id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02622v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02622v2 | DenseFormer: Enhancing Information Flow in Transformers via Depth Weighted Averaging | 2024-02-04T21:44:09 | 2024-03-21T10:57:40 | Matteo Pagliardini, Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Francois Fleuret, Martin Jaggi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The transformer architecture by Vaswani et al. (2017) is now ubiquitous
across application domains, from natural language processing to speech
processing and image understanding. We propose DenseFormer, a simple
modification to the standard architecture that improves the perplexity of the
model without increasing its size -- adding a few thousand parameters for
large-scale models in the 100B parameters range. Our approach relies on an
additional averaging step after each transformer block, which computes a
weighted average of current and past representations -- we refer to this
operation as Depth-Weighted-Average (DWA). The learned DWA weights exhibit
coherent patterns of information flow, revealing the strong and structured
reuse of activations from distant layers. Experiments demonstrate that
DenseFormer is more data efficient, reaching the same perplexity of much deeper
transformer models, and that for the same perplexity, these new models
outperform transformer baselines in terms of memory efficiency and inference
time. | [
0.0064409818,
0.0846856013,
0.0159086082,
0.0423200391,
-0.021709526,
0.003996117,
0.0174108725,
-0.0486415066,
-0.0468431488,
0.0255290288,
-0.0164813399,
-0.0470363162,
0.0354340859,
0.0440237336,
-0.0175618399,
-0.0686082765,
0.0027087419,
-0.0009514075,
-0.0654203892,
-0.0140959732,
-0.0149059603,
-0.0082511092,
-0.0040769237,
0.0365661867,
0.0017944459,
-0.0082274135,
-0.0432974957,
0.0066139214,
0.0434898138,
-0.0134561816,
0.0137706324,
0.0553514734,
0.0260288287,
0.0606830716,
0.0000021348,
0.0004798385,
-0.0114482436,
-0.0119850254,
-0.04960908,
0.0223826766,
-0.0150487851,
0.0035936572,
0.0042840363,
-0.0169411115,
-0.0184114855,
-0.0595206991,
0.0764144287,
0.0947446674,
0.0729139894,
0.0329812057,
-0.0073448983,
-0.0600263141,
0.0555829071,
-0.0507057011,
-0.0079802768,
-0.0542169847,
0.0033348862,
-0.0253050253,
-0.0616402514,
-0.0149513958,
-0.033147227,
0.0424557999,
0.0592911802,
0.0001668208,
0.0131072765,
0.039899528,
0.0137341032,
-0.0082835639,
0.0035070388,
0.0830295682,
-0.0533038341,
0.0114818057,
-0.0132675357,
-0.0069864718,
-0.0266528334,
-0.0195043441,
-0.036065232,
0.0008453985,
0.024543047,
0.004237744,
-0.0513822064,
0.0408078022,
0.0641799867,
0.0012666715,
-0.0608836561,
0.0080334609,
0.0108334785,
0.0094914176,
0.009414074,
-0.0059196777,
-0.0079660853,
-0.0465058237,
0.0040054438,
0.0187070332,
-0.0296062119,
-0.0031911945,
-0.0024360165,
-0.0305093825,
-0.0166975092,
-0.0067508803,
0.0610782951,
0.0412194356,
-0.0380229391,
0.0474994928,
-0.0174340364,
0.0513262413,
-0.0625239834,
0.0163260363,
-0.0164670385,
-0.0086951694,
-0.0217734426,
-0.0373093374,
-0.0295753777,
0.0567792393,
-0.0137039237,
-0.03594248,
-0.0415159725,
0.0204522461,
-0.0327044465,
-0.0406118706,
0.0107142879,
0.0386686698,
-0.0330933332,
-0.0177017935,
0.0130116399,
0.061368607,
0.0190937277,
0.0095515111,
0.0396254063,
-0.0254735388,
-0.0390877873,
-0.0204625465,
0.0158417709,
-0.0175455865,
0.0250225291,
0.0258096568,
-0.020136103,
-0.0375467241,
-0.0307392105,
0.0159575474,
-0.0016586181,
-0.0476280563,
0.029758703,
-0.0489393175,
0.0361044742,
-0.0174751617,
0.0240444355,
-0.0125551047,
0.0079754395,
0.0200443529,
-0.0178646073,
0.0548246428,
0.0163600072,
-0.028237734,
0.0090475017,
0.0317724198,
0.0169942919,
0.0395792015,
0.0252430849,
0.0502331369,
-0.0293803234,
-0.020846393,
-0.0070395181,
0.021461349,
0.0094259279,
0.0109413071,
-0.0195101686,
-0.0414072275,
-0.0743833631,
0.0014557317,
0.0317032449,
0.0374622755,
-0.0717321783,
-0.0195734724,
0.0398520119,
0.0169229787,
0.0238797981,
0.0565291755,
0.0213924348,
-0.019856194,
-0.0091662453,
0.0283287857,
-0.0579935089,
0.0875466466,
0.0229191575,
-0.0325831585,
0.0174259078,
0.059314575,
-0.0555467382,
-0.0258136149,
0.0413718969,
-0.0116951969,
0.0277718995,
0.0033039134,
0.0147162005,
0.0442072488,
-0.0181144699,
0.1274750829,
0.0242549703,
-0.0445235744,
-0.0308339577,
-0.0619595274,
0.0079261865,
0.0174841117,
0.0254167207,
0.0027653773,
-0.0121918619,
0.0287825149,
0.0180345569,
0.0316259563,
0.0010670947,
0.0104438066,
0.0784938782,
-0.0339872129,
-0.0589382462,
-0.0084090075,
0.0221808404,
0.0219026599,
0.0165709332,
-0.0360927805,
0.0355472863,
-0.0276983697,
0.0134596042,
-0.0034555965,
0.000708338,
0.003719972,
0.0594330207,
0.0081364196,
0.0175065268,
0.0069522001,
-0.0010925536,
-0.0099704415,
0.0312894322,
-0.0419796929,
-0.0530404337,
0.0176662877,
-0.0747185573,
0.0076829894,
0.0160132032,
-0.0123715494,
-0.0008620294,
0.0920306072,
-0.0468562394,
-0.0460859016,
0.0550371222,
-0.0408105887,
0.056754563,
-0.0258549098,
0.0101242531,
-0.0122116022,
0.0406321101,
-0.0231116395,
0.057851322,
-0.0314992331,
-0.0150977951,
-0.0056905518,
-0.0348592885,
0.0038732772,
0.0022335632,
-0.0143796401,
-0.0184453446,
-0.0365263969,
0.0020022113,
0.0061126808,
-0.028501818,
0.0047376798,
-0.0153457336,
-0.0258455519,
-0.0174667835,
-0.0260059722,
-0.0087936521,
0.0051314072,
0.0843431428,
0.0541654751,
-0.0109588765,
-0.0219230317,
0.0250181947,
-0.0033776937,
0.0051874341,
-0.0139800068,
-0.0061597247,
-0.0365028903,
-0.0252584964,
-0.0498727039,
0.0149611477,
0.0682285354,
0.0063364259,
-0.0319186412,
-0.0323386341,
-0.0273296908,
-0.0070747272,
0.0244425926,
-0.0162285622,
-0.0452135466,
-0.0172834173,
-0.0084956195,
0.0201476961,
0.070401594,
0.0102469651,
0.0160326269,
0.0259421617,
-0.0075680339,
-0.0378947817,
0.026695976,
-0.0543625653,
0.0208925977,
-0.0581731685,
0.0181753952,
0.0115303313,
0.0542867221,
-0.0148832658,
-0.0031430805,
-0.0203459505,
-0.037954811,
0.0216168072,
-0.0320673063,
0.0254946034,
-0.0258536544,
0.0047783731,
0.0130662788,
-0.0170240924,
-0.0425798222,
0.0593745299,
-0.0091216974,
-0.0103128161,
0.0054740477,
0.0094835302,
-0.0421075374,
0.0483539999,
-0.0015963734,
0.0439488925,
-0.0357200056,
-0.0507981218,
-0.0341346078,
0.0061261416,
-0.0027806831,
-0.0006554151,
0.0717894658,
-0.0471023805,
0.0049402784,
0.0007229937,
-0.0654735193,
-0.0582175329,
-0.0006708573,
-0.0414739512,
0.020214539,
0.0220279433,
-0.0515265241,
-0.1134184003,
-0.0059723351,
0.0618005432,
0.0582911223,
0.0105094146,
-0.0230176505,
-0.0004923465,
0.0216979869,
0.0099693723,
0.0611579195,
0.0555437766,
-0.0168372225,
0.060392987,
0.0784331635,
-0.0274566878,
0.0038582715,
-0.0952169076,
0.0296133142,
0.025385892,
0.01230569,
-0.0104977507,
-0.0072406968,
0.0255269669,
-0.0494634733,
-0.0125243589,
0.0670917332,
-0.0126096578,
-0.0837504715,
0.0110647101,
0.0100780195,
0.0363173261,
0.0074464092,
0.0193014368,
-0.0496869087,
-0.0456216149,
0.0021054891,
-0.0038411412,
0.0400330499,
-0.0062885475,
0.0517401211,
-0.0735195726,
0.0432112105,
-0.0076243063,
0.0150897913,
-0.0223052409,
-0.0395322219,
-0.0085577182,
-0.0328923091,
-0.0054428284,
-0.0155458413,
0.0083420957,
-0.0591012239,
0.0244991239,
-0.0038889106,
-0.0268596523,
0.0491840057,
-0.0205223002,
-0.0319457017,
0.0646457523,
-0.0148602948,
-0.0042928224,
-0.0736644566,
0.0225573592,
0.0094606727,
0.0013264018,
0.0044832076,
0.0886932537,
0.0373339504,
-0.0277762692,
-0.0355103575,
0.0202774126,
-0.0281646047,
-0.0341846347,
-0.0676396266,
0.0434552543,
-0.0187853426,
0.0068462836,
-0.0105234338,
-0.0015172737,
-0.0188962352,
0.0363801606,
0.0016240927,
-0.0023091075,
-0.0183258951,
-0.008618651,
0.0335312374,
-0.0458200052,
-0.0500425138,
0.0397544429,
0.0336702876,
-0.0581831634,
-0.0186322611,
0.0453446358,
-0.0191488992,
0.0382801332,
0.0067461468,
-0.0403412879,
0.0376367979,
-0.0094424738,
-0.0548168719,
0.0086538699,
-0.0206566006,
0.0394667648,
-0.0429025665,
-0.0071354262,
0.030511409,
-0.0064858189,
-0.0280735847,
0.0269653089,
-0.1253154129,
-0.051871378,
0.037874829,
0.0260599256,
0.0203754045,
0.0473076254,
-0.0072502284,
-0.0124228774,
0.0655497015,
0.001806192,
-0.0026408385,
0.0345015526,
0.0400023237,
-0.0521787554,
-0.0153616127,
0.043159239,
-0.0475970209,
0.0293482561,
0.0570787638,
0.0039597871,
-0.0354190171,
-0.003344242,
0.0200122874,
-0.0383362398,
0.0534879006,
0.0324306041,
0.0608513691,
0.0007144647,
0.050304547,
0.0156593192,
-0.0036790546,
-0.067712225,
-0.008339515,
0.0396063477,
0.0208593458,
0.0338629,
0.0267822649,
0.0487333424,
0.0190267898,
-0.0215383843,
-0.0119603444,
-0.0302576106,
-0.0484104082,
-0.0065969629,
0.0121601075,
-0.004696073,
-0.0042252089,
0.0281905793,
0.0287130326,
0.017367553,
0.0129882181,
0.0192770045,
-0.0057157399,
-0.0802157745,
0.0236917585,
-0.1240792796,
-0.058986973,
-0.007496994,
-0.0457757562,
0.048806157,
-0.0095345126,
0.0237562023,
0.0053288578,
0.00246444,
-0.0094052712,
0.0029921196,
-0.0183805469,
-0.0249957107,
0.0209307764,
0.0245731901,
0.0220071319,
-0.0084240343,
0.0706167594,
-0.0159227308,
0.038212914,
-0.0046797437,
0.0301251244,
-0.0224209316,
-0.0538413897,
0.02185308,
0.0461526588,
-0.0148560759,
-0.0089563867,
-0.019262014,
-0.0626934022,
0.0470890589,
-0.0500892699,
0.0391786769,
-0.0247502755,
0.0284674801,
0.030867625,
0.0230994187,
-0.0492436662,
0.0117383925,
-0.0297856815,
-0.0108080823,
-0.0064551425,
-0.0042418553,
-6.777549983e-33,
0.0269929394,
0.0387572199,
0.0142351501,
0.0108700255,
-0.042734243,
0.0421997048,
-0.0423470549,
-0.0135391988,
-0.0242726505,
0.0543294884,
-0.0265123006,
0.0317065716,
0.0120241828,
0.0385808498,
0.01809863,
-0.0318350345,
0.0630374104,
0.0282766074,
-0.0091915065,
0.0557003878,
0.0103755081,
0.0173781831,
0.0715874508,
-0.0210858639,
-0.0635546446,
0.0299161263,
-0.0241974201,
0.0158671699,
-0.0279348772,
0.0407334119,
-0.0369094536,
-0.0325419977,
0.0022067381,
-0.0418747924,
-0.0397339277,
-0.0073053385,
-0.0671039969,
0.0152991619,
-0.02901401,
0.016347276,
-0.049492348,
0.0066581513,
0.0262956768,
0.0173641518,
0.0004737965,
-0.0887704939,
0.0155951204,
0.0026397365,
-0.029382091,
-0.0314853936,
-0.0154352747,
0.0234219693,
-0.0351190493,
-0.029080525,
0.0003683465,
0.0143719716,
-0.0189384352,
0.0319215991,
-0.0852894858,
0.0050269854,
0.0097808661,
0.0256500337,
0.0283873063,
0.0414737239,
0.0033470788,
0.0494613349,
0.0355162285,
-0.0306002181,
-0.0436977856,
0.0185193103,
0.0276829228,
0.0712901726,
0.0322920568,
0.0060672988,
0.0640834719,
0.00784651,
-0.069633387,
0.0086021563,
-0.0545160435,
0.0878840759,
0.0185239464,
0.0079831379,
-0.0061364421,
-0.0216580946,
-0.0176724251,
0.0069191311,
-0.0345599316,
0.0084621869,
-0.0141563257,
0.0396900922,
-0.0324545391,
-0.010288002,
0.035588935,
-0.0325885266,
0.0259672645,
0.0081808278,
0.0273177642,
0.0310803708,
0.0232461859,
-0.0042545376,
0.0048742825,
-0.0155230192,
0.0148820467,
0.0127138598,
0.0084586507,
0.0069644749,
0.0304150991,
0.0697189346,
-0.0464989096,
-0.0361840464,
-0.0500961021,
-0.0038806242,
-0.0001613238,
0.0569252782,
0.0030828496,
0.0035731406,
-0.0219128393,
0.0160860643,
-0.0336563028,
0.0337460339,
-0.0211421307,
0.0203527249,
0.0296925362,
0.0535470024,
-0.0264573451,
-0.0533397384,
-0.0636103675,
-0.0422143973,
0.0551431812,
-0.0887715444,
-0.0432293043,
0.0428114943,
2.925e-7,
0.006854564,
0.0026160111,
0.0185972862,
-0.0055113942,
0.0131727457,
0.01615531,
0.0000168193,
0.0135953594,
0.0151860015,
-0.0006248027,
0.0027368905,
0.0516600497,
0.0397020765,
0.0140533401,
-0.0811985433,
-0.0232012346,
-0.073328115,
-0.0243331213,
-0.0196024645,
-0.0441339724,
-0.0062197065,
0.1192936897,
0.0200613812,
-0.0386465229,
0.0589062758,
0.010711452,
0.0542332418,
0.028490603,
0.0463766381,
0.0079130288,
0.034293808,
-0.0172936115,
0.0111544533,
0.006302332,
-0.0372857042,
0.0298749413,
0.0002524237,
0.0584821813,
-0.0052392757,
-0.0613639876,
-0.0001719157,
0.024416836,
0.0250031389,
-0.0319866091,
0.0447228216,
-0.0597455539,
-0.0354951099,
-0.0160529818,
-0.0374524556,
-0.0033952668,
0.0214764178,
0.0280731022,
-0.004166815,
0.0114050964,
0.0002262348,
-0.0245662145,
0.0039946996,
-0.0796257034,
-0.0092776744,
-0.0498005152,
-0.0521833301,
-0.0139652146,
-0.0472102538,
-0.0875638202,
0.0350132696,
0.017284926,
-0.0064679873,
2.85778679e-34,
0.0405021459,
-0.0062828311,
0.0123508582,
0.028230112,
0.0130769415,
-0.0268622879,
0.0299376082,
-0.0132035855,
-0.0002841646,
-0.1034528837,
-0.0226631183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02619v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02619v7 | Increasing Trust in Language Models through the Reuse of Verified Circuits | 2024-02-04T21:33:18 | 2024-06-16T22:09:57 | Philip Quirke, Clement Neo, Fazl Barez | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Language Models (LMs) are increasingly used for a wide range of prediction
tasks, but their training can often neglect rare edge cases, reducing their
reliability. Here, we define a stringent standard of trustworthiness whereby
the task algorithm and circuit implementation must be verified, accounting for
edge cases, with no known failure modes. We show that a model can be trained to
meet this standard if built using mathematically and logically specified
frameworks. In this paper, we fully verify an auto-regressive transformer model
for n-digit integer addition. To exhibit the reusability of verified modules,
we insert the trained integer addition model into a larger untrained model and
train the combined model to perform both addition and subtraction. We find
extensive reuse of the addition circuits for both tasks, easing verification of
the more complex subtractor model. We discuss how inserting verified task
modules into LMs can leverage model reuse to improve verifiability and
trustworthiness of language models built using them. The reuse of verified
circuits reduces the effort to verify more complex composite models which we
believe to be a significant step towards safety of language models. | [
-0.0061851223,
0.0982872993,
0.0169237871,
0.034222573,
-0.0111556044,
-0.0250175297,
0.0255429205,
-0.0486590266,
-0.0088767372,
-0.0426569395,
-0.0086099822,
-0.0042754523,
0.0337617137,
0.0527060404,
0.0723649338,
0.0123369982,
0.0516326278,
-0.0312808119,
-0.0433860905,
0.0012932515,
-0.0210978985,
-0.0210378021,
0.003681282,
0.0240058377,
-0.0114110457,
-0.0091216862,
0.0045746975,
-0.061261721,
0.0052925004,
0.0080990251,
-0.0051593729,
0.0616043769,
-0.0148216439,
0.056452591,
0.0000022714,
-0.0083227027,
-0.0427248292,
0.0384110734,
-0.0864175037,
0.032493718,
-0.0089034662,
0.0058665276,
-0.0410956964,
0.0364842229,
-0.0205096584,
-0.0117101353,
0.0640784726,
0.0303994734,
0.0789040923,
0.0705473945,
0.0034226291,
0.0016907126,
0.0745084584,
-0.0198710077,
-0.0012617655,
-0.0125368144,
0.0190660525,
0.0146056255,
-0.0103404988,
-0.0182108171,
0.0098078344,
-0.0135088116,
0.0497668236,
-0.0142121846,
-0.0148314452,
0.009963884,
-0.0244827699,
0.0046061929,
-0.0603256412,
0.0151501559,
-0.0449829474,
-0.0806277096,
-0.0064336001,
-0.0055098045,
-0.0602042712,
-0.0106665771,
-0.0248429794,
0.0255620722,
0.0095482478,
-0.0089970911,
-0.0080044484,
-0.0238287617,
0.0637543574,
-0.0096222134,
0.0031565619,
0.0949382409,
0.0267641786,
0.0058972863,
-0.0337040573,
-0.0103128748,
-0.0324146152,
-0.0633015037,
-0.0066481442,
0.029525172,
0.0269459262,
0.0188492835,
-0.0432796441,
-0.0096547836,
0.0063244719,
-0.0625881851,
0.0180539507,
0.0475450158,
0.0028644633,
-0.0100490227,
-0.0484578423,
0.0649699122,
-0.0250168592,
0.0248491187,
0.0042219395,
0.0525972731,
0.0121489465,
-0.019151751,
-0.0274254344,
0.0441751294,
0.0125218919,
-0.0016032144,
-0.0553846732,
0.0530577637,
-0.0422125868,
0.0566695444,
0.0176890977,
-0.0343185998,
0.0334568247,
-0.0443426818,
0.0085680885,
0.0058661881,
0.0288702101,
0.0099560469,
-0.0090285949,
-0.0789875463,
-0.0064589926,
0.0045521562,
-0.0444580093,
0.0060314136,
-0.0025282877,
0.0771695226,
0.0059247464,
-0.0364706144,
-0.0520065352,
-0.0427809209,
-0.0336122252,
-0.0472461283,
0.0019671042,
-0.1010535359,
-0.0183294863,
-0.0046389052,
0.0068810261,
-0.0080762412,
0.0276678279,
0.0352546573,
0.002985707,
0.0585940294,
0.0142546948,
-0.0153236836,
-0.0394153148,
0.0011107113,
-0.0061703059,
0.0162219703,
0.0487559251,
-0.0191986449,
0.0460308492,
-0.0118177133,
0.0464122966,
0.0492301732,
0.0151264686,
-0.0104304738,
-0.0245617572,
-0.0237190146,
0.0165433194,
-0.0608256683,
-0.0463698208,
0.088614285,
-0.0453767702,
-0.0131773418,
0.0460673943,
0.0120677408,
0.0001325649,
0.0579383932,
-0.0029476699,
-0.0320884064,
0.0242348853,
0.0010940921,
-0.0975498408,
0.0468067378,
-0.0636726692,
0.0244418327,
0.0464753397,
0.0198812112,
-0.0179473292,
-0.0446518771,
-0.0349600427,
-0.0541659482,
0.076090619,
-0.0022060552,
0.0376077034,
-0.0082784574,
-0.0406253152,
0.0736841112,
0.0050283223,
-0.1047849059,
-0.0404789634,
-0.1068327427,
0.0414987355,
0.0315459557,
0.0623654611,
0.0123671899,
0.0549361259,
-0.0264119152,
-0.0233678594,
-0.0016122462,
0.0339291617,
-0.0023664455,
-0.0064153844,
-0.0220518298,
-0.0187539998,
0.022799775,
0.050917957,
0.0149584375,
0.0478795394,
-0.0186881479,
0.0202231854,
-0.0100893909,
-0.0282181259,
0.0056965789,
-0.0187766589,
-0.0351410136,
0.0032818879,
0.0242891703,
-0.0297224652,
0.0048870579,
-0.0091386484,
0.0565511025,
0.0232725106,
0.0230767485,
-0.020047022,
-0.0264888443,
-0.0455857962,
0.0374840647,
0.0672463849,
-0.0144421551,
0.0029372252,
0.0506243743,
0.0120986337,
-0.0378630757,
0.0507638827,
-0.0751807392,
0.0305212811,
-0.0342883393,
0.0427704528,
-0.0171111822,
-0.0237746052,
-0.0002921995,
0.0345251523,
-0.0070791761,
0.0050127371,
-0.0351735316,
-0.0263242181,
0.0203319564,
0.0069644372,
-0.0634349585,
-0.0101968227,
-0.0029463021,
0.0654584393,
0.0347219072,
-0.0196678285,
0.0031639081,
-0.0347900763,
-0.0454414487,
-0.0348734297,
-0.0320630111,
0.0677346811,
-0.009075704,
-0.0134646166,
0.028510645,
-0.0078337276,
-0.0117876679,
-0.0321941637,
0.0168878138,
-0.0020232133,
-0.0032057483,
-0.034019798,
-0.0438964888,
-0.0040585883,
-0.0405436233,
-0.027271226,
0.0789851919,
-0.0230085496,
0.0147568695,
-0.0482389852,
-0.0019370782,
0.0011395371,
0.0429130085,
-0.0127841327,
-0.0140875066,
0.0293865465,
0.0229493678,
-0.0091427192,
0.0035716053,
-0.0134848766,
-0.0315263122,
0.0479471795,
0.000326943,
-0.0169376153,
-0.0190428011,
0.0061643263,
-0.0556560755,
0.0245563947,
-0.0083876178,
-0.0389374904,
0.0787003189,
-0.023410324,
-0.0102659864,
-0.0274839569,
-0.0129182069,
0.0337918922,
0.0094116405,
0.025854731,
-0.0727438554,
-0.0161789116,
0.0212446433,
-0.0182437152,
-0.0799994543,
0.0611129478,
-0.0588369258,
-0.0175424777,
-0.0209612995,
0.0009006812,
-0.0020894152,
0.0306280535,
0.0186377447,
0.024929408,
0.0514931194,
0.0275953691,
-0.0127270333,
-0.0104247238,
0.0422228277,
-0.0662832111,
0.0933730826,
-0.020861974,
0.0194560662,
-0.008122527,
-0.0319005065,
-0.0615685098,
0.0181442183,
-0.0282981265,
0.0284816418,
-0.0145025188,
-0.0407533757,
-0.0155866835,
0.0370962098,
0.0611569025,
0.0458806641,
-0.0165902209,
-0.0150677087,
-0.0143659757,
-0.0032404743,
-0.003384253,
-0.0363130793,
0.0644245967,
-0.0585370362,
-0.003945705,
0.0126552721,
0.0524953119,
0.0311760325,
-0.0713089928,
-0.0160287656,
0.0238237176,
-0.0132772783,
0.0031711564,
0.0578589998,
-0.0117326323,
-0.027838476,
0.0040732082,
0.072916992,
0.0076965429,
-0.0356594734,
-0.0027307814,
-0.0229758695,
0.0042528929,
0.0206470136,
0.0422873758,
-0.1034652963,
0.0221416745,
0.0206828248,
0.0037688883,
-0.0253940094,
0.0021917892,
-0.0267753918,
-0.1060529128,
0.0219073221,
0.043573454,
-0.0239307508,
-0.0307367742,
-0.0564704053,
-0.0282304324,
-0.0148668308,
0.0306577813,
0.0274052322,
-0.0013052096,
-0.0313886963,
0.0155654205,
-0.0648812056,
-0.0092408946,
0.0210912023,
0.0078329546,
0.0144326314,
0.0727932379,
-0.0325877815,
-0.0189207904,
-0.0710988566,
0.0126959579,
0.0491288267,
-0.0161914751,
0.0447104722,
0.0081927907,
0.0267535988,
-0.0174047854,
0.0027444907,
0.0045353766,
-0.0274950638,
-0.0302766673,
-0.0377263986,
0.0789733976,
-0.0040090634,
-0.0329984874,
0.0086292503,
-0.0198707003,
0.0070537007,
0.0313947834,
-0.0133429039,
0.0201069117,
-0.0224083364,
-0.0522570536,
-0.0086818011,
-0.0212335344,
-0.056611184,
-0.0036803894,
0.0368786678,
-0.043997556,
-0.0167070422,
0.0355952159,
-0.0522457771,
0.0324459299,
0.0046406086,
-0.070770368,
0.0796926245,
-0.0243876968,
-0.0695741624,
0.001783286,
-0.0694127902,
0.069471471,
-0.0703587607,
0.0377648063,
-0.0060228314,
-0.0306224395,
-0.013188825,
0.0203255471,
-0.0922642946,
-0.0841619745,
-0.0101915002,
0.0796569437,
0.0372003689,
-0.0054836543,
-0.0031314224,
-0.0268362779,
0.0223390516,
0.0004061763,
-0.05068703,
0.0313135311,
0.0642871559,
-0.0425481461,
-0.0035342604,
-0.027562838,
-0.009576506,
0.0116154812,
0.0375521667,
-0.0185922626,
-0.0500623211,
-0.0204221047,
0.0399574265,
0.0258506462,
0.0442761369,
0.0083407471,
0.0768191442,
0.0007350366,
0.044011578,
-0.0231472217,
0.011349041,
-0.030639736,
0.0265694614,
0.008020821,
0.006274954,
0.0019253356,
-0.0572933741,
0.0264845211,
0.0363256931,
-0.0003456614,
0.0440250002,
-0.0249766205,
0.0459478796,
0.0102441357,
-0.0346870646,
-0.0243668146,
-0.0060082534,
0.0143494112,
0.0216156542,
0.0046793204,
-0.0211363509,
0.004305488,
0.0114746029,
-0.020363519,
0.0166995246,
-0.0442532152,
-0.078767933,
-0.0421379581,
0.0024973149,
0.0098705404,
0.0353449248,
0.0083788969,
-0.0448724031,
0.00626759,
-0.0555394366,
-0.0027363279,
0.0026891015,
-0.0214751139,
0.0068858862,
0.0356598496,
0.009376253,
-0.0408531949,
0.0400857739,
-0.0162057616,
0.0273290668,
-0.0306174662,
-0.0158725642,
-0.0259011406,
-0.065173693,
-0.0148909492,
0.0280598383,
-0.0552454479,
-0.0424106047,
-0.0321916603,
-0.0814690441,
0.0103058768,
0.0220170412,
0.0478960164,
0.0008250934,
0.0242015589,
0.0491037704,
-0.0096067321,
0.0302272104,
-0.0098592686,
-0.0340384394,
0.0416134261,
0.0154307233,
-0.0254345778,
-6.360725563e-33,
-0.0068522845,
-0.0167602878,
0.0335193239,
0.0106537193,
0.0237150993,
0.0423321649,
-0.0552798472,
0.0557468422,
-0.0097953966,
-0.0175433792,
0.0179150347,
0.0071028504,
0.0318524763,
0.0085686604,
-0.0006619334,
0.0361374654,
0.0571407788,
-0.0092912484,
-0.0437579118,
-0.0017972704,
0.0216010455,
-0.0343869999,
0.0720723495,
-0.0585360974,
0.0540303774,
-0.0059889401,
-0.049943313,
-0.0144879902,
-0.0406966247,
0.0771455467,
0.0107150814,
0.0261776298,
-0.0153935775,
-0.0554645956,
-0.0061599757,
0.0345942527,
-0.0378456786,
-0.0068380036,
-0.0050351936,
-0.0043513831,
-0.0062759575,
-0.0238926224,
0.0464606136,
-0.0176816117,
-0.0482333153,
0.0147695662,
-0.0206907932,
-0.0211016983,
0.0014659119,
0.0122375051,
-0.021455029,
0.0385835245,
0.0290138982,
-0.0168586299,
0.0239343457,
0.0326514356,
-0.036483597,
-0.0639822707,
-0.0523862839,
0.0655269399,
0.0621992312,
0.0248683766,
0.0589199886,
-0.0140533084,
-0.0070216814,
0.041377712,
0.0340032727,
-0.0091520259,
-0.028738115,
-0.0003005117,
0.0407513753,
0.055355195,
0.0978325084,
0.0270093884,
0.0477216542,
-0.0207155999,
-0.0364168435,
0.0207100548,
0.0394642204,
0.0338220038,
0.0425122716,
0.0056700762,
-0.0608944744,
-0.0122602191,
-0.019818794,
0.0261505693,
-0.0579850785,
-0.0333528295,
-0.0284539443,
0.0466603711,
-0.007877443,
0.028561309,
0.0054945862,
-0.0613592789,
-0.0028728556,
0.0347193964,
0.0397671051,
0.0046506519,
-0.0244765785,
0.0202918984,
0.0028136694,
-0.0078668939,
-0.0215747599,
-0.0301102418,
0.008695933,
0.0197948851,
0.011328036,
0.0723114386,
-0.0785421282,
0.006867433,
-0.0330073684,
-0.0092809666,
0.0544057302,
0.0500487834,
0.02680902,
0.0036176736,
-0.0044370927,
-0.0066489209,
-0.0580193512,
-0.0486262143,
-0.0030130276,
0.0698407814,
0.0015198403,
0.0628741011,
0.0168181788,
-0.0239037741,
-0.0326575823,
0.0280429889,
0.0513583124,
-0.0081755416,
-0.0067406828,
-0.0164625533,
3.103e-7,
0.0007040981,
0.0047222823,
0.0276629161,
0.0101191597,
0.0241434369,
0.0332839899,
-0.0141366599,
0.0230166465,
-0.0287841596,
-0.0171075948,
-0.0349601619,
0.0014420147,
0.0358872302,
0.0188679323,
0.0226244424,
-0.0172745623,
-0.0548391938,
0.0151840113,
0.0269310325,
-0.0170439128,
0.0041530966,
0.0745205209,
0.035798151,
0.008412635,
-0.0087159788,
-0.0397926271,
0.0440731794,
0.003102497,
-0.0034503676,
-0.0016818142,
0.0272034518,
0.0247988813,
0.0059065949,
0.0374965072,
-0.0121409381,
0.0278341603,
-0.0027805965,
0.0685809702,
0.0084251212,
-0.0034007696,
-0.0061606513,
-0.0583911315,
-0.0335844494,
-0.0194636136,
0.0251213387,
-0.0189638119,
-0.002576059,
-0.0775667503,
-0.019256806,
-0.01095396,
0.0296839885,
0.0121413488,
0.0173634626,
0.0009849236,
0.0171233602,
0.0113974977,
0.0315680765,
-0.0439579375,
-0.0713494122,
0.0051583634,
-0.025580151,
-0.0552544184,
-0.0133082196,
-0.0026041758,
0.0127816722,
-0.0330136493,
0.0130825443,
3.078051243e-34,
0.0331999697,
-0.0355747305,
-0.0067369668,
0.0477485731,
0.0585514717,
-0.0127210049,
-0.0196629893,
-0.0000532849,
0.0151287634,
-0.0136853056,
-0.0440589264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02617v1 | Layer-Wise Analysis of Self-Supervised Acoustic Word Embeddings: A Study on Speech Emotion Recognition | 2024-02-04T21:24:54 | 2024-02-04T21:24:54 | Alexandra Saliba, Yuanchao Li, Ramon Sanabria, Catherine Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The efficacy of self-supervised speech models has been validated, yet the
optimal utilization of their representations remains challenging across diverse
tasks. In this study, we delve into Acoustic Word Embeddings (AWEs), a
fixed-length feature derived from continuous representations, to explore their
advantages in specific tasks. AWEs have previously shown utility in capturing
acoustic discriminability. In light of this, we propose measuring layer-wise
similarity between AWEs and word embeddings, aiming to further investigate the
inherent context within AWEs. Moreover, we evaluate the contribution of AWEs,
in comparison to other types of speech features, in the context of Speech
Emotion Recognition (SER). Through a comparative experiment and a layer-wise
accuracy analysis on two distinct corpora, IEMOCAP and ESD, we explore
differences between AWEs and raw self-supervised representations, as well as
the proper utilization of AWEs alone and in combination with word embeddings.
Our findings underscore the acoustic context conveyed by AWEs and showcase the
highly competitive SER accuracies by appropriately employing AWEs. | [
-0.0471056923,
0.0506451875,
0.0186362453,
0.042731341,
0.0018321696,
-0.0258468818,
0.0298996214,
-0.0528552197,
0.0030177813,
-0.0379513763,
-0.0934022143,
-0.0174348559,
0.007561042,
0.0012932273,
-0.0192337185,
-0.0253883675,
0.0147146126,
0.0109298751,
0.0254949741,
0.0006492828,
0.0188353136,
-0.0078205988,
-0.0376835652,
0.0573822632,
-0.0363574475,
-0.0159649048,
-0.0094490265,
0.0155820586,
0.0110337278,
-0.0247587003,
0.0116908606,
0.0360613801,
0.0767882913,
0.0260952804,
0.0000018551,
-0.0114467936,
-0.002094904,
-0.0091243824,
-0.0610597134,
0.041559279,
0.0463340543,
0.0244775694,
-0.0434860885,
0.0117300972,
0.0044584903,
-0.0477362685,
0.0376002789,
0.0140508786,
0.0262056906,
0.0330156796,
-0.0092920586,
-0.0155760469,
-0.0003635597,
-0.0208790377,
-0.0187173691,
0.0013121533,
-0.005094599,
-0.0330905728,
-0.0089071514,
-0.0449268967,
-0.0551722869,
0.02317225,
-0.0286909826,
0.0146918055,
0.058734823,
0.0173644591,
-0.0403008908,
-0.0242990833,
-0.014346865,
0.0729005858,
0.0111618238,
0.0131426491,
-0.0226683766,
0.0102720717,
-0.0201338325,
-0.0201059915,
-0.0131565705,
-0.011912805,
0.0540327318,
0.0242102854,
-0.0177642703,
0.1081467941,
0.0284356177,
0.0117852725,
-0.0266370736,
0.0310710762,
-0.0356119797,
-0.0376084782,
0.0094298441,
-0.0446507446,
0.0094620148,
0.0289600361,
0.0200939327,
-0.0238827486,
0.0236913636,
-0.012937298,
-0.0325561762,
-0.0128578208,
-0.0224433523,
-0.0649327412,
-0.0173666403,
0.0208130982,
-0.0672599152,
0.0520735718,
-0.0183866806,
0.0586860217,
0.0438156202,
-0.0218463074,
-0.0292790588,
0.0206415672,
-0.024311075,
0.0349873044,
-0.0084831705,
0.0245536342,
-0.0064165005,
-0.0833240598,
-0.0617044792,
0.0038326003,
-0.0281233564,
0.0328943506,
-0.0054925815,
0.0221279971,
0.018397674,
0.0125920977,
0.0273984391,
0.0120684085,
-0.0196094811,
0.047804378,
-0.0246945731,
-0.0241907071,
-0.0004459409,
0.0161860622,
0.0291623659,
0.0012751279,
0.0338425897,
0.0547129661,
0.0217617508,
-0.0446549281,
-0.015038698,
0.0110761467,
-0.0517109074,
-0.0205677692,
-0.0119144302,
-0.0233249664,
0.0634983405,
-0.0313239098,
0.0092417132,
-0.0128844203,
-0.000353176,
-0.0448869802,
0.0022715512,
0.0977400914,
0.0258842148,
-0.017223943,
0.0329600982,
0.0242581982,
0.0083896564,
0.0140841659,
0.0645401254,
0.0148883779,
0.067218326,
-0.0624596328,
0.0049329172,
0.0105666397,
-0.0106745698,
-0.0232026782,
-0.041621998,
-0.0155101391,
-0.0225043837,
0.0543487035,
0.0607855022,
-0.0010276528,
-0.035731487,
-0.0429723784,
0.060240671,
0.1158777326,
0.0052352343,
0.0259514544,
-0.0213996135,
0.0149714695,
0.0304498486,
-0.0158004574,
-0.0150609817,
-0.0061578928,
-0.0033901543,
0.0011509858,
0.0432148911,
0.002199749,
-0.0379453003,
-0.0296197459,
-0.0321952328,
-0.0341069214,
-0.022075884,
0.0121119553,
0.0270104539,
-0.0453358404,
-0.0259924997,
-0.009913885,
-0.0132831205,
-0.0807026699,
0.0015674166,
-0.0019768057,
-0.0015822728,
0.0567504987,
0.0183525551,
-0.0378328376,
-0.0353842936,
-0.0308951996,
-0.0217285454,
-0.0089591322,
0.0242949612,
-0.0100353258,
0.0721695721,
-0.0770118535,
-0.0196163598,
-0.0350596532,
0.0205390602,
0.0261724833,
-0.0236732531,
0.0565802604,
0.0183077585,
-0.0713912621,
0.0253708735,
0.0074395919,
-0.0196698122,
-0.075658977,
0.0086362669,
0.0477688909,
0.0475327857,
0.0344513766,
-0.0519716479,
-0.0024862741,
0.0548723079,
-0.0074201925,
-0.0290786959,
0.0392456837,
-0.0537865236,
-0.0169907119,
0.0301878471,
-0.0326196887,
0.047616601,
0.012829517,
-0.0140202492,
-0.0355511047,
0.055044882,
-0.0048125293,
0.0488976911,
-0.0485966839,
0.0172345601,
-0.0246171039,
0.0712558553,
0.0225217771,
-0.0008292157,
0.0213767681,
-0.0223640539,
-0.0227051396,
0.0206900667,
0.0335740224,
-0.018681325,
-0.0619642586,
0.01594932,
0.0180143379,
0.0244627316,
-0.0062175896,
-0.0340959057,
-0.0175337885,
-0.0230411626,
-0.109786965,
-0.0070022587,
-0.0147172594,
-0.0191529039,
-0.0322306901,
-0.0027088241,
-0.0375201814,
-0.0118892388,
-0.0046068709,
-0.0255909506,
-0.0297116749,
-0.0157419685,
-0.0259133317,
-0.025651671,
-0.0240600724,
-0.0865392759,
0.0203987099,
0.007903764,
0.0013404062,
-0.0246293638,
0.0044831261,
0.0079959463,
-0.0144851906,
-0.0100269765,
0.0296448898,
-0.0017569663,
-0.0447323173,
0.014618028,
-0.0121989921,
-0.0087559447,
0.0504563674,
0.01146146,
0.0890467092,
0.0441000499,
-0.0035977988,
-0.0360804275,
0.0279390439,
-0.0006990473,
0.068804875,
-0.0001210447,
0.0486373678,
-0.040602833,
0.0412006415,
0.0358170085,
0.0205987506,
-0.018965533,
-0.0195016582,
0.0136668487,
-0.0110464906,
-0.0205229111,
-0.0526989065,
-0.0326665267,
-0.0291268528,
0.0230798721,
-0.053350389,
0.0209294856,
-0.0568988882,
-0.0352081098,
-0.0694132149,
-0.0695654675,
-0.0163827837,
0.0673724636,
-0.070688799,
-0.0079909759,
-0.0169217829,
-0.0003943501,
0.029372124,
0.0162495077,
-0.0013783319,
-0.0646890104,
-0.0099595292,
-0.0012784241,
-0.0239665825,
0.0456300676,
-0.0395593084,
-0.0290858783,
-0.0773120373,
-0.0496276133,
-0.0178192202,
0.0030828435,
-0.0214493517,
-0.021160664,
0.0073669609,
0.0258065201,
0.0063899606,
0.0264885426,
0.0033664538,
0.0054895421,
0.0362427309,
0.0074621765,
0.0423650555,
0.0000803306,
0.0540188737,
0.0717841908,
-0.0122548677,
0.0777321607,
-0.0049435827,
-0.0632541329,
0.0349797197,
0.0203153286,
0.0158156976,
-0.0209293347,
-0.0237736516,
0.0247873235,
-0.0292677488,
0.0480159707,
0.1334838122,
0.0391125791,
-0.0236135498,
0.0306657366,
0.0020180983,
-0.0196840204,
0.0194196142,
-0.0120124752,
-0.0061170906,
-0.026644554,
0.0213179048,
0.036847841,
0.0371231064,
0.0163715892,
-0.0080605559,
-0.0522926413,
0.0474026911,
0.0204480868,
-0.0040060007,
-0.0240327921,
-0.0414456837,
0.0315066651,
-0.0463042334,
-0.0019596068,
-0.078576684,
0.0087617943,
-0.0327756442,
0.0276257005,
-0.0717917234,
-0.0585656278,
0.0429286696,
-0.0399746969,
0.0749876723,
0.0277291555,
0.0654087216,
-0.0270718634,
-0.0624790341,
0.0386226363,
0.0143202515,
-0.0247238837,
-0.0162416901,
0.0389687978,
-0.036605712,
-0.0174108371,
0.0431369618,
0.0293264054,
-0.0240238048,
0.0038623756,
0.0084043099,
0.0909471065,
-0.0251058172,
-0.0099609988,
-0.0310461279,
0.0118186343,
0.0331476666,
0.0799810961,
0.0113068391,
-0.0315369777,
-0.0248185229,
0.0207473729,
0.0382712372,
0.0358506553,
-0.0197862517,
-0.0004372504,
0.0019378104,
-0.0000847633,
-0.0312162414,
-0.0701597109,
0.0150756529,
0.030830862,
0.0076273116,
-0.0115599101,
-0.0263645407,
0.0190035999,
-0.042448204,
0.0472834036,
0.0462804697,
0.0275903828,
-0.0240726285,
0.0231630187,
0.0542057529,
-0.0025605429,
-0.0302013699,
0.0133157624,
-0.0093363142,
-0.0599376746,
0.0299300719,
-0.0524811521,
0.0053085745,
0.0213973876,
-0.0192122478,
-0.0103903059,
0.096668832,
0.0121685369,
-0.0452318043,
-0.0015770246,
0.068260625,
0.0193805993,
-0.0313350409,
0.0248991679,
-0.0324652903,
0.0394629389,
-0.0355159044,
0.0092256637,
0.0450973101,
-0.039755933,
-0.0483873785,
-0.0279603191,
0.0671472773,
0.0011440192,
-0.0030925618,
-0.0560602956,
0.0147251533,
0.0050681462,
0.0477628447,
-0.0541494302,
-0.0392298251,
0.01514218,
-0.0060175383,
-0.0534887947,
-0.0087572159,
-0.0150547558,
-0.0137109058,
-0.0103958258,
0.0796888024,
0.0273289867,
-0.0280421618,
-0.0386069752,
0.0283604432,
-0.0112089105,
0.021468183,
-0.0041847206,
-0.0257460251,
-0.001013813,
0.0041460372,
-0.0277938247,
-0.017333081,
-0.0304184351,
0.0344240963,
-0.027288083,
0.0083697904,
-0.019851476,
0.0266475342,
0.0268306471,
-0.0823068321,
0.0029950484,
-0.0177775826,
0.04011143,
-0.0252746567,
-0.0152208898,
-0.0632005185,
0.0196158849,
0.026758777,
0.0002433699,
-0.0578463711,
0.0318280272,
0.0403177701,
0.0028256183,
0.0490150489,
-0.0293352194,
0.0190025661,
-0.0530523509,
-0.0143095301,
0.0561009347,
0.0240611359,
-0.0158776529,
0.020558292,
-0.0461923294,
-0.0610886626,
0.031884551,
-0.0453908071,
-0.0171374753,
0.0073872912,
0.0109300613,
0.0530490391,
-0.0337232165,
0.07048776,
0.0172544681,
-0.0207589939,
-0.0350465998,
-0.0479598865,
0.0159740057,
-5.330047708e-33,
0.0094535332,
0.0110443486,
-0.0268813521,
-0.015967045,
-0.0405301303,
0.0567025766,
0.0139726363,
0.0281201415,
0.0080247167,
0.0179752465,
-0.0086963866,
0.0080376267,
0.0300112665,
-0.0102885086,
0.0014459604,
-0.0197587553,
0.0347753316,
-0.052962929,
0.0017148975,
-0.0304977484,
0.016564671,
0.0474732518,
0.0356241204,
-0.0804779083,
0.0234012045,
0.010052707,
0.0142572969,
-0.0440329313,
0.0902674571,
0.0597708039,
-0.0354602933,
0.0336394943,
-0.027467411,
0.0211088639,
-0.0179916006,
0.0093712397,
-0.0625675842,
-0.0161789451,
-0.0040546465,
0.0370329507,
-0.031193424,
0.0043608239,
0.0447382294,
0.0268039685,
-0.0379964262,
-0.0464783832,
0.0049645575,
0.0005282203,
-0.0157621447,
-0.0363455005,
-0.050454013,
0.0388204604,
-0.0360872038,
-0.0232119616,
0.094763644,
0.0223045144,
0.0169338565,
-0.0012546658,
-0.0652426258,
0.0043659061,
-0.025323147,
-0.009653111,
0.0336572565,
-0.016207749,
-0.0043685427,
0.0804023743,
0.049349796,
-0.0863876343,
-0.0130763594,
-0.0066642114,
0.06546323,
0.0317908525,
0.0131921032,
-0.0241871011,
0.014323947,
-0.0086048134,
-0.0083924392,
0.0020613677,
0.0451902337,
0.0104938764,
0.0729648471,
0.0466787145,
-0.0546065271,
0.0110477153,
-0.064013131,
-0.023458628,
-0.0105743101,
-0.0087561114,
0.0583748296,
0.0044022202,
0.0190944355,
-0.0016040242,
0.0225268677,
-0.0369818546,
0.0040791547,
0.027568629,
-0.0272072293,
0.0214896407,
0.0460013896,
0.0340613946,
0.0160550512,
0.0189439822,
0.0463822633,
0.055970069,
0.0600837283,
-0.048704993,
-0.0210126396,
0.0731403455,
-0.0262729209,
-0.0228611939,
-0.0198527128,
-0.0361903459,
-0.0261512138,
0.0014570099,
0.0030911393,
0.0312063731,
-0.0090544783,
-0.0119169531,
-0.0231202468,
0.0444253013,
0.0191784967,
0.0030908501,
-0.0101294639,
0.0355987251,
-0.0208526254,
-0.0039004802,
0.0375933424,
-0.0153755182,
0.0103980927,
-0.0437824056,
0.0111884177,
-0.0089811375,
2.679e-7,
-0.0533499904,
0.0214871727,
0.0092042172,
-0.0684340745,
0.0400475338,
0.0225234311,
-0.0490745753,
0.0092039993,
-0.0304658767,
-0.0049735154,
0.0563845858,
0.0068534478,
0.0878261849,
0.0292695034,
-0.0618320033,
-0.0105446856,
-0.0391723923,
0.0406849347,
-0.0325973034,
0.0069685383,
0.0366874859,
0.1039196998,
0.0463516936,
0.0001739399,
-0.0161691178,
-0.0130064748,
0.0151906367,
-0.0454487391,
0.0362076275,
-0.0285990424,
-0.0175764263,
-0.0090655964,
-0.0184432156,
-0.034889672,
-0.0320771672,
0.0603529774,
0.0639561862,
0.0350020304,
0.0192938242,
-0.066039741,
0.008582118,
0.0406923331,
-0.0257794205,
-0.0155160502,
0.0519463159,
-0.0090398854,
-0.0200898964,
-0.0210436992,
0.0005243653,
0.0057006422,
0.0948728323,
-0.0324565172,
-0.0031527586,
-0.0066569895,
0.0127712162,
-0.0337373875,
-0.0328442007,
-0.0927184001,
0.0067098918,
0.0248131175,
-0.0623037815,
0.0256947167,
-0.029031001,
0.0133146206,
0.0762628093,
-0.0164277796,
-0.0077724434,
1.941805317e-34,
0.0029530521,
-0.0205131862,
-0.0311876796,
0.0240312628,
0.0128194094,
-0.0150527544,
0.0244940557,
-0.0293826647,
0.0578556992,
-0.0263736378,
-0.0025379173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02611v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02611v2 | PuzzleBench: Can LLMs Solve Challenging First-Order Combinatorial Reasoning Problems? | 2024-02-04T20:56:09 | 2024-02-22T14:42:45 | Chinmay Mittal, Krishna Kartik, Mausam, Parag Singla | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent works show that the largest of the large language models (LLMs) can
solve many simple reasoning tasks expressed in natural language, without
any/much supervision. But, can they also solve challenging first-order
combinatorial reasoning problems, such as graph coloring, knapsack and
cryptarithmetic? To answer this question, we present PuzzleBench, a dataset of
31 such challenging problems along with a few solved instances for each
problem. These problems are all first order, i.e., they can be instantiated
with problem instances of varying sizes, and most of them are NP-hard,
requiring several reasoning steps to reach the solution. We first observe that
LLMs, even when aided by symbolic solvers, perform rather poorly on our
dataset. In response, we propose a new approach, Puzzle-LM, which combines LLMs
with both symbolic solvers and program interpreters, along with feedback from
solved examples, to achieve huge performance gains. Our extensive
experimentation and analyses offer new insights into the reasoning abilities
and limitations of present-day LLMs. | [
0.0337994136,
0.093032077,
-0.0139691541,
0.0707200393,
-0.0720084608,
0.0065334439,
0.0059367749,
0.0138933016,
0.0162297618,
-0.016139105,
0.0308998376,
0.0209447239,
-0.0143091911,
0.0292067472,
0.0116529092,
-0.0106455078,
-0.0055034878,
-0.0912614465,
0.0170096233,
-0.022771623,
-0.0081239268,
0.0320624411,
-0.0159248672,
0.0033854744,
-0.0024102097,
-0.0260812808,
-0.0399204493,
0.0001718619,
-0.0229485985,
-0.0145344771,
-0.0345794074,
0.0423486717,
0.0062721516,
0.0085132774,
0.0000023612,
-0.0449211821,
-0.0393239595,
-0.0178172272,
-0.080581367,
-0.0133292349,
0.0074416124,
-0.0158129577,
0.014479978,
0.0351519622,
-0.044537168,
-0.001339538,
0.0528877825,
0.0391180925,
0.0873053893,
0.0510267243,
0.0142079974,
-0.0010418112,
-0.0000626669,
0.0117250923,
0.0548252352,
-0.0571204722,
0.0141671738,
0.0423941091,
0.0346331522,
-0.0187650491,
-0.0285132248,
0.0143938279,
0.0411274657,
-0.0227498636,
-0.0202770568,
-0.0137201073,
-0.0177977402,
0.0140252728,
-0.0236076191,
0.0631594658,
-0.0406032093,
-0.0110809002,
-0.0053113988,
-0.006416793,
-0.0096896989,
0.0199518912,
-0.0142162992,
0.082001321,
-0.0312983394,
0.0052517606,
0.0083261449,
0.0036574779,
0.0301914215,
0.0289006699,
-0.0458471403,
0.1208698824,
-0.0146851819,
-0.0007550531,
0.0072056223,
-0.0473785363,
-0.0161789916,
-0.0652273744,
0.0247783698,
0.0403128676,
-0.0309718493,
0.0024682584,
0.0137935728,
-0.0054383026,
-0.0032596451,
0.0191308837,
0.063781932,
0.0369435288,
0.0105091976,
0.0645492002,
0.0266977996,
0.0823934451,
-0.0214043986,
0.0168827567,
-0.05641938,
-0.0028363909,
-0.0280180834,
-0.0128209079,
-0.0459648035,
0.0327826701,
-0.0406102836,
0.009731506,
0.0121089015,
0.0193966534,
-0.0112199802,
0.0519611612,
0.0303606465,
0.0008361804,
0.0175852533,
-0.055908151,
-0.0328460336,
-0.0364191085,
-0.0285715964,
-0.0087931948,
-0.0230189916,
-0.0283387657,
-0.0179289188,
0.0145914583,
0.01659986,
-0.0579154603,
0.0439127609,
0.0865382254,
0.0394946039,
-0.0089736264,
-0.0261579957,
-0.0213615764,
0.0074773896,
-0.0873681754,
-0.0063445331,
-0.0979827121,
0.0449801981,
0.0092580719,
0.0119680893,
-0.0450782888,
0.0124447811,
-0.0169701241,
-0.0097850878,
0.0843739286,
0.0437228605,
0.0223755166,
-0.0164798629,
-0.02185761,
-0.011320618,
0.0493956357,
0.0393528566,
0.040720284,
0.0035924942,
0.0011227829,
0.0150029492,
0.0412905738,
-0.0065183877,
0.0187682118,
-0.0274413265,
0.0002578378,
0.0082979864,
0.0089551182,
-0.0329414792,
0.0663310587,
-0.0040904549,
-0.0513841063,
0.0053026192,
0.0525692776,
-0.0169377923,
-0.0224312395,
-0.0114884404,
0.0195240136,
0.0180086773,
-0.0268418621,
-0.0493849665,
0.0610402413,
-0.0606666803,
-0.0097078895,
-0.0183488633,
0.0350122824,
-0.0035081743,
-0.0487973727,
-0.0299006775,
-0.0049233991,
0.0394411162,
0.0426076055,
0.059969075,
-0.004228862,
-0.0352555662,
0.0105499318,
0.0045191972,
-0.023639312,
-0.0429272279,
-0.0361765027,
0.0321329869,
0.0849648938,
0.0710156932,
-0.041912239,
-0.0310013872,
0.008308948,
0.0017458686,
0.0176514573,
0.0010216131,
0.0110290647,
0.0147364847,
-0.0497394912,
-0.0135160079,
-0.031952858,
0.0124948351,
0.0164817814,
0.0279863775,
-0.0450724065,
-0.0191418938,
-0.0428106822,
-0.016853638,
0.0078300843,
-0.0146739352,
-0.0000467308,
0.0109182624,
0.006240136,
0.0201099087,
-0.0068688891,
-0.0061970619,
0.0334754027,
-0.0086831655,
-0.0532014258,
-0.028068956,
-0.0343050435,
0.0028442007,
-0.0404010974,
0.0365254991,
-0.0404693261,
-0.0406966768,
0.0567044578,
-0.0837798789,
-0.0160564352,
0.0501344986,
-0.0234905854,
-0.0082389927,
-0.0047550001,
0.0062157605,
0.0124857333,
-0.0153939603,
-0.0184577368,
0.0487966798,
-0.036797557,
-0.0141700162,
-0.0228696372,
-0.0139791863,
0.0126782348,
-0.0525210015,
-0.0098781604,
0.0343837067,
0.0175066702,
0.0165910572,
-0.0080877692,
0.0092964694,
-0.0149598038,
-0.0353522375,
-0.0295684393,
0.0326588117,
0.0063745813,
0.0217928439,
-0.0137498081,
0.0117455004,
0.0036438808,
-0.0109111173,
-0.0578384809,
0.0023648387,
0.0202995464,
0.0180715341,
0.0201867688,
0.0047135106,
-0.0302251671,
-0.0252312571,
-0.0422853455,
-0.0226267241,
0.0316849314,
-0.0074864766,
-0.0299153905,
-0.0144953532,
0.0564892553,
-0.033208359,
0.0188447963,
-0.015286345,
0.0071619474,
-0.0117387166,
-0.075677596,
0.0066716522,
0.0730658993,
-0.0307414941,
0.0291704237,
0.0531718172,
-0.076867193,
-0.054893218,
0.0192083493,
0.0096892845,
-0.0066485526,
-0.0042136014,
-0.0723858774,
-0.0125373239,
0.0697789863,
-0.0024379506,
-0.0080136247,
-0.032263089,
0.0543823726,
0.023331156,
0.026838908,
-0.0721414685,
-0.0158216599,
0.048509296,
0.0485306457,
-0.0295395721,
-0.0356147848,
0.058088176,
-0.0188603364,
-0.0134427911,
0.0024262427,
-0.0224721152,
-0.1003442928,
0.1018066257,
0.0452181399,
0.0261783991,
0.0072703301,
-0.0184085853,
-0.0376627669,
-0.0283046402,
0.0409319513,
-0.0514895543,
0.0175133329,
-0.0644521639,
0.0187507514,
-0.0040874765,
-0.0523104891,
-0.0190887973,
0.00273116,
-0.059349481,
-0.0222627055,
0.0220672395,
-0.0299645849,
-0.0229229443,
0.0464213118,
0.0007985488,
-0.008301192,
-0.0082640527,
0.008762382,
-0.0138594052,
0.0062881773,
0.0160882119,
0.0262454916,
0.0217808522,
-0.0335065387,
0.0229433961,
0.0463602878,
0.0430898294,
0.0092914859,
-0.025825236,
0.0581252351,
0.0280151367,
-0.0007503575,
-0.0083975783,
0.0229728874,
-0.0043657501,
-0.0636484697,
0.0025255443,
0.0783047751,
0.048035495,
0.0102959014,
-0.0055200793,
-0.0233772714,
-0.029859459,
0.0264659356,
0.0557586662,
-0.0964070782,
-0.0367277488,
0.0350383669,
-0.0091982074,
0.0052193799,
-0.0745518208,
-0.0450460166,
-0.1069226414,
0.0118249608,
0.0458957627,
-0.0249920562,
-0.0373842716,
-0.021305576,
-0.0382668488,
-0.0134163294,
-0.0199660864,
0.0204216409,
0.0157098044,
-0.0025077497,
-0.0131353438,
-0.0347072035,
0.0187229179,
0.0448898226,
0.0139730731,
0.0256639626,
0.0542517118,
-0.0039470023,
-0.0071897749,
-0.0355375707,
0.0614094771,
0.0784161761,
-0.0049087484,
-0.0203740709,
0.0053475783,
0.0295728873,
-0.0199279804,
-0.0154571887,
0.0171817038,
-0.0602863021,
-0.0260129478,
0.0297524408,
0.0802073777,
-0.0102235209,
-0.0236185305,
0.002295245,
-0.0248045828,
-0.0204103328,
0.0533626825,
0.0175144263,
-0.0100766355,
-0.0587087311,
-0.1087551937,
-0.0203595106,
-0.0478483476,
-0.0380895883,
0.051666297,
0.0368604921,
0.0274450481,
-0.0282649398,
0.0334039479,
0.0636420473,
0.0195034891,
-0.0068715308,
-0.0386322625,
0.0017820339,
0.0027170673,
-0.0311512016,
0.0334442742,
-0.0566884428,
0.0446531773,
-0.0348588116,
-0.0322369747,
-0.00978377,
-0.0485641472,
-0.0081089679,
-0.0114667425,
-0.0946002454,
-0.0284227841,
-0.0195017178,
0.0371556096,
0.030322196,
0.0061756531,
-0.0026013069,
-0.0263519194,
-0.0114774546,
0.0677211434,
-0.025863884,
-0.0031089943,
0.0107096871,
-0.0032985117,
0.0136635778,
0.0173469819,
-0.0313589387,
0.0337948389,
0.027957065,
0.0696047693,
-0.0256535523,
0.0301816948,
0.0552018955,
0.0769001767,
-0.0251949206,
0.0507185981,
0.0061721546,
-0.0098799998,
0.0204060804,
-0.0235722531,
-0.0796970278,
-0.0491356626,
-0.0031228159,
0.0228098053,
-0.0142759737,
0.0356809311,
-0.021104848,
0.045773562,
0.0362811871,
0.0242555793,
0.0109990174,
0.0289048161,
0.0043318202,
0.0858162791,
-0.0146285053,
0.005433064,
0.0629083142,
-0.0054889466,
0.0381283797,
0.0258378536,
0.0329857767,
0.022464931,
0.0077012512,
-0.0965640396,
-0.0091619585,
-0.0231144913,
-0.1101079509,
0.0338827595,
0.0009783685,
0.0737472549,
0.0025009816,
-0.0367228389,
-0.0207196455,
0.0066291858,
-0.0128338346,
0.008439756,
0.0680987015,
-0.0428472497,
0.0326902568,
0.0548399836,
0.0215669312,
-0.024361264,
0.0357670709,
0.0298866238,
0.0435624048,
0.0190655813,
-0.0008155419,
-0.0406848043,
-0.0267800391,
-0.0131259374,
0.0140524684,
0.013835649,
0.0244467054,
-0.0644944683,
-0.0722253695,
0.0305007752,
0.0214135237,
0.0259361919,
0.0102388328,
0.0505624935,
0.0261227675,
0.0279040951,
-0.0106996112,
-0.0198814664,
0.0346525572,
0.0115192235,
-0.0317856781,
0.011008258,
-6.547181743e-33,
-0.0295832362,
-0.0614301972,
0.020728305,
0.0230979435,
0.0535243414,
-0.0066048661,
-0.05138392,
-0.0036572046,
0.018014092,
-0.0212165862,
-0.0087758917,
0.0222039241,
-0.0005764095,
0.0172292069,
0.0009313693,
-0.0077915583,
0.0071409685,
0.0311896615,
-0.0386910364,
-0.0382270366,
0.0170019194,
-0.0377702974,
-0.0092093535,
-0.032796137,
0.0009543935,
0.0182209313,
-0.0092547191,
0.0532737263,
-0.0615586713,
0.0133488495,
-0.0127672357,
0.0073341341,
0.0073329466,
-0.0433423109,
-0.0050522783,
0.0009248032,
-0.0238586348,
-0.0349118523,
0.0301011521,
-0.0019990364,
-0.0539265499,
-0.0450306274,
0.0176564697,
0.0122614289,
0.0033886705,
0.0104190949,
-0.0070802667,
-0.0510285199,
0.0035602914,
0.0023766381,
0.0406224132,
0.0192062426,
-0.0438953042,
0.0073794299,
0.0447677076,
-0.0286259428,
-0.0255205724,
0.0241498929,
0.0176294185,
0.0511889718,
0.0413486473,
-0.0153809246,
0.0399112366,
-0.0201216396,
0.0102724768,
0.025370812,
0.0101379603,
-0.0223045051,
-0.0374814197,
0.0540373586,
-0.0437368825,
0.0731022507,
0.0551090539,
0.0136374515,
0.0223356634,
0.0319194868,
-0.0503345542,
-0.009579624,
0.017423328,
0.0341945179,
0.055011712,
0.0185825396,
-0.0348858349,
-0.0553833134,
-0.0500024296,
0.0262026917,
-0.0561474338,
0.0036982391,
0.0181867313,
-0.0242520887,
-0.0381375439,
-0.0784322396,
0.0065427721,
-0.0253179185,
-0.0316517502,
0.0652593225,
0.0368189365,
0.0017442838,
-0.0035233886,
0.0422911271,
-0.0343580954,
-0.0231510121,
-0.0215717293,
-0.0559115559,
0.0291477423,
0.0242199507,
-0.0026493019,
0.0427524298,
-0.0735636055,
-0.0046638618,
-0.0703261867,
0.0146576371,
0.0163461007,
-0.0058561624,
0.0318150297,
-0.0040840823,
-0.0066998033,
0.0265310872,
-0.0151002333,
-0.0552820563,
-0.0044692308,
0.0170680303,
-0.0259666573,
0.0002530277,
-0.0075756907,
-0.0126408804,
-0.0506736152,
-0.0309743192,
0.0254054051,
-0.0127572343,
-0.0100574819,
0.0030817122,
3.063e-7,
0.0096501838,
0.0459740348,
0.0209670141,
0.05502446,
0.0369419195,
0.0191333611,
-0.0503739864,
-0.0294180233,
-0.0009355384,
-0.0298747923,
-0.0143605787,
0.0963905081,
0.0394483767,
0.0448583849,
-0.0538509116,
0.0747817233,
-0.0041021071,
-0.0162968747,
-0.0334382355,
0.0154905654,
0.0378321894,
0.0640022978,
0.0354983956,
0.0119133489,
-0.0212994423,
-0.0762306079,
-0.0099438885,
-0.0198541824,
0.0015676443,
-0.0174897108,
-0.0332968384,
-0.0039865347,
-0.0152367447,
0.039108105,
0.0293426421,
-0.0196681544,
0.0003325166,
0.0597025119,
0.0101373969,
-0.0059846528,
-0.030011436,
-0.0433592796,
-0.0157325529,
0.0033543555,
0.0920317695,
-0.0130716572,
-0.0594383553,
-0.0261448659,
0.0254768487,
-0.0518169552,
-0.0255683139,
0.0061289058,
0.0022140956,
0.014644145,
-0.0181356259,
-0.0181235038,
0.0173850618,
-0.0511311144,
-0.0171647705,
-0.0231088605,
-0.0072733876,
-0.0356020667,
-0.024769932,
0.0658437237,
0.0235930011,
-0.0264367033,
-0.0082180332,
3.085603565e-34,
0.0561751649,
-0.0023739324,
0.0190503132,
0.0360597298,
0.0611450002,
-0.0038875251,
-0.0845231265,
0.0195244625,
0.0393680558,
-0.0942158923,
-0.0200928096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14594v1 | Improving Assessment of Tutoring Practices using Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-02-04T20:42:30 | 2024-02-04T20:42:30 | Zifei FeiFei Han, Jionghao Lin, Ashish Gurung, Danielle R. Thomas, Eason Chen, Conrad Borchers, Shivang Gupta, Kenneth R. Koedinger | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | One-on-one tutoring is an effective instructional method for enhancing
learning, yet its efficacy hinges on tutor competencies. Novice math tutors
often prioritize content-specific guidance, neglecting aspects such as
social-emotional learning. Social-emotional learning promotes equity and
inclusion and nurturing relationships with students, which is crucial for
holistic student development. Assessing the competencies of tutors accurately
and efficiently can drive the development of tailored tutor training programs.
However, evaluating novice tutor ability during real-time tutoring remains
challenging as it typically requires experts-in-the-loop. To address this
challenge, this preliminary study aims to harness Generative Pre-trained
Transformers (GPT), such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models, to automatically assess
tutors' ability of using social-emotional tutoring strategies. Moreover, this
study also reports on the financial dimensions and considerations of employing
these models in real-time and at scale for automated assessment. The current
study examined four prompting strategies: two basic Zero-shot prompt
strategies, Tree of Thought prompt, and Retrieval-Augmented Generator (RAG)
based prompt. The results indicate that the RAG prompt demonstrated more
accurate performance (assessed by the level of hallucination and correctness in
the generated assessment texts) and lower financial costs than the other
strategies evaluated. These findings inform the development of personalized
tutor training interventions to enhance the the educational effectiveness of
tutored learning. | [
0.0345307328,
-0.0190222729,
-0.0454783775,
-0.0018691008,
-0.0148292286,
0.0029749353,
0.0701559484,
-0.0406179242,
-0.0261926092,
-0.0278031081,
-0.0364302658,
-0.0096888309,
-0.0299206544,
-0.0274726246,
0.0325641893,
-0.0894793645,
-0.0031938115,
0.0394206755,
0.0136558041,
0.025225006,
0.0142455734,
-0.003263701,
-0.0453873985,
0.0603335537,
-0.0378530733,
-0.0510062389,
-0.0073045567,
-0.0269067176,
0.0241503697,
-0.027739428,
0.0410257392,
0.0663535669,
-0.0132811163,
0.0246881079,
0.0000021967,
-0.0482913218,
-0.0259925015,
-0.023173362,
-0.0122748213,
-0.0421541966,
0.0473299623,
0.0875280648,
0.0208211746,
0.0216380861,
-0.0821264237,
0.0098231947,
0.0300120115,
0.0169056132,
0.090436399,
0.0375977568,
0.0006944138,
-0.0093204184,
0.0230980646,
-0.0148267653,
0.0477118641,
0.0048453347,
0.0037846535,
0.0039977031,
-0.0042725089,
0.0102914916,
-0.04573505,
0.0175211113,
0.0309965573,
-0.0386515222,
0.0452519879,
-0.0060466044,
-0.0259373914,
-0.0099585801,
-0.016672736,
0.0391479954,
0.0545186512,
0.0373750664,
-0.0217103846,
-0.0088604512,
0.0616757944,
0.0933657065,
-0.049516242,
0.0229746029,
-0.0397938751,
-0.0190519616,
-0.0095325932,
0.0085654678,
-0.0488398224,
-0.0071923719,
0.0487568006,
0.0038029272,
-0.014464437,
-0.0393613875,
-0.007984261,
0.0410539433,
0.0092592537,
-0.028302636,
0.0452666692,
0.055741556,
-0.0051811058,
0.0165732205,
-0.0091661382,
-0.0840788409,
-0.0223845653,
0.0648322478,
0.0676649287,
0.059963271,
-0.0697429702,
-0.0369730294,
-0.0054175342,
0.0672025084,
0.0450549237,
0.0263837427,
-0.0210798215,
0.1036448404,
-0.054951489,
-0.033610642,
-0.0578774177,
0.0469211265,
0.0013527385,
0.022302229,
-0.0728804171,
-0.0197124537,
-0.0557091162,
0.008615558,
-0.0319636501,
0.0078193285,
-0.0208277404,
0.0411375836,
-0.0263172053,
0.0177879911,
-0.0263591893,
0.0057348702,
0.0384508148,
-0.0910949036,
-0.0005004026,
0.0048889145,
0.0206960961,
0.0289774779,
0.016828455,
0.0068044402,
-0.0339757763,
-0.052875828,
-0.0458368957,
-0.0549112745,
0.0074782041,
-0.012150717,
0.0138448374,
-0.0294551812,
-0.0135221845,
-0.0038840165,
-0.0115642855,
-0.0078610675,
0.0139443027,
0.0322993025,
0.0508223884,
0.0203938857,
0.0002143991,
0.0002938966,
0.0346555077,
0.0197657123,
-0.061114911,
0.0077134524,
0.0169729795,
0.0167727675,
0.0111097619,
-0.0371543132,
0.0890413672,
-0.0200587343,
0.01310651,
-0.0118124699,
0.0368361063,
-0.0287236609,
0.0004118744,
0.0182768665,
-0.0127153005,
0.0083861975,
-0.0457821339,
0.0482524261,
0.0103999116,
0.0467210151,
-0.0045605842,
0.071017839,
0.0538600683,
0.0330338553,
0.0484616645,
0.0191721898,
-0.065486148,
0.0142233782,
-0.0495756269,
0.0080035012,
0.0050829398,
0.0107461968,
-0.0173995383,
-0.0706570446,
-0.0022358741,
0.0137855969,
-0.0380624384,
0.0179424249,
0.0375741869,
0.004355514,
-0.0624269657,
0.0140220784,
-0.0258360617,
-0.0932362452,
0.0109004863,
-0.0715779439,
0.0312913731,
0.041184321,
0.064104788,
-0.0378036089,
-0.0296169873,
-0.0254539531,
0.0083801858,
-0.0017340466,
-0.0040966864,
-0.0012336473,
-0.0206977539,
-0.0232377779,
-0.0111019248,
-0.018589776,
0.0230555516,
0.0397488587,
0.0210414138,
0.0242076349,
0.0348410569,
0.019595176,
-0.0191031229,
0.0186562724,
-0.0233708154,
-0.0844012722,
-0.0415429994,
0.0134235118,
-0.0008920039,
0.035299316,
-0.0106554711,
0.0172614511,
-0.0056895087,
0.0337348469,
-0.0106045203,
0.0017671717,
-0.0923313051,
-0.0207436197,
0.0089896312,
-0.0281815436,
-0.0242144279,
0.0151633127,
-0.0028999697,
-0.0143521,
0.0534021072,
-0.0248172153,
0.0273340084,
-0.0405406617,
0.0238000806,
-0.038184166,
-0.0144296335,
0.0028437646,
0.0063828263,
0.0439818315,
0.0415087752,
0.0286262166,
0.0114810318,
-0.0010301071,
-0.059008956,
-0.0133739728,
-0.0480057672,
-0.0564367957,
0.0087483842,
-0.0087310923,
0.0287819561,
-0.0781321153,
-0.0049693892,
-0.0405692421,
-0.0088690994,
0.0052067218,
0.0290406123,
-0.0079230526,
-0.0596587062,
-0.0416138135,
0.0040164022,
-0.0495040677,
0.0059332019,
0.0138548352,
-0.0225831158,
-0.0131524634,
0.0081423009,
-0.0018397366,
-0.0562135391,
-0.0138596222,
-0.0324310698,
0.0170736723,
0.0997176468,
0.0415992737,
-0.0181472246,
0.0525839478,
-0.0138770314,
-0.0065130838,
-0.0150799956,
-0.042040661,
0.0388498902,
-0.0173303168,
0.0907368287,
0.0578646734,
0.0183557048,
0.0606447607,
-0.0269213673,
-0.0632857159,
-0.0494266637,
0.0227492508,
-0.0108485548,
-0.0590538867,
0.0349982828,
-0.0388948992,
-0.0032972421,
0.0314158574,
0.0147771882,
-0.0367547795,
-0.0369282775,
0.0327440947,
0.0094588315,
-0.0066319476,
-0.0290487017,
-0.0336423479,
0.0112171611,
-0.0170029234,
0.0104946373,
-0.0447344258,
0.0444608182,
0.0214842521,
-0.033855211,
-0.0255853161,
0.05244039,
0.0021973865,
0.0306020919,
-0.0221564472,
-0.016502114,
-0.077450417,
-0.0318207443,
-0.0422942005,
-0.0027703356,
0.0482377745,
-0.0609216169,
-0.0183343664,
-0.0237778369,
-0.0311998781,
-0.0140028875,
0.0355491266,
-0.0689045861,
0.016570989,
0.0139863426,
-0.0159212854,
0.0324174166,
-0.0027481618,
-0.031554874,
-0.0300040338,
0.0472959056,
0.022147255,
-0.0457566306,
-0.0477202907,
0.0066812122,
-0.0005857619,
-0.006291863,
-0.0123685524,
0.0133700753,
-0.048226051,
0.0671316907,
0.0378286615,
0.0606862009,
-0.0382979065,
-0.0084816655,
0.0037002664,
0.0244780183,
-0.0136886481,
0.0093676392,
0.0459022075,
-0.0079943053,
-0.0488045812,
0.0071454872,
0.0815730765,
0.0255979989,
-0.0424094833,
-0.0307038054,
-0.0471875258,
-0.0385934934,
-0.0232309047,
0.0168788414,
-0.0733978152,
-0.002157938,
-0.0151351951,
0.0653467849,
-0.0223391186,
-0.0435480624,
0.0094542494,
-0.0934277326,
0.0568881109,
0.0020545206,
-0.0183593836,
-0.0159890614,
0.0133722024,
-0.0050157984,
0.0374692455,
-0.0071548908,
0.0028608637,
-0.0107718902,
0.0604658723,
0.0548500158,
-0.0000767688,
-0.0261765905,
-0.0050145537,
-0.0011177481,
-0.0057567419,
0.0354199298,
0.0051159305,
-0.0049347612,
-0.0668747053,
-0.05327392,
0.0840453729,
0.0039589112,
-0.0049968609,
0.0483915359,
-0.0311398152,
0.0376848727,
-0.0167887229,
0.0510826074,
-0.0315880142,
-0.0062515512,
0.0605274588,
0.0512373745,
-0.0086473767,
0.0080601908,
-0.0185787622,
0.0324093327,
0.0562547483,
0.0372113921,
0.0195881352,
-0.0038022848,
0.0215707365,
-0.0029271161,
0.0713883489,
-0.0511636585,
-0.0326806121,
-0.0003253293,
0.0171890687,
0.034174785,
-0.0127139241,
-0.0474332869,
0.024854688,
0.0530911572,
-0.0140835736,
-0.0624624453,
-0.0015152664,
0.0270056687,
-0.0490513444,
0.0471835136,
-0.0025879384,
0.004713309,
-0.0624963939,
-0.0422971323,
0.0073879994,
-0.0518902205,
-0.0230876654,
0.0006657681,
-0.0200033858,
-0.0201117788,
0.0318510607,
0.0758770332,
0.0223106481,
-0.0237711631,
0.0578607507,
0.0208675582,
0.0013386206,
0.0277229343,
-0.0174055565,
0.0076980046,
0.0202634297,
0.0330926105,
0.0126682594,
-0.0242503323,
-0.0007840401,
0.0287967212,
0.0081631672,
0.0072333892,
0.0375627652,
-0.0009071877,
0.0125749335,
0.0390794314,
0.0498422123,
-0.0153728323,
0.0196174122,
-0.0505386032,
-0.0090618152,
-0.0416252837,
0.0057311817,
-0.0477699712,
-0.013547767,
0.0043543954,
0.0190983415,
0.0043686526,
-0.0246273261,
-0.0439711474,
0.0304595213,
-0.0377239399,
0.0384215526,
-0.0398706757,
0.0098006064,
-0.0088048093,
-0.0008338364,
-0.0003066065,
-0.0402597561,
0.0272217449,
0.0418874323,
0.0207765456,
0.1255677193,
0.0200787336,
0.0226906724,
0.0438676886,
0.021487765,
-0.0133075034,
-0.0662935972,
-0.0519167148,
0.0369962789,
-0.032797575,
0.0037364087,
-0.0051882947,
-0.0200636331,
0.0386819802,
0.0221279431,
0.0202973392,
-0.007587865,
-0.0677829981,
0.0152509054,
-0.0121445553,
0.0407517515,
-0.0211171396,
0.0291642714,
-0.0720068514,
0.0033368645,
-0.0515572764,
-0.0281243213,
-0.0185112339,
-0.0003928378,
0.0353767574,
0.0040960526,
0.0405298136,
-0.0059597502,
-0.0793117285,
-0.0132216578,
-0.0340420306,
0.0210299268,
-0.0186378285,
-0.0404296368,
0.0528389215,
0.0638802871,
-0.0561679043,
-0.0325376093,
-0.0081295976,
0.0753632411,
-0.0680263937,
-0.0155685283,
-0.0252413377,
-5.711116528e-33,
-0.0195467547,
-0.0509771891,
0.0540790074,
0.0409670994,
-0.0157960132,
-0.0029384431,
-0.0416971669,
0.0406126007,
0.0291466527,
0.0038743115,
-0.0088120243,
0.024129726,
-0.0028129723,
0.0409958772,
0.0191631615,
0.007723948,
0.0361285433,
0.0104685295,
-0.0127060404,
0.0395026058,
-0.0297335628,
0.0097756721,
0.0717857704,
-0.0372874998,
0.05794001,
-0.0392067432,
0.0071856282,
-0.0311501995,
0.0142467115,
-0.0103806574,
0.0007829664,
0.0509201251,
-0.0140398517,
-0.0610205755,
0.0135068754,
0.0345058255,
-0.0164816454,
-0.0872824937,
-0.0386090055,
0.0081762886,
-0.1027797908,
-0.0272141155,
-0.0191780124,
-0.000945173,
-0.0503287427,
-0.0020026807,
0.0554764085,
0.0237662792,
0.0434680022,
-0.0114643481,
-0.0356289372,
-0.0032437702,
-0.0473695658,
-0.0714624897,
-0.0236452036,
0.0850894451,
0.0037142348,
-0.0067167771,
-0.0393368229,
0.044570446,
0.0716171712,
-0.0020530368,
0.0330862701,
-0.0005038007,
-0.0159980766,
0.0090162847,
0.0339838751,
0.0092764096,
-0.0233165454,
-0.0205015074,
0.0451123603,
0.0140343485,
0.0584606677,
0.0274660159,
0.026964331,
0.0046655922,
-0.0090326359,
0.088318795,
0.0519744791,
0.0175828487,
-0.0061634257,
-0.0442479514,
-0.0233102087,
-0.005422859,
-0.0267953835,
-0.0347216502,
0.0073733656,
-0.0417239182,
0.0615214743,
-0.0205417573,
0.0182573292,
-0.0070120017,
0.001855485,
-0.0039163195,
0.0368952155,
-0.0016455377,
-0.0645692199,
0.0299972873,
-0.0347752385,
-0.0188395027,
-0.0269446168,
-0.0252618566,
0.0366385281,
-0.0043619233,
0.0125678722,
-0.0062120324,
-0.0216702279,
0.0310124271,
-0.014847937,
-0.0082220118,
-0.0257146787,
0.0514076911,
0.0508756116,
-0.0462677032,
0.0073902942,
0.0341529138,
-0.019468721,
0.0403304175,
0.00278699,
-0.0017424916,
-0.0437776111,
-0.0081980806,
-0.0222033486,
-0.0229208097,
-0.0110072028,
0.0098762065,
-0.0123516098,
-0.0180599187,
-0.0138359275,
-0.0329451151,
-0.003559042,
-0.0333218202,
2.98e-7,
-0.0147848334,
0.0372047983,
0.0283091925,
-0.0446358435,
-0.0280022193,
0.0176185928,
0.0278366376,
-0.0002635935,
0.0841394588,
0.0069674398,
0.0349016599,
0.0150286723,
0.0371337608,
0.0243003145,
-0.0489483513,
-0.0463959724,
-0.0339195393,
0.0054888483,
-0.0063944347,
0.0396014266,
0.1141765863,
-0.0357176624,
0.0056100427,
-0.0019653356,
-0.0054649366,
-0.0053253374,
0.0335955732,
0.0169415325,
0.0116200419,
0.0150666144,
0.0498700738,
-0.0115946392,
0.032262262,
0.0361840613,
0.0067321262,
0.0457532518,
0.0009442265,
0.0158443507,
0.0050560948,
0.004299806,
0.0225286372,
0.0425317548,
-0.016590355,
-0.0191322528,
-0.0106102461,
-0.0812548175,
0.0131025193,
0.071823597,
-0.0823245198,
-0.0234917998,
0.0096403761,
-0.0147698401,
-0.0214227829,
0.0343136005,
0.001528092,
-0.0196448229,
0.0147639271,
-0.0050442163,
0.0074569276,
0.0145496139,
-0.047788348,
-0.0285974331,
-0.0473058447,
-0.0055250502,
-0.025447391,
-0.0299940556,
-0.0043685148,
2.289774145e-34,
0.0001079421,
0.0043877293,
0.0605375543,
0.0054100649,
0.0136326291,
0.0331488661,
-0.0455691367,
0.0470245332,
0.0466571935,
-0.024138324,
-0.0480633005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02591v1 | On the performance of phonetic algorithms in microtext normalization | 2024-02-04T19:54:44 | 2024-02-04T19:54:44 | Yerai Doval, Manuel Vilares, Jesús Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | User-generated content published on microblogging social networks constitutes
a priceless source of information. However, microtexts usually deviate from the
standard lexical and grammatical rules of the language, thus making its
processing by traditional intelligent systems very difficult. As an answer,
microtext normalization consists in transforming those non-standard microtexts
into standard well-written texts as a preprocessing step, allowing traditional
approaches to continue with their usual processing. Given the importance of
phonetic phenomena in non-standard text formation, an essential element of the
knowledge base of a normalizer would be the phonetic rules that encode these
phenomena, which can be found in the so-called phonetic algorithms.
In this work we experiment with a wide range of phonetic algorithms for the
English language. The aim of this study is to determine the best phonetic
algorithms within the context of candidate generation for microtext
normalization. In other words, we intend to find those algorithms that taking
as input non-standard terms to be normalized allow us to obtain as output the
smallest possible sets of normalization candidates which still contain the
corresponding target standard words. As it will be stated, the choice of the
phonetic algorithm will depend heavily on the capabilities of the candidate
selection mechanism which we usually find at the end of a microtext
normalization pipeline. The faster it can make the right choices among big
enough sets of candidates, the more we can sacrifice on the precision of the
phonetic algorithms in favour of coverage in order to increase the overall
performance of the normalization system.
KEYWORDS: microtext normalization; phonetic algorithm; fuzzy matching;
Twitter; texting | [
0.0303239953,
-0.0190093387,
-0.0038439285,
-0.0049597146,
-0.0783245042,
-0.0081770523,
0.020914603,
0.0316195004,
-0.0337431245,
-0.0134983407,
0.0448016003,
-0.0361956544,
0.0633344576,
-0.0092877885,
0.0141024347,
-0.0414986238,
0.0076615438,
-0.015478543,
0.0067832698,
-0.0436493233,
0.0791299939,
0.0148614589,
0.0110668046,
0.0318717286,
-0.0146616315,
0.0352329873,
0.0319768004,
-0.0137874661,
-0.0027055957,
0.0299507044,
-0.0280609466,
0.0236942004,
-0.050910674,
0.0413939059,
0.0000015507,
-0.0354996324,
-0.0531352237,
-0.0269829184,
0.0523701794,
-0.0133352401,
0.0599593073,
-0.0181235019,
-0.0476405583,
0.0791786537,
0.0113873491,
0.000117265,
0.1019893363,
-0.0019885488,
0.0156765785,
0.0526432209,
-0.0405718647,
-0.0808925629,
-0.0066502276,
0.0206578113,
-0.0081811054,
-0.0069774729,
0.0132221077,
-0.0244469214,
0.0008522166,
-0.0195324346,
0.0322345681,
0.0422292911,
-0.0434262715,
-0.02732265,
0.0099874474,
-0.0120071573,
0.0092526954,
-0.0321142338,
0.0092472024,
0.0238643009,
-0.0598113574,
-0.0525882505,
0.031931974,
0.0252841096,
-0.0230511539,
0.0085444925,
0.0080895601,
-0.0235956982,
-0.0369508304,
0.0304537918,
0.0202333108,
0.0143907275,
0.0089281946,
0.024575334,
-0.0184266753,
0.0378005467,
0.017689595,
-0.0412863195,
-0.025245104,
-0.010288652,
0.0230191872,
-0.0098603731,
0.0948217213,
0.0307129044,
0.0226039514,
-0.008192746,
-0.0184838343,
-0.0322871283,
0.0124933226,
-0.012953938,
-0.0229880624,
0.0173508637,
0.076678507,
-0.0211737026,
-0.0114287371,
-0.019903101,
0.0045230892,
-0.0299202334,
-0.0480372012,
-0.0316694602,
-0.0351756588,
0.0143314162,
-0.0912657306,
0.0351205319,
0.0171115715,
0.0013464474,
-0.0534915179,
-0.0156331677,
0.0112242308,
-0.0114123318,
-0.0045401119,
0.0027568394,
-0.0044095372,
-0.0209334735,
0.0386749171,
0.0424766056,
-0.0507857986,
0.0163672157,
-0.0591038838,
0.0141793499,
0.048781395,
0.0220190119,
0.0913421959,
0.0256839152,
-0.0055815401,
0.0140337748,
-0.0011134879,
-0.0131972004,
-0.0536013171,
-0.0280305073,
-0.0301380642,
0.0175354723,
-0.0540845543,
-0.0642678589,
-0.0243501067,
-0.0160649866,
0.007129286,
0.0073034749,
-0.0164939612,
0.0127399247,
-0.0115383714,
0.0532138087,
-0.0560500361,
0.0250402521,
0.0653311461,
-0.0164516345,
0.0344525874,
0.0416225791,
0.0642354339,
0.02405487,
0.0476726517,
-0.0514165685,
0.0081918212,
0.0621994957,
0.0075414418,
-0.0133973788,
-0.0017171117,
-0.0637382343,
-0.053081207,
0.0468477719,
0.0010250284,
0.1127894595,
0.003128395,
-0.0048166313,
0.0231947489,
0.0924061611,
0.0728846863,
0.02032369,
0.0208187401,
0.0166641083,
0.0269183032,
0.0138811963,
0.0416932292,
-0.0373619236,
-0.0494411141,
0.0008750166,
0.0298943035,
0.0414939187,
-0.0366023965,
0.008056541,
0.0117952637,
-0.0136269331,
-0.0081962226,
-0.0468493588,
0.0244908407,
-0.0048606624,
0.0126164863,
0.02507676,
-0.0205758326,
-0.0278766379,
0.0442170762,
-0.01415502,
-0.0029513189,
0.0700955763,
0.0538523383,
-0.0061608967,
0.0128315436,
-0.0106088985,
-0.0758705214,
0.0375049822,
-0.029709572,
-0.0414302796,
-0.0243478753,
-0.0684822649,
0.0159326624,
0.115616098,
-0.0125512984,
-0.0077052545,
-0.0006690734,
0.0395396464,
0.022743715,
-0.006561527,
-0.0686990544,
0.002456574,
0.0242267195,
-0.0337304212,
0.0207116101,
0.017609572,
-0.0110181002,
0.0828026161,
0.0117974915,
0.0001178807,
-0.0121582653,
-0.0304039307,
0.0255683996,
0.0170706231,
-0.0031429632,
-0.030722687,
0.0731731802,
-0.0585419312,
0.0186909232,
0.0240729321,
0.0138575239,
-0.0665988773,
0.0167409461,
-0.0428327397,
0.0080822567,
-0.0480751023,
0.0573464334,
-0.0590053052,
-0.0192446671,
-0.0023938494,
-0.0359262675,
0.0150859188,
0.0163842943,
-0.0086564422,
-0.0048790779,
0.0340232849,
-0.0322579034,
-0.0374495089,
0.0332089029,
-0.0298913121,
0.0639656708,
0.0248826146,
-0.0181745514,
-0.0259774458,
-0.0274929032,
-0.043052122,
-0.023041172,
0.0052271229,
0.0405528508,
0.0198978111,
0.0745978504,
0.0393550247,
-0.0084608383,
-0.0363166928,
0.0120984418,
0.0026407589,
0.0148088634,
0.05241061,
-0.0310207121,
-0.0017827688,
-0.0249502119,
-0.0139725395,
-0.0050185728,
0.0088607268,
0.018646542,
-0.023558259,
-0.0407196134,
0.0101673687,
-0.0266883001,
0.0110785132,
0.061852362,
-0.0753685385,
-0.0089226188,
-0.0041448381,
0.0407007337,
-0.0183599684,
0.0072786068,
-0.0379441977,
-0.0075488775,
0.0190013666,
0.0046075135,
-0.0544713922,
0.0143459607,
0.0323945843,
-0.0275254045,
-0.0455841348,
-0.0166006293,
0.0597827956,
0.0028257361,
0.0145609146,
-0.0647967607,
0.0241956338,
-0.0512232669,
-0.0142739043,
-0.0151718901,
-0.0072662821,
-0.0456631482,
0.0214656647,
-0.0217752066,
-0.0415005684,
0.0439709201,
-0.0266468115,
0.0021699734,
-0.0705728158,
-0.0404055715,
-0.0063723065,
-0.0048844102,
-0.0405034423,
0.061310146,
-0.0190116428,
-0.0444504805,
0.0246433932,
0.0032239105,
0.0536108762,
-0.044962354,
0.0008881918,
0.041340448,
0.0206485987,
-0.0106039094,
-0.0186650045,
0.021092454,
-0.0521235019,
-0.0352843851,
0.0286213588,
0.0805956423,
-0.0375311486,
-0.000859344,
0.0934379697,
0.0066384394,
0.0143654216,
0.0047210949,
0.0269920621,
0.0171603952,
0.0878775418,
-0.0151913399,
-0.0086554959,
-0.0455704778,
0.048485294,
0.0461515263,
-0.0143339196,
0.0869309232,
-0.0262573082,
-0.0175419282,
-0.0074534919,
0.0107029779,
-0.0540654138,
0.0120970467,
-0.0144030899,
0.030596992,
0.0113835586,
0.0335647166,
0.1203389689,
0.038398698,
-0.0206822008,
-0.0154037895,
0.0295391791,
-0.0022002803,
-0.0429187529,
-0.0145941759,
-0.0865752026,
0.0077942526,
0.0096025746,
0.0453064218,
-0.0196596682,
-0.032324411,
0.0026532502,
-0.0567225441,
-0.0279890765,
0.0439963043,
-0.0451508351,
-0.0251498837,
-0.0066300235,
0.011062067,
-0.0200783052,
0.02264704,
0.0342079401,
-0.0063159973,
-0.0021652237,
0.0260062516,
-0.0397843793,
-0.0573788621,
-0.0319627188,
-0.0750240311,
0.0623445548,
-0.0051084799,
0.0477811396,
-0.0245208815,
-0.000150739,
-0.0286890231,
-0.0275129825,
-0.0156529583,
-0.0275309552,
0.0199233666,
0.0214671735,
-0.0118296742,
-0.0597500205,
-0.0136238979,
0.0053268536,
0.0244908743,
-0.0071890485,
0.0312425066,
0.0141816484,
-0.0204786286,
0.0147313792,
0.0278174561,
0.0089439629,
0.0380655527,
0.0006440811,
-0.0585204735,
-0.0368384309,
-0.0402138233,
-0.0090270238,
-0.0664791018,
-0.0408547856,
-0.010487291,
0.0079751424,
-0.1061970294,
-0.0747172534,
-0.0392043963,
0.0291035157,
0.0701884255,
0.0221374631,
0.0101315062,
0.0799827054,
-0.0094326185,
-0.0084532816,
-0.0657222718,
-0.0034912298,
0.0207628887,
-0.0333713442,
0.0343361683,
0.0325685553,
-0.0196344834,
0.0278850701,
0.0008498746,
-0.0265227128,
-0.0693221465,
0.044509314,
-0.0524352491,
0.0290156696,
0.0005254795,
-0.0644020066,
-0.0987512171,
0.0519037247,
0.0437496528,
-0.0191987492,
-0.0080569442,
0.0431072004,
0.0519587845,
-0.0102568427,
0.034832336,
-0.0034266715,
0.0285617821,
-0.044112362,
-0.011995404,
-0.0251295883,
-0.0494198985,
0.0074839387,
0.0475619547,
-0.0259544998,
-0.0519262999,
-0.0034243381,
-0.0167951789,
-0.0376096629,
0.0217559859,
0.0134196915,
0.0100798858,
0.0075727794,
0.0580373146,
0.0319249071,
-0.0201311409,
-0.05603569,
-0.0235543828,
-0.0410038568,
-0.0123752607,
0.0381287076,
-0.0308050048,
0.065103218,
0.0022899476,
0.0058161332,
0.0082811872,
0.0533752479,
-0.0124413231,
-0.009791472,
-0.0297593717,
-0.074300684,
-0.0031882832,
0.0177161098,
-0.0310580749,
0.0319934301,
-0.0164306108,
0.0446176231,
-0.0182438418,
0.0030724336,
0.094073534,
-0.0095384214,
0.0661014691,
0.0098267114,
0.0223696195,
-0.004348279,
-0.0307776611,
-0.0343252793,
0.0351896137,
-0.0332695916,
-0.0077298693,
-0.0175994001,
0.0141466614,
0.0500723422,
-0.0512072258,
0.0170110408,
0.0148684429,
-0.0285162292,
-0.0160789881,
0.0294768419,
-0.0586085171,
0.0567335039,
-0.0406080969,
-0.0344520137,
-0.0432920642,
-0.039997723,
0.0466539189,
-0.0243794806,
0.0047164545,
0.0086630667,
0.0010869073,
0.0050676186,
0.0140855145,
0.0605991445,
-0.0075938092,
-0.0189903732,
-0.0061153835,
-0.0399014913,
0.0181159526,
-5.811616887e-33,
0.028779868,
-0.0433986597,
-0.0322450399,
0.0021843982,
0.0084934421,
-0.0210719444,
-0.0097628105,
-0.0015127157,
-0.0162719656,
-0.009250287,
-0.009891483,
-0.0023019263,
0.0312473308,
-0.0196208041,
0.0040408638,
0.0339922719,
0.0255173799,
-0.0440278016,
-0.0007360984,
0.0041588722,
0.0239159651,
0.0246344823,
0.0157301258,
-0.0701795369,
-0.0138843302,
-0.0022318207,
-0.0485310778,
0.0207068548,
0.0653571635,
0.0333687924,
-0.0151344603,
0.078201212,
0.0266265869,
0.0180406906,
0.010302484,
0.0446455143,
-0.0729940161,
-0.0370261893,
0.0377715416,
0.0202873796,
-0.0089684203,
-0.0354673266,
0.0415029675,
-0.0250022635,
-0.0543041117,
0.0511398129,
-0.0110811442,
-0.0046567656,
0.0450063683,
-0.0106792692,
-0.0342937522,
0.0544916652,
0.0116819395,
0.0019698243,
0.1080912277,
-0.0224662833,
-0.0140449246,
-0.0192587655,
-0.0121901641,
0.0571393706,
0.0305005535,
0.0511736088,
0.0165566951,
-0.0006544404,
-0.0327240601,
-0.0324388221,
0.0792687908,
-0.0023081067,
0.0353052914,
-0.0184439328,
0.0188816506,
-0.0151769854,
0.0424175747,
0.0547983237,
0.0356926806,
-0.0434529372,
0.0063176551,
0.0257323366,
0.0242571309,
0.0033977462,
-0.0427554809,
-0.0010818164,
-0.0320275463,
-0.0309989173,
-0.0150756007,
-0.0522567481,
-0.0384819135,
-0.0047825128,
-0.0252867583,
-0.0083202608,
-0.0221909434,
0.062557444,
0.0155001506,
-0.0298195109,
0.0162892882,
-0.015561169,
0.025527969,
0.0360177457,
-0.0202451311,
0.0266965963,
-0.0392385311,
-0.0574405603,
0.0485751927,
0.0104325172,
-0.0237032697,
0.0069008772,
-0.0393940508,
0.025424201,
-0.0588709936,
0.0028289875,
-0.0024589824,
-0.0003313445,
-0.0027173171,
-0.0152842803,
-0.0064498289,
-0.018619813,
0.0171888433,
-0.0523448065,
0.0806339756,
-0.0150477756,
0.005037732,
-0.0084310919,
0.0076582073,
-0.0099638477,
-0.0274188183,
0.0381210968,
0.0056215646,
0.0207366087,
-0.0010985131,
0.0140002668,
-0.0204953756,
-0.0099858651,
2.455e-7,
0.0429050811,
0.0601993948,
0.0748562291,
-0.018884765,
0.0321926139,
-0.0124935564,
0.0135652972,
-0.0009790462,
-0.0336962156,
0.0567389242,
0.0623522103,
-0.0541710444,
0.0613617077,
0.0259874333,
-0.0678635985,
0.0098233176,
-0.0341669992,
-0.0178121533,
-0.0175915733,
0.076016739,
0.0091839433,
0.0363801084,
-0.0047620973,
-0.0414233319,
0.0012810458,
-0.0976523235,
-0.0184136536,
0.0054613696,
0.0283989795,
0.0002211814,
0.0538144782,
-0.001098622,
-0.0016288918,
-0.0040771379,
-0.0055227862,
0.0298210289,
0.026848793,
0.023113871,
-0.0388901345,
0.0426645502,
0.0047897371,
-0.0560826324,
-0.0074691349,
-0.0687064677,
0.0412501022,
0.0317271203,
-0.0417714715,
-0.0200769734,
0.0082339337,
-0.0130079892,
-0.0197375156,
-0.0153762419,
-0.0571417101,
-0.0003175243,
0.0128878923,
0.0231214743,
-0.0304926336,
-0.0122111095,
-0.0202195644,
0.0217998642,
0.0063552065,
-0.0547560938,
-0.0116154989,
-0.0026463205,
0.0343293808,
-0.0292142257,
0.0612782724,
1.785471571e-34,
0.0320781656,
-0.0571224205,
-0.0130679598,
0.0135690747,
-0.0374005064,
0.0079358537,
-0.0035604937,
0.0184304882,
0.0041686092,
-0.0566158295,
-0.0140385218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02572v1 | A Quantitative Discourse Analysis of Asian Workers in the US Historical Newspapers | 2024-02-04T17:32:52 | 2024-02-04T17:32:52 | Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Warning: This paper contains examples of offensive language targetting
marginalized population. The digitization of historical texts invites
researchers to explore the large-scale corpus of historical texts with
computational methods. In this study, we present computational text analysis on
a relatively understudied topic of how Asian workers are represented in
historical newspapers in the United States. We found that the word "coolie" was
semantically different in some States (e.g., Massachusetts, Rhode Island,
Wyoming, Oklahoma, and Arkansas) with the different discourses around coolie.
We also found that then-Confederate newspapers and then-Union newspapers formed
distinctive discourses by measuring over-represented words. Newspapers from
then-Confederate States associated coolie with slavery-related words. In
addition, we found Asians were perceived to be inferior to European immigrants
and subjected to the target of racism. This study contributes to supplementing
the qualitative analysis of racism in the United States with quantitative
discourse analysis. | [
0.0206610803,
0.0975067988,
-0.014950511,
-0.0033213622,
0.0057536918,
0.0513871945,
0.0583534949,
0.0081111277,
-0.0103656724,
-0.073249802,
0.0087301023,
0.0173571873,
0.0671453029,
-0.0807560831,
-0.0330812521,
-0.0068514035,
0.0039457227,
0.0828412101,
0.0430650339,
-0.0178858321,
-0.0025717665,
0.0318496078,
0.0062166345,
0.0410379693,
-0.0538394451,
-0.0060746539,
0.0451295301,
-0.0227859281,
0.0053519583,
-0.0350638703,
0.0028670402,
0.0192121807,
0.005365876,
0.0200298242,
0.0000016901,
-0.0175559726,
0.0069052535,
-0.0131068369,
0.0308854524,
-0.0059675495,
0.0837781057,
-0.0017382146,
-0.0155020095,
0.014544934,
-0.0309659634,
-0.0144125801,
0.0326085389,
0.0335821211,
0.0353193097,
0.0096659977,
-0.0035471523,
-0.0187504794,
-0.0343284346,
0.0218285378,
-0.0357850417,
0.0398402959,
0.0459646583,
0.0028522355,
-0.0306500942,
-0.0713965222,
-0.0231622607,
0.0203217175,
0.0011561669,
0.0274142027,
-0.027005434,
-0.0057307421,
-0.0317820236,
0.0430200845,
0.0172112025,
-0.0040821536,
0.0444755703,
0.0096202949,
0.0064360448,
0.0504891574,
-0.045642551,
0.007778279,
0.0161846485,
0.0149635393,
-0.0274260975,
-0.0002610508,
-0.0056673475,
-0.0353045575,
0.0105400952,
0.055134844,
0.0195525568,
0.1018534005,
-0.0090058353,
-0.0017337499,
-0.0219199657,
-0.0125909075,
-0.0106309699,
-0.0301420689,
0.0523399375,
0.0309494678,
-0.0352574997,
0.0418594107,
0.0278651137,
-0.0665811747,
-0.003431418,
-0.0758236945,
0.0062660305,
0.0193203129,
-0.0251952801,
-0.0339068584,
0.059830334,
0.0201372113,
0.0123891924,
-0.00758914,
0.013842999,
-0.0029762392,
-0.0237160418,
-0.0226709116,
-0.0029565073,
-0.0034937004,
0.0121675115,
0.0162148383,
-0.0448416322,
-0.038483195,
-0.0294741038,
-0.005045881,
-0.0262368154,
0.0059564132,
-0.0415926948,
0.0301127285,
-0.0412596278,
-0.0082081771,
-0.0766522959,
0.0273611657,
-0.0638762861,
-0.0162161309,
0.0513095334,
0.0168010984,
-0.0219372381,
-0.028135756,
-0.0185178518,
-0.0223308206,
-0.0131603219,
0.018095063,
-0.0381199867,
-0.0076538934,
-0.0264048465,
-0.0299237762,
-0.0325003825,
-0.0535912551,
-0.0213680044,
0.0180793758,
0.0198408794,
-0.0764085427,
0.0135317892,
0.0151511738,
-0.0302846152,
0.0390483849,
0.0277567543,
0.0055476278,
0.0924752727,
0.0236864965,
0.0169996936,
0.03989169,
0.0691247731,
-0.0015208353,
0.0423521586,
-0.0088741928,
-0.0109724598,
0.0075458498,
-0.0331398062,
0.0108179487,
-0.0662445873,
0.0157715213,
-0.0372286402,
-0.0143316574,
-0.0004228915,
0.0546775311,
0.0227956641,
-0.0107595297,
-0.0140499873,
0.1321869493,
-0.0740731061,
0.0118315332,
0.0419752784,
0.0498905703,
-0.052307792,
-0.002388479,
-0.0151370931,
-0.0617051423,
-0.0012034208,
-0.0750800893,
0.0122626284,
0.0337471627,
-0.0256247707,
-0.0225784387,
-0.0277603641,
0.0141025325,
0.057086274,
-0.0462568775,
0.0315213539,
0.0048750755,
0.0092922002,
0.0086714504,
0.0612983443,
-0.0074939588,
-0.0378393047,
-0.0136755304,
-0.0133295711,
0.060754206,
0.0089573069,
0.0096051386,
0.0931263939,
-0.0212945007,
0.0410932489,
0.0850063935,
0.0096397474,
-0.0035323966,
-0.0161637031,
-0.0158381872,
0.000401741,
0.0370398723,
0.037062861,
0.0354395285,
0.048184596,
0.0580270961,
0.0137123028,
0.0649400502,
-0.0466158092,
0.0102602169,
0.0216129366,
-0.0532636754,
-0.0182735622,
-0.0031498999,
0.0361808725,
0.0167606398,
-0.0316165201,
-0.0347398967,
-0.0139195379,
-0.0006249906,
-0.0414594859,
0.081733197,
-0.0377458073,
0.0595272109,
-0.0042097638,
-0.0659250617,
-0.0122336503,
0.0026746164,
0.0309397131,
0.0080972901,
0.0743155777,
0.0008998537,
-0.0096078198,
-0.0209126733,
0.009809861,
-0.0508379079,
0.0101572154,
-0.0177748501,
0.050293684,
-0.0114246327,
0.0232446883,
0.048481524,
-0.0699205697,
0.0420345552,
0.0178345516,
-0.0547571741,
0.0221147407,
-0.0173604246,
0.043475125,
-0.0280880481,
-0.0561821572,
-0.0049563772,
0.0258434545,
-0.0715182647,
0.009468006,
0.0042151036,
-0.0431034602,
-0.0028615983,
-0.0036135339,
-0.0240701381,
-0.0007394485,
0.0497796349,
-0.0360393301,
0.0147326831,
0.0342836492,
0.0051620672,
-0.0303439163,
0.0279326178,
-0.0105795758,
-0.0229506511,
-0.0548282154,
0.0381655023,
-0.0131875938,
-0.0328646563,
-0.0114681441,
-0.0104092592,
-0.0444913395,
-0.0046710609,
-0.0047536995,
-0.0395743474,
0.0564119928,
0.0498836488,
-0.0134730833,
0.03886595,
0.0458162315,
0.1059072018,
0.0313723385,
-0.0763622522,
0.0072749606,
-0.0159990285,
-0.0150850331,
0.0245154873,
0.0142163541,
-0.0665567592,
-0.024148386,
0.05592544,
0.0533701479,
0.0043993457,
-0.0373355374,
0.0397740789,
-0.1103476286,
-0.0329397283,
-0.011765237,
-0.049490232,
-0.0562910885,
0.0171614811,
-0.0193846356,
-0.0130424965,
-0.0015315345,
0.0261051226,
0.0604703128,
-0.0332064331,
0.0092696147,
0.008038966,
0.0774575993,
-0.0153995538,
0.0298714042,
-0.0291835088,
-0.0576118641,
0.00068687,
-0.0115582002,
0.0235917661,
-0.0525698252,
0.0355736613,
-0.0243121982,
-0.0061547961,
0.0190978162,
-0.0002998408,
-0.0173179843,
-0.0761398822,
-0.0478614606,
-0.0166253243,
0.0099094082,
-0.0184591655,
-0.0270178989,
0.0447783433,
0.0264003742,
-0.022188222,
-0.0106554208,
0.0299117323,
0.0070144236,
-0.0158737469,
-0.0070962124,
0.0163991321,
0.0183693785,
0.0412458777,
0.0022946629,
0.0285267923,
-0.0097361226,
0.0225931704,
0.0295286607,
-0.0056484416,
0.0122515205,
-0.0255678669,
0.012448323,
-0.0253706202,
0.0477167815,
-0.0155279832,
0.0398610905,
0.0668880567,
0.0384016,
-0.0129712289,
0.0109140389,
-0.0052032475,
-0.02866151,
0.0197141655,
0.0068406076,
-0.0921802744,
0.0629863814,
0.0092470292,
0.0169291198,
-0.0905591622,
-0.0461208299,
0.0010324917,
-0.0827013627,
-0.0051513016,
-0.0182207525,
0.0233071595,
0.0264720153,
-0.0235425495,
0.0298542883,
0.0520978235,
0.0236776695,
-0.0095078442,
0.0389557518,
-0.006695901,
-0.0041529993,
-0.0353116654,
0.0071129901,
0.0220617149,
0.0163404681,
-0.0404265635,
-0.0262136795,
0.057260897,
-0.0263210777,
-0.0012945909,
0.0032582677,
-0.0290859938,
-0.0233933218,
-0.0634987876,
0.0226981845,
0.0116633037,
-0.0155010112,
-0.0248991828,
0.0077406378,
0.0246128086,
0.0185373295,
0.0462403521,
-0.0303834528,
0.0122436378,
-0.0220757034,
-0.0068844683,
0.0019442479,
0.0091138259,
0.0299403351,
0.0503680222,
-0.0447304212,
0.0381276719,
-0.0855866894,
0.039645154,
-0.0081803184,
-0.0792402551,
-0.0128548648,
-0.0230117757,
-0.0798299909,
-0.0396275185,
-0.0901503116,
-0.0064401887,
0.0422769971,
0.0671918541,
-0.0160425976,
0.0358649902,
-0.0383230709,
-0.0805540234,
-0.0015474622,
-0.0366216078,
0.0195041224,
0.054405462,
-0.0249097906,
-0.0091392249,
0.0320354924,
-0.0127499383,
-0.0218059532,
-0.0121268937,
-0.0431112088,
0.0912869126,
0.011949149,
0.0228455383,
-0.0106035378,
-0.0378628597,
-0.0298563112,
0.0347839333,
0.066883713,
-0.0107001355,
0.0237848479,
-0.0417080596,
-0.0250036065,
0.0079496205,
-0.007020168,
0.0125079928,
0.0479099192,
0.0159546901,
-0.018352177,
-0.0485649183,
0.02996815,
-0.0076568187,
-0.0222562477,
0.0076460936,
-0.0247716866,
-0.024960719,
0.0097096534,
-0.0440481193,
-0.03050928,
-0.0430238433,
0.0109070195,
-0.0154970093,
-0.0265126154,
-0.0004522141,
-0.0697100237,
-0.0192578118,
-0.0255108383,
0.1028754339,
-0.0488615185,
0.0544397607,
0.0068949601,
0.0814180002,
-0.0012850801,
-0.0019125531,
-0.0124010043,
0.0665459111,
-0.039012827,
0.0308510922,
0.0328234397,
0.0390823297,
0.0170751419,
0.010317225,
-0.003211769,
-0.0024536443,
-0.029989548,
-0.018995434,
0.0118422201,
-0.0239769537,
0.0028797092,
-0.0502365865,
0.0147302337,
0.0365900919,
-0.0199297853,
-0.0073162117,
0.0072125187,
0.042622719,
-0.0487261489,
0.0515204109,
0.0167790111,
0.0056970236,
0.023419667,
-0.009090228,
-0.0712609291,
0.0319241285,
0.1024779379,
-0.0858251229,
0.0109965559,
-0.0371082574,
0.025747437,
0.0094114309,
0.0365209095,
-0.035673663,
-0.0627375618,
-0.0283895694,
0.014317276,
-0.0089626946,
0.045601014,
-0.0304551125,
-0.0188876316,
0.0259394739,
-0.0006834298,
0.0091733718,
-0.0396796279,
0.0390054174,
-0.0662730783,
-0.019320067,
0.0351235718,
-5.730997444e-33,
-0.0275598895,
-0.1097101048,
0.0016379026,
-0.006945441,
-0.0297753252,
-0.0119109834,
-0.0459585041,
0.0175781269,
0.0162339043,
0.0063066352,
-0.0395606309,
0.0100145387,
0.012798314,
-0.0091703795,
0.0143596455,
0.011831834,
0.0098643489,
0.0062422114,
-0.0179829001,
-0.0005127229,
0.0323900767,
-0.0278661214,
0.013646503,
-0.0380362608,
0.0530808307,
0.0145283705,
-0.0431312956,
-0.0126937255,
0.0442354381,
0.0222319402,
-0.0264787097,
0.0596854314,
0.0318741128,
0.0106685963,
0.0334485918,
0.0883449093,
-0.0368531346,
-0.0107681509,
0.0301318206,
0.0332154483,
0.0762175098,
-0.0117554506,
-0.0224047359,
0.0049581132,
-0.0224888269,
0.0162245687,
0.0546549,
-0.0203074068,
0.0331119038,
0.0020480542,
-0.0347671062,
0.0177286603,
-0.0465783514,
0.0405030958,
0.0076930765,
0.0018236433,
0.0181552693,
0.0177965425,
-0.0667012632,
-0.0028165483,
-0.0161422957,
-0.0099115996,
0.0088775652,
0.0106456215,
0.0356976166,
0.0237394795,
0.0189716145,
0.0256586876,
-0.0621136278,
-0.0035101161,
0.0621824563,
-0.041693721,
-0.0414917469,
0.0470431931,
0.0498038754,
-0.105477348,
0.0332313143,
-0.0431696884,
0.0546181053,
0.0354091115,
0.0166640393,
-0.008541435,
-0.0272093099,
-0.0588782281,
-0.0311735608,
-0.0320836045,
-0.0049195113,
-0.0268443413,
0.0118978648,
-0.0147609711,
-0.0087736538,
0.013693152,
0.0261337403,
0.0002681757,
-0.0593366735,
0.0141329495,
-0.0503276773,
-0.0138566988,
0.0090830885,
0.0047609843,
-0.0472578071,
0.0343616307,
-0.0333795547,
0.0364383198,
0.030361468,
0.0123671321,
0.0028396945,
-0.0049742265,
-0.0350516923,
0.0120170135,
0.0319888107,
-0.0002899982,
-0.0305356905,
0.0158584286,
0.0239126906,
0.0677785352,
0.0050491933,
-0.0242818575,
0.0689752325,
-0.0265627075,
-0.0082010375,
-0.0175829586,
-0.0275140814,
-0.0155034028,
-0.0488402285,
-0.0291790888,
0.0416683815,
0.0879056007,
0.052437868,
-0.0619947016,
-0.007501245,
-0.0585674867,
2.381e-7,
0.0368517153,
0.0359086618,
0.0080719953,
0.044123631,
-0.0129283313,
-0.0136597296,
0.0248878002,
-0.0212060548,
0.0277383663,
-0.0016703048,
0.0104425261,
0.0229221359,
0.0245320536,
0.0478668325,
-0.0587366819,
-0.0044244179,
-0.0889581293,
0.0063628238,
-0.0316447653,
0.0456899554,
0.0017188562,
0.0067013861,
0.008387995,
-0.0040261312,
-0.0712751374,
0.0166849364,
-0.006333909,
-0.0477197617,
0.0176363029,
0.0079990393,
0.0136179626,
-0.0156676322,
-0.0018229805,
-0.0053377114,
0.0223453846,
0.0488968939,
0.0351292491,
0.0151412562,
0.0040063155,
0.0632874444,
-0.012069216,
0.009535972,
-0.0354120657,
-0.0304526873,
0.0041347812,
0.0405672714,
-0.0357900038,
-0.0477562211,
-0.0653581172,
-0.0062547862,
0.0165239703,
-0.0216873325,
-0.0259959102,
0.0013288218,
0.0057478403,
-0.0039481348,
0.0321609192,
-0.0216889195,
-0.0253474098,
-0.0348956138,
-0.0153692458,
-0.0134347593,
0.0212867353,
0.0035834671,
-0.0261947345,
0.0104845976,
0.0487437472,
1.734987417e-34,
0.02969319,
-0.0090150312,
-0.022698421,
-0.0169943683,
0.0508173741,
0.0086320909,
0.0194663145,
-0.0413020514,
0.0221408643,
-0.0138420528,
0.0063162283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02564v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02564v2 | A Truly Joint Neural Architecture for Segmentation and Parsing | 2024-02-04T16:56:08 | 2024-03-02T16:33:32 | Danit Yshaayahu Levi, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Contemporary multilingual dependency parsers can parse a diverse set of
languages, but for Morphologically Rich Languages (MRLs), performance is
attested to be lower than other languages. The key challenge is that, due to
high morphological complexity and ambiguity of the space-delimited input
tokens, the linguistic units that act as nodes in the tree are not known in
advance. Pre-neural dependency parsers for MRLs subscribed to the joint
morpho-syntactic hypothesis, stating that morphological segmentation and
syntactic parsing should be solved jointly, rather than as a pipeline where
segmentation precedes parsing. However, neural state-of-the-art parsers to date
use a strict pipeline. In this paper we introduce a joint neural architecture
where a lattice-based representation preserving all morphological ambiguity of
the input is provided to an arc-factored model, which then solves the
morphological segmentation and syntactic parsing tasks at once. Our experiments
on Hebrew, a rich and highly ambiguous MRL, demonstrate state-of-the-art
performance on parsing, tagging and segmentation of the Hebrew section of UD,
using a single model. This proposed architecture is LLM-based and language
agnostic, providing a solid foundation for MRLs to obtain further performance
improvements and bridge the gap with other languages. | [
-0.0037115321,
0.0640822574,
-0.0119434251,
0.0603952222,
-0.0441589244,
0.0159100313,
0.012726333,
-0.0088555058,
-0.0315413214,
-0.0088970959,
-0.0185172278,
-0.0637802035,
0.0180327781,
0.0004798522,
0.0238518454,
-0.0288585741,
0.0244209822,
-0.0581024736,
-0.0145018473,
0.007811869,
0.0283113942,
0.0209293589,
-0.004314919,
-0.0257777255,
-0.0689845234,
-0.0202315077,
-0.0051630661,
-0.000627122,
-0.003158737,
-0.0054806634,
-0.0260219127,
0.0063513527,
-0.0506589077,
0.0223931763,
0.0000017826,
-0.0241393242,
-0.0301208906,
-0.0089233434,
-0.0316203609,
-0.0101441685,
0.0461757518,
-0.0721778646,
-0.069943957,
-0.0350240655,
-0.0071371528,
-0.0191221777,
0.0400960818,
0.0211819094,
0.0251029581,
0.0745456591,
-0.0200266689,
-0.085427396,
0.0878422484,
-0.0135144908,
-0.0526347309,
0.0197571274,
-0.0048891949,
-0.0508209653,
-0.0205465686,
0.0058399038,
-0.0071135033,
0.0195730366,
0.0353275612,
0.0167830586,
-0.0490128696,
0.012441312,
-0.0234169643,
-0.0394048728,
0.0285992008,
-0.018961018,
-0.0616039596,
-0.0166528672,
0.0268714707,
-0.0106009329,
0.0180677269,
-0.0268612988,
-0.0299508963,
0.0699389353,
-0.029449787,
0.0540907048,
0.061707139,
-0.0303133931,
0.0228992887,
0.0022499796,
-0.0464453623,
0.0855146721,
0.0344482809,
-0.0505030006,
0.0077156103,
0.0471470356,
-0.0341899246,
-0.0161144845,
0.0687487945,
-0.0115236919,
0.0188829675,
0.015379549,
-0.0021577834,
-0.0480841137,
-0.0077873007,
-0.0477141142,
-0.0062769935,
0.0101751303,
-0.04972516,
0.0000290009,
-0.0581314154,
-0.0098375333,
0.0160362255,
0.0057663186,
-0.036785569,
-0.0009013994,
0.001217071,
-0.0011906127,
-0.0354494154,
0.0518568754,
-0.0550672598,
0.0273152161,
-0.0013322012,
0.0167936739,
0.0237412769,
0.0028293591,
0.0217906144,
-0.0289250854,
-0.0204118583,
0.0036157104,
0.0159740932,
-0.0029887033,
-0.0731800348,
-0.0409089327,
-0.0169053432,
-0.065365985,
0.0057727746,
0.0568942204,
-0.0059435666,
-0.0477331951,
-0.0024810703,
0.0681170747,
-0.0025361555,
-0.0436605476,
-0.0507564917,
0.005773935,
-0.0383899584,
-0.0049078134,
0.0468061566,
-0.0638047531,
0.0378913581,
-0.0025710673,
-0.0211342759,
0.0109540615,
-0.0212432295,
0.0273943581,
0.023243567,
0.0532146655,
0.0137000037,
-0.0558419228,
0.0062947101,
-0.0057763499,
0.0283441804,
0.0383021869,
0.0025208045,
-0.0045410949,
-0.0052108038,
0.0170334596,
-0.0317386091,
0.0362948813,
-0.0369192772,
-0.0272257831,
-0.0523369536,
-0.0531883724,
-0.0345373712,
0.017021358,
0.0340956524,
0.0563656874,
-0.0113240657,
-0.0304098874,
0.0040236223,
0.0645419657,
0.008120534,
0.0594575889,
0.0224218126,
0.0071799438,
0.0234304518,
0.048534207,
-0.0136675183,
-0.0072648311,
0.0147118382,
0.0301803276,
-0.100358516,
0.0670900047,
0.0037531746,
-0.0379444025,
0.0054468582,
-0.0241343156,
-0.0254830588,
-0.0449995026,
0.0527897328,
0.0167723056,
-0.0397117957,
0.0531040356,
0.0219634306,
-0.0249786414,
0.0174477696,
-0.020329766,
-0.0038211755,
0.0056620273,
0.0019133775,
-0.0414457284,
-0.0587913468,
0.0326546356,
-0.0357357822,
0.0575061403,
-0.0276415292,
0.0185226277,
0.0183683448,
-0.0447410382,
0.0371160507,
0.0185482595,
0.0247846209,
0.0336603709,
-0.0455530137,
-0.0024325228,
0.0113090742,
0.03410336,
0.0223449543,
0.0283804201,
0.017772248,
0.0442996584,
-0.0323763117,
-0.0014296768,
0.0114277974,
0.0168489609,
-0.0163636226,
0.0070311017,
0.0265491158,
-0.0679023564,
0.0227463059,
-0.016320521,
-0.1106498763,
-0.0434171855,
0.041944176,
0.0095885685,
-0.0372183546,
-0.027996337,
0.0047875578,
-0.0137788318,
0.0470509082,
-0.0125657208,
0.0821760371,
-0.0369859897,
0.050692644,
0.0453493558,
0.0424161106,
-0.0393263474,
0.0798875466,
0.0030219122,
0.0253068805,
-0.0076259747,
-0.0199513733,
-0.0065589999,
-0.0060033719,
-0.0418680646,
0.0149275372,
-0.0177985411,
-0.0289085917,
-0.019125687,
0.0016851494,
-0.003520719,
-0.062393479,
-0.0502174646,
-0.0289910045,
-0.0483740345,
0.071198836,
0.0021461176,
0.0333550461,
0.02222565,
-0.0064027323,
-0.0283313729,
0.0222278889,
-0.0012384928,
-0.0189645737,
0.0198768862,
-0.0142285395,
-0.0023588301,
-0.0387511663,
-0.0583229885,
-0.0193902012,
0.0434236825,
0.0342166536,
-0.0424347259,
-0.0223758221,
-0.0330309682,
-0.0029131386,
0.0534342974,
0.0218467284,
-0.0136356084,
0.0183730479,
-0.0546204522,
0.0687386096,
0.0457931906,
-0.0293137375,
-0.03828061,
-0.014846093,
-0.0655763745,
-0.0001157274,
0.0005366445,
0.029875854,
0.0560723357,
-0.0887006223,
0.012426015,
-0.0173716433,
0.0779632851,
-0.0369179919,
0.0013848428,
0.0178930722,
-0.0062292265,
-0.0501325987,
0.002904739,
0.0687916502,
-0.0007841168,
-0.0496676676,
0.0308397263,
-0.0410711281,
-0.0089534903,
0.0342589058,
-0.0380699523,
-0.0591192208,
-0.0361505598,
0.0042804703,
-0.0495698936,
0.0187076777,
0.0457465015,
-0.0063924743,
0.0050563072,
-0.0692217276,
-0.0421921946,
0.0401906818,
-0.0281171091,
0.0109215798,
0.0607810356,
-0.0465152971,
-0.0005091472,
-0.0162185244,
-0.0360171609,
-0.0101590035,
0.039847374,
-0.0040494082,
0.0334755592,
0.0433181524,
0.0014989853,
0.044338543,
0.0143538564,
-0.0580882579,
0.0650383607,
0.0270007309,
0.0065977997,
-0.0328243971,
0.0549858287,
-0.0253130775,
-0.0046196328,
0.0175894294,
0.0201001391,
0.0238839295,
0.009875454,
-0.0022885667,
-0.0253111087,
-0.0528514124,
0.0262086559,
0.0417561457,
-0.0458147116,
-0.0650935546,
-0.0315941125,
-0.0153858922,
-0.0516677871,
-0.0120329158,
0.0764276758,
0.0437219217,
-0.0251351576,
0.0020436717,
-0.0177345593,
0.0188599844,
0.0020566161,
0.0108899605,
-0.0412208624,
0.0025301729,
0.0336662531,
-0.0222020671,
0.0248519741,
-0.0228391755,
0.0639963001,
-0.084942311,
-0.0080030514,
0.0060224878,
0.0168003831,
0.0420603454,
0.0199065227,
-0.0325501412,
-0.0201324895,
-0.0043679532,
0.0113898236,
-0.0197913796,
-0.0021073718,
0.0379985869,
-0.00882765,
-0.0027548787,
-0.0193894245,
-0.0408267938,
0.0005955655,
0.0488288812,
0.0161105227,
-0.0731491819,
0.0070081064,
0.0846820399,
-0.0321100801,
0.006216269,
-0.0176026635,
-0.0010649035,
0.0416623317,
-0.0418503471,
-0.0294438954,
-0.021758683,
-0.0217669401,
-0.0098863645,
-0.0175696611,
0.0670419186,
0.014048676,
0.0535352416,
0.0482877083,
-0.0122875832,
-0.0801506266,
0.0110848276,
-0.0023848901,
-0.0062142937,
-0.0780707598,
-0.0454442985,
-0.0065423637,
-0.0663603544,
-0.0049689137,
0.0286180954,
0.0312731341,
-0.0125318104,
-0.0861059204,
-0.0682691559,
0.0227867328,
0.0275713243,
-0.0021941925,
-0.0252691302,
0.0087907864,
-0.0409019105,
-0.0107548134,
-0.0018422992,
0.0411836803,
0.0186954923,
-0.065015927,
0.0069973539,
0.024218224,
-0.003271051,
-0.009207217,
0.0089422725,
-0.0262736138,
-0.0129824011,
0.0581933707,
0.031247491,
0.0027523329,
0.03212744,
-0.0602568276,
-0.0242892299,
0.0036647858,
0.0043357979,
-0.0418024994,
0.0317703001,
0.0496050157,
0.0354188383,
-0.0167998578,
0.0226959847,
0.0422227271,
0.0395990759,
0.0076963427,
0.0199409034,
-0.0522973947,
-0.0113574145,
0.0244025812,
-0.0015166474,
0.0303808376,
0.0297177061,
0.0837901086,
-0.0447620563,
0.0155710801,
-0.0434273295,
0.0330274031,
-0.0342381224,
0.0080701094,
0.0401417837,
0.0181458127,
-0.0028345492,
0.0176781416,
0.0298924353,
0.0088718729,
-0.000710398,
0.0503208451,
0.056621477,
-0.0102084,
-0.0264587253,
0.0328000784,
0.0186847821,
-0.0201136339,
0.0096096257,
0.0337337665,
-0.0767187402,
0.0253889915,
-0.0151870847,
-0.0134870242,
-0.0354092903,
0.0181649588,
0.0152584165,
0.0070624212,
-0.0107498234,
0.0264642201,
0.0390818715,
-0.033473637,
0.0613765121,
-0.0139372787,
-0.0001053955,
-0.0089084618,
0.0051136985,
0.0005940566,
-0.0118055055,
0.0196915008,
0.0235546511,
-0.0078742364,
-0.0829081014,
0.0227464978,
0.0037996061,
-0.0039717173,
0.0109661669,
0.0087658949,
-0.015769273,
-0.0416810066,
-0.0364871025,
-0.0069548455,
-0.050260637,
0.0085260123,
-0.0507169627,
-0.0566640235,
-0.0230162963,
0.0266266484,
0.0495296493,
-0.0183666162,
0.0378111526,
0.0466291495,
0.0126169221,
-0.0536448583,
-0.0076634283,
0.0105506675,
0.0410979353,
-0.0331999548,
0.0099530024,
-5.454815046e-33,
-0.0272051934,
0.0590776354,
-0.0117069632,
-0.0182767473,
-0.0156958774,
0.0233245287,
-0.0154604372,
0.0133599201,
-0.0246954802,
-0.0117500722,
-0.0275781713,
0.0190003067,
0.0405472293,
0.0303237494,
0.0794162601,
-0.0105741788,
0.0414303094,
-0.0129579045,
0.045709379,
-0.0397096574,
0.0091439355,
0.0548435114,
0.1035016775,
0.0298282243,
-0.0068530743,
-0.0104680834,
0.0161265451,
0.0285603795,
-0.020541044,
0.0428779162,
0.0019731724,
-0.0061154058,
0.0277804136,
-0.0246680342,
-0.0117252422,
-0.0055280547,
-0.1150353774,
-0.0365104079,
0.0351633392,
0.0560385548,
-0.0494249761,
-0.0080462908,
0.0330665149,
-0.0062176795,
0.0266463254,
0.0286466852,
0.0037689824,
-0.0247476399,
0.0056205094,
-0.0069163288,
-0.0689429715,
0.0600655861,
0.0184388086,
0.0456964672,
0.1058013365,
-0.0066904728,
0.0071281549,
0.0173255559,
-0.0308792721,
-0.0554113872,
-0.0377363861,
0.0858652964,
0.0192902517,
0.0371657871,
-0.05520989,
0.0030733587,
0.0707555488,
-0.0684707761,
0.0482148379,
0.0640381649,
0.0214283634,
0.0104626184,
0.0191146955,
-0.0352193862,
0.0294767767,
0.0213944167,
-0.0443219133,
-0.0481213145,
0.0591605902,
0.0577725507,
-0.0390119217,
0.0183357131,
-0.0287389811,
-0.0155675216,
0.0290247239,
-0.0862121582,
-0.0368005559,
-0.0188248102,
0.0006967575,
-0.0064090486,
0.0077207563,
0.0905298889,
0.0171056725,
0.0136232395,
0.0042351237,
-0.0232983399,
-0.0165110733,
0.0423099846,
-0.0185875688,
0.0357392952,
-0.0393099524,
-0.0639154986,
-0.031986922,
-0.009277869,
0.0161907934,
0.0066189468,
0.0403903425,
0.0011322073,
-0.0344480164,
0.008894423,
-0.0515666641,
-0.0017378184,
0.015838623,
0.0943910182,
0.0162345339,
0.0201950446,
-0.000257234,
0.0391193777,
0.043916747,
-0.008413434,
-0.0247642398,
0.038095966,
-0.0205352213,
0.033485271,
-0.0187373459,
-0.0176200066,
0.0147380866,
0.0061571137,
0.0475574248,
-0.0446678028,
-0.0158979036,
0.0378343835,
2.623e-7,
0.0539514162,
0.0152245164,
0.0635943487,
-0.0218748804,
0.0223728213,
-0.0019165989,
-0.0154481456,
0.0128042642,
-0.0466102362,
0.0071342792,
-0.0317629501,
-0.0027484375,
0.0188459028,
0.0320913084,
-0.0996933356,
-0.0042186091,
-0.0139490953,
-0.0125181908,
-0.0457467586,
0.0099296663,
0.0479038805,
0.1187871471,
-0.028676765,
-0.0364185683,
-0.0326433554,
-0.0139928041,
0.0031319079,
0.0179896634,
0.0047356109,
0.0348054469,
0.0167868305,
-0.044283852,
-0.0185420513,
0.0213200655,
-0.0116417743,
0.0081374161,
0.0387878194,
0.0452168994,
0.0193496514,
0.022697879,
0.0698182881,
-0.0183544997,
-0.0259770099,
-0.0062180404,
0.0474550277,
-0.0181739926,
0.0019302034,
0.0539174639,
-0.0125685045,
0.0299338326,
-0.0439047255,
0.0103777163,
-0.021506181,
0.0249261614,
0.0592908002,
-0.0285762921,
-0.0429327376,
-0.0441105068,
0.0040501342,
0.0527129248,
-0.0108898953,
0.0047734356,
-0.0354411229,
0.0135168694,
0.0183285046,
-0.0004279884,
-0.0549945049,
2.571129865e-34,
0.0054983567,
-0.0029297911,
0.0100677731,
0.0465709493,
-0.0102979625,
-0.0056613744,
-0.0450416058,
0.0599921495,
-0.0571466275,
-0.0171448663,
-0.0146243069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02563v2 | Synergy-of-Thoughts: Eliciting Efficient Reasoning in Hybrid Language Models | 2024-02-04T16:45:01 | 2024-05-23T14:20:53 | Yu Shang, Yu Li, Fengli Xu, Yong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive emergent abilities in a
wide range of tasks, but still face challenges in handling complex reasoning
problems. Previous works like chain-of-thought (CoT) and tree-of-thoughts (ToT)
have predominately focused on enhancing accuracy, but overlook the rapidly
increasing token cost, which could be particularly problematic for open-ended
real-world tasks with huge solution spaces. Motivated by the dual process
theory of human cognition, we propose "Synergy of Thoughts" (SoT) to unleash
the synergistic potential of hybrid LLMs for efficient reasoning. By default,
SoT uses smaller-scale language models to generate multiple low-cost reasoning
thoughts, which resembles the parallel intuitions produced by System 1. If
these intuitions exhibit conflicts, SoT will invoke the reflective reasoning of
scaled-up language models to emulate the intervention of System 2, which will
override the intuitive thoughts and rectify the reasoning process. This
framework is model-agnostic and training-free, which can be flexibly
implemented with various off-the-shelf LLMs. Experiments on six representative
reasoning tasks show that SoT substantially reduces the token cost by
38.3%-75.1%, and simultaneously achieves state-of-the-art reasoning accuracy
and solution diversity. Notably, the average token cost reduction on open-ended
tasks reaches up to 69.1%. Code repo with all prompts will be released upon
publication. | [
0.0438566841,
0.0143945646,
-0.0196947679,
0.0565768667,
-0.0698707402,
0.0192275327,
0.0261288062,
-0.021341756,
0.0167232919,
-0.0402060859,
-0.0361490846,
-0.0294091627,
-0.0075914962,
0.0351860635,
0.0131738344,
-0.0572822355,
0.0545409061,
-0.06337253,
0.0261025187,
-0.0162630975,
-0.0033217785,
0.023626022,
-0.0463692211,
0.0546822399,
-0.0145371668,
-0.0278753396,
-0.0327816084,
-0.0093137706,
0.0380143411,
-0.0316434205,
-0.0283121485,
0.0265065357,
0.0356061496,
0.0605051965,
0.0000022449,
-0.0649259016,
-0.0031975887,
-0.0124868564,
-0.0170219764,
-0.019495409,
-0.0067084595,
0.0208135806,
0.0333914012,
0.0330062434,
-0.0364142284,
-0.0072492156,
0.0106599117,
0.0495170392,
0.0537405685,
0.044939097,
-0.0035769646,
-0.0372174829,
0.0007370908,
-0.0016354102,
0.0215863734,
-0.0206951965,
0.0014444984,
-0.0033517519,
0.0485939197,
-0.0121673308,
0.0065014218,
0.0168783851,
0.0434589274,
-0.0046643764,
-0.0060306806,
0.0566888601,
-0.0108487774,
-0.023407178,
-0.0116552906,
0.0382736772,
-0.029348297,
-0.0218941718,
-0.0098287398,
-0.0137931546,
-0.0099809505,
-0.0169243831,
-0.0473059043,
0.0411031656,
-0.0233912356,
0.0291431118,
0.0239934027,
-0.0110723935,
0.0200365372,
0.0236615241,
-0.0624004006,
0.0948524773,
-0.010363414,
-0.0384990126,
0.0417185165,
0.0004651794,
-0.0243987776,
-0.0641383901,
0.0000145954,
0.0586510748,
-0.0376937091,
0.0123989163,
0.0006254525,
-0.0441786014,
-0.0179161001,
-0.0166211277,
0.0490071885,
0.0649463832,
0.0047888546,
0.0640303195,
-0.0639714673,
0.0142046111,
-0.022119794,
0.0418833271,
-0.0323213153,
-0.0188333299,
-0.0711898804,
-0.0209401492,
-0.0220241137,
0.0730457455,
-0.0121380268,
-0.028840255,
-0.0210374799,
0.0333601125,
-0.0224853735,
0.0018176684,
0.0193692055,
0.0157294851,
0.0494633429,
-0.0565151013,
-0.0654675066,
0.0389926545,
-0.0336197391,
0.0436464511,
0.0326583497,
-0.0258122068,
-0.0125946915,
0.0056921341,
0.0000178442,
-0.0340072401,
0.0123452675,
0.0462575108,
-0.0328606516,
-0.0079812873,
-0.0477032065,
-0.0425778143,
0.0116182249,
-0.0768541992,
0.0105891107,
-0.0785402581,
0.018507015,
0.016967522,
-0.0272964779,
-0.0027310078,
0.0284767449,
0.0123408148,
-0.0372915938,
0.0889902189,
-0.0202021226,
0.0189550985,
0.0014857333,
0.0106879929,
-0.0576746538,
0.0705476254,
0.0461394116,
0.0105144586,
-0.013813911,
0.0363722667,
-0.0106372489,
0.0180999339,
-0.0002829085,
-0.0528513864,
-0.0074340985,
0.0080128647,
-0.0107142925,
0.0373977646,
-0.0130412271,
0.0600507297,
-0.0299780443,
0.0352224968,
0.0555499606,
0.0704536363,
-0.0045154835,
0.0207211599,
0.0520804897,
-0.0165689979,
0.0030127822,
-0.0300935786,
-0.0585902222,
0.0616926998,
-0.0545391999,
-0.0040880931,
-0.006767815,
0.0480122492,
-0.0374475792,
-0.0328044966,
-0.0354240686,
0.0003959555,
0.0050103641,
0.0269558374,
0.0406577624,
-0.0184608884,
-0.0231649298,
0.0608529747,
0.0027674844,
-0.0341629051,
-0.0328607373,
-0.072105296,
0.0258960724,
0.0590766408,
0.0258129276,
-0.0308192261,
-0.0100058867,
-0.0129638286,
-0.0332009904,
0.0357145481,
0.0241723526,
0.0068429923,
-0.0360045955,
-0.0547747277,
-0.014214078,
-0.0225670673,
-0.0113570467,
-0.0067268782,
-0.0106617576,
0.0008826491,
0.0003872057,
0.0177871734,
0.0242576953,
0.0113972342,
0.0029851829,
0.0354412682,
-0.0233642459,
0.0293333866,
0.0222020615,
0.007198514,
0.0148931984,
0.0372767895,
0.0128999529,
-0.0322867893,
-0.0405868553,
0.0429871604,
-0.0439361259,
-0.0566147044,
0.0368731283,
-0.0083594816,
-0.0093178982,
0.0243933164,
-0.0140627865,
-0.0488415547,
0.0252183396,
-0.0338246487,
0.0469328612,
-0.0444829911,
0.0251983088,
0.0028427201,
-0.0300707947,
-0.0172563028,
0.106669873,
-0.0180856157,
0.0247221626,
0.0261079539,
-0.0258449223,
0.0283891093,
-0.0196110066,
0.0052635581,
-0.0052201063,
-0.0076972968,
-0.0274899714,
-0.0081790695,
-0.0046237158,
-0.0661662817,
-0.0420969613,
-0.1004441828,
-0.017038146,
-0.0104144793,
0.0122039588,
0.0015171182,
0.0040077781,
0.0082829176,
0.0181842949,
-0.0339394659,
0.0450370647,
0.0423756912,
0.0353820249,
0.0260956287,
-0.01688122,
-0.0208178852,
0.0086699957,
-0.0008205171,
-0.0516199283,
0.0476413928,
0.0001816686,
-0.019246541,
-0.0409858525,
0.0392494313,
-0.0592170916,
0.0265794769,
0.0000441944,
-0.0098138964,
0.0526445545,
-0.0337157398,
0.0420003496,
0.0777218416,
-0.006143725,
-0.0240958817,
0.0655068159,
-0.0111340871,
-0.0503486432,
0.0461493731,
0.0002194094,
0.0302283335,
-0.0110206725,
0.0108223101,
-0.0502904467,
0.0583240241,
-0.0066172276,
-0.0090010976,
-0.0532826781,
0.0374550261,
0.013888251,
-0.0451724529,
-0.0309775937,
-0.0508739762,
-0.0010862665,
0.051700484,
-0.0302769039,
-0.0121613564,
0.091871269,
-0.008176852,
-0.003829502,
-0.0429054759,
0.0071696946,
-0.0341260582,
0.0929051489,
-0.008621864,
0.0092483917,
-0.0047278586,
-0.0044757714,
-0.0655037612,
0.0096810656,
-0.0020220983,
-0.0262916759,
0.0548835844,
-0.0470993742,
0.0172105841,
-0.0203988962,
-0.0634843037,
-0.065679431,
0.018165987,
-0.0639736131,
0.0324831419,
-0.0067641563,
-0.008307701,
-0.0083659841,
-0.0015128364,
0.0599090382,
0.0327540003,
0.0011796209,
-0.0260176584,
-0.0180400833,
0.013203104,
0.0176201165,
0.0168744884,
0.0563352481,
-0.0040189442,
0.0440450981,
0.0406696163,
0.0725404322,
-0.0257741865,
-0.0235430356,
0.0121458592,
0.0074958084,
-0.0026628757,
-0.0128767658,
0.0154440189,
0.0709108189,
-0.0591635667,
-0.0328544714,
0.1270309091,
0.0617853664,
-0.0393223763,
0.0021829144,
-0.0654143319,
0.0218005851,
0.0393696725,
0.0224909279,
-0.0631254911,
-0.0444925763,
0.0273201875,
-0.0338034146,
-0.0070129544,
-0.0583905652,
-0.0103547415,
-0.1160092652,
0.0145680932,
-0.0110553866,
-0.01798282,
0.0006321687,
0.0060287463,
-0.0106598921,
0.0393238366,
-0.044191245,
0.0327961557,
0.0272417497,
0.0073093353,
0.0065246443,
-0.0035279747,
0.0027572932,
0.0504466407,
-0.0216592848,
0.0115996143,
0.0354091339,
0.0038107147,
0.0405663289,
-0.1071408018,
0.0591805093,
0.0099484995,
0.026979357,
-0.0295719486,
-0.0271085892,
0.0147756739,
-0.0120070213,
-0.0202151742,
0.0510080904,
-0.0486193299,
-0.0360799171,
0.0063423081,
0.1289062798,
-0.0365161709,
-0.0165876374,
-0.0147856046,
0.006257446,
-0.0272922721,
0.068242006,
0.0132247703,
-0.0285027809,
-0.0456221104,
-0.0101063419,
-0.0613646992,
-0.031034369,
-0.0297266562,
0.0042529511,
0.0713844597,
0.0130229602,
-0.0324012525,
-0.037316706,
0.034761522,
0.0576511286,
-0.013674275,
-0.0018565106,
-0.0028347564,
0.0249009896,
-0.027829295,
0.0145589728,
-0.0418086462,
0.0410906449,
0.0033840635,
0.0135389678,
0.0001719743,
-0.0277273636,
-0.0269044209,
-0.0004713101,
-0.1023423746,
-0.0638491511,
-0.0371520706,
0.0566602908,
0.0298109502,
0.0292685553,
-0.0073318491,
-0.033875972,
0.0090568941,
0.0276181214,
-0.0507658571,
0.0001243576,
0.0221777745,
0.0328845382,
0.0386677422,
0.0530119985,
-0.0281383302,
0.008360751,
0.0345912501,
0.0574337691,
-0.0072204554,
0.0046111317,
0.0194002502,
0.0142397871,
0.0212009978,
-0.0047509279,
0.0121245338,
-0.0402703397,
0.0421301015,
-0.0249647032,
-0.0258017629,
-0.0472154692,
0.0067253923,
-0.0041007637,
-0.0018996999,
0.0162290949,
-0.0368335173,
0.0194935873,
0.0153716924,
0.0211099666,
-0.0101588154,
0.0126431882,
0.0466969945,
0.0260143131,
-0.021864865,
-0.0319080874,
-0.0093819732,
-0.018752763,
0.0192323979,
-0.0310991574,
0.1114380285,
0.0340123847,
-0.0248330794,
-0.048046276,
0.0007377918,
-0.0731321275,
-0.0916814134,
0.0389308743,
0.0320190229,
0.0504446551,
0.0358156599,
-0.0021383716,
-0.0582973734,
0.0064130174,
0.015464616,
0.023562083,
0.014503736,
-0.0502954498,
0.0165066663,
0.0246884525,
0.0067798607,
-0.0509110615,
0.0568797961,
-0.0713258013,
0.01535316,
0.0117173065,
-0.0104292501,
-0.0317500047,
-0.0350185595,
-0.0279757511,
0.0497232787,
-0.0055954359,
0.0546862781,
-0.0861353129,
-0.0610486344,
-0.0000307303,
0.0202799551,
0.0083730165,
0.0033554069,
0.0494858958,
0.0495171882,
-0.0019939227,
-0.0436456576,
0.0127778528,
0.0193663221,
0.0086900182,
-0.0179082546,
-0.0403921679,
-6.427352583e-33,
0.0054160189,
-0.0115337539,
0.0635528564,
-0.0104363943,
-0.0333819427,
-0.024603717,
-0.0388534553,
0.0206562113,
-0.023161618,
0.0077615567,
-0.0142342905,
0.0049849986,
-0.0023757182,
0.0290433392,
0.0323930383,
0.000607082,
0.0057201339,
-0.0185493659,
-0.013963745,
-0.0018310067,
0.0556781776,
0.0015066747,
0.0176440347,
-0.0261720102,
-0.0109472824,
0.019866867,
0.0080000143,
0.0586862117,
-0.0372753218,
0.0279263947,
-0.0146652879,
0.0208136141,
0.0483285934,
-0.0344495662,
0.0048719407,
0.0156526007,
-0.0454500169,
-0.0381021574,
0.0575968362,
-0.0181628969,
-0.0468226857,
-0.0186877716,
0.0178572554,
0.0027682234,
0.000597775,
-0.0266362727,
0.0087245135,
-0.0291900691,
0.0121382782,
-0.0003106278,
-0.0490561947,
-0.0264856163,
-0.0119665554,
-0.0098613976,
0.0122396611,
0.0286459476,
-0.0230906941,
0.0129382191,
-0.0718716905,
0.004673935,
-0.0020754235,
0.0113079092,
0.0836328194,
0.0213339198,
0.0042737368,
0.0536432676,
0.0184844341,
0.0019526926,
-0.0744290352,
0.0117484685,
0.0167162344,
0.0507484935,
0.072739616,
-0.0081722923,
0.0160949286,
0.0223386511,
-0.0875457898,
-0.0295418147,
0.0351944119,
0.0515380986,
0.0587061718,
0.0250369497,
0.006370577,
0.0027364595,
-0.0413314328,
0.0253079049,
-0.0589773282,
-0.0145543804,
0.0252114497,
0.004732633,
0.012132288,
-0.0137816453,
0.0396148823,
-0.0299802907,
-0.0098329391,
0.0103216739,
0.0090281237,
0.0176271386,
-0.0115632126,
0.0189017933,
-0.0561322123,
-0.0081061032,
0.0042194468,
0.04173759,
-0.0034162037,
0.0186146982,
0.0352019258,
0.0030050543,
-0.0395111479,
-0.0107085798,
-0.0965569615,
0.018814655,
-0.0095638959,
-0.011465502,
0.0316975974,
0.0338171907,
-0.0181841757,
0.0109277405,
-0.0224271975,
-0.0292204171,
-0.0324242935,
0.0226708371,
-0.0136133851,
0.0346305482,
-0.0102891251,
-0.0044689691,
-0.0448126495,
-0.0182418507,
0.0167570114,
-0.0393765606,
-0.0146469306,
0.0556593165,
2.952e-7,
0.0047416934,
0.0214479845,
-0.0223382842,
0.0196486302,
0.046070151,
0.0436559357,
-0.0114806369,
-0.0176675208,
0.0277457796,
-0.0643265098,
-0.0169825908,
0.0684037134,
0.0375330448,
0.027967345,
-0.0906007364,
-0.0296967756,
-0.0335480124,
-0.0372239091,
-0.0460629463,
0.0081798313,
0.0689154863,
0.0664832294,
0.035006281,
-0.0209404305,
0.0109512191,
-0.0088492213,
0.0595102608,
-0.0058474327,
0.0074200667,
-0.018663412,
0.0217790436,
-0.0245320126,
0.017073622,
0.0345900357,
0.0261982381,
0.0160685033,
-0.015237188,
-0.0014640449,
-0.0137079051,
-0.0138987964,
-0.0118563669,
-0.033961311,
-0.0035445401,
-0.0754887313,
0.0847519562,
-0.061987184,
-0.0208491832,
0.0106645413,
0.0211694147,
-0.018516086,
-0.0013281326,
0.0078433147,
-0.0124121848,
0.0234361626,
-0.0051494897,
-0.0064526778,
0.0170326047,
-0.1082533002,
-0.0200823564,
0.0110035697,
-0.0376708843,
-0.0324946903,
-0.0347798988,
0.0152305104,
0.042000439,
-0.0591133609,
-0.0192395821,
2.876782963e-34,
0.0153913638,
-0.0103378613,
0.0322791599,
0.0457594879,
0.0271047466,
-0.0150764063,
-0.0243189875,
0.0050776158,
0.0296437647,
-0.0939508975,
-0.0414290354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02559v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02559v1 | NavHint: Vision and Language Navigation Agent with a Hint Generator | 2024-02-04T16:23:16 | 2024-02-04T16:23:16 | Yue Zhang, Quan Guo, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing work on vision and language navigation mainly relies on
navigation-related losses to establish the connection between vision and
language modalities, neglecting aspects of helping the navigation agent build a
deep understanding of the visual environment. In our work, we provide indirect
supervision to the navigation agent through a hint generator that provides
detailed visual descriptions. The hint generator assists the navigation agent
in developing a global understanding of the visual environment. It directs the
agent's attention toward related navigation details, including the relevant
sub-instruction, potential challenges in recognition and ambiguities in
grounding, and the targeted viewpoint description. To train the hint generator,
we construct a synthetic dataset based on landmarks in the instructions and
visible and distinctive objects in the visual environment. We evaluate our
method on the R2R and R4R datasets and achieve state-of-the-art on several
metrics. The experimental results demonstrate that generating hints not only
enhances the navigation performance but also helps improve the interpretability
of the agent's actions. | [
0.0476605184,
0.0036852036,
-0.004230666,
0.0259078927,
-0.0037061851,
0.027527729,
-0.0251908135,
-0.0127026942,
0.0113484049,
-0.021860892,
0.0087862145,
-0.0001219981,
0.0206222106,
0.0176258404,
0.0224077068,
-0.0727484897,
0.0208774097,
-0.0647846013,
-0.0528282449,
0.0417640582,
-0.0013485278,
0.0090077715,
0.0029623162,
0.0554851927,
-0.0365104377,
0.0049388646,
-0.0673786998,
0.0431749262,
0.0495681129,
-0.0696044266,
-0.0001651376,
0.0053072711,
0.0736845806,
-0.0006437809,
0.0000019751,
0.0261865314,
0.0332359411,
-0.0312374886,
-0.0092105437,
-0.0651376992,
0.0217037089,
-0.043913126,
-0.0023134542,
0.0154542476,
-0.0324835591,
-0.0380514786,
0.0635554716,
0.0814882889,
0.047456298,
0.055329442,
-0.0171827152,
-0.0061400994,
-0.0254286174,
0.000697305,
0.0454840586,
-0.0217447784,
-0.0071509415,
0.026630424,
-0.0630116388,
0.0351145603,
-0.0441572443,
0.0189025849,
0.0392280184,
-0.0153789548,
0.0007199178,
0.0655794367,
-0.0037816504,
-0.0226223767,
-0.0184298549,
0.0918937102,
-0.047046639,
-0.0074815326,
-0.0101862671,
-0.0003135633,
-0.0106764678,
-0.0127162887,
0.0023169548,
0.0108658131,
-0.0506328382,
0.023669865,
0.0197317246,
-0.0142469825,
0.0030502491,
-0.0255745929,
0.0345378555,
0.0085782288,
0.0054355869,
0.0198140293,
0.0169422422,
0.0163618233,
-0.0152200675,
-0.0694335178,
-0.0008187371,
0.0378636494,
-0.029048631,
0.0459807627,
-0.0452709459,
0.0379346795,
-0.0257032681,
-0.0688299239,
0.0633524284,
0.040031217,
-0.08453729,
0.0527163111,
-0.0590665676,
0.0462693386,
-0.0103543904,
0.056596607,
-0.0258508231,
-0.0204455722,
-0.0373791754,
0.0221383255,
-0.0478295311,
-0.0090526808,
-0.03592797,
-0.027210027,
0.0033648741,
0.0334443189,
0.0127127459,
0.0334161669,
-0.0191237256,
0.0390774831,
-0.0596062578,
0.0085675688,
-0.0238417052,
-0.0077670589,
-0.0430686027,
0.0029301201,
-0.0091348579,
-0.0312048327,
-0.0069236779,
0.0385461114,
-0.0152153615,
-0.0046855742,
-0.0103789158,
0.0963772088,
-0.0240381155,
-0.0424475484,
-0.0914472118,
0.0057284678,
0.015600103,
-0.0540546626,
0.0264941119,
-0.0478712134,
0.0457089171,
-0.0174779147,
-0.0313473418,
-0.0318669863,
0.0431771167,
0.0229602512,
0.0328490473,
0.0711563826,
-0.0210856833,
-0.0245059598,
0.0027447632,
0.0244208705,
-0.0228989553,
0.0504474305,
0.0140074743,
0.0751923248,
-0.003008469,
0.0129300179,
0.0217601284,
0.0066955467,
-0.0139999921,
0.0347174481,
-0.0112669058,
0.0025723556,
-0.0039078314,
0.0259240344,
0.0228864048,
0.0472320206,
-0.0531030931,
-0.0161054805,
0.0553069264,
0.0290888436,
0.0295329317,
0.0101253465,
0.0798823535,
-0.0037612007,
-0.0150542166,
-0.0099501675,
-0.0641655475,
0.0501075014,
-0.0163546372,
-0.0185492132,
-0.0595736876,
0.0190961044,
-0.0598396286,
-0.0554006398,
0.0282628499,
0.0139664328,
0.0050931959,
-0.0007549738,
0.0509552434,
-0.0005333513,
-0.0550104529,
0.0038880119,
0.0356814787,
-0.0350495391,
0.0061582807,
-0.0106346747,
0.0158060901,
0.0677765533,
0.0171218328,
0.0093395486,
-0.0401972197,
-0.0178439729,
0.0593338348,
0.0346890353,
0.0152204856,
-0.0107389698,
0.0717044026,
-0.0588606298,
-0.0663787723,
0.0161121842,
-0.0146745201,
0.0704305544,
0.0168155171,
0.0177457482,
0.0388861448,
-0.0445687249,
-0.0223247744,
0.0496843196,
0.0618540607,
-0.0135427648,
-0.0082229665,
0.0173973832,
-0.0170504265,
0.0186250992,
-0.0006934906,
-0.0319508687,
0.031317506,
-0.0191932525,
0.030030949,
0.0202690084,
-0.0212990493,
-0.0714489371,
-0.0042186654,
-0.0713091716,
-0.0085409861,
0.0331971347,
-0.0226572882,
-0.0271726307,
-0.0131258285,
-0.0410306975,
-0.0093000075,
0.0109502794,
-0.0060689733,
0.0440784506,
0.0255070403,
-0.0005401276,
0.0684549809,
-0.01265678,
0.0008899164,
0.0312682465,
0.0048766066,
0.0160648618,
-0.038089931,
0.0234033223,
-0.0262637977,
0.0365548469,
-0.0091175186,
0.0327258781,
0.0056648511,
-0.0426910929,
-0.0018476759,
-0.0534781516,
-0.0133241201,
-0.0504171178,
-0.0118829198,
0.0120581491,
-0.0254861917,
0.0092625171,
-0.038808722,
-0.0190171134,
0.0525625348,
-0.0094106151,
-0.0138251865,
0.0128738834,
0.0155419838,
-0.0399679281,
-0.039946273,
0.0090205222,
-0.0008179188,
-0.0013437994,
0.0386743024,
-0.0404898189,
-0.1120399535,
0.0187587719,
-0.000480358,
0.0514236204,
-0.0615803301,
-0.0425549522,
0.0138226142,
-0.0196691174,
0.0034871201,
0.0601897687,
-0.0191950761,
0.0451487452,
0.0555851609,
-0.0389588512,
-0.0515441149,
0.0048347763,
-0.016117597,
0.0037687502,
-0.0493489355,
-0.0229048822,
-0.0608196929,
0.0020351533,
-0.0021208585,
0.0517816879,
-0.0579374954,
-0.0016794491,
-0.0089974031,
-0.0514193811,
-0.0241555721,
0.0578377582,
0.0002779137,
0.0457494222,
-0.0375191234,
-0.0534706265,
0.0494025499,
-0.0188304354,
-0.0260409154,
0.0045922776,
-0.0087751411,
-0.0139308777,
0.0686748698,
0.0377191864,
0.0200739726,
0.0167295132,
-0.0383240879,
-0.0353741311,
-0.0241340082,
0.0056789936,
0.0366366096,
0.0506557152,
-0.0894544125,
-0.015457239,
-0.0339675844,
0.017745506,
-0.0421483144,
0.0047007343,
0.0141204568,
0.0135062262,
0.0188773945,
-0.0216044411,
-0.0396330096,
0.0205181148,
0.0365469158,
0.0396556593,
-0.0023305493,
-0.0353405029,
-0.0146878706,
-0.0138120549,
0.0734576136,
0.0016837824,
-0.0210640859,
-0.0497604422,
0.0242373105,
0.061535649,
0.0138200661,
-0.0282868221,
-0.0739818662,
0.0320398174,
0.0268109962,
0.0292165689,
-0.01295745,
0.0329655856,
0.063045077,
-0.0735884979,
-0.0294146109,
0.0603852868,
0.0107320435,
-0.0299906246,
-0.0059396257,
-0.0045782453,
0.019570414,
0.032669764,
0.0461365208,
-0.0504491068,
-0.0484862775,
-0.0161748398,
0.0002919761,
0.030641444,
-0.0031875279,
-0.0267633144,
-0.0538048111,
0.0504005179,
0.0110757453,
-0.0575560667,
-0.0267683174,
-0.0079943128,
-0.0049685659,
-0.0159148574,
-0.0161892641,
-0.009526317,
0.0105085466,
-0.0389819965,
0.0127903018,
0.0180135909,
0.0027298266,
0.0003949768,
-0.0560297817,
0.0284978691,
0.0474344641,
0.0089057917,
0.0115979975,
-0.0406243615,
0.0071791094,
-0.0045289425,
0.0392620005,
-0.0328021981,
0.0816524625,
-0.0335489698,
-0.0408526659,
0.0181501862,
0.0329971053,
-0.0399895646,
0.0050409148,
0.0011405365,
0.0116055859,
-0.0324358717,
0.0277894866,
-0.0175062362,
0.0004036501,
0.0293961968,
0.0172944311,
0.0042297463,
0.0058930735,
-0.0536984764,
-0.0353759937,
0.0157371797,
-0.0505528599,
-0.0103478162,
0.0029105239,
-0.0236707721,
-0.0541451052,
-0.0651409253,
-0.0974879265,
0.0662898198,
0.0727012083,
0.0239250325,
-0.0311755426,
-0.0456466004,
0.0123238135,
-0.0241275318,
0.0336281173,
-0.0327489711,
0.0380954631,
-0.040640641,
-0.0325234458,
-0.008265744,
-0.0568807423,
0.022133762,
0.0261175372,
-0.0581106357,
-0.0692333579,
-0.0195531417,
0.074922502,
0.014237944,
0.0724749267,
0.0053633964,
-0.0069113276,
0.0099820597,
0.0097740283,
0.0245517287,
-0.0096567133,
0.0350613594,
-0.0073557775,
0.0000670252,
0.0264174901,
-0.0702445805,
-0.0141507722,
-0.0036720855,
0.0269653331,
-0.0340670682,
0.0183957182,
0.0485925861,
-0.0637254789,
0.047976017,
-0.0223179106,
0.0699479878,
-0.0240777396,
0.013731855,
-0.0232706144,
-0.006343408,
-0.0696404055,
0.0419538356,
0.0293004569,
0.0241992287,
0.0475724526,
0.0009369677,
-0.0286581293,
-0.0133173931,
-0.0399847105,
-0.0047848327,
0.0366530605,
0.0152501259,
-0.0074975216,
0.0445383117,
-0.0163124185,
0.0350850895,
-0.0073909182,
0.0367055088,
0.0149196321,
0.0663221851,
0.0555678755,
-0.0061059846,
-0.0312068462,
0.0258683059,
-0.0182409901,
-0.0647916943,
-0.0182425268,
0.0606544316,
0.0786349252,
-0.0050497865,
0.0243562963,
-0.0478762649,
0.0201326609,
0.0109963743,
0.0205313377,
0.0118174748,
-0.0718683302,
0.0573092103,
0.0278204102,
0.0223385114,
-0.033269342,
0.0574693345,
0.0160057768,
0.0575198978,
0.0118783982,
-0.0065691057,
-0.0421039723,
0.0250866879,
0.0492016338,
0.0274871681,
-0.0120674772,
0.0455153286,
-0.0185458567,
-0.035798382,
-0.0199564267,
0.0453859121,
0.0043096058,
0.0036420394,
0.0591823049,
0.0088422531,
-0.0032237915,
-0.0780312344,
-0.0411547497,
-0.0619665943,
-0.0275228955,
0.0125120664,
-0.0195870493,
-5.810857959e-33,
-0.0540917814,
-0.0352516919,
0.0551852472,
0.0316997431,
-0.0112045957,
0.006254111,
-0.0511918776,
-0.0098782685,
-0.0364443846,
0.0380047038,
0.0170412548,
0.023188496,
0.0230771881,
0.0262049753,
-0.0055542104,
-0.0442943387,
0.0448411331,
0.0348339342,
-0.0323490053,
0.0204084218,
0.0432555825,
-0.0175575372,
0.0646774396,
-0.0689398795,
-0.0003777453,
-0.0165232439,
-0.0170692839,
0.0385922641,
0.0232646242,
0.0551601723,
-0.0119169382,
0.0314015634,
-0.005912194,
-0.0198180787,
-0.0428001061,
-0.0221572984,
-0.0614982806,
-0.0403015092,
-0.0061340481,
0.0701291412,
-0.0872895196,
-0.0131922709,
0.0144247524,
-0.0288855415,
0.0187476389,
-0.0027094004,
0.0553397723,
-0.0216277353,
-0.0348651223,
0.0093286773,
-0.0555783696,
0.017120393,
-0.0035302443,
-0.0827093571,
0.0513703749,
0.0291149877,
0.0358035862,
-0.0726557672,
-0.021687666,
0.0148629593,
0.044626072,
0.0286802277,
0.0465560295,
0.0764540583,
0.0033098795,
0.0555106699,
0.0898663178,
-0.0129489331,
0.0104099382,
-0.0136962682,
-0.0172547661,
0.0437480099,
0.0192561839,
0.0247909389,
0.0140726604,
0.0201055333,
-0.0256676544,
0.0376673192,
-0.0207801182,
0.0772601441,
-0.015232739,
0.0098863374,
-0.0516798459,
-0.0155904843,
-0.027281424,
-0.0399917811,
-0.0106820567,
-0.0514694676,
0.0558403507,
0.0554010049,
-0.0087196678,
0.0065658162,
0.0467908718,
-0.0136916703,
0.0400262251,
0.0035970504,
-0.0201432575,
0.0113065224,
-0.0047860276,
-0.0003675106,
-0.0587027781,
-0.0379288197,
0.0390299074,
-0.0141523024,
0.0124778328,
0.0046197912,
-0.0022502928,
0.0533791259,
-0.0173235089,
-0.0104535865,
-0.0646876693,
-0.0204661805,
0.0180460699,
-0.0207950491,
0.0332237333,
-0.0274627153,
-0.0629690588,
0.0581507497,
-0.012612409,
-0.0353950486,
0.0093069291,
0.0023461981,
0.0078699468,
0.0432857946,
-0.0390906632,
-0.0050674686,
-0.0542996041,
-0.0014936661,
0.0258195382,
-0.0514153652,
-0.0034624159,
0.0351712108,
2.635e-7,
-0.0187040772,
0.0167583581,
0.0149735436,
0.0243260134,
-0.026324952,
0.0461424142,
-0.0260827672,
0.0078181615,
-0.0242728908,
-0.0472168699,
0.020395156,
0.0405042879,
-0.0120469956,
0.0228280649,
-0.0536476187,
0.035195563,
0.0470777191,
-0.0184622444,
-0.034814395,
0.0147819258,
0.0865083039,
0.0754716992,
-0.0177371521,
-0.0122015765,
0.0300573613,
-0.0263392385,
0.0548302978,
-0.0278172474,
0.0020810901,
-0.0339629948,
0.0339014977,
0.0695418268,
-0.0659242049,
0.0274068695,
-0.0233722087,
-0.0249484219,
-0.0009369745,
0.0114009269,
-0.0452711917,
-0.0226591267,
-0.0131169995,
0.0183683112,
-0.018990064,
-0.0197753627,
0.0245290119,
-0.0383895822,
-0.0039749509,
0.0317306556,
-0.0241125394,
-0.0063627935,
-0.0154034644,
-0.0104711708,
-0.0312451366,
-0.024288943,
0.015460833,
-0.0110760033,
-0.0334952623,
-0.0536392145,
-0.0075855134,
0.0052416152,
0.0204206426,
-0.0216058344,
-0.0341728739,
0.0134276971,
0.0040552444,
-0.020871887,
-0.0569366887,
1.731387696e-34,
0.0318836868,
-0.0296440516,
-0.0205063634,
0.0081766788,
0.0287802462,
0.0002323743,
-0.007267803,
-0.002526562,
0.0210352372,
-0.0117298998,
-0.0737295374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02558v1 | Enhancing Robustness in Biomedical NLI Models: A Probing Approach for Clinical Trials | 2024-02-04T16:18:01 | 2024-02-04T16:18:01 | Ata Mustafa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models have revolutionized various fields and industries, such
as Conversational AI, Content Generation, Information Retrieval, Business
Intelligence, and Medical, to name a few. One major application in the field of
medical is to analyze and investigate clinical trials for entailment
tasks.However, It has been observed that Large Language Models are susceptible
to shortcut learning, factual inconsistency, and performance degradation with
little variation in context. Adversarial and robust testing is performed to
ensure the integrity of models output. But, ambiguity still persists. In order
to ensure the integrity of the reasoning performed and investigate the model
has correct syntactic and semantic understanding probing is used. Here, I used
mnestic probing to investigate the Sci-five model, trained on clinical trial. I
investigated the model for feature learnt with respect to natural logic. To
achieve the target, I trained task specific probes. Used these probes to
investigate the final layers of trained model. Then, fine tuned the trained
model using iterative null projection. The results shows that model accuracy
improved. During experimentation, I observed that size of the probe has affect
on the fine tuning process. | [
0.067094706,
0.0403882153,
-0.0182245895,
0.0169418436,
-0.0486918092,
-0.0142848883,
-0.0010393684,
0.0078610182,
0.0104193771,
-0.0350058265,
-0.0195711628,
-0.0319087841,
0.0267057586,
0.0645954236,
0.0372606926,
-0.0014762288,
0.0687485412,
-0.0077711917,
0.0205547437,
-0.0147183575,
-0.0339536406,
-0.0146135055,
-0.0156060671,
0.020002149,
0.0115903793,
-0.0166406929,
0.0013919411,
-0.0160893407,
-0.0067670182,
-0.0547469743,
-0.0100937309,
0.0602562539,
-0.0259480681,
0.0270572081,
0.0000022579,
-0.0458040498,
-0.0082788281,
0.0453071035,
-0.0284130834,
-0.0045288252,
0.073203288,
-0.0254722312,
0.0106439227,
0.0239015892,
-0.0214284677,
0.0126017435,
0.0213693138,
0.071947664,
0.0340359062,
0.0790783539,
-0.0119033409,
0.0015801584,
0.0373420119,
-0.0340461023,
-0.0288359821,
-0.0729138628,
0.0515644066,
-0.0112325167,
0.0387784392,
0.0338881128,
0.0191569794,
0.0318586417,
0.0097497646,
0.0249764845,
-0.0124408845,
0.0251765307,
0.0148760686,
-0.0471646413,
-0.008750136,
0.0340531431,
-0.0390931182,
-0.0126893139,
0.0111328261,
-0.0099974107,
-0.0085849119,
0.0118849967,
-0.0319271311,
-0.010342476,
-0.0113732899,
-0.0148910498,
0.0578640029,
-0.0285737272,
0.0449853502,
0.0113547379,
-0.0183139872,
0.0212680828,
0.0244896784,
-0.0319198295,
-0.0093424516,
-0.0062320023,
0.0018423063,
-0.0307861827,
0.0107591087,
0.0186100546,
-0.0663186982,
0.0112987775,
-0.0267582517,
-0.0528021492,
0.0722199902,
-0.0803281218,
0.0168916769,
-0.0038571949,
-0.018852571,
0.0183538385,
-0.0267862417,
0.0106681185,
-0.0247738212,
0.080887042,
-0.0320379511,
0.0083457399,
-0.0442086048,
-0.0214519631,
-0.0153248673,
0.0524569862,
-0.0273355655,
-0.0076136505,
-0.0659194589,
-0.0012338582,
-0.0142721152,
0.0246211868,
-0.0440909341,
0.0171721503,
-0.0633829162,
0.0201375466,
-0.0065380251,
0.0206069257,
-0.0429744087,
0.0417740047,
-0.0309697073,
-0.0696304142,
-0.0300832503,
0.0121722696,
-0.0149504645,
-0.0268901978,
0.0109812887,
0.0688776374,
0.0194999538,
-0.03687796,
-0.0539531782,
-0.0607525483,
-0.0628140718,
-0.0755781829,
0.0436697602,
-0.0434577838,
0.0074693044,
0.0171814356,
-0.0218983293,
-0.0568842627,
0.0001217735,
-0.0137201501,
-0.0687468424,
0.1087632477,
-0.0182937235,
-0.0366595201,
-0.0121298088,
0.0217448864,
0.0001893919,
0.0541551001,
0.0189416688,
-0.0071831322,
0.005617708,
-0.0079598688,
-0.010471724,
-0.0217489898,
0.0455165394,
-0.0185048785,
-0.0388156511,
0.0129704028,
-0.0145192752,
0.0632319599,
-0.0578167215,
0.0771606863,
0.0023714718,
0.0257710703,
0.051492732,
0.0278572068,
0.0180759188,
0.0193444192,
-0.0315765031,
-0.0619409904,
0.011730602,
0.0145129412,
-0.040819332,
0.0089509878,
-0.0428996086,
0.0176038221,
-0.030966891,
-0.0008748252,
-0.0245089121,
-0.0479131564,
-0.0597432666,
-0.0089031188,
0.0081973616,
-0.0128902765,
0.0713431612,
-0.0083077308,
-0.0246347059,
0.014493092,
0.0412793458,
-0.0086226137,
0.0016411716,
-0.0808292851,
0.001901906,
0.0056871423,
0.0480635725,
-0.055489976,
-0.0247515608,
-0.0264260042,
-0.0211200565,
0.0143320533,
0.0294036251,
-0.0125866355,
-0.0009147039,
-0.0151038701,
-0.0171932932,
-0.021158671,
0.0320129395,
-0.0314752869,
-0.029864613,
0.036599163,
0.0003075678,
-0.0586676411,
-0.0108937668,
0.053469412,
-0.0589315556,
0.0074121668,
-0.0130848167,
-0.0036604712,
0.0458321869,
0.0214331727,
-0.0218567997,
0.0455157682,
0.0592505708,
-0.0440695994,
-0.0018717442,
-0.0226213001,
-0.0011438925,
-0.0287896991,
0.0303548761,
-0.0406602658,
-0.0096379826,
0.0207431335,
-0.0349216647,
-0.0348245203,
-0.0094918003,
-0.0347612761,
-0.0180622544,
-0.0139060877,
0.0222301856,
-0.0196391772,
0.0017976514,
-0.0601804294,
0.057273414,
-0.0029415388,
0.0046329927,
0.0015263783,
-0.0361685418,
0.0373053998,
-0.0311039221,
-0.0494510829,
0.0521927811,
-0.0128743378,
-0.0187779739,
-0.0022136208,
-0.0246701054,
-0.0320202112,
-0.0399380066,
-0.0804215968,
0.0065811747,
0.0000350425,
0.0195921175,
0.0004774211,
0.0170286782,
0.0252891202,
-0.0197853018,
-0.0240313951,
-0.022034429,
0.017583238,
0.0364386179,
0.0391865782,
0.0414254926,
0.0060753315,
-0.04866492,
-0.0116614206,
-0.0487417392,
0.0536911637,
0.0176394507,
-0.0307413694,
-0.0344148092,
0.0240560789,
-0.0089153107,
0.0041754269,
-0.0034454591,
-0.046288006,
0.0346250758,
0.0234877728,
-0.0249446332,
0.0983813405,
0.0061213104,
0.042668622,
0.044987753,
0.0474211983,
0.0140167428,
0.0101597412,
-0.0208601635,
-0.0061210976,
-0.0142578166,
-0.0127858296,
-0.005886687,
0.0676352084,
0.0316858478,
-0.0121719157,
-0.04101713,
0.0561659858,
-0.0308086723,
-0.0178701244,
-0.0038840182,
0.023985561,
-0.0286362637,
0.0353580005,
-0.0059467135,
-0.014657937,
0.1308929175,
-0.0038635326,
0.0527442247,
-0.092117168,
-0.0063499515,
0.0108708637,
0.0209572129,
0.0013618002,
0.0293056071,
0.0541581288,
-0.0002832014,
-0.041533459,
-0.0195663311,
0.0145642161,
-0.0313747674,
0.0601402186,
-0.0288868509,
0.0281416196,
0.0211514384,
-0.0497864634,
-0.0542422868,
-0.0136171216,
-0.0358598381,
0.0176701676,
0.0121637573,
0.0263580568,
-0.0419016033,
0.0093775336,
-0.0030466027,
0.0523365662,
-0.0238862894,
-0.0093259662,
-0.0296624918,
-0.0079501728,
0.058362782,
-0.0091321236,
0.0397267416,
-0.0248682648,
0.0162333269,
0.0470926613,
-0.0509911738,
0.0717036948,
-0.0453419238,
0.0080262618,
-0.0275116023,
-0.0485633761,
-0.01490587,
0.035634771,
0.0309782606,
-0.053028442,
-0.0373390578,
0.0862573236,
0.0134645412,
0.0007097058,
0.041386392,
-0.0230532214,
-0.017105164,
-0.0217889845,
0.0085453847,
-0.0646914989,
-0.0316375643,
-0.0009048441,
0.0305437353,
-0.0290286522,
-0.0079776859,
0.0189979952,
-0.0695042834,
0.0185173061,
0.0046559749,
-0.0564048104,
-0.0586979873,
-0.0745854229,
0.0185916889,
-0.0311542042,
0.0744998083,
0.0023646355,
0.0218434148,
-0.0115346741,
-0.0022437628,
0.0295046531,
-0.136191681,
0.0195369385,
-0.0454992987,
0.0750472918,
0.0527448542,
0.0348053984,
-0.0247102808,
0.0077425465,
0.0280943848,
0.0120466556,
0.0155988261,
0.0006547761,
0.0817909613,
0.0244104173,
0.0068903272,
-0.0475322865,
0.0430469215,
-0.033723101,
-0.0092440769,
-0.0388396792,
0.076018326,
-0.0463125035,
-0.0382501893,
-0.0496265478,
-0.0018838079,
0.0066835275,
0.0763548017,
0.0091637513,
-0.0226412192,
-0.0424956046,
-0.0004721186,
0.0479079932,
0.0097639915,
-0.0354104154,
0.0620098189,
-0.0028542285,
0.0104897022,
-0.0557034835,
-0.0456653647,
0.0284117777,
0.0310926195,
0.0005401059,
0.0382524878,
0.0306597408,
-0.0114566293,
-0.0314078964,
0.0439389087,
0.0352627449,
0.0186831728,
-0.0269676335,
0.0093107643,
0.0582408048,
0.0032271051,
-0.0062617175,
0.0167004205,
-0.0585374907,
-0.0509239174,
-0.0099265035,
0.0578541532,
0.0284029823,
0.026837321,
-0.0428459644,
-0.0411992967,
0.022445526,
0.0311436821,
-0.0250425208,
-0.0208867397,
0.0264019594,
-0.041015707,
-0.026318647,
0.0177615676,
-0.0360314138,
0.0115617784,
0.0252860729,
0.0608082339,
0.0069006509,
-0.0715516284,
0.0353083648,
0.0625577047,
0.0621506944,
-0.0104844179,
-0.0230754819,
-0.0134744691,
0.0120749706,
-0.0374236479,
0.0131511446,
-0.0091605196,
0.0135666626,
0.0093282424,
0.0358020887,
-0.0059791002,
-0.0539633036,
-0.0681125894,
0.0101468395,
-0.0449360162,
0.012201705,
0.0141701819,
-0.0058247587,
0.0507004,
0.0102764321,
-0.0207740217,
0.0131058013,
-0.00923819,
0.0281501245,
-0.0323011801,
0.0315964594,
0.0417753011,
0.0170844309,
-0.0557406768,
0.0358542167,
-0.0539174266,
-0.0099791884,
-0.0287526622,
0.032192979,
0.0239767414,
0.0140702454,
0.0100083817,
-0.0323146097,
0.0031647836,
-0.0138236796,
0.0466645546,
-0.0008749079,
0.0287518278,
0.0547754541,
0.019340029,
0.0036423737,
-0.0166933611,
0.0673131198,
0.0398707204,
0.0541887879,
-0.0307053328,
-0.0182863902,
-0.0511169992,
-0.0125255752,
0.0062607327,
0.0077293185,
-0.0762114227,
0.0227595493,
-0.0513004474,
-0.0640546754,
0.0579843819,
-0.0016103009,
0.0023032899,
-0.0377014466,
0.0377366357,
0.0563053861,
0.033312194,
-0.031224655,
0.0008474972,
0.0266027134,
0.031700708,
-0.0370396078,
-0.0188930109,
-7.019729002e-33,
0.0022974112,
-0.0376280583,
-0.0125605371,
-0.04225998,
0.0060720239,
0.0058048191,
-0.0687242895,
-0.000857792,
-0.0299956687,
0.0279938374,
-0.0166956615,
0.0193718169,
0.0113519644,
0.0192838572,
-0.0038849441,
-0.0338707119,
0.0508780628,
0.0119846724,
-0.0091165239,
-0.0053672125,
-0.0147796758,
0.0521022156,
0.0635716692,
-0.0762217939,
0.0280335415,
0.0343756229,
-0.0031437336,
0.0244122911,
-0.0653763264,
0.0745668188,
0.0057192282,
0.0277937725,
0.0374010801,
-0.0219131727,
0.0108406628,
-0.0419875309,
-0.0611181967,
-0.0369443372,
0.0136386193,
-0.0078118769,
-0.0440797545,
-0.0220465697,
0.0736476704,
-0.0458968058,
-0.008085697,
0.0065602548,
0.0171902142,
-0.021149775,
-0.0344002582,
-0.0135987233,
-0.0597466603,
0.0148739554,
0.0121665988,
-0.0067494363,
-0.0104934108,
0.0081127593,
-0.0190204624,
0.028404424,
-0.0393708721,
-0.0186892506,
0.032640107,
0.0247589331,
0.0143524026,
0.0116866399,
-0.0108444393,
0.0674872696,
0.009542509,
0.0472217798,
-0.0223532133,
-0.0113431085,
0.032774508,
0.0479345322,
0.077879943,
0.0367219523,
0.0158208869,
0.00289706,
-0.115161851,
-0.0161114018,
-0.0043186028,
0.0547937453,
0.0373990312,
-0.0057143099,
-0.0387715362,
-0.0124988724,
-0.0517562293,
-0.0441287719,
-0.0322709307,
-0.0318699703,
0.0210653059,
-0.0095059043,
-0.0149718178,
0.0132271219,
0.0147485202,
-0.0311929025,
0.0361148529,
-0.009496131,
0.0209729616,
0.0132564027,
-0.0301702898,
0.0283488259,
-0.0339168496,
-0.0176544171,
0.0016334966,
-0.0085076606,
0.0644819289,
0.0071058264,
-0.000706523,
-0.0260347538,
-0.0182022639,
-0.0102887433,
-0.0011231687,
-0.022154497,
0.0299764182,
0.0321916379,
0.0464827493,
0.0175568201,
0.0065040719,
0.0572877824,
0.0266311634,
0.0368868448,
-0.0443006493,
0.0161163565,
0.0190086458,
0.0053264871,
-0.0352220796,
-0.0324131027,
-0.0343659595,
0.0545340404,
-0.0015151231,
-0.0750515088,
-0.0228974428,
-0.0227877572,
3.208e-7,
0.0664258152,
0.06841553,
-0.00920483,
0.0231220517,
0.0213325489,
0.0429757424,
-0.0091553684,
0.0137033034,
-0.0112602012,
-0.0390868485,
0.0181524847,
-0.010358192,
0.0242193397,
0.0235663597,
-0.0553948507,
-0.0242106058,
-0.0520657189,
0.0070917252,
-0.0200935565,
0.0104960129,
0.0346469805,
0.0896866322,
-0.0216350164,
-0.0117023811,
-0.0147576993,
-0.0547902621,
0.0275850855,
0.0246870406,
-0.0161719397,
0.0612011887,
0.0328621566,
-0.0028219945,
0.0352634005,
0.0711247101,
-0.0194847286,
0.0024565854,
-0.0029361576,
0.059466321,
-0.0521862283,
0.0043316903,
0.0060466626,
-0.0193148516,
0.0369806699,
-0.0393768698,
0.0644772649,
-0.0757628456,
-0.068422839,
-0.0457481481,
0.0138482088,
-0.0235384014,
0.068326965,
-0.0181694943,
-0.0018134343,
0.0184823219,
0.0155451735,
0.0190374907,
-0.0178743768,
-0.0449837446,
-0.0051664165,
0.0703969523,
-0.0484709032,
-0.0307599287,
0.0339840986,
-0.0394764319,
0.04660777,
-0.0831410661,
0.0080541875,
3.152820949e-34,
0.0532898158,
-0.0187003352,
0.0149829872,
0.0190274399,
0.0525157824,
-0.0051888139,
-0.0116298497,
0.0075196801,
0.0251601189,
-0.0614191592,
-0.0127139688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02555v1 | Generalizable Entity Grounding via Assistance of Large Language Model | 2024-02-04T16:06:05 | 2024-02-04T16:06:05 | Lu Qi, Yi-Wen Chen, Lehan Yang, Tiancheng Shen, Xiangtai Li, Weidong Guo, Yu Xu, Ming-Hsuan Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this work, we propose a novel approach to densely ground visual entities
from a long caption. We leverage a large multimodal model (LMM) to extract
semantic nouns, a class-agnostic segmentation model to generate entity-level
segmentation, and the proposed multi-modal feature fusion module to associate
each semantic noun with its corresponding segmentation mask. Additionally, we
introduce a strategy of encoding entity segmentation masks into a colormap,
enabling the preservation of fine-grained predictions from features of
high-resolution masks. This approach allows us to extract visual features from
low-resolution images using the CLIP vision encoder in the LMM, which is more
computationally efficient than existing approaches that use an additional
encoder for high-resolution images. Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate
the superiority of our method, outperforming state-of-the-art techniques on
three tasks, including panoptic narrative grounding, referring expression
segmentation, and panoptic segmentation. | [
0.0230411962,
0.0655274615,
0.0411142074,
0.0466495007,
0.0138130533,
-0.0024628239,
-0.006763876,
0.0162318759,
-0.0563281029,
-0.0841872841,
0.0070338836,
0.0008702865,
0.009517598,
0.0320342518,
0.016066229,
-0.0758221447,
-0.0071841325,
-0.0244302731,
-0.0329317898,
0.0134346643,
0.051090423,
0.011607944,
-0.0091600046,
0.0289957896,
-0.0687533468,
0.0182975009,
0.0014216157,
-0.0086107496,
0.0207788143,
-0.0381880403,
-0.0222140476,
0.0315223671,
0.0610896088,
-0.0040335376,
0.000001968,
-0.037521828,
-0.0355665982,
0.0183478594,
0.0128889363,
-0.0089623481,
0.0321960524,
-0.0434289314,
-0.0157417525,
-0.0586472191,
0.0054835794,
0.0026712907,
0.0715798065,
0.0944382772,
0.0557639301,
-0.0004452383,
-0.0381877981,
-0.0645523146,
0.0226100255,
-0.004324995,
0.0013335054,
-0.0257872418,
0.0208749548,
0.0643858761,
-0.0482639819,
-0.0158372149,
-0.0545501709,
0.0301526263,
-0.0227631275,
0.0065301163,
0.0302125365,
0.0565879494,
0.0057530799,
-0.0356498994,
-0.0130124427,
0.0946131423,
-0.0154378889,
0.0200594794,
-0.0245055128,
0.0225296598,
-0.0146836815,
0.0018329158,
-0.03048384,
0.0412747078,
-0.0052010627,
0.047569491,
-0.0252094679,
0.0064693452,
-0.0087018861,
0.0083494978,
-0.0442204922,
-0.0280461945,
0.0314936414,
0.0124207446,
0.0078577446,
0.0310396012,
-0.0464654826,
-0.0465741009,
0.0326394327,
0.0098173954,
0.0206757616,
0.017100757,
-0.0392112099,
-0.023380043,
-0.0202731732,
-0.0351954699,
-0.0233522989,
-0.0089600123,
-0.0347246975,
0.0780365989,
-0.0258057527,
0.0093098329,
-0.0324998088,
0.0256443452,
0.0054724095,
-0.0287898127,
-0.031522844,
0.0043352833,
-0.0269027911,
0.0272179786,
-0.06130578,
-0.0482475087,
-0.0241342597,
-0.0300193392,
-0.0103336144,
0.0190547872,
-0.0238515213,
0.0369132273,
-0.0215333067,
-0.0036810562,
-0.0211925898,
0.0204077512,
-0.0311514568,
0.0030492202,
-0.0126689645,
-0.0306101535,
0.0308744125,
-0.0067224586,
0.0244270284,
-0.0219046883,
0.0267676655,
0.0849087164,
-0.0444276668,
-0.0649692863,
-0.0559225157,
-0.0312867165,
-0.0409945101,
-0.0372943059,
0.0209518466,
-0.0625993684,
0.0102268197,
-0.0219607204,
0.0228531212,
-0.0494194888,
0.0344413854,
-0.0007767263,
-0.0311186425,
0.1250025034,
-0.0109870797,
-0.0029930365,
0.025077967,
0.0189976543,
0.0300357547,
0.0736568347,
0.0583713017,
0.0293868575,
0.0549370795,
-0.0006684305,
0.014269392,
0.0550829656,
-0.0137493741,
-0.0124229835,
-0.0523582958,
-0.0378869921,
0.0138129974,
-0.0082453545,
0.0500604883,
0.0381415673,
0.0044462052,
0.008846757,
0.0840416327,
0.0588050298,
-0.0805415213,
0.0149882594,
0.0215355512,
0.0030871327,
-0.0453809947,
0.00835995,
-0.056359645,
0.0151770134,
0.0029690089,
0.0076886737,
0.0071238428,
0.0495170914,
-0.0209767278,
0.00898345,
0.0139991995,
-0.0081442166,
0.020786617,
-0.006538481,
0.0673328117,
0.0077667907,
-0.0661965311,
0.0711887777,
0.0256910771,
-0.0554438904,
0.0003329274,
-0.0026286892,
0.0155757219,
0.014543023,
0.0399329774,
0.0043724743,
-0.0262039118,
-0.0038936697,
0.0338634551,
0.0686591193,
-0.0433390476,
-0.0083149169,
0.025392646,
-0.0687498525,
-0.0224394854,
0.0099833738,
0.0039970852,
0.0093775187,
0.0242394358,
0.0049869949,
0.0332540423,
-0.0621048659,
-0.0084039923,
0.070699051,
0.0343629941,
0.0012540794,
-0.0844740868,
0.0440787151,
-0.0056459489,
0.0162592325,
-0.0452654138,
-0.0231046509,
0.0155602628,
-0.0321842954,
0.0038576303,
0.0229862072,
-0.0448397174,
-0.0109390803,
0.0049716686,
-0.0747836679,
-0.0055870493,
-0.0325728916,
-0.0241507385,
-0.0440054908,
-0.00683012,
-0.0020897894,
0.0387632102,
-0.0333740041,
0.0209355578,
0.0232861601,
0.0521001108,
-0.0351759829,
0.0589279607,
-0.0146574443,
-0.0225521252,
0.0063586808,
-0.0201025605,
-0.0257399697,
-0.0165476389,
-0.0303258672,
0.030722158,
0.0172905661,
-0.0141522121,
0.0194677506,
0.011997479,
-0.0481337085,
-0.0075212335,
-0.1141120046,
-0.0224112757,
0.0027315242,
-0.024049487,
-0.0223986451,
0.0049387896,
0.0081500253,
-0.0210135933,
-0.0060613011,
-0.0157331023,
0.0009836392,
0.0050038029,
0.0156263113,
0.032640744,
-0.0342753083,
-0.0159899537,
-0.0027115333,
0.014227978,
0.0748383924,
0.0182297025,
-0.0812131912,
-0.0279759057,
0.0104751876,
-0.0170160346,
0.0319256932,
-0.020334905,
-0.0066788173,
-0.00950626,
-0.0017835147,
0.0457115509,
0.0660886839,
0.0111716939,
0.0293307062,
0.0004570827,
-0.0730914101,
-0.0077903266,
0.0149355363,
0.0047531743,
-0.0106744915,
-0.01209764,
-0.0163544063,
-0.0184501782,
0.0538557805,
-0.0352727473,
0.0506931655,
-0.0312051456,
-0.0013540457,
-0.0013320455,
-0.0436135754,
-0.0443506092,
0.039015539,
-0.0111067025,
0.0005675025,
-0.0413505659,
-0.0419183522,
0.0223952271,
-0.071866028,
-0.0370601304,
0.0338930003,
0.0061298977,
-0.0186612327,
0.0755374432,
0.0182837285,
0.0254730843,
0.0048821513,
-0.0304985866,
-0.0121991942,
0.0236426815,
-0.0198873356,
-0.0009867158,
0.0964024365,
-0.0520410687,
0.016592985,
-0.0113485735,
0.0016828323,
-0.0203615092,
-0.0058527566,
-0.0637818873,
-0.0037968142,
-0.0180735607,
-0.006289734,
-0.0095681446,
0.0601980947,
0.019118879,
0.0022485927,
-0.0009709647,
0.0013285779,
-0.0151047204,
0.0533680357,
0.0410395525,
0.02787444,
-0.0504095741,
-0.0324856453,
0.0044324007,
0.0273776315,
0.015567515,
-0.0190094952,
-0.0070106136,
0.0134533858,
0.008768063,
0.025639154,
-0.0023441124,
0.0041851108,
0.0721556246,
-0.0565834418,
0.0035005098,
0.0835164487,
0.0065592546,
-0.0536181666,
-0.0306411888,
0.0188583024,
0.0109119304,
0.0200887769,
-0.034927845,
-0.0366435647,
-0.0796256065,
0.017941948,
-0.0487057231,
0.0382375717,
-0.0249582343,
-0.0173873175,
-0.0806445479,
0.0256291274,
0.0035235384,
-0.0576164573,
-0.0362126231,
-0.0241946373,
0.0470437966,
-0.0158087034,
-0.0252884645,
-0.0284064468,
-0.0066448073,
-0.0292097367,
-0.005545476,
0.0177266262,
-0.0169935748,
0.0146380179,
-0.0663175061,
-0.0092462637,
0.0703607649,
0.039487239,
-0.0373851247,
-0.0150183048,
0.0050280923,
-0.0361289009,
-0.0090528745,
0.0174657647,
0.07755211,
-0.0808110014,
-0.0223315321,
0.0088927178,
0.0407311991,
0.0213062447,
-0.006902236,
-0.0079074809,
0.0145276589,
0.0002797616,
0.0169243105,
-0.0291077048,
0.006507704,
-0.0043479032,
0.0447586402,
0.0198476706,
-0.0324436761,
-0.0032297086,
-0.0130043812,
0.0317818783,
-0.0294026006,
-0.0080967741,
0.0139149064,
-0.0744366869,
-0.0218566768,
-0.0544988513,
-0.0111979162,
0.0767390355,
0.0478783622,
0.0235364474,
-0.0046017859,
0.0295967329,
0.0429972224,
-0.0583067499,
0.0613358803,
-0.0588053614,
0.0235059969,
-0.054399047,
0.0067709675,
0.0627241507,
-0.0073246476,
-0.018093409,
0.0520736724,
-0.0457817055,
-0.0158432089,
-0.0003842034,
0.0392303132,
0.008927593,
0.0307335928,
0.021772353,
-0.0077566011,
0.0282467734,
0.0060277493,
0.0149375508,
0.0290561728,
-0.0031670863,
-0.0201443713,
-0.0241574328,
0.0096194148,
-0.048728928,
0.0475194789,
-0.0049244994,
0.0433182418,
-0.0136246104,
-0.0111923255,
0.0030090557,
0.0001388874,
0.0543458052,
-0.0472436957,
0.0229312778,
-0.0457767136,
-0.0047975751,
0.0064158249,
-0.0285742283,
-0.0597523414,
0.0254233647,
-0.0162161067,
0.0337476917,
0.024053067,
0.033645235,
0.0250911545,
0.0336162969,
-0.0006785339,
-0.0095258076,
0.0070480942,
-0.0630258769,
-0.0011385186,
0.0244191866,
0.0144834043,
0.0207961034,
-0.0195767451,
0.0204900503,
-0.0290337894,
0.0763392225,
0.0117872627,
-0.0419351272,
-0.0476547778,
0.0414614864,
0.0363487042,
0.0473657288,
-0.0608736947,
0.0813305378,
0.0728325769,
-0.0303372052,
0.0381331593,
-0.0184432697,
-0.0225976259,
0.0217487458,
0.0168690644,
0.0066431016,
-0.0379329696,
0.0646238402,
0.0231382269,
-0.0197152849,
-0.009204478,
0.0303423237,
0.0124245118,
0.0427333154,
0.0202413704,
-0.022768626,
-0.0510944612,
0.0017088995,
0.0047385381,
-0.0154349282,
0.0108457915,
0.0386223905,
-0.0373228118,
-0.0416897684,
0.0187962614,
-0.0201190058,
-0.0302852727,
0.0359814055,
0.0418041013,
0.0333056338,
0.0137252705,
-0.0044867629,
-0.0008985035,
-0.0121961478,
-0.0180966537,
0.0061420393,
0.0050758072,
-5.82006061e-33,
-0.0782316849,
-0.0589078367,
0.0146689359,
-0.0057836217,
-0.0506141633,
0.0444065817,
-0.0194875691,
0.028840594,
0.0067339744,
0.0194305237,
0.0111071393,
-0.0361172073,
0.0375912264,
0.0446525626,
-0.0192196891,
-0.001774774,
0.0540719107,
0.0207836758,
0.0070213587,
-0.0152683323,
-0.0045396979,
0.039832443,
0.0761877149,
-0.0578631796,
0.0068101832,
0.0151484488,
-0.0395948216,
0.0221841354,
0.0661520287,
0.0470173992,
-0.047959052,
0.0141866524,
0.0127247572,
-0.0437331945,
-0.0161683168,
0.0149679426,
-0.0915870816,
0.0467452221,
0.0240301769,
0.0207622219,
-0.0296450406,
-0.007370519,
0.0279504284,
-0.022111848,
0.0248683225,
-0.0174572915,
0.0634497628,
-0.0464775898,
0.0181031842,
0.0012335678,
-0.0575753041,
0.0253158156,
0.0046914644,
-0.0300591886,
0.0575865209,
-0.0450088419,
0.0540339388,
0.0032900844,
-0.0247128829,
0.0095640281,
0.0156136332,
-0.0073338719,
0.0758867711,
0.079895854,
0.0072999764,
0.08790759,
-0.0125389192,
-0.041935306,
-0.0572258644,
0.0120253926,
0.0207989644,
0.0727131814,
0.0107961483,
0.0307129938,
-0.0033323166,
0.0308309942,
-0.0162063558,
0.012404846,
-0.0696558952,
0.0382219292,
0.0232860614,
0.022223454,
-0.0106216222,
0.008500319,
-0.0255531762,
-0.0280926954,
-0.0224640071,
-0.0113988975,
0.023714697,
0.0287938304,
-0.0337624289,
0.0793806314,
0.0743874013,
0.0214225985,
-0.0052048885,
0.0313381143,
0.0181108303,
0.0576385818,
-0.021987129,
-0.0400987677,
-0.0269404501,
-0.0191202983,
0.0506537035,
-0.048427511,
0.010325606,
0.0093360338,
0.0094824173,
-0.0085301884,
-0.0288881436,
-0.0160488933,
-0.0201525148,
-0.0205837823,
-0.043664135,
0.0459596477,
0.0259333458,
0.0085205995,
-0.0693655685,
0.0403075702,
0.0210413169,
0.0310925376,
-0.0023425042,
-0.0421559997,
0.0118263196,
0.0436957143,
-0.0422163755,
0.0299379155,
-0.0124831507,
-0.0587635636,
0.0395767391,
-0.0504694059,
-0.0160748605,
0.0074210297,
2.572e-7,
0.0134856561,
0.036880333,
0.0371089987,
-0.0260044895,
-0.0255445167,
0.0588779375,
0.0100819161,
0.0193794947,
-0.0153510533,
-0.1053005457,
-0.0090250662,
0.0294445455,
0.0233575683,
0.0173136909,
-0.049263794,
0.0011427631,
0.0066686347,
-0.0457716621,
-0.067358613,
-0.0062786574,
0.0237147789,
0.0942217931,
-0.0019214017,
-0.0294268671,
0.0122833569,
-0.0666531026,
0.0599350221,
-0.0306317564,
-0.0292880125,
-0.0021762243,
-0.0205826256,
0.0410600863,
-0.0530589856,
0.0425295159,
0.01620562,
-0.0065528634,
0.0892441645,
0.0357214063,
-0.036817506,
0.0406580567,
-0.0456050783,
0.0261937045,
-0.0378243774,
-0.0039755641,
0.0565587915,
-0.0312488955,
-0.0201692134,
-0.0368694887,
-0.0208925623,
0.0134784589,
-0.0178323761,
-0.0160939135,
-0.0482698046,
0.0258409083,
0.0313595422,
-0.0122376755,
-0.0569539815,
-0.1051395759,
-0.0091376221,
0.0112661086,
-0.019163033,
-0.0201895293,
-0.0058300886,
-0.0719810575,
0.0036465018,
-0.0559341349,
-0.0313115455,
2.478409764e-34,
-0.0065863798,
0.0214186721,
-0.0239478685,
0.0333404243,
0.0543638729,
-0.0086651929,
-0.0359707847,
-0.0253060199,
-0.0494842753,
-0.0572808385,
-0.0032948419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02549v1 | Are Large Language Models Table-based Fact-Checkers? | 2024-02-04T15:52:59 | 2024-02-04T15:52:59 | Hangwen Zhang, Qingyi Si, Peng Fu, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Table-based Fact Verification (TFV) aims to extract the entailment relation
between statements and structured tables. Existing TFV methods based on
small-scaled models suffer from insufficient labeled data and weak zero-shot
ability. Recently, the appearance of Large Language Models (LLMs) has gained
lots of attraction in research fields. They have shown powerful zero-shot and
in-context learning abilities on several NLP tasks, but their potential on TFV
is still unknown. In this work, we implement a preliminary study about whether
LLMs are table-based fact-checkers. In detail, we design diverse prompts to
explore how the in-context learning can help LLMs in TFV, i.e., zero-shot and
few-shot TFV capability. Besides, we carefully design and construct TFV
instructions to study the performance gain brought by the instruction tuning of
LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate that LLMs can achieve acceptable results
on zero-shot and few-shot TFV with prompt engineering, while instruction-tuning
can stimulate the TFV capability significantly. We also make some valuable
findings about the format of zero-shot prompts and the number of in-context
examples. Finally, we analyze some possible directions to promote the accuracy
of TFV via LLMs, which is beneficial to further research of table reasoning. | [
0.0277535208,
0.0376038849,
-0.0008334602,
0.053392183,
-0.0688166693,
0.0366511196,
0.0210718829,
0.0176707022,
0.0009457805,
-0.0426834486,
-0.0098000374,
-0.0324519202,
-0.0259282477,
0.0056413505,
-0.0034147508,
0.061197307,
0.0713110492,
-0.0102513963,
-0.0127443327,
0.0144228404,
-0.0165480189,
-0.0205177832,
-0.0419026203,
-0.0141182346,
-0.0165360551,
-0.005770002,
-0.0198089369,
-0.0195748191,
-0.0103979912,
0.001264911,
-0.014652201,
0.0700012594,
0.0172404796,
0.0339975879,
0.0000020625,
0.0028352472,
-0.038702514,
-0.0019109342,
-0.0746328905,
-0.0089469887,
0.0004322253,
-0.0265433956,
-0.0090374071,
-0.0202607922,
-0.0256985929,
-0.0551151633,
0.021398278,
0.0766328499,
0.0335037969,
0.0613183081,
0.0065065776,
-0.0256887302,
-0.0003006285,
0.0205041431,
0.0628845692,
-0.0318691097,
0.0262779966,
0.0077837231,
0.0127563188,
0.0074190544,
0.0241107363,
0.0375506468,
0.0389755443,
0.0066867806,
-0.0253104623,
0.0475995019,
-0.0377022326,
0.0151855061,
0.0012290491,
0.077198334,
0.0286168512,
-0.0341143385,
0.0029737314,
0.0037328729,
0.0107194213,
0.001072272,
-0.0272383988,
0.0516288616,
-0.0261740666,
-0.0105994567,
0.021460589,
-0.0124330167,
0.0094583649,
-0.0104461918,
-0.0384435132,
0.0982352197,
-0.0158111695,
-0.0639843196,
0.0094912089,
-0.0124746989,
-0.0270784535,
-0.0587734468,
-0.0264191609,
0.0439842232,
-0.0433829539,
0.0407226607,
-0.0029673046,
-0.0075993538,
0.030870216,
-0.0560255311,
0.0280150939,
0.0602460504,
-0.030766381,
0.0441366173,
-0.0640399083,
0.0320984796,
-0.0254330542,
0.0190226547,
-0.0241551008,
-0.0277016461,
-0.0452612266,
0.0290999375,
-0.0386153087,
0.0406142399,
-0.0373941176,
0.0011133334,
0.0027716991,
0.002856032,
-0.0334659517,
0.0966750905,
-0.0189750791,
-0.0123513201,
0.0110509191,
0.0089565534,
-0.0610011034,
0.0038045302,
-0.0267220978,
-0.0129841631,
-0.0232184064,
-0.077856563,
-0.0205217879,
-0.0362800062,
0.0171011016,
-0.0287462305,
0.0648562536,
0.0378067158,
-0.0142672341,
-0.0157191511,
-0.041792728,
-0.0316292979,
-0.0556028038,
-0.1058137268,
-0.0023907144,
-0.0745569468,
0.0346329249,
0.0268776137,
0.0020392116,
-0.0176160615,
0.0163928382,
0.0613416992,
-0.011198123,
0.0696391538,
0.0395430066,
0.0110564819,
-0.0194867458,
-0.0208760984,
-0.0074240202,
0.0621237084,
0.0018767957,
0.0026615236,
-0.0102385245,
-0.0015155297,
-0.0319427885,
0.0042026085,
0.062622942,
0.0230719522,
-0.0038829446,
0.0377554595,
0.0764464512,
0.0039641811,
-0.0421114191,
0.0295272879,
-0.0209224802,
0.030241292,
0.0408407673,
-0.0091453958,
0.0007112181,
0.0197563767,
0.0352037512,
-0.0221817493,
0.0338735767,
0.0372634567,
-0.0500083156,
0.03379412,
-0.0410591066,
0.0131105371,
0.0298985783,
-0.0036679509,
-0.020283943,
-0.0453681648,
-0.0249199588,
0.0230815262,
-0.0319644846,
0.0200089868,
0.03446858,
0.0297020189,
-0.0511824116,
0.0196251869,
0.0370221138,
-0.051079426,
-0.0613309741,
-0.0198525414,
0.0454610698,
0.0331072584,
0.048287984,
-0.0620796047,
-0.0107761566,
-0.0115124192,
0.0362474024,
0.0210836399,
0.0529276356,
-0.0183705948,
-0.0201363117,
0.0221110098,
0.0101996977,
0.0005203531,
0.0426579453,
-0.0356983393,
0.0349468924,
-0.0114451554,
-0.0160883181,
-0.0245586075,
-0.0183263458,
0.0302608181,
0.0419059806,
-0.0012367537,
0.0183799826,
0.0269894917,
0.0323812179,
0.0123672318,
-0.0105050737,
0.0244740658,
0.0462080203,
-0.0232308116,
0.0000697316,
-0.0441439599,
-0.0305511691,
-0.0538068786,
0.0491829105,
0.0420773141,
-0.0736992806,
-0.0296081919,
-0.0377404802,
-0.0149309756,
-0.0283823013,
-0.0090401601,
-0.0248693153,
-0.0203194376,
0.0200807564,
0.0015755655,
0.01318256,
0.007971867,
0.1198090836,
0.0052348641,
0.0333181098,
0.002153893,
-0.0495693758,
0.0180256031,
-0.0208154675,
0.0102940248,
-0.0010459039,
-0.0184386931,
0.0061182412,
-0.0002677649,
0.0149274115,
-0.0335095674,
-0.0039153551,
-0.1152808368,
0.0586108863,
-0.0335671604,
-0.0121301459,
0.0213217605,
-0.0123911221,
0.0072171045,
0.0086163878,
-0.0279329307,
-0.0126160476,
0.0165168028,
0.0189302526,
0.0699581802,
-0.0214900654,
-0.035850361,
-0.0035604984,
-0.018731989,
-0.0555502363,
0.0378048085,
-0.0274200607,
-0.0196394213,
0.0254177209,
0.0053684111,
-0.0101478556,
0.0238212552,
0.0231316276,
0.0294176452,
0.0006424528,
-0.0101684127,
0.0301004574,
0.057744436,
-0.0374381617,
0.0357321203,
0.0564354323,
-0.0036424282,
-0.0259236339,
0.0511281081,
-0.0068098884,
-0.006280438,
0.0349592082,
-0.0472363532,
0.0192579348,
0.022677904,
0.0020118854,
-0.0026883504,
-0.0374910757,
0.0173021033,
0.0184707064,
0.0109115513,
-0.0657441095,
0.0497242436,
0.0152351931,
0.0207337122,
-0.0159228425,
0.0142322257,
0.0325782038,
-0.045487944,
0.017167205,
-0.038002044,
-0.0199330747,
-0.0473504327,
0.0710330084,
0.0206476767,
-0.0034420213,
0.0101513434,
0.0124464203,
-0.0162037164,
-0.0158562083,
0.0301788095,
-0.0201669075,
0.1068159863,
-0.0483894274,
0.0167684164,
-0.0224888753,
-0.0372202545,
-0.0474651568,
-0.0705775172,
-0.0354091935,
0.037227992,
-0.0370216109,
-0.0130050834,
-0.0327548347,
-0.033442013,
0.0668566376,
0.039501112,
-0.0236350745,
-0.0149435364,
-0.0419335961,
0.0388492458,
0.0352747105,
-0.0068777893,
-0.0244226027,
-0.0106147593,
0.0455848873,
0.0457638688,
-0.0089731757,
0.0044029714,
-0.0158426892,
0.0050952542,
-0.0054427143,
-0.0273119435,
0.0086579192,
0.0476115569,
-0.030009713,
-0.0624901019,
-0.0372331217,
0.0815615952,
0.0415720008,
0.0471601672,
-0.0057463334,
0.0260179974,
0.0042520864,
0.0179347359,
0.0472508594,
-0.1158521101,
-0.0431607254,
0.0052357316,
-0.0645258799,
-0.0346769169,
-0.0281416532,
-0.0496972501,
-0.1326921433,
0.0466181599,
-0.0397327803,
-0.0427378155,
-0.0853721946,
-0.0327339061,
0.0155000687,
0.0151862744,
0.0191446394,
0.0627873018,
-0.0156018669,
-0.0084340228,
0.0087672789,
0.005431341,
-0.0411908999,
0.0474793129,
-0.0479062758,
0.0429096632,
0.0180315133,
0.006102012,
-0.0245880336,
-0.0212835446,
0.0076306979,
0.0045707463,
-0.0064856694,
-0.0107264137,
0.0480918027,
-0.0206845701,
0.0197333079,
0.0001997794,
-0.0123933246,
0.0050173923,
-0.0182627309,
0.0212888699,
0.0747346282,
-0.0324062668,
-0.0156086851,
0.026787404,
0.001319444,
-0.0135070141,
0.0975004137,
0.0120774275,
0.0079317661,
-0.0450405441,
-0.0284134801,
-0.0882867798,
-0.0266280249,
0.0106102545,
0.0501313582,
-0.0175604671,
-0.0051271166,
-0.0257426556,
0.0348339565,
0.0641403422,
0.0545303114,
-0.0208009742,
0.0194204301,
-0.0228873808,
0.0054640812,
-0.0185558833,
-0.0344446078,
-0.0851046741,
0.0418650843,
-0.0217000656,
0.0065185656,
0.0212235861,
-0.0316580757,
-0.0181163326,
0.0155651178,
-0.0679632574,
-0.0160396937,
-0.0146400705,
-0.0099984873,
0.016851509,
0.0331831835,
-0.0057845418,
0.0102659492,
0.0101654837,
0.0308298897,
-0.0611129925,
-0.0029651669,
0.0079252291,
-0.0347377919,
0.0221904181,
0.025205493,
-0.0311175603,
-0.0019073889,
0.0243339669,
0.0371762961,
-0.0183830913,
0.0245138817,
0.0771877915,
0.0244289879,
0.0310959592,
0.0615203232,
-0.0716567412,
-0.0156014059,
0.0489182658,
-0.0598709472,
-0.064443551,
0.0237546172,
0.0018149371,
-0.0026093666,
-0.0126107084,
-0.0145310126,
-0.0164002422,
0.0050871754,
0.0606782213,
0.0169646535,
-0.0160563849,
0.0309318397,
-0.0294339396,
0.0198825672,
-0.0465834588,
-0.0454800054,
-0.0010577652,
0.0249449033,
0.0278221332,
-0.0155807957,
0.027619835,
0.0470706001,
-0.0417419337,
-0.060460858,
-0.0044133444,
-0.0891408175,
0.0020521556,
0.007949329,
0.0365262181,
0.0556610674,
-0.0134253912,
-0.0135092288,
-0.0442314148,
-0.0202121139,
-0.0005419352,
-0.0004192558,
0.0424986482,
-0.0153677175,
0.0396841466,
0.0126672052,
-0.0138830906,
-0.0237542726,
0.0360478871,
0.0256657731,
0.0376733318,
0.0411922745,
-0.01335565,
-0.0578909442,
-0.0036413977,
-0.0287237819,
-0.0080686985,
-0.0280484855,
-0.0006484289,
-0.0619821362,
-0.0279783178,
0.0406192578,
0.0271218084,
-0.0244369246,
-0.010383565,
0.0009451894,
0.0424577855,
0.0705947205,
-0.050973285,
-0.0574500449,
0.0430270135,
0.0169553552,
-0.0179485921,
-0.0177880954,
-6.460195895e-33,
-0.0510853529,
-0.0371422023,
0.0241012648,
-0.0317360014,
0.0402544998,
-0.0080828276,
-0.0476431549,
-0.0219367146,
-0.0420356989,
0.0242994633,
-0.0446751714,
0.0344060548,
0.0262930132,
-0.0348093435,
-0.001377031,
-0.0704730079,
0.0374855995,
-0.0008213018,
-0.0161096025,
-0.0142425224,
0.0347258858,
-0.0254887026,
-0.0050882511,
-0.0278365314,
0.0453360267,
-0.0155223887,
0.0000855959,
0.0097694937,
-0.0474620052,
0.0323024876,
-0.0296122897,
0.0326960087,
0.0431534126,
-0.0840787441,
0.0059281606,
0.0052382769,
-0.143371284,
-0.0213420689,
0.0227420237,
-0.0116836978,
-0.0032203821,
-0.0115198856,
0.0034604939,
0.0083355615,
-0.0110078361,
-0.0219859388,
-0.0033475354,
-0.0372643583,
0.0069004558,
-0.0038007346,
-0.0423809886,
0.0149485338,
0.0182285737,
0.0082083931,
0.036359299,
0.0347068198,
0.023948865,
-0.0317633934,
-0.049173478,
0.0146952905,
0.0106593966,
0.018425582,
0.0456002466,
-0.0351359956,
-0.0047127204,
0.0291765425,
-0.0059314463,
0.0249600075,
-0.0555594899,
0.0133123975,
-0.0161764976,
0.0624891631,
0.0397559144,
0.0406233296,
0.0562774464,
0.0146155516,
-0.0791861266,
0.0115654841,
0.0447927937,
0.0347691029,
0.0045953961,
-0.0395624079,
-0.0522962473,
-0.0137736257,
-0.0312129967,
0.0357503109,
-0.0459223129,
0.0026668413,
0.017881874,
-0.0034413217,
0.0233571511,
-0.0077628461,
0.0157989077,
-0.0119205881,
-0.0126309507,
0.066198729,
-0.0166093931,
-0.0071547506,
0.0068689436,
0.0208595842,
-0.0519555025,
-0.0349209756,
0.0022370031,
-0.0233681593,
0.0299542677,
0.057167571,
0.0852044448,
0.0168911759,
-0.0687162802,
-0.0130422069,
-0.0583362281,
0.0412407257,
-0.0138040343,
-0.0036151898,
0.0172043703,
0.0365277082,
0.0049998299,
0.0418361239,
0.0156147964,
-0.0255020391,
-0.0246211104,
0.0374815129,
-0.0073869159,
0.0081009232,
0.0075610001,
0.0064789383,
-0.039093446,
0.04115583,
0.0201366637,
-0.0363795869,
0.0189078581,
0.0284199305,
2.71e-7,
0.0210159309,
0.0289421827,
0.0213088151,
0.0580454729,
-0.0176054519,
0.0391515642,
-0.0081007686,
-0.0215507839,
-0.021173032,
-0.0657274872,
0.0241524465,
0.0240853336,
0.0512319282,
0.0548095852,
-0.0204771291,
-0.0041189855,
-0.0497368351,
-0.0143481381,
-0.0484230295,
0.0168343876,
0.0444555357,
0.0743228793,
-0.0018795176,
-0.0029541478,
-0.0057688351,
-0.0106884483,
0.0276822448,
-0.0093816482,
0.0081996731,
0.015097593,
0.0324683525,
-0.0247216225,
0.0093906969,
0.0884313285,
0.0015177611,
0.0113908518,
-0.0335695557,
0.0626729578,
0.0171563067,
0.0517203286,
-0.0354132429,
-0.0628718138,
-0.0015654564,
-0.0563022606,
0.1394878775,
-0.036287047,
0.012005453,
0.0220831577,
0.0104952827,
0.0233775917,
-0.0175388344,
0.0314523056,
-0.0224381108,
-0.0121547123,
0.0275645312,
0.0046227723,
-0.0067969547,
-0.03552147,
-0.0189643335,
0.0366358608,
-0.0156420264,
-0.0561147556,
0.0117463991,
-0.0167659726,
0.0225945935,
-0.0790813789,
-0.0406180508,
2.871928768e-34,
0.0358577967,
-0.0063581248,
0.0388408042,
0.0026266717,
0.0516030155,
-0.0079792682,
-0.0317103267,
-0.0219776984,
0.0242338013,
-0.0721452087,
-0.0129185822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02548v1 | "What's my model inside of?": Exploring the role of environments for grounded natural language understanding | 2024-02-04T15:52:46 | 2024-02-04T15:52:46 | Ronen Tamari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | In contrast to classical cognitive science which studied brains in isolation,
ecological approaches focused on the role of the body and environment in
shaping cognition. Similarly, in this thesis we adopt an ecological approach to
grounded natural language understanding (NLU) research. Grounded language
understanding studies language understanding systems situated in the context of
events, actions and precepts in naturalistic/simulated virtual environments.
Where classic research tends to focus on designing new models and optimization
methods while treating environments as given, we explore the potential of
environment design for improving data collection and model development. We
developed novel training and annotation approaches for procedural text
understanding based on text-based game environments. We also drew upon embodied
cognitive linguistics literature to propose a roadmap for grounded NLP
research, and to inform the development of a new benchmark for measuring the
progress of large language models on challenging commonsense reasoning tasks.
We leveraged the richer supervision provided by text-based game environments to
develop Breakpoint Transformers, a novel approach to modeling intermediate
semantic information in long narrative or procedural texts. Finally, we
integrated theories on the role of environments in collective human
intelligence to propose a design for AI-augmented "social thinking
environments" for knowledge workers like scientists. | [
0.0645840392,
-0.0017111847,
-0.0492361523,
0.0401921049,
-0.0046517784,
-0.0061895787,
0.0029006167,
-0.0134524079,
-0.0103222616,
-0.0530346781,
-0.0249138195,
0.0145462472,
0.0398874469,
0.0118144182,
0.0048104851,
-0.0400995389,
0.031044323,
-0.015952155,
-0.0256691203,
0.0257711969,
-0.0191208925,
0.012966508,
-0.036759682,
0.0510983095,
0.0089857681,
-0.0145002706,
-0.0369642824,
-0.020863425,
0.0148579003,
-0.046398256,
-0.0203337949,
0.0066830236,
0.0715219006,
0.0103305057,
0.0000021387,
-0.0154429767,
0.0306150615,
-0.0221497696,
-0.0248793885,
-0.0382546186,
-0.0006813672,
0.0168885477,
0.023051789,
-0.0248806402,
-0.0461678132,
-0.0046915291,
0.0598589219,
0.038890291,
0.0602911413,
0.0129167438,
-0.0068180501,
-0.0303499643,
-0.0339928307,
0.0329236574,
0.0078767641,
-0.0157475229,
-0.0085103353,
0.0712119192,
0.0548019819,
-0.0183039457,
-0.02795914,
0.0181788485,
0.0383910537,
0.002857771,
0.031963557,
0.0725176856,
-0.0198979173,
0.0004960301,
-0.0176848769,
0.100701347,
0.0281760264,
-0.0350611992,
0.0085955653,
0.0129291015,
-0.0011651034,
0.0080243861,
-0.0453329645,
0.0608337373,
-0.0205414128,
0.0161238257,
0.0164741147,
0.0323241986,
-0.0101962108,
0.0215784702,
0.0102647087,
0.0857789516,
-0.0344093032,
0.0075274324,
-0.0113752307,
0.0323225074,
-0.0211208649,
-0.0384679772,
-0.0029816767,
0.0401499011,
-0.0372791514,
0.0389766172,
-0.0146134673,
0.0117165325,
-0.0090304129,
-0.0095784115,
0.0213199034,
0.0343710668,
0.0179880448,
0.0467434861,
0.0234355368,
0.0123601248,
0.0031725692,
-0.0039789639,
-0.0020413348,
0.0408156067,
-0.0886485875,
-0.0198273789,
-0.0319143869,
0.0353391171,
-0.072159104,
-0.0308324359,
0.0369390212,
0.0110949315,
-0.0089069437,
-0.0017697458,
-0.0136275664,
0.0460252613,
-0.030652592,
0.0223104991,
0.0017373959,
-0.0348267294,
-0.0876808986,
0.0417837128,
-0.007902828,
-0.0892352983,
-0.0169641934,
-0.0240270607,
0.0198603515,
-0.0043182899,
-0.0155323371,
0.0305763688,
0.0343490243,
-0.0250204187,
-0.0112223681,
-0.0423807241,
0.0033571597,
-0.0468752384,
0.005410057,
-0.0225733463,
0.0099803796,
-0.0083001107,
0.0235835537,
-0.009490028,
0.0198245253,
0.0281911734,
-0.0079601165,
0.0914898738,
-0.0203460418,
-0.0138871642,
0.0504450276,
0.0303438585,
0.0431412943,
0.0605857372,
0.0343048647,
-0.0366353989,
-0.0029841729,
0.0111043099,
-0.0104248906,
0.0038562343,
0.003297542,
-0.0427746996,
-0.0007139651,
-0.0056824307,
-0.0141507555,
0.0579205491,
-0.0149387093,
0.0045943377,
-0.0465550981,
0.0044366638,
0.0531646423,
0.1225134134,
-0.0791444033,
0.0216602348,
0.0249377564,
0.0027385962,
-0.0197692085,
0.0010638278,
-0.0173302051,
0.038855046,
-0.0124854473,
-0.0180079844,
-0.0574014671,
0.0065060277,
-0.001837343,
-0.0320020467,
-0.0176351685,
0.0247129109,
0.059134379,
-0.019666113,
0.0197034683,
-0.0122871092,
-0.0106988689,
0.028624557,
0.0172738321,
-0.0730087236,
0.0100888945,
-0.0319793783,
0.0276915133,
0.044622343,
0.0500280932,
-0.0331139229,
-0.0389265008,
-0.0311087165,
0.0371314399,
0.0770896152,
-0.0174737051,
-0.0293167681,
0.0045481385,
-0.0150896814,
-0.0193985123,
-0.0746072009,
-0.0080974586,
0.0216563102,
-0.0139395706,
0.0037742408,
-0.0276943166,
-0.0168502424,
-0.0143717825,
0.0528211482,
-0.0557241403,
0.0089750169,
-0.0870990753,
0.0052422741,
0.0155316098,
0.0205688011,
-0.0243532602,
-0.0142393503,
0.0196940713,
-0.0357175097,
-0.0185583998,
0.0849967748,
-0.0211840123,
-0.0140543319,
0.0268697031,
-0.0918630064,
-0.013489767,
-0.0029420226,
0.0305587668,
-0.0048609143,
0.0263682939,
-0.0611303635,
0.0466359928,
-0.0084244413,
-0.0197485108,
-0.0317994468,
-0.0159493834,
-0.041271124,
0.06076888,
-0.0153410193,
0.0000241831,
-0.0020001039,
-0.0518918261,
0.0466712192,
-0.0403109007,
0.0380013362,
0.0170982759,
0.0160768963,
-0.0582858585,
0.0300059877,
0.0017511639,
-0.0947642103,
-0.0046466645,
-0.094985798,
-0.0213030651,
-0.024229249,
-0.0248532332,
0.0292036459,
-0.0347170569,
-0.0265478045,
-0.0182232186,
-0.0079914266,
-0.010183272,
0.0025646589,
0.0023848992,
0.054238271,
0.0245078355,
0.0017336104,
-0.0061509665,
0.0341461413,
-0.0457251593,
0.0658132359,
0.0599725991,
-0.0210222118,
-0.0796579048,
0.0163899511,
-0.0271706488,
0.0198943708,
0.0002176729,
-0.0284601524,
0.073569186,
0.0308221541,
0.045541741,
0.0820315331,
-0.0156232817,
0.0747681484,
0.0669858828,
-0.0561237223,
-0.0192359611,
0.0126656452,
0.0167793576,
0.0582867339,
-0.0159643125,
-0.0226414632,
0.0136600435,
0.0674263313,
0.0121146636,
0.0199463964,
-0.091312632,
0.0864453763,
-0.0267195348,
-0.037333902,
-0.0319966897,
-0.0294745844,
-0.0038716565,
0.0322514065,
-0.050126113,
0.0239403173,
0.0838702694,
-0.0128089441,
0.0054907491,
-0.0735607296,
0.0295268763,
-0.0084477989,
0.0835476145,
-0.0229704194,
0.0103593571,
0.0408744961,
-0.0191131961,
-0.0359885022,
0.0052691437,
0.0152892182,
0.0060978974,
-0.0039718552,
-0.0738104433,
0.0057293558,
0.0216313358,
-0.0218708254,
-0.0143818446,
0.0105766077,
-0.0643105358,
-0.0128493747,
0.0053570946,
0.0074957577,
-0.0454263091,
0.0163856372,
0.0436098613,
0.0181163326,
0.0120411953,
-0.0255258009,
-0.0150543414,
0.013884794,
0.0706668273,
0.0518858097,
0.0184666291,
-0.0302369222,
0.0362347849,
0.0388589129,
0.0069420692,
-0.0115786921,
0.0002490756,
0.0175047312,
0.0313033201,
-0.0221729465,
-0.0230063703,
0.0273052789,
0.0641058832,
-0.0404171497,
-0.0615852475,
0.1022296473,
0.0466689132,
0.0202499852,
0.0339463577,
-0.0464776829,
-0.0005251468,
0.0365657322,
0.0022080985,
-0.0323476121,
-0.0215026569,
0.0044479151,
-0.0322052017,
0.0193066206,
-0.0889236555,
-0.0048177517,
-0.1010176241,
0.0166140068,
-0.019020604,
-0.1055896282,
-0.0233896747,
-0.0204270612,
0.010584279,
0.0187668297,
-0.0213250443,
-0.0162357185,
0.027423773,
0.0328152813,
0.0132809067,
0.0016860404,
-0.0006173314,
0.0141038392,
-0.0523158684,
0.0972918645,
0.0171991419,
0.0820707753,
0.0093326075,
-0.0592779107,
-0.0311077535,
0.0026562989,
0.0475538895,
-0.0255077314,
0.0290647447,
-0.0131401038,
-0.0044950321,
-0.0162208062,
0.0395996533,
-0.0442619883,
-0.0475454554,
0.0023020268,
0.084382385,
-0.0352360308,
0.0198682453,
-0.0061574061,
0.0588238239,
0.0295442306,
0.060152147,
0.0336934999,
-0.035607893,
-0.0039303307,
-0.0084822709,
0.0261361916,
-0.026298292,
-0.0632946566,
-0.029730767,
-0.0001571183,
0.0334400907,
-0.0774052441,
-0.041119691,
0.0418687277,
0.0625817105,
0.0250572003,
-0.0139522431,
0.0198112391,
0.0319024846,
-0.026392011,
0.0481310673,
-0.0396214649,
-0.019346118,
0.0112048024,
-0.0227632895,
0.0241745654,
-0.0626319125,
0.0098144831,
0.0150767639,
0.0126143135,
-0.0415524654,
0.0301226377,
0.0077749877,
0.0236060806,
0.0303642992,
0.0123489769,
-0.0281457026,
-0.0105467765,
-0.0203210451,
-0.0899078026,
0.0281128772,
-0.0225679409,
0.0101711135,
0.029725235,
-0.0041830563,
0.0010801087,
-0.0223096646,
-0.018835308,
0.0475201346,
-0.054541681,
-0.0204233322,
0.0224559922,
-0.0139418421,
0.0392150395,
-0.0283923224,
-0.0147045134,
-0.0398312509,
-0.001124537,
-0.0385762975,
-0.0159977172,
-0.0183096975,
-0.0035698779,
0.0029002836,
-0.0033450057,
-0.0023464717,
0.0293144565,
-0.0406551547,
0.0733418688,
0.0159571115,
-0.0017420917,
0.0474654138,
0.0088874819,
-0.0424271636,
0.0056777718,
0.0140611511,
0.0027526703,
-0.0554309748,
0.0683610812,
0.0162674803,
0.079559423,
0.0425777957,
-0.068571575,
-0.0101021007,
0.0226721279,
-0.0382851139,
0.0213314109,
0.0288444553,
0.0560532063,
0.0178771764,
-0.0045361295,
0.0069421642,
-0.0108979661,
0.0032712179,
0.0510398895,
-0.012627393,
0.0280025601,
-0.0784104392,
0.0035172536,
0.0443809628,
-0.0232400857,
-0.0182961095,
0.0132483291,
-0.0013222725,
0.0633575171,
0.0127853053,
-0.0100515001,
-0.0261466466,
0.0193421803,
0.007636094,
0.04106782,
0.0039602383,
0.0517137498,
-0.0905206501,
-0.0245636478,
0.018992234,
0.0644104108,
-0.0076816203,
-0.0167985409,
0.0399697684,
0.0271933228,
0.0156231942,
-0.0451131836,
0.0074719936,
0.0552753806,
-0.0572507083,
-0.0019928603,
-0.0572711304,
-5.871457264e-33,
-0.07811106,
-0.0535732247,
0.0424489751,
0.0144526688,
-0.0437000692,
0.0113935545,
-0.0617980659,
0.0095381141,
0.0098567763,
0.0129425488,
0.0004922295,
0.0261379406,
-0.0116412584,
-0.0269963797,
-0.0180587061,
-0.0398545526,
-0.0042121778,
-0.0086414367,
-0.0339228325,
-0.0144860381,
0.0530098602,
-0.0038367815,
0.0440138616,
-0.0758903101,
0.0091181137,
0.0186415017,
0.0155588342,
0.0204643998,
-0.0192342922,
0.0076743523,
-0.0401308946,
0.0225716941,
0.0299421586,
-0.0348596014,
0.0271399356,
0.0406202301,
-0.0553040095,
-0.059441518,
0.0327081233,
0.0178247113,
-0.0208009128,
-0.0219266023,
-0.0104712984,
-0.0125815282,
0.0063382681,
0.0191222075,
0.0567922071,
-0.0408301651,
0.0286464207,
-0.018287966,
-0.0630331188,
-0.0127573591,
-0.0525822006,
-0.0164445322,
-0.017971402,
0.0151998494,
0.005692008,
-0.0013669536,
-0.0408117287,
0.0301936604,
-0.0092426054,
-0.0381834991,
0.0477600507,
-0.0013821925,
0.0432823151,
0.0904308185,
0.0019434276,
0.0468895435,
-0.1024260223,
0.0032516832,
0.0582402162,
0.0120767988,
0.0480588302,
0.0297345296,
-0.0310729947,
0.0321774967,
-0.0603376329,
0.0241354443,
0.0171990078,
0.0430193059,
0.011573582,
0.024427034,
-0.0319352821,
-0.0073334808,
-0.0408109985,
-0.011452252,
0.0121382773,
-0.0148829995,
0.0081978627,
-0.0459996983,
-0.0545892566,
-0.0335587934,
0.0022141258,
-0.0369793288,
0.0097482326,
0.0408405997,
0.0110442247,
0.0048579308,
-0.004533119,
-0.0141119985,
-0.0242869388,
-0.0115170311,
0.0177595783,
0.0264774412,
0.04180637,
-0.0001846852,
-0.0169643629,
0.0303076636,
0.0171840005,
-0.0346578807,
-0.023785403,
0.0082628876,
0.0176225305,
-0.0030440718,
0.0374661125,
0.0005766119,
-0.0300885998,
-0.0071184384,
0.0447467417,
-0.0126424842,
0.0013338883,
0.011474845,
-0.0356398858,
0.0133398604,
-0.0161114372,
-0.0262492653,
-0.0208358597,
0.0160277132,
0.02214217,
-0.0650975406,
-0.0186827648,
0.0018604454,
2.898e-7,
-0.0014378882,
0.0532280877,
0.0389324464,
-0.0481609255,
0.0025092536,
0.0142575055,
0.0091813663,
0.0062780771,
-0.0080478815,
-0.0912403837,
0.0029767,
0.0625261366,
0.0035324309,
0.0021395634,
-0.0833268538,
-0.0142934304,
-0.0206559747,
0.0000079267,
-0.0389509425,
0.0112276925,
0.0285617001,
-0.0132483197,
0.0338104144,
0.018043451,
-0.0130393747,
0.0010791539,
0.0036190988,
-0.0548926182,
0.0437497646,
-0.0026697526,
-0.002409349,
-0.0229785275,
-0.0243480802,
0.0122048808,
0.0346796438,
0.0277630929,
0.0192728452,
0.0139578795,
-0.0313250832,
0.0226441231,
-0.0154770901,
-0.0570756085,
-0.0159928799,
-0.0472454466,
0.0596056506,
-0.0923493281,
-0.0452428907,
-0.0072773672,
-0.0231337566,
-0.0404579267,
-0.0153289922,
0.0044803103,
-0.0091708694,
-0.0095163193,
-0.0146918865,
-0.0291747414,
0.0140405046,
-0.0657905489,
-0.0183008946,
0.0028930961,
-0.024848789,
0.0103427768,
-0.033260081,
-0.024569001,
0.0110660065,
-0.0763151422,
-0.0210802741,
2.408108084e-34,
-0.0493364818,
0.0062352717,
0.0127434162,
0.0174655337,
0.0663504601,
-0.0101097552,
0.0189275667,
-0.0009292157,
0.0667698607,
-0.0285228491,
0.0166633185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02547v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02547v2 | Integration of cognitive tasks into artificial general intelligence test for large models | 2024-02-04T15:50:42 | 2024-03-06T02:46:40 | Youzhi Qu, Chen Wei, Penghui Du, Wenxin Che, Chi Zhang, Wanli Ouyang, Yatao Bian, Feiyang Xu, Bin Hu, Kai Du, Haiyan Wu, Jia Liu, Quanying Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | During the evolution of large models, performance evaluation is necessarily
performed to assess their capabilities and ensure safety before practical
application. However, current model evaluations mainly rely on specific tasks
and datasets, lacking a united framework for assessing the multidimensional
intelligence of large models. In this perspective, we advocate for a
comprehensive framework of cognitive science-inspired artificial general
intelligence (AGI) tests, aimed at fulfilling the testing needs of large models
with enhanced capabilities. The cognitive science-inspired AGI tests encompass
the full spectrum of intelligence facets, including crystallized intelligence,
fluid intelligence, social intelligence, and embodied intelligence. To assess
the multidimensional intelligence of large models, the AGI tests consist of a
battery of well-designed cognitive tests adopted from human intelligence tests,
and then naturally encapsulates into an immersive virtual community. We propose
increasing the complexity of AGI testing tasks commensurate with advancements
in large models and emphasizing the necessity for the interpretation of test
results to avoid false negatives and false positives. We believe that cognitive
science-inspired AGI tests will effectively guide the targeted improvement of
large models in specific dimensions of intelligence and accelerate the
integration of large models into human society. | [
0.0040525082,
0.0598018467,
-0.0578945316,
-0.0133379921,
-0.0191542897,
0.0282770693,
0.0567526035,
0.0220396649,
0.0565195829,
-0.0011329637,
-0.0446146168,
-0.0513336807,
-0.0212156605,
0.0389568321,
0.0693603456,
-0.0210085213,
0.0513969511,
-0.0409437828,
0.0256361421,
0.007130737,
-0.0705983788,
-0.044580549,
0.0002946522,
0.0072748926,
0.0090404516,
-0.0025521803,
0.014158641,
-0.0187871829,
0.0369648077,
-0.0475415178,
-0.0444336571,
0.0274336487,
0.027316954,
0.0365087166,
0.000002359,
-0.0487721786,
0.0265554935,
0.0062997062,
-0.0453093275,
0.0006994058,
0.0434248187,
0.0368555784,
0.0126855541,
0.0106048035,
-0.0266742986,
0.0121607967,
0.0048689335,
0.0233569574,
0.0100196227,
0.0208414253,
-0.0018314556,
0.015564831,
0.0599569753,
-0.01261805,
0.0078757918,
0.0066863941,
0.0249683801,
0.0357689187,
0.0303339045,
-0.0438901484,
0.0214921255,
0.0295632202,
0.0483686626,
0.021707654,
0.0049149091,
0.0276333913,
-0.011361083,
-0.0218851808,
-0.0140736224,
0.0255099423,
0.010234396,
0.0087543791,
-0.0070931218,
0.0365525112,
0.0288528614,
0.0311309043,
-0.0553031676,
0.0175108928,
0.0309438836,
-0.0624183305,
0.0148172081,
0.0361045003,
0.0520378761,
-0.0073564262,
-0.0369558744,
0.0614360832,
0.0244704559,
-0.0207846761,
0.0148764346,
-0.0131816166,
-0.0656576306,
-0.0001375045,
-0.0349305086,
-0.0086632865,
-0.056496378,
-0.065993458,
0.0117973303,
0.0153067503,
0.0193523131,
-0.0223396812,
0.1214318648,
0.0273672976,
0.0470632203,
0.0279633049,
-0.0188109372,
0.1007899046,
-0.0159913264,
0.0229268596,
-0.0212547686,
0.0067330105,
-0.0620382428,
-0.0010849701,
0.0239777323,
0.0325652659,
0.0035936099,
-0.040937379,
-0.0174158067,
0.0121026179,
-0.0744523853,
0.0037169063,
-0.0492685512,
0.0414736569,
0.0604078881,
0.0243779346,
-0.0497668125,
-0.0600512363,
-0.0613603145,
0.0192628819,
-0.0005994519,
-0.0033930996,
0.0022970543,
-0.0030004284,
-0.0113467285,
-0.0016498757,
0.0143349115,
0.0901578516,
0.0246379171,
-0.0257631782,
-0.0021688764,
-0.0245687701,
0.0361659937,
-0.06626378,
0.0500814356,
0.0016029418,
0.0392935202,
0.0017434027,
0.0152687421,
0.002390689,
-0.0253624376,
-0.0265358202,
-0.0058929892,
0.0241059083,
0.0150122605,
0.0137381069,
0.0398580506,
0.0099470392,
0.0029169193,
0.0562862903,
0.0154525144,
-0.0049874359,
-0.002231163,
0.019547645,
0.0223757867,
0.0164557807,
-0.0166033264,
0.0164506249,
0.0044933637,
0.0076821614,
0.0055213724,
0.0410216749,
-0.0077740992,
0.0160216894,
-0.0252743214,
0.0071669258,
0.0475275926,
0.0704199672,
-0.0398794077,
0.0148187978,
0.0689879283,
-0.0083968779,
0.0127087478,
-0.0186530687,
-0.079772085,
0.0444351919,
-0.0728563219,
-0.0011306204,
-0.0077236169,
0.0315983593,
-0.026102541,
-0.0333279036,
0.000785313,
0.0077817114,
0.0537918918,
0.0248312075,
0.0224704482,
-0.0542713515,
0.0030473047,
-0.0333387852,
-0.0009318616,
-0.021298416,
-0.0504344702,
-0.0800979882,
0.0407693349,
0.0256664027,
0.0245971698,
0.0028727881,
-0.0478648581,
0.0267185941,
-0.0001981151,
0.0249197185,
0.0624023564,
-0.0172481835,
-0.0251127854,
0.0107580479,
0.0023854785,
-0.0051441067,
0.0302886721,
0.0405135714,
0.0004262113,
-0.0065323194,
-0.0059231534,
0.0284359455,
-0.0216738004,
0.0151846036,
-0.0455289334,
0.0329054296,
-0.0791636631,
-0.0019653132,
0.0836577266,
0.0024005263,
-0.0036359269,
-0.0233589336,
0.0360623784,
-0.0078203594,
-0.0405302383,
0.0056535364,
-0.0031683687,
0.0784215108,
-0.0227790866,
-0.0234878957,
0.0019020744,
0.0490940101,
0.0425911769,
0.0027827937,
0.0558160283,
-0.0294337496,
0.0279021934,
0.0013075413,
0.0539420061,
-0.0629684106,
-0.0086025828,
0.0260338653,
0.0539192222,
-0.0022674459,
-0.0031976693,
0.0118946917,
-0.0255285576,
0.0529325344,
-0.0587194338,
-0.000294621,
-0.0100761065,
-0.0214229189,
-0.0104939155,
0.0137005644,
-0.0133177089,
-0.0580306388,
0.0079041217,
-0.0974702165,
-0.0013303951,
0.0116478167,
0.0061748791,
-0.0084423441,
-0.0473359004,
-0.0109644439,
0.0458676778,
0.0117487339,
0.0234785452,
0.0541927181,
0.0052570808,
-0.0112670986,
-0.0427881628,
-0.0106394589,
-0.029270051,
0.0199321136,
-0.0495224781,
0.0677810907,
0.0611572601,
0.0163041446,
-0.0060479837,
-0.0070134443,
-0.0529490858,
-0.0016899961,
-0.0030302377,
-0.0664677396,
0.0532490499,
0.0096564405,
0.0136868162,
0.1015704647,
0.0015616558,
0.0109132053,
0.0310375616,
0.003820495,
0.0074608466,
0.0200614054,
0.0102064023,
0.0445834771,
-0.0135114575,
-0.0348389335,
-0.0202361587,
0.0612724945,
-0.0232129581,
0.0336825773,
-0.0199227352,
0.0962037221,
-0.0578251183,
-0.0785152093,
-0.0204933863,
0.0187015627,
0.0034762821,
0.0191538054,
-0.056964796,
-0.003987398,
0.0386279523,
0.015956182,
0.0139152445,
0.0251803175,
0.0106716249,
0.0048241215,
0.0511490777,
0.031710919,
0.0031425538,
-0.0243227202,
0.0294702314,
-0.0294852946,
0.0039623198,
-0.0353942625,
-0.0209079124,
-0.0316280015,
-0.0805718228,
-0.023771381,
0.0313915052,
-0.0524425544,
-0.0386008881,
0.0608680323,
-0.0363543592,
0.0495794937,
0.017687859,
-0.0586102195,
-0.0931052417,
-0.0018467654,
0.0426400378,
-0.0361335054,
-0.0355002396,
-0.0001627756,
0.0135946935,
-0.0088183545,
0.0279044881,
0.0729988217,
0.0300868731,
-0.0436474979,
0.0436359458,
0.0439334437,
-0.0017249985,
-0.0007019078,
-0.0302220248,
0.0512296259,
0.0104990574,
-0.0042128679,
-0.005461459,
0.0053577768,
0.0460158847,
-0.0198588204,
-0.0134715829,
0.0998773202,
0.0058971322,
0.0151436394,
0.0173197445,
0.0082863579,
-0.0485874116,
0.0442079753,
0.0068610413,
-0.0294414535,
-0.0009063208,
-0.0089265723,
-0.0249798186,
-0.0448203869,
-0.042447608,
0.0609117597,
-0.0769066364,
0.0480409749,
0.0028620146,
-0.0533747338,
-0.0269841906,
-0.0207112748,
0.0468427651,
-0.013055807,
-0.0348810405,
-0.0100066541,
0.0253794231,
-0.0260472335,
-0.0387663506,
-0.0339727849,
-0.0358818844,
0.0611953661,
-0.0594865456,
0.0477847308,
0.0460169911,
0.0428838953,
-0.039568197,
-0.0716126338,
-0.0122251734,
-0.0045360499,
0.0368450508,
0.0124623058,
0.0409006141,
0.0115413172,
0.0411244519,
-0.0297555495,
0.0019544191,
0.018301256,
-0.0101990206,
0.0204819702,
0.0681577325,
-0.0252006147,
-0.084208712,
-0.0285912473,
0.0018482016,
-0.0115503445,
0.0689878389,
-0.0030782786,
-0.0528247394,
-0.0362916104,
-0.016477691,
-0.0304329842,
-0.0280359983,
-0.0746256709,
0.002559239,
0.0553404614,
0.0091977278,
-0.038840957,
-0.0210785735,
0.0312852673,
0.0023935153,
-0.0017020283,
-0.075785093,
-0.0075492123,
-0.0020477003,
-0.0358675048,
0.0138512924,
-0.0038960346,
-0.0091912877,
-0.0453908034,
-0.0261769332,
0.0055293674,
-0.066657424,
-0.0075718332,
0.0383881368,
-0.0012830856,
-0.0255410764,
0.0380657017,
0.0255900454,
0.0306165852,
-0.0370088071,
-0.0504818447,
-0.0032592567,
0.0844431072,
-0.0550903566,
-0.0708072707,
0.0463029072,
-0.0118444646,
0.0191752855,
-0.009610272,
0.0022966103,
-0.0176667441,
0.0451270007,
0.0011050954,
-0.0292603318,
0.0029628945,
-0.0194255318,
-0.0148397731,
0.0345067084,
0.0268272106,
0.0309418179,
-0.0083364109,
0.0090669161,
-0.0398269184,
-0.0193364378,
-0.0002894094,
-0.000695174,
-0.0257962421,
0.0071441825,
0.0397768952,
-0.0030737221,
0.0142130563,
0.0302495584,
-0.0094624823,
-0.075345546,
-0.0247901138,
-0.0134594254,
0.0106042987,
-0.0423208363,
0.0202689897,
-0.0085139032,
-0.0152931549,
-0.0832923353,
0.0365172848,
0.0183845349,
0.0812311769,
-0.030879667,
-0.0138759343,
-0.0634573698,
0.0561741404,
-0.0782877058,
-0.0557014607,
0.0030148348,
0.0880701691,
0.0295558553,
0.0518424958,
-0.0157146547,
-0.0647970736,
-0.0023989759,
-0.024443293,
-0.0278665554,
0.0067397431,
-0.0338013396,
-0.0172796287,
0.0555213355,
-0.0214694124,
-0.0172454212,
0.0026718171,
0.0058482909,
0.0496262871,
-0.0571821965,
-0.0130965877,
-0.0395572111,
-0.020819135,
-0.005518869,
0.0346540436,
-0.0125664603,
-0.0018173673,
-0.0586386733,
-0.0506022237,
0.0025388331,
0.0846015811,
0.0113094561,
0.0022924424,
-0.0063300943,
0.0236611813,
-0.0354385637,
-0.0706640333,
0.0247639455,
-0.0451254919,
-0.074027136,
0.0150199858,
-0.0311334878,
-6.838493487e-33,
0.0020931966,
0.0086562103,
0.0200993754,
-0.0293898266,
-0.0213533286,
-0.0293485858,
-0.0228944365,
0.0360874198,
-0.0221719332,
-0.0173313376,
0.0071420451,
-0.0033185817,
-0.0135617526,
-0.0296051614,
0.0334413759,
0.0152467592,
0.0122398958,
-0.0291940179,
-0.0322230309,
0.0257653352,
-0.0315854698,
-0.0286819376,
-0.0041691642,
-0.0723805502,
0.0022486355,
0.0033535454,
0.0188958775,
-0.0232517999,
-0.0650363639,
0.037495967,
-0.0570098758,
0.0116439983,
0.0398471504,
-0.0094814291,
0.0174069535,
-0.0002057783,
-0.0345436931,
-0.0108623123,
-0.0074584624,
-0.0466431044,
-0.0673146248,
-0.0702215284,
-0.0006296566,
0.0001545924,
-0.0508129634,
-0.0194478463,
0.0321224257,
-0.0329422913,
0.0514196381,
-0.016699506,
-0.0676461011,
0.0021513421,
-0.0211979095,
0.0176812951,
-0.0246938113,
0.0109259924,
-0.0362614132,
-0.0011481551,
-0.0181429349,
0.0431313328,
-0.0237300992,
-0.0845744833,
0.0388257094,
0.0177782308,
0.0447290838,
0.053619951,
0.036379721,
0.0219993033,
-0.0113193784,
-0.0350438617,
0.0420980677,
0.0809509605,
0.0608653203,
0.0470638946,
-0.0021528322,
-0.0237449817,
-0.0302570686,
0.0199164506,
0.0078287618,
0.0108715491,
0.0407948531,
-0.0122766877,
-0.055860348,
0.0041722334,
0.0067459578,
-0.0167848393,
-0.0262661576,
-0.0056301802,
0.0328068137,
-0.0308962353,
-0.0046702172,
-0.0169031732,
0.0395686179,
-0.0432626195,
0.0629131272,
-0.0085994815,
0.0209027752,
0.0573539212,
0.0197597053,
-0.0139167616,
-0.006541695,
-0.043128781,
0.0060606869,
0.0535135269,
0.0573869124,
-0.0187760461,
-0.0191283375,
0.0248418357,
0.0220786892,
-0.0184566025,
-0.019447336,
-0.0108701466,
0.0741536766,
-0.0441703573,
0.036816638,
0.0160371549,
0.0231097583,
-0.0659274831,
-0.0044601937,
0.0172211006,
-0.0366651937,
0.0428101905,
-0.0515423752,
-0.0050255461,
-0.0019603691,
-0.0107513703,
-0.0707248598,
-0.003942329,
-0.029267326,
-0.0513304621,
-0.0035234042,
0.0146177085,
3.196e-7,
-0.0358842351,
0.0689523146,
-0.0236198548,
-0.0038917498,
0.0141722597,
0.0135241058,
-0.0139027024,
0.0036190501,
0.0400625318,
-0.0015729971,
0.0308527164,
0.0572616458,
0.0442302413,
-0.0008188148,
-0.0351323076,
-0.0461727083,
0.0221004616,
-0.0142355282,
-0.0476552099,
0.0164312553,
0.0089998879,
0.0313079581,
0.0313770287,
0.0096750623,
0.0388412513,
-0.0492602997,
0.0044601369,
-0.0447030589,
0.0223425813,
-0.0060544824,
-0.0152373565,
0.0368641056,
0.0032937101,
0.0762747303,
0.0270976592,
-0.0028820876,
-0.0188772995,
0.0118490234,
0.0189534891,
0.0296113417,
0.0003080343,
-0.0040668496,
0.0346270613,
-0.0472783782,
0.0838587284,
-0.0737183765,
-0.0339895301,
-0.0046861996,
-0.0198089257,
-0.0055562342,
0.0011818977,
0.0112947701,
0.0094109084,
0.0098621016,
-0.0105401464,
-0.018978728,
0.0113777304,
-0.0179240201,
0.0252507776,
0.0289970879,
-0.0652109906,
-0.0852023363,
-0.0377421826,
-0.0257368051,
0.0323244035,
-0.0664487332,
-0.0083877463,
2.909065206e-34,
0.0071093128,
0.0257342067,
0.0324384123,
-0.0588430837,
0.0825359151,
-0.0161907021,
-0.0346752778,
-0.0200130399,
0.0205723327,
-0.0643945932,
0.0170580335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02541v1 | Knowledge Generation for Zero-shot Knowledge-based VQA | 2024-02-04T15:41:35 | 2024-02-04T15:41:35 | Rui Cao, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Previous solutions to knowledge-based visual question answering~(K-VQA)
retrieve knowledge from external knowledge bases and use supervised learning to
train the K-VQA model. Recently pre-trained LLMs have been used as both a
knowledge source and a zero-shot QA model for K-VQA and demonstrated promising
results. However, these recent methods do not explicitly show the knowledge
needed to answer the questions and thus lack interpretability. Inspired by
recent work on knowledge generation from LLMs for text-based QA, in this work
we propose and test a similar knowledge-generation-based K-VQA method, which
first generates knowledge from an LLM and then incorporates the generated
knowledge for K-VQA in a zero-shot manner. We evaluate our method on two K-VQA
benchmarks and found that our method performs better than previous zero-shot
K-VQA methods and our generated knowledge is generally relevant and helpful. | [
0.0209809784,
0.0032313503,
-0.0101334173,
0.0634522811,
0.0064950287,
-0.0151217263,
0.003405808,
0.0389070138,
0.0100361072,
-0.0629924312,
-0.0235225316,
0.0054647606,
-0.0465852171,
0.0346566923,
0.0613256432,
-0.009682714,
0.0324947834,
-0.0214873981,
-0.0202110391,
-0.016140135,
0.0126930149,
-0.0149530442,
-0.0191230159,
0.0084598707,
-0.055654414,
-0.037632592,
-0.039704401,
-0.0020372544,
0.0193296894,
-0.0355343707,
-0.0372857191,
0.0188359804,
0.0345319472,
-0.0239492282,
0.0000019834,
-0.0058553438,
0.0059915837,
-0.0010731558,
-0.0430721007,
-0.0263717789,
-0.0488411225,
-0.0212859679,
0.0295087602,
0.0232752096,
-0.058342997,
-0.004937748,
0.0382195078,
0.0179053117,
0.0546819568,
0.0384769216,
-0.0177551433,
0.007419908,
0.0044935942,
0.0204305351,
0.0641372353,
-0.0539911091,
-0.0025462611,
0.031258326,
0.0182727426,
-0.0223475993,
-0.0481015369,
0.0499167703,
0.0210971385,
-0.0014323818,
0.0174806956,
0.0534614399,
-0.0330465622,
-0.0039368141,
-0.0170605574,
0.1251904368,
0.0118248938,
0.0114466827,
-0.0046019019,
0.0039499877,
-0.0041912296,
0.0277271122,
-0.0602494776,
0.058347512,
0.0002283002,
-0.0134849027,
-0.0665890425,
0.0342225805,
-0.0146014495,
-0.0298937988,
-0.0007736506,
-0.0089858323,
0.004799312,
0.0010584329,
-0.017635189,
0.0097370856,
-0.0485305898,
-0.0677976012,
-0.0901277512,
0.0931898803,
0.0320161991,
0.0223143995,
-0.0008097463,
-0.0139123257,
0.0101214638,
-0.0297237039,
0.0548240952,
0.0319540203,
-0.0407685973,
0.0405167751,
-0.0473473147,
0.0580053069,
-0.0075097131,
0.0088640219,
-0.0423899665,
-0.0139952116,
-0.0553165823,
-0.0199404396,
-0.0247394145,
0.0481091589,
-0.0276372749,
-0.0429833867,
-0.0114922039,
0.0211489554,
-0.0106661953,
0.0023196773,
0.0021827382,
0.0479691774,
0.0170389172,
0.0148282526,
-0.0782269239,
0.0480646528,
-0.0532778762,
0.0184464958,
-0.0494084731,
-0.0319579318,
-0.0062583601,
0.035597574,
0.042711217,
0.0102431308,
-0.0033120762,
0.0735047013,
-0.0396189615,
-0.0063200127,
-0.0441565439,
-0.0441627949,
-0.0123126013,
-0.0298747346,
0.0533749722,
-0.0457947329,
0.0098691862,
-0.0105798822,
-0.0242177844,
0.0057003205,
0.0272483137,
0.0345566683,
-0.0304470435,
0.073209323,
-0.0669999421,
-0.0115927011,
-0.0005908742,
0.0192876663,
0.0150021669,
0.0820805877,
-0.0026390781,
0.0067464304,
0.0318439826,
0.0179072376,
0.046324905,
0.020849932,
0.0297903009,
0.013867449,
-0.0418758914,
0.029923575,
0.0042652115,
0.0080930945,
0.0090661757,
0.0081615457,
-0.0612669326,
-0.0277948324,
0.0061138873,
0.0386878401,
0.0454141311,
-0.010411554,
0.0268210135,
0.0015073402,
0.0239655338,
-0.0082130227,
-0.0000200836,
0.0889541805,
-0.0484902188,
0.0162706785,
-0.019088015,
0.0006445008,
-0.0643185377,
-0.0415997468,
0.0004558404,
-0.0138509246,
-0.016593188,
0.0218695067,
0.0404112451,
0.0518023819,
-0.0365142226,
0.008079025,
-0.0026712276,
-0.0213691778,
-0.0256538223,
-0.0213964749,
0.10693001,
0.0591826625,
0.0302628204,
0.0059942612,
-0.0514138564,
0.0127074448,
0.0044395584,
0.0233182888,
-0.0567775518,
-0.0108383968,
-0.00769252,
-0.0499674641,
-0.0492723212,
-0.0570391715,
-0.0067034028,
-0.0097737499,
0.0168338474,
0.0377840474,
0.0036665816,
-0.0344422422,
0.060328871,
0.011587075,
0.0043785623,
-0.0275054816,
0.0181448981,
0.0152240042,
-0.028254021,
0.0228969548,
0.004978817,
-0.001344952,
0.018560905,
-0.0297613647,
-0.013168348,
-0.0082936957,
-0.0118680438,
-0.0777490512,
0.0312312748,
-0.0517451316,
0.0186442304,
-0.0110033257,
-0.0440061092,
-0.0320197456,
0.0213257018,
0.0214775819,
-0.0223722532,
-0.0495924763,
-0.0574986413,
0.0530303083,
-0.0084820371,
-0.0064849472,
0.0765695646,
-0.009706527,
-0.0271657035,
0.0070465603,
0.0049216598,
0.0494115427,
-0.0273825582,
0.0150586665,
-0.0131427059,
0.0089099649,
0.0154976556,
-0.0359605849,
0.0277987048,
-0.0582173578,
0.0151678957,
-0.0982866958,
0.0077354754,
-0.0083005512,
-0.0193124246,
0.0321393572,
-0.0211774018,
0.0026403726,
-0.0322378501,
-0.0710754842,
0.0587469004,
0.0099374456,
-0.0201707631,
0.0562293902,
0.0343777798,
0.0267580207,
-0.0159862768,
0.0113520753,
0.0193779655,
0.0825017393,
0.020731058,
0.0224537365,
-0.0024644106,
0.022194352,
-0.0952876657,
0.0342863798,
0.0081554176,
-0.0206655581,
0.0296571236,
-0.0205089077,
-0.0046182419,
0.0277682692,
-0.0094857793,
-0.0029979134,
0.0128060151,
-0.0151041299,
-0.0278813224,
0.02017246,
0.0085662259,
-0.0484744012,
0.0304883346,
-0.0165300742,
-0.0373167433,
0.0159182437,
-0.0261191819,
-0.0245068986,
-0.0812587067,
0.0802725852,
0.0549618378,
-0.0244806614,
-0.0698268339,
0.044828333,
0.0241409969,
0.064700231,
-0.0269659534,
-0.0267626848,
0.0074658007,
-0.0107275732,
0.0158111602,
0.0431918949,
0.0141959619,
-0.0436481051,
0.05978062,
-0.0148980208,
0.0193396639,
-0.0167222433,
0.031273026,
-0.0433323756,
-0.0356434844,
0.0004495066,
-0.0058935112,
0.0359688513,
-0.0384122618,
0.0405536816,
-0.0249395147,
0.0114559019,
-0.070138678,
0.0023945873,
-0.0335228704,
0.0301211681,
-0.0701384097,
-0.0052319737,
0.0335078612,
0.0093915062,
0.032388296,
-0.0232554022,
-0.0141292848,
-0.0005697748,
-0.0147702564,
0.0645420104,
0.073103793,
0.027376445,
-0.0271408316,
-0.0081816884,
0.0355674326,
0.0677760541,
0.0119003961,
0.013256643,
-0.0052157962,
0.0067254566,
-0.0109730624,
0.0156704355,
0.0017109391,
0.0350222662,
0.0114722494,
-0.018314898,
0.0089924922,
0.0660153106,
0.0333337598,
0.0083485218,
-0.0067110048,
-0.0331804417,
-0.0128926421,
0.0376381278,
0.060583856,
-0.1586943865,
-0.0421821326,
-0.0483325832,
0.0116356928,
0.0047826618,
-0.0192599855,
-0.022924481,
-0.0961758047,
0.0603255443,
-0.0108927265,
-0.0397078134,
0.0045995824,
0.0237469021,
-0.0166155454,
0.0074060415,
-0.0328544341,
0.0109859072,
-0.0156717785,
0.0341765396,
-0.0054878653,
0.0167393368,
-0.0204503797,
0.0387022533,
-0.0339835063,
0.0029371106,
0.0288061108,
0.0239109006,
-0.0127244964,
-0.0720793307,
-0.0577948205,
-0.0485986844,
0.0375288725,
-0.0080079362,
0.0524353869,
-0.0100592645,
-0.0480195917,
0.0155983474,
0.0148914149,
0.0011963532,
0.0010225326,
0.0263116732,
0.0354780667,
-0.0167200696,
-0.0259965975,
-0.0058182906,
0.0148711838,
-0.0067801443,
0.0382868797,
0.0341596566,
0.0065905848,
-0.043817319,
-0.0059546223,
-0.0081662452,
-0.0625407696,
-0.0734171867,
0.0048191957,
0.027939884,
-0.0115876058,
-0.1032064259,
-0.0177324563,
0.0826949701,
0.0887003615,
-0.0381668471,
-0.0111132246,
-0.0205067489,
0.0190656185,
-0.0404131711,
0.0129743423,
-0.0365473032,
0.0152870705,
-0.0323180296,
0.0022431316,
0.020922659,
-0.0596944466,
-0.0186808538,
-0.0436973348,
0.0023647456,
-0.0152123412,
-0.054465048,
0.1012479886,
0.0046788235,
0.01952173,
0.0318809338,
-0.0140165547,
0.0768675357,
0.0411630832,
0.0092795826,
0.0328006111,
-0.0077766613,
0.0176733844,
0.0055731162,
0.0030641449,
-0.0536419004,
0.0023805278,
-0.0098858476,
0.0546183698,
-0.0689430535,
0.0043334593,
0.0020133813,
0.0201082118,
-0.0235537291,
0.002429259,
0.0041198344,
0.0082290843,
0.0186858196,
-0.0266506206,
0.0049951631,
-0.0941552445,
0.0077180727,
-0.0059104436,
-0.0222969428,
0.0159922708,
-0.0350513346,
-0.0747420937,
0.0309877116,
-0.0054284842,
-0.0255063716,
0.0536296256,
0.0108075542,
-0.0035269291,
0.0012069352,
0.0076627368,
0.0059100967,
0.0013027823,
0.0599055625,
0.0216455404,
0.0731041506,
0.0183729529,
-0.0028375718,
-0.0597530343,
0.0268347729,
-0.006323982,
-0.0694880113,
0.014640999,
0.0697213858,
0.0723811984,
0.0356902033,
-0.0279320832,
0.0153074656,
-0.0122341029,
0.0306156836,
-0.0072510056,
-0.021724632,
-0.0395447984,
0.0790844932,
0.0277231336,
0.0111065032,
-0.0279391073,
0.0974219665,
0.0084853545,
0.0285278019,
-0.0558012314,
0.0128002465,
-0.023852855,
0.0073870802,
0.0480785593,
0.0019993193,
0.0364366844,
0.0459928028,
-0.0519321784,
-0.0664681941,
0.0444430821,
0.0044557601,
-0.048506014,
0.0100039309,
0.0496146455,
-0.007139917,
0.0648768917,
-0.0116809113,
-0.0163937937,
-0.0046723308,
-0.0350627005,
0.0067767422,
0.0333175063,
-6.344300968e-33,
-0.0436788909,
-0.0787472874,
0.0861474648,
-0.024407912,
-0.001262113,
0.0223128777,
-0.0100858975,
-0.0108630201,
-0.0104694013,
-0.0103116175,
0.0158921592,
-0.0484698564,
-0.0118514141,
0.0228260607,
-0.0259136651,
-0.0485250019,
-0.0149320867,
-0.0205086339,
0.0128349513,
-0.0011755207,
0.0037627751,
0.0107887173,
0.0124810264,
-0.0054249484,
-0.0172644947,
-0.0191568919,
0.0019799315,
0.0209885612,
0.0168897621,
0.060690295,
-0.0256951675,
0.0077384599,
0.0161988325,
-0.0051078997,
0.017487973,
-0.022403948,
-0.0501262359,
-0.0623662509,
0.0388857722,
-0.0162336584,
-0.0885579139,
-0.0011847832,
0.0116565255,
-0.007472137,
0.0351567864,
-0.0292231254,
0.0408208556,
-0.0036866921,
0.0023522866,
-0.0395382158,
-0.0177876484,
-0.0106090736,
-0.0125309667,
-0.0493169799,
0.0178023688,
0.049469009,
0.0350245908,
-0.0089455033,
-0.0651108474,
0.0152469343,
0.0152430041,
-0.0229254626,
0.0870468169,
0.0151948743,
0.0172590762,
0.0257116742,
-0.0010882685,
-0.0389400907,
-0.0920195952,
0.0050783865,
-0.0146821197,
0.0563627779,
0.0482946448,
0.0292483382,
0.0031758824,
0.0219413396,
-0.0596649498,
0.0166527517,
-0.0737885535,
0.0539759323,
-0.0350366235,
-0.0400707647,
0.0152561991,
-0.0124050518,
-0.0427559726,
0.0187959932,
-0.0446124822,
-0.0087578036,
0.051439438,
0.0305265654,
-0.0076858695,
0.0154099641,
0.0368162729,
-0.0223951656,
0.0384882763,
0.0256052501,
-0.0116818659,
0.0507754833,
0.0011680395,
0.0033532262,
-0.0580097176,
0.0439596102,
0.0753924623,
-0.0192526616,
-0.0130304359,
0.0490693413,
0.0270314775,
0.0061717574,
-0.0234602783,
-0.0229234323,
-0.0251212995,
0.024116287,
-0.0147134867,
-0.0332200676,
-0.0322454572,
0.031403441,
-0.0423308387,
-0.0063080397,
-0.0109993815,
-0.0019440157,
0.0380282588,
-0.0419699177,
-0.0081377467,
0.0301798917,
-0.0497933365,
0.0241097398,
-0.0141910752,
-0.0066098035,
-0.0236532632,
-0.0610953681,
-0.0034010417,
0.0600324571,
2.54e-7,
0.03624928,
-0.0211951174,
-0.0151618458,
0.037950784,
-0.0019150916,
0.0394382775,
-0.0170743316,
-0.0068965717,
0.0012874783,
-0.03555784,
0.0120835304,
0.0940292031,
-0.0109381769,
0.0081599513,
-0.0402257293,
0.0422070622,
0.0180527605,
-0.0455451384,
-0.0503834486,
-0.0034572273,
0.0781432241,
-0.0001884615,
-0.0228040144,
-0.0074992999,
0.0436233953,
-0.0309474971,
0.0849285275,
0.0439005457,
0.0064001889,
-0.0353152417,
0.0492647551,
-0.0081940321,
-0.0169069953,
0.0268683322,
0.0216006301,
-0.0036256008,
0.0039579398,
0.0140499659,
-0.0285904687,
-0.0419123434,
-0.0036205896,
0.0064188465,
0.0094995573,
0.0068979901,
0.1176487952,
-0.0259338729,
-0.0214858372,
0.0104996953,
-0.0533270501,
0.0016079245,
0.0114542395,
0.0079631917,
-0.0098398244,
0.0187847018,
0.039221935,
-0.0314622745,
-0.0167756844,
-0.0331053473,
0.0234487113,
-0.028818056,
-0.0027800361,
-0.0022092853,
-0.0172814969,
-0.0240982044,
0.0125829736,
-0.0019588156,
-0.0479394235,
1.62976288e-34,
0.010789386,
-0.001631321,
0.0091973869,
0.0355031714,
-0.0024217227,
-0.0189011805,
-0.0179434381,
-0.0282430891,
0.0316201486,
-0.0528598987,
-0.0132429777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02522v1 | Absolute convergence and error thresholds in non-active adaptive sampling | 2024-02-04T15:10:34 | 2024-02-04T15:10:34 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Jesús Vilares Ferro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Non-active adaptive sampling is a way of building machine learning models
from a training data base which are supposed to dynamically and automatically
derive guaranteed sample size. In this context and regardless of the strategy
used in both scheduling and generating of weak predictors, a proposal for
calculating absolute convergence and error thresholds is described. We not only
make it possible to establish when the quality of the model no longer
increases, but also supplies a proximity condition to estimate in absolute
terms how close it is to achieving such a goal, thus supporting decision making
for fine-tuning learning parameters in model selection. The technique proves
its correctness and completeness with respect to our working hypotheses, in
addition to strengthening the robustness of the sampling scheme. Tests meet our
expectations and illustrate the proposal in the domain of natural language
processing, taking the generation of part-of-speech taggers as case study. | [
-0.0086190999,
0.0357789733,
-0.0188675169,
-0.0334569998,
-0.0468722656,
0.0246782992,
-0.0027233807,
0.0159822386,
0.0051235789,
-0.0072674593,
0.0413895138,
-0.0585207529,
-0.0325195789,
0.0048986459,
0.0151201133,
-0.0165224187,
0.0095349448,
-0.044737231,
-0.0036676337,
-0.0258690305,
0.003278339,
-0.0081300186,
0.004270846,
0.044910077,
0.0240539126,
0.0294623896,
-0.0087763416,
-0.0262890402,
-0.0295563657,
-0.0181538053,
0.0019144625,
0.0284358021,
-0.0220460948,
0.0010936401,
0.0000018215,
-0.0553875528,
0.0038942099,
0.004369447,
-0.0194645878,
-0.0261808895,
0.0485900566,
0.0183430351,
0.0151726725,
0.0385375097,
-0.0187526047,
-0.0140075609,
0.0212274827,
-0.0281016696,
0.0505213812,
0.0083337072,
0.0083356733,
0.0243604071,
0.019157121,
-0.034584526,
-0.0235399995,
-0.0748574063,
0.0329090469,
-0.0187013466,
0.0095000034,
-0.0350774825,
0.0099097826,
0.0329678506,
-0.0042936974,
0.0015347148,
0.0174667742,
0.0268800668,
-0.0198380966,
-0.0490872897,
0.0058032311,
-0.0063428441,
-0.0407166146,
-0.0215711389,
0.0048638065,
-0.045782309,
0.0074717146,
0.0452775024,
-0.0450381599,
0.0029651835,
-0.0307510551,
0.0473811552,
-0.0016058735,
-0.0410947166,
0.021842137,
0.0150675382,
0.0020151364,
0.0526715405,
-0.0257115178,
-0.0474136211,
0.0494470932,
0.0471680574,
-0.0430714488,
0.0055372338,
0.0086770719,
0.0346788354,
-0.0259172674,
0.0027391345,
-0.0512053259,
-0.0105063617,
0.006349199,
-0.0385501944,
0.0744010434,
-0.032997027,
0.0537262075,
0.0408634618,
0.0068219709,
-0.0095566064,
0.0190662183,
-0.0189135596,
-0.0230140444,
-0.0003322925,
-0.028687764,
0.0270160716,
-0.0446403809,
0.0355984196,
0.0001680407,
0.0340566225,
-0.0664999336,
0.0262653213,
-0.0077031837,
-0.0175005943,
0.0214465708,
-0.0212146044,
-0.0837773085,
0.0606697537,
-0.0132742934,
-0.0232232735,
-0.0194116067,
0.0139967473,
-0.0094991019,
-0.0446414351,
0.0064568389,
-0.0189312082,
-0.0141289234,
-0.0249225199,
-0.0055731498,
0.0507936776,
0.0011441107,
-0.0141743291,
-0.0812196508,
-0.0271482542,
-0.0185211115,
-0.0070274896,
0.0028963573,
-0.0281442329,
-0.0077700452,
-0.0003894913,
0.0370367318,
-0.0221241079,
-0.0289548635,
0.0039572618,
-0.0326055326,
0.0522336029,
-0.0162658934,
0.0310958996,
-0.0141453957,
-0.0480284989,
-0.0014691741,
0.1043853983,
0.0684967712,
0.0125167798,
0.0624305122,
0.0197555516,
-0.0192396492,
0.0250477698,
0.0132379606,
-0.0141361449,
-0.0368751213,
-0.0501580052,
-0.018246172,
-0.0116062229,
-0.0316166282,
0.0062051564,
-0.031824287,
-0.0088140713,
0.0376544595,
0.0076585934,
0.018580405,
0.0408213958,
0.0472339392,
-0.0129719917,
-0.0081576491,
0.0359760858,
0.0102963857,
-0.0501033738,
-0.0108084809,
0.0100817,
-0.027237609,
0.0287884269,
-0.0308434386,
-0.051726643,
0.0103071099,
-0.0014185915,
-0.0129825473,
-0.0137074254,
0.0816665515,
0.015828684,
-0.0209751371,
0.0101698376,
0.0376069508,
0.0021872411,
0.0427020714,
-0.0714014769,
0.0015405022,
-0.0304561369,
0.0307909492,
-0.0652655661,
-0.0001262838,
-0.0286315959,
-0.0026926531,
-0.0389244556,
0.045596756,
-0.0203422308,
0.0331074148,
-0.0116025433,
-0.0518786423,
0.0854189619,
0.0007064221,
-0.0303617343,
-0.0282658301,
0.0566646494,
-0.0230016652,
-0.061661087,
-0.0875198543,
0.0359950364,
-0.0578482002,
-0.0365440249,
0.0302315615,
-0.0262176823,
0.0795523375,
0.0085282242,
-0.050647784,
-0.0180378351,
0.0486641489,
-0.0213703513,
-0.0201514624,
0.01081225,
-0.0148647493,
-0.0097984532,
0.032970231,
-0.0225634649,
0.0263874419,
-0.0131713543,
-0.0356577635,
-0.025830647,
0.0100561399,
-0.0460079089,
-0.0165675171,
-0.067274332,
0.0566840246,
-0.0543239191,
0.0464962982,
-0.0631301105,
0.0276710819,
-0.0125933737,
0.0076837516,
0.0127991783,
-0.0339885838,
-0.0217935182,
-0.0140608558,
-0.0674781203,
-0.0232608169,
-0.0189898871,
0.004420606,
0.0440236665,
0.0097937295,
-0.0088661779,
-0.0181736983,
-0.0162869934,
-0.0073475982,
-0.0398105048,
0.0128814718,
-0.0344097763,
-0.006159361,
0.0266728997,
-0.0112703694,
0.0310093798,
0.0073006204,
0.0094580064,
0.0340779833,
0.0301871244,
-0.0005182879,
-0.0245296434,
-0.0105575314,
-0.0421070419,
0.0011578315,
0.0818956643,
0.0646771193,
-0.0235564187,
-0.043970935,
-0.0387014374,
0.0331957079,
0.0018186745,
0.0368415192,
0.0205087084,
-0.0004111396,
-0.0069428459,
-0.0475825518,
0.0781815574,
0.0221041795,
0.0574188195,
0.0075987615,
0.0526526049,
-0.0327436589,
0.0199265461,
-0.0653112158,
-0.0196868218,
-0.0229618233,
-0.0215336811,
0.0519080944,
0.0994838327,
-0.0177192073,
-0.0079209562,
-0.0163946226,
0.0269397534,
-0.0120602548,
-0.0676812679,
-0.0012448962,
0.0495584272,
-0.0569317862,
0.016464835,
-0.009191988,
-0.0429344364,
0.0223538633,
-0.0058177388,
0.0168475881,
-0.0311365854,
-0.0141579015,
0.0014253549,
-0.038456481,
0.0519449301,
0.0054864138,
0.0453873202,
0.0148297548,
-0.0099549871,
-0.054932788,
0.0459435843,
-0.0102737732,
0.0018588331,
-0.027646143,
0.0202563144,
0.0254716408,
-0.0136646638,
-0.0299509447,
0.0128379986,
-0.0068621677,
0.032095328,
-0.0181892887,
0.0156816263,
-0.0106678782,
0.0526757687,
-0.0235927813,
0.0488064215,
-0.0172541011,
-0.0333618037,
-0.0006630703,
0.0322077014,
0.0460121073,
0.0233524144,
-0.0262807645,
-0.0534844324,
0.0223601628,
-0.006595837,
0.0779513419,
0.0478393883,
-0.0423796996,
0.0219142567,
0.0221445486,
-0.059303049,
-0.0177082662,
0.0182620101,
-0.0196137149,
-0.0095950766,
-0.0088333394,
0.0886972174,
0.0073244851,
-0.0142638534,
0.0310213566,
0.0279074721,
0.0433633998,
0.0376047082,
0.0121197933,
0.0041707312,
-0.0176586639,
0.0035451599,
0.1112925783,
-0.0431393534,
-0.0514961854,
0.0207510162,
-0.0736644641,
0.0573415682,
-0.0259755794,
-0.0652757213,
0.0221039988,
-0.0349591859,
0.0168939698,
-0.0651467592,
0.0008698587,
0.0013468126,
-0.0242575333,
0.0194415059,
0.0691610798,
-0.0390046053,
-0.016417535,
-0.0566899888,
-0.0813465565,
0.0486197807,
0.0347015113,
0.0475784987,
0.0000451869,
-0.0057760919,
0.0326595195,
-0.0544143766,
-0.0050279009,
-0.0237250254,
0.0114846062,
0.0564506091,
-0.0186228193,
0.0032182976,
0.0084759556,
0.0303245261,
0.0387219563,
0.0236418266,
0.1018521935,
0.0040316302,
-0.0417319834,
-0.0024684379,
0.0025985879,
0.0117040947,
0.0105952444,
0.0258103516,
-0.0602548756,
-0.02504557,
0.0258738622,
0.0359731615,
-0.0695936903,
-0.0349372476,
0.0539107099,
-0.0918254331,
-0.0201874133,
-0.0576307513,
0.0050868066,
0.019495815,
0.1294171363,
0.0099462047,
0.0641477033,
0.0735563859,
0.0195271783,
-0.0146085061,
0.0012310899,
-0.0028019031,
-0.0285721421,
0.0001192095,
-0.0420098156,
0.0254584886,
-0.0303131863,
-0.0342504233,
-0.0001987768,
-0.0287461132,
-0.0554547459,
0.0675858483,
0.0352155343,
0.0313452594,
0.0364895761,
0.0017090973,
-0.1115327999,
0.0708649531,
0.0287167523,
0.0727384984,
0.0154426629,
0.0271006264,
-0.0143510457,
-0.0355287343,
0.0400564931,
-0.0526399575,
0.01278238,
0.0120981857,
0.0061876113,
-0.0401495621,
-0.0404574163,
0.0081720715,
0.0563651696,
0.0060638427,
-0.0397963114,
-0.0719534531,
-0.0142853642,
0.0112015055,
0.1098979861,
0.0280682724,
-0.0721506849,
0.0370595716,
-0.0013213167,
0.0031653189,
-0.0317966752,
-0.0098991962,
0.020351911,
0.0284877159,
-0.0465937518,
0.0111635029,
-0.0048886668,
0.0335853249,
-0.001857206,
0.0004978689,
0.0041808356,
0.0170377046,
0.0254102368,
0.0220913868,
0.0106607489,
0.0387459956,
0.0047535067,
0.0940836221,
-0.016127713,
-0.006520567,
-0.050978601,
-0.024561163,
-0.076730758,
0.0623935536,
0.0164662376,
-0.0119294906,
0.042992875,
-0.0087981904,
0.0160423256,
-0.0183325801,
0.0256712604,
0.0135869775,
-0.0222109668,
0.0101246377,
0.013669488,
-0.0160996579,
0.0365827084,
0.0507462285,
0.0045733023,
0.0487369522,
-0.0241385046,
-0.0046622311,
-0.0358533449,
-0.025493782,
0.0060956152,
-0.0537068658,
-0.0110844802,
0.0261991192,
-0.0247180443,
-0.0594406538,
0.0248095207,
-0.0161513854,
0.0244044866,
-0.0348665901,
0.0183422379,
0.0413217694,
0.0015497584,
0.0552877001,
-0.0321504325,
0.0037681058,
0.0129758688,
0.0208821651,
0.0096788974,
-5.879691602e-33,
-0.0142967161,
-0.006401632,
-0.0431926809,
0.0287898872,
-0.0029707856,
-0.0094386404,
0.0170577262,
-0.0217380524,
0.0304185208,
-0.0072007687,
-0.0386215225,
-0.0463505872,
0.0259781703,
0.0356466807,
0.0101601398,
-0.0204089973,
0.0612634532,
-0.0411500484,
-0.0118820509,
0.0324881822,
0.0285205841,
0.0383163951,
0.0001559659,
-0.0407055169,
-0.0271544605,
0.0244731344,
-0.033743348,
0.0177448262,
0.0258560404,
0.0529290326,
0.0374507047,
0.0413720794,
0.0098551931,
-0.0704618841,
0.0092618531,
-0.0389637537,
-0.0710215494,
-0.0270306617,
-0.0298776701,
0.0344448015,
-0.018607337,
0.0391259752,
0.0380219184,
0.004165587,
-0.0436577201,
0.0372566059,
0.0342959613,
-0.0339165963,
-0.0674047992,
-0.0685015991,
0.0025799952,
0.024036739,
-0.0265431218,
0.0360328667,
0.0075013605,
0.0234015025,
-0.02066526,
0.0036814648,
0.0121471044,
-0.027564561,
0.0627921671,
0.0202739183,
0.0246741846,
0.0539884195,
0.0172975082,
0.0453406572,
0.0393746234,
0.0030478416,
0.089412868,
0.0137574347,
0.010765153,
0.0054331915,
0.0006721104,
0.0239111297,
0.0360937454,
0.0178390928,
-0.0208119657,
0.0082831988,
0.1151414216,
0.0063899183,
0.0528257117,
-0.0412812047,
-0.0369679928,
-0.0156817455,
-0.0298386421,
-0.0505463071,
-0.0176170021,
0.0039428007,
0.0207605306,
0.0431005843,
-0.094468154,
0.0400562622,
0.0115929907,
-0.0314217433,
0.0111386012,
-0.0648651049,
0.0203711763,
-0.0020617079,
0.0151551319,
-0.0090810042,
-0.0148073481,
-0.0804769546,
-0.0314197913,
-0.0045167306,
0.0320210457,
-0.017615648,
0.0056996504,
0.0203267001,
-0.0192932561,
0.0064336187,
-0.0118776383,
0.0662692487,
0.0358950384,
0.0453766957,
0.0606170222,
-0.0362476856,
-0.014931892,
0.0353712477,
0.0326371081,
-0.0441798717,
-0.0202351566,
-0.0083786175,
0.0307079069,
0.0218409989,
-0.0495573469,
-0.0269203931,
0.0115741147,
-0.0209172219,
-0.0144154597,
-0.0622767992,
-0.0334572084,
0.0175385661,
2.642e-7,
0.002721156,
0.0148452697,
-0.0297677647,
-0.0121483626,
0.0030410946,
0.0193648767,
-0.0162167922,
0.0200888216,
-0.0040291855,
0.0588686392,
-0.0182770696,
-0.0205043647,
0.0290446002,
0.0513522439,
-0.0806071013,
-0.0306039993,
-0.0360033624,
0.0730149448,
-0.0087688603,
0.0072337938,
-0.0189837292,
0.0498083532,
-0.0154793365,
-0.0603556745,
0.0012505761,
-0.1254091859,
-0.0205400568,
0.0182226058,
0.0183471963,
0.0348369293,
0.0632006899,
0.0065307897,
0.0081413416,
0.0322056934,
-0.0298877228,
0.016314026,
-0.0053730854,
0.0321509056,
-0.0116396071,
0.0043143872,
0.0537943542,
-0.0165641736,
0.0438828059,
-0.0009763918,
0.0917207077,
-0.0465868264,
0.0106178829,
0.0032868127,
0.0131769804,
-0.0473442003,
-0.0034955216,
-0.0544051081,
0.0257274471,
0.0157868061,
0.0166442804,
-0.0200103838,
-0.0406923294,
-0.00127747,
0.0341181643,
-0.0260918476,
-0.0325622782,
-0.0779411122,
-0.0229649469,
0.0206894781,
0.0162576884,
-0.0460661352,
0.032484591,
2.191779012e-34,
0.0626521856,
-0.0082088644,
0.0065953173,
0.0471010767,
-0.0463085398,
-0.013845359,
0.019635234,
0.0032542781,
0.0063638864,
-0.0503306799,
-0.0294744149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02516v1 | Adaptive scheduling for adaptive sampling in POS taggers construction | 2024-02-04T15:02:17 | 2024-02-04T15:02:17 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Jesús Vilares Ferro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce an adaptive scheduling for adaptive sampling as a novel way of
machine learning in the construction of part-of-speech taggers. The goal is to
speed up the training on large data sets, without significant loss of
performance with regard to an optimal configuration. In contrast to previous
methods using a random, fixed or regularly rising spacing between the
instances, ours analyzes the shape of the learning curve geometrically in
conjunction with a functional model to increase or decrease it at any time. The
algorithm proves to be formally correct regarding our working hypotheses.
Namely, given a case, the following one is the nearest ensuring a net gain of
learning ability from the former, it being possible to modulate the level of
requirement for this condition. We also improve the robustness of sampling by
paying greater attention to those regions of the training data base subject to
a temporary inflation in performance, thus preventing the learning from
stopping prematurely.
The proposal has been evaluated on the basis of its reliability to identify
the convergence of models, corroborating our expectations. While a concrete
halting condition is used for testing, users can choose any condition
whatsoever to suit their own specific needs. | [
0.0332427323,
0.0060552452,
-0.0177486707,
-0.016300967,
-0.0338541903,
0.017802801,
0.0039290893,
0.0033931821,
0.0147961387,
-0.035747502,
0.0178902876,
-0.0232208334,
-0.0186059345,
-0.0025827631,
-0.0286392551,
-0.0735510364,
0.0382262878,
-0.0481249727,
0.0008003179,
-0.0106283203,
-0.0053348793,
-0.0104819322,
-0.0581992343,
0.0304128174,
-0.0057079741,
0.0229633823,
-0.0096700732,
-0.0491977669,
-0.0337554738,
-0.047632169,
-0.0113461111,
-0.0047808015,
-0.0200905036,
0.0476118773,
0.0000019682,
-0.0691138804,
-0.0382680856,
0.022160979,
-0.0153558031,
-0.0489403047,
0.0563987046,
0.0135757308,
-0.0202801693,
0.048423294,
-0.0243503582,
0.0220900085,
0.0554295741,
0.0166601222,
0.0155359721,
0.0370712988,
-0.0120737888,
0.0000560752,
-0.0009939158,
0.0183050465,
0.0174464956,
-0.0623850636,
0.0022970943,
-0.0078663994,
0.0506541394,
-0.0229780078,
-0.0160951931,
0.0429855399,
-0.0379895642,
-0.008349481,
0.0309913512,
0.0085367495,
-0.0137028173,
-0.0287117381,
-0.0258212872,
0.0070715374,
-0.0112863807,
-0.009531158,
0.0358480774,
-0.0106083527,
-0.0069673536,
0.0005210514,
-0.0089009823,
-0.020373974,
-0.0303223897,
0.0491410233,
0.0204098206,
0.0061408565,
0.0024346672,
-0.0134221641,
-0.0230881944,
0.0868161097,
-0.0033705437,
-0.0663186312,
0.0300994013,
0.0360134691,
-0.0276461653,
-0.0069706528,
0.033741612,
0.0198641978,
-0.0284498967,
0.0331905298,
-0.0544640347,
-0.0235077348,
-0.0139483809,
-0.0478989482,
0.040554177,
0.0019733408,
0.0317242555,
0.0270012654,
-0.0193053912,
-0.023278581,
0.0252628271,
0.0028760303,
-0.0330928527,
-0.0111199701,
-0.0897348821,
0.006443039,
-0.0745317638,
0.0493824556,
0.0048163156,
-0.0043748934,
-0.0685825273,
0.0042067589,
-0.010225785,
-0.0357785821,
0.007924634,
-0.0286702812,
-0.0549508892,
0.0365498252,
-0.0337420329,
0.0009312907,
-0.0297983084,
0.0024168373,
-0.032871332,
-0.0366387554,
-0.0032799027,
-0.000337291,
-0.0054837833,
0.004228964,
0.0161898956,
0.0226490442,
-0.0052541695,
-0.0091493083,
-0.0916006789,
-0.021989949,
-0.0434683338,
0.0059155952,
-0.0151001336,
-0.0326159336,
-0.0018703168,
0.0117100729,
-0.0091571454,
-0.0051776743,
-0.0056077619,
0.0216296148,
-0.0295312759,
0.0796420649,
-0.0492243581,
0.0123592364,
0.0228239782,
-0.0438284017,
-0.0010823261,
0.0759372264,
0.0800824538,
-0.0055789109,
0.0656567141,
0.0164807178,
-0.0121204201,
0.0805395469,
-0.0252197292,
-0.0383332334,
0.0039922083,
-0.086378403,
0.0461585782,
0.0127015794,
0.033560168,
0.0467994027,
0.0044060983,
0.0147188753,
-0.001126489,
0.0369684137,
0.0274320934,
0.0267796107,
0.0524295829,
0.0287455451,
-0.0139228841,
0.0097963093,
0.0310061015,
-0.0693781972,
-0.0378018543,
0.0108862258,
-0.0265271291,
0.007268792,
-0.010225242,
-0.037939202,
-0.0053731357,
-0.0329922959,
-0.0036051529,
-0.0009141657,
0.1105278656,
0.0359668396,
-0.0498646572,
0.0425442532,
0.0515066832,
-0.0017467138,
0.0164973103,
-0.0539225712,
-0.0484867208,
0.0355609246,
0.0269419979,
-0.0717358366,
0.0124489591,
-0.0192540307,
-0.0174112022,
0.0107695926,
0.0607127175,
-0.009928938,
-0.0030401153,
-0.0504792035,
-0.0281854514,
0.0854479969,
-0.0297371242,
0.0052920529,
0.0012393732,
0.0349670239,
-0.0156239877,
-0.0584382825,
-0.0314243734,
0.0545885637,
-0.0252354629,
-0.0441032611,
0.0180251282,
-0.014084843,
0.0145073542,
0.0441083908,
0.0001966933,
0.0139834601,
0.0377016217,
-0.0390481018,
0.0322446376,
0.0011777427,
-0.0182405207,
0.0204366706,
0.0578585938,
0.0369808935,
-0.0018139326,
-0.0242221449,
-0.0001823168,
-0.0496806167,
0.0185175948,
-0.0466785282,
0.0372060277,
-0.0380218513,
0.0499418341,
-0.008884944,
-0.0001977564,
-0.0554915108,
0.0062146545,
0.0343217589,
0.0261673015,
0.0028039545,
0.0167818386,
0.0153689235,
-0.0575304925,
-0.0795694888,
0.0031567048,
-0.0328510925,
-0.0262706708,
-0.0043742615,
-0.0165341441,
-0.0149552235,
-0.045402199,
-0.0798997134,
-0.0168762747,
0.0044682007,
0.0325803645,
-0.0356510617,
-0.0087389927,
0.0063334303,
-0.0554832667,
-0.004288449,
-0.0134079996,
0.0228980873,
0.0004908857,
0.0021821926,
0.0090852212,
-0.0648682937,
0.0018648431,
0.0010719511,
-0.0192015339,
0.0161894336,
0.0616925769,
-0.0753434151,
-0.0701034591,
-0.0453512408,
0.0264695883,
0.0460489057,
0.0528371185,
0.0003160397,
0.0074780341,
0.0201877356,
0.0172791034,
0.0423691794,
0.0234885123,
0.0070500346,
-0.0027937889,
0.0267391372,
-0.0369614996,
0.0011163085,
-0.039861735,
-0.0212061871,
-0.0319387168,
-0.0106509663,
0.0196990706,
0.0695818886,
-0.0007693287,
0.0297271423,
-0.022894064,
-0.0409553275,
-0.0273701884,
-0.0617677979,
-0.0079765059,
0.0036961222,
-0.0698959529,
-0.0191935711,
0.0041218176,
-0.0265869852,
0.0262681656,
-0.0225726776,
0.0048271269,
-0.087541692,
-0.0357095599,
0.004553223,
0.0227921642,
0.0223026872,
0.017349964,
0.0747564062,
-0.0352065004,
-0.0140769295,
-0.0012869445,
0.0347559527,
-0.03488639,
-0.0396476835,
-0.0334978253,
0.022121951,
0.0169233959,
-0.0283224396,
-0.0582130998,
0.0112986295,
-0.0345048793,
0.0246177018,
-0.0200424455,
0.0004761207,
0.0031339962,
0.0364377014,
-0.0095383637,
0.0420964845,
0.0033118026,
-0.0023373037,
-0.0119440267,
0.024993727,
0.0362406224,
0.0331020914,
-0.0381911546,
-0.0069591734,
-0.0068313489,
-0.0015838925,
0.1061934009,
0.000914989,
-0.0343186222,
0.0267706215,
0.0211075749,
-0.0623180605,
-0.039956592,
0.0307956226,
-0.0255326014,
-0.0205756798,
-0.0152467834,
0.0960327759,
0.0347170122,
-0.0192155056,
-0.0109383157,
0.0209307633,
0.0304560754,
0.0084255403,
0.0400632322,
-0.0344181173,
-0.0254188925,
0.0303268321,
0.0945167542,
-0.0254668873,
-0.0176792536,
0.010624011,
-0.1281553805,
0.017668616,
-0.006499392,
-0.0355718657,
0.0198461413,
-0.0159584656,
-0.0464306138,
-0.0186601765,
-0.0436314568,
0.0122467615,
-0.031674467,
0.0214763246,
0.0957154632,
-0.0620774776,
0.0010711746,
-0.026573671,
-0.0756716952,
0.0720404834,
0.067029044,
0.0038637104,
0.0101088397,
-0.0486131832,
0.0130865062,
0.0094293216,
-0.0021945764,
-0.0227107611,
0.009343151,
0.000370509,
-0.0037022706,
0.0015916703,
0.0017242415,
0.0059942622,
-0.0040935557,
0.0194726866,
0.0931784362,
-0.0092309471,
0.0348152332,
-0.0028060335,
0.0507843159,
0.0393576175,
0.045298811,
-0.0201892089,
-0.081478104,
-0.0296134986,
0.0068186857,
0.0153528117,
-0.0812848583,
0.0099179409,
0.0569435619,
-0.0829775706,
-0.0494005606,
-0.0944368467,
0.0220458172,
0.0205969587,
0.0980604365,
0.0249145906,
0.0576511696,
0.0393498689,
0.0604875199,
-0.0585623682,
-0.035798423,
-0.018244477,
-0.0145473881,
-0.0691565052,
-0.0528377332,
0.0375389159,
0.0035050127,
-0.0238523055,
-0.0120248608,
-0.0090428721,
-0.0642973855,
0.0974168852,
0.0391758755,
0.0317704901,
0.0259035155,
0.0020109299,
-0.0682046115,
0.0364258066,
0.0602465533,
0.0191026647,
0.0017493921,
0.0384633392,
0.0057860184,
-0.0212633107,
0.0117312372,
-0.0302772783,
0.0204197709,
-0.0303802732,
0.0244243331,
-0.0468703769,
0.0065577915,
0.0046453592,
0.0584221631,
0.0388307162,
-0.0562511422,
-0.0479303338,
-0.0150338262,
0.0251940992,
0.0278939959,
0.0231137965,
-0.0419869274,
0.0244689062,
-0.0141486274,
-0.0022651551,
-0.0018130295,
-0.0069091376,
-0.0198455956,
0.0051898588,
0.0261614118,
0.0236539878,
-0.0022567713,
0.0047245212,
-0.0408334471,
0.0142793711,
0.0311810356,
0.0133309225,
0.0526497886,
0.0247265119,
-0.0183607936,
0.0322775133,
0.0179034937,
0.0633266121,
-0.0337685011,
-0.0236255135,
-0.0174873117,
0.0095860753,
-0.0547268242,
0.0360662118,
0.0121126939,
-0.0017553559,
0.0059099589,
-0.0163065735,
0.015906835,
0.0005026911,
0.0296611264,
-0.024852518,
-0.008586836,
0.0051564462,
0.0086151976,
-0.017374333,
0.0094575882,
0.0573689491,
-0.0069819442,
0.0378782526,
-0.0232037473,
-0.023807073,
-0.0376900025,
-0.0131472042,
-0.0189832356,
-0.0025386787,
-0.0120269973,
0.015628485,
-0.0367524177,
-0.0264913905,
-0.0056929132,
0.0130105969,
0.0254506227,
-0.0243480075,
0.0772013888,
0.0066748052,
-0.028928481,
0.027864214,
-0.0460605286,
-0.0036757209,
0.0450049452,
-0.0174254496,
0.0145884389,
-5.5917212e-33,
-0.0345273204,
-0.0243252479,
-0.009649233,
0.0293859337,
-0.0243914984,
-0.0368182398,
0.0398854166,
0.0222807676,
0.0210291222,
-0.0241782032,
-0.0331229828,
-0.0560980886,
0.0571529306,
0.0296230186,
0.0178253222,
0.0159290042,
0.0822931305,
-0.0592626296,
0.0030086881,
-0.0048313611,
0.0738912374,
0.0533559546,
0.0258317981,
-0.0177407227,
0.0111289173,
0.0273364279,
-0.0181500576,
0.0025241489,
0.0651854053,
0.071624212,
0.0147725092,
0.0389290638,
0.006239472,
-0.0218322519,
-0.0006882648,
0.0493997261,
-0.1100968868,
-0.0166759137,
-0.0114182075,
0.0517042615,
0.0031337931,
0.0165776536,
0.0238249544,
-0.0187568646,
-0.0545378812,
0.0551884286,
0.0270568579,
-0.0454629287,
-0.0459160656,
-0.0082901753,
-0.0248867515,
0.0332159847,
0.0202800296,
0.0295499321,
0.0679240748,
-0.0235531498,
-0.0219451021,
-0.0382566005,
-0.0140660917,
0.0189793855,
0.0572999157,
0.0348620564,
0.0288855992,
0.0467257127,
0.012507787,
0.0634235516,
0.0632905439,
-0.0268964302,
0.0602027997,
0.0103521049,
0.0519310124,
0.0029950049,
0.0250628367,
-0.0161827747,
0.0919380561,
-0.0174431838,
-0.01410993,
0.0111984303,
0.0622632653,
-0.0171632152,
0.0182259381,
-0.0028926753,
-0.0650658458,
-0.0083342222,
-0.0198804215,
-0.0249993037,
-0.024065733,
-0.0364175066,
0.0270789862,
0.029856069,
-0.0633852705,
0.0382825173,
0.0270432048,
-0.0479865,
0.0179085359,
-0.0931833014,
0.013240952,
0.0203474239,
-0.0260768794,
-0.0292630047,
-0.0476831011,
-0.0981801972,
0.0002347492,
0.0008835807,
0.0478406921,
-0.0244433954,
0.0239106715,
-0.0087022632,
-0.0843804777,
0.0351595059,
-0.0016972562,
0.0706405863,
0.0262800511,
0.0212878566,
0.0602218807,
-0.0176160745,
-0.0043926593,
0.0151704047,
0.0221613571,
-0.0289021339,
-0.0187493879,
-0.0233166236,
0.0213106629,
0.0275260638,
-0.0306381043,
0.0262600649,
0.0083940104,
0.0148595031,
-0.0074594351,
-0.0459117666,
-0.0173082203,
0.0341228321,
2.744e-7,
0.0169348121,
0.0489040986,
0.0354644805,
-0.0148155047,
-0.0004122432,
0.0089047533,
0.013901202,
0.0276327431,
-0.0152309826,
0.0406870432,
-0.0303416271,
-0.0303232521,
0.0170855187,
0.0298853256,
-0.1031858325,
-0.0437977426,
0.0047918591,
0.0610951819,
-0.026970109,
0.0398269445,
0.0322979726,
0.0450912192,
0.0014572828,
-0.0366868563,
-0.0008646222,
-0.0843063071,
0.0096532516,
0.0326001234,
0.0169529952,
0.0252536107,
0.0467366017,
0.0567628108,
0.0089924699,
0.0264620576,
-0.0531984605,
0.0068156566,
0.0144216018,
-0.0004441965,
-0.0097173546,
-0.0195890088,
0.0395212397,
-0.0172557253,
-0.0126561169,
0.0173101407,
0.0519107319,
-0.0423620641,
-0.0095281648,
-0.0073433924,
0.0276577864,
-0.045042742,
-0.0343660042,
-0.0258999243,
-0.0270372499,
0.0213979613,
0.0381172225,
-0.0141649228,
-0.0230858345,
-0.029619744,
0.0283485595,
0.0229823124,
-0.0194057785,
-0.0521945283,
-0.0229971241,
0.0151034044,
0.0175451711,
-0.0337037556,
0.0080897454,
2.342022802e-34,
0.0378053859,
-0.0319463089,
-0.0026649828,
0.0482862294,
-0.0193079617,
-0.0105206724,
0.0179785304,
0.041861482,
0.0138979414,
-0.0466218516,
-0.0289920885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02515v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02515v1 | Modeling of learning curves with applications to pos tagging | 2024-02-04T15:00:52 | 2024-02-04T15:00:52 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Francisco J. Ribadas Pena | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | An algorithm to estimate the evolution of learning curves on the whole of a
training data base, based on the results obtained from a portion and using a
functional strategy, is introduced. We approximate iteratively the sought value
at the desired time, independently of the learning technique used and once a
point in the process, called prediction level, has been passed. The proposal
proves to be formally correct with respect to our working hypotheses and
includes a reliable proximity condition. This allows the user to fix a
convergence threshold with respect to the accuracy finally achievable, which
extends the concept of stopping criterion and seems to be effective even in the
presence of distorting observations.
Our aim is to evaluate the training effort, supporting decision making in
order to reduce the need for both human and computational resources during the
learning process. The proposal is of interest in at least three operational
procedures. The first is the anticipation of accuracy gain, with the purpose of
measuring how much work is needed to achieve a certain degree of performance.
The second relates the comparison of efficiency between systems at training
time, with the objective of completing this task only for the one that best
suits our requirements. The prediction of accuracy is also a valuable item of
information for customizing systems, since we can estimate in advance the
impact of settings on both the performance and the development costs. Using the
generation of part-of-speech taggers as an example application, the
experimental results are consistent with our expectations. | [
0.0049672062,
-0.0050042528,
-0.0086820675,
-0.0115269786,
-0.031085521,
0.0039188103,
0.0204442311,
0.0171439536,
-0.0046188324,
0.0115498127,
0.0416365117,
-0.0313105211,
0.0157019515,
0.0116005754,
-0.0228580479,
-0.066973336,
0.0301211327,
-0.0467395298,
0.0051392568,
-0.0068351361,
-0.0067941239,
-0.056263838,
-0.043554537,
0.0614655204,
-0.0739495978,
0.0235968791,
-0.0046470417,
-0.0410951227,
-0.0239714123,
-0.0598364659,
0.0037628273,
0.004397566,
-0.004644745,
0.0759897828,
0.0000020821,
-0.0756252781,
-0.051826559,
0.0221943352,
-0.0225062873,
-0.039761059,
0.0482952036,
0.0329455659,
-0.0367353149,
0.0265232306,
-0.0173083525,
0.0111227389,
0.0639582202,
-0.0187082998,
0.0378081389,
0.0336230472,
-0.0103488239,
-0.0372400545,
0.0047434722,
0.0084504336,
0.026567474,
-0.0520499274,
0.0278191306,
0.0226240978,
0.0180552322,
-0.0563777499,
-0.0335991457,
0.0635822639,
-0.0211703219,
-0.0204165652,
0.0276519638,
0.0098389341,
0.0304366089,
-0.0130035859,
-0.0025424873,
-0.0203540716,
-0.0114296526,
-0.0025367143,
0.0126424739,
-0.0161884315,
-0.0271531902,
-0.0197711587,
0.0035154577,
-0.0344576389,
-0.0319390148,
0.0157029927,
-0.0070649609,
-0.009838976,
-0.0228871629,
-0.0210128054,
-0.0289970469,
0.0719552785,
-0.0107766297,
-0.078634955,
0.0493132174,
0.0072500999,
-0.0038353303,
-0.010065523,
0.0127518345,
0.0325998925,
-0.0044266223,
0.0358172059,
-0.0358838923,
-0.0273300596,
-0.0180587042,
-0.0605705529,
0.0423240289,
-0.0165302046,
0.0266725514,
0.0277252663,
-0.0394855663,
0.0119949384,
0.0067919414,
-0.0285120998,
-0.0537588969,
0.0094594536,
-0.1026389971,
0.0180002805,
-0.0443769135,
0.0380868241,
0.0323587172,
0.0080446796,
-0.088719219,
-0.0185747668,
0.0067577432,
-0.0013935884,
-0.013213315,
-0.0252935104,
-0.0251320284,
0.027163757,
-0.066985175,
0.0074101919,
-0.006078802,
-0.0025795614,
-0.0360072404,
-0.0038632397,
0.0198718794,
0.0100172441,
0.00889327,
0.0392441973,
0.0412209332,
0.0349288359,
0.0186466854,
-0.0092057968,
-0.0878189877,
-0.0376068056,
-0.0212308038,
0.015029788,
-0.011836485,
-0.0329039358,
-0.0337489694,
0.0133243464,
-0.0238618664,
-0.0116085624,
-0.0209612157,
-0.0105534112,
-0.0029379507,
0.0654066503,
-0.0495467298,
0.0504274778,
0.0404725559,
-0.0484242253,
-0.049566295,
0.0589658022,
0.065736331,
-0.0077498788,
0.0524578877,
-0.0235371962,
-0.0138300043,
0.0756773949,
-0.0128363175,
-0.0485168137,
0.004586014,
-0.0708930716,
0.0371960849,
0.0147102242,
-0.0047003739,
0.0250367131,
-0.0102362791,
0.0384995379,
0.0368625149,
0.0577251203,
0.0731079429,
0.0133554097,
0.0393022038,
0.0064444011,
0.0226340368,
0.0095467623,
0.0365675874,
-0.0525845103,
-0.0407286324,
0.0228680279,
-0.0243014395,
-0.0243313145,
-0.0071940855,
-0.0631538481,
-0.0195539203,
-0.0304449685,
-0.0075974003,
-0.0421996601,
0.0835992396,
0.0079264725,
-0.0728655979,
0.0293913689,
0.0334505662,
-0.0084809521,
-0.0071759629,
-0.0558134392,
-0.0105678514,
0.0310758334,
0.0393456966,
-0.0699805096,
0.0135855544,
-0.0246546436,
-0.016582083,
0.0005738867,
0.041507978,
-0.0012702454,
-0.0260645524,
-0.0357009843,
-0.0392575935,
0.0806062743,
-0.0302349925,
-0.0039243698,
-0.0086701456,
-0.0042211036,
-0.0117878402,
-0.0196527503,
-0.0368787646,
0.0545851737,
-0.0474053472,
-0.0290484708,
-0.0051360941,
0.0097434344,
0.0157469213,
0.0397365727,
0.0082544526,
0.0064334129,
0.0383254848,
-0.01378043,
0.0264211111,
0.0159901977,
0.0251949485,
0.0358003005,
0.0732536465,
0.0131378388,
-0.0152148288,
-0.0532229543,
0.0060575553,
-0.0539900996,
-0.0030812169,
-0.0683450177,
0.0423948877,
-0.0272158701,
0.061494004,
-0.0232223701,
-0.0525791459,
-0.033303,
0.0188003108,
0.0290020648,
0.0712639391,
-0.0190288946,
0.0014183088,
0.058693435,
-0.0405474715,
-0.065067105,
-0.0257594772,
-0.0349714309,
-0.0305408929,
-0.0015635315,
-0.0094912415,
-0.0140090864,
-0.021697823,
-0.0747751594,
-0.0497610234,
0.0246956423,
0.0659478381,
-0.0185704548,
-0.0377417542,
-0.0064751478,
-0.023039829,
0.0045122453,
0.0089236889,
0.0007298343,
-0.0049138661,
0.0319973193,
0.02235502,
-0.0766083524,
-0.0346125774,
0.0061108815,
-0.0183369927,
0.0239730179,
0.0654769689,
-0.0567913912,
-0.0626027659,
-0.0167382844,
-0.0179863498,
0.0533735007,
0.0404672585,
-0.015495671,
0.0403233878,
0.0217181835,
0.0472726934,
0.0161354616,
0.0181101114,
-0.0223898627,
0.0063835303,
0.0147657013,
-0.0417318679,
-0.0090015894,
-0.0531199947,
-0.0047232881,
-0.0290775616,
-0.0104789883,
0.0073551764,
0.0691201016,
0.0046827784,
0.0039598495,
-0.031401448,
-0.0263169538,
-0.0337125063,
-0.0287628341,
-0.0240241028,
0.0103911152,
-0.0407685377,
-0.0133013949,
-0.0067562461,
-0.0549490042,
0.0443010181,
-0.009874274,
0.0189135429,
-0.0545496233,
-0.0299190991,
0.01197052,
0.0390160084,
0.0386464894,
0.0148014817,
0.0402006954,
-0.0116420733,
-0.0238462277,
0.0312641747,
0.0486756191,
-0.0505725928,
-0.0084729418,
-0.0627782121,
0.0275028255,
0.0104491422,
0.0242842343,
-0.0199461225,
0.020169137,
0.0051994049,
0.0259979889,
-0.0244716909,
-0.0041696299,
0.0555798598,
0.0334211066,
-0.0001585099,
0.0669600666,
0.0355815366,
-0.001681834,
-0.0012459845,
-0.0168802459,
-0.012657132,
-0.0158335045,
-0.0351842456,
-0.0348796807,
-0.0013990944,
-0.019022271,
0.0633789152,
0.0284078103,
-0.0647281185,
-0.0262337383,
-0.0117451036,
-0.0609232411,
-0.0490656905,
0.0416002832,
-0.0224757213,
-0.0368853249,
-0.0072790049,
0.0904374272,
0.0314157158,
-0.0042361924,
-0.0174361747,
0.026183486,
0.0053727347,
0.0075674863,
0.0135970814,
-0.0151430732,
0.0104237413,
0.0140050407,
0.0761182904,
-0.0272861961,
-0.0255140606,
0.0125668468,
-0.115379706,
0.0273508932,
-0.0241272748,
0.0009574261,
0.0014902378,
-0.0205969587,
-0.0279723685,
-0.0101063643,
-0.0871009007,
0.028846221,
-0.0191143844,
0.0201740507,
0.0748873577,
-0.0898840353,
-0.0287071113,
-0.0373491496,
-0.0647951365,
0.0311427694,
0.0803235099,
0.0129510509,
0.0031314052,
-0.0801188871,
0.0194759183,
0.0272518173,
0.030872168,
-0.0214963015,
0.060910143,
0.0295426324,
0.0094419988,
0.0108996201,
-0.0091649191,
0.0367445201,
0.0235831384,
-0.0017001781,
0.0630433783,
-0.0093146041,
0.0206900463,
0.0135996966,
0.0222079922,
0.0298947617,
0.0342458785,
-0.0020579363,
-0.0861388072,
-0.0254339781,
-0.0033673979,
0.0631567091,
-0.0192597453,
0.0205659345,
0.0224752352,
-0.0939043835,
-0.0464619957,
-0.097754173,
0.0557057112,
0.0069372305,
0.0932507589,
0.0041455259,
0.0415128544,
0.0027174449,
0.0335676298,
-0.0397069603,
-0.0179752503,
0.0276623089,
0.01715241,
-0.0935467035,
-0.0263552349,
0.0548365675,
0.0164820813,
-0.0332721882,
-0.0609102435,
-0.0260600969,
-0.0504845008,
0.0606425852,
0.0511118695,
0.0324885361,
-0.0010102907,
-0.0005613184,
-0.072279945,
0.0414839163,
0.0340888165,
0.0322361253,
-0.01453669,
0.0487584062,
0.0268397592,
-0.0184709989,
-0.0050886329,
0.0108502172,
0.0293501969,
-0.0177569538,
0.0004317824,
-0.0332785659,
-0.0058785984,
-0.0176122542,
0.0469253473,
0.079828009,
-0.0500203557,
-0.0975060016,
-0.0290475748,
0.0222235769,
0.048343081,
0.0075500291,
-0.0307436343,
-0.0140504949,
0.0061597778,
0.0260351244,
0.0034973593,
0.000711383,
-0.0210283492,
-0.0108853327,
0.011041401,
0.0448709093,
0.0224757884,
0.0378569737,
-0.0137683842,
-0.0015063677,
0.0350693353,
-0.0088758068,
0.0153652849,
-0.0017753475,
0.0204054154,
0.040077094,
0.0011149542,
0.0575801507,
0.0331557095,
-0.0014906425,
0.0072045219,
0.0084782923,
-0.0694798455,
0.0182892885,
0.0080437213,
0.0258343648,
0.0081674652,
-0.0172071122,
0.0154418908,
-0.0068812435,
0.016127998,
-0.0346115865,
0.0007336407,
0.0007803454,
-0.0050021862,
-0.0229083523,
0.0033849648,
0.0488556251,
-0.0105915358,
0.0406441279,
-0.0817760974,
-0.0195005275,
-0.0240783133,
0.0076888078,
0.0080879247,
-0.0177392066,
-0.0252455696,
0.0214052089,
-0.0554640219,
-0.0278195739,
0.0034920885,
0.0313257277,
0.043812342,
0.0008176297,
0.0700254738,
0.0038717315,
-0.0457027629,
0.0380958058,
-0.0261485465,
-0.0252467487,
0.0246048104,
0.0090783248,
0.0069676554,
-5.433268969e-33,
-0.0187646281,
-0.0363933519,
-0.0049926229,
0.0638339221,
-0.0212030802,
-0.0113265775,
0.0274708848,
0.026626261,
0.0132325133,
-0.0386283398,
-0.0110011119,
-0.0587164126,
0.0201453473,
-0.009991765,
-0.0095773414,
-0.0009194311,
0.0645571947,
-0.0517639406,
0.0074948366,
-0.0683055669,
0.0642631128,
0.0557475463,
0.0415330492,
-0.0431795195,
0.019626718,
0.0231019333,
-0.0439476259,
0.0195935667,
0.034090966,
0.0487425327,
0.0229799282,
0.0179034136,
-0.0033878961,
-0.0488152318,
-0.0049975915,
-0.0102153514,
-0.0375188366,
0.0002119244,
-0.0305905715,
0.0342460424,
0.0151489982,
0.031898167,
0.0442394689,
-0.0093511613,
-0.0717238709,
0.0396204442,
0.040311534,
-0.0291546118,
-0.0026177296,
-0.0137020145,
-0.0372669697,
0.0344333202,
0.0377260149,
-0.0008372691,
0.0614757463,
0.0128984954,
0.0008392586,
-0.0706663579,
-0.0700449646,
0.034222845,
0.0642776638,
0.0362266824,
0.0176415462,
0.0281838886,
0.0426881388,
0.0373886414,
0.0571019128,
-0.0340310149,
0.0380199105,
-0.0061855302,
0.0514017716,
0.0135641908,
0.0476979017,
-0.0479715876,
0.0857994333,
-0.0256774165,
-0.0324351154,
0.0418479517,
0.0035055992,
0.0028222154,
-0.0333819911,
0.0285853073,
-0.0498196818,
0.0125788441,
-0.0247449204,
-0.0095248064,
0.0112697221,
-0.0521794669,
0.0230370928,
-0.0003778638,
-0.0651510879,
0.0218539778,
0.0062470152,
-0.0292249341,
0.0240112785,
-0.0942961276,
0.0070068543,
0.0704992115,
0.0002718513,
-0.0001716067,
-0.07328666,
-0.0971635506,
0.0044130245,
0.0055699763,
0.0666410103,
-0.0331766494,
-0.0129459677,
0.0219606739,
-0.0872962847,
0.0291208904,
0.02849246,
0.0207675416,
0.0005490003,
-0.0005216082,
0.0608542673,
-0.0398074351,
-0.0027293412,
0.0266224742,
0.0179659463,
0.0391302258,
-0.0273564328,
-0.0172466561,
0.0136774965,
0.0173964649,
-0.000985251,
0.0189069621,
0.0220237821,
0.0152522549,
-0.0221880544,
0.0111899888,
-0.0113163264,
0.0484196842,
2.764e-7,
0.0345859863,
0.0502646901,
0.0200528633,
0.0114840819,
0.0186211169,
0.0199930556,
-0.0049173217,
-0.0278866049,
0.0078949006,
-0.0258717667,
-0.0097417524,
-0.0534503758,
0.0264551584,
0.0207128767,
-0.0928464606,
-0.0896215811,
0.0266568977,
0.0520145893,
-0.0282443315,
0.0596727878,
0.052468244,
0.020722555,
0.0164212789,
-0.0219814964,
0.0029491216,
-0.0435778983,
0.0206363946,
0.028160369,
0.0192507543,
0.0182425473,
0.0551398322,
0.0160181299,
0.01377727,
0.0288460068,
-0.0484335758,
0.0239807945,
0.0201064162,
-0.0193991549,
-0.0134773087,
0.022094937,
0.050026454,
0.0134645188,
-0.0002926657,
0.001142096,
0.0466278121,
-0.0029504381,
0.0018232908,
-0.0220384113,
0.0276805405,
-0.0094916336,
0.0266847052,
-0.0286297593,
-0.0176982619,
-0.007244207,
0.010527662,
-0.014744726,
-0.0226215534,
-0.0086622098,
0.0061688772,
0.0110614635,
0.0000475839,
-0.0663234591,
-0.0225226171,
0.0343322158,
0.0147990314,
-0.039396368,
0.0077449484,
2.352250292e-34,
0.0092999423,
-0.0502123982,
0.0303204153,
-0.0037564677,
-0.0073239445,
0.0095268004,
0.0498271063,
0.0189912636,
0.0256550498,
-0.0163364187,
-0.0115926713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02513v1 | Early stopping by correlating online indicators in neural networks | 2024-02-04T14:57:20 | 2024-02-04T14:57:20 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Yerai Doval Mosquera, Francisco J. Ribadas Pena, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE | In order to minimize the generalization error in neural networks, a novel
technique to identify overfitting phenomena when training the learner is
formally introduced. This enables support of a reliable and trustworthy early
stopping condition, thus improving the predictive power of that type of
modeling. Our proposal exploits the correlation over time in a collection of
online indicators, namely characteristic functions for indicating if a set of
hypotheses are met, associated with a range of independent stopping conditions
built from a canary judgment to evaluate the presence of overfitting. That way,
we provide a formal basis for decision making in terms of interrupting the
learning process.
As opposed to previous approaches focused on a single criterion, we take
advantage of subsidiarities between independent assessments, thus seeking both
a wider operating range and greater diagnostic reliability. With a view to
illustrating the effectiveness of the halting condition described, we choose to
work in the sphere of natural language processing, an operational continuum
increasingly based on machine learning. As a case study, we focus on parser
generation, one of the most demanding and complex tasks in the domain. The
selection of cross-validation as a canary function enables an actual comparison
with the most representative early stopping conditions based on overfitting
identification, pointing to a promising start toward an optimal bias and
variance control. | [
-0.0305190403,
0.0516566671,
0.0096380198,
-0.0289697517,
-0.0109110922,
0.0554692559,
0.0100845881,
-0.026132917,
-0.0122296968,
-0.0031441392,
0.0499762185,
0.005271629,
-0.013074398,
0.0342814364,
0.0060706721,
-0.0114397351,
0.0608231984,
0.0008181327,
0.0637995973,
-0.0096495477,
-0.0079800002,
-0.0110535054,
-0.0029245699,
0.0772706941,
-0.0403957777,
-0.0356775559,
0.027267389,
-0.0156388115,
-0.00328654,
-0.0386907682,
0.0283868611,
-0.0131805595,
-0.005097433,
0.076603286,
0.0000021696,
-0.0712421462,
-0.0480231009,
0.0166661479,
-0.0302050635,
-0.0377081148,
-0.0248762313,
-0.0216691177,
0.0142675787,
0.0165854786,
-0.0184139628,
-0.0012935493,
0.0441404842,
0.0480963103,
0.066171959,
0.0565720312,
-0.0053629642,
-0.0037165247,
0.0498540774,
0.0001122523,
-0.0164394993,
-0.0378059559,
-0.0081950445,
-0.0147311259,
-0.0231069718,
-0.1256380975,
-0.001328761,
0.0278847553,
0.0118154744,
0.0397858657,
-0.0111126313,
0.0408342667,
-0.0475382507,
-0.036632251,
-0.022639852,
0.0132644,
-0.0528308339,
-0.0192467794,
0.0301922075,
-0.0165321138,
-0.0160741881,
-0.0010336894,
-0.0210246313,
0.0137638692,
-0.0220533479,
0.0431491323,
0.05182679,
0.0286094267,
0.0151108326,
0.0364691094,
-0.014775889,
0.103325747,
-0.0112599675,
-0.0646887422,
0.0741335452,
0.095835425,
-0.0475153029,
-0.01317163,
0.0136719979,
0.0198098756,
-0.056098979,
-0.0042097368,
-0.0551653728,
0.0075075319,
-0.012603513,
-0.0512194745,
0.0270538237,
0.0328593254,
0.0011088729,
0.0091829458,
-0.0451884083,
0.0212695207,
-0.0284767542,
-0.0022579082,
0.0010756885,
0.0280085243,
-0.0479834527,
0.0084431153,
-0.0636629686,
0.0233444739,
0.0456190705,
0.0047417404,
-0.0637125671,
0.0141239185,
-0.038113866,
0.062811695,
-0.0400713235,
0.0246960819,
-0.0102699725,
0.036447119,
-0.0098262792,
-0.0099088978,
-0.0319444351,
-0.0107614547,
0.0109599689,
-0.0412747301,
-0.0191126559,
0.0375641771,
-0.0017056714,
-0.033685822,
0.0068739946,
0.0681362227,
0.0012972705,
0.0127687985,
-0.0392178781,
-0.0754581392,
0.0032728312,
-0.0410190672,
0.0244528465,
-0.0237866137,
-0.009811149,
0.0028706475,
0.0218206868,
-0.0028371946,
-0.0155157764,
0.001764318,
0.0251793973,
0.0144532435,
-0.027266223,
-0.0210268646,
0.0363135524,
-0.033068154,
-0.0387720168,
0.0688687563,
0.024970239,
-0.0020686232,
0.0442137718,
-0.0034712015,
-0.007070729,
0.0097115356,
0.0226243511,
-0.0528856292,
-0.0674115568,
-0.0473466329,
0.0101588648,
0.0264361762,
0.0130929155,
0.0188937746,
-0.0497887805,
0.0145751107,
0.0406945907,
0.0317174457,
0.0283804126,
0.0481245928,
0.1147244871,
0.0189222451,
-0.025460057,
0.0483679734,
-0.0271637551,
-0.0135224108,
-0.0396759175,
0.0085550928,
-0.0508403853,
0.0083890408,
-0.0275084246,
-0.0649634078,
0.0059342943,
0.0045656613,
-0.04471609,
-0.0168215372,
0.0477191433,
0.0078260293,
-0.0379992947,
0.0027058832,
-0.0118785147,
-0.0034208209,
0.0038753573,
-0.0558319576,
0.0236199163,
0.059450075,
0.0318498798,
-0.0274102371,
-0.0147862453,
-0.0291568171,
0.0145816691,
-0.0059131342,
0.0166148581,
-0.0070400219,
0.0431290865,
-0.0628592744,
-0.0131726079,
0.032552503,
0.021963425,
-0.0343899056,
-0.0098829465,
0.0404389389,
0.0100365216,
-0.005417183,
-0.0858333334,
0.0580113418,
-0.0020884618,
-0.0300333183,
0.0135291414,
0.0310352873,
0.029052468,
-0.0220073536,
-0.0150589878,
0.0009295815,
0.0199707411,
-0.0074058725,
-0.0202098154,
0.0482951589,
-0.0512221307,
-0.0345428698,
-0.0042784382,
-0.060189791,
-0.0012165568,
0.0112796584,
-0.0243493915,
-0.0581356101,
0.0220299456,
-0.0621361844,
0.0402952842,
-0.0105592432,
0.0229977686,
-0.0176925156,
0.0320362151,
-0.0260784179,
0.0621117465,
-0.006823299,
0.0439646356,
0.0112097282,
-0.0419910513,
-0.0081561469,
-0.054649964,
-0.0941151008,
-0.0083873151,
-0.0378779992,
0.0041175876,
0.0169192925,
0.0155721931,
-0.045883961,
-0.0126071088,
-0.0724374503,
-0.0071913009,
-0.0250979085,
0.0212617852,
-0.0198621843,
-0.051763054,
-0.0036668829,
-0.0292858835,
0.0138944071,
0.0389457904,
0.0413662978,
0.0032595997,
0.0479702689,
0.0095723718,
-0.0527394637,
-0.0082218731,
-0.0334978327,
-0.030073557,
0.0742512867,
0.0274142846,
-0.0602992401,
-0.0381410047,
0.0197105594,
-0.0043935464,
0.0320411585,
0.0194959212,
0.0045611956,
0.0491096564,
-0.0221060626,
-0.0537087843,
0.0893001184,
0.001908147,
0.0029340365,
0.0230520647,
-0.0009450769,
-0.0526700243,
0.0362218209,
-0.0164653752,
0.0229500849,
0.006982259,
0.0016656835,
0.0194313042,
0.1090661138,
-0.0174325649,
0.0137867099,
-0.0382672362,
0.0189030115,
-0.0261600073,
-0.0311724413,
-0.001854804,
-0.0171882361,
-0.002202535,
0.0276092533,
-0.0135638192,
-0.0842990205,
0.0692016408,
0.0075116502,
-0.0101688877,
-0.0211062226,
-0.0139962919,
-0.0179660581,
0.0107913697,
-0.0006594143,
-0.0111431535,
0.0485985763,
-0.0293947477,
-0.0041044457,
-0.0029783014,
0.0069754035,
0.0058577154,
0.0051382482,
-0.040627256,
0.0156480428,
0.0116439657,
-0.018182477,
-0.0515991487,
-0.0191315692,
-0.021692222,
-0.0209008642,
-0.050918676,
0.0163078979,
-0.0172655005,
-0.027860539,
-0.0655581057,
0.0659616888,
-0.0079177907,
-0.0253246725,
-0.0330304503,
0.055813875,
0.0003663806,
0.0158685222,
0.0382296033,
-0.0378671363,
0.0814776197,
-0.0001811334,
-0.0100694308,
0.0263085123,
-0.0502224155,
0.0237391423,
0.0179098547,
-0.0606163517,
-0.042141404,
0.0369965136,
-0.0117539838,
-0.0826191902,
-0.0660204217,
0.1030541286,
0.0046059811,
-0.0440913551,
0.0071627363,
0.0264520459,
0.031395033,
0.0069303373,
0.0320813581,
-0.0195917189,
-0.0086547732,
-0.0006005368,
0.0613642409,
-0.0617935061,
-0.0400608368,
-0.0243875105,
-0.0703732446,
0.0259571504,
-0.0114956275,
-0.0292750802,
0.0450693145,
0.0203742608,
-0.0475400388,
-0.0444296002,
0.0064063887,
-0.0069925888,
-0.0100491317,
0.0225848537,
0.0514681861,
-0.0248573348,
-0.0636230409,
0.001456509,
-0.0530244187,
0.0337758251,
0.0745331272,
0.0117645273,
-0.0246024579,
-0.032512892,
0.0180088673,
-0.0235212613,
0.0335170366,
-0.0054961042,
0.0584941022,
-0.0000381691,
-0.0209753253,
-0.0336366594,
0.0071850945,
0.0102615636,
0.0029348836,
0.0213221963,
0.0952196494,
-0.0317531265,
-0.0745370165,
0.0009875679,
0.0359193459,
0.0332179405,
0.0351168923,
0.0056338916,
-0.0728765577,
-0.0846665353,
0.0027705193,
0.0393153317,
-0.1094341949,
0.0442384668,
0.0128747532,
0.0339489095,
-0.0541302264,
-0.07023599,
-0.015673846,
-0.0182331987,
0.0579260327,
-0.0194790624,
-0.0216675811,
-0.0017517016,
0.026010083,
-0.0428120196,
0.052185148,
0.0465307683,
-0.0082251243,
-0.0895772204,
0.0478756018,
0.018108163,
-0.0162961092,
-0.0312729292,
0.0045200209,
-0.0488481633,
-0.0578445941,
0.0279789977,
0.0624766424,
0.0224403124,
0.0240900367,
-0.0244355015,
-0.1044127569,
0.0564607233,
0.0281399731,
-0.008336518,
-0.0067807068,
0.0727253258,
-0.0163976289,
-0.0012814652,
0.0250202212,
-0.0010023856,
0.0319212824,
-0.0035484252,
-0.0112931766,
-0.0321193486,
0.0526530594,
0.0391936228,
0.0007259814,
0.0314291976,
-0.0419535786,
0.002636733,
-0.0220628455,
-0.0155200763,
0.0688687861,
-0.0012367101,
-0.0509033576,
0.0114485417,
0.036699228,
0.0028816238,
-0.0263260063,
0.018740939,
0.0120989503,
-0.0262384675,
-0.0445715524,
0.0294888411,
-0.0107150124,
0.050293047,
-0.0030877625,
0.0006938854,
-0.0396197923,
0.0194266066,
-0.0090063317,
0.0288645271,
-0.0091928663,
0.0518369935,
0.0320496559,
0.0847609565,
-0.0032227372,
0.0009653036,
-0.0481036119,
-0.0279692244,
-0.0634916797,
-0.0088667413,
0.0288882069,
-0.0123910243,
0.0589328296,
-0.0069766766,
0.0157333333,
-0.0062809531,
0.0362665989,
-0.0121263936,
-0.0305953976,
-0.0037566181,
0.0157111976,
-0.0257960111,
-0.047657162,
0.0505043268,
-0.0038594946,
0.0372352824,
-0.0235118959,
-0.0083692474,
-0.0312183555,
-0.0163975433,
-0.0123642618,
-0.0034318231,
-0.0317004733,
-0.0166666918,
-0.0235663187,
-0.0253015701,
0.0301870164,
0.0298183765,
0.0673860162,
0.0096126869,
0.0267945919,
0.0216607973,
-0.0198248867,
0.0253158808,
-0.0221077986,
-0.0151372459,
0.0474615023,
0.0081931632,
-0.0547842868,
-5.975217048e-33,
-0.0143256374,
-0.0297162868,
0.0354429074,
-0.0091185281,
-0.0336659215,
0.0237319227,
-0.0222650208,
0.0003277262,
0.0099571617,
0.0095584253,
-0.0023515117,
0.0174758118,
0.0240528733,
0.0011579019,
0.0330413431,
-0.0233147964,
0.0349418558,
-0.0015526739,
-0.0104135014,
-0.0086568277,
0.0331181623,
0.0369598195,
0.0545535646,
-0.0344945602,
-0.0210574102,
0.0132805277,
-0.0519898832,
-0.0226875748,
-0.0345415697,
0.0145263821,
-0.0085264016,
0.0364758447,
0.0302060004,
0.0005422277,
-0.0014070004,
0.0320613794,
-0.0387462527,
-0.0475033745,
-0.0305291843,
0.055843465,
-0.0092648473,
-0.0034124921,
0.0755461976,
-0.0123300282,
-0.0559966974,
0.0289958231,
0.0130680883,
0.0108493026,
-0.0114931529,
-0.0692883208,
-0.0493595675,
0.0346257761,
-0.0011180231,
-0.0088579981,
0.0323221497,
0.0930888057,
-0.0113837589,
-0.0167668294,
-0.0348681882,
0.0300039276,
0.0065708016,
-0.0209908336,
0.0233608335,
0.0105600972,
-0.0158111509,
0.042330306,
0.047083009,
0.0147209847,
0.0213874411,
-0.0087691471,
0.0552386269,
0.0221973564,
0.0207355898,
-0.0225521121,
0.0906391591,
-0.0294094235,
-0.0480924174,
0.0244244132,
0.0291700605,
0.0547031462,
0.0316647999,
-0.012307195,
-0.0487574339,
-0.0364850163,
-0.0074885376,
-0.0844352916,
-0.0189397391,
-0.0020532471,
0.0412024669,
0.0333549008,
-0.0322779045,
0.0091065438,
0.0093244975,
-0.0385815352,
0.0743315518,
0.0099911923,
-0.0122444481,
0.0096632103,
0.0183449462,
-0.0123679144,
-0.0273584351,
-0.0838335752,
-0.0184847657,
-0.0053521455,
0.0806139633,
-0.0414983295,
0.0446071513,
0.0293426588,
-0.0197701119,
0.0345702991,
-0.030040551,
0.0353503227,
0.042761039,
0.0554566234,
0.0789624751,
-0.0199116878,
-0.0157447457,
0.0285878759,
-0.0077113123,
0.0224325247,
-0.0448755287,
-0.0224287435,
0.0504769646,
0.0297157448,
-0.0149376458,
-0.0261233523,
0.0269330852,
0.0162649788,
-0.0173779353,
-0.0497543849,
-0.0134562384,
0.0444634408,
2.903e-7,
-0.0019936983,
0.0186662916,
0.0445074253,
-0.0069740904,
0.0297627933,
-0.0014586002,
0.0105413022,
-0.0016122331,
-0.0370327793,
0.0296139028,
0.0468149856,
-0.0305479039,
0.0528219566,
0.0542653985,
-0.0719302744,
-0.0810055509,
-0.0270888731,
0.0489609614,
-0.0017184572,
-0.0226566568,
0.0281582829,
0.0227297433,
-0.0218378231,
-0.0323527418,
0.0336217508,
-0.0519299544,
0.026537735,
0.0098109227,
0.0500403196,
-0.0056867739,
0.0113754002,
0.0121429162,
-0.0095455395,
0.0304167457,
-0.0098333238,
0.0496751331,
-0.0069504981,
0.0240752045,
-0.0000025927,
0.0265711192,
0.0136595601,
0.0056310422,
0.0193533394,
-0.0269611441,
0.0573111735,
-0.0770596266,
-0.0135333799,
-0.0262291972,
0.0005741435,
-0.0619302616,
0.0608578324,
-0.0459868871,
-0.0092336088,
0.0192448106,
0.0103228707,
-0.011008719,
-0.0117172636,
-0.0399257988,
-0.0131226759,
0.056193307,
-0.0302558448,
-0.0376276039,
-0.0460781232,
0.013464638,
0.0335274786,
-0.0478901863,
0.0042576133,
2.614143545e-34,
0.023676943,
-0.0237239767,
0.0422091745,
0.0246095266,
-0.0073011885,
0.0165992454,
-0.0406754129,
0.0123726772,
0.0355129912,
-0.016321484,
-0.010034197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02503v1 | GeReA: Question-Aware Prompt Captions for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering | 2024-02-04T14:28:23 | 2024-02-04T14:28:23 | Ziyu Ma, Shutao Li, Bin Sun, Jianfei Cai, Zuxiang Long, Fuyan Ma | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Knowledge-based visual question answering (VQA) requires world knowledge
beyond the image for accurate answer. Recently, instead of extra knowledge
bases, a large language model (LLM) like GPT-3 is activated as an implicit
knowledge engine to jointly acquire and reason the necessary knowledge for
answering by converting images into textual information (e.g., captions and
answer candidates). However, such conversion may introduce irrelevant
information, which causes the LLM to misinterpret images and ignore visual
details crucial for accurate knowledge. We argue that multimodal large language
model (MLLM) is a better implicit knowledge engine than the LLM for its
superior capability of visual understanding. Despite this, how to activate the
capacity of MLLM as the implicit knowledge engine has not been explored yet.
Therefore, we propose GeReA, a generate-reason framework that prompts a MLLM
like InstructBLIP with question relevant vision and language information to
generate knowledge-relevant descriptions and reasons those descriptions for
knowledge-based VQA. Specifically, the question-relevant image regions and
question-specific manual prompts are encoded in the MLLM to generate the
knowledge relevant descriptions, referred to as question-aware prompt captions.
After that, the question-aware prompt captions, image-question pair, and
similar samples are sent into the multi-modal reasoning model to learn a joint
knowledge-image-question representation for answer prediction. GeReA unlocks
the use of MLLM as the implicit knowledge engine, surpassing all previous
state-of-the-art methods on OK-VQA and A-OKVQA datasets, with test accuracies
of 66.5% and 63.3% respectively. Our code will be released at
https://github.com/Upper9527/GeReA. | [
0.0404124595,
0.0327752158,
-0.0119374767,
0.0591356307,
-0.0095933247,
0.014769488,
0.0354381502,
0.0136729777,
0.0347188003,
-0.0703191757,
-0.0066930577,
0.0197657235,
-0.0253002383,
0.0612369142,
0.052283112,
-0.06282565,
0.0361577123,
-0.0547577664,
0.0042559565,
-0.0046509514,
0.0504994951,
0.0249914583,
-0.0096944673,
0.0418376997,
-0.0287125558,
-0.0488752909,
-0.0342107974,
0.0057583977,
-0.0022436883,
-0.0074263662,
-0.014804055,
0.0349680632,
0.0646002367,
-0.0315890424,
0.0000019052,
-0.0030096096,
0.0295749865,
-0.0173795428,
-0.0001884077,
-0.0114817973,
-0.0396501794,
-0.0169674326,
0.0402845927,
-0.0053557102,
-0.0396846421,
-0.0019332619,
0.0467547737,
0.0475228354,
0.0867260993,
0.0241045486,
-0.0177844279,
0.0013167615,
-0.008377349,
-0.0040956545,
0.0470047183,
-0.0260773115,
-0.0204502624,
0.0612331703,
-0.0124856737,
0.0233455151,
-0.0501720905,
0.0597461313,
-0.0000926536,
-0.0332397148,
0.0015769346,
0.0540796705,
0.0122761447,
-0.0456206575,
-0.0336044654,
0.10646718,
0.0374637581,
0.0135772694,
-0.0359652825,
0.0086198123,
0.0314377509,
0.044190336,
-0.0493700653,
0.0433265008,
-0.0126621611,
-0.0149672711,
-0.0497041941,
0.010866316,
-0.0155434711,
0.0007975105,
0.0231266469,
0.0033637297,
0.0181572102,
0.0154413786,
-0.0246857814,
0.008985376,
-0.0677681789,
-0.0606236085,
-0.0550374463,
0.0662283376,
0.0096738981,
0.0174814928,
-0.0178778637,
0.0031055589,
0.0045091668,
-0.015968198,
0.0061900453,
0.0125875007,
-0.0534126833,
0.0650145859,
-0.0315967798,
0.0706348494,
-0.0044704219,
0.0229673255,
-0.0462671295,
-0.0377270393,
-0.0184770692,
-0.0187198315,
-0.0496746823,
0.0055321804,
-0.0656377077,
-0.0467497744,
-0.0030436139,
0.0504957475,
-0.0204846505,
0.0253924057,
-0.0014245255,
0.0506991744,
0.0020489881,
-0.0003971299,
-0.0737983808,
0.0503819734,
-0.0462622866,
0.0170262177,
0.0034870538,
-0.0148944603,
0.007199713,
0.0334779099,
0.0298258383,
-0.0246553943,
-0.0097781047,
0.0572502837,
-0.0542401299,
-0.0053606764,
-0.0055691176,
-0.0568502806,
-0.0239914842,
-0.0172541365,
0.0300347488,
-0.0369851775,
0.0306897908,
-0.0037882624,
0.0051444001,
-0.0150353694,
0.0062413923,
0.034343183,
-0.013053406,
0.0931590796,
-0.0284281597,
0.0018558817,
0.0268122144,
0.0238971785,
-0.0274149533,
0.0487738699,
-0.0125741698,
0.0263426192,
0.0584717318,
-0.0165804978,
0.0203079749,
0.0128886448,
0.0239755958,
-0.0001493935,
-0.0252067409,
0.0509747192,
0.0105585624,
0.0134158656,
0.0365910456,
0.0223599635,
-0.0098829763,
-0.0110151963,
0.0797286332,
0.0190262794,
-0.0136372074,
0.0166532323,
0.019688962,
-0.0071410295,
0.0091758501,
-0.0152762514,
-0.0509484112,
0.0973571241,
-0.0372953266,
0.0157825816,
-0.0049569975,
0.0267408602,
-0.0500053167,
-0.0032125246,
0.0085215429,
-0.0096812211,
-0.0068766535,
0.0515669994,
0.0208691712,
-0.0032674368,
-0.0471034013,
0.0451823883,
-0.0044986634,
-0.0174716562,
-0.0137428017,
-0.0298166983,
0.0848763734,
0.0403030366,
0.0121809198,
-0.0026623379,
-0.0369441323,
-0.0011348475,
0.0216024332,
0.0339909308,
-0.01283246,
-0.0163794309,
0.0121976268,
-0.0362863988,
-0.0431487635,
-0.0212678965,
-0.0236980449,
-0.006173925,
0.0211314466,
0.0095309643,
0.0151629969,
-0.0077876705,
0.0257920343,
0.0181559138,
0.03538353,
-0.0106272455,
-0.0359938852,
0.0323154964,
-0.0117629226,
-0.0078833206,
0.0101618376,
-0.0015471947,
0.0114104878,
-0.0348330811,
-0.0216404758,
0.0075053298,
-0.0687478334,
-0.08102604,
0.0223762412,
-0.036659047,
-0.0020862767,
-0.0008924687,
-0.0362863131,
-0.0205166489,
-0.0049290922,
-0.0216176379,
-0.0167047735,
-0.0784442723,
-0.057583034,
0.04692607,
0.0216753911,
-0.0175908878,
0.0511499643,
-0.0007920034,
-0.0278417133,
0.031519752,
0.0010707679,
0.020023305,
-0.0054667266,
-0.0067043053,
0.0154157951,
0.0064696553,
0.0187752955,
0.0142959598,
0.0373938531,
-0.0568840615,
0.0076780999,
-0.1150643304,
-0.0271080621,
-0.0074781086,
-0.0504805893,
0.0066142925,
0.0177181792,
0.0098941419,
-0.0479354151,
-0.0677501932,
0.0436154716,
-0.0023520452,
0.0145429987,
0.0499899387,
0.0253974851,
0.0162886325,
0.0019043322,
0.0075468156,
0.0141762253,
0.0977948084,
0.0229270775,
0.020317927,
-0.0521286838,
0.002524178,
-0.0665681288,
0.0487844758,
-0.0037348706,
-0.0208734926,
0.009171064,
-0.0270799249,
0.0396318473,
0.0593906865,
0.0090848487,
-0.0106217004,
0.006503955,
-0.0278721265,
-0.0439413078,
0.0246963799,
0.0051632212,
-0.077239126,
0.0190058369,
-0.043745447,
-0.0374674313,
0.0108045666,
0.0046100155,
-0.0244903304,
-0.0734944865,
0.0531042591,
0.0414793044,
-0.0178768709,
-0.100997366,
0.0093089705,
0.0240733419,
0.0412645452,
-0.0447101146,
-0.0617905222,
0.0621730611,
-0.0311390478,
-0.0181113891,
0.020856902,
-0.0129808253,
-0.0368933156,
0.0888077915,
0.0010609414,
0.0297989324,
0.0044777603,
0.0126053402,
-0.0263158157,
-0.0306214467,
0.0135354567,
0.0143696247,
0.0534423925,
-0.0684555918,
0.0236839503,
-0.0191513859,
-0.0378214009,
-0.0235578325,
-0.0442852937,
-0.019982297,
0.0078898305,
-0.0755908862,
-0.0159394685,
0.0265220571,
0.0348362736,
0.0586178266,
-0.0023130241,
-0.0232484303,
-0.0136919869,
-0.0147492513,
0.0582697317,
0.0801254064,
0.0672060475,
-0.0317717418,
-0.0238819513,
0.0542806387,
0.0379602984,
-0.0086679924,
-0.0164658278,
-0.0156131377,
0.0364026874,
0.0052784979,
0.0446078479,
0.0020142656,
0.0369224474,
0.0874190256,
-0.0314829648,
0.0045762621,
0.1004104093,
0.0002452558,
-0.0335024633,
-0.0397944376,
0.0066572311,
0.0336660631,
0.0409224592,
0.0366081633,
-0.0801367536,
-0.0625991002,
-0.0378432274,
-0.0128205931,
-0.0081937192,
0.0062900009,
-0.0196655113,
-0.0758144557,
0.0346126333,
-0.0267549045,
-0.034242481,
-0.056434501,
0.0085208965,
-0.0253173169,
0.0302366689,
-0.0119238906,
-0.0079304511,
-0.0154474629,
0.0048954152,
0.0063793333,
0.0241870433,
0.0027283453,
0.0418807603,
-0.0557066314,
-0.0041510486,
0.0352519788,
0.0243051331,
-0.0054835314,
-0.0597757101,
-0.0181448217,
-0.0213087723,
0.0229628421,
-0.0066418867,
0.0534645766,
-0.0114060268,
-0.0513156876,
-0.0167473089,
0.0218393337,
-0.0123530645,
-0.0107710799,
0.0181852952,
0.0732603148,
-0.0237795357,
-0.007516487,
-0.0354553238,
0.0247197971,
0.0034004448,
0.0620326661,
0.0290502664,
-0.0112246824,
-0.0151311709,
-0.008430765,
-0.014947379,
-0.0268014874,
-0.0045835418,
0.0175954439,
0.0310367048,
0.0223342422,
-0.0728225634,
-0.01910365,
0.0647324473,
0.0480213538,
-0.0054821698,
-0.0030668427,
-0.0246440135,
0.0369703956,
-0.0501771085,
0.0634561628,
-0.0345453732,
0.0165913701,
-0.0212458912,
-0.0013508968,
0.0365698263,
-0.0492171608,
-0.0214136746,
0.0337481126,
-0.0353687666,
-0.0052627767,
-0.0526267327,
0.0776282176,
0.0082058916,
0.0373738632,
0.038708441,
-0.0229384638,
0.0432969108,
0.0229356363,
0.0015479152,
0.00483838,
-0.014715747,
0.0092259701,
-0.0045099366,
0.0197457522,
-0.0448636822,
-0.0235320814,
-0.0189904198,
0.0018540833,
0.0094661359,
-0.0410861336,
0.0167785417,
0.0364879407,
-0.0142648118,
-0.016136663,
0.0034167028,
-0.0235596672,
0.0017083929,
0.0004257808,
-0.0063347542,
-0.0729592368,
0.0384269767,
-0.0087706782,
-0.023249967,
0.018213626,
-0.0314839222,
0.0085512316,
0.0146973673,
-0.0282951426,
-0.0062390952,
0.0423293188,
0.0040102671,
0.0027707401,
0.0173524935,
-0.0175030343,
0.0125071108,
-0.0237075947,
0.0354014225,
-0.0091327969,
0.1226753742,
0.0348604359,
-0.0486690886,
-0.038265761,
0.033349704,
-0.0200186577,
-0.0581217147,
0.0000608005,
0.0615174696,
0.0446766242,
0.0076496685,
-0.0308438111,
-0.0040938351,
-0.0164234955,
0.0151994787,
0.032346189,
0.0126618315,
-0.0416788496,
0.0921506956,
0.0239364747,
0.0070086052,
-0.0054612961,
0.0547071584,
-0.0079448493,
0.030725982,
-0.0105570816,
-0.0177772418,
-0.0417754762,
0.0157292113,
0.0605020486,
0.0030535224,
-0.0059684343,
0.06340231,
-0.0231519137,
-0.0557602756,
-0.0037669118,
0.0209437925,
-0.0472644269,
0.0247879047,
0.0535422824,
0.0483825952,
0.0326480381,
-0.0540825278,
-0.0328540653,
0.0263675749,
-0.0536669642,
0.0316449814,
0.0020750752,
-6.139163245e-33,
-0.0555477552,
-0.0397496223,
0.046513442,
-0.0287138559,
-0.0180940144,
0.0262379553,
-0.0343641303,
-0.0085692629,
-0.0266828202,
-0.0011803386,
0.0176940914,
-0.045361802,
-0.0073552737,
0.039252013,
-0.0085487068,
-0.0368006229,
-0.00547241,
0.0026713219,
-0.0122464066,
0.0316762701,
0.0399798192,
0.0075719887,
0.0283040255,
-0.0114496006,
0.0177829582,
-0.0030473599,
-0.0339045636,
0.0419415869,
-0.016613679,
0.0548299514,
-0.0399849899,
0.0263258461,
0.02346614,
-0.0211964212,
-0.0063823848,
0.03030839,
-0.0870752558,
-0.0302857086,
0.0566802695,
0.0076143206,
-0.0883571655,
-0.0006777825,
-0.0085632531,
-0.0448796377,
0.0401871763,
-0.0462800711,
0.065569438,
0.0045270729,
0.0153769339,
0.0019636997,
0.0026691072,
-0.0270442739,
-0.0204441324,
-0.0423739031,
-0.0025615501,
0.0548870303,
0.0458406657,
0.0349219404,
-0.021716034,
0.0160141811,
0.0011680485,
0.011675844,
0.0820826292,
0.0348302349,
-0.008166682,
0.0481894575,
0.0102297803,
-0.0400766656,
-0.0511851572,
0.0006134979,
-0.0050499537,
0.0617918186,
0.0416306444,
0.0423566364,
-0.0278863683,
0.0321123302,
-0.0447876826,
0.0247505046,
-0.0573592968,
0.0302495938,
0.0037657314,
-0.0193354655,
0.0109442892,
0.0012005697,
-0.0604638569,
0.0147830704,
-0.0523782074,
-0.0022141447,
0.0542132705,
0.0264194608,
0.0144153498,
0.0422546118,
0.062802732,
-0.0325968228,
0.0169418436,
0.0081067299,
-0.0208976902,
0.0240887348,
-0.0040910323,
0.0294916332,
0.0010494323,
0.0197720211,
0.0621246509,
-0.043524839,
-0.0128457295,
0.0300138965,
0.0133256186,
0.0235235356,
-0.0307673737,
-0.0234924555,
-0.0656161755,
0.0025046093,
-0.0569229014,
0.0015156418,
-0.0196018293,
0.0402605645,
-0.076562658,
-0.0106746415,
-0.0260361861,
-0.0182322748,
-0.003649476,
-0.0488535427,
0.0070269257,
0.031501174,
-0.0412048101,
0.0057546441,
-0.0424901024,
-0.0654529706,
-0.026219802,
-0.0505492426,
-0.0120180435,
0.071415633,
2.461e-7,
0.0189409163,
0.0046438063,
-0.0016869721,
0.0442943349,
0.0212805904,
0.0711218044,
-0.0285978112,
0.0085281888,
0.0298267305,
-0.0466859378,
0.0056082131,
0.0593826175,
0.0042866198,
-0.008464749,
-0.032796897,
0.0118298661,
0.0007126449,
-0.0629976913,
-0.0618859269,
0.0130692367,
0.0893070623,
0.0548978113,
-0.0124992039,
-0.0331248902,
0.0424236022,
-0.0715482756,
0.0734313577,
-0.0195818488,
-0.0100270053,
-0.0169255268,
0.0542008579,
0.0053803669,
-0.019101711,
0.0515521728,
0.0104641905,
-0.0447078981,
0.030091159,
0.0371972583,
-0.0129164523,
-0.0390456542,
-0.0490560345,
0.0298998803,
-0.0079590362,
-0.074768953,
0.0904649496,
-0.0219347011,
-0.0225981101,
-0.0102056395,
-0.0377402902,
-0.0374604352,
0.0227795374,
-0.032321021,
-0.0469154231,
0.0143280951,
0.0278190244,
-0.0212539472,
-0.0119600901,
-0.0728764683,
-0.009482028,
-0.0079598082,
-0.0406215116,
-0.030429475,
-0.0633938387,
-0.0203737933,
0.0343047455,
-0.0535482727,
-0.0450144522,
1.802908262e-34,
0.0096098185,
0.0065058297,
-0.0015547726,
0.0135422228,
0.0287618693,
-0.0169530138,
-0.013122092,
-0.0332308635,
0.0112700285,
-0.0845899731,
-0.0165935233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05123v1 | A Survey on Data Selection for LLM Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-04T13:32:01 | 2024-02-04T13:32:01 | Jiahao Wang, Bolin Zhang, Qianlong Du, Jiajun Zhang, Dianhui Chu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is a vital step of training large language models (LLM),
so how to enhance the effect of instruction tuning has received increased
attention. Existing works indicate that the quality of the dataset is more
crucial than the quantity during instruction tuning of LLM. Therefore, recently
a lot of studies focus on exploring the methods of selecting high-quality
subset from instruction datasets, aiming to reduce training costs and enhance
the instruction-following capabilities of LLMs. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey on data selection for LLM instruction tuning. Firstly, we
introduce the wildly used instruction datasets. Then, we propose a new taxonomy
of the data selection methods and provide a detailed introduction of recent
advances,and the evaluation strategies and results of data selection methods
are also elaborated in detail. Finally, we emphasize the open challenges and
present new frontiers of this task. | [
0.0167049095,
0.0663679242,
-0.020401625,
0.0480135158,
-0.0223503411,
0.0334127359,
0.0218572095,
0.0124981087,
-0.0070402422,
-0.0497374758,
-0.0708139613,
-0.048351638,
0.0050930544,
-0.0598207377,
0.0319345333,
-0.0297761019,
0.0447729565,
-0.0575165562,
-0.0693406463,
0.0123225851,
-0.0224112235,
0.0299006328,
-0.0038060255,
0.0132094584,
0.0327174328,
0.0082389312,
0.0105918916,
0.0267777629,
-0.0161773358,
-0.0463573299,
0.0246168878,
0.0458554476,
0.039212618,
-0.0276527498,
0.0000019046,
-0.0393095687,
-0.01358891,
-0.0256671198,
-0.0475011729,
0.0422099009,
0.0261168256,
-0.0021017457,
-0.0144675774,
0.0311184786,
-0.0048101051,
0.0028650169,
0.0375214182,
-0.0165431518,
0.0611195378,
0.0911613256,
0.0272783898,
-0.03042241,
0.0034239197,
-0.0041833306,
-0.0067254654,
-0.0168812163,
0.027993707,
0.036565572,
0.000785642,
0.0406280495,
-0.0456113927,
-0.0188055579,
-0.0015934679,
-0.0000576171,
-0.0189155936,
-0.0005828189,
-0.0491103195,
-0.0089796009,
-0.0197733231,
0.0650716722,
0.0071799872,
-0.0253839549,
-0.008561912,
-0.0167237259,
-0.0225674715,
0.0006990029,
-0.0180875398,
0.0248072837,
0.007938277,
0.0537717417,
0.0593157075,
-0.0376150236,
0.0150443697,
0.0033514255,
-0.019604668,
0.0490413457,
0.0194585267,
-0.0460380092,
0.0281679481,
-0.0079734232,
-0.040360596,
-0.0258850753,
-0.0332508236,
0.0292969178,
-0.0322169289,
0.0438195542,
-0.0733184144,
0.00262147,
0.0025884996,
-0.0163292736,
0.0957603455,
0.037869174,
-0.0049525108,
0.0247466136,
-0.0005199693,
0.042339202,
0.0384090729,
0.0519754142,
-0.0483268574,
0.0232851803,
-0.0503316075,
0.0429032482,
-0.0272185318,
0.0295225829,
-0.019215731,
0.0430331007,
-0.0470538177,
0.0246716309,
0.0079805376,
-0.0096774707,
0.0405605584,
-0.0757967234,
-0.0529730283,
0.033590924,
-0.0134814633,
0.0013733848,
-0.0117075723,
0.0218765531,
-0.0320260935,
-0.081483312,
0.005909163,
0.0280162636,
-0.0146644302,
-0.0359378941,
0.030731136,
0.0531308092,
-0.0016234814,
-0.0442261696,
-0.0872068778,
0.0106459698,
0.01409736,
-0.0624474101,
0.0245117825,
-0.0521727055,
0.0009506621,
0.0041962503,
0.0246250145,
-0.017817026,
0.0069711967,
0.0127921812,
0.0166073572,
0.0201072022,
-0.0185085144,
0.0239771381,
-0.0152668469,
-0.0254903976,
0.0181823708,
0.0844050497,
0.0415165275,
-0.0250896756,
0.0510959737,
-0.0527143553,
-0.0265941396,
0.0355227776,
0.0139725106,
0.0340519026,
-0.0130616035,
0.0315667018,
0.0237328671,
-0.00987285,
0.0238064472,
0.0226050913,
-0.010661656,
-0.0052874144,
0.0396320261,
0.0184505321,
0.0200782176,
-0.014424664,
0.0506267399,
0.0258401968,
0.026726272,
0.0402795933,
-0.0277601611,
-0.0016055199,
-0.0043429863,
0.0064475341,
-0.0096458038,
0.0290398337,
-0.0427743345,
-0.0534093603,
-0.0161257032,
0.0179502312,
-0.0112011451,
0.0197116174,
0.041092854,
-0.0166298337,
-0.056474898,
0.0466488115,
0.0611557215,
-0.0301329959,
-0.004949315,
-0.0491937697,
0.0061878408,
0.0480498597,
0.0232346989,
-0.0274732355,
-0.0414187312,
0.0007100298,
0.0829438865,
0.0043692491,
0.0524700545,
-0.022597691,
0.0256480817,
-0.0861805603,
-0.0333229415,
-0.0196781978,
0.0113971392,
0.0021496832,
0.0233265162,
-0.0304056965,
-0.0165010486,
-0.018295126,
-0.0956619084,
0.0731153339,
-0.0425353386,
-0.0571131743,
-0.0131194284,
0.01574618,
0.0491146222,
-0.0122287767,
-0.0128004355,
-0.0202510711,
0.0455788299,
0.0048575001,
0.0640214682,
-0.0329989009,
-0.0471671708,
-0.0332551524,
0.009222812,
-0.0181029588,
-0.0163241513,
0.010847168,
-0.0734982565,
-0.0440132469,
-0.0258975551,
-0.0490173995,
0.0151460562,
-0.0152926743,
0.05450451,
-0.0279776473,
-0.0099170031,
-0.0428463705,
0.0303393696,
-0.0268540308,
0.0171532873,
0.0413370915,
0.0269921646,
0.0033792837,
-0.0489320159,
-0.0001308803,
0.0051345015,
-0.0043035611,
0.0443239324,
-0.0032678396,
0.0544767976,
-0.0377716273,
-0.0439839587,
-0.0437833071,
0.0198929403,
-0.0402649157,
0.0359277576,
0.0341962576,
-0.0322015658,
-0.0270687565,
0.0062228609,
-0.0168219544,
-0.0265411455,
-0.0232566446,
0.0117995553,
0.0106726736,
0.0050343899,
-0.0426224172,
-0.0423236974,
-0.0341343321,
0.0020090528,
0.0063287355,
-0.0129236113,
0.0137147158,
-0.0762317032,
0.0715874583,
0.01611338,
0.017917892,
-0.0163518433,
-0.0579535551,
0.016167989,
0.0152468123,
-0.0043214499,
0.0735829473,
-0.0136579191,
0.0167340375,
0.0494646356,
-0.0051240558,
-0.052309934,
0.0068802102,
-0.0231371559,
-0.0392710567,
-0.0666692331,
-0.0584775917,
0.0112518826,
0.0674275309,
-0.0023247071,
-0.0085673183,
-0.0336313136,
-0.0225854982,
-0.0396674909,
0.0061845412,
0.0055228318,
0.0387198925,
-0.0054882076,
0.0117896991,
-0.019792797,
-0.0847318694,
0.0585021861,
-0.0322901011,
0.0155342165,
-0.0669853389,
-0.0074965814,
-0.0581786335,
-0.0043917624,
0.0047443993,
-0.0084943892,
-0.0213596709,
-0.0159179084,
-0.0560538396,
-0.0025627667,
0.0386947915,
-0.0064653088,
0.0655593723,
-0.0626788884,
0.0059747738,
-0.0008208236,
-0.0018086315,
-0.0171240754,
0.0014860844,
0.0187405571,
0.0153176226,
0.049065344,
-0.0077965907,
-0.0219871905,
-0.0136795193,
-0.0096987188,
0.0258890577,
-0.0140152182,
0.0219300948,
-0.0314770713,
-0.0370713286,
0.020294955,
0.0065575405,
-0.020854583,
-0.0803911239,
0.0050659305,
-0.0071515711,
0.0471964553,
-0.0153619712,
-0.0001053802,
0.0377477817,
0.0639933646,
-0.0536967814,
-0.022946978,
0.0510203987,
0.0907859355,
-0.0583237186,
-0.0028659969,
0.1081392244,
0.0271182526,
-0.0255840551,
0.010773587,
0.0205561966,
0.0207536016,
0.0323208943,
0.0227393005,
-0.0471800715,
-0.0273093954,
-0.0295835137,
0.0530695021,
-0.0160514787,
0.0046626767,
-0.0274580549,
-0.115551196,
0.0362661071,
0.0310283992,
-0.0435686596,
-0.0320546441,
-0.0582069084,
0.0120962011,
-0.0296235215,
0.0555985682,
0.015775336,
-0.0692690983,
-0.0201503783,
0.0661356524,
-0.0197354238,
-0.0841654241,
0.0315281749,
-0.0245504696,
0.0633476898,
0.0305711143,
0.0218376555,
0.0000946505,
-0.0260973126,
0.0190031901,
-0.0261921044,
-0.000049529,
-0.0415566489,
0.0594579801,
-0.0079252562,
-0.0012482856,
0.0234055389,
0.0405530483,
-0.0046560122,
0.0289813876,
0.0172210243,
0.0643174946,
-0.0248351898,
0.0165655706,
0.0176331308,
-0.0177495815,
0.0161386337,
0.0492879823,
0.0475635715,
-0.060171131,
-0.0019991731,
-0.0241660587,
-0.0315964594,
-0.0767950565,
0.00431976,
0.0542628951,
-0.0776759014,
0.0086714718,
-0.0309815761,
-0.0250160731,
0.0708395317,
0.0117957238,
0.0332523361,
0.0244513396,
0.0329497084,
-0.0099187763,
-0.0140206311,
0.0476922095,
-0.0464605652,
0.00907283,
-0.120684512,
-0.0884766728,
0.0158239901,
0.0022146262,
0.0029825578,
-0.0030879991,
-0.0691825449,
-0.059182778,
-0.0007408701,
0.0611310974,
0.0093814284,
0.0519611351,
0.0294960495,
-0.0588881895,
0.0009988152,
-0.0078915451,
-0.0149379484,
0.0174272992,
0.0525604784,
-0.0228694249,
-0.0253288466,
0.0122279497,
-0.0275680944,
0.031679038,
0.0745356679,
0.0202717986,
-0.0428917781,
0.011334355,
0.0196517687,
0.0301651042,
-0.0036416403,
-0.0155443586,
-0.0138264028,
-0.05510436,
0.0583570674,
0.0248994362,
0.0225043222,
-0.0426148735,
-0.0034961614,
-0.0063671349,
-0.0148944724,
-0.0114343837,
-0.0387506075,
-0.0313300528,
0.0304386057,
-0.028540168,
0.0782654807,
-0.0032990328,
0.0437834263,
0.0391475074,
0.0236322172,
-0.0131928651,
0.0087648509,
0.008660771,
0.0441773534,
0.0262056272,
0.0568686463,
-0.0035094989,
0.0489982255,
0.008096098,
0.0088312756,
-0.0175231192,
-0.0137335155,
-0.0537942871,
-0.0107061341,
0.0590058006,
-0.0526676066,
0.0463906452,
0.0014022371,
0.0136399092,
-0.0373517759,
0.049515456,
0.0001532826,
-0.0226238891,
0.0084470492,
0.0429559425,
-0.0141204018,
0.0043936227,
0.0754739866,
0.0490776598,
0.0465739779,
0.003273563,
0.0216260534,
-0.0441000499,
-0.0019906948,
0.0317075439,
-0.0165695399,
-0.0063046766,
0.0185031313,
-0.0344713889,
-0.0582561903,
-0.0482796244,
0.0000688815,
-0.0041278466,
-0.0213928036,
0.0488703959,
0.0247454401,
-0.0232195202,
-0.0001531316,
-0.0589237064,
-0.0328733884,
-0.0061512478,
-0.0211248361,
-0.0325245075,
-5.666552803e-33,
-0.0490208678,
0.0094522079,
0.0241751708,
0.0078491038,
0.0134567106,
0.0039400095,
-0.0216215812,
-0.0327537581,
-0.0246863961,
-0.0247128308,
-0.0000786436,
-0.0082468111,
0.0061701555,
0.0294413604,
-0.0002888583,
-0.0035943014,
0.0396231897,
-0.0217070524,
-0.0231117699,
0.0233227443,
0.0291683674,
0.0064523262,
0.0790240839,
-0.0177640095,
-0.0057973503,
-0.0097509427,
0.0274717398,
0.010633586,
-0.0174874477,
0.0910540298,
0.0358169898,
0.0484966487,
0.0130568165,
-0.0462687276,
-0.0254372191,
-0.0434100814,
-0.0246326663,
-0.0540791266,
0.0244019944,
0.0346436873,
0.0125210648,
-0.0446019806,
0.0077959271,
-0.0189663582,
-0.0307890754,
-0.0329422168,
0.0228722002,
-0.0288795624,
-0.0412927717,
0.0160845444,
-0.0435126424,
0.0338928327,
-0.0112275546,
-0.0276954751,
0.0267026257,
0.0170565452,
-0.0029507782,
-0.0145683233,
-0.0295734219,
0.0528463162,
0.0806714892,
0.1001383364,
0.0665300936,
0.0351339728,
0.0220333673,
0.0265412107,
-0.0063840039,
0.0278894696,
0.0576146133,
0.0075653819,
0.0508972071,
0.0724100545,
0.0123799564,
-0.0275962614,
0.0247445926,
-0.011582328,
-0.0804780871,
-0.006446525,
0.033123415,
0.0165464859,
0.0090550007,
-0.0085134255,
-0.0437862612,
-0.0225927792,
-0.0403279886,
-0.0053054714,
0.0042591784,
-0.0110442182,
0.0456659757,
0.0028180585,
-0.0387660749,
-0.0296823066,
0.041597534,
-0.0265249778,
-0.0450217389,
-0.0094113089,
-0.0185069852,
0.01601821,
0.0025608491,
0.0125233242,
-0.0899103731,
-0.0906382427,
0.0274657868,
-0.0528072454,
0.0425812081,
-0.0049409643,
0.0261847656,
0.0255438183,
-0.036974512,
-0.0113146156,
-0.0395789184,
0.0123534445,
-0.0073583215,
0.0316880681,
0.0265754852,
0.0115971947,
0.0021246821,
0.0694522262,
-0.003640214,
-0.0380528234,
-0.027574949,
-0.0191856436,
-0.008664133,
0.0547277108,
-0.0113466838,
0.0057528671,
-0.0328786224,
-0.0115915034,
0.0115181999,
-0.018302016,
-0.0021342742,
0.0152467564,
2.469e-7,
0.0142071983,
0.0543849394,
-0.0143371392,
0.0479775704,
-0.021377258,
0.0029917494,
-0.0360993333,
-0.0202977639,
0.0247122534,
-0.0118893916,
0.0012557356,
0.0313772671,
0.084651798,
0.0213547256,
-0.0717021748,
0.0053377138,
0.0027599356,
0.0410760008,
-0.0441091694,
0.0019462636,
-0.0001672853,
0.1027155966,
-0.0103099681,
-0.0040101875,
-0.0278714374,
0.0149641093,
0.0013023075,
-0.0456697047,
-0.0038959344,
0.0750602856,
0.0255595874,
0.0338783786,
-0.0182856135,
0.0334924497,
-0.0526263937,
0.0109883547,
-0.045007918,
0.0780579969,
0.0071468512,
-0.0071971449,
0.0353674814,
-0.0038525495,
-0.0472256504,
-0.0187952854,
0.0533056222,
-0.0432450958,
-0.0124268625,
0.0145534184,
0.0121656423,
-0.0226651803,
0.0016174,
-0.0270999391,
0.015138221,
0.0281120222,
0.0365593098,
-0.051174432,
-0.0169374552,
-0.0231692027,
0.0174462069,
0.0251897071,
-0.0211679563,
-0.0815084204,
-0.0299602393,
0.0032317247,
-0.0024650465,
-0.0232016742,
0.0102822063,
2.442068392e-34,
0.0275853891,
-0.0321287028,
0.0405546203,
0.0363596603,
0.012188239,
-0.0166343004,
-0.0217967629,
0.0333972834,
-0.0114156371,
-0.0814314559,
-0.0000054246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09674v1 | Navigating the Peril of Generated Alternative Facts: A ChatGPT-4 Fabricated Omega Variant Case as a Cautionary Tale in Medical Misinformation | 2024-02-04T13:21:19 | 2024-02-04T13:21:19 | Malik Sallam, Jan Egger, Rainer Roehrig, Behrus Puladi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG | In an era where artificial intelligence (AI) intertwines with medical
research, the delineation of truth becomes increasingly complex. This study
ostensibly examines a purported novel SARS-CoV-2 variant, dubbed the Omega
variant, showcasing 31 unique mutations in the S gene region. However, the real
undercurrent of this narrative is a demonstration of the ease with which AI,
specifically ChatGPT-4, can fabricate convincing yet entirely fictional
scientific data. The so-called Omega variant was identified in a fully
vaccinated, previously infected 35-year-old male presenting with severe
COVID-19 symptoms. Through a detailed, albeit artificial, genomic analysis and
contact tracing, this study mirrors the rigorous methodology of genuine case
reports, thereby setting the stage for a compelling but entirely constructed
narrative. The entire case study was generated by ChatGPT-4, a large language
model by OpenAI. The fabricated Omega variant features an ensemble of
mutations, including N501Y and E484K, known for enhancing ACE2 receptor
affinity, alongside L452R and P681H, ostensibly indicative of immune evasion.
This variant's contrived interaction dynamics - severe symptoms in a vaccinated
individual versus mild ones in unvaccinated contacts - were designed to mimic
real-world complexities, including suggestions of antibody-dependent
enhancement (ADE). While the Omega variant is a product of AI-generated
fiction, the implications of this exercise are real and profound. The ease with
which AI can generate believable but false scientific information, as
illustrated in this case, raises significant concerns about the potential for
misinformation in medicine. This study, therefore, serves as a cautionary tale,
emphasizing the necessity for critical evaluation of sources, especially in an
age where AI tools like ChatGPT are becoming increasingly sophisticated and
widespread in their use. | [
0.0063999882,
0.036917869,
-0.0140448371,
-0.0097382264,
-0.0124336537,
0.0033181831,
0.0150653133,
-0.0171878003,
0.0544810407,
0.0240425654,
0.0351016968,
0.0373760983,
0.0416350514,
0.0875687227,
-0.0100160232,
0.0088034403,
0.0379524231,
0.0351274982,
0.0336169414,
-0.0054297168,
-0.077346541,
0.0357803106,
0.0123042958,
0.0324297361,
0.0421074405,
-0.0429212376,
0.0468083471,
-0.0179095846,
0.0182861481,
-0.0540718511,
0.0075629884,
-0.0136082405,
-0.0095764203,
0.0600245707,
0.0000024483,
-0.0395861976,
0.0020335363,
0.029426178,
-0.036825493,
-0.0167830307,
0.0418946706,
0.0080775358,
0.0030700616,
0.0207951143,
-0.0398850814,
-0.0371646918,
0.0665324554,
0.0185605567,
0.0139292767,
0.084776938,
-0.006183025,
-0.0278463364,
0.0912638232,
0.0286806207,
0.0355129726,
-0.0070075891,
0.0462353341,
0.0117338132,
0.05353323,
0.0176439546,
0.057820145,
0.0565318763,
-0.0104681365,
-0.0080780182,
-0.0166740194,
0.0751180872,
-0.007751782,
-0.0452741049,
0.0283526815,
0.0159901492,
0.0678401142,
-0.0474710986,
0.0243348982,
0.0211043023,
-0.022798745,
-0.0031703648,
-0.001036602,
-0.011599673,
-0.0491653197,
0.0087661697,
0.040658284,
-0.0054490576,
0.0521989726,
0.0129086273,
-0.0089913625,
0.0116028776,
-0.0477668494,
-0.0312975422,
-0.0430987626,
-0.0371755473,
-0.0162213948,
-0.087160863,
0.0223551709,
0.0388090238,
-0.0498702042,
0.0148933418,
-0.0040350109,
-0.0250045527,
0.0581753179,
-0.1211800873,
0.0018852985,
-0.0019466929,
0.0043913145,
-0.0273692403,
0.0267029423,
-0.0204025488,
-0.0483947024,
0.0725684091,
-0.0219428781,
0.0656042919,
-0.0382437408,
-0.0016344545,
-0.0265889633,
-0.0207686368,
0.0051806797,
0.0213661883,
-0.0487449989,
-0.0348579213,
-0.0341046229,
0.0441873744,
-0.0382729955,
0.0485008769,
-0.0418924764,
0.0407292247,
0.0093592759,
0.0215637013,
0.0093815699,
0.016591955,
0.006691223,
-0.0613644533,
0.0019495052,
-0.0377522744,
0.0086899316,
0.0157891475,
0.0116915228,
0.0408766009,
-0.0082650455,
0.0174118746,
0.0510231145,
-0.0164498389,
-0.0470239595,
-0.0657151192,
-0.012202953,
-0.0368493348,
0.0129982466,
0.0440069661,
-0.0452100895,
-0.0299647469,
-0.0238532461,
-0.0145196393,
-0.1169697791,
0.0368607901,
-0.0798194781,
-0.008848411,
0.0574240685,
0.0385192893,
-0.0127053857,
-0.0108833257,
0.0382334664,
0.0056594089,
0.0142523469,
0.0064123725,
0.04665244,
-0.0405146629,
0.021591194,
0.040797431,
0.043488849,
-0.0019946024,
-0.0162515361,
0.0603663437,
-0.0290696826,
0.0034088218,
-0.0064645018,
-0.0217667818,
0.0361749344,
-0.0150234345,
-0.0279541165,
0.0027042103,
0.0277905446,
0.0373366177,
0.0338515677,
0.0238017086,
0.0010048557,
-0.0217478294,
-0.0582475476,
0.0124580506,
-0.0364785343,
0.0126479035,
-0.0023924017,
-0.0197955426,
-0.0165014733,
-0.0081050368,
0.0022922114,
-0.0015955867,
-0.0300910342,
-0.0429361798,
-0.0223572832,
-0.0551478229,
0.068025656,
0.013726091,
-0.0150320996,
-0.0980134606,
-0.029178923,
0.0627955422,
0.0322559811,
0.0051834197,
-0.0510454439,
-0.0396877229,
-0.0012760613,
-0.012479702,
0.0495242737,
-0.0049985754,
-0.0321165547,
0.0115160858,
0.0440534912,
-0.0594593883,
0.0422558449,
0.0050143441,
-0.0418961644,
0.0185938627,
-0.0203394685,
0.0027993333,
-0.0404796228,
0.0036430762,
-0.1004016101,
-0.0191629864,
-0.0115844524,
-0.003852163,
0.0621433184,
0.0012685744,
0.0183034316,
0.0540368631,
0.0520459078,
-0.0248836428,
-0.0247989241,
0.0154909035,
0.0371492952,
0.0385408439,
-0.0368587859,
-0.0195719935,
-0.0200643595,
-0.0048225541,
-0.0266907252,
0.0242494103,
-0.0124722598,
-0.0235900898,
0.0211377162,
0.0135248266,
-0.0022006989,
0.0058195693,
0.039130345,
0.0191832185,
0.0046946439,
-0.009116509,
-0.0294124465,
0.0188195109,
-0.0286653508,
0.007897988,
-0.0415728129,
0.0576431714,
-0.0260751899,
0.0152044911,
0.0006656897,
-0.033678893,
-0.0538209714,
0.0225675553,
-0.0016685788,
-0.0374635719,
-0.0096899988,
0.04018097,
0.0006959478,
0.0158734936,
-0.0357431695,
-0.030135408,
0.0174293797,
0.0389358215,
-0.0382997021,
0.0572480001,
0.0240784306,
0.0159710161,
0.0191014595,
-0.0149160875,
-0.0386548825,
0.0175670739,
-0.0789197758,
0.0262224805,
0.0528172962,
-0.0020389962,
-0.0477648526,
-0.0384772792,
-0.0607285351,
0.0262378622,
-0.0123761576,
-0.011451385,
0.0176797919,
0.0054482082,
-0.0263605416,
0.0323032625,
0.0102694724,
0.056677103,
0.0567277223,
0.0465819985,
0.0390439704,
0.0039988123,
-0.0223297626,
-0.0163256265,
0.0124139888,
-0.048113931,
-0.0200945437,
0.0312722251,
0.0418359376,
0.0114330463,
-0.018183466,
0.0521923043,
-0.0075152768,
-0.0551607087,
0.0476933531,
-0.0885500088,
-0.0397787131,
0.0207192264,
-0.0330414139,
-0.0160831027,
0.0430733934,
-0.0053476705,
0.0490029603,
-0.092666924,
0.0093398429,
0.0132878507,
-0.0199781787,
-0.0099894069,
0.0193103682,
0.0825041458,
0.0383521356,
0.0409149416,
-0.0251125526,
-0.0111342585,
-0.0528276488,
-0.0302725304,
-0.0074634538,
0.0111181028,
0.0487174913,
-0.0017819006,
-0.0328683406,
-0.0074942387,
-0.0461342596,
-0.0259511843,
0.0208220445,
0.0004091021,
-0.070441395,
-0.0470995456,
0.0205905773,
0.0514618531,
0.0142333787,
0.0013099007,
0.0158479139,
-0.0313324593,
0.0181631166,
-0.0367953852,
0.0490698814,
-0.0216348488,
0.0190163255,
0.0179618672,
-0.0369169116,
0.0035480463,
-0.0431429856,
-0.0043319361,
-0.0321194865,
-0.0029047588,
-0.0216693524,
0.0519539192,
0.0081195878,
-0.038294591,
0.0036864353,
0.0652535781,
0.0001728549,
0.0052707484,
0.0366363153,
-0.018175479,
-0.0631681308,
-0.0363065898,
0.049537234,
-0.0753815696,
0.0190531611,
-0.0021356214,
-0.0102466885,
-0.0847572759,
-0.0487425774,
-0.0296347197,
0.0355120823,
0.0867510363,
0.0150138093,
-0.0344901532,
-0.0405418538,
-0.0632011667,
-0.0273741782,
-0.0123753175,
0.0225120485,
-0.0226140358,
0.0501886606,
0.0096402112,
-0.0200517084,
-0.0074481238,
-0.0187722147,
0.0250794031,
0.0141976094,
0.0358601958,
0.043082606,
0.0625214949,
-0.031439662,
-0.0266697109,
-0.029546719,
0.0682130978,
0.0165926535,
-0.0057790368,
0.0964393392,
-0.0114730569,
0.024623936,
-0.0704785809,
0.0229704995,
-0.0157033447,
0.0086970227,
0.0073407316,
0.0705211312,
-0.0314595811,
-0.0989115536,
-0.0361314267,
-0.0001333651,
0.0304565672,
0.0407851562,
-0.0035609973,
0.0458932519,
0.0307077076,
0.0219415184,
0.0993065163,
0.0079775341,
-0.0161749106,
0.0336864106,
-0.0061277482,
-0.1120460257,
-0.0147172464,
-0.0445526056,
-0.0312240832,
-0.0219480563,
0.0108065009,
-0.0663225055,
0.0170047674,
-0.0340385176,
-0.0212079082,
0.0257803053,
0.0377285369,
0.0357308462,
0.0279466361,
-0.0269056633,
0.0241372585,
-0.0119248852,
0.0023306562,
0.0457201414,
0.0230422933,
-0.0507480241,
0.0419570059,
0.0209514368,
0.0296218656,
0.0220691338,
0.0109606506,
0.0261397995,
0.0457393639,
0.0372129753,
-0.0253927745,
-0.0170509741,
-0.0385176279,
-0.0207969565,
-0.0064235129,
-0.0112527953,
0.0334591977,
0.0277754646,
-0.0115765724,
-0.0331385769,
-0.0463837348,
-0.0001615302,
0.0446608067,
0.0073332256,
0.0418789797,
-0.0444989204,
-0.0316485167,
-0.0107780602,
-0.0006855443,
-0.0389489159,
0.0169201586,
0.0186548401,
-0.0541747622,
-0.029471226,
0.0052681617,
-0.0416381024,
0.0223112106,
-0.0871640071,
-0.0063343039,
-0.0567400642,
0.0538994819,
0.0311755724,
0.0783864483,
0.0449210368,
-0.0352715626,
0.011168329,
0.052199807,
-0.0176127516,
0.0139358025,
0.0142138535,
-0.0154899694,
-0.0068735415,
0.0047709621,
0.0010240223,
0.0192847811,
-0.0599698611,
-0.049552802,
-0.038005624,
0.028952213,
-0.0104513625,
0.0474394709,
-0.0057171294,
-0.009209685,
-0.0136115253,
-0.0414137803,
0.0139624728,
-0.0079223448,
0.010564195,
-0.0357509851,
-0.0104013989,
-0.0605800934,
-0.0056173573,
0.0369853452,
-0.0136078913,
0.1192104369,
-0.0217861086,
-0.0569223836,
-0.0148879904,
-0.0528307483,
-0.0209561996,
0.0180881508,
-0.048279915,
-0.01825995,
-0.0706398562,
-0.0214525778,
0.03276195,
-0.0019707244,
-0.0132174436,
0.0034563858,
-0.0490564182,
0.0392955355,
0.0210724529,
-0.0479318909,
0.0137380194,
0.0629793778,
-0.0393376611,
-0.022663841,
0.0016388881,
-7.066620207e-33,
0.0372949764,
-0.0258378536,
0.0311396569,
0.0029275739,
0.0049258904,
0.073749885,
-0.0631405488,
-0.030367896,
-0.0427383259,
0.0475826114,
-0.0166024957,
-0.0097883977,
0.0075508361,
-0.0313590765,
-0.0048417859,
0.0002698878,
0.0670082793,
-0.0000712729,
-0.0120620579,
-0.0028532671,
0.0092364298,
0.0195958447,
0.0059857722,
-0.0904901177,
0.0394625403,
-0.0272715744,
0.0127254864,
-0.015991088,
-0.04668146,
0.0212174505,
0.0353701264,
-0.0057738973,
0.0107820574,
0.0332247131,
0.0047502415,
-0.0280723609,
-0.0001540235,
0.0335833021,
0.0014706531,
-0.0491199382,
-0.0180242546,
-0.0345592424,
0.0403566249,
0.0121585829,
-0.0146503383,
0.0095228069,
0.0202144925,
-0.0549949594,
-0.0044131563,
-0.0124480426,
-0.051823508,
-0.0026814556,
-0.0098159108,
0.0167638231,
-0.0584396385,
-0.0039801407,
-0.0379355513,
0.044627022,
0.0127186738,
0.0272903237,
0.0710055828,
-0.0260664746,
0.0256359801,
-0.033473596,
0.0083247479,
0.0074972492,
0.0644944385,
0.0024469066,
-0.0872589052,
-0.0030869714,
-0.004436031,
0.0663294718,
0.0086379992,
0.0421800017,
-0.024248844,
-0.0585145243,
-0.0701815858,
0.0461352021,
-0.0334914774,
0.0230043326,
-0.0274966136,
-0.024565177,
-0.0565702207,
0.0003557054,
-0.0132825226,
-0.041402027,
-0.0428514034,
-0.0094093969,
-0.0209097993,
-0.0133765545,
-0.0265746061,
0.0563851446,
-0.0171564054,
-0.0229553897,
0.0336009264,
-0.0478828102,
0.0389520936,
-0.0186259784,
-0.015397232,
0.0152918957,
-0.0359806269,
0.013336095,
0.0495910309,
0.0002137568,
0.0467920341,
0.0106955366,
0.0188831631,
-0.0047475905,
-0.0127389254,
0.016570542,
-0.0067627681,
0.0172631666,
0.0147041604,
-0.025025079,
0.03361018,
0.0071754446,
0.0233876668,
-0.0091700992,
0.0266219135,
0.0727167651,
-0.0080382563,
-0.0235943925,
-0.0564597733,
0.0338568799,
-0.0378413014,
0.0325139388,
-0.0040967762,
0.0339386202,
-0.0195486099,
-0.1061670482,
-0.0049889307,
-0.0117675904,
3.378e-7,
0.0418820567,
0.0907657668,
0.0038955903,
-0.0258019716,
0.0146591514,
0.033293359,
-0.0297440719,
-0.0086058537,
0.018897444,
-0.0325384289,
0.0290309247,
0.0293167271,
0.0068672546,
0.0143611953,
0.0169270113,
0.0096047316,
-0.0503832027,
0.0488230512,
-0.0278338511,
-0.0028697867,
0.0203580447,
0.0009026913,
-0.0038268156,
-0.0189850945,
0.0135551058,
0.0223119818,
-0.0005997458,
0.0376940034,
-0.0105297677,
0.0201820098,
-0.0151677281,
-0.0103346156,
0.0254674796,
0.0450784191,
-0.0724986494,
-0.0729434118,
-0.0399162509,
0.0402822867,
-0.0276302863,
0.0480805151,
0.0212477501,
-0.0455139652,
0.031296581,
-0.0257872995,
0.021527715,
-0.0348748155,
-0.0552586019,
-0.0074552838,
-0.0502343178,
0.0291219726,
0.027738627,
0.0138145024,
-0.0210415181,
0.0540795438,
-0.0304249153,
0.0553135835,
-0.0043351594,
-0.0174719486,
0.0049923966,
-0.0177253243,
-0.0371814966,
-0.039684467,
0.0439150818,
-0.0048875329,
0.0370617546,
-0.0398241766,
0.0260173045,
3.057148107e-34,
0.0321267135,
0.0226310957,
-0.0258820858,
-0.0544018485,
0.0280262642,
-0.0053149574,
0.0162592977,
0.0147407027,
0.0250765178,
0.0022207957,
-0.0260476656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02479v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02479v2 | BRAIn: Bayesian Reward-conditioned Amortized Inference for natural language generation from feedback | 2024-02-04T13:16:29 | 2024-06-10T10:18:46 | Gaurav Pandey, Yatin Nandwani, Tahira Naseem, Mayank Mishra, Guangxuan Xu, Dinesh Raghu, Sachindra Joshi, Asim Munawar, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Distribution matching methods for language model alignment such as Generation
with Distributional Control (GDC) and Distributional Policy Gradient (DPG) have
not received the same level of attention in reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF) as contrastive methods such as Sequence Likelihood Calibration
(SLiC), Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and its variants. We identify high
variance of the gradient estimate as the primary reason for the lack of success
of these methods and propose a self-normalized baseline to reduce the variance.
We further generalize the target distribution in DPG, GDC and DPO by using
Bayes' rule to define the reward-conditioned posterior. The resulting approach,
referred to as BRAIn - Bayesian Reward-conditioned Amortized Inference acts as
a bridge between distribution matching methods and DPO and significantly
outperforms prior art in summarization and Antropic HH tasks. | [
0.033629939,
0.1246237159,
0.0158300418,
-0.0304671414,
-0.0176890139,
0.0182577055,
-0.0131826224,
-0.0188290942,
-0.0426920801,
-0.0004452524,
-0.0397559851,
-0.0666607395,
0.0622039996,
0.0200397316,
0.0436114483,
-0.0623248443,
0.0087273009,
-0.005588314,
0.0172513798,
-0.0076266364,
0.006566199,
0.0255168658,
-0.0394090898,
0.0626867935,
0.0285372492,
0.0074880715,
0.0034224258,
-0.0013139343,
0.038162116,
-0.0290707834,
-0.0036046512,
0.0565287322,
0.0556010157,
0.0064242017,
0.0000019392,
-0.0227953121,
0.0023194181,
-0.0198583156,
0.0128543954,
-0.0362444818,
0.0663498193,
-0.0160375703,
-0.0077709267,
0.0231755544,
-0.0017093945,
0.0136214849,
0.0565877892,
0.0377902351,
0.0275682509,
0.0585471801,
0.0069232346,
-0.033909481,
0.0234327316,
-0.0597133711,
0.0384751409,
0.0010899354,
0.0163387544,
0.0289423093,
0.0271706451,
-0.0305637326,
-0.0208697598,
0.016399527,
0.0264751874,
-0.0139802378,
-0.0072235735,
0.0695840642,
0.041942168,
0.0089610545,
-0.0158579201,
0.0578560941,
0.0011288655,
-0.0305434093,
0.0187675301,
-0.0169087779,
0.0015207524,
0.0050999224,
-0.0100525478,
0.0932429731,
-0.0304174591,
0.0511592627,
0.0370969176,
-0.034252841,
0.0165249258,
0.0185879618,
-0.0059491559,
0.0685381815,
0.0336708948,
-0.0173928924,
-0.0013495997,
0.0470774025,
-0.0819748342,
-0.0714743733,
0.0070540095,
0.0093849264,
-0.0683918595,
0.0016323129,
-0.1004563943,
-0.0395241007,
-0.0179538708,
-0.0024256727,
0.0407067873,
0.0623363703,
0.0166054573,
-0.0178641677,
0.0017913659,
0.0531730577,
-0.0305345971,
-0.0057453513,
-0.0378458463,
0.0467278995,
-0.0125194592,
-0.0004042947,
-0.0103837103,
0.0265978668,
-0.0458862595,
-0.0333854146,
-0.0808847547,
0.0132462382,
-0.0147266965,
-0.0031043093,
0.0058037043,
0.0377317704,
-0.0539121665,
0.0467218421,
-0.036851339,
-0.0096175727,
-0.0512835085,
0.0136797801,
0.0528738722,
0.0226635728,
-0.039381519,
0.0492684878,
-0.000975461,
-0.0179512072,
0.0068157888,
0.0539366081,
-0.0220945776,
0.0100115342,
-0.0361441523,
-0.0352461152,
-0.0425287001,
-0.0430568568,
0.0123989871,
-0.0797690079,
0.0155837853,
-0.0261458568,
-0.0508863963,
-0.0237250999,
0.0043293349,
0.0138925519,
-0.0297678784,
0.0281600486,
0.0113121569,
-0.0116321687,
0.0386671498,
-0.025603259,
0.0061037703,
0.0522406287,
0.0759281889,
0.0273237899,
-0.0453454703,
0.0583605058,
-0.0044580218,
0.0091723967,
0.0396938957,
0.0179738682,
-0.0563106239,
-0.0393761918,
-0.0582964718,
0.0683408454,
0.1202152595,
0.0370179191,
-0.0459141284,
0.005228864,
0.0467544422,
0.0242716689,
-0.0040960242,
-0.0534739718,
0.0616208315,
-0.0039458922,
-0.0362016447,
0.041970253,
-0.0378071368,
0.0346694514,
-0.0076524992,
0.0431707501,
0.058127895,
0.0012738435,
-0.0011825049,
-0.0397389121,
0.0243959799,
-0.0077676829,
-0.009197141,
0.0073001492,
0.0201841444,
0.0223893486,
-0.0411365218,
0.0356801823,
0.0595521964,
-0.0195467435,
0.020483844,
-0.029931413,
0.0441600941,
0.0301296003,
0.0515147559,
0.0359325036,
-0.0147722857,
-0.0102768596,
-0.0551368073,
0.0911069959,
-0.0076454682,
0.0088831149,
-0.028503716,
-0.0262396783,
-0.0405474603,
-0.0083546955,
0.0140786897,
0.0283882096,
0.0009929112,
0.0041142255,
0.0103121633,
-0.0081063611,
-0.0507757664,
0.0421699211,
-0.0006894241,
-0.0100464234,
0.0273154527,
-0.002687162,
0.0392842926,
-0.0098227011,
-0.0143509647,
0.0380146839,
-0.0227273926,
-0.0136574563,
-0.0265678447,
0.0205314662,
-0.0573341958,
-0.0813411027,
0.0223370586,
-0.029564118,
0.0124110598,
-0.0035515497,
-0.0086676972,
-0.0507035032,
0.0388931744,
-0.0245803315,
-0.0003859707,
-0.0122769782,
0.0335673578,
0.0208900832,
0.0207492691,
-0.0464489274,
0.057276275,
-0.0287928004,
-0.0222770888,
0.0315666944,
0.0179328602,
-0.0287222639,
-0.0493159592,
-0.0046482971,
-0.0043117683,
0.0110568767,
-0.0176816154,
0.049925413,
0.0408868715,
-0.0384631306,
0.0019145098,
-0.043682646,
0.0344986729,
-0.0099809775,
0.0425808392,
0.0605968796,
0.0078838207,
-0.0094581116,
0.0055789314,
-0.0489835776,
-0.0107377768,
0.0363604687,
0.009307717,
0.0232425183,
-0.0137254009,
0.0126387123,
-0.0589013174,
-0.0004631265,
-0.0287424121,
0.0217677262,
0.0042160791,
0.0230990276,
-0.0623650737,
0.0481560975,
-0.0504572056,
0.0243388861,
0.0011647698,
-0.0072576921,
0.0324207246,
0.0097648026,
0.081011042,
0.0540751442,
0.0353269763,
0.0039450717,
0.0614991896,
0.007613637,
-0.0422101803,
0.0082993489,
-0.0614339374,
-0.0102449963,
-0.0097226212,
-0.0283641834,
0.0219985303,
0.0893699974,
0.04042916,
0.0376119241,
-0.0700824559,
0.0213043243,
-0.0017227832,
-0.0229352359,
-0.0164373461,
0.0024782026,
-0.0275288187,
0.0051059108,
-0.0415074192,
-0.0504077114,
0.1023528874,
-0.0452138558,
0.034743242,
-0.0530936159,
0.0017778602,
-0.0234406218,
-0.0148266917,
0.0289646965,
0.0288962591,
0.0057489667,
-0.0327983275,
-0.0592161007,
-0.0335182697,
0.0186115764,
-0.0073889405,
0.0378926881,
-0.0532379076,
0.0130379088,
-0.0087640686,
-0.0121844597,
-0.0622198731,
-0.0568338521,
0.0094749629,
0.0180732533,
0.0398910604,
-0.0471294373,
-0.0365653895,
0.0277962834,
0.0516491085,
0.0447619632,
-0.0341981761,
-0.0265717003,
-0.0238017533,
0.0506451763,
0.1127860025,
0.0167808775,
0.020532243,
-0.0290823616,
-0.0524638221,
0.0240760781,
0.0590222403,
0.0590441227,
-0.0056723002,
0.0298755784,
0.0211069845,
-0.0407052338,
0.0244953148,
0.0343242139,
0.0389261134,
-0.007377665,
-0.0140311467,
0.1173605323,
-0.0006113633,
-0.0911429152,
0.0127949528,
-0.0015532398,
0.1024769992,
-0.0293724593,
0.0133505715,
-0.095011808,
-0.0054283412,
0.0054935063,
0.0493932068,
-0.0021550497,
-0.0480085611,
-0.0158226117,
-0.0876445845,
-0.0029605317,
0.0268860068,
-0.0568806715,
-0.0172309298,
-0.0135012111,
0.0188110154,
-0.0049941465,
0.0204090867,
0.0147776818,
0.0062514497,
0.049020078,
0.0382329486,
0.0260858852,
-0.0378066339,
-0.0138382213,
-0.048556108,
0.0395693928,
0.102466844,
0.024548633,
0.0278373845,
-0.015229499,
-0.0280242469,
-0.0258951914,
-0.0248788483,
-0.0069404193,
0.0160194989,
-0.0253442954,
0.0205405168,
-0.015682932,
0.0714827925,
-0.0207297243,
-0.015312437,
-0.0137988077,
0.0322480761,
-0.0328343771,
-0.0015198973,
-0.0362806953,
0.0518420711,
0.0509377681,
0.0590297468,
0.0423239432,
-0.060871277,
-0.03245496,
-0.005873363,
-0.0282858796,
-0.0475646146,
-0.0129389334,
0.0132522061,
-0.0107056815,
-0.0357367769,
-0.1253807396,
-0.0215894338,
-0.0244718008,
0.0394470207,
0.0050592679,
-0.0180890225,
0.0071975025,
-0.0585077852,
-0.0193643421,
0.0241811275,
-0.0224330109,
-0.0006115555,
-0.06637308,
-0.0319016464,
-0.0483393222,
-0.0463126712,
-0.0273167472,
0.0316916741,
-0.0787245408,
-0.0857531726,
-0.0237308983,
0.0332323462,
0.0138508985,
0.0497175567,
0.0104044741,
-0.0129105691,
0.059377715,
0.0213231109,
0.002928114,
0.0488580912,
-0.0290619787,
0.0384640209,
0.0083200261,
0.0298764203,
-0.0196657199,
0.0212877374,
0.0260659382,
0.0750213936,
0.0386677086,
-0.0252500158,
0.0238322951,
-0.0119282035,
0.0022139004,
-0.0943472981,
0.0059723756,
-0.0427956842,
-0.0481630042,
-0.021568248,
-0.0181405228,
-0.0351609886,
-0.0176031291,
0.0184144825,
0.0091028512,
0.0060150269,
-0.0228216257,
-0.0174014587,
0.0098587358,
-0.0149127422,
-0.0347318389,
0.0050554401,
0.004490687,
0.009667092,
0.0156854559,
0.0207816008,
-0.0150358621,
-0.0432982631,
0.0628847554,
-0.0104299979,
0.0730198249,
0.0407985598,
-0.0276397057,
-0.0037149391,
0.0096852249,
-0.0622515045,
-0.015003087,
-0.0162524693,
-0.0033269881,
0.0574781857,
-0.0067348448,
0.0702301189,
-0.0160194151,
0.0190799534,
-0.0077440855,
0.0389596708,
-0.0347729623,
-0.0124523202,
0.0307996981,
0.0048450436,
-0.0004174884,
-0.0271574408,
0.0789268315,
0.0237927865,
0.0112506021,
-0.0446936823,
0.0023494414,
-0.0193365142,
-0.0437659658,
-0.0293015223,
-0.0019186485,
-0.029162392,
-0.0170662068,
-0.025158383,
-0.0530888103,
-0.0286956206,
0.0352748223,
0.0057752621,
0.000785391,
0.0574624352,
0.0320183374,
-0.0565088056,
-0.0367974117,
-0.0461165234,
0.0288798902,
-0.0462255999,
-0.0320644341,
-0.0857112259,
-6.25215764e-33,
-0.0515020005,
-0.0455408804,
0.0325779431,
-0.0215485692,
-0.0520147458,
-0.0177464988,
-0.0611795299,
-0.0021419665,
0.0396879092,
-0.0097644459,
0.0006330503,
0.000871278,
0.009239533,
0.0236926842,
0.0163353495,
0.0176822469,
0.0293623898,
-0.0092301825,
-0.0801603869,
0.019984927,
0.0408606902,
0.004255286,
0.0535077639,
-0.0068610054,
0.0281630568,
0.0115148677,
-0.0173689164,
-0.0050752694,
0.0001015502,
0.0290363356,
-0.0101654278,
0.0111357281,
0.0010726165,
-0.0013729441,
-0.0210530572,
0.0182838496,
-0.0230342802,
-0.0147073418,
0.0407403968,
-0.0263251066,
-0.0643713623,
-0.018497644,
0.0419969968,
-0.0094424253,
-0.0123026269,
0.0141410846,
0.0114498232,
-0.0209347736,
-0.0022264356,
-0.007972301,
-0.0619291104,
0.0074743167,
0.0088870004,
-0.0012988383,
-0.015618653,
0.0223798733,
-0.0220072065,
0.0148466285,
-0.0251622945,
0.0356056318,
0.0342315249,
0.0423286147,
0.0749555379,
0.0515747294,
0.0352639034,
0.0315183997,
0.0283556357,
-0.0277479421,
-0.0435362943,
0.0044572102,
-0.0021326018,
0.0028921447,
-0.022878401,
0.0168890636,
0.0470152497,
0.0375257619,
-0.0209391825,
0.0526450351,
-0.002993146,
0.0318458639,
0.0110772513,
0.0154648786,
-0.026214242,
-0.0151139349,
-0.0406680778,
-0.0269953273,
-0.0162245911,
-0.0521368124,
0.0069404617,
0.0163492262,
-0.0100698946,
-0.0550637618,
0.0154977934,
-0.0000360269,
0.0052109114,
-0.0053026937,
-0.0423288308,
-0.0083986958,
0.0121462932,
-0.0045959963,
-0.0893876031,
0.0116644921,
0.0210516974,
0.0084299613,
-0.0122747328,
0.0376799405,
0.0003080368,
0.0113017559,
-0.0075563816,
0.0257112999,
-0.0386976711,
0.0168838892,
-0.0118052205,
0.0227208212,
0.0456817076,
-0.0167250931,
0.0007701453,
-0.0056568682,
-0.0040189717,
-0.0380140468,
-0.0025449181,
0.0471201278,
0.0038742847,
0.0562510006,
-0.0271636527,
0.0253720321,
-0.0013173088,
0.0325483792,
0.0124976505,
-0.0767586827,
-0.0383426398,
0.0159151759,
2.688e-7,
0.0077849263,
-0.0063079856,
0.0157872438,
0.0223569516,
0.0006404555,
0.0206513051,
0.0279643014,
0.0014227012,
0.0058993734,
-0.0295237359,
0.026204681,
0.024206182,
0.0441477522,
-0.0075047179,
-0.0483519137,
-0.0243669786,
-0.1002390608,
0.0208780598,
-0.0134171918,
-0.062059354,
0.0135178631,
0.0276107341,
0.0149600785,
-0.0315754227,
0.0322222337,
0.0247235373,
0.062021099,
0.0194317605,
-0.0234065913,
0.0087332129,
-0.0116326585,
-0.0221722797,
-0.0103708468,
0.0075365133,
-0.0034817951,
-0.0014583428,
-0.0294732172,
0.0337292105,
0.0244393367,
-0.027625056,
-0.0238411278,
0.0101878978,
0.0189225115,
-0.0365052782,
0.0190764219,
-0.0450486802,
-0.0317297727,
-0.0404703692,
0.0120958155,
0.0008711153,
0.0035775341,
-0.0222074054,
-0.0218311902,
-0.0087469984,
0.030677788,
0.051643502,
0.0008589547,
-0.0417221487,
-0.0306177605,
0.0525626652,
-0.0487875044,
-0.0033656179,
-0.0570374355,
-0.0045936308,
-0.0105712721,
-0.0813558772,
-0.0246382691,
2.604541685e-34,
0.0122829275,
-0.0221732296,
0.0112995999,
-0.0167547781,
0.0131991627,
0.0318781473,
0.0033574379,
-0.0025675248,
0.0393814109,
-0.0632485971,
-0.061485894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02456v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02456v2 | tnGPS: Discovering Unknown Tensor Network Structure Search Algorithms via Large Language Models (LLMs) | 2024-02-04T12:06:13 | 2024-06-01T15:54:54 | Junhua Zeng, Chao Li, Zhun Sun, Qibin Zhao, Guoxu Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Tensor networks are efficient for extremely high-dimensional representation,
but their model selection, known as tensor network structure search (TN-SS), is
a challenging problem. Although several works have targeted TN-SS, most
existing algorithms are manually crafted heuristics with poor performance,
suffering from the curse of dimensionality and local convergence. In this work,
we jump out of the box, studying how to harness large language models (LLMs) to
automatically discover new TN-SS algorithms, replacing the involvement of human
experts. By observing how human experts innovate in research, we model their
common workflow and propose an automatic algorithm discovery framework called
tnGPS. The proposed framework is an elaborate prompting pipeline that instruct
LLMs to generate new TN-SS algorithms through iterative refinement and
enhancement. The experimental results demonstrate that the algorithms
discovered by tnGPS exhibit superior performance in benchmarks compared to the
current state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0171649959,
0.0737239122,
-0.0328993164,
0.0306658,
-0.0344535038,
0.0093802148,
0.0283508897,
0.0199404694,
0.0397639424,
0.0297073629,
-0.0103449756,
-0.0339267291,
-0.0074622324,
0.02340368,
0.0159659386,
-0.0017142597,
-0.0248640832,
-0.0173838697,
0.002488222,
-0.0269939955,
-0.0376034752,
0.014349943,
0.0212023538,
-0.00630712,
0.0108665256,
0.0168587063,
-0.0142371226,
-0.0112223113,
-0.0018849858,
-0.0195440166,
-0.0030537508,
0.0667062476,
0.0203904174,
0.0684815198,
0.0000019799,
0.0110123185,
-0.0330123529,
-0.0075076898,
0.0258416571,
0.0106057553,
0.0176553838,
0.0109362528,
0.0233261883,
-0.009716277,
-0.040574871,
0.0282997452,
0.0522184074,
0.0061323196,
0.0829171389,
0.0541614182,
-0.0083254734,
-0.002422702,
-0.0066182213,
0.0026125268,
-0.0045660348,
-0.0488485694,
0.0158899203,
0.0127405822,
0.0001177426,
-0.001058799,
0.0156128891,
0.044577647,
-0.0164340492,
-0.0222732481,
0.0355399698,
0.0324201211,
-0.0119341156,
-0.0202738978,
0.0012994191,
0.1150525585,
-0.0137379346,
-0.0253744833,
0.0541652068,
0.0094055412,
-0.0486185551,
0.0430701636,
-0.0548613891,
-0.0056284089,
-0.0209692884,
-0.022799639,
0.0125462934,
-0.0368365161,
0.0368930437,
-0.0054295138,
-0.0239105728,
0.0446846932,
0.055933442,
0.0085503003,
-0.0125996172,
-0.0305663235,
-0.0021316591,
-0.015118653,
0.0341182351,
-0.0059842276,
-0.0471065715,
-0.0408585221,
0.037555214,
-0.0964401364,
-0.0315519907,
-0.0373142697,
0.0832777023,
0.0468084626,
0.0140577117,
0.0600536168,
-0.0795968324,
0.0240747239,
-0.0909801051,
-0.0324331559,
-0.0411728695,
0.0080081802,
-0.045208849,
-0.0199834853,
-0.0294115487,
-0.0134886447,
-0.0269214567,
-0.0471853502,
-0.018000789,
0.0471336767,
-0.0178550854,
-0.0243079402,
0.0155869983,
0.047827445,
0.050139837,
-0.0122128846,
-0.0572709404,
0.0091275955,
-0.0051420806,
-0.0123830447,
-0.0652683005,
0.0520150512,
-0.0058082845,
0.0523678064,
0.0050073662,
-0.0109258192,
0.0637988821,
0.0828058124,
0.0041497597,
-0.0394080691,
-0.0096321516,
0.017774133,
0.0161629617,
-0.0580314621,
0.0635223836,
-0.0415969789,
0.0291129351,
0.0084295562,
-0.0054506883,
-0.0357979834,
-0.0144952657,
-0.0001982862,
-0.0448451117,
0.0184670743,
-0.0055071358,
0.0394214168,
0.0481201373,
-0.0147699527,
0.0100987013,
-0.0030066038,
0.0024065408,
0.026303025,
0.0435778759,
-0.0360035896,
0.0094565917,
0.0348476171,
0.0068443655,
-0.0044015152,
-0.01978123,
0.0127625084,
-0.0023197127,
0.0732658952,
-0.0053703561,
0.035314884,
-0.0644033551,
-0.0121859796,
0.0315748006,
0.0763686597,
0.0279151667,
0.0600599982,
0.0279639885,
-0.014741105,
-0.0256669577,
-0.029842658,
-0.0126634659,
0.0697978213,
-0.0193356182,
-0.0268952344,
0.0432572961,
0.0116888862,
-0.0336983912,
0.0207801647,
0.0107303225,
0.0069740321,
0.0120507265,
-0.0130579388,
0.0631094202,
-0.0163713675,
-0.0330668651,
0.0250663999,
-0.0148144616,
-0.0171188097,
-0.0182698499,
-0.0311303958,
0.0327730477,
0.0639802665,
0.0669324398,
-0.0474848263,
0.0090837497,
0.0167829003,
0.0005596707,
-0.0101864487,
0.0070134569,
0.0045348303,
-0.0334743299,
-0.0396974534,
-0.0356620811,
-0.0121431276,
-0.0070888223,
-0.0248440094,
0.0109786373,
0.0013886521,
0.0051479219,
-0.0388388298,
-0.0390171818,
0.0332174376,
-0.0488754325,
0.0017161127,
0.1049700156,
-0.0050376873,
0.0097659556,
0.0536515191,
-0.0074150171,
-0.0051334216,
0.0260919333,
-0.0273010787,
-0.0373674706,
-0.0278587006,
0.0150380414,
0.0354644358,
0.0315845273,
-0.0443545282,
-0.0410062894,
-0.0137297185,
-0.0319444686,
-0.0264552739,
0.1271285415,
-0.0043380097,
-0.0118912281,
-0.0205587838,
-0.0102066947,
-0.0288704708,
-0.0314764567,
-0.0200821627,
0.0576633327,
0.0172994938,
-0.014842269,
0.0499107726,
-0.0272456668,
0.0303317942,
-0.0126817906,
-0.0295354612,
0.0061317477,
0.0219942685,
0.0088261412,
0.0447941311,
0.0015366784,
0.0245846119,
-0.0395814776,
-0.0750803873,
0.01882766,
-0.0121667441,
0.0192916468,
0.0226480085,
-0.016045602,
-0.0047167004,
-0.0165944248,
0.0096873157,
0.0077514611,
0.0012481654,
-0.0327136591,
0.0458722822,
0.0106781768,
-0.0733479559,
-0.0493034236,
-0.05615348,
-0.0145290717,
0.061696317,
-0.0032087874,
-0.0104829604,
-0.0330883488,
-0.0131607903,
-0.013088434,
0.0285158101,
-0.0266331136,
-0.0007948999,
0.0242140424,
-0.0143878777,
0.0181895699,
0.0624713488,
-0.001992106,
0.0013853755,
0.0548257045,
0.0204365961,
0.0159404483,
0.0043165889,
-0.06047244,
-0.0138043091,
-0.0112307686,
-0.0100218747,
0.027550038,
0.0281218328,
-0.003557164,
-0.0064644292,
-0.0380111039,
-0.0098340707,
0.0068207942,
0.0464326628,
-0.060337428,
-0.0284987614,
0.0234542713,
0.0665558428,
0.0489897802,
-0.019955527,
0.0644821823,
-0.0036746692,
-0.0115062399,
-0.042688679,
-0.039083004,
-0.0509957895,
0.0385659076,
-0.0257051829,
0.0521470755,
-0.0142320618,
0.0344971605,
-0.0162998214,
0.0316287875,
0.0566314645,
-0.0107682245,
-0.0052749324,
0.0027207078,
0.0034638599,
0.0274532139,
-0.035929326,
-0.0130965114,
-0.0099470308,
-0.0292892326,
0.0128112473,
0.0282858629,
-0.0809574425,
-0.0197352841,
0.0066621131,
-0.0015204162,
0.0396468453,
-0.0041922717,
-0.0079013407,
-0.0240288042,
0.041886311,
0.0388014466,
-0.0623808838,
0.0649386942,
-0.0098370221,
0.0336552784,
0.0238379557,
0.0084836539,
0.0124758687,
-0.0853353441,
-0.002422733,
-0.0035978481,
-0.0240130089,
0.0079607731,
0.0147172194,
-0.0394836739,
-0.0079632215,
0.01933451,
0.0587384701,
0.0135916881,
-0.0605540425,
-0.0147369606,
0.0250491686,
0.0118769454,
0.0269595608,
0.0527296923,
-0.0839456469,
0.0148045234,
-0.0088246344,
0.0115676019,
-0.0277915467,
-0.0546683222,
0.0195946768,
-0.0424547531,
0.058346577,
0.0017724822,
0.0265130382,
0.0018667978,
-0.0689139962,
-0.0185148902,
-0.0323252045,
-0.0153229646,
0.0195175055,
0.014238623,
-0.0255198125,
-0.0101786163,
0.00289669,
-0.0597876646,
-0.005260522,
-0.0033290808,
0.0129433954,
-0.0007441455,
0.0096209757,
-0.0239633974,
-0.0426837467,
0.0071280138,
0.08051572,
0.0483027548,
-0.0183202941,
0.0277163647,
0.0105602844,
-0.0249306951,
-0.0745644942,
0.053888116,
-0.0755046085,
0.0285233259,
-0.0132686235,
0.0834125802,
-0.0082809944,
-0.0445272475,
-0.0393241942,
-0.0240543243,
0.010579546,
0.06077452,
-0.0191497803,
-0.0656487122,
0.0002655958,
0.024600897,
0.0328539312,
-0.0033697414,
-0.0536478087,
-0.0475311056,
0.0292784777,
0.0413108096,
-0.0380005464,
0.1016325876,
0.0144020133,
0.0231047403,
0.0143010104,
0.0036594933,
0.0014606679,
-0.033188317,
-0.0434721299,
0.0634368584,
0.0121760871,
0.0085662268,
-0.0425716378,
-0.0123531707,
0.010828346,
-0.0126604065,
-0.0467331521,
0.0297940169,
-0.105471395,
-0.0503111705,
-0.0873242989,
0.0417528749,
0.0056174998,
0.0028497083,
-0.0049197841,
-0.0329917297,
0.0547899567,
-0.0084785018,
-0.0580938533,
0.0019537031,
-0.0129364394,
-0.0645280182,
-0.0516789369,
-0.006240814,
-0.0013751062,
0.0011841999,
0.0620985292,
0.0129420264,
0.0059711742,
-0.0105279516,
0.0389899649,
0.016871918,
0.0375793129,
-0.0385439508,
0.034051612,
-0.0557062179,
-0.0015848187,
0.0618839413,
-0.0098008495,
-0.0517147221,
0.008610541,
0.0003257574,
-0.0160056502,
0.0276480466,
-0.0325232893,
0.0351148918,
0.0380576923,
-0.0123772724,
-0.0040209359,
0.0269210003,
0.0246620513,
0.043964617,
-0.0303809997,
0.0163700711,
0.016279418,
-0.0414646193,
0.0679201409,
-0.0345199034,
0.04485498,
0.029319793,
-0.0393961258,
-0.0480037257,
0.0281188767,
-0.0283707008,
-0.1328044385,
-0.0300580747,
-0.0004041692,
0.0834700316,
0.0400391594,
-0.0198482201,
-0.0456618257,
-0.0053374763,
0.000709438,
0.0077752732,
-0.0301108025,
0.0238742698,
-0.0153677752,
-0.0085764201,
-0.0152055463,
-0.0084777949,
0.0323144794,
0.0076508941,
0.0202853549,
-0.0158126764,
-0.0412873365,
0.0024216697,
-0.0307073016,
-0.0040588803,
0.0670867264,
-0.0459323004,
0.0105578322,
-0.0238942504,
-0.0191980489,
-0.0314433277,
-0.0407217182,
-0.0384987071,
-0.0172922332,
0.0487013608,
0.062302731,
0.0151477559,
0.0269243307,
0.0064118532,
-0.0400423966,
-0.0256444477,
-0.0630566478,
-0.053188175,
-6.26506016e-33,
0.0411191918,
-0.024207443,
0.0162140764,
-0.0344845578,
0.0263595767,
0.0030446444,
-0.0601304732,
0.0302958991,
0.0227816906,
0.0221827049,
-0.0105364677,
-0.0134345274,
-0.0272458401,
-0.0353825167,
0.071542412,
0.0488842726,
0.018444689,
-0.0109331608,
-0.0271200743,
0.0432888903,
0.0263038259,
0.0024069396,
0.0518950745,
-0.095297955,
-0.052398473,
0.0018021362,
0.0101199532,
0.0561909601,
0.0305706114,
0.0711069703,
-0.0297912546,
-0.0194636863,
-0.0104277739,
-0.046060171,
-0.0061732088,
-0.0299655031,
-0.0155121759,
0.0172855966,
0.0187607352,
-0.0526666753,
-0.0546792857,
-0.0004335491,
-0.0146460505,
0.0110054845,
-0.0267133433,
-0.0014439928,
0.0209443737,
0.0103958165,
0.0123126162,
0.020164635,
-0.0073795798,
0.0152247809,
-0.0479035787,
0.030377211,
0.0294008795,
0.0118205184,
-0.0383584201,
-0.0258651823,
-0.0414032079,
0.0610127188,
-0.0220533386,
-0.0195262618,
0.0273406748,
0.0128964717,
0.0380805247,
0.059394829,
0.0259571485,
0.0229408946,
0.0163663626,
-0.0235691685,
0.004777519,
0.0559812523,
0.0268232133,
-0.0017685236,
-0.0201681312,
0.0020174729,
-0.0644943938,
-0.0372319706,
0.0025343366,
0.0047717434,
0.0901335552,
0.0106715672,
-0.0160325207,
-0.0355787016,
-0.0179477986,
-0.0175956935,
-0.0535780042,
-0.0195029806,
-0.0079861889,
0.024623381,
-0.018976137,
-0.033267051,
0.0366534032,
-0.0592694953,
0.0679272264,
0.0470822155,
-0.0405343696,
0.0147002498,
0.0429548509,
-0.0209858268,
-0.0306240674,
-0.0729832426,
-0.0335195363,
-0.0613766834,
0.031956505,
0.0047154566,
-0.0352651514,
0.0341157839,
-0.0336610712,
-0.0105011305,
-0.0255041756,
-0.012406067,
-0.0057757138,
0.0125124622,
-0.0209472384,
0.0346315652,
-0.0159474537,
0.0351180434,
0.02541635,
0.0649970174,
-0.029759502,
0.03644545,
0.0282848272,
0.0067723622,
-0.0017216014,
-0.0328260548,
-0.0282085445,
-0.0052030315,
0.0919414982,
-0.0494454429,
-0.0289313532,
0.0056159091,
2.865e-7,
-0.0158078242,
0.066090703,
-0.0448553748,
0.0108125508,
0.0540433601,
0.0307396334,
0.0057926853,
-0.0177943762,
0.0113126561,
-0.0136587508,
0.0555606261,
0.0165058896,
0.0025123302,
-0.013744032,
-0.0699492618,
-0.031305708,
-0.0745769292,
-0.0081940908,
-0.0631453916,
-0.0196350422,
-0.0326547325,
0.0493374914,
0.0421067216,
-0.0173334014,
0.0104974695,
-0.0512569062,
0.0450337529,
-0.0242638849,
0.0625585914,
0.0502055511,
-0.0185931828,
0.0171734467,
-0.0277183931,
0.0278112013,
0.0034841355,
0.0460631847,
-0.0114084445,
0.0518736467,
0.0177207217,
0.0346938707,
0.0321762227,
-0.0072906334,
-0.0036180064,
-0.0573713519,
0.0283797625,
-0.0161269754,
-0.0372714996,
-0.0688426495,
0.0176244508,
-0.0628286079,
0.0271927044,
-0.0296252929,
0.0562885664,
0.0457609594,
0.0089490116,
-0.0077333194,
0.054069303,
-0.0512619838,
0.0369863659,
0.0366074219,
-0.0476186797,
-0.0038932718,
-0.0435457453,
-0.0203918014,
0.0502580255,
0.0254697222,
0.0579942018,
2.374150532e-34,
0.0214616079,
-0.002617555,
0.0232507363,
0.0713541955,
0.0526814871,
-0.0223979857,
-0.0221128743,
-0.0025608346,
0.0105804792,
-0.0752528086,
-0.0282535087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02449v1 | Surfing the modeling of PoS taggers in low-resource scenarios | 2024-02-04T11:38:12 | 2024-02-04T11:38:12 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Víctor M. Darriba Bilbao, Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Jorge Graña Gil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68, 68T50 | The recent trend towards the application of deep structured techniques has
revealed the limits of huge models in natural language processing. This has
reawakened the interest in traditional machine learning algorithms, which have
proved still to be competitive in certain contexts, in particular low-resource
settings. In parallel, model selection has become an essential task to boost
performance at reasonable cost, even more so when we talk about processes
involving domains where the training and/or computational resources are scarce.
Against this backdrop, we evaluate the early estimation of learning curves as a
practical mechanism for selecting the most appropriate model in scenarios
characterized by the use of non-deep learners in resource-lean settings. On the
basis of a formal approximation model previously evaluated under conditions of
wide availability of training and validation resources, we study the
reliability of such an approach in a different and much more demanding
operationalenvironment. Using as case study the generation of PoS taggers for
Galician, a language belonging to the Western Ibero-Romance group, the
experimental results are consistent with our expectations. | [
-0.0014314344,
0.0504673198,
0.0029314547,
0.020511372,
-0.0316017531,
0.0044341404,
0.0093881907,
0.0003239368,
-0.0096857427,
0.0006839231,
0.0261909682,
-0.0573288575,
0.003787393,
0.0237754937,
-0.0279851723,
-0.0501092002,
0.029076701,
-0.0662504807,
0.0206971094,
-0.0229037143,
-0.0221850965,
-0.0107242381,
-0.0221304875,
0.0487475768,
-0.0518373996,
0.0108918902,
-0.0022982853,
-0.0266254134,
-0.0438149236,
-0.0382063873,
0.0056944047,
0.0240933709,
-0.0188964922,
0.0720295608,
0.0000020342,
-0.0665118992,
-0.0674787834,
0.0139123136,
-0.0122127049,
-0.0151457973,
0.0139223272,
-0.0307653751,
-0.0417272188,
0.0030247024,
-0.0393919125,
-0.0331860706,
0.0651399866,
0.0001281702,
0.0222911928,
0.0285965651,
-0.0192667861,
-0.0424898751,
-0.005673253,
-0.0079355584,
-0.0265486911,
-0.0424667224,
0.0240588151,
0.0022591751,
0.0033835627,
-0.0074398029,
-0.0254594367,
0.0354302265,
-0.0081655392,
-0.028092334,
-0.0042173415,
0.0198573023,
-0.0172765218,
-0.0142198317,
-0.000541865,
0.0239706449,
-0.0487848744,
-0.0058521684,
0.0000251536,
-0.0257138051,
-0.0509802476,
-0.0476121455,
-0.013669814,
-0.0221703518,
-0.0037385114,
0.0385493003,
0.0482245907,
-0.0133481212,
0.0242267959,
0.0057970989,
-0.0209044479,
0.0746793002,
0.0001502821,
-0.0442332104,
0.0520244688,
0.0485813618,
-0.0527463444,
-0.0140732359,
-0.0022627504,
0.0177030936,
0.0021247936,
0.0159587599,
-0.0340826735,
-0.0101024006,
-0.0116721196,
-0.050696291,
0.043636363,
-0.007217261,
0.0089671845,
0.051167272,
-0.0543137453,
0.0050146659,
-0.0065027508,
-0.0385099314,
-0.0003112827,
-0.02612436,
-0.0779147521,
0.0129957208,
-0.0768690556,
0.0309607945,
-0.0067266137,
0.0009123638,
-0.0465082005,
-0.0314713232,
-0.0015106997,
-0.0192077402,
-0.0211268384,
-0.0167470425,
-0.0301299933,
0.0334459431,
-0.0497723669,
0.0259139184,
-0.0111289546,
-0.0102608809,
-0.0325615481,
-0.0770907179,
0.034694273,
0.021446798,
0.0098941242,
-0.0219579246,
0.0254954174,
0.0328208581,
-0.0057034073,
-0.012970712,
-0.0689204335,
-0.0313990898,
-0.064516753,
-0.0260092597,
-0.00834041,
-0.067509912,
0.0011693949,
0.0094987452,
0.0083982935,
-0.0501358509,
0.0024916527,
-0.0141491964,
-0.0125098443,
0.0447380729,
-0.0290701482,
0.0057086926,
-0.0010626919,
-0.0161625836,
-0.0316966474,
0.0405029207,
0.0529453792,
0.0094591649,
0.0654013157,
-0.0340414494,
-0.0142633356,
0.0771396607,
-0.0156672169,
-0.0114676226,
-0.0091214217,
-0.0477079824,
0.0219580922,
0.0160025191,
0.0520759039,
0.0698084459,
0.0165663026,
0.0367975757,
0.0331382677,
0.0421506874,
0.0739505365,
0.034153413,
0.0935943276,
-0.0151782613,
0.0046986495,
-0.0202985536,
0.0274598654,
-0.0582672544,
0.0008729291,
0.0109666781,
-0.0149083007,
0.0026014959,
-0.0172761809,
-0.0457432047,
-0.0187678896,
-0.0227401182,
-0.0370329805,
-0.0426750816,
0.1016112342,
-0.0290012099,
-0.0597197898,
0.0370581858,
0.0190588608,
0.0047062477,
0.0061343475,
-0.0471804254,
-0.0068765362,
0.0286658779,
0.0480879731,
-0.0278507713,
0.00291396,
-0.0135638528,
-0.0115627684,
0.0198050421,
0.0709603131,
-0.0098776715,
0.0041554747,
-0.0519318581,
-0.0245972462,
0.0748897269,
-0.0036084855,
-0.0025490762,
0.0006051962,
0.019989321,
-0.0040477794,
-0.0380236246,
-0.0815895572,
0.0524923988,
-0.0363242775,
-0.0787403435,
0.0298602637,
0.0094941724,
0.0153817022,
0.0523689725,
0.015873367,
-0.0007953397,
0.049711559,
-0.0505837612,
0.0387227498,
-0.0227854773,
-0.029424198,
0.0308443327,
0.0455835834,
0.0043108319,
0.0159876309,
-0.0138131585,
-0.0005580058,
-0.0573095344,
-0.0216821656,
-0.0480293036,
0.0570579693,
-0.0215316899,
0.0437504053,
-0.0237798933,
0.0067228526,
-0.0349333026,
0.0542777143,
-0.0036374226,
0.0657885373,
0.0034896354,
-0.0082895588,
0.0350494459,
-0.0450073592,
-0.0597000346,
0.0073830071,
-0.0197224785,
-0.0098281046,
0.0002047475,
0.0083298888,
-0.0012911612,
-0.0099485684,
-0.0742414445,
-0.0228301492,
-0.0098674996,
0.0393565856,
-0.027742533,
-0.0037000333,
-0.0007166797,
-0.03739921,
-0.0230615344,
-0.0030528207,
0.0284900591,
0.0361456387,
0.0391490832,
0.0390872099,
-0.0493828245,
-0.0372380167,
-0.0192144699,
-0.0032314844,
0.0306314174,
0.0266589038,
-0.0587055348,
-0.0461932756,
0.0031823551,
-0.0222906116,
0.0637694448,
0.0202633217,
-0.025406003,
0.0239060987,
0.0071001649,
0.0512155555,
0.0107745752,
-0.0281808376,
0.000454768,
0.0151466085,
0.0291121881,
-0.0433743112,
-0.0150414295,
-0.0348841213,
-0.0232187267,
-0.0398099609,
-0.0371584892,
0.0054785404,
0.1070319191,
-0.026756525,
0.020284785,
-0.0212400984,
-0.0276146103,
-0.0449161753,
-0.023024112,
-0.0029297224,
0.0334281176,
-0.0076218597,
0.0264606923,
-0.0156623274,
-0.0610979348,
0.0395562612,
-0.0244871173,
-0.004284115,
-0.0460659787,
-0.0501574799,
-0.0233759973,
0.0222611353,
0.0286693573,
0.0015327797,
0.009642926,
-0.0165649522,
-0.020507995,
0.0160035584,
0.0331974514,
-0.0210141782,
0.0214344747,
-0.0346412547,
0.0463028103,
0.0011964217,
-0.0162716322,
-0.0285748858,
-0.0202013906,
-0.0348370858,
0.0531926192,
0.0240312815,
-0.0066311383,
0.0420580022,
0.0370619334,
-0.0097569209,
0.0692119151,
0.0398225971,
-0.0020716416,
-0.0214053281,
0.0376030356,
-0.0007194391,
-0.0380031168,
0.0249616094,
-0.0572800562,
0.0147154974,
-0.0162953231,
0.0509323403,
-0.0179783218,
-0.0596875735,
-0.0122013483,
0.0243123602,
-0.0310458113,
-0.0701109916,
0.0252506677,
-0.0124670519,
-0.052835077,
-0.0293836463,
0.089093715,
0.0145364571,
-0.0327551551,
0.0206683706,
0.0187460389,
0.0789581984,
0.0089801084,
0.0371933356,
-0.0425118729,
-0.0026691083,
0.028212484,
0.0582792498,
-0.0177775268,
-0.0405732878,
0.0152520826,
-0.148351565,
0.030407181,
-0.0131807169,
-0.0078020715,
0.0388536453,
-0.0438463688,
-0.0212988425,
-0.0339649767,
-0.0670057163,
0.0002621744,
-0.0187744852,
-0.0016857361,
0.0687767789,
-0.0674932674,
-0.0368242189,
0.011243186,
-0.0699284896,
0.0011386657,
0.069173418,
-0.0019553043,
-0.0111328792,
-0.0453977697,
0.0675857663,
0.0407706127,
0.0280542914,
-0.0332609974,
0.0197598431,
0.0316601992,
-0.0111618545,
0.0183235724,
0.0030589306,
-0.0307973251,
0.0278208051,
-0.0199907068,
0.1045723632,
-0.0062421216,
-0.00575697,
0.01804718,
-0.0147145577,
0.0381459706,
0.0360048488,
0.0067131184,
-0.0642442703,
-0.0688728541,
-0.0106269615,
0.0406055264,
-0.0349389091,
-0.0111416606,
0.0444749407,
-0.052730944,
-0.0662125871,
-0.0617296025,
0.0095104184,
0.0485891439,
0.0834064186,
-0.0070387493,
0.0267170332,
-0.004729603,
-0.0023727727,
-0.0321156122,
0.0305200815,
-0.0144720105,
-0.0054740934,
-0.0992254838,
-0.0102685662,
0.0307563208,
0.0335157588,
-0.0370897092,
-0.0587527715,
-0.0554871969,
-0.0556076951,
0.0519545265,
0.0670027807,
0.0368882567,
0.0046107527,
-0.0100905215,
-0.0637535229,
0.0322279595,
0.0475072972,
-0.0252408236,
-0.0207157321,
0.0262112338,
-0.0018747102,
-0.0302723292,
0.0166993756,
-0.0036146594,
0.0320491381,
-0.0259825122,
0.0339392833,
-0.0111447824,
-0.0411562026,
0.005676358,
0.0239569452,
0.0745204017,
-0.0254295077,
-0.0765917376,
-0.0238033049,
-0.0035522324,
0.0537236407,
0.0081771007,
-0.0189002771,
-0.0003685092,
0.0058601885,
0.0509922579,
-0.0131219868,
0.0074174539,
0.004934438,
0.0432706438,
-0.0130385747,
0.0355236158,
0.0758802369,
0.0118735181,
0.019495111,
0.0150607275,
-0.002957416,
0.0377568752,
0.0016587573,
0.0370036028,
-0.0017840802,
0.007737861,
-0.0157510955,
0.0745381862,
0.0209026262,
-0.0332803801,
0.0035800152,
-0.0447981879,
-0.0551304966,
-0.010089593,
0.0616446212,
-0.0229449291,
0.025785787,
-0.0286807623,
-0.0006842389,
-0.0264948327,
0.0079317437,
0.0079029063,
-0.0179298446,
0.0020516256,
0.0205855127,
-0.0263120886,
0.0313994028,
0.0675225928,
0.0405017436,
0.043960616,
0.0006663192,
-0.000923574,
-0.0373735987,
0.0132393241,
0.034865655,
-0.0056341202,
-0.0437138639,
0.0009551701,
-0.0518641882,
-0.0512868091,
0.0197607893,
-0.0131245945,
-0.0049207499,
-0.0142166894,
0.0452601686,
0.0561825037,
-0.0114095341,
0.0333160758,
-0.0523926131,
-0.0077165705,
-0.0033235364,
0.0023137792,
-0.0199406203,
-5.838748031e-33,
0.0200849343,
-0.035427995,
-0.0005159764,
0.0022569078,
-0.002130264,
0.021454921,
0.0040240362,
0.0199113544,
-0.0066826851,
0.0018964687,
-0.0206953082,
-0.0440251157,
0.0387197882,
0.0322928317,
0.0198347047,
0.0341777503,
0.0629243702,
-0.0366063416,
0.0286820941,
-0.0248739924,
0.0417082086,
0.043341022,
0.0354154371,
-0.0584335774,
0.0434339494,
0.0117409118,
-0.009085861,
0.0279386602,
0.0513415784,
0.0757118165,
-0.0219837185,
0.0215006676,
0.012729669,
-0.0007408037,
0.0000749069,
0.0078631453,
-0.0612180792,
0.0031334241,
-0.0256161336,
0.0344581828,
-0.0054320819,
-0.0007720992,
0.0337365866,
-0.0015638926,
-0.01511792,
0.0470394455,
0.0259557497,
-0.0264364108,
-0.0354705937,
-0.0217778385,
-0.0360600986,
0.0486874655,
0.0510079451,
0.023830533,
0.0568810292,
0.0487874113,
-0.0208621323,
-0.0182543471,
-0.0806222111,
0.0138775473,
0.0391309671,
0.0582785048,
0.0593678541,
0.0362322032,
0.0037913413,
0.0532747954,
0.0412186123,
-0.0226082653,
0.0261454601,
0.0064665261,
0.0742014423,
0.0417109095,
0.0545478873,
-0.0046587316,
0.085565798,
0.0216712318,
-0.0650227964,
-0.0135531891,
0.0191273671,
0.0032353925,
0.0052156406,
0.0218030121,
-0.0936066434,
-0.0038599658,
-0.0096818479,
-0.0477300696,
-0.0062251375,
-0.0418524332,
0.0194579661,
0.0053596767,
-0.0618059374,
0.0283211898,
0.0480771661,
-0.0394592881,
-0.0075268587,
-0.060881719,
0.0090738665,
0.0692094788,
-0.02098931,
0.0361346975,
-0.0754971281,
-0.11632099,
-0.0279642083,
0.0088481698,
0.0482490472,
-0.0034054853,
0.0172030088,
-0.0069126938,
-0.0852678642,
0.0124373827,
-0.0128300991,
0.036073193,
0.008561614,
0.0762814805,
0.056545604,
-0.048148904,
0.0021195551,
0.0575420447,
0.0278910697,
0.0147243105,
0.0344492383,
-0.0126475813,
0.0097502377,
0.0140561694,
-0.0101719359,
0.0084633883,
-0.0079519236,
0.035913635,
0.0003100759,
-0.0134399813,
-0.0120223835,
0.0150830979,
2.727e-7,
0.0396812484,
0.0296332464,
0.0312988833,
-0.0096199019,
0.0047068973,
0.0238334332,
0.0236504376,
-0.012376301,
-0.072798118,
-0.0230488311,
-0.0048183925,
-0.0208704565,
0.0521243438,
0.0450259745,
-0.0792536139,
-0.0338519253,
-0.0035354164,
0.0443658903,
-0.038167879,
-0.0077102217,
0.0377183221,
0.0812158883,
-0.0183763485,
-0.0339515544,
-0.0156973973,
-0.0779381469,
0.0430728234,
0.038599629,
0.0088024652,
0.0253300685,
0.0629570857,
0.0393842161,
-0.0032913121,
0.0163193196,
-0.0279181562,
0.0139063718,
0.0200257823,
0.0359097123,
-0.0000237801,
0.0120017277,
0.0577103719,
-0.0194555819,
-0.0206413027,
-0.0278876126,
0.0551891364,
-0.0285689775,
-0.002304509,
-0.008063281,
0.0084980931,
-0.0080651948,
0.0025081155,
-0.0507351346,
-0.0412881821,
-0.0064548822,
0.0396996476,
-0.0483964607,
-0.0433543436,
-0.0021176853,
0.0007908444,
0.0178066287,
-0.0055993795,
-0.0384775959,
-0.0485574491,
0.0360384658,
0.0226638503,
-0.0231761262,
0.0251618661,
2.784095692e-34,
0.0365274623,
-0.0290030409,
0.0050190701,
0.0272586737,
-0.0104576536,
-0.0108936448,
0.0329792388,
0.0027104006,
0.0131289139,
-0.0338887088,
-0.0177670848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02447v1 | Breaking MLPerf Training: A Case Study on Optimizing BERT | 2024-02-04T11:12:17 | 2024-02-04T11:12:17 | Yongdeok Kim, Jaehyung Ahn, Myeongwoo Kim, Changin Choi, Heejae Kim, Narankhuu Tuvshinjargal, Seungwon Lee, Yanzi Zhang, Yuan Pei, Xiongzhan Linghu, Jingkun Ma, Lin Chen, Yuehua Dai, Sungjoo Yoo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Speeding up the large-scale distributed training is challenging in that it
requires improving various components of training including load balancing,
communication, optimizers, etc. We present novel approaches for fast
large-scale training of BERT model which individually ameliorates each
component thereby leading to a new level of BERT training performance. Load
balancing is imperative in distributed BERT training since its training
datasets are characterized by samples with various lengths. Communication cost,
which is proportional to the scale of distributed training, needs to be hidden
by useful computation. In addition, the optimizers, e.g., ADAM, LAMB, etc.,
need to be carefully re-evaluated in the context of large-scale distributed
training. We propose two new ideas, (1) local presorting based on dataset
stratification for load balancing and (2) bucket-wise gradient clipping before
allreduce which allows us to benefit from the overlap of gradient computation
and synchronization as well as the fast training of gradient clipping before
allreduce. We also re-evaluate existing optimizers via hyperparameter
optimization and utilize ADAM, which also contributes to fast training via
larger batches than existing methods. Our proposed methods, all combined, give
the fastest MLPerf BERT training of 25.1 (22.3) seconds on 1,024 NVIDIA A100
GPUs, which is 1.33x (1.13x) and 1.57x faster than the other top two (one)
submissions to MLPerf v1.1 (v2.0). Our implementation and evaluation results
are available at MLPerf v1.1~v2.1. | [
0.0207624361,
0.0429314673,
0.0186895113,
0.0670942739,
0.0161809493,
0.0183620285,
0.0369019285,
0.0232377853,
-0.0156008564,
-0.0281169172,
-0.0428696051,
-0.0332281999,
-0.0204135049,
-0.0342521109,
0.0461235158,
-0.0680687577,
0.0046335384,
0.0069419448,
-0.0044053807,
-0.0278542954,
0.0226891581,
-0.000498072,
-0.0169161502,
0.0120780366,
-0.0218784902,
-0.0164098106,
-0.0241905041,
0.0453694537,
0.048191987,
-0.0098966463,
0.0182443727,
0.0389144681,
0.056171108,
0.0458318666,
0.0000020383,
-0.0059639495,
-0.0294672903,
0.0205955058,
-0.004877666,
0.0286302287,
-0.0463433154,
0.0081592631,
-0.0372297801,
0.0288227648,
0.0058114445,
0.0196408648,
0.038683977,
0.015869515,
0.06713368,
0.0707606748,
-0.0036015494,
-0.0316350944,
0.0171949547,
-0.0224662255,
-0.0407214239,
-0.0291444212,
0.0191281233,
-0.02039304,
-0.015932152,
-0.0731373429,
-0.0276233181,
0.0117769027,
0.0304939598,
0.0396008268,
0.0147240879,
0.0362006761,
-0.1098975912,
-0.0320622362,
-0.0432021245,
0.0849708021,
-0.0546237677,
-0.00397398,
0.0238781087,
0.0105590625,
-0.015393652,
-0.0255940799,
-0.0087495428,
0.0197148491,
-0.0079316301,
0.0291909315,
-0.0415005572,
-0.0472444966,
0.0414829813,
-0.0184041001,
-0.0432404205,
0.0332782865,
0.0225825235,
-0.0277976096,
-0.0259467755,
0.0085064666,
-0.0462152362,
-0.022645684,
0.0512063242,
0.0184279438,
-0.031392578,
-0.0060372395,
-0.0404259115,
-0.0742481425,
-0.0108101778,
-0.0353233777,
0.0631908923,
0.0159956254,
0.0058105309,
0.0358126499,
-0.0397454686,
0.020035794,
-0.0046340968,
-0.0004190135,
0.0000174655,
0.0112884166,
-0.0252492428,
-0.004052361,
-0.0671064332,
0.0324905068,
-0.0346151069,
-0.0291703567,
-0.0250710752,
0.0008054728,
-0.0150202326,
-0.0220470931,
0.0457221195,
0.0188358296,
-0.0207234938,
0.0185615271,
0.0249150041,
0.0469180048,
-0.0760425329,
-0.0152697582,
-0.0253013205,
-0.0479147471,
0.0029339695,
-0.0032848914,
0.0036072584,
-0.0053947717,
0.0411436185,
0.0350783505,
-0.0035412232,
-0.0130507527,
-0.0601872541,
0.0276008602,
0.0197783243,
-0.0266466271,
-0.0170747135,
-0.0434623957,
0.0521410294,
-0.0028655045,
0.0301750582,
0.0476474948,
0.0187380407,
-0.0082307039,
0.0109525127,
0.0459454171,
-0.0303382799,
-0.0029509822,
0.054938022,
-0.0036837847,
-0.0141371489,
0.0846543238,
0.0580819659,
0.023825936,
0.0103151584,
-0.0148078296,
-0.0214477926,
0.044680994,
0.0449451655,
0.0193368215,
-0.0372852087,
-0.0214766506,
-0.0128189037,
0.0383766629,
0.0438224562,
0.0545291826,
-0.0656956509,
-0.0429951809,
0.0566406362,
0.0346969999,
0.0139614409,
0.0493982546,
0.0082073696,
0.0076013813,
0.0285657514,
-0.0111549981,
0.0045135962,
-0.0178774633,
0.0214083027,
-0.0008120458,
0.0385540016,
0.0535204299,
-0.0448431,
0.0313208438,
0.0049680835,
-0.0118173128,
-0.0518358015,
0.0177630764,
0.0190861877,
-0.0090015475,
-0.0454030596,
0.0958020538,
0.0358882397,
-0.048337575,
-0.01856382,
-0.0221473947,
-0.0368337631,
0.0609094873,
0.0409817696,
-0.0445493944,
-0.0685644001,
0.006270125,
-0.0040622815,
0.0302088279,
0.0031556846,
-0.004067434,
0.0378529914,
-0.0806745961,
-0.0010985456,
0.0078239897,
-0.031102946,
0.0588588901,
0.0307163522,
0.0071115796,
-0.0358811989,
-0.0140331872,
-0.0242397934,
0.0327301174,
-0.0148998639,
-0.0241627749,
-0.0064051943,
0.0379607715,
0.0432226099,
0.000720793,
-0.0509624816,
-0.0289236512,
0.0591533184,
-0.0399905667,
-0.0010953767,
-0.0123443063,
-0.0223089382,
-0.0690235198,
0.0385977104,
-0.0146507313,
-0.0198279992,
0.0522935949,
-0.0471315831,
-0.0280416626,
-0.0043162084,
-0.029759137,
0.0716078579,
-0.0178589635,
0.0376887284,
0.0107259694,
-0.0233236402,
-0.0098378472,
0.0409763567,
-0.0101676546,
0.0240029432,
0.0005588057,
0.0088283913,
0.0307595357,
-0.0642336011,
0.0091426652,
0.0140776262,
-0.0111782718,
-0.0112812836,
-0.0227732882,
-0.0000883788,
-0.0442731008,
-0.0211632308,
-0.1120659411,
0.0034096735,
-0.0291176699,
0.044728443,
0.0172189884,
0.0157337915,
-0.0162052251,
-0.0479052998,
-0.0069183432,
-0.0131659666,
-0.0590345971,
0.0224867817,
0.0162335373,
0.0122894319,
-0.0409441255,
0.0134649267,
-0.024552023,
0.0013183294,
0.0594873726,
-0.0184348803,
-0.0409037247,
-0.0258505102,
-0.0443480872,
-0.0428456962,
0.0530021973,
0.0075819511,
-0.0185059402,
0.0167092737,
0.0100444723,
0.0437872969,
0.0672918707,
0.0375173651,
0.0481087714,
-0.0332144052,
0.0268988181,
-0.0734703764,
0.057624761,
0.0028786552,
0.013864466,
-0.0291732792,
0.0245843455,
-0.0151109705,
0.0565693527,
-0.0437336229,
0.0204462931,
-0.0443891287,
-0.0544170626,
-0.0092615029,
-0.0742724091,
-0.061574012,
-0.0094230231,
-0.0432744287,
-0.0587750487,
-0.0174512509,
-0.0541528314,
0.0457701199,
-0.0396590605,
-0.0048259418,
-0.0559765287,
-0.0365876481,
-0.0191123523,
0.0223151203,
0.0009612262,
0.0660755783,
-0.0949840397,
-0.0655149668,
-0.0105546955,
0.0029415924,
0.0129260002,
-0.0103519233,
-0.0345509872,
0.0016321971,
0.0070508672,
-0.0421119705,
-0.0906934217,
-0.0140851783,
-0.0221175943,
-0.0147254877,
0.0070300517,
0.0322177783,
-0.0828720108,
-0.0526404493,
0.0442265607,
0.016827045,
0.0625809953,
-0.0227324869,
0.0027937819,
-0.0071162931,
0.0517867617,
0.009114312,
-0.028324496,
-0.0065863775,
-0.0529255234,
-0.0320192687,
0.0547163337,
0.1141335294,
-0.0085474383,
-0.0517045856,
-0.0056440821,
0.0087927738,
-0.0659108683,
-0.0155883962,
-0.02162713,
0.0156346411,
-0.0348696038,
0.020256009,
0.078493394,
0.0398147441,
-0.0576175377,
-0.0021256912,
0.0069087208,
0.0607876889,
-0.0144732483,
0.0245758984,
-0.0804830417,
-0.0300088711,
0.0148161873,
0.027373217,
0.0384354591,
-0.0155059602,
0.0012211342,
-0.0832665637,
0.0110873086,
0.0007989539,
-0.0385374948,
-0.0200813953,
-0.0503697544,
-0.0301510133,
0.0122927548,
0.0087081576,
-0.007952719,
-0.0007994995,
0.0058217095,
0.0730745718,
-0.0047751199,
0.0002894077,
-0.030995572,
-0.0598099865,
0.0106703173,
0.0493197106,
0.0372802503,
0.0011118635,
-0.0413826406,
0.020024728,
0.0418296643,
-0.000310248,
-0.0147850271,
0.0481389239,
-0.0731999129,
-0.0293880347,
-0.0061887731,
-0.0215340257,
-0.0156566259,
-0.0011629951,
0.0032381364,
0.0565529466,
0.0144922389,
0.0129823731,
0.0152323861,
-0.0080182217,
0.0106462725,
0.0513921194,
0.0205772575,
-0.0350356176,
-0.0087068742,
0.0031207805,
0.0049420488,
-0.0249440763,
0.0503162071,
-0.0187041964,
-0.0339900963,
-0.0371563546,
-0.0547887012,
-0.0029808695,
0.0378121883,
0.0835181177,
0.0123173418,
-0.0126230912,
0.0108716507,
0.0370047316,
-0.0573321581,
0.0402127504,
-0.0103802914,
0.0137649206,
-0.0795568749,
-0.0438183472,
0.037442591,
0.0287142657,
-0.0258551817,
0.0273617879,
-0.0359229557,
-0.0607256554,
0.0056374888,
0.0324812941,
0.0149070565,
0.0343060531,
0.0051545831,
-0.0375573225,
0.0430735275,
0.0936291292,
-0.0073581454,
0.0226551667,
0.0171850584,
-0.0481384955,
0.0080090687,
0.0360324681,
-0.0474820323,
0.0043058866,
-0.0152356206,
0.0556288511,
-0.0159496553,
-0.0022236437,
-0.0327948779,
0.0497382469,
0.0034925556,
-0.0347509533,
-0.0334918462,
-0.0324368477,
0.0590405352,
0.0311076939,
0.0083462773,
-0.052463457,
0.0410661064,
0.0324691422,
0.03065194,
-0.0191695802,
0.0478460975,
0.0772764906,
-0.0495276898,
-0.0310384408,
0.0253315773,
-0.0176006332,
-0.0235880967,
0.0247205365,
0.0107356068,
0.0150880041,
-0.0290021263,
0.0255881641,
0.0203292388,
-0.0137624955,
0.0132128131,
0.0418748558,
0.0004571479,
-0.043371208,
0.0566021539,
-0.0449180342,
-0.0560283177,
-0.0452385806,
0.0566731468,
0.0858185217,
0.0277594607,
0.0593686141,
0.0011006598,
-0.0264404453,
0.0118804742,
-0.0326484405,
-0.0175444037,
-0.0024302078,
0.0099773249,
0.0277668145,
-0.0038653777,
0.0261143092,
0.0605395064,
-0.0237145908,
0.0572142862,
0.0033366994,
-0.0046471362,
-0.0466115475,
-0.0096494015,
0.0520145185,
-0.0062301476,
-0.0239849817,
-0.0315243267,
0.0348552912,
-0.0444225334,
0.0038793387,
-0.0029694911,
-0.0046180114,
-0.0015445417,
0.0687667504,
0.0215267818,
-0.0066834926,
-0.0135730673,
-0.0223098677,
0.031482812,
-0.0026386851,
-0.0030618615,
0.0147030428,
-6.338918674e-33,
-0.0121706612,
0.0210805759,
0.0170180406,
-0.0122056315,
-0.0331268683,
0.0497117899,
0.0020120319,
-0.0448026173,
0.0031316669,
-0.0010998633,
-0.0250959173,
0.0318042338,
0.0354632735,
0.0157562625,
-0.0408939421,
-0.0237173885,
0.0383509099,
-0.0245778188,
-0.0252742376,
0.0065753059,
0.0098558227,
0.1037424952,
0.0469999909,
-0.012818316,
-0.0541766658,
-0.0029804551,
0.0027108556,
0.0207498409,
0.0171511546,
0.0205666497,
-0.0213014539,
-0.0000832819,
-0.0104605295,
-0.0400495641,
0.0046909582,
0.0025747644,
-0.0662379786,
0.0067016087,
-0.0148471193,
0.0462391712,
-0.0609336942,
0.0320470259,
0.0211874358,
0.0311157759,
0.0277680028,
0.0282564666,
0.0105041517,
0.0146219358,
-0.0366153978,
-0.0670214146,
-0.006679629,
0.0366633162,
-0.0009749383,
-0.0181416608,
0.0427488387,
-0.0034165166,
0.0145351682,
0.0087587694,
-0.0520589091,
-0.0013301676,
0.0506707206,
0.0167760588,
0.0497734733,
0.0688456893,
0.0453011543,
0.0762543529,
0.070705004,
-0.0202850886,
0.0211881027,
-0.0182653349,
0.0079392809,
0.037191689,
0.0097633246,
-0.0207856819,
0.0354486331,
0.0200729463,
-0.075283803,
-0.0106299715,
0.0683142915,
-0.0294566415,
0.0089031979,
0.037294127,
-0.02764838,
0.0128916064,
0.0139075136,
-0.0250777192,
-0.0064235125,
0.0043796245,
0.0155323213,
0.0273917783,
-0.0296656433,
0.0556462705,
0.0067499708,
-0.0325146317,
-0.0090500293,
-0.0036749449,
0.0331827402,
0.0067806803,
0.0179477483,
0.0310757272,
-0.070943661,
-0.0299209971,
-0.0195512138,
0.0078816582,
0.0160214473,
-0.0029129367,
0.062243741,
0.0232208576,
-0.0515058599,
-0.0031230811,
-0.0217905343,
0.0113652777,
-0.0103311958,
0.0827649683,
0.0473269597,
-0.0387865975,
0.0274206158,
0.0263214577,
0.0121623324,
0.0306434054,
0.0065449099,
0.0243105423,
-0.0175030045,
0.0116487117,
0.0048406674,
0.0037530586,
-0.0495298132,
0.0276268888,
0.0172737595,
-0.0856125727,
-0.0215032436,
-0.0229968354,
2.813e-7,
0.0176159535,
0.0208995771,
0.0260498449,
-0.039742887,
0.0027476957,
-0.0084938966,
-0.0191815849,
0.0405641384,
0.0167875253,
0.0562759005,
0.0185502581,
0.0365819819,
0.026830174,
-0.0097848652,
-0.1097194031,
-0.0329034701,
-0.0908097848,
0.0236000698,
-0.0288316663,
-0.0268080328,
-0.0535588115,
0.0897986218,
0.009977174,
-0.0344113223,
0.0747122392,
-0.0279718079,
0.0219140407,
-0.0246767905,
0.0031318811,
0.0189208519,
0.0252336208,
0.0107477019,
-0.0138659906,
0.0111102266,
-0.0117874919,
0.0040600831,
0.0111887008,
0.0556291603,
-0.0434339829,
-0.0160539001,
0.0401256569,
-0.0049388073,
-0.0072342535,
-0.0165468697,
0.0140491026,
0.0180736668,
-0.0203750953,
0.0174474772,
-0.0167295001,
-0.0364794396,
0.0414978787,
-0.0523178056,
-0.0087135313,
0.0171172898,
0.0185510479,
-0.0623181872,
-0.0249829646,
-0.0780397803,
-0.0113811838,
-0.0176517945,
-0.0328758843,
-0.0707550272,
-0.0618939288,
-0.0155498581,
0.0165032353,
-0.0749477968,
-0.0069431094,
2.393414864e-34,
0.0336718224,
-0.0145882778,
0.0137463156,
0.0573507026,
0.0245616082,
-0.0342615657,
0.0020261379,
-0.0320125781,
-0.0363866314,
-0.0455599912,
-0.041258499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02446v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02446v3 | LQER: Low-Rank Quantization Error Reconstruction for LLMs | 2024-02-04T10:59:52 | 2024-05-30T09:49:47 | Cheng Zhang, Jianyi Cheng, George A. Constantinides, Yiren Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Post-training quantization of Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging. In
this work, we introduce Low-rank Quantization Error Reduction (LQER), which
combines quantization and low-rank approximation to recover the model
capability. LQER leverages an activation-induced scale matrix to drive the
singular value distribution of quantization error towards a desirable
distribution, which enables nearly-lossless W4A8 quantization on various LLMs
and downstream tasks without the need for knowledge distillation, grid search,
or gradient-base iterative optimization. Unlike existing methods, the
computation pattern of LQER eliminates the need for specialized Scatter and
Gather processes to collect high-precision weights from irregular memory
locations. Our W4A8 LLMs achieve near-lossless performance on six popular
downstream tasks, while using 1.36$\times$ fewer hardware resources than the
leading state-of-the-art method. We open-source our framework at
https://github.com/ChengZhang-98/lqer | [
-0.0595781542,
0.0968836397,
0.0168212131,
0.077880457,
0.0408876687,
0.0191991199,
-0.0087733343,
0.0240040645,
0.0273287445,
-0.0152169755,
-0.0404733904,
-0.0608613603,
-0.0013650964,
-0.0236628018,
0.0461593643,
0.0129042314,
0.0411866754,
-0.0301520359,
-0.0061530601,
-0.0416308418,
-0.0149211697,
-0.0049801921,
0.0072413948,
0.0109919943,
0.009757515,
-0.0284885596,
-0.0064258482,
0.0229371376,
0.0041952073,
-0.02476486,
0.0239038877,
0.0371058397,
0.0611235946,
0.0300137699,
0.0000022137,
-0.0103748124,
-0.0239466503,
-0.0236267634,
-0.0227388907,
0.0364158973,
-0.0175277758,
-0.0040209289,
-0.0411974192,
0.0114788339,
0.0097349938,
0.0048466194,
0.0499850623,
0.0086883884,
0.056464918,
0.0325936712,
0.0065628565,
-0.0177757628,
0.0316092372,
-0.0272021405,
-0.0174617581,
-0.0349505208,
0.0101972241,
0.0240211282,
-0.0668769404,
0.008515263,
-0.0242927745,
0.0395030901,
-0.0109958276,
0.012616301,
-0.0358852744,
0.0009731987,
-0.0337726586,
0.012782733,
-0.0112169888,
0.0575641766,
-0.0666790754,
-0.0313239917,
-0.011045862,
0.0235625878,
-0.0103348996,
-0.1143815145,
-0.0408802107,
0.0590527505,
0.0446965694,
0.0499692336,
-0.037450254,
-0.037356317,
0.0531615242,
0.0150042726,
-0.037861634,
0.0446569137,
0.0212279018,
-0.0073356633,
-0.0276336279,
0.0013546663,
-0.0737156197,
-0.0143260565,
-0.0020349971,
-0.0078266617,
-0.0238034669,
-0.0057664984,
-0.0458286554,
-0.0331535973,
-0.0236641727,
0.0090111876,
0.0461416543,
0.0474335253,
-0.0078110783,
0.0258682724,
-0.0082869725,
0.0705242977,
-0.0129191373,
0.0374197513,
-0.0359813124,
0.0240469445,
0.012973587,
0.0053501897,
-0.0225564055,
0.0436719656,
-0.0526994169,
-0.0004838676,
-0.0333428606,
-0.0282024667,
-0.0188655164,
0.0019103832,
0.0089406576,
0.0320780799,
-0.0344564468,
-0.0149497092,
0.0260359254,
0.0375471115,
0.0290990826,
0.01832477,
-0.0005571046,
-0.0218909755,
-0.0339841954,
0.0160122402,
0.0143101765,
-0.02505688,
0.0407919809,
-0.0103254514,
-0.0254299846,
-0.0512221009,
-0.0365404002,
0.0218813326,
-0.0190897938,
-0.0610414855,
-0.0170006156,
-0.0647710785,
0.0174160134,
-0.0220756847,
0.0232998319,
-0.0565904081,
0.0256318972,
-0.0069558234,
-0.0224876963,
0.067084834,
-0.0366669707,
-0.0049458505,
0.0174299609,
0.0278433487,
0.0573666431,
0.046098996,
0.020614963,
0.0439190902,
-0.001568581,
0.0125346119,
-0.0229894537,
0.0491908714,
0.0441886075,
-0.004168049,
-0.0566778705,
-0.0333126523,
-0.0392389968,
0.0396390855,
0.1110339016,
0.1024942398,
-0.0731041059,
-0.0054516187,
0.0411550924,
0.0902722627,
0.0347641259,
0.0219379142,
-0.0179304127,
0.001585994,
0.0096533895,
-0.0339319929,
-0.0276980847,
0.0063149757,
0.015952386,
-0.0140215456,
0.062113069,
0.0459471419,
-0.0425139181,
-0.0254266169,
-0.007391178,
-0.021775838,
-0.0109372521,
0.0050749443,
0.0417577773,
0.0086839171,
-0.0049145613,
0.1074007824,
0.0274595227,
-0.0769144893,
0.0036290828,
-0.0761056021,
0.0165893026,
0.0411881208,
0.0304158907,
-0.0210645739,
0.023766825,
0.0001481518,
-0.0104660122,
-0.0196598712,
-0.0372871272,
0.0030860209,
0.0319865681,
-0.0496935397,
-0.0321122408,
-0.0108012846,
0.015561929,
-0.0137187513,
0.0241022445,
-0.0076074856,
-0.0054790103,
-0.061233826,
-0.0172168259,
0.0122293001,
0.0202740543,
-0.0596477538,
0.0400035903,
-0.0212676767,
0.0179237165,
0.0300865304,
-0.0237636883,
0.0004683117,
0.0421183705,
-0.0424083136,
0.0252699256,
-0.0757181272,
0.0034804121,
-0.0456063747,
0.0696768984,
0.0240204223,
0.0443494469,
0.1138800085,
-0.0415312238,
-0.0647945777,
0.0300871152,
0.0048171491,
0.0076737031,
-0.067566447,
0.0070459764,
-0.0081574768,
0.0657071024,
-0.0196545236,
0.0322050862,
-0.0398180299,
-0.0002379294,
0.029689407,
0.0170242582,
-0.0389425904,
-0.0436521098,
-0.0740629956,
0.0038177613,
-0.0037339467,
0.0893116891,
0.0011513124,
-0.0029780813,
0.0070909071,
0.0097173937,
-0.1129073501,
0.018415546,
-0.0520430319,
0.0166666638,
0.0331291817,
0.0379024409,
0.0217976496,
-0.0315765515,
-0.0088679474,
0.0064152852,
0.0108558936,
-0.0154835852,
-0.0118396971,
-0.013036673,
0.0102931987,
-0.0460579917,
-0.0397292264,
0.0230083615,
0.0272466745,
-0.0796161219,
-0.003548434,
-0.10142456,
0.0402731746,
-0.024392534,
0.0468267128,
-0.0217536632,
-0.0311343335,
0.0033131391,
-0.0344681777,
0.0031381862,
0.0270831324,
-0.0032986556,
0.0322535522,
0.0770877227,
0.0163697358,
-0.0542971455,
0.014217237,
0.000277615,
-0.0511609055,
-0.0156719126,
-0.0082169808,
-0.0070111421,
0.060100086,
-0.0021064267,
-0.0035528124,
-0.0081311939,
-0.0014439493,
0.0227279719,
-0.0038294862,
-0.0767484307,
0.0248818491,
-0.0388560593,
0.0468645617,
-0.000043901,
-0.0361699499,
-0.0105367359,
-0.0490791723,
-0.0062964433,
0.0071133939,
-0.01448703,
0.0039508366,
0.0437942222,
0.0181684438,
0.0277044494,
-0.048517704,
-0.0225346033,
-0.0396618284,
-0.0203404948,
-0.0464613102,
-0.0504938327,
0.040832527,
-0.0335622467,
0.0295544546,
-0.038098719,
-0.029171614,
0.01395409,
0.0127825681,
0.002833717,
0.0160819534,
0.0471299849,
-0.0416540951,
0.0533472113,
0.0322243236,
0.0262304712,
0.0595789626,
-0.0049958802,
-0.0031212438,
-0.0282616206,
0.0881048962,
0.0293552596,
0.0169927329,
0.0524153896,
-0.0056840507,
0.0121013112,
0.0472767018,
0.0689656511,
0.0330351777,
-0.0542705581,
0.0039124098,
0.0562658943,
0.0509541519,
-0.0146641871,
0.0090822354,
0.0452008322,
-0.0478871725,
-0.0184381474,
0.064700976,
0.0071393484,
-0.0671268106,
0.0077851815,
0.000010877,
0.0273285154,
0.0180825908,
0.0254851468,
-0.0885353982,
0.0012314171,
0.0238822587,
0.0367148891,
0.0702470466,
-0.0113923168,
-0.0019157212,
-0.0597102568,
0.0430946685,
0.0442731604,
0.0063592531,
-0.0316985101,
-0.0079813851,
-0.0099703409,
-0.0209932812,
0.0874815807,
0.059726391,
-0.0057251267,
-0.0096167754,
0.0231200084,
-0.0125622349,
-0.0635422021,
0.0221284404,
0.0047563422,
0.0772666931,
0.0422445759,
0.0228024852,
-0.0078961384,
-0.0041912785,
0.0070921755,
-0.0110136056,
-0.025489727,
-0.0001080126,
0.0165133029,
0.0223673191,
-0.0213796366,
0.0268541742,
0.0312282164,
-0.0151855676,
-0.0251666829,
-0.0259066075,
0.050583411,
-0.0243921522,
-0.0135974232,
0.0408264734,
-0.0566010363,
-0.0119988751,
0.0284708887,
0.0206890944,
0.0103984671,
-0.0475868993,
-0.0162756201,
0.0393204726,
-0.0348209888,
-0.068315424,
-0.0187482554,
-0.0074851923,
-0.0073519871,
-0.0453798957,
0.0032898588,
0.0169810578,
0.0059960769,
-0.0596883893,
-0.020946756,
-0.0140826618,
-0.0195275005,
-0.0779104382,
0.003540959,
-0.0532482751,
0.0233857445,
-0.0196176339,
0.0090967789,
-0.0093010338,
-0.0254254695,
-0.0130063482,
-0.0252775718,
-0.1174919084,
-0.0491340496,
-0.0006120852,
0.0266159717,
0.0082717454,
0.0448076539,
0.0188958887,
-0.0534853265,
0.0691338703,
0.0394555144,
-0.0056217317,
0.0517888255,
0.0191624407,
-0.0028679818,
-0.0183953904,
0.0460055359,
-0.0342295654,
0.0168310627,
0.0161613692,
0.0852682516,
-0.0472925231,
-0.0345883109,
-0.0067927809,
0.0011922769,
0.0650757626,
0.00327836,
-0.0116276611,
-0.0094994204,
0.0080085816,
0.0019373542,
-0.0010149627,
-0.051524505,
-0.0040006819,
0.0148049863,
-0.0297651216,
-0.0172428805,
-0.0071269493,
0.0433875471,
-0.0078536002,
0.0082657849,
-0.0224019568,
-0.0416940935,
0.0000726207,
0.051670216,
-0.0045493441,
-0.0223322157,
0.0160930455,
0.0190307349,
0.0385667048,
-0.0165860914,
-0.0177144147,
-0.0214317534,
-0.003711391,
-0.0417063423,
0.0240193252,
-0.0267889984,
-0.0845375881,
-0.0551989153,
-0.0107596796,
0.0702321306,
0.0339656919,
0.0786682144,
0.0336404778,
-0.0197425373,
-0.0238346923,
-0.0090389084,
0.0144246975,
0.0078178542,
0.0393982045,
0.0187019147,
-0.0169536881,
0.0175505243,
0.0741761848,
0.0182342175,
0.0238203462,
-0.0142548336,
-0.0111305863,
-0.0309989657,
-0.0628626198,
-0.031427674,
0.007593831,
-0.0281456541,
-0.0521104448,
0.0296044145,
-0.058421392,
0.0075124926,
0.0317475758,
-0.0390484855,
-0.0257273559,
-0.0042534815,
0.0402205288,
0.0085618161,
0.0067722835,
-0.0311668944,
-0.0543273166,
0.0075502982,
-0.0230698697,
0.0025735528,
-6.775387808e-33,
-0.0311766732,
0.0153202591,
0.0131009156,
-0.0292277876,
-0.0180475023,
0.0185235981,
-0.0218935069,
0.0127837332,
0.0110943587,
-0.0053828661,
-0.0242617801,
0.0450564511,
0.0162537955,
0.0293917898,
-0.0021679671,
0.0508350879,
0.0710690171,
-0.0384717248,
-0.0169135444,
0.0382761918,
0.0277563762,
0.0478413552,
0.0497034751,
0.0304520968,
-0.0285912175,
0.0054752259,
-0.007160909,
0.0111378506,
0.0360551961,
-0.0074059837,
-0.0612166226,
0.0310597122,
0.0105143962,
0.0099550197,
-0.0390596762,
-0.006941753,
-0.0724657252,
0.020183064,
-0.0048273792,
0.0011922236,
-0.0289492197,
-0.0006094421,
0.0263116714,
0.0083870776,
-0.0215569958,
-0.0542037338,
-0.0242507197,
-0.0260921922,
-0.0055851187,
-0.0788898692,
0.0100071635,
0.0090611065,
0.007958821,
0.0116152652,
0.0653170124,
-0.028283529,
-0.0201845765,
0.0004391749,
-0.1101968363,
-0.0171283744,
-0.0179821104,
0.0819344521,
0.0579913892,
0.0343835354,
-0.0088995351,
0.0466281585,
0.044414252,
-0.0452062935,
-0.0138860345,
0.0310360473,
0.0538672172,
0.0352819189,
0.0210316293,
0.0345575176,
0.0593441017,
-0.0014148969,
-0.0562933385,
0.0025723616,
-0.0238088164,
0.0342142172,
0.0221786387,
0.0636221543,
0.0082307588,
-0.0487712882,
-0.0188118592,
0.0064371563,
-0.0618578866,
-0.0311964303,
-0.0056977323,
0.0160437524,
-0.0401516855,
-0.0083685033,
0.0304191671,
-0.0585302152,
-0.0076025394,
-0.0006485062,
0.0166621562,
0.0117876753,
0.0003050657,
0.0297297575,
-0.0243569054,
-0.0196782369,
0.0168034453,
0.0048129344,
0.0009870081,
0.0007477262,
0.0241015088,
0.0668146834,
-0.0614813082,
-0.0188094471,
-0.0227089487,
-0.0079104854,
-0.0086135175,
0.0358977839,
0.004314654,
0.0178585388,
0.0267854799,
0.0436635837,
-0.0014589863,
0.0392156579,
-0.0053752931,
-0.0051764902,
0.0090151662,
0.0312280059,
-0.0521246381,
0.0090203425,
-0.0616102964,
0.0644964129,
0.0481491983,
-0.0477962121,
-0.0322425738,
0.0011435664,
2.878e-7,
0.0456314497,
0.0136270318,
0.0027957945,
-0.0041078664,
-0.0080134971,
-0.0130633432,
-0.0103930822,
0.011394443,
-0.0145965051,
-0.0109683927,
0.0362273194,
0.0205572788,
0.0527683496,
0.012482089,
-0.0348302536,
0.0045446628,
-0.0657220036,
-0.0169903915,
-0.0228340402,
-0.0640024692,
0.0224097408,
0.0895361081,
-0.0138906455,
-0.0392113812,
0.0162167083,
0.025831271,
0.0646212101,
-0.0011321451,
0.0204905942,
0.0189102013,
0.0416210182,
0.0179016981,
-0.0049284431,
-0.0429038443,
0.0021146471,
0.0016857461,
-0.0416382141,
0.0615451895,
-0.0148842391,
-0.0219858475,
0.0059051747,
0.0310099944,
-0.0060747638,
-0.0495179817,
0.0380733684,
-0.0184684582,
0.0186144337,
-0.0863876641,
-0.023995867,
-0.0147938365,
-0.0086111827,
-0.0344883762,
0.0197526142,
0.0087701725,
0.0063138404,
0.0119416183,
0.0057417587,
-0.0981559977,
-0.0139931627,
0.0207747128,
-0.0455718525,
-0.0466592908,
-0.0158217773,
-0.0223968234,
-0.0134591525,
-0.0645831451,
0.0227823015,
2.629682341e-34,
0.0320612863,
0.0050274823,
0.0262226481,
0.0387542099,
0.0078936657,
-0.0410379022,
0.0006888984,
0.0068347752,
-0.0371566042,
-0.0651816577,
-0.0313481949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02420v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02420v2 | Factuality of Large Language Models in the Year 2024 | 2024-02-04T09:36:31 | 2024-02-09T06:36:41 | Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Muhammad Arslan Manzoor, Fei Liu, Georgi Georgiev, Rocktim Jyoti Das, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), especially when instruction-tuned for chat,
have become part of our daily lives, freeing people from the process of
searching, extracting, and integrating information from multiple sources by
offering a straightforward answer to a variety of questions in a single place.
Unfortunately, in many cases, LLM responses are factually incorrect, which
limits their applicability in real-world scenarios. As a result, research on
evaluating and improving the factuality of LLMs has attracted a lot of research
attention recently. In this survey, we critically analyze existing work with
the aim to identify the major challenges and their associated causes, pointing
out to potential solutions for improving the factuality of LLMs, and analyzing
the obstacles to automated factuality evaluation for open-ended text
generation. We further offer an outlook on where future research should go. | [
0.0544419698,
0.0329420231,
-0.0183393471,
0.0577034689,
-0.0514047146,
-0.0343793519,
0.0187323689,
-0.0179761965,
0.0066312421,
-0.0652444512,
0.0140934009,
-0.0706802607,
0.0274677053,
0.0149982786,
0.0225680359,
-0.015749082,
0.0293658953,
-0.0126545718,
-0.0074968999,
-0.0188231487,
0.0031395545,
0.0398501046,
-0.0198332146,
0.0489180274,
-0.0268537924,
-0.0182988346,
-0.0146742007,
0.004094339,
-0.0078378031,
0.012226494,
-0.0065035159,
0.0248682015,
-0.0038647729,
0.0566569231,
0.0000022258,
-0.0423832797,
0.0139929699,
-0.021005528,
-0.0482071377,
0.0444596373,
0.0426444151,
0.0187109467,
-0.0148904463,
0.0196940564,
-0.0278273001,
0.0150710121,
0.039550852,
0.0034957665,
0.0843307003,
0.0747757331,
0.0084601771,
0.0037670648,
0.018906543,
0.0153399892,
0.0103983684,
0.024937259,
0.0190109909,
0.040101897,
0.0229467545,
0.0136170564,
0.0225076489,
0.0463275053,
0.0177165866,
-0.0449607484,
0.0068628974,
0.0468755029,
-0.035348177,
-0.0294718109,
0.027613949,
0.0536436327,
0.0325848721,
-0.0117740138,
-0.0017311623,
-0.0201232154,
-0.0100727044,
-0.0043554711,
-0.0298342779,
0.0765557289,
-0.0305083916,
0.0084265927,
0.0060353996,
-0.0178374369,
0.0161971543,
0.025097765,
-0.0112008406,
0.0563791879,
0.0106554292,
-0.0261391662,
-0.0594652668,
0.0170549043,
-0.0057153045,
-0.0859844834,
-0.0136784548,
0.0257810578,
-0.040289335,
0.0349902436,
-0.0523112193,
0.022224851,
0.0394730903,
-0.0659946874,
0.0274441876,
0.0280625317,
-0.0146766705,
-0.0001525515,
0.023081556,
0.0303539708,
0.0054133213,
-0.0055047893,
-0.0221304465,
0.0344267562,
-0.0049844556,
-0.0026907935,
-0.0150214536,
0.025285,
-0.0272464361,
0.0028966828,
-0.0312594287,
0.0206706561,
0.0051887534,
0.0345653966,
-0.026086675,
0.0115393773,
-0.0481797121,
-0.0037437798,
-0.0411956348,
0.0187071469,
-0.0200877935,
0.0147834392,
0.0135991117,
-0.092663601,
0.0173441134,
0.0493684039,
-0.0233975183,
-0.0001963446,
-0.0289903451,
0.0235765725,
-0.0076060714,
0.005282212,
-0.0370347612,
-0.0684094429,
-0.0388468727,
-0.0782903582,
-0.030786721,
-0.0763823688,
0.0208326727,
0.0128669627,
-0.0181974266,
-0.0115208225,
0.0098878415,
0.0523795597,
-0.0192822535,
0.0360270329,
-0.0248974096,
0.0116143888,
0.043872904,
0.0045361132,
-0.0004405399,
0.0488444269,
0.0695813373,
0.0347773023,
0.0639736205,
0.0243999697,
0.0063297264,
0.025266489,
0.0061488263,
0.0109383687,
0.0024115553,
0.0026530849,
-0.0185201727,
0.0585738122,
0.0043019992,
0.0707399696,
-0.0290692952,
0.0036664596,
0.0953035206,
0.0077669104,
-0.0115085728,
0.0196828563,
0.0704773366,
0.0409684554,
0.0470769517,
0.0725490823,
-0.0173654724,
0.0172633007,
-0.0344942547,
0.0475025214,
0.0484390706,
0.0503481477,
-0.0016385696,
-0.0729684159,
-0.0264437422,
0.0088240132,
-0.0237769559,
-0.0071240426,
0.0047271391,
-0.0108140651,
-0.0206693057,
0.0556908175,
0.0496575236,
-0.0728825256,
0.021304924,
-0.0483783782,
0.0307835508,
0.0625986606,
0.0711794347,
0.0066494495,
-0.0477292836,
-0.0022116657,
0.0259378254,
0.0726105794,
0.0534397066,
-0.0017984853,
-0.0166341886,
-0.0378674194,
0.0288356449,
-0.0168829169,
0.0145258373,
-0.0182435643,
0.0255819466,
-0.017789783,
0.0198657904,
-0.0081834011,
-0.0389559008,
0.0186192915,
-0.0453025289,
-0.0024566187,
-0.0109860655,
0.0026444071,
0.0018392877,
-0.0031809891,
-0.0298517104,
0.0243027285,
-0.0172834694,
0.0019179366,
-0.0164160654,
0.007462115,
-0.0506622791,
-0.0222166888,
0.0526353009,
-0.0084463134,
-0.0106993178,
0.0069057005,
-0.0133599322,
-0.0154929673,
-0.0118250158,
-0.0653731674,
0.0304220971,
-0.028346587,
0.0251789782,
0.0353592299,
0.0034641402,
-0.0247163884,
0.0536828265,
0.0004203948,
0.0128367869,
0.0244489778,
0.001783372,
0.0082448432,
-0.0448897555,
0.0047121514,
0.0422411077,
0.0093052648,
0.031369783,
0.0470715351,
0.0194231234,
-0.0526288375,
-0.0168618262,
-0.0863754675,
0.0077096606,
-0.0204757098,
0.0086910538,
0.0290312842,
-0.0049925465,
-0.0149453692,
0.016257368,
-0.0588033684,
-0.0062163859,
0.0210105404,
-0.0017609928,
0.0770192593,
-0.0102172876,
-0.0008841411,
-0.0453321151,
0.0133521566,
-0.016001394,
0.0163273662,
0.0519847311,
-0.0047787121,
-0.058703009,
0.0471637584,
-0.0910674185,
-0.0040301424,
0.014525394,
-0.0480493344,
0.0137021784,
0.0193214584,
0.0555005334,
0.0256018117,
0.0438178256,
0.0264016036,
0.0574104749,
0.0003838808,
-0.0394510813,
-0.0009879832,
-0.0200441871,
-0.03401573,
0.010104442,
-0.0874803364,
0.0202133134,
0.0279546287,
0.0438256189,
-0.0085081356,
-0.0471975096,
0.0208998993,
-0.047415778,
-0.0269788317,
-0.0390582308,
-0.0096446816,
-0.0270858817,
0.0252924208,
-0.005411563,
-0.0503204912,
0.0850376561,
-0.0652898028,
0.0247340538,
-0.0442810021,
-0.0106503507,
-0.0255511925,
0.017107144,
-0.0089191841,
0.0340148956,
0.0325429924,
0.0120139029,
-0.0374468192,
-0.0042856322,
0.0494013093,
-0.0409885757,
0.0622390807,
-0.0834269151,
0.0137987789,
0.0153526999,
-0.0345508009,
-0.0407473408,
-0.0942972302,
0.0095141977,
-0.0260436852,
0.0162211545,
-0.0181725081,
-0.03653026,
-0.0082158241,
0.0653615147,
-0.0014035709,
-0.0192345679,
-0.0239536949,
-0.026124943,
0.0318201147,
0.0738793984,
0.0114626531,
0.0412768088,
-0.0306952074,
0.0261099599,
0.0738011524,
-0.0132498983,
0.0240932591,
-0.0020097673,
-0.0400736593,
0.0179086104,
-0.0200195145,
-0.0412481688,
0.0353082716,
0.076511167,
-0.0443697907,
-0.0438971967,
0.1120834872,
0.0435351506,
0.015027808,
0.0199194327,
-0.0029307944,
0.0339241736,
-0.0208380166,
0.0198823977,
-0.0905458853,
0.0075912285,
-0.0046712011,
0.0257394686,
-0.0455392003,
-0.0346060619,
-0.0363696553,
-0.1255169362,
0.0438214205,
0.0241379663,
-0.0092419386,
-0.0438124128,
-0.0073189503,
-0.0060270717,
0.0289921816,
0.0385283977,
0.0106229745,
-0.0229964945,
0.0225588623,
0.0436432995,
-0.0606556796,
-0.0219198335,
0.009164338,
-0.0170206148,
0.0521921441,
0.0159072187,
0.032199271,
0.0088619217,
-0.0124742379,
0.0024563174,
0.0235701967,
-0.0103633674,
0.0131381406,
0.0136154657,
-0.0050572734,
-0.0028861137,
-0.0538363904,
0.0109786699,
0.0254091471,
-0.0162056219,
0.0036320321,
0.0444209464,
-0.0416811034,
-0.0043287096,
-0.0026346429,
0.0551672205,
0.0165467896,
0.0809824914,
0.0339290276,
-0.0132828141,
0.0033770625,
-0.059561301,
-0.0164487381,
-0.0027449322,
-0.045900695,
0.0124152582,
-0.0236218181,
-0.0141392192,
-0.0919743031,
-0.047656849,
0.0011458384,
0.0005076921,
-0.0351278782,
-0.0429588482,
0.0406694859,
-0.0305649973,
0.0278869849,
-0.0053268513,
-0.0559352525,
0.0308253132,
-0.0428798907,
-0.0065515945,
0.0160515942,
-0.049876187,
0.0339037105,
0.0111446781,
-0.0822361708,
-0.0653553382,
-0.0066742981,
0.0231783539,
0.0208990946,
0.040455915,
-0.0196215473,
-0.0433257036,
0.017474521,
0.0404040739,
-0.0523040704,
0.0400642566,
0.003528842,
0.0281510577,
0.0116039198,
0.0433871225,
-0.0061758407,
0.0012007932,
-0.0374150202,
0.0505160987,
-0.0147747695,
-0.0832108855,
0.0466803312,
0.0687271655,
-0.0100735417,
-0.0195118021,
-0.0183765683,
-0.0240063723,
0.0155276554,
-0.0669198632,
-0.0480410829,
-0.0252375919,
-0.0022990399,
-0.0190345552,
-0.0026114245,
-0.0144978249,
-0.0366822965,
-0.0538353249,
0.0482387431,
-0.0138989128,
-0.0078997286,
-0.036302276,
0.0087559428,
0.0388638414,
-0.0215278752,
-0.0602619834,
0.0291130226,
-0.0210346486,
0.0535775721,
0.0141581679,
0.0514369458,
0.0154534262,
-0.0179936998,
0.0037982718,
-0.0023802062,
-0.0400736593,
-0.0281721726,
-0.0358993374,
0.0668432489,
0.0602994338,
0.020445412,
0.0728430077,
-0.0587065704,
-0.0071281185,
-0.0107990941,
0.0323701538,
0.0328068137,
-0.0597901307,
0.00395768,
-0.0010676881,
-0.043260958,
-0.0006954988,
0.0833756998,
0.0008787022,
0.035092786,
0.0051625459,
-0.0325948074,
-0.0359558165,
-0.0458981283,
-0.0237939693,
-0.0062885964,
-0.0053771394,
-0.0105782617,
-0.0891478434,
-0.0674150065,
-0.0186075624,
0.0486084707,
0.0169334058,
-0.0403735265,
0.0095027247,
0.0752300471,
0.0225644019,
-0.0023152875,
-0.0709344894,
0.0591830835,
-0.0301739164,
0.0386993922,
-0.0161130931,
-6.969176868e-33,
-0.0396398939,
-0.0572298132,
0.028113056,
-0.0140508264,
-0.029059276,
0.0102183111,
-0.0336023532,
0.0129766101,
-0.0141664268,
0.023653876,
0.0098641729,
0.0036194047,
0.0208162647,
0.0244825929,
-0.0177832562,
-0.0183714367,
0.0479777493,
0.0045527043,
-0.0667585805,
0.0193566885,
0.0508396327,
-0.0414308049,
0.0298253279,
-0.0413803421,
0.0735452697,
-0.0398191586,
-0.0228287149,
0.023961205,
-0.0438607745,
0.0521786213,
-0.0177211948,
0.0782348886,
0.0055556023,
-0.0244647861,
-0.0155064389,
-0.0115412734,
0.0045365812,
-0.0343092903,
0.0527782924,
-0.0126989931,
-0.0166708156,
-0.0218012445,
0.0036686109,
-0.015657261,
-0.0201045703,
0.0057791243,
0.0217873733,
-0.0185402799,
0.0057353731,
0.0065036947,
-0.0654720515,
0.0384510644,
0.0176172517,
-0.018816961,
-0.0529911332,
0.0354140699,
-0.0020488228,
-0.0396097042,
-0.0479506068,
0.0413929671,
0.0357622653,
0.0347793251,
0.0773571432,
-0.0261456221,
-0.0088460036,
0.0440853722,
-0.0271577351,
0.0373313241,
-0.0584960841,
0.0051808162,
-0.0130891707,
0.0309028458,
0.0176760647,
0.0878784657,
-0.0228417851,
-0.0096819028,
-0.0551394224,
0.0175082721,
0.0420055874,
0.011064155,
0.0048932661,
-0.0367448479,
-0.06647636,
-0.0251867175,
-0.0232609436,
0.05482978,
-0.0130508514,
-0.037595313,
0.0039594159,
-0.0260186177,
-0.0225112289,
-0.0504550636,
-0.0114729255,
-0.0193856992,
-0.0119752232,
-0.002709083,
-0.0633092448,
0.0091662621,
-0.0212271046,
0.0347536951,
-0.0429141223,
0.0167823676,
0.0044508888,
0.0011518837,
-0.0150833149,
0.050799083,
0.0055305585,
0.0220480859,
-0.0151409032,
0.0298106093,
-0.0452097058,
0.0012150753,
0.0100340685,
-0.0528091043,
0.025987532,
-0.0148084853,
-0.0499819331,
0.0323696434,
-0.0015431296,
0.0143630365,
-0.0231668428,
-0.0370136313,
-0.0004676343,
0.0251461677,
-0.0444893874,
0.0355162397,
-0.0576058291,
0.005740691,
0.0352031998,
-0.0412333272,
-0.0188280661,
-0.0354713462,
2.887e-7,
0.0074176192,
0.0402669534,
0.0388154387,
0.0493991077,
-0.0201158803,
0.0332723893,
-0.0095787961,
0.0025601073,
0.0207131337,
-0.0280516595,
-0.0081691239,
0.0257818252,
0.0598473959,
0.044548396,
-0.0315706432,
-0.0053396947,
-0.0836517587,
-0.0178477522,
-0.0639488325,
-0.026362,
0.0608022325,
0.0453587808,
0.0180925056,
0.0061479355,
-0.007240518,
-0.0277344659,
0.0463382415,
-0.0069396147,
-0.0983738825,
0.0399280153,
0.0832853317,
-0.025791591,
0.0184881743,
-0.0094623975,
-0.0012845808,
-0.0219206903,
-0.0199125595,
0.0505573452,
0.046270933,
0.002715148,
-0.0114025818,
-0.0455690585,
0.0016995015,
-0.0576319806,
0.0529987887,
-0.0309382901,
-0.0202774536,
-0.0422933809,
-0.0027247877,
0.0028578513,
0.0082574859,
-0.0232439842,
-0.0564373285,
0.029183099,
0.0007212469,
0.0079322867,
0.0068563758,
0.0084901946,
-0.0553105734,
0.0004260022,
-0.0318930857,
-0.0986423939,
-0.0018836762,
0.0046686819,
0.0098876618,
-0.0442938283,
0.022787353,
2.67223317e-34,
0.0256832372,
0.0157181453,
0.0227864999,
-0.0147608556,
0.0586629175,
0.0299627297,
-0.0007310172,
-0.0054739802,
0.0234365407,
-0.0574078523,
-0.0229154285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02416v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02416v4 | Aligner: Efficient Alignment by Learning to Correct | 2024-02-04T09:24:51 | 2024-06-24T18:55:16 | Jiaming Ji, Boyuan Chen, Hantao Lou, Donghai Hong, Borong Zhang, Xuehai Pan, Juntao Dai, Tianyi Qiu, Yaodong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the rapid development of large language models (LLMs) and ever-evolving
practical requirements, finding an efficient and effective alignment method has
never been more critical. However, the tension between the complexity of
current alignment methods and the need for rapid iteration in deployment
scenarios necessitates the development of a model-agnostic alignment approach
that can operate under these constraints. In this paper, we introduce Aligner,
a novel and simple alignment paradigm that learns the correctional residuals
between preferred and dispreferred answers using a small model. Designed as a
model-agnostic, plug-and-play module, Aligner can be directly applied to
various open-source and API-based models with only one-off training, making it
suitable for rapid iteration. Notably, Aligner can be applied to any powerful,
large-scale upstream models. Moreover, it can even iteratively bootstrap the
upstream models using corrected responses as synthetic human preference data,
breaking through the model's performance ceiling. Our experiments demonstrate
performance improvements by deploying the same Aligner model across 11
different LLMs, evaluated on the 3H dimensions (helpfulness, harmlessness, and
honesty). Specifically, Aligner-7B has achieved an average improvement of 68.9%
in helpfulness and 23.8% in harmlessness across the tested LLMs while also
effectively reducing hallucination. In the Alpaca-Eval leaderboard, stacking
Aligner-2B on GPT-4 Turbo improved its LC Win Rate from 55.0% to 58.3%,
surpassing GPT-4 Omni's 57.5% Win Rate (community report). | [
0.040761821,
0.0884810463,
-0.0183749851,
0.030770367,
-0.0577051602,
0.0085796695,
-0.0338701084,
-0.0298491549,
0.0165555961,
-0.0237210542,
-0.0185674503,
-0.0274652224,
0.0108083291,
0.0025992645,
0.0085441256,
0.0015081473,
0.077502735,
-0.0187319238,
0.0310569834,
-0.0116710812,
0.0242232364,
0.0169546511,
-0.0140894214,
0.039153479,
0.0167328566,
-0.0157215949,
-0.0364892595,
-0.0010536364,
0.0272744801,
-0.0256403964,
0.0212397035,
0.0717081428,
0.0055899844,
0.0725997239,
0.0000022366,
-0.0622643791,
-0.0399055742,
-0.0111066671,
-0.024172226,
0.0256004501,
-0.0023104667,
0.0195387639,
-0.0169486441,
0.0383571312,
-0.0431770943,
0.0159753412,
0.0905769989,
0.0123255905,
0.0911047533,
0.048885081,
0.01284137,
-0.0176337659,
0.0160842035,
-0.0088552134,
0.0045523061,
-0.0606082119,
0.009288664,
-0.0048198323,
-0.0314254686,
-0.0429931469,
-0.0083115613,
0.0190941151,
0.002773056,
0.0200063735,
0.0137307122,
0.0160412416,
-0.0398952141,
-0.029226549,
-0.0393757336,
0.0710246339,
-0.009353729,
-0.0471280403,
-0.0248523131,
-0.0227473583,
0.0209063012,
-0.0096066846,
-0.0208045803,
-0.0096435435,
0.0022262936,
0.0240657777,
0.014469048,
-0.0206640381,
0.0101822931,
0.0026739535,
-0.0223597083,
0.0845969468,
0.0277779568,
-0.0495786071,
0.0114266509,
0.0075542275,
-0.024428701,
-0.0625764877,
-0.0067791115,
0.0049333475,
-0.0786800906,
0.024426939,
-0.0434314422,
-0.0063551017,
0.0564677455,
-0.0486232378,
0.0303386208,
0.0440520532,
-0.0111460518,
0.0392137207,
-0.0154700568,
0.0909093171,
-0.0044518928,
0.0353530943,
-0.0217511263,
0.0020779453,
-0.0008948894,
-0.0227587335,
-0.0005799426,
0.022354601,
-0.0124152964,
-0.0009918476,
-0.0705476999,
0.0208262391,
-0.0325721018,
0.0576656759,
0.0223593358,
0.0057503423,
-0.0251538903,
-0.0048899911,
-0.0327500738,
0.0494818352,
-0.0290815327,
0.0179427899,
0.0216705929,
-0.0612944923,
0.0062173666,
-0.015297981,
-0.0295993462,
-0.0282585081,
0.0258339234,
0.0713569969,
-0.0056628343,
-0.0093098562,
-0.007748479,
-0.0014396675,
-0.0251498502,
-0.073172614,
-0.0377019644,
-0.0888551027,
0.046589788,
0.0074566538,
-0.0129380552,
-0.065070428,
0.0147897387,
0.0183980018,
-0.039048627,
0.0711122006,
0.0049466048,
0.0259523131,
-0.0142703559,
-0.0011165717,
-0.0029340237,
0.0690816492,
0.0196612179,
0.0440784618,
0.0462682396,
-0.0513630919,
0.0214081183,
0.0458999388,
0.004762412,
-0.0097066555,
0.0024794186,
0.0188032612,
0.0321642756,
0.0334543586,
0.011069431,
0.0402181558,
0.0220648926,
-0.0417362563,
0.0989793316,
0.0110114701,
0.003381426,
-0.0074711693,
-0.0285984874,
0.0187782869,
-0.0040329471,
0.0016471384,
-0.0921264291,
0.0491806455,
-0.0513036251,
0.0246776119,
0.0128439907,
0.0801249892,
-0.0076531195,
-0.0304447915,
-0.0194075555,
0.0015084784,
-0.0089457138,
0.0432517417,
0.0272468012,
-0.0368208736,
-0.0762013197,
0.0476622134,
0.0408640392,
-0.0543210432,
-0.0345890857,
-0.0575622916,
0.0487447493,
0.055780042,
0.051777117,
-0.0038163876,
-0.0451099277,
-0.02478862,
-0.0299364179,
0.0470180511,
0.0411396883,
-0.0056323563,
0.0001282875,
-0.0527375601,
-0.0377406664,
0.0209323261,
0.0015897299,
0.0353102572,
0.0149451951,
-0.0123503832,
-0.0066868793,
-0.0117767118,
-0.0142151648,
0.0500313975,
0.0131996786,
-0.0367981344,
-0.0321540311,
0.0115363291,
0.0447990149,
0.0134535674,
-0.0100327898,
-0.0006353399,
0.0500431843,
0.0280981641,
0.0096152388,
0.0021965213,
-0.0367947668,
0.0209418405,
0.0889266282,
0.0064759427,
-0.023429079,
0.0750985667,
-0.0355089456,
-0.0086288583,
-0.0218320433,
-0.0299276654,
0.0428537801,
-0.0158644095,
0.0641710833,
-0.032164596,
-0.0151280407,
-0.0467465632,
0.0371939763,
-0.016693512,
0.0142624062,
-0.0243998766,
-0.032870274,
0.0176500026,
-0.0124611864,
-0.0308453944,
0.0031618318,
-0.0186372008,
0.0120595666,
0.0319840945,
0.0069133481,
-0.0507871881,
-0.033961039,
-0.0768630803,
0.0231422149,
-0.0037588503,
0.0157376546,
0.0339642577,
-0.0015760927,
0.0057137725,
0.0011365442,
-0.0466196537,
-0.0123020457,
0.036642503,
0.0277274363,
0.0047681783,
-0.0131554045,
-0.0639571995,
-0.0641712844,
-0.0086966436,
-0.0369138904,
-0.0002188219,
-0.034728609,
-0.01786929,
-0.0469148941,
-0.0056682811,
-0.0545011908,
0.033547204,
-0.0070441086,
-0.0701769292,
0.0127777634,
0.0156626962,
0.0019942725,
0.0676473901,
0.0353955738,
-0.0226184726,
0.06605196,
-0.0034837364,
-0.0881024227,
0.0015908955,
-0.015660977,
-0.0709896386,
-0.0228309911,
-0.0504414886,
-0.0225201827,
0.0944736078,
0.008882124,
0.0140196905,
-0.0647348911,
0.0016441309,
0.0070502502,
-0.0404961221,
-0.025383722,
-0.02535378,
-0.0278424602,
0.0135606937,
-0.0296848994,
-0.0830461234,
0.1030872911,
-0.0331761204,
-0.0027941938,
-0.0420556515,
0.0144340219,
-0.003901616,
0.0366213806,
-0.0061697825,
0.0221069958,
0.0205172468,
-0.0207540784,
-0.0520834327,
-0.0572830588,
0.0290056672,
-0.0705796555,
0.0613524765,
-0.0533948652,
0.0013518744,
-0.0073614973,
-0.0570363142,
-0.058371745,
-0.0560029671,
-0.0148227513,
-0.0114167603,
-0.0066686822,
-0.0220960528,
-0.0353352763,
-0.0239273943,
0.0288859587,
-0.0118317828,
-0.0162818357,
0.0115027521,
-0.0192603376,
0.0000636304,
0.1004078239,
0.0129502844,
0.0497237556,
-0.0264711715,
0.0085877758,
0.0626985133,
0.0532657094,
0.0003658378,
0.0155722797,
-0.0087497625,
0.0481362231,
-0.031695798,
0.0148186414,
0.0467734821,
0.0445226096,
-0.0188699029,
0.0269926526,
0.1013914347,
0.038570594,
-0.0230887122,
0.001786568,
-0.0215448663,
0.0667509362,
0.0306846946,
0.0292203557,
-0.0896749645,
-0.0295687225,
0.0071941614,
0.0312676616,
-0.0067604668,
-0.013826414,
0.003637033,
-0.1309449226,
-0.0019416781,
0.0294359587,
-0.0443366617,
-0.0348914266,
-0.0319123864,
0.0056378441,
-0.0400221199,
0.0355554074,
0.0421357453,
0.0206107609,
-0.0199234895,
-0.0080858106,
-0.0158703271,
0.0169354547,
0.0215746574,
-0.0663890317,
0.0963053852,
0.0835381746,
0.016548682,
-0.0116246315,
-0.0661573708,
0.0190360155,
0.0142683014,
-0.0249165446,
0.0180844087,
0.0374916531,
-0.0184537824,
0.01603131,
-0.0308247712,
0.0182315316,
-0.0082976148,
-0.0021081634,
0.0406894386,
0.0850467011,
0.0189529322,
0.0058958014,
-0.006785016,
0.0082500111,
0.0293989349,
0.0791300759,
-0.0040770737,
-0.0366306566,
-0.0454619974,
-0.0254756026,
-0.0110977851,
-0.0274264421,
-0.0407558009,
0.0033610903,
0.0160373803,
-0.0012384253,
-0.0544563383,
-0.0396981239,
0.0097985202,
0.0210415889,
0.0232299622,
0.0016067678,
-0.0289574694,
-0.0069621322,
-0.0390728191,
0.014461075,
-0.0202028714,
0.0270703286,
-0.0540631227,
0.0041576261,
0.0029578665,
-0.0165693089,
0.0049981512,
0.0314484276,
-0.0344448574,
-0.0778518692,
0.044438228,
0.0551850013,
0.0313921012,
0.0404303968,
-0.0050721527,
-0.0250040591,
0.0120313773,
0.0334442481,
-0.0451496169,
0.025411047,
0.0164784063,
-0.01861687,
0.0048782965,
0.0188666936,
-0.0271955654,
-0.0208478831,
0.0358449221,
0.0311466735,
0.005482683,
-0.0378925838,
0.0653287768,
0.0246396307,
0.0356849767,
-0.0235222373,
-0.0085204635,
-0.0052448115,
0.0319108926,
-0.0393456966,
-0.0306955781,
0.0006158666,
-0.0174129959,
0.0112497509,
-0.0091713127,
0.0163099412,
-0.0030705363,
-0.0281243268,
0.024221655,
-0.0563323386,
-0.008460653,
0.0043284278,
0.0071910159,
0.032982368,
-0.0057104728,
-0.0367061272,
-0.0062322915,
0.0193696637,
0.0764644742,
0.0099476753,
0.0692212656,
0.0019812291,
-0.026103057,
-0.0139421308,
0.0361130275,
-0.0260618012,
-0.0413334854,
-0.0327474214,
0.0243726987,
0.0582762398,
0.0032345355,
0.0580530576,
0.0002236835,
-0.0067532528,
-0.0119533865,
0.0225529019,
-0.019805219,
-0.0220565293,
0.013814196,
0.0309826937,
-0.0277023017,
-0.0053620348,
0.0380310491,
-0.0174578018,
0.036985185,
-0.0516006909,
-0.0128697623,
-0.0259072147,
-0.033037249,
-0.005037257,
0.0321228877,
-0.0609780699,
-0.0357979983,
-0.0788968205,
-0.0493569858,
-0.0357953981,
0.0556927733,
0.0000623727,
-0.0042261556,
0.009541858,
0.0678747445,
-0.0153461602,
-0.0421894193,
-0.0368128605,
0.0011823087,
-0.0282604154,
-0.0115013272,
-0.0328610912,
-6.626884668e-33,
-0.0322826318,
0.0063778022,
0.0163757131,
-0.0220226701,
-0.0324025676,
-0.0354095474,
0.0022307369,
0.0426093377,
-0.0507471152,
-0.0229089893,
-0.0212099832,
-0.0003942304,
0.020562293,
-0.0085386466,
0.0351270996,
0.0092262514,
0.0188151579,
0.0074520414,
-0.0542048141,
-0.0005266341,
0.0298421234,
-0.0000885902,
0.0576960668,
-0.0881817639,
0.0231565852,
0.0200576391,
-0.0252053123,
0.009651185,
-0.0717011839,
0.0598079599,
0.0146667277,
0.0098940609,
-0.0010615085,
-0.023245139,
-0.0031181464,
0.0188855659,
-0.0158006549,
0.0027491839,
0.0536484122,
0.0110970391,
-0.0023914729,
-0.0139500052,
0.0352601372,
-0.0301126763,
-0.0412454493,
-0.0180262234,
0.0258395039,
-0.0316616297,
-0.0083961561,
0.045235768,
-0.0771108717,
-0.0002775718,
-0.018437108,
-0.0053768773,
-0.0243742,
0.0706108212,
0.0109512731,
0.0333206244,
-0.0783145726,
0.0361546986,
0.0173377208,
0.0366523899,
0.1000380144,
0.0356942043,
0.0029619955,
0.0665539801,
0.0236953031,
-0.0267594736,
0.0064025712,
-0.0200342387,
0.0083547831,
0.020181641,
0.0928248912,
0.0533871204,
0.0335026905,
-0.0279977638,
-0.0403026976,
0.0409917831,
0.0450342484,
0.0017918891,
0.0358552784,
0.0320245475,
-0.0822678879,
0.0035709487,
-0.0212709475,
0.0275468286,
-0.0381908268,
-0.0530614518,
0.0473781638,
-0.0063421321,
-0.0153672229,
-0.0155275082,
0.0427011326,
-0.0358683839,
0.0018168299,
0.0267908219,
-0.0146449562,
0.0193001106,
-0.0274345484,
0.0066551245,
-0.047296498,
-0.0052232263,
-0.013967298,
0.0098670349,
0.0315107815,
0.0134395789,
0.0224475544,
0.0077379299,
-0.0780327246,
0.0315866619,
-0.0288308896,
0.014307146,
0.005970805,
-0.0406833962,
0.0391666591,
-0.0247243717,
-0.003037604,
0.0213719122,
0.0152071184,
-0.010339139,
-0.0602530353,
-0.0154265566,
-0.0082776379,
0.0043539321,
-0.0066270409,
-0.0045837681,
-0.0241177622,
0.0203456394,
-0.0165452268,
-0.0020054237,
-0.0146932518,
-0.0032941559,
2.917e-7,
0.0008487699,
0.0149896834,
0.0178678446,
-0.002174262,
-0.029938763,
0.060039185,
-0.0203446746,
0.0378816351,
0.049267672,
-0.0283150673,
0.0109177725,
-0.0029731488,
0.0526333973,
0.0291557088,
-0.038026128,
-0.0091496026,
-0.0532409325,
0.008673545,
-0.0517679155,
0.0255363677,
0.055336684,
0.0972237736,
0.0337791443,
-0.0068002921,
-0.0037535604,
0.0141916396,
0.0199838057,
-0.0235326942,
-0.0303724371,
0.0271988939,
-0.0075146831,
-0.0343196355,
-0.0274163913,
0.0234875977,
-0.0103500299,
0.0246448759,
-0.0379259288,
0.0562055446,
-0.0303250197,
-0.0452832878,
-0.0165762007,
-0.0109008122,
0.0054900572,
-0.0860297233,
0.0558135547,
-0.0223903731,
-0.0340083167,
-0.0418070406,
-0.0489504486,
-0.0181677081,
0.014446876,
-0.0123904124,
-0.0183992591,
0.0067526577,
0.0133637087,
0.0116321677,
-0.028662581,
-0.0486116521,
-0.0494262725,
0.0293304771,
-0.0118810218,
-0.0662240684,
-0.0107084205,
0.0265954752,
-0.000855553,
-0.0854427665,
0.0172861796,
2.883658227e-34,
0.0041903947,
-0.0174178239,
0.0597725809,
0.0246443544,
0.0388540737,
-0.0010827382,
0.0417942218,
0.0298241545,
0.0264078639,
-0.0554397702,
-0.0069336253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02408v1 | GLaPE: Gold Label-agnostic Prompt Evaluation and Optimization for Large Language Model | 2024-02-04T08:57:54 | 2024-02-04T08:57:54 | Xuanchang Zhang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the rapid progress of large language models (LLMs), their task
performance remains sensitive to prompt design. Recent studies have explored
leveraging the LLM itself as an optimizer to identify optimal prompts that
maximize task accuracy. However, when evaluating prompts, such approaches
heavily rely on elusive manually annotated gold labels to calculate task
accuracy for each candidate prompt, which hinders the widespread implementation
and generality. To overcome the limitation, this work proposes a gold
label-agnostic prompt evaluation (GLaPE) to alleviate dependence on gold
labels. Motivated by the observed correlation between self-consistency and the
accuracy of the answer, we adopt self-consistency as the initial evaluation
score. Subsequently, we refine the scores of prompts producing identical
answers to be mutually consistent. Experimental results show that GLaPE
provides reliable evaluations uniform with accuracy, even in the absence of
gold labels. Moreover, on six popular reasoning tasks, our GLaPE-based prompt
optimization yields effective prompts comparable to accuracy-based ones. The
code is publicly available at https://github.com/thunderous77/GLaPE. | [
0.0376276635,
0.0215607397,
0.0024512617,
0.0302156098,
-0.0518814363,
-0.0064234133,
0.0529933311,
-0.0144697772,
0.0362073556,
-0.0316472426,
-0.0384964272,
-0.0125966957,
-0.0093238968,
0.0108497376,
0.0078657679,
-0.0378140695,
0.0708096921,
-0.0831536502,
0.038088195,
-0.0362009555,
-0.0276381858,
-0.0171749499,
-0.0404506139,
0.0400034301,
-0.0118734455,
-0.0534963161,
-0.0006282997,
-0.0153300073,
0.0064403825,
-0.0306625012,
-0.0033024654,
0.0967149436,
-0.0417212211,
0.0501220636,
0.000002386,
-0.0750030801,
0.0082300138,
-0.0214601513,
-0.0689266697,
0.0107931448,
0.005874374,
0.0305458382,
-0.0046371673,
0.0389930084,
-0.0253177583,
-0.0092672464,
0.039989844,
0.018368518,
0.0692440569,
0.0297373347,
0.0149186403,
0.0066913073,
0.006871724,
-0.031293992,
0.0236221068,
-0.0734137893,
-0.0020905777,
0.0086067421,
0.0336128771,
0.0399109721,
-0.0099039655,
0.0510165729,
0.037921641,
-0.0392522067,
0.0120448871,
0.0233799834,
-0.0163841266,
-0.0294854399,
-0.0370759256,
0.0612406544,
0.0094843535,
-0.0121595729,
-0.0350867063,
-0.0242123213,
0.0287756752,
-0.0122598885,
-0.0383351073,
0.0379330553,
0.0147132752,
-0.0200509261,
0.0009015469,
0.0354829729,
0.0135950791,
0.0010732618,
0.0043035885,
0.1074758023,
0.0360718593,
-0.0301615056,
0.0210875329,
0.0059716394,
-0.0479854085,
-0.0826191306,
0.0047829598,
0.0505856797,
-0.0863662139,
0.0056960038,
-0.042551823,
0.0030337037,
0.0380824097,
0.0084949574,
0.0579500608,
0.0495699681,
-0.0418592691,
0.0636938065,
-0.0161670446,
0.1126416251,
0.0018892946,
0.0087441616,
-0.0442072414,
-0.0056056986,
-0.0236341041,
0.0093605882,
-0.0459351242,
0.0098499814,
0.0184061229,
-0.017850155,
-0.0421449207,
0.0416195355,
-0.0244926587,
0.038481161,
0.0262246877,
-0.0014189079,
0.002879743,
-0.0195573755,
-0.0264774412,
0.0215485934,
-0.0606215559,
-0.0037942259,
0.0331442878,
-0.057917349,
-0.0033384329,
0.0049861479,
-0.012174801,
-0.0369169377,
0.004486864,
0.0601965524,
-0.006703279,
-0.0110027101,
0.0042281467,
-0.0210589319,
-0.0405135565,
-0.0579034835,
-0.0352337807,
-0.0756282359,
0.0414687283,
0.0153942127,
-0.0047243573,
-0.0288693141,
-0.0004594687,
0.0212718397,
0.0124013294,
0.0598708652,
-0.0042637289,
0.0304527227,
0.0170862209,
0.0123168407,
-0.0466475263,
0.0379108042,
0.0026517899,
0.043510098,
0.0571452528,
-0.0394688807,
0.0105906557,
0.0526464917,
-0.0004447842,
-0.0260696616,
0.0135530271,
0.0085407263,
0.0678881258,
0.030524198,
-0.0063019963,
0.0438585393,
0.0084075769,
-0.0090086199,
0.0827460736,
0.0460196771,
-0.0344997793,
-0.0531589128,
0.0202104356,
-0.0118021928,
0.0060656224,
0.0058037005,
-0.0809921026,
0.0247482955,
-0.0539901145,
0.0150112938,
0.0453767143,
0.013653433,
-0.0229335371,
-0.0402014144,
-0.0207855441,
0.0042570429,
-0.04235081,
0.046667885,
0.011733301,
-0.0015251435,
-0.0364502668,
0.0542105064,
0.0071998532,
-0.0396799818,
-0.0150535712,
-0.0525994375,
0.0666185319,
0.0394273959,
0.0372687206,
-0.0087707639,
-0.0291984305,
-0.0119237686,
0.0423773043,
0.0497392379,
0.0530826002,
-0.0160616543,
-0.0035809262,
-0.0364727713,
-0.0355990864,
0.0000413043,
-0.0043600495,
-0.0046305587,
0.0296390615,
-0.0083823036,
0.0153272375,
-0.026751576,
-0.0017732391,
0.0303045064,
0.0078563178,
-0.0465979688,
0.008596601,
0.0120489486,
0.0100338208,
0.0214614067,
0.0121667506,
0.0369062908,
0.0248175599,
-0.018832311,
-0.0015071696,
-0.0425880998,
-0.069143489,
-0.0120419413,
0.0495388843,
0.0090280101,
-0.0437533297,
0.0337469354,
-0.0280151498,
-0.0542458035,
-0.0342983752,
-0.0293664932,
-0.0093313232,
-0.0219063871,
0.040489316,
-0.0149458824,
-0.0027199029,
-0.0649279058,
0.0567635074,
0.0142451748,
0.0299303513,
0.0187135506,
0.0621393509,
0.0259691402,
-0.0752504915,
-0.0520429611,
0.010484552,
-0.0144970985,
-0.0021945341,
0.044550579,
0.0156625211,
-0.0551580079,
-0.0350109115,
-0.1025018319,
0.0104920641,
-0.0151958382,
0.0017794026,
0.0260952692,
0.0093214009,
-0.012851228,
-0.0291493703,
-0.0278937146,
-0.0233073216,
0.0297565982,
0.0288144983,
0.0111118667,
-0.0034966278,
-0.013914803,
-0.026138803,
-0.023181621,
-0.0052698096,
0.0169073828,
0.0075915591,
0.0163508616,
-0.0528280511,
-0.0038329817,
-0.0326307341,
0.0187432673,
0.0132401716,
0.0115807848,
0.0284805875,
-0.0075155823,
0.0498947017,
0.0650391206,
0.0252430234,
-0.0297613721,
0.0548720062,
-0.0186825804,
-0.0715343505,
0.0080477269,
-0.0160689838,
-0.0483883247,
0.0172968283,
-0.0345100798,
0.0178981479,
0.0821477026,
-0.0013070204,
-0.0040947427,
-0.0545756035,
0.0071674101,
-0.0385480635,
-0.0247948542,
-0.0664731488,
-0.0005888009,
-0.0257643741,
0.0551066548,
-0.0230037719,
-0.0593732037,
0.0788418055,
-0.0676556081,
-0.0020267181,
-0.0199468732,
0.014142137,
-0.0166396778,
0.083263807,
-0.0123985093,
0.0072032302,
0.047540158,
-0.0143521922,
-0.0227114987,
0.0089881122,
0.0211994071,
-0.0386410095,
0.0452359393,
-0.0428896584,
0.0182611495,
-0.0177618396,
-0.0591605827,
-0.0506061465,
-0.0433642119,
-0.0327589512,
0.0261770245,
-0.0375940204,
0.0039155837,
-0.0142795173,
0.0095669674,
0.0211956836,
0.0339040533,
-0.0517685972,
0.0093170209,
-0.0346224979,
0.0299963653,
0.0616885051,
0.0146903321,
0.015566892,
-0.0074305455,
0.0350268222,
0.0256304946,
0.0382579863,
0.0337079279,
0.0040782583,
0.0050440654,
0.0605776608,
-0.0410667136,
-0.022128446,
0.0587494709,
0.0441818051,
-0.0527148545,
-0.0153002515,
0.1405798048,
0.0451644659,
-0.0500025749,
-0.0099978391,
-0.0275089275,
0.034736,
0.031834852,
0.0282607619,
-0.0562044233,
-0.0490700677,
0.026893748,
0.0190322977,
-0.0008283054,
-0.0271415021,
-0.001976911,
-0.1307936758,
0.0258468948,
-0.0169943608,
-0.0240306817,
0.0038588771,
-0.0381204262,
0.0053195697,
0.0025820024,
0.0396468006,
0.0433349572,
-0.006435079,
0.001715448,
0.0293949507,
-0.0175392367,
-0.0445632823,
0.0702172369,
-0.0238529146,
0.0727184787,
0.0761879086,
-0.0096134245,
-0.0051725833,
-0.0813784525,
0.0453324169,
0.0059579364,
-0.0153021337,
-0.0085453894,
-0.004701924,
0.0079029659,
-0.013782816,
-0.0084247086,
0.0175111741,
-0.0148428222,
-0.0316662006,
0.0487527847,
0.0915381461,
-0.007752419,
0.0044540931,
-0.0033885005,
-0.0164959244,
0.0258701779,
0.0952026695,
0.0299150515,
-0.0549273826,
-0.0337555744,
-0.0299317408,
0.0041014496,
-0.0384017713,
-0.0375099182,
0.0364901721,
0.0147412121,
-0.0038662164,
-0.0242413711,
-0.0370099768,
0.0367608853,
0.0361702293,
0.0057045096,
0.0036540921,
-0.0583617613,
0.0024344039,
-0.0239971336,
0.0512805991,
-0.0749531165,
0.0428035446,
-0.110066101,
0.0276094656,
0.0117405113,
-0.0002216113,
-0.0181908105,
0.0600732565,
-0.0455222875,
-0.0565347075,
0.0084968312,
0.0595608689,
0.0249890164,
-0.0022019597,
-0.0342391469,
-0.0671095103,
0.0115486477,
-0.0097645288,
-0.0299962889,
0.0133315381,
-0.0049879379,
-0.0074624657,
-0.010763308,
0.0233154632,
-0.0402057394,
0.0271948073,
0.0258798599,
0.0625174567,
0.0260768384,
-0.067401588,
0.0328884199,
0.0587130152,
0.0499439538,
-0.0286696255,
0.0242110454,
-0.0158268549,
0.025891304,
-0.0022749349,
-0.0397849791,
-0.0217818581,
0.0217390768,
0.0057143886,
-0.0392998718,
0.0332650132,
-0.0003208287,
-0.013685233,
0.0285550579,
-0.0514569543,
-0.004056077,
-0.0047210068,
0.0337268971,
0.0277173277,
-0.0187885482,
-0.0337570868,
0.0152820423,
0.0211138353,
0.0355437174,
0.0003514776,
0.0676711425,
0.0305207502,
-0.0103175761,
-0.0148143955,
0.0370444097,
-0.0564384274,
-0.0817813873,
-0.0004069487,
0.022789998,
0.0604037307,
0.0094494438,
0.0108390776,
-0.0069000917,
-0.0206827614,
-0.0420029089,
0.0080153681,
0.0645343661,
-0.0467961989,
0.0455372669,
0.0318449996,
0.0051951855,
-0.0121207228,
0.0418688692,
-0.0409827866,
0.0141177699,
-0.0068596862,
0.0087021142,
-0.0364348628,
-0.0249369293,
-0.0221618433,
0.005976005,
-0.0453274399,
-0.0229306836,
-0.0652248114,
-0.0535530597,
0.0059951232,
0.0408288576,
-0.0070939017,
0.017216336,
0.0432983451,
0.0627821237,
-0.0041659577,
-0.0308365319,
-0.0288740098,
0.0116892187,
-0.0137040187,
-0.016948672,
-0.0224803798,
-6.574113053e-33,
-0.0443718247,
-0.0337641798,
0.0224681962,
-0.0375134014,
0.001406285,
0.0198076013,
-0.0500301868,
0.0307597984,
-0.0167063884,
-0.0102573577,
-0.0256167892,
-0.0343556255,
0.0245035719,
0.0080313068,
0.0230895113,
-0.0145503543,
0.0336551033,
0.0230387077,
-0.0625290349,
0.0044881948,
0.0032257733,
-0.014065356,
0.0143340407,
-0.0365789682,
0.0606102794,
-0.0134290094,
-0.0143422261,
0.0291777607,
-0.0339657925,
0.0683147833,
-0.0222073775,
0.0521537438,
0.0133041032,
-0.0706111863,
-0.0204193369,
0.0522560999,
-0.0533710681,
-0.0556189157,
0.0202229153,
-0.0070196651,
-0.0678590238,
-0.0172481257,
-0.0187713541,
-0.0137370536,
-0.0506311506,
0.0022745184,
0.0150919491,
-0.0064091426,
-0.0258644298,
0.0243386477,
-0.0422028676,
0.0032345355,
-0.0030582035,
-0.0282132719,
0.0084189866,
0.0523586608,
0.0031451297,
0.015973052,
-0.0262920391,
0.0223688334,
0.0175830107,
0.0370509028,
0.071031265,
0.0469610803,
-0.0147092026,
0.0355058052,
0.0319854356,
0.006744165,
0.0030420586,
-0.0187128391,
0.010981448,
0.013788987,
0.0743743628,
0.0192703716,
-0.0091059832,
-0.0018210115,
-0.0335898511,
0.0303441323,
0.0493699759,
-0.005185917,
0.024454562,
-0.0016959085,
-0.0239512827,
-0.023301268,
-0.0825075582,
0.0142731415,
-0.0506400578,
-0.0134991426,
0.0568367094,
-0.0228066538,
-0.0301544741,
-0.0089149605,
0.044242043,
-0.0102434354,
-0.0305267051,
0.0100923851,
0.0106110582,
0.0381470211,
-0.0051024165,
0.0344175249,
-0.0309971329,
0.000572448,
0.0011032028,
-0.0181984417,
0.0279728808,
0.0108086541,
0.0000543391,
0.0098762624,
-0.0640374124,
0.0108129913,
-0.0449799635,
0.0254580937,
0.00335269,
-0.0326776765,
0.0383956358,
-0.0169408936,
-0.0076280674,
0.0736587271,
-0.002970516,
-0.0261326618,
-0.0200584456,
0.010750643,
0.0034898026,
-0.0032407059,
-0.004171507,
0.0156637598,
-0.0235432666,
0.0365834795,
-0.0122672534,
0.0069482657,
-0.0007694731,
0.004979718,
2.876e-7,
0.0341537632,
0.0134331165,
0.0200524163,
0.0333239995,
0.0149046872,
0.0423654206,
-0.0127462056,
0.0021275147,
0.0218940787,
-0.0307513028,
-0.0304675642,
0.0243987292,
0.0347245485,
0.0307173748,
-0.0880110338,
0.0159105994,
-0.0648057088,
0.0192940645,
-0.0642392412,
0.035354279,
0.0435291119,
0.0538799912,
0.0188664272,
-0.0200959686,
-0.0067303181,
-0.0113921575,
0.0196079388,
-0.0321165659,
0.0047586029,
0.0352358632,
0.0471796766,
-0.0380202234,
0.0074711437,
0.038564261,
0.0097973067,
-0.0128460079,
0.0122996289,
0.0674049929,
0.0121420221,
-0.0119167482,
-0.0399031043,
-0.0212973654,
0.0183419809,
-0.095019497,
0.0888074487,
-0.0027972695,
-0.020921817,
-0.0576633327,
-0.001498235,
-0.0270501766,
0.0368935093,
-0.0171896107,
-0.0177860819,
0.0147995343,
0.020120034,
0.0138450796,
-0.0384532213,
-0.0597278625,
-0.0513196848,
-0.0058017806,
-0.0394973904,
-0.0369815826,
-0.0517184138,
0.0032678063,
-0.0029127642,
-0.107314676,
-0.0042777089,
2.68660267e-34,
0.0113305254,
-0.0099065686,
0.0470837429,
0.01711132,
0.0193045605,
0.0094373161,
-0.0046028988,
0.0182967279,
0.0261470992,
-0.0718908682,
-0.0370796509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02392v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02392v2 | DeLLMa: A Framework for Decision Making Under Uncertainty with Large Language Models | 2024-02-04T08:11:45 | 2024-06-09T05:04:13 | Ollie Liu, Deqing Fu, Dani Yogatama, Willie Neiswanger | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The potential of large language models (LLMs) as decision support tools is
increasingly being explored in fields such as business, engineering, and
medicine, which often face challenging tasks of decision-making under
uncertainty. In this paper, we show that directly prompting LLMs on these types
of decision-making problems can yield poor results, especially as the problem
complexity increases. To aid in these tasks, we propose DeLLMa (Decision-making
Large Language Model assistant), a framework designed to enhance
decision-making accuracy in uncertain environments. DeLLMa involves a
multi-step scaffolding procedure, drawing upon principles from decision theory
and utility theory, to provide a rational and human-auditable decision-making
process. We validate our framework on multiple realistic decision-making
environments, demonstrating that DeLLMa can consistently enhance the
decision-making performance of leading language models, and achieve up to a 40%
increase in accuracy over competing methods. | [
0.0084541691,
0.1022896543,
-0.0143566476,
-0.0086600631,
-0.0332785845,
-0.0068437303,
0.0066043753,
0.0174013991,
-0.0189806037,
-0.0223228503,
-0.0012406841,
-0.0435436442,
0.0076865009,
0.0609114431,
-0.0082596671,
-0.0199028794,
0.0127520096,
-0.0712320283,
0.0667022318,
-0.0176165085,
-0.0094323484,
-0.0267798286,
-0.0021616332,
0.0317698307,
-0.0013479152,
0.0007017456,
0.0074200141,
-0.0254855957,
0.0233253725,
-0.0517306812,
-0.0033052606,
0.0591172017,
0.03140416,
0.0225683376,
0.0000022894,
-0.0649357513,
-0.0284547526,
-0.01432506,
-0.0543135628,
0.0442046598,
0.0522294827,
0.0082777077,
-0.0140926549,
0.0146161309,
-0.031047035,
0.0118501661,
0.0304781981,
0.0135631002,
0.0204044618,
0.0188973751,
-0.0110619273,
-0.0018439225,
-0.0124906749,
-0.0601843968,
-0.0575427674,
-0.0778850317,
0.0309544411,
0.0150169078,
0.0431834124,
0.0001034168,
-0.001406674,
0.0378073975,
-0.0005194729,
-0.0323427469,
-0.0352961197,
0.0295185968,
0.0162360594,
-0.0162022896,
-0.019825764,
0.0411247462,
0.011025548,
0.0212956145,
-0.0127180442,
-0.0283755511,
0.0083442936,
0.0108786626,
-0.0238667056,
0.0122235706,
-0.0035551023,
0.0330429897,
-0.0179392584,
0.0267855804,
0.0222047642,
0.0372238196,
-0.0370573364,
0.1081304997,
-0.034545932,
-0.0007532119,
0.0387541279,
0.0397673212,
-0.0120528266,
-0.0631343499,
0.0129875019,
0.0483577214,
-0.0936187804,
0.0187974703,
0.019011803,
0.0272661578,
0.0319974534,
-0.0614276938,
0.0161025357,
0.0222966727,
0.0268643815,
0.0353395827,
-0.0072020753,
0.0315972045,
-0.0219758227,
-0.0307519194,
-0.0325810835,
0.0413076468,
0.0149104688,
0.0057758247,
-0.0201533176,
-0.0061489409,
-0.0628850311,
0.000729738,
-0.0923772752,
-0.006768947,
-0.0722925961,
0.0569294728,
0.0045939907,
0.0307902303,
0.0158101749,
-0.0448061414,
-0.0784225687,
-0.010027715,
-0.01113379,
0.0670729205,
-0.0073333536,
-0.0012454753,
0.0451094285,
0.0182990674,
-0.0349250324,
0.0022579441,
0.0038908047,
0.0919438377,
-0.0187297296,
0.0051830984,
-0.03605555,
-0.0181527063,
-0.0159367062,
-0.0796976984,
-0.0657411665,
-0.0747838467,
-0.0085602673,
0.0102632241,
-0.0004824518,
-0.0559875704,
0.0216713138,
-0.0136801898,
-0.0081400629,
0.0725635812,
-0.0157004502,
0.0157655422,
0.0276021287,
0.0079474309,
0.0060015647,
0.060272567,
0.0256145541,
0.0412830859,
0.0140129942,
-0.0017269969,
0.0173415188,
0.0178332068,
-0.0302075446,
0.0207115449,
-0.0815082043,
0.0151764592,
-0.0310561191,
0.01314737,
-0.029847376,
0.0348345451,
-0.0118804751,
0.0175383836,
0.0468802564,
0.0108673768,
0.0390269943,
-0.0155967278,
-0.0105154254,
0.0126283458,
-0.000258383,
-0.0547562242,
-0.0134608354,
0.0200120471,
-0.0143742636,
-0.0032957981,
-0.0054930309,
0.0208430775,
0.001084258,
-0.0528585277,
-0.0251121037,
-0.0315561369,
0.0337621458,
0.012067752,
0.0479200035,
-0.0730313808,
-0.017053334,
0.0050692922,
0.0386512801,
0.0174541399,
-0.0567538291,
-0.0794229433,
0.0495390557,
0.0921667665,
0.0251660161,
-0.053257484,
-0.010714408,
-0.0221001953,
-0.0169808958,
0.0148077747,
0.0263017975,
-0.0112617668,
-0.0319253653,
-0.0487374663,
-0.0099650687,
0.0439687707,
0.0415078625,
0.0398178585,
0.0362645127,
0.0551322103,
-0.0119530205,
0.0120577533,
-0.038024839,
-0.006907627,
0.0022980021,
-0.0278596524,
0.0181585494,
-0.0074956189,
0.0404385738,
-0.0103771696,
-0.0039448398,
0.044596903,
-0.0076141316,
0.0035708146,
-0.0526539274,
-0.0094054779,
0.0173341855,
0.0609646887,
0.0354006365,
0.0298956577,
-0.0052190726,
-0.0461828262,
-0.0213430505,
-0.0167212877,
0.0153966965,
-0.0289098192,
0.0012600491,
-0.005437776,
0.037984699,
-0.0481929593,
0.0060424684,
-0.0595185906,
0.0610151738,
-0.0038873623,
0.0031944832,
0.0219934564,
0.0139448997,
-0.0075021638,
-0.0369774923,
0.012456865,
0.0292171575,
0.0312059168,
0.0525590815,
0.0201550331,
0.0365641601,
0.0049929526,
-0.0267378706,
-0.0470462404,
-0.0306530595,
0.0258734953,
0.0182352271,
-0.0430618562,
-0.0433977097,
-0.0176176317,
-0.0075776107,
-0.0198425315,
0.0225971211,
0.0064382032,
0.0340770632,
0.0239745788,
0.0182728134,
-0.0217553601,
-0.055000592,
-0.0309741665,
-0.0000171072,
0.0318251774,
0.0364814997,
-0.0216305144,
-0.0818725005,
0.0433176383,
-0.0269828718,
0.0068965461,
-0.0016668164,
-0.0080766929,
0.0047678794,
-0.0068371883,
0.0423123054,
0.0119189145,
-0.0141245294,
0.0384375006,
0.095030956,
-0.0076797917,
-0.0647085011,
-0.0043554991,
-0.0170461982,
0.0024286478,
0.004063163,
-0.0340170562,
-0.00882251,
0.0550079644,
-0.0234959535,
0.0037703644,
-0.0298765488,
0.0413176678,
-0.0533694252,
0.0001009474,
-0.0482041426,
-0.023532467,
0.0049787313,
0.1428658366,
0.0457100943,
-0.0455569029,
0.0935472175,
-0.0021514043,
0.0278097317,
-0.0311095044,
-0.0476334393,
-0.053262841,
0.0017867492,
-0.0319060944,
0.0064093131,
-0.0376903638,
0.004745516,
-0.0092886817,
-0.0410387591,
0.0356542617,
-0.0457808189,
0.0786208957,
-0.0801931545,
0.0235370211,
-0.0073088156,
-0.0304573122,
-0.0141370604,
-0.0044098273,
-0.0836513191,
-0.021357812,
0.066626586,
-0.0448316224,
-0.0554314665,
0.0231194627,
0.0336801298,
0.0410729982,
-0.0286985449,
-0.0073277219,
0.0060111363,
-0.0268973131,
0.0110195931,
0.0134917963,
0.0997704491,
-0.0187045466,
0.0324407443,
0.0245434325,
0.0039030425,
0.0049025598,
-0.0176318418,
0.0026042566,
0.021925455,
-0.0049403454,
-0.0010258586,
0.0555569828,
0.0012838835,
-0.0481086485,
0.0049987016,
0.0802901611,
0.0172515474,
-0.047561653,
0.0129390992,
-0.0899487883,
0.0177980829,
0.0037749803,
0.0460679419,
-0.0720409527,
-0.0192953292,
-0.0087819668,
0.016266698,
-0.0218614116,
-0.0207749475,
0.0070466311,
-0.0877870992,
0.0799842998,
0.0064767613,
-0.0078228209,
-0.0124958111,
-0.0432121158,
0.0085827122,
-0.0388867669,
0.026474677,
-0.0036831277,
-0.0037275113,
-0.0218351651,
0.0030571632,
-0.0458232835,
-0.0517279506,
0.0206298567,
-0.0198220573,
0.0152105028,
0.029305635,
0.0099396501,
-0.0148579553,
-0.0093613947,
0.0253035873,
0.0264212657,
-0.015491114,
-0.0029285224,
0.0117333746,
0.0593810081,
-0.0163086019,
-0.0315443799,
0.0005208157,
-0.0075699124,
-0.024183739,
0.0152781382,
0.0799065679,
-0.0229319166,
-0.0238215383,
0.0069396789,
0.0141659463,
0.0236764923,
0.0306938309,
-0.022022292,
-0.0603350513,
-0.0459488221,
-0.0742584541,
-0.0158163346,
-0.0098834308,
-0.0306786057,
0.037800394,
-0.0099656098,
-0.0405692272,
-0.0250404626,
-0.0088368114,
0.0393792465,
0.0174246058,
0.0198795609,
-0.0005875732,
0.0586656034,
0.0106740091,
-0.015323679,
0.0298427623,
-0.0161868092,
0.0728406608,
-0.0667986423,
0.0434089899,
0.037294209,
0.0018270948,
-0.0302316789,
0.0264133718,
0.0003992348,
-0.0666311681,
-0.0011566044,
0.0524549,
0.04421027,
-0.0511586666,
-0.0200447217,
-0.0438918248,
0.0186599996,
0.0318683386,
-0.0186747666,
-0.0197801869,
0.0383200161,
0.0418173671,
-0.0144552831,
0.0311962347,
-0.0035729005,
0.0021822415,
-0.0116810575,
0.0187435169,
-0.0596425012,
-0.0641429946,
0.0036688372,
0.0209830645,
-0.0143906828,
-0.0183622185,
-0.0025020859,
-0.0299882479,
0.013298572,
-0.0068641361,
-0.0182928853,
-0.0067537972,
-0.0231816992,
0.0226905942,
-0.0434933268,
0.0238584988,
-0.0151171936,
-0.0090809939,
-0.0444203392,
0.009823449,
0.0597503595,
0.0103624053,
0.0243534353,
0.1008018255,
-0.018499773,
0.0100129303,
0.0005840926,
-0.0163942855,
0.0342716835,
0.0277098045,
0.0346737467,
0.004115623,
-0.0312033333,
-0.0327254161,
0.0059216395,
0.0085503319,
-0.1110630706,
0.0045222063,
0.0225919895,
0.017632233,
0.0141126411,
0.0311192218,
-0.0652510822,
-0.0064627687,
-0.0214420166,
-0.0121266358,
0.0050467402,
0.0128144007,
0.0318818837,
0.0237788633,
-0.0331275463,
-0.0027905533,
0.0729066208,
0.0104085365,
0.0187526308,
-0.0707292706,
-0.0646554753,
-0.0427536145,
-0.0666555539,
-0.0147776967,
0.0071122725,
-0.0633545667,
-0.01622192,
-0.1099134907,
-0.0340567417,
-0.0145560512,
0.0261267126,
-0.0376511104,
-0.0489717983,
-0.0065587568,
0.0350692794,
0.0262884628,
0.0447212644,
-0.0380810797,
0.0132512646,
-0.0194699988,
0.0177131742,
-0.0312803127,
-6.430156137e-33,
0.0234292168,
-0.0489548594,
0.0218141675,
-0.0550786518,
0.0283066016,
-0.0180682428,
-0.0185372885,
0.0688620433,
0.0120740552,
0.0358916186,
0.0003713859,
-0.0059884735,
0.0225981381,
-0.0167302787,
0.0582814626,
-0.010049792,
0.0056238323,
0.0349518918,
-0.0226984397,
-0.026694376,
0.0178493094,
-0.0132190986,
0.0245493371,
-0.0616956577,
0.0309148692,
0.0469350219,
-0.0372928232,
0.0245161895,
-0.0412304103,
0.054612603,
-0.0142159043,
0.0340597816,
0.0007603297,
-0.0637680665,
-0.0092376042,
0.0317987725,
0.012537729,
-0.0090493485,
0.0039773267,
0.0091265868,
0.010476931,
-0.0221720506,
-0.01477951,
0.0340824686,
-0.0579428598,
0.0648080185,
-0.0154447751,
-0.0598784573,
-0.0127618331,
0.0064830738,
-0.0456428044,
0.0348703489,
0.0010751671,
0.0052545965,
0.0185434148,
0.0763841569,
-0.0492084622,
0.0076270327,
-0.0179967228,
0.0424418673,
0.0513570532,
-0.0007162818,
0.0590889044,
-0.0210688319,
-0.0388434753,
0.0380725823,
-0.0250336193,
-0.0340792723,
-0.041789405,
-0.0333384052,
-0.0331890769,
0.0789306238,
0.0448466316,
0.0422327965,
-0.0300465617,
-0.0135176582,
-0.0804019198,
0.0491377264,
0.0108651789,
0.0546133742,
0.0463280976,
0.0246772449,
-0.0394255482,
-0.0603914261,
-0.017930286,
-0.0113339778,
-0.0393989384,
-0.0027191925,
0.0040771822,
0.0132574355,
-0.0298011582,
0.0346913412,
0.0166710652,
-0.0175416283,
-0.0690907612,
-0.0057905838,
0.0018946913,
0.0369751863,
-0.0029602605,
0.027404977,
-0.0390654914,
-0.0157557409,
-0.0331405252,
0.0052656601,
0.0062400862,
0.0116543891,
-0.0022041958,
-0.0252370983,
-0.0513980687,
0.0372924693,
-0.0142944679,
0.0256518666,
0.0150035415,
-0.0000789757,
0.0273307413,
-0.0178424064,
0.0037108965,
0.0534757636,
-0.0050008083,
-0.0203300621,
0.0149280867,
-0.0079919202,
-0.0174735654,
0.034766607,
-0.0156672988,
-0.014604114,
-0.0464977287,
0.036487598,
0.0469457544,
-0.0163623281,
-0.0006627819,
0.0009101243,
2.922e-7,
0.0373010114,
0.0846724361,
-0.0156256016,
0.0140191773,
0.0157623328,
0.070008263,
-0.0363269299,
-0.0425296724,
-0.0156195015,
0.003568517,
0.0327274278,
0.0055059083,
0.0373472273,
0.0628530979,
-0.0068893824,
-0.0458329283,
-0.0587213002,
0.0170337763,
-0.0451803282,
-0.031582009,
0.0369055234,
0.0661741197,
0.0136049408,
-0.0233200546,
-0.0043453071,
-0.0145469792,
0.035720747,
-0.0841594115,
-0.0091235284,
0.0311299637,
0.0371153876,
0.0069623259,
0.0030748739,
0.0403809659,
0.0088852243,
0.0046537006,
-0.0191228036,
0.0936776251,
0.0217864811,
0.0286621358,
0.0094582196,
-0.0161709879,
0.0227348432,
-0.0379583836,
0.036902789,
-0.0627140924,
-0.0643566251,
-0.0347826369,
0.0319634117,
-0.0266360976,
0.0635421649,
-0.0290638991,
-0.0109118242,
0.0035405937,
-0.0207837913,
0.0224412046,
0.0102677057,
-0.026389705,
-0.0264580939,
0.0769108459,
-0.0423440188,
-0.0209756419,
-0.0235050805,
0.0428474881,
0.0420772173,
-0.0746827945,
0.0454028733,
2.567627948e-34,
0.0599215478,
0.0140434075,
-0.0200566743,
0.0330062993,
0.0497864634,
0.0393398926,
-0.0198517162,
0.0264016166,
0.033361312,
-0.0387144051,
-0.0099268463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02389v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02389v2 | KICGPT: Large Language Model with Knowledge in Context for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-02-04T08:01:07 | 2024-02-23T09:01:44 | Yanbin Wei, Qiushi Huang, James T. Kwok, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) is crucial for addressing knowledge graph
incompleteness and supporting downstream applications. Many models have been
proposed for KGC. They can be categorized into two main classes: triple-based
and text-based approaches. Triple-based methods struggle with long-tail
entities due to limited structural information and imbalanced entity
distributions. Text-based methods alleviate this issue but require costly
training for language models and specific finetuning for knowledge graphs,
which limits their efficiency. To alleviate these limitations, in this paper,
we propose KICGPT, a framework that integrates a large language model (LLM) and
a triple-based KGC retriever. It alleviates the long-tail problem without
incurring additional training overhead. KICGPT uses an in-context learning
strategy called Knowledge Prompt, which encodes structural knowledge into
demonstrations to guide the LLM. Empirical results on benchmark datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of KICGPT with smaller training overhead and no
finetuning. | [
0.0626362115,
0.0268165767,
0.0033002933,
0.0594129264,
-0.0053164843,
0.0017045788,
-0.0691918731,
0.02160131,
0.0913595706,
-0.0309422109,
0.0204442255,
0.0138022853,
-0.0056081284,
0.0133014489,
0.0252398141,
-0.0146453623,
0.0154194664,
0.000709525,
0.012330126,
-0.0295998752,
-0.0198275261,
0.0479580984,
0.0155593203,
-0.0057831518,
-0.0079033347,
0.0059599215,
0.0111488821,
0.0070906198,
-0.0216007419,
-0.0213255435,
0.0125321951,
-0.0072258827,
0.0004506164,
-0.0259142071,
0.0000020708,
-0.0461370237,
-0.0135053536,
0.0256842002,
-0.0345052853,
-0.0165341403,
0.0153408032,
-0.0185494237,
0.0321684517,
0.001907474,
-0.0498049185,
0.0201266259,
0.003629202,
0.0489454754,
-0.0023651388,
0.0458698831,
0.0049702302,
-0.029576607,
0.0308781881,
-0.0459738187,
0.0074725724,
-0.0293987766,
0.0612334535,
0.0198541209,
0.0454903208,
0.01991974,
-0.0129897436,
0.0389968455,
0.0103828534,
0.0233003888,
0.0103007695,
0.0330888145,
-0.0283779949,
0.0256223399,
0.0264466088,
0.0765260458,
0.0086816773,
0.0244967528,
0.0136330463,
-0.007766407,
0.0130926473,
0.0190004278,
-0.0303275753,
-0.0238153674,
-0.0233357809,
-0.0018744209,
-0.0291714966,
-0.0414108895,
0.0422669537,
0.0005714788,
-0.0306336936,
0.072818011,
-0.0042781122,
-0.0211691912,
0.0159346461,
0.0295282826,
-0.0250817779,
-0.0315643921,
-0.0121177901,
0.0250117667,
-0.0282401592,
0.0559003167,
0.0039795944,
0.0209153965,
0.0299560037,
-0.0213210341,
-0.0512172431,
0.0131572075,
-0.0052336343,
0.0677893162,
-0.061328847,
-0.0020472275,
-0.0020027009,
0.0028753874,
-0.0353269354,
-0.0519406423,
-0.0482350811,
-0.0008975876,
-0.0315062813,
0.0566851608,
-0.0206113122,
-0.0265042,
-0.0252270959,
0.0427327491,
-0.0262780469,
0.065365456,
0.0409532562,
-0.0010382625,
0.0019130147,
-0.0324962437,
-0.0280768145,
0.0401114449,
-0.0117245335,
0.0186292287,
-0.0273083355,
0.0075821881,
-0.0067530745,
-0.0274761058,
0.0178098194,
-0.0548375621,
0.0304897334,
0.0292447321,
0.0189181045,
-0.0575700365,
-0.0615171902,
-0.0457655266,
-0.00916427,
-0.0755217969,
-0.0365050025,
-0.086340256,
0.0685768947,
0.0401882194,
-0.0024161404,
-0.0445133932,
0.0358094499,
-0.0152246449,
-0.0708262697,
0.0359296985,
-0.0363620706,
0.0031760877,
-0.0049499152,
0.0069000819,
-0.0237819199,
0.0553169362,
-0.0083821891,
0.0004647571,
0.0444193743,
0.0130069703,
-0.0528567508,
0.0267305933,
0.064361386,
0.0181208067,
0.0132466517,
0.0351012684,
-0.0004888314,
0.0152864046,
0.0109164082,
0.0378607847,
-0.0173434243,
0.0194322355,
0.0276550241,
0.0025592144,
0.006242583,
-0.0140958494,
0.0380949266,
0.0011190335,
-0.0126950536,
0.006144301,
-0.0382284187,
-0.0130249793,
-0.0651839748,
0.0519792251,
0.0314345993,
0.0284995269,
-0.0103077115,
0.0025289464,
0.0310042072,
-0.0236256272,
0.0416700207,
0.0531003475,
0.0999715924,
0.023061078,
-0.0260879137,
0.0226426143,
0.0622085929,
-0.0081622628,
0.0367734842,
0.021903621,
0.0105757415,
0.0604940839,
0.0490755104,
-0.0286311042,
-0.0055252761,
0.0122813294,
0.0184200797,
-0.0113362893,
0.0013014498,
-0.0399551764,
-0.0123624094,
-0.0236030985,
-0.0599742159,
0.0244298317,
-0.0060363412,
-0.004561034,
0.0556233637,
0.0582941808,
0.0338708945,
-0.0999208093,
0.007235948,
0.0145361777,
-0.0558717474,
0.0212784987,
-0.0116481716,
0.0144989127,
0.0120178917,
0.042992387,
0.011143785,
-0.0125844209,
0.0430559814,
-0.016785644,
-0.0446751267,
-0.0552817695,
0.0102013806,
-0.071391739,
0.0590707213,
0.0171517003,
-0.0082321223,
-0.0195199233,
-0.0338094272,
-0.0457827561,
-0.0204936191,
0.0137036368,
0.0953218937,
-0.0212975349,
0.0063651199,
0.0032633303,
-0.0234759431,
-0.0113345915,
0.0897680372,
0.0009320853,
0.0347475447,
-0.0039648144,
-0.0149901435,
-0.0194308758,
-0.0154535268,
-0.0509940498,
0.0168561768,
0.0224457197,
0.0128843337,
0.0328343734,
-0.0184530765,
-0.0620055422,
-0.0124947159,
-0.1210621819,
0.0374088027,
0.0077698315,
-0.0163247734,
-0.0452752709,
0.0316340365,
0.0112117119,
-0.0088998284,
-0.0005477259,
0.010373001,
-0.0288047604,
0.0274753906,
-0.0101930769,
0.0421056785,
-0.0367723107,
0.0160989035,
-0.0253787003,
0.0025263363,
0.0587990917,
-0.0092070969,
-0.0221849605,
-0.0191719178,
0.0419427194,
-0.0457863025,
0.0299494229,
-0.0358158611,
0.0331200175,
-0.0254299641,
-0.0254800934,
0.0225656666,
0.0143178431,
-0.0106705893,
0.0041227867,
0.0033977353,
0.0062628491,
-0.0697172731,
0.0041709882,
-0.0539081059,
-0.0212159231,
-0.0555041209,
0.0101060672,
-0.0218421593,
-0.0006531786,
0.0116275838,
-0.035524223,
-0.0689571351,
-0.0265447702,
-0.000313137,
0.0202665925,
-0.0475721397,
0.0167429205,
0.0219743084,
-0.0144194392,
-0.0229132734,
0.0161776748,
0.0787868425,
-0.0286378395,
0.0132202776,
0.0350622274,
0.0027647291,
-0.0351068079,
0.0671749488,
0.0079216622,
0.0108226407,
-0.0030107885,
-0.0194143131,
-0.0371134207,
0.0025937157,
0.0182753559,
-0.0279659294,
0.0345311724,
0.0065965797,
0.0421822369,
0.0278125573,
-0.0152605958,
-0.0141855264,
0.004853873,
-0.0320592634,
0.033272665,
0.0092598507,
0.0017491531,
0.0106793847,
-0.0095671061,
0.0136897294,
0.0194091741,
0.0144281844,
-0.0194279496,
-0.0257161297,
0.0129546123,
0.0558868125,
-0.0352101997,
0.0058675357,
-0.0276352093,
0.0025452704,
0.0533833243,
0.0228396337,
-0.0287947413,
0.0252635181,
-0.0131949782,
0.0078560086,
-0.0550659075,
-0.0290396605,
0.0178634934,
0.0033705346,
-0.0416246355,
0.0383258797,
0.1001052931,
-0.0132916048,
-0.0372945778,
-0.0035388609,
0.0270798653,
0.0123984022,
0.0370155685,
0.0215948038,
-0.1067145467,
0.0002817003,
-0.0016559255,
0.0383557044,
0.0424874984,
-0.0713993534,
-0.0033128604,
-0.125549078,
0.022737762,
0.0230218116,
-0.0224069133,
-0.0661257282,
-0.0495814197,
0.0129987272,
0.0052439179,
-0.0276629925,
0.0200112481,
-0.0251224469,
-0.0036222904,
-0.0072726528,
0.0070559965,
-0.065890938,
0.0428541936,
-0.0415673405,
0.0515194796,
-0.020422101,
0.0202196371,
0.0001076868,
0.0189485364,
-0.0112384688,
-0.007466895,
-0.0311782453,
-0.0039139139,
0.0290807169,
-0.0377988145,
0.0017696533,
-0.0063384841,
0.0179584511,
-0.0368466415,
0.0020047782,
0.0209508091,
0.099579826,
0.0219554156,
-0.0210930631,
0.011670039,
-0.0478627197,
0.0236180332,
0.0568198971,
-0.0079381112,
-0.0138554266,
0.0172432512,
0.004073659,
-0.0132046444,
0.0193296801,
0.0028737742,
0.0521693751,
-0.0387524702,
0.0469740666,
-0.0274299607,
-0.0572820082,
0.0806414038,
0.0062179519,
-0.0049291202,
0.0933593661,
0.0157375876,
-0.0185228996,
-0.0541274808,
0.0254741795,
-0.054431241,
0.0271232817,
-0.0378202759,
-0.0034278573,
0.0021398419,
-0.0545589961,
-0.0332233645,
-0.0008321777,
-0.0575485155,
-0.0758680552,
-0.0420941971,
0.0320902653,
0.0053869085,
0.0942683518,
-0.0284094289,
-0.0428712741,
0.0502855107,
0.0562467501,
-0.0455872975,
0.0108283814,
-0.0100963358,
-0.0135136358,
0.0005970767,
0.0485842414,
-0.0891632587,
-0.0295258034,
0.0086251283,
0.0809928179,
-0.0376746915,
-0.0434748605,
0.0197631083,
0.057472989,
0.0042448724,
0.0036155821,
0.0097307721,
-0.0638825521,
0.0216155592,
-0.0153762102,
-0.0318115391,
-0.054051958,
-0.0177930109,
0.0195498038,
-0.0202663876,
0.0094840759,
-0.052915629,
0.0209176466,
0.0518947057,
-0.040972095,
-0.0151409712,
-0.0016844167,
-0.0536094755,
0.1198024526,
-0.0368955098,
-0.0104443217,
0.0401992314,
0.0016126075,
0.0206672139,
-0.0431214198,
0.0236654803,
0.0356385931,
-0.0223533995,
-0.0113188243,
-0.0225530379,
0.0021295573,
-0.0247063544,
-0.0388885252,
0.0584451333,
0.0624007657,
0.0072387047,
0.0249893609,
-0.0366455801,
-0.0198054463,
-0.0282160863,
0.012072389,
-0.0176240094,
-0.0502406061,
0.0289590899,
0.0276486855,
-0.0359712169,
0.0385077931,
0.0721333027,
0.0320523866,
0.0651500076,
-0.0008410428,
-0.0351822525,
-0.0317023657,
-0.0312205497,
0.0304737575,
0.0232337378,
-0.0322645754,
0.0328864083,
-0.0266040694,
-0.0945065394,
0.0094155623,
-0.0434615836,
-0.0963237584,
0.0053188768,
0.0056056515,
0.0473969169,
0.0214439631,
-0.0328958072,
-0.064742364,
-0.018291736,
-0.0227809306,
-0.020887021,
0.0253907125,
-6.261505759e-33,
-0.0346161649,
-0.0434896201,
0.0355928615,
0.0191532932,
-0.02728251,
0.0148715219,
-0.0000050313,
-0.016315382,
-0.0398127548,
0.021996554,
-0.013154407,
0.0092575634,
-0.0022816898,
0.0243558604,
-0.0034841069,
0.0229260866,
0.0195662919,
0.0249287132,
0.0290186498,
0.0199416578,
0.0387606882,
0.0550077409,
0.0544157736,
-0.0838888809,
0.037790671,
-0.0216045417,
0.0209379327,
0.0101098241,
0.0261140708,
0.0383069217,
0.0016789797,
0.0669904575,
0.0178733841,
-0.0199222136,
0.0066441097,
-0.0383484662,
-0.1201926991,
-0.0212541241,
0.0131226676,
0.0240063984,
-0.0034734157,
0.0107260188,
0.0233556051,
-0.0332165025,
0.0711077824,
-0.0360803083,
0.0310964435,
-0.0256755874,
-0.0794891044,
-0.0551116318,
-0.0142225511,
0.0341553688,
0.0280988216,
0.018768806,
0.0068613081,
-0.0260091517,
0.0361988768,
-0.0147567196,
-0.0581136607,
-0.0166119076,
0.0127430679,
-0.0001236191,
-0.0005335935,
0.0053986297,
0.0142209483,
0.0190228466,
-0.0222880226,
0.0346029736,
-0.0349510238,
-0.0051807053,
-0.0029455577,
0.0541338213,
-0.0464636758,
0.0246291216,
-0.0448519923,
-0.0578069761,
-0.0477293655,
-0.0104468744,
0.0137360264,
0.0082649933,
0.0144896833,
-0.0123090632,
-0.0447415411,
-0.0437512323,
-0.0344012901,
0.0001260176,
-0.0197684299,
-0.0381487384,
0.0159440748,
0.013260711,
-0.0020727292,
0.0054131076,
-0.0052781673,
-0.0698102564,
-0.0537553579,
0.0776387528,
0.0129786879,
-0.0027826475,
-0.023680279,
0.0409860909,
-0.0479026251,
-0.0467741378,
0.0061011221,
-0.0628745481,
-0.0235744994,
0.0139005855,
0.030399086,
0.0130919265,
-0.027757328,
-0.0072694011,
-0.0268512145,
0.0242002439,
-0.0054758452,
-0.0151506774,
0.0594480745,
0.0597277731,
0.0143910572,
0.0348279737,
0.0638538674,
-0.0113254162,
-0.0134229437,
0.0141953984,
0.0124960123,
-0.034300372,
-0.0014217416,
0.0027151348,
-0.0301158559,
-0.0068001831,
0.0270649716,
-0.0086684041,
0.0010908626,
0.0099465363,
2.856e-7,
0.0350026228,
0.0042476822,
-0.0179083794,
0.0536985844,
-0.0340138748,
-0.0045919246,
0.0107679442,
0.0116474107,
0.0103532756,
-0.019539265,
0.0461645573,
0.0044202688,
0.0037635879,
0.0349076055,
-0.1272428781,
0.0000035089,
-0.0301376395,
-0.0395505168,
-0.0574505851,
-0.0171679575,
0.0380063206,
0.0444923006,
0.0570161678,
0.0046787886,
-0.0096488902,
-0.0797030851,
0.0789746493,
0.0057238489,
-0.0053990684,
0.0304884799,
0.0146469073,
0.0460099727,
-0.0067025712,
0.0708872527,
0.0016958799,
0.0637765676,
0.0147169987,
0.0464176424,
-0.000519229,
0.0339857079,
0.0130034517,
-0.0324500725,
0.000850767,
-0.043949984,
0.0932808295,
-0.0626436546,
0.0174278524,
0.0182446726,
-0.0477729924,
-0.0562328883,
-0.0272517391,
0.0079963012,
0.0314517096,
0.0084657921,
0.0249405112,
-0.0121812224,
0.0051225838,
-0.0774107426,
0.0168599598,
0.0362361558,
-0.0212335717,
-0.0557525456,
0.0184027553,
-0.0256460421,
-0.0123441396,
-0.0648536682,
0.0268150233,
2.758957103e-34,
0.0336859562,
-0.0002578713,
0.0039972663,
0.0060973163,
0.0464079939,
-0.0317255743,
-0.0114256246,
0.0192301441,
0.0073531298,
-0.0879705995,
-0.0178620107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02388v1 | Solution-oriented Agent-based Models Generation with Verifier-assisted Iterative In-context Learning | 2024-02-04T07:59:06 | 2024-02-04T07:59:06 | Tong Niu, Weihao Zhang, Rong Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | Agent-based models (ABMs) stand as an essential paradigm for proposing and
validating hypothetical solutions or policies aimed at addressing challenges
posed by complex systems and achieving various objectives. This process demands
labor-intensive endeavors and multidisciplinary expertise. Large language
models (LLMs) encapsulating cross-domain knowledge and programming proficiency
could potentially alleviate the difficulty of this process. However, LLMs excel
in handling sequential information, making it challenging for analyzing the
intricate interactions and nonlinear dynamics inherent in ABMs. Additionally,
due to the lack of self-evaluation capability of LLMs, relying solely on LLMs
is insufficient to effectively accomplish this process. In this paper, we
present SAGE, a general solution-oriented ABM generation framework designed for
automatic modeling and generating solutions for targeted problems. Unlike
approaches reliant on expert handcrafting or resource-intensive neural network
training, SAGE establishes a verifier-assisted iterative in-context learning
process employing large language models (LLMs) to leverages their inherent
cross-domain knowledge for tackling intricate demands from diverse domain
scenarios. In SAGE, we introduce an semi-structured conceptual representation
expliciting the intricate structures of ABMs and an objective representation to
guide LLMs in modeling scenarios and proposing hypothetical solutions through
in-context learning. To ensure the model executability and solution
feasibility, SAGE devises a two-level verifier with chain-of-thought prompting
tailored to the complex interactions and non-linear dynamics of ABMs, driving
the iterative generation optimization. Moreover, we construct an evaluation
dataset of solution-oriented ABMs from open sources.It contains practical
models across various domains. | [
0.0129529871,
0.0317040309,
-0.0233544819,
0.0397100225,
-0.0438442156,
-0.035697408,
0.0028164184,
-0.0320643038,
0.0251572784,
-0.0379894525,
0.0211296212,
0.012296332,
-0.0280785859,
0.0744174421,
0.026350731,
-0.0256325658,
0.0247980803,
-0.0442275517,
-0.0119975852,
-0.0040959693,
0.0019525349,
-0.0218936466,
0.0047402093,
0.0480284728,
-0.0011911093,
-0.018120693,
-0.0487394743,
-0.0163196158,
0.0138327451,
-0.034858875,
0.0180991031,
0.0262409206,
0.0555802807,
0.0070660575,
0.0000027943,
-0.0599839799,
-0.0584908202,
0.0168789849,
-0.0350466445,
0.0080003254,
0.051585298,
0.0154677685,
-0.0206423625,
0.0002889803,
-0.0350017063,
0.0137515208,
0.0130921416,
0.0022583194,
0.0774592906,
0.0246096589,
0.0001852901,
-0.0042579151,
0.0055593988,
0.0174254812,
-0.0562945865,
-0.0569090545,
0.0478851981,
0.0205420237,
0.0269131046,
-0.0075414362,
-0.0164292473,
0.0026099146,
0.0281602405,
-0.0034453431,
0.0059184898,
0.0099249789,
0.0536775514,
-0.0137264142,
-0.0316958539,
0.0428265743,
0.0157554392,
-0.0132539896,
-0.0032917876,
-0.0058753998,
0.0108112432,
0.0454186872,
-0.0148598142,
0.0323602371,
-0.0089314003,
-0.0097830705,
0.0052142558,
0.0021828702,
0.0187802427,
0.0157634635,
-0.0657159835,
0.0862870589,
-0.0468682721,
-0.0143375769,
0.0004478888,
-0.0393401124,
0.0117815584,
-0.0576154217,
-0.0080290521,
0.0678246096,
-0.0933178142,
0.0062893531,
0.0142764328,
-0.0062683257,
-0.0062498059,
-0.0551457107,
0.0878606886,
0.0042890809,
0.0392504483,
0.0103616398,
0.0040092906,
0.0365508646,
-0.0506221205,
-0.031298846,
-0.0152224647,
0.0284553524,
-0.0802981108,
-0.0027236112,
-0.0378629453,
0.0302937124,
-0.014806686,
0.0067625432,
-0.0210689232,
0.0469493456,
-0.0721038878,
0.0381378829,
-0.0586602241,
0.022136353,
0.0270876233,
-0.0223836638,
-0.0824903846,
-0.0024622295,
-0.0162309613,
0.0228973553,
0.0192338303,
0.0061478796,
0.0312448684,
0.003987717,
-0.0408471487,
0.0083311033,
0.0174434278,
0.1035987511,
0.0117012132,
0.0390935913,
-0.0490104146,
-0.046735242,
0.0262962636,
-0.0806110874,
-0.0049777948,
-0.1059236601,
-0.0255790222,
-0.0155976173,
-0.0342057012,
-0.0488620438,
0.0044409884,
-0.019401066,
0.0111936424,
0.0756878704,
-0.021669602,
0.0332124643,
0.0230097342,
0.0133612752,
0.0021696084,
0.0586650521,
0.0240099039,
0.0142149227,
0.002672239,
0.0056792651,
0.0288039725,
0.0393250883,
-0.0070865597,
0.001420564,
0.0090274438,
0.0187467244,
0.0183771662,
0.0003566681,
-0.0552958921,
-0.008774884,
-0.0157529879,
0.030739313,
0.0428258181,
0.0377359986,
-0.0042760898,
0.0306169763,
0.0651219711,
0.0415207595,
-0.0169938039,
-0.0377476737,
-0.0005630339,
0.0312177353,
-0.0249812696,
0.00337649,
-0.0671753287,
0.0400427356,
-0.0284564085,
-0.0689476654,
0.0228091311,
0.0153473131,
0.0289686099,
0.0351047181,
0.0624728836,
0.0108138723,
-0.0467935279,
-0.0022145614,
-0.0085396888,
-0.0029597366,
-0.0122642992,
-0.0827497244,
0.0461238101,
0.0885849074,
0.0612240322,
-0.039625708,
-0.0281098299,
-0.0342419669,
0.0375326499,
0.0369691364,
0.019810468,
-0.0331182368,
-0.0562228784,
-0.0190571137,
-0.0502813682,
-0.022393357,
0.0021995909,
0.0417269394,
0.0171603933,
-0.0187782571,
-0.0180696845,
0.0462295488,
-0.0544285625,
0.0385017805,
-0.0859819278,
0.0004461094,
0.0134026837,
0.0172898117,
0.0708044916,
0.0042880876,
-0.0151902754,
0.0439357422,
0.0337068588,
-0.0284421612,
-0.0507340021,
0.0091804154,
-0.0024365583,
0.0519290343,
0.0284028985,
-0.0408282652,
0.0145886252,
-0.0402905047,
-0.0174077768,
-0.0023802056,
0.0291817319,
0.0004694409,
0.0035804848,
-0.0266738161,
0.0331400745,
-0.046873726,
-0.0060922122,
-0.0237882771,
0.0311974753,
0.0220134836,
-0.0562547296,
0.0179167502,
0.0499808863,
0.0182040241,
0.0090850284,
-0.0106454389,
0.0129458401,
-0.0145918513,
0.0501366071,
0.0478701293,
0.0226131752,
-0.0012537951,
-0.0110523263,
-0.0390439779,
0.0126098655,
0.0257426966,
-0.0166977085,
0.0024706034,
-0.0412906408,
0.0026034319,
0.0400755443,
-0.003185245,
0.0491194911,
0.0242833346,
-0.0027969666,
0.020785464,
0.0263666529,
-0.0752668604,
-0.0144660948,
0.0243126471,
-0.0342132375,
0.0436763726,
0.0106016435,
0.00118461,
-0.0697998554,
0.061421115,
-0.0145461755,
0.0098595209,
-0.0114323255,
-0.033466056,
0.035495121,
-0.0176887065,
0.0041115279,
0.0133288736,
-0.0115603982,
0.0588136353,
0.0525870062,
-0.0536678247,
-0.0743094906,
0.023059506,
-0.0415519327,
-0.012215646,
-0.0292940307,
-0.0003772919,
0.0159684662,
0.0473322682,
-0.0214976873,
-0.0003027405,
-0.0324807279,
0.0558231957,
0.0050911219,
-0.0118449396,
-0.0473747924,
-0.0336656682,
0.0113601135,
0.0915506482,
-0.0078602191,
-0.0136057353,
0.0942164063,
0.0078206165,
0.027653886,
-0.014539836,
-0.0292268563,
-0.0374882109,
0.0238556433,
-0.0357789882,
-0.0064654392,
0.0263517424,
0.0619450063,
-0.0510823764,
-0.0209172275,
0.0254000966,
-0.001764801,
0.0193862729,
-0.0470527746,
0.0024487746,
0.0319827721,
-0.02857453,
-0.0486300774,
0.0019903735,
-0.0070334347,
0.053355366,
-0.0429360084,
-0.0044423672,
-0.0274091419,
0.024849873,
0.0284796637,
-0.003917702,
-0.0067038904,
-0.051457759,
-0.037473619,
-0.0453700274,
-0.0101173036,
-0.0165073834,
0.0311566498,
-0.0231391061,
0.0531707518,
0.0043711332,
0.033714436,
-0.0385710858,
-0.0466468073,
0.0094965314,
-0.0158439819,
-0.0116201816,
0.0630727783,
0.0451184362,
-0.0382640883,
-0.0774789304,
-0.0230716635,
0.0604869723,
0.0039769649,
-0.0063198279,
0.024594333,
-0.055110693,
-0.0052454816,
0.0292856768,
0.0731430799,
-0.0636081323,
0.0075876093,
-0.0131260678,
-0.003419674,
-0.0398984738,
-0.0471795276,
-0.0007932276,
-0.09308137,
0.0725563467,
-0.0004307146,
-0.031379275,
0.0017956257,
-0.0438798741,
-0.0240858197,
-0.0242081285,
-0.017003661,
0.0146823386,
0.0156567916,
-0.0385237262,
0.0101263979,
0.004647248,
-0.0494508371,
0.0449232832,
-0.0385626405,
0.0287143476,
0.0736867711,
0.0074335071,
0.0089493208,
0.0131483013,
-0.001581336,
0.0225290731,
0.034678828,
0.0141819352,
-0.0285101589,
0.002299255,
0.0047688638,
-0.0124331769,
0.0291455239,
-0.0716938823,
-0.0648924112,
0.0698243827,
0.0991919339,
-0.0083736377,
-0.0202572308,
-0.0253608655,
0.0097182151,
0.025248725,
0.0290099271,
0.0089196395,
-0.0399426632,
-0.0571357906,
-0.0110703381,
-0.0590121299,
-0.0035358497,
-0.0336915106,
0.0149701033,
-0.0154167367,
-0.0099209836,
-0.0113100056,
-0.0078334399,
0.0186006259,
0.0368126594,
0.0200814866,
-0.0382409729,
0.0834015384,
0.0080841566,
-0.0164445024,
-0.0251104161,
-0.0186984316,
0.0530851632,
-0.0052957744,
-0.0181034748,
0.0296577569,
-0.0382698663,
-0.0149576226,
0.0305668041,
-0.0014100599,
-0.0756150782,
-0.0080702407,
0.08491721,
0.0220910273,
0.0635993779,
-0.0018221762,
0.0015571305,
0.0970322937,
0.0211854801,
-0.0094351349,
-0.017678827,
0.00909355,
0.0147691583,
0.0079514515,
-0.0016785427,
-0.0247482788,
0.0240807906,
0.0384037308,
-0.002662709,
-0.0421151668,
-0.011384449,
0.04134598,
-0.0068450342,
-0.0420512259,
-0.0206950661,
-0.0854771137,
-0.0363468975,
-0.008948924,
-0.0091224145,
-0.0511536598,
-0.040089231,
-0.002745538,
-0.0223579612,
-0.027051853,
0.0804774091,
0.0135899773,
0.0129300049,
0.0173220597,
0.0445138328,
0.0474283174,
0.0018827518,
0.041228395,
0.0364660025,
0.0049811555,
0.019059306,
-0.0178556647,
-0.014819867,
0.0211449079,
0.0086854016,
0.0686068162,
0.018080188,
0.0244690143,
-0.0439918488,
0.0149874603,
-0.0199346375,
-0.0706524327,
-0.0312440246,
0.0487620197,
0.0284177233,
0.0529823676,
-0.0396773368,
-0.0749356151,
0.0062040603,
-0.0065245992,
0.0361866839,
-0.0080264369,
-0.0273009036,
0.0014720517,
0.0460762605,
-0.0133535583,
-0.0288733393,
0.0663908198,
0.0188774895,
0.0305717923,
-0.0277626626,
-0.0447392315,
-0.050011538,
-0.0370367393,
0.0060937316,
0.0075446437,
-0.016383063,
-0.0058897668,
-0.066407375,
-0.047872182,
-0.027562758,
0.0560184456,
-0.0031613919,
0.0050136461,
0.0037171373,
0.0639315993,
0.006736699,
-0.0030101212,
-0.0096445447,
-0.0280682389,
-0.0450439341,
-0.0199709702,
-0.0302926023,
-6.429893855e-33,
-0.0259577166,
-0.0493291132,
0.0797162205,
0.0091063716,
0.0166819189,
-0.0210943632,
-0.0429367237,
-0.0095534073,
0.0090485048,
0.0391503908,
0.0152800344,
-0.0325044021,
0.0088363076,
-0.0278243516,
0.0217442214,
0.026360387,
0.0319354609,
-0.0271571223,
-0.0122237829,
0.0103598544,
0.0082314275,
-0.0085477596,
0.0039438121,
-0.0774577633,
0.0254079252,
-0.0178874396,
-0.0251137391,
0.0453037098,
-0.036858771,
0.0499675348,
-0.0201165155,
0.0491293482,
0.0173609164,
-0.0464907102,
0.003350528,
0.0005014978,
-0.0314294547,
-0.0006839226,
-0.0256723929,
-0.0327205956,
-0.009871779,
-0.036490377,
0.0445228554,
0.0104723014,
-0.0514148884,
0.0138002355,
0.049909912,
-0.0404076166,
0.0444288924,
0.0098839719,
-0.1120971963,
0.0051783831,
-0.0509323068,
-0.0341568775,
-0.0053875097,
0.0445569307,
-0.026299553,
-0.0402430333,
-0.0169468559,
0.0356385969,
0.0246482175,
-0.0551880114,
0.1021206081,
0.0148000941,
0.0298840608,
0.0406374484,
0.0275941622,
0.0483246595,
-0.0290767159,
-0.0321737193,
0.0032588739,
0.073742941,
0.0184153896,
0.0739869773,
-0.0398894884,
0.0013166403,
-0.0734207183,
0.0367050394,
0.0222513713,
0.0448989719,
0.0650372505,
0.0042905286,
-0.0020591444,
-0.039962206,
-0.0141337346,
-0.0232923105,
-0.0119966893,
-0.0321002044,
0.0345439799,
-0.0076194322,
-0.0475771464,
-0.0068549179,
0.0211881232,
-0.0811688155,
-0.0122393835,
0.0048973705,
0.0023650539,
0.0065606176,
0.0036968028,
0.0072771925,
-0.0556321368,
-0.0442796312,
-0.0397269689,
0.014535239,
0.0147529403,
0.0336738862,
-0.0054004653,
0.0191920456,
-0.0012103387,
0.0160900299,
-0.0529753678,
0.0277576912,
0.0485090725,
0.0100745363,
0.005027032,
0.0008456843,
0.0053063841,
0.0353085287,
-0.0065269298,
-0.0572706349,
0.0299281441,
0.045268096,
-0.0240856986,
0.0183551423,
-0.0182934348,
-0.0316292606,
-0.0578345172,
0.0077887499,
0.0331639312,
-0.0070158523,
-0.013304662,
0.0154089537,
3.372e-7,
-0.0120815998,
0.0415951163,
0.0076615806,
0.0120015526,
0.0303910468,
0.0764156878,
-0.0225824974,
-0.0142554976,
-0.0119743338,
-0.0323203839,
0.0307504628,
0.0521965586,
0.034996897,
0.0064480687,
-0.0279674418,
-0.0291136168,
-0.0131763564,
-0.0007910728,
-0.0793771297,
-0.0214773044,
0.047731787,
-0.0076616779,
0.0212906748,
-0.0088798441,
0.0201651752,
-0.0244652256,
0.038365569,
-0.04316191,
0.0129747242,
0.0589011721,
-0.0940979496,
0.0046132132,
0.0158990268,
0.0383305177,
0.0197127424,
0.0221189521,
-0.0501998886,
0.075280346,
0.0128851244,
0.0034194801,
0.0264903139,
-0.0163871516,
0.0120490799,
-0.0529834591,
0.0198250543,
-0.1067077592,
-0.0422190651,
-0.055442255,
-0.0267957188,
-0.0439859107,
-0.015106014,
-0.0197348054,
0.012961071,
-0.0061140233,
-0.038756147,
-0.0108079528,
0.0031735203,
-0.0164778158,
0.0185499657,
-0.014236914,
-0.035183534,
-0.0327955633,
-0.0053413888,
0.0251921974,
0.0514624752,
-0.0396169722,
0.0604615808,
3.418527442e-34,
-0.0008956761,
0.0095283538,
0.0152986804,
0.0489112958,
0.0373784751,
0.0276889615,
-0.0591281913,
0.0356035009,
0.0369326621,
-0.0432160608,
-0.0346172564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02380v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02380v3 | Evaluating Large Language Models in Analysing Classroom Dialogue | 2024-02-04T07:39:06 | 2024-02-23T02:19:09 | Yun Long, Haifeng Luo, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | This study explores the application of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4, in the analysis of classroom dialogue, a crucial research
task for both teaching diagnosis and quality improvement. Recognizing the
knowledge-intensive and labor-intensive nature of traditional qualitative
methods in educational research, this study investigates the potential of LLM
to streamline and enhance the analysis process. The study involves datasets
from a middle school, encompassing classroom dialogues across mathematics and
Chinese classes. These dialogues were manually coded by educational experts and
then analyzed using a customised GPT-4 model. This study focuses on comparing
manual annotations with the outputs of GPT-4 to evaluate its efficacy in
analyzing educational dialogues. Time efficiency, inter-coder agreement, and
inter-coder reliability between human coders and GPT-4 are evaluated. Results
indicate substantial time savings with GPT-4, and a high degree of consistency
in coding between the model and human coders, with some discrepancies in
specific codes. These findings highlight the strong potential of LLM in
teaching evaluation and facilitation. | [
0.047495611,
0.0403052606,
-0.0247793477,
0.0485087,
-0.0117909079,
0.0124455066,
0.0187561847,
-0.0353051834,
-0.0175975505,
-0.0711457208,
-0.0175686236,
-0.0266715121,
0.0091554476,
-0.0084191039,
0.0105866734,
-0.0358410738,
0.0070751803,
-0.0135304146,
0.0282385964,
0.0334562697,
0.0264925677,
0.003972495,
-0.0202744603,
0.0421655588,
-0.0051060892,
-0.039831765,
-0.0213729031,
-0.0325420573,
-0.019626528,
-0.0275107212,
0.0208498407,
0.0824917704,
0.011114046,
0.0471413434,
0.0000023572,
-0.0284354892,
0.0029170604,
0.00708029,
-0.0220508557,
0.0915340334,
0.0108237471,
0.0309213568,
-0.0083320579,
0.0066003464,
-0.0580632128,
-0.0076108761,
0.0430179648,
0.0068166717,
0.0594758205,
0.0040091416,
0.0024444077,
-0.0556980222,
0.0271516796,
0.0284227915,
-0.0327346809,
-0.0360798463,
0.0373123102,
0.108534418,
0.020474555,
0.0282635521,
-0.0594800748,
0.0290709678,
0.0162350889,
-0.0692620501,
-0.0160759781,
-0.0249759443,
-0.0512879975,
-0.0058876602,
0.0143816322,
0.0577674061,
0.0502499491,
0.0198911782,
-0.0084860418,
-0.0179076493,
0.012130348,
0.0262366552,
-0.0886202455,
0.0297131743,
0.0065909121,
0.023769781,
-0.013477114,
0.0012727845,
-0.0297157448,
0.0046291403,
-0.0274826083,
0.0053300434,
-0.0044254512,
-0.0316815637,
-0.033421725,
0.028540818,
-0.0459459201,
-0.0252716355,
-0.0252312142,
0.0360533372,
-0.0020418132,
0.0517683886,
0.0195797626,
0.0078514814,
0.0140909711,
-0.0384473577,
0.0012753686,
0.0533327498,
0.0105137937,
-0.0094898092,
0.0390511043,
0.069652155,
0.0152886575,
-0.0213212054,
-0.0267414767,
0.0338539295,
-0.0894661918,
-0.0186459143,
-0.0279817898,
0.028401209,
0.0158841088,
-0.0207400415,
-0.0388871916,
0.0068870629,
-0.0158981588,
0.0305021778,
-0.0306700319,
-0.06573838,
0.0124114184,
0.0110818744,
-0.0131256729,
0.0762121305,
0.0131993331,
0.0383996069,
-0.0344131738,
-0.0864455029,
0.0411609598,
0.0401869491,
-0.0331865475,
-0.0167278852,
-0.0427298769,
0.0152600119,
-0.0277239718,
0.0076756286,
0.014951068,
-0.0361980051,
-0.020255575,
-0.045216687,
-0.028448889,
-0.0626424849,
-0.0410801508,
0.0128312018,
0.0074253543,
-0.0320668109,
0.0250134468,
-0.0107714459,
0.020362258,
0.0104444679,
-0.0244886298,
0.0468295217,
0.0634343326,
0.0114213433,
0.0407807492,
0.0508017763,
0.0624947399,
-0.079223223,
0.0147656417,
-0.0826283991,
0.0283050779,
0.0510047674,
-0.0068609575,
0.030579336,
-0.025345318,
0.0035634229,
0.0355117619,
0.0325237885,
-0.0448191203,
0.0601195097,
-0.0287599955,
0.0469085276,
0.0229819324,
0.0742552876,
-0.0329059884,
0.0234566182,
0.0172962826,
0.0340018421,
0.0571436994,
0.0049395408,
0.0131615093,
-0.0214342196,
0.0268915575,
-0.0196803547,
0.0566655509,
-0.0060336376,
-0.0029756275,
-0.0751514658,
-0.0420143791,
0.0157996975,
0.0219327305,
0.0194724444,
0.0574067906,
-0.0330804959,
-0.0073877838,
0.0267155301,
-0.008314264,
-0.0441976935,
-0.0038983924,
-0.0651105568,
0.0426947251,
0.0659734085,
0.0314419754,
-0.0029526139,
-0.0325846449,
-0.0262783729,
0.026742015,
0.0392277353,
0.0249258224,
-0.0080446815,
-0.0442318879,
-0.049084276,
-0.0157505125,
-0.0212660413,
0.0153120561,
-0.0189799573,
-0.0122206658,
0.0035706372,
0.0189602785,
0.0094001992,
-0.0733914152,
-0.0016497,
-0.0775752142,
-0.0255357511,
-0.0339837,
-0.029670056,
0.0400877185,
0.0399809219,
-0.0127117084,
0.026297139,
-0.0088142268,
0.0202363562,
0.0242897347,
0.0112627698,
-0.0316666253,
0.0115858195,
0.0448309481,
-0.0339244828,
-0.007807848,
-0.0114421267,
-0.0198282339,
-0.0505373999,
0.0205878504,
-0.0299349651,
0.0314675979,
-0.0096133938,
0.0200018305,
-0.055724714,
-0.0195505433,
-0.031535726,
-0.0056711552,
0.04008656,
0.0244009178,
0.020139819,
0.0288079679,
0.069348529,
-0.0282571372,
-0.0183045864,
0.0428284258,
-0.0070213373,
0.036787726,
0.0136066508,
-0.0092350105,
-0.0342594907,
-0.0416778512,
-0.087338008,
-0.0352741927,
0.0064399154,
0.0110353418,
-0.0058694161,
-0.0437651165,
-0.0137922689,
0.0320586674,
-0.0339229964,
-0.0495945141,
-0.0051236749,
0.0083889477,
-0.0086572962,
0.0093012396,
-0.0185093693,
-0.0290233865,
-0.0145073999,
-0.0203692075,
0.0356849246,
0.0923762992,
-0.0041240253,
-0.0383536108,
0.0362699702,
-0.0237011723,
-0.030196026,
0.0134610245,
-0.0569676645,
0.0475825928,
0.0054787151,
0.0338826887,
0.0329093114,
-0.0105260285,
0.0504921786,
0.0267803352,
-0.089944385,
-0.0520264693,
-0.0285255555,
0.0258140415,
-0.040329963,
-0.0538508333,
-0.0516131148,
-0.0405686833,
0.0671845153,
0.0384460837,
-0.0252460204,
-0.0447726287,
0.0342494324,
-0.0695409924,
0.0237090569,
-0.0277255978,
-0.0682587773,
-0.0292635951,
0.0461792648,
0.0334597565,
-0.0064033912,
0.0214878507,
-0.020631779,
0.0104333051,
-0.0695726126,
0.0077865529,
-0.0223598834,
0.0199664272,
-0.0301145576,
-0.0297542997,
-0.0346949697,
-0.0215383247,
0.0082083484,
-0.0059314384,
0.021407824,
-0.0611634851,
0.0558673888,
-0.0978575125,
0.0078299707,
-0.0189311858,
0.0137806097,
0.0001130007,
0.0129908966,
-0.0293212794,
0.0229281243,
0.0236645341,
-0.0189935677,
0.0432471856,
0.0682847053,
-0.0075878804,
0.0251886025,
-0.044557251,
0.0155722853,
-0.0021442929,
-0.0177608337,
-0.0202663895,
-0.0081785526,
0.004557055,
-0.0296429098,
0.1067395806,
0.028949745,
0.0047680805,
0.0524643101,
-0.027249923,
-0.0320697986,
0.0155250179,
0.046008449,
-0.0640855506,
0.0257747658,
0.0447421819,
-0.0959260464,
-0.0073166024,
0.1077722907,
0.006635318,
-0.0292269196,
-0.0269573536,
-0.0398876779,
-0.0245331507,
-0.0246227179,
-0.0232040398,
-0.0768062174,
0.0072704419,
-0.0241755173,
0.0073199845,
-0.0270114336,
-0.0187686607,
0.0027204491,
-0.104176864,
0.0512474254,
0.021115426,
-0.0250181463,
0.0044108639,
-0.0116871977,
0.0212486535,
-0.0008223963,
0.0452502295,
0.0114943804,
0.0049815876,
0.0260377452,
0.0613962151,
-0.0607424937,
-0.0475881733,
0.0230068453,
0.0383366421,
0.0495129675,
0.015242897,
0.0368256234,
-0.0371043198,
-0.0180597547,
0.0458995141,
0.003795835,
-0.0639356002,
0.0041709552,
-0.0039416514,
0.0301105008,
-0.0027564184,
-0.0108258277,
0.0399030559,
-0.0128047448,
-0.0110460352,
0.0575069338,
0.0783636719,
-0.0177708305,
0.0341505334,
-0.0007227518,
0.0500813834,
-0.010285873,
0.069116421,
0.0611432269,
-0.0452217422,
0.0324325114,
-0.0167445522,
-0.0138115799,
0.0054186955,
-0.047253456,
0.0062011718,
-0.0074690427,
0.0237969719,
-0.0095431078,
-0.0440535471,
0.0606425628,
-0.0085132429,
0.0187317301,
0.0370628983,
0.0373231508,
0.0007815656,
0.004434099,
0.0108905109,
0.0065351939,
0.0120993797,
-0.0679673925,
-0.0030766036,
0.0330668017,
0.0142620374,
0.004749306,
0.0247931741,
-0.055956237,
-0.0644728467,
-0.0046223584,
0.0036117344,
0.0150750754,
-0.0129177356,
0.0522805564,
-0.0228418335,
-0.0645940453,
-0.0293395799,
0.0092630694,
-0.0051316433,
-0.0008995031,
0.0672178119,
0.0052253967,
-0.0201633424,
0.0422067232,
-0.0017757436,
-0.0002124915,
0.0096044363,
-0.0840255022,
-0.0876695216,
0.0046871179,
0.0258552711,
0.0069379159,
-0.0056198663,
-0.0099999905,
-0.0316638164,
-0.0122705931,
-0.0644863322,
-0.0225279108,
-0.0607846193,
0.0063987998,
0.0327298865,
-0.0303529762,
-0.010859591,
-0.0491998307,
-0.051769156,
0.0372751914,
0.0067031644,
0.0600067042,
-0.028890986,
-0.0170541629,
0.0133446287,
-0.003933338,
-0.0135618066,
-0.0042785932,
0.0031142512,
0.0360106751,
0.0268861279,
0.0906833038,
0.0132840928,
0.0165486559,
0.0889469013,
-0.014369905,
0.0292253047,
-0.0590042397,
-0.0179537162,
0.0070658904,
-0.0207500607,
0.0152435889,
0.0345170908,
-0.0309169479,
0.0085224546,
-0.0367652662,
0.0507571995,
-0.0047090081,
-0.0266339872,
0.0544821098,
0.0224353615,
-0.0017027942,
-0.0281324573,
0.0326584317,
0.0046171639,
-0.0032685476,
-0.0012482422,
-0.0132658565,
-0.0163696073,
-0.0120164761,
0.0619522221,
-0.0218565147,
0.0157950819,
0.0136186117,
-0.0724859908,
-0.0292598885,
-0.0535307191,
0.0048000496,
0.0016405653,
-0.02340555,
0.0124858562,
0.0556261763,
-0.0315746255,
0.0051250327,
-0.0425886326,
0.0043006004,
-0.0003797433,
-0.0260541458,
-0.0072198487,
-6.435283497e-33,
-0.0493149497,
-0.0750984848,
0.0342584178,
0.0153995221,
-0.0278650075,
-0.0243309028,
-0.0124165565,
0.0252922643,
-0.0175484028,
0.0181783121,
0.032777492,
0.0271110162,
-0.0096264379,
0.0387839228,
0.0570713058,
0.0162944682,
0.0191616174,
0.0148996273,
0.0062608356,
0.0209849179,
0.0127290338,
-0.0527521595,
0.0533312373,
-0.0475607812,
0.0582700633,
-0.0206306037,
0.0031510668,
0.000847112,
-0.0449884534,
0.0570869371,
-0.0199917071,
0.0353263468,
0.0203765668,
-0.043731533,
-0.0086924369,
0.029818261,
0.0073121195,
-0.0400871001,
0.0418966822,
0.0346273594,
0.0215600561,
-0.0467075482,
0.0170244481,
-0.0250257757,
-0.0405297205,
-0.0198075529,
0.0389276817,
-0.0351573229,
-0.01892698,
0.0028478222,
-0.0610618331,
0.0616849884,
-0.0539517701,
-0.0202877764,
0.0356140323,
0.0402503684,
-0.0307739768,
-0.0439137444,
-0.0289840046,
0.0494899228,
0.0931562781,
0.0090146549,
0.0102318646,
0.0072870473,
0.015376851,
0.0206957981,
0.0158791225,
-0.0086570336,
0.004811632,
-0.0066844048,
0.0433813147,
-0.0054385909,
0.0618759245,
0.0353002511,
-0.0298970547,
-0.0004443747,
-0.0489480272,
-0.026753936,
-0.0046003945,
0.0004928344,
0.0106221186,
-0.0368113853,
-0.0415509231,
-0.06613563,
-0.0440941192,
0.0165289491,
0.0219683889,
-0.0333458707,
0.0264021344,
-0.0741448253,
-0.011387432,
0.0147149619,
0.0658732429,
-0.0149879334,
-0.0243557785,
0.0102576977,
-0.0281353015,
0.055142913,
-0.0371304303,
0.0248298217,
-0.0613320842,
-0.0084668687,
0.0095864814,
-0.0072751623,
0.0210565794,
0.0140066147,
-0.0170368534,
-0.0037279292,
-0.0131396241,
-0.0047849929,
-0.0227257721,
-0.0200693067,
0.0006273323,
-0.039230071,
-0.0218724944,
0.0214622933,
0.0070564211,
0.0792616308,
0.0268471465,
-0.0329611897,
-0.0276756808,
-0.0296030603,
-0.0271307155,
-0.0352983326,
-0.0212126579,
0.0039021748,
-0.0018113586,
0.0217754934,
0.0500773415,
-0.0106800133,
0.0070650349,
-0.0131293312,
3.013e-7,
0.066392526,
0.0735979229,
-0.0028331077,
-0.0426978394,
0.013616153,
0.0026135836,
-0.0178303532,
-0.0458408482,
0.0596784577,
0.0264078714,
0.0380583256,
0.0272484254,
0.061313536,
0.0380228534,
-0.0338352956,
-0.0131206289,
-0.051954899,
-0.0149285393,
-0.0502362885,
0.0312967077,
0.0704527646,
0.0125289196,
-0.0133920377,
0.0277777109,
-0.0656390786,
-0.0105084674,
0.0252445266,
-0.0261373725,
-0.0373468846,
0.0812506303,
0.0196660664,
-0.0216011032,
0.0218086261,
0.0176633131,
0.02084882,
0.0254495349,
0.0189136248,
0.0622311831,
0.017814992,
0.035850089,
0.0158780627,
-0.018802302,
0.0042009,
-0.0553813279,
0.0201518647,
-0.0640080124,
-0.023384396,
0.0370675586,
-0.021063311,
-0.0641048104,
0.044016853,
-0.0306647811,
0.0200949535,
0.0379520319,
-0.0187157765,
-0.0139033711,
0.0506018996,
0.0299313813,
0.0041253017,
-0.017815046,
-0.0577662252,
-0.0558077917,
0.0033367805,
-0.0530600324,
-0.0270496756,
-0.0035210585,
0.0169251263,
2.21192221e-34,
0.0528359525,
-0.0361364707,
0.0415382013,
0.041843988,
0.0370920412,
0.0181198493,
-0.0073650912,
0.0498866327,
0.0399333499,
-0.0546768531,
-0.0046753292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02379v1 | Rethinking the Evaluation of Pre-trained Text-and-Layout Models from an Entity-Centric Perspective | 2024-02-04T07:33:45 | 2024-02-04T07:33:45 | Chong Zhang, Yixi Zhao, Chenshu Yuan, Yi Tu, Ya Guo, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently developed pre-trained text-and-layout models (PTLMs) have shown
remarkable success in multiple information extraction tasks on visually-rich
documents. However, the prevailing evaluation pipeline may not be sufficiently
robust for assessing the information extraction ability of PTLMs, due to
inadequate annotations within the benchmarks. Therefore, we claim the necessary
standards for an ideal benchmark to evaluate the information extraction ability
of PTLMs. We then introduce EC-FUNSD, an entity-centric benckmark designed for
the evaluation of semantic entity recognition and entity linking on
visually-rich documents. This dataset contains diverse formats of document
layouts and annotations of semantic-driven entities and their relations.
Moreover, this dataset disentangles the falsely coupled annotation of segment
and entity that arises from the block-level annotation of FUNSD. Experiment
results demonstrate that state-of-the-art PTLMs exhibit overfitting tendencies
on the prevailing benchmarks, as their performance sharply decrease when the
dataset bias is removed. | [
0.0263786465,
0.002622575,
0.0285769012,
0.0298492592,
0.0240692031,
0.0472190492,
-0.0018540981,
0.0156372897,
0.0093013095,
-0.0566762239,
-0.0521399789,
0.0223844405,
-0.0034547856,
-0.0131788505,
0.0090862066,
-0.0440021679,
-0.0011630739,
-0.0022826127,
0.0018845068,
0.0687029511,
0.0285730064,
-0.0017003148,
0.0076229898,
-0.033335492,
-0.0470869094,
-0.0043749143,
-0.0020883412,
0.0592382625,
0.0468412898,
-0.054275427,
-0.0190235246,
0.0236518327,
0.0086069126,
0.0468125455,
0.0000018098,
-0.0474565886,
-0.036099989,
0.0431363955,
-0.0410432108,
0.013737536,
0.0057744891,
-0.0476423986,
-0.015924409,
-0.0642251074,
-0.0017092855,
-0.0320289247,
0.0335754678,
0.0863449425,
0.0239292625,
0.0770366788,
-0.0349141844,
-0.0391699038,
0.0592552982,
-0.0452656038,
-0.0095168035,
-0.0273790359,
0.0213530716,
-0.0114796134,
-0.0068536196,
-0.0061069033,
-0.0008295489,
0.016046945,
0.0300187748,
0.0094407666,
0.012166244,
0.0271361712,
-0.0175527036,
0.011279623,
-0.0100331195,
0.1063778847,
-0.0024652104,
-0.0036424526,
0.03120666,
-0.0336913988,
-0.0346406549,
-0.0097356271,
-0.0258416012,
-0.0133812549,
-0.0369911678,
-0.0088505251,
-0.0066349967,
0.0409211963,
0.0242331978,
-0.0163324345,
-0.0154704172,
0.0000669232,
0.0036421949,
-0.0199852884,
0.0432851091,
0.0539555028,
-0.007836503,
-0.0501884334,
0.0181811787,
-0.0008220181,
0.0426297486,
0.0241826084,
-0.069113493,
-0.0522678159,
-0.0134149566,
-0.0196665637,
-0.0330118313,
-0.0280071683,
-0.0270655118,
0.0700076297,
-0.076029554,
0.0383145139,
-0.0353326052,
0.070384033,
-0.0000450919,
0.0229095183,
0.021334039,
0.0202534497,
-0.0348390564,
0.0271058567,
-0.0273093339,
-0.0553472564,
0.0126716122,
-0.0022638005,
0.0173601098,
0.0601575449,
-0.0092972098,
-0.0555969067,
-0.0231818873,
-0.0362154394,
-0.0016639961,
-0.0261084288,
-0.0027421147,
-0.0189436991,
-0.0186966117,
-0.0168965869,
0.009880635,
0.007155281,
0.0007285962,
-0.0688944757,
-0.0030287667,
0.0668462217,
0.0068540671,
-0.0792560726,
-0.0606442131,
-0.006083528,
0.0263721067,
-0.0541333407,
0.0416776352,
-0.0223377086,
0.0304382555,
0.0140164662,
-0.014691107,
-0.0226447266,
0.0100313462,
-0.0100910664,
-0.0518135168,
0.06202434,
-0.0382637307,
-0.0041185943,
-0.0030921998,
0.0273216683,
0.0514458828,
0.0820043683,
0.0438907109,
0.0650526211,
0.0560082123,
0.0179192815,
-0.0339467488,
0.0675581917,
0.0238747001,
-0.041820392,
0.0311966147,
0.0472607687,
0.0230337437,
-0.0097164176,
0.0280356538,
0.0267303288,
-0.0513367578,
-0.0341435,
0.0463680923,
0.0100000789,
0.0428409129,
0.0031498377,
0.0429580808,
-0.0219685305,
0.0404674336,
0.0081409439,
-0.0562512018,
-0.0277932584,
-0.0022216865,
0.0423818566,
0.0327859223,
0.021273965,
-0.0149323987,
0.0047719735,
-0.018256221,
-0.0153059196,
0.01320225,
-0.0106119365,
0.084849298,
0.0079338113,
-0.0694469512,
0.0386917926,
0.0080527496,
-0.0253408942,
-0.0307054576,
0.0203228947,
0.0189916864,
0.0347014107,
0.0465976223,
-0.0511448458,
-0.0371507891,
-0.0023694211,
0.0220407862,
0.0363930538,
0.0526011325,
-0.0273692645,
0.0431739651,
-0.0194367748,
-0.0237744041,
-0.0122969979,
-0.0125156501,
-0.0079150107,
0.0537842289,
0.0130608222,
0.02660718,
-0.0505224392,
-0.0050982423,
0.0665517151,
-0.015207109,
-0.0038917442,
-0.0427014865,
0.0211441908,
-0.0239942819,
0.0380274244,
-0.0434833318,
-0.014672664,
0.0207121689,
-0.0087266481,
0.0610675551,
-0.0126630533,
-0.0261826739,
-0.0398107208,
-0.0168144871,
-0.0042454908,
-0.0464537703,
-0.0045738379,
-0.0503474772,
-0.0241225902,
-0.0379678719,
0.0353255942,
0.0416757688,
0.001921061,
0.0054023676,
0.0355378762,
0.0275789406,
-0.0312911868,
0.0476835892,
0.0105097014,
0.0168895107,
0.0117627997,
0.0000186719,
0.0118492423,
-0.0312137753,
-0.0296608005,
-0.0130256824,
-0.0164174587,
-0.0231599938,
0.0027689312,
0.0315835662,
-0.0693883076,
-0.0029900144,
-0.0835329667,
0.0205562543,
-0.0329769179,
0.0491919816,
0.0166523419,
-0.015003751,
-0.0406938754,
-0.0597303696,
-0.0082960343,
0.0008365404,
-0.0303216893,
-0.0025252819,
0.0295703597,
0.0343252793,
0.0145582007,
-0.0410872623,
-0.0287529938,
0.0029566134,
0.0393171124,
0.0536741763,
-0.0499874875,
-0.004137272,
0.0527425408,
0.0146589018,
-0.0098798824,
-0.0108672203,
0.0310572702,
-0.0188630652,
-0.0163490865,
-0.0018656909,
0.0962703004,
-0.0354910977,
0.0583295748,
-0.0495754518,
-0.0135708256,
-0.0310588498,
0.0306714978,
-0.0157194417,
0.0864976943,
-0.0064718067,
-0.0125339702,
0.0309698246,
0.0431272462,
-0.0619564913,
0.0421747938,
-0.0160079058,
-0.0124153299,
0.011082761,
0.0059174886,
-0.0102840206,
0.0013007863,
0.043725431,
0.033922676,
-0.0410625376,
-0.0470050164,
0.0104560368,
-0.0686105192,
-0.0101622939,
0.0225716345,
0.0327988192,
-0.0308324564,
0.0525466725,
0.0607065074,
-0.0071411077,
-0.0128305648,
-0.0300853383,
-0.0297156218,
0.0397519134,
0.0017248535,
-0.0120335184,
0.02452261,
-0.0301275682,
0.0733369589,
-0.0567138195,
-0.0252958946,
-0.0066952407,
-0.0256584659,
-0.0065543847,
-0.0087951627,
0.0027047452,
-0.0007333946,
-0.006621968,
0.0651224852,
-0.0022873478,
0.0957390219,
-0.0055709565,
-0.0281457789,
-0.0060865739,
0.0836787969,
0.0239577796,
-0.0307966731,
0.0436570011,
-0.0340444557,
0.0137890894,
0.0368011743,
-0.0050914916,
-0.0078057572,
-0.0194020756,
0.003444056,
-0.0065797367,
-0.0359460823,
-0.0022055951,
-0.0145342276,
0.0553834625,
-0.0622942634,
-0.0306177326,
0.0979414582,
0.0263204742,
-0.0082181999,
-0.0621950962,
0.0428471416,
0.0211344976,
-0.0143631063,
0.0069071525,
-0.0877541825,
-0.0185097232,
-0.0090910541,
-0.0197466183,
0.0452553742,
-0.0339515619,
0.0074724718,
-0.0829875097,
0.0077064731,
-0.0224780235,
-0.0624303967,
-0.0014845025,
-0.058829613,
0.0134393806,
-0.0468699373,
-0.0244647656,
-0.0273044929,
-0.0219264962,
-0.015683867,
-0.0027106423,
-0.0381555632,
-0.0300680939,
0.0115996841,
-0.035083387,
0.0048091449,
0.0532304794,
0.0116367824,
0.00084135,
0.0162781216,
0.0291783158,
-0.0253585055,
-0.0295068119,
0.0051746168,
0.0854651555,
-0.0620898716,
0.0141226156,
-0.0038617894,
0.0003227358,
0.0009013246,
-0.0230129659,
-0.0191348232,
-0.0027176689,
0.0254279058,
-0.0006685129,
-0.018171804,
-0.025926685,
-0.0116158202,
0.0380504616,
0.0285678543,
-0.016753966,
-0.0811828822,
-0.0202075727,
0.0305669066,
-0.0631208047,
0.0068786326,
0.0153957894,
-0.0794757754,
-0.0365292504,
-0.0906785801,
-0.0481475405,
0.0288274586,
0.0724227577,
0.0007654943,
-0.0412809923,
-0.0439051427,
-0.014035007,
-0.0470321476,
0.0506061912,
0.0042772307,
0.020240644,
-0.0615559146,
0.0036912975,
0.0144811366,
-0.0475129709,
-0.0315516889,
-0.0010047908,
-0.07681261,
-0.0116573954,
0.0001539717,
0.0470928475,
0.0143367928,
0.0579338558,
-0.0224612281,
-0.0168711767,
0.0253437608,
0.0413589589,
-0.0669958517,
-0.0313979462,
0.0157640018,
0.0125693837,
-0.0317928679,
-0.0062354142,
-0.0326316059,
0.0487025641,
0.0731359869,
0.0216788761,
-0.0117218252,
-0.0248765741,
-0.0263877306,
0.0257646125,
0.0684520081,
0.0122249508,
-0.0069321799,
-0.0410810821,
0.034738481,
-0.0033550952,
0.018405417,
-0.0229876693,
-0.0076882383,
0.0058294269,
0.0484142751,
-0.0223042704,
0.0626471788,
0.0610402413,
0.0324265249,
-0.0598532185,
-0.008488805,
0.0146091348,
0.0134729976,
-0.0049152658,
0.0020645342,
0.0086312611,
0.0047483738,
0.0292020738,
0.0622798242,
-0.031550087,
0.048401773,
0.0383126475,
-0.0026555851,
0.022928359,
0.0519922152,
-0.0360900126,
0.0214971621,
-0.0701977462,
0.0177537464,
0.0302256159,
-0.0302779693,
0.0595134273,
-0.015658427,
-0.0223829634,
0.0134835197,
0.0015392795,
0.0194377601,
0.0072758924,
0.0198872909,
0.0213301051,
0.0015379908,
0.0123395091,
0.0319621749,
0.0312217418,
0.0198558085,
0.0110796187,
-0.0160511527,
-0.0485805273,
-0.0108560082,
0.0439556465,
0.0075685042,
-0.0076938937,
-0.0317244753,
-0.0325450785,
-0.0303971916,
0.0311578717,
0.0148748308,
-0.0192719083,
0.0461858548,
0.032380484,
0.0339387134,
0.0434837677,
-0.0027792235,
-0.0139037985,
-0.0264874641,
-0.0096313702,
-0.010866995,
0.0194757022,
-5.751275089e-33,
-0.0680331215,
-0.0072478303,
0.015154345,
-0.0021849326,
-0.0497545004,
0.0282524787,
-0.0288321041,
-0.0406653099,
-0.0277346466,
-0.0019501871,
-0.0113055157,
-0.0178241357,
0.0195167586,
0.0289568342,
-0.0653345808,
-0.0211794879,
0.0375448763,
0.0047231205,
-0.0505636968,
0.0104615912,
0.0128864916,
0.0251238123,
0.0690222159,
-0.0738733485,
0.0016072375,
0.0049183564,
0.0042306636,
-0.0253700018,
0.0463707596,
0.0463493839,
-0.0032033313,
-0.0433895476,
0.023111796,
-0.0483499505,
-0.0122577948,
0.0320438296,
-0.1448501498,
0.006402602,
-0.0053788307,
0.0480832718,
-0.0281449966,
0.0076427804,
0.0240979958,
-0.0098240012,
0.0381080285,
-0.0357157439,
0.0394635759,
-0.0100136884,
-0.0119312163,
-0.046198234,
-0.0709821507,
0.0690729693,
-0.0046722,
0.0315667093,
0.0772023872,
-0.0346976854,
0.0149456905,
0.0261796732,
-0.0903497636,
-0.0255654249,
0.0297918357,
-0.0194206387,
0.035850469,
0.0185834989,
0.0055286703,
0.0470910594,
0.0157182664,
0.006256063,
-0.0214849319,
0.0432671644,
0.0213717762,
0.0556701533,
0.004785432,
0.023838507,
0.0264734197,
0.0299801938,
-0.1052911654,
0.0610423535,
-0.0330635011,
-0.005087134,
-0.0169726685,
-0.0033429661,
-0.043909546,
0.0100703584,
-0.026354786,
-0.0137944436,
-0.0058356808,
-0.0152516896,
0.0480861217,
0.0310702007,
-0.0325657502,
0.0786070302,
0.0459814668,
0.0016186205,
-0.0129043953,
0.0042014159,
-0.0052084085,
0.0643444061,
-0.0241495129,
-0.0463693775,
-0.0833531544,
-0.0437584966,
0.055801101,
-0.0058506927,
0.011199357,
-0.0305173434,
0.0833811387,
-0.0229937714,
-0.0519619323,
0.0106531018,
0.0066377986,
0.0005238583,
-0.0051085101,
0.0084954714,
0.031813316,
-0.0277550276,
-0.0276439395,
0.0462072752,
0.0539823808,
-0.0068652676,
-0.0244578887,
0.0117057171,
0.0130647924,
0.0128056109,
0.0219334438,
-0.0149577772,
0.0075002131,
-0.0337522142,
0.0020644164,
-0.064611949,
0.0134270014,
0.0183154698,
2.398e-7,
0.0566789024,
0.0065505514,
0.06243065,
-0.0248792358,
0.0059167631,
-0.0081324112,
0.0103176283,
0.0260335635,
-0.0444732904,
-0.0099653928,
0.0131590646,
-0.0133168008,
0.0550786667,
0.0079983845,
-0.0486421138,
0.0155010708,
-0.0371059179,
-0.0280221161,
-0.0688976496,
-0.0355484225,
0.02088679,
0.027311163,
-0.0287663713,
-0.0071840566,
-0.0135527058,
-0.0254727639,
0.055655852,
-0.0326253138,
0.0505289212,
0.0406450182,
0.0092013786,
0.0266459938,
-0.0552373379,
0.0541319475,
-0.0133639676,
0.0442828834,
0.082597442,
0.0563878417,
0.0000828011,
0.0230047852,
-0.0175491143,
-0.0427602939,
0.0150394738,
-0.0350329503,
0.0747057423,
-0.0340270922,
-0.0011530508,
0.0186401736,
-0.0551600717,
-0.0246694144,
0.0030943912,
0.0172086265,
0.0156511981,
0.0545462668,
0.0380218662,
-0.0349335745,
-0.0146213723,
-0.0840511993,
0.0115043297,
0.0151851811,
0.0141261201,
-0.0049191071,
-0.0388952307,
0.0060620671,
-0.0105246827,
-0.0608540922,
-0.041244369,
2.339129066e-34,
-0.003554485,
0.0034387405,
-0.0157864299,
0.0309236925,
0.0461611189,
-0.0359236039,
-0.0265982356,
-0.0344537944,
-0.0370480716,
-0.0730795413,
0.0464209057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02370v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02370v2 | AutoTimes: Autoregressive Time Series Forecasters via Large Language Models | 2024-02-04T06:59:21 | 2024-05-23T01:58:28 | Yong Liu, Guo Qin, Xiangdong Huang, Jianmin Wang, Mingsheng Long | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Foundation models of time series have not been fully developed due to the
limited availability of time series corpora and the underexploration of
scalable pre-training. Based on the similar sequential formulation of time
series and natural language, increasing research demonstrates the feasibility
of leveraging large language models (LLM) for time series. Nevertheless, the
inherent autoregressive property and decoder-only architecture of LLMs have not
been fully considered, resulting in insufficient utilization of LLM abilities.
To further exploit the general-purpose token transition and multi-step
generation ability of large language models, we propose AutoTimes to repurpose
LLMs as autoregressive time series forecasters, which independently projects
time series segments into the embedding space and autoregressively generates
future predictions with arbitrary lengths. Compatible with any decoder-only
LLMs, the consequent forecaster exhibits the flexibility of the lookback length
and scalability of the LLM size. Further, we formulate time series as prompts,
extending the context for prediction beyond the lookback window, termed
in-context forecasting. By adopting textual timestamps as position embeddings,
AutoTimes integrates multimodality for multivariate scenarios. Empirically,
AutoTimes achieves state-of-the-art with 0.1% trainable parameters and over 5
times training/inference speedup compared to advanced LLM-based forecasters. | [
-0.0136733791,
0.1179824695,
0.0073750271,
0.0057353494,
-0.0125545273,
0.0221264511,
0.0532636568,
-0.0207772721,
-0.0179108325,
-0.013240587,
0.0211162716,
-0.0328561738,
-0.0111898296,
0.0568954237,
0.0049506263,
-0.0685544237,
0.0461743623,
-0.0351875238,
-0.0026336878,
0.0029392217,
0.0040499372,
-0.0197567828,
0.018518975,
0.04792092,
-0.0411162935,
-0.0050080321,
-0.0547113791,
-0.0367294811,
0.0306023303,
-0.060828086,
-0.0138670001,
-0.0041214908,
0.068380788,
0.0577878319,
0.00000199,
0.00461479,
-0.0166771561,
-0.0196426492,
-0.018923929,
-0.0057392442,
0.0167780425,
-0.0666047856,
0.0353221446,
0.0170578714,
-0.0722493157,
-0.0262786113,
0.0387084223,
0.0244593322,
0.0790471435,
0.0808176026,
-0.0158045534,
-0.0359570868,
0.0367071405,
-0.0478885621,
-0.0118572647,
-0.0584339686,
-0.0021089055,
-0.0478536561,
-0.013031478,
0.0138373598,
-0.0307061318,
0.0472193211,
0.0141812591,
0.0085145356,
0.0029643481,
0.0442197435,
0.0297065061,
0.0005531246,
-0.062943235,
0.0179360528,
0.023157021,
-0.0308629945,
-0.0015829491,
0.0135985054,
-0.0446636789,
0.0301789176,
-0.0727746114,
-0.0048056692,
0.044284828,
0.0511659756,
0.0413746051,
0.0353214182,
0.0227127932,
0.0171489529,
-0.0342294835,
0.0844302103,
-0.0028770072,
-0.0299485624,
-0.0483357571,
0.0155353704,
0.0321299545,
-0.0373449698,
0.004183122,
0.0413010679,
-0.0202389397,
0.0000748494,
-0.0235428438,
-0.0189228319,
-0.0451271497,
-0.0097440789,
0.0440060049,
0.0514053777,
0.0002632017,
0.0154742161,
-0.0057715327,
0.0284774266,
-0.0108712362,
-0.0946707129,
-0.0393001027,
-0.0260846056,
-0.0361408107,
-0.0434046425,
-0.050559435,
-0.034029264,
-0.0166571364,
-0.0111784721,
-0.0466848612,
0.0220024325,
-0.0123979747,
0.0066209198,
0.0315254405,
0.0117879556,
-0.0469640382,
-0.030157188,
-0.0203536022,
0.0263041668,
-0.0270856433,
0.0138000697,
0.0011130593,
-0.0329160988,
-0.0065333997,
0.0108924685,
0.0049655144,
0.0077481051,
-0.0162096173,
0.0654214919,
0.0422338322,
0.0174217355,
-0.0595170148,
-0.0342644192,
-0.0275869798,
-0.0273141116,
0.0089886524,
-0.0059696827,
0.0149753056,
0.0132175572,
0.031641461,
0.0152651137,
-0.0013951132,
0.0026196344,
-0.013510529,
0.0735744312,
0.0129607152,
-0.0018176769,
-0.0094139138,
-0.0384592861,
0.0440735705,
0.0739451796,
0.0487018079,
0.014167632,
0.0411602929,
0.000445487,
-0.0260866024,
0.0352731012,
0.0003139181,
-0.0157285724,
-0.0601377599,
-0.0004118953,
-0.0232213773,
0.0156443734,
0.0314678736,
0.0024228892,
0.0048488919,
-0.0198203046,
0.0412400216,
0.0537637062,
0.0288617667,
0.0209519342,
0.0830133408,
-0.0362370051,
-0.0147591,
-0.0100396192,
0.0059122262,
0.0432631299,
-0.0118520884,
0.0260959659,
0.0050619445,
0.0317657217,
-0.0288866516,
-0.0336842872,
-0.0043132333,
-0.0246274788,
0.0085168555,
-0.0405312926,
0.041446764,
-0.0345815718,
-0.0454438515,
0.0467888452,
0.0141007081,
-0.0126692383,
0.001838645,
-0.0066342326,
0.0130531015,
0.0945698917,
-0.0006129979,
-0.0021870201,
0.0195917226,
-0.0234382674,
0.0424050651,
0.0367775783,
0.0104189394,
-0.0032686598,
-0.015998276,
-0.0548406653,
-0.0396273062,
0.021932248,
0.0166058559,
0.0347465575,
-0.0436153561,
0.063848801,
0.0257063359,
0.0057962262,
0.0206313543,
0.0010544206,
-0.0398933664,
-0.0557267927,
-0.0019315535,
-0.0038342492,
0.0411142781,
0.0034258016,
0.0109154563,
0.0444720015,
0.0282298904,
-0.0598660223,
-0.0248471219,
0.0569855496,
-0.1143068448,
-0.0526182875,
0.0050694603,
0.009407063,
0.027877951,
-0.0114658419,
-0.0468024947,
-0.0686341226,
0.0661878437,
-0.0271309912,
0.0988110229,
-0.054682076,
-0.0148809077,
0.0467209369,
0.0018687793,
0.0138473678,
0.0227183457,
-0.014859804,
-0.0195762999,
0.0024952299,
0.0309295282,
-0.0202195179,
-0.0049931193,
-0.0101612946,
0.0081377188,
0.0257928912,
-0.0043923627,
0.0205019712,
-0.030189326,
-0.0086892368,
-0.0038863055,
-0.0787003636,
-0.0443719998,
-0.0322708189,
0.0161744952,
-0.0062816874,
-0.0203517862,
0.023756437,
-0.0138172843,
-0.010844308,
0.0089468397,
-0.0112628667,
0.0026274966,
0.0288241114,
-0.0064942501,
-0.0075443038,
-0.0095416568,
-0.0171078946,
-0.0279278662,
0.0792779773,
0.0039946265,
-0.0232483223,
-0.0312759206,
-0.0335403793,
-0.0076726726,
-0.0035731974,
-0.0216164328,
-0.0154053634,
-0.0105887931,
-0.0360902809,
0.0469293445,
0.0062268879,
0.0212065093,
0.0407432616,
-0.0071242368,
-0.0710942224,
-0.0358946212,
0.0272574108,
-0.0242724288,
0.0298576858,
-0.0398057662,
0.007713845,
-0.0036064007,
0.0837537721,
-0.0066981688,
0.0113494992,
-0.0601611771,
0.0105742645,
-0.0472047664,
-0.0113510666,
-0.0314806961,
-0.0164336823,
-0.0577122532,
0.0161683243,
0.0021478632,
-0.0805834532,
0.0313848667,
-0.0385196507,
-0.0266540404,
0.0266086422,
-0.0245420579,
-0.0660598278,
0.0234344564,
0.016610682,
0.0005414917,
-0.0085934987,
-0.0136621324,
0.0013060939,
0.0152400741,
-0.009416339,
-0.0139679555,
0.0139069203,
0.0111208828,
0.0085775694,
0.0268058013,
-0.001308361,
-0.0299329832,
-0.0347080864,
-0.067229338,
0.0169593971,
-0.0260568522,
-0.0208758619,
-0.034941759,
0.0561851412,
-0.042589657,
0.0183940493,
-0.0115804272,
-0.0113604087,
0.0254285522,
0.0329067446,
0.0482071117,
-0.0082337009,
-0.0156878475,
-0.0248527862,
0.0462623388,
-0.0160772298,
0.0657746866,
0.0041340701,
-0.0630133152,
0.035350889,
0.0182032175,
-0.0263395384,
-0.0211203154,
0.0160601921,
-0.0131805344,
-0.0640421957,
-0.0102769854,
0.1220823601,
0.0051253298,
-0.0236623157,
0.0090059936,
0.0097789848,
0.0083788373,
-0.0038581092,
-0.0216591172,
-0.0727954879,
-0.0393196344,
0.0269588735,
0.0005618085,
-0.0006289801,
-0.0426787958,
-0.0222915653,
-0.0785792544,
0.0501677766,
0.0356917679,
-0.0280122869,
0.0039385669,
-0.0762164518,
-0.0243837424,
-0.0208273511,
0.0238759853,
0.0012118493,
-0.0246553347,
0.0315257385,
0.0492995083,
-0.0999528915,
-0.0367558822,
-0.0155487694,
0.0142664174,
0.0130136153,
0.0694180354,
0.0357256979,
-0.0083010029,
-0.0240763705,
-0.0426116586,
-0.0211949926,
0.0423722975,
-0.0250200257,
-0.0030964389,
-0.0291441809,
-0.0145466281,
-0.0079302108,
0.0666747093,
-0.0150878346,
0.0092942463,
0.0054074014,
0.0991006568,
-0.0133896405,
-0.0305656753,
-0.0100734867,
-0.0124755641,
0.0287926849,
0.0656110868,
0.0118588237,
-0.0368415304,
-0.0481946543,
-0.0099341068,
0.0174176432,
-0.0469085649,
-0.0283122119,
-0.0275704712,
0.0097967666,
-0.0277963728,
-0.0495434552,
-0.0491704755,
0.0090774586,
0.0562583692,
-0.0085352827,
0.0383167155,
0.0179119315,
-0.0177274458,
-0.051282689,
-0.0108781382,
-0.0165961906,
0.0408495292,
-0.0437315851,
0.0198539533,
0.0603821278,
0.0224452224,
-0.0223680325,
0.0249230154,
-0.0972731486,
-0.0591658913,
0.0244897306,
0.0017356364,
0.0171117187,
0.029096866,
0.0510205813,
0.0194993336,
0.1227042973,
0.0533869639,
-0.0074688494,
0.0089856237,
0.0548440181,
0.0607224591,
0.0237784255,
0.0370330885,
-0.0087977825,
0.0181384906,
-0.0494866446,
0.0365337245,
-0.0158180743,
-0.0283461157,
-0.0105356062,
-0.019243909,
0.0496200882,
-0.0049750381,
0.0214350484,
-0.000158573,
-0.0120098172,
-0.0244857352,
0.0126953451,
-0.0548590831,
0.0451243185,
0.0397742167,
0.0017891049,
-0.0275709778,
0.0282089096,
0.0405268781,
-0.0279529765,
-0.0172592774,
0.0532868691,
0.0036977504,
0.0270752273,
0.0178326257,
0.0184876695,
0.020654127,
-0.0210014712,
0.0055251829,
-0.0136472285,
-0.011600147,
0.025136007,
-0.004609846,
0.0533385724,
-0.0235772859,
-0.0101435175,
-0.0814415514,
-0.0146708805,
-0.0153277209,
0.0102292523,
0.0286711138,
-0.0346230306,
0.0390794724,
-0.060865704,
0.0177721009,
0.0190281086,
0.0426781885,
0.0014789935,
-0.0176563151,
0.0417403691,
-0.0089440187,
-0.0726950541,
0.0129954722,
0.0537839159,
0.0254439358,
0.0594449714,
0.0259210728,
-0.0285149664,
-0.0167609472,
-0.0142826019,
0.0178567618,
-0.02602005,
0.0056216633,
-0.0105832499,
-0.0438751169,
-0.0570034087,
0.0264013465,
-0.0407946855,
-0.0276933536,
-0.0239366926,
0.0016541973,
0.0265911557,
0.0061059026,
0.042908784,
-0.0166971479,
0.0197438598,
0.0050644409,
-0.0491778851,
-0.0531525873,
-6.395052202e-33,
-0.0125842104,
-0.0153314481,
0.0252191797,
-0.0589216501,
-0.0277889632,
0.0547493771,
-0.0081054708,
-0.0302214734,
0.029362198,
0.0103820013,
-0.0156459957,
-0.0088566663,
0.030432947,
0.023658229,
0.0731463283,
0.0119972909,
0.070365563,
-0.039948985,
0.0289381836,
0.0108581064,
0.0697093531,
0.0491865985,
0.05828996,
0.0117990822,
0.0145332813,
-0.0039762435,
-0.0173753556,
0.0081122089,
0.0798249841,
0.0392634124,
-0.0295612924,
0.0427809879,
0.0291849095,
-0.034110155,
-0.0611114316,
0.0615952313,
-0.0531710908,
-0.0637293458,
-0.0022815894,
-0.0014275115,
-0.021892326,
-0.0009831931,
-0.0208698437,
-0.0161544029,
-0.0283722784,
0.028178446,
0.0019021487,
-0.0231710933,
-0.0153968232,
-0.0456585661,
-0.0166023206,
0.0269483104,
-0.023106901,
0.0077865501,
0.061649248,
0.0664664209,
0.0236902516,
0.0141935777,
-0.0441406034,
0.0318318568,
-0.0120378677,
0.0129977101,
0.0361809805,
0.0367042013,
0.0165311154,
0.0476719514,
0.0065797465,
-0.0640184209,
-0.0301520322,
0.0512361638,
0.0139953503,
0.0246006604,
0.0101414863,
-0.0016508218,
0.0509667695,
-0.0426216424,
0.0036639019,
0.0170267727,
0.0447191261,
0.0574119575,
0.0486711748,
0.0286320355,
-0.0219664145,
-0.0310659856,
-0.016201213,
-0.0244928747,
-0.0042785918,
-0.0241915248,
0.0404691286,
0.0381479003,
0.0359079242,
0.0299070105,
0.0615572408,
-0.0280030463,
-0.0370555595,
0.0533455238,
0.0113171553,
-0.0235115271,
0.0155767752,
0.0377418436,
-0.0618701465,
-0.0314945802,
-0.0032208252,
0.0165756159,
-0.0004270167,
-0.0510965548,
-0.0171354767,
0.0695023164,
-0.0722502023,
-0.0235806406,
-0.0252705514,
-0.0067328932,
0.0167778041,
-0.0159585662,
0.071767576,
-0.040809758,
-0.0211937521,
0.0448668413,
-0.0199722368,
0.0014139025,
0.0328543074,
-0.0191157367,
0.0151018091,
0.0228623785,
-0.0192162395,
-0.0217282195,
-0.0159709994,
-0.0018145142,
0.0608948804,
-0.0471256301,
-0.0056674476,
0.0305739231,
2.735e-7,
0.0090679843,
0.0550123267,
0.032625258,
0.0077232993,
0.0374560803,
0.0204065647,
-0.0365679972,
0.027190499,
-0.0172818117,
0.0284643434,
0.0429671891,
-0.0080785444,
0.0727495551,
0.0213692989,
-0.0456925668,
-0.0234934166,
-0.1180021241,
0.0104610221,
-0.0625814721,
-0.0322274677,
0.032926403,
0.1082506254,
0.0263313558,
0.0123672942,
0.05007229,
-0.0587338954,
0.0473931208,
-0.0146805122,
-0.0159847625,
-0.0103400704,
0.0102466736,
0.0356844254,
-0.0174636487,
-0.0388011485,
-0.0236060303,
0.0282258242,
-0.0286941733,
0.0145123517,
0.0152981775,
-0.0230819583,
0.0092475163,
-0.0169262085,
-0.0358139463,
-0.0222679563,
0.057049185,
-0.0438819453,
-0.0283875335,
-0.0624793284,
-0.057593137,
0.0446931198,
0.0145959072,
0.0123730451,
-0.0051144361,
0.0457795635,
-0.0021008535,
-0.0124157397,
-0.0204956271,
-0.0719317645,
-0.0234277863,
-0.0020784787,
-0.0486687645,
-0.0048596235,
-0.0706624165,
0.002803694,
0.0285761598,
-0.0470965467,
0.0036884248,
2.487942747e-34,
0.0686982572,
-0.0167293902,
-0.0164257083,
0.042668581,
0.0125447689,
-0.0235788394,
-0.0220863242,
0.0502205826,
0.0298875421,
-0.0837768465,
-0.0529491045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02369v1 | M$^3$Face: A Unified Multi-Modal Multilingual Framework for Human Face Generation and Editing | 2024-02-04T06:56:23 | 2024-02-04T06:56:23 | Mohammadreza Mofayezi, Reza Alipour, Mohammad Ali Kakavand, Ehsaneddin Asgari | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | Human face generation and editing represent an essential task in the era of
computer vision and the digital world. Recent studies have shown remarkable
progress in multi-modal face generation and editing, for instance, using face
segmentation to guide image generation. However, it may be challenging for some
users to create these conditioning modalities manually. Thus, we introduce
M3Face, a unified multi-modal multilingual framework for controllable face
generation and editing. This framework enables users to utilize only text input
to generate controlling modalities automatically, for instance, semantic
segmentation or facial landmarks, and subsequently generate face images. We
conduct extensive qualitative and quantitative experiments to showcase our
frameworks face generation and editing capabilities. Additionally, we propose
the M3CelebA Dataset, a large-scale multi-modal and multilingual face dataset
containing high-quality images, semantic segmentations, facial landmarks, and
different captions for each image in multiple languages. The code and the
dataset will be released upon publication. | [
-0.0095208567,
0.0494456626,
0.0075333738,
0.015529423,
-0.0201050118,
0.00634235,
0.0749106109,
0.0044796579,
-0.0393671505,
0.0051451344,
-0.0196557418,
-0.0499266312,
-0.0007870328,
0.0816280842,
0.0286432616,
-0.1152236238,
-0.0308418777,
-0.0237575546,
-0.0320804901,
-0.0104816174,
0.041162625,
0.0182886552,
-0.0104323598,
0.0206548627,
-0.0863941163,
0.0075860424,
-0.0340838581,
0.0668534338,
-0.0027719848,
-0.0166664477,
-0.0257657748,
0.080646731,
0.0014109198,
0.0076141427,
0.0000021785,
-0.0249890685,
-0.0150481164,
-0.0085222684,
0.0213107001,
0.0034279374,
0.0959149674,
-0.0429756679,
-0.0455472544,
-0.0692447498,
-0.0311694629,
0.0106495097,
0.0906619653,
0.0665661022,
0.0876666978,
-0.0119081307,
-0.0269476846,
-0.0327401236,
-0.0455334559,
-0.0193722341,
0.0505107231,
0.0013124692,
0.010003549,
0.0042648241,
-0.0376107171,
-0.0487393439,
-0.020884769,
0.0398568287,
0.0118300216,
-0.034256272,
0.0287671499,
0.0241639148,
-0.0213298742,
-0.0854547992,
-0.0274040718,
0.0601692721,
-0.0086891809,
0.0278926548,
0.0007910104,
0.0000492176,
-0.0001477787,
0.0193524547,
-0.013001116,
0.007649661,
-0.0237942282,
-0.0007800036,
-0.0718216896,
-0.027267009,
0.0224159509,
-0.0253397934,
-0.003988178,
-0.0330190212,
0.0443223566,
0.0131008774,
-0.0562118962,
0.0104446877,
-0.0182860177,
-0.072014682,
0.0448567346,
-0.0109939743,
-0.009808897,
-0.0190788377,
-0.0778405368,
-0.0377032086,
0.0083967084,
0.015763931,
0.0039649042,
0.0022389907,
-0.0363828987,
0.0473661497,
-0.01705781,
0.0072166123,
-0.0153390653,
0.0016537702,
-0.0209011212,
-0.0409390666,
-0.0022515219,
-0.0029725253,
-0.0006730237,
-0.0497913212,
-0.0344157256,
0.0412457138,
-0.0911179706,
0.0268255696,
-0.0310903471,
0.0104214437,
-0.0049653105,
0.0405584499,
-0.0590136684,
0.0118694482,
-0.0555097014,
-0.0138763133,
-0.0218874626,
0.0364340208,
-0.0127791967,
-0.0716028735,
0.0111850044,
-0.0060549979,
0.0458123945,
0.0208014827,
0.0161502007,
0.043594975,
-0.0512767322,
0.0302759465,
-0.0110042924,
-0.019377904,
-0.0153529262,
-0.0340079069,
-0.0018005527,
-0.0686419606,
0.0132357683,
-0.0448685437,
-0.0137919663,
-0.0066375672,
-0.004380221,
0.0125850402,
0.0663614273,
0.0621830076,
0.0068276268,
0.0064857765,
0.0402977131,
0.0131361494,
-0.0492429547,
0.0214273687,
0.0177888703,
0.0364705473,
0.0391506217,
-0.0066103004,
0.0286214817,
0.0386027917,
0.0203360915,
0.0297414735,
-0.0291149598,
-0.019034395,
0.0472795963,
0.0108318143,
0.0040316517,
0.0210264325,
-0.0496213436,
-0.0068706926,
0.0630055591,
0.0261802468,
0.0414894409,
0.0396683887,
0.0205729585,
-0.0124912467,
0.0144105973,
-0.0377180763,
-0.0155760041,
0.0732050538,
0.0011659738,
0.0050252974,
-0.0428558812,
0.0551864691,
-0.0647762269,
-0.0100853732,
0.0581516773,
-0.0186792538,
0.0505753607,
-0.0263714604,
0.0527022071,
-0.0038939069,
0.0197336301,
-0.0096344445,
-0.0491638221,
-0.0974365398,
0.0262957439,
-0.0496008731,
-0.0081341276,
0.0433128662,
-0.0362061113,
0.00527112,
-0.0240623616,
-0.0000872289,
0.0382432155,
0.0469917953,
0.0099651311,
-0.0075314809,
0.0839090198,
-0.0533518381,
-0.0195981488,
-0.0310937464,
0.0059684515,
0.0287723076,
-0.0170719381,
0.0000294098,
-0.0074631269,
0.0220557749,
0.0875361934,
0.0385915264,
-0.0067585837,
0.0278111901,
0.0097006205,
0.0460047834,
0.002477309,
-0.0088069569,
0.0005229987,
-0.0197246019,
0.0174155738,
-0.0101881009,
0.0163814295,
0.0419816636,
-0.0099538062,
0.0274624806,
0.0404102914,
-0.0564760715,
-0.0462764911,
-0.0338720419,
0.0030310701,
-0.043868538,
0.0415886901,
0.0223534293,
0.0020297859,
-0.057183601,
-0.0169716105,
-0.0222507678,
-0.0084344447,
-0.0057949889,
0.0560838021,
-0.009267862,
-0.0270169862,
0.0585538074,
0.0096796816,
-0.0504527539,
-0.0204236079,
-0.0367616341,
-0.0034527506,
-0.0074777557,
0.0119885746,
-0.0068950923,
0.0515121706,
-0.0482977442,
-0.0148615185,
-0.078069903,
-0.0255206544,
0.0029403355,
-0.0275750291,
0.0254494864,
0.0376067869,
-0.0003357693,
-0.0546953417,
-0.0569302067,
0.0175276119,
0.0081056589,
-0.0284968782,
0.0168893579,
0.0118087959,
-0.0065500769,
-0.0369386077,
0.0131090805,
0.0372679159,
0.016282117,
0.0424007773,
-0.0197640155,
-0.0142332288,
-0.0134338206,
-0.0434659794,
0.0468664505,
-0.02108825,
-0.0173688903,
0.0057120514,
-0.0132149104,
0.065758571,
0.0570609607,
-0.0012247871,
-0.0091004083,
0.0165669452,
-0.0251260009,
0.0041598561,
-0.0053358609,
0.0128689175,
0.022011755,
-0.0187599808,
-0.0605533719,
-0.0166179407,
0.0069003622,
0.0278133433,
0.0298561435,
-0.0419817045,
0.0567261241,
0.034381032,
-0.0491918698,
-0.0126687437,
0.0467863083,
-0.0382719301,
0.0393251777,
-0.0643158853,
-0.0618892498,
0.0517181046,
-0.0180477425,
-0.044205524,
0.0845287293,
-0.0035360476,
0.0150585882,
0.059515696,
-0.0106461374,
0.0360587984,
-0.0006669628,
-0.0130919684,
-0.0395145305,
0.0252349526,
0.0424551591,
-0.0295587573,
0.0190650951,
-0.0606748722,
-0.0357426181,
-0.0354006328,
-0.0122204991,
0.0093071917,
-0.0009927012,
-0.0278930422,
-0.0389916115,
0.0043916577,
-0.0249761399,
0.0111699821,
-0.0137514239,
0.0659866855,
0.0246407203,
-0.0279045515,
-0.0098736593,
0.0136393905,
-0.0309163649,
0.0202119295,
0.0585911386,
-0.0573326088,
-0.0353301279,
0.0170750692,
0.0592990443,
0.0363795608,
-0.040393278,
-0.0355033986,
0.0615831614,
0.014405896,
0.0725797862,
-0.0271108542,
0.0107505443,
0.0571569465,
0.0018518299,
0.0454543717,
0.0185157917,
-0.0103148557,
-0.0296714827,
-0.0407357775,
-0.0123436311,
0.0196168832,
0.0663198158,
-0.0079438323,
-0.0725159645,
-0.028346708,
0.0198169574,
0.0055819298,
0.0051130923,
-0.0064704209,
-0.0022684073,
0.0208446905,
0.0726321861,
0.0087539963,
-0.0664786324,
-0.0072260159,
0.027112212,
0.0573137403,
-0.0102650225,
-0.0667459816,
0.0162102748,
-0.016289765,
-0.0019581052,
0.002647704,
0.1029666141,
-0.0337488726,
0.0018335164,
-0.047772631,
-0.0066187824,
0.0423624776,
0.0260977596,
0.0487432629,
-0.0681500584,
0.0051444047,
0.0264902934,
-0.001453633,
-0.0303444937,
0.0401351191,
0.0406356715,
-0.0244844202,
-0.0367607139,
0.0761831328,
0.0440649614,
0.0062720296,
0.0168987606,
0.0020019438,
0.0208422318,
0.0511948504,
-0.0223529339,
-0.0274624657,
-0.0133893443,
-0.0081623383,
0.0044264463,
-0.0357737318,
-0.0354446918,
-0.0339926332,
0.0283676218,
-0.079235509,
-0.0471219122,
0.0293943938,
-0.0370098874,
-0.0904118344,
-0.0382955,
0.0220081676,
0.0705197752,
0.0529402494,
0.0022123596,
-0.0446100347,
0.0130522409,
0.0288316403,
-0.0387062468,
-0.0077043381,
-0.0028926898,
0.0232470296,
-0.0162310712,
-0.019148577,
0.002457805,
-0.0742250383,
0.0205062833,
-0.0173895229,
-0.0161217954,
-0.048991181,
0.0037959495,
0.0783868358,
0.0126455799,
0.0201658476,
0.019783821,
-0.0780184269,
0.014427783,
0.009924667,
0.0193864256,
0.0079592448,
0.0261543281,
0.021678498,
0.0007051004,
0.0116453292,
-0.0397442728,
-0.0154387541,
0.0095412647,
-0.0144844269,
-0.0260855053,
-0.0238318797,
-0.0124521712,
0.0120057259,
0.0022690517,
-0.031756755,
0.0273321029,
-0.0582472309,
0.0068225395,
-0.0393692404,
-0.0246632881,
-0.0669897646,
0.0084133502,
-0.0089152623,
0.0189800709,
0.0322198533,
-0.010471208,
-0.01111551,
0.0467388071,
-0.0268575624,
0.0476457216,
0.0151443733,
0.0322021693,
0.0325036645,
0.0594663881,
0.0360571183,
0.0511345938,
-0.003323399,
-0.0069464166,
-0.0142017649,
0.0281796567,
-0.042822741,
-0.04464617,
-0.0357972495,
0.0498063192,
-0.0277651995,
0.0153453713,
-0.0287989303,
-0.0027011686,
0.0452829152,
0.0357027464,
0.0750215501,
-0.0083942702,
-0.0142246941,
-0.0154995089,
0.0750277564,
0.0052387924,
-0.0665155128,
0.0430704392,
-0.0293155015,
-0.0214492604,
-0.0360525846,
0.0386325978,
-0.0533281304,
0.0064015649,
-0.0185725447,
-0.0335512497,
-0.0415467806,
0.0240355376,
0.0613917187,
-0.0289177187,
-0.0628302917,
-0.0331966504,
-0.0286728535,
-0.0047490988,
0.0070910822,
0.0304831676,
0.0002243824,
0.026178766,
0.042691227,
0.058072757,
-0.0231676605,
0.0037232975,
-0.029141292,
0.0404146872,
-0.0256242473,
-0.0089392513,
0.0190566462,
-6.105806022e-33,
-0.0211192854,
0.0103689432,
0.0109357936,
-0.044372905,
-0.0274143126,
-0.0059905583,
-0.0191219766,
0.0597218275,
0.0057494426,
-0.0134533895,
0.0081345355,
-0.0400102474,
0.0016981361,
0.0373604968,
0.0032133544,
0.0098511539,
0.0387009121,
-0.0119920671,
-0.0056262361,
0.0260297209,
0.0188367926,
-0.0068300487,
0.0468817241,
-0.0732221603,
-0.039071653,
0.0054747816,
-0.050388027,
-0.0079638408,
-0.0208032615,
0.0473070927,
0.0072489679,
0.0161318947,
0.0098258648,
-0.0014025382,
0.0121891396,
0.0017291358,
-0.0311388243,
-0.0145141613,
-0.0711089969,
0.0267570168,
-0.0517323464,
-0.0357662961,
0.0266772266,
-0.0244889576,
-0.0063305781,
0.0056613456,
0.0459713936,
-0.0217302814,
-0.0041855075,
-0.0060414891,
-0.0134378588,
0.0142747695,
0.006205359,
-0.0296228491,
0.0324350074,
0.0583381243,
0.0224392805,
-0.0208565332,
-0.024441557,
0.0374472737,
-0.0200831387,
-0.0547482818,
0.0638125911,
0.0541789345,
0.0558315739,
0.035052266,
0.0542150177,
-0.0549927242,
-0.0120561393,
0.0168390255,
0.0381441675,
0.0827333704,
-0.0133503946,
0.106742382,
-0.0166442152,
-0.0351827554,
-0.0138699682,
0.036161609,
-0.0617613532,
0.0167396646,
-0.0202249065,
0.0403031707,
0.0502074808,
0.0275736284,
-0.0220716819,
-0.0158496406,
-0.0544112958,
-0.0172817241,
0.0083270082,
0.0269363374,
-0.0555468015,
-0.0123822354,
0.0179755427,
0.0353534445,
0.0331095979,
-0.027189929,
-0.0572517775,
0.0643960088,
0.0058328053,
-0.0309267733,
-0.0027333803,
-0.0160487052,
0.0572206639,
0.005080997,
0.0437200963,
0.0159182381,
-0.0351149514,
0.0197646543,
-0.0171734486,
0.0083791269,
-0.0336599723,
0.0327661708,
-0.0057141124,
0.0625734776,
0.0136421528,
-0.0278912354,
-0.0552105643,
-0.031141974,
0.0103032188,
0.0167719945,
-0.0597652085,
-0.0670452043,
0.0174337514,
0.0425989255,
-0.0505307242,
0.0450499244,
-0.0699715316,
-0.034078341,
0.0810413659,
-0.0374636427,
-0.0330061316,
0.0077612563,
2.78e-7,
-0.0254655462,
0.0403461456,
-0.0067923102,
-0.0077957329,
0.0270491466,
0.0909932703,
-0.0356021374,
-0.0107319709,
-0.0025149384,
-0.0104419626,
-0.0030281055,
-0.0011420401,
0.0324485265,
0.066477567,
-0.0074844416,
0.0346953906,
0.0435985625,
0.0283245537,
0.0110134408,
0.0426348411,
0.0518742688,
0.0338129289,
0.0016844044,
-0.0141318729,
0.0750465244,
-0.0095249079,
0.0535963327,
-0.0391747542,
0.0081782294,
-0.0482385419,
-0.0103637716,
0.0225557033,
0.0079924306,
-0.0072150538,
-0.0266395956,
-0.0496836305,
0.0307323821,
0.0439296924,
-0.031634815,
-0.0000871951,
0.0216280129,
0.0482630096,
-0.0223899744,
-0.0225211401,
0.0251196343,
0.0312928818,
0.0030647099,
-0.0469225273,
-0.0279790703,
0.0525349826,
0.0254510324,
-0.0518706441,
-0.050346788,
0.0293680578,
0.0315340795,
-0.010178973,
-0.0202299431,
0.0016266851,
-0.0235479847,
-0.0536407791,
-0.0357523002,
-0.0328756683,
-0.0841821209,
0.0174081661,
0.0101589505,
0.0253489651,
-0.0135232201,
1.990240506e-34,
-0.0350031182,
0.0031317854,
0.0278443862,
-0.0473013818,
0.020946091,
0.0153870881,
-0.0241279136,
0.0062734033,
0.0015194018,
-0.0092040021,
-0.0511894636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02364v1 | The Developmental Landscape of In-Context Learning | 2024-02-04T06:23:05 | 2024-02-04T06:23:05 | Jesse Hoogland, George Wang, Matthew Farrugia-Roberts, Liam Carroll, Susan Wei, Daniel Murfet | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We show that in-context learning emerges in transformers in discrete
developmental stages, when they are trained on either language modeling or
linear regression tasks. We introduce two methods for detecting the milestones
that separate these stages, by probing the geometry of the population loss in
both parameter space and function space. We study the stages revealed by these
new methods using a range of behavioral and structural metrics to establish
their validity. | [
-0.0371610001,
0.0462926552,
-0.0357317775,
0.0079236487,
0.0175550114,
0.0316187032,
0.0120514212,
-0.015638195,
-0.0889663249,
0.0234917961,
-0.044545792,
-0.0375754498,
0.0008764943,
-0.0157126337,
0.0428930856,
-0.0416659527,
0.040698681,
-0.0082022948,
-0.0446804129,
-0.0111554423,
-0.0397174023,
-0.015636079,
-0.0212452859,
0.0466417782,
-0.013829466,
-0.0166977849,
0.0029501263,
-0.0380158201,
0.0051057409,
-0.0335603505,
0.0337461531,
-0.0085465368,
0.0485506803,
0.0576859526,
0.0000016385,
-0.0303007923,
0.0048123198,
-0.0048137926,
-0.0511008538,
-0.0476151109,
0.0370183103,
-0.0035004332,
-0.0383392908,
0.0207318142,
-0.0122739654,
-0.0098114852,
0.0748773888,
0.0361533724,
0.0193941593,
0.0189705696,
-0.0140305692,
-0.0182217732,
0.0129343476,
-0.0124809472,
0.0099619711,
0.0074008475,
0.0028875573,
-0.0414309092,
-0.0320989564,
-0.0348749869,
-0.0452016816,
0.0121316314,
0.030697722,
0.0164795183,
-0.0015123402,
0.0421448648,
0.0393297225,
-0.0358852595,
-0.0198781118,
-0.0070286118,
-0.0088721104,
-0.0081207706,
-0.0121996729,
0.0256518237,
0.0149769364,
-0.0170530286,
-0.0294364877,
0.0247664135,
0.0127210375,
0.0050378037,
-0.0429921299,
-0.0020612166,
0.0264256783,
-0.0396955982,
-0.0042661694,
0.052579619,
0.0202851407,
-0.0283614043,
-0.0053959573,
0.0056441235,
0.0065326523,
-0.0116815362,
0.0129906619,
0.0104555367,
-0.0147768585,
0.0498084202,
-0.0121307382,
-0.0132621257,
-0.0080434056,
-0.0080399644,
0.0572257973,
0.0147586614,
-0.0380059667,
-0.0035460044,
-0.0198463667,
0.0694994181,
-0.0219497737,
0.0235784743,
-0.0033773913,
0.0223107263,
-0.040221788,
-0.0555817224,
-0.0172208697,
-0.018382499,
0.0186293237,
0.0036991669,
-0.0236849263,
0.067257829,
0.0094704852,
-0.0131034283,
-0.0136262858,
0.0017011141,
-0.0918918401,
0.0245699771,
-0.0434031226,
0.0569668263,
0.0033373593,
0.0140487738,
0.0036981371,
0.0047183903,
-0.0256036501,
-0.0104665216,
0.0205485113,
-0.0035267239,
-0.010507293,
0.0882896706,
-0.0135701904,
-0.0374739654,
-0.0453098007,
0.0424928479,
-0.011376353,
-0.0503495745,
0.0320205986,
-0.0273473356,
-0.0324813873,
0.0394674763,
-0.0175974816,
-0.0158296507,
-0.0190644152,
-0.0024509286,
0.0737620294,
0.0486254692,
-0.0048887446,
-0.0059741698,
0.0290560573,
-0.0139374305,
0.0099328021,
0.0666603446,
0.0023636287,
-0.0492440984,
-0.0369624607,
-0.0037735584,
0.0016446131,
0.0418986492,
0.0198854879,
0.0190809239,
-0.028850697,
-0.0445565842,
0.0205579363,
0.008106729,
0.0589332618,
-0.008001457,
-0.0451780185,
0.039750766,
0.081546776,
0.0830422342,
0.0525778309,
0.0320692845,
0.0111455908,
-0.025556922,
0.0060120388,
0.0114533203,
-0.0710600019,
0.0245977324,
0.017700823,
0.0043723383,
-0.0708552599,
0.0231612138,
-0.0240150392,
-0.0197002403,
0.0111530367,
-0.0010710161,
-0.0347229578,
-0.0372046418,
0.0773802921,
0.0484479666,
-0.0412707478,
0.0624119304,
0.010125719,
-0.0340449698,
0.0296998601,
-0.0497492738,
-0.0061272164,
-0.0309366863,
-0.0246521272,
-0.0463489518,
-0.018821232,
-0.0139319496,
0.0057140044,
0.0428172909,
-0.0338316448,
-0.0194334127,
0.0250241887,
0.0085658077,
-0.0243336186,
0.0103769116,
0.0174267218,
-0.029298747,
-0.0163058564,
-0.0527848378,
-0.0274660587,
-0.0730230808,
0.0078104995,
0.065650098,
-0.0687415674,
-0.0033846796,
-0.0372368209,
0.0162066016,
0.0229871925,
-0.0418847352,
0.0052853506,
-0.0069426163,
0.0279311575,
0.0216028783,
-0.0062165959,
0.0596279614,
-0.0659573302,
-0.0171400402,
0.0317639709,
-0.0393026099,
-0.017025331,
0.0462016836,
0.0181208234,
-0.0190641396,
0.0181858577,
-0.0938595235,
0.0975769833,
-0.0202733558,
0.0512217544,
-0.0639923215,
-0.0174903031,
-0.057585258,
0.0735090524,
-0.0001418556,
-0.0071756151,
0.009613689,
-0.0075485259,
-0.0025382112,
-0.0090739243,
-0.0101246731,
-0.0242632255,
-0.0451565497,
0.0292822383,
-0.008152402,
-0.0284477472,
-0.0440793373,
-0.0094803842,
-0.0224139951,
-0.0097609796,
0.0007379606,
0.0435831882,
0.0191345848,
-0.0565080047,
0.0083883265,
0.0004309988,
0.0252170544,
0.0328707173,
0.0031952458,
0.0266782064,
0.0447867438,
0.0265819617,
-0.0463850535,
-0.0208618827,
-0.015805779,
-0.0200678334,
0.0369483903,
-0.0205719285,
0.0109586585,
-0.0763415992,
0.0384541936,
0.0330024064,
0.0080446852,
-0.0216548909,
-0.012302883,
0.0566264018,
0.0297246724,
0.0823294073,
0.077334784,
0.028417496,
0.1014866978,
0.0390218049,
0.0200545453,
-0.0070632589,
-0.0136178918,
-0.0791972727,
-0.0348809846,
-0.066362597,
0.0145732341,
0.0076127467,
0.0608798005,
0.0010333017,
-0.0014163232,
-0.0460903719,
-0.012148615,
-0.0240870323,
0.0065133846,
-0.0116615407,
-0.0104250396,
-0.0377636813,
0.0299896523,
-0.011023595,
-0.0477484427,
0.0299892556,
0.0238682423,
-0.0114275571,
-0.0483431704,
-0.0011020207,
0.0279668085,
0.0218492318,
0.0120731052,
0.0041622752,
0.0447096117,
-0.0676686466,
-0.1137467325,
0.0360927954,
0.0462245457,
0.0151412366,
0.0831584334,
-0.0359034315,
-0.0225162059,
-0.0055012987,
-0.0118214926,
-0.0353845395,
0.0146406954,
0.0183508676,
0.0088727325,
0.0156170586,
-0.0602312051,
-0.0779943094,
-0.0220809542,
0.0262576882,
0.0577197447,
0.0089245811,
-0.0528133437,
-0.0140431235,
-0.0081766574,
0.0151839443,
0.0322074853,
0.0730382204,
-0.1037054136,
0.0125922998,
0.0143236713,
0.0302508678,
0.0080822343,
-0.0524892174,
0.0162085053,
0.0110579729,
0.0135560799,
0.0175856836,
0.0536113232,
0.0248655248,
-0.0212619249,
-0.0543557703,
0.0260046255,
-0.0057955827,
-0.0506797284,
0.0182261318,
-0.0251931343,
0.0263838153,
0.0556095652,
0.0123668266,
0.0042023556,
0.0133408075,
0.0150442868,
0.0286467746,
0.0022955446,
0.0124710733,
0.0342005715,
-0.063610442,
0.0123741888,
-0.0299650673,
-0.0735521093,
-0.0176344141,
0.0041444888,
0.0213731546,
-0.0044782241,
0.0375962704,
0.0129405744,
-0.0659858361,
-0.0336981006,
0.0466586798,
0.0125775151,
-0.0624437742,
-0.0042874808,
-0.0395934545,
0.0440197848,
0.069552131,
0.014633297,
-0.020945387,
-0.0182705522,
0.0510000512,
-0.0248749088,
-0.0037841268,
0.0221607555,
0.0486473665,
0.0342692845,
-0.0080041382,
-0.0355380699,
0.0437993035,
0.0011630616,
-0.0125398813,
-0.0489671342,
0.0462597348,
-0.0033489619,
-0.0409747697,
0.0164443273,
-0.0164993964,
0.0141396914,
0.0119152246,
0.0203586649,
-0.0634976104,
-0.0228089336,
-0.0328400284,
0.0392468907,
0.0553452484,
-0.0476685613,
0.031471543,
0.0127981296,
-0.0641698986,
-0.0497315302,
0.0527621321,
0.003422003,
0.0480229259,
0.0240897108,
-0.0490220301,
0.0101213567,
-0.0085760932,
-0.0280230474,
0.0389943495,
0.0230104607,
-0.0174402334,
-0.0827693343,
0.0089670587,
0.0312470496,
-0.0494790822,
-0.0421633609,
-0.0232804418,
-0.1095902994,
-0.0422941819,
0.0470048115,
0.0211806986,
0.0275515821,
0.0068092435,
0.0239536781,
-0.0497346781,
0.1084442288,
0.0436300896,
0.0501181595,
0.0293415952,
0.0718077347,
-0.005528633,
-0.0325229652,
0.0067936108,
-0.0186458435,
-0.0053124158,
0.0106887603,
0.006887204,
-0.0215798598,
0.0670664385,
0.0407283604,
-0.0874105692,
0.0749904215,
-0.026044311,
-0.0361433141,
-0.0468482301,
0.0010667207,
0.0337049924,
0.0222531557,
-0.006240793,
-0.0840206966,
0.0354933143,
0.0656067953,
0.0198443159,
0.0209762715,
0.0588554032,
0.0070377477,
-0.0031243521,
0.0017233061,
0.0417126901,
0.0104206549,
0.0291339271,
0.0765718669,
0.0255878642,
-0.0074719009,
-0.0268399306,
0.0176376496,
0.0263767391,
0.0366465896,
0.0491129234,
0.0153388446,
0.006080193,
0.0065990421,
-0.0544003658,
0.0211294331,
-0.0494651794,
-0.0577777512,
0.018253414,
-0.0281394143,
0.0197325181,
-0.0472151414,
0.0020996088,
-0.0106090438,
0.0055166399,
-0.0276493449,
-0.0106798885,
0.0217722245,
0.0110453814,
0.0326231904,
-0.0247718263,
0.0491016656,
0.0091332607,
0.0695715398,
-0.0711477846,
0.0313873179,
-0.0098110996,
-0.0112277893,
0.0184874572,
-0.0244542882,
-0.0197448693,
-0.0217783544,
-0.0246632434,
-0.0557650886,
0.0077015888,
-0.0087361643,
0.0031772766,
-0.0593773201,
0.0340953507,
0.0273962189,
-0.0272537526,
-0.033232078,
0.0156755354,
-0.0454501957,
0.0410984419,
0.0371954069,
-0.0306205042,
-5.584705335e-33,
-0.0277159121,
-0.0883692726,
0.0205279719,
0.0185566731,
-0.0148047255,
-0.0005931889,
-0.0387377366,
0.0397725254,
-0.0273810346,
0.0050202413,
0.0178910811,
0.0366811864,
0.0060003074,
0.0313894786,
0.0108863562,
-0.0341522917,
0.0252000336,
-0.0223102812,
-0.0117807575,
-0.0168722551,
0.0301011205,
0.012382675,
0.066011481,
-0.0412553847,
-0.0361038409,
0.0060018622,
-0.0209947545,
0.0288200453,
-0.038589187,
0.012733778,
-0.016827669,
0.0379399583,
-0.0033112844,
-0.0648548231,
-0.0312082972,
0.0149343051,
-0.0664850697,
0.0020801413,
-0.0187314488,
-0.0003885535,
-0.0237700678,
-0.0008874696,
0.0498304963,
-0.0117650805,
-0.0058230269,
-0.0499885343,
0.0536178909,
-0.0303793419,
-0.0016038764,
-0.0233423822,
-0.0874866247,
-0.0127147101,
-0.0144225657,
-0.0303182863,
0.0086571286,
0.0529961176,
-0.0034913518,
0.0039195609,
-0.0728188306,
0.0177093539,
-0.0181104932,
0.015754614,
0.0621526316,
0.0747735277,
0.027021639,
0.041921217,
0.0313936919,
0.042234797,
0.0129309967,
-0.0865400136,
0.0978338867,
0.0255210977,
0.011300181,
-0.0209736731,
0.0177838765,
0.0025977963,
-0.0174162555,
0.0078142779,
-0.0173204839,
0.0509233661,
0.0151744774,
0.0130622312,
0.0452348627,
0.0018744523,
-0.0289527755,
-0.0413957909,
0.0037243634,
0.0119127585,
0.007409147,
0.0141592557,
-0.0081023294,
-0.0143411774,
-0.0010535017,
-0.0154666826,
-0.0011065787,
-0.0090209823,
-0.0196822584,
0.0491323695,
0.0107362485,
-0.0015461753,
-0.0500713065,
-0.0456887446,
-0.0203550588,
0.0686142221,
0.0405337587,
-0.0096611129,
0.0520728789,
0.0391233452,
-0.0403244123,
0.0098001994,
-0.0200529546,
0.0112905139,
0.0343538262,
0.0275634136,
0.0208162665,
-0.0263908189,
-0.009783173,
-0.0178604759,
0.01376021,
-0.0184214246,
-0.0564832166,
0.09624625,
-0.0261661336,
0.00249909,
-0.0075934581,
-0.0220197495,
-0.0589247234,
0.0620381609,
0.0530821271,
-0.0530080348,
-0.0252362136,
-0.0083313957,
2.41e-7,
0.0451640189,
0.0428816453,
0.0397402011,
0.0113822902,
0.0442389138,
0.0227492787,
-0.0294231009,
-0.0122306226,
0.0388167053,
-0.0011996953,
0.0178875774,
-0.0144144138,
0.0554495119,
0.0181643218,
-0.0363275521,
-0.0484391972,
-0.0751195848,
0.0248055663,
-0.026302468,
0.0281710401,
-0.0062817694,
0.0382447205,
-0.0128675262,
-0.0267514791,
-0.0027222682,
0.0159792546,
0.0510503836,
-0.0147522781,
0.0842251107,
-0.0048269127,
-0.072254166,
0.002934553,
0.0060574929,
0.0276735239,
-0.0084546776,
0.0417377725,
-0.0375574008,
0.0003300588,
0.0230395719,
-0.0530581214,
0.0170716271,
0.0619828142,
-0.0088500502,
-0.008313451,
-0.0087825172,
-0.106083177,
-0.0172109585,
-0.0322663374,
-0.0008654821,
-0.014977851,
0.0188245662,
-0.0158342682,
-0.0086957896,
0.0046110889,
-0.0195722952,
0.0035228611,
0.0056185937,
-0.0601322912,
-0.0185293779,
0.0359495319,
-0.0531724989,
-0.0644389614,
-0.0303813424,
0.008800826,
0.0368749984,
0.0242253039,
0.0197034013,
1.915062706e-34,
-0.0222551953,
-0.0183200948,
0.045914799,
0.0055988259,
0.0043328684,
-0.0101588145,
0.0422005728,
0.0029831948,
0.0449750274,
-0.0333326831,
0.0217622407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05952v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05952v1 | Advancing Graph Representation Learning with Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey of Techniques | 2024-02-04T05:51:14 | 2024-02-04T05:51:14 | Qiheng Mao, Zemin Liu, Chenghao Liu, Zhuo Li, Jianling Sun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Graph Representation
Learning (GRL) marks a significant evolution in analyzing complex data
structures. This collaboration harnesses the sophisticated linguistic
capabilities of LLMs to improve the contextual understanding and adaptability
of graph models, thereby broadening the scope and potential of GRL. Despite a
growing body of research dedicated to integrating LLMs into the graph domain, a
comprehensive review that deeply analyzes the core components and operations
within these models is notably lacking. Our survey fills this gap by proposing
a novel taxonomy that breaks down these models into primary components and
operation techniques from a novel technical perspective. We further dissect
recent literature into two primary components including knowledge extractors
and organizers, and two operation techniques including integration and training
stratigies, shedding light on effective model design and training strategies.
Additionally, we identify and explore potential future research avenues in this
nascent yet underexplored field, proposing paths for continued progress. | [
0.0327694677,
0.0269102771,
-0.0056805331,
0.0443791077,
-0.027498683,
0.0188968275,
-0.0241676643,
-0.0235621724,
0.0758073628,
-0.0615169443,
-0.0150590902,
-0.0353235565,
-0.0171561427,
0.0287419036,
0.0410245918,
-0.0099968258,
-0.0070572989,
-0.0277940091,
0.0168233849,
-0.0300585199,
-0.0133355428,
0.028977111,
0.0629779994,
0.0037844926,
-0.0080279298,
-0.006594534,
0.0120418277,
0.006885652,
-0.0310933348,
-0.0265265498,
-0.0446076207,
0.0109276148,
0.0650915354,
0.0412698835,
0.0000017079,
-0.0281592775,
-0.0377134569,
-0.0004778065,
0.0005170429,
-0.0190754496,
0.0576969609,
-0.0664494783,
0.0172173139,
-0.0100924773,
-0.0423823707,
-0.0304089803,
0.0646878034,
0.016309822,
0.0421645418,
0.0589494854,
-0.0244747177,
-0.03356006,
0.0364509858,
-0.0145300925,
-0.0240295306,
-0.025129376,
0.0602455139,
0.0525568686,
0.0096207848,
-0.0040196301,
-0.0635659695,
0.023671601,
-0.0184100959,
-0.0247532502,
0.0426896624,
0.04243863,
0.0156391822,
0.02319845,
-0.0097981002,
0.0856252685,
0.0010684126,
-0.0127583975,
-0.0000576024,
0.0074604321,
0.0063933735,
0.0373028219,
-0.0675543174,
-0.0138937114,
0.0183394067,
0.0327186286,
-0.0116197132,
-0.0538515151,
0.0870889947,
-0.0144793009,
-0.027553726,
0.059021607,
-0.002658929,
-0.0182259493,
0.0068350667,
-0.0140666114,
-0.0344629064,
-0.0081403768,
-0.0271317158,
0.0295093339,
-0.0039722724,
0.0256500617,
0.0122651411,
-0.0013191408,
-0.0138383526,
-0.0287039299,
0.0496541411,
-0.0387416333,
0.0215766206,
0.0600070655,
-0.0354129374,
0.0487212166,
-0.0368873812,
0.040167883,
-0.0476827212,
-0.0295490008,
-0.0587008856,
-0.0076873442,
-0.0155879576,
0.0252129864,
0.0359258652,
-0.0495057404,
-0.0192843769,
0.0428224429,
-0.0385803506,
0.0324783698,
0.0079086851,
-0.0048795631,
0.0303311646,
-0.0251917038,
0.0104797436,
0.0212442651,
0.0364671908,
0.0150352651,
-0.0467059538,
-0.0029096457,
0.0125798564,
0.0101482049,
0.0361166894,
-0.0410158448,
0.004978518,
0.0706024468,
0.0428026207,
-0.0108447596,
0.0051972112,
0.0133950002,
-0.0251910798,
-0.0597455986,
0.0198360272,
-0.0967512131,
0.0388602093,
0.0373227112,
0.0106691876,
-0.0429769047,
0.0184521936,
-0.040494822,
-0.0625102744,
0.0626293123,
-0.0087567279,
0.031663008,
-0.0242306218,
-0.0548212975,
-0.0052129542,
0.0481920391,
0.0209944267,
0.0083803209,
0.0129746208,
-0.0208771098,
-0.0475885049,
0.0416056328,
0.0154734096,
0.0241630375,
-0.0096937362,
0.0040021674,
0.0314858556,
-0.0049403459,
0.0064892825,
0.0717533976,
-0.0290663857,
-0.0258017201,
0.0322767235,
0.0534474067,
-0.0002889676,
0.0061920886,
0.0482937321,
0.0071165082,
-0.0260276906,
-0.0059577366,
-0.0571818352,
-0.0264601745,
-0.0040493328,
0.0114964042,
-0.0246929582,
0.005074624,
-0.0030655479,
0.0074773417,
-0.0100884326,
-0.0293904785,
0.0717261434,
0.0076618679,
0.0882277489,
-0.010330121,
-0.0139444256,
0.0138176121,
0.0376615226,
-0.0123942001,
0.0374126546,
0.0113780461,
-0.0331887081,
0.0603615008,
0.0262576379,
-0.0435885005,
0.0052092299,
0.0007057302,
-0.0052465149,
-0.0334646888,
0.0347991697,
-0.0529600605,
-0.0320978127,
-0.0285042264,
-0.0279314741,
-0.0137243206,
-0.0104895607,
0.0209179167,
0.0052789482,
-0.0179870185,
0.0109266909,
-0.0754732564,
-0.0613487139,
-0.0031563051,
0.0047867727,
-0.0004265447,
-0.0167546384,
-0.0024229016,
-0.0039811395,
0.017370278,
-0.0032274658,
0.0095228385,
0.0267873276,
-0.02600828,
-0.0153798312,
-0.0134162428,
-0.0048282766,
-0.0251739938,
0.0828119293,
0.0035156205,
-0.0206076354,
0.003901463,
-0.0448495559,
-0.0240672454,
0.0443474762,
-0.056615781,
0.0632841364,
-0.0011886073,
0.0099489968,
-0.0101399291,
-0.0190255344,
-0.0220123753,
0.0719343722,
0.0017824006,
-0.0106777623,
0.0128114121,
-0.0042736763,
-0.0075845551,
-0.0382880196,
-0.0164285582,
0.0439513586,
0.015132878,
0.041899167,
0.0399980061,
-0.036303971,
-0.0375598148,
-0.0002754387,
-0.0840703323,
0.0012195763,
-0.0040714694,
0.0172956791,
-0.0065143011,
-0.0050145481,
0.0183797237,
-0.0139806746,
-0.0620638765,
0.0155919073,
0.0214924775,
0.0338229649,
0.0048327162,
-0.0109936558,
-0.0462120362,
-0.0134110898,
-0.0619770475,
-0.057690423,
0.0959332287,
0.0059268563,
-0.0622637235,
-0.002892876,
0.0292268284,
-0.0434972942,
0.0294261929,
-0.0266505554,
0.0303993225,
-0.0245275777,
-0.0366998576,
0.0391364023,
0.0333038941,
-0.0351583138,
0.0449431799,
0.0622229427,
-0.019635465,
-0.0116064874,
-0.018884832,
-0.0616593584,
-0.0089328149,
-0.0634193644,
-0.017534636,
-0.0309262071,
0.0025247841,
0.0044733388,
-0.019523982,
-0.0390652083,
-0.0125051038,
-0.0484801903,
0.0058854236,
-0.0217692163,
-0.0269326549,
0.0206743143,
-0.0151008582,
-0.0536449775,
-0.0455123261,
0.0627952963,
-0.0172539316,
0.013119353,
0.0438087918,
-0.0340293609,
-0.0823567584,
0.0692386702,
0.0643572435,
0.0425376035,
-0.0041063996,
-0.0202583298,
-0.0339766219,
0.0119159808,
0.0205069743,
-0.0377875455,
0.0380362533,
0.0162003748,
0.0531499833,
0.0197614711,
-0.0253113732,
0.000035992,
-0.0084850993,
-0.0379183292,
0.0528172478,
0.0259999372,
-0.0373503864,
0.002950022,
0.0286373589,
-0.0150968088,
-0.0301201064,
-0.0026832914,
0.0158381592,
-0.0332695618,
0.0319276825,
0.0380531587,
-0.0365872681,
0.032196112,
-0.0331693739,
0.0013345858,
0.0372900814,
0.0208435021,
-0.0388416685,
-0.0406118892,
0.0191224013,
0.0132272849,
-0.0095429551,
-0.0084733171,
-0.0141762299,
0.0234886464,
-0.007694677,
0.0148198092,
0.0762511715,
0.0156675763,
-0.0489263982,
0.0078214919,
0.0202364046,
0.0262309574,
0.0320936963,
0.0142131718,
-0.0801636279,
0.0106653804,
-0.0175235868,
-0.0021710291,
0.0360651836,
-0.0606468879,
-0.0110874744,
-0.103262417,
0.0244779401,
0.0698375925,
-0.0036418769,
-0.0535448082,
-0.0615477301,
0.0056359242,
-0.0072959093,
-0.0088180685,
-0.0243581161,
-0.0558426864,
-0.0260037836,
0.0185078979,
-0.0342912562,
-0.0281190649,
0.017327169,
-0.0239414852,
0.0026095368,
0.0013909853,
0.0357528664,
0.0115628904,
0.033660017,
0.0157558061,
0.022090042,
-0.0333068147,
-0.011630876,
0.0177310575,
-0.0109936129,
0.0012661959,
-0.0204311851,
0.0167444032,
-0.029512085,
-0.0155731039,
-0.0520052835,
0.1256401688,
0.0142216226,
-0.0256139673,
0.0175882932,
-0.0335565433,
-0.0022383335,
0.0117490496,
0.0464609824,
0.0025203016,
-0.0419122875,
-0.0489904396,
0.0132864099,
0.00547302,
-0.0401789732,
0.0345679186,
-0.0403297693,
0.039661672,
-0.0220711231,
-0.0061178692,
0.0326614454,
-0.0282066204,
0.0153816165,
0.0361732841,
0.0525946468,
-0.0581189357,
-0.0659021363,
0.0106928004,
-0.0523846336,
0.0498001054,
-0.0007995596,
-0.0338353999,
0.0189909432,
-0.001293605,
-0.0236642342,
0.0088870963,
-0.0728272945,
-0.1020860597,
-0.0389403887,
-0.0058777528,
0.0074375784,
0.0379229225,
-0.0148427757,
-0.0382899009,
0.0371660516,
0.028064061,
-0.0079459632,
-0.0076073986,
0.0149444621,
-0.0091124,
-0.0080894502,
0.0527217463,
-0.06783057,
0.0141945388,
0.0332314521,
0.0254910253,
-0.0394904613,
-0.0313424952,
0.044448588,
0.0798682719,
0.0156820286,
0.0311368611,
-0.0028435136,
-0.0502745956,
-0.0414827801,
-0.0333775207,
-0.0578237772,
-0.0066682021,
-0.0259694941,
0.0422067605,
0.0013199513,
0.0059583639,
-0.0301618688,
0.0456655584,
0.0468113981,
-0.0418861844,
0.0110815838,
0.0133591965,
-0.0735170245,
0.0616589449,
0.0169373881,
-0.0029428345,
0.0210460685,
0.0029514276,
0.0051619285,
0.0108367968,
-0.0272355396,
0.0069699152,
-0.0201823227,
-0.0694283396,
-0.0066850176,
-0.0353195295,
-0.0440281518,
0.0137766367,
-0.0021764426,
0.0718956888,
-0.0006908017,
0.0599864572,
-0.0142688872,
-0.0274709277,
-0.029177634,
0.0227113515,
-0.012562749,
-0.0572822914,
0.0583387651,
0.0295073353,
-0.0071148081,
0.0305911433,
0.0396343358,
0.0741762668,
0.0203992277,
-0.0050994786,
-0.0406153314,
-0.02936396,
-0.0301110614,
0.0001364077,
0.0110492148,
-0.0259378497,
0.0340511315,
-0.0593591407,
-0.0964987874,
0.0138043528,
-0.0261110105,
-0.0099476026,
0.0045282426,
0.0003359604,
0.0326357596,
0.0196995102,
-0.0074017639,
-0.0678319484,
0.0375340991,
-0.0092335492,
-0.015219572,
0.0152940266,
-5.624093212e-33,
-0.0061401702,
-0.0602484383,
0.0208364725,
0.0118647795,
-0.0454674773,
0.0327523574,
-0.0178478248,
0.0057915743,
-0.0215789806,
0.0165792685,
0.0163387842,
-0.0144384904,
-0.0194643531,
0.0108237779,
-0.0352637731,
0.0097089792,
0.0299108475,
0.0268792938,
0.0216730367,
0.044583112,
0.0485813208,
0.0180679988,
0.0361098275,
-0.0767118633,
0.0230519194,
-0.0221370161,
0.0162344631,
0.0403748825,
0.0492839366,
0.0545870066,
-0.0213676114,
0.0443467647,
0.0380355306,
0.0078656198,
-0.0113364542,
0.0311739296,
-0.0630531609,
0.0202136431,
0.0081346827,
0.0105436668,
-0.0052015763,
-0.0330827534,
0.0417554155,
-0.0067846272,
0.0320365764,
-0.0535090417,
0.0483323559,
-0.0043967469,
-0.0602946356,
0.0308090653,
-0.0565645993,
0.0359889157,
-0.006790047,
0.0216199346,
0.0653995723,
-0.0188536253,
0.0200001094,
0.0245226063,
-0.0459870771,
0.0464914404,
-0.0191906951,
0.0012278426,
0.0347472951,
0.0571280457,
0.0354230031,
0.0472569056,
-0.017112717,
-0.0069745993,
-0.0044260914,
0.0049274177,
0.0022589155,
0.0737184584,
-0.0147675546,
0.00886897,
-0.0483106263,
0.0130242966,
-0.0897376537,
-0.0254093111,
0.0114678694,
0.0196065754,
0.0071835653,
0.0322281457,
-0.0033333623,
-0.0632081106,
-0.0385820046,
-0.0113706375,
-0.0095891841,
-0.0169319734,
-0.0207200684,
-0.0114814285,
-0.0218132716,
0.0393621735,
0.0178747717,
-0.0863259658,
-0.0779879764,
0.0809301287,
-0.0017963012,
0.0529425703,
-0.0086845085,
0.0340399779,
-0.0770835429,
-0.0519221686,
-0.0172946267,
-0.0597574301,
-0.0030367333,
0.0056724395,
0.0554877222,
0.0259787962,
-0.0221087635,
0.0034143138,
-0.0294737089,
-0.0471619889,
-0.0194850098,
0.0021578949,
0.0505818874,
0.0665708855,
0.0159134567,
0.0456997417,
0.0680225939,
0.0172837004,
0.0121261124,
0.0346108004,
-0.015015644,
0.0117466189,
-0.0184919033,
-0.0125927459,
-0.0414716676,
0.0306827445,
0.058138676,
-0.0433262549,
-0.0297748744,
-0.0461768173,
2.482e-7,
0.0714127347,
0.0531962179,
0.0333066732,
0.0354011618,
0.0302277301,
0.0203504935,
-0.0383029133,
0.04433956,
0.0174649432,
-0.0057763397,
0.0469913781,
0.0716131926,
-0.0376253985,
0.0346653461,
-0.041826725,
0.070249036,
-0.0690342188,
-0.014953617,
-0.0377710126,
0.031049367,
0.0197521951,
0.0719171092,
0.0190535951,
-0.0026943781,
-0.0363485515,
-0.0810557678,
0.093923986,
-0.03170304,
-0.0224720258,
0.0193826891,
-0.0155998478,
0.0104058273,
-0.0187911801,
0.022209933,
0.0271278135,
0.0440895483,
0.0316092595,
0.0240214281,
-0.0205975678,
0.0362401158,
0.0045777117,
-0.0337428302,
-0.0132252593,
-0.0301052127,
0.0582574718,
-0.0764712617,
-0.074333109,
-0.0337833986,
-0.0186803322,
-0.0174653139,
-0.0057526412,
0.0086715911,
-0.0144581739,
0.0294194315,
0.014961388,
-0.0198213682,
0.0283702575,
-0.0315673798,
0.030664295,
0.0300870016,
-0.0170490481,
-0.0595154688,
0.008050709,
0.0256982446,
0.0047254632,
-0.0052169468,
0.061978884,
2.35029167e-34,
0.0441021621,
0.0153725957,
-0.0085534593,
0.0195803382,
0.0362300538,
-0.0482581556,
-0.0409173407,
0.030594077,
0.0344351456,
-0.125308767,
0.0056535206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05122v1 | History of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) chatbots: past, present, and future development | 2024-02-04T05:01:38 | 2024-02-04T05:01:38 | Md. Al-Amin, Mohammad Shazed Ali, Abdus Salam, Arif Khan, Ashraf Ali, Ahsan Ullah, Md Nur Alam, Shamsul Kabir Chowdhury | cs.GL | cs.GL, cs.CL, cs.HC | This research provides an in-depth comprehensive review of the progress of
chatbot technology over time, from the initial basic systems relying on rules
to today's advanced conversational bots powered by artificial intelligence.
Spanning many decades, the paper explores the major milestones, innovations,
and paradigm shifts that have driven the evolution of chatbots. Looking back at
the very basic statistical model in 1906 via the early chatbots, such as ELIZA
and ALICE in the 1960s and 1970s, the study traces key innovations leading to
today's advanced conversational agents, such as ChatGPT and Google Bard. The
study synthesizes insights from academic literature and industry sources to
highlight crucial milestones, including the introduction of Turing tests,
influential projects such as CALO, and recent transformer-based models. Tracing
the path forward, the paper highlights how natural language processing and
machine learning have been integrated into modern chatbots for more
sophisticated capabilities. This chronological survey of the chatbot landscape
provides a holistic reference to understand the technological and historical
factors propelling conversational AI. By synthesizing learnings from this
historical analysis, the research offers important context about the
developmental trajectory of chatbots and their immense future potential across
various field of application which could be the potential take ways for the
respective research community and stakeholders. | [
0.1012767479,
-0.0032924083,
-0.0531870648,
-0.0310094617,
-0.0458823033,
-0.0196648296,
0.0259582698,
0.0198964067,
0.060607139,
-0.0411509648,
0.026662115,
0.0107542491,
-0.0331898257,
0.0584421754,
0.0053840885,
-0.058043316,
0.0024868441,
0.0081390236,
0.0018716857,
0.0219102278,
-0.0076143146,
0.0167059526,
-0.0269257482,
0.0843256786,
-0.0671313778,
-0.0042571835,
-0.027787352,
-0.0162012745,
-0.0091952728,
-0.0009508678,
-0.0072886902,
0.015868092,
0.0109348791,
0.0487013012,
0.0000018375,
-0.064125292,
0.0086806249,
0.016858317,
-0.050351426,
-0.0766110495,
0.0501841046,
0.0389219373,
-0.0328190513,
0.0398322642,
-0.0688512176,
0.0357033238,
0.0636419132,
0.0194849651,
0.0258744452,
0.0747133344,
-0.0237439219,
-0.0079551646,
0.0599656627,
0.0128137218,
0.0137413852,
-0.0423388667,
-0.0226038676,
0.0137886787,
0.0391659252,
-0.0223146323,
-0.0297123361,
0.0213947464,
0.0333286226,
-0.0353140682,
-0.0150270676,
0.0399995893,
-0.0537137948,
-0.0767128468,
-0.0357881524,
0.0348408446,
0.0278076734,
-0.0034058725,
0.0114987129,
0.0175884459,
0.0251564961,
0.0057819407,
-0.0034313563,
0.020643428,
-0.0121160075,
-0.0211684778,
-0.0023974522,
-0.0200206395,
-0.0257177874,
0.0014116603,
-0.0178663526,
0.0189533606,
0.0014748903,
-0.0243835524,
-0.0077773347,
0.0058744396,
0.0300261825,
-0.0680111721,
0.0025063115,
0.0560145453,
-0.0117667969,
0.0046534706,
-0.0188493691,
0.0048276838,
-0.0118420757,
-0.0299652498,
-0.032756649,
0.0353979208,
-0.00382479,
0.0265245307,
0.0054543824,
0.0889473632,
-0.0024335885,
-0.0079394104,
-0.0159262586,
-0.0210958011,
-0.0770324767,
-0.0320498422,
-0.0445013978,
0.0401123464,
0.0124894045,
-0.0225727055,
-0.0166870486,
0.0826626495,
0.000560027,
-0.0100730462,
-0.0205915179,
0.0102990111,
-0.0192630701,
0.0236021411,
-0.0532172285,
-0.0217384286,
-0.0351647809,
0.0015917128,
0.0288054794,
-0.0945383683,
0.0106805926,
0.0182076674,
0.0007671349,
0.0002337907,
0.0058185495,
0.08849933,
0.0023857269,
-0.064563781,
0.0291591231,
-0.0102728223,
-0.0119545618,
-0.0702842996,
0.0182469636,
-0.0280591119,
0.0279363506,
0.0169873089,
0.0031927216,
-0.0037686534,
0.0079093482,
0.006966,
-0.0100985197,
0.0124794841,
-0.0121819461,
0.0150784161,
0.0436204225,
-0.0013528861,
-0.0253343135,
0.0465248302,
0.0489808992,
0.0122918533,
0.0245744772,
-0.0092130657,
0.082418099,
0.0116541926,
-0.0399528556,
-0.0611326285,
0.030507654,
-0.0194520112,
-0.0319463052,
0.0218429901,
-0.0214074459,
0.0570365228,
-0.0463470258,
0.0192323755,
0.0504460596,
0.0722583607,
-0.0052482039,
0.0674744844,
0.0749919489,
0.0185223408,
0.0370008834,
-0.0122834835,
-0.0139387343,
0.0070809424,
-0.0289339628,
-0.0320894532,
-0.0239194855,
0.0094973966,
-0.0245904569,
-0.0587341785,
0.0415694155,
-0.0272150952,
0.0465573333,
-0.02589125,
0.0430946201,
0.0101870038,
-0.0317599513,
-0.025802847,
-0.0042443974,
-0.0482949279,
-0.0684363022,
-0.0977274105,
0.0043217768,
0.0921789855,
0.0662334263,
0.0005741166,
-0.0227121189,
-0.007027681,
-0.0339878723,
0.0692396164,
0.0077156164,
0.0211790446,
-0.0149167236,
-0.0031451334,
0.0093842503,
0.0059992275,
-0.0219874494,
-0.0018632016,
-0.0143023431,
0.0198285244,
-0.0270513035,
0.0536059998,
0.0187293161,
0.0213543028,
-0.0082651498,
-0.0026526994,
-0.0290004499,
-0.0106700277,
0.0476494543,
0.0345897228,
-0.0166729204,
0.0027605246,
0.0102793593,
0.0030107775,
-0.0219070278,
0.0659861863,
0.0014664746,
0.0050769015,
0.0245456025,
-0.0734542161,
-0.0102075618,
0.0431081057,
0.0071342648,
-0.0241678748,
0.0220236108,
-0.0894432515,
0.0593535267,
-0.0312677994,
0.0305262376,
-0.0366269834,
0.0354589708,
-0.0078726429,
0.0417636447,
0.0202209949,
-0.0433650948,
0.0049054907,
0.0171665438,
0.0009086414,
-0.0322873145,
-0.005694719,
0.0363427997,
-0.0021166746,
0.0148166874,
0.0430347957,
0.0041556861,
-0.0402239338,
-0.0317024328,
-0.0966455042,
-0.0321160518,
0.0247054063,
-0.0315885022,
-0.0019169002,
-0.0092780516,
0.0016804152,
-0.0106580239,
-0.0262383763,
0.0586712994,
0.0151366135,
0.0017782354,
0.0687888563,
-0.0229838509,
-0.0795702115,
-0.0480282865,
0.0141586363,
-0.0149686737,
-0.0043025822,
0.0794488266,
-0.0158297736,
-0.0428691357,
0.0268323664,
-0.0287811309,
0.045464348,
-0.0304905251,
-0.0304068774,
0.0527257062,
-0.0035090621,
0.0400440916,
0.047241848,
0.0561803803,
0.0893796757,
0.0107821459,
0.0176969264,
-0.0416904651,
0.0357861109,
-0.0247300938,
0.0019662345,
-0.0162430834,
-0.0278854575,
0.0133477785,
0.0372612551,
-0.0131758219,
0.0245280676,
-0.0410935879,
0.0632449389,
0.0308435764,
-0.0791582093,
0.0141721107,
-0.0046976698,
-0.0335896909,
0.0409112051,
-0.0032168287,
-0.0444395207,
0.0650782883,
-0.0038913267,
-0.0174264852,
-0.0238615591,
-0.0373486392,
0.0129919695,
0.0699331239,
0.0093353437,
0.0012282548,
0.0246297922,
-0.0265455712,
-0.0474536382,
0.0004207207,
0.0187387913,
-0.0553959869,
-0.0290066656,
-0.0162745919,
0.0120849116,
0.0194686782,
-0.0241915826,
-0.0533206686,
-0.0356230102,
-0.0310071055,
0.0107163079,
0.063026607,
-0.0473320968,
-0.0626820549,
-0.0000432347,
-0.0037740327,
0.0422584042,
0.040165104,
-0.031782005,
-0.0303005744,
-0.0508467332,
0.0018910578,
0.0437912792,
0.0054342151,
0.055932913,
0.0652673468,
0.0382520333,
0.0119651565,
-0.0076182173,
-0.0264358651,
-0.030806141,
0.0115076862,
-0.017583536,
-0.0178360939,
0.0216726474,
0.0130117638,
-0.0312822871,
-0.0017891717,
0.0750072077,
0.0087912586,
-0.0190397166,
0.004477032,
-0.0155802649,
-0.0400709696,
0.0025602637,
0.0609874465,
-0.0819261372,
0.0091473013,
0.008639968,
0.0047919014,
-0.0660279021,
-0.0297779627,
0.0024224708,
-0.1066312939,
0.0551438369,
-0.0504745506,
-0.0474208556,
-0.050797835,
-0.0202641971,
-0.0409083851,
0.0201709624,
0.014895346,
-0.0108294524,
0.0140062263,
-0.0322656035,
0.0035199784,
-0.0768190622,
0.0124685336,
0.0363870263,
-0.0383258536,
0.0717415437,
0.0823227987,
0.0787998959,
0.0069674728,
0.0318714827,
-0.0217240639,
0.0717161968,
0.0339416452,
0.0008926651,
0.0648501366,
-0.0000221601,
-0.01222903,
-0.0408046953,
-0.0135362027,
0.0098153437,
0.0197691843,
0.0165456906,
0.0296447519,
-0.0634835809,
-0.0263763722,
-0.0433383286,
0.0346738398,
0.022207614,
0.0288520977,
-0.004467085,
-0.0515616499,
-0.0597116575,
-0.0332783684,
0.0484897718,
-0.0028533351,
-0.0576545373,
-0.0402258672,
0.0085236551,
-0.0573538914,
-0.0969813839,
-0.0390151516,
0.0138486978,
0.0205919091,
0.0250469986,
-0.0316288956,
0.0282872934,
0.0292850528,
-0.0106436107,
-0.02860949,
-0.0037477768,
-0.0340194032,
-0.0414887592,
-0.0571002178,
0.0073712696,
-0.0860912576,
0.0033893797,
0.0160844363,
-0.0083127012,
-0.0265685692,
0.0232093986,
0.052848205,
0.0310490355,
-0.002070717,
-0.0317151994,
-0.0145935351,
0.0219772644,
0.0542540476,
-0.019569166,
-0.0020939077,
0.0384165384,
0.0387449637,
-0.0069706975,
0.0060417778,
-0.0429256372,
0.0059529832,
-0.0443832763,
-0.0088683534,
-0.0134879695,
-0.03446633,
0.0530551784,
0.0238593537,
-0.0007750641,
0.0025900863,
0.0208311975,
0.0139350444,
-0.0082653826,
-0.0588269755,
0.0172533076,
-0.0477378555,
-0.0309571214,
-0.0292720925,
0.0293902792,
0.0413574912,
0.0025539845,
-0.059112832,
0.0213027988,
0.0137436911,
0.0179924257,
0.0364320427,
0.070462361,
-0.0109696276,
-0.0056535136,
0.0088348938,
0.0401047841,
-0.0055600936,
0.0504491143,
0.0291195381,
0.0686807558,
-0.0145377461,
-0.0250006355,
-0.0112664429,
0.0428133644,
-0.1102825999,
-0.1045178846,
0.0385437123,
0.0656684935,
0.0253149644,
0.0487813465,
0.0230433755,
-0.0423362814,
0.0089850361,
-0.0007238001,
0.0308148731,
0.0076900525,
-0.0063427412,
-0.0436496548,
0.005041556,
-0.0122495806,
-0.0170356128,
0.0347650014,
-0.0268445145,
0.0487959981,
-0.0186556838,
-0.031261228,
-0.0335645936,
-0.0481971651,
-0.0026319476,
-0.0408102274,
0.0372787081,
-0.0123660164,
-0.030130608,
-0.0323485881,
-0.0211376883,
0.024638474,
0.0129367998,
-0.034155529,
0.0533907339,
0.0515915304,
-0.0036668233,
-0.0438707769,
-0.0515595637,
0.0083724093,
-0.0260160677,
0.0194528773,
-0.0029557375,
-5.609593122e-33,
0.0074482104,
-0.0205804016,
0.0556490012,
0.0531655811,
-0.0275012273,
-0.0266714245,
-0.0335516818,
0.0173261426,
-0.040206302,
0.0066901851,
-0.0623122565,
0.02896869,
0.0074356948,
-0.0304687601,
0.0178530253,
-0.0156289767,
0.041063711,
-0.0234972052,
-0.0179932658,
0.0303355232,
0.0168119334,
-0.0033473913,
0.0125640193,
-0.0463110842,
0.0283751078,
-0.000264528,
-0.0134347901,
-0.0142003829,
0.0035127834,
0.0141993258,
0.0016078359,
0.0176600292,
0.0290649701,
-0.0184146818,
-0.0019651193,
0.0388531126,
-0.0268468391,
-0.0177550018,
-0.0239272844,
-0.0034760905,
-0.0159628727,
-0.0251041055,
0.0150287105,
-0.0201066677,
-0.0415466353,
0.0172430389,
0.033338774,
-0.0049307994,
0.0428661443,
-0.0002132713,
-0.0705379993,
-0.0078574903,
-0.0415449999,
-0.0639551878,
-0.0008528635,
0.0540608875,
-0.0050235945,
-0.0238028392,
-0.0086473739,
0.0718859732,
-0.0148542514,
-0.0559085347,
0.0414283201,
0.0067096343,
0.0355080515,
0.0505290963,
0.0943029746,
0.0468376838,
-0.0479109399,
-0.0182421841,
0.0127272122,
0.0483863465,
0.0268056616,
0.0177372377,
-0.0210884735,
-0.0309105366,
-0.0380427055,
0.0080334153,
0.0867054909,
0.0205291919,
0.0175403021,
-0.0078921327,
-0.0931228474,
0.0065126587,
0.0178870987,
0.0081283925,
-0.0024244003,
-0.0433681384,
0.0049922718,
0.0008833341,
0.0248469878,
-0.0492316745,
0.0226044729,
-0.0810859054,
0.0385443792,
-0.0039692898,
-0.0353047773,
0.0331564173,
0.0084345797,
-0.0293275286,
-0.0232050419,
-0.0560289696,
0.0451977439,
0.0280452427,
0.0393739939,
0.0166805163,
-0.0438823141,
0.0521778911,
0.0049491553,
-0.0115521634,
-0.0114993732,
0.0333191454,
0.0075722551,
-0.0396808237,
-0.0059221392,
0.0323431157,
-0.0241034087,
-0.0022306107,
0.0245455466,
0.0497621819,
-0.0519580878,
0.0137982098,
-0.0066285026,
-0.0186198745,
-0.0335912816,
-0.015915405,
-0.0542107895,
0.0455772541,
0.0182733107,
-0.0495000109,
-0.0286509711,
-0.0282713883,
2.66e-7,
0.0017385349,
0.0445427708,
0.047100354,
0.0100041591,
0.010708198,
0.0179254636,
0.0218681134,
0.0072048982,
0.019678684,
0.052742295,
0.0127976006,
0.0253734589,
0.0152423754,
0.0044242023,
-0.0736040846,
-0.0636457503,
-0.0417260975,
-0.0313815027,
-0.0207546223,
0.0274006967,
0.0666849688,
0.0599629395,
0.0003288058,
-0.036417339,
-0.0033537953,
-0.0139677301,
0.0013163437,
-0.0475283004,
0.014014909,
0.027081145,
0.0094953217,
0.0366281196,
0.0083658379,
0.0388695672,
0.0218588077,
0.0243844613,
-0.0043966002,
0.015696574,
0.007663697,
0.0013902861,
0.0343520381,
0.0271670464,
0.0059215627,
-0.0312293936,
0.0455129258,
-0.0404210873,
-0.0496456064,
-0.0260448512,
-0.0234019384,
0.0006998157,
-0.0035320804,
-0.0218053479,
-0.0165959168,
0.0073280502,
-0.0234103687,
0.0086710844,
0.0148325143,
-0.0338172615,
0.0349394977,
-0.023054257,
-0.0490537547,
-0.0918396786,
-0.0163192134,
-0.0179960001,
0.047910586,
0.0174721982,
0.0361573286,
1.721404718e-34,
-0.0066048359,
0.0055533908,
0.0235468484,
0.0567420721,
0.0263345372,
0.0378535353,
0.0307572614,
0.0109498315,
0.0315613151,
-0.0338221826,
-0.0299395379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02330v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02330v2 | Enhance Reasoning for Large Language Models in the Game Werewolf | 2024-02-04T03:47:10 | 2024-03-29T09:01:56 | Shuang Wu, Liwen Zhu, Tao Yang, Shiwei Xu, Qiang Fu, Yang Wei, Haobo Fu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper presents an innovative framework that integrates Large Language
Models (LLMs) with an external Thinker module to enhance the reasoning
capabilities of LLM-based agents. Unlike augmenting LLMs with prompt
engineering, Thinker directly harnesses knowledge from databases and employs
various optimization techniques. The framework forms a reasoning hierarchy
where LLMs handle intuitive System-1 tasks such as natural language processing,
while the Thinker focuses on cognitive System-2 tasks that require complex
logical analysis and domain-specific knowledge. Our framework is presented
using a 9-player Werewolf game that demands dual-system reasoning. We introduce
a communication protocol between LLMs and the Thinker, and train the Thinker
using data from 18800 human sessions and reinforcement learning. Experiments
demonstrate the framework's effectiveness in deductive reasoning, speech
generation, and online game evaluation. Additionally, we fine-tune a 6B LLM to
surpass GPT4 when integrated with the Thinker. This paper also contributes the
largest dataset for social deduction games to date. | [
0.046161741,
0.032570038,
-0.0253624916,
0.0749412477,
-0.0442884304,
0.0131601337,
0.0037155263,
-0.0321585871,
0.039966315,
-0.0184217691,
-0.0112686036,
0.0126739545,
-0.0109043252,
0.0381159112,
0.0252126269,
0.0037969486,
0.0308193844,
-0.0646068305,
0.0412993766,
-0.0142869987,
-0.0291433968,
0.0085590221,
-0.0202739313,
0.0258556791,
0.007569673,
-0.0197069533,
-0.0366649963,
0.0089508686,
0.0339401476,
-0.0409102179,
-0.0545541942,
-0.0093933949,
0.0546351746,
0.0346234702,
0.0000020056,
-0.0578653105,
-0.0009131805,
-0.014483612,
-0.0263105053,
-0.0210753027,
-0.018097572,
0.0340769999,
0.0055138287,
0.0224097259,
-0.0421133377,
0.0132833337,
0.0381753556,
0.0357814394,
0.0776136145,
0.0651276037,
0.0087150652,
-0.0527811535,
0.00759474,
-0.0064281123,
0.0316138789,
-0.0473311096,
0.0202150121,
0.0367832147,
0.0628843531,
-0.0267423149,
0.0031046281,
0.0061177663,
0.0430414192,
-0.0016795537,
-0.0629070476,
0.0438688435,
-0.021081375,
0.0145982876,
-0.0207428727,
0.0456903614,
0.0079251006,
-0.0199826024,
0.0003531235,
0.0292184334,
0.0103888838,
0.007070668,
-0.0058977134,
0.0841392055,
-0.0265262369,
0.0003026546,
0.0099754035,
-0.001039556,
0.0493995287,
0.0197180919,
-0.0597764403,
0.1360329688,
-0.0069966852,
-0.0163010061,
0.0032774026,
-0.007725127,
-0.0556222983,
-0.0572312959,
-0.0045270021,
0.0577194765,
-0.0766954795,
0.0308799148,
-0.0103597902,
0.0145017086,
0.0025475975,
0.0044997223,
0.0107063651,
0.0261774138,
0.0285655092,
0.0665235147,
-0.0080649974,
0.0313484073,
-0.0147259459,
0.0073502488,
0.0082457019,
-0.0195703842,
-0.0586421676,
-0.0204917453,
-0.0395635329,
0.0325307809,
-0.020838799,
-0.0134349242,
-0.0130814509,
0.0434074551,
-0.013308038,
0.0336718112,
-0.0106939916,
0.0103200991,
-0.0118097449,
-0.0324859284,
-0.0558422282,
0.0064504617,
-0.0633539706,
0.0192703959,
0.0414515585,
-0.0863757282,
-0.0100504607,
-0.0299124159,
0.0066104098,
-0.0114439521,
0.0280526467,
0.0930680856,
-0.0060968483,
-0.0147599308,
-0.031273257,
-0.0363977738,
0.0082624685,
-0.1077230051,
-0.0453318506,
-0.0788606033,
0.0135556832,
0.0033675833,
0.0011280888,
-0.025540825,
0.0213423371,
0.0011730583,
0.0074751684,
0.1088998839,
-0.014349293,
0.0085176313,
0.0130920252,
0.019206753,
-0.0064763194,
0.0714823455,
0.054360535,
0.0394979678,
-0.0078552123,
0.0311519802,
0.0359309651,
0.0307849385,
-0.0065621831,
-0.0257897023,
-0.0266213398,
0.0103506111,
-0.029141685,
0.0471295416,
-0.0213216599,
0.0582325235,
-0.0373143479,
-0.0068156119,
0.0782776698,
0.0646796525,
-0.0051355562,
0.0278134737,
0.0568068288,
0.0224239733,
-0.0211818982,
-0.0382335447,
-0.0324706882,
0.033342611,
-0.0379040577,
-0.0023659242,
-0.0275439937,
0.0279750247,
0.0003195849,
-0.0234788228,
0.0171043854,
-0.0063989372,
0.0621159673,
0.0482582822,
0.0240718164,
-0.0000805061,
-0.0341904834,
0.0309887528,
0.0208436083,
-0.0473819561,
-0.0245933272,
-0.0631525666,
0.0512013435,
0.067413792,
0.0672198832,
-0.0383671075,
-0.0369125418,
-0.0126611022,
-0.0011789205,
0.0726598948,
-0.0013937915,
-0.0035315054,
0.0108996537,
-0.034075018,
-0.0226794612,
-0.0238134097,
0.0121379644,
0.0579232499,
-0.0062191398,
0.0113299442,
-0.01208751,
0.0048424122,
0.009382871,
0.0052020606,
-0.023794746,
-0.0182105936,
-0.0237455685,
0.0084363939,
0.0314886607,
-0.0015324606,
-0.0093681449,
0.008749607,
0.024272874,
-0.0203138739,
-0.0216700006,
0.0091656419,
-0.0018513117,
-0.040877793,
0.04662247,
-0.0173311327,
-0.0149491075,
0.0184285305,
-0.0023574722,
-0.0047392906,
0.0248002037,
-0.0691133738,
0.0586884692,
-0.0245055016,
0.0030750337,
-0.0207301546,
-0.0164600648,
-0.0174796991,
0.0815641284,
0.0173769742,
-0.0411411226,
-0.010732729,
0.0001683161,
0.0181663986,
-0.0742394626,
0.0353788547,
0.0065393518,
-0.0035980828,
-0.0008495511,
0.038773492,
0.0025387618,
-0.0575968027,
-0.0386001244,
-0.0713679343,
0.0301048681,
-0.0056933705,
0.0157610793,
-0.0136207109,
0.0095421216,
-0.0066514234,
0.0108277928,
-0.0392283238,
-0.0032372628,
0.0137703251,
0.0100652128,
0.0202953015,
0.0362112671,
-0.0446780734,
0.0179491378,
0.0132047832,
-0.0237409249,
0.0173537713,
0.0033144664,
0.0070980242,
-0.0436584689,
0.0313759446,
-0.0826811865,
0.0310778916,
-0.0166693013,
-0.0603961125,
0.0534344949,
-0.018875394,
0.0403665192,
0.0865925923,
0.0093410071,
0.0086900825,
0.061989069,
-0.0476008765,
-0.0441551954,
0.0432830527,
-0.000442644,
-0.0119431429,
-0.0646432862,
-0.0218199864,
0.0114527252,
0.047265701,
-0.0192758311,
-0.0043285796,
-0.0401367471,
0.0537555665,
0.0365573317,
-0.0569868349,
-0.024884183,
-0.0216542203,
-0.0030060566,
0.0284375623,
-0.0224845745,
-0.0007700741,
0.0967423916,
-0.0199627466,
-0.001911878,
-0.0130052352,
-0.0122699924,
-0.0404335745,
0.0827498659,
0.0084398342,
-0.0020307589,
-0.0266531166,
-0.0147323813,
-0.0383377299,
-0.0451268479,
0.0613847561,
-0.0150154727,
0.0219615791,
-0.067135185,
0.0005728421,
0.0391021706,
-0.029418258,
-0.043855682,
0.016178254,
-0.0927745402,
-0.0166942403,
-0.0102795651,
-0.0272042509,
-0.0674518719,
-0.0192651711,
0.0640394315,
-0.004242056,
-0.003217292,
-0.0122875236,
-0.0298754591,
-0.0230708811,
0.0563220903,
0.0295254849,
0.0403028652,
-0.046126131,
0.0550512858,
0.0462515019,
-0.0139375152,
-0.0454643704,
-0.0390129238,
0.0251514502,
-0.0054770918,
-0.015871672,
0.0094590178,
0.038450852,
0.0282788537,
-0.0839819759,
-0.0072129988,
0.1115141287,
0.0227821246,
0.0033572575,
0.0039143572,
-0.0240984932,
0.0270242691,
0.0153282769,
0.0303913727,
-0.0894619077,
-0.0663193986,
0.0073090172,
-0.0256185904,
-0.0235541891,
-0.0575064272,
-0.0229591373,
-0.1084455103,
0.0161589272,
0.0041210107,
-0.0050812154,
0.0074982662,
0.0185360536,
-0.0058698221,
-0.0212298594,
-0.0332541876,
0.0097349044,
0.0217025131,
-0.004688092,
-0.0204494763,
0.0168093834,
0.023211835,
0.0340670384,
-0.0542030893,
0.0484745093,
0.0500311926,
0.0606622472,
0.0032388379,
-0.0565338582,
0.0273054447,
0.0264730509,
-0.0045497096,
-0.0133529734,
0.0005585057,
-0.012227226,
-0.0011265181,
-0.0302063543,
0.0326102339,
0.0072891894,
-0.0535464734,
0.0195334386,
0.0759388208,
-0.0150907123,
-0.0406183414,
0.0140367504,
0.0183212068,
0.0074918997,
0.0907531083,
0.0037068697,
-0.0185445882,
-0.0410954766,
-0.0254449677,
-0.0704718754,
-0.0162386224,
-0.066787079,
-0.0261418112,
0.0344426632,
-0.0038119543,
-0.0531194806,
-0.009669899,
0.0332635455,
0.0336831026,
-0.0058609759,
0.0233701058,
0.0150234597,
0.0496935733,
-0.0251445211,
0.0092800539,
-0.0571972281,
0.0079399198,
0.001622003,
0.0073077241,
-0.001615525,
-0.0558660105,
-0.0075233714,
0.0616876557,
-0.0233490169,
-0.0519593246,
-0.0084911501,
0.0322813503,
0.0304745492,
0.0328911468,
-0.010489787,
-0.058704555,
0.0493878014,
0.0360841379,
-0.0471057184,
-0.008929668,
0.0066647241,
0.0478354879,
0.0508028716,
0.0415853523,
-0.0446567982,
0.0124120433,
0.0199330002,
0.0338154398,
-0.0226416197,
0.0104672294,
0.021600198,
0.0344109833,
-0.0035567167,
-0.0127830915,
-0.0180064831,
-0.0076580178,
0.0282775257,
-0.0788829252,
-0.0111471498,
-0.0498887487,
0.0080231829,
0.0077656587,
0.0090643242,
0.0162073225,
-0.0304846205,
0.0150941154,
0.0060688364,
0.0357172899,
0.0030603637,
0.0475937575,
0.0129849687,
0.03901181,
-0.0224805512,
0.008253119,
0.0172745455,
0.0056130807,
0.0495519713,
0.0246488787,
0.0627981573,
0.0488045886,
-0.0490508452,
-0.0252464898,
0.0159982964,
-0.0521134324,
-0.0820454136,
0.0891861394,
0.0461692959,
0.0371164046,
0.0603296869,
0.0031132994,
-0.0491003729,
0.0021654847,
0.008753337,
0.0307295453,
0.02919662,
-0.0695947036,
-0.0018044295,
0.0506230369,
-0.0440117046,
0.0045032399,
0.0196938831,
-0.0089801354,
0.0341887362,
0.0151308002,
-0.0230378881,
-0.048706349,
-0.0125115076,
-0.037393555,
0.0191276576,
-0.0167550575,
0.0205033682,
-0.0761171281,
-0.0434363484,
-0.0261699837,
0.0670864806,
-0.0022568274,
0.0200632624,
0.0348067395,
0.0032668898,
0.002950446,
-0.0744383559,
-0.0239732731,
0.038522549,
-0.0306625348,
-0.0201895107,
0.0024386619,
-5.82936024e-33,
-0.0281394515,
-0.0365600325,
0.0690812692,
0.0078040902,
-0.0346428975,
-0.0331528708,
-0.063251093,
0.0017723819,
0.0045539476,
0.0249138866,
0.0073203188,
0.0379634574,
0.0062794136,
-0.0003945434,
-0.0148830935,
-0.0280430745,
0.0052616051,
0.0275377221,
-0.043500632,
0.0220082439,
0.0326451175,
-0.0017880998,
0.0239163823,
-0.0333197825,
-0.033733312,
-0.0020291666,
-0.0278276373,
0.0550170764,
-0.0434612855,
0.0152185503,
-0.0172995813,
-0.0135098286,
0.0016332071,
-0.0301800221,
0.0110577689,
0.020297898,
-0.0328338444,
-0.010094814,
0.0259572845,
-0.0190573279,
-0.0325492024,
-0.0447694473,
0.0142663829,
-0.0054414766,
0.004474571,
-0.0068958411,
0.0116021251,
-0.0482227802,
0.0355491489,
0.0054213186,
-0.043963369,
0.0031383988,
-0.0337757729,
-0.0195560399,
0.0071506165,
0.0222052652,
-0.0302982759,
-0.0013193954,
-0.0195491686,
0.0561454855,
0.0243154615,
-0.0429674797,
0.0662437305,
-0.0008014949,
0.0383772403,
0.0470630117,
0.0197521169,
-0.0073305881,
-0.0878723785,
-0.01635902,
0.0039954442,
0.0962199122,
0.0604865961,
0.0404280536,
-0.0245567486,
0.0302808061,
-0.0888010263,
0.0059132446,
0.0787132606,
0.0587938875,
0.0368564278,
0.006166087,
-0.0272097066,
0.0044230036,
-0.0190807767,
0.0253274124,
-0.0209046509,
-0.044665426,
0.0133881904,
-0.0181178339,
-0.0168313719,
-0.0311821289,
0.0214182604,
-0.0494029038,
-0.0048736371,
0.0325895436,
-0.0069198404,
-0.0181159098,
-0.0123341689,
-0.0052173538,
-0.0224065538,
-0.0013029429,
0.0345317833,
-0.0063229841,
0.0199885387,
0.0207206197,
-0.0141593143,
0.0224135015,
-0.0207111053,
-0.0124283917,
-0.0571104512,
0.0289333016,
0.0000581076,
0.0098283272,
0.0362403356,
-0.0201819055,
-0.0140258353,
-0.0200978573,
-0.0201784074,
-0.0325527936,
-0.0162061397,
0.0545175821,
-0.0230027977,
0.0088716084,
-0.0186705254,
-0.021281762,
-0.0690267757,
-0.0034151601,
-0.0145464409,
-0.0308163315,
-0.0133257909,
-0.0244329143,
2.877e-7,
-0.0203249417,
0.0542247519,
-0.0141898831,
0.0427998416,
0.0225159321,
0.0567013137,
-0.0359779894,
0.0156504903,
0.0241770633,
-0.0702247918,
0.0008197877,
0.0706363246,
0.0409636982,
0.0267340988,
-0.0750943199,
-0.0025767605,
-0.0116960993,
-0.0431245528,
-0.0628551841,
-0.0144014107,
0.0292146988,
0.0473965295,
0.0546552613,
-0.0119287325,
0.0395323448,
-0.0325521231,
0.0235533006,
-0.0431038253,
-0.0156746041,
0.0031436982,
0.0320257321,
0.0070258211,
-0.0047534998,
0.0185934026,
0.0110590486,
0.0098318886,
-0.0569003932,
0.0426881649,
0.0011040864,
-0.0181305315,
-0.0272573438,
-0.0169271529,
-0.0136389434,
-0.0399237126,
0.0631560981,
-0.0430131815,
-0.0623513572,
0.0211694818,
-0.0025995611,
-0.05022569,
-0.0558121763,
-0.0200735498,
-0.012493005,
-0.0099061877,
-0.000129752,
-0.0267549623,
0.0084132683,
-0.0668035746,
-0.0118951844,
-0.0003318175,
-0.0567125715,
-0.0525343865,
-0.0355035588,
0.0100687938,
0.029094778,
-0.0700994357,
0.0025449686,
2.508330457e-34,
0.0206482839,
0.0095589319,
0.0078879623,
0.0134820677,
0.0645639449,
0.0295427982,
-0.0426085219,
0.0198416691,
0.0671756417,
-0.0800656006,
-0.0058370498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02318v1 | Diversity Measurement and Subset Selection for Instruction Tuning Datasets | 2024-02-04T02:09:43 | 2024-02-04T02:09:43 | Peiqi Wang, Yikang Shen, Zhen Guo, Matthew Stallone, Yoon Kim, Polina Golland, Rameswar Panda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We aim to select data subsets for the fine-tuning of large language models to
more effectively follow instructions. Prior work has emphasized the importance
of diversity in dataset curation but relied on heuristics such as the number of
tasks. In this paper, we use determinantal point processes to capture the
diversity and quality of instruction tuning datasets for subset selection. We
propose to measure dataset diversity with log determinant distance that is the
distance between the dataset of interest and a maximally diverse reference
dataset. Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed diversity measure in the
normalized weight gradient space is correlated with downstream
instruction-following performance. Consequently, it can be used to inform when
data selection is the most helpful and to analyze dataset curation strategies.
We demonstrate the utility of our approach on various instruction tuning
datasets. | [
-0.005480085,
0.0444767363,
-0.0279761497,
0.0197097529,
-0.0284090005,
0.0459053181,
0.0369390175,
0.0190460905,
-0.0136827119,
-0.0099513968,
-0.0315877907,
-0.0361599922,
0.0247932747,
-0.0311728008,
0.0408089608,
-0.0369187519,
0.0477952324,
-0.0746383443,
-0.0464856252,
-0.0336693823,
-0.029972624,
-0.0225370899,
-0.0074536172,
0.0512346141,
0.0281237774,
-0.0124138901,
0.017087847,
0.0233663749,
0.0091316085,
-0.016793659,
0.0233660266,
0.0683062598,
0.0363720059,
-0.0008715684,
0.0000018789,
-0.0364070348,
0.0163891558,
0.0061176871,
-0.0405115858,
-0.0002493264,
-0.0310118627,
0.0197211262,
0.0030158304,
-0.0054097557,
0.0212364141,
0.0119764302,
0.0641110167,
-0.0136448452,
0.0232742149,
0.0777807012,
0.006523421,
-0.0170999728,
-0.0136080347,
-0.0245327838,
0.0298528336,
0.0246250015,
0.0100441836,
0.0407593139,
0.0354341529,
0.0311607234,
-0.0416260324,
0.0061989482,
0.0102779102,
0.0270817708,
0.0219833422,
0.0185496304,
-0.0183225404,
0.0098530566,
-0.0031766591,
0.0697890744,
-0.0123587586,
-0.0027879649,
0.0039010574,
-0.034130048,
0.0120980199,
0.0033394166,
-0.0462885164,
0.0151220514,
-0.0182798132,
-0.0076408815,
0.0254425071,
-0.0346450247,
0.0181211885,
-0.0437073484,
-0.0061068302,
0.0434850901,
0.0298222359,
-0.065485321,
0.0005844251,
0.013878963,
-0.0279824883,
-0.0372024365,
-0.0332160369,
-0.0117243426,
-0.037529856,
0.0154786482,
-0.0642890632,
-0.0268254206,
0.0047490643,
-0.0082978979,
0.1071029827,
0.0423267782,
-0.0305432286,
0.0204200521,
0.0195449218,
0.0631416515,
-0.0084797628,
0.0080950567,
-0.0360752009,
0.0395053625,
-0.0522111282,
0.0382316336,
-0.0040302328,
0.0276021156,
-0.0228756182,
0.0361637063,
-0.029726509,
0.0485559404,
0.0035860594,
-0.043778941,
0.0524658374,
-0.0367930233,
-0.0689128041,
0.0253685247,
-0.0135600464,
0.0272575375,
-0.0677808374,
0.0214335807,
-0.0009122412,
-0.0477332547,
-0.0185825396,
-0.0018095641,
-0.0013649418,
-0.0651464686,
0.0360197239,
0.0467738919,
-0.006035822,
-0.0458009541,
-0.0488902628,
0.0120681562,
-0.0138660483,
-0.0629150644,
-0.006854713,
-0.0795526877,
0.0055233506,
0.0241084304,
-0.0041465838,
-0.0320022255,
-0.0273523405,
-0.0013433539,
-0.0027940914,
0.0177704487,
0.0387737229,
0.018001575,
0.0243816469,
-0.0418476984,
-0.0310058109,
0.0884236917,
0.0032716014,
0.0043398151,
0.040709056,
-0.0320401117,
-0.0317547284,
0.020324979,
-0.0178349856,
0.0262581389,
-0.0101270061,
0.029136898,
0.0122455442,
-0.0033641427,
0.0080028847,
0.0049049561,
-0.0440257862,
0.0082271975,
0.0564705953,
0.0730498806,
0.0316726118,
-0.0373316333,
0.0527667291,
-0.0024392372,
-0.0042666723,
0.0373536199,
-0.0362929814,
0.0260593928,
0.0059029986,
-0.0022403521,
0.022703262,
0.0841685608,
-0.0356946848,
-0.0239224304,
0.0033943474,
0.0226133429,
-0.0033053833,
0.0013474344,
0.0607963689,
-0.0648859292,
-0.0384946689,
0.0171120279,
0.0488922149,
-0.0296852719,
-0.0287853628,
-0.0395388566,
0.0298789293,
0.0530640781,
0.0049778493,
-0.0222834442,
-0.0294474475,
-0.0077727279,
0.0868641064,
-0.0446710661,
0.041284997,
0.0070564789,
0.0382725932,
-0.0574851595,
-0.0668644086,
0.0078965435,
0.0162179042,
0.0634612739,
0.0064952602,
-0.0224369951,
-0.0189461354,
-0.0034580848,
-0.0790108964,
0.0479476862,
-0.0231914427,
-0.0070568528,
0.0378921628,
0.0051289494,
0.0542434379,
-0.0047209621,
-0.0302653499,
-0.0160851423,
0.0098469723,
-0.0075847148,
0.0629325286,
-0.0331282802,
-0.0203432366,
-0.0175584294,
0.0018052123,
-0.0634847134,
-0.0121280449,
0.0231493507,
-0.013564595,
-0.0484640896,
0.0274771955,
-0.0244173557,
-0.0553454868,
0.0093424898,
0.0447437875,
-0.0292986445,
0.0315665677,
-0.067485854,
0.058190871,
-0.0215481129,
0.0382154286,
0.0365448929,
0.0153086456,
0.0047266274,
-0.0635536909,
-0.0072017042,
-0.011655313,
-0.0140618058,
0.0312558115,
0.0252536964,
0.0263559502,
0.0039546019,
-0.042963583,
-0.0620470196,
0.0178306755,
-0.0484255739,
0.0353046432,
0.0328778438,
0.0056684976,
-0.0045365738,
0.0032159023,
0.0087083736,
-0.0141614629,
-0.0204632357,
0.0448691882,
0.0030136188,
0.0107214758,
-0.0495338999,
-0.0224299207,
-0.0556213483,
0.0214632601,
0.0092962459,
-0.0070652561,
0.0224678274,
-0.0666681081,
0.0299994722,
0.0126467431,
0.0359658524,
-0.0184721816,
-0.008706294,
0.055945158,
0.023362305,
0.0470502377,
0.1144862026,
-0.0331963487,
-0.0114848437,
0.0458688587,
-0.0026989845,
-0.0480114371,
0.0196921565,
-0.0209251828,
0.042516388,
-0.0560589395,
-0.052899912,
0.0174950603,
0.0493162312,
0.0310382675,
-0.0273229666,
-0.0726481751,
-0.0325794145,
-0.0403874107,
-0.0295317899,
-0.0317771509,
-0.0015278169,
-0.0263492912,
0.0013511953,
-0.0337290391,
-0.0879199579,
0.0558522083,
0.0138009796,
0.0181922186,
-0.0644831434,
-0.0138453757,
-0.0175848436,
0.0036399143,
0.0009053085,
-0.0177169796,
-0.0125426752,
-0.0020874341,
-0.062664479,
0.0434577204,
0.0532123707,
0.0057403627,
0.0985270664,
-0.0766104087,
0.0187324975,
-0.0229059365,
-0.0015794617,
-0.0060765971,
-0.013262582,
0.0721005276,
-0.0244237669,
0.0795173943,
-0.0509201586,
-0.0157811809,
0.0000749442,
0.0250286292,
0.0699312389,
-0.0455427542,
0.0037170092,
-0.0076966514,
-0.0611822158,
0.0338731743,
0.0082523609,
-0.0172881186,
-0.0820128024,
-0.0031628194,
-0.0404016636,
0.0383279808,
-0.0384864062,
-0.0061508259,
0.0481420904,
0.0215905011,
-0.0258319508,
-0.0430277772,
0.0643816441,
0.1085976064,
-0.0144664869,
-0.0270985812,
0.0672692284,
0.0172762554,
-0.0573118776,
-0.0001908075,
0.0126536367,
0.0453103296,
0.0266368594,
0.0208730604,
-0.0140125593,
-0.0116750998,
-0.031177884,
0.0457086638,
-0.0104672797,
-0.0055883205,
-0.0011043099,
-0.0585324578,
0.0209108833,
0.0021578053,
-0.0637624338,
-0.0596203618,
-0.0233709812,
0.0080374982,
-0.0461235568,
0.0277648065,
-0.004486593,
-0.034964256,
0.0044394122,
0.0640181899,
-0.0171477348,
-0.1014908105,
0.0350262746,
-0.0063230228,
0.0377256162,
0.0538419969,
-0.0146424454,
-0.0051296875,
-0.0126857329,
0.0349273607,
-0.023439642,
-0.0022635669,
0.0039658914,
0.0480919816,
0.0280613955,
-0.0233398043,
0.0396150313,
0.04602376,
-0.0109446626,
0.0407981016,
0.0256345514,
0.0524421856,
-0.0406417325,
0.0370410457,
0.01156516,
-0.0631964579,
0.0382830165,
0.027437849,
0.0419910587,
-0.0597659647,
0.0229717288,
-0.0327489898,
-0.0247103181,
-0.07356558,
0.0331119634,
0.0185460728,
-0.0673161224,
-0.0229744352,
-0.051597897,
-0.0191992968,
0.0504618511,
0.0454783924,
0.0021669623,
0.019262623,
-0.0008286739,
0.0050947084,
0.0132235931,
0.0419953316,
0.0005053579,
0.0229653344,
-0.1010604054,
-0.0864050984,
-0.041050721,
0.0020094267,
-0.0153566105,
-0.0105903894,
-0.1245109513,
-0.0780460089,
0.0342764109,
0.0511245579,
0.0185201671,
0.0341949165,
0.0128080873,
-0.0707361028,
-0.0071070585,
0.0109433541,
0.0146589605,
0.0275563262,
0.0417183153,
-0.0740109086,
-0.0255926736,
0.0032181309,
-0.0376723297,
0.0553706102,
0.0331329405,
0.0000992165,
-0.0336210169,
-0.0099826194,
-0.0231335945,
0.0039196759,
0.007473079,
-0.0187877826,
-0.0401135758,
-0.0714755505,
0.0382782109,
0.007292876,
0.0343572833,
-0.0483545139,
-0.0290944465,
0.0218425766,
-0.0186861735,
-0.0119153624,
-0.0035574909,
-0.0002696878,
0.0034615763,
-0.1014040187,
0.0459425822,
0.0159586146,
0.0622704811,
0.039982006,
0.0312829614,
0.0026850444,
0.0421203747,
-0.0033976596,
0.0093167322,
0.02677406,
0.0460819937,
-0.0022687828,
0.0475701168,
0.0137842167,
0.0196820069,
-0.068726778,
0.0008879182,
-0.0360501111,
-0.0168686192,
0.0435163341,
-0.0366417468,
0.0587625019,
0.0046511907,
0.0208704211,
-0.0487552807,
0.0247925129,
0.0159129556,
0.0125710871,
-0.0020691343,
0.039722167,
0.014652133,
-0.0217301697,
0.083383739,
-0.0014007556,
0.0394952781,
-0.0154348426,
0.0223825946,
-0.0482091643,
-0.0245421305,
0.0228909869,
-0.0019544209,
-0.0166913234,
0.0026889679,
-0.0364204533,
-0.0402124189,
-0.0422971286,
0.0079759704,
0.0407883376,
0.0008176015,
0.0326870978,
0.0308918711,
-0.0524787903,
0.0159553774,
-0.0241707209,
-0.0341728777,
0.0071080714,
-0.0168297887,
-0.0501739457,
-6.277441789e-33,
-0.0276063494,
0.0040184748,
-0.0104309348,
-0.0365894511,
0.0228627678,
-0.0002771946,
-0.0036306379,
-0.0032019753,
-0.031664364,
-0.0118816737,
-0.0110098524,
0.0142868496,
0.0125655392,
0.0086373203,
0.0334207304,
-0.0043111257,
0.027739713,
-0.0195360277,
-0.0390052758,
0.0288912244,
0.0490966477,
-0.0110393055,
0.0559076741,
0.0176411439,
0.0139627075,
-0.0160168167,
0.0221141297,
-0.0164353698,
-0.0059588039,
0.0819089264,
0.0245037694,
0.0543451011,
0.018004708,
-0.0631821975,
-0.0591540188,
-0.0589537136,
-0.0084342239,
-0.0808811933,
0.0088939723,
-0.003837249,
0.0030756181,
-0.0266781934,
0.0101692211,
0.0098556727,
-0.0538298935,
-0.0413234234,
0.0518373325,
-0.0150308777,
-0.044561144,
0.0133409705,
-0.0311295297,
0.0262167081,
-0.0289158728,
-0.0206954759,
0.0149213886,
0.0169395898,
0.0221564882,
-0.0360286795,
0.0262974221,
0.0434101522,
0.0651786476,
0.0669554099,
0.0432794951,
0.0436677635,
0.0391340889,
0.0245334562,
0.0085775796,
0.0354691036,
0.0661672205,
-0.0084375115,
0.0319930092,
0.0327033661,
0.013551807,
-0.0043869591,
0.0308843236,
0.0016138024,
-0.0790944323,
0.0115276603,
-0.0087094018,
-0.0093934936,
0.0172367394,
0.0013559286,
-0.0639581904,
-0.0090352362,
-0.0014285172,
0.0139226867,
-0.000876522,
-0.0016168194,
0.0546627529,
-0.0020091897,
-0.056037128,
0.0062951981,
0.0684547499,
-0.0116107492,
-0.0372932032,
0.0075893528,
-0.0210287888,
0.0187923554,
0.0454639681,
-0.0117189409,
-0.0593503751,
-0.071235083,
0.0415649563,
0.0188330561,
0.040971484,
-0.0127410954,
0.0043814117,
0.0205524713,
-0.0461348891,
-0.0051852195,
-0.0258473214,
0.0320378318,
-0.0049425052,
0.0516025312,
0.0295357108,
-0.0193641689,
-0.0052926363,
0.0925175771,
0.0038744723,
-0.0585341826,
-0.0300713889,
-0.0232964512,
-0.0125937704,
0.0384531394,
-0.0061899591,
0.0274392851,
-0.0223622769,
0.005195118,
0.0414027311,
-0.0087742843,
-0.0259931777,
0.0042045866,
2.598e-7,
0.0122677963,
0.045716539,
0.0146363815,
0.0353361331,
0.0012385185,
0.0036898798,
-0.0454555415,
0.0010674235,
0.0074823922,
-0.0192561802,
0.0184610207,
0.0284437593,
0.0345159844,
0.0159519576,
-0.044096943,
0.0187779237,
-0.0223973636,
0.0693667829,
-0.0658441931,
-0.0053200698,
-0.008320529,
0.0698312521,
-0.000837649,
0.0061539146,
-0.0038298564,
0.0262145512,
-0.0112681435,
-0.0411595888,
0.0106616085,
0.0330880918,
0.0480145738,
-0.0286366623,
-0.0172221139,
0.0309070088,
-0.0199243817,
0.0090369079,
-0.0167504828,
0.045702666,
-0.034858264,
0.0231010951,
0.0174528155,
0.000829845,
-0.0413640961,
-0.0293336269,
0.0519420095,
-0.0107644023,
-0.0001286507,
-0.0389758348,
0.004827498,
0.007548009,
0.0433160178,
0.0001689831,
0.0219601262,
0.0160623174,
0.0238533709,
-0.048718486,
0.0193181932,
-0.0178625789,
0.0156942476,
0.0184838902,
-0.0407080203,
-0.0745349452,
-0.0660057813,
0.0100666471,
0.008241985,
-0.0010458009,
-0.0179605354,
2.670106031e-34,
0.0285483878,
-0.0256781206,
0.0526017211,
-0.01264391,
0.0050831083,
-0.0378583707,
-0.0471647419,
0.0095831202,
0.002804091,
-0.0803423971,
-0.0374790244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02315v1 | A Survey of Large Language Models in Finance (FinLLMs) | 2024-02-04T02:06:57 | 2024-02-04T02:06:57 | Jean Lee, Nicholas Stevens, Soyeon Caren Han, Minseok Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-fin.GN | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities across a wide
variety of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks and have attracted attention
from multiple domains, including financial services. Despite the extensive
research into general-domain LLMs, and their immense potential in finance,
Financial LLM (FinLLM) research remains limited. This survey provides a
comprehensive overview of FinLLMs, including their history, techniques,
performance, and opportunities and challenges. Firstly, we present a
chronological overview of general-domain Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs)
through to current FinLLMs, including the GPT-series, selected open-source
LLMs, and financial LMs. Secondly, we compare five techniques used across
financial PLMs and FinLLMs, including training methods, training data, and
fine-tuning methods. Thirdly, we summarize the performance evaluations of six
benchmark tasks and datasets. In addition, we provide eight advanced financial
NLP tasks and datasets for developing more sophisticated FinLLMs. Finally, we
discuss the opportunities and the challenges facing FinLLMs, such as
hallucination, privacy, and efficiency. To support AI research in finance, we
compile a collection of accessible datasets and evaluation benchmarks on
GitHub. | [
0.0209108088,
0.0935106054,
0.0041194349,
0.0426856279,
-0.0025519507,
0.0162582546,
0.0476167612,
0.0447017476,
0.0177836083,
-0.02764697,
-0.075416483,
-0.0593379959,
-0.004531946,
0.029487038,
0.0500968955,
-0.0258460976,
0.0196394827,
-0.0322120711,
0.0384504721,
-0.0099993339,
0.023218682,
0.0159866214,
0.0142295687,
0.0410999618,
-0.011241328,
-0.0183377378,
-0.0039233868,
-0.0221399255,
-0.0107309045,
0.0017474137,
-0.0095188329,
0.03343492,
0.0428748876,
0.0657866746,
0.000001992,
-0.058608491,
-0.0269115921,
0.0040088226,
-0.0308188852,
0.0266719405,
0.0226455964,
-0.050925564,
0.0553537719,
0.0067620813,
-0.057455752,
0.0075362991,
0.0567045398,
0.0913532674,
0.0589770265,
0.091824986,
-0.0153025677,
-0.0670133457,
0.019215025,
-0.0856196061,
-0.0145128807,
-0.0873748213,
0.0391546637,
0.0102078216,
-0.0460824072,
-0.0070885331,
-0.0211335551,
0.0309798904,
-0.0082711577,
0.0175882019,
-0.0003184593,
0.0086301686,
-0.0520345941,
0.0092661269,
-0.0515885055,
0.0666294023,
-0.0160891805,
0.0443733856,
0.0122404117,
-0.0408380628,
-0.0231658183,
0.0158031955,
-0.0360619165,
0.0637767464,
0.0159702413,
0.0159681253,
0.0125869727,
0.0026326834,
0.0467942208,
0.0095730014,
-0.0474653244,
0.039126303,
0.0020826943,
-0.0216261912,
0.0428937785,
0.0163783319,
-0.0312448852,
-0.0294637438,
0.0276428182,
-0.0088026412,
0.0366580263,
0.0076005352,
-0.0197388399,
-0.0312479902,
0.0042626527,
-0.0846193358,
0.0432644784,
0.0160532147,
-0.0160766393,
0.0646014288,
-0.0372985639,
0.0497314706,
-0.0135244029,
-0.0133007364,
-0.0067658951,
0.0068646525,
-0.0456853658,
-0.0200334676,
-0.0539259724,
0.0801643506,
-0.0452419594,
-0.0608140305,
-0.0689555109,
-0.0353310071,
-0.0099335862,
0.0183026362,
0.0160168931,
-0.0317123458,
0.0012822318,
-0.0495959781,
-0.0243389606,
-0.0220116396,
-0.02902315,
0.0238869023,
-0.0197090749,
-0.030935511,
0.0095788958,
0.041904889,
-0.0401815213,
-0.029914815,
0.0134877805,
0.0744561404,
0.0714588538,
-0.0583672039,
-0.0417975783,
-0.0381142497,
0.0002897127,
-0.0384049416,
-0.0263078827,
-0.0291924048,
0.0307257567,
-0.027573701,
0.0198227186,
-0.0325181447,
0.0186620299,
-0.0035547649,
-0.0192576386,
0.0987005159,
0.0123850051,
-0.0211877581,
0.0007019471,
-0.0430957787,
0.0197344255,
0.0710779652,
0.0002029635,
0.0293330476,
0.0510944091,
-0.0059248293,
0.0130264638,
0.0575994439,
0.0034440814,
-0.0505972542,
0.0027370059,
0.0206825919,
0.0109126531,
-0.0021154322,
0.0433896706,
0.0395091847,
-0.0250029173,
-0.0255764071,
0.059912689,
0.0559676103,
0.0684810355,
0.0108496435,
0.004960326,
0.0478440523,
0.0451531745,
-0.0312849768,
-0.0138387317,
-0.0292156786,
-0.0220305566,
0.0152978478,
0.0039239074,
0.0145181641,
-0.0348719023,
-0.0223185215,
-0.0175992306,
-0.0404281542,
-0.0194855146,
0.0014854447,
0.0286121182,
-0.0307486672,
-0.0472272038,
0.0718256459,
0.0339562334,
0.0043297131,
-0.0054204962,
-0.0369023457,
0.033233095,
0.0970013663,
0.0307545289,
-0.032122612,
0.0294733625,
-0.0247788336,
-0.0088230828,
0.0752920434,
0.0261078663,
0.0162810441,
0.0095072808,
-0.0577051155,
-0.0052309781,
0.007885552,
0.0215345994,
0.0306637771,
0.0102013694,
-0.007788267,
0.0293013863,
-0.0142414775,
-0.0287822131,
0.0320724286,
0.000297748,
-0.0437067822,
0.0054320013,
-0.0353323221,
-0.0030377437,
0.0168606564,
-0.0147303287,
0.0093826782,
-0.0011835645,
-0.0105954716,
-0.016553456,
0.0017772478,
-0.0538626164,
-0.0019958478,
0.0074954163,
-0.0072346604,
0.0064721941,
0.0231845733,
-0.0545461699,
-0.0159440022,
-0.0405671522,
0.0079164989,
0.0300609656,
-0.0755690336,
0.0070282081,
0.0250432566,
0.0431913622,
0.0006543566,
0.0688176379,
-0.0246234927,
0.0140250204,
-0.0207441375,
0.0263294727,
-0.0093189785,
-0.0358294658,
0.0314483829,
-0.0101100039,
-0.0226558056,
0.0329720937,
0.0250315107,
0.0062656123,
-0.0050092703,
-0.020290317,
-0.0590967163,
-0.0215749796,
-0.0172564462,
0.0317813456,
-0.0091933198,
-0.0029416564,
-0.0200917702,
-0.0241515916,
-0.0248863436,
0.0046409075,
-0.0092298575,
-0.0054218499,
0.0397656001,
0.0006909706,
-0.0078771953,
-0.0553104579,
-0.0045109126,
0.0201227479,
0.0380849093,
0.0016626175,
-0.0436327383,
-0.0313152038,
0.0051634246,
-0.0044043018,
0.0207664352,
-0.0159914941,
0.0406945199,
-0.007006235,
-0.0288677886,
0.0247439537,
0.0096590063,
0.0072498806,
0.0636703148,
-0.0344306156,
-0.0168782435,
-0.0214934126,
0.0093768314,
-0.007458041,
-0.0027750807,
-0.0387415923,
0.0238517951,
0.0457214266,
0.062703371,
-0.0349758789,
0.0005050284,
-0.0764709935,
0.0352836996,
-0.0102695972,
0.0088559119,
-0.0314535275,
0.0072638434,
-0.0285818689,
0.0376554355,
0.0027590091,
-0.0384469405,
0.0406509042,
-0.0339733474,
-0.0135210548,
-0.0150695238,
-0.0207131337,
-0.0814306438,
0.0578230694,
-0.0177965444,
0.0126288123,
-0.0079671629,
-0.0660613403,
0.0022641609,
-0.0087840343,
0.0196354482,
-0.0136752473,
0.0378209874,
-0.0315475576,
0.0467004143,
0.0015866326,
-0.0035086055,
0.0002592964,
-0.1178584546,
-0.0459646285,
0.0087722456,
0.0395509005,
-0.0544610694,
-0.0402433239,
0.029120503,
-0.0572355241,
-0.0085099516,
0.0025104424,
0.0021588621,
0.0058128755,
0.0229374673,
0.0846419111,
0.0138870552,
0.039650593,
-0.0464667007,
0.0336280502,
0.0092505291,
0.0162308328,
0.0145944161,
-0.0010759464,
-0.0219627917,
0.0010844598,
-0.0719544142,
-0.0083637172,
0.0060165669,
-0.0042539234,
-0.0510823093,
0.0112395957,
0.1219486296,
0.0124488948,
-0.0102348542,
0.0037785789,
0.0233330019,
0.0010635606,
-0.0410237722,
0.0153998761,
-0.1180000976,
-0.0322577395,
-0.0213857833,
-0.0135899838,
0.0402499065,
-0.0440911055,
-0.0203302633,
-0.1259044856,
0.0274286494,
-0.0081239101,
0.0103021255,
-0.0226327181,
-0.0015889317,
-0.0388085805,
-0.0450458229,
0.0239101984,
0.0006791356,
-0.0227046274,
-0.0009064624,
-0.000469685,
-0.0524707846,
-0.0204209201,
-0.0011756013,
-0.0320572034,
-0.0163639057,
0.0444074459,
-0.0080328742,
-0.0132388622,
-0.0204282496,
-0.0237359572,
0.0074021323,
-0.0032911473,
-0.0046645999,
0.0376772843,
-0.0254660882,
-0.0344620086,
0.0065984093,
0.0317071564,
-0.032494314,
0.0347023085,
0.0079271868,
-0.0124063091,
-0.0395242758,
-0.0348324329,
0.0196239222,
0.0373093337,
-0.0153055415,
0.0779875368,
0.024944596,
-0.0445184149,
-0.0338570885,
-0.0328145176,
0.0166006368,
-0.0398642197,
-0.0190861709,
-0.0018849568,
0.0393917859,
0.0088886591,
-0.0842167661,
-0.0595244281,
0.0320971534,
0.0123476097,
0.0088523915,
0.0268979706,
0.0507205799,
-0.0319297537,
-0.0297811292,
0.0497934632,
-0.0891906694,
0.0256215688,
-0.0440970995,
0.021418076,
0.0314563885,
-0.0106379539,
-0.0498518646,
0.0545380488,
-0.0907497033,
-0.03186794,
0.0120110409,
0.0252478439,
0.0168006532,
0.0010920577,
-0.0314753912,
-0.0044291895,
0.0336308442,
0.0214981884,
-0.0627292171,
-0.0162158106,
0.0559147075,
0.0062883138,
-0.0200971942,
0.0437460281,
-0.0290909968,
0.0221502911,
-0.0160564184,
0.0316455513,
-0.0348874554,
-0.0014816736,
-0.0085824654,
-0.0038628799,
0.0436897315,
0.0047147134,
0.00667592,
-0.0331431925,
-0.017847579,
-0.0178784505,
0.0102613792,
-0.0366531312,
-0.0356586538,
0.0672248825,
-0.0350199379,
-0.0206226986,
0.0139578581,
-0.0246948432,
-0.0133876996,
-0.0182971545,
0.0265005901,
-0.0032974661,
0.001929922,
0.0212351829,
-0.02812225,
0.0205242168,
0.0415431857,
0.039326407,
0.0161500759,
0.0097280601,
0.0045515178,
0.0053998753,
0.0065053287,
-0.029751718,
-0.0082194405,
0.0088302791,
-0.0553016886,
-0.0159451198,
0.0457501449,
0.0480075181,
-0.0411246233,
0.0119486814,
-0.0504604392,
0.0072251973,
-0.001732274,
0.021608172,
0.0243758056,
-0.0445799828,
0.0161135346,
-0.000716781,
-0.0584816113,
-0.0135595854,
0.1368926764,
0.0353103727,
0.0115071815,
-0.0027564198,
0.0065955468,
-0.0556058772,
-0.0519238226,
0.0214612037,
0.0240131672,
-0.0310898423,
0.0306886081,
-0.0686012059,
-0.0500910878,
0.0135103771,
-0.0409885868,
-0.0120386416,
-0.0069892909,
0.0362091362,
0.0527949035,
-0.0064396448,
0.0323409811,
-0.0081197154,
-0.0087480824,
0.0069639101,
-0.0180136431,
-0.0752305165,
-6.289416403e-33,
-0.0303021614,
-0.0184802096,
0.0364914834,
0.0042434167,
0.0155001888,
0.021457158,
0.002279365,
-0.0111788064,
0.0181694701,
0.0010142261,
0.0110814283,
0.0351377986,
0.0196808614,
0.0432828218,
-0.0124089327,
0.0059949891,
0.04590673,
-0.0272111353,
-0.0030058788,
0.0002303999,
0.0110880239,
0.0709029436,
0.070716247,
-0.06088176,
0.0284332018,
-0.0026888759,
-0.0476079658,
0.0113324849,
0.0352052487,
0.0432700329,
-0.0350923091,
0.0342679508,
0.0166424625,
-0.0888480917,
-0.0302483682,
-0.002718861,
-0.0165051054,
-0.0305306185,
0.0214270651,
0.0392264277,
0.0155814607,
-0.0209359825,
0.0363697298,
-0.0264372788,
-0.0096922349,
0.0090133268,
0.0033364831,
-0.0076991953,
0.022656342,
-0.0225873347,
-0.0744550005,
0.0563911274,
0.0140934428,
0.0209328458,
0.0662958324,
0.0325533114,
-0.0119859967,
0.0334438384,
-0.0310821552,
0.0181354433,
0.0182487313,
-0.0039308956,
0.014313031,
0.0081774443,
-0.0091748554,
0.0573253445,
0.000576356,
0.0024711906,
-0.0186961386,
0.0140092103,
0.0228705388,
0.0773600563,
0.0511089712,
0.0166192278,
0.0140938079,
-0.0175425727,
-0.015882954,
0.0108843027,
-0.0161471721,
0.0192598719,
0.0239313263,
0.0203296375,
-0.0301736929,
-0.0353715643,
-0.0232767444,
0.0076324963,
-0.0173660778,
-0.0047304179,
0.0129852444,
0.0300387032,
-0.0183404665,
0.0364419073,
0.0220011603,
-0.0514233746,
-0.0702125505,
0.008640958,
0.0263367407,
0.0028038081,
0.0011538977,
0.0168442,
-0.0482214019,
-0.0526913069,
-0.002659189,
-0.0207924675,
-0.0102565316,
-0.0410557762,
0.0273713917,
0.0008288515,
-0.0481845289,
-0.0087395106,
0.0201741271,
0.0059141447,
0.0237137582,
0.0513318256,
0.0274873525,
0.02553601,
-0.005269561,
0.0228358805,
0.0055301217,
0.0014748434,
0.0082258731,
-0.0180905089,
0.0110535193,
0.0632820427,
0.0254083984,
0.0062459083,
-0.0177336317,
0.0250921398,
0.0638163984,
-0.0194474701,
-0.0280493833,
0.0313872322,
2.579e-7,
0.0457702912,
0.0641231462,
0.0188304987,
0.0221127793,
-0.0005221394,
0.027087044,
-0.0171718467,
0.0025920831,
-0.0199997574,
0.0174435377,
0.0106573822,
0.0308717582,
0.0899852514,
-0.0287589263,
-0.0868974999,
-0.0484563932,
-0.0548233762,
0.0385368764,
-0.0992160589,
0.0010021802,
0.0091268579,
0.1211114451,
-0.0212566387,
-0.0366409197,
0.0063963751,
-0.1064640507,
0.0710397586,
-0.0575249344,
-0.0439531282,
0.025918005,
0.0001803572,
0.0544324331,
-0.003086929,
0.0138904667,
0.0030594408,
0.0232845061,
0.0366755836,
0.0533478074,
0.0324865766,
-0.008189816,
-0.0041349116,
0.0195984375,
-0.0256487913,
-0.0347482935,
0.0457158983,
-0.0617168956,
-0.0458513871,
-0.0475302637,
-0.0275729969,
-0.0248244703,
0.056454055,
0.0008726757,
-0.0096253213,
0.0149049796,
0.0284037422,
-0.0203050692,
-0.0020230166,
-0.0435339473,
-0.0057213027,
0.0129925366,
-0.0370494016,
0.0464701131,
-0.0445706435,
-0.0029354105,
0.0188169125,
-0.0531965271,
0.0223227981,
2.317306656e-34,
0.0696049184,
-0.027649926,
-0.0242446605,
0.0769416392,
0.0741944611,
0.0203878824,
-0.0200704765,
0.0617422424,
-0.0195512734,
-0.1075211763,
0.0140401972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02314v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02314v3 | Selecting Large Language Model to Fine-tune via Rectified Scaling Law | 2024-02-04T01:55:00 | 2024-05-28T16:16:42 | Haowei Lin, Baizhou Huang, Haotian Ye, Qinyu Chen, Zihao Wang, Sujian Li, Jianzhu Ma, Xiaojun Wan, James Zou, Yitao Liang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The ever-growing ecosystem of LLMs has posed a challenge in selecting the
most appropriate pre-trained model to fine-tune amidst a sea of options. Given
constrained resources, fine-tuning all models and making selections afterward
is unrealistic. In this work, we formulate this resource-constrained selection
task into predicting fine-tuning performance and illustrate its natural
connection with Scaling Law. Unlike pre-training, we find that the fine-tuning
scaling curve includes not just the well-known "power phase" but also the
previously unobserved "pre-power phase". We also explain why existing Scaling
Law fails to capture this phase transition phenomenon both theoretically and
empirically. To address this, we introduce the concept of "pre-learned data
size" into our Rectified Scaling Law, which overcomes theoretical limitations
and fits experimental results much better. By leveraging our law, we propose a
novel LLM selection algorithm that selects the near-optimal model with hundreds
of times less resource consumption, while other methods may provide negatively
correlated selection. The project page is available at
rectified-scaling-law.github.io. | [
-0.0106701255,
0.0381501354,
-0.0178449173,
0.0279020555,
-0.0080691753,
0.0227954499,
0.003929147,
0.0427058563,
-0.0268560126,
-0.0497951992,
-0.0644626021,
-0.0280425828,
0.0088774012,
0.0113888122,
0.0354157798,
-0.0143699525,
0.0370957851,
-0.0506825708,
-0.0220716279,
-0.0125278952,
-0.0126889842,
0.0063219978,
0.0229389071,
0.0206456836,
0.0345170833,
0.0247872453,
0.0185201,
0.021315854,
-0.0051912903,
-0.0159190111,
0.0224049892,
0.0504929796,
0.0066584786,
0.0160203353,
0.0000020283,
-0.0729988068,
-0.013675251,
-0.02212568,
-0.0266801212,
0.0283561386,
0.0330060422,
-0.0045413291,
-0.0238596704,
0.0257067606,
-0.0365282409,
-0.004339254,
0.041999381,
0.010898401,
0.01601143,
0.0712433308,
0.0116434004,
-0.0336121209,
0.0092602605,
-0.0605996288,
-0.0600882806,
-0.0579139404,
0.0357483812,
0.0105917752,
-0.0374139585,
0.0116188768,
-0.0354330204,
0.0097107543,
-0.0307020377,
-0.0051723151,
-0.0035747485,
0.0168449488,
-0.0277454462,
-0.0093465392,
-0.0027924285,
0.0863067135,
-0.0609763339,
-0.0286780056,
0.0264945384,
-0.0397881679,
-0.0188216846,
0.0105731841,
-0.0450624079,
-0.0004047819,
0.0466492921,
0.0394590646,
0.0183310341,
-0.0205449034,
0.0736669898,
0.029081732,
-0.0361007936,
0.0308077149,
0.0185054038,
-0.0170074925,
-0.001198995,
-0.0218282156,
-0.034417022,
-0.0464150421,
-0.0266648289,
0.0091119958,
-0.0397334546,
-0.007747815,
-0.037823718,
-0.0146159772,
0.0124844424,
0.0125985872,
0.0675398931,
-0.0096758511,
0.0090994071,
0.0484520607,
-0.0288051721,
0.0254891813,
-0.0058162538,
0.0157360621,
-0.0378606543,
0.0181685518,
-0.0095944852,
0.0412786528,
-0.0370310545,
0.0120001659,
-0.0118044391,
-0.0015863846,
-0.0370256715,
-0.024104489,
0.0291828625,
-0.015810499,
0.0391856134,
-0.0424684696,
-0.0339834467,
0.0064076371,
0.0251671989,
0.0577388518,
-0.0374414586,
0.0103554586,
-0.023784278,
-0.0638780221,
-0.0147846797,
0.0114919851,
-0.0064651361,
-0.0237741116,
0.0364129543,
0.0440375246,
0.0064071771,
-0.0378830321,
-0.0864684582,
0.0089434301,
-0.0147904605,
-0.0689767674,
-0.0094034644,
-0.0570403934,
-0.0042640376,
0.0019554673,
0.0266121086,
-0.0256134272,
-0.0054866597,
-0.0209375527,
-0.042773176,
0.0487075038,
-0.0295904092,
0.026288189,
-0.0162673015,
-0.020550603,
0.0222170148,
0.0821994767,
0.0575992689,
0.0072879824,
0.0438878983,
-0.0389730111,
-0.0032110123,
0.0607905202,
0.0052263783,
0.0448187515,
-0.0252328757,
-0.0220317245,
0.0112696113,
0.01773059,
0.0193473436,
0.0131475478,
-0.0263735801,
-0.0091593666,
0.044768326,
0.0416786037,
0.0593758598,
0.0664537475,
-0.002468097,
-0.0114545543,
0.0002040319,
0.0051540611,
-0.0624171682,
0.0203160215,
-0.0526867695,
0.0088562435,
0.0222696066,
0.0426067524,
-0.0319911912,
-0.0421926565,
-0.0288381074,
-0.0167105105,
-0.0263738353,
-0.0077624987,
0.0483928658,
0.0098574106,
-0.0266327634,
0.0755070746,
0.0459968001,
-0.0327434316,
-0.0122686736,
-0.0547911003,
-0.0011197507,
0.0367207192,
0.0484814942,
-0.0488107093,
-0.0088248169,
-0.0095615303,
0.0389653742,
0.002450428,
0.0681567937,
-0.0026679714,
0.0018177801,
-0.089202553,
-0.03694278,
0.0058557182,
0.0238106567,
-0.0266097654,
0.0244195201,
0.0216707289,
0.0077313329,
-0.0602187961,
-0.0337734558,
0.0322547257,
-0.0399531201,
-0.0335118659,
0.0151946498,
-0.0069521079,
0.0232458767,
-0.0337483324,
-0.0281621106,
-0.0128849903,
0.0061951485,
-0.029418448,
0.0168703608,
-0.0061855093,
-0.0338142365,
0.00920342,
0.0213413239,
0.0156067861,
0.0255431533,
0.0119515471,
-0.0628949478,
-0.0510609709,
0.010922418,
-0.0005464582,
0.0305381902,
-0.0349266604,
0.0370211154,
-0.0435422063,
0.0380939208,
-0.06804353,
0.0344517604,
-0.004736708,
0.0088756019,
0.0313352756,
0.0033295669,
0.0238287486,
-0.0030037842,
-0.0466723256,
0.0441066474,
0.0011111731,
0.0180363171,
0.0085973945,
0.0109237386,
-0.0222409368,
-0.0461822115,
-0.0300732926,
0.0090380637,
-0.0556213856,
0.0287196916,
0.0174226668,
0.0124677094,
-0.0051076324,
-0.0056750271,
0.0118691297,
0.0186106097,
-0.0146415215,
0.0219778791,
0.0362616964,
-0.0317828543,
-0.0303938556,
-0.0718721822,
-0.0508228503,
0.0183747429,
0.0322150141,
0.0038059698,
0.0100258254,
-0.0643521845,
0.0790658817,
-0.0035707245,
0.0064117694,
-0.0274920072,
-0.0674624071,
-0.025290275,
-0.0373455696,
-0.0028367939,
0.0959077552,
0.0099279927,
-0.0137607353,
0.0749213845,
0.0175179429,
-0.0489113517,
-0.0037137873,
0.0089940242,
-0.0519898385,
-0.0688107684,
0.003110036,
0.0068326578,
0.0755549818,
-0.029020261,
-0.0040223394,
-0.0385336392,
-0.0138886254,
-0.0155732566,
0.0195635296,
0.0155596044,
0.0555511676,
-0.0167114157,
0.0689891353,
0.0220370181,
-0.0882887617,
0.0373948328,
-0.0205264818,
0.010467831,
-0.0169846527,
-0.0158510152,
-0.0555005819,
0.032994166,
0.004313136,
-0.010973217,
0.0164512396,
-0.0175257977,
-0.064646773,
-0.0449799001,
0.0356418267,
-0.0223584715,
0.0790968314,
-0.0506504104,
0.0310702771,
-0.0310303047,
-0.0631023943,
-0.0045055319,
-0.0067998832,
-0.0406251699,
0.0077597084,
0.0239683464,
-0.0407342575,
-0.0362339132,
-0.0127937449,
-0.0124675343,
0.0330133997,
-0.0109366607,
0.0025947127,
-0.0240829643,
0.031531021,
0.0453143939,
0.0598662794,
0.0647254437,
-0.0319972411,
0.0070247841,
0.0028883452,
0.0203646906,
0.0279733893,
-0.0530655459,
0.0062752469,
0.0475149229,
-0.057101611,
-0.0646459982,
0.0435636975,
0.0481364168,
-0.0451954119,
0.009103098,
0.1231099665,
-0.0190345403,
-0.0416987948,
0.0144760245,
0.0282264687,
0.0445726253,
0.0374147482,
0.0184253044,
-0.0550416708,
-0.0373955444,
0.0159636065,
0.0233224705,
0.0211307947,
-0.0224887636,
0.015788842,
-0.0901489481,
0.0413798466,
0.0359245092,
0.0177937113,
0.0088821435,
-0.0326862149,
0.0396438278,
-0.0639855042,
0.0315788873,
0.0132035222,
-0.0589411184,
-0.0113968477,
-0.0035488773,
-0.0027003079,
-0.0495855734,
0.0493751802,
-0.036669489,
0.0339269266,
0.0460566804,
0.0383877903,
-0.0204838514,
-0.0343062542,
0.0725045577,
-0.0024624516,
0.0121619878,
-0.0465034693,
0.0332557894,
0.0465585478,
-0.0116620027,
0.0291905627,
0.0242882613,
-0.0139516555,
0.0146684637,
-0.0005983484,
0.0430291183,
-0.0132444547,
-0.041477982,
0.0191269498,
-0.0214163531,
-0.014179742,
0.0639471412,
0.0512973294,
-0.0284599941,
-0.0607814454,
-0.011506076,
-0.0007747518,
-0.0379250236,
-0.0624710135,
0.0127555123,
0.0188664068,
0.025896769,
-0.0414895937,
0.0405026972,
0.0118813245,
0.0294689834,
0.0134035163,
0.0357032716,
0.0347672403,
0.0096671553,
-0.012047492,
0.0200526826,
-0.0489329435,
0.0073430208,
-0.0889378041,
-0.0183292422,
0.0666903034,
-0.0147594223,
-0.0039142626,
-0.0335279703,
-0.089578554,
-0.0631162375,
0.0110155344,
0.0399927944,
0.0243552458,
0.0302483961,
0.0026786132,
-0.0910178125,
0.0313912258,
0.0396477133,
0.00559146,
0.0530927293,
0.0353376977,
-0.0075014671,
-0.0324292853,
0.059086822,
-0.0342825241,
0.0232666992,
0.0512263924,
0.0253607221,
-0.0297089163,
-0.0655218288,
-0.038698826,
0.0363778472,
0.0308925826,
-0.0326874256,
-0.018312851,
-0.0209337268,
0.0194132812,
0.0650913343,
0.0161080025,
-0.0345111154,
0.0105023393,
-0.0028437546,
-0.0242790394,
-0.0061920378,
-0.0130993444,
-0.0057828235,
-0.0119677754,
-0.0556267612,
0.0576980598,
-0.0022389337,
-0.001783266,
0.0689256117,
-0.0103626363,
-0.0050955401,
0.072836265,
0.0097503727,
0.046190612,
-0.0167770479,
0.0196403582,
0.0068280366,
0.044247333,
-0.0698109567,
0.0323150605,
-0.0509916246,
-0.0700683072,
-0.0133963712,
0.0216560904,
0.0709281117,
-0.0472292081,
0.0699148402,
0.0094536478,
-0.0124111548,
-0.0326637477,
0.0251586288,
0.002846278,
0.0234241709,
0.0176700018,
0.0243825037,
-0.0408771373,
0.0446380153,
0.0733558089,
0.0043207197,
0.0440722145,
0.0286256801,
0.056024354,
-0.0024203612,
-0.0498092584,
-0.0402752161,
-0.016599657,
-0.0053154496,
-0.005682298,
-0.0450999513,
-0.0585902929,
-0.014400336,
-0.0031689601,
-0.0119501846,
-0.0310226306,
0.0321108587,
0.0538230799,
-0.0066857045,
0.0093930038,
-0.0178559925,
-0.0220110416,
0.0308271982,
-0.0156134749,
-0.002750756,
-6.219353266e-33,
0.0070214183,
0.0241429992,
0.0014576131,
0.021596279,
-0.0039725676,
-0.0012271124,
-0.0201535448,
-0.0130149471,
-0.0543598942,
-0.0132884523,
-0.029236706,
-0.0033875604,
0.0142314909,
0.0376826525,
0.0064672208,
-0.0206984468,
0.0672103539,
-0.0178943872,
-0.0284045823,
0.0362078138,
0.002403568,
0.0286611076,
0.0531563945,
-0.0410367027,
-0.0504734628,
0.0137563581,
-0.0202133022,
0.0262608174,
-0.0378002636,
0.0676752999,
0.0327715427,
0.0201366525,
0.0177181549,
-0.0535040274,
-0.039795395,
-0.0384211875,
-0.0523608737,
-0.0343834609,
0.0047754855,
0.0015366011,
-0.0109173693,
-0.0151726883,
0.0698017627,
-0.0159056745,
-0.0185732022,
-0.0421205759,
0.0260803793,
-0.0255790148,
-0.0395908318,
-0.0249370318,
-0.0276753623,
0.0327253453,
0.0001679829,
-0.0133533916,
0.0492668152,
-0.0392783992,
-0.0229767617,
0.0546789207,
-0.0252796784,
-0.0057293111,
0.0652452484,
0.0832388997,
0.0515431575,
0.0406716987,
-0.0115741035,
0.0415873416,
-0.0145001654,
0.0224569887,
0.0198355727,
-0.0267858207,
0.0594535433,
0.0874612033,
0.0161690898,
0.0116933808,
0.0248189028,
-0.0320216939,
-0.0887833089,
-0.0164843984,
0.0392842926,
0.0304775164,
-0.0180161335,
0.0363490023,
-0.0006437027,
-0.0303887725,
-0.0643964186,
-0.030975705,
-0.0237407666,
-0.0006787577,
0.0098567288,
0.0045386404,
-0.0151385376,
-0.0408574976,
0.0289663859,
-0.0534100719,
-0.0239944756,
0.0253723897,
-0.0024766796,
0.0185431764,
-0.0063760369,
0.0066786511,
-0.0439460762,
-0.0671967641,
-0.0050313468,
-0.0112010874,
0.0274292976,
-0.0179523211,
0.00604804,
0.0156932883,
-0.0561442971,
-0.0097594447,
-0.0063851424,
-0.01233113,
0.0389023647,
0.0482015684,
0.0269459039,
0.0034334131,
0.0256069582,
0.0448661856,
0.01019667,
-0.0286343563,
-0.0199748874,
0.0287761167,
0.0390328802,
0.0418304875,
-0.0333659612,
-0.0004543601,
-0.0493366458,
0.0135016171,
0.0555548966,
-0.0215552915,
-0.0219837055,
0.0258886293,
2.65e-7,
0.0383319035,
0.0515498668,
-0.0190537199,
0.0109419199,
0.0293442253,
0.0460259803,
-0.0234678946,
-0.0112015344,
0.0012086646,
0.0001135743,
0.0133968238,
0.0302423984,
0.0936387032,
0.0043268763,
-0.0770388395,
0.0290360153,
-0.0676404089,
0.0310785826,
-0.023719117,
-0.0458580181,
-0.0372337811,
0.0998190343,
0.0105200941,
-0.0279853046,
-0.0092717903,
-0.0345480144,
0.0316855125,
-0.0579529479,
0.0347835198,
0.0687969401,
-0.0051637078,
0.037825577,
-0.0169848315,
0.0139707737,
-0.0305125229,
0.0358187295,
-0.0310244244,
0.0914117545,
0.0165512227,
0.0150233386,
0.0140145831,
-0.0207158495,
0.0034225665,
-0.0428374857,
0.0862501934,
-0.0410833545,
-0.002008633,
-0.0485901944,
0.0348276347,
-0.046504695,
0.0315974467,
-0.0423130617,
0.0031131664,
0.0656010136,
0.0218463838,
-0.02579288,
-0.0348309763,
-0.0762976184,
-0.0038187148,
0.0403557979,
-0.0289660748,
-0.0372962505,
-0.0396574289,
-0.0327812098,
0.0361807011,
-0.0260138884,
0.0260283034,
2.485258396e-34,
0.0376027599,
-0.0439799018,
0.0297090244,
0.0086743636,
0.0134794554,
0.0027713093,
-0.0179030858,
0.003304247,
-0.0043640952,
-0.1023809686,
0.002790407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02309v1 | Jailbreaking Attack against Multimodal Large Language Model | 2024-02-04T01:29:24 | 2024-02-04T01:29:24 | Zhenxing Niu, Haodong Ren, Xinbo Gao, Gang Hua, Rong Jin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | This paper focuses on jailbreaking attacks against multi-modal large language
models (MLLMs), seeking to elicit MLLMs to generate objectionable responses to
harmful user queries. A maximum likelihood-based algorithm is proposed to find
an \emph{image Jailbreaking Prompt} (imgJP), enabling jailbreaks against MLLMs
across multiple unseen prompts and images (i.e., data-universal property). Our
approach exhibits strong model-transferability, as the generated imgJP can be
transferred to jailbreak various models, including MiniGPT-v2, LLaVA,
InstructBLIP, and mPLUG-Owl2, in a black-box manner. Moreover, we reveal a
connection between MLLM-jailbreaks and LLM-jailbreaks. As a result, we
introduce a construction-based method to harness our approach for
LLM-jailbreaks, demonstrating greater efficiency than current state-of-the-art
methods. The code is available here. \textbf{Warning: some content generated by
language models may be offensive to some readers.} | [
0.0504380837,
0.0909044892,
-0.0136630405,
0.0713371709,
-0.0517972298,
-0.005388807,
0.0432343557,
0.0074541331,
0.0448388867,
-0.0396637619,
-0.0198409185,
-0.0108740283,
-0.0147586474,
0.0018682813,
0.0549667701,
-0.017994862,
0.0149655268,
-0.0486906134,
-0.0396523364,
-0.0223875474,
0.0151522737,
-0.0071159997,
0.0166469999,
0.0242412519,
-0.00708305,
-0.0256529097,
-0.0535615422,
0.0449031107,
-0.0079516508,
-0.0327028111,
-0.042773284,
0.0278021526,
-0.0225921255,
0.0473311022,
0.0000022375,
-0.0266268607,
-0.0475673303,
0.0331249237,
-0.0178897474,
0.0308505278,
0.0217274204,
-0.0304235816,
-0.0310116932,
-0.0064462097,
-0.0103667071,
0.0183024406,
0.0507497862,
0.0718516707,
0.0951045677,
0.0642357767,
-0.0041739084,
-0.0092130983,
0.0215597451,
0.0017104787,
0.0516536273,
-0.0309571549,
0.0135331759,
-0.0206753537,
0.0225554835,
0.0097696828,
0.0138474787,
0.0113726687,
0.0165458005,
-0.0124523174,
-0.0781921819,
-0.0186668765,
-0.0077265324,
-0.0334535018,
-0.0102700461,
0.0524853729,
-0.0182263255,
0.0027277418,
0.0169168673,
0.0305402298,
0.0382988676,
0.0693452358,
-0.0238834862,
0.0599918067,
-0.0185618326,
-0.0142500689,
0.0007847529,
-0.0388155654,
0.0496437512,
-0.0050131562,
-0.0199064165,
0.0345884673,
0.0529973879,
-0.022330571,
-0.0162821561,
-0.0568718873,
-0.003474006,
-0.0380978957,
-0.0068830894,
-0.0060010119,
0.0184600186,
0.0118343467,
-0.0773253962,
-0.0173847079,
0.0242573675,
-0.0339660868,
0.0174295269,
0.0034360087,
-0.0116214892,
0.0388122648,
0.00999243,
-0.0256037544,
-0.0553190187,
0.0091827428,
0.0000128,
0.0074014631,
0.0102490811,
-0.0157484785,
-0.0070661884,
0.0276464149,
-0.0417901687,
-0.0012438074,
-0.018482564,
0.0562641919,
-0.0232732184,
0.0119928541,
-0.0819787756,
0.0120995957,
-0.0021214879,
0.0208274275,
0.0439849682,
-0.0311194956,
0.0048439545,
-0.0405818932,
0.0025584486,
-0.0661273673,
0.0063760551,
0.0210007727,
-0.0470472202,
-0.0179257374,
-0.0067806439,
0.1306649745,
0.0243097823,
-0.0125419423,
-0.082381092,
-0.1056818366,
-0.0259763505,
-0.0435282327,
0.0175138786,
-0.0890852511,
-0.023179248,
-0.0389196314,
0.0069201072,
-0.0310408361,
-0.0063502486,
-0.0047662752,
-0.0343463048,
0.0810780972,
0.0136961583,
-0.0368804298,
0.0045617321,
0.0434318855,
0.0241807904,
0.0816499367,
-0.0425012,
0.0710251704,
0.0723334104,
-0.0297198743,
0.0441925153,
0.0718720853,
-0.0154982954,
0.0405648351,
-0.0425724573,
-0.0169505291,
0.0617734082,
-0.0230660699,
-0.0450172499,
0.0260263085,
-0.0354366302,
-0.0221237876,
0.0828196481,
0.0532544591,
-0.0250037964,
0.0296213422,
-0.0266263373,
-0.0273612626,
0.0019047569,
0.0243873894,
-0.065690212,
0.008292906,
-0.1077479497,
-0.0173077229,
-0.0235052221,
0.0348254964,
-0.0089623528,
0.019858975,
0.0255969316,
-0.0193632189,
-0.0445784293,
0.0096313823,
0.009418332,
0.0206069332,
0.0139499968,
0.0556020625,
0.0191424005,
-0.0282462258,
-0.036140725,
-0.0577117689,
-0.0159223024,
0.0114227114,
0.0526471324,
0.016087573,
0.0223417785,
-0.0111315707,
-0.0060405978,
0.0224188678,
-0.0317397825,
0.0112123359,
0.0159564111,
0.004852186,
-0.0081372298,
-0.0217447001,
0.0238959286,
0.0078518521,
-0.0282156654,
-0.0106948027,
-0.0106325634,
-0.0355464183,
0.0170319639,
-0.0008091699,
0.0105526252,
-0.0231305398,
-0.0010887355,
0.0400715098,
0.0173135195,
0.0094668362,
-0.0219861958,
0.0067452318,
0.0658284575,
-0.0000935269,
0.0340687595,
-0.0042260224,
-0.0174783487,
-0.0077149817,
0.0363987498,
-0.0778272897,
0.0170950796,
0.0588219874,
-0.0158514604,
0.0009929442,
0.044482585,
-0.026867453,
0.0565463789,
-0.000423764,
0.0301074889,
0.0147659667,
-0.0040300451,
-0.0351751335,
-0.0083083389,
-0.0274032038,
0.0066680037,
0.0154716605,
-0.0060684895,
0.0154516008,
0.0040700343,
-0.0600203909,
0.0436160229,
-0.0284835733,
0.0215730369,
-0.0032466257,
0.0258201063,
-0.0098210583,
-0.0400888994,
-0.0639568195,
-0.029245235,
-0.0139953187,
0.0094863139,
0.0374337211,
0.0565077923,
-0.0322646648,
-0.0228434801,
-0.0152611127,
-0.0231420323,
0.0008443594,
0.029923657,
-0.0032567042,
-0.0104338164,
-0.0510271043,
0.0082172807,
-0.0340760238,
0.0220161229,
0.0728389919,
-0.0409417041,
-0.0229367558,
-0.0180988032,
-0.0141376574,
-0.0163096525,
0.0252389926,
-0.0286952928,
-0.0382987447,
0.0425586179,
-0.0306520704,
-0.0104426816,
0.0683053955,
0.0152920056,
0.0575647615,
0.0441121608,
-0.0051691509,
-0.0313289873,
-0.0351064503,
0.0446724147,
-0.0453096405,
-0.0284187589,
-0.0810889825,
0.0316993929,
0.0143387681,
0.0353716239,
0.0185460281,
-0.0016152007,
0.0503630377,
0.0175952446,
-0.0479839183,
-0.0114806499,
0.0298136398,
-0.0263805613,
0.0000159589,
0.0068735122,
-0.0865781158,
0.0416405648,
-0.0460157394,
0.0241202265,
0.0310404338,
-0.0491473787,
0.0125092091,
0.0568604954,
0.0004352266,
0.0522330329,
0.0592128336,
-0.0237016473,
-0.0206829552,
0.0071599595,
0.0504756458,
-0.0123551162,
0.018055521,
-0.0539998338,
-0.0171342064,
-0.0143757779,
-0.0365068428,
-0.0299210958,
-0.0707016736,
-0.0028458624,
-0.0625624135,
-0.0013603721,
-0.0439590402,
-0.0100688208,
-0.0358749256,
0.0252110399,
-0.0317964852,
-0.0229896009,
-0.0047991881,
-0.0272403136,
0.0459705852,
0.0378809012,
-0.034163028,
-0.0171432123,
-0.0144344149,
0.0383123867,
0.0975410938,
0.046924118,
0.001617761,
0.00681506,
0.0490530282,
0.0287401304,
0.0499276333,
-0.0204390045,
0.0169421863,
0.0558742695,
-0.0138655892,
0.0010895717,
0.0269065425,
0.0144753549,
-0.0273038987,
0.0078138262,
0.033533264,
0.0379940085,
0.0079750996,
0.0277976785,
-0.0846443474,
-0.0445538126,
0.0087113874,
0.066878058,
-0.0400893576,
-0.0301606711,
-0.0312522314,
-0.0894864425,
0.0145011786,
0.0298304763,
0.0233606473,
0.0158356,
-0.0127513157,
-0.0191724245,
0.0372503921,
0.0037989574,
-0.0221260954,
-0.0163682792,
0.0140266456,
-0.0059607569,
0.0138619086,
0.0083630448,
-0.0101347081,
-0.0243053399,
0.0455272309,
0.0477023982,
-0.0203438159,
-0.0392063223,
0.0153491562,
0.053451024,
0.0278852265,
-0.0185657386,
-0.0006093489,
-0.0000765288,
0.020778494,
-0.0204361454,
-0.0200897641,
0.0561862253,
0.0240471233,
-0.0215732753,
0.0303425435,
0.0390625671,
-0.0016896361,
0.0033575422,
-0.0229502637,
-0.0408910364,
0.0143749584,
0.0333222672,
0.0231000613,
-0.0447803289,
-0.0289237686,
-0.0973304585,
-0.040849112,
-0.0012563148,
-0.014282126,
0.0292582642,
0.0138896005,
0.007910382,
-0.015970625,
0.0345633924,
-0.0105002541,
0.080506362,
0.0334287882,
0.0036566535,
-0.0397006683,
-0.005079329,
-0.0220643599,
-0.0182106737,
-0.0182304699,
0.026265258,
-0.0773278847,
0.0453226268,
0.0179853309,
-0.0366682336,
0.0099036312,
0.0080566583,
-0.0641035214,
-0.0812082887,
0.0140096853,
0.0626524165,
0.0261636302,
-0.0028231808,
-0.0083241211,
-0.0711482838,
0.0227702018,
0.0972905979,
-0.0565448366,
0.0322900526,
0.0677121431,
-0.0021643036,
-0.0075275018,
0.0217576567,
-0.0287791789,
-0.0195042584,
0.0806641281,
-0.0187314469,
-0.0434199907,
0.0094200587,
0.0177014284,
0.068870768,
-0.0345083959,
-0.0200683288,
-0.0138214827,
0.0466577969,
0.0255365893,
-0.0033761822,
-0.0314768404,
-0.0193707757,
0.0245515965,
0.0067525157,
-0.0238474123,
0.0527416728,
-0.0164214708,
0.0298257712,
-0.0126013858,
-0.0338327251,
0.0280880332,
0.0371556841,
-0.0007468525,
0.0745936856,
0.0081874244,
-0.010866466,
0.067133747,
0.0184992086,
0.0342130102,
-0.0103563312,
0.0656014606,
0.0098237582,
-0.0309065487,
-0.0218143836,
0.059329059,
-0.0418663397,
-0.0560692064,
0.0127078621,
0.0867288336,
0.0188543871,
0.0124533139,
-0.0169469807,
-0.0064615994,
0.0007521839,
-0.0484751202,
-0.0087599996,
0.0172989909,
-0.0494591407,
0.0328744128,
-0.0064911847,
0.0081367791,
0.0346353091,
0.0296813529,
0.0319838934,
0.0528731719,
0.0288079828,
-0.011383201,
-0.0692169815,
0.0105857328,
0.0709217489,
0.0261162613,
-0.0380907767,
-0.0364852287,
-0.047202412,
-0.0650333241,
-0.0506685972,
-0.0076291161,
0.0218802951,
0.0128816469,
-0.044997409,
0.044537656,
0.0265528876,
0.019450916,
-0.0619650371,
0.0371076427,
0.0131889787,
-0.0580962785,
0.053476125,
-6.517429246e-33,
0.0273600835,
-0.068629086,
-0.0540828593,
-0.0370026566,
0.0269525871,
-0.004728646,
0.0140214516,
0.0329969898,
0.0078051817,
-0.0415722355,
-0.0180178359,
-0.0343013518,
0.0009614815,
0.0143576954,
-0.0473075286,
-0.0203191359,
-0.0105117979,
0.0249134284,
-0.0251428727,
0.0150433797,
0.0574003868,
0.007427929,
0.0071579884,
-0.0258394238,
0.0384776779,
-0.0574735776,
-0.0597702041,
0.0335904434,
-0.0352846421,
0.0768998563,
0.0018929989,
0.0257300027,
-0.0011616764,
0.0008241407,
0.0002603577,
0.0586801879,
-0.0103596887,
0.0088898093,
0.0278766453,
0.0095595643,
0.0012761514,
-0.0501356684,
0.0156227658,
-0.0264103711,
0.012416916,
-0.0146077005,
-0.0151465125,
-0.0015602746,
-0.0010874937,
0.0117979804,
-0.002882462,
-0.0014799415,
-0.0428565256,
0.0041291076,
0.0171110202,
-0.0158637818,
0.0152994944,
-0.0148360739,
-0.0053782091,
0.0388325527,
0.0497172885,
-0.0191336311,
0.0482612662,
0.014064732,
0.0006956249,
0.0613893606,
-0.0030101072,
-0.0349656567,
0.023796251,
-0.0157791432,
-0.0057255658,
0.0788912997,
0.0354068987,
0.0813695043,
0.0406288542,
-0.0015335133,
-0.0262442604,
-0.0067645647,
0.0184773952,
0.0091376901,
0.0288907643,
-0.0207053963,
-0.0252042674,
0.0006776468,
-0.0262844842,
-0.0405038595,
-0.0303022917,
-0.0419906974,
0.0278566983,
0.0095334863,
-0.0533387363,
-0.037303701,
0.0345972218,
-0.0621499382,
-0.0420562997,
-0.0126187922,
0.0002575789,
-0.0080846408,
-0.0229797196,
0.0115323802,
0.0427204706,
0.0291944724,
0.0217284448,
-0.076171577,
0.0187035706,
0.0114748888,
0.0114336815,
0.0256286897,
-0.0692062676,
-0.0250246748,
-0.0240975916,
0.0265804287,
0.0077893445,
-0.0159735493,
0.0414740928,
-0.0519437417,
-0.0094160503,
-0.0333234407,
0.0395651795,
-0.0021980242,
-0.046972353,
0.007223587,
-0.029704053,
0.0204028748,
-0.0025266421,
0.0019949293,
-0.010053861,
-0.0127135636,
0.0687116608,
-0.0622748137,
-0.0050788191,
0.0010599542,
3.087e-7,
-0.0401873663,
-0.0293808691,
0.0166012533,
-0.0013548436,
0.0259132255,
0.0884378329,
-0.0179411732,
0.0517028458,
-0.0120001007,
-0.0708651617,
-0.0522583798,
-0.0367199108,
0.0607289299,
0.0186252389,
-0.0678882524,
0.0421019867,
-0.0034199681,
-0.0007987923,
-0.0650963485,
0.0110568553,
0.0415140465,
0.0685864687,
0.0025330915,
-0.0490724444,
0.0264678318,
-0.0514091514,
-0.0051507568,
-0.035151165,
-0.0328675844,
-0.0329288431,
0.0192988273,
0.0123177748,
0.0219734758,
0.0181502998,
-0.0246414971,
-0.0572379716,
-0.0258895122,
0.0278856922,
0.0376839042,
-0.0124721946,
-0.0277516562,
-0.0438708924,
-0.0225297268,
-0.0444090217,
0.0814623833,
0.0629483387,
-0.0441928878,
-0.027590584,
0.0061746896,
-0.0783376545,
0.0062674461,
-0.0657849684,
-0.0065784459,
0.0131157078,
0.0246527921,
-0.0045325332,
0.0212872326,
-0.0395841524,
-0.0068681538,
-0.0111967316,
-0.0135377161,
-0.0334045961,
-0.0228115935,
-0.000320783,
0.0490879342,
-0.0450993255,
0.0037141636,
3.128337606e-34,
-0.010847941,
-0.0283376947,
0.0325751416,
0.0337998569,
0.0269842241,
0.0053574662,
0.0183769278,
0.0097255455,
0.0022063926,
-0.0705643818,
-0.0249256268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05121v1 | Large Language Model for Table Processing: A Survey | 2024-02-04T00:47:53 | 2024-02-04T00:47:53 | Weizheng Lu, Jiaming Zhang, Jing Zhang, Yueguo Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Tables, typically two-dimensional and structured to store large amounts of
data, are essential in daily activities like database queries, spreadsheet
calculations, and generating reports from web tables. Automating these
table-centric tasks with Large Language Models (LLMs) offers significant public
benefits, garnering interest from academia and industry. This survey provides
an extensive overview of table tasks, encompassing not only the traditional
areas like table question answering (Table QA) and fact verification, but also
newly emphasized aspects such as table manipulation and advanced table data
analysis. Additionally, it goes beyond the early strategies of pre-training and
fine-tuning small language models, to include recent paradigms in LLM usage.
The focus here is particularly on instruction-tuning, prompting, and
agent-based approaches within the realm of LLMs. Finally, we highlight several
challenges, ranging from private deployment and efficient inference to the
development of extensive benchmarks for table manipulation and advanced data
analysis. | [
0.0239972752,
0.0939287469,
-0.0140218036,
0.0298786554,
-0.0625495017,
0.0368377566,
-0.0144844046,
0.0224169306,
0.0096402084,
-0.0258266442,
-0.0186367817,
-0.0271065049,
-0.0483414605,
0.0199023634,
0.0209196024,
0.0165338535,
0.0449437276,
-0.016282754,
-0.0361344144,
0.0174894836,
-0.0234176312,
-0.0445100628,
-0.0131352004,
-0.0173588172,
0.0032835172,
-0.0060729044,
-0.0389626361,
-0.0219021831,
-0.0452871658,
0.0197754353,
-0.0176264644,
0.0766049251,
0.0205694791,
0.0435477011,
0.0000019324,
-0.0164420418,
-0.0488770492,
0.0144694233,
-0.0272293799,
0.0126653006,
0.0212172065,
-0.0325206295,
-0.0415636189,
-0.0081473235,
-0.0546382219,
-0.0231562424,
0.0228596553,
0.0297111198,
0.0678332373,
0.0581861101,
0.0055536483,
-0.0326779187,
-0.012504383,
0.0043919161,
0.0504609048,
-0.0656310245,
0.0418264903,
0.0107149212,
0.0135119781,
-0.0275125168,
0.0124310907,
0.0301003717,
0.0298602339,
-0.0268112477,
-0.0279362202,
0.0264378786,
-0.0302428752,
0.042110581,
-0.0121735856,
0.0548977032,
0.020537328,
-0.0052155312,
0.0203775279,
0.0227476712,
0.0257110279,
-0.0208249502,
-0.0406248905,
0.0205745827,
0.0118482122,
-0.0212875325,
0.0138854096,
-0.0474920012,
-0.0198234934,
0.0082896762,
-0.0497149304,
0.0610290989,
-0.0122445235,
-0.0540977567,
-0.0198772065,
-0.0253080819,
0.0403771847,
-0.0586640947,
0.0220485516,
0.0847673714,
-0.016413264,
0.0279327556,
0.0155423386,
-0.0209626406,
0.0387370773,
-0.0585369803,
0.035426721,
0.0315901078,
0.0042188494,
0.0414941423,
-0.021270724,
0.0186717603,
-0.0109239565,
0.0348880067,
-0.0161239412,
-0.0121274572,
-0.0340272002,
0.0242637042,
-0.0478783846,
0.0240596347,
-0.0565688834,
0.0149386022,
-0.0001425112,
0.0312861353,
-0.0183720645,
0.0958235264,
-0.0070524234,
-0.000385076,
-0.0018697553,
-0.0010436841,
-0.0534515679,
0.0095679006,
-0.0272115916,
-0.0229777768,
-0.0272903349,
-0.0969967619,
-0.014787796,
-0.0050746957,
0.0218931884,
-0.0286846366,
0.0677592978,
0.0843206495,
-0.0349696577,
0.0111022275,
-0.0482038073,
-0.0166882947,
-0.0080082864,
-0.0692924112,
-0.0065438766,
-0.0572440848,
0.0389927141,
0.0020880897,
-0.0201843977,
-0.0370116495,
0.0147760725,
0.055200845,
0.0157368928,
0.0541052744,
0.0206917133,
0.0244708769,
-0.0035251896,
-0.0311446581,
-0.0124165388,
0.061229378,
0.0289628264,
0.0285247955,
-0.0099508828,
-0.0264599323,
-0.0029607681,
0.0572957024,
0.0095589096,
0.0025187985,
-0.0177223235,
0.0812387168,
0.0374065414,
0.0275746789,
-0.022083303,
0.0490505733,
-0.0017912626,
0.02572136,
0.0468311273,
0.0447917618,
-0.0039292718,
0.071747005,
0.0088302046,
0.0049466551,
0.0461125337,
0.0003599468,
-0.0186182354,
0.0270638205,
0.0153805437,
0.0128349066,
-0.0049061351,
0.0270792656,
-0.0163875483,
-0.0449295789,
0.0177035853,
0.0066234428,
0.0003005478,
0.0051159989,
0.0667951405,
0.014930144,
-0.035011556,
-0.0177174136,
0.0054223449,
-0.0571872555,
-0.0345924459,
-0.0461374782,
0.0226306189,
0.0610867143,
0.0363995023,
-0.0762178078,
-0.0161047578,
-0.0096616,
0.0262870751,
0.0109669389,
0.051066298,
-0.0528154932,
-0.0485341921,
0.0037471731,
0.0020026108,
0.0535753965,
0.0269563273,
-0.0231371578,
0.0456346795,
-0.0132469377,
-0.0145185478,
-0.0400030315,
-0.0551492386,
0.0272359177,
0.037958432,
-0.0322930366,
-0.0093869027,
0.027198365,
0.0390918814,
0.0281361341,
-0.0148652662,
0.0241514649,
0.0497320406,
-0.0079248007,
0.0212520864,
-0.0369176008,
0.0127251409,
0.032178089,
0.0544674918,
0.0478239432,
-0.0828601792,
-0.0147117032,
-0.0366272181,
-0.0147189945,
0.015642589,
-0.0272344723,
-0.0374788381,
-0.0385455377,
0.0211050268,
-0.0025385113,
-0.0103503708,
-0.006773185,
0.0712384507,
-0.0037892025,
0.0166215673,
0.0026394024,
-0.0856071338,
0.0231780577,
-0.0464855023,
0.0133835729,
-0.0069485302,
-0.0178483762,
0.0537766479,
-0.0063709305,
0.0237760544,
-0.0575329848,
-0.0206646938,
-0.076440081,
0.0462609157,
-0.0381413251,
0.0381484292,
0.016174024,
0.0086852135,
-0.0251602605,
-0.036581073,
-0.0629840866,
-0.0083559798,
0.0035608727,
0.0157712474,
0.0700857565,
0.0051885108,
-0.043130938,
-0.028370304,
-0.0231412165,
-0.0351416618,
0.0048428723,
-0.00763086,
-0.0282454696,
0.0028082044,
-0.0179572962,
-0.0106711704,
0.0513497964,
0.0259716846,
-0.0118389688,
-0.0074057458,
-0.0356016979,
0.0397212915,
0.0797906667,
-0.0262282956,
0.0319219083,
0.0318235196,
-0.0176297501,
-0.0132816462,
0.0348533653,
-0.0107537908,
-0.0053476961,
0.00083984,
-0.0564959534,
0.0283140726,
0.0366985984,
-0.0472500697,
-0.006426678,
0.006422258,
0.0091181109,
0.0262360256,
0.0056615165,
-0.0484239794,
0.0659796596,
-0.0101221334,
0.0050705653,
-0.0190597121,
0.0117608625,
0.0248222593,
-0.0416148119,
0.0082039181,
-0.0263726246,
-0.0249293894,
-0.0603069514,
0.0875826254,
0.0265398007,
0.0108798398,
-0.049344752,
-0.0217248052,
-0.0286167488,
0.0000927152,
0.0141684115,
-0.0460110046,
0.1123829782,
-0.0548289977,
0.0205050558,
-0.0171201471,
-0.0321071185,
-0.0184664838,
-0.0351276733,
-0.0484621637,
0.0257206634,
0.0131178116,
-0.0249184426,
-0.0392111205,
-0.0330084339,
0.0556250364,
0.0496409349,
0.0067573567,
-0.0063412404,
-0.0407142714,
0.01646889,
0.0199889001,
0.0322311148,
-0.0557207912,
-0.022282673,
0.0304597598,
0.0715376586,
0.0143737895,
-0.0456680097,
-0.0206975918,
0.019430453,
0.0068518138,
-0.0625627935,
0.0336040705,
0.0399401821,
-0.0429635607,
-0.0689457655,
-0.0190173537,
0.0718939155,
0.0267598536,
-0.002180459,
-0.0106982626,
0.0078716837,
0.0003774261,
0.0223095473,
0.0661732703,
-0.1104787886,
-0.0148448227,
-0.0072142947,
-0.0216055214,
-0.0009675206,
-0.0501176864,
-0.0308563225,
-0.1202817857,
0.0593535528,
-0.0359046683,
-0.0381391011,
-0.0821059421,
-0.0582676642,
0.0143171474,
-0.0259557907,
0.0203135982,
0.0744095519,
-0.0263971537,
-0.0060993698,
0.0191529915,
-0.0390031748,
-0.0441876873,
0.0024147548,
-0.0627411455,
0.0370779224,
0.0452968739,
0.0224476047,
-0.0357027352,
-0.0010830588,
-0.0033629432,
0.0292005427,
-0.0003061578,
-0.010986248,
0.0461106077,
0.0067206365,
-0.0073856506,
-0.0198990349,
0.0004017016,
-0.0167286824,
0.0132033117,
0.0458912551,
0.0899796113,
-0.0213455167,
-0.0062516988,
0.0385267287,
-0.0300204754,
-0.0062638079,
0.0696869045,
0.0268669985,
0.0011675918,
-0.0615430884,
-0.0300599262,
-0.0894843787,
-0.0435989723,
0.0237144101,
0.0290003829,
-0.0326988213,
-0.0138633773,
-0.0350847356,
-0.0042643575,
0.097543031,
0.0382820144,
-0.0018555449,
0.0469129123,
0.0050339438,
-0.0126123698,
-0.0516469106,
-0.0424070433,
-0.0822287649,
0.041377712,
-0.0234024283,
-0.0512537882,
0.0042574531,
-0.0143767614,
-0.0267318115,
-0.0110106422,
-0.0662430003,
-0.0216957126,
0.0108519876,
0.0263449159,
0.024212813,
0.0097600529,
-0.0043963902,
-0.0058614407,
-0.0299018864,
-0.0003467872,
-0.083625868,
-0.0276276618,
-0.0152920419,
-0.049790971,
0.0152801685,
0.0311800502,
-0.0228077434,
-0.0046182466,
-0.0168193001,
0.0236107558,
-0.0223570075,
0.0134765552,
0.0429862887,
0.0421538614,
-0.0371160395,
0.0653045326,
-0.0638678968,
-0.0028027224,
0.0501489751,
-0.0612387285,
-0.0498380139,
0.0117385462,
-0.0101087857,
0.0075709606,
0.0102643324,
-0.0021150706,
0.0065642493,
0.0222206954,
0.0126082459,
-0.0163546242,
0.02537659,
0.0170671549,
-0.009864415,
0.0327871554,
-0.0206542183,
-0.0122806886,
-0.0239959639,
0.040745344,
0.0340622813,
0.0151684228,
0.0103794765,
0.0277914256,
-0.0408814177,
-0.0514799021,
0.0276333783,
-0.0628544539,
-0.0434173048,
0.0139398612,
0.0223726667,
0.0402319022,
0.005661807,
-0.0078134518,
-0.041234035,
-0.0287775509,
0.0212125555,
-0.0177422576,
0.0337505601,
-0.0045750528,
0.0192477815,
0.0087927077,
0.0038655775,
-0.0233939253,
0.0785828233,
0.0412664004,
0.0237316117,
0.0072079278,
-0.0097743711,
-0.0711613819,
-0.0098092081,
-0.0173172355,
-0.0294375625,
-0.0327802524,
-0.0365468077,
-0.0348178782,
-0.05230093,
0.0098953089,
0.0707479343,
-0.0296120793,
-0.0177428983,
0.0220028907,
0.0599851795,
0.07129547,
0.0076095113,
-0.0547503047,
0.041300036,
0.0037768721,
-0.0410493016,
0.0045420723,
-5.984740022e-33,
-0.0183824487,
-0.0200588834,
0.0462478697,
-0.0161529444,
0.0172683839,
-0.0318483002,
-0.0453927666,
-0.0343055986,
-0.0042426349,
-0.0016397338,
-0.0453313217,
0.0367612541,
0.0317108557,
-0.0254426841,
0.0223899949,
-0.0602508038,
0.0387846865,
-0.0250603594,
0.0142130898,
-0.0155181149,
-0.0220330991,
0.0195739251,
0.0062632845,
-0.0045905556,
0.037066251,
0.0013142361,
-0.0127200512,
0.0106844716,
-0.0230761711,
0.0119344573,
-0.0424502231,
0.0255556554,
0.0241014808,
-0.0403159484,
-0.0239095651,
0.0140952943,
-0.1434284449,
-0.0210645013,
-0.0116838338,
0.0296782963,
0.002498813,
-0.0244329013,
0.0173752643,
-0.0033541056,
-0.0296049267,
0.0240775365,
0.0170174856,
-0.036194209,
0.0227661505,
0.0247758944,
-0.0221221037,
0.0171436165,
0.0137154516,
0.0184873361,
0.0759515017,
-0.0095078759,
0.025184337,
-0.0569124594,
-0.0187576003,
0.0368339196,
0.0538859405,
0.0143845147,
0.0547645204,
-0.0268050451,
0.0376614667,
0.0139702205,
0.0384803005,
0.0358793177,
-0.0262958687,
0.0191867761,
-0.0426840298,
0.0591965988,
0.0247008968,
0.0017728411,
0.0084158676,
0.0252575092,
-0.0681663379,
0.0635814145,
0.0316324756,
0.035013631,
-0.0170055218,
-0.0321221091,
-0.0372970626,
-0.006804368,
-0.004893342,
0.050835494,
-0.0324296169,
0.0000915533,
0.0115230121,
-0.0016837382,
0.0183408838,
0.0016097063,
0.0007672459,
-0.0022836265,
-0.0505118072,
0.0246227868,
0.0166900009,
0.0092205424,
0.0147533268,
0.0010095844,
-0.0337617919,
-0.0179932546,
-0.0196604598,
-0.0253082868,
0.0147089353,
0.057626307,
0.024177596,
0.0301884897,
-0.0717899427,
0.0028903417,
-0.0432174765,
0.0607460923,
0.0216501374,
0.0276070833,
-0.0015690526,
0.015445875,
0.0286960863,
0.0637616515,
0.0294330847,
-0.0056730742,
-0.0048594568,
0.0136987753,
0.0012481675,
0.0020680001,
0.0152883613,
0.0062634507,
-0.0487198494,
0.0302332155,
0.0000602767,
-0.0370927788,
0.029617738,
0.0018200384,
2.518e-7,
0.0562782101,
0.0289736707,
0.0513443612,
0.0584149882,
-0.0016407247,
0.0087455716,
-0.0261283237,
-0.0135689648,
-0.0393327549,
-0.0064807138,
0.050610356,
0.0130468886,
0.0438943096,
0.0334262103,
-0.0363033935,
-0.0271101277,
-0.0407525748,
-0.0049061589,
-0.0634691194,
0.0158319082,
0.0237244014,
0.0815282464,
-0.0652639195,
-0.0073681399,
-0.0159798134,
-0.0376038775,
0.0170428064,
-0.0511966199,
0.0300146732,
0.0391138569,
0.0417455845,
-0.012068782,
0.0110599333,
0.0438052863,
-0.0114993257,
-0.000529745,
-0.0314933956,
0.0647940561,
0.0001017602,
0.0770532638,
0.0068701697,
-0.0920376703,
0.0242447872,
-0.0514121242,
0.1014524698,
-0.0413000733,
-0.0073250686,
0.0710228607,
-0.0092298249,
-0.0013668865,
-0.0214326791,
0.0040170574,
-0.0176269282,
-0.0005661038,
0.0153849898,
-0.0035550394,
0.0184885487,
-0.0291867126,
-0.0099754287,
0.0064324806,
-0.0225955471,
-0.0343537293,
-0.0076487651,
-0.0144686904,
-0.0220376849,
-0.0427300818,
-0.0131666884,
2.526109121e-34,
0.0520113707,
-0.0015038638,
0.0249581933,
0.0526894405,
0.0645266473,
-0.0222427342,
-0.0177271441,
0.0140789635,
0.0167140458,
-0.0928212628,
-0.0335140713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02302v1 | Predicting positive transfer for improved low-resource speech recognition using acoustic pseudo-tokens | 2024-02-03T23:54:03 | 2024-02-03T23:54:03 | Nay San, Georgios Paraskevopoulos, Aryaman Arora, Xiluo He, Prabhjot Kaur, Oliver Adams, Dan Jurafsky | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | While massively multilingual speech models like wav2vec 2.0 XLSR-128 can be
directly fine-tuned for automatic speech recognition (ASR), downstream
performance can still be relatively poor on languages that are
under-represented in the pre-training data. Continued pre-training on 70-200
hours of untranscribed speech in these languages can help -- but what about
languages without that much recorded data? For such cases, we show that
supplementing the target language with data from a similar, higher-resource
'donor' language can help. For example, continued pre-training on only 10 hours
of low-resource Punjabi supplemented with 60 hours of donor Hindi is almost as
good as continued pretraining on 70 hours of Punjabi. By contrast, sourcing
data from less similar donors like Bengali does not improve ASR performance. To
inform donor language selection, we propose a novel similarity metric based on
the sequence distribution of induced acoustic units: the Acoustic Token
Distribution Similarity (ATDS). Across a set of typologically different target
languages (Punjabi, Galician, Iban, Setswana), we show that the ATDS between
the target language and its candidate donors precisely predicts target language
ASR performance. | [
-0.014122759,
0.0803385973,
-0.0276975315,
0.0037793287,
-0.0557432994,
-0.0079666711,
0.0173331667,
0.0143425073,
-0.0707732216,
0.0025363676,
-0.0528638326,
-0.0387180112,
0.0315943137,
0.0088720117,
0.0351597965,
-0.06658151,
0.0263934899,
-0.0649951771,
0.0338314474,
-0.0101752346,
-0.017456146,
-0.0027287288,
-0.0277386215,
0.0499868877,
-0.036836043,
0.0412211008,
0.0249927659,
0.018164495,
0.0076665105,
-0.0369101912,
-0.0619340092,
0.0181262828,
0.0001205042,
0.005367761,
0.0000017674,
-0.060524717,
-0.0010146467,
0.0012246366,
-0.0268696435,
0.0259977207,
0.039516326,
0.0240604002,
-0.0042313677,
0.0425528251,
0.0167838577,
-0.0144306459,
0.0594491214,
0.0243722796,
-0.0052087083,
0.0443177931,
-0.0239145607,
0.0010469719,
0.0010896861,
0.0099947434,
-0.0104746195,
-0.0262928624,
0.0100928703,
-0.0400062315,
0.0167375952,
-0.0420205779,
-0.0325142443,
0.0202348866,
-0.0076220795,
-0.006955924,
0.02634627,
0.009115329,
-0.1174261197,
-0.0438955761,
0.0046351845,
0.0341538489,
-0.0276739504,
-0.0393422581,
-0.0001604919,
0.0071950136,
-0.0082751,
-0.0123519301,
-0.0296902731,
-0.0509822704,
0.038777221,
0.0179418866,
0.0408989489,
0.0143240253,
0.025203865,
-0.0222515687,
-0.009355912,
-0.0101661738,
0.0273014773,
-0.0403664447,
-0.006245621,
-0.0270949285,
-0.0399752185,
-0.0197832584,
0.0388560705,
-0.0180873182,
0.0092199873,
-0.009415511,
0.0073789856,
-0.042780865,
0.0005837656,
0.0087168766,
0.0056732506,
0.0602928549,
-0.0939579234,
-0.0017977455,
-0.0574115179,
0.0447423868,
0.0058874222,
0.0222954024,
-0.0534570068,
-0.0298722684,
-0.0238723774,
-0.0142164575,
-0.0454433002,
0.0188641399,
0.0017565389,
0.0006352034,
-0.0328804478,
-0.0047364142,
-0.0189725887,
-0.0291046426,
0.0292415321,
-0.0235678814,
-0.0382483117,
-0.0079573123,
0.0242860392,
0.0347220823,
-0.0154947462,
0.0491388962,
-0.0143758394,
-0.0983402282,
0.0074987411,
0.0297960266,
0.0145233516,
-0.0072226333,
0.0104447901,
0.0845342875,
-0.0018935775,
-0.0175558552,
-0.0268602371,
0.0354097486,
0.0066886274,
-0.0337775089,
-0.0326318555,
-0.033625517,
0.015255101,
0.0356312618,
0.0121711353,
-0.0021049441,
-0.0348871462,
-0.0317765065,
0.0201522261,
0.0457121804,
0.0053308541,
0.0339438841,
0.046699997,
-0.0157392472,
-0.0114500606,
0.032328289,
0.0162574109,
-0.036653176,
0.0317334831,
-0.0570203476,
-0.0393960476,
0.0519980639,
0.024034705,
0.0373061858,
-0.0235828068,
-0.0035890311,
0.0348950587,
0.0063943355,
0.0366925038,
0.023323385,
-0.02614302,
-0.0027479667,
0.0398248099,
0.1013921201,
0.0071699191,
0.018231798,
0.0179498903,
-0.0053496477,
-0.035889186,
-0.0061951969,
-0.0232388172,
0.0031517562,
0.0411746949,
0.0047979094,
0.0648645684,
0.0285061505,
-0.0349004231,
0.0347752385,
-0.0171591453,
-0.0267979149,
-0.0180763341,
-0.0104647856,
0.0662858561,
-0.0135836722,
-0.0465318412,
0.0524577238,
0.0371244811,
-0.0366039611,
0.0575600006,
-0.0744917989,
0.0157058574,
0.0083527872,
-0.020697467,
-0.0369291604,
0.0217875559,
0.0056145135,
-0.0101695349,
0.0110433185,
0.0097238999,
0.0166431665,
0.0518327989,
-0.040242292,
-0.0070105884,
0.0514993779,
-0.0190844648,
0.0642187893,
-0.0486413799,
0.0583194792,
0.0009796014,
-0.0782189965,
-0.0069910698,
-0.0028044283,
-0.0066939276,
0.014125769,
0.063573882,
0.0240669176,
0.0766585097,
0.0373151004,
-0.0068006185,
-0.0088601848,
0.0301559642,
-0.0556646734,
-0.0026328608,
0.0714485198,
-0.0679665729,
0.018775316,
0.0124200014,
0.0136578791,
0.0697594956,
0.0233486108,
0.0176717918,
-0.069227159,
0.0806102455,
0.009738978,
0.1097156331,
-0.028467821,
0.0593301617,
0.0003115819,
0.0164471809,
0.036155697,
-0.0159799773,
0.0356895961,
0.0136134094,
0.0063714865,
0.0019948806,
0.055416286,
-0.0529646091,
0.0123255253,
0.0378297158,
-0.0202817712,
-0.0035107541,
0.0290791262,
-0.0032600502,
-0.0096998904,
0.0070412229,
-0.0883206949,
-0.0226296354,
-0.0110701546,
0.0287790466,
-0.0238828417,
0.0323109329,
0.0027618615,
-0.0113215791,
-0.0349102132,
-0.0516388156,
-0.0008535875,
0.0182310566,
-0.0327169672,
-0.0159787629,
-0.0153905433,
0.0061689578,
-0.0276122261,
0.0473423041,
0.0259758886,
-0.0130640035,
-0.0122809382,
-0.0548888557,
-0.0324580185,
0.0089580435,
-0.0149792675,
0.0029526604,
-0.0571652353,
-0.0358290374,
0.0150624132,
0.0160639808,
0.0225021373,
0.0051075905,
-0.0642465204,
0.008205154,
0.0140981684,
-0.036007341,
-0.0279525686,
0.0225906242,
0.0207583867,
-0.0148882996,
0.0010659625,
-0.0092095034,
0.0026441913,
-0.0041486765,
-0.0088185016,
-0.073554419,
-0.0783383995,
-0.046906244,
-0.0341600031,
-0.011715373,
-0.0231954698,
-0.0380619392,
0.018460596,
-0.0138778882,
-0.0403373055,
0.0298302062,
-0.0699354634,
-0.021227764,
-0.0329766273,
-0.0340674967,
-0.016927043,
-0.0112507679,
0.0037714385,
0.0065872399,
-0.050647404,
-0.0477582924,
-0.0062938267,
0.0052657509,
-0.0059446581,
-0.0287763309,
-0.0139846131,
-0.0079478147,
0.0199525058,
-0.0249749441,
-0.0491298959,
-0.0008733196,
-0.0065997923,
0.0282427017,
0.0435667895,
0.0235678852,
-0.0088601429,
0.0014432515,
0.0437514447,
0.0144411577,
0.0534443408,
0.0113052735,
0.027588686,
0.0079720477,
0.0256778877,
0.0010672359,
0.0361559279,
-0.0141566442,
-0.0300206412,
-0.0047270381,
-0.0477525033,
0.1019918546,
-0.0193363912,
-0.0057626981,
0.0080659762,
0.0557701029,
0.0062809177,
-0.0195612218,
0.0280578639,
0.0692700222,
0.036202576,
0.0063947081,
0.0443582647,
-0.0157578196,
-0.0226093959,
0.0258438867,
-0.047679171,
0.0322975069,
0.0078667849,
-0.0340050347,
-0.0377958231,
-0.0048944457,
0.0538422503,
0.0330706276,
-0.0221000202,
0.0120274751,
-0.0160556212,
-0.1056602448,
-0.0064677205,
-0.0017862957,
-0.0838107765,
-0.0165279135,
-0.0663704425,
-0.010340956,
-0.0399375297,
0.054941345,
0.006268736,
-0.015878519,
-0.0304462612,
0.0747458637,
-0.0168630295,
-0.0507150069,
-0.0049716327,
-0.0410987027,
0.0676036254,
0.0392533764,
-0.0123242438,
-0.0283404216,
-0.031975463,
0.0096247839,
-0.024649974,
-0.0020487399,
-0.0173582714,
0.0162997879,
0.0327146724,
-0.0202718861,
0.0318277963,
0.0371241271,
-0.0068557495,
-0.0120404735,
0.032237377,
0.0881830752,
0.0285632424,
-0.0111755719,
0.0280555151,
-0.028308006,
0.0031956332,
0.0523631647,
0.0105252052,
-0.0461913347,
0.0402639769,
0.0529850535,
0.0333619863,
-0.0131271603,
0.0175335221,
-0.0026577271,
-0.0663418472,
-0.0737087429,
-0.0477250963,
0.0202007256,
-0.0013328228,
0.0937473997,
0.0542167239,
0.0847083628,
-0.0344794542,
0.0080097653,
0.0017075464,
0.0080869012,
-0.0119172782,
0.046431087,
-0.0772016421,
-0.0369125381,
0.0080617163,
-0.0480573736,
-0.0310955495,
-0.0427903458,
-0.0221841466,
-0.0548569523,
0.0137738148,
0.0032578004,
0.0184002481,
0.041954834,
0.0162167437,
-0.0584495589,
0.068518512,
0.0278949961,
-0.079937242,
0.0003006222,
0.0516372025,
-0.0343213193,
-0.0048119808,
0.0344103239,
-0.0416298211,
0.0077387718,
0.0087982332,
0.0030300641,
0.0000374608,
0.0122271087,
-0.0173646882,
0.057323724,
0.0551487431,
-0.0566642918,
-0.0310103018,
-0.0108517725,
0.0421310253,
0.0089275269,
0.0596822165,
-0.0201659687,
-0.0414642692,
0.0155624915,
0.0324665792,
-0.0250509251,
-0.0043479283,
-0.0242522638,
0.0138273146,
0.027067475,
0.0727526546,
0.0046443301,
0.0739789605,
0.0327460393,
0.0039887498,
0.0008921285,
-0.0380857252,
0.0117015466,
0.0027690013,
-0.0601344667,
-0.0020118649,
0.0105405804,
0.0464109816,
0.0737476423,
0.0192484166,
0.0144238966,
-0.0135465981,
0.0162601024,
0.0215577409,
0.0205727518,
-0.0384808667,
0.0563132018,
0.0034364245,
0.0226610545,
-0.05078822,
0.0082484297,
-0.0508082211,
0.0015686284,
-0.0068512568,
-0.0053312718,
-0.0244438406,
0.0538085289,
0.0401572846,
0.0010766704,
0.0121452641,
-0.0702048317,
0.0443134345,
0.0155081246,
-0.0158932786,
0.0189876892,
0.0171674378,
-0.0160498917,
0.0212963261,
-0.0333755799,
-0.0845361203,
-0.020066252,
-0.0445404947,
0.0240691118,
0.0199587513,
0.0125772618,
0.03465195,
-0.043880254,
-0.0098493472,
0.0009219976,
-0.027714964,
0.0308754109,
-0.0029822593,
0.0562133826,
-5.856434079e-33,
0.0250999946,
0.0213964265,
-0.0264143124,
-0.0141220726,
-0.024121372,
0.023987256,
-0.0034569844,
-0.025666859,
0.0186015684,
-0.0388211273,
-0.0141485371,
-0.030253781,
0.0306484941,
0.0272156373,
0.0226660091,
0.0213986114,
0.0845117047,
0.0393245965,
0.002835029,
0.0079358593,
0.0548349842,
0.0213905312,
0.045240391,
-0.0274606105,
-0.0406989492,
-0.0116746612,
0.0609540269,
-0.0136942547,
0.057566911,
0.0146099608,
0.0056506819,
0.0444151238,
0.0008649413,
-0.0442496054,
-0.0045075361,
-0.0336228311,
-0.0773319602,
-0.0228666384,
0.0557849929,
0.0580075085,
0.0190514214,
-0.0221870579,
0.0147492848,
0.0107198264,
-0.0570869669,
0.0367450863,
-0.0018370996,
-0.0046584555,
-0.0437289588,
-0.030830089,
-0.0528106727,
0.0552354231,
-0.0202736799,
0.0398282222,
0.0463846922,
0.0588192232,
-0.0227065962,
-0.0378640033,
-0.0221838877,
0.0139874201,
-0.0145509494,
0.0772583038,
0.0489600599,
0.0388106629,
-0.0050540562,
-0.0078295004,
0.0739728957,
-0.0969926044,
0.0744176731,
-0.0354158245,
0.0587404296,
-0.0123768039,
0.0048487447,
0.0088212788,
0.0609888546,
-0.0964369699,
-0.0320600495,
-0.0050339187,
-0.0071514845,
0.0085352222,
0.0240582731,
0.0471179858,
-0.0151976645,
-0.0035744128,
-0.0223621689,
-0.0447319709,
-0.03485208,
-0.0425642543,
0.073509939,
-0.010392461,
0.0103295436,
0.0141370213,
0.0785498396,
0.0280681252,
-0.0083219018,
0.0242289472,
-0.0226882622,
-0.0093935998,
-0.0343877785,
0.0117724361,
-0.0754702762,
-0.0761590004,
0.0485787429,
0.0234039128,
0.0249287393,
-0.0560543165,
0.0353373624,
0.0163733922,
-0.0729549602,
0.004205469,
0.0183946658,
0.019502325,
0.0288547073,
-0.0032724424,
0.0510322377,
0.0226874538,
0.0032090102,
-0.0039418149,
0.0070917294,
-0.0299219489,
-0.0112233106,
0.0255304482,
-0.0060782605,
0.0205261689,
-0.0668957978,
0.0165862311,
-0.020537911,
-0.0097377058,
0.0022557289,
-0.0343619138,
-0.0337499045,
0.0103730103,
2.682e-7,
-0.0739264637,
0.0137061635,
0.0192701314,
-0.0750974342,
-0.0207441505,
0.0056662089,
-0.0725991353,
-0.0040149624,
0.0105398539,
0.0462220497,
0.0117215663,
-0.0099768853,
0.0564976037,
0.0324392878,
-0.0916032046,
-0.0050515779,
-0.0715278909,
0.0080091134,
-0.057090763,
0.0135735488,
-0.0194608625,
0.0790157318,
0.0079346048,
-0.0407605767,
-0.0025567242,
-0.049453903,
0.00737538,
-0.0322658643,
0.0016473768,
-0.0303399432,
0.0128384857,
-0.0219045077,
0.0012399293,
0.0486230776,
-0.048444014,
0.0220452044,
0.0319064185,
0.0115023926,
-0.0388908461,
-0.0257790852,
-0.0045084637,
0.0506509021,
-0.0314639993,
-0.0217441581,
0.0447724313,
0.0371721983,
-0.0468283556,
-0.0231281873,
-0.0652787313,
0.0136746792,
0.014252306,
-0.0049373251,
-0.0037411333,
0.0434804261,
0.016449403,
-0.0136260847,
-0.0221794378,
0.0005390807,
0.0389869139,
0.0083763031,
-0.031706322,
-0.054703977,
-0.0322949253,
0.0594719797,
0.0204972625,
-0.0016720318,
0.0350026339,
1.904616533e-34,
0.0507786199,
-0.0156430956,
0.0342241861,
-0.0019034691,
0.0037245012,
-0.0439183377,
-0.0094532352,
0.038969066,
-0.0146965906,
-0.0204734597,
-0.0175107867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02289v1 | SemPool: Simple, robust, and interpretable KG pooling for enhancing language models | 2024-02-03T23:03:51 | 2024-02-03T23:03:51 | Costas Mavromatis, Petros Karypis, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge Graph (KG) powered question answering (QA) performs complex
reasoning over language semantics as well as knowledge facts. Graph Neural
Networks (GNNs) learn to aggregate information from the underlying KG, which is
combined with Language Models (LMs) for effective reasoning with the given
question. However, GNN-based methods for QA rely on the graph information of
the candidate answer nodes, which limits their effectiveness in more
challenging settings where critical answer information is not included in the
KG. We propose a simple graph pooling approach that learns useful semantics of
the KG that can aid the LM's reasoning and that its effectiveness is robust
under graph perturbations. Our method, termed SemPool, represents KG facts with
pre-trained LMs, learns to aggregate their semantic information, and fuses it
at different layers of the LM. Our experimental results show that SemPool
outperforms state-of-the-art GNN-based methods by 2.27% accuracy points on
average when answer information is missing from the KG. In addition, SemPool
offers interpretability on what type of graph information is fused at different
LM layers. | [
0.0356193148,
0.0128040239,
0.0299470946,
0.0399591103,
-0.025062684,
0.0020082113,
-0.0289152525,
-0.0297554191,
0.0560427122,
-0.0332175419,
0.0064193755,
0.0210209005,
-0.0023576764,
0.037492346,
0.0283717215,
-0.0068745525,
0.017336566,
-0.0185462292,
0.018623475,
-0.0225137696,
-0.0043538371,
0.0633911788,
-0.0042027077,
0.0139981527,
-0.0201389454,
-0.0060789944,
-0.009396798,
0.0202914868,
-0.0291547794,
0.0033825091,
-0.005721251,
0.0108641936,
0.0190022197,
0.0170280617,
0.0000019873,
-0.0196342114,
-0.0016687302,
-0.0063680983,
-0.0613026023,
0.0186274368,
-0.0215435792,
0.0008367076,
0.0354616642,
0.0065345932,
-0.0471172854,
-0.0262590013,
0.0164199658,
0.0113162212,
0.066132009,
0.0264442451,
-0.0017743361,
-0.0124081103,
-0.0052133109,
-0.0095164562,
-0.0113290707,
-0.0796103179,
0.0288489908,
0.0467859842,
0.0170348398,
-0.0275596306,
-0.0393820554,
0.0266782418,
0.0422827825,
-0.0236808825,
0.0287111159,
0.0474791862,
-0.0227705054,
0.0411538705,
0.0114034312,
0.1294313371,
-0.0170443412,
-0.043031022,
-0.028445268,
-0.0294449944,
0.0090683289,
0.0297779683,
-0.0567454062,
-0.0182339381,
0.0234186333,
0.0076923375,
-0.0635272637,
-0.0238432586,
0.0742584988,
0.0179393757,
-0.0273472387,
0.0860896781,
0.0010119122,
0.0183002949,
0.0090557775,
0.0181536563,
-0.0627890304,
-0.0360848717,
-0.0230844356,
0.0867773294,
-0.0021865116,
0.0374331176,
-0.0174550265,
0.0021686186,
0.0178177878,
-0.0488514639,
-0.0042290329,
0.0030716129,
-0.0015426468,
0.0925876871,
-0.0250401814,
0.0242495257,
-0.0279888418,
0.0812712759,
-0.059789855,
-0.0587302558,
-0.0390230194,
-0.0314021669,
-0.0415141284,
0.032894928,
-0.0102740452,
-0.0573463999,
-0.0398916937,
0.053387206,
-0.0174672026,
-0.0065489714,
0.0159365777,
0.0798746571,
0.0360222533,
-0.0292300247,
-0.0186148081,
0.0622649305,
-0.0468324833,
0.0310541447,
-0.0022343299,
-0.0224933438,
-0.0353636332,
-0.0054218071,
0.0540597029,
-0.0130344993,
0.0156172495,
0.0663568676,
0.0246581044,
0.0263019949,
-0.0106468974,
-0.0305597018,
-0.0049801865,
-0.0271194205,
0.0089228097,
-0.0813492835,
0.0729844049,
0.0248513371,
-0.0368120931,
-0.0486551896,
0.0167225506,
-0.0043537361,
-0.0411749706,
0.045707345,
-0.0413366891,
-0.0048592258,
0.0164114758,
-0.0053220964,
-0.0236410722,
0.0658797771,
0.0294631608,
0.0101793651,
0.0421162173,
-0.0017039914,
-0.0185694229,
0.0135353943,
0.0625605434,
-0.0051049683,
0.0367361158,
0.0204741936,
-0.0339211076,
-0.0153412549,
-0.0015341875,
0.0237260535,
-0.0224958267,
-0.0442610085,
0.0233802237,
0.0509649217,
-0.0058967844,
0.0118735628,
0.0151516479,
0.0163035858,
-0.0124646341,
-0.0063166744,
-0.0394274034,
0.020895049,
-0.0412946083,
0.0197004266,
-0.0123783872,
-0.0099378629,
-0.0278938841,
-0.0155480281,
-0.003792664,
-0.0196360014,
0.0765627697,
0.0552664436,
0.0512921102,
0.0207975153,
-0.0195670724,
0.0744035915,
0.0334278867,
0.0092552667,
0.0160334297,
-0.0105619505,
0.0056880098,
0.0475097708,
0.0336096808,
0.0127843628,
-0.0559155643,
0.0159411822,
0.0140682105,
-0.0159321427,
0.0183758494,
-0.0181316771,
0.040764723,
-0.0583579652,
-0.0308817606,
-0.0622974262,
-0.0183397494,
0.0189118404,
0.0229575131,
-0.0120229507,
0.0265246201,
-0.0869118795,
-0.0065802876,
-0.0018171933,
0.0228643324,
-0.0080456287,
0.0171767995,
-0.0158444587,
-0.0222877618,
0.0156337116,
0.0410139225,
0.0463050418,
0.017905131,
-0.0022551117,
-0.0563425869,
0.0036098831,
-0.0536293648,
-0.0696806237,
0.0339137651,
0.0139795104,
-0.0114424052,
-0.0140983518,
-0.0784179121,
-0.046986755,
0.0535859987,
-0.0592354983,
0.0563640855,
-0.0128682079,
-0.033595372,
0.0275793485,
0.0010109489,
-0.0051086335,
0.0674527064,
-0.0228128377,
-0.002532817,
-0.013423007,
0.0469825268,
0.0101779141,
-0.0417619161,
0.0250973646,
0.0069407588,
-0.0052126716,
-0.0068862494,
0.0031743059,
-0.0202953741,
-0.0680004731,
0.0439968146,
-0.1141120642,
0.0071783969,
0.0046993298,
0.0174350962,
0.0102704559,
0.0188228972,
0.0257573295,
-0.0396118425,
-0.078347072,
0.0267345626,
0.036362648,
0.0137863047,
0.0255631413,
0.0193587951,
0.0244439431,
-0.029538054,
-0.0597320162,
-0.0217500813,
0.1011871845,
0.0256651863,
-0.0104415808,
0.0121848108,
0.0013936131,
-0.0807740986,
0.0299624,
-0.0118051022,
-0.006269468,
-0.0090078264,
-0.0420645811,
-0.0094567761,
0.0262110177,
-0.0296021979,
0.0042524361,
0.0327804573,
-0.017087169,
-0.0581052564,
0.0116947526,
-0.0576577708,
0.0047442806,
-0.0184549112,
0.0109804673,
-0.0012726381,
0.0127336904,
0.017446883,
-0.0251375996,
-0.0467586294,
0.0167373177,
0.0172666032,
0.0179570653,
-0.0383145884,
-0.0324702151,
0.0186356548,
-0.0172838718,
-0.0487759523,
0.0049213152,
0.0891252011,
0.0091299983,
-0.0260310378,
-0.0025753344,
-0.0428170711,
-0.0797610506,
0.0350759104,
0.0023396795,
-0.0006230419,
-0.0430622362,
-0.0023199155,
-0.0098541752,
-0.0465358756,
0.0124275461,
-0.0328188762,
0.0285448357,
-0.0037449074,
0.0368257053,
0.0159661118,
0.0047354149,
-0.0382006094,
-0.0042843381,
-0.0488337688,
0.0438491926,
-0.0132175284,
0.0062145134,
0.0343311802,
-0.0251210853,
-0.0020142992,
-0.0054134401,
-0.0281753093,
0.020589849,
-0.0096698375,
0.0592820905,
0.058638148,
0.0463130809,
0.0308571253,
0.003880928,
0.0291938595,
0.0773432776,
0.0247783363,
-0.0354668982,
-0.0240211226,
0.0173429921,
-0.0138835013,
0.0008600492,
0.0121951224,
-0.0197306741,
0.0599856973,
-0.0670992434,
0.0201017968,
0.0870786607,
0.0204396285,
-0.0124243954,
-0.0081780041,
-0.0046445541,
0.0026645609,
0.0017005061,
0.0227738507,
-0.0835564807,
-0.0284932852,
-0.0248241052,
0.0308304392,
0.0342322402,
-0.0297725368,
-0.021975223,
-0.0961389765,
-0.0170130823,
0.0155024473,
-0.0255558938,
-0.0329511128,
-0.0522803925,
-0.014779604,
-0.0184029154,
-0.0076788873,
-0.0098088346,
-0.0084574176,
0.0047758771,
0.0215955041,
-0.0157344379,
-0.0071406183,
0.0557865575,
-0.0178284813,
-0.009377135,
-0.0010239206,
0.0387338623,
0.0126843378,
-0.0178739149,
0.0619672015,
-0.0352998525,
-0.0229245499,
-0.0102779567,
0.0193022452,
0.0122474851,
-0.0095080314,
-0.0427567549,
0.0283758864,
-0.0531439483,
-0.0298543535,
-0.0323193371,
0.0697552189,
0.0024318655,
-0.0457797647,
0.0089507485,
0.0158769004,
-0.0289392564,
0.0273384731,
0.0584077984,
0.0223823879,
-0.041695483,
-0.0459364355,
-0.0011337881,
-0.0604112111,
-0.0249003991,
0.0454123132,
0.0145195406,
0.0365607664,
-0.0589284711,
-0.0470366552,
0.0394296125,
0.0184057876,
-0.0222640652,
0.013793855,
0.0329532921,
-0.0121436818,
-0.0669824779,
0.0517004989,
-0.053202372,
0.0196355339,
0.011016774,
-0.0165120345,
0.0081533175,
0.0049504158,
-0.0242491029,
0.012728476,
-0.0722180009,
-0.09529154,
-0.0376383029,
0.0255118757,
0.0173203144,
0.0496891476,
-0.0559594892,
-0.0098957978,
0.0446062125,
-0.001016946,
-0.0409247354,
0.0039426498,
0.0248234402,
-0.0181925464,
-0.0188021064,
0.0263651349,
-0.1042573899,
-0.0031547181,
0.0180964861,
0.039609801,
-0.0654638112,
-0.0338050686,
-0.0048990906,
0.0262591783,
-0.0216335487,
0.0497804396,
0.0179532822,
-0.0271829646,
-0.0049241376,
-0.0115446765,
0.0043359161,
-0.039119076,
-0.0244356096,
0.0069413623,
-0.038611494,
0.0019059598,
-0.0547875315,
0.0213411916,
0.0219165329,
-0.0150860623,
-0.0399356335,
0.0438628457,
-0.0369600393,
0.0193433762,
0.0083408421,
-0.0396054536,
0.0471476428,
-0.0041379509,
0.040167354,
-0.008780377,
0.0352520905,
0.0240323469,
-0.0410784893,
-0.055810079,
0.001863185,
-0.0845465809,
-0.0737521201,
-0.0189341437,
0.0160387196,
0.0529084243,
0.0090498282,
0.0111892149,
-0.0047634575,
-0.0207719319,
-0.0201755892,
0.0185513366,
0.0137630412,
-0.0539682359,
0.0538279526,
0.0385884903,
0.0010580394,
0.0251697283,
0.0499712192,
0.0539381243,
0.035408482,
-0.0024384789,
-0.0241345596,
-0.018333964,
-0.0383553989,
-0.0291920137,
0.0668017194,
-0.0054817665,
0.0267258883,
-0.0344880149,
-0.0963654667,
0.000792974,
-0.0052125454,
-0.0050374931,
0.0193198826,
0.024269361,
0.019606974,
0.047151953,
-0.0171214081,
-0.0296755973,
0.06786412,
-0.0413809083,
0.010998291,
0.0186878685,
-6.372657566e-33,
-0.0185237713,
-0.0661603883,
0.007788951,
0.0072149723,
-0.0291371923,
0.0077403286,
-0.0488342457,
-0.0058841291,
-0.0595541149,
0.0073368712,
0.0102774734,
0.0128054265,
-0.009812057,
0.0451513119,
-0.0230883118,
-0.0453946479,
-0.0059305276,
0.0420536958,
0.0111368373,
0.0368718952,
0.0437399894,
0.0350569449,
0.0399297252,
-0.0547060333,
0.020117268,
-0.0434869118,
0.0356908329,
0.0165197141,
-0.0013056634,
0.0461923741,
-0.0075047147,
0.0648980141,
0.0361936428,
0.0026191704,
-0.0064991899,
0.0125427712,
-0.1090759933,
-0.0511443987,
0.0426118784,
0.027995633,
-0.0461891256,
-0.014712926,
0.0434649959,
-0.0061098193,
0.0766130164,
-0.0467724465,
0.0306845866,
0.0137871196,
-0.0509979464,
-0.0027275633,
-0.0033566647,
0.0262926426,
-0.0131989289,
-0.0115505978,
-0.0229598284,
-0.014371166,
0.0004367122,
-0.0066585541,
-0.0531890467,
-0.0113293286,
-0.0195064694,
-0.0107837757,
0.0306201465,
0.0345742702,
0.0116493106,
0.0409606844,
-0.0409215204,
-0.0389433131,
-0.0794978738,
0.0181905422,
0.0214753244,
0.0438932851,
0.0451418608,
-0.0050080968,
-0.0143293375,
0.0219542682,
-0.0785506815,
0.0033836202,
0.0164532065,
0.0292747878,
-0.0301040206,
0.0211926438,
0.0098702172,
-0.0547441877,
-0.0353835747,
0.0205813013,
-0.0443254113,
-0.0336245783,
-0.003105694,
-0.0109770223,
-0.0446097367,
0.0456371345,
-0.0050723823,
-0.0628833175,
0.0024087923,
0.1142823994,
0.0263972282,
0.0099284267,
-0.0040890635,
0.0431133471,
-0.030805828,
0.0508817025,
0.0414801016,
-0.0287945438,
-0.01701154,
0.0498964898,
0.0203255042,
-0.0026865716,
-0.0047499845,
-0.0131783281,
-0.0650710911,
-0.0159451775,
-0.0429914258,
0.004770604,
0.0321516879,
0.0796855092,
-0.016913034,
0.0177200586,
0.0182871241,
0.0622676574,
0.0103313355,
0.035449408,
0.016438365,
0.0372180529,
-0.0474655591,
-0.0252862256,
-0.0166156627,
0.0127376448,
-0.0159952845,
-0.0467244387,
-0.0093058804,
0.0168205183,
2.659e-7,
0.093548581,
-0.0054044789,
0.0448092408,
0.0300767086,
0.0026344005,
0.0162275024,
0.004646562,
-0.0030997347,
0.0407467186,
-0.0191901997,
0.0105344718,
0.0819552094,
-0.0218268055,
0.0474228784,
-0.0478432663,
0.0333644785,
-0.0561327338,
-0.0345158391,
-0.0218053274,
-0.0072734575,
0.0426521711,
0.053502351,
0.0594050176,
-0.0212897547,
-0.0259519983,
-0.0800078064,
0.0636118725,
0.0151983956,
0.0012097091,
0.0050260411,
0.0098344469,
0.0191871636,
-0.0117005231,
0.0222662259,
-0.022180263,
0.0178800076,
0.0288084578,
0.0390683003,
-0.0131780896,
-0.0568584763,
-0.0242343917,
-0.0407997072,
0.0449702293,
-0.0432753973,
0.111926116,
-0.0466917269,
-0.0253175087,
-0.0284996964,
-0.01664312,
-0.0264571067,
0.0289415643,
0.0005102784,
-0.0011329087,
0.0094148405,
0.0212054867,
-0.0452745967,
0.0152406758,
-0.0944740102,
-0.0243094545,
0.0092804637,
-0.0208244789,
-0.0044698603,
0.0007174977,
0.0061004548,
0.0249944385,
0.0008466458,
0.0286959261,
2.21051552e-34,
0.0147672417,
0.0174085703,
0.0120458612,
0.0262869466,
0.01409378,
-0.0057945149,
-0.0084096296,
0.0138087496,
0.0504869036,
-0.0836852342,
0.0033259261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02285v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02285v1 | SynthDST: Synthetic Data is All You Need for Few-Shot Dialog State Tracking | 2024-02-03T22:49:00 | 2024-02-03T22:49:00 | Atharva Kulkarni, Bo-Hsiang Tseng, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Hong Yu, Shruti Bhargava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In-context learning with Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
promising avenue of research in Dialog State Tracking (DST). However, the
best-performing in-context learning methods involve retrieving and adding
similar examples to the prompt, requiring access to labeled training data.
Procuring such training data for a wide range of domains and applications is
time-consuming, expensive, and, at times, infeasible. While zero-shot learning
requires no training data, it significantly lags behind the few-shot setup.
Thus, `\textit{Can we efficiently generate synthetic data for any dialogue
schema to enable few-shot prompting?}' Addressing this question, we propose
\method, a data generation framework tailored for DST, utilizing LLMs. Our
approach only requires the dialogue schema and a few hand-crafted dialogue
templates to synthesize natural, coherent, and free-flowing dialogues with DST
annotations. Few-shot learning using data from {\method} results in $4-5%$
improvement in Joint Goal Accuracy over the zero-shot baseline on MultiWOZ 2.1
and 2.4. Remarkably, our few-shot learning approach recovers nearly $98%$ of
the performance compared to the few-shot setup using human-annotated training
data. Our synthetic data and code can be accessed at
https://github.com/apple/ml-synthdst | [
0.0079027237,
0.0716445372,
0.0121640135,
0.0215596072,
-0.0018338456,
0.0074342908,
0.034566354,
-0.0052562235,
0.0199294407,
-0.0661083162,
-0.0283184703,
-0.0604676567,
-0.0324333087,
0.0655877888,
0.0204032362,
-0.0688060597,
0.0474678315,
-0.0400002971,
-0.0093220333,
0.0059362464,
0.0323108323,
0.0129512455,
-0.0578968078,
0.0528851114,
-0.0190268103,
-0.0347271673,
-0.0533602387,
0.0228559095,
-0.003288819,
-0.0324743502,
-0.0138731496,
0.0458430909,
0.0432662703,
0.0357866548,
0.0000018715,
-0.0498386025,
0.0058339746,
-0.0237757303,
-0.0598762594,
-0.0179587305,
-0.0003730069,
-0.0058038211,
-0.0309712719,
0.0453358069,
-0.0305416342,
-0.0096563231,
0.0306236669,
0.013631653,
0.0815896913,
0.0889050588,
-0.0126371635,
-0.0216738973,
0.0154569261,
-0.0186796449,
0.0269186441,
-0.0522294044,
-0.023820471,
-0.0074815778,
0.0024949734,
0.0110686263,
0.0066191661,
0.0186065398,
0.0104697635,
-0.046757035,
-0.0230021812,
0.0142957261,
-0.0471753888,
-0.0286790263,
-0.0369498879,
0.1006585211,
0.0242444072,
0.0304959435,
0.0090044392,
0.000603153,
0.0172053706,
-0.0379387289,
-0.0721691623,
-0.0115231937,
-0.0150079709,
-0.0056917141,
-0.0332756452,
0.0079568559,
-0.0180263743,
-0.0183016621,
-0.0031324246,
0.0055048964,
0.0038802992,
-0.0128902048,
-0.0278787147,
-0.0102211274,
0.0075312983,
-0.0845231414,
-0.0273722224,
0.0185727552,
-0.0765006766,
0.020293653,
-0.0760406852,
0.0013613298,
-0.0038131948,
-0.0090194009,
0.0346287116,
0.0563951842,
-0.0178815592,
0.0421734378,
0.0198316555,
0.0523390993,
0.0064598885,
-0.0146545833,
-0.0157025941,
-0.0056295604,
-0.0594144687,
0.0168502405,
-0.0664614812,
0.0061133411,
-0.053466212,
-0.0555479452,
-0.0292364229,
0.0448826291,
-0.0002131107,
0.0389091894,
-0.0290118866,
0.005731035,
-0.0293756239,
-0.0024894173,
0.0014451086,
0.0389032662,
-0.0287539903,
0.0007953276,
0.0493641496,
-0.0634828806,
-0.0240272488,
0.0335598066,
0.043726977,
0.0024180105,
-0.0123986695,
0.0647161603,
-0.0161106456,
-0.0388183296,
-0.0206039511,
-0.0282264687,
-0.0224075262,
-0.0484268665,
-0.0109606478,
-0.0370546915,
0.033177413,
-0.0217581671,
-0.0116066542,
-0.022230573,
0.0019124304,
0.0245173741,
0.0136605995,
0.0416168757,
-0.0345464125,
-0.0115004946,
0.0044437419,
-0.0015023388,
-0.0209177099,
0.0820241943,
0.0367547385,
0.0212800484,
0.0326061174,
-0.0072550462,
0.0386145376,
0.0364617854,
0.0396537185,
0.0261388607,
-0.0343037993,
0.0326335914,
-0.0057389946,
0.020783823,
0.0319765024,
0.0287954416,
-0.0608724579,
0.0152427843,
0.0708549097,
0.0515699163,
0.0320253149,
-0.0171764884,
0.0335626453,
0.0497410968,
0.013105805,
-0.0199756492,
-0.0276109409,
0.0430954248,
-0.0003108771,
0.0072955401,
0.0341339894,
0.0058480962,
-0.0499846675,
-0.0216240901,
0.0212628245,
-0.0004369046,
-0.0374380983,
0.00459173,
0.0238255393,
0.0274610966,
-0.0718146712,
0.0301967207,
0.0047802515,
-0.0416626446,
-0.0563044026,
-0.0119524868,
0.0111050755,
0.0805602893,
0.0254884623,
-0.0168383252,
-0.0534739979,
-0.0698475689,
0.0246772282,
0.0590921603,
0.0242563728,
-0.0393007211,
0.0713534355,
-0.0535558276,
-0.0074327216,
-0.0310578551,
0.0108116791,
0.0182275008,
0.0085331108,
-0.0178701095,
0.0088613341,
0.0250183269,
0.0636646524,
0.0099968426,
0.0011303365,
-0.0429263785,
0.014974921,
-0.0013938443,
0.0485567227,
0.0335901976,
-0.0049819914,
-0.0218180921,
0.0064955903,
-0.0047423779,
0.0245831385,
0.0232388917,
-0.0699374899,
-0.0844433457,
0.017687941,
0.0375370905,
-0.0163301863,
-0.0106630251,
-0.048755154,
-0.0627181679,
-0.0115394844,
-0.033250995,
0.0218104851,
-0.0331915542,
-0.0021260455,
0.045400735,
0.0104995584,
-0.0219589751,
0.0210456941,
0.0066723502,
-0.0290922504,
0.0524961315,
0.038602367,
0.0098673645,
-0.0313788205,
0.0203542821,
0.0322680101,
-0.0243787002,
0.004980104,
-0.003864944,
0.0130199259,
-0.0658618063,
0.0019329982,
-0.084710978,
0.0138000911,
-0.025986921,
-0.0069200131,
0.0158239715,
0.0146247754,
-0.0270810723,
-0.0225417092,
-0.0531386212,
-0.0156308506,
0.0314070471,
-0.0208204184,
0.0152031602,
0.0250616074,
-0.0233383831,
-0.0490161926,
0.0360217467,
0.0030342625,
0.0217482969,
-0.0289575811,
-0.0142655941,
-0.0613539964,
0.0281147938,
-0.0255384091,
0.0514551252,
-0.0261883382,
-0.0257083848,
0.0415871441,
0.0137759689,
0.0345921665,
0.0384272262,
0.0073127309,
0.0283589363,
-0.0021443903,
-0.0231193528,
-0.0720433444,
0.0510828309,
0.0021472932,
0.0094222883,
-0.0322176777,
0.0194644183,
0.0154735204,
0.0308228899,
0.0157815386,
0.0515022539,
-0.0578383617,
0.0401313603,
0.0444207974,
-0.0255586095,
-0.0115637491,
0.0006429877,
-0.0515672863,
0.0337172598,
0.004682946,
-0.0463124476,
0.056123063,
-0.0511097796,
-0.0545675382,
-0.0187563878,
-0.0163433757,
-0.007296755,
0.0505454689,
-0.0269745942,
-0.0008857049,
0.024342427,
-0.0299775563,
-0.0222759768,
-0.017987011,
0.0214422662,
-0.027156489,
0.0431950539,
-0.0433327481,
0.0181762837,
-0.0211617853,
-0.0468719117,
-0.0654590875,
-0.0336464457,
-0.0379208885,
-0.0077289147,
-0.0257616956,
-0.0235938691,
0.0041342592,
0.0112858061,
0.0104096653,
0.0805641711,
0.0089332443,
-0.0135973124,
-0.0351462513,
0.0473797284,
0.0768949836,
-0.0196218174,
-0.0284030288,
-0.0158467945,
0.1211402118,
0.044901371,
0.0712081268,
0.0209847409,
-0.0221202783,
-0.0144549534,
0.0054983459,
0.0085397502,
0.0057744132,
0.0199868493,
0.0758604631,
-0.0362499207,
-0.0137371132,
0.1222131401,
0.0107389176,
-0.0447521135,
-0.0158431046,
-0.0035892788,
0.028529048,
0.0311065428,
0.023375921,
-0.1115681902,
-0.0614732951,
0.0199745893,
0.0346853696,
-0.0095286286,
-0.0236270018,
-0.0299241096,
-0.1129920408,
0.0368312187,
0.0014427457,
-0.0609797016,
-0.0068466994,
-0.0117443539,
0.0120716998,
0.0225316174,
0.0192343649,
0.0227581263,
0.0034903642,
-0.0109351417,
0.0093122423,
-0.0010063002,
-0.0265146736,
0.0289419889,
-0.0139360176,
0.0986319631,
0.0656716675,
0.0319277272,
0.0359288901,
0.0188291911,
0.0318358652,
-0.0086713713,
0.0001002606,
0.0111871921,
0.0510621034,
-0.027430281,
-0.0246058423,
-0.0112652732,
0.0646453053,
-0.009796015,
-0.0179293621,
0.0070024324,
0.0119821168,
-0.0552622266,
0.0298060495,
-0.0177621506,
0.0161124635,
0.0257004667,
0.0461847112,
0.0512375757,
-0.0601671375,
-0.0038024699,
-0.0226383153,
-0.0167501811,
-0.0519759431,
0.0109380065,
-0.0194299053,
0.0125788562,
0.0161094181,
-0.0889931694,
-0.0470004529,
0.0550662614,
0.0716225728,
-0.0428395271,
-0.0131291216,
-0.0227409396,
0.0084315771,
0.018297324,
0.0244211368,
-0.0342582986,
0.0119591784,
-0.0610581934,
-0.0200967435,
0.0533685796,
-0.0018125051,
0.0017070597,
0.0441187993,
-0.065099895,
-0.0612293705,
-0.0262897499,
0.0674843565,
0.0230982862,
0.0783318728,
0.0150246378,
0.0055046119,
-0.003550255,
0.0500981137,
-0.0094228974,
-0.0171712693,
0.0554264709,
0.0654937252,
-0.0309350323,
0.025409285,
-0.0236894973,
0.0207630862,
-0.0199832115,
0.0319688842,
-0.0645079836,
-0.0501665734,
0.0144991893,
-0.0242774319,
0.0633556098,
-0.0075721284,
-0.0033847105,
-0.0122701516,
0.0388100892,
-0.0283045415,
-0.0163360015,
-0.0930742621,
0.0008112257,
-0.0238744915,
-0.0465164185,
0.0079494519,
-0.0212782696,
-0.0449207798,
0.0432889313,
-0.0197676122,
-0.0354983844,
0.0066088438,
0.017055396,
0.0102682114,
-0.0154324844,
-0.0191438179,
0.0567364953,
0.0189622864,
0.0333027877,
-0.0125084966,
0.1123753041,
0.0105923237,
-0.0219444726,
0.0170628,
0.0241665393,
-0.0649417192,
-0.0448701531,
-0.0412868075,
0.0550899059,
0.0457976684,
0.0111298105,
0.0497250073,
-0.0149021698,
0.0100060478,
-0.00594449,
0.0733963698,
-0.0072181458,
-0.0412448347,
0.0150333308,
0.0344875827,
-0.0097705703,
-0.0031671978,
0.073888123,
0.012429337,
0.0392317772,
0.0085089384,
0.045919124,
-0.0721336305,
-0.0186313242,
0.0195566379,
0.027693212,
0.0049892734,
0.0074509801,
-0.0483907834,
-0.0358954594,
0.005276368,
0.0025078431,
-0.0168521926,
-0.0172673762,
0.0586171672,
0.0174250528,
-0.0231986791,
0.0068050697,
-0.0235322788,
-0.0097274221,
0.0114702331,
-0.0330852009,
-0.0081297141,
-5.436774514e-33,
-0.048049584,
-0.034372028,
0.0389698781,
-0.0122001534,
-0.0263595767,
-0.0328243747,
-0.0535698533,
0.0139808245,
-0.0205611102,
-0.0150541123,
-0.019313354,
0.0186828636,
0.0168779753,
0.0379233398,
-0.0320516489,
-0.0187866706,
0.0459823683,
-0.0136571908,
-0.028404355,
0.0406293198,
0.0350488834,
0.0127257509,
0.0214524679,
-0.0366579667,
0.0012320668,
-0.0138629368,
-0.0174557362,
0.0262466129,
0.0114867836,
0.0340655223,
-0.0036556942,
0.011264435,
-0.0089174323,
-0.0419079773,
-0.0144421998,
0.0345747881,
-0.0097922478,
-0.0120465737,
0.0070087262,
0.0000489251,
-0.0051270323,
0.0046974118,
-0.0190304425,
-0.0327075087,
0.0219732989,
0.0061263251,
-0.0067375186,
-0.0172689632,
-0.0414825827,
-0.0333713628,
-0.0542993993,
0.0257069319,
-0.0238946751,
-0.0902017802,
-0.0118394522,
0.1117794812,
0.042893894,
-0.0208678748,
-0.0177580584,
0.0142591996,
-0.0262324978,
-0.0113023669,
0.0434082076,
0.033028435,
0.0181187112,
0.0904982761,
0.0586340278,
0.0128288288,
-0.0026946566,
-0.0293436684,
-0.0042269025,
0.0312534869,
0.0360099375,
0.0609609,
0.0154922232,
0.0099025927,
-0.0374012701,
0.0125914877,
0.0225603338,
0.0115070799,
-0.018609304,
0.0229859091,
-0.020470906,
0.0003503772,
-0.0197861902,
-0.0065787975,
-0.0041204076,
-0.0066858218,
0.0388524942,
0.0375425592,
-0.0179875232,
-0.0207283236,
0.0858232602,
-0.0107532991,
0.0128589673,
0.0161998123,
-0.0359236337,
0.024996208,
-0.0286010504,
0.0018764029,
-0.0338585675,
-0.0288792141,
0.0637874752,
0.0334812291,
0.0330886692,
0.0226053204,
0.0184934344,
0.0084942821,
-0.0611640662,
0.0096941618,
-0.0502671488,
0.0678892434,
-0.035777986,
0.0085655795,
0.0198412538,
-0.0219735224,
-0.0289256517,
0.0894920453,
-0.0227579214,
-0.0546509139,
-0.0181219541,
-0.0239822865,
-0.0104985964,
0.0121653192,
-0.0367876031,
-0.0021620237,
-0.0177749172,
-0.0348106287,
0.0333370678,
-0.0372521505,
0.0036408778,
-0.0075670276,
2.557e-7,
-0.0272685084,
0.0225730352,
0.0322389677,
0.0184945669,
0.0271595437,
0.0672443509,
-0.0243060924,
0.0233665127,
0.0295797382,
-0.0328156948,
0.0084558092,
0.0050450061,
0.0664941669,
0.0325137302,
-0.1242411882,
-0.023943197,
-0.0633067861,
-0.0144627169,
-0.0567605272,
0.0158530287,
0.0345884077,
0.0771894455,
0.0010146776,
0.0010748403,
0.0583572462,
-0.0153297456,
0.0559477471,
-0.0138907442,
-0.010904978,
0.0173578691,
0.0022135011,
-0.0090380479,
-0.0237447191,
-0.018860912,
-0.0112110004,
0.0204711314,
-0.0214161165,
0.0979879797,
-0.0003747965,
-0.0420801491,
-0.0132434191,
-0.005487245,
0.0056641311,
-0.0203714594,
0.0386682563,
-0.0546355434,
-0.0088036656,
-0.0543142706,
-0.0234601106,
-0.0275084488,
0.0164163038,
-0.0024961613,
-0.0063127289,
0.0154808117,
0.0132530518,
-0.0126339309,
-0.0020455047,
-0.0740373582,
-0.037193656,
-0.027284652,
-0.0421893783,
-0.0354176871,
-0.0300900321,
-0.0217814241,
0.0028710219,
-0.0098804701,
-0.0183137804,
2.109695298e-34,
0.0396840535,
-0.009916788,
0.0406630412,
0.0621868707,
0.0077068629,
-0.0037271217,
0.0090338951,
-0.004811265,
0.0592548661,
-0.0514863431,
-0.013316215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02262v1 | Data Quality Matters: Suicide Intention Detection on Social Media Posts Using a RoBERTa-CNN Model | 2024-02-03T20:58:09 | 2024-02-03T20:58:09 | Emily Lin, Jian Sun, Hsingyu Chen, Mohammad H. Mahoor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Suicide remains a global health concern for the field of health, which
urgently needs innovative approaches for early detection and intervention. In
this paper, we focus on identifying suicidal intentions in SuicideWatch Reddit
posts and present a novel approach to suicide detection using the cutting-edge
RoBERTa-CNN model, a variant of RoBERTa (Robustly optimized BERT approach).
RoBERTa is used for various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, including
text classification and sentiment analysis. The effectiveness of the RoBERTa
lies in its ability to capture textual information and form semantic
relationships within texts. By adding the Convolution Neural Network (CNN)
layer to the original model, the RoBERTa enhances its ability to capture
important patterns from heavy datasets. To evaluate the RoBERTa-CNN, we
experimented on the Suicide and Depression Detection dataset and obtained solid
results. For example, RoBERTa-CNN achieves 98% mean accuracy with the standard
deviation (STD) of 0.0009. It also reaches over 97.5% mean AUC value with an
STD of 0.0013. In the meanwhile, RoBERTa-CNN outperforms competitive methods,
demonstrating the robustness and ability to capture nuanced linguistic patterns
for suicidal intentions. Therefore, RoBERTa-CNN can detect suicide intention on
text data very well. | [
0.0779502839,
0.094859302,
-0.0018154825,
-0.0074847401,
-0.0083680199,
0.0270642657,
-0.0132580576,
-0.0068434142,
0.0175023787,
-0.0134023195,
-0.0036021161,
0.0316160619,
-0.0639525726,
-0.0001274028,
-0.0760323331,
-0.0192239713,
0.0061741495,
0.0427341275,
0.057627175,
0.0050948355,
0.0249504428,
0.0450014733,
-0.0114038121,
0.053421177,
-0.0115216216,
-0.0144736776,
0.0255270004,
0.0253401492,
0.0222364161,
-0.0483526103,
0.0410263948,
0.045498427,
-0.0286081657,
0.0261677448,
0.0000021197,
-0.0112898378,
-0.0125271864,
-0.0146694425,
-0.0268865824,
-0.0572213754,
0.0274011977,
-0.0734748617,
0.0101219742,
0.0015942159,
-0.0609116293,
-0.0338653252,
0.0204494316,
0.0578973033,
0.0359851867,
0.09289933,
-0.0244124141,
-0.0401821658,
0.0633997843,
-0.0072389101,
-0.0299426112,
0.0072166878,
0.033893466,
0.0023081503,
-0.007444168,
0.0022056545,
-0.0332405344,
0.0112678669,
0.0110598262,
0.01880778,
-0.0115368376,
-0.0167898927,
-0.0265178084,
-0.0610020906,
0.0211676639,
0.0500642508,
-0.039733544,
0.0040725139,
0.038076058,
-0.0181382205,
-0.0271591041,
-0.0371754654,
0.0115047153,
-0.0235210788,
-0.0264901929,
0.0314036123,
0.0235360283,
0.0318423733,
0.007328792,
0.0183844864,
0.0591109246,
-0.0198238716,
-0.0105866529,
0.0054052514,
0.0029611259,
0.0011914641,
-0.0473314263,
-0.0349954255,
0.0203827359,
0.0111228116,
-0.0550298281,
0.0127855428,
-0.0673603266,
-0.0741476715,
0.0215615798,
-0.0437780879,
0.066002503,
0.0381170548,
-0.0278927051,
-0.0058802492,
0.0078572268,
-0.0121182259,
0.0191233456,
-0.0177779812,
-0.0402371287,
0.0278221332,
-0.0619528927,
0.0297917072,
-0.0314907767,
0.0052810987,
0.0554628558,
-0.0209863577,
-0.0803884715,
0.0214340892,
-0.004055717,
-0.0021536511,
-0.0126314117,
-0.0030287646,
-0.0258499123,
0.0036371055,
0.0264662001,
0.0236298162,
-0.0432866365,
0.0130905937,
-0.0199701861,
-0.0321081616,
0.0355124436,
0.0186874792,
0.0334025025,
-0.0241213217,
0.0225776155,
0.05003893,
0.042790059,
-0.0250683054,
-0.047029499,
-0.0361595303,
-0.04832533,
-0.0418151133,
-0.0030621863,
-0.0142702097,
0.0022300514,
-0.0183356386,
-0.0194701385,
-0.0368348397,
0.0414049216,
-0.0287264138,
-0.0001258752,
0.0619135574,
-0.0276999567,
-0.0162558667,
0.0428663716,
-0.0003352299,
-0.0208219904,
0.0580983274,
-0.0071136206,
0.0759877041,
0.0241018552,
-0.0100956988,
0.0036491312,
-0.0162897222,
0.0185798667,
-0.0188010782,
-0.0303696692,
0.0022315446,
-0.0974856913,
0.0278956089,
-0.0041817185,
0.0010310245,
0.0084328903,
-0.0072161374,
0.0557360835,
0.0386027321,
-0.0061612828,
0.0538631156,
0.0252706893,
0.055129163,
-0.0334361009,
-0.0590042993,
-0.0356449522,
0.0134726549,
-0.0142211439,
-0.006402059,
0.0154088205,
-0.0131505048,
0.0016905661,
-0.0498870425,
-0.0266810339,
-0.0204642136,
-0.0175971501,
-0.0124380076,
0.0048295106,
-0.0037007558,
-0.0259695183,
-0.0117657231,
0.0167930406,
-0.0022814248,
-0.0326383077,
-0.0372015089,
0.0371296667,
0.028892735,
-0.001575331,
-0.0386486053,
-0.0375625826,
-0.0189367123,
0.0328008421,
-0.0002617059,
0.0115610743,
0.0343333669,
0.0234675538,
-0.034124352,
-0.0479874723,
0.0349167995,
-0.0066300351,
-0.0395064019,
0.0115877064,
0.0526351482,
-0.0227182768,
0.0035166852,
-0.0361232869,
0.0364172459,
0.0540168025,
-0.0274675824,
0.0149995536,
0.0376416557,
0.0332605466,
0.0051131751,
0.0006589238,
-0.0188481323,
0.0007770234,
-0.0209272653,
-0.0621994846,
-0.0379421934,
-0.0087513458,
-0.0455119535,
-0.0143850772,
-0.0706914142,
-0.0107057802,
0.0970408916,
-0.0383364297,
-0.0282892454,
0.0193256829,
-0.0522718392,
0.0043850569,
-0.02243766,
-0.05010847,
-0.025480682,
0.0136765931,
0.0260079224,
0.0697515979,
-0.0347560644,
0.0179358851,
-0.0143978205,
-0.0410542563,
-0.0027694202,
-0.0261040889,
-0.067796424,
-0.0672639757,
-0.0254999362,
0.0042068679,
0.0294670966,
0.0086250911,
-0.0095535908,
-0.0234040264,
-0.1011186242,
0.0349483043,
-0.0495766066,
-0.0031354213,
-0.0150004523,
-0.0012326605,
-0.0217548963,
-0.0299714282,
-0.0268058926,
0.0229899753,
-0.0191203952,
0.006118407,
0.0214742217,
-0.0240636505,
0.0148676075,
-0.026276866,
-0.0267581455,
0.0113878148,
-0.0018204446,
0.0071599009,
-0.0492984429,
-0.0092021665,
0.0055939681,
-0.026262302,
-0.0046134666,
-0.0001052804,
-0.0735381916,
-0.0107266949,
-0.0064980378,
0.0284488741,
0.0323648639,
0.0243967697,
0.0346074887,
0.0041899998,
0.0828562751,
-0.015001975,
0.034736257,
-0.0664469004,
0.0112239607,
-0.0473456606,
-0.0241504889,
-0.0133096464,
0.0304068662,
0.0136283888,
-0.0267427899,
-0.0264499318,
-0.0486063473,
-0.0363048725,
0.0011303052,
0.035610076,
-0.0116166715,
0.0298520718,
-0.0150603959,
0.0016232941,
-0.047310099,
0.0421707965,
0.0509827845,
0.0047659106,
-0.0087781325,
-0.0263384916,
-0.0351980887,
0.0319144465,
0.0312497206,
0.0129020866,
-0.0054006618,
0.0052863476,
0.0460375212,
-0.0182789378,
-0.0347124934,
-0.0154313194,
0.0088395877,
-0.0081816167,
0.0296881776,
0.0103033585,
-0.0290145092,
-0.0554945879,
-0.0365731157,
-0.0769212767,
-0.0417463556,
-0.0417135656,
-0.0047125868,
0.0038270915,
-0.0253853519,
-0.0280449502,
0.0299365036,
-0.0270905923,
-0.034038119,
-0.0136501519,
0.0052363486,
0.0806210786,
-0.0887776166,
0.0415054187,
0.005148923,
0.0497424714,
0.0509285294,
-0.0793065056,
0.1017545089,
-0.0492006205,
0.0193754937,
-0.0143373562,
0.016359916,
-0.002051373,
0.0005660256,
0.0336982571,
-0.0089903595,
-0.0007865367,
0.0747685954,
-0.0034131249,
-0.0574458055,
0.0122509627,
0.0254960638,
0.0137429191,
0.0048810225,
-0.0100578126,
-0.0064377575,
-0.0667390823,
-0.0251857005,
0.0379408821,
-0.0452875197,
-0.0276308935,
-0.0015125005,
-0.0264601205,
0.0624032244,
-0.0607962869,
-0.0003029945,
0.0434201658,
-0.02940212,
0.0284762084,
-0.0466483906,
0.014964004,
-0.0700362846,
-0.015539417,
0.0053966045,
-0.0138431061,
-0.093618378,
-0.0062156967,
-0.0055052098,
-0.0211781673,
0.0859188661,
-0.0069348575,
0.0611821301,
-0.0159580503,
-0.0310926232,
0.0255514756,
0.0363444239,
-0.0070948154,
-0.0084995907,
0.103969641,
0.0053994395,
-0.0367989875,
-0.078257814,
0.0706023872,
-0.0585801043,
-0.0286882482,
-0.0264211167,
0.0235963445,
-0.0365121439,
-0.0363476798,
-0.0543316379,
0.0506317541,
0.0217335019,
0.055592306,
0.0263098646,
-0.0675941706,
-0.0162924416,
0.0129425647,
-0.0211203527,
-0.069973357,
-0.0189113505,
-0.0005120466,
-0.0377206877,
-0.0555692799,
-0.0272406284,
-0.0275806636,
0.0027941132,
-0.0411051698,
-0.026333034,
-0.0181092788,
0.0314970538,
0.0189314,
-0.1029619426,
0.0431477241,
0.026171593,
0.0170407686,
-0.0259988941,
0.0304484926,
0.0313203335,
-0.0212738868,
-0.0154039171,
-0.0019424995,
-0.0692038834,
0.0190964639,
0.0468807146,
0.0282346383,
-0.0002956361,
-0.0173128806,
-0.017041456,
-0.0476937145,
0.0435486808,
-0.0136111872,
0.0177934524,
-0.0210571066,
0.0308631863,
0.0114274826,
0.0090248119,
0.0483125076,
0.0158975087,
0.0781968608,
0.0340570435,
-0.0118659753,
-0.0509621389,
0.0536646135,
-0.0145880487,
-0.0112683037,
0.0157971289,
0.0074541289,
-0.0223403294,
-0.0018972481,
-0.0188537091,
0.0455587246,
0.000746189,
-0.0285016149,
-0.0234142523,
0.076827012,
0.0220782869,
-0.0479179099,
-0.0225020554,
-0.0081204735,
-0.0418261625,
-0.0164462905,
0.0082269982,
0.0601116344,
0.065243654,
0.0361547805,
0.0186135639,
-0.0585238114,
0.0560239591,
-0.0081353262,
0.0077571021,
-0.0235385261,
0.03054858,
0.0117507726,
-0.0103383027,
0.0819478557,
0.0378682353,
-0.0609608516,
-0.0560090914,
-0.0354369506,
-0.0008564209,
0.0307890307,
-0.005410566,
0.040943794,
-0.0175420139,
0.0366780311,
-0.0005768082,
0.0581143945,
-0.0144052049,
-0.0247368049,
-0.0051513845,
-0.0084887892,
-0.0125541501,
-0.0201355014,
0.0060591688,
0.022502739,
0.0234009903,
0.0322377905,
-0.0043418594,
-0.0180836357,
0.0351604074,
0.0449869893,
0.0434159227,
-0.0213043764,
0.0179260373,
0.0179707799,
-0.0423374064,
0.0670741722,
-0.0373882614,
-0.0186309982,
-0.0047341608,
0.021650508,
0.0117130019,
0.0138570294,
-0.0271546301,
-0.0670143217,
0.0075987517,
-0.0214501154,
-0.0302487146,
-0.0299905036,
-5.653516203e-33,
0.0477351211,
0.0021111376,
-0.0505437516,
0.022920832,
0.0087026525,
0.044549305,
0.008668473,
-0.0006319063,
-0.0213997588,
0.0533475317,
0.0190240704,
0.0947350413,
-0.0006072463,
0.0534396581,
0.0217518955,
-0.0222012047,
-0.0025603347,
0.005316182,
0.0233753473,
0.0138541013,
-0.0041616582,
0.0755666792,
0.0759057552,
-0.036710646,
0.0199946724,
0.0176095925,
-0.013448487,
0.0218161661,
0.0588161126,
0.0427179411,
-0.0443983078,
0.0528924353,
0.0522618368,
0.0218165573,
-0.0150310909,
0.0327922143,
-0.0452746823,
-0.0446504951,
-0.0200479757,
0.029899789,
-0.064068377,
0.0049784202,
0.0287229437,
-0.0028024651,
-0.0183171034,
-0.0297634546,
0.0401391685,
0.0118591767,
0.026202051,
-0.0049202167,
-0.0195027944,
0.0050744815,
-0.0216888525,
-0.0135102319,
0.0219104551,
0.0054260031,
0.0117297657,
0.0150638195,
-0.0735131577,
-0.0116087357,
-0.0830911249,
-0.0008889844,
-0.0298975594,
-0.0466982499,
-0.0502351299,
0.0791664794,
0.0196342319,
-0.0169462617,
-0.0152550135,
-0.0024712342,
0.0210785419,
0.0836420357,
0.078801237,
0.0244164541,
0.048918359,
-0.0127692223,
-0.0598938651,
0.0199010689,
0.0466873273,
-0.0058051688,
0.0353659205,
-0.0193219408,
-0.0346951559,
0.0280907229,
0.0209290851,
-0.0507242903,
-0.0264771935,
0.0143756112,
-0.0068462985,
0.0094571402,
-0.0194681883,
-0.0033233229,
-0.0156151205,
-0.0527292714,
0.0167706795,
0.0260827411,
0.0210399814,
0.0305961389,
0.0191106331,
0.0107149091,
-0.0025448077,
0.0272872448,
0.0048124176,
-0.001140804,
0.0360432751,
-0.0045657111,
0.0685624033,
0.0071849236,
-0.0341235511,
-0.0249266494,
-0.0044298177,
0.026979249,
-0.0113843596,
0.0373775698,
-0.0160172917,
0.021113826,
-0.0004394089,
0.0520857386,
0.0355885737,
0.0774272084,
-0.0482360385,
-0.0223565027,
0.0062545463,
0.0044250046,
0.009269963,
-0.071373187,
-0.0245369151,
0.0622339062,
-0.0074844654,
-0.0807885453,
0.0089710793,
0.0036207521,
2.767e-7,
0.0663043335,
0.0367790349,
0.0047495756,
0.0194790997,
-0.0211039968,
0.0271275993,
0.0419703983,
0.0599693395,
0.0235994942,
0.0087937238,
0.0209171847,
0.0333311446,
0.0403323397,
0.0622326136,
-0.0642595962,
-0.0280044544,
-0.0176197849,
0.012681541,
-0.0625377372,
0.0149956122,
0.0973943099,
0.0787956938,
0.0518686175,
-0.0524516366,
0.0263375454,
-0.0079833791,
0.0216187667,
-0.0275375936,
0.0491846651,
0.030527316,
0.0271756966,
-0.0193029363,
0.0070016137,
-0.0371582955,
-0.0038793962,
-0.0509836078,
0.0064784642,
0.0762739629,
-0.035029985,
-0.0299796816,
0.0119139124,
0.0367709137,
0.026111979,
-0.0210946966,
0.0682694912,
-0.0343416557,
-0.0052500796,
-0.081670776,
-0.0157200806,
0.0027748528,
0.0670730844,
0.0023527401,
-0.0104598366,
0.0362735987,
0.0313559398,
-0.0050620935,
-0.0289303157,
-0.0819983855,
-0.0331452936,
-0.0025398668,
-0.0082001826,
0.0061321915,
-0.0645726398,
-0.0137784854,
0.0529825799,
-0.0445056036,
0.0078401091,
2.031019369e-34,
0.0152940946,
0.0288999807,
0.0287658963,
-0.0283661447,
-0.0245502889,
0.0344127901,
0.0086351493,
-0.0022338266,
-0.0186050944,
-0.0640186965,
0.005769066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02255v1 | Frequency Explains the Inverse Correlation of Large Language Models' Size, Training Data Amount, and Surprisal's Fit to Reading Times | 2024-02-03T20:22:54 | 2024-02-03T20:22:54 | Byung-Doh Oh, Shisen Yue, William Schuler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent studies have shown that as Transformer-based language models become
larger and are trained on very large amounts of data, the fit of their
surprisal estimates to naturalistic human reading times degrades. The current
work presents a series of analyses showing that word frequency is a key
explanatory factor underlying these two trends. First, residual errors from
four language model families on four corpora show that the inverse correlation
between model size and fit to reading times is the strongest on the subset of
least frequent words, which is driven by excessively accurate predictions of
larger model variants. Additionally, training dynamics reveal that during later
training steps, all model variants learn to predict rare words and that larger
model variants do so more accurately, which explains the detrimental effect of
both training data amount and model size on fit to reading times. Finally, a
feature attribution analysis demonstrates that larger model variants are able
to accurately predict rare words based on both an effectively longer context
window size as well as stronger local associations compared to smaller model
variants. Taken together, these results indicate that Transformer-based
language models' surprisal estimates diverge from human-like expectations due
to the superhumanly complex associations they learn for predicting rare words. | [
0.024342699,
0.0428008698,
-0.0224818252,
0.0223373417,
-0.0090850722,
0.0296109747,
0.0505052172,
-0.0016341656,
-0.064355731,
-0.0146280071,
-0.0414645448,
-0.0541573204,
0.0654623955,
0.016577892,
0.0174956657,
-0.0329977646,
0.0345299654,
-0.0311541576,
-0.0195315313,
-0.0163555983,
-0.0227506123,
-0.008493484,
0.0216468424,
0.0317101665,
0.0083421869,
-0.0026734779,
0.0225247424,
-0.0296353251,
0.0046280925,
0.0090197735,
0.0078563699,
0.0746814087,
0.0126826847,
0.0694400966,
0.0000016522,
-0.0576224849,
-0.0038830636,
0.0268502068,
-0.0138431815,
0.0314107426,
0.0627575964,
-0.043596372,
0.0012726841,
0.0288136192,
-0.0048504765,
-0.0248317998,
0.0472458526,
0.0248274896,
-0.0598849244,
0.0452841707,
-0.0127546201,
-0.0327372849,
0.0488268547,
-0.023305973,
0.0314627513,
-0.0321890339,
0.0088298786,
-0.0021845549,
-0.0181824509,
-0.0126401624,
-0.0727504194,
0.053951364,
0.0190082341,
0.0446076766,
0.0138577418,
0.051174745,
0.0093401708,
-0.0437653847,
-0.0019643004,
0.012124694,
-0.0001990553,
-0.0375504307,
-0.034063343,
0.0056792116,
-0.0210215431,
0.0695591196,
-0.0069882558,
0.0227566846,
0.0036505605,
0.0093535688,
0.0212807022,
0.0068313987,
0.0255672596,
-0.0096953111,
-0.0575502068,
0.0321528278,
0.0259134006,
-0.0461531878,
0.0169256926,
0.0208953358,
-0.0371253267,
0.0184666533,
-0.0081446562,
-0.022561444,
0.0246602036,
0.034404885,
-0.0394654907,
-0.0405778587,
0.0401446037,
-0.014679783,
0.032369338,
0.0444764048,
-0.0214840379,
-0.0005276956,
-0.0259655584,
0.0557830296,
-0.0059953532,
0.0135971298,
-0.0429126583,
-0.0297406334,
-0.0156878252,
-0.0087377736,
0.0031047736,
-0.0445198491,
-0.0433333926,
-0.0203544535,
-0.0781438947,
0.0028141693,
0.0583822317,
-0.0340279564,
0.0379930325,
0.011155556,
-0.0562023968,
-0.0015222665,
-0.0303659923,
0.0338066667,
0.0046419003,
0.0259597208,
-0.0463493429,
-0.0548669584,
0.0238728691,
0.0008124508,
0.0209608786,
-0.0615533926,
-0.0006445022,
0.0364907868,
-0.0373062119,
-0.0600782298,
-0.0311833192,
0.0243559554,
-0.0467456728,
-0.053853862,
-0.013383423,
-0.0595637895,
-0.0064450945,
0.0642644763,
0.0002562114,
-0.0282648206,
-0.0340754278,
0.0101799928,
-0.0479529351,
0.0379515961,
0.0020648183,
0.0582088344,
0.0321799032,
-0.0034853867,
0.0081635993,
0.0663043335,
0.04523338,
-0.0177333187,
-0.0043457607,
-0.034248136,
-0.0251802467,
0.038172096,
-0.0083370004,
0.0225456413,
-0.0114511084,
-0.0239191186,
0.0052656471,
-0.0185186099,
0.0724661276,
0.0391881913,
-0.0088528916,
-0.0576175787,
0.0830872357,
0.0653066337,
0.0429311357,
0.0536325723,
0.0195141081,
0.0056909737,
0.0047617122,
0.0059331981,
-0.0445868373,
-0.0040112794,
-0.0157951731,
0.0195342004,
-0.0227833316,
0.0481756404,
-0.0050216578,
-0.0285162833,
-0.0067632357,
-0.0001206978,
0.0365609601,
-0.0026309742,
0.0645068139,
-0.0153904939,
-0.026450295,
0.082648173,
0.0467696264,
-0.0094146663,
-0.0367756225,
-0.017618278,
-0.0082159592,
0.0332122706,
-0.0080953967,
0.0093715601,
0.0185962319,
0.0166137423,
-0.0089360261,
0.041904211,
0.0231281798,
0.0230776295,
0.0175458547,
-0.0204659868,
0.0083153415,
0.0370572098,
0.0173296705,
0.0116451448,
0.0265872777,
0.0401399843,
0.0177723207,
-0.0603779443,
-0.0637758821,
0.0330108553,
-0.1207607016,
-0.0243607406,
-0.0399742573,
0.0126713524,
-0.0034210179,
-0.0370759331,
-0.004170916,
0.0037821014,
-0.0023283912,
-0.0004458441,
0.0344662443,
0.0248813927,
-0.0606174916,
0.0162972715,
0.0193443093,
-0.0179274622,
0.0306745451,
0.0501047149,
0.0359097905,
-0.0158922095,
-0.014481266,
-0.051759176,
0.0737741366,
-0.0193712804,
0.0373628847,
-0.0738978833,
0.0431621782,
-0.031856887,
0.0253116824,
-0.0300341584,
0.0218952168,
-0.0180284288,
-0.022728866,
0.0049697193,
0.0028110235,
-0.0453121401,
0.0055627329,
-0.0207724962,
-0.006867697,
0.0201731287,
-0.034709692,
-0.0229990128,
-0.0380554385,
-0.0797855631,
-0.0335255228,
-0.0136448424,
-0.0114652785,
-0.0002804373,
-0.005824442,
-0.0214854572,
0.0222627167,
-0.0051330868,
-0.0085186549,
-0.0071497587,
0.05260811,
0.0022345034,
-0.0024002327,
-0.0451033004,
-0.0504020415,
-0.0313008577,
-0.0315604173,
0.0702567697,
0.0153155401,
-0.0141573222,
-0.0635984167,
0.0676593557,
0.0014206157,
0.0094552357,
-0.0228096601,
-0.0480390377,
0.0190659724,
0.0322976299,
0.0589290075,
0.0480822623,
0.0291537903,
0.0278066713,
0.0622798838,
0.0182378329,
-0.037118163,
-0.0255448855,
-0.0505156256,
-0.048291944,
-0.0701445416,
-0.0758210644,
-0.0355713703,
0.0930860937,
0.0082789892,
-0.0040950333,
-0.0445274673,
0.0193062276,
-0.0165624302,
-0.0322295986,
0.0108695691,
0.0157987662,
-0.0250587389,
0.0602571368,
-0.0153663587,
-0.0811619759,
0.0355080515,
-0.0118974671,
0.006172556,
-0.0446318015,
-0.0088671232,
-0.0240164548,
0.0415593237,
0.0176908579,
0.022183612,
-0.0036335699,
-0.0242671259,
-0.0702065453,
-0.0086453985,
0.0444547199,
-0.0141711356,
0.0990353599,
-0.0032756494,
-0.0003267964,
0.0043630535,
-0.0312698558,
-0.03402647,
-0.0444461927,
-0.0273370184,
-0.0227966085,
0.0296742171,
-0.0525495969,
-0.0720747113,
-0.0224702898,
0.0174045134,
0.0389327072,
-0.011974345,
-0.0349530578,
0.0156360827,
0.0144548388,
0.047965087,
0.0065788613,
0.0398685709,
-0.0688729659,
0.0180806313,
0.0141707538,
0.0008131684,
0.0289605185,
-0.0330832936,
-0.0271126069,
0.0133464485,
-0.0141676478,
-0.0082366895,
0.0186192784,
0.0605303124,
-0.027840713,
0.0011084608,
0.1075013727,
0.0107207671,
-0.0284285601,
0.0337377749,
-0.0255744029,
0.0844679996,
0.0052593877,
0.0121458881,
-0.0257063787,
0.0055319662,
-0.0127692912,
0.0284626205,
-0.0031206077,
-0.0242798049,
-0.0240865834,
-0.080323264,
-0.0165261477,
0.0112480586,
-0.0458012708,
0.0011545812,
-0.0229142755,
-0.0098134866,
-0.0409071483,
0.0514228456,
0.0128752487,
-0.0449162275,
-0.0066624931,
0.0389736332,
-0.0104641607,
-0.0384417363,
0.0396901444,
-0.0223175604,
0.0171124861,
0.0105385222,
0.0244492404,
-0.0453768075,
-0.0352733694,
0.004907418,
0.0232762657,
0.0320833139,
0.0225140043,
0.0665225908,
0.0230864007,
0.013658341,
-0.0168163087,
0.003379016,
-0.014904811,
-0.0052293213,
-0.0358478948,
0.0498973988,
0.0328263678,
-0.0518087111,
-0.024559522,
-0.0186241232,
-0.0238056444,
0.0643739477,
0.0158113949,
-0.0471492894,
-0.0310148168,
0.0325221419,
-0.007676329,
0.0190813448,
-0.0584043823,
0.0563941039,
0.0075553004,
-0.0717549622,
-0.0474998057,
-0.0319608673,
-0.0063638641,
0.0276474077,
0.027264053,
0.0301154424,
0.0069469945,
-0.0188597012,
-0.0520485826,
0.0566593446,
0.028274348,
-0.0062059262,
-0.0795231909,
-0.0137648908,
0.0158565585,
-0.0266527031,
-0.0326283351,
-0.0367554426,
-0.1144165248,
-0.0428929031,
0.0531734824,
-0.007924634,
0.0348192193,
0.0438636355,
0.0450707376,
-0.0532850325,
0.0688764602,
0.0334733501,
-0.0385281518,
0.0443490222,
0.0064470009,
-0.042532824,
0.0024851724,
0.0120273363,
-0.0073708333,
0.027393166,
0.0507850237,
-0.0047749132,
0.0034295465,
-0.0090286154,
-0.0107411928,
-0.0048058606,
0.0407907814,
-0.0326743051,
-0.0095845954,
-0.0242685117,
-0.0112482179,
0.0036043292,
0.0539758094,
-0.0059658629,
-0.0277674794,
0.0528982282,
0.0224887393,
-0.0335078202,
-0.0112112407,
-0.0005583676,
-0.0034483315,
-0.0489167683,
0.0423303284,
-0.0134695722,
-0.0093508596,
0.0504163057,
0.0488161817,
-0.009132918,
0.0090113468,
-0.0321693942,
0.051962819,
0.0349811278,
0.0415570214,
-0.0188214686,
0.0071540778,
-0.0395924598,
-0.0138933109,
-0.0700195953,
-0.026819393,
-0.020999711,
-0.0293263402,
-0.0024088044,
-0.0637931079,
0.0495918728,
-0.0370493233,
0.0219640974,
-0.0427637734,
0.0059264982,
-0.0225878153,
0.0267013926,
0.0095023001,
-0.0021238038,
-0.0167705361,
0.0199300032,
0.0955065563,
0.0618427843,
0.0067105652,
0.0108209671,
-0.0399738587,
-0.0141729806,
-0.0088291019,
0.0299134087,
-0.0256511662,
-0.0401365757,
-0.0119492672,
-0.0805461109,
-0.0656762272,
0.0273833536,
-0.0349534936,
0.0219609067,
-0.0149079598,
-0.0124230217,
0.0619059242,
-0.035925135,
-0.0200372115,
-0.0425606109,
0.0079483911,
0.00134672,
-0.0080217887,
0.0157804545,
-5.821311409e-33,
0.0062171505,
-0.0192788951,
0.0130418697,
-0.0028409157,
0.0149497045,
0.0128213372,
-0.0109164054,
0.0263021868,
-0.0365685336,
0.0277791582,
-0.0152749559,
0.0124948751,
0.0182200857,
0.0107408408,
0.0094284425,
0.0124717588,
0.0391657054,
0.0223035198,
-0.0035833393,
-0.0243232325,
0.0434995145,
0.0474985577,
0.0649366528,
-0.0683624521,
-0.0013918922,
0.0201521851,
0.0267325491,
-0.0204171389,
0.039462924,
0.0625760108,
-0.0338587053,
0.0817049071,
0.0226003788,
-0.0551261976,
-0.0167056546,
0.0253365375,
-0.0640299469,
-0.012953653,
0.0394861959,
0.02230452,
0.0294279568,
0.0089904722,
0.0586774461,
-0.0196290649,
-0.0387059115,
-0.0592055023,
0.0525475182,
-0.0358593725,
-0.0562850162,
-0.0237684436,
-0.0762798786,
0.0354058184,
0.0231092777,
0.0193542577,
0.021082826,
0.0543116741,
0.0096822893,
0.0284193717,
-0.039863538,
-0.0020904595,
0.0659869388,
0.0524750091,
0.0360863432,
0.0363031663,
0.0111516332,
0.0561782829,
0.0640785694,
0.0347062498,
0.0064654485,
-0.0119465701,
0.0939950645,
0.0228747744,
0.0188529063,
0.0586082488,
0.0815162584,
-0.0481765196,
-0.0229193792,
0.0179446414,
-0.0111665567,
0.0108393431,
0.0675380901,
-0.0096579744,
-0.0740645826,
-0.0333149619,
-0.0467601977,
0.0231181867,
-0.0286576152,
-0.0383816399,
0.0236561485,
-0.0051503354,
0.0083693825,
-0.0112448521,
0.0312682427,
-0.0491053574,
-0.0356033966,
0.0169945527,
-0.0149155436,
0.0317536369,
-0.0318392478,
0.0146390721,
-0.0367853381,
-0.0239994582,
-0.0192968938,
0.0439046882,
0.0134175392,
0.0051306929,
0.0317899846,
0.0160070993,
-0.0896833763,
-0.0089149475,
-0.0190162305,
-0.0504483022,
0.0302666146,
0.0090395417,
0.0422331244,
-0.0089224074,
-0.0167336222,
0.0132049797,
0.0282023642,
0.0012188777,
-0.0453554578,
0.0103925774,
-0.0035004348,
0.0285346974,
-0.0177486669,
-0.0434164628,
-0.016662119,
0.0166016929,
0.0767925978,
-0.0341805257,
-0.0077434094,
0.0099099753,
2.438e-7,
0.0393220596,
0.0724240765,
-0.0334018618,
-0.0438591838,
0.015202838,
0.0061149066,
0.0309981797,
0.019504128,
-0.0037209927,
-0.0088322703,
0.0118063195,
0.0140447682,
0.0543971732,
0.0220783986,
-0.0440428257,
-0.0617800355,
-0.0798159912,
0.0571623556,
-0.0413731001,
0.0356894881,
-0.011523691,
0.0812405199,
-0.0079530859,
-0.0511596985,
-0.0026167133,
-0.0172989517,
0.0464223363,
-0.0588088669,
0.0052459785,
0.0150792385,
0.0075500524,
0.0112627763,
0.051408004,
0.0149472514,
-0.0180235188,
0.041096095,
-0.0229351111,
0.0305757988,
-0.014088084,
0.0031782617,
0.0213802028,
0.0136661492,
-0.0334081054,
-0.0894040987,
0.0342207812,
-0.043620687,
-0.0403670296,
0.0006599058,
-0.0076407753,
0.0213381872,
0.0153263835,
-0.0077652666,
0.0172643252,
0.0168800205,
0.0294684768,
-0.0406524725,
-0.0082602482,
-0.0487041622,
-0.0375197977,
0.0341152176,
-0.0411169343,
-0.0616518334,
-0.0558299832,
-0.0362743475,
0.038696833,
-0.0126673263,
0.0218055174,
2.15803888e-34,
0.0194257349,
0.0059614307,
0.0243585557,
0.0071474779,
0.0204274859,
-0.0212085228,
0.0740711242,
0.0166534409,
0.0171163436,
-0.1021599397,
-0.0165409762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02244v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02244v3 | Beyond the Limits: A Survey of Techniques to Extend the Context Length in Large Language Models | 2024-02-03T19:20:02 | 2024-05-29T13:38:25 | Xindi Wang, Mahsa Salmani, Parsa Omidi, Xiangyu Ren, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Armaghan Eshaghi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities
including understanding context, engaging in logical reasoning, and generating
responses. However, this is achieved at the expense of stringent computational
and memory requirements, hindering their ability to effectively support long
input sequences. This survey provides an inclusive review of the recent
techniques and methods devised to extend the sequence length in LLMs, thereby
enhancing their capacity for long-context understanding. In particular, we
review and categorize a wide range of techniques including architectural
modifications, such as modified positional encoding and altered attention
mechanisms, which are designed to enhance the processing of longer sequences
while avoiding a proportional increase in computational requirements. The
diverse methodologies investigated in this study can be leveraged across
different phases of LLMs, i.e., training, fine-tuning and inference. This
enables LLMs to efficiently process extended sequences. The limitations of the
current methodologies is discussed in the last section along with the
suggestions for future research directions, underscoring the importance of
sequence length in the continued advancement of LLMs. | [
0.0449519381,
0.0602720343,
-0.0276284963,
0.044892408,
-0.0583317429,
0.0043807221,
0.0201016981,
-0.0313725173,
-0.0296085794,
-0.0394460373,
-0.0063617406,
-0.0746207014,
0.0153400628,
0.026925968,
0.0391459279,
-0.0531158224,
0.0430706218,
-0.0419563875,
-0.0023858726,
0.0033479074,
-0.0123914992,
-0.01060698,
0.0307956822,
0.0185594335,
0.0203797352,
-0.0173413325,
-0.067494154,
-0.0213225447,
0.0097377729,
-0.0545691922,
-0.0228735916,
0.0426007919,
0.0457656756,
0.0548930541,
0.0000019894,
-0.0316923968,
0.0050633713,
-0.0061941938,
-0.0224212632,
0.0337748267,
0.0002351845,
-0.0148616936,
-0.0016700187,
-0.0104538659,
-0.0330082476,
0.0154286306,
0.0613205135,
0.0026623488,
-0.0018511044,
0.0762548894,
-0.0021143944,
-0.060017813,
0.0111522144,
-0.0632762983,
0.0207490753,
-0.0517749898,
0.0356465466,
-0.0112941451,
0.0857117698,
0.0344970636,
-0.0535736531,
0.0202251505,
0.0603859387,
0.0206260234,
-0.0172684938,
0.0448726714,
0.0110425865,
-0.0210196972,
-0.0052847709,
0.0396704897,
-0.0449029766,
-0.0377748013,
-0.022802107,
-0.0001961779,
0.0076319682,
-0.058527533,
-0.040163938,
0.020974094,
0.0123622473,
0.0166469682,
0.0372163728,
0.0018895395,
0.0305639114,
0.0055852081,
-0.0829285011,
0.038524434,
0.0242009219,
-0.040073406,
-0.045669008,
-0.0257920939,
-0.0140661756,
-0.0572384223,
0.0069743609,
0.074548617,
-0.0270284731,
0.0465926789,
-0.0339010656,
-0.0178733729,
0.0300269425,
-0.0403091945,
0.0305923652,
0.058159288,
-0.0128260935,
0.038493678,
-0.049664557,
0.041768834,
-0.0444572754,
-0.011059368,
-0.0522561595,
0.0252441429,
-0.0054817297,
0.0102254311,
-0.0372067317,
-0.0087533286,
-0.0692451224,
-0.0428844653,
-0.0338003226,
0.0689500719,
0.039309036,
-0.0060518156,
-0.015739629,
0.0141272293,
-0.0155297592,
-0.0164726786,
0.0051062531,
0.0302757397,
-0.0456267782,
-0.0000292163,
0.0175203029,
-0.036955256,
-0.0158352889,
0.0239962582,
0.0163605791,
-0.0456436798,
-0.0087698661,
0.0723930448,
0.0242677443,
-0.0638688505,
-0.0210106224,
0.0065711751,
-0.0545998998,
-0.0719981566,
0.0275167543,
-0.0542379767,
0.0051680328,
-0.0069394144,
-0.0281905215,
-0.0091809556,
0.0280735996,
0.0069124419,
-0.0169730224,
0.0723219439,
0.0027388292,
-0.0072073592,
-0.0134307351,
0.013673503,
0.0344140045,
0.066337131,
0.0262454506,
0.0131726852,
0.0101657845,
-0.0197327808,
-0.0321368501,
0.0257186163,
0.0160507485,
-0.0147956247,
-0.0300002974,
0.0201102793,
0.0193515737,
0.0328359753,
0.0175789464,
0.0292479843,
-0.0092271809,
-0.0476669371,
0.0367443711,
0.0457141511,
0.0346711092,
0.011886959,
0.0743684173,
-0.0431213006,
-0.0225750916,
0.0320463181,
-0.0527085774,
0.0397814475,
-0.0018909435,
0.0525870472,
0.0270418506,
0.0454830378,
-0.0235795006,
-0.0305715278,
-0.0345280878,
-0.0029822993,
0.0309440438,
0.038138181,
0.036070209,
-0.0175788775,
-0.0448547043,
0.0296829697,
0.0199597962,
-0.0251049716,
-0.016488554,
-0.0404917523,
0.0361746438,
0.0698989555,
-0.0027181276,
-0.0415553935,
-0.0340854339,
0.016722573,
0.0048860335,
0.0666837096,
0.0069373855,
0.0220918395,
-0.0106300004,
-0.0345286131,
-0.0132511426,
0.002879692,
-0.0048991032,
0.0512947626,
0.0430565514,
0.0044654789,
0.033365909,
-0.0028791914,
0.0209196415,
0.0275643785,
-0.0465174727,
-0.0398441851,
-0.0382631905,
0.0191297699,
0.0515833721,
0.0070053814,
0.018367853,
0.0365116447,
0.0526586697,
-0.0433222391,
0.016891079,
-0.0138676334,
-0.1105239466,
-0.049743589,
0.0500368662,
0.0316659175,
0.0049000154,
-0.0134567609,
-0.022880068,
-0.0362418741,
0.0273546558,
-0.0642792657,
0.0674418882,
-0.0336948,
0.0276186503,
0.0202539843,
0.0543731377,
-0.0562934019,
0.0642562509,
-0.0303983185,
0.0068116789,
0.04937068,
0.0280636121,
-0.0180016998,
-0.0452231318,
-0.0053812461,
0.0400332399,
0.0016291295,
-0.014738244,
-0.0118959313,
-0.0219992008,
-0.0419418328,
-0.0289185885,
-0.071825847,
-0.0079075331,
-0.0208127927,
0.0321044736,
-0.0052719419,
0.0144791948,
-0.0033592891,
0.0077437432,
-0.0442869477,
0.0029476222,
0.0114568025,
0.0302227009,
0.0049895709,
0.0213675648,
-0.0733884498,
-0.0321977064,
-0.0383297578,
0.0006380327,
0.0629114136,
-0.0407520235,
-0.0406118222,
-0.0709444582,
0.0039473344,
-0.0212554391,
0.0258510057,
-0.0357375704,
-0.0178842228,
0.0038312923,
-0.0380439274,
0.0588099696,
0.0679294467,
0.0160400886,
0.0329167508,
0.0589439571,
-0.0207378082,
0.0013710005,
0.0233462863,
-0.0367544256,
-0.0089870431,
-0.0405707844,
0.0041775298,
-0.0343376957,
0.0686917678,
-0.0482323505,
-0.0113609526,
-0.0582100898,
0.0006476046,
0.0203482863,
-0.0451375544,
0.0067537525,
-0.0321750939,
-0.0520281605,
0.0465840474,
-0.0416794345,
-0.0357008614,
0.0586108416,
-0.0520030521,
-0.0006069918,
-0.0424996167,
-0.0033695276,
-0.0455529653,
0.0890102014,
0.0299157482,
0.0252527464,
-0.0079110228,
-0.0046833856,
-0.0286696553,
0.0123256361,
-0.0509229228,
-0.0152967907,
0.0492334329,
-0.0297332667,
-0.0026544563,
-0.0113906339,
-0.0042653354,
-0.0461502559,
0.0119029563,
-0.0159758478,
0.023990009,
0.0094781797,
-0.0068710204,
-0.0172927491,
0.053406965,
0.0101662725,
0.0456691235,
-0.0054535996,
0.0504205897,
-0.0362329707,
0.0251807887,
0.0367105566,
0.0217865501,
0.0203298368,
-0.0220173802,
0.019471623,
0.047890503,
0.0255156271,
-0.0181845129,
-0.0246239342,
0.0063964319,
0.0128145581,
-0.0420971699,
-0.02008426,
0.0478487462,
0.0393227302,
-0.1017553732,
-0.0296762306,
0.1104958057,
0.0220983494,
-0.0256731063,
0.0341942981,
-0.0185637809,
0.0402269363,
0.0174021665,
0.0081903394,
-0.0594624504,
-0.0297346693,
0.0280714557,
-0.0348531529,
-0.0190512445,
-0.0002180118,
-0.0162801892,
-0.1270027757,
0.0058582053,
0.0291690324,
-0.0783408657,
-0.0545319133,
-0.0310033392,
0.0035802033,
0.0734529421,
0.0314838327,
0.0660119429,
-0.0110092135,
-0.0160784237,
0.0051833517,
0.0050564017,
-0.0400627777,
0.0266137794,
-0.00794244,
0.0454802476,
0.0484318174,
0.006953984,
0.0324529223,
-0.0316842012,
0.0276838038,
-0.0212149713,
0.0609347485,
-0.0000880331,
0.0071165157,
-0.0172299817,
-0.0117392428,
0.0003929638,
0.0241683628,
-0.0155583341,
-0.0371600129,
-0.0034157305,
0.0890436843,
-0.0138189094,
-0.0150145972,
-0.0211860612,
0.0124505945,
-0.0167588461,
0.059951786,
0.0797352642,
-0.0462178849,
-0.040964298,
-0.0049039237,
-0.0447361022,
-0.0409635305,
0.0158136785,
0.0001484139,
0.0023473545,
-0.030716572,
-0.0326220803,
-0.0525442921,
0.0185478926,
0.0393067524,
0.004522969,
0.0187123753,
0.0062174671,
-0.0273473766,
-0.0662052631,
0.0142701687,
-0.0253796447,
0.0312558301,
-0.0365418196,
0.0210818667,
-0.0183860753,
-0.0266320184,
0.0040073819,
0.0438744761,
-0.0776947513,
-0.0871362016,
0.0040033455,
0.0396268293,
0.0195207056,
0.054990299,
0.0166578088,
-0.0220546033,
0.0332187526,
0.0006942161,
0.005411949,
0.0332332328,
0.0296981987,
0.0186669864,
0.0061089569,
0.0278583542,
-0.0125704752,
0.0220303275,
0.031979356,
0.0661680996,
-0.0326810554,
-0.030429909,
0.0054389066,
-0.0206093062,
0.014932937,
0.0068191946,
0.0077053141,
0.0131065669,
0.0680881366,
-0.0552386008,
0.0100342501,
-0.0081976792,
-0.0151748769,
0.0112692332,
0.0001914805,
0.0154311489,
-0.0419223495,
0.0025953557,
-0.0146229388,
-0.0117393453,
0.0852139145,
-0.0010535092,
0.0012726474,
0.0355419144,
0.0120346835,
-0.032652121,
0.0063550556,
-0.0244086143,
0.0477234051,
-0.0306238867,
0.0542335324,
0.025140943,
0.0012092753,
-0.0453134887,
0.0257912595,
-0.0852765366,
0.0109576806,
-0.0032075595,
0.0284283217,
0.0612753965,
-0.0146843567,
0.0090465108,
-0.0044783205,
-0.022322122,
-0.0141303334,
0.0280058421,
0.0001789618,
-0.0620735176,
0.0052195257,
0.0470134839,
-0.0191790797,
-0.0160601493,
0.0420587212,
0.0182534344,
0.0295994263,
0.0165665913,
0.000854533,
-0.0197441876,
-0.0453933552,
-0.0061462955,
0.0222437941,
-0.0407512262,
0.00502371,
-0.0441673212,
-0.0937517807,
0.0046898718,
0.0086320154,
0.0056123612,
-0.014839204,
0.010235508,
0.0354716852,
0.0008944217,
-0.0111014266,
0.0064656683,
0.0254495088,
-0.0036786215,
-0.0255537257,
-0.0146876201,
-5.954555898e-33,
-0.022425741,
-0.018969629,
0.0407734253,
-0.0493808948,
-0.0720609576,
0.0070581641,
-0.0625101849,
0.002846332,
0.0182879642,
-0.0218397807,
-0.0163883679,
-0.0230404064,
-0.001141258,
0.0323170237,
-0.0062788161,
-0.0125132175,
0.0177449808,
0.0358058773,
0.0239050929,
0.0143961683,
0.0145191038,
0.0265593044,
0.033017192,
0.0018503675,
0.0086049568,
0.020584764,
0.0292134341,
0.0150596472,
-0.0456383713,
0.0736140087,
-0.0227477178,
0.0104923025,
0.0393340997,
-0.0455797352,
-0.027244959,
0.0418023169,
-0.0704320148,
0.0178250186,
0.0375658795,
-0.0056637153,
-0.0176915936,
-0.0639691576,
0.0449906103,
0.0086168423,
0.0238987375,
-0.0161513332,
0.0022904861,
-0.0601947792,
-0.0502443835,
0.0032940756,
-0.0762517825,
0.0252632089,
0.0207595993,
0.0122788902,
0.022754591,
0.0097543523,
-0.0127355158,
0.0199799296,
-0.0109977378,
-0.0117493048,
0.0363160335,
0.0761826113,
0.0458469316,
0.0636088625,
0.0298810862,
0.0085105607,
0.0101121264,
-0.0314204842,
-0.0515939444,
-0.0216065515,
0.0136522679,
0.0154752489,
0.0373979062,
0.0025901347,
0.0441550314,
-0.0015609373,
-0.0571840927,
-0.0471984558,
0.0060048085,
0.0540247485,
0.0469139069,
0.0328427032,
-0.0190998446,
-0.0012254074,
-0.0202679094,
0.0068717715,
-0.0406578369,
-0.0160782635,
0.048894383,
0.0178935044,
-0.0022148716,
0.0102072563,
0.05901739,
-0.0163421761,
-0.0012650402,
0.0327589922,
0.0240540579,
0.0035948646,
0.0026722625,
0.0385237075,
-0.0352954343,
-0.0336515494,
0.0357952043,
-0.0129281916,
-0.0211343467,
-0.0336477496,
0.0358859152,
0.0143590206,
-0.0517215505,
-0.0080661038,
-0.0618472286,
0.0011389481,
0.0022931786,
0.0484231636,
0.0654788464,
0.0024257582,
0.0012316369,
0.0514221303,
0.0127569837,
-0.0305925813,
-0.0145608224,
-0.0118916845,
-0.0009423878,
0.0323851705,
-0.0427426547,
0.0118892826,
-0.0309166871,
0.0353169627,
0.0312335342,
-0.0499921404,
-0.015530033,
0.0422073267,
2.676e-7,
0.0387672558,
0.0405566618,
0.0643626824,
0.0176318474,
0.0352463126,
-0.009102433,
0.0162431579,
0.0203516763,
0.014931527,
-0.0165395532,
0.0099906353,
0.0360764079,
0.0259467363,
-0.0164155476,
-0.0730065331,
-0.0152494749,
-0.0470063239,
0.024299141,
-0.0612499267,
0.0149998451,
0.0586097166,
0.1354162097,
-0.0105872583,
-0.0062524551,
0.0188890714,
-0.0369971767,
0.028808739,
-0.0219673496,
0.0181028023,
-0.0153384684,
-0.0298189241,
-0.0135055277,
-0.0027052045,
-0.0053664856,
0.0139089944,
0.0236183908,
-0.0408152565,
0.0571885556,
-0.0159986727,
-0.0315741524,
0.0113945222,
-0.0044784211,
-0.032734964,
-0.0627859831,
0.0605473854,
-0.0680021271,
-0.0308202468,
-0.0234103203,
-0.0139273647,
-0.0153576927,
-0.0392990299,
0.0037153244,
0.0089096781,
0.0175198335,
0.0153861651,
-0.0196451899,
0.0096431086,
-0.1252269745,
-0.0340384245,
0.0097980825,
-0.0587026663,
0.0001859403,
-0.0810723454,
-0.0043830015,
0.0534051433,
-0.04323202,
-0.0307243131,
2.889388762e-34,
0.0271295719,
-0.0327518508,
0.0100139277,
0.0151557354,
0.0193621032,
-0.0344709158,
-0.0237777364,
0.0240710154,
0.0519237146,
-0.1186249107,
-0.0544312485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02243v1 | Language Writ Large: LLMs, ChatGPT, Grounding, Meaning and Understanding | 2024-02-03T19:19:34 | 2024-02-03T19:19:34 | Stevan Harnad | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Apart from what (little) OpenAI may be concealing from us, we all know
(roughly) how ChatGPT works (its huge text database, its statistics, its vector
representations, and their huge number of parameters, its next-word training,
and so on). But none of us can say (hand on heart) that we are not surprised by
what ChatGPT has proved to be able to do with these resources. This has even
driven some of us to conclude that ChatGPT actually understands. It is not true
that it understands. But it is also not true that we understand how it can do
what it can do. I will suggest some hunches about benign biases: convergent
constraints that emerge at LLM scale that may be helping ChatGPT do so much
better than we would have expected. These biases are inherent in the nature of
language itself, at LLM scale, and they are closely linked to what it is that
ChatGPT lacks, which is direct sensorimotor grounding to connect its words to
their referents and its propositions to their meanings. These convergent biases
are related to (1) the parasitism of indirect verbal grounding on direct
sensorimotor grounding, (2) the circularity of verbal definition, (3) the
mirroring of language production and comprehension, (4) iconicity in
propositions at LLM scale, (5) computational counterparts of human categorical
perception in category learning by neural nets, and perhaps also (6) a
conjecture by Chomsky about the laws of thought. The exposition will be in the
form of a dialogue with ChatGPT-4. | [
0.0090748006,
0.0147674568,
-0.0310745239,
0.0466051102,
-0.0520087294,
0.0309672989,
-0.04826805,
0.0295764152,
0.0135045508,
-0.0476671197,
-0.0714194477,
-0.0171866696,
0.0152182188,
0.0041268035,
0.0211263243,
-0.0165806524,
0.0460330546,
-0.0038535297,
-0.0260946583,
-0.015081021,
-0.0299764704,
-0.0287339613,
-0.0179367159,
0.038856864,
-0.0195951946,
-0.0229100063,
-0.0285282899,
-0.0328249745,
-0.0441875421,
-0.0035538161,
-0.0491817519,
-0.0146986181,
0.0192595627,
0.0651617199,
0.0000021036,
-0.0505163185,
0.0272577759,
-0.019228695,
-0.0280340631,
0.0089364145,
0.0121999765,
-0.0109585067,
0.0011397527,
-0.0055523007,
-0.0310918596,
0.0017328326,
0.04330815,
0.064050056,
0.0058536478,
0.0500402786,
-0.0021610032,
-0.0456740744,
0.013467324,
0.0021611298,
0.0645975471,
-0.0290444531,
0.0264996178,
0.0220063739,
-0.0003067568,
-0.0155415889,
-0.083436206,
-0.0009632883,
0.0324768238,
0.0247588959,
-0.0118838567,
0.0690689534,
-0.0342499316,
-0.031246461,
0.009014341,
0.0354929306,
0.0486685038,
-0.0458259508,
-0.0316962451,
0.0102709811,
-0.0032127595,
-0.0056026545,
-0.0478823371,
0.0514954105,
-0.0105661871,
0.059955921,
0.0195170753,
-0.0018974398,
0.0059278412,
0.0278990027,
-0.0188928712,
0.0624499731,
-0.0011678727,
-0.033441212,
0.0423641279,
0.0542716682,
-0.0263283849,
-0.0554932356,
-0.0278157592,
0.0509341583,
-0.0013648166,
0.0255894084,
0.0065879622,
0.0596252456,
0.0113632763,
-0.0908984244,
0.0156251527,
0.0818796381,
-0.0737535134,
0.0219192598,
-0.0395756252,
0.0489261113,
-0.0455213413,
0.0722602308,
-0.0352926105,
-0.0038026241,
-0.0420816168,
-0.0368925296,
-0.0289095286,
0.0526082329,
-0.0173036512,
-0.0252902135,
-0.019577641,
0.0408702306,
0.0025749402,
-0.0303841047,
-0.0277331024,
0.0030328531,
-0.0444317088,
0.0213076342,
-0.0428350009,
0.0323080122,
-0.0129880039,
0.0269238036,
-0.008298819,
-0.0763454065,
-0.0129435789,
0.0194496382,
-0.0318595804,
-0.0105058784,
-0.0132890707,
0.0955240577,
0.0261957981,
-0.0185298529,
-0.0667094141,
-0.0225087404,
-0.0440446585,
-0.051693514,
0.033825133,
-0.0105102751,
-0.0374411941,
0.035067793,
-0.034358684,
-0.0319188312,
0.004831946,
-0.0132477423,
-0.0634321943,
0.0550552607,
0.005447791,
-0.0124131832,
0.0052364846,
0.0379296876,
-0.0135057438,
0.0614566058,
0.0052028736,
0.0191479586,
0.0205033291,
0.0075897039,
-0.0006431988,
0.0010781599,
0.0187295768,
-0.015696248,
-0.0013834656,
-0.0322107784,
0.0078248782,
0.0522321686,
0.0234812479,
0.0797805339,
-0.0169462711,
-0.0076809027,
0.058917243,
0.0638399571,
0.0028979895,
0.0431481265,
0.0152071286,
-0.0245082192,
0.0181910805,
0.0918731391,
-0.0498583987,
0.015992621,
-0.0152615607,
0.0098047117,
-0.0353342891,
0.0019720928,
-0.0399960838,
-0.0432862341,
-0.0274776723,
0.0235769786,
0.0067746323,
-0.0542884171,
0.0176691655,
0.0076022651,
-0.0005846204,
0.0396589972,
0.0521608442,
-0.0300187971,
0.0257222131,
-0.0876365975,
0.0077087022,
-0.0391281247,
0.0132844858,
0.0134030208,
-0.0210930333,
0.0232155062,
0.038540598,
0.0772280395,
0.0362610258,
0.0216826126,
-0.0263162572,
-0.0215451531,
0.0132483477,
-0.0348170958,
0.0016295428,
0.0132652298,
-0.0580403656,
0.007616098,
-0.0320416428,
-0.0202325229,
0.0134251099,
0.0497558713,
-0.0049044387,
-0.0433429331,
-0.0376942307,
0.0193269998,
0.0569650196,
-0.009202512,
-0.0009615744,
0.031259425,
0.0328334421,
-0.0137451887,
-0.0257110447,
0.0737514645,
-0.0622248277,
-0.0031241879,
0.0280645024,
-0.0343412943,
-0.0048217061,
-0.0351498276,
-0.0029295611,
-0.0306517817,
0.048043251,
-0.0209285542,
0.0922063589,
-0.0365166888,
-0.0117979739,
0.0039887787,
0.0101928674,
-0.0388283655,
0.0527056418,
0.018518893,
-0.0339927338,
-0.0048093125,
0.0205600709,
0.0520771593,
-0.0183498133,
-0.0122853862,
0.0256847013,
0.0062021958,
0.0115846153,
-0.0280516576,
0.013167589,
-0.0719066784,
-0.0277644526,
-0.0886625499,
-0.0159686916,
0.019709086,
0.0151356766,
0.0281273052,
-0.0232720841,
-0.0185632594,
0.0152408136,
-0.0096968785,
0.0355915017,
0.0268471502,
0.0353257842,
0.053325858,
0.0045985836,
-0.0397456214,
0.0044136313,
0.0244516619,
-0.0394456945,
0.0294660907,
-0.0070196311,
-0.0254667755,
-0.0539414287,
0.0455230549,
-0.0490536764,
0.0068689352,
-0.0142794475,
-0.032488022,
0.0484209582,
0.0266160313,
-0.0012494352,
0.0522417277,
-0.0013134851,
0.0975750387,
0.0326629356,
-0.025174208,
-0.0185323618,
-0.0293468572,
-0.0230815243,
-0.0767539963,
-0.0051172427,
0.0212099869,
-0.0515979864,
0.0909881741,
0.0336638875,
-0.0170800406,
-0.0450167879,
0.0168084521,
-0.0221548472,
-0.0193383638,
-0.0351971649,
-0.0192571823,
-0.0690460652,
0.0459320024,
-0.0320912302,
-0.0308850277,
0.0410501435,
-0.0275031514,
-0.0179035179,
-0.035676688,
0.0219457317,
-0.0528121628,
0.0906767696,
-0.0316513255,
0.0179100726,
0.0318017937,
-0.0356830843,
-0.0741856918,
-0.0312111415,
-0.0116467513,
0.0228869822,
0.0352629907,
-0.0507238656,
0.0109385736,
-0.0119189434,
-0.0198627729,
-0.0571623407,
0.0202567205,
-0.0163273886,
-0.0061309179,
-0.0114015164,
0.0485931821,
0.0140576987,
0.0063379332,
0.0092949467,
-0.0457397737,
-0.0224780049,
-0.023263311,
-0.0329918303,
-0.0030868624,
-0.0114893746,
0.0385432504,
0.0421264134,
-0.0024646341,
-0.000505919,
0.0758003071,
-0.0226530284,
-0.014570781,
-0.0166832432,
0.0446693599,
0.0042352253,
-0.0399686098,
-0.0585739054,
0.0076504257,
0.0484749041,
-0.0321178883,
-0.0390111618,
0.0857656151,
-0.0057057617,
-0.0352462381,
0.0549818501,
-0.045325622,
0.0038979913,
-0.0011484436,
0.0103087099,
-0.0901303515,
-0.0004095169,
0.0094016092,
-0.0180795453,
0.0060349251,
-0.0331086069,
-0.0228523854,
-0.0760508254,
0.0368654765,
0.0108385608,
-0.0571256429,
-0.0075419815,
0.0108326683,
0.0122963125,
0.0233566854,
0.0730223134,
0.0349700861,
-0.0203790851,
0.0123230349,
0.0471788868,
-0.0067511182,
0.0045639458,
0.0121966889,
-0.0352522172,
0.0428283177,
0.0021790324,
0.0443165638,
-0.0142485518,
-0.0469934829,
0.0934956372,
-0.0021896297,
0.0391443782,
-0.0270436965,
-0.0147691565,
-0.0048566796,
0.0019562899,
-0.0201921202,
0.0390835404,
-0.0202650931,
-0.0080273682,
-0.0157575458,
0.0673444942,
-0.0523641855,
-0.0295749344,
0.0105367508,
0.0258080401,
-0.0479372628,
0.0711432174,
0.0493957289,
-0.0044057192,
-0.0311360192,
-0.0190671254,
0.0100866873,
0.0872638375,
-0.0808939338,
0.0305647627,
0.0040499289,
-0.0339662246,
-0.0432410687,
-0.0434877984,
-0.0043462636,
0.0316228084,
0.0239364523,
0.0011069978,
-0.0229633115,
-0.0192305017,
0.0052882549,
0.035410516,
-0.0248174928,
-0.0349939167,
-0.0318365581,
-0.0045493059,
0.0293831266,
-0.0705163032,
-0.0171624459,
-0.0469176508,
-0.0194096547,
-0.0517355725,
0.0385625362,
-0.0042959056,
0.0409593619,
0.0074604475,
0.0143982954,
0.0062795738,
0.002761943,
0.0415959135,
-0.0064680227,
0.0854108706,
0.0215130635,
0.0755835101,
0.0356658697,
0.0337117165,
-0.0207194239,
0.010217079,
0.017104676,
0.015187175,
0.0262773335,
-0.0040758629,
0.0411115251,
0.0292855799,
0.0754836947,
-0.0032388582,
0.016968973,
-0.0305288732,
-0.0058171353,
0.0042056316,
0.0147341993,
-0.035339389,
-0.029475823,
0.0351201892,
0.0446953066,
-0.0408737175,
-0.0530977957,
-0.0366588645,
0.0527913384,
0.0274925679,
0.0001536704,
0.0015088889,
0.0026908221,
-0.0136012444,
0.0319475271,
-0.031454701,
0.0258514546,
-0.0332580954,
0.023574017,
-0.0091822967,
0.0540115312,
0.0488394722,
0.0207446162,
-0.0048220353,
0.0167513452,
-0.058963459,
-0.0485680439,
0.0323289819,
0.0706683248,
0.0656544268,
-0.0072144167,
-0.0107668201,
-0.067466259,
0.0071308515,
0.0250876937,
0.01822019,
-0.0079085287,
-0.0254746415,
0.0396273583,
-0.0132496059,
-0.0207278132,
-0.0110786362,
0.0546017326,
-0.027652543,
0.0519653112,
0.0303790346,
0.0103214812,
-0.0222563613,
-0.0380475521,
0.0279282369,
0.0049797879,
0.0114392247,
0.0124268429,
-0.0936594009,
-0.044814609,
-0.0305287912,
0.0135891959,
0.0016993709,
-0.047772754,
0.0236728229,
0.0526044257,
0.0183343291,
-0.0200711004,
0.0229822993,
-0.003523024,
-0.03141357,
0.0124233877,
0.0197321232,
-5.989866279e-33,
-0.0539752245,
-0.0216040574,
0.0444631688,
0.0693250895,
-0.0605845898,
-0.0043589165,
-0.0286267456,
0.0271069929,
-0.0329463407,
0.0153757324,
-0.0243313685,
-0.017019432,
0.0155836362,
-0.000200815,
0.0137972739,
-0.0556326024,
-0.0095938435,
-0.0175480545,
-0.0010449823,
-0.0236499067,
0.0319321789,
0.0072924551,
0.064108856,
-0.0635400116,
0.0409045815,
0.0125169139,
0.0016229021,
0.0183345862,
-0.033731252,
0.0333613418,
-0.0440660194,
0.0525317565,
0.0332628265,
0.0064537087,
0.0040135323,
-0.0014809744,
-0.0239286758,
-0.065738447,
0.0764207244,
0.0427690819,
-0.0085522505,
-0.0200316049,
0.0384158157,
-0.0174056683,
-0.0632358417,
0.0195423532,
0.0029156189,
-0.0373919643,
-0.0257402547,
0.0475448892,
-0.0707973316,
-0.0307486132,
0.0340963863,
-0.020109877,
-0.0119291786,
-0.0789544806,
-0.0350978673,
-0.0218165945,
-0.0190292019,
-0.0042594057,
-0.0331245326,
0.0094286809,
0.0566964559,
0.0179096591,
0.018741563,
0.0737510696,
0.0613007732,
0.0043867589,
-0.0567443259,
-0.0358709358,
0.0199097972,
0.030895615,
0.0153290657,
0.007510846,
0.0263268147,
0.0179511271,
-0.0562664606,
-0.0317796692,
0.0553798638,
0.0573299043,
0.0173286274,
0.0226971433,
-0.0262454823,
-0.0338253677,
0.0095648877,
-0.0288657807,
-0.0273757707,
-0.0418275855,
0.0216751322,
-0.0357957669,
0.013973454,
-0.0220442042,
0.0214412864,
-0.0529582575,
0.0229941458,
0.001876149,
-0.0244241301,
0.0038381421,
0.0035860993,
-0.0092920493,
-0.0697613284,
-0.0466828346,
-0.0325836763,
0.0249424074,
0.0069385921,
0.036399167,
-0.0052857161,
0.006103606,
0.0094561623,
-0.0099671427,
-0.0454007238,
-0.0444233865,
0.0384785272,
-0.0279054344,
0.0491414815,
-0.0112885283,
-0.0116520766,
0.0195417069,
0.0285905208,
0.0180239566,
-0.0189255886,
-0.0041760616,
-0.0383959785,
0.005954091,
-0.0465567224,
0.0002307035,
0.0036401872,
0.0172499344,
0.0369245298,
-0.0842008889,
-0.0214960445,
-0.0017554912,
2.935e-7,
0.0603528954,
0.0391915552,
0.035298124,
0.0223620236,
0.0363002084,
0.0114865657,
-0.0280131288,
0.0037600666,
0.0012535932,
-0.0398072228,
-0.0051997928,
0.0609999001,
0.0174684115,
0.0280783437,
-0.0342929102,
0.0085008051,
-0.0492560565,
0.0002622903,
-0.0226044115,
0.0349941365,
0.068320252,
0.0716927052,
-0.0042934879,
-0.0224779211,
-0.0076196971,
-0.0431721397,
0.0662446395,
-0.0249722023,
0.0387439802,
-0.0167016014,
0.0362755619,
0.0012644542,
0.0017873602,
0.0211502183,
0.0568959005,
0.0005937124,
-0.0144869266,
0.0104836784,
0.0044799191,
-0.0191206541,
-0.0153930411,
-0.0239880998,
-0.0027884059,
-0.0531212837,
0.0674127862,
-0.0847018287,
-0.05346293,
0.0080361003,
0.0402099751,
-0.0406009443,
0.0110618854,
0.0220763627,
-0.0080780583,
-0.0189329013,
0.0187690202,
-0.0273400415,
-0.0348181576,
-0.080235675,
-0.0036459249,
-0.0132783856,
-0.0323586948,
-0.0671443641,
0.0097048981,
0.0234461576,
0.0709580556,
-0.0508295149,
-0.0639399588,
2.792413003e-34,
0.0121461926,
-0.0294474885,
0.053003557,
0.0163913053,
0.0164839104,
0.0009285714,
0.0835297257,
0.0177719686,
0.0177239794,
-0.0397866927,
-0.0257000532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02212v1 | A Data Generation Perspective to the Mechanism of In-Context Learning | 2024-02-03T17:13:03 | 2024-02-03T17:13:03 | Haitao Mao, Guangliang Liu, Yao Ma, Rongrong Wang, Jiliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-Context Learning (ICL) empowers Large Language Models (LLMs) with the
capacity to learn in context, achieving downstream generalization without
gradient updates but with a few in-context examples. Despite the encouraging
empirical success, the underlying mechanism of ICL remains unclear, and
existing research offers various viewpoints of understanding. These studies
propose intuition-driven and ad-hoc technical solutions for interpreting ICL,
illustrating an ambiguous road map. In this paper, we leverage a data
generation perspective to reinterpret recent efforts and demonstrate the
potential broader usage of popular technical solutions, approaching a
systematic angle. For a conceptual definition, we rigorously adopt the terms of
skill learning and skill recognition. The difference between them is skill
learning can learn new data generation functions from in-context data. We also
provide a comprehensive study on the merits and weaknesses of different
solutions, and highlight the uniformity among them given the perspective of
data generation, establishing a technical foundation for future research to
incorporate the strengths of different lines of research. | [
0.0026206246,
0.0406487398,
-0.0215501375,
0.0434261486,
-0.0174715053,
0.04024297,
0.0040427302,
-0.0319904685,
-0.026898168,
-0.04124818,
-0.0718809366,
-0.0439188145,
0.024636196,
-0.0045077843,
0.051265534,
-0.039419461,
0.0076228068,
-0.0359587073,
-0.0182455368,
0.001587024,
-0.026784407,
-0.0033403146,
0.0107718743,
0.0421808586,
-0.0019397202,
-0.022077769,
0.0115360152,
0.0058931671,
-0.016438121,
-0.0177611653,
0.026390247,
0.0186701659,
0.0480836593,
0.0475728028,
0.0000021456,
-0.0369067676,
-0.0031358039,
-0.0249012578,
-0.0387600251,
-0.0344807655,
0.0345558748,
-0.0488457158,
-0.0086447028,
0.0237272605,
-0.0576182455,
-0.0393619277,
0.0256121904,
-0.0336047783,
0.007050259,
0.0705294088,
-0.0075146942,
-0.0383784696,
0.0028487623,
-0.0370273478,
0.0130107198,
-0.0449024141,
0.024163194,
0.0009201601,
-0.0120783905,
-0.0165445022,
-0.0390283614,
0.0485147387,
0.041592069,
-0.0027768968,
0.0067333002,
0.0501097366,
0.0122885304,
-0.0052587311,
-0.0114190876,
0.041804336,
-0.0252669789,
-0.0197678767,
-0.0248269849,
-0.0136440322,
0.0146706682,
0.0003024271,
-0.0498825461,
0.0351200178,
-0.0043925899,
0.0421122238,
0.0200686902,
-0.0155915469,
0.0623508357,
0.0026310121,
-0.0302413516,
0.0379862115,
-0.0155172953,
-0.0281421486,
0.0049122977,
0.012631922,
-0.0256295484,
-0.0540419668,
-0.0305196922,
0.0370550789,
-0.0436538458,
0.0515361018,
-0.0490897335,
0.003378541,
-0.0101930005,
-0.0245494097,
0.0224448759,
0.0225873832,
-0.0219937582,
0.0162069071,
-0.023156045,
0.0193246212,
-0.0060007307,
0.0135321524,
-0.0446893834,
-0.0202477612,
-0.0477511995,
-0.0148808481,
-0.0274721161,
-0.0183771662,
-0.0276362188,
-0.0010273264,
-0.0104665449,
0.0751641169,
-0.0335303508,
0.0177446697,
-0.018793406,
-0.0283405948,
-0.0520901866,
0.0223673359,
-0.0068049273,
-0.0113757728,
0.0133137675,
0.0343552977,
-0.0050684949,
-0.0323943645,
0.0056590559,
0.0073775901,
0.0222704969,
-0.0066558756,
0.0224921089,
0.04862497,
-0.0234561153,
-0.0345142558,
-0.0403748862,
-0.0177869201,
-0.0164366718,
-0.0792953223,
-0.0157648697,
-0.0678903237,
-0.0058557959,
0.0301727764,
0.0112730246,
-0.0466361418,
-0.0204152744,
0.0168558024,
-0.0126647819,
0.0580359809,
-0.0189005993,
0.0225496143,
0.0220081676,
0.0015554703,
0.0216033291,
0.0844907835,
-0.0018416764,
-0.0306915902,
0.0189025905,
0.0048480965,
0.005777658,
0.0448876545,
0.049705036,
0.0147669995,
-0.0342031009,
0.0037278167,
0.0315046422,
0.0350866467,
0.0323678367,
-0.009747087,
-0.0384439304,
0.053343337,
0.0697929636,
0.0618057586,
0.0562962107,
0.0128951697,
0.0575264767,
0.0020616399,
0.0024252608,
0.0237086043,
-0.0599768199,
-0.0185562279,
0.0069637583,
0.0112570273,
-0.0078441473,
0.0001423275,
-0.0344385616,
-0.0404132381,
-0.0019457868,
-0.0041986941,
-0.0054985876,
0.0374607407,
0.0435483232,
0.056855388,
-0.0037828614,
-0.0193936639,
0.0254214443,
-0.0173736159,
0.0457600057,
-0.0537246503,
-0.001862038,
0.0664167926,
0.0337392688,
-0.0257860441,
-0.0066556172,
-0.01627337,
0.0492648073,
0.0165517926,
-0.0001816053,
-0.0582359433,
0.0357042886,
-0.0264079478,
-0.0289984606,
-0.0219816994,
0.0191073455,
-0.0045691561,
0.0084448485,
-0.0253008362,
0.0030778332,
-0.0266594365,
-0.0262995195,
0.0429151841,
-0.0605132654,
-0.0250311941,
0.0210269298,
0.0178745892,
0.0161154307,
-0.0007547458,
-0.0053972672,
-0.0037216512,
0.0209139083,
-0.0360556729,
0.0194143951,
0.0569518097,
-0.1014747024,
-0.0531110764,
0.0116865179,
0.0011230235,
-0.0066229384,
-0.0269619841,
-0.0278830025,
-0.040929649,
0.0055842451,
-0.0170138851,
0.0879560336,
-0.0414611176,
0.0184621066,
-0.0211734958,
0.0146646993,
-0.0184122249,
0.0973087549,
-0.0002728052,
0.0008227912,
0.0482714139,
0.0883672386,
-0.0149797844,
-0.0264627654,
0.0023485837,
-0.0056973128,
0.0105654746,
0.0272039138,
0.002658559,
0.0317685083,
-0.0474165902,
0.0091298725,
-0.0970629975,
-0.0057498212,
-0.0545872375,
-0.0161541756,
0.054552611,
-0.0099358344,
-0.0032801859,
-0.0328173377,
-0.0134067945,
-0.0107550928,
0.0147644114,
0.0184352063,
0.0437074378,
0.0341075808,
-0.0188390911,
-0.0132528739,
-0.0000859882,
0.0057019913,
0.0565845929,
0.0136209885,
0.0077719148,
-0.0837901384,
0.0322855674,
0.0257033389,
0.0249541644,
-0.0283451583,
0.0162941236,
0.0243781582,
-0.0039354526,
0.0259549227,
0.0453235842,
-0.0194662269,
0.0663090646,
0.0427442044,
-0.0004107092,
-0.0500771292,
-0.0058330121,
-0.0369269252,
-0.0158445053,
-0.0728111491,
-0.0105791697,
0.0068557416,
0.035670612,
0.0201976951,
-0.0045898207,
-0.0356836542,
0.0128960349,
-0.012410922,
-0.0251451898,
-0.0674936324,
-0.0086984038,
-0.0356436223,
0.0277249869,
-0.0409387387,
-0.0989081189,
0.0309152473,
-0.0114132781,
-0.0036652016,
-0.0761732683,
-0.0305832345,
-0.0183486603,
0.058832325,
-0.0079470938,
0.0115525359,
-0.0176357534,
-0.0313616879,
-0.0614027642,
0.0101798233,
0.0222935062,
0.0021527873,
0.0587000474,
-0.0761222467,
-0.0016937328,
0.0252405368,
-0.0152738374,
-0.0669659823,
-0.0095360307,
0.0020880923,
0.0320609324,
0.0125701427,
-0.0035468924,
0.0293653365,
-0.0197776537,
0.0269477367,
0.0625040457,
0.0216531977,
-0.0387018733,
-0.0264685713,
0.027574135,
0.0293737985,
0.0026281204,
0.0101803876,
-0.0428480692,
0.0219723098,
0.0330102146,
0.0771680325,
-0.007489901,
-0.0281479266,
0.0192031022,
0.0395525768,
-0.0117222155,
-0.0151308188,
0.0399063528,
0.02274937,
-0.0581941865,
-0.0407582521,
0.0962535888,
-0.0049262061,
-0.0967568085,
0.0180217531,
0.0220909212,
-0.0151966289,
0.0464573801,
0.007632954,
-0.066813454,
-0.0200947057,
0.0122419344,
0.0223290622,
-0.0097895805,
-0.0088286046,
-0.0303091761,
-0.0912282094,
0.0421349704,
0.0029238902,
-0.0854140297,
-0.0427971818,
-0.0308462754,
0.0160869453,
0.0135653801,
0.0524496436,
0.0184099041,
-0.0346611775,
-0.0082095331,
0.0465073995,
0.0070514316,
-0.123956576,
0.0195320398,
-0.0449030139,
0.0488556363,
0.0748876259,
0.0242954697,
0.0146065047,
0.0065934076,
0.0468352027,
-0.0354043506,
0.0196556821,
-0.0304444022,
0.0313151479,
-0.0189761017,
-0.0002253756,
0.0245538987,
0.0807177499,
-0.0361783989,
-0.0232842825,
0.0135363201,
0.0576106608,
-0.017442761,
0.0087712929,
0.0159437824,
-0.0493519828,
0.0671415403,
0.0709219202,
0.0242535435,
-0.0772879124,
-0.0106070889,
0.0044732424,
0.0270152297,
0.0103356605,
0.0010762517,
0.0134926336,
-0.0176741797,
-0.0062279883,
-0.0324741937,
-0.0249987114,
0.0329920575,
0.049924124,
0.0225375984,
0.0215984005,
-0.01973054,
-0.0130706187,
-0.0493641347,
0.0160826575,
-0.0192787461,
0.0243362822,
-0.0281726662,
-0.0579591282,
0.0260884147,
-0.064775683,
-0.018463647,
0.0094555831,
-0.0826067924,
-0.0544150174,
0.0079204049,
0.0241069999,
0.019097941,
0.1045648605,
0.0113259368,
-0.0453284346,
0.0896936581,
0.0321775675,
-0.0219809096,
0.0271416809,
0.0359122939,
0.0137962662,
0.0063114753,
0.0390794091,
-0.0536261871,
-0.0070062685,
0.0604845248,
0.0173508488,
-0.0291683972,
0.0573428459,
0.0414209925,
-0.0658447072,
0.0163020771,
-0.0428627841,
-0.0313442685,
-0.0617031418,
0.0035897393,
0.0306755025,
-0.0211284291,
-0.0407784842,
-0.0255844686,
0.0257373638,
0.0187693052,
0.0080979047,
0.0071053966,
0.0173886195,
0.0265256874,
-0.0461360477,
0.0011532241,
0.0164787062,
0.0410242938,
0.0405993201,
0.0228632372,
-0.0054373308,
0.0181751978,
-0.0267690811,
0.0242978465,
-0.009303486,
0.0390823372,
0.0227970388,
-0.0220795292,
-0.0187945627,
0.0154548744,
-0.0969759524,
-0.0123528577,
-0.0583262667,
0.0440420434,
0.0963540524,
-0.0352645926,
0.0331498757,
-0.0398460776,
-0.0033923972,
-0.0132431323,
0.0162135381,
-0.012486401,
-0.0570305735,
0.000819422,
0.0014510265,
-0.0226552058,
0.0089482851,
0.0919728056,
-0.000216071,
0.0612897947,
-0.0296113789,
0.0036795107,
-0.0280738622,
-0.015960658,
0.0637406558,
0.0481262617,
-0.0166840553,
0.0216312315,
-0.0365402289,
-0.0717529729,
-0.0446374789,
-0.0089696068,
-0.0236800015,
-0.0148986159,
0.0290581118,
0.085516274,
-0.0118568558,
0.002322284,
-0.0395112112,
0.0086788945,
-0.0054953429,
-0.0131619433,
-0.0413466282,
-6.306004832e-33,
-0.0200258959,
-0.045226071,
0.032151226,
0.0181265995,
0.0177678335,
0.0196199268,
-0.0249970853,
-0.0012011257,
-0.0079104574,
-0.0063234228,
-0.0108619481,
0.0198923033,
0.008226471,
0.0395120457,
0.0083249081,
-0.0113114258,
0.0503411256,
-0.0171497017,
-0.006196368,
0.0489472039,
0.0528878346,
0.0166433491,
0.0832112879,
-0.061939951,
0.0454221033,
-0.050164789,
-0.0055465698,
0.0401906818,
0.0018063039,
0.0336547345,
-0.0152325202,
0.0419689082,
0.0408568643,
-0.0469700135,
-0.0451364145,
0.0070907106,
-0.0935808942,
-0.0050354749,
0.0207963362,
0.0283835288,
-0.0404425822,
-0.0231874343,
0.0642750636,
-0.01984182,
-0.0279436521,
0.0080704568,
0.0464230478,
-0.0283371918,
-0.0283330437,
-0.0352096781,
-0.0623402186,
0.0020475287,
-0.0057818689,
-0.0238472447,
0.0246408619,
0.0088160094,
-0.0042260555,
-0.0200529601,
-0.0832929164,
0.0157893952,
-0.0040657232,
0.0347277857,
0.0860540643,
0.0521095656,
0.042600859,
0.0504478551,
0.0456885919,
-0.0131607391,
0.037024457,
-0.0729854181,
0.0726351291,
0.0176456589,
-0.028781455,
0.0401065536,
0.0430067256,
-0.0180482659,
-0.0595311113,
-0.0047386275,
0.0186732989,
0.0031689489,
0.0224252194,
-0.0048882682,
-0.0230544433,
-0.0559283867,
-0.0400108099,
-0.0537238643,
-0.0037354184,
-0.0009039743,
0.0418508798,
0.0319483839,
-0.0030595865,
0.0049585802,
0.0104843033,
-0.0580111146,
-0.023516763,
0.0364436582,
-0.0114523573,
0.0070204139,
0.0251144022,
-0.0093117598,
-0.0674758181,
-0.0501554646,
-0.0239234716,
0.0262858421,
0.0066881212,
0.0016349611,
0.0677935481,
0.0549140312,
-0.026085671,
0.0003060756,
-0.0562819764,
0.0506829396,
-0.0042569782,
-0.0098626921,
0.0348522365,
0.0073044472,
-0.0240520425,
0.0243806634,
0.0335932449,
-0.0173594542,
-0.0105564632,
0.0215320941,
-0.0299202595,
0.0208849777,
-0.0251867939,
-0.0228161924,
-0.0071163657,
0.002051034,
0.0811694711,
-0.0274260473,
0.002024089,
0.0007553695,
2.636e-7,
0.0347606838,
3.731e-7,
-0.0018002102,
-0.0035345859,
0.0593972728,
0.0136616919,
-0.0365039594,
-0.0014011634,
0.025102606,
0.0318802744,
0.0200295337,
0.0229789708,
0.0436865129,
0.0285096988,
-0.0457379296,
0.017489206,
-0.0540374741,
0.0321888998,
-0.0205067508,
0.0036727681,
-0.0183288269,
0.0614982098,
-0.001345049,
-0.0397802256,
0.0074638794,
-0.0507784933,
0.0645278841,
-0.0660546198,
0.063197203,
0.0247893371,
-0.0350264795,
0.0428415239,
0.0273464806,
0.0231670793,
-0.0124388291,
0.0402426906,
-0.0188185647,
0.0536184758,
0.0238575786,
-0.0144625213,
-0.0069556218,
0.0118703572,
0.0121198902,
-0.0855455175,
0.060665641,
-0.1016718522,
-0.0038016171,
-0.055299297,
0.0362557508,
-0.0335660577,
-0.0194594748,
0.0154225267,
-0.023310639,
0.0071742553,
0.0256703962,
-0.0185054541,
-0.0314208269,
-0.0717681721,
-0.0250905287,
0.0180091821,
-0.0412413552,
-0.0528597906,
-0.0232872423,
-0.0008096345,
0.0362099521,
-0.0388978124,
0.0197656732,
2.330856524e-34,
-0.0065238094,
0.0136133833,
0.031856887,
0.0314971954,
-0.0237567537,
-0.0159552488,
0.0062325737,
0.0106268721,
0.0591006838,
-0.036835704,
-0.0033658517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05948v1 | DE$^3$-BERT: Distance-Enhanced Early Exiting for BERT based on Prototypical Networks | 2024-02-03T15:51:17 | 2024-02-03T15:51:17 | Jianing He, Qi Zhang, Weiping Ding, Duoqian Miao, Jun Zhao, Liang Hu, Longbing Cao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Early exiting has demonstrated its effectiveness in accelerating the
inference of pre-trained language models like BERT by dynamically adjusting the
number of layers executed. However, most existing early exiting methods only
consider local information from an individual test sample to determine their
exiting indicators, failing to leverage the global information offered by
sample population. This leads to suboptimal estimation of prediction
correctness, resulting in erroneous exiting decisions. To bridge the gap, we
explore the necessity of effectively combining both local and global
information to ensure reliable early exiting during inference. Purposefully, we
leverage prototypical networks to learn class prototypes and devise a distance
metric between samples and class prototypes. This enables us to utilize global
information for estimating the correctness of early predictions. On this basis,
we propose a novel Distance-Enhanced Early Exiting framework for BERT
(DE$^3$-BERT). DE$^3$-BERT implements a hybrid exiting strategy that
supplements classic entropy-based local information with distance-based global
information to enhance the estimation of prediction correctness for more
reliable early exiting decisions. Extensive experiments on the GLUE benchmark
demonstrate that DE$^3$-BERT consistently outperforms state-of-the-art models
under different speed-up ratios with minimal storage or computational overhead,
yielding a better trade-off between model performance and inference efficiency.
Additionally, an in-depth analysis further validates the generality and
interpretability of our method. | [
0.0307813659,
0.0849561617,
0.0052605919,
0.0139991492,
-0.0150097283,
-0.0044215224,
0.0179554764,
-0.0178494137,
-0.0479941592,
0.000776635,
-0.024222808,
-0.0575884879,
0.0026626373,
-0.0034533374,
0.0458848514,
-0.0621216446,
0.0359911956,
-0.01750727,
-0.0221583731,
-0.0133880898,
-0.0095525971,
-0.0146454144,
0.0067924396,
0.0824242905,
0.0316759907,
0.0095012356,
-0.0421714,
0.0402566791,
-0.0050252983,
-0.026495168,
0.0466337241,
0.0685499236,
0.0124459062,
0.0483637042,
0.0000021518,
-0.0553154945,
0.0054190741,
0.0107157985,
-0.0222061444,
0.0390204452,
-0.0562329181,
0.0429625288,
-0.00127215,
0.0358458832,
0.0092131123,
-0.0437617078,
0.084575586,
-0.0114128133,
0.0147618437,
0.045977436,
-0.0079864357,
-0.0133240316,
0.0167541225,
-0.0365979783,
0.0282213278,
0.0025322223,
0.0262719616,
-0.0833571628,
-0.0290339403,
-0.0940444171,
0.0018476939,
0.0102506401,
0.0396475792,
0.0370284654,
-0.038926594,
0.0660343841,
-0.0343575776,
-0.0395340547,
-0.0206935741,
0.044927381,
-0.0534903482,
-0.0386072733,
0.0058220746,
-0.019772293,
-0.0102491882,
-0.0349393338,
-0.0057840836,
-0.0157562159,
-0.0055117588,
0.0083829174,
-0.0033087009,
0.0544315949,
0.0192774646,
0.0132816946,
-0.0444855653,
-0.0068381848,
0.0486896038,
-0.0197346397,
-0.0035779187,
0.0267495848,
-0.0248274915,
-0.0223726351,
0.0255797599,
-0.0108105857,
0.0363733433,
0.0168825388,
-0.0507674739,
-0.0050434284,
-0.0266173203,
-0.0465812795,
0.0195170622,
0.0433728993,
-0.0031614848,
0.027567327,
-0.0140856346,
-0.0037669356,
-0.0245251544,
0.0317259841,
-0.0310267713,
-0.0022512155,
-0.0123912124,
0.014451826,
-0.0591113381,
0.0348593853,
0.0509652607,
-0.0349315368,
-0.0507402346,
0.0209392849,
0.0273754504,
0.0002875268,
-0.0025443279,
0.0324474946,
-0.0255122911,
-0.0061407518,
-0.013913759,
0.0332256891,
-0.0554950498,
-0.0043443129,
0.0030755813,
-0.0352283046,
-0.0297035668,
0.035615474,
0.017393183,
-0.0287280306,
0.0395711288,
0.0608381666,
0.023763597,
-0.0411263071,
-0.0667857453,
0.0353646353,
-0.0000049973,
-0.0620667972,
0.0123891253,
-0.0590321496,
0.015111194,
0.009552164,
-0.0186888035,
-0.0124848653,
-0.0157403294,
-0.0148228928,
-0.004209999,
0.0373223722,
-0.0564781837,
0.0030323174,
-0.0065255687,
0.0055964715,
-0.0029823321,
0.059772566,
0.0305280853,
0.0260403994,
0.031408634,
-0.0223150216,
-0.007496269,
0.0828425214,
0.0481915735,
-0.0150867216,
-0.0582036898,
-0.0118801305,
-0.0005286594,
0.0117159756,
0.0169775132,
0.0185755715,
-0.0397531092,
-0.0023056397,
0.0769193619,
0.0652051196,
0.014979478,
0.0359858163,
0.0340448096,
-0.01064335,
0.0164131839,
-0.0003990671,
-0.051531814,
-0.0099262381,
-0.0168390274,
0.0195675995,
0.0414319709,
0.0591528118,
-0.038606219,
-0.0286956392,
-0.0090200957,
-0.0267644413,
-0.0529751964,
-0.0155186076,
0.0466107503,
-0.0015304064,
-0.0331139751,
0.0805112347,
0.0168881081,
-0.0298800636,
-0.0140323546,
-0.0463768132,
0.0305819511,
0.0715874955,
0.0296042953,
-0.0311892368,
-0.0808693022,
0.0345693827,
-0.0358932689,
0.0396800004,
0.0186939631,
0.0120773306,
0.0786391199,
-0.0555196926,
-0.0448696762,
0.0591130629,
0.0047030724,
0.0138172461,
0.0630300045,
-0.0048292778,
-0.0081232367,
-0.1198177785,
0.0290997624,
0.0266495813,
-0.0079920618,
0.008723842,
0.0162587594,
0.0504783057,
0.033988189,
-0.0173329189,
-0.035034705,
-0.0114191482,
0.0262386445,
-0.0061210883,
-0.0000282052,
0.0265124142,
-0.0616399907,
-0.0741643757,
0.0034150914,
0.0033975737,
0.0010468829,
0.016748948,
-0.0192264505,
-0.0191425122,
0.0199665613,
-0.0429599397,
0.1137879118,
-0.0345633999,
0.0239890553,
-0.0293982886,
-0.0073003666,
0.0090297246,
0.0631964654,
-0.0425005071,
0.0295236129,
0.0105013689,
0.0133898892,
0.0158437435,
-0.0048006596,
-0.051870048,
0.0038243807,
-0.0187645219,
-0.0174855422,
0.0331522822,
0.0090401014,
-0.0413317308,
-0.0151921725,
-0.0510943085,
0.0152469454,
-0.0050815288,
0.0533128828,
0.0142845251,
0.0138144651,
-0.0184495877,
-0.0284815002,
-0.0004273984,
-0.0120162787,
-0.0630028993,
0.0085586067,
0.0223171022,
0.0305531342,
-0.0583692379,
-0.0322785303,
-0.0278767031,
-0.0046382239,
0.0911428258,
-0.0426541828,
-0.0335035026,
0.0095969355,
-0.0349311829,
-0.0397199914,
0.0713483542,
0.0176444352,
-0.0469237491,
0.0043451046,
-0.058761403,
0.0478871875,
-0.008756089,
0.0024246781,
0.0047091418,
0.0115580149,
0.0089184279,
-0.0641871467,
-0.0099662645,
-0.0487722605,
0.0420233905,
-0.0167415664,
-0.0061697783,
-0.0237961691,
0.0800356716,
0.0031897801,
0.0043397653,
-0.0655157045,
-0.0058870348,
0.034969613,
-0.021447992,
0.004613346,
-0.0060715401,
-0.0048299632,
-0.0050834282,
-0.0279389806,
-0.0366703905,
0.1063449904,
-0.0389707424,
-0.0076192953,
-0.0009886071,
0.0150943212,
0.0001962996,
0.0557982624,
0.0172094088,
0.005984046,
0.0269490816,
-0.0487856977,
-0.0348502882,
-0.002634983,
0.0031882022,
-0.0062521705,
0.0065218508,
-0.0362554491,
-0.0049734865,
0.0159817412,
-0.0450405851,
-0.0161812603,
-0.019845482,
0.0040547387,
0.0001964491,
-0.0178298894,
-0.041804038,
-0.0432194099,
0.002514892,
-0.0162622482,
0.0913219154,
-0.0079630632,
0.0241757948,
-0.0039626593,
0.0703880042,
0.0015315468,
-0.0090161283,
0.018434979,
-0.0446632355,
0.0435838588,
0.0261007585,
0.0630680472,
0.0190003496,
-0.077669017,
-0.0107028149,
0.0442403555,
-0.0129577201,
-0.0489340872,
0.0409019478,
0.0006662937,
-0.0567073114,
-0.0281903874,
0.1338260621,
0.0031051571,
-0.0342932977,
0.0008170089,
0.0462807976,
0.0769076124,
0.0024104016,
0.0177423749,
-0.0266732853,
-0.0394288041,
0.0074134199,
0.043248076,
0.0248239953,
-0.0288221426,
0.0128663843,
-0.121570006,
0.0240930039,
-0.0040477626,
-0.041801285,
-0.014782371,
-0.0350570418,
0.0037049011,
-0.0027994104,
-0.0306377802,
0.002692224,
0.0206398014,
0.0051453914,
0.0529864579,
-0.0474261753,
-0.0256013237,
0.0186826903,
-0.0506493002,
0.0240757633,
0.0423341468,
-0.0077414671,
-0.017208267,
-0.0379288495,
0.0415458642,
-0.0825924575,
-0.0225572251,
-0.0016135399,
0.0794244707,
-0.0185519159,
-0.0152010461,
-0.0302083995,
0.0112738535,
-0.0072539551,
-0.0064700693,
-0.0099223936,
0.0414256603,
0.0020190366,
-0.0673504323,
-0.0164025687,
0.0193328317,
-0.0259236824,
0.0575377196,
0.0424925946,
-0.09838406,
-0.0323006995,
0.0113701671,
0.0018317049,
-0.0567505397,
0.0525704771,
-0.0088527845,
-0.024370404,
-0.0962870941,
-0.0219300352,
0.0014237596,
0.0276719369,
0.0783271417,
0.0035098905,
-0.0308907777,
-0.0223164875,
0.0373998359,
-0.0423365161,
0.0189053807,
0.0505311154,
-0.0069202413,
-0.0536184125,
0.0127390809,
0.0574428104,
-0.0104080392,
-0.0443691313,
0.0108646927,
-0.0267716497,
-0.0565533265,
0.028253939,
0.0472064316,
0.0176360365,
0.0398898534,
-0.0182287171,
-0.0606432073,
0.0900833756,
0.0528142713,
0.0375959277,
-0.0068957852,
0.0527841486,
-0.0146529116,
0.0136149582,
0.0269464031,
-0.0415118001,
0.0232902467,
0.0321916565,
0.0205401275,
-0.0422478467,
-0.0149729764,
0.0049526542,
-0.0082976101,
0.062621735,
-0.0319804698,
-0.0165300108,
-0.0541248508,
0.0373759754,
0.0413555317,
-0.0115531469,
-0.048996035,
0.0173977651,
0.044765871,
0.0463271923,
-0.0170619842,
0.0089365933,
0.0377159081,
-0.0083531179,
-0.0447989181,
-0.0070738876,
0.0420327149,
0.0567088798,
0.0307241809,
-0.0120074777,
-0.0264349766,
0.0197738949,
-0.0037971472,
0.0110155828,
-0.0639255047,
0.0229213573,
0.055936791,
0.0076011736,
0.0131498426,
0.0354683772,
-0.0448768251,
-0.0084701153,
-0.1016490012,
0.0660166591,
-0.0045742001,
0.0343395211,
0.0145266596,
-0.0215069763,
0.0090572936,
0.0081109321,
0.0200772304,
-0.0313861221,
-0.0651425943,
0.0083897561,
0.0208120756,
-0.0018743421,
-0.0319237635,
0.0398112796,
0.0204007067,
0.0759952888,
-0.0069465525,
-0.0100955907,
-0.0272482764,
-0.0144834146,
0.057616353,
0.0179723166,
-0.0285750534,
0.0262595117,
-0.0129998541,
-0.0625297129,
-0.0365734622,
0.0423796289,
0.0022390678,
0.0400321223,
0.0539170429,
0.0532323644,
-0.0105400207,
-0.0533304699,
0.0212922134,
-0.0024162114,
-0.0057873721,
-0.0025449607,
0.022470437,
-6.878155401e-33,
-0.0311805401,
0.0102435816,
-0.0026464299,
-0.0205455422,
-0.0089060748,
0.0053829611,
-0.0390988067,
0.0112316106,
-0.017484704,
-0.0168920849,
0.0117140692,
0.0253157765,
0.0181825161,
0.0247878339,
-0.0108338846,
-0.0124344686,
0.0505211949,
-0.0015135169,
-0.018552538,
0.0018873047,
-0.0258997977,
0.0549451821,
0.0860892013,
0.009612551,
-0.0451526977,
0.0010640587,
-0.0465763584,
0.0116941417,
0.014726161,
0.0300022271,
-0.0209963247,
0.0228123646,
-0.0152849853,
0.0022525296,
-0.0092226518,
0.0011179704,
-0.0796880424,
-0.0426929891,
-0.0121402135,
0.0228386503,
-0.0186296105,
0.0224098265,
0.044839792,
0.0050040651,
-0.0045818402,
0.0147148157,
0.0381755829,
0.0197525192,
-0.019370459,
-0.0510304496,
-0.0263051409,
0.0352727287,
-0.0185493194,
-0.0295640342,
-0.0091897137,
0.0208932757,
-0.0040420173,
-0.0221851673,
-0.052602604,
0.0035267011,
0.0334251896,
0.0035738328,
0.01644882,
0.0405916497,
0.0093821492,
0.0540788025,
0.056208048,
-0.0124897417,
0.0280522313,
-0.0459508523,
0.0879118145,
0.0286414865,
0.0147696026,
-0.0555402115,
0.0454326421,
0.0046198708,
-0.0595146194,
0.0341706909,
0.0383450203,
0.0033504374,
0.0179013256,
-0.0137308612,
-0.0324862301,
-0.0299082883,
-0.0281358212,
-0.0583575927,
-0.0312539116,
-0.009076017,
0.0262663979,
0.0013779304,
-0.0308046006,
0.0025011117,
0.0160013195,
-0.0199864749,
0.0253899414,
0.0076523945,
-0.0219236072,
0.0192539077,
-0.0001995069,
0.0381627418,
-0.0673227087,
-0.0617495067,
-0.0150329089,
0.0078734616,
0.0117136575,
-0.0030887243,
0.0297072548,
0.04711923,
-0.0702160448,
-0.0015869924,
-0.0474908501,
-0.0016998994,
-0.0044177538,
-0.0136258407,
0.0351363868,
-0.006963355,
-0.0071700742,
0.0097722933,
0.0299057364,
0.0516640171,
-0.006652175,
0.0104881413,
0.0340625793,
0.0407116115,
-0.0114018433,
-0.023673974,
-0.0339292958,
-0.0173273254,
0.0340069719,
-0.0535052866,
-0.0248122402,
0.0231953952,
2.928e-7,
0.0519435182,
0.0175271686,
0.0646036565,
-0.0037442944,
-0.0147388596,
0.0202083737,
0.0082122171,
0.011315681,
0.0002748719,
0.0477185771,
0.060240455,
-0.0116413645,
0.0064564883,
0.0098277982,
-0.0937972143,
-0.0013473138,
-0.0713094175,
0.0125594651,
-0.0452144854,
-0.0016060323,
-0.0082527809,
0.08103659,
0.0365352854,
-0.0235676523,
0.016043162,
-0.0590257868,
0.0411101878,
-0.0177801494,
0.0194128435,
0.0196270086,
0.0368779637,
0.0058433325,
-0.0046622697,
-0.0057791634,
0.0072186887,
0.0454593226,
-0.0056242705,
0.0094091259,
-0.0206085704,
-0.0351926871,
-0.0016414468,
-0.0019589309,
0.0023009481,
-0.0570006743,
0.0554337874,
-0.045450069,
-0.0222671945,
0.0320924297,
-0.0211785398,
-0.0310333297,
-0.0070710881,
-0.0313575901,
-0.0254532155,
-0.0066353069,
0.0220291745,
-0.0573961399,
-0.0204049647,
-0.0724081919,
-0.0433859676,
0.0221681185,
-0.0451205038,
-0.0440732874,
-0.0412616879,
-0.0314551368,
0.0417045988,
-0.0841768384,
0.0072982521,
2.877345914e-34,
0.0447096936,
-0.0171401128,
0.0114130862,
0.0171626899,
0.0133027397,
-0.0071495431,
0.0542242117,
-0.0130030122,
0.0217416249,
-0.04754287,
-0.0521657281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02175v1 | Enhancing Complex Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs through Evidence Pattern Retrieval | 2024-02-03T14:54:13 | 2024-02-03T14:54:13 | Wentao Ding, Jinmao Li, Liangchuan Luo, Yuzhong Qu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Information retrieval (IR) methods for KGQA consist of two stages: subgraph
extraction and answer reasoning. We argue current subgraph extraction methods
underestimate the importance of structural dependencies among evidence facts.
We propose Evidence Pattern Retrieval (EPR) to explicitly model the structural
dependencies during subgraph extraction. We implement EPR by indexing the
atomic adjacency pattern of resource pairs. Given a question, we perform dense
retrieval to obtain atomic patterns formed by resource pairs. We then enumerate
their combinations to construct candidate evidence patterns. These evidence
patterns are scored using a neural model, and the best one is selected to
extract a subgraph for downstream answer reasoning. Experimental results
demonstrate that the EPR-based approach has significantly improved the F1
scores of IR-KGQA methods by over 10 points on ComplexWebQuestions and achieves
competitive performance on WebQuestionsSP. | [
0.0298213512,
0.0178084038,
-0.0060161431,
0.0446483418,
-0.0564078763,
-0.009521259,
-0.0486552827,
0.0341151953,
0.0343116671,
-0.032278154,
0.003852648,
0.0002724704,
-0.041574847,
0.0252714101,
-0.006848102,
-0.0202407017,
0.0348182172,
0.0216835998,
0.0525355488,
0.0115964375,
0.0010958897,
0.0280826371,
-0.0459652506,
0.0079464102,
-0.0374276377,
-0.0531959608,
-0.0112889791,
0.0092606815,
0.0314807855,
-0.0411261134,
0.0166054573,
-0.0044224062,
-0.0031978984,
-0.0459570587,
0.0000016409,
-0.0354291312,
-0.0320244394,
0.0271093398,
-0.042732317,
-0.0042802561,
-0.0540114418,
0.0486323088,
0.0482853055,
0.0127320103,
-0.0529343896,
-0.0071374481,
0.019474877,
0.075214982,
0.0298829172,
0.0229273178,
-0.0054990398,
-0.0350923687,
0.0046484475,
0.0344668366,
-0.0118615609,
-0.0086879842,
0.0420067161,
0.0469392538,
0.0345858149,
0.0224471223,
0.0030319525,
0.0059143691,
0.010127482,
0.0276949164,
0.0067079314,
0.0131181637,
-0.021642549,
0.0466231443,
0.0361247584,
0.1177110523,
0.0408958197,
-0.0089423861,
-0.0067182104,
-0.0068461783,
0.013462727,
0.0888840705,
-0.0725870058,
0.0049118083,
-0.0492985137,
-0.0356252156,
0.0126224421,
0.0248313844,
0.0234854817,
-0.0115416534,
-0.0098138843,
0.0781183168,
-0.0065694642,
-0.0383721851,
0.0038673144,
-0.0098374588,
-0.0540939122,
0.0053698844,
0.0249471664,
0.0433623567,
-0.0006593361,
0.0386253223,
0.0460291579,
0.0202636197,
0.0209336877,
-0.0320085399,
-0.024295032,
0.0186605584,
-0.0093582431,
0.0641462207,
-0.0242862366,
0.0202789791,
-0.0205916427,
-0.0322646163,
-0.0413541757,
-0.0229771268,
-0.1004514843,
-0.0309485104,
-0.0462752283,
0.0810461119,
-0.0374571867,
-0.0478465855,
0.0232429393,
0.025197519,
-0.0081922086,
-0.0448972806,
0.0229960158,
0.0665959045,
0.0180747025,
0.0123135084,
-0.0599541031,
0.0631212369,
-0.0486042202,
0.0171212349,
0.0132364053,
-0.0064329421,
0.0046880189,
0.0038308993,
0.0552654751,
-0.0268877707,
-0.0199825224,
0.0338708535,
0.0207870621,
-0.0049765077,
-0.0316080377,
-0.0857888162,
-0.0025689597,
0.0143987928,
0.02041425,
-0.0744785368,
0.0332722925,
0.0094395038,
-0.0419052988,
0.0070640473,
0.0162147228,
0.0276360791,
-0.040965803,
0.0058108503,
-0.0153692765,
-0.0442752801,
0.0067415568,
0.0211651232,
-0.0323432386,
0.0394155867,
-0.0054887729,
0.0192228314,
0.0558079258,
0.0137942256,
-0.0384280309,
-0.0404449105,
0.0337282047,
-0.0154910414,
0.0282693841,
0.0550379679,
-0.0103403963,
-0.0032174836,
-0.0242790338,
0.0307232011,
-0.0709719583,
-0.0333453156,
0.002940886,
0.0523230322,
0.0183811486,
-0.0136222867,
0.0013058853,
0.0192169752,
0.0261146668,
0.0339131542,
0.0135588646,
0.0032075976,
-0.0278054718,
0.0096096816,
-0.0082961125,
0.0102036009,
-0.03128355,
-0.0608929135,
-0.0156373605,
0.0378353484,
0.0094315,
0.0347558409,
0.0320588984,
-0.0104135303,
-0.0252162367,
0.0190153215,
0.0383340642,
0.0130674103,
0.0019254993,
-0.0143930251,
0.0254167095,
0.076840803,
0.0445140786,
-0.0338533334,
-0.0447105691,
0.0454335809,
-0.032197468,
-0.0514554456,
-0.0177045874,
-0.0445897728,
0.0034800565,
-0.0330390818,
-0.0406643599,
-0.0222770497,
-0.0311733931,
-0.0315018333,
0.0167357102,
-0.0055808234,
-0.0061851097,
-0.0480596088,
-0.0180527605,
-0.0029305387,
0.0249468964,
-0.0049950955,
0.0154834576,
0.0053879586,
0.0330091193,
0.0377928279,
0.0037132695,
0.0387684107,
0.0422528796,
-0.0168565884,
-0.0429455526,
-0.0142721962,
-0.030606024,
-0.0751559138,
0.0335920453,
-0.031857051,
0.0306154881,
-0.036051318,
-0.0137953181,
-0.0540676378,
-0.0111119896,
-0.0598977022,
0.0577668622,
0.0035511884,
-0.0645954236,
0.063970387,
-0.0473834202,
-0.0633859932,
0.0678931475,
0.0069629811,
-0.0019686667,
-0.0251203328,
-0.0157624669,
0.0154621638,
-0.0253364332,
0.0397202224,
-0.0101721715,
-0.0318623856,
0.0171960071,
0.0509125777,
-0.0517835096,
-0.0585485175,
0.0200491082,
-0.0485318564,
0.0468179919,
0.0082946615,
0.0241705067,
-0.0066277348,
0.0061224671,
0.0222593993,
-0.0448444113,
-0.051990021,
0.0355109721,
-0.0227694418,
0.0123491818,
0.0249952096,
0.0469294302,
0.0040128659,
-0.0197909456,
-0.0613106675,
-0.0160756465,
0.0636753291,
0.0014887159,
0.0173871294,
0.009012457,
0.0075708074,
-0.0411499217,
0.0136301918,
-0.0084719881,
0.0081494693,
0.0152759105,
-0.0360810161,
-0.014233253,
0.0538935624,
-0.0387840942,
-0.0073663425,
0.0148538128,
-0.039668519,
-0.0794952363,
0.0180284567,
-0.0302352104,
0.0508975945,
0.0086312108,
-0.0210205428,
0.0168339722,
0.0034844689,
0.0267077629,
-0.0342848785,
-0.0176565312,
0.0019370279,
0.0163956508,
0.0290134978,
-0.0333384313,
-0.0124094468,
0.0480847396,
0.0114503615,
-0.0509311594,
0.0123712337,
0.0816015303,
0.0166117772,
0.0473905876,
-0.0334261581,
0.0017741217,
-0.0137485461,
0.0441177525,
-0.0056064432,
0.0172542669,
0.0119617693,
-0.0132304356,
-0.0260684937,
-0.0126380501,
0.0392901599,
-0.0478897505,
-0.0068373559,
0.0018441976,
0.0348038115,
0.0095533403,
-0.0112931952,
-0.0343054123,
0.0168408733,
0.0008354112,
0.0505053177,
0.0101429913,
-0.0136414981,
-0.009416623,
0.0216475856,
0.0315021314,
-0.04306712,
-0.0412640348,
-0.0083552422,
-0.0090702055,
0.0793265924,
0.059779074,
0.0187985525,
0.0374794416,
0.0394210294,
0.0197439231,
0.0764138699,
-0.0260309931,
-0.019372737,
0.0088056736,
-0.0183565989,
-0.0119350068,
-0.0601798557,
-0.012660821,
-0.009624267,
0.0273215286,
-0.0597830936,
0.0103420783,
0.0593761429,
0.0501179807,
0.0063068066,
-0.0240876563,
-0.0106389318,
0.0112371156,
0.0096563324,
0.0302480366,
-0.0864545181,
-0.0201315135,
-0.0075750002,
0.0310092978,
-0.0080123898,
-0.0278486442,
0.0537797995,
-0.0884822309,
0.0365751795,
-0.0052578924,
0.000135392,
-0.0386321805,
-0.0648975745,
0.0098741464,
0.0145792244,
-0.0360675007,
0.0183051638,
-0.0369564667,
-0.0048021441,
0.032936994,
-0.0085463533,
-0.0000950879,
0.0211106334,
-0.0185039677,
-0.0116062621,
-0.0055225845,
0.0020469667,
0.00302679,
-0.0439297557,
-0.0530060753,
-0.0518188067,
0.0333848968,
-0.0130346222,
0.0011170635,
0.0235663708,
-0.0051434729,
-0.0613830537,
-0.0173972212,
-0.037326742,
-0.0252186097,
0.0208564289,
0.103011407,
-0.0283295028,
0.0010319577,
-0.0307721961,
-0.0280680489,
-0.0326381139,
0.0504801683,
0.0340330079,
0.0556205474,
-0.0346478485,
-0.0130282994,
0.0244497545,
-0.0391461439,
-0.0107781878,
0.0360118896,
-0.0131680025,
0.07476978,
-0.0873573571,
-0.0495104827,
0.0352811553,
0.054704573,
-0.0576720126,
0.0073588672,
0.0444712825,
0.0105557879,
-0.0997116789,
0.0568292439,
-0.016803313,
-0.0008310128,
-0.0307557601,
-0.0071113985,
-0.0024006099,
-0.0221583974,
-0.0288248416,
-0.0215057041,
0.0466169044,
-0.0290990453,
-0.0290641859,
0.0143632162,
-0.0005072721,
0.0329474695,
-0.0102509176,
-0.0236532856,
0.0280602705,
0.0000998977,
-0.0455121994,
-0.0687091202,
0.0099276165,
-0.0405898578,
-0.0307144225,
-0.0160574578,
-0.0864251181,
0.0132266991,
0.0046604499,
0.0968617722,
-0.0511934385,
-0.0076871412,
0.0553362481,
0.0526585579,
0.0089200735,
0.0541278906,
-0.0288422201,
-0.0269971956,
0.003103717,
-0.0118795028,
0.0025023497,
-0.0108096432,
0.0192790665,
0.0052224742,
-0.0303242281,
0.0027701552,
-0.0229354147,
-0.0048432951,
-0.0021867394,
0.0103851529,
-0.0267789159,
0.0666127875,
-0.0024229807,
0.0199302752,
-0.0254747327,
-0.0377718918,
-0.004033139,
0.0175815113,
0.0476599522,
-0.0160873905,
0.0387868509,
0.0388288088,
-0.0284451321,
-0.0597625263,
0.0065903822,
-0.0535123535,
-0.0334146172,
-0.0026042243,
-0.0049911384,
0.0486402512,
0.0074343793,
-0.0231709983,
0.0350594334,
-0.033169698,
0.0033306575,
-0.011421321,
0.0042291773,
0.0310474169,
0.0707109869,
0.0705108345,
-0.0057276548,
0.0161133856,
0.0611755699,
0.0021039243,
0.0099270092,
-0.0142082265,
-0.0669370443,
-0.0063970536,
-0.034271758,
0.0196832679,
0.0618498139,
-0.0418128632,
0.0188255273,
-0.0128720142,
-0.0496603735,
-0.0068225767,
0.0226199478,
-0.0198722668,
-0.0029730867,
0.053693343,
0.0317393355,
0.0621743165,
-0.0532249399,
-0.023735363,
0.0178778376,
-0.0616290309,
-0.0157893188,
0.0136483647,
-6.188112299e-33,
-0.0105806664,
-0.0467474945,
0.0311994962,
0.0030670073,
-0.0111704636,
0.0406461395,
-0.0123613384,
-0.0301803704,
-0.0455723181,
0.036222171,
0.011501722,
-0.0097206021,
-0.003199555,
0.003884689,
-0.0076615,
-0.0014894812,
-0.008003328,
0.0249114521,
0.0029406345,
0.0327942707,
0.0580705144,
0.0152956136,
0.0163946506,
-0.0476024449,
0.0245514214,
-0.0231542569,
0.0680186823,
0.0448921695,
-0.0123364441,
0.0893927962,
-0.015924355,
0.0333313234,
0.0383976661,
-0.0078754472,
0.0351108536,
0.0003111191,
-0.1105036438,
-0.0666963905,
0.0283385832,
-0.021837011,
-0.0680458397,
-0.0262953434,
0.0272983946,
0.0065014325,
0.0818831027,
-0.0231538899,
0.0484225936,
0.0012716544,
-0.049153287,
-0.0273435079,
-0.0298363604,
0.0340765938,
-0.0260176659,
0.0214514378,
-0.0552627295,
0.0221575107,
-0.0022119922,
-0.0116906343,
-0.0752444193,
-0.0184900258,
-0.0298097469,
0.0318248868,
-0.0265802704,
0.027951777,
0.0146491053,
0.0291344263,
0.0113098612,
-0.0258165114,
-0.0140832672,
-0.0108238794,
-0.0210154168,
0.0651667863,
0.021072546,
0.0072562979,
0.0548503585,
0.0231703892,
-0.1169825569,
0.0115139289,
0.0586251616,
0.060533978,
-0.031939026,
0.0087898159,
-0.0531385094,
-0.0374034159,
-0.0096127549,
0.0168098882,
-0.0397600457,
-0.0201809984,
0.0183150377,
-0.0056293099,
-0.0025777884,
0.0374503471,
0.0224610008,
-0.0401596017,
0.0350907817,
0.06082692,
0.0118482644,
0.0398320667,
-0.0085593788,
0.056283664,
-0.0343500823,
0.0144695183,
0.0190671701,
-0.0620591491,
-0.0002567896,
0.0360401161,
0.0102390507,
-0.0202694852,
0.0039142286,
-0.0301748477,
-0.0178106111,
-0.0379050672,
-0.0446655676,
-0.0677931905,
0.0381266437,
0.0899285674,
0.020991819,
0.0240247492,
0.0243026614,
0.0372728743,
-0.0036820238,
-0.005406077,
0.0099685295,
-0.0044717062,
0.0066372748,
0.008712789,
-0.0376319438,
0.0186109338,
-0.081985727,
-0.0721644461,
-0.0112750707,
0.0667841062,
2.554e-7,
0.051822301,
0.017450342,
0.0089622475,
0.0096569788,
-0.0057034446,
0.0002403319,
0.0142110931,
-0.0329131857,
0.0393404514,
-0.0293186996,
0.0217735581,
0.0600683726,
-0.0169544332,
0.0559169464,
-0.050269559,
-0.0274645239,
-0.0192414187,
-0.0877186134,
-0.0496065393,
-0.0103994329,
0.0745717436,
0.014800135,
-0.0053130905,
0.0056640413,
-0.02695328,
-0.0534623452,
0.0534951985,
0.0548650362,
0.0160170011,
-0.006724237,
0.0575840622,
-0.0230317935,
0.0096099749,
0.0423880257,
0.0051509421,
0.0463008285,
0.0148819163,
0.0159665681,
-0.0181355309,
-0.0446714908,
0.0064432798,
-0.0526717938,
0.054375086,
-0.0020902641,
0.1020217165,
-0.039577473,
-0.0163593013,
0.0298308842,
-0.0788854212,
-0.0193737932,
-0.0385706201,
0.019755058,
-0.0017544413,
0.0132547533,
-0.0076439264,
-0.0063071535,
0.0067318282,
-0.0377089158,
0.0340992659,
0.0343960375,
0.0087025538,
0.002121201,
0.0309507661,
-0.0262686387,
0.0222227145,
0.0298153721,
-0.0000248623,
1.964973576e-34,
0.02184649,
0.0206004735,
0.029140031,
0.0352998413,
0.035854537,
-0.0287379269,
-0.0811850652,
-0.0115790144,
0.0255548134,
-0.1067532077,
-0.0049784603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02145v1 | Analyzing Sentiment Polarity Reduction in News Presentation through Contextual Perturbation and Large Language Models | 2024-02-03T13:27:32 | 2024-02-03T13:27:32 | Alapan Kuila, Somnath Jena, Sudeshna Sarkar, Partha Pratim Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL | In today's media landscape, where news outlets play a pivotal role in shaping
public opinion, it is imperative to address the issue of sentiment manipulation
within news text. News writers often inject their own biases and emotional
language, which can distort the objectivity of reporting. This paper introduces
a novel approach to tackle this problem by reducing the polarity of latent
sentiments in news content. Drawing inspiration from adversarial attack-based
sentence perturbation techniques and a prompt based method using ChatGPT, we
employ transformation constraints to modify sentences while preserving their
core semantics. Using three perturbation methods: replacement, insertion, and
deletion coupled with a context-aware masked language model, we aim to maximize
the desired sentiment score for targeted news aspects through a beam search
algorithm. Our experiments and human evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness
of these two models in achieving reduced sentiment polarity with minimal
modifications while maintaining textual similarity, fluency, and grammatical
correctness. Comparative analysis confirms the competitive performance of the
adversarial attack based perturbation methods and prompt-based methods,
offering a promising solution to foster more objective news reporting and
combat emotional language bias in the media. | [
0.0570140779,
0.069157131,
-0.0081135351,
0.033763811,
-0.0664703399,
-0.0195077956,
-0.0128279412,
-0.0413846262,
0.0019625169,
-0.0439281911,
-0.0262300093,
0.0026945316,
-0.0233880728,
0.0151858767,
-0.0249769222,
-0.0750592053,
0.0648883358,
0.0664152429,
0.0403697081,
-0.0081891175,
0.0699266493,
0.009385868,
0.0016132471,
0.0109936362,
-0.0288774502,
0.0052983817,
0.0192733016,
0.0384179689,
0.0370449536,
0.0005218122,
0.0281770788,
0.0323559158,
-0.0204427615,
0.0153267197,
0.0000018955,
0.0101589877,
-0.0181983877,
-0.0202504937,
0.0522199944,
0.0206943676,
0.1347471029,
-0.0674445778,
-0.0147072459,
0.0229520425,
-0.0440850183,
-0.0258456934,
0.0442323983,
0.0615012236,
0.1248540133,
0.1208705306,
-0.027784992,
0.023784373,
-0.0287388638,
-0.0157650001,
-0.004199252,
-0.0317857377,
0.0351238549,
-0.0355163328,
-0.0585011877,
0.0032612996,
-0.0030251162,
0.041161444,
0.0190993473,
0.0108337346,
-0.0342324786,
-0.012421879,
-0.0225210637,
0.0055601243,
-0.0065521104,
0.016209146,
-0.0028774422,
-0.041257564,
-0.0027112591,
-0.0055055167,
-0.0035653224,
0.0154979667,
-0.0295658149,
0.0009515394,
-0.0039879205,
-0.0037908724,
-0.0246047098,
-0.019662397,
0.0177728124,
0.0367049053,
-0.0041871928,
0.0264737029,
0.0269719176,
-0.0501093976,
-0.0239089932,
-0.0076241591,
-0.0329218954,
-0.0012152699,
0.055046089,
-0.0245003905,
-0.0015658258,
0.0139992535,
-0.0535320602,
-0.0502980761,
-0.0211059209,
-0.0978203788,
-0.0345298201,
0.0090300171,
-0.0087840306,
0.0250833016,
0.0225246437,
-0.0004868062,
-0.0011776898,
0.0018381119,
-0.0475481935,
-0.000393309,
-0.0114766741,
-0.0019395528,
-0.0030212044,
0.0129430173,
-0.0448494703,
0.0002803363,
-0.0507296808,
-0.0035547935,
-0.0232682694,
-0.0117063494,
-0.0237861369,
0.018315874,
-0.017034702,
-0.0109181786,
0.0177205876,
0.0410176069,
-0.0173481051,
0.0297512375,
-0.0283713937,
-0.0026645232,
-0.0245391298,
0.0734762251,
-0.0398063436,
-0.020106405,
-0.0153827602,
0.0462333113,
0.000446974,
0.0113735795,
-0.0168591831,
-0.0146023212,
-0.038825646,
-0.0218043905,
0.0183183141,
-0.026380457,
-0.0069248271,
-0.0251221322,
-0.0282881837,
-0.027704468,
0.0054031345,
0.01103824,
-0.0384565629,
0.0852484033,
0.040390946,
-0.0404440388,
0.0370461233,
0.0345097445,
0.0205705073,
0.0386798754,
-0.0064229947,
0.0878387243,
0.0483383164,
0.0030224246,
0.0177993085,
0.0185814258,
0.0171417836,
0.0138105704,
-0.0061960551,
-0.0112191727,
-0.0026382154,
0.0135423457,
0.005806739,
0.0672680363,
-0.0108588403,
-0.0380049646,
0.084922947,
-0.0203380808,
-0.0569320209,
0.0272034574,
0.0099473763,
0.0322287716,
-0.0137470104,
0.0426359102,
-0.0517057925,
0.0205029044,
-0.0653756931,
-0.036477495,
-0.0032120869,
0.0259433389,
-0.0130801229,
-0.0251568388,
0.0132387858,
0.0031861034,
0.0551397577,
-0.0284620989,
-0.0062857503,
0.0332416259,
-0.0601657666,
0.0243621543,
0.0287001561,
-0.0492465608,
0.007809788,
-0.0315912217,
-0.0248106234,
-0.0049106036,
0.0548463091,
-0.024478104,
0.0081952373,
-0.0113864793,
0.014817589,
0.0363441072,
0.0616665408,
0.0228654426,
-0.041036088,
-0.0130790565,
0.0173180662,
-0.0067483233,
0.0310590919,
0.0347997583,
-0.0081160199,
0.0327389836,
0.0048943637,
0.0300957412,
-0.0069252206,
0.0316794701,
0.0344605446,
-0.0286320299,
0.0225003418,
0.0326513946,
0.0359632596,
0.0267975889,
-0.0141439904,
0.0022401225,
0.0173886288,
0.0017572665,
-0.0585694388,
0.0368799902,
-0.0425981581,
-0.0548192076,
-0.0050896062,
-0.0707964003,
-0.0064531295,
0.056374602,
-0.0442985967,
0.0169705693,
0.0691504851,
-0.0349182263,
0.0001456119,
-0.014665748,
-0.0140764033,
-0.0108425701,
-0.0011837587,
-0.0579355918,
0.0450880863,
0.0025938605,
-0.0081377979,
-0.0214624647,
-0.0309458505,
0.0034129967,
0.0114386138,
-0.0324307792,
0.0022809412,
0.0248224437,
-0.0022181231,
0.0579274297,
-0.024665812,
-0.0041717831,
-0.0721085146,
-0.0508841611,
0.000682105,
-0.0137974732,
0.0202920418,
0.0637190193,
0.0023509231,
-0.0132579505,
0.0425550044,
-0.0257173069,
-0.0497616939,
-0.0242300741,
0.034065865,
0.0225276221,
0.0297146365,
0.0003027866,
-0.0435360074,
0.0090817949,
-0.0463495441,
0.0173382256,
0.0109369326,
-0.0578203499,
-0.0241324324,
0.0542865954,
-0.0195158813,
0.0038395384,
-0.028182989,
-0.0615829043,
-0.0009394668,
0.0127662448,
0.0320523679,
0.0797120333,
0.0343249887,
0.0696163476,
0.0220449269,
0.0028944286,
-0.0062180059,
-0.0073709842,
-0.0511313118,
0.018346563,
0.0007799785,
-0.0331017263,
0.0558848679,
0.0127497576,
0.0526509322,
0.0016141945,
-0.0403882451,
0.0436216779,
-0.0245094225,
-0.0304851271,
0.0041589076,
-0.0165573731,
-0.0082923882,
-0.0272378307,
-0.0341437869,
-0.0119723743,
0.0628750622,
0.0159720965,
0.0394308828,
-0.0852908343,
-0.0125107337,
-0.0279925168,
0.0159530994,
-0.0254359227,
0.0276314467,
-0.0353447236,
0.0127548501,
-0.0794988647,
-0.0609523244,
0.067856282,
-0.0030735198,
-0.0008497415,
-0.026364712,
-0.0092627751,
0.0247700755,
-0.0447436981,
-0.0153869689,
-0.0875752568,
0.0210840888,
-0.0072931531,
0.0813839734,
-0.0149770994,
-0.0508880466,
0.0015918692,
0.0318684466,
-0.0306839906,
-0.0271717664,
0.0092365984,
0.0014272319,
0.0359717533,
0.0404584594,
-0.0586863495,
0.0344300643,
0.016447043,
-0.0019502315,
0.0472133197,
-0.0345733911,
0.0131946765,
-0.0019997442,
-0.019162409,
-0.0307277888,
-0.0356744006,
-0.0104523869,
-0.0608803555,
0.0317022838,
-0.0270642005,
0.0393295288,
0.076164864,
0.0405242518,
-0.0301868394,
0.0065191635,
0.0192743465,
-0.0293794069,
0.0149646197,
0.0316885971,
-0.0675316676,
0.0138840526,
-0.0090145534,
0.0392783657,
-0.0078382958,
-0.0065300819,
-0.0521859638,
-0.101133056,
-0.0345377438,
0.0118338363,
0.0113859894,
-0.0344402306,
-0.0406201258,
0.0067920722,
-0.034191329,
-0.0083530946,
-0.0244153738,
0.0426680483,
0.0185681079,
-0.0390157253,
-0.0130514838,
-0.0257946514,
-0.0319198333,
-0.0217038952,
0.0291782916,
0.0359291546,
0.061635714,
-0.0192118529,
-0.0086954143,
0.051152721,
0.0298168808,
-0.0188864879,
-0.0331218839,
0.0376484022,
-0.0326204523,
-0.0108953407,
-0.0171822216,
0.0481591001,
0.0344907455,
-0.0069292802,
-0.0068149189,
0.0077416496,
0.0215929002,
-0.0322321877,
-0.0262378361,
0.0534571931,
0.0875447094,
0.0873113722,
0.0138531737,
-0.0344928801,
-0.0005965545,
-0.0448830761,
0.0187094361,
-0.0263486858,
-0.0647601336,
-0.0379172042,
-0.0006108708,
0.0078962613,
-0.0838465765,
-0.0467506461,
-0.0129384398,
0.0145757785,
0.0069338419,
-0.0137135526,
-0.0210820157,
-0.0185534544,
0.0007724705,
-0.0003676458,
0.0057277922,
0.0157709457,
0.0152321756,
-0.0163441934,
0.0163642038,
-0.0075040949,
-0.0276335087,
-0.0078231972,
-0.0224605687,
-0.0567577444,
0.0373536125,
0.0443001613,
0.0071017137,
0.0277678967,
-0.022897996,
-0.0190508794,
0.0030418755,
0.1165477484,
-0.0347784422,
0.045458965,
0.0350603536,
0.0372532532,
0.0217423774,
0.0254167523,
-0.0027641575,
0.034775313,
0.0540231951,
-0.0116175972,
-0.0250681899,
-0.0101943472,
0.0290095508,
0.0184027087,
0.0510483049,
0.0139596751,
-0.0279037245,
-0.0239902977,
-0.0112205707,
-0.0420607626,
-0.0240367372,
0.0094193891,
0.0005815632,
-0.0186137129,
0.0195940975,
-0.0627301782,
0.0282701887,
-0.0374042876,
0.0230981335,
-0.0330951102,
0.0194894783,
0.0241818726,
0.0223492868,
-0.013896008,
0.0339692384,
-0.0036474897,
0.0331581831,
0.0076573598,
0.0097141666,
-0.0144176958,
-0.0174438208,
0.0424332432,
0.0099986903,
-0.0062115765,
0.015895417,
-0.0614769682,
0.0362608917,
-0.0203061402,
0.0256047975,
-0.0027932352,
-0.0008428412,
0.0085376333,
-0.0223435517,
-0.018037539,
-0.0018742039,
-0.0167329516,
0.0261736307,
-0.0258161351,
0.0248000994,
0.00572776,
-0.0218212456,
0.0220531803,
0.0283369571,
-0.061661467,
0.1041508317,
0.0481105633,
-0.0335108936,
-0.0407657661,
-0.0160173569,
0.0811072364,
-0.0211549569,
0.0086607328,
-0.0011420255,
-0.0582792349,
-0.0364121012,
0.0343653262,
-0.0092348261,
0.0153707918,
-0.0051171551,
0.0052959723,
0.0654707551,
-0.0042622387,
0.0431506261,
-0.0156623051,
0.0253598075,
-0.0473194532,
-0.0769173875,
-0.0011004505,
-6.405829281e-33,
-0.014738257,
0.0069905492,
-0.0455356129,
0.0204922371,
0.0046959203,
0.0053772256,
-0.016581174,
0.0146016944,
-0.0128256613,
0.0346590653,
0.0139741674,
0.0410184041,
-0.0053096344,
-0.009361174,
-0.0616052337,
-0.0003073997,
0.0716027766,
-0.0125350263,
-0.0271543153,
0.004890264,
0.0247388016,
0.0173909627,
0.0375667363,
-0.1187697574,
0.0403927937,
0.0042460472,
-0.0902394876,
-0.0161915962,
0.0255010128,
0.0170592647,
0.0099038668,
0.0314213708,
0.004863976,
-0.0416884236,
-0.0094755953,
0.0780551136,
0.0082353754,
-0.0297387913,
0.0585314482,
0.0152069796,
0.0074409256,
-0.0486220308,
-0.003147441,
-0.0082279416,
-0.0351268724,
0.0291364547,
0.0107360743,
-0.0058819726,
0.0319822319,
-0.0491446294,
-0.0459436327,
0.0094318632,
-0.023178054,
-0.0087574562,
-0.0274096653,
0.0117035415,
0.0239839219,
0.0486089177,
-0.0552592985,
0.0216773935,
-0.0325642414,
0.054568477,
-0.0105549674,
-0.0367607214,
0.0176739339,
0.0671637058,
0.0240173824,
0.0196852256,
-0.0259158313,
0.0274127759,
0.0324974246,
-0.0148027735,
0.0802558362,
0.1098958924,
0.0183676649,
-0.0593033545,
-0.0697579458,
-0.0006088807,
0.0340198986,
0.0130174858,
0.0281964075,
0.0230273362,
-0.0215210244,
-0.0040833727,
-0.0164257269,
-0.0835772306,
-0.0417839959,
-0.0377914123,
0.0129443975,
0.0145257469,
-0.0717033595,
-0.0053665489,
-0.0176079329,
-0.0518578887,
0.0190651733,
0.0394777805,
-0.0525076911,
-0.0038549518,
0.0015584928,
0.0202985406,
-0.0539254472,
0.0453543775,
0.0175088011,
0.0159066767,
0.0048191589,
-0.013323687,
0.0588187426,
0.0231456719,
-0.0639830679,
-0.0018494972,
0.0090311877,
0.0475318022,
-0.0008057716,
0.0124299666,
-0.0013726358,
0.0275380034,
-0.0102948165,
-0.0150378514,
0.0574849285,
0.0312841311,
-0.0077203424,
0.0032640353,
-0.0315916948,
0.0224633068,
-0.0391612761,
-0.0183549076,
0.027348401,
-0.0135370288,
0.0006719818,
-0.0804546252,
-0.0269040745,
-0.0346991532,
2.797e-7,
0.0317273811,
0.091345042,
-0.0039563165,
0.0143933212,
0.0177809615,
0.0328958742,
0.0164706465,
0.0353276245,
-0.0064760707,
-0.0550019927,
0.0133445133,
0.0098116901,
0.0083342101,
0.002265031,
-0.093964994,
0.0353602208,
-0.0373966023,
0.0130556831,
-0.0132647995,
0.0210743826,
0.0882800817,
0.0759555101,
0.0281748977,
0.0134744868,
-0.0345329158,
-0.0171185303,
0.0519265719,
-0.0264148489,
-0.0496687852,
0.0115657896,
-0.00675466,
-0.0323326066,
0.0047098403,
-0.0311468113,
-0.0170424506,
-0.0273125079,
0.0053932606,
0.0362815969,
0.035481561,
-0.0816702098,
-0.0256944671,
0.0207971036,
-0.0236525089,
-0.0087388949,
0.0777898878,
-0.0641978309,
-0.0199542064,
-0.1008623168,
-0.0584398285,
0.0017307156,
0.0515493602,
-0.0305084959,
-0.0719615221,
0.0076932213,
0.0116945151,
0.0620388314,
-0.0247222763,
-0.0488138013,
-0.0029814378,
-0.042070806,
-0.0332876891,
-0.0233039577,
0.0051107737,
0.0637602061,
0.0075098183,
-0.0170220155,
0.0303019118,
2.572867852e-34,
0.0652826205,
-0.0187637657,
-0.0090486668,
-0.0379221849,
0.032114964,
0.0478083082,
-0.0482550152,
0.0087921405,
0.0295894146,
-0.054509405,
-0.0096596144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02144v1 | Probing Critical Learning Dynamics of PLMs for Hate Speech Detection | 2024-02-03T13:23:51 | 2024-02-03T13:23:51 | Sarah Masud, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Vikram Goyal, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the widespread adoption, there is a lack of research into how various
critical aspects of pretrained language models (PLMs) affect their performance
in hate speech detection. Through five research questions, our findings and
recommendations lay the groundwork for empirically investigating different
aspects of PLMs' use in hate speech detection. We deep dive into comparing
different pretrained models, evaluating their seed robustness, finetuning
settings, and the impact of pretraining data collection time. Our analysis
reveals early peaks for downstream tasks during pretraining, the limited
benefit of employing a more recent pretraining corpus, and the significance of
specific layers during finetuning. We further call into question the use of
domain-specific models and highlight the need for dynamic datasets for
benchmarking hate speech detection. | [
0.0309681091,
0.0456217714,
-0.0290762335,
0.0326431505,
0.0045931325,
0.0431915708,
0.0221292283,
0.0110954884,
-0.0406320915,
-0.0604299717,
-0.0292728506,
-0.033965569,
-0.0078910124,
0.0228339117,
-0.0229913164,
-0.029966874,
0.030897487,
0.0205571279,
0.0377707444,
-0.0152569171,
0.0659147054,
0.0089575965,
0.0036750692,
0.0222710688,
-0.072256811,
0.0272975843,
0.0367683917,
-0.0015922588,
0.0321276262,
-0.0092331916,
0.0538699068,
0.0527394228,
0.0365630686,
0.0462761596,
0.000001856,
-0.0354964435,
0.0206183307,
-0.0136538995,
-0.0141528966,
-0.0131052146,
0.0713766366,
-0.0234381109,
-0.0249735992,
0.0359182768,
-0.0416699462,
0.0132679455,
0.0520747043,
0.0436199084,
0.0373502783,
0.0471237414,
-0.0059637185,
-0.0116291596,
0.0156558193,
0.0036792208,
-0.0406807587,
0.0186596196,
0.0420083851,
-0.0697177723,
-0.063128598,
-0.0142036304,
-0.0207324773,
-0.0107317753,
0.026245011,
0.033233352,
-0.0028495127,
-0.016140949,
-0.0177036859,
-0.0396042131,
-0.0209583677,
0.048364263,
-0.0639564618,
0.0029327897,
0.0000114887,
-0.0138098178,
-0.039122697,
-0.0501970835,
-0.0022442366,
-0.0022154595,
0.0009500743,
0.0194274094,
-0.0173902661,
0.0253672972,
0.0590341091,
0.0749750957,
0.0142852291,
0.025843557,
-0.0077127963,
-0.0297778342,
0.0289856009,
-0.0019290387,
0.0124725662,
0.0148507413,
0.0151608698,
-0.0079413867,
0.0091895303,
0.0164734218,
-0.0706982613,
-0.0400052555,
0.00360903,
-0.0605702661,
0.0738895908,
0.038515538,
-0.0397729017,
-0.0042037442,
-0.0102921687,
0.0276577678,
0.003027007,
0.0355150662,
0.001077323,
0.0133182909,
-0.007595608,
0.0143948048,
-0.0077420133,
-0.016326759,
0.0052702716,
0.0300168097,
-0.0340884961,
-0.0220517348,
-0.0226078164,
-0.0493878722,
-0.0413629673,
-0.0050155511,
-0.0187563505,
-0.0085811354,
-0.0218798835,
-0.0030153992,
-0.0274187773,
0.0292453934,
-0.0332613774,
-0.0991990492,
-0.0107223205,
0.0365346782,
-0.0367666632,
-0.02137357,
0.0344975926,
0.0358254313,
0.0201781448,
-0.0436227545,
-0.0514736436,
-0.0181786548,
-0.0319387652,
-0.0691633448,
0.0157107729,
-0.0433731191,
0.0088507542,
-0.0174337532,
-0.0196728799,
-0.0527209789,
-0.0016903776,
0.0092500588,
-0.0525684059,
0.0817332193,
-0.0036191056,
-0.0142740281,
0.0262207109,
0.0221420452,
0.014114338,
0.0764218792,
0.0227233842,
0.0183169097,
0.046509847,
-0.0290133432,
-0.0002025624,
0.0779156238,
0.0543677472,
0.0188843142,
-0.0510053784,
0.0065436102,
-0.0471086726,
-0.0455510393,
0.0246778838,
0.0135450494,
-0.0040357597,
-0.0587685294,
0.0688715652,
0.1020896137,
-0.0354338959,
-0.0029948936,
0.0564676486,
0.0099953152,
-0.0088926954,
-0.0161844883,
-0.0653431341,
-0.0632242635,
-0.0324839838,
-0.0360304564,
-0.0070917327,
0.0825656727,
-0.0223029573,
-0.042259831,
-0.0262783635,
-0.0242450889,
0.0225633159,
-0.0273559261,
0.0427519046,
0.0246327613,
-0.0146076148,
0.0220912658,
0.046151191,
-0.016351942,
0.012010416,
-0.036101371,
-0.0080261854,
0.0638291761,
-0.0043181726,
-0.003116162,
0.0148968836,
-0.0560461059,
0.0358491726,
0.0543644391,
0.0173635967,
0.0072580604,
0.0371173732,
-0.0489622168,
-0.0247688442,
0.0245121345,
0.0339824297,
0.0141067989,
0.0773849264,
0.0114436541,
0.021826461,
0.0049400995,
-0.0526527315,
0.0336307324,
-0.0030673037,
-0.0213257596,
-0.0214067809,
-0.0061153695,
0.0413531139,
0.0150960041,
-0.0565610006,
-0.0503714159,
0.0212403294,
-0.0021014253,
-0.0069637233,
0.018133115,
-0.0585276075,
0.0192650333,
0.0170624815,
-0.0344711468,
-0.0105949305,
0.0602210984,
-0.0010896872,
0.0152374329,
0.0519026257,
0.0032238411,
0.0029255413,
-0.0389818065,
-0.0251678117,
-0.0718351081,
0.0531023741,
-0.0108173247,
0.03692035,
-0.0049059177,
-0.025160769,
0.0298486184,
-0.0325554386,
0.0310395379,
0.0218475629,
-0.0634384379,
-0.039918337,
-0.0273012351,
0.0248490553,
-0.0244589597,
0.0068752323,
-0.0155577557,
0.0277289767,
-0.0689168051,
-0.0117099071,
-0.0452884659,
-0.0388781652,
-0.0036029394,
-0.0264430605,
-0.0387466624,
-0.0060154186,
0.0136762597,
-0.0266692862,
0.0639401376,
0.026497893,
-0.0175509546,
-0.0596236251,
-0.0081049222,
-0.0297140144,
-0.013922249,
0.0219569821,
0.0032027778,
0.0002193296,
-0.0502540916,
0.0500983372,
-0.0104012452,
-0.0151603837,
0.0309412237,
-0.0208150931,
-0.0620025173,
0.0336295813,
0.0362265185,
-0.0076211463,
0.0362335108,
0.0652161986,
0.1063638106,
0.0093531255,
-0.0018543523,
-0.0266751666,
-0.0024275375,
-0.039550554,
0.010382791,
-0.0550277233,
-0.0203265026,
-0.0044890065,
0.1164633259,
0.0340913646,
0.0070051705,
-0.0496274307,
0.0350396857,
-0.0586609431,
-0.036407616,
-0.0054555172,
-0.0660688058,
-0.0365157463,
-0.0064805411,
-0.05267011,
-0.0987000838,
0.0519195497,
-0.0199950039,
0.0205964837,
-0.0110444529,
-0.0336491205,
0.0093211839,
0.0362154916,
0.0168764498,
0.0133647416,
-0.0139551628,
0.0163374823,
0.0120346062,
-0.0039641191,
0.0108168051,
-0.0345137864,
-0.017447168,
-0.0222973805,
0.0272433702,
0.0009071684,
-0.0278653726,
-0.0689019933,
-0.0707434416,
-0.058108028,
-0.0430488959,
0.0336252078,
0.0009906929,
0.0037719845,
0.0195734072,
-0.0082634035,
-0.0025315019,
0.0007662051,
0.0182616208,
0.0313752703,
-0.030067049,
-0.0009172417,
0.0026912731,
0.0231676009,
-0.0178982876,
-0.0212520212,
0.0245941784,
0.0100692222,
0.0015142529,
-0.0267536007,
0.0248049386,
0.0235212427,
0.0298738498,
0.0133093791,
-0.012500437,
0.0169277098,
-0.0229168534,
0.0026724157,
0.093533583,
-0.0006448355,
-0.0125611704,
-0.0050249919,
0.0285556391,
0.0135451695,
0.0172820482,
-0.0340432003,
-0.081456095,
-0.0157324504,
-0.0148314899,
0.042715095,
-0.0625443459,
-0.012626783,
-0.0200638212,
-0.0675181374,
0.0061038556,
-0.0202729143,
-0.050038565,
0.0090010706,
0.0066855997,
0.0271106157,
0.0016086868,
0.0353462361,
-0.040746402,
0.0234931409,
-0.0075552766,
0.0314344876,
-0.0656219646,
-0.0617011487,
0.0293592066,
-0.0348753259,
0.0428891443,
0.0754632205,
0.006650609,
-0.0154483048,
-0.0178053342,
0.0571746863,
-0.0017132979,
0.0026781068,
-0.0655714646,
0.0556783564,
-0.0095762322,
-0.0466413982,
0.002254948,
0.0418135747,
-0.0157479774,
0.0135964043,
0.012598413,
0.0198891126,
0.0275080726,
-0.014903944,
-0.0642302781,
0.0420769639,
-0.016172491,
0.0743491873,
0.0334216617,
-0.0622501746,
0.024448365,
-0.0420806855,
0.0031563789,
-0.0565980263,
-0.0987394825,
-0.0072297915,
-0.0403439701,
0.0241050534,
0.0016108385,
-0.0263830349,
0.023947347,
0.0275707599,
0.0297596492,
-0.0092389807,
-0.0128504094,
-0.0084004505,
-0.075876087,
0.0584172979,
0.0054363036,
0.0461363159,
-0.0461726636,
-0.02753588,
0.0076717599,
-0.0169535745,
-0.0254066214,
0.0034536151,
-0.0726636797,
-0.0516235195,
0.0961786136,
0.0619066954,
0.0222822875,
0.0217244364,
-0.0018714089,
-0.0591429211,
0.0948400572,
0.0327616371,
-0.0158808883,
0.0123464018,
0.0580293611,
-0.0613186173,
-0.0139828986,
0.0107352193,
0.0171085484,
0.0774608403,
0.0648120418,
-0.0591476299,
-0.0332870483,
-0.0168726128,
-0.0325162821,
-0.0256762616,
0.0822904631,
-0.0067529343,
-0.0647649989,
-0.032277517,
-0.0059208632,
0.020554509,
-0.0329620838,
-0.0363678038,
-0.0295102336,
0.0064861756,
0.0042063305,
-0.0456473157,
-0.013207308,
-0.0454912037,
0.0291912034,
-0.0195791647,
0.0330040902,
0.0396188684,
0.0238136444,
0.0576549806,
0.0380471349,
-0.0142242759,
0.0758373961,
-0.013688161,
-0.0402234495,
0.0114382152,
0.0110159768,
0.0067215534,
0.0277668908,
0.0398906469,
-0.0187168699,
0.023603335,
-0.0402093269,
-0.0721188858,
-0.0328234993,
-0.0171872191,
-0.0532497093,
0.0272532869,
0.0079165902,
-0.0094847698,
-0.0185349621,
-0.0130261844,
-0.0159891061,
-0.025283182,
0.0283399988,
0.0227209646,
-0.0438514054,
0.02627155,
0.0500538312,
0.0262154173,
0.0498507768,
0.0496400706,
-0.0221509747,
-0.0152175566,
0.0072718887,
0.0437673554,
0.0250435658,
0.0037152257,
0.0253058951,
-0.0515702106,
-0.0350293927,
-0.002107447,
-0.0377412215,
0.0319560729,
0.0063496791,
0.037971098,
0.0652468279,
-0.0333097652,
0.0493658744,
0.0284265745,
0.0015037351,
0.0126232058,
-0.0526483953,
0.0175621491,
-5.980615139e-33,
-0.0208882093,
-0.0101467827,
-0.019428229,
-0.0158518311,
-0.0149358595,
0.0108861336,
0.034186136,
0.0258071665,
-0.0152107868,
0.0167529359,
0.0074888305,
0.0332493484,
0.0183001142,
0.0227159727,
-0.0225914735,
-0.0271216389,
0.0478606112,
-0.0511322878,
-0.0050874376,
-0.0240828451,
0.0258544367,
0.0363965295,
0.038346298,
-0.0223133899,
0.0329553932,
-0.0046675052,
-0.013243949,
0.0092066089,
0.0026988531,
0.0698376298,
-0.0221392829,
0.0816851333,
0.0382037275,
-0.0134556396,
-0.0290209092,
0.0430348702,
-0.0487645082,
-0.0003250508,
0.0286164451,
0.0332861207,
0.0210922398,
0.0242325682,
0.0311008692,
-0.0039876676,
-0.0598422475,
-0.016008826,
0.0225032736,
-0.0558766574,
0.010244349,
-0.0426810198,
-0.0699328482,
0.0335879065,
-0.0052250242,
-0.0255632289,
0.0083415508,
-0.0029863701,
0.0245285928,
0.0241322741,
-0.0522332527,
0.0148709454,
0.0269017778,
-0.0094794203,
0.0183263384,
0.0479582809,
0.016360186,
0.0845223442,
0.0163772423,
0.0299330056,
-0.0007309876,
0.0364536159,
0.0743702352,
0.0296009276,
0.0484224483,
0.0465468653,
0.0453463309,
-0.0604913794,
-0.0368412808,
-0.009729933,
0.0260148551,
-0.0290935654,
0.030272115,
-0.0401867628,
-0.0186706223,
-0.0461795479,
-0.0460817702,
-0.0388048328,
-0.007356762,
-0.0235821977,
0.035730999,
0.0111728534,
-0.0136161353,
-0.0104499236,
0.0340679735,
-0.0225365907,
0.0036787861,
0.0259822588,
-0.0295151174,
-0.0132090701,
0.0209332686,
0.0380539149,
-0.0853686333,
-0.0009357888,
0.00707951,
-0.0259984955,
0.0186617542,
-0.0165866315,
0.0598903336,
0.0261676554,
-0.0552365482,
0.0198604632,
0.0017666378,
0.0656085908,
0.0135072963,
0.0685036033,
0.0328460708,
0.0522216596,
-0.0215512719,
-0.0163266174,
0.0139676016,
-0.0437040254,
-0.019689735,
0.0268218778,
-0.025565397,
0.0369029194,
0.011706396,
-0.0191991925,
-0.0022572302,
0.0075044516,
0.0301174596,
-0.098600328,
0.0192036983,
-0.0333681032,
2.442e-7,
0.0011965816,
0.035630919,
0.0180600155,
-0.0245172195,
0.0145531381,
0.0385451876,
0.0034171892,
0.0070356848,
-0.0126266424,
-0.0014045428,
-0.0298262592,
0.0727115422,
0.0425781161,
0.057541322,
-0.0010763259,
-0.0397358835,
-0.0547925644,
0.0282879323,
-0.069526352,
-0.0144661264,
-0.0263934527,
0.0701923221,
0.0551974364,
-0.0507482775,
-0.0257347263,
-0.0363505445,
0.0229996461,
-0.0593992844,
0.0156741124,
-0.0162386075,
0.0527946167,
0.0407010131,
-0.0188023001,
0.0146064684,
-0.0113360994,
0.0465323254,
-0.0073010707,
0.0333351605,
0.0308258217,
-0.0009688096,
0.0018155765,
-0.0071918014,
-0.0247661863,
-0.0340446122,
0.0504770651,
-0.040693108,
-0.003841761,
-0.0630790219,
-0.0112877116,
-0.0167139061,
0.0382103771,
-0.0210432839,
0.0064243665,
-0.005455059,
0.0431984849,
-0.01449061,
-0.0235034637,
-0.097047843,
0.001013031,
-0.0027929654,
-0.0345173292,
-0.0463999659,
-0.0534854196,
-0.0147581222,
0.0285030417,
0.0391915254,
0.0410009474,
1.7719147e-34,
0.0301322509,
-0.0524904914,
0.0053635086,
-0.0347166285,
0.0167496353,
0.0210327692,
0.0132436408,
-0.0133401733,
0.0279527139,
-0.0249221437,
0.0111507894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02135v1 | Do Moral Judgment and Reasoning Capability of LLMs Change with Language? A Study using the Multilingual Defining Issues Test | 2024-02-03T12:52:36 | 2024-02-03T12:52:36 | Aditi Khandelwal, Utkarsh Agarwal, Kumar Tanmay, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the moral judgment and moral reasoning abilities
exhibited by Large Language Models (LLMs) across languages through the Defining
Issues Test. It is a well known fact that moral judgment depends on the
language in which the question is asked. We extend the work of beyond English,
to 5 new languages (Chinese, Hindi, Russian, Spanish and Swahili), and probe
three LLMs -- ChatGPT, GPT-4 and Llama2Chat-70B -- that shows substantial
multilingual text processing and generation abilities. Our study shows that the
moral reasoning ability for all models, as indicated by the post-conventional
score, is substantially inferior for Hindi and Swahili, compared to Spanish,
Russian, Chinese and English, while there is no clear trend for the performance
of the latter four languages. The moral judgments too vary considerably by the
language. | [
0.0390663259,
0.0502869114,
-0.0347866789,
0.0418458581,
-0.0652883202,
0.0347586162,
0.0379679427,
0.0181533918,
0.0218266919,
-0.0104947677,
-0.0449302718,
-0.0780307427,
0.0125261256,
-0.0466412231,
0.022136664,
0.0100231329,
0.0343855657,
-0.0106531484,
0.0907241851,
-0.0095913587,
-0.0163647849,
0.0575328395,
0.051182583,
-0.016950449,
0.0254569259,
0.000480321,
0.001275297,
-0.046562925,
0.0193768945,
-0.0328465924,
-0.0137305055,
0.0464865156,
0.0105265947,
-0.0033356941,
0.0000017407,
-0.0549482182,
0.0204127301,
-0.0247791503,
0.0458799489,
0.0354995318,
0.0797641203,
0.0102819577,
0.0034100562,
0.0051269084,
-0.0436111875,
0.0707201436,
-0.0098399734,
0.0813215524,
-0.0262491945,
0.0475455262,
0.0012139708,
-0.0413852446,
0.011096213,
0.0040946454,
0.0086717485,
0.0077237762,
0.0182877295,
0.0880888402,
-0.007743557,
0.011396057,
-0.0099618668,
-0.0079501588,
0.0229863394,
-0.0100163724,
-0.0937445313,
-0.0452337861,
0.0097533921,
-0.0398149714,
0.0101824123,
0.0198155958,
0.0407877713,
-0.0094767883,
0.0047023697,
0.0321680754,
0.0142066982,
-0.0125695476,
0.007110728,
0.079536669,
-0.0143336887,
0.0189751331,
0.071270816,
-0.0021536525,
-0.0167554356,
0.0171699729,
0.0315650851,
0.0181687158,
-0.0313393101,
-0.0049628206,
-0.0022575115,
-0.0145724975,
-0.0794623867,
-0.0214451905,
-0.0266426224,
0.0192707106,
0.0011356192,
0.0227859784,
0.0261655897,
0.0514874868,
0.0458743498,
-0.0832500383,
-0.0031449355,
0.037940409,
-0.0111491298,
0.0074926261,
-0.0055597755,
0.056760855,
0.0064707934,
0.0433019437,
-0.0273209978,
0.0275211986,
0.0279027373,
-0.0304417573,
0.0611897856,
0.0312969312,
0.0027145168,
0.0468388386,
-0.0848282948,
-0.0172389094,
-0.0362135246,
-0.0327785127,
-0.0561115593,
-0.0456677787,
0.0018121372,
-0.0205982421,
-0.0394602083,
0.0214267429,
-0.0577490255,
0.0090391729,
-0.0202956963,
-0.0410073474,
0.0666291192,
-0.0277941972,
-0.0439755842,
0.0046936427,
0.0243482888,
0.1090321615,
-0.0474366881,
-0.0060680094,
-0.0242934059,
0.0028192662,
-0.0156286657,
-0.0899099037,
-0.0115928128,
-0.0328935683,
0.0128181865,
0.0183543172,
-0.0096731503,
-0.0477937683,
0.0447920822,
0.0269675888,
-0.010875416,
0.0079455301,
0.0705377087,
0.0273869243,
0.0027317968,
0.0334701687,
0.0148358541,
0.057672929,
0.0033705365,
-0.0041465433,
0.0219056141,
-0.0029707123,
-0.0363545157,
0.0041695684,
-0.0295389034,
0.0035332111,
-0.0473596342,
0.0078757843,
0.0137543594,
-0.0269172024,
0.0243700333,
0.0341409706,
-0.039879363,
0.0298331026,
0.0176551156,
0.1132766083,
0.0149405664,
0.0413687006,
-0.0057375752,
-0.0072959266,
0.0243810471,
0.041298788,
-0.0505046733,
0.0307848901,
0.0275887009,
-0.0214301795,
-0.0425427109,
0.0532138459,
-0.0147209214,
-0.0356355086,
-0.0090270694,
-0.0075303465,
0.0122588314,
-0.0008479704,
-0.0306475256,
-0.0195884891,
0.0059405072,
-0.066351369,
0.0696373209,
-0.0750804693,
-0.0187816638,
-0.0325323455,
0.0952041298,
0.0402632505,
-0.0037809694,
0.0411472917,
0.0090303458,
-0.0094681047,
-0.0147534655,
0.0384415798,
0.0261322539,
-0.0104653221,
-0.0241163615,
-0.0568393953,
0.0120198075,
-0.0341548622,
-0.0325502492,
0.0460601933,
-0.0381985344,
0.0484516211,
0.0357841738,
-0.009297817,
0.0042421827,
-0.0068636723,
-0.0234342385,
0.0285757147,
-0.0621360652,
0.0133543136,
0.0140358759,
-0.0083960053,
-0.0079230834,
-0.0309211928,
-0.026733499,
0.0005481273,
0.0021766881,
0.0478623472,
-0.055192925,
0.0096068261,
0.0187958442,
-0.0761301592,
-0.0085802265,
-0.002005524,
0.0209989026,
0.0311524812,
-0.0209731217,
-0.0005832062,
0.0042051808,
-0.0477263257,
0.0286068488,
-0.0850606933,
-0.0138953319,
-0.0039071259,
0.0722943023,
-0.0193732213,
0.0388700552,
-0.0114896912,
-0.0023609351,
0.0577606931,
0.0089277839,
-0.0322701372,
0.0421858206,
-0.0131173637,
0.0087251877,
0.0258812979,
0.0670251399,
-0.0218456853,
-0.0387503989,
-0.0560349375,
0.0080182673,
0.0239182301,
-0.0098242527,
-0.0065485039,
-0.0258738417,
-0.0238796398,
0.0488983728,
-0.0510598607,
-0.0003956455,
0.0512913316,
0.027247915,
-0.0044521587,
-0.0416313596,
0.0108073456,
0.0070259217,
0.0027408975,
-0.0222873241,
-0.0127029764,
0.036484886,
-0.027529249,
-0.0136188371,
0.0595187582,
-0.0952738076,
-0.0190412663,
-0.0126624443,
-0.0819355473,
0.0054293978,
0.0429373458,
0.0124870399,
0.0595197678,
0.0441319495,
-0.0016608327,
0.0146739064,
0.0288293865,
-0.0250424258,
-0.0286382399,
0.0177416634,
0.0082678879,
-0.0226924475,
-0.0851032734,
-0.0496840775,
0.0737192929,
0.0097985147,
0.0219913647,
-0.0079054302,
0.012935956,
-0.0784067363,
-0.048519019,
0.0093922364,
-0.051143501,
-0.0004262476,
0.0659107417,
-0.0265853927,
-0.047469914,
0.0420230068,
0.0406684577,
0.0177221932,
-0.0073251943,
0.0351794064,
-0.02670791,
0.045816794,
-0.0109329652,
0.0273483116,
-0.0340387151,
-0.0361820757,
-0.0301652588,
-0.0261847097,
0.0325638317,
-0.0295296684,
0.0476296879,
-0.013235095,
-0.0011213676,
-0.0231040642,
-0.0550382547,
-0.0174227711,
-0.0069822394,
-0.0114679793,
-0.0312172249,
0.0038375577,
0.0198400766,
0.0585636534,
-0.0054480876,
0.0351283513,
-0.0629406646,
-0.0356736332,
0.035381157,
0.0045323442,
-0.0682764724,
-0.0024801381,
-0.0101288948,
0.0678988993,
-0.0498101413,
0.0696436614,
0.0354598537,
-0.0321574323,
-0.0238532759,
0.0778259709,
0.0509980805,
0.0493272245,
0.0526592024,
-0.0273650214,
0.0272092745,
0.0558016934,
0.0236497372,
0.03579228,
0.0824336112,
0.030800892,
-0.02040001,
-0.0069987457,
-0.0632286146,
-0.0339117385,
0.031927377,
0.0097608883,
-0.0772782639,
0.0179175679,
0.0117406417,
-0.0468221121,
-0.089090921,
-0.0369293876,
-0.0051738094,
-0.0617798604,
0.0231593959,
0.0409899764,
-0.0204196218,
-0.0219606087,
0.0158699658,
-0.0271915477,
0.0303434357,
0.065795593,
0.0354830958,
-0.0037891546,
-0.0372079052,
0.0021135835,
0.0258461162,
0.0185539387,
0.0655937493,
0.0130067058,
0.0259543303,
0.0235679727,
0.0411134697,
-0.0352556184,
-0.0400816761,
0.0207443144,
0.0507672504,
-0.0168229546,
0.0095028784,
-0.0331698023,
-0.0053966814,
-0.0089600766,
-0.0787570477,
-0.00060219,
0.0372670516,
-0.0205025785,
0.0120293824,
0.0488499105,
0.007755944,
-0.0523044355,
0.0289470702,
0.0172632057,
-0.043128252,
0.0338280685,
0.007290076,
-0.0305259619,
0.0111334985,
-0.0251080059,
-0.0685988069,
-0.0155538339,
-0.0791399479,
0.0131998798,
-0.0239152126,
-0.0405816026,
-0.0368252732,
-0.0734635219,
-0.0340943374,
-0.0314680748,
0.0523861758,
-0.0411334634,
0.0209643915,
-0.0122115975,
-0.0337520987,
-0.0163118411,
-0.0092771966,
-0.0108031379,
-0.0290061552,
0.0707038492,
0.0083900392,
-0.0422314741,
0.0049185446,
-0.0374156013,
-0.0007195362,
-0.016589772,
0.0244848523,
0.0093299439,
0.0079182871,
-0.045371145,
0.015892474,
-0.0015999835,
-0.012774203,
-0.0014946992,
-0.0501507148,
0.0626330376,
0.0115422802,
0.0602515675,
0.0034487743,
0.0192415603,
0.0152380504,
0.0477096438,
0.0302124005,
-0.0304856617,
0.0116553102,
0.0008233869,
0.0394444354,
0.0472673289,
-0.0470687784,
0.0137729989,
0.0019678348,
-0.0679002851,
-0.0426921546,
-0.0481211804,
-0.043413721,
-0.0305598956,
-0.02364856,
0.0315129459,
-0.0070064398,
0.0231418926,
-0.0008610126,
-0.0410048477,
-0.0235452615,
0.010156122,
0.0354278721,
0.0082608014,
0.0486790426,
-0.0155680962,
0.0205150452,
-0.0275402814,
-0.0009997652,
-0.0296984911,
0.0401413031,
-0.0169498324,
0.1082575917,
-0.0190554671,
-0.0133525524,
0.0283756107,
0.0055658901,
-0.0319452398,
-0.0415310562,
0.0079187639,
-0.0028866446,
-0.0122263124,
0.0032858194,
0.0158750694,
-0.0162890106,
0.0104353698,
-0.0400730446,
0.0332240947,
-0.0070650312,
-0.0501823649,
0.0076131294,
-0.0115665849,
-0.0260422789,
-0.0221627001,
0.0293358248,
-0.0615891069,
-0.0205319133,
0.009795527,
-0.0078312261,
-0.0011158015,
-0.0463187099,
0.0209726021,
-0.0575021505,
0.0058039404,
0.0055950163,
-0.0730009302,
-0.0479603,
-0.0537758954,
-0.0015728972,
-0.0143583519,
-0.0247847494,
-0.0396739691,
0.0849594027,
-0.0175122265,
0.0301723648,
-0.0411906727,
0.0173601005,
-0.0151980547,
0.021840401,
-0.0156106893,
-5.186775518e-33,
-0.0171130411,
-0.0314105414,
0.0078177936,
-0.0566756055,
0.0064232592,
-0.0279108789,
0.001248956,
0.0418851972,
-0.0516911,
0.0345458239,
-0.0067207539,
0.0083983317,
0.006921974,
-0.0432280004,
0.0112096686,
-0.0244658999,
-0.0216023922,
0.0148952417,
-0.0166539904,
-0.0080775367,
-0.003274455,
-0.0151382098,
0.0758245587,
-0.0394392833,
0.078206569,
-0.0019040429,
-0.0020861793,
-0.0331740007,
-0.0283694733,
0.0047546108,
-0.0217655879,
0.0151793752,
0.0306004714,
-0.0010149045,
0.0012533069,
0.0210800879,
0.0122731822,
-0.0204848498,
0.0852249712,
-0.0159100834,
-0.0152950874,
-0.0678925887,
-0.0071898135,
-0.0148667647,
-0.0364590883,
0.0008271295,
0.0270665977,
-0.0074003013,
0.0260208324,
0.005511269,
-0.0662322268,
-0.0049105398,
-0.0284565613,
0.0169205051,
-0.0666798577,
0.0647683442,
-0.037887048,
0.0294854622,
0.0209797937,
0.0446222238,
-0.0028133926,
-0.0001489315,
0.0143637536,
-0.0393950827,
0.0078336131,
0.0779637247,
0.0043152687,
0.024564568,
-0.0077587343,
-0.0118964743,
0.0201700944,
0.0181560125,
0.0156732928,
0.0823590606,
-0.0294235367,
-0.0851091295,
-0.0480242558,
-0.0383972973,
0.0672448501,
-0.0044295681,
0.0156553518,
-0.0188089348,
-0.0245504137,
-0.0161179435,
-0.0085619465,
-0.0230658203,
-0.0213575382,
-0.0360357687,
0.0332072899,
-0.0483822227,
0.0117052188,
-0.0562011003,
0.0446393155,
-0.0093018888,
0.0166909099,
0.0089843702,
-0.0393039361,
0.0050303629,
0.0048341895,
0.0516398512,
-0.0282559767,
-0.0284206644,
-0.0374957286,
-0.0006914994,
0.037648093,
-0.0065131858,
0.0352611095,
-0.0258737113,
-0.0235119816,
-0.0033831997,
-0.0233688578,
0.0107291825,
0.0419037901,
0.0077487356,
-0.001088615,
0.0289103203,
0.0050686295,
-0.0377498493,
0.0344816782,
-0.0419228487,
-0.0549746826,
-0.0344178416,
-0.0290814247,
0.0564713031,
-0.0376322828,
0.0073668635,
-0.0339395665,
0.0842034668,
0.0193380527,
-0.0516873524,
-0.0276477411,
0.0384364128,
2.456e-7,
-0.009317643,
-0.002891016,
-0.0190159436,
0.0135683101,
-0.0190572217,
0.0394467041,
0.025295049,
0.0034337835,
0.0809052959,
-0.0094927521,
-0.0272815712,
0.0154675543,
0.0573186688,
0.0233628824,
-0.0078434609,
0.0272920001,
-0.0208201818,
-0.0482692495,
-0.0164455324,
0.0411415584,
0.0155011807,
0.0416563861,
-0.0147397229,
-0.0062330393,
-0.0198002569,
0.0112209888,
0.0376387462,
-0.0502918214,
-0.0627131015,
0.0091803418,
-0.0238410514,
-0.0098822499,
0.0233010575,
0.0505083278,
0.0322167985,
-0.0252564009,
0.0433284193,
0.0584952533,
0.0195228457,
0.0041710911,
0.0038735184,
-0.0254763104,
-0.0352548398,
-0.0270659849,
0.0945556015,
0.0121271843,
-0.0453839526,
0.0062323785,
0.0425945707,
-0.0275864322,
0.024169337,
-0.0228824057,
-0.0166446324,
0.036912661,
0.0238701925,
-0.0191261247,
0.0458639972,
-0.002768361,
-0.0043705497,
-0.0128925275,
0.0230108239,
-0.0852395147,
-0.0225304831,
0.0339309461,
0.0437811986,
-0.0508774258,
0.0042080777,
1.784433485e-34,
0.0318521969,
-0.0278109163,
0.0577481873,
0.009972454,
0.0656979904,
0.0414264798,
-0.0111965518,
0.0136363069,
0.0069380193,
-0.0089393416,
-0.0027357945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02130v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02130v4 | GITA: Graph to Visual and Textual Integration for Vision-Language Graph Reasoning | 2024-02-03T12:19:47 | 2024-05-24T06:58:05 | Yanbin Wei, Shuai Fu, Weisen Jiang, Zejian Zhang, Zhixiong Zeng, Qi Wu, James T. Kwok, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used for various tasks with
graph structures. Though LLMs can process graph information in a textual
format, they overlook the rich vision modality, which is an intuitive way for
humans to comprehend structural information and conduct general graph
reasoning. The potential benefits and capabilities of representing graph
structures as visual images (i.e., $\textit{visual graph}$) are still
unexplored. To fill the gap, we innovatively propose an end-to-end framework,
called $\textbf{G}$raph to v$\textbf{I}$sual and $\textbf{T}$extual
Integr$\textbf{A}$tion (GITA), which firstly incorporates visual graphs into
general graph reasoning. Besides, we establish $\textbf{G}$raph-based
$\textbf{V}$ision-$\textbf{L}$anguage $\textbf{Q}$uestion $\textbf{A}$nswering
(GVLQA) dataset from existing graph data, which is the first vision-language
dataset for general graph reasoning purposes. Extensive experiments on the
GVLQA dataset and five real-world datasets show that GITA outperforms
mainstream LLMs in terms of general graph reasoning capabilities. Moreover, We
highlight the effectiveness of the layout augmentation on visual graphs and
pretraining on the GVLQA dataset. | [
0.0170537215,
0.0310738888,
-0.0041769049,
0.044279974,
-0.0439703427,
0.0184687637,
-0.0241100751,
0.0072575859,
0.067459859,
-0.0175090935,
-0.0063891588,
-0.0273276083,
0.0255264323,
0.0496503226,
0.041116938,
-0.04968898,
0.0149989463,
-0.0425199196,
0.0101539716,
-0.0013081082,
0.0137022063,
0.0233269911,
0.0045460793,
-0.0026571928,
-0.0337888487,
-0.0254495703,
-0.0241514966,
0.0273444057,
0.0111828567,
-0.0437299311,
-0.0908493847,
0.0070139319,
0.064918831,
0.0278126057,
0.0000018556,
0.0098711029,
0.0090406137,
-0.0037151347,
-0.0189959835,
-0.0213846155,
0.0147958742,
-0.0721578896,
0.0330735557,
-0.0174349379,
-0.0481584892,
-0.0375545211,
0.0768220574,
0.024976315,
0.0646497309,
0.050253287,
-0.0393387675,
-0.0497742631,
0.0209438298,
-0.0179080497,
0.0181085207,
-0.0062101819,
0.0212520231,
0.0587274134,
0.0339600332,
-0.0223329756,
-0.073892355,
0.0408748575,
0.0333559513,
-0.0415349565,
0.0227420237,
0.0511301234,
-0.0290114824,
-0.0253483001,
-0.0073531521,
0.1152718365,
-0.0013997044,
-0.029956609,
-0.0029567103,
0.0021358421,
-0.0153126465,
0.0122399572,
-0.0455555022,
0.0016992697,
-0.0274629369,
0.0184504725,
-0.032182049,
-0.0539802797,
0.036624264,
-0.0257488918,
-0.0082583232,
0.0630879253,
0.0136008905,
0.0171924047,
0.0199366249,
0.0220579468,
-0.0511104576,
-0.0389689282,
-0.0245416164,
0.0500420071,
-0.0053913286,
0.0164896064,
-0.0342576578,
-0.0128822094,
-0.0410919785,
-0.0084337117,
0.0339411758,
0.0247319844,
-0.0268848017,
0.0466954783,
-0.0327717587,
0.0776630268,
-0.0356243812,
0.1027994528,
-0.0339835808,
-0.0124818096,
-0.0336212255,
-0.0102333017,
-0.0578455441,
0.0006092404,
-0.0179915745,
-0.0658983067,
-0.0312758647,
0.039931085,
-0.0181595758,
0.0146093303,
0.027548166,
0.0135083711,
0.0013895257,
-0.0330515578,
-0.0009457124,
0.0165813323,
0.0224681385,
0.0127211735,
-0.0550474711,
-0.013824611,
0.0075747385,
0.0446650498,
0.0318240933,
-0.0301598907,
-0.000055183,
0.086586535,
-0.0044850139,
-0.0104725584,
-0.0329768509,
0.0011148555,
0.0048681456,
-0.0581032299,
0.045485355,
-0.0795073286,
0.0348825566,
-0.0055950624,
-0.0083960313,
-0.0309392624,
0.0132965874,
-0.0048751798,
-0.049817428,
0.0826689377,
-0.0281598698,
0.0103044668,
-0.0136671802,
-0.0216460023,
0.0116060246,
0.0418513156,
0.0390240736,
0.0182084665,
-0.0035374858,
0.0042161923,
-0.0159923006,
0.0396090485,
0.0173941385,
-0.0101376045,
-0.0419380516,
0.0026228058,
-0.0370646045,
-0.0007815712,
0.0073584751,
0.0765361786,
-0.0438498259,
-0.0442306064,
0.0345662124,
0.0287494604,
0.0240281299,
-0.0300240126,
0.0154667655,
-0.0074132974,
0.0121752312,
0.0102613866,
-0.082054995,
0.051013194,
0.027648937,
0.0365878455,
-0.0508194417,
-0.0198424123,
0.0014618024,
-0.0226490367,
-0.0185196549,
0.011367932,
0.0558415316,
-0.0094593791,
0.0657235011,
0.0285489745,
-0.0349459946,
-0.0320606083,
0.0100598689,
-0.0061982623,
0.000445424,
0.0083709639,
0.0032235514,
0.0518796258,
0.0390042774,
0.0103911916,
-0.0060874368,
0.0149708092,
0.0054670912,
0.0082320552,
0.0209357794,
-0.0103973551,
-0.018098997,
-0.0513754748,
-0.0297124423,
-0.0003216205,
-0.0279898252,
0.0244852137,
0.0084292423,
-0.0034921682,
-0.0003145743,
-0.0872169435,
-0.0173608251,
0.0179859698,
0.0611980222,
0.035642378,
-0.0580218397,
0.0231425203,
-0.0180869754,
-0.0033444327,
-0.0058650812,
0.0191116408,
-0.0120870462,
-0.017569907,
0.0125159621,
0.0255976524,
-0.0098619182,
-0.0559077561,
0.0578822494,
-0.0352943502,
-0.0488701724,
-0.0066792406,
-0.0428905152,
-0.0351696424,
0.0230964739,
-0.0543294922,
0.0178044159,
-0.017010713,
-0.0200405531,
0.0156640876,
-0.0073469784,
0.003193337,
0.0762468576,
0.0279760789,
-0.0323735997,
0.0000507696,
0.0330273435,
0.0035863779,
-0.0474706106,
0.0058177286,
0.0429441966,
0.0188217647,
-0.0050465199,
-0.0385145396,
-0.0114441151,
-0.0543079413,
0.053680703,
-0.0806902498,
-0.0248181801,
0.0090179285,
0.0109023601,
-0.0066796271,
-0.0092206104,
0.0036584083,
-0.0343385451,
-0.046463538,
0.065253064,
0.0284503326,
0.0199191216,
0.0250621419,
-0.0221303683,
-0.0116735948,
-0.0131822871,
-0.0382496864,
-0.0454772711,
0.0778936148,
0.0578933619,
-0.0507829227,
0.0132662561,
0.0289223194,
-0.0355532169,
0.0340015776,
-0.018321922,
-0.0180299729,
0.0187707562,
-0.0234029945,
0.0528241433,
0.0606684573,
-0.0500212647,
-0.0049762861,
0.0155652901,
-0.0160226692,
-0.0038791264,
0.0089003984,
0.001798679,
-0.0034861853,
-0.0212411378,
-0.0088257557,
-0.0778775141,
-0.0058592795,
-0.0245449319,
0.0124012874,
-0.0543681383,
-0.0112573756,
-0.0076765632,
0.0140593499,
-0.0262095779,
-0.032514248,
0.0159888007,
0.0320370682,
-0.06196668,
-0.0395079069,
0.070805639,
-0.0405814461,
-0.0311660022,
0.0564509965,
0.0164460354,
-0.0598228648,
0.092013903,
0.0757188573,
0.0075066965,
-0.0188759286,
-0.0229564086,
-0.0667630956,
-0.013999261,
0.0189359654,
-0.0008083325,
0.0334896259,
-0.0436544828,
0.0547496416,
-0.0320570767,
0.0102248946,
-0.0130043365,
0.049398642,
-0.0582618974,
0.0120226769,
-0.0329413004,
-0.0375255831,
0.0187137276,
0.0399761796,
0.0033196772,
-0.0251530353,
-0.0249950103,
0.0139842052,
-0.0264816079,
0.049188491,
0.0443516187,
-0.00324382,
-0.007585281,
-0.0351471566,
0.0027549288,
0.0616094358,
0.001944857,
-0.0242999475,
-0.0450685546,
0.0497888476,
0.0022287411,
0.0620687306,
-0.0255567729,
-0.0309437867,
0.0327797569,
-0.0482493266,
0.0034263944,
0.0342436396,
0.0036759623,
-0.0351861939,
-0.0263137128,
0.0228816699,
0.0650771633,
0.0460093617,
0.0374738798,
-0.1129917204,
-0.0237792991,
-0.0003326626,
-0.0260089245,
0.0424972698,
-0.0440812856,
-0.0392024368,
-0.0892201662,
0.0519887172,
0.04424043,
-0.001116556,
-0.0512684435,
-0.0059251147,
0.0106394747,
0.0092189489,
-0.0452236123,
-0.0189106632,
-0.0279170778,
0.0195211861,
0.0015212038,
-0.0053718416,
0.0434076563,
-0.0154265044,
-0.0081510907,
-0.0277902689,
-0.0278674867,
0.0168845039,
0.0199516565,
-0.0441850014,
0.0572820455,
0.0333259925,
-0.0096022915,
-0.0197140817,
0.0393820442,
0.0078033917,
-0.0425024815,
-0.0202221479,
0.010734763,
-0.0280365832,
-0.047147505,
-0.06271182,
0.0864133164,
0.0027847697,
-0.0091757076,
-0.0066393074,
-0.0045386255,
-0.0468999855,
-0.0072837053,
0.0578534901,
0.0293455031,
-0.0838934779,
-0.0424760245,
0.024099607,
-0.0562857129,
-0.062328063,
0.0461634882,
-0.003594944,
-0.0065566814,
-0.016580753,
-0.0020847314,
0.0509771071,
0.066735141,
-0.0064484198,
-0.0311345793,
0.0233614072,
-0.0230615754,
-0.0645080134,
0.0300589874,
-0.0448531434,
0.0703083351,
-0.0103845894,
0.0088731134,
-0.0256851427,
-0.0146365389,
-0.0050021252,
0.0159891341,
-0.0516560227,
-0.0609656647,
-0.0414351746,
0.0161233358,
0.0214531422,
0.0479912981,
-0.0053002588,
-0.0038080947,
0.0257456172,
0.0158704072,
0.0312879868,
0.0086431298,
0.0025056503,
-0.0420976691,
0.0041148802,
0.0179629494,
-0.0220745038,
-0.000501037,
0.0263103023,
0.0377078168,
-0.0099346638,
0.0108437343,
0.0013745798,
0.0675820038,
0.0015029033,
0.0279468093,
0.0396278352,
-0.0504108295,
-0.0167064015,
-0.0236543342,
-0.0224260539,
-0.0452096015,
-0.0129728504,
0.0419691242,
0.0247501191,
0.0123031307,
-0.0478559062,
0.0247646123,
0.0283555444,
0.0084432326,
0.0005402603,
0.0310303029,
-0.0347699001,
0.0536826476,
0.0197088569,
0.0146975648,
0.0054003652,
-0.0178270191,
0.0235424936,
0.0012958995,
0.0172684267,
0.0337772369,
-0.060164731,
-0.0380297042,
0.0019762164,
-0.0339453109,
-0.0687927529,
0.0205244068,
0.0242718197,
0.0493687689,
0.0251594651,
0.0240514483,
-0.0090596117,
0.0026326245,
0.0260996334,
0.056996502,
0.0025007904,
-0.0620584413,
0.0843053535,
0.0376339667,
0.0043825652,
-0.0163331218,
0.0290949456,
0.056507308,
0.0010073424,
-0.0063027078,
-0.036738582,
-0.002447834,
-0.0471289866,
-0.0085108764,
0.0055595897,
0.0065763569,
0.0247479882,
-0.0471473038,
-0.1197076663,
-0.0087184329,
0.0342300534,
-0.0145973768,
0.0428241044,
0.0218113605,
-0.0002442251,
0.0637416393,
-0.0332867727,
-0.0030809327,
0.031294737,
-0.028178541,
-0.0033574095,
0.0232426804,
-5.291780592e-33,
-0.027226733,
-0.0679321364,
0.0365306996,
0.0204899851,
-0.0659202859,
0.0143644437,
-0.0482417196,
-0.0003180559,
-0.0409876369,
0.0340376981,
0.0079727499,
0.0237100441,
-0.0002951547,
0.026898656,
-0.0395532399,
0.0038815308,
0.0055694599,
0.008953711,
-0.0019590633,
0.0166975837,
0.0064692413,
0.0048429957,
0.0478160232,
-0.0574025884,
-0.0156704355,
0.0111957546,
0.0080880877,
0.0489548407,
-0.0053248857,
0.0443116203,
-0.0259105172,
0.0041327621,
0.0289123096,
0.0276636519,
-0.0139865316,
0.0496011786,
-0.0787811503,
-0.0311400238,
0.0590524226,
0.0581798553,
-0.0857022777,
0.0087468633,
0.0406951457,
-0.0380056687,
0.037971478,
-0.0586985685,
0.0409260131,
-0.0211811829,
-0.0344746411,
0.0639846176,
-0.0276401732,
0.0129002687,
-0.0048336606,
0.0103476075,
0.0627694279,
0.0047196248,
0.0207257774,
0.0290265754,
-0.0388637967,
0.0321252123,
-0.0610708036,
-0.0325013809,
0.0602194108,
0.044226665,
0.0238736719,
0.0338013507,
0.0240198597,
-0.041972965,
-0.0431443229,
0.0138408123,
-0.0064267381,
0.0892585665,
0.0081411861,
0.0023009821,
-0.037457183,
0.0028922688,
-0.0615600757,
-0.0219703354,
-0.0633038059,
0.0776324347,
-0.0319355205,
0.0312971883,
-0.0111320307,
-0.0499295481,
0.012352095,
-0.0347414203,
-0.0477694683,
-0.0004541556,
0.0185478739,
-0.0127104903,
-0.0046473709,
0.0533323735,
0.020773543,
-0.0454810001,
-0.012672618,
0.0852849558,
-0.0279844813,
0.0691377819,
-0.0127970511,
0.0496581495,
-0.0301846005,
-0.0294640455,
0.0274452288,
0.0057885298,
0.0044916105,
-0.0048329965,
0.072232984,
0.019371694,
-0.0288181137,
0.0061135851,
-0.0669224411,
-0.0378333554,
-0.0055795358,
-0.0179457329,
0.0518418215,
0.0403593071,
-0.0283171721,
0.031908907,
0.0123248072,
0.0051856311,
-0.0312112495,
0.02134775,
-0.012820296,
0.0367547423,
-0.0095259054,
-0.0207670853,
-0.0278680567,
0.0097849742,
0.0311585721,
-0.0616836473,
-0.0232311673,
0.0152051188,
2.581e-7,
0.0515177064,
0.0233472008,
0.0614845417,
0.0308119692,
0.0262442306,
0.0265578441,
-0.0446297005,
-0.0052090907,
-0.0030084527,
-0.0191277601,
0.0300840437,
0.070823893,
-0.0155735137,
0.0208601188,
0.0060996846,
0.0624913573,
-0.0505763739,
-0.045779556,
-0.054084558,
0.0166513845,
0.0761373863,
0.0229228362,
0.0105754118,
-0.0284524895,
-0.0093124351,
-0.0785251409,
0.0593666993,
0.0035386565,
0.0121732512,
-0.0278623588,
-0.0304061249,
0.0190807432,
-0.0293427706,
0.0300959963,
0.0177044012,
-0.0002976471,
0.0315504447,
-0.005289345,
-0.0314038396,
0.0275844485,
-0.0147040784,
-0.0161988698,
-0.0137929162,
-0.0518992692,
0.0761380419,
-0.0476448014,
-0.0455746949,
0.0039309012,
-0.0470677242,
-0.0069502043,
-0.0178743098,
0.0407165512,
-0.0033337728,
0.0241017137,
0.044177819,
-0.0398059338,
-0.0166349951,
-0.0436783843,
-0.015928058,
0.0019860521,
-0.0164483283,
-0.0133025367,
-0.0505485013,
0.0440958068,
0.0161961094,
0.0320595428,
-0.0262222644,
2.039661778e-34,
0.0292599685,
0.0082589705,
0.0177922081,
0.001320845,
0.0392122194,
-0.0364828482,
0.0068292767,
0.0191942453,
0.0081960931,
-0.1041310281,
-0.0189297535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02113v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02113v1 | Zero-shot Sentiment Analysis in Low-Resource Languages Using a Multilingual Sentiment Lexicon | 2024-02-03T10:41:05 | 2024-02-03T10:41:05 | Fajri Koto, Tilman Beck, Zeerak Talat, Iryna Gurevych, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Improving multilingual language models capabilities in low-resource languages
is generally difficult due to the scarcity of large-scale data in those
languages. In this paper, we relax the reliance on texts in low-resource
languages by using multilingual lexicons in pretraining to enhance multilingual
capabilities. Specifically, we focus on zero-shot sentiment analysis tasks
across 34 languages, including 6 high/medium-resource languages, 25
low-resource languages, and 3 code-switching datasets. We demonstrate that
pretraining using multilingual lexicons, without using any sentence-level
sentiment data, achieves superior zero-shot performance compared to models
fine-tuned on English sentiment datasets, and large language models like
GPT--3.5, BLOOMZ, and XGLM. These findings are observable for unseen
low-resource languages to code-mixed scenarios involving high-resource
languages. | [
-0.0260943864,
0.0924429744,
0.0112083172,
0.0748434141,
-0.0396339893,
0.0245201197,
-0.0046708798,
0.0076022022,
-0.0193518866,
-0.0542757399,
-0.0484618992,
-0.039035216,
-0.0227915868,
-0.0092845419,
-0.0026321758,
-0.0182582717,
0.0267543346,
0.0193439387,
0.0137167023,
-0.0248744953,
0.0355113335,
0.0329916328,
0.0121444035,
-0.006776257,
-0.0250636786,
-0.01558288,
0.0248683318,
0.0073882793,
0.012016152,
-0.0361827798,
0.0140908677,
0.028949799,
-0.0109580318,
0.0237931181,
0.0000019015,
-0.0110570816,
0.0105263125,
-0.0194002837,
0.0285810586,
-0.0108609051,
0.1037925258,
-0.0815729648,
-0.011249776,
-0.0088646412,
-0.0287388936,
-0.036336571,
0.0652566776,
0.0060406975,
0.0299544521,
0.0828141421,
-0.0404400714,
-0.0276285671,
-0.0374826677,
-0.0121626882,
0.0172760636,
-0.0036876407,
-0.0049310247,
-0.0382876433,
-0.0156625193,
-0.0081522902,
-0.0296398848,
0.0173315499,
-0.0068170917,
0.0272983946,
-0.0354926996,
-0.0028718472,
-0.0507367291,
-0.0251886062,
-0.0073546986,
0.0525214337,
-0.0535694659,
-0.0164355692,
-0.0403213836,
-0.0287210234,
-0.0355167836,
-0.0677503347,
-0.0145399245,
0.0049969801,
0.0370216928,
0.042959474,
0.0193214845,
0.0246370826,
0.021386819,
0.0106938919,
-0.0322238356,
0.0413894765,
0.0047962302,
-0.0207709428,
0.0203805976,
0.0712031797,
0.0257828236,
-0.0119219767,
-0.0403715409,
-0.0115616722,
0.0072472212,
0.0277398489,
-0.0159917977,
-0.0339709036,
0.0220934488,
-0.0636835769,
0.0263215639,
0.0315617807,
-0.0494565591,
0.0223371387,
-0.0217285957,
-0.0261966921,
0.0072684316,
-0.0328644924,
-0.0117393648,
-0.0458750762,
-0.0358051099,
0.0287040062,
-0.0009871277,
0.0089685339,
-0.0224646758,
0.0097570773,
-0.0505848564,
-0.0029470362,
0.0035735751,
-0.0079693208,
-0.01026126,
-0.0266820751,
-0.0129770348,
0.0001783707,
0.0128852464,
0.0822764784,
-0.0528700612,
0.0035319142,
-0.0355971493,
-0.0820178539,
-0.0138524184,
0.0346501619,
0.0028905368,
-0.0434817411,
0.0392794758,
0.0459074974,
0.0174280684,
-0.039940618,
-0.0378667116,
-0.0075166114,
-0.0069247996,
-0.0898422748,
0.0048714136,
-0.0728273019,
0.032409735,
0.0222855154,
0.0359497927,
0.0125702918,
-0.0000204011,
-0.0157226603,
-0.0440513976,
0.0778940246,
-0.0387515239,
-0.0379425026,
-0.0731040761,
-0.0129372748,
0.0431988128,
0.1149516329,
-0.0371881947,
0.0027813457,
0.0481739566,
0.0114012174,
-0.012262133,
0.0314986296,
0.0066747805,
0.0175734255,
-0.0416795537,
-0.0052494556,
-0.0099354638,
-0.0322728716,
0.0361990109,
-0.018622594,
-0.0283945352,
0.0118437726,
0.02874358,
0.0141141042,
-0.0097398991,
0.0306117609,
-0.0051555685,
-0.0106552206,
-0.0259966031,
-0.0087934416,
-0.0074656988,
0.0277610291,
-0.007443178,
0.0012893926,
-0.0003209417,
0.0382203199,
-0.0371714942,
-0.0213039406,
-0.0123790009,
-0.0553614348,
0.0163491592,
-0.0068813311,
0.0662890971,
0.0114087854,
-0.0401778892,
0.0130902063,
0.0613175072,
-0.0828488991,
-0.021181874,
-0.0060920459,
-0.0093697812,
0.054281123,
0.000389829,
-0.0193373393,
-0.0175295733,
-0.015668666,
0.0184580572,
0.0451722108,
0.0194427017,
0.0138677638,
0.0707291439,
-0.052811332,
0.0069652349,
-0.0262501389,
0.0132743502,
0.0548167601,
0.0010370262,
0.0612082854,
-0.0246472433,
0.0137401773,
-0.0253127385,
-0.0277208649,
0.0064388681,
-0.0009480119,
0.0293680448,
-0.0057023354,
0.0369223505,
0.043881312,
-0.0408723839,
-0.0298268944,
-0.0017900844,
-0.0505806766,
-0.0223257951,
0.0325499102,
0.0006511863,
-0.0734746233,
0.0238310695,
-0.0270460714,
-0.0208973829,
0.021787649,
-0.0385043845,
-0.028290879,
0.0589857325,
0.0304324795,
0.0603685863,
-0.0197557211,
-0.0196563266,
-0.0304381792,
0.0408866443,
0.0314368606,
0.0249234606,
0.0188234746,
0.027980214,
-0.0327957384,
-0.0181793347,
0.0402647927,
0.019564474,
-0.0720980316,
0.055365596,
0.0273744166,
0.0218976792,
0.0428730138,
0.0466913655,
0.0005140469,
-0.0086740684,
-0.1071893498,
-0.0158740599,
-0.0085953018,
0.0154576097,
-0.0092198206,
0.0304392464,
-0.0065532466,
-0.0015727394,
-0.0330845453,
0.0325347669,
0.005052974,
0.0418596752,
0.0421568751,
0.001094666,
0.0476184711,
-0.0316304788,
-0.0032252495,
0.0138912341,
0.0171534605,
-0.0007319821,
-0.0153491963,
0.0301413797,
0.031603802,
-0.0571485497,
0.0045006769,
0.005952572,
-0.068482697,
0.0036891571,
-0.0243952181,
0.0058593792,
0.0118227815,
-0.0495784357,
-0.0038067384,
0.0218961127,
-0.0155714368,
-0.0405952036,
0.0256956425,
-0.0104617868,
-0.0189074483,
-0.0086492272,
0.0155221419,
-0.0217033159,
0.0693942681,
-0.0017708581,
-0.0300614238,
-0.0520907789,
-0.005657794,
-0.0357028171,
-0.0049724383,
-0.004683685,
0.0450811908,
0.022740867,
0.0251851287,
0.0216113124,
-0.0188017301,
0.0494970605,
0.0015786404,
-0.0314011984,
-0.0702812821,
0.0043620453,
-0.0401080064,
0.0274647363,
-0.0303989816,
0.0272920169,
-0.0294478573,
0.0510936417,
-0.0039857472,
-0.0288578272,
-0.0230705477,
0.0121271815,
0.0342448689,
0.0189334955,
0.0217536576,
-0.014332572,
-0.0590237826,
0.0463322327,
-0.0279133264,
-0.0537231714,
-0.0132058533,
0.025457263,
-0.037728101,
0.0124636879,
-0.0128509365,
-0.0079252534,
-0.0093335267,
-0.0011054379,
-0.0288816243,
0.0349730998,
0.005271751,
0.0065983334,
-0.0770329237,
0.0186287183,
-0.0071417852,
-0.0090809688,
0.0373247899,
0.0068308502,
-0.0016853641,
-0.0055113849,
-0.0058869966,
0.029499799,
0.0249914825,
-0.0243242942,
-0.0639834255,
0.0247980356,
-0.0241932794,
0.0264030565,
0.0947282538,
0.0143113369,
-0.0834519491,
-0.0013712721,
-0.0148327956,
0.022276653,
0.0450336933,
0.0099469842,
-0.1128133908,
-0.0477244183,
-0.0504181348,
-0.0029481982,
-0.0105015207,
-0.020861201,
-0.0156739336,
-0.1403095722,
-0.0177076813,
0.0058177183,
-0.0373759642,
-0.0196283069,
-0.0342469215,
-0.0158169996,
-0.0332610644,
-0.0213385317,
-0.0782978982,
0.0254554544,
-0.0067609265,
-0.0248197969,
-0.0097331526,
-0.0478916951,
0.0435179323,
-0.0001842432,
0.0348315947,
0.042713467,
0.0734631643,
-0.0320321955,
0.0159390178,
0.0138886366,
-0.0155531745,
-0.0012571778,
-0.0544536598,
0.054894086,
-0.0304104332,
-0.0527618863,
0.0425486453,
-0.0273572356,
-0.068609342,
0.0172642525,
-0.0017217826,
0.0253333542,
0.0107208723,
-0.0320917629,
-0.0120483767,
0.0067476803,
0.0426925533,
0.0407047309,
-0.0009535867,
-0.0791399032,
-0.0182648879,
-0.0238076206,
-0.0204611663,
-0.0635122508,
-0.0299393591,
-0.0224784371,
-0.001621883,
-0.047732871,
-0.0355766937,
-0.0677805021,
0.0181125216,
0.0433714911,
-0.0286233909,
0.0087834913,
-0.0157440528,
0.0050479989,
-0.0286982004,
0.0135019394,
-0.0097703682,
0.0045943637,
-0.0235306956,
-0.0256910343,
0.0567636453,
0.0107159624,
0.0097337449,
-0.0269808453,
-0.037807554,
-0.0518101454,
-0.0313325599,
0.0689515173,
0.0090627037,
0.0355869196,
-0.0062022344,
-0.053639736,
0.025528295,
0.0624335818,
-0.0231385287,
0.0117005091,
0.0891321525,
0.0619025864,
0.013150366,
0.0495485812,
0.0026353151,
0.0676617622,
0.0246536732,
-0.0027648502,
-0.027635185,
-0.0151853226,
-0.0196651686,
-0.0078512579,
0.0584792346,
-0.019559389,
-0.0185864717,
-0.0229735151,
-0.0028340947,
-0.0309591237,
-0.0146752512,
-0.0468003377,
-0.0321235359,
0.0258557554,
-0.0211867355,
-0.0582508184,
0.0028797369,
-0.0329477787,
-0.0045517585,
-0.0155697213,
0.0554262288,
0.0690102503,
-0.0040657264,
0.0311115738,
0.0345635228,
0.0029790071,
0.0010769087,
-0.0069135143,
-0.0150274308,
-0.0330400057,
0.0236345455,
0.0093630515,
0.0086515164,
0.0230400506,
0.0083443848,
0.0157686155,
0.0231577661,
0.0096427044,
-0.0003421296,
0.0389159545,
-0.0173391476,
0.0774657801,
-0.0194836445,
0.0073433281,
-0.0008880647,
0.0158011429,
-0.0200197585,
-0.038410075,
0.0016013068,
-0.0017354705,
-0.041303616,
0.028337732,
0.0862960368,
-0.0388920195,
0.0383881144,
0.0425777584,
0.0480383076,
-0.014385486,
0.0165148079,
0.0772570372,
-0.0046731257,
0.0326335244,
0.0409168489,
-0.0691500232,
-0.0696715266,
0.050731618,
-0.0210885853,
-0.0047845384,
0.0163352918,
0.0180551372,
0.0601939447,
0.0157538801,
0.0799786448,
-0.0425068885,
-0.0043326397,
0.0013330481,
-0.0425949916,
0.0109322611,
-6.276106868e-33,
0.0177420899,
0.0183889009,
-0.0381235629,
-0.0103274742,
0.0256669074,
0.0281309504,
-0.0350141376,
0.0429418385,
-0.0167368595,
0.033573404,
-0.0098457783,
0.0269110128,
-0.000687497,
0.0357597247,
0.0607393496,
0.0083308453,
0.0373496376,
0.006340656,
-0.0062334691,
0.0282418765,
0.0467607118,
0.0257401261,
0.0848077759,
-0.0479074456,
0.0500473939,
-0.0334387347,
-0.0281662736,
-0.0054147691,
0.0775940195,
0.038130831,
-0.0139760338,
0.08913178,
0.0216631982,
-0.0003639733,
-0.0096676098,
-0.0000468326,
0.0053425157,
-0.0467924476,
0.0191002209,
0.0128408317,
0.0135904802,
-0.0108568938,
-0.0216622055,
-0.0001241534,
-0.0229947176,
0.0165880248,
-0.0027177907,
0.0000504144,
0.0168276317,
-0.0550413318,
-0.0821213275,
0.0179761052,
-0.0002380302,
-0.0014606311,
0.0538386554,
0.0868488997,
0.0072822669,
0.0522869751,
-0.0618142039,
0.0394677445,
-0.0505149886,
-0.00310267,
0.0253781844,
-0.0235583708,
-0.0058325147,
0.0574384145,
0.0239258911,
0.0239049774,
0.0233185701,
0.0815334693,
0.0406144336,
-0.0218341518,
0.0258801263,
0.1125686467,
0.0421753973,
-0.0297437515,
-0.0495502204,
-0.0199775193,
0.0398943424,
-0.0038860822,
0.0507938154,
0.0059243646,
-0.0098611042,
-0.0363586619,
0.0368058793,
-0.0537763722,
-0.0361124463,
-0.0209071618,
0.0010368488,
-0.0140715428,
-0.0102806157,
0.0137306955,
0.0453978404,
-0.0488208942,
-0.046753373,
0.0636710301,
-0.0325749405,
0.0270598996,
0.0075700548,
0.0282955803,
-0.0567741804,
-0.0212888028,
-0.0297930762,
0.0281266719,
0.023679575,
0.0053237318,
0.0760521516,
0.0540323742,
-0.0772246495,
-0.0252110735,
-0.029949829,
0.0208079033,
-0.0084665781,
0.072504431,
-0.0123821618,
0.0033275068,
-0.0062875962,
0.0799544826,
0.0354602709,
-0.0100808553,
0.0072053568,
-0.0181018189,
0.0024075375,
0.006903863,
-0.0447878726,
-0.0514822714,
-0.018116327,
-0.046597939,
0.009915527,
-0.0566079319,
-0.0110909054,
0.0031599584,
2.699e-7,
0.034446381,
0.0493070967,
-0.0447677299,
-0.0029613639,
0.0077930763,
0.0518220551,
-0.0206104126,
0.0215180404,
-0.029603662,
0.0123396544,
-0.0088315494,
0.0276605319,
0.0318195373,
0.0378051996,
-0.0983251259,
0.0083977999,
-0.0196002014,
0.0080543775,
-0.0415617526,
0.0238021854,
0.0493150726,
0.131267786,
0.0194270127,
0.0052103479,
-0.0034388441,
-0.0200249441,
0.0480104312,
-0.0166861396,
-0.0329489224,
-0.0042314995,
-0.0410636142,
0.0415872633,
-0.0314841755,
-0.0344673768,
-0.0078769373,
0.0160169452,
-0.0063738353,
0.0347018652,
-0.0097688651,
-0.0518393591,
0.0363995172,
-0.0015399827,
-0.0341128185,
-0.0093917996,
0.0541726723,
-0.0353224017,
-0.0399503857,
-0.0667346865,
0.022588769,
0.0302344281,
0.0914847851,
-0.0310022142,
-0.0502800271,
0.0195815284,
0.0343713053,
-0.0262119267,
-0.0711181462,
-0.0447694249,
-0.0089581413,
0.0147314714,
0.0336567461,
-0.0167217795,
0.0194595251,
0.0250302739,
0.028646253,
-0.0212621856,
0.0294604097,
2.074143481e-34,
0.062955752,
-0.0388927273,
0.0077148103,
0.0123009803,
0.012154527,
-0.0116062118,
-0.0439404361,
-0.018745048,
0.0069514937,
-0.009848753,
0.0182456002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02101v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02101v1 | Are Large Language Models Good Prompt Optimizers? | 2024-02-03T09:48:54 | 2024-02-03T09:48:54 | Ruotian Ma, Xiaolei Wang, Xin Zhou, Jian Li, Nan Du, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLM-based Automatic Prompt Optimization, which typically utilizes LLMs as
Prompt Optimizers to self-reflect and refine prompts, has shown promising
performance in recent studies. Despite the success, the underlying mechanism of
this approach remains unexplored, and the true effectiveness of LLMs as Prompt
Optimizers requires further validation. In this work, we conducted a
comprehensive study to uncover the actual mechanism of LLM-based Prompt
Optimization. Our findings reveal that the LLM optimizers struggle to identify
the true causes of errors during reflection, tending to be biased by their own
prior knowledge rather than genuinely reflecting on the errors. Furthermore,
even when the reflection is semantically valid, the LLM optimizers often fail
to generate appropriate prompts for the target models with a single prompt
refinement step, partly due to the unpredictable behaviors of the target
models. Based on the observations, we introduce a new "Automatic Behavior
Optimization" paradigm, which directly optimizes the target model's behavior in
a more controllable manner. We hope our study can inspire new directions for
automatic prompt optimization development. | [
0.0316644944,
0.0336356424,
-0.0251319297,
0.0498750769,
-0.033998549,
-0.0110595711,
0.0028158596,
0.0095763057,
-0.0043908758,
-0.02155561,
-0.0470330752,
-0.0200155769,
0.0134180794,
0.0053259926,
0.0084063169,
-0.0450169817,
0.0985154137,
-0.064349778,
-0.0285855122,
-0.0055538788,
-0.0362303518,
-0.0212987456,
0.0103223063,
0.0391044766,
0.0029362983,
-0.0321156494,
-0.0213931184,
0.0400595367,
-0.0202099718,
-0.0230133142,
0.0041359835,
0.0457779132,
-0.0145679768,
0.0297834128,
0.0000020976,
-0.0978052765,
-0.0189620685,
-0.0047439276,
-0.0466171578,
0.0591728278,
0.0386402979,
0.0126768434,
-0.0368004963,
0.0282172021,
0.0024261135,
0.0147922756,
0.0175205301,
-0.0019017151,
0.0563359261,
0.074226208,
0.0088951513,
0.0220222473,
0.0019823259,
-0.0023880515,
0.0022824444,
-0.0189129412,
0.0139878523,
-0.0585147254,
0.0168279782,
0.0271920078,
-0.0146023203,
0.0064753694,
-0.0115412194,
-0.0476446301,
-0.0394843854,
0.0038066905,
0.0205452479,
-0.0565639921,
-0.0509264879,
0.0281964727,
-0.0010614236,
-0.0098077813,
0.0124647599,
-0.0438206382,
0.0420162864,
0.0115493145,
-0.0073543112,
0.0467850789,
-0.0233529396,
-0.0132249817,
0.0063085733,
-0.0112124821,
0.0156755392,
-0.0114714215,
-0.0235616323,
0.096407488,
0.0241373815,
-0.0177136231,
0.0097097056,
-0.0290785711,
-0.0030767976,
-0.0760427266,
-0.0261276234,
0.0450569689,
-0.1095879599,
0.023681365,
-0.0300219655,
0.0061295456,
0.0382683314,
0.0430321135,
0.0561810844,
0.0716410279,
-0.023016423,
0.0032127101,
-0.0185186286,
0.0813534036,
-0.0060958765,
-0.0130159697,
-0.0275980365,
0.0488341786,
-0.0045754355,
-0.0093140164,
-0.0685001239,
0.0264363438,
-0.0161207952,
0.0279286262,
-0.0132439723,
0.0883039832,
0.0112874731,
0.0635440573,
-0.0169266518,
-0.0252963547,
-0.0259060804,
0.0017723731,
-0.0216971375,
0.0019651309,
-0.0208589844,
-0.0125007965,
0.017823644,
-0.0684247464,
-0.0020285209,
0.0066546737,
-0.0347677134,
-0.0067821564,
-0.0083467932,
0.0827109441,
-0.0052496661,
-0.0060891062,
-0.0117474711,
-0.0615673959,
-0.0140254376,
-0.0234459136,
-0.0367758907,
-0.0603115223,
-0.016665699,
0.0164937209,
-0.0163349118,
-0.0171814561,
-0.0078138718,
0.0007122534,
0.004429053,
0.0571279302,
-0.0412496999,
0.0311869606,
0.0171443429,
0.0090673426,
-0.0297229178,
0.0656816736,
0.0005184118,
0.0318589136,
0.0387704521,
-0.0172880013,
0.0072284183,
0.06929297,
-0.0024329796,
0.0239374973,
-0.0132669099,
-0.0068146139,
0.0527186394,
0.0265338495,
0.0398308486,
0.0389219671,
-0.0001061648,
0.0131425997,
0.0274020284,
0.0273306388,
-0.0125095434,
0.000721322,
0.0545905307,
0.0002426982,
-0.0003605664,
0.0400013439,
-0.0607879125,
-0.0191713441,
-0.0497113764,
0.0331258029,
-0.0175638944,
0.0245410521,
-0.0030996876,
-0.0480238944,
-0.0064313305,
0.0265551731,
-0.0463640243,
0.011398972,
-0.01312079,
0.0243118946,
-0.0597472265,
0.0513266958,
0.016466165,
-0.0312939398,
-0.0357552171,
-0.0757280141,
0.0416885279,
0.0529066287,
0.0365041383,
-0.0422632545,
-0.0527588353,
-0.006932836,
0.0224775486,
0.0200679954,
0.0850807056,
-0.0278313439,
-0.0181178078,
-0.0127274403,
-0.0322148316,
-0.0248054117,
0.0222218893,
0.0610995293,
-0.0039586737,
-0.0218535811,
0.0074719111,
0.0368223339,
-0.0118415672,
0.0329150669,
-0.0166002307,
-0.0144655388,
0.0133705018,
0.014101156,
0.0223482922,
-0.0007604667,
-0.0155234765,
0.0183637477,
0.0216012914,
0.0120054139,
0.0008664887,
-0.0136990575,
-0.0513926707,
-0.0512563623,
0.0386367589,
0.0297323875,
-0.0172841754,
-0.0076015429,
-0.0313356332,
-0.0443501584,
-0.0251589045,
-0.0390394665,
0.0199319273,
-0.0177818947,
0.0904678702,
-0.0424121469,
-0.0141012389,
-0.0628035963,
0.0364779308,
0.0071006771,
0.0157807413,
0.086687237,
0.0552602001,
0.0354656056,
-0.0570307933,
-0.0216628723,
0.0028851752,
-0.0252171177,
-0.0014800783,
0.0447573438,
0.033301089,
-0.0284427349,
-0.0487604886,
-0.0731811002,
0.0231985282,
-0.0215555448,
-0.0006332571,
0.0087978914,
0.0449946076,
-0.0476887785,
-0.0051972582,
0.0014272641,
-0.0010005919,
0.0236946084,
0.0454648025,
0.0590220615,
0.0061103241,
-0.0610153973,
-0.0403880626,
-0.0015984268,
-0.0321820416,
0.0077042868,
-0.0193703398,
-0.0177085642,
-0.0931802616,
0.0848605931,
-0.0011572009,
0.0233704839,
-0.0032323615,
-0.0049216924,
0.0185725018,
-0.004913955,
0.0472365879,
0.0505405255,
0.0055213822,
0.0034591807,
0.040088132,
-0.0057490501,
-0.0887951925,
0.0166752469,
0.0061035017,
-0.0468784273,
0.0009349731,
-0.0309709534,
0.0545455441,
0.0778191984,
0.0063014701,
-0.0123107359,
-0.0227526128,
0.0242168587,
0.0010593162,
-0.0338485129,
-0.0324351043,
-0.0540503561,
-0.0446672514,
0.0830025375,
0.0003365501,
-0.0666510686,
0.077123791,
-0.0560516529,
-0.0080167549,
-0.0016413173,
0.0195223466,
-0.0409008674,
0.0182825774,
-0.0139419818,
-0.0062264944,
0.042686455,
-0.0624758489,
-0.0415557362,
0.0009513246,
0.0538991131,
0.0043038172,
0.0515188873,
-0.0230730306,
-0.001473473,
-0.0263758525,
-0.054618258,
-0.0585243925,
-0.0741904899,
-0.0059717409,
-0.0183096919,
0.0024227656,
0.0182163604,
0.014534804,
-0.0020151674,
0.0064880927,
0.0329097174,
-0.03326983,
-0.0235083289,
-0.0390131772,
-0.0245081335,
0.0214078669,
-0.0057605682,
0.0194962863,
-0.0251486376,
0.0722315907,
0.0053602289,
0.0365662053,
-0.0022436201,
-0.0107565029,
0.0127983931,
0.0684695244,
-0.059464179,
-0.0656081587,
0.057978265,
0.0696221218,
-0.0574231632,
-0.0202706121,
0.1106889993,
0.0532519296,
-0.038745299,
0.0214877762,
-0.0724908933,
0.0492931865,
0.0477873012,
0.025654953,
-0.0610119924,
-0.0188290346,
0.0396696553,
0.0283356477,
-0.0221357085,
-0.0036678095,
-0.0100155836,
-0.1204925701,
0.0524894297,
-0.0156115051,
-0.0068791551,
0.0155704105,
-0.0331320576,
-0.0028839312,
0.028970249,
0.0486957282,
0.053354349,
-0.0416126847,
-0.0124870911,
0.0149987461,
-0.0299164951,
-0.0103422115,
0.0008292191,
-0.0264882613,
0.040638648,
0.0934400558,
-0.0217769649,
0.0126834605,
-0.0234708153,
0.0678599179,
-0.0039178459,
0.0424926952,
-0.0311244726,
-0.0023803487,
0.0253550541,
0.0029117838,
0.0104438812,
0.0066633993,
-0.0060285591,
-0.0348282419,
0.0320970081,
0.0498088524,
-0.0395146236,
0.0061054118,
0.0005155146,
-0.0015561602,
0.0168891922,
0.0538441911,
0.048481822,
-0.0283090379,
-0.040040236,
-0.0486819334,
-0.0347291045,
-0.0191024654,
-0.011511174,
0.0061036083,
-0.0020284739,
-0.0128609855,
-0.037391793,
-0.0327449068,
-0.003488159,
0.0407017469,
0.0162025541,
-0.0173771549,
-0.0594640039,
0.0009833985,
-0.0045921747,
0.0317621306,
-0.0267102625,
0.0253791343,
-0.0879266486,
0.0433970802,
0.0191020817,
-0.0352550969,
0.0000479497,
-0.0132660083,
-0.0254364423,
-0.0823674425,
-0.0095236842,
0.0714760274,
0.0259113535,
0.0576301962,
-0.0238148235,
-0.0502087213,
0.0420201607,
0.0326319672,
-0.0034983631,
0.0170085002,
0.0340420157,
0.0315841548,
-0.0244746264,
0.0226299353,
-0.0440409407,
-0.0098435478,
0.0184807964,
0.0167453494,
0.0087609468,
-0.0928438306,
0.0258405954,
0.0798920393,
0.0366837494,
-0.0317454785,
-0.0149618648,
-0.0227662027,
0.0205024593,
-0.0367732085,
-0.0300605651,
-0.0178587195,
0.0481363684,
-0.0019897306,
-0.031036336,
0.0227702018,
-0.0164751802,
-0.0591620021,
0.0397157967,
-0.0313062146,
0.0424951166,
-0.0159894805,
0.0138299465,
0.0587970503,
0.0159984827,
-0.0002537024,
0.0518192723,
0.0401428044,
0.0246828627,
-0.0116887279,
0.0677894056,
0.0313200653,
0.0350296535,
-0.0349446349,
0.0303571299,
-0.0392075591,
-0.0742456838,
0.0124206915,
0.04693323,
0.0568659864,
0.010286171,
0.0155681474,
-0.0163377933,
-0.0167736672,
-0.0058091274,
0.0033571541,
0.0564596169,
-0.0701763257,
0.0293420739,
0.0209377762,
-0.0246223286,
-0.0292195249,
0.0533579513,
-0.0373875499,
0.0454878807,
0.009878845,
-0.0068793157,
-0.0428654104,
-0.0001188555,
0.0215806458,
-0.0190888196,
-0.0345643759,
-0.0463341475,
-0.0691932961,
-0.0354473107,
0.0154172508,
0.0307743996,
-0.0114870807,
-0.0192891918,
0.0228749402,
0.0501874797,
0.0223418977,
-0.01912467,
-0.0324399136,
0.0053404253,
-0.0027255567,
-0.0254901424,
-0.0187176857,
-5.39656673e-33,
-0.050694555,
-0.0152405519,
0.0122990729,
0.0005042813,
-0.0215036776,
-0.0145797161,
-0.0386566222,
0.020796353,
0.0130441366,
-0.0172643214,
-0.064988181,
-0.0322674587,
0.0206482448,
-0.0371493325,
0.0211108588,
0.001880443,
0.0418191776,
0.00349635,
-0.101635471,
-0.0275296271,
-0.0168351755,
0.0204179771,
-0.0122053362,
0.0061826045,
0.0214752145,
0.0117992815,
-0.0112293866,
0.0476289988,
-0.0102271819,
0.041151017,
0.0071954415,
0.0250461064,
-0.0021043187,
-0.0609860569,
-0.047612939,
0.0500230715,
-0.0446647443,
-0.0754820555,
0.0419660583,
0.0226874556,
-0.0375283025,
-0.0587621517,
0.0022340294,
-0.0072889132,
-0.0464534611,
0.0417624824,
-0.0063647726,
-0.0085349567,
-0.0113150943,
-0.0097024953,
-0.0617135316,
-0.0079412153,
-0.0088628372,
-0.019661542,
0.0278651882,
0.031801343,
0.0218892358,
-0.0002304565,
0.00640867,
0.0165063348,
0.0316828527,
0.0393922888,
0.0824617371,
0.0423725359,
-0.0156216603,
0.017618496,
0.0365385413,
0.0473265611,
0.0110393725,
0.0065724254,
0.0162930954,
0.0180990342,
0.0252887849,
0.026730543,
-0.0344675072,
-0.0266227126,
-0.0091485595,
0.0533002056,
0.0533351414,
-0.000173762,
0.0109855374,
0.0138818314,
-0.0035056523,
-0.0360056534,
-0.0680053607,
0.0288731661,
-0.0395895354,
-0.0135986879,
0.0402281508,
-0.027616078,
-0.003342753,
-0.048977077,
0.0297012813,
-0.0181356184,
-0.0071211387,
-0.0040231524,
-0.0388446413,
0.0167300664,
-0.013448108,
0.0398687907,
0.0088065378,
-0.0349095203,
0.0060017053,
-0.0211390983,
0.0440372042,
0.0377946869,
-0.0147137372,
0.0244051125,
-0.0716157705,
0.0242787022,
-0.0367961824,
0.0320461877,
0.0010587769,
-0.0146881286,
0.0208243001,
-0.0343086049,
-0.0105150547,
0.0462823659,
0.0165280774,
-0.0354990251,
-0.0528080501,
0.0295531396,
-0.0082741324,
0.0238373261,
-0.0160471499,
0.0073662605,
-0.0061581498,
0.0622731261,
0.0256235879,
-0.0055406676,
-0.0360709056,
-0.00025288,
2.713e-7,
0.0270863418,
0.0404216461,
0.0249855909,
0.0762401372,
0.0063140118,
0.0396715552,
-0.029463293,
0.0100387046,
0.0310481675,
-0.0156944375,
0.0171100199,
-0.0184154678,
0.0218501426,
0.0001675915,
-0.08795169,
0.0064742742,
-0.0355115272,
0.0225380585,
-0.0672149286,
0.0103106769,
0.0058916621,
0.047727704,
-0.0219810456,
-0.0208711065,
-0.0090347761,
-0.0020622911,
0.0120567577,
-0.0512196459,
-0.01478511,
0.0716617256,
0.057537958,
-0.0417549238,
0.0072572143,
0.0260936152,
0.0090576448,
0.0090955049,
-0.0332033224,
0.0553575046,
0.0230620485,
-0.007682608,
0.0013517661,
-0.0131112197,
0.0060255877,
-0.0544135086,
0.0631723255,
-0.0119344415,
0.0013351267,
-0.0451026559,
0.0039565554,
-0.0519678295,
-0.0073392373,
-0.0371282957,
0.0200966988,
0.0470169969,
-0.0083252871,
0.0211542044,
-0.0234025493,
-0.029190084,
-0.0334544629,
-0.0106717851,
-0.0304599293,
-0.0667504147,
-0.0244907346,
0.021595506,
0.0016659563,
-0.101653859,
-0.0206462555,
3.071036159e-34,
0.0318435505,
-0.0322927274,
0.0456703492,
0.008377715,
0.0291405413,
0.0171798002,
-0.0163718294,
0.0522463843,
0.0450684391,
-0.0495586321,
-0.0495950244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02099v1 | Analyzing the Evaluation of Cross-Lingual Knowledge Transfer in Multilingual Language Models | 2024-02-03T09:41:52 | 2024-02-03T09:41:52 | Sara Rajaee, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in training multilingual language models on large datasets
seem to have shown promising results in knowledge transfer across languages and
achieve high performance on downstream tasks. However, we question to what
extent the current evaluation benchmarks and setups accurately measure
zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer. In this work, we challenge the
assumption that high zero-shot performance on target tasks reflects high
cross-lingual ability by introducing more challenging setups involving
instances with multiple languages. Through extensive experiments and analysis,
we show that the observed high performance of multilingual models can be
largely attributed to factors not requiring the transfer of actual linguistic
knowledge, such as task- and surface-level knowledge. More specifically, we
observe what has been transferred across languages is mostly data artifacts and
biases, especially for low-resource languages. Our findings highlight the
overlooked drawbacks of existing cross-lingual test data and evaluation setups,
calling for a more nuanced understanding of the cross-lingual capabilities of
multilingual models. | [
-0.0276803225,
0.0287025888,
-0.0231173001,
0.0649614185,
-0.0394324772,
0.0177458096,
0.0436730534,
-0.0211909488,
-0.0303257443,
-0.0381261632,
-0.077585496,
-0.0305743907,
0.0033965111,
-0.0142573453,
0.0310654659,
-0.039464362,
0.0539209358,
-0.0496166274,
-0.0312474705,
-0.0112311952,
-0.0210804828,
0.0075536794,
-0.0110256597,
-0.0019240804,
0.001480476,
-0.0071306364,
0.0312091373,
-0.0151566966,
0.0104285171,
0.0065093557,
-0.0200980436,
0.0306601524,
-0.0061096712,
0.0494077355,
0.0000018719,
-0.0483218879,
-0.0095802275,
0.0177041925,
-0.012783926,
0.0059906519,
0.0476939753,
-0.0743990541,
-0.0120384721,
-0.0165115483,
-0.0128576513,
-0.0368904099,
0.0546580032,
0.0274756346,
0.0100922557,
0.0678221658,
-0.0213633049,
0.0129542174,
0.0275276415,
-0.039756529,
0.0175457373,
-0.0584712885,
0.0230944268,
0.027496133,
-0.0391922295,
-0.0110377679,
-0.0455264077,
0.0393020324,
0.012142024,
0.0360140316,
-0.0401720442,
0.0378209092,
-0.033383552,
0.0131849917,
-0.0129912822,
0.0498118736,
-0.0621196814,
-0.0194499269,
-0.0320908464,
-0.0041095736,
-0.0120504713,
0.0037449999,
-0.0776313171,
0.0227813181,
0.0215552915,
-0.0043687066,
0.0368960723,
0.0006433228,
0.0523517393,
-0.0166672971,
-0.0145387566,
0.0573725291,
0.0372506939,
-0.0337178186,
0.0444189645,
0.0472602509,
0.0338378623,
-0.0372223519,
-0.0549170338,
-0.0045670578,
0.0134136379,
0.0304718427,
-0.0384446159,
-0.0356965251,
0.0129235629,
-0.0180321224,
0.0653256327,
0.0233275853,
-0.0254724603,
0.0565145202,
-0.0605523437,
0.0448293574,
-0.0025903529,
0.0390398279,
-0.0254591312,
-0.0733804554,
-0.0652050674,
0.0178027283,
-0.0044153659,
0.0152715985,
0.0074456721,
0.0006865929,
-0.0024792787,
-0.0219689477,
-0.0082289483,
-0.0285542626,
0.0029397393,
-0.0543118604,
-0.0387585424,
-0.0087836245,
0.01033518,
0.0737015307,
-0.0160435848,
0.0327649713,
-0.0085853953,
-0.0507538244,
-0.0145446425,
0.0222921669,
0.0026931826,
-0.075564757,
0.0142731583,
0.0768055096,
-0.0542528667,
-0.0159137622,
-0.0367344841,
0.0178897977,
-0.0086618122,
-0.086941503,
0.0438019931,
-0.062405128,
0.0605263598,
0.0111739645,
0.025532119,
-0.0199797638,
-0.021879578,
-0.0079567796,
-0.0567888282,
0.0514053442,
0.0182533935,
0.0007840063,
-0.0037666683,
-0.0123963989,
-0.0425111353,
0.0916305929,
0.011598764,
-0.0164738297,
0.0388262793,
-0.0084673334,
-0.0481646769,
0.0482023694,
0.0426249988,
0.0495524369,
-0.013982879,
-0.003605359,
0.0360354222,
0.0021152615,
0.0474516302,
0.0014355601,
-0.0316955186,
0.0287458822,
0.0534445904,
0.023633169,
0.028584728,
0.0117442226,
0.055134736,
-0.0304953028,
-0.0265137404,
-0.0066621602,
-0.0244115051,
0.0211709403,
0.0027225548,
-0.0071706641,
-0.011571954,
0.0486160778,
-0.0406085141,
0.0233811624,
0.0158035439,
-0.0305126235,
0.0154086165,
-0.0055934242,
0.0706744343,
0.0374699719,
-0.0179452561,
0.0628358051,
0.067890048,
-0.0434565395,
0.0210873466,
-0.014400675,
0.0009828516,
0.016268855,
-0.0107920878,
0.0211853478,
-0.0321248099,
0.0018612328,
0.0373305567,
0.0148894461,
0.0828892291,
-0.0146930972,
0.0572406352,
-0.0419919416,
-0.0107051199,
-0.0404496565,
0.0109106526,
0.0621093959,
-0.0127477348,
0.0720260665,
-0.0000965569,
-0.0496222414,
-0.0162448119,
0.0177753661,
-0.0878162086,
-0.0041511115,
-0.0046824985,
0.0209923238,
0.0078898361,
-0.0016394554,
-0.0042078285,
-0.0184464101,
-0.0114055621,
-0.0427561849,
-0.0158953909,
0.0315170176,
-0.0145589849,
-0.0473671183,
0.0127149289,
-0.0272313841,
-0.0064849742,
0.0264938213,
-0.0176071078,
-0.0359579399,
0.0438400768,
0.0392253734,
0.0346505605,
-0.0265097525,
-0.0014341298,
-0.0191186052,
0.0496928245,
0.0218332242,
0.0396951027,
0.025390733,
0.0191080514,
-0.0067135831,
-0.032880079,
0.0333644859,
-0.0052427584,
-0.0214722548,
0.0383380055,
-0.030175807,
0.0186100062,
0.0075571183,
0.0169673115,
-0.0093073677,
0.0072130337,
-0.0883805454,
0.0278649963,
-0.0215648916,
0.0313082933,
0.0204834118,
0.0122174788,
-0.0093208514,
-0.0004519357,
-0.0444003008,
0.0081429174,
0.0132314386,
0.0404439904,
0.0034578696,
0.0067301146,
0.0382385887,
-0.0340680666,
-0.0115686553,
0.0072171353,
0.067339763,
-0.0296375751,
-0.0041899914,
-0.0049031884,
0.0476886369,
-0.0380281769,
-0.0030996534,
-0.0109433159,
-0.0184088293,
-0.0114461742,
0.0110182045,
0.0165023673,
0.0508909263,
-0.0631604865,
-0.0248839539,
0.0468700565,
-0.0413964316,
-0.0588364713,
0.0150303701,
0.0237774234,
-0.0104469573,
-0.0530650429,
-0.0221887343,
-0.0169473235,
0.0741343498,
-0.0038747876,
-0.0301670786,
-0.0588402301,
-0.0057178233,
-0.0330028608,
-0.0271107368,
-0.0399511084,
0.0438597351,
0.0146017931,
0.0377435423,
-0.0450633466,
-0.0054959697,
0.0093188509,
-0.0363389254,
-0.0035624185,
-0.0172223318,
0.0072729462,
-0.0348974615,
0.0451057106,
-0.0232229996,
0.0309125856,
-0.0142947445,
0.0138819255,
-0.0564301498,
-0.0006004354,
0.0194793977,
0.0021351064,
0.0332267508,
-0.0449390374,
-0.004535764,
-0.0181218516,
-0.042711094,
0.0050136349,
0.006267508,
0.003424986,
0.046576377,
-0.0046820147,
-0.0061475849,
-0.0386812724,
-0.0088257175,
0.0417257287,
0.0314521305,
-0.002437246,
0.0083143134,
0.0030040471,
0.016507538,
0.0211169384,
-0.0077410615,
0.0018255148,
-0.0476146191,
0.014937385,
0.0074220197,
0.0506137908,
0.0155117586,
-0.0108774062,
0.0094202226,
0.0238550529,
-0.0031611237,
-0.0604810081,
-0.0219020955,
0.0576768331,
-0.0247080214,
0.001074088,
0.0456301868,
-0.0280109495,
-0.0161179397,
-0.0017683972,
-0.030339133,
-0.0046109972,
0.0195822567,
0.0270231757,
-0.0866144076,
-0.0367608182,
0.0052590617,
-0.0244936924,
0.0343766287,
-0.0388992429,
-0.0207031295,
-0.150647819,
-0.0085726157,
-0.0126269544,
-0.1027217656,
-0.0293796379,
-0.0385966115,
-0.0018111728,
-0.0255591255,
0.0258868132,
-0.0527788214,
-0.0020851921,
-0.0121770622,
0.0173090342,
0.0048574326,
-0.0843584463,
0.0726938695,
-0.0485130996,
0.0556231216,
0.0335900858,
0.0418129638,
-0.0317783244,
-0.0057844473,
0.0127494158,
-0.0085037192,
-0.029273076,
0.0234628003,
0.0558476187,
-0.0150775975,
-0.0161943957,
0.074517116,
-0.0176868197,
-0.0390837267,
0.0119856838,
0.0250374041,
0.102582261,
0.0586958081,
-0.0418392867,
0.0308425911,
-0.0443030745,
0.0227506869,
0.0681845695,
0.0065850941,
-0.0180199556,
-0.0091839666,
0.0052311756,
-0.0407897159,
-0.0554224029,
-0.0330051258,
0.0451290198,
-0.0351038128,
-0.0436603986,
-0.0699554086,
-0.0806003138,
0.0324594826,
0.0224931967,
0.0234773066,
0.0134006795,
-0.0439109653,
-0.0203290693,
-0.0135038327,
0.0036761402,
-0.0446774922,
0.0428264998,
-0.0262513813,
-0.001011944,
-0.0076132743,
-0.0282933619,
-0.0042903856,
-0.0213108622,
-0.0593265928,
-0.0358025618,
-0.0413617976,
0.0793532357,
0.0111377314,
0.0518686101,
-0.0156451762,
-0.0365091637,
0.0169471428,
-0.0039504762,
-0.0363416895,
-0.002323176,
0.0596391633,
-0.0250296723,
0.0157088395,
0.0599528588,
-0.0475764759,
0.0227874294,
0.0350521691,
0.0316116922,
-0.0189947076,
-0.0041156788,
-0.0089335833,
0.0038545087,
0.0235142726,
-0.0097868945,
-0.0354399122,
-0.0314257704,
0.0127431937,
-0.0298901908,
-0.0105718616,
-0.0419808105,
-0.035829585,
0.0537986718,
0.0274412353,
0.0161900185,
0.0204818025,
0.0042770044,
-0.0035247619,
-0.0437635183,
-0.005774389,
0.0264572967,
0.0337033719,
0.0229411684,
0.0441732444,
-0.0057681231,
-0.0296129044,
0.0111452378,
0.024343282,
-0.0540945046,
0.0061831721,
0.0048514516,
0.0068691066,
0.0266421139,
-0.0135300104,
-0.0394176207,
-0.0239690114,
0.022271309,
-0.0180199035,
0.0608668514,
-0.044339601,
0.1012198925,
-0.0107807387,
-0.0071832533,
-0.0327735879,
0.0252748765,
-0.0201740768,
-0.0084401537,
0.02355453,
0.0115485974,
0.0089458525,
0.0214186236,
0.1012319997,
0.0159890316,
0.054756064,
-0.0323121771,
0.0139240045,
-0.0102064721,
-0.0147580961,
0.0580375642,
-0.0188652445,
-0.0198304672,
0.0231964607,
-0.0548430197,
-0.0877285898,
-0.0041113305,
-0.0277886651,
0.0088210506,
0.0108639942,
-0.0106095206,
0.0928872824,
-0.0248568412,
0.0113880169,
-0.0574841537,
-0.0266897492,
0.0115313539,
0.0233665444,
0.0101830065,
-5.778926022e-33,
-0.0076598693,
0.0423553847,
0.0485994257,
-0.0022442411,
0.0161892101,
0.0148718078,
-0.0301137101,
0.0019224326,
-0.0411422364,
0.0253856555,
-0.0039426945,
-0.0238692835,
0.0152173666,
0.0319801643,
0.0445980579,
0.0091970731,
0.0255432446,
0.0024174605,
-0.0125564085,
0.0113911498,
0.047067225,
0.0420863703,
0.1049128622,
-0.0127686085,
0.0356542543,
0.0164312422,
0.0284148864,
-0.0114312237,
0.016415989,
0.0494105034,
-0.0081812264,
0.0461027697,
0.0380426012,
-0.0685343444,
-0.0169030949,
-0.0206627902,
-0.0658188462,
-0.0443137884,
0.0387705788,
0.0304626301,
0.0019714909,
-0.0322830714,
-0.0095915552,
-0.0123534268,
0.021514833,
-0.0484868027,
0.0193968304,
-0.0318089277,
-0.0322837047,
0.003059224,
-0.1173120365,
0.0104120551,
-0.0016494559,
-0.0263478253,
0.0636748597,
0.0626882315,
0.0119767096,
-0.0033080974,
-0.0687208399,
0.0144919818,
-0.0492302328,
0.0241036676,
0.0925962403,
0.0008828067,
-0.0376595967,
0.0371665508,
0.0445304103,
0.0266179424,
0.0359543525,
0.0243154652,
0.0661454424,
0.0362041965,
0.0211647246,
0.0761187598,
0.0318629146,
-0.0047877831,
-0.0829143301,
-0.0006362484,
-0.0014381019,
0.0205702484,
0.0106676724,
-0.0039515179,
0.0036437616,
-0.0321774036,
-0.041190885,
-0.029287247,
-0.0234922431,
-0.0301915873,
0.0299650989,
-0.009328099,
0.0097689237,
0.0081276521,
0.07093779,
-0.0382945985,
-0.048703745,
0.0204017702,
-0.0229065977,
0.0156639237,
-0.0079228245,
0.04252588,
-0.1028269678,
-0.044780571,
-0.0112669729,
0.0255576838,
0.0299909152,
0.0106191924,
0.0970165804,
0.0226350278,
-0.0525949039,
-0.0190159101,
-0.0654958785,
0.0064882929,
0.0217047203,
0.0546571687,
0.0094021205,
0.0166726112,
-0.0134891048,
0.0324714184,
0.0336430445,
-0.0447377749,
0.0031926997,
-0.010037683,
-0.0140422331,
-0.0083310921,
-0.0303073153,
-0.0193932895,
-0.0616129451,
-0.0287558343,
0.0350523703,
-0.0231635235,
-0.0245101415,
0.0158826411,
2.506e-7,
0.0519494005,
0.0088223079,
-0.0357034728,
0.0063436762,
0.0042137862,
0.0314116925,
-0.0680799559,
0.0398862176,
-0.0059455289,
0.0105683459,
-0.0344851613,
0.0555250868,
0.0860369578,
0.0358181708,
-0.0612129308,
-0.0326327197,
-0.0104318382,
0.012462181,
-0.0286586713,
-0.0047320817,
-0.0112534417,
0.0520436838,
-0.0019585616,
-0.020421816,
-0.0116347978,
-0.0219213963,
0.0880350098,
-0.0417354517,
-0.0227648411,
0.0059462381,
-0.0071793934,
0.0203092005,
-0.0197510757,
0.0670917407,
-0.0363242924,
0.0204416011,
0.0456053615,
0.0437108353,
0.0106753623,
-0.0071170595,
0.0089016305,
-0.0178369731,
-0.0397916473,
-0.0432763137,
0.0887816101,
-0.0519935787,
-0.0268815421,
-0.0251848679,
-0.0138914119,
0.0530885458,
0.0622009449,
-0.0262228642,
-0.0416876934,
0.0187475886,
0.0556825101,
0.011753588,
-0.0628768876,
-0.0162774753,
-0.0040660864,
0.0447148308,
0.0008421905,
-0.0441209301,
-0.0106876781,
-0.0550830625,
0.0045164768,
-0.0559976026,
0.0257678516,
1.815157165e-34,
0.0144381924,
0.0037163983,
0.0275744367,
-0.0207734369,
0.0170030054,
-0.0553707704,
-0.0259661451,
0.0081922328,
-0.026013352,
-0.0129969781,
0.0191127248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02084v1 | Revisiting the Markov Property for Machine Translation | 2024-02-03T08:50:50 | 2024-02-03T08:50:50 | Cunxiao Du, Hao Zhou, Zhaopeng Tu, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we re-examine the Markov property in the context of neural
machine translation. We design a Markov Autoregressive Transformer~(MAT) and
undertake a comprehensive assessment of its performance across four WMT
benchmarks. Our findings indicate that MAT with an order larger than 4 can
generate translations with quality on par with that of conventional
autoregressive transformers. In addition, counter-intuitively, we also find
that the advantages of utilizing a higher-order MAT do not specifically
contribute to the translation of longer sentences. | [
0.0068786624,
0.039707303,
0.0129461875,
-0.011647475,
-0.0288536027,
0.0042321887,
0.0407947712,
0.0160665121,
-0.0608430021,
-0.0017271894,
0.0064677373,
-0.0268428605,
0.0495837145,
0.0069716019,
0.028451588,
-0.0563636869,
0.0121161072,
-0.0039071282,
-0.0667471513,
0.0135170203,
-0.0256385561,
-0.0211606603,
-0.0322759226,
0.0528890155,
-0.060767252,
0.0140921744,
0.0030737482,
0.0082741166,
0.0541673638,
-0.0233729817,
-0.036571838,
0.0266155563,
-0.0113844285,
0.0462525859,
0.0000019105,
0.0047029061,
0.0121368207,
-0.0005389066,
0.0508232154,
-0.0409076996,
-0.0146206534,
-0.0580086857,
-0.0342396311,
0.0280233584,
-0.0404612124,
-0.0386915989,
0.0513666943,
0.0316328295,
0.0582667254,
0.1221283972,
-0.0375984088,
-0.0658286661,
0.0480559431,
-0.0824061036,
0.0060913591,
-0.0521411002,
-0.0242618695,
0.0132651115,
-0.0396786407,
-0.0167349633,
-0.0307755899,
0.0841908306,
0.0211130735,
0.0044293203,
0.0224058703,
0.0282627493,
0.023776887,
-0.0120412633,
-0.0364232659,
0.0605475754,
-0.0269606411,
0.0194343608,
-0.010310404,
0.0043561622,
-0.0174250733,
-0.011264327,
-0.0264217947,
0.0459451415,
0.0178351216,
0.0412779897,
-0.0143557554,
0.0841353536,
0.0144256623,
-0.03150516,
-0.0739654303,
0.0543962158,
0.0297742635,
-0.0166202709,
-0.0313912556,
0.0234674923,
0.0465475097,
0.0032928975,
0.0421435311,
0.0201009884,
0.0306338258,
0.0103821391,
-0.0419105105,
-0.0086284429,
-0.0231604818,
-0.0312115736,
0.0712680519,
0.0549734421,
0.018503461,
0.0287638102,
-0.0296294987,
0.0804720297,
-0.0760370195,
-0.0183041282,
-0.0591464192,
0.002774531,
-0.0485436842,
0.0413971096,
-0.0571441092,
0.0006670304,
0.0047395676,
-0.0163603481,
-0.0456122458,
0.0272056647,
0.0315835737,
-0.0293424632,
0.0245456807,
-0.0460235104,
-0.1068259031,
-0.0425662361,
-0.02744711,
0.0727881491,
0.0127860969,
-0.0467014685,
0.0405401513,
-0.0567937084,
-0.0238145944,
0.0201503634,
-0.0099402992,
-0.0486430265,
-0.0158365965,
0.0928415209,
-0.0155677516,
-0.0255752709,
0.0334159546,
0.0095380619,
-0.0268497132,
-0.0347708873,
0.0270040948,
-0.0260420181,
0.0232001543,
0.0094030062,
0.0250983182,
0.0019637416,
-0.0008145993,
0.0175725296,
-0.0146175213,
0.0322208367,
0.0534345023,
-0.0304973461,
0.0098076863,
-0.0254074913,
0.0141136218,
-0.001743761,
0.0568899587,
0.0379301868,
-0.0063264132,
-0.0022768117,
0.0226166807,
0.0276673082,
-0.0134910652,
0.0116026811,
-0.0137205021,
-0.026523089,
-0.0192493889,
0.0332577489,
0.0403457694,
0.0776977465,
-0.0166201908,
0.0167356469,
0.0643052906,
0.035813529,
0.0074518574,
0.067735754,
0.0493161827,
-0.0251976587,
-0.0220293459,
0.0117469588,
-0.0148392785,
0.0602761805,
0.010567585,
-0.0099741928,
-0.003262057,
0.0347298682,
-0.0214770231,
-0.0330574289,
0.0059913574,
-0.014565248,
0.0272479299,
-0.0618116669,
0.0182305519,
0.0282014646,
-0.0489692874,
0.0596789978,
-0.0499601252,
-0.0599343143,
0.0084511405,
-0.0802800879,
-0.064700909,
0.0196695179,
0.0346769281,
0.0136923213,
0.0034764509,
-0.0470556468,
0.0092816623,
0.0516673252,
0.0670208409,
0.0663110018,
0.0254287086,
-0.0394380838,
-0.0243469048,
0.0042712712,
-0.0019308159,
0.0363934264,
0.0052830637,
0.0706108585,
0.0452919453,
0.0129227582,
-0.0232796725,
0.0323926955,
0.0198195092,
-0.0297918506,
0.0580728874,
0.0221208371,
0.0376973413,
-0.0114599355,
-0.0116408737,
0.0202773511,
-0.0050319792,
-0.0603282042,
-0.0213223416,
0.0731457919,
-0.0977940261,
-0.0261344183,
0.021401519,
-0.0781186447,
-0.0057848105,
0.0356385335,
-0.0280195586,
-0.0607408322,
-0.0034500279,
-0.0539900549,
0.0150743565,
-0.033663474,
0.0209414773,
0.0459323339,
0.0462417826,
-0.0337772667,
-0.0100354338,
-0.0183109473,
-0.0423123576,
-0.0223990642,
-0.045842573,
0.0265822541,
-0.0241454672,
-0.0204993859,
0.0295650046,
0.0146218678,
0.0306764171,
0.0483688675,
0.0064520855,
-0.0068442752,
-0.0569364205,
0.0098159621,
0.0050812936,
-0.0370456763,
0.0235943645,
0.0416438878,
0.0597866364,
0.035725683,
-0.0034254743,
-0.0544400215,
0.0296171084,
0.0041599218,
-0.0080985501,
0.0355650187,
0.0084208734,
0.022833379,
-0.0025730145,
-0.0385511182,
0.0152579797,
0.052188471,
-0.0094668223,
-0.0127311694,
-0.0839852318,
-0.0069515426,
0.0118771382,
0.0177407023,
-0.0171966366,
-0.0783832371,
0.0076704561,
-0.0567954332,
0.0743166506,
0.0364289805,
0.0499394685,
0.0408900976,
0.0275770966,
-0.0198899265,
-0.0123792812,
0.0255386941,
-0.0471941382,
-0.0119887963,
-0.0288164187,
-0.0474116877,
0.009188774,
0.0609865002,
0.0101245549,
0.0141829532,
-0.0615139604,
-0.0616339445,
0.0150466021,
-0.0023525949,
0.0492662862,
0.0291564707,
-0.0189171676,
0.004443605,
-0.0084950477,
-0.0361700952,
0.0607705638,
-0.0318244435,
0.0110809067,
-0.0269674417,
-0.0160007048,
-0.0027849388,
0.0079924269,
0.0067086406,
0.0112986919,
-0.0342427827,
-0.0261576138,
0.001117652,
0.0038794382,
0.0048684576,
-0.0089521315,
0.0372874029,
-0.0215460341,
0.0056799557,
-0.0227346867,
0.0088757407,
-0.0252466127,
-0.0075365845,
-0.0038762358,
-0.0142869847,
0.0369813628,
-0.030817613,
-0.068857044,
0.0436971784,
0.0213421378,
0.0693334937,
-0.0193081331,
-0.0218863599,
-0.0181757249,
0.0525118075,
0.001352457,
-0.0003268471,
0.0423168056,
-0.0260136761,
0.01950817,
-0.0048175617,
0.0183301959,
-0.0190165974,
-0.0826745182,
-0.0294595528,
0.0078679165,
-0.0079839928,
-0.0061179241,
0.0002822626,
0.0241746474,
-0.0384069756,
-0.0116599854,
0.0667874217,
-0.0104436819,
-0.052775085,
-0.0202200972,
0.0477003641,
0.0386250429,
-0.0044635609,
0.0246259831,
-0.054436598,
-0.014102499,
0.0031043566,
0.0049873949,
0.0402541459,
-0.0046151117,
-0.0134251118,
-0.0493411943,
-0.0015151212,
0.0183296483,
-0.0497140177,
-0.0692618564,
-0.0033016554,
-0.0435902104,
-0.0487326309,
0.0361634381,
0.0035447709,
-0.015607792,
0.0030340445,
0.0093500139,
0.0098292083,
-0.0360682569,
-0.0221466124,
-0.029795289,
0.0026485247,
0.0980514735,
0.0291582402,
-0.0170488972,
-0.067636624,
0.0297646727,
0.0135550397,
0.0501732044,
0.0178858321,
-0.0138661945,
0.0197128598,
-0.0477584004,
-0.0048346757,
-0.0198934618,
-0.0094075678,
0.0345162451,
-0.0097025391,
0.0673297867,
-0.0441441089,
-0.0249238163,
-0.0019853411,
-0.0134892045,
-0.0136337727,
0.0348821022,
0.0152378026,
-0.0223207157,
-0.0513363145,
-0.0204039272,
0.0362443663,
-0.0701905414,
-0.0224632919,
-0.0072760964,
-0.0132716279,
-0.0586405881,
-0.0890968964,
-0.0568656847,
-0.0177563373,
0.0776822641,
-0.0074208803,
-0.0312877037,
0.0402626544,
0.0076409443,
-0.0279290285,
0.0113186426,
-0.0449289382,
0.0067297975,
-0.078405872,
0.0381876342,
0.0310246665,
-0.0006604875,
0.0169117711,
-0.0034994329,
-0.1137382612,
-0.0733101517,
-0.0140082221,
0.0777836293,
0.0213135872,
0.0325280093,
-0.0051701469,
-0.0024671666,
0.0382708572,
-0.0169200953,
0.0057674558,
0.0081531135,
0.0248520095,
-0.016924765,
-0.016931301,
0.0214532986,
-0.0036084685,
0.0241387691,
-0.0371471047,
0.0614045672,
-0.0141571267,
-0.0386974327,
0.0137962848,
-0.0013139042,
0.0555796176,
-0.0371010974,
0.0175612774,
0.0053454088,
0.0196762607,
-0.0097599141,
0.0327886567,
-0.0465477258,
0.0254334901,
0.0577966236,
0.0000062766,
-0.0104688164,
0.013439713,
-0.0157570466,
-0.0412129536,
0.0197352301,
0.0210614614,
-0.0543442816,
-0.0139970845,
0.0169617888,
0.0344293639,
-0.013450318,
0.0193486288,
0.0391987823,
-0.0079836873,
-0.0163209736,
0.0338355452,
0.0069378852,
0.0117813228,
-0.0191668253,
0.0176402349,
-0.0728591904,
-0.003789155,
0.0000492764,
-0.0083449241,
0.0660027862,
0.0098435478,
0.1097711176,
-0.0204579905,
0.0143064307,
0.0197632145,
0.0552816316,
0.002036063,
0.0199088901,
-0.0064721587,
-0.0116625903,
0.015842285,
0.0186490174,
0.0306675676,
-0.0330878496,
0.0051164753,
0.0364925154,
0.0137415277,
-0.03190016,
0.006124883,
-0.0487635806,
-0.0614675097,
0.0234753657,
-0.028249627,
0.010085254,
-0.0267519522,
0.0179309864,
-0.0072229858,
0.0227154475,
-0.0292514917,
0.0180821102,
0.0460151359,
-0.0101843113,
0.0155130671,
-0.0305888876,
0.0051222276,
0.0418905765,
-0.0197580531,
-0.0487686731,
-6.101380285e-33,
-0.0188234281,
0.0003569271,
0.0250669476,
-0.0045014997,
-0.026880661,
-0.0195198376,
-0.0144232251,
-0.0191182494,
-0.0268911179,
0.0194696672,
-0.0182258487,
0.0260457303,
0.0241982266,
0.0019945533,
0.0207588561,
0.0344187841,
0.0748445243,
-0.0316891074,
-0.0153425699,
0.0239710398,
0.0097159203,
0.0316926092,
0.0789341107,
0.0026271478,
-0.0405603573,
0.0052217813,
-0.0229099393,
-0.0004260453,
-0.0005024647,
-0.0171087384,
-0.0077944468,
0.0113588264,
0.0330863632,
-0.0278592091,
-0.0121508343,
-0.0332778618,
-0.0967913941,
0.0036015275,
-0.0249046031,
0.0547471568,
-0.0090917191,
-0.0354927517,
0.0497389399,
-0.0398157164,
-0.0206133891,
-0.0348099656,
0.011844066,
-0.0262217931,
-0.0367340334,
-0.0466289595,
-0.0256276187,
0.0136167416,
0.0009938688,
-0.0309115332,
0.0390634537,
0.0612949394,
-0.0437079668,
-0.013308988,
-0.0583263785,
0.0196390431,
-0.0345300585,
0.052675087,
0.0332728773,
0.0222087316,
0.0018246536,
-0.0124422973,
0.0310570095,
0.0158903096,
0.0212095864,
0.0455565788,
0.0155576486,
0.0076273126,
0.0637320429,
-0.0181636922,
0.0664543584,
-0.0152300717,
-0.0405307934,
0.0319481902,
-0.0021858213,
0.0550689809,
0.0134564117,
-0.0152314026,
-0.0219487008,
0.0258653462,
-0.0132495649,
-0.0372069329,
-0.0152681209,
-0.0176309776,
0.0047078789,
0.0469049066,
0.0081613436,
0.0133220945,
0.0869488493,
-0.0127852466,
0.00058729,
0.0133683188,
-0.0446414202,
-0.0031840021,
-0.0456326418,
0.0178467035,
0.0020980441,
-0.0393198431,
0.0027621493,
0.0415175594,
0.0017291412,
-0.0204478819,
0.0090803169,
0.0502213426,
-0.0625755191,
-0.0279892497,
-0.0271924753,
0.04922463,
0.0274167303,
0.0046369908,
0.0141400294,
-0.0405626968,
-0.000918942,
0.0547390617,
-0.0182165317,
-0.0232564937,
0.010644949,
0.0299887471,
0.0394949876,
0.0463127494,
-0.046751596,
0.0366970748,
-0.0349769481,
0.0752860606,
0.0468465053,
-0.0578574352,
-0.0494788587,
0.0266750399,
2.634e-7,
0.0340350755,
0.0662193,
0.0346458964,
-0.0014806959,
0.0044746408,
-0.002417054,
-0.0466114059,
0.0126642799,
-0.0095893852,
0.0722200572,
0.0144028794,
-0.0040727952,
0.0926989168,
0.0193775799,
-0.0402204618,
-0.0329982154,
-0.0668835863,
0.0183598436,
-0.0348490588,
-0.0257424638,
0.0423803627,
0.0612454973,
-0.0294359811,
0.0215051342,
0.022770416,
-0.0143950218,
0.0588495024,
-0.0043520168,
0.0234718397,
-0.0019265744,
0.0570920222,
0.0072043529,
-0.043018382,
-0.0457816646,
-0.0276864264,
0.0103861317,
0.0100221429,
0.0588981472,
-0.0188853238,
-0.0474239439,
0.0374437533,
-0.0024672793,
-0.0388211571,
0.001484171,
0.0256366543,
-0.094046779,
-0.0041677677,
-0.0085562225,
-0.0692017227,
0.0176778883,
0.0475554615,
-0.0174000952,
-0.0205014385,
-0.0052507138,
0.0443347581,
-0.0113698384,
-0.0049837683,
-0.0705523193,
0.0004990777,
-0.0086441701,
-0.0257794801,
-0.0150472708,
-0.0437449962,
-0.0422459841,
0.0324053094,
0.0333908312,
-0.0407880023,
1.863144541e-34,
0.0443670899,
-0.0238922555,
0.0261151157,
-0.0163401496,
0.0043946081,
-0.0142306397,
-0.0126476185,
-0.0021683269,
-0.0147869401,
-0.0879553556,
-0.0673424825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02082v1 | GliDe with a CaPE: A Low-Hassle Method to Accelerate Speculative Decoding | 2024-02-03T08:44:11 | 2024-02-03T08:44:11 | Cunxiao Du, Jing Jiang, Xu Yuanchen, Jiawei Wu, Sicheng Yu, Yongqi Li, Shenggui Li, Kai Xu, Liqiang Nie, Zhaopeng Tu, Yang You | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speculative decoding is a relatively new decoding framework that leverages
small and efficient draft models to reduce the latency of LLMs. In this study,
we introduce GliDe and CaPE, two low-hassle modifications to vanilla
speculative decoding to further improve the decoding speed of a frozen LLM.
Specifically, GliDe is a modified draft model architecture that reuses the
cached keys and values from the target LLM, while CaPE is a proposal expansion
method that uses the draft model's confidence scores to help select additional
candidate tokens for verification. Extensive experiments on different
benchmarks demonstrate that our proposed GliDe draft model significantly
reduces the expected decoding latency. Additional evaluation using walltime
reveals that GliDe can accelerate Vicuna models up to 2.17x and further extend
the improvement to 2.61x with CaPE. We will release our code, data, and the
trained draft models. | [
0.0250107795,
0.0718344897,
0.0336526036,
0.0159125775,
-0.0255210586,
0.0087615661,
-0.0499460287,
0.0282281805,
-0.0602520928,
-0.004823287,
0.0080530178,
-0.0317880064,
-0.0013814996,
0.0173685998,
0.0088339718,
-0.0107138101,
0.0232007764,
-0.0349239819,
0.0290500708,
-0.0107335206,
-0.0527487546,
0.0277571399,
-0.0034686716,
0.045602981,
0.0325783119,
-0.0065613268,
-0.0603688546,
0.0381684005,
0.0033585469,
-0.0786982626,
-0.0219664201,
0.0698733553,
-0.0179698002,
0.0170368813,
0.0000021182,
-0.0040339604,
-0.0415262096,
0.0261074193,
-0.070765838,
0.0459847078,
0.0557078309,
0.0060711931,
-0.0435777009,
0.0215666201,
-0.0118611259,
-0.0459643491,
0.0257697757,
0.0059877252,
0.0038620981,
0.0769727081,
-0.0024676202,
-0.024813205,
0.0202637482,
0.0202577226,
-0.0147018507,
-0.0962076262,
0.0314207673,
-0.0254285,
-0.0333835632,
0.0072545474,
-0.0011575168,
-0.003814749,
0.0376353301,
0.020725742,
0.007380703,
0.0230170619,
-0.0189521872,
0.0015674545,
-0.0471613072,
0.028346112,
0.0012817784,
-0.0693466812,
-0.0024808536,
0.0189570896,
-0.0202111956,
-0.040752884,
-0.0200160407,
-0.0027638201,
-0.0444713645,
0.0129147088,
0.0405919254,
0.0195166785,
0.0548167191,
-0.005722262,
-0.0236463603,
0.0649181381,
0.0369695462,
-0.0034878301,
-0.0239814427,
0.012088106,
0.0229884032,
-0.0692145899,
0.0183555204,
-0.0014540326,
-0.0302584395,
-0.0286552068,
-0.0515212789,
-0.0228612758,
0.0060647298,
-0.0222987141,
0.0572984144,
0.0747503564,
-0.024653269,
-0.0104494151,
-0.0442142375,
-0.0186600219,
-0.0384329818,
0.0055417791,
-0.0208523534,
-0.0068520638,
-0.0059682606,
-0.0057702488,
-0.0361124165,
0.0439159013,
-0.027733393,
-0.0178025495,
-0.0359604321,
0.0099284006,
0.0570722334,
0.022294512,
0.0552209392,
-0.0239821691,
-0.0084736701,
-0.0176371802,
0.016151337,
0.0044691549,
-0.0112502966,
0.0148054762,
-0.0123349624,
-0.0729574412,
-0.0174577069,
0.0252886023,
0.0016788702,
-0.0112792747,
0.0029889161,
0.0519007817,
-0.0209001489,
-0.037536893,
-0.0144487303,
-0.0235483423,
0.0332888402,
-0.0286946297,
0.0051433379,
-0.0545466356,
-0.0005119052,
0.0174196083,
0.0051888381,
-0.0003904039,
-0.0381741934,
0.0046089389,
0.0146019878,
0.0529069826,
-0.0170250162,
-0.005953968,
-0.0178162344,
-0.0000450732,
-0.0259139668,
0.0888433903,
-0.0068217581,
0.0577801839,
-0.0043727504,
-0.0248661656,
-0.0226331111,
0.062798813,
0.0462819189,
-0.0145289358,
0.0036954714,
0.0078208214,
0.0326305218,
-0.0227582622,
0.0318854786,
0.0244923402,
-0.0579750799,
-0.0142148593,
0.0370432436,
0.0739633292,
0.0087136524,
0.011217799,
0.0091795512,
0.0302041769,
0.0249498822,
-0.0331406221,
-0.0313177183,
0.0286604092,
-0.0431255959,
0.0131193474,
0.0375191905,
0.0639547631,
-0.0156504195,
0.0054440401,
-0.0296961591,
-0.0253994465,
-0.0084165353,
-0.0060094097,
0.0411165692,
-0.0130478172,
-0.0940304101,
0.0819982439,
-0.0147762774,
-0.0557569005,
-0.0629630983,
-0.0228613373,
0.0115063051,
0.0769622996,
0.0730613098,
0.0478772298,
-0.0036796916,
0.0162825994,
-0.0258879997,
0.0210754331,
0.0276864283,
0.0017054687,
0.0227124337,
-0.0427717306,
-0.0351192504,
0.0742207244,
0.0305188894,
0.0509343483,
0.0705678165,
0.0075501907,
-0.0081603657,
-0.0279597286,
0.0117963692,
0.0171302035,
0.060505975,
0.0167770348,
0.0276564565,
0.0010640781,
0.0584696867,
0.0234196875,
0.0113795185,
0.0063062846,
0.053987354,
-0.0423870571,
-0.0085056713,
0.0198673867,
-0.0281260181,
-0.0273990426,
0.0406025536,
0.018507449,
-0.0234034192,
0.0357081741,
-0.0117422892,
-0.017149495,
0.0065270853,
-0.0114520369,
0.0485030785,
-0.0420360081,
0.0414175168,
-0.0068377042,
0.0215888433,
0.006571033,
0.0312075093,
-0.0688840523,
-0.010151173,
-0.0193582885,
0.0120333927,
-0.0013462906,
-0.0393954031,
0.0194768552,
0.0407638177,
-0.0353360549,
0.0062324484,
-0.0272912178,
0.0203639194,
-0.0030144446,
-0.0307464749,
-0.0907470435,
-0.0077010938,
-0.0450830013,
0.0579835139,
-0.0103522055,
-0.009014003,
-0.0180284344,
-0.0180284847,
-0.0032461113,
-0.0122333439,
-0.0257219691,
-0.0192296188,
-0.0202420615,
-0.0226002634,
-0.0750365481,
0.0211983752,
-0.0080816178,
0.0221326165,
0.0494201593,
-0.0643324405,
-0.0404505767,
-0.0438162349,
0.0119509296,
0.0525882989,
-0.0420522466,
0.0196828414,
-0.040682707,
0.0347639769,
-0.0244899541,
-0.0122168278,
-0.006805127,
-0.0016026936,
-0.0056618382,
-0.0058548516,
0.009214648,
-0.0411332771,
-0.0047532911,
0.0127882129,
0.0002059254,
-0.0734717175,
-0.02975199,
0.0191081297,
0.0326043516,
-0.0078228498,
0.0145703582,
-0.0646662116,
-0.0191699509,
0.048682034,
-0.0505071916,
0.0073763835,
-0.007303888,
-0.0131491134,
0.0332732424,
-0.0185690634,
-0.0467953868,
0.0307659656,
-0.0801088512,
-0.0150420414,
-0.0141144609,
0.0176070668,
-0.0244501233,
0.0188617855,
-0.0444216579,
0.0041289707,
-0.0518310517,
-0.0614179745,
0.0460579656,
-0.0149333701,
-0.0046478603,
-0.0689458847,
0.0277254153,
-0.0096843457,
0.0375642665,
-0.0305001233,
-0.028150335,
-0.029811563,
0.0122870617,
-0.0624257885,
-0.0254130401,
0.0039073583,
-0.0627371669,
-0.0068283933,
0.0259286724,
-0.0822104439,
0.045016747,
-0.0167417414,
0.0100422781,
-0.0275031179,
-0.0051852409,
-0.0117812939,
-0.0066889129,
0.0131433401,
-0.0148945181,
0.0437889025,
0.0852770358,
0.0555648841,
0.0079942998,
-0.0848044157,
0.0263153352,
0.0431888551,
-0.0064445972,
0.0277330354,
0.0855492502,
0.0396093354,
-0.0280539487,
0.0159804318,
0.0878212452,
-0.0023709566,
-0.0582118742,
-0.0153370453,
0.0087075634,
0.0444726348,
-0.005015254,
0.0097683445,
-0.0703589171,
-0.0435511097,
0.0690436512,
0.0472781546,
-0.0065690684,
0.0070533655,
-0.0212758519,
-0.0707895756,
0.0745455325,
0.0262554158,
-0.0223406032,
0.028603049,
-0.0625176206,
-0.065414995,
0.0345520787,
0.0388299599,
0.0365597345,
0.0561903566,
-0.0143493935,
0.0086873556,
-0.0259695295,
-0.0674133524,
0.0141610578,
-0.0141831543,
0.0639461875,
0.0478146449,
-0.0219479371,
0.0389019772,
-0.0084533347,
0.0017851432,
0.0069635115,
-0.0460804813,
-0.0369891226,
-0.0133206472,
-0.0149996104,
0.0157173146,
0.0126694115,
0.0036788615,
-0.0462773629,
-0.0256936941,
-0.0338203274,
0.0319862217,
-0.0150388423,
0.0009504569,
-0.0116355233,
-0.0166491419,
0.0004913315,
0.0612579584,
0.0130604738,
0.0182378907,
-0.0181433223,
-0.0442046747,
-0.0319359414,
-0.1037221253,
-0.028662283,
0.0130380364,
0.0442975685,
-0.02222386,
-0.0153412353,
0.0296148509,
0.00383435,
0.0547245145,
-0.030682385,
0.069913879,
-0.025061924,
-0.0102641154,
-0.1071662158,
-0.0080970479,
-0.0309844762,
0.0222884864,
-0.0764718801,
0.016960226,
0.0171673093,
-0.0248591732,
-0.0160038359,
0.0414660014,
-0.0897834226,
-0.0389246792,
-0.0008420295,
0.0367898867,
0.0348917358,
0.0091142729,
-0.0510380156,
-0.0418068282,
0.0442457609,
0.0379602388,
-0.0404399633,
0.0353473239,
0.0085939765,
-0.0356356129,
0.0144581171,
0.006770099,
-0.0288506933,
-0.0211553928,
-0.0104666743,
0.0322553404,
0.0183386933,
-0.0161782391,
0.0272677653,
0.0354863293,
-0.0071383612,
-0.0399536006,
-0.0131641347,
0.0452775583,
0.0818032995,
0.0006870367,
0.0276084319,
0.0127192754,
0.0161368549,
0.0069877105,
-0.0525671579,
0.0100739012,
-0.0088487919,
0.0159058012,
0.0271823574,
0.0277670808,
0.0040219491,
-0.0215832144,
0.0361384563,
0.0553249568,
-0.0482829101,
-0.0026631383,
-0.0180280227,
0.0111921364,
0.0080619976,
-0.0353605524,
-0.037136957,
0.0123455208,
0.0303384475,
-0.0291224867,
0.0335068777,
-0.0361325108,
-0.0370789319,
-0.0310221426,
0.0297330897,
0.0728456825,
0.0435121879,
0.0317423865,
-0.030780429,
0.0128555037,
-0.0408591889,
0.004628513,
-0.0101904599,
-0.0192956589,
0.0453118458,
0.0054226341,
-0.012785323,
0.0064596431,
0.0166129824,
0.0079343338,
0.0735332519,
-0.0191609915,
0.0153945861,
-0.0406967662,
-0.0547689423,
-0.0092398301,
0.028916914,
-0.059885066,
-0.0143765919,
-0.0159371942,
-0.0173603687,
0.0522684827,
-0.0100462846,
0.0248376839,
0.0146991536,
0.0090201916,
0.0567755811,
-0.003872744,
-0.0482239723,
-0.0062421742,
-0.0461403653,
0.037291415,
-0.0444876514,
0.0229608938,
-6.841968542e-33,
-0.0062651364,
-0.0022827559,
0.0146104172,
-0.0417894498,
-0.0123611335,
-0.0014253987,
-0.0261015091,
-0.0271753985,
0.0359146819,
-0.0163375959,
-0.0189330615,
0.0313586406,
0.0563388355,
0.0150530217,
-0.0078743668,
-0.00103323,
0.0843534619,
-0.0204595886,
-0.036629051,
-0.025511574,
0.0249278173,
0.0254816208,
0.015471234,
-0.0050365436,
-0.0203046389,
-0.0058817053,
-0.0419032201,
-0.0371710099,
0.0055078221,
0.0609981492,
-0.0113810245,
-0.0255092829,
0.0058217384,
-0.0031426223,
-0.0291000158,
-0.0207478851,
-0.0953616723,
0.0516161919,
0.031391833,
0.0541087128,
0.0335100628,
-0.0898478925,
-0.031722717,
0.034346994,
-0.0534298271,
0.0081954682,
-0.0585652962,
-0.0237645246,
-0.0427020863,
-0.0515547208,
0.0136005729,
0.0341470577,
0.0152707016,
0.0391186774,
0.0925706103,
-0.023872273,
-0.0213885009,
0.0092292214,
-0.0516898073,
0.0173589494,
-0.0309129097,
0.0419665873,
0.0457412638,
-0.0244288426,
-0.0379674658,
0.0465318859,
0.0464338101,
-0.0534059331,
-0.0438235551,
0.0320790708,
0.0385752656,
0.0214393046,
0.0115295872,
0.012932485,
0.0683165118,
-0.0309738405,
-0.0329299644,
0.0412888527,
0.0251975264,
0.0287276991,
0.0653786436,
0.0231635645,
-0.0330897011,
-0.0095875068,
-0.0438711196,
-0.038612362,
-0.0318764746,
-0.0361343995,
0.0525091588,
0.0462259203,
-0.0253031552,
-0.0166270584,
0.066528447,
-0.0261789504,
0.0127633829,
0.0118329739,
0.01383969,
0.0511409454,
-0.0219353009,
0.0083142938,
0.0244744346,
-0.0348032005,
0.05503406,
-0.0396344624,
-0.0040394412,
-0.0287426673,
-0.0229629278,
0.0215386357,
-0.0661132038,
0.0074483156,
-0.0049142162,
0.023514336,
0.0365939699,
0.0181158315,
0.0484606959,
-0.0321344025,
0.0179351345,
0.0286643058,
-0.056643337,
0.036582347,
-0.0076433318,
0.016455397,
0.0351555683,
0.0806159377,
0.0199199077,
0.043554116,
-0.0394299142,
-0.0234653484,
0.0145729361,
-0.012231729,
-0.0208185688,
0.0498136878,
2.818e-7,
0.0214952584,
0.0489943922,
0.085371457,
0.0058459546,
0.0051093316,
0.0041566403,
-0.0433772728,
0.0019716502,
-0.0233962554,
-0.0227856245,
-0.0215455294,
0.0364768505,
0.0833321065,
0.0110998247,
-0.0739779547,
-0.0334866382,
0.0139812604,
-0.0025544174,
-0.0451944172,
-0.0194531623,
-0.0143349459,
0.0698524714,
-0.0214339308,
-0.0357172079,
0.0561823808,
0.0288802292,
0.0073312852,
-0.0092198923,
-0.0252951533,
0.0020508431,
-0.0030427598,
-0.007653072,
0.0171458405,
0.0026856647,
-0.0016158718,
0.0001818169,
-0.0337224752,
0.0547330193,
0.0143103078,
-0.0586838201,
0.0122250021,
-0.0213684663,
-0.01360601,
0.0338093452,
0.0350436904,
0.0486306697,
-0.020784691,
-0.0181086212,
-0.0399118178,
-0.0106670931,
-0.0436160751,
0.0072234543,
0.0436759032,
0.0637394786,
0.0264394004,
0.0113379415,
0.0027247295,
-0.0542385355,
-0.0382501259,
-0.0401806794,
-0.0485551022,
-0.0264986344,
-0.051527705,
0.0570759475,
0.0284140352,
-0.0399027243,
-0.0085676368,
3.0252192e-34,
0.0710059181,
-0.0154263312,
0.0056357007,
0.1167433485,
-0.0036491237,
-0.0312902965,
0.0355993882,
0.0348392874,
-0.0149327051,
-0.0598581508,
-0.0144357588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02080v1 | Translation Errors Significantly Impact Low-Resource Languages in Cross-Lingual Learning | 2024-02-03T08:22:51 | 2024-02-03T08:22:51 | Ashish Sunil Agrawal, Barah Fazili, Preethi Jyothi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Popular benchmarks (e.g., XNLI) used to evaluate cross-lingual language
understanding consist of parallel versions of English evaluation sets in
multiple target languages created with the help of professional translators.
When creating such parallel data, it is critical to ensure high-quality
translations for all target languages for an accurate characterization of
cross-lingual transfer. In this work, we find that translation inconsistencies
do exist and interestingly they disproportionally impact low-resource languages
in XNLI. To identify such inconsistencies, we propose measuring the gap in
performance between zero-shot evaluations on the human-translated and
machine-translated target text across multiple target languages; relatively
large gaps are indicative of translation errors. We also corroborate that
translation errors exist for two target languages, namely Hindi and Urdu, by
doing a manual reannotation of human-translated test instances in these two
languages and finding poor agreement with the original English labels these
instances were supposed to inherit. | [
-0.0110266106,
0.012688119,
-0.0377419405,
0.0563389584,
-0.0540374368,
0.026633013,
0.0536226444,
0.0037963248,
-0.0395310521,
-0.0237532239,
-0.0823027045,
-0.039240256,
0.0625345632,
-0.0630377531,
0.0047475048,
-0.0339851081,
0.0887485892,
-0.0056085046,
-0.019401446,
-0.0052614827,
-0.0219873358,
0.0165808331,
-0.0338315889,
0.0110130841,
-0.0134075647,
-0.0088514443,
0.0186147522,
-0.0117482394,
0.0512574017,
-0.031397786,
-0.0422506221,
0.0235931817,
-0.0050103185,
0.0783512816,
0.0000018505,
-0.0471042879,
-0.0285791233,
0.0098952549,
-0.0073623126,
0.020592846,
0.0653091371,
-0.0776282772,
-0.0070994003,
-0.0062168459,
0.0098210862,
-0.0563681982,
0.0597229004,
0.0150764687,
0.001645576,
0.0579002164,
-0.0072172326,
0.016799584,
-0.0091624847,
-0.019598281,
0.0500609837,
-0.0595107749,
-0.003177461,
0.0178362168,
-0.0145224053,
0.006259806,
-0.0622364283,
0.0364405103,
0.0020734072,
0.0246759616,
-0.0352171585,
0.0068901051,
-0.0435780734,
-0.0216246098,
0.0153074125,
0.0729314238,
-0.0324504338,
-0.0163541157,
-0.0471717939,
-0.0001677945,
-0.0255191904,
0.0191853996,
-0.0356368981,
0.0385570601,
-0.0025369655,
0.0006804991,
0.0348173454,
0.0349350646,
0.0273440126,
-0.0211949162,
-0.0098127546,
0.0121086035,
0.021559095,
-0.0460143462,
0.0100082913,
0.0415407568,
0.0066739651,
-0.012062001,
-0.0069734897,
-0.0205876622,
-0.0252366196,
0.0351495631,
-0.0347085372,
-0.0686657056,
0.018346481,
-0.0094775604,
0.0419108346,
0.0543078594,
-0.0352224074,
0.0318560898,
-0.0376408435,
0.1057278961,
0.0292797405,
0.0237253103,
-0.0545254424,
-0.0287721846,
-0.0403692164,
0.026418034,
-0.0019081546,
-0.0100547699,
-0.0380284712,
0.0146871535,
-0.0610610507,
-0.0250452608,
-0.0103598526,
0.0295618977,
-0.0078561315,
-0.0712411329,
-0.0730242878,
0.0007286824,
0.0050045047,
0.0779408589,
-0.0310825519,
0.0015577058,
-0.020627562,
-0.0829482898,
-0.0188384857,
0.0298172198,
-0.0464349799,
-0.0345173962,
-0.0234300923,
0.1015179306,
-0.0408643037,
-0.0160999894,
-0.0266191047,
0.0069115083,
-0.0142212454,
-0.0688421205,
0.0156645365,
-0.0562501885,
0.0564198345,
0.0295966417,
0.0316670872,
-0.002637455,
-0.0057361452,
0.0038949125,
-0.0418520607,
0.0690987632,
0.0073945448,
-0.0064956942,
0.0015099599,
0.0131967086,
-0.0212886166,
0.0863764361,
0.0181023777,
-0.0148797166,
0.0374091528,
0.0006628463,
-0.0529691465,
0.0171617307,
0.0227581747,
0.0226079877,
-0.0361161642,
-0.0137048597,
0.0496253446,
0.0410100035,
0.0198788494,
0.0091845542,
-0.0341636948,
0.0314830579,
0.0259905979,
0.0556613654,
0.0106416633,
0.022239469,
0.0288611911,
0.0085983984,
-0.0163304433,
0.0384281315,
-0.0240895301,
0.0214355513,
0.0254124682,
-0.0029102252,
0.012008667,
0.0198105928,
-0.0202639606,
-0.0084623015,
-0.020783281,
-0.0174241569,
0.0161775183,
-0.045360405,
0.0622620992,
0.0193460118,
-0.0451011732,
0.0351641886,
0.0479472242,
-0.0390251316,
0.0409048423,
-0.0056278734,
0.0014035549,
0.0467994437,
0.0001876597,
0.014151738,
0.0073925569,
0.0332702659,
0.0219536871,
0.0523277782,
0.0964123979,
-0.0019320431,
0.0174892452,
-0.0390356071,
-0.0131620206,
-0.010816115,
0.0228146445,
0.0521437116,
-0.0271884818,
0.0852405503,
0.0182616208,
-0.0658547357,
-0.060821902,
0.0247350447,
-0.059443444,
-0.0156114334,
0.0010962622,
0.0085864328,
-0.0006800875,
-0.006058211,
-0.0293449778,
-0.0147239631,
-0.0273656677,
-0.0072128959,
-0.0028902155,
0.0335506126,
0.003465656,
-0.0446175374,
-0.002351586,
-0.0918218344,
-0.0086389519,
0.0261614118,
-0.031715747,
-0.0564306788,
0.040975146,
0.008457168,
0.0030274822,
-0.0204629246,
0.0356512591,
-0.0226390362,
0.0141104348,
-0.0228017326,
0.0300770979,
0.0451819003,
0.0398032144,
-0.0124056451,
-0.0003774432,
0.0561968572,
-0.0069034696,
-0.0123968618,
0.0660569593,
0.003793828,
0.0146630267,
0.0206998158,
0.0214999113,
-0.0563251451,
0.0106756212,
-0.0642446354,
0.0146999573,
0.0000026546,
0.044843033,
0.0282755923,
0.0152030494,
0.0213825628,
0.0038653852,
0.0018563712,
0.0297039002,
0.0185099803,
0.0346816964,
0.012143258,
-0.0008493392,
0.0361474715,
-0.0066543459,
-0.0129626123,
0.0061287279,
0.0435575396,
0.0102971559,
-0.0126859993,
-0.0411747806,
0.0439436622,
-0.0447258502,
-0.0323172286,
0.0070878514,
-0.0457483046,
0.0116615305,
0.0260805469,
-0.0183781553,
0.0269933362,
-0.0457224771,
-0.0151398582,
0.038656164,
-0.0409618206,
-0.0616832003,
-0.0155996028,
0.0225312319,
-0.0592805333,
-0.013448921,
-0.0371610187,
-0.0260100514,
0.0518227182,
-0.0000346571,
-0.0184949674,
-0.0799095407,
-0.024162529,
-0.0869877487,
-0.0199113693,
-0.0384110883,
0.0455384143,
0.0310372654,
0.0599036403,
-0.0320830494,
-0.0118534323,
0.0376404002,
-0.0186542738,
0.0059875608,
-0.0740897954,
0.0400270224,
-0.0292496905,
0.0032125763,
-0.0483907089,
0.0130906729,
-0.0570927747,
-0.0169952307,
-0.0601750948,
0.0118297664,
0.0337160751,
-0.0108303064,
0.0062062503,
-0.0655604899,
0.0051918165,
-0.0484497063,
-0.0013397477,
-0.0134077771,
-0.0052105295,
0.0213512685,
-0.0019603076,
-0.0060769836,
-0.0150260432,
-0.044191815,
0.0102319308,
0.0109707005,
0.0052558756,
-0.0172361005,
-0.0008950917,
0.0078364778,
-0.0106567917,
-0.0154817523,
-0.0402218588,
0.0228791349,
-0.0694420487,
0.0339501239,
0.0099019352,
0.0311771575,
0.0145754376,
0.0025502655,
0.0030688944,
0.0259032045,
-0.0073539452,
-0.0507403612,
-0.0089662457,
0.0595812015,
-0.0136224916,
-0.0258319564,
0.0552925579,
0.0127157355,
-0.0344044343,
-0.0012543135,
-0.0476588719,
-0.0220834501,
-0.0085343337,
0.0035882716,
-0.1035454571,
-0.0139738955,
0.0038245239,
0.0291035734,
0.0173520725,
0.0026101323,
-0.0141054001,
-0.1502272785,
-0.0091710649,
0.0406285189,
-0.1037082598,
-0.0046602152,
-0.0153116612,
0.0066569326,
-0.0261000413,
0.0907434151,
-0.0024495234,
-0.0095246825,
0.0060053626,
0.0179865304,
0.049325455,
-0.0649506971,
0.015962299,
-0.0206663515,
0.029466724,
0.0101968255,
0.0127387717,
-0.0288299881,
-0.0527037084,
0.014014788,
-0.0475037619,
-0.0225096215,
-0.0007581415,
0.0389636494,
0.0131759588,
-0.0200881585,
0.0402153321,
-0.031123532,
-0.0060334164,
-0.0068202806,
-0.0149061913,
0.0681506842,
0.0216729827,
-0.0218395311,
0.0463994257,
0.0083599901,
0.0009285555,
0.0637977198,
0.0093547674,
-0.0242145378,
-0.0172229614,
0.0213476866,
-0.0152395535,
-0.0673279613,
-0.0250940062,
0.0757736638,
-0.0823773369,
-0.0679678991,
-0.0423550121,
-0.0975208804,
0.0192703977,
0.0255972557,
0.0360682905,
0.0045923162,
-0.0533510074,
-0.0080261575,
0.0048077013,
0.0069695152,
-0.0269457065,
0.0287417024,
-0.0032147814,
0.030140711,
-0.0107020019,
-0.0064178715,
0.00203849,
0.0012583068,
-0.0500727929,
-0.0394380242,
0.006175003,
0.0385259427,
0.0191501137,
0.016961325,
0.0004294762,
-0.0122183524,
0.02236115,
-0.0024788908,
0.0042253803,
0.0257956255,
0.0233350638,
0.0105162542,
-0.0045209634,
0.0480300412,
-0.0319561064,
-0.003336895,
0.0111012962,
0.0308804829,
-0.0157463253,
-0.0252940264,
0.0139200864,
0.0188701116,
0.0227319598,
-0.0410477445,
-0.014747587,
-0.0112099862,
0.024359297,
-0.0357001685,
-0.0120068472,
-0.0162370224,
-0.0702724829,
0.0633844137,
0.0097477622,
0.0239943117,
0.0264812857,
-0.0143105742,
0.0023428004,
-0.02341168,
0.0153026758,
0.0158308018,
0.0884434059,
-0.0221801773,
0.0450902954,
-0.0074613127,
-0.043861717,
0.0026260293,
0.0534693748,
-0.0351531133,
0.0570271388,
0.0149482787,
0.0301768091,
0.0334230848,
-0.0050336262,
0.0161892958,
-0.03027834,
0.0268934388,
-0.0266204197,
0.0494849645,
-0.0030544729,
0.1055591479,
-0.0037913937,
-0.008306684,
-0.0186925493,
0.0403056443,
-0.0311808754,
0.0111970045,
0.0009806771,
-0.0202120431,
0.015339422,
0.0064769741,
0.0700508878,
-0.00388382,
0.0173872206,
-0.0224841181,
0.0191313904,
-0.0037245674,
-0.0068454049,
0.019862771,
-0.0349588692,
0.0046635736,
-0.0294622146,
-0.0754951313,
-0.0702881739,
0.0173544511,
0.0226869453,
0.0335587971,
0.0221809,
-0.0169926863,
0.07739757,
-0.0208197571,
0.0154096754,
-0.049024608,
-0.0136822723,
0.011669673,
-0.008193057,
-0.0036098214,
-5.676586749e-33,
-0.0399630517,
0.0053833704,
-0.0038937002,
-0.041085232,
-0.017533632,
0.0276888274,
-0.0212404113,
-0.0013798083,
0.0059773908,
0.011657184,
0.0219389442,
0.00135473,
0.0248400792,
-0.0071279327,
0.0459499285,
-0.0139322104,
0.0314328298,
0.0124563994,
-0.0351307206,
-0.0066196756,
0.0620930344,
0.0174000356,
0.1240399256,
-0.0566728339,
0.0828397647,
-0.0115014324,
0.0006832757,
-0.0128922947,
0.0244099181,
0.0309405718,
0.0109413117,
0.0480705202,
0.025265608,
-0.0588703752,
-0.0109999869,
-0.0356709771,
-0.0882382542,
-0.0478317626,
0.0558692254,
0.0636334568,
-0.0255991518,
-0.0208798517,
0.0063610026,
-0.0408194922,
-0.0437424369,
-0.0242183302,
0.0085433237,
-0.0214196257,
-0.0201436486,
0.0400592908,
-0.0939542204,
0.0123179713,
-0.0259860661,
0.0312719047,
0.0559609868,
0.0777830705,
-0.0228072107,
-0.006313209,
-0.0788569003,
-0.0048032803,
-0.0467296764,
0.0339119285,
0.085639894,
0.01102213,
-0.0502311811,
0.0141525548,
0.0627599657,
0.0009802292,
0.0825330392,
0.0014629832,
0.0475422591,
-0.0164508913,
0.0249026362,
0.0973504931,
0.0470059775,
-0.0334987827,
-0.0618639737,
0.0334299505,
-0.0353909321,
0.0432227403,
-0.0144121237,
0.013948584,
-0.039057374,
-0.0233393926,
-0.0344575755,
-0.0494609885,
-0.0379928946,
-0.0467499308,
0.0151568493,
-0.0230479371,
-0.0080678659,
0.0075661968,
0.0794315785,
-0.0073707257,
-0.0115875583,
-0.0258571953,
-0.0310310051,
0.0072833356,
-0.0277606957,
0.0375142321,
-0.0512018949,
-0.0717427507,
-0.0217971839,
0.058794681,
0.0485416465,
-0.0056775757,
0.0783128813,
-0.0102361534,
-0.0509816669,
0.0075942129,
-0.0378650017,
-0.0089777308,
0.0001397726,
0.0252811741,
0.0316181667,
0.0132728629,
-0.0211533811,
0.0080690729,
0.0423247069,
-0.0201932043,
-0.000961085,
0.0192104299,
-0.0068740072,
-0.0255998671,
-0.0411938913,
0.0193097778,
-0.0275849849,
-0.0056697205,
0.0415771343,
-0.0462435894,
-0.0209189337,
0.023165429,
2.621e-7,
0.0202393662,
0.0373112969,
-0.0034701293,
0.0013101385,
-0.0157240052,
0.0115807382,
-0.0791739225,
0.0317083187,
-0.0091911629,
0.0247314107,
0.0107072135,
0.0332165696,
0.097209394,
0.0463836119,
-0.0177399665,
-0.0355462804,
-0.0099461684,
0.0328033976,
-0.0426631272,
0.0306574553,
0.0235968027,
0.0301912166,
-0.0104784658,
0.0106296744,
-0.0195401497,
-0.0221815743,
0.0800977051,
-0.014565832,
-0.026971845,
-0.0046443874,
-0.0073632183,
0.03689567,
-0.0229550526,
0.0384581871,
-0.0228436347,
-0.0130856521,
0.045074515,
0.0277242847,
-0.0006578808,
-0.0111245811,
-0.0002119116,
-0.0080245752,
-0.0116281472,
-0.0188474618,
0.0470916517,
-0.0148775838,
-0.0197837334,
0.0089412946,
-0.0261132363,
0.0464477204,
0.0637456626,
-0.0042952686,
-0.0076142414,
0.0291316863,
0.0455976687,
0.0265107621,
-0.0439072922,
0.0102204485,
0.0033908773,
0.0422005653,
-0.004947756,
-0.0596415475,
0.0074247508,
0.0124458326,
-0.0036700405,
-0.0313753411,
-0.008493443,
1.903451255e-34,
0.0507134087,
-0.0272636302,
0.030090116,
-0.0550634302,
0.0224308781,
-0.0317615978,
-0.0134598482,
0.00186409,
-0.0084225992,
-0.02177516,
0.0082217455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02078v1 | Exploring the Robustness of Task-oriented Dialogue Systems for Colloquial German Varieties | 2024-02-03T08:16:43 | 2024-02-03T08:16:43 | Ekaterina Artemova, Verena Blaschke, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mainstream cross-lingual task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems leverage the
transfer learning paradigm by training a joint model for intent recognition and
slot-filling in English and applying it, zero-shot, to other languages. We
address a gap in prior research, which often overlooked the transfer to
lower-resource colloquial varieties due to limited test data. Inspired by prior
work on English varieties, we craft and manually evaluate perturbation rules
that transform German sentences into colloquial forms and use them to
synthesize test sets in four ToD datasets. Our perturbation rules cover 18
distinct language phenomena, enabling us to explore the impact of each
perturbation on slot and intent performance. Using these new datasets, we
conduct an experimental evaluation across six different transformers. Here, we
demonstrate that when applied to colloquial varieties, ToD systems maintain
their intent recognition performance, losing 6% (4.62 percentage points) in
accuracy on average. However, they exhibit a significant drop in slot
detection, with a decrease of 31% (21 percentage points) in slot F1 score. Our
findings are further supported by a transfer experiment from Standard American
English to synthetic Urban African American Vernacular English. | [
0.0580638126,
0.0307532977,
-0.0044555701,
0.0321676359,
-0.0294547342,
-0.000876917,
0.0083993897,
-0.0210110508,
0.0031881703,
-0.0415591411,
-0.0763819814,
-0.0535401404,
0.0155914864,
0.0349180624,
0.0108072888,
-0.0284202825,
0.0368928723,
-0.0155229066,
0.0090899104,
0.0228060465,
-0.0071288482,
0.0000204251,
-0.0426018089,
0.0550355352,
-0.0108168134,
0.014974595,
-0.0374856144,
0.0226751603,
-0.0125106042,
0.0184190422,
0.0340884477,
0.0688845366,
-0.0150250141,
0.0245781709,
0.0000019032,
-0.0730130896,
0.0022368378,
-0.0456950106,
-0.0651434809,
-0.025662493,
0.0003404357,
-0.0031602732,
-0.0293791834,
0.0128459884,
-0.0483974256,
-0.0248266496,
0.0572039932,
0.0500916317,
0.0326142386,
0.0798261464,
-0.0124307303,
0.0256320983,
0.0274601001,
-0.012618769,
0.0124348244,
-0.073940523,
0.0319193229,
0.04300154,
-0.0025156429,
-0.0068206103,
-0.0248951241,
0.0130054001,
0.0091801388,
-0.0431974567,
0.0111189317,
-0.0007246576,
-0.0131066507,
-0.0081987316,
-0.0603435636,
0.0873929039,
0.0186630748,
-0.0150594041,
-0.0282931104,
0.0150589878,
-0.0040598242,
-0.0186165515,
-0.0545739532,
-0.0180521086,
0.0034835108,
-0.0035115588,
0.0142670516,
-0.0098682446,
-0.027564982,
0.004014709,
-0.0257870741,
0.0828060433,
0.0104636345,
-0.0390571319,
0.0214949865,
0.0110699646,
0.0504135676,
-0.0813059956,
0.0228912178,
-0.0069409129,
-0.071670942,
0.0072249975,
-0.0154011222,
-0.0122577054,
0.0019934112,
-0.0093850764,
0.0405640304,
0.0438938774,
-0.0572649315,
0.0266993642,
0.031712234,
0.0570223294,
0.007813869,
0.0242897272,
-0.0453863628,
-0.0180048849,
-0.0804387704,
0.0259655025,
-0.0410308801,
0.0108355656,
-0.0520923026,
0.0069207707,
-0.0292066745,
0.0207063127,
0.0076716812,
-0.022307856,
0.0136501621,
-0.0063503776,
-0.0406880528,
0.0029183009,
-0.0270023048,
0.0824560151,
0.0127151534,
0.0430869833,
0.0032658535,
-0.0584470667,
-0.0406270884,
0.0140773728,
0.0150282364,
-0.0629869476,
-0.003902775,
0.0220340285,
-0.0540708937,
-0.025292784,
-0.0245572012,
-0.0002925798,
-0.0641007349,
-0.0876261145,
-0.0405215323,
-0.0479938798,
0.0087605882,
0.0116955694,
0.0344143212,
-0.0406105593,
-0.0047868281,
0.0043588309,
-0.0456293002,
0.0701068044,
-0.0091140261,
0.0165809616,
-0.0008146292,
-0.0166694783,
-0.0560320206,
0.0391311049,
0.0127564333,
0.008317587,
0.0329335555,
-0.013754637,
-0.0181939453,
0.0163910463,
0.0097759962,
0.0060403869,
0.0557130873,
0.0106292656,
0.0164767914,
-0.0064504789,
0.0526232831,
0.0710174888,
-0.0247725248,
-0.000816122,
0.0610365644,
0.0399645008,
0.0195827633,
0.0056315344,
0.0563359633,
0.072988525,
0.0079725664,
0.0243005175,
-0.0542168356,
-0.0289687905,
-0.0325258821,
-0.0286463778,
0.0032181086,
0.0258869547,
-0.0291642006,
-0.0044170516,
0.0013101996,
-0.0036103907,
0.0505739637,
-0.0172428899,
0.0468578376,
0.0273028612,
-0.0252051055,
0.0583187006,
0.0263291635,
-0.0244440287,
-0.0315436162,
-0.0357561521,
-0.0150542054,
0.0398205146,
-0.0016508788,
0.0057868911,
-0.0708194226,
-0.0392620862,
0.0299598053,
0.0124298045,
0.0733863711,
-0.0144922091,
0.0715501755,
-0.0516953059,
0.0045123375,
-0.0009175848,
-0.0006507069,
0.007514501,
-0.0200545397,
0.0097424155,
0.0040800534,
-0.0292098206,
0.0170882624,
-0.0052447827,
0.0040762764,
0.0027784954,
0.0617581233,
0.0155325318,
0.012033022,
0.0377772227,
0.0125485258,
-0.0312257353,
-0.0041250195,
-0.02069683,
0.0253967289,
0.0775892511,
-0.0645594001,
-0.0428924896,
0.0141221955,
-0.0026207543,
-0.0399204753,
0.0101108607,
0.0016704098,
-0.0817747191,
0.0221543591,
-0.0318730883,
0.0284895469,
-0.0687279105,
0.0067808866,
0.0256909579,
0.0398762897,
-0.0171413049,
0.0004664755,
0.0405658074,
-0.0058220471,
0.0605673492,
-0.0332783796,
0.0397391692,
-0.0294434596,
0.0114785656,
0.002957379,
-0.0559289455,
-0.0203326605,
-0.0026665083,
0.0357956178,
-0.0537909456,
0.006453136,
-0.1021791101,
0.0100883534,
-0.0350271501,
0.0233680401,
0.0125414096,
0.0179871637,
-0.009711151,
-0.0202384405,
-0.0259001553,
-0.0133129684,
0.0179860983,
-0.0059550311,
0.0196037795,
-0.0006153706,
-0.0111126127,
-0.0198428947,
0.0326042958,
-0.0043079313,
0.0177914761,
-0.0571902767,
-0.0344053544,
-0.0415647589,
0.0424555838,
0.0257639177,
0.0047196136,
0.0050072391,
-0.0206626412,
-0.0018344853,
0.0200661682,
0.0427664183,
0.0506072938,
-0.0119051039,
-0.0059625683,
-0.0061151818,
-0.063704446,
-0.042570971,
0.0318322442,
-0.0008568962,
-0.0059784576,
-0.0726239681,
-0.0495650172,
0.0081766564,
0.040280655,
0.0132108014,
0.0122962045,
-0.0616306961,
-0.0210613757,
-0.014891983,
-0.0481027849,
0.0003520073,
0.0228192341,
-0.0428964309,
0.0031152442,
-0.0297302175,
-0.0088767018,
0.0537639521,
-0.0092974091,
-0.0593591444,
-0.0447171554,
-0.0040538693,
-0.0307439454,
0.0322415642,
-0.0318689533,
0.0124581419,
0.082284905,
-0.0713881999,
-0.0126645137,
0.0019033673,
-0.0057875635,
0.0021740138,
0.059368737,
-0.0495096594,
-0.0055536497,
-0.0145323388,
-0.0774107128,
-0.049644772,
-0.0506218188,
-0.0143255694,
0.0365148038,
0.0217512716,
-0.0222444404,
0.0183128491,
0.0034457075,
0.00286546,
0.0257909633,
-0.0176310036,
-0.0019528723,
-0.0000905623,
0.0465457365,
0.0400134213,
0.0812087655,
-0.0318055153,
0.0439732037,
0.0350757092,
0.0283522923,
0.0100300489,
0.005396829,
0.0034744998,
0.0269429963,
0.052415777,
-0.0000356953,
-0.0280747507,
0.0152796283,
0.0967581347,
0.0073472187,
-0.02331689,
0.0885764211,
0.0233440176,
-0.0113724191,
-0.0124172429,
-0.0328816921,
0.027041411,
0.0072222631,
0.0393862948,
-0.1049726084,
-0.0508791097,
0.0258107521,
-0.004019171,
-0.0244031195,
-0.0202125218,
-0.0289829317,
-0.125875771,
0.0408925936,
-0.0247545913,
-0.0436486416,
0.0123638241,
-0.0115164192,
0.0300775412,
-0.0332484692,
0.033099141,
-0.0165390242,
-0.0060228589,
-0.0387828536,
0.0403617509,
-0.0099817021,
-0.0524139218,
0.0187391639,
-0.0132211922,
0.0865954086,
0.00039439,
0.031973388,
0.0123509504,
-0.0148129882,
-0.0213632006,
0.0112819597,
-0.0178663079,
-0.0207739342,
0.0299416743,
0.0097894967,
-0.011609925,
0.0004233617,
0.0358498842,
-0.0233030934,
-0.0346080214,
0.0175432097,
0.0598868877,
-0.0382857844,
0.0181819983,
0.0237805694,
0.005371029,
0.0755555779,
0.0973536819,
0.0492158234,
-0.0427518934,
-0.0133403931,
-0.0241413917,
-0.023508504,
-0.0567698032,
-0.0064754169,
0.0175422244,
-0.0227533169,
-0.0202580616,
-0.0263071954,
-0.0330410413,
0.0103995968,
0.04709417,
0.0588020794,
0.0020633927,
0.019188147,
-0.0124334348,
-0.0231439713,
0.0048801489,
-0.0217164271,
0.0593894012,
-0.0499029718,
-0.0353758447,
0.0178663153,
-0.0315527953,
0.0009322732,
-0.0109656397,
-0.0804271474,
-0.0581122153,
0.0102629559,
0.047850851,
0.0222764332,
0.0274797846,
-0.0098292567,
-0.0212654658,
-0.0287624672,
-0.0271295253,
-0.0174843427,
0.0108966064,
0.0852533504,
-0.0217968691,
0.0003233564,
0.0321210362,
-0.0002517354,
0.0344473086,
0.0169043541,
0.035023272,
-0.0563769676,
-0.0135827754,
0.0149919111,
-0.0083688181,
0.0576183535,
0.011180697,
-0.058317963,
-0.0287327319,
0.0547776185,
-0.0033939732,
0.0044566812,
-0.0542783625,
-0.0116505222,
0.0112727303,
0.0024556122,
0.0043637212,
0.0058368384,
-0.0607236512,
0.048999887,
-0.0312155243,
-0.0036938398,
0.0467394851,
-0.009909085,
-0.0084747924,
-0.0021925701,
-0.0275045112,
0.0114597734,
0.0760179982,
0.0604275838,
0.0029156387,
0.0792931691,
0.0075129177,
-0.0512632206,
0.034997724,
0.025789611,
-0.0366755053,
0.0151100047,
0.0148350699,
0.0142343957,
0.0348900892,
-0.0139999976,
0.0787553638,
-0.0216971133,
0.0271079894,
-0.015216806,
0.0325899348,
-0.0077495249,
0.0068080202,
0.0394482762,
-0.0131371496,
-0.0151124522,
0.0228634384,
0.0228220075,
-0.0231221002,
-0.00932639,
0.0223344304,
-0.0009995395,
-0.0429112948,
-0.0296133328,
0.0349409729,
0.0107246805,
-0.0056763147,
0.0031532706,
-0.0562702864,
-0.0523662604,
0.0210157074,
-0.0325230137,
0.0342114158,
-0.0151829273,
0.0139687536,
0.0429956391,
-0.0267013405,
-0.0129299071,
-0.027082812,
-0.0146110011,
0.0058688079,
-0.0184513591,
-0.0379891731,
-6.270363843e-33,
-0.0011014375,
-0.0059923385,
0.0000109768,
-0.0061933454,
-0.0329963304,
-0.0102445893,
-0.0439498499,
0.0107626151,
-0.0158851165,
0.0181607213,
-0.0186736844,
-0.0245741345,
0.0351953581,
0.0427096784,
0.0106697716,
-0.0038481508,
0.0209823102,
0.0271142293,
-0.0215892065,
-0.0014901995,
0.0332439505,
0.0412707888,
0.0787951052,
-0.0484830104,
0.0251576416,
0.0526785143,
-0.0139570478,
0.0237002149,
0.0388608389,
0.0577163994,
-0.0001196021,
0.0705616176,
0.0266854055,
-0.0555767082,
0.0135634542,
0.065587081,
-0.0926963389,
-0.027508907,
0.0757328942,
0.0292846691,
0.0320757031,
-0.0201786533,
-0.023547221,
-0.0243340712,
-0.027800167,
0.0329651237,
-0.002893059,
-0.0182628427,
0.0043612621,
0.0296522323,
-0.1039846838,
0.0110082971,
-0.012637849,
-0.0753540248,
0.0012154244,
0.0761570558,
-0.0025081143,
-0.0965869948,
-0.0147891156,
0.0336926579,
-0.0361070037,
0.0079902112,
0.0375423804,
0.0263637975,
-0.0304874033,
0.0503598303,
0.030080907,
0.0081792856,
0.0232733414,
-0.0346882418,
0.0136517724,
0.0488333628,
-0.012654379,
0.0500225239,
0.0165449772,
0.0186828543,
-0.0340413526,
0.0161553975,
0.0458746627,
0.0402986184,
-0.0187175088,
0.0060063633,
-0.0684901625,
-0.0467900932,
0.0003916585,
0.00619049,
-0.0171284098,
-0.0452500731,
0.0560556687,
-0.0203798357,
0.0000838616,
0.0300930943,
0.0727369115,
-0.0401758738,
-0.0152695617,
0.0140248304,
-0.0417534858,
0.006138471,
-0.02193968,
0.0051200986,
-0.1007401571,
-0.0441647321,
0.0279679634,
0.0521985516,
0.0311052464,
0.0153174056,
0.0523906983,
0.0284346081,
-0.0424156524,
0.0006114002,
-0.0425163545,
0.0586948991,
-0.0538754314,
0.0654424727,
0.0344274901,
0.0458272733,
-0.0334097594,
0.053570088,
0.0192301199,
-0.0256693419,
-0.0489012599,
-0.0349005982,
0.026120536,
0.0356946588,
-0.0153226927,
0.0024639929,
0.0203771573,
-0.0342838205,
-0.0367722623,
-0.0239043497,
-0.0118379276,
-0.016245205,
2.778e-7,
0.0095412806,
0.0286022834,
0.0085464492,
0.0158441812,
-0.0169390216,
0.037173219,
-0.0288577676,
0.0362497568,
0.0373894721,
-0.0001432048,
0.0178062133,
-0.0064432528,
0.0801407918,
0.0308779664,
-0.129758656,
-0.0407498144,
0.0023968604,
-0.026307648,
-0.0388341174,
0.0190583616,
0.053658206,
0.0766738132,
0.0102686733,
-0.0279808771,
0.0020110377,
-0.0247335192,
0.011532139,
-0.0480360352,
-0.0059638442,
0.0338050574,
0.0269447956,
-0.0350041352,
0.0008267195,
0.0600462854,
-0.0204203613,
0.0359191298,
0.0007201265,
0.0442396142,
-0.0002387293,
-0.0801402628,
-0.0614261515,
-0.0041055763,
0.0115606384,
-0.0541044287,
0.0578946359,
-0.0487362444,
-0.0345188864,
-0.023191208,
-0.0056673535,
0.011282092,
0.021594584,
-0.01667629,
-0.0032329531,
-0.0134172803,
0.0469471067,
-0.0129473954,
-0.0065110088,
-0.0441343002,
-0.0054654367,
0.0262691863,
-0.0067232917,
-0.0439953171,
-0.0012250788,
-0.0491302423,
-0.028059639,
-0.0313074999,
0.0133824479,
2.312278203e-34,
0.0282463524,
0.0052581429,
0.0742037818,
0.0389091372,
0.0114040878,
0.0009317423,
-0.0133862253,
-0.0040307678,
0.0246873312,
-0.0525865033,
-0.0055253175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02077v1 | Investigating Content Planning for Navigating Trade-offs in Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue | 2024-02-03T08:16:39 | 2024-02-03T08:16:39 | Kushal Chawla, Hannah Rashkin, Gaurav Singh Tomar, David Reitter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-grounded dialogue generation is a challenging task because it
requires satisfying two fundamental yet often competing constraints: being
responsive in a manner that is specific to what the conversation partner has
said while also being attributable to an underlying source document. In this
work, we bring this trade-off between these two objectives (specificity and
attribution) to light and ask the question: Can explicit content planning
before the response generation help the model to address this challenge? To
answer this question, we design a framework called PLEDGE, which allows us to
experiment with various plan variables explored in prior work, supporting both
metric-agnostic and metric-aware approaches. While content planning shows
promise, our results on whether it can actually help to navigate this trade-off
are mixed -- planning mechanisms that are metric-aware (use automatic metrics
during training) are better at automatic evaluations but underperform in human
judgment compared to metric-agnostic mechanisms. We discuss how this may be
caused by over-fitting to automatic metrics and the need for future work to
better calibrate these metrics towards human judgment. We hope the observations
from our analysis will inform future work that aims to apply content planning
in this context. | [
0.0823096186,
0.048282221,
-0.0034924266,
-0.00808651,
-0.0278463364,
-0.0107298549,
-0.0038689803,
-0.0141764469,
0.0002575081,
-0.0430747233,
-0.0115361577,
0.0151307071,
-0.0096549103,
0.0367337205,
0.0093080588,
-0.0879712626,
0.0171715096,
-0.0065778238,
0.0187670942,
0.0014832477,
-0.0034383084,
0.0133036217,
-0.0177660957,
0.0367495976,
-0.0719163939,
-0.0026125836,
-0.0461251028,
0.0138218142,
0.0209866129,
-0.0168678574,
0.0151533773,
0.0574734434,
-0.0163706783,
0.006279774,
0.0000019614,
-0.0354832374,
0.0209030267,
-0.0362453498,
-0.0191402361,
-0.0248767752,
-0.0228723884,
-0.0055967453,
0.0274008512,
0.0085311076,
-0.0720369145,
0.0451104753,
0.0015180359,
0.0651378557,
0.042656064,
0.0803395808,
-0.0197889768,
-0.0103729088,
-0.0226279423,
-0.0183398463,
0.0003769099,
-0.0540868565,
-0.02667596,
0.0544011071,
0.0089041572,
0.0384432934,
-0.0119169811,
0.0026013332,
0.0258690137,
-0.0567916296,
0.0396205075,
0.0157828685,
-0.0159101449,
-0.0445408784,
-0.0287077669,
0.0759404525,
0.066112496,
0.0103349788,
0.0418496206,
-0.0415730588,
0.02810538,
-0.0227289014,
-0.0334171467,
0.0020401275,
-0.0015848129,
-0.0204751808,
-0.065408729,
0.0169319939,
-0.0004601006,
0.0248179454,
0.0059711668,
0.0519194566,
-0.0325894058,
-0.0195380468,
0.016343981,
0.0262285508,
0.0089490907,
-0.1112875864,
-0.0018900324,
0.0609018914,
-0.0409059189,
0.0107336724,
-0.0477223471,
0.0318162404,
0.0283571426,
0.0006134445,
0.0046857335,
0.0383634642,
0.014415686,
0.0392495655,
0.0065781362,
0.0824766755,
-0.0018031554,
-0.0050624176,
-0.0238928385,
0.0483993068,
-0.0325739831,
-0.0157830659,
-0.0393459834,
0.022399338,
-0.0798561126,
-0.0629801601,
-0.0027465515,
0.0497514606,
-0.0088715721,
0.030579146,
0.0234752186,
0.0463396087,
-0.0386707745,
0.0017004085,
-0.0492935926,
0.0095854197,
-0.0878614038,
0.0194779411,
0.0468856953,
-0.0238642879,
-0.0022381602,
0.0624916665,
0.0041731517,
0.0112338569,
-0.0129942084,
0.0471325628,
-0.0398371294,
0.0022573189,
0.0150340833,
-0.0875284746,
-0.0587390736,
-0.0554555319,
0.0193363503,
-0.0224915128,
0.0310802311,
0.0228573568,
-0.0285943355,
-0.0258502997,
0.0009451592,
-0.0040248111,
-0.0030072157,
0.0087336898,
0.0383332483,
0.0258564875,
0.0218329374,
0.0274684504,
-0.0517488047,
0.0771862492,
0.0321120583,
0.04374272,
0.0237955898,
0.0257517323,
-0.0420567095,
-0.0193050932,
0.0293957274,
0.0082081007,
0.0301340744,
0.0189043079,
-0.020218445,
0.0308728479,
0.0227716286,
0.0359044895,
-0.0376363285,
-0.0019789473,
0.0473631099,
0.0379483216,
-0.0084849605,
0.02686706,
0.0425306335,
0.0365821384,
-0.0172746889,
0.0484757833,
-0.0047207419,
0.0634560883,
0.0377136357,
-0.0019946722,
0.0707488135,
0.0037611574,
-0.0397825949,
-0.0587702617,
-0.0079084747,
0.009191581,
0.0056974683,
-0.0133070312,
-0.0227640513,
0.0358244143,
-0.0414030179,
0.034485016,
-0.0483084135,
-0.0350126848,
0.0237071794,
-0.0276212245,
0.0565055646,
0.0343058594,
0.0650637299,
-0.0134119987,
-0.040185269,
0.0011577447,
0.0194592774,
0.0593369715,
0.0820827633,
-0.0409089848,
-0.007388006,
-0.0594042018,
-0.0338974632,
-0.063449271,
0.0025153619,
0.0168529768,
0.0504937507,
0.0249735229,
0.0222652517,
0.0113665136,
0.0179190226,
0.0241597723,
0.0046064095,
0.0038735291,
0.0187674388,
0.0036347664,
0.0377021283,
0.0383733362,
0.0166167244,
0.0115846144,
0.0240899902,
0.0079086646,
-0.0299905557,
0.0474190377,
-0.0704977363,
-0.0125716841,
0.0160964988,
-0.0401251167,
-0.0097399252,
-0.0559728108,
-0.0163331311,
-0.0654966384,
0.0400045328,
-0.0244210344,
0.0036265128,
-0.0452504568,
-0.010779921,
0.0447458178,
-0.0192179922,
-0.0133958943,
0.039001707,
0.0035796699,
-0.0078306785,
0.0587746724,
-0.007901785,
0.0345487148,
-0.0319896638,
0.0404571109,
0.0152512146,
-0.0265340507,
-0.007444188,
0.0528425723,
0.0187446475,
-0.0647371411,
-0.063143827,
-0.1117607728,
-0.0132917808,
-0.0378706641,
-0.0006859746,
0.0208492409,
0.0279889312,
0.0008536798,
-0.0192999709,
-0.0639673099,
-0.0204528105,
0.032283511,
0.0039089508,
0.0313506983,
0.0356021151,
0.0752903298,
-0.0161296055,
0.031338051,
0.0299700517,
-0.0022994017,
0.0410245545,
-0.0045808689,
-0.0423027277,
0.0554291904,
-0.0658626407,
-0.0061226878,
-0.0063275103,
-0.0232851245,
0.0376924127,
0.0108449487,
0.0429034531,
0.0343291909,
0.0302254986,
0.0153428791,
0.0135588273,
-0.0185578912,
-0.0768435523,
0.0563557111,
-0.0492522046,
0.0061934707,
-0.0377477594,
0.0011485304,
0.0266562551,
0.0435835719,
-0.000197573,
0.0215391163,
-0.0821980461,
0.0136584369,
-0.0034652152,
-0.0636375844,
0.0026742024,
-0.0269323252,
-0.0152748115,
0.0749100447,
-0.0099204639,
-0.026078688,
0.0662607774,
0.0070435051,
-0.008949697,
-0.0255815443,
0.0474283323,
-0.026970204,
0.0306187924,
-0.0311490111,
0.0005778857,
-0.0544998236,
-0.0127233611,
-0.0523935966,
-0.0147423521,
0.0252645109,
0.0027884252,
0.0067499033,
-0.0398576967,
-0.0065705944,
-0.0042646569,
-0.0384405553,
-0.0456687249,
-0.006438924,
-0.0172410365,
-0.003227633,
-0.0084504224,
-0.0294505972,
-0.0200404841,
-0.0091403294,
0.0213034227,
0.0492440015,
-0.0246528648,
-0.0007159763,
-0.0101171667,
0.0389573574,
0.04014498,
0.053030286,
0.0341329761,
-0.0254223272,
0.0376603156,
0.0457512103,
0.0322683938,
0.0113799591,
0.0268653203,
0.0010454853,
0.0022890833,
0.0162770618,
-0.0028363799,
0.0359426066,
0.0782783478,
0.0017317047,
-0.0434207432,
0.0960919783,
0.0360348076,
-0.0098124398,
-0.0065981322,
-0.0581336059,
0.0768157616,
0.0120607801,
0.0236710552,
-0.0764046907,
-0.0100513324,
0.004316885,
0.0318776369,
-0.023470128,
-0.0578157455,
-0.0209745206,
-0.0623494387,
0.0399022698,
-0.0186871439,
-0.0064825714,
-0.0005081178,
-0.0153976493,
0.0009427408,
0.0197707117,
-0.0024554846,
-0.0112041291,
0.0277202278,
0.0161892604,
0.0262370333,
-0.0232398901,
-0.0164112393,
-0.0251810085,
0.0237697028,
0.0209740605,
0.0488348939,
0.0593361817,
0.0581174828,
-0.0097294059,
-0.0182548985,
0.0155625856,
0.0369050391,
-0.0143844476,
0.0243631396,
-0.0174938627,
0.019558195,
-0.0123389876,
0.0585881621,
-0.007411757,
-0.0383919552,
0.0305052549,
0.0363288336,
-0.0618265644,
-0.0135888141,
-0.0251887944,
0.05829845,
0.042539265,
0.0886190608,
0.055534672,
-0.0352736227,
-0.0324667506,
0.01807894,
0.0460612737,
-0.1011517942,
0.0260612108,
-0.0121794594,
0.0091407262,
0.0394269861,
-0.1095237285,
-0.0715118423,
0.0091490336,
0.0300498549,
-0.0029602798,
-0.0640856698,
-0.030042531,
0.0026613888,
-0.0058885915,
0.0063150511,
0.0036139644,
-0.0127757192,
-0.0686533302,
-0.0348391607,
-0.0018378129,
-0.0581198782,
0.0061221053,
0.023998186,
-0.0685260966,
-0.0615455247,
-0.0248847082,
0.0509866066,
0.0277331602,
0.0565713644,
0.000590813,
-0.0230603926,
0.0451043583,
0.0410736576,
-0.0980219394,
0.0379442461,
0.0318641476,
0.0410234742,
-0.0218172148,
0.0436958224,
-0.039685145,
0.0168225579,
-0.0056669433,
0.0409093685,
-0.0170877837,
-0.0795542598,
-0.0137763973,
-0.0104019577,
-0.0274688657,
-0.0183724053,
-0.0129411025,
-0.0159108993,
0.0295469016,
-0.0078699002,
-0.032596495,
-0.0450128354,
-0.0044485927,
-0.0219830386,
0.0162428953,
-0.0052831704,
0.0267141294,
-0.0197057426,
0.0695254281,
0.0008683489,
-0.0056274538,
0.0315859877,
-0.010672274,
0.0016831653,
-0.0010154134,
-0.0211967491,
0.0086978078,
-0.0194332339,
0.0346264243,
0.0215977784,
0.0868697092,
0.0385043658,
-0.0228631012,
0.038029775,
-0.0085059125,
-0.0721845999,
-0.0446614958,
0.0048589855,
0.0258379169,
-0.0241255015,
0.0009415175,
0.0472657606,
-0.0590488873,
-0.0015874797,
0.0095135551,
0.0231337585,
0.0054532364,
-0.0402957052,
-0.0032642165,
0.0264471602,
-0.0147114303,
-0.0036935946,
0.0457810424,
-0.0443646833,
0.0371526182,
-0.0387304872,
-0.0152726285,
-0.0660904571,
-0.0666290447,
-0.0049457969,
0.023080593,
0.0125121875,
0.0071455678,
-0.0858168378,
-0.0475914702,
0.0011948708,
0.0180128999,
-0.020736929,
-0.0161141418,
0.0400690138,
0.0496026836,
-0.0097849295,
0.0025605545,
-0.0328893773,
0.0033545978,
-0.039737571,
-0.0295956489,
-0.0348753259,
-5.715969483e-33,
-0.0547411852,
-0.0540679879,
0.0243180171,
-0.0142861977,
-0.0362391248,
0.0106792301,
-0.0488632135,
-0.0008619187,
-0.0009997943,
0.0153697217,
-0.0380958505,
-0.0081622479,
0.0077074207,
0.0163128581,
-0.004054042,
-0.0147954747,
0.0302260537,
-0.0335728861,
-0.0520057753,
0.0669821575,
0.0482507348,
-0.0058763027,
-0.0137448562,
-0.044163309,
0.0062556234,
0.0430489294,
-0.0128444452,
0.0054069669,
0.0254583135,
0.0600797385,
-0.0301149264,
-0.0093452316,
0.0205371808,
-0.0084167859,
-0.0205961764,
0.0510479845,
-0.0498969778,
-0.0570798852,
0.0363135487,
0.0043748599,
-0.0460198745,
-0.0305493008,
-0.0096727386,
-0.0121604837,
-0.0124509605,
-0.0137970336,
0.0138466405,
-0.0001562156,
-0.0205160361,
-0.033359319,
-0.0538987294,
0.00827369,
-0.0442406051,
-0.024216298,
0.0216891114,
0.07768251,
0.0222635195,
-0.0270935223,
0.0021698996,
0.0398981087,
-0.0218266416,
0.0218341853,
0.0394485779,
0.0133022973,
0.0087387469,
0.0696831718,
-0.0197821315,
0.0139273768,
-0.0306194816,
-0.0273104589,
0.0110425865,
0.0403412022,
0.0226717051,
0.054858949,
-0.0322849713,
-0.0041593481,
-0.0231022257,
0.0248730648,
0.0071621663,
0.0225936789,
0.0168581158,
-0.009864958,
-0.0250953417,
-0.0087672472,
-0.0281384494,
-0.0273123793,
-0.0146617489,
-0.0249330755,
0.0339721926,
0.0613240525,
-0.0288088713,
0.005588342,
0.0342893489,
-0.0233916398,
0.0424402021,
0.0710899383,
-0.0550201535,
0.0239756145,
0.0042907572,
-0.0031121983,
-0.0590054914,
-0.0026259359,
0.0542779267,
0.018956149,
0.0069146813,
0.0233394764,
0.0023929086,
0.0201659966,
-0.0273777563,
-0.0001082938,
-0.0351607762,
0.0824435651,
-0.0379576571,
-0.0299400408,
-0.0007094888,
0.0064525437,
-0.0497412272,
0.0309825111,
0.0075897099,
-0.0208873171,
-0.0257652681,
-0.0485703945,
0.0362123698,
0.0094341971,
-0.0638237149,
-0.0097988863,
0.026425017,
-0.0258039106,
0.0137705794,
-0.0272628143,
-0.0163591132,
0.0368344784,
2.658e-7,
-0.0213510394,
0.0130108977,
0.0616692789,
-0.0190171432,
0.0171435382,
0.0054589082,
0.0220447909,
0.0319590904,
0.0030910857,
-0.0530783422,
0.05309885,
0.0119117778,
0.0650539175,
0.0170068555,
-0.1087147295,
0.0136254132,
-0.072064653,
-0.045050174,
-0.0253546406,
-0.0570520647,
0.0296583343,
0.0009263892,
-0.0050076731,
0.0024023587,
-0.015623332,
0.0137970084,
0.0402179286,
-0.03073618,
0.0295713674,
0.0140036205,
0.0770374835,
-0.0324145555,
-0.0061136344,
0.0336577371,
-0.0206534043,
0.0388553664,
0.0101479571,
0.0603936464,
0.0375766866,
-0.0848282054,
-0.0284261294,
-0.0157098994,
0.0329227634,
-0.0631024465,
0.0320795327,
-0.0255411603,
-0.0022834279,
-0.0132334242,
-0.0312893353,
-0.0288245734,
-0.0200124178,
-0.02202636,
0.0115263462,
0.0406098738,
0.0016673147,
0.00637057,
0.0628253818,
-0.0702587813,
-0.0067566172,
-0.0280512497,
-0.0631239414,
-0.0466903187,
-0.0621306114,
0.006117289,
-0.0200461671,
-0.0478232577,
-0.0275802054,
2.129999896e-34,
0.0094483644,
-0.0036790923,
0.0021049203,
-0.0118972939,
0.0318760909,
0.0174329244,
0.0155213336,
-0.0037642519,
0.0509286374,
-0.0711480305,
-0.0378429405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02057v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02057v1 | Break the Sequential Dependency of LLM Inference Using Lookahead Decoding | 2024-02-03T06:37:50 | 2024-02-03T06:37:50 | Yichao Fu, Peter Bailis, Ion Stoica, Hao Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Autoregressive decoding of large language models (LLMs) is memory bandwidth
bounded, resulting in high latency and significant wastes of the parallel
processing power of modern accelerators. Existing methods for accelerating LLM
decoding often require a draft model (e.g., speculative decoding), which is
nontrivial to obtain and unable to generalize. In this paper, we introduce
Lookahead decoding, an exact, parallel decoding algorithm that accelerates LLM
decoding without needing auxiliary models or data stores. It allows trading
per-step log(FLOPs) to reduce the number of total decoding steps, is more
parallelizable on single or multiple modern accelerators, and is compatible
with concurrent memory-efficient attention (e.g., FlashAttention). Our
implementation of Lookahead decoding can speed up autoregressive decoding by up
to 1.8x on MT-bench and 4x with strong scaling on multiple GPUs in code
completion tasks. Our code is avialable at
https://github.com/hao-ai-lab/LookaheadDecoding | [
-0.0004216789,
0.0981528535,
0.0012011485,
0.0653081611,
-0.0120112905,
0.0342320055,
-0.0214729942,
0.0071957018,
0.0174019355,
-0.0116869044,
-0.0122309327,
-0.0201049279,
0.0088995388,
0.047033336,
0.0095350826,
0.0081849433,
0.0483171605,
-0.0589301549,
0.0117239933,
-0.0117177991,
-0.0116804503,
0.0265684556,
0.0008523834,
0.0474718697,
0.0370019488,
-0.0378806107,
-0.0117107537,
0.0036307662,
-0.0103589566,
-0.0010477422,
-0.0056619602,
0.0090279644,
-0.0229992289,
0.0176714398,
0.0000022422,
-0.0065890248,
-0.0154840993,
-0.0205797069,
-0.0367416255,
0.0356970765,
0.0313278846,
-0.0513231941,
-0.0367783494,
0.0153668076,
-0.0072889859,
-0.0612995885,
0.0530885272,
-0.0185509436,
0.0122502847,
0.0395960771,
0.0063482528,
-0.0472728796,
0.0477710329,
-0.0467381962,
0.0102959201,
-0.0597315952,
0.0007477033,
0.0130458549,
0.0019388077,
-0.0079089748,
-0.0352901854,
0.0488454737,
0.0196225457,
0.0095731989,
-0.0101197809,
0.0270514581,
0.0132556101,
-0.0263264943,
-0.0166875273,
0.052694831,
-0.0480849557,
-0.0397914723,
-0.0101071484,
-0.0224187039,
-0.0258173812,
-0.0157815889,
-0.025763154,
0.0618028268,
-0.0382231548,
0.0151066417,
0.0884149224,
-0.0092171831,
0.0447699167,
-0.00312595,
-0.0518091209,
0.0792398304,
0.0175538864,
0.0192534178,
-0.0208564252,
0.0250208862,
0.0218584575,
-0.0360170119,
0.0466861539,
0.0138129666,
-0.0109163001,
0.0159342233,
-0.0488587394,
-0.031123627,
0.0023908191,
-0.0277327038,
0.0569511205,
0.1003236696,
-0.0215251446,
0.0249698199,
-0.0397194624,
0.037933819,
-0.0440328084,
-0.037936084,
-0.0543866083,
0.0049469494,
0.0328039341,
-0.0077294828,
-0.0387019031,
0.0308803637,
-0.0478071235,
0.0010261374,
-0.0116862087,
0.0561500415,
0.0118550705,
0.0065464703,
-0.0067398273,
-0.0060212226,
-0.0431256779,
-0.0059962212,
0.0426974967,
0.0512971878,
-0.034025237,
-0.0298989508,
-0.0390331037,
-0.0930205733,
-0.037404377,
0.0239163525,
-0.0064147236,
-0.0150982598,
0.0034396995,
0.056337595,
-0.0134386634,
-0.0053449348,
-0.0592645369,
-0.0023830677,
0.0482933447,
-0.0144348582,
0.0001977818,
-0.0573440194,
0.0309708193,
0.0300017726,
0.0109158196,
-0.0581403375,
-0.0033145195,
0.0308561288,
-0.0336501412,
0.0317970999,
-0.0269145053,
-0.028136218,
0.0018360943,
0.008311918,
-0.0144500788,
0.0860232413,
0.0238433518,
0.0355769694,
-0.0116246101,
-0.0104202069,
0.0182813499,
0.0791090056,
0.0205210764,
-0.02250419,
-0.0206002202,
-0.0010588452,
0.0001519554,
-0.0035549856,
0.107693851,
0.034470316,
-0.0430814102,
-0.038782645,
-0.0187480617,
0.0534157455,
0.0227800421,
0.0328358486,
0.0268376619,
0.0159283932,
0.0012043153,
-0.0085595269,
-0.0130499359,
0.0497578494,
0.0018965577,
0.0304466374,
0.037536189,
0.0299469326,
0.0042079072,
-0.0173288956,
-0.0042520901,
0.0013334404,
-0.0242041014,
0.0289203282,
0.0349479094,
-0.0074881534,
-0.0604301058,
0.0374854617,
0.0272007771,
-0.0275130272,
-0.0531763509,
-0.0439515263,
0.0171814673,
0.050382752,
0.0496939719,
0.0213639438,
-0.027054932,
0.0063707377,
-0.0319187045,
0.0152562624,
-0.0039824881,
-0.0005999412,
0.0085986312,
-0.0586065613,
0.0074636843,
0.0241995752,
0.0021856083,
0.0566345192,
0.0395895056,
-0.0040399018,
-0.0004668891,
0.0232055485,
-0.0371958725,
-0.0083778156,
-0.0244363286,
-0.0184209943,
0.0014331351,
-0.0113175893,
0.0336413197,
-0.0113260262,
-0.0122922389,
0.0256032925,
0.0403165221,
-0.0613697842,
0.0347379968,
0.0031146095,
-0.0351056419,
-0.0450603552,
0.0222175941,
-0.0165052731,
-0.0224552602,
0.025098417,
-0.0289220437,
-0.019216666,
0.0431344099,
-0.0328023024,
0.073862955,
-0.0227433182,
0.0270850118,
0.0251798518,
0.0323971957,
-0.0092747156,
0.0413097665,
-0.0521263704,
-0.0078436425,
0.0226253849,
0.0532466695,
-0.0134112714,
-0.0031499707,
-0.0072195474,
0.0537380576,
0.0026481033,
-0.0186598431,
-0.0377317257,
-0.0220411867,
-0.0025846572,
-0.0125392945,
-0.0574108623,
0.011489138,
-0.0260134786,
0.0456435531,
0.0180534143,
0.0304317363,
0.0058309124,
-0.0210241266,
0.0185471494,
0.0300053451,
-0.0229470488,
0.0282534491,
-0.0143187279,
-0.0196655691,
-0.0364269428,
-0.0150668072,
-0.0444939584,
-0.0056580557,
0.0585194752,
-0.015646765,
-0.0550344475,
-0.0738676414,
0.0343359411,
0.0248632859,
0.0148586901,
-0.0299626086,
-0.0465295278,
0.0090067564,
-0.053150218,
0.0435712077,
0.059654884,
-0.0191398971,
0.0128781805,
0.0215190239,
-0.0195752606,
-0.0597431771,
0.0219349023,
0.0410810933,
-0.0282316711,
-0.0139743509,
-0.0680879056,
-0.0164318029,
0.1134197339,
0.0051085609,
-0.005153961,
-0.0367964953,
-0.0473535173,
0.0227630287,
-0.027675366,
0.0042351442,
-0.0066833491,
-0.0155652827,
0.0138286566,
-0.0232709032,
-0.0656487271,
0.0532785319,
-0.0591239817,
-0.0342163146,
-0.0050277989,
0.0013721031,
-0.033865463,
0.0552367084,
-0.0009561288,
0.0015516153,
-0.0735643879,
-0.0642042011,
0.0542465672,
0.055538699,
-0.0303893127,
-0.0485114008,
0.0550341494,
-0.0356752239,
0.031276267,
-0.0405499339,
-0.0070303907,
-0.0362722799,
0.0213238914,
-0.0742061511,
-0.014917626,
0.0463207215,
-0.032568451,
-0.0131366644,
0.0113253538,
-0.0058900351,
0.0627053156,
-0.001855965,
0.0004887744,
-0.014528932,
-0.013916241,
0.0261780582,
-0.041831959,
-0.0091408379,
-0.0197217818,
0.0057892902,
0.0648611262,
0.0443998128,
0.0088784182,
-0.0730685294,
0.0243911408,
0.0815534294,
0.0111256363,
-0.0187571887,
0.0513283201,
-0.0159638599,
-0.0742935985,
0.0039338586,
0.077170752,
0.0094741173,
-0.0774701908,
-0.0104858242,
-0.0064333854,
0.0569475517,
0.0153723052,
0.0370272212,
-0.0904139653,
-0.0538378209,
0.030692704,
0.0184906498,
0.0188528709,
-0.0210900623,
-0.0240385216,
-0.1009699404,
0.0401537679,
0.0243723039,
-0.00548372,
-0.0366345197,
-0.0244333558,
-0.032824751,
0.0109811351,
-0.0155333169,
0.0619114861,
-0.000632476,
0.0195213929,
-0.012397591,
0.0080389557,
0.0506631508,
0.0054718326,
-0.0068075405,
0.0684873909,
0.0723069683,
-0.0034691647,
0.0286728088,
-0.0142233688,
0.0254871845,
-0.0180631187,
-0.0033623052,
-0.0521133356,
0.0010792552,
-0.0435242318,
-0.0096859271,
0.0115715265,
0.0192546323,
-0.0534169264,
0.0142255453,
-0.0092920214,
0.0730178878,
-0.0222850237,
-0.0266522877,
-0.0165239498,
-0.0170630999,
-0.0228661094,
0.0564443581,
0.0179158393,
0.008562969,
-0.0199375618,
-0.097911559,
-0.0222988892,
-0.0706407726,
-0.0403387807,
0.0071694786,
0.0563991256,
-0.0517829098,
0.0133430101,
-0.0077201207,
0.0300578717,
0.00276573,
-0.0098430691,
0.015529626,
0.0305188205,
-0.0392154753,
-0.0913750753,
-0.0006935842,
-0.0425424352,
0.0067349188,
-0.0763799027,
-0.0106834872,
0.0390136093,
-0.0114603266,
-0.0058040516,
0.0514780656,
-0.1204266548,
-0.0475176759,
-0.0004066101,
0.0322587751,
0.0197218433,
0.041068837,
-0.0306709483,
-0.0522294976,
-0.036153499,
0.0095533952,
-0.0536367297,
0.0471683443,
0.0238914825,
0.0020477208,
0.0158799198,
0.0259055942,
-0.0210779402,
-0.0108908284,
-0.0150750987,
0.0200116411,
-0.0117377825,
-0.0368631072,
-0.0082991766,
0.0210161023,
-0.0051827785,
-0.0038918636,
-0.0059036454,
0.0085999249,
0.0288913399,
0.017744761,
0.0082424022,
-0.0535725877,
0.0428906828,
0.0401011705,
-0.0552315079,
-0.0089841289,
-0.0196477957,
0.0156415813,
-0.0226022918,
-0.0075366222,
0.0371838771,
-0.0023986124,
0.0050806166,
0.0617390387,
-0.0316939019,
-0.0212911032,
0.0082113501,
0.0161115974,
0.0427148044,
-0.0248976089,
0.0158788245,
0.0055595678,
0.0013940776,
-0.0111909891,
0.0019874487,
-0.0411711223,
-0.048892092,
-0.0242185704,
0.0079902289,
0.0560207479,
0.0145914992,
0.0514474139,
-0.0028806983,
0.0217304397,
-0.0143402228,
0.0169270206,
-0.0051695537,
-0.040300142,
0.0236585662,
0.0344367288,
-0.0137310363,
0.0038106118,
0.0614973605,
0.0278153531,
0.0403988361,
0.0071864254,
0.0041056126,
-0.0335181989,
-0.0663534105,
-0.0249705445,
-0.0017034535,
-0.0444834158,
-0.0111072054,
-0.0060663144,
-0.0448351093,
0.0250003599,
0.0160084795,
0.0003122939,
-0.0276584588,
-0.0188141372,
0.0472725257,
0.0169473924,
-0.0412458032,
-0.0295603573,
0.0621567145,
0.016423976,
-0.0387049653,
-0.0164727848,
-6.513068896e-33,
-0.0151533475,
-0.019267479,
0.0103998464,
-0.0458945148,
-0.009600345,
0.0119832996,
-0.0402268469,
-0.0235097948,
-0.0025069739,
-0.0229863077,
-0.0124225272,
0.0607125908,
0.0184529461,
-0.005355773,
0.0258507524,
0.015607683,
0.0401034765,
-0.0028537784,
-0.0258884188,
0.0178455282,
-0.0003049008,
0.0727945045,
0.0191344861,
0.0113951918,
-0.0026824805,
-0.0415340587,
0.0347145498,
-0.0122910263,
-0.0050995373,
0.021303162,
-0.043108698,
0.0107654836,
0.0021746634,
-0.0426044203,
-0.0346262231,
-0.0026215215,
-0.1017623842,
-0.0037310296,
0.0650293902,
0.0401340909,
-0.0114299962,
-0.0445090421,
-0.0014788582,
0.0471758433,
0.0071702725,
-0.0279769432,
-0.0270849504,
-0.0168180689,
-0.0389715023,
-0.0062226132,
-0.0185797308,
0.0398835316,
0.0014120272,
0.0377028212,
0.10963507,
0.0058685732,
0.0082490351,
0.0585715771,
-0.0409381017,
0.0007631537,
-0.0031857698,
0.0946178213,
0.0987353176,
0.0107446071,
-0.0042019244,
0.0247656815,
0.0332245417,
-0.0341226272,
-0.0564138778,
0.0367947742,
0.0124365529,
-0.0000658188,
-0.0548025183,
0.0096983146,
0.0763456151,
0.0067010717,
-0.0306747239,
-0.0031121329,
0.0559065826,
0.0408712104,
0.0303822272,
0.0332522765,
-0.0504909456,
-0.031656418,
-0.0097220475,
-0.0114201047,
-0.0570224486,
-0.0008814194,
0.0276930425,
0.0088617001,
-0.0380820446,
0.0067232801,
0.060273774,
-0.0383057781,
0.0125207752,
0.0486539938,
-0.0044262996,
0.0297796093,
-0.0068910071,
0.0457978509,
-0.0014228468,
-0.0234889351,
-0.0100410022,
-0.0228781831,
0.0679190457,
0.0077977474,
-0.0298437215,
0.0102773029,
-0.0556825884,
-0.0358148478,
-0.0598000996,
-0.0085980026,
0.0018032707,
0.0184832904,
0.0552120507,
-0.0052329651,
0.0238143522,
0.0524718948,
-0.0263228118,
0.024023341,
-0.0242266078,
0.0140095726,
0.0047061685,
0.0221921783,
-0.0472461395,
-0.0238482058,
-0.0589616708,
0.0475909002,
0.0169056151,
-0.0794959888,
-0.0380383208,
0.0606870204,
2.857e-7,
0.0047593061,
0.0351923779,
0.062525399,
0.0578864664,
0.0096102031,
0.0058003408,
0.0100233825,
-0.0100184297,
0.0439607278,
0.0004243814,
-0.0024478426,
0.0288257003,
0.0702115223,
0.0000372456,
-0.0657728538,
-0.0097315311,
-0.0070344959,
0.0100716799,
-0.0335083343,
-0.0585556813,
0.0090170698,
0.0850917995,
-0.0416646712,
0.0069128955,
0.0606134087,
0.0142370593,
-0.0028282676,
-0.000115798,
0.0011516943,
0.0057439571,
-0.0104691228,
0.0116377268,
-0.0328080803,
-0.0101210009,
0.000140513,
-0.0094617093,
-0.0348368809,
0.0710807815,
0.0190346427,
0.005427483,
0.0272533149,
-0.0436147153,
-0.0077029103,
-0.0235932507,
0.058883965,
0.0190895218,
0.01025494,
-0.0197084323,
-0.0306196082,
0.006255703,
-0.0496306568,
0.0004639049,
0.0584944077,
0.0272026416,
0.0388853885,
-0.0614260174,
-0.0330631249,
-0.0498608463,
-0.0802661702,
-0.0192276016,
-0.0420628861,
-0.0190553293,
-0.0689801797,
0.0154089825,
0.0329733603,
-0.0567410626,
0.0058837687,
2.828957791e-34,
0.0601035357,
-0.0108933672,
0.0118472567,
0.0949268267,
0.0393391252,
-0.0375397541,
-0.0005358911,
0.0444455817,
-0.030346131,
-0.0851370841,
-0.0656146258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02056v1 | AnthroScore: A Computational Linguistic Measure of Anthropomorphism | 2024-02-03T06:36:11 | 2024-02-03T06:36:11 | Myra Cheng, Kristina Gligoric, Tiziano Piccardi, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Anthropomorphism, or the attribution of human-like characteristics to
non-human entities, has shaped conversations about the impacts and
possibilities of technology. We present AnthroScore, an automatic metric of
implicit anthropomorphism in language. We use a masked language model to
quantify how non-human entities are implicitly framed as human by the
surrounding context. We show that AnthroScore corresponds with human judgments
of anthropomorphism and dimensions of anthropomorphism described in social
science literature. Motivated by concerns of misleading anthropomorphism in
computer science discourse, we use AnthroScore to analyze 15 years of research
papers and downstream news articles. In research papers, we find that
anthropomorphism has steadily increased over time, and that papers related to
language models have the most anthropomorphism. Within ACL papers, temporal
increases in anthropomorphism are correlated with key neural advancements.
Building upon concerns of scientific misinformation in mass media, we identify
higher levels of anthropomorphism in news headlines compared to the research
papers they cite. Since AnthroScore is lexicon-free, it can be directly applied
to a wide range of text sources. | [
0.0242570452,
0.097138837,
-0.038923528,
-0.007089837,
-0.003368547,
0.0145995272,
0.0455105528,
-0.0345407799,
-0.000816834,
-0.1037104353,
-0.0262494218,
0.0211992543,
0.0152269043,
-0.0073637823,
0.0463212505,
-0.0228241142,
0.0374548621,
0.0431649573,
0.015906306,
0.0063054031,
-0.0374298915,
0.0328578614,
0.0186889675,
0.0352233313,
0.010560777,
-0.0368236899,
0.0610294864,
0.0071859965,
0.0235954337,
-0.047066506,
0.007602158,
0.0149343703,
0.029126307,
0.0176896751,
0.0000019546,
-0.0711007342,
0.0443772152,
0.029513767,
0.0142480657,
-0.0082460037,
0.0546484739,
0.0188120306,
-0.0239837244,
-0.0164147187,
-0.0149388518,
-0.0383693352,
0.0493341982,
0.0226469953,
-0.0149788344,
0.0293949358,
-0.0130035477,
0.0014623804,
-0.0376826972,
0.0302393697,
-0.031354975,
0.0230161827,
0.0211783983,
-0.0437447801,
-0.0299781393,
0.0223960355,
0.0140444385,
0.0190075263,
-0.003970203,
0.0046722265,
0.0511311293,
0.004539249,
-0.018953301,
-0.0359325893,
0.0210827347,
0.0353237167,
0.0580070205,
-0.0404148325,
0.0141513729,
0.0530532375,
0.0232259035,
0.0402098857,
0.0028952113,
0.038638629,
0.0158208925,
-0.0495215692,
-0.0464014858,
0.0006219294,
0.0239290856,
0.0775211379,
0.0021783111,
0.1081139073,
0.0003344073,
-0.0185229164,
0.0172358509,
-0.0053445264,
0.0126886591,
-0.0260477103,
0.0061222082,
0.0151425637,
0.0070016664,
-0.003057587,
-0.0319133848,
-0.0133115342,
0.0191094726,
-0.0899834558,
-0.0156714413,
0.0013192329,
0.0115258275,
0.0255339313,
0.0086680409,
0.0300051458,
-0.0137587348,
-0.0234523006,
-0.0040830346,
0.0259614475,
-0.0504735373,
-0.0297901537,
0.0122246156,
0.0064547192,
0.0303628165,
0.0030968671,
0.0029006936,
-0.0002941905,
-0.0726007149,
-0.0089780837,
-0.099923566,
0.0273252372,
-0.0097025512,
-0.0193294361,
-0.0012691615,
-0.0291857682,
-0.0384572521,
0.0393977836,
-0.0461845435,
-0.0560822487,
0.0223356746,
-0.0012889783,
-0.0194344893,
-0.0188342202,
-0.0025399942,
0.0801714137,
0.0170176607,
-0.0149797555,
0.0419707708,
0.0108211655,
0.0151312258,
-0.0002716901,
0.0217847321,
-0.0160288904,
-0.0092256665,
-0.0016635959,
0.0063387449,
-0.052860789,
-0.0143432356,
0.0215161964,
-0.0364933126,
0.0641632527,
-0.0317023322,
-0.0059504444,
0.0550567545,
0.0227835793,
0.0086636255,
0.0391456559,
0.0331218839,
0.0247765016,
0.0371424034,
-0.0075824424,
-0.0410632566,
-0.0000592237,
-0.0006994343,
-0.0086849406,
0.0185228288,
0.0159583893,
-0.0091925049,
0.0248325095,
0.0198283382,
0.0181877818,
0.0059059695,
0.0025099781,
0.0273623597,
0.0682024881,
-0.0747371987,
0.0633601248,
0.0348247327,
-0.0057499087,
-0.0135304667,
0.007471282,
-0.0707208365,
0.005021113,
-0.0251902025,
-0.0572607666,
-0.0245359372,
0.0466125011,
-0.0372316837,
-0.0186892357,
0.0106183179,
0.0211353116,
0.0738438293,
-0.0128816478,
0.0300725754,
0.0114118308,
-0.0004875803,
-0.009441616,
-0.0088086119,
-0.0232272577,
-0.0086069927,
-0.049496077,
-0.0252011325,
0.0130549818,
0.0191634707,
-0.0137106357,
0.0444291383,
-0.0345314443,
0.0073534432,
0.0602151081,
0.0264733266,
-0.005826008,
-0.0524644554,
0.0295128245,
0.0367797129,
-0.0104159638,
0.0258894712,
0.0553732477,
-0.0128100459,
0.0403564535,
0.0270899106,
0.0223271959,
-0.0472603366,
0.036000926,
-0.008397772,
-0.0134768831,
-0.0347542875,
-0.0045338054,
0.0199311562,
0.018699985,
-0.0153294783,
0.0298960935,
0.0149485329,
-0.0154790273,
-0.035559997,
0.0308719315,
0.0223366898,
0.0634560138,
0.0255693514,
-0.0990779176,
-0.0303098802,
0.0711322874,
0.0215362329,
0.0129666319,
0.0847300142,
-0.0488302782,
0.0374851972,
-0.0355426036,
0.0159001984,
-0.0598009937,
0.0210018102,
-0.0146598071,
0.007906964,
0.0145132588,
0.0114039266,
-0.0245121848,
-0.0358968601,
0.0236785337,
0.0158668905,
-0.0423384719,
0.0110044191,
-0.0165192671,
0.015443855,
0.0471576005,
-0.0665143058,
-0.0477624089,
0.0180531926,
-0.0479688048,
-0.0298719108,
0.0360662788,
-0.0080123059,
0.011765467,
-0.0455289222,
0.0011654128,
0.0094369911,
0.0134121878,
-0.0554020591,
-0.0418901742,
0.0408947356,
0.0178267621,
-0.0435909554,
-0.0048444062,
-0.0312397853,
-0.0093304617,
-0.0637136176,
0.0654740483,
0.0453615151,
-0.0097805699,
-0.0257655662,
0.0022014289,
-0.067765303,
-0.0100392597,
-0.0013893042,
-0.0195045397,
0.0335539393,
0.0575061999,
-0.015563705,
0.069574073,
0.0437452272,
0.0485369116,
0.0455429703,
0.0465962365,
-0.0209098812,
-0.0459060371,
0.0216984097,
-0.0202787463,
0.047284089,
-0.0905003101,
0.0506020039,
0.0303416681,
0.0000061265,
-0.032180395,
-0.039960973,
0.1085661352,
-0.0700701252,
-0.0684994385,
-0.0210697874,
-0.0359592475,
-0.0046472149,
0.0348031633,
-0.0185814742,
-0.0130331991,
0.0412187018,
-0.0086360769,
0.0309310351,
0.0223433264,
0.0140622426,
-0.0031747106,
0.0096914573,
0.0309514236,
0.0519485101,
0.0585653521,
-0.0119119911,
-0.0723156035,
-0.0017074703,
-0.0099965911,
-0.0211933702,
0.0116296234,
-0.0251340643,
0.0194043741,
0.038689442,
0.0009026991,
0.0113527132,
-0.0443359241,
-0.0094421934,
0.0177178439,
-0.0106894542,
-0.0325221382,
-0.0448156893,
-0.0330121629,
0.0322406553,
-0.0234078746,
0.0180240069,
-0.006577644,
0.0166747086,
-0.0359101631,
0.0288455673,
0.0349253602,
0.0363018811,
0.036777705,
-0.0063966503,
0.0266265105,
0.0030031863,
0.0086170137,
-0.0492929183,
0.0188074056,
-0.0170308799,
-0.0350438617,
0.0145104462,
-0.0065901428,
0.014033108,
-0.0235104132,
0.0410382934,
0.0701266825,
0.0082318094,
-0.0313719399,
0.0398185179,
0.0288798921,
-0.0578206405,
0.0509852096,
0.0073676459,
-0.0547331274,
0.0457359329,
-0.0225403178,
-0.0135208853,
-0.0707024857,
-0.0598811992,
-0.0144895278,
-0.0610725135,
-0.0010493314,
-0.0055722566,
-0.0153269544,
0.0057648974,
-0.0402098857,
0.0431524068,
0.0454275794,
-0.0305097997,
-0.0060929698,
-0.0065929424,
-0.0125991795,
-0.0251431819,
-0.0437271819,
-0.0145881195,
0.0380114876,
0.0057659233,
0.0206209496,
0.0650773197,
0.0967162028,
-0.037183933,
0.0026637053,
0.0222144183,
-0.0000421115,
-0.0277101733,
-0.0125509007,
0.0068986304,
-0.0504658371,
-0.0056058145,
-0.0177601296,
-0.0064245276,
0.0248190928,
0.0077101062,
-0.0085992701,
0.0332538784,
0.0102272714,
-0.065404065,
-0.0628497526,
-0.0226413719,
-0.0268277712,
0.0576113611,
0.0276314691,
-0.0215775836,
0.0068721119,
-0.0191631205,
0.0299697127,
0.0475700386,
-0.0986206532,
0.0027264727,
-0.0217170659,
-0.0752553493,
-0.0723460615,
-0.0605952218,
-0.0140373157,
-0.0523160435,
0.0455523059,
-0.0627909973,
0.0535296276,
-0.0015499709,
-0.0984741822,
0.0411852524,
-0.002259176,
0.0182664786,
0.0419485308,
-0.0024981759,
0.0461088233,
0.0473861955,
-0.0077703106,
0.0564094,
0.0686760545,
-0.0561787784,
0.0234784931,
-0.0126765752,
0.0241785273,
-0.0033731209,
-0.0022963758,
-0.0488581657,
0.0216544028,
0.0363694169,
-0.02388753,
0.0416007228,
-0.0086700171,
0.0211150814,
-0.0245250836,
0.0118081663,
-0.0235189758,
0.040430259,
-0.0226203557,
-0.0488048121,
-0.0460994951,
-0.017059261,
0.0044621285,
0.0171154961,
0.0200297218,
-0.0531135872,
0.045496814,
0.0226595327,
-0.0650426522,
-0.0191742852,
-0.0160594471,
0.0048649055,
-0.0623911023,
0.0005627336,
0.0470231846,
-0.0024279717,
0.0026216917,
-0.0407736674,
0.0601836033,
0.0000766999,
0.0144676706,
0.0067617963,
0.0680999532,
-0.0366532654,
0.0087735914,
-0.006035191,
-0.0134950187,
-0.0532274656,
0.0361329205,
0.0103566758,
0.0083244164,
0.0312475506,
0.0382797681,
-0.0405012555,
0.0571372062,
-0.0491169803,
-0.0288172625,
-0.0128681092,
-0.0233642012,
-0.0267829709,
0.020247994,
0.0393523686,
0.0172861256,
-0.0249091294,
0.0096422518,
0.0142835239,
0.0031988618,
0.004641111,
0.0185466986,
0.0343681127,
-0.0106702531,
0.0207756422,
0.019224951,
0.0187507719,
0.0093422839,
0.0071730991,
-0.035011325,
-0.0099637145,
-0.0277201086,
-0.020010205,
-0.0334007032,
0.0116290879,
-0.0034662772,
-0.0635283291,
-0.0800455362,
-0.0190297961,
0.0066563599,
0.0274217073,
-0.0231023207,
-0.0176668223,
0.0397232622,
-0.0044824486,
-0.0498420112,
-0.0266633891,
0.0398501791,
-0.0351585634,
-0.0135766137,
-0.0100834463,
-6.10218256e-33,
-0.038428966,
-0.047359135,
-0.0186190177,
-0.0071835746,
-0.0660508722,
0.0106891068,
-0.0515837334,
0.014115395,
-0.035909161,
0.0196571555,
0.0174179822,
-0.0038021044,
-0.0083213467,
-0.031766437,
0.0468815565,
0.0321000032,
0.0520488583,
-0.0189659204,
-0.0053125247,
-0.0210378729,
-0.0151862828,
-0.0399117842,
0.0131985573,
-0.0911109298,
0.1124191359,
0.0224410761,
-0.0305964816,
-0.0216087215,
0.0541081317,
-0.0286991186,
-0.0160196498,
0.0370471254,
0.0373633653,
-0.0002178592,
0.017859282,
0.0981695652,
-0.0627582818,
-0.0119403349,
0.024889078,
-0.0149267223,
0.0213596728,
-0.0356884599,
0.0270779859,
-0.0159426834,
-0.0567157716,
0.0142156426,
0.0783325508,
-0.0376063325,
0.0340969153,
-0.0023653896,
-0.0688338578,
-0.0259199701,
-0.0548244491,
0.0255199745,
-0.0120368777,
0.0669079795,
-0.0420799032,
0.0081847254,
-0.0879728794,
0.0221893135,
-0.0318066701,
-0.0435022749,
0.0279666055,
0.0218881071,
0.0740319118,
0.0648224875,
0.0713502243,
0.0710816458,
-0.0561907254,
0.0234535579,
0.0691141188,
-0.0087403329,
0.0032961976,
0.0286563821,
0.0080439225,
-0.0321090333,
0.0117579801,
-0.0183676109,
-0.0000840946,
0.0218880828,
0.028231442,
-0.007916024,
-0.0512123629,
-0.0382070653,
0.0072812727,
-0.0748906657,
-0.0191157311,
-0.0618605316,
-0.0099251876,
-0.061817456,
-0.0412818864,
0.0501361899,
-0.0023440202,
-0.0478163324,
-0.0026998254,
-0.0452973694,
0.0062785046,
0.0045303567,
0.0259661265,
-0.0110558672,
-0.0413241871,
0.0027583207,
-0.000641483,
0.0649929047,
0.0818616599,
-0.0056185108,
-0.0412878059,
-0.0315139443,
-0.0292655397,
-0.0255834926,
0.0036344815,
-0.0590637103,
0.0069732964,
0.0011209026,
0.0045994073,
0.0156456158,
-0.0022762849,
-0.0430469401,
0.0389854461,
0.0114110801,
-0.0359339081,
0.0960154533,
-0.0472424254,
0.0166334137,
-0.0299660601,
-0.0472516865,
-0.032419458,
0.039046526,
0.0726227015,
-0.0865346566,
-0.0290890858,
-0.0424078479,
2.821e-7,
0.0063546593,
0.071887359,
-0.0191593748,
-0.014632728,
0.0274720415,
0.0561812818,
0.0316633955,
0.0515595712,
0.0479341112,
-0.040622972,
-0.0285635721,
-0.0023708232,
0.0054877391,
0.0135095557,
-0.0229008589,
-0.0223884657,
-0.0374446735,
-0.0081670433,
-0.0284053311,
0.0302285496,
0.0013032076,
0.00186428,
0.0164425969,
-0.0068237376,
-0.0570430569,
-0.0206264369,
0.0158168953,
-0.0237314943,
-0.0097092139,
0.0033840337,
-0.0373776555,
0.0765740126,
-0.0100366632,
0.0332051143,
-0.0041464493,
0.0096207624,
0.0655338988,
-0.0168086328,
-0.0260221604,
0.0065844064,
0.009393259,
0.0114875808,
-0.0218226127,
-0.0305764433,
0.0319590718,
-0.0304279979,
-0.046507515,
-0.0450957566,
-0.0452136137,
0.0053801588,
0.0040886211,
-0.0064402437,
-0.0222901963,
0.0333914794,
-0.0046866317,
-0.022025954,
0.0234160647,
-0.0607504733,
-0.0095756482,
0.0139952609,
-0.0307320803,
-0.0188295338,
0.0089538433,
0.0283125415,
0.0338629447,
-0.011798583,
0.0486800186,
2.044100876e-34,
0.0256362576,
0.0199310295,
0.0109143257,
0.0047723902,
0.0494214147,
0.0190592408,
0.0253030621,
-0.0176533759,
0.0673922524,
-0.0543169789,
0.0075871879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05120v1 | More Agents Is All You Need | 2024-02-03T05:55:24 | 2024-02-03T05:55:24 | Junyou Li, Qin Zhang, Yangbin Yu, Qiang Fu, Deheng Ye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We find that, simply via a sampling-and-voting method, the performance of
large language models (LLMs) scales with the number of agents instantiated.
Also, this method is orthogonal to existing complicated methods to further
enhance LLMs, while the degree of enhancement is correlated to the task
difficulty. We conduct comprehensive experiments on a wide range of LLM
benchmarks to verify the presence of our finding, and to study the properties
that can facilitate its occurrence. Our code is publicly available at:
\url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/more_agent_is_all_you_need}. | [
0.0220291335,
0.0531233698,
-0.0389430486,
0.0353026986,
-0.0262363553,
-0.0124644004,
0.0236722808,
0.0099875024,
0.0083004097,
-0.0230127815,
-0.030542193,
-0.0498488508,
-0.0151407979,
-0.0094334604,
0.0290210787,
-0.0422029793,
0.0169767719,
-0.0785496682,
-0.0034941921,
-0.0494855456,
-0.0354577973,
-0.0160517916,
0.0223098621,
0.0478397384,
0.0413408428,
0.0078312289,
-0.0035639121,
-0.0219533257,
-0.0070014051,
0.0010584092,
-0.0478293747,
0.032107681,
0.0296769571,
0.0251561701,
0.0000021013,
-0.0422781445,
0.01288075,
-0.0062912735,
-0.0463308543,
0.0616863258,
0.0624507703,
-0.0102715706,
-0.003380399,
0.0306770876,
-0.0255025048,
-0.0095114652,
0.0278555937,
-0.0104233604,
0.0225914512,
0.05571042,
0.005999384,
0.0046743406,
0.0028792121,
-0.033546783,
-0.0193703044,
-0.0473766513,
0.0169702005,
0.0161898285,
0.0509198792,
0.017545836,
-0.0392837673,
0.0424229056,
0.0214201957,
-0.0165575482,
0.0033271334,
0.0702626333,
-0.0304939803,
-0.0048477808,
-0.0064788498,
0.0453958847,
-0.0161169916,
0.0078605842,
-0.0153896771,
-0.012498904,
-0.0014874067,
0.0278456584,
-0.0588516742,
0.0395019911,
0.0106386896,
0.0164744128,
0.0338143408,
-0.0036814993,
0.0422113352,
0.0073539168,
-0.0302279238,
0.0794179067,
0.0284413882,
-0.0081266081,
-0.0193590093,
0.0014890239,
-0.0156939961,
-0.041879639,
-0.0200813226,
0.0160999447,
-0.0455646701,
0.0210223701,
-0.0438847281,
-0.0063635437,
0.0170192625,
-0.0364254303,
0.0737727433,
0.0121479081,
0.0184888002,
0.07854186,
-0.0214752275,
0.0423869044,
-0.0252763368,
0.0419607088,
-0.0351082385,
-0.0038852338,
-0.0473904014,
0.0071917879,
-0.0563014224,
0.0273600034,
-0.0106217172,
-0.0103695206,
-0.0202230066,
0.0567923002,
0.035246253,
-0.0211556293,
-0.0221277494,
-0.0607674718,
-0.0196549296,
-0.0193252284,
-0.0074338885,
0.010262955,
-0.0290115755,
0.0258644074,
-0.0146074528,
-0.0719436929,
-0.0030693901,
-0.006594596,
0.018259149,
-0.0183847621,
-0.0039907517,
0.0614128783,
0.0090343347,
-0.043632485,
-0.0248321015,
0.0253780633,
0.0068570133,
-0.0529849492,
-0.0750543848,
-0.0802411661,
0.0242302828,
0.0092342505,
-0.0026976541,
-0.0253897384,
-0.0017020577,
-0.0172495712,
-0.064039968,
0.0476838909,
-0.0110775689,
0.0590010062,
0.0140879638,
-0.0115826428,
-0.0219310801,
0.0800138414,
0.0507842712,
0.0159220789,
0.0295422636,
-0.0086196642,
0.0480048731,
0.0645320043,
-0.0217249542,
0.0654172003,
0.0465330482,
-0.0151328538,
0.0006769959,
0.0318248421,
0.0136663709,
0.0761518553,
-0.0435344093,
-0.0163787547,
0.0779586881,
0.0634361356,
-0.0010484939,
-0.0154356193,
0.0156088015,
0.006731594,
0.0021976584,
0.0010190536,
-0.0631071404,
0.0388282761,
0.0143959234,
0.0144977802,
0.0263521522,
0.0441335924,
-0.0528206863,
-0.0198619179,
-0.0189786218,
0.0098140733,
0.032260377,
0.0074911602,
0.0716008544,
-0.0163377225,
-0.0248817522,
0.0112593472,
0.046068944,
-0.0601823367,
0.0113519477,
-0.0885182396,
0.0320931822,
0.0573784001,
0.0523332506,
-0.0144324778,
-0.0065148599,
-0.005081174,
0.0358616561,
0.0742479637,
0.0593817756,
-0.0036439884,
0.0274953824,
-0.034388639,
-0.013791603,
0.0063532339,
-0.0041533122,
0.049734056,
0.0192564018,
-0.008443783,
-0.0072845044,
-0.0268531442,
-0.0466011055,
0.0155715682,
-0.0515435971,
-0.0056542661,
-0.010588197,
-0.0052974755,
0.0538378097,
-0.0137052797,
-0.0263967291,
-0.0024196336,
-0.0011038544,
-0.0576677062,
-0.0284145493,
-0.0158530734,
0.0134143848,
-0.0330078639,
0.031879656,
0.0120779956,
0.011128501,
0.0358054861,
-0.0222690515,
-0.0286485292,
0.0433164649,
-0.0408227034,
0.0615768544,
-0.0171039272,
0.0508659407,
-0.0406532921,
0.0195267126,
-0.0370282382,
0.0463158563,
-0.013791672,
-0.0014588383,
0.0119331703,
0.0445397459,
-0.0066219592,
-0.0312233139,
-0.0243026167,
-0.0101486035,
0.0223270822,
0.0446662158,
0.0498203188,
-0.021689713,
-0.0017641621,
-0.0607216507,
-0.062827073,
-0.0034797839,
-0.0164232291,
-0.0149078146,
-0.0130663831,
0.0075222421,
-0.0038546503,
0.0105136391,
-0.0384975113,
0.0402500033,
0.0007981894,
0.0563011207,
0.0106454883,
0.0125656631,
-0.1089154929,
-0.0580469258,
-0.018367717,
0.0094266832,
0.0169937275,
0.0222079847,
-0.0175307356,
-0.0531679504,
0.054692477,
-0.0046179714,
0.0091310367,
-0.034586072,
-0.0542244948,
0.0052606673,
-0.0522801913,
0.021920329,
0.0696176291,
-0.0145135308,
0.0260234009,
0.0558592863,
0.0022814302,
-0.0545130782,
0.0148526877,
-0.0209970754,
-0.0234421324,
-0.0677734464,
-0.0576702803,
0.0154976975,
0.0810701102,
-0.0043277973,
-0.0358920656,
-0.0337260216,
0.0076311575,
-0.0311633516,
-0.0352873802,
0.0051098717,
-0.001697051,
-0.0069144946,
0.0364075005,
-0.0372687951,
-0.061103113,
0.0373578668,
-0.0456703119,
-0.026596928,
-0.0296136867,
-0.0211780574,
-0.0404574275,
0.0759259909,
0.0470923819,
0.0187799465,
-0.0227942951,
-0.0179284308,
-0.0357798114,
-0.014061084,
0.0215026457,
-0.0126096355,
0.0698605254,
-0.0526839085,
0.0372077115,
-0.0242777932,
-0.0533666871,
-0.0214677509,
-0.0517163426,
-0.0324631482,
0.0241812672,
0.0312181339,
-0.0235325024,
-0.048054494,
0.0313490257,
0.0200013444,
0.0386908315,
-0.01184812,
-0.0091876797,
-0.0201882571,
0.0035477967,
0.0419663675,
0.0212044865,
0.0264549423,
-0.0991135091,
0.0538960248,
0.0213295612,
0.0634829104,
0.0123408353,
-0.0273401756,
-0.0329397619,
0.026079908,
-0.0426422916,
-0.018476516,
0.0044090012,
0.0305771939,
-0.0337919034,
0.0135378772,
0.1091902703,
0.0050346707,
-0.0308012441,
0.0197141524,
-0.0130066564,
0.0490124784,
0.0303786602,
0.033469595,
-0.0272804033,
-0.0115632415,
0.0050447802,
0.0045465538,
-0.0065558301,
-0.0306319762,
0.007157241,
-0.113566719,
0.0375667065,
0.0157881416,
-0.0322813764,
0.0040239696,
-0.0388212316,
0.0127555178,
-0.0256922115,
0.0400567353,
0.0377496183,
0.0026893946,
-0.0098195029,
0.0201371741,
-0.0299006347,
-0.019685125,
0.0134764053,
-0.0621112362,
0.0943718851,
0.0601683855,
0.013232654,
-0.0306656789,
-0.0110099763,
0.0197223257,
0.0418071747,
0.000048566,
0.0073091313,
0.034934327,
0.0196931195,
-0.0285015106,
0.0013145227,
0.0116844969,
-0.0217310712,
0.0214446373,
0.0203232002,
0.0415212587,
0.0165399555,
-0.0357944742,
0.0061643599,
-0.0411809646,
-0.0215752032,
0.0706062466,
0.0358238034,
-0.0609587021,
-0.0203450546,
-0.0483119562,
-0.0532101579,
-0.0366176143,
-0.0320347995,
0.0186688714,
-0.0344251208,
-0.0090275882,
-0.0532066263,
-0.0359724164,
0.0532379001,
0.0238708463,
0.0213974249,
0.0593177415,
0.0586640723,
-0.0019931844,
0.0108556477,
-0.0330300219,
-0.0666607916,
0.0229740888,
-0.0420810618,
-0.0544189364,
0.0423875079,
-0.0093366858,
0.0099092685,
-0.0295098871,
-0.0986199006,
-0.0839334279,
0.0027771178,
0.0446150415,
0.0190213248,
0.0233829524,
-0.0222507194,
-0.0640504882,
0.0464180559,
-0.0048542721,
-0.0260744542,
0.0579273142,
-0.0053192191,
0.0017269632,
0.0120016886,
0.0610396154,
-0.0475754254,
0.0255954005,
0.0287777949,
0.0530900508,
-0.0726058781,
-0.020068543,
-0.007411995,
0.0247164872,
-0.0155661348,
-0.0098483711,
0.0190552901,
-0.0092002582,
0.0097472901,
-0.0322822742,
0.0100013409,
-0.0496173911,
-0.0035612085,
0.0365636609,
0.006077271,
0.0081969537,
0.007224164,
0.0096685104,
0.0411753021,
0.0219537579,
0.0243130941,
-0.0268907659,
-0.0079304948,
0.0674481913,
0.0238073822,
-0.0272523481,
0.0274981838,
-0.0078478986,
0.0257239379,
0.0218386333,
0.0153366029,
-0.0088768536,
-0.0159426592,
-0.0214383285,
-0.0001225534,
-0.0936938599,
-0.0799774379,
0.025428677,
0.07081642,
0.0591757335,
0.014844073,
0.0809229985,
-0.0219100192,
0.0098828077,
-0.0363795236,
-0.0002315465,
0.0122625185,
-0.0375874415,
0.0148292966,
0.0325739644,
-0.0087880762,
0.0069326414,
0.1004097983,
0.0226070825,
0.0398429893,
0.0107825799,
0.0090990374,
-0.0195997395,
-0.0206413046,
-0.0130939456,
-0.0048658745,
-0.031463366,
0.0178674981,
-0.0380053781,
-0.0325795226,
-0.0228906758,
0.0209889244,
0.007332522,
-0.0434909537,
-0.0016895136,
0.0536991134,
0.0071606874,
-0.0070288437,
-0.0695270747,
-0.0058573801,
-0.0171801653,
-0.0099691357,
0.0184466299,
-6.127650013e-33,
-0.0465174131,
-0.0042357827,
0.0342818797,
0.0125062149,
0.00827129,
-0.0078516267,
-0.053056255,
0.0227988567,
-0.0107138194,
0.0061882231,
-0.0207242388,
0.0037334526,
0.0102751814,
0.0200488232,
0.0225450657,
0.0115490183,
0.0543382131,
0.0102854818,
-0.0217841528,
0.0030458898,
-0.0165827721,
0.0057329745,
-0.0142277228,
-0.02421581,
-0.035090059,
0.0001622623,
0.0138347019,
0.0049978537,
0.0036742557,
0.0650650039,
-0.0095259408,
0.0285490509,
0.0178043321,
-0.0567459054,
-0.0451578349,
-0.0174739696,
-0.0163160171,
0.0038967417,
0.030671902,
0.0161986351,
-0.0073070605,
-0.0427842773,
0.016873436,
-0.0148399444,
-0.0082144979,
0.0116569838,
0.025549436,
-0.0460461043,
-0.0701999292,
0.0194399208,
-0.0568915829,
0.0381745622,
0.0205462407,
0.0051007615,
0.0085168825,
-0.0349539034,
-0.0245327242,
0.0087209139,
-0.0196829233,
0.022415895,
0.0415645204,
0.0482870936,
0.0332339071,
0.0549110398,
0.0146476477,
0.0474206209,
0.0439531468,
0.022918649,
-0.0378375091,
-0.020135818,
0.0270174686,
0.0297347493,
0.0408725068,
0.0740253627,
-0.0211966056,
-0.0041504283,
-0.0515885241,
0.0020492163,
0.0768670291,
-0.0104739144,
0.0755064115,
0.0257824566,
-0.0419083275,
-0.048339624,
-0.0411944203,
0.0143347988,
-0.0234563872,
-0.0294614658,
0.0252749752,
0.0242785979,
-0.0188018996,
-0.0799233392,
0.0526225232,
-0.0562196858,
-0.042884998,
-0.0053397529,
-0.0111657176,
0.0377221145,
-0.028890945,
0.0054361103,
-0.0602313131,
-0.0379726961,
-0.0471207649,
0.0042379205,
-0.0026319781,
0.0176102724,
0.0066399155,
0.0248955488,
-0.0677225068,
-0.0099212565,
-0.0228744335,
-0.0111930929,
0.0298974607,
0.0288364366,
0.0168783199,
-0.0324206986,
0.0231245346,
0.0290385354,
-0.0003563729,
-0.0380819924,
-0.0102294367,
0.0063442988,
-0.0161014814,
0.0039699599,
-0.0369988643,
0.0061591887,
-0.077208817,
0.0218164772,
0.0463927872,
-0.028044736,
-0.0313293599,
-0.0182343125,
2.622e-7,
-0.0000187161,
0.0402756557,
-0.0098045552,
0.0152073093,
0.0289354678,
0.031202713,
-0.0432856642,
0.0106731737,
-0.0140996631,
0.0117112026,
-0.0133717926,
0.065278098,
0.0421918593,
0.0216355883,
-0.0928633064,
-0.0018153151,
-0.0297960844,
0.0392924733,
-0.0265737362,
-0.0391370952,
-0.006607811,
0.1019868478,
0.0459749848,
-0.0080290381,
-0.0197688732,
-0.0951560736,
0.0563763641,
-0.0391251259,
-0.0310665127,
0.0694669113,
-0.0160807483,
0.0158690959,
-0.0170353986,
-0.0018735565,
0.014426006,
0.0223743021,
-0.0156227676,
0.0812202841,
-0.0023043675,
0.0195467733,
0.0485741571,
-0.0360755399,
-0.010414483,
-0.0180395283,
0.0487382077,
-0.0438470244,
-0.0266165119,
-0.0153465336,
0.0101853451,
0.0024681177,
-0.0124113923,
-0.0209934786,
-0.0266664289,
0.015153992,
0.0204316881,
-0.0533610918,
0.0099468315,
-0.0552983321,
-0.0068211681,
-0.0346150249,
-0.0340429023,
-0.1179331467,
-0.0268046111,
0.0088842306,
0.0245981477,
-0.029034486,
0.0032429679,
2.457303441e-34,
0.0723876879,
0.0133302733,
0.0204699803,
0.0580612719,
0.0303465705,
-0.0051152171,
-0.0474318676,
-0.0078760628,
0.0424090177,
-0.1180408299,
-0.0061988272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02037v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02037v3 | EffiBench: Benchmarking the Efficiency of Automatically Generated Code | 2024-02-03T05:24:39 | 2024-06-07T09:21:21 | Dong Huang, Yuhao Qing, Weiyi Shang, Heming Cui, Jie M. Zhang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Code generation models have increasingly become integral to aiding software
development. Although current research has thoroughly examined the correctness
of the code produced by code generation models, a vital aspect that plays a
pivotal role in green computing and sustainability efforts has often been
neglected. This paper presents EffiBench, a benchmark with 1,000
efficiency-critical coding problems to assess the efficiency of code generated
by code generation models. EffiBench contains a diverse set of LeetCode coding
problems. Each problem is paired with an executable human-written canonical
solution, which obtains the SOTA efficiency on the LeetCode solution
leaderboard. With EffiBench, we empirically examine the ability of 42 large
language models (35 open-source and 7 closed-source) to generate efficient
code. Our evaluation results demonstrate that the efficiency of the code
generated by LLMs is generally worse than the efficiency of human-written
canonical solutions. For example, GPT-4 generated code has an average
\textbf{3.12} times execution time that of the human-written canonical
solutions. In the most extreme cases, the execution time and total memory usage
of GPT-4 generated code are \textbf{13.89} and \textbf{43.92} times that of the
canonical solutions. The source code of EffiBench is released on
https://github.com/huangd1999/EffiBench. We also provide the LeaderBoard at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/EffiBench/effibench-leaderboard. | [
0.0149240484,
0.0608986989,
-0.0081677418,
0.0421119668,
-0.0294512045,
-0.0201583952,
-0.0516531318,
0.0353120789,
-0.0035117511,
-0.0246687233,
-0.0103295781,
0.081961371,
-0.0037012948,
0.0459842198,
0.0124022365,
-0.0025580321,
0.0609187707,
-0.002490374,
-0.0446606725,
-0.0058281501,
-0.0255087763,
-0.0082637202,
0.0313560367,
0.0084147276,
-0.0032789363,
-0.0040874123,
-0.0155468676,
0.0812897757,
-0.0055092648,
-0.0086293146,
0.0330940038,
0.0535603538,
-0.0231758654,
0.0011471828,
0.0000025731,
-0.0224255417,
-0.0086147944,
0.0194378607,
-0.0022476653,
0.0848073959,
0.0458442606,
-0.0119492039,
-0.0180259086,
0.0230377614,
-0.0034990176,
-0.0186238401,
0.0352526419,
-0.0832369253,
0.0382429734,
0.0120577561,
0.0077002984,
0.0052431617,
0.0178534165,
0.0138304327,
0.0294783451,
0.0218403209,
-0.0160539057,
0.0132209333,
0.0001250194,
-0.0149308955,
0.007412632,
0.0390917808,
0.0296525378,
-0.0148979584,
0.0179131478,
0.0035840643,
-0.0455926917,
-0.0134818833,
-0.0186719988,
0.0235442109,
-0.0224858075,
-0.0227795057,
-0.0010050451,
-0.0197473112,
-0.0580518171,
-0.0209045094,
-0.0069667678,
0.035541296,
0.0061034122,
0.0007587906,
0.0051719416,
0.0346188061,
-0.0121206641,
0.0033582216,
-0.0020567633,
0.0509513691,
-0.0061257542,
-0.0171210226,
0.0047668456,
-0.0006498606,
-0.0283046924,
-0.0274415817,
-0.0001633603,
-0.0149822114,
0.0366470367,
-0.0196305886,
-0.0200112499,
0.0108879069,
0.030639261,
-0.0340621024,
0.0538901053,
0.0609607287,
0.0808634609,
-0.0355584286,
-0.0327125452,
0.0565582998,
-0.057721287,
-0.0507000685,
-0.0149610154,
0.0200284589,
-0.0130112236,
-0.0063283946,
-0.0470483713,
0.0170564149,
-0.0044992352,
0.0382532366,
-0.0171627998,
0.028887419,
-0.0096582919,
0.0367086343,
0.0271396246,
-0.0005055809,
0.0380830355,
-0.0083963573,
0.0438103415,
-0.0251350142,
-0.007669582,
-0.0360639989,
-0.0294927415,
-0.0960729867,
0.0355330408,
0.0159726683,
-0.0234998185,
0.0065321131,
0.018166136,
0.0645409822,
0.0284437593,
0.0126068341,
-0.0173746329,
-0.0535624772,
0.0449271426,
-0.0230360478,
-0.0380147174,
-0.0646862164,
-0.0213955063,
-0.0151343644,
0.0136347543,
-0.0277198497,
0.0205180105,
-0.0392423868,
-0.0109791076,
0.0183560345,
-0.0858791322,
0.0663468167,
0.0118008852,
0.0544118546,
-0.0051583638,
0.0585575029,
0.0551960394,
-0.0029517007,
0.0123928916,
-0.0749824271,
0.0283409487,
0.0327110887,
-0.0080619846,
0.0095368717,
0.0098911757,
0.0213837773,
-0.0123786181,
0.0046309708,
0.000631712,
0.0405508988,
-0.00054104,
0.0389444977,
0.001491954,
0.0188976806,
-0.0044556009,
0.0141195534,
0.0071871374,
0.0398801528,
0.0227447711,
-0.0169051271,
-0.0152739976,
0.0565506853,
-0.0361054391,
-0.0175833516,
-0.0030966166,
0.0158197265,
0.007587309,
-0.0635063872,
-0.0300480332,
-0.0178338718,
-0.0323248468,
-0.0100768115,
-0.0267634429,
-0.0300314967,
-0.0550245009,
0.0587213524,
-0.0309186,
-0.1255665272,
-0.0576285683,
-0.0477351509,
0.0465363488,
0.0266419817,
0.0285721049,
-0.0003550733,
-0.0100999642,
0.0146776093,
-0.0447075814,
-0.0484877527,
0.0582484119,
-0.0149146738,
0.0006521132,
-0.050120119,
-0.0109355869,
-0.0315833613,
-0.011592634,
0.019961657,
0.040098682,
-0.0303301383,
0.0524544008,
-0.0187836755,
-0.0222238339,
0.0108808996,
0.0249190442,
0.0139385359,
0.022350587,
-0.015994722,
0.0402787812,
-0.0292121712,
-0.0369505137,
0.0019754665,
0.0569791086,
-0.0150054693,
-0.0292465612,
-0.0145737259,
-0.0307115559,
0.0209575556,
-0.000259789,
-0.0601394139,
-0.0271630716,
0.0784068033,
-0.0155200148,
-0.0076090749,
-0.0161623321,
-0.023361491,
-0.0009344818,
0.0108934836,
0.0423213877,
-0.0444887094,
0.0122577026,
0.0016096603,
0.0506411567,
-0.0097030252,
0.0525908731,
-0.0063308636,
0.0702446103,
0.0603830516,
0.0198347513,
0.0200553238,
-0.0033123977,
-0.0352228507,
-0.0147546902,
0.0388519354,
0.0611229092,
-0.0144003332,
-0.0323060341,
-0.1067318395,
0.0584593192,
0.0056428504,
0.035583742,
0.0484573096,
-0.0022375274,
0.0054164487,
0.0623902529,
0.0090836119,
0.0305352639,
0.0021799235,
0.0206476022,
0.0044547864,
-0.0623966418,
-0.048081018,
0.0093362387,
0.0010347907,
-0.0367455259,
0.0376403332,
-0.0191493966,
-0.0154367937,
-0.0817965791,
0.1044923812,
0.0318759754,
-0.0121317673,
-0.0014774069,
-0.0567969084,
-0.0295134038,
-0.0219510198,
0.0798969716,
0.0315279402,
0.0098239966,
0.0010031129,
0.0125230616,
-0.0007088861,
-0.0647840202,
0.0260902978,
0.0761368722,
-0.0299809221,
0.076117754,
-0.0692162737,
0.0498358943,
0.0456770286,
-0.0227414612,
-0.0324529372,
-0.0083085103,
0.0511142351,
0.0056800852,
-0.0219327603,
-0.0052803853,
-0.0199504662,
0.0134592177,
0.0622664206,
-0.0049576545,
-0.112365447,
-0.0088610426,
-0.0526599288,
-0.0421918817,
0.0109380204,
-0.0245728344,
-0.0360769033,
0.0381649546,
0.0178209897,
0.0430764556,
-0.0225966778,
-0.0097901151,
0.0084487358,
0.0381577611,
0.0008288208,
-0.0282190684,
0.0352464803,
-0.0433829017,
0.0098997531,
-0.0356595889,
-0.0550436638,
-0.0126756979,
0.0025590267,
0.0262329821,
-0.0189608764,
0.0165696759,
-0.0236713979,
0.03923719,
0.0267816372,
0.0404211842,
0.027223872,
0.0228298567,
-0.0389044248,
0.0292991996,
-0.0045062904,
-0.0474417992,
-0.049038209,
-0.0114895767,
0.0347892083,
0.0062126829,
0.061558608,
0.0128959995,
0.0631515682,
-0.0250572786,
0.0122866156,
0.0577938035,
0.0296928138,
-0.0668478459,
0.0628085658,
0.0439555198,
-0.0354345031,
0.0074924831,
0.0292100422,
0.0163986366,
-0.00675144,
0.0320826918,
-0.0212302152,
0.0369094312,
0.0490711443,
0.0331949219,
-0.0743293092,
-0.0184061974,
0.0306825992,
0.0236827843,
-0.0384494513,
0.0027322958,
-0.0491204113,
-0.0456682779,
0.0562838688,
0.0119107477,
-0.0223295987,
-0.0164225362,
-0.0326168649,
-0.045883067,
0.0027544615,
-0.0685135648,
0.0364024304,
0.0096484311,
0.0321863182,
-0.0065534385,
-0.037259303,
0.0109963138,
-0.0010326481,
0.0197956003,
0.0056872736,
0.0859885812,
0.0252057072,
0.0050691469,
-0.0291602146,
0.0378476046,
-0.0248055682,
0.0024685459,
-0.0625850931,
-0.0241361987,
0.0458078384,
-0.0253136922,
0.029748274,
0.0175981503,
-0.0702912733,
0.0128141344,
0.0518875532,
0.0612425692,
0.0290753599,
-0.0286608804,
-0.0138687054,
-0.0284170676,
-0.0056878109,
0.0455504321,
0.0203272868,
0.0238627531,
-0.0791379213,
-0.0978532732,
-0.0090267211,
-0.0589124858,
-0.0245396588,
-0.0485526621,
-0.0166219976,
-0.0507371053,
0.0213835016,
0.0384071209,
-0.0269214679,
0.0234356336,
-0.0108344844,
-0.0561314188,
0.0052700522,
-0.0216402989,
-0.0696849078,
-0.03067993,
-0.0601532906,
0.0250822939,
-0.0567700379,
-0.0337849557,
0.0602627508,
0.0506894886,
0.0131709976,
0.0298003983,
-0.0554000065,
-0.0618737042,
-0.0249353983,
0.0843564644,
0.0252544321,
-0.0426407829,
0.0268864688,
0.0308815017,
-0.0458308309,
0.074383013,
-0.017221123,
0.0645216256,
0.0046835765,
0.0098053813,
0.0210221577,
-0.0252869371,
-0.0105387392,
0.0133871017,
-0.0088170776,
0.0421691574,
-0.0012920178,
-0.0134531781,
0.0282216109,
0.0937271342,
-0.0190421361,
-0.0227058455,
-0.0390368104,
0.060857594,
-0.0166215412,
0.0025091036,
-0.0340935662,
-0.0723100454,
0.0358970314,
-0.0091061397,
0.0020351848,
0.0125048002,
0.0497126766,
-0.0478284098,
0.0183944739,
0.0128657557,
0.0482612401,
-0.0368410796,
0.0398445427,
0.0679060891,
-0.0017200871,
-0.0371682532,
-0.0155537287,
0.0248809513,
-0.0079310639,
-0.0344246626,
0.0089841252,
0.0076026465,
0.0622908771,
0.0240992866,
0.036449492,
0.003530758,
-0.0539923087,
0.0004070031,
0.0095073571,
0.0304888748,
0.0764537901,
-0.0057170917,
-0.0390650965,
-0.0170743894,
-0.0232455265,
0.0267688651,
-0.024522135,
-0.0111045726,
0.0137143517,
0.0210204925,
-0.0511189923,
-0.0817930922,
0.1073410138,
0.045700781,
0.0056087943,
-0.0426937379,
-0.0021348444,
-0.0314717703,
-0.0104998527,
-0.0122420676,
-0.0478768051,
0.0186484735,
-0.018504573,
-0.0348499827,
-0.0335667729,
0.0032809421,
0.0359547511,
0.0700412467,
0.0118699735,
0.0324318409,
0.0374710187,
-0.0103148539,
-0.0464599915,
0.0051679946,
0.0008364191,
-0.0462711193,
-0.0249001272,
0.0337460525,
-6.977741079e-33,
-0.024451131,
-0.0541533716,
-0.0146564916,
0.0381301306,
0.0031776119,
-0.0005991168,
-0.0314411782,
-0.0037701274,
-0.0033867725,
-0.0244173855,
0.0096009616,
-0.0240765847,
-0.0060904408,
-0.0243231039,
0.0226381607,
0.0450270213,
0.006553893,
0.0325479358,
-0.0600165762,
-0.0310375057,
-0.0265400074,
0.013126689,
-0.0274837632,
-0.0115849599,
-0.0660883859,
-0.0228562374,
0.0053851716,
-0.0088670012,
-0.0160369072,
-0.0232636426,
-0.0035630662,
0.0159291979,
-0.0070599401,
0.0047178231,
-0.0318787061,
0.010921035,
-0.0326331742,
-0.052482985,
0.0186947249,
-0.0193187762,
-0.0235090218,
-0.0696560368,
0.0377339907,
0.0373543054,
-0.0717535168,
0.0223567262,
-0.03420927,
0.0030948131,
-0.0268671233,
-0.0247607883,
-0.0424452908,
0.0061040567,
-0.0168479085,
0.0430514999,
-0.0320949219,
0.0173050016,
0.0019163876,
0.0404781848,
0.0054593747,
0.0163826533,
0.0228920225,
0.0498358458,
0.0653304383,
-0.0689742491,
0.017878281,
-0.022181686,
0.0337740257,
-0.0056787217,
-0.072332032,
0.0079150274,
0.0227652658,
0.0003832564,
0.019726295,
0.0088836513,
0.046567928,
-0.0368189327,
-0.0239386037,
0.0460771807,
-0.0035631987,
-0.0341819897,
-0.0322814472,
0.0135598136,
0.004944439,
-0.0468654707,
-0.0435743183,
0.0362860858,
-0.0186816603,
-0.0149024008,
0.0417653248,
-0.0281697474,
-0.0339374952,
-0.0297215097,
0.0034316862,
-0.0153480135,
0.0338632017,
0.0696634203,
-0.0250485092,
0.0015962933,
0.015168149,
0.0500715114,
0.0022037956,
-0.0423422195,
-0.044686202,
0.0322511457,
0.0880962238,
0.0114623038,
-0.0099835871,
0.0312265083,
-0.073524788,
0.0237923265,
-0.0652406514,
-0.0088848677,
0.0032311929,
-0.0563605465,
-0.0432454869,
-0.0307300035,
0.0350339748,
0.0333577245,
0.0024625969,
-0.0288686361,
-0.0434544832,
-0.0160579477,
0.0142644448,
0.0494436882,
0.0054399837,
-0.0219979696,
-0.0601442456,
0.0210102517,
0.0159069132,
0.0132951848,
-0.0731082112,
0.0569686741,
3.281e-7,
-0.003003835,
-0.0080669224,
-0.0066684852,
0.0197775234,
0.0079329247,
0.0354638509,
0.0080723129,
-0.0125648873,
-0.0415805094,
0.0075952173,
-0.0294167548,
-0.0244282968,
0.0578779168,
0.0041870177,
0.025134787,
0.0082707889,
-0.0041929986,
-0.0232431106,
-0.034789063,
-0.001364068,
0.0060170642,
-0.0401126109,
0.0130198942,
-0.0187139586,
0.0110847363,
0.0008045173,
0.0252192765,
-0.0581703335,
0.0548891574,
0.0240455996,
-0.0734742135,
0.0051278025,
-0.0148810241,
-0.025694944,
-0.0013634728,
-0.0488801748,
0.0172051471,
0.0848123953,
0.0278916508,
0.0471247025,
0.0726401955,
-0.0536258928,
-0.0266044103,
-0.0219519548,
0.0331244506,
0.0493570454,
-0.0172690097,
0.022580713,
-0.0194412563,
-0.0053876834,
-0.0289420392,
-0.042409163,
0.0273469836,
0.0008257024,
-0.0148781333,
-0.0070532747,
-0.0238527935,
0.0247095115,
-0.0101785213,
-0.0520817488,
0.0000312141,
-0.0653025731,
-0.0290609915,
0.0818495378,
0.0664518252,
0.0146558415,
-0.0187977962,
3.238403366e-34,
0.0090888347,
-0.0448235236,
0.0363351889,
0.0078924252,
0.0561678186,
0.0262140166,
-0.0266469512,
-0.0303971376,
-0.0426853448,
0.0324236937,
-0.033646401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02030v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02030v2 | Panacea: Pareto Alignment via Preference Adaptation for LLMs | 2024-02-03T05:01:04 | 2024-05-23T13:49:25 | Yifan Zhong, Chengdong Ma, Xiaoyuan Zhang, Ziran Yang, Haojun Chen, Qingfu Zhang, Siyuan Qi, Yaodong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current methods for large language model alignment typically use scalar human
preference labels. However, this convention tends to oversimplify the
multi-dimensional and heterogeneous nature of human preferences, leading to
reduced expressivity and even misalignment. This paper presents Panacea, an
innovative approach that reframes alignment as a multi-dimensional preference
optimization problem. Panacea trains a single model capable of adapting online
and Pareto-optimally to diverse sets of preferences without the need for
further tuning. A major challenge here is using a low-dimensional preference
vector to guide the model's behavior, despite it being governed by an
overwhelmingly large number of parameters. To address this, Panacea is designed
to use singular value decomposition (SVD)-based low-rank adaptation, which
allows the preference vector to be simply injected online as singular values.
Theoretically, we prove that Panacea recovers the entire Pareto front with
common loss aggregation methods under mild conditions. Moreover, our
experiments demonstrate, for the first time, the feasibility of aligning a
single LLM to represent an exponentially vast spectrum of human preferences
through various optimization methods. Our work marks a step forward in
effectively and efficiently aligning models to diverse and intricate human
preferences in a controllable and Pareto-optimal manner. | [
-0.0106387371,
0.0722791329,
0.0053348872,
0.03753509,
0.0045902776,
0.0246731434,
-0.026171146,
-0.0147003597,
-0.0283156559,
-0.0257932357,
-0.0703292415,
-0.0299142972,
-0.0017618624,
-0.0199655499,
0.0328592807,
-0.0552081354,
0.0540379994,
-0.0052294759,
-0.0193382278,
-0.0270776432,
0.0430062748,
0.0207548887,
0.004006668,
0.0040828395,
0.0341159701,
-0.0229768828,
0.0142318783,
0.0118374815,
0.0538594089,
0.004372709,
0.0158189833,
0.0419503674,
0.0348311253,
0.0164363086,
0.0000017866,
-0.056149248,
-0.0407366194,
-0.021657858,
-0.0286653806,
0.0060011842,
0.034586709,
0.019625498,
-0.0374206379,
-0.0020190019,
-0.0133148395,
0.0142849153,
0.0660879016,
-0.0106998235,
0.0435029753,
0.0858705938,
-0.0052676089,
-0.0531214699,
-0.0190450978,
-0.0189045556,
-0.0228143316,
-0.0409601256,
0.0166427847,
-0.0646417513,
-0.0366734155,
-0.020405408,
-0.0132321604,
0.0263712853,
-0.0324824788,
0.0302315317,
0.0310571678,
0.012402866,
-0.0141210733,
-0.0134819206,
-0.024367027,
0.0866465196,
-0.0316233225,
-0.0190713778,
0.0180470459,
-0.0059487764,
0.0100841373,
-0.0407527275,
-0.0410356112,
-0.0230599195,
0.0273926333,
0.0409361012,
0.0093744704,
-0.0350474268,
0.0075258254,
0.0121906931,
-0.028363971,
0.08274775,
0.0418017097,
-0.0448556654,
0.0249146428,
-0.0133075081,
-0.0305978172,
-0.0230508223,
0.0183250736,
-0.0061276397,
-0.0778822526,
0.0342441089,
-0.0664664358,
-0.0452913158,
0.00051613,
-0.0766762346,
0.066755943,
0.0517075025,
-0.0082810782,
0.0283605009,
0.0284036715,
0.0713330731,
-0.0674540699,
0.0148622356,
-0.071242176,
0.0087098544,
0.0042361026,
0.0039069597,
0.0204988271,
0.0286406875,
-0.0150598884,
0.0080974344,
-0.0488716625,
0.0567565151,
0.0102395974,
0.0494650044,
0.0126803704,
0.0175890122,
-0.0325464346,
-0.0445621833,
-0.0180101153,
0.1010406613,
-0.0148946615,
0.0168375205,
-0.005434704,
0.0236331448,
0.0138246324,
0.0686795637,
-0.003106449,
-0.028437892,
0.0006085706,
0.0717371926,
-0.0485291295,
0.0146222673,
-0.0007608912,
0.0007765793,
-0.0363765359,
-0.044781018,
-0.0179907791,
-0.0500607155,
0.051588688,
0.0059429724,
-0.0126574282,
-0.0636145473,
-0.0202098954,
-0.0092006866,
-0.0296766721,
0.0678484365,
0.0416090563,
0.0134028923,
0.0102094579,
-0.0373267941,
0.0034961863,
0.0601054356,
0.0301154461,
0.0369526036,
0.0161140468,
-0.0325691514,
-0.0501270108,
0.0776782557,
-0.0140501875,
0.0143883331,
-0.0622792505,
0.0278962012,
0.0302559603,
0.0514716692,
0.0698599964,
0.0334650874,
0.0186320841,
-0.0334278159,
0.0728606433,
0.052526243,
0.0289589334,
0.0176801588,
-0.0273379236,
0.0390130021,
-0.0416837633,
0.0119971624,
-0.040460214,
0.0353652984,
-0.0437007584,
0.0126559492,
0.0269769318,
0.0517676398,
-0.0136143938,
-0.0206565373,
-0.0189475007,
-0.0054150485,
-0.0364837497,
0.0058461181,
0.0322431959,
-0.0656864196,
-0.0544912182,
0.0634724647,
0.0266776513,
-0.0786836296,
0.0180859268,
0.0016794507,
0.0402254313,
0.0771912783,
0.0132959485,
-0.0139395585,
-0.0543838963,
0.0093458146,
-0.0182584431,
0.055011522,
0.0371810235,
-0.0212819315,
-0.0136043206,
-0.0558876544,
-0.032485351,
0.0517730489,
-0.007821884,
0.0429050997,
-0.0112520857,
-0.0393791683,
-0.0154765313,
-0.0054053771,
-0.0015106063,
0.0192190576,
-0.0242596921,
-0.0166316386,
0.0031703236,
0.029180333,
0.0369489715,
0.0068506137,
0.0138083491,
-0.0223195031,
0.0200062245,
-0.0121830497,
0.0023055843,
0.0051109637,
-0.0190664511,
-0.0003202443,
0.0549925752,
-0.0372418091,
-0.043490611,
0.0625725538,
-0.0349298269,
-0.0393035077,
-0.029571021,
-0.0294650085,
0.0084269904,
-0.0262782089,
0.0431315415,
-0.0160912387,
0.0037200667,
-0.0495676808,
0.0627785623,
-0.0110749286,
0.0009674517,
0.003616913,
-0.0154567445,
0.0015058439,
-0.0822618157,
-0.0232925061,
0.0189537667,
0.0030303537,
0.0416467749,
0.015561386,
0.0113095101,
-0.0379096381,
-0.0266868677,
-0.0572382361,
0.0352400057,
-0.0125005394,
0.0347587876,
0.034280736,
-0.0162749011,
-0.0036447735,
-0.029081447,
-0.0629824251,
0.0203533117,
-0.0197552852,
0.0115951411,
0.0462651812,
-0.0105923824,
-0.0262075346,
-0.065959461,
0.0169704147,
-0.0096905399,
-0.0112712346,
-0.0515485406,
0.0137169501,
-0.0658542216,
0.0646377206,
-0.0423025601,
0.0066060973,
0.0007890938,
-0.0264060684,
-0.0188712496,
0.0068670106,
0.0358468965,
0.074009344,
0.0210027546,
0.0003845876,
0.0666025952,
0.0130523881,
-0.0548621491,
-0.0054975059,
-0.041809313,
-0.0163024683,
-0.0642287657,
0.0113990167,
0.0214656983,
0.0451805741,
-0.0072312318,
0.0191466007,
-0.0708778724,
0.0111827226,
0.0166227799,
-0.0143885529,
-0.0333412662,
0.0486692451,
-0.057079833,
0.0352299437,
-0.0160258245,
-0.0330515802,
0.0691563711,
-0.0154015431,
-0.0197853483,
-0.0380758904,
-0.0128995916,
-0.0409150682,
-0.0263684262,
-0.0148944724,
0.0233623814,
-0.0327171497,
-0.0042788661,
-0.108404614,
-0.0195477922,
0.0111020319,
-0.0256743692,
0.071295768,
-0.0328887142,
0.0082057668,
-0.0260536466,
-0.089766182,
-0.0359320641,
-0.0462327749,
-0.0058085686,
-0.0281063206,
0.0097450903,
-0.051334016,
-0.0468979441,
-0.0253242739,
0.0127281565,
0.006254517,
-0.0038840515,
0.0239459015,
-0.035212189,
0.0212487299,
0.0857939422,
0.0652236715,
-0.0094227167,
-0.0034441561,
-0.0103335418,
0.0384534858,
0.0513708554,
-0.0113174953,
-0.0015872557,
0.0107015939,
0.0702435821,
-0.036611136,
-0.0051535233,
0.0109961173,
0.017606711,
0.01058135,
0.0290517565,
0.105251275,
0.0149410339,
-0.0761767775,
-0.0001174763,
-0.0130387899,
0.0695373565,
0.0244027823,
0.0374301299,
-0.0442632958,
-0.0067438497,
-0.0102678863,
0.0425131842,
0.0327725746,
0.0135251405,
-0.0182793047,
-0.1052372307,
0.001982478,
0.0388992727,
-0.0313354172,
0.0293786339,
-0.0165624451,
0.0260272678,
-0.0550016165,
0.0770355016,
0.019180825,
-0.0123452572,
-0.0253954194,
0.0091455346,
-0.0117708705,
-0.0197986979,
0.0013165214,
-0.020691501,
0.0554571524,
0.0582201257,
0.0367389843,
-0.0005928108,
-0.0743262172,
0.0143303983,
0.02544819,
-0.0425652117,
-0.0015999826,
-0.0036433637,
-0.0185422357,
-0.005504386,
-0.0153397629,
0.0638621822,
-0.0460912324,
0.0110161249,
-0.0078000235,
0.0830177292,
0.0076110195,
0.0354106389,
0.0188452136,
-0.0213885084,
-0.0283351447,
0.062293373,
-0.0003753077,
-0.0761888996,
-0.0124280648,
-0.0380249955,
-0.0464651063,
-0.0363219976,
-0.0366340838,
0.0034030105,
-0.0412754864,
-0.0142801134,
-0.0548718646,
-0.0040915655,
-0.006224812,
0.0346720219,
0.0073125861,
-0.0086279036,
0.0082096718,
-0.0223645642,
-0.0125240795,
0.0339665525,
-0.0329501443,
-0.0101062553,
-0.0740132183,
-0.0086562019,
0.0326107889,
-0.0198394954,
-0.0030608845,
-0.0414607786,
-0.0423619412,
-0.0886514187,
-0.0019717142,
0.0190549139,
0.0172857884,
0.0556135401,
0.0152456602,
-0.0747445971,
0.0304935258,
0.0368212312,
0.0213210844,
0.0528669655,
0.0278476272,
0.0356512479,
-0.0115947844,
0.0513849519,
-0.0569641851,
-0.0089268163,
0.005160002,
0.0179396551,
-0.0320930183,
-0.0483028293,
0.0182385892,
0.0239723735,
0.0229512602,
-0.0419375785,
-0.0408681333,
-0.0197451562,
0.0222956371,
-0.0132549126,
-0.0225969981,
0.0040480588,
-0.043732293,
0.0385165364,
-0.0164340157,
0.0027189308,
0.0179961678,
-0.005761411,
0.0284742732,
-0.0522844158,
-0.0085676732,
-0.0006621286,
-0.0105634471,
0.0399421193,
0.0514362678,
-0.0061443197,
0.0312908068,
0.0125549836,
0.0525411591,
-0.0088595767,
0.0165881887,
0.0317138284,
0.0120330453,
-0.0274150614,
0.0404688716,
-0.0032772596,
-0.0569877438,
-0.0380580314,
-0.0290738419,
0.0512276925,
-0.0077834013,
0.0871245116,
0.0125401681,
-0.0183395017,
-0.0319256,
0.0421440937,
-0.0455629639,
0.0128709869,
0.0339321978,
0.0008013964,
-0.0187699292,
0.0074061397,
0.0453271978,
0.0059789657,
0.0091714179,
-0.0504485406,
0.0157321636,
-0.0521403365,
-0.0269705225,
-0.0139315808,
0.0124419434,
-0.036357373,
-0.0516804494,
-0.0408556983,
-0.0552558899,
0.0116650825,
0.0033519617,
-0.0109862108,
-0.0053310841,
0.0362980887,
0.0379454829,
-0.0588301867,
0.0141489282,
0.0070028366,
-0.0215097889,
-0.0279860273,
-0.0306797344,
-0.0174975693,
-6.148264878e-33,
-0.0443208069,
-0.0138566205,
0.0231833886,
0.0070251063,
-0.0259917267,
-0.0713473111,
0.0213839393,
0.0419978835,
0.012362238,
-0.0361307189,
0.0050716493,
-0.0382417776,
0.0207609497,
0.0067626443,
0.0408590659,
0.0011673081,
0.0318846591,
-0.010412571,
-0.0438389741,
-0.0275882129,
0.0528376624,
0.0186398439,
0.0485853739,
-0.0541836061,
-0.0013432242,
0.0214615241,
-0.0231298022,
0.0385951437,
0.0094546583,
0.0780520588,
-0.0004355874,
0.0456365272,
0.0045388667,
0.0058771665,
-0.0202448126,
0.0457364284,
-0.0109335575,
-0.0051069232,
0.0480513126,
0.0421637557,
0.0458325073,
-0.0503183007,
0.0384684987,
0.0014639477,
-0.0514437482,
-0.0012790107,
0.0427573621,
-0.0335611179,
-0.0227517374,
0.0333658867,
-0.047054898,
-0.0003523761,
-0.0045019723,
-0.0033207419,
0.0406702459,
0.0450592786,
-0.0013906307,
0.0389130116,
-0.0532679968,
0.0440646484,
-0.0379095338,
0.0300154872,
0.1169059426,
0.0287965182,
-0.031270761,
0.0429549702,
0.035671182,
-0.0455593616,
0.0324852914,
-0.0384678431,
0.030555509,
0.0144537147,
0.0173908994,
0.0441375636,
-0.0103974696,
0.0012769047,
-0.0159482751,
0.0465640612,
0.0094038593,
-0.0151175791,
0.0147705683,
0.0788559914,
-0.021341566,
-0.0199508239,
-0.0252766442,
-0.0183843076,
-0.0446160026,
-0.0179569926,
0.0218655169,
-0.0138818473,
-0.0190414004,
-0.0075751725,
0.0440592468,
-0.0360883512,
-0.0082764085,
-0.0074940086,
-0.0351956859,
0.0273043774,
0.0126196472,
0.0057916348,
-0.0481235236,
-0.0321748368,
-0.0107426895,
-0.018239202,
-0.0006759018,
0.0183846261,
0.0249782503,
0.0101822969,
-0.0647021458,
0.0232413094,
-0.005311517,
-0.063290976,
0.0021998833,
0.0417952463,
0.0398532264,
-0.0246361941,
0.0119064534,
0.0825408325,
0.0212403964,
0.0103696557,
-0.041754052,
-0.0342835411,
0.0011931128,
0.0109068239,
-0.0175997131,
0.0355674103,
0.0119366907,
0.0051086619,
0.0257342514,
-0.0163836386,
0.0011390757,
-0.0273062363,
2.509e-7,
0.0361086801,
0.0490088947,
0.0006610744,
-0.0313936286,
-0.0072237086,
0.0550123043,
-0.0298481453,
0.0311890822,
-0.009419933,
-0.0086638862,
0.0299811102,
0.0022031197,
0.0502470583,
0.0018308448,
-0.0783131272,
-0.0000936688,
-0.0416968465,
0.0391768031,
-0.0482554585,
0.0042111734,
0.0399857983,
0.0971147642,
0.0354125202,
-0.0095230108,
-0.0192024522,
0.0475970842,
0.0692422986,
-0.0417155102,
-0.0160556249,
-0.002396578,
-0.0024036756,
-0.0315837637,
-0.0495356955,
-0.0330752656,
0.0024984179,
0.0533606559,
-0.0192465056,
0.1085270047,
-0.0145472232,
-0.0676410943,
-0.0064131524,
0.02654282,
-0.0082202908,
-0.0382717438,
0.0229394678,
-0.034858495,
-0.0184865184,
-0.0374712497,
-0.0188399814,
0.0243365131,
0.007497442,
-0.0290641394,
0.0200071186,
-0.0040547173,
0.0230585672,
-0.014066725,
-0.0191488713,
-0.0558090471,
-0.02053909,
0.0436190739,
-0.0661386251,
-0.0453191996,
-0.0065215724,
0.0315139405,
0.0382462405,
-0.0363551378,
-0.0026175529,
2.036377052e-34,
0.0018824481,
0.0116155688,
0.010223411,
0.0463341288,
-0.0111686662,
-0.0152398879,
0.0002039885,
0.0322505794,
0.0384088904,
-0.0846773833,
0.0020049431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05119v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05119v4 | A Closer Look at the Limitations of Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-03T04:45:25 | 2024-05-28T01:55:38 | Sreyan Ghosh, Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Sonal Kumar, Ramaneswaran S, Deepali Aneja, Zeyu Jin, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction Tuning (IT), the process of training large language models (LLMs)
using instruction-response pairs, has emerged as the predominant method for
transforming base pre-trained LLMs into open-domain conversational agents.
While IT has achieved notable success and widespread adoption, its limitations
and shortcomings remain underexplored. In this paper, through rigorous
experiments and an in-depth analysis of the changes LLMs undergo through IT, we
reveal various limitations of IT. In particular, we show that (1) IT fails to
enhance knowledge or skills in LLMs. LoRA fine-tuning is limited to learning
response initiation and style tokens, and full-parameter fine-tuning leads to
knowledge degradation. (2) Copying response patterns from IT datasets derived
from knowledgeable sources leads to a decline in response quality. (3)
Full-parameter fine-tuning increases hallucination by inaccurately borrowing
tokens from conceptually similar instances in the IT dataset for generating
responses. (4) Popular methods to improve IT do not lead to performance
improvements over a simple LoRA fine-tuned model. Our findings reveal that
responses generated solely from pre-trained knowledge consistently outperform
responses by models that learn any form of new knowledge from IT on open-source
datasets. We hope the insights and challenges revealed in this paper inspire
future work in related directions. | [
0.0597260594,
0.0555290803,
-0.0308817476,
0.0169179384,
0.002595664,
0.0150063885,
-0.0132384067,
-0.016711615,
-0.0139996894,
-0.0637025088,
-0.0888582245,
-0.0209867265,
-0.0204544328,
0.0109586809,
0.0014656862,
-0.0457697846,
0.0430019535,
-0.0729748607,
-0.0019676953,
-0.0178224836,
-0.0029959928,
0.0144621944,
-0.0223126858,
0.0543879271,
0.0175149627,
-0.0256380178,
-0.0414847583,
0.010646333,
-0.0149426432,
-0.0138148209,
0.044553414,
0.061099939,
0.0383172929,
-0.0045405822,
0.0000020789,
-0.0575195588,
0.0112577258,
-0.0512314104,
-0.0266775917,
0.0192600563,
0.037710689,
0.0184222311,
0.0175186228,
0.0319293775,
-0.0575423166,
-0.0384716056,
0.0154442145,
0.0441852137,
0.0507891513,
0.0707406476,
0.0070650605,
-0.0426095352,
0.036906369,
-0.0045845965,
-0.005972404,
-0.0310124755,
-0.0014481252,
0.0140904384,
-0.0011551027,
-0.0014251255,
-0.0400324613,
0.0155176045,
0.0253275633,
0.0027651475,
0.0188974869,
0.0018087083,
-0.0690541863,
-0.0419153459,
-0.0527917221,
0.0945385993,
-0.0037771733,
-0.0042391815,
-0.0193877202,
-0.006259752,
0.0198387019,
-0.0040496457,
-0.0254664272,
0.0182288419,
0.0213226359,
0.0199221987,
-0.0187768657,
-0.0230147727,
-0.0145088695,
-0.0072618164,
-0.0223989189,
0.0475764722,
0.0000323408,
-0.035488952,
0.0229634978,
-0.0244874675,
-0.0167470202,
-0.0662065446,
-0.0241565909,
0.0617515482,
-0.0437087864,
0.0201367382,
-0.0583654009,
0.0372243114,
0.0379390903,
0.0027782756,
0.0743373036,
0.0306375269,
-0.0228204112,
0.0034953761,
-0.0249689519,
0.0449838936,
0.0150383255,
0.056549117,
-0.0276290309,
0.0105284918,
-0.0712208301,
-0.0174927469,
-0.0349193886,
0.0220289864,
-0.0451170802,
-0.0236891434,
0.003461668,
0.047022257,
0.0081790611,
-0.0101480335,
-0.0215283837,
-0.0096464138,
-0.0058614262,
0.0032332141,
-0.0757171139,
0.0270945281,
-0.0206674058,
0.0592497624,
0.0262548104,
-0.1077100262,
-0.0110655241,
0.0121430978,
0.0244100131,
0.0136410659,
0.0284482557,
0.0430877879,
-0.015302768,
-0.0445379764,
-0.0170948133,
-0.0244031884,
-0.0080851195,
-0.1067600027,
0.0161114819,
-0.0360602848,
0.0074208253,
0.0244632512,
-0.0265632626,
-0.0170583948,
0.0169569366,
0.0001402243,
-0.0538246222,
0.0356464423,
-0.0076379399,
0.0345215984,
0.0079218037,
0.0137138106,
0.0181070399,
0.0553413294,
0.0313256532,
0.0001986078,
-0.0009073913,
-0.0415006205,
0.0283301771,
0.0336023308,
0.0130865658,
0.0150012914,
0.0258092955,
0.0330531187,
0.0324841253,
0.0106641576,
0.0614069887,
0.0179175697,
-0.0342895128,
0.0204876028,
0.0838859752,
0.0108666494,
0.0068020197,
-0.001089912,
0.0381257273,
0.0461949185,
0.0266195107,
0.0107536865,
-0.0677742362,
0.0170596261,
-0.0059215855,
0.0146551821,
0.0315871127,
0.0114085916,
-0.0629837811,
-0.050453525,
0.0166962817,
0.0022913055,
0.0154227782,
0.0440466516,
-0.0070888163,
0.0558675304,
-0.0910211354,
0.0423010774,
0.0533523746,
-0.0314473808,
-0.0036976382,
-0.0781812742,
0.0358967446,
0.0624376982,
0.0197628755,
-0.0049619819,
-0.0417990647,
-0.0173078701,
0.0608771443,
0.0559260771,
0.0440027416,
-0.0040215761,
0.037175741,
-0.0745135248,
-0.0225384925,
-0.0526969917,
0.0026851664,
0.0304271691,
0.0100903986,
0.0022399249,
-0.0184806846,
0.009787051,
-0.0334836394,
0.0332053602,
-0.0121678635,
-0.0349972285,
-0.029490808,
0.001727429,
0.0178044308,
-0.0128446817,
0.0057804189,
0.0082984399,
0.0283690318,
-0.0020654325,
0.0138248075,
0.0040109544,
-0.0626922473,
-0.0192429572,
0.0071694925,
0.0232309457,
-0.0177070294,
0.0225338507,
-0.0200909916,
-0.0416004844,
0.036887899,
-0.0137298126,
0.0707236752,
-0.0150527591,
0.0326866917,
0.0013143412,
0.0356620885,
-0.026014939,
0.0209765583,
-0.0003823724,
-0.0071563693,
0.0328563154,
0.0415191166,
-0.0221814867,
-0.0311154742,
0.014572911,
-0.0112082679,
-0.0049581714,
0.0228732899,
-0.0027651745,
0.0195506439,
-0.0723741576,
-0.0418595858,
-0.0734175816,
0.0087126093,
-0.0138323698,
0.0201928914,
0.0215533115,
-0.0133606633,
-0.0328666754,
-0.0247753747,
-0.0350919031,
0.0290802922,
0.0046112742,
0.0261146631,
0.0025529612,
0.0217141639,
-0.0509680994,
-0.0484514758,
0.0278190654,
0.014597672,
-0.0037120001,
-0.0150606399,
0.0511253402,
-0.0544864126,
0.0632286221,
-0.0243944433,
0.0422866791,
-0.019784255,
-0.0694964081,
0.0369804464,
-0.0033459445,
0.0370608717,
0.0673382431,
0.0317531303,
0.0179192461,
0.031953603,
-0.0251505878,
-0.0701319054,
0.0333667397,
-0.0361899175,
-0.0660151765,
-0.0682361946,
-0.0068625561,
-0.0043545947,
0.0553304851,
0.0265397001,
0.0441470705,
-0.0713311434,
-0.0015081898,
0.0172990933,
-0.0804271251,
0.0168878939,
0.004222543,
-0.0214902796,
0.002097755,
-0.0246059429,
-0.046622701,
0.0456404723,
-0.0252953805,
-0.0356771313,
-0.033483047,
0.0059035057,
-0.0331680626,
0.017771937,
-0.0022971048,
-0.0008912068,
-0.0197596364,
-0.0248494912,
-0.0551443025,
-0.0167520847,
0.0022422622,
-0.0142878722,
0.0373363309,
-0.0541430749,
-0.022527175,
0.0135135539,
-0.0397075862,
-0.0521687306,
-0.0305229109,
-0.0001909178,
0.0095041413,
-0.0006487028,
0.012819713,
-0.0287792981,
-0.0026669994,
0.0185883027,
0.0230147578,
-0.0187353641,
-0.0063178721,
-0.043612238,
0.0032115839,
0.0727202967,
0.0335105434,
0.0093529755,
-0.0399845354,
0.0586549006,
0.0214161426,
0.0381382257,
0.0022181701,
-0.0062723886,
0.0371532291,
0.0289061088,
-0.004111967,
-0.0013666824,
0.0348921567,
0.0937602744,
-0.0371079519,
-0.0295938719,
0.1215403453,
0.0148341144,
-0.0263195708,
-0.0030143473,
-0.0246915258,
0.0660560876,
0.0327916704,
0.0073201628,
-0.0636355281,
-0.0397298932,
-0.0220915079,
0.0269796085,
-0.0169152189,
-0.003838073,
0.0007321496,
-0.1245645434,
0.037449114,
-0.0034349007,
-0.0700514242,
-0.0070026829,
-0.0307433251,
0.015239262,
0.0228716321,
0.0558426231,
0.0115521597,
-0.0482433289,
-0.0068131285,
0.0387544818,
-0.00598747,
-0.0368584394,
0.0370060764,
-0.0354739577,
0.0808779076,
0.0758950859,
0.0176656973,
0.0270242523,
-0.0416315906,
0.0305923764,
-0.015150154,
0.0382342152,
0.002194677,
0.0402436629,
-0.0053007319,
0.0067498116,
-0.0148309879,
0.0419739708,
-0.03376038,
-0.007134933,
0.0070708045,
0.022884747,
-0.0273970701,
-0.0116903689,
0.0197221916,
0.0182686243,
0.0334946439,
0.058246471,
0.0576953627,
-0.0550974347,
-0.0474654846,
0.0067239539,
0.0132141626,
-0.0290854611,
-0.0307911448,
0.040708635,
-0.0122213755,
0.0230759047,
-0.0352588445,
-0.0780244842,
0.0539885722,
-0.0169338584,
0.0011904732,
-0.0001096161,
-0.0203081314,
0.0066982685,
0.0040331651,
0.0631054863,
-0.0493213311,
-0.0196428858,
-0.0927178934,
-0.0753268078,
0.015386153,
-0.0515822992,
0.0052785818,
0.0010480849,
-0.054458037,
-0.0703113675,
0.0181656983,
0.0904974937,
0.0226079151,
0.0621717721,
0.0259660799,
-0.0449194871,
0.0353992656,
0.0154119506,
-0.0406797715,
0.036610052,
0.039874211,
0.0132455127,
-0.0065951189,
0.0411191061,
-0.0350643396,
0.043280296,
0.0440105349,
0.0386620127,
-0.0074606044,
-0.0271263979,
0.035723798,
0.0027817881,
0.0252148118,
0.0174363088,
-0.011902038,
-0.0144022247,
0.0388973057,
-0.0103001455,
0.0211342759,
-0.052278772,
-0.055476699,
0.0107487096,
0.0078502446,
0.0126806935,
-0.0148856295,
-0.0448315851,
0.0369532555,
-0.0321506113,
0.0307186823,
0.0397926606,
0.0280688927,
0.0500577278,
0.0156736299,
-0.0465929918,
0.0369060151,
0.013979312,
0.0326248705,
0.0225295015,
0.0807068869,
-0.0114959925,
-0.0107910158,
-0.0122246407,
0.0369725041,
-0.0472826548,
-0.0848161653,
-0.0048011541,
0.0187492557,
0.0064618681,
-0.0012768401,
0.0553536452,
-0.0077496408,
0.0217278227,
0.0025314009,
0.0151899131,
-0.0096792774,
-0.0318113007,
0.0365501791,
0.0248622634,
-0.0189622473,
-0.0029826541,
0.0803232417,
0.0007374479,
0.0887838677,
-0.0198736973,
0.048554495,
-0.0377682745,
-0.0294328388,
0.0266813915,
-0.00355175,
-0.0059613637,
0.0264495276,
-0.0222074222,
-0.0472011492,
-0.0380142294,
-0.0023966681,
-0.0113445539,
-0.0434043817,
0.0503638163,
0.0180108305,
-0.0240368657,
-0.0375992022,
-0.0481723584,
-0.0067140358,
-0.0146947065,
-0.0149848498,
-0.0061084908,
-6.623231819e-33,
-0.033433076,
0.0073781745,
0.0390441306,
0.0127508705,
-0.0144327944,
-0.0386203751,
-0.0437388308,
-0.0026586773,
-0.0417824686,
-0.0232856851,
-0.0089536002,
0.0023919605,
0.0136321392,
0.0201358572,
0.0069043781,
-0.0312447492,
0.0417440087,
-0.0028150843,
-0.0262078941,
0.025926888,
0.013445979,
0.0038155254,
0.0381259955,
-0.043799635,
-0.0082209194,
-0.0280862395,
-0.0026144048,
0.0009848599,
-0.0252124444,
0.0625711307,
-0.0190889891,
0.0390439518,
0.0061352113,
-0.036275208,
-0.0162565652,
0.0233401284,
-0.0470311865,
-0.0345191732,
0.0290321093,
0.0232321136,
-0.0256734621,
-0.0489220433,
0.0351259634,
-0.0143430149,
-0.0326603353,
0.0045594038,
0.0155620174,
-0.0035230601,
-0.0091221277,
0.0397450291,
-0.0988639891,
-0.0129325613,
-0.0015484906,
-0.0702029541,
-0.0171331726,
0.0578422621,
-0.0124495467,
-0.0151053835,
-0.0674253851,
0.0379814208,
0.0335132852,
0.0023753108,
0.0401811227,
0.0424396433,
0.0128174573,
0.0446174257,
0.0363449231,
0.0399079807,
0.0333012491,
-0.0170367695,
0.029934559,
0.0619148761,
-0.0381322354,
0.0105495416,
0.0057679131,
0.0054475791,
-0.0355023742,
-0.0130162342,
-0.011318136,
0.0557744838,
0.0204906426,
0.008093019,
-0.0320542939,
-0.0138172284,
-0.0479086675,
0.0134798586,
-0.0251967367,
-0.0316477753,
0.066876255,
0.0321247093,
0.0109311379,
-0.0418645702,
0.0432446003,
-0.017326368,
-0.0097300168,
-0.018959064,
-0.0392079093,
0.02388102,
-0.0302929394,
0.0092244279,
-0.0957334861,
-0.0620794781,
0.0482109338,
-0.0374333486,
0.0212844331,
0.038522087,
0.0059055001,
0.0357703306,
-0.0564254522,
-0.01748541,
-0.0255728886,
0.0656019375,
0.0212598201,
-0.0044549266,
0.0192449372,
0.0195588693,
-0.0356338359,
0.0522394627,
-0.0086870957,
-0.0287708174,
-0.0266696289,
-0.0452123433,
-0.0008124802,
0.0151623702,
-0.0423203073,
-0.0090238154,
-0.0462901443,
-0.0430908762,
-0.0177581534,
-0.0480081514,
-0.0130702313,
0.0146172382,
2.842e-7,
-0.0104948888,
0.0300165396,
-0.0004925434,
0.0389297418,
0.0160687454,
0.0209024027,
-0.0129567897,
0.0269368868,
0.0564656071,
-0.0113797802,
-0.0197420008,
0.0437952876,
0.0512687527,
-0.0044339653,
-0.0953981876,
-0.0405283496,
-0.0233497638,
0.0073789698,
-0.0520220287,
-0.0148341674,
0.0204102453,
0.0699097216,
-0.0147090303,
-0.0095686503,
-0.0242854189,
-0.0032686372,
0.0721195489,
-0.0301015526,
-0.0155753056,
0.0535626039,
0.0068675857,
0.0039210478,
-0.0085010966,
0.059235964,
0.0142507525,
0.0291128829,
-0.0465145931,
0.044106517,
-0.0023613602,
-0.0767740682,
0.0129520092,
-0.0000066353,
-0.0009582069,
-0.0408915617,
0.078476727,
-0.0625868812,
-0.0400881507,
0.0100060459,
-0.0128577845,
-0.0275500156,
0.003324677,
-0.0161350314,
-0.016966382,
0.0170907378,
0.0116534391,
-0.0035305205,
0.0060234237,
-0.0668524876,
0.0247762334,
0.0158214327,
-0.0305742286,
-0.0739444047,
-0.0328752398,
-0.0048485608,
0.0125750694,
-0.0374920294,
0.0250541586,
2.359973427e-34,
0.0076894909,
0.0090689156,
0.0620403625,
0.0613737814,
0.027606491,
0.0056425491,
0.0071830032,
0.0334681049,
0.0363275185,
-0.1273566931,
0.0018369885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02008v1 | How well do LLMs cite relevant medical references? An evaluation framework and analyses | 2024-02-03T03:44:57 | 2024-02-03T03:44:57 | Kevin Wu, Eric Wu, Ally Cassasola, Angela Zhang, Kevin Wei, Teresa Nguyen, Sith Riantawan, Patricia Shi Riantawan, Daniel E. Ho, James Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are currently being used to answer medical
questions across a variety of clinical domains. Recent top-performing
commercial LLMs, in particular, are also capable of citing sources to support
their responses. In this paper, we ask: do the sources that LLMs generate
actually support the claims that they make? To answer this, we propose three
contributions. First, as expert medical annotations are an expensive and
time-consuming bottleneck for scalable evaluation, we demonstrate that GPT-4 is
highly accurate in validating source relevance, agreeing 88% of the time with a
panel of medical doctors. Second, we develop an end-to-end, automated pipeline
called \textit{SourceCheckup} and use it to evaluate five top-performing LLMs
on a dataset of 1200 generated questions, totaling over 40K pairs of statements
and sources. Interestingly, we find that between ~50% to 90% of LLM responses
are not fully supported by the sources they provide. We also evaluate GPT-4
with retrieval augmented generation (RAG) and find that, even still, around
30\% of individual statements are unsupported, while nearly half of its
responses are not fully supported. Third, we open-source our curated dataset of
medical questions and expert annotations for future evaluations. Given the
rapid pace of LLM development and the potential harms of incorrect or outdated
medical information, it is crucial to also understand and quantify their
capability to produce relevant, trustworthy medical references. | [
0.0670182332,
0.046853859,
0.0090476554,
-0.0372472182,
-0.0228715129,
0.0062638107,
0.0242981818,
0.0368811302,
0.0265168268,
-0.0436295755,
-0.0112527646,
-0.0262200795,
-0.0197240971,
-0.0055372845,
0.0132230194,
0.0045915525,
0.0163907092,
0.0455178991,
0.0628445446,
-0.0039506783,
-0.015019183,
0.0176079627,
-0.0421317331,
0.0496926866,
0.0240509566,
0.0005323025,
0.0569939837,
-0.0116189718,
0.0242696051,
-0.0753296688,
-0.0021262516,
0.0257347804,
-0.0348221883,
-0.0041756621,
0.0000018947,
-0.0518946275,
-0.0122020515,
0.0314225331,
-0.0292724445,
0.0162008852,
0.0147231026,
-0.0213993676,
0.0095881689,
0.0239585917,
-0.0540733337,
-0.0493914895,
0.029867677,
0.018742634,
0.0682664141,
0.0533573292,
-0.0108822193,
0.0212336499,
0.0456465892,
-0.0292809047,
0.0423263349,
-0.0464899242,
0.0430799797,
0.0347579978,
0.0376749784,
0.0313987695,
0.0488571748,
0.0554069206,
-0.0280473121,
0.0241514202,
0.0230944268,
0.0348260924,
-0.0481637232,
-0.0103029218,
0.0282988846,
0.0405782387,
0.0552454479,
-0.017908467,
0.0261420459,
0.0040316284,
-0.0130340615,
0.0619481727,
-0.0447581708,
0.010012133,
-0.024027979,
-0.0063137421,
-0.0002921896,
-0.0319593735,
0.0482841507,
0.0201716963,
0.0114927534,
0.0505557731,
0.0019455242,
-0.0252260678,
0.0310673211,
0.0078910775,
0.0003212472,
-0.0610253476,
0.0311098862,
0.019664621,
-0.0167894345,
0.0131763658,
0.0162579957,
-0.0077756424,
0.1019972935,
-0.0335882008,
-0.0139425043,
-0.014127682,
-0.0318483673,
0.0299381204,
-0.0194916781,
-0.0098791495,
-0.049793791,
-0.0011466763,
-0.0395730585,
0.0127359247,
-0.04761713,
-0.0308297519,
0.0016541679,
0.0057746051,
-0.0080938591,
0.0242623016,
-0.0770918876,
-0.0142944949,
-0.0317459963,
0.0208331794,
-0.0053980672,
0.0192083474,
0.0034970478,
0.0132510448,
-0.0463171043,
0.0366129801,
-0.0015952836,
0.0394381247,
-0.0137699815,
-0.0718633384,
0.0239137076,
0.0084892958,
0.005320922,
-0.0121750925,
0.0360867679,
0.049948547,
0.0256511848,
0.0041221902,
-0.0026038273,
-0.0449143201,
-0.0505731255,
-0.0355877168,
0.0223841798,
-0.0726325437,
0.0296456497,
0.041073557,
0.0112095987,
-0.0663020834,
0.0234655347,
0.0591631308,
-0.0694758222,
0.0350752287,
-0.056822788,
0.0307792109,
0.035174299,
0.0238421075,
0.0151438564,
-0.0048268936,
0.0299119987,
-0.0677396581,
0.0078712469,
-0.0016377681,
-0.0022926098,
-0.0022204507,
0.0331898667,
-0.0016502639,
0.0306197479,
0.0460545123,
-0.0009956978,
0.0462977663,
-0.0423084833,
0.0904170349,
-0.022259498,
-0.0080525577,
0.0383191928,
0.0543646701,
-0.0119447224,
-0.0054096123,
0.0282256305,
-0.0223734472,
0.0312235616,
-0.0071576959,
-0.0226148199,
0.00838577,
0.0143953273,
-0.0141279818,
0.0288469046,
-0.008247559,
-0.010158495,
-0.0243653599,
-0.0506417528,
0.0074517629,
-0.0545284189,
0.0135017941,
0.0147670321,
-0.0289744195,
-0.0188833717,
0.0984959677,
0.0209012479,
-0.045511242,
-0.0099719856,
-0.0298240557,
0.0020806252,
0.0206092335,
0.0617130361,
-0.0179680809,
-0.0378192849,
-0.025145635,
0.0131309573,
0.0153775681,
0.0253278725,
-0.0063962149,
-0.0116878254,
-0.0321488827,
0.000366437,
0.029472027,
0.0196462348,
-0.0492535681,
0.0261701439,
0.0115800472,
-0.0019084081,
-0.046194382,
-0.0352619663,
0.0430011302,
-0.0683122575,
-0.0021110503,
-0.0023196733,
-0.0345374234,
0.040231362,
0.0306440555,
-0.0196634606,
0.0606013946,
0.039177265,
-0.0209949836,
-0.010193821,
0.0106488885,
-0.0072169821,
0.030072771,
0.0465339422,
-0.0432277545,
-0.0047795777,
-0.0328874998,
-0.0342746601,
-0.0297917444,
-0.0418095961,
-0.0538832508,
0.0099194264,
-0.0334871113,
-0.0149387205,
0.0349475779,
-0.005173889,
-0.049909316,
0.035718482,
-0.0152304173,
0.0380012281,
0.0323162265,
-0.0327176303,
0.0251084622,
-0.0379423611,
-0.0381613262,
0.0114807179,
0.0016759614,
0.0169020165,
0.0264831595,
0.0035774945,
-0.0471422113,
-0.0352710336,
-0.1058041528,
0.0032766836,
0.0166426953,
0.013283588,
0.023607526,
0.0000862821,
0.0051418818,
-0.0041608238,
-0.0444687866,
-0.0311948415,
0.0374810435,
0.0314868577,
0.0337827429,
0.0398197956,
0.0444830693,
-0.0484678447,
-0.0165065359,
-0.0422583297,
0.0079701301,
0.0517749526,
0.0026345933,
-0.0276106019,
-0.0072242604,
-0.0760162175,
-0.017099306,
0.0056467457,
0.0107633453,
0.0278878585,
-0.0033027376,
-0.0165384077,
0.0084639871,
-0.0005785925,
-0.0425398424,
0.0576527417,
0.006383928,
-0.0616970919,
0.0148196789,
-0.0100263525,
-0.0662866458,
0.0024768237,
-0.069194518,
0.0155285029,
0.0227838717,
0.0124318609,
-0.0217998195,
-0.030641811,
0.0071934382,
-0.033207044,
0.0249811523,
-0.0435544141,
-0.002067836,
-0.0329876095,
0.0708431154,
0.0131948125,
-0.0200408939,
0.0679109544,
-0.0374055095,
0.0238991957,
-0.058446683,
0.0130135259,
-0.0471603796,
-0.0185886808,
-0.0069186091,
0.0050386456,
0.0156795569,
0.0137468288,
-0.0206592269,
0.0341587402,
0.0128908809,
-0.0854493752,
0.0695323274,
-0.0250591934,
0.0502008498,
0.0119376564,
-0.046781756,
-0.0382809266,
-0.0298557263,
-0.0584849305,
-0.0059378375,
-0.0134187108,
0.0088312794,
-0.0626094714,
-0.0015548924,
0.0411992557,
0.0425063297,
0.0141767049,
-0.018118307,
-0.0001494982,
0.0181338247,
0.0504726283,
0.0103425076,
0.0125198374,
0.0115991924,
-0.0221416149,
0.0744430944,
0.0195589475,
0.0371682085,
-0.0117445607,
-0.0306798425,
0.0136392973,
-0.0438436307,
-0.0100176884,
0.0118184332,
0.0184978694,
-0.0468531288,
-0.0021078638,
0.0963558108,
0.0303799473,
-0.0530442409,
-0.017480161,
-0.0281825736,
-0.0252039358,
0.010646224,
0.0225894041,
-0.0994496047,
-0.0099908328,
-0.0282924734,
0.0480345301,
-0.01814726,
-0.0318073519,
0.0139943315,
-0.0818228051,
0.0337408073,
-0.0055363942,
-0.0235786922,
-0.0132958768,
-0.0504691675,
0.0201354735,
-0.0010902205,
-0.0099716689,
0.0345949754,
-0.0087830797,
0.0127384905,
0.0162617415,
-0.0596140772,
-0.0756394044,
0.0459994413,
-0.0249992311,
0.0664856061,
0.0749901384,
0.0322110392,
-0.0201771893,
-0.0366748311,
0.0134509727,
-0.0302949026,
-0.0213913377,
-0.0116119152,
0.0812802911,
0.0218818597,
0.0100692008,
-0.0470052138,
0.0202565473,
-0.0210020505,
-0.0133437254,
0.014657029,
0.0779802501,
-0.0236453414,
0.0000340443,
-0.0518141091,
0.0539455488,
-0.0019865152,
0.0679019466,
-0.0015379497,
0.0065726629,
-0.0007180808,
0.0119105745,
0.0548110232,
-0.0058924989,
-0.0397365615,
0.0481118299,
-0.0202002339,
0.0050423373,
-0.0717933029,
-0.0091416044,
0.0229599215,
-0.0419002213,
0.0105546052,
0.0367785431,
0.0206640679,
-0.0005364165,
-0.0490833484,
0.0562807024,
0.0013735112,
0.0051285159,
-0.0353728011,
-0.0198805947,
0.093579717,
-0.0015087093,
-0.0173327997,
0.0416715257,
0.0047464981,
-0.011294147,
-0.0335737653,
0.0285267625,
0.0232873466,
-0.0228874721,
-0.0149395866,
-0.0333871134,
-0.0002861877,
0.0560470037,
-0.0489670485,
-0.0045378152,
-0.0156061761,
-0.0022535729,
-0.0078622047,
-0.0086555723,
-0.0572661906,
0.0225884076,
-0.0197089761,
0.039186947,
-0.0073303743,
-0.0287053995,
0.0440950692,
0.0456141382,
0.0584378466,
-0.0227998067,
0.0237257872,
0.0106702289,
0.0078900261,
-0.0110047814,
0.0013030358,
-0.0220641196,
0.0157877617,
0.0072203809,
-0.0221391506,
-0.0168034565,
-0.0007444973,
-0.0553393997,
0.0528989099,
-0.0375826284,
0.0283320062,
0.0074653612,
0.0075222487,
0.011818232,
-0.0456119552,
-0.0200897064,
-0.0118177179,
-0.0137608591,
0.0309189949,
-0.0102136396,
0.0448400043,
-0.0196159501,
0.0132783372,
0.0513323918,
-0.0002869116,
-0.0845801011,
-0.0418718532,
-0.0188311469,
0.00389614,
0.0322644524,
0.0141546363,
0.0784253851,
-0.034186963,
-0.0168723278,
-0.0488503948,
-0.0123760551,
-0.0020107226,
0.0208754633,
0.0543174036,
0.0128104296,
-0.0063180407,
-0.0117215607,
0.0707508102,
0.023306476,
0.0440852679,
-0.0228090379,
-0.0641758293,
-0.044194974,
-0.0561643839,
-0.0686132982,
0.0249409545,
-0.0497853123,
0.0082825543,
-0.0744876191,
-0.0378031284,
0.0196591169,
-0.002688993,
-0.0123799574,
-0.0221986994,
0.0141142393,
0.057532724,
0.0173118524,
-0.0308911763,
-0.0494632088,
0.0742463991,
-0.0487954579,
0.0004653496,
-0.0069998233,
-6.033750055e-33,
-0.0019280509,
-0.0503560379,
0.0247540884,
-0.040297851,
-0.0003429886,
0.0369022489,
-0.0434558652,
0.0004164311,
-0.0404535793,
0.0322397649,
-0.0316814408,
0.0086179301,
0.0125605473,
0.0237918496,
0.027215438,
-0.0204168744,
0.0194634479,
0.0077837352,
-0.0245753806,
0.0273334645,
-0.0010691143,
0.0105538946,
0.0333856642,
-0.118995443,
0.0590050183,
-0.0356613286,
0.020085346,
-0.0090171518,
-0.0278676469,
0.0853374451,
-0.0177647844,
0.0382958725,
0.0405473337,
-0.0294812489,
0.0158800464,
-0.0344718173,
-0.0734445304,
0.0024293258,
0.0276508462,
-0.0486798249,
-0.0468299836,
-0.0163514372,
0.0637041032,
-0.0187956244,
-0.0418732017,
-0.0163211506,
0.038360063,
-0.050165195,
-0.0082620652,
-0.050050851,
0.0022759205,
0.0470796749,
0.0311880987,
0.045277629,
-0.033961162,
0.0627311766,
-0.0296506304,
0.0574485473,
-0.0239252076,
0.0161628891,
0.0061800885,
0.03994596,
0.0123660211,
-0.0731444284,
-0.0153482566,
0.0380813852,
-0.0053634755,
-0.0317006893,
-0.0369135439,
-0.0378469378,
-0.0520452186,
0.0334242992,
0.050247442,
0.0692441314,
0.0027467343,
-0.0083255321,
-0.0918400362,
0.0336739607,
-0.0196530633,
0.0653914437,
0.0415131077,
-0.0471415929,
-0.0252090786,
0.0136108752,
-0.0331413932,
0.0061030048,
-0.0249891225,
-0.0357503109,
0.0282743741,
0.005644415,
0.0169384293,
0.0479237624,
0.0179105997,
-0.0165453404,
0.0030254633,
0.0280458108,
-0.009877448,
-0.0005641091,
-0.0195402373,
0.0193661805,
-0.0523691997,
0.0305625144,
0.0014258832,
-0.0115220034,
0.0449747927,
0.0231599323,
0.0053559626,
-0.0463488735,
-0.0646457672,
-0.0161978696,
0.0113484012,
0.0265342407,
-0.0426060036,
-0.0009875551,
0.0120367333,
0.0485538915,
0.0282114949,
0.039115265,
0.0190282091,
0.0187315047,
-0.0373946354,
-0.0498162992,
0.0038893691,
-0.0078626759,
-0.0423910245,
0.0206247102,
0.002769117,
0.0742099881,
0.0022344671,
-0.0259785485,
0.0050823009,
-0.0067443275,
2.7e-7,
0.1158427149,
0.0492209643,
-0.0151561024,
-0.0254176427,
0.0363559388,
-0.0068986299,
-0.013081138,
-0.0150083415,
0.0376937315,
-0.0299194138,
0.010145288,
-0.010633491,
0.0322923139,
0.0567952171,
-0.0593169555,
-0.0544292852,
-0.1075165421,
-0.0275223739,
-0.0115003847,
-0.0279221423,
0.0251305345,
0.0475197993,
-0.0415778458,
-0.0233099088,
-0.0243885368,
-0.0355795547,
0.058644969,
-0.033474911,
-0.0094594667,
0.0616371818,
0.0710356981,
0.0150734941,
0.0320074484,
0.0456927121,
-0.0274153538,
-0.0111955032,
0.0164512601,
0.090355441,
-0.0203870256,
-0.0031825716,
0.0081750732,
-0.0162486956,
0.0505284071,
-0.0564984083,
0.0535873659,
-0.0271160342,
-0.0272439271,
-0.0430994965,
-0.0584618486,
-0.0248749983,
0.0690851361,
-0.0026101233,
-0.0299646556,
0.0253095496,
-0.006403503,
0.033854682,
-0.0531463362,
-0.0543342568,
-0.0356993824,
0.0394167192,
-0.0500877798,
-0.0666268244,
0.0288329646,
-0.0264984742,
-0.0351743586,
-0.0800557658,
0.0348226838,
2.122257934e-34,
0.014902696,
0.0238578208,
0.0127635794,
0.0169250183,
0.0325100161,
0.0186124835,
-0.0114717819,
0.0282301083,
-0.0066748047,
-0.0585905574,
0.0138882166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01981v1 | Self-Debiasing Large Language Models: Zero-Shot Recognition and Reduction of Stereotypes | 2024-02-03T01:40:11 | 2024-02-03T01:40:11 | Isabel O. Gallegos, Ryan A. Rossi, Joe Barrow, Md Mehrab Tanjim, Tong Yu, Hanieh Deilamsalehy, Ruiyi Zhang, Sungchul Kim, Franck Dernoncourt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable advances in language
generation and understanding but are also prone to exhibiting harmful social
biases. While recognition of these behaviors has generated an abundance of bias
mitigation techniques, most require modifications to the training data, model
parameters, or decoding strategy, which may be infeasible without access to a
trainable model. In this work, we leverage the zero-shot capabilities of LLMs
to reduce stereotyping in a technique we introduce as zero-shot self-debiasing.
With two approaches, self-debiasing via explanation and self-debiasing via
reprompting, we show that self-debiasing can significantly reduce the degree of
stereotyping across nine different social groups while relying only on the LLM
itself and a simple prompt, with explanations correctly identifying invalid
assumptions and reprompting delivering the greatest reductions in bias. We hope
this work opens inquiry into other zero-shot techniques for bias mitigation. | [
-0.0072708828,
0.0806752369,
-0.011804698,
0.0569082163,
0.020144023,
0.0372227132,
0.0544594862,
-0.0290009622,
0.000777866,
-0.0736000836,
-0.0395842418,
-0.0123357326,
0.0282811988,
0.0145918168,
0.0361474082,
-0.0393229797,
0.0424003936,
-0.0032904181,
0.0322118551,
-0.0590374731,
0.018510554,
0.0358354822,
0.008233279,
0.0295597203,
-0.0094085084,
-0.0301684588,
0.0383326188,
-0.0126133338,
-0.0119761406,
-0.0262722354,
0.0295465216,
0.0691398978,
0.0152260391,
0.050442934,
0.0000021217,
-0.0556668974,
0.0065837093,
-0.0147822527,
-0.0253546126,
0.0156123592,
0.0494927913,
-0.0356561877,
0.0114551708,
0.0316556133,
-0.0266820136,
-0.0411858745,
0.0565510653,
0.0092597548,
0.052265022,
0.0219458602,
0.0012841205,
-0.0435795411,
-0.0730559155,
-0.0193033293,
0.0014102331,
0.0131370975,
0.0486866347,
-0.0377676897,
-0.0753669143,
-0.0346562229,
-0.0398726538,
-0.0037507962,
-0.0077232583,
0.0125169298,
0.0364428498,
0.0308506042,
-0.04897606,
-0.0383939594,
0.0053079664,
0.0746220499,
-0.0067945789,
-0.0605443828,
0.0031074972,
-0.0015480447,
0.013706577,
0.0100318361,
-0.0275996756,
0.0552954823,
0.0296832528,
0.0295801573,
-0.0338949338,
0.0206836592,
0.0419933051,
0.0220169201,
-0.0291868523,
0.047960978,
0.0230024811,
0.0081338966,
-0.0497626513,
0.0353129469,
0.0256857313,
-0.0614871681,
-0.0375525132,
0.0302751102,
0.0074560805,
0.0208633132,
-0.0382758565,
0.0005558154,
0.0079028951,
-0.0245896839,
0.007328331,
0.0375637598,
-0.0077165724,
0.0081305467,
-0.015309372,
0.0114469845,
0.0247298125,
-0.0220146682,
-0.001598548,
-0.0027679226,
0.0027401242,
-0.0213935152,
-0.0227545016,
0.0047892984,
0.0194469262,
0.044481501,
-0.0316627696,
-0.0038105114,
-0.0371926054,
0.0045698588,
-0.0109299067,
0.033572793,
-0.048670914,
-0.0371216536,
-0.0110361371,
0.0474235378,
-0.0289646611,
-0.0213534851,
-0.0354282297,
-0.1020495445,
-0.0077170581,
0.0034125107,
0.0074719312,
-0.0264894962,
-0.0233523604,
0.0613467023,
0.0013720476,
-0.0242369808,
-0.0291636921,
-0.0468194559,
-0.0419988334,
-0.0617253892,
0.0024368255,
-0.0558670908,
0.0110322284,
0.0046286522,
0.0129487291,
-0.0693411902,
0.002092805,
0.005615152,
-0.0536283106,
0.0724949092,
-0.0015693259,
0.0188192558,
0.0535321087,
0.0211301576,
-0.0095063308,
0.1120910496,
0.0061696945,
-0.0172990374,
0.0231005438,
-0.0288447272,
0.0231322441,
0.0387957431,
0.0562972128,
-0.0031262573,
-0.043337822,
-0.0232319292,
0.0064510531,
-0.0092474809,
0.0798180476,
0.0321825109,
-0.021311257,
-0.0319345146,
0.0676763654,
0.0494636372,
-0.0378118865,
0.0257565137,
0.0314404294,
0.0209519919,
-0.0170141552,
0.0325185284,
-0.0706974193,
0.0203582756,
-0.0077762757,
-0.0231403615,
0.0046287701,
0.0558979809,
-0.0383539572,
0.0001595448,
0.0168613698,
-0.0183147732,
0.0396606512,
0.0065803123,
0.0292993207,
0.0424915999,
0.0033995237,
0.0746476054,
0.0534748882,
-0.0364437252,
0.0128326062,
-0.0621526614,
0.0466167368,
0.0296520498,
0.0382546298,
0.0131302569,
-0.0009280632,
-0.0282664075,
-0.0169817172,
0.058115989,
0.0569721088,
-0.0126356902,
0.0238849763,
-0.0411046594,
0.0065351748,
0.0022131198,
0.0363775343,
0.0258906651,
0.0414203182,
0.0273208171,
0.0318761319,
-0.014680963,
-0.0118834879,
0.0140672345,
-0.0332517438,
-0.0605471842,
0.0176580623,
0.0215563234,
0.0057365862,
0.0205631591,
-0.0256821588,
-0.0092368135,
-0.0270178393,
0.0071852836,
0.0055693537,
0.0594814457,
-0.1056096777,
-0.0505114123,
0.0240175147,
-0.0442696512,
-0.0415883064,
0.0187012609,
-0.0075846962,
-0.0149180396,
0.0802720785,
0.0054641287,
0.0307528172,
-0.0209769402,
0.0065385061,
-0.0320723541,
0.0429895297,
-0.0187629927,
0.0363970175,
0.0239076596,
-0.0457050093,
0.0238571689,
-0.0519096926,
0.0089826817,
-0.0384077094,
-0.0352395028,
0.017243322,
-0.0086169913,
-0.0162312668,
0.016173197,
-0.0316523574,
-0.015646033,
0.0273468755,
-0.0597101487,
-0.0240343865,
-0.013882054,
-0.0068929773,
0.0319443233,
0.0101230163,
-0.0102706859,
-0.0258973427,
-0.0460678898,
-0.0154163362,
0.019643385,
0.0155639928,
0.0276436079,
-0.0306190066,
-0.0075021898,
-0.0143124377,
-0.0007089691,
-0.0283243693,
0.0709007904,
0.0172969848,
-0.0005390047,
-0.0476102382,
-0.0005841563,
-0.0526714697,
0.0249087885,
0.0273770597,
-0.0357732959,
0.0099771395,
0.0143576618,
0.0055260342,
0.0692367181,
0.008165759,
0.005716891,
0.072135739,
-0.0137464115,
-0.0454929993,
-0.0415637866,
-0.0038820917,
0.0281017534,
0.025407277,
-0.0691915601,
-0.0436082669,
0.0894862786,
0.042265743,
-0.0211930908,
-0.0661352426,
0.0581708774,
-0.0285963546,
-0.0643319413,
-0.0052593346,
-0.0327351615,
-0.0076131304,
0.019333424,
-0.0476989374,
-0.0542789735,
0.0636417642,
-0.0318060368,
-0.0018293266,
0.0266578645,
0.0237193368,
-0.0244288519,
0.0428677574,
0.0000890093,
0.0470108166,
0.0411096103,
0.0079108663,
-0.0391435288,
-0.050650917,
0.0379477777,
-0.011647136,
0.0134477085,
-0.0563707426,
0.0134607218,
-0.0084372833,
-0.0452374406,
-0.0522789881,
-0.0630906746,
-0.0455121845,
-0.0178586058,
-0.0186619963,
-0.0339924507,
0.0090434263,
0.0082841124,
0.0094611952,
0.0082721459,
-0.023467822,
0.0100390958,
0.0046129352,
0.0210584383,
0.0450771041,
-0.0265892092,
0.0156705491,
-0.0178289209,
0.0471838005,
0.0298265629,
-0.0106119812,
0.0565863624,
-0.0318933167,
-0.010388704,
0.0128851095,
-0.0164369196,
0.0021424734,
0.0033284025,
0.0621828549,
-0.0318564959,
0.0016613771,
0.1346307546,
0.0059442217,
-0.0579014085,
0.0184727311,
0.003368167,
0.0069558453,
0.0308648963,
0.0013829052,
-0.1067616642,
-0.0240983628,
0.0051733395,
0.0194040015,
-0.0108005684,
-0.0620824918,
-0.0303107649,
-0.1504678875,
0.0226746406,
0.0488977879,
-0.0259119589,
-0.0202674866,
-0.0167005826,
0.0072714696,
-0.0233358443,
0.03114748,
-0.0131405555,
0.0005533164,
0.0123608597,
0.0078159282,
-0.0522398464,
-0.0509624667,
0.0121147847,
-0.0217930041,
0.1009124219,
0.0254122522,
0.031112561,
0.0082496395,
0.038664978,
0.0062451116,
-0.0159323867,
-0.0015582278,
-0.0180152822,
0.068636544,
-0.0394973122,
-0.0347512439,
0.000792939,
0.0356370248,
0.0076670526,
0.0255233496,
-0.0157022532,
0.0325235315,
0.0189237595,
-0.0444758683,
-0.0130714485,
-0.0008544214,
0.0016133813,
0.102976501,
0.0550911464,
-0.010892,
-0.0069612502,
-0.0697842389,
-0.0048700157,
-0.0068989387,
-0.046622932,
0.0267480388,
0.0119744884,
-0.0529654101,
-0.0494111702,
-0.0447311923,
0.0429117754,
0.0046338732,
0.00717746,
-0.0380617827,
0.0117032044,
-0.0015360208,
-0.053017091,
-0.000483635,
-0.0816820785,
0.0182074569,
0.0155681474,
0.0028383264,
0.01149756,
-0.0415086374,
0.008510055,
0.0086129224,
-0.0265172292,
-0.0875846818,
0.0275806114,
0.0391460545,
0.0226467438,
0.0827332884,
0.0020366181,
-0.1004060581,
0.0781714767,
0.0494023077,
0.0062447609,
0.0320525654,
0.0082437498,
0.0272223912,
0.0097148493,
0.0466700681,
-0.0194631442,
0.0536903925,
0.0004735227,
-0.0317681842,
-0.0489641316,
-0.017965585,
0.0015378691,
0.01725756,
0.0283836611,
-0.0558626391,
0.0634323582,
-0.0316901729,
-0.0520521663,
-0.0777239576,
-0.0274912063,
-0.0109722028,
-0.0012667797,
0.0256925523,
-0.0088733137,
-0.011816211,
-0.0404242575,
-0.0637123063,
0.038901303,
-0.0210371204,
0.0193726998,
0.0192523431,
0.0094219362,
0.0164049417,
0.0116528422,
-0.0109250974,
0.0410130769,
-0.0209877547,
0.0171783827,
0.0119584603,
0.0283994377,
0.0149825979,
0.0286326353,
-0.0293744858,
-0.0108567532,
-0.0016632865,
-0.0278844908,
0.0003550537,
0.0292030722,
0.0430922396,
-0.0064158472,
0.0758243129,
0.0247389153,
-0.0130478078,
0.0105563421,
0.0120725492,
0.0052368799,
-0.026612442,
0.02846108,
0.0047095334,
-0.0293774251,
0.0145332245,
0.090248853,
0.0270097833,
0.0599495694,
0.0015589782,
-0.0145894568,
-0.0324059948,
-0.0062714224,
0.0305431243,
-0.0252503231,
-0.001712761,
-0.0093964022,
-0.0633412674,
-0.0934702232,
-0.0478541106,
0.0017870372,
0.0201342087,
-0.0144855427,
0.0159374494,
0.0197022967,
-0.0243473165,
-0.0266384427,
-0.0187956076,
0.0271956511,
-0.022354871,
-0.0066321325,
-0.0022213112,
-6.928551048e-33,
-0.0159606915,
-0.0447023287,
-0.0221512839,
-0.051808469,
0.0019110049,
-0.0133609017,
-0.0468063466,
0.0117604053,
-0.0228438675,
0.0257578846,
0.0024090228,
0.0055589057,
0.0082078557,
-0.0105270166,
-0.0020540855,
0.0154238464,
0.0996843725,
-0.0384080485,
-0.0497764871,
0.0144656189,
0.0207178332,
0.0149803571,
0.0377717912,
-0.0290936902,
0.0305420179,
-0.0208871812,
-0.0374904461,
0.0238386039,
0.0348845683,
0.01818645,
-0.0462180674,
0.0409668498,
0.0423122272,
-0.0065359641,
-0.0198570192,
0.0496527441,
-0.0608470254,
-0.0241014436,
-0.0048498614,
0.0253314544,
0.0102622965,
-0.0296438318,
0.0264935251,
-0.0122076124,
-0.0566892661,
-0.0088478588,
0.0210536029,
-0.0152505795,
0.0300393756,
0.0393523127,
-0.0536786206,
0.0196326729,
-0.0283828788,
-0.0154648293,
0.0364153348,
0.0096043255,
0.0118043115,
0.0165703576,
-0.0247558281,
0.0390365161,
0.0030335912,
-0.0135630844,
0.0851138681,
0.0306221787,
0.0086761042,
0.0427827351,
0.0585271157,
0.0351145938,
-0.0099856984,
-0.0345788971,
0.0374095254,
-0.0327459201,
0.0012610579,
0.0892616585,
0.0535718128,
-0.030644225,
-0.0178481936,
-0.0102246646,
0.0507191159,
-0.0107318498,
0.0277394429,
-0.012372721,
-0.0643213391,
-0.0525076166,
-0.0417850502,
-0.0859088078,
-0.0221227314,
-0.0342362896,
0.0175931361,
0.0140087884,
-0.0646341294,
0.0170445237,
0.0356484689,
-0.0634312928,
-0.0200063698,
0.0320206732,
-0.0204604194,
-0.0288614817,
0.0081845084,
-0.0061950381,
-0.0614128448,
0.0133848926,
0.0114155803,
0.0512732081,
0.0206692293,
0.0262205172,
0.0174680203,
0.0218838006,
-0.0504944436,
0.0188595224,
-0.0276753902,
-0.0042493111,
0.0180036388,
0.017391732,
0.0231059082,
0.0228919405,
-0.010289479,
-0.004438085,
0.0345351808,
-0.0109109748,
-0.0213027485,
0.0347416997,
-0.000999631,
0.0309450664,
-0.0450884774,
-0.0286655072,
-0.0029460841,
-0.024208501,
0.0742576644,
-0.0421579219,
-0.0195358731,
-0.0535255261,
2.657e-7,
-0.0079267621,
0.0630378425,
-0.0057009193,
0.0285821948,
0.0581777692,
0.0516551323,
0.0502620079,
0.0402198061,
-0.0008622358,
-0.0076164841,
-0.0088067157,
0.0728002489,
0.022583548,
0.0415900983,
-0.0607356615,
0.0118431542,
-0.0719591528,
0.0138429794,
-0.0202564821,
-0.031893611,
0.0201703217,
0.0657501891,
0.0121741286,
-0.0098384526,
0.0059482292,
-0.030993389,
0.0467882343,
0.0008239397,
0.0130493818,
0.0124524841,
0.0107554998,
0.0319961458,
-0.0074977446,
-0.0066876262,
0.0094989333,
0.0106599005,
-0.0455834903,
0.0223341603,
-0.0271302555,
0.0134241357,
-0.0041395854,
0.0291220453,
-0.022523975,
-0.0815046877,
0.0648467392,
-0.0498990715,
-0.0485389791,
-0.064998962,
-0.025237266,
-0.0113623561,
0.0137855336,
-0.0223614927,
-0.0263553429,
0.0236353744,
0.0274116956,
-0.0100187799,
-0.0229899548,
-0.0719592422,
-0.0499836281,
-0.0368689671,
-0.0260388777,
-0.0324000977,
0.0223525334,
-0.0180915873,
0.0137517871,
-0.0400545262,
0.0541454218,
2.209229363e-34,
0.0240337122,
0.0043557361,
0.0106625985,
-0.0271750335,
0.0258276835,
-0.0149437338,
-0.0384180285,
-0.0066911574,
0.0586783364,
-0.0327867456,
-0.0143383676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01980v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01980v2 | SOCIALITE-LLAMA: An Instruction-Tuned Model for Social Scientific Tasks | 2024-02-03T01:33:16 | 2024-03-14T15:30:41 | Gourab Dey, Adithya V Ganesan, Yash Kumar Lal, Manal Shah, Shreyashee Sinha, Matthew Matero, Salvatore Giorgi, Vivek Kulkarni, H. Andrew Schwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social science NLP tasks, such as emotion or humor detection, are required to
capture the semantics along with the implicit pragmatics from text, often with
limited amounts of training data. Instruction tuning has been shown to improve
the many capabilities of large language models (LLMs) such as commonsense
reasoning, reading comprehension, and computer programming. However, little is
known about the effectiveness of instruction tuning on the social domain where
implicit pragmatic cues are often needed to be captured. We explore the use of
instruction tuning for social science NLP tasks and introduce Socialite-Llama
-- an open-source, instruction-tuned Llama. On a suite of 20 social science
tasks, Socialite-Llama improves upon the performance of Llama as well as
matches or improves upon the performance of a state-of-the-art, multi-task
finetuned model on a majority of them. Further, Socialite-Llama also leads to
improvement on 5 out of 6 related social tasks as compared to Llama, suggesting
instruction tuning can lead to generalized social understanding. All resources
including our code, model and dataset can be found through
bit.ly/socialitellama. | [
0.062743403,
0.0637576059,
-0.0174637958,
0.0215341132,
0.0242220536,
0.0353801213,
-0.0296127498,
-0.0034133864,
0.0357882902,
-0.0548087098,
-0.0460820906,
0.0199324377,
-0.0288301483,
0.0004823671,
0.0373895988,
-0.0650948063,
0.0413096361,
0.0088260667,
0.0465569086,
-0.0110055003,
0.0330610275,
0.034023352,
-0.004662571,
0.0244528875,
0.0271903239,
-0.0173882432,
-0.0033661029,
0.0387669206,
0.0143568553,
-0.0265675578,
0.0558221973,
0.0542990305,
0.0301405638,
-0.0434084907,
0.0000020055,
-0.0394004174,
0.019280728,
-0.0438672043,
0.0004194266,
0.0461421348,
0.0722455755,
-0.0355266593,
-0.0045753531,
0.011045509,
-0.0537986942,
-0.0015905193,
0.0246907622,
0.0255761631,
0.0436699688,
0.0580152683,
0.0053243646,
-0.0045872796,
-0.0016195402,
-0.0256980695,
0.0012920785,
-0.0572302788,
0.0410783924,
0.0029012412,
0.0088057565,
0.047218468,
-0.0331009068,
0.0351038948,
-0.0007071502,
-0.0200897548,
0.0183844157,
0.0223910529,
-0.0332973674,
-0.0023928606,
-0.0516220257,
0.0799816251,
0.0346546322,
-0.0267652143,
0.0170768797,
0.0048958831,
0.0266670436,
0.0384485275,
-0.0520476215,
-0.0020672469,
0.0101454249,
0.0232275371,
0.0514600128,
-0.002330157,
0.000929686,
0.065949291,
0.0688970909,
0.0586122237,
-0.0363326445,
0.0057187518,
0.0184435137,
0.0312043019,
-0.0213791784,
-0.0308131743,
0.0605292432,
0.0411102399,
0.0084268255,
0.0149486903,
-0.0417806506,
0.0187574625,
0.0258887708,
-0.0271708444,
0.0317862257,
0.0448808894,
-0.0101813274,
0.0499466322,
0.0213165712,
0.0030802886,
-0.0183575451,
0.0378282331,
0.0220386889,
-0.0076924488,
-0.0624263287,
0.0130817685,
-0.0272043031,
0.0171705205,
-0.0411652215,
0.0057234196,
-0.0259373635,
0.015422849,
-0.0219911188,
-0.0273569077,
-0.001729342,
0.0157818869,
-0.0524009764,
0.0058510979,
-0.0295062978,
0.0288008023,
-0.0669848993,
0.0490326583,
-0.0154468194,
-0.0663481951,
-0.044387877,
-0.0170478765,
0.0451696366,
-0.020877881,
0.0064766207,
0.0018057874,
0.0001547094,
-0.0503158905,
-0.0441970825,
-0.0298440941,
-0.0065917228,
-0.0611764044,
0.0224160403,
-0.0441643037,
0.0569859892,
0.0136773894,
0.0132546388,
-0.0417503305,
-0.0033201382,
0.0123993885,
-0.0409407131,
0.0400144085,
0.0004230326,
0.0006701584,
0.0052281823,
0.0505834371,
0.0195828639,
0.1017049924,
-0.0094319154,
-0.0077142916,
0.0328642726,
-0.0074174944,
-0.014338051,
0.0319969021,
0.0249512605,
0.00378742,
0.009138261,
0.0144748809,
-0.028531678,
-0.0048065227,
0.079863973,
0.0314859115,
-0.0245603081,
-0.0158525407,
0.0363292508,
0.0453918688,
-0.0235140175,
0.0631942227,
0.0280205589,
0.0518225059,
0.0249842275,
0.0029058419,
-0.0536933206,
0.0591949187,
-0.0646596923,
-0.0474314578,
-0.013551929,
0.0228976477,
-0.0440493599,
-0.0227157976,
-0.0046710954,
-0.0043672207,
0.0436739251,
0.0213555321,
0.0217646137,
0.014090511,
-0.0457873382,
0.025783496,
0.0553654954,
-0.0342079364,
-0.0187449194,
-0.0219816174,
0.0221792106,
0.0547855534,
0.0286926161,
-0.0359308235,
-0.0426569171,
-0.0130936168,
0.054238461,
0.0353736319,
0.0635276213,
-0.0442926958,
0.0090618478,
-0.040985167,
0.0026965637,
-0.03401649,
0.0272302795,
-0.0099403141,
0.0844107196,
0.0164124798,
-0.0033014885,
0.0106615787,
0.0062737227,
0.030496031,
-0.0658406615,
-0.018200919,
-0.0593523867,
-0.0168990754,
0.0241248198,
-0.0061795367,
0.0276983511,
-0.0174680986,
0.0063802837,
-0.0246591289,
-0.0054142345,
0.0220318381,
-0.0246925838,
-0.0582771152,
0.042441044,
-0.007271809,
-0.0690176934,
0.0536570065,
-0.0297406819,
0.0156648383,
0.0589641035,
-0.0426339656,
0.022616338,
-0.0299430508,
-0.0205478314,
-0.0385002606,
0.041855026,
-0.0069467234,
0.0604151115,
-0.0130094346,
-0.0385531969,
0.0203336179,
-0.0308835674,
-0.045451954,
-0.0364573598,
0.0032182769,
-0.0391274057,
0.025382895,
-0.0397124626,
-0.021842679,
0.0067753969,
-0.0787981004,
-0.061029993,
-0.0665078983,
0.0253856741,
0.0007573138,
0.0111357793,
0.0122365691,
-0.0138550811,
-0.0264212899,
0.0044593718,
0.0151904859,
0.0314689763,
-0.0362064578,
0.0109735727,
0.0416022316,
-0.0119441599,
-0.0075223264,
-0.0742885843,
0.0070855678,
-0.0491711274,
-0.0043537975,
0.0182068795,
0.0114140091,
-0.0580621473,
0.0367519297,
-0.0378880501,
0.0201945174,
-0.0130311865,
-0.0741566271,
0.0087980209,
0.0120860543,
0.0427692942,
0.1136626378,
-0.020436069,
0.0510454364,
0.0147291385,
-0.0106754331,
-0.074003458,
0.0241830274,
-0.0235232748,
0.0448663719,
-0.0230072308,
-0.0322688222,
-0.0470119566,
0.0645189285,
-0.0158420298,
0.0135180438,
-0.0693584085,
0.0222109836,
-0.0053307316,
-0.035859365,
0.0106039699,
-0.0099098133,
0.0107595334,
-0.0161422342,
-0.0492772274,
-0.0219603907,
0.0718278736,
0.0121932188,
-0.0313619934,
-0.0375715196,
-0.0215469301,
-0.0247778296,
0.0638851672,
-0.0497898348,
0.0062239366,
-0.0349132568,
-0.008429464,
-0.0284978375,
-0.044001013,
-0.0164631978,
-0.0252099,
0.0622218512,
-0.051260449,
-0.0149945309,
0.0241634734,
-0.0387093946,
-0.0096780304,
-0.0620342419,
-0.0615764819,
-0.0054827449,
-0.0130842263,
-0.0236557107,
-0.0000291244,
-0.0489309244,
0.0084637729,
-0.0260266215,
-0.0257259421,
-0.0325904265,
-0.0142528713,
-0.0264328849,
0.0677425787,
0.0313232429,
0.0208154805,
-0.0301862396,
-0.0218051728,
0.0492161289,
0.0398032479,
-0.0270676985,
-0.0263128038,
0.0079940706,
0.0375582054,
0.006671051,
-0.0063807233,
-0.0031613156,
0.1222516671,
-0.0356793553,
-0.0135327065,
0.1067489013,
0.003774602,
-0.0024050344,
0.0217879154,
-0.0166734885,
0.0174124818,
0.0414498486,
0.0455615148,
-0.0070793629,
-0.0558622405,
-0.011970087,
0.0044438336,
0.0148861837,
-0.0495577641,
-0.0198356789,
-0.100983873,
0.0138746323,
0.0085944785,
-0.0124220494,
-0.0030883655,
-0.0506415516,
0.0313188098,
-0.0016646555,
-0.0255797133,
-0.0196501967,
-0.0340459645,
0.0089184111,
0.0241116881,
0.0054446049,
-0.0374490544,
0.0697075874,
-0.031921044,
0.0980732441,
-0.013935376,
0.0769206733,
0.0078041698,
-0.0411252342,
0.0268625095,
-0.0077804779,
0.0083955694,
-0.0347384252,
0.0241576042,
-0.0180121008,
0.0043213242,
-0.0255842749,
0.0685543194,
-0.051448334,
0.0043129567,
-0.0104479911,
0.0612308681,
0.006040825,
-0.0288823079,
-0.0285656359,
0.0380204059,
0.0102997618,
0.075687781,
0.0513400994,
-0.0113541437,
-0.0295296162,
-0.034498319,
-0.0146080619,
-0.0546919033,
-0.0461508594,
0.003126293,
-0.0065337671,
-0.0371057577,
-0.046003025,
-0.0418450981,
0.047103174,
0.0337582789,
-0.0041267369,
-0.0397898629,
0.0419597365,
0.011983458,
-0.0436546169,
0.0642983913,
-0.0568991005,
0.0107038757,
0.0095644603,
-0.049147591,
0.0335317329,
-0.0139151281,
-0.0163379665,
0.0184540059,
-0.059632346,
-0.0716321096,
0.0209529828,
0.0430127643,
0.0179736093,
0.0173901562,
-0.01778524,
-0.0756663755,
-0.0103365825,
0.0477507338,
-0.0432436094,
0.0720117688,
0.0111465184,
0.0162228663,
0.0261743385,
0.0607517175,
-0.0015707234,
0.0251656305,
0.0113053657,
0.0320824198,
-0.0495957993,
-0.0095871156,
-0.0222640615,
-0.0045112157,
0.0305006634,
0.0154030891,
-0.0796294212,
-0.0320958607,
-0.0559798814,
-0.001530017,
-0.0036587752,
-0.0323824137,
-0.0153560443,
0.0045312592,
-0.0224867444,
-0.0485269241,
-0.036393147,
-0.0463836864,
0.0719786361,
-0.0472781137,
0.03172208,
0.0343065746,
0.0107350005,
-0.0079237893,
0.0098471222,
-0.0324570723,
-0.0039068079,
-0.0135002509,
0.0342471339,
0.0018394489,
0.0502003729,
0.0127795413,
-0.0021706333,
0.0005881645,
0.0124970293,
-0.0081164762,
0.0180898588,
0.027960306,
0.0536500998,
0.0146024134,
-0.0209143702,
0.060893476,
-0.0093869315,
-0.0012990886,
0.0179588888,
0.0306719653,
-0.0387099311,
-0.0623930544,
0.0856299326,
0.0118821934,
0.001594767,
-0.018969385,
0.0566427037,
-0.0326121897,
0.0665776357,
0.034628313,
0.0036342815,
-0.0113894623,
-0.0318800732,
0.0287936591,
0.0128430212,
0.02020403,
0.0237537771,
-0.055037085,
-0.0488477759,
-0.0016925281,
-0.0137851248,
-0.0367007926,
-0.0382317007,
0.0248994958,
0.0642383471,
-0.0349671841,
-0.0423998274,
-0.0367983095,
0.0435603634,
-0.0474569947,
-0.0110437991,
-0.0216284972,
-6.734418891e-33,
-0.0532435402,
-0.0424511842,
0.0099747311,
0.0489212461,
-0.036191456,
0.0254462883,
-0.0866475031,
0.0040366105,
-0.0406048633,
0.03877303,
-0.0188100729,
0.0522740372,
-0.0041451575,
-0.0296648759,
0.0094397217,
-0.0341750644,
0.0199261308,
0.0085380236,
-0.0155611821,
0.0213402845,
0.0121166231,
0.0101248482,
0.0614225641,
-0.0912467837,
0.0106290346,
0.0127369436,
0.0066492339,
0.0124705527,
0.0326141231,
0.0262541715,
-0.0159684028,
0.0513218343,
0.0205794703,
-0.0010283678,
0.0234753489,
0.0607727915,
-0.0678128153,
-0.0700805411,
0.0429021455,
-0.0102918698,
-0.0528481901,
-0.0414955877,
0.0497217961,
0.0059147775,
-0.0172467064,
-0.0163284987,
0.0350505523,
-0.0139834825,
0.0286818463,
0.0043663196,
-0.0599508025,
0.0031790442,
-0.0237135757,
-0.0426234752,
-0.0149437813,
0.0011710391,
0.0181691684,
0.0421854146,
-0.0403102189,
0.0320492499,
-0.0346200205,
-0.0034229662,
0.0059117018,
-0.0499922968,
0.0191960093,
0.068807438,
-0.0301957149,
0.0269295238,
-0.0164400525,
0.0078300145,
0.0389766172,
0.0275688749,
0.0055729547,
0.0261979811,
0.0015699164,
-0.0032060747,
-0.0534965247,
0.0169644915,
0.0929994062,
0.0085132634,
0.0004056195,
0.0002690785,
-0.0534592643,
-0.0004781216,
0.0007630163,
0.0184087176,
-0.0021150273,
-0.0152613586,
0.0155144846,
0.0175425261,
-0.0574841462,
0.0399444252,
-0.018173676,
-0.0295630395,
-0.0157319661,
0.0140423244,
-0.0164891072,
0.0132039646,
0.004620214,
-0.0120539116,
-0.0800457969,
-0.0416254587,
0.0050491546,
0.0061991289,
0.0452303551,
0.0262078289,
0.0271705296,
0.0257929787,
-0.0402739756,
-0.0093094194,
-0.0340941809,
0.0266036838,
-0.0211984217,
-0.0073607732,
0.0074881054,
0.0565130971,
-0.0160393883,
0.0143077569,
0.045664262,
0.0220018793,
-0.0097522736,
0.0162560791,
-0.0108723352,
0.0121277161,
-0.0413438343,
-0.0418564118,
-0.0122194337,
-0.0539426319,
-0.0361960642,
-0.055580385,
-0.0165670142,
0.0114948507,
2.695e-7,
0.0180782359,
0.097580336,
0.0098107569,
0.011698328,
0.0288659576,
0.0235615764,
-0.0031204426,
0.0501502492,
0.0251155198,
-0.0457499325,
-0.036789421,
0.0719147772,
0.0143171856,
0.0228021014,
-0.0872231349,
0.0051751412,
-0.0156179592,
0.0214580949,
-0.0231824964,
-0.0303764474,
-0.0036770634,
0.0518564545,
0.0583905317,
0.0120985294,
0.0001204022,
-0.0323538519,
0.0608447231,
0.0052628997,
-0.0093842587,
0.0389794782,
-0.0187200829,
0.0231670961,
0.0025697728,
0.0140321488,
-0.0055922368,
-0.0068148626,
-0.0181495547,
0.1021117568,
-0.0146714374,
-0.0172019806,
0.0264629945,
-0.0223875549,
-0.0197643247,
-0.0336788148,
0.0572312139,
-0.0703763217,
-0.0449153073,
0.0202922598,
-0.0105242655,
-0.0029314363,
-0.0018482057,
0.0226269849,
0.005565654,
0.0050393688,
0.0073332652,
-0.0411853679,
-0.0425621718,
-0.076175265,
-0.012601262,
-0.0303726718,
-0.0189754255,
-0.0405393615,
-0.0107536931,
-0.018658597,
0.0033048221,
-0.0671179593,
0.0243333504,
2.376532056e-34,
0.0019952555,
0.0101488614,
0.0235813409,
-0.0123488065,
0.043559473,
0.0081414878,
-0.0490942672,
0.010790877,
0.0710921884,
-0.0519826747,
0.0226097945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01976v1 | MasonPerplexity at ClimateActivism 2024: Integrating Advanced Ensemble Techniques and Data Augmentation for Climate Activism Stance and Hate Event Identification | 2024-02-03T01:06:33 | 2024-02-03T01:06:33 | Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Dhiman Goswami, Md Nishat Raihan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of identifying public opinions on social media, particularly
regarding climate activism and the detection of hate events, has emerged as a
critical area of research in our rapidly changing world. With a growing number
of people voicing either to support or oppose to climate-related issues -
understanding these diverse viewpoints has become increasingly vital. Our team,
MasonPerplexity, participates in a significant research initiative focused on
this subject. We extensively test various models and methods, discovering that
our most effective results are achieved through ensemble modeling, enhanced by
data augmentation techniques like back-translation. In the specific components
of this research task, our team achieved notable positions, ranking 5th, 1st,
and 6th in the respective sub-tasks, thereby illustrating the effectiveness of
our approach in this important field of study. | [
0.0162380878,
0.1211113185,
0.0037854272,
0.0272721611,
-0.0195523128,
0.0361205861,
0.0085202381,
-0.0251066163,
0.0105482768,
-0.0493106097,
0.0225192662,
-0.0311895069,
-0.0102105187,
-0.0128864413,
-0.0162264314,
-0.0424427353,
0.0134168426,
0.0344898365,
0.0030824977,
-0.0310300458,
0.036520727,
-0.0141287399,
-0.012071697,
0.0301677156,
-0.0129358377,
0.0180315208,
0.0028586558,
0.0102068996,
0.0742839053,
-0.0013124349,
0.0203097984,
0.0468338244,
0.0093698269,
0.0905430019,
0.0000019678,
-0.0330117606,
-0.0437897779,
-0.0189752076,
0.018951077,
-0.0285344403,
0.0240555964,
0.0105725657,
0.0243230946,
0.0253539588,
-0.0514696129,
0.010115156,
0.0662950426,
0.0273505561,
0.0465734974,
0.0602717139,
-0.0097053014,
-0.0114964601,
0.0088222045,
0.0049165362,
0.0047669606,
0.0493726507,
0.0378713682,
-0.040935535,
-0.077960901,
-0.0013843917,
-0.0052615167,
0.0306026451,
-0.0138190649,
0.0189494025,
0.009476386,
-0.0100408336,
-0.0211194269,
-0.0074870544,
-0.0295260102,
0.0498511009,
0.0165697131,
-0.0039000628,
-0.0067231716,
0.0112751015,
-0.0143196285,
0.0127487108,
-0.0501361005,
-0.016236851,
-0.0279862694,
0.0325269997,
-0.0131787192,
0.0769175813,
0.0331566855,
0.0590465702,
-0.0249254107,
0.0633506849,
-0.0374825671,
-0.0080233132,
-0.0084356535,
0.0316236205,
-0.0057100407,
0.0217067227,
0.0438616574,
-0.0188965332,
0.0055321716,
0.0235490371,
0.0035333347,
-0.0540659353,
-0.0051157097,
-0.0712463856,
0.0266243294,
0.0339056663,
0.0267830305,
0.0493809469,
0.0267514661,
0.0128219659,
0.0087983012,
-0.0008833617,
-0.0047321478,
0.0132015198,
-0.0892006382,
0.0280466843,
0.0131073277,
-0.0009835652,
-0.0088694878,
0.0301995464,
-0.0338386074,
-0.0262807775,
-0.0477986783,
-0.0150349457,
0.0189113524,
0.0154727744,
0.0333259702,
-0.0129665928,
0.0073768152,
0.0742830783,
-0.0251805205,
0.0246089231,
0.0043624477,
-0.0487756543,
0.0055732401,
0.0225740205,
0.0088851908,
-0.0101002008,
-0.0088699553,
0.0049497508,
0.0459275693,
0.0068476689,
0.0309350472,
0.0022719004,
-0.028627865,
-0.0512319542,
0.0229686275,
-0.0628285185,
0.0499607138,
0.0046863193,
0.0132002505,
-0.0602001436,
0.0038468163,
-0.007020534,
-0.0232900269,
0.0853583589,
0.0007885413,
-0.0086788479,
0.0343941599,
0.0288052466,
0.007624866,
0.0825775191,
0.0160649791,
0.0537982993,
0.0355970673,
-0.0190583076,
0.0068175015,
0.0262635387,
0.019663522,
0.0208128691,
-0.0660827607,
0.0073954109,
-0.0484566055,
-0.0137891909,
-0.0504422374,
0.0442746282,
-0.0026343148,
-0.0452448204,
0.0613236539,
0.0231702551,
-0.0477079675,
0.0053510922,
-0.0099332854,
0.0035883137,
-0.0176549871,
-0.0380921736,
-0.0085370382,
0.0131308595,
-0.0476630107,
-0.0505571589,
0.0306440555,
0.0695405826,
-0.0252757072,
-0.0611711703,
-0.0302714594,
0.0230765603,
0.0260853022,
-0.0179070178,
0.0055030519,
-0.0464258157,
0.0016625773,
-0.0451492928,
0.0114154164,
-0.0740811229,
0.0047014877,
-0.0314170085,
-0.0132224923,
0.0667210147,
-0.0102440873,
-0.006195216,
-0.0517373644,
-0.0803451538,
0.0185942426,
0.0148545867,
0.0347130448,
0.0029978172,
-0.0041640666,
-0.0183438752,
-0.050340347,
0.0413941592,
0.025437925,
0.0073764436,
0.0358916968,
0.0134163322,
-0.0194335412,
0.0095792841,
-0.0228473842,
0.0367680639,
0.0158613585,
-0.0141583337,
0.0119609218,
0.0287667047,
0.0649011508,
0.0415334366,
0.0000913502,
-0.0294187516,
0.0517136939,
-0.0343080796,
-0.1160669252,
0.0459228382,
0.0021787051,
-0.0560897551,
0.029680578,
-0.0463796631,
-0.0234583002,
0.021956211,
-0.0319633521,
-0.0039842972,
0.0681381673,
-0.0209248848,
-0.0260739215,
-0.0122596892,
-0.0225162469,
-0.0577643998,
0.0395541266,
-0.0354144648,
0.0635180995,
-0.0476088077,
-0.0147611545,
-0.0289431475,
-0.1103875861,
0.0516174175,
0.0078559639,
-0.0221805256,
-0.0193017274,
0.0198023599,
0.0459570996,
0.01422833,
-0.0672879219,
-0.0429299697,
0.0049065184,
-0.0618426166,
0.009223354,
-0.0307941027,
0.0254325401,
0.0034894934,
-0.0052875765,
-0.0212975722,
0.0322919711,
-0.0026158681,
-0.0282266811,
0.004156407,
0.0277154483,
-0.0132796019,
-0.0267689731,
0.0062051965,
-0.0410011709,
-0.0096255792,
-0.0101217991,
0.0553006381,
0.0365394503,
-0.0906204209,
0.0209317338,
-0.0363827161,
-0.0612061955,
-0.0295010507,
-0.0285488497,
-0.0237351898,
0.000227191,
-0.0130458623,
-0.0197966248,
0.0088799438,
0.0503992811,
0.0744299665,
0.0095819188,
0.0215708278,
-0.0584258847,
-0.0084883589,
-0.054768458,
0.0303556006,
0.0069702445,
-0.0303445347,
0.0049713594,
0.0483037755,
-0.0075210789,
-0.0036476164,
-0.0257635526,
0.065272972,
-0.0233948678,
-0.0456471369,
-0.0309293922,
-0.0460798256,
0.0242831949,
-0.0159692299,
-0.0147351213,
-0.0545277558,
0.0674428269,
0.0076013901,
0.0409849733,
-0.0625753924,
-0.0376621634,
-0.0113212075,
0.0391713418,
0.0113460524,
0.022959942,
-0.0330964439,
0.0451353416,
0.0327115618,
-0.0455207638,
-0.0073985471,
-0.0390656777,
0.0014599609,
-0.0073621278,
0.0238058455,
0.0227310248,
-0.0097240265,
-0.0423538089,
-0.0616222471,
-0.0444139577,
-0.0199014209,
0.0119781615,
-0.0370640904,
-0.0560731255,
0.0430898108,
0.021437563,
-0.0467165001,
-0.0025919608,
-0.0157438163,
0.0425377227,
-0.0132601978,
-0.0119504966,
0.0051805354,
0.0135378875,
-0.0397430956,
0.006638214,
0.0397716463,
0.0318373926,
-0.0128983855,
-0.0803789422,
-0.0382476747,
0.0182374958,
0.0126800258,
0.011835712,
-0.0805339515,
0.0542491823,
-0.0234363377,
0.0303396191,
0.0611756518,
0.012668754,
-0.0379901379,
-0.0177440178,
0.0172402058,
0.0422689728,
0.0100123342,
-0.0039417003,
-0.02025152,
-0.0102425944,
-0.0069808904,
0.0250986796,
-0.0359551385,
-0.0562805161,
0.0036885182,
-0.0428698547,
0.0456536785,
0.0103491442,
-0.060619045,
-0.0183295738,
-0.0527004562,
0.0486117937,
-0.0406542756,
0.0030852961,
-0.0586264282,
0.0490371399,
0.0310136322,
0.0352527797,
-0.0555521995,
-0.0300679412,
-0.0196461845,
-0.0292907711,
0.0112011712,
0.0567108542,
0.038095139,
-0.0042545432,
-0.0209524278,
-0.0052474779,
-0.024647681,
-0.0042936383,
-0.0360716581,
0.0700237602,
-0.0026727053,
-0.0038498987,
-0.013585126,
0.0536251403,
-0.0527604558,
0.0081953239,
0.0064805681,
0.0835076049,
-0.0194474515,
-0.0048757633,
-0.0455195047,
0.0258175973,
0.0569048151,
0.0578252487,
0.0214846916,
-0.0135512697,
0.0087201158,
-0.0870189369,
0.002225386,
-0.0645981506,
-0.0034007053,
-0.0207388047,
0.0123497229,
-0.0356581509,
-0.034370508,
-0.020028064,
0.0534645431,
0.0409562066,
-0.0216817092,
0.0221269615,
-0.0122576542,
0.0044811983,
-0.0667356849,
0.0458523743,
0.0159343518,
0.0723154992,
0.0346339159,
-0.0555403978,
0.0104453862,
0.0270678867,
-0.0273791794,
0.0178681761,
-0.0531949922,
-0.0509514734,
0.0262041558,
0.0527686179,
0.026708426,
0.0251607392,
0.0070046792,
-0.0341347232,
0.0266274959,
0.1322359294,
0.0511814207,
-0.0102579379,
0.0128300115,
0.0167805776,
0.0031657154,
0.0143149886,
0.0351409353,
0.0455062538,
0.0353578739,
-0.0121231219,
-0.0897681564,
-0.0120451478,
0.000368605,
-0.0170915052,
0.0598101951,
0.0082289707,
-0.0733537376,
-0.0292279739,
-0.0162271317,
0.010090339,
-0.0279570539,
-0.0222133789,
-0.0246891379,
0.046832297,
-0.0243289415,
-0.0379970446,
0.0510041453,
-0.009351912,
0.0036524301,
-0.0781842843,
0.0736602023,
0.0247505624,
0.0412981361,
0.008661719,
0.0170049071,
-0.0150372256,
0.0020156978,
0.033871837,
-0.0262758788,
0.0119726425,
-0.0056731976,
0.0016473948,
0.036344301,
0.0088317236,
-0.0037249657,
-0.0407567807,
-0.0246523451,
-0.0510620438,
0.0107133416,
-0.029734455,
0.0129006514,
0.0377159193,
0.0269618016,
-0.0328663103,
-0.0386910997,
0.0380932465,
-0.0081504257,
-0.0272218231,
0.0320830978,
0.0225737728,
-0.0313110985,
0.0091999667,
0.0252690297,
-0.0622495152,
0.0291561726,
0.0488717966,
-0.0472018197,
-0.0350894295,
-0.0006386202,
0.0041453112,
-0.0199346263,
0.0145715196,
0.0144788511,
-0.0495330058,
-0.0200123601,
0.0292607769,
-0.0360796675,
0.028998699,
0.006456221,
-0.0070906389,
0.0360478237,
-0.0289454199,
0.0458124988,
-0.0250493661,
0.0185607802,
-0.0772153139,
-0.0323546305,
-0.0049843127,
-5.854195497e-33,
-0.0101859681,
-0.0382648222,
-0.0219191182,
-0.0125295259,
-0.0077280998,
-0.0326468684,
0.0029514395,
0.0446829908,
-0.0031037873,
0.0325898677,
0.0167762432,
-0.0111537874,
0.0134267351,
0.0126725165,
-0.0029558879,
-0.0096034305,
0.019833507,
-0.0161478985,
-0.0159439519,
0.0222029928,
0.0713875517,
0.0179124195,
0.0405431911,
-0.0906600207,
0.0205653347,
0.0131933233,
-0.0238376725,
-0.0193552878,
0.0081496015,
0.0495101176,
-0.0004135455,
0.0567733757,
0.0446288548,
-0.0307452567,
-0.0031283535,
0.0192840118,
-0.0129809259,
-0.0099044265,
-0.0205534175,
0.0009342145,
0.0213721581,
0.0225553866,
0.0180424117,
0.0087581547,
-0.0510995463,
-0.0184872784,
0.0212183502,
-0.0401931815,
0.0269517601,
-0.0325924829,
-0.0391454138,
0.0341096893,
-0.0438906103,
0.0215704124,
-0.0145106902,
0.0293651689,
0.0301884934,
0.0784737766,
-0.077008009,
0.0443398021,
0.0035349145,
-0.036682725,
0.0344867781,
0.0110177221,
0.0117004868,
0.0728459656,
0.0250874534,
0.0168235395,
-0.0914222747,
0.0170557257,
0.0181845464,
0.0330303796,
0.072590746,
0.0800418332,
0.0238279924,
-0.0396687612,
-0.0593548939,
0.0512762107,
0.0761390179,
-0.0463660993,
0.0266676787,
0.0027631139,
-0.0282258578,
-0.0048861946,
-0.0276668966,
-0.0551414602,
-0.0229287036,
0.0052062357,
-0.0084753437,
0.0024990325,
-0.072871916,
0.0114632146,
0.0364894159,
-0.0398639068,
-0.0267961305,
0.0682588667,
-0.0118815908,
0.0300633572,
0.033992473,
0.0420314223,
-0.034051355,
0.003585492,
-0.0148701901,
0.0242081843,
0.021837214,
-0.0241814591,
0.0862003714,
0.0184640922,
-0.0507779308,
0.0043503116,
-0.0215172842,
0.0097442167,
-0.0455885567,
0.037336126,
-0.0013891559,
0.0294372104,
0.002229081,
0.0006910295,
0.0099292686,
0.0306019317,
0.0457375124,
-0.0035740566,
-0.0445927121,
0.0061888341,
-0.0053455187,
-0.0283503532,
0.0141760129,
-0.0596238747,
-0.0022762469,
-0.0758732483,
0.0162719227,
-0.0292949528,
2.574e-7,
0.0647316724,
0.0470098592,
-0.0246110559,
-0.0714988783,
0.0142866429,
0.0277293827,
-0.032368008,
0.0014620194,
-0.0184452273,
-0.0429221392,
-0.0212665889,
0.0673501641,
0.0367001779,
0.0346236192,
-0.019186141,
-0.050268624,
0.0072556492,
0.0169017818,
-0.0491184592,
0.0455636121,
0.0075057214,
0.0755072832,
0.0476170555,
-0.0055501321,
-0.0107132811,
0.0087800613,
0.0724526942,
-0.0627811551,
-0.0105346814,
0.002367422,
0.0625824034,
-0.027530171,
0.0017094652,
0.0289282221,
-0.0228949077,
0.0091500198,
0.0074624801,
0.0213883817,
0.0188863873,
-0.0173726324,
-0.0149912555,
-0.0043307212,
0.020032078,
-0.0484145992,
0.0183281135,
-0.0519852154,
-0.0247443784,
-0.0542036556,
-0.0540840551,
0.0410381369,
0.0477276482,
0.0018407153,
0.0214859918,
-0.0050049373,
0.0162030701,
-0.0212726314,
-0.0038194973,
-0.0545936301,
0.0120971464,
-0.0608066879,
-0.0698281527,
-0.0464575551,
0.0077266265,
0.0148943448,
0.0433474146,
0.0335326418,
0.0017628086,
2.226563773e-34,
0.0438961275,
0.0112367589,
-0.034953244,
-0.0513317026,
0.032336738,
-0.0245504882,
-0.0267868955,
0.0194149632,
0.0245343018,
-0.0557844825,
0.0068481178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01967v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01967v2 | MasonPerplexity at Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection 2024: Hate Speech and Target Detection Using Transformer Ensembles | 2024-02-03T00:23:36 | 2024-02-18T06:39:55 | Amrita Ganguly, Al Nahian Bin Emran, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | The automatic identification of offensive language such as hate speech is
important to keep discussions civil in online communities. Identifying hate
speech in multimodal content is a particularly challenging task because
offensiveness can be manifested in either words or images or a juxtaposition of
the two. This paper presents the MasonPerplexity submission for the Shared Task
on Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection at CASE 2024 at EACL 2024. The task
is divided into two sub-tasks: sub-task A focuses on the identification of hate
speech and sub-task B focuses on the identification of targets in text-embedded
images during political events. We use an XLM-roBERTa-large model for sub-task
A and an ensemble approach combining XLM-roBERTa-base, BERTweet-large, and
BERT-base for sub-task B. Our approach obtained 0.8347 F1-score in sub-task A
and 0.6741 F1-score in sub-task B ranking 3rd on both sub-tasks. | [
0.0306013674,
0.0734699741,
-0.0117245996,
0.0692409575,
-0.0192928202,
0.050666891,
0.0345904939,
0.0298860688,
-0.0082636494,
-0.076545164,
-0.0036816027,
-0.0176460259,
0.0010689165,
-0.0241639223,
-0.029093381,
-0.0618428513,
0.0035491092,
0.0241227485,
-0.018037064,
-0.0255039111,
0.0556021519,
-0.0034015379,
-0.0130829215,
0.0399613231,
-0.0983049572,
0.0277671013,
0.0379377119,
0.0075421026,
0.0544045754,
0.0190207418,
0.0231664758,
0.0472150296,
0.0171252303,
0.0716288015,
0.000001834,
-0.030351419,
-0.013772618,
-0.0074725524,
0.0310602169,
-0.0690275878,
0.0232923273,
-0.0043468806,
-0.0104338648,
0.024180403,
-0.0015290787,
0.0142943226,
0.0758572966,
0.1166264489,
0.0529039875,
0.0537613109,
-0.0191816911,
-0.0452074856,
0.0286542382,
0.0334750414,
-0.0009285589,
0.0268299989,
0.0311499815,
-0.0574034639,
-0.0724797025,
-0.0007887215,
-0.0301547591,
0.0065046209,
-0.0110761672,
0.0381428227,
-0.0117437989,
-0.0167667866,
-0.04277841,
-0.0197291989,
-0.0045557986,
0.0299191214,
-0.0159806814,
0.033776246,
0.0121472171,
0.0257348996,
-0.0326945558,
0.0306075849,
-0.0231240559,
0.0135009773,
-0.0417405032,
0.0164196752,
-0.0334209763,
0.0163696781,
0.0140162064,
0.0514149033,
-0.0142562157,
0.0439192653,
0.0207025483,
-0.0156268794,
-0.0035018967,
-0.0012160074,
-0.0249725785,
0.0320516191,
0.0509076305,
-0.0076960125,
-0.0198738705,
-0.0018797156,
-0.0340020508,
-0.0851114541,
-0.0085521555,
-0.0651883334,
0.0505449139,
0.0333889276,
-0.05168733,
0.0340247676,
-0.0035873926,
0.0816193074,
-0.0273299795,
0.0132581256,
-0.0092147384,
-0.0119405044,
-0.054750558,
0.0215062052,
-0.0144199096,
-0.0134710697,
-0.0179009438,
0.0094630793,
-0.0491730608,
-0.0265587065,
-0.0438579246,
-0.039208658,
0.0253118668,
0.0239656977,
-0.0293034501,
-0.0003295694,
0.011985518,
0.0517884158,
-0.0114144282,
-0.0093985228,
-0.0682109371,
-0.0622063205,
0.0139281498,
0.0765305683,
-0.013090712,
-0.0497682802,
0.0183892604,
0.051706858,
-0.0073243864,
-0.0516606756,
-0.0130505003,
-0.0017084293,
-0.0704671592,
-0.0404480845,
0.0535834394,
-0.0491527021,
0.0345618315,
-0.0156539343,
-0.0035916604,
-0.0396075994,
0.0093903653,
0.0017416803,
-0.0222561397,
0.0921928287,
0.0411211401,
-0.0187661089,
0.0760965124,
0.0284832288,
-0.0233185366,
0.0749513879,
0.0122916019,
0.044947736,
0.0493624732,
-0.0092102215,
0.0142877242,
0.070060432,
-0.0131232329,
-0.004007386,
-0.0629337281,
-0.0014658677,
-0.0407687128,
-0.0074344855,
0.0172584429,
0.0409517512,
-0.0062609599,
-0.068508856,
0.0657729506,
0.0596257895,
-0.0196467582,
0.0008472906,
0.0189095847,
-0.0072024637,
-0.0371587835,
-0.0125030046,
-0.0304558873,
0.0189553816,
-0.0368152931,
-0.0566023476,
0.0243098289,
0.091766566,
-0.0303918365,
-0.0205230769,
-0.0074451729,
-0.0358018912,
0.0423809141,
-0.0524790846,
0.0562900826,
-0.0195794478,
-0.0547869876,
0.0114158709,
0.0237523261,
-0.0105697336,
0.0034974334,
-0.062757276,
-0.0076991976,
0.0522237271,
0.0111088138,
-0.005870407,
-0.012162433,
-0.0539266579,
0.0161912423,
0.0592412166,
-0.0409266464,
0.0139328279,
0.0043860092,
-0.0506681465,
-0.0447402857,
0.0420156531,
0.0171410665,
0.017347414,
0.052588623,
0.0002818317,
0.0022126017,
0.0477894098,
0.0054941461,
0.0257076304,
0.0577849969,
-0.0137909809,
-0.0072059734,
0.0181194618,
0.0509993508,
0.0175213236,
-0.0319562331,
-0.0564988032,
0.0138206938,
-0.0374426283,
-0.0653962046,
0.0192398392,
-0.0045148004,
-0.0265156794,
0.0244520381,
-0.0735195056,
-0.0140959285,
0.1014779732,
-0.0036211903,
0.028691778,
0.0674994513,
-0.0395488217,
-0.007572154,
-0.041099675,
-0.019664716,
-0.0377357565,
0.0418730602,
-0.0127375899,
0.0694498494,
-0.0136091886,
-0.0212685931,
0.0133943465,
-0.0784679651,
0.0257922374,
0.0171944425,
-0.0720584467,
-0.0194002334,
-0.0030565541,
0.043335598,
-0.010702149,
-0.0171132684,
-0.017532127,
-0.0121304113,
-0.0633225515,
-0.0057002003,
-0.0391486697,
-0.0401034467,
-0.0101589346,
-0.013961995,
0.0065539968,
0.0150283081,
0.0183769371,
-0.0331722163,
0.0433624238,
0.0225893557,
-0.0151022971,
-0.0614476614,
-0.0341438316,
-0.0025501549,
-0.0093043875,
-0.0231350716,
0.0590458177,
0.0101322038,
-0.0723463669,
0.0263641197,
-0.044172693,
-0.0135822026,
0.0074862251,
-0.0146887656,
-0.0614492483,
0.0221590064,
0.0280347709,
0.0384027213,
0.0418336056,
0.0795742869,
0.094506219,
-0.0232290365,
-0.0159108751,
-0.0089179631,
-0.0040690601,
-0.023551207,
0.0335829109,
0.0055855471,
-0.0385103412,
0.0080517894,
0.0763696954,
0.0223568659,
0.0264057908,
-0.0445937961,
0.000878654,
-0.0401776694,
-0.0285781249,
-0.0026356,
-0.0777948499,
-0.0245128218,
-0.0378671996,
-0.0134882331,
-0.0536947586,
0.0370330326,
-0.0053593372,
0.0138825942,
-0.0171622634,
-0.0068398621,
-0.0124981292,
0.0451984406,
0.017049918,
0.057148125,
-0.0537029915,
-0.0169379469,
0.0017866655,
-0.0384226143,
0.0092937611,
-0.0397233814,
0.022608215,
0.0284811873,
0.0049234172,
0.0116271442,
-0.0222421307,
-0.0592350513,
-0.0381801836,
-0.0349473767,
-0.0468234159,
0.0013911544,
-0.032342989,
-0.0656521767,
0.0381510891,
0.0245201178,
-0.0388028733,
0.002207373,
0.0125718592,
0.0516594648,
0.0451723337,
-0.0140928589,
0.0115265641,
-0.0149035249,
-0.0230570156,
-0.0422616377,
0.0642043054,
0.0109974258,
0.0071777171,
-0.067386359,
-0.0062292805,
0.0315921567,
0.0204610713,
0.0202409271,
-0.0460107662,
0.0316947214,
0.0135086561,
0.0275697149,
0.0886813104,
0.0012523032,
-0.0244595893,
-0.0187832937,
0.0185799319,
0.0000848259,
-0.0035839679,
-0.0138580045,
-0.0507395864,
-0.010868459,
-0.0223271511,
-0.0012925884,
-0.0571313053,
-0.0357877836,
0.0323056169,
-0.0373051651,
0.041598957,
-0.0012414729,
-0.0240047947,
-0.0321426615,
0.014031332,
0.0393670313,
-0.014255859,
0.0236675888,
-0.0141554652,
0.0289677791,
-0.0258367155,
0.0177108794,
-0.0429393686,
-0.016166741,
0.0138331149,
-0.0472473316,
0.0106644537,
0.0296162851,
0.0398944616,
-0.048723489,
-0.0377749503,
-0.0054053129,
-0.0027565337,
0.0039039617,
-0.0608857162,
0.0719972998,
-0.0117597636,
-0.0422448777,
-0.0316652283,
0.0169384256,
0.015814675,
-0.0325489491,
-0.0078691058,
0.0588645823,
-0.0082225399,
-0.0043343254,
-0.0524601564,
0.047470361,
-0.0120914532,
0.0692797229,
0.0137196677,
-0.0469400287,
0.0291336887,
-0.0296782814,
0.0260965135,
-0.0521577559,
-0.0553105362,
0.0099984761,
-0.0053148326,
-0.0576547869,
-0.0453911647,
0.0160867665,
0.0495631546,
0.0410310067,
-0.0175937209,
-0.0307501834,
-0.0482648313,
0.0238747746,
-0.0696494654,
0.0280539058,
0.0214380622,
0.0457497351,
0.0010283642,
0.010367251,
-0.003811965,
-0.0076929866,
-0.0391143635,
0.0375076011,
-0.0602230541,
-0.0130757084,
0.0622934215,
0.0555705316,
0.0215262771,
0.0055599012,
0.0214568619,
-0.0418869704,
0.0568961203,
0.0565808229,
0.0176936463,
-0.0004079757,
0.0257221796,
-0.0267920792,
-0.0310893115,
0.0021363108,
-0.005086598,
0.0630329251,
0.0341563113,
-0.0211977959,
-0.0478401743,
-0.011200116,
-0.0179075748,
-0.0411119722,
0.0634471104,
-0.0120522585,
-0.0506042428,
-0.0325122587,
-0.0156729352,
0.0275570303,
-0.0139898593,
-0.0250028241,
0.0081522623,
-0.0090840142,
0.0151422517,
-0.0402368903,
-0.0177764166,
-0.0299253594,
0.0173828769,
-0.038184125,
0.0582332239,
0.0394255407,
-0.0013073276,
0.0028136338,
0.0229382142,
-0.016316006,
0.0400441699,
0.0487207137,
-0.0187837258,
0.0122366762,
0.0634888485,
0.0129483752,
0.0132147921,
0.0270489249,
-0.003111185,
0.0187149588,
0.0135992114,
-0.0641143769,
0.0041489797,
-0.0136241745,
0.000118143,
0.0253850296,
0.004358504,
-0.0106260413,
-0.0131137548,
-0.0007372739,
-0.0142312283,
-0.0129831908,
0.0625176132,
0.0219367072,
-0.0024048809,
0.0077320831,
0.0419041552,
-0.0496602356,
0.0247561391,
0.0694372654,
-0.037202619,
-0.0310309958,
-0.0125374254,
0.0525645576,
-0.0075164651,
0.0093480907,
0.0095282914,
-0.0233985484,
-0.007553298,
0.0659846589,
-0.0556317344,
0.0211510789,
0.0046665701,
0.0181146767,
0.0516661331,
-0.0010512741,
0.0207901038,
0.0128875086,
-0.0170579832,
0.0097806444,
-0.0322604142,
0.0240241755,
-5.85230442e-33,
-0.0311147347,
-0.0401764885,
-0.0225264411,
0.0172461104,
-0.007519267,
-0.0009419101,
0.056403216,
0.0089005809,
0.0041814623,
0.0195550527,
0.0248709098,
-0.0112105981,
0.010660802,
0.0133771226,
0.0033900149,
-0.0303890631,
0.0080821868,
-0.0204855055,
-0.0021891857,
-0.0014274484,
0.0233097449,
0.0193526465,
0.0678169876,
-0.0532913394,
-0.0134015791,
0.0230857972,
-0.0280181188,
-0.0108978581,
0.0484838895,
0.08377067,
-0.0337946527,
0.0534157492,
0.0453997552,
-0.0436248481,
0.0177766997,
0.0470542535,
-0.0138566652,
-0.0113255139,
0.0060367351,
0.0485023037,
0.0134216445,
0.0162722878,
0.0335713066,
-0.0208022278,
-0.0552616268,
-0.0608808622,
0.0442581065,
-0.0339038037,
0.0325501338,
-0.0510757975,
-0.0671293736,
0.0387970805,
-0.035126809,
-0.0145523511,
-0.0067120097,
0.011667328,
0.0559745952,
0.0534609668,
-0.0650999025,
0.0198078305,
-0.0394103043,
-0.038963493,
0.0078829061,
0.0156032033,
-0.0047328384,
0.0806382895,
0.0236030016,
-0.0047254306,
-0.0454978123,
-0.0114206886,
0.0286021251,
0.068761155,
0.0785596073,
0.0704670623,
0.0187690202,
-0.0295448788,
-0.0565648265,
0.0341138169,
0.0534170754,
0.0011488497,
0.0331779122,
-0.0202894956,
-0.0306825377,
-0.0065963711,
0.0046880199,
-0.0453348272,
-0.0313092731,
-0.0281047504,
0.0125723211,
-0.007937015,
-0.0262978673,
0.0341524482,
0.06349691,
-0.023442978,
0.0092250425,
0.0114193,
-0.0092495158,
0.046303831,
0.0048391446,
0.0450729094,
-0.0043343552,
-0.0246497486,
0.0352962278,
-0.008479381,
0.0394629538,
-0.0038155173,
0.0483318195,
0.0317710079,
-0.0896267071,
-0.0059028803,
-0.0005493659,
0.0093838703,
-0.0161128268,
0.0432815477,
-0.000937971,
0.0298037995,
-0.0204372369,
-0.0350911021,
0.0194524992,
-0.0184852853,
-0.0074824565,
-0.0192185938,
-0.0093454244,
-0.0087381536,
0.0015359662,
-0.0128640346,
0.0051108003,
-0.048641365,
0.0079629505,
-0.1111365035,
0.0151430992,
-0.0489526652,
2.602e-7,
0.0174291432,
0.0635903701,
0.0021251081,
-0.0349433124,
0.0034919002,
0.016699465,
-0.004818772,
0.0309695713,
0.0114210071,
0.0036072109,
-0.0068506249,
0.0352557003,
0.010684263,
0.0462697931,
-0.0029818807,
-0.0404897407,
-0.056025818,
-0.0123061258,
-0.0664035678,
0.0236966424,
0.0236663297,
0.0745288581,
0.0518186614,
-0.0591350719,
-0.0257865898,
-0.0224117544,
0.0411078483,
-0.0446576513,
-0.0193419121,
-0.0339490436,
0.0538961552,
-0.0061193057,
-0.00261586,
0.0468939357,
0.0102028828,
0.014971355,
0.0479981899,
0.0263789222,
-0.0023771704,
0.012836461,
0.001352958,
-0.0018811873,
-0.037151482,
-0.0313420631,
0.0279290937,
-0.0253326092,
-0.0297125895,
-0.0499985591,
-0.0697064847,
-0.0078354878,
0.0520713143,
-0.0238436628,
-0.016300058,
0.0008996943,
0.0511206388,
-0.0195998922,
-0.01224929,
-0.0981004313,
0.0322357826,
-0.0208041072,
-0.0698090717,
-0.0226383153,
-0.0158953909,
-0.0476143509,
0.0490797162,
0.0472593047,
-0.0010274666,
2.244944418e-34,
0.030183414,
-0.0115565248,
-0.0168727152,
-0.0263432395,
0.018010946,
0.0011047238,
-0.0323952511,
-0.0103295371,
0.0001857389,
-0.0508850366,
0.0030044389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01963v1 | Improving Large-Scale k-Nearest Neighbor Text Categorization with Label Autoencoders | 2024-02-03T00:11:29 | 2024-02-03T00:11:29 | Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Shuyuan Cao, Víctor M. Darriba Bilbao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T50, 68T07, I.2.6; I.2.7; H.3.1 | In this paper, we introduce a multi-label lazy learning approach to deal with
automatic semantic indexing in large document collections in the presence of
complex and structured label vocabularies with high inter-label correlation.
The proposed method is an evolution of the traditional k-Nearest Neighbors
algorithm which uses a large autoencoder trained to map the large label space
to a reduced size latent space and to regenerate the predicted labels from this
latent space. We have evaluated our proposal in a large portion of the MEDLINE
biomedical document collection which uses the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
thesaurus as a controlled vocabulary. In our experiments we propose and
evaluate several document representation approaches and different label
autoencoder configurations. | [
0.0016808318,
0.0066855862,
-0.0089737428,
-0.0515752099,
0.0119729983,
0.0590328686,
0.059822876,
0.0569934025,
0.0345006585,
-0.0635081157,
-0.054089129,
0.0295938924,
-0.0114606302,
0.0196609553,
0.0009108197,
-0.0137460623,
0.0255901329,
0.0089434246,
0.01816695,
-0.0291453321,
-0.0324356221,
0.0141004445,
-0.0156150525,
0.0244094841,
-0.0031035624,
0.0181058291,
0.0248647593,
-0.0432850718,
-0.0265927482,
-0.0463929847,
0.0160925444,
0.0286036804,
0.0132117188,
0.0043216059,
0.0000018728,
-0.0150564443,
-0.0019231429,
0.0111350948,
0.0172547866,
0.0017425166,
0.0608726554,
-0.0725305229,
0.0404004231,
-0.0186535642,
-0.0039744214,
-0.0774900615,
0.0106063625,
0.0279305559,
0.0419454351,
0.0104244268,
-0.0292437784,
-0.0765660629,
0.0425895005,
-0.0066518495,
0.0279984139,
-0.0854970589,
0.05358335,
-0.0052224458,
0.0104115894,
0.0269047339,
-0.0189156905,
0.0417415649,
-0.0104750721,
-0.0177101754,
0.09531115,
0.0527501218,
0.0153771825,
-0.0292541608,
-0.0007535786,
0.0230435897,
-0.0293625891,
-0.0050219758,
0.0105827432,
-0.0141532328,
-0.0577985533,
0.0197767578,
-0.0047708713,
-0.015470094,
-0.0079441862,
-0.0408616923,
0.0166221224,
0.0431409255,
0.0086485706,
-0.0076279277,
-0.0232246742,
-0.0000168417,
0.0262151472,
-0.0471878648,
0.0350952521,
0.002726123,
0.0072720968,
0.0024388826,
0.034318056,
0.0350644179,
-0.0351441614,
-0.0086079612,
-0.0072895354,
-0.0741764382,
0.0433585346,
-0.054028336,
-0.01427007,
0.0003222417,
-0.0011916591,
0.022026442,
-0.0644373298,
0.0116557973,
-0.0154258031,
0.0220149048,
-0.0230423212,
-0.0152922301,
-0.0496751182,
-0.0209450349,
-0.0119627826,
0.0354598165,
0.0686807111,
-0.0504706651,
-0.0278204661,
-0.0154940682,
0.0095317522,
0.012247609,
-0.0129592316,
0.0235430244,
-0.0562789887,
0.0014020774,
-0.010376039,
0.0253050458,
-0.0393958911,
0.0465123467,
-0.0563232526,
0.0607491657,
0.0444793925,
0.0228759144,
0.0770231634,
-0.0130519634,
0.0105737029,
-0.0194115862,
-0.003541288,
0.0049747247,
-0.0204993654,
-0.0503337607,
-0.0056378096,
0.0675837845,
-0.0147844078,
-0.0501442365,
0.0048881657,
-0.0082692206,
0.0285055805,
-0.0348727964,
-0.0220839325,
-0.0267308038,
-0.0634915382,
0.0695927069,
-0.0159813929,
0.0001263079,
0.0847417116,
0.0052451263,
0.0453411452,
0.0164296739,
-0.0415835232,
-0.0156190591,
0.0017327273,
-0.0274864286,
-0.0146295056,
-0.0289013181,
-0.001261801,
-0.0508402884,
-0.0029694296,
-0.0204911381,
0.0149975484,
0.0734434575,
-0.0158239603,
0.012183561,
-0.025989715,
-0.0054357108,
-0.0515225567,
0.0446118377,
0.0434745252,
0.0140420925,
-0.0055027897,
-0.0109857768,
-0.0390018858,
-0.0444304347,
0.0643846244,
0.0353198275,
0.0143587049,
0.001385206,
0.0530247055,
-0.0123628918,
-0.037042547,
0.0044338168,
-0.0089891274,
-0.0229478143,
-0.039761018,
-0.0318172537,
0.0779751986,
0.0161016174,
-0.0061814464,
0.0337573439,
0.0608048663,
0.0116234999,
0.0112847527,
-0.0123353293,
-0.0056279884,
0.0205432065,
0.0509634502,
-0.0386673808,
-0.0440348946,
-0.0447399616,
0.0321559161,
-0.0238307398,
0.0103463037,
-0.0634464622,
-0.0162969213,
-0.0520712808,
-0.0496085733,
0.0382381827,
0.0303536709,
0.0224299002,
-0.0532808416,
0.0756342709,
0.0443061069,
-0.0139338002,
0.0446835533,
0.0477479436,
-0.0479522273,
-0.0064305309,
0.0362769999,
0.0267903246,
0.0147750238,
0.0141908033,
-0.0259806644,
0.0012886606,
0.0449792482,
-0.0726967379,
-0.0344687775,
-0.0918466598,
-0.0161162168,
-0.0068541756,
0.017149495,
-0.0248128381,
0.0047204159,
-0.0134571968,
-0.0002389809,
-0.029915737,
0.0043390002,
-0.0049601463,
-0.066636242,
-0.0087796031,
-0.0258623883,
-0.03941321,
-0.0031234187,
-0.0331579112,
0.0427500792,
0.0202539079,
0.0620217249,
0.0121799465,
-0.01939396,
0.0268395878,
0.0184753314,
0.011730317,
0.0063768118,
0.0225702059,
-0.0174552035,
0.0338993482,
-0.0022672978,
0.0157082006,
-0.0594224781,
-0.033288151,
-0.0207854193,
-0.0020613896,
-0.0344845615,
0.0142127899,
0.0291712191,
0.0370940156,
-0.0180750582,
-0.0502169281,
0.0344835594,
0.0155171547,
0.0035119934,
0.0284114592,
0.009769639,
-0.0001343857,
0.0481957085,
-0.0372420549,
-0.0216764957,
0.0151488157,
0.0175121054,
-0.0464002863,
0.0110726533,
0.0014257289,
-0.0240824167,
-0.0423270389,
0.02135773,
-0.0128001412,
0.0175212808,
-0.0357624628,
-0.0382573567,
0.0224406347,
0.0138139846,
0.0103717642,
0.043881949,
0.0326891169,
-0.0406408869,
-0.0106630614,
-0.0592739098,
-0.0308258533,
-0.0181500744,
-0.0321561098,
0.0089363717,
0.0379835106,
0.0187614225,
0.0088943038,
-0.0412071757,
-0.0296883956,
-0.0174393188,
0.0060841255,
-0.0653778687,
0.0047743134,
0.0113632828,
0.0347368345,
0.029113641,
0.0362262577,
0.0951047391,
0.0461158305,
0.0179055799,
-0.0484299734,
-0.0062644808,
-0.0538376346,
-0.009832113,
-0.0146231735,
0.0416455381,
-0.0292241517,
-0.0111160167,
0.0170965679,
0.0554764159,
0.0349673368,
-0.0045665693,
-0.0247861557,
0.0524952076,
0.0085936589,
0.0222042371,
-0.0258645322,
0.0022072664,
-0.052051384,
0.0037074417,
0.0110605061,
0.0011199528,
0.025238974,
-0.019093452,
0.032259386,
-0.0233403668,
0.0796878934,
0.0128674535,
-0.0200699139,
-0.0174825545,
0.0377252139,
0.0285288114,
-0.0397179611,
-0.028343739,
0.0103359586,
0.010800533,
0.015485513,
0.0126782022,
0.0134658096,
0.0081249885,
0.0536277704,
0.0368449241,
-0.0013703983,
0.0392761417,
-0.0048596566,
-0.0763637871,
0.001776084,
-0.0004784891,
0.1004149914,
0.0602107905,
-0.0958526656,
0.0012958905,
-0.048454728,
0.0260857828,
0.0247370061,
0.0437080264,
-0.0131952725,
-0.0046788612,
-0.0261640754,
0.0261939801,
-0.0067132441,
-0.0291502103,
0.0622372851,
-0.0449389927,
-0.0170181524,
0.0215409286,
0.0177711211,
0.0000862277,
-0.0635559186,
-0.0122713307,
0.0000969811,
-0.0626487508,
-0.0192571972,
0.030253103,
-0.0288262106,
0.0175400861,
-0.0149003584,
-0.048260849,
0.0035497763,
-0.0086792624,
0.0521222055,
0.0294882841,
0.0247367322,
-0.0420861952,
-0.0181528069,
0.0070759482,
0.0368790589,
-0.022477271,
-0.0243503172,
0.0227326192,
-0.0148689328,
0.0156931952,
0.0282637198,
0.0127545288,
-0.0845569745,
0.0197605845,
0.0085644899,
0.0587180033,
-0.0408916771,
-0.0551418774,
-0.0422475114,
-0.0470571443,
0.0120744919,
-0.0133956531,
-0.0111696497,
0.012790449,
0.0130535709,
0.0202484746,
0.0616409853,
0.0424254201,
-0.0211422872,
0.036446359,
-0.0553644039,
-0.0808081254,
-0.0622725338,
-0.0183373149,
0.0406994931,
0.017521752,
0.0213719402,
-0.0066574789,
0.0206116308,
-0.0337204598,
-0.0435048826,
-0.0278360657,
0.040812362,
-0.0163133536,
0.0004494419,
-0.0296952203,
0.1017274633,
0.001512136,
-0.0226953775,
-0.0633297339,
0.0293458495,
0.00425538,
0.0145005789,
0.0097284941,
-0.0041166474,
0.0359582864,
-0.0269640293,
-0.0695841759,
0.0724735409,
0.0505964309,
-0.1058029681,
-0.0021039532,
-0.0292031467,
-0.0649919659,
-0.0256452635,
0.0119245443,
-0.0592538863,
0.0582653023,
-0.0470019095,
0.0193659551,
-0.022219874,
-0.0578680523,
-0.0019840931,
0.0237774868,
0.0617540888,
-0.0147954719,
0.0243505277,
-0.0499087907,
-0.0016130328,
0.007349534,
-0.0204744153,
0.0118631897,
0.0097797215,
0.0609144233,
-0.0174589753,
-0.0338319317,
0.0633364841,
0.0313991383,
0.0133509319,
0.0295878109,
0.0323174819,
0.0217616279,
0.0451155044,
-0.0048480504,
0.0220215078,
-0.0400727652,
0.0050194496,
0.0308011118,
0.0294020697,
-0.0583980121,
0.009390343,
0.032573238,
0.0444583036,
-0.0565351471,
0.039689526,
-0.0562349632,
-0.0113134515,
-0.029756505,
-0.0287505481,
-0.023231009,
-0.0098220771,
0.0012094927,
-0.0231330507,
-0.0287756864,
-0.0131004993,
0.0170919932,
-0.0214834698,
-0.0369000807,
0.0124748945,
0.0029969977,
0.007039404,
-0.0042988621,
0.071406126,
0.0246303733,
0.0006986908,
-0.005084997,
-0.0501557365,
-0.0278227758,
0.0306556392,
0.0180628598,
0.0230991468,
-0.0131824901,
0.0247103348,
0.0292378087,
0.0104236677,
0.0790328234,
-0.0752703622,
-0.0482425131,
-0.012601967,
0.0622817688,
0.0179584641,
0.0241818242,
0.0505997837,
-0.0146053741,
0.0121671902,
-0.0319220051,
-0.0563331656,
0.01501894,
-6.06650998e-33,
0.015436898,
-0.0311054252,
-0.0279938709,
-0.0530602746,
0.0096430713,
-0.0035310879,
-0.0231446885,
-0.0340922959,
0.0596329346,
0.0339673832,
-0.0116646821,
0.002193531,
-0.0108685102,
0.0203030296,
0.0550213531,
-0.0219256748,
0.0296085719,
0.0108305793,
0.0175592098,
0.0563797429,
0.0041896636,
0.0577802025,
0.0074139042,
-0.1120448187,
-0.0157207735,
0.039649006,
0.0554897673,
-0.0303005315,
0.0647221357,
0.0542526245,
-0.0519305281,
0.0438709818,
0.0095945969,
-0.0186704379,
0.0211532637,
-0.0040551848,
-0.0715081468,
-0.0369889736,
-0.1228026077,
0.0217101537,
-0.0010822234,
-0.0408538841,
0.027900327,
-0.0022550458,
-0.0060218382,
-0.000622145,
0.0578118451,
0.0027056688,
-0.0702078044,
-0.0809087977,
-0.0146212205,
0.0160486754,
-0.0164100491,
0.0303212553,
0.048791822,
-0.0307954028,
-0.0202623252,
0.0617813878,
-0.0287452172,
0.0175218768,
-0.046146933,
0.0257614981,
-0.0108239958,
-0.0125394333,
0.0238113217,
0.0457244255,
0.0383992717,
0.0175659396,
-0.0550177544,
0.0505626686,
-0.0078782523,
-0.0407422259,
0.0229942836,
0.0482426137,
0.0382205434,
-0.1003742293,
-0.0429892875,
0.0512971692,
-0.0396569744,
0.0338259749,
0.0089744925,
0.0026025544,
-0.0312136449,
-0.0510781407,
-0.0096732266,
0.0126771526,
-0.0456252098,
-0.0061115595,
0.0055371211,
-0.0141318021,
-0.0210986398,
0.0326879732,
-0.0004751665,
-0.0352709405,
-0.0230695326,
-0.0121587496,
0.022812143,
0.0603789091,
-0.0228753369,
0.0018206482,
-0.0286667813,
-0.0306340344,
0.0208734423,
-0.0216855817,
0.0298481453,
-0.0046886154,
0.0293289628,
0.0079634152,
-0.0325395279,
-0.0359166563,
0.054737471,
-0.1076689288,
0.0434887856,
0.0236711837,
-0.0194877107,
0.0307202656,
0.0416964777,
0.0837719589,
0.0426745564,
0.0064154891,
0.000511517,
-0.0390276983,
0.0459597744,
-0.0057874103,
-0.0448230021,
-0.0260908715,
-0.0576084666,
-0.0034608149,
0.0714861378,
-0.0454714783,
0.0165952668,
0.0227456819,
2.732e-7,
0.0619124845,
0.0447761305,
-0.0119988807,
-0.0645474344,
0.0225845482,
0.0317878202,
0.0322695002,
0.0463296548,
-0.0201442651,
-0.0223759972,
0.0527521521,
-0.0403266288,
0.0150489844,
0.0182839092,
-0.0561801493,
-0.0256730821,
-0.0344470553,
0.0201991498,
-0.0433656238,
-0.0107834311,
0.0287320875,
0.0756482705,
-0.0279250089,
-0.0143857459,
0.0265277531,
-0.0136983031,
0.0262181107,
0.0330547281,
0.0547431558,
0.0365603194,
-0.0155348396,
0.0044840951,
0.0126324026,
0.0347447582,
0.0014456618,
0.0040404806,
0.0325243995,
0.0229287259,
-0.06617295,
-0.0180057045,
0.0054442515,
-0.009542386,
0.0170886759,
0.0360468999,
0.0446899757,
-0.0717773065,
-0.0373282358,
0.0346289836,
-0.0021788015,
0.0081481794,
0.0412398092,
-0.0289488751,
-0.0216752905,
0.0285949633,
0.0374555215,
0.0344119482,
-0.0063808779,
-0.076179795,
0.0556074977,
0.0189980604,
-0.0477326736,
0.0386752859,
0.0174854752,
0.0512281805,
0.0377517343,
-0.0089050541,
0.0067123394,
2.031288906e-34,
-0.0025173344,
0.0087364996,
-0.0257474147,
0.0123259369,
-0.0169630069,
-0.0508514531,
-0.0138358502,
-0.0091714403,
0.0045068162,
-0.0779294819,
-0.018146079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01945v1 | A Case Study on Filtering for End-to-End Speech Translation | 2024-02-02T22:42:33 | 2024-02-02T22:42:33 | Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is relatively easy to mine a large parallel corpus for any machine
learning task, such as speech-to-text or speech-to-speech translation. Although
these mined corpora are large in volume, their quality is questionable. This
work shows that the simplest filtering technique can trim down these big, noisy
datasets to a more manageable, clean dataset. We also show that using this
clean dataset can improve the model's performance, as in the case of the
multilingual-to-English Speech Translation (ST) model, where, on average, we
obtain a 4.65 BLEU score improvement. | [
0.0266241692,
0.0377112105,
-0.0222556125,
0.0347471945,
-0.0252230279,
-0.0080861859,
0.0355864987,
0.0116950488,
-0.0477727242,
-0.0200520139,
-0.0326770842,
-0.0263203382,
0.0382959284,
-0.0244885683,
0.005925254,
-0.043034438,
0.0313649848,
-0.0063657067,
-0.009964739,
0.0005855838,
-0.025103109,
0.0468968861,
-0.0003474365,
0.0307898205,
0.0161659252,
0.0041776309,
0.0342601202,
0.0479975939,
0.0340537503,
0.0119635081,
-0.0486415774,
-0.0385215506,
-0.0158965364,
0.0456062667,
0.0000020964,
-0.0346943513,
-0.0413391776,
0.0114635536,
0.008397297,
-0.003335285,
0.0387784988,
-0.0124663534,
-0.0215159263,
0.0728668869,
-0.0207106378,
0.0060361926,
0.032071624,
-0.0174665507,
0.0469276644,
0.0602835864,
-0.0342090353,
-0.022287162,
-0.0159561727,
-0.0430370495,
-0.0642101243,
-0.0339180566,
-0.0194332488,
-0.0226591676,
-0.0106554134,
0.002636642,
-0.0227229781,
0.0718062446,
-0.0080831116,
0.0060360646,
-0.0035711899,
-0.018963404,
-0.0026700718,
-0.0464639068,
-0.0027334727,
0.0682098269,
-0.0682526454,
-0.0059884842,
0.00166826,
-0.0055028503,
-0.0049283518,
-0.0148236426,
-0.0246303212,
0.0481329747,
-0.0035642588,
0.0175215919,
0.0006363244,
0.0037779321,
0.056330882,
-0.0195742678,
-0.0626788586,
-0.0070669483,
0.0225673188,
-0.0393575504,
0.0304537043,
0.0089486418,
-0.004647674,
-0.0114274072,
0.0876384899,
-0.0132814972,
-0.0201106407,
-0.0002611576,
-0.0298086759,
-0.0606632344,
-0.0408978499,
-0.0541147366,
0.0228756238,
0.0754413083,
-0.0044524535,
0.037159048,
0.0063280882,
-0.0145773655,
-0.0059690606,
0.0350606441,
-0.0625476763,
-0.0424914733,
-0.0150827514,
0.0674883127,
-0.0541755371,
-0.0131362565,
-0.0724861026,
0.0096039614,
-0.0093835853,
-0.0087496024,
-0.0230382327,
0.0090811951,
0.0287080538,
-0.0199552234,
-0.0577609092,
0.0057012476,
0.0266078357,
0.0318931639,
-0.0007238346,
0.021908557,
-0.0042229714,
-0.049444478,
-0.020533042,
0.0026640643,
0.0315526985,
-0.0455673002,
-0.0039636753,
0.0623396523,
-0.0014503766,
-0.0115698157,
-0.0356836766,
-0.0036937355,
-0.0174355395,
-0.0545059033,
0.004839527,
-0.0264250357,
0.0559443086,
-0.0224104449,
0.0517208986,
-0.0225380678,
-0.0175082982,
0.0072799935,
-0.0317374691,
0.0666106492,
-0.0120517127,
0.007591051,
0.0258536022,
-0.0086892787,
-0.004048394,
0.0688578784,
0.0834587067,
0.0045061591,
0.0337032117,
-0.0287284087,
-0.0424571037,
0.0731104016,
0.0174150988,
0.041579321,
-0.0411664508,
-0.0122648906,
-0.0004520819,
0.0268616639,
0.0214527026,
0.0442380533,
-0.0101122139,
0.0110667106,
0.0602796488,
0.0251103975,
0.0478802137,
0.0385453887,
0.02736458,
-0.0082526356,
-0.0276446156,
-0.0002776037,
0.0319541842,
0.0078431144,
0.0194157884,
-0.0320125856,
0.0646396205,
0.0806753039,
-0.0180394724,
-0.0203199126,
-0.0101431394,
0.001456794,
0.0159569792,
0.0182744116,
0.0402037464,
0.0225561354,
-0.0403108522,
0.0325432457,
0.0092203254,
-0.0853245407,
0.054039076,
-0.0176663976,
-0.0092413928,
0.0578627437,
0.0472393185,
0.0245797988,
0.02239733,
-0.0652933568,
-0.0118782679,
0.0201339275,
0.020348087,
-0.0038103624,
0.0798527822,
-0.0649667978,
-0.018433433,
0.0603100322,
-0.0191188417,
0.0160269924,
-0.0428029187,
0.0269111656,
0.0242139846,
-0.0061284215,
-0.0597875528,
0.0306754597,
-0.0205424204,
-0.0040823864,
0.0700771809,
0.0454200245,
0.0616072379,
0.0328257568,
-0.0063759638,
-0.0252585895,
0.0434417762,
-0.0416424498,
0.0135134012,
0.0343021378,
-0.0017418013,
-0.033840809,
0.0288751982,
-0.0658233985,
0.0179405026,
0.0725953281,
-0.0281583462,
-0.0724351928,
-0.0136484299,
-0.0185798872,
0.0317741185,
-0.0086198831,
0.0404821001,
0.0051119239,
0.0184668303,
-0.0266238395,
-0.0228189565,
0.0175288152,
-0.0053275479,
0.0242875945,
-0.005004975,
0.0270791333,
-0.0798015743,
-0.0150554199,
0.0845476016,
0.0053791166,
0.0305059999,
0.0587657467,
-0.0019775538,
-0.0069138445,
0.0000438754,
-0.0649389252,
0.024267897,
-0.0074247373,
0.0116056604,
0.0488246232,
0.0643266365,
0.0187737849,
-0.0085725477,
-0.0048687174,
-0.0091294516,
0.0037283734,
-0.0126036648,
-0.0288733616,
0.0098790247,
-0.0028368179,
-0.0205538776,
-0.0106920274,
0.0112122493,
0.0216874406,
0.0045400122,
-0.0200696029,
-0.0416175947,
0.0537830628,
-0.0029274561,
0.0052665425,
0.0288162436,
-0.0598950796,
-0.0158788059,
-0.0034314566,
0.0074292021,
0.0332899876,
0.0002275226,
-0.0139330085,
0.0484078117,
-0.025366459,
-0.0599165335,
0.0278546438,
-0.0103092203,
0.0205070097,
-0.0244242195,
-0.0270130392,
0.0205369946,
0.037513148,
0.0096620144,
0.0026634717,
-0.0630837306,
-0.0246173702,
-0.0140961632,
-0.0196441133,
-0.0205880422,
0.0188159794,
-0.0050987052,
0.0341485813,
-0.0346437842,
-0.0221963003,
0.0387628376,
-0.0638134032,
-0.0014502421,
-0.0659552515,
-0.0354810022,
-0.0066720266,
0.0004572688,
-0.040449813,
0.0255705025,
-0.0683748946,
0.0122922119,
-0.0296480469,
0.0173818041,
0.0167889223,
-0.0215517674,
0.0387745462,
-0.065591231,
0.0179123823,
-0.0178083219,
-0.0239287484,
-0.0209646374,
-0.0015160933,
-0.0094484901,
-0.0191881489,
0.0375346616,
-0.0248576403,
-0.0702515095,
0.0304285139,
0.0041873655,
0.0723296702,
0.0191611927,
-0.0106016528,
-0.0120344935,
0.0107652973,
-0.0116881877,
-0.0080810739,
0.0142535372,
-0.0470535234,
0.0203054547,
-0.0022066743,
0.057404995,
-0.0167840142,
-0.02650683,
-0.0467065275,
0.0470714569,
0.0190257728,
-0.0263230242,
-0.0001479169,
0.0147313327,
-0.0470237993,
-0.006333082,
0.0821654275,
-0.0019924485,
-0.0193640105,
-0.0147391278,
0.0381528735,
0.0106800161,
0.0015946141,
-0.0143344346,
-0.0671064779,
-0.0428991169,
0.0402188562,
0.0461773649,
0.018830128,
0.0223040339,
-0.0360949524,
-0.0875913724,
0.0497792438,
0.0524954423,
-0.06567166,
-0.0505055971,
-0.0097859306,
-0.0498213395,
-0.0682975724,
0.0306316298,
-0.0308439415,
0.0202959403,
-0.0027438772,
0.0399576686,
0.03152062,
-0.052857291,
-0.0054871268,
-0.0387277976,
0.0304535218,
0.0386916138,
0.0778091177,
0.0001002405,
-0.0222493485,
0.0075440002,
-0.0120602269,
-0.0276145376,
-0.0266027842,
0.0167925321,
-0.0064492533,
-0.0313923843,
0.0422250368,
0.0058065713,
-0.0605664812,
0.0333794802,
0.0341952965,
0.040824499,
-0.0338033326,
0.0195293818,
0.028873682,
-0.0030739198,
0.0227656309,
0.0757485926,
0.0004575071,
-0.0590621196,
0.0271588769,
-0.0156777278,
-0.0278463643,
-0.0646515712,
0.0055141007,
0.0150178112,
-0.0619777627,
-0.0463475771,
-0.0792916119,
-0.0505513623,
-0.0003417381,
0.0635437295,
0.0318110511,
0.0202722009,
0.0298682861,
0.0187582616,
0.0087651322,
0.0200802516,
-0.0463715792,
0.0586749129,
-0.0599148497,
0.0191514809,
-0.0078727296,
-0.0295322631,
-0.0134126302,
0.0924879238,
-0.082283318,
-0.0521438383,
0.0027447206,
0.0305130854,
0.0295581874,
0.0582492948,
-0.0351250917,
-0.0056609223,
0.0128361806,
-0.0118522672,
-0.0805245787,
0.0002780917,
0.0238980521,
-0.0270727295,
-0.0111219129,
0.0397071205,
-0.0187401734,
0.0056324778,
0.0007429027,
0.0263255946,
-0.0205140151,
-0.0575284958,
0.0026956694,
0.0472950377,
0.0387298763,
-0.0168941878,
-0.0327649005,
-0.0553808734,
0.0564677119,
0.0155494697,
0.0102008888,
-0.0686128512,
-0.0026252999,
0.0574935004,
-0.0037721719,
-0.0052487301,
0.0285014082,
0.0084847929,
-0.0464633517,
0.000381827,
0.0041299197,
-0.0375124849,
0.038827572,
0.017780574,
0.0270285606,
0.0030837927,
0.0151925888,
0.0347682126,
0.0188128799,
-0.0184610486,
0.0218881108,
0.0093149776,
0.0383230373,
0.0338690728,
0.0202169549,
-0.063922897,
-0.0219456535,
-0.0232656505,
-0.0286985263,
0.0458973385,
-0.0151662696,
0.1245041415,
0.0135630732,
0.015523674,
-0.0410550646,
0.0363580771,
-0.003810195,
0.0135097196,
-0.0178478062,
-0.0383403189,
-0.0175155997,
0.03334032,
0.0522034615,
-0.0276330691,
0.0426029786,
-0.0213488452,
-0.0277286805,
-0.0299201012,
-0.0421010107,
-0.0263818093,
0.0097170621,
-0.0325335413,
-0.0317770988,
-0.024208717,
-0.0386264883,
-0.0089231236,
-0.0121421134,
0.0146809602,
-0.0434478,
0.0228314865,
0.0504500009,
-0.0433273502,
0.0380070284,
-0.0467247106,
-0.032333564,
-0.0127003901,
-0.0037592032,
-0.0142193101,
-6.245142877e-33,
-0.0310490523,
0.0173491929,
0.0173091814,
-0.0408977866,
0.0006318777,
-0.0606814399,
-0.0233362559,
-0.0548572615,
-0.0155607769,
-0.0059591047,
-0.0086324597,
0.0371331349,
0.0347862765,
0.0052783038,
0.0057633622,
0.0430263057,
0.111200273,
-0.0015977075,
-0.0413599126,
0.0268100295,
0.0837788507,
0.0550563633,
0.060831327,
-0.0487267189,
-0.009565983,
0.0039836797,
-0.0318365432,
-0.012149414,
-0.0178599581,
0.0185546298,
0.0198909137,
0.0154748783,
-0.0025817293,
-0.026848767,
-0.0338561609,
-0.0212788824,
-0.0795727447,
0.0453085937,
0.0182878356,
0.0779828578,
0.0088310717,
-0.0472875647,
0.0366926007,
-0.0186886489,
0.0022601038,
-0.0328019001,
0.009282019,
-0.0592233613,
-0.0319362469,
0.0039606523,
-0.0283875056,
0.0238975286,
-0.0513685308,
-0.0258306172,
0.0598454289,
0.0731764734,
-0.0261388458,
-0.0050279824,
-0.0810458884,
0.0222395156,
-0.014809886,
0.0267550033,
0.0585134961,
-0.0001489533,
-0.0003124225,
0.0058830776,
0.0351870619,
-0.0169260576,
0.0840309039,
-0.001244235,
0.0160695929,
0.02011027,
0.0353329554,
0.0386031829,
0.0535803623,
-0.0626160726,
-0.0974433497,
0.0312799811,
-0.0286088325,
0.0110272309,
0.0030995563,
0.0178580265,
0.0061023585,
-0.0002133383,
-0.0278768688,
-0.0544812605,
-0.0004743735,
0.0013547977,
0.0287530199,
0.0347037613,
-0.0396157168,
-0.0145100849,
0.0700907037,
-0.0235049352,
0.0337004997,
-0.0279208105,
-0.0620899834,
-0.0345258415,
-0.0244036838,
0.0280732326,
-0.0308265388,
-0.0460668504,
0.0289732572,
0.0121061355,
0.0018697699,
-0.0178443938,
0.0332535803,
0.0272392966,
-0.0529564768,
0.0029726827,
-0.0787225142,
0.0436552018,
-0.0314324796,
0.0477755219,
0.026065981,
-0.0054177339,
0.0082193296,
0.0467514805,
-0.0006032923,
0.0180160757,
0.0117132692,
-0.0295672454,
0.0218974389,
0.0105230389,
-0.0566599667,
-0.0112585258,
-0.0079446658,
-0.0044816043,
0.0886782855,
-0.0425654314,
-0.0262730084,
-0.0124362204,
2.816e-7,
0.0050749448,
0.0185699593,
-0.0143516278,
0.0048661255,
-0.0026597257,
0.0208993126,
-0.0470811613,
0.0240524579,
0.0019854824,
0.0567428954,
0.0041347342,
-0.0144931115,
0.1300659925,
0.0345543697,
-0.0819837749,
-0.0560788326,
-0.0487651117,
0.0184366759,
-0.0216642115,
-0.0197915938,
-0.0139543982,
0.1113031805,
0.0118873985,
-0.0336806364,
0.0143627524,
-0.0341895744,
0.0591950417,
-0.0443558879,
-0.0244888179,
-0.0170332976,
0.0448088683,
0.01764635,
-0.0653674453,
0.0050931512,
-0.0554396734,
0.0490949899,
0.0561363436,
0.0832953453,
0.013723799,
-0.0048448951,
0.0113199763,
-0.0009544266,
-0.0304952823,
-0.000935099,
0.0316582918,
0.0227812137,
-0.0057620434,
-0.0136736874,
-0.0200413615,
0.0214088801,
0.039635852,
-0.0232277066,
-0.0005652009,
0.0068697436,
0.0287863854,
-0.0181934927,
-0.0075748251,
-0.0310122278,
-0.0075207991,
-0.0251001026,
-0.0365745984,
-0.0699800625,
-0.0274581872,
0.0020268583,
0.0029178155,
-0.0154781109,
-0.0086508347,
2.186300336e-34,
0.0330425464,
-0.0175686982,
0.0164098591,
-0.0412753895,
0.0435756296,
-0.0501365215,
0.0131970029,
-0.0149940085,
-0.011556793,
-0.0322383083,
-0.0436427817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01939v1 | A Morphologically-Aware Dictionary-based Data Augmentation Technique for Machine Translation of Under-Represented Languages | 2024-02-02T22:25:44 | 2024-02-02T22:25:44 | Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Sina Ahmadi, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | The availability of parallel texts is crucial to the performance of machine
translation models. However, most of the world's languages face the predominant
challenge of data scarcity. In this paper, we propose strategies to synthesize
parallel data relying on morpho-syntactic information and using bilingual
lexicons along with a small amount of seed parallel data. Our methodology
adheres to a realistic scenario backed by the small parallel seed data. It is
linguistically informed, as it aims to create augmented data that is more
likely to be grammatically correct. We analyze how our synthetic data can be
combined with raw parallel data and demonstrate a consistent improvement in
performance in our experiments on 14 languages (28 English <-> X pairs) ranging
from well- to very low-resource ones. Our method leads to improvements even
when using only five seed sentences and a bilingual lexicon. | [
0.0235726628,
0.0675024241,
-0.020957103,
0.0479352362,
-0.0649059042,
0.0093296142,
-0.0058069453,
0.0015661517,
-0.0520544909,
-0.018276114,
0.0017060805,
-0.0381028578,
0.0555082001,
-0.0347107202,
0.0426427387,
-0.0331961364,
0.0261552446,
-0.0046265069,
-0.0972487628,
-0.0357188471,
-0.0010269475,
0.0426964872,
0.0126299709,
-0.0256811827,
-0.0343296453,
0.0319432914,
-0.0080493018,
0.0533836819,
0.0372237936,
0.0092385821,
-0.0369670801,
0.0255660024,
-0.0250004251,
0.0815694183,
0.0000018523,
-0.040321812,
-0.0340077318,
0.0140310135,
0.0187131912,
0.0046587042,
0.057958588,
-0.0937087387,
-0.0355477966,
0.0269166864,
-0.0052370424,
-0.0378115661,
0.070438467,
-0.0406374112,
0.031321492,
0.0572727472,
-0.0368078575,
-0.05200243,
0.0339152217,
-0.016924629,
-0.0310316365,
0.0384361073,
-0.0055337138,
-0.0044929576,
-0.0105338749,
0.0108046466,
0.0118870065,
0.0535464212,
0.0132905338,
0.010703682,
-0.0222055521,
-0.0098836562,
-0.025139235,
-0.0472760089,
0.0025669471,
0.0445265397,
-0.0357413031,
-0.0500346683,
-0.013935606,
-0.0321142636,
-0.0031214415,
-0.0078928033,
-0.0240639839,
0.0210062135,
-0.0027364641,
0.0400270559,
0.0903553218,
-0.0071531981,
0.0381758697,
-0.0100265816,
-0.0473997667,
0.0066138962,
0.0652504638,
-0.0345811397,
-0.0226352084,
0.0539216325,
-0.0071727452,
-0.0079351468,
0.0042308071,
-0.0325324424,
0.0050321976,
0.0435387194,
-0.0506242998,
-0.128180474,
0.0283953268,
-0.0598328039,
0.0447386988,
0.0423430577,
-0.0057875882,
0.0093905935,
-0.0356897488,
-0.0035868802,
-0.0057646758,
-0.0069025625,
-0.0961857215,
-0.0432660505,
0.0138974087,
0.0680079907,
-0.0538268723,
-0.0416934453,
-0.0598772652,
0.0286469255,
0.0020920574,
0.0440155715,
0.0353195667,
-0.0067397789,
0.0296278596,
-0.0573623665,
-0.0746311843,
-0.0108885244,
-0.0033470755,
0.0082348408,
-0.0170154721,
-0.0081708385,
-0.018864641,
-0.0850765556,
-0.0218841787,
0.0067517054,
0.0327878706,
-0.0318291262,
0.0014159689,
0.0692396015,
-0.0073627331,
-0.0612056293,
-0.009714568,
-0.0059396639,
-0.0408736169,
-0.0256657321,
-0.0124604302,
-0.0727047771,
0.0614038333,
0.0095584998,
0.0125765316,
0.0106038162,
0.0070286184,
-0.0114049679,
-0.0358252674,
0.0675242916,
-0.098337248,
-0.0028973033,
-0.0133625846,
-0.0354732126,
0.0340555161,
0.0856402442,
0.025790805,
-0.0037624969,
0.0154720591,
0.0140237762,
-0.0599762462,
0.0502962247,
0.0160644036,
0.0396990106,
-0.0681864768,
-0.0030391819,
0.0163368173,
0.0469760746,
0.0279040951,
0.0695867017,
-0.0039574732,
0.0413961001,
0.0511144362,
0.0204888098,
-0.0150064342,
0.0417368598,
0.0357680507,
-0.0004735021,
-0.0259773359,
0.0190502629,
0.0019948315,
-0.0057241507,
0.0046810373,
0.0511393622,
0.0245087612,
0.0832458958,
0.0081919897,
-0.0281829517,
-0.0163532253,
-0.0044814646,
0.0167189967,
-0.0032553412,
0.035878446,
0.0436645448,
-0.0128766736,
-0.0000917319,
0.0358652957,
-0.0740240365,
0.0282457527,
0.0248921122,
-0.0559739135,
0.0756013989,
0.0489541851,
0.0258759633,
-0.0610676818,
0.0197520684,
-0.0102453819,
0.0447575152,
0.057079833,
0.0067910766,
0.0307347197,
-0.0486767329,
0.0021308882,
0.0231787469,
-0.006314096,
0.0455882326,
0.0122951474,
0.0322974473,
0.0351690464,
0.0051630577,
-0.0782671347,
0.0219636355,
-0.0398366153,
0.0021833873,
0.0453913212,
0.0057209907,
0.0328773819,
0.0334823169,
-0.004264486,
0.0055361711,
0.0415594429,
-0.0353375711,
0.0097164968,
0.0470593311,
-0.0216987152,
-0.0551621355,
0.0479843207,
-0.0365095511,
-0.0000458987,
-0.0312844329,
-0.012028466,
-0.0736834109,
-0.0243403241,
-0.076379098,
0.0631326959,
-0.0617221519,
0.0514779389,
0.0145377722,
0.0208818801,
-0.0149504738,
0.0273731649,
0.0080345357,
0.0322476067,
-0.0016033859,
-0.0216454566,
0.0157949608,
-0.0390314609,
-0.0068636625,
-0.0058874325,
0.0362091027,
0.0398839451,
0.0214659311,
-0.0131753432,
-0.0081589352,
-0.0301160812,
-0.0731458142,
-0.0056301621,
-0.020617703,
0.0412966385,
0.0319149308,
0.0957413018,
-0.0009237452,
0.0011149896,
-0.0281668361,
0.0570051894,
0.0310597308,
0.0244206693,
0.0177592486,
0.0124063576,
0.0010973881,
0.0051978305,
0.0058756205,
0.0364837609,
-0.0036114689,
0.033145424,
-0.003342991,
-0.0423386917,
-0.0037453673,
-0.01783593,
0.0182342269,
0.0167658422,
-0.0585482754,
-0.0115488628,
-0.0338450558,
0.0934844241,
-0.0129475202,
-0.0276859999,
-0.0604566894,
0.0504104383,
-0.0149059659,
-0.0233195219,
-0.0087837772,
-0.0192719419,
-0.0130610736,
-0.0349161774,
-0.06696821,
-0.0056218696,
0.0574303977,
-0.0261958186,
-0.0372423418,
-0.024560459,
-0.0082661854,
0.0002300419,
-0.0119522791,
0.00476663,
0.0393008143,
-0.0116523569,
0.0533282645,
-0.031770777,
-0.0456092767,
0.0771741793,
-0.0559614822,
-0.0076595997,
-0.070536837,
-0.0280886982,
-0.0222130157,
0.0340851769,
0.0001131689,
0.0183627307,
-0.0373694673,
0.0213342886,
-0.0323133878,
0.067918852,
0.016307449,
-0.0153690521,
0.026262816,
-0.0853819251,
0.0188980382,
-0.0160332266,
-0.0269622151,
-0.0378380679,
-0.0585674308,
-0.0022197769,
-0.0331573524,
0.0767028406,
-0.0401007235,
0.0000367883,
-0.0125053637,
-0.0200271402,
0.0895494074,
0.0023462519,
0.0228740126,
-0.006500029,
-0.0224075355,
-0.0103811454,
-0.0021619776,
-0.0022856665,
-0.0167962704,
-0.013847894,
-0.0314179473,
0.0077719921,
-0.0462605096,
-0.0160581842,
-0.0197750703,
0.0290366653,
0.0096588442,
-0.0437319875,
-0.0218824111,
-0.0078646662,
-0.003461584,
-0.0405490845,
0.0694458485,
0.0264614541,
-0.0278081074,
-0.0142517006,
-0.0118325595,
0.0195445325,
0.0223630052,
0.0246801097,
-0.0914918408,
-0.0029132927,
0.0026106031,
0.0287090372,
0.0096914144,
0.0120312348,
-0.0466212556,
-0.1214837134,
0.0037391498,
0.0451653674,
-0.0245818831,
-0.0211689118,
-0.0112432698,
-0.0179329906,
-0.0468288213,
0.0181931332,
-0.0036964866,
0.0109800734,
0.0090942318,
0.0076228138,
0.0738550425,
-0.0481884405,
-0.0689572468,
-0.0324322134,
0.0029944922,
0.0143513456,
0.0331587233,
-0.0211661626,
-0.0329550393,
0.0113075888,
-0.0289476439,
-0.0221444741,
0.009502545,
-0.0008443632,
0.023760356,
-0.032520175,
0.0085809808,
0.0130222701,
-0.0251999386,
0.0084884325,
-0.0052897511,
0.0486221239,
-0.0081545319,
0.0417657048,
0.0078862878,
-0.0397181101,
0.0133522255,
0.0272015519,
0.0092774192,
-0.0373394638,
0.0556105487,
0.0067154798,
-0.0206018724,
-0.0712145865,
0.038141232,
0.0008451763,
-0.0534465834,
-0.0548181385,
-0.0890865475,
-0.0592007488,
0.0104834083,
0.0451058112,
0.0355670452,
0.0106080584,
-0.0386237279,
-0.0234813597,
-0.0419944562,
0.0219630636,
0.0043495581,
0.0046335617,
-0.0426967479,
-0.0144489864,
0.0167766027,
-0.0306991767,
0.0147129456,
0.0380640738,
-0.0674711764,
-0.0605519488,
0.0209974535,
0.0416668095,
0.0093510468,
0.0458113402,
-0.038626723,
-0.0092049828,
0.0292302296,
0.0425009988,
-0.0044330936,
-0.0069915834,
0.0089114942,
-0.0111077046,
0.0119054299,
0.0477808341,
-0.0023971412,
-0.0017286775,
0.0153742656,
0.0264755953,
-0.0353126563,
-0.0878728479,
0.0445056856,
0.0295962133,
0.0438304059,
-0.0821825266,
0.0219208095,
-0.0223922525,
0.0335399583,
-0.0284180027,
-0.0238127802,
-0.0201384015,
-0.013623869,
0.0571975745,
-0.0148027632,
-0.0078811012,
0.0161862038,
-0.0254097749,
-0.0236053392,
0.0156161366,
-0.0245023891,
0.0194937922,
-0.0029516406,
0.0313861221,
0.0379716791,
0.0065183355,
0.0242062174,
-0.0071727815,
0.0241856258,
-0.0584854819,
-0.0205713231,
-0.0055715716,
-0.0102707744,
-0.0111401854,
0.0247795284,
-0.0113804042,
0.0145704616,
-0.0316704363,
0.0226410441,
0.0743434578,
-0.0206370503,
0.0877427533,
-0.0456010289,
-0.0067545664,
-0.0140058817,
0.0283261929,
0.0076575549,
-0.0238371249,
-0.0187775865,
-0.0079253884,
-0.0170208719,
0.010751334,
0.0574624315,
-0.0006014545,
-0.0006905957,
0.0000379361,
0.0172839221,
-0.0029162483,
-0.0207132716,
-0.016597271,
0.0272142049,
-0.0387448482,
-0.008482242,
-0.025447011,
-0.0716777593,
-0.0118373875,
0.0479937159,
0.0131455492,
-0.0044204681,
0.0112219742,
0.0314373374,
-0.0411648452,
0.0255389977,
-0.0333738104,
0.0406447984,
-0.0129818479,
-0.0381141268,
0.0005111923,
-5.643511277e-33,
-0.0040768627,
0.0185088217,
-0.029335469,
-0.0514712222,
0.0307846237,
0.0055806418,
-0.0118889948,
-0.0121429367,
0.0267903171,
0.0178064518,
-0.0261284858,
0.0292336121,
0.0337070487,
0.0140413279,
0.0260960832,
0.0579015613,
0.0476022698,
0.0163594875,
0.0109167239,
-0.0214741193,
0.0430379771,
-0.0037323893,
0.0956727862,
-0.0251368098,
0.0575941838,
-0.051362291,
0.0046748547,
0.0008534358,
-0.0086375,
-0.0030894554,
0.0244179834,
0.0490303598,
0.0022209317,
-0.0096970433,
-0.0357151292,
-0.0267527867,
-0.0761006922,
0.0000772931,
0.0620104,
0.0467434153,
-0.0525312386,
-0.0210575983,
0.0193674676,
-0.046382159,
0.0111346217,
0.0209251568,
-0.0177276153,
-0.0573611259,
-0.0229428262,
0.0234953091,
-0.0220878515,
0.012288237,
0.0265388582,
0.0074129147,
0.0669462979,
0.0156540722,
0.0162919592,
-0.0712984204,
-0.0077934805,
0.0210203845,
-0.0081778122,
0.0540148653,
0.0841565877,
0.0148636568,
-0.0186323635,
0.0023458856,
0.0291985497,
-0.0029802953,
0.088473022,
0.0308857113,
0.0075717061,
-0.0233458895,
0.027569646,
0.0970792919,
0.0660310015,
-0.0337057784,
-0.0157699287,
0.0411475562,
0.0258808397,
-0.0354496799,
-0.004844653,
-1.002e-7,
-0.0118851811,
-0.0304293558,
-0.0256279632,
-0.0554703176,
-0.0077544483,
-0.0074282554,
-0.0200484414,
0.0059506278,
-0.0530094244,
0.0582887754,
0.044700522,
-0.0040894728,
-0.006059377,
0.0001856497,
-0.0140103269,
0.0072076041,
-0.0450564101,
0.0420843512,
-0.0157336667,
-0.0410056375,
0.0322478265,
0.0514997877,
0.0014497344,
0.0066108927,
0.0347622782,
0.0123313963,
-0.0442799665,
0.0187200662,
-0.0549830049,
0.0171827469,
-0.0372999422,
0.0212275013,
0.0421383195,
0.0189396609,
0.0161461774,
-0.0014968636,
0.0820778012,
-0.0075883893,
-0.0225561894,
-0.0359732173,
-0.0003767995,
0.0172493029,
-0.036254473,
0.0243077874,
-0.0173545461,
-0.0243080817,
0.0417815037,
-0.0090528699,
-0.0148969358,
0.0115097323,
2.651e-7,
0.0327467769,
0.03101811,
0.0125656174,
0.0093671819,
0.004112598,
-0.0193623118,
-0.0295936111,
0.024524169,
-0.0210109055,
0.0014306233,
0.0311539657,
-0.0068921158,
0.0576292463,
0.0271777585,
-0.097949408,
-0.0469227172,
-0.0329999812,
0.0538855828,
-0.0639432073,
0.0068580629,
0.0305068605,
0.1097424477,
0.015040921,
-0.0172706079,
-0.005714912,
0.0000719833,
0.0239983909,
-0.0189525746,
-0.0278161708,
-0.0000123363,
0.0288321935,
0.0327792726,
-0.0340276361,
0.0190156028,
-0.065659374,
0.0329232886,
0.0151041979,
0.0268630367,
-0.0159538444,
0.0357560515,
0.0277354047,
-0.0473316908,
-0.0274889003,
-0.0062359362,
0.0383363068,
0.0045060446,
0.0179321468,
0.0042589232,
-0.0233035255,
0.0438607521,
-0.0061481749,
-0.0258945022,
-0.0431143902,
0.0114268409,
0.0683310702,
-0.0276552495,
-0.0468705148,
-0.0418889709,
-0.0291584656,
0.0196336061,
0.0139854373,
-0.0506380051,
-0.0004160406,
0.0336722583,
0.0182625297,
-0.0163886081,
-0.0016339013,
2.409744363e-34,
0.0257153101,
0.0017356368,
0.0058422587,
-0.0176883396,
0.007691639,
-0.0500000156,
0.0179731958,
0.0315126404,
-0.0215652678,
-0.0291144103,
-0.0360824205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01935v1 | Code Representation Learning At Scale | 2024-02-02T22:19:15 | 2024-02-02T22:19:15 | Dejiao Zhang, Wasi Ahmad, Ming Tan, Hantian Ding, Ramesh Nallapati, Dan Roth, Xiaofei Ma, Bing Xiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have shown that code language models at scale demonstrate
significant performance gains on downstream tasks, i.e., code generation.
However, most of the existing works on code representation learning train
models at a hundred million parameter scale using very limited pretraining
corpora. In this work, we fuel code representation learning with a vast amount
of code data via a two-stage pretraining scheme. We first train the encoders
via a mix that leverages both randomness in masking language modeling and the
structure aspect of programming language. We then enhance the representations
via contrastive learning with hard negative and hard positive constructed in an
unsupervised manner. We establish an off-the-shelf encoder model that
persistently outperforms the existing models on a wide variety of downstream
tasks by large margins. To comprehend the factors contributing to successful
code representation learning, we conduct detailed ablations and share our
findings on (i) a customized and effective token-level denoising scheme for
source code; (ii) the importance of hard negatives and hard positives; (iii)
how the proposed bimodal contrastive learning boost the cross-lingual semantic
search performance; and (iv) how the pretraining schemes decide the downstream
task performance scales with the model size. | [
-0.0329186358,
0.0620871969,
-0.0260268301,
0.0287107173,
0.0050370423,
0.0226697847,
0.0013343623,
0.0096227871,
-0.0213421173,
-0.0110231237,
-0.0125543317,
-0.0043781907,
-0.0024993229,
0.0798680484,
0.0705239773,
-0.0208032541,
0.030304065,
-0.0152004017,
-0.0251572579,
-0.0023932338,
0.0170041155,
0.0333384834,
0.0277523994,
0.0558480509,
0.0142939892,
-0.030045623,
-0.0020118637,
0.0306038503,
-0.0144128008,
-0.0314321406,
0.0212422702,
0.0195055921,
0.0410873815,
0.0233367346,
0.0000022147,
-0.0084209824,
-0.0109556168,
-0.0216443613,
0.0176536869,
0.0274699852,
0.0324997827,
-0.0481201671,
0.003651496,
0.0030879257,
-0.0331225581,
-0.0367150344,
0.1052850038,
-0.0378883667,
0.0599572249,
0.0425664186,
0.0007662342,
-0.0230748225,
-0.0025888716,
-0.0065525919,
0.0199524499,
0.0225436464,
-0.0294403005,
0.0349877849,
-0.027138209,
0.0226154923,
-0.0249023717,
0.019243272,
0.0446476378,
0.0276232325,
0.0265473686,
0.0473790504,
-0.0404306799,
0.011289468,
0.0170074608,
0.0458867475,
-0.0747984424,
-0.0608317927,
-0.0149702393,
-0.020182373,
-0.0401333869,
-0.0497248732,
-0.0127784722,
0.030964287,
0.0135477353,
0.0364953242,
0.012122388,
-0.0011488325,
0.0417409427,
-0.0147735914,
-0.0387600511,
-0.0208654944,
0.0133482842,
0.0010289097,
-0.0304655693,
-0.0160863344,
-0.0219521318,
-0.0492611825,
-0.0000593089,
0.0264240373,
-0.0060986453,
-0.0119062038,
-0.0399228074,
-0.0528573096,
0.0151226046,
-0.0256243404,
0.0067061665,
0.0587889217,
-0.0392776467,
-0.002896514,
-0.0762550384,
0.0411879905,
-0.0205372684,
0.0165078696,
-0.0119246058,
-0.0211832616,
-0.0526948906,
-0.0133364145,
-0.0477345288,
0.0534029864,
-0.0447367728,
0.0266518109,
-0.023382891,
0.0223986711,
-0.0095218793,
0.0118497256,
-0.0366758741,
-0.0041379309,
-0.060982123,
0.0122672031,
0.0498150438,
0.0162386317,
-0.0373394266,
-0.045404423,
-0.0048661297,
-0.0429869778,
-0.0111940149,
0.0305775162,
-0.0142837455,
-0.0385004058,
0.0295645576,
0.06397558,
0.0015354515,
0.0290946253,
-0.0508261807,
-0.0296265502,
0.0234442409,
0.0005631393,
-0.0160288159,
-0.0823314786,
-0.0430125035,
0.0253171567,
0.0110226329,
-0.1007831618,
0.0051088603,
-0.0124386959,
0.0338985249,
0.0774262398,
-0.0462942757,
-0.0371056944,
0.0116506573,
0.002799093,
-0.0013548263,
0.0545833074,
0.0380640663,
0.0115225352,
-0.0134547129,
-0.0552468821,
0.0119478293,
0.0160523392,
0.0356779285,
0.0197341945,
-0.0119708767,
0.0092180818,
0.0526979081,
-0.0066975453,
0.1015266478,
0.0335623659,
-0.0382140018,
-0.0249208696,
-0.0000056155,
-0.0026169189,
-0.0060380725,
0.0424159952,
0.0852482244,
0.029519707,
-0.0583242215,
-0.0190185606,
-0.0062469798,
0.0529083163,
0.0283069182,
0.0102731753,
0.0090436293,
0.0251071416,
-0.031567663,
-0.021526821,
0.026939597,
-0.0240938123,
0.0199853126,
-0.0171713009,
0.0157332327,
0.0159115251,
-0.0503670871,
0.0356392749,
0.032662563,
-0.0622273237,
0.0131711047,
-0.0576246232,
0.0036445262,
0.0231233276,
0.0457749739,
-0.0261052977,
0.0149417454,
-0.0127645349,
-0.0259461626,
-0.0010112517,
0.0005653406,
-0.0016836554,
0.0480689704,
-0.0753683746,
-0.0296085067,
-0.0829816088,
-0.0272321161,
0.0584540814,
-0.0052824155,
-0.0018577944,
0.0491256006,
-0.0228267796,
-0.045078624,
0.0361856855,
-0.0147984577,
-0.0140755996,
0.0316596441,
0.0148963993,
0.0211356897,
-0.0520600453,
-0.0546510033,
0.0124469791,
0.0141865984,
-0.0520482138,
0.0008925008,
-0.0397492461,
-0.0646077842,
-0.0695131719,
0.0064990642,
-0.0783948824,
0.0197546575,
0.0650682673,
-0.0154779581,
-0.0200623255,
0.0755309612,
-0.039354872,
0.0430668332,
-0.0151129225,
-0.0093919886,
-0.0116569875,
0.0197171532,
-0.0143580353,
0.0269008372,
-0.0003409856,
0.0255481787,
-0.0005560979,
0.0731256828,
0.0451018959,
0.00333005,
-0.009993921,
-0.0173250828,
-0.0226976015,
0.0232906695,
-0.0019873099,
0.0389690176,
-0.0057439683,
0.0007412619,
-0.0846308097,
0.0101068066,
-0.0355387442,
-0.0175822619,
0.03560609,
0.0185971633,
0.0366432667,
-0.0341173671,
-0.0479629375,
-0.0131294765,
-0.030283343,
0.0208704062,
0.0114764879,
-0.0070950342,
-0.0406004824,
-0.0241044369,
-0.005318305,
-0.0034109664,
0.0479493439,
-0.0395740233,
-0.0063740998,
-0.0649074838,
0.0880466104,
-0.0009349043,
0.012370307,
-0.0203111321,
-0.0547793023,
0.0233754572,
-0.0285873469,
0.0565087646,
0.0221101139,
-0.0148538528,
-0.0130373817,
0.0622406192,
0.0142208626,
-0.062554501,
0.0073433057,
0.0261283461,
-0.0245642923,
-0.0057047172,
-0.0436272994,
0.0253993943,
0.0813585818,
0.0269175395,
-0.004052273,
-0.0710731521,
-0.0087011261,
-0.0013485568,
-0.0352810062,
-0.0205191448,
-0.0303479265,
0.0022885762,
0.0541967489,
-0.0413827263,
-0.0906304196,
0.0623350926,
-0.0233874824,
-0.0377272516,
-0.0229378212,
-0.012793879,
-0.0314915441,
0.0443117209,
-0.0078660566,
0.0336453244,
0.0343930051,
-0.04637032,
-0.0587361641,
-0.0022774052,
-0.0168130081,
0.001339201,
-0.0059001246,
-0.036956206,
0.009772351,
-0.0009203438,
-0.0415422842,
-0.0204578415,
-0.0379405282,
0.0154462652,
0.0215330683,
0.0730012581,
0.0152232964,
0.0253961347,
0.0347017199,
0.0069081141,
0.0534534119,
0.0400623009,
-0.0412832573,
-0.034131851,
-0.0077158534,
-0.0095803868,
-0.0399757512,
0.0005346532,
-0.0306484085,
-0.0343008116,
0.0011368793,
0.0269848816,
0.0266310666,
-0.0732281059,
0.0286032353,
0.0296200607,
0.0159805678,
-0.0405688658,
0.0512346216,
0.0643445328,
-0.0316317044,
-0.0519167967,
0.0816744342,
0.0200367216,
-0.0681295842,
0.0107634915,
-0.0103650941,
0.061737325,
0.0699689761,
-0.0084585967,
-0.061650414,
-0.0350286774,
-0.0175579209,
0.0226725768,
0.0003349493,
0.0129051264,
0.0031936704,
-0.0849507153,
-0.0006971063,
0.0391108058,
-0.0281874631,
-0.0670594648,
-0.0304369926,
-0.0571834184,
-0.0140836937,
-0.011105285,
0.006829618,
-0.0008218937,
0.0172910709,
0.0145506496,
0.0171735846,
0.0126221562,
0.0151169794,
-0.0489630774,
0.0134658096,
0.0903817341,
0.0062601017,
0.0175347198,
-0.0148129137,
0.0114053525,
-0.0355467051,
0.02046041,
-0.0260021295,
0.0598086305,
0.007938182,
-0.0312729031,
0.0320646726,
-0.0074497797,
-0.0734690875,
-0.0074499156,
0.016689714,
0.0379199423,
-0.0120007228,
0.0219469834,
-0.0132853119,
-0.0124509465,
0.0095650358,
0.0240260884,
0.0629997551,
-0.0148252565,
-0.0333465934,
-0.0590867549,
0.04723965,
-0.0569853298,
-0.0124522801,
-0.0264678691,
-0.0023461652,
0.0288949497,
-0.0418221988,
-0.016827343,
0.0000595359,
0.054785084,
0.0125983246,
-0.0357784256,
-0.0094015738,
-0.014651875,
-0.0802455917,
0.0244156271,
-0.0533449277,
0.00701212,
-0.0189678613,
-0.0491765626,
0.0022216227,
-0.0323803313,
-0.0258177854,
0.0084361164,
-0.0764849782,
-0.0270776656,
-0.0472849943,
0.0430106036,
0.0108670304,
0.049911432,
-0.0002160896,
-0.0558088496,
0.0053916802,
-0.0038149173,
-0.0511282496,
0.0147321736,
0.047009889,
-0.0079997731,
0.0115618352,
0.007906029,
-0.0586841814,
0.0021529784,
0.0332652554,
-0.0079501355,
-0.0294411685,
0.0468082465,
0.0434403121,
-0.010911243,
0.0335268863,
-0.0041425363,
-0.014046913,
-0.0134102032,
-0.0019111958,
0.0104878983,
-0.0158495046,
-0.044486247,
0.0038134276,
0.0451623648,
-0.000312784,
0.0190006457,
0.0703752413,
0.0060876026,
0.0281691104,
-0.0273977332,
0.043181248,
0.0084355166,
0.0545631088,
0.0436064601,
0.0284164269,
-0.013745117,
0.0133313797,
0.008848968,
0.0295982733,
-0.0184420235,
0.0412994698,
0.0156643819,
0.0424418487,
-0.0007155277,
0.0075934846,
-0.0374536142,
-0.0417620502,
-0.011736121,
-0.0640385449,
0.0657174885,
0.0299804024,
0.0472291149,
0.0140338978,
0.022011552,
-0.0246178508,
0.0684936941,
-0.0044484241,
-0.0374660268,
0.0047888798,
0.0150994891,
-0.0314853415,
-0.0376601778,
0.0976524726,
-0.0043751979,
0.0246382877,
-0.0240950044,
0.0271262024,
-0.0377342738,
0.0139362663,
0.0487837866,
0.033003889,
0.0097219199,
0.0054695997,
-0.0083999857,
-0.0634203181,
-0.0097250473,
0.001949469,
0.0060372222,
-0.0071123685,
0.0683204606,
0.0820947662,
-0.018649824,
-0.0098730735,
-0.0163264591,
0.0226464849,
0.0312716365,
-0.0246959813,
-0.0508460216,
-6.279254254e-33,
-0.0114874672,
-0.0048008678,
-0.0095834536,
-0.0201379508,
0.015893124,
0.0157022364,
-0.0560435094,
-0.0076850923,
-0.0155487424,
-0.0219098609,
0.0655681267,
0.0314832777,
-0.0106717441,
-0.0026968732,
0.0173299368,
0.0250233468,
0.0797319636,
0.0248749908,
-0.0272626448,
0.0703960732,
-0.0004848244,
0.0282819588,
0.0160086062,
-0.0521770939,
-0.0353814289,
0.0051926412,
0.0263139792,
-0.0249374937,
0.0748301223,
0.0369217582,
-0.0237196703,
0.0357594453,
-0.0063660974,
-0.0272650588,
-0.0603472181,
-0.0705150813,
-0.0317665637,
-0.0187938735,
-0.0037578933,
0.0071124807,
-0.0081151202,
-0.0889898688,
0.0780718476,
0.0094092721,
-0.0239172075,
0.00120396,
0.0282172412,
0.0110896183,
-0.0155671844,
-0.0482352674,
-0.0759490877,
0.0289425142,
-0.0522413999,
-0.0206307732,
0.0208114944,
0.0224477611,
0.0021515666,
0.0617050678,
-0.0128642051,
-0.0022986007,
-0.0179981701,
0.0596367568,
0.0502627604,
0.0383816659,
0.0214348808,
0.0361096188,
0.0478629768,
0.0202491246,
0.0156285837,
0.0351630971,
0.0707317516,
0.0111134946,
0.046762377,
0.0364285782,
0.056466613,
0.0068291021,
-0.0618707538,
0.0106095187,
-0.0449242257,
0.0247171409,
0.0217284244,
0.0694017708,
-0.0210126434,
-0.0200861078,
-0.0339122377,
-0.0534078442,
-0.0227181744,
-0.0364014581,
0.0351616219,
0.0059743179,
-0.0132601969,
0.0018564545,
0.0406363234,
-0.0385511629,
0.0244184807,
0.0486223064,
-0.0380072482,
0.0158964731,
0.0163325593,
0.0205735434,
-0.035431236,
-0.0340804234,
0.0435840823,
-0.004474361,
0.0745564252,
0.0012222795,
0.0356920958,
0.0112894941,
-0.062964201,
-0.0103639672,
-0.0512176491,
-0.0097157452,
-0.0041944575,
0.0229485184,
0.0082449717,
0.0063968203,
0.0041116769,
0.0021212806,
-0.0070009748,
-0.031416256,
-0.0422922857,
-0.0113930115,
-0.0111565962,
0.0601970293,
-0.0576089956,
-0.0307202954,
-0.0650381595,
0.0236775689,
0.0494106226,
-0.0494011752,
-0.0872415453,
-0.0050476794,
2.725e-7,
0.0132196788,
0.0106830951,
0.009935122,
0.0435314402,
0.0066808616,
0.0448996946,
-0.017321134,
0.008864549,
0.0120881516,
-0.0355282426,
-0.0231697373,
0.0273786169,
0.0417747311,
0.0377524383,
-0.0353176333,
0.0609254837,
-0.0099512869,
0.0102591272,
-0.0498188399,
0.0362317525,
0.0477323122,
0.1086612493,
-0.0200726781,
-0.0072618239,
0.0611639284,
-0.0295846127,
0.0589942783,
0.0017934678,
0.0362957083,
-0.0005339542,
-0.1095789745,
0.0319556408,
-0.0271950997,
-0.0179169886,
-0.0157200135,
-0.0216017831,
0.0090551814,
0.0461999811,
-0.0213655066,
0.0049410937,
0.0419574752,
0.0046011256,
-0.0224978309,
-0.0691312701,
0.0607980005,
-0.0213636197,
0.00145639,
-0.0073557971,
-0.0292161275,
0.0420723446,
0.0029269711,
-0.029157212,
-0.0271417368,
0.0069832508,
0.0120441634,
0.0004484979,
-0.0422275998,
-0.0453510247,
-0.0464696027,
0.0214554761,
-0.0033706909,
-0.0424489267,
-0.0699877739,
0.0072996174,
0.046721749,
-0.0054490236,
0.0405597985,
2.728030811e-34,
0.0373331606,
-0.0358121581,
0.014068882,
0.0164532941,
0.0294611957,
-0.031698823,
-0.0475475192,
0.0087119266,
0.0155628631,
-0.0111583443,
-0.0319582559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01931v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01931v1 | Digits micro-model for accurate and secure transactions | 2024-02-02T22:01:27 | 2024-02-02T22:01:27 | Chirag Chhablani, Nikhita Sharma, Jordan Hosier, Vijay K. Gurbani | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems are used in the financial domain
to enhance the caller experience by enabling natural language understanding and
facilitating efficient and intuitive interactions. Increasing use of ASR
systems requires that such systems exhibit very low error rates. The
predominant ASR models to collect numeric data are large, general-purpose
commercial models -- Google Speech-to-text (STT), or Amazon Transcribe -- or
open source (OpenAI's Whisper). Such ASR models are trained on hundreds of
thousands of hours of audio data and require considerable resources to run.
Despite recent progress large speech recognition models, we highlight the
potential of smaller, specialized "micro" models. Such light models can be
trained perform well on number recognition specific tasks, competing with
general models like Whisper or Google STT while using less than 80 minutes of
training time and occupying at least an order of less memory resources. Also,
unlike larger speech recognition models, micro-models are trained on carefully
selected and curated datasets, which makes them highly accurate, agile, and
easy to retrain, while using low compute resources. We present our work on
creating micro models for multi-digit number recognition that handle diverse
speaking styles reflecting real-world pronunciation patterns. Our work
contributes to domain-specific ASR models, improving digit recognition
accuracy, and privacy of data. An added advantage, their low resource
consumption allows them to be hosted on-premise, keeping private data local
instead uploading to an external cloud. Our results indicate that our
micro-model makes less errors than the best-of-breed commercial or open-source
ASRs in recognizing digits (1.8% error rate of our best micro-model versus 5.8%
error rate of Whisper), and has a low memory footprint (0.66 GB VRAM for our
model versus 11 GB VRAM for Whisper). | [
-0.0192773771,
0.0677959248,
-0.0184211507,
0.0583912097,
0.0077522057,
-0.0097391959,
0.1009753197,
0.0003445823,
-0.0221332442,
0.010953879,
-0.0434986092,
-0.0331923403,
0.0475062393,
0.0288936011,
0.0251440611,
-0.0297875982,
0.0085393908,
-0.0648950189,
0.0211931281,
-0.0377340019,
0.0068692048,
0.0043803658,
-0.0139290597,
0.0266685896,
0.0038383051,
-0.014311213,
-0.0104557406,
-0.0205866937,
0.0273635108,
0.0201362893,
-0.0166429225,
-0.0075614159,
0.0418704823,
0.0874756947,
0.0000021851,
-0.0204203483,
-0.0174782872,
0.0185630266,
-0.0927870646,
0.044988364,
0.0169783216,
-0.0059695984,
-0.0055128876,
0.0170096215,
0.0072965291,
-0.0262144096,
0.0344236791,
0.0604494736,
0.0523873344,
0.0218308289,
-0.0145096621,
-0.0388354175,
0.0069138161,
-0.0345439501,
-0.0164136253,
-0.0278169699,
-0.0077145756,
-0.0170045532,
-0.0618408844,
0.0031379531,
0.0236907005,
0.0128955534,
0.0139863985,
0.0047817389,
-0.0075128349,
0.0063076741,
-0.0260613561,
-0.0149913998,
-0.0514909998,
0.0521788634,
-0.0271001756,
0.0137004694,
0.0462110788,
-0.0075125638,
-0.0191489402,
-0.005529922,
-0.0196320023,
0.0046035876,
-0.0036270109,
-0.0398396365,
-0.0503384955,
0.0319086537,
0.0376968831,
-0.0107847955,
0.024837777,
-0.0504326373,
0.0107198814,
-0.0124298707,
-0.0388559401,
-0.0853212625,
-0.004968063,
0.0016392678,
0.0589298233,
-0.0240788627,
0.0628532544,
-0.0155291557,
-0.0602525882,
-0.053165637,
-0.0042019752,
-0.033847589,
0.041411154,
0.0512101464,
-0.038076628,
0.0009116938,
-0.0181853175,
0.049213089,
-0.0359722078,
-0.0568261258,
0.0298173819,
0.0318021812,
0.0452531204,
0.00924093,
-0.0442004278,
0.0563069023,
-0.0412023142,
-0.0443457402,
-0.064105019,
-0.0115655465,
-0.0066271247,
0.025884524,
0.0174903609,
0.0067888796,
0.0001731652,
-0.0621782728,
0.0468968228,
-0.0040515685,
-0.023963172,
0.0380803533,
-0.002690648,
-0.0633410364,
-0.0100488346,
-0.0046200976,
0.0212852769,
0.0014910481,
0.009592874,
0.0708281398,
0.051083561,
-0.0150412461,
-0.0474092849,
-0.0405885391,
-0.0120359538,
-0.0198142994,
-0.0313308276,
-0.0440863669,
-0.0043744906,
-0.006288182,
0.0159572102,
-0.0010819793,
0.0295356158,
-0.0093186768,
0.0112561025,
0.0869256407,
0.0022298226,
-0.0124720475,
0.0386212841,
-0.0171736181,
0.0204017889,
0.0059304,
0.0606399477,
-0.0273000989,
0.0288344175,
-0.0501484871,
0.0228527058,
0.0312822126,
0.0276228692,
-0.0055080783,
0.0070509333,
0.0039774878,
0.0251814276,
0.0133167244,
0.0402954072,
0.0581063181,
-0.0348686874,
-0.0615512207,
0.10470099,
0.0929967463,
0.0136923324,
0.0286650639,
-0.0234401636,
0.0115598897,
0.0206674784,
-0.0730611011,
-0.0168580301,
0.0176955722,
-0.0189412497,
0.0245790146,
0.0613181889,
0.0061214995,
-0.0266571287,
0.0036653269,
-0.0094760591,
-0.0540988371,
-0.0422785096,
0.0698216408,
0.0059796334,
-0.0058920835,
-0.0218200888,
0.06816376,
-0.0073110722,
-0.0666938052,
-0.0359101407,
-0.0664637983,
0.0328262448,
0.0860305876,
0.0244490355,
-0.0063876645,
0.0391010456,
-0.0608009994,
-0.0646926463,
0.0260322597,
0.0114668468,
0.0003364027,
0.0394988507,
-0.07073915,
0.0262574703,
0.0502659045,
-0.008358255,
0.032344643,
0.0078795906,
0.024648834,
0.0291749965,
-0.0143277142,
0.013804784,
-0.0229181089,
0.0018285939,
-0.073355794,
0.0685738176,
0.0191035215,
0.035942886,
0.0213897042,
-0.0072156973,
-0.0162926782,
0.0201794785,
0.0107023111,
0.0429131649,
0.0018235585,
-0.0558211617,
0.0541943088,
0.0551172979,
0.017540399,
0.0302030575,
0.0376270935,
-0.0143649001,
-0.0533714071,
0.0081000281,
-0.0197181087,
0.006313317,
-0.0556998365,
0.0067113782,
0.0219873786,
0.0117340973,
0.0091408705,
-0.0383367352,
0.0103481561,
0.0028200056,
-0.0312470254,
-0.0018627949,
0.0279774331,
-0.0666633919,
-0.0081130955,
-0.0218628477,
-0.0243374836,
0.0665044561,
0.0150685571,
-0.0205096602,
0.0037043518,
0.0005767958,
-0.0694316104,
-0.0460990556,
0.0069031063,
0.0276667085,
0.0012821902,
0.0478127524,
-0.003455,
-0.0559406616,
-0.0172070209,
-0.0129398741,
-0.0302813277,
-0.0274231378,
0.0037968531,
-0.0188639518,
-0.0266922265,
-0.0156121114,
-0.0189027619,
0.0237655435,
0.0171842743,
-0.0281517636,
-0.0123881046,
-0.0383209065,
-0.0111564258,
0.0551448688,
0.0292042214,
-0.0175401866,
-0.0140586263,
-0.0128915133,
0.0367943645,
-0.0051120454,
0.0293829665,
-0.0269920565,
-0.0038354308,
-0.0319792069,
0.0043465816,
-0.0257160328,
0.0042447015,
0.018770894,
0.0190421641,
-0.0296482854,
0.0309059378,
-0.0464191772,
0.0370125994,
0.0017134036,
0.0134968022,
-0.0336019211,
0.0088568777,
0.0377701744,
-0.0167533047,
-0.0199659187,
0.0215141065,
-0.0128406547,
0.0203287955,
0.0022545778,
-0.0219204836,
0.0173729714,
-0.0435377955,
-0.0096570728,
0.014490651,
-0.0229638517,
-0.0187932663,
0.040343646,
-0.0300465766,
0.0190162882,
0.0190998856,
-0.0328984484,
0.0073567741,
0.0210306011,
0.0436352454,
-0.0355977528,
0.0542263053,
-0.0044963774,
-0.0020749792,
-0.0329634137,
-0.0636970401,
-0.0072948909,
-0.0463877395,
-0.0738427639,
0.0356777124,
0.0134729072,
-0.0713815689,
-0.0384722836,
0.0460424758,
0.060830079,
0.0818011314,
0.0094482563,
0.0087977136,
-0.0102523202,
0.0384598039,
-0.0116486875,
-0.0088297604,
-0.0096923169,
-0.0256064497,
0.0616915673,
-0.0020566883,
0.0822642222,
0.0240939409,
-0.0530798919,
-0.0294584073,
0.042143818,
-0.0401240103,
-0.0172828697,
0.0355493799,
0.0441618413,
-0.0699603334,
0.0018332435,
0.0641139597,
0.0003227935,
-0.0023631575,
-0.0253726523,
0.0016432883,
0.0108544286,
-0.0131728705,
-0.0162014421,
-0.0731161982,
-0.0150622483,
0.0566067211,
0.048774302,
0.0071947579,
0.0190870538,
-0.0168828238,
-0.0926398784,
0.033651337,
0.0283398125,
-0.0088761793,
-0.0298783965,
-0.0182323027,
-0.0124288145,
-0.051709082,
0.0711153969,
0.0115861539,
-0.0324902982,
-0.0441676676,
0.0305801202,
-0.0489389077,
-0.009069195,
0.0383064263,
-0.0383406281,
0.034434095,
0.0368951,
-0.0101174247,
0.009245812,
-0.0465062708,
-0.0325633846,
0.0258774236,
-0.0277531426,
0.0297990348,
0.0210211277,
0.0106197698,
-0.006574024,
0.0207718182,
0.0554995649,
-0.0051738336,
0.0067837629,
0.0194855873,
0.0080820424,
-0.019187035,
0.0221794806,
0.0025842143,
0.0050802873,
-0.0416017771,
0.0403102897,
0.0004146186,
-0.0440091453,
-0.0170377176,
-0.0392509922,
0.0050700605,
-0.024071496,
0.002457368,
-0.0092300409,
0.0768448561,
-0.0864169449,
-0.0023144302,
-0.0141469175,
-0.0078118863,
0.0170514826,
0.036871925,
-0.0317722484,
0.0947868228,
0.0492902994,
-0.0329457298,
-0.0111694233,
-0.0864283964,
0.0395366997,
-0.0689108223,
0.0559679642,
0.0089116655,
-0.0390698686,
-0.0332424305,
0.0275666695,
-0.1055278108,
-0.0296904538,
0.0243214387,
0.0259525739,
0.025610568,
0.0009785988,
-0.0399676897,
-0.063055329,
0.0605163537,
0.0317852087,
-0.109612301,
-0.0100577129,
0.0767170936,
-0.0210306458,
-0.0122777727,
0.000480551,
-0.0168311689,
0.0238850955,
0.0132197207,
-0.0571012534,
-0.0809238628,
-0.0478977002,
0.0052219387,
0.0333600193,
0.0190075673,
-0.0192612112,
0.0382980853,
-0.0230958015,
0.0580335371,
0.0057776398,
0.0330554619,
-0.0014760268,
-0.0522666499,
0.007768854,
0.0224161576,
0.0062474716,
-0.0459341183,
0.0389232449,
-0.0319087952,
-0.0324026197,
0.0266649872,
0.0132583305,
0.0488581359,
0.0006135484,
-0.0447694249,
-0.0099041695,
0.0836942568,
0.0066599203,
0.000867115,
-0.0042901952,
-0.0140093444,
-0.0118823797,
0.0125744287,
0.0008759945,
0.0171211231,
-0.0168835428,
-0.0604916476,
-0.0082230978,
0.0322263688,
0.0088339532,
0.013740276,
-0.0387485437,
-0.0406345949,
0.0187080987,
-0.0586457662,
-0.0126315905,
-0.0020467592,
-0.0024843733,
-0.0285246875,
0.0390948914,
-0.0171655267,
0.0241526235,
0.0374117419,
-0.0091142319,
0.0131349294,
0.0029128711,
-0.008852995,
-0.048433017,
-0.0200023912,
-0.0082113128,
0.0467276201,
-0.0398534611,
-0.0245453827,
-0.0418691784,
-0.0365357138,
0.0531861112,
-0.0176348817,
0.026753258,
-0.038520772,
0.0370079726,
-0.001523912,
-0.0487135872,
0.0184487849,
0.0130190914,
-0.0178599879,
-0.0032728135,
-0.0380403809,
-0.034337189,
-5.909973438e-33,
0.0134561099,
0.0023501178,
0.0123865642,
0.0208626706,
0.0562743805,
0.0313859731,
0.0116144121,
0.0075711352,
0.0125910155,
-0.0286216717,
-0.0496017635,
0.0041553453,
0.0433599055,
0.0343328193,
0.0010261347,
0.0259947125,
0.1264082491,
-0.0395398326,
0.0266372431,
-0.0045323744,
0.0303856824,
0.0378073603,
0.0314930305,
-0.0576431155,
0.001573659,
0.0106104463,
-0.058623191,
-0.0656582788,
-0.0153949643,
0.0329197422,
-0.0345836803,
0.0175848585,
-0.0436094925,
-0.0634836853,
-0.0003967445,
0.038207043,
-0.0757451206,
0.0284140147,
-0.0240449905,
0.0350053385,
0.0356965475,
-0.0504145287,
0.0129509754,
-0.0320236906,
-0.0516731665,
0.0065387683,
-0.0159673672,
-0.0106958766,
-0.0114163393,
-0.0651036352,
0.031433899,
0.0339381546,
0.0109902937,
-0.0145321088,
0.108510673,
-0.009857784,
-0.0248388331,
-0.0283309035,
-0.0851866826,
0.052785404,
0.0348551162,
0.0014655242,
-0.0093607986,
0.0061427769,
-0.0183068346,
0.0017401638,
0.0726337433,
-0.0520415828,
0.0237632394,
-0.0278649367,
0.0153267048,
0.035100501,
0.0611060895,
0.0217237864,
0.0714208931,
-0.0438915603,
-0.031947162,
-0.022762388,
0.0310452152,
0.0130076511,
0.0594729856,
0.0029202655,
-0.0567668304,
0.0243132096,
-0.0361321643,
-0.0461163372,
-0.0523772091,
0.0334897712,
0.0164902993,
0.0344543308,
0.0149924392,
0.0257893112,
0.0253442694,
-0.05970186,
-0.0056223646,
-0.0176266003,
0.0492488779,
0.0120563954,
-0.00758021,
-0.001157593,
-0.0070749661,
-0.0260475241,
0.0076678786,
-0.0097715808,
0.0206697956,
-0.0206111446,
0.0237850957,
0.0206644703,
-0.0939488634,
-0.0127607798,
0.0027663487,
0.0324822962,
0.019630162,
0.0316662714,
0.0214372501,
-0.0198113639,
0.0178307071,
-0.0037043435,
-0.0135210557,
-0.0286711492,
0.0050468463,
0.0132415593,
-0.0318368934,
0.0502078719,
0.0082465513,
-0.0061785025,
-0.0256242603,
0.0159522761,
0.0276058856,
0.0241226461,
-0.0018103069,
-0.0023563348,
2.911e-7,
-0.0827344656,
0.036706727,
-0.0159005709,
-0.0067192279,
0.020917736,
0.070292443,
0.0349411927,
0.0335983783,
-0.0296646841,
-0.0419505015,
-0.0031177336,
-0.007888224,
0.1082727984,
0.0249240771,
-0.067187041,
-0.047057908,
-0.0178238321,
0.0261066053,
-0.0052572694,
0.0321590789,
-0.054503765,
0.1020068526,
0.0232588947,
-0.0354357101,
0.0360226147,
-0.0591689125,
0.0177143011,
-0.0193387028,
0.0049076052,
-0.0420892015,
0.0130251916,
0.0552735776,
-0.0087290825,
0.0288461819,
0.0019735803,
0.0124704149,
-0.0283715054,
0.0908795595,
-0.0094879735,
-0.0097399866,
-0.0189687908,
0.0112460144,
-0.0390241742,
-0.0051909178,
0.0042621377,
0.0113147898,
-0.0273668673,
-0.0240352042,
-0.0106523279,
-0.0183088519,
0.0019650145,
-0.0031964278,
0.0262556318,
0.0106564155,
0.0283018518,
-0.0476256125,
-0.0042078798,
-0.0186507292,
0.0294338446,
0.0127512822,
-0.0382575765,
-0.0035490345,
-0.0422167815,
-0.0145234354,
0.0319127999,
-0.0017930899,
0.0350501053,
2.361958681e-34,
0.0363283679,
-0.0670060441,
-0.0106678642,
0.0647648796,
0.0055047083,
-0.0197222196,
0.0476193801,
-0.0055419467,
0.0488157757,
-0.0524370037,
-0.0479292348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01920v1 | Preference Poisoning Attacks on Reward Model Learning | 2024-02-02T21:45:24 | 2024-02-02T21:45:24 | Junlin Wu, Jiongxiao Wang, Chaowei Xiao, Chenguang Wang, Ning Zhang, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning utility, or reward, models from pairwise comparisons is a
fundamental component in a number of application domains. These approaches
inherently entail collecting preference information from people, with feedback
often provided anonymously. Since preferences are subjective, there is no gold
standard to compare against; yet, reliance of high-impact systems on preference
learning creates a strong motivation for malicious actors to skew data
collected in this fashion to their ends. We investigate the nature and extent
of this vulnerability systematically by considering a threat model in which an
attacker can flip a small subset of preference comparisons with the goal of
either promoting or demoting a target outcome. First, we propose two classes of
algorithmic approaches for these attacks: a principled gradient-based
framework, and several variants of rank-by-distance methods. Next, we
demonstrate the efficacy of best attacks in both these classes in successfully
achieving malicious goals on datasets from three diverse domains: autonomous
control, recommendation system, and textual prompt-response preference
learning. We find that the best attacks are often highly successful, achieving
in the most extreme case 100% success rate with only 0.3% of the data poisoned.
However, which attack is best can vary significantly across domains,
demonstrating the value of our comprehensive vulnerability analysis that
involves several classes of attack algorithms. In addition, we observe that the
simpler and more scalable rank-by-distance approaches are often competitive
with the best, and on occasion significantly outperform gradient-based methods.
Finally, we show that several state-of-the-art defenses against other classes
of poisoning attacks exhibit, at best, limited efficacy in our setting. | [
0.0207368527,
0.0747973844,
-0.007684235,
0.0405692719,
-0.0283909012,
-0.0042519001,
0.0054536061,
-0.0194822941,
0.0252459925,
0.0033504923,
-0.0365317576,
0.0168641061,
0.0206555352,
-0.0000797296,
0.0584575385,
-0.0136008952,
0.0279458035,
-0.0047411467,
-0.0148755312,
-0.0330947153,
0.0277041923,
-0.0244050622,
0.0256156046,
-0.0043271994,
0.0255956464,
-0.0233006757,
-0.0111755515,
0.009067568,
0.0503192693,
-0.0365559459,
0.02010094,
0.0211646613,
-0.0022269206,
0.0186726786,
0.0000023995,
-0.0204072688,
-0.0667761415,
0.0074918936,
-0.0164593663,
-0.0020471474,
0.0205152705,
0.029536128,
0.0135380598,
0.0447366349,
-0.0280571431,
0.025150571,
0.0126200933,
0.0472423881,
0.0484823249,
0.0630949065,
0.0015071685,
0.0112450887,
0.0193393435,
-0.060326308,
0.0180565715,
-0.0118267098,
0.0187668055,
-0.0838233903,
-0.0183674823,
0.0186003819,
0.0190793704,
-0.0252959765,
-0.0143227335,
0.0246167518,
0.0061217085,
0.0398417525,
0.0309950206,
0.0163380541,
-0.0194156803,
0.0495250113,
-0.0507656336,
0.0328549631,
0.0280555859,
0.0058631394,
0.0321756974,
0.002544485,
0.0134243052,
-0.0004716142,
-0.0114883455,
-0.0171323624,
0.0050236569,
0.0283983536,
0.0491059497,
0.0306961183,
-0.0114600062,
0.0459523723,
-0.0117876129,
-0.0417949632,
0.0136408331,
-0.028807817,
-0.026559094,
-0.0443895236,
0.0071321973,
-0.0328757763,
-0.0358130932,
-0.0095348926,
-0.0202300232,
-0.0115751084,
0.0048306547,
-0.0420029424,
0.0796239376,
0.0107277501,
-0.0045052459,
0.0143840928,
0.0217718706,
0.0227317866,
-0.0308996104,
0.0437288098,
-0.0020162491,
0.0757252052,
0.0324085988,
0.0082409708,
0.0538133681,
0.055710569,
-0.0134869227,
0.033631172,
-0.0300852805,
0.0402477719,
-0.087011233,
0.0635236427,
-0.0350717455,
0.0604586489,
0.0060452987,
0.0494098477,
-0.051293321,
-0.0310575273,
-0.0132599715,
0.006323386,
0.0171296261,
0.032649219,
-0.0309364386,
-0.0242051315,
-0.043637909,
-0.0261414479,
0.0080783125,
0.1220578626,
0.0234807935,
-0.0296730679,
-0.0151988687,
-0.0889267698,
-0.0240225084,
-0.0031923975,
-0.0452663265,
-0.0664607063,
-0.0001593464,
-0.0155433053,
-0.0136727039,
-0.0486035869,
-0.0023718609,
-0.0083862338,
-0.0600580461,
0.0832051337,
0.0721661747,
-0.0266667083,
0.0001716811,
0.0298101455,
-0.0802384764,
0.0064866496,
-0.003199571,
0.1189531684,
0.0361464545,
0.0011250768,
0.0204466302,
-0.0298977308,
0.0274016056,
0.0080486974,
0.0095067183,
0.0363842398,
0.0157359019,
-0.0070649697,
-0.0295289364,
0.0361086056,
-0.0381541662,
-0.0665052459,
0.1175346375,
0.0181848649,
-0.0466264486,
-0.0155217359,
-0.0122847082,
-0.0147171086,
-0.0502959713,
-0.0015928858,
-0.0680811405,
0.0117568802,
-0.0529845953,
-0.0459580645,
0.0148652028,
0.0003292834,
-0.0153156966,
-0.0221906509,
0.0354449451,
-0.0372394249,
0.0241323914,
0.0531568304,
-0.0065449318,
0.0316140428,
-0.0057191076,
-0.0655915067,
0.0284853224,
-0.0089061204,
-0.0028383459,
-0.0350141861,
0.0024448438,
0.0675458387,
0.062229082,
-0.0343467705,
0.0292995758,
-0.0472520851,
-0.0487028956,
-0.0488027893,
0.0301257242,
-0.0273850262,
0.0111699654,
-0.0053647556,
-0.0117184371,
0.0054103513,
0.0141643826,
0.0480970331,
0.0051959362,
-0.0246417746,
-0.034626238,
0.0070690396,
-0.0024580872,
-0.0100847157,
0.0148842996,
-0.049779959,
0.081483677,
0.0523004755,
0.0461150445,
-0.0053033512,
0.0148871224,
0.0204894803,
0.020501459,
0.026232278,
-0.0246656183,
-0.0148703121,
0.0118852565,
0.006463449,
-0.002062981,
-0.0193342697,
-0.0072495942,
0.0977553055,
-0.0265580229,
0.0132878451,
0.0293879844,
0.0056269104,
-0.0220164265,
0.0167981014,
-0.0046083443,
0.0224381685,
0.0132852802,
-0.0620284751,
0.0555120409,
-0.0197901782,
-0.0118455058,
-0.034829814,
0.003244245,
-0.0085955607,
-0.0509372056,
-0.0227296427,
-0.024962157,
-0.0324581973,
0.0017520908,
0.0080902372,
-0.0258744042,
0.0028752817,
-0.0179671906,
-0.0282034744,
-0.0036950605,
-0.0121868635,
0.0191369317,
-0.0193555802,
0.0073067537,
0.0188916121,
-0.0488245785,
-0.0136223994,
-0.046433039,
-0.0407236293,
0.0435722731,
0.0014431311,
0.0210707169,
0.0212377515,
-0.0167066306,
-0.0193533134,
-0.0199332032,
0.0549515933,
-0.0146838222,
0.0652046725,
0.0096616,
-0.0068206177,
-0.0362787694,
0.0226381775,
-0.0238116048,
0.0098377736,
0.0212520398,
0.0100932475,
0.0091401096,
0.0996614769,
0.0638548359,
0.0836686119,
0.068111591,
0.0473476984,
-0.0535191037,
-0.0176326614,
-0.0500578135,
0.0016246964,
-0.0336424448,
0.0008326026,
0.0053271865,
0.0404557176,
0.0391309783,
-0.0154193006,
-0.0366207771,
0.0568570532,
0.010109459,
-0.0384106636,
-0.0444836095,
0.0346787721,
0.0021398561,
-0.0222944133,
-0.0222979821,
-0.0624592155,
0.1066663191,
0.0076703806,
0.0591583103,
-0.0259192772,
-0.0362412483,
0.0355682336,
-0.0241249744,
0.0237982292,
0.0134669142,
0.018095877,
0.0281431209,
-0.0418025218,
-0.0160514452,
0.081664741,
-0.0403604619,
-0.0105250133,
0.0093855066,
-0.0225603208,
-0.000751472,
-0.0934446678,
-0.0410452336,
-0.1025107503,
0.0214182604,
-0.0250249505,
0.0246940982,
-0.0313334763,
0.010014818,
-0.0637006611,
0.0397777706,
-0.0011853511,
-0.0348160528,
-0.0365791209,
-0.020341184,
0.0110811498,
0.0426790453,
-0.0704539195,
0.0200816151,
-0.0091943461,
-0.0009406226,
0.0888110101,
0.0601010807,
-0.003960792,
-0.0284010768,
0.0194691848,
0.0061074612,
-0.02527133,
0.0122330086,
0.021628689,
-0.0139675131,
0.0135046951,
0.0020977654,
0.0223058388,
0.0242756866,
-0.0865599513,
0.0289687812,
0.0442461446,
0.0343659595,
0.0043510143,
0.0080663403,
-0.0844662786,
-0.000655962,
0.0026901099,
0.0946250707,
-0.0513835549,
-0.03557292,
0.0051381243,
-0.0882770047,
-0.0018790248,
-0.0126458816,
-0.0103643686,
0.0162483621,
-0.0739900693,
-0.0115450146,
-0.0217519533,
-0.0198512189,
-0.0285242815,
0.0030473655,
-0.0010432282,
0.0045468062,
0.0242441203,
-0.0028906355,
0.0247781333,
-0.0450766124,
0.0255369376,
0.0954466984,
0.0087401429,
-0.0225436129,
0.00535521,
-0.0302390028,
0.0016441392,
-0.0304353554,
0.0100910449,
0.070533745,
-0.0281298868,
-0.0018255586,
0.0038817786,
0.0535335913,
0.0058253626,
0.0022546418,
0.013371923,
0.024638528,
-0.0041496539,
-0.0168998428,
-0.0096230805,
-0.0336803645,
0.0610305592,
0.0387910567,
-0.0327440687,
-0.0710463673,
0.0066982,
-0.0830167755,
-0.0045105568,
-0.0060699284,
-0.0475416072,
-0.0214243233,
0.0151238283,
0.0024773923,
-0.0707479343,
0.0038695917,
-0.0313706025,
0.0037119314,
0.0058374438,
-0.0246903673,
-0.0142627526,
0.0112860473,
-0.0434676781,
-0.0060320492,
0.0291135795,
0.0374285579,
-0.05248693,
0.0041109328,
-0.0105198938,
-0.043234732,
-0.0395206138,
-0.0384951346,
-0.0145335011,
-0.0620119311,
-0.0195247121,
0.098702088,
0.0134842396,
0.0519319139,
-0.0375468656,
-0.0304970965,
0.0503812321,
0.0485421009,
0.0125483032,
0.0154875768,
0.0862051398,
-0.0105934571,
0.0004887682,
0.0160869844,
-0.0314958729,
0.0168151185,
0.0785849243,
-0.0548483506,
-0.025429491,
0.0552251004,
0.0099605024,
-0.0003594394,
0.0806489289,
0.0016187228,
0.013690128,
0.0219151508,
0.0279421341,
-0.0022364119,
-0.033901982,
0.0049847867,
-0.0291125793,
0.0124139497,
0.0299131498,
0.00171631,
-0.0429758765,
0.0696963146,
-0.0186165161,
-0.0492844619,
-0.0131330155,
0.0285580214,
0.0255729537,
0.0498426594,
0.0181629434,
-0.0119463829,
0.0083651291,
0.0322789885,
0.0486934073,
-0.0077129053,
0.006311208,
0.0196895339,
0.0043420554,
-0.0110857673,
0.0516212694,
-0.0387170985,
-0.0368667468,
0.0135873575,
-0.0388386324,
-0.022890076,
-0.0169307049,
-0.0077698329,
0.0053854715,
0.0135112545,
-0.0475185215,
-0.0450025313,
-0.0354246162,
-0.0163688399,
0.0001318685,
0.0196799543,
0.0193687547,
0.0437971689,
0.0600613467,
0.0057096481,
0.0361130349,
-0.0317123495,
-0.0403943695,
-0.0068173101,
-0.0051913173,
0.0005368529,
0.0389771014,
-0.0283234064,
-0.0674325824,
-0.0373000018,
-0.0563511886,
-0.0160047822,
0.0043370049,
0.0409791768,
-0.0089836791,
-0.0009868809,
0.0042447089,
0.0005351076,
0.0714980066,
-0.0747109354,
0.0095170969,
-0.0412976854,
-0.0801064298,
-0.0039185463,
-6.480785413e-33,
0.0646280199,
-0.0087451236,
-0.0470756553,
0.0202695616,
0.028484771,
-0.019554805,
0.0097077675,
-0.0259826835,
-0.0181875136,
-0.0255851895,
-0.0127568543,
-0.0130579509,
-0.0121404491,
0.0201343317,
-0.0329137258,
-0.0525319837,
-0.0049674013,
-0.0099258004,
-0.0529241711,
0.0377588086,
0.0907796025,
-0.0119150179,
-0.0087042963,
-0.0880534127,
0.0123218242,
0.0092144459,
-0.02218212,
-0.0029981327,
-0.0816916227,
0.053830836,
0.02387527,
0.0106337285,
-0.0200780611,
-0.0315761007,
0.0029611185,
0.036734838,
-0.0284094959,
-0.0148183992,
-0.0381282456,
-0.0343664587,
-0.0066746445,
-0.0423396863,
0.0236572344,
0.0216351561,
0.0044922009,
-0.0104558393,
0.0040469877,
0.0091189183,
-0.0221312363,
0.0070291567,
0.0257093441,
-0.0025842264,
-0.037759345,
-0.0107675465,
0.0302233137,
0.0474995263,
0.0196776036,
0.0299837533,
-0.0352024846,
0.0597059317,
-0.0170837436,
0.027799353,
0.0061107194,
-0.0107795456,
0.0110964356,
0.052818872,
0.021578189,
0.0026037956,
0.0212985743,
0.0012224682,
-0.0389413945,
0.0422369726,
0.0529022627,
0.0476167314,
0.0353767835,
-0.0471051261,
-0.0157896541,
0.0409058258,
0.0318858959,
-0.0621400923,
0.0523947291,
-0.0054150783,
-0.0760649443,
-0.0176632144,
-0.0158595461,
-0.0604986064,
-0.0532555394,
-0.0298759826,
0.0390051939,
0.041446913,
-0.0345037058,
-0.0103178024,
-0.0095123416,
-0.0589512438,
-0.0292431861,
0.0212190058,
-0.0117954491,
0.0020667161,
0.0012337947,
-0.0574689656,
-0.0256994292,
0.0319831446,
-0.0152743189,
-0.069047071,
0.0053188684,
0.017028749,
0.0329443738,
0.0208166372,
-0.0086588077,
-0.0177932959,
-0.0158815868,
0.0329001807,
-0.004535777,
0.0306681562,
0.0146885868,
-0.0020047049,
-0.005654172,
0.018092975,
0.0105665317,
0.0285849664,
-0.0735349804,
0.0050933491,
-0.0437095314,
-0.0096377395,
0.0269123819,
0.0059014326,
-0.0102335429,
0.0406444222,
-0.0040528704,
-0.0436659046,
0.0076294602,
-0.0518882573,
3.108e-7,
-0.0393635966,
0.016299041,
0.0053383219,
-0.0023850435,
0.021320641,
0.1097560972,
0.0237875711,
0.0923370793,
0.0200520903,
-0.0057467171,
-0.0181763545,
-0.015430416,
0.0130893048,
0.0256088283,
-0.0474954024,
-0.0043442752,
-0.0194334891,
0.0146446731,
-0.0353196412,
-0.0433077477,
0.0266361497,
0.0510904267,
0.054322321,
-0.0034984248,
-0.005979334,
0.0495834239,
0.0237469748,
-0.0497964546,
-0.0016566473,
-0.0575791299,
0.0249793418,
-0.030672349,
-0.0148485145,
0.0154971108,
-0.0565881431,
-0.0178869497,
-0.0512574725,
0.0079238163,
0.038402345,
-0.0610642545,
-0.0208316986,
0.0034774619,
0.036799904,
-0.0327589139,
0.0614098199,
-0.0075720898,
-0.0067787906,
-0.0092986664,
-0.0239886027,
-0.0248770099,
0.0386262052,
-0.0013933535,
-0.0246067625,
-0.0249650087,
-0.0062609264,
0.0441529751,
0.04775564,
-0.0835155919,
-0.0122022815,
-0.0004500904,
0.0112938052,
-0.0396596119,
0.0145459706,
0.09322346,
-0.0055991882,
-0.0096426895,
-0.0273230113,
3.125046222e-34,
-0.0222289618,
-0.0123032937,
-0.0019887881,
-0.0408907533,
0.0275916792,
-0.002870183,
0.0072300802,
-0.006271475,
0.0643299296,
-0.0123401182,
-0.0205017086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01917v1 | Whispering in Norwegian: Navigating Orthographic and Dialectic Challenges | 2024-02-02T21:38:12 | 2024-02-02T21:38:12 | Per E Kummervold, Javier de la Rosa, Freddy Wetjen, Rolv-Arild Braaten, Per Erik Solberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | This article introduces NB-Whisper, an adaptation of OpenAI's Whisper,
specifically fine-tuned for Norwegian language Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR). We highlight its key contributions and summarise the results achieved in
converting spoken Norwegian into written forms and translating other languages
into Norwegian. We show that we are able to improve the Norwegian Bokm{\aa}l
transcription by OpenAI Whisper Large-v3 from a WER of 10.4 to 6.6 on the
Fleurs Dataset and from 6.8 to 2.2 on the NST dataset. | [
0.0045909863,
0.0759970471,
0.0003104114,
0.0540458784,
-0.0365152285,
-0.02580381,
0.0253456272,
0.0115664098,
-0.0209579282,
-0.0097768428,
-0.0465621762,
-0.0232626554,
0.0643258765,
-0.0068478319,
0.034630727,
-0.0364520624,
0.0341832936,
-0.0904507414,
0.0055041686,
-0.0159949176,
-0.0241622552,
0.0200800691,
-0.0596648902,
0.057875637,
0.0173903517,
0.0035923491,
-0.0151617359,
0.0081769004,
0.0202181879,
0.0281851739,
-0.0116305845,
-0.0294411648,
-0.015129745,
0.0822434053,
0.0000019845,
-0.0120990407,
0.0184775665,
0.0039466661,
-0.0406043679,
0.0569703504,
0.0776641667,
0.0235104598,
-0.0159311593,
0.0106410859,
0.0214737318,
-0.030694576,
0.0681825578,
0.0128568318,
0.0176462624,
0.039400097,
-0.0000043622,
-0.0098218536,
0.0274345707,
-0.0100776516,
-0.0575421825,
-0.0234850477,
-0.0069821435,
-0.0229878109,
-0.0313374326,
-0.0158113409,
-0.0053139012,
0.0842038989,
-0.0234487765,
-0.0144294994,
-0.0167100839,
0.0129891699,
-0.046133507,
-0.0257590972,
-0.0109270541,
0.0647351816,
-0.002408528,
-0.0163333844,
0.0024877484,
-0.0039281887,
-0.0462838821,
-0.091500856,
0.0184310414,
-0.0297412444,
0.020653801,
-0.0173264034,
0.0293037836,
0.0248921961,
-0.0053731599,
-0.0241681132,
0.0206481759,
0.0027755997,
-0.0065922444,
-0.007944365,
0.0083017657,
-0.0323907733,
0.0349860601,
0.0117767118,
0.0040287389,
0.0178266354,
-0.0234069545,
-0.019179659,
0.0132068843,
-0.0605756529,
0.0300128479,
0.0059713433,
0.0540673621,
0.0261879116,
-0.0941157341,
-0.0120421089,
-0.0024038765,
0.020927811,
0.0021631969,
0.0037423067,
-0.0260986052,
-0.0113436561,
0.0434555747,
0.0166791398,
-0.0593755879,
-0.0405270569,
-0.047787901,
-0.0391968042,
-0.0165513624,
-0.053202033,
0.0245168675,
0.0036665914,
0.0440007895,
-0.045314081,
-0.0705563575,
0.0044280165,
0.0237356108,
0.0349682122,
0.0598186105,
0.0520074032,
-0.0530992448,
-0.0198764037,
0.0283175427,
0.031698484,
0.0441898108,
0.0265797079,
-0.0327438824,
0.0248681381,
-0.0212417282,
0.0012945397,
-0.009424123,
0.03487074,
-0.0204130244,
-0.0588096976,
-0.0426592231,
-0.0318523385,
0.0183774978,
-0.0310592633,
-0.0112637822,
-0.058794871,
0.0080810534,
-0.0340611152,
0.018497318,
0.0473382063,
-0.0270936601,
-0.0078858454,
0.0528132468,
-0.0055609387,
-0.0131702572,
0.0297030229,
0.0537231937,
-0.0089599397,
0.0102021843,
-0.0421046987,
-0.0030912145,
0.0941366777,
0.0394132733,
0.0144503461,
0.0002768181,
0.0056912866,
0.0018846742,
-0.0053552212,
0.0415887348,
0.0781416148,
0.0308234617,
-0.0280413013,
0.0332905166,
0.0623440854,
0.0542567223,
0.0286591016,
0.0357071869,
0.050521601,
-0.0250050034,
-0.0357930623,
-0.0040366035,
0.0160615575,
0.02404413,
-0.0050237942,
0.0448947996,
0.0278069656,
0.0231496189,
-0.00696145,
0.0002813052,
-0.0022927048,
-0.0154191954,
0.054961022,
-0.0046229078,
0.0146415653,
-0.0529266298,
0.0162110198,
0.0376862772,
-0.0809157118,
0.0402718522,
-0.0210923646,
0.0178182628,
-0.0078610871,
0.0027671577,
0.0088446876,
-0.0097418716,
-0.0530972295,
-0.0302330293,
0.023435561,
0.0305009261,
-0.0136485314,
0.0598026738,
-0.0552018955,
0.051984489,
0.0514555052,
-0.0231884085,
0.0733074471,
-0.0197474416,
0.0044461121,
-0.0175586231,
-0.0599707775,
-0.0508307777,
-0.0169025064,
-0.0334213562,
-0.0149616003,
0.0275461115,
0.0162385181,
0.0690249503,
0.0253190976,
-0.0312422346,
0.026829768,
0.0233092383,
-0.052720543,
0.0009974589,
0.0202267859,
0.0090690972,
-0.0075456873,
-0.001363875,
0.047879301,
-0.0136069246,
-0.0139352344,
0.0227563456,
-0.0595399924,
0.0769668743,
-0.0142097501,
0.0487008058,
0.007178368,
0.0008904587,
0.008655685,
0.0027970297,
0.0096086431,
-0.0338219292,
0.012961789,
-0.0348152705,
-0.0148167834,
0.0110830646,
0.009856659,
-0.0718536153,
-0.0210965872,
0.059237469,
-0.035049472,
0.0281598456,
-0.0220797118,
-0.0116753345,
0.0279385336,
-0.0180850513,
-0.0451639667,
-0.0089355065,
-0.0380273648,
0.0272879917,
-0.0163800865,
0.0669295713,
-0.0052469294,
-0.0193671975,
-0.0506382994,
0.047159858,
-0.0147687746,
-0.0415889136,
-0.0547091775,
0.0016355712,
-0.035573855,
-0.0177894402,
0.0095423898,
0.0068426612,
-0.0190284755,
-0.0380492657,
-0.0395311937,
-0.0911330804,
0.0741732046,
-0.0326825939,
0.0319158994,
-0.0057655792,
-0.0564624369,
-0.0088177072,
-0.0226294789,
0.0810580924,
0.0583415069,
-0.0645392612,
-0.0325597823,
0.0031065824,
-0.0069022919,
-0.0603499189,
0.0090673361,
0.0028857407,
0.0148432748,
-0.0054682335,
0.0211671311,
-0.0190776736,
0.0051810876,
0.0594403408,
0.0238483772,
-0.0069789463,
-0.0322355144,
-0.0218086224,
-0.0256151017,
-0.0199558549,
-0.0205808636,
-0.0064412919,
0.0641040802,
0.0051268293,
0.0066019082,
0.0122219715,
-0.0512206145,
-0.0304285921,
-0.0472601466,
-0.0262553077,
-0.01561346,
0.0333079696,
-0.0393982232,
0.0146543663,
0.0046917349,
-0.0642955378,
0.0524809994,
-0.0427290648,
0.0067639127,
-0.0131096151,
0.0201882068,
-0.0094378162,
-0.0058544171,
-0.0057369829,
-0.040371947,
0.0117524192,
-0.0100732725,
-0.0529534742,
0.0205486882,
0.0059108776,
-0.0385844409,
-0.0185943097,
0.0223630089,
-0.0391191356,
0.0354997031,
-0.0239891596,
0.0622371659,
-0.0420742631,
0.0004430274,
0.00232834,
-0.0002736015,
0.0196413752,
0.0504078828,
0.0738450512,
-0.0072874743,
0.0456110798,
0.0050918078,
-0.0445123874,
-0.0400325768,
0.0674227551,
0.0071613849,
0.0188685376,
0.0214611515,
0.0852402598,
-0.0125640351,
0.0111855939,
0.0328930579,
-0.0242950115,
0.00649649,
-0.0007448393,
0.016958762,
0.0728881508,
-0.0103624631,
0.0135943126,
-0.0597546138,
-0.0023248165,
0.0158421937,
0.0643343627,
0.0240551829,
0.0071891015,
-0.0215566438,
-0.0579377823,
0.072401993,
0.0526426323,
-0.0391793065,
0.0010146466,
-0.0422561057,
-0.0266432408,
-0.0817698464,
0.0192257483,
0.0325782746,
0.025128983,
-0.0470610633,
0.011433783,
-0.0243371837,
0.0052668331,
0.0131390505,
-0.0280666128,
0.0823885575,
0.0296618249,
0.0249028727,
-0.0078648133,
-0.0886327475,
0.0599125512,
0.0159297623,
-0.0194379501,
-0.0196476094,
0.0283739865,
0.0314086527,
-0.0159717947,
-0.0390282422,
0.0630438775,
-0.0055410941,
-0.0020511395,
0.0347950496,
0.0148203829,
-0.0327627659,
0.0137877474,
0.048590932,
0.0523368716,
0.0521848276,
-0.0185715798,
0.0367359668,
-0.0191581491,
-0.0016086206,
-0.0124916323,
0.0013209822,
-0.0087172361,
0.0108854091,
-0.0159548428,
0.0149868177,
-0.0035461893,
-0.0017925565,
-0.0120770764,
0.0034318028,
0.0028978868,
0.0553480946,
0.0064540454,
0.0578255989,
0.0205603298,
-0.0148352953,
-0.0488346629,
-0.0153805371,
0.0081270896,
-0.0217884183,
-0.0157989282,
0.0739143193,
-0.0111818044,
0.037370868,
-0.0079396721,
-0.1055242047,
-0.0677118525,
0.0307342578,
0.0237646233,
0.0129215214,
0.0539655872,
-0.0190442335,
-0.0211938098,
0.0027195076,
-0.0229958463,
-0.0492088012,
0.0037315395,
0.026340235,
0.0257817563,
0.0247587506,
0.0409151502,
0.0126079321,
-0.0007632516,
-0.0081375884,
-0.0283420067,
0.0089612203,
-0.0699521005,
-0.0495487824,
0.0149244573,
0.023515163,
-0.0335351229,
-0.0178960096,
-0.0744136497,
0.0016430374,
0.0171868037,
0.0212515406,
-0.0092955595,
0.0264257733,
0.0369216762,
0.0312877931,
-0.0270036943,
0.0203623492,
-0.0662197769,
0.0136667276,
-0.0563623793,
0.0667411014,
0.0381374806,
0.0352182128,
0.0373525918,
0.0324206911,
-0.0487206616,
0.1041862071,
-0.0087112375,
0.0482679792,
0.0110023385,
-0.0152309705,
-0.0273193438,
0.0251937825,
0.0017538249,
0.0025449633,
-0.0500287898,
-0.0216939729,
0.0155627104,
-0.002525918,
0.0478921123,
0.029055316,
0.0854365677,
-0.0146380346,
0.0285403058,
0.0216898229,
0.0448876321,
-0.0603919998,
-0.0225444045,
-0.0143557005,
-0.0078266412,
-0.0033208223,
0.0491300337,
-0.0148359481,
-0.0210484974,
0.0413105972,
0.0664232895,
0.039189931,
-0.0504348427,
-0.0563206263,
0.0535635389,
0.0257984549,
-0.0678909272,
0.0021796532,
0.0123465816,
-0.0375339277,
-0.0148991328,
0.0003581528,
0.0020886711,
-0.0050158631,
-0.0371683277,
-0.0023235802,
0.0107368417,
-0.032846909,
-0.051232852,
-0.0415360443,
-0.0079211062,
-0.0649843439,
0.0337547511,
-6.298780684e-33,
-0.0100362347,
0.0151845822,
-0.0020060809,
0.0758177713,
-0.0115783047,
-0.0063623423,
-0.0090890313,
0.0042443001,
0.0047529945,
-0.0092663467,
-0.0192793086,
-0.0501352921,
0.0267009884,
-0.0091827577,
-0.0327403694,
-0.0038375841,
0.050519336,
-0.005158165,
0.0152832428,
0.0178560168,
0.0176677257,
0.0306757893,
0.0487068668,
-0.0617291927,
0.0391240939,
0.0146870567,
-0.0509083904,
-0.0066768252,
0.01379182,
-0.0047138608,
-0.0153229684,
0.0361988917,
-0.0312325396,
0.0502781086,
-0.0426641032,
-0.0061283759,
-0.0719917864,
0.0458587222,
0.02578618,
0.077859059,
-0.0189797431,
-0.0267723817,
-0.0054144873,
-0.0428740531,
-0.0857818574,
-0.0036010623,
-0.0181749556,
-0.0059060804,
-0.0053918902,
-0.0090887537,
-0.0328611024,
0.0015086824,
-0.0314427912,
-0.064625226,
0.0657931194,
0.0283299536,
-0.0113301817,
-0.1465186328,
-0.1205214635,
0.0547973067,
0.0089105451,
0.0420667976,
-0.0089141475,
-0.006956168,
-0.0823529214,
-0.0001369338,
0.0669183284,
-0.0326744393,
-0.0022424757,
-0.0159053374,
0.0637897253,
0.0067571774,
0.019564772,
0.012670421,
0.0326719023,
-0.058789961,
-0.0096737407,
-0.0211476441,
0.021804953,
-0.0032994805,
0.0361085311,
0.0309338924,
-0.0053909905,
-0.0246789679,
-0.0477966703,
-0.1136285514,
-0.0288287271,
0.0026666638,
0.0347752571,
-0.0230882261,
0.0067429165,
-0.0152109368,
0.0936534926,
-0.0033322687,
0.0068154801,
-0.0301226769,
0.0201960523,
-0.0200048611,
-0.0446778387,
0.0164760333,
-0.0045883032,
-0.0262869038,
0.0350362659,
0.0516527481,
0.0315898806,
-0.0142351529,
0.0280931238,
0.0227763895,
-0.0280195903,
0.0219173338,
-0.014392022,
0.0392031036,
0.0301362257,
0.0067173657,
0.0178211648,
-0.0453177541,
0.0283803865,
0.0333037749,
-0.0072062174,
0.0176750105,
-0.0255760998,
0.0127872312,
-0.0152177839,
0.0110853687,
-0.097282432,
-0.0024624595,
-0.0133916559,
-0.0360655226,
-0.0015385245,
0.0061449618,
0.0047136834,
-0.0107872952,
2.638e-7,
-0.0231804345,
0.0230479166,
0.0297109969,
-0.0464535505,
0.0292079281,
-0.0205433369,
0.0070731812,
0.0179792121,
0.0061957063,
0.0597323179,
0.0123190796,
-0.008823555,
0.0747278333,
0.0227855686,
-0.0823948458,
-0.0492143854,
-0.0149003454,
0.0030215587,
-0.0649045482,
-0.0034218666,
0.0076079201,
0.0707662851,
-0.0429601409,
-0.0161198601,
-0.0201157667,
0.0130428271,
-0.0123209693,
-0.018702874,
0.0105728796,
-0.0033590803,
-0.0031204724,
0.0101522608,
0.0212153401,
-0.0268686861,
-0.0199192092,
0.0042329873,
0.0019850377,
0.0396956652,
0.0146377301,
-0.060357973,
0.0231124796,
0.0616303757,
-0.0065877647,
-0.0454754941,
-0.0145661784,
0.0124644898,
-0.0695810392,
-0.0099369138,
0.040003974,
0.0537271611,
0.016928643,
-0.0226620585,
0.0546087436,
0.0224465057,
0.0348139517,
-0.0290195122,
-0.0405093692,
0.0068214457,
-0.0715751275,
-0.0002184037,
-0.0054540019,
-0.0149698518,
0.0111226235,
0.0123299621,
-0.0298638213,
-0.0206855573,
0.0034285029,
1.990899884e-34,
0.0174043328,
-0.0158083048,
0.0157178696,
0.027416965,
0.0366341695,
-0.0268831719,
0.0443164073,
0.0468713827,
-0.0113103474,
-0.0292484555,
-0.0708543062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01916v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01916v1 | CoLe and LYS at BioASQ MESINESP8 Task: similarity based descriptor assignment in Spanish | 2024-02-02T21:36:03 | 2024-02-02T21:36:03 | Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Shuyuan Cao, Elmurod Kuriyozov | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68P20, 68T50, H.3.3; I.2.7 | In this paper, we describe our participation in the MESINESP Task of the
BioASQ biomedical semantic indexing challenge. The participating system follows
an approach based solely on conventional information retrieval tools. We have
evaluated various alternatives for extracting index terms from IBECS/LILACS
documents in order to be stored in an Apache Lucene index. Those indexed
representations are queried using the contents of the article to be annotated
and a ranked list of candidate labels is created from the retrieved documents.
We also have evaluated a sort of limited Label Powerset approach which creates
meta-labels joining pairs of DeCS labels with high co-occurrence scores, and an
alternative method based on label profile matching. Results obtained in
official runs seem to confirm the suitability of this approach for languages
like Spanish. | [
-0.0046706968,
0.0148999132,
-0.0121174715,
-0.0390501358,
-0.0257444717,
0.0328777879,
-0.0093495315,
0.0355357863,
0.00175615,
-0.0501422398,
-0.0257091559,
0.0292087328,
-0.0327189304,
0.0102139395,
-0.0009246031,
0.0051821489,
0.0646296218,
0.0526542664,
-0.0166621506,
-0.018702155,
0.0006282593,
-0.0138994884,
-0.0178754088,
0.0083502168,
0.0178460404,
0.0392877199,
0.0362468399,
-0.0419541113,
0.0425144061,
-0.0810257271,
0.0099340742,
0.0242940485,
-0.0337669924,
0.0359980613,
0.0000016919,
-0.0769627392,
-0.0754659772,
0.0451176018,
0.033877328,
-0.0405749939,
0.0411979221,
-0.0131525015,
0.01978397,
-0.006135297,
0.0078749666,
-0.0524745286,
0.0690115392,
-0.044334352,
0.0212210231,
0.007563835,
-0.0230670199,
-0.0486810729,
-0.0063453852,
0.0114555601,
0.0401847027,
-0.0429912359,
0.0170544386,
-0.0326467007,
0.0720720887,
0.0073844567,
0.052892305,
0.0180361941,
-0.0498734005,
-0.0011253328,
0.0249339473,
0.0265485849,
-0.0258008353,
-0.0291154254,
0.0425873622,
0.0087331478,
0.0276096109,
-0.0600608252,
0.0098976949,
0.0235352963,
-0.0394450314,
0.027916763,
-0.0162351802,
-0.0253494214,
-0.011136611,
-0.0103790471,
0.0645452216,
0.0746486485,
0.0083304904,
0.0171556436,
-0.0009367522,
0.028466614,
0.0355206132,
-0.0369166099,
0.0407269672,
-0.0118737603,
0.0362980552,
-0.0099673448,
0.0457331948,
0.0253845807,
-0.0019369384,
-0.006274587,
0.0435840376,
-0.0608730391,
0.0828484595,
-0.075218752,
-0.0644612461,
-0.0077434308,
-0.014194767,
0.0251484178,
-0.0171014182,
0.0177614558,
0.0104972357,
0.0584242977,
-0.0376313552,
-0.0459389351,
-0.0801052675,
-0.0102569237,
-0.0473847762,
0.0488773622,
0.0392937697,
0.0165381096,
-0.063879922,
-0.0435055383,
-0.0367309749,
-0.0248394106,
0.0089621823,
0.0159722492,
-0.0207422581,
0.043909885,
-0.0465435833,
0.0239923727,
-0.0160270892,
-0.0241842214,
-0.058514066,
-0.0386902019,
0.0334238596,
0.0221057851,
0.0117061054,
-0.0522346497,
0.044503361,
0.0380781144,
0.0069407844,
-0.0497906432,
0.0239099618,
-0.0281427354,
-0.0119472705,
-0.0128651671,
-0.0023783133,
-0.066049248,
0.0478628278,
-0.0033265001,
0.0074303234,
-0.0721902028,
0.0241169296,
0.0117593119,
0.0092614023,
0.0742405504,
-0.057737086,
-0.0271740556,
0.0189745873,
0.0132097481,
0.0159769692,
0.013274895,
-0.0189166516,
0.000603947,
0.0179765187,
-0.0164121948,
-0.0172183793,
-0.0201342534,
-0.0135702742,
-0.0197320636,
0.0152667593,
0.0094880043,
0.0622296929,
0.1023257747,
0.0074752253,
0.042568922,
-0.0120581826,
-0.0079061408,
-0.0066991434,
0.0956098586,
-0.0041472511,
-0.0062010675,
-0.0131196314,
-0.0208233688,
0.0093170926,
-0.0897828937,
0.0119631942,
-0.0206776839,
0.0371814668,
0.0129621439,
0.0045954399,
0.0299816877,
-0.0081388336,
-0.0016630179,
-0.0109702749,
0.0410391837,
-0.0352219157,
-0.0228710938,
0.0356205367,
-0.0260500424,
0.0348197445,
0.0265958197,
0.0056377416,
-0.0234864485,
0.0024755385,
-0.0138423331,
-0.0463529229,
0.0426384024,
0.0381519161,
-0.0449229889,
-0.0574628189,
0.0398536921,
-0.0283544958,
0.0074201142,
-0.0150797861,
-0.0448599644,
-0.0129518546,
-0.0279480238,
-0.0129117072,
0.0562132522,
-0.0257180836,
0.0136254402,
-0.0501363426,
0.0622336231,
-0.0234780759,
-0.0563745312,
-0.0203447584,
0.0398538373,
-0.0234231371,
-0.0347961187,
-0.003499185,
-0.0064017032,
0.0360585116,
0.0372936502,
0.0173845533,
0.0200864058,
0.0674611777,
-0.0521818101,
0.0029302114,
-0.0017435534,
0.0380175859,
0.0219195932,
0.0586615168,
-0.0642159581,
0.0042633824,
0.0020055166,
0.0238919202,
-0.0188543964,
-0.004653024,
-0.0128030758,
0.0119709466,
-0.0260554664,
0.0575137325,
-0.0284653101,
-0.0158979036,
-0.0596275479,
0.0228441842,
0.0200323779,
0.0517679565,
-0.0183524918,
-0.0811698139,
0.026778983,
-0.0619629323,
-0.0020329694,
0.0438482799,
0.049548775,
-0.0139481742,
0.0227570292,
0.02841115,
0.0034162749,
0.0178825632,
-0.06118007,
0.0118946182,
0.0387847573,
0.0268827323,
0.0436337031,
-0.0216122512,
0.0157739818,
-0.0042114914,
-0.047207322,
-0.0404402986,
0.0067498866,
0.0042131771,
0.0242372844,
0.0227460675,
-0.0002013986,
-0.0195854083,
0.0033648864,
-0.0431642048,
0.0142871989,
0.0059917117,
-0.065649569,
0.0171024203,
-0.0130830575,
-0.0420002043,
0.0031014027,
0.028091643,
-0.0202785805,
-0.0082378294,
0.0360262543,
-0.0459088273,
0.0025727821,
0.0137845892,
0.005639785,
0.0824381709,
0.0343377851,
-0.0234699994,
-0.0082586696,
-0.0395956486,
0.0318459459,
-0.0020285193,
-0.0751614049,
0.0647013336,
0.0134039549,
-0.0405454822,
-0.0157218669,
-0.010442337,
-0.0190095715,
-0.0067812754,
-0.0466121845,
-0.0562607832,
0.0482299104,
-0.0064167962,
0.0524060018,
0.0065095429,
-0.0442637838,
0.0510020778,
-0.0244500507,
0.0224545915,
-0.0963429138,
-0.0063584591,
-0.0477722175,
0.0488407314,
-0.0057620425,
0.0350493267,
-0.00469684,
0.0072446964,
0.0361182317,
0.0257340707,
0.0021336207,
-0.058944501,
-0.0114254598,
-0.0149793262,
0.0289996043,
0.0058066654,
-0.0512031391,
-0.0029500453,
0.0517183617,
-0.0334882773,
0.0127250589,
0.0556474328,
0.0089572659,
-0.0554472059,
0.0661735982,
0.0430997089,
0.0067477627,
0.0056958585,
-0.0061854138,
0.0065789707,
0.0024589705,
0.0194671042,
-0.0359477475,
0.0086901598,
0.0170152802,
-0.0126515236,
0.0298013538,
-0.0152909253,
-0.009630356,
0.0246512555,
0.0192198306,
0.0486132391,
-0.0344585143,
-0.0059066829,
-0.0321623012,
-0.0116222091,
0.0080003235,
-0.0392175391,
0.0508838892,
0.0713454112,
-0.0935581774,
-0.0170650259,
-0.0121073443,
-0.0203298628,
0.0403237343,
0.0510137565,
-0.0539057627,
0.0054850904,
0.0177250225,
0.0289645195,
-0.0220126938,
-0.0204763003,
-0.0147729218,
-0.0551304705,
0.0248604137,
0.0077806693,
-0.0297379326,
-0.0184360202,
-0.0733160004,
-0.0001535555,
-0.041083239,
-0.0465045758,
0.0013710014,
0.0040662671,
-0.0044105253,
0.0452031568,
-0.0037406657,
-0.0414617881,
-0.0142350337,
-0.0239515603,
-0.0309984069,
0.0141682485,
0.0496335179,
-0.0001991063,
-0.0561978668,
0.0001177458,
-0.0469194688,
-0.0484723635,
-0.0196357071,
-0.0010474457,
-0.001644237,
-0.0083907861,
-0.0314317197,
-0.0223531164,
-0.039912194,
-0.0109916693,
0.0143749965,
0.0957527906,
-0.0320558697,
0.0430750735,
-0.0530777015,
-0.0346168689,
-0.0420945808,
0.0164088048,
-0.0030667731,
0.0060705356,
0.0033316687,
0.0284573901,
0.0583201535,
-0.0020840971,
-0.0286944881,
0.0271196924,
-0.1038714424,
-0.0390583165,
-0.0388504863,
-0.0311778914,
0.041866526,
0.0317010656,
0.0497173481,
0.0287640952,
0.0139965704,
-0.0139115304,
-0.0445116237,
0.0251662862,
0.0164659414,
0.0194557607,
-0.071879819,
-0.0761043429,
0.0651011765,
0.0293665193,
-0.0466945469,
-0.0190880578,
0.0428846627,
-0.0364550799,
0.0208779573,
-0.005555613,
0.0167239029,
-0.0151653225,
-0.0232042279,
-0.0437468626,
0.0354327597,
0.0602735095,
-0.015777532,
-0.0288333073,
-0.0402931981,
-0.0521302037,
-0.0295012891,
-0.0206464101,
-0.0097760241,
0.0662938431,
-0.0444395505,
0.0708580762,
-0.0012468123,
-0.0744641274,
0.0773240998,
0.0456354842,
0.0678885356,
-0.0654543862,
-0.0070304773,
-0.0293886159,
-0.0095738014,
0.0055687972,
-0.0063974829,
0.0281171054,
-0.0221151765,
0.0112313265,
0.029118007,
0.003649449,
0.0780555308,
-0.0135748871,
-0.0033852879,
0.0176872145,
0.042142082,
0.0117630335,
0.0817525983,
-0.0432299413,
0.0082939146,
0.015020825,
-0.0109489113,
-0.0087566571,
0.0323582329,
-0.0874451473,
-0.0269157179,
0.0365429409,
0.0201499928,
-0.0113502108,
0.064201422,
-0.0144295059,
0.0353844836,
-0.0263909698,
-0.036766436,
0.048128318,
-0.0003684881,
-0.0044317688,
0.0172644481,
-0.042195797,
-0.0121316491,
-0.0015299483,
-0.033340577,
0.0414879136,
0.0417941287,
0.0274647605,
-0.0108339479,
-0.0391016155,
0.0506732613,
0.0131388865,
0.018690411,
0.0064220908,
-0.0601094291,
0.02344325,
-0.0028912574,
-0.0029138208,
0.0129190218,
-0.0384683609,
-0.0740185753,
-0.0603829399,
0.0092379106,
0.0932908133,
-0.0026651148,
-0.0252975486,
0.0273639224,
0.0600460544,
0.0274405666,
0.0262621697,
-0.0426056124,
-0.0056775804,
0.0010707089,
-0.0463970713,
-0.0222091824,
0.0319021083,
-5.861868536e-33,
-0.0013917364,
-0.0566451885,
0.0183128212,
-0.0054889629,
0.0160520617,
0.000332226,
-0.0027987433,
-0.0407916307,
0.0470141359,
0.0558746196,
0.0083307279,
-0.0491610095,
0.0184024256,
-0.0334792286,
0.0318533555,
0.032731507,
-0.0053415536,
0.0297809429,
-0.0036240912,
-0.0185209196,
0.0400944948,
0.0270162579,
0.0649736673,
-0.1106944308,
-0.0095390538,
0.0443219617,
0.0358802862,
0.0204241481,
0.0548308045,
0.0576212965,
-0.0333842859,
0.0317065157,
0.0022906305,
-0.0060938303,
0.0287608523,
-0.0377058238,
-0.0491230898,
-0.0452327691,
-0.0165805928,
-0.0013343811,
0.0268407073,
-0.050524231,
-0.0100573367,
-0.0237516109,
-0.0679178089,
0.057443101,
0.0459918976,
-0.0077626635,
-0.0485259891,
-0.0472807102,
-0.0206746459,
0.0280857366,
0.0579454191,
0.0578576066,
0.0709835365,
0.0023054944,
-0.0529962294,
0.0376033261,
0.0314848125,
0.0502008125,
-0.0280783307,
0.047380209,
0.0090049403,
-0.0065810387,
0.02275653,
0.0513095446,
0.0324598663,
-0.0732857212,
0.0876911134,
0.0416686125,
-0.0094220424,
0.0025309417,
0.0257992353,
0.0699984953,
0.0151081923,
0.0072027985,
-0.0269905981,
0.0639654398,
-0.0488150492,
-0.0050134929,
-0.0390528105,
0.0264485851,
-0.0204358716,
-0.0040327339,
-0.0308909565,
0.0559831299,
-0.0214778464,
-0.024184972,
0.0108921574,
-0.0364884324,
-0.0095892064,
0.0648575276,
-0.0085278824,
0.0226851013,
-0.0040686172,
-0.0531013012,
0.0562961996,
0.0173225123,
-0.0386274606,
0.0178176574,
-0.0385074466,
-0.0592642538,
0.031726826,
0.012043939,
0.060029991,
-0.034315031,
0.0281921998,
-0.0342469439,
-0.0275071282,
0.0112852687,
-0.0014607819,
-0.0369660631,
-0.0155473268,
-0.0047656009,
-0.017099455,
0.0150042567,
0.0456778631,
0.0331614204,
0.0663488805,
0.025896715,
-0.0045570419,
-0.0529317372,
0.0222603623,
0.0300664622,
-0.0353887267,
0.0282149483,
-0.0590607747,
0.0294113327,
-0.0163837522,
-0.0416849628,
0.0092013711,
-0.0168892592,
2.791e-7,
0.0503513515,
0.0427117161,
0.0161641762,
0.0119005144,
0.0137135088,
-0.0310841668,
-0.0109829251,
0.0154756214,
-0.0501680411,
0.0268732719,
0.0396233276,
-0.0172031652,
-0.0074354573,
0.0793868229,
-0.0351830013,
-0.0215670969,
-0.0257709119,
-0.0555315316,
-0.0377970524,
0.0113048879,
0.0406614691,
0.0461360887,
-0.0132454475,
0.0041615646,
-0.0030380553,
-0.0222848915,
0.0178281385,
-0.0399690047,
0.0084470846,
0.0174856037,
0.0066873585,
0.0090338886,
0.0244294982,
0.0178076942,
0.0049635759,
-0.0236993078,
0.034187749,
-0.0206407607,
-0.087211892,
-0.0096517643,
0.02542983,
-0.0006485541,
0.0135080796,
-0.0254360028,
0.0020007163,
-0.0195260849,
-0.0398781076,
-0.0200947952,
-0.0530019365,
0.0254045501,
-0.0053192894,
0.0083807884,
-0.0661548153,
0.044322297,
0.0207695775,
0.0335953645,
-0.0364224128,
-0.0454731919,
0.0369508602,
0.0554639325,
0.000606193,
-0.0196920615,
-0.0214038566,
0.0105589535,
0.0162716135,
-0.0365300365,
0.0019961784,
2.202215887e-34,
0.0020615985,
-0.0043538073,
-0.0348146372,
0.0056452891,
0.0003087513,
-0.0219885036,
-0.0244458206,
0.0317488685,
-0.0211504903,
-0.0209542699,
0.0109578148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01912v1 | Natural language guidance of high-fidelity text-to-speech with synthetic annotations | 2024-02-02T21:29:34 | 2024-02-02T21:29:34 | Dan Lyth, Simon King | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Text-to-speech models trained on large-scale datasets have demonstrated
impressive in-context learning capabilities and naturalness. However, control
of speaker identity and style in these models typically requires conditioning
on reference speech recordings, limiting creative applications. Alternatively,
natural language prompting of speaker identity and style has demonstrated
promising results and provides an intuitive method of control. However,
reliance on human-labeled descriptions prevents scaling to large datasets. Our
work bridges the gap between these two approaches. We propose a scalable method
for labeling various aspects of speaker identity, style, and recording
conditions. We then apply this method to a 45k hour dataset, which we use to
train a speech language model. Furthermore, we propose simple methods for
increasing audio fidelity, significantly outperforming recent work despite
relying entirely on found data. Our results demonstrate high-fidelity speech
generation in a diverse range of accents, prosodic styles, channel conditions,
and acoustic conditions, all accomplished with a single model and intuitive
natural language conditioning. Audio samples can be heard at
https://text-description-to-speech.com/. | [
0.0054173497,
0.0926796272,
0.023935128,
-0.0016495388,
0.0134670204,
-0.0171660073,
0.047401268,
-0.0261055287,
-0.0401919819,
-0.0300533194,
-0.0604372434,
-0.0449314527,
0.0128363781,
0.048421558,
0.0495172925,
-0.0887011364,
-0.0118581308,
-0.0375325866,
0.0073128049,
-0.0248162262,
0.0162317585,
0.0264445767,
-0.0327421986,
0.0360617824,
-0.0436108187,
-0.0004236405,
0.0057749487,
0.0347854085,
0.0463218614,
0.0218714569,
-0.0032153046,
0.0559173562,
0.0427614525,
0.0024564106,
0.0000020185,
-0.0199405607,
-0.0119030336,
-0.0102284765,
-0.0353982039,
0.0178568251,
0.0263276584,
0.0350494385,
-0.0428990908,
0.0120794792,
-0.0148709202,
-0.0095232315,
0.0484816618,
0.0340655483,
0.0745527819,
0.072726585,
0.0051729991,
-0.0820307806,
0.0027538796,
-0.0121828448,
0.0127237234,
0.0236188993,
-0.0206963606,
-0.0384149365,
-0.0023257444,
0.0023655726,
0.0349923633,
0.0404298194,
0.0101596052,
-0.0023434581,
0.0687672123,
0.0135536063,
-0.0444720462,
-0.0039670449,
0.0139230015,
0.077791363,
0.030567633,
-0.0177896582,
0.0226988476,
0.0400770344,
-0.0186414756,
-0.0528762825,
0.0247645359,
0.0253179166,
0.0019325165,
-0.0048147957,
-0.0577118546,
0.0598762594,
0.0237849765,
-0.0360071771,
0.0347093046,
-0.0258527547,
0.0044403896,
-0.0198277608,
0.0007184809,
-0.0183629151,
-0.0445732661,
-0.0198432133,
0.0424364768,
-0.0180123355,
-0.0274930131,
-0.0207994208,
-0.0540207103,
-0.0282731783,
-0.0431674421,
-0.02375824,
0.0388653576,
0.0376732014,
-0.0166890062,
-0.0086132204,
0.0059222057,
0.0156824663,
-0.0125202406,
-0.0235467143,
-0.020502286,
0.0048882663,
-0.0213368982,
0.0056033609,
-0.0362572968,
-0.0251756962,
-0.0269226246,
-0.0026995449,
-0.0451993793,
-0.0249454714,
-0.0478088856,
0.0266603231,
-0.0024819355,
0.0317607969,
-0.074856028,
-0.0142544676,
0.0043289987,
-0.020825766,
-0.0235292986,
0.0235180408,
0.0036446436,
-0.0485814363,
-0.0013559149,
0.0405442715,
0.0354491994,
-0.0023174416,
0.0289401505,
0.0122192698,
-0.0105426256,
0.003998606,
-0.037573427,
-0.0324886553,
-0.0290889926,
-0.0493851043,
-0.0245342366,
-0.0791670233,
0.0287915375,
-0.0317891277,
-0.0127788009,
-0.0460510328,
-0.0092860125,
0.0051876856,
0.0180518609,
0.0392154939,
-0.0135319661,
0.0327905454,
0.047013469,
-0.0043086819,
0.0075085666,
-0.0053878687,
0.0594535843,
-0.0012496656,
-0.0133138718,
-0.0425842367,
0.0400014631,
0.0700539574,
0.0326849036,
0.0129014384,
-0.0136297969,
-0.0354861952,
-0.0025517347,
0.0606095493,
0.0789058432,
0.0163712036,
0.0025932749,
-0.0157652851,
0.0936448872,
0.0015181892,
0.0144481109,
0.0279399958,
0.0849406868,
0.0567523167,
0.002743904,
-0.0229405556,
-0.0415156111,
0.0039751627,
0.0361007601,
0.0215992052,
0.0613366589,
0.0173516646,
-0.036240764,
-0.0123970918,
0.0255545694,
-0.013857414,
-0.0321513005,
0.0036325934,
-0.0378996842,
0.0497344472,
-0.0032791994,
0.0225261822,
0.0061394805,
-0.0605333857,
0.0301615689,
0.0107962471,
-0.0167031419,
0.0786157846,
-0.0261348449,
0.0127882557,
0.0634476766,
-0.0596715063,
0.0212897509,
0.0556057058,
0.0160235781,
-0.0174823422,
0.050022196,
-0.0553754531,
0.0179499816,
0.0148907974,
-0.0015669686,
0.0260967985,
-0.0093464144,
0.0202843864,
0.0149682555,
-0.0429407842,
0.0047836863,
-0.0062643574,
-0.0365814753,
-0.0755787492,
0.0354147293,
0.0182812642,
0.0044449721,
0.0567618199,
-0.0501274616,
0.0054479796,
-0.0012000408,
-0.0320013687,
0.0013864472,
0.0470482185,
-0.0804795772,
0.0019022351,
-0.0057458063,
-0.052337449,
0.009398655,
0.0089760488,
0.0066529149,
-0.0835636854,
0.0352083221,
-0.0438180938,
0.0256110802,
-0.0140704922,
0.0132785728,
0.0386687517,
0.0065467735,
0.0053385622,
0.0262528174,
0.0432361811,
-0.0278268978,
0.0204787757,
0.0337458216,
-0.0288322493,
-0.074275136,
0.0152782667,
-0.0356286727,
0.0058983671,
0.0446361825,
-0.0188298952,
-0.0217633303,
-0.040672522,
0.0029127854,
-0.0436882935,
0.0039407681,
-0.0298686009,
0.0039944639,
0.003163842,
0.0091373539,
-0.0192884784,
-0.0297290161,
-0.0942142308,
-0.0780673474,
-0.0086828945,
-0.037780825,
-0.0165527686,
-0.0070420471,
-0.022800304,
-0.0188617595,
0.0117531894,
0.004026453,
-0.0066791191,
0.0053847167,
0.0114100501,
-0.0370897464,
-0.01136545,
-0.0066135875,
0.0274464134,
0.0063164015,
0.0208848808,
-0.0254020151,
0.0323508158,
0.064253144,
0.0147873284,
0.0220549703,
-0.0438659489,
0.0177342836,
0.0083157793,
-0.0437086597,
0.0116694774,
0.0078231357,
0.0546750166,
-0.014121362,
-0.0241374746,
0.0254573915,
0.0013342791,
0.0436047278,
0.0238531195,
-0.0383100472,
0.0204767399,
-0.0006477549,
-0.0196840633,
0.0289987214,
-0.0207194984,
-0.0284936856,
0.0181812122,
-0.0062696147,
-0.0066330102,
0.0573720299,
-0.0520082153,
-0.0349727497,
-0.0098155821,
-0.0589014664,
0.0128221028,
0.0029860779,
-0.0125652831,
0.0476897284,
0.0083252909,
-0.0029280449,
-0.0053998744,
-0.0030979819,
0.0589425117,
-0.0484802462,
0.0108215325,
-0.0272220857,
0.0183524154,
-0.0047658817,
-0.063369818,
-0.0393095687,
-0.0606167801,
-0.0314199217,
-0.0143227428,
0.0352344327,
-0.0455156118,
-0.0039955638,
0.0094146701,
0.0224709976,
0.0559731871,
-0.0237064026,
0.0091761574,
-0.0303183123,
0.0259160958,
0.0296463426,
0.0511167012,
-0.0334980004,
-0.0101305023,
0.0206391532,
-0.0070242905,
0.0273467228,
0.0507834144,
-0.0592233874,
-0.0042851386,
0.0051429337,
0.0112668313,
-0.0376452394,
0.0272917803,
0.0565926544,
-0.0422985479,
-0.0167310126,
0.1059156433,
-0.005854731,
-0.0230287388,
-0.0031519451,
0.0066137044,
0.0765611902,
0.0106960582,
0.0178073831,
-0.075390622,
-0.0339286551,
0.0303638503,
0.0860533565,
-0.0073590283,
-0.0048132427,
-0.0414675064,
-0.0893965065,
0.0515450053,
0.0372011103,
-0.0732966512,
-0.0402320288,
-0.0596991889,
-0.034841042,
-0.0203348212,
0.0117283249,
0.0190031752,
-0.0051969257,
0.0051645585,
0.0466838852,
-0.02114732,
-0.0589566864,
0.0250205286,
-0.0631713793,
0.1158649549,
0.0616266318,
0.0379261971,
0.0190674812,
-0.0370774269,
-0.0323493704,
0.026801005,
-0.0046279719,
0.019804772,
0.0756595731,
-0.0234876387,
-0.0107084587,
-0.0155747654,
0.106272392,
0.0128995338,
0.0211868174,
0.0006432783,
-0.0207851883,
-0.0082328338,
0.006512179,
0.0257099252,
0.0742976665,
0.0475995727,
0.0520206839,
0.0290733874,
-0.0775046572,
0.0069591547,
-0.0111897793,
0.0628572926,
-0.0698469952,
-0.05920716,
0.0389460996,
-0.0183169674,
-0.0373651944,
-0.0628925338,
-0.0062936218,
-0.0251615848,
0.039930094,
0.0197784305,
-0.046586819,
-0.0038932345,
-0.0056825448,
-0.0313810818,
0.0538251139,
-0.0652539432,
0.0567307509,
-0.0172314588,
-0.0195840355,
0.0324282497,
-0.0722811967,
0.0021573205,
0.0631245971,
-0.0395411067,
-0.0379058942,
0.0211318098,
0.0142301014,
0.0152524747,
0.1212079376,
-0.0142585021,
-0.0612634495,
0.0164486635,
0.0337631926,
-0.0046807118,
-0.0105897151,
0.0610523634,
0.0291496664,
-0.0186613649,
0.0165829472,
-0.0323982425,
0.0725484863,
0.0010977683,
-0.0106359357,
-0.0075622071,
-0.0461496562,
0.0024364658,
0.0169531256,
0.0203934908,
-0.0320972539,
0.0656887516,
-0.025666127,
-0.0262688659,
-0.0040510688,
-0.0143799996,
-0.0419325046,
-0.0059228288,
0.033810854,
0.0488308705,
-0.0035147173,
-0.0103856651,
0.0036110661,
0.0041084518,
-0.0265940186,
-0.0302514657,
0.0172884297,
-0.0058656898,
0.0057491348,
0.0173740033,
-0.0288347974,
0.0634983107,
0.0132144066,
0.050677076,
0.0046876497,
-0.0052301283,
0.0182058755,
-0.0201409832,
-0.0169299692,
0.0165573098,
-0.0411816202,
-0.0018164761,
-0.0501018092,
0.0141192572,
0.0363771096,
-0.0132801402,
0.0723548755,
-0.0109604876,
0.0390545577,
-0.0033543487,
0.0173804574,
0.0021185561,
-0.03444653,
0.0095622782,
-0.0136382729,
-0.02355594,
0.0180153996,
0.0250085946,
0.0137765361,
0.0258912612,
-0.0530452542,
0.0244443007,
-0.0413487703,
-0.0106313424,
-0.0535849743,
0.0055505959,
-0.0106149754,
-0.0616936646,
-0.0327405818,
-0.0545312315,
-0.003580675,
0.0070674517,
-0.0134781273,
-0.0218413826,
0.0609558634,
-0.03656587,
-0.044936128,
-0.0051942635,
-0.0057135373,
-0.0274876319,
0.0327613913,
-0.0178158935,
0.0098838238,
-6.14448199e-33,
-0.0292324107,
0.0134430248,
-0.0020524189,
0.0090428311,
-0.0373498537,
-0.0546441674,
-0.037718229,
0.0015863979,
-0.0012796236,
0.0028129814,
-0.0437919497,
-0.0130842272,
0.0239748042,
0.060313385,
-0.038560763,
0.0109499963,
0.0927215368,
-0.0061468179,
-0.0354296677,
0.0696656257,
0.0588054061,
-0.0044325884,
0.0304864142,
-0.0861223787,
-0.0012496036,
-0.0337755494,
-0.0306171402,
-0.0010789081,
0.0137207815,
-0.0012899118,
-0.0202085283,
0.0571698658,
-0.0237302203,
-0.0645572618,
-0.0287757292,
0.0232216399,
-0.0596950054,
0.0136433821,
-0.0481103025,
0.0408236161,
-0.0050096111,
-0.0223970357,
0.0283594634,
-0.0222762525,
-0.0380532406,
0.0111684212,
0.0604018122,
-0.0363228433,
-0.0015372848,
-0.0581453778,
-0.0406281091,
0.0239022151,
-0.0272624027,
-0.0719642639,
0.0210948586,
0.0758178011,
-0.0177488364,
-0.0499939434,
-0.0707858577,
0.048383411,
0.0015505063,
-0.0050423639,
0.0354528464,
0.0704590231,
-0.0152491843,
0.0335440822,
0.0433204249,
-0.0064267316,
-0.0094278166,
0.0023371989,
0.0335326232,
0.0165886227,
0.0124204271,
0.0811486393,
0.0150933033,
-0.0229533613,
0.0132548306,
0.0227431282,
0.0185420699,
-0.0622064546,
-0.0026879485,
0.0040163468,
-0.0270902291,
-0.0154288393,
-0.0811090618,
-0.0461150371,
0.0077359178,
0.0120895747,
0.0297617782,
-0.0081719859,
-0.0354633704,
0.0014333505,
0.0427606218,
-0.0068826126,
-0.0037863166,
-0.0350509025,
-0.0569300801,
0.0234546382,
-0.0325922817,
-0.0048162816,
-0.01538142,
-0.0217772312,
0.0909531265,
0.0547665842,
0.0228236243,
-0.0065975492,
-0.0041950536,
0.045111306,
-0.0384044051,
0.0213160031,
-0.0069737514,
0.0548296794,
-0.0015362935,
-0.0331447609,
0.0355971195,
-0.0079480382,
-0.0051513021,
0.0448692292,
0.0146485362,
0.0249475744,
0.0358103365,
-0.0351940617,
0.0042334138,
0.0115574906,
-0.0353428908,
0.0461034328,
0.0029218672,
-0.062793009,
0.0268075913,
-0.045440644,
0.0023468542,
-0.0292887893,
2.726e-7,
-0.0650834516,
-0.0141309323,
0.0387633406,
0.0008342062,
0.0355010182,
0.0416091233,
0.0214731544,
0.0267391652,
-0.0164675526,
-0.0343235657,
0.0108960504,
-0.0064297705,
0.1120272651,
0.0058195335,
-0.095368363,
-0.0245515648,
-0.0991769731,
0.0338733084,
-0.0412931442,
-0.0241194796,
0.0211501066,
0.0789488852,
0.0089726709,
-0.0434758253,
0.0463070348,
-0.01538203,
0.0358082987,
-0.0065218965,
0.0134564545,
-0.0172315743,
0.0389903933,
-0.0089113591,
-0.0338139348,
0.0220330469,
-0.035363134,
0.0137739265,
0.020136781,
0.0990368053,
0.0418238491,
-0.0130795082,
-0.0273565371,
0.037854407,
-0.0215133484,
0.0196960047,
0.0379923545,
0.0020063554,
-0.0235000774,
-0.020426603,
-0.0468028747,
0.0064687305,
-0.0244827271,
-0.0140422583,
-0.0203527343,
0.0028038456,
0.020082755,
0.0186928492,
-0.0121797472,
-0.0223118421,
-0.0323447995,
0.0237553529,
-0.0424983874,
-0.0198636092,
0.0003133891,
0.0011058832,
0.0174683239,
-0.030757945,
-0.00059697,
2.040195342e-34,
0.0080409925,
0.0048551746,
0.0353669785,
-0.0237682089,
-0.0114379525,
0.0085509745,
0.0211405884,
0.0014685895,
0.0606908575,
-0.0392482914,
-0.0298910327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01878v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01878v2 | LiPO: Listwise Preference Optimization through Learning-to-Rank | 2024-02-02T20:08:10 | 2024-05-22T18:51:02 | Tianqi Liu, Zhen Qin, Junru Wu, Jiaming Shen, Misha Khalman, Rishabh Joshi, Yao Zhao, Mohammad Saleh, Simon Baumgartner, Jialu Liu, Peter J. Liu, Xuanhui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Aligning language models (LMs) with curated human feedback is critical to
control their behaviors in real-world applications. Several recent policy
optimization methods, such as DPO and SLiC, serve as promising alternatives to
the traditional Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) approach. In
practice, human feedback often comes in a format of a ranked list over multiple
responses to amortize the cost of reading prompt. Multiple responses can also
be ranked by reward models or AI feedback. There lacks such a thorough study on
directly fitting upon a list of responses. In this work, we formulate the LM
alignment as a \textit{listwise} ranking problem and describe the LiPO
framework, where the policy can potentially learn more effectively from a
ranked list of plausible responses given the prompt. This view draws an
explicit connection to Learning-to-Rank (LTR), where most existing preference
optimization work can be mapped to existing ranking objectives. Following this
connection, we provide an examination of ranking objectives that are not well
studied for LM alignment with DPO and SLiC as special cases when list size is
two. In particular, we highlight a specific method, LiPO-$\lambda$, which
leverages a state-of-the-art \textit{listwise} ranking objective and weights
each preference pair in a more advanced manner. We show that LiPO-$\lambda$ can
outperform DPO variants and SLiC by a clear margin on several preference
alignment tasks with both curated and real rankwise preference data. | [
0.0531882308,
0.0537143424,
0.0041158632,
0.0208240524,
0.0031736647,
0.0275976658,
-0.0146577731,
-0.0168117303,
0.0481293462,
-0.0239099376,
-0.0437877402,
-0.035358917,
0.0240782164,
-0.0036207358,
0.0076677273,
-0.0602567941,
0.0335837267,
-0.0444405153,
0.0174498446,
-0.0202755108,
0.0185364354,
0.0106792552,
-0.0165769402,
0.0289904866,
0.0795024335,
0.0047524916,
-0.0087984959,
-0.0017479308,
0.0767538026,
-0.0273249261,
0.0274480693,
0.0494440198,
-0.0004943445,
0.028678542,
0.000001915,
-0.0420474336,
-0.028773576,
-0.0263542589,
-0.0158271939,
-0.0192421861,
0.0273703784,
0.0222099163,
-0.0212656371,
0.0273754839,
-0.0248662252,
0.016119292,
0.0530955121,
-0.0130238049,
0.0579069443,
0.0578827709,
0.01604563,
-0.0104243923,
0.0089285215,
-0.0465931632,
0.0204376653,
-0.0184959508,
0.0092146844,
-0.0359245576,
0.0201890022,
0.0164090469,
-0.0064924862,
0.0109360712,
-0.0114078382,
-0.0056514777,
0.0083581619,
0.0360769406,
-0.0137530928,
-0.0159898866,
-0.0434322469,
0.0944091454,
-0.0314203203,
-0.0174032897,
0.0075922608,
-0.0204616189,
0.0177608095,
-0.0164215788,
0.007158719,
-0.0208489187,
0.0098455669,
0.0267291889,
0.0184246656,
0.0099642258,
0.0240199622,
0.0230391677,
-0.02906234,
0.0988601595,
0.0009566871,
-0.0592178293,
0.0503572524,
0.0040951385,
-0.0234846454,
-0.0399797447,
0.0162091162,
0.0088766841,
-0.0793622211,
0.0240043458,
-0.0182364937,
0.0067041889,
0.0165308956,
-0.0341347978,
0.0687415004,
0.0543355308,
0.0137534086,
0.0192420743,
0.007901337,
0.089593783,
-0.0234169662,
0.0377018638,
-0.0743761435,
0.0492502488,
-0.008381377,
-0.0260727927,
0.0220885035,
0.0422766358,
-0.0359765515,
-0.0223727841,
-0.0595292076,
0.027787162,
-0.0387963243,
0.06217058,
-0.0012430802,
0.0050574304,
-0.041135326,
0.0043160217,
-0.0697430521,
0.0359538645,
-0.0011510969,
0.0144292247,
0.0236821473,
0.030094536,
0.0221582986,
0.0080831628,
-0.0353752598,
-0.0231510233,
0.0009403998,
0.0805255026,
-0.0229254216,
0.0116256196,
0.025377728,
0.0213589538,
-0.0398279093,
-0.0424186885,
-0.0455388017,
-0.0658118576,
0.0248187892,
-0.0134662045,
-0.0104567185,
-0.023619609,
0.0097304862,
0.025584409,
-0.0295071397,
0.0813037977,
0.0605990179,
-0.0234911703,
0.0154299708,
-0.0336310901,
0.0076082498,
0.0281020831,
0.042372711,
0.0441171601,
0.0077264886,
0.0090302182,
-0.0240349472,
0.0430590324,
0.0206351914,
0.0212927833,
-0.0310667027,
0.0185140371,
0.0014605763,
0.0426743738,
0.0457331277,
0.0238360465,
-0.0052797473,
-0.0257005095,
0.0651303753,
0.0394642912,
0.0252058562,
-0.05240421,
0.0006409742,
0.0305604804,
-0.0314471163,
0.0256077815,
-0.0449316725,
0.0332543366,
-0.0325073674,
0.0344259739,
0.041077897,
0.0166697409,
-0.0088095907,
-0.0654854029,
0.0164782535,
-0.0111039206,
0.0129629411,
0.0524843298,
0.0065933131,
-0.0396214724,
-0.0688751489,
-0.0074388208,
0.023500707,
-0.0184447747,
-0.0224794317,
-0.0400253609,
0.0334699973,
0.1147840917,
0.0256331619,
-0.0281142741,
-0.0534694977,
-0.0080145616,
-0.0603888594,
0.0443011113,
0.031869445,
-0.0442681834,
0.0093958285,
-0.0327478871,
-0.046853248,
0.0568367876,
-0.0240755696,
0.0558486395,
-0.0093951747,
-0.0147600537,
-0.01613608,
0.007337728,
-0.0519801043,
0.0300434418,
0.0083653815,
-0.0268455818,
0.0224977098,
0.0277350657,
0.055303853,
0.0040849322,
0.0395473726,
0.0011246024,
0.0066907145,
-0.0035681797,
0.0177590121,
-0.0386975668,
-0.0412207097,
-0.0365614295,
0.0430599377,
-0.0095218532,
-0.0127693731,
0.0992756858,
-0.0562889986,
-0.0169756301,
-0.062441688,
-0.0031474989,
0.0021780992,
-0.022673279,
0.0190825462,
0.0042050658,
-0.0395867452,
-0.0999337807,
0.0577741712,
-0.0197060313,
0.0428553522,
0.0357915126,
0.0060247402,
-0.020184489,
-0.0969049707,
-0.0269611534,
0.0464098789,
-0.0046337284,
0.0212852601,
0.0512532666,
0.0534989312,
-0.0298998319,
-0.0253974739,
-0.064808242,
0.0156802628,
-0.0141528435,
-0.0099974731,
0.0066370899,
-0.0078122392,
-0.00626201,
-0.0301487986,
-0.0366904549,
-0.0404080823,
-0.0038025312,
0.0186468679,
0.0470772609,
0.0077631096,
-0.0135817472,
-0.074419044,
-0.0186410081,
-0.010168233,
-0.0019865178,
-0.0355865434,
0.0169309955,
-0.0615440942,
0.0383331664,
-0.0604257919,
0.0131208887,
-0.0054687867,
0.0021013438,
0.0111930035,
-0.0076933121,
0.0372604318,
0.1075476632,
0.04322768,
0.0215923898,
0.0613338314,
0.034648452,
-0.0946125984,
0.0077254861,
-0.0554025061,
-0.0088913618,
-0.0398437418,
0.0058889766,
0.0396032408,
0.0361404605,
-0.0009322929,
0.0120107578,
-0.0807369724,
0.008277053,
0.0014602874,
-0.0326001607,
-0.0697691366,
0.0062326933,
-0.0494573452,
0.0570645221,
-0.0215541217,
-0.058117751,
0.0953770578,
-0.0066754175,
0.0204703808,
-0.0897710621,
-0.0024922767,
-0.0396093242,
-0.0152646033,
0.0267793387,
0.0353014916,
-0.0522971898,
-0.0246532727,
-0.0819750726,
-0.0098776137,
0.0199584849,
-0.0483424664,
0.0455335937,
-0.0321139917,
0.0193022061,
-0.0274019539,
-0.0755850002,
-0.054011967,
-0.0258198325,
0.0021134368,
-0.0128344139,
-0.00530212,
-0.0186512358,
0.0034998381,
-0.0002141359,
0.0283958875,
0.0580966882,
-0.0008417185,
0.0008025211,
-0.0249138698,
0.0139722042,
0.0797341466,
-0.0016134853,
0.0042576948,
-0.0088381032,
0.010855129,
0.0086390851,
0.0751914456,
-0.0014857556,
0.0193568338,
0.0332511254,
0.0777708292,
-0.0575648248,
0.0009770237,
0.0343544967,
-0.0118649583,
0.0070810011,
0.0147138573,
0.0833965987,
0.0355069488,
-0.0796940178,
0.0043069725,
-0.0036764489,
0.0881688744,
0.0015159433,
0.0594847873,
-0.0433817245,
0.0106389495,
0.0184015967,
0.0678887442,
-0.0070652687,
0.0110963583,
-0.0158595238,
-0.1304039359,
0.0151262134,
0.0124386866,
-0.0272822827,
0.0019099854,
-0.0236605909,
0.0088145668,
-0.0250345599,
0.0173424482,
0.0219211746,
0.0005334003,
-0.00164733,
0.0118163629,
0.0071576005,
-0.0173391085,
0.0009595742,
0.0034313719,
0.034479782,
0.1121385396,
0.0427526459,
0.0194794759,
-0.0267692637,
0.0004546691,
0.0035199649,
-0.0560307056,
-0.0202168878,
-0.0404695645,
-0.0286273863,
0.0138209378,
-0.024888739,
0.0840951949,
-0.0241974667,
0.0017230051,
-0.0156653337,
0.0375008471,
-0.0129170297,
0.0211012028,
-0.0152206384,
0.0025506171,
0.022573065,
0.0531571843,
-0.0123540228,
-0.0851832181,
-0.0133861508,
-0.0562339388,
-0.0276636649,
-0.049458988,
-0.0549521558,
0.0086690607,
0.0033839326,
0.0126627302,
-0.0696912408,
-0.0375819243,
-0.0109985685,
0.0200766716,
0.0046951254,
0.006110433,
-0.0150235547,
-0.0260809157,
0.0169527102,
-0.0119760046,
0.0085004978,
0.0270476583,
-0.0901768804,
-0.0151173528,
0.012183425,
-0.0350954719,
-0.0562381893,
-0.0198021252,
-0.0282309428,
-0.0733117834,
-0.0052582463,
0.0799825937,
0.0221726671,
0.0341821834,
0.0112597737,
-0.0223921537,
0.051198896,
0.0391183086,
0.012864816,
-0.0078281704,
0.0139214527,
0.047283344,
-0.0130568733,
0.025726771,
-0.0477720648,
0.0021533559,
0.0041406634,
0.034949027,
-0.0240728427,
-0.0426319465,
0.0213474128,
-0.0023984846,
0.020702986,
-0.0445543863,
-0.0474956371,
-0.0425888188,
0.0403255261,
0.009021936,
-0.0360361747,
-0.0041934387,
-0.022764599,
0.0368586518,
-0.0222034175,
0.0096456232,
-0.0432252958,
0.0246521421,
0.0237119161,
-0.0415503867,
-0.0023897311,
0.0288858153,
0.0161631592,
0.0407287367,
0.0313503519,
-0.0041942098,
0.0464053825,
0.02104057,
0.0806175098,
0.0159580838,
0.0316679999,
0.0481461994,
-0.0049087033,
0.0000031108,
0.0518997647,
-0.0453869142,
-0.048394151,
-0.0407814384,
-0.00701589,
0.0173315778,
-0.0028207987,
0.0440738797,
-0.0056786942,
0.0006882205,
-0.0301459059,
-0.0042726281,
-0.0127640879,
-0.0102347452,
0.0136303781,
0.0331126601,
0.0115276808,
0.0267254841,
0.0757916272,
0.0390880853,
-0.0193001907,
-0.0243425518,
0.0223748907,
-0.0557857901,
-0.0216468181,
-0.0192568079,
0.041108802,
-0.0513313934,
-0.0200874284,
-0.04270171,
-0.0306464918,
0.0040693665,
0.0165687986,
0.0178213771,
-0.0187108181,
0.0280635227,
0.02092137,
-0.0506375246,
0.0207628775,
-0.0498642139,
-0.0265736915,
-0.0353799649,
-0.0485362187,
-0.0516353473,
-5.91994163e-33,
-0.0565120466,
-0.038888827,
0.0210388247,
0.017914135,
-0.0172952842,
-0.027911054,
0.0207786746,
0.0107997935,
0.0123531735,
-0.0281609036,
-0.0062931706,
-0.0374152027,
0.0193849578,
0.0062506087,
0.027880989,
-0.0088509386,
0.0116188666,
-0.0144931152,
-0.0678008795,
-0.009354881,
0.0395367928,
0.0061214301,
-0.0105166584,
-0.0314879082,
0.0663733035,
0.0110484175,
-0.0158682652,
0.0152442874,
-0.0140557103,
0.0815995112,
0.0022175172,
0.0098781334,
0.0036522434,
-0.0423676334,
0.0048149438,
0.0563904941,
-0.0544446483,
-0.0234369058,
0.0118747568,
-0.0056421687,
-0.0084982971,
-0.0197908189,
0.0084106028,
0.0068543484,
-0.0368567891,
-0.0102496753,
0.0228282586,
-0.0255032051,
-0.0414057784,
0.0161780417,
-0.0452066436,
0.004102143,
-0.0197321773,
-0.0166340936,
0.0350464284,
0.0960441008,
-0.0141701065,
0.0814580768,
-0.0470202528,
0.0486585647,
-0.0315444246,
0.0526808351,
0.0946192145,
0.0303246472,
-0.0354095958,
0.0427584872,
-0.0046683289,
-0.0437712856,
0.0364205614,
-0.0321387313,
0.0097805224,
0.0243191589,
0.0136599913,
0.0187871773,
0.0006804132,
0.0012736415,
-0.0337914787,
0.0700134709,
0.0125018945,
-0.0137178125,
0.0306414329,
0.0392878912,
-0.0538502149,
-0.0275045969,
-0.0447344333,
-0.0220179223,
-0.0385768078,
-0.0357830822,
0.0419396795,
0.0200984962,
-0.0389664024,
-0.0207469668,
0.0447910391,
-0.0271660052,
-0.0385674387,
-0.0115454383,
-0.0175274163,
0.0257344134,
0.0099100936,
0.0216314904,
-0.0859688595,
-0.0164484419,
-0.0286006965,
-0.0107428199,
-0.0301585738,
0.0140114054,
0.0103622181,
-0.0136951208,
-0.0422709063,
0.0283157621,
0.0014248,
-0.0064340667,
-0.0225196667,
0.0732437819,
0.027125001,
-0.027946502,
0.0102371722,
0.0648084134,
-0.0038203441,
-0.0262697116,
-0.0258115474,
-0.0248901919,
-0.0383448452,
0.0071035032,
-0.0263775811,
0.0183300953,
-0.0071380539,
0.0415461846,
-0.0212040637,
-0.011331643,
-0.0132978214,
0.0124691995,
2.529e-7,
-0.0041070729,
0.0363703854,
0.0143950712,
0.0116785858,
-0.017282404,
0.04436424,
-0.0048392192,
0.054808449,
0.0112494174,
0.0075191385,
0.0197109114,
-0.0109824399,
0.0310440939,
-0.0127011985,
-0.0836151838,
-0.0138121843,
-0.0649203658,
0.0199238695,
-0.043859005,
-0.0259792935,
0.0250554867,
0.0714086369,
-0.0030424688,
-0.0085320892,
0.0075226515,
0.0579088591,
0.0440067984,
-0.0405713283,
-0.0181781147,
-0.003496679,
0.037741933,
-0.0296548586,
-0.0269633885,
0.0066251112,
0.0040902952,
0.0348699652,
0.0123361815,
0.0631841794,
0.005532241,
-0.0780528709,
-0.0179705098,
0.0370059423,
0.0161025953,
-0.0736686811,
0.0354834758,
-0.0109560639,
0.0008539213,
-0.0009918879,
-0.0275796801,
-0.0154208606,
0.0140644377,
-0.0300732441,
-0.0293236654,
0.0126775503,
0.0217008162,
0.0030900079,
0.0116394907,
-0.0422786288,
-0.0196825098,
-0.0252012908,
-0.0167657584,
-0.0349687375,
-0.0213233512,
0.0341079496,
-0.0185832437,
-0.0476798974,
-0.0341084749,
2.239506149e-34,
0.0034545066,
-0.012799616,
0.0117904022,
0.0119542005,
0.0024761735,
0.0235666968,
-0.0133936424,
0.0356343985,
0.0563076623,
-0.069988817,
-0.0272013526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01874v1 | The RL/LLM Taxonomy Tree: Reviewing Synergies Between Reinforcement Learning and Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T20:01:15 | 2024-02-02T20:01:15 | Moschoula Pternea, Prerna Singh, Abir Chakraborty, Yagna Oruganti, Mirco Milletari, Sayli Bapat, Kebei Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO | In this work, we review research studies that combine Reinforcement Learning
(RL) and Large Language Models (LLMs), two areas that owe their momentum to the
development of deep neural networks. We propose a novel taxonomy of three main
classes based on the way that the two model types interact with each other. The
first class, RL4LLM, includes studies where RL is leveraged to improve the
performance of LLMs on tasks related to Natural Language Processing. L4LLM is
divided into two sub-categories depending on whether RL is used to directly
fine-tune an existing LLM or to improve the prompt of the LLM. In the second
class, LLM4RL, an LLM assists the training of an RL model that performs a task
that is not inherently related to natural language. We further break down
LLM4RL based on the component of the RL training framework that the LLM assists
or replaces, namely reward shaping, goal generation, and policy function.
Finally, in the third class, RL+LLM, an LLM and an RL agent are embedded in a
common planning framework without either of them contributing to training or
fine-tuning of the other. We further branch this class to distinguish between
studies with and without natural language feedback. We use this taxonomy to
explore the motivations behind the synergy of LLMs and RL and explain the
reasons for its success, while pinpointing potential shortcomings and areas
where further research is needed, as well as alternative methodologies that
serve the same goal. | [
0.0881618783,
0.0477959961,
-0.0102303131,
0.0122089069,
-0.0751156956,
0.0362131633,
-0.0065155486,
-0.0196479484,
0.0048462269,
-0.0414205082,
-0.0385059677,
-0.0122755039,
-0.0134218428,
0.0275242459,
0.0053940406,
-0.0595470816,
0.0444785133,
-0.0518201664,
0.0398731753,
0.0058261696,
-0.0062735956,
-0.0070709228,
-0.0004697311,
0.0495515615,
-0.003962629,
0.0365278088,
-0.0253689773,
-0.0034056499,
0.0152104031,
-0.0148107745,
0.0249868091,
-0.0018275571,
0.0652506202,
0.0845577046,
0.0000019433,
-0.0690972954,
0.0175119527,
-0.0184118655,
-0.0130317509,
-0.0248285048,
0.0546554439,
-0.0404330827,
-0.0072350632,
0.000140312,
-0.0438623317,
-0.0229581483,
0.0353571735,
0.0701557994,
0.0199051686,
0.1117283851,
0.0326675065,
-0.0541559309,
0.0365738273,
-0.0454990231,
0.0177089237,
-0.0339086503,
0.0385659188,
-0.0154886255,
0.0305109117,
0.0115017258,
-0.0333692208,
0.0109506724,
0.0576930232,
-0.0233717039,
-0.0326909721,
0.0575963296,
0.0060762996,
-0.0373684801,
-0.0195152946,
0.044036217,
-0.0357443579,
0.0097640986,
0.023896642,
-0.0177059323,
0.0030493955,
0.0020068018,
-0.0152794681,
0.0612496212,
0.0370403342,
0.0383044817,
0.0233381577,
-0.0376500078,
0.0557536073,
0.038301155,
-0.0222787764,
0.0605447851,
-0.0241789687,
-0.0693964884,
0.0469573662,
0.0158332083,
0.0124187833,
-0.0797015354,
-0.0172413606,
0.0503165387,
-0.0545776971,
0.0381780937,
-0.0145917144,
0.0197106842,
0.0204439014,
-0.016116526,
0.0262145102,
0.0203424022,
0.012963783,
0.0387536846,
-0.0339567661,
0.0492952541,
-0.0224246271,
0.0461301319,
-0.0019297274,
0.0120483479,
-0.0500194579,
-0.006924897,
-0.0297674313,
0.0431782193,
-0.023602467,
-0.0307786278,
-0.0453750305,
0.0287115425,
-0.0021178913,
0.044976864,
0.0089870915,
0.0195870064,
-0.0355112888,
-0.0131755089,
-0.0934945047,
0.0196591839,
-0.032178387,
0.0336296372,
0.0193050727,
-0.0260809883,
0.0272717178,
0.0050528296,
0.0060025463,
-0.0224834867,
0.0198282227,
0.0803912729,
-0.0041570887,
-0.0223996434,
-0.0412655994,
-0.0209285785,
-0.0179491509,
-0.0680111125,
0.0315042548,
-0.0710654035,
0.0126542691,
-0.0501021445,
-0.0142673841,
-0.0056281178,
0.0122055616,
0.0047237505,
-0.0283865053,
0.0646413043,
0.019481102,
-0.0005184197,
0.0167503022,
-0.0107125659,
0.0181129407,
0.0467136838,
0.0425949097,
0.0200871788,
-0.0140729351,
0.0270337723,
-0.0011516119,
0.0351288691,
-0.0174715165,
0.0117295962,
-0.0208040476,
-0.0206162054,
-0.0335306823,
0.0607410148,
0.0364333577,
0.0492174141,
-0.0290763434,
0.0162285753,
0.0558239184,
0.0674986839,
0.025213128,
-0.0051474301,
0.0616700426,
0.0174482688,
-0.0250027198,
-0.0048905988,
-0.0594448522,
0.0107652592,
-0.003847128,
0.013768415,
-0.0136342496,
-0.0060644164,
-0.0207154322,
-0.063093558,
0.0181451906,
-0.0241137147,
0.0621797852,
0.0372063592,
0.0541980676,
0.0152623672,
-0.0585478693,
-0.0482770428,
0.02687441,
0.0285120998,
0.0230989028,
-0.0715397894,
0.0325373411,
0.0561513975,
0.0387890972,
-0.0535368696,
-0.0121260192,
-0.0336725339,
-0.0154209742,
0.097896114,
0.0351009369,
-0.0120337894,
-0.0249699876,
-0.0309096985,
-0.0328668058,
-0.0342606455,
0.0012265743,
0.0606975816,
0.0175566152,
0.008666019,
-0.0243957695,
0.0608218648,
-0.0491109975,
0.0360120758,
-0.0022680056,
-0.0418968871,
0.0197642837,
0.0062999171,
0.0295606237,
-0.0017140356,
-0.0256293397,
0.0081613446,
0.0064763036,
-0.0151028149,
-0.0412420295,
-0.0401213989,
-0.0596943386,
-0.0204087105,
0.0268513169,
0.0149670681,
0.0018772725,
0.0330014862,
-0.0367757119,
-0.0295705553,
0.0191036146,
-0.0298347101,
0.0511486419,
-0.0183315612,
-0.0111309607,
0.0082003288,
-0.0255358517,
-0.0460570678,
0.0503948331,
-0.0083347252,
-0.018966997,
0.016380135,
0.0195646472,
-0.039502006,
-0.0351934619,
-0.0144092543,
0.0315907188,
0.0089426003,
0.0173589177,
0.0657082573,
0.0639281496,
-0.0482331701,
-0.038702134,
-0.0203002114,
-0.0132593624,
-0.0440466143,
-0.0019140549,
-0.0125707816,
-0.0077817235,
-0.0160214342,
-0.018724151,
-0.0312790088,
-0.0063999388,
0.0362819098,
0.0042180889,
0.0438560434,
0.0361942127,
-0.0105917891,
-0.0505976751,
-0.0254969466,
0.0083658965,
-0.0090189399,
0.0073438799,
-0.0080395043,
-0.04880099,
0.0189981312,
-0.0235965718,
0.0382385664,
-0.0141617991,
-0.0494140722,
0.0017736879,
-0.0401436053,
0.0210098736,
0.075769186,
0.0001249697,
0.0384030491,
0.0513023883,
-0.0117399311,
-0.0618102774,
0.0574841127,
-0.0633936152,
-0.0667509064,
-0.0855063349,
0.0062100622,
0.0346950814,
0.063690044,
-0.0267894715,
0.0133685032,
-0.0353064314,
0.0206326991,
-0.0020371585,
-0.0730123222,
-0.0098459041,
-0.0154371401,
-0.0417744033,
0.034821704,
-0.0298901983,
-0.0593743585,
0.0853657648,
0.0177395102,
-0.0119071966,
-0.045945663,
-0.0430168174,
-0.0524199456,
0.0172029976,
0.0163262952,
0.0265927166,
-0.0254831109,
-0.0497824252,
-0.0326362364,
-0.0451397486,
-0.0017376737,
0.0056917779,
0.0719845295,
-0.0236775,
0.0153841414,
-0.0009010982,
-0.0316813216,
-0.0585562587,
-0.0116145257,
-0.0457524359,
0.0328171737,
-0.0165664256,
-0.0397778302,
-0.0149096437,
-0.032650359,
0.04468536,
0.0283912327,
0.0023810479,
-0.0215712208,
-0.0435254015,
-0.0194114931,
0.0495787263,
0.0110193966,
0.0090025328,
-0.013588028,
0.0506935567,
0.0102771977,
0.0153047871,
-0.0081214197,
-0.0283596925,
0.0287899133,
0.0297625326,
-0.0654321909,
-0.000650742,
0.0442558341,
0.0138191385,
-0.0912943557,
-0.0160916951,
0.1023340896,
0.0214261506,
-0.036189504,
-0.0118560791,
-0.0133050792,
0.031164892,
0.0135233337,
0.0451378077,
-0.0427453406,
-0.0246416684,
0.0095528811,
-0.002675296,
-0.0132929459,
-0.0283627845,
0.007248783,
-0.1248011589,
0.0137401391,
-0.0196474101,
-0.0446993522,
-0.0236499049,
-0.0136460364,
-0.0065428144,
0.0227431078,
0.0487523861,
-0.0007571575,
-0.0120436829,
-0.0471131653,
0.0148010217,
-0.0328695774,
-0.0275971312,
-0.0061066947,
-0.0762745366,
0.0503164195,
0.1167031154,
0.0270456579,
-0.0276895948,
0.0169554465,
0.0125159873,
0.020876389,
0.0197530445,
-0.0184877161,
-0.0023118248,
-0.0172841977,
-0.0107947215,
-0.0010322593,
0.0568584539,
-0.0030145433,
-0.0163693018,
-0.004000315,
0.0746868551,
-0.0246481709,
-0.0238699112,
-0.0042685652,
0.0115440618,
0.0276001468,
0.0514961369,
0.0008176005,
-0.0619194806,
-0.0838684961,
-0.015234434,
-0.0553980283,
-0.0520361066,
-0.0317340642,
-0.0138352402,
-0.022081336,
0.029471878,
-0.0516447425,
-0.0889973715,
0.0194125082,
-0.0215742271,
0.0061464128,
-0.0031033398,
0.0238979626,
0.0060140211,
-0.0043969192,
0.0087120915,
-0.0508916043,
0.0265637729,
-0.0404055379,
-0.0165396277,
0.0046998514,
-0.0368212648,
-0.0117523083,
-0.024243813,
-0.0568568632,
-0.0686737895,
-0.0183813535,
0.0514767282,
0.0068759508,
0.0610506311,
-0.0112275267,
-0.0738059208,
0.0640347973,
0.0205905493,
-0.0208867155,
0.0214272905,
0.0241613165,
0.0487983823,
0.0058780196,
0.0488616414,
-0.0546622165,
0.014288961,
0.0181281287,
0.0306044277,
-0.0113183158,
-0.0032746636,
0.0151742361,
-0.0288913809,
0.0249217786,
-0.0059394469,
-0.018253563,
-0.0258721337,
-0.008776716,
0.0048290547,
-0.0335888751,
-0.018353248,
-0.0103195561,
0.0340024009,
0.0272468273,
0.0034897577,
0.0152485417,
0.0220728982,
0.0079856701,
0.0012623393,
0.0188355334,
0.0335820019,
0.0129485857,
0.0218451936,
0.0442406349,
0.0006580337,
0.0272152293,
0.002649572,
0.0372424386,
0.0204694197,
0.0490617901,
0.0515257008,
0.0021956966,
-0.0300254393,
-0.0387265347,
-0.0564604513,
-0.0756473318,
0.0547357351,
0.0419264957,
0.0715044737,
0.0102123376,
0.0072919591,
-0.0706349835,
-0.0169331487,
-0.0109230345,
-0.0311586186,
-0.0248921458,
-0.0258947108,
0.0506805554,
0.0146201737,
-0.0163666438,
0.0050920569,
0.0334312208,
0.0267479755,
0.0585480519,
0.0067329304,
0.0138360253,
-0.029249426,
-0.0353233628,
0.0237173308,
0.0226675197,
-0.0167802665,
-0.0088824648,
-0.0164051354,
-0.0489187203,
-0.0135159316,
0.0368396826,
-0.0065644505,
-0.022686746,
0.0491440408,
0.0220358726,
-0.0041505448,
-0.0045627961,
-0.0448660553,
-0.0066374238,
-0.0083997482,
-0.0586619526,
-0.0090953335,
-5.865398325e-33,
-0.0060989265,
-0.0075040446,
0.0515688993,
-0.0194012821,
-0.0540778786,
0.0094606094,
-0.0050844187,
-0.0131645966,
-0.0000920412,
0.037388742,
-0.0064921849,
0.0020565873,
0.0128739476,
0.0247290228,
0.0249863211,
-0.0510876961,
0.0447841287,
-0.0238194242,
-0.0098247491,
0.0062168399,
0.0050477348,
0.0245100372,
0.0389220007,
-0.0120287705,
0.0290016774,
0.0241069701,
0.0042647091,
0.05322567,
-0.0168979857,
0.0828647166,
-0.0119658569,
0.0165664963,
0.013487367,
-0.0322838947,
-0.0315340683,
0.0910368487,
-0.0841398984,
-0.0397004187,
0.0316438153,
0.0110754305,
-0.0818091631,
-0.0301448554,
0.0559375137,
0.0097736511,
-0.0013692798,
0.0151241533,
0.022182839,
0.0003526176,
-0.0188164786,
-0.0069221826,
-0.0481508039,
-0.0134957936,
0.0025084496,
-0.0140321432,
0.0383695401,
0.0099640423,
-0.0172747318,
0.0283367112,
-0.026863886,
0.0207380112,
0.0044996296,
0.0212711208,
0.0375633799,
0.0621249676,
0.0192968883,
0.0604178868,
0.0112216277,
-0.0151331844,
-0.0398043916,
-0.016278604,
0.0623192228,
0.0333845988,
0.0061298739,
0.0408361629,
0.0134758018,
0.0192545112,
-0.0539506078,
-0.0263653621,
0.0391931795,
0.0661045834,
0.0265170448,
0.0112571055,
-0.039736066,
-0.0274602491,
-0.0735107809,
0.0352838896,
-0.0272518415,
-0.0353066139,
0.0465565845,
0.048453562,
0.0143571468,
-0.0151035134,
0.0281145051,
-0.0364779569,
-0.0185863171,
0.0296415165,
-0.0079575367,
0.0311345514,
-0.0097662909,
0.0020131078,
-0.089422971,
-0.0157658271,
-0.0082173729,
-0.0353567377,
-0.025170641,
0.0130952271,
0.0107444376,
0.0545395985,
-0.0411515608,
0.0260110945,
-0.0087775588,
0.0388593264,
0.0198596679,
0.0156934801,
0.0458962731,
-0.0079709822,
-0.0110183945,
0.0470464528,
0.0252488833,
-0.059889175,
-0.0098925997,
-0.0059943222,
-0.0193342529,
0.0118647031,
-0.027846856,
0.0109381499,
-0.0417090803,
0.0261377264,
0.0062527484,
-0.0612831488,
0.0055325725,
0.0113163311,
2.707e-7,
-0.0190119147,
0.0536346659,
0.035966672,
0.0406823568,
0.0335251875,
0.0330382735,
-0.0276572201,
0.0344082788,
0.0033905415,
0.0142051503,
0.0307542905,
0.0459896438,
0.0153876934,
-0.0178512279,
-0.071794264,
-0.000729316,
-0.0720159188,
-0.0010610479,
-0.0738761947,
-0.0313616283,
0.0058862888,
0.0742747709,
0.0278216805,
-0.0297538899,
0.0043597654,
-0.0285027791,
0.0562929697,
-0.0678774342,
-0.0127518531,
0.0202005804,
0.0072155558,
0.0398757234,
-0.0069323042,
-0.0087926267,
0.0225411262,
0.034201581,
-0.0525080189,
0.0704488084,
0.0193914343,
-0.0238856487,
-0.0200721212,
0.0036615427,
0.0084179798,
-0.0336834416,
0.0403905474,
-0.0801749825,
-0.0160948392,
-0.0172746722,
0.0373534784,
-0.054831069,
-0.0053233108,
-0.0361018069,
-0.0230587944,
-0.0037832051,
0.0116177285,
0.0175456665,
-0.0040054154,
-0.0998619199,
0.0079447115,
0.0187876634,
-0.022422431,
-0.0152797829,
-0.0674349219,
0.0461292155,
-0.0027818303,
-0.0725179017,
-0.0170049742,
2.296669842e-34,
0.0124402707,
-0.0049361186,
-0.0005120845,
0.0040800502,
0.0019412274,
0.0569647551,
-0.0309660025,
0.0341942608,
0.0605677404,
-0.0761023164,
-0.0189933237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01869v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01869v2 | InferCept: Efficient Intercept Support for Augmented Large Language Model Inference | 2024-02-02T19:47:57 | 2024-05-30T04:18:03 | Reyna Abhyankar, Zijian He, Vikranth Srivatsa, Hao Zhang, Yiying Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models are increasingly integrated with external environments,
tools, and agents like ChatGPT plugins to extend their capability beyond
language-centric tasks. However, today's LLM inference systems are designed for
standalone LLMs. They treat each external interaction as the end of LLM
generation and form a new request when the interaction finishes, causing
unnecessary recomputation of already computed contexts, which accounts for
37-40% of total model forwarding time. This paper presents InferCept, the first
LLM inference framework targeting augmented LLMs and supporting the efficient
interception of LLM generation. InferCept minimizes the GPU resource waste
caused by LLM interceptions and dedicates saved memory for serving more
requests. InferCept improves the overall serving throughput by 1.6x-2x and
completes 2x more requests per second compared to the state-of-the-art LLM
inference systems. | [
-0.00806922,
0.0564683527,
-0.0154030789,
0.0846805722,
-0.054136306,
-0.0011869826,
-0.0012012459,
0.0139261493,
0.0758722723,
-0.0359691344,
0.0001736241,
-0.0193311963,
-0.0041517862,
0.0072414237,
0.0100586573,
0.024948338,
0.0460668802,
-0.0510679074,
-0.0334162936,
-0.0215319954,
-0.0139693543,
0.0273620449,
0.0090172701,
0.0134918988,
0.0175675508,
-0.0379273929,
-0.0267699771,
0.0157012977,
-0.0103528975,
-0.0020348302,
-0.0074216612,
0.0232942365,
0.024056742,
0.0686835498,
0.000002066,
-0.0550249293,
-0.0400287509,
0.0230532158,
-0.045518633,
0.0321635045,
0.0112104872,
0.004510629,
-0.02595127,
0.0300408155,
-0.016251592,
0.0263365768,
0.0398932062,
-0.0137354108,
0.0150254285,
0.0469965264,
-0.0056427885,
0.0157289058,
-0.0059972289,
-0.0203761347,
-0.0039345953,
-0.0537777916,
0.0165478028,
-0.0308255535,
0.037028119,
-0.0006979903,
0.0091481209,
0.017984407,
0.0302207414,
-0.0124128573,
-0.0624920651,
0.018786354,
-0.0165296718,
0.0061250618,
-0.0352680385,
0.0074176826,
0.0304710288,
-0.0305979904,
0.0202319417,
0.013398842,
-0.0302640721,
0.0051192325,
-0.0424174629,
0.0231193304,
-0.0221989695,
0.0001868815,
0.0785926357,
-0.0244338848,
0.021573713,
0.0171466712,
-0.0523042381,
0.0751204267,
0.0608253963,
0.0241826996,
-0.0686758906,
0.0149466293,
-0.0125213051,
-0.0709369555,
-0.0061443537,
0.0240376089,
-0.061670877,
0.0139623834,
-0.030147329,
-0.0030933127,
0.0223781299,
-0.0475488901,
0.03624966,
0.0682550296,
-0.0356436633,
0.0491540134,
-0.0257378612,
0.0146802505,
-0.0480528362,
-0.0239550304,
-0.0187328253,
-0.025813533,
0.0325679183,
0.0138445087,
-0.0251777135,
0.026814241,
-0.0715523735,
-0.0129178762,
-0.0442653075,
0.0723777935,
0.0017565944,
0.0049591907,
-0.0110676354,
-0.0155726839,
-0.0144125232,
0.0049724993,
-0.0022865967,
0.0223925263,
-0.0038164849,
-0.01950147,
0.0022334743,
-0.1406887919,
-0.0216429662,
0.0291421451,
0.001119511,
-0.0326668918,
0.0168876834,
0.107930012,
0.0118106361,
-0.0402121097,
-0.0256969202,
-0.0494160205,
0.0536787212,
-0.0676774308,
0.0016830257,
-0.0826531649,
0.0297500324,
0.0341447853,
-0.0185819678,
-0.0131067876,
-0.0146606397,
0.0007781803,
-0.0177064501,
0.0298356507,
-0.0321691781,
0.0039341408,
0.0141196353,
0.0082336823,
-0.0277132895,
0.1145368069,
-0.0147475116,
0.0197529271,
0.0411417931,
0.0187566578,
0.0082978196,
0.0880628973,
0.0198768731,
0.0347167961,
-0.0367920883,
0.0017207435,
0.0224091373,
-0.0022196502,
0.0122985635,
0.0208998807,
-0.0267883874,
-0.0129345162,
0.0411960967,
0.0655719116,
-0.0043571959,
-0.0044203927,
0.0243084189,
0.0223292597,
-0.0180471856,
-0.0047668247,
-0.0622986257,
0.0184398852,
-0.0522423647,
0.0025858015,
0.0566610098,
0.0718508959,
-0.007015836,
0.0067734928,
-0.0075993394,
0.0026961721,
-0.038709227,
0.0225480609,
0.0584629737,
-0.0089139761,
0.0020958753,
0.0533081293,
0.0793288574,
-0.0329567492,
-0.0621093698,
-0.070445247,
0.0341133252,
0.0526872985,
0.054375831,
-0.0080269538,
-0.063834928,
0.0369613543,
-0.0067035565,
0.0702444911,
0.0162141416,
0.0125068808,
0.0375408046,
-0.0107130958,
-0.0081379805,
0.0154703427,
0.0342181027,
0.0483648032,
0.0577666461,
-0.0022197275,
-0.0155368783,
-0.0267525632,
-0.0059086056,
0.0105729327,
-0.0436331667,
-0.0254643355,
-0.0044356897,
0.0064442959,
0.0304992925,
-0.0078655584,
0.0233228635,
-0.0186020825,
0.0358139761,
-0.0101545099,
0.0103377262,
0.0327879936,
0.0011274077,
-0.0340960808,
0.0470306538,
0.0334516913,
-0.0115479892,
-0.0303146392,
-0.0443693548,
-0.0149787059,
0.0423919186,
-0.0203241259,
0.1124476269,
-0.0516501442,
0.0128328307,
0.0069935126,
0.0087608686,
0.0146047315,
0.01379913,
-0.0029625634,
-0.0068945545,
0.0496724509,
0.0102493139,
-0.0074528106,
-0.011517331,
-0.0084634097,
0.0251695849,
0.0075226403,
0.01069244,
-0.0314631127,
0.0252518449,
-0.0123358928,
0.0228728838,
-0.0958994254,
0.0315936208,
-0.0252811331,
0.0499247164,
0.0324935466,
0.0656173229,
-0.0209973194,
-0.0049545742,
0.0273501296,
0.0233096238,
0.0257782899,
0.0571503527,
-0.0147704482,
0.0065286774,
-0.0769201517,
-0.0014065085,
0.0006984343,
-0.0057120146,
0.0532700233,
-0.0249826722,
-0.062508814,
-0.051019866,
-0.001873916,
-0.0328359753,
0.0364048034,
-0.0334011503,
-0.0203105304,
0.0059639327,
-0.0591004491,
-0.0041844258,
0.0390500836,
-0.021559393,
-0.0049100202,
0.0087347878,
-0.0395043716,
-0.0835038647,
-0.0076705678,
-0.0123731578,
-0.0377632529,
-0.0195837673,
0.0001160229,
-0.0391286165,
0.0838131085,
-0.0616594814,
-0.0185980536,
0.0124985287,
-0.0184882954,
0.0264832713,
-0.0187634472,
-0.0151574109,
0.0150726791,
-0.0219457,
0.0392750204,
0.0182535015,
-0.0860928372,
0.0453019589,
-0.0694226399,
-0.0059499596,
-0.0194105301,
-0.0372657552,
-0.0274994988,
0.0704548061,
-0.0032402377,
0.0154868197,
-0.0456849523,
-0.0268991459,
0.014232873,
0.0412605442,
0.0202493202,
-0.0306198765,
0.0634318963,
-0.06427183,
0.0353929922,
-0.0349275544,
-0.0336027108,
-0.036983218,
0.0410584547,
-0.0488189049,
-0.0103705917,
-0.0204754062,
-0.0333841071,
0.0022725912,
0.0181818809,
-0.0151723381,
0.0559099168,
-0.0289215725,
0.0173429269,
-0.0429450236,
-0.0273022559,
0.019469412,
0.0029568768,
-0.0069083134,
-0.0351356342,
0.0085762842,
0.0888211057,
0.0024657242,
-0.0461775586,
-0.0300092306,
-0.0078734979,
0.064783074,
-0.0069004581,
0.0031781862,
0.0526326001,
0.0206146799,
-0.0944629461,
-0.0167102553,
0.0789119899,
0.008359476,
-0.0644952282,
-0.0139572341,
-0.0224748049,
0.0516219996,
0.0169870984,
0.0510682091,
-0.1193758845,
-0.0322855636,
0.0437000394,
-0.0115762819,
-0.0158177037,
-0.0142615251,
-0.0211462937,
-0.1149637774,
0.0585226826,
0.0031905703,
-0.0068081948,
0.0256472565,
-0.0480639189,
0.0198225267,
0.0400196761,
0.0090199346,
0.0091836536,
0.0147513645,
-0.0081079528,
-0.0306478254,
-0.0062986203,
0.0049893102,
-0.0227848273,
-0.0465496778,
0.0472529307,
0.0092836358,
0.0184134133,
0.0156465508,
0.0016502221,
0.0582020506,
0.0094192885,
-0.0190706085,
-0.0605960935,
0.002816271,
-0.0049275425,
0.0107747056,
-0.0162577182,
0.0221298616,
-0.0168233719,
-0.0098570492,
-0.007715581,
0.0814208612,
-0.0514553897,
0.019601604,
-0.0007749863,
-0.0128402365,
0.0117731895,
0.056771405,
0.0149203343,
0.0095124245,
-0.047449477,
-0.0637708902,
-0.0773967877,
0.0056355619,
-0.0135726752,
0.0018062554,
-0.0041388366,
-0.0514853187,
0.0077560907,
0.0523970313,
0.0410310477,
0.0302823763,
0.0028258546,
0.070595324,
-0.0036152974,
-0.0200466029,
-0.0489309505,
0.0135871489,
-0.0606877618,
0.0204558447,
-0.0209725052,
0.0026121272,
0.0414347872,
-0.0332470052,
-0.0115547664,
0.0570540354,
-0.0744453743,
-0.1021610796,
-0.0119183687,
0.038443502,
0.0341943353,
0.0781180635,
-0.0418999493,
-0.0127307018,
0.0002473691,
0.0511403568,
-0.0551311374,
0.0315970182,
0.0034419149,
0.031110039,
0.0057773851,
0.030440405,
-0.0419288501,
-0.0099908942,
0.0135433869,
0.026898006,
0.0091672009,
-0.0608284399,
-0.02872077,
0.0586518832,
0.0000577879,
-0.02978733,
-0.0272542406,
-0.0149677629,
0.0486033149,
-0.05267125,
0.0063528623,
-0.0349743702,
0.0274560489,
-0.0520480014,
-0.0067932475,
-0.0039452445,
-0.006217218,
0.0242011752,
0.0102802478,
-0.0367734134,
0.018254308,
-0.0342895463,
-0.0459941253,
0.0706010163,
-0.0178549699,
0.0245698802,
0.0033922577,
0.0234595314,
0.0675233975,
-0.0544493273,
0.0298566539,
0.0229477733,
-0.0158014987,
-0.0150215868,
0.0106771681,
-0.0335242413,
-0.0724131316,
-0.0032815745,
0.0670893639,
0.071296975,
0.0207295865,
0.0680508465,
-0.034346018,
-0.0120380381,
-0.0103836786,
0.0398008339,
-0.0093628559,
-0.0249729082,
0.0304844882,
0.0153519465,
-0.0115640676,
0.0256281663,
0.0362121835,
-0.0143650547,
0.0520006306,
0.0107492972,
-0.0305048544,
-0.0331050195,
-0.0659085736,
-0.0028335296,
0.0053990535,
-0.0193141513,
-0.0142863579,
-0.0375544354,
-0.0587175116,
-0.0289296694,
0.0058748708,
-0.0509796739,
-0.0206559617,
0.0014649003,
0.0635188445,
0.0497764051,
-0.0451490618,
-0.0411954559,
0.0316940695,
-0.0189366564,
-0.014862163,
0.0299622491,
-6.438972345e-33,
-0.0298843887,
-0.0419988185,
0.0587289929,
-0.0079534361,
-0.0158288963,
-0.0048795771,
-0.0321150944,
-0.0291596074,
0.0295470059,
-0.0241226219,
-0.0047526178,
0.0239403024,
0.0335396938,
0.006172637,
-0.0082030548,
0.0010212543,
0.0086687431,
0.0167749934,
-0.0011686655,
0.0210290477,
0.0371541083,
0.0245605316,
0.0418873318,
-0.0505445302,
-0.027112579,
-0.0305052716,
0.0436237492,
0.0199213084,
-0.0519263372,
0.0332291536,
-0.0196176339,
0.0127485311,
0.0124830473,
-0.0291576851,
0.0109008905,
-0.0129742324,
-0.0366264805,
-0.0164617021,
0.0556810573,
0.0062585464,
-0.0354276523,
-0.0264364891,
-0.0314407274,
0.0378216356,
-0.0037098168,
-0.0031841174,
-0.0299446918,
-0.0116891051,
0.0010800069,
0.0086685531,
-0.0374342278,
0.0352057517,
0.040869154,
0.053085845,
0.0470422693,
-0.0194565207,
0.0055261995,
0.0063282745,
-0.0209486857,
0.003046415,
0.0000692298,
0.023706615,
0.0814652741,
0.0322288014,
0.0133610871,
0.0349797606,
0.0362554938,
-0.0082300687,
-0.0189397559,
0.006668549,
0.0080757933,
0.0405830331,
-0.0032567747,
0.0103542879,
0.0065733972,
0.0089932978,
-0.0451888405,
0.0177711435,
0.0704461336,
0.0015211079,
0.0504022129,
-0.0078946529,
-0.0019610622,
-0.02790807,
-0.0054724622,
0.0026021837,
-0.0352319852,
-0.0241439771,
0.0146804964,
0.0090286937,
0.0030298908,
-0.0081663532,
0.0538417883,
-0.0387910381,
-0.0237364955,
-0.0206455495,
-0.002861548,
-0.0312745981,
0.0156641621,
0.0446112007,
0.0135019431,
-0.0270733945,
-0.0196861383,
-0.0462535359,
0.0150655238,
0.0058590309,
0.0057252492,
0.0078407507,
-0.0401781127,
0.0164862797,
-0.0667129457,
0.0372482762,
0.0046979999,
0.0132381478,
0.0557987019,
0.0008576691,
0.0299568716,
0.0481955893,
0.0291449521,
0.0404652245,
-0.0375884399,
-0.0159623213,
0.004223045,
0.0011403729,
-0.0445471816,
0.0087552164,
-0.0467663184,
0.0179445408,
0.0181017201,
-0.0626605153,
-0.0210122019,
0.0117348935,
2.889e-7,
0.0141235888,
0.0280273445,
0.0179555807,
0.0482513346,
0.0160152186,
0.0053084614,
0.0121672321,
-0.0142288422,
0.0562950037,
-0.0153663587,
-0.019867206,
0.0221468471,
0.0615995266,
0.0143972393,
-0.0586261041,
0.0042271768,
-0.0409184918,
-0.0302085336,
-0.0555386245,
-0.0291645434,
-0.0065643424,
0.0714075416,
-0.0083655724,
-0.0238742176,
0.0435856767,
-0.0142627461,
-0.0047052037,
-0.0542065762,
-0.0457202271,
0.0149266757,
0.0288043339,
0.0148642454,
0.0105473828,
0.0031897903,
-0.0046978667,
0.012516221,
-0.071470499,
0.0426296853,
-0.0061542806,
0.0031686036,
-0.001530377,
-0.0695941821,
0.0036594965,
-0.0250540357,
0.0804267153,
0.0217043664,
-0.0083929235,
-0.0407358669,
0.0128029976,
-0.0697357431,
-0.0566580184,
-0.0170525257,
0.0257548932,
0.0367085747,
0.0176585875,
-0.0464383364,
-0.017823847,
-0.0474924929,
-0.0467854664,
-0.0120642344,
-0.0542123429,
-0.0830480084,
-0.0403526872,
0.0199015029,
-0.0033780399,
-0.0437063575,
-0.0029709344,
3.458533739e-34,
0.0278124474,
0.0332253836,
0.0016451343,
0.0997254476,
0.0361454301,
-0.0156547166,
-0.0044136322,
0.021545643,
0.0140331807,
-0.0916674137,
-0.0366946422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01867v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Structure Learning in Prompted Weak Supervision | 2024-02-02T19:45:39 | 2024-02-02T19:45:39 | Jinyan Su, Peilin Yu, Jieyu Zhang, Stephen H. Bach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Prompted weak supervision (PromptedWS) applies pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) as the basis for labeling functions (LFs) in a weak supervision
framework to obtain large labeled datasets. We further extend the use of LLMs
in the loop to address one of the key challenges in weak supervision: learning
the statistical dependency structure among supervision sources. In this work,
we ask the LLM how similar are these prompted LFs. We propose a Structure
Refining Module, a simple yet effective first approach based on the
similarities of the prompts by taking advantage of the intrinsic structure in
the embedding space. At the core of Structure Refining Module are Labeling
Function Removal (LaRe) and Correlation Structure Generation (CosGen). Compared
to previous methods that learn the dependencies from weak labels, our method
finds the dependencies which are intrinsic to the LFs and less dependent on the
data. We show that our Structure Refining Module improves the PromptedWS
pipeline by up to 12.7 points on the benchmark tasks. We also explore the
trade-offs between efficiency and performance with comprehensive ablation
experiments and analysis. Code for this project can be found in
https://github.com/BatsResearch/su-bigdata23-code. | [
0.0348171107,
0.0657010451,
0.0219299123,
0.0494458787,
-0.0062683462,
0.0381098203,
0.0223118104,
-0.0067883483,
0.0603665896,
-0.018840855,
-0.0850049257,
-0.025726812,
-0.0059197871,
0.0180690028,
0.0141952112,
-0.0137318494,
0.0205763448,
-0.0494585223,
0.0165878404,
-0.0078836316,
-0.0117367031,
-0.0117653878,
0.0168712121,
-0.0097077852,
-0.0451425202,
-0.0101419892,
0.0164439976,
-0.0002722112,
-0.0139392186,
-0.0191677343,
0.0503755845,
0.0851847753,
0.0220472012,
0.0189751275,
0.000002025,
-0.0068847956,
-0.0063915099,
-0.0045137047,
0.0112632131,
0.0321169235,
0.0083971331,
-0.0422932692,
0.0168107636,
-0.0058949152,
-0.0108306734,
-0.0503127053,
0.0523739122,
0.0782630071,
0.0742745399,
0.0657489151,
-0.0013827812,
-0.0564999841,
-0.0093270652,
-0.0714740306,
0.0236034337,
-0.0198836476,
0.0692197755,
0.0102044605,
-0.0323859155,
0.0370015539,
-0.0095035424,
0.0447462313,
0.0100157419,
-0.0339873172,
-0.0099665709,
0.0291796867,
-0.0408278629,
-0.0412746146,
0.0271816757,
0.0978940651,
0.019040728,
-0.0176709145,
0.0262897909,
-0.0021756475,
-0.0310816094,
0.0189773273,
-0.033936739,
-0.0100803515,
0.0085419724,
0.0352746099,
0.0272924025,
0.0278208591,
0.0396002308,
-0.0086779622,
0.0208980571,
0.0478314981,
0.026735384,
-0.0496546291,
0.001335943,
0.0130561357,
-0.0335422717,
-0.034857776,
-0.0329455845,
-0.0259543806,
-0.0413396694,
0.0334067866,
-0.0475507788,
-0.0537295416,
0.0110648908,
-0.0104454681,
-0.0041928389,
-0.0304891765,
-0.0652602017,
0.0890047252,
-0.0478125103,
0.0344740152,
-0.012553324,
0.0418021865,
-0.0243736338,
-0.0001629036,
-0.0283439476,
-0.0142013347,
-0.0055000219,
0.0280632619,
-0.0011300141,
-0.0078290328,
-0.0218792558,
-0.0180383716,
-0.0298382677,
0.0324106254,
0.0073566972,
-0.0087833647,
-0.0305087212,
0.037858963,
0.0258868597,
-0.0088052126,
-0.0097982585,
-0.0020459816,
-0.0459269807,
-0.0187746305,
-0.0120972041,
0.0423705466,
0.0269475468,
-0.0406911075,
0.0428977683,
0.0376240164,
0.0155661171,
-0.0394907072,
-0.0625664592,
-0.0269523077,
-0.0521269292,
-0.0460441187,
0.014560678,
-0.0685060397,
0.0328684747,
-0.0011283172,
0.0096028792,
-0.0342775173,
0.0246908944,
0.0126011604,
-0.0859835073,
0.0798769817,
-0.0069434424,
-0.001872903,
-0.0109226797,
0.0041064238,
0.0033241,
0.0488467626,
-0.0434816405,
0.0297291987,
0.0404184647,
-0.0131708384,
0.0073804334,
0.0349789485,
0.0141976792,
0.0435955338,
-0.0195809864,
-0.0014562835,
0.0492479391,
-0.0158003736,
0.0421318673,
0.0657321066,
-0.015834799,
-0.0034662334,
0.0335271843,
0.011388354,
0.0064322273,
-0.0247452389,
0.0522588119,
-0.0080818739,
0.0173770301,
0.028440766,
-0.0639946312,
-0.0227000713,
-0.0353112221,
0.0005504349,
-0.010969772,
-0.0193739198,
-0.0501861833,
-0.0265850872,
0.0105521465,
-0.0172334239,
-0.0324891843,
0.0120338425,
0.0660982952,
0.0566917025,
-0.0141245732,
0.0069171772,
0.073098518,
-0.0129469596,
-0.0026463347,
-0.0199362915,
0.0403494984,
0.0397898369,
0.0386807919,
-0.0523632728,
-0.0194744449,
0.0053899083,
0.0765644982,
0.0124040255,
-0.0006022588,
-0.0318545662,
0.0326975323,
-0.0428754985,
-0.0440346561,
-0.0106494846,
0.0200986769,
0.0133336214,
0.0103778113,
-0.0279702637,
0.0377095491,
-0.0135164363,
-0.0305981748,
0.0534061566,
-0.0005106752,
-0.0326198228,
0.0140290223,
0.0161700491,
0.0305683166,
0.0099809272,
-0.0277411118,
0.0030856796,
0.0509659089,
-0.0655062869,
0.0101283211,
-0.0513670854,
-0.0701442584,
-0.0484603569,
0.0342712961,
-0.002615164,
-0.048941765,
-0.0014863492,
-0.0550984442,
-0.0604847968,
-0.0135204764,
0.0032315284,
0.0088261906,
-0.0260324683,
-0.0081941597,
0.0033021448,
-0.0065328795,
-0.0539094061,
0.0651071891,
0.0101937484,
0.0437640473,
0.0527506545,
0.0151722087,
0.0033121617,
0.017407883,
-0.0363898575,
0.0004940841,
-0.0141110057,
-0.0074931029,
0.0325001515,
0.0501944348,
-0.0459140725,
-0.0303028859,
-0.0490284003,
-0.0079151895,
-0.0416755006,
-0.0047443216,
0.0337435231,
0.0011319144,
0.0217037182,
-0.0396272615,
-0.0192583036,
-0.0311678015,
-0.0300734565,
0.0290354546,
0.0031965654,
-0.0034564545,
-0.0615785532,
-0.0555156283,
-0.0225114524,
-0.0128839659,
0.0353692882,
-0.0058192252,
-0.0762995332,
-0.0451317355,
0.0652329847,
-0.0133864228,
0.018860206,
-0.0097103259,
-0.0185462926,
0.0177242309,
-0.0420426689,
0.0861243978,
0.0070757838,
-0.0565101802,
0.0067279204,
0.0513434038,
-0.0175911412,
-0.0127884746,
-0.0233023874,
-0.022877261,
-0.0087010441,
-0.0099677444,
-0.0038901274,
-0.0077837124,
0.0400411226,
0.0195258819,
-0.000363471,
-0.0488741994,
-0.011692591,
-0.004886419,
-0.0016350686,
-0.0531568937,
0.0042760372,
-0.0189154819,
-0.0241886955,
-0.0392579809,
-0.0474258251,
0.032187175,
-0.0415140577,
-0.0153572951,
-0.0076415301,
0.0031151045,
-0.047070384,
0.0633815303,
0.042661339,
0.0093791774,
0.0265098456,
-0.0279564373,
-0.055058375,
0.015459667,
0.0042614955,
-0.0107326079,
-0.0333224237,
-0.0509998612,
0.0355118252,
0.0131253935,
-0.0402409732,
-0.0306631662,
-0.0329166204,
-0.0262845103,
0.019109996,
0.0109748524,
-0.0020725455,
0.0092638656,
-0.0021459383,
0.0337393954,
0.0659577996,
0.0069941636,
0.0279412232,
-0.0521875918,
0.0336657576,
0.0544953831,
-0.0613569915,
-0.0373371877,
-0.0300152432,
0.009314972,
0.0463307202,
0.0249851309,
0.0073781824,
-0.0300777089,
0.0244093407,
0.0115366159,
0.0483398438,
-0.0132637834,
-0.0188130401,
0.0286159758,
-0.0244691297,
-0.0000297335,
0.1023795307,
0.0258647855,
-0.053001903,
-0.0178648438,
0.0240941308,
0.0459890775,
0.0583101772,
0.0075717825,
-0.047618635,
-0.0498036928,
0.0108181825,
0.0182588678,
0.0174340196,
-0.0380303524,
0.0216501802,
-0.1011630446,
0.0168753602,
0.0036879964,
-0.0044067125,
-0.039501112,
-0.077223897,
0.0303693786,
-0.0019153539,
-0.0224316996,
-0.0141622871,
0.009296556,
0.0095991911,
0.0275640041,
-0.0206089094,
-0.0626884326,
0.0112296976,
-0.0420035869,
0.0638660491,
0.0565597005,
0.0058276583,
-0.0117400223,
-0.011876421,
0.0642929226,
-0.036558263,
-0.0465791523,
-0.031836845,
0.0478073694,
0.0015980117,
-0.0354841799,
-0.0054708039,
0.0719612613,
-0.0582930893,
-0.0010035235,
-0.0011259709,
0.0826802403,
-0.0192162283,
-0.0027198957,
-0.00375917,
-0.0189716704,
0.0355268605,
0.0862457752,
0.0462009646,
-0.0426841676,
0.0169586893,
0.0309383497,
0.0029171759,
0.0131426929,
-0.0304036606,
0.0314514823,
-0.0451692417,
0.0027325426,
-0.0651322678,
-0.0230989996,
0.0769621357,
0.0097799096,
0.0068411231,
0.0150211351,
-0.0124128163,
-0.0537045971,
-0.0243493151,
0.0526409559,
-0.0492148623,
0.0129575972,
-0.0893380493,
-0.0494794361,
0.0490984954,
0.0123417042,
-0.0096718846,
0.0404128507,
-0.0714529231,
-0.0535524152,
0.014898154,
0.0614771657,
0.0067872591,
0.0359815024,
-0.0145491064,
-0.0254224632,
0.0164495613,
0.036843624,
-0.0459276624,
0.0053466638,
0.0146184862,
-0.0271552857,
-0.001537748,
0.0379233584,
-0.0391117558,
0.0293202326,
0.0713853091,
0.0500619896,
0.004545806,
0.0187432412,
0.0319437198,
0.0405612923,
0.0998900607,
-0.0173667502,
0.0200570226,
-0.0653752387,
-0.0081423232,
-0.0230281651,
-0.060969241,
-0.0462763868,
0.0484741852,
0.0268548131,
0.001441775,
-0.0124807674,
0.002353718,
-0.002229773,
0.0718231499,
0.0013052194,
0.0045145233,
0.0125143584,
0.0028344304,
0.0510079302,
-0.007626025,
-0.0108370241,
0.0544828698,
0.0333021544,
0.0001579727,
-0.014544894,
-0.0014898924,
0.04662361,
-0.0017697751,
-0.0604935177,
0.0092607355,
-0.0383421928,
-0.0253683571,
-0.0164900068,
0.0242979582,
0.0358005874,
-0.0526692346,
0.0433374718,
-0.0223827604,
-0.0301992968,
-0.0309889577,
0.0112799089,
0.0410877876,
-0.0036661862,
0.056497097,
0.0281117056,
-0.0330978483,
0.075341478,
0.1052043959,
0.0293538701,
0.043909125,
0.0015356838,
0.0056291232,
-0.035606999,
0.0135852313,
0.0333528034,
0.0090919286,
-0.048413597,
0.0208526682,
-0.0078422828,
-0.0609192289,
-0.0110711372,
-0.0514497757,
-0.0487248078,
0.0429240316,
0.0513687432,
0.0333940759,
0.0195311327,
0.0107038394,
-0.0181066133,
-0.0191040877,
0.0478391387,
-0.0927201435,
-0.0031913146,
-6.982686971e-33,
0.0181752872,
-0.0407641865,
-0.0094561866,
-0.0108004836,
0.0342976376,
0.0412752107,
-0.0259325728,
0.0147809898,
0.0169343334,
0.0427535549,
-0.0213520806,
-0.0177443791,
0.0186307635,
0.034219373,
0.0080254804,
-0.0221100133,
0.0566144623,
-0.0151814213,
0.0134562682,
0.0494749174,
0.0353990234,
0.0454032198,
0.0411536358,
-0.119333528,
0.0420893766,
-0.004889742,
-0.0121773267,
0.0218078662,
0.023770012,
0.0315491259,
-0.0307190567,
0.0194698926,
0.0095161879,
-0.0232492778,
-0.0073612267,
0.0441765748,
-0.1223859042,
-0.0133409081,
-0.0132080475,
-0.0156768952,
-0.0750213936,
-0.0273357891,
0.0012545651,
-0.0178525988,
0.0472065248,
0.008820639,
0.0346228704,
-0.0346226543,
-0.0460079946,
-0.00851232,
-0.0433877707,
0.0379293896,
0.0053385925,
-0.0027678311,
0.0249231569,
0.0316931158,
-0.0166806951,
0.031508293,
-0.0201057158,
0.0078722537,
-0.0258057751,
0.0530812442,
-0.0039024483,
0.0426898338,
0.0084970463,
0.0526416488,
0.0140008936,
0.0157416668,
0.0305206161,
-0.02833746,
-0.0047538169,
0.0661457479,
0.0282234717,
-0.0014620853,
-0.0084517999,
0.0237421449,
-0.0759468675,
-0.0258038994,
0.009460994,
0.0146264955,
-0.0129341204,
0.0025271128,
-0.0239810906,
-0.0390884392,
-0.0394112468,
-0.0110206623,
-0.0437752567,
-0.0034296894,
0.0191587731,
0.0301579535,
-0.0595355555,
-0.0239688084,
0.0150760189,
-0.0304337274,
-0.0296638943,
0.0140003841,
-0.0022429929,
0.0154391769,
-0.0035657999,
-0.0142935887,
-0.0626299232,
-0.0444974788,
0.0612455867,
-0.0365985073,
0.0263957717,
-0.0167837124,
0.0951475129,
0.0148058394,
-0.0567496344,
-0.025615938,
-0.0111900866,
-0.0088049863,
-0.0017559561,
0.0089720376,
0.0159469005,
0.0050160885,
0.0080989171,
0.0543579198,
0.0736961588,
0.0340920947,
0.0019960725,
-0.0216270667,
-0.006764885,
0.0232964959,
-0.0155147696,
-0.0170535203,
-0.0278940126,
-0.0202169362,
0.0474584289,
-0.048145324,
0.0080884025,
-0.0142054781,
2.863e-7,
0.0220849868,
0.0336668901,
-0.0023338948,
-0.018932946,
0.0067145955,
0.0349396244,
-0.0273068603,
-0.0009013152,
-0.0269972049,
-0.0513740033,
0.0298563428,
-0.021068532,
0.0518151596,
-0.0058354056,
-0.0957642198,
0.007579979,
-0.0581154935,
-0.0398749225,
-0.0504930615,
-0.0154083632,
0.0181235448,
0.1177421957,
0.0214195829,
-0.0218126848,
-0.017715022,
-0.047807008,
0.0348411761,
-0.0116524044,
-0.0203525312,
0.0065049138,
0.0292278323,
-0.0191267841,
0.0019098903,
0.0015663343,
-0.0170736741,
0.0026967775,
0.0347563885,
0.0597900599,
0.0237597972,
0.0277390555,
0.0192999747,
0.0197769832,
0.0069923084,
0.0156413931,
0.0953293592,
-0.0526952222,
-0.0386852399,
-0.0086672083,
-0.0064939372,
-0.0114484048,
0.0074163112,
-0.0074955239,
-0.0247295368,
0.0244952012,
0.0280133393,
-0.0047858865,
-0.0406558625,
-0.0496605672,
0.0128816264,
0.0111407256,
-0.043373052,
-0.0149044553,
0.0010635736,
0.0253336783,
-0.0014437835,
-0.0487509631,
0.0172089841,
3.245480439e-34,
0.0384731553,
-0.0195577946,
0.0069743283,
-0.0189218633,
0.051715862,
-0.053992413,
-0.1015945002,
0.0360664465,
-0.0072976528,
-0.0774532929,
0.0070410301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01865v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01865v2 | What Will My Model Forget? Forecasting Forgotten Examples in Language Model Refinement | 2024-02-02T19:43:15 | 2024-06-20T06:25:39 | Xisen Jin, Xiang Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Language models deployed in the wild make errors. However, simply updating
the model with the corrected error instances causes catastrophic forgetting --
the updated model makes errors on instances learned during the instruction
tuning or upstream training phase. Randomly replaying upstream data yields
unsatisfactory performance and often comes with high variance and poor
controllability. To this end, we try to forecast upstream examples that will be
forgotten due to a model update for improved controllability of the replay
process and interpretability. We train forecasting models given a collection of
online learned examples and corresponding forgotten upstream pre-training
examples. We propose a partially interpretable forecasting model based on the
observation that changes in pre-softmax logit scores of pretraining examples
resemble that of online learned examples, which performs decently on BART but
fails on T5 models. We further show a black-box classifier based on inner
products of example representations achieves better forecasting performance
over a series of setups. Finally, we show that we reduce forgetting of upstream
pretraining examples by replaying examples that are forecasted to be forgotten,
demonstrating the practical utility of forecasting example forgetting. | [
0.0012165835,
0.0572830178,
-0.0153131615,
-0.0240155477,
0.0168414116,
0.0387095362,
0.0148867397,
-0.0130482959,
-0.0016735974,
-0.0328582525,
-0.008276063,
-0.0591686219,
-0.0014272151,
0.0406184681,
-0.0027206028,
-0.0299265645,
0.0602912493,
-0.0411642268,
-0.0361475721,
-0.0301986001,
0.0082716793,
0.0111590372,
0.0092787771,
0.0614788681,
0.002220196,
-0.0360081419,
-0.0410389155,
-0.015899159,
-0.0451538302,
-0.0057564033,
0.0484798029,
0.025852669,
0.0471850298,
0.0266755335,
0.0000018708,
-0.0206826106,
-0.0483036563,
-0.0183273684,
-0.0570599847,
0.0207418893,
-0.0068509765,
-0.0149408486,
0.0061842655,
0.0329004042,
-0.0268036239,
-0.0207659304,
0.0427695177,
0.0448939353,
0.0769234821,
0.0664168149,
0.0203500967,
-0.0165974144,
0.0160734542,
-0.0145547474,
0.0270698704,
-0.0378096923,
0.0077851349,
-0.0425009876,
-0.0739386752,
-0.0467123538,
-0.020431729,
0.017298257,
-0.002690098,
0.0330591127,
-0.0213924609,
0.0296794772,
0.0140205016,
-0.0027020255,
-0.0275097024,
-0.0039177337,
-0.0178528484,
-0.0443645567,
0.0044212071,
-0.0008044633,
-0.0111689828,
-0.0254331995,
-0.0458419994,
-0.0128557337,
0.0225468129,
0.0284826271,
0.0310132094,
-0.0534898043,
0.0327355638,
0.0168974791,
-0.0046054502,
0.0795375407,
-0.0058799414,
-0.0370377898,
-0.0441427454,
0.0220162533,
-0.0021811817,
-0.0113789467,
0.0024030108,
0.0303618852,
-0.0259220209,
0.0511665642,
-0.0297293719,
-0.0325151086,
-0.0434753932,
-0.0319789536,
0.1102293134,
0.051157821,
-0.0094227381,
0.0182289109,
-0.0202099308,
0.0406544022,
0.0291886963,
0.0099818772,
-0.0062028966,
0.0346606635,
-0.089312382,
-0.0293282662,
-0.0682758465,
0.041089654,
0.0538315289,
0.045102492,
-0.0243144277,
0.0033480902,
-0.0437852032,
0.0275657419,
0.0109769301,
-0.0193768404,
-0.0852321759,
-0.0114319343,
-0.0270359144,
0.0195734315,
0.0075960248,
-0.0137176421,
0.0035536629,
-0.0726072937,
-0.0075671002,
-0.0503217727,
-0.018748194,
0.0061789523,
0.0072138351,
0.0500755832,
0.0209723953,
-0.0208090395,
-0.0645646825,
-0.0605737381,
-0.004478375,
-0.0405281596,
0.0350541584,
0.0055860695,
-0.0209998395,
0.0012192932,
0.026232088,
-0.0337440856,
-0.0134762814,
-0.0104472442,
-0.0059754509,
0.0566322058,
0.0281858463,
-0.0169446748,
0.00411929,
-0.0227318257,
0.0197035633,
0.0795788839,
-0.0014817528,
0.0018429641,
0.0174952038,
-0.0146406451,
0.0087354174,
0.0352422893,
0.0579777472,
0.0114532467,
-0.059065748,
-0.0063177394,
0.0160999838,
0.0054324511,
0.0244996957,
-0.03496987,
-0.0037712485,
0.0256377682,
0.0496794768,
-0.0109410034,
0.0164309666,
0.0332885981,
0.0408321396,
-0.0235650688,
-0.0107102217,
0.0139402105,
-0.0229003858,
0.0068039354,
-0.013201206,
0.0195726044,
-0.0160853844,
0.0297675245,
-0.058704447,
-0.0438868888,
-0.0001592894,
-0.0190031137,
-0.0210081246,
0.0001477873,
0.085241802,
0.0001976831,
-0.0485420786,
0.1212483421,
0.0417775586,
-0.0213297736,
0.0386824273,
-0.0591074117,
0.033001706,
0.0501086339,
0.0214006826,
-0.0116341999,
-0.0494732521,
-0.0075145015,
-0.0174460616,
-0.0369387083,
0.0800356269,
-0.0039703795,
-0.0043753008,
-0.0610013753,
-0.0420721024,
0.020815311,
0.0402864367,
0.0497560054,
-0.0234486274,
0.0161884353,
0.0137079293,
-0.0203858707,
-0.0644664988,
0.0226003602,
-0.019862907,
-0.0354249962,
-0.0141842645,
-0.0198596157,
0.0486083627,
-0.030882718,
0.0074843294,
0.0153952725,
0.0450324491,
-0.0001216346,
-0.0276964121,
0.0315375477,
-0.1076873392,
-0.0444900095,
0.0317961611,
0.0288986918,
0.0351233631,
0.0087510236,
-0.0561450385,
-0.0691078603,
0.0672002286,
-0.0140835438,
0.0718933344,
-0.0343535282,
0.0379716754,
-0.0163902789,
-0.0089725917,
0.0020546715,
0.0204473045,
-0.0147671336,
0.0213221107,
-0.069406189,
-0.0154521102,
-0.015395863,
-0.0093294596,
-0.0306876004,
0.018846279,
-0.0147282016,
0.0342998542,
-0.0240623914,
-0.0296117328,
-0.0498291552,
-0.0003747226,
-0.0308082867,
-0.0227635261,
-0.0422508828,
0.0037462467,
-0.0033371912,
-0.0164880585,
-0.0002109092,
-0.0422285013,
-0.0101028346,
0.0120078735,
-0.011963944,
0.0172529463,
-0.0140714934,
0.0218581911,
-0.0011703874,
0.0137324836,
-0.0242231544,
-0.0109832985,
0.0526487045,
-0.0376625545,
0.0097306818,
-0.0888664573,
0.0082483282,
-0.0399309061,
0.0294905715,
-0.0112552214,
-0.0237062871,
-0.0292340759,
-0.0376483351,
0.0121596865,
0.0550769381,
-0.0310997758,
0.0397940949,
0.0475847982,
-0.0111114532,
-0.0538725518,
0.013065476,
-0.0243909713,
-0.0768575743,
-0.033962585,
0.0100369127,
-0.0286031123,
0.0776208788,
-0.0030714157,
-0.0054217172,
-0.0545101948,
0.013306912,
-0.0597272068,
-0.0140246786,
-0.0388318375,
-0.0070122876,
-0.0269076377,
0.0434058234,
0.0098857172,
-0.0690532923,
0.0704097748,
0.0132114831,
-0.0222434662,
-0.0381546654,
-0.0075011048,
-0.0028747681,
0.0330951177,
0.0191633366,
-0.0099494597,
0.0179269034,
-0.0294680241,
-0.0405854285,
-0.037278194,
0.0248572435,
-0.027287785,
0.0115731265,
-0.0224881712,
-0.0179907363,
0.0266092438,
-0.0009006844,
-0.0268201437,
0.0038240275,
-0.0317735747,
-0.0129504213,
0.0015165769,
0.0043304628,
-0.0330310315,
0.0138466088,
-0.0155374277,
0.0400036871,
-0.0295463577,
-0.0144969504,
0.0032042505,
-0.0252378695,
0.0220475458,
-0.0055451924,
-0.0014676265,
-0.090694584,
0.0155576821,
-0.0191428475,
0.0857134461,
-0.0141763063,
-0.0352562517,
0.0275059175,
0.0225657672,
-0.0205198061,
-0.0501079187,
0.0674273521,
0.0198681429,
-0.1031786129,
-0.0599553175,
0.0857118368,
0.0266954433,
-0.0319562703,
0.0031222126,
0.00599596,
0.0482986048,
0.0169895384,
0.0270275399,
-0.0184748583,
-0.0147771724,
0.0388397761,
0.0435543694,
-0.0018386117,
-0.0181810372,
-0.0172263645,
-0.1033422425,
0.0209480971,
0.0405598991,
-0.0148625299,
0.0081408964,
-0.0223347154,
-0.0374128558,
-0.0294770002,
0.0319550484,
0.0334475487,
-0.0220323149,
0.0500815175,
0.0805038512,
-0.0482366718,
-0.0635576174,
0.0364063568,
0.0121450434,
0.0211220402,
0.0750340596,
-0.0138670877,
-0.0030285693,
-0.0245158263,
0.0513254106,
-0.036645703,
0.0530151576,
-0.0056046615,
0.058457166,
0.0151407318,
-0.0199693255,
0.0183638409,
0.0242074877,
0.0042431662,
0.016434839,
0.0019604366,
0.0926771238,
-0.0166742522,
-0.0370310135,
0.0376189984,
-0.0257361624,
0.001533516,
0.0379579477,
0.0173407234,
-0.0169843547,
-0.0473642498,
-0.0088198045,
0.0173133034,
-0.0261296965,
0.0106853917,
0.0299758837,
-0.0393335633,
-0.0101016471,
-0.0199241154,
-0.0433407687,
0.0163582899,
0.0747733787,
0.0188320205,
-0.0080658887,
0.0067941421,
0.0342678763,
-0.0188744292,
0.0334769972,
-0.0070417598,
-0.0070577785,
-0.0465961918,
0.0158618782,
0.0375195853,
-0.0052258861,
-0.0270789862,
-0.0152898561,
-0.0662371442,
-0.0522369705,
0.0839093551,
0.0407872461,
0.0300019328,
0.0649086833,
0.0176841374,
-0.0294233374,
0.0489889197,
0.0309885796,
-0.0086795781,
0.022690583,
0.0712602511,
-0.0115911821,
0.008230661,
0.0390977636,
-0.0440565757,
0.0080230664,
0.0239699315,
-0.0175325554,
-0.0060140663,
0.0220830012,
0.0235954802,
-0.0056770686,
0.0389786176,
0.000789553,
-0.0285266694,
-0.0145486537,
0.0349875242,
0.0640345365,
0.0020603999,
-0.0295520853,
0.0267464295,
0.0129510555,
-0.0022271727,
0.0045440067,
0.017427111,
0.0067708371,
0.006050711,
-0.0098079983,
-0.0198508333,
0.0381634161,
0.0390953422,
0.0422274396,
0.0191988256,
-0.0165319834,
-0.0118113067,
0.0018627257,
0.023775639,
-0.0021927583,
0.0559591427,
0.0006426548,
0.0579576157,
-0.0473210961,
-0.0486329049,
-0.0682886615,
-0.0716672316,
-0.0538865849,
0.0191436596,
0.0175777543,
-0.0431183614,
0.0311917588,
-0.0372058041,
0.0011185609,
0.009126069,
0.0047308835,
-0.0170630421,
-0.0442617722,
0.0225415379,
-0.0048847049,
-0.0405190736,
-0.000134198,
0.0531164557,
-0.0064376867,
0.0885874182,
0.0174548198,
0.0241818279,
-0.0341321863,
0.0244187787,
0.0658272952,
0.0127488347,
-0.0105647482,
-0.0214841273,
-0.0226583984,
-0.0544159003,
0.0019572875,
-0.0041330843,
0.0151281049,
-0.0313016027,
0.0097238533,
0.0528346971,
-0.0384450331,
0.0320422761,
-0.0242847074,
-0.0105364118,
0.0037018987,
0.0140534835,
-0.0361338854,
-6.169900953e-33,
-0.0431489535,
0.0284951143,
-0.0008455256,
-0.0308207888,
0.0022493359,
0.0381894968,
-0.0098408954,
-0.0213603489,
0.0124593265,
0.004225147,
-0.0312851481,
0.012574425,
0.0307576954,
0.0267128609,
0.0625797734,
-0.0242639836,
0.0697325096,
-0.0415812731,
-0.014176311,
0.0281584077,
0.0660879016,
0.0808729008,
0.0985867232,
-0.0181656107,
0.0299040265,
0.0113676181,
-0.0437643304,
0.0077361432,
-0.0340456143,
0.0420531444,
0.0045572845,
0.0172818787,
0.0051869941,
-0.0530652702,
-0.0760412142,
-0.0674537942,
-0.0424162298,
-0.0451694466,
-0.0172217302,
0.0368582495,
-0.0067628701,
0.0301858634,
0.0298707895,
-0.004626425,
-0.0406298712,
-0.0006634259,
0.0155361462,
-0.0303111132,
-0.0525765829,
-0.0140799619,
0.0068595135,
-0.0033339693,
-0.0077992347,
-0.020737974,
0.0326948836,
0.0409172736,
0.0031028092,
-0.0053030606,
-0.0735204145,
0.0263955574,
0.0423609614,
0.0455637164,
0.0642876625,
0.0199003462,
0.0016433906,
0.0324822851,
0.0515729114,
0.0112290941,
0.0309843067,
-0.0363246128,
0.0723849237,
0.0067211199,
0.0197778344,
-0.0164853521,
0.0777786747,
-0.0189149398,
0.0039182552,
0.0059723821,
0.0246249884,
0.0701082349,
0.0499334633,
0.0149117336,
-0.0356084295,
-0.0515180603,
-0.0439030379,
-0.0490015037,
-0.0235357955,
-0.0116364053,
0.0197262838,
0.0269396417,
0.0036754324,
0.0048869322,
0.0268891156,
-0.0203315243,
-0.0251232944,
0.0112645179,
-0.0128378086,
-0.0178232919,
-0.0239816979,
0.0321884006,
-0.043730583,
-0.0632184222,
-0.0205742586,
0.0100122783,
-0.0055411048,
0.0045255772,
0.033057984,
0.0617688745,
-0.0799642056,
-0.0007442475,
-0.0265215691,
0.0050795735,
0.0323274955,
0.0129074194,
0.0680876449,
-0.0148342401,
0.0001585494,
0.0581306703,
0.0501817018,
-0.0337461904,
-0.0327591486,
0.002187216,
0.0098901698,
0.0331197977,
-0.0258791689,
-0.0162993837,
-0.0435640514,
-0.028447086,
0.0703629926,
-0.02769248,
-0.0037239471,
0.0121381748,
2.604e-7,
-0.0122118844,
0.0323061794,
-0.0182401221,
-0.0176438931,
0.0282232761,
0.0672071427,
-0.0687260255,
0.0062902123,
0.0041272147,
0.0433943458,
0.0491593666,
-0.0319319777,
0.0609053522,
0.0178453848,
-0.0461802334,
-0.0106729399,
-0.0951068252,
0.0211258978,
-0.0449365601,
-0.0194248166,
0.0064426335,
0.1298285574,
0.0628936812,
-0.0132882232,
0.0291314162,
-0.0386440866,
0.0368298143,
-0.0042794794,
-0.01008063,
-0.0119628245,
0.0216225386,
0.0521108657,
-0.0086761191,
-0.0047098999,
-0.0406998508,
-0.0089667644,
-0.0469485037,
0.0120439697,
0.0015587744,
0.002897077,
0.0070543638,
0.022330489,
-0.0389093123,
-0.037445087,
0.0391078815,
-0.0761728287,
-0.0221193861,
-0.0387819596,
-0.0077887927,
-0.0174113493,
0.0087571582,
0.0214301292,
0.0158217922,
0.0355797857,
-0.0226262249,
0.0075498126,
-0.0110299382,
-0.0676515475,
-0.0030265034,
0.03851711,
-0.0189907514,
-0.0307202674,
-0.0420517959,
0.025594566,
0.032178726,
-0.1022562459,
0.0155619858,
2.547728574e-34,
0.0714161247,
-0.0080192657,
0.0059566498,
0.0598171651,
0.0136595545,
-0.0273131207,
0.0325955711,
0.050579112,
0.0245206915,
-0.0225599296,
-0.0375544317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01858v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01858v3 | Explaining latent representations of generative models with large multimodal models | 2024-02-02T19:28:33 | 2024-04-18T03:54:39 | Mengdan Zhu, Zhenke Liu, Bo Pan, Abhinav Angirekula, Liang Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Learning interpretable representations of data generative latent factors is
an important topic for the development of artificial intelligence. With the
rise of the large multimodal model, it can align images with text to generate
answers. In this work, we propose a framework to comprehensively explain each
latent variable in the generative models using a large multimodal model. We
further measure the uncertainty of our generated explanations, quantitatively
evaluate the performance of explanation generation among multiple large
multimodal models, and qualitatively visualize the variations of each latent
variable to learn the disentanglement effects of different generative models on
explanations. Finally, we discuss the explanatory capabilities and limitations
of state-of-the-art large multimodal models. | [
-0.0093268044,
0.1004525274,
-0.016784545,
0.0371153094,
-0.0041598673,
0.0169627555,
0.0682639778,
-0.0237111561,
-0.0657061934,
0.0118407076,
0.0173192024,
-0.0218638834,
-0.0061326986,
0.0503996015,
0.0639756694,
-0.0773426816,
-0.0128344372,
-0.0514315851,
-0.0241694432,
-0.0193123966,
0.025593413,
0.0022090047,
-0.0264059864,
0.0540027209,
-0.0393534899,
-0.0463720784,
-0.0430952832,
-0.002042548,
0.0031656276,
0.0046740454,
-0.0571487807,
0.0105013112,
0.0794118568,
-0.006314822,
0.0000018983,
0.0042784526,
-0.0024941913,
0.0092936279,
-0.017922163,
0.0275307652,
0.0076289782,
-0.023138674,
0.0199341457,
-0.0217544455,
-0.0168924835,
-0.0041460879,
0.0952283517,
0.0408803597,
0.0499862656,
0.0064159473,
-0.0014778334,
-0.0364749469,
-0.0021221426,
-0.0108928103,
0.0538913421,
-0.0209358186,
-0.0257566031,
0.0362054855,
-0.0075843078,
0.0288066156,
-0.0800597742,
-0.0057878182,
0.025546601,
-0.0408863053,
0.0291927233,
0.033693511,
0.06271936,
-0.0533681922,
0.0252552349,
0.0733009949,
-0.0019829161,
-0.003559269,
-0.0071655829,
-0.014468573,
-0.004226109,
0.0959551632,
-0.0813003927,
0.0176160336,
0.0190349855,
0.0149906483,
-0.0181254614,
-0.0022197373,
0.0415581428,
-0.004209857,
-0.0157706738,
-0.0059830556,
0.0189359542,
0.0270182788,
-0.0831336826,
-0.0022591869,
-0.0562546328,
-0.02899874,
-0.0175792202,
0.0297992937,
-0.0176790096,
-0.0031584154,
0.0208263546,
-0.0273575876,
-0.0303773824,
0.0306054633,
0.0322096646,
0.0423899479,
-0.0483295433,
0.0211579744,
0.0111653665,
0.0552850999,
-0.0611535721,
-0.020252293,
-0.0265859291,
-0.0102931093,
-0.0496377349,
-0.0278841518,
0.0207446665,
-0.0172580536,
-0.0396644957,
-0.0452178568,
-0.0198281724,
0.0386344306,
-0.0177250933,
-0.0081666447,
0.015677426,
0.061087992,
-0.0300579332,
-0.0055729402,
-0.0404556207,
0.0497869104,
-0.076730296,
0.022357652,
0.0312553346,
-0.0071507161,
0.000997919,
0.0335286781,
0.0316861309,
-0.0202296171,
-0.0218018722,
0.0838569105,
-0.014660676,
0.0137428818,
-0.0113613708,
-0.0386166684,
-0.0212965012,
-0.0603011176,
0.0510467254,
-0.0085076578,
0.0296053439,
0.0096675707,
-0.0020676064,
-0.0284684207,
-0.0081055397,
-0.0196654256,
-0.0148068182,
0.0934633017,
0.0015832784,
0.0093289688,
0.0237486102,
-0.0032477994,
-0.0163242035,
0.0194261223,
0.0163614471,
0.0303602405,
0.0086660786,
-0.0563608669,
0.0304828193,
-0.0055692461,
0.019384779,
-0.0140508292,
0.0120755993,
-0.0331099369,
-0.0310949311,
0.0395251364,
0.0531792678,
0.0054492331,
-0.026273055,
-0.0030501757,
0.060218025,
0.0105863996,
0.0491232947,
0.0195102748,
0.0552002564,
-0.0145432036,
-0.0287995618,
0.0272267684,
-0.0259374715,
0.0915168226,
0.0040789507,
0.013980262,
0.0615053736,
0.0288900174,
-0.0245361887,
-0.0447322056,
0.0226564147,
-0.000166915,
-0.028404275,
0.0174495913,
0.0632392392,
-0.0289527606,
-0.0274966452,
-0.0136432359,
0.0262528434,
-0.0252898242,
-0.0117730293,
-0.0316450745,
0.053384345,
0.0678965151,
0.0483567938,
0.0061886073,
0.0064129406,
-0.0053695343,
-0.0013723929,
0.0151674878,
-0.0356366783,
-0.0028626921,
0.0145080518,
-0.0319009982,
-0.0570216738,
-0.0603059605,
0.0167122278,
0.0165592507,
-0.0202246234,
-0.0560857207,
-0.0123762451,
-0.038342528,
0.0393704847,
0.0071000904,
-0.0039225365,
-0.0132631762,
-0.0250802059,
0.0071361656,
0.0438545533,
0.0240418985,
0.0160701331,
0.0204922855,
0.0142201949,
-0.0315224789,
-0.004815408,
0.0356159471,
-0.0191690661,
-0.0363613479,
-0.0173234157,
-0.0839919746,
0.003711066,
-0.0212574154,
-0.0411949009,
-0.0498854965,
0.0594326146,
-0.027927218,
0.003220384,
-0.0451127291,
-0.0300203376,
0.0351222493,
0.0381935164,
-0.0145772584,
0.061461661,
-0.0346684568,
-0.01896571,
0.0235035848,
0.0497763418,
0.0212856214,
0.0118069584,
0.0416737199,
0.010756352,
-0.0105577139,
-0.0102805058,
0.0103316046,
-0.0389451422,
0.0068167173,
0.01466248,
-0.0366798788,
-0.0230267607,
0.0022028689,
-0.0199388713,
0.0229229257,
-0.0249911696,
0.0242459532,
0.0058222795,
-0.017835265,
0.0475917086,
0.0308602061,
0.0091737723,
0.0227574669,
-0.022495104,
-0.00738924,
-0.0246027876,
0.0129074408,
-0.0118877655,
0.1189760342,
0.0183232576,
0.0071324143,
-0.0400354527,
-0.0225505084,
-0.0257604271,
-0.010313198,
-0.0159053691,
-0.0365966596,
0.0545764044,
-0.0371301472,
0.0574264489,
0.0463556498,
0.0022136085,
0.0873637944,
0.0211840738,
-0.0106748631,
-0.0400856696,
-0.0261697341,
-0.0362637155,
-0.013593805,
0.0074469871,
-0.0622665584,
-0.0438148603,
0.0569484495,
0.025192149,
-0.0158194844,
-0.0505391173,
0.0632358417,
0.0307387877,
-0.0415462255,
-0.0261493232,
-0.0167161003,
0.0145445876,
0.0595788695,
-0.0477406494,
-0.0708218962,
0.0452377275,
-0.0219870079,
0.0098758088,
0.0548972189,
0.012885836,
-0.0083843535,
0.0815258846,
0.0256919526,
0.0334012173,
0.0083490517,
0.011791232,
-0.0410209745,
0.0253221598,
0.0630395859,
0.0100768488,
-0.0032605072,
-0.0512992479,
-0.0185288303,
0.029483486,
0.0024035608,
-0.010649953,
-0.0164568312,
0.0102841184,
0.008200706,
0.0251353756,
-0.0037970799,
-0.022596512,
0.0051643732,
0.0338668413,
-0.0475071371,
-0.0190678537,
-0.0048831608,
-0.0177362282,
0.0437307246,
0.039361354,
0.0169241913,
0.0118650356,
-0.089889653,
0.0063594496,
0.0055752234,
-0.014500034,
-0.0097255344,
-0.0689474717,
0.0298493635,
-0.0260791685,
0.0537302643,
-0.0015488876,
0.0261958987,
0.0607774481,
-0.0253574606,
0.0164674595,
0.0544103533,
-0.003752742,
-0.0053915465,
0.033003252,
0.0047968002,
0.0122289155,
0.0127446456,
0.0133679966,
-0.0411899649,
-0.0342909954,
-0.032765612,
-0.02156711,
0.032296475,
0.0035204543,
0.0140513228,
-0.0679897815,
0.0707981586,
-0.0011294368,
-0.0165313315,
-0.0471110903,
-0.0119433189,
-0.0294404794,
-0.0138137564,
-0.033052776,
-0.0039852164,
0.0211699009,
0.0324001834,
0.0339081101,
0.0377279446,
-0.0494438559,
-0.0037915071,
-0.0269606393,
0.0222011805,
0.061942637,
0.0211250242,
0.0054974458,
-0.0505600385,
-0.0205101296,
0.0166643821,
0.0300378688,
0.0080137076,
0.0578903444,
0.0336902142,
-0.024124464,
-0.0446949452,
0.0722024441,
-0.0065545277,
-0.0331715383,
-0.0524218492,
0.0535470396,
-0.0355951861,
-0.0161027554,
-0.0285849888,
0.0194683056,
-0.0046079946,
0.0263529792,
0.0363641791,
-0.0413370915,
-0.0555777289,
-0.0418957584,
0.0129568838,
-0.0198586043,
-0.0032451414,
0.0015060902,
0.0519154593,
-0.0081140362,
-0.0411647223,
0.0086703598,
0.0127605889,
0.0255968329,
-0.0090166777,
-0.009117458,
-0.0508020036,
-0.0133277718,
-0.0210819021,
0.0536727309,
0.0368677527,
-0.0049626781,
0.0171944965,
-0.030858852,
0.0093833273,
-0.0863204524,
-0.0243402366,
0.0074026491,
-0.0613906533,
-0.0316487998,
-0.0269527379,
0.0469812565,
0.0241726376,
0.0256320592,
0.0416273288,
-0.0738753155,
-0.0113606667,
0.0111886319,
-0.0205235165,
-0.0072528748,
-0.0097333724,
0.0407625139,
0.0008362633,
0.0085129151,
-0.0217007175,
0.0277392026,
-0.0107186288,
0.015952209,
-0.0263728797,
-0.0200821124,
0.0308318492,
-0.031198075,
0.0345020927,
-0.038641572,
-0.0231056884,
-0.0582616776,
-0.0244226549,
-0.0119316727,
-0.0000338306,
-0.046424482,
0.0060326783,
0.0354514383,
-0.013125062,
0.0006221668,
-0.0246453267,
0.0243262965,
0.0286428705,
-0.0467433594,
-0.0023927719,
0.025131911,
-0.0177650005,
-0.0268767346,
0.0386657193,
0.0191567112,
0.0211143941,
-0.0565385409,
0.0147236064,
0.0155305509,
0.1208138093,
0.0108039621,
-0.0020119026,
-0.0263764951,
0.0015503725,
-0.0691561103,
-0.0286402609,
-0.0155540025,
0.0351506807,
0.0459121615,
0.0257327892,
0.0288914666,
0.0019149444,
-0.0031567519,
0.0062624021,
0.1006463468,
0.0523807928,
-0.0269035716,
0.0527818985,
0.0070734876,
0.0042358651,
-0.0443313681,
0.0640239939,
0.0426562615,
0.002892572,
-0.0446073376,
0.0037376191,
-0.0201931428,
-0.0208999068,
0.0277472176,
0.0363690481,
0.0133238062,
0.0502010584,
-0.0269361157,
-0.0408655144,
-0.0649205372,
0.0370216668,
-0.0299410336,
0.0079035014,
0.0236308761,
0.0523128435,
-0.0163520053,
-0.0560564213,
-0.0390461758,
0.024138147,
-0.0302502159,
0.021624729,
0.0005089788,
-6.298963621e-33,
-0.0203178525,
-0.0768121853,
0.0215194169,
-0.0428585857,
-0.0196605846,
-0.0071577555,
-0.0468062386,
-0.0158626176,
0.008619939,
0.0346018225,
0.0462050587,
-0.0203457847,
-0.016990006,
0.0433303975,
0.0280691683,
-0.0058240853,
0.0363827534,
0.0129146101,
-0.0006508356,
0.0380733758,
0.052236639,
0.0077568125,
0.0157666821,
-0.0556775182,
0.0187539607,
-0.0187398307,
-0.0487003475,
-0.0004348756,
-0.0177181121,
0.0567620248,
-0.0734456405,
0.0047003594,
0.0225547999,
-0.0434685238,
-0.0137515226,
0.0083583761,
-0.0563278832,
0.0112073952,
0.0216571633,
-0.0139817977,
-0.097253345,
-0.0587512702,
0.0101948865,
-0.018411696,
0.0115524083,
-0.0443186462,
0.0500932038,
-0.0080005312,
0.0037071933,
-0.0137056084,
-0.0667602643,
-0.0034768006,
-0.0698219761,
-0.0211352184,
-0.0035355028,
0.0398734398,
0.0250322316,
0.0414001644,
-0.0008131797,
0.0213528089,
0.0190505534,
-0.0237806011,
0.1026607603,
0.0363081321,
0.0321408138,
0.0497503653,
0.0151026165,
-0.0484641716,
-0.0887781009,
-0.0055003399,
-0.0342935473,
0.0927504301,
0.0557578169,
0.078347519,
0.02543067,
0.0450438485,
-0.0451112352,
0.0367992893,
-0.063439101,
0.0145722711,
0.0558307394,
0.0352257751,
0.0182230268,
-0.0055258027,
-0.0466471575,
-0.0246796757,
-0.0456561148,
-0.0256291702,
0.0288861822,
-0.0214337017,
-0.0566048212,
-0.0040325234,
0.049364116,
-0.0734537318,
0.0082675423,
0.0018623337,
-0.0121252611,
0.034675274,
0.0072559724,
-0.0161844082,
0.015775729,
-0.0123565271,
0.0566995554,
-0.0143975383,
0.0340288319,
0.0197404064,
0.0076460722,
0.011334002,
0.009303309,
-0.0105623454,
-0.0717853904,
-0.0427158587,
-0.0287304372,
-0.0302835815,
0.0260394961,
0.0025747684,
-0.0662750676,
-0.0130082779,
0.0147459079,
0.0409292132,
0.0176614244,
-0.0385547169,
-0.024792999,
0.0081154834,
-0.0268430151,
0.0140809454,
-0.0312861577,
-0.0833459273,
0.0586189628,
-0.0617741831,
-0.0310413167,
0.0515431948,
2.507e-7,
0.0471080616,
0.0195970684,
0.005480167,
-0.0054091904,
0.0550242513,
0.0314686224,
0.0106074894,
-0.0209348407,
-0.0065584425,
-0.0430461876,
0.0136019411,
0.061610464,
0.0299187265,
0.0231772158,
0.0405678935,
0.0070529459,
-0.0131170964,
-0.0222003292,
-0.0398671553,
0.0249908902,
0.0834008455,
0.0526375361,
-0.0370508395,
-0.0177319571,
0.071489878,
-0.0038112686,
0.1002235785,
-0.0213017948,
0.0013601206,
-0.0325506106,
0.0050214007,
-0.0349591263,
0.016747199,
-0.0000732689,
-0.0029604128,
-0.0560379736,
0.0281271487,
0.0378229879,
-0.0143220583,
-0.0382173397,
-0.017192876,
-0.0009071167,
0.0031885887,
-0.060297247,
0.0666440353,
-0.0366711393,
-0.0613615029,
-0.0087426007,
-0.0285630822,
-0.0157265831,
0.0001763546,
-0.0254578106,
0.0122892857,
-0.0025802841,
-0.0264669545,
-0.0184177067,
0.0050888048,
-0.0439749584,
-0.018787073,
0.0147769535,
-0.0710917413,
-0.0008928642,
-0.0392095894,
-0.0436030142,
0.0814081281,
0.0121074514,
-0.0666487217,
1.819767078e-34,
0.0130936448,
0.0155036701,
0.000933983,
-0.0121873273,
0.0416980535,
-0.0217898544,
-0.04029328,
-0.0157243069,
0.0217405204,
-0.0714120045,
-0.03309495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01841v1 | COMET: Generating Commit Messages using Delta Graph Context Representation | 2024-02-02T19:01:52 | 2024-02-02T19:01:52 | Abhinav Reddy Mandli, Saurabhsingh Rajput, Tushar Sharma | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Commit messages explain code changes in a commit and facilitate collaboration
among developers. Several commit message generation approaches have been
proposed; however, they exhibit limited success in capturing the context of
code changes. We propose Comet (Context-Aware Commit Message Generation), a
novel approach that captures context of code changes using a graph-based
representation and leverages a transformer-based model to generate high-quality
commit messages. Our proposed method utilizes delta graph that we developed to
effectively represent code differences. We also introduce a customizable
quality assurance module to identify optimal messages, mitigating subjectivity
in commit messages. Experiments show that Comet outperforms state-of-the-art
techniques in terms of bleu-norm and meteor metrics while being comparable in
terms of rogue-l. Additionally, we compare the proposed approach with the
popular gpt-3.5-turbo model, along with gpt-4-turbo; the most capable GPT
model, over zero-shot, one-shot, and multi-shot settings. We found Comet
outperforming the GPT models, on five and four metrics respectively and provide
competitive results with the two other metrics. The study has implications for
researchers, tool developers, and software developers. Software developers may
utilize Comet to generate context-aware commit messages. Researchers and tool
developers can apply the proposed delta graph technique in similar contexts,
like code review summarization. | [
0.0442181788,
0.0270102825,
-0.0154196657,
-0.0271027107,
-0.0228288192,
-0.0303540602,
-0.0242032222,
0.0086571481,
-0.029837735,
-0.0236988179,
0.0154936919,
0.002945544,
0.0226634406,
0.0256281439,
-0.0133691086,
-0.0569968,
0.021200506,
0.0073813833,
0.0140401842,
0.0659391657,
-0.0032157658,
0.0145668099,
0.0230326802,
0.0428926088,
-0.0213784855,
-0.0429988503,
-0.0008731954,
0.0575680509,
0.0600776672,
-0.0071486095,
-0.0172534529,
0.0634322986,
-0.0432302356,
0.0341477171,
0.0000021327,
-0.0223361608,
-0.0133831538,
-0.0039764713,
-0.0096433377,
0.0460882001,
-0.0035521111,
-0.0460895561,
-0.0316550434,
0.0141023863,
-0.0207210742,
0.0164272729,
0.0734395981,
-0.0095068486,
0.1187804341,
0.0356865078,
0.0088389628,
-0.0024242881,
-0.0188718848,
0.0188361239,
0.0333734751,
0.0249015074,
-0.0486169346,
0.0554529987,
-0.0151638892,
0.0342751145,
0.0125652049,
-0.0010045407,
0.0109456312,
-0.0275331456,
0.0505262837,
0.0342393182,
0.030063808,
-0.0212997552,
0.0228054766,
0.0166134927,
-0.026016688,
-0.0342211165,
0.0128437718,
-0.0283030737,
-0.0376196615,
-0.0103640538,
-0.0624717362,
0.0027388611,
0.0049356101,
-0.0188416019,
-0.0628405139,
-0.0174812265,
-0.0010770269,
-0.0679668337,
-0.0109998193,
-0.0312611274,
-0.0049068253,
0.0261719525,
-0.0636945739,
-0.0172180496,
-0.0175417531,
-0.0617438257,
-0.0270445049,
0.0215387065,
-0.0191519074,
-0.0102808094,
0.0039785397,
-0.0767425597,
0.0762275383,
-0.0222690385,
-0.0204241574,
0.0051423968,
-0.0222428106,
-0.0249062106,
-0.0202204492,
0.0727089345,
0.0321670435,
-0.0052409549,
0.0387775935,
0.0034641225,
-0.0571975559,
-0.0009734082,
-0.0176963061,
-0.0104760453,
0.0490329303,
0.0355990864,
-0.0097502675,
0.0703036413,
-0.0025174224,
0.0703464672,
0.0333421864,
-0.0488822125,
-0.0687364861,
0.0232291687,
0.0553181246,
-0.0417956673,
-0.0266959574,
-0.0522377826,
-0.0033706147,
0.0118999267,
-0.0326581448,
-0.0156481154,
-0.0148946373,
0.0007035447,
-0.0351261124,
0.0597504824,
0.0476224422,
0.0449233018,
-0.0004670458,
-0.0368920006,
-0.0318082534,
0.0121490704,
-0.0684033409,
-0.0663202554,
-0.0495570302,
0.0324249864,
0.0085055195,
-0.0768209398,
-0.0255497918,
-0.0137998657,
0.020446945,
-0.0063601476,
-0.0940342322,
0.0305214934,
-0.0006309334,
0.0271096472,
-0.0554623604,
-0.0185193717,
0.0160121024,
0.0497144572,
0.0303859171,
-0.0422327444,
0.0551478304,
-0.0243587252,
-0.0155031681,
0.0411480181,
0.0096808383,
-0.0014475993,
0.0329955705,
-0.0379845947,
0.0093934434,
0.0225925054,
0.0021752613,
-0.0321240388,
0.0121368915,
-0.0002081105,
0.024793325,
0.0325852856,
-0.0011764172,
0.0678370446,
-0.0323235653,
-0.014955407,
-0.0146695971,
0.0712150484,
0.0172374062,
0.0283679832,
-0.0274983253,
0.0155253354,
0.006458893,
-0.013278326,
-0.0183273237,
0.0035994025,
-0.0552664809,
-0.0445473865,
0.0017316446,
0.0111283017,
-0.0118183596,
0.0448631905,
0.039928142,
-0.0660520867,
-0.0565877408,
-0.0037167999,
0.0320680961,
0.057816796,
0.055528339,
-0.03128279,
-0.0499501377,
-0.022631593,
-0.0102022784,
-0.0109048272,
0.0612684749,
0.0004036636,
-0.0227526315,
-0.0401141606,
-0.0166803468,
-0.0300075226,
-0.0136341415,
0.0279459171,
-0.0102627045,
-0.003865689,
0.0414174572,
-0.0237255637,
-0.0287842881,
-0.0009310666,
0.0891869515,
0.0390556827,
0.0141848419,
-0.0361306444,
0.0111460658,
0.036206726,
-0.0392894186,
0.0006358516,
0.0454562381,
0.0308393221,
-0.0532727838,
0.0573952235,
0.0045645386,
0.0208763611,
-0.0010922406,
-0.0205430742,
0.0033919387,
-0.025813479,
-0.0522720627,
-0.014586349,
0.034299992,
-0.0181143321,
0.0324557684,
0.0271170065,
0.0220808573,
-0.0342009328,
-0.0330615342,
-0.0294255149,
0.0071489783,
0.0293540657,
-0.0160361584,
-0.030597806,
0.0497404337,
0.0348065645,
0.0257662553,
-0.0159898587,
0.0349317715,
-0.0327965468,
0.0166631714,
0.0144378589,
0.028746495,
-0.0013235583,
-0.0333683342,
-0.0831103697,
-0.0479872338,
-0.0108539695,
0.0083891405,
0.0337142013,
0.0378557332,
-0.0036326544,
-0.001268941,
-0.0227067247,
-0.0014575089,
-0.0060105561,
-0.012640411,
0.0306082685,
-0.004270595,
-0.0277320612,
-0.0496591069,
-0.0086948751,
-0.028473286,
0.0594695061,
0.034465991,
-0.0570523068,
-0.0800487176,
0.0483591482,
-0.0091151055,
-0.030398244,
0.0043467432,
-0.0351640545,
0.0128263459,
-0.0184949487,
0.0962092429,
-0.0006473089,
0.0200082045,
0.0191036183,
0.0346062295,
0.0098035894,
-0.0518451259,
-0.0197683033,
0.0126521364,
-0.0516200922,
0.0260474384,
-0.0319573544,
0.079320848,
-0.0035546289,
0.0272249524,
-0.010055583,
-0.0473167375,
-0.0046051224,
-0.0030045297,
0.0555983819,
0.0490346588,
-0.0452536494,
0.0035018858,
0.0074475282,
-0.0158196539,
-0.069963485,
0.0311029926,
-0.0497823991,
0.0067889597,
-0.0150902113,
-0.0127355,
-0.0608826391,
0.0812881663,
-0.0217704587,
0.0103585292,
0.0096381838,
-0.009918781,
0.0099810734,
0.0051753493,
0.0246533416,
0.0200222135,
0.0102968859,
-0.0337757729,
-0.0087466342,
-0.0013169441,
0.0437976941,
0.0188714378,
0.0034806079,
-0.0338591412,
-0.0283615515,
0.0186567362,
-0.0259658583,
0.0514910519,
0.0806170851,
-0.0198262651,
0.0227165762,
0.0532292165,
-0.0455456413,
-0.0155252274,
-0.0821746066,
-0.0270997174,
-0.0478360355,
-0.018611867,
-0.0192152802,
-0.0207180101,
0.0699539557,
0.0796614438,
0.0187952872,
-0.052622769,
-0.0758201033,
-0.0242946912,
-0.0363406017,
-0.0444173925,
-0.0032226564,
0.0356506035,
-0.0180775933,
0.0205236543,
0.0694158897,
0.0201150775,
-0.0724322945,
0.0295695849,
0.0016325141,
0.0726292655,
0.0267206002,
0.0166658796,
-0.1251511723,
-0.0290981475,
-0.0297419522,
-0.0008350016,
0.0191604439,
-0.006104988,
-0.0054535116,
0.0078457873,
0.0303834286,
0.0197495297,
-0.0112504354,
-0.0095554292,
-0.0614771023,
0.0145300673,
-0.0006906906,
-0.0723070502,
-0.0040072263,
0.0255656745,
0.0309664812,
-0.0190780517,
-0.0320006907,
0.0174790453,
0.0145060048,
-0.0387107022,
-0.0081245452,
0.0414226502,
0.0112318452,
0.0399695896,
0.0245233402,
0.0491770208,
-0.0092872931,
0.0212114528,
-0.0182627328,
0.0339936092,
0.0112969987,
-0.007185339,
0.0391077623,
-0.0513752028,
-0.0242229439,
-0.0379390791,
0.0158656891,
0.0290714502,
-0.0443068445,
-0.0358632766,
-0.0113844145,
0.0013180204,
0.0081798118,
0.0152573101,
0.076546602,
-0.0131403422,
-0.0415605307,
-0.0455828458,
0.0546147153,
0.0050561237,
0.0072832941,
-0.0838269293,
-0.0085159233,
-0.0209110212,
-0.0737943798,
-0.019576313,
-0.0181098264,
0.0374235734,
0.0412467271,
-0.041866228,
0.003051135,
-0.020778114,
-0.0635436848,
-0.0047117202,
-0.0091492077,
0.0169172436,
-0.013924446,
-0.0127039971,
0.004812777,
0.0654016361,
-0.0032976198,
-0.0107849678,
-0.0351701677,
-0.0318396166,
-0.0290509053,
0.0302393083,
0.0232807845,
0.0015636007,
-0.027442148,
-0.03146616,
-0.05476759,
0.0068361578,
0.0021486001,
-0.0005721268,
0.0160212107,
-0.0270150229,
-0.0131176645,
-0.0479388312,
-0.0584921502,
-0.0167406294,
-0.0132231899,
-0.0097135482,
-0.0257273316,
-0.0521520451,
-0.0044359714,
0.0028674039,
0.0190022141,
0.0573281981,
-0.0041837874,
0.0040895147,
-0.0143559733,
0.0088167274,
0.0056619192,
-0.0039440598,
0.036929138,
-0.0204722844,
-0.060437616,
0.0132477311,
0.0649363101,
-0.0563891232,
0.0067478432,
0.0019341818,
0.0167241227,
0.0132966135,
0.0457846224,
0.0249194186,
-0.0113343224,
-0.0249493252,
-0.0313608237,
0.0171874519,
0.0156251229,
-0.0048783044,
0.0258108657,
0.0314436592,
-0.0068140943,
0.026294684,
0.0370395146,
-0.0797992051,
-0.0098115113,
-0.008109686,
-0.0329187252,
0.0284240283,
0.0972596034,
0.0780983716,
-0.0215302501,
0.0132754371,
-0.0391251259,
0.0768531486,
0.0116972709,
-0.0221238863,
-0.017138239,
-0.0252456889,
-0.0024487057,
-0.0105341487,
0.0413079672,
-0.0570135266,
-0.0097194947,
-0.0613252297,
-0.0392635912,
-0.0271244999,
0.000081754,
-0.0055143544,
-0.0288397148,
0.0157663021,
-0.0615491159,
-0.0669981986,
-0.0016445263,
0.0565614402,
0.022754211,
0.045834817,
-0.0133812008,
0.0053013884,
0.0686374083,
0.0315666348,
-0.0335554071,
0.0121736573,
-0.0041457349,
-0.0198829602,
-0.0125397351,
-0.0468391925,
-5.151183019e-33,
-0.0170579702,
-0.0586838797,
-0.0416935422,
0.0514819436,
-0.0252275541,
-0.0193015747,
-0.0719857439,
-0.0075025721,
-0.0034853092,
-0.0371260606,
0.0090087596,
0.0377474837,
0.0017751084,
-0.0890785456,
0.0521504432,
0.0557382219,
0.0951206163,
0.0591159016,
-0.0395925716,
0.1065222844,
0.0149216689,
-0.0141916908,
0.008768091,
-0.0515523963,
0.0243772361,
-0.0072341827,
0.0187517256,
-0.0168996807,
0.0521415435,
0.0233133305,
0.0337316766,
-0.0210647378,
-0.0051330859,
-0.0029895026,
-0.0444848612,
-0.0498402938,
0.0075106462,
-0.0336746015,
0.0026338259,
-0.0021035275,
0.0534028299,
-0.0495193712,
0.0095710754,
0.0036561962,
0.0115773492,
-0.0323746391,
0.0214198586,
0.0408813655,
-0.0406413563,
-0.0363008566,
-0.0233749989,
0.0417285748,
-0.057928782,
0.0571397841,
-0.02904303,
0.028836403,
0.0406577401,
0.0125938542,
-0.0259476304,
0.0155907907,
0.0338177048,
0.013557855,
0.0457712226,
-0.0007213294,
-0.0181232449,
0.0055267001,
0.0112363147,
0.0627364218,
0.0081689386,
0.0480029397,
0.0302121788,
0.0601490997,
0.0621556677,
0.0365174823,
-0.0238537211,
-0.0190247688,
0.0423144028,
0.0356892347,
-0.0243067611,
0.0313580222,
-0.0047575366,
0.0507535525,
-0.035774,
-0.0048954324,
-0.0060187127,
-0.022866372,
-0.0011664926,
-0.0530554242,
0.0159551706,
-0.0338115767,
-0.0083119087,
0.0401098505,
-0.0093598254,
-0.0138293924,
0.0621263832,
0.0483545884,
-0.0642585754,
0.0408699475,
-0.0321095586,
-0.0551761352,
0.0240529533,
0.0104728304,
0.0283326693,
0.0556630269,
0.0792382509,
0.0161255915,
0.0385338105,
0.016669089,
-0.0522084758,
0.026375629,
-0.0115600992,
-0.0108760167,
-0.0900517032,
-0.0755989403,
-0.0314562321,
-0.0112311384,
0.0183771811,
0.0634968728,
0.0024589116,
0.0231128,
-0.0353565924,
0.0795779973,
-0.0001771786,
0.0486277677,
-0.0240896735,
-0.0115407463,
0.0345795453,
0.0131762801,
0.0514834262,
-0.0186842717,
-0.0499552228,
-0.0112130465,
2.704e-7,
0.0029390599,
0.0666766316,
0.0476226918,
-0.0112148169,
0.0111728348,
0.0500807352,
-0.0199807286,
-0.0107114445,
0.0439293683,
0.0442620553,
-0.0165843628,
0.005276728,
0.0176300984,
0.0565721244,
-0.0101647964,
-0.0003123025,
-0.0635469258,
-0.0241348799,
-0.0810760632,
0.0160241816,
0.0994361117,
0.000702269,
0.0146387676,
0.0224513765,
0.0223423,
-0.0013093622,
-0.0221216604,
-0.0153663699,
0.0222930294,
0.0657292381,
0.0083823502,
-0.0412059538,
-0.0027086376,
-0.0204358175,
-0.040386539,
-0.0743257925,
-0.0277829934,
0.0398078188,
-0.0286787096,
0.0194875728,
0.0376376323,
0.0030148872,
0.0029417537,
-0.0326391123,
-0.0027146542,
-0.0042875269,
-0.0010318365,
-0.0220161043,
-0.0244114492,
-0.0254511088,
0.0150794918,
0.0209297221,
-0.0115262503,
0.003811101,
-0.0219702069,
0.0082777953,
-0.0234667528,
-0.0386078581,
-0.0510018542,
0.030197965,
0.0159755982,
-0.0219582152,
-0.0084162075,
0.0057038763,
0.0207994748,
0.026407348,
0.038672667,
2.470285537e-34,
0.0708188713,
-0.0320865884,
0.0278872494,
-0.0291375481,
0.0189370103,
-0.0215309057,
0.0472615398,
0.0208428744,
0.0178454276,
0.0182296336,
-0.0232298896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01830v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01830v2 | PiCO: Peer Review in LLMs based on the Consistency Optimization | 2024-02-02T18:49:26 | 2024-04-20T09:09:38 | Kun-Peng Ning, Shuo Yang, Yu-Yang Liu, Jia-Yu Yao, Zhen-Hui Liu, Yu Wang, Ming Pang, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Existing large language models (LLMs) evaluation methods typically focus on
testing the performance on some closed-environment and domain-specific
benchmarks with human annotations. In this paper, we explore a novel
unsupervised evaluation direction, utilizing peer-review mechanisms to measure
LLMs automatically. In this setting, both open-source and closed-source LLMs
lie in the same environment, capable of answering unlabeled questions and
evaluating each other, where each LLM's response score is jointly determined by
other anonymous ones. To obtain the ability hierarchy among these models, we
assign each LLM a learnable capability parameter to adjust the final ranking.
We formalize it as a constrained optimization problem, intending to maximize
the consistency of each LLM's capabilities and scores. The key assumption
behind is that high-level LLM can evaluate others' answers more accurately than
low-level ones, while higher-level LLM can also achieve higher response scores.
Moreover, we propose three metrics called PEN, CIN, and LIS to evaluate the gap
in aligning human rankings. We perform experiments on multiple datasets with
these metrics, validating the effectiveness of the proposed approach. | [
0.0370526351,
0.0550010465,
0.0096377274,
0.0351690203,
-0.0233413074,
-0.0104037467,
0.0164211206,
-0.007566934,
0.023680253,
-0.0551023185,
-0.0911118612,
-0.0144555019,
-0.0089194188,
-0.0183017552,
0.0176899582,
0.0032663543,
0.0042148703,
-0.0360985361,
0.0155781861,
-0.0362402126,
-0.0292991996,
-0.0356132276,
0.0021992952,
0.03795458,
0.0812862888,
-0.0153495371,
0.0469613746,
-0.0396504216,
0.0158842448,
0.016779488,
0.0144589553,
0.0768679455,
0.0015817418,
0.0194854345,
0.0000020987,
-0.065505527,
-0.0109699024,
0.0201233774,
-0.0114773205,
0.0364177525,
-0.0087634223,
0.0411746465,
0.0098416908,
0.0080803437,
-0.0616352521,
-0.0151406629,
-0.014238419,
-0.0351997539,
0.096665293,
0.0269771889,
0.0487466976,
-0.007538233,
0.026232617,
-0.0385845043,
0.0076048579,
-0.0556268133,
0.0255051814,
0.0441458486,
-0.0042208503,
0.0510191321,
-0.0149616366,
0.0188577492,
0.014462187,
-0.0402005985,
0.0469007008,
-0.0063605974,
-0.0523391329,
0.0157819781,
0.0122936452,
0.0829698145,
0.010648163,
-0.0080976551,
-0.0053093932,
-0.0092930468,
0.0088188434,
0.0364878662,
-0.0597363226,
0.0208948348,
0.0407016426,
-0.0115134455,
-0.0228533801,
0.0234171264,
0.0299647916,
0.0153093226,
0.0175191108,
0.1119102016,
0.0127823912,
-0.0292374622,
0.0208385792,
0.0042269328,
-0.0284855291,
-0.0464804098,
-0.0168419946,
0.0218861941,
-0.0478766151,
0.0063395849,
0.0382472314,
0.0029112247,
0.043145176,
-0.0307727419,
0.0503339432,
-0.0287229735,
0.03538711,
0.0644338652,
-0.0216052067,
0.0654655695,
0.0114335045,
0.0424294658,
-0.0417385213,
-0.0101939822,
-0.072918579,
0.0002955987,
0.0345055535,
0.0347812027,
0.002944689,
0.0294245873,
-0.0723873377,
-0.0029110587,
-0.0652778074,
0.0198080651,
0.0513374321,
0.0077863503,
0.0149184456,
-0.007441787,
-0.0590469018,
0.0249745436,
-0.0024041822,
0.014195404,
-0.0219897423,
-0.021075096,
0.0241606608,
0.0221624933,
-0.022494426,
-0.0088926163,
0.0181467235,
0.0670824572,
0.0030818465,
0.0193664785,
0.0414329097,
-0.0214107651,
0.0153236575,
-0.0712631792,
-0.0206089672,
-0.0810882449,
0.0289374925,
0.0181290042,
-0.0014174739,
-0.0319331437,
0.0054467078,
0.0154296421,
0.0058112703,
0.0268198177,
0.0124347713,
0.0102353441,
0.0341022983,
0.0258856378,
-0.0318583734,
0.0263073444,
0.011205365,
-0.0081965169,
0.0392443761,
-0.0114062689,
0.0122348536,
0.0354519337,
0.0248363782,
0.0063687181,
0.0114096738,
0.065966174,
0.012613873,
0.0344888493,
0.0008781658,
0.0302235261,
0.0016462272,
-0.0341982432,
0.0467186421,
0.0462489165,
0.0187694952,
-0.0025061024,
0.022005938,
0.02890159,
0.0278639439,
0.0064165122,
-0.0376771204,
0.0342811272,
-0.0069462461,
-0.0127715264,
0.0474770702,
0.0053749173,
-0.010820087,
-0.0540055819,
-0.0121689877,
-0.0010307026,
-0.0489789136,
0.0233027562,
0.0593094714,
-0.0275255963,
0.0132403215,
0.0647142231,
-0.0076176515,
-0.0509060137,
0.0298358798,
-0.0401245058,
0.0250273459,
0.025022205,
0.0522828884,
-0.0234696846,
-0.004147748,
-0.0082645193,
-0.0100992573,
0.0244937688,
0.0230109915,
-0.0320962407,
-0.0118725719,
-0.0152989132,
-0.0430252999,
0.018540848,
-0.0143361744,
0.0032514108,
0.0096260505,
-0.024806736,
0.0085175373,
-0.0767237544,
-0.0563460402,
0.015035199,
-0.0330296345,
-0.0094895093,
0.0140365083,
-0.0159324594,
0.0485006347,
0.0259925369,
-0.0027806447,
0.0339462273,
0.0346002169,
-0.0268565547,
-0.0447384007,
-0.0512780994,
-0.017905131,
0.009759889,
0.0352824666,
-0.0632311627,
-0.027806256,
0.0512639582,
-0.0318757668,
-0.0460495874,
0.0138123743,
-0.01116791,
0.0056062564,
-0.0394697003,
-0.0006878458,
-0.0277925264,
-0.0659158453,
-0.0637325868,
0.0610919669,
-0.0192755405,
0.073617883,
0.0315415934,
0.0007254833,
0.0284155402,
-0.0104197962,
-0.0364199691,
-0.010992717,
0.0055409982,
0.0478189178,
0.0493692458,
0.0202733092,
-0.0548239946,
-0.0431243293,
-0.0804598257,
0.0078412453,
-0.0166616347,
0.0208131038,
0.0201786887,
-0.0371937975,
0.0225226674,
-0.0010153118,
-0.0643424243,
0.0109462673,
0.0116955396,
-0.0052348198,
0.0232503042,
0.0452190824,
0.0061109713,
-0.0459089689,
-0.0266858302,
-0.0087517267,
0.0319887362,
0.0227540918,
0.0389704555,
-0.038063433,
0.0526744872,
-0.0655158609,
0.020306766,
-0.0065111872,
-0.0298291687,
0.0140854297,
0.0049992483,
-0.0163962487,
0.0588350371,
-0.0010638832,
-0.0505922586,
0.0643750653,
0.0119542917,
-0.0688626617,
-0.0155567797,
-0.0098620271,
-0.0535062738,
-0.0121583082,
-0.022248283,
0.0242870208,
0.0434209928,
0.0173244216,
-0.0464035012,
-0.0184234176,
0.0242407918,
-0.0492853187,
-0.0163484383,
-0.0450795703,
0.0133557366,
-0.0014979595,
0.0296872575,
-0.0094433473,
-0.0625339001,
0.0641175732,
-0.0440299995,
0.0085227219,
-0.0122207394,
0.0068644234,
-0.0913565531,
0.0428896956,
0.0179052129,
0.0064274096,
-0.0569254123,
-0.0029534742,
-0.0592785627,
0.0183313936,
0.0478206091,
-0.0624144115,
0.0173749421,
-0.0419959128,
0.0057334695,
-0.0063261595,
-0.0435094982,
-0.0068574026,
-0.0215301588,
-0.0170698818,
0.0420545265,
0.0139338616,
-0.0130843874,
-0.0119567197,
0.003417585,
0.0136475135,
0.013052077,
-0.0151141668,
-0.0000534542,
-0.0187841244,
0.0254172068,
0.0307494048,
0.0148143722,
-0.0077332095,
-0.0335441642,
0.0044772904,
0.0521863364,
0.0409161448,
0.0128396312,
-0.0060480391,
-0.0228692405,
0.043281734,
-0.0436294265,
-0.0265082587,
0.0210289992,
0.0187493209,
-0.0338539854,
0.0205272008,
0.1255188733,
0.0278942902,
-0.0662153438,
-0.0252532214,
-0.0299397297,
0.0056603248,
0.0460315198,
0.0258172899,
-0.041392304,
-0.0062321513,
-0.0311091933,
0.0459902026,
0.0078043514,
-0.0317713171,
0.0077903029,
-0.1571540236,
0.0216764193,
-0.0063504283,
-0.0158102643,
0.0131713971,
-0.0324973799,
0.0192199852,
-0.0363173857,
-0.0212622061,
0.0239136145,
0.0050598183,
0.0187445804,
0.0120968726,
-0.0537440963,
-0.0563004091,
0.0806119442,
-0.0380963571,
0.0895831138,
0.0392696485,
0.0089094676,
-0.0315266624,
-0.0647729188,
0.0478647873,
-0.0341543034,
-0.0101850014,
-0.0047376351,
0.0167532675,
-0.0266745985,
0.0088953832,
-0.0361149386,
0.0124208461,
-0.0088698836,
0.0291840453,
0.0284664612,
0.0796449259,
0.0062628724,
0.0040985639,
-0.0041438984,
-0.0057806671,
-0.0215198547,
0.0762308612,
0.0058920048,
-0.0583757758,
0.0038779131,
-0.0121046118,
-0.0065627317,
-0.0007299102,
-0.061262548,
0.0380005054,
0.0122867478,
0.0007253036,
-0.0604592077,
0.0081174877,
0.019777609,
0.0004345986,
0.0048762592,
0.0469113812,
0.0194300208,
-0.0032564115,
-0.0206619371,
0.01450093,
-0.0455004722,
0.0104061384,
-0.0835447162,
0.0000667012,
0.0694375709,
0.0107184416,
-0.0398943275,
0.0119099291,
-0.059130311,
-0.0373607352,
-0.0369895175,
0.0756740272,
0.0220240224,
-0.0110703548,
-0.0160497501,
-0.098474443,
0.0212284084,
0.0021989574,
-0.0159074496,
0.0121484622,
-0.0015647672,
-0.0008139748,
-0.0212095082,
0.0252052397,
-0.0798287913,
0.0005546454,
0.0339446962,
0.0225267895,
-0.0156676676,
-0.0738976002,
0.014789491,
0.0205129795,
0.0255784057,
0.0155814616,
0.011644057,
0.0007462273,
0.02396027,
-0.0210960638,
-0.0335342474,
-0.0247414,
-0.0118786236,
0.0332955867,
-0.0348252431,
0.0365657695,
0.0116746733,
-0.0033345025,
0.0331192054,
-0.054627616,
0.0399007872,
0.0319838859,
-0.0102090612,
-0.007904076,
0.0031885447,
-0.0290823467,
-0.0324937925,
0.0016497433,
0.0528481565,
0.012534067,
0.053594429,
-0.0055725323,
0.0162337385,
0.0253394619,
0.0311310943,
-0.0786139816,
-0.0451264344,
-0.0355993621,
0.0466857478,
0.0425239503,
0.0726926327,
0.039580781,
0.0227125324,
0.0001995745,
-0.039027486,
-0.0182152987,
-0.0088986484,
-0.0014121091,
0.0389354378,
0.0348457247,
0.0021890379,
0.0594188012,
0.0787691697,
0.0505215526,
-0.018632371,
-0.0514289662,
-0.0031033242,
-0.0441881232,
-0.0117926979,
-0.0340836272,
0.0147140846,
-0.0196122341,
0.0109929582,
-0.0548928343,
-0.048848711,
-0.0057208245,
0.0757692233,
-0.0058038826,
0.003593025,
0.023736041,
0.0621867143,
-0.0319496393,
-0.0507004037,
-0.0651691332,
-0.0027761494,
-0.0311303996,
-0.002327132,
-0.0201540943,
-6.205648471e-33,
-0.0464429073,
-0.0662492961,
0.0014830772,
0.0055169938,
0.0033577222,
0.0161057506,
0.0020499513,
0.015990369,
-0.009716304,
-0.0189806409,
-0.0038507108,
-0.0116122086,
-0.0043786066,
0.003501876,
0.0491648912,
-0.0114425914,
0.0042981827,
-0.0314838067,
-0.0436043441,
0.0194872618,
-0.0038940641,
-0.0109853558,
0.0309896395,
-0.0605519004,
0.0744153261,
-0.0264762454,
-0.0055556563,
0.0375024453,
-0.0258699339,
0.0664694756,
0.0055664736,
0.0199430306,
0.0394221134,
-0.0589261316,
-0.0048468942,
-0.0327584334,
-0.0347788893,
-0.022449458,
0.0202140547,
-0.0199912433,
-0.042400185,
0.0016191415,
0.0624975897,
0.0108673368,
-0.0788951367,
-0.0200326014,
0.0512992963,
-0.0090391254,
0.0025927259,
-0.0167583637,
0.0216953065,
0.0174540505,
-0.0192948617,
-0.0046980409,
-0.0276378449,
0.0306387581,
-0.0236268118,
0.0331135876,
-0.0383021049,
0.017884966,
-0.0182008035,
0.0648820549,
0.0952792019,
0.0048716278,
-0.0086483536,
0.060586635,
-0.0030490009,
0.0069333045,
0.0168402586,
-0.0878228173,
-0.0058929101,
0.0572056063,
0.0817590281,
0.0768503621,
-0.0369462632,
0.0414259247,
-0.0835010633,
0.0644744188,
0.0314541645,
0.0210023038,
0.0105861407,
0.0118608428,
-0.0226292163,
-0.0121955834,
-0.0782017186,
-0.0360667892,
-0.0296240412,
-0.0145231355,
0.0331957899,
-0.0147090331,
-0.0288786106,
-0.0521917455,
0.0293638837,
-0.0602653399,
-0.0295987707,
0.0124426587,
0.0129672149,
0.0590704679,
0.0134934038,
0.0230423938,
-0.0748843625,
0.0106976228,
-0.0165611133,
0.0218396951,
0.0179265123,
0.0011562292,
-0.008770912,
-0.0161850546,
-0.0484269299,
-0.0045082183,
-0.0404319018,
-0.0374843553,
-0.0270587802,
0.0235838294,
0.0231783446,
-0.0232969355,
0.0026873853,
0.057474833,
-0.0300223827,
0.0191968661,
-0.0052012713,
0.0269403867,
0.0120808911,
-0.0206066407,
-0.0214000978,
0.0195204802,
0.024684241,
0.0210793782,
0.006853634,
0.0195202362,
0.0039375904,
-0.0104769943,
2.779e-7,
0.0476195104,
0.0470153838,
-0.0249300972,
-0.0007489197,
0.0307309274,
0.0348447748,
-0.0381831601,
0.0178878438,
0.0480699725,
-0.038857121,
-0.0023881067,
-0.0177899897,
0.041011326,
0.0173459891,
-0.0841937363,
-0.0032265768,
-0.0677175745,
0.0006838634,
-0.0086648939,
-0.0251260549,
0.0537974313,
0.0434064753,
-0.0073306202,
0.0041844067,
-0.0514600649,
-0.068305634,
0.0656253323,
-0.05401076,
-0.0610909015,
0.0363122001,
0.0365779884,
0.0227915328,
0.0159510914,
0.0331771933,
0.0022290528,
0.0191760361,
0.0603367388,
0.086838074,
0.019908322,
-0.0059333383,
0.0067169275,
-0.0215743259,
0.0206571296,
-0.0572740845,
0.0602428578,
-0.0350414291,
-0.0487769358,
-0.0294366702,
-0.0045636068,
-0.0464512035,
0.0341951922,
-0.0209565293,
-0.0177479591,
0.0103206169,
-0.0029545517,
-0.0160526037,
-0.0163766239,
-0.0254114922,
-0.0427921377,
-0.0330599658,
-0.0397541523,
-0.0969805568,
-0.0034960306,
-0.0087046986,
-0.0276535619,
-0.0435568951,
0.0112500079,
2.469252158e-34,
0.0351574086,
0.0009247709,
0.0367223211,
-0.0129971467,
0.0259198546,
0.0222017113,
-0.042878855,
-0.0020326192,
0.0058399057,
-0.0785675943,
0.0078292517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01629v1 | Position Paper: Generalized grammar rules and structure-based generalization beyond classical equivariance for lexical tasks and transduction | 2024-02-02T18:44:37 | 2024-02-02T18:44:37 | Mircea Petrache, Shubhendu Trivedi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Compositional generalization is one of the main properties which
differentiates lexical learning in humans from state-of-art neural networks. We
propose a general framework for building models that can generalize
compositionally using the concept of Generalized Grammar Rules (GGRs), a class
of symmetry-based compositional constraints for transduction tasks, which we
view as a transduction analogue of equivariance constraints in physics-inspired
tasks. Besides formalizing generalized notions of symmetry for language
transduction, our framework is general enough to contain many existing works as
special cases. We present ideas on how GGRs might be implemented, and in the
process draw connections to reinforcement learning and other areas of research. | [
0.0392301902,
0.075696826,
-0.0138693871,
-0.0139074354,
-0.0460077263,
0.0220192503,
-0.0232174601,
-0.0123608466,
-0.0682135448,
-0.0345089138,
-0.0281938687,
-0.0738408193,
0.0227052681,
-0.0072229351,
0.0442385375,
-0.0831846669,
0.0670870766,
-0.0311838742,
-0.0425461493,
-0.0135362903,
-0.0221878458,
-0.0468884334,
-0.0440973639,
0.0175256953,
-0.0181069858,
0.0307588112,
0.0092412028,
-0.0304291267,
0.0220310967,
0.0184148289,
-0.0188113563,
0.0156425908,
-0.0089907115,
0.0493928157,
0.0000014858,
-0.0579925925,
0.0288531967,
-0.0192144886,
0.0191663932,
-0.0203573368,
0.0001919708,
-0.0615929589,
-0.0316608511,
-0.0272272844,
-0.0283540636,
-0.0233519934,
0.1024752483,
-0.0406909101,
0.0241542645,
0.0764010474,
-0.0153677901,
-0.0876271203,
0.0285210796,
-0.0208319388,
0.0408218354,
-0.0006060981,
0.0358802713,
-0.0473344922,
-0.0011549249,
-0.0425308347,
-0.0478040986,
-0.0024197956,
0.0372484513,
0.039050933,
0.0192141104,
0.0485431515,
-0.0273860879,
-0.0101291277,
-0.0169521868,
0.0479345508,
0.0104688387,
-0.04248951,
-0.0030885821,
0.0220632441,
-0.0255957656,
0.0334665515,
-0.0326506458,
0.0293965843,
-0.0070325923,
0.0660904348,
0.0467528477,
-0.0569878742,
0.0180467349,
-0.0496489406,
-0.0203600693,
0.039357163,
0.0430233143,
-0.0441776738,
-0.0047414051,
0.0372283943,
-0.0437165201,
-0.0154397544,
-0.0127803823,
0.0192484949,
0.0015203134,
-0.0223897044,
7.953e-7,
-0.0448413864,
0.0069591147,
-0.0296070389,
0.0564315692,
0.0242137499,
0.0339366198,
0.0355112776,
-0.0290632546,
0.0626933724,
-0.0407594815,
0.0596501455,
-0.0851067454,
0.0110926805,
-0.0582630262,
-0.0319026932,
-0.0304131676,
0.0104533276,
0.0336880498,
-0.0035314523,
-0.0386678837,
0.02393483,
-0.0200923029,
0.0321090072,
0.0306769609,
-0.0114592202,
-0.0526209064,
-0.0132953981,
0.0344170146,
-0.0041022012,
-0.0096134553,
0.0075153899,
0.0079990225,
0.0007747663,
-0.0330652483,
-0.0071020047,
-0.0012039265,
0.0285644736,
-0.0300937667,
0.0840868205,
0.0244305003,
-0.00487966,
-0.0145557355,
0.0225643925,
-0.0211071745,
-0.0240671746,
0.0786982849,
-0.0146532869,
-0.0105794081,
0.0108084287,
-0.0171373691,
-0.045148246,
-0.0091235815,
-0.0160400532,
-0.0090080723,
0.0351172909,
0.0847815871,
0.0277252197,
-0.017775787,
-0.0379241705,
-0.0077107218,
0.0678058118,
0.0077221775,
-0.0544317774,
-0.0132928919,
-0.0275200084,
0.0466643125,
0.0349259675,
0.0113645261,
0.022918934,
-0.0360320732,
-0.0655342489,
0.0426837802,
0.0241880678,
0.027342651,
0.0638547018,
-0.0156372674,
-0.0567573011,
0.042172499,
0.058434017,
0.0170694198,
0.0481074639,
0.0674937665,
-0.0913641006,
-0.0182581674,
0.0631065518,
-0.0577083416,
0.0052381521,
-0.0280247256,
0.0354281925,
-0.0782853141,
0.0272879265,
-0.0128743537,
-0.0173949096,
-0.0159584191,
0.0022120532,
0.0349817947,
-0.0414837226,
0.054459136,
0.0511147566,
0.0038401277,
0.0233380217,
0.0132132908,
-0.035832487,
0.0206837691,
-0.0043538408,
0.0370001122,
-0.0128238043,
0.0003154958,
-0.0512048677,
-0.0165757574,
0.0085494602,
0.0258616023,
0.05484467,
0.0403796583,
0.0063230661,
0.0001613682,
-0.0333740003,
-0.0039706966,
0.0299753677,
0.055214908,
0.0053558112,
-0.0377551913,
-0.0289745145,
0.0037818237,
-0.0167422183,
0.0015406467,
0.0403940752,
0.0151067926,
-0.0278980192,
0.0180132296,
0.0088174893,
0.0262014307,
-0.0423584245,
0.009031998,
0.0595665872,
0.0090519069,
-0.0445367321,
0.0107721919,
0.0734213293,
-0.070047006,
-0.0305526201,
0.0004602807,
-0.0624869391,
0.037055213,
0.0260736942,
0.0106402738,
-0.0445044935,
0.0926456675,
-0.060706649,
0.0719234496,
-0.006508383,
-0.0064127571,
0.0220498387,
0.0042550899,
-0.0296580996,
0.0347384959,
0.0243508723,
0.0256509427,
-0.0086571649,
-0.0735659525,
-0.0153534543,
-0.0325928777,
0.0013579328,
0.048027683,
0.0058808108,
-0.0131885521,
0.0163426269,
0.0050308378,
0.0032660125,
-0.0392882414,
-0.0013398114,
-0.0458261557,
-0.0216999929,
0.0689581931,
0.0457980111,
0.0343349203,
0.011457039,
0.0068356553,
-0.0053958301,
0.0225813668,
0.0179608632,
0.0091538411,
0.0467399657,
-0.0050843819,
-0.0655247569,
-0.0127900392,
-0.0540637001,
-0.0478732325,
0.059977036,
-0.016276041,
0.0572687015,
-0.069247745,
-0.009723912,
0.0181580819,
0.0457010679,
-0.010506398,
-0.053696014,
0.0202506389,
-0.0057829069,
0.0012623727,
0.0857021809,
-0.0178733654,
-0.038300477,
0.0124084987,
-0.0145804035,
-0.0089364331,
-0.0186878461,
-0.0856332406,
0.0102209216,
-0.024387924,
0.0104552694,
0.0266002677,
0.0961942747,
-0.0058784508,
-0.0563976876,
-0.0686602443,
0.0141195729,
-0.0783368871,
-0.0015765859,
0.0055385032,
-0.036998868,
-0.0338253751,
-0.016855428,
-0.035811469,
-0.0271521304,
0.0824688375,
0.0262174737,
-0.0156331155,
-0.0563760586,
-0.004207558,
-0.056848295,
0.0546280853,
0.0426023267,
0.011854142,
0.0386034139,
-0.0128065469,
-0.0529947802,
0.0114657078,
0.0579470545,
0.0390523113,
-0.0227109678,
-0.0568362065,
-0.00955192,
-0.0058479933,
-0.048475083,
-0.0191731304,
0.0243335199,
0.0030193562,
0.0062792739,
-0.0038983335,
-0.0550061874,
-0.0007724483,
0.0202923603,
-0.0289158151,
0.0363624208,
0.008854406,
-0.0194832273,
-0.0292727519,
-0.0004998351,
-0.0077247792,
-0.0073912279,
0.0009743614,
-0.0113737229,
-0.0346871018,
0.015646914,
-0.0005369836,
0.0508645624,
0.013341777,
0.1030962393,
0.0372042432,
-0.0179953184,
-0.0529341251,
-0.0069973362,
0.0082881525,
-0.035864152,
-0.0320035592,
0.0426951684,
0.0361408405,
0.008913422,
0.0534045734,
-0.0359709561,
0.0097032581,
0.0127091836,
0.009891632,
-0.0275095087,
0.001365172,
0.0068777357,
-0.0244900528,
0.0060132551,
-0.0362243094,
0.0315425135,
-0.0128801549,
-0.0318984762,
0.0460068733,
-0.0845901892,
-0.0577135459,
-0.0044332752,
0.0290107168,
-0.060613241,
-0.0285219792,
0.0260285344,
-0.0479637459,
0.0117125595,
0.0341250785,
-0.012053716,
-0.0253696498,
-0.0202790834,
-0.0586316884,
0.0085415002,
0.089896746,
-0.0115339374,
-0.0093940906,
-0.0702504218,
0.0212374069,
0.0212518498,
-0.009413789,
0.0062194429,
-0.0453852788,
0.042998869,
-0.0291966051,
-0.0334310979,
0.0663402826,
-0.0406436771,
-0.026753258,
-0.0359671824,
0.096856758,
0.0306922328,
-0.0568192117,
-0.0301521644,
-0.0060265772,
-0.0015265143,
0.0687761232,
0.0318720341,
-0.0470908545,
-0.0446071588,
-0.0652662069,
0.0212278236,
-0.0535374768,
-0.0238204636,
0.022781536,
0.0427051373,
-0.0481399484,
-0.10521999,
0.0101071941,
0.0093070231,
0.0156542026,
0.0254741777,
-0.0479914472,
0.0367509238,
-0.0385691337,
0.0196830053,
-0.0420427844,
0.002761662,
-0.0004786431,
-0.0444137789,
-0.0011494579,
0.0407162607,
-0.0277431644,
-0.0541891083,
-0.0097020287,
-0.0051730555,
-0.0873089433,
0.0478213727,
0.0365007408,
0.021027552,
0.0128681157,
0.0040813638,
0.0141756041,
0.0294541121,
0.0269744899,
0.0155726783,
0.04953086,
0.0540301874,
-0.0466092639,
0.0353804193,
0.0050542844,
-0.0177561678,
-0.0009691891,
0.0277258828,
0.034287475,
0.0021997495,
0.0055280081,
0.0768493339,
-0.0007206603,
0.0386033617,
0.00198086,
-0.0044997428,
-0.0042446903,
0.0106837628,
0.0017717934,
0.0274510439,
-0.0487013869,
0.0085347109,
0.0291165318,
0.0237796158,
-0.0162471589,
-0.0332734846,
0.0365870856,
0.0547873564,
-0.0149328643,
0.0059055239,
0.013081396,
-0.0028862087,
-0.0015340053,
0.0507534258,
0.0353921801,
0.0432671458,
-0.0520166308,
0.0131701743,
-0.024476001,
-0.0377531163,
0.0836780816,
0.0097548915,
-0.0674703345,
-0.0214300994,
-0.0660071671,
0.0210307036,
-0.0253725965,
-0.0226285923,
0.0587520488,
0.0114949197,
-0.0115426816,
-0.0799898207,
0.0046051349,
0.017160872,
0.0176498964,
-0.0312262196,
0.0327051356,
0.0130020585,
0.0197505988,
0.0613893569,
-0.037826445,
0.0781407133,
-0.0219641663,
0.0926699191,
-0.0172221102,
0.0286004078,
-0.035478089,
0.0106116431,
-0.0068620876,
-0.0029353723,
0.0144823054,
-0.0071531604,
-0.0410766304,
-0.0444768965,
-0.030615706,
0.0324514583,
0.0454985723,
-0.0063036927,
0.0334246606,
0.0491738841,
-0.0389136039,
-0.0542242192,
0.0117496271,
-0.0441636965,
0.0418360941,
-0.0147706624,
0.0018258496,
-5.348275218e-33,
0.0067325258,
0.0374877267,
0.0209208615,
0.0552318543,
-0.0236173011,
-0.0535274819,
0.0193465762,
-0.0089905476,
0.0007783763,
0.0187954679,
0.0108965803,
0.0055303006,
0.0009096999,
0.0169630796,
0.0396482535,
-0.0118188355,
0.0044131428,
-0.0058532748,
-0.0065834527,
-0.0325797647,
-0.0036412622,
0.0088279154,
0.1129468009,
0.0231858585,
-0.0075846743,
0.050669238,
-0.004461634,
0.0308596212,
-0.0398637466,
0.0290894248,
-0.0120385066,
0.0203144774,
0.0087086568,
-0.017488353,
-0.0425934345,
0.0077010416,
-0.0386348702,
-0.0758835897,
0.0121364519,
0.019767927,
-0.0355661698,
-0.0442858562,
0.0593550578,
-0.0512215644,
-0.030009998,
-0.0158188697,
-0.0032921797,
0.0006659537,
0.0085456856,
0.0295592751,
-0.0410983749,
-0.0230208132,
-0.0324402452,
-0.0264698956,
0.0190093312,
-0.0060311733,
-0.035529159,
-0.0431376733,
0.0314904749,
0.0612071306,
-0.0002116888,
0.0462340452,
-0.0044493787,
0.0162012409,
0.0275376346,
-0.00395789,
0.0481684506,
-0.05462813,
-0.0453184471,
0.0223431773,
0.0328612663,
0.0189863369,
0.0115521681,
0.0137758311,
0.0527575128,
-0.0030922554,
-0.0594130829,
-0.0279077869,
-0.0526828915,
0.0670028552,
-0.0172920302,
0.0520642549,
-0.0268645883,
-0.0296850652,
-0.0295996442,
-0.0034545045,
-0.0050581321,
-0.0022003471,
0.0113576325,
-0.0018571161,
-0.039469026,
0.0113744866,
0.0158034638,
-0.0288949814,
-0.0218885019,
0.0331498571,
0.0035169008,
0.053065788,
-0.005988033,
-0.025242582,
-0.0295300893,
-0.0228238069,
0.0287797451,
0.0457392223,
0.0071376194,
0.0129161179,
0.0238608792,
0.0665460825,
0.0007420177,
-0.0348891839,
-0.0313367732,
-0.0195662417,
0.0257440787,
-0.0149981948,
0.0396978073,
0.0408303812,
-0.009315813,
0.0280777048,
0.0015783027,
0.0151578933,
-0.0417222492,
0.0557159521,
-0.0109524559,
0.0876373574,
0.0019571753,
-0.0411439799,
0.0146856336,
-0.0016688629,
0.0794304311,
-0.0310747102,
-0.0192517973,
0.0294688791,
2.431e-7,
0.0377614275,
0.0212421324,
0.0420283973,
0.0294776838,
0.0109178107,
0.0026915933,
-0.0183670111,
0.0301424824,
0.0024448996,
0.0119720055,
0.028652152,
0.0150785595,
-0.0247635432,
0.0131769553,
-0.0543094501,
0.0080436561,
-0.065027453,
0.0192085076,
0.0081346473,
-0.0116595272,
-0.0246182363,
0.0284689907,
0.0131164035,
-0.0137064308,
0.0018596504,
-0.0031654313,
0.0489683822,
-0.0327565297,
0.0538447276,
0.0095633594,
0.0278377552,
-0.0534342527,
0.0288698971,
0.035283044,
0.0002764388,
0.0080051627,
0.0071916971,
-0.0358758271,
-0.023680333,
0.0067420732,
-0.0208757948,
-0.0258122068,
-0.0121387672,
-0.0498646125,
0.005502413,
-0.0559361093,
0.0053384234,
0.0053701056,
-0.0176119171,
0.0251266118,
0.0350957923,
-0.0061711911,
0.0055840015,
-0.0206047576,
0.0414335318,
0.0585722663,
-0.0147033865,
-0.0346136317,
-0.0146924332,
0.0282220505,
-0.0313318186,
-0.0144435139,
0.0039286162,
0.024072146,
0.0057102391,
-0.0584825911,
-0.0559177808,
2.040837502e-34,
-0.0029567052,
-0.0192300417,
0.0443740822,
0.0124433879,
-0.0247465987,
-0.017747378,
-0.0294181406,
-0.0021262029,
0.0271127373,
-0.0525489338,
-0.0458194762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01829v1 | Predicting ATP binding sites in protein sequences using Deep Learning and Natural Language Processing | 2024-02-02T18:42:39 | 2024-02-02T18:42:39 | Shreyas V, Swati Agarwal | q-bio.BM | q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG | Predicting ATP-Protein Binding sites in genes is of great significance in the
field of Biology and Medicine. The majority of research in this field has been
conducted through time- and resource-intensive 'wet experiments' in
laboratories. Over the years, researchers have been investigating computational
methods computational methods to accomplish the same goals, utilising the
strength of advanced Deep Learning and NLP algorithms. In this paper, we
propose to develop methods to classify ATP-Protein binding sites. We conducted
various experiments mainly using PSSMs and several word embeddings as features.
We used 2D CNNs and LightGBM classifiers as our chief Deep Learning Algorithms.
The MP3Vec and BERT models have also been subjected to testing in our study.
The outcomes of our experiments demonstrated improvement over the
state-of-the-art benchmarks. | [
0.0344392359,
0.0306766275,
0.0094103245,
0.0133898631,
-0.000444277,
-0.0079038246,
0.005928671,
-0.0025828364,
0.010977569,
-0.0280237496,
-0.0111327991,
-0.0370095968,
0.0090618674,
0.0245538224,
0.0120736007,
0.0310304854,
0.0644310117,
0.0510476157,
-0.032482639,
-0.0060322946,
-0.0103296703,
0.0158838481,
0.0200352222,
0.0500290282,
-0.0005123034,
-0.0182281751,
-0.020455908,
-0.0291382838,
0.0473852456,
-0.0211767014,
-0.0207342692,
0.0448283702,
0.0221095737,
0.0524308793,
0.000001734,
-0.0612012446,
-0.0380831175,
-0.0262564979,
-0.0313463435,
0.0718609467,
-0.0591700301,
-0.02030137,
0.0052705444,
-0.0122111095,
0.0015148834,
-0.0388635583,
0.0796069056,
0.0478521883,
0.0079890126,
0.0326102525,
0.0054884218,
-0.0203149393,
0.0498502329,
-0.0348809026,
0.0470594913,
-0.0435661711,
0.0722003654,
-0.024709994,
0.0071936944,
-0.0031938807,
-0.0052175727,
0.0351880863,
-0.0290778149,
0.0063673318,
0.0353104658,
0.0546209812,
-0.0451577529,
-0.0126393512,
-0.0022025732,
0.0601195171,
-0.0392980799,
-0.0237832889,
-0.0424888358,
0.0137676839,
-0.0458227359,
0.019738622,
-0.0111277197,
-0.0105860606,
-0.0234129746,
0.0674505457,
-0.0438269451,
-0.0329426453,
0.0357205719,
0.0182395428,
0.0343882591,
0.007701552,
-0.0243143048,
-0.0519216098,
0.0201706067,
0.0332855061,
-0.0403811447,
-0.0064239069,
0.0504310355,
-0.0332426988,
0.0261572562,
0.0065221563,
0.0248423778,
-0.0064216726,
0.0224936251,
-0.1211936921,
0.0643000305,
-0.0093064336,
-0.0306018461,
0.0131666381,
-0.0767414346,
-0.0353485756,
-0.0250198264,
0.028717339,
0.0158536993,
0.0361526906,
-0.0640847608,
0.0161596872,
-0.0244885162,
0.0306156203,
0.0201295707,
-0.0257995259,
-0.0531268306,
-0.0452522524,
-0.0435342938,
-0.0147780571,
-0.0126340128,
0.1002491415,
0.0093516558,
0.0466653258,
-0.0235722158,
0.0242960434,
-0.026105985,
-0.000360119,
-0.0608305521,
-0.0439386368,
0.0118507985,
-0.0170023814,
0.0388297066,
0.0018394154,
0.0182387643,
0.0858283862,
0.0223304313,
-0.0353318751,
-0.0380709991,
-0.0323293805,
-0.0338847153,
-0.0011639057,
-0.015985284,
-0.0573497564,
0.0254075043,
0.0091953538,
-0.019628305,
0.0153499357,
0.0403048508,
0.007404888,
-0.0429090038,
0.0945702866,
0.0084237698,
-0.020561181,
0.0380665027,
0.0025903911,
0.0022138334,
0.0000265527,
0.0128988754,
0.0208956581,
0.018350577,
-0.0180924702,
0.0163077079,
-0.0134663507,
-0.0179123897,
-0.0589569286,
0.015016051,
-0.0235005599,
0.0197740532,
0.0446857512,
-0.0128166843,
-0.0059257345,
0.0411923155,
-0.0268742498,
-0.0033705439,
0.0359425731,
0.0198198762,
0.0692008287,
0.0365614779,
0.0350999385,
0.0200483017,
-0.0379827581,
0.0297464933,
0.0199908949,
0.0036147952,
0.0138184661,
0.0523760244,
-0.025734283,
0.0004538568,
-0.020318957,
-0.0411094502,
-0.0104087349,
0.0083695715,
-0.0448069833,
0.0250702891,
-0.0239199679,
-0.0728857964,
0.0591456965,
0.0189590547,
-0.0242705103,
0.0019384837,
0.0196800102,
-0.0094906827,
0.0643991977,
0.0340801366,
-0.0367815755,
0.0099260807,
-0.0139070107,
-0.0210531056,
0.0057065622,
0.0070652436,
0.0111369723,
0.0055103665,
-0.0485508256,
-0.0090062311,
-0.0346139632,
-0.0156240053,
0.0190793779,
-0.0365760624,
0.0196382981,
0.0117293969,
-0.0330141373,
-0.0129129495,
0.0093546659,
0.0409178063,
-0.0252083782,
0.0257445071,
0.0171620529,
0.0335944369,
0.0201410633,
-0.0130038094,
0.0301083196,
0.0445428155,
-0.0516204722,
-0.0254862439,
-0.0064765802,
-0.0097258426,
-0.0199998934,
0.0262946244,
-0.0193113033,
0.0076846099,
0.0311189834,
-0.0337094888,
-0.0216356535,
0.0266442392,
-0.0435741358,
0.0495761633,
-0.0236868169,
-0.0280490778,
0.0240219645,
0.051163543,
-0.0193871669,
0.0593380108,
0.024960313,
0.0383252054,
0.0304501988,
0.0034885164,
0.0558931679,
-0.0075689047,
-0.0211462136,
-0.0171972867,
-0.0338620022,
-0.0034183594,
0.0116686774,
-0.0232877489,
0.0013179379,
0.0283996686,
-0.0793900266,
-0.0011699098,
0.0195601992,
0.0068200822,
-0.03658887,
-0.0550146401,
0.0000013125,
-0.0003306164,
-0.0509885922,
0.0232208837,
-0.0691084042,
-0.0070754373,
0.0215448402,
-0.0022094403,
0.0107501401,
-0.0418741666,
-0.0078874929,
-0.0752573088,
0.0672778189,
0.0043766228,
-0.0865007266,
0.0235910248,
0.0189970732,
-0.0075213844,
0.0565337539,
0.0453979634,
-0.0379070975,
0.0139925415,
-0.013653188,
0.0111108189,
0.0160107948,
0.0309377275,
0.0287826974,
0.0354598388,
0.0478609055,
-0.0109416684,
0.0069605946,
-0.0517480597,
0.0221335702,
0.0045451447,
-0.0026657879,
-0.0178571232,
0.0562106557,
0.0295730177,
-0.0053732693,
-0.0067544458,
-0.0278290249,
0.0148764495,
-0.0112083815,
-0.0282341223,
0.0073195216,
-0.0189795494,
0.012435481,
0.0191554315,
-0.0422683507,
0.0708750039,
-0.0205549486,
0.0205621924,
-0.053957209,
-0.0248297658,
-0.017795179,
0.0078311972,
0.0142235467,
0.0555595979,
-0.0259234607,
0.0041232696,
0.0478154384,
0.0292868838,
0.0099194255,
-0.0311993062,
0.0095088109,
0.0271259584,
0.0194649789,
-0.004534137,
-0.0184285771,
-0.0225571878,
0.01082444,
-0.0394547991,
0.0269745868,
0.0052441824,
-0.0502907671,
-0.0567431264,
0.0330032147,
-0.0198766887,
-0.0160485767,
-0.0017512685,
0.0133696962,
-0.0400568172,
0.0152922319,
0.0261372458,
0.0039297752,
-0.0145082781,
0.0094909584,
0.0163300242,
0.0543608516,
-0.0560020879,
0.0471445099,
-0.0298101753,
0.0061032693,
0.0261429138,
-0.0224436801,
0.0035812499,
-0.015061372,
0.0232101213,
-0.030667251,
-0.0242073517,
0.1079700217,
0.0779947266,
-0.048827529,
0.0128640039,
0.0032758708,
-0.0422169827,
-0.0234976187,
0.003996599,
-0.0552401841,
-0.0475542061,
-0.0324709788,
0.0182459559,
0.0032234634,
-0.0116412053,
0.0188274104,
-0.0611068271,
0.0333581753,
0.0035095285,
0.0174156278,
-0.0066954978,
-0.0764231384,
-0.0340165459,
-0.0181044266,
-0.0195314083,
-0.0755661353,
0.0074806213,
-0.0013180216,
0.0532078221,
-0.0500236489,
-0.0436626039,
0.0685803816,
-0.0674788952,
-0.019130487,
0.0724214315,
0.0437127165,
-0.0107709579,
-0.0293188393,
-0.0333262309,
0.0140797002,
0.0120014278,
-0.022260135,
0.0075355922,
-0.0059706075,
-0.0313715041,
-0.0063112564,
0.0068909666,
-0.0637270138,
-0.0262400676,
-0.039408505,
0.0970875695,
-0.0265543535,
-0.0231494289,
-0.0420139916,
0.058064647,
-0.0424392745,
0.0860494152,
0.0187739693,
-0.0296407305,
-0.0248192735,
-0.0235779472,
0.066056177,
-0.0734142736,
0.0005480397,
-0.0012793523,
-0.0307453573,
-0.0182519555,
-0.0323643908,
-0.0211398564,
0.0727653429,
-0.0048011993,
0.0139273889,
0.0388352647,
0.0093893139,
-0.0371236019,
-0.0748265088,
0.0667666569,
0.0655727163,
0.0290921722,
-0.0254489593,
-0.077171348,
0.0805775449,
0.005374982,
-0.0506290048,
0.0641677454,
-0.019016061,
-0.0829171464,
-0.058786761,
0.0408641547,
0.0096967965,
-0.0010778814,
-0.0225380193,
-0.0189159904,
0.0111307558,
0.0787355676,
0.0461116731,
-0.0282358881,
0.0105263665,
-0.0150056537,
-0.0140042482,
-0.0182538442,
-0.0076680402,
0.01696207,
-0.0153353363,
0.0356999002,
0.038548205,
-0.0387254618,
0.0336465724,
-0.0427047163,
0.091944918,
-0.0099848481,
-0.0872762352,
-0.0428063683,
0.0204320084,
0.0342002809,
0.03660037,
-0.0353191011,
-0.0109448181,
0.0402422473,
-0.0075744526,
-0.0347182751,
0.0223774742,
-0.0018459117,
-0.0230428409,
-0.002326403,
0.0582955219,
0.0359753557,
-0.0250917859,
0.0140459528,
-0.0288619772,
-0.0166910887,
-0.0288629122,
0.0221624244,
-0.0061584297,
0.0081819082,
-0.0417097323,
-0.012420401,
0.0639306828,
-0.0308401491,
0.0272539835,
-0.0034788658,
-0.0004597864,
-0.0377688259,
0.0157990549,
0.0598707683,
-0.0684696585,
-0.0148230111,
-0.0300483871,
-0.0176950246,
-0.0399125405,
-0.0115394201,
-0.0413768739,
-0.0136757921,
0.0732605681,
0.0404446349,
-0.0383613072,
-0.0180011019,
0.0464233607,
0.0379805751,
0.0530644618,
-0.0088732615,
-0.1058631465,
-0.0044116634,
0.0341755338,
-0.0299715195,
0.0343756117,
-0.0501765124,
0.0011761847,
0.0009192887,
-0.0303421803,
0.0234609377,
0.0062838034,
-0.0214688871,
0.0407543778,
0.0409326591,
0.0257808641,
0.0278353766,
-0.0267234482,
-0.0046851276,
0.0380504653,
-0.0245645531,
-0.0290919375,
-0.0435853936,
-5.7660404e-33,
0.0426901393,
-0.0523991883,
-0.0179939326,
0.00660099,
0.0285725426,
0.0379172377,
-0.0553015471,
-0.0035641689,
-0.024908293,
0.0610740073,
0.0359899811,
-0.0573833734,
0.0141124055,
-0.027890699,
-0.0095812101,
-0.0272820927,
0.048540134,
0.0175149087,
0.040880952,
-0.0367840603,
0.0303925555,
0.0789545327,
0.0780703574,
-0.0236413311,
-0.0090954714,
0.0429975353,
0.0179808959,
-0.0311283004,
0.0052900198,
0.0710694939,
-0.0220235381,
0.0745189339,
-0.0228547622,
-0.0300991014,
0.0021079332,
0.0434585474,
-0.055874832,
0.0088513102,
-0.0151332598,
0.0142074814,
-0.0304997917,
0.0132680926,
0.038295459,
0.0314631537,
-0.0320182219,
0.0282691717,
0.0556664802,
-0.0083260974,
-0.0312825032,
-0.0223801471,
-0.0590316765,
0.0149635477,
0.0219229758,
-0.021228211,
0.0288202949,
-0.0073005497,
0.0346317813,
0.0154884271,
-0.0203258712,
0.0078136744,
0.0260573998,
0.0637701452,
0.0375653207,
-0.0112097161,
-0.0154655464,
0.0659138262,
0.0042139785,
-0.0216434784,
-0.0027942481,
0.0005167127,
-0.0104643628,
0.0589138083,
0.0638504997,
-0.0407442003,
0.0320213251,
0.003825,
-0.0889139026,
0.038944874,
-0.0005089055,
0.0246141348,
-0.0156975184,
0.0170642994,
-0.030275479,
0.0089575937,
0.0053484784,
0.0332087576,
-0.0209666807,
-0.0446475744,
0.0122130485,
-0.0549990535,
-0.0370903835,
0.0764828995,
0.009969499,
-0.0498856492,
-0.0503458492,
0.0262197852,
0.0259806328,
0.0031326027,
-0.0066513754,
-0.0154588809,
-0.0140921501,
-0.0339230374,
0.0129903881,
-0.0465515032,
0.0014233902,
-0.0295728929,
0.0201815814,
-0.0052100737,
-0.0077871736,
0.0105980327,
-0.0273185875,
-0.0466088504,
0.0084065413,
0.0926650017,
0.0247971844,
-0.0071263197,
0.0012784061,
0.0788657293,
-0.0001770088,
0.031993974,
0.0274616964,
-0.0319545306,
0.0002519951,
0.0253423993,
-0.0289237034,
-0.0220443793,
-0.0484509654,
-0.0100533376,
-0.0112299453,
-0.0838965997,
-0.0156912934,
0.0066708019,
2.805e-7,
0.0605329759,
0.0433924198,
0.0186149329,
-0.022717081,
-0.0414357707,
0.0233414657,
0.0088611832,
0.0458495915,
-0.0544040948,
-0.0150674935,
0.0170467645,
-0.0114129949,
0.0345866047,
0.0080995709,
-0.0679158494,
0.0116144419,
-0.0639186054,
0.0111662773,
-0.0628911555,
-0.0015794955,
-0.0159317832,
0.1341896355,
-0.0266517494,
0.001449169,
0.074406907,
-0.0630403012,
0.0314689577,
-0.0138187753,
0.0151893143,
0.0025817025,
0.040887814,
0.0034549355,
0.0089330124,
-0.0121378843,
-0.0904816464,
-0.0091328705,
0.0247677565,
-0.0204314981,
-0.0208127443,
-0.0506479293,
0.0309815351,
0.0030159384,
0.0269596875,
-0.0070891799,
0.0404971875,
-0.0183360819,
-0.0564778559,
-0.0219985042,
0.0269379783,
0.0027389333,
0.0552636683,
-0.0326775089,
0.0092479624,
-0.0093895653,
-0.0122591509,
-0.0379553251,
-0.0194625594,
-0.0666294098,
-0.0008760783,
0.020664556,
-0.0188901406,
0.0544167832,
-0.0345540084,
-0.0199964736,
0.0856396109,
-0.0209323596,
-0.0120441662,
2.137856653e-34,
0.02893316,
-0.0261847246,
-0.0037199983,
0.0123312641,
0.0010827045,
-0.0043248641,
-0.0125196194,
0.0147746382,
-0.032664977,
-0.05159178,
-0.0337433815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01622v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01622v3 | TravelPlanner: A Benchmark for Real-World Planning with Language Agents | 2024-02-02T18:39:51 | 2024-06-23T08:50:17 | Jian Xie, Kai Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Tinghui Zhu, Renze Lou, Yuandong Tian, Yanghua Xiao, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Planning has been part of the core pursuit for artificial intelligence since
its conception, but earlier AI agents mostly focused on constrained settings
because many of the cognitive substrates necessary for human-level planning
have been lacking. Recently, language agents powered by large language models
(LLMs) have shown interesting capabilities such as tool use and reasoning. Are
these language agents capable of planning in more complex settings that are out
of the reach of prior AI agents? To advance this investigation, we propose
TravelPlanner, a new planning benchmark that focuses on travel planning, a
common real-world planning scenario. It provides a rich sandbox environment,
various tools for accessing nearly four million data records, and 1,225
meticulously curated planning intents and reference plans. Comprehensive
evaluations show that the current language agents are not yet capable of
handling such complex planning tasks-even GPT-4 only achieves a success rate of
0.6%. Language agents struggle to stay on task, use the right tools to collect
information, or keep track of multiple constraints. However, we note that the
mere possibility for language agents to tackle such a complex problem is in
itself non-trivial progress. TravelPlanner provides a challenging yet
meaningful testbed for future language agents. | [
0.0491794273,
0.0750429332,
-0.029151585,
0.0200484451,
-0.0356252827,
-0.0240140017,
-0.0033487058,
-0.0134654222,
0.0079831947,
0.0131877521,
0.0196027104,
-0.0164085589,
-0.0294032656,
0.0619069189,
-0.0269714296,
-0.0570621975,
0.0191170406,
-0.0596472211,
0.0202031732,
0.0148008615,
-0.0237265117,
0.0264881738,
-0.0362810269,
0.0434962474,
-0.0182148926,
0.0160817467,
-0.0682374835,
0.008876049,
0.0275345016,
-0.0522203594,
-0.0133050382,
0.03595642,
0.0526456535,
-0.0005009818,
0.0000021376,
-0.0027943202,
-0.0265844874,
-0.0416168123,
-0.0378114767,
-0.0453651324,
0.0054558725,
-0.0031242836,
-0.0004419924,
0.017394688,
-0.0533830561,
0.0145152668,
0.0083946763,
0.0459491797,
0.0473596305,
0.0804247335,
-0.0107157761,
-0.0040869769,
-0.0247180108,
-0.0025285047,
-0.0107477037,
-0.0546613783,
-0.0134670921,
-0.0069910507,
0.018572554,
-0.0050181486,
-0.0082245041,
-0.0308678951,
0.0257746764,
-0.022302404,
-0.0491810851,
0.0181922764,
-0.0817413628,
-0.0216361266,
-0.0186344907,
0.0720721632,
0.0025009778,
-0.0251600686,
0.0372942276,
-0.0029167831,
-0.0540439487,
-0.0183583889,
-0.020852251,
0.0095156282,
0.0148837343,
0.0383506007,
0.0278924331,
0.0087135183,
0.0275572948,
0.0229459517,
-0.0232445188,
0.1087199375,
-0.0078622382,
-0.0164074413,
0.0199321937,
-0.0055299993,
0.0365244448,
-0.0991892889,
0.0336031839,
0.0570674278,
-0.0832952708,
0.0153645631,
0.025133498,
0.046201434,
-0.0070839422,
-0.0047683772,
0.0623199902,
0.0656238496,
-0.0030783913,
0.0499192327,
0.0328853913,
0.0580673553,
0.0026220123,
0.0112958662,
-0.0393565781,
0.0030760071,
-0.0411622934,
0.0387487374,
-0.060982246,
-0.0102294721,
-0.0805346146,
0.0000049078,
0.0021275987,
0.0346815027,
-0.0100466283,
0.051965192,
0.0051517934,
-0.0017013263,
0.0022598652,
-0.050042741,
-0.0767326802,
-0.0324290544,
-0.0708526745,
0.0150236003,
-0.0050733644,
-0.0093429778,
0.0050287046,
0.0174386855,
0.0247439668,
-0.0276963599,
-0.0272505358,
0.0628519505,
-0.003083183,
0.0028993268,
-0.0650721192,
-0.0630386993,
0.0261937026,
-0.1162840351,
0.0005951844,
-0.0697969571,
0.0369506553,
-0.0066369111,
-0.0477917753,
-0.0645419285,
0.017940389,
-0.0004066994,
0.0068130158,
0.0363368578,
0.0441900007,
0.0148953116,
-0.0001253453,
0.0238225926,
0.0121387634,
0.0302914288,
0.040980421,
0.0771790221,
0.0191107243,
0.0459832363,
0.0293283202,
0.0506880805,
0.0033845636,
0.0252318457,
0.0069757621,
0.020171402,
-0.0079984656,
0.0213163719,
-0.031559445,
0.039011959,
-0.0286151394,
0.02331011,
0.0387058854,
0.034439981,
-0.0206265226,
0.0049255677,
0.0627276972,
0.012613114,
-0.0345544182,
-0.0500944592,
-0.0337977596,
0.0249754284,
0.0009805991,
-0.0107037248,
-0.0092829578,
0.024181908,
-0.0115947993,
-0.0514103808,
0.0136236306,
-0.0253109392,
0.054421477,
-0.0222039837,
0.0212062858,
-0.0446652211,
-0.0509000234,
0.0186339207,
-0.0059109242,
-0.0322017632,
-0.0063779689,
-0.0193994418,
0.004458948,
0.0894802064,
0.0323902778,
-0.0062831827,
-0.0423689336,
0.006490842,
0.0249940455,
0.0162369236,
0.0771197379,
-0.0169256739,
0.0147754224,
-0.0534647256,
-0.027748961,
0.0330320261,
0.0092236269,
-0.0064566717,
0.0449227393,
0.0483716764,
0.0030564019,
-0.0292757768,
-0.0061276252,
0.0017380903,
-0.0244362336,
-0.0307529997,
-0.035803616,
0.0136233643,
0.0389384218,
0.0002024886,
-0.0177612714,
-0.0118834842,
0.0457243025,
-0.0181317981,
-0.0004276138,
0.0439755842,
-0.0171890203,
0.0187814478,
0.0224972088,
-0.0103666736,
-0.0404415168,
0.049313657,
-0.0115328804,
-0.052069407,
-0.0043809293,
0.0216866303,
0.0120767877,
0.0000472976,
0.036542993,
0.0177377779,
-0.0172415562,
0.000734833,
0.0677289814,
0.0186107028,
-0.0304818135,
0.0403298028,
0.0354198776,
0.0442447774,
-0.0361223444,
-0.0002856155,
0.0294724274,
0.0345204175,
0.002160752,
0.0274861883,
0.019123286,
-0.0381444171,
-0.0116710039,
-0.0747793242,
0.0019945856,
-0.0304996371,
-0.0057544536,
-0.0093903663,
-0.0143369297,
-0.0107844798,
0.0008660804,
-0.0307458844,
0.0655307323,
-0.0142979398,
-0.0300730467,
0.0184938665,
0.0163100082,
-0.0330482759,
-0.0391799621,
0.0194274578,
-0.0189090539,
-0.030314574,
0.0247916728,
-0.0076239998,
-0.0297616459,
-0.0051131826,
-0.0593211167,
0.0302464236,
-0.0118479226,
-0.0571393296,
-0.0058362307,
-0.0309787318,
-0.0100044664,
-0.0026661097,
-0.0009383463,
-0.0057373005,
0.0916566774,
-0.0467372276,
-0.0739632174,
0.0595888495,
-0.0337334014,
0.0195976347,
-0.08656542,
-0.0576814413,
-0.0139823286,
0.0130862975,
-0.0295372419,
0.0537535883,
-0.0608222187,
0.0116040325,
0.0071255178,
-0.0233450681,
0.0121539794,
0.0267292634,
-0.0257663615,
0.1280207932,
-0.0216510296,
-0.0021180406,
0.0300712436,
-0.0122030722,
-0.0119104469,
-0.0070331935,
-0.0065337699,
-0.0332657769,
0.0826661065,
0.0290851705,
0.0519464128,
-0.0071584065,
0.043438226,
0.0103539871,
-0.0080273887,
-0.0413348749,
-0.0233331472,
0.0316390954,
-0.0650597811,
0.0264595747,
0.0028024346,
-0.0746628195,
-0.0345913358,
-0.0028021829,
-0.0537323281,
-0.0095534222,
-0.0011835109,
-0.0748263076,
-0.0312709399,
-0.0221104007,
0.0165190529,
0.078214176,
0.0087401308,
-0.0084290439,
-0.0092630852,
-0.0225601029,
0.0724230632,
0.0822803006,
0.0053902641,
0.0319076367,
-0.0008606153,
0.0101495096,
0.0211978536,
-0.0033841196,
0.0003326218,
0.0493111871,
-0.0008999713,
0.0005050661,
0.0064066122,
0.0543487296,
0.0426844358,
-0.0448717847,
-0.0445390157,
0.0801310614,
0.0437917337,
-0.0447896719,
0.0193931684,
-0.0647375956,
0.0305910986,
0.0213691052,
0.0738213807,
-0.0474286303,
-0.0249065682,
0.0017782605,
-0.0297643226,
-0.0223199464,
-0.0534750186,
-0.0237395819,
-0.0846912488,
0.0614948794,
-0.0040523675,
-0.021445334,
0.0308790244,
-0.0598414727,
-0.0157975983,
-0.0059182979,
0.0039486028,
-0.0266618729,
0.0372768231,
-0.0357041284,
-0.0117373774,
-0.0378768146,
-0.0261597354,
0.0300765485,
-0.0436291844,
0.076836586,
0.051085759,
0.0696186125,
-0.0107772648,
-0.0384832993,
0.0033428555,
0.0639236271,
0.0241317153,
-0.0228962228,
0.001931169,
0.0343323871,
-0.0113236867,
0.0189809259,
0.0101501644,
-0.0809029266,
-0.0367968418,
0.04707532,
0.1022895053,
-0.0134106074,
0.0067618354,
-0.0083009396,
0.0213758498,
0.0328104347,
0.055240877,
-0.0457991809,
-0.0324303396,
-0.0665856898,
-0.0644069761,
-0.0158345606,
-0.0809905604,
-0.0196370594,
0.0226799622,
0.0132502839,
0.020229876,
-0.0501136631,
-0.073576428,
0.050266955,
0.0250406098,
0.0070396294,
-0.0048140441,
0.0348438844,
-0.0093144337,
-0.004313298,
-0.0104972627,
-0.0318955667,
0.019659115,
-0.0386450961,
-0.0074254153,
-0.03576703,
-0.0159363393,
-0.0271796323,
0.0215253569,
-0.052987583,
-0.0653467029,
0.0377574489,
0.0190442093,
0.0254308842,
0.0105639612,
-0.006538352,
-0.0077103791,
-0.0102538168,
-0.0252467915,
-0.0319657885,
-0.0033655351,
0.009915024,
0.0193371717,
0.0029028123,
0.0581529737,
-0.0526902787,
0.0392392203,
-0.000940393,
0.0439078771,
-0.0784245208,
0.0091301026,
0.0211828873,
0.0125606824,
-0.0379985571,
0.0144605674,
0.001623753,
-0.0211616606,
0.0306400638,
-0.0148064652,
-0.0262986291,
-0.0261168033,
-0.0388056561,
0.0139672915,
-0.0070054312,
0.0269996859,
0.0066822823,
-0.0075581288,
-0.0539584868,
0.0122559937,
0.0066706478,
0.0238573346,
-0.0051536402,
0.0337518752,
0.0000191724,
0.0085135736,
0.0305471309,
-0.007356361,
0.0457312837,
-0.0214917362,
0.0288690254,
0.0181735642,
0.0032651115,
-0.0476685353,
-0.0328558944,
-0.0316556878,
-0.0838306323,
0.0667961836,
0.0258031916,
0.0518269837,
-0.0173008386,
0.0083825029,
-0.0758344457,
0.0089711435,
-0.0000842529,
-0.0465264395,
0.019431198,
-0.0235611144,
0.0367248766,
0.021753775,
0.0016533204,
0.0169496387,
0.0281835832,
-0.0080173565,
0.0847825855,
0.0364481434,
-0.0237896908,
-0.0492474437,
-0.0057326597,
-0.0269785151,
0.000643775,
-0.0179647356,
0.0066124857,
-0.0410113297,
-0.0280953124,
0.0148891434,
0.0315462984,
-0.0288012475,
-0.0412878133,
-0.0004416214,
-0.017937528,
-0.0086082593,
-0.025174696,
-0.0353078134,
-0.0536536127,
-0.0478092395,
-0.0133679155,
-0.0201849397,
-6.415796004e-33,
0.0104139941,
-0.0363595821,
0.0952955857,
-0.0340450965,
0.0188289061,
-0.029326912,
-0.0736946389,
-0.0035610369,
-0.0327788293,
0.0288683716,
-0.0421547778,
-0.0011818374,
0.0265395604,
0.0091157174,
0.0175300129,
-0.0072541591,
0.0221269503,
0.0186774991,
-0.0446229614,
0.0025697215,
0.0506010838,
-0.032560125,
0.0118740909,
-0.0562806204,
-0.0284069702,
-0.0159692727,
-0.0300219283,
0.0557557568,
0.0142576806,
0.0576629043,
-0.0011058875,
0.007162571,
0.0154630784,
-0.0064431848,
-0.000439346,
0.0019720572,
-0.0294542443,
-0.0673362687,
0.0143482927,
0.0083796484,
-0.0405514427,
-0.0222268421,
-0.0254100934,
0.0002210251,
-0.0070971316,
0.0457941853,
0.0181133039,
0.0007046438,
0.0109264217,
0.0795247778,
-0.0621108413,
0.0069047147,
-0.0235263463,
0.0179116968,
0.0636593848,
0.0121827442,
0.0050324122,
-0.0109827369,
-0.032409329,
0.0376379453,
-0.0312936604,
-0.0068978639,
0.0327771008,
-0.0427426025,
-0.031830959,
0.0706050619,
0.0149203492,
0.0126554444,
-0.0364536606,
-0.0001243113,
-0.0087524168,
0.0790833756,
-0.0282307547,
0.0610614493,
-0.0249245781,
0.0007462828,
-0.0259321835,
0.0266843382,
0.0228339974,
0.0234577712,
0.0742530376,
0.0204358492,
-0.0447074994,
-0.0019619805,
-0.0384747982,
0.0139173856,
-0.0190310404,
-0.0235775448,
0.0215072017,
0.0564968251,
0.026080925,
0.0297690686,
0.0417075641,
-0.0101336241,
-0.0053372863,
0.0553569235,
-0.0062670908,
-0.0075325416,
0.0042152624,
0.0568252429,
-0.0857898891,
-0.0277084783,
-0.0265136287,
0.0022887688,
0.0362453237,
0.0345073901,
0.0047518234,
0.0305024236,
-0.0112312129,
-0.0027641198,
-0.0589168109,
0.0132990703,
-0.0251720995,
-0.0195842721,
0.0375858098,
-0.0340076424,
-0.0105151413,
-0.0178797115,
0.0335820355,
-0.0497710593,
-0.0008523319,
-0.0366522595,
0.01224628,
0.0082879402,
-0.0211858544,
0.0139830261,
-0.0439592153,
0.011801092,
0.0384083502,
-0.035912782,
0.0181710143,
0.0251886696,
2.756e-7,
-0.0018485202,
0.0575904734,
-0.0073253824,
0.0719552338,
0.0099592172,
0.0192765202,
-0.0151940733,
-0.0113025354,
-0.0637805164,
0.0326198973,
0.0386469811,
0.0419118851,
0.0233730711,
0.0625201911,
-0.0516744405,
0.0609779507,
-0.0060239183,
-0.0430835932,
-0.0846031234,
-0.0014989951,
0.0537710823,
0.0781041384,
0.0279119983,
-0.0104385456,
0.0061441315,
-0.0329983793,
0.0008336124,
-0.0821045265,
0.0000652856,
0.0288163908,
-0.0116019594,
0.053445518,
-0.0140897464,
-0.0015277124,
-0.0318834484,
0.00282847,
-0.0204416774,
0.080169782,
0.0061650132,
-0.0355630741,
0.001652598,
-0.0416622385,
-0.018014377,
-0.0509307273,
0.0333417915,
0.0426971838,
0.0011052,
0.011537143,
-0.0020959049,
0.0056619225,
-0.0238982681,
0.0045873867,
-0.0008894104,
-0.0069631701,
0.0095256921,
0.0021447942,
-0.0008672155,
-0.0720503405,
0.0199714638,
0.0517353974,
-0.0011470658,
0.0076355888,
-0.0579346605,
0.0264341626,
-0.005414925,
-0.0571459904,
0.0066752993,
2.193755312e-34,
-0.0086347163,
0.0406272858,
-0.0269940905,
0.0085502136,
0.0593731999,
0.0194007996,
0.004889857,
0.0280598812,
-0.003602464,
-0.0466765948,
-0.0304977335
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.