,
-0.0353160277,
0.0256467424,
0.0186938737,
0.0326769538,
0.0390618332,
-0.0281070825,
-0.019797219,
0.0067300079,
0.0051480755,
0.052452933,
0.0093198447,
0.0195183903,
-0.0312004276,
0.037623886,
0.0286345836,
-0.0162765142,
-0.0022961497,
-0.0455684923,
-0.0029261508,
-0.01780116,
-0.0679917261,
-0.0257996526,
0.0417293422,
0.0658804476,
-0.0579918213,
-0.0107791489,
0.1033667922,
0.0328755751,
0.0322432779,
0.0374891162,
-0.027553875,
0.0704256892,
0.0092259683,
0.0238347333,
-0.0591621846,
-0.002537949,
0.0529901944,
0.0447551198,
-0.0315898396,
-0.0158717465,
-0.0140048405,
-0.0992182419,
0.0621765293,
0.0064617251,
-0.0422690511,
0.0092959162,
-0.0151395621,
0.0128803803,
0.0211822949,
-0.0007905551,
0.0391462818,
-0.0185376126,
0.0266122632,
-0.01730261,
-0.0490854792,
-0.0473495312,
-0.0276051797,
-0.0396571271,
0.0542942397,
0.0872392952,
0.0246164761,
0.0283845253,
-0.0117192836,
0.0572380126,
0.0506655984,
0.0420795083,
0.0014430744,
0.0338454992,
0.0288668703,
0.0093110204,
-0.0054982738,
0.0163830593,
0.0447112173,
-0.0349105597,
0.0297494084,
0.0579635054,
-0.0220578574,
-0.0009474636,
-0.0135246795,
0.0147801861,
0.0106628733,
0.0640242249,
0.0926522389,
-0.0473913811,
-0.0267012846,
-0.0441113897,
-0.0166297406,
-0.0621312186,
-0.0069625303,
-0.0254111942,
-0.0381610915,
-0.0076647932,
-0.0877271369,
-0.0751198828,
0.0396632515,
0.0290724207,
0.032648921,
-0.023816105,
-0.0115660345,
0.0046520499,
0.00099452,
0.0124442959,
-0.0222102199,
0.0105246184,
-0.0580981709,
-0.0368157253,
0.0032182036,
-0.0316693783,
-0.0129889287,
0.0149359656,
-0.0344631821,
-0.064437665,
0.016595237,
0.0596024618,
0.0271804612,
0.027232714,
-0.0009010654,
-0.054445859,
0.017526295,
0.0259731747,
-0.0100242263,
0.041028861,
0.0105652809,
0.0140159512,
0.0080269156,
-0.0027781541,
-0.0130852237,
-0.0210658833,
0.0242174231,
0.0606859289,
0.0042896308,
-0.0390583575,
0.0182631463,
0.0528826602,
0.0066263871,
-0.0595508367,
0.0052724355,
-0.0392928682,
0.0024044323,
-0.08204934,
-0.0221560188,
-0.0558220297,
0.0219289195,
0.0172013752,
0.0271803886,
0.0076828715,
-0.001167618,
-0.0751361325,
0.0491456315,
-0.0497287065,
0.0080788797,
-0.0187616423,
-0.0078002131,
0.0396141559,
0.0082946569,
-0.0082556959,
-0.0110923629,
-0.0274125934,
0.0103081241,
-0.0159398373,
0.0364095457,
-0.0014644874,
-0.0113429297,
-0.0282786321,
0.0520846583,
-0.0316985771,
-0.0187215228,
-0.0404612795,
0.037131086,
0.0365284532,
0.0132204136,
0.0506559275,
-0.0366575234,
-0.0232931618,
-0.0162551645,
0.0572189614,
0.0134767285,
-0.0711382478,
-0.0544540696,
0.0197361968,
-0.0425934605,
-0.0441663601,
0.0403325371,
0.0000035063,
0.0454312675,
-0.050889194,
-0.0271388814,
-0.0525927357,
-0.0516183488,
-0.0302974731,
-0.0354382545,
-0.0032035804,
-0.0498679578,
-0.0529810414,
-0.0447193943,
-0.0106457025,
0.0127922045,
0.0199132897,
0.0105334753,
0.0423025191,
0.0551567823,
-0.04354693,
-0.0017947216,
-0.0128493626,
-0.0157722272,
0.0291169621,
0.0064131673,
-0.0405575782,
-5.44984748e-33,
-0.0467817411,
-0.0142838927,
0.0253290888,
-0.059100233,
-0.0802088827,
-0.0292825792,
-0.0614348948,
0.052582588,
0.0832548216,
0.0145447887,
-0.0210866872,
-0.0452375524,
0.0056230947,
-0.000053725,
0.0212459005,
0.000064789,
0.087532796,
0.0414292216,
-0.0642506704,
-0.0112267444,
0.004618458,
0.0238416698,
0.0306332577,
-0.029738944,
0.0625321493,
0.017848134,
-0.039056547,
-0.0173663981,
-0.0212233365,
0.0703707039,
0.0151942987,
-0.0108103408,
0.0049283225,
-0.0636348575,
-0.0463422798,
0.0059235222,
-0.0102738682,
0.0126873329,
0.0163338501,
-0.005927396,
-0.0334027186,
-0.0670965239,
0.0383969285,
-0.01381783,
-0.0455264896,
-0.0108810645,
0.0251009203,
-0.0642250329,
0.0110381609,
-0.002912885,
-0.0728749111,
0.0089329509,
-0.0237358157,
-0.0565713644,
-0.0354311094,
0.043242678,
-0.0000860478,
-0.0420882627,
-0.0069877547,
0.0240235198,
0.0605425872,
0.0223038923,
0.0707576126,
0.0039324057,
0.0220801216,
0.0366524421,
0.032435976,
0.0185663383,
-0.0492095165,
0.0237630699,
-0.004693774,
0.0375090688,
0.0319427773,
0.0581816547,
0.0123611856,
-0.0201755371,
-0.0117431991,
0.0289713014,
-0.0729019195,
0.0262979195,
-0.0088521186,
0.0138771124,
-0.0025993874,
-0.0108586075,
-0.0660118461,
-0.0147096906,
-0.0188701525,
-0.052869983,
0.0395483226,
0.0107659679,
-0.0266170073,
-0.034222275,
0.0263371952,
0.0184918046,
-0.0069815344,
0.0090248249,
-0.0468516275,
0.0609327108,
-0.0048015341,
-0.0508245602,
0.0192606077,
0.0410943031,
0.0641996861,
0.0288983695,
0.0369751379,
-0.017622767,
0.0233023036,
0.0432143509,
-0.0629732609,
0.023326382,
-0.0181996897,
0.0160928816,
0.0009124998,
-0.0399687514,
0.0422468781,
-0.0173557512,
-0.0339646973,
0.0217300989,
0.0122627448,
0.0160797052,
-0.0420045294,
0.0178062245,
0.0133924652,
0.0255643781,
-0.0231732521,
0.0271211136,
-0.0049172514,
0.0054801735,
0.0511445962,
-0.019353427,
-0.0401739404,
-0.0066006491,
2.707e-7,
0.0265278034,
0.0436702892,
0.0477896035,
0.0202062987,
0.0032110796,
0.0019577064,
-0.0139975278,
-0.012692702,
0.0190487746,
0.0233653747,
0.0140167708,
-0.0168878604,
0.0567579679,
0.0225513428,
-0.0691148937,
-0.0040509612,
-0.081270501,
0.0463215783,
-0.0493881218,
-0.0315896012,
0.0572949834,
-0.00042008,
0.0137814358,
0.0191489924,
-0.004018974,
-0.0353983901,
0.0369287618,
-0.0382383317,
-0.0285688937,
0.0180588271,
0.0494399928,
-0.0271392744,
0.0213490948,
-0.0305673219,
-0.0295697991,
-0.0362279117,
0.0102837365,
0.06349051,
0.0118894419,
0.0179975647,
0.0237005632,
0.0111351851,
0.0066047255,
-0.0388526544,
0.0343715474,
-0.0473742932,
0.0015220389,
-0.0271754302,
-0.0415585861,
0.0105716521,
0.0285700876,
-0.0338035859,
0.0019610834,
0.0165276062,
0.0162517596,
0.043319717,
-0.0081870481,
0.0144303534,
-0.0608563758,
0.0042119892,
-0.031399399,
-0.0648164228,
-0.0371343605,
-0.0325115025,
0.0190214012,
-0.0582215115,
-0.0323614255,
2.291219176e-34,
0.0317554809,
0.000230552,
0.0515858345,
-0.0044394378,
0.0632907078,
-0.0112152286,
0.0447270833,
0.0020825884,
0.0196643211,
-0.0613375492,
-0.0417664349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09391v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09391v3 | LlaSMol: Advancing Large Language Models for Chemistry with a Large-Scale, Comprehensive, High-Quality Instruction Tuning Dataset | 2024-02-14T18:42:25 | 2024-04-01T17:28:16 | Botao Yu, Frazier N. Baker, Ziqi Chen, Xia Ning, Huan Sun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL | Chemistry plays a crucial role in many domains, such as drug discovery and
material science. While large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 exhibit
remarkable capabilities on natural language processing tasks, existing research
indicates that their performance on chemistry tasks is discouragingly low. In
this paper, however, we demonstrate that our developed LLMs can achieve very
strong results on a comprehensive set of chemistry tasks, outperforming the
most advanced GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus by a substantial margin. To accomplish
this, we propose SMolInstruct, a large-scale, comprehensive, and high-quality
dataset for instruction tuning. It contains 14 selected chemistry tasks and
over three million samples, laying a solid foundation for training and
evaluating LLMs for chemistry. Using SMolInstruct, we fine-tune a set of
open-source LLMs, among which, we find that Mistral serves as the best base
model for chemistry tasks. Our analysis further demonstrates the critical role
of the proposed dataset in driving the performance improvements. | [
0.0260345694,
0.0861425102,
0.0197461676,
0.0229389686,
-0.00780934,
0.0050725467,
0.0406823382,
-0.0094625875,
0.0673355311,
-0.0238322187,
-0.0642777979,
-0.0202141199,
-0.0474951267,
0.0385012254,
0.0202001575,
-0.0018621944,
0.0333348326,
-0.0454386584,
-0.024781879,
-0.0004776154,
0.020471761,
0.0120751709,
-0.0188451223,
-0.0048280912,
0.0519915558,
-0.0316571407,
0.0184088368,
-0.0187005252,
0.0229220279,
-0.0371886566,
0.0121681299,
0.0696554482,
0.0243716165,
0.0669399425,
0.0000018437,
-0.0575558618,
0.006778013,
0.0235927273,
-0.0063247271,
0.0043077311,
0.0599390939,
-0.0462791882,
-0.018830793,
0.0129584298,
-0.0357269086,
0.0295273885,
0.0737361386,
0.0233913437,
0.0468552671,
0.0397086404,
0.0033041546,
-0.0397030339,
0.0364421569,
-0.034724731,
0.0508254133,
-0.0122700073,
0.0406984463,
0.0227062609,
0.0248406064,
0.0152718853,
-0.0014598926,
0.0364888944,
-0.0115880286,
-0.0264180638,
0.0167094488,
0.0086220494,
-0.0619474389,
-0.0173907503,
-0.0100598177,
0.0923043713,
-0.0376488529,
-0.0205129646,
-0.061366234,
-0.0087388642,
-0.0559837036,
-0.0038326697,
-0.0556442961,
0.009623914,
-0.0026011791,
0.0204057898,
0.0368813537,
-0.0178667922,
0.0240432173,
0.0209665596,
0.0328194462,
0.0469656959,
0.0119826831,
-0.0205950569,
0.0171924084,
0.0006084499,
-0.0675594211,
0.0063072923,
0.0223591588,
-0.0088493284,
-0.0060330904,
0.016146699,
0.0119980583,
0.0020192442,
0.0580721647,
-0.029615147,
0.0411434621,
0.0294646602,
-0.0031433026,
0.0550916344,
-0.0374044701,
0.0227127783,
-0.0091138696,
0.0152262999,
-0.0496313646,
-0.0024316208,
-0.0705111101,
0.0035369773,
-0.0409997404,
-0.0052689826,
-0.0457067341,
-0.0123310648,
-0.0455616377,
0.0147483982,
0.0119474167,
-0.0070818546,
0.0674232692,
0.0247910451,
-0.0271505732,
0.0093572326,
-0.0257908907,
0.0432383604,
0.0062581333,
0.0182755999,
-0.0075304289,
-0.0426387377,
-0.0570772216,
-0.0039159032,
-0.0247531515,
-0.0428179875,
0.0235125124,
0.0998699293,
-0.0113820182,
-0.0257178601,
-0.0140034491,
-0.0419073962,
0.0306243151,
-0.0716994181,
0.0316942632,
-0.0424258374,
0.0518832095,
0.0306277331,
0.0150494622,
-0.054799173,
0.0204708204,
-0.0056021428,
-0.0176032428,
0.0999647453,
0.0035634448,
-0.0798240826,
0.008661327,
0.0126881925,
-0.016632881,
0.0060526314,
0.0059454353,
-0.0065162317,
-0.0014029884,
-0.0111479862,
-0.0012206,
-0.0042485716,
-0.0034908256,
-0.0090710893,
0.0144374566,
0.0040107933,
-0.0165458955,
0.0586506054,
0.0320300348,
0.0060243225,
-0.0104610194,
-0.0293428544,
0.0430003107,
0.0367583707,
0.0396319069,
0.0410287976,
0.0181379672,
0.003520634,
0.0311284792,
-0.0381054357,
-0.0431561694,
0.0441452637,
-0.0323121697,
0.0028413692,
0.0237621721,
0.0434430018,
-0.012449516,
-0.0200109556,
-0.00868122,
0.0134092141,
0.0127288913,
-0.0357437693,
0.0404712409,
-0.0329588614,
-0.0883320272,
0.0415600725,
0.047899615,
-0.0467253923,
-0.0199798904,
-0.0085540861,
0.0389336944,
0.0912088454,
0.0493171997,
-0.0621224679,
-0.0476880632,
0.0027129946,
-0.0105541991,
0.0313547738,
0.0007705724,
-0.0189505536,
0.0274903085,
-0.0504811741,
-0.0359557085,
-0.0427113883,
0.0090110889,
-0.0230811089,
0.0183816925,
-0.028796332,
-0.0090515018,
-0.0195101686,
-0.0314793177,
0.026752485,
-0.0105591258,
-0.0651965737,
-0.0098705003,
-0.0289228763,
0.0353013128,
0.002894097,
0.0042711501,
0.0263531581,
0.0564213842,
-0.046836026,
0.0154674128,
-0.0508050136,
-0.0039050011,
-0.0728725791,
0.0374314897,
-0.0314200781,
0.0116930883,
-0.0010415665,
-0.06167496,
-0.0272322316,
0.074145548,
0.0024781171,
-0.0187843852,
-0.0097048506,
0.0007802279,
0.0205536485,
0.0579001643,
-0.044521872,
0.040388383,
-0.0231828652,
0.0101454509,
0.0076460443,
0.0287051126,
-0.0018948759,
-0.0217544511,
0.0095355511,
-0.0057980265,
0.0494267233,
0.0494040996,
0.016346423,
0.0037857273,
-0.0296784062,
-0.0255172011,
-0.0284257699,
0.0251419321,
-0.0129805757,
0.0248833299,
0.0305586308,
-0.0039545419,
0.0127287097,
-0.0031324031,
0.0077909753,
-0.0306284372,
-0.0403384678,
-0.0092026936,
0.023022186,
0.0063733533,
-0.0479630977,
-0.0689074695,
-0.0559338406,
-0.0350914523,
0.0266510472,
-0.013885322,
-0.0061825924,
-0.0129133472,
-0.0104751447,
0.0109279454,
0.0345838331,
-0.0005778083,
-0.0303191822,
0.0082755713,
-0.0081178546,
0.0208696425,
0.0480194651,
-0.0247497689,
0.0397980958,
0.0611384287,
0.0047570881,
-0.0264584217,
0.0092806788,
-0.0189839769,
0.0014648593,
0.0325682536,
-0.0008276406,
-0.0017014878,
0.0989912227,
-0.0415571071,
0.0045792763,
-0.0303318892,
0.0472536981,
-0.0002731386,
-0.0111803468,
-0.0158602763,
0.0267762598,
0.0194062535,
-0.0358293094,
-0.0036092533,
-0.0626456514,
0.0907519385,
-0.0279555954,
0.0123825194,
-0.1029155403,
-0.0131478161,
-0.0025853077,
-0.0224785469,
0.0193492919,
0.0074445163,
-0.0009295739,
0.0157879833,
-0.0164655969,
-0.0036340493,
0.0418207757,
-0.0051579848,
0.0458198749,
-0.0639890656,
0.0243430901,
-0.0048409351,
-0.0489591174,
-0.0017316426,
0.0100242849,
-0.0226268079,
0.0742411464,
0.0331508182,
-0.0489716753,
-0.0520637296,
0.0162249301,
0.0277657341,
0.028983321,
-0.0105616497,
-0.0035976886,
-0.0514708534,
0.0104956655,
0.0324522145,
-0.0570931211,
0.0358965211,
-0.0291426815,
0.0474999547,
0.0496903583,
0.0292612929,
-0.013668932,
-0.0092221508,
0.0322101749,
0.0270365216,
-0.0121181449,
0.0023402628,
-0.003394716,
0.0207491424,
-0.056063354,
-0.0279017948,
0.0827450603,
0.0191348959,
-0.0137580559,
0.0093515888,
0.0138612073,
-0.0337517001,
0.0014578102,
0.0340498202,
-0.0911766589,
-0.0503941774,
-0.0544050634,
0.0238127057,
0.0005585055,
-0.0148567753,
-0.0172811877,
-0.0683105141,
0.0479605868,
0.0298647638,
-0.0555280298,
-0.0422477163,
-0.0744913965,
-0.0385793857,
-0.0514252,
0.0202994142,
0.0282738656,
-0.0299916063,
-0.02783034,
0.033517655,
0.0022036757,
-0.0993323475,
0.0484312847,
-0.0193353929,
0.0017362699,
0.0487027988,
-0.0106739737,
0.0179887358,
-0.0196149275,
0.0458079204,
-0.010340129,
0.0094139157,
-0.0341765173,
0.0226289239,
0.0406980403,
-0.0269430485,
-0.0110245869,
0.0536301769,
-0.057244461,
-0.0405712985,
-0.0353198647,
0.1369876713,
-0.008172174,
0.0082503622,
-0.0409345627,
0.0029201305,
0.006646974,
0.0504746176,
-0.0093094949,
-0.0002364307,
-0.085136503,
-0.0318394154,
-0.0078480598,
-0.0433638208,
0.001303966,
0.0116755888,
-0.0320269726,
0.0012861186,
-0.0153186368,
-0.0266225953,
0.0613458529,
-0.0176743716,
-0.0214780644,
0.0087734349,
0.0116971247,
-0.0307163801,
-0.0394653417,
0.075911589,
-0.0060888715,
0.0139514366,
-0.0693588778,
-0.0650203377,
0.0209474675,
-0.0056200069,
-0.0257693082,
0.0613733083,
-0.0757768303,
-0.0608912259,
-0.020797072,
0.0526043288,
0.0197933819,
0.0261499099,
-0.0267394856,
-0.0791133791,
0.025133606,
0.0149594666,
-0.0007415237,
-0.0348913111,
0.000507593,
-0.013407181,
-0.0119116446,
-0.0150263961,
0.008523087,
0.0338083804,
-0.003103961,
0.0478613451,
-0.0117118498,
-0.0064411066,
0.0455557182,
0.0143792201,
0.0647755489,
0.0153009007,
0.0457816161,
-0.0460409522,
0.0002564494,
0.0266110748,
0.0225384925,
-0.0424599685,
0.0002121016,
0.062208809,
-0.0691770911,
-0.0287034754,
-0.0105527192,
-0.0410974175,
0.0213663299,
-0.0350365154,
0.0471568517,
0.0115220388,
-0.0023839751,
0.0951569378,
-0.0205854233,
-0.0209106021,
-0.0003707579,
-0.0424824916,
0.0570169091,
-0.0326057412,
0.0421732627,
0.000706514,
0.0577328205,
-0.0417572744,
0.0458468273,
-0.0157613214,
-0.031367097,
-0.086901769,
0.0262061059,
0.0564058349,
-0.0265492518,
0.055877842,
-0.0340919644,
-0.0315450653,
-0.0431966744,
0.0338780954,
0.0078010242,
-0.0035257924,
0.0636974573,
0.0464084744,
-0.0008180828,
-0.0182270985,
0.0807078108,
0.0187895223,
0.0548711643,
0.0045561073,
-0.0408879146,
-0.0291172788,
-0.0270679146,
-0.0283502191,
0.0193006527,
-0.0175299533,
0.018681515,
-0.0287949629,
-0.029226711,
-0.0087067783,
0.0345457196,
-0.0180902779,
-0.002827256,
0.0489329658,
0.0507404022,
-0.0054188301,
-0.0683212355,
-0.0256427322,
-0.0081069218,
0.0109633589,
-0.0498333089,
-0.0132889068,
-5.611275548e-33,
-0.0013265766,
0.0270406697,
0.0248699952,
-0.0126312366,
0.0102047045,
-0.0361136459,
-0.0785937011,
-0.0299743041,
-0.0098883864,
0.071891807,
0.0096978648,
-0.0012853703,
0.019129565,
-0.0161272641,
0.0286245979,
0.0152978282,
0.0246030912,
0.0321906172,
-0.020120142,
0.0343754366,
0.0580793098,
0.0384365767,
0.0937433243,
-0.0300403051,
-0.0384231173,
0.0491752177,
0.0196147207,
-0.0077123228,
-0.0581650473,
0.059757024,
-0.055353649,
0.0737307146,
-0.0163852312,
-0.0483343974,
-0.0375778638,
-0.0321518779,
-0.0501536466,
-0.0143307205,
0.0212268028,
-0.008539266,
-0.015962908,
-0.0338922702,
0.005882368,
0.0151202949,
-0.0381587446,
-0.0241423193,
0.0153183574,
-0.0214908738,
0.0011391586,
-0.0189225003,
-0.0920711979,
0.0243086498,
0.0011394835,
-0.0080526359,
0.0029599636,
0.0042693042,
0.0056616911,
0.0171758328,
-0.0414680652,
0.0343497321,
0.0187387895,
0.0727345943,
0.043281775,
0.0003402868,
-0.0106110238,
0.0342701226,
0.0146777751,
0.0111459242,
0.0395875163,
0.0119940871,
0.0040934514,
0.0480988696,
0.0379794575,
-0.0067908019,
0.0455853827,
0.0384075753,
-0.1068576127,
-0.0123889325,
-0.0063298955,
0.0482823774,
-0.0065043047,
0.040710941,
-0.0054952754,
-0.0395429693,
-0.0230961721,
0.0305949152,
-0.0167767648,
-0.0084732007,
-0.0168030765,
-0.0247292258,
-0.0357779786,
0.0100699132,
0.0293477643,
-0.0453587733,
-0.0355324037,
0.0318962522,
-0.0196580421,
0.0299203768,
0.0065521635,
0.0175327789,
-0.0940854028,
-0.0324712247,
0.0133463982,
-0.0389648639,
0.0111977365,
-0.0044177496,
0.003955584,
0.0302689262,
-0.0171765797,
-0.0152332243,
-0.1022581905,
0.0140959769,
0.0238443501,
0.0484314337,
-0.0096026761,
0.0295634475,
0.0021137698,
0.0664597452,
0.0090863835,
-0.0403852537,
0.0316981338,
0.0120471241,
0.0282929465,
0.0356085785,
-0.0368881822,
0.0027682269,
-0.0677547827,
-0.0066331155,
0.0182712451,
-0.0664234534,
-0.0075421156,
0.0094415564,
2.595e-7,
0.0705682784,
0.0437357761,
0.0261384472,
0.0224368349,
-0.022465108,
0.0129644796,
-0.0098056644,
0.0429319516,
-0.0209488049,
-0.0032872015,
0.0000310686,
0.0051321625,
0.0264993459,
0.0298949219,
-0.0417324491,
0.0110844746,
-0.0519354492,
-0.0240606312,
-0.0560182966,
-0.0262266733,
-0.0061457898,
0.1109591946,
-0.0006813456,
-0.0200322233,
0.0167379547,
0.0014125064,
0.0546184406,
0.0022313881,
-0.0012648347,
0.0708686709,
0.0123947039,
-0.0204261225,
-0.0082913404,
0.0574068353,
-0.0362586416,
0.002523449,
-0.0088315569,
0.0447600558,
-0.0279849619,
-0.0061681871,
0.0350065902,
-0.0484647416,
0.01014065,
-0.0114598451,
0.0115479343,
-0.0222683605,
-0.0085710166,
-0.0025222225,
-0.0195637774,
0.0027021237,
0.0438165404,
-0.0244730022,
0.0106186783,
0.0253494047,
-0.0096805282,
0.0023136786,
-0.0155272102,
-0.0504684336,
-0.0490751527,
0.0278968625,
-0.0389587171,
-0.0074428669,
-0.0270293541,
-0.0042176158,
0.0154143535,
-0.0172645543,
-0.0093703922,
2.307472681e-34,
0.0565431006,
-0.011012773,
0.0365927145,
0.0118338158,
0.0648752898,
-0.018006634,
-0.009506694,
0.0283870865,
-0.0059417291,
-0.0946290046,
-0.0146250986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09390v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09390v2 | HGOT: Hierarchical Graph of Thoughts for Retrieval-Augmented In-Context Learning in Factuality Evaluation | 2024-02-14T18:41:19 | 2024-07-02T12:42:59 | Yihao Fang, Stephen W. Thomas, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | With the widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) in numerous
applications, the challenge of factuality and the propensity for hallucinations
has emerged as a significant concern. To address this issue, particularly in
retrieval-augmented in-context learning, we introduce the hierarchical graph of
thoughts (HGOT), a structured, multi-layered graph approach designed to enhance
the retrieval of pertinent passages during in-context learning. The framework
utilizes the emergent planning capabilities of LLMs, employing the
divide-and-conquer strategy to break down complex queries into manageable
sub-queries. It refines self-consistency majority voting for answer selection,
which incorporates the recently proposed citation recall and precision metrics
to assess the quality of thoughts, linking an answer's credibility
intrinsically to the thought's quality. This methodology introduces a weighted
system in majority voting, prioritizing answers based on the citation quality
of their thoughts. Additionally, we propose a scoring mechanism for evaluating
retrieved passages, considering factors such as citation frequency and quality,
self-consistency confidence, and the retrieval module's ranking. Experiments
indicate that HGOT excels as a versatile approach, outperforming competing
models in FEVER by up to $7\%$ and matching leading models such as
Retrieve-then-Read in Open-SQuAD, and DSP in HotPotQA, demonstrating its
efficacy in enhancing LLMs' factuality. | [
0.0606548227,
-0.0051303483,
0.0039270725,
0.0258267317,
-0.0740150437,
-0.0178716425,
-0.0402321517,
-0.0361816138,
0.0589217991,
-0.0571806282,
-0.0209671985,
-0.0383573025,
-0.0166324247,
-0.0170549639,
-0.0078535974,
-0.0136193754,
0.0484076403,
-0.0171002988,
0.0492309146,
-0.0051217121,
-0.0007095695,
0.0114217019,
-0.0071428474,
0.0313945375,
0.0060847015,
-0.0339193568,
0.0203147642,
0.0115624182,
0.021076927,
-0.0693311095,
0.0064870967,
0.0344415307,
-0.001782999,
0.051981844,
0.0000022797,
-0.0512323231,
-0.0374558792,
-0.0242144037,
-0.0101293204,
-0.002039837,
0.0474846959,
0.0385111496,
0.0323377587,
0.0139752543,
-0.0697525442,
0.0235341676,
0.0006755425,
0.0433067419,
0.0558392741,
0.04806979,
0.000929251,
-0.0406348482,
0.0225316696,
0.0330182873,
0.0262608286,
-0.0221861023,
0.0373612382,
0.0394100174,
0.0377232879,
0.0230506156,
-0.0008674873,
0.039403975,
-0.0170889795,
-0.0076945131,
0.0675002113,
0.0315868296,
-0.0147098815,
-0.0101705678,
0.0227065478,
0.0787455216,
0.0138180908,
-0.0447498336,
-0.0115933539,
0.0033020999,
0.0004116778,
0.042883683,
-0.0700315833,
0.0067348466,
-0.0275594704,
0.0197143052,
0.0320908464,
0.0132489344,
0.0278403927,
0.0121618751,
-0.0343738385,
0.076324366,
-0.0105291819,
-0.0539267138,
0.0356302783,
0.01010687,
-0.0054810643,
-0.0256229695,
0.0207105055,
0.0344276689,
-0.0495304242,
0.0164473671,
-0.0005690553,
0.0025492718,
0.0239043366,
-0.0586774908,
0.0259673391,
0.0123969726,
-0.0048948308,
0.0575852357,
-0.0026111545,
0.0046053831,
-0.0036253224,
0.0426852517,
-0.056700334,
-0.0082971891,
-0.046892643,
0.0047596311,
-0.0209203083,
0.0468448326,
-0.0018739023,
-0.0231751781,
-0.0458150022,
0.0111542214,
-0.0201671366,
-0.0084233098,
-0.0064398339,
0.0247409027,
0.0114777982,
0.0034655672,
-0.0449952185,
0.0396725535,
-0.0037929281,
0.0022277625,
-0.0060794358,
-0.0269397181,
-0.0130691016,
-0.0021116352,
-0.0009248988,
-0.0141246459,
0.0156234829,
-0.0047503794,
0.002453174,
-0.0234349836,
-0.0452463776,
-0.0292070098,
-0.0244535711,
-0.0690818131,
0.0054369457,
-0.0879896432,
-0.0174031649,
0.0065217097,
0.0018058012,
-0.0085754199,
0.0352844857,
0.0605706573,
-0.0356187858,
0.0180237107,
-0.0133556705,
-0.0043711811,
0.0094916178,
0.0179106947,
0.0042314823,
0.0555039309,
0.0315098166,
0.023614917,
0.0588907786,
0.0454817563,
0.0273511782,
-0.0088813109,
0.0190903191,
0.0192551408,
0.0070592389,
0.0139298961,
-0.0051732021,
0.0233146362,
-0.0498715043,
0.0539954528,
-0.0268171113,
-0.0138168745,
0.0784513429,
0.0629136562,
-0.0132067604,
-0.0348238982,
0.0036892768,
0.0253017135,
0.0278271269,
0.0290378053,
-0.0171913859,
0.0475517921,
-0.0339910686,
0.01792573,
0.0488538928,
0.0197059531,
-0.0049905768,
-0.0294564329,
-0.0282669421,
0.0319513418,
-0.0140113197,
0.044292409,
0.0270764064,
-0.0192171112,
-0.0608905181,
0.0319729857,
0.0245815702,
-0.0330462344,
-0.0002678326,
-0.0356402211,
0.0195151716,
0.0555695444,
0.0683056489,
-0.0260868426,
-0.0097257877,
-0.0136575373,
-0.019173041,
0.0208147969,
-0.0040598488,
-0.0176908635,
-0.0356699117,
-0.0526361987,
-0.0058104931,
0.0080114594,
0.0102868443,
-0.0399487875,
-0.0056453678,
0.0050729648,
-0.0141026545,
-0.0383520611,
-0.0455428883,
0.0128553277,
0.0079768067,
-0.0019639779,
-0.0162773132,
-0.0116307614,
0.0245455094,
0.0411990695,
-0.0244429484,
0.0373621956,
0.0338719301,
-0.0187918618,
-0.0216070209,
-0.0040519098,
-0.0667287633,
-0.0289118253,
0.045000989,
-0.0239809025,
0.0023088811,
-0.0193864629,
0.0027588487,
-0.0283084102,
-0.0126214176,
-0.0564303771,
0.0070032799,
-0.0315457955,
0.0089809811,
-0.0390898287,
-0.0287453812,
-0.0587525368,
0.0799690485,
-0.0153157683,
0.0302957408,
0.0289898124,
-0.0068778023,
0.0237879697,
-0.0259852074,
-0.023084024,
0.015605974,
0.0162614826,
0.0248126406,
0.0487468876,
-0.0181441158,
-0.0801225007,
0.0038582541,
-0.1047358587,
0.0059462241,
-0.0265566669,
-0.0121337604,
0.0045097936,
-0.0240880195,
-0.0021456077,
-0.0014822782,
-0.0272264946,
0.0115690725,
0.0124002211,
0.028655393,
0.0111972867,
-0.0119785778,
0.0404988453,
-0.0354277939,
-0.0181121007,
-0.0316223316,
0.0514974743,
0.0266956165,
-0.0224657711,
-0.0111102788,
0.0482070707,
-0.0688182935,
0.0005973658,
-0.0103859697,
-0.0019687957,
0.0244094729,
-0.0384570807,
0.0391549766,
0.0686472356,
0.022230003,
-0.0139742782,
0.0809785575,
-0.0286692698,
-0.0581985116,
0.005178282,
-0.0311960075,
-0.0220528245,
-0.0195467547,
-0.0215403382,
0.0091161411,
0.0233387165,
0.0401738472,
-0.0229295325,
-0.0451980904,
0.007605934,
-0.0388662182,
0.0066333325,
-0.0507934168,
-0.0013556021,
-0.0134646995,
0.0370088555,
-0.0127088502,
-0.0313996263,
0.1033773497,
-0.0043624775,
0.0250249784,
-0.0802896917,
-0.014609186,
-0.043096222,
0.0408776775,
0.0086365426,
0.003688192,
-0.0110161388,
0.0029536984,
-0.053274937,
-0.0099997474,
0.0325770415,
-0.091697529,
0.0452532396,
-0.0137312729,
0.0053797672,
0.0176210236,
-0.0022758143,
-0.0489695519,
0.0042099827,
-0.0449871607,
0.0078336019,
0.0004537197,
0.0066589131,
-0.0525045991,
-0.0362022258,
0.077573359,
0.0117684249,
-0.0207134821,
-0.0350922048,
0.0206409395,
0.0290218759,
0.0708730444,
-0.0055341828,
0.0511391573,
-0.017251173,
0.0289381333,
0.110442847,
0.0538742393,
-0.0279985685,
0.0132467514,
-0.0339136012,
0.0360504538,
-0.0286958646,
-0.0018485162,
0.0179441031,
0.0363211296,
-0.0507543944,
-0.0223371163,
0.0996299684,
0.0498462245,
-0.0619457699,
-0.0163191408,
-0.0497226976,
0.0289572943,
0.0255431551,
0.0122337937,
-0.1057252437,
-0.0136930272,
-0.0159799065,
0.0422681011,
-0.0317468233,
-0.0600260459,
0.0082377959,
-0.1230197474,
0.0357268415,
0.0186319929,
0.0192843247,
-0.0171146002,
-0.0837035552,
0.0012903323,
0.0099341441,
-0.0356772728,
0.0093054231,
-0.009142342,
0.0197801683,
-0.0002308758,
0.0029811789,
0.0021321718,
0.0524795949,
-0.014668732,
0.0053210529,
0.0040272195,
0.0615977794,
0.0179603435,
-0.0686819553,
-0.0088334167,
-0.0578232966,
-0.0192272551,
-0.0232198071,
0.0211466253,
-0.0070047658,
0.0444582328,
-0.0537088625,
0.002988193,
0.0133430306,
-0.043160893,
0.0129609043,
0.1193742529,
-0.023938302,
-0.0117537733,
-0.0637345687,
0.0469192639,
0.0098628858,
0.0848795101,
0.0123452246,
-0.0171782877,
-0.027252214,
-0.0289460309,
0.0475359894,
-0.0278986208,
-0.0797009766,
0.0362025276,
-0.0031552683,
0.0684265643,
-0.0723256022,
-0.0257352088,
0.0031800764,
0.0318260081,
-0.0075600045,
0.0529734157,
0.0418993533,
0.0070163845,
-0.0496899448,
0.0065298737,
-0.0420300215,
0.0131159127,
-0.0229658876,
0.015292353,
0.0747607574,
-0.0169233698,
-0.0017215697,
0.0211299546,
-0.0235145129,
-0.0491336584,
-0.0031489858,
0.022826368,
0.0194171388,
0.0376511626,
-0.0039331838,
-0.0140628526,
0.0945118591,
0.0295468122,
-0.0429644957,
0.0060225474,
0.0110139921,
0.0231965668,
-0.0003058144,
0.0271625631,
-0.0485139117,
0.0115042441,
-0.0049472861,
0.0610849969,
-0.0121909203,
-0.0478353649,
0.0302683208,
0.0227771401,
0.0222083405,
0.0321344957,
-0.0148184132,
-0.0325080156,
0.0123744085,
-0.0216563754,
-0.0247111544,
-0.0146326888,
0.0070353574,
0.0310352221,
-0.0352856144,
-0.001254929,
-0.0137989502,
-0.0207556542,
0.0371223241,
-0.014507032,
-0.0107707512,
-0.0200407989,
-0.0064878175,
0.0180276204,
-0.0064360243,
-0.0583646782,
-0.0061337994,
-0.0007622832,
0.055746112,
0.0222706478,
0.079019472,
0.0142848939,
-0.0650552884,
-0.0083430484,
0.0019542419,
-0.1121593416,
-0.0146695618,
-0.0125346752,
-0.01210122,
0.0518427864,
0.0198710859,
0.0528240986,
-0.0236461591,
-0.0111275287,
-0.0241765138,
0.0009258096,
-0.0019866554,
-0.0222011749,
-0.0007144733,
0.031065328,
-0.00484807,
0.0545541085,
0.0515317395,
-0.0072252117,
0.0167314541,
0.0314239599,
-0.0553346165,
-0.0211915579,
-0.0438701212,
-0.0748556331,
0.0759205669,
-0.0094064679,
0.0160003994,
-0.1110981107,
-0.0424619503,
0.0441433117,
0.0153828142,
-0.0109716412,
-0.0309075639,
0.0422685072,
0.0528405458,
0.0018183871,
-0.0317286029,
-0.0564749949,
0.0430886485,
-0.0214328282,
-0.0215238221,
-0.0225944445,
-7.023733764e-33,
0.0101668248,
-0.0702099651,
0.0302992854,
0.0024908578,
-0.0393759198,
-0.0006750965,
-0.0291466489,
0.0180077795,
-0.0492178313,
0.016888421,
-0.0104407007,
0.0114386389,
-0.0011471097,
0.042409502,
-0.0129592549,
-0.0013806011,
0.0265136864,
-0.0010762203,
-0.0186379477,
0.0379723981,
0.0707674921,
0.0100471843,
0.0561101176,
-0.082470201,
0.0268374681,
-0.0166832525,
0.0336204469,
0.0307160523,
-0.0295447763,
0.0393151231,
-0.0088936305,
0.0683214888,
0.0212038532,
-0.0326549821,
0.0193586927,
0.0036588095,
-0.0517961793,
-0.0420748144,
0.0284988899,
-0.0297401696,
-0.0267368276,
-0.0209147166,
0.0173217133,
0.0039967573,
-0.0163631067,
-0.0507301614,
0.0455207638,
-0.0195670947,
-0.0437768027,
-0.0171912741,
-0.0468163192,
0.0158213265,
0.000279389,
0.0221818238,
-0.0208317619,
0.0398776978,
-0.0002241637,
0.0487972945,
-0.1208842397,
0.0347337313,
-0.0431606285,
0.0101188598,
0.0318780765,
-0.0093856081,
0.023206519,
0.0876625627,
0.0262427032,
0.011934625,
-0.039614208,
-0.0540188141,
0.0239079073,
0.0365855657,
0.0524835773,
0.0724679604,
0.0141511336,
0.0215598252,
-0.097322844,
0.0197233614,
0.0108779203,
0.0374966785,
0.0457995199,
0.0173780378,
-0.0340244174,
-0.0167839117,
-0.0220630914,
0.0068692151,
-0.0349124819,
-0.0016174612,
0.0145625975,
-0.0041181003,
-0.0212063827,
0.0131944669,
0.0307509974,
-0.0323392116,
-0.022660505,
0.0738816261,
-0.036094591,
0.0280975066,
-0.0131695904,
0.0357279554,
-0.0651425794,
0.0294272508,
-0.0104129072,
-0.0049975356,
-0.0143571701,
0.0287115555,
0.0016361577,
-0.0153741222,
-0.0325563699,
-0.0086466512,
-0.015872322,
-0.006601227,
-0.0123844976,
-0.0535120144,
0.037084356,
0.0248981491,
-0.0020929996,
0.052449055,
0.0305330288,
0.0306141898,
-0.0155107034,
-0.0113993641,
-0.0026595187,
-0.0089783287,
-0.0038717606,
0.0158333201,
-0.0257868394,
0.0508882292,
-0.0010117923,
-0.0774301142,
-0.0102237184,
0.0167855676,
3.081e-7,
0.0169335958,
0.0599260256,
-0.0181155913,
-0.0179915279,
-0.0035975769,
0.0527163297,
-0.0002692587,
0.0015464416,
0.0737666637,
-0.0397489667,
-0.0187168065,
0.0302492063,
0.0303090271,
0.0674524084,
-0.0923569128,
-0.0123491213,
-0.0582156219,
-0.0221488159,
-0.0342903435,
-0.0069127651,
0.0580918193,
0.0336944796,
0.0293744449,
-0.0106414296,
-0.0083309617,
-0.0573286973,
0.057013914,
-0.0009385489,
-0.0398489907,
0.0331346579,
0.0556476377,
0.0227793157,
0.0155869229,
-0.0014597357,
-0.0041529047,
0.0101096286,
0.0135658747,
-0.0061657238,
0.0091109658,
-0.0622829534,
-0.0075997645,
-0.0239867922,
0.0191371217,
-0.0920522884,
0.0562386923,
-0.05522177,
-0.0289097708,
-0.0074933623,
-0.0390152223,
-0.0101025673,
0.043813698,
-0.0006473653,
-0.0352811962,
0.0065031513,
-0.0074583679,
0.047003936,
-0.009051878,
-0.0355984978,
-0.0129962517,
0.0271612275,
-0.0123131461,
-0.0761697963,
0.0030425314,
-0.007576352,
-0.0208561085,
-0.055162508,
0.032583572,
3.038349151e-34,
0.0305846613,
-0.0152707314,
0.0281043481,
0.0196029171,
0.0156901535,
0.0042924355,
0.0109321885,
-0.0028475986,
0.0294295307,
-0.0966205299,
-0.0184032582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09371v1 | Transformers Can Achieve Length Generalization But Not Robustly | 2024-02-14T18:18:29 | 2024-02-14T18:18:29 | Yongchao Zhou, Uri Alon, Xinyun Chen, Xuezhi Wang, Rishabh Agarwal, Denny Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Length generalization, defined as the ability to extrapolate from shorter
training sequences to longer test ones, is a significant challenge for language
models. This issue persists even with large-scale Transformers handling
relatively straightforward tasks. In this paper, we test the Transformer's
ability of length generalization using the task of addition of two integers. We
show that the success of length generalization is intricately linked to the
data format and the type of position encoding. Using the right combination of
data format and position encodings, we show for the first time that standard
Transformers can extrapolate to a sequence length that is 2.5x the input
length. Nevertheless, unlike in-distribution generalization, length
generalization remains fragile, significantly influenced by factors like random
weight initialization and training data order, leading to large variances
across different random seeds. | [
0.0215303749,
0.0822263733,
0.0083350493,
0.0131401932,
0.0175624397,
0.0118139666,
-0.0159042813,
-0.000577729,
-0.0946627781,
-0.0232560374,
0.010103167,
-0.0690686628,
0.0465692133,
-0.0024095555,
0.062670894,
-0.057168413,
0.0295915753,
-0.0014827258,
-0.0314645357,
-0.0108048767,
-0.009193602,
-0.024184458,
-0.0117327971,
0.0426434577,
0.0037019665,
0.0120227048,
-0.035227336,
-0.0504091308,
0.0065611671,
-0.0241941046,
-0.0055120955,
0.0271251835,
0.019280307,
0.0655481219,
0.0000016623,
-0.055738654,
-0.0171534959,
0.002466518,
-0.0209684521,
0.016150726,
-0.0086045275,
-0.0375934988,
-0.0308734942,
0.0489843972,
-0.0222774837,
-0.0491331033,
0.0675725862,
0.030523058,
0.038902007,
0.0886477083,
-0.0183936544,
-0.0625694543,
0.0313564651,
-0.0675072297,
0.0339220129,
0.0081404001,
0.0190020818,
-0.0104509033,
0.0068141241,
0.0202442221,
-0.052205205,
-0.0134910876,
0.0389708839,
0.0224201269,
-0.0400720872,
0.0226183124,
-0.0485568866,
-0.0193050709,
-0.0104690129,
0.016824754,
-0.0693597347,
-0.0304494668,
-0.002534338,
0.0093639949,
0.0080058388,
-0.0416742042,
-0.0495127067,
0.0405437499,
0.0147527494,
0.0036102722,
-0.0222657863,
0.0004940583,
0.0318733566,
-0.0442609899,
-0.0557211451,
0.0561830699,
0.0320863388,
-0.0200307053,
-0.0496803448,
-0.0075706271,
-0.026431432,
-0.0246985033,
-0.0404669158,
0.0572471619,
0.0144685842,
0.0216075536,
-0.0278813392,
-0.0494973287,
0.0109840026,
-0.033876542,
0.0360372588,
0.0566132963,
-0.0211102422,
-0.0102266874,
-0.0523902364,
0.0802400634,
-0.0325737819,
0.062477272,
-0.0483444743,
0.0263780169,
-0.001854666,
0.0048285001,
-0.0460439473,
-0.0017685882,
-0.0129335038,
-0.0233121291,
-0.0552357957,
0.0566797815,
0.0562534742,
0.016188655,
0.0387078859,
-0.0083548157,
-0.0325133651,
-0.0070590028,
0.0124030272,
0.0358763933,
-0.0233123768,
0.0114169605,
0.0161936861,
-0.036610879,
-0.0377118438,
0.0134181036,
0.0283193793,
0.0047228374,
0.0072512617,
0.0963827372,
-0.0178647395,
-0.0359383896,
-0.0101605011,
0.0151509903,
-0.0309553482,
-0.0325217582,
0.0152924396,
-0.0638375804,
-0.0063624769,
0.0151462685,
0.0019362435,
-0.0014077231,
0.012869373,
0.0265679844,
-0.0058305743,
0.0449524224,
0.0008977404,
-0.0080759535,
0.0076890667,
-0.0017025345,
0.0388823748,
0.0402814373,
0.0455954969,
-0.0010789604,
0.0293483287,
-0.0219661817,
0.0134308236,
0.0843764096,
0.0005516836,
0.0010771062,
-0.0003365035,
-0.0293312352,
0.0240029171,
0.0116296262,
0.0204581786,
0.0625963733,
-0.0468814261,
-0.0399498306,
0.0377676375,
0.0566245168,
0.0308697075,
0.0679656193,
0.0451519676,
0.0041686432,
-0.0047034202,
0.0371106341,
-0.0382575132,
0.0034180451,
-0.0103985369,
0.0467168391,
0.0335759446,
0.0462365374,
-0.0498533808,
-0.0340545475,
-0.0496144891,
-0.0325107388,
0.0456392951,
-0.0470335223,
0.0456077829,
0.0484179482,
-0.035099946,
0.1113202795,
0.0012203723,
-0.088062644,
-0.005927946,
-0.0365832746,
0.0026035851,
0.0005714073,
0.0342215449,
-0.0277586095,
-0.0009203886,
-0.0081343073,
-0.0452565365,
0.0090646977,
0.0297071226,
-0.0095289461,
-0.0010679186,
-0.0414310768,
-0.0432867333,
0.0408674553,
0.0238876771,
-0.0068780263,
0.0469458401,
-0.0137355095,
0.0443608426,
-0.0605139695,
0.00195361,
0.0313024521,
-0.0496516302,
-0.0318242237,
-0.0157843307,
0.0092600994,
-0.0047209654,
-0.0089393267,
0.0099787125,
0.0403685085,
0.038208019,
0.0024547651,
-0.0259559862,
0.0010390028,
-0.0349354483,
-0.0041616028,
0.0558945648,
-0.0154621322,
0.0207702387,
0.0654054359,
-0.0216341633,
-0.0492216907,
0.0122114485,
-0.0890835524,
0.050220523,
-0.015724523,
0.0478278548,
-0.0159954429,
0.0398988724,
-0.0193200875,
0.0293144789,
-0.0171918031,
0.0303790383,
-0.0305543803,
-0.0107851578,
0.0329081304,
-0.0271522477,
-0.0492723361,
0.012652304,
-0.0288692787,
0.0217985474,
0.0263268929,
-0.0423434637,
-0.0237991139,
-0.0636600703,
-0.0600539111,
-0.017472785,
-0.0421943329,
0.0587201938,
0.0000537937,
0.0288681015,
0.0075924979,
-0.0285298675,
-0.0703789592,
-0.0051275706,
0.0111429412,
0.0010125303,
0.0316759422,
0.0256919563,
-0.04745242,
-0.0156567171,
-0.0418233573,
-0.0103626875,
0.0783023164,
-0.0147185335,
0.0164416377,
-0.0853752866,
0.0032059054,
-0.0146391205,
0.0409433208,
-0.0350165367,
-0.0437358022,
-0.0049984311,
-0.0296110827,
0.0412426293,
0.0191708319,
0.0459994562,
-0.0059690485,
0.0277374499,
0.0387900658,
-0.0022037523,
-0.0113076596,
-0.0513836071,
-0.0411884002,
-0.0635613427,
0.0018945632,
-0.0418664776,
0.115322575,
-0.0625491366,
-0.023718223,
-0.0514400564,
-0.0347513668,
0.0142675526,
0.0164112449,
0.024725955,
-0.0100772567,
-0.0329869576,
0.0140945408,
-0.0071278489,
-0.0569507815,
0.0345049948,
-0.0479018092,
-0.0243289638,
-0.0541297048,
-0.0029179698,
-0.0587991476,
0.074613452,
0.042054791,
0.0121394601,
-0.0150220897,
-0.0205155369,
-0.0494492017,
0.038625896,
0.0135850059,
-0.0530203842,
0.0921559781,
-0.0089976965,
0.011882782,
-0.0398988165,
-0.0250291564,
-0.0546311922,
-0.0161970686,
-0.0023378371,
0.0160549413,
0.0497332513,
-0.0651745498,
-0.046701204,
0.01146462,
0.0365076587,
0.1003114209,
0.0059213485,
0.0091367746,
-0.0130398143,
0.0195719376,
0.0375181027,
0.0116660949,
0.0399643704,
-0.0430584326,
-0.0095755626,
-0.0016262707,
0.0209834836,
0.0114784557,
-0.054444313,
0.0008853285,
0.0128468964,
-0.0370042957,
-0.022598967,
0.065425396,
0.0231281277,
-0.0215886068,
-0.0261203554,
0.0701112896,
0.0198413469,
-0.0490793362,
0.0414815694,
0.003517312,
0.0534075499,
0.0352108367,
0.0088976081,
-0.0830020234,
0.002489683,
0.0186652038,
-0.0179759003,
-0.0061560185,
-0.0079216436,
-0.022389885,
-0.1411038488,
-0.031673003,
0.0187206734,
-0.0493797511,
-0.030810982,
-0.0205277354,
-0.011307477,
-0.0099158455,
0.0448754393,
0.0300095975,
-0.0454421975,
-0.0058008418,
0.0572433248,
-0.0344898812,
-0.0473749489,
-0.015883632,
0.0064137406,
0.0115201045,
0.0531536676,
-0.0302660428,
-0.0191490464,
-0.0548092276,
0.0161574446,
0.0423737764,
-0.0030847306,
0.0562246479,
0.0613533184,
0.0349344313,
-0.0136011122,
0.0449046567,
0.0229813866,
-0.019974649,
0.0229917746,
-0.0409253053,
0.0588654205,
0.0149239358,
-0.0304223374,
0.0093289213,
-0.0204447135,
-0.0256387088,
0.0330170766,
0.0127301747,
-0.0236627702,
-0.000904529,
-0.0388912372,
0.002538122,
-0.009821279,
-0.0448963717,
0.0176844317,
0.0283576567,
-0.0616317987,
-0.0652951598,
-0.007643952,
-0.020518316,
0.0456750169,
-0.0084321052,
-0.047717534,
0.0007025618,
0.0090995319,
-0.0653389245,
-0.007258411,
0.0096288286,
0.0309860501,
-0.0537485853,
0.0165750775,
0.0332275741,
-0.0193390809,
-0.0305561833,
-0.0084676435,
-0.135776937,
-0.0643036887,
0.0266282465,
0.048684556,
0.028824104,
0.0454337373,
0.0253008418,
-0.0052724099,
0.0638249964,
0.0068744714,
-0.0263291672,
0.0414403304,
0.0566567481,
-0.0472401716,
-0.0140148252,
-0.0084336996,
-0.0323822275,
0.0372119881,
0.0023008694,
-0.0019046597,
-0.0387004353,
-0.0218546726,
0.0382382907,
-0.001242572,
0.0201120637,
-0.0104513401,
0.0599846877,
0.0299819037,
0.0636109859,
-0.0060365964,
0.0319681019,
-0.0345264636,
-0.0032744377,
0.0109619647,
0.0168958474,
0.0126938848,
0.0198306255,
0.0182230957,
0.0066661914,
0.0204841439,
0.0218703896,
-0.0091478629,
0.0174615663,
0.0298289564,
0.0068721166,
0.0035940078,
-0.0138886869,
0.0130484244,
0.0316753015,
0.0070158192,
0.0124984561,
0.0221835338,
0.0552667789,
-0.0273551717,
0.0150605347,
-0.059978947,
-0.0187870208,
-0.0514778867,
-0.0192282852,
0.0182446018,
-0.0229470152,
0.0237265266,
0.0012237721,
0.0176523961,
-0.0196632426,
0.0040646191,
-0.0378944986,
-0.0277788136,
-0.0021231812,
0.0243825186,
-0.0122340079,
-0.0177167207,
0.0820119753,
-0.00126572,
0.0506741852,
-0.0415277407,
0.0247501936,
-0.0158794541,
-0.0337058902,
0.014849578,
-0.0183675233,
-0.0171510112,
-0.0288287457,
-0.0137908943,
-0.0842407495,
0.012300767,
0.0115201874,
0.0575776845,
-0.0111028841,
0.041575674,
0.0513966866,
-0.0495596416,
0.0288802218,
0.0022783272,
-0.058840137,
0.0283016171,
0.028801389,
-0.0297108721,
-5.212437295e-33,
0.0114224805,
0.0047824448,
0.0210999455,
0.0014508184,
-0.0092451805,
0.0140673649,
-0.0283276625,
0.0337940417,
0.0159585495,
-0.0146723753,
-0.0130195767,
0.0085617034,
0.0073453821,
0.042265553,
0.0076962695,
-0.0087883808,
0.0653576329,
0.021188302,
-0.0270653404,
-0.0119793639,
-0.0008570696,
0.0111782523,
0.085865438,
-0.0066135717,
0.0123948585,
0.0086701643,
-0.0221359283,
-0.009113051,
-0.0100786183,
0.0672580823,
0.0224629138,
0.0409822799,
0.0119670713,
-0.0727039501,
-0.0491570272,
0.0154853566,
-0.0659465492,
-0.0041786875,
-0.0087010823,
0.0237518214,
-0.0256412495,
-0.0001332828,
0.038967751,
-0.0399727263,
-0.0350714177,
-0.0417001918,
0.0302576497,
-0.0431973897,
-0.0334630683,
-0.0384216793,
-0.017331237,
0.0168199241,
0.0151283583,
-0.0142678944,
0.0179240387,
0.0286349244,
0.0067520342,
-0.003334403,
-0.0069809263,
0.0461821333,
0.0513669252,
0.0743533298,
0.0015120558,
0.0107887983,
-0.0092695029,
0.021760365,
0.0116386758,
-0.0229545683,
0.0012484748,
-0.0383551344,
0.031710092,
-0.0230657514,
0.0597024038,
-0.0068893181,
0.0749619529,
-0.0156982522,
-0.0417081937,
0.0189077817,
-0.0007891107,
0.01809958,
-0.0125776613,
0.0127119347,
0.0043491512,
-0.0057663769,
-0.0427817106,
0.0208241772,
-0.0145564815,
-0.0401787683,
0.0059867064,
0.0446258448,
0.0197117254,
0.0222555306,
0.0182047691,
-0.0331211723,
0.0025740801,
0.040756803,
-0.0283531006,
0.028598398,
-0.0310560595,
0.0040763384,
-0.0035670206,
-0.0439989939,
0.0378975868,
-0.0057091508,
-0.0127748959,
-0.0138453059,
0.0633184761,
0.0554172844,
-0.0872151032,
-0.0140043385,
-0.0212001987,
0.0150917396,
0.0108977631,
0.0621630736,
0.0468224287,
0.0071422895,
0.0059467969,
0.0250336975,
-0.030272644,
0.0086878957,
-0.0197952222,
0.0280133151,
-0.0021051019,
0.0430832803,
-0.0209542327,
-0.0120183807,
-0.0375875682,
0.0302215889,
0.0229104348,
-0.0684626997,
-0.0113319848,
-0.0047681634,
2.418e-7,
0.051466573,
0.014703705,
0.0725614056,
-0.0148512069,
0.0250847302,
-0.0168953743,
-0.0116403829,
0.0586293042,
-0.0173606109,
-0.0014046209,
0.0013935772,
-0.0190649815,
0.008477075,
-0.0140187358,
-0.0720860809,
-0.0268729068,
-0.0807417035,
0.0574925803,
-0.0047063376,
0.0158852749,
-0.0002434423,
0.143688634,
-0.0005742777,
0.0123369535,
0.0025938971,
-0.0239351951,
0.0580182187,
0.005211378,
0.0092611266,
0.0142779527,
0.0171473511,
0.0142960129,
0.0087938039,
-0.0069520511,
-0.0465521999,
0.0551407859,
0.0254259799,
0.0285778418,
-0.0131420828,
-0.0113444328,
0.0063210698,
-0.0027883709,
-0.0391606949,
0.0005710839,
0.0216032192,
-0.081979014,
-0.0099629257,
-0.020381717,
-0.0290307663,
0.006197677,
-0.0224455204,
0.0102645177,
0.0283844545,
0.0265329406,
0.0522459932,
-0.0040438436,
0.0309354961,
-0.104579553,
-0.0389087014,
0.0104741426,
-0.0437343679,
-0.0407326184,
-0.0626136139,
-0.0350450501,
0.0240369253,
-0.0213002693,
-0.0131200897,
2.443350415e-34,
0.0536093302,
-0.0189730767,
0.002746064,
-0.0010323044,
0.0066488893,
-0.0583899692,
0.0312071666,
0.0479987003,
0.0273468476,
-0.0486397706,
-0.0300962031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09369v1 | Massively Multi-Cultural Knowledge Acquisition & LM Benchmarking | 2024-02-14T18:16:54 | 2024-02-14T18:16:54 | Yi Fung, Ruining Zhao, Jae Doo, Chenkai Sun, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained large language models have revolutionized many applications but
still face challenges related to cultural bias and a lack of cultural
commonsense knowledge crucial for guiding cross-culture communication and
interactions. Recognizing the shortcomings of existing methods in capturing the
diverse and rich cultures across the world, this paper introduces a novel
approach for massively multicultural knowledge acquisition. Specifically, our
method strategically navigates from densely informative Wikipedia documents on
cultural topics to an extensive network of linked pages. Leveraging this
valuable source of data collection, we construct the CultureAtlas dataset,
which covers a wide range of sub-country level geographical regions and
ethnolinguistic groups, with data cleaning and preprocessing to ensure textual
assertion sentence self-containment, as well as fine-grained cultural profile
information extraction. Our dataset not only facilitates the evaluation of
language model performance in culturally diverse contexts but also serves as a
foundational tool for the development of culturally sensitive and aware
language models. Our work marks an important step towards deeper understanding
and bridging the gaps of cultural disparities in AI, to promote a more
inclusive and balanced representation of global cultures in the digital domain. | [
0.0477199405,
0.0939829201,
-0.0456217155,
0.0656802878,
-0.027174009,
0.0294102356,
0.0241138302,
-0.0337227806,
0.0402935594,
-0.0222807117,
-0.0268311724,
-0.0524151884,
-0.0039089681,
0.0341759138,
0.0201986451,
-0.0275462419,
0.0471872464,
0.006724772,
-0.0018708553,
-0.0364286527,
0.0118423784,
0.0593285039,
0.0066557042,
0.0247908793,
-0.0507850163,
-0.0218479671,
0.039526552,
-0.010970166,
0.0206329413,
-0.0269792639,
0.046828296,
0.0262995046,
-0.0051194695,
0.0493399277,
0.0000021124,
-0.0385082848,
-0.0031176594,
-0.04391158,
0.0203600843,
0.0478575565,
0.0792206898,
-0.014323514,
-0.0252048858,
-0.0146005899,
-0.0710953474,
-0.0074460432,
0.0352841988,
0.0264559798,
0.0464192815,
0.0588141046,
-0.0073112543,
-0.0094458293,
-0.0130486172,
-0.0279907398,
-0.0470404141,
-0.0129954545,
0.0525413305,
0.0454415865,
-0.0307479464,
-0.0419339426,
-0.0169680435,
0.0490386076,
0.014369335,
-0.0128533598,
-0.014246095,
-0.0047230585,
-0.0748868585,
-0.0299589429,
0.0112476302,
0.0805436596,
0.0342208706,
0.0142801665,
0.028238818,
0.026609607,
-0.0495348461,
-0.0013578269,
-0.0269596558,
0.0353071801,
-0.0037639909,
0.0237419959,
0.0062943012,
-0.0002679844,
0.0354594178,
0.041586604,
-0.0196148343,
0.0854614004,
0.0063319709,
-0.0344606638,
-0.0359875411,
0.0068334178,
0.010288964,
-0.045572482,
0.0246769153,
0.0084440811,
0.0176295862,
0.0333631188,
-0.0076961624,
-0.0003747731,
0.047572393,
-0.0305674914,
-0.0223545954,
0.0106831957,
-0.0419163033,
0.03494462,
0.0123056537,
-0.0094207106,
-0.0149688208,
-0.0266294051,
-0.0113482131,
-0.031704627,
-0.0210162979,
0.0044966456,
0.0314856954,
0.0042483048,
-0.0086380197,
0.0115347216,
-0.0578267314,
0.0039285435,
-0.0380862392,
0.0306653623,
-0.0118107228,
-0.0402003191,
-0.0128087671,
-0.0197848156,
-0.0060492377,
0.0534584038,
-0.0310161989,
0.0018704076,
-0.0406121239,
-0.0529234,
0.025724981,
-0.0062563717,
0.0014037943,
-0.0168863088,
0.0176285971,
0.0315178968,
0.0164651647,
-0.0285446141,
-0.0680363476,
0.0078769829,
-0.0031978213,
-0.0244900901,
0.0207068324,
-0.0707414001,
0.0765327364,
-0.002946282,
0.008099623,
-0.0581790172,
0.0172880478,
0.0162960235,
-0.0371410549,
0.0294509456,
-0.0144771915,
0.0385478698,
0.0711716637,
0.0081635676,
0.011395907,
0.0902649909,
0.0318017006,
0.0161395352,
0.1119650155,
0.0116064604,
-0.0278283097,
0.0689348355,
0.0243216157,
0.0272497647,
-0.0235157963,
0.0202796459,
0.0106730005,
-0.0237756036,
0.0373589434,
0.0417688899,
-0.0059865974,
0.0155921346,
0.0508739464,
0.052294936,
-0.0583385341,
0.0376758017,
0.0653446615,
0.0146684665,
-0.0009199585,
-0.0006606823,
-0.0499300025,
-0.0185809899,
0.0084509281,
-0.0053188754,
-0.0102117201,
0.1082023382,
-0.0266599376,
-0.0197772942,
0.0092969844,
-0.0139643867,
0.0487304479,
0.0392421484,
0.0502455309,
-0.0091542928,
0.0234212168,
0.0445009321,
0.0952351242,
-0.0719413832,
0.0138487108,
-0.0061976435,
0.0305635761,
0.0548060499,
0.0038262352,
-0.0322165303,
0.0061931224,
0.0088679902,
0.0445311368,
0.0504103713,
0.0526263192,
-0.0319724455,
0.0255670231,
-0.0429689288,
-0.0194569398,
-0.0024110393,
-0.0096465973,
0.0282414462,
0.0740702301,
0.0572654456,
0.0336583853,
-0.007254153,
-0.0429717451,
0.0168744419,
-0.0591537766,
0.0017596696,
0.0057869419,
0.0071683936,
0.00005967,
0.0597996451,
-0.0371863693,
-0.0471335426,
0.0008321281,
-0.0368663482,
0.0015947554,
0.0152167631,
-0.0454498865,
-0.0204084255,
0.053430777,
-0.0614077263,
-0.0514835566,
0.0310392026,
-0.0190185867,
-0.0144866304,
0.0207581166,
0.043928273,
0.0012193202,
-0.052856002,
-0.0103764189,
-0.0183158126,
0.0333719626,
0.0009312507,
0.0477469303,
-0.0224131774,
-0.0202090554,
-0.0060903989,
-0.0280881766,
0.0258140825,
-0.010612255,
-0.0607785955,
0.0231157355,
0.0024108363,
0.0053258804,
0.0364519693,
0.0270906761,
-0.0311894026,
0.0113518611,
-0.117006287,
-0.0174353626,
-0.0193014815,
-0.0110113993,
-0.0180472471,
0.0290142521,
-0.0428229161,
0.0059982827,
-0.0462625921,
-0.0221280009,
0.0218734182,
0.0191534124,
0.0261166785,
-0.02131439,
0.0105159609,
-0.0161862411,
-0.0437657461,
0.0025533475,
0.0433444306,
-0.0228974074,
-0.0347944014,
-0.0026982215,
-0.0189729575,
-0.0711784959,
-0.0053578163,
-0.0342279524,
-0.0510839298,
-0.009612944,
-0.006832568,
0.0290530417,
0.0481463932,
0.0165763162,
-0.0111279953,
0.0548142791,
-0.0094348853,
-0.0142200841,
-0.001330943,
0.0112575674,
0.0438018106,
-0.0013770311,
-0.0559503883,
0.011078665,
0.0382731147,
0.002045213,
-0.0189813375,
-0.0235622115,
0.0019596922,
-0.0435722545,
-0.0349205583,
-0.010879633,
0.0109776873,
-0.0034463257,
0.0578556582,
-0.0488528684,
-0.0236210767,
0.0516937599,
-0.006670604,
0.0019381613,
0.0098362491,
-0.0178164728,
-0.0313117318,
0.0502263941,
-0.0012927507,
0.035384614,
-0.0041424357,
-0.005573615,
-0.0168120228,
-0.001334967,
0.0274080262,
-0.0424106047,
0.0406962559,
-0.020715557,
-0.0124299098,
-0.0064282184,
-0.0389421433,
-0.0670562088,
-0.0041050613,
-0.0144561846,
0.0004198555,
-0.0029617092,
0.0060692644,
0.0154616749,
-0.0203205235,
0.0633780211,
-0.0010888146,
-0.0022077824,
0.037942443,
0.0200554784,
0.0000600757,
0.0470957272,
-0.0203043893,
0.0189607255,
-0.0110347327,
0.024371922,
0.0157939438,
0.0527353063,
-0.0086849388,
0.0397454686,
0.0057363226,
0.0254474077,
-0.0232861098,
-0.0139604528,
-0.0195317585,
0.0495076254,
-0.0414105058,
0.0233959462,
0.0934682712,
0.0060369503,
-0.0620241836,
0.0008936345,
-0.0216716714,
-0.0112515902,
0.0263396651,
0.0411613397,
-0.1434718668,
0.0273311622,
-0.0072859637,
-0.0168681666,
-0.0111997323,
-0.0405700728,
-0.0012120991,
-0.1143189892,
-0.0039910218,
0.0191023536,
-0.0299028885,
-0.0459128357,
-0.0034505054,
-0.0383017622,
-0.0149088129,
0.0278741866,
-0.0169235896,
0.0016097055,
-0.0069348337,
-0.0199463945,
-0.0433804616,
-0.0718885884,
0.0480548032,
-0.0398586877,
0.0438359007,
0.0292876773,
0.0554856174,
-0.0193313304,
-0.0281133819,
-0.0180722568,
-0.0355227999,
-0.0315650664,
-0.0030541513,
0.021130871,
-0.0248219725,
-0.0410999544,
0.0295355022,
-0.005638971,
-0.0408591926,
-0.0050798017,
0.0491427295,
0.0481799953,
0.0284594651,
0.005619979,
0.0054005599,
0.0010424233,
0.0460388623,
0.0681211874,
0.0164029095,
-0.0393312275,
0.0144357728,
-0.0282766279,
-0.0268535577,
-0.0240810737,
-0.0726066008,
0.055976972,
-0.0692754164,
-0.0204451121,
-0.0575284474,
-0.0710918158,
0.0018289932,
0.0084761446,
0.0422953628,
-0.0371400006,
0.0507020578,
0.0044520018,
-0.0497878641,
0.0364699289,
-0.0569877476,
0.0074275397,
-0.0057127601,
-0.0377009362,
-0.0084089283,
-0.026359871,
0.0102469046,
0.0244013295,
-0.0335952602,
-0.0574682914,
0.0516257361,
0.0522292815,
0.0012642802,
0.0369228758,
0.0063194176,
-0.0383509435,
0.0449423306,
0.0032992165,
-0.0394037589,
-0.0066604479,
0.0316030383,
0.0321667865,
-0.0035858075,
0.0602056235,
-0.04527146,
0.0604508966,
0.0201750919,
0.0310555901,
-0.0460128821,
-0.0044999807,
-0.0252518207,
0.022097636,
-0.0060640788,
-0.0534407496,
-0.0191594083,
-0.0738643259,
-0.0188546199,
-0.0497500449,
-0.0483405218,
-0.0255206637,
-0.0170666147,
-0.0013494148,
0.0089133689,
-0.0242740251,
0.0186341107,
-0.0038944064,
0.0033991912,
-0.0686435997,
0.0182424001,
0.0039948463,
0.055511076,
0.0045545003,
0.0000141864,
-0.0208340287,
0.0315770432,
-0.0150926141,
0.020726487,
-0.0285646655,
0.0397862308,
0.0050746989,
-0.0078294342,
0.004906361,
0.0246856753,
-0.0278303269,
-0.0145711387,
0.0518110059,
0.0172779951,
0.1176173091,
-0.0526762977,
0.0788729936,
0.0170643497,
-0.0277353898,
-0.0040061199,
0.0271460935,
0.0286901928,
-0.0426543616,
-0.0056303144,
0.0166159775,
-0.0520960465,
0.0300005618,
0.0472382531,
-0.0548921786,
0.0256470311,
0.0493413247,
-0.0223445501,
-0.003548085,
-0.0375756584,
0.0347327143,
0.0148085486,
-0.0442648642,
-0.0007580707,
-0.0587139949,
-0.0848791003,
-0.0077498951,
0.0020506331,
-0.0170468725,
-0.0013412866,
-0.0040786141,
0.0837621242,
0.0186462421,
-0.012206668,
-0.0540466122,
0.0054448755,
-0.0440901294,
-9.061e-7,
0.02089151,
-6.678811396e-33,
0.0001469666,
0.002582008,
0.0073503535,
0.0208847914,
-0.0338928029,
0.0023165334,
-0.0167900175,
-0.0119896736,
-0.0639086887,
0.0277907141,
-0.035444364,
0.0236760024,
0.0127639333,
0.0251864064,
-0.0028182054,
0.029544495,
0.0134849986,
0.0156413708,
0.0082534999,
0.0287309811,
0.0283215158,
0.0427679196,
0.0674483031,
-0.0869154632,
0.0479526781,
-0.0112070749,
0.0240493007,
0.0198300257,
0.0540850312,
0.0497046784,
-0.0414496437,
0.0643800497,
0.0223804303,
-0.0045784274,
0.0055829971,
-0.0147256684,
-0.1061929315,
-0.0223053023,
0.0079835653,
0.0205066595,
0.045647338,
-0.0454049893,
0.0148187913,
-0.0367411226,
0.0094571505,
0.0092803864,
0.050251741,
-0.0166033786,
0.0120305223,
-0.0429522991,
-0.0630253702,
0.0450391434,
-0.0041514654,
0.0403771587,
0.0109967543,
0.029549472,
0.0137267746,
-0.0138931144,
-0.0660620332,
0.0161922667,
-0.0175944418,
0.0253015812,
0.0663644671,
-0.0052080248,
0.0215084907,
0.0604211092,
0.0209706202,
0.0368726812,
0.0051068664,
-0.015020893,
0.0342627093,
-0.0137507059,
-0.0456564128,
0.1010359153,
-0.0157089792,
-0.0553691685,
-0.0826525763,
0.0024711089,
0.0504454412,
-0.0164180398,
-0.0084647136,
-0.0348930508,
-0.0135917347,
-0.0119808102,
0.0053815427,
-0.0398285836,
-0.0074246465,
-0.0308611915,
0.0065339045,
-0.0066491216,
-0.0405424647,
0.0231893342,
0.0087398076,
-0.0587157346,
-0.0228487663,
0.0205731206,
-0.0025525498,
-0.048061952,
0.0177009571,
0.0237940606,
-0.0528439209,
-0.0323871821,
-0.042058859,
-0.0114871887,
0.0071017109,
0.017631663,
0.0253707878,
0.0375970379,
-0.0451083183,
0.0016642645,
-0.0102293519,
0.0147873741,
-0.0277404245,
-0.0064940806,
0.0364865065,
0.0183538646,
-0.0197446998,
-0.0083566634,
0.0808566064,
-0.0027242079,
-0.0157699771,
-0.0677948296,
-0.0113567747,
0.0335385799,
-0.0601034127,
-0.0223341566,
-0.0441020615,
0.0298724193,
0.0337775797,
-0.0463197492,
-0.0146298725,
-0.0298567582,
2.776e-7,
0.0193583425,
0.0163353663,
-0.0091683464,
0.0679606944,
0.0051893364,
-0.0090103382,
-0.0218364652,
0.0197285451,
-0.0240096785,
-0.0161765218,
0.0136735113,
0.0515757725,
0.0717095062,
0.0467886701,
-0.1017222106,
-0.034470439,
-0.0225598887,
-0.0007296581,
-0.0734506398,
0.0025992701,
-0.0210904069,
0.057300102,
0.038082283,
-0.0287456438,
-0.0513905883,
-0.0345861614,
0.0391357243,
-0.0298324618,
-0.0288405456,
0.0050541069,
0.0352023356,
-0.0223248415,
-0.010870331,
0.0074838414,
-0.0236017276,
0.0507737324,
0.0312048979,
0.0900512412,
0.01975061,
0.0170910805,
0.0060912436,
-0.0073342421,
-0.0189685952,
-0.0748426914,
0.0942077264,
0.0254268982,
-0.0327808745,
-0.0323533677,
-0.0132143842,
-0.028364202,
0.0247290991,
-0.020113552,
-0.0323168449,
0.0293320082,
0.0342012905,
-0.0237797592,
-0.0186796859,
-0.0699434131,
-0.0214341935,
-0.0149340415,
0.0075521795,
-0.0486218035,
0.0243430194,
-0.0451871194,
-0.0086664502,
0.0087868683,
0.0569322668,
2.561051608e-34,
0.0071673226,
-0.0119263651,
-0.0133833643,
0.0051523419,
0.0637803823,
-0.0286213178,
-0.008983505,
-0.0093516773,
-0.0124052949,
-0.0228453055,
0.0051308069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09363v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09363v2 | Copyright Traps for Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T18:09:53 | 2024-06-04T21:07:11 | Matthieu Meeus, Igor Shilov, Manuel Faysse, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Questions of fair use of copyright-protected content to train Large Language
Models (LLMs) are being actively debated. Document-level inference has been
proposed as a new task: inferring from black-box access to the trained model
whether a piece of content has been seen during training. SOTA methods however
rely on naturally occurring memorization of (part of) the content. While very
effective against models that memorize significantly, we hypothesize--and later
confirm--that they will not work against models that do not naturally memorize,
e.g. medium-size 1B models. We here propose to use copyright traps, the
inclusion of fictitious entries in original content, to detect the use of
copyrighted materials in LLMs with a focus on models where memorization does
not naturally occur. We carefully design a randomized controlled experimental
setup, inserting traps into original content (books) and train a 1.3B LLM from
scratch. We first validate that the use of content in our target model would be
undetectable using existing methods. We then show, contrary to intuition, that
even medium-length trap sentences repeated a significant number of times (100)
are not detectable using existing methods. However, we show that longer
sequences repeated a large number of times can be reliably detected (AUC=0.75)
and used as copyright traps. Beyond copyright applications, our findings
contribute to the study of LLM memorization: the randomized controlled setup
enables us to draw causal relationships between memorization and certain
sequence properties such as repetition in model training data and perplexity. | [
0.0533575229,
0.0865868106,
-0.0309670903,
0.0559057444,
-0.0733610243,
0.0262448192,
0.0436662436,
0.0208464283,
0.027363399,
-0.0634187683,
-0.0086654276,
0.0005208816,
-0.0074742045,
-0.0224149637,
0.0173068643,
0.0199693888,
0.0231934916,
-0.0229167994,
-0.0110434685,
-0.0204176027,
-0.0034595961,
0.0066949646,
0.0347193927,
0.0122080576,
-0.0167960115,
-0.024010295,
0.0040559238,
-0.0211983938,
0.0039202366,
-0.0307914894,
-0.0045400886,
0.0749465227,
0.0217184536,
0.0971790627,
0.0000016695,
-0.0687811822,
-0.0349004231,
0.016596403,
-0.0139124058,
0.095585376,
0.0542945601,
0.0257789884,
0.0125753358,
-0.0009268261,
-0.0285203494,
0.0356413908,
-0.0095370943,
0.0468675755,
0.024669271,
0.0664984062,
-0.0221875664,
0.0009109293,
0.0250310041,
-0.0482389517,
0.0230596177,
-0.0354551226,
0.0499055982,
0.041627612,
0.0060664816,
-0.0077213813,
-0.0148631018,
0.0604851879,
0.0262325089,
0.0358843356,
-0.0238076001,
0.0256139897,
-0.0142467776,
0.0135627128,
0.0219916292,
0.0251684859,
-0.0027086637,
-0.0478670113,
0.0427865684,
-0.0074982736,
0.0546991192,
0.0535817519,
-0.0257456303,
0.0579618327,
-0.0031553076,
0.0306597501,
0.01578076,
-0.0304720756,
0.0470745899,
0.0056265662,
0.0042705755,
-0.009641544,
0.0260221437,
-0.0573331751,
0.0022222598,
-0.012256287,
0.0013366812,
-0.0497230217,
0.0263109561,
-0.0285845771,
0.0415857658,
0.0220083781,
-0.076298967,
-0.0390350521,
0.0259059276,
-0.0636838302,
0.0525809526,
-0.0107339928,
-0.0288723819,
0.0659490079,
-0.0521680526,
0.0248296708,
-0.0381544977,
0.0530581512,
0.0033984743,
0.0251841974,
-0.0247626267,
-0.0277048405,
-0.0278699715,
0.0626694709,
0.0033661395,
-0.0432758033,
-0.0151498448,
0.0107616195,
0.0157484785,
0.015220494,
-0.0708038434,
0.0008374697,
0.0216172617,
0.0084946305,
0.0317165889,
-0.0360399634,
0.0216130074,
0.0404620953,
-0.0017042324,
-0.0547714606,
-0.031114921,
0.0081256889,
0.0045111468,
-0.0288144033,
0.0335387476,
0.0593390949,
0.018761998,
-0.0571519323,
-0.0111021735,
-0.0519345179,
-0.0100573935,
-0.0289186686,
0.0291014314,
-0.050671339,
-0.0139048127,
-0.0102602551,
0.0272553191,
-0.044020474,
-0.0111147333,
0.0280520525,
-0.0637822971,
0.0387483388,
0.0413982496,
0.0009306538,
-0.0221479237,
0.0300185177,
0.0084355082,
0.0291578863,
0.0240041856,
0.0362760462,
0.0642175823,
-0.0165454783,
0.0252134986,
0.0569124147,
0.0258827992,
0.0335824229,
-0.0044926922,
-0.0451725349,
0.050212197,
-0.0138568068,
0.0222722627,
0.0408240892,
-0.0142224003,
-0.0294765756,
0.0698129833,
0.0954135731,
-0.0443266667,
0.0303882733,
-0.003550007,
0.0163393505,
0.0331456065,
0.0634095445,
-0.0344481654,
-0.0177802853,
-0.0208186135,
-0.0058513335,
0.0227599535,
0.0037810709,
0.0129280323,
0.0128942477,
-0.0166644026,
-0.0056041717,
0.000996953,
0.0116442041,
0.012791587,
0.0176636931,
-0.0324008465,
0.0976087898,
-0.0059836195,
-0.0504105575,
0.0156734232,
-0.0475511067,
0.0550918207,
0.0232568812,
0.0736250281,
-0.0201505311,
0.0750762671,
-0.0327217989,
-0.0158329979,
0.0438212827,
0.0225306246,
0.0080551635,
0.016179245,
-0.0294410903,
-0.0194983464,
-0.0517341942,
0.0312610865,
0.0281053539,
0.0104188733,
0.016764449,
0.0310052596,
-0.0034507902,
-0.0532295033,
0.0296034683,
-0.0370378122,
-0.0452587828,
-0.0312723145,
-0.0185675286,
0.0395233333,
0.0147796012,
-0.0442335047,
0.0096012335,
0.0294778496,
-0.0248233899,
-0.0345517434,
-0.0126043614,
-0.019582551,
-0.0288503151,
0.0407141186,
-0.0280971397,
0.0193134062,
0.0615843236,
-0.0139218168,
-0.0058286558,
0.0119924191,
-0.0346347727,
0.0841019079,
-0.0412108079,
0.0128571605,
-0.0286776591,
0.0536039658,
-0.0280310512,
0.0368538462,
-0.0088615781,
0.039829243,
0.0379031412,
-0.0732417405,
0.0590936914,
-0.022914147,
-0.0554731414,
0.0048875529,
-0.0275074523,
0.0126971696,
0.0156183308,
-0.0191063751,
-0.0132998032,
-0.0158439893,
-0.0286747888,
-0.0195240565,
-0.0137847997,
0.0132737542,
-0.0113093872,
-0.0291261561,
-0.0450551398,
-0.0171537865,
0.0034822391,
-0.0814680904,
-0.0059097293,
0.0282831788,
-0.0164744947,
-0.0253058132,
-0.0433793962,
0.0034702113,
-0.0054975124,
-0.0075572897,
0.0522497632,
-0.0106178606,
-0.0065331762,
-0.0424772725,
0.0582907125,
0.0123487245,
0.0045069791,
-0.0145627959,
0.0010819498,
0.0027104642,
-0.0099095507,
-0.0361592919,
0.0861177221,
0.0079754805,
-0.0117228162,
0.0596129596,
-0.0030284126,
-0.0487516485,
-0.0184476227,
-0.0037150418,
-0.0342213996,
-0.0630927384,
-0.0359075218,
0.0345850028,
0.017975891,
0.018699225,
-0.0101819364,
-0.0090970472,
0.0169949997,
-0.0312505215,
-0.0416757502,
0.0025112499,
-0.0326963812,
-0.052849751,
0.0265885051,
0.016657142,
-0.0599058904,
0.0258223508,
-0.0652038381,
0.0107750595,
-0.0022219536,
0.0416573137,
-0.0239800215,
0.0640470982,
0.0245443881,
0.0189444982,
0.0203057434,
-0.0315945819,
-0.0229386613,
-0.0109615391,
0.0684307516,
-0.0453668721,
-0.0013322099,
0.001048502,
-0.000004359,
-0.0024643524,
-0.0324749909,
-0.049167458,
-0.0620676428,
-0.0113565559,
-0.0146519886,
-0.0091431383,
-0.0098024281,
-0.0212511271,
-0.0307802502,
0.0435819477,
0.0151183447,
0.0043343497,
0.0158001389,
-0.0064833295,
0.0896589458,
0.0642020479,
-0.0120497821,
0.0242814217,
-0.0182396676,
-0.026278384,
0.0548803695,
-0.0100133363,
0.0712353662,
0.0269506946,
0.0242639408,
0.0240428578,
-0.0020909605,
0.0048235464,
0.0525366105,
0.0026692271,
-0.0385074764,
0.0058337501,
0.0852724463,
0.0168087352,
-0.0209639017,
-0.0127127217,
0.0058545144,
0.001867538,
0.0038115031,
-0.0127677089,
-0.0901534334,
-0.0116461227,
0.0145489089,
0.0156891532,
-0.0259454474,
-0.0178519189,
-0.0094982125,
-0.1176683083,
0.0202653203,
0.0188630354,
-0.0363847949,
-0.0051490753,
-0.0236516874,
-0.0286782086,
-0.0095698386,
-0.0238745119,
-0.0277447402,
-0.0191903114,
-0.0069643022,
0.0120559521,
0.0063977223,
-0.0381081663,
0.0091816131,
-0.0274108853,
0.0347229131,
0.0432975255,
0.0012984745,
-0.0336530991,
-0.0422330238,
0.0091781374,
-0.0367675237,
-0.010146183,
0.0200414695,
0.0539006516,
-0.0169453993,
0.0084832916,
-0.0238640606,
0.0587050542,
-0.0081655104,
-0.0482562706,
0.0189045724,
0.0674657226,
0.0203844067,
-0.0537872091,
-0.0115250172,
-0.0171415973,
-0.0036179407,
0.088984929,
0.0622649752,
-0.0036319289,
0.0000818505,
-0.0194758866,
0.0140844351,
-0.0632669628,
-0.0089197392,
0.0076612863,
-0.0241016634,
-0.0081601404,
-0.0587898605,
-0.0100889476,
-0.0600577742,
0.0248801,
0.0432077982,
0.0455855839,
0.0223106388,
-0.0333434269,
-0.0374614336,
-0.0002572942,
-0.069328703,
-0.0084394356,
-0.0348740965,
-0.0092575401,
0.008744508,
0.0131707164,
-0.031448964,
-0.0050753211,
-0.1167909354,
-0.0678360164,
0.0417601988,
0.0215922557,
0.0197297949,
0.0414446853,
0.0217445754,
-0.0282752477,
0.075861901,
0.0366693437,
-0.0274778679,
0.0456499755,
0.0599885248,
-0.0579006672,
-0.0203128755,
0.0360984467,
-0.0337887742,
-0.0181122664,
0.0560389534,
-0.0174810812,
-0.0180272348,
-0.0052293753,
0.0234461818,
0.0314831473,
-0.0105830161,
-0.0301219728,
0.0253036488,
-0.0194688085,
0.037424013,
0.0127560925,
-0.0057017021,
-0.0226714537,
-0.0009737039,
0.0187905356,
-0.0114483647,
-0.0185060296,
0.0341215506,
-0.0265693683,
0.0481360331,
-0.0143663511,
0.0046407338,
-0.0082069263,
-0.0197981484,
0.0097184284,
-0.0058057494,
-0.009901939,
0.05240063,
-0.0240125842,
0.0511288159,
0.0039826189,
0.0511650629,
0.0245128144,
0.006046399,
0.0024493588,
0.0226649456,
-0.0692667887,
-0.0184608363,
0.0030682259,
0.026415661,
0.0672328994,
-0.0700053945,
0.045134861,
-0.0573785082,
-0.0207507089,
-0.0037220386,
0.0200954787,
-0.039346274,
-0.0576873906,
-0.0256605707,
0.0049445215,
-0.0251511391,
0.0383897945,
0.0920583904,
0.0387744345,
0.0438773222,
-0.0034060129,
-0.0456275716,
-0.0068161939,
-0.0509520248,
0.0591149069,
-0.0112411613,
-0.0176450666,
-0.0000737328,
-0.0631214753,
-0.0930576101,
-0.0091765383,
0.0034458952,
0.0185595695,
0.0001405028,
-0.0330172069,
0.0589695312,
-0.0117404889,
-0.0239222348,
-0.0288135316,
0.0514911711,
0.0069514387,
-0.047544919,
-0.0289684832,
-5.437135611e-33,
0.0224356409,
-0.0137814702,
-0.0344935209,
0.0347300991,
-0.0111332694,
0.0176350512,
-0.0261997227,
-0.0266832635,
0.018399423,
-0.0179533772,
-0.0351173282,
-0.0047295946,
-0.0018666035,
0.0138079273,
0.0078540491,
-0.0321956798,
0.0261729732,
0.0284787416,
-0.0545831695,
0.0094551472,
0.0376830213,
0.0253611058,
0.0426680557,
-0.0230654422,
0.0230475944,
-0.0318711214,
-0.0199369658,
-0.057688769,
-0.0978841335,
0.0652113482,
-0.0205098614,
-0.0015804097,
0.0213369131,
-0.0444037169,
-0.0122237876,
0.0041573262,
-0.0235682782,
0.0034158756,
0.0305311568,
0.0000598187,
0.0653571188,
-0.0416198559,
0.0412112996,
-0.0275338609,
-0.041811619,
0.0025481968,
0.0365675464,
-0.0352941789,
-0.0574185811,
-0.034475971,
-0.0290776435,
-0.0071214084,
-0.0173588656,
0.0234760605,
0.0340137333,
-0.008468668,
0.0159467608,
0.021303311,
-0.0399478488,
0.0193946753,
0.0363212489,
0.0222653449,
0.034861397,
0.0114477668,
0.0467724167,
0.0625958294,
0.018831471,
-0.0282907952,
0.0205447022,
-0.008995397,
0.0268626958,
-0.0173687208,
0.0410369374,
0.0687898397,
0.0980097726,
-0.0072534541,
-0.0116936164,
-0.0158275086,
-0.0339092575,
0.0243938416,
0.0534785688,
-0.009753786,
-0.0374725647,
-0.0300177038,
-0.0522695407,
-0.0254808385,
-0.0129590854,
-0.0072002904,
0.0474437475,
0.0240483414,
-0.0141608426,
-0.0235673953,
0.0411266126,
-0.0458529964,
-0.0598656237,
0.0150567358,
-0.0208979584,
0.0108781578,
-0.0123656904,
0.0051155891,
-0.0631590486,
0.0052236523,
0.024589425,
-0.0451837666,
0.0445419624,
-0.0166234449,
0.0773409531,
0.0321148969,
-0.0613000616,
0.0107985195,
-0.0085561182,
0.0011898694,
0.0475923754,
0.0043302737,
0.0374637246,
0.0139558809,
0.0133938268,
-0.0073384754,
-0.0050276411,
-0.0145489182,
-0.0610224567,
0.021933388,
-0.006239105,
0.0088635013,
-0.0241753198,
-0.03136703,
-0.0019107714,
0.0531244949,
0.0555233285,
-0.0674873814,
0.0006207232,
0.0093790228,
2.412e-7,
0.003327894,
-0.0333021283,
0.008841699,
-0.0165555738,
0.0012570908,
0.0642713681,
-0.0395982601,
0.0667137429,
-0.016688982,
0.0225847363,
-0.0207604039,
0.0056296415,
0.0791783929,
0.0090372982,
-0.1063218489,
-0.0290200394,
-0.0716348588,
-0.0009813986,
-0.0720784664,
-0.0090649659,
0.0242713764,
0.0805791542,
0.052473627,
-0.0373952724,
0.0105424905,
-0.0849971622,
0.0440810919,
-0.0195332859,
-0.0195673238,
-0.0220021904,
0.029686911,
0.0253336672,
-0.0034942443,
0.0010537048,
-0.010145097,
0.0174094569,
-0.0108840428,
0.0238562729,
0.072077781,
-0.0223893728,
-0.0550563075,
-0.0409099609,
-0.0247211587,
-0.0380245298,
0.0477572046,
0.0348363779,
-0.0058323406,
-0.0356812701,
-0.0050464957,
-0.0604366697,
0.0124305999,
-0.0101882685,
0.0145139173,
-0.0018171687,
-0.0149967708,
0.0133561864,
0.0219892059,
-0.0830708444,
0.0134272827,
-0.0385967381,
-0.0413631089,
-0.0110430773,
-0.0470121503,
-0.0129520576,
0.0100138094,
-0.0743830502,
0.0388001762,
2.458499599e-34,
0.0376959629,
-0.0481982268,
0.0001111849,
0.0285713281,
0.0135852816,
-0.0128535004,
0.0538970269,
0.005533861,
-0.0302083865,
-0.0837119296,
-0.000995341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09353v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09353v5 | DoRA: Weight-Decomposed Low-Rank Adaptation | 2024-02-14T17:59:34 | 2024-06-03T07:27:15 | Shih-Yang Liu, Chien-Yi Wang, Hongxu Yin, Pavlo Molchanov, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Kwang-Ting Cheng, Min-Hung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Among the widely used parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, LoRA
and its variants have gained considerable popularity because of avoiding
additional inference costs. However, there still often exists an accuracy gap
between these methods and full fine-tuning (FT). In this work, we first
introduce a novel weight decomposition analysis to investigate the inherent
differences between FT and LoRA. Aiming to resemble the learning capacity of FT
from the findings, we propose Weight-Decomposed Low-Rank Adaptation (DoRA).
DoRA decomposes the pre-trained weight into two components, magnitude and
direction, for fine-tuning, specifically employing LoRA for directional updates
to efficiently minimize the number of trainable parameters. By employing \ours,
we enhance both the learning capacity and training stability of LoRA while
avoiding any additional inference overhead. \ours~consistently outperforms LoRA
on fine-tuning LLaMA, LLaVA, and VL-BART on various downstream tasks, such as
commonsense reasoning, visual instruction tuning, and image/video-text
understanding. Code is available at https://github.com/NVlabs/DoRA. | [
0.0343955345,
0.0430586524,
-0.0259508062,
0.0547153577,
0.0708695129,
0.0346215703,
-0.0254856013,
0.0281149428,
-0.0051225582,
-0.0258387011,
-0.0708940774,
0.0166470688,
0.0068038455,
-0.0359976478,
0.0454854183,
-0.0468458608,
0.0300943647,
-0.0262259524,
0.0125733782,
-0.0053207199,
-0.0022145391,
-0.0133213503,
-0.0049139429,
-0.003461044,
0.096010007,
0.0037359376,
-0.0400205888,
0.0233140737,
0.068667531,
0.0237144064,
0.0242999773,
0.0744439214,
0.0239787251,
-0.003463435,
0.00000206,
-0.0292265248,
-0.0103403153,
-0.0178867206,
-0.0095827412,
0.0299120732,
0.0262893159,
0.0075610923,
-0.0177401453,
0.0038197094,
-0.0206757784,
-0.026254097,
0.0372029729,
0.0374099724,
0.043639943,
0.0933379829,
-0.0081222551,
-0.070212692,
-0.0001735002,
-0.0452859178,
0.0031890045,
-0.0762571767,
0.0097380541,
-0.0157728903,
-0.0580771752,
-0.012530054,
-0.0407156907,
-0.0159836132,
0.0075792442,
0.0366753191,
-0.0363053083,
0.0146141984,
-0.0690719485,
0.0041681314,
-0.0182744507,
0.0969868004,
-0.0561838038,
-0.0097897239,
-0.0010206526,
-0.0080018751,
0.0362414382,
-0.0534823276,
-0.0207745414,
-0.0197883882,
0.0220728386,
0.0389949866,
-0.0047467193,
-0.0287138391,
0.015865868,
-0.0018941638,
-0.0112378625,
0.0109757651,
0.0118974838,
-0.0006432955,
-0.0075816605,
-0.0392700657,
-0.0619012415,
0.0049304496,
0.0009302986,
0.0181179196,
-0.0150201991,
-0.0353927016,
-0.0363611653,
-0.0418543108,
0.0060543795,
-0.0081748106,
0.0925344005,
0.0488738939,
-0.0295255315,
0.0337795988,
-0.0622110441,
0.0546904542,
-0.0234649926,
0.035910815,
-0.0323330238,
0.033836782,
-0.017754484,
0.0397550575,
-0.0174559858,
0.014243165,
-0.0627371669,
0.0107362289,
-0.0397874489,
0.015129324,
-0.0104108276,
-0.0078019174,
-0.0071998979,
0.0154452194,
-0.0256881882,
-0.0113240033,
-0.0192004144,
0.0928004161,
-0.0255014841,
0.0701439381,
-0.0137834018,
0.0047606276,
-0.0209034681,
0.0197927821,
0.0223876499,
-0.0198568571,
0.0831560567,
0.0321193375,
-0.0495734811,
-0.0151610291,
-0.046716772,
0.0099963332,
-0.016752556,
-0.0920139253,
0.0328845456,
-0.019865321,
0.023784589,
-0.0268920492,
0.043936763,
-0.0163118485,
-0.0242327973,
-0.0141354101,
-0.061498899,
0.0690122396,
0.0153587246,
-0.0287328046,
0.000829828,
0.0066447575,
-0.0251950324,
0.0735425949,
0.0036432883,
0.0367004797,
-0.0140325194,
-0.0211215839,
-0.0804415122,
0.0062183128,
0.0002726698,
0.0203425642,
-0.0209369007,
0.0002160835,
-0.0056464826,
-0.0001203416,
0.0423564017,
-0.0171075687,
-0.0321674496,
0.0016526747,
0.0486672483,
0.0037982741,
0.0893466771,
0.0390755348,
0.0099572903,
-0.0462458543,
0.0325698107,
0.0166981984,
-0.0652577505,
0.054130815,
-0.1134233698,
-0.0266765244,
-0.0133571299,
0.0619940907,
-0.0535466671,
-0.0478962809,
0.0123931132,
0.0064981701,
-0.0052589239,
-0.006182339,
0.0324407108,
0.0041123498,
-0.0104541732,
-0.0299467295,
0.0519418903,
-0.0216267202,
-0.011550623,
-0.0528764613,
0.0244778115,
0.0198078416,
-0.0044459212,
-0.0249840748,
-0.0073528732,
0.0194939375,
0.0810697377,
-0.0284349024,
0.0295552053,
0.0165904406,
0.0209083445,
-0.0545669384,
0.0076844222,
-0.0084079038,
0.0061576795,
0.01109559,
-0.0236540698,
0.0080513721,
0.0110798357,
-0.0519385003,
-0.0109936595,
0.0240141917,
0.0273918435,
-0.0111861015,
0.0311607346,
0.0179338474,
0.0239770021,
-0.0115693416,
0.0180394109,
-0.0558447987,
0.0209174976,
0.0058563678,
0.0455797128,
-0.0156933703,
0.0181926321,
-0.0360932238,
0.0245775059,
-0.0180240776,
0.0247242488,
0.0629198998,
-0.0482868403,
-0.0262550954,
0.0231026411,
0.000768628,
-0.0321406201,
-0.0258690175,
0.004012086,
-0.0157430377,
0.0535026789,
-0.0221689809,
0.0483284965,
0.0048563248,
0.007244281,
0.0366302095,
0.0302305408,
0.016760502,
-0.0393675677,
-0.0349982381,
0.015236618,
-0.0038508505,
0.0346602015,
-0.0170506444,
0.0344869792,
-0.0144451866,
-0.0370345414,
-0.0601633787,
0.0322551057,
-0.038351316,
0.0269324519,
0.0134209422,
-0.0078797154,
-0.0038599311,
-0.0285674427,
-0.0002101976,
0.0750302002,
-0.0455411598,
-0.0013387386,
0.0299794525,
-0.0030631279,
0.0164769534,
-0.0306895692,
-0.0022725433,
0.0165022723,
0.0137953311,
-0.0159200095,
0.0079354225,
-0.0628223792,
0.0082381424,
-0.0370185561,
0.0329002924,
-0.0369293243,
-0.0832928792,
-0.03958413,
-0.0155710373,
0.0374657996,
0.0925302804,
-0.0149761625,
0.0095698535,
0.0599426813,
0.0588535294,
0.0079963459,
0.0326374546,
-0.0096341697,
-0.0506094582,
-0.0382043719,
0.0121674715,
-0.0112602282,
0.0125886742,
-0.040392682,
-0.0135135911,
-0.0836990997,
0.0146646909,
0.0334809199,
-0.0060624196,
-0.0267444383,
0.0680092946,
-0.0080494946,
-0.0267069284,
-0.0178753063,
-0.0021017808,
0.0665447414,
-0.0083140805,
-0.0193646196,
-0.0411757901,
-0.04300097,
-0.0221944377,
-0.0388302393,
-0.0086794682,
0.042877432,
-0.0226396285,
0.0156844612,
-0.0620590597,
-0.0099394647,
0.0515719019,
-0.0150083853,
0.0260157604,
-0.0133049693,
-0.0019055246,
-0.0679015666,
-0.0449694544,
0.0241263472,
-0.0394299701,
0.0244602058,
0.0183288511,
-0.0113060297,
-0.0284818467,
-0.0177939162,
-0.0177473407,
0.0037287637,
0.0309970137,
-0.0630805194,
-0.0014279069,
-0.0452318564,
0.010322419,
0.0329286717,
0.0917765424,
0.0347809605,
-0.0229715146,
0.0391955785,
0.0104571907,
0.0189608354,
-0.0387843587,
-0.0183574669,
0.0993357003,
0.0039618062,
0.0335514434,
-0.0030481652,
0.0313962772,
0.067336604,
-0.0076545053,
-0.0066574956,
0.0445883572,
-0.0015505791,
-0.0569693446,
-0.0089887809,
-0.0220612902,
0.0557393283,
0.053587433,
0.0444753766,
-0.0335480683,
-0.0635126755,
-0.0042976732,
0.0520386174,
0.0325026698,
-0.0114465393,
0.0248582605,
-0.0656602904,
0.0370242931,
0.0238826871,
-0.0345733017,
-0.0267666429,
-0.0228414107,
0.018585857,
-0.0115883332,
0.0053190337,
0.0348870307,
-0.0328485295,
-0.0131620383,
0.0238719862,
0.0302054118,
-0.0500583611,
-0.0067744851,
-0.0248077605,
0.0254179016,
-0.0032453546,
0.013701167,
-0.0275196712,
-0.0670200884,
0.0092130182,
-0.0892788544,
0.0146116102,
-0.023224825,
0.0123713808,
0.0247954726,
-0.0590957142,
0.0061932448,
0.0697889179,
0.0060777962,
-0.026217239,
-0.0087836506,
0.0392247662,
-0.0161655471,
-0.0079302862,
0.0162901413,
-0.0112876454,
-0.0088033751,
0.0169621129,
0.0127962762,
-0.0276361499,
-0.0163549185,
0.0076755038,
-0.0188342985,
0.0081088543,
-0.0130441263,
0.0065412838,
-0.0471786,
0.0084960172,
-0.0259381253,
0.0314063579,
0.0119528966,
0.0577254854,
-0.0313138328,
-0.0237276442,
-0.0515214689,
0.0006220317,
-0.014974677,
0.0472059213,
-0.0168302804,
-0.0238689911,
-0.0194563661,
-0.017647611,
0.0680920854,
-0.0165214036,
0.0002831239,
-0.0051159617,
-0.042868536,
-0.0415558293,
-0.0038400611,
0.0770723298,
0.0142887374,
0.0114966249,
-0.0014440096,
-0.0618913881,
0.0278744251,
0.0419763699,
0.0430751108,
0.0924647152,
0.0334211588,
-0.0521546826,
-0.0103750331,
0.0507661961,
-0.0469126888,
0.0146346986,
0.0329151079,
0.0180261061,
-0.0216346998,
-0.0214046054,
-0.0233118031,
0.0269623715,
0.0240060799,
0.0125698885,
-0.0564935319,
-0.0171771776,
0.0687790513,
-0.0095770666,
0.002169746,
-0.0046437881,
-0.0449961871,
0.0086950213,
0.0043548564,
-0.0228616092,
0.0348430239,
0.0418584272,
0.0128538953,
-0.0611062311,
0.0217076987,
0.0268596597,
0.0436869152,
0.0125458529,
0.0172351636,
-0.0016823024,
0.0323717259,
0.0613720529,
0.0350993723,
-0.0255743135,
0.0354238003,
0.026173057,
0.0081670508,
-0.1208932102,
0.059443336,
-0.0247190557,
-0.0614723675,
-0.0296218563,
0.025534777,
0.0582506582,
0.0072196126,
0.0132299932,
0.044483263,
-0.0474639758,
-0.0105475411,
-0.0074014775,
-0.0076969806,
0.0447409898,
0.0411159694,
0.0032097292,
0.0147593776,
0.021108225,
0.0437216312,
0.0103697851,
0.0738666058,
-0.0323062092,
0.0263794251,
-0.0302398484,
-0.0240543745,
0.0011887405,
0.0360673517,
0.0033120816,
-0.0185985696,
0.0138002597,
-0.045695316,
-0.0205812193,
-0.0167488102,
0.0120410798,
-0.0187011566,
-0.0050420077,
0.0267789122,
-0.0002862483,
-0.0395413265,
0.0199814793,
-0.0666800588,
-0.0185073782,
0.0214056857,
0.0304416753,
-6.937245298e-33,
-0.0539230295,
0.0406577922,
0.0080123488,
0.0113625862,
0.0038611232,
-0.0141591253,
-0.0133771328,
0.0035355538,
-0.0447727852,
0.0119792391,
-0.0127611179,
0.0055560158,
0.009310863,
-0.0286221374,
-0.0166159831,
-0.0104120951,
0.0364250913,
-0.0016150242,
-0.0464269258,
-0.0117785996,
0.0252302252,
0.0007108272,
0.0299071334,
-0.032796599,
-0.0555623062,
0.0472237505,
-0.0706332996,
0.0065802899,
-0.0622368529,
0.0308992527,
-0.0018268764,
0.03874911,
0.0040064147,
0.0227700267,
-0.0195015632,
-0.0108050304,
-0.1001509428,
-0.051853843,
0.0281229578,
-0.0243251808,
-0.0068872673,
-0.0285808686,
0.0917827263,
0.0325860232,
-0.0322329551,
-0.0205719192,
0.0201814119,
-0.0592972785,
0.0135730319,
-0.008184243,
-0.0336211659,
-0.0135621326,
-0.0233774148,
-0.0132989194,
0.0060813101,
0.0152057977,
-0.0078965025,
0.0135965059,
-0.055577077,
-0.0347726345,
0.0460336804,
0.0565755032,
0.0043099164,
0.0119294254,
-0.0284773745,
0.0018536125,
0.0200913809,
-0.0025378813,
0.0342779979,
-0.0403614715,
0.0461372174,
0.0526532605,
0.0621598586,
0.0418908522,
-0.0108174393,
-0.0321461558,
-0.1255761981,
0.0168388318,
-0.0132100815,
0.0609697774,
-0.0242886245,
0.0355495214,
0.0049144574,
0.0051308167,
-0.0375898443,
-0.0261164978,
-0.0479463972,
0.0022249499,
0.0211807042,
0.0306838155,
-0.039111197,
0.0025114266,
0.0162260197,
-0.0354039408,
0.0428361148,
0.0003068426,
-0.0240725838,
0.0089458488,
0.0337680727,
0.0103218826,
-0.0288261101,
-0.066711314,
0.0728992373,
-0.0046887994,
0.0223818123,
-0.0173228141,
0.0625019893,
0.0442850888,
-0.0420602709,
-0.0070806011,
-0.0098267524,
0.0196123384,
0.028688645,
0.0817119479,
-0.020923404,
-0.0362775996,
0.0122004375,
0.0288918074,
0.0083499011,
0.0118851447,
-0.028237965,
-0.011411055,
0.0431669615,
0.0426558517,
-0.0357784107,
0.0278340206,
0.0031962898,
0.0097773848,
0.0113919498,
-0.0679898337,
-0.0119375428,
0.0438353978,
2.947e-7,
0.0156341605,
0.0223350041,
-0.0235116631,
-0.0665514097,
0.0256674048,
0.0463926569,
-0.0507962815,
0.0266820863,
0.0256975535,
0.0196292922,
0.0164788291,
0.0364287123,
-0.0013280164,
-0.0146728205,
-0.0186431054,
0.0046168175,
-0.0254471861,
0.02128773,
-0.0451362915,
-0.0313299038,
0.0146931605,
0.0761582255,
0.0168379247,
-0.0303910691,
0.0372850448,
0.0066411505,
0.0472683869,
-0.001312277,
0.0055944948,
-0.0141564477,
0.0346314199,
0.0162960589,
-0.0346748866,
-0.0207244996,
0.0042140833,
0.075546883,
-0.0520200245,
0.0620571151,
-0.0512696803,
0.0002128861,
0.0235653035,
0.0310652032,
0.0305791907,
-0.040165294,
0.1009047031,
-0.0604262277,
-0.0283533819,
-0.0183063932,
-0.0402236655,
-0.0415548943,
0.0162526164,
-0.0429931358,
0.0022743053,
0.0270483717,
0.0038781159,
0.0088782832,
-0.0682185814,
-0.1138017997,
0.0193389934,
0.0390855223,
-0.0243867524,
-0.0437167287,
-0.03671268,
-0.0134114902,
0.0584055819,
-0.0793120563,
0.0073222527,
2.47664767e-34,
-0.0104979677,
-0.0248049051,
0.0455581956,
-0.0097505273,
0.0217799321,
0.0090643978,
-0.0111166053,
-0.0065221312,
0.039128352,
-0.0978280157,
-0.0096444506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09344v1 | Generating Diverse Translation with Perturbed kNN-MT | 2024-02-14T17:46:46 | 2024-02-14T17:46:46 | Yuto Nishida, Makoto Morishita, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating multiple translation candidates would enable users to choose the
one that satisfies their needs. Although there has been work on diversified
generation, there exists room for improving the diversity mainly because the
previous methods do not address the overcorrection problem -- the model
underestimates a prediction that is largely different from the training data,
even if that prediction is likely. This paper proposes methods that generate
more diverse translations by introducing perturbed k-nearest neighbor machine
translation (kNN-MT). Our methods expand the search space of kNN-MT and help
incorporate diverse words into candidates by addressing the overcorrection
problem. Our experiments show that the proposed methods drastically improve
candidate diversity and control the degree of diversity by tuning the
perturbation's magnitude. | [
0.0402452312,
0.0215305258,
-0.0018097974,
0.0009413083,
-0.0220133234,
-0.0118068932,
0.0032326062,
0.0419728421,
-0.0316253752,
-0.0009101161,
-0.0317647085,
-0.0331757106,
0.0146548916,
-0.014570416,
0.0299900398,
-0.0836717039,
0.0255374834,
-0.0066921846,
-0.0485035852,
-0.0235562027,
-0.0164168738,
0.035693571,
0.0132755265,
0.0295132436,
-0.0083204946,
-0.0059874696,
0.0240479875,
0.0405356996,
0.0339205973,
-0.0038590385,
-0.0157181788,
0.0492176116,
-0.0189352706,
0.0588976704,
0.0000020085,
-0.009476929,
-0.0451684594,
0.0097563192,
0.0168120004,
-0.0046318439,
0.0609593205,
-0.0042438023,
-0.0044890796,
0.0211365353,
-0.0236693937,
-0.0049878741,
0.0701007247,
0.0164587405,
0.0363208726,
0.0762598887,
-0.0173808914,
-0.0154273855,
-0.0731006339,
-0.0315964371,
0.0435760245,
-0.0272985809,
-0.0256638005,
-0.0342280716,
-0.0241746549,
0.0245110616,
-0.000521665,
0.0302906595,
-0.0122069018,
0.0188638754,
0.0393863618,
0.0199389104,
-0.0208172407,
-0.0263310056,
-0.0123764435,
0.0698839575,
-0.0845786035,
-0.0105489073,
0.0038982185,
-0.0186482575,
-0.0097295269,
0.0031455946,
-0.0051598572,
-0.0299505647,
-0.0306404084,
-0.0106129739,
-0.0195745025,
0.0754890218,
0.026216859,
0.0139803095,
-0.0553053208,
-0.0466338657,
0.0473813005,
-0.0402901508,
-0.0236680005,
0.0127891218,
0.0159075148,
0.009202322,
0.045921389,
-0.010705377,
-0.0272079669,
0.0117136305,
-0.0442716293,
-0.0630081147,
0.0305143818,
-0.0643851086,
0.0600955002,
0.0463490002,
-0.0159617066,
0.0399155393,
-0.017945081,
0.0043609729,
-0.0404922217,
-0.0205881707,
-0.0683670714,
-0.0158680938,
-0.0373859257,
0.0118863536,
-0.0235355049,
-0.0254401583,
-0.0668097213,
-0.0170529895,
-0.0309356786,
0.0558515601,
0.0244285353,
-0.0194064565,
0.0538854077,
0.0284553301,
-0.0910587758,
-0.0604753606,
-0.0080145728,
0.0217474215,
-0.0372714214,
-0.0313261226,
0.01942081,
-0.027542891,
-0.0215121061,
0.0213207137,
0.0090036625,
-0.0380423218,
-0.0043301447,
0.0539365821,
-0.0289733019,
0.0071084574,
0.0387358293,
-0.0194317605,
-0.0408070795,
-0.0087993024,
-0.0236016307,
-0.0742133707,
0.0433719791,
-0.0009411603,
-0.0098145083,
-0.052418422,
0.0073356144,
-0.026836548,
-0.0370300524,
0.0381722152,
-0.0139249656,
0.0221340731,
0.0528900847,
-0.0268498138,
-0.0528855734,
0.0629832447,
0.0119220568,
0.0232465845,
0.0209256355,
0.012247311,
0.0137292165,
0.0390683189,
-0.0278015099,
0.007776239,
-0.0054010116,
-0.0168471709,
0.0118663087,
0.0660349801,
0.0010199547,
0.0442978442,
-0.0387387238,
0.0593565404,
0.0493954159,
0.0030493774,
0.0417276062,
0.0687850639,
0.0185777266,
0.0130534172,
-0.0462514423,
-0.0054210862,
-0.0158314127,
0.0367444903,
-0.000920624,
0.0130963149,
0.0528028384,
0.0766658038,
-0.0231256988,
-0.0185237918,
0.0124628013,
-0.0086955149,
-0.0063808402,
-0.0241318941,
0.0467806384,
0.0286806952,
-0.0422257073,
0.0688493177,
-0.0136518516,
-0.0488954261,
0.0208167415,
0.0007053885,
-0.049313426,
0.0924476534,
0.0327627063,
-0.0022061965,
-0.0237074345,
-0.0044548889,
-0.0312217604,
0.0847608522,
0.0782328993,
0.0385045707,
0.0284568127,
-0.0966341943,
-0.03864979,
0.0375961587,
0.0188846197,
0.061724104,
0.0116021419,
0.0425793193,
0.0574827269,
-0.0608096346,
-0.0222142842,
0.0235086195,
0.0046122549,
-0.0115818391,
0.0682764351,
0.0276023224,
-0.0143886339,
0.0268813483,
0.004925068,
0.004174043,
-0.0165856779,
-0.027916776,
-0.0055433577,
0.0429042913,
-0.0334120058,
-0.0580582693,
0.0045726681,
-0.0571380816,
0.0013393454,
-0.0187352728,
-0.0156580769,
-0.0546581782,
0.0231448431,
-0.0290169381,
-0.0211833566,
-0.0486219041,
0.0205647666,
0.0005567773,
0.0086184312,
-0.0300229099,
0.0557091609,
0.0090206908,
-0.0103224739,
0.0057100495,
-0.0417774655,
0.0015697232,
-0.0629347563,
-0.0230447408,
0.019208638,
0.023463564,
0.0216732901,
0.0292806886,
0.0131199379,
-0.0071449731,
-0.0838248506,
-0.0324285775,
-0.006693216,
-0.0183755774,
-0.0081865815,
0.0279169232,
0.0669990033,
0.0034387449,
-0.0165725406,
-0.0061737052,
-0.021569103,
0.0361484997,
0.0125834756,
0.0139480205,
0.006848197,
0.0074341344,
0.0099442136,
0.000094081,
0.0459970944,
0.0344653055,
-0.0085205715,
-0.0271745343,
-0.0814827383,
0.0091838976,
-0.0417937301,
-0.0119075002,
0.012116719,
-0.0361164808,
0.0017807244,
-0.0234938003,
0.0358879901,
-0.0299015697,
0.019206332,
-0.0425390489,
0.0226717293,
-0.0002776232,
-0.0838825852,
0.0101507315,
-0.0164109487,
-0.0232601408,
0.0298660826,
-0.0557507277,
0.0219474491,
0.0133620538,
0.0233124252,
-0.0143532781,
-0.0996964946,
-0.0114507228,
0.0132739479,
-0.0287975632,
-0.0307030249,
0.0266091693,
0.0040195086,
0.0217317902,
-0.0162540283,
-0.0414284579,
0.081476979,
0.0105598606,
0.0185528547,
-0.064800851,
0.0171453804,
-0.0095105609,
0.0116118966,
-0.0862424746,
0.0318506844,
-0.0212791767,
-0.0040411279,
-0.0307890568,
0.0031631573,
0.0347581133,
-0.0399430655,
0.0586206242,
-0.0326515548,
-0.023964053,
0.0108974185,
-0.0038690867,
-0.0400857627,
-0.0217962544,
0.0313006677,
-0.062337935,
0.0495752096,
0.0213888232,
-0.032491345,
0.0222416893,
-0.0169386789,
0.048687309,
-0.0110814674,
0.0040287632,
0.0049582175,
-0.0012859354,
0.008560284,
-0.0212309752,
0.0036242132,
-0.0432704389,
0.0360359922,
0.0003676038,
-0.0129424315,
-0.0763213485,
0.0092160953,
-0.0028791202,
0.0217941403,
-0.0056871241,
-0.0355145894,
-0.0010472691,
0.0284971427,
-0.0090480121,
0.000925197,
0.0755952969,
0.0194816608,
-0.0647444725,
-0.0108181378,
-0.0142440544,
0.0544510931,
0.0006921843,
0.0702802986,
-0.0405581333,
0.0040470907,
-0.0150893871,
0.055488199,
0.0209435951,
0.013460068,
-0.0403165966,
-0.0902843028,
0.00427526,
0.0610497445,
-0.0570163541,
-0.0727577731,
0.0309797227,
-0.0365344062,
-0.0039121946,
0.0053186659,
0.0323417038,
0.046744287,
0.003172924,
0.0117714377,
0.001112433,
-0.0960568786,
-0.029818872,
-0.0564011894,
0.0091699092,
0.0725138634,
0.0063614119,
0.0091641396,
-0.0176647883,
-0.0352695026,
0.0033924743,
0.0507497862,
-0.0020923347,
-0.0014699943,
0.0292947404,
-0.0248880237,
0.024377441,
-0.006787606,
-0.0291775633,
0.0173638817,
0.0046830387,
0.0378496051,
-0.0220910572,
0.0032426661,
0.0184567161,
-0.0137981912,
0.0672492683,
0.0362332463,
-0.0086818002,
-0.0379453488,
0.0093280999,
-0.0406854488,
0.0057227495,
-0.0647828728,
0.04469648,
-0.0183886699,
-0.053157948,
-0.0404185839,
-0.1130566671,
-0.0203083437,
-0.0004886456,
0.0733911321,
0.0205252543,
0.0442426503,
-0.0250687674,
0.0112016238,
0.0213099048,
0.0264624637,
-0.0194528233,
-0.0165254436,
-0.0299370382,
-0.036628779,
0.0015449028,
-0.0457840338,
0.0333622843,
-0.0082576871,
-0.0647846237,
-0.0843067616,
-0.005186683,
0.0474559963,
0.0215048436,
0.0730203241,
-0.0383012258,
-0.0445719436,
0.0389814787,
0.0512122586,
-0.0083721261,
-0.0079380367,
0.0276937112,
-0.0100341514,
-0.0305732004,
0.0368144438,
-0.0559017584,
-0.0064696148,
-0.0081175435,
0.0576309524,
-0.008409407,
-0.0625510216,
-0.0034958909,
-0.0051943325,
0.0264034625,
-0.0908707157,
-0.0071986844,
-0.0285041556,
0.0122497445,
0.0075769383,
-0.0215935204,
-0.03302221,
-0.0104736537,
0.0671124235,
-0.0403570607,
0.0201521423,
0.0105075026,
-0.0232770089,
-0.0012925147,
-0.0167874228,
-0.0186064895,
-0.0468787923,
-0.0153668327,
0.0354590155,
0.0358385518,
-0.0350758769,
0.0577245578,
-0.0296358429,
-0.0031490773,
-0.025967326,
0.0139212543,
-0.0088582458,
0.0152913295,
-0.0247879755,
0.0297468826,
-0.0487004779,
0.0005630077,
-0.0411791019,
0.0341100991,
0.0791309103,
0.0104779312,
0.0573641695,
-0.0020327184,
-0.0102165155,
-0.0095706293,
0.020653272,
0.0215818658,
-0.0002679579,
-0.0138822906,
-0.0035773395,
0.0168193914,
-0.0072193709,
0.0872304216,
-0.0684113428,
0.0049861516,
-0.0204756241,
-0.007742472,
-0.0449260436,
0.0242650919,
0.0187396239,
-0.0107348245,
-0.014631642,
-0.0184373353,
-0.0105577651,
-0.0227595679,
0.0867432952,
-0.0067289211,
-0.0040883762,
0.0111755468,
0.0507134609,
0.0763806924,
-0.0503762476,
0.0484553725,
-0.0219662078,
-0.0016864205,
0.0131650558,
-0.024184294,
-0.0269478261,
-6.312661803e-33,
-0.0049486952,
0.0034828435,
-0.0071291942,
-0.0771289021,
-0.0001119872,
-0.0538082756,
0.0141099123,
0.0045713354,
0.0015605165,
-0.0004127226,
-0.0394715779,
-0.0123556415,
0.0362929031,
0.0118181352,
0.032032907,
0.0058908327,
0.0509220958,
0.0132104456,
-0.0163948108,
0.0204922277,
-0.0035756628,
0.0333247818,
0.0584397279,
-0.0475071222,
0.0126613425,
-0.0045222901,
-0.0260595288,
-0.0155434487,
0.035249263,
0.0232068989,
0.0068050493,
0.0468743332,
0.0050310725,
-0.0344508588,
-0.0545823351,
-0.0672381222,
0.0100410124,
-0.0333512314,
0.0085059814,
0.0232038312,
0.0622545183,
-0.0610562377,
0.0280391518,
-0.0486000404,
-0.011171259,
0.0112508358,
0.0100121675,
-0.055598937,
-0.0691598207,
-0.0152522009,
0.0052413596,
0.0430203155,
0.0152091021,
-0.0168272369,
-0.0240936968,
0.0575606972,
-0.0190477408,
-0.0381750762,
-0.0581305847,
0.0638686568,
0.037504714,
0.0565435067,
0.067304112,
0.0431066938,
0.0030310135,
-0.0222649705,
0.0097174523,
-0.0110491691,
0.005464443,
0.0045023919,
-0.0091593247,
0.0207873397,
0.0574186854,
0.0982506573,
0.0415076092,
-0.0448386893,
0.040172562,
0.0586553887,
-0.0179508533,
-0.0388268866,
0.0635842681,
0.0212108083,
-0.052360028,
-0.0186838266,
-0.0170231406,
-0.0423752889,
-0.0379243866,
-0.0560336411,
0.0150521025,
0.04855939,
-0.0511604846,
0.0021331548,
0.0556803383,
-0.005326652,
0.0328683183,
0.0112184789,
-0.0255818013,
-0.0037506439,
-0.0100887669,
0.0051473854,
0.0147997933,
-0.0531337671,
0.0410793982,
0.006515801,
-0.0362792537,
0.0100964801,
-0.0055086818,
0.0141119491,
-0.0662932247,
0.0321657136,
-0.0022795743,
-0.0048392788,
0.0097356085,
0.0017276324,
0.0058474615,
-0.0332027823,
-0.0113817109,
0.0319273397,
0.0365256295,
0.00864824,
0.0146929072,
0.0128226634,
0.0204755887,
0.0380473435,
-0.0292510558,
0.0657051355,
-0.0029660664,
-0.047495164,
0.0321774296,
-0.0007819766,
-0.035001602,
0.0290840119,
2.799e-7,
0.0374052823,
0.063817583,
-0.0068542124,
-0.0217590518,
-0.0097599281,
0.0090675671,
0.0010787663,
0.0327878371,
0.0086553479,
0.018005481,
0.0363755971,
0.0198849756,
0.0629759282,
0.0353760719,
-0.082077466,
-0.0237011705,
-0.0159117337,
0.0836044252,
-0.0414945111,
-0.0267732665,
0.0578659251,
0.1023570001,
-0.0138842491,
0.0013318183,
0.0030690231,
-0.0329736657,
0.079173319,
-0.0314612314,
-0.0106698805,
-0.0036517787,
0.0670402944,
-0.028996706,
-0.0415585302,
-0.0232578199,
-0.0448539555,
0.0059038638,
0.0500939898,
0.0603749603,
-0.0130862445,
-0.0347605906,
0.0311857499,
0.0098551316,
-0.0089790197,
-0.0501301736,
0.0386008061,
0.0065915124,
0.0390552469,
-0.000856432,
-0.0157525633,
0.0199733842,
0.0491861962,
-0.0717128068,
-0.0427310877,
0.0136821987,
0.0566510819,
0.0113347825,
-0.0191952791,
-0.0401435681,
-0.0413910225,
-0.0529191718,
-0.0272128414,
-0.0154761421,
-0.0212381277,
0.0191576928,
0.0320364796,
0.0246833246,
-0.0003973033,
2.118322783e-34,
0.031094756,
0.0099722985,
-0.0004965859,
-0.0505286232,
0.0117861852,
-0.0208745338,
0.0301304813,
0.0398562513,
0.0146498987,
-0.0549004897,
-0.0414842553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09320v1 | ICDPO: Effectively Borrowing Alignment Capability of Others via In-context Direct Preference Optimization | 2024-02-14T17:14:34 | 2024-02-14T17:14:34 | Feifan Song, Yuxuan Fan, Xin Zhang, Peiyi Wang, Houfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) rely on Human Preference Alignment (HPA) to
ensure the generation of safe content. Due to the heavy cost associated with
fine-tuning, fine-tuning-free methods have emerged, typically modifying LLM
decoding with external auxiliary methods. However, these methods do not
essentially enhance the LLM itself. In this paper, we rethink the derivation
procedures of DPO, based on which we conversely build an instant scorer using
the states of the LLM before and after In-context Learning (ICL). Accordingly,
we propose a novel approach called In-Context Direct Preference Optimization
(ICDPO). It enables LLMs to borrow the HPA capabilities from superior LLMs with
ICL, generating well-aligned responses as estimated by the aforementioned
instant scorer, thereby enhancing the final performance. ICDPO can be further
enhanced with a two-stage retriever and an upgraded scorer, both offering
benefits. Extensive experiments show its effectiveness, particularly in
outperforming two fine-tuning-free baselines, and it exhibits competitiveness
with SFT + LoRA. We also conduct detailed analyses to offer comprehensive
insights into ICDPO. | [
0.0079957731,
0.081592001,
0.00582611,
0.0144528663,
-0.0162209868,
0.0158993546,
-0.0445429869,
-0.0223564021,
-0.0445682332,
0.0053516296,
-0.0778744966,
-0.0422077179,
0.0163875502,
0.0123196691,
0.0092929006,
-0.0089136129,
0.0312540755,
-0.0052550556,
-0.0079481564,
-0.0141845075,
0.025549069,
0.0139487805,
0.00730382,
0.0297729224,
0.0352688245,
-0.0198715758,
-0.0107613243,
0.0371776894,
0.0489736535,
-0.0395755507,
0.0332724191,
0.0750389472,
0.0271579083,
0.0341824256,
0.0000023522,
-0.0355532169,
-0.0431163274,
0.005384014,
-0.0338319913,
0.0076342924,
0.0317177027,
0.0012796663,
-0.0367783494,
0.0164959896,
-0.0384319685,
0.007901568,
0.0821820423,
-0.0204004049,
0.0301728752,
0.1084821448,
-0.0088323997,
-0.0225582235,
0.0175983626,
-0.0484598055,
-0.01100027,
-0.0416701883,
0.0360803828,
-0.0452852771,
-0.0216912348,
0.0072813579,
-0.0135586001,
0.0288519785,
0.0123006934,
0.0142894154,
0.0123775005,
0.0087355915,
0.0145690851,
-0.0163004566,
-0.0150366416,
0.0711106583,
-0.0041701128,
-0.0270257983,
-0.0054013338,
-0.0173984077,
-0.0204195473,
-0.0511790588,
-0.0043893033,
0.0027875893,
-0.0019868158,
0.0633800626,
0.0633597299,
0.0214743856,
0.0229786299,
-0.0090451296,
-0.0315292403,
0.0719375014,
0.0275905449,
-0.0413146205,
0.0159477796,
0.0238185581,
-0.0033450208,
-0.0407736413,
0.0088224486,
-0.017031692,
-0.0337001495,
0.0148658874,
-0.0684127286,
-0.0125169577,
0.0150861908,
-0.036083363,
0.0793917403,
0.0773235485,
-0.0086984467,
-0.0139084505,
0.0166377388,
0.0571973994,
-0.0479811057,
0.0292433463,
-0.0510407425,
0.0418044589,
0.0103688454,
-0.0149423555,
0.0127503769,
0.0276207551,
-0.0508708097,
-0.0066394405,
-0.0635088831,
0.0485022925,
0.0098840827,
-0.0072664712,
0.0173609592,
0.0003053355,
-0.0755014718,
-0.0035767104,
0.0028577859,
0.0461892597,
0.0126543054,
0.0193975456,
0.0039157989,
-0.0361394621,
-0.0243757125,
0.0248639565,
-0.0024986262,
-0.0371017121,
-0.0193540417,
0.0708139464,
-0.0302065164,
-0.0258756466,
0.0200186782,
-0.0052702418,
-0.0377400927,
-0.0586658455,
-0.0162611064,
-0.0583826974,
0.0262822062,
-0.0020930641,
-0.0142371217,
-0.0748056844,
-0.0000739247,
0.0188072547,
-0.0135066677,
0.0281771887,
-0.0110918544,
0.0066354889,
-0.0268105194,
-0.0144509254,
-0.0084715467,
0.0726420805,
0.0232866462,
0.0380660631,
-0.0002179789,
0.0015440177,
-0.0159412511,
0.073107563,
0.0430097058,
0.0292334277,
-0.0388823934,
0.0098346872,
0.0311522596,
0.0037887234,
0.0718356073,
0.0199747235,
-0.028775353,
-0.0099211475,
0.0918887109,
-0.0095236255,
0.0613744631,
-0.0215870254,
0.0079844343,
0.0325297862,
-0.0213132594,
0.044601921,
-0.0317111611,
0.0279042739,
-0.0406581759,
0.0274180286,
0.0565793328,
0.0522954054,
-0.0090194354,
-0.0241330806,
0.0068330579,
-0.0069479677,
-0.0219155271,
0.0301688239,
0.0331711322,
-0.0041254954,
-0.0819004923,
0.0152147049,
0.0393807143,
-0.0344606154,
0.0183906406,
-0.0242556259,
0.0240156874,
0.0753304884,
0.055536259,
0.006084017,
-0.0215125531,
0.0236515794,
-0.0670053139,
0.0550019778,
0.0012734866,
0.0043634945,
0.0286992043,
-0.0585843734,
-0.0536740795,
0.0323024876,
0.0057601617,
0.0560806356,
0.043422848,
-0.0037638266,
-0.004794003,
0.020191893,
-0.0124876602,
0.028661672,
0.0004189333,
-0.025858717,
0.0219655428,
0.0178784225,
0.0568432771,
0.0159393754,
-0.0130474344,
0.0073395902,
0.0259537101,
-0.0350969099,
0.0029283201,
-0.0151497005,
-0.0935362503,
-0.0669654906,
0.0405563489,
0.0109030996,
-0.0350070558,
0.0383591764,
-0.0219066348,
-0.0173621681,
-0.0113765551,
-0.0041506588,
0.0206515566,
-0.0361774564,
0.0290926453,
0.0164550785,
0.0170514975,
-0.0781981796,
0.059203051,
-0.0155357858,
-0.0131311202,
-0.0038317393,
-0.0043248078,
-0.0089383284,
-0.0673409328,
0.0065617375,
0.0103405053,
-0.0144273704,
0.0277958736,
0.0110895438,
0.0353120491,
-0.0171735659,
-0.0407389402,
-0.045460362,
0.0359543152,
-0.0276216622,
0.0369400866,
0.0409573689,
0.022420885,
-0.018924104,
0.0037549599,
-0.0328396037,
-0.0045683249,
-0.0374963917,
0.0105212806,
0.0013833488,
0.0169894677,
-0.0102938469,
-0.0484379306,
-0.0098541975,
-0.000499448,
-0.0122580146,
-0.0461725593,
-0.0116305603,
-0.0413275957,
0.0695837736,
-0.0067588207,
0.0057064532,
-0.004595892,
-0.0306756403,
0.0032386705,
-0.0059644035,
0.0375409238,
0.0737963244,
0.014920569,
-0.0096210856,
0.0427355208,
-0.0034717596,
-0.0854488313,
-0.0111620547,
-0.0500284843,
-0.0308300573,
-0.0526569411,
-0.00676833,
0.0209646076,
0.0690516755,
0.0335286446,
0.0024797684,
-0.0960911736,
-0.0093498286,
0.002798704,
-0.0485651232,
-0.0074081374,
-0.0098047918,
-0.0389090031,
0.0518687069,
-0.039968323,
-0.0537209548,
0.0940297469,
-0.0346269384,
0.0088567426,
-0.0426313058,
0.0154137928,
-0.0380164348,
-0.0225514285,
-0.0304899886,
0.0131885614,
-0.0472386889,
-0.0462772995,
-0.0572479106,
-0.0175947901,
0.0365185849,
-0.0420162305,
0.0380295068,
-0.0451782234,
0.0080039641,
-0.0412415117,
-0.0787640139,
-0.0435972102,
-0.0508904867,
0.012984396,
-0.0218439233,
0.0058197519,
-0.0061701168,
-0.0190809742,
-0.0016672829,
0.0040130089,
0.0367528647,
-0.024785161,
0.0241957493,
-0.039078556,
0.0386037529,
0.0754363537,
-0.0410922989,
-0.0149952229,
-0.0406816117,
-0.0080545796,
0.0586695336,
0.0413742512,
0.0064260582,
-0.0030647756,
0.0355939753,
0.0841339231,
0.0233174302,
-0.014099475,
0.0310434606,
0.0238880385,
-0.0215563681,
0.0032177325,
0.1083714142,
0.0088248979,
-0.0761256292,
-0.0033988992,
-0.0061659357,
0.0614815392,
-0.0030604475,
0.0269674882,
-0.0788756907,
-0.0302405339,
0.0263622217,
0.056758821,
-0.0059799617,
0.005375362,
-0.0084286975,
-0.1232210994,
0.0139741879,
0.0479148105,
-0.0295328572,
-0.0184027441,
-0.014770912,
0.0123671433,
-0.0309263747,
0.0352419205,
0.0590229221,
0.0227669645,
-0.0028809251,
0.009055228,
0.0268291999,
-0.0447408631,
0.0190742668,
-0.009807881,
0.0511026792,
0.1354394257,
0.0028398552,
0.0416183583,
-0.0153071564,
0.0182939582,
-0.0343216285,
-0.0254135225,
-0.0123305349,
-0.0026085549,
-0.0572791249,
0.0072216173,
-0.0191155169,
0.0603241101,
-0.0192002971,
-0.0021535335,
-0.0308417082,
0.0225089081,
0.0109953471,
0.0254923496,
0.0097657936,
-0.0077128126,
0.0145523585,
0.044765994,
0.0120152337,
-0.0746400356,
-0.0140748443,
-0.0209762771,
-0.0158479083,
-0.0496911854,
-0.0028787346,
0.0083669648,
0.0018417297,
-0.0600316823,
-0.070567131,
-0.0111935586,
-0.0102146761,
0.0346021503,
0.0010771924,
0.0093869539,
-0.0393331125,
-0.0370064452,
-0.0363943242,
0.0179612916,
-0.0360086299,
-0.0079126405,
-0.0726482719,
-0.0103857173,
0.010903582,
-0.0473499633,
0.0063445466,
0.0281383656,
-0.0078327218,
-0.0948451981,
0.0215943698,
0.0440761745,
0.0229602978,
0.0594226643,
-0.0088057397,
-0.0414080285,
0.0421169177,
0.0740749985,
-0.0056360117,
0.0351177342,
0.019919578,
-0.0063818772,
0.0068034437,
0.0328540578,
-0.0451193191,
-0.0154033815,
0.0351869017,
0.0638885945,
0.0116526233,
-0.0535142981,
0.0593930855,
0.004200066,
0.0484430045,
-0.0440518782,
-0.0011943186,
-0.0390137359,
0.038525708,
-0.0278627854,
0.0023746847,
-0.0232643075,
-0.0384639129,
0.057217747,
-0.0170903411,
0.0089327181,
-0.0074333544,
-0.0120000485,
0.0069936314,
-0.0327323005,
-0.0095646083,
0.0123468246,
0.0175875314,
0.0509316027,
0.0312898308,
-0.0138045494,
0.0419517979,
0.0131100304,
0.0466447733,
-0.0275470819,
0.0352189466,
0.0204253774,
0.0193621125,
-0.0217266344,
0.0446923673,
-0.0129758259,
-0.0021045273,
-0.0697242841,
-0.0410263166,
0.0562606826,
-0.0035932111,
0.0858459845,
0.0094248718,
0.0014782007,
-0.0346647501,
0.0200274307,
-0.0481263734,
-0.0374320857,
0.0017320559,
0.0033509065,
-0.0111901024,
0.011831414,
0.0685673729,
-0.0000420198,
0.0288601834,
-0.0585357696,
0.031552691,
-0.0405466221,
-0.0197224785,
0.0345089696,
0.0167788118,
-0.0560647137,
-0.0341804549,
-0.0510478057,
-0.0677114204,
0.0062214681,
0.0105196675,
-0.0074516349,
0.0047014682,
0.0298404749,
0.0230090693,
-0.0658289865,
-0.0140372794,
-0.0365226269,
-0.0352598615,
-0.0150388014,
-0.0309438463,
-0.0224858802,
-7.392496628e-33,
-0.0469440147,
0.0050947438,
0.0061369776,
-0.0165344682,
-0.040674936,
-0.0135745844,
-0.0238255206,
-0.0135720847,
0.0236364603,
-0.0402049348,
-0.0290646292,
-0.0301126223,
0.0190741643,
0.0280811414,
0.0033755682,
0.0023573791,
0.0149091724,
-0.0185694862,
-0.0533312745,
-0.0157372802,
0.0477050133,
0.0254572462,
0.0232636724,
-0.0393247753,
0.0059632631,
0.0087386193,
-0.0223572962,
-0.0069728014,
-0.0292810127,
0.0527446941,
-0.010448114,
0.0077167121,
0.0012664438,
0.0000946075,
-0.0223383978,
0.0048870347,
-0.065041922,
0.0246593207,
0.0231102761,
-0.0042361962,
0.0095924223,
-0.0634347498,
0.0140560232,
0.005016366,
-0.0410646982,
-0.0238040462,
-0.0102778822,
-0.0229349211,
-0.0243220124,
-0.0143572018,
-0.0631941035,
0.0185585991,
-0.0008053214,
-0.0200488549,
0.0451125242,
0.0278011281,
0.0011316459,
0.05470898,
-0.0492022708,
0.0508080497,
-0.0160580631,
0.0440325253,
0.0881185085,
0.027681781,
0.021771986,
0.0386200696,
0.0223787054,
-0.0468464755,
0.0518925563,
-0.0543394424,
0.0291239135,
0.0156918131,
-0.016440507,
0.0657126978,
0.0396008119,
-0.0060176593,
-0.0485614091,
0.0420067906,
0.0066983714,
-0.0151664782,
0.0520496108,
0.0516586415,
-0.0572222099,
-0.0076597231,
-0.0382308811,
-0.0288768131,
-0.044249177,
-0.0296213254,
0.0391120091,
0.0262836795,
-0.0276871622,
-0.0463252887,
0.0534373559,
-0.0329596996,
0.0536085814,
-0.0045107459,
-0.0384056456,
0.0140245929,
-0.0198772699,
0.017230168,
-0.0678708032,
-0.0278062914,
0.0310346596,
-0.0241729803,
-0.0275374744,
0.0027861549,
0.0036000223,
0.0331244878,
-0.0464413725,
0.0122912526,
-0.0412301831,
0.0269939508,
0.0320523307,
0.0285266079,
0.0612833537,
-0.0144704301,
-0.0029337965,
0.0481198877,
0.030422667,
0.0191929117,
-0.0379926674,
-0.0076935776,
0.0177355446,
0.0102055268,
0.0016687866,
0.0379815362,
0.0205204505,
-0.0000646259,
-0.0175795481,
-0.0202881042,
-0.0255582295,
0.020462919,
3.064e-7,
0.0435219333,
0.0446904227,
0.0515676588,
-0.0093159731,
-0.0015257978,
0.041371014,
-0.0126674185,
0.032216955,
0.0357488878,
0.0215273872,
0.0374753848,
0.0058946968,
0.0686989278,
-0.0063805506,
-0.0805217698,
0.0240419656,
-0.0113100698,
0.0281074941,
-0.0233581439,
-0.0320340618,
0.0278015155,
0.0820951462,
-0.0136666028,
-0.0068279086,
0.0227536466,
0.0230900627,
0.0681316853,
-0.0044250265,
-0.0064701689,
0.0215565469,
-0.0396789871,
-0.030833533,
-0.0179301221,
-0.023039436,
-0.0020526398,
0.0451600291,
-0.0243377313,
0.0825705826,
-0.007130533,
-0.1048056334,
0.0103067057,
0.0168146584,
-0.0202563703,
-0.0753584802,
0.0381999016,
-0.0623893552,
-0.0512334295,
0.0084186271,
-0.0623891056,
-0.0142409522,
-0.0124420412,
-0.0333832912,
-0.0045981398,
0.0306233261,
0.0228804592,
0.0296775941,
-0.0474177264,
-0.0451353826,
-0.0378740095,
-0.0056908592,
-0.0452326015,
-0.0521331206,
-0.0239789244,
0.0689584911,
0.0106535796,
-0.0506143905,
0.013568351,
3.127113209e-34,
0.0013784522,
-0.0138378181,
0.0165775605,
0.0226689335,
0.0022488798,
-0.0006541151,
0.0190759823,
0.041432064,
0.0261996407,
-0.0609559752,
-0.0302120429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09283v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09283v3 | Attacks, Defenses and Evaluations for LLM Conversation Safety: A Survey | 2024-02-14T16:14:03 | 2024-03-27T13:55:14 | Zhichen Dong, Zhanhui Zhou, Chao Yang, Jing Shao, Yu Qiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are now commonplace in conversation
applications. However, their risks of misuse for generating harmful responses
have raised serious societal concerns and spurred recent research on LLM
conversation safety. Therefore, in this survey, we provide a comprehensive
overview of recent studies, covering three critical aspects of LLM conversation
safety: attacks, defenses, and evaluations. Our goal is to provide a structured
summary that enhances understanding of LLM conversation safety and encourages
further investigation into this important subject. For easy reference, we have
categorized all the studies mentioned in this survey according to our taxonomy,
available at: https://github.com/niconi19/LLM-conversation-safety. | [
0.0712170675,
0.040932402,
-0.0094026811,
0.0565703586,
-0.044067312,
-0.0083278716,
0.0207482316,
0.0183531903,
0.0328484215,
-0.0512301475,
-0.0336686298,
-0.0479497574,
0.0204167068,
0.0127754631,
0.0355802476,
-0.0113514755,
0.034415435,
-0.0762947276,
0.0175463986,
0.0047717551,
0.0265165269,
-0.0132028051,
-0.0047848066,
0.0609712191,
-0.0117447749,
-0.0153961945,
-0.0289694462,
0.0144725144,
-0.0099995201,
-0.0251772981,
0.0005812417,
0.0405816771,
-0.0199831538,
0.0724997893,
0.0000019509,
-0.0460403077,
0.000545073,
0.0253499337,
-0.0401308723,
0.0297404137,
0.0505531766,
0.0052836277,
-0.0433834679,
0.0487459265,
-0.0326397493,
0.0385737196,
0.0356668159,
0.0446401797,
0.0786858797,
0.07761617,
-0.0215547364,
0.017236175,
0.0601157136,
0.0025584528,
0.0082925223,
-0.0478349775,
0.0387690328,
-0.0076827528,
-0.0016007177,
0.0515222549,
0.0361499824,
-0.0018893683,
-0.0257989913,
-0.0447477996,
-0.0251531918,
0.009122666,
-0.0269049425,
-0.061501544,
-0.0193618909,
0.0462133177,
-0.0051253978,
0.0078024468,
0.029895775,
0.0091178231,
0.0060156821,
0.0104809981,
-0.0468978025,
0.0401329435,
-0.0229216255,
-0.0167379342,
-0.0353680626,
0.0032011319,
0.0550129935,
0.0017385317,
0.0190814976,
0.0352402516,
0.0257796049,
-0.0098218964,
-0.0193060301,
-0.0356385708,
0.0243006144,
-0.0762366652,
-0.0133178439,
0.0104916003,
-0.0423249006,
0.0221896246,
-0.049570851,
-0.0338949785,
0.0528900251,
-0.0899248496,
0.0023471471,
0.0177868325,
0.0178597979,
-0.0031392828,
0.0428328067,
-0.0157082789,
-0.0377365164,
-0.0257081632,
0.0227433741,
0.0063251574,
0.0096687078,
-0.0155887231,
0.0051015336,
0.0408750884,
-0.0160992872,
0.0076119858,
-0.0408083387,
0.04955424,
-0.0016051012,
0.0429128855,
-0.0535003021,
-0.0111291129,
0.0058384188,
0.0125134252,
0.007713201,
-0.0310711674,
0.0042408309,
0.0032738009,
-0.0080896281,
-0.1091231182,
0.0039168331,
0.0266681816,
-0.0367577523,
-0.0215492472,
-0.0397264548,
0.1102246642,
0.0165747758,
-0.0333301015,
-0.0238312185,
-0.0905788541,
-0.039685674,
-0.0299826786,
0.000743321,
-0.0617253892,
-0.0064247623,
0.0058448724,
-0.0379733481,
-0.0133875636,
0.0327152498,
0.0163802542,
-0.0493476503,
0.0291235037,
-0.03356231,
0.0020119853,
0.0184969567,
0.0735566616,
-0.0092595723,
0.0684037581,
0.0318790711,
0.0331981778,
0.0577242114,
-0.0254939385,
0.0630941913,
0.0559612922,
-0.0009364996,
0.0192139763,
-0.0017823454,
0.0247850474,
0.0196369421,
-0.0353120007,
-0.0473104455,
0.0772932395,
-0.0212968141,
-0.0323759317,
0.1132804975,
0.0737018809,
-0.0675767511,
0.0422472097,
-0.0410380252,
0.0230551958,
0.0123024015,
0.0121515961,
-0.060386505,
-0.0202944893,
-0.0828840658,
-0.0245130435,
0.0327918567,
-0.0003759006,
-0.0196956992,
0.0005453018,
-0.0073054787,
-0.0426821262,
0.0461739264,
-0.0003108666,
0.0006562773,
-0.0057349475,
0.0031006623,
0.0555477627,
0.0190185476,
-0.0543720685,
-0.0497452505,
-0.0462035127,
-0.0074445829,
0.0520788431,
0.0470204726,
0.0219956338,
-0.0149634518,
-0.0537181906,
0.007514562,
0.0275819041,
0.0159531981,
0.0346547477,
0.0465957522,
-0.0080621792,
0.002618521,
0.0194447301,
-0.0116996961,
-0.0253015235,
0.0255570319,
0.0225332081,
0.0051667378,
0.0290722959,
-0.0281443894,
-0.0130843567,
-0.0144339744,
-0.0295844264,
-0.0008923156,
0.0006770694,
0.0260574687,
0.0187555384,
-0.0108222114,
0.0027693969,
0.027100414,
0.0246937312,
0.0148283588,
0.0014234937,
-0.0402390696,
0.038066566,
0.0286294874,
-0.0091682281,
-0.0130546317,
0.0164652858,
-0.0032025257,
0.0003789119,
0.0327390917,
-0.0636051446,
0.0642273426,
0.0023004485,
0.0165994912,
-0.0131097324,
0.0307059381,
-0.005563701,
-0.0125173591,
-0.0177151021,
-0.0019547602,
-0.0081075765,
-0.0020615775,
-0.0007536559,
-0.0423786975,
-0.0639606118,
0.0181099996,
-0.0219277013,
0.0409278385,
0.0155388936,
-0.0059013553,
-0.0446249954,
-0.0099135078,
-0.0859207585,
-0.0172028318,
-0.00903627,
0.0494427197,
0.016707059,
0.0384889618,
-0.0267040618,
-0.03775765,
-0.0195011348,
0.0087030688,
0.0121423788,
0.0427981764,
0.0291679036,
-0.0167728271,
-0.0556035265,
-0.0174634885,
-0.0042446987,
-0.0098062521,
0.0553769208,
0.0053378604,
-0.0615139306,
-0.0309008714,
0.0583903305,
-0.0327523202,
0.0290133748,
-0.0245628692,
-0.0579876974,
0.0470555574,
0.0248885714,
0.0231101308,
0.021316098,
0.0698889941,
0.0214764737,
0.038617637,
-0.0154962614,
-0.0427870154,
-0.0297467262,
0.0174633358,
-0.0355263017,
-0.0431495234,
-0.0457853377,
0.0185305178,
0.04617998,
0.0092366673,
0.012396222,
0.0029726946,
0.0218647365,
-0.0042571328,
-0.0361879282,
-0.0190609433,
-0.0503666475,
-0.0361262932,
0.0326776728,
0.0029775624,
-0.0936746523,
0.0527488217,
-0.0533504486,
0.002448017,
-0.0054117865,
-0.0521000437,
0.0264385808,
0.0416510068,
-0.0382486992,
0.0070504737,
0.0430506915,
-0.0506648347,
-0.0041770488,
-0.0687945709,
0.0129182795,
-0.0445549563,
0.0210996512,
-0.0396988355,
0.0065614074,
-0.0050185565,
-0.0204309169,
-0.0590790473,
-0.07228975,
-0.0463057272,
-0.0334627703,
-0.0027745708,
-0.0244963821,
-0.0086385701,
0.0150051033,
0.026754193,
-0.0392881893,
-0.019539794,
0.00098642,
-0.013547074,
0.0029120529,
0.0487705283,
-0.0227496997,
0.0200830083,
-0.0128062116,
0.0548365265,
0.1233918369,
0.0128718773,
0.0229306277,
-0.0044029159,
-0.0520799868,
0.0151285026,
0.0079900362,
-0.0378864668,
0.0513428375,
0.0654296204,
-0.0195254572,
-0.0299588237,
0.065266259,
0.0167144388,
-0.0587145016,
0.0032597436,
-0.0389259458,
0.0248770621,
-0.0261218883,
-0.0075237476,
-0.082800135,
0.0077877701,
0.0159766115,
0.0406604074,
-0.0339240432,
-0.0054057059,
0.0006177957,
-0.0881045014,
0.0236750878,
0.0276785716,
-0.0368045904,
-0.0107155126,
-0.0317312628,
0.0017771262,
0.0460221246,
0.0920224115,
-0.035221599,
-0.0073255603,
-0.0294031855,
0.0083365412,
-0.0926998258,
-0.0197673589,
-0.0033523792,
-0.0337887146,
0.0775401145,
0.0472412929,
0.0014444669,
-0.0248166937,
0.0006506954,
0.0600120835,
0.0112677002,
-0.0271242782,
0.01192958,
0.0257951748,
0.0201921221,
-0.0038736062,
-0.0337799229,
0.0103097064,
-0.000935521,
-0.0227434039,
0.0343034863,
0.0161870904,
-0.0712945312,
-0.0100318715,
-0.024854729,
0.0348299257,
0.057278391,
0.0459225848,
0.032785397,
-0.0451883338,
-0.0013149811,
-0.0532422587,
0.0207704324,
0.0087413685,
-0.0323123634,
-0.004398786,
0.0484545492,
-0.0321826264,
-0.0549368449,
0.0037897879,
-0.0296052843,
-0.0237242244,
0.0120106572,
0.0271405634,
0.0062753703,
0.0354522206,
0.0273665991,
0.0014899254,
-0.0179099459,
0.0382525399,
-0.0456729941,
0.074300997,
0.0066479305,
-0.0244479328,
0.0394970365,
0.0125536146,
-0.0793617815,
-0.0666487962,
0.0062076594,
0.0629553497,
0.0269980598,
0.0265698247,
-0.0310286637,
-0.0644006133,
0.0250855628,
0.0273446273,
-0.046630539,
0.0183636323,
0.0502713956,
0.0381909497,
0.0288316794,
0.0078489035,
-0.0308795292,
-0.0179520529,
0.0388931558,
-0.002249236,
-0.073646307,
-0.0814903677,
-0.0264783092,
0.0604120344,
0.0251423493,
0.0146388691,
0.0341322646,
0.0414176099,
0.0231653135,
-0.0438929684,
-0.0115588894,
-0.0204551928,
0.0097086597,
-0.0366680659,
-0.0136874486,
0.0403545909,
-0.0246161502,
-0.0565981492,
0.0237452351,
0.0177065395,
0.0430457853,
-0.006481648,
-0.0018309345,
0.044885993,
0.0109272245,
-0.0263973121,
0.0544850677,
0.0111693703,
0.0212123096,
0.0073185479,
0.0361918248,
-0.0198499728,
-0.0413143672,
0.0231126919,
0.0500481464,
-0.0471666828,
-0.053152021,
0.0103012295,
0.0596716255,
-0.0080451826,
0.0415063277,
0.046299845,
-0.0152251013,
0.0267750211,
-0.0448412672,
0.0258753411,
-0.0356724933,
-0.0384110324,
0.0026252652,
-0.0053557483,
-0.0281752478,
0.0312068556,
0.0500913188,
0.0085207922,
0.0140422648,
0.0271338131,
-0.0449331179,
-0.034301687,
-0.0169166978,
0.0352945589,
0.0233786721,
-0.0398018621,
-0.0373055041,
-0.048464302,
-0.0803147033,
-0.0109186908,
-0.0249257851,
0.0288510136,
-0.020250177,
0.0116974954,
0.0355102271,
0.0407310948,
0.0222085454,
-0.0505876653,
0.0088773286,
0.0126115791,
-0.0341873355,
-0.007988588,
-5.630390556e-33,
0.0400412381,
-0.0667216107,
-0.0196346473,
0.0116189057,
-0.0096092299,
-0.0099214008,
-0.0183381997,
0.0489577912,
-0.0188855715,
-0.0324598141,
-0.0251729153,
0.0377905779,
0.0186178703,
0.0297458079,
-0.0452260561,
-0.0097340103,
0.0085643679,
-0.0252808481,
-0.000398467,
0.0328571126,
0.0429741032,
-0.0155807426,
-0.0029603923,
-0.1158126518,
0.0487794839,
-0.0251868498,
-0.0249367077,
0.0053992197,
-0.0102637364,
0.0637717918,
-0.0124471039,
0.0437770002,
-0.0087546865,
-0.0004682904,
-0.0095420163,
0.0796139836,
0.0290786643,
-0.0202564038,
0.0181111153,
-0.0015647839,
0.0223847665,
-0.0608743504,
0.0446127057,
-0.0175228138,
-0.0200666152,
0.0063584959,
-0.0110223284,
-0.0036728356,
-0.0373705365,
0.0065533533,
-0.002996817,
-0.0024907799,
-0.0037742895,
-0.0072376672,
0.0217066258,
0.0305396337,
0.0161446929,
-0.0350175388,
-0.0233493187,
0.0544871911,
0.005992441,
-0.0194446035,
0.0301836859,
0.0087311985,
0.0195795,
0.0584372357,
0.0195152555,
0.0416711122,
-0.0378908366,
-0.0452550501,
-0.0186092667,
0.0561747514,
0.020605091,
0.0534493923,
-0.0350120254,
-0.0333584882,
-0.0638627782,
0.0168753602,
0.0386535339,
0.0197355263,
0.0459057242,
-0.0273638796,
-0.0672425553,
-0.0319005325,
0.0081459759,
0.0359730199,
-0.0332778543,
-0.0303551313,
0.019408768,
-0.0138295414,
-0.0132205971,
-0.0396676511,
0.0229806472,
-0.0754082277,
-0.0201346558,
-0.0117410896,
0.0234199669,
-0.0132242143,
0.0028606544,
0.0090934141,
0.0034099352,
0.01012599,
-0.00062403,
-0.0535996594,
0.0165327545,
0.0145740658,
-0.0025328267,
0.0123380646,
-0.0549421422,
-0.0113460105,
0.0001794617,
0.0574647263,
0.0281358398,
0.0050336742,
0.0246502478,
-0.0382810757,
-0.0128479591,
0.031258028,
0.0295155123,
0.0232583322,
-0.0384610482,
-0.0041353344,
-0.0355948731,
0.0251514371,
-0.0241400599,
0.0070589953,
-0.0286595542,
0.0211878456,
0.0666041225,
-0.0329547301,
-0.0036496355,
-0.0713021308,
2.643e-7,
-0.0206715837,
0.0412058942,
0.0132769831,
0.0250884201,
0.0482840016,
0.0707564205,
0.0009963613,
0.0660201758,
0.0148092145,
-0.0191301014,
-0.0166150425,
-0.0038654369,
0.0702702329,
0.0643761307,
-0.0630186051,
-0.0267904457,
-0.105750747,
-0.0139341783,
-0.0425456725,
-0.0051270924,
0.0492676459,
0.072156176,
0.004202459,
-0.024299413,
-0.0133228824,
-0.0429706685,
0.0257367101,
-0.0471003167,
-0.0207356717,
-0.0233247876,
0.0700142086,
0.028397765,
0.0309350155,
0.0430399366,
0.0017341936,
-0.0280337576,
-0.040069174,
0.0617877319,
0.0127291037,
-0.0315070003,
-0.0152682224,
-0.0556572974,
0.009711151,
-0.0489519648,
0.0379801244,
-0.0455283932,
-0.0551641509,
-0.0139485775,
0.0022066792,
-0.0468643233,
0.0267561637,
-0.0284768026,
-0.0117242252,
0.0021199724,
0.0027539097,
0.0146094393,
0.0209721196,
-0.0381020978,
-0.0075881747,
-0.0134825772,
-0.0092706867,
-0.1040973291,
-0.0188203193,
0.0002086716,
-0.0207987502,
-0.0176904295,
0.0313038789,
2.187792663e-34,
-0.0207804665,
-0.0160912089,
-0.0091488846,
0.0435776189,
0.0308033992,
0.0299917646,
0.0272531286,
0.024417432,
0.0389416516,
-0.0356049277,
-0.0203187969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09282v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09282v4 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Enhanced NLP Task Performance through Knowledge Distillation and Optimized Training Strategies | 2024-02-14T16:10:45 | 2024-03-24T07:06:19 | Yining Huang, Keke Tang, Meilian Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emerging Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 have revolutionized Natural
Language Processing (NLP), showing potential in traditional tasks such as Named
Entity Recognition (NER). Our study explores a three-phase training strategy
that harnesses GPT-4's capabilities to enhance the BERT model's performance on
NER. Initially, GPT-4 annotates a subset of the CONLL2003 and additional BBC
dataset without fine-tuning. We then train BERT using a mix of original and
LLM-annotated data, analyzing the efficacy of LLM annotations against
traditional methods. The second phase involves comparative experiments with
different training regimens, assessing the synergy between distilled and
original data. We observe that sequential strategies, particularly a simple mix
of training first with distilled data followed by original data, significantly
boost performance. In the third phase, we investigate various data blending
techniques, including sigmoid and power decay functions, to optimize the
training process further. Our results indicate that a strategic mix of
distilled and original data markedly elevates the NER capabilities of BERT. Our
approach presents a scalable methodology that reduces manual annotation costs
and increases efficiency, making it especially pertinent in resource-limited
and closed-network environments. The study concludes that while the 'Simple
Mix' strategy yields the best results, understanding its underlying mechanisms
requires further research. Future work will also focus on refining prompt
designs and enhancing annotation selection processes, aiming to extend our
methodology to diverse NLP tasks. | [
0.0596728474,
0.0276059546,
0.0271676928,
0.0273207147,
0.0082319705,
0.0529939421,
-0.0075195017,
-0.0046081338,
0.0141819194,
-0.0921645612,
-0.0101112742,
-0.020323338,
-0.0396216735,
-0.0124069443,
0.0346558578,
-0.02849379,
0.0203136429,
-0.0062737917,
0.0132576684,
0.0262041818,
0.0036605885,
0.0103812022,
0.0076375771,
0.011619892,
0.0098690353,
0.0201578252,
0.0063124555,
0.0385939181,
0.0272083711,
-0.0566472076,
0.0092683733,
0.0596321598,
0.0064247567,
0.0500229672,
0.0000020174,
-0.0713467896,
-0.0337319188,
0.0292621311,
-0.0460704826,
0.0411302857,
-0.009356291,
0.0023771969,
0.0133931246,
0.0218203403,
-0.0256705284,
-0.0327473134,
0.0269630458,
0.0644147024,
0.0640268177,
0.086603269,
0.002997471,
-0.0319570303,
0.0761578679,
-0.0288460758,
0.0000523316,
-0.0172014385,
0.0460907966,
-0.0076583931,
0.0066994266,
0.0220651031,
0.0209839586,
0.01752064,
-0.0147244623,
0.0209412239,
0.0324485376,
0.0668591037,
-0.0879150704,
0.0099278865,
-0.0203428436,
0.0494921356,
-0.0364194326,
0.0208706297,
0.0403333865,
-0.0056299469,
-0.0296945479,
-0.0403641351,
-0.0347605124,
-0.0099087832,
-0.0267947726,
0.0394097753,
0.0087416135,
-0.012542583,
0.0241899807,
0.0176137928,
-0.0261597689,
0.0190893058,
0.0253723208,
-0.0459335931,
0.0353017151,
0.0122801568,
-0.0436331853,
-0.0600979403,
0.0204368755,
0.0163272414,
0.0523708016,
0.0283364523,
0.0058041485,
0.007864912,
0.0077408138,
-0.0474920385,
-0.0045302077,
0.0314897522,
-0.0053470233,
0.0453570709,
-0.0562800653,
0.0127449175,
-0.0161924362,
0.0074019092,
0.009057641,
-0.0122323101,
-0.1099236757,
-0.0158077125,
-0.040445026,
0.0681715384,
-0.0310186259,
-0.0259641334,
-0.0389022045,
0.012130321,
0.0060806447,
-0.0026685265,
0.0707018971,
-0.0022626002,
-0.0067278701,
0.016961908,
-0.0413002856,
0.0466038249,
-0.0072239032,
-0.0205128193,
-0.011204618,
-0.0809881538,
-0.0032384139,
-0.0347918943,
0.0101446342,
-0.0656564683,
0.027314581,
0.0609488972,
0.0238825027,
-0.0884981751,
-0.0838363096,
0.0232133903,
-0.0201785304,
-0.0500229783,
0.0184029751,
-0.0299726371,
0.0215793084,
0.0054073585,
0.0230977964,
-0.0247950871,
0.0489684269,
-0.0101298038,
-0.0339273401,
0.1032684818,
-0.0431358181,
-0.0166510679,
0.0086520286,
-0.0011720887,
0.0115807159,
0.0918631926,
0.0462551974,
-0.0181386713,
0.0233020652,
-0.0038798542,
-0.0204919241,
0.0318282731,
0.0096874712,
0.0273707043,
0.003511376,
-0.0084664468,
-0.013280849,
0.0033572626,
0.0307602491,
0.0585702173,
-0.025899807,
0.0132977096,
0.0622806065,
0.0215527937,
0.0012434126,
0.0104651051,
0.0031761224,
0.0073569082,
0.0124428086,
-0.0133455591,
-0.0399769731,
-0.0316712297,
-0.0219583716,
0.0040658535,
0.0360865705,
0.0678286478,
-0.022600444,
0.0028244995,
-0.0296598449,
-0.0002163645,
0.0269100852,
-0.004860864,
0.0413485765,
-0.0163076278,
-0.0333323814,
0.0743800178,
0.0376579575,
-0.030530775,
0.0167412292,
-0.0281223468,
-0.0273256861,
0.0415309668,
0.0229884423,
-0.0425591618,
-0.0395133756,
-0.0413364954,
-0.027606966,
0.0397114232,
0.0107425265,
-0.0102288015,
0.0339758731,
-0.0479309261,
-0.0300145615,
-0.0178138427,
0.012749278,
0.0207567215,
0.0245177932,
0.0124988835,
0.0223032963,
-0.04421122,
-0.0373098031,
0.0420510732,
-0.0185789596,
-0.0794308633,
-0.0009771739,
0.0014974052,
0.0182620808,
0.0524840802,
-0.0155254183,
0.0026725079,
0.007669644,
-0.0413753465,
-0.0263926387,
-0.0089830747,
0.0123909218,
-0.0579383485,
0.0308678411,
0.0064815702,
0.0066169645,
0.0239525512,
-0.0425510071,
-0.0637161881,
-0.0744505897,
-0.0183185488,
0.0791176409,
-0.0477186181,
0.0217330027,
0.0188088026,
-0.0103650792,
-0.0400494337,
0.0594476275,
-0.0217953548,
0.0042443881,
-0.0057269232,
-0.0131576797,
0.01060546,
-0.0198894031,
-0.0620667525,
0.0278471597,
0.0323710032,
-0.0117337471,
0.0170117449,
-0.0073167626,
-0.0516346805,
-0.0140816523,
-0.1273838878,
0.0375790708,
-0.0280298907,
0.0553639755,
0.0153813502,
0.0373770557,
-0.0184714962,
-0.0076586823,
0.002095113,
-0.0516634583,
-0.0342060626,
0.0463850349,
0.0269633662,
0.0344994031,
-0.0210749377,
0.0001183965,
-0.0130064208,
-0.0403736494,
0.0306453239,
0.0113332281,
-0.0540360995,
-0.0592420474,
0.0036428934,
-0.0280666966,
0.0333706141,
0.0005051726,
0.0042502987,
-0.0023129412,
0.0197739825,
0.0271438845,
0.0041002734,
0.0057075522,
0.0114973569,
-0.0230229478,
-0.019641025,
-0.0368925892,
0.049117256,
-0.0176124796,
0.013774462,
-0.0360096917,
-0.0344576761,
0.0307129342,
0.0628670156,
-0.0466220938,
-0.0100551741,
-0.046571888,
-0.0212449282,
-0.0092666503,
-0.0101961419,
-0.0154770073,
0.0022623122,
-0.0303650126,
-0.0043086754,
-0.015239303,
-0.0348427445,
0.0504125878,
-0.0525106378,
-0.0140073961,
-0.0476993956,
0.0104389871,
-0.0453177653,
0.0550327599,
0.0139144156,
0.0061776387,
0.0171665307,
-0.056644883,
0.0101410272,
0.0200097859,
-0.0046069571,
-0.0260653272,
0.0561893769,
-0.0202230457,
0.0337954164,
-0.0091734082,
-0.0432843827,
-0.0291119404,
-0.0241883006,
-0.0428002067,
0.0453684963,
0.0247649625,
-0.0210808963,
0.0025192592,
0.0490875654,
-0.0129388114,
0.0583336391,
-0.0084021566,
-0.0067943907,
-0.0204571858,
0.0406069756,
0.0187345855,
-0.0040253745,
0.0112762917,
0.0063703135,
-0.0099760275,
-0.0029251182,
0.0388734713,
-0.0082805064,
-0.033335723,
0.0034987503,
0.0149739012,
-0.0867701173,
-0.0355644487,
-0.0089150192,
0.0622202419,
-0.0482654981,
0.002667228,
0.1260073036,
0.00672326,
-0.0175954755,
-0.0317673199,
0.0381464288,
0.0141469073,
0.0275408532,
0.0230339654,
-0.0750536546,
-0.0471410826,
0.0017090442,
0.0160556976,
0.0050955112,
-0.0738145187,
-0.0086034443,
-0.1404487193,
0.0129708741,
-0.0302384738,
-0.0287547894,
0.0117425015,
-0.0890382826,
-0.007231927,
-0.0405109376,
0.0085116848,
-0.0142020555,
-0.0431379043,
0.0040434417,
0.0559153035,
-0.016610384,
-0.0497178026,
0.0116897086,
-0.0525351986,
0.0612565316,
0.0540052205,
0.0371442884,
-0.0240512919,
-0.0209715851,
0.0406263359,
-0.0305308904,
-0.0094514098,
-0.0202373676,
0.0669159368,
-0.0559931584,
-0.0060061477,
-0.0012673165,
0.0009624217,
-0.0017130898,
-0.0093988776,
-0.0161343236,
0.0583412834,
0.0062304335,
0.0125393905,
0.0026803294,
-0.0365495831,
0.0285478309,
0.0874084532,
0.0163406488,
-0.0244794618,
-0.0457209721,
0.0180831943,
0.0062507754,
-0.0245244224,
0.0299526416,
0.0161392745,
-0.0516438521,
-0.0208063256,
-0.037245255,
-0.0425276384,
0.0446850173,
0.0233960971,
0.0358370207,
0.0456478558,
0.0239139423,
0.0385442227,
-0.050201349,
0.0666692853,
-0.0105134156,
0.0077198613,
-0.0460634194,
-0.0326185264,
0.0114650838,
0.0259817224,
-0.0454905853,
0.0036714748,
-0.0892032683,
-0.0629220009,
-0.0202176534,
0.0220210124,
0.0242358353,
0.0481696911,
0.0095712002,
-0.0471096933,
0.0220830683,
0.0322961025,
-0.0193670541,
-0.0299515259,
0.0198519733,
0.0450636037,
-0.0050264257,
0.0102138044,
-0.022269465,
0.0153724821,
0.0110514481,
0.0759416372,
-0.018979447,
0.012662923,
-0.0009578852,
0.0238007251,
0.0657501668,
-0.0410174839,
-0.0134656113,
-0.054719463,
0.0301070921,
0.0176602881,
0.0193770304,
-0.0464733168,
-0.0157054607,
0.0288392995,
0.0078641167,
-0.0262377523,
0.0549755506,
-0.0179499071,
0.0239951815,
-0.0825644806,
0.0051681213,
0.012598508,
-0.0029062405,
0.018534312,
-0.0283598993,
-0.0013268873,
0.045174405,
0.0556761324,
0.0210958272,
-0.0318768807,
0.0236257482,
0.0146297188,
0.0068751038,
-0.0006429909,
0.0334680378,
-0.071427308,
-0.0168117415,
-0.040394187,
0.0453344025,
0.0482395217,
-0.0276340991,
0.0753875077,
-0.0255355109,
-0.0220464971,
-0.003906271,
-0.0151864542,
-0.0075039901,
0.0121014975,
0.0293901227,
0.0276572723,
-0.0360260755,
-0.0056729806,
0.0757173672,
0.0381077789,
0.0727908239,
0.0048524723,
-0.0007722537,
-0.0351787731,
-0.0242264718,
0.0443118587,
0.0186841413,
-0.0251508094,
0.0036520264,
-0.0295513831,
-0.0427850597,
0.0100857532,
-0.0614339858,
-0.0111755012,
-0.0074930997,
0.0604975447,
0.011991486,
-0.0139945932,
-0.0465040579,
-0.028950667,
-0.0317295194,
0.0186224133,
-0.0173449963,
0.0186547711,
-6.814726461e-33,
-0.0096377637,
0.0074503589,
0.0269631986,
-0.0024511595,
-0.02295026,
0.0527862534,
0.0053434633,
-0.0370154269,
0.0003492943,
-0.0239538252,
-0.0183502175,
-0.0044379747,
0.0315236673,
0.0253516119,
-0.0129026724,
-0.0219217278,
0.0779461041,
0.0168723445,
-0.0186960977,
0.0177581832,
0.0273875743,
0.0744411275,
0.0695750862,
-0.0407966077,
0.0307651889,
0.0090458998,
-0.0053042383,
0.0172972996,
0.0625306517,
0.0483221784,
-0.0436838679,
0.0109269582,
0.0243555717,
-0.0692476183,
0.0101889567,
0.0268548466,
-0.109181352,
-0.0052132485,
0.0186962187,
-0.0054775551,
-0.0122296661,
-0.0080838026,
0.0208901633,
0.0038193678,
0.017920386,
0.0269378666,
0.0199030899,
-0.0002065438,
-0.0175906383,
-0.0545446761,
-0.0514342152,
0.0486898609,
0.011306298,
0.0097346818,
0.0491324477,
-0.0426658876,
0.0152494153,
0.0067432611,
-0.0685784593,
-0.0249859951,
0.0636356995,
0.0096547082,
0.0130959321,
0.057200484,
-0.000768636,
0.0564924739,
0.0064620734,
-0.0092788748,
-0.0294936281,
-0.0338839628,
0.014470825,
0.0603006259,
-0.022657983,
-0.0238742288,
0.0420089439,
-0.0110249417,
-0.0660929605,
0.0200469401,
0.046436891,
0.0202866495,
-0.0032078256,
0.0019121129,
-0.0498139635,
-0.021028094,
-0.0367949121,
-0.0253049601,
-0.0347453579,
-0.0028250983,
0.0365629941,
0.0216119234,
-0.0352541171,
0.0596632622,
0.024604192,
-0.034684401,
-0.0472003035,
0.0177817997,
0.0352699086,
0.0145942001,
-0.0047302237,
0.0200831369,
-0.063495487,
-0.048097156,
0.0140644135,
-0.0038609363,
-0.0010819612,
-0.032450296,
0.0406945497,
0.0067407358,
-0.0574994534,
-0.0017818459,
-0.0424946509,
0.0312961079,
-0.0312245134,
0.0438768975,
0.028959319,
0.0121190893,
0.0013234676,
0.0224916488,
0.064534992,
0.0025037818,
-0.0294538271,
0.0114571499,
0.0323669799,
0.0156126739,
0.0092870453,
0.0038366124,
0.0366240963,
0.0053327926,
-0.0019805534,
-0.0503441617,
-0.0202988666,
0.0035551414,
2.829e-7,
0.0481247306,
0.0472486652,
0.0193078276,
-0.0343838669,
-0.0071997754,
-0.0164501257,
-0.0033825152,
0.0251564365,
0.0062952391,
-0.0157775059,
-0.0252708439,
-0.00897625,
0.027694121,
0.0432364903,
-0.0902040228,
-0.056325119,
-0.037473429,
0.0017575548,
-0.0877660513,
0.0102846734,
0.0251084175,
0.0798417702,
0.0185837634,
-0.0337696038,
-0.0079449676,
-0.0301499832,
0.0671056286,
-0.0222731195,
0.0266068615,
0.0453937128,
0.0277935825,
0.0750632063,
0.0051012817,
0.0383824259,
-0.0197763629,
0.028625153,
0.0006058899,
0.0917062163,
-0.0239462983,
-0.0114376396,
0.0066563836,
-0.0256189741,
0.0010803101,
-0.0629342943,
0.0842458159,
-0.0327325687,
-0.0216027629,
0.0048662592,
-0.0299744383,
-0.0466395169,
0.0284843072,
-0.0155316917,
-0.0094823148,
0.0387862995,
0.0000997399,
-0.019512862,
-0.0385315642,
-0.0928181484,
0.0099191722,
0.0325392969,
-0.030582238,
-0.043825835,
-0.0431121029,
-0.0265690833,
0.0106431982,
-0.0714769885,
0.0165268201,
2.995978779e-34,
-0.0074444464,
0.0108493976,
0.0101168565,
0.0601927638,
0.0151964938,
0.0156201888,
-0.0234286506,
0.0093270084,
-0.0226200465,
-0.0785253644,
0.0057978923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09269v1 | Personalized Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T15:55:30 | 2024-02-14T15:55:30 | Stanisław Woźniak, Bartłomiej Koptyra, Arkadiusz Janz, Przemysław Kazienko, Jan Kocoń | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks in recent years. However, their universal nature poses
limitations in scenarios requiring personalized responses, such as
recommendation systems and chatbots. This paper investigates methods to
personalize LLMs, comparing fine-tuning and zero-shot reasoning approaches on
subjective tasks. Results demonstrate that personalized fine-tuning improves
model reasoning compared to non-personalized models. Experiments on datasets
for emotion recognition and hate speech detection show consistent performance
gains with personalized methods across different LLM architectures. These
findings underscore the importance of personalization for enhancing LLM
capabilities in subjective text perception tasks. | [
0.068652451,
0.0635497198,
-0.0150207961,
0.0447101444,
-0.0462699197,
0.0247419532,
0.0315965526,
0.0008352778,
0.0522388406,
-0.0884628817,
-0.0352692939,
-0.0118522821,
-0.0437303744,
0.010647756,
-0.014352479,
-0.0417070836,
0.0220682491,
-0.0134381829,
0.0522356778,
-0.0073082289,
0.022120228,
0.0344409496,
0.009190077,
0.0289019682,
-0.0023526852,
-0.0392692126,
0.0227837544,
0.0027864638,
-0.0070549422,
-0.0197349042,
0.0145307221,
0.0451943316,
-0.0090398602,
0.012983161,
0.0000019891,
-0.0358644128,
0.0027349787,
-0.0144278845,
-0.0301625114,
0.0016269822,
0.1235971972,
0.0463251993,
-0.0173976235,
0.0146500561,
-0.0302111264,
0.0190635007,
0.0391481444,
0.0864855349,
0.0515695699,
0.0713014156,
-0.017170243,
-0.0288638752,
-0.0204129666,
0.0206414461,
0.015943056,
-0.0182515178,
0.027313659,
-0.0199562516,
0.015591003,
-0.0134806866,
-0.0036911767,
-0.0053306855,
0.0073258383,
0.0256592464,
0.0213705935,
0.0099872397,
-0.0647862852,
-0.0150163444,
-0.0041110655,
0.075042285,
-0.0173077229,
-0.0221593492,
-0.0151464557,
-0.005916954,
-0.0140320864,
-0.0482606068,
-0.0437344424,
0.0192501638,
-0.0192894023,
0.0199370384,
-0.0234200303,
-0.0062880819,
0.0171941593,
0.0658801123,
-0.0469237901,
0.0821816176,
-0.0107687507,
-0.012939957,
0.0079667838,
-0.0000948509,
-0.0380583145,
-0.0226340163,
0.0128455786,
0.0271814279,
-0.0150140328,
0.0075099231,
-0.0440125391,
0.0172160342,
-0.0032560932,
-0.0841653422,
0.0249703415,
0.0464656316,
-0.0074411607,
0.0704821646,
-0.0185213815,
0.0228800233,
-0.0144667234,
0.0073191295,
-0.0267485753,
-0.0285754334,
-0.0602382943,
0.0095310863,
0.00611979,
0.0325133614,
-0.0238864236,
-0.023836337,
-0.039103169,
0.0358393453,
0.0021876702,
-0.0088010076,
0.0096764443,
0.0462839566,
0.0007473854,
-0.0363034979,
-0.0452235229,
0.020981878,
-0.0473768823,
0.021097634,
-0.0274028257,
-0.0554452091,
0.0070760716,
0.0208148435,
0.0222551003,
-0.0260994751,
0.0371815078,
0.0428986177,
0.0246983301,
-0.0459511243,
-0.0615659691,
-0.0174872801,
-0.0316404104,
-0.0979673117,
-0.0079678399,
-0.0628862604,
0.0043409397,
0.0253380481,
0.0065853237,
-0.0200682059,
0.0041805157,
0.010361406,
-0.0864100382,
0.0769341514,
0.0034727906,
-0.0245200451,
-0.0106872907,
0.0188669935,
0.0079018231,
0.0652338043,
0.0172492862,
0.0616442934,
0.040522173,
0.0210814811,
-0.0061743623,
0.0047990121,
-0.0312900208,
-0.0048324596,
-0.0584971309,
-0.0060481923,
-0.055051133,
0.0065669278,
0.0064587584,
0.0409296453,
-0.0426408276,
-0.0249082614,
0.0669013783,
0.0634064078,
-0.013444542,
0.0144575583,
-0.0024372863,
0.0244137868,
0.0182542,
-0.025779957,
-0.0390147306,
0.0245785061,
-0.0310211871,
-0.0404130556,
0.0205917265,
0.0175012145,
-0.0115835033,
-0.0569285564,
-0.0495976284,
-0.0222272314,
0.025381308,
0.0158757623,
0.0298017059,
-0.01857806,
-0.0289736241,
0.0024736852,
0.0449045934,
-0.0272099338,
-0.0362114832,
-0.0362556241,
0.0494870432,
0.134411186,
0.0433491953,
-0.015706161,
-0.0244660936,
-0.0256287754,
0.0012134972,
0.039954748,
0.0475889631,
0.0080937464,
-0.0011751995,
-0.0696890801,
-0.0101335729,
-0.0089205056,
0.0194518529,
0.0263709258,
0.0179262646,
0.0070253341,
0.0002104373,
-0.0038043687,
-0.0237591155,
0.0003201007,
0.0108413193,
-0.0548234321,
0.038603209,
0.0130360471,
0.0378872789,
0.0163394436,
0.0021716794,
-0.0198500678,
0.0028801754,
-0.0134100337,
-0.0420036837,
-0.0128750186,
-0.0007830071,
-0.0180967692,
0.0290597472,
0.0168125853,
0.0000044853,
0.0353267044,
-0.0169605147,
0.0048688808,
0.003487793,
0.0065549389,
0.0417116582,
-0.0313106403,
0.0161907859,
-0.0327723958,
0.0373879597,
-0.0474667624,
0.0369460769,
0.0249800719,
-0.0251014475,
0.0005703726,
-0.0016564167,
0.0178235471,
-0.0101629449,
-0.0711785555,
0.0303169936,
0.0381593443,
0.0101378085,
0.0291020684,
-0.0110953432,
-0.0457848385,
-0.0291314311,
-0.1288509369,
0.0271257591,
0.011775055,
-0.011874591,
-0.0103948778,
-0.0126557657,
-0.0112056378,
0.0112188384,
-0.0106873326,
-0.0169791766,
0.0016120352,
0.0451523848,
0.014170019,
-0.0224290062,
-0.0145934671,
-0.0327729806,
0.0006558715,
-0.0190235674,
0.0414585359,
-0.0089643281,
0.0399044342,
-0.0272070058,
-0.0191211589,
-0.0396671779,
0.0517731048,
0.0128946789,
-0.0487116314,
-0.0055071549,
-0.0102634793,
0.0166109763,
0.1267351955,
-0.0011978616,
0.0690936521,
0.0542621613,
0.0136621911,
-0.0647457689,
0.0169758052,
-0.0164873023,
0.0028357748,
-0.0237341728,
-0.01153359,
-0.038131237,
0.0654812306,
-0.0032084878,
0.0004553204,
-0.0676955804,
0.0748074129,
-0.0144435456,
-0.0013576213,
-0.0164696146,
-0.0130955866,
-0.0120591987,
0.0173733905,
-0.0111473287,
-0.0326759964,
0.063640058,
-0.0159526393,
0.0280191135,
-0.0540784411,
-0.0204076022,
-0.0335882343,
0.0536977611,
-0.0122965379,
0.0240613092,
0.0030837141,
0.0292416364,
-0.009067378,
-0.0210031755,
0.0104160849,
-0.036763411,
-0.0069686985,
-0.0210717879,
-0.0160768498,
0.0177161898,
-0.0328072794,
-0.0461572707,
-0.0648437887,
-0.0821628496,
-0.0099510541,
0.0257000886,
-0.0182470195,
-0.0355178528,
0.0081117153,
0.0038682099,
-0.022668967,
-0.0436490327,
-0.0120474678,
-0.0114690578,
-0.0281184092,
0.0436119772,
-0.0188353751,
0.0368462168,
0.0300492439,
0.0206353702,
0.0485009179,
0.0331485532,
0.0120779462,
-0.0333589762,
-0.0002481486,
0.0210225806,
-0.0160215739,
-0.0174434949,
-0.0071219918,
0.0305093676,
-0.0683628544,
0.0205518398,
0.1444399804,
0.0491072647,
-0.0436291099,
-0.001311647,
-0.0023916815,
0.003651289,
0.0310661569,
0.0283963792,
-0.0530033819,
-0.047052294,
0.0063577197,
0.0190032553,
-0.0437829718,
-0.0305379126,
-0.0117542818,
-0.1054015756,
0.023786528,
0.0188282132,
0.0052694366,
-0.0042149518,
-0.0280954801,
0.0034732174,
-0.0167487916,
0.0255605839,
-0.0325595811,
0.0103803826,
-0.0277570132,
0.0215616208,
-0.0135473851,
-0.0513116531,
0.0471242927,
-0.0187003668,
0.0724717453,
0.025644552,
0.0724553615,
0.0233128928,
-0.0125548309,
0.0637789667,
0.0462266058,
0.0198483858,
-0.0322696194,
0.0654016882,
-0.0150785083,
-0.0110195093,
-0.0306032635,
-0.0050762454,
-0.0167901069,
-0.0081303772,
-0.0178958625,
0.0583611429,
-0.008570686,
0.0022966033,
-0.0368035324,
0.0069108754,
-0.0418793932,
0.0808677375,
0.0017187799,
-0.0544506498,
-0.0564873368,
-0.0419715084,
-0.0607734509,
-0.0187666956,
-0.0653871745,
0.0062504406,
-0.0330319479,
-0.0215489548,
-0.0485306978,
-0.0327718817,
0.0338180773,
0.0143692689,
-0.0079992032,
0.022598004,
0.0119666718,
0.0054685697,
-0.0250764042,
0.0450915806,
-0.0480384901,
0.0106229717,
-0.0416366942,
0.0280193947,
0.0498710871,
-0.0629078075,
-0.0102097411,
-0.0068511935,
-0.0540655404,
-0.064239867,
-0.0085325995,
0.0242799036,
0.0159919411,
0.0654181987,
-0.0315817818,
-0.1182379052,
0.0094160922,
0.0453193337,
-0.0365289636,
-0.0099005764,
0.0422961377,
0.0532360598,
0.0041519138,
0.0317941122,
-0.0200081505,
0.0320684351,
0.027361935,
-0.0143201156,
0.0040113279,
-0.0406168588,
0.0126908775,
0.0315611884,
0.0579130985,
0.0385114029,
-0.0410915986,
-0.0033873196,
0.0210862961,
-0.0260661487,
-0.0419022627,
-0.0206021294,
-0.0131615466,
0.0078134146,
0.0026732089,
-0.074723132,
-0.0376707725,
-0.0165931825,
0.04520455,
-0.0244680457,
0.0108595621,
0.0047325785,
-0.0187815428,
0.0422517024,
0.0060286745,
-0.0320518985,
0.0237579234,
0.0050560017,
0.014234364,
-0.0138099436,
0.0468694121,
0.0122135207,
-0.0224074777,
-0.0555161946,
0.0119147357,
-0.0252322089,
-0.0652608275,
0.0200804863,
0.0421109907,
0.0185738448,
-0.0513038673,
0.0159964338,
-0.0327505693,
-0.0201825034,
-0.008126542,
-0.0034755031,
0.0037808886,
-0.0054990663,
-0.0045192922,
0.0244982038,
-0.0430623367,
0.009918726,
0.0419855006,
0.0174132902,
0.0416296422,
0.0043796306,
-0.0506030358,
-0.0398142301,
0.0064428779,
0.0367837623,
0.0329218581,
0.0281975511,
0.0364551619,
-0.056118343,
-0.0500197336,
0.0216150302,
-0.028974276,
-0.00812924,
-0.0324519463,
0.010976647,
0.0703529045,
-0.0318252854,
-0.0106350817,
-0.0421499684,
-0.011234385,
0.0009509654,
-0.0121799801,
0.0000105071,
-6.687910457e-33,
0.0136415428,
-0.0012553629,
-0.0035821302,
0.0176893622,
0.0004097945,
-0.0317540988,
0.0085540563,
0.0274476465,
-0.0048848889,
0.0052414224,
-0.0329740904,
0.0192724951,
0.0110783624,
0.0015436535,
-0.0059646764,
-0.0278641935,
0.0684572086,
-0.0039209672,
-0.0142988106,
-0.0104081826,
0.0441843197,
0.0261402484,
0.0487015545,
-0.0849685445,
0.0033246865,
0.0098364297,
-0.0092367865,
0.0168987755,
0.0037423936,
0.077899009,
-0.0109444084,
0.0438917801,
0.0228729583,
-0.0137340436,
0.0189541243,
0.0187355895,
-0.0365643874,
-0.0142449969,
0.026473457,
0.0391676873,
0.0066274949,
-0.0637433156,
0.0365173593,
0.0173344892,
-0.031585712,
0.0055922722,
0.0241485275,
-0.0502799191,
0.0027806386,
-0.0425548479,
-0.0339418203,
0.0253640637,
-0.0112838857,
-0.0229472872,
0.0273480322,
-0.0071907374,
-0.0326847993,
0.0750332326,
-0.0218383279,
0.0016810359,
0.0015466321,
-0.0069852443,
0.034152884,
-0.0090603745,
0.0016268479,
0.0740154833,
0.019444095,
0.0296466928,
-0.0400134623,
0.004535893,
0.0364308171,
0.0446710996,
0.0307854526,
0.0733409896,
0.0264625531,
-0.0058586807,
-0.0283950511,
-0.0161866713,
0.0507099777,
0.0236476436,
0.1031684056,
0.0344769731,
-0.0644003078,
-0.0127764829,
-0.0473308973,
-0.0211120099,
-0.0669381246,
-0.0177258551,
0.0311256163,
0.0072197588,
-0.0461207516,
-0.0494337827,
0.0288013052,
-0.0576435477,
-0.0241343062,
0.0382290147,
-0.0405183211,
0.0124273775,
-0.0028814892,
0.0275153816,
-0.0479151607,
-0.0034589577,
0.0202079881,
-0.0365127735,
0.0010637332,
-0.0020248431,
0.0372150019,
0.0139934449,
-0.0687696785,
-0.0109995212,
-0.0355973281,
0.0181319341,
0.0017216769,
0.0442448221,
0.0041514197,
0.0409118719,
-0.0226633325,
0.0873553976,
0.0120706651,
0.015853662,
-0.0229677036,
-0.0134807946,
-0.007724124,
-0.0173084568,
-0.0126545308,
-0.0264645535,
-0.0148664676,
-0.0192548539,
-0.0062978989,
-0.0724876076,
-0.0113725271,
0.0039318362,
2.756e-7,
-0.0045964541,
0.0933579281,
-0.0539260916,
0.0018466074,
0.0271291025,
0.0605920367,
0.0215308256,
-0.0044469838,
0.0248942822,
-0.0118687572,
-0.0083636018,
0.073814638,
0.0255022217,
0.0215351675,
-0.0705796182,
0.0044796085,
-0.023825014,
0.0173022524,
-0.0566669106,
0.0045907078,
0.0658275783,
0.1187950969,
0.0753227025,
0.0128654717,
0.0234931074,
-0.0185046103,
0.0391914546,
-0.0399139673,
-0.0157353226,
0.0274527725,
0.032685101,
0.0174844749,
0.0006671465,
0.0077059772,
0.0273015853,
0.0017640532,
0.0013487472,
0.0831957683,
0.0003858808,
-0.0415056609,
0.0139806736,
0.0066571878,
-0.0166552775,
-0.0495479479,
0.1116971597,
-0.0383622386,
-0.0509836525,
-0.0416607708,
0.013004439,
-0.0300232172,
0.0407798477,
-0.0325950533,
0.0005739549,
0.0021750375,
0.0046327556,
-0.03234585,
-0.0381603092,
-0.0997751951,
0.0003027316,
0.0042660157,
-0.0324786454,
-0.0241725482,
-0.020333929,
0.0032685068,
0.0689514279,
-0.047720395,
0.0194747318,
2.533580397e-34,
0.0352322049,
0.0204640012,
0.002507342,
0.0016612189,
0.04449277,
0.038268365,
-0.0314163342,
0.0052634003,
0.0553682074,
-0.0884435698,
0.010151119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09267v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09267v2 | Self-Alignment for Factuality: Mitigating Hallucinations in LLMs via Self-Evaluation | 2024-02-14T15:52:42 | 2024-06-11T12:22:14 | Xiaoying Zhang, Baolin Peng, Ye Tian, Jingyan Zhou, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite showing increasingly human-like abilities, large language models
(LLMs) often struggle with factual inaccuracies, i.e. "hallucinations", even
when they hold relevant knowledge. To address these hallucinations, current
approaches typically necessitate high-quality human factuality annotations. In
this work, we explore Self-Alignment for Factuality, where we leverage the
self-evaluation capability of an LLM to provide training signals that steer the
model towards factuality. Specifically, we incorporate Self-Eval, a
self-evaluation component, to prompt an LLM to validate the factuality of its
own generated responses solely based on its internal knowledge. Additionally,
we design Self-Knowledge Tuning (SK-Tuning) to augment the LLM's
self-evaluation ability by improving the model's confidence estimation and
calibration. We then utilize these self-annotated responses to fine-tune the
model via Direct Preference Optimization algorithm. We show that the proposed
self-alignment approach substantially enhances factual accuracy over Llama
family models across three key knowledge-intensive tasks on TruthfulQA and
BioGEN. | [
0.0441151559,
0.0391780995,
-0.0000803698,
0.0292413048,
-0.0238291696,
0.0055430559,
-0.0099524604,
-0.0306139421,
0.0091486117,
-0.0539554246,
-0.0591957532,
0.0093570026,
-0.0060066893,
-0.0114863236,
0.0188199356,
0.0114885513,
0.0765053183,
-0.0113801938,
0.0166993253,
-0.0275221802,
-0.0030719992,
0.0158960484,
-0.0210509412,
0.0090741804,
-0.0356169119,
-0.0477007292,
0.0138874771,
-0.0156913977,
0.0097906748,
-0.0223796275,
0.0273368154,
0.0680280402,
-0.0018653153,
0.0620142892,
0.0000018712,
-0.069483377,
-0.0179333687,
-0.0057618851,
-0.0688638464,
0.0381559059,
0.0387059934,
0.0337868631,
-0.0117057571,
0.0041601886,
-0.0458803512,
0.0352522433,
0.0507164598,
0.0383797623,
0.0721957535,
0.0814847574,
0.0197648779,
-0.0136780255,
0.0173170026,
-0.0091836993,
0.0139365112,
0.0047193896,
0.0168332979,
0.0226862933,
-0.0356737114,
-0.0012161552,
0.0021917061,
0.052402094,
-0.0074258293,
-0.0253361482,
0.0714484081,
0.0150387334,
-0.0185642783,
-0.0412803069,
0.014540527,
0.0435999371,
0.0388386138,
-0.0615263805,
-0.0135840653,
-0.0183554906,
0.0080951201,
0.0080341985,
0.0038436383,
0.00913502,
0.0000535397,
0.0399725437,
0.0278931893,
0.0197575502,
0.032041356,
0.0253994148,
-0.0125740143,
0.105803661,
-0.0049945056,
-0.04181467,
-0.0024149963,
0.0185029916,
0.0401448086,
-0.0704627112,
0.0040845606,
0.0256436951,
-0.0328046009,
0.0180724431,
-0.0287387185,
0.0093341889,
0.06367708,
-0.0886405632,
0.0107009551,
0.0178303532,
-0.0325535536,
0.0209302995,
0.0056159748,
0.0428829789,
0.0013909967,
0.0432033129,
-0.0233805738,
0.0163828544,
-0.0323274806,
-0.0076860976,
0.0048052245,
0.0142459003,
0.0136354817,
0.0368679203,
-0.0646257773,
-0.0024824759,
-0.0197276864,
0.0193758663,
-0.0083673792,
0.0281531494,
-0.0310744066,
-0.0164445452,
-0.0836756453,
0.0550343879,
-0.0142998397,
0.001568745,
-0.0063695577,
-0.0509588532,
-0.0173852239,
-0.0017183424,
-0.0233409274,
-0.0222898461,
0.012480272,
0.0369197242,
-0.0072778556,
-0.0191536658,
-0.0231731459,
-0.0157165304,
-0.0568478294,
-0.0743026808,
-0.0391737334,
-0.0462632403,
0.0032407283,
-0.0201895479,
-0.00384901,
-0.0438982174,
0.0269334391,
-0.0035583831,
-0.0081673507,
0.0852909908,
-0.0383697636,
-0.0047177467,
0.0443250723,
-0.0062872656,
0.0143705625,
0.055576615,
0.0457664728,
0.0119067794,
0.041969575,
-0.0093782581,
0.0254416615,
0.0004069012,
0.0148603525,
-0.0316217989,
-0.0075324229,
0.0143649848,
-0.0341293886,
0.0695755184,
0.0627044812,
0.0369687229,
0.0146877356,
-0.0267512463,
0.09438546,
0.0133153303,
0.0185067318,
0.0199710671,
0.0194047354,
0.0181273874,
0.0234096535,
0.0526913293,
-0.056146156,
0.0584904142,
-0.0331969,
0.0106277401,
0.0431046337,
0.017654229,
0.0049974164,
-0.0909917653,
-0.028502794,
0.0003963971,
-0.0223990958,
0.0116974758,
0.0100096278,
0.0192583948,
0.0072985888,
0.0236188583,
0.0311886314,
-0.0585481487,
-0.0016080322,
-0.0621845387,
0.0581741221,
0.0861084387,
0.0503704511,
-0.0235726945,
-0.0555317216,
-0.0093663773,
-0.0500212573,
0.0726988092,
0.0633758008,
-0.0161062814,
-0.022729462,
-0.029110359,
-0.007354992,
-0.028393019,
0.0374730937,
-0.0163343176,
-0.0143923732,
-0.012461965,
0.002414743,
-0.042503994,
-0.0368635654,
0.0548554361,
-0.0173093975,
-0.0430639349,
0.0165963303,
-0.003360711,
0.0318935104,
0.0251755863,
-0.0127023719,
0.0510343015,
0.019530464,
0.0078280969,
-0.037895944,
-0.0012013654,
-0.034438435,
-0.027833296,
0.0679857507,
0.0118774762,
-0.0334794,
0.0062926216,
-0.0164475758,
-0.0314358138,
-0.0112788724,
-0.0538941361,
-0.0003184111,
-0.0662924349,
0.0286072474,
0.0088295862,
0.0346583202,
-0.017810924,
0.0537519716,
-0.0019172111,
-0.016722599,
-0.0195630006,
-0.0285541639,
0.0055187624,
-0.0465528779,
-0.0027518638,
-0.0272324495,
0.0159240924,
0.027582014,
0.0337044597,
-0.0064766356,
-0.0646580607,
-0.0081993425,
-0.0786257163,
0.0067935707,
-0.0153561085,
0.0236707665,
0.0179748554,
-0.0320741385,
0.0014797855,
-0.0145054841,
-0.0417758897,
-0.0168726444,
-0.0021629571,
0.0007842169,
0.0685988814,
-0.0137893297,
0.0097571854,
-0.0563067235,
0.0235509165,
-0.0426834524,
0.0149060292,
0.0120928306,
0.0080870027,
-0.0545431413,
0.0095954109,
-0.0849698037,
0.0214897003,
0.0177955963,
-0.0385905579,
0.022705745,
0.0470382385,
0.0153880175,
0.0512430109,
0.0311059989,
0.0044373549,
0.1003427655,
0.0201014373,
-0.0676275715,
0.0198062528,
0.0015202772,
0.0079570021,
-0.0164825413,
-0.0166519135,
0.0167545285,
0.0658900142,
0.0154676046,
-0.0255145431,
-0.0392818823,
0.03237468,
-0.0230764747,
-0.0708039999,
0.0166798588,
-0.0040151253,
-0.0291562993,
0.0504237115,
-0.0144755468,
-0.0666679889,
0.1167944372,
-0.0532912388,
0.0121861883,
-0.0264849737,
-0.0052573546,
-0.0108373621,
0.0277808011,
-0.0120823001,
0.0051550134,
0.0397316962,
0.0220601577,
-0.0380346738,
-0.0194088463,
0.0277239066,
-0.0595952608,
0.0673978776,
-0.0423634909,
0.0204950497,
0.0376337618,
-0.0402516648,
-0.0648890287,
-0.0357759222,
-0.0261699781,
-0.0277445242,
-0.0252933931,
-0.0090706451,
-0.0313525163,
-0.0352290608,
0.0283393227,
0.0215353891,
-0.0181751903,
-0.0185458306,
0.007721209,
0.0032003028,
0.0762145817,
0.0487414114,
0.0798713863,
0.0127786035,
0.0442075916,
0.0512505919,
0.0080143521,
0.0060971342,
-0.010911867,
-0.0152553841,
0.005729598,
-0.0463307798,
-0.0081877923,
0.0119456798,
0.0671567172,
-0.0518270805,
-0.0210121702,
0.1377604455,
0.0263447408,
-0.016203111,
0.0161668845,
-0.0594939776,
0.0049858517,
0.0257692263,
0.0470644906,
-0.0690105706,
-0.0132331261,
-0.0211793911,
0.0258666426,
-0.0256398581,
-0.0240139514,
-0.0200336911,
-0.0970475823,
0.0429010727,
0.0248635504,
-0.0046582404,
-0.0181207433,
-0.0239192694,
0.0028933811,
-0.0460421145,
0.0395979211,
0.0136055136,
0.0064356448,
0.004109256,
0.0231773481,
-0.0478992648,
-0.0424269475,
0.0504242778,
-0.0267194472,
0.1033088639,
0.0652906001,
0.0386769883,
0.0003109406,
-0.064697355,
-0.0105601996,
-0.0177368596,
-0.0025432697,
-0.0072001144,
0.0462474898,
-0.031775333,
-0.0007680826,
-0.0215062946,
0.0079524415,
0.0034637391,
-0.0112950793,
-0.0219940133,
0.0634779036,
-0.0338052064,
-0.0374150388,
-0.017169809,
0.0215349067,
-0.0089001972,
0.0823562667,
0.0241225399,
-0.0230497867,
-0.0208341852,
-0.0329027325,
0.0116458265,
-0.0262477286,
-0.0719211623,
0.0391335674,
0.0076727341,
-0.032876052,
-0.0968823284,
-0.0429282933,
0.0031591328,
0.0045241858,
-0.0096359625,
0.007370533,
0.0219687503,
-0.0253989678,
-0.0185191743,
0.014152783,
-0.0524517037,
0.0040181796,
-0.0119534275,
-0.0067819185,
0.0641448498,
-0.0173032563,
0.0179355126,
0.0372560993,
-0.0475762114,
-0.0845231637,
0.0117254118,
0.0630845279,
0.0240164082,
0.0557473637,
-0.0198505986,
-0.0696582273,
0.057085488,
0.0580024049,
-0.0588499866,
0.0028702379,
0.0276153684,
0.0124420496,
-0.0244729966,
0.0566793308,
-0.0109437155,
0.0187896807,
-0.0149895065,
0.0527805053,
-0.0251353085,
-0.0706072971,
0.0700220764,
0.0156941917,
0.0378653705,
-0.050473921,
0.0139779681,
-0.0419787355,
-0.0020780771,
-0.0270126797,
-0.0406664461,
-0.0054250564,
-0.0051684077,
0.0119343139,
-0.007125332,
-0.006609723,
-0.0404145755,
-0.0759482682,
-0.0057537844,
-0.0224392246,
-0.0187056065,
0.0154103674,
0.0068850322,
-0.0234257355,
-0.0153670944,
-0.0179564189,
0.0154060973,
0.0191367883,
0.0364362001,
0.0129774483,
0.0343633592,
-0.0039352761,
0.019335404,
-0.0077884812,
0.0144854048,
-0.0370870382,
0.0111504132,
-0.0441574864,
0.0242546909,
0.0467152856,
0.0097428476,
0.0640718937,
-0.0179710723,
-0.0113199549,
-0.0148091102,
0.0248165447,
-0.0199482925,
0.0183906481,
0.012491148,
0.0121627683,
-0.048791904,
-0.0330339223,
0.0342591889,
-0.0075619067,
0.0624223202,
-0.0181369614,
-0.0204006415,
-0.0552192256,
-0.0736980587,
-0.0594283901,
-0.0268276073,
-0.0359824784,
-0.0173490904,
-0.0741777048,
-0.0881212875,
0.0293843169,
0.0466681421,
-0.0096533885,
-0.0349440388,
0.0217345245,
0.0619953834,
-0.0169848911,
-0.0284479726,
-0.0395424515,
0.0107321665,
0.0177285429,
-0.0007156061,
-0.0000769169,
-6.721539881e-33,
-0.0345664993,
-0.0492863804,
0.0423714556,
-0.0168416779,
-0.0067564854,
-0.0035305014,
-0.0049734223,
0.0343029611,
-0.025717143,
0.0388030894,
-0.0111212153,
0.0167021994,
0.0130630583,
-0.0139175393,
0.0327508263,
0.004906937,
0.0500301383,
-0.0344852321,
-0.0423850156,
-0.0155762117,
-0.0047839861,
0.0118593248,
0.0713673905,
-0.0569518395,
0.0615997165,
0.0213188175,
-0.0446971953,
0.0395315699,
-0.0704489499,
0.0634690598,
-0.0405365974,
0.0413900688,
0.0213544574,
-0.0244979765,
-0.0146959117,
-0.0259227268,
-0.054405652,
-0.0417926647,
0.0360513367,
-0.0189424623,
-0.0434857942,
-0.0324268043,
0.0686742887,
-0.0118710902,
-0.0570644401,
0.0110590653,
0.0270032138,
-0.0316909552,
0.0078337155,
0.0205662772,
-0.0455342978,
0.0096566333,
0.0047985958,
-0.0312815048,
0.0048875539,
-0.0037021951,
0.0039818161,
-0.0262018405,
-0.0784107223,
0.0245923121,
-0.0012443765,
0.0408727191,
0.0920086056,
-0.0196647272,
-0.0110268788,
0.0509612598,
0.0114348466,
-0.0049963081,
-0.0457878523,
-0.0103408284,
0.0139010474,
0.0380193964,
0.0409207121,
0.0739822313,
-0.0027607817,
-0.0021304316,
-0.0475750118,
0.0414201915,
0.0061825193,
0.0029078368,
-0.002164793,
0.0075441655,
-0.0379448757,
0.0062977499,
-0.0309912246,
-0.002605763,
-0.0284657143,
-0.0163289942,
0.00012259,
-0.0106874481,
-0.0334620774,
-0.0056539378,
-0.0189006403,
-0.0197198223,
-0.0103515051,
-0.0293727163,
-0.0164070614,
-0.0037642275,
0.0231947862,
0.0118081365,
-0.0345950536,
0.027857177,
0.0061446792,
0.0219497774,
0.0254139043,
0.0146071957,
0.0285953488,
0.0112143969,
-0.0813777894,
0.0278655905,
-0.0295146815,
0.0107623003,
0.004874222,
-0.0321772248,
0.0100496393,
0.0031888504,
-0.0284876246,
0.0354898572,
0.0130588161,
0.0396346524,
-0.0374693573,
0.0161660481,
0.0042024036,
0.0212668162,
-0.0267834831,
0.0086102616,
-0.0017466055,
0.0171606708,
-0.0097584706,
-0.0364062116,
-0.0171672106,
-0.0009447525,
2.693e-7,
0.0496011712,
0.0695880279,
0.0204179715,
0.0087513914,
0.0252000093,
0.0703664422,
-0.021301372,
0.0249798968,
0.0025878288,
-0.0721246898,
0.0214407183,
0.0137193548,
0.0356546678,
0.0385362022,
-0.0418918878,
-0.0019155242,
-0.0558951348,
0.0355210155,
-0.0247428697,
-0.0396943614,
0.0164240282,
0.085925363,
0.0350201651,
-0.0184979104,
-0.0137111312,
-0.0047521172,
0.0638918504,
0.006992836,
-0.0352482535,
0.0477097593,
0.0679624826,
0.00497308,
-0.0066534649,
0.0085088061,
-0.0153749827,
-0.0012088721,
-0.0243702698,
0.0614010617,
-0.013172105,
-0.0553218387,
-0.0095394859,
0.0253959391,
0.0232679956,
-0.0648299232,
0.0392138064,
-0.0016919581,
-0.0377813317,
-0.0630930588,
0.0130248014,
0.0279991198,
0.0480443984,
-0.0211548153,
-0.0324229077,
0.0313796625,
0.0202209316,
0.0424579494,
-0.0503459089,
-0.0421630628,
-0.0667459741,
-0.008752808,
-0.0441471487,
-0.026495751,
-0.0085538849,
0.0004389507,
-0.0031680127,
-0.076886043,
0.0344166905,
2.035980322e-34,
0.0272235703,
0.0100853052,
0.0125062596,
-0.0029660892,
0.0228319336,
0.0166170355,
0.0001553248,
0.0166295096,
0.026482705,
-0.035372626,
-0.0103508122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09259v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09259v2 | SyntaxShap: Syntax-aware Explainability Method for Text Generation | 2024-02-14T15:45:56 | 2024-06-03T10:30:00 | Kenza Amara, Rita Sevastjanova, Mennatallah El-Assady | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To harness the power of large language models in safety-critical domains, we
need to ensure the explainability of their predictions. However, despite the
significant attention to model interpretability, there remains an unexplored
domain in explaining sequence-to-sequence tasks using methods tailored for
textual data. This paper introduces SyntaxShap, a local, model-agnostic
explainability method for text generation that takes into consideration the
syntax in the text data. The presented work extends Shapley values to account
for parsing-based syntactic dependencies. Taking a game theoric approach,
SyntaxShap only considers coalitions constraint by the dependency tree. We
adopt a model-based evaluation to compare SyntaxShap and its weighted form to
state-of-the-art explainability methods adapted to text generation tasks, using
diverse metrics including faithfulness, coherency, and semantic alignment of
the explanations to the model. We show that our syntax-aware method produces
explanations that help build more faithful and coherent explanations for
predictions by autoregressive models. Confronted with the misalignment of human
and AI model reasoning, this paper also highlights the need for cautious
evaluation strategies in explainable AI. | [
-0.0064515024,
0.0706411377,
-0.0163317174,
0.0072202655,
-0.013943702,
0.016582815,
0.0112306187,
-0.0142552136,
-0.0362892002,
-0.0089763412,
0.0496141985,
-0.0133355353,
0.0247699469,
0.0787020698,
0.0384972915,
-0.0584753193,
0.0133547541,
-0.0319092534,
0.0133290524,
0.0417951085,
0.0148275085,
0.0252077375,
-0.015377203,
0.087162286,
-0.0032346549,
-0.0081070364,
-0.0529921241,
0.007621611,
0.0192500483,
-0.0008528063,
-0.0264654756,
0.0270723738,
0.0266541969,
0.0150984898,
0.0000020075,
-0.0164421685,
-0.0343857482,
0.0185695142,
-0.050584957,
-0.0066590053,
-0.0297601111,
-0.0235406123,
0.0219978038,
0.0187432505,
-0.0245796014,
0.0550932251,
0.0533170998,
0.0161571167,
0.0842215419,
0.0723343492,
-0.0004024383,
-0.0277042929,
0.0054401024,
-0.0045630136,
0.0161186978,
-0.0109615885,
-0.0368669294,
0.0322660431,
-0.0161648598,
-0.0189290103,
0.0190458577,
0.0047579082,
0.0370652005,
-0.0561380945,
0.0443326496,
0.0149492361,
0.0073057413,
-0.0378751904,
0.004930154,
0.0451808646,
-0.0163616259,
-0.0522341244,
0.0322774127,
-0.0413441099,
-0.0175029784,
0.0183557477,
-0.0393401906,
0.0356386453,
0.0267252214,
0.0225161463,
0.0358648226,
0.0374884978,
0.0769460052,
0.002059326,
-0.0045586745,
0.0696739554,
-0.0187735073,
0.0158912782,
-0.0472398326,
0.0046818317,
-0.0512411632,
-0.0833718255,
-0.0234838333,
0.0507008769,
-0.0891356841,
0.0261567961,
-0.0241756588,
-0.0121942153,
0.0027344332,
-0.0183957871,
0.0566437505,
0.0233984143,
0.0139197009,
-0.0030881411,
-0.0129704298,
0.0666728765,
0.0117884679,
-0.0317375027,
-0.0132161267,
0.0216591619,
-0.0741948485,
-0.0293853078,
-0.0061062956,
-0.0164024625,
-0.0354018323,
0.0004335806,
-0.0175722726,
0.019147383,
-0.0250038579,
0.0384165086,
0.018968273,
0.0121148303,
-0.0579946563,
-0.0199538805,
-0.0148185305,
-0.0415126942,
-0.0562158264,
-0.0146542322,
0.0494208708,
-0.0400152579,
-0.0307479259,
0.0484844223,
-0.0184325781,
-0.0147556989,
-0.0356574394,
0.0861192942,
-0.0052389605,
-0.0049034511,
-0.0120889051,
-0.0903285518,
-0.0309887305,
-0.0550930649,
-0.0232894942,
-0.0270369295,
-0.0127453171,
0.013131991,
-0.0193651989,
-0.0611397102,
0.0072535747,
-0.0126395598,
-0.0080651361,
0.0487675555,
-0.0264626052,
0.0021039536,
-0.0390314721,
0.0007286615,
-0.0303144846,
0.032453157,
0.0685760826,
0.0414138436,
0.0195167121,
-0.0150415143,
0.0276727844,
-0.0415737629,
0.0250511393,
-0.0047439071,
-0.0416873917,
-0.0003243812,
-0.0529781505,
0.0306345336,
0.025996957,
0.019222457,
0.0059668315,
0.0093090599,
0.0253582243,
-0.0145383626,
0.0380399935,
0.0345883816,
0.0884560719,
0.0107092615,
-0.0465439335,
0.0407497436,
-0.0321854725,
0.0450076014,
-0.0102401637,
0.0357211493,
-0.0015725354,
0.0163121615,
0.0031876406,
-0.0841888189,
-0.0171279721,
-0.0122179938,
-0.0020144917,
-0.0100094872,
0.007478511,
0.0029746471,
-0.039662037,
0.038185358,
0.0041385805,
-0.073880069,
0.0021352342,
-0.0591414459,
0.0346081294,
0.0751311257,
0.0441586673,
-0.0168333016,
-0.0429439954,
-0.0120858867,
-0.0127532342,
0.0422826037,
-0.0249542426,
0.008686712,
0.0412874296,
-0.0382045768,
-0.0233622752,
-0.0506436266,
0.0285001006,
0.011248813,
-0.016541779,
-0.0488511175,
0.0483750477,
-0.0365292318,
-0.0771553963,
0.0471071601,
-0.0488082021,
-0.0098438831,
-0.0215125177,
0.0008935939,
0.0388734378,
0.0237351283,
-0.0160778165,
0.0384016894,
0.0112653691,
-0.0123834349,
-0.0071478514,
0.0510446727,
-0.0548039488,
0.0049016154,
-0.012117316,
-0.0275236275,
0.017687574,
0.0124049839,
-0.0194558073,
-0.0785920843,
0.009440966,
-0.0750353262,
0.0164293963,
-0.0050223605,
0.0195897147,
0.0088908467,
-0.0052963123,
-0.0222013667,
0.0603924766,
-0.0029752322,
-0.0051508723,
-0.0130586065,
0.0024389867,
0.0351426341,
-0.0068402044,
0.0300349463,
0.0092591848,
-0.0128062908,
-0.0212120246,
0.0501229279,
0.0052147424,
-0.0207553897,
-0.0235312618,
-0.0152223893,
-0.0080230748,
-0.043516662,
0.0143293589,
0.0502650738,
-0.0088599958,
0.0238606986,
0.0153306713,
-0.0467116013,
0.0332049765,
0.0239830166,
-0.0107214432,
0.0683108047,
-0.0001082665,
-0.0517747477,
-0.0500730649,
-0.0027975307,
-0.0192181934,
0.094119668,
0.0383750312,
0.0004441475,
-0.066703774,
0.0437526293,
-0.0349173434,
-0.0393059812,
-0.0063877269,
-0.0667238832,
0.0466944501,
0.019188026,
-0.0045809257,
0.0238196515,
-0.0050088563,
0.0664078519,
0.0420051254,
0.0052571497,
-0.0245693866,
-0.0160649456,
-0.0115926983,
0.0256840345,
-0.0058323224,
-0.0760736763,
0.0187914446,
0.0977895856,
-0.0163932778,
-0.0010584451,
-0.075217694,
0.032207422,
0.0014707587,
-0.0332065858,
0.0002849028,
-0.0740487501,
0.0095355697,
0.0603942685,
-0.0174532086,
-0.0809016824,
0.0684865117,
-0.0661601871,
0.0071125929,
0.0113987066,
-0.0182089508,
-0.0362517014,
0.0899820849,
0.0264616478,
0.023188604,
0.0327255093,
-0.0059263408,
-0.039292939,
-0.0217101611,
0.0419748612,
0.0297060777,
0.0104127815,
-0.0668907687,
-0.0016335039,
0.0333767533,
-0.0032080209,
-0.0282145329,
-0.0447949879,
-0.0093375808,
0.0238308217,
0.0579857193,
-0.0551543497,
-0.010483047,
0.02916128,
0.0540893078,
-0.0044899164,
-0.0093728621,
-0.0156826898,
-0.0327126384,
-0.0136485603,
0.0418417826,
0.0160517264,
0.0598224588,
-0.0395424925,
0.0370787755,
0.0117617585,
0.0315314084,
0.0253409669,
-0.0613318533,
0.0193687864,
-0.0332045332,
-0.0232109129,
-0.0586792715,
0.0365244336,
0.0623161122,
-0.0495664701,
-0.0108820712,
0.1020872071,
0.0226433724,
0.0195149239,
0.0517589375,
-0.0101198023,
0.0664473325,
-0.0004656035,
0.010225635,
-0.0032286183,
-0.0146791525,
0.012741873,
0.0354250148,
-0.0160840955,
-0.0406722352,
-0.0053016189,
-0.0319042169,
0.0282426607,
0.0040346403,
-0.0219127238,
-0.0183230229,
-0.0435140021,
-0.0463670865,
-0.0169645566,
-0.0018089052,
0.0269467477,
0.0041082357,
0.0377333015,
0.0488706827,
-0.0390543453,
-0.0186292082,
-0.0035119283,
-0.0129303401,
0.0600671358,
0.1038432121,
0.0454493426,
0.0230908096,
-0.0113786273,
-0.0271210615,
0.0097574443,
0.0478659235,
-0.0043140673,
0.0500618294,
0.0392005555,
-0.0081843268,
-0.02209609,
0.0274358373,
-0.0340626575,
-0.0308661107,
-0.034222357,
0.0349047929,
-0.0257325955,
-0.0186760314,
0.0040279636,
0.0035677138,
0.0151540814,
0.0719786733,
0.064137049,
0.0111179808,
-0.0708199739,
-0.0426818803,
0.0087705795,
-0.0958680436,
0.0063678431,
-0.0009739279,
0.0242636986,
-0.0516166538,
-0.0782171637,
-0.0436902344,
-0.0169288162,
0.0449590161,
-0.0223887451,
-0.0194902364,
0.0037274782,
-0.0142941214,
-0.0173208565,
0.0142709063,
0.0275033787,
0.0129988063,
-0.0200420264,
-0.0107790474,
-0.030020725,
-0.0423286296,
-0.0153094213,
0.0017200892,
-0.0318541527,
-0.0365941711,
0.0040507885,
0.0424923971,
0.0332114212,
0.0236989446,
-0.0083353492,
-0.0630993247,
-0.0029005094,
0.0215780158,
-0.0323799588,
-0.0049789357,
0.0395400673,
-0.0236569531,
0.024196865,
0.051484637,
-0.0321458243,
-0.0219396949,
-0.0045415964,
0.0408410281,
-0.0212654006,
0.0022366617,
0.0294847749,
0.0189675428,
0.0046989284,
-0.0323307626,
-0.0226848014,
-0.0081496406,
-0.0128244888,
-0.0440328717,
-0.0155612584,
-0.0676492304,
0.0558103621,
0.0001491647,
-0.0076744445,
0.0238629971,
-0.026131615,
-0.0285666287,
-0.0017170364,
0.0027877912,
0.024109792,
-0.0095487516,
0.0328961052,
0.0165558886,
0.0070144054,
-0.0113932891,
0.0147915082,
-0.0440050438,
0.0307091773,
0.0217164177,
0.0402189083,
0.0195810124,
0.0179332998,
-0.0080179824,
0.0314078517,
-0.0756179616,
-0.0225399043,
-0.0083807521,
-0.0275071785,
0.0433449112,
-0.0031895747,
0.0983234718,
-0.0274050348,
0.0334185772,
0.0175971836,
0.1030562147,
0.0471102558,
-0.0491573922,
-0.0251566544,
0.013580827,
-0.0573531128,
-0.0304983538,
0.1105172038,
0.0536362454,
0.001719492,
0.001179336,
-0.036032889,
-0.0127337463,
-0.0558111966,
-0.0148515347,
0.0404334441,
-0.0098055974,
-0.0057882178,
-0.0303514525,
-0.0563883446,
-0.0168658216,
0.0344901346,
0.0113825398,
-0.0090288417,
0.0110920146,
0.0695096478,
-0.0141354753,
-0.0428986959,
-0.0631897151,
0.0124979885,
-0.0155192763,
0.0277111344,
-0.012441677,
-6.196295944e-33,
-0.0248960033,
-0.0877951384,
0.004214114,
-0.0345664956,
-0.0093121845,
0.0079947263,
-0.0866592228,
0.0048344638,
0.0088118203,
0.0280998461,
0.0272952281,
0.0461426191,
0.0042266822,
0.0258991215,
0.0080978228,
-0.0225319415,
0.0367779694,
0.0410533845,
-0.0304391868,
0.0466984101,
0.0640176982,
0.0058115544,
0.0211161971,
-0.0313180722,
0.0657932833,
-0.0043230746,
-0.0302516669,
-0.0005914197,
-0.030209057,
0.044037886,
-0.0081245983,
-0.0117790652,
0.0178431161,
-0.0235057846,
-0.0186389517,
-0.0219772495,
0.0093391258,
-0.0062915809,
0.020069791,
-0.0125702135,
-0.0541523919,
-0.0500407368,
0.0292721502,
-0.0029304586,
-0.0046760482,
-0.0164643638,
0.0185405128,
-0.0142092798,
-0.006869318,
0.0074178302,
-0.0409760326,
0.0323935859,
-0.0485815071,
-0.0332496725,
0.015687393,
0.0469041653,
0.0189225674,
-0.0046918774,
-0.0079065859,
-0.0129332207,
0.0127194719,
0.0321726613,
0.0914306492,
0.0048519294,
-0.0254744515,
0.0586111024,
-0.0051740897,
-0.0016762789,
-0.0692649111,
0.0403149351,
-0.050201524,
0.093950063,
0.0817231759,
0.0233961903,
-0.0109275244,
0.0215363223,
-0.0889559686,
0.0407168604,
-0.0077586928,
0.0438939296,
0.0371748358,
0.0064401557,
-0.0604447015,
-0.0207231492,
-0.0224479958,
-0.0188761167,
-0.0096365744,
-0.0462376289,
0.0061413152,
-0.0342120863,
-0.0481414497,
-0.0008339643,
-0.0042641992,
-0.0139743993,
0.0294043198,
0.0289295986,
-0.0395928025,
-0.0028869631,
0.0045317281,
0.0150907803,
-0.0011453778,
-0.0017426558,
0.011307993,
0.0143861584,
0.0582187027,
0.0040887659,
0.0192493275,
0.0310707893,
0.0027317028,
0.0007078837,
-0.0743087009,
0.0049112956,
-0.0136055462,
-0.0162186511,
0.0237279832,
-0.0038247933,
-0.0471879244,
0.0260630734,
0.0004265851,
-0.0044996976,
0.0173604973,
-0.002671045,
-0.0300237127,
0.0124718817,
-0.0194027591,
-0.0392167941,
-0.0461272858,
0.0093836179,
0.0345706642,
-0.0353796668,
-0.0383628905,
0.0056382343,
2.7e-7,
0.037216872,
0.046296306,
0.0280470774,
0.0388111211,
0.0131128374,
0.0559801273,
-0.004135076,
-0.0078704329,
-0.0604245588,
-0.0258731041,
0.0099919336,
-0.0007865885,
0.085106723,
0.039773576,
0.0247339327,
-0.0210391544,
-0.1026957035,
-0.0263881404,
-0.0380030274,
-0.0143854739,
0.0714428425,
0.0193136968,
-0.0029466483,
0.0047616782,
0.0434488356,
-0.0182521231,
0.0047379849,
-0.0243782904,
-0.0003091651,
0.0210715719,
0.0547380298,
-0.0217003301,
-0.0044687157,
0.00571999,
-0.0311197545,
-0.0132228555,
-0.0243996363,
0.0424930789,
-0.0129046869,
0.0009525891,
-0.0092646778,
-0.0422367714,
0.0337990224,
-0.0976386219,
0.0427667201,
-0.0077103279,
-0.0493402779,
0.0191937163,
-0.03916087,
-0.0057353107,
-0.0212668385,
0.0100112064,
0.0074052126,
0.0215269923,
-0.0231648721,
-0.0438058339,
0.0168319438,
-0.0342985019,
-0.0808383077,
0.0011178714,
-0.0053800261,
0.0314755812,
-0.075156495,
0.01328295,
0.0450998843,
-0.0346617475,
-0.0468209907,
2.642641707e-34,
0.0075033847,
-0.0002648355,
0.0173011348,
-0.0229832008,
0.0766655952,
0.0289867856,
-0.0331207514,
0.0332186632,
0.0487169996,
-0.0393469334,
-0.0339012295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09221v1 | Spectral Filters, Dark Signals, and Attention Sinks | 2024-02-14T15:01:07 | 2024-02-14T15:01:07 | Nicola Cancedda | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Projecting intermediate representations onto the vocabulary is an
increasingly popular interpretation tool for transformer-based LLMs, also known
as the logit lens. We propose a quantitative extension to this approach and
define spectral filters on intermediate representations based on partitioning
the singular vectors of the vocabulary embedding and unembedding matrices into
bands. We find that the signals exchanged in the tail end of the spectrum are
responsible for attention sinking (Xiao et al. 2023), of which we provide an
explanation. We find that the loss of pretrained models can be kept low despite
suppressing sizable parts of the embedding spectrum in a layer-dependent way,
as long as attention sinking is preserved. Finally, we discover that the
representation of tokens that draw attention from many tokens have large
projections on the tail end of the spectrum. | [
-0.0225312449,
-0.0210032333,
0.010184655,
0.059436772,
-0.0020731071,
-0.0029359015,
-0.0277336445,
0.0239509009,
-0.0272806138,
-0.0380640179,
-0.0651322901,
-0.0556771308,
-0.0149287116,
-0.007785318,
0.0359583236,
-0.021782184,
0.0345276892,
-0.0078251548,
-0.0812927261,
-0.0009257753,
-0.0147499694,
-0.0209032409,
0.0136549883,
0.0522693135,
-0.0232147593,
0.0093255034,
-0.0193858631,
-0.001594716,
0.0255155303,
0.0065621422,
-0.0139750047,
-0.0144637572,
0.0304877162,
0.0052524433,
0.0000018781,
-0.0057496349,
0.004336291,
-0.0148127656,
-0.0200077742,
-0.0094725778,
0.0439785831,
0.0117630521,
0.016447043,
0.0140758026,
-0.0151592921,
-0.0001884914,
0.0479078591,
0.0418519489,
0.0207975954,
0.0565428063,
-0.0051048258,
-0.0374040082,
0.0298762545,
-0.0307506248,
0.044058241,
0.004486755,
0.0090976665,
-0.0427787304,
-0.0434163362,
-0.0096765887,
-0.0499299727,
0.0599964857,
0.0335313603,
0.0235103928,
0.067836009,
0.0287036821,
0.0192356911,
-0.0266394429,
-0.0007555613,
0.0339145176,
-0.0493449196,
-0.0126799261,
-0.0153966164,
-0.0020228743,
0.0337803438,
-0.0266301055,
-0.044658687,
0.0422229506,
0.0529994518,
0.049736049,
-0.004925698,
0.0044696308,
0.0451303422,
-0.0145895593,
-0.0719487295,
0.0538987741,
0.0143538071,
-0.0389243588,
0.039195329,
-0.0106424456,
0.0109335855,
-0.0294745564,
-0.0030033512,
0.0489243567,
0.0509148501,
-0.0063555823,
-0.0312205404,
0.0008920997,
-0.0233078636,
0.0131448647,
0.0466691367,
0.0363941304,
-0.0527455173,
0.040575549,
-0.03977862,
-0.0181432236,
-0.0497908778,
0.0875950605,
-0.0268561598,
-0.0330250263,
0.0465378873,
-0.008619721,
-0.0302858744,
0.0426014028,
0.0008361989,
-0.0145384399,
-0.0188084207,
0.0185659267,
-0.0086499518,
-0.0221511275,
-0.0278906189,
0.0057042497,
-0.0287400503,
-0.0027442521,
0.0207354166,
0.0324503854,
0.0365720354,
0.0189840868,
0.0098678144,
-0.0226945877,
-0.0577380918,
0.0682160705,
-0.0074269189,
-0.0285785068,
0.0166312866,
0.0846643001,
0.0328294039,
-0.0958754569,
-0.0399744101,
0.0023786323,
-0.0068749185,
-0.0228934083,
0.0551417805,
-0.0141137466,
-0.0048464742,
0.0202861521,
0.0256646704,
-0.0259862877,
0.0147017688,
0.0123615125,
-0.0028463481,
0.0605846457,
-0.0079766233,
-0.017054867,
-0.0250850711,
0.015993068,
-0.0304826908,
0.0503476746,
0.0295623019,
0.0320848227,
-0.0188114438,
-0.048203852,
0.0037940876,
0.0408608951,
0.012417878,
-0.0068650041,
-0.043899551,
-0.0499265417,
-0.0472454354,
-0.0068567493,
0.0695419312,
0.0336133093,
-0.0346700586,
-0.0456955023,
0.0311144441,
0.0934660435,
0.0688677356,
0.0409867279,
0.0340900086,
-0.0123931104,
-0.0256611388,
0.04456909,
-0.0468456373,
0.0562454984,
0.022657685,
-0.0335332453,
0.0003651717,
0.0133666331,
-0.0229650103,
-0.029063452,
-0.0100666266,
-0.0159916766,
0.011962289,
-0.0085841641,
0.0608838797,
-0.0126517955,
-0.0336465798,
0.1503633857,
0.0360855907,
-0.0505106375,
0.0220149141,
-0.0703819394,
-0.0215458293,
-0.0162745267,
-0.0125468457,
-0.0353249423,
0.0129582109,
-0.0322246328,
0.0458073765,
0.022282362,
-0.0209372528,
0.0467392243,
0.0218933932,
-0.0429700613,
-0.0364191197,
-0.0203229655,
-0.004389802,
0.0240473971,
-0.0443005934,
0.0031281251,
0.0229841582,
-0.0339053981,
-0.011584742,
0.0238793977,
0.0186845642,
-0.028386347,
-0.030584231,
-0.0010714418,
0.0202107672,
0.0121597387,
0.0072005098,
0.0241496563,
0.0583703853,
-0.0499033295,
0.0039140652,
-0.0139411278,
-0.0547034182,
0.0372051522,
0.0503535569,
-0.0936408415,
0.0153743615,
0.041231133,
-0.0056910268,
-0.0404111892,
0.0416909903,
-0.0441036783,
0.0406766906,
-0.00657106,
-0.0066064848,
0.01596223,
0.027254371,
-0.0032990719,
0.019232152,
-0.0264489837,
0.018581884,
-0.0211621094,
0.0069167772,
0.0055038007,
-0.0446692817,
-0.0122115156,
0.0315230265,
-0.0078335078,
-0.0108330501,
-0.0201851781,
-0.0326276645,
-0.0170812365,
0.0064128274,
-0.053807158,
-0.0188205261,
-0.0269316845,
-0.0191416964,
0.0214778576,
-0.0009736183,
0.0271424819,
0.00788817,
-0.0262866355,
0.0545188524,
-0.0091576781,
0.0098604932,
0.0045942846,
-0.0310742147,
-0.0425088294,
-0.0281601585,
-0.030567931,
0.0076320576,
0.0389653444,
-0.0221036728,
-0.0692564324,
-0.0617051944,
0.0120561728,
0.0321972035,
0.0249635726,
-0.0100595681,
-0.0216719415,
0.0208339989,
-0.0313310362,
0.0340242684,
0.0793815032,
0.0075807478,
0.0741197914,
0.0693093687,
0.0045831297,
-0.0298722945,
0.0164849628,
-0.0410413966,
-0.0015659641,
-0.05796602,
0.0094140582,
0.0126290331,
0.0772288293,
-0.0192696229,
0.0104320114,
-0.0660629719,
-0.0316141732,
-0.0028336707,
-0.0391898379,
-0.0007310886,
0.0227516461,
-0.064343065,
0.017041944,
0.0135580003,
-0.0292429365,
0.0304527059,
0.0130765382,
-0.0282955952,
0.0190955698,
-0.0445063524,
-0.0122479973,
-0.0171870403,
0.0052842125,
0.0059698918,
-0.0444588847,
-0.0123519078,
-0.0762141868,
0.0036208376,
-0.0388192795,
-0.0039679357,
0.1109714881,
0.0203205831,
-0.0367905125,
-0.0234727543,
0.0122093633,
-0.0541208796,
0.0109328646,
-0.0152193485,
-0.0085539371,
-0.0085014291,
-0.0002490403,
-0.0740633309,
0.0015508023,
0.014828492,
0.0130349994,
0.0040175626,
-0.0021315208,
-0.0326081924,
0.0203268006,
0.0113559254,
0.0094658574,
0.0783583522,
-0.0405064076,
0.0263882279,
0.0782305524,
0.0069093239,
-0.0087022465,
-0.0295625273,
0.0102224266,
0.0484433174,
-0.0125618028,
-0.0245269388,
-0.0046319459,
0.0465961322,
-0.0540269837,
-0.0027449091,
0.0623889677,
-0.0146564087,
-0.0719671473,
0.0286544338,
-0.0069464105,
0.0062337588,
0.0275268834,
-0.02135114,
-0.0796152428,
-0.0208086651,
-0.0162769724,
0.0339019969,
0.0559973232,
0.0076654097,
-0.0136760157,
-0.0301262084,
0.0180991814,
0.0589782521,
0.0210591443,
-0.0122724017,
0.0082178134,
0.0021427816,
-0.0040372955,
0.040228162,
-0.004391877,
-0.0134607768,
-0.0396506079,
0.0410661399,
0.0380817205,
0.0144689167,
-0.0082737887,
-0.0134630743,
-0.0248828568,
-0.0138545251,
-0.0144917592,
-0.0184436422,
-0.0723535344,
0.051266145,
-0.0574798994,
-0.0016185177,
0.011184915,
0.0194320995,
-0.0194519497,
-0.030799713,
0.0187181514,
0.0116027715,
-0.0621918216,
-0.0407855473,
-0.0468909219,
0.0869505927,
-0.0418115705,
-0.025242934,
-0.0248104986,
-0.0004376214,
-0.0439876504,
0.0793129206,
0.0668536648,
-0.043656636,
-0.0102299424,
-0.021890007,
0.020863723,
0.0057523213,
-0.0700218976,
0.0330158211,
0.0328939334,
-0.0368355736,
0.00817353,
-0.0458382405,
0.0125081008,
0.0268863793,
-0.0109158969,
-0.0282593351,
0.0024988542,
-0.0529344343,
-0.0180974044,
0.0740728304,
-0.0381031632,
-0.0136293275,
-0.0766966045,
0.0002837426,
0.0234349798,
-0.0173177067,
-0.0110422438,
-0.0402112715,
-0.1230474189,
-0.0585102066,
0.0535236299,
0.0076565491,
0.027286578,
0.0308712665,
-0.0183018483,
-0.0400544293,
0.0227352642,
0.0012790773,
0.0182952303,
0.0752414241,
0.0470986515,
-0.0303580575,
0.0087521775,
0.0419332869,
-0.0655459538,
0.0172733739,
0.0511448905,
0.014457114,
-0.0239090305,
-0.0196162965,
0.0318757854,
-0.0522819236,
0.100822106,
-0.0217147488,
0.0047055036,
0.0062826956,
0.0308057833,
0.0126482714,
0.0116787618,
-0.0569300801,
-0.0201166607,
0.0245228242,
0.0210503004,
0.0040284423,
0.001491266,
-0.0084151011,
0.0239792261,
-0.0444133654,
0.0558774844,
-0.0408455469,
-0.0737707093,
0.0048706252,
0.0356685519,
-0.0200176444,
0.0316514894,
-0.0021976177,
0.0045825783,
0.0414069667,
0.0127629926,
0.0124886306,
-0.0002293394,
-0.0351493843,
0.0418550931,
-0.0650355369,
-0.047805775,
0.0032149919,
0.0155135049,
0.061159607,
-0.0214456283,
0.01352394,
-0.0046333526,
-0.0160389356,
0.0026929709,
0.0131795667,
-0.0112993261,
0.0179717243,
0.0704034045,
0.0142884078,
-0.0051730126,
-0.0001638817,
0.0337363482,
0.0161269046,
0.0317961536,
-0.0004213584,
0.0289379917,
-0.0173391476,
-0.0300946347,
0.0181343816,
0.0161171742,
0.0123894718,
0.0208637845,
-0.0448138043,
-0.0670500398,
0.0126752136,
-0.0450846329,
-0.0132668559,
-0.0426097065,
0.0480352566,
0.020244481,
0.021225946,
-0.0080160899,
0.0419665016,
-0.0170544498,
0.0579589978,
-0.0440141894,
0.0181976054,
-6.563489523e-33,
-0.0366246514,
-0.0215129927,
-0.0250429306,
0.0316269696,
-0.0051773363,
-0.0018079835,
-0.0094198938,
-0.0004778458,
-0.0070478409,
0.0087595014,
0.0159062259,
0.0460617431,
0.0140660461,
0.0189406332,
-0.0172952339,
-0.0513261668,
0.033293575,
-0.0129032368,
0.0289811455,
0.005521561,
0.0149421226,
0.0452651009,
0.0803996474,
-0.0361098573,
-0.0072879815,
0.0118651614,
-0.0063696313,
-0.0090395119,
-0.0097605642,
0.0663457513,
-0.0359481946,
0.0448913723,
0.0069171335,
-0.0260551106,
-0.0380920209,
0.0034540289,
-0.0378438868,
-0.0227389298,
-0.0113871545,
0.0281555355,
-0.0593815334,
-0.0447230376,
0.1072308645,
0.0073731188,
-0.053003151,
-0.0467369556,
0.0032580504,
-0.013056539,
-0.0388096645,
-0.006698227,
-0.0101176808,
-0.0013672129,
0.0041317986,
0.0003154985,
0.0566731654,
0.0157886576,
-0.0111996327,
0.0549161956,
-0.0575964004,
-0.0037730057,
-0.0038757301,
0.0312202331,
0.0262206607,
0.0562664159,
-0.0099515533,
0.0327380076,
0.0338563696,
-0.0553187244,
-0.0002455316,
-0.0568887293,
0.0165789407,
0.0248490404,
0.0523066334,
-0.0525769666,
0.0432668477,
0.0414786972,
-0.0642445609,
-0.0250286441,
-0.0724121481,
0.0927910358,
-0.0096233226,
0.0396628454,
-0.0088964524,
-0.0099931443,
0.0155422958,
-0.0090010045,
-0.0313232355,
-0.0215591416,
0.0414020866,
-0.0065112137,
0.0012519559,
-0.0033379907,
0.0376965925,
-0.0370336324,
0.0105760172,
-0.0102704382,
0.0178143028,
0.01311081,
0.0151299667,
0.0075681466,
-0.0383547843,
-0.0047427369,
0.056249734,
-0.0123125482,
0.0189020615,
0.0038539839,
0.0157979131,
0.0298813954,
-0.0509825461,
-0.0447694473,
-0.040643096,
-0.0438631102,
0.0344890766,
0.0572865009,
0.0867454633,
-0.0054680924,
0.006659308,
0.0909408554,
0.0086818505,
-0.003563276,
-0.0235176496,
0.0013334309,
0.0169407334,
0.0676086098,
-0.0464840084,
-0.0072830012,
-0.0356608368,
-0.0000887439,
0.0675471574,
-0.0479976051,
-0.0407768786,
-0.0226569921,
2.788e-7,
0.0498415008,
-0.0139377918,
-0.0131596792,
0.0235786736,
0.0112967053,
0.0213533454,
-0.0005769057,
0.0441433676,
-0.0125130033,
-0.0395615958,
0.0079313023,
0.0327782631,
0.0171361864,
-0.0126963854,
-0.0544511043,
-0.0237982459,
-0.0409031287,
0.0229901243,
-0.0124361441,
0.0226578061,
0.0586529784,
0.1166540757,
0.0002490258,
-0.0010953771,
0.0060966811,
-0.0694689453,
0.0634327829,
-0.0429706052,
0.0228179973,
-0.033706028,
0.0846618116,
0.0030476963,
-0.0132113164,
0.0122861406,
0.0093537886,
0.0482193083,
0.0087097315,
-0.0103945183,
-0.0189980548,
-0.0617772862,
0.010670444,
0.0421033949,
0.0065808813,
-0.037767455,
0.0466397256,
-0.0638001114,
-0.0302463155,
-0.023724163,
-0.0017243583,
-0.0115460632,
-0.0121578705,
-0.0046086125,
-0.0095595913,
-0.0531325378,
-0.0064709843,
-0.0119149582,
-0.0149807399,
-0.1111866608,
0.0045879683,
0.0267819688,
-0.0376466773,
-0.029014362,
-0.0690918565,
0.0081479615,
0.0441983268,
0.010951207,
-0.0606833883,
2.64694397e-34,
0.0077795582,
-0.0294999089,
0.0408864357,
0.0749215558,
-0.0114919003,
-0.0232366472,
-0.0278837197,
-0.0066373805,
0.0352093242,
-0.0826857388,
-0.0104353605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09216v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09216v3 | AutoTutor meets Large Language Models: A Language Model Tutor with Rich Pedagogy and Guardrails | 2024-02-14T14:53:56 | 2024-04-25T13:15:55 | Sankalan Pal Chowdhury, Vilém Zouhar, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs) have found several use cases in education,
ranging from automatic question generation to essay evaluation. In this paper,
we explore the potential of using Large Language Models (LLMs) to author
Intelligent Tutoring Systems. A common pitfall of LLMs is their straying from
desired pedagogical strategies such as leaking the answer to the student, and
in general, providing no guarantees. We posit that while LLMs with certain
guardrails can take the place of subject experts, the overall pedagogical
design still needs to be handcrafted for the best learning results. Based on
this principle, we create a sample end-to-end tutoring system named MWPTutor,
which uses LLMs to fill in the state space of a pre-defined finite state
transducer. This approach retains the structure and the pedagogy of traditional
tutoring systems that has been developed over the years by learning scientists
but brings in additional flexibility of LLM-based approaches. Through a human
evaluation study on two datasets based on math word problems, we show that our
hybrid approach achieves a better overall tutoring score than an instructed,
but otherwise free-form, GPT-4. MWPTutor is completely modular and opens up the
scope for the community to improve its performance by improving individual
modules or using different teaching strategies that it can follow. | [
0.0183719918,
0.011827861,
-0.050627172,
0.0322455019,
-0.063244015,
-0.0228546578,
0.0539051257,
-0.0299475081,
0.0131714605,
-0.0436098352,
-0.003976515,
0.0049780738,
-0.0258179195,
0.0142267356,
0.0332005583,
-0.0776325539,
-0.0097588962,
-0.0363275446,
-0.0159862358,
0.0078197578,
0.0069674551,
-0.0086499657,
-0.0411033668,
0.0506091528,
0.0210423805,
-0.025357943,
-0.0451874249,
-0.0547434017,
0.0042955317,
-0.0123780109,
0.0130308121,
0.0444598831,
0.0034981929,
0.0232748073,
0.0000023691,
-0.0522425957,
-0.0158136133,
-0.0076294565,
0.011316563,
0.00661497,
0.0004920848,
0.0473624319,
0.0135111343,
0.0276988447,
-0.0535128117,
0.007091884,
0.0188163295,
-0.0128403753,
0.1061826646,
0.0484140888,
0.0143932542,
-0.0089573422,
0.0487853773,
0.0432108529,
0.015140092,
-0.0462990627,
0.0306058843,
0.0279761273,
0.0589410439,
0.0314076021,
-0.0877947882,
0.0257916804,
0.038007386,
-0.0417447723,
0.0303273853,
-0.0067241001,
-0.0146040879,
-0.0236991514,
-0.0264197588,
0.0653917864,
0.0275424682,
-0.0216427408,
-0.0030729817,
-0.0021599813,
0.0119470945,
0.0684970021,
-0.058101844,
0.0457359292,
-0.0055316659,
-0.0060680248,
0.0476726517,
-0.0324963592,
-0.0306340642,
0.0316298641,
0.0076075862,
0.0602280386,
0.0203735288,
-0.0361125544,
-0.0193622429,
0.0423881002,
0.030863842,
-0.0380985811,
0.0468681008,
0.1073054671,
-0.0081184804,
0.0268876515,
-0.0338761248,
-0.0591387041,
-0.0129340515,
-0.0027813262,
0.0625060201,
0.0592791028,
-0.000520914,
0.0141107403,
0.0122214295,
0.065048933,
0.0242753252,
0.0048148832,
-0.0471740849,
0.0358436704,
-0.0609573498,
-0.0288815331,
-0.0557101406,
0.0452822745,
0.016170986,
-0.0057968525,
-0.026125554,
0.0219437014,
-0.0457367264,
0.0197311528,
-0.0299781635,
-0.0317356177,
-0.0181289781,
-0.0197341405,
-0.0091459481,
0.0660662949,
-0.0028308793,
-0.0004513196,
-0.001547305,
-0.0324439146,
0.0066791507,
0.0167714395,
0.0002321105,
0.0097151529,
0.0074975626,
0.0538575202,
-0.028459793,
-0.0227988269,
-0.0264833402,
-0.053805273,
0.0178324245,
-0.0569592826,
-0.0247893874,
-0.0790523961,
0.0135012623,
0.0338948034,
-0.00261547,
-0.0266264174,
0.0139589235,
0.0182974748,
0.0369997248,
0.0320313163,
0.0050474587,
0.0027666898,
0.0641141236,
0.0127027929,
0.0004070713,
0.0374989733,
0.0456467457,
0.0101222191,
-0.0059188684,
-0.0447953269,
0.0731468499,
0.0305077303,
-0.0055936836,
0.0228505023,
-0.0119771445,
-0.0058361725,
0.00866119,
0.0209717397,
-0.0659262836,
0.0485173091,
0.0059097782,
0.0535722412,
0.0477354154,
0.0371880494,
-0.0110777672,
0.0623184964,
0.0518200062,
0.0226912629,
0.0484247468,
0.0184359215,
-0.0161344837,
0.0205572508,
-0.0595165938,
-0.0201641135,
0.0275749639,
0.0108725652,
0.0001049816,
-0.0832603276,
0.0038835802,
-0.0106204264,
-0.0065565133,
0.0396288559,
0.0660593733,
-0.0241778772,
-0.0200152118,
0.0428206436,
-0.0044247112,
-0.0305862743,
0.0518107004,
-0.0754264966,
0.0844691545,
0.0641040355,
0.0719450787,
-0.0512248464,
-0.0317546986,
-0.020056339,
0.0570551082,
0.0135950055,
0.0364433676,
-0.023186516,
-0.0388914347,
-0.0295208208,
-0.0130937956,
-0.0034838147,
0.0150936069,
0.0033954564,
-0.002743168,
0.0228025597,
0.0316285416,
-0.0166196879,
-0.0410051197,
0.0131818,
-0.0684541985,
-0.0806493014,
-0.036739286,
0.0048481785,
-0.0076245526,
0.0253256708,
0.009462649,
0.0284649953,
0.0154499393,
-0.0248949379,
-0.0151398536,
-0.0470920056,
-0.059704192,
0.0121896705,
0.0464160331,
-0.0725933909,
0.0094399313,
0.0206213184,
-0.0160275809,
-0.0590422004,
0.029940797,
-0.0433729477,
0.0136602707,
-0.010497571,
0.031534519,
-0.022284383,
-0.0493886992,
-0.0108371051,
0.0111675896,
0.0414997041,
0.0256411787,
-0.0153642567,
0.0303283315,
0.0397711396,
-0.0070632827,
-0.0063788807,
0.0132585997,
-0.0117108421,
0.026300896,
0.0187878851,
0.0164539944,
-0.0598748587,
-0.0355776809,
-0.0298473984,
0.0126741743,
-0.0058524772,
0.0152780646,
0.0040208809,
0.0042206435,
-0.0167765841,
0.000604296,
-0.0663186535,
-0.0087325526,
0.0104669239,
-0.024848748,
-0.0083988812,
0.0165939499,
-0.022498209,
-0.0343269892,
-0.0142663717,
-0.0488939248,
0.0139127802,
0.0601104908,
0.0145956669,
-0.0793223754,
0.0458435416,
-0.0052261776,
-0.0058421781,
0.0097954832,
-0.0390400849,
0.0182922389,
-0.0422965586,
0.0466589816,
0.0654494092,
0.0003766383,
0.0447586179,
0.0608284548,
-0.034393549,
-0.0559945814,
0.0139008844,
-0.0249036439,
-0.0237458292,
-0.0062228423,
-0.0382488519,
-0.0237287357,
0.0393678024,
0.0346643031,
-0.0512621701,
-0.0426611975,
0.0780165121,
-0.0622711144,
0.0242952444,
-0.0171318166,
-0.0337688476,
-0.0155678187,
0.0076991776,
0.0298146252,
-0.0292171203,
0.1071244776,
0.000836899,
0.0051028742,
-0.0285546165,
0.0145551004,
-0.0557927117,
0.0178957246,
0.0206682347,
0.0106542939,
-0.0502884686,
-0.0005362985,
-0.0170658249,
0.0177106466,
0.0422410406,
-0.0530514978,
0.0312858932,
-0.0757306218,
-0.0376862586,
-0.0006883783,
-0.0306830592,
-0.0319385231,
0.0382950157,
-0.0374566428,
-0.0111855092,
0.0065391334,
-0.0098537495,
0.0199996568,
-0.016834436,
0.0331186317,
0.02012996,
-0.0564522967,
-0.0121758161,
-0.0132724484,
0.0173841119,
0.0338285193,
-0.0308283847,
0.0007145284,
-0.0632862747,
0.0861729681,
0.0209803861,
0.0619774684,
0.0099470783,
-0.005683478,
0.022123741,
0.050605882,
-0.0387273505,
0.008747289,
0.0480554737,
0.0647564828,
-0.0899406001,
-0.0142332138,
0.103343308,
0.0396044478,
-0.0289514959,
-0.0148432003,
-0.0283577424,
-0.0257760733,
0.0024049962,
0.0529623181,
-0.0763798654,
-0.0069220462,
-0.0253823809,
0.0520592406,
-0.0113924751,
-0.0333958492,
-0.0164645221,
-0.0878899023,
0.032687109,
0.0523511544,
-0.0233015642,
0.0049052103,
-0.0291921347,
-0.0209234841,
-0.0019523586,
-0.0390497334,
0.008223217,
-0.0170753486,
0.0421849675,
0.0507707633,
-0.0190294404,
-0.0206676237,
-0.0181609858,
0.0115964497,
0.0247063506,
0.0209564939,
0.0134980446,
-0.0391524546,
-0.0611103214,
0.0007052728,
0.0129545983,
-0.0332622416,
-0.0092435637,
0.0011721165,
0.0031786407,
-0.010105269,
-0.0508601144,
0.0588892959,
-0.0114511549,
0.0092978925,
0.0615843907,
0.1139640436,
-0.0067896452,
-0.0073987078,
-0.0251453426,
-0.0117075425,
0.0277143214,
0.0597270727,
0.025142476,
-0.0475478545,
-0.0002658837,
-0.0537377596,
-0.0285981838,
-0.0509347096,
-0.0410894342,
0.0108803092,
-0.0031506936,
0.027782606,
-0.0250358712,
-0.0435945168,
0.0737439618,
0.0333891883,
0.0205525178,
0.021060016,
0.0297395568,
0.0129517727,
-0.0179394148,
-0.0061520878,
-0.0308656674,
0.0073005352,
-0.0633697063,
-0.0585164167,
-0.0008358426,
-0.0464806221,
-0.0064920518,
0.0464447103,
-0.0473096855,
-0.0741681755,
0.0121809412,
0.0610399097,
0.0252714753,
-0.0232552905,
0.0401377752,
-0.018169377,
0.0071221003,
-0.0166262649,
-0.032107994,
-0.0097675715,
-0.0236962773,
0.0030162609,
0.0214041527,
-0.0020737052,
-0.0201460607,
-0.0060803085,
0.0187392775,
0.0335730724,
0.0007344372,
-0.0469275042,
0.0519955195,
0.0597127043,
-0.0022947176,
-0.0149754798,
0.0221300311,
-0.0180131309,
-0.0049953572,
-0.0546630807,
-0.0222185608,
-0.0481535457,
0.0158377457,
0.0331760384,
-0.0353693105,
0.0241965037,
-0.0206908118,
-0.0052072676,
0.0478684157,
0.0056991791,
0.0941731855,
-0.020606963,
-0.0092442418,
0.0442320034,
-0.0207464211,
-0.0102931019,
-0.0109863374,
0.02729523,
0.0600646101,
0.0151159782,
0.1135003343,
0.0023121983,
0.017123051,
0.0253654681,
0.0029831857,
-0.0141277928,
-0.0892638564,
-0.0271484517,
0.0777161494,
-0.0049290238,
0.0058908695,
-0.0088344039,
-0.0580212995,
0.0072476249,
-0.0086412216,
0.0472976938,
0.0006536471,
-0.0395174734,
0.0176082496,
0.0326648615,
0.0627598017,
-0.0110524381,
0.0362168662,
0.0147138406,
0.0177506357,
0.0130081698,
-0.0064298324,
-0.0452880487,
-0.0041106264,
0.0300120227,
-0.0011195217,
0.0139116049,
0.0211605933,
-0.0645055622,
-0.0566354506,
-0.051634565,
0.0131619824,
-0.0004629359,
-0.0317940339,
0.0341772437,
0.0333403125,
-0.042304527,
-0.0026927441,
-0.0510587059,
0.0795548186,
-0.0163964368,
-0.0515156873,
0.0140581354,
-6.39284962e-33,
-0.0335411541,
-0.0537040606,
0.0506787375,
0.0532066599,
0.0059309788,
-0.044359196,
-0.029212445,
0.0279946756,
0.0402600951,
0.0087808892,
0.0124195395,
-0.0196379572,
-0.0120660989,
0.0383571051,
0.0104894638,
0.003564944,
0.0370090529,
0.006019529,
-0.0154761784,
0.0324068964,
-0.0165975075,
0.01442667,
0.0330076031,
-0.0191499554,
0.0278504509,
-0.0670469627,
0.0139583852,
-0.0063955993,
-0.0317356512,
0.0204292294,
-0.0145546542,
0.0637844577,
0.0035812547,
-0.0430976562,
-0.0034385661,
0.0236601122,
-0.0183742624,
-0.064791128,
-0.0000056448,
0.0205290336,
-0.0433288403,
-0.0653512627,
0.0202966612,
-0.0378603153,
-0.0442596376,
0.0075836717,
0.0530498587,
-0.013845427,
0.0265919417,
-0.0139580667,
-0.0648288131,
-0.0030364427,
-0.0567866862,
-0.0553948693,
-0.0010979753,
0.0406117178,
-0.010797062,
-0.0529703796,
0.0012954556,
0.0444846228,
0.0893663764,
0.0179332234,
0.057699088,
-0.0067364275,
-0.0340761058,
0.001116068,
0.0158034768,
0.0035042069,
-0.0208903775,
0.0093806395,
0.0067513343,
0.0246734284,
0.0916509479,
0.0164558813,
-0.0132761542,
-0.0060361209,
-0.029820716,
0.0348489285,
0.0358243994,
-0.0066168224,
-0.0020919298,
-0.0457292609,
-0.0578179732,
-0.0264992435,
-0.052777674,
0.0227303412,
-0.0055277552,
-0.0301017035,
0.0456053913,
-0.0507238284,
-0.0178502034,
-0.0314393006,
0.0127073238,
-0.0535476729,
-0.0323090144,
0.0028101727,
-0.0064742276,
0.0188057348,
-0.0292605143,
0.0107506737,
-0.0068138833,
-0.0224645343,
-0.0293134823,
-0.0346768945,
0.0209564287,
0.0154669043,
-0.0096787475,
0.0453110598,
-0.0371343642,
-0.0061886096,
-0.0699198619,
-0.0116470177,
0.0765430406,
-0.0102096517,
0.0209571924,
0.0165522359,
-0.0181844831,
0.0281562954,
0.0143907825,
-0.0466899574,
-0.0181810148,
-0.0260187425,
-0.0135582751,
-0.0147379767,
-0.023594318,
-0.0201156028,
-0.0421557203,
0.0270911623,
0.0077075968,
-0.0686620846,
0.006943732,
-0.0096361367,
3.045e-7,
-0.0066633988,
0.0583212338,
-0.0008982337,
-0.0250656195,
-0.0041060024,
0.0190175809,
-0.0174294803,
-0.0101972017,
0.0382194929,
0.0226434637,
-0.0058660489,
0.031589251,
0.0550409555,
0.0333950184,
-0.0622124113,
0.0146727925,
0.0253045,
0.0047350442,
-0.0762794837,
0.0292146653,
0.0817479193,
-0.0078493962,
0.0340017006,
0.0056129447,
-0.0316080265,
-0.0266250856,
0.0287452042,
0.0143647287,
-0.0104026869,
0.0483678728,
0.0077335681,
0.0159796681,
0.0032228634,
0.0098416619,
0.0064160014,
0.0188290123,
-0.0173251294,
0.0650611669,
0.0333207399,
0.0152788954,
0.0238339286,
-0.0160864461,
-0.0028900523,
-0.0716224164,
0.0305426531,
-0.0203947145,
0.0063463869,
0.0205092598,
-0.0423385687,
-0.0455007069,
-0.0063305879,
-0.025302453,
0.0313784406,
0.0077607208,
-0.0205161851,
-0.0460261106,
0.0464269295,
0.0201292392,
-0.0236990955,
-0.0104681673,
-0.0374473929,
-0.0413191244,
-0.0536056869,
0.0018494368,
-0.0305940732,
-0.0496412441,
0.0105379568,
2.480272876e-34,
0.0046728468,
-0.0473758802,
0.0654080361,
0.015684858,
0.0028989699,
0.0249094702,
-0.0299594812,
0.0358172432,
0.0563117638,
-0.0543093607,
-0.0508556664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09205v2 | Tell Me More! Towards Implicit User Intention Understanding of Language Model Driven Agents | 2024-02-14T14:36:30 | 2024-02-15T09:59:52 | Cheng Qian, Bingxiang He, Zhong Zhuang, Jia Deng, Yujia Qin, Xin Cong, Zhong Zhang, Jie Zhou, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Current language model-driven agents often lack mechanisms for effective user
participation, which is crucial given the vagueness commonly found in user
instructions. Although adept at devising strategies and performing tasks, these
agents struggle with seeking clarification and grasping precise user
intentions. To bridge this gap, we introduce Intention-in-Interaction (IN3), a
novel benchmark designed to inspect users' implicit intentions through explicit
queries. Next, we propose the incorporation of model experts as the upstream in
agent designs to enhance user-agent interaction. Employing IN3, we empirically
train Mistral-Interact, a powerful model that proactively assesses task
vagueness, inquires user intentions, and refines them into actionable goals
before starting downstream agent task execution. Integrating it into the XAgent
framework, we comprehensively evaluate the enhanced agent system regarding user
instruction understanding and execution, revealing that our approach notably
excels at identifying vague user tasks, recovering and summarizing critical
missing information, setting precise and necessary agent execution goals, and
minimizing redundant tool usage, thus boosting overall efficiency. All the data
and codes are released. | [
0.0426354036,
0.0308136791,
-0.0184742287,
0.0210376438,
0.0038515921,
0.0053846901,
-0.0043103588,
-0.0143039487,
0.0466188602,
-0.0339983143,
-0.0279049762,
0.0033106373,
-0.0258077849,
0.0396990627,
0.0044172071,
-0.0512285195,
0.0354514048,
-0.0264987871,
0.0153464219,
0.0171722136,
0.0232829377,
-0.0041333125,
-0.0117136771,
0.0414357632,
-0.0221327487,
-0.0282597356,
-0.0651781335,
0.0255023427,
-0.0057856054,
-0.0179541595,
0.021516528,
0.0029720308,
0.0455597155,
0.0161037166,
0.000002195,
-0.0590503961,
0.0093714157,
-0.015910212,
-0.046499569,
-0.0232895408,
0.0228930544,
0.0302693807,
0.0078711621,
0.0078006182,
-0.0564537607,
0.0592518784,
0.0020870806,
0.0629613549,
0.0673035905,
0.0489191115,
-0.014255926,
0.0404110998,
-0.0322161652,
0.0207637176,
0.0580193214,
-0.0492610261,
-0.0071011004,
-0.022006236,
0.0144790532,
0.011353639,
0.0356851146,
0.036662247,
0.0151576437,
-0.0169088002,
-0.008567486,
0.0234681647,
0.0164348185,
-0.0854902044,
-0.0359644704,
0.0497434288,
0.0310710408,
0.01551197,
0.0101861255,
-0.0182326995,
0.0173317734,
0.0436609536,
-0.0013508869,
-0.0311887935,
-0.0087151071,
-0.016460875,
0.0116355391,
0.0430683047,
0.0274739284,
0.0224463623,
-0.0149548044,
0.0911972672,
-0.0271334741,
-0.0213148668,
0.0207686536,
-0.0197330061,
0.0314602405,
-0.0665014163,
-0.0155776097,
0.0533394404,
-0.1051369905,
0.0448287018,
-0.0023019623,
0.0133699495,
0.001239438,
-0.0495064668,
0.0387865007,
0.0839694068,
0.0103952428,
0.0399355367,
0.0004358543,
0.0324178562,
0.0398517139,
-0.0206432696,
-0.0258545335,
0.0085358946,
-0.0151905678,
-0.0135828657,
-0.0658427402,
-0.0061052763,
-0.0220392141,
-0.0119342301,
0.0014409802,
0.0823720023,
-0.0058181961,
0.0347775221,
-0.0042855009,
0.0274089072,
-0.0558209233,
0.0113451611,
-0.0779185519,
0.0183838289,
-0.0589511916,
0.018117331,
0.0201824121,
-0.0600445978,
0.0088105034,
0.0181486253,
-0.0098412903,
-0.0100965146,
-0.0298431441,
0.0728299096,
-0.0200898666,
-0.023769388,
-0.0305681638,
-0.0701096058,
0.0507234968,
-0.0698300675,
-0.0259957872,
-0.0271225106,
0.0162454378,
0.0143373786,
-0.0041027311,
-0.042915538,
0.0036592705,
0.0141133182,
0.0192638785,
0.0801702589,
-0.0222354215,
0.0006327872,
0.021992093,
0.0349359103,
-0.0597192831,
0.0604899973,
-0.0202484224,
0.1045536101,
0.0377454013,
0.0195586123,
0.0301923752,
0.0234099831,
-0.0121078165,
0.0012634969,
0.031605944,
0.0326926559,
-0.0416203998,
0.027757477,
0.0140666105,
0.0265005454,
-0.0099485861,
0.0191393755,
0.0769291446,
0.0733232796,
-0.018362876,
-0.0444367267,
0.0610366017,
0.0441859029,
-0.0112274596,
-0.0110233938,
-0.0554420836,
0.0337248966,
-0.0257587433,
0.0059151514,
-0.0381673798,
-0.0167398639,
-0.055333972,
-0.0661691576,
0.0133294594,
0.0018269166,
0.0624787174,
0.0227390826,
0.0139281675,
-0.006103565,
-0.0505952723,
0.0221300833,
-0.0041635502,
-0.0251958184,
-0.0060857036,
-0.0811749175,
0.0354193039,
0.0978849828,
0.0297035836,
-0.0216109455,
-0.053470213,
-0.0056769052,
-0.0184193533,
0.0124491015,
0.0201192107,
-0.0590446182,
0.0133378841,
-0.0146820955,
-0.0554635376,
-0.0117837293,
0.0167421736,
0.012789404,
0.0067315241,
-0.005557091,
0.0102044661,
-0.0336875357,
0.0048408066,
0.0339471586,
-0.0612865351,
-0.0245384295,
-0.0389783233,
0.0384295657,
0.0293846484,
0.0254986566,
0.0446339473,
-0.017739309,
0.030532185,
0.0262810998,
-0.0189447757,
0.0150753455,
-0.0043333801,
0.0094687026,
0.0234745573,
0.0034870449,
-0.0267037172,
0.0246891715,
0.006413138,
-0.013459635,
0.0133341933,
-0.0268462934,
0.0345306732,
-0.0469177626,
-0.0028144952,
-0.0083959876,
-0.0456229486,
0.0008594389,
0.0280597676,
0.004972198,
-0.0426276028,
0.052734416,
-0.0124438256,
0.0152581753,
-0.0065822392,
-0.0093807299,
-0.0255411491,
0.0102613512,
0.0141427079,
0.0468857773,
0.0157543272,
-0.070009999,
-0.0097152181,
-0.0874756724,
-0.0145051815,
-0.0386750102,
-0.018355662,
0.0194202811,
0.0701225102,
0.0021771023,
-0.0270606466,
-0.0155966273,
0.020986136,
-0.0150915496,
0.0264648478,
0.0448665172,
0.0383473858,
-0.053088557,
-0.0504497848,
0.0401805937,
-0.0166082699,
-0.0376628675,
0.0156305861,
-0.019663455,
-0.0378447473,
0.0209252369,
-0.0338903628,
-0.0020306187,
-0.0518284589,
-0.0527409688,
0.0523281135,
-0.0229545105,
-0.0041653509,
0.0423518829,
0.0016028512,
0.0823425651,
0.0364553519,
-0.0227695256,
-0.0987781733,
0.0397946611,
-0.0276531987,
-0.0141965244,
-0.070241943,
-0.0198673364,
0.0326627381,
0.086359337,
-0.014200639,
0.0183120538,
-0.0638401881,
-0.0279452838,
-0.0042005214,
-0.0618139692,
-0.019589778,
0.0041874317,
-0.0238962509,
0.0606971495,
0.0111296922,
-0.0456905551,
0.082493104,
-0.0053076781,
-0.0254199542,
-0.0149184568,
-0.021259645,
0.0052815946,
0.0487493686,
-0.0222435985,
0.0187850632,
0.0176142156,
-0.017426081,
-0.0292711165,
-0.0230327863,
0.0025180685,
-0.011273589,
0.0182004757,
-0.0301379543,
-0.0000652177,
0.0071465531,
-0.0029858884,
-0.0451159365,
-0.0822251141,
-0.0266597997,
-0.0064385682,
-0.012583998,
-0.0205693115,
-0.0376545452,
-0.0155460136,
0.0132201836,
0.0203731172,
-0.0100572482,
-0.0647705197,
-0.0321643502,
-0.0603175126,
0.0610028505,
0.0249067824,
-0.034142442,
-0.0383903421,
0.049678795,
0.0322479494,
0.0051958947,
-0.0706694201,
-0.0289085116,
-0.0062449235,
0.0372941792,
-0.0276614856,
0.0090103438,
0.0681804568,
0.0852691978,
-0.0283559896,
0.0055602523,
0.1221057996,
0.0386894383,
-0.0331312083,
0.0174480379,
-0.0620912835,
0.02511671,
0.0259588826,
0.0362620018,
-0.0597397424,
-0.0684787557,
-0.0054509612,
0.0342244059,
-0.0130592594,
-0.0110649075,
-0.0070090313,
-0.033436656,
0.0243994743,
-0.043110963,
0.011288451,
0.0568434037,
-0.0591767058,
0.0299764369,
-0.0244928803,
0.0354605094,
0.0003505398,
0.0028238907,
-0.0427108482,
-0.0120817674,
0.0148706259,
-0.0629569069,
0.031310074,
-0.0441795439,
0.0429106392,
0.0733978152,
0.03647127,
0.0226964764,
-0.0632034838,
0.0184174161,
0.014180813,
0.0387093611,
-0.0188196916,
0.0271772929,
-0.0266637672,
0.0275412407,
-0.0021964223,
0.035773851,
-0.0451767743,
0.0059320512,
-0.0135785062,
0.0582298711,
-0.0379612148,
0.0100369425,
-0.021704467,
-0.0098179718,
0.0632949322,
0.0694593713,
-0.0248745922,
-0.0397983678,
-0.0294289794,
-0.0520158447,
-0.0350505933,
0.0202916972,
-0.0174562037,
-0.0002383013,
-0.0408649556,
-0.0307509769,
-0.0118854381,
-0.1431813985,
0.0614676699,
0.0124975033,
0.0076729115,
0.0074531226,
0.0371846482,
0.0184146967,
-0.003646696,
0.0383632518,
0.0059996331,
0.0448382683,
-0.0070012952,
-0.0422900729,
-0.0013584053,
-0.0413270518,
0.0363201015,
0.0147702582,
-0.0347771868,
-0.0323821045,
-0.0005406115,
0.0618583485,
0.0247459002,
0.0629909709,
-0.0314748995,
-0.0063640093,
-0.0080384677,
-0.0139670931,
-0.0491002016,
-0.020173423,
0.0375726223,
0.03252092,
-0.0126882875,
0.0403485335,
-0.0495828353,
-0.0248402562,
-0.0076931925,
0.0073506143,
-0.0845268667,
-0.0336747244,
0.0460790843,
0.0366747417,
0.0023928855,
-0.0212036315,
0.0169559456,
-0.0074658478,
0.0124280192,
-0.0187108554,
-0.0216384102,
-0.0514740944,
-0.0191877466,
-0.0100997621,
-0.0221408345,
0.0295344014,
0.0057102973,
-0.0623204447,
-0.0125942882,
-0.0292003341,
0.0353292748,
0.0092730531,
0.0302663986,
0.0230952799,
0.0084643234,
-0.0188168976,
0.0129191708,
0.0149585651,
0.0346507765,
0.0067588598,
0.0665314719,
0.0167003777,
0.0083075706,
-0.0237228945,
0.0196953937,
-0.0125314156,
-0.047379598,
0.0307464302,
0.0096406573,
-0.0006307078,
-0.0032215519,
0.052636873,
-0.051814504,
0.0366877541,
-0.001046254,
0.0282672774,
0.0039444673,
-0.056808304,
0.0091164038,
0.0164251775,
-0.0027843011,
-0.0106601072,
0.0227587484,
-0.0600869581,
0.0490972176,
-0.0304589532,
-0.039171122,
-0.055909548,
0.0094688963,
0.0912797004,
0.0216034707,
-0.0412476361,
-0.0223312955,
-0.0218819827,
-0.0327108018,
-0.0485284328,
0.0115171121,
-0.0478405952,
-0.0360258743,
0.0444125831,
0.0569639429,
0.0092037255,
-0.0346834324,
-0.0547502339,
-0.0572420992,
-0.0435586907,
0.0049749608,
-0.0519604608,
-6.041081466e-33,
-0.0207726732,
-0.02548692,
0.0596975312,
-0.0254124347,
-0.0264750272,
-0.0113910325,
-0.0855763853,
-0.0015007049,
-0.0228742436,
0.0190990437,
-0.0267939903,
0.0210205689,
0.0138663203,
-0.0174548086,
0.0104944883,
0.013195917,
0.0542018041,
-0.0043617599,
-0.0228356067,
0.0076107318,
0.0218492839,
-0.0078897942,
-0.0269988105,
-0.0688256696,
0.0682544932,
-0.0021767125,
-0.0435279831,
0.037950214,
-0.0108932387,
0.033211045,
-0.0292386599,
0.0024163411,
0.0239270944,
-0.0174786318,
-0.0147589808,
0.0027437445,
-0.0371831469,
-0.0457524732,
0.0301484652,
0.035625115,
-0.081585139,
-0.0113880457,
-0.0030169548,
-0.0165047739,
-0.03427222,
0.0297903605,
0.0332125425,
0.0378004014,
0.0235633273,
0.026530236,
-0.0714446753,
0.0021463295,
-0.0138519201,
-0.0373335406,
0.0405086875,
0.0400492363,
0.0043969485,
-0.0262813233,
-0.0381941199,
0.0007006571,
-0.0035104067,
-0.0090223635,
0.0773768276,
0.0440793075,
-0.0020912285,
0.0431641489,
0.0139935091,
0.016448196,
0.0069221035,
0.0435191765,
0.0118757505,
0.0280597322,
-0.0337645188,
0.0129602961,
-0.0094383126,
-0.0019722676,
0.0117686661,
0.0783846825,
0.0439296812,
0.0586240813,
0.0256249327,
0.0324247926,
-0.0605830401,
0.0062710801,
-0.0156002799,
0.0264021996,
-0.025216138,
-0.0670471042,
0.0405183956,
0.0153046362,
0.0026233376,
-0.0397640355,
0.0130018722,
-0.0214053709,
-0.0066548018,
-0.0053823586,
-0.0300853495,
0.0155730201,
-0.0019661256,
0.0177259836,
-0.0087007964,
0.0027401017,
-0.0053567993,
0.0011759675,
0.0237883329,
0.0382033698,
-0.0349312313,
0.0471988544,
0.000624011,
-0.0131420121,
-0.0342627801,
0.016844118,
-0.0228317622,
0.0173490774,
0.0441553555,
-0.0091965767,
-0.0349125564,
0.0390180834,
-0.0397155918,
-0.0578856766,
-0.040447481,
0.0120401606,
0.0244748835,
-0.0048558521,
-0.0477132909,
-0.0306616295,
-0.041937951,
-0.0005160455,
0.0209080297,
-0.0422850512,
-0.0009091652,
-0.0058852597,
2.883e-7,
-0.0239029266,
0.0182593465,
-0.0221683737,
0.0811637044,
-0.0282488056,
0.0942880139,
-0.043151319,
0.0354404934,
-0.0079140635,
-0.0170352627,
0.0417399444,
0.0237576663,
0.0104583809,
0.0384900384,
-0.0596022382,
0.0035778556,
0.0366167203,
0.0048244074,
-0.0276023708,
0.0580430888,
0.0632930025,
0.0410416685,
-0.015829483,
0.0109916413,
0.0307263955,
-0.0099784639,
0.0051446585,
-0.0338366926,
-0.0098636886,
0.0270232838,
0.0236295145,
0.0108205955,
0.0237876195,
-0.0043943278,
0.0031801311,
0.0208416805,
-0.0514951125,
0.0888007581,
-0.033294145,
-0.0396813974,
-0.0300212316,
-0.0304783396,
0.0321384557,
-0.0338781364,
0.0145776113,
-0.0127365654,
-0.030446453,
0.0435484424,
-0.0006468692,
-0.0009126049,
-0.0323265828,
-0.0114200739,
-0.0201626979,
-0.0136101479,
0.0088655613,
-0.0282836929,
-0.0338089764,
-0.0480566323,
0.013553407,
-0.0121908169,
-0.0388968214,
-0.0465896502,
-0.0402297787,
0.0618653037,
0.0172729064,
-0.0626420677,
0.0051817074,
2.24454126e-34,
-0.003322738,
0.0172104053,
-0.0057011582,
0.057355918,
0.0413845293,
0.0253202543,
0.0138853006,
0.0349873006,
0.0909211263,
-0.0485951342,
-0.0184427388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09199v1 | Ten Words Only Still Help: Improving Black-Box AI-Generated Text Detection via Proxy-Guided Efficient Re-Sampling | 2024-02-14T14:32:16 | 2024-02-14T14:32:16 | Yuhui Shi, Qiang Sheng, Juan Cao, Hao Mi, Beizhe Hu, Danding Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the rapidly increasing application of large language models (LLMs),
their abuse has caused many undesirable societal problems such as fake news,
academic dishonesty, and information pollution. This makes AI-generated text
(AIGT) detection of great importance. Among existing methods, white-box methods
are generally superior to black-box methods in terms of performance and
generalizability, but they require access to LLMs' internal states and are not
applicable to black-box settings. In this paper, we propose to estimate word
generation probabilities as pseudo white-box features via multiple re-sampling
to help improve AIGT detection under the black-box setting. Specifically, we
design POGER, a proxy-guided efficient re-sampling method, which selects a
small subset of representative words (e.g., 10 words) for performing multiple
re-sampling in black-box AIGT detection. Experiments on datasets containing
texts from humans and seven LLMs show that POGER outperforms all baselines in
macro F1 under black-box, partial white-box, and out-of-distribution settings
and maintains lower re-sampling costs than its existing counterparts. | [
0.0353695489,
0.0277452767,
-0.0187049713,
0.0111570787,
-0.0450827032,
-0.0056180693,
0.033021301,
0.0498915836,
0.0205001589,
-0.0690781176,
-0.0192002337,
-0.0466003381,
0.0136719532,
0.0676528662,
0.0467401668,
0.0152177913,
0.0364982784,
-0.0230517723,
0.0070763477,
-0.0085759591,
-0.0018931825,
0.0418731458,
0.0162780806,
0.0314498506,
-0.0134071792,
-0.0051353648,
0.0105118044,
-0.0031345366,
0.0070917909,
-0.0238364562,
-0.0038686283,
0.0582947582,
-0.0083163846,
0.065582104,
0.0000021587,
-0.0258113667,
-0.051034946,
-0.0132473102,
-0.0120198121,
0.0055272053,
0.0691518784,
-0.0202183183,
-0.0054451255,
0.0548883639,
-0.0404865704,
0.0367256328,
0.0018756097,
0.0362514481,
-0.0151087241,
0.0748452693,
-0.0287516247,
0.046229057,
0.0184138697,
-0.0119538093,
0.0189740248,
-0.0032811,
0.0369090103,
-0.0128974831,
-0.0171017516,
0.0221764427,
0.0095395111,
0.0041621085,
0.031010868,
-0.0321149677,
-0.0028950192,
0.0261552501,
-0.0399269387,
-0.0041542011,
-0.022696713,
0.0514072888,
-0.0476959758,
-0.0314985104,
0.0385261774,
-0.0272261966,
0.0246057604,
-0.0133910254,
-0.0085884798,
0.024847962,
-0.0502286814,
0.025062982,
0.0255003944,
-0.0117047923,
0.0242959149,
0.0480113067,
0.0179940835,
0.0424229577,
0.0226439573,
-0.0408403315,
-0.0029548856,
0.0088000316,
-0.0180370901,
-0.0557554774,
0.0590130016,
0.0085580572,
0.0032712943,
-0.0030881376,
-0.1011934653,
-0.0475111008,
0.0305630807,
-0.0162034445,
0.035952203,
-0.0157625265,
-0.0192945749,
0.0442352369,
-0.0294409469,
0.0382087417,
-0.0210657567,
0.0178108662,
-0.0199760962,
0.0297990758,
0.0280466471,
-0.021475289,
-0.0285058469,
0.0201426633,
-0.0492438301,
-0.0564805828,
-0.0383980162,
-0.0344904102,
0.0050338199,
-0.0528492928,
-0.0316172466,
-0.0027599444,
-0.0220244899,
-0.016477583,
0.0358505994,
-0.0204645135,
-0.002455008,
0.0208247211,
-0.0034831162,
-0.0786023587,
-0.0273577292,
0.0366678126,
0.0197549742,
-0.0061464747,
0.011143133,
0.0257695038,
-0.0026246395,
-0.0538627692,
-0.0492250808,
-0.0724166483,
-0.0656868368,
-0.0230623763,
0.0113095008,
-0.069930017,
-0.034598425,
-0.0243457295,
-0.0062522544,
-0.0181993917,
0.0172386281,
0.0288069732,
0.000235635,
0.0165950377,
-0.0063741556,
-0.0084435446,
0.03339779,
0.0021368978,
0.0314809419,
0.0738964081,
0.0328522325,
0.0767334923,
0.0457845107,
0.0340266749,
0.0264781248,
0.0711278096,
0.0585967265,
0.0374091864,
0.0091981571,
-0.0763943642,
-0.044210203,
0.0088573908,
0.0599744134,
0.0352467149,
-0.0172368735,
-0.0350434966,
0.0710786059,
0.0221619233,
-0.0227748398,
0.0007902887,
0.0657398403,
0.0400213934,
-0.0151294637,
0.0031609563,
0.0231255479,
-0.0046832249,
-0.0471005253,
-0.0211919397,
0.0227142852,
0.0653920695,
0.0004399081,
-0.0366663113,
0.0028815677,
-0.0102830101,
-0.0032621019,
-0.0163999107,
0.0641660616,
0.051433783,
-0.0452629291,
-0.0102588255,
0.0303076915,
-0.0293815825,
0.0171903148,
-0.0874283165,
0.065950498,
0.0541769266,
0.0677040368,
0.0077079693,
0.0504539572,
-0.0451456048,
-0.0095436219,
0.0752522498,
0.0211571306,
0.0061143599,
-0.0095431395,
-0.0502507016,
-0.0337122492,
-0.0141364122,
0.0183509141,
0.0458262712,
0.0385495424,
0.0275343284,
0.0377176665,
-0.0238446612,
-0.0454809107,
0.0415885188,
-0.0409948193,
-0.0416884013,
0.0061757024,
-0.0278193448,
0.0321416818,
-0.0081701521,
-0.0236852672,
0.0187012143,
0.0230005533,
-0.0481908098,
-0.0551364534,
-0.0369790457,
-0.0168478396,
-0.0261912812,
0.0074763959,
-0.0553717129,
0.0526265725,
0.0354461856,
0.0032448771,
-0.0237822365,
-0.0056203525,
-0.0484890044,
0.007991923,
-0.0372138359,
0.0355633646,
-0.0074944436,
0.0471651107,
-0.0298171826,
0.0401040465,
-0.0304844752,
-0.0184130371,
0.019350281,
-0.0020466389,
0.0100650638,
-0.0388110802,
-0.0052257655,
-0.0154157393,
-0.0052442895,
0.001495398,
0.0386169478,
0.0328639299,
-0.0276455116,
-0.0138337798,
-0.0870308578,
-0.0179313049,
-0.0361938365,
-0.0162276234,
0.0352127627,
-0.0112202065,
-0.024252126,
0.0005414945,
-0.0180729739,
-0.0512813777,
0.0279577747,
-0.0051172976,
-0.0003324999,
-0.0421881452,
0.0327066891,
-0.0109912651,
0.0148862088,
-0.0025240362,
0.0272362623,
0.0521557368,
-0.0393221118,
-0.0497967713,
0.0530596897,
0.002104948,
-0.0121541619,
-0.0104932776,
-0.0194973648,
-0.0177755207,
0.0144730369,
0.0145694744,
0.0502016768,
0.0323073715,
0.0216710977,
0.0225667302,
0.0395096727,
-0.0414666869,
-0.0144976033,
-0.0082867602,
0.0327132195,
-0.0105467336,
-0.0690317675,
0.0449559093,
0.0325686522,
0.0537064262,
0.0184472464,
-0.0068104719,
0.0504674651,
-0.0224012565,
-0.0712389722,
-0.0071826102,
-0.0239901002,
-0.0409319066,
0.0104487184,
-0.044642318,
-0.0863301903,
0.0234665126,
-0.0484273694,
0.0342814326,
-0.0295662414,
-0.0099073099,
-0.0115139149,
0.0089981388,
0.0100809978,
0.0181274265,
0.021202527,
0.0058605573,
-0.0265033077,
0.0283902977,
0.0100942673,
-0.056988772,
0.0124440724,
-0.0333821476,
0.0040582796,
0.0302968174,
-0.0167862158,
-0.0473428704,
-0.082203649,
-0.033908356,
-0.0116821369,
0.0074375561,
-0.0508981496,
-0.0026308545,
0.0058375052,
0.0188219845,
0.0796315297,
-0.0509480424,
-0.0078844195,
-0.0064600278,
0.0603088439,
0.0887582898,
-0.076150611,
0.0415201522,
-0.0528863445,
-0.0046456843,
0.046290163,
0.0017610079,
0.0580514744,
0.000472322,
-0.0339900553,
0.028896261,
0.0273444951,
-0.0452724658,
0.0074436055,
0.01280085,
-0.0497514121,
-0.0223622099,
0.1135956794,
0.0233531073,
-0.0331551507,
0.0156499669,
-0.0196690205,
0.0552168228,
0.001082417,
0.0039188708,
-0.066020146,
-0.0409839153,
-0.0018912898,
0.0123944627,
-0.079492487,
-0.0145497676,
-0.0127208428,
-0.1472700834,
0.0340326168,
0.0483236909,
-0.0060938359,
-0.0211539585,
0.0077019623,
-0.0055387416,
0.0284710843,
0.0050333119,
-0.0132019594,
-0.0105938157,
-0.0064916564,
0.0119517297,
-0.0133929243,
-0.0312605873,
-0.0063229729,
-0.0024651079,
0.037339054,
0.0559423342,
0.026410576,
-0.0178623181,
-0.0035269081,
0.0007660515,
-0.0152410315,
-0.0107052317,
-0.0155700007,
0.0786570162,
-0.0187809803,
0.0050171334,
0.0151565243,
0.0643005744,
-0.0417805277,
0.003519923,
0.026832005,
0.0368140712,
-0.0190002602,
-0.0679514557,
-0.0332598016,
0.0144596444,
0.0379446559,
0.0867133364,
0.0318722539,
-0.0574570782,
-0.0121259587,
0.0020455839,
0.0233123917,
-0.0743142217,
-0.0085084196,
0.007115873,
-0.0440319404,
-0.0166519508,
-0.1001536697,
-0.0040612407,
0.0186347216,
0.0439733714,
-0.0044631446,
0.0438059606,
0.020741066,
-0.0447438285,
-0.0241889581,
-0.0092745321,
-0.0516719408,
0.0281512011,
-0.0118789859,
-0.0290759597,
-0.0008638171,
-0.0570010506,
-0.0395846404,
0.0682862028,
-0.0669007525,
-0.04419351,
0.0218394529,
0.019056581,
0.0217327699,
0.019158015,
-0.0070280023,
-0.0489402749,
0.1088773459,
0.031786941,
0.0139778703,
0.0419016518,
-0.0072762384,
-0.027170606,
-0.0098512722,
0.0167068169,
-0.0350627042,
0.0288370475,
0.0362991206,
-0.0215622243,
-0.0337103717,
0.0023501189,
0.0014521425,
0.0228027813,
-0.0004338604,
-0.0744060129,
0.0503500588,
-0.0246343408,
-0.0333349779,
-0.0055516162,
-0.0015507195,
-0.06301862,
0.0547489077,
0.0285755787,
-0.0260369834,
-0.0168456323,
-0.0091275889,
-0.0678218752,
0.0104333581,
-0.0351698138,
-0.0346177407,
-0.02663422,
0.0298315119,
0.0267659519,
-0.0187424403,
0.0204787757,
0.0566248111,
0.0052783103,
0.0312205143,
0.010161113,
0.0474301614,
0.014986489,
-0.0271065123,
-0.0084271934,
0.0144004999,
-0.026148973,
0.0141495178,
-0.0788782537,
0.0444586612,
0.0178849865,
-0.0084876437,
0.0600369982,
-0.0216504652,
-0.0108140316,
-0.0152297635,
0.0276663266,
0.0201174486,
-0.0424467251,
-0.0092270486,
0.0024175574,
-0.0461266451,
0.0371681489,
0.1048899963,
0.0205426253,
0.0371738598,
0.0101687117,
-0.0235847812,
-0.0278061219,
-0.0046478757,
0.0225183722,
0.0121312365,
0.0003369875,
0.0286681075,
-0.072945565,
-0.0357745439,
0.0344717987,
-0.0136402752,
-0.0014219465,
-0.0305288583,
0.0344381481,
0.0526413918,
-0.0598262399,
0.0256485995,
-0.0504798964,
-0.0003573987,
-0.0308989938,
-0.045210477,
0.0069596828,
-6.576108454e-33,
-0.0221609715,
-0.0965081528,
-0.0259499885,
-0.0037246298,
-0.0238008052,
0.0418744609,
0.0161394291,
-0.0240218304,
0.0433585048,
0.0379158445,
0.0062760743,
0.0136574516,
0.0189809725,
0.041217234,
-0.02484731,
-0.0016892725,
0.0577748083,
-0.0278802738,
-0.0578848533,
0.044931747,
0.045274239,
0.0271416288,
0.0047099744,
-0.0259145536,
-0.0123927565,
-0.0089011136,
-0.0316417776,
-0.0132907759,
-0.0260571204,
0.0469820984,
0.0015913607,
0.0452438183,
0.0349688418,
-0.0061167087,
-0.0179495551,
0.0463233925,
0.0140007455,
-0.0023702669,
-0.010480538,
-0.0261505712,
-0.0259385705,
-0.0433799662,
0.0439261757,
-0.0078406511,
-0.0134083657,
0.0316584744,
0.030674424,
-0.0403153002,
-0.037354026,
-0.0078597656,
-0.0545672961,
0.0332417712,
0.002990535,
-0.0009437504,
-0.021798294,
0.0572684407,
-0.0114790397,
0.0104813231,
-0.0113444943,
0.0148076592,
0.0554604977,
-0.0043591182,
0.0188714899,
0.0368971601,
0.009363791,
0.074496381,
0.0315176137,
0.0013050336,
-0.0151571464,
-0.0391450338,
0.0348992869,
-0.0045407931,
0.0411838852,
0.0678066909,
0.0521140136,
-0.0236459021,
-0.0435346402,
0.0115007339,
0.0158361997,
-0.021931028,
0.0509910025,
-0.0506367274,
-0.0467320345,
-0.0220810566,
-0.0362064429,
-0.0799803138,
-0.0111856554,
0.0033465137,
0.0291971229,
0.0735149533,
-0.0447162837,
-0.025405176,
0.0131604448,
-0.0171728805,
0.0313678123,
0.0169806443,
-0.0403360836,
0.008630476,
0.0029549741,
0.0308962036,
-0.0479930975,
-0.0239342172,
0.0334518179,
0.048384998,
0.0061404612,
-0.0087402733,
0.0369079672,
0.0038920164,
-0.0699392855,
0.0147361448,
-0.0295109209,
0.0324129947,
0.0183486771,
-0.0254254453,
0.0099500706,
-0.0241001621,
-0.011773075,
0.0134889707,
0.043439921,
-0.0187241007,
-0.0063327327,
-0.0264050588,
0.0030328813,
0.0185111705,
-0.0481581129,
-0.0072556352,
0.002429283,
0.0101426439,
0.0668199211,
-0.0678441003,
0.0104032792,
-0.0235891938,
2.814e-7,
0.0334192328,
0.0284281764,
-0.009180773,
0.0108940853,
0.0196327399,
0.0439438894,
0.0476496443,
0.0222143643,
-0.0288923103,
0.012833369,
-0.021075638,
0.0131138312,
0.0811104774,
-0.0088703018,
-0.0598485842,
0.0422696508,
-0.0612479076,
0.0242185257,
-0.0664943829,
-0.0603848174,
0.0123326946,
0.0682357326,
0.0180255882,
-0.0708021894,
0.008828707,
-0.0823698714,
0.072777532,
0.0005283514,
0.0010017961,
0.0250185765,
0.0561068617,
0.0518993735,
0.0101710893,
0.0125298668,
-0.0232714284,
0.0123032583,
0.0365470797,
0.063694872,
0.0112420814,
0.016580876,
0.0066538882,
-0.0052610342,
-0.0076850825,
-0.0362933613,
0.0661879852,
-0.0141870091,
0.0173884388,
-0.0814909637,
-0.0085761305,
-0.0463252962,
0.0210392233,
-0.0668267682,
-0.0088773835,
0.0305775478,
0.0174901299,
0.0203539897,
-0.0098947966,
-0.0328165069,
-0.0055015492,
-0.0376454778,
-0.0430788137,
-0.0185988881,
-0.0580534451,
0.003902579,
0.0094958972,
-0.0452453159,
0.0415779129,
2.819743477e-34,
0.0269390065,
-0.0552820787,
-0.016908342,
0.0336127765,
0.0210783202,
0.0024871801,
0.016340781,
-0.0129125649,
-0.006749012,
-0.0393829122,
-0.0043536457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09193v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09193v2 | (Ir)rationality and Cognitive Biases in Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T14:17:21 | 2024-02-15T11:09:09 | Olivia Macmillan-Scott, Mirco Musolesi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Do large language models (LLMs) display rational reasoning? LLMs have been
shown to contain human biases due to the data they have been trained on;
whether this is reflected in rational reasoning remains less clear. In this
paper, we answer this question by evaluating seven language models using tasks
from the cognitive psychology literature. We find that, like humans, LLMs
display irrationality in these tasks. However, the way this irrationality is
displayed does not reflect that shown by humans. When incorrect answers are
given by LLMs to these tasks, they are often incorrect in ways that differ from
human-like biases. On top of this, the LLMs reveal an additional layer of
irrationality in the significant inconsistency of the responses. Aside from the
experimental results, this paper seeks to make a methodological contribution by
showing how we can assess and compare different capabilities of these types of
models, in this case with respect to rational reasoning. | [
0.0166765358,
0.0762517378,
-0.0284996498,
0.0259812213,
-0.0461856276,
0.0364095233,
0.0264103375,
0.0299804378,
0.0032147085,
-0.0374523513,
-0.027532585,
-0.0354344361,
0.0246432498,
-0.0020374584,
0.0270177312,
-0.0322026648,
0.0162797645,
-0.0504045151,
0.0888082236,
-0.0309123527,
-0.0707566664,
-0.0002097053,
0.0103258351,
0.0145685775,
0.0520587601,
-0.0291998852,
0.0113840019,
-0.0358531363,
-0.0048946193,
-0.0378226042,
-0.0620379671,
0.0502389334,
-0.0004005054,
0.024022596,
0.0000021045,
-0.0771545321,
0.0454730131,
-0.0224752109,
-0.0395548716,
0.0568001196,
0.0264291931,
-0.0019078634,
0.0195214041,
0.0129025262,
-0.0352564305,
0.0324165635,
0.0140891671,
0.0901926979,
-0.0017647983,
0.0208939686,
0.0114389425,
-0.0408065096,
-0.0079444274,
-0.0058369813,
-0.0041766115,
-0.0063037919,
0.0506744385,
0.0496176034,
-0.0034754353,
-0.0028377576,
-0.0040947152,
-0.0229257643,
0.0124514075,
0.0140088918,
-0.0569910221,
0.0211254526,
0.0219664779,
-0.0302183181,
0.01256325,
0.035542842,
-0.0095603094,
-0.0095566604,
-0.0045228954,
0.000309636,
-0.0097944336,
0.0131586362,
-0.0550666898,
0.0747401044,
0.0133264186,
0.0293213837,
0.0267416351,
0.02056068,
0.0209467094,
0.0196363404,
-0.0539619885,
0.0658796281,
-0.0005144845,
-0.018323591,
0.024861807,
0.0090709599,
-0.0633259863,
-0.070112519,
-0.0603619106,
0.0255674683,
-0.0188496932,
0.0218305588,
-0.0021840604,
0.0478527546,
0.0270769503,
-0.0753738433,
-0.0064166095,
0.0331897326,
0.0470385626,
0.0327949561,
-0.012985548,
0.063383922,
-0.020615451,
0.0432387143,
0.0026578801,
0.0125589799,
-0.0300308522,
-0.0135284038,
0.0207223669,
0.0105387308,
-0.0225967392,
-0.0025553713,
-0.0581629984,
-0.0263006426,
-0.0254156701,
0.0110910386,
-0.0017368157,
0.0134622948,
0.0075052446,
-0.0424335115,
-0.1003991738,
0.0011627767,
-0.032117039,
0.0574368127,
-0.0195210204,
-0.0565478802,
0.0266962852,
0.0069899014,
-0.0281826593,
-0.0408722199,
0.01213599,
0.0298624467,
-0.0259409659,
-0.00065885,
-0.0402494147,
0.0156683009,
-0.002193562,
-0.0881471708,
-0.0173170008,
-0.0293843951,
-0.0083551714,
0.0286857784,
-0.012059669,
-0.0443149693,
0.0097229984,
0.0052542984,
-0.0676640868,
0.0675940812,
0.0033454557,
0.0404171348,
0.0349651799,
0.002641174,
-0.0237074606,
0.0466331169,
0.0348230861,
-0.0052966508,
0.0002921919,
-0.0257838722,
-0.0023029516,
-0.0051197736,
-0.0401988886,
0.0101001998,
-0.0877869129,
0.0230677277,
-0.0391904041,
0.0198845081,
0.0408632495,
0.0768961683,
-0.0293549821,
-0.006667864,
0.0808722451,
0.0534413941,
-0.0096684769,
0.0293640643,
0.01512127,
-0.0081368964,
0.0132961357,
0.0065246597,
-0.072754845,
0.0043168538,
-0.0073401793,
0.0079955617,
0.0146352798,
0.0183836222,
-0.0114411805,
-0.04243524,
-0.0269572642,
-0.00758004,
0.0334696583,
0.040348988,
0.0427786298,
-0.0549206585,
-0.0076834518,
-0.008303904,
0.002364625,
-0.0093981307,
-0.0100519666,
-0.0575195067,
0.0785547271,
0.0298465472,
-0.0153356716,
0.0075456765,
0.0369474106,
-0.0028457148,
-0.0145004224,
0.0323943272,
0.0934702456,
-0.0001504948,
-0.0373614505,
-0.029923752,
0.0114671998,
-0.015999943,
0.0440055728,
-0.0043364605,
-0.0229137018,
0.0432738476,
-0.0089994166,
-0.0705259964,
-0.0061392691,
0.0280882679,
-0.0338410623,
-0.044470381,
-0.0747632459,
-0.0234860256,
0.0298923925,
-0.0029199342,
-0.0067479294,
0.0429714918,
0.0083283419,
0.0036184133,
-0.0426509231,
0.0250945855,
-0.0229419023,
0.0307412315,
0.0308689401,
0.0000805662,
-0.0309046526,
-0.0291089453,
-0.000700716,
-0.0119395815,
0.0546786301,
-0.0306341071,
0.0167642813,
-0.0016389323,
0.0621777028,
-0.0360862315,
-0.0042922706,
-0.0170481987,
0.09753564,
0.0002543814,
0.0417068563,
0.0246386398,
-0.0273506567,
0.035291601,
-0.0572495162,
0.018394744,
0.0297489278,
0.0123014785,
-0.0076177451,
-0.0053837122,
-0.0367349908,
-0.0264370199,
-0.010069116,
-0.0329104662,
-0.0230255425,
-0.0042863255,
-0.0058720955,
0.0012985464,
-0.0523507334,
-0.0130232964,
0.0063229757,
0.0081082452,
-0.0089159794,
0.0277240518,
0.06004389,
0.0146697033,
-0.028478723,
0.0055556628,
-0.014269108,
-0.0148114273,
-0.0235330202,
0.0322255939,
0.0165212154,
0.0303249601,
-0.0596704967,
0.0145501299,
-0.0395760015,
0.0147735728,
-0.0140216425,
-0.0431483723,
0.0263987333,
0.0168066025,
0.0175687801,
0.0966869667,
0.0134566762,
0.0098434472,
0.0751227215,
0.0112447739,
-0.0495169759,
-0.0190587584,
-0.0203346536,
0.015405356,
-0.056782607,
-0.0854520425,
-0.0136089316,
0.0875643194,
0.0114542544,
0.032481607,
-0.0434629284,
0.1043652445,
-0.0295612961,
-0.0568079315,
-0.0237392914,
-0.0412149429,
-0.0004079544,
0.1050799042,
0.0031920448,
-0.0299455225,
0.0433209464,
-0.0194636583,
0.0287379324,
-0.0418517143,
-0.004264323,
-0.0239585061,
0.0501256324,
-0.0151498187,
-0.0134319132,
0.0122571727,
0.0094375946,
-0.0574342571,
-0.0626775622,
-0.0027249153,
-0.0312149376,
0.071179077,
-0.0578218065,
-0.0110992948,
-0.0114972796,
-0.0197546221,
-0.0350808389,
-0.0293813385,
-0.0878493711,
0.0087225353,
0.0112415338,
-0.0369593129,
-0.0465440489,
0.0150224753,
0.0524907522,
-0.0302927177,
0.005665903,
-0.0102704884,
0.0182619151,
-0.0396088064,
0.0430008247,
0.06468793,
0.0980030447,
-0.0224210788,
0.0683012009,
0.0254869293,
0.002536671,
-0.00385753,
-0.0018452593,
0.0005721812,
0.006963802,
-0.0062683052,
-0.0188996214,
0.049569279,
0.0766830444,
-0.0179801211,
-0.0040971152,
0.1194337904,
0.0459696464,
0.0085650003,
0.0204067081,
-0.0299780462,
0.0018231148,
0.051257506,
-0.0147139737,
-0.0167288706,
-0.01578876,
0.0214171279,
-0.0020675925,
-0.0382246785,
-0.0433119833,
-0.0009507395,
-0.1422268003,
0.037192408,
0.0026805124,
0.0294499099,
-0.027362084,
-0.0345619395,
0.0024938709,
-0.0252784602,
0.0179815907,
0.0257537048,
-0.0140898433,
0.0098518375,
-0.0044816625,
-0.0150941713,
-0.0134359207,
0.0378628857,
0.0042469827,
0.0284704827,
-0.0283469297,
0.0435492918,
-0.0300500393,
-0.093708545,
-0.0000293558,
-0.0238840617,
-0.0257852506,
-0.0022710485,
-0.0099929534,
0.0449155681,
0.0136278225,
-0.0282008797,
0.0153609561,
-0.0004760122,
-0.037099503,
0.0086196121,
0.0603908598,
-0.0245482419,
-0.076511547,
0.0013320225,
0.0259963516,
-0.0424915962,
0.0901660547,
0.0045309006,
-0.0186378472,
-0.065662846,
-0.0302268639,
-0.0387455411,
-0.0267434847,
-0.0408779792,
0.0272078775,
0.0282826573,
0.0246178173,
-0.03859796,
-0.0265445597,
-0.0017249321,
-0.0120243095,
-0.0015012148,
-0.0180373378,
0.032196112,
-0.0295632295,
0.0125664677,
0.015410305,
-0.0239095576,
0.0214206334,
-0.0184076428,
0.0460093319,
-0.0024559936,
-0.0536683165,
-0.0082242861,
-0.0320935585,
0.0057696197,
-0.0508193336,
0.0210906584,
0.0003931609,
0.0337431356,
-0.0115994401,
-0.0154664861,
-0.0298760328,
-0.021310905,
-0.0314624794,
-0.0301343538,
0.0451917984,
-0.0045694113,
0.0662756637,
0.0137165263,
0.041009292,
0.0028595105,
0.0460912473,
0.0167739429,
0.0241661053,
-0.0577813238,
-0.04978659,
0.0153950555,
0.0014915684,
0.0407282636,
0.0290641282,
0.0228488613,
-0.0113522122,
-0.0197818596,
-0.0250730496,
-0.0182296354,
0.0236725435,
-0.0386677422,
0.0285670757,
0.0254516732,
-0.0276772566,
-0.0486842766,
-0.0350310914,
0.0028018598,
0.0105186393,
0.0449102744,
0.0045679747,
-0.0080681602,
0.0167869609,
-0.010948631,
-0.0087056998,
0.0169703811,
-0.0427144356,
0.0692866445,
0.0373305455,
0.0807846338,
0.0073356847,
-0.0164830443,
-0.0274231452,
-0.0398900695,
-0.0557497591,
-0.0824135542,
0.0776207298,
-0.0296372175,
0.0227565262,
-0.028329052,
0.0279642493,
-0.0460775383,
0.0016711697,
-0.0215906557,
-0.0142060202,
0.0321051367,
0.0031602662,
0.0674518347,
0.0035042716,
-0.06137814,
-0.0004319379,
0.0468416587,
0.0095087355,
0.0055299266,
-0.0164682493,
-0.0290800966,
-0.011129681,
-0.0428676605,
-0.0151283238,
-0.0063751144,
-0.025788758,
0.008025595,
-0.0803791657,
-0.0658528581,
0.0189674348,
-0.0088429693,
-0.0014995009,
-0.0570866466,
-0.028567696,
0.0548583791,
-0.0141300485,
0.0092212269,
-0.0242737103,
0.0594659336,
-0.0341582559,
0.0241638776,
-0.0610006265,
-6.14201088e-33,
0.0135055091,
-0.0412181132,
0.0063168509,
-0.0528478324,
0.016376365,
-0.0409057066,
-0.0228398219,
0.0343266241,
-0.0669987872,
0.0264028423,
-0.00649055,
0.0091800317,
0.0242091306,
-0.0306607168,
0.0402863063,
-0.0066146804,
0.0319222733,
0.0161585901,
-0.007370356,
-0.0552798174,
0.0316377133,
-0.045501072,
0.0260681659,
-0.0550367571,
0.0328518935,
0.0092104645,
0.0190566294,
0.021053303,
-0.0322034173,
0.0346546955,
-0.0276262928,
0.0363757014,
0.0288568642,
-0.0412215851,
-0.0034805716,
0.0397447646,
0.0037872,
-0.0101442002,
0.0493532531,
-0.0075295405,
0.0173263084,
-0.0180958621,
0.0170661919,
0.0153835993,
-0.0657554343,
-0.001947052,
0.0134789003,
-0.0364620611,
-0.0084970538,
0.0583687089,
-0.0657382086,
0.0187765155,
-0.0029622745,
0.054871127,
-0.0544761643,
0.0148691833,
-0.0374544375,
0.0312459841,
-0.0838927627,
0.0197414681,
0.0351601578,
-0.0136065632,
0.029203834,
0.0004338207,
0.0176013969,
0.0705674961,
0.0343350396,
0.0257640313,
-0.0717677623,
0.0307743195,
0.0195061229,
0.0569260493,
0.0872998014,
0.0562436245,
0.0234232992,
-0.0253288578,
-0.0586172156,
-0.0393793806,
0.0317278653,
0.0438045003,
0.0752714276,
0.0254250448,
-0.0212888308,
-0.0183082316,
-0.0510960817,
0.0042137927,
-0.0411233678,
-0.0097778691,
0.0311707146,
-0.0120503074,
0.0109352218,
-0.0282395966,
0.0390183292,
-0.0205668453,
-0.0134320781,
-0.0104964441,
0.0007282565,
0.0132996822,
0.0059846425,
0.0144108627,
-0.0442358442,
-0.0223570541,
-0.0056775985,
0.0457386747,
0.0202642065,
0.0188543182,
-0.008059632,
-0.052553419,
-0.0369897261,
-0.0121893007,
-0.0204052962,
0.0084282886,
0.0189605337,
0.0194942802,
0.045459941,
0.015457958,
0.0021995695,
-0.0398529992,
-0.018710183,
-0.0402320735,
0.000763168,
-0.0066974345,
0.0052445563,
0.020831896,
-0.0244899597,
-0.0089399433,
-0.0395383425,
0.0382383876,
-0.0003001102,
-0.0147902463,
-0.0172360055,
0.0303348396,
2.727e-7,
0.0251322407,
0.0488982983,
-0.0284099784,
-0.0111038629,
0.0331339277,
0.0479106456,
-0.0217575766,
-0.0406935327,
0.033032272,
-0.0306222457,
-0.0344172642,
0.0264159031,
0.0351062864,
0.0339710377,
-0.0324340314,
-0.014623601,
-0.0495434925,
0.0106579876,
-0.0359670036,
0.0353652798,
0.0427114069,
0.0565627776,
0.011321648,
0.0153491506,
-0.0001397137,
-0.0425843336,
0.0174845047,
-0.0314419232,
-0.0097598676,
0.0064068539,
0.0018596777,
0.0230947696,
0.0313849598,
0.0467681512,
0.0187020525,
0.0177090708,
-0.0133696692,
0.0562719442,
-0.0049922746,
-0.024690818,
-0.030223567,
-0.0442065969,
0.015271741,
-0.0894867554,
0.0825804025,
-0.06833639,
-0.0682618245,
-0.0003789262,
0.0094417362,
-0.0239994042,
0.0434811376,
-0.0104493974,
0.0110780075,
0.0115874689,
0.0220077708,
0.0172144342,
0.0089115556,
-0.0317136124,
-0.0013396312,
0.0200496726,
-0.0615559779,
-0.0723748952,
-0.0255241431,
0.0524298847,
0.0460117683,
-0.010983658,
0.0035463711,
2.172773197e-34,
0.0533877909,
0.0178680066,
0.0152215324,
-0.0112371761,
0.0611200444,
0.0173493158,
-0.0163139738,
0.0210198034,
0.0420530364,
-0.084799014,
0.0198662169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09177v1 | Leveraging the Context through Multi-Round Interactions for Jailbreaking Attacks | 2024-02-14T13:45:19 | 2024-02-14T13:45:19 | Yixin Cheng, Markos Georgopoulos, Volkan Cevher, Grigorios G. Chrysos | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are susceptible to Jailbreaking attacks, which
aim to extract harmful information by subtly modifying the attack query. As
defense mechanisms evolve, directly obtaining harmful information becomes
increasingly challenging for Jailbreaking attacks. In this work, inspired by
human practices of indirect context to elicit harmful information, we focus on
a new attack form called Contextual Interaction Attack. The idea relies on the
autoregressive nature of the generation process in LLMs. We contend that the
prior context--the information preceding the attack query--plays a pivotal role
in enabling potent Jailbreaking attacks. Specifically, we propose an approach
that leverages preliminary question-answer pairs to interact with the LLM. By
doing so, we guide the responses of the model toward revealing the 'desired'
harmful information. We conduct experiments on four different LLMs and
demonstrate the efficacy of this attack, which is black-box and can also
transfer across LLMs. We believe this can lead to further developments and
understanding of the context vector in LLMs. | [
0.0581786409,
0.073574543,
-0.0409168601,
0.0565925352,
-0.0523051061,
-0.0126542356,
0.0023594475,
0.0183432791,
0.0066658775,
-0.0306304526,
-0.0134572051,
-0.0231630206,
0.0273482706,
0.0032803542,
0.0625077561,
0.0211246926,
0.0456197672,
-0.029105179,
-0.030067645,
0.0060609132,
0.0276766755,
-0.0106915748,
0.0329488702,
0.0176016577,
0.0096184239,
0.0100117857,
-0.0483897254,
0.0194791313,
0.0163812954,
-0.0474813282,
-0.0000941538,
0.0566540845,
0.0100298291,
0.0396811552,
0.0000020982,
-0.0369047597,
-0.034501709,
0.0052712341,
-0.0416446067,
0.0468294173,
-0.0074414508,
-0.0360788219,
-0.0076874197,
-0.0027364646,
-0.0572686605,
0.0092502926,
0.0038795443,
0.0478912629,
0.075664036,
0.0752398595,
0.0050498242,
-0.0055440525,
0.0449506752,
-0.0200378057,
0.0428334959,
-0.0590331033,
0.033175718,
-0.0317376107,
0.0220203418,
0.0484735705,
-0.0016524617,
-0.0192033909,
0.0266642533,
0.0130775329,
-0.0608439706,
-0.0101352539,
0.010295501,
0.0066717719,
0.0078795822,
0.0494509861,
0.0061430205,
-0.0069888528,
0.005714986,
0.0136268223,
0.0298855491,
0.0490229577,
-0.0352642909,
-0.0028960758,
-0.0082905376,
-0.0333970077,
0.0275782365,
-0.0084807118,
0.0552212894,
0.0041484986,
-0.0075024185,
0.0388966985,
-0.0005806129,
-0.029246496,
-0.0268649645,
-0.0754702166,
-0.0038159727,
-0.0590430349,
-0.016051963,
0.0189996492,
0.0041690231,
0.0131526748,
-0.0808569267,
-0.0171958786,
0.0394617841,
-0.0509254262,
-0.0271514859,
0.0303265788,
-0.0045556277,
0.0120568946,
0.01501993,
0.0018582392,
-0.0469181463,
-0.018588176,
-0.004459837,
0.016126832,
-0.0055137915,
-0.0302455984,
0.0128010195,
0.0487732738,
-0.0313369706,
0.0158568025,
-0.0198258013,
0.0480048209,
-0.0351228043,
0.0205917526,
-0.083719328,
0.0099351062,
0.000698328,
0.021911718,
0.0282770228,
-0.0495538674,
-0.0316406004,
-0.0056437072,
0.0065047774,
-0.081615746,
-0.0434133075,
-0.0157856438,
-0.0541063212,
-0.0180860236,
-0.0191214327,
0.1150474995,
0.0276798382,
-0.0082480665,
-0.0631646663,
-0.1409629434,
-0.0127055077,
-0.0053352886,
-0.0080649434,
-0.0823934749,
-0.0061244317,
-0.0006906611,
-0.017933771,
-0.0371220373,
0.0077161482,
0.0113147274,
-0.0368362814,
0.0768675581,
0.024936771,
-0.027079707,
0.0072809169,
0.0689929724,
0.0412739627,
0.0652572066,
-0.0143167917,
0.0414256267,
0.0407653041,
0.0026180074,
0.054828953,
0.0409090705,
0.0289789382,
0.0238417741,
0.0116677079,
0.0208408218,
0.0471679159,
-0.0203440227,
-0.0408747941,
0.0019557434,
-0.0349580236,
-0.0416457504,
0.0835955217,
0.0446318425,
-0.0477820039,
0.0646231771,
0.002908631,
-0.0276355799,
-0.0225014724,
0.0345791057,
-0.0539139286,
-0.0049680583,
-0.093576096,
-0.0306204595,
-0.0175996162,
0.00341902,
-0.0019590512,
0.0043010176,
0.0350510664,
0.0027853914,
-0.0106203724,
0.0180791914,
-0.0148973167,
0.052123934,
0.0154045597,
0.0558298193,
0.0288690422,
0.004510399,
-0.003117231,
-0.066694729,
-0.0269907396,
0.020561045,
0.0697373599,
-0.0200193338,
0.0151989423,
-0.0058123395,
-0.0045360667,
-0.0061999378,
0.0086362911,
0.0068908436,
0.0043298164,
0.0278389435,
-0.0119552026,
-0.0405327044,
0.025634855,
0.0106991371,
-0.0197921265,
-0.011365233,
0.0086270794,
0.0050664716,
0.0125912996,
0.011785958,
0.0085101686,
-0.0451925993,
0.0066704927,
0.0299076419,
0.021109188,
0.019829262,
-0.007015286,
0.036587216,
0.0622423589,
0.0049373223,
0.0194752906,
0.0295476764,
-0.0491410829,
-0.0054972093,
-0.0133035164,
-0.0074573667,
0.0115148453,
0.0274264701,
-0.0042108428,
-0.001938047,
0.0659532472,
-0.041270446,
0.0841615647,
0.0068932609,
0.0096685346,
0.0116464086,
0.0063455813,
-0.0339285322,
0.0412708446,
-0.0232760329,
-0.0034234386,
-0.0059723509,
0.0336932838,
-0.0148987751,
0.0004877637,
-0.0164305456,
0.0003122542,
-0.0508642867,
-0.0044564353,
0.0239510611,
-0.0119689964,
-0.0336122364,
-0.0340592153,
-0.0559436157,
-0.0379653163,
-0.0239539649,
0.0276721474,
0.0357167125,
0.0460121296,
-0.0199751966,
-0.0279199313,
-0.0172435921,
-0.0215691943,
-0.0132386955,
0.0316862538,
-0.0054594926,
0.0308899879,
-0.041023992,
-0.0226661302,
0.0006808381,
-0.0213255882,
0.0871927515,
-0.0160019863,
-0.0164343249,
-0.0018867332,
-0.0154292872,
-0.0108009437,
0.0274162702,
-0.0376376212,
-0.018354604,
0.0520521514,
-0.0121891964,
-0.0090161264,
0.0544340312,
0.0418356434,
0.0700643435,
0.0300355554,
-0.0176695436,
-0.0477268212,
-0.0166396108,
0.0073130014,
-0.0330559351,
-0.0703704655,
-0.0692352504,
0.0205135737,
0.0597319044,
0.0653429627,
0.0153584899,
-0.0059809424,
0.0604618452,
-0.0018599515,
-0.0367744304,
-0.0276008155,
-0.041735597,
-0.0358565561,
0.0276866499,
-0.0132125514,
-0.0705171898,
0.0804458335,
-0.0312583819,
0.0365513675,
0.0045832102,
-0.0224793255,
0.0171598606,
0.059635248,
-0.0168669838,
0.0145245614,
0.0646794215,
-0.0332367271,
-0.0504273139,
-0.0334466472,
0.0381547362,
-0.0140238609,
0.0228321701,
-0.0575935543,
-0.016373748,
0.0210862085,
-0.0299706142,
-0.067684792,
-0.0762338117,
-0.0153038092,
-0.0178405307,
0.0258625261,
-0.0458879806,
0.0207037963,
-0.0356509909,
0.0352898985,
-0.0283616241,
-0.0292297341,
-0.0244738758,
-0.0313201398,
0.0539296716,
0.045795396,
-0.0529154837,
0.0088222492,
-0.0028527186,
0.0321995467,
0.1048034951,
0.0619196221,
0.0118750371,
0.0228305068,
0.0245115627,
0.0039369534,
0.0193190351,
-0.0199467018,
0.0286639296,
0.0259359386,
-0.0477625988,
-0.048889339,
0.0451545566,
0.0397214033,
-0.0235119313,
0.0323523842,
-0.003932118,
0.0076263873,
0.0036750203,
0.0182555411,
-0.0800432488,
-0.0287203528,
-0.0049598557,
0.0425291546,
-0.0418897048,
-0.0292151701,
-0.0436215997,
-0.0944733098,
-0.024155844,
0.020127954,
-0.0166847836,
0.0253597163,
-0.0466597974,
-0.0082279174,
0.0551301166,
0.015617582,
-0.0034658408,
-0.001491228,
0.0072273244,
-0.0143640917,
-0.0147877811,
-0.0011652919,
0.0258520469,
-0.0243937578,
0.0546937734,
0.072144419,
0.0093290946,
-0.0212125611,
0.0465970226,
0.0574072525,
-0.0434552543,
0.0152763249,
-0.0273643006,
0.0022951483,
0.0027320019,
0.0085005453,
-0.0008195184,
0.0571478456,
0.0037697768,
-0.0281963609,
0.0452492386,
0.0369860977,
-0.0190241113,
0.0138652455,
-0.0081723807,
-0.0153431082,
0.0394129157,
0.0271061901,
0.0362025611,
-0.0375997126,
-0.0152176218,
-0.0763168409,
-0.0179001242,
-0.0383846387,
-0.0391035676,
-0.0220939182,
0.0602653176,
-0.0025230972,
-0.0546606146,
-0.0091764582,
-0.0267149098,
0.0283028353,
0.0281427167,
0.0138974059,
-0.0349080004,
0.0052107144,
-0.0254656505,
-0.0275973659,
0.0055243466,
0.0269849785,
-0.0284959022,
0.0335799195,
-0.0126153361,
-0.0435606502,
-0.015172109,
0.0201605558,
-0.0754230395,
-0.0828576311,
0.0131264636,
0.0659874678,
0.0220541079,
0.060150452,
-0.0274356883,
-0.054766167,
0.0288852993,
0.0490930937,
-0.0521127656,
0.0214819815,
0.0674497932,
0.0107716816,
0.0149299875,
0.0270535816,
-0.0339582302,
-0.02532579,
0.0717528611,
-0.0077274409,
-0.1064286977,
-0.0083068348,
0.0250297077,
0.0111411596,
0.0280766692,
0.0154662626,
-0.0052595376,
0.0494689979,
0.0224006157,
-0.0145577174,
-0.0319066904,
0.0178934541,
0.0193614904,
-0.0062214741,
-0.0174345318,
0.0536489785,
0.0077041727,
-0.0177034754,
0.0019897884,
-0.0189341661,
0.0234751813,
0.0524839349,
0.038448561,
0.0594320521,
0.011357734,
-0.0095974049,
0.0363380909,
0.0118495924,
0.0501655303,
-0.011592349,
0.063014403,
-0.022371117,
-0.0355493575,
-0.0213028695,
0.0423448794,
-0.1094932556,
-0.0154061373,
0.0293859765,
0.0255025756,
-0.0317870826,
0.002461998,
0.0002309296,
0.0085163554,
0.0035175027,
-0.0034270745,
-0.0089987237,
-0.0209819116,
-0.0711244792,
0.0305951871,
0.0117999949,
-0.0056979428,
0.0595565438,
0.0551013537,
-0.0062175803,
0.0572915524,
0.0291480664,
-0.0207989682,
-0.0193068404,
-0.0013034656,
0.0533937067,
0.0386766344,
-0.0529398769,
-0.0169885959,
-0.0641965196,
-0.0681067184,
-0.0382975973,
-0.0096763335,
0.0349459685,
-0.0003797539,
-0.0280521773,
0.0583496317,
0.0285035148,
0.0138278343,
-0.0681638867,
0.0754738674,
-0.0231787264,
-0.0714555904,
0.013274936,
-6.068249344e-33,
0.0272369068,
-0.0666021034,
-0.0464238897,
-0.0242466871,
0.0014508597,
0.0180324093,
-0.0288661048,
0.0213839691,
-0.0453881137,
-0.0453946143,
-0.013607719,
0.0177218206,
-0.0109291691,
-0.003929338,
-0.0581489019,
-0.06016789,
-0.0120751187,
0.0110272598,
-0.017808158,
0.038453985,
0.0618426353,
0.0183011238,
0.0053563751,
-0.0613080561,
0.0632209852,
-0.058364369,
-0.0265382938,
0.0314209647,
-0.0466564968,
0.0613017194,
0.0043253582,
0.0112062804,
0.0051482869,
-0.0201220047,
0.0166840088,
0.064596355,
-0.0028506762,
-0.0211325679,
0.0333638936,
-0.0183211491,
0.0030284517,
-0.0331253931,
0.0036364303,
-0.0021685273,
0.0021514418,
-0.0010364812,
-0.0194035713,
-0.006516817,
-0.0163018908,
-0.0210472606,
-0.0229946915,
-0.0052748621,
-0.0333893225,
-0.0086953919,
-0.017313052,
0.0320990346,
0.0383190811,
-0.0038244673,
-0.0275559537,
0.0444504097,
0.0331542864,
0.0081054075,
0.028805254,
0.017924875,
0.0147020966,
0.0568873249,
-0.0199310631,
-0.0051702443,
-0.0040536299,
0.010145341,
-0.01330553,
0.0406587832,
0.0427186191,
0.0880588815,
0.0497572273,
-0.0191619042,
-0.0524454191,
-0.0159397349,
0.0336048938,
0.0327782631,
0.0395376831,
-0.0204668511,
-0.0531741157,
0.0000923218,
-0.0254277922,
-0.0061555207,
-0.0374529958,
-0.037445616,
0.0108779054,
0.0084601073,
-0.0400557853,
-0.0292821527,
-0.0103522325,
-0.0686496347,
-0.0024048123,
0.0288905371,
-0.0139142731,
-0.0369958505,
-0.007893214,
0.0015934552,
0.0246149451,
0.0336790569,
0.0100163268,
-0.068769604,
0.0308948793,
-0.0014154671,
0.0199266728,
0.0115967588,
-0.0573646538,
-0.0590543188,
-0.0285244007,
0.0422246531,
-0.0041834516,
-0.0357120372,
0.0436466374,
0.0190476254,
-0.0138739562,
-0.0097560771,
0.0492090508,
0.0064545809,
-0.0689835027,
0.0246173181,
-0.0515993573,
0.0362890288,
-0.0132955033,
-0.0164635759,
0.0175159294,
0.0418996587,
0.0547015257,
-0.0821706578,
-0.0176876709,
-0.0002042697,
2.908e-7,
-0.0164330117,
-0.0123172058,
0.0149538713,
0.0078733927,
0.0469142497,
0.0818212107,
0.0065113804,
0.0742542073,
0.0164352246,
-0.0632938147,
-0.0244615525,
-0.0246072952,
0.0526697077,
0.0424524099,
-0.0596956909,
0.0129772378,
-0.0706818625,
-0.0077986326,
-0.045720011,
-0.0173857938,
0.0465367287,
0.0682486519,
0.0046939719,
-0.0200004168,
-0.0112551982,
-0.0309861228,
0.0084513975,
-0.0276038181,
-0.0167611018,
-0.0067606024,
-0.0231406391,
0.0117369788,
0.0155087467,
0.0330740809,
-0.0531071424,
-0.0354865938,
-0.0696663037,
-0.0004326045,
0.0285495408,
-0.0486306846,
-0.038965445,
-0.0292478595,
-0.0054154345,
-0.0631482527,
0.0686968565,
-0.0204987787,
-0.0128422538,
0.0077290596,
0.0246816892,
-0.0323115215,
-0.0159299038,
-0.0307633728,
-0.0278227124,
-0.0121272439,
0.0209846739,
0.0329733379,
0.0555270091,
-0.0551118553,
-0.0099129369,
0.0115496945,
-0.0061047813,
-0.0340089202,
-0.0145886689,
0.0007799317,
0.0155464113,
-0.0018629325,
0.0113081839,
2.739373413e-34,
-0.0170317646,
-0.0229004063,
0.0250275824,
0.0312896259,
0.0301626027,
0.0051718848,
0.0209870804,
0.039555829,
0.0537824631,
-0.0478874594,
-0.0485594273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09151v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09151v2 | Chinese MentalBERT: Domain-Adaptive Pre-training on Social Media for Chinese Mental Health Text Analysis | 2024-02-14T13:08:25 | 2024-06-12T16:03:31 | Wei Zhai, Hongzhi Qi, Qing Zhao, Jianqiang Li, Ziqi Wang, Han Wang, Bing Xiang Yang, Guanghui Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In the current environment, psychological issues are prevalent and
widespread, with social media serving as a key outlet for individuals to share
their feelings. This results in the generation of vast quantities of data
daily, where negative emotions have the potential to precipitate crisis
situations. There is a recognized need for models capable of efficient
analysis. While pre-trained language models have demonstrated their
effectiveness broadly, there's a noticeable gap in pre-trained models tailored
for specialized domains like psychology. To address this, we have collected a
huge dataset from Chinese social media platforms and enriched it with publicly
available datasets to create a comprehensive database encompassing 3.36 million
text entries. To enhance the model's applicability to psychological text
analysis, we integrated psychological lexicons into the pre-training masking
mechanism. Building on an existing Chinese language model, we performed
adaptive training to develop a model specialized for the psychological domain.
We evaluated our model's performance across six public datasets, where it
demonstrated improvements compared to eight other models. Additionally, in the
qualitative comparison experiment, our model provided psychologically relevant
predictions given the masked sentences. Due to concerns regarding data privacy,
the dataset will not be made publicly available. However, we have made the
pre-trained models and codes publicly accessible to the community via:
https://github.com/zwzzzQAQ/Chinese-MentalBERT. | [
0.0591791682,
0.0947512016,
-0.040967118,
-0.0125251086,
0.0110480702,
0.0201175679,
0.0253603365,
0.0192756988,
0.0796490237,
-0.0478183664,
0.002219998,
-0.0462750234,
-0.0445193462,
0.031286709,
-0.023259867,
-0.0670590028,
0.0151566984,
0.0821054354,
0.0480570048,
-0.0084563121,
0.0364524014,
0.0251147542,
0.0248723347,
0.0315120928,
-0.0034274606,
-0.0389372259,
0.0320495963,
0.009242557,
0.0381803624,
-0.0898488164,
0.0518863015,
0.0571748987,
-0.0223129932,
0.0179862566,
0.0000023386,
-0.0265059415,
-0.0549793169,
-0.021127034,
0.0375329219,
-0.0123653095,
0.0836900473,
-0.0613264255,
-0.0001546721,
0.0243352614,
-0.0712167099,
-0.028532099,
0.0364227891,
0.1041298583,
0.0790788308,
0.0732359514,
-0.0385403857,
-0.0103100976,
-0.0188499689,
-0.0022015432,
-0.0245111473,
-0.0288565904,
0.0733458996,
-0.0395100974,
-0.0249707457,
-0.0586176142,
-0.0154861258,
0.0081535485,
-0.0272677466,
0.050506141,
-0.0405765437,
-0.009239722,
-0.0143392812,
-0.0457389913,
-0.0075779296,
0.0743411705,
-0.0128276898,
-0.0057701147,
0.0298627988,
-0.0252439957,
-0.0126653137,
0.0239518881,
-0.0095483223,
0.0083053103,
-0.0077551459,
0.036166884,
0.0161795169,
0.0165535305,
0.00751684,
0.0421033539,
0.0013442516,
0.0287201684,
-0.0430861972,
-0.049817007,
0.0184946992,
-0.0203188807,
-0.0533293895,
-0.0592654757,
0.047375232,
0.0125233913,
0.0140274977,
0.0357718803,
-0.048836749,
-0.1052345335,
0.0023370949,
-0.0652944893,
-0.0231551547,
0.0233889241,
-0.0419882014,
-0.0283209402,
0.0363411307,
-0.0011058951,
0.0056829094,
0.045609761,
-0.0101800924,
0.0171846226,
-0.0629121065,
0.0113907149,
-0.0295708962,
0.0386464186,
0.0178569313,
-0.0144265778,
-0.0817528516,
-0.0066271345,
-0.0388470404,
-0.0454274677,
-0.0337200351,
-0.0151830735,
-0.003290233,
0.0001425065,
0.011350709,
0.0014101014,
-0.0189988613,
0.0298465751,
-0.0140713966,
-0.0082168607,
0.0420756862,
-0.0071346359,
0.0284731798,
-0.0125914225,
0.0205965452,
0.022590844,
0.0224770121,
-0.0200740248,
-0.0540583134,
-0.0275335945,
-0.0307480581,
-0.0195097588,
-0.0042959973,
-0.012613738,
0.0039934525,
-0.0165126268,
0.021213118,
-0.0574596077,
0.0387508348,
0.0082271034,
-0.0473558158,
0.0674079284,
-0.0349638015,
-0.0118975928,
-0.0054495116,
0.0558107458,
0.0323361643,
0.0602317415,
0.0225890484,
0.0291047972,
0.0901966691,
-0.0140588135,
0.0031551274,
0.0163353365,
0.0239335746,
-0.0396395661,
-0.0060906075,
-0.010427041,
-0.0277424809,
-0.0177438967,
-0.0174885895,
0.0151182171,
-0.0035618693,
0.0072829099,
0.0472587794,
0.0602598563,
-0.0156784672,
0.0428845733,
-0.0444090106,
0.0477500707,
-0.0097804153,
-0.0065102233,
-0.0326088294,
-0.0092774397,
-0.0644888282,
-0.0089750448,
-0.0169360358,
0.0116306841,
-0.0376396067,
-0.0643798336,
-0.0432898402,
-0.0239576194,
0.0473081544,
-0.0033349518,
0.0027085284,
-0.000617157,
-0.0101926168,
0.0161222573,
0.0555827096,
-0.0565868244,
-0.0197430719,
-0.0347718932,
-0.0045413892,
0.0662224442,
0.011670256,
-0.048901923,
0.0110362414,
-0.0142253265,
0.0273369942,
0.0388552435,
-0.0005859277,
0.0164903961,
-0.0176092107,
-0.0339689292,
-0.0192976147,
0.0295825358,
0.0073506939,
-0.0156014152,
0.0273866337,
0.0540019609,
-0.0113796573,
0.0291433558,
-0.0344401225,
0.0440875404,
-0.035123989,
-0.0450913757,
0.0084176864,
0.0111623863,
0.0647072196,
0.0281118974,
-0.0255608968,
0.0045347572,
0.0117311589,
-0.0071126642,
-0.0896172076,
0.0171570722,
-0.0186155867,
-0.0340909138,
0.027259903,
-0.0336827375,
0.0226804819,
0.0946003273,
-0.0556994528,
-0.0100693377,
0.0464277789,
0.0242238641,
0.0347893089,
-0.0390443578,
-0.0007010797,
-0.0364464298,
0.0545643196,
0.0162583794,
0.0433442444,
-0.0318128839,
0.0136263305,
-0.0239596218,
-0.0330702029,
-0.0070002023,
0.0107198311,
-0.0438927487,
-0.0446444601,
-0.0100945793,
0.0299625136,
-0.0116168922,
0.0203179084,
-0.0308605321,
-0.0188976675,
-0.1077506915,
0.0118633462,
-0.0394122675,
-0.0200734958,
0.0235264283,
-0.0221187994,
-0.0424192436,
-0.0146176945,
-0.0248565674,
0.0290176161,
0.0104315858,
0.0281448308,
-0.0050651706,
-0.0156165939,
0.0228049885,
-0.0414056554,
0.0051089837,
-0.0394959003,
0.0003010224,
0.0006207379,
-0.0766892806,
0.0186837856,
0.0162934288,
-0.0396297686,
0.0269709695,
-0.0165361874,
-0.076092802,
-0.0364411362,
0.021416964,
0.0046768896,
0.0116693471,
0.0335455649,
0.0532456003,
0.0193644967,
0.0290617514,
0.0130776158,
0.0059632943,
-0.0230446532,
-0.0222298242,
-0.0223464482,
-0.0569483973,
-0.002780112,
0.0696832314,
0.0580914803,
-0.0176380612,
-0.0486827046,
-0.0092092194,
-0.0400214568,
-0.0383657441,
-0.0208857208,
-0.0038921314,
-0.0169493724,
0.0094924597,
-0.0204265099,
-0.013350985,
0.0535582416,
0.0405037962,
0.0246179625,
-0.0439505056,
-0.0386357158,
-0.0242651887,
0.0411807857,
0.0150703508,
0.0213295911,
0.08272136,
0.0170290954,
0.0061011617,
-0.0255339704,
-0.0300553218,
-0.047966402,
-0.0437238216,
0.0054603699,
-0.0121273268,
0.0292862821,
-0.0311177876,
-0.0228193719,
-0.0957549661,
-0.0426333733,
-0.0079352716,
0.0073547671,
0.0199779943,
0.0046774298,
0.0091174515,
0.0071716993,
0.00912531,
-0.0101365838,
-0.0242624115,
0.0167497583,
-0.0007410876,
0.0516914576,
-0.0363455378,
0.0362813696,
-0.0221132338,
0.0377600081,
0.0652202964,
0.0339288339,
0.0238669999,
0.0551136732,
0.0049281386,
-0.009127453,
0.0029862442,
-0.0085630035,
0.0033924202,
0.0391277596,
-0.0186458416,
0.0136443358,
0.1247505695,
0.0313178338,
-0.0072084651,
0.0226101354,
-0.0053186757,
-0.0229501259,
0.022994766,
-0.0207725279,
-0.0694031864,
-0.014783985,
-0.0259393919,
0.0253775716,
-0.0431618579,
-0.0305530131,
0.0133566828,
-0.0566169955,
0.0214891117,
0.0041857851,
0.0183468629,
0.0180073231,
-0.030693423,
0.0138405478,
-0.0135466382,
-0.008177137,
-0.068013899,
0.0013610849,
-0.0253366493,
0.0073558418,
-0.0715881735,
-0.0516872108,
0.0452831388,
-0.0185693782,
0.0345287435,
0.0287830699,
0.0781448856,
-0.0060917693,
-0.0463465936,
-0.008488954,
0.0098806862,
-0.0072765751,
-0.0230621714,
0.1012386456,
-0.0061505875,
-0.0060567479,
-0.0422148071,
0.0610276386,
-0.0556180738,
-0.009381162,
0.0172548946,
0.0394358933,
0.0144268833,
-0.0322870761,
-0.025843136,
0.0515887663,
0.0356498249,
0.0683710724,
0.0065700663,
-0.0726806223,
0.0129650421,
-0.0144687397,
0.0171223748,
-0.0420967303,
-0.0709819794,
0.0340397395,
-0.0534121618,
-0.0211018007,
-0.0641717911,
-0.0434814841,
-0.0075145974,
-0.0103465039,
-0.0083786976,
-0.0276706237,
0.0583016649,
0.0091518816,
-0.0657087192,
0.0214062501,
-0.0032295641,
0.0098089967,
-0.0149960425,
-0.0290811881,
0.0211468562,
-0.0003092941,
0.0116626257,
0.0124780033,
-0.0410609804,
-0.0349738114,
0.0609982312,
-0.0150373261,
0.003906725,
-0.0180132296,
0.0087755183,
-0.0466921777,
0.0736634731,
0.0158494562,
-0.0360503979,
-0.0117587289,
0.0500974953,
0.027288679,
0.001592688,
0.0267358385,
0.0144509058,
0.05796507,
0.0620209351,
-0.0164068919,
-0.0395000689,
0.0097469399,
0.0071582682,
0.0104687568,
0.0512376167,
-0.0092354519,
-0.0712469667,
-0.0377312899,
-0.0278828368,
-0.0344317108,
-0.0314457044,
-0.0189327188,
-0.0367972739,
0.0473031029,
0.015981866,
-0.0593801029,
-0.0187789146,
-0.0324718319,
-0.0228036214,
-0.073164925,
0.0289410986,
-0.0153889963,
0.0464471951,
-0.0085117687,
0.0142339924,
-0.0008783672,
0.008223651,
0.0117865633,
-0.0074820137,
-0.0086011225,
0.0668447241,
-0.0060896939,
0.0061363014,
0.0407953486,
0.0172469858,
-0.0356611647,
-0.0343633182,
-0.0338326767,
-0.0404439084,
0.0243973956,
-0.019834049,
0.0463406257,
-0.0326371975,
0.0014002273,
-0.0064958814,
0.0157170873,
-0.0322359614,
-0.0440082364,
0.0164825488,
-0.0213771779,
-0.0428525917,
0.0011575175,
0.0730119795,
0.0041252193,
0.0302070547,
0.0565835834,
-0.0435565636,
-0.0292302985,
0.0397162326,
0.058158949,
0.0647119805,
-0.0141412579,
0.031829033,
-0.0494587086,
-0.066270113,
0.0647453815,
-0.0668807402,
-0.0208736155,
0.0001023012,
0.0132270157,
0.0442736447,
0.0044282107,
0.0095763272,
-0.0573001504,
0.0078667561,
-0.0202691723,
-0.0328115262,
0.002997292,
-6.660112219e-33,
0.0114322323,
-0.0213157106,
-0.0237825792,
0.0154768582,
0.0096902959,
0.0051387409,
-0.0123479022,
0.0160054099,
-0.0151633527,
0.0257710554,
0.000128219,
0.0469417945,
0.0040294328,
0.0511457659,
-0.0076387175,
0.0101819104,
0.0364203081,
-0.0065745935,
0.0149090551,
0.0072005102,
0.0439361371,
0.0751194581,
0.0588565655,
-0.1223196983,
0.0303411502,
0.0038802542,
-0.012840122,
-0.0219605565,
0.0660806373,
0.042053286,
-0.0390147828,
0.0680907741,
0.0387246907,
0.0094399946,
-0.0084908009,
0.0406183712,
-0.0495809279,
-0.0408729613,
-0.0182031989,
0.0029018114,
-0.0060459394,
0.0106315389,
0.0053317463,
-0.0177106783,
0.0101317633,
-0.009396499,
0.0450056382,
-0.0328560919,
0.0517284125,
-0.0267775357,
-0.0355407707,
0.0265855305,
0.0204127673,
0.0289597455,
-0.0048387214,
0.066722095,
-0.0269748066,
0.0306499004,
-0.0989982486,
-0.0195917021,
0.0303510986,
0.0089382483,
-0.0052607693,
-0.0326499119,
0.0227293689,
0.0588679798,
0.013273878,
0.0077983332,
0.0043541538,
0.0318419337,
0.0324772112,
0.0111779412,
0.0404132158,
0.0639714226,
0.033460632,
-0.0867876261,
-0.0656224489,
0.0090880096,
0.0153662777,
-0.0345196687,
0.0471992232,
0.0201723278,
-0.0228857026,
-0.018024262,
0.0073624887,
-0.0041709538,
-0.0319770724,
-0.0143265817,
-0.0018066657,
0.0139269,
-0.0444517434,
0.0115915453,
-0.007471357,
-0.0490935408,
-0.0279088076,
0.0107672103,
0.0053795506,
0.0215206258,
-0.0033435563,
0.0204752963,
-0.0599565916,
-0.0168485977,
0.0026415873,
0.0148941819,
0.0409240313,
-0.0202330593,
0.0560067184,
0.0160352178,
-0.0777828097,
-0.0102166235,
0.0260994993,
0.027108537,
0.0428742729,
0.030240206,
-0.0322459601,
0.0292795021,
-0.0054955403,
0.0038469795,
0.064616926,
-0.0002256227,
-0.056934081,
-0.0344018079,
-0.015508798,
0.0074070767,
-0.0157275256,
-0.0312501006,
-0.0171327088,
0.0132176727,
0.0602019764,
-0.0653102472,
-0.0113305785,
-0.0304348357,
2.966e-7,
0.0277195405,
0.0282058045,
-0.0236186553,
0.0049128062,
0.017404614,
0.0449357554,
0.022792941,
0.0468110368,
0.0062075034,
-0.0153211085,
0.0240320675,
0.0341336392,
0.0408747531,
0.0472797044,
-0.017571792,
-0.0310481489,
-0.0147430953,
-0.0148037085,
-0.0406145416,
0.0359985158,
0.0438831709,
0.096378468,
0.0322764553,
-0.0035725918,
-0.0236154422,
-0.025968736,
0.0468689799,
-0.0273464657,
-0.0014013723,
0.0452109836,
0.0236153677,
0.0389219932,
-0.0100059016,
-0.0210116487,
-0.0332465023,
0.0163114015,
0.0045058755,
0.0484636612,
-0.0020017356,
-0.0101339882,
0.0220691916,
0.0174594782,
-0.0070729135,
-0.0304587912,
0.0589170046,
-0.0762612894,
-0.0518263169,
-0.0228512175,
0.0041186865,
-0.0244000498,
0.0581865273,
-0.027830895,
-0.0176186115,
0.0524616726,
0.0335579105,
0.0130518368,
-0.0059093647,
-0.0791966319,
-0.0330015123,
0.0065514129,
-0.0274603926,
0.002324143,
-0.0029803272,
-0.0021102207,
0.0002900566,
-0.0654957071,
0.0602511019,
2.712601529e-34,
0.008465399,
0.0017587713,
-0.0232636761,
-0.0046896832,
0.0363519713,
0.0017467772,
-0.0318938158,
0.0012366599,
-0.0161857065,
-0.0626136363,
-0.0009240078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09141v1 | Advancing NLP Models with Strategic Text Augmentation: A Comprehensive Study of Augmentation Methods and Curriculum Strategies | 2024-02-14T12:41:09 | 2024-02-14T12:41:09 | Himmet Toprak Kesgin, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study conducts a thorough evaluation of text augmentation techniques
across a variety of datasets and natural language processing (NLP) tasks to
address the lack of reliable, generalized evidence for these methods. It
examines the effectiveness of these techniques in augmenting training sets to
improve performance in tasks such as topic classification, sentiment analysis,
and offensive language detection. The research emphasizes not only the
augmentation methods, but also the strategic order in which real and augmented
instances are introduced during training. A major contribution is the
development and evaluation of Modified Cyclical Curriculum Learning (MCCL) for
augmented datasets, which represents a novel approach in the field. Results
show that specific augmentation methods, especially when integrated with MCCL,
significantly outperform traditional training approaches in NLP model
performance. These results underscore the need for careful selection of
augmentation techniques and sequencing strategies to optimize the balance
between speed and quality improvement in various NLP tasks. The study concludes
that the use of augmentation methods, especially in conjunction with MCCL,
leads to improved results in various classification tasks, providing a
foundation for future advances in text augmentation strategies in NLP. | [
0.0850216374,
0.0449982323,
-0.034593612,
0.0072891675,
-0.0287312064,
0.0423337258,
0.0154684698,
-0.0326649807,
-0.0112598566,
-0.0691860244,
0.0079802945,
0.0067263525,
-0.0409126095,
-0.0133505166,
0.0041055079,
-0.0495428294,
0.0490461178,
0.036998976,
0.0099472655,
0.0012458689,
0.0189576652,
0.0159492195,
-0.0075911107,
0.0129388366,
-0.0076443944,
-0.0218764003,
0.0015109428,
-0.0168870594,
0.0377658084,
-0.0261072814,
0.036551971,
0.0347578228,
0.0328370444,
0.040149983,
0.0000020575,
-0.0539096445,
-0.0353335328,
-0.007192018,
-0.0149025377,
-0.0117035452,
0.1179043949,
-0.0087412084,
0.0185954403,
0.0350428186,
-0.0486717261,
0.0397168472,
0.0241241921,
0.060594175,
0.0617797039,
0.0639385059,
-0.0263157673,
-0.0283383373,
0.0205581766,
0.0147218583,
-0.032154765,
0.0129587129,
0.0483861379,
0.0375124626,
0.0043977275,
0.0662055984,
-0.0030283402,
-0.0026847392,
0.0345909223,
0.0126480414,
0.0927523896,
0.0254456215,
-0.0264371224,
0.0159757994,
-0.0141606601,
0.0076606809,
-0.0172339976,
-0.0258318894,
-0.0165039394,
-0.0220581237,
-0.0083909063,
-0.0401968062,
-0.0339251868,
-0.028706884,
-0.0118615683,
0.0190818831,
0.0448623337,
-0.0258968454,
-0.0065036169,
0.0526861623,
0.0173797812,
0.038701199,
-0.0143531961,
-0.0914294496,
0.0201930255,
0.0402754657,
0.0344381966,
-0.025373647,
0.0069401772,
0.0317371599,
0.0193639044,
0.0531654917,
-0.04830442,
-0.0402617678,
0.033035703,
-0.0624786988,
0.0176475178,
0.0105878329,
-0.0507046282,
0.019914059,
-0.018794192,
0.0227554012,
0.0295273196,
0.0440107808,
-0.044871863,
0.0599458478,
-0.0855242312,
-0.0142645882,
-0.0218060017,
0.0181607325,
-0.0011224104,
0.008387737,
-0.0837640837,
0.0268727932,
-0.0125475321,
0.0006610493,
0.0074705528,
0.0068585034,
-0.0432637483,
0.0369305536,
-0.0261861477,
0.0242401212,
-0.013509498,
0.0600574054,
-0.0485112928,
-0.0076051485,
0.0002180738,
0.0074908799,
0.0333040319,
-0.0119979344,
0.0328641087,
0.0111103887,
-0.0194147713,
-0.0600125976,
-0.0425484441,
0.0064118365,
-0.050231941,
-0.0195713043,
-0.0036336761,
-0.0796630457,
0.0084564211,
-0.0228885487,
-0.0192380231,
0.0248580743,
0.0027811008,
0.0142259309,
-0.0214397572,
0.0592482463,
-0.0448494926,
-0.0173822269,
0.0301515311,
-0.0088668158,
0.0347399339,
0.0726624429,
0.0311071798,
0.0246806778,
0.0581298955,
-0.0058168275,
-0.0126670757,
0.0143427998,
-0.0110623669,
0.0036000882,
-0.0268701594,
0.0076343254,
-0.0141787371,
0.0085798558,
-0.0043403478,
-0.0207874756,
-0.037737105,
-0.0005001012,
0.032161776,
0.0036417858,
-0.0055448962,
0.0009429143,
0.0214154832,
-0.0056178849,
0.0334752463,
0.0099256802,
-0.0245024636,
-0.0425966009,
-0.0215017647,
-0.0068536494,
-0.0137234237,
0.0116335377,
-0.0033014356,
-0.098001413,
-0.0327256508,
0.0070121731,
0.0592165701,
-0.0142021561,
0.0353667997,
0.0232858323,
0.0116836233,
-0.0954273194,
0.0828920454,
-0.0291417427,
0.0273985658,
-0.0060346355,
-0.0311700571,
0.1003632918,
0.0260033552,
-0.052977778,
-0.1067960113,
-0.0331422761,
0.041617129,
0.0348436609,
0.0145894885,
-0.0257961247,
0.0046574054,
-0.047483813,
-0.0219095889,
-0.0282523278,
0.0170679223,
0.0193107929,
0.0503929369,
-0.005368338,
-0.0105224205,
0.0076869004,
-0.094477661,
0.0540495403,
-0.0191022065,
-0.0691542104,
0.0231939163,
0.0217258241,
0.0058805789,
0.0379870459,
0.0029679462,
-0.0217148066,
0.0312450137,
-0.0147976596,
-0.0367634855,
0.018747028,
-0.0222781505,
-0.0550287999,
0.0276287775,
0.0145244896,
-0.0237941742,
-0.0007723244,
-0.0409914628,
-0.0078723207,
0.0050287526,
-0.0189916696,
0.0320980884,
-0.0388807319,
0.0076899324,
-0.0482469536,
0.0010212376,
-0.0514680259,
0.0605468266,
0.0103083486,
-0.0026094471,
0.0103111099,
-0.0132349525,
-0.0010570104,
-0.031406913,
-0.038042739,
-0.0198485758,
0.0027700365,
0.0095472503,
0.0073108776,
0.0090489928,
-0.0685401037,
-0.0319536813,
-0.1099885702,
-0.0080307024,
-0.0206817761,
0.0196332093,
0.0296586696,
-0.0408593416,
-0.0134415217,
0.000316435,
-0.0113029405,
-0.0195163209,
-0.0090419119,
0.0691594705,
0.0375851318,
0.0099794678,
-0.0097377673,
-0.0126287965,
-0.0181526653,
-0.0304818489,
0.0184857827,
0.0306544751,
0.0312656797,
-0.0202655457,
-0.0135122053,
-0.0010068044,
0.0032795523,
-0.0147319939,
-0.0004722198,
0.0063180057,
0.0364442803,
0.0236361492,
0.0457843021,
0.0033677453,
0.0600587092,
0.0299779996,
0.0375655219,
-0.0213979334,
0.0119956667,
-0.0364921652,
-0.0463518538,
-0.0277405009,
-0.0215035584,
-0.0063860831,
0.0554496944,
-0.0187834203,
-0.0250642858,
-0.0408873186,
-0.0103198644,
-0.0302061513,
-0.0438537449,
-0.0629188716,
-0.0569591038,
-0.0195991378,
-0.0088722939,
-0.0224895179,
-0.040774744,
0.0733817741,
0.0227150023,
0.0058804885,
-0.1075058803,
-0.0591690056,
-0.0349998139,
0.0225137416,
0.0276313201,
-0.0066415048,
0.0274128392,
-0.024289852,
-0.0268630441,
-0.0117467865,
0.0120614339,
-0.0377050452,
0.0010254078,
-0.0059118248,
-0.0296215657,
0.0344997793,
-0.0248627048,
-0.0871068761,
-0.0034229662,
0.0124685755,
-0.0095425351,
0.0318676531,
0.0386947915,
-0.0299650002,
-0.0418492965,
0.0069455341,
0.0316715501,
-0.0151966056,
-0.0273638498,
-0.0045054788,
0.0129678361,
0.046245791,
0.0090699643,
0.0052927001,
-0.0096746385,
-0.036592897,
0.0159687009,
0.0668492094,
-0.0729187354,
-0.0299009196,
0.0245236922,
0.0088784462,
-0.0516280942,
-0.0156186046,
0.014246135,
-0.0186811201,
-0.0622935779,
-0.0181465205,
0.0803025961,
0.0357363634,
-0.0464080311,
0.0124141788,
0.015352645,
-0.0077279517,
0.0430002846,
0.01981299,
-0.033911936,
0.0008730287,
-0.0255820248,
0.0402256735,
-0.0603945963,
-0.0143780382,
-0.0226342604,
-0.0975231007,
-0.0267607197,
-0.0136882523,
-0.0142802913,
0.0068594483,
-0.0794615224,
0.0014013893,
-0.0420433991,
0.0322395861,
-0.0377847292,
-0.0262134485,
0.0109635768,
0.0528036281,
-0.0594285727,
-0.0772159398,
-0.017654052,
0.010047623,
0.0250881482,
0.0141510703,
0.0253129415,
-0.0335411504,
0.0040135095,
0.0421439223,
0.0012595332,
0.0328351371,
0.0071680802,
0.0423831679,
-0.0537590384,
0.0054322323,
0.0111809727,
0.0212835018,
0.0170800872,
-0.0100379726,
0.022483835,
0.0843094513,
0.0329641327,
0.0339242071,
-0.0396804474,
0.0086447531,
-0.0021500133,
0.0402984805,
-0.005164382,
-0.0687548667,
0.0344616957,
0.0067359,
0.011220092,
-0.0551291443,
0.0063966946,
0.0017659983,
-0.0453346148,
-0.0088754874,
-0.0524156503,
-0.0897190422,
0.0339455158,
0.027340984,
0.0138695873,
0.0225148611,
0.0009169988,
-0.022973394,
-0.0579661131,
0.0094906976,
-0.0096017793,
-0.0063571204,
-0.0170591474,
-0.0534286238,
-0.0321103819,
-0.0557542555,
-0.0382776037,
-0.0329528935,
-0.0722989216,
-0.0635498017,
0.0284758341,
0.0324993171,
0.0096966643,
0.0762877539,
0.0135464137,
-0.0549250022,
0.0249416549,
0.0752610266,
-0.0252933092,
-0.011888166,
0.0388048887,
0.0012015029,
0.0029101945,
-0.0131341405,
-0.0098609738,
0.0379651673,
0.0267712045,
0.0059255143,
-0.0204471759,
0.0161077045,
0.0237995181,
0.0109059326,
0.0736088529,
-0.0123852724,
-0.05331067,
-0.0536522381,
0.0235537142,
-0.0159749836,
-0.0468580313,
0.0267502442,
0.0034232801,
0.0119753275,
0.0311713871,
-0.0616327673,
0.0000626139,
-0.0270240773,
0.0238987394,
-0.0482193306,
0.0149028078,
-0.0089278398,
0.0137642333,
-0.0051237703,
0.0328501798,
-0.0250535347,
0.0274279341,
0.0231686067,
-0.0038250664,
-0.0059082266,
0.0229721423,
0.0117153833,
0.0301649366,
-0.0131405294,
0.0278044268,
-0.076006189,
0.0888716131,
-0.0343380496,
0.0020964819,
0.0257340074,
-0.0584673546,
0.0260406956,
-0.0430160835,
-0.0171749778,
0.0127852131,
-0.0151460236,
-0.006400723,
-0.0659824908,
0.0054048393,
0.0350688286,
-0.0291672032,
-0.0183494929,
0.0404339135,
0.004490539,
0.0393004529,
0.0124857379,
-0.0098142941,
-0.0347346663,
-0.0175783057,
0.0485694781,
0.0524662063,
-0.0114455856,
0.0503094196,
-0.0410539508,
-0.0262947995,
0.0477553643,
-0.0439206176,
0.0279822629,
-0.0237205736,
0.0092841852,
0.0594844706,
-0.0099901343,
0.0137796877,
-0.0129761538,
0.0151674543,
0.0539245009,
-0.0164590664,
-0.0134219062,
-5.913494044e-33,
-0.0013375174,
-0.0103841424,
0.0400314443,
0.0136485882,
-0.0078431815,
0.0244105011,
0.0569259375,
0.0137594184,
0.0154427709,
0.017525984,
-0.0208411664,
0.0109026777,
0.0069590067,
0.0183336884,
0.018775152,
0.0065667876,
0.0540851541,
0.0164215658,
-0.0186939482,
-0.0018006088,
0.0347803421,
0.0381977893,
0.0961085781,
-0.0809499323,
0.0438410975,
0.0182822384,
0.0056341551,
0.0018087658,
0.0397749171,
0.0653537065,
-0.0053102421,
0.09452115,
0.0568484962,
-0.0417149365,
0.0168762039,
-0.0174199846,
-0.0635795668,
-0.0465310588,
0.0330760628,
0.0272947978,
-0.0208089612,
-0.0242536645,
0.0297205783,
0.0018076209,
-0.0334322117,
-0.0256200116,
0.0553505942,
-0.0585123263,
-0.0058742505,
-0.0430881754,
-0.0830597878,
0.0261314418,
0.0016035142,
0.0237233471,
-0.0004244811,
0.0126912193,
0.0060276254,
0.0187233109,
-0.0632202625,
0.0223657191,
0.0309172515,
0.0339283645,
0.0032753542,
0.0054912418,
-0.0210201032,
0.056116499,
-0.0078660334,
0.0712900013,
-0.0272176657,
0.0217337906,
0.0655290559,
-0.0092990883,
0.0297083091,
0.0730062053,
0.0636313111,
-0.0224102437,
-0.0223587677,
0.0333441235,
0.011373817,
0.0167009681,
0.0276424624,
-0.0131009119,
-0.0624910817,
-0.0217228476,
-0.0062901876,
0.0287011713,
-0.0153377345,
-0.015269978,
0.0242472868,
0.0503228009,
-0.0475904197,
0.0501558669,
-0.0382818989,
-0.0324368849,
0.0078486465,
0.0446187332,
-0.02234287,
0.0005874189,
0.0090141008,
0.0116646132,
-0.0916824862,
-0.0371640623,
0.0461445749,
-0.0000062402,
0.0186418854,
-0.0335778296,
0.1067177057,
0.0163063966,
-0.0721433088,
-0.0008910263,
0.0120917577,
0.0348173417,
0.0216330402,
0.012605926,
0.0364920534,
0.0442397632,
-0.0133937849,
0.0435375832,
0.083861582,
0.0095234653,
-0.0413572639,
-0.0451630354,
-0.0050371489,
0.0075200014,
0.0143609578,
-0.0023747152,
0.0172297079,
0.0130810784,
-0.0153147886,
-0.0769010037,
-0.0146303587,
-0.0204913877,
2.696e-7,
0.0311487485,
0.0917327479,
0.0028199276,
-0.0468440279,
0.0133979851,
-0.0040083621,
-0.0200260896,
0.0272117909,
0.0335661061,
-0.0071874182,
0.0110432664,
0.0208148491,
0.0026127736,
0.0051238895,
-0.0219541825,
-0.0048484057,
-0.0742997825,
0.0261454545,
-0.0399665311,
0.0373470969,
0.078617081,
0.0673133731,
0.045996394,
-0.0188880824,
-0.0221904181,
0.0015521457,
0.0283404328,
0.0104122637,
-0.0011081272,
0.0184203982,
0.0130511587,
0.050237447,
0.0051887198,
0.0504219159,
-0.039583724,
0.0485366769,
-0.0004395471,
0.0261917412,
-0.0240843054,
0.0180133134,
0.0024435308,
0.0282789152,
-0.0397552066,
-0.0602140687,
0.0747838393,
-0.0575247332,
-0.0072893947,
-0.0259367749,
-0.0593483001,
0.0484018214,
0.0143578118,
-0.0055981791,
-0.0332710743,
0.0086858962,
0.0063436273,
0.0101828342,
-0.0264364406,
-0.088225618,
0.001861321,
0.0367116816,
-0.0088611962,
-0.0380511358,
-0.0198551435,
0.0116671948,
0.0251705386,
-0.0589779839,
0.0156095829,
2.782874051e-34,
0.0266170483,
-0.0123135271,
0.027883755,
-0.0435757525,
-0.0129097933,
0.014096343,
0.014266761,
0.0171835572,
0.0177333746,
-0.0570072867,
-0.005492277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09136v1 | DolphCoder: Echo-Locating Code Large Language Models with Diverse and Multi-Objective Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-14T12:34:58 | 2024-02-14T12:34:58 | Yejie Wang, Keqing He, Guanting Dong, Pei Wang, Weihao Zeng, Muxi Diao, Yutao Mou, Mengdi Zhang, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Code Large Language Models (Code LLMs) have demonstrated outstanding
performance in code-related tasks. Several instruction tuning approaches have
been proposed to boost the code generation performance of pre-trained Code
LLMs. In this paper, we introduce a diverse instruction model (DolphCoder) with
self-evaluating for code generation. It learns diverse instruction targets and
combines a code evaluation objective to enhance its code generation ability.
Our model achieves superior performance on the HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks,
demonstrating new insights for future code instruction tuning work. Our key
findings are: (1) Augmenting more diverse responses with distinct reasoning
paths increases the code capability of LLMs. (2) Improving one's ability to
evaluate the correctness of code solutions also enhances their ability to
create it. | [
0.0121838087,
0.0913997516,
0.0103255063,
-0.0218817033,
-0.0036945266,
0.0291077904,
-0.0179204196,
-0.0081388736,
-0.0162978042,
-0.0053595151,
-0.0474040024,
-0.0078079565,
-0.0390833244,
0.0055847764,
0.0366463289,
0.0083440635,
0.0536972992,
-0.0456731096,
-0.0511128753,
-0.0102586448,
-0.0257774126,
0.008461548,
0.0157289114,
0.0521166287,
0.0159253925,
-0.0400633737,
-0.0358240046,
0.0400969014,
-0.0252091866,
-0.0296220556,
0.0386491008,
0.0507320464,
0.0136312181,
-0.0041336357,
0.0000020036,
-0.0300506148,
-0.0170875024,
-0.0096256873,
-0.0053784912,
0.0207594447,
0.0050739055,
0.020115979,
-0.0096256621,
0.0460113734,
-0.0086194258,
-0.0159152169,
0.0644007996,
-0.0427949205,
0.0780083537,
0.0885394663,
0.0242279153,
-0.0286664851,
0.0014508805,
-0.0201149695,
0.0677298307,
-0.0274654031,
-0.0047779991,
0.0193444267,
0.0051949858,
0.0266505405,
-0.0044061532,
0.0065589109,
0.0560729951,
0.0035172233,
0.0287985113,
0.0352675207,
0.0001547823,
-0.0065257368,
-0.0299763903,
0.0196625516,
-0.055742953,
-0.0193102714,
0.007502065,
-0.0135122156,
-0.0116313742,
-0.1078487933,
-0.0090922629,
0.0396901593,
0.001517753,
0.003526961,
0.0136881042,
-0.0169172157,
0.0207912549,
0.0153081277,
-0.0263622887,
0.0451753326,
0.017019473,
-0.0223348346,
-0.0223061107,
0.0029313776,
0.006022593,
-0.0338181555,
0.0028728186,
0.0862030089,
-0.0376988538,
0.0187132694,
-0.0486485586,
0.0055472343,
0.0137812244,
-0.0177583098,
0.0974452421,
0.0591120534,
-0.0332466066,
-0.0004303866,
-0.0611007661,
0.048225008,
-0.0402808636,
0.0033481484,
-0.0496764481,
0.0200221445,
-0.051457461,
0.0116021037,
-0.0269983336,
0.0556594357,
-0.02833304,
0.0320315138,
-0.0693110079,
0.0474874303,
0.0104495054,
0.0298028942,
-0.0088108312,
0.0030450206,
-0.0366273001,
-0.0011223459,
0.0249164812,
-0.0315218158,
-0.0214746241,
-0.0498099551,
-0.0060662464,
-0.0447561964,
-0.0086205294,
0.0360219926,
-0.0367324091,
-0.0332719758,
0.060424909,
0.0550651848,
-0.0189471934,
0.0052490355,
-0.0422321856,
-0.0264946148,
-0.0231501386,
-0.0423878767,
0.019607434,
-0.0791942254,
-0.0428994149,
-0.0230394583,
-0.0275079608,
-0.0556185581,
0.0247451961,
-0.0093325879,
0.0299285483,
0.0157198273,
-0.0327805392,
-0.0017898348,
0.0093059689,
0.0163226649,
0.016983524,
0.0473154821,
0.0146076903,
0.0237874798,
-0.0195568521,
-0.0253039971,
0.0161997788,
0.0316290781,
0.0074568894,
0.0092105856,
0.0175566226,
0.0255131274,
0.0314347632,
0.0177241378,
0.056841094,
0.0347520486,
-0.0143504124,
0.0199860297,
-0.0025803477,
-0.0011359762,
0.035777133,
0.0280118585,
0.1004686281,
-0.0019553832,
-0.0257020071,
-0.0054616504,
-0.0308175962,
0.0596588813,
0.0074912184,
0.022331072,
0.0142795173,
0.0301561896,
-0.0142916935,
-0.0731712431,
-0.0099860672,
-0.0190864373,
-0.031670209,
0.0136214877,
0.0078687491,
-0.0104247769,
-0.0713067502,
0.0242384337,
0.0074412841,
-0.0432618149,
-0.0175581835,
-0.0965768844,
0.014432352,
0.0337841734,
0.0257209167,
-0.0525964163,
-0.060832303,
-0.0133623816,
-0.0060763494,
0.0018322774,
0.0297814719,
0.0069666249,
0.0271489676,
-0.0500514843,
-0.011589352,
-0.072785303,
0.000972597,
0.0333784521,
0.0794052482,
-0.039173156,
0.0210806038,
0.0351185612,
-0.0577377342,
0.0539705344,
-0.0167356543,
-0.0303692874,
0.0187037345,
0.0056405379,
0.0238102283,
-0.0282632168,
-0.0348076411,
0.0348405316,
0.0044627902,
-0.0100591145,
-0.0083939536,
-0.0760066733,
-0.0705546215,
-0.0238544736,
0.0446158685,
-0.0266923159,
-0.0216320306,
0.0031171038,
-0.0048280819,
-0.023632668,
0.0309897345,
-0.0591742769,
0.0130921034,
-0.0185079221,
0.0347373188,
-0.033610113,
-0.0153081641,
-0.0315649472,
0.0533648245,
-0.0165061336,
0.0094341477,
0.0077020442,
0.0964387059,
0.0090887537,
-0.0118243191,
-0.0019860461,
-0.0114164036,
-0.0404862054,
0.04999974,
-0.0091391588,
0.0723552704,
-0.0239011999,
-0.0954094231,
-0.0699661821,
0.0474518314,
-0.0376937687,
-0.0185208861,
0.0147244427,
-0.0072543374,
0.0094159041,
-0.005346064,
-0.0251500458,
-0.0025436811,
-0.0062776357,
-0.0026773883,
0.010700888,
-0.0217153225,
-0.0544956289,
-0.0275007635,
-0.0109367222,
-0.0058798301,
0.0201020576,
-0.0302615166,
0.0606197976,
-0.076989755,
0.0697916225,
-0.017327195,
0.003612288,
0.017449012,
-0.0621740744,
0.041597534,
-0.0305017326,
0.0421870723,
0.0613994673,
-0.0006097059,
0.0412341058,
0.0740194619,
0.0102246897,
-0.0447964668,
0.0355130695,
0.0071733552,
-0.0738823414,
-0.0253666677,
-0.033597894,
0.0353505686,
0.0814738199,
-0.0021179798,
-0.0118426085,
-0.0630400255,
-0.0092166569,
0.0289765671,
-0.0501032732,
-0.0305893868,
-0.0291469246,
-0.0101134796,
0.0247380603,
-0.0102416193,
-0.1042787656,
0.0443019569,
-0.0093836132,
-0.0016024098,
-0.0452244952,
-0.0332986489,
-0.0520622432,
0.0281297341,
-0.0429240204,
0.04012914,
-0.0110717351,
-0.0432111733,
-0.0513617098,
-0.0031006653,
-0.0241404474,
-0.0356652811,
0.0300827269,
-0.0361913405,
-0.0139395446,
0.0157456622,
-0.0515334271,
-0.0538188033,
0.0023675452,
0.0267317947,
0.0113595184,
0.0544448718,
-0.0178830568,
0.0187852327,
-0.0096533904,
0.0184380449,
0.0294921193,
0.0098152515,
-0.0210773181,
-0.0265096128,
-0.0420351736,
0.0055598873,
-0.0206534527,
0.0218188632,
-0.0375004448,
-0.0050568478,
-0.0099602891,
0.0527243838,
0.0016049867,
-0.055560872,
0.0732618645,
0.0406397358,
-0.0203136429,
-0.0052896575,
0.0726271421,
0.0772455186,
-0.0329943188,
-0.0474575721,
0.1018113121,
0.041140113,
-0.0358711407,
0.0167791341,
-0.0127891535,
0.0490288138,
0.0566568896,
0.0672917664,
-0.0260952972,
-0.011142347,
-0.0156748015,
0.0283073001,
-0.0254482627,
-0.0056222049,
-0.0367150605,
-0.1067823023,
0.0218766667,
0.0285965689,
-0.0346647985,
-0.0632427484,
0.0118234865,
-0.0467010476,
0.0154202543,
-0.0081785591,
0.0507861748,
-0.0198232923,
0.0134757096,
0.0201474074,
0.0192486197,
0.0204292592,
0.0438233279,
-0.0245968848,
0.0490825437,
0.1140747517,
-0.0194036551,
0.0163924173,
0.0120566646,
0.0311413165,
-0.0099568376,
0.0489748158,
-0.0100478521,
-0.0052287444,
-0.0014149732,
-0.0123823294,
-0.0025334016,
0.0310253073,
-0.045447398,
0.0024067506,
0.0344719887,
0.0391518548,
-0.020867724,
-0.0109588122,
-0.0065554846,
0.0051262644,
-0.0057432111,
0.0066850348,
0.0271117836,
-0.0521882027,
-0.0463943742,
-0.0621769503,
-0.0263271704,
-0.0909034833,
0.0006420256,
0.0288526304,
-0.0178260673,
0.0009187983,
-0.043193996,
0.003063977,
0.0016646208,
0.0727818608,
0.0012513009,
-0.0401248001,
0.012519246,
-0.0103021711,
-0.0419330597,
-0.0155234337,
-0.0193815753,
-0.0119730895,
-0.0587552786,
-0.0268478282,
0.0319425911,
-0.04671048,
0.0090092337,
-0.0076697906,
-0.1023193449,
-0.0436568409,
0.0057736761,
0.0819194093,
0.014825156,
0.0388624221,
-0.0231028236,
-0.0541912988,
-0.0127957864,
-0.0031578557,
-0.0080068223,
0.0368063077,
0.0382265598,
0.0111148879,
0.0064019798,
0.0028893505,
-0.0377436578,
0.0298300739,
0.0699896589,
0.0089867236,
-0.0160172209,
0.0151796751,
0.0488846786,
0.0056672972,
-0.0275426023,
-0.0305960961,
-0.051358413,
-0.0051348736,
0.0079314243,
0.0317662284,
-0.007049791,
-0.0321159326,
0.0209265929,
0.0185314212,
-0.0253719371,
0.0252190642,
-0.0166310221,
0.0240152813,
0.0412916318,
-0.0138892466,
0.0695448518,
-0.013409934,
0.0196614228,
0.0585432574,
0.0048068604,
-0.0266336408,
0.0784396976,
-0.0029488297,
0.031638898,
0.0144671677,
0.0637684613,
-0.0144171445,
0.0330901965,
-0.009884892,
0.0086373799,
-0.0615090355,
-0.0446052477,
-0.0432075486,
0.0033998929,
0.0756748095,
0.0655807629,
-0.002841881,
-0.010850491,
0.0125851063,
-0.0043756175,
0.0417403392,
-0.0279107839,
-0.0340452939,
0.0034270503,
0.0306622908,
0.0003717111,
-0.0594118461,
0.0624012202,
0.0189637262,
0.0365220234,
-0.0035660092,
0.0332954414,
-0.0518070012,
-0.0061467621,
0.0394801572,
0.0163612571,
-0.0097318571,
0.0313971005,
0.0214115195,
-0.0615687929,
-0.0134388627,
0.0373667963,
0.0208255369,
-0.0068491735,
0.0371426865,
0.077595748,
-0.0363411456,
-0.0051717255,
-0.0324078389,
-0.0003620944,
0.0192714892,
-0.0165778752,
0.0084182192,
-6.235402437e-33,
-0.0303576477,
-0.0280287974,
0.0350788124,
-0.0578395128,
-0.0132382782,
0.0014770494,
-0.0290305465,
0.0059990096,
-0.0120952753,
-0.0528030731,
0.0175285116,
0.0438283868,
-0.0018178015,
-0.0018824649,
0.0431976579,
0.0277021509,
0.0468498208,
-0.0019823944,
-0.0327042304,
0.0161268953,
-0.0431177132,
0.0158174913,
-0.0077164439,
-0.0060088681,
-0.0331367776,
0.0092774155,
0.0068410961,
0.0121933501,
-0.0046352781,
0.0521364175,
-0.0055141696,
0.0271346122,
-0.013115203,
-0.0215370599,
-0.0330114216,
-0.04542052,
-0.0000711719,
-0.0294009633,
0.0002152114,
-0.0199213624,
0.0174018722,
-0.1074853241,
0.0513767675,
0.0118939159,
-0.0668962449,
-0.0273568723,
-0.0061150864,
0.0072393604,
0.011218491,
-0.0056473878,
-0.073847048,
0.0321202986,
-0.0131772179,
-0.0355768725,
-0.037620198,
-0.0286435504,
-0.0198737271,
0.0241796672,
-0.0010758613,
0.0265088808,
0.0152148977,
0.0678049251,
0.0504273288,
0.0234047771,
0.0036326954,
0.0119883558,
0.0864746049,
0.0302579515,
-0.0019132642,
0.0240628328,
0.0419137031,
0.0429590493,
0.0394350328,
0.0170058757,
0.020912461,
0.0019733554,
-0.0483037382,
-0.0128051126,
-0.0003797164,
-0.0017706335,
0.0729921535,
0.024015462,
-0.012899667,
0.0075650876,
-0.0300245434,
-0.0029759097,
-0.0335180871,
-0.0380294472,
0.0519665368,
0.0255953539,
-0.039251212,
0.0031730833,
0.0402782001,
-0.0195391774,
0.0313849263,
0.0119212279,
-0.0293715261,
0.0444473922,
-0.009983792,
0.0542816296,
-0.027083192,
-0.0381764434,
0.0544416457,
-0.0331634991,
0.0457530878,
0.0252826177,
0.0025094186,
0.0265087429,
-0.0784146637,
-0.0070345029,
-0.0525492951,
0.0083473343,
0.016208088,
0.0216256473,
0.0115136076,
-0.0088282796,
-0.0025443262,
0.024344895,
-0.0137408115,
-0.0381360091,
-0.0489628613,
-0.0135592185,
0.0104809226,
0.0627080724,
-0.0208541472,
0.0205591563,
-0.0468923338,
0.0112662772,
-0.0179350395,
-0.0286690425,
-0.0632952228,
0.0312715545,
2.729e-7,
0.0244612638,
0.03458656,
0.0055641001,
0.0502543785,
-0.0016588784,
0.0308046564,
-0.0239732675,
-0.0132290861,
-0.0007115201,
-0.0164295435,
-0.007459362,
0.0493851304,
0.0339208879,
0.0159414057,
-0.0059733079,
0.0155542428,
0.005459636,
0.0316104516,
-0.0598868057,
0.0190565791,
0.0251643863,
0.0870394483,
-0.0444843285,
-0.0030536312,
0.0391261354,
0.0171071067,
0.0123694716,
0.0197620653,
0.0003724741,
0.0319787078,
-0.0879097059,
0.0293820072,
-0.0140739465,
-0.020237226,
0.0100104865,
-0.0101753417,
0.0000309079,
0.0938372761,
-0.0066148173,
-0.0035987436,
0.0650075227,
0.015158332,
-0.0245657507,
-0.0717951134,
0.0365819447,
-0.0162463002,
0.0007693861,
-0.0376704112,
0.0263093114,
0.0005835702,
0.0032304665,
-0.0670008734,
0.0282305926,
0.0099004898,
-0.0057929251,
-0.0269241985,
-0.0106355678,
-0.0666562542,
-0.0392446741,
0.0200476572,
-0.0070418767,
-0.058376953,
-0.0730984509,
0.046187263,
0.0499749593,
-0.0480156988,
0.0122481678,
2.683672659e-34,
0.0180819761,
-0.035545174,
0.024946887,
0.0332945958,
0.0390293449,
0.0028112454,
-0.0502149388,
0.0201862399,
0.0243911818,
-0.0195586234,
-0.0426660031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09126v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09126v2 | MPIrigen: MPI Code Generation through Domain-Specific Language Models | 2024-02-14T12:24:21 | 2024-04-23T16:59:46 | Nadav Schneider, Niranjan Hasabnis, Vy A. Vo, Tal Kadosh, Neva Krien, Mihai Capotă, Guy Tamir, Ted Willke, Nesreen Ahmed, Yuval Pinter, Timothy Mattson, Gal Oren | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | The imperative need to scale computation across numerous nodes highlights the
significance of efficient parallel computing, particularly in the realm of
Message Passing Interface (MPI) integration. The challenging parallel
programming task of generating MPI-based parallel programs has remained
unexplored. This study first investigates the performance of state-of-the-art
language models in generating MPI-based parallel programs. Findings reveal that
widely used models such as GPT-3.5 and PolyCoder (specialized multi-lingual
code models) exhibit notable performance degradation, when generating MPI-based
programs compared to general-purpose programs. In contrast, domain-specific
models such as MonoCoder, which are pretrained on MPI-related programming
languages of C and C++, outperform larger models. Subsequently, we introduce a
dedicated downstream task of MPI-based program generation by fine-tuning
MonoCoder on HPCorpusMPI. We call the resulting model as MPIrigen. We propose
an innovative preprocessing for completion only after observing the whole code,
thus enabling better completion with a wider context. Comparative analysis
against GPT-3.5 zero-shot performance, using a novel HPC-oriented evaluation
method, demonstrates that MPIrigen excels in generating accurate MPI functions
up to 0.8 accuracy in location and function predictions, and with more than 0.9
accuracy for argument predictions. The success of this tailored solution
underscores the importance of domain-specific fine-tuning in optimizing
language models for parallel computing code generation, paving the way for a
new generation of automatic parallelization tools. The sources of this work are
available at our GitHub MPIrigen repository:
https://github.com/Scientific-Computing-Lab-NRCN/MPI-rigen | [
-0.0115674343,
0.0609950125,
-0.0124635985,
0.0007238814,
-0.0313704684,
0.0126540428,
-0.0092701977,
-0.0201917868,
-0.0376544259,
0.0065157143,
0.0234666057,
0.0087838061,
0.0278708506,
-0.0168309417,
0.0008609613,
-0.0248797406,
0.0511721894,
-0.0200540926,
-0.0431394055,
-0.0137135033,
-0.0292897932,
0.0581215955,
0.0048806397,
0.0405880399,
-0.0046565859,
-0.0546138547,
-0.0032831507,
0.0413438901,
-0.023798598,
0.0064486084,
0.0283711646,
0.0302464087,
0.0035878206,
0.0026788921,
0.0000025687,
-0.0223384071,
0.0266897399,
0.0337458551,
0.0587492026,
0.0722942427,
0.0397342704,
-0.0187667198,
0.007144921,
0.0069380598,
0.0333114453,
-0.0255988371,
0.0678299665,
-0.0590506792,
0.0334190726,
-0.0094117196,
0.0198420584,
0.0200723615,
0.0436994247,
0.0166054089,
-0.0466307364,
0.0125438469,
-0.0014499306,
0.0339623019,
0.007469675,
-0.013234796,
0.0331099033,
0.0197295733,
0.0155818649,
0.0086867046,
-0.0457582884,
0.0308227446,
0.0068115485,
-0.0334356613,
-0.0414312631,
-0.0119359335,
-0.0748653933,
-0.0639461204,
-0.0259393454,
0.0016921818,
-0.0693669617,
0.001175405,
-0.0322250165,
0.0343808681,
-0.0102356663,
-0.0405295454,
0.073025316,
-0.0024312688,
0.0299521461,
-0.0226843581,
0.0256826822,
0.0620645806,
0.0559796169,
-0.0442742519,
-0.0193150826,
-0.0143055571,
-0.0122346813,
-0.0352144502,
0.0298190229,
-0.0007860232,
0.0021093646,
-0.0004038993,
-0.0668136999,
-0.0306762476,
0.0320352577,
-0.0789339617,
0.0131567763,
0.0832770541,
0.0438773744,
-0.012081841,
-0.034893766,
0.0132324733,
-0.033036042,
-0.0482667126,
-0.0102767786,
-0.0455374978,
-0.0366900451,
0.0029653357,
-0.0460571833,
0.0390027352,
-0.0264297836,
0.0369128287,
-0.0501942821,
0.0464470349,
-0.0134446295,
0.0195613056,
0.0008495337,
-0.0434077792,
-0.0508935042,
0.0026325986,
0.0590215176,
0.0467041023,
-0.0460820273,
-0.0715282857,
-0.0412055738,
-0.043105498,
-0.0368235745,
0.0335438922,
-0.0465390533,
-0.0447897725,
0.0153627591,
0.0838036239,
-0.0291684922,
0.0113194203,
0.0289846919,
-0.012657471,
0.0462877862,
-0.0259872023,
-0.0164690278,
-0.0600691661,
0.0249791499,
0.0246509891,
0.0189646333,
0.0061300867,
-0.0058333999,
-0.0147353513,
0.0020680625,
0.0219250005,
-0.0182839129,
0.0053354106,
0.0416311398,
0.0443200096,
-0.0296618361,
0.0537831597,
-0.0000214705,
-0.00411049,
-0.0164332781,
-0.0479502678,
0.0174177494,
0.0289900713,
-0.0035506978,
0.0220243912,
0.0021526988,
0.0377706625,
0.0195452273,
0.0025048426,
-0.0114852283,
0.0146631571,
0.0082938038,
0.0201503038,
-0.0159008149,
0.0097223697,
-0.0408109874,
0.0236946028,
0.1180724129,
0.0163409039,
-0.0106858267,
-0.0186204426,
-0.0228021778,
0.0449085087,
0.0209023114,
0.028589543,
0.0223916583,
0.0701656342,
0.0068432973,
0.0062667876,
-0.0012879909,
-0.0171715338,
-0.0457416214,
-0.0271362346,
0.0624047108,
0.0093224384,
-0.0762971789,
0.0406713597,
0.039131321,
-0.0869343057,
-0.0408303924,
-0.0035950392,
-0.0037252607,
0.039169319,
0.0544514954,
-0.0210916307,
0.0110304076,
0.0046443162,
-0.0050982861,
0.0015382534,
0.0717186481,
0.009568451,
0.0181502253,
-0.0575505532,
0.0195731018,
-0.0090984786,
-0.0003049206,
0.073239617,
0.0380722694,
-0.0020768042,
0.0220380351,
0.0246751215,
-0.0232727472,
0.0101473108,
-0.0130321681,
0.0068719937,
0.0155929094,
-0.0169893671,
0.0347301215,
-0.0261217002,
-0.0175357163,
0.0062067658,
0.0585259534,
0.0006469407,
0.0236105416,
-0.0112364152,
-0.0443603732,
-0.0210159849,
0.0121020796,
-0.0370301306,
-0.0176914968,
0.0380096622,
0.0057019992,
-0.0346298143,
0.0769528151,
0.0052034864,
0.0071652289,
-0.0079358602,
0.0555813164,
-0.0354199037,
0.0047177975,
0.0065394253,
0.0317202657,
-0.0029282807,
0.0122495973,
0.0013527329,
0.0876847059,
0.0092306789,
0.014278993,
-0.0095868884,
0.0325290151,
-0.0109575232,
0.0180746261,
0.0169390347,
-0.0081037637,
0.0442625321,
-0.0049860212,
-0.1054070294,
0.0494576693,
-0.0060115159,
0.0015249923,
0.0535091273,
0.0578187704,
0.0411399864,
0.0271963682,
0.0284615289,
0.0313455723,
-0.0109443376,
0.0157760736,
-0.0036673946,
-0.0247922968,
-0.0677425712,
-0.006598481,
-0.0495460778,
-0.028231306,
0.0497253314,
-0.0518319458,
-0.0207194835,
-0.047013469,
0.0256188959,
0.010843738,
0.0302327201,
-0.0370095931,
-0.0344697572,
0.0426235013,
-0.0549396686,
0.070921503,
-0.0058744987,
-0.0511555709,
-0.0075225458,
0.028792182,
0.0000123334,
-0.0568747781,
0.0683288425,
-0.0206735283,
0.0036586882,
0.0490864627,
-0.0231391266,
0.0230710749,
0.0975745022,
0.0026444867,
-0.0158731919,
-0.0402919911,
-0.0099451179,
0.0207602326,
-0.0376488604,
0.0145845152,
-0.0423386469,
0.0073455363,
0.0135817202,
-0.0050576357,
-0.0932917818,
0.0608955659,
-0.0718017593,
-0.0237451065,
-0.0261464398,
-0.0836701021,
-0.0194995496,
0.0210288689,
-0.0092254216,
0.020306617,
-0.0891587809,
0.0126453973,
-0.0005591831,
0.0485406741,
-0.0339859985,
0.0098560238,
0.0146501716,
-0.0199857466,
-0.0135105746,
0.0122075127,
-0.0171937197,
0.0006446674,
0.0425449349,
-0.0020505199,
0.0233091451,
0.0324539617,
-0.0274479203,
0.0321040489,
0.0512570851,
-0.007524068,
0.0294241663,
-0.0169694945,
-0.0197083261,
-0.0186883733,
-0.064012751,
-0.0312108174,
-0.0772962719,
-0.0127878645,
0.0022945341,
-0.0148744583,
0.0035973035,
0.0207619015,
0.0085442699,
-0.0618035085,
-0.0192378238,
0.0557069071,
-0.0428587832,
-0.0611668602,
0.0371103249,
0.0492854826,
-0.0754063502,
-0.0605474412,
0.0278209373,
0.0298047345,
-0.0333983041,
-0.0001512897,
0.009683799,
0.0899351388,
0.0287958235,
0.0299263448,
-0.061676316,
-0.0230926778,
0.0041445675,
0.0086400909,
-0.0218752995,
0.0409114696,
-0.0248607788,
-0.0778269172,
0.0441998094,
0.0331903994,
-0.0165019762,
-0.0222097803,
-0.0422551483,
-0.0354629084,
0.0372458175,
-0.0267339442,
0.0284152739,
0.0296051372,
0.0475431755,
-0.0235970952,
0.0030633977,
-0.0152621232,
0.0308114756,
0.0184892844,
0.0019505987,
0.078367196,
-0.0136044724,
-0.0140318722,
-0.0219812691,
0.0584222935,
-0.0015302955,
0.0051753838,
-0.051944375,
-0.0081834858,
-0.0115036126,
0.0188163444,
-0.0122015681,
-0.0258608889,
-0.034769848,
-0.0234761313,
0.0206151996,
0.1094567478,
-0.035750445,
-0.0200605858,
-0.0524210483,
-0.002280911,
0.0165165365,
0.037148241,
0.0105039254,
-0.0133334957,
-0.0723071098,
-0.0917882174,
-0.0279828869,
-0.0422622859,
0.0673854351,
-0.0319912322,
0.0113626793,
-0.0221313406,
0.0477344468,
0.0151857631,
0.0469408259,
-0.0019625721,
0.0211110748,
-0.047516387,
-0.0137171755,
-0.040421389,
-0.0999493524,
-0.027503619,
-0.0197591949,
0.0109375482,
-0.0122124851,
-0.0118299359,
0.0337196961,
0.0195333567,
0.0117238816,
0.0604436956,
-0.0698280931,
-0.0675482303,
-0.0470974967,
0.1304377913,
0.0157459192,
0.0453710668,
-0.0424927026,
-0.0095018744,
-0.0349715836,
0.0102312779,
-0.0457713977,
0.0175649896,
-0.0012945177,
-0.0370071828,
0.0076131062,
-0.0417306088,
-0.0360944122,
0.0058146184,
0.0142477509,
-0.0134755159,
0.0315949507,
-0.0499212965,
0.0135408398,
0.0295992084,
-0.0115076508,
-0.0024615538,
-0.0362639725,
0.0288787503,
-0.0043317201,
-0.0276186168,
-0.0085382862,
-0.0694446117,
0.0140250679,
0.0225689393,
0.018239161,
0.0215823147,
-0.0512942001,
-0.0100359265,
0.0065744333,
-0.0296356212,
0.0242333375,
-0.0577926263,
0.0179469157,
0.0740086883,
0.0117243342,
-0.017152112,
0.0086309854,
0.0141147915,
0.0307544116,
-0.0450500026,
0.0280452967,
0.007077035,
0.0243175346,
0.0262351874,
-0.0109747341,
-0.0319370702,
-0.0658690706,
-0.0309160873,
0.0065730736,
0.05789873,
0.0483118631,
0.011438353,
-0.0173203852,
-0.0046159462,
-0.0055195219,
0.0415078849,
-0.0136620626,
-0.0166417211,
0.0233325195,
0.0276162028,
-0.0264810529,
-0.054104127,
0.0496650748,
-0.0111340545,
-0.0130078578,
0.0133099714,
-0.0137838591,
-0.0238523483,
-0.0144190043,
0.0044520311,
0.0549335368,
-0.0188027155,
-0.015122653,
-0.0076498683,
-0.0110050226,
-0.0573670007,
0.0217430554,
0.0070057674,
-0.0303851422,
0.0232249275,
0.0701473802,
-0.0095976517,
-0.0676720217,
-0.0162295178,
0.0336353481,
-0.0047575617,
-0.0308930222,
-0.0089122085,
-6.468298725e-33,
-0.0294502731,
-0.0113288518,
0.0109459171,
0.029244706,
0.0126668699,
-0.0569363944,
-0.0388757624,
-0.0317525603,
0.0264364593,
-0.0062115602,
0.051738847,
0.0073425197,
-0.0040739728,
-0.0377524756,
0.0054402552,
0.0642487854,
0.0577884354,
0.0206406713,
-0.046268668,
0.0169291049,
-0.0010482686,
0.0511257127,
0.0047701206,
-0.0370354429,
-0.0634476468,
-0.0471262559,
0.0252400991,
-0.032034561,
-0.0256892871,
0.0140616139,
0.042107258,
0.0116719585,
-0.0143888686,
-0.0576075912,
-0.0114446478,
-0.0153626325,
-0.0195908379,
-0.0114046214,
0.0487219021,
-0.0026524146,
-0.0461791083,
-0.0724009201,
0.002958674,
0.0380793065,
-0.011323832,
-0.0254346449,
-0.0249705873,
0.0597805195,
-0.0059105642,
0.0000539958,
-0.0469020493,
-0.0001911439,
0.0020251488,
0.0366324484,
0.0336270407,
-0.0026538111,
-0.0203862544,
0.0744345486,
-0.0002242574,
0.0067997789,
0.0182117894,
0.0517309345,
0.0803953931,
0.0148199741,
0.0299326964,
-0.0182360504,
0.1078144982,
0.0208121128,
0.0070709572,
0.0588177368,
-0.0083563486,
0.0110120205,
0.0260706767,
0.0052104066,
0.0184467435,
-0.0092385625,
-0.0338049419,
-0.011203127,
-0.0165517163,
-0.0315332524,
-0.0004116787,
0.0065672826,
-0.0254763905,
-0.0491109565,
-0.0167865735,
-0.0059787813,
-0.0334203094,
-0.0442314334,
0.0210945215,
-0.0158100985,
-0.0239368957,
0.0840013176,
0.0373477452,
0.0230985899,
0.0320066512,
0.0128865074,
-0.0651703253,
0.0147780851,
0.0117009822,
0.0500512198,
-0.002671493,
-0.0360680483,
-0.0269066803,
-0.047965914,
0.0841105804,
0.0362167768,
-0.0101130307,
0.0002909555,
-0.030826997,
0.0115793021,
-0.0467848517,
0.0040103723,
0.0017470247,
0.0507854782,
-0.0062492653,
0.0215045828,
0.022221189,
0.0193363652,
0.0296301562,
-0.0172812939,
-0.0405847132,
-0.011759622,
0.0069041909,
0.0050024278,
-0.0307367314,
0.0024437001,
-0.0440968424,
0.0153124221,
0.0416003391,
-0.0395492166,
-0.0659816638,
0.0495394468,
3.219e-7,
0.0120086744,
0.0382930413,
0.0147486934,
0.0206049308,
-0.0057035312,
0.0049949521,
0.0062871869,
-0.002355125,
0.0417593755,
0.0284711402,
-0.0170414131,
0.011124217,
0.0362526253,
0.0222077854,
-0.0456528552,
0.0189113505,
-0.0051185647,
0.041305948,
-0.0724262372,
-0.0029530597,
-0.0281482432,
0.0373159945,
0.001250678,
0.0060483674,
-0.006438998,
0.0092706596,
0.0294816177,
-0.0116363103,
-0.0648533702,
0.0355321206,
-0.0906495303,
0.0023635186,
-0.0400892906,
0.0237379428,
-0.035323102,
-0.0201747809,
0.0272662416,
0.089672707,
-0.0025693057,
0.0377925895,
0.100977689,
-0.0287137218,
-0.0028839859,
-0.0498182364,
0.0105799064,
-0.0020765539,
0.0005498629,
-0.0186993368,
-0.0118632158,
0.023354508,
-0.0150721483,
-0.021567516,
0.0409005545,
-0.0047005303,
-0.0063432707,
0.0178484395,
-0.012284494,
0.036057841,
-0.0813869685,
-0.0080058053,
-0.0215312224,
-0.0866969898,
-0.066355668,
-0.0145274792,
0.022648789,
-0.021164855,
-0.0148118241,
3.542240416e-34,
0.0560021959,
-0.0265145376,
0.0146896625,
0.0045090816,
0.0270180181,
-0.0534220226,
-0.0493142828,
0.0399507433,
-0.0087929517,
0.0132356323,
-0.0619890168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09025v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09025v4 | SLEB: Streamlining LLMs through Redundancy Verification and Elimination of Transformer Blocks | 2024-02-14T09:01:13 | 2024-06-12T01:40:12 | Jiwon Song, Kyungseok Oh, Taesu Kim, Hyungjun Kim, Yulhwa Kim, Jae-Joon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have proven to be highly effective across
various natural language processing tasks. However, their large number of
parameters poses significant challenges for practical deployment. Pruning, a
technique aimed at reducing the size and complexity of LLMs, offers a potential
solution by removing redundant components from the network. Despite the promise
of pruning, existing methods often struggle to achieve substantial end-to-end
LLM inference speedup. In this paper, we introduce SLEB, a novel approach
designed to streamline LLMs by eliminating redundant transformer blocks. We
choose the transformer block as the fundamental unit for pruning, because LLMs
exhibit block-level redundancy with high similarity between the outputs of
neighboring blocks. This choice allows us to effectively enhance the processing
speed of LLMs. Our experimental results demonstrate that SLEB outperforms
previous LLM pruning methods in accelerating LLM inference while also
maintaining superior perplexity and accuracy, making SLEB as a promising
technique for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs. The code is available at:
https://github.com/jiwonsong-dev/SLEB. | [
0.014094973,
0.055291716,
0.0044158292,
0.0599972047,
-0.0451372862,
-0.0036644381,
0.0138084097,
0.0144393295,
0.0271281097,
-0.0185786169,
-0.0321803093,
-0.0144272828,
0.0066784644,
-0.0259476025,
0.0085990829,
0.0022392035,
0.0560221374,
-0.0311059486,
-0.0286831707,
0.0009553838,
0.0050049899,
0.0368048996,
-0.0028831414,
0.0241082981,
0.0203045011,
-0.0069246618,
-0.0059365844,
0.0107517196,
0.0098766331,
-0.0198302791,
-0.0147245852,
0.0581512786,
-0.0052086641,
0.0258105788,
0.0000021504,
-0.0249270573,
-0.0154867098,
-0.0084500508,
-0.0574384183,
0.0427648798,
0.0399138182,
-0.0043950127,
-0.0170819294,
0.0369368717,
-0.0101739923,
-0.0457232669,
0.0394815132,
0.0584379621,
0.0409857258,
0.0845454112,
0.0026193087,
-0.0398373641,
-0.0011958624,
-0.0116953906,
-0.0406142436,
-0.0213306025,
0.0323442481,
-0.0175624415,
0.0206629187,
-0.0041613337,
0.0062004374,
0.0394784994,
0.0310653932,
0.0244216528,
-0.0618790984,
0.0162890889,
0.0012702191,
-0.0098026441,
-0.0060399869,
0.059031073,
-0.0427913256,
-0.0352616087,
0.0143126734,
-0.0071024015,
-0.0342392363,
0.0173180141,
-0.0302880891,
0.0592754707,
-0.010970111,
0.0246874318,
-0.0038923735,
-0.0116120642,
0.0547508635,
-0.0007179333,
-0.0505384691,
0.0816265717,
0.0402995571,
-0.0022164958,
-0.0358084664,
-0.0217860062,
-0.0171214547,
-0.0746279061,
0.0114187049,
0.0146478973,
-0.0085944701,
0.0057505425,
-0.0269781034,
-0.0177480336,
0.0148013346,
-0.009054916,
0.0220131967,
0.0408920348,
-0.0015160101,
0.0427133031,
-0.0379561149,
0.0283683483,
-0.034779951,
0.0022938086,
-0.0342682488,
-0.0155237326,
0.0039480557,
-0.0110241389,
-0.0302106459,
0.0468604267,
-0.0253578927,
-0.0444093235,
-0.0155504756,
0.0116032166,
0.0044073602,
-0.0095619783,
0.0318939649,
-0.0157137439,
0.0375594348,
-0.0236206017,
-0.0081882989,
0.0328021236,
-0.0056995172,
-0.0008301437,
-0.0377949066,
-0.0732049271,
-0.028797714,
0.0544095188,
0.0366487131,
-0.0163637251,
0.0188493822,
0.0423576012,
0.0261816233,
-0.0578206405,
-0.0648263991,
-0.0143196452,
-0.0013373609,
-0.0716716051,
0.0157416072,
-0.0935931206,
0.030032374,
-0.0202844422,
0.0033022685,
-0.0413567722,
0.0000908876,
0.0301548187,
-0.0232479982,
0.0573879108,
-0.0046240035,
0.0257891454,
-0.0185154043,
0.028300222,
0.0440987498,
0.0568529032,
0.0194496512,
-0.0054994305,
0.0199744664,
-0.0211371891,
0.0010484905,
0.0756056607,
0.0114557091,
-0.0126857832,
-0.0290763546,
-0.0479532927,
-0.0147903636,
-0.0071142279,
0.0327644609,
0.0754832625,
-0.0418356284,
-0.0190740824,
0.0368083417,
0.0438347422,
0.0432260185,
0.0475723296,
0.0393554047,
0.0387315117,
0.0075391033,
0.0155552104,
-0.0610440746,
0.025825182,
-0.0177765638,
0.0036198408,
0.0369029976,
0.0736579672,
-0.0338202603,
0.0012211346,
-0.044083558,
-0.0268145967,
0.0158171523,
-0.000229759,
0.0418680198,
0.0131838256,
-0.0505966097,
0.1313183606,
0.0337070264,
-0.0661954507,
-0.0428866819,
-0.0515445285,
0.0179545619,
0.0506284423,
0.0593325607,
0.008065681,
-0.0112210652,
0.0311649125,
0.0125578186,
0.0461997576,
0.0019606156,
0.0257033538,
0.0340698659,
-0.0590668693,
-0.0159581695,
0.0479922146,
0.043026641,
-0.0044695567,
0.0782208443,
-0.0351168066,
0.0394087471,
-0.0177971628,
0.0113774305,
0.0262647215,
-0.0231800303,
0.027117515,
0.0219272468,
-0.0053734905,
0.0212759636,
0.0044875834,
-0.0018126799,
0.0131516159,
0.0513387993,
-0.0456827432,
0.0006803484,
0.0002433062,
-0.0393076837,
-0.0785936862,
0.0564759597,
0.0083865896,
-0.0023487066,
0.0908042118,
-0.0408775024,
-0.0285962466,
0.0231842231,
-0.0684371963,
0.0378880315,
-0.0417656377,
0.0440921858,
-0.0029596286,
0.050168179,
0.0081746615,
0.0330071338,
-0.0239312798,
0.0303017255,
0.0187142491,
-0.0268573221,
0.0099157924,
-0.0373433903,
-0.0300749261,
0.005977165,
-0.0333510712,
-0.0099699441,
-0.0050616493,
0.004250769,
-0.0031526361,
-0.0173848011,
-0.0614045411,
-0.0049326052,
-0.0204664711,
0.0501763001,
0.0160943083,
0.0491566844,
0.0021166783,
0.0020796738,
0.020492699,
0.0000023821,
0.0357447527,
0.0027837267,
0.0085599907,
-0.0411587059,
-0.098763451,
-0.0144985551,
-0.029037971,
0.002697268,
0.0759565234,
-0.0412760824,
-0.036288593,
-0.061591778,
0.0422841795,
-0.0165136065,
0.0509484448,
-0.0126551827,
-0.0238259118,
-0.0132006193,
-0.014910304,
0.0147071173,
0.0065730833,
-0.01573826,
-0.0330488123,
0.0573723875,
-0.0165199675,
-0.0430040285,
-0.0079055931,
-0.0224781446,
0.024396209,
-0.0239847992,
-0.0441296063,
-0.0114611331,
0.0544424616,
0.0096744942,
-0.0022172346,
-0.0112128919,
-0.0141472174,
0.0342709683,
0.0029094459,
0.0132285729,
-0.0180135276,
-0.0206766874,
0.0156299863,
-0.0220630877,
-0.0476323627,
0.0423451252,
-0.0980279148,
-0.0209181216,
-0.0319046937,
-0.016080102,
-0.0334329307,
0.0570369586,
0.0143209593,
0.008887928,
-0.0140974475,
-0.0283007212,
-0.0211183224,
0.0106262788,
-0.0086800102,
-0.0333400108,
0.0726349652,
-0.0575467981,
0.0410539769,
-0.0191886686,
-0.0269539785,
-0.0425577573,
-0.0097051859,
-0.0405800007,
0.0257214326,
0.0321002528,
-0.0281173121,
-0.0407480784,
0.0307687297,
0.0131978989,
0.0491603576,
0.0105712302,
0.0320904255,
-0.0241700672,
0.0507014543,
0.0332638174,
0.0188964289,
0.0707607418,
0.0082397573,
0.0530095547,
0.0701332688,
0.0151902065,
0.0333501399,
-0.0628631115,
-0.0253315903,
0.0299503338,
-0.0262931231,
0.0184958093,
0.0216811243,
0.0350125991,
-0.058179453,
-0.0125780785,
0.1404515952,
0.0095391441,
-0.0139084412,
0.0099970428,
0.0189520456,
0.0188162904,
0.0046516447,
0.0408885665,
-0.0831760913,
-0.0525095761,
0.0120062027,
-0.0215205587,
0.0016834977,
-0.0016578358,
-0.0396328196,
-0.1312117279,
0.0507047698,
0.0072263032,
-0.0199319422,
-0.0180831049,
-0.0623776838,
-0.0197581146,
0.0120999869,
0.0151458606,
0.0412630625,
-0.0204238109,
-0.0585893169,
-0.0157143734,
-0.0587032288,
-0.0485616662,
0.0216554441,
-0.0394282416,
0.0421774238,
0.0175188668,
-0.0137229888,
0.0098821186,
-0.0396507941,
0.0771814659,
-0.0376840383,
-0.0190378334,
-0.0428701229,
0.0110988123,
0.0158654805,
0.003137754,
-0.0176174305,
-0.0044931094,
-0.0463381484,
-0.0280108992,
-0.0401951745,
0.0804567635,
-0.0281106308,
-0.0272179209,
-0.005757113,
0.0475430898,
-0.0237193573,
0.0765577704,
0.0380840153,
-0.0011415312,
-0.0434405282,
0.0062692859,
-0.0457061902,
-0.0281330515,
-0.0323894359,
0.0162118021,
0.0013814373,
-0.0305143185,
-0.0245736726,
0.0531169586,
0.0128468256,
-0.0067746467,
-0.0213172752,
0.0265636053,
0.0173483118,
-0.0108317742,
-0.0372789837,
0.0219442248,
-0.0529888682,
0.0286248345,
-0.0546879247,
0.0550613329,
0.0324678756,
-0.0152149107,
-0.0173631813,
0.0320060924,
-0.1323098391,
-0.0631519705,
-0.0278962757,
0.0144466208,
0.0238423739,
0.051634714,
-0.0266638529,
-0.0492654331,
-0.0169567745,
0.0570183173,
-0.0408333279,
0.0505946428,
-0.0021332945,
-0.0085882405,
0.0019660431,
0.04550758,
-0.0128819766,
0.0387770608,
0.0031200713,
0.0479929075,
-0.0202236213,
-0.0349609517,
-0.00765272,
0.0535778441,
0.0412264578,
0.0231132079,
0.0346950516,
-0.0175408423,
0.048877161,
-0.0123605737,
-0.0073804436,
-0.0388021432,
0.0337615572,
0.0045141117,
0.0012438889,
-0.0121562853,
-0.0015864286,
0.0038397203,
0.0170935337,
0.010984729,
0.018809814,
-0.0287372898,
-0.0431941748,
0.0329398103,
-0.0352934822,
-0.0102641499,
0.0058953692,
0.009453522,
0.0022589485,
-0.0398809947,
0.0171481781,
0.001292209,
-0.015378518,
-0.0932400152,
0.038767457,
-0.0446499623,
-0.0615354776,
-0.0241860393,
0.0247022361,
0.0555131175,
0.0087808454,
0.0693807453,
-0.0164492484,
0.0102813588,
-0.0504079387,
0.0201047175,
-0.0038010424,
-0.0064478279,
0.0640496612,
0.0343020484,
-0.0203269906,
-0.006610299,
0.0562955998,
0.0144195398,
0.0456516668,
-0.0167903397,
-0.0208791755,
-0.0335945562,
-0.0747020692,
-0.0325091854,
0.0068236124,
-0.0636199117,
-0.0164277181,
-0.0260587353,
-0.0779429674,
0.0181427691,
0.0168388449,
0.0185376145,
-0.0179037098,
0.0290963948,
0.0399976783,
0.0212214347,
-0.0224153437,
0.0020342853,
-0.0279597212,
0.0121762548,
-0.047967013,
0.0043980102,
-7.043440927e-33,
-0.0055402,
-0.0477822758,
0.0382375568,
-0.0304153264,
-0.0386563428,
0.0145195397,
-0.0448868573,
-0.0214127582,
-0.0267271455,
-0.0274131782,
-0.0081137419,
0.0327458084,
0.0200253334,
0.0293060783,
-0.0181371495,
-0.0031729029,
0.049222637,
0.0182319246,
-0.0162092876,
-0.0071216146,
0.0136134876,
0.0121052647,
0.0622197576,
-0.0289682467,
-0.0493052602,
-0.0010849411,
-0.0131796738,
0.0207829159,
-0.0421419591,
0.0469053611,
-0.0336949937,
0.0142719345,
0.0220361333,
-0.062488284,
-0.0181425195,
0.0343790874,
-0.0767336413,
-0.0029645851,
0.0372727886,
0.0089190947,
-0.0085676108,
-0.0094719287,
0.0704572424,
0.0084833344,
-0.0270614587,
-0.0054172957,
-0.0008081967,
-0.0109665385,
-0.0236973017,
0.0126769822,
-0.0259126369,
0.0577868447,
0.0244947337,
-0.0114186676,
0.0218752231,
0.033255443,
-0.0327156,
0.0490108356,
-0.0729346201,
0.0138816545,
0.0166858807,
0.0627750605,
0.0820191726,
-0.0135406246,
0.0019528457,
0.0458538868,
0.0033985658,
-0.0658462718,
-0.0552468225,
0.0077723037,
0.0548164472,
0.0499170236,
0.0412344784,
0.0117300497,
0.0235856511,
-0.0057480703,
-0.0887288749,
0.0103561766,
0.0058343159,
0.0744665265,
0.0160039794,
0.0164422747,
-0.0201699603,
-0.0384891443,
-0.0065307128,
-0.0101475725,
-0.0455244668,
-0.0092344861,
0.0157228634,
0.0263776947,
-0.0432174951,
-0.0114896232,
0.0293340441,
-0.0580662005,
-0.025495721,
0.0133945001,
0.0185286868,
0.0028554422,
-0.0013649972,
0.0227562021,
-0.0339369886,
-0.0279117357,
-0.0003673849,
-0.0388923325,
-0.0035626679,
-0.0073438985,
0.014318102,
0.0355488546,
-0.0833996236,
-0.0068941675,
-0.0414655432,
-0.0027708786,
-0.0144407181,
0.0249794833,
0.0310105626,
0.0112115117,
0.025039725,
0.0446308553,
0.0287991613,
-0.0251129605,
-0.0145312911,
0.0115197673,
0.0347601846,
0.0367342867,
-0.0253773052,
0.0011914709,
-0.0375065096,
0.0009136517,
0.0249987505,
-0.0481922701,
-0.0220849589,
0.0603442155,
2.909e-7,
0.0450117998,
0.02025472,
0.0326842777,
0.0317624174,
0.0311668795,
-0.000504938,
-0.0075578978,
-0.0218015276,
-0.0095485458,
0.0112725142,
0.0061845444,
0.0215461086,
0.0620870627,
0.0009693046,
-0.0930421352,
0.032176584,
-0.0718112737,
-0.0345303975,
-0.0387265682,
-0.0376655422,
0.014388876,
0.0879822001,
-0.0005369584,
-0.0255617369,
-0.0305392668,
-0.0356905237,
0.0158818383,
-0.0196605772,
0.0087967385,
0.016200969,
0.0256871562,
-0.0251018014,
0.0196944419,
-0.0027295239,
0.0061314637,
0.0393804796,
-0.0240972769,
0.0884366408,
0.0154998163,
-0.0008421584,
0.0180018432,
-0.0458898358,
-0.0180994757,
-0.0338824131,
0.077601403,
-0.0165334661,
-0.0056682206,
-0.0429655798,
0.0095376633,
-0.0198782403,
-0.0101174358,
0.0166539717,
-0.0015779816,
0.029810708,
0.0400567688,
-0.0507679619,
-0.0202574115,
-0.0775576904,
-0.0352552645,
-0.0272984225,
-0.0788989216,
-0.0415798575,
-0.0285807438,
-0.0127543807,
0.0416440703,
-0.0405148193,
-0.0191718228,
3.177312787e-34,
0.0080291433,
-0.0105229104,
-0.0015056573,
0.0721162036,
0.0374698974,
-0.0274202004,
-0.0208420251,
0.0188475475,
-0.0356780328,
-0.1117191911,
-0.0214283839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09015v3 | Towards better Human-Agent Alignment: Assessing Task Utility in LLM-Powered Applications | 2024-02-14T08:46:15 | 2024-02-22T23:49:10 | Negar Arabzadeh, Julia Kiseleva, Qingyun Wu, Chi Wang, Ahmed Awadallah, Victor Dibia, Adam Fourney, Charles Clarke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid development in the field of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to
a surge in applications that facilitate collaboration among multiple agents to
assist humans in their daily tasks. However, a significant gap remains in
assessing whether LLM-powered applications genuinely enhance user experience
and task execution efficiency. This highlights the pressing need for methods to
verify utility of LLM-powered applications, particularly by ensuring alignment
between the application's functionality and end-user needs. We introduce
AgentEval provides an implementation for the math problems, a novel framework
designed to simplify the utility verification process by automatically
proposing a set of criteria tailored to the unique purpose of any given
application. This allows for a comprehensive assessment, quantifying the
utility of an application against the suggested criteria. We present a
comprehensive analysis of the robustness of quantifier's work. | [
-0.0184833277,
0.0436672755,
-0.0245659705,
0.0236884933,
-0.0780861676,
0.0147632807,
0.0214360896,
0.0173438806,
0.0279818494,
-0.0192548167,
-0.0051020239,
0.00214436,
0.0263001472,
-0.0079219146,
-0.0063595441,
-0.0453301966,
0.0285974853,
-0.032303907,
0.0224581901,
0.0250501558,
-0.0065549784,
-0.0223882422,
-0.0525852367,
0.0521843955,
-0.0130939456,
-0.0326358117,
0.0048091919,
-0.0166554134,
0.0407923684,
-0.0097384918,
-0.0365742184,
0.0322060771,
0.0021557293,
0.0050363406,
0.0000022195,
-0.0720065907,
-0.0005061228,
0.0225727223,
-0.0564915463,
-0.0048047593,
0.0631880686,
0.0574233346,
-0.0164827034,
0.0049126074,
-0.0629103929,
0.0844848007,
0.0492136925,
-0.0560829379,
0.034370143,
0.0271872189,
-0.007921949,
0.0433449559,
-0.005745457,
0.0263573639,
0.0389479771,
-0.0596191064,
0.0171288196,
0.0088545186,
0.0898504108,
-0.0293644592,
0.0348551646,
0.0443880036,
0.0376553647,
-0.0246639568,
0.0244173519,
-0.004153173,
-0.0277304091,
-0.0273854174,
-0.0250124503,
0.0378490277,
0.0345081799,
0.0183597617,
0.0001237792,
-0.020460777,
0.0112999836,
0.0661615133,
-0.0413565375,
-0.0115511864,
-0.0016759339,
-0.0071350257,
-0.0001588666,
0.0141053991,
0.0278584156,
0.0250448789,
-0.017581135,
0.1081235111,
-0.0061559947,
-0.0087734275,
0.0095410896,
0.0134989135,
-0.045089405,
-0.0617023967,
0.027664151,
0.0564134419,
-0.0584165864,
0.0018961158,
-0.0127062555,
-0.0492383838,
0.0058691646,
-0.0735964775,
0.0593310185,
0.0576991476,
0.0338563472,
0.0225591138,
0.0084723253,
0.0684503317,
-0.0057797614,
-0.0178269036,
-0.0137844738,
0.052777078,
-0.0383251198,
-0.0122404182,
-0.0191860888,
0.0463295802,
-0.0324010439,
0.0212623663,
-0.0390471742,
0.0495519228,
-0.0430088751,
0.0478160791,
-0.0084906081,
-0.0209054388,
0.0098346714,
-0.018264696,
-0.0429551043,
-0.005975252,
-0.0602182522,
0.0230898727,
-0.0116386367,
-0.0699713826,
0.0396209694,
0.0313199647,
-0.0380846635,
-0.0123646026,
-0.0003116502,
0.1115373522,
0.0242274627,
-0.0029940477,
-0.0194436572,
-0.0515626408,
0.0247379653,
-0.0694982857,
-0.049027577,
-0.0831318572,
-0.0011970279,
-0.0009614885,
-0.0267479364,
-0.0444249883,
0.0112248752,
0.0142921126,
0.0349542983,
0.0709101111,
0.0019155783,
0.0265657175,
0.0244775116,
0.0014898288,
-0.0493240021,
0.0738431439,
0.0554217249,
0.0336117148,
0.0601208135,
0.0070286612,
0.0334588178,
0.0547986813,
-0.0459715091,
-0.001025093,
0.0174028948,
0.0120630795,
-0.0122330245,
0.0449058264,
-0.0770911723,
0.0213408768,
-0.0198820867,
0.0092780702,
0.0763910338,
0.0890702605,
0.0441776887,
-0.0296370629,
0.0135698859,
0.0293379501,
-0.0010040094,
0.0031215998,
-0.0558399186,
0.0492406338,
-0.0244039726,
-0.0087673021,
-0.0260068532,
0.0293563362,
-0.0036951143,
-0.0857819617,
-0.019738337,
-0.0095476052,
0.0361934565,
0.0295261443,
0.0588700585,
-0.0427224971,
-0.0002697239,
0.0209045336,
-0.0142000262,
-0.0626073554,
-0.0186907463,
-0.0806922317,
0.0169137474,
0.0648064017,
0.054250557,
-0.0459292866,
-0.0137272757,
0.027230693,
0.0054443697,
0.0286681429,
0.0348381288,
-0.0068484992,
0.0035895132,
-0.0400438681,
-0.0239071082,
-0.0076231491,
-0.006325996,
0.0067336704,
0.036764428,
0.0092867389,
-0.0109345149,
-0.044662416,
-0.0184252858,
0.0191901326,
-0.0330593213,
-0.0643314049,
-0.0197447576,
0.0558329597,
0.0069702994,
0.0287178196,
0.0019948557,
0.0298923925,
0.024761986,
-0.0008788118,
-0.0128894551,
0.0133552747,
0.0024253754,
0.0522909537,
0.0460652374,
-0.013109304,
-0.0148123922,
0.0281592589,
0.0117048025,
0.0120461592,
0.0167351961,
-0.0228406787,
0.0229115412,
0.0054472792,
0.041259151,
-0.0382880345,
-0.0343252532,
-0.044821471,
0.0340868048,
0.0322529748,
-0.0093849404,
0.0213345848,
-0.0195275825,
0.0041431952,
-0.0202550925,
0.0084867775,
0.0132899908,
0.0203788448,
0.0417455062,
0.0187726486,
0.032048177,
-0.0155401435,
-0.022325363,
-0.0816166773,
-0.0181181896,
-0.0151113505,
0.0369031318,
0.0038027503,
0.01641858,
0.003207254,
0.002186452,
-0.026662847,
0.016151784,
-0.0082801208,
-0.0024118242,
0.0255971849,
-0.0002760074,
-0.0491172709,
-0.0245490149,
0.0063457084,
-0.0338552557,
0.0048544933,
0.0542980283,
0.0083276508,
-0.0488597602,
0.0324673206,
-0.0068119345,
-0.0112725971,
0.0012730972,
0.0287734699,
0.0426606238,
0.0079293661,
0.0086375624,
0.0653516948,
-0.0319525898,
0.0299264397,
0.0242931824,
-0.0419183932,
-0.066617392,
-0.0170302801,
-0.0059532113,
-0.0000117536,
-0.0209459756,
-0.0405335128,
0.0202702191,
0.0451410599,
-0.0364082679,
0.0095740706,
-0.0324810632,
0.0173669495,
-0.0309978239,
-0.0318080448,
-0.022294946,
-0.0030686997,
-0.0352130607,
0.0590323247,
0.00350627,
-0.0625196248,
0.066817835,
-0.031061504,
-0.0205222871,
-0.0252624862,
-0.0268449951,
-0.0737230405,
0.0481661558,
-0.0318739936,
-0.0119638611,
-0.0318848416,
0.0018688482,
-0.0199773051,
-0.0290259682,
0.0187233575,
-0.0229516178,
0.0753227174,
-0.0882866979,
-0.0014516626,
-0.0241271872,
-0.0283006169,
-0.0006258562,
-0.006750931,
-0.0144711314,
0.017582193,
-0.0151312137,
-0.0287615266,
-0.0350384563,
0.0010450042,
0.0524136126,
-0.0145992674,
-0.0215931274,
-0.0415953323,
-0.0154555766,
-0.0369819738,
0.0069879522,
0.0537944175,
0.0048617101,
-0.0226026457,
0.0218802169,
0.0436423421,
0.0399623178,
-0.0195015222,
-0.0177529883,
-0.0045613297,
0.043218229,
-0.0442713052,
-0.0040909424,
0.0696576908,
0.0278023779,
-0.0511632785,
0.0355853103,
0.0692277476,
0.0315090902,
-0.0558890104,
0.0124832802,
-0.1069621667,
-0.0137534542,
0.0085197482,
0.0226111505,
-0.0758212134,
-0.0062890975,
0.0099220648,
0.0349290818,
-0.0112619242,
-0.0364262126,
0.0126116266,
-0.0699438602,
0.0580098778,
0.0129784923,
0.0143536655,
0.0248307642,
-0.026237281,
0.0351858586,
-0.0172129665,
0.0158461016,
0.0196350291,
-0.0031720763,
-0.0076241517,
0.005471155,
-0.0243665483,
-0.0294180699,
0.0239643827,
-0.0312115904,
0.0263541415,
0.0750321746,
0.044503618,
-0.0048482381,
-0.0925311223,
-0.0045838142,
0.0822125152,
0.0160760358,
-0.0017726393,
0.0057079298,
-0.0138248475,
0.0094254054,
-0.0273812469,
0.000675659,
-0.0481806546,
-0.0149131855,
0.0514993146,
0.0767408609,
-0.0344013311,
0.0254354607,
-0.0127991736,
-0.0117588043,
0.0150201432,
0.0535564572,
-0.001604453,
-0.0317654684,
-0.0476019233,
-0.0386247337,
-0.0418950953,
-0.0452821553,
-0.0676184446,
0.0043449271,
-0.0014169895,
-0.0485621281,
-0.0306057762,
-0.054149434,
0.0574350357,
0.055689197,
-0.0177420881,
-0.0064330995,
0.0446266271,
0.0362547711,
-0.0140069453,
0.0016235219,
-0.0022124031,
0.0909443796,
-0.0499800891,
0.0276014563,
-0.007428633,
-0.0415506251,
0.0266136024,
-0.0125860469,
-0.0478470474,
-0.0509754568,
0.0116851572,
0.0443402901,
0.0391553976,
-0.0104092965,
-0.0190300122,
-0.0093383873,
-0.0036437851,
0.028665429,
-0.0776594952,
0.0305349585,
0.0109228874,
0.0116726542,
0.0055923616,
0.0045211976,
-0.0350959785,
-0.0000231286,
-0.025083771,
0.0414341316,
-0.0296514835,
-0.051183451,
-0.0024760317,
0.0504230373,
-0.0337963589,
-0.0054675625,
-0.0053202906,
0.0025344435,
0.0081420997,
-0.0272974782,
-0.0072335294,
-0.0557307042,
-0.010104741,
-0.0294700414,
0.0055766581,
0.0577483252,
0.0192772653,
-0.0288700163,
-0.0308337938,
0.0217627417,
0.06825912,
-0.0590986572,
0.0381724834,
0.0226976536,
0.0241652709,
-0.0011687898,
0.0263883248,
-0.0400124565,
0.0447851904,
0.0164394658,
0.0350454263,
-0.0071483483,
0.0260560196,
-0.0183153618,
0.0350340009,
-0.0034996434,
-0.0941279531,
0.0008259895,
0.0129053313,
0.0197939202,
0.0319470651,
0.0173226595,
-0.0663343072,
0.0112395314,
-0.013467188,
-0.0169189982,
0.0119534982,
-0.0041080881,
-0.0203733332,
0.0296888277,
-0.0038187904,
-0.0725927055,
0.0442971699,
-0.0385543071,
-0.0255704392,
-0.0356035382,
-0.0461317524,
-0.03748703,
-0.0700083822,
0.0118621346,
-0.00616703,
-0.0251443647,
-0.0308841188,
-0.1070008427,
-0.0518367141,
-0.0172861125,
0.0286158752,
-0.0219506286,
-0.0616418608,
0.0416643582,
0.0689004958,
0.0092495074,
-0.0199402943,
-0.0393546969,
-0.0138362842,
-0.0679793358,
0.0329501703,
-0.028893169,
-5.737316093e-33,
-0.0210802387,
-0.0537030064,
0.0635872334,
0.0377141349,
0.0121973678,
-0.0243159607,
-0.0322077163,
0.0448441431,
0.0020608911,
-0.0159325805,
0.0034097908,
-0.0142242089,
0.0169458445,
-0.0573294573,
0.0362702012,
0.0157908406,
0.000473313,
-0.0107360249,
-0.0501570627,
-0.0473919101,
-0.0125515396,
-0.0438728966,
0.0222609211,
-0.0698610842,
0.0566946007,
0.0105546899,
0.0101683782,
0.0207251869,
-0.0409151055,
0.0480190441,
0.0123847164,
0.0397174694,
0.0099760825,
-0.0231935531,
-0.0352428854,
0.0262875315,
0.011503336,
-0.0453750603,
0.0273580775,
0.0215567444,
-0.0539043024,
-0.0318852551,
0.0166770462,
0.0148664508,
-0.0783759952,
0.0159715936,
0.038021408,
-0.0341979712,
0.0042335005,
0.0180475693,
-0.0641485602,
0.0365615934,
0.0013259045,
0.0081449226,
0.0186471827,
0.033128649,
-0.0323941112,
-0.0433050208,
-0.0276307445,
0.0391049236,
-0.0004123341,
-0.0098283971,
0.0704676658,
0.0037063861,
0.0105665652,
0.0275349505,
0.0028267216,
-0.0027301556,
-0.0513518974,
-0.0268274806,
0.02997417,
0.0639561042,
0.0363911502,
0.0584565811,
0.0079208771,
0.0220487881,
-0.0058997576,
0.0625101924,
0.0503826886,
0.0251729339,
0.022867687,
0.0359832533,
-0.0589195117,
-0.0119131347,
0.0055627921,
0.0777664781,
-0.0372674465,
-0.0752300322,
0.020050345,
-0.0188407004,
0.0229308084,
-0.0045695528,
0.0084600803,
-0.0187273324,
0.0055367392,
-0.0188015401,
0.0094482815,
0.0328103863,
0.0220036823,
-0.0125841452,
-0.0316459425,
0.0227364022,
-0.0395398326,
0.0344220027,
0.0703327358,
0.0148713263,
-0.0575949922,
0.0218361318,
-0.0219975635,
0.000633273,
-0.0218302198,
-0.011725313,
0.066414915,
0.0021467898,
0.0410544574,
-0.0313757621,
-0.008350323,
0.0459341034,
-0.062975727,
-0.0685401112,
-0.0452356115,
0.0232122727,
-0.0022070648,
-0.0044482159,
-0.0320549682,
-0.0366656296,
-0.0540662296,
0.0312271006,
0.034072917,
0.0092318989,
-0.0225057658,
-0.0303117912,
2.997e-7,
0.0248225629,
0.0198477525,
-0.00240028,
0.031705521,
-0.0257760417,
0.0642645881,
-0.0250777919,
-0.0232853852,
-0.0179511253,
-0.0009723009,
0.0479496159,
0.0342566036,
0.051164411,
0.0453977771,
0.0036107628,
-0.0110333273,
0.0109754605,
0.0174247734,
-0.0336873196,
0.0327780657,
0.0504483506,
-0.0141912466,
0.0441202819,
0.0050047622,
-0.002642992,
-0.0617481768,
0.0086291218,
-0.0672414377,
0.0161792208,
0.0308683775,
-0.0045472533,
-0.0160062294,
0.007931646,
0.0066195312,
0.0218412448,
0.0028043729,
-0.012646866,
0.1064532176,
-0.0200272482,
0.0120700253,
-0.0149793671,
-0.0538955778,
0.0072719604,
-0.0205524862,
0.0141289216,
-0.0231544282,
-0.0406052731,
0.0009738197,
0.0081478953,
-0.0309694298,
-0.0059469263,
0.0004343521,
0.0128980475,
0.0026551678,
0.0097191557,
-0.0143726096,
-0.0239404682,
-0.0296007711,
-0.0187175069,
0.0282677133,
-0.0613135286,
-0.0610259138,
-0.0458914377,
0.0460572913,
-0.0093267094,
-0.0560608357,
-0.0039486536,
2.960794534e-34,
0.0067195049,
0.0384111814,
0.0206628162,
0.0534690693,
0.0453238487,
0.043084532,
-0.0767824203,
0.0417736508,
0.0520285629,
-0.0554595217,
-0.0207191817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09008v1 | Multi-Query Focused Disaster Summarization via Instruction-Based Prompting | 2024-02-14T08:22:58 | 2024-02-14T08:22:58 | Philipp Seeberger, Korbinian Riedhammer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic summarization of mass-emergency events plays a critical role in
disaster management. The second edition of CrisisFACTS aims to advance disaster
summarization based on multi-stream fact-finding with a focus on web sources
such as Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, and Webnews. Here, participants are asked to
develop systems that can extract key facts from several disaster-related
events, which ultimately serve as a summary. This paper describes our method to
tackle this challenging task. We follow previous work and propose to use a
combination of retrieval, reranking, and an embarrassingly simple
instruction-following summarization. The two-stage retrieval pipeline relies on
BM25 and MonoT5, while the summarizer module is based on the open-source Large
Language Model (LLM) LLaMA-13b. For summarization, we explore a Question
Answering (QA)-motivated prompting approach and find the evidence useful for
extracting query-relevant facts. The automatic metrics and human evaluation
show strong results but also highlight the gap between open-source and
proprietary systems. | [
0.0398223028,
0.0103710992,
0.0106589459,
0.0339259803,
0.0118979495,
0.0219565239,
-0.0474647209,
-0.02787783,
0.0166148301,
-0.0354901925,
0.041000016,
-0.0496150553,
-0.0461717546,
0.0095131984,
-0.0097188922,
-0.09242744,
0.0277913082,
-0.0158139952,
0.0182035938,
-0.0153242555,
0.0248736832,
0.0197200831,
0.0011373742,
-0.0068320767,
0.0213768166,
0.0311326813,
-0.027231222,
0.0069420221,
0.0226673614,
-0.030145986,
-0.0025467626,
0.0173724778,
0.03624136,
-0.0114894984,
0.0000019134,
-0.0707066283,
-0.0336390734,
-0.0413941257,
-0.0116292117,
-0.0013063193,
0.0039001722,
-0.0185478982,
0.02159396,
0.0316577256,
-0.0331729762,
-0.0105976108,
0.0105572017,
0.0405562855,
0.120755218,
0.0871037468,
0.0122080417,
-0.0520529673,
0.0197425894,
0.0109220566,
0.005756645,
-0.0297616087,
0.0175964832,
-0.0016910466,
0.0436033681,
0.0200598743,
0.0282172579,
0.0525839664,
0.0077008302,
0.0203440636,
-0.0058478024,
0.025383316,
-0.0419599488,
0.0020965848,
-0.0065781614,
0.0805799887,
0.0374412648,
0.0263684485,
0.0581447035,
0.0345211551,
0.0311243441,
0.0374118388,
-0.0803231001,
0.0325098187,
-0.019981198,
0.0043351604,
-0.0226945896,
0.0235622227,
-0.0135546606,
0.0254758298,
0.0074141752,
0.0290132668,
-0.0099139027,
-0.0347356796,
-0.0650206953,
0.0040254761,
-0.0279170759,
-0.0422366299,
0.0303171538,
0.0542585254,
-0.0552816801,
0.0156043842,
-0.0168402027,
-0.015525612,
0.0185550097,
-0.083175905,
-0.0289971046,
0.0100036962,
-0.0063681579,
0.0583957918,
0.0104393847,
0.0255647209,
0.0212496724,
0.0082971063,
-0.0613694303,
0.0022798807,
-0.0557645969,
0.0014481866,
-0.0178362858,
0.0517382957,
-0.0144408606,
0.0258434787,
-0.0118694473,
0.02371547,
0.0238974243,
-0.0063823937,
-0.0158123858,
0.0130579164,
-0.0375370272,
-0.0030107338,
-0.0325384215,
0.0156403184,
-0.0482535698,
-0.0351658501,
0.0082268417,
-0.0287977643,
-0.0205577314,
0.0006949376,
0.0305013154,
0.0301960632,
-0.0132394405,
0.0192673802,
-0.0360265262,
-0.0134512661,
-0.0344730392,
-0.0221587624,
0.0100384224,
-0.0101626813,
0.0047733709,
-0.0845014676,
0.0356550068,
0.0154279554,
-0.0214963853,
0.0371588133,
0.0347034037,
0.0183537789,
-0.0572115146,
0.0078367256,
-0.0297571346,
0.0389691778,
0.0432888493,
0.0188547503,
0.045060873,
0.0657486841,
0.0313697159,
0.0716272891,
0.0802329034,
0.0101557942,
0.0188524537,
-0.0058942474,
-0.0172937382,
0.0157667715,
0.0209870823,
0.0289274044,
-0.0360489376,
-0.0054017678,
0.0138987098,
0.0206651911,
0.0035206792,
0.0263087619,
0.0434532352,
0.0400748216,
-0.0105648031,
-0.0044144001,
-0.0040359795,
0.0673029423,
0.0010054008,
0.0597008839,
-0.0081014521,
0.0633359477,
-0.0310608577,
0.0562413931,
0.1153811887,
0.069191739,
-0.0329757594,
-0.0550116226,
-0.0176710095,
0.0295295045,
-0.0357772298,
0.0375810228,
0.0031510878,
-0.0097086541,
-0.0434031263,
0.003793386,
0.0093653649,
-0.0464901701,
0.0422032103,
-0.045023676,
0.0032434149,
0.0913788602,
0.0417666174,
-0.0593326278,
-0.0326450095,
-0.0099384682,
0.0714423135,
0.0216136314,
-0.0070826253,
0.0063864901,
-0.0050083329,
-0.0410638712,
-0.0206770971,
0.0018809289,
0.0061468361,
-0.0047110813,
0.008856548,
-0.0329919755,
0.0084985932,
-0.0104200877,
-0.0634841323,
0.0145367756,
0.0294184759,
-0.0468473062,
-0.0401980206,
0.0025411684,
-0.0271738563,
0.0251499396,
0.0089214221,
0.013092462,
0.0352488421,
-0.0179395545,
-0.0584790856,
-0.000613999,
-0.032756757,
-0.0195556935,
0.0356954634,
-0.0373744071,
-0.008864061,
0.0182782765,
-0.0701941773,
-0.0504056215,
0.0523037799,
-0.0321370214,
-0.0159940924,
-0.0130102448,
0.0081931129,
0.0325852409,
-0.0476041362,
-0.0350576453,
0.104267858,
-0.000051837,
0.0234846584,
0.0159625001,
-0.0400694087,
-0.0282479804,
-0.0404263698,
-0.028325513,
0.0121916635,
-0.0171047207,
0.0438202433,
0.0286654923,
-0.0133257499,
-0.0578214116,
-0.0132738557,
-0.0698157251,
0.0367734209,
-0.0405714102,
0.0452414304,
0.0582906008,
0.0411918685,
-0.0312680863,
-0.0067464528,
-0.0256343801,
-0.0567037016,
0.0233938061,
0.0248653833,
0.0319875367,
0.022258319,
0.0288499221,
-0.0618569925,
-0.0170491245,
-0.0188350491,
0.0172489397,
0.0249899793,
-0.0532181151,
-0.0420139246,
0.0104458509,
-0.0453750081,
-0.0160270855,
0.0021968829,
-0.0325957462,
0.0091653615,
-0.024859732,
0.0731778368,
0.0213724226,
0.0485084429,
0.0346940681,
0.0249261595,
-0.010367075,
-0.0387956649,
0.0189683307,
-0.0524196029,
-0.0566115677,
0.014774994,
-0.0437914021,
0.0161532555,
-0.0008142905,
0.0012747585,
0.0034161308,
-0.0195943266,
-0.0066728136,
-0.025201695,
0.0044163875,
-0.077960968,
-0.0191232078,
-0.0136787919,
0.0083696777,
-0.0287070572,
0.0011868897,
0.0539413542,
0.0263839345,
0.0149690611,
-0.0511268303,
-0.0115229618,
-0.0758691728,
0.056134928,
-0.0343838632,
0.0254037697,
-0.0233985391,
-0.0213910677,
-0.0209158119,
-0.0225996636,
0.0359161757,
-0.0629190877,
0.0375062451,
-0.0584265143,
0.0057376795,
-0.004583369,
-0.0144943176,
-0.0256906915,
-0.0562518276,
0.0017379387,
-0.0171707477,
0.0079819057,
0.0172442552,
-0.0466613285,
0.0107984086,
0.0968827978,
0.0116511928,
-0.0037497664,
-0.0120610856,
-0.0060530053,
0.0906905457,
0.0591062456,
0.0194395073,
0.0284709819,
-0.0337677933,
0.04376157,
0.0536569618,
0.087041907,
-0.0559043102,
0.0264401902,
-0.0140348664,
0.0269615874,
-0.0598531626,
0.0121392887,
0.0044978391,
0.0643219948,
-0.0185344853,
0.0043134829,
0.0912126377,
0.0565897934,
-0.0150996083,
-0.0065785223,
-0.0094249155,
-0.0052610962,
0.030661853,
0.0453838706,
-0.035410516,
-0.0100811776,
-0.0250130165,
0.0503115915,
0.0197032187,
-0.0399207771,
0.0102267768,
-0.0791606233,
0.0379479788,
-0.0175042357,
-0.0024551351,
-0.0310392529,
-0.0851785615,
0.0370506383,
-0.0022972382,
-0.0456601381,
0.0287850723,
-0.0492637455,
0.0108815348,
0.0362161696,
-0.0280580707,
-0.025196813,
-0.0044707567,
-0.0379767045,
0.0088007869,
0.0369430967,
0.0073108352,
-0.014931595,
0.0289416555,
0.022578327,
-0.0415142253,
-0.0030262177,
0.0170288794,
0.0547145121,
-0.0091448575,
-0.0019125853,
-0.0483004749,
0.006078227,
-0.0077522271,
0.0183463693,
0.0280441567,
0.0414646529,
0.012049051,
-0.0015770559,
-0.0463055596,
0.0136461817,
0.0077911755,
0.0636858195,
0.0215530265,
0.0014830091,
-0.0016155891,
-0.0520961247,
0.0015621551,
-0.0584474467,
-0.0274946168,
-0.0099166799,
-0.0561235808,
-0.0557822399,
-0.0866113752,
-0.0385702476,
0.0345673189,
-0.0094334716,
-0.0442041941,
-0.0314900279,
0.030554438,
0.0122299436,
-0.0218081027,
0.0272556562,
-0.0208336823,
-0.0091879759,
-0.035593655,
-0.0218086131,
0.0357257612,
0.0051988913,
-0.0219453294,
0.046083346,
-0.0669068396,
-0.0331897996,
0.0067134281,
0.0256325938,
0.0234685615,
-0.0192045737,
-0.0071608438,
-0.0062351003,
0.0028976928,
0.0742734894,
-0.0232259538,
0.0037346424,
-0.0148752835,
-0.0020857556,
0.0028296588,
0.0239633005,
-0.0688002259,
0.0464597493,
-0.0569193214,
0.0805000812,
-0.07570602,
-0.0226446018,
0.0233459156,
0.041649688,
0.0149762714,
0.0198917203,
-0.0623501204,
-0.0377826989,
-0.0244529415,
-0.0221257024,
-0.03138588,
0.0074764662,
0.0754261315,
-0.0189166013,
-0.0012995829,
0.0118467929,
0.0232790373,
-0.0105480468,
0.0051753614,
-0.0462104045,
-0.0232432671,
0.0194061249,
-0.0135222375,
-0.0414819345,
-0.0096754702,
-0.0358763784,
0.0310339481,
0.0148453247,
0.0022661604,
-0.0077448287,
-0.0091535095,
0.0222527683,
-0.0044739316,
0.0039307191,
0.0424369164,
-0.0875474736,
-0.0361332893,
-0.0469400883,
0.0209494438,
0.0633747429,
0.0139802871,
0.0303421412,
0.0296913162,
-0.0048802011,
-0.0015159177,
-0.0156790633,
0.0219596643,
-0.0290745012,
0.000981729,
0.0445796326,
0.0036275433,
0.0263960455,
0.0806933343,
-0.0306703504,
0.0055564474,
0.0488626286,
-0.0291028786,
-0.0152189927,
-0.0544523187,
-0.0262180809,
0.0549433827,
-0.0172008295,
-0.0117555689,
-0.0624614656,
-0.0047769686,
0.0261842702,
-0.0041747703,
-0.0082802167,
-0.0277795698,
0.0477767177,
0.0564847179,
0.0350175947,
-0.0058454298,
-0.0412377156,
0.0102935703,
-0.0489562564,
-0.0190252401,
0.0064710956,
-6.830633103e-33,
-0.0148858316,
-0.0414557867,
-0.0053654509,
-0.0337462351,
-0.0031574769,
0.0205201246,
-0.0310816634,
0.0089972373,
-0.0236108024,
-0.0374539196,
-0.0077371718,
0.0109198531,
0.0134002371,
-0.0141264433,
0.0268423632,
-0.0397374332,
0.0124784922,
-0.0069033913,
-0.0406308323,
0.0315468498,
0.0636159256,
0.0035505721,
0.0197758544,
-0.0232549962,
0.0223227087,
-0.0472952425,
-0.0080729667,
0.0148483859,
0.0551961139,
0.0195937715,
-0.0222031884,
0.040610157,
0.0316687971,
-0.0527421646,
-0.0128286993,
0.0410653651,
-0.0407586657,
-0.0273801554,
0.0666955933,
-0.079235509,
-0.0558764003,
-0.0166240837,
0.017390389,
0.0079732388,
0.0343250707,
-0.0251784958,
0.0450722873,
0.0029357618,
-0.0004702014,
-0.0241853315,
-0.0240324121,
0.017253954,
-0.0594610721,
-0.0236337278,
-0.0269924235,
0.0583709963,
0.0233438611,
0.0288061798,
-0.0198305342,
0.0489314198,
-0.0155415637,
0.0488384999,
0.0642278716,
-0.0042803395,
-0.0368262455,
0.0466734059,
-0.0452684946,
-0.0001222928,
-0.051819507,
-0.0128771029,
-0.0499499179,
0.0125939734,
0.0272530969,
0.0649674684,
0.0240777396,
0.0119166635,
-0.0526577495,
0.0696537644,
0.0075449971,
0.030651845,
0.0070680208,
0.0027051978,
-0.0392880514,
-0.004755686,
-0.0035257186,
0.0539881475,
-0.043174006,
-0.0064269383,
0.001550841,
0.0106754387,
-0.0381044,
0.0349672064,
0.0015075316,
0.0134158237,
0.0122600188,
0.017514972,
0.015422388,
0.0527721085,
-0.0173576865,
0.0275544357,
-0.0471864007,
0.0525357313,
0.0339086503,
0.0079086116,
-0.0232782215,
0.0163774509,
-0.0105577512,
0.0015039613,
-0.0251588579,
0.0224102419,
-0.0046080798,
0.0202889238,
-0.0617375448,
-0.0276060291,
0.0003313996,
0.0344663635,
0.0164083429,
0.0031595819,
0.0383551568,
0.0036984,
-0.0014155257,
-0.0431881063,
-0.0208391435,
-0.0007210019,
0.0150033915,
0.0374180749,
-0.0329193287,
0.0318538211,
-0.0484837629,
-0.0423503667,
-0.0195302963,
0.020739032,
2.769e-7,
0.0386753306,
0.0525409095,
0.0557831302,
0.0432819612,
-0.0448742881,
-0.0046229707,
0.0170149114,
0.0323175974,
0.0530343018,
-0.0209163167,
0.0101193525,
0.0809612423,
0.0235359259,
0.0449611098,
-0.1059212983,
-0.0245334171,
-0.0738487393,
-0.0228690654,
-0.0704457387,
-0.0417859331,
0.1003380418,
0.0381408483,
0.0029149866,
0.0249041487,
-0.0624045096,
-0.0403609723,
0.0099039497,
-0.0029437435,
-0.0727545321,
0.0378416851,
0.0568376929,
0.0269231983,
-0.0274080168,
-0.0152816931,
0.0041874424,
-0.023729071,
0.0734307468,
0.0278983396,
0.038880337,
-0.039694868,
-0.0113329226,
-0.0257465951,
0.0351285636,
-0.032934159,
0.054867167,
-0.0409622751,
0.0027644576,
0.0318694226,
-0.0686268583,
0.0148103088,
-0.0287346728,
-0.0184339993,
-0.0725558475,
0.0425438508,
-0.0182366371,
-0.0239048526,
0.0026975356,
-0.0483118966,
-0.012940797,
0.0120597174,
0.001294969,
-0.0667128563,
-0.0288777426,
0.0071721352,
0.0118178865,
-0.0458784886,
0.027062282,
2.222296407e-34,
0.0589455292,
0.0199068226,
-0.0196692739,
-0.0159325916,
0.0328546725,
-0.0024621151,
-0.0750766322,
-0.0098425858,
0.0092628878,
-0.0829660073,
-0.0090262564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08983v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08983v3 | SafeDecoding: Defending against Jailbreak Attacks via Safety-Aware Decoding | 2024-02-14T06:54:31 | 2024-06-07T17:25:04 | Zhangchen Xu, Fengqing Jiang, Luyao Niu, Jinyuan Jia, Bill Yuchen Lin, Radha Poovendran | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into
real-world applications such as code generation and chatbot assistance,
extensive efforts have been made to align LLM behavior with human values,
including safety. Jailbreak attacks, aiming to provoke unintended and unsafe
behaviors from LLMs, remain a significant/leading LLM safety threat. In this
paper, we aim to defend LLMs against jailbreak attacks by introducing
SafeDecoding, a safety-aware decoding strategy for LLMs to generate helpful and
harmless responses to user queries. Our insight in developing SafeDecoding is
based on the observation that, even though probabilities of tokens representing
harmful contents outweigh those representing harmless responses, safety
disclaimers still appear among the top tokens after sorting tokens by
probability in descending order. This allows us to mitigate jailbreak attacks
by identifying safety disclaimers and amplifying their token probabilities,
while simultaneously attenuating the probabilities of token sequences that are
aligned with the objectives of jailbreak attacks. We perform extensive
experiments on five LLMs using six state-of-the-art jailbreak attacks and four
benchmark datasets. Our results show that SafeDecoding significantly reduces
the attack success rate and harmfulness of jailbreak attacks without
compromising the helpfulness of responses to benign user queries. SafeDecoding
outperforms six defense methods. | [
0.0511061773,
0.0465399735,
-0.0197950806,
0.0288919862,
-0.0067262673,
-0.0011700332,
-0.0337527655,
-0.0028497167,
0.0557614751,
-0.0286365598,
0.015103762,
-0.0039622318,
0.0035718426,
0.013727217,
0.0393337049,
0.024654625,
0.038925387,
-0.0559689328,
0.0407144986,
0.0102072684,
0.024451388,
0.015679488,
0.019164281,
0.0866890326,
-0.0195561871,
-0.0132068936,
-0.0184863321,
0.0303961281,
0.0046586031,
-0.0569333173,
0.0229056496,
0.0276096892,
-0.0326402076,
0.0203613285,
0.0000022476,
-0.018367447,
-0.0321635492,
0.0295138508,
-0.0431636423,
0.0192252807,
0.0110765724,
-0.0526450574,
-0.0316821523,
0.0368903689,
-0.0351114497,
-0.003563591,
0.0523615591,
0.0145161059,
0.089167878,
0.0476149097,
0.0005879308,
0.0250897985,
0.0600770637,
0.0303993449,
0.0338295102,
-0.0470737778,
0.0061074845,
-0.0279010925,
-0.0127134593,
0.0400480814,
-0.0037376971,
-0.011220783,
0.0219828375,
-0.0145494519,
-0.0557059385,
-0.0212285835,
-0.0570141487,
-0.0464038476,
-0.006854129,
0.0374297649,
-0.0322316065,
-0.0314045772,
0.0138104735,
-0.0006728145,
0.0314255245,
0.0095712449,
-0.0120443199,
0.0366058722,
-0.0117876623,
-0.0146773551,
0.015503956,
-0.0024197977,
0.0336900689,
-0.0173110329,
-0.0065404722,
0.0406618938,
0.0053661638,
-0.0128785977,
-0.0204426497,
-0.0463163741,
0.007339525,
-0.0581333712,
0.0160061326,
0.0076873857,
0.0176430792,
0.0052660871,
-0.0707927346,
-0.0544573143,
0.0565975904,
-0.0654589981,
-0.0564619265,
0.0537309647,
-0.0259434618,
-0.0079094358,
-0.0161143541,
0.0017191014,
0.0060309176,
0.0294770487,
0.0115842391,
0.0133020924,
0.0019007262,
-0.0186507236,
-0.0198756326,
0.0613732599,
-0.0027443178,
0.0400172435,
-0.0240733624,
0.0522797853,
0.0015035698,
0.0139799211,
-0.0218036715,
0.0052237823,
-0.0044079372,
0.0308861956,
0.0659974217,
-0.0430243388,
-0.0172418617,
-0.0270221569,
0.0084374733,
-0.1029983461,
-0.0077390918,
-0.0061679706,
-0.0463449322,
-0.002851441,
-0.0375850648,
0.1445629299,
0.0336117968,
0.0092703644,
-0.0641670227,
-0.1105025336,
-0.0251762159,
0.0108131515,
0.0004961233,
-0.0874246806,
-0.0307368692,
0.0252268389,
-0.003932904,
-0.0841996446,
0.0213674102,
0.011350736,
-0.0755869001,
0.0154891685,
-0.0171726681,
-0.0137893353,
-0.0216823295,
0.0472796187,
-0.0045042089,
0.0611564033,
0.0347092934,
0.0599985942,
0.0574588813,
-0.0041767815,
0.0576619841,
0.0406856388,
-0.0024592381,
0.0052909493,
0.0019896931,
-0.014181016,
0.0363714583,
-0.0388504416,
-0.0214452967,
0.0391072929,
-0.0292062685,
-0.0215056669,
0.0660331845,
0.0586174168,
-0.0632365048,
0.0554451421,
-0.0269563515,
0.0128036337,
0.0039325445,
-0.014005797,
-0.0628439784,
-0.001096053,
-0.0760797858,
-0.0382641926,
-0.0122734597,
0.0062615704,
0.0151807433,
0.0180598125,
-0.0097420989,
-0.0241934657,
0.0291289054,
-0.0052032126,
-0.0131049175,
0.0146991154,
-0.0124864914,
0.069448173,
0.0106111271,
-0.035579551,
-0.0426943302,
-0.0606161132,
-0.0043405415,
0.0804904401,
0.0503411926,
0.0382444039,
-0.0029255257,
-0.0042215851,
-0.0128281666,
-0.0218501426,
-0.0185461529,
0.0259527694,
0.0583325922,
0.0010950381,
-0.0114755603,
0.0038713077,
0.0256492589,
-0.0111819776,
0.0198828671,
0.013688053,
0.0152718769,
-0.0180757958,
-0.0443158671,
0.032275226,
0.023530798,
-0.0014605242,
0.0099203419,
0.0183411185,
-0.0018246601,
-0.002334631,
-0.0040647509,
0.0298404358,
0.0427370891,
-0.0088835582,
0.0316933468,
0.020627819,
-0.0468220748,
-0.025991749,
0.0313925892,
-0.031181138,
-0.0186757185,
0.071866557,
-0.0207876079,
0.0171876345,
0.0584939234,
-0.0619222783,
0.0500829294,
0.0027256513,
0.0141399447,
-0.0087275105,
0.0033460571,
-0.0178326108,
-0.0052682445,
-0.0216210969,
-0.0116942152,
-0.0448067151,
0.0199653693,
0.003182054,
0.0266486481,
-0.0329238214,
0.0146489246,
-0.063255921,
0.0367833823,
0.0184506141,
0.0525907576,
-0.0080612451,
-0.0077638999,
-0.0589938052,
-0.016581377,
-0.0263334289,
0.0243378598,
0.0307845008,
0.0494946428,
-0.0222312827,
-0.0354501009,
-0.00351523,
-0.025768809,
-0.0019102155,
0.025652485,
-0.0095256986,
-0.0422569588,
-0.0376399979,
-0.0091052586,
0.0069324663,
-0.0117260832,
0.0437250622,
-0.0341670848,
-0.0322260335,
-0.0079110954,
0.0076388218,
0.0120683983,
-0.0100059621,
0.0124248872,
-0.0644315481,
0.0269565545,
-0.0061494396,
-0.0128309028,
0.0433105715,
0.0371301584,
0.0192282517,
0.0547445305,
0.0020797979,
-0.0607464053,
-0.0278656352,
0.049513828,
-0.0384257808,
-0.0205341373,
-0.0928857177,
0.0453100801,
0.0398183428,
0.0435058065,
0.0145659754,
-0.0424149521,
0.0082674297,
-0.0144536821,
-0.0329132378,
0.0043999925,
-0.0195291582,
-0.0453138351,
0.0188174397,
-0.0110569177,
-0.0688632652,
0.0794353262,
-0.0215518195,
0.0257179905,
-0.0126169287,
-0.0153884226,
0.0094421171,
0.0314975902,
-0.0498614013,
0.0369508974,
0.0317535698,
-0.0577837676,
-0.0030794791,
-0.0168171283,
0.0123218037,
-0.0366985537,
0.0342447869,
-0.044320669,
-0.0187774468,
-0.0067764185,
-0.0234422889,
-0.0346284658,
-0.0770350173,
-0.0214992668,
-0.0406097174,
0.0518664718,
-0.0276101995,
0.0181783736,
-0.0129999388,
0.0083182752,
-0.0014993582,
-0.034115959,
-0.0017443806,
-0.0222109575,
0.0068322415,
0.0050281934,
-0.0834003761,
-0.0084671108,
-0.0044707288,
0.0379361771,
0.1132193357,
0.0523533225,
0.0066504544,
-0.0113630677,
0.0089773685,
0.0353434086,
0.0209191889,
-0.0006655694,
0.0702189133,
0.0537850782,
-0.0269968715,
-0.0452536009,
0.0300598443,
0.0325893424,
-0.0085084438,
0.042669829,
-0.0210927352,
0.0581813268,
0.0080808727,
0.009541858,
-0.0542138815,
-0.040135771,
0.0213200655,
0.0880147219,
-0.0060527241,
-0.0146004055,
-0.0195944998,
-0.0607247725,
0.0126676168,
0.0391969867,
-0.023072185,
-0.0089647556,
-0.0462569557,
-0.0281753205,
0.0298223682,
0.0107110273,
-0.0080599189,
0.0059677428,
-0.0005167194,
0.0149187567,
-0.0749099851,
0.0067901192,
0.0124481386,
-0.0548304282,
0.0540800095,
0.1006477103,
-0.0171981901,
-0.0043378868,
0.0411573648,
0.0171752106,
0.0222920645,
-0.0237904023,
-0.0013683777,
-0.0144333951,
0.0161468759,
0.0052532288,
0.0066036456,
0.0158531889,
-0.0521347672,
-0.0439323224,
0.0427411497,
0.0220138393,
-0.0223965831,
0.0047924328,
-0.0394757725,
0.008470187,
0.0276884511,
0.0314934961,
0.0366241224,
-0.0228915308,
-0.0346889161,
-0.1009695902,
-0.0104005132,
-0.0659321621,
-0.0112966094,
0.0089388248,
0.0360040031,
-0.0511016548,
-0.0599755123,
0.0301857423,
-0.0406461954,
0.0007708227,
0.0322473496,
-0.0026940119,
-0.0030480926,
0.0166153163,
-0.0218249112,
-0.0330923162,
-0.0240548328,
0.0281812772,
-0.0555957295,
0.0561754853,
-0.0157534312,
-0.0089817997,
-0.0050922479,
0.0395854786,
-0.0580915511,
-0.0796730295,
0.0208694097,
0.0825792551,
0.0207585748,
-0.0068953326,
-0.0589765757,
-0.0760729015,
0.0188787896,
0.1033895835,
-0.1016842574,
-0.0061340621,
0.0509387627,
-0.0270009879,
0.0328609683,
-0.0080207959,
-0.0673841462,
-0.0488556661,
0.0385577343,
0.0211803392,
-0.042739585,
-0.0204451084,
0.0238345135,
0.056388557,
-0.0185630787,
0.0050213048,
0.0141098984,
0.0606935658,
0.0171341989,
-0.0102560138,
-0.0311233979,
0.0047073644,
0.037943121,
0.0102423811,
-0.0349845216,
0.0305708367,
0.0114593226,
-0.0155588742,
0.0459085219,
0.0124311913,
0.0356478691,
0.0043262737,
0.066252999,
0.0539219417,
0.0021935212,
-0.0345661677,
0.0419246331,
-0.0057265633,
0.0135628665,
-0.0326169096,
0.0304533597,
-0.0324834473,
-0.0211465098,
0.0063849273,
0.049580805,
-0.0664288476,
-0.05614255,
-0.0014110352,
0.0547513664,
-0.031862516,
0.0482975915,
0.0094709704,
-0.0115882438,
0.0233953614,
-0.053391993,
-0.0078556575,
-0.0325855277,
-0.0626348257,
-0.0001645243,
-0.0023032993,
-0.00827845,
-0.0184093844,
0.0784286261,
0.0202937033,
0.0251431279,
0.017140273,
-0.0465852804,
-0.0386665426,
0.0109810857,
0.0858392417,
0.0419804007,
-0.0679553598,
-0.0577998199,
-0.0546914786,
-0.0790256709,
-0.0360513628,
0.0017557541,
0.0680266991,
0.0250514094,
-0.0270462036,
0.0511754341,
0.0115564009,
-0.0127132433,
-0.0670533627,
0.0316114426,
0.0070107402,
-0.0283325929,
-0.0091788573,
-5.679983193e-33,
0.0300566405,
-0.0233153272,
-0.0703227967,
-0.0316480957,
0.0225991681,
-0.0257050656,
-0.0540217981,
0.0125590675,
-0.0002607405,
-0.0352855325,
-0.0109087676,
0.015931448,
0.0057325326,
-0.0033172064,
-0.0057193274,
-0.0364778079,
0.0202364661,
0.0163784921,
-0.0246143471,
0.044334501,
0.0418679453,
0.0193489473,
-0.0081647374,
-0.060647428,
0.0371737741,
-0.0497841276,
-0.0111894133,
0.0038365289,
0.0028440738,
0.0595239028,
0.0151891774,
0.0131994057,
0.0036690419,
0.003978359,
-0.0186329763,
0.0396538079,
-0.0117293345,
-0.0109193576,
0.024349371,
0.000096749,
0.0129097747,
-0.0767949298,
0.0244418848,
-0.0011752336,
-0.0078559555,
-0.0100552514,
-0.018534109,
0.0049843746,
-0.0228602011,
-0.0340176336,
-0.0052843946,
-0.0116796615,
-0.0444293693,
-0.0223445222,
0.0075990297,
0.0280391164,
0.0010597843,
0.0023073414,
0.0118478779,
0.024660496,
0.0083636576,
-0.0130829727,
0.0344478078,
-0.0088906186,
-0.0320542976,
0.0381542556,
-0.0382633433,
-0.025590837,
0.0136054847,
0.0031914189,
0.0060698711,
0.0434384979,
0.0190923642,
0.0734173432,
0.0605216138,
-0.0371234976,
-0.0603453182,
0.0284354277,
0.0010541977,
0.0209059138,
0.0340034328,
-0.0030972601,
-0.0525069274,
-0.0146272285,
-0.0054192198,
0.0305837244,
-0.0167114697,
-0.0527428836,
0.0188529193,
-0.0222904701,
-0.0485036559,
-0.0625015274,
-0.0052442672,
-0.087763764,
0.0013018842,
0.0457349531,
-0.0003630622,
-0.0315969326,
-0.0359503552,
0.0508748628,
0.0296635479,
0.0098141963,
0.0373069495,
-0.0727991536,
0.0466397703,
-0.0052426257,
0.0265161023,
0.0185960308,
-0.0514298119,
-0.0314355008,
-0.0119379573,
0.0428563468,
-0.0048751049,
0.0005444957,
0.0261381753,
-0.0147365835,
0.0030893618,
-0.0265463647,
0.0261567384,
0.0110860085,
-0.0576749183,
0.0138704069,
-0.020266097,
0.0216629282,
0.0002737329,
-0.0046922499,
-0.0103966808,
-0.0003172727,
0.0389083922,
-0.0689323694,
-0.0201455299,
0.0115271537,
2.952e-7,
-0.028482588,
0.0233836416,
0.041924946,
-0.0137708969,
0.0286595039,
0.080437243,
-0.0186966248,
0.0760297477,
0.0117860222,
-0.0254370812,
-0.0414564721,
-0.0201434698,
0.0676465183,
0.0644206107,
-0.0608079433,
0.0183711313,
-0.0534446165,
-0.0174245685,
-0.0537216179,
-0.0029240693,
0.0619117767,
0.0556032546,
-0.0230261963,
-0.0230628084,
0.0146252951,
-0.0265031494,
-0.0173194241,
-0.0131544042,
0.0067945239,
-0.0068716123,
-0.0109637883,
0.0333000869,
0.0526214354,
0.0268155839,
-0.026200626,
-0.0481881611,
-0.0266427826,
0.037692599,
0.0094534019,
0.0078998711,
-0.0131721944,
-0.0460889898,
0.0046216291,
-0.0466442816,
0.0331826657,
0.0018707892,
-0.0008331645,
-0.018010335,
0.0005228557,
-0.0331014134,
-0.0269974247,
-0.0335772149,
-0.0082367919,
0.007988519,
0.0268336162,
0.0339728519,
0.0331352651,
-0.0304589514,
-0.0267173238,
-0.0119277183,
0.008285162,
-0.0487706847,
-0.0180316903,
0.076678507,
0.0378622301,
-0.0399885364,
0.0521136522,
2.991680189e-34,
0.0005881042,
-0.0388266109,
0.0157810841,
0.0412524231,
0.059443146,
0.014863709,
0.054310333,
0.0370872766,
0.0043685129,
0.015225932,
-0.0274471845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08971v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08971v2 | Structured Language Generation Model for Robust Structure Prediction | 2024-02-14T06:33:22 | 2024-02-19T00:06:41 | Minho Lee, Junghyun Min, Woochul Lee, Yeonsoo Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous work in structured prediction (e.g. NER, information extraction)
using single model make use of explicit dataset information, which helps boost
in-distribution performance but is orthogonal to robust generalization in
real-world situations. To overcome this limitation, we propose the Structured
Language Generation Model (SLGM), a framework that reduces sequence-to-sequence
problems to classification problems via methodologies in loss calibration and
decoding method. Our experimental results show that SLGM is able to maintain
performance without explicit dataset information, follow and potentially
replace dataset-specific fine-tuning. | [
0.005114188,
0.0780262128,
0.0204552338,
0.0294982418,
0.0378904194,
0.0266162958,
-0.0283609405,
-0.0007950669,
0.0041754935,
0.0049471469,
-0.0201366693,
-0.0499978364,
0.022417156,
0.0570750237,
0.0542583019,
-0.0344958268,
-0.0048819548,
-0.0323785879,
0.0138561195,
0.0057000443,
0.0080237174,
0.0263304431,
0.048504252,
-0.0048637637,
-0.0052996571,
0.0213346295,
-0.0304418243,
0.0430323444,
-0.0134677058,
-0.0788816437,
0.0770498961,
0.0375609323,
0.0332149975,
0.0036393411,
0.000002013,
0.0031894273,
-0.0033702976,
-0.0017569269,
-0.0129497657,
-0.0242680721,
0.0055333301,
-0.0954507664,
0.0190510806,
0.0390001573,
-0.0068884389,
-0.0179629903,
0.0457731038,
0.0186086874,
0.0082640881,
0.0791783854,
-0.0196609981,
-0.0805762485,
0.0270570945,
-0.0451055951,
-0.0169567429,
-0.0141163506,
0.0147992261,
0.0273186937,
-0.0430029072,
0.0264897551,
0.0166514702,
0.0212502815,
0.0159838889,
0.0059528989,
0.0191718601,
0.0264325943,
-0.0508493967,
-0.0287092794,
-0.0104019335,
0.0764931813,
-0.0293844193,
-0.0221968703,
0.0327590592,
-0.047631368,
-0.0170442648,
-0.0547752529,
0.0076296572,
0.0348817259,
-0.0353641957,
0.0350110419,
0.0367124341,
0.005759662,
0.0460705459,
-0.0202719197,
0.0053721219,
0.0414306223,
-0.0014496936,
0.0021518003,
-0.0316184573,
0.0357203968,
-0.0061631855,
-0.0097740116,
-0.0063523082,
0.0293882731,
-0.0412790924,
0.0268439446,
-0.0893046185,
-0.0421488285,
-0.0067943931,
-0.0787060186,
0.0563421845,
0.0203084443,
0.0004025773,
0.003774344,
-0.0616537035,
0.0416524671,
-0.0340178013,
0.0138160829,
-0.0353546999,
-0.0023473545,
-0.0334837213,
0.0041547548,
-0.0145659056,
0.0541024022,
-0.0672229901,
0.0027577451,
-0.0328730121,
0.0202522203,
0.0351434834,
0.0186341815,
0.025841713,
0.0099045485,
-0.068162553,
-0.0196716115,
0.0040641832,
-0.0417162739,
-0.012671886,
-0.0268718153,
0.0046307067,
-0.0185656697,
0.0116671016,
0.0555507205,
-0.0116154077,
0.0027567567,
0.013828706,
0.0624188259,
-0.0338864587,
0.0049567805,
-0.0703718066,
-0.058185745,
-0.0093891779,
-0.0664895177,
0.0408951081,
-0.038315881,
0.040905349,
0.0359158553,
-0.0363656692,
-0.0717031285,
0.0317669362,
-0.0220478307,
-0.0217242111,
0.0567407683,
-0.0479493774,
-0.0334386081,
0.0238431748,
-0.0012351713,
0.0389076136,
0.0690056682,
0.0181494076,
0.0179560054,
0.013387776,
0.0187602527,
-0.0387995876,
0.0468262993,
0.0152646778,
0.0071812337,
-0.011210354,
0.0280337185,
-0.0284032002,
-0.0114434874,
0.017863173,
0.0277754124,
0.0156247579,
0.0018748427,
0.0138559332,
-0.0317499153,
0.0346008241,
0.028791504,
0.0133855268,
-0.0112687126,
-0.0105368681,
0.0015103708,
-0.0295246188,
-0.0088491328,
-0.0317880847,
0.0517433472,
-0.0076430929,
0.0024741397,
-0.0289293267,
-0.0225572698,
-0.0280351341,
-0.0252780896,
0.0048269629,
-0.0150705613,
0.0281035006,
0.0195352696,
-0.0868967623,
0.0465337932,
0.0089859599,
-0.0237692539,
0.0337003358,
0.0181929618,
0.0200126767,
0.023057444,
0.0111033292,
-0.0108623654,
-0.0431933738,
0.0140367951,
0.0085149202,
0.0496792644,
-0.021058796,
-0.0286605246,
0.0553891361,
-0.064545922,
-0.0505111441,
0.026407389,
0.0147195095,
0.0165779088,
0.0075442591,
-0.014974365,
0.0766657814,
-0.0307270419,
-0.0451196879,
0.0450873449,
-0.0318396352,
-0.0372067504,
0.0164417811,
-0.0122461598,
0.0481007732,
0.0023165704,
-0.00377832,
0.0027578208,
0.0394730791,
-0.0309795309,
-0.0012673947,
-0.0300488025,
-0.101028651,
-0.0577843711,
0.0065920008,
-0.0027271409,
0.0200367793,
0.0099150632,
-0.0436193123,
-0.057555303,
-0.0447820351,
-0.0031581386,
-0.0188246369,
-0.0466686487,
0.0286222156,
0.0331528783,
0.0179464035,
-0.0227341242,
0.0533524379,
-0.0155190071,
-0.0085458513,
0.0206935257,
0.007463681,
0.0192761887,
-0.0308914259,
-0.0264234897,
0.0348387435,
0.0152384033,
-0.0078546768,
0.0386827625,
0.0220391415,
-0.0392457359,
-0.0009743041,
-0.0034835967,
-0.0260244701,
-0.0456477888,
0.0555097796,
0.0351635069,
0.0078981258,
0.0208908897,
-0.0385215692,
-0.0785891265,
0.0124473497,
-0.000589216,
-0.0238980986,
0.0434918217,
0.0295790918,
-0.0332155041,
-0.0182834528,
0.0014245671,
0.0068118856,
0.0299384054,
0.0206533838,
-0.0570148267,
-0.1050589383,
0.0660329014,
-0.0086084111,
0.0261429958,
-0.0226898529,
-0.0083556082,
-0.0172020402,
-0.0334547646,
-0.0010795004,
0.0036148704,
-0.0133043416,
-0.0297364742,
-0.0108250119,
0.0404168181,
-0.0332696959,
-0.0085049309,
-0.0614697784,
0.0129765738,
-0.0393588617,
-0.0479587279,
0.0099186338,
0.0891176164,
0.0128268898,
0.0546950884,
-0.0737438872,
-0.0367009416,
0.0312413722,
-0.0121415546,
-0.0154596437,
0.022019716,
0.0036785724,
0.04384166,
0.0027512419,
-0.0486513227,
0.0550656579,
-0.0437043346,
-0.019351216,
0.000976978,
0.0027016257,
-0.0388819054,
0.0384561047,
0.033238709,
0.012208106,
0.0503839105,
-0.0392771773,
-0.0793261006,
-0.0265838597,
0.0394178852,
-0.0107776364,
-0.0020274087,
-0.0488092937,
0.0114912027,
-0.0062210835,
-0.0293922629,
-0.0593984984,
0.0355922915,
-0.0029516267,
0.034895543,
0.049725391,
-0.0339746848,
-0.0139392857,
0.0177686699,
-0.064269416,
0.0716003403,
0.0045553702,
0.0029571275,
-0.0170542952,
0.0631242618,
0.0324226134,
-0.0259249993,
-0.0164813325,
-0.0607305095,
-0.0132692913,
0.0433954895,
-0.0336178578,
0.0207569227,
-0.0171403158,
0.0236378703,
0.0521221235,
0.0353187546,
-0.0297912378,
0.0451774858,
0.0241961777,
-0.0581130646,
-0.0423885211,
0.1004113853,
0.0149830105,
-0.0049629281,
-0.0140652405,
0.0015726648,
0.1176073551,
0.0273462906,
0.0140510071,
-0.0228510704,
-0.0192480609,
-0.0085762097,
0.0493043922,
0.0196019467,
-0.0499632806,
0.0071593043,
-0.0915745795,
0.0065961876,
0.0397778004,
-0.0598778911,
-0.0557382554,
0.0016591145,
-0.0382569134,
0.0043795668,
0.0131170815,
0.0328595378,
-0.0038143767,
0.0001197548,
0.0453854203,
-0.072722353,
-0.0309409741,
-0.0395214893,
-0.0178298336,
0.0442312844,
0.0573945381,
-0.0199117474,
0.0138554601,
0.0259875935,
0.0555852354,
0.0047939261,
0.0028685385,
-0.0255342182,
0.0474831834,
0.0032316002,
-0.006713469,
0.009163551,
0.0464436226,
-0.0795439184,
0.018050082,
0.0212776549,
0.0439741351,
-0.0064748172,
-0.0114313234,
0.0003306012,
-0.0234657638,
0.0506759472,
0.034355741,
0.0078429142,
-0.0045265476,
-0.0359941684,
-0.0351420119,
0.0336516984,
-0.0453768186,
0.0340586416,
0.039429903,
-0.0312919021,
0.0148827983,
-0.0937451199,
-0.0463028252,
0.0428472944,
-0.0037079051,
-0.0094038425,
0.0088553336,
0.0100531038,
-0.0346390679,
-0.0601643026,
-0.0297695249,
0.0016422655,
-0.0226685815,
-0.0626421869,
-0.040471226,
0.0068581477,
-0.0295030214,
-0.0180081166,
0.0294419769,
-0.0975139812,
-0.0811046287,
-0.0285683274,
0.0513978451,
0.007545976,
0.0766437724,
0.0301362369,
-0.0063801827,
0.0637633801,
0.0139816673,
-0.0215904545,
-0.0308522526,
0.0636970922,
-0.0372584425,
-0.0313377082,
0.0377986245,
-0.0566929728,
0.0005147248,
0.0351122767,
0.0406548493,
0.0149660362,
-0.0420482233,
0.025003681,
0.034665823,
0.0045205839,
-0.0705398396,
-0.0125816809,
-0.0057130009,
0.027040679,
-0.0004041537,
-0.0075808465,
-0.0471804403,
0.0424472056,
0.0279563311,
-0.0066409851,
0.0083574625,
0.0366189443,
-0.0151678827,
0.0744895414,
-0.0067672646,
0.0012945675,
0.0154149374,
0.0187941827,
0.0775871128,
-0.0073016286,
-0.0115099419,
0.0377751365,
0.027001854,
0.0540534928,
-0.0317054726,
0.01899595,
0.0248207115,
0.0723342821,
-0.0140020009,
-0.0062876437,
0.0030303951,
-0.0023089137,
-0.0931398124,
-0.0116045959,
0.0096487589,
0.0079364823,
0.0328260809,
-0.0335410424,
0.0029621064,
-0.0306044258,
0.0850166529,
-0.0171686392,
-0.0245027505,
0.0313380547,
-0.0008334016,
-0.037532635,
-0.0083690006,
0.0900956318,
0.0927356109,
0.0054526539,
-0.0042858166,
0.0039726151,
-0.0484511293,
0.0048087733,
-0.0030948434,
0.0123302657,
-0.0373201817,
0.00255012,
0.013282395,
-0.0804935768,
0.0418551452,
-0.005704178,
0.0238621458,
0.0097979913,
0.0396714397,
0.0392591693,
-0.0247306488,
-0.0015227909,
-0.0218595676,
-0.0232155696,
0.0242365152,
0.0002011298,
-0.0488333739,
-6.106202751e-33,
-0.008444624,
-0.0401083715,
-0.0011898576,
-0.0084999427,
0.0212409794,
-0.0049936273,
-0.0504895188,
0.0291638356,
0.0081271892,
0.0033852472,
-0.0106674442,
0.0003038411,
0.0230592173,
0.0669757947,
0.0007873418,
-0.0318489671,
0.0344921909,
-0.0167089868,
-0.0150330793,
0.0300767981,
0.0196682904,
0.0545220599,
0.0735413581,
-0.0896297544,
0.0212001689,
-0.0364735425,
0.0021153311,
-0.0199432634,
0.0552223437,
0.0287084728,
0.0061989999,
0.0451067053,
0.0172717981,
-0.0028036006,
-0.0329004005,
-0.0172025207,
-0.1119039282,
0.0214295071,
-0.0017143711,
0.0183567218,
-0.0306783337,
0.0026097838,
0.0003065446,
-0.0445353948,
0.0004459139,
-0.0340736769,
0.0431022719,
-0.0389153026,
-0.0344108604,
-0.0751242116,
-0.0494251363,
0.0306352489,
0.0089684213,
0.0118187508,
0.0263317581,
0.030881511,
0.0005920146,
0.0145269502,
-0.0383313186,
-0.0034886566,
-0.0046195877,
0.0390128493,
0.0520767272,
0.0968046933,
-0.0247296896,
0.0114984084,
0.044846613,
0.009577848,
-0.0209372174,
0.0319552198,
-0.012415274,
0.0210417472,
0.0084712077,
0.0424317345,
0.0188013092,
0.0043841959,
-0.0877483934,
0.0280492064,
-0.0239075553,
0.009624552,
0.0137452511,
0.0073528863,
-0.0247418433,
-0.0460898392,
-0.0184146278,
-0.0573526248,
0.0039008446,
-0.0144806392,
0.0306041483,
0.0382869132,
-0.0414435305,
-0.0105439164,
0.032740511,
-0.0169573594,
-0.0199709367,
0.0386646613,
-0.0158415921,
-0.0283371117,
-0.0126517676,
0.0157429967,
-0.0542089678,
-0.058631029,
0.0228455737,
-0.001653414,
0.0160403457,
-0.0180146955,
0.0381207354,
0.0252938792,
-0.0505015329,
0.0107727014,
-0.0406092778,
0.029120408,
0.0228131358,
0.078519024,
0.0192662962,
-0.0411279574,
-0.0227158442,
0.0467468314,
0.0041574519,
0.003940226,
-0.014004468,
0.0163803827,
0.0355205722,
0.0609925948,
-0.0163192414,
0.0039957864,
-0.0325010866,
-0.0378643535,
0.0980134606,
-0.025930034,
-0.0014446317,
0.0108601535,
2.504e-7,
0.0582720749,
0.0197971687,
0.0343129225,
0.0216530431,
-0.0161186978,
0.025273703,
0.0061053978,
0.0298838541,
-0.0176778473,
-0.0488668047,
0.011515527,
-0.0674938187,
0.0472772829,
0.0113036176,
-0.097956799,
-0.0025397218,
-0.0458190478,
0.0473422296,
0.0025609459,
-0.0074184486,
0.0132955099,
0.1051570624,
-0.0558246002,
-0.0247011557,
0.008939499,
-0.0401941389,
0.0442788973,
0.0035531893,
0.0160725303,
0.0192702487,
-0.0205710623,
0.0269234572,
-0.040650364,
0.0153504265,
-0.04095871,
-0.0001862724,
0.0353375413,
0.0672908053,
0.0198010821,
-0.0197611116,
0.0229448285,
-0.0060899351,
-0.0023149929,
0.0010620652,
0.0278903283,
-0.0505411513,
-0.0129911238,
0.0412650704,
-0.0411237627,
0.0229041725,
-0.0332512408,
-0.0010576021,
-0.0122298719,
0.0149628315,
0.0479402915,
-0.0246790629,
-0.0030587683,
-0.0434353389,
-0.0292795859,
-0.0188340638,
-0.0335132182,
-0.0333100408,
-0.0296058729,
0.0039535584,
0.0091190236,
-0.0273521412,
0.0017888708,
2.410788992e-34,
0.0029176534,
-0.0033320375,
-0.0256547499,
0.0445284098,
0.0209455118,
-0.0505182818,
-0.0027743611,
0.0283193123,
0.0175339263,
-0.0466484912,
-0.0157071613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10965v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10965v2 | Generalization in Healthcare AI: Evaluation of a Clinical Large Language Model | 2024-02-14T06:24:52 | 2024-02-24T13:17:38 | Salman Rahman, Lavender Yao Jiang, Saadia Gabriel, Yindalon Aphinyanaphongs, Eric Karl Oermann, Rumi Chunara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Advances in large language models (LLMs) provide new opportunities in
healthcare for improved patient care, clinical decision-making, and enhancement
of physician and administrator workflows. However, the potential of these
models importantly depends on their ability to generalize effectively across
clinical environments and populations, a challenge often underestimated in
early development. To better understand reasons for these challenges and inform
mitigation approaches, we evaluated ClinicLLM, an LLM trained on [HOSPITAL]'s
clinical notes, analyzing its performance on 30-day all-cause readmission
prediction focusing on variability across hospitals and patient
characteristics. We found poorer generalization particularly in hospitals with
fewer samples, among patients with government and unspecified insurance, the
elderly, and those with high comorbidities. To understand reasons for lack of
generalization, we investigated sample sizes for fine-tuning, note content
(number of words per note), patient characteristics (comorbidity level, age,
insurance type, borough), and health system aspects (hospital, all-cause 30-day
readmission, and mortality rates). We used descriptive statistics and
supervised classification to identify features. We found that, along with
sample size, patient age, number of comorbidities, and the number of words in
notes are all important factors related to generalization. Finally, we compared
local fine-tuning (hospital specific), instance-based augmented fine-tuning and
cluster-based fine-tuning for improving generalization. Among these, local
fine-tuning proved most effective, increasing AUC by 0.25% to 11.74% (most
helpful in settings with limited data). Overall, this study provides new
insights for enhancing the deployment of large language models in the
societally important domain of healthcare, and improving their performance for
broader populations. | [
0.0464761369,
0.0610127635,
-0.0135714505,
-0.0325442739,
0.0074105542,
0.0498037413,
0.0126969824,
0.0172801632,
0.0164219197,
0.0006559631,
0.0178672057,
-0.0631227717,
0.0083754594,
0.0557647906,
0.0050309491,
-0.0484792069,
0.0358288549,
-0.0144686829,
0.0414933972,
-0.0029465295,
-0.040272411,
0.0139893238,
-0.010574284,
0.0651128441,
0.0200184323,
0.0249960236,
0.0213585217,
-0.0229456965,
0.0082715871,
-0.05070078,
-0.0045437058,
-0.005398897,
0.0057038935,
-0.0272737294,
0.0000022597,
-0.0724570304,
-0.0250059422,
0.0269940998,
-0.0394082963,
-0.0355550572,
0.0327688418,
-0.0724173263,
0.0113718398,
0.0298649687,
-0.0119800866,
-0.0658219084,
0.0176543351,
0.0346086621,
0.0081615439,
0.0430935249,
-0.0265434161,
-0.0192818902,
-0.0112980306,
-0.0181945749,
0.003623738,
-0.07520473,
0.0472944975,
0.0157344174,
0.0269066505,
-0.0830520093,
-0.0094543463,
0.0316643827,
0.0113838334,
0.0310374144,
0.0303999521,
0.0499772243,
-0.0465682968,
0.0025632002,
-0.0046714665,
0.0440781079,
0.0067894491,
0.0183858126,
0.0229727142,
0.0032629555,
0.0233832672,
0.0125851305,
-0.0549852923,
0.0021176024,
0.0026405789,
0.0023203723,
-0.001407374,
0.0150223458,
0.0477094091,
-0.0162234139,
-0.0458229631,
-0.0027688055,
0.0135063622,
-0.0279120095,
0.0182182472,
0.0145332534,
-0.031341359,
-0.0187381376,
0.0456451885,
0.0549755581,
-0.0716865659,
0.0046930416,
0.0192809049,
0.0164447911,
0.0857408121,
-0.0508711971,
0.0468234941,
0.0040863319,
0.0129755046,
0.0355778225,
0.0056517958,
-0.0020149008,
-0.0241068266,
0.0168527402,
-0.0388745591,
-0.0103098918,
-0.0564234145,
0.0158078577,
-0.0074142809,
0.0333408862,
0.0450173952,
-0.0001873624,
-0.0840889215,
-0.0096388143,
-0.0040958109,
0.0288588982,
0.0401020944,
0.0375447907,
0.0012950413,
-0.0034837993,
-0.0101347053,
-0.0077646836,
-0.0148970187,
0.0255827121,
-0.0319123901,
-0.0105468584,
0.0429349095,
0.0082366467,
0.0153586837,
0.0116345705,
-0.0024662684,
0.0480587892,
0.0269929022,
-0.0201117545,
-0.0293114744,
-0.0247962493,
-0.0468398444,
-0.0180389695,
-0.0163290408,
-0.0550728813,
0.0092925522,
0.0289557111,
0.0269905087,
-0.0511917174,
-0.0092558069,
-0.0364512242,
-0.0583422817,
-0.0046500238,
-0.0505067185,
0.023081433,
0.0501074716,
0.025185464,
0.0203092247,
-0.0022411314,
0.0260242708,
-0.0073894267,
-0.0161712673,
-0.0517204143,
0.0435898043,
0.0269134529,
0.0072885551,
-0.0161481816,
0.0260419212,
0.0086460654,
0.0143551342,
0.0603226088,
-0.0426152311,
0.0660503879,
0.010040598,
-0.0037306177,
0.0191842038,
0.0442287363,
0.0550885648,
0.0195719525,
0.0120460512,
-0.0283888709,
-0.0250879396,
-0.0765772313,
-0.0006964616,
-0.0072264327,
0.0090598008,
-0.0080072852,
0.016611455,
0.0074363411,
-0.0418427512,
-0.0467943363,
-0.0446388759,
-0.0175180659,
-0.034080755,
-0.0118203321,
0.0667501017,
-0.0246715434,
-0.0148627069,
0.0336303562,
0.0507556796,
0.0040051863,
-0.0398821384,
-0.0843798816,
-0.0020099552,
0.1064745709,
0.0466702133,
-0.0270331372,
0.0103437072,
-0.0327812098,
0.0039867046,
-0.0173181146,
0.0422541946,
-0.0122090904,
0.0005805739,
-0.0343950912,
0.0048583644,
0.0518185832,
0.0272668097,
0.0008480222,
-0.0087684458,
0.0157907419,
-0.0300727934,
-0.0366658121,
-0.0894173831,
0.0524161644,
-0.0450717099,
0.0005357747,
-0.0020717257,
0.0010786584,
0.0463185348,
-0.0058850511,
0.00575798,
0.001067728,
0.0035256164,
-0.0140888263,
-0.0368240885,
-0.0051605781,
-0.056964118,
0.0117867356,
-0.0148816099,
0.0192790497,
0.0137138302,
-0.0429675281,
-0.0075542317,
-0.0337867662,
-0.0117937718,
-0.0315904282,
0.0389270447,
0.0172023103,
0.0585871525,
0.0017048834,
-0.0116809802,
-0.0442760885,
0.0133868838,
-0.0529649556,
-0.0133028282,
-0.0199939106,
-0.019879004,
0.0128440429,
0.0079378961,
-0.0199294239,
0.0038159918,
-0.0290715694,
0.0183512624,
-0.0010145631,
0.0035938192,
-0.0106442384,
-0.0228090603,
-0.1194220334,
-0.0224593487,
-0.0027497387,
-0.0301217027,
0.0109885177,
0.0227895454,
-0.0138105312,
-0.0078862142,
-0.0149063757,
-0.0029267343,
0.0154735949,
0.0190402642,
0.0069591436,
0.0625310838,
-0.0523770377,
-0.0219969992,
0.0119610289,
-0.0412665382,
0.0396618731,
0.0092876554,
-0.0343827531,
-0.0139330318,
0.0278460532,
-0.0198234711,
-0.0535811894,
-0.0245191678,
-0.0204701778,
-0.0007072271,
-0.0430250093,
-0.0290077459,
0.0336256586,
-0.0402559564,
0.0073010917,
0.048924081,
0.0063632098,
-0.0249151606,
0.0075901514,
-0.0183541272,
-0.0380226038,
-0.0070707342,
-0.0512800701,
-0.0200442243,
0.0713302791,
0.0292873885,
0.0078051388,
-0.017093949,
-0.011655705,
-0.0717003345,
0.0334460065,
-0.0500674807,
0.0304176379,
-0.022607239,
0.0526923686,
0.0235125609,
-0.0522464924,
0.0542462915,
0.0195261016,
0.0667706057,
-0.0648214668,
-0.0470270813,
-0.068007946,
0.0044117854,
-0.0088922717,
0.012458792,
-0.0273424778,
-0.0278232899,
0.0162694976,
-0.0054902765,
-0.0625741929,
-0.0407557487,
0.1006883904,
-0.0166058354,
0.045576904,
0.0152638704,
-0.0563529991,
-0.0275820009,
0.0070493878,
-0.0354483165,
0.0066073565,
0.0251187589,
-0.0090952553,
-0.0605111718,
0.0279948302,
-0.0088122869,
0.085845165,
0.0005590327,
-0.0391703956,
0.0228524096,
-0.0476109944,
0.0094795385,
-0.0034115426,
-0.011420982,
-0.0328600816,
0.0352996141,
0.0194192827,
0.0131291216,
0.0346301533,
-0.0177014992,
0.0035968686,
-0.0081494339,
-0.0375634246,
-0.0106138205,
0.0618790761,
0.0372784473,
-0.0474719256,
-0.0090978229,
0.0990165025,
0.0286911689,
-0.0802766606,
0.0274654385,
-0.0452032387,
-0.0056650108,
-0.0003462117,
0.0051538087,
-0.0109648695,
-0.023021454,
-0.008492833,
0.0278358422,
0.0040528174,
-0.0298547745,
0.0471196808,
-0.0100327497,
0.0210568197,
0.0218140446,
-0.0730100572,
-0.018199794,
-0.0195928141,
0.0064367699,
-0.0290345158,
-0.012157782,
-0.0132963769,
-0.0252107456,
-0.0304278489,
-0.004931611,
-0.1110273525,
-0.0627266169,
0.0392732769,
-0.007514385,
0.0550205,
0.0682464987,
0.0271226037,
-0.0367173851,
0.0281783845,
0.0293158498,
0.0405258425,
0.0310045704,
-0.0011754337,
0.0629035234,
0.0334810093,
0.0207603108,
-0.0378214009,
0.0039471323,
-0.0377531759,
-0.013844124,
0.0396325961,
0.0833488926,
-0.0586675927,
-0.0586028583,
-0.0156721454,
0.0187649969,
0.0150438976,
0.0201889053,
-0.0080650691,
-0.0296950359,
-0.0233388525,
0.015553005,
0.0144263022,
-0.0033379823,
0.0174713172,
0.0298618171,
-0.0207578428,
-0.009394208,
-0.0207104944,
-0.017129818,
0.0505136959,
-0.0238322672,
0.033039391,
0.0195681769,
0.0523631126,
-0.0025750885,
-0.0277137384,
0.0128264595,
-0.0118760709,
0.0112574538,
-0.0524411649,
-0.0655428022,
0.0445061065,
0.0172834732,
-0.0093211727,
-0.0229492113,
0.0008637665,
-0.0024630309,
0.0605101027,
0.0610736832,
0.0226874016,
-0.0128961131,
0.0272307415,
-0.0231926702,
0.0637008771,
-0.0054176431,
-0.0215977672,
-0.0307490174,
-0.0235489402,
0.0042835255,
-0.0213322993,
0.0133590549,
-0.0370110348,
0.057970129,
0.0212043747,
0.0035844899,
-0.0366289504,
0.0074095265,
-0.031361647,
0.0159807708,
-0.0295324661,
-0.0023515627,
-0.0300215427,
-0.0446270965,
0.0048503163,
0.0051811435,
0.0482073091,
0.0048959148,
-0.0163120907,
0.0523325577,
-0.0012697105,
-0.0130288629,
-0.0083536627,
-0.051665917,
-0.0630621165,
-0.032554809,
0.0515244231,
0.0204900932,
0.0168173164,
0.0717117861,
-0.008022774,
-0.0151818153,
0.0430839434,
0.007109859,
0.0278058425,
0.0241290033,
0.0637347996,
-0.0265863668,
0.0530125648,
-0.0421679765,
0.0346746892,
-0.021865543,
-0.0788471922,
-0.0021389327,
0.005281752,
0.0354786441,
-0.0060721878,
0.0033359909,
-0.0284440555,
0.021768555,
-0.0377240218,
0.0067587406,
0.0018754939,
0.0154479304,
0.0389659442,
0.0146496091,
-0.0385524184,
0.0153118465,
0.0883345604,
0.0009318304,
0.0456450507,
-0.029560538,
-0.0042345477,
-0.0383266956,
0.0088162068,
0.0456663705,
0.0183082633,
-0.0755524412,
-0.0199719742,
-0.0665210038,
-0.0055059097,
0.0313526727,
-0.0368936583,
-0.0122445971,
-0.0379329585,
0.0405887738,
0.039573282,
0.0032303161,
-0.0090873772,
-0.0263292175,
-0.008783536,
-0.0264299307,
0.0011938692,
0.0167497583,
-5.759566365e-33,
0.0189040303,
-0.0278779529,
0.0183854755,
-0.0425302945,
0.0156112136,
0.0230110437,
-0.0124568325,
-0.0061560301,
-0.011007742,
0.0083021568,
-0.0090587661,
0.0079642851,
-0.0054976121,
0.0288072973,
0.0505784824,
-0.0341046825,
0.0115546528,
0.0390696898,
-0.018651586,
0.0396442711,
-0.0204800796,
0.0439953655,
0.0192075595,
-0.0641429871,
0.0092344601,
-0.0052359141,
0.025298629,
-0.0259803981,
-0.0365828872,
0.0581776798,
-0.0145649379,
0.0460583121,
0.0492052622,
-0.010403201,
0.0062672654,
0.0389008783,
-0.0036253866,
-0.0178690869,
0.0204964913,
-0.0272722635,
0.0038648336,
-0.0587713011,
0.0383141711,
0.0104138581,
-0.0558421798,
-0.0068286504,
0.0167564135,
-0.043567095,
-0.0231580883,
-0.0375925116,
-0.0289320406,
0.0538399555,
-0.0172173586,
0.0189644191,
-0.0626207292,
-0.0359156504,
-0.0609131493,
0.0799775571,
-0.0556316972,
-0.0124120628,
0.0226453766,
0.0048238998,
0.0012480563,
-0.022337731,
-0.0414418951,
0.0671332926,
0.0386352986,
0.0485619716,
-0.0478470623,
0.0012959761,
-0.0495339558,
0.0225488916,
0.0442471243,
0.0216468442,
0.0220422465,
-0.0495789014,
-0.0900216103,
0.0273298919,
-0.0788553655,
0.0454208404,
0.0827506408,
-0.0214939024,
-0.0670561939,
-0.0244898256,
-0.0399574265,
0.0154885063,
-0.0149807753,
-0.0022398916,
0.0377087444,
0.0139771039,
0.0427988656,
0.0322415382,
0.0190738849,
-0.0257294178,
0.0171890408,
0.0046183271,
0.0404739417,
0.0211138129,
-0.0431966819,
0.0023647042,
-0.0648295507,
-0.0289438013,
-0.0037537133,
-0.0036236122,
0.0615427978,
0.0117257489,
0.0407514758,
-0.0303699262,
-0.0477337576,
-0.0150998048,
0.0603593811,
-0.0250695385,
-0.0129736569,
0.0135041587,
0.0383221172,
0.0184972771,
0.0196616855,
0.0920848176,
-0.0093400003,
-0.0083656097,
-0.0302308742,
-0.0468259454,
-0.0143097341,
-0.0145193283,
-0.0402594618,
0.008780594,
-0.0465088226,
0.0292364731,
0.0574959479,
-0.0499898084,
-0.0055100797,
-0.0046865242,
2.971e-7,
0.0913973674,
0.0797381774,
-0.0325729027,
-0.0555709079,
0.0365472808,
-0.0052254293,
0.0038205825,
-0.0356264077,
0.0093033751,
0.0414082669,
0.0672256052,
-0.0008259107,
0.0548854917,
0.0489794612,
-0.0789859146,
-0.0031461986,
-0.1051726341,
-0.0002896356,
-0.0734529346,
-0.0186015405,
0.02814731,
0.0780892745,
-0.0356761403,
-0.0435687304,
0.00718799,
-0.0067372816,
0.0176849179,
-0.062034186,
-0.0169449467,
0.0662753657,
0.0060489369,
0.0326762125,
0.0086594075,
0.0398966782,
-0.0195965935,
0.0211886242,
-0.0189717785,
0.1072179526,
-0.0711035803,
0.0417856574,
0.0352565721,
-0.0176783688,
0.0285081267,
-0.0585510805,
0.0701272413,
-0.051516179,
-0.0441463925,
-0.0205041282,
0.0073015909,
-0.019191388,
0.1049721986,
-0.0165366624,
0.0024457807,
0.0230569914,
0.018151857,
-0.0043598744,
-0.0341041498,
-0.0493463129,
-0.011892478,
0.0669506267,
-0.018310139,
-0.0406524949,
0.0567590892,
-0.0304678362,
0.008400104,
-0.0671589747,
0.0354377553,
2.474126556e-34,
0.0627470911,
-0.0079510128,
0.0072813835,
-0.0039554276,
0.0397206396,
-0.0262032598,
-0.0069520567,
0.0371005684,
-0.0038549099,
-0.053211011,
0.0020704118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08966v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08966v2 | Pretraining Vision-Language Model for Difference Visual Question Answering in Longitudinal Chest X-rays | 2024-02-14T06:20:48 | 2024-06-17T12:57:55 | Yeongjae Cho, Taehee Kim, Heejun Shin, Sungzoon Cho, Dongmyung Shin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Difference visual question answering (diff-VQA) is a challenging task that
requires answering complex questions based on differences between a pair of
images. This task is particularly important in reading chest X-ray images
because radiologists often compare multiple images of the same patient taken at
different times to track disease progression and changes in its severity in
their clinical practice. However, previous works focused on designing specific
network architectures for the diff-VQA task, missing opportunities to enhance
the model's performance using a pretrained vision-language model (VLM). Here,
we introduce a novel VLM called PLURAL, which is pretrained on natural and
longitudinal chest X-ray data for the diff-VQA task. The model is developed
using a step-by-step approach, starting with being pretrained on natural images
and texts, followed by being trained using longitudinal chest X-ray data. The
longitudinal data consist of pairs of X-ray images, along with question-answer
sets and radiologist's reports that describe the changes in lung abnormalities
and diseases over time. Our experimental results show that the PLURAL model
outperforms state-of-the-art methods not only in diff-VQA for longitudinal
X-rays but also in conventional VQA for a single X-ray image. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed VLM architecture
and pretraining method in improving the model's performance. | [
0.0388251431,
0.0670870543,
-0.0106220124,
0.0295748748,
-0.0227510333,
0.0243771691,
0.0064401403,
0.0219345707,
0.0181381572,
-0.0056467,
-0.0221560132,
-0.0423011631,
-0.0099799363,
0.0490833968,
-0.0069912313,
-0.0689523965,
0.0542847365,
0.0025372906,
0.0248355959,
-0.0158861447,
0.0019185821,
-0.0136537002,
-0.022688888,
-0.0083900737,
0.02707964,
-0.0310427677,
-0.0090265628,
0.0070109172,
0.0371880122,
-0.0397124439,
0.0069014849,
0.049132362,
0.0432534851,
0.0113459202,
0.0000019089,
-0.0242945831,
0.0090153422,
0.0170962531,
-0.0373874754,
-0.043730896,
0.0099693583,
-0.0211292021,
0.0067113219,
-0.0106455516,
-0.0487310216,
-0.0789626315,
0.0545542501,
0.0321896225,
0.0929029137,
0.0505315177,
-0.0131782675,
-0.0123596806,
0.0185719412,
-0.0249756929,
0.0431648195,
-0.0697722137,
-0.0008620115,
0.0110289799,
0.0271793772,
0.0354130417,
-0.0467236191,
0.0717281997,
0.0586279184,
0.0445459336,
0.0259741675,
0.0659614503,
0.0132920993,
0.0017872991,
-0.0264116805,
0.0961678624,
-0.0256746504,
0.011432182,
-0.0244406648,
-0.0327332988,
0.0069346987,
-0.0239337813,
-0.0301551651,
-0.0028882746,
-0.0161123648,
-0.012603757,
-0.0416365638,
0.0002164167,
-0.0144156488,
0.0067851651,
-0.0443124734,
-0.0600198917,
0.0041894424,
0.0126019651,
0.0134147713,
0.0339526422,
0.0046350523,
-0.0642987788,
0.0274386033,
0.0631166026,
-0.0511314906,
0.0122131705,
-0.0267165694,
-0.0410294794,
0.0074268715,
-0.0588879175,
0.0062731565,
-0.0150144324,
-0.0976020023,
0.0633334517,
-0.042919375,
0.0749373809,
-0.0365827419,
0.0402565934,
-0.0502728894,
0.016730424,
-0.0452132113,
-0.0309775211,
-0.0620875955,
0.0122259157,
-0.0434562229,
-0.0347429402,
-0.0301871002,
0.002309517,
-0.0057499036,
0.0078025297,
0.0373124182,
0.0580667444,
-0.0240212362,
0.007123373,
-0.0205602422,
0.0437466241,
-0.0341158919,
-0.0035106868,
-0.017441757,
-0.0603797026,
-0.0022251345,
0.0201435536,
0.013426532,
-0.021074947,
-0.0051233661,
0.0351882093,
-0.0535258204,
-0.0031765646,
-0.0008966087,
-0.0240782909,
0.0077449377,
-0.0449436195,
0.035809502,
-0.086584121,
0.0508362614,
0.0075443736,
0.0000641674,
-0.0215555504,
-0.0008329774,
0.0057745823,
-0.0399272181,
0.103694655,
-0.0238775499,
-0.0071978476,
0.0267050527,
0.0272756778,
0.0598687232,
0.0365427881,
0.0078272745,
-0.0267326161,
0.0274981726,
0.0095138969,
0.0192153808,
0.0278734937,
0.001313007,
-0.021459138,
-0.0511393175,
0.0434000716,
-0.0151553256,
0.066621758,
-0.0109426267,
0.050033696,
-0.0237983204,
-0.0752967894,
0.0260643363,
0.0485194698,
0.0477235653,
-0.0183802694,
0.0243754275,
-0.0172757059,
0.0173697546,
0.0214207768,
-0.0204502326,
0.0398483835,
0.0379021317,
-0.0120689133,
-0.0580175258,
-0.0155744394,
-0.0653240308,
-0.0499020703,
-0.0130546009,
0.0013534059,
-0.0100275427,
0.0094606904,
0.0440349691,
0.0173950158,
-0.0378062055,
-0.005410823,
0.007752399,
-0.0080729416,
-0.0246024095,
-0.0635892972,
0.01298411,
0.0748165473,
0.0245302785,
-0.0070674098,
-0.0616326816,
0.0146554876,
0.0152989924,
0.0408411771,
0.0528226867,
-0.0104121668,
0.0216031279,
-0.0537939146,
-0.0409229994,
0.0143251196,
-0.0033778667,
0.002546662,
0.0206991713,
0.0011055729,
-0.0136701604,
-0.0303605013,
0.0001873138,
0.0457939133,
-0.0293998048,
-0.0199002177,
-0.0259966701,
0.0083303126,
0.0048870039,
-0.013693843,
-0.0232320577,
-0.0072939182,
0.0008348618,
-0.0051721022,
-0.0297632124,
0.0256571006,
-0.0684346035,
-0.0313346125,
0.0176261384,
-0.049403742,
-0.0245530494,
0.0266828425,
-0.0600189231,
-0.0154990247,
-0.0178349502,
-0.0509908795,
-0.0084751705,
-0.033417996,
-0.0306388438,
0.052491419,
-0.004820521,
-0.056795124,
0.0328275338,
-0.0148287099,
-0.0045979656,
0.0006203325,
0.0212038551,
0.0143881105,
-0.0442761444,
-0.0141565436,
0.0321801268,
0.0112631992,
0.0068388605,
-0.0212759394,
0.0345333144,
-0.0373266637,
0.0028658751,
-0.0573317148,
0.0020781248,
-0.0134704551,
-0.0123345163,
0.0378056727,
0.0024531146,
-0.0176718105,
-0.0844739601,
-0.068903245,
0.0463842638,
0.0526332073,
0.0270381607,
0.0653835088,
0.0243463814,
0.0357612148,
-0.0488282405,
-0.024883531,
-0.0005158217,
0.0272951722,
0.0396704711,
-0.0270864889,
-0.0195973571,
0.0301670693,
-0.0584284104,
0.0671415627,
-0.011891732,
-0.0330349244,
0.0349340364,
-0.0466393791,
0.0166360009,
0.0708668157,
0.003082874,
0.009963694,
-0.0065148463,
-0.0197623763,
-0.0530513488,
0.0137218991,
-0.0180801898,
-0.0666126013,
-0.0081573548,
-0.0181985106,
-0.0377064794,
0.0579592772,
-0.0121719558,
-0.0178219806,
-0.0413918905,
-0.0059974501,
-0.0227022078,
-0.0107598705,
-0.0794819519,
0.0184419397,
0.0214335714,
0.0276328903,
-0.024022432,
-0.0610526949,
0.094443731,
0.0266069174,
0.0009353371,
-0.0747120455,
0.0093720891,
-0.025097305,
0.0697230324,
0.0424205475,
0.0223066956,
0.0209706686,
-0.0143849291,
-0.0853329301,
-0.0256930832,
-0.0067256149,
-0.0414256901,
0.0245190766,
-0.0494120419,
0.0358681791,
-0.0421372093,
-0.0082072141,
-0.0430192761,
-0.0170654189,
-0.0167701356,
0.0016505454,
-0.0670824796,
0.0170914866,
-0.0560452752,
0.0464936644,
0.0028920942,
0.0585505478,
-0.007803821,
-0.0002039592,
-0.0285048652,
0.06585522,
0.0457414016,
0.0522343069,
-0.0032966323,
-0.0389235765,
0.0009065907,
0.0821446329,
-0.0004442318,
0.0043387213,
-0.0503644273,
0.0228342973,
-0.0043360721,
-0.0021088938,
0.0192644522,
0.0067297705,
0.0497171208,
-0.077991657,
-0.0179463066,
0.0581992865,
0.0577998124,
-0.0144567955,
-0.0325135849,
0.0213734843,
-0.0298846066,
0.0018211625,
0.0270522367,
-0.0724621192,
-0.0255190581,
-0.039148856,
0.0021204187,
0.0114192655,
-0.0004225537,
-0.0199344549,
-0.043533504,
0.0390575789,
-0.009094174,
-0.0297212023,
-0.0097615663,
0.0140816318,
-0.0072210757,
-0.0041047507,
-0.0415358469,
0.0026674408,
0.025931282,
-0.0089956913,
-0.0065846061,
-0.0081207799,
-0.0157087371,
0.0277708601,
-0.0497340932,
-0.0265343618,
0.0447809771,
-0.0060819294,
-0.0217275918,
-0.0600466095,
0.0181916393,
-0.0048718248,
0.017033238,
0.0041133361,
0.0750631988,
0.0150136892,
-0.0344902426,
-0.0415845737,
0.0190228894,
-0.013636915,
-0.0238368604,
-0.0029095958,
0.0320268609,
-0.0068695582,
-0.0325749889,
-0.0640785992,
0.0440265089,
0.0024267556,
0.0113940462,
-0.0008165355,
-0.0065247915,
-0.0663555935,
-0.0125320032,
0.0448923446,
-0.0659956709,
-0.0322260112,
0.011186366,
0.0013742538,
-0.0007426493,
-0.0668011606,
-0.0398127474,
0.0132849347,
0.0166945364,
-0.0308349356,
-0.0499663651,
0.0170946866,
-0.0015056616,
-0.0740256906,
0.0744855106,
-0.0000810251,
0.0340709388,
-0.0403036028,
-0.0366936438,
0.0491589755,
0.001704904,
-0.0436972231,
0.00950367,
-0.0848877355,
0.0210333951,
0.0006629351,
0.0468544327,
0.0174935684,
0.0252862796,
-0.0198565777,
-0.0311720744,
0.0643948242,
0.0154347215,
-0.0156088276,
0.0125183789,
0.0089362888,
-0.054137677,
-0.0328956768,
-0.0074921679,
0.0154112158,
0.0306826048,
0.0426884331,
0.0305621382,
-0.0346235856,
-0.0087449504,
0.0036383725,
-0.0054294295,
0.0089550493,
0.0421919897,
0.0089190062,
-0.0396264717,
0.0399829485,
0.0163846184,
0.0196189638,
-0.0380600728,
-0.0117753455,
0.0134654855,
-0.0015018776,
-0.0094884383,
0.004141151,
-0.0311641321,
0.0029771959,
-0.0463146344,
0.0165170636,
0.0759498551,
-0.000066997,
0.027558893,
-0.0099924309,
-0.0186585113,
-0.0044367448,
0.008540323,
0.0450092405,
0.0119078439,
0.070032239,
0.0356000587,
0.0083158799,
-0.0163428802,
0.0421260856,
-0.0389010832,
-0.0379386768,
-0.0142739071,
0.0248766504,
0.0223677978,
0.0157678705,
-0.0533097759,
0.0250200629,
-0.0032582842,
-0.0185340811,
0.0071103503,
-0.0054397737,
0.0137533192,
0.0786644369,
0.0258455593,
0.0340768471,
-0.0187051184,
0.0733917654,
0.0272442233,
0.0354630239,
-0.027055908,
-0.0078809178,
-0.0503038131,
-0.0254107155,
0.0068860617,
-0.0100922091,
-0.035587877,
0.0558703765,
-0.0144177489,
-0.0465475842,
0.0071531273,
0.0344031937,
0.0043770899,
0.0376281589,
0.0609425232,
0.0585522689,
0.0273797922,
-0.0534011945,
0.0051176092,
0.0331766121,
-0.0077397604,
-0.0082550859,
-0.000575933,
-5.843921676e-33,
-0.0236392301,
-0.01256127,
0.0840857103,
-0.0626712367,
-0.0073358477,
0.0314862952,
-0.0216216221,
-0.0139674703,
-0.0349904858,
0.0031641615,
0.0067565199,
0.019765988,
0.0292171706,
0.0285833031,
-0.0182696357,
-0.0359215029,
0.0330057628,
-0.0100732911,
0.0060681854,
-0.0050729439,
-0.0346595459,
0.0276148636,
0.0606320649,
-0.0586700514,
-0.0104631986,
0.0067327959,
0.0278942548,
0.0235311687,
-0.0021758219,
0.0577352382,
-0.0191204324,
0.0005363576,
0.035672266,
-0.0253676772,
-0.0328520052,
0.0270281397,
-0.1050033644,
-0.0414973162,
0.0211117137,
0.055021584,
-0.0770615414,
0.0271141659,
0.0175143853,
-0.0376727544,
0.0564466864,
-0.059740942,
0.0398943312,
-0.0148100946,
0.0337231979,
0.0316639394,
-0.0187611114,
0.0450433716,
0.0165370815,
-0.0022098382,
-0.008210375,
0.0005549185,
-0.0218583848,
0.0449606292,
-0.0413060412,
-0.0008755334,
0.083429046,
0.0301792771,
0.0157394372,
0.026858855,
-0.0383179598,
0.0185776781,
0.0706373677,
-0.0817636475,
-0.021064382,
0.0171440504,
-0.0010530382,
0.016726872,
0.0761799514,
0.0402779616,
0.0471569002,
0.0337869339,
-0.0859341025,
-0.0186133645,
-0.0927883536,
0.0923994631,
-0.0086121969,
-0.0128586926,
0.014491125,
0.0078977887,
-0.0126691321,
-0.0064817611,
-0.0439703427,
-0.0032714384,
0.0618147552,
0.0268170573,
0.0202096403,
0.0380525738,
0.0483071953,
-0.0371225514,
0.0271126498,
-0.0085526779,
0.0350323431,
0.0377854407,
0.0120338639,
0.0462834388,
-0.0266013984,
0.0136700263,
0.0777292997,
-0.0012314006,
0.006095103,
0.0133927157,
0.0381282605,
0.0120870806,
-0.0612264648,
-0.0066432222,
-0.0031356637,
-0.0237568077,
-0.0322681591,
0.0555665046,
0.0129732741,
0.0498322919,
-0.0585769787,
0.0586500764,
-0.01722835,
-0.033819817,
-0.0447884239,
-0.0419995412,
-0.0119999917,
0.0444000661,
-0.0230944846,
0.0035689042,
-0.03873289,
0.0063743601,
0.030066181,
-0.0589228012,
-0.000844751,
0.0663163438,
2.57e-7,
0.039078407,
0.0099188602,
0.0521218441,
0.0195900183,
0.0225025862,
-0.0101550817,
-0.0389796309,
0.0183362421,
0.0183479115,
-0.011749126,
0.0208220668,
0.074637033,
-0.0161293782,
0.0289808717,
0.0100573553,
0.0102400808,
-0.0430763178,
-0.0016388153,
-0.0362924971,
-0.01316051,
0.0809441507,
0.0583695099,
-0.033809755,
-0.0196974911,
0.0308960583,
-0.0294123814,
0.054116182,
-0.0060604541,
0.0253295265,
-0.004293229,
0.0047438727,
0.0248825438,
0.007427481,
0.0673606098,
0.0151316151,
-0.0277080368,
0.0400125198,
0.0586511567,
-0.0319906697,
-0.0227454901,
-0.0224332865,
0.0182866119,
-0.0101195164,
-0.0366859138,
0.0780572966,
-0.0738459229,
0.0003135479,
-0.0063617923,
-0.0586281158,
0.0123228133,
0.0502301045,
-0.0349670611,
-0.0364965945,
0.0338604487,
0.0520222373,
0.0254923198,
-0.0168114714,
-0.0953518972,
-0.0065790806,
0.0107076028,
-0.0133296391,
-0.0275450926,
-0.0285690594,
-0.0380620658,
0.0096928459,
0.0014517135,
-0.0357784331,
1.666816322e-34,
0.0207761414,
0.0199435912,
-0.0194338225,
0.0008733017,
-0.0190818068,
-0.0157991219,
-0.0255805422,
-0.0040826653,
0.0167129468,
-0.043325901,
-0.0068985717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08957v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08957v3 | MUSTARD: Mastering Uniform Synthesis of Theorem and Proof Data | 2024-02-14T05:57:58 | 2024-05-23T03:13:23 | Yinya Huang, Xiaohan Lin, Zhengying Liu, Qingxing Cao, Huajian Xin, Haiming Wang, Zhenguo Li, Linqi Song, Xiaodan Liang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Recent large language models (LLMs) have witnessed significant advancement in
various tasks, including mathematical reasoning and theorem proving. As these
two tasks require strict and formal multi-step inference, they are appealing
domains for exploring the reasoning ability of LLMs but still face important
challenges. Previous studies such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) have revealed the
effectiveness of intermediate steps guidance. However, such step-wise
annotation requires heavy labor, leading to insufficient training steps for
current benchmarks. To fill this gap, this work introduces MUSTARD, a data
generation framework that masters uniform synthesis of theorem and proof data
of high quality and diversity. MUSTARD synthesizes data in three stages: (1) It
samples a few mathematical concept seeds as the problem category. (2) Then, it
prompts a generative language model with the sampled concepts to obtain both
the problems and their step-wise formal solutions. (3) Lastly, the framework
utilizes a proof assistant (e.g., Lean Prover) to filter the valid proofs. With
the proposed MUSTARD, we present a theorem-and-proof benchmark MUSTARDSAUCE
with 5,866 valid data points. Each data point contains an informal statement,
an informal proof, and a translated formal proof that passes the prover
validation. We perform extensive analysis and demonstrate that MUSTARD
generates validated high-quality step-by-step data. We further apply the
MUSTARDSAUCE for fine-tuning smaller language models. The fine-tuned Llama 2-7B
achieves a 15.41% average relative performance gain in automated theorem
proving, and 8.18% in math word problems. Codes and data are available at
https://github.com/Eleanor-H/MUSTARD. | [
0.0019831785,
0.0971630365,
-0.0025324225,
0.0412010401,
-0.0460092165,
0.0250118859,
-0.0084557878,
-0.0385994688,
-0.0127094192,
-0.0220609363,
0.0115471594,
0.0411758795,
-0.0062436289,
0.0323402137,
0.0498244986,
-0.0636873916,
0.0204162095,
-0.0368622839,
-0.0184588972,
-0.0260174256,
-0.0130312918,
-0.0061242916,
-0.0286254901,
0.0228563249,
-0.0657848418,
-0.0701781884,
-0.0002859277,
-0.015270439,
0.0099239536,
-0.0421300866,
-0.0225471426,
0.0672629029,
0.015688343,
0.0639314502,
0.0000023376,
-0.0548146106,
0.0089125838,
0.035478618,
-0.0441479795,
0.0082370844,
-0.0409621298,
-0.0172497127,
0.0019951616,
0.0271487869,
-0.0593688078,
-0.0280230045,
0.0060474877,
0.0155667989,
0.0802869201,
0.0697904229,
0.0069480445,
-0.1106437072,
0.0431379676,
-0.0131673999,
0.019354349,
-0.0511719845,
0.0067973281,
0.0239413027,
0.0537723936,
-0.0038439641,
-0.0103612868,
0.0495542213,
0.0512106083,
-0.0175390821,
-0.0278687496,
0.0162483193,
-0.0634116828,
-0.0292485394,
0.0207041968,
0.0778978989,
-0.0065163081,
-0.0525850579,
-0.0223523732,
0.0220557246,
0.0008143212,
-0.0014922743,
-0.0340019502,
0.0608623698,
-0.0493374281,
0.0139370747,
0.020682022,
-0.0352639966,
0.0523654148,
-0.0210404396,
-0.0393409133,
0.096666947,
0.0000372334,
-0.0405598953,
0.0038460097,
0.0008479389,
-0.0763383731,
-0.078454785,
0.0126002971,
0.0304211751,
0.0064572846,
0.0086202621,
-0.0301881842,
-0.0385608152,
-0.0045228302,
-0.0295635108,
0.0207474995,
0.0396294445,
0.0030356285,
0.0080367718,
-0.0199971944,
-0.0265666302,
-0.0046688546,
0.0525662564,
-0.0169261061,
-0.024635477,
-0.0369975902,
0.0316792056,
-0.0251136478,
0.0470573008,
-0.0074053458,
0.0207332503,
-0.0238887444,
0.0290799867,
-0.0430737808,
0.0796470493,
-0.0066508208,
-0.0439838618,
0.0081948731,
-0.0114384303,
-0.0162300318,
-0.0561567843,
-0.0735357329,
0.0098184217,
0.0372683927,
-0.0505836084,
-0.0113766734,
0.0116992733,
-0.0158900712,
0.0248267073,
0.0337244757,
0.0670499951,
0.0160748996,
0.0291229971,
-0.042985484,
-0.016885316,
0.0445582047,
-0.0713309795,
-0.0105755059,
-0.1002135798,
0.0550744608,
0.0287666079,
-0.0223659724,
-0.0210663006,
-0.0083911642,
0.0448981896,
0.0239128657,
0.0702347681,
-0.0445026979,
0.0133678187,
0.0232091304,
0.0011806311,
-0.0627400801,
0.0446882695,
0.0477946773,
0.0238410942,
0.0279255211,
0.0101602897,
0.0051316251,
0.0295901466,
0.0170158055,
-0.0203018263,
-0.0243305434,
0.0394623391,
0.0240448136,
0.0655157641,
-0.0303095002,
0.0567657128,
-0.0250340551,
0.0169530716,
-0.0055280379,
0.0325036123,
0.0295404848,
0.0078421691,
0.0723475665,
0.0024202969,
0.0713213682,
-0.0074430783,
-0.0466832668,
0.0052586263,
-0.0466239676,
0.0099575371,
0.004417425,
0.0352188498,
-0.0181848556,
-0.0724013299,
-0.0406525619,
0.0038126369,
-0.0770862252,
-0.006976801,
0.044806309,
0.0274614915,
-0.0006578482,
0.0268848147,
0.0314556323,
-0.0507630967,
-0.0298043732,
-0.0157071091,
0.0622036532,
0.0021285424,
0.0634446293,
-0.0594404452,
0.0156650487,
-0.0457785837,
0.0435650125,
0.0602435581,
0.013961168,
-0.0256869234,
-0.0449112542,
-0.0161658842,
-0.0128257032,
-0.0333297141,
0.0146929873,
-0.0094756829,
0.0509521551,
0.006328892,
0.0220824331,
-0.0395080522,
-0.0052816654,
0.0442872271,
-0.0282761343,
-0.016772382,
0.0194063466,
0.0006093413,
0.0252639819,
-0.0044872314,
-0.0196366664,
0.0466949679,
-0.0020598494,
-0.0456775129,
-0.0045142225,
0.0083279731,
-0.0050730654,
-0.0908145458,
0.036025662,
-0.0853123292,
-0.0385925174,
0.0120413937,
-0.0905599222,
-0.0016264799,
0.034406811,
-0.0192296673,
-0.0314966664,
-0.0313206352,
0.0003795011,
0.0404464528,
0.0194702726,
0.0244890116,
0.058928892,
-0.0035930786,
-0.0083505269,
0.0010395272,
0.0155604789,
-0.0001197406,
0.0113050956,
0.0162514653,
-0.0013792611,
-0.0031716975,
0.0525413901,
-0.0023947768,
0.022218151,
-0.0111289024,
-0.0356347598,
-0.0321644619,
0.0219034199,
-0.0106780175,
0.0313064158,
0.0021124796,
-0.0276227351,
-0.0163576715,
-0.0026986913,
-0.023915533,
0.0174704939,
0.0026294249,
-0.0290591754,
0.0402959809,
-0.0038668062,
-0.0315384306,
-0.0201477092,
0.0059169563,
-0.0204943158,
0.0457371809,
-0.0092265122,
-0.0022921185,
0.0134740248,
0.005370535,
-0.0342338234,
0.0320489034,
-0.0036929003,
0.0240762979,
0.0554465875,
-0.012594834,
0.0232902523,
0.0489040688,
0.0290997773,
0.0132331494,
0.0162982158,
-0.0117688933,
-0.0339733995,
0.0299208928,
0.0013550743,
0.0506050438,
-0.0085760029,
-0.0219835471,
0.0080190767,
0.0327342115,
-0.0307444707,
-0.0181895141,
-0.0271377955,
0.0409851819,
-0.0069009974,
0.0083829686,
-0.0050064591,
0.0441931412,
-0.0224497356,
0.0197133981,
-0.0076486627,
-0.0463698097,
0.0373655781,
-0.0407166146,
0.0048580496,
-0.0345729329,
0.0003870505,
-0.0797823444,
0.035237588,
0.0073470296,
-0.0207612142,
-0.0163168497,
0.0354016796,
-0.0087963855,
-0.0024768689,
0.0628812313,
-0.0160753615,
0.0393456444,
-0.0486678742,
0.0053840727,
-0.0264622997,
-0.0313301012,
-0.0608763397,
0.0187083744,
-0.0400916226,
0.0069825016,
-0.0188708603,
-0.0066785524,
-0.0253074244,
-0.0311043859,
0.0077836937,
0.0594641007,
0.0035266383,
-0.0253981613,
-0.031461522,
-0.04593895,
0.0027669789,
-0.0060808086,
0.0304021221,
-0.0486797132,
0.020955544,
0.0394537896,
0.0071481364,
0.0321385674,
-0.0100055672,
-0.0034251751,
-0.0133638717,
-0.0261745024,
-0.0274427161,
0.0186857376,
-0.0192689877,
-0.0443941876,
0.0011790564,
0.0998710096,
0.0248326641,
0.0039201607,
0.0167100281,
-0.0394941457,
0.0509685762,
0.0247317106,
0.0241664071,
-0.1269245744,
-0.0429589823,
0.0231616478,
0.0146802152,
0.011727456,
-0.0303003788,
-0.0187143069,
-0.1256523728,
0.0545145087,
0.0167999435,
-0.0317284539,
0.0228336155,
-0.0407651328,
0.0140592344,
0.0215893183,
-0.0167738125,
0.0139262397,
-0.0062580085,
0.040481627,
0.0384672545,
-0.0351290889,
-0.0647767335,
0.0251696017,
-0.041205883,
-0.0014810358,
-0.0352062248,
0.0175418966,
-0.013566005,
-0.0639597774,
0.0401749946,
0.0491998456,
-0.0327592231,
-0.0110319648,
0.0085972156,
-0.0271087494,
0.0144964308,
0.0079364022,
0.0498322174,
-0.0574304499,
-0.0438923575,
0.0658326596,
0.1050810739,
-0.0119903972,
-0.0432614572,
-0.0513548404,
0.013186167,
-0.0167940967,
0.0444961973,
0.0432987139,
-0.0001459873,
-0.0190052092,
-0.0417892337,
-0.0315163098,
-0.0580469929,
0.0037944061,
0.0079014711,
0.0196468681,
-0.0348936804,
-0.0443808325,
-0.0133694382,
0.0295529887,
0.1003470644,
0.0031489113,
-0.0176414438,
-0.0154320644,
-0.0066935164,
-0.0395616777,
0.039860826,
-0.0421346053,
0.0300178993,
-0.0517231897,
0.004963317,
-0.01033979,
0.0132784126,
-0.0428972282,
0.078187421,
-0.0662292987,
-0.0575261265,
-0.0069954828,
0.0514442883,
0.0186657868,
0.0554892682,
0.0041849338,
0.0027512563,
0.0259820279,
0.0734618753,
0.0149883581,
0.0062685506,
0.0700438321,
-0.0239325371,
0.0263506491,
0.0349443667,
0.0026065556,
0.0210242998,
0.0125123784,
0.0606769323,
0.0242158305,
-0.0327856578,
0.0123765944,
0.0549227819,
-0.0340873711,
-0.0004937436,
-0.0175027661,
-0.0139503293,
0.0280516539,
-0.032434009,
-0.0315076895,
-0.0558427311,
0.0503775552,
-0.022583684,
-0.0277038738,
-0.0003233251,
0.0034264275,
0.0047352235,
0.0356453881,
0.0170227978,
0.0220034234,
0.0041842754,
0.0623281859,
0.0532474779,
-0.0562479235,
-0.0094546825,
-0.0503337122,
-0.0026478376,
0.031267114,
-0.0208132304,
0.0271927081,
0.0566758923,
0.026171498,
-0.0474165492,
0.0056795548,
-0.0079391552,
-0.0467623137,
-0.0384269543,
0.0482624918,
0.0504198335,
0.0491247587,
0.006278282,
-0.0443541817,
-0.0148914866,
0.0068934653,
0.068114236,
-0.0023403165,
-0.0452888422,
0.0177653152,
0.0040436052,
-0.0072282571,
-0.0550817512,
0.0429421961,
-0.0639971197,
0.0413614884,
-0.0015088569,
0.0245690253,
-0.0546849892,
-0.0106795738,
-0.0425924212,
-0.0000250025,
0.0078758402,
-0.0121151982,
-0.0831823796,
-0.1028822735,
0.0196610186,
0.0355622247,
-0.0210677981,
0.0527480431,
0.0392380729,
0.0753229707,
0.0397962183,
-0.0294451527,
0.009640377,
0.0327642262,
0.0002590331,
-0.0609998107,
0.0402805172,
-6.041183587e-33,
-0.0238354299,
0.0092534656,
0.0201836228,
0.0232559443,
0.0154838292,
-0.0415875874,
-0.0590595827,
-0.0144367153,
0.0015731441,
0.05347348,
-0.0279597305,
0.0161176194,
0.0020019198,
0.0012712959,
-0.021326948,
0.0148630152,
0.0079202019,
0.0079580359,
-0.0634436384,
0.0012635489,
0.0350726768,
-0.0001526146,
0.0640301928,
-0.0248960257,
-0.0115836328,
-0.0072800964,
-0.0129306279,
0.0165060479,
-0.0573591068,
0.0328308307,
-0.0057789437,
0.0392071903,
-0.0132644316,
-0.0055665011,
-0.025814442,
-0.0006977119,
-0.0426811725,
-0.0420951322,
0.0215685647,
-0.0193140823,
-0.0597144179,
-0.0392553881,
0.0336588956,
0.0149476621,
-0.0219985805,
-0.0189002678,
0.0377571695,
-0.0214938596,
-0.0118678715,
-0.0236355886,
-0.0500429086,
0.0489231087,
-0.0230579264,
-0.0292033292,
-0.0097643482,
0.0109809618,
0.0153406253,
-0.0661137924,
-0.0032804951,
0.0024784619,
0.0239383094,
0.0046396209,
0.0622429475,
-0.0537882186,
0.0126810176,
0.0390312932,
0.018985251,
-0.0094816061,
-0.0321686454,
0.0204262976,
0.0120603805,
0.0782418177,
0.0412774496,
0.0089820689,
0.0165403392,
0.0084233992,
-0.0702038184,
0.0237019435,
0.0071192617,
0.03295644,
0.0015923952,
-0.0283844583,
-0.0277977232,
0.0028184063,
-0.0526204258,
0.0032228909,
-0.0109941754,
0.0051047592,
0.026315473,
-0.0016608633,
-0.0396061912,
-0.0153080551,
-0.0041193827,
-0.0361130387,
-0.062009722,
0.0183300506,
-0.0339728296,
0.0037757803,
0.0102539314,
0.0272293296,
-0.0449302681,
-0.0283373334,
0.0076285489,
0.0323087387,
0.0401662327,
0.015863454,
0.0320965499,
0.0181619823,
-0.0171351153,
0.0005314287,
-0.0724520534,
0.0179073662,
-0.0038292604,
-0.0029591594,
0.028486751,
0.0357519276,
0.0046148985,
0.0281740781,
-0.0223511588,
-0.0097485892,
-0.0388756022,
0.0941703022,
0.0262264628,
0.0244624503,
-0.0044251871,
-0.0107150506,
-0.0228783414,
0.0054672626,
0.0554458648,
-0.0656614378,
0.009567515,
0.0174293071,
2.97e-7,
0.0226829704,
0.0242078602,
0.0424587727,
0.0696479008,
0.0015870841,
0.023761956,
-0.0289704092,
-0.0010695154,
0.0034171562,
-0.0292472914,
-0.028834343,
0.0467575006,
0.035697002,
0.0655226186,
-0.0867910981,
-0.0123687871,
-0.0609740317,
-0.009231789,
-0.0638090894,
-0.0239618495,
0.0532073081,
0.0835096762,
0.0417403542,
-0.0311932415,
-0.0080350116,
-0.009509501,
0.0467505194,
0.0215513054,
-0.0140194371,
0.038150657,
0.0423627421,
-0.0334186926,
0.0551369898,
0.0097273504,
-0.015130912,
0.0132903988,
-0.0076626702,
0.0436851829,
0.0091184322,
0.0533705354,
-0.0182888433,
-0.0654069185,
0.0055569038,
-0.0371808149,
0.0586366244,
-0.0525299497,
-0.0257223304,
0.0177641977,
-0.0224372223,
-0.0395598486,
0.0273073204,
-0.0041093011,
0.0205515213,
0.0078533245,
0.0311966389,
-0.0177257527,
-0.012108501,
-0.0495478474,
-0.0260625966,
-0.0008960358,
-0.0598143116,
-0.0406960733,
-0.0154176522,
0.017426217,
-0.0018820306,
-0.0163769126,
-0.01042163,
3.087400326e-34,
0.0612360239,
-0.0149609977,
0.0263236128,
0.0083899647,
0.0436417945,
-0.0096049979,
0.0129074641,
0.008600926,
-0.0055393307,
-0.0447009504,
-0.0323018767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08955v1 | Using Counterfactual Tasks to Evaluate the Generality of Analogical Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T05:52:23 | 2024-02-14T05:52:23 | Martha Lewis, Melanie Mitchell | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have performed well on several reasoning
benchmarks, including ones that test analogical reasoning abilities. However,
it has been debated whether they are actually performing humanlike abstract
reasoning or instead employing less general processes that rely on similarity
to what has been seen in their training data. Here we investigate the
generality of analogy-making abilities previously claimed for LLMs (Webb,
Holyoak, & Lu, 2023). We take one set of analogy problems used to evaluate LLMs
and create a set of "counterfactual" variants-versions that test the same
abstract reasoning abilities but that are likely dissimilar from any
pre-training data. We test humans and three GPT models on both the original and
counterfactual problems, and show that, while the performance of humans remains
high for all the problems, the GPT models' performance declines sharply on the
counterfactual set. This work provides evidence that, despite previously
reported successes of LLMs on analogical reasoning, these models lack the
robustness and generality of human analogy-making. | [
0.0289041102,
0.0369204432,
-0.0270766336,
0.0092224749,
-0.042339325,
0.0572022498,
0.0161816906,
0.0193790924,
-0.0095761633,
-0.0377938598,
-0.0516337566,
-0.0326794684,
-0.0332785472,
-0.0403475575,
0.0569516458,
-0.0523870103,
0.015939882,
-0.032352712,
0.0028916216,
-0.0264013913,
-0.0554456711,
0.0153054707,
-0.0128191849,
0.0060806754,
0.0558124371,
-0.0158922672,
0.025146516,
-0.0348957032,
0.0518160313,
-0.0227191299,
-0.0435616933,
0.0190152209,
0.0250343718,
0.0081804572,
0.0000020879,
-0.057726942,
0.0617278554,
0.0032125011,
-0.0018770648,
0.0200176127,
0.0117047876,
0.0133351889,
0.0054418328,
0.0275766458,
-0.0117066428,
-0.026817482,
0.0184420682,
0.0593852773,
0.0135734593,
0.0362027772,
-0.0169263706,
-0.0616874583,
0.0058275568,
-0.0020808768,
0.0246204957,
-0.0092546837,
0.0115143536,
0.0552839525,
0.0326040015,
-0.027253177,
0.0023615707,
0.0023794046,
0.0435735583,
0.053891331,
-0.037138734,
0.0689106137,
-0.0209654737,
0.0275216717,
0.0412148982,
0.036356017,
0.0000358517,
-0.0613876358,
-0.0103745293,
-0.0066183577,
-0.0045338287,
0.0625702217,
-0.0693350732,
0.0227422379,
-0.0106889084,
0.034798909,
0.0401100665,
0.0223042518,
0.0254165269,
0.0163177662,
-0.0335446112,
0.0556037351,
0.0084412172,
-0.0222151987,
0.0425332338,
0.0016112069,
-0.0448268987,
-0.0213402919,
-0.0191212781,
-0.0052324017,
0.0006367497,
0.0106900912,
-0.0196657069,
-0.0072360043,
0.0044208863,
-0.0736799464,
0.0807896629,
0.0748730153,
0.0163572468,
0.046952527,
-0.0851475745,
0.0706400424,
-0.0373989306,
0.1001254693,
-0.0182972029,
-0.0141328303,
-0.0586238205,
-0.0345072374,
-0.0303932428,
0.0286738668,
0.0265215617,
0.0056667295,
-0.0127641177,
-0.0028991869,
-0.0447792299,
-0.0251860823,
-0.0195716731,
-0.0000100718,
-0.0027172039,
-0.0687138662,
-0.0779662803,
-0.0362326466,
-0.0598250031,
0.0464679636,
-0.0141438711,
-0.0332206264,
0.0039834999,
-0.0310816914,
-0.0123320725,
-0.0706574023,
0.0158844031,
0.0736967996,
-0.0231826883,
0.0192439593,
-0.0354013704,
0.0085435193,
0.0644331053,
-0.06370873,
0.0246114619,
-0.0394909345,
0.0169577077,
0.039268259,
0.0022681027,
-0.0288019683,
-0.0148243783,
0.0341506675,
-0.0617562458,
0.0780914873,
0.0661222562,
0.0332568251,
0.0031202382,
0.0023978364,
-0.0257174149,
0.0046495739,
0.0049438137,
-0.0452239811,
-0.0390414596,
0.0015145047,
-0.0152149126,
0.0036132133,
-0.0088904239,
-0.0158309881,
-0.058364071,
0.0117754843,
-0.0122756362,
0.040829815,
0.0671968758,
0.052987054,
-0.0344983153,
-0.0682612136,
0.0499336794,
0.0505807176,
0.0014789486,
0.0548421927,
0.0376007594,
-0.0106023112,
-0.0135342628,
0.029632315,
-0.0866030678,
0.0534981415,
-0.0077579301,
0.0181855094,
-0.0024958611,
0.0178411901,
-0.0573547035,
0.0328255668,
-0.0332071669,
0.015434186,
-0.0060683247,
-0.0144897057,
0.0309225041,
0.0141294328,
-0.0195723716,
-0.0005969341,
0.0191150885,
-0.0053909225,
-0.0140655385,
-0.0512694232,
-0.0067597609,
0.0156252123,
0.0205433331,
-0.0083625372,
0.0076741641,
0.0072924765,
-0.0187891126,
0.0194671098,
0.0783004165,
0.0185760912,
-0.0385614298,
-0.0374568179,
0.0204250924,
-0.0463756882,
0.0062969541,
0.0237485506,
-0.014224912,
0.0187970437,
0.0101141622,
-0.0411546938,
0.0204008333,
0.0352850854,
-0.0764157549,
-0.021404488,
-0.0484534539,
0.0093120178,
0.0197991487,
-0.0169577859,
-0.0092829829,
0.0241731498,
-0.0165295787,
-0.041562777,
-0.0332272612,
0.0842405036,
-0.0634416789,
-0.0057650032,
0.002947516,
-0.0787649378,
-0.0078127002,
0.0489636026,
-0.0064623542,
-0.021698365,
0.0592812635,
0.0111165633,
0.1295252144,
-0.0165882148,
0.034902554,
-0.0148673011,
-0.0050271004,
0.0249483883,
0.0771287605,
0.0059390604,
0.0332022868,
0.0061600045,
0.0350840688,
0.0050553633,
-0.0263134222,
-0.0143278213,
-0.0042138919,
0.024057921,
-0.043283429,
-0.0324739143,
-0.0384209752,
-0.0487985238,
0.0265319701,
-0.052642379,
-0.0095517533,
0.0101970797,
0.0185362101,
0.0385181457,
-0.017809581,
-0.0161586925,
-0.0043944512,
-0.0167392045,
0.0026345372,
-0.0161409751,
0.0409396067,
0.0184846912,
-0.0279683284,
0.0175422374,
-0.0100099714,
0.0015931036,
-0.0441691726,
0.053259261,
0.0112768076,
0.0496465117,
-0.0176686291,
0.0521436967,
-0.0406072028,
0.0295331515,
-0.0141615272,
-0.0289174225,
0.0171726346,
0.0168100987,
0.0449138172,
0.0541462973,
-0.0066915485,
-0.0196745358,
0.0728997067,
0.0185040683,
-0.0593097433,
0.0066175465,
0.0061831586,
-0.0181439109,
-0.0114524756,
-0.063081339,
-0.0603143871,
0.0766022503,
0.0105919801,
0.0142163206,
-0.056416221,
0.0554907098,
0.0080637932,
0.0104626939,
-0.023772601,
-0.0233547166,
-0.0225372016,
0.0118606072,
-0.0281255879,
-0.0018962633,
0.0737080202,
0.0257959012,
-0.0048805354,
-0.0009421038,
0.013692339,
-0.0037375635,
0.0937011167,
0.0135468561,
0.0058671543,
-0.005083011,
0.0196409971,
-0.0574491508,
-0.0177480578,
0.0102950921,
0.0113544893,
0.0526611805,
-0.045906961,
0.0272949543,
-0.0029640386,
-0.0507377945,
-0.025826402,
0.015771836,
-0.0585943088,
0.0256342795,
-0.0519153625,
-0.0127260042,
-0.056083817,
0.0420431122,
0.0166034549,
0.0326637402,
0.0257652234,
-0.0275040381,
0.0043857051,
-0.0009575038,
0.0133325458,
-0.000065524,
0.0197240766,
-0.0276100114,
0.0657760203,
0.0133222602,
0.0602582321,
-0.0125179449,
-0.0332066827,
0.0266666934,
-0.0195158962,
-0.0116921077,
-0.017238602,
0.0047066715,
0.0105582215,
-0.0298464466,
-0.017116284,
0.0708442628,
0.0400724448,
-0.0182698816,
0.026610326,
-0.0019504158,
0.0239330065,
0.0476044863,
0.0094878506,
-0.0475775972,
-0.0379771404,
0.0399118438,
-0.0338133499,
-0.0333833285,
-0.0474613048,
0.014734189,
-0.1194262505,
0.0225390866,
0.006867378,
-0.0589815266,
-0.0405589752,
-0.0145206945,
0.0369279385,
-0.0208384432,
-0.0221840404,
0.0177483466,
-0.0138615789,
-0.0003910473,
-0.0134844501,
0.0276980884,
-0.0269139595,
0.0426469408,
-0.0202949978,
0.071136795,
-0.0002155109,
0.0176249407,
0.0001303378,
-0.0164766815,
0.0496689416,
-0.0239479281,
0.009285748,
0.0060264813,
0.0007333171,
0.0252523478,
0.0132751279,
-0.0299517903,
0.0304845236,
-0.0182506405,
-0.0445134379,
-0.0125392936,
0.078410089,
-0.0213384591,
-0.0713041499,
-0.0159153063,
0.0184022766,
-0.0782539919,
0.0901686847,
0.0333904885,
-0.0159155149,
-0.021067569,
-0.0179591626,
-0.0230508372,
-0.0278048813,
-0.0282981098,
-0.001255632,
0.0186506268,
0.0207501017,
-0.0336521156,
-0.0341513343,
-0.002664461,
-0.0024465572,
-0.0153581891,
-0.0390972383,
0.0024995608,
-0.0223646015,
-0.0120944362,
0.0212007649,
-0.0381629057,
0.0226318575,
0.0212141704,
-0.0321447439,
0.0507487655,
-0.0457227752,
-0.0580783822,
0.0098774331,
-0.051172033,
-0.0401601233,
-0.0044134432,
0.006883685,
0.0328518935,
0.012392547,
0.01918808,
-0.0251655523,
0.0022154101,
0.00424241,
0.0094647808,
0.0239903741,
-0.0242167115,
-0.0073340563,
0.047773473,
0.0286307298,
0.0032360686,
0.0332264006,
0.0459708124,
0.0369391032,
0.0049090195,
0.0355292074,
0.0332499295,
0.0067526442,
-0.0003731488,
0.0500096716,
-0.0159784872,
-0.0393792018,
0.0059809838,
-0.0059370054,
0.0011564635,
0.0011341175,
-0.0281096026,
0.0270907748,
0.0414390303,
-0.0437012576,
-0.0947492495,
-0.0299550444,
0.0516776405,
0.0233213454,
-0.0089854095,
0.007725724,
0.0459310636,
0.0143767744,
-0.0000785848,
-0.0258434378,
0.0040422776,
0.0000595651,
0.0615875386,
-0.036567241,
0.0589442216,
0.0336569808,
-0.0028693483,
-0.0144688236,
-0.028334761,
-0.0897009522,
-0.0594683774,
-0.0046017813,
0.0476470701,
0.0089415433,
-0.053863544,
0.0006706136,
-0.0678904355,
0.014244684,
0.0173938237,
-0.029733425,
-0.0045104125,
-0.0130570587,
0.0402359962,
0.0228036586,
0.0251774695,
0.0143700289,
0.0220413469,
-0.0555275641,
0.0613845997,
-0.0244251397,
-0.0230977926,
0.0073385304,
-0.040089827,
-0.006545743,
0.0202778354,
0.0049295514,
0.0183978193,
-0.0574678257,
-0.0866365135,
-0.0548107214,
0.0339275263,
0.0058985474,
-0.0195393488,
0.0150271095,
0.0227301959,
-0.020259982,
-0.0233648196,
0.0168239512,
-0.0004798819,
-0.0501163267,
0.0077793119,
-0.0694820732,
-6.327563398e-33,
-0.0243261848,
0.0276360251,
0.0205234848,
-0.0539553501,
-0.002299964,
-0.0479317233,
-0.0500532873,
-0.0116770761,
-0.0561523773,
0.0197783727,
-0.0104051996,
-0.0116009265,
0.0023179627,
-0.0106892129,
0.0054274756,
-0.0124893337,
0.0057641249,
0.0068973429,
-0.0123607256,
-0.0087261684,
-0.0132309357,
-0.0262518544,
0.0332588926,
-0.0415426493,
-0.0184203293,
-0.0154596269,
0.0205747988,
-0.0060284296,
-0.0515522622,
0.047849562,
-0.0108741205,
0.0247182567,
0.0582797267,
0.0170707218,
0.002445352,
-0.0059072697,
-0.0346425511,
-0.0363002867,
0.0714050233,
-0.0286901668,
0.0291135032,
-0.0019134888,
0.056226749,
0.0030947125,
-0.0473906137,
-0.0311876517,
0.0383553095,
-0.0304758959,
0.041759707,
0.0521880724,
-0.066743657,
-0.0157961473,
-0.0027750118,
0.005279236,
-0.0160881113,
0.0703305304,
-0.0229447223,
0.0483087488,
-0.0570545271,
0.0399383381,
0.0168966595,
-0.0457054786,
0.0464511998,
-0.010317211,
0.0236445218,
0.0622870438,
0.0346426181,
-0.0182642248,
-0.0114085637,
-0.023247337,
0.0173101034,
0.0233479049,
0.016162347,
0.0276618358,
0.0903820619,
-0.0055713165,
-0.0108918305,
-0.0231257621,
0.0265999772,
0.0349964276,
0.0838695019,
0.0415555052,
-0.0030897912,
0.0026712485,
-0.0606819801,
-0.0350986868,
-0.060274709,
-0.0449619107,
0.0369469374,
-0.0402078293,
0.0170016829,
0.0128173102,
0.0076201991,
-0.0110165328,
-0.0105201239,
-0.0176498368,
-0.0139206853,
0.018278813,
-0.0422032699,
0.0181856286,
-0.0582508966,
-0.0534999035,
-0.00261368,
0.0455618948,
0.020997718,
0.0132828373,
0.0184737016,
-0.0139148217,
-0.0715982616,
-0.0283481088,
-0.0666488335,
-0.0336934701,
0.0075069969,
-0.0557514764,
0.0244440865,
0.0330769606,
0.0221000556,
0.0108690504,
0.0044747707,
-0.0601292923,
-0.0312717855,
0.0194309633,
-0.0285505038,
0.015688898,
0.0032555498,
0.0149613461,
-0.0232467186,
-0.0104542449,
0.0201601982,
-0.0552734658,
-0.0387129486,
0.0344307795,
2.74e-7,
0.0191059168,
0.0288458895,
-0.0026199706,
-0.0021471945,
0.0052341605,
0.0249893479,
-0.0210392382,
-0.0129581289,
0.0566997901,
0.0370943211,
0.0157657079,
0.0701421201,
0.030545935,
0.0252812244,
-0.0372246094,
0.064203918,
-0.1112405881,
-0.0507530347,
-0.0280390456,
-0.0131237004,
0.0436759405,
0.0424072966,
0.051396057,
-0.0080643035,
0.0344587155,
-0.0691756234,
0.0566574261,
-0.0594356805,
0.0348396264,
-0.0203720853,
-0.0352803171,
0.0423247851,
-0.0047456459,
0.0704920068,
0.0481106453,
0.0084434869,
0.011642714,
-0.0018915733,
-0.0051030004,
0.0020142158,
-0.0245548226,
-0.0271309335,
0.0049296897,
-0.1101382971,
0.0633737966,
-0.0868621022,
-0.0198827051,
0.0141759422,
-0.0156587884,
0.0051553068,
-0.0010743237,
0.0074678464,
-0.0319038779,
0.0088196127,
0.0385211483,
-0.0006081673,
-0.0068510761,
-0.05762529,
-0.0238027163,
0.0647962987,
-0.0553066768,
-0.0305414591,
-0.0450464971,
0.0034663919,
0.0434355475,
-0.0273772646,
-0.0178897884,
2.032524553e-34,
0.0312794782,
0.0367408171,
0.0290325098,
-0.000089721,
0.0480656996,
0.0143185351,
0.0356948227,
0.0202452112,
0.024942141,
-0.0686453357,
-0.0217646994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08939v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08939v3 | Premise Order Matters in Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T04:50:18 | 2024-05-28T04:32:09 | Xinyun Chen, Ryan A. Chi, Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have accomplished remarkable reasoning
performance in various domains. However, in the domain of reasoning tasks, we
discover a frailty: LLMs are surprisingly brittle to the ordering of the
premises, despite the fact that such ordering does not alter the underlying
task. In particular, we observe that LLMs achieve the best performance when the
premise order aligns with the context required in intermediate reasoning steps.
For example, in deductive reasoning tasks, presenting the premises in the same
order as the ground truth proof in the prompt (as opposed to random ordering)
drastically increases the model's accuracy. We first examine the effect of
premise ordering on deductive reasoning on a variety of LLMs, and our
evaluation shows that permuting the premise order can cause a performance drop
of over 30%. In addition, we release the benchmark R-GSM, based on GSM8K, to
examine the ordering effect for mathematical problem-solving, and we again
observe a significant drop in accuracy, relative to the original GSM8K
benchmark. | [
-0.0040761484,
0.0589273237,
-0.0015104273,
0.0432979763,
-0.0620320551,
0.0291885789,
0.022911299,
-0.0103431605,
0.0097601563,
-0.0273967963,
0.0337350816,
-0.0149882212,
0.0490443893,
0.0044484828,
0.0106512355,
-0.0499575399,
0.0298224632,
-0.102744177,
0.0196780264,
-0.0245583635,
-0.0176750645,
-0.0295794737,
-0.0481451973,
-0.0076064789,
-0.0115858968,
-0.0324818119,
-0.0133589702,
0.0083464989,
0.0482310653,
-0.0481184535,
-0.0585148409,
0.0581670851,
0.0067426055,
0.0507902242,
0.0000022303,
-0.0303919334,
0.0206931066,
0.0189787075,
-0.0486471653,
0.0474863127,
-0.0276219137,
-0.0092811352,
-0.0162462145,
0.0183394738,
-0.0153460829,
-0.0209964812,
0.0021205521,
0.07678736,
0.0371549055,
0.0580290295,
0.0126647213,
-0.0550319739,
0.0180347636,
-0.0356116295,
0.0001850887,
-0.0474859141,
0.0116699254,
0.0384259485,
0.0312408973,
0.0524069183,
-0.0053556249,
0.0145776914,
0.0495558977,
0.044417955,
-0.0885458291,
0.0553638078,
-0.0312656052,
-0.0037488067,
0.0199365281,
0.046620626,
-0.0214259829,
0.0014726326,
-0.00609271,
0.0186555684,
0.0154455509,
-0.004228076,
-0.0588879436,
0.1007032469,
-0.0300174169,
-0.0057063755,
0.0288367122,
-0.0081531024,
0.0360136181,
-0.0000138104,
-0.0556405261,
0.1325894296,
0.0116784889,
-0.0410797745,
-0.0096076094,
0.0039502215,
-0.04896909,
-0.0516535416,
0.0053010699,
0.010063204,
-0.013908755,
0.0313659124,
-0.0103396568,
0.0237750392,
0.0156700704,
-0.0125692803,
0.0153454579,
0.0429992676,
0.0147428364,
0.0375686325,
-0.0441600159,
0.0515808314,
-0.0319469087,
-0.0118501354,
-0.0073105842,
0.0086434539,
-0.0098433588,
-0.0194269121,
-0.0002497127,
0.0537532121,
-0.0143427597,
0.0065586981,
-0.0439650044,
0.0291045662,
0.0112895174,
0.0138849299,
-0.012313962,
-0.0366536602,
0.0049347193,
-0.0442763083,
-0.038284909,
-0.0026696676,
-0.0499654561,
0.0480649434,
0.027756162,
-0.0476381071,
-0.0083432458,
-0.0323993079,
-0.0440019444,
0.0073149269,
0.0123866685,
0.0231660903,
0.0196167026,
-0.0070554907,
-0.0205753017,
-0.0154512301,
0.0230373777,
-0.068133086,
0.0029044973,
-0.0841983855,
0.0246453546,
0.0529467203,
-0.0193277895,
-0.0022693917,
0.026168989,
0.028160356,
-0.0345261618,
0.0633338764,
0.0638218448,
0.0401081964,
0.0130470581,
0.0270109642,
-0.0445382558,
0.0595913269,
0.0050403448,
0.0216373727,
0.0013019156,
0.0080248136,
0.0055451486,
0.0216329936,
-0.0176596362,
-0.004238544,
-0.0049663731,
0.0197566841,
0.0160146691,
0.0333780684,
0.0106609948,
0.0434429049,
-0.0575459674,
-0.0071172789,
0.0631743297,
0.0571357794,
-0.0279850345,
-0.024614146,
-0.0067499764,
-0.0326933153,
0.0060922513,
0.0106800236,
-0.0908973813,
-0.001259955,
-0.0267928988,
0.0132365003,
-0.0081548495,
0.0442334712,
-0.0097328741,
-0.0467032902,
-0.0356725194,
0.0265548136,
-0.0213863067,
0.0332417376,
0.0228524152,
-0.0038228389,
-0.0002034727,
0.082873486,
0.021033477,
-0.0430145226,
-0.089144215,
-0.0410736613,
0.0210676733,
0.0228000823,
0.0034514475,
-0.0303048473,
-0.0465627126,
0.0232212003,
0.0376441032,
0.0408314988,
0.029053241,
0.0362626612,
0.0000371479,
-0.0147326645,
-0.0072998903,
-0.0111746043,
0.0190337077,
0.0337010138,
0.0422916859,
0.0156375468,
0.0151433907,
-0.0196407866,
0.0470906198,
0.0030388951,
-0.0310630091,
-0.0114413816,
-0.0135965189,
0.0028434496,
0.0035564105,
-0.0369104743,
0.0042270771,
0.0353624299,
0.0248631891,
-0.0315323099,
0.0085789757,
0.0006301656,
-0.0603833683,
-0.0592204593,
0.0141552277,
-0.0115741035,
-0.031719856,
0.0267874356,
-0.065208748,
-0.0084535284,
0.0286051631,
-0.0048072119,
0.0041335491,
0.0182669684,
0.0375605226,
0.0445915125,
-0.0357324667,
-0.019321112,
0.1013281196,
-0.0201314166,
0.0137170656,
0.0262665432,
0.0444986001,
-0.0165336281,
-0.0615539774,
0.0251958258,
0.0147000393,
-0.002254101,
-0.0168634411,
-0.017330993,
-0.0323111005,
-0.0373556875,
-0.0291009117,
-0.0988563076,
-0.0049416753,
-0.003830943,
-0.0064767874,
-0.0006055633,
-0.0118187498,
-0.0197788849,
-0.0201074928,
-0.0260798745,
-0.0387331471,
0.0459837504,
0.0407967716,
-0.0001202737,
-0.0153456107,
-0.0387981758,
0.012291071,
-0.0240244828,
-0.0141689945,
0.0481444485,
-0.0260084718,
0.0500505418,
-0.0610680766,
0.023163138,
-0.0423205085,
0.0028489567,
-0.033311449,
0.0153825553,
0.0371561199,
-0.0076751062,
0.0200842582,
0.1034803316,
-0.0155558288,
0.0231655017,
0.0540233813,
-0.0187980235,
-0.0257226806,
-0.0091448277,
-0.0084965564,
0.0358152501,
-0.015602544,
-0.0646081567,
-0.0580256283,
0.0657118186,
-0.0181390177,
0.0067303739,
-0.0096350582,
0.0470834039,
-0.0452290624,
0.0033462439,
-0.0184645858,
-0.0402773097,
-0.0124665191,
0.0806429908,
-0.0353009291,
-0.0058479258,
0.0240991749,
-0.0131122414,
0.0179934427,
-0.0706741661,
0.0219610948,
-0.0404667854,
0.0717365816,
0.0042805523,
0.0144354403,
-0.0029400471,
-0.0047878018,
-0.0559243597,
-0.027630046,
0.0557288527,
-0.0308839884,
0.0446837582,
-0.0507001132,
0.0096074073,
-0.0239496343,
-0.0929429084,
-0.0695669577,
-0.0166531187,
-0.0540903285,
0.0240310002,
-0.0302992035,
-0.0042723673,
-0.0349290408,
0.015865609,
0.0488261878,
0.0041131526,
-0.0289481841,
-0.0104936445,
0.0049252426,
0.0261252318,
0.0030766428,
-0.0184723288,
0.0231794119,
-0.0313525125,
0.0331807472,
0.054179389,
0.0492791049,
-0.0068777367,
-0.0155822523,
-0.0000366582,
0.0028178447,
-0.0170664433,
-0.0632292554,
0.01168653,
0.0082534524,
-0.0551474467,
-0.0081811529,
0.1213562265,
0.0200791452,
0.0239235666,
0.0191975869,
-0.0576615892,
0.0506742559,
0.0301792752,
0.0286553465,
-0.0673377216,
-0.0193124898,
0.0654466525,
-0.0174648985,
0.0150462473,
-0.0066289511,
0.0155139584,
-0.1316426992,
0.0393517055,
0.0157371219,
-0.0367245376,
-0.0135739446,
-0.0669960976,
-0.016883729,
0.0181046221,
-0.0028737918,
0.0595136434,
-0.0031924574,
0.0011246382,
0.0220227446,
0.0026929325,
0.0079025328,
0.0318723992,
-0.0148912957,
-0.0072931689,
0.0279667452,
-0.0186269972,
-0.0210896619,
-0.0533877015,
0.0324761532,
0.0632573515,
0.0099154441,
-0.0053328765,
-0.0106475661,
0.0114031816,
0.005713392,
-0.0463371575,
0.0051375749,
-0.0173623003,
-0.0524767563,
0.0099506415,
0.0701456293,
-0.0109577905,
-0.0420900919,
-0.0231791735,
0.0092678545,
-0.067689307,
0.0565339923,
0.0065343045,
0.0186260175,
-0.0475542918,
-0.0553765781,
-0.0218698718,
0.0114644207,
-0.0398058072,
0.0110311219,
0.0591541044,
-0.0186059326,
-0.0276205968,
-0.0085527217,
0.0153895048,
0.0647453144,
-0.0155445021,
0.0223025586,
0.009378368,
0.0163318459,
-0.0322808065,
0.0356365517,
-0.0095514329,
0.0117335655,
-0.0842915475,
0.0281234868,
0.0207912717,
-0.0155139426,
-0.0346637666,
0.0000025182,
-0.0536608584,
-0.0710896626,
0.0375831947,
0.0441231914,
0.0221908577,
0.0325060152,
0.0293723214,
-0.025526749,
0.0561703853,
0.007010967,
-0.0114423642,
0.0439982861,
0.0317418873,
-0.0386881977,
0.0301840492,
-0.0009574665,
-0.028525861,
0.0560918823,
0.0163155645,
0.0454754867,
-0.0488071814,
-0.0401591286,
-0.0015144439,
0.0449039191,
0.0785544589,
0.0302789379,
-0.0234491602,
-0.0132427812,
0.0589749254,
-0.0626788363,
-0.0264291093,
0.0037067041,
0.047327213,
0.0249345209,
0.0269616432,
0.0044682762,
-0.0169476233,
0.0316011235,
0.0274595562,
0.0367086977,
-0.0088136625,
-0.0012349051,
-0.0026096669,
0.0642443076,
-0.0053518335,
-0.0404223762,
0.0325247608,
-0.0202938989,
0.0623129942,
-0.0263526402,
0.0647042915,
0.0304057673,
-0.0130508803,
-0.0504092239,
0.0202364102,
-0.0898268074,
-0.0854979455,
0.0526319593,
-0.0145332692,
0.0240851864,
-0.0097393915,
0.017458111,
-0.050720524,
0.0025712119,
0.0075875265,
0.0061777979,
0.0330303833,
-0.0384548716,
0.0363733768,
0.0401782095,
-0.0037717095,
0.0199644025,
0.0595867708,
-0.004862003,
0.027819464,
0.0436040014,
-0.0094970372,
-0.0076094787,
-0.0504959412,
-0.0386154316,
-0.0108946972,
-0.0183942672,
-0.0101870699,
-0.0645440966,
-0.0750041604,
-0.0033158669,
-0.0023282904,
-0.0061594746,
-0.0187345576,
0.0130398758,
0.0756647512,
0.0238647386,
-0.0553894304,
0.0009449818,
0.0102472864,
-0.0425860286,
-0.0300884061,
0.0130325928,
-6.403454048e-33,
-0.0343521088,
-0.0072138878,
0.0262544658,
-0.0256835464,
0.0194999985,
-0.013983584,
-0.0113218473,
0.053552445,
0.0064497367,
0.0254967306,
-0.0265756845,
0.0286478251,
0.0153613491,
-0.0109861298,
-0.0237038322,
0.0092857657,
0.0101302043,
0.011323547,
-0.0434323028,
-0.0062190196,
0.0369843617,
0.0091111269,
0.0099299718,
-0.0416687652,
-0.0232352074,
-0.0374202356,
0.0282142945,
0.0270067826,
-0.0975184366,
0.0589081943,
-0.0034815562,
-0.0192348473,
0.0149401352,
-0.0508589819,
0.0084762778,
0.0379581898,
-0.0323552489,
-0.024129305,
0.0325435027,
0.0057141455,
-0.0342749208,
-0.0354560055,
0.002413058,
0.0310784746,
-0.0244567692,
-0.0469918996,
-0.0170415398,
-0.0240999795,
-0.0350892842,
0.0084507931,
-0.0323781148,
0.0328005515,
0.0010991982,
-0.0371677987,
0.0198736452,
-0.0033817659,
-0.0185744092,
-0.0400446691,
0.0042051049,
0.0199151542,
0.0161687993,
0.0112890117,
0.0456776321,
0.0187826362,
-0.0089359023,
0.0525493175,
0.0262371283,
0.0224079397,
-0.0298957154,
-0.0036382945,
-0.0192152187,
0.0821074098,
0.0364546217,
-0.0245752893,
0.0357151702,
0.034697488,
-0.095113337,
-0.019985605,
0.021328453,
0.0379829034,
0.0619306676,
-0.0045420998,
-0.057286799,
-0.0395798385,
-0.0573044308,
0.0399583168,
-0.0520441085,
-0.0092109675,
0.0444995351,
-0.0034187576,
-0.0295449067,
-0.0283636414,
0.02899573,
-0.0230101887,
-0.0545939058,
0.0441303328,
-0.018825762,
-0.0040525091,
-0.0254684947,
0.0587350912,
-0.0588622093,
0.0094066579,
-0.0018335272,
0.0138108702,
0.0177466441,
0.0131351417,
0.0201582927,
-0.0244745724,
-0.0430892743,
-0.0213654898,
-0.0330346003,
0.0256048646,
0.0206667185,
0.0299640708,
0.0537316501,
0.0022388652,
0.0027471541,
0.0582607463,
-0.005532308,
-0.0428093672,
-0.058551386,
0.0414881408,
-0.0204834249,
0.0271301176,
-0.0093707414,
-0.0190301109,
-0.0187865831,
0.0106793884,
0.0280788001,
-0.0413594209,
-0.0297860596,
0.0270383377,
2.876e-7,
0.0067650792,
0.0545162484,
0.0106651643,
0.0735777617,
0.0100927986,
0.0459842272,
-0.0456804968,
-0.0283378847,
0.0303267855,
-0.0028411809,
-0.0189221818,
0.0747433975,
0.0195872001,
0.059216287,
-0.0486852042,
-0.0043602809,
-0.0352661237,
-0.0175597388,
-0.0412199795,
0.0031826152,
-0.0050675697,
0.0856381506,
-0.0146312127,
0.0015095726,
0.0044240686,
-0.0110117206,
0.0662985295,
-0.0159846433,
0.0205094162,
-0.0416885242,
0.0180822536,
-0.0120891724,
0.0003122888,
0.0343736522,
0.0418714359,
-0.0143322069,
-0.0185253657,
0.0564386137,
0.0078602983,
-0.026852278,
-0.0367910899,
-0.0370275155,
-0.0036663015,
-0.0614845082,
0.0824443772,
-0.0452012084,
-0.0399698801,
-0.0154141001,
-0.0162809826,
-0.048445791,
-0.011415761,
0.0124160722,
-0.0118002808,
-0.0071334643,
0.0105214678,
-0.0390435085,
-0.0031730935,
-0.0748583376,
-0.0507371761,
0.0403001495,
-0.027358735,
-0.0618924275,
-0.0042813006,
0.0249865819,
0.0524325669,
-0.0022337886,
-0.0301961917,
2.942800746e-34,
0.037228249,
-0.0079900939,
0.0125259142,
0.0335799865,
0.0376245752,
-0.022797497,
0.001242565,
0.0309946667,
0.0088740941,
-0.0976478606,
-0.017518051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08925v1 | MaxMin-RLHF: Towards Equitable Alignment of Large Language Models with Diverse Human Preferences | 2024-02-14T03:56:27 | 2024-02-14T03:56:27 | Souradip Chakraborty, Jiahao Qiu, Hui Yuan, Alec Koppel, Furong Huang, Dinesh Manocha, Amrit Singh Bedi, Mengdi Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) aligns language models to
human preferences by employing a singular reward model derived from preference
data. However, such an approach overlooks the rich diversity of human
preferences inherent in data collected from multiple users. In this work, we
first derive an impossibility result of alignment with single reward RLHF,
thereby highlighting its insufficiency in representing diverse human
preferences. To provide an equitable solution to the problem, we learn a
mixture of preference distributions via an expectation-maximization algorithm
and propose a MaxMin alignment objective for policy learning inspired by the
Egalitarian principle in social choice theory to better represent diverse human
preferences. We elucidate the connection of our proposed approach to
distributionally robust optimization and general utility RL, thereby
highlighting the generality and robustness of our proposed solution. We present
comprehensive experimental results on small-scale (GPT-2) and large-scale
language models (with Tulu2-7B) and show the efficacy of the proposed approach
in the presence of diversity among human preferences. Our algorithm achieves an
average improvement of more than 16% in win-rates over conventional RLHF
algorithms and improves the win-rate (accuracy) for minority groups by over 33%
without compromising the performance of majority groups, showcasing the
robustness and fairness of our approach. We remark that our findings in this
work are not only limited to language models but also extend to reinforcement
learning in general. | [
0.0498951674,
0.0707478225,
-0.0043164142,
0.0228738543,
-0.0083204331,
0.0026498965,
-0.0365103036,
-0.0106571326,
-0.0091829821,
-0.0104618417,
-0.0441084728,
-0.0500723496,
-0.0028847461,
-0.006826567,
0.013356911,
-0.0632044449,
0.0270511433,
-0.0020861188,
0.0099060219,
-0.0710519254,
0.0249308739,
-0.0080755679,
0.0260546841,
0.0440960526,
0.0211703666,
0.033432696,
0.0133674191,
-0.0088597685,
0.0586557202,
0.0165606663,
0.0447273776,
0.0713558495,
-0.0027414823,
0.0225535166,
0.0000024144,
-0.0320380852,
-0.0412557237,
-0.0286305733,
0.0164923109,
-0.0351464488,
0.0560594685,
0.0304965917,
-0.0360428616,
0.0216116142,
-0.0214388482,
0.0614081882,
0.0648888722,
0.0135655701,
0.0293284394,
0.0328806229,
0.0143731534,
-0.0224274527,
-0.0274678282,
-0.0442273915,
0.0150862988,
-0.0269275457,
0.0370417424,
-0.0208117235,
0.0170723852,
-0.0295470115,
-0.030768944,
-0.0146283284,
0.0134879053,
0.0176501758,
0.0264676698,
0.0349135734,
0.0078708995,
-0.0242656041,
-0.0167011935,
0.0888446048,
-0.004159994,
-0.0015098634,
0.0045274603,
-0.0086908825,
0.0213097855,
0.0255897455,
0.0166641362,
0.0124210855,
-0.0089472383,
0.0616541244,
0.0013451399,
0.01443855,
0.0410827771,
0.0438491181,
-0.0343975835,
0.1078522056,
-0.0041537732,
-0.0215342417,
0.0150241936,
0.0230414476,
-0.0414624773,
-0.007193652,
0.0204077158,
-0.0060984395,
-0.0492149442,
0.0008962159,
-0.0212711543,
-0.0105788065,
0.0247601923,
-0.0310177673,
0.0343092643,
0.0551702902,
0.0171884801,
0.0311986618,
0.0627517402,
0.0421827659,
-0.0204436537,
0.008717278,
-0.0264510624,
-0.0036603867,
-0.0107893161,
0.0013841222,
0.0429123677,
0.0219068229,
-0.0550300032,
0.0333414562,
-0.0921480209,
0.0367911234,
-0.0581490211,
0.041212935,
0.0460610203,
0.0335537009,
-0.0535498895,
-0.0131642558,
-0.0606836155,
0.0312713906,
-0.0397498012,
0.0114138098,
0.0236654207,
0.0208063871,
0.0419531092,
-0.0082419794,
-0.0337287299,
-0.0509391986,
0.0094477497,
0.0655659884,
0.0060602557,
0.0059543452,
-0.0067188195,
0.0047971965,
-0.0329104103,
-0.042333439,
-0.0641416311,
-0.0935186446,
0.024042869,
-0.0070386273,
-0.0216853544,
-0.062629275,
-0.0158016738,
-0.0222684313,
-0.0660365447,
0.0743370876,
0.037745215,
0.0052835322,
0.0502763093,
-0.0276564751,
-0.0152331041,
0.0635238513,
0.0336687826,
0.0337897688,
0.0270985235,
-0.0000020107,
-0.0011247755,
0.0577116087,
0.0017877113,
0.0270553138,
-0.0093291337,
-0.0038369207,
0.0028549919,
0.0257055387,
0.0713033378,
0.0362580232,
-0.0115961768,
-0.0895815268,
0.0630705878,
0.0383512713,
-0.0285841897,
-0.0156137059,
-0.0302408226,
0.0416372754,
-0.0402937047,
0.0146162454,
-0.053552065,
0.0220156368,
-0.0140987327,
-0.007916769,
0.0348119587,
0.0357206129,
-0.0220493358,
-0.0275855754,
0.0104261087,
-0.0353667066,
0.0534705631,
0.0524958298,
0.0575182624,
-0.0672525167,
-0.0411781929,
-0.0055349986,
0.0803304687,
-0.0215375032,
0.0198044982,
-0.0230861492,
0.0382096916,
0.0561128072,
0.0105739227,
-0.0426273681,
0.0267917421,
-0.0385570489,
-0.0833488479,
0.0461030118,
0.0674767569,
-0.0162449889,
-0.025935458,
-0.0422717892,
-0.0635439828,
0.0481677502,
0.0082815215,
0.0775377527,
0.0331462994,
-0.0124723744,
-0.0283059087,
0.0010866625,
-0.0235377941,
0.0145442402,
-0.0005883391,
0.0190733802,
0.0173284765,
0.0280761104,
0.038108211,
0.0034752714,
-0.0174407288,
-0.0039784303,
-0.0288138743,
0.0166303776,
-0.0288141184,
-0.0049183476,
-0.0413508862,
-0.005426819,
0.0453960709,
-0.0326572359,
-0.0182204656,
0.0671936348,
-0.0215391293,
-0.0023652036,
0.0085590314,
0.0105116069,
0.0097878501,
-0.0258298833,
0.0288079809,
-0.0089484341,
-0.0207061283,
-0.0905480459,
0.0648716614,
-0.0324484929,
0.0015966955,
-0.0351110213,
-0.0402846299,
0.0016858426,
-0.0996792465,
-0.0348723382,
0.0423933491,
0.0239496734,
0.051713381,
0.0817914456,
0.0122837108,
-0.0099761542,
-0.0183980241,
-0.0529435948,
-0.0117908437,
-0.0190192088,
0.0018085766,
-0.0059734406,
0.0014986513,
-0.0137241911,
-0.0217091069,
-0.0434135124,
-0.0244938638,
0.0006805274,
0.009195935,
0.0346184969,
0.0090844538,
-0.0016884907,
-0.0581916682,
-0.0369263999,
-0.0062760036,
0.0066099386,
-0.019231407,
0.0331274532,
-0.0083862441,
-0.0187039562,
-0.0473524369,
0.0308152419,
-0.0340464152,
-0.0236186888,
-0.0135442931,
0.0251299422,
0.0354865454,
0.0788668469,
0.0517695956,
0.0374049507,
0.0555653349,
0.0476088822,
-0.0858721286,
0.003166303,
-0.0485666133,
-0.0127519779,
-0.0315003581,
-0.03677506,
0.0284780115,
0.0884694755,
0.0047190157,
-0.0117937885,
-0.0742076114,
0.0234617461,
-0.0120947696,
-0.0541768894,
-0.0737200752,
0.0158420336,
-0.0424476266,
0.0089374604,
-0.0439872034,
-0.0576996431,
0.1032159403,
0.0484615453,
0.0224459451,
-0.059801627,
-0.0186088718,
-0.0418297872,
-0.025498176,
0.0019519057,
0.0343991444,
-0.0485124625,
0.0069124224,
-0.0892435983,
-0.0358974002,
0.0712259039,
-0.0332999416,
0.0485855304,
-0.0119479923,
0.015328397,
-0.0209996197,
-0.1186533347,
-0.0389955752,
-0.0526189506,
0.0091825807,
-0.0040149232,
0.039097432,
-0.0456901528,
-0.0312422384,
-0.000176533,
0.0317087993,
-0.003864391,
-0.0212041624,
0.0117045715,
0.0042777508,
-0.007921447,
0.0625829399,
-0.0081893355,
-0.0054505351,
-0.0560193956,
-0.0324033871,
0.0254218448,
0.035065297,
-0.0091904141,
0.0384306386,
0.0336270742,
0.0504128076,
-0.0465414785,
0.0008888855,
0.0395548418,
0.0327730104,
-0.0045778719,
0.0541863479,
0.0632059798,
0.0231044814,
-0.0535683595,
0.0137171885,
-0.0290368386,
0.0706186965,
-0.0006876509,
0.0460575819,
-0.0510892458,
0.0055418997,
-0.0159436371,
0.0709383637,
0.0132565396,
-0.0333472379,
0.0229668375,
-0.0996890888,
-0.0281299036,
0.0242401715,
-0.0593310222,
-0.0161626376,
0.0045619481,
0.0158272423,
-0.04805604,
0.0343114771,
-0.0109566078,
0.0380827412,
-0.0001047097,
0.0331569947,
0.0380088575,
-0.032645002,
0.0003988914,
-0.0676106736,
0.0455127098,
0.0883687884,
0.0290609114,
-0.021182755,
-0.0281716548,
-0.0192964841,
0.0431557521,
-0.0605893806,
0.0107710185,
-0.0240432192,
-0.0235174093,
-0.0033047632,
-0.023984706,
0.0712464973,
0.0152584296,
-0.000332043,
0.0005887469,
0.0342942216,
-0.002049448,
-0.0203623287,
-0.0170989912,
-0.0281396024,
0.0292723849,
0.076929085,
-0.0237485599,
-0.0727681741,
-0.0191962291,
-0.0667822808,
-0.0652041584,
-0.0266385712,
-0.0458225906,
0.021830542,
-0.0037690429,
-0.0124022467,
-0.0493434295,
-0.0333491638,
-0.0440293103,
0.0112175727,
0.0018407259,
-0.0168026518,
0.0279725436,
-0.0054969243,
0.0043302877,
0.0199019462,
-0.0342949778,
0.0251881722,
-0.0853942335,
-0.042011898,
-0.0111740464,
-0.0426684171,
-0.0354936458,
-0.0468988679,
0.0160874035,
-0.0863412991,
-0.0025892344,
0.0388571471,
0.0167945512,
0.0535301715,
0.0062805787,
-0.0372330174,
0.0493653007,
0.0504462942,
0.013455376,
0.0290823244,
0.0284834877,
0.024530286,
-0.017812036,
0.0284156129,
-0.0478245504,
0.0102364253,
0.0146647459,
0.0279252958,
-0.0161018819,
-0.0256581027,
0.0213095285,
-0.0236074515,
-0.0066235843,
-0.0526531972,
-0.024669772,
-0.019541055,
-0.0244655684,
0.0188349765,
-0.0407298915,
-0.0035924844,
-0.0637467206,
0.0377174765,
-0.0112234224,
0.0023622159,
-0.0217047166,
0.0414434969,
0.0207428057,
-0.0194656532,
0.0195136126,
-0.0147593105,
-0.0019184233,
0.044912383,
0.0325099938,
0.0230025202,
0.0175704677,
0.0070280158,
0.0489093177,
0.039334774,
0.0430632681,
0.0392245688,
-0.0073970598,
0.0017545394,
0.0003716576,
-0.001752871,
-0.0300769974,
-0.0231140796,
0.0006634601,
0.0478778407,
-0.0055905879,
0.0227418859,
-0.0493741557,
-0.0112866489,
-0.052294679,
-0.0113686873,
-0.0221154466,
0.0220946185,
0.0425202586,
0.0110533265,
-0.0001183175,
0.0047181211,
0.0686281398,
0.0188473817,
0.0141134765,
-0.0638457313,
-0.0017984514,
-0.034253031,
-0.0131504163,
0.0027885593,
-0.0054319245,
-0.0501362421,
0.003807629,
-0.0822054148,
-0.029911384,
-0.0399715416,
0.0573229901,
-0.0053279232,
0.0212168153,
0.04591465,
0.0222747382,
-0.072628282,
0.0160936266,
-0.0556483418,
-0.0008975039,
-0.028272938,
-0.0122666359,
-0.0110988086,
-6.830151885e-33,
-0.0137813557,
-0.0221803375,
-0.0088784043,
-0.033629071,
0.0101498971,
-0.0672093108,
0.0166018587,
0.0271634106,
0.0036969609,
-0.0142675992,
0.0051580379,
-0.0222295038,
0.0084379492,
-0.0091512501,
0.0226727277,
-0.0083669005,
0.0257977545,
0.0128935035,
-0.0644288212,
-0.0158045273,
0.0034784337,
0.0109912548,
0.0314550065,
-0.0563117154,
0.0502911843,
0.036337126,
0.0140690906,
0.0211163647,
0.0073791808,
0.0683901161,
0.0137145203,
0.0567750856,
0.0036933986,
-0.054264944,
-0.0096669998,
-0.0014171737,
-0.0422123708,
-0.0111203352,
0.0124269193,
0.0029788378,
0.0044069551,
-0.0232065003,
0.0432774089,
0.0085311551,
-0.054296419,
0.0082240039,
0.0439802893,
0.0053109974,
-0.0054711807,
0.0314949267,
-0.0234453902,
0.0250589456,
-0.0071943509,
0.0205709375,
-0.0162543282,
0.0227875635,
0.0035449332,
0.0364362001,
-0.0206581578,
0.0461703315,
-0.0201815404,
0.0011586143,
0.0641763583,
0.0255039372,
0.0180287119,
0.0374013595,
0.0160391573,
-0.0185196232,
-0.0200937707,
-0.0775330439,
0.0190830659,
0.0082371514,
0.0129576577,
0.0682040229,
0.008510855,
-0.0054994235,
-0.0040224353,
0.059392821,
0.0419067889,
-0.0131017938,
0.0254577808,
0.0407944992,
-0.0923457369,
-0.0459265634,
-0.0306727421,
-0.0075846468,
-0.0317927301,
-0.0277767945,
0.0267084558,
0.0134232212,
-0.0288959276,
-0.0256829243,
0.010166714,
-0.0601668358,
-0.07429488,
0.0271461401,
-0.0284625255,
-0.020835951,
0.0158183668,
-0.0131229041,
-0.0715423673,
-0.0098962393,
-0.0469267406,
-0.0275013335,
-0.0407202356,
0.0414577834,
-0.0007572101,
0.0052961726,
-0.0358864591,
0.0265231505,
0.0005787316,
-0.0120417494,
0.0363974459,
0.0112084439,
0.0535339862,
-0.0070130317,
0.0111123333,
0.020891659,
0.0038358544,
-0.0182093158,
-0.0158179086,
-0.0287557673,
-0.0273216404,
0.0303779412,
-0.0089718839,
0.0170124192,
-0.0109833032,
0.0326253958,
0.0086045153,
-0.000202946,
-0.009184883,
-0.0568994433,
2.89e-7,
0.0158155542,
0.0442811586,
0.00911019,
-0.022076821,
-0.0232896227,
0.0798945874,
-0.029226603,
0.0350523703,
-0.0014824052,
0.0130570875,
0.0185159687,
0.0300087798,
0.0300628226,
-0.0052608806,
-0.0679678991,
0.0018069294,
-0.0648525804,
0.0303501021,
-0.0375226252,
0.0119160172,
-0.015640052,
0.0582504161,
0.0595931858,
-0.0030546044,
0.003043341,
0.0398205258,
0.0599168949,
-0.0898868665,
-0.0097510079,
-0.0024386048,
0.0132878236,
-0.0218036305,
-0.0051730573,
-0.0212164409,
0.017166242,
0.0321892351,
-0.0085481061,
0.0563609898,
-0.0108286561,
-0.0222471915,
-0.0127612706,
-0.0059056957,
0.002019332,
-0.0592052229,
0.0282857846,
-0.0237254743,
-0.0274596903,
0.0040892572,
0.0280021373,
-0.0157561265,
0.0505168587,
-0.0360028856,
-0.0284808464,
-0.0092756525,
0.0228779335,
0.0218629893,
0.0204953402,
-0.0413680971,
-0.0126301879,
0.0211743247,
-0.058591187,
-0.054475572,
-0.013455905,
0.077698946,
-0.0094078658,
-0.0339004546,
0.007569843,
2.619516152e-34,
0.0173049886,
0.0161943287,
0.0049100849,
-0.0211602841,
0.0090988493,
0.0231966805,
-0.0064234594,
0.0133914156,
0.0682795644,
-0.0127585763,
-0.0095171891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00774v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00774v2 | Regional inflation analysis using social network data | 2024-02-14T02:33:17 | 2024-03-14T11:34:28 | Vasilii Chsherbakov, Ilia Karpov | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.SI | Inflation is one of the most important macroeconomic indicators that have a
great impact on the population of any country and region. Inflation is
influenced by range of factors, one of which is inflation expectations. Many
central banks take this factor into consideration while implementing monetary
policy within the inflation targeting regime. Nowadays, a lot of people are
active users of the Internet, especially social networks. There is a hypothesis
that people search, read, and discuss mainly only those issues that are of
particular interest to them. It is logical to assume that the dynamics of
prices may also be in the focus of user discussions. So, such discussions could
be regarded as an alternative source of more rapid information about inflation
expectations. This study is based on unstructured data from Vkontakte social
network to analyze upward and downward inflationary trends (on the example of
the Omsk region). The sample of more than 8.5 million posts was collected
between January 2010 and May 2022. The authors used BERT neural networks to
solve the problem. These models demonstrated better results than the benchmarks
(e.g., logistic regression, decision tree classifier, etc.). It makes possible
to define pro-inflationary and disinflationary types of keywords in different
contexts and get their visualization with SHAP method. This analysis provides
additional operational information about inflationary processes at the regional
level The proposed approach can be scaled for other regions. At the same time
the limitation of the work is the time and power costs for the initial training
of similar models for all regions of Russia. | [
0.0007864477,
0.042391289,
-0.0445512831,
0.006955592,
-0.0216180757,
0.0169781633,
-0.0169249959,
-0.0065654339,
-0.0266849194,
0.0042736768,
0.0497300029,
-0.0017309955,
-0.0014664995,
0.0472893603,
-0.0195539035,
-0.041901812,
0.026556788,
0.0053372639,
0.0848568454,
-0.0317077562,
0.020100547,
-0.0472245887,
0.0094151217,
0.0085424697,
-0.0420124941,
0.0245425291,
0.0178263057,
-0.0021937706,
0.0121663846,
-0.0177179612,
0.0112858154,
-0.0010345591,
0.0030845602,
0.0562841482,
0.0000019695,
-0.0653436705,
-0.0369544439,
0.0053225853,
0.0140096992,
-0.0079483306,
0.0593500622,
-0.0240614284,
0.0186171085,
0.0055129277,
-0.0908469856,
0.0442193151,
0.0518980324,
0.0449654758,
0.0657239482,
0.0424075276,
-0.031643372,
-0.0687646121,
-0.0345256589,
-0.0486439168,
-0.0412400588,
-0.04978659,
0.0547798984,
-0.0101232724,
-0.0416469723,
0.0373729728,
0.0033729,
0.0214391574,
-0.0014262772,
-0.0012561746,
0.0133148208,
-0.001976643,
-0.0779008716,
-0.0214643776,
-0.0148160169,
0.0388081819,
0.0217333101,
-0.0054641552,
0.0681235492,
-0.0042815208,
0.0022533911,
0.0747051761,
-0.0452499799,
-0.0439781919,
0.0012068417,
0.049047064,
0.0021404321,
0.0074249851,
-0.017992964,
0.0228532236,
0.0023032811,
0.0203214139,
-0.020235341,
-0.0439679958,
0.0015836217,
0.0048790541,
-0.0225171838,
-0.0217565261,
0.0252708793,
-0.001999008,
0.0006613304,
-0.0168240778,
0.0035889796,
-0.0589538813,
0.021987902,
-0.1161800548,
-0.0143554099,
0.0311839189,
0.037499398,
0.039033059,
-0.0054783341,
-0.0206804816,
-0.0014743907,
-0.0106555149,
0.0365129076,
0.0163059905,
-0.0902699977,
0.0122869369,
-0.0466906875,
-0.0009453429,
0.0377145559,
0.0218838006,
-0.0553261079,
-0.0315500796,
-0.0476693846,
-0.0171133261,
-0.0086512845,
0.0460579023,
0.0346465334,
0.0165358614,
-0.028560767,
0.0278388131,
-0.0678152516,
-0.0092881043,
-0.0195095148,
0.0620126389,
0.051423464,
-0.0173251126,
0.0508328453,
0.0252080671,
0.0269327611,
-0.0275166538,
0.0382342413,
-0.0128281871,
-0.0263707954,
-0.008372305,
0.0101352297,
0.0156322066,
0.0176525265,
-0.0143582439,
-0.0048126536,
-0.0491007082,
-0.0091334069,
0.0598726943,
-0.0458181389,
-0.0236706268,
-0.0452572517,
0.0105714388,
-0.026645476,
-0.0062201112,
0.0364664979,
-0.0479034558,
0.0519676469,
0.0339850485,
0.0085248882,
0.0339832045,
0.0426265597,
-0.0286027659,
-0.0350951925,
0.0138058476,
0.0188858863,
-0.0165723618,
-0.0220694039,
-0.0154795377,
-0.0753941983,
-0.0140665593,
-0.0037897637,
-0.0378161632,
-0.0124847889,
-0.0271239989,
0.0302941352,
0.0358655415,
0.0016355425,
0.0024014742,
-0.0140258418,
0.0175908003,
-0.0063952743,
-0.0612429492,
0.03569033,
-0.0124628125,
-0.0407924019,
0.0302377362,
0.0201858748,
-0.0295811892,
-0.0452133864,
-0.0222896747,
-0.0310900696,
-0.0111697465,
0.0688180923,
0.0034293253,
0.0910675451,
-0.0777421668,
0.0076193856,
0.0588438958,
0.0234975647,
0.01575635,
-0.0133553324,
-0.0120929172,
0.0174408387,
0.0141831832,
0.0164667554,
-0.0220852531,
0.014996266,
0.0041410625,
0.017424643,
0.0379473716,
0.0290676299,
0.0170224514,
-0.0516601093,
-0.0423786193,
-0.0302861538,
0.0644842908,
0.0170147438,
-0.0123359328,
0.0449784175,
0.0258616433,
-0.0332761109,
-0.0228577796,
0.0217532329,
-0.0475597046,
-0.01536946,
-0.0008376766,
-0.0187635962,
0.0260255598,
0.0082566021,
0.0277036391,
-0.0036458836,
0.011111225,
0.0030918135,
-0.0376437679,
-0.0449273586,
-0.0145109957,
0.0235614274,
0.0764522702,
0.0014787812,
-0.0122139463,
0.0200612731,
-0.0297058802,
-0.0145124728,
-0.0363668613,
0.1032517999,
-0.0157820545,
0.0470242165,
-0.0355344601,
-0.0346238948,
-0.0328310877,
0.0101228543,
0.0237542745,
0.0250779297,
-0.0298960563,
-0.0002399896,
-0.0283449292,
-0.0049475627,
0.0312691815,
-0.0153504908,
0.036496982,
-0.0369994864,
-0.012732354,
0.0029721793,
0.0135258203,
-0.0313474201,
-0.0047364826,
0.0099771321,
-0.0255400147,
-0.0604717359,
0.0092580477,
0.0567194223,
0.0179862808,
-0.013675102,
-0.003627111,
0.0002413356,
0.011930001,
0.0558956154,
0.0006165886,
0.0011076618,
0.0508937687,
0.0073906551,
0.020057451,
-0.0306557622,
-0.0421668366,
-0.0511586554,
0.0303843245,
0.0577357784,
-0.0789428204,
0.0521682575,
-0.1003785878,
-0.0492641181,
0.0024042206,
-0.0050241491,
-0.0476087369,
-0.0149618061,
-0.0090850228,
0.0256687794,
-0.0131320553,
-0.0165368486,
0.0312999524,
-0.0121734273,
-0.0069281575,
-0.0104946103,
0.0165622924,
-0.0574021116,
0.1034107804,
-0.0010328948,
-0.0146214599,
0.0596422814,
0.0829127058,
0.002330296,
0.0116278753,
-0.0455024801,
0.0491715707,
-0.0113440203,
0.0026843743,
-0.0586491115,
0.0087658241,
-0.0038347074,
0.0339466929,
0.0160113722,
-0.0199384056,
0.0353995189,
0.0241686366,
0.0635037944,
0.0181350783,
-0.0541279428,
-0.0265528411,
-0.0559060872,
0.0076941331,
0.0045612487,
-0.0169681665,
-0.0060318778,
0.0587907359,
-0.0512611158,
0.0551486127,
-0.0126954354,
-0.0113393012,
0.0004019362,
0.0489396974,
0.0125575149,
0.0106542418,
0.0288438033,
-0.1350519359,
-0.01933036,
0.0308125522,
0.0078872982,
-0.0539360866,
0.0192228146,
0.0569434278,
-0.0443082787,
0.0001204528,
0.0189965479,
0.0015556344,
0.0308019463,
0.0282664802,
-0.0049812477,
-0.0506347008,
-0.0709995776,
-0.0293828342,
-0.006659389,
-0.0235133786,
0.0137742106,
0.0586617291,
-0.0656050965,
-0.0145791061,
-0.0006431194,
-0.0309583284,
-0.0092902444,
-0.0271998513,
-0.0590633154,
-0.0126002477,
0.0133121368,
0.0478715301,
0.0302927103,
0.0431929529,
-0.003137229,
-0.03158186,
0.0017314013,
-0.0202195998,
-0.0033296151,
-0.0660181493,
0.0199405346,
-0.0024655557,
-0.0219442211,
-0.0406813808,
-0.0735994577,
0.0040935515,
-0.0707231313,
0.0277257804,
-0.0152669651,
-0.0264768582,
-0.0048726089,
-0.0541381948,
0.0214854926,
-0.0291450769,
-0.0653374344,
-0.0294309407,
-0.0071522505,
0.026385406,
0.0549556054,
-0.084113732,
-0.0460544489,
-0.0216216817,
-0.020391874,
-0.030580949,
0.0148442816,
0.0787731633,
-0.0609651133,
-0.0129973665,
-0.0213903114,
0.0705711991,
0.030216584,
-0.0106604388,
0.0221567322,
0.0325160027,
-0.0310622826,
-0.0186152663,
0.0233952366,
0.0277117379,
0.0403162763,
-0.0388037823,
-0.0367716216,
-0.0069208662,
-0.0470815375,
-0.0022904042,
0.0430216007,
-0.0145657472,
-0.0026998755,
0.0284863804,
0.0268563088,
-0.0368551686,
0.0363130122,
-0.0126052927,
0.0103463819,
0.0489071384,
-0.0125107924,
-0.0222193524,
-0.0264106747,
-0.0559047908,
0.0126718218,
0.0098375203,
0.0529851839,
-0.0183944013,
-0.0012902458,
0.1215417311,
-0.0104294373,
-0.0178582426,
-0.0017334149,
-0.0338040181,
-0.0097175166,
0.007474191,
-0.0110759484,
0.006533646,
0.0174012836,
-0.0249152966,
0.0231670197,
-0.0364846922,
-0.0435462482,
0.0375200808,
0.0021062475,
0.0253519602,
-0.006339089,
-0.040556822,
-0.0187844355,
0.078456901,
0.0292601865,
0.048569873,
-0.0325881056,
-0.0127259279,
0.0482810736,
-0.0009056874,
0.0036034863,
0.0149347391,
0.0281137172,
-0.0285289418,
-0.0403251238,
-0.0691307783,
-0.0395907164,
-0.0558381043,
0.0188414343,
0.056909956,
0.0392651372,
-0.0227108728,
-0.0315040797,
-0.0519586466,
0.0133722117,
0.013509633,
0.0099382438,
-0.0403260104,
0.0156079549,
0.0071008396,
-0.0288882907,
-0.005190982,
0.0216958206,
-0.0514739119,
-0.0300082732,
0.0092167286,
-0.0115130516,
0.0396414623,
-0.0225303043,
-0.0062588626,
0.0055609564,
-0.004720395,
-0.0170616452,
0.0258692484,
-0.0049644564,
0.0395588055,
-0.0464897305,
-0.0263837855,
0.0480636917,
0.0338563621,
-0.0759987161,
0.0282309074,
-0.0207100157,
0.0226519573,
0.0426790752,
-0.0147361113,
0.0051612193,
-0.0228755753,
0.0099066859,
0.0292449854,
0.0402981378,
-0.0410640314,
-0.0405119285,
0.01925366,
-0.014220411,
-0.0520997122,
0.053091906,
0.0289791916,
0.0150387092,
-0.0296771526,
0.0088159116,
-0.0639477447,
-0.0156828985,
0.0428259782,
0.0479259491,
0.0324138328,
-0.0205557533,
0.0067993705,
-0.0179850627,
-0.004937748,
0.010328671,
-0.0011891953,
-0.0116254911,
0.0165611226,
0.0659156591,
0.0107559543,
-0.0171829313,
0.0771238655,
0.0071825087,
-0.008821913,
-0.0934868529,
0.0142051466,
-0.0387897305,
-5.890338642e-33,
-0.0020216343,
-0.0542474985,
0.0012652621,
-0.0330043361,
-0.003048934,
0.0281953812,
-0.0301288087,
-0.0476252697,
-0.0081556169,
-0.0143551063,
0.0058559352,
0.0260409508,
0.0295621045,
-0.0116656851,
0.0283166077,
-0.04621711,
0.0538229421,
-0.0096883047,
0.0437318496,
-0.0234988872,
0.045943182,
0.0298214536,
0.1153257564,
-0.010933782,
0.0365368202,
0.057282161,
-0.0218431652,
-0.0092386222,
0.0853505656,
0.0088651879,
0.0083057499,
0.0261153895,
0.0094265994,
-0.0050216168,
0.0064555872,
-0.0029734382,
-0.0330756716,
-0.0680019036,
-0.026823286,
-0.0112213856,
-0.0151691968,
0.0479326621,
0.0746555254,
0.0147931296,
-0.0075305295,
0.0786012933,
0.0347127393,
0.0432881825,
-0.0017559443,
0.0107072564,
-0.0368554257,
0.0320743285,
-0.0039702323,
0.0545866042,
-0.0125426818,
0.0731473267,
0.0004070205,
0.0092917755,
-0.0854988247,
0.0150596322,
0.0404551141,
-0.0366458222,
-0.0468557253,
-0.0131401392,
0.0785141513,
0.0289007332,
-0.0088769095,
0.0249144454,
0.0326267034,
0.0185408071,
0.0185056031,
0.0223289374,
0.0396757163,
0.0687619224,
0.0539078973,
-0.0769922286,
-0.0387909897,
0.0342337675,
0.0764071047,
-0.001047419,
0.0061686072,
-0.0007495229,
-0.0498087145,
-0.0139733823,
0.004809747,
-0.0402055942,
-0.0060090488,
-0.0303155463,
-0.0204622913,
-0.0129167456,
0.0180865023,
0.0407746099,
-0.0243289713,
-0.0595988892,
-0.0004147137,
-0.0046568159,
0.0539668091,
0.0450777039,
0.0027838354,
-0.0413349904,
-0.0152932256,
-0.05478229,
-0.0293191727,
0.036526639,
-0.0145595977,
-0.0198994968,
-0.0350698791,
-0.0050109248,
-0.0213301256,
0.0028315948,
0.0214821845,
0.0031561365,
-0.0168408602,
0.0278715864,
0.0288114231,
-0.0155106913,
0.0082269786,
0.0228795763,
0.0265133679,
0.0939680487,
0.0527500212,
-0.0168367755,
-0.0098079788,
0.0112188617,
0.0356328301,
-0.0023456956,
-0.0463583469,
0.0476040132,
0.0094137602,
-0.0390346721,
0.0006969927,
-0.0162290651,
2.748e-7,
0.0179481842,
0.088262789,
-0.0196992066,
-0.0059234444,
0.0369545557,
0.0393838324,
0.0005803941,
-0.0042091962,
-0.0081202779,
0.009894616,
0.0419377163,
-0.0028990512,
0.0139095671,
0.0680522695,
-0.0570934303,
-0.0459407382,
-0.09076453,
-0.02258504,
-0.02643108,
0.0524187647,
0.0528867692,
-0.0017241812,
0.0355916843,
-0.0106448913,
-0.0050880429,
-0.0383449905,
0.0337834321,
-0.0301340297,
-0.0554533675,
-0.0296222605,
0.003110514,
0.0348900817,
0.0536340773,
0.0105113955,
-0.017368,
0.0168083496,
-0.0215860121,
-0.0305390693,
0.0070037199,
0.0305489376,
0.0361173339,
-0.0645092279,
0.0032961448,
-0.0593594573,
0.0394775011,
-0.0714160502,
-0.0750268623,
-0.0435738936,
-0.0100070722,
0.0364275053,
0.0716497824,
-0.0310521331,
-0.0359968804,
0.0046203351,
-0.00206984,
-0.0209000688,
-0.0021036905,
0.0196658261,
0.0352731533,
-0.0204793606,
-0.0326005109,
-0.0210109744,
0.006783667,
0.0728756562,
0.0196555965,
-0.0031243151,
0.0091632875,
2.116515231e-34,
0.0285672694,
-0.0060274052,
0.0133761354,
-0.0163916592,
0.0122016603,
0.0556900948,
-0.0504390597,
0.0018464769,
0.0268353727,
-0.0663941801,
0.0200929344
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.