id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00707v1 | Non-Exchangeable Conformal Language Generation with Nearest Neighbors | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | Dennis Ulmer, Chrysoula Zerva, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Quantifying uncertainty in automatically generated text is important for
letting humans check potential hallucinations and making systems more reliable.
Conformal prediction is an attractive framework to provide predictions imbued
with statistical guarantees, however, its application to text generation is
challenging since any i.i.d. assumptions are not realistic. In this paper, we
bridge this gap by leveraging recent results on non-exchangeable conformal
prediction, which still ensures bounds on coverage. The result,
non-exchangeable conformal nucleus sampling, is a novel extension of the
conformal prediction framework to generation based on nearest neighbors. Our
method can be used post-hoc for an arbitrary model without extra training and
supplies token-level, calibrated prediction sets equipped with statistical
guarantees. Experiments in machine translation and language modeling show
encouraging results in generation quality. By also producing tighter prediction
sets with good coverage, we thus give a more theoretically principled way to
perform sampling with conformal guarantees. | [
0.0123841232,
0.0535999946,
-0.0130463289,
-0.007340604,
-0.0346648283,
-0.0125198271,
0.0155013185,
0.0383045152,
-0.0137117496,
0.0193920191,
-0.0230157096,
-0.1045398638,
-0.0051126266,
0.0120497197,
0.0494923405,
-0.044670485,
-0.0319741555,
-0.0321741998,
-0.0304624122,
-0.0435973108,
-0.0329517946,
0.0049290685,
0.0167966727,
0.0185701028,
-0.0286881533,
-0.0079194643,
-0.0136281243,
0.0132823857,
0.0024542026,
-0.0011320879,
0.0028365504,
0.097483553,
-0.0040398743,
0.0382197574,
0.0000018658,
0.0159857143,
-0.0317419134,
0.0071009761,
0.0562203154,
-0.0259349942,
0.0616564713,
-0.0510842018,
-0.0177860167,
0.0162684042,
-0.0205928069,
0.0233696606,
0.0703204051,
0.050757058,
0.0066330838,
0.0436456464,
-0.0184482038,
-0.0213292427,
-0.0184222981,
-0.0291971937,
0.0385407209,
-0.0070382534,
0.0194234308,
0.0006007014,
-0.00941227,
-0.0260142256,
-0.0305613913,
0.0134149985,
0.0415583551,
0.0043288483,
-0.0003618196,
0.068902187,
0.0117667327,
-0.0311856121,
0.0018934087,
0.0171884596,
-0.0578787662,
-0.0587505326,
0.0148267578,
-0.0109855505,
-0.0605267026,
0.0272623003,
-0.0412336402,
0.0442819595,
-0.0413198732,
0.0526351891,
0.0078424513,
0.0310583431,
0.0040087695,
-0.0486337282,
-0.0193198416,
0.0119131841,
0.0585881621,
-0.0454282165,
-0.0053481776,
0.0521010198,
-0.0337981433,
-0.0448518731,
-0.0078103775,
-0.0190341957,
-0.028476771,
0.0027160256,
-0.0902788192,
-0.0040953523,
0.0486991592,
-0.0368715487,
0.0803479552,
-0.0042625563,
0.0329960696,
-0.0013469692,
-0.0444027334,
0.0037609127,
-0.0028107017,
0.0407052934,
-0.0351935849,
-0.0051660989,
-0.0087263929,
0.0021113474,
-0.0364406034,
0.0094913207,
-0.0505326986,
-0.0240869205,
-0.0462023988,
0.0088056102,
0.0284269582,
-0.0225828607,
0.0278324094,
0.0255240425,
-0.0937031657,
-0.0203806702,
0.0257102083,
-0.0212161653,
-0.0337063223,
-0.0161507688,
0.0106030023,
-0.0553118698,
-0.0262794066,
0.0389293693,
-0.0114176152,
-0.0030759766,
-0.0069160843,
0.0809539184,
-0.0090856291,
-0.0287870038,
-0.0022595383,
-0.0359164476,
-0.0497896448,
-0.0345853977,
0.0509500057,
-0.078900449,
0.0148606338,
-0.0112274904,
-0.0197568275,
-0.0371203683,
0.0262127202,
0.0275051855,
-0.0206619427,
0.0078979377,
-0.0139147099,
-0.0014943643,
-0.0202791281,
-0.0039791828,
0.0503550544,
0.0545519143,
0.0093100425,
0.077485159,
-0.0040844944,
0.0244410429,
0.0395525582,
0.0311438143,
0.030810615,
0.0102136107,
-0.0579716824,
-0.043097727,
0.0596357845,
0.0012548715,
0.0194246229,
0.0823258534,
-0.0327931717,
-0.0164910983,
0.0478064008,
0.0207879134,
0.0062143337,
-0.0056342175,
0.0414075516,
-0.007203138,
-0.0470870696,
0.0592759252,
-0.0365657471,
0.0325105228,
-0.014524078,
0.0214294884,
0.0717573985,
0.0338592902,
-0.0368128568,
-0.0047556278,
0.0123242792,
-0.0202550311,
-0.022510305,
-0.0707327798,
0.0430356264,
0.037952248,
-0.0562939756,
0.0293616392,
0.0339964032,
-0.048040539,
0.0430029668,
-0.0055932323,
0.0525380298,
0.0387368798,
0.0418740995,
-0.0037388755,
0.0242942199,
0.0184145793,
0.0200743359,
0.0863368809,
0.0382443629,
0.0241606813,
0.0555393584,
-0.0431247503,
-0.0036655033,
0.0296047628,
0.0161021035,
0.0350660086,
0.0100288102,
-0.0120179886,
0.0144878794,
-0.0428656712,
-0.0653891563,
0.0197686553,
-0.0449594744,
-0.0216638055,
0.0267204586,
0.0098041994,
0.0164464433,
-0.0014674709,
-0.0389140844,
0.0281538181,
0.0275674853,
-0.0737656802,
-0.0559256226,
-0.0206622239,
-0.0424970873,
-0.0197936967,
-0.0019342678,
-0.0705745965,
0.0350140259,
-0.0600285567,
0.00999902,
-0.0581123196,
0.038062565,
-0.0318734236,
0.0564153045,
-0.0600293353,
0.0004017776,
0.026995156,
0.0394483916,
-0.0410171896,
0.0476257317,
-0.0229087174,
0.0337773934,
-0.0017128704,
-0.0070188525,
0.0069437046,
-0.0007598384,
-0.0442993492,
-0.0303785112,
-0.0305690374,
0.0084048808,
0.0415514745,
0.0265149362,
0.0036544467,
-0.1120254844,
-0.0278880708,
0.0012105845,
-0.0271216445,
-0.012308172,
0.0341374911,
0.0146326115,
-0.0145059777,
-0.0144623807,
-0.0279386528,
-0.0346522778,
0.0515462607,
0.0035642441,
0.0102519151,
0.016969176,
-0.0406784229,
0.019116573,
-0.0158809237,
0.0194345322,
0.0125735542,
0.0326381661,
-0.0030133938,
-0.0670377165,
0.0515933968,
-0.0161920432,
0.0198230185,
0.0133723672,
-0.0318804085,
0.0119152265,
-0.0305414628,
0.0257623065,
0.0118321413,
0.0336327069,
-0.0150631294,
0.0031368642,
0.0189770572,
0.0275391359,
-0.0356714465,
-0.0721227899,
0.0063098641,
-0.0043231742,
-0.0933468342,
0.041705694,
0.0466130152,
0.052985426,
-0.0049128095,
-0.0751959011,
0.0458821617,
0.0179526787,
-0.024311645,
0.0163863059,
0.0336539373,
-0.0303295422,
0.0480712764,
-0.0285738669,
-0.0652549863,
0.064594999,
-0.0523218811,
0.0169010945,
0.001380688,
0.0025082049,
0.0122140758,
0.0157213304,
0.0335972086,
0.0456087179,
0.0264443457,
-0.0197034162,
-0.0417994261,
0.0138263479,
0.0117825838,
0.0064209797,
-0.0047375369,
-0.0137547003,
-0.0096846065,
0.0299006756,
-0.015846476,
-0.0429682471,
-0.0135263344,
0.0192682128,
-0.0156844761,
0.0374479443,
-0.0135813607,
-0.0031976895,
0.0198531691,
-0.0226448774,
0.0225424189,
-0.040854115,
-0.012517116,
-0.0203799009,
0.0142456023,
0.0623396337,
-0.0565874428,
-0.0014801791,
-0.0851220787,
-0.0000686588,
0.0554708578,
0.0063258987,
0.0664821267,
-0.0072633792,
-0.0252182651,
0.0040604468,
0.0214257557,
-0.0109764291,
0.0443157777,
0.0419239663,
0.0367010199,
-0.0284921564,
0.1091281772,
0.0129523082,
-0.0054176534,
0.0206435025,
0.0274413675,
0.0899659246,
0.0076239444,
0.0418618247,
-0.0429483391,
0.0181839522,
-0.0072077778,
0.0617712997,
-0.0389228612,
-0.0353130437,
0.002571902,
-0.0830963105,
0.0337603204,
0.0325791687,
-0.0552289337,
-0.0827300251,
0.0011361087,
-0.0253279805,
-0.0094442572,
-0.0060455306,
0.0141307786,
-0.0041585257,
0.0112541812,
0.0383480415,
-0.0049384269,
-0.0133278426,
-0.012713423,
-0.0373962782,
0.040622849,
0.0429966152,
0.0135426158,
0.0082260668,
-0.0308816675,
-0.0417992361,
0.0027653042,
0.013640224,
0.0076069967,
0.0230650678,
0.0578557923,
-0.0183291007,
0.0039540217,
0.0543517843,
-0.0367221422,
-0.023967959,
-0.0123046543,
0.0391156301,
-0.0333509445,
-0.0686818883,
0.0289429855,
0.0766874403,
0.0655399263,
0.0662894025,
0.0457275361,
-0.0223126188,
-0.0218797866,
-0.0267826617,
0.0519083068,
-0.0462963805,
0.0170205906,
-0.0388651453,
-0.0073352735,
-0.0333424844,
-0.1163843274,
0.0112581765,
0.0087424461,
0.110738337,
0.0063617192,
-0.0144779393,
-0.0007646957,
-0.0575894192,
0.034496069,
-0.05078407,
-0.060389556,
-0.0260314625,
-0.0540171601,
-0.0132719623,
0.0053041978,
-0.0386017188,
-0.0252304692,
0.0503218994,
-0.0703309923,
-0.0806055441,
0.0364257768,
0.0602271035,
0.0260715298,
0.0631595701,
-0.023847362,
-0.0333475173,
0.0656869784,
0.0405661464,
0.0152932424,
0.0236698296,
0.0053958585,
-0.0420423225,
0.0128557039,
0.0366648696,
-0.0062975069,
0.0509381965,
0.0135160666,
0.0017877604,
0.007127828,
-0.0355831981,
0.0259030871,
0.0072505157,
-0.005494603,
-0.065688096,
0.0337736532,
-0.0237989873,
0.0026615481,
-0.0123768412,
0.0151700592,
-0.0233809501,
-0.0030288068,
0.0159280282,
0.0033873483,
-0.009211326,
0.0040072259,
-0.0324739181,
0.0656070784,
0.0431990474,
-0.0495935455,
-0.0292777307,
0.0539348423,
0.0439407267,
-0.0092398701,
0.010957811,
0.0288772881,
-0.0023400593,
0.059194684,
0.0006292383,
0.0332733728,
0.019806223,
0.0289839432,
-0.0162154008,
-0.0051684179,
-0.0654995814,
-0.0537307747,
-0.1044498682,
0.0316667072,
0.0382857248,
0.0058289506,
0.0010984135,
-0.0757819563,
0.0317875408,
-0.0151686231,
0.0551194288,
0.017844392,
-0.0532215685,
-0.0088727325,
-0.0085469708,
-0.0137319649,
0.0022706522,
0.0831565112,
-0.0496358573,
0.0245028604,
-0.020396553,
-0.0215610508,
-0.0413303934,
-0.0238101035,
-0.0147579676,
-0.0291928481,
-0.0229575131,
-0.0140274428,
-0.0301645007,
-0.0454100408,
0.1077695116,
0.0238589495,
0.0049111708,
0.0003104836,
0.0342906378,
0.0299858488,
-0.0503066443,
0.049986627,
-0.0150180329,
0.0196531806,
0.0400303341,
-0.0199448951,
-0.0159126706,
-6.258760245e-33,
-0.0364892818,
-0.0098383054,
-0.0178652704,
-0.018745359,
0.0025024945,
-0.0490685403,
-0.0078580873,
-0.0024682563,
0.0827979147,
0.0215514898,
-0.0023949516,
-0.0110931238,
0.022140272,
0.0494034402,
0.0064033745,
-0.0061085634,
0.0606344528,
-0.0270378385,
-0.0360474773,
0.0495455675,
0.0307625234,
0.0186882839,
0.0485963784,
-0.0320794471,
-0.0125176637,
0.0222489629,
-0.0263014492,
0.0073880022,
0.0059250551,
0.0053692842,
0.0004574173,
0.0035640837,
-0.0166616514,
-0.0192128047,
-0.0259498879,
-0.0299670119,
0.0307122748,
-0.0290143676,
-0.0110961413,
-0.0192075726,
0.0236987174,
-0.020655496,
0.0023798118,
-0.0382390507,
-0.0160776563,
0.0217057746,
0.009783484,
-0.0164403915,
-0.0500184968,
0.0244912095,
-0.0346414074,
0.0140516432,
0.0162480306,
-0.0051572183,
-0.054901734,
0.0443067551,
0.0006030473,
-0.0419974178,
0.0089128138,
0.0397924036,
0.0603176691,
0.0480927713,
0.0163864866,
-0.0018077159,
0.0261432976,
0.0792869329,
0.07069619,
-0.0123639153,
0.0006794634,
-0.0179382339,
0.0116791436,
0.0044654282,
-0.0042546992,
0.0315635502,
-0.0057199574,
-0.0355986506,
-0.0245528053,
0.0357074738,
-0.0328313336,
-0.009967274,
0.0640491694,
-0.0416654274,
-0.0159198865,
-0.0427333601,
-0.0148839066,
-0.0845935121,
-0.0025751502,
-0.0174206551,
-0.0032569626,
0.0484436154,
-0.0668004006,
-0.0217454992,
0.0309431832,
-0.0349010788,
0.039975591,
-0.0131294644,
-0.035922911,
0.0074172551,
-0.0209329184,
-0.0042426777,
-0.0266215056,
-0.037115939,
0.0282267667,
-0.0049695321,
-0.0232814569,
0.0114847133,
0.0415161885,
0.0207277704,
-0.0578042343,
0.012045553,
-0.0409329794,
0.0390401706,
0.0416031554,
-0.011692496,
0.0331311673,
-0.0162956975,
0.0023932108,
0.0048386771,
0.0029483663,
0.0092618344,
-0.0033712485,
0.0349060409,
0.0238067899,
0.0157212373,
-0.0476663336,
0.0121520236,
-0.0481974557,
-0.0365141369,
0.0329737812,
-0.0417335369,
-0.0367696732,
0.0049184826,
2.629e-7,
0.0363094769,
0.0232879557,
0.0283730347,
-0.0155142033,
0.0247139465,
-0.0310646612,
0.0177069884,
0.0566360839,
-0.0070624058,
0.0174282156,
-0.0125316838,
-0.0236539841,
0.043050915,
0.0296940673,
-0.1283465028,
0.0495009422,
-0.0675865561,
0.0134467427,
-0.0233376641,
-0.022338897,
0.0042532347,
0.062167909,
-0.0125041837,
-0.0306327473,
0.0417957939,
0.0048164222,
0.0648200586,
0.0102757504,
-0.0060717575,
0.0039967629,
0.0249953419,
-0.0205314215,
0.0039346032,
0.0314090587,
-0.033973176,
-0.0202507563,
0.0166503806,
0.0399713553,
0.0436159335,
-0.0366845019,
0.0364585221,
-0.0073977541,
-0.0146106435,
-0.0115743624,
0.0246509407,
-0.0533106029,
0.0023338085,
-0.0204687119,
-0.0278167687,
0.0168032795,
-0.0110687669,
-0.0388651155,
-0.0257858224,
0.0384791642,
0.0180373974,
0.0312260687,
0.0500754192,
0.0274018776,
-0.0013118207,
-0.0464700684,
-0.0496803485,
-0.0123618152,
-0.0437194631,
-0.0002915835,
0.0056077554,
-0.0423971787,
-0.0103241745,
2.510725986e-34,
0.0364981666,
-0.0090039326,
0.0102822566,
-0.0443967804,
0.0013731953,
-0.0207300149,
0.060172718,
0.027352538,
0.0080996677,
-0.0642071292,
-0.0400639512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01777v1 | On the Psychology of GPT-4: Moderately anxious, slightly masculine, honest, and humble | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | Adrita Barua, Gary Brase, Ke Dong, Pascal Hitzler, Eugene Vasserman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | We subject GPT-4 to a number of rigorous psychometric tests and analyze the
results. We find that, compared to the average human, GPT-4 tends to show more
honesty and humility, and less machiavellianism and narcissism. It sometimes
exhibits ambivalent sexism, leans slightly toward masculinity, is moderately
anxious but mostly not depressive (but not always). It shows human-average
numerical literacy and has cognitive reflection abilities that are above human
average for verbal tasks. | [
0.0159807205,
0.0769763067,
-0.025060229,
-0.0121711539,
-0.0192251317,
0.0390302949,
0.0034788698,
0.0045358026,
0.0018948591,
0.0388213918,
-0.0155816721,
-0.0065913708,
0.0025283818,
-0.0336339884,
0.0420860797,
-0.0491828136,
-0.0054352186,
0.0404624604,
0.0690932795,
-0.007357067,
-0.0414227694,
0.0340140238,
0.0139196711,
-0.0052958895,
-0.0003857108,
-0.0493831001,
0.0476565547,
-0.0017792961,
0.0253378265,
-0.0399883874,
0.0052337758,
0.0529506952,
0.0041287672,
0.0027666322,
0.0000022978,
-0.0175716635,
0.0268522687,
0.0120719457,
0.0367473066,
0.0064805527,
0.0462692268,
0.0201139599,
0.0413417704,
0.0585301742,
-0.0461617745,
-0.0695269257,
0.0020765441,
0.0794532299,
0.0376578495,
-0.0003916294,
-0.0056293425,
0.0088283429,
-0.0169371776,
-0.0500976071,
0.0150757376,
0.0110215051,
0.0229778681,
-0.042064324,
-0.0285727847,
0.0178290494,
-0.0140453186,
-0.0521698035,
-0.0085730674,
0.034904968,
-0.0470235236,
-0.012308768,
-0.0007925457,
0.0027999708,
-0.0097645056,
-0.0307941977,
0.107564047,
0.0210848115,
0.0038986264,
0.0552254356,
0.0390143692,
-0.0214204993,
-0.0121690212,
-0.0058248788,
-0.0447422154,
-0.0403873436,
-0.0170496032,
0.0029257084,
-0.0376180634,
-0.0016564555,
0.0362711474,
0.0760686994,
0.0043721818,
-0.0146005722,
0.0218508001,
-0.017227808,
-0.0142817674,
-0.0353931077,
-0.0019022272,
-0.0164189693,
0.0345979854,
-0.0253267512,
-0.0031316937,
0.0363087468,
0.0148076247,
0.0113228671,
-0.0320867039,
0.0479920022,
-0.0040802215,
-0.0212490559,
0.0221829116,
0.0516623482,
0.0453572124,
-0.0187481362,
0.0030168546,
-0.0026864214,
-0.0417861268,
-0.0198890548,
-0.0069693536,
0.0176968314,
0.080648385,
0.0260302555,
-0.0665525422,
0.0098430049,
-0.0159681309,
0.0039986949,
-0.0481526442,
-0.0221253783,
-0.0167315677,
-0.0086353496,
-0.0070204055,
0.0307077002,
-0.0819860697,
-0.0173998605,
-0.0089496318,
-0.096702911,
0.0251854435,
-0.0473243557,
-0.0055650063,
-0.0430964306,
0.0283027906,
-0.0006156031,
0.0265259687,
-0.0181229338,
-0.0011593474,
0.0256253071,
-0.0094662476,
-0.0594430342,
-0.0042489832,
0.0152159454,
-0.0146124894,
0.0459360071,
0.0020900313,
-0.0494018048,
0.0165237859,
0.0013414739,
0.0246836841,
0.0399848744,
0.0211558938,
0.0241704322,
0.0283722449,
0.037067268,
-0.0334303975,
0.0107309846,
0.0104834884,
-0.0325973779,
0.0063586584,
-0.0736645162,
0.0549797118,
-0.0264531132,
-0.0196471885,
0.0207013953,
0.0744916126,
-0.0023141853,
-0.021244375,
0.0387931392,
0.0787091851,
-0.0026541483,
-0.0050129532,
0.0554058254,
0.0925758705,
0.0552363694,
0.0298406668,
0.0808091089,
-0.0207951739,
0.0335575007,
0.0169183016,
0.031534683,
-0.0583819374,
0.0064248769,
-0.0281529948,
-0.0097024878,
-0.0580989234,
0.0212101005,
-0.0085210903,
-0.0043315273,
-0.0019225046,
0.0338668115,
0.0052286461,
0.0171133988,
-0.0243358091,
-0.0470331945,
-0.0022293329,
-0.0473947152,
0.0096990215,
-0.026963748,
-0.0553486869,
-0.0368658602,
0.0146694621,
0.0108928848,
-0.0282637682,
0.0279167071,
0.0004779838,
-0.0378215127,
-0.0169216618,
-0.0047601257,
0.0664559603,
0.0315838158,
-0.0019415693,
-0.0361349545,
0.008920949,
0.0061685671,
0.0116979098,
0.0350501053,
-0.0277126487,
0.0919378251,
0.0375126749,
0.0219138544,
0.0330816247,
-0.0243456345,
0.0259531084,
-0.0567859933,
0.0043660598,
-0.0105028376,
0.074980028,
-0.0018355852,
0.0121976025,
-0.0102102747,
-0.0214431491,
0.0143955713,
0.0222197268,
0.0279919021,
-0.0140837412,
0.1056005135,
-0.0281084552,
-0.0584371798,
-0.0458215475,
0.0667700022,
0.0117655341,
-0.004101085,
0.0137275094,
-0.0417351425,
0.0281884614,
-0.0129800318,
-0.0063162753,
-0.0058256551,
0.045992706,
0.0588486306,
0.0276658982,
0.0232710466,
-0.008681424,
-0.0207265783,
-0.0520143434,
0.013534761,
-0.0407989658,
0.0058421874,
-0.0531012826,
0.0096331956,
0.0277686398,
0.0124103483,
0.0328484625,
-0.0357456133,
0.001856947,
-0.0783847868,
0.0051551983,
0.0167296268,
0.0386571251,
0.0265016314,
-0.0546992905,
-0.0593625084,
0.0105374623,
-0.0175857432,
0.0260507967,
0.0232614595,
0.0462599173,
0.0166614689,
-0.0018712785,
0.0373858474,
0.009688356,
-0.0024693981,
-0.058934167,
-0.0495226644,
-0.0222371593,
-0.0054112468,
0.0088618044,
-0.0085783713,
-0.0591713935,
0.0086718826,
-0.0028903328,
-0.0629196092,
0.0573294722,
0.0356698632,
0.0465789065,
0.0463296548,
0.0612898208,
0.035142798,
-0.0043030926,
0.0472772494,
0.0374214053,
0.0049324688,
0.0236662347,
-0.0128575517,
0.012461219,
-0.087047711,
-0.0330901779,
-0.0024107636,
0.0128528578,
0.0192732047,
-0.0198884401,
0.0432829484,
0.0150878401,
-0.0285351668,
0.0177971665,
0.0030704795,
-0.0064866543,
0.053713277,
0.0064336155,
-0.0069067841,
-0.00633989,
0.0285665784,
-0.0170118604,
0.0116365282,
0.0002946105,
0.0442373604,
0.0867881402,
0.016352823,
-0.0131098544,
0.0467584096,
-0.0609238856,
-0.0529288352,
-0.0431122072,
0.0010225413,
-0.0102600744,
0.0521325804,
-0.0283880401,
-0.0451826416,
-0.0041345381,
-0.032146167,
0.0263043828,
-0.0016710424,
-0.0222280473,
0.0069562858,
0.0015220506,
-0.0502555855,
-0.0121341031,
-0.0545334294,
0.049030479,
0.023462588,
-0.0527187921,
-0.0011846635,
0.013613862,
-0.0622909404,
0.0350697525,
0.0235279445,
0.0404447578,
-0.0497663617,
-0.057397835,
0.0047347401,
-0.0492986664,
0.0146345589,
0.0110304123,
-0.0053114085,
0.0019079266,
0.0164577421,
-0.0201890264,
-0.0124868881,
0.0232042633,
0.0150319925,
0.0245526209,
0.0784135684,
-0.0356906652,
-0.0196958799,
0.0269664247,
0.0202106442,
-0.0455283001,
0.0224892367,
0.0162285529,
0.0009393954,
0.0383835398,
0.0051344582,
0.044197388,
-0.0514526889,
-0.0324811377,
-0.0062493146,
-0.0502069145,
0.0297696739,
0.0208421666,
-0.0523143448,
-0.0415463038,
0.0250136536,
0.0405478999,
0.0255031027,
-0.0093290266,
-0.0196089204,
0.0277482606,
0.0054781814,
-0.0370521955,
-0.0503806174,
-0.0275576655,
0.0922522172,
0.010620256,
-0.0178081505,
-0.0277140848,
0.056091167,
-0.0410689339,
-0.0389904976,
-0.0211058129,
-0.015638886,
-0.0181199983,
-0.0020016266,
-0.0094448952,
-0.0721248612,
0.0093127536,
-0.111060448,
0.0414446369,
0.014227801,
0.1057716832,
0.0257910844,
0.0234164782,
0.0110967914,
-0.0907528847,
-0.0011048412,
0.0129909506,
0.0030233322,
0.0241002794,
-0.0014354383,
0.0200620759,
0.0117364917,
0.0103538623,
0.0645734891,
0.0199291259,
-0.0402065068,
-0.0397550575,
0.0549941026,
0.0092928829,
-0.0326646157,
-0.1004756689,
0.0165954232,
0.016382901,
-0.0119528677,
-0.0928186923,
-0.0495464355,
0.0381237306,
-0.0507679731,
0.0324424766,
0.0554236509,
-0.0206040032,
-0.0019631083,
-0.0465202369,
0.0240038969,
-0.0273541436,
-0.0169347841,
-0.0124830557,
0.0424176827,
0.0118012289,
0.0401671752,
0.0387750342,
0.0312411096,
-0.0454716012,
0.0301939007,
0.0069212629,
-0.0138500258,
-0.0237694141,
-0.0521565452,
0.0511541367,
-0.0328295343,
0.0578986667,
-0.0103401933,
-0.0077683739,
0.01527707,
0.0363309756,
-0.0424476191,
-0.0575435869,
-0.0076417471,
-0.0361346714,
0.0244272631,
0.0069437465,
0.0108408555,
-0.0230856948,
0.0142317852,
0.0018793021,
-0.055839017,
-0.0574479885,
-0.0016662427,
-0.0044412236,
-0.0714782327,
-0.0055711698,
0.0070068529,
-0.0255076028,
-0.1026398465,
-0.0340701565,
0.0103299888,
-0.0776392594,
0.0141475769,
-0.0252988897,
-0.0154591845,
-0.0440841168,
0.006378016,
-0.0121924039,
-0.0364544727,
-0.0222954396,
0.0703719556,
0.0010694314,
0.1002766788,
-0.0159953982,
0.013347527,
0.0448328368,
0.0276438035,
-0.0784433559,
-0.0862699822,
0.0170186386,
-0.0536688417,
-0.0605768338,
0.0081392648,
0.0202839654,
-0.0774903744,
0.0008554885,
-0.0043282085,
0.0035188391,
-0.009413478,
0.0153997345,
0.0082038138,
0.0179214794,
0.02456747,
-0.048635073,
-0.01712244,
-0.0183987562,
0.021024039,
-0.0164487623,
-0.0584731512,
-0.0273507982,
0.00100912,
0.0077545708,
0.0099465139,
-0.0092620645,
-0.0215542484,
-0.0664896816,
-0.0526835471,
-0.042548839,
-0.0230606552,
0.0063439314,
-0.0081423344,
-0.0167854112,
0.0205071289,
-0.0403801203,
-0.085801065,
-0.0212999713,
0.002039565,
-0.0492428131,
0.0247979127,
-0.0057101529,
-6.722914475e-33,
-0.0360613726,
-0.0106714787,
-0.0023292061,
-0.0077685993,
-0.0357247256,
-0.0549366251,
-0.0106179575,
0.0315808281,
-0.0507183671,
0.0072855675,
-0.0191208795,
0.0439371131,
-0.0002646013,
-0.0259411,
0.0623360649,
0.045617003,
0.0209565088,
-0.019571837,
-0.0063157436,
0.007327727,
-0.0071794679,
0.0173158199,
0.1098289639,
-0.0207450315,
0.024919739,
-0.0326612554,
0.0001522195,
-0.0410377383,
0.0179385543,
-0.0518222377,
0.0161430202,
0.0055776862,
0.0493265092,
0.0259337332,
0.0233476013,
0.0202932898,
-0.0362047888,
-0.0192440469,
0.0106220404,
-0.0363557525,
0.0073342794,
-0.0443048291,
-0.0174003504,
-0.0228698589,
-0.0098277861,
-0.0889763013,
0.0091851419,
0.0282873828,
0.0698015764,
0.0272182804,
-0.0071870233,
-0.0210387651,
-0.0141761042,
0.0285733417,
-0.0514846705,
0.0320943892,
-0.0324774384,
0.0100692064,
-0.0418989025,
0.0098017482,
-0.0290471427,
-0.0020239986,
-0.0161508191,
-0.0302834231,
0.039975848,
-0.0113581605,
0.0633003861,
0.0625950471,
-0.0483185574,
-0.0239863377,
0.0310429633,
-0.0283326507,
0.0421375073,
-0.0164148621,
0.0296351891,
-0.0554018542,
0.0470248759,
-0.0424063094,
0.1058453172,
0.0257877875,
-0.0119229564,
-0.0175712015,
-0.0305626784,
-0.0041946964,
0.0185816083,
-0.0351798758,
-0.0017827143,
-0.0432239473,
-0.0030563411,
-0.0667966306,
0.0092235161,
0.0294251349,
0.0470060632,
0.0125770671,
-0.0303888917,
-0.0337170251,
-0.0357903056,
0.0303307008,
0.0239352994,
-0.0236203354,
0.017510185,
0.0385973975,
0.0156979021,
0.0624006242,
0.0640769973,
0.011184169,
-0.0295049138,
0.0160910804,
-0.0728209168,
-0.0041235401,
0.0044354955,
0.0227040797,
0.01468236,
-0.0246871654,
-0.027981285,
0.0035403573,
0.0460715853,
-0.0607271343,
0.0300932582,
-0.0086056609,
-0.054193072,
0.0229183454,
-0.0290494077,
-0.0107562151,
0.0290316157,
0.001654753,
0.0108464239,
0.0474995263,
0.0538010187,
0.0130057931,
0.0124560203,
-0.0459895059,
3.068e-7,
-0.0606771372,
0.0476505756,
-0.0225538388,
0.0075836689,
0.0344222486,
0.0223273914,
-0.00390267,
0.0445503667,
0.063926287,
-0.0104790917,
0.0444008932,
-0.0035309973,
0.0282469355,
0.0126798479,
0.0079951361,
0.0112173762,
-0.0086439773,
-0.0608361736,
-0.0280704554,
0.0514767244,
0.0488089472,
-0.0006257764,
-0.0115210777,
-0.0075423829,
0.0102553954,
0.0217287708,
-0.0202655438,
-0.0033676315,
0.0338735841,
-0.0050838497,
-0.0289860815,
0.0060264412,
-0.0102036251,
0.0943879336,
-0.0077669281,
-0.0579255894,
0.0052729654,
0.0316954143,
-0.0339114144,
0.0435099714,
0.000890529,
0.0362649895,
-0.031547945,
-0.0366754904,
0.0270940065,
0.0122016082,
-0.0568807274,
0.0178011879,
-0.0461607091,
-0.0406669229,
0.023414636,
0.0062777642,
-0.0122011267,
0.0389148407,
0.0124708954,
-0.0244100336,
0.0252311267,
-0.0272509288,
0.0851422027,
-0.025434684,
-0.0152921015,
-0.0720959008,
-0.024493916,
0.0433852747,
0.0232935678,
-0.0127872434,
-0.0097902557,
2.574377857e-34,
-0.0238223914,
0.0401366465,
0.0118753389,
-0.0734654218,
0.0632735416,
0.0223232675,
0.0106794573,
0.0117239971,
0.017516261,
0.0187404901,
-0.0271676928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00667v1 | Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Scalable Oversight and Ensemble Learning | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | Jitao Sang, Yuhang Wang, Jing Zhang, Yanxu Zhu, Chao Kong, Junhong Ye, Shuyu Wei, Jinlin Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a follow-up study to OpenAI's recent superalignment work
on Weak-to-Strong Generalization (W2SG). Superalignment focuses on ensuring
that high-level AI systems remain consistent with human values and intentions
when dealing with complex, high-risk tasks. The W2SG framework has opened new
possibilities for empirical research in this evolving field. Our study
simulates two phases of superalignment under the W2SG framework: the
development of general superhuman models and the progression towards
superintelligence. In the first phase, based on human supervision, the quality
of weak supervision is enhanced through a combination of scalable oversight and
ensemble learning, reducing the capability gap between weak teachers and strong
students. In the second phase, an automatic alignment evaluator is employed as
the weak supervisor. By recursively updating this auto aligner, the
capabilities of the weak teacher models are synchronously enhanced, achieving
weak-to-strong supervision over stronger student models.We also provide an
initial validation of the proposed approach for the first phase. Using the SciQ
task as example, we explore ensemble learning for weak teacher models through
bagging and boosting. Scalable oversight is explored through two auxiliary
settings: human-AI interaction and AI-AI debate. Additionally, the paper
discusses the impact of improved weak supervision on enhancing weak-to-strong
generalization based on in-context learning. Experiment code and dataset will
be released at https://github.com/ADaM-BJTU/W2SG. | [
0.0045174216,
0.0564973243,
-0.0074352995,
-0.0170796514,
0.0203965139,
0.0185702387,
-0.0032356593,
-0.0381331481,
-0.002436141,
0.014870503,
-0.0271396171,
-0.0223814119,
-0.036410708,
0.0122171193,
0.0359951966,
-0.0752462372,
0.047891885,
-0.0499454588,
0.0177511349,
0.0026433617,
-0.0162047222,
-0.059826225,
-0.0202246811,
0.0360788554,
-0.0049406304,
-0.0117042288,
-0.027278021,
-0.0205763225,
0.0654807091,
-0.0023588338,
-0.0063727596,
0.0104627302,
0.0526327081,
0.0422975607,
0.0000021527,
-0.030260589,
0.0149212889,
-0.0075786184,
0.0060306629,
-0.0476867519,
-0.0656343102,
-0.0126894591,
-0.0232730173,
-0.0007148789,
-0.0572134145,
-0.0005671853,
0.0447022058,
0.0633979365,
0.0418974869,
0.0510648713,
0.0139042996,
-0.0067097493,
0.0493451059,
-0.0193847176,
-0.0051981262,
-0.0930677652,
0.0165445581,
0.0126811266,
-0.0125673981,
-0.0293314029,
-0.0274426639,
-0.0109242303,
0.0191943441,
-0.0214373209,
0.0413182601,
0.0086415848,
-0.0500023104,
-0.010239413,
-0.0233639069,
0.0543504357,
-0.0193390045,
0.0111574158,
-0.033307299,
0.0031260701,
0.050909631,
0.0098703476,
-0.0324163139,
0.0138357384,
-0.0125538958,
-0.000032443,
-0.0177329257,
0.0235294942,
0.0155790541,
-0.0005284903,
-0.0258257966,
0.047064878,
-0.0227993503,
-0.0350361094,
0.0172552783,
0.0387024991,
-0.0904789865,
-0.0214701686,
-0.0073102792,
0.0387395509,
-0.0987725928,
-0.0103306705,
-0.0297972281,
-0.0388732292,
-0.0365187488,
0.0252957735,
0.0351019502,
0.0123553909,
-0.0175108165,
0.0331139006,
-0.005170289,
0.1051793098,
-0.0309924986,
0.0619668625,
-0.0225892831,
0.0246278513,
-0.0598448478,
-0.0072456575,
0.0117094805,
0.0154788923,
-0.0076425597,
0.014000006,
-0.0340303443,
-0.0048039998,
-0.0577243902,
0.0321792513,
-0.0096720243,
0.0116309682,
-0.0560399219,
0.0130484151,
-0.0305169336,
0.0053698672,
-0.0624696985,
0.0204284266,
0.0412521288,
0.0207723007,
-0.0149741974,
0.0103885382,
-0.0318002701,
-0.0082120653,
0.0003293999,
0.0644292682,
-0.0085966634,
0.0062029646,
-0.03545608,
-0.0001987699,
0.0022826367,
-0.0618020408,
0.0014535672,
-0.0064183194,
0.0240501426,
-0.0354577675,
-0.0239318851,
-0.0173452646,
-0.0059905392,
-0.0366197228,
0.0090352651,
0.0357515961,
0.00328135,
0.0080344891,
0.0140851131,
0.0135151697,
-0.0717137679,
0.0443381816,
0.0084185228,
0.0204719398,
0.0095583964,
0.012896209,
0.07264027,
0.0155594787,
-0.0202628747,
0.0127537977,
0.0070074471,
-0.0192914829,
0.0185757689,
0.0758967698,
0.0316846631,
0.0376501754,
-0.0216864888,
0.0663502589,
0.0375552885,
0.0382700339,
-0.0026957421,
-0.0021452354,
0.0347297974,
-0.0393313654,
0.0035168862,
0.0378990211,
-0.0768018663,
0.0392403603,
-0.0173646547,
-0.0171262771,
-0.0769598708,
0.0443690456,
-0.0349379927,
-0.0612071194,
0.0312332306,
0.0137898857,
-0.0396781713,
0.0007757854,
0.0680803955,
0.0156208565,
-0.0180308074,
-0.0772379786,
0.0105959093,
-0.0557513274,
-0.0010113841,
-0.090271771,
0.0254609678,
0.0343245529,
0.038815055,
-0.0553135015,
-0.0333531164,
-0.0283691566,
0.0112566492,
0.000082584,
0.0060786824,
-0.0289108735,
0.0118825287,
-0.0298974626,
-0.0369349495,
0.0224051457,
0.0187645033,
0.0081344638,
-0.0068585477,
-0.0376341827,
-0.0360800549,
-0.0045450139,
-0.0625624135,
0.0628977939,
-0.0383188315,
-0.0289049987,
-0.0504060276,
0.0303339418,
0.0317340977,
0.0327224024,
-0.0332170427,
-0.0102697723,
0.021702338,
-0.0073693264,
-0.0300283283,
-0.009283877,
-0.0399878845,
0.0314418115,
0.0374519154,
-0.0654414594,
-0.0352094099,
0.0339035504,
-0.008441465,
-0.0609498397,
-0.0083964635,
0.0173305366,
-0.0061981436,
0.0079866666,
0.0405560695,
-0.0500361919,
-0.0341876186,
-0.0257985741,
0.0731873214,
0.0160375293,
-0.0431495011,
0.0204888061,
0.0218423735,
0.0149805062,
-0.0467507727,
-0.0211063903,
0.008893122,
-0.005428954,
0.0220609047,
0.0466392897,
-0.0116152465,
-0.0322489589,
-0.0082734115,
-0.0570553653,
0.0087023452,
-0.0184594039,
-0.004607575,
-0.0142271575,
-0.016064629,
-0.0092706382,
0.0138149466,
-0.0153098721,
-0.0087660784,
-0.0291893911,
-0.0367015451,
0.0265952684,
0.0122873988,
-0.0139260404,
-0.0444248244,
0.0204108153,
-0.0281753913,
0.0185707528,
0.0526541248,
-0.0107921585,
-0.0439949632,
0.0334498361,
-0.0209540874,
0.0322036445,
-0.0214469805,
-0.0417936146,
0.0532691292,
-0.0180072747,
0.0415391661,
0.1305932552,
-0.023313636,
0.0254268162,
0.0693000406,
0.0496752746,
-0.0381931141,
0.0378878675,
0.0251546409,
-0.0622469187,
-0.0123117864,
0.0531648993,
-0.0083262529,
0.0488696657,
-0.0227773711,
-0.0019310445,
-0.0608315654,
0.0233959872,
-0.0147504825,
-0.059255477,
-0.0024092435,
-0.0330226161,
-0.0114941327,
0.0043447823,
-0.0541282482,
-0.0438990481,
0.0673473254,
0.0501365326,
0.0196270477,
-0.0056077377,
-0.0207300913,
0.0010170451,
0.0580912158,
-0.0206393823,
0.0216048826,
-0.0177592728,
-0.0130000385,
-0.1056039408,
0.0144672338,
0.0039468505,
-0.0120026814,
0.0080234772,
-0.0311787371,
-0.0198714565,
-0.0056379926,
-0.0562418662,
-0.0392113104,
0.0372461379,
-0.0246002879,
0.0395498276,
0.0087980283,
-0.0514253713,
-0.0435001813,
-0.0211243369,
0.0367741063,
0.0072155888,
-0.0379413441,
-0.0135190953,
-0.0184123293,
-0.0321815871,
0.0291165654,
-0.0160487574,
-0.0067314277,
-0.0639209151,
0.0551598407,
0.0343583263,
0.0868522152,
-0.0340362117,
-0.0482904427,
-0.0021817619,
-0.005017498,
0.0117982263,
0.0162150152,
0.0122814383,
0.1076874062,
-0.01865796,
-0.0039089834,
0.0403140411,
0.0025206681,
-0.0163810849,
0.0139311068,
-0.0226347968,
-0.0051149735,
0.012853303,
0.0290319938,
0.0091388961,
-0.0325082392,
-0.0103763528,
0.07487306,
-0.0092070885,
-0.0651226565,
0.0629749075,
-0.0717324838,
0.0148993991,
0.0374271199,
-0.0508498214,
-0.039762713,
0.0150368279,
0.0310255736,
-0.044477988,
0.0281760339,
0.011374779,
0.0457149036,
-0.0103943469,
0.0391372256,
0.0404353142,
-0.0369352177,
-0.0104619348,
-0.0934690535,
0.0463897921,
0.1140097752,
0.0107330084,
-0.0278342403,
0.0081956144,
0.0216776021,
0.0039820364,
0.041816093,
0.055340521,
0.0275072884,
-0.0313852057,
-0.018650312,
-0.031475354,
0.0714784265,
0.011745193,
0.0128507055,
0.0370858572,
0.1097857654,
-0.0329423733,
-0.0493682101,
-0.0310808849,
-0.0654929951,
0.0474107526,
0.0484634228,
0.0052196956,
-0.062974982,
-0.0312613696,
-0.0043177395,
0.0220347159,
-0.0221906826,
-0.0149840936,
0.0266791228,
0.0083963182,
-0.0427630432,
-0.0636217296,
-0.0153345466,
0.0367669836,
0.059559688,
0.0272100344,
-0.0411325172,
-0.0156794321,
0.0157027859,
0.0276805758,
0.008233469,
0.0134858722,
0.0153072551,
-0.0219154954,
-0.0361959934,
0.0307842046,
-0.0003061199,
0.0164037719,
0.0229617395,
-0.0149121135,
-0.065210104,
0.0299188178,
0.0909717083,
0.0297204442,
0.0270653777,
-0.0102060605,
-0.0348399691,
0.0546430163,
0.0597911328,
0.0002024987,
0.0243102368,
0.0326109268,
-0.0214088894,
-0.0055357455,
0.0200674664,
-0.0566120408,
0.0300975274,
0.0412611663,
0.0102803214,
-0.0308735352,
0.0409584977,
0.0311419126,
0.0030804281,
0.0296090748,
-0.0439420417,
-0.0197006091,
-0.0312751681,
-0.0117802117,
0.0143563263,
-0.0302735623,
-0.0467154346,
0.0274210572,
0.0440976545,
0.0357217118,
0.0455247201,
-0.0005890378,
0.0403228216,
0.023491893,
-0.0460399501,
0.0270171314,
0.0178295616,
0.0635784119,
0.0052150423,
0.0263017882,
-0.0048715463,
0.0058422131,
-0.0036254777,
0.0321945697,
0.0434511155,
0.0519340634,
0.0536273606,
0.0507989079,
-0.0124133285,
0.0151164606,
-0.1211843789,
-0.0599499904,
-0.0005843294,
0.0371974558,
0.0381236263,
0.0310003404,
-0.0153676579,
-0.0015709742,
0.0097860545,
0.0072723627,
0.0307706967,
-0.0180670768,
0.030079795,
-0.0027031966,
0.0365757123,
0.0171565413,
0.0487827808,
0.0456153154,
-0.0590232164,
0.0482022017,
-0.0623111688,
0.0148583679,
-0.0093794437,
-0.0062573804,
0.0249366537,
0.0014596641,
-0.0005398936,
-0.0371877551,
-0.02598425,
-0.0192929097,
-0.0110316724,
0.0408886448,
0.0102421148,
-0.0055127963,
-0.0004878281,
0.029096758,
-0.0442964248,
-0.0220315941,
0.0249715243,
-0.0646616146,
0.034219157,
0.0171838384,
-0.0261610653,
-6.026946881e-33,
-0.018161783,
-0.0315899849,
-0.0111973882,
-0.0141101861,
-0.0259502083,
-0.0122008696,
-0.0113152787,
-0.0004901175,
-0.0281096343,
0.0294747464,
-0.0144696804,
0.0215495955,
-0.0003460333,
-0.0186922234,
0.0474558063,
-0.0169361737,
0.0251082797,
-0.0176085923,
-0.0354263335,
0.0410863087,
0.0370351225,
0.0272383429,
0.0167240333,
-0.1043210551,
0.0155550512,
-0.0256641433,
-0.0551680401,
0.0177703165,
-0.0135595072,
0.0151497461,
0.0125590833,
-0.0121361502,
-0.0026622391,
-0.0126409614,
-0.0086381314,
0.0403454565,
-0.0323490053,
-0.0171836726,
-0.0496014208,
-0.0295579191,
-0.0573445447,
-0.0407756455,
0.0444522388,
0.0065399455,
-0.0437265337,
-0.020462811,
0.0349197611,
-0.0117303086,
0.0098829987,
-0.0403156988,
-0.0465866551,
0.0054960707,
-0.0334928222,
-0.0158197954,
-0.0343073048,
0.0162772723,
-0.0067110443,
-0.0459588207,
0.0291537438,
0.0146666095,
0.0223211329,
-0.0421479009,
0.0397556163,
0.0549650379,
-0.0128881689,
0.0515361652,
0.0495724715,
-0.0017114786,
-0.0103817554,
-0.0834397227,
-0.0224856138,
0.0675811917,
0.0549213663,
0.0322375186,
0.0288217533,
0.0037361947,
-0.0543764308,
0.0324865952,
0.0352794081,
0.0292116664,
-0.038227953,
0.0394203439,
-0.0761322975,
-0.0070704087,
0.0247275792,
-0.0854952782,
-0.004621746,
-0.0108817713,
0.0351617187,
-0.0036850479,
-0.0292601939,
0.0140755391,
0.0124778748,
-0.0476453044,
0.0655784383,
0.0052385326,
-0.0222098902,
0.0521670133,
-0.0152554372,
-0.0314390101,
-0.0446154661,
-0.0629974157,
0.0462450311,
0.0473555215,
0.0537621193,
0.0319496505,
0.0632672012,
0.0300336815,
-0.0071816309,
-0.0059457077,
-0.0150228152,
-0.0226954427,
0.053717602,
-0.0496108793,
0.03473581,
-0.0138878319,
0.0098245069,
0.0302876122,
0.0070512942,
0.0117007829,
-0.0255718008,
-0.0075721806,
-0.0108194249,
-0.014918766,
-0.0020212925,
-0.0295119025,
-0.012551019,
-0.0282890107,
-0.006322328,
-0.0802010074,
-0.0129378056,
0.0114982612,
2.942e-7,
-0.0138058467,
0.0055541741,
0.0344277397,
-0.0563226007,
-0.0256995279,
0.036786899,
-0.0498105101,
0.0385566205,
-0.0043718228,
-0.0134679694,
0.0470783934,
0.0275875609,
-0.0017285037,
0.0016785273,
-0.0456226096,
-0.0260499734,
-0.0373637043,
0.0242519621,
-0.0566085353,
0.0046082535,
0.0551180504,
0.0705377162,
0.0096374592,
-0.0133340452,
0.0228206776,
-0.0593339652,
0.020422738,
0.0259165671,
0.0340004005,
0.0306265112,
0.0348322764,
0.0364330858,
-0.0383744761,
0.0475470833,
0.0046623969,
0.0431278907,
0.0284363423,
0.0216334406,
-0.0468223244,
0.0368994549,
-0.014327406,
0.0488388352,
0.0413612388,
0.021315312,
0.0425373539,
-0.064204812,
-0.0152341751,
0.0014914306,
-0.0181691125,
-0.0034480183,
-0.0449247286,
0.007288876,
0.0502426215,
0.0242280681,
-0.0248050429,
0.0374213643,
-0.0304645076,
-0.0537798665,
-0.0028455372,
0.0187367424,
-0.0158134848,
-0.0823479518,
0.0116454726,
0.036504548,
0.0142026059,
-0.0576354191,
-0.0059646387,
2.501167518e-34,
-0.0157864783,
-0.0230051149,
0.0291447043,
0.0035715725,
0.0270485207,
-0.0364721529,
-0.0641287416,
0.0072002755,
0.072719112,
-0.0103036622,
-0.0104243588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00658v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00658v2 | Learning Planning-based Reasoning by Trajectories Collection and Process Reward Synthesizing | 2024-02-01T15:18:33 | 2024-04-15T06:36:24 | Fangkai Jiao, Chengwei Qin, Zhengyuan Liu, Nancy F. Chen, Shafiq Joty | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks through step-by-step rationale generation.
However, recent studies have raised concerns regarding the hallucination and
flaws in their reasoning process. Substantial efforts are being made to improve
the reliability and faithfulness of the generated rationales. Some approaches
model reasoning as planning, while others focus on annotating for process
supervision. Nevertheless, the planning-based search process often results in
high latency due to the frequent assessment of intermediate reasoning states
and the extensive exploration space. Additionally, supervising the reasoning
process with human annotation is costly and challenging to scale for LLM
training. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose a framework to
learn planning-based reasoning through Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) on
collected trajectories, which are ranked according to synthesized process
rewards. Our results on challenging logical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our learning framework, showing that our 7B model can
surpass the strong counterparts like GPT-3.5-Turbo. | [
0.0272291787,
0.0427385271,
0.0052182684,
0.0216913298,
-0.0464945994,
0.0074330741,
-0.0262012836,
-0.0261240788,
-0.0336185209,
-0.0094227567,
0.0150940903,
-0.0059903273,
-0.0265247524,
0.0112259695,
-0.0087236296,
-0.0639693588,
0.0487210825,
-0.0570496097,
0.0210887194,
0.0171744078,
-0.0151729733,
0.0459588319,
-0.0359607451,
0.061292965,
-0.0012978779,
0.002780898,
-0.0295236129,
-0.0061148675,
0.0429265574,
-0.0767844394,
-0.0396345556,
0.0260250065,
0.0513342917,
0.0097947707,
0.0000021639,
-0.0587036647,
-0.0324699245,
-0.0099896574,
-0.043522194,
-0.0418500304,
-0.0222234912,
0.0147786932,
-0.0055482071,
0.04942986,
-0.0182161015,
0.0401432849,
0.0081518516,
0.0401552767,
0.0686420202,
0.0816684216,
0.0123649929,
-0.0623690225,
-0.0080225803,
-0.0291174874,
0.0105434833,
-0.0357380733,
-0.0224311091,
0.0321989469,
0.0508139953,
0.0347382873,
0.0272998009,
-0.0215290319,
0.0397050753,
-0.046396859,
-0.0296936799,
0.0500745364,
0.0254164748,
-0.0164711028,
0.0059371833,
0.0758335814,
-0.010341364,
-0.0250950903,
0.0313588902,
-0.022307897,
-0.0290677324,
-0.0411919355,
-0.0400340743,
0.0647859052,
0.000828772,
0.0352927819,
0.0441296995,
-0.0015563107,
0.0262356251,
0.0026951686,
-0.0248323362,
0.0942466184,
-0.018352706,
-0.0187513996,
0.0219170712,
-0.0151294796,
-0.0227299221,
-0.0621836036,
-0.0102512892,
0.0668106452,
-0.0648077503,
0.0240872577,
-0.0013505277,
0.0628398359,
-0.0032560085,
0.0170339048,
0.059771996,
0.0705955029,
0.019060351,
0.0396541245,
-0.031468451,
0.0321176574,
-0.0103564411,
0.0566109419,
-0.0328856781,
0.028137289,
-0.0778826475,
0.0145100886,
-0.0221777484,
0.0420335941,
-0.0658879802,
-0.0118059693,
-0.0419466831,
0.0373350307,
-0.0278249327,
0.0439548828,
0.0425510481,
-0.0017808353,
0.0054737809,
-0.0402601659,
-0.0846266896,
-0.0066216267,
-0.044504486,
0.0233259965,
0.0154332882,
0.0250428002,
-0.0274206921,
-0.0002017416,
-0.0027908229,
-0.0178950336,
-0.0042175152,
0.0699113756,
0.0020216138,
-0.0097089643,
-0.0706451535,
-0.0653290823,
-0.0086564356,
-0.0892767906,
0.0166705884,
-0.0427508242,
0.01047746,
-0.0300701614,
-0.0307686459,
0.0099318121,
0.0236909017,
0.0252170693,
0.0014891619,
0.0548646413,
0.0287433062,
-0.0118122129,
-0.0469411574,
0.0063134995,
-0.0139942821,
0.06045736,
0.0543575473,
0.0391361415,
-0.02032803,
0.0201035738,
-0.0245857555,
-0.0157753117,
0.0208372883,
-0.0248084683,
-0.0075681508,
0.0226714946,
-0.0344888121,
0.0353617035,
0.0458068475,
0.0282804109,
-0.0553301089,
0.0020914883,
0.0136691099,
0.0376656502,
0.0068208072,
-0.0284510609,
0.0523002855,
-0.0108853439,
-0.0267546121,
-0.028494535,
-0.0517089963,
0.0548836514,
-0.0304005593,
0.0066638691,
-0.0013994629,
-0.0214195941,
-0.0018962377,
-0.060934972,
0.0012166105,
0.0080248956,
0.0278970711,
0.0194160659,
0.0427318439,
-0.0066633979,
-0.0875488818,
0.0004660364,
-0.0168336537,
-0.0430228077,
-0.0190891251,
-0.0387950242,
0.069560878,
0.0767467543,
0.0241919551,
-0.0202068761,
-0.0131186564,
-0.0188758373,
-0.0053656483,
0.0144343711,
0.018471662,
-0.0458816886,
-0.0134149054,
-0.0445741713,
-0.0603231601,
-0.0412664674,
0.0027746039,
0.0119643919,
0.0287981406,
-0.0238315295,
0.0021900365,
-0.0121511864,
-0.0074613872,
0.0176129341,
-0.000512934,
-0.0136301024,
-0.0011616341,
-0.0058996859,
0.0420023315,
0.010416707,
0.002611282,
0.042278666,
0.0294768959,
-0.0174293201,
-0.0045304634,
0.0258967225,
-0.0620151646,
-0.0423351713,
0.0358052328,
0.0053220931,
-0.0231080893,
-0.0132820653,
-0.0610361695,
-0.0607266575,
-0.002911089,
-0.0107929185,
0.0071007479,
-0.0233558584,
0.0182455368,
0.055840645,
-0.0562286824,
-0.0456266217,
0.0823147222,
-0.0100426432,
-0.0320713334,
0.0250009168,
0.0238103382,
0.025826348,
-0.0542110093,
0.0296908263,
0.0585089587,
0.0021875401,
-0.0182489473,
0.0220025741,
0.0044739079,
-0.0526375696,
-0.0196721386,
-0.06557253,
0.0196490735,
-0.0189089812,
0.0216565896,
0.0128699448,
-0.0144494176,
0.0304064937,
-0.0139558567,
-0.0164369643,
0.0036680999,
0.0202198569,
-0.0043220455,
0.0251100734,
0.0293664448,
-0.0217138268,
-0.0249549765,
-0.0040490041,
-0.040004544,
-0.0243465062,
0.0067115817,
0.0313538611,
-0.0446546376,
0.0334994458,
-0.0056592356,
0.0033653844,
-0.0032477072,
0.0100326883,
0.0575887114,
-0.0148932394,
-0.0104543855,
0.0780981034,
-0.0042881016,
0.0065905354,
0.0563431494,
-0.0277791638,
-0.0570374653,
0.0588454343,
-0.0358950347,
0.0097081494,
-0.0410204381,
-0.0294448379,
-0.0171505157,
0.0396139398,
-0.0230702329,
0.0322624035,
-0.0779595003,
-0.0003967427,
0.0073722103,
-0.0095698461,
0.0000663736,
-0.0170648973,
-0.010250547,
0.0548691899,
-0.0274443403,
-0.0119033121,
0.0782938376,
-0.0112102134,
0.0138880806,
-0.0433040038,
-0.0030918252,
-0.0235910509,
0.076731436,
0.0056552882,
0.0047080694,
-0.0225283746,
0.0007476138,
-0.0348887593,
-0.0469136797,
0.0455748476,
-0.0199519955,
0.0427445024,
-0.0982696116,
0.0280741863,
0.0045672213,
-0.0547143593,
-0.0579189993,
0.0006335689,
-0.0480545685,
0.0293046311,
-0.0201015063,
-0.0477610119,
0.0267442763,
-0.0037609821,
0.0304362066,
0.0541206561,
0.0172833726,
-0.0218640771,
-0.025097996,
-0.0305136666,
0.0291276127,
0.0227168668,
0.0322299898,
-0.0008494785,
0.027457187,
0.0150565822,
0.0768442228,
-0.0179472119,
-0.01965761,
0.034638349,
-0.0028489155,
-0.0274949688,
-0.0070547131,
0.0482574143,
0.0595521592,
-0.054255046,
-0.0282967743,
0.1045346931,
0.0317084827,
0.0324069373,
0.01243365,
-0.0160835497,
0.0610638894,
0.0126024913,
0.0461467914,
-0.0242230557,
-0.0354939885,
0.0206985958,
0.0239797737,
-0.0288271289,
-0.0506309681,
-0.0136543605,
-0.1368300021,
0.0567266755,
-0.0175440572,
-0.0045245737,
0.0175255463,
-0.0635965317,
-0.0369623713,
-0.0323782153,
0.0040485184,
0.0192013551,
0.0060181036,
0.0091942456,
0.0381821431,
-0.0180154592,
-0.0116764382,
0.046755258,
0.0199899115,
0.0061473665,
0.0951450542,
0.0429435447,
0.0360132344,
-0.050042741,
0.0138805956,
0.0371737517,
0.0061938162,
-0.0247184616,
-0.0077573964,
0.016552791,
0.0029491729,
-0.0021428543,
0.0774902701,
-0.0427724794,
-0.0614480674,
0.0001907926,
0.0950884447,
-0.0444418192,
0.0053557972,
-0.0215334762,
0.0222181119,
-0.0066009741,
0.0505849123,
-0.0281098504,
0.0022190164,
-0.065798007,
-0.0353878811,
-0.0355736129,
-0.0948040187,
-0.0131460512,
0.0003601547,
0.0278019048,
0.0474579819,
-0.0607696176,
-0.0178075954,
0.0414831825,
0.0791801512,
-0.0176438149,
-0.010282306,
-0.001775308,
0.0039462675,
-0.0286667328,
0.0326251201,
-0.0263345186,
0.0334607922,
-0.033813525,
0.01986981,
-0.0076239146,
0.0043738317,
-0.0218218099,
0.0060637286,
-0.0574701466,
-0.0533507206,
-0.0400344804,
0.0594126284,
0.0237765722,
0.0786503777,
-0.0067256242,
-0.0013192124,
0.0038626594,
-0.0347855687,
-0.0043933676,
-0.0194106381,
0.047488153,
0.0150616458,
-0.0055778325,
0.0213622879,
-0.0376444235,
0.0120990714,
-0.001573271,
0.0737499744,
-0.0260236412,
-0.0098960837,
0.0425983332,
-0.0004219889,
0.0037557329,
-0.0183859952,
-0.0046353335,
-0.0413506068,
0.0315207057,
-0.0407284237,
-0.0020105133,
-0.0473418795,
0.0367051661,
0.0319321938,
-0.0556232892,
0.0285735037,
-0.0543379374,
0.0000479095,
-0.0137763089,
0.0563862137,
-0.0008263068,
0.0470683612,
-0.0032915329,
0.0186355617,
-0.0146763269,
-0.0075276201,
-0.0012987991,
0.0129959164,
0.0697646663,
-0.0037893096,
0.0940880328,
0.0557004809,
0.0115228025,
-0.0060801748,
-0.0128755551,
-0.0708350837,
-0.0628688484,
0.0145373745,
-0.0214478578,
0.0619432405,
-0.0230697207,
0.0341512263,
-0.0797618032,
0.0105318315,
0.0246080551,
0.0325686149,
-0.0089794071,
-0.0173283666,
0.0324082151,
0.0344972052,
0.0033001921,
-0.0220740214,
0.0409689806,
-0.0102459509,
0.0662873611,
-0.020217048,
0.0003059732,
-0.054561194,
-0.0665313378,
-0.0461061113,
0.0446505994,
-0.0107617909,
0.0071563502,
-0.0602192543,
-0.0404685587,
-0.0225676894,
0.0324320756,
-0.0103947334,
-0.0284331404,
0.045569893,
0.0256485548,
-0.0185764562,
-0.0477782786,
-0.024885403,
-0.0596586466,
-0.0040992228,
-0.0206543971,
-0.0363988802,
-6.006118958e-33,
-0.0090824626,
-0.0409227423,
0.0788889825,
-0.0643738955,
-0.0269235708,
-0.0499480218,
-0.0399173722,
-0.0141712781,
-0.0081532318,
0.0198730789,
-0.0189981777,
0.0023589758,
0.0100772576,
0.0246624108,
0.0146045033,
0.0120234964,
0.0511350371,
0.003007665,
-0.0431016088,
0.0211839806,
0.0739059746,
-0.035941314,
0.0006495268,
-0.0159633793,
-0.0067226551,
0.0555272698,
-0.0391385891,
0.0741024464,
-0.0605057552,
0.0516101494,
0.0083382688,
-0.0348702222,
0.0028985615,
-0.0302793793,
-0.0142393522,
-0.0096880123,
-0.0654347241,
-0.0269694179,
0.0391198695,
-0.0294656232,
-0.0556610264,
-0.0338087566,
-0.0062138299,
0.0019867008,
0.0212167166,
0.0092475191,
-0.0178681128,
-0.0097476048,
-0.0199393537,
0.0605048761,
-0.0545753986,
0.0157534126,
-0.0210613292,
-0.0116506061,
0.0472749248,
0.0261973683,
0.0053709662,
-0.0194470081,
-0.0146387778,
0.0168795828,
-0.0427147783,
0.0039097569,
0.0665980726,
0.0235583112,
0.0059001688,
0.0485429391,
-0.0003187295,
0.0024579272,
-0.0191262104,
0.034113422,
-0.021356307,
0.1028200984,
0.0091382246,
-0.0081548002,
-0.0011856591,
0.043057356,
-0.0944978818,
0.0205891132,
-0.0194812156,
0.0604385249,
0.0416385718,
0.0228062384,
-0.0207172353,
-0.0076025431,
-0.0673549548,
0.0086918864,
0.0017545717,
-0.0218364317,
0.027686879,
0.0522598289,
0.0004344969,
-0.0242628586,
0.0285752248,
-0.0219822228,
-0.0101761678,
0.0249310471,
-0.0382025577,
0.0053334185,
-0.0162497535,
0.0402917787,
-0.0838430375,
-0.0295463651,
0.0155432383,
-0.0169171877,
0.0000100981,
0.0070293345,
0.0108113978,
0.0036547624,
-0.0332031436,
0.008584735,
-0.072510004,
0.0320574604,
-0.0351103619,
0.0018666753,
0.0524849221,
0.0117236003,
-0.0057348544,
0.0203369465,
-0.0114666549,
-0.0305771939,
0.0059643714,
-0.002718597,
-0.0034754733,
0.0205318984,
0.0080018705,
0.0031809108,
-0.0000688474,
0.025762409,
0.0043423716,
-0.0336841941,
-0.0022702778,
0.0503351651,
2.841e-7,
0.002428503,
0.0124990195,
0.0148537476,
0.0483976267,
-0.0020121401,
0.0387180746,
-0.0056552454,
-0.0366298966,
0.0030958641,
-0.0226639435,
0.027519796,
0.0188053194,
0.0270463526,
0.024775289,
-0.0428664498,
-0.0197835322,
-0.0016133639,
-0.0446513072,
-0.0448096916,
-0.0264309701,
0.0700513944,
0.0672511533,
0.0233741738,
-0.0096614668,
0.0224181712,
0.0022714601,
0.048488982,
-0.0090379454,
0.0035419944,
-0.0005267459,
0.0320730545,
-0.0135200955,
0.003248052,
0.0054085059,
-0.0166823324,
0.0144622196,
-0.0558319353,
0.0776095837,
-0.0135930581,
-0.0672039613,
-0.0233064815,
-0.03450289,
0.0256584212,
-0.0255876482,
0.0681196153,
-0.0538196377,
-0.0229375008,
0.0177280456,
0.0187840797,
-0.0110637769,
-0.0220300592,
0.0247454103,
0.0009050902,
0.0150336707,
-0.0076712924,
-0.0015819623,
0.0213654526,
-0.0982803255,
0.0027925537,
0.0378729329,
-0.0116718449,
-0.0270813666,
-0.0226803627,
0.0491532087,
0.0034260224,
-0.0113219768,
-0.0453103893,
2.829396076e-34,
0.008348152,
-0.0026087605,
0.0103649786,
0.0062326132,
0.0528721213,
0.0266087018,
0.000593017,
0.0067205243,
0.0573217049,
-0.0631749034,
-0.0316451974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00632v1 | Prosody in Cascade and Direct Speech-to-Text Translation: a case study on Korean Wh-Phrases | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | Giulio Zhou, Tsz Kin Lam, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speech-to-Text Translation (S2TT) has typically been addressed with cascade
systems, where speech recognition systems generate a transcription that is
subsequently passed to a translation model. While there has been a growing
interest in developing direct speech translation systems to avoid propagating
errors and losing non-verbal content, prior work in direct S2TT has struggled
to conclusively establish the advantages of integrating the acoustic signal
directly into the translation process. This work proposes using contrastive
evaluation to quantitatively measure the ability of direct S2TT systems to
disambiguate utterances where prosody plays a crucial role. Specifically, we
evaluated Korean-English translation systems on a test set containing
wh-phrases, for which prosodic features are necessary to produce translations
with the correct intent, whether it's a statement, a yes/no question, a
wh-question, and more. Our results clearly demonstrate the value of direct
translation systems over cascade translation models, with a notable 12.9%
improvement in overall accuracy in ambiguous cases, along with up to a 15.6%
increase in F1 scores for one of the major intent categories. To the best of
our knowledge, this work stands as the first to provide quantitative evidence
that direct S2TT models can effectively leverage prosody. The code for our
evaluation is openly accessible and freely available for review and
utilisation. | [
0.0487482622,
0.0287345499,
-0.0241489466,
0.0052313711,
-0.0619380698,
-0.0030344483,
0.0554140024,
0.0053825607,
-0.0309571475,
-0.0182764996,
-0.0594089814,
-0.0538299754,
0.0934411958,
-0.0034947011,
0.0129177701,
-0.0820118934,
0.0376498997,
-0.0325231403,
0.025759384,
0.0076831453,
-0.0016951996,
-0.0036663194,
-0.0316067562,
0.0302303527,
0.0019417314,
0.0013583773,
-0.0251797922,
0.0797830522,
0.0421476178,
-0.0237816125,
-0.0442575514,
0.0481470935,
0.0049560294,
0.0450251848,
0.0000019526,
-0.0400547087,
-0.0004849412,
-0.0024182792,
-0.0178094935,
0.0145222535,
0.0536103733,
0.0070149866,
-0.004946277,
0.0372284427,
0.0036364819,
-0.02821563,
0.0640667379,
0.0094645312,
0.0075544571,
0.0306606516,
-0.018376179,
-0.0489876568,
-0.0145097915,
-0.0148235634,
-0.0259429682,
-0.016599698,
-0.0081321066,
-0.0595485568,
-0.0357826315,
-0.0483360626,
-0.0319785289,
0.06514965,
-0.0257320795,
-0.0012230752,
0.0130894687,
-0.0206164308,
-0.0328501724,
-0.0486031212,
-0.0029041748,
0.0531304218,
0.0190248154,
0.010642441,
-0.0054942714,
-0.0107145132,
-0.0187746026,
-0.0243907645,
0.0356717557,
0.0077990107,
-0.0181211662,
-0.0343707427,
0.0158307254,
0.0470347926,
0.0052043837,
-0.0306198411,
-0.038687367,
0.0045328606,
0.0447845794,
-0.0287347715,
0.0055140019,
-0.0137185529,
-0.0022660561,
-0.0142867593,
0.0898159295,
-0.0330226347,
-0.0040880796,
0.0300491862,
0.0068347389,
-0.0421112515,
-0.0059607718,
-0.0112359412,
0.0014404668,
0.073627837,
-0.0566274188,
-0.0131063582,
0.0002785644,
0.0517816395,
0.0099898856,
-0.007752778,
-0.0966036096,
0.0244949404,
0.0071115959,
0.037717618,
-0.0501755662,
-0.0138490461,
-0.0571558028,
-0.0072472789,
-0.0171118304,
-0.0132625801,
0.020828547,
0.0116122365,
0.0242394693,
-0.0368523039,
-0.1090643257,
0.0042861747,
0.0157131646,
0.0746857524,
-0.0193951391,
0.0643830672,
-0.0195130538,
-0.0297560859,
0.0145634878,
0.036305856,
0.0238776691,
0.0289662834,
-0.016583357,
0.0304126367,
-0.0010736482,
-0.0173853841,
-0.0135292429,
0.0102248574,
-0.080331251,
-0.0606823191,
-0.0477323979,
-0.0406073444,
0.0377876759,
0.0242721979,
0.0260736849,
-0.0043898118,
-0.003615337,
-0.0274685975,
0.0229448378,
0.0613177344,
0.0268826373,
0.0351841934,
0.0240045469,
-0.0110594425,
-0.0063470742,
0.0428195447,
0.0801745877,
0.0007954268,
-0.0025741921,
-0.0044096797,
-0.0688808858,
0.0450046062,
-0.0240644272,
0.0176878162,
-0.0200975258,
0.0104381777,
0.0090265777,
0.0001189647,
-0.0037214628,
0.0853383169,
-0.0082265195,
0.014105537,
0.0740773007,
0.0406853631,
0.0192211028,
0.0128007848,
0.0491324738,
0.0414995216,
0.0232245699,
0.0180426408,
0.0176060963,
-0.0525695756,
-0.0534096695,
0.0213759076,
0.0149625577,
0.023789838,
-0.0427339859,
-0.0368882567,
-0.0184681825,
-0.0105653545,
0.0202705655,
-0.0007322275,
0.0602354147,
0.0144883022,
-0.0754061043,
0.0075700558,
-0.005213595,
-0.0801016837,
0.041268032,
-0.0196263101,
-0.0417874455,
0.0825387836,
-0.0053818277,
0.0122974459,
0.0333604403,
-0.0345922932,
-0.0476926453,
0.0720671266,
0.0360285752,
-0.008146029,
0.0570129864,
-0.0240252949,
0.0103425682,
0.0668795183,
0.0291590746,
0.0110483794,
-0.0512804873,
0.045766592,
0.0373423211,
0.0146789066,
-0.0193914529,
-0.0073966105,
-0.003929988,
0.0021512134,
0.0373246558,
0.0321733579,
0.0192793105,
0.0540540181,
-0.0343547054,
0.0155601967,
-0.0006416573,
-0.0401047096,
0.0015204757,
0.0446490459,
-0.0143273622,
-0.074038744,
-0.0212964565,
-0.0337435268,
0.0169318859,
0.0007017758,
-0.0020278937,
-0.0756144598,
-0.0183010213,
-0.0574052036,
0.0168641303,
-0.0172845516,
0.0557125248,
-0.0303012319,
-0.010479236,
-0.0088300118,
-0.0040958044,
0.0086875297,
-0.0424950458,
0.0239630509,
-0.0000652624,
0.0215952434,
-0.0483187027,
-0.0392647795,
0.0494547263,
-0.0294882283,
0.0202258453,
0.0074546179,
-0.0111464104,
-0.0630154833,
-0.0417113751,
-0.0747696683,
0.0319007188,
-0.0196699351,
0.0482846163,
0.0428449884,
0.0119916964,
-0.0117632216,
0.0089805368,
0.0238016881,
-0.0297549982,
-0.0087179216,
-0.0120722065,
-0.0288565941,
-0.0212095547,
-0.0038842033,
-0.0197666641,
-0.012550259,
-0.000413171,
-0.0219737925,
0.0149878543,
-0.0175721664,
-0.040676944,
0.0793934911,
0.0070099747,
-0.0787057355,
0.0421453416,
-0.0443148203,
0.0286178254,
-0.0021157158,
0.0619364083,
0.0301438086,
-0.0137137994,
-0.009402642,
0.0057089217,
-0.0666152239,
0.0037554167,
-0.0068031359,
-0.0085168723,
-0.030680025,
-0.011636666,
-0.0708728507,
-0.0363504216,
0.0056733354,
0.0845964774,
0.0231717713,
-0.0760169402,
-0.0721356496,
-0.0657823384,
-0.0091455569,
0.0209633503,
-0.0314025395,
-0.0134155117,
0.0233917944,
-0.0034675742,
-0.0187081974,
0.0627435222,
-0.0486131459,
-0.0305410121,
-0.0671132207,
0.0281714723,
-0.0173568577,
0.0205395296,
-0.0637568682,
-0.0024380037,
0.0042627407,
-0.0722750574,
0.0090678036,
-0.014189627,
0.0130973831,
-0.0891903788,
0.0339639559,
-0.0347675607,
-0.0105250888,
-0.0146527346,
-0.0264734849,
-0.0204064678,
-0.0302231628,
-0.0194759294,
0.0027902417,
-0.0079451697,
-0.004347119,
0.0232482199,
0.0653605908,
0.0298975464,
0.0189731456,
-0.0081242528,
0.0263396651,
-0.018600069,
0.0311339442,
-0.0085253492,
0.0115097249,
0.0095487665,
-0.0440688282,
0.0728077069,
-0.0249937922,
0.043394763,
0.0138318669,
-0.0308978558,
0.0134599768,
0.0299146157,
0.012885876,
-0.0420680642,
0.0131835332,
0.0823991001,
-0.0453086458,
0.040547777,
0.0986339822,
-0.0005751429,
-0.0216349941,
-0.0192226656,
0.0104257623,
0.0477333963,
0.0038200719,
-0.0313594118,
-0.0168568343,
-0.0400385931,
0.043654412,
0.0392478257,
0.0057989089,
0.029215401,
-0.0043367101,
-0.0752539933,
0.045668602,
0.0475631617,
-0.0340356976,
-0.0420380309,
-0.0242034607,
0.0072041089,
-0.0012540538,
0.0086807841,
0.0003679548,
0.0031799432,
-0.0276857559,
-0.0046900073,
-0.0228089169,
-0.005745376,
0.0171161368,
-0.0259971768,
0.0151302665,
0.0513279475,
0.0349708907,
-0.0026791426,
-0.0182031263,
-0.0250317622,
-0.066885002,
-0.0188960284,
-0.0144804092,
0.0066738934,
0.0285179522,
-0.0012287149,
-0.0309345461,
0.0212170463,
-0.027104063,
0.0509354696,
-0.0056847287,
0.0153606012,
0.0002602865,
0.002310144,
0.0308995433,
0.0167485941,
0.0517968647,
0.0442091711,
0.0174388364,
-0.0796826854,
-0.0051645627,
0.0012556623,
0.0025020174,
0.0133149642,
0.0002401128,
0.0020590732,
-0.0135604581,
-0.0320911743,
-0.0702616349,
-0.0360925347,
-0.0129048713,
0.0348964967,
0.0311806388,
0.035950318,
-0.0086928066,
0.050569199,
-0.0001750203,
0.0212267935,
0.0091927992,
0.0507596247,
-0.0304132588,
0.0101190861,
-0.0025765144,
-0.053308975,
0.0069409921,
-0.0077621946,
-0.0604234412,
-0.0418533646,
0.0264187288,
-0.0290979389,
0.0229167454,
0.0049447846,
-0.03141528,
0.003004319,
-0.0145535553,
-0.0008028253,
-0.0252291616,
0.0066442448,
0.059037786,
-0.0075279581,
-0.023923438,
0.0567952953,
-0.0170461312,
-0.0075871474,
-0.0470014699,
0.0865411758,
0.0203372575,
-0.0907784104,
-0.0258024801,
0.0389986187,
0.0440812968,
-0.0165586937,
-0.0558338054,
-0.0078870356,
0.0277427472,
-0.0171127822,
0.0346073359,
-0.0163352937,
-0.0109048234,
0.047332596,
0.0192409642,
-0.0141632706,
0.0088829324,
-0.047551062,
-0.0423675999,
0.0466758125,
0.0310441274,
0.0370082632,
0.0874527469,
-0.0178200454,
0.0099553689,
-0.0579209402,
0.0262364689,
0.0196573008,
0.0167559441,
0.0048832204,
0.0488068461,
-0.0315392129,
0.0050376011,
0.0065522417,
0.0012863296,
-0.0072591309,
0.0015101079,
0.0091784969,
-0.0267173033,
0.048559241,
0.012152262,
0.1000487432,
-0.0183311719,
0.0346482657,
-0.0447304957,
0.0344438218,
-0.0166549105,
0.0138684064,
-0.014938388,
-0.012258607,
0.0083769849,
0.0490679033,
-0.0041729081,
0.0009958131,
-0.0052879811,
-0.0263729189,
0.0011436158,
0.0013047104,
-0.0431726202,
-0.0203772224,
-0.0078063016,
-0.0528420471,
-0.0330782905,
-0.0998320058,
-0.0455134399,
-0.0061576138,
0.0250176247,
0.0425205417,
-0.0255555846,
-0.0082030473,
0.0204058643,
-0.0421058685,
-0.0449364632,
-0.0213998575,
0.0073345904,
-0.0068184412,
0.0272333566,
0.0093538314,
-6.358077028e-33,
-0.0150493747,
-0.0168757401,
-0.0282817315,
-0.0104071824,
-0.0570696965,
-0.0027355314,
-0.0502993912,
0.0014868731,
-0.0171704274,
-0.0179689862,
-0.0209232569,
-0.0063082697,
0.0403303504,
-0.0079124756,
0.0042237896,
0.0030026785,
0.0631068349,
-0.0167806447,
-0.0317433104,
0.065158844,
0.0420147926,
-0.0057183071,
0.029878607,
-0.0333974101,
0.0433693156,
-0.0482380018,
-0.0206359774,
-0.0176435225,
0.0117402039,
0.0211265273,
-0.0144183021,
0.0343014114,
-0.0046476168,
0.0069313212,
-0.0312076658,
0.029203482,
-0.0907154456,
0.0050084894,
0.0315924957,
0.0572253205,
-0.0425921194,
0.0022145244,
0.0241913218,
-0.0024191816,
-0.0285141338,
-0.017999975,
-0.0212431364,
-0.0383075848,
0.0125317778,
-0.013118254,
-0.0512190424,
0.0387497582,
-0.0255827103,
-0.012338534,
0.0503647774,
0.0801761597,
-0.0527092107,
-0.0015614692,
-0.0364055336,
0.0091708358,
0.0148834344,
0.0082656918,
0.0615653545,
0.0249339212,
-0.0219435655,
-0.0262497496,
0.0395531058,
-0.0300522894,
0.0652517304,
-0.0517966487,
0.0422826819,
0.0304617453,
0.0306579769,
0.0072701289,
0.0628307089,
-0.0363046005,
-0.049647864,
-0.0160027575,
-0.0062822718,
0.000720966,
0.0341639705,
0.009022519,
-0.0590944067,
-0.0040561552,
-0.0894222111,
-0.059486784,
-0.0169457421,
-0.0324054323,
0.0187210403,
-0.0027459203,
-0.0064632953,
-0.027314771,
0.1165431812,
0.0172266494,
0.0352000818,
-0.0144927902,
-0.0410696119,
0.0420995392,
-0.0225796942,
0.0579616092,
-0.0645329431,
-0.006932829,
0.0192007162,
0.0370747298,
0.0085404301,
-0.0267118122,
-0.0295619927,
0.0371045209,
-0.0142747825,
0.0292602554,
0.0089346403,
-0.0319088176,
-0.0497726128,
-0.020685995,
0.0482226871,
0.0134568987,
0.0196976401,
0.0686832815,
0.0033789943,
0.0218816809,
-0.0562581941,
0.0262492746,
0.0103216935,
0.027571084,
-0.0073935268,
0.0285223499,
0.0254008509,
0.0462867692,
0.0215992928,
-0.0249237865,
-0.0162589271,
0.0365456939,
2.767e-7,
0.0159874018,
0.0208280738,
0.033194568,
-0.0047607142,
0.0155302528,
0.0269000046,
-0.046649199,
0.0032016344,
0.0492762066,
0.0297101829,
0.0397132896,
-0.0078454688,
0.1397657692,
0.0280454829,
-0.0597454868,
0.0017600146,
-0.0158261377,
0.0444884188,
-0.0431294851,
0.0390285589,
0.0990333408,
0.0580307841,
-0.0362066664,
-0.0096122511,
-0.0248392057,
0.0087341005,
0.0575778782,
0.0150864525,
0.0329967886,
-0.0011681868,
0.035556227,
-0.0464344881,
-0.0177703425,
0.0421657898,
-0.0310563687,
0.0328514576,
0.0306607522,
0.0975166783,
0.0054917946,
-0.0498124063,
-0.0050149108,
0.0098295491,
-0.0288405884,
-0.0314831883,
0.0575594343,
-0.0019015195,
0.0134211201,
0.0524470247,
0.0045116311,
0.0266881678,
0.0020979897,
-0.0292961746,
-0.0179175902,
0.016322596,
0.001037491,
-0.0164872352,
-0.0586473793,
0.0181604866,
-0.0199014265,
0.0051992387,
-0.0252827909,
-0.0597997792,
-0.0071565351,
0.020110853,
0.0040257415,
-0.0178657565,
0.0066477791,
2.430690662e-34,
0.057192117,
-0.05739538,
0.0032780885,
-0.0302930512,
0.0262580179,
-0.0316885673,
-0.053378094,
0.0222597178,
0.0250419043,
-0.0939134136,
-0.0314106494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00620v1 | Actor Identification in Discourse: A Challenge for LLMs? | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | Ana Barić, Sean Papay, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | The identification of political actors who put forward claims in public
debate is a crucial step in the construction of discourse networks, which are
helpful to analyze societal debates. Actor identification is, however, rather
challenging: Often, the locally mentioned speaker of a claim is only a pronoun
("He proposed that [claim]"), so recovering the canonical actor name requires
discourse understanding. We compare a traditional pipeline of dedicated NLP
components (similar to those applied to the related task of coreference) with a
LLM, which appears a good match for this generation task. Evaluating on a
corpus of German actors in newspaper reports, we find surprisingly that the LLM
performs worse. Further analysis reveals that the LLM is very good at
identifying the right reference, but struggles to generate the correct
canonical form. This points to an underlying issue in LLMs with controlling
generated output. Indeed, a hybrid model combining the LLM with a classifier to
normalize its output substantially outperforms both initial models. | [
0.0302791968,
0.0430052765,
0.0215011649,
0.0507591181,
-0.0238971859,
-0.031080652,
-0.0014383961,
-0.0170700904,
0.0065848716,
-0.0501034372,
0.0457914136,
0.0001428003,
-0.0280893091,
-0.0242580306,
0.0176422391,
-0.0154031906,
0.0319959447,
0.0292077344,
0.043503277,
-0.0283814576,
0.0051927557,
0.0245858394,
0.0050540632,
0.0278639961,
-0.0381313823,
0.0185680334,
0.0152427126,
0.0028084063,
0.0646855831,
-0.0127130235,
-0.0199354962,
0.0370416418,
-0.0022860835,
0.0460889824,
0.0000013995,
-0.0633243769,
-0.0102692032,
-0.0417378321,
0.0100606196,
-0.0086012464,
0.0202628653,
0.0209089499,
-0.0039795055,
0.0045991177,
-0.0144862784,
0.0216411091,
0.0074972021,
0.0640872344,
0.0411738381,
0.0847002193,
0.0037595136,
-0.0550566167,
-0.0063569606,
-0.0085496185,
-0.0658597946,
-0.0442505218,
0.0318927355,
-0.0183765721,
-0.0065673864,
0.0358725674,
0.0073246043,
0.0374106392,
-0.024946142,
-0.0238636527,
0.0015568675,
0.011622116,
-0.026374843,
-0.0062034796,
0.009083949,
0.0492834821,
0.1116045341,
-0.0219041798,
0.0622600392,
-0.0011110976,
0.0066599012,
0.0654744953,
0.0047649643,
0.0533650108,
-0.0364198089,
0.0226991568,
0.0613524728,
-0.0067905448,
0.0227820445,
0.0379889049,
0.0148942852,
0.0306222755,
-0.0217229687,
0.0035770831,
0.0291070584,
0.0253849849,
-0.009598555,
-0.0585470423,
0.0304079186,
0.0193592682,
-0.031283766,
0.0222019572,
-0.0089779142,
0.0001648524,
-0.0083438307,
-0.0782540068,
0.0230676271,
-0.0027103128,
-0.0197473746,
0.0206671283,
-0.0357260667,
0.0339287296,
-0.0595583282,
-0.0167055186,
0.0083034476,
-0.0311673135,
-0.0483463444,
-0.0244939998,
-0.0409985185,
0.0683157593,
-0.0416972451,
-0.0085356627,
-0.0340343788,
0.0098549128,
-0.0060278364,
0.0245849732,
0.0154626742,
0.0197597146,
0.0036684126,
0.0097866794,
-0.0700198859,
0.0725864172,
-0.0352331214,
-0.0059471577,
-0.0240757614,
0.0091761844,
0.0111773955,
0.0655025691,
0.0014401504,
-0.0079706041,
-0.0055044219,
0.0524283424,
-0.006496734,
0.0018043666,
0.0073502492,
-0.0446877517,
-0.0322293453,
-0.0259008314,
0.0062320055,
-0.056529291,
0.0017540874,
0.003050657,
0.0030457887,
-0.079124622,
0.0451585874,
0.0051146466,
-0.0253133271,
0.0277883653,
0.0280050375,
0.0256525259,
0.0449017473,
0.0049970043,
0.0232492071,
0.0309657194,
0.0425889678,
-0.024673013,
0.0457611978,
0.0016274884,
0.0060075969,
0.0271203872,
0.0170440413,
-0.0056718346,
0.0262142587,
-0.0247833766,
-0.0637400299,
0.0310170781,
0.0389235504,
0.0576418824,
-0.0007839525,
-0.039517872,
0.0323482566,
0.0333047099,
-0.0223244969,
-0.0198840778,
0.0167253241,
-0.0081214141,
0.0107507221,
0.0515151024,
0.0151781542,
-0.0081751142,
-0.0080268849,
-0.0563720129,
0.0237062313,
-0.0033169887,
-0.0238898713,
-0.0229190271,
0.0037015323,
0.0360523872,
-0.0248175468,
-0.0187642556,
0.0246439613,
0.0093149114,
-0.0285718627,
0.0830092579,
0.0234645251,
-0.0290402882,
0.0308821052,
-0.0300219096,
-0.0002879417,
-0.0341992229,
0.0337019674,
0.0034808032,
-0.0134972185,
-0.0308350231,
0.0407453403,
0.0855157748,
0.0358856581,
-0.0521327332,
-0.0336123817,
0.0169638749,
0.000979973,
-0.0093095694,
0.0225352608,
0.0681836829,
0.0160472654,
-0.0320725255,
0.0133103607,
-0.0068773115,
-0.0153364278,
0.0255024824,
-0.0420948565,
-0.0305370558,
0.0334185734,
-0.0097337775,
0.0369008482,
0.0744985864,
0.001470907,
-0.0349923372,
0.0323227905,
-0.0331346616,
-0.0094667608,
0.0282126386,
-0.0085859522,
0.0003306767,
0.0340129323,
-0.0622958317,
-0.0292938724,
-0.0065864329,
-0.0065237526,
-0.0641879439,
0.0663789138,
-0.0203740485,
0.0014429827,
-0.0370804481,
-0.017272843,
0.0161249638,
-0.0352422968,
-0.0778549165,
0.0831513703,
0.0226264689,
0.0266421661,
0.0378837734,
0.0017876611,
0.0293254647,
-0.0640116632,
-0.0079519367,
-0.029614158,
0.0092165191,
0.0184518527,
0.0557230152,
-0.03915032,
-0.0113614872,
-0.0481122695,
-0.0412201695,
0.0146582443,
-0.0082688974,
0.0348005109,
0.0106875906,
-0.0135570746,
0.0055848979,
0.0164945778,
-0.0145175541,
-0.0417501293,
0.0244944319,
-0.0453322865,
0.0658482909,
0.009469294,
-0.0181405041,
-0.0218138751,
0.0574803054,
-0.0312335771,
0.045698639,
0.021984376,
-0.0704492107,
-0.0309790764,
0.0156081729,
-0.0344670191,
0.0019325439,
-0.0254763737,
0.0168402698,
0.0303003509,
0.0526434891,
0.0239056069,
0.0280125272,
0.0107998811,
0.0547939949,
-0.032392554,
-0.0124948379,
-0.0776205063,
0.0025381995,
-0.0556028374,
-0.0016992094,
-0.0603255071,
-0.0094575789,
0.0519226938,
0.0629714578,
-0.0065615289,
0.0106121525,
0.0085125817,
0.0475849584,
0.0036248143,
-0.0131729515,
0.0470674746,
-0.0452178083,
-0.0236085095,
0.0481161475,
0.0074671158,
0.0199669413,
0.0122738229,
-0.0359180532,
0.0534238182,
0.0204204563,
-0.0351021625,
-0.0388578922,
0.0576069616,
-0.0008558455,
0.0103691062,
0.0200818479,
-0.05215903,
-0.0189394709,
-0.0255705509,
0.0654246211,
-0.0153476279,
0.0563010797,
-0.0426810198,
0.0617970861,
-0.0126867043,
-0.0307735931,
-0.0616935529,
-0.0340314545,
-0.0203279853,
0.0271908231,
-0.0381255969,
-0.0069077513,
-0.0586640835,
0.0282108057,
0.0161419865,
-0.048901923,
0.0326367915,
0.0268614925,
-0.0396740809,
0.0812515914,
-0.0338721909,
0.0147255659,
0.0308461767,
0.022868108,
-0.0117789144,
0.0409471057,
-0.0452479534,
0.0160011109,
-0.0363011546,
-0.055944223,
-0.0065746941,
-0.0726634488,
-0.0399850644,
-0.0392779335,
0.0689677,
-0.0329930559,
0.0129255531,
0.0895044133,
0.0143031599,
-0.0135250865,
-0.0078839837,
0.0118632279,
-0.008820666,
0.0228651054,
0.0121317627,
-0.0782979056,
0.0317957029,
0.0174202528,
-0.0055953939,
-0.060061641,
-0.0684113428,
-0.011543191,
-0.1027930677,
0.0360377133,
0.0039441963,
0.0150884567,
0.003447023,
-0.0624954589,
0.0165844597,
-0.014856535,
-0.0125630619,
0.0110356351,
0.010035187,
0.0167455357,
0.0492404811,
-0.0321736671,
-0.0242260266,
-0.016419217,
-0.0338603146,
0.0553217754,
-0.0018868584,
0.054918576,
0.0078103133,
0.0367800593,
0.0369229428,
-0.0395693444,
-0.0091482811,
-0.0362864658,
0.0209585633,
-0.0207362231,
-0.0231890939,
-0.013550031,
0.0361926407,
0.0028210033,
-0.0399140827,
0.0095397923,
0.051393088,
-0.0450504832,
-0.0079189679,
0.0299397353,
0.0399907045,
0.0187542755,
0.0613187514,
0.0299432352,
0.0250708647,
-0.0326136686,
-0.044292707,
0.0212702136,
-0.0390430614,
-0.0690611824,
-0.0087974342,
-0.0082354899,
0.0010112529,
-0.0474637784,
-0.0259020403,
-0.0191571377,
0.0593055114,
-0.0049052425,
0.0242864415,
0.0254961681,
-0.003775991,
-0.0313818157,
-0.0000096444,
-0.0583820418,
-0.0239364561,
-0.0158608817,
-0.0175295807,
0.0886687487,
0.0202362817,
-0.0307273399,
0.037835069,
-0.0156263225,
-0.0740123019,
-0.045062881,
-0.0234904066,
0.0279200245,
0.0445811152,
0.0085074101,
-0.0433723032,
0.0298305247,
0.055477038,
0.000038691,
0.0344783738,
-0.0054180385,
0.0148407705,
-0.0254941061,
0.0220606774,
-0.0004511381,
0.050234776,
0.0139934327,
0.0208099019,
-0.0781425536,
-0.0546635538,
0.0174661689,
0.0368677564,
0.0234289076,
-0.0378344432,
0.0111675905,
-0.0441824608,
-0.0397612974,
-0.0297938772,
-0.0272572935,
-0.0113885468,
0.0252520125,
-0.0072449776,
0.0005930178,
-0.0159591679,
-0.0341930017,
-0.0536825247,
0.1331382096,
-0.0199372694,
0.018912809,
0.0377861559,
-0.0099132592,
-0.0340690427,
-0.0141619314,
0.010254655,
0.04162056,
0.0451521687,
0.0780194104,
0.0173146166,
-0.0203579832,
0.0028336882,
0.0305805691,
0.0238842443,
-0.0543914326,
-0.0691156238,
0.0106991706,
-0.0406329297,
0.0240518954,
0.049708005,
0.002310419,
0.057227388,
0.00265005,
-0.0000279909,
0.003602478,
0.0316941254,
-0.0155188087,
-0.0225020181,
0.0430996493,
0.0028177025,
-0.0490540043,
0.0204129703,
0.0442464836,
0.0122379772,
0.0251317155,
0.0141835632,
-0.0140927853,
-0.0668947101,
-0.12156827,
-0.0332631692,
-0.0449017547,
0.0031776293,
-0.0050706617,
-0.047961887,
-0.0017904182,
0.0344439819,
-0.0231307205,
0.0272627268,
-0.0066102953,
0.0001786311,
0.0390353277,
0.0358574465,
0.0238302164,
-0.0527063273,
-0.0083797304,
-0.0389385223,
-0.0463144518,
0.0023103473,
-5.604502497e-33,
-0.0754584968,
-0.063203007,
0.0424119048,
0.0336839929,
-0.0285177026,
0.0243623741,
-0.031754382,
0.0130693624,
0.0023044634,
0.0089068199,
-0.0067398176,
-0.0220286753,
0.0263107028,
-0.0053646355,
-0.0140355155,
-0.0231494773,
0.0225476846,
0.0152677242,
-0.0305923317,
0.0211992152,
0.0738101974,
0.0076315505,
0.059823297,
-0.0983873829,
0.0184462052,
0.0278221071,
-0.0253687408,
0.0013598861,
0.0320732035,
0.029863691,
0.0043877061,
0.0203247759,
0.0103103016,
-0.0072862352,
0.0149721131,
0.0546232797,
-0.0684889778,
-0.03181554,
0.0363191552,
0.006721531,
0.0112952711,
-0.0497678518,
0.0388310328,
-0.026484048,
-0.0422546975,
0.0271276645,
0.0452011861,
-0.0042854231,
-0.0123537155,
-0.0543523766,
-0.0322713479,
0.0475385822,
-0.0124214962,
0.0564481765,
-0.0253616069,
0.0276923701,
0.0074850055,
0.0100369724,
-0.0798573792,
0.0108732833,
-0.0485221967,
0.0189262796,
0.0219284501,
-0.0023450409,
-0.0225060843,
0.0577078275,
0.0185558517,
0.0257085245,
-0.0568867289,
0.0029413267,
-0.0222483687,
0.026591992,
0.0242296364,
0.0914526731,
-0.0303005204,
-0.0165753756,
-0.0969536006,
0.0030659176,
0.0461020134,
0.0006639443,
0.0103385961,
-0.0436761826,
0.0359069668,
-0.0129025849,
-0.0645679384,
-0.0806619003,
0.0073495996,
-0.0358837284,
-0.0071350117,
0.0043588364,
-0.0299338922,
0.0361503325,
0.0439689048,
-0.066433318,
0.003878494,
-0.0148993414,
-0.0148778362,
0.0339003392,
-0.0093006846,
-0.0028626297,
-0.0573174395,
-0.0571335219,
0.0001377879,
0.0217765328,
0.033578679,
-0.0216431879,
-0.003678438,
-0.0433580428,
-0.0393789411,
-0.0013458624,
-0.0246776715,
0.0265475735,
-0.0588357374,
0.0457211025,
0.0074876873,
0.0090886876,
0.0033386524,
-0.0116418535,
0.0124770077,
-0.0059694988,
0.0311254673,
0.0164832622,
-0.0120337652,
0.0280807987,
-0.0426777452,
0.0045780414,
0.0098587843,
0.0750709847,
0.0277046096,
-0.0227130856,
0.0182794221,
-0.0494526066,
2.293e-7,
0.0320796184,
0.0298891813,
0.0273341369,
-0.0085837357,
0.0056720916,
-0.0100594256,
0.0495263487,
0.0357460007,
-0.0068295947,
-0.1124434546,
0.0053679636,
-0.0063885525,
0.0244554132,
0.04630946,
-0.1215000972,
-0.0441174917,
-0.0641556233,
0.008500359,
-0.0338527746,
0.0122047644,
0.0004118377,
0.036984209,
0.0242364164,
-0.0054945261,
-0.0473240986,
-0.0426845327,
0.0767972171,
-0.0125227636,
-0.0465508737,
0.0520999692,
0.0508067757,
-0.0370976664,
0.0125702433,
0.04225339,
0.0091462601,
0.0454801247,
-0.0473286919,
0.0551556982,
0.0450874493,
-0.0566493273,
-0.0371768773,
-0.0219778065,
0.0292974841,
0.020896947,
0.0092691267,
-0.0267026462,
-0.0271366406,
-0.0356355421,
-0.0554818064,
-0.0225417893,
0.0074690701,
0.0220221672,
0.0201807301,
0.0327757746,
-0.0251400564,
-0.011531055,
0.0003571566,
-0.076606378,
-0.0082474016,
-0.0274549853,
-0.0441032685,
-0.0443561934,
0.0458616018,
-0.029667234,
0.0086104954,
-0.0142939202,
0.0024691655,
1.598060808e-34,
0.0180774294,
0.0329337977,
-0.0354735553,
0.0216087904,
0.0355854072,
0.0403468646,
-0.0361971743,
0.0101912804,
0.0107567841,
-0.0176796578,
0.0166617092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01775v1 | Design and consensus content validity of the questionnaire for b-learning education: A 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic Delphi based Decision Support Tool | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | Rosana Montes, Cristina Zuheros, Jeovani M. Morales, Noe Zermeño, Jerónimo Duran, Francsico Herrera | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | Classic Delphi and Fuzzy Delphi methods are used to test content validity of
data collection tools such as questionnaires. Fuzzy Delphi takes the opinion
issued by judges from a linguistic perspective reducing ambiguity in opinions
by using fuzzy numbers. We propose an extension named 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic
Delphi method to deal with scenarios in which judges show different expertise
degrees by using fuzzy multigranular semantics of the linguistic terms and to
obtain intermediate and final results expressed by 2-tuple linguistic values.
The key idea of our proposal is to validate the full questionnaire by means of
the evaluation of its parts, defining the validity of each item as a Decision
Making problem. Taking the opinion of experts, we measure the degree of
consensus, the degree of consistency, and the linguistic score of each item, in
order to detect those items that affect, positively or negatively, the quality
of the instrument. Considering the real need to evaluate a b-learning
educational experience with a consensual questionnaire, we present a Decision
Making model for questionnaire validation that solves it. Additionally, we
contribute to this consensus reaching problem by developing an online tool
under GPL v3 license. The software visualizes the collective valuations for
each iteration and assists to determine which parts of the questionnaire should
be modified to reach a consensual solution. | [
-0.0029627401,
-0.0162654258,
-0.0380920917,
0.0016352352,
-0.0580737442,
-0.0105006015,
0.0215089228,
-0.0421931855,
-0.0020778449,
-0.0246679429,
0.0067910245,
0.0312591605,
0.0010429817,
0.0007610407,
-0.0474644452,
-0.019475989,
0.0275287684,
0.0193700604,
0.0636341721,
0.0135734547,
0.0113675138,
-0.0246900376,
-0.0417120084,
-0.0040139169,
0.0079449629,
0.019584205,
-0.0106412219,
-0.0499817617,
0.0558751039,
-0.0372598432,
0.0373545289,
0.0330552384,
-0.0248139743,
-0.0158804432,
0.0000025459,
-0.0497562103,
-0.0508802496,
0.0139008816,
0.0238618907,
-0.0337254182,
0.0827600285,
0.1293381155,
0.0000445011,
-0.006588365,
-0.0435944423,
0.0738087818,
-0.002118319,
0.0088069281,
0.0645106509,
-0.0139464792,
0.0051720226,
-0.0943685472,
-0.0428494178,
0.0399119183,
-0.0086809509,
0.039160423,
-0.0214877408,
0.0373984091,
0.0691457838,
0.0037176562,
-0.0009154213,
0.0026520663,
-0.0011266354,
0.0093956171,
-0.0390195549,
-0.0043227565,
0.0464750044,
-0.036403738,
0.0482696481,
0.0181769822,
0.0397898778,
0.0489228219,
-0.0146390973,
-0.0062260148,
0.0647660419,
-0.0052357544,
0.0002255344,
0.0139214555,
-0.0150324088,
-0.0139246192,
0.0099625243,
0.0295807682,
-0.0584071688,
0.0106829656,
-0.0351876169,
0.0766478926,
-0.0251204744,
-0.0209902786,
0.0022236893,
0.0199083891,
0.0212931111,
-0.0028345252,
0.0076199598,
0.0421152599,
-0.0450591408,
0.0053482559,
0.0252719764,
0.004168388,
0.0429293253,
-0.0351404324,
-0.006901748,
0.0188231897,
0.0039025694,
-0.0144178616,
0.0238446519,
0.0097429799,
0.0475191958,
0.0343473405,
-0.0395121612,
0.0285682213,
-0.0503408238,
0.0317797661,
-0.0072371494,
0.030355351,
0.0219329614,
0.0214861147,
-0.0657573342,
0.0125223435,
-0.0670254678,
0.0424471758,
-0.0119769443,
-0.0013394876,
0.0700519159,
0.0673179552,
-0.0646703094,
0.0151362149,
-0.0305656437,
0.0359824151,
0.0060789459,
0.0252457075,
0.0916940719,
-0.0159463529,
-0.0149050048,
-0.0361333936,
0.0345944576,
-0.0088953376,
-0.0133110592,
0.0200973917,
-0.0645269081,
-0.0110029792,
-0.0090955701,
-0.0395245254,
-0.0233231969,
-0.0668902025,
-0.0171098113,
-0.0388645194,
-0.029428741,
0.0037856679,
0.0262738727,
0.0344685689,
-0.0072933603,
0.0335326791,
-0.0124116186,
-0.0560718924,
0.0183163881,
0.0197236501,
0.0104573835,
0.0044558779,
0.0247186869,
-0.0122027295,
-0.0073697437,
-0.0273117535,
0.0176416412,
-0.0331290886,
0.0265112687,
-0.0272313412,
-0.0255236812,
0.0195783824,
-0.0566331595,
0.0090283733,
-0.070568949,
0.0484736301,
-0.0239469111,
0.0361043029,
0.0361613296,
-0.0152349323,
0.0409656316,
-0.0197934099,
-0.0422802754,
0.0454782806,
0.0150179081,
0.0140835717,
0.0064769033,
0.0302126668,
0.0036531086,
0.0288715195,
0.0164526254,
0.0268912315,
0.0129915476,
-0.0847522542,
0.0083793961,
0.0077007012,
0.1008705348,
0.0148079833,
0.0012106654,
-0.0656559616,
-0.0032142946,
-0.017108595,
-0.0083763124,
-0.044382304,
-0.0164253991,
-0.0440580212,
0.0729504153,
0.0285863578,
0.006007514,
-0.044975061,
-0.0580602325,
-0.0093357144,
-0.0339669846,
-0.0120948916,
0.0023782034,
-0.0106643103,
-0.044050172,
-0.0366858952,
-0.0190669112,
0.0216442402,
-0.0197490398,
0.0356094539,
-0.0496743694,
0.0622964613,
-0.0267385393,
0.03796909,
-0.0184389967,
-0.007640982,
0.0501157604,
0.0109284958,
-0.0218640789,
0.0292623229,
0.0538398437,
0.0391536728,
-0.0113224499,
0.0164509788,
-0.0009330473,
0.0432523116,
-0.0238287356,
-0.0661650375,
0.0143783716,
-0.0040971856,
0.0630503669,
-0.0577651672,
0.0149462475,
-0.0158001669,
-0.0168344248,
-0.0204526708,
0.0414306149,
-0.0237368308,
-0.0858804211,
-0.0095458496,
0.0266230274,
-0.0572943687,
-0.029242238,
-0.0564616062,
0.0175333992,
0.0337731205,
0.0243237969,
-0.0604130141,
-0.040792495,
0.0658385977,
-0.0353332497,
-0.0524952859,
0.0506241694,
-0.014938985,
0.0652720928,
0.0195775032,
0.0279475506,
-0.0522457585,
-0.0155639006,
-0.0485621355,
-0.0119849518,
0.03694297,
-0.0038986127,
-0.0132865254,
-0.0736507177,
0.0000157713,
0.0171307512,
-0.0596498884,
-0.0146737797,
0.0273285545,
-0.0197635274,
0.0188877266,
0.0075368951,
0.0067210859,
-0.0167161431,
-0.0253614858,
-0.0216127187,
-0.0220987182,
0.0657750666,
-0.0130976476,
0.0115015535,
-0.0389872156,
-0.1047994122,
-0.0170614421,
0.0535719059,
-0.0189283751,
0.029021753,
0.0454172641,
-0.0566290133,
0.0127396602,
0.037939325,
-0.0300516505,
0.0653551668,
-0.0555581227,
-0.0418465212,
-0.0065383189,
-0.0173805635,
0.0220944304,
0.0335487165,
-0.0461155213,
0.0052702446,
-0.0163924899,
0.0068529313,
-0.0285306145,
0.0182068143,
0.0614164062,
-0.0276788622,
0.0318891406,
-0.0315560512,
-0.0293698777,
0.0012471377,
0.0634756759,
0.0313527323,
-0.0265068524,
0.0607449859,
0.0031015046,
0.0403650589,
-0.122065194,
-0.0031416782,
-0.0093466435,
-0.0283902455,
-0.0454072244,
0.0173476469,
0.0115760034,
-0.0096252691,
-0.0271464717,
-0.0014818761,
0.0534743182,
-0.0442214981,
0.0080377841,
-0.0286992006,
-0.0236191507,
0.0055183046,
0.0277320296,
-0.0026948161,
0.0558985025,
0.0199233703,
0.0124325231,
0.0365107059,
0.0460848324,
-0.0220220145,
-0.029487161,
0.0649687126,
-0.0138889607,
-0.0010106838,
0.0101473201,
0.0031211812,
-0.0093637379,
-0.0152710686,
-0.0110925427,
0.0815211385,
-0.0235247966,
-0.0053173485,
0.0330869257,
-0.0321349166,
-0.0090903379,
0.0072048269,
-0.0108342925,
0.0091077229,
-0.0250356104,
-0.0156122586,
0.0136641841,
-0.0366887748,
-0.0218778122,
0.0153972488,
0.0574129075,
0.0268079005,
-0.0140384706,
-0.0044493242,
-0.0395031013,
-0.0648181066,
-0.0084015736,
0.0208042413,
-0.0878767967,
0.0137422765,
-0.0353789255,
0.0389555022,
-0.0666728392,
-0.0046973182,
0.0014552707,
-0.0307817589,
0.0154816117,
-0.0084244441,
0.0270633604,
0.0300236382,
0.052652359,
0.0035643906,
0.0013730699,
-0.0138796447,
-0.0186114311,
0.0616351888,
0.0261889137,
0.01407173,
0.0060086236,
-0.0142875109,
0.0173155461,
-0.0252270885,
-0.0223991219,
-0.0137877949,
0.0366520844,
-0.0243687686,
-0.0967590213,
0.0186963081,
-0.0342025012,
-0.0493873619,
0.0009256185,
-0.0036023466,
0.001534613,
0.0009140446,
-0.042836763,
-0.0071089044,
0.0405024849,
0.0112649547,
0.0103466734,
0.0439166278,
-0.0083256029,
-0.0144983279,
-0.0351293348,
0.0447072722,
-0.0131999813,
0.0042504328,
-0.0138431285,
-0.0577002056,
0.0312623829,
0.0187181942,
-0.0407628864,
0.0707513243,
-0.0242890511,
0.0072569842,
-0.0472143665,
0.0292157345,
-0.0504377112,
-0.0187924616,
0.054529056,
0.0501667634,
-0.0438239276,
-0.0347138382,
0.0401450843,
0.0013927579,
-0.0087630358,
0.0003029911,
0.0587208718,
0.0441661626,
-0.138838619,
0.0246511139,
-0.0165655129,
0.0440050513,
-0.0575044341,
-0.0147926388,
0.0836043134,
-0.0436674766,
0.0446820892,
0.0418562517,
0.0161368735,
-0.046863813,
-0.01198385,
0.013438643,
0.0481239073,
0.0048629106,
-0.001629401,
-0.0097955391,
0.016759051,
0.0464387871,
-0.0000127804,
-0.0275284685,
0.0285734981,
0.0122601809,
-0.0060930373,
-0.0184796788,
-0.032297954,
0.0065317154,
0.0006807197,
0.0518544391,
0.0163709819,
0.0141081074,
0.0471611544,
-0.019308269,
-0.0048135682,
-0.0079716593,
-0.0445979051,
-0.0311259329,
-0.0289354045,
0.0134470202,
-0.0114717316,
0.0224651396,
-0.0340457447,
0.0134430947,
-0.0089133624,
0.0412248485,
0.0568411127,
0.0002391767,
0.017451115,
-0.019980792,
-0.020426983,
-0.0278774258,
-0.0552091375,
0.0079061426,
0.0405849293,
0.028870238,
0.0928213373,
0.0098383436,
-0.0212948062,
-0.0078840619,
0.0513590872,
0.0699724108,
-0.0097711831,
-0.027404258,
-0.0034322452,
-0.0471655875,
0.064312309,
-0.035353329,
0.0098249912,
0.0096735684,
-0.0315881446,
-0.0262039565,
-0.0116476296,
-0.0208781064,
0.0233394019,
0.0004474493,
0.0023511329,
-0.049032677,
-0.0273749009,
-0.0762143061,
-0.0882605016,
-0.076976262,
-0.0206104349,
-0.0275584944,
0.0129042808,
-0.0046862722,
0.0385751687,
-0.0393837206,
-0.0027879688,
-0.0612241738,
-0.0056771017,
-0.0057048267,
0.0595544428,
0.0454788692,
-0.0244612303,
0.040043097,
0.0071725664,
0.0174070243,
0.0252132434,
-0.0084580481,
-0.0454720408,
-0.0058863605,
0.0301611815,
0.0256027207,
-6.346394818e-33,
-0.0459235273,
-0.0270773955,
0.0430068001,
-0.0133605525,
0.0269129705,
-0.0468151495,
0.0346897356,
0.049489174,
-0.0162013173,
-0.0061514769,
0.0373415202,
-0.036002215,
-0.0059281518,
0.008855883,
0.0358785316,
-0.020175498,
-0.0087504415,
0.0177151561,
-0.0454873405,
-0.037181586,
0.0138849886,
-0.0477822982,
0.0668016598,
-0.0538791642,
0.0869473368,
0.0462305434,
-0.0270765945,
0.0023364192,
-0.0305353552,
0.0109327063,
0.0372018293,
-0.009420285,
0.0102174822,
-0.0655918941,
-0.0071445215,
0.0067482395,
-0.0239534136,
-0.0780169442,
-0.0152850263,
0.0345959477,
-0.008568082,
0.0177310668,
-0.0102260839,
-0.0024674863,
-0.0354036093,
-0.0025847468,
0.0218380466,
-0.0178352259,
0.0226988588,
0.0119910669,
-0.0334756896,
0.0215159561,
-0.017368149,
0.0036741854,
-0.0027976902,
0.0708930045,
-0.0628125072,
-0.0203727838,
-0.0553576201,
0.0396141559,
0.0457521416,
-0.0467456579,
0.0316894054,
-0.075355351,
-0.0107060038,
0.0066469293,
0.0261255596,
-0.0293728765,
-0.0280601326,
-0.0052599483,
0.0302910022,
0.0418264642,
0.0996902883,
0.0318821333,
0.005808061,
0.0068946318,
-0.0145989181,
0.0398299694,
0.0362659097,
0.0370705724,
-0.036668025,
-0.031675186,
-0.0308380313,
-0.045995459,
-0.0381940864,
-0.0197884738,
-0.0118957162,
-0.0076123853,
0.0440839678,
-0.0434786379,
-0.036037039,
-0.0001657813,
0.0124671813,
0.0106138028,
-0.0166816954,
-0.0385847911,
0.002589074,
0.0541108549,
0.0229286142,
-0.0097489236,
-0.0318453722,
0.0414583161,
-0.0320094004,
-0.0226511322,
0.0064823669,
0.0549261272,
-0.0274625923,
-0.0439159721,
-0.0284471679,
0.0086689219,
0.0096350517,
-0.0266136657,
0.0096966662,
-0.0262494069,
0.0162227191,
-0.0145878792,
0.0121918274,
0.0237884857,
0.0124652591,
0.0239086747,
-0.0312271584,
0.0137095908,
-0.0205891524,
0.0115285739,
0.0198113304,
-0.0359401666,
-0.0226225834,
-0.0304237194,
-0.0068896315,
0.0214398801,
0.0192308184,
-0.0076480992,
3.299e-7,
-0.009110339,
0.074830547,
-0.0830745548,
-0.00552803,
-0.0270335693,
0.0434651226,
0.0070659607,
-0.0148140481,
0.0403348207,
0.0438865535,
0.0617303662,
-0.0556099489,
-0.0261595398,
0.0941652581,
-0.0016145488,
-0.0859442279,
0.0296440832,
-0.0082427198,
-0.0237870403,
0.0602900088,
0.0998161733,
-0.001225672,
0.0335041471,
0.0073363492,
0.0033305855,
-0.0418512933,
-0.0073987534,
0.0065363548,
0.0289336536,
0.0268883985,
0.0926055759,
-0.0330768637,
0.036443267,
0.0573932976,
0.0477075279,
0.0196952019,
0.0365957022,
-0.0055550793,
0.0222072974,
0.0138981212,
0.0369486064,
-0.0193784125,
0.0168502647,
-0.0671106577,
0.0237349644,
-0.0732359141,
-0.0155752487,
0.0041256407,
-0.084069781,
-0.0431689657,
0.0525888912,
0.0091833258,
-0.044018019,
0.0004178089,
-0.0113373846,
-0.0003741688,
0.0157309286,
0.0198211409,
0.0357432067,
-0.0020456049,
0.0184823517,
-0.0711671636,
0.0053661442,
0.0255367607,
0.005441186,
-0.0474689528,
0.0158154406,
2.492375647e-34,
0.0229509734,
-0.0242961291,
0.0197272375,
-0.0207987241,
0.0235128384,
0.0477097854,
0.0039726691,
-0.0337793902,
0.0048805759,
0.0014628621,
-0.0012647473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03471v1 | The Information of Large Language Model Geometry | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | Zhiquan Tan, Chenghai Li, Weiran Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | This paper investigates the information encoded in the embeddings of large
language models (LLMs). We conduct simulations to analyze the representation
entropy and discover a power law relationship with model sizes. Building upon
this observation, we propose a theory based on (conditional) entropy to
elucidate the scaling law phenomenon. Furthermore, we delve into the
auto-regressive structure of LLMs and examine the relationship between the last
token and previous context tokens using information theory and regression
techniques. Specifically, we establish a theoretical connection between the
information gain of new tokens and ridge regression. Additionally, we explore
the effectiveness of Lasso regression in selecting meaningful tokens, which
sometimes outperforms the closely related attention weights. Finally, we
conduct controlled experiments, and find that information is distributed across
tokens, rather than being concentrated in specific "meaningful" tokens alone. | [
0.0038563623,
0.0276550949,
-0.0319849923,
0.0444302708,
-0.031484358,
0.0169848837,
-0.0027604122,
0.0453017429,
-0.0309073329,
-0.034005221,
-0.0088907452,
-0.0501148738,
0.019627437,
-0.0129076391,
0.071343556,
-0.058974985,
0.0029072443,
-0.0764409676,
0.0181751978,
-0.0278157666,
-0.0139240241,
-0.0256503932,
0.0597405992,
0.0502043255,
-0.0253622495,
0.0221105199,
0.0072552203,
-0.0060362746,
-0.0256555453,
-0.0240044333,
-0.059326537,
0.0299855843,
0.030721439,
0.0370090716,
0.0000018978,
-0.0414976701,
0.0024792801,
0.0149360597,
-0.0198877398,
0.0629134402,
0.0033404839,
-0.0624393225,
0.0008740869,
-0.0251210835,
0.0286623146,
-0.0058496641,
0.0495282598,
0.0190867949,
-0.0160235297,
0.0390443951,
-0.0063852821,
-0.0403032266,
0.0618609935,
-0.045439072,
0.0419525243,
-0.0325392,
0.0418149233,
0.0040178071,
-0.0220722612,
0.0298774764,
-0.0499352328,
0.0521819256,
0.0060406234,
0.0094458442,
0.0386305898,
0.0493260249,
0.0045008245,
0.0089180721,
0.0163225308,
0.050928738,
-0.018103512,
-0.0203717034,
-0.0213413052,
0.0003675936,
0.0192335006,
0.0113627715,
-0.0654157326,
0.019384414,
0.0351060927,
0.02689155,
0.0386355221,
-0.0090095587,
0.0566575937,
-0.0241635498,
-0.0707305968,
0.0434950739,
0.0245485455,
-0.0627754703,
-0.0433508568,
-0.0371996015,
-0.0652480945,
-0.0345951691,
-0.0490672402,
0.0161742233,
0.0240163095,
0.0264168195,
-0.0147576258,
-0.0382623747,
0.0101074539,
-0.055479262,
0.0285213254,
-0.0043369634,
0.0296178218,
0.0385311544,
-0.0171827544,
0.076507546,
-0.0264054313,
0.0491256677,
-0.0325725675,
0.000858743,
-0.019190006,
-0.0386350639,
-0.0389356688,
0.0427026264,
0.0076642474,
-0.0302916598,
-0.0039225724,
0.0348027758,
0.0067048487,
-0.0100200996,
-0.030634433,
-0.012625142,
-0.0022179524,
0.0090790354,
-0.0069105197,
-0.000683951,
-0.0084481239,
-0.0047237668,
-0.0360218436,
-0.0127406707,
-0.0018879578,
0.0103281066,
-0.0027709948,
-0.0009427435,
-0.0253589656,
0.0689534247,
0.0473650843,
-0.0333123095,
-0.0363436192,
-0.0185453724,
-0.0394579321,
-0.052928634,
-0.0098827733,
-0.063661702,
0.0101494994,
0.0375325605,
-0.0062494627,
-0.0408259295,
-0.0117184659,
-0.0136959795,
-0.0731521174,
0.060095761,
0.0012036517,
0.0135399299,
0.0088049835,
-0.0202317648,
0.0428136028,
0.086081177,
0.0484832376,
0.0409473218,
0.0392997079,
-0.0302057546,
-0.0414477102,
0.0303923432,
0.0325105526,
0.0568963736,
-0.0648273975,
-0.0031232203,
0.0497465581,
0.0492617339,
0.0088380184,
0.073506102,
-0.0194802694,
-0.033995308,
0.0410373136,
0.1117074415,
0.0334366634,
0.0428524055,
0.0218612161,
0.001038366,
0.003728651,
0.0408036187,
-0.0287580676,
-0.0103003634,
-0.0135179805,
0.0313275866,
0.0756250843,
0.0030980988,
-0.0346653946,
-0.0269022863,
-0.04999616,
0.0054879379,
-0.0294285212,
-0.0185085014,
0.0691420883,
-0.0504546613,
-0.0118741449,
0.0677268803,
0.0414459035,
-0.0242847502,
-0.0230717584,
-0.0072328318,
0.0244280118,
0.0161182396,
0.0158703998,
-0.0327290893,
0.0246548876,
-0.0053699957,
0.0182554685,
-0.0030179524,
0.0136827519,
0.0104173655,
-0.0239177663,
-0.0297682323,
0.0188273787,
0.0131982965,
0.0120749976,
0.0344751738,
-0.0524815693,
0.005106017,
-0.0078321109,
-0.0074923718,
-0.0344787911,
0.027711954,
-0.0311011933,
-0.0329089388,
-0.0257001389,
-0.0031905936,
0.0503366366,
-0.0145656094,
-0.028578002,
0.0257768352,
0.0325390883,
-0.0637427419,
0.0212877337,
-0.0040818551,
-0.0411347747,
0.0024670581,
0.0334135331,
0.0022868286,
0.0402240343,
-0.0283506382,
0.0239596926,
-0.0219533909,
0.0548787229,
-0.0431027487,
0.1149467379,
-0.0303142983,
0.025829507,
-0.0450135879,
0.0219263826,
-0.0638396591,
0.0509296805,
-0.035922166,
0.0533377007,
0.0331260264,
-0.0487740338,
0.0358744264,
-0.0095198248,
-0.011785361,
0.0231481325,
0.0044576428,
0.0131677967,
0.0143565582,
-0.049532596,
0.0496598147,
-0.0439645573,
-0.0281765778,
-0.0281903278,
-0.0280420817,
-0.0126125207,
0.0129240714,
-0.0000480189,
-0.0017152688,
0.0117446398,
-0.0074243909,
0.0004352147,
-0.0283085089,
0.0193344839,
0.0241387896,
0.0017516054,
-0.0268354602,
-0.0431986712,
-0.0561824329,
-0.0267118756,
0.0797977373,
0.0187963583,
-0.0094620707,
-0.0692860186,
0.0739217326,
-0.0065482804,
0.0208235383,
-0.0271509737,
-0.0456776433,
0.0017663048,
-0.0504916236,
0.0531221069,
0.0463914461,
0.0083133839,
0.0534328893,
0.0804506242,
0.0188478511,
-0.0262427405,
-0.0225786865,
-0.0444119871,
0.0202539153,
-0.0795584247,
-0.0648903921,
0.0246006101,
0.0578239188,
0.0203524493,
-0.0191489365,
-0.0559071004,
-0.0059099309,
-0.0531188175,
-0.0101940744,
-0.050995294,
0.0114052966,
-0.0287991781,
0.0570744462,
-0.0100596501,
-0.0765023753,
0.035556186,
-0.0453819409,
0.0176629163,
0.0053026816,
-0.0022312924,
-0.0666759908,
0.0596516132,
0.0441492461,
0.0222486481,
0.0267654397,
-0.0401439443,
-0.0114224134,
-0.0324174315,
-0.0109578911,
-0.0059142984,
0.0559981279,
0.0095039103,
0.0006910702,
0.0006872659,
-0.0124892397,
-0.0021100568,
-0.0660719946,
-0.0095419567,
0.0037315839,
0.1050934196,
-0.0538811348,
-0.0064898892,
0.0427745618,
0.0387665369,
-0.0123840198,
-0.0207683612,
-0.0060416744,
-0.0156539362,
0.0228035655,
0.042546507,
-0.0029663933,
0.0547696054,
-0.0511378981,
0.0182147287,
0.0116166035,
0.0254098326,
0.0514762923,
-0.0269100219,
-0.0120816333,
0.0429590233,
-0.0093445256,
-0.0360543765,
0.0199510176,
0.0513133742,
-0.0236719828,
0.016496975,
0.1334038824,
0.0177145172,
-0.0610776804,
0.0364234969,
-0.0176646896,
0.0689612553,
0.0311139617,
-0.000677018,
-0.0343901441,
0.0123306634,
0.0119791562,
-0.0072576045,
0.0181475002,
-0.0200238992,
0.0233467352,
-0.0793877766,
0.0130038923,
0.022171719,
-0.0142062455,
-0.0326500796,
-0.0342208855,
0.0062662065,
0.0033732697,
0.0069396375,
-0.0024575063,
-0.0532851033,
-0.0114664473,
0.015360334,
-0.0363010727,
-0.0086916275,
0.0095397457,
-0.033758536,
0.0358088985,
0.0107949115,
0.0675576627,
-0.0444807298,
-0.0753753409,
0.0073175216,
0.0374168195,
-0.003716494,
-0.0059887767,
0.0472512767,
0.0344905667,
-0.0165853314,
-0.0128840907,
0.0053346553,
-0.0004613183,
0.0147711001,
-0.0457112379,
0.0787926689,
-0.0018303994,
-0.0220208354,
-0.0089670103,
-0.0465899743,
-0.0318510868,
0.0842969939,
0.0667045787,
-0.0199879594,
-0.0321528949,
-0.0287520979,
0.0209588371,
0.0251927748,
-0.050750941,
-0.0009010193,
0.0271648541,
-0.0304139741,
-0.0304104388,
0.0261115041,
0.0204669144,
0.0417783186,
0.0228917208,
0.020158587,
-0.0004848741,
-0.035336446,
0.0100515643,
0.0061337678,
-0.0138379494,
-0.0092807701,
-0.0675271004,
0.0045990665,
-0.0009208017,
-0.0147035467,
-0.0274095573,
-0.0425741747,
-0.0596299469,
-0.0755243823,
-0.0158194248,
0.0042491364,
0.0165337604,
0.0309642684,
-0.0046215514,
-0.0646552891,
0.0507095382,
0.0044595767,
-0.0296735968,
0.0311178956,
0.0030836791,
-0.0174633097,
0.0225114152,
0.0624931827,
-0.024318004,
-0.0212634318,
0.007945043,
-0.0067580575,
-0.0000307585,
-0.0627709478,
0.0048073465,
0.0271316953,
0.0209226888,
-0.0192417409,
-0.0419287458,
0.0023410586,
-0.0038988187,
-0.0157333538,
0.0275576282,
-0.0206268523,
-0.0054326435,
0.0288883019,
-0.0153383408,
-0.0054894323,
-0.0149348872,
0.0132013438,
0.0164296813,
-0.0415955409,
0.0204983987,
-0.0279806331,
0.0118444087,
0.0592550002,
0.0260533728,
0.0006637396,
-0.006605288,
-0.0467654876,
0.0140017765,
-0.0090167029,
-0.0077744522,
0.0078032101,
0.0150844203,
-0.0487438105,
0.0167580508,
-0.0898554176,
-0.0614508875,
0.0097296666,
0.0047214855,
0.0497923642,
-0.0181273762,
0.0383526459,
-0.0355832539,
-0.0036942477,
-0.030209126,
0.0163225885,
-0.017809134,
-0.0118211238,
0.0409392007,
0.0216153916,
-0.0378641151,
0.0249073748,
0.0806896836,
0.063146621,
0.0183740072,
0.0076668239,
-0.0075233276,
-0.0064336299,
0.0336053595,
0.0227031335,
0.053208001,
-0.0437174849,
0.0186014269,
-0.0721501783,
-0.0699666589,
-0.0070620291,
-0.0209563375,
-0.0171167534,
0.0071042851,
0.0066061341,
0.0464099981,
-0.0012964545,
-0.0074748527,
-0.0248192456,
0.0123829236,
-0.0038393424,
-0.0372926556,
0.0180923529,
-6.435403985e-33,
-0.0116580762,
0.0033700515,
-0.0276935864,
0.0249076486,
0.0085378224,
-0.0010814926,
-0.01182965,
0.0168787781,
-0.0222252775,
0.0283085536,
-0.0081275702,
-0.0336385183,
-0.0108806919,
0.02496472,
0.0290277265,
0.0025501871,
0.02105226,
0.0071099582,
0.0343682058,
0.0393076465,
0.0400484875,
0.0134982252,
0.052733086,
-0.0581980497,
0.0259193908,
-0.0028532867,
0.0371236578,
0.015008891,
0.0235630553,
0.0497793555,
-0.0503363423,
0.0381888412,
0.0250610113,
-0.0609211028,
-0.0382163823,
-0.0014581704,
-0.0369438939,
-0.0272114184,
0.0352127329,
-0.0168047808,
-0.0095951539,
-0.0698223487,
0.0455942154,
-0.0107376706,
0.0017093325,
-0.0345666446,
0.0520768687,
0.0105525935,
-0.0681150705,
0.0054270173,
-0.0705366731,
0.0160295293,
-0.0241995212,
-0.0007195111,
0.0529107451,
-0.0150399208,
-0.0054384298,
0.0195015445,
-0.0063481722,
0.0126970988,
0.0312015563,
0.0751062334,
0.0056858207,
0.0378230438,
0.0286491998,
0.068393223,
0.0267972592,
-0.0185045246,
-0.0461093225,
-0.0021924484,
0.0632611364,
0.0305353422,
0.0376831628,
-0.0330982506,
0.0327538997,
-0.0368202738,
-0.0819412172,
-0.0444037057,
-0.0148426192,
0.0497506,
0.035963133,
0.0131492475,
-0.0607396998,
-0.0432575382,
-0.0391673632,
-0.0450187884,
-0.0122946575,
-0.0256401971,
0.0078573376,
-0.0161730442,
0.0131028537,
0.0045497441,
0.0440291725,
-0.0636763275,
-0.0569433384,
0.0493074618,
0.0110997912,
0.0436333157,
0.0095323743,
0.0189576428,
-0.0688614994,
-0.0056509664,
-0.0405427702,
0.0015146623,
0.017900493,
0.0168939643,
0.027759321,
0.0167977847,
-0.0562691651,
-0.0423190035,
-0.0271880496,
-0.0672444701,
0.0114597399,
0.0030991877,
0.0503261164,
-0.0176412538,
0.0063069211,
0.0237545799,
0.0083920155,
0.0107814344,
-0.0109911896,
0.0165883359,
-0.0155914659,
0.0302491654,
-0.0320562497,
-0.0166338086,
-0.064484559,
0.0226119459,
0.0946880803,
-0.0170835778,
-0.0303826127,
-0.0069120056,
2.687e-7,
0.0208800267,
0.0636140183,
0.0246092305,
0.0186296683,
0.0283686966,
0.0228076614,
-0.0078853779,
0.0246158075,
-0.0140135512,
-0.0333957598,
-0.0039403792,
0.0142394984,
0.034242548,
0.007900591,
-0.1123679355,
-0.0096567012,
-0.057313621,
0.0013117534,
-0.0372750759,
0.0059040338,
0.0102419034,
0.1325645745,
0.0209890734,
0.0163896251,
-0.002760353,
-0.057165198,
0.0229697321,
-0.0579763688,
0.0215958245,
0.0313244797,
0.0150722452,
-0.0003976905,
-0.0002721042,
0.0027114886,
0.0103689814,
0.0245974325,
-0.0234289374,
0.0135382283,
-0.0174605325,
0.0210685041,
0.0098378109,
-0.0306821633,
-0.0228508897,
-0.0699382052,
0.0544767641,
0.0019205951,
-0.0518599153,
-0.0635016039,
0.0599211007,
0.005755499,
0.0289015453,
0.0036306572,
0.0248005018,
0.0146184256,
0.0189211946,
-0.0306437239,
0.0301498491,
-0.0652518868,
-0.0143002504,
0.0367366597,
-0.0713400394,
-0.0180724803,
-0.0434977114,
-0.011633452,
0.0569920428,
-0.0410900749,
0.0100309057,
2.830422567e-34,
0.0411365554,
-0.0077155167,
0.0223568007,
0.0569506027,
0.003711757,
-0.0382364392,
-0.0019365746,
0.002953016,
0.0205391385,
-0.1180148348,
-0.0090579242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00559v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00559v4 | A Chain-of-Thought Is as Strong as Its Weakest Link: A Benchmark for Verifiers of Reasoning Chains | 2024-02-01T12:46:45 | 2024-05-21T09:55:07 | Alon Jacovi, Yonatan Bitton, Bernd Bohnet, Jonathan Herzig, Or Honovich, Michael Tseng, Michael Collins, Roee Aharoni, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting language models to provide step-by-step answers (e.g.,
"Chain-of-Thought") is the prominent approach for complex reasoning tasks,
where more accurate reasoning chains typically improve downstream task
performance. Recent literature discusses automatic methods to verify reasoning
to evaluate and improve their correctness. However, no fine-grained step-level
datasets are available to enable thorough evaluation of such verification
methods, hindering progress in this direction. We introduce REVEAL: Reasoning
Verification Evaluation, a dataset to benchmark automatic verifiers of complex
Chain-of-Thought reasoning in open-domain question-answering settings. REVEAL
includes comprehensive labels for the relevance, attribution to evidence
passages, and logical correctness of each reasoning step in a language model's
answer, across a variety of datasets and state-of-the-art language models.
Evaluation on REVEAL shows that verifiers struggle at verifying reasoning
chains - in particular, verifying logical correctness and detecting
contradictions. Available at https://reveal-dataset.github.io/ . | [
0.0166854225,
0.0604818016,
0.0118153067,
0.0483136587,
-0.0528503992,
0.0174698588,
0.0066908794,
-0.0123314243,
0.0379237384,
-0.0195065122,
-0.0116974972,
0.0241113938,
0.0134665491,
0.032972306,
0.0060957335,
-0.0342870615,
0.0317554958,
-0.025864562,
0.0202962719,
-0.0057116384,
0.0062676268,
0.029802328,
-0.0230239816,
0.0325522572,
0.0080191502,
-0.0508995429,
-0.0054713758,
-0.007291534,
0.0496767685,
-0.0334077552,
0.0060108094,
0.0580534451,
0.0010610924,
0.0475234203,
0.0000019016,
-0.0376344584,
-0.0025282137,
0.0103984289,
-0.0777563304,
-0.012460608,
-0.0471187979,
0.0175592657,
0.0190036241,
0.0343564227,
-0.0351695456,
-0.0155552374,
0.0063807741,
0.0408348776,
0.076541096,
0.044596836,
0.0123988446,
-0.0148372492,
0.003265043,
-0.0048141708,
0.0002486921,
-0.0316971652,
0.0297667179,
0.0383179635,
0.0043756138,
0.0227904283,
0.0052840752,
0.0160814896,
0.031767372,
-0.0284209885,
-0.0574733876,
0.0210797824,
-0.0272853486,
-0.0149252564,
0.0135666626,
0.0831926763,
0.0283322129,
-0.0583507493,
-0.0385937728,
-0.0109989997,
-0.0160954781,
0.0329941399,
-0.0259993989,
0.0409604497,
-0.0435448922,
-0.0217366051,
0.0017178226,
-0.0000546165,
0.0214118417,
0.0127749993,
-0.0200352482,
0.1161594167,
-0.0188493915,
-0.0434732884,
0.042960532,
0.0067604897,
-0.0203387924,
-0.0934012458,
-0.0042486377,
0.0372299775,
-0.0260902531,
0.0439335704,
-0.0042246724,
-0.0111602172,
0.0293296147,
-0.0131710591,
0.0145706004,
0.0046310336,
-0.0178956967,
0.0561590306,
-0.0314667411,
0.0160792693,
-0.0351828374,
0.0324798077,
-0.0010235462,
-0.0270188358,
-0.0474180095,
0.0094994828,
-0.0133966599,
0.0357254259,
0.0030323395,
0.0407968462,
-0.0300866254,
-0.0059580808,
-0.0440409333,
0.0490175262,
-0.0074418033,
0.0030781582,
0.0480248369,
-0.0219274275,
-0.0614306368,
0.0329255611,
-0.0726772547,
0.0486913174,
0.0474975556,
-0.0394514054,
-0.0291124862,
-0.0080991192,
-0.0036897568,
-0.0138363261,
0.0417639576,
0.0041426448,
0.0112586683,
0.0322405435,
-0.0370911956,
-0.0489498116,
0.0107386829,
-0.0649061576,
-0.0146403993,
-0.0849764496,
0.0250055306,
0.0223004334,
-0.0165103432,
-0.0179186314,
-0.0030810814,
0.065246895,
-0.0094264401,
0.0623748079,
-0.0378061123,
-0.0183161926,
0.0060677128,
0.027041031,
-0.030269403,
0.0447100028,
0.0337475315,
0.0265181977,
0.0579694621,
0.0197303519,
0.0176425893,
0.0015929785,
0.0358298719,
-0.0066126357,
0.0255963188,
0.0796964988,
-0.0056485618,
0.0095597766,
-0.055022493,
0.0366806388,
-0.0298638977,
-0.0275453888,
0.015604944,
0.0415874682,
0.0210956708,
-0.0361915492,
0.0359830223,
-0.0383306853,
0.0360274389,
-0.004370831,
-0.0335063823,
0.0114589138,
-0.0311744753,
-0.0262851175,
-0.0125902975,
0.025160037,
-0.010880501,
-0.068343915,
-0.0221527833,
0.0225951634,
-0.0009080112,
0.0329019539,
0.0366324745,
0.0455047823,
-0.0180289075,
0.0513577685,
0.0428606905,
-0.0600172095,
-0.0291160215,
-0.0434476919,
0.0538035929,
-0.0012670731,
0.0557489321,
-0.0388032123,
-0.0084471181,
-0.0239636507,
0.0826812983,
0.0097934101,
0.0168105941,
-0.0247844122,
0.0167742353,
-0.018649701,
-0.0233527478,
-0.0279077999,
-0.0146885756,
-0.0185620189,
0.0594011173,
-0.001017315,
-0.0065470058,
-0.0394613929,
0.0133812549,
0.0300930589,
0.0000566698,
0.0188687369,
0.0108298929,
0.0113885393,
0.024283072,
0.0192318726,
0.0011375253,
0.0159184206,
0.0085726753,
0.0034557963,
-0.0312044639,
0.010475737,
-0.0173951387,
-0.0257354658,
0.0492733754,
-0.0542802252,
-0.0505481847,
0.0150314299,
-0.0580782481,
-0.0230637453,
0.0076639522,
-0.0129569639,
-0.0471904501,
-0.0190510936,
-0.0089243231,
-0.0079274736,
-0.0060810093,
0.0135720465,
0.0907047689,
-0.009733092,
0.0304246116,
-0.0130215595,
0.0229095761,
0.0451885536,
-0.0095150722,
0.0172528271,
0.0084435195,
-0.0240665823,
-0.0058088969,
0.0331949778,
-0.0011033175,
-0.0787503347,
-0.007891546,
-0.0480904877,
0.0031086768,
-0.0113752596,
0.0457598493,
0.021604944,
-0.0160765182,
0.0172910653,
0.0053526619,
-0.0296481922,
0.0179416388,
0.0244102329,
-0.0011130618,
0.04263933,
-0.006241512,
0.0001757886,
-0.0224748049,
-0.0201826468,
-0.0434202179,
0.0581136309,
0.0096562654,
0.0289809946,
-0.0274008438,
-0.0260539129,
-0.0688025728,
0.0301072355,
-0.0006210358,
-0.0112447422,
0.0624625944,
0.01617039,
-0.00158549,
0.0615484454,
0.012073528,
-0.0264791567,
0.05076674,
-0.0128832143,
-0.0396360233,
0.0217802003,
-0.0250588283,
0.0141096972,
-0.0147755295,
-0.0276768189,
-0.0097623253,
0.0435547195,
-0.0122750765,
-0.0032880625,
-0.0373163,
0.0334357955,
-0.0130808204,
-0.001901764,
-0.0283163935,
-0.0428083055,
0.0088299504,
0.1015122905,
-0.0399996564,
-0.0180727523,
0.0791070536,
-0.0440155417,
0.0138771906,
-0.0281808954,
0.0038144921,
-0.0501404479,
0.0710949823,
-0.0028681061,
-0.0198798142,
0.0498096272,
0.0392399952,
-0.0148977395,
-0.0339934193,
0.0473473668,
-0.0548278168,
0.0320741273,
-0.0531654097,
0.0012343681,
0.0118865259,
-0.0409110375,
-0.0524952225,
-0.0067884903,
-0.0485437624,
-0.0165851451,
-0.0340799727,
-0.0205174498,
-0.0341370814,
-0.038281586,
0.0389362425,
0.0106750429,
0.014071105,
-0.0222635437,
-0.0092974287,
0.0333743207,
0.0242053885,
0.0131425634,
0.0708992183,
-0.012605425,
0.0192798991,
0.0657310784,
0.0396891423,
0.0046918532,
-0.0307197515,
-0.0177992787,
-0.0172356423,
-0.0214778576,
0.0245677773,
0.0100396499,
0.0343860909,
-0.0656277016,
-0.0242582858,
0.0894254148,
0.0264059417,
-0.0257161204,
-0.0097502237,
-0.033181645,
0.0284716357,
0.0195125416,
0.0244917497,
-0.1367893219,
-0.0397671573,
0.0056423354,
0.0129317334,
-0.0158364121,
-0.0561936311,
-0.0002356748,
-0.1194041297,
0.0222793445,
-0.0302103404,
-0.012847703,
-0.0144357029,
-0.0882846043,
0.0397638641,
-0.013149335,
-0.032504607,
0.0086480575,
0.0207236744,
0.0051628659,
0.0144378161,
-0.0146884909,
-0.0150917089,
0.084642753,
-0.0439177677,
0.012782678,
0.0233582463,
0.0089664469,
0.0073067076,
-0.0749461576,
0.0184103418,
-0.0480518825,
-0.0458282121,
0.0013613388,
0.0260536335,
-0.0073374114,
0.0154379429,
-0.0297605544,
0.0204164144,
-0.0475658514,
-0.0284577832,
0.0546142906,
0.1035376564,
0.0032446566,
-0.0463097095,
-0.0228162631,
0.0449645966,
-0.0292799305,
0.0515158772,
0.0374214426,
0.0303544272,
-0.0233671144,
-0.0396152437,
-0.0244261213,
-0.0305719096,
-0.0393929482,
0.0458249338,
0.0570809245,
0.0524294749,
-0.0535011515,
-0.0489289835,
0.0236860309,
0.0420566835,
-0.0518721119,
-0.0048999935,
0.0049105375,
0.0133848526,
-0.0373494141,
0.0364500061,
-0.0584649853,
0.039608404,
-0.0284239296,
0.0416998118,
-0.0139788529,
0.0006078099,
-0.0310482103,
0.0448362567,
-0.0847655311,
-0.0385429561,
-0.0523775779,
0.0430051014,
0.021164041,
0.0431674756,
-0.0439481996,
-0.0201373044,
-0.0050040269,
-0.0092103565,
-0.0100838998,
-0.0197132975,
0.0409086533,
-0.0210565068,
0.0035967818,
0.0281228181,
-0.0305424165,
0.0076828804,
0.0299826991,
0.0355842412,
-0.0120091671,
-0.0660952181,
0.0297966935,
0.0058332272,
0.0120507739,
0.0420726575,
-0.0213097595,
-0.0095329974,
0.0501452312,
-0.0306664631,
-0.0382037908,
-0.0104221534,
0.0286928061,
-0.0046411222,
-0.0545802303,
0.0025645804,
-0.0072210194,
-0.0206565671,
0.0189649854,
-0.0160620883,
0.0178844258,
0.0592420809,
0.047582332,
-0.0011509681,
-0.0515427068,
-0.0290055647,
-0.0490195304,
0.0023110243,
0.0631556287,
0.0019004485,
0.0689522624,
0.067411311,
-0.0094227288,
0.0007153786,
-0.0060124081,
-0.0657164827,
-0.0330263264,
0.0118504073,
-0.0348866582,
0.0396245085,
0.0230906401,
0.0217679851,
-0.013536294,
-0.0328741074,
0.0053395471,
0.000014707,
0.0153481811,
-0.0268248096,
0.0359041505,
0.0330769494,
-0.0127295097,
-0.0035967464,
0.0377554744,
-0.0116666006,
0.0269427374,
0.0382877812,
-0.0250281859,
-0.0154056465,
-0.0453666411,
-0.0911060795,
0.0026879054,
0.0056723692,
-0.0007410928,
-0.0579795502,
-0.0815508515,
-0.0093999086,
0.0409956574,
0.020113742,
0.038084168,
0.0073691206,
0.0580714829,
0.050432343,
-0.0422321409,
-0.0157745108,
-0.0075979908,
-0.0110876448,
-0.0303298086,
-0.0127343992,
-5.721361696e-33,
-0.0035106239,
-0.0545075834,
0.0277219042,
-0.00138508,
0.0159198213,
0.0166737661,
-0.0593606383,
-0.0241974592,
-0.0665675253,
0.0877055824,
-0.0317216963,
0.0387213454,
0.0085302871,
0.0035457574,
-0.005424005,
-0.0237970874,
0.0028433192,
0.003855109,
-0.0615638793,
0.0230806787,
0.0314111337,
-0.034604013,
0.036992874,
-0.0504352972,
0.0377092436,
-0.0043382109,
-0.0143924495,
0.053636644,
-0.0615815073,
0.0482008457,
0.0202049743,
0.0234263074,
0.0247412901,
-0.0424491055,
0.0295935813,
0.0061979881,
-0.0995619893,
-0.0287311133,
0.0297791995,
-0.0412225239,
-0.101655066,
0.0096544567,
0.0103639187,
0.0258450601,
0.0143271703,
-0.0686937273,
0.0187779292,
-0.010575478,
0.025744766,
-0.0291805174,
-0.0219295043,
0.0466923863,
-0.0189113915,
-0.0340436101,
-0.0201685801,
0.0445086733,
-0.0101748882,
-0.0256299172,
-0.0439289771,
0.0017819628,
0.0130926445,
-0.0090398099,
0.0680674613,
-0.0258000605,
-0.0175448433,
0.0484805964,
0.0111514321,
0.0226860866,
-0.0644085407,
0.0278780926,
-0.0200178064,
0.036367666,
0.1111988798,
0.0279651154,
0.0045621758,
0.0512977354,
-0.1045497507,
0.0084867524,
-0.0069076628,
0.0552838184,
0.0154453861,
-0.0320210606,
-0.0059197228,
0.0060286275,
-0.0652430654,
0.0132259056,
-0.0439807065,
-0.010689199,
0.007613902,
-0.0146274734,
-0.0331931971,
-0.0376505069,
-0.0009017916,
-0.0490770973,
-0.0110272123,
0.062502265,
0.0082296366,
-0.0015526232,
0.0201257225,
0.0483456478,
-0.043879535,
0.0436062105,
0.0266549196,
0.016081281,
0.022884585,
0.0076155313,
0.0568754077,
-0.0194936339,
-0.0293547232,
0.0072157588,
-0.0631715432,
0.028116921,
-0.0294070262,
-0.0034775918,
0.0425888263,
0.0487471037,
0.0054947957,
0.0578607619,
0.0163045879,
0.0123785017,
-0.0353315808,
0.0617446937,
0.0161466394,
0.0049511236,
-0.0133092003,
-0.0035996125,
-0.0576289855,
0.014503018,
0.0002673356,
-0.0340710804,
0.0074791387,
0.0412380509,
2.494e-7,
0.0243372172,
0.0317177176,
0.0337943807,
0.0647014081,
0.0052126767,
0.0390405841,
-0.0059127016,
-0.0267376602,
0.0170449801,
-0.0780152678,
-0.0262872782,
0.0441945195,
0.0657329932,
0.068551667,
-0.0238810591,
-0.0373392142,
-0.0655483902,
-0.0426437519,
-0.0303385425,
-0.0168838035,
0.0540292561,
0.0517307073,
0.0165895913,
-0.0134633379,
-0.0256663207,
-0.0182356741,
0.0341048948,
0.0085713742,
0.0251608994,
0.0041140411,
0.041449964,
-0.0301037729,
0.0356985927,
0.0525600724,
-0.0151411425,
-0.0157713033,
-0.0293712001,
0.0184266064,
0.0121911159,
-0.0198709983,
-0.0432240963,
-0.042987451,
0.0294738933,
-0.0652162805,
0.0791268125,
-0.0408068299,
-0.0288326629,
-0.0142446384,
-0.0131269414,
-0.0414579324,
0.0373614095,
-0.0084923645,
0.0040776534,
0.0218680371,
0.0073496578,
0.0131995808,
0.007268589,
-0.0676243976,
-0.0367259793,
0.0091927275,
-0.0033899972,
-0.011199275,
0.0207093433,
-0.0046650255,
0.0133254174,
-0.0368189588,
-0.0018893119,
2.16748485e-34,
0.0091250576,
-0.018331321,
0.0251507703,
-0.0013730859,
0.0887437761,
-0.012245114,
-0.0328783765,
-0.0197142586,
0.0197185259,
-0.0906579345,
-0.0216314252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00530v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00530v2 | Superfiltering: Weak-to-Strong Data Filtering for Fast Instruction-Tuning | 2024-02-01T11:57:53 | 2024-06-07T20:28:36 | Ming Li, Yong Zhang, Shwai He, Zhitao Li, Hongyu Zhao, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is critical to improve LLMs but usually suffers from
low-quality and redundant data. Data filtering for instruction tuning has
proved important in improving both the efficiency and performance of the tuning
process. But it also leads to extra cost and computation due to the involvement
of LLMs in this process. To reduce the filtering cost, we study Superfiltering:
Can we use a smaller and weaker model to select data for finetuning a larger
and stronger model? Despite the performance gap between weak and strong
language models, we find their highly consistent capability to perceive
instruction difficulty and data selection results. This enables us to use a
much smaller and more efficient model to filter the instruction data used to
train a larger language model. Not only does it largely speed up the data
filtering, but the filtered-data-finetuned LLM achieves even better performance
on standard benchmarks. Extensive experiments validate the efficacy and
efficiency of our approach. | [
0.008258502,
0.0391747989,
-0.017831821,
0.0355165005,
-0.0113823973,
0.0295118783,
-0.0170805138,
0.0346358158,
0.0067045316,
-0.0480861589,
-0.0470501631,
-0.023118211,
-0.0168206953,
-0.0143886488,
0.0261331759,
-0.0052690436,
0.0669870451,
-0.0637208596,
-0.0342526063,
-0.0090942364,
-0.0458115712,
0.0014945831,
0.001445927,
0.0125463037,
0.0548936538,
0.0185803771,
0.0149459923,
0.0453700759,
-0.0124319419,
-0.0098469704,
0.0257561021,
0.0119622592,
0.0156868845,
-0.0241037831,
0.000002063,
-0.0148548028,
0.0042135422,
0.0006131881,
-0.0058249161,
0.048759371,
0.0138753569,
0.0322214141,
-0.0402622335,
0.0262189284,
-0.0073568872,
0.0377346985,
0.0024699119,
-0.0365158096,
0.0635801554,
0.0815765932,
0.0134026436,
-0.0197702013,
0.0050746957,
-0.0027920264,
0.0048851208,
-0.0240758043,
0.0193799585,
0.0007867165,
0.0197234433,
0.0055202073,
-0.0336632654,
0.0190749839,
-0.0083519183,
0.0186263956,
-0.0332516842,
-0.009969769,
-0.0109671345,
0.0012077433,
-0.014087799,
0.0388649218,
-0.0448078737,
-0.0036044053,
-0.0046155797,
-0.0314760543,
-0.0113585917,
-0.0199242719,
-0.0185731016,
0.020789491,
-0.0119068259,
0.0345274359,
0.046213828,
-0.0608098656,
0.0336034186,
0.0052777389,
-0.0179801602,
0.0918202326,
0.0390892364,
-0.0388007574,
0.0125264348,
0.0005082644,
-0.0161294956,
-0.0336637385,
0.0034309421,
0.0524053723,
-0.031930171,
0.0156235509,
-0.06977956,
0.033079911,
-0.004661127,
-0.0123045752,
0.0666663647,
0.0557885244,
-0.0204936806,
0.0267171282,
-0.0495207161,
0.0176826455,
-0.0124192452,
0.0657939166,
-0.0338544063,
0.0354347005,
-0.0114566078,
0.0446951054,
-0.0009388916,
0.0550967492,
-0.0470344163,
0.0562250726,
-0.055083897,
0.0204372332,
0.0062241005,
-0.0195262562,
0.0168508179,
-0.0674307123,
-0.0525219887,
0.0407555401,
-0.0313347578,
-0.0041072783,
-0.0107028568,
0.0079481481,
-0.0354589932,
-0.063605018,
-0.0006782647,
0.0234138314,
-0.0253222231,
-0.048581358,
0.0600193404,
0.0741651431,
-0.0118172718,
-0.0223460104,
-0.0899111629,
-0.0104579749,
0.023742836,
-0.0546601489,
0.0286800303,
-0.0294738431,
-0.014559906,
-0.0140445484,
0.0168634057,
-0.0559504926,
-0.0002052433,
0.0128167002,
-0.0149049116,
0.0185570568,
-0.025519209,
-0.0125853056,
-0.0077263406,
0.0184769332,
0.0068250978,
0.071747832,
0.0343518592,
-0.0061989333,
0.0187137276,
-0.0282125119,
-0.0296122748,
0.0439468622,
0.0037687398,
0.0304845367,
-0.051743146,
-0.0109039228,
-0.0197387952,
-0.0087308185,
0.0324391462,
0.0103800287,
-0.0029790173,
0.0019802495,
0.0232593101,
0.0183700621,
0.0457075797,
0.0095460908,
0.0371827893,
0.0194733646,
0.0052741803,
0.0424881317,
-0.0287523847,
0.0373445414,
-0.0022664098,
0.0104993368,
-2.6e-7,
0.0579292588,
-0.0367340222,
-0.0592919998,
-0.0058324281,
0.0168692134,
-0.0110544506,
0.0294137616,
0.0302445665,
-0.0402207524,
-0.0675425157,
0.0592211597,
0.078145273,
-0.0241064336,
-0.0309472457,
-0.1168674156,
0.0107501633,
0.0550953448,
0.0524459183,
-0.0331262387,
-0.0329480022,
0.0046147509,
0.0705854893,
-0.0112488912,
0.0300057307,
0.0211321767,
0.0279784743,
-0.0573014058,
-0.0422895104,
-0.0001097325,
-0.0071829632,
0.0042122323,
0.0158799011,
-0.0338344239,
0.0144033264,
0.0263345446,
-0.0761544481,
0.0480214171,
-0.0081300782,
-0.0490571596,
-0.0095164031,
0.0211458523,
0.0274901707,
-0.0138532259,
-0.0061724028,
-0.016150279,
0.0573663339,
-0.0080270367,
0.0639313608,
-0.0735524818,
-0.0405114219,
-0.0198674984,
0.0291440319,
-0.0229733195,
0.0049123433,
0.0195044167,
-0.0499675535,
-0.043169383,
-0.0119192908,
-0.0480756909,
-0.0003849113,
0.0079449425,
0.0578413457,
-0.0331968926,
-0.0043953294,
-0.0611620396,
0.0393061377,
-0.0207611825,
0.017338993,
0.0313050747,
0.0272527207,
0.0000179916,
-0.0277820807,
-0.0296235867,
0.0057826913,
-0.0010219605,
0.025530206,
-0.0220340025,
0.0388650708,
-0.0371743068,
-0.0747024789,
-0.0125536248,
0.0298036728,
-0.0290646851,
0.0302322879,
0.0136430562,
-0.0143750096,
-0.000247623,
-0.0008014646,
-0.0129520958,
0.0178440865,
-0.0244822782,
0.0107147666,
0.0059269313,
0.0076604593,
-0.0653643161,
-0.051238846,
-0.0586168244,
-0.0079387026,
-0.0019619798,
-0.0369926877,
-0.036237549,
-0.0698967203,
0.0651347712,
-0.0058700461,
0.0442442,
-0.006832114,
-0.0670874417,
0.0176842231,
-0.0154163772,
-0.0071117198,
0.1018359512,
-0.0328101628,
0.0153343212,
0.0681607425,
-0.0251416601,
-0.0553676933,
0.0446768031,
0.0095099155,
-0.0370630249,
-0.0556918457,
-0.0234731771,
-0.0253429338,
0.0787721425,
-0.0262213256,
-0.0116455965,
-0.0282001998,
0.0110538676,
0.0071503245,
-0.0119070308,
0.0178055,
0.0293340851,
-0.0310435072,
-0.0039360747,
-0.0403752811,
-0.0721919015,
0.0478809029,
-0.0167406052,
0.0109636374,
-0.0286888089,
-0.0403236672,
-0.0125817349,
-0.0452935211,
0.0077182949,
0.0001373988,
-0.0767423883,
0.0126623306,
-0.0450394005,
-0.005007714,
0.0186505523,
-0.0372032113,
0.0849044695,
-0.0559481606,
0.0022266316,
-0.0085764406,
-0.0081452718,
-0.0180042814,
0.037882369,
0.0175125003,
0.0096727759,
0.0540685318,
-0.0316947512,
-0.0244170707,
-0.0018855629,
0.0150734466,
0.022857232,
-0.0182412881,
-0.0099140834,
-0.0610809438,
-0.0402583592,
0.0132326782,
-0.0168904476,
-0.0087298751,
-0.0424372554,
0.0380993746,
0.007357527,
0.0487972721,
-0.0245358888,
-0.0130328657,
0.0473710112,
0.0583467931,
-0.0317004882,
-0.0349844582,
0.0772685036,
0.0760155171,
-0.0557356179,
-0.0257337317,
0.0708508641,
0.0329189003,
-0.0118556386,
0.0041673258,
0.0163826514,
0.0288403109,
0.0626443997,
0.0393633768,
-0.0213315599,
-0.044804316,
0.0118435519,
0.0548721887,
-0.0068073915,
0.0029718813,
-0.0260463357,
-0.0509762615,
0.0218336061,
0.0297195055,
-0.005204556,
-0.0383362882,
-0.0287796948,
-0.0014132651,
0.0103354687,
0.031595923,
0.0138342967,
-0.0405802391,
-0.0057659913,
0.0460783839,
0.0144610126,
-0.0546326227,
0.0260914993,
-0.0161692053,
0.0349811204,
0.0248686392,
0.0095835347,
0.0003058355,
-0.042884808,
0.0900259539,
-0.0139334397,
0.0244645812,
-0.0636987612,
0.0265757982,
0.0076710139,
-0.0174700022,
-0.0016351221,
-0.00809542,
0.0022750574,
0.0227133874,
0.0033357709,
0.0632973909,
-0.0378763862,
0.0322472304,
0.0073858355,
-0.0274551194,
-0.0132915583,
0.040631067,
0.0313759856,
-0.0499555953,
0.0004755001,
-0.0445621721,
-0.0564945005,
-0.0638098344,
-0.0370848104,
0.0510360599,
-0.0657989308,
0.0031835511,
-0.0161061883,
-0.0045168698,
0.0189219136,
0.0371170826,
0.0155262034,
0.0189874265,
0.0173266679,
-0.0171761774,
-0.0259022862,
0.0226430148,
-0.0490649827,
0.0384977125,
-0.1226510406,
-0.0472580567,
0.0242565572,
0.026980279,
-0.0151460497,
0.033233285,
-0.0838356093,
-0.0726029351,
0.0049181995,
0.0828390867,
0.0138046704,
0.0176711548,
0.0026436693,
-0.0546218865,
-0.0033897769,
0.0207820851,
-0.0131392973,
0.0471812859,
0.0558322296,
-0.0548710786,
-0.0118179983,
0.0070069488,
-0.0371407717,
0.0334535949,
0.0869312659,
0.0151816644,
-0.0319772065,
-0.0289250389,
0.0012506401,
0.0554698892,
0.0229958743,
-0.0067925476,
-0.0195437931,
-0.0053731031,
0.0548066981,
0.0260805301,
0.0276888553,
-0.0497606359,
-0.0011582216,
-0.001024202,
-0.0319418125,
-0.0116008539,
-0.0144749554,
-0.0048912112,
0.0381387658,
-0.0338291191,
0.0931073353,
-0.0415873751,
0.0262500849,
0.036371246,
0.0090078302,
0.0015303541,
0.0405347906,
0.0346640833,
0.0350616798,
-0.0057891482,
0.0479151942,
-0.0134296687,
0.0551471151,
-0.038877897,
0.0203993022,
-0.0363784395,
-0.0308502875,
-0.0581927709,
-0.0081489412,
0.0503103919,
-0.0196946338,
0.0328120366,
0.0192964841,
0.0043906067,
-0.0211860221,
0.0094047328,
0.0130582564,
-0.0015806776,
0.0450119041,
0.0160013754,
0.0080067879,
-0.0141460998,
0.0641375333,
-0.000597988,
0.0616174564,
0.0062533198,
0.0038595442,
-0.0376716703,
-0.038437847,
0.0222706273,
0.0135040758,
0.0135545973,
0.0153527251,
0.0025293175,
-0.030434778,
-0.0442522429,
-0.0045434507,
0.0288986322,
-0.0418616794,
0.0277786739,
0.025437288,
-0.0144387148,
-0.0341640487,
-0.0319676958,
-0.0450966172,
0.055584304,
-0.0091425097,
0.0119906617,
-6.239491688e-33,
-0.0593154319,
0.0145473089,
0.0099171354,
0.0065773376,
0.0216084309,
-0.0106681865,
-0.0166841671,
-0.0227545127,
-0.0320604853,
-0.0308711082,
-0.004016364,
0.02094041,
0.0191831756,
-0.0128846196,
-0.0010101713,
0.0156716425,
0.0671016574,
-0.0015758751,
-0.0288990662,
0.0112692947,
-0.0054940036,
0.0246487763,
0.0460634306,
-0.0417130738,
-0.0439912006,
-0.000311265,
-0.0003058392,
0.0016940213,
-0.021632418,
0.0584929101,
0.0231509525,
0.0333561376,
0.0132212993,
-0.0564168692,
-0.0344559029,
-0.0583533682,
-0.0272362698,
-0.052351553,
0.023540901,
0.0200124178,
0.028070379,
-0.0724805668,
0.0576148964,
0.0386183523,
-0.0681322217,
-0.0330199264,
0.0086094597,
-0.03190317,
-0.0456753224,
0.0071382243,
-0.0282762107,
0.0398922637,
0.0121434797,
0.0052674902,
0.0481558032,
-0.003131323,
-0.0024234611,
-0.0116365496,
-0.0262013469,
0.0294378642,
0.0782367736,
0.1216746718,
0.0698948056,
0.0275756065,
-0.0163600259,
0.0046101548,
0.0106803095,
0.0227103736,
0.0532636903,
-0.0058924286,
0.0533726178,
0.0701579526,
0.0136164874,
-0.012233004,
0.0377066471,
-0.0286743902,
-0.0886150748,
0.0134294862,
-0.0092054904,
0.0285654943,
0.007533804,
0.0148094334,
-0.0537728705,
-0.012867705,
-0.0294497889,
0.0242564324,
-0.0319523774,
-0.0124088144,
0.0377213731,
-0.0107621979,
-0.0375368185,
-0.0211956613,
0.0228469484,
-0.0238756686,
-0.0034222314,
-0.0255074352,
-0.0412112921,
0.003138982,
-0.0099389609,
0.0132581051,
-0.0452879965,
-0.1165049076,
0.0246511009,
-0.0340851024,
0.0648775324,
-0.0109786307,
0.0145058818,
0.0191641692,
-0.0776106715,
-0.0160817932,
-0.0497984737,
0.020606827,
0.0183607358,
0.0315631628,
0.0098044183,
-0.0083829854,
0.0156958494,
0.0734808445,
-0.0235188119,
-0.0478841662,
-0.0295954812,
-0.03479781,
0.0256849695,
0.0749607533,
-0.0306223445,
0.0140180634,
-0.0354245938,
0.0151729798,
0.0038007994,
-0.0490355156,
-0.0344232842,
0.0148174595,
2.727e-7,
0.0031312446,
0.0541284718,
-0.0179094542,
0.0575130321,
-0.0189249441,
0.0192408767,
-0.0233289823,
-0.0268903226,
0.0192324296,
-0.0190608874,
0.0120586278,
0.0610969178,
0.0538386628,
0.0049249874,
-0.0163323041,
0.013515424,
-0.0027693061,
0.0482562594,
-0.0394980758,
-0.0098455548,
0.0284143854,
0.0802251846,
-0.0089098541,
-0.031279441,
-0.0014618279,
-0.0249350425,
-0.0120371385,
-0.039298676,
0.0061912187,
0.0553913303,
0.0515849292,
0.0368069038,
-0.0257082842,
0.0251257904,
-0.051787518,
0.0012486372,
-0.0403086916,
0.080444321,
-0.0285436288,
-0.0044921217,
0.0728583932,
0.0113481227,
-0.0143151935,
0.0152170621,
0.0680367351,
-0.0044904049,
0.0216526072,
-0.0123979747,
0.0265369657,
-0.0387276448,
0.0066223396,
-0.0377952941,
0.0176307764,
0.02982473,
0.0325040296,
-0.0409247056,
-0.0318814963,
-0.0511547029,
-0.0130264685,
0.030879071,
-0.021292679,
-0.0888731256,
-0.0703725591,
0.0445734523,
-0.0058947834,
-0.0537623763,
-0.0044094757,
2.854795479e-34,
0.0350459516,
-0.0352772214,
0.0433524624,
0.038773261,
0.0254690927,
0.0037577017,
-0.0545095317,
0.0310592726,
-0.0087145735,
-0.0612800792,
-0.0272941142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00518v1 | EE-Tuning: An Economical yet Scalable Solution for Tuning Early-Exit Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | Xuchen Pan, Yanxi Chen, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jingren Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work introduces EE-Tuning, a lightweight and economical solution to
training/tuning early-exit large language models (LLMs). In contrast to the
common approach of full-parameter pre-training, EE-Tuning augments any
pre-trained (and possibly fine-tuned) standard LLM with additional early-exit
layers that are tuned in a parameter-efficient manner, which requires
significantly less computational resources and training data. Our
implementation of EE-Tuning achieves outstanding training efficiency via
extensive performance optimizations, as well as scalability due to its full
compatibility with 3D parallelism. Results of systematic experiments validate
the efficacy of EE-Tuning, confirming that effective early-exit LLM inference
can be achieved with a limited training budget. In hope of making early-exit
LLMs accessible to the community, we release the source code of our
implementation of EE-Tuning at https://github.com/pan-x-c/EE-LLM. | [
0.0161736626,
0.0952102765,
0.0087241335,
0.0314647891,
0.0083243102,
0.0387908183,
0.0113334777,
-0.0068950485,
-0.0349429548,
-0.0133078918,
-0.0443076976,
-0.0003026017,
-0.003796882,
0.0278853271,
0.0323712155,
-0.0282029863,
0.0233696904,
-0.0340985954,
-0.0377722718,
-0.016638387,
-0.0137976948,
0.0331720039,
-0.0010609594,
0.0296374317,
0.055159308,
0.002297048,
-0.0063884305,
0.0401884206,
0.0228135884,
-0.0171100032,
0.0236001294,
0.0517374128,
0.0355336629,
0.029765442,
0.0000020917,
-0.0514668748,
-0.0171455238,
-0.0121790143,
-0.040512912,
0.0702495351,
0.0223083701,
0.0046099699,
-0.0004141454,
0.025846066,
0.0161747131,
-0.0332722515,
0.0694382042,
-0.0125208683,
0.0385774635,
0.0876936689,
0.0000059912,
-0.0221638214,
-0.0031656513,
-0.0664028823,
-0.0321091004,
-0.0482329801,
0.0435904674,
-0.0421804376,
-0.039444454,
-0.0134218819,
-0.0049631195,
0.014765745,
0.0242972784,
0.028652288,
-0.0311502814,
0.0520601869,
-0.0074068606,
-0.0464231148,
-0.0379692316,
0.0356180891,
-0.0204603244,
-0.0552025214,
0.0300629027,
-0.0294475388,
-0.0259256233,
-0.0009770386,
-0.0316753834,
0.0072206259,
0.0466399267,
0.0056738285,
0.0222601872,
-0.0032484999,
0.0366347171,
0.0187600255,
-0.0441293716,
0.0134531865,
0.0687253401,
0.0050669787,
-0.0029294102,
0.000836212,
-0.0146668125,
-0.0401647948,
-0.0069449339,
-0.0048467694,
0.0051853973,
-0.000404385,
-0.0579337887,
-0.0244657025,
-0.014258544,
-0.0406042263,
0.0488865785,
0.036809288,
0.0107377991,
0.0849947408,
-0.0280803442,
-0.0030273015,
-0.0142718721,
0.0086080302,
-0.0359318033,
-0.002023601,
0.0392329395,
0.0351702012,
-0.0191375762,
-0.0307079665,
-0.0138399303,
-0.024273755,
-0.0449096225,
0.0259920917,
0.0348439068,
-0.0235293861,
0.027595507,
0.0046255253,
-0.028583942,
-0.0335206613,
0.0403653979,
0.0396979228,
-0.0363363214,
0.0138873598,
-0.0245245174,
-0.0405518487,
-0.0327583551,
0.0459435731,
0.0346620083,
-0.0273076557,
0.0652751476,
0.0395977423,
0.0225439556,
-0.0417479388,
-0.0499862358,
0.0303082392,
-0.0011041355,
-0.08398927,
0.0105565554,
-0.076056309,
0.0187427755,
0.0205176715,
0.0155847985,
-0.0245810095,
-0.0222553462,
-0.0156049151,
-0.0227310434,
0.0208485648,
-0.0114806239,
0.0015645096,
0.0289557558,
-0.0198638439,
0.0190191604,
0.0915923566,
0.0195986573,
0.0342458896,
0.033846736,
-0.0410421193,
-0.0400304683,
0.0910418779,
0.0304521937,
0.0466820896,
-0.0428822748,
-0.0113671152,
0.0319279358,
0.0324034467,
0.0403176695,
0.0081410371,
-0.044457227,
-0.0139108021,
0.0479024127,
0.0672940165,
0.0119938636,
0.0108619248,
0.0287699383,
0.0018032778,
0.0018384968,
-0.0366478711,
-0.0381975733,
0.0250860602,
-0.0151307965,
-0.0066835997,
0.0457441323,
0.0831933245,
-0.0260256305,
-0.002718271,
-0.0133677172,
-0.0031943473,
-0.0276170932,
0.0287806895,
0.0698260069,
-0.0241502542,
-0.0264760591,
0.0699535981,
0.0543982983,
-0.0248337463,
-0.0175566338,
-0.0556513406,
0.0193240568,
0.0372871011,
0.0198275503,
0.009940098,
-0.0282468181,
0.0114977863,
0.035568323,
0.0445451848,
0.0376736633,
0.0061633587,
0.0390529372,
-0.0736480057,
-0.0216025356,
0.0383278206,
0.0160911009,
0.010187557,
0.0710969716,
-0.001772936,
0.0079562543,
-0.0466319658,
-0.0242125411,
0.0328394398,
-0.0639397129,
0.0024235328,
0.0024496228,
0.007738845,
0.0308281276,
-0.0192697011,
-0.0121402629,
-0.0313138366,
0.0292220972,
-0.0117571102,
0.0148213264,
-0.0049147829,
-0.0273297615,
-0.0089542959,
0.0257618073,
0.0236458294,
0.0086421687,
0.0406636558,
-0.0474988595,
-0.0371505395,
0.0228639469,
-0.0192533284,
0.0718545243,
-0.0342812799,
0.0306853186,
-0.0407986231,
0.0201888662,
-0.0359917469,
0.0357556641,
-0.0309980772,
0.011094504,
0.004818548,
0.0021536129,
-0.025292702,
0.0037677011,
-0.0520864502,
0.0060560526,
0.0280340221,
0.0112795532,
0.0096739121,
0.0218279287,
-0.0208563432,
-0.0026732665,
-0.0669131577,
0.034517251,
-0.0433902219,
0.0333123654,
0.0386067964,
0.00302922,
-0.0253135245,
-0.0118165445,
0.0458790958,
0.0208894722,
-0.0284937583,
0.0049813706,
-0.0225893762,
-0.0164609086,
-0.052412238,
-0.0307283923,
-0.0359154716,
0.0155875925,
0.0762384236,
-0.0156863928,
-0.0212725457,
-0.0367008522,
0.0188859813,
0.0100358538,
0.0495148487,
0.0020448358,
-0.0406158566,
-0.0117027862,
-0.033057943,
0.0393025167,
0.0562828034,
-0.0175040644,
0.0079993187,
0.0260642376,
0.0283181053,
-0.0531413332,
-0.0094625503,
-0.0360689946,
-0.0218064841,
-0.0599118769,
-0.0202086754,
-0.0102192536,
0.0866448358,
-0.0289218538,
0.007726375,
-0.0386604369,
0.0178737119,
-0.0063175457,
-0.0167757459,
0.0042218822,
0.040246781,
-0.0199054684,
0.0115047321,
-0.0049484707,
-0.0566196255,
0.059884619,
-0.046845533,
-0.0068618953,
-0.019171752,
-0.0158485454,
-0.0459484346,
0.0339359939,
-0.0037398022,
0.0105545018,
-0.0176623631,
-0.0076255579,
-0.0209562164,
0.0188512243,
0.006066835,
0.0138822654,
0.0485789105,
-0.0483900048,
0.01850833,
-0.0202453155,
-0.0400432609,
0.01031256,
-0.0268729664,
-0.0581685267,
-0.0304800998,
0.0252017863,
-0.0623234361,
-0.0456565171,
0.0009946175,
0.0056524538,
0.0852536932,
-0.0191352013,
0.0321160816,
-0.0092701484,
0.0079487981,
0.0547455475,
0.0144429151,
0.0209428575,
-0.0771068782,
0.0030855695,
0.0321780406,
-0.0007932212,
0.0070514292,
-0.0615382828,
-0.0125230579,
0.085909225,
-0.0240078382,
-0.0225288011,
0.0279367194,
0.0156243965,
-0.0604198687,
0.0057696016,
0.1273201853,
-0.0081491228,
-0.0814136639,
-0.0107094254,
0.0236454979,
0.0617595762,
0.0196510348,
0.0218866505,
-0.0427936651,
-0.0342011042,
-0.0129322717,
0.0285642222,
0.0352470316,
0.0065465276,
-0.008711054,
-0.1057863086,
0.0358416326,
0.020457441,
-0.0442449972,
-0.0125954263,
-0.0452077873,
0.0083243316,
-0.037618205,
-0.0005578506,
0.0071463226,
-0.0198692251,
-0.0091280201,
0.0277772471,
0.0079360427,
-0.0558951981,
0.0323649608,
-0.0342635438,
0.0568362698,
0.0095211491,
-0.0085950345,
-0.0205054674,
-0.0306772534,
0.0674010739,
-0.0175224971,
-0.0315342769,
-0.0332555138,
0.0130401468,
-0.0249422714,
-0.0014513467,
-0.0086924369,
0.0367428735,
-0.0022838062,
-0.0108653493,
0.0187277012,
0.0477379449,
-0.024477696,
-0.0409299284,
0.0109555926,
-0.0116802957,
-0.0527638532,
0.06809856,
0.0455046706,
-0.0783827156,
-0.015505407,
-0.0029011511,
-0.0371951237,
-0.0608098619,
-0.013855489,
-0.0236958992,
-0.0244355723,
-0.041517254,
-0.006511189,
0.046261847,
0.0304825008,
0.0533115156,
0.0036907566,
-0.0044419812,
-0.0047810865,
0.0112661747,
-0.0449245945,
0.0349830091,
-0.0220392477,
-0.0070403703,
-0.0817943662,
0.0077895555,
0.0566456914,
-0.0227311999,
-0.0186356902,
0.0115153799,
-0.1100545824,
-0.0731218979,
0.001737886,
0.02610787,
0.012244611,
0.066295445,
0.0088686142,
-0.0995135978,
0.0396003909,
0.0079396814,
0.0182060227,
0.0597773381,
0.0325084962,
-0.0137096122,
-0.0195725821,
0.036427062,
-0.0159104578,
0.0190696977,
0.0491677448,
0.015147646,
-0.0360689275,
-0.0385291986,
-0.0437542908,
-0.0108698932,
0.0505095199,
-0.0440752693,
-0.0228978228,
-0.0702926964,
0.0392450355,
0.0054403315,
0.0080421744,
-0.0474620312,
0.0006073983,
0.0289880931,
0.0218368005,
-0.0301587991,
0.0049545565,
0.0592946894,
0.0069898628,
-0.0717532635,
0.0457350686,
-0.0117559787,
0.0085323742,
0.0717002898,
-0.0147585664,
-0.030796973,
0.0464807078,
-0.0110432943,
0.02762633,
-0.0464065857,
0.0529684089,
0.0284650233,
-0.0047528553,
-0.0303585455,
0.0261965375,
-0.0327722766,
-0.0627216697,
-0.0676754043,
0.0493161455,
0.048960574,
0.0195277911,
0.0893415734,
-0.0002507551,
-0.0314928889,
-0.0262526348,
0.0115850987,
-0.0307905283,
-0.0218914282,
0.0133795561,
0.022759445,
-0.0281229429,
0.0226109456,
0.0427507088,
0.0490992554,
0.0462446921,
0.0236378685,
0.0029388433,
-0.014665015,
-0.0265306029,
-0.0176784489,
0.009217524,
-0.044019334,
0.0237534493,
0.0029574514,
-0.0541106574,
-0.046291478,
0.0357699245,
-0.022833854,
0.0161323603,
0.0278883874,
0.0676704422,
-0.0395791382,
-0.0208207499,
-0.0292866789,
0.0019714977,
0.0167533923,
-0.0213152468,
0.013921597,
-6.916634474e-33,
-0.0095404396,
0.0204458982,
0.0239597801,
0.0058202287,
-0.0091257459,
-0.0040288516,
-0.0287422016,
-0.0079809865,
-0.0184702612,
-0.0344295464,
0.0153627582,
0.0056380127,
0.0176488757,
0.0293208528,
-0.0021873671,
0.027290104,
0.0576104894,
0.0014294721,
-0.0316395871,
0.0295464899,
-0.015541208,
0.0466743633,
0.0870349258,
0.0077593862,
-0.0474921912,
-0.0146864764,
-0.0274288971,
0.0136571974,
-0.0300834347,
0.0385354534,
-0.0217096172,
0.0036062854,
-0.0085470974,
-0.0392613448,
0.0051325685,
-0.0155893173,
-0.0685673952,
-0.0077315108,
0.0307882335,
0.0217878073,
-0.0173649732,
-0.0084032798,
0.0227756258,
0.0106929624,
-0.0420893133,
-0.0310388021,
0.0277755037,
0.0071001267,
-0.0500877351,
-0.0114361793,
-0.0252607409,
0.039724566,
0.0017027925,
0.0086679272,
0.0024023522,
-0.0116176615,
-0.0073782802,
0.0290325563,
-0.0463575013,
0.0094270837,
0.0139285866,
0.0369659774,
0.0450208783,
0.0737665668,
0.018331198,
0.0641454235,
0.0350170434,
0.0001215025,
0.0175116714,
-0.006114217,
0.0936868414,
0.0197658185,
0.0063949968,
-0.0059778625,
0.0058705877,
-0.0175428148,
-0.0782007575,
-0.0115305511,
0.011567153,
0.0300161,
0.0429716408,
0.0126359314,
-0.0086381277,
-0.034899082,
-0.0569727421,
-0.0360922851,
-0.0336928703,
0.0172807276,
0.0240220632,
0.0285519622,
-0.0598606616,
-0.0374013074,
0.045546256,
-0.0274225585,
0.0172213968,
0.0248255469,
-0.0031360944,
0.0141717009,
-0.0118097086,
0.0450438447,
-0.0785075724,
-0.0527566671,
-0.0244942978,
-0.0497277826,
0.0336224176,
-0.0447903723,
0.0140935369,
0.0390805118,
-0.062681362,
-0.0050957659,
-0.0390656851,
-0.0025514101,
0.029301649,
0.0601800308,
0.0201060437,
-0.0013795146,
0.0082213897,
0.0422976129,
0.017301118,
0.0120901726,
-0.0180800445,
-0.0461777523,
0.0307308063,
0.0304714181,
-0.0304469634,
0.0075534242,
-0.021494709,
-0.0104277739,
0.0324777476,
-0.0718226209,
-0.03035805,
0.0377079323,
2.737e-7,
0.0307348315,
0.0445112735,
-0.0006360742,
0.0232108701,
-0.0158717725,
0.0130667668,
0.0021001745,
-0.0055879424,
0.0348778181,
0.0434128344,
0.0354169719,
0.0334437564,
0.0534112006,
-0.007220285,
-0.0947925448,
0.0233605895,
-0.0796577632,
0.0441850685,
-0.0367593393,
-0.0218946561,
-0.0354602002,
0.097784102,
0.0460156612,
-0.0197403431,
-0.0048319506,
-0.0240027253,
0.0427318215,
-0.0454117917,
-0.0119429193,
0.0390590802,
0.0000781209,
0.0258180127,
-0.0149060572,
-0.0035840757,
-0.009372334,
0.0530771203,
-0.0167407971,
0.0938122422,
0.0085587669,
-0.0040061614,
0.031614162,
-0.0034952618,
-0.0241077617,
-0.0656264201,
0.0737021342,
-0.0374221131,
-0.0120353336,
-0.072185874,
-0.0037128262,
-0.0548575148,
0.0115594333,
-0.0596572571,
-0.0070123416,
0.0174349844,
0.0395047218,
-0.0431219116,
-0.0288753901,
-0.0831543282,
-0.016640313,
0.0183241386,
-0.0621071085,
-0.069355011,
-0.0365302376,
-0.0304034147,
0.0329939015,
-0.0364728868,
-0.0042812186,
2.92544223e-34,
0.0562273115,
-0.0190835688,
0.0094914883,
0.016713975,
0.032004118,
-0.0210103616,
0.0311951078,
-0.0081836898,
-0.0095357588,
-0.1234925985,
-0.0330065973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00913v1 | Institutional Platform for Secure Self-Service Large Language Model Exploration | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | V. K. Cody Bumgardner, Mitchell A. Klusty, W. Vaiden Logan, Samuel E. Armstrong, Caylin Hickey, Jeff Talbert | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper introduces a user-friendly platform developed by the University of
Kentucky Center for Applied AI, designed to make large, customized language
models (LLMs) more accessible. By capitalizing on recent advancements in
multi-LoRA inference, the system efficiently accommodates custom adapters for a
diverse range of users and projects. The paper outlines the system's
architecture and key features, encompassing dataset curation, model training,
secure inference, and text-based feature extraction.
We illustrate the establishment of a tenant-aware computational network using
agent-based methods, securely utilizing islands of isolated resources as a
unified system. The platform strives to deliver secure LLM services,
emphasizing process and data isolation, end-to-end encryption, and role-based
resource authentication. This contribution aligns with the overarching goal of
enabling simplified access to cutting-edge AI models and technology in support
of scientific discovery. | [
0.0317949317,
0.0894332081,
-0.0060974802,
0.0807906836,
-0.0730525702,
-0.0245227423,
0.1084973514,
-0.0433151685,
0.0559623688,
-0.001934731,
-0.0253873039,
-0.0010908465,
-0.0209460761,
0.0607510917,
0.0199746601,
0.0519515611,
0.0396945812,
-0.0785978064,
0.0407430716,
-0.0503771678,
-0.0333691649,
0.0320354998,
0.009026967,
-0.0040969742,
0.0259112474,
-0.0411423258,
-0.0319237188,
-0.025244765,
-0.0097325454,
-0.0182651151,
-0.0018628944,
0.0635205135,
0.0200221352,
0.0960606039,
0.0000023997,
-0.045673959,
-0.0592068098,
0.0482004397,
-0.0671271235,
0.0046693338,
0.0676574111,
-0.0015105475,
-0.0114439139,
-0.0035279868,
-0.0425319076,
0.0265114885,
0.0674011856,
-0.0342942029,
0.035057839,
-0.0008971802,
0.0050849686,
-0.0528552122,
-0.0163165163,
-0.0236009862,
-0.0612714179,
-0.0359233283,
0.046058435,
-0.0224687532,
0.0208342541,
0.0147713032,
-0.0029120857,
0.0391261764,
0.0165640693,
0.0017230813,
-0.0008503327,
0.0379924066,
-0.0220558979,
-0.0547021404,
-0.0512060262,
0.0065038665,
0.0322253704,
-0.0041026105,
0.0018669961,
0.0274502598,
-0.0160456598,
0.0544111133,
-0.0069645084,
0.0689730644,
0.0071865316,
-0.0206963923,
0.0466148667,
0.0028548453,
0.0007922769,
0.0534160994,
-0.0089330794,
0.1102083996,
0.0288349371,
-0.0104982704,
-0.0390702896,
-0.0430967845,
0.0344174244,
-0.0601961464,
0.039788086,
0.0144593418,
0.0310709067,
0.0053613889,
-0.0423669368,
-0.0520820729,
0.0387498736,
-0.0301493779,
0.0224482361,
-0.0238840301,
0.0023246664,
0.0528912209,
0.0167992171,
0.0262057092,
-0.0286491998,
0.019663984,
0.0535950325,
-0.000868579,
-0.0214915108,
-0.020392105,
-0.0191214364,
0.0428214557,
-0.0285544805,
0.0082175713,
-0.0093608135,
0.0271924883,
0.0090430249,
0.0510948971,
-0.0165657122,
-0.017678434,
-0.000237849,
-0.0420951322,
0.0017598937,
-0.016504202,
0.0013214109,
0.0085255969,
-0.0042711468,
-0.0997213796,
-0.02996145,
0.0017943764,
-0.016069226,
-0.0076745804,
0.007175996,
0.1057337001,
0.0543734059,
-0.0289411619,
-0.0122773238,
-0.0697572082,
0.0244570021,
-0.0729236901,
-0.0297702234,
-0.0782678276,
0.0384034924,
0.0008046849,
-0.0165332966,
-0.0603535958,
0.0019721622,
-0.0233137906,
-0.0110088084,
0.0437740162,
-0.0418475941,
-0.0124574266,
0.0236945655,
0.0231338255,
0.0109706745,
0.0322674513,
0.0119647551,
0.035977792,
0.0610780381,
0.0004983344,
0.0444713682,
0.0273857601,
-0.0060143466,
-0.0068319328,
0.0000160357,
0.0490573049,
0.0354105569,
-0.0163626224,
-0.0380206816,
0.0322691239,
0.0141094355,
-0.0395021476,
0.0738804564,
0.1217811778,
-0.0265602972,
0.0397156551,
-0.0167547707,
0.0352164991,
0.0028646002,
-0.0876732916,
-0.0412049815,
0.0479164831,
-0.0006415045,
-0.0256104991,
-0.0089079514,
0.072948277,
0.0161918402,
-0.0008406205,
-0.015684031,
-0.0296227653,
-0.020556001,
-0.000124548,
0.0611245558,
-0.0095051657,
0.0188606475,
0.0359013826,
0.0277499016,
-0.051862482,
-0.0228016395,
-0.0783576816,
0.0598708019,
0.0899871439,
0.0543530881,
0.0079503739,
0.0077331169,
-0.0109885931,
0.0068126926,
0.0745057613,
-0.0030259793,
0.0177267026,
0.0305657219,
-0.0429263599,
-0.0382421315,
-0.0067683584,
0.0299180076,
0.0355120488,
-0.0179534014,
0.0003224526,
-0.0127265295,
-0.0064443005,
-0.0256173238,
0.0114396941,
-0.0534970351,
-0.0170204062,
0.0008536681,
0.0179766435,
0.0342127085,
0.0319411904,
-0.0229563396,
0.0221840311,
0.0184365083,
0.0121986698,
0.0134306736,
-0.0287268814,
0.0382770225,
0.0717393607,
0.0062072999,
-0.0019839881,
0.0421623178,
-0.0026503096,
-0.0024396908,
0.0016246844,
0.0487772115,
0.0023326953,
0.0009476208,
-0.0183707494,
0.0059265392,
-0.0186686441,
0.0605782084,
-0.0313095935,
0.0167809296,
-0.002660715,
-0.0065801069,
-0.0193234868,
-0.0295794327,
0.0416794233,
-0.0463574156,
-0.0044518886,
-0.0297281556,
0.0098606106,
-0.0083014742,
-0.0174403936,
-0.0199521072,
0.008064121,
-0.0031568743,
-0.0005894445,
0.005718478,
-0.0258445907,
0.0482826978,
0.0054162862,
0.0061829621,
-0.0492345057,
-0.0231125448,
0.0111714974,
-0.0264301281,
-0.0597914346,
0.0026531662,
0.0061449842,
0.0046107899,
-0.0691605061,
-0.0083068777,
-0.0336194299,
-0.0006396442,
0.0496459082,
-0.0039030698,
-0.0121871736,
-0.0493181869,
0.0087823831,
-0.0259342473,
-0.0009814638,
0.008596316,
-0.0222684983,
0.0331999846,
-0.03510442,
-0.0419925377,
0.0418766849,
-0.0174752828,
-0.0045895875,
0.0774512962,
-0.0351881348,
-0.0272330344,
-0.0244098529,
-0.0029128096,
0.0099181859,
-0.0170075949,
0.0275382642,
-0.0032583924,
0.0187276602,
-0.0009684442,
-0.0244380068,
-0.0049326257,
0.0219627805,
0.0007155034,
-0.0366102159,
0.015186334,
-0.0021831945,
0.0169695653,
0.0474786721,
0.0020453199,
-0.0368615203,
0.0780002177,
-0.0678196549,
-0.0048696804,
-0.052997414,
-0.0850845277,
-0.0339668393,
0.0626197606,
-0.0288397782,
0.0287158061,
0.0141804321,
0.011882782,
-0.0067152167,
0.0062909764,
0.0053203488,
-0.042632889,
-0.0246477351,
-0.0467514992,
-0.0139092738,
-0.0011096245,
-0.0184897855,
-0.0177903511,
0.0001257183,
-0.0516579561,
-0.0140565364,
-0.0078478167,
-0.0492358394,
0.0136779165,
0.0352287814,
0.0668528005,
0.0345124081,
-0.0137970895,
0.0337937437,
-0.0221705846,
-0.0309624486,
0.0080819195,
0.0066175028,
0.018448906,
0.0074827005,
0.0263963658,
0.0527871549,
0.0070803361,
-0.0350792222,
0.0031133483,
-0.0234821718,
0.0279804654,
-0.0264713559,
0.0127906008,
0.023014091,
0.0228860565,
-0.0555035509,
-0.0075434856,
0.0457920469,
0.0114354631,
-0.0690213665,
-0.0089559974,
-0.0469161384,
-0.0000055083,
0.0118839247,
0.0459401496,
-0.1163317487,
0.0269582234,
0.005477156,
0.0420540012,
-0.0368229449,
-0.0351223499,
-0.0533625484,
-0.0730942562,
0.0798875019,
0.0066085602,
-0.0144006116,
-0.013636101,
-0.0859918445,
0.0140590323,
-0.0316403583,
-0.007287648,
-0.008791741,
0.0129290819,
0.0020206736,
-0.0155265052,
-0.0246760789,
-0.0130045153,
-0.018059222,
-0.0214432254,
0.0473358221,
0.0395896286,
-0.0093275104,
-0.0199317578,
-0.0331260897,
-0.0118408976,
0.0489370972,
-0.0087663671,
-0.0046257474,
-0.0288716685,
0.0278660636,
-0.0325034447,
-0.0092602391,
0.0687713102,
-0.0176040903,
-0.0264114738,
0.0348083004,
0.0696347132,
-0.0432508178,
0.0144743193,
-0.0276027117,
-0.0293774735,
0.0377810523,
0.0756555051,
-0.0000740435,
-0.0254755449,
-0.0493439771,
-0.0284312144,
0.0027792652,
-0.0061383187,
-0.0316412896,
0.0232479703,
-0.0194793865,
-0.0477087088,
0.0023773236,
-0.0128038069,
0.0078079384,
0.0108504295,
0.0207575932,
0.0087739835,
0.0468118712,
-0.0038106174,
-0.0433292538,
-0.007640677,
-0.0974681899,
0.0284968819,
-0.0078965398,
-0.0061559868,
0.0069118673,
-0.0275130179,
-0.0275219344,
0.0365068689,
0.0008006134,
-0.0728921294,
0.0565618686,
0.0718097761,
0.0279703233,
-0.0136253675,
-0.0231807847,
-0.0536635928,
0.1197323427,
0.0415534563,
-0.0681204498,
0.0051339096,
-0.0010268099,
-0.0398701839,
-0.0028356658,
0.0243925229,
-0.0346687958,
0.017423192,
0.021831749,
-0.010860038,
-0.0364019088,
-0.0468688011,
-0.0000459216,
0.0513918959,
-0.0070679514,
-0.0134500917,
0.0437707901,
-0.0373231247,
0.0510566682,
-0.0379169323,
0.0055517955,
-0.0227348097,
-0.0053654909,
0.0150718605,
-0.0281055328,
0.0505957082,
-0.0137257241,
0.035636466,
-0.0289668962,
0.0067043705,
0.0543526299,
0.016188411,
0.0175514799,
0.0235237367,
0.0069867172,
-0.0201465786,
0.0616308898,
-0.0423334427,
0.0369387381,
-0.0038377442,
0.0264643133,
-0.0070355069,
-0.0072530634,
-0.0413075723,
0.0648054108,
-0.0422359407,
-0.0734753609,
0.0027021698,
0.0251615308,
-0.0040014531,
0.0780603141,
-0.0066402568,
-0.0727618784,
-0.0089163119,
-0.021002965,
0.0056117568,
0.0114625208,
-0.046320606,
0.0056414818,
0.0352000669,
-0.0005354424,
-0.0015576438,
0.0496194512,
0.0279238466,
0.0516609959,
-0.0150115788,
-0.0069701602,
-0.0423682854,
-0.0363559686,
-0.0373496227,
0.0115608461,
-0.037418481,
-0.0393739454,
-0.0406279452,
-0.0410378166,
0.0060784719,
0.0116360746,
-0.0153746139,
-0.0086587612,
0.0160453655,
0.0438069291,
0.0063643153,
-0.0570536368,
-0.0383726805,
-0.0075757201,
-0.0129443416,
-0.046272859,
0.0124730226,
-6.638839445e-33,
0.0202984829,
-0.0302065555,
0.0117392829,
0.0202584434,
0.0610569306,
0.0068304124,
-0.0173376203,
-0.0094403299,
-0.0063501173,
0.0078214463,
0.01305696,
-0.0003171545,
0.0340468325,
0.0102161542,
0.0083660642,
0.049682647,
0.0116288085,
-0.006561304,
0.0151657397,
-0.0007747471,
0.0483897887,
0.0202754904,
0.0430912897,
-0.1097251698,
0.0416836552,
-0.046309799,
-0.0290923864,
0.0037596899,
-0.0845174491,
0.0460976511,
-0.0303168241,
0.0276590753,
-0.0137011912,
-0.0647330731,
-0.0033525398,
0.004741923,
-0.0245925281,
-0.018272981,
0.0154437339,
-0.0165126193,
0.0013419482,
-0.0813294053,
0.0290892869,
-0.0199909974,
-0.0286455452,
0.0367553346,
0.0071121207,
-0.0145470863,
0.0068143154,
0.0189480428,
0.0042165187,
0.0128610395,
-0.0082329269,
0.0526011176,
0.0752858669,
-0.0834046081,
-0.021142371,
-0.021387713,
-0.0219913255,
0.0636413321,
-0.0005634841,
-0.0152749689,
0.048142761,
0.0019810868,
-0.008136264,
0.0245288685,
0.0526148006,
-0.0241383892,
-0.0072999457,
-0.0247233678,
-0.0138199758,
0.0812083408,
0.0376481488,
0.0474245362,
-0.0233398173,
-0.0229528081,
-0.0340999775,
-0.0132970726,
0.0365628153,
0.0032573359,
0.0585703626,
0.0079142088,
-0.0361977927,
0.003582773,
-0.0126806069,
-0.0678097829,
-0.0453797542,
-0.02121385,
-0.0209896155,
0.0007465231,
-0.0498106442,
0.0225165747,
0.027181603,
-0.0540061332,
-0.0208013989,
0.0335428193,
0.0456250645,
-0.0085514523,
0.0078356378,
0.0221203398,
-0.0513753891,
-0.0013921906,
-0.0206943452,
-0.0458973795,
0.017826248,
-0.0033778043,
-0.0100483624,
0.0268042646,
-0.0462156869,
0.0082392041,
-0.0173749551,
0.010435489,
0.0587498322,
-0.0043944069,
0.0102889547,
-0.0211178884,
0.030961806,
0.0265058726,
0.0469928645,
0.0230995081,
0.0283148065,
0.0631553456,
-0.029306585,
-0.0098249447,
-0.0040352806,
0.0102041475,
-0.0315639116,
0.0208543949,
0.0514151752,
-0.0048608594,
0.0159123205,
-0.0217793342,
3.183e-7,
0.033433754,
0.0383429825,
0.0229476504,
-0.0060718432,
0.0344692767,
0.0192175973,
0.0273632817,
0.0302256104,
-0.0448607542,
-0.0183898285,
-0.0471695364,
0.029175669,
0.0555248708,
0.0300714392,
-0.0416133367,
-0.0298657026,
-0.0495800637,
0.0026648098,
-0.096683979,
-0.0127744004,
0.0200748295,
0.0717506856,
0.0284893494,
-0.004464461,
-0.0366806425,
-0.054486528,
-0.0196904149,
-0.0071855094,
0.0101571064,
0.0142338108,
-0.0053543067,
0.0621711165,
0.0124524198,
0.0156947821,
-0.0224217195,
0.0340804718,
-0.0817612708,
0.0749567747,
-0.0019789049,
0.0107489889,
0.0417469665,
-0.0411535241,
-0.0401296802,
-0.0141287073,
0.03900012,
0.0081292335,
-0.0659040362,
-0.0262852646,
0.0008199635,
-0.0493477024,
0.0056844,
-0.0298933201,
0.0314336196,
0.010102354,
-0.0103766816,
-0.0511183292,
-0.0009181662,
-0.0765018463,
-0.0062685017,
-0.0453682803,
-0.0422531366,
-0.0069502904,
-0.0213475749,
-0.0210192241,
0.0377969891,
-0.0253270306,
0.0646473393,
3.04452945e-34,
-0.0007401977,
-0.0030308235,
-0.0368900485,
0.0665315911,
0.0183238182,
-0.0163168851,
-0.0014249415,
0.0306082778,
0.014496387,
-0.0691286922,
-0.0186982006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01772v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01772v1 | Disentangling the Roles of Target-Side Transfer and Regularization in Multilingual Machine Translation | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | Yan Meng, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multilingual Machine Translation (MMT) benefits from knowledge transfer
across different language pairs. However, improvements in one-to-many
translation compared to many-to-one translation are only marginal and sometimes
even negligible. This performance discrepancy raises the question of to what
extent positive transfer plays a role on the target-side for one-to-many MT. In
this paper, we conduct a large-scale study that varies the auxiliary target
side languages along two dimensions, i.e., linguistic similarity and corpus
size, to show the dynamic impact of knowledge transfer on the main language
pairs. We show that linguistically similar auxiliary target languages exhibit
strong ability to transfer positive knowledge. With an increasing size of
similar target languages, the positive transfer is further enhanced to benefit
the main language pairs. Meanwhile, we find distant auxiliary target languages
can also unexpectedly benefit main language pairs, even with minimal positive
transfer ability. Apart from transfer, we show distant auxiliary target
languages can act as a regularizer to benefit translation performance by
enhancing the generalization and model inference calibration. | [
0.006520696,
0.0284543131,
-0.0277399085,
0.0248945914,
-0.0327106789,
0.0040898961,
0.0277960561,
0.0167825129,
-0.080705002,
0.0159143377,
-0.0511399619,
-0.0336050838,
0.017262958,
-0.0114249866,
0.0599783659,
-0.0501656272,
0.016151106,
-0.0253215805,
-0.0729220435,
-0.0044645001,
0.008392632,
-0.0000591099,
0.0358807072,
-0.0009079885,
0.0064481315,
0.0544622391,
0.0215158425,
0.0517874993,
0.0634496137,
0.0091661187,
-0.0548790209,
0.0079597365,
0.0149305807,
0.0448421761,
0.0000019313,
-0.0499649979,
-0.0586617887,
0.0131663801,
0.0078621656,
-0.0098299868,
0.0609226376,
-0.1097375154,
0.029679494,
-0.0155997472,
0.0127727808,
-0.0097684525,
0.0846179873,
-0.0087162117,
0.0223474093,
0.0840516686,
-0.0384368822,
-0.0194108449,
-0.0004217138,
-0.04207775,
-0.0049586082,
-0.0796672776,
-0.0083550168,
0.0273313671,
-0.0472251177,
-0.0146397362,
-0.0140321041,
0.0609363206,
-0.012857574,
0.0031829535,
-0.0023347212,
0.0003388709,
0.0019245273,
-0.0193953458,
0.0039754263,
0.0580887534,
-0.0354338102,
-0.0136480061,
-0.0144065162,
-0.0046409438,
-0.0091690561,
0.0422774851,
-0.0592404827,
0.0002051548,
0.0007215366,
-0.016613258,
0.0386111438,
0.0279597268,
0.039891392,
-0.0214399789,
-0.0498350225,
-0.0078848405,
0.0549203455,
-0.0370455347,
0.0337918736,
0.0665455088,
0.0043762536,
-0.0168871433,
0.0529293455,
-0.0058128233,
0.0314205401,
0.0136364885,
-0.0301536676,
-0.0555814914,
-0.0228358097,
-0.0218582302,
0.0467174686,
0.0578401424,
-0.035814181,
0.033189889,
-0.0372934192,
0.0084124925,
-0.0497865118,
0.0298956875,
-0.0720451325,
-0.0413726903,
-0.0526019298,
0.0255682021,
-0.0264379065,
-0.0005583921,
0.0164012946,
0.0405740291,
-0.0098333955,
0.0045512011,
0.0118571911,
-0.0375389904,
-0.0174025223,
-0.0734725744,
-0.0794555545,
-0.044855088,
0.0242657475,
0.08201278,
-0.0302662794,
-0.0045062252,
-0.0157933179,
-0.044415988,
-0.0349962451,
0.0265698433,
0.0226528756,
-0.0638156235,
-0.0084864004,
0.0973726735,
-0.0393992066,
-0.0065959669,
-0.0007556921,
0.0090302657,
-0.0017848819,
-0.0694098473,
0.0050833761,
-0.0293179601,
0.0864465833,
0.0228410587,
0.0247777775,
-0.0437847339,
-0.0427048467,
-0.0410787724,
-0.0389555097,
0.0250386074,
0.0021162981,
0.0033754956,
0.0195525698,
-0.0314366259,
-0.0537755564,
0.0635123774,
0.0197849814,
-0.0168200061,
0.0436693728,
-0.021124946,
-0.0423058905,
0.0563287288,
0.0204410888,
0.0493298545,
-0.0243801195,
0.0007431536,
0.0154992072,
0.0277396813,
0.0449570455,
0.0366635509,
-0.0359608531,
0.0318004526,
0.0677412674,
0.0215871241,
-0.006662237,
0.0347169824,
0.0489131436,
-0.0138228545,
-0.051645726,
0.0180249475,
0.0156508759,
0.0249377806,
-0.0220826957,
-0.0325420275,
0.0200089794,
0.0468978211,
-0.0095657278,
0.029575957,
0.0129472604,
-0.030941667,
0.0114005608,
-0.0427005142,
0.0811648592,
-0.0030776185,
-0.0389672332,
0.0450088121,
0.0143480645,
-0.0447261818,
0.0374263525,
-0.010645424,
-0.0149698704,
0.0024712412,
-0.0094026709,
0.0198627915,
-0.0544980504,
-0.0054450273,
-0.0262904335,
0.0313449688,
0.0955600217,
0.0120038576,
0.0608997345,
-0.0258797966,
-0.0170872211,
0.0071382453,
0.0045568836,
0.078397952,
-0.0282898396,
0.0496342629,
0.0386142209,
-0.0465537645,
-0.0233938154,
0.0072265491,
-0.0498964638,
0.0274814572,
0.0111689419,
0.0230611172,
0.0158765372,
-0.0000104937,
-0.0107494704,
-0.0137423733,
-0.021860078,
-0.0477845781,
-0.0271275882,
0.0646360368,
-0.0217157546,
-0.006954791,
0.009052325,
-0.0205266476,
0.0225114897,
0.0307996105,
-0.0057673822,
-0.0350578539,
0.0365080349,
-0.0099217696,
0.0145752886,
-0.0108683202,
0.0412577577,
-0.0089599872,
0.0139293438,
-0.0141199064,
0.0146921808,
0.0352465063,
-0.0157613847,
-0.004796329,
-0.0784831792,
0.0206598751,
-0.0279411264,
-0.0103060296,
0.0261214115,
0.0272587929,
0.004720015,
0.0477164537,
-0.0174778942,
-0.0076968982,
0.0003335751,
-0.027351182,
0.0150032509,
-0.0072645806,
0.0469675958,
0.0449326709,
0.0453004353,
0.027254153,
0.0218430031,
-0.0192363542,
0.0164523497,
0.0097565083,
0.035494227,
0.0043148436,
0.0126498286,
0.0233452525,
-0.0234744474,
-0.0102803661,
0.037809547,
0.0415111147,
0.0142140063,
-0.048027698,
-0.0683385432,
0.0234127901,
-0.0688207373,
-0.0174462553,
-0.0088834427,
-0.0195272416,
-0.0256340522,
-0.0264784861,
0.008777312,
0.0125765596,
-0.0451833867,
-0.0358756036,
0.0208654664,
-0.0106574409,
-0.0501848236,
0.0107001914,
-0.0033889748,
-0.0419023335,
-0.0525531024,
-0.0535322353,
0.0145060476,
0.068792291,
-0.0026545927,
-0.0502880402,
-0.0594812632,
-0.0224324018,
-0.0133976964,
-0.014802699,
-0.0219935402,
0.0449069776,
0.0395299681,
0.0574543625,
-0.0181443859,
-0.0562431365,
0.0468036346,
-0.0120731806,
-0.0153979091,
-0.018378213,
0.0033598063,
-0.0134695768,
0.0439907238,
-0.0284381118,
0.0263601132,
-0.0327553377,
0.0053521674,
-0.0447135307,
0.0014534312,
0.0364681669,
0.0245260149,
0.0475282259,
-0.0864427835,
-0.0101702036,
-0.0163062885,
-0.0161186252,
0.0049147429,
0.0019839786,
0.0107275434,
-0.0161956549,
0.0269835014,
-0.026429737,
-0.0420857593,
0.0102986507,
0.0273906179,
0.0310143791,
0.0041820956,
0.0069473446,
0.0098031852,
0.0276299231,
0.001038608,
-0.0051964386,
-0.0117816031,
-0.0805804506,
0.0108862091,
-0.0001331975,
-0.0063140136,
-0.0271090697,
-0.0009181993,
-0.0390856378,
0.0573716015,
0.0012145584,
-0.0629279613,
-0.0236135572,
0.0859264657,
-0.0102567365,
0.0085966978,
0.055800356,
-0.0066194595,
-0.033535134,
0.004833871,
-0.0273724403,
0.0296148006,
0.0044961921,
0.0397148244,
-0.0646900386,
-0.0237997994,
0.0044564134,
0.0091318181,
0.0368122719,
0.0026420439,
-0.0425373465,
-0.092568025,
-0.0301333796,
0.0220817495,
-0.0959110782,
-0.0350141153,
-0.0061061294,
-0.0262991954,
-0.0272848699,
0.0036657755,
-0.005059001,
0.0239468832,
-0.004549202,
0.0030714716,
0.030383369,
-0.0345520452,
-0.0055919527,
-0.0635820776,
0.011868841,
0.0492942929,
0.0378649235,
-0.0284925885,
-0.0022421461,
0.0386191159,
0.0259782616,
0.0094079934,
-0.0100743147,
0.0320174024,
0.0174347963,
-0.0123256398,
0.0562013909,
-0.0089408616,
0.0009076521,
0.0316375792,
0.0319775529,
0.0606983267,
0.0320256092,
-0.0394605733,
0.0390886106,
-0.0239056312,
-0.0226061735,
0.0413018912,
-0.0225676596,
-0.0442049019,
0.0246008057,
-0.0060007507,
-0.0222955365,
-0.0555803962,
0.0051293597,
-0.0086262207,
-0.0789141953,
-0.0909824744,
-0.083699137,
-0.0317087956,
0.0166395511,
0.0465016849,
0.0309521221,
0.0045980704,
-0.0162324719,
-0.0006274952,
0.039204441,
0.0283165537,
-0.046055451,
0.0256922431,
0.0007525937,
-0.0168082099,
-0.0012682172,
-0.0446349792,
0.0080294544,
-0.0032532325,
-0.108002238,
-0.0619213469,
-0.07168632,
0.0539234318,
0.0128813991,
0.0378407501,
0.0239146966,
-0.0224630702,
-0.0542205162,
-0.0154679837,
-0.0206868798,
-0.0068365857,
0.0453200825,
-0.0291769262,
0.0023601109,
0.0529747531,
-0.0320584811,
0.0050167535,
0.0318783559,
0.0360316634,
-0.0120821251,
-0.0224179756,
0.0050164768,
0.0342205353,
0.0268993583,
-0.0361952037,
-0.0495983213,
-0.0263344552,
0.0042964383,
-0.0169369355,
-0.0002623985,
-0.0498424433,
-0.0220483765,
0.0755488724,
0.0265987851,
0.0060853302,
-0.0448720269,
-0.015934078,
0.0067760376,
-0.0242627561,
-0.005282226,
-0.0100197401,
0.0508245602,
0.0394966118,
0.0419660881,
-0.0145074548,
-0.0051620784,
-0.0024266383,
0.011072359,
-0.0484097451,
0.0154011846,
-0.001528699,
0.0500142016,
0.0272538252,
-0.006276587,
-0.0280545168,
-0.0121803833,
0.0214560498,
-0.0109322723,
0.0803141072,
0.0102214329,
0.1352738291,
0.0170679204,
-0.0049339882,
-0.0149875805,
0.062989682,
-0.0182746984,
-0.0319703743,
0.0074267453,
-0.0318935029,
0.0097031519,
0.0282545909,
0.0791651458,
-0.0450630225,
0.0255579818,
-0.0535745919,
-0.0063232398,
-0.0002491546,
0.0035559223,
0.0498100817,
-0.0081898971,
0.0073425309,
0.0167315062,
-0.0226193219,
-0.061904192,
0.0091705108,
-0.0578996725,
0.0128086545,
0.0119159045,
-0.0066095875,
0.0995882228,
-0.0611256137,
-0.013153608,
-0.045608785,
-0.0171054453,
0.0127530275,
0.0271921586,
0.0119381929,
-6.075473125e-33,
-0.0075338953,
0.0325987451,
0.0026956266,
-0.0325583555,
-0.014964642,
-0.0350783765,
-0.0102909412,
-0.0089926105,
-0.0018754425,
0.0058591031,
-0.0033156616,
-0.0200449657,
0.0195730142,
-0.0013350601,
0.0245574322,
0.0065436712,
0.0381371267,
0.0404818431,
-0.011206626,
0.02207545,
0.0370997079,
0.032727208,
0.1292907596,
-0.0542122982,
0.0692527741,
-0.002591382,
0.0126203634,
-0.0080609564,
0.0319718979,
-0.0105084116,
0.0282190479,
0.0068184156,
0.0212606452,
-0.0451168194,
-0.0261604022,
-0.0558892824,
-0.0416281112,
-0.0091033271,
0.0494909547,
0.0179649051,
0.0357461497,
-0.0783585161,
0.0169194955,
-0.0529962778,
0.0077889548,
-0.0435119122,
0.0149175031,
-0.0362107717,
-0.0290574133,
-0.0122759184,
-0.0841210932,
0.0304477029,
-0.0062861843,
0.0232565068,
0.0079155257,
0.0850086212,
-0.0069095469,
-0.0150093231,
-0.017377859,
0.0300855562,
-0.0299542043,
0.0236936808,
0.0784716159,
0.0042132125,
-0.0361365639,
-0.0181088205,
0.017117504,
0.002502878,
0.0570484996,
0.0351716243,
0.0199686382,
-0.0014642348,
0.0469878614,
0.0459915958,
0.0418079868,
-0.0224450361,
-0.0393463299,
0.0233407877,
-0.0008733982,
-0.0085206199,
0.0151614239,
0.0333541594,
-0.0025097423,
-0.0273266472,
-0.0316030607,
-0.0343727283,
-0.0074578198,
-0.0455052555,
0.0003449917,
0.0002381775,
-0.0105884923,
0.03522598,
0.1113199592,
-0.0086606015,
-0.0139425853,
0.0115521615,
-0.0450369157,
0.0030735799,
-0.0296762474,
0.0088821528,
-0.0469666757,
-0.0739831552,
-0.0105491057,
-0.0032040093,
0.0160519127,
-0.0120255761,
0.0481946692,
0.0203547217,
-0.0510489456,
-0.0048332154,
-0.0460016243,
-0.0237350017,
0.0022469782,
0.0291045196,
0.0055022156,
0.003307787,
-0.0168901384,
0.0339051597,
0.0509541333,
-0.0222532395,
-0.0219170097,
0.0106143933,
0.0212660842,
0.0167043619,
-0.0524757542,
0.0023897693,
-0.0106025152,
-0.0548969023,
0.0559163429,
-0.0425839238,
-0.0559407733,
-0.037141867,
2.729e-7,
0.0596529767,
0.0177557264,
-0.005232505,
0.0053920862,
-0.0132987788,
0.0161793586,
-0.0552107655,
0.0367932506,
0.0184765626,
0.0753972977,
0.0176254027,
0.0268413704,
0.0797622949,
0.0522096865,
-0.0400993004,
-0.0599388108,
0.0134964176,
0.0321692005,
-0.0147280963,
0.0005835702,
0.0156898052,
0.0637931824,
0.0046067731,
-0.0082272151,
0.002452167,
-0.055226367,
0.086324662,
-0.041823186,
-0.0128738862,
0.0243113302,
0.0542150848,
-0.0278554112,
-0.0477565527,
0.0157283749,
-0.019741958,
0.0191576537,
0.0612064004,
0.0810538903,
-0.0006628839,
0.0030427699,
0.0077777933,
-0.0283306744,
-0.0318843983,
-0.0109707648,
0.0322943255,
-0.0426459759,
-0.0081732171,
0.0081176804,
-0.0079191495,
0.0302977692,
0.0165471248,
-0.0344191827,
-0.0254283547,
0.0419030152,
0.0724854916,
0.0206415355,
-0.0618465282,
-0.0074305241,
-0.0244734604,
0.0268518012,
-0.0060545881,
-0.0635984316,
0.0044112699,
-0.0237648655,
0.022159839,
-0.015084615,
-0.0024176876,
2.140883551e-34,
0.0423206054,
0.0058369432,
0.0041428725,
-0.0357350111,
0.0480002314,
-0.0584828258,
-0.0289074294,
0.0222579557,
-0.0090614622,
-0.026723817,
-0.0136640556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00474v1 | SA-MDKIF: A Scalable and Adaptable Medical Domain Knowledge Injection Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | Tianhan Xu, Zhe Hu, Ling Chen, Bin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
performance in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their
effective application in the medical domain is hampered by a lack of medical
domain knowledge. In this study, we present SA-MDKIF, a scalable and adaptable
framework that aims to inject medical knowledge into general-purpose LLMs
through instruction tuning, thereby enabling adaptability for various
downstream tasks. SA-MDKIF consists of two stages: skill training and skill
adaptation. In the first stage, we define 12 basic medical skills and use
AdaLoRA to train these skills based on uniformly formatted instructional
datasets that we have constructed. In the next stage, we train the skill router
using task-specific downstream data and use this router to integrate the
acquired skills with LLMs during inference. Experimental results on 9 different
medical tasks show that SA-MDKIF improves performance by 10-20% compared to the
original LLMs. Notably, this improvement is particularly pronounced for unseen
medical tasks, showing an improvement of up to 30%. | [
0.061855603,
0.0453624539,
0.0074769696,
-0.0148047172,
-0.0126361633,
0.0400580615,
0.0221928451,
0.0088956729,
0.0341236927,
-0.0399646424,
-0.0297788009,
-0.0308477171,
-0.0028940826,
0.0250282772,
0.0385817699,
-0.0388633795,
0.0283424035,
-0.0121197803,
-0.0013112575,
0.0137727605,
-0.0269878022,
-0.0042340891,
-0.0505666062,
0.0360665061,
0.0267967544,
-0.0046044206,
0.0355237313,
-0.0190663468,
0.0047813933,
-0.0498360507,
-0.0073564695,
0.0211320743,
0.0217618477,
-0.0184332766,
0.0000020559,
-0.0479625016,
0.0083496505,
0.0370254815,
-0.0423505493,
-0.0316566341,
0.041611813,
-0.0590454675,
0.0002857912,
0.0366578437,
-0.0369645953,
-0.0455754995,
0.0280644931,
0.0546504967,
0.0571059994,
0.0991207063,
-0.0037288624,
-0.0148670217,
0.0638165027,
-0.0288803559,
0.0115261972,
-0.0391225256,
0.0617420897,
0.020869419,
0.0318013318,
0.0060681854,
0.0114017343,
0.0559535436,
-0.0155656338,
0.0151889892,
0.0349129513,
0.0418169126,
-0.0058774771,
-0.0043112682,
-0.0139200278,
0.0170409195,
-0.0193383563,
-0.0107216444,
0.0059244777,
-0.0007231797,
-0.0213983264,
0.0301765166,
-0.0631523803,
-0.0012292716,
-0.0118181631,
-0.0067460923,
0.0228244942,
-0.0311122555,
0.0392481126,
0.0201265533,
-0.0127588855,
0.0031476687,
0.0227825809,
-0.0336691737,
0.0218207054,
-0.012841302,
-0.0200820919,
-0.0235137083,
0.0380105451,
0.0599149205,
-0.0505245291,
0.0246158913,
-0.0521665551,
-0.0291314051,
0.0553691536,
-0.0634935871,
0.0535999238,
0.0062872237,
-0.0002653667,
0.0599370934,
-0.0371323749,
0.0021729374,
-0.0424357243,
0.0348203443,
-0.040345408,
-0.0043190261,
-0.071514748,
-0.0239035636,
0.0067717214,
-0.0014981489,
-0.0371966176,
-0.0142157124,
-0.0550569966,
0.0203298386,
0.0008424995,
-0.0150011675,
0.0383970514,
0.0250752959,
-0.0318898149,
-0.0009436344,
-0.0197774917,
0.0397299081,
0.0260380413,
0.0363588594,
-0.0382068492,
-0.0320919454,
-0.0073523605,
0.0073046414,
0.0212653577,
-0.020722311,
0.0453811474,
0.0695556402,
-0.0026091335,
-0.0136081344,
-0.0307768099,
-0.0185932498,
0.0014014546,
-0.0496582948,
0.0145911481,
-0.0581078231,
0.0268952753,
0.0163046401,
0.0117736049,
-0.0690951422,
0.0155149642,
0.0278676059,
-0.0772706419,
0.0923673064,
-0.0307402555,
0.0320407264,
0.0334468149,
0.0286565181,
-0.0035635363,
0.0520622283,
0.009794048,
-0.0627522692,
-0.0228705797,
-0.030540023,
-0.009988389,
0.0106828455,
0.0012466571,
-0.0392044075,
-0.0256756041,
0.0197168589,
0.0203412492,
0.0721847638,
-0.0126684383,
0.040496733,
0.0130526572,
0.029291179,
0.0271579381,
0.0531084612,
0.0519607216,
-0.0147962179,
0.036244005,
-0.0075275614,
0.0220700093,
-0.0433171466,
-0.0321073942,
-0.0055508399,
0.0346222445,
0.0024605587,
-0.0402745903,
0.0341577604,
-0.0267989058,
-0.0233282279,
-0.0390667841,
-0.0081558144,
-0.0381802283,
0.0147100696,
0.061885193,
0.0136320451,
-0.0231118035,
0.0594684929,
0.0846604556,
-0.0160540044,
0.0094605237,
-0.0520065986,
-0.0440531969,
0.0776982009,
0.0690032244,
-0.053272754,
-0.0686392784,
-0.0124172177,
0.0235234778,
0.0173918139,
0.0214623436,
-0.0196525939,
0.0109185679,
-0.0609995201,
-0.0013898526,
0.0554944277,
0.0270981714,
-0.0215271171,
0.0378828794,
0.0131931575,
-0.0131482352,
-0.0095278295,
-0.0218309406,
0.0667439178,
-0.087308079,
-0.0427937508,
0.0007715081,
-0.0087651527,
0.0249785297,
0.0198390521,
-0.014335528,
0.0224258471,
0.0394369066,
-0.039917402,
-0.01885329,
0.0125900339,
-0.0358566195,
-0.0313372239,
0.0316001587,
0.0035389424,
-0.0302898865,
-0.0130561879,
-0.0195851196,
-0.0204026215,
-0.0274942629,
-0.0191467386,
0.0287021529,
0.0050390894,
0.0301528387,
0.0206194296,
-0.0112054721,
-0.047105059,
0.0343206227,
0.0108402297,
-0.002402728,
0.0046693762,
-0.0087816287,
-0.0459749252,
-0.0056359773,
-0.0073731174,
-0.014799186,
-0.0012279791,
0.0286491662,
-0.0435040034,
0.0223983116,
-0.0283930898,
-0.0570064113,
-0.0972275361,
0.0101321293,
0.0224840529,
0.0189502314,
0.0245199203,
0.0240959357,
-0.0145067899,
-0.0136690913,
-0.0282447264,
-0.0283344723,
0.0067696916,
0.0237291735,
0.0145042874,
0.0174342841,
0.005617612,
0.0033377616,
0.0202139579,
-0.0509433523,
0.0008148032,
-0.0020372325,
0.0143035883,
-0.0212613046,
0.0197097659,
0.0075427322,
0.0198501162,
-0.0058862986,
-0.0114589976,
-0.0058798273,
-0.0036697362,
0.0330270194,
0.0647802725,
-0.0205682032,
0.0213864762,
0.031587936,
-0.0047274339,
-0.0047693639,
0.0186714344,
-0.0210218951,
-0.007083646,
-0.0538469441,
-0.0107799387,
-0.0070186127,
0.0844190195,
0.0059711332,
-0.0055687698,
-0.0207382422,
-0.0141609209,
-0.0419639386,
-0.0005788967,
-0.0313393697,
0.0179651268,
-0.050905589,
-0.0080349054,
-0.0034856731,
-0.0297190137,
0.0802631676,
-0.0231289826,
0.025266625,
-0.0876049548,
-0.0521550179,
-0.0478005372,
0.0110802539,
0.0007433727,
0.0020818284,
-0.0071012666,
-0.0139299212,
-0.0038909237,
0.0487082303,
-0.0150367236,
-0.0595179871,
0.0753056705,
-0.0464468226,
-0.0019105022,
-0.0011154625,
-0.0246651992,
-0.0570541807,
0.0176324192,
-0.0229187217,
0.0222514402,
0.0242688321,
-0.0014725274,
-0.0848722607,
0.0161670335,
0.0066652051,
0.0753959194,
0.0066060391,
0.0004224569,
-0.0161944106,
0.0209357515,
0.0185857695,
0.007744465,
-0.0344933271,
-0.002798198,
0.0262551047,
0.0497900508,
0.0152347526,
-0.014966242,
-0.0109806126,
0.0041507543,
0.0084676072,
-0.051455006,
0.0220016651,
0.0289970078,
0.0386330299,
-0.0913480744,
-0.0028890057,
0.1124623939,
0.0400585756,
-0.0669989213,
0.0025637129,
0.0201185271,
-0.0158511996,
0.0234362613,
0.0320500657,
-0.0536586642,
-0.05248373,
0.002463012,
0.0362868123,
-0.0160721205,
-0.0275099128,
0.0045304238,
-0.0784357563,
0.0347858369,
0.0024588685,
-0.0354946554,
-0.0502617285,
-0.0798091367,
0.0063694851,
-0.0181882847,
0.023457028,
-0.0164503548,
-0.0521451533,
-0.0096019199,
0.0438535623,
-0.0394857973,
-0.1387481093,
-0.0055376641,
-0.0311672539,
0.1021647453,
0.0250862837,
0.0129686147,
-0.00698076,
0.0081727337,
0.0245745368,
0.0297535527,
0.0183450785,
-0.019377118,
0.083294563,
-0.0108474083,
-0.0067152665,
-0.0343665034,
0.0361277983,
-0.0499452204,
-0.0339235552,
0.0084609259,
0.0997427553,
-0.0142201483,
0.0069969678,
-0.031844385,
-0.0249488,
0.0084094377,
0.0642953664,
-0.0137439594,
-0.0156779811,
0.0025849729,
0.0176960398,
0.0011843382,
0.0102357659,
-0.0497211032,
0.0479716435,
-0.059419062,
-0.0252887402,
-0.0405680649,
-0.021840252,
0.0764122009,
0.008276091,
0.0331092589,
0.0524602607,
0.0270937476,
-0.0030076725,
-0.0945065394,
0.0478533283,
-0.0038916217,
0.0269063916,
-0.0677924007,
-0.0663058311,
0.061486885,
-0.0215008799,
-0.0212863274,
0.0244422145,
-0.0426610187,
-0.0385078043,
-0.0121789929,
0.0425711051,
0.0198777877,
0.0478696786,
-0.0228865705,
-0.0215991214,
0.0392945409,
0.0421284847,
-0.0820434391,
-0.0110291084,
-0.0099891098,
-0.0296708904,
0.0147878118,
0.0091510098,
0.0056527345,
0.0142711168,
0.014272145,
0.0412015207,
0.0142093878,
0.0109184189,
0.0147883808,
0.0318424925,
0.0406772532,
0.0049653607,
-0.0023639523,
-0.0378082544,
0.03350088,
-0.0209404025,
0.0047918605,
-0.0318878703,
-0.0065499279,
0.0472644791,
0.0115002543,
-0.0067893271,
0.0086015165,
-0.0205250401,
-0.0303715412,
-0.0493957102,
0.0678181574,
0.0092321718,
0.0030451745,
0.0615174174,
0.0038281262,
0.0058953101,
-0.0100627458,
-0.0020336346,
0.0171869472,
-0.016174702,
0.0517923683,
-0.019444095,
0.019919578,
-0.0188867711,
0.0313823111,
-0.0488641448,
-0.0343514495,
-0.0047400626,
0.0502300747,
0.0392356031,
-0.0365049727,
0.0474869236,
-0.0294758957,
-0.0024858839,
-0.0074399905,
0.0005041957,
-0.0402992107,
0.0342550054,
0.0606533326,
0.020239437,
0.0166524556,
-0.0226008929,
0.0913790911,
0.0157988854,
0.0840361491,
-0.0157629196,
-0.0544281155,
-0.0466480032,
-0.0396807268,
0.0706169456,
0.0106549216,
-0.0859095678,
0.0321322568,
-0.0449652523,
-0.0697560832,
-0.0157949235,
-0.0392695293,
-0.0319162868,
-0.025776701,
0.0432134382,
0.0195057783,
0.0053348164,
-0.0269543063,
-0.0215103887,
0.04505248,
-0.015107682,
-0.0280250069,
0.0525603965,
-6.215927434e-33,
-0.0031903065,
-0.013006838,
0.0579771474,
-0.0148053989,
-0.0110537782,
0.0377222449,
-0.0076483469,
-0.0086539211,
-0.006126903,
0.0301142056,
-0.0141737778,
-0.0114492709,
0.0139561472,
0.03077971,
0.0207964163,
-0.0011478955,
0.0130305719,
0.0180936903,
0.0132302968,
0.0026469203,
-0.0178285893,
0.0595536754,
0.0500640087,
-0.0622587912,
-0.0199458897,
0.0220772959,
0.0356999971,
0.0100782625,
-0.0113939708,
0.0630558431,
-0.0410116166,
0.032629475,
0.0468978956,
-0.0359023698,
-0.0065903175,
0.0066601313,
-0.0769407004,
0.0047851461,
0.039640557,
-0.0013492376,
-0.0294269472,
-0.034422785,
0.0503781922,
-0.0022533913,
-0.0081579033,
-0.0093097184,
0.0231867041,
-0.0561421812,
-0.0184055734,
-0.0019551276,
-0.04839091,
0.0570821278,
0.0146861998,
-0.0226601623,
-0.0062295655,
-0.046303492,
-0.0191791244,
-0.0062768981,
-0.0348222181,
-0.0090989117,
0.034750659,
0.0594397038,
0.0089206472,
-0.0131555013,
-0.0084388219,
0.0363336913,
0.0212225635,
-0.0404717997,
-0.0109917205,
0.0020683701,
-0.0237372015,
0.0500820279,
0.0226700902,
-0.0054928092,
0.0175938755,
-0.0147552304,
-0.0810356066,
0.016375592,
-0.0358024761,
0.0781493932,
0.0100618554,
0.0056909188,
-0.0582683347,
-0.0044544837,
-0.0199065562,
0.023408277,
-0.0249796044,
-0.0239389241,
0.044235155,
0.0182123408,
-0.0108053023,
0.0293864124,
-0.0027856161,
-0.0364042632,
0.0191650502,
-0.0064119324,
0.0365270264,
0.0170547068,
-0.0523435138,
0.008583189,
-0.0918257013,
-0.036792133,
0.0262637734,
-0.0226506311,
0.0323864333,
-0.002076077,
0.0306886546,
-0.0121621899,
-0.0863367915,
-0.0270896424,
-0.0163821485,
-0.01055256,
0.0261583589,
0.0684375167,
0.0414455235,
0.0292721801,
-0.0069946498,
0.0414737873,
0.0062135495,
-0.0387161635,
-0.0393753238,
-0.0236072987,
0.0068977769,
-0.0230391193,
-0.0530958772,
0.0040644547,
-0.04392533,
0.0018996206,
0.0077421148,
-0.0638635829,
0.0004109784,
-0.0107671134,
2.841e-7,
0.088161774,
0.0790544897,
-0.0210549552,
0.0007126543,
0.0260082986,
-0.0086381184,
-0.0351772755,
0.0039959676,
0.0096433759,
0.0205225088,
0.0040054824,
0.0452361703,
0.0306062903,
0.0241310168,
-0.0868454501,
-0.0262827743,
-0.0264747702,
-0.0164762195,
-0.0239043031,
-0.0395702422,
0.0105562545,
0.0899072066,
-0.0243951976,
-0.0431861132,
0.0068542082,
-0.0363505818,
0.0297669284,
0.0000563537,
-0.0116700018,
0.0363959335,
-0.0086790295,
0.0192620531,
0.0223895144,
0.0703409389,
-0.0397245884,
-0.0093952008,
-0.0123805935,
0.1075272933,
-0.0644099638,
0.0475055948,
0.0273123644,
0.0021426717,
0.0028772035,
-0.0410873182,
0.0525812581,
-0.0649150237,
-0.0557629988,
-0.0284916572,
-0.0041212593,
-0.0193784535,
0.0263883341,
-0.0022368315,
-0.0241977628,
0.0128742782,
0.0385300443,
0.0012776165,
-0.0608044267,
-0.0738179833,
-0.0366612896,
0.0284363814,
-0.0367079265,
-0.045375023,
0.0098256161,
-0.0292855203,
0.0259037502,
-0.0755876228,
0.0261880662,
2.826363898e-34,
0.0129646836,
0.0308521967,
0.0128065702,
0.0518079735,
0.0266883597,
-0.0204714648,
0.0050575379,
0.0402944423,
0.0119932331,
-0.0884625316,
0.0018614833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00453v2 | Instruction Makes a Difference | 2024-02-01T09:43:30 | 2024-06-13T13:28:37 | Tosin Adewumi, Nudrat Habib, Lama Alkhaled, Elisa Barney | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce Instruction Document Visual Question Answering (iDocVQA) dataset
and Large Language Document (LLaDoc) model, for training Language-Vision (LV)
models for document analysis and predictions on document images, respectively.
Usually, deep neural networks for the DocVQA task are trained on datasets
lacking instructions. We show that using instruction-following datasets
improves performance. We compare performance across document-related datasets
using the recent state-of-the-art (SotA) Large Language and Vision Assistant
(LLaVA)1.5 as the base model. We also evaluate the performance of the derived
models for object hallucination using the Polling-based Object Probing
Evaluation (POPE) dataset. The results show that instruction-tuning performance
ranges from 11X to 32X of zero-shot performance and from 0.1% to 4.2% over
non-instruction (traditional task) finetuning. Despite the gains, these still
fall short of human performance (94.36%), implying there's much room for
improvement. | [
0.0000303178,
0.062308684,
0.0249754041,
0.0626954511,
-0.0034475517,
0.0274737887,
0.0156621952,
-0.0099185025,
0.0064210291,
-0.0406243838,
-0.0332456939,
-0.0444818661,
-0.0018824022,
-0.0090211015,
0.0042931312,
-0.0372442268,
0.0483282842,
-0.051686462,
-0.0377165005,
0.0080733579,
-0.0028266034,
0.0107817948,
-0.0227425192,
-0.0047650528,
-0.0188489594,
-0.0576224513,
-0.0331611447,
0.0081127528,
0.0063759978,
0.0100081209,
0.0273813512,
0.0594028421,
0.038063053,
0.0365546569,
0.0000019993,
-0.0255230907,
0.0176715162,
0.0046768016,
-0.0315797739,
-0.0075353845,
0.0406892486,
-0.0505221821,
-0.0100467214,
-0.0190479178,
-0.0132474927,
-0.0214201771,
0.0393594913,
0.0568670072,
0.0550778918,
0.062288247,
-0.0303790122,
-0.0330097452,
0.0697768331,
-0.0057287593,
0.0625621751,
-0.046501305,
0.0024070533,
0.0110301655,
-0.0069408552,
0.0165986549,
-0.0134582398,
0.0261418875,
0.0736146495,
-0.0195013937,
-0.0067957453,
0.0297729541,
-0.0519597493,
-0.0216542333,
-0.0108022699,
0.0910333171,
-0.0271109622,
0.007259354,
-0.0326964185,
0.0065873265,
0.0058073374,
-0.0219258536,
-0.0435369983,
0.0121195894,
-0.0136014633,
0.0097341975,
0.0212203953,
-0.0309444554,
0.0082461946,
0.0248715095,
-0.0134536214,
0.0224266294,
0.0111413291,
-0.0159092788,
0.0434850641,
0.0171527006,
-0.0443205908,
-0.0336245559,
-0.0053689331,
0.0509168506,
-0.0247941148,
-0.0108286617,
-0.0508451276,
-0.0310337581,
0.0134018371,
-0.0497001037,
0.0599043742,
0.0007732203,
-0.0901563913,
0.0816979781,
-0.0691970736,
0.0711680576,
-0.0329354629,
0.0846102908,
-0.0279916879,
0.0106397299,
-0.015704032,
0.0037915818,
-0.0428290218,
0.0082393689,
-0.0302999876,
-0.0406778902,
0.0126206903,
0.0037084133,
-0.0034004098,
0.0165028982,
-0.0146292951,
0.0446280614,
-0.0321628675,
-0.0397271402,
-0.0174817946,
0.0110420911,
-0.0257693492,
0.0201449022,
-0.014279603,
-0.0596952327,
-0.0210964028,
0.0244502984,
0.0153811788,
0.004369963,
0.0359003805,
0.0395400673,
-0.0382232666,
-0.0281607807,
-0.0247070137,
-0.0105344588,
0.0337172896,
-0.0604372732,
0.0706200451,
-0.0642393157,
0.0349048004,
-0.018668117,
-0.0042238724,
-0.0097030234,
-0.001840014,
0.0370890275,
0.0006660897,
0.0837467909,
-0.0203065518,
-0.0323935747,
0.015871169,
0.0346132927,
0.0167126171,
0.0494589731,
-0.0087904911,
0.0359958932,
0.0185216274,
-0.002884184,
0.0474138223,
0.0379058868,
-0.0245419443,
0.0125946356,
-0.0013520623,
0.0149857933,
-0.0137067009,
0.0107997628,
0.036581669,
0.0278774053,
-0.0126083232,
-0.0661390498,
0.030840382,
0.0436236933,
-0.0132401837,
-0.0198061075,
-0.0024126745,
0.0200295132,
0.0250090193,
0.0248410497,
-0.0675237477,
0.0440410748,
0.0403895378,
0.0032203037,
-0.0169341266,
-0.0452486761,
-0.0572603829,
-0.0285743978,
-0.0049753021,
-0.0082369605,
0.0051942538,
0.0235229712,
0.0349417776,
0.0266943537,
-0.0819732025,
-0.0086007267,
0.001853641,
-0.0011529587,
-0.0339983292,
-0.0585108846,
0.05248373,
0.0844940096,
0.0444083065,
-0.0433253944,
-0.0142946374,
0.0017354899,
0.0862292275,
0.0573179498,
0.0462244898,
0.0077342037,
0.0526495427,
-0.0596272871,
-0.0110157337,
-0.0458335988,
0.0022827035,
0.0354891904,
0.0065971231,
0.0032892786,
0.0145690087,
-0.0283776578,
-0.0380911902,
0.0581263565,
0.0226270799,
-0.0488778353,
-0.0263195205,
0.0166637618,
-0.0076042591,
-0.0067102904,
-0.0000252052,
-0.0112617481,
0.0182172563,
-0.0367939211,
0.0395796858,
-0.0422933213,
-0.0443205312,
-0.0032112284,
0.0153846871,
-0.0284345858,
-0.0003777094,
0.0369341895,
-0.0381389074,
-0.0261257663,
-0.0092107542,
-0.0366694517,
-0.0135601163,
-0.0296466593,
-0.0062631518,
0.0106628565,
0.0505864434,
-0.0098699098,
0.0343578197,
-0.0232355893,
0.0254959799,
0.0435329489,
0.048132617,
0.0331926048,
-0.0135921398,
0.0092596617,
-0.0148558514,
0.0023462679,
-0.0096977931,
-0.0264872368,
0.0219544731,
-0.0680361316,
-0.0060267849,
-0.0750753209,
0.0135901496,
-0.0289982185,
0.0101399152,
0.025129037,
-0.0156752747,
-0.0012962006,
-0.0462233052,
-0.0521036312,
0.023681609,
-0.0139718307,
0.0340278782,
0.0137554826,
-0.0186011735,
0.0030841362,
-0.0354715995,
-0.030187631,
0.0022554011,
0.00842789,
0.008064203,
-0.0034246701,
-0.0543848164,
0.0432686061,
0.0061793127,
0.0615394823,
-0.0189202148,
-0.0517003462,
0.0292548332,
-0.0352906398,
0.0334304273,
0.140208751,
-0.0309418049,
0.031186603,
0.0246444289,
-0.0076398677,
-0.0303208493,
-0.013004343,
0.0342388004,
0.004244837,
0.0016848663,
-0.0151153868,
-0.0354031064,
0.0359050184,
-0.0132896379,
0.0259743612,
-0.0322706886,
0.0040109842,
-0.0108896308,
-0.0345575474,
-0.0323328786,
0.0168261509,
0.0115787238,
0.0306320079,
-0.0416240655,
-0.0439708233,
0.0418617353,
-0.0224855673,
-0.0325045027,
-0.0109949093,
0.0394938253,
0.0017098044,
0.0298448019,
0.0555744544,
-0.0063938736,
-0.0826578662,
-0.0295895673,
-0.0634874552,
0.0031547591,
-0.0264532659,
-0.0376564339,
0.0083147539,
-0.0332921557,
0.0067913448,
-0.0519291461,
-0.0072082281,
-0.041643627,
-0.0186533909,
-0.0008560378,
0.018325299,
-0.02082197,
-0.0053398102,
-0.0409529246,
0.0093544712,
0.0206784233,
0.0761856288,
-0.0307365544,
-0.0250521619,
-0.0384858288,
0.0582145229,
0.0713904202,
0.0047755796,
0.0171753094,
-0.0448856354,
0.0526701175,
0.0630458519,
0.0377782919,
0.0244102366,
-0.0583776236,
0.0237860195,
0.0025361441,
0.0220114291,
-0.0015542057,
0.005847224,
0.0518070944,
-0.1082905233,
-0.0241758358,
0.0732173398,
0.0314261951,
-0.055514086,
-0.0413744822,
-0.0197674558,
0.023503622,
0.0130560808,
0.0324368589,
-0.1001546681,
-0.0398821309,
-0.0121567864,
0.0112137506,
0.0199210476,
-0.0139679536,
-0.0027594159,
-0.0556858145,
0.0776948035,
-0.0193789862,
0.010879023,
-0.0392046645,
-0.0248142667,
0.0003587817,
0.0310542956,
0.0168881249,
-0.0213409737,
0.0125327818,
-0.035296578,
0.0052650087,
0.0257948674,
-0.0043405341,
0.0475358292,
-0.0171522051,
-0.0279530641,
0.0903347433,
0.0047950447,
0.0074639395,
-0.0462737642,
0.0395446308,
-0.0212057792,
0.0038041288,
0.0340921059,
0.0766850635,
-0.0060009314,
-0.0332034826,
-0.0031707652,
0.0646450073,
-0.0555299781,
-0.001200047,
-0.0284308624,
-0.0039782692,
-0.023322111,
-0.0122875096,
-0.0355743282,
-0.0221379176,
-0.0220691934,
0.040324457,
0.028059883,
-0.0343940556,
-0.058435943,
-0.007648855,
0.0364471078,
-0.0825245604,
0.005079431,
0.0290054716,
0.0065577845,
-0.00659328,
-0.0490214378,
-0.0634210259,
0.0524086207,
0.0200444777,
-0.0124510573,
-0.0457030572,
-0.0110541126,
-0.0118897026,
-0.0436106548,
0.059898328,
-0.0229611304,
0.0274274535,
-0.0654288158,
-0.0132411551,
0.0337834954,
0.0074484218,
-0.002838677,
0.020069465,
-0.1211457923,
-0.0261724889,
0.0246078279,
0.0402307473,
0.0085176164,
0.0505364314,
-0.0270868987,
-0.0607522279,
0.012792618,
0.0240295101,
-0.0284049325,
0.0089390157,
0.0136062456,
-0.0530843511,
0.0067058825,
0.0201235171,
-0.0442625545,
0.0271995105,
0.0200572461,
-0.0475452058,
-0.0190329961,
0.0289162472,
0.0045307628,
-0.0218605287,
-0.0283501763,
0.0128520951,
0.0354826748,
-0.0192053691,
0.0341763683,
0.0210800301,
-0.0084132152,
-0.0357236303,
-0.0108530642,
0.0189450197,
-0.0475953594,
-0.0158550516,
0.0262864958,
0.0135376062,
0.0044351737,
-0.040291965,
0.0063522304,
0.0311313141,
0.0099101588,
0.012344962,
0.0092644552,
-0.0324228704,
0.0334431045,
-0.0178398918,
0.0842707828,
0.0116212005,
0.081327714,
0.0169626828,
-0.0101027889,
-0.0336870812,
0.008179388,
-0.038517274,
-0.0732296258,
-0.0407947376,
0.0546219498,
0.0197627209,
-0.0460549705,
-0.0068400786,
-0.0222382918,
-0.0077278516,
-0.0042243134,
-0.0193967875,
0.0303311776,
-0.0107872067,
0.022520138,
0.053545095,
0.0524458028,
-0.0186177492,
0.081631735,
0.0281046256,
0.0354747884,
0.020414995,
0.0053418609,
-0.040343374,
-0.0062530073,
0.0124502257,
0.0179171506,
0.0139004299,
0.0392342918,
0.0445096567,
-0.0348633863,
-0.0395685136,
0.0132593336,
-0.0115239974,
0.0257608518,
0.0229153261,
0.0409061387,
0.0046755951,
-0.040900819,
-0.0097373007,
0.0157962348,
0.0020062863,
-0.0298736133,
-0.0019493334,
-5.861927311e-33,
-0.0150311971,
-0.0115643833,
0.01883303,
-0.0049192756,
0.0036493598,
-0.0001461733,
-0.0286474675,
-0.0125170602,
-0.0614620894,
0.0274422914,
-0.021357296,
0.052398745,
0.035219714,
0.0557860769,
-0.0028651545,
-0.045113828,
0.0197832678,
-0.0479802452,
0.0003490291,
0.017110765,
0.0126841618,
-0.0063402574,
0.0692095384,
-0.0508916825,
0.0289252028,
-0.0241091792,
0.0091047483,
0.0031330057,
0.00116925,
0.0468014926,
-0.0465674326,
0.0099147493,
0.0241926331,
-0.0028992635,
-0.0284895431,
0.0488937087,
-0.0880806968,
-0.0288007297,
-0.051407747,
0.0894197077,
-0.0808039084,
-0.0183670875,
0.0531273112,
0.0030817618,
0.0401405729,
-0.0280782282,
0.0225648042,
-0.0303736925,
-0.0079039773,
0.0353048779,
-0.0868958831,
0.0037777552,
-0.0229798108,
-0.0609011278,
0.0584495738,
0.0365276001,
-0.0023575854,
-0.0069024526,
-0.0896049887,
-0.0282720812,
0.0023324443,
0.0447049066,
0.0427675806,
0.0467293374,
-0.02236313,
0.0319368988,
0.0625601709,
0.0039106775,
-0.0118900258,
-0.027180424,
0.0500028357,
0.0524830706,
0.0626819283,
-0.026232928,
0.0813562348,
0.0487766117,
-0.0439637788,
0.0151465237,
-0.0245522931,
0.0603430234,
0.0371982642,
-0.0364410281,
-0.0218315125,
-0.007943267,
-0.0083361119,
0.0051227058,
-0.0472060964,
0.0091975052,
0.0608890913,
0.0059225699,
0.0046979403,
0.0069098743,
0.0627989918,
-0.0351618901,
0.0083170366,
0.0320735015,
-0.0483238846,
0.0366955064,
-0.0095276302,
0.0064607603,
-0.0462436303,
-0.0129018091,
0.0510333627,
0.0092021888,
0.0037279937,
0.0250940323,
0.0393958464,
-0.014247315,
-0.0617237799,
-0.0200982727,
-0.0453685336,
0.0189606808,
0.0433977433,
0.0673439503,
0.0267836135,
-0.0358437449,
-0.0309330784,
0.0669343621,
-0.0306695998,
0.0002104894,
-0.0063508996,
-0.0374137536,
-0.017961299,
0.0204488505,
-0.0107050287,
-0.0256659277,
-0.0515543036,
-0.016105609,
-0.0145954909,
-0.0633837953,
0.0056611234,
0.0555194318,
2.598e-7,
0.0130782733,
0.0199182816,
0.0435021929,
0.0383860655,
0.0116560124,
0.0090040937,
0.0079423003,
0.0072946097,
0.0147232041,
-0.0686484948,
-0.0090422146,
0.0600322895,
0.0568876788,
0.0199797619,
-0.0711706951,
0.0020982749,
-0.0095407041,
0.0435163826,
-0.0692309588,
-0.0469841361,
0.0029249995,
0.0762632564,
-0.0368487239,
-0.0446758121,
0.0353295021,
-0.0330548175,
0.0471308157,
0.0126783587,
0.024308363,
0.0161166023,
0.0275631566,
0.0592834651,
-0.0079243761,
0.0392333232,
-0.0125280442,
0.0054038209,
0.0471325181,
0.0143833486,
-0.0235346761,
-0.0337777771,
-0.0056504696,
-0.0178828016,
0.007043981,
-0.0341876931,
0.1006007567,
-0.0220844094,
-0.0105185313,
-0.0039967909,
-0.0364373364,
-0.0257651974,
0.0276517682,
-0.0238426346,
0.0208678115,
0.0275057144,
0.0287375841,
-0.0654060245,
-0.0413791761,
-0.0384169109,
-0.0065671392,
-0.014220994,
-0.0121153155,
0.0054226378,
-0.0660951808,
0.0009291491,
0.0034034597,
-0.0428408831,
-0.0463413149,
1.980955937e-34,
0.0301924385,
-0.0022372564,
0.0398991369,
0.0462161191,
0.0053275982,
-0.0152373854,
0.0169178098,
-0.0122716883,
-0.0095573235,
-0.0827775076,
-0.0179546624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00446v1 | Improving Dialog Safety using Socially Aware Contrastive Learning | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | Souvik Das, Rohini K. Srihari | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art conversational AI systems raise concerns due to their
potential risks of generating unsafe, toxic, unethical, or dangerous content.
Previous works have developed datasets to teach conversational agents the
appropriate social paradigms to respond effectively to specifically designed
hazardous content. However, models trained on these adversarial datasets still
struggle to recognize subtle unsafe situations that appear naturally in
conversations or introduce an inappropriate response in a casual context. To
understand the extent of this problem, we study prosociality in both
adversarial and casual dialog contexts and audit the response quality of
general-purpose language models in terms of propensity to produce unsafe
content. We propose a dual-step fine-tuning process to address these issues
using a socially aware n-pair contrastive loss. Subsequently, we train a base
model that integrates prosocial behavior by leveraging datasets like Moral
Integrity Corpus (MIC) and ProsocialDialog. Experimental results on several
dialog datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in generating
socially appropriate responses. | [
0.0640391931,
0.0940646827,
-0.0274057295,
0.0404704697,
-0.0212515369,
0.0113166189,
0.0124141555,
-0.0138469739,
0.0237975717,
-0.0232014377,
-0.0506310686,
-0.0377781019,
-0.026700642,
0.0427775532,
0.0198871233,
-0.0526647381,
0.051754158,
0.0153787453,
0.0596508719,
-0.0152317472,
0.0421164967,
0.0189380758,
0.0088503668,
0.0113701141,
-0.0202009752,
0.0099640228,
-0.0040945294,
0.0167459492,
0.0646706596,
-0.0125127248,
0.0751485452,
0.0564843938,
0.015413695,
0.0407745391,
0.0000017585,
-0.036148034,
0.0335016064,
-0.0070312019,
-0.0016905862,
-0.0303481538,
0.0827490091,
-0.0244784635,
-0.0317583829,
0.0576748736,
-0.0742892995,
-0.0044694315,
0.0383622609,
0.0774166584,
0.0520717353,
0.0742556602,
-0.0064351079,
-0.0092252307,
0.0485197417,
-0.0185143482,
-0.054011263,
-0.030807985,
0.0262121633,
-0.0013365255,
-0.0487034246,
0.0154679613,
0.0114788562,
0.0032710182,
0.0122215282,
-0.0321101435,
0.0083686933,
0.0035833505,
-0.0274420083,
-0.0259624347,
-0.0346183218,
0.1042446047,
-0.0096813776,
-0.0048954394,
0.0134261725,
-0.0172462165,
0.0041576959,
-0.0345206074,
-0.0195212588,
0.0104211206,
-0.012724692,
0.0057004271,
0.013789122,
0.0355034024,
0.0149422409,
0.0610521175,
0.058522772,
-0.0315392688,
-0.0229633413,
0.0204628389,
0.0194731783,
-0.0151082948,
-0.0428042151,
-0.0164496433,
0.0249062479,
-0.0080863014,
-0.0431429334,
0.0177594926,
-0.0427222103,
-0.0139667839,
0.0595384352,
-0.0499488935,
0.0258241966,
-0.0023520815,
-0.0174492281,
0.0253806561,
0.0439615771,
0.0040883482,
0.0146987867,
0.0449923836,
-0.0124811977,
0.016940739,
0.0063295583,
0.0106645599,
-0.0256771985,
-0.0041279905,
-0.0572533533,
0.0440729856,
0.0000643858,
-0.0035606185,
-0.0644088611,
0.0096504921,
0.0047284933,
0.0310557671,
-0.0644781813,
-0.011909524,
-0.0150131285,
-0.0183733422,
-0.0366883613,
0.0380033776,
0.0207924489,
-0.0684294999,
-0.0232018083,
-0.0024979422,
-0.0028946663,
-0.0077640824,
0.0016160302,
0.1148929521,
-0.0132504879,
-0.0464964062,
-0.0248482674,
0.001665197,
-0.0538672805,
-0.0480164215,
-0.0017607509,
-0.0148655819,
0.0349535756,
-0.0404978991,
-0.0509731285,
-0.0672186464,
0.0341250598,
-0.0138532072,
-0.0153874466,
0.0713524744,
0.0116447313,
-0.0389516912,
0.0238093175,
0.0525081083,
-0.0456050448,
0.0650821403,
0.0446450748,
-0.0025851936,
0.0235334449,
-0.0118580731,
0.0083239311,
-0.0139309671,
0.0377552845,
0.0202496722,
-0.0174329095,
0.0205005128,
0.0022390271,
-0.0009548029,
0.0238846373,
0.0627969131,
-0.0262115933,
-0.0905132294,
0.0726249292,
0.051968839,
-0.0297388546,
0.046776209,
-0.0040659676,
0.044505287,
-0.0278098229,
0.0050427169,
-0.0574137047,
0.0216816366,
-0.0045979032,
-0.0506664738,
-0.0191770773,
0.0252727829,
-0.0306731053,
-0.0354225151,
0.0128294714,
-0.0214229301,
0.0808420628,
-0.0172178056,
-0.0044314968,
0.0369334519,
-0.0498018637,
-0.0641894192,
0.0454182997,
-0.0601057224,
-0.0054603876,
-0.0485638976,
0.0393511914,
0.0823528469,
0.0265456568,
-0.0182560161,
-0.0215745959,
-0.0710472614,
0.0099773211,
0.0186028257,
0.0226654056,
-0.0225779209,
0.0775489584,
-0.0500235409,
-0.021107303,
-0.00993664,
-0.0151166301,
0.0229740478,
-0.0021958896,
0.006115586,
0.0024462789,
0.0445907563,
-0.0435839184,
0.0193585046,
-0.0238034353,
-0.0152303707,
-0.0008766977,
-0.002063944,
0.0680617169,
-0.0137213673,
-0.005939126,
-0.0308873691,
0.0194948185,
0.0016671196,
-0.0218756814,
-0.0075165043,
-0.0635046363,
-0.0406633876,
0.0223500971,
-0.0619502179,
-0.0028786678,
0.0528935827,
-0.0480322018,
0.0262826923,
0.0126100061,
-0.0385112427,
0.0049223928,
-0.0252541136,
-0.028199492,
-0.0145088555,
0.0091112116,
-0.0077569829,
0.0631302744,
-0.036498338,
-0.0326536968,
-0.0084959287,
0.0307741165,
-0.018947605,
-0.0275484957,
0.0054462403,
-0.009033462,
-0.0182574838,
0.0628200918,
0.0248199198,
0.0231623072,
-0.0639305487,
-0.0349811912,
-0.0359204151,
-0.0267596599,
-0.0251622479,
0.0158683173,
0.0116382372,
-0.0329128467,
0.0035246275,
0.0020149783,
-0.0187272001,
0.0071326392,
0.0031613167,
0.0053626001,
0.0346354209,
0.0052461098,
0.0027934888,
-0.0557454377,
0.0028111297,
0.0027787886,
0.011333039,
0.0039043305,
-0.0088881301,
-0.0196271408,
0.0560476743,
-0.0321421623,
0.0524976514,
-0.0272653122,
-0.1046922654,
0.013351039,
0.0647644773,
0.0024243391,
0.1004323661,
0.0796885267,
0.0577330478,
0.0253793672,
0.0306621697,
-0.0465890616,
0.0203772783,
-0.0019602817,
0.0061528953,
-0.0293439422,
-0.0428187214,
-0.0404323339,
0.051839307,
-0.001242439,
0.018838618,
-0.0550061911,
0.026865365,
0.0203465056,
-0.0902510807,
0.036038436,
-0.0580193512,
-0.0112846792,
0.0013063328,
-0.0508323312,
-0.0364457704,
0.0728443712,
0.0302432831,
-0.0025023932,
-0.0116048446,
-0.0363818705,
0.011531136,
0.034376733,
-0.0185383689,
0.0079039559,
0.0077465256,
-0.025805233,
-0.0589474514,
-0.0486593358,
0.0425668843,
-0.0396298505,
0.0126497755,
-0.0240038056,
-0.0216191132,
0.014797356,
-0.0738724545,
-0.0476071499,
-0.053609591,
-0.0095483493,
0.0011912219,
-0.0002596339,
-0.0037700096,
0.0056120101,
-0.0204517636,
-0.0040672943,
-0.0025942249,
-0.0111126909,
0.008627506,
-0.0022080862,
0.0062897252,
0.061090678,
0.0096943472,
0.0434631333,
-0.0126633011,
0.0689825267,
0.0580039732,
0.021240145,
-0.0153427552,
-0.0215216149,
-0.0045468621,
-0.0125677995,
0.0686370805,
0.0157780405,
0.0230768155,
0.0436062366,
-0.0133231096,
-0.0055180383,
0.0476342998,
-0.0196640939,
-0.0072688446,
0.023802476,
0.0054885843,
0.0158963483,
0.0003720824,
-0.031856969,
-0.0473708622,
-0.0235194694,
-0.0126993936,
0.022783285,
-0.0436685458,
-0.0515280291,
0.0220458824,
-0.0589517169,
0.0309170876,
0.0225750655,
-0.036246758,
-0.0337728523,
-0.0087381443,
0.0016943017,
-0.0342715308,
0.0468860827,
-0.0133345639,
0.0181641318,
-0.0548043475,
0.0145905148,
0.0412217081,
-0.0202807747,
0.0207826309,
-0.0538837761,
0.087384209,
0.0623129234,
0.0694154575,
-0.0244948156,
-0.004172679,
-0.0098907519,
-0.0015475722,
-0.0159039497,
-0.002829239,
0.0626614615,
-0.04418559,
0.0013704344,
-0.0147490725,
0.0719409063,
-0.0053794328,
-0.0361203067,
-0.0103285862,
0.0205297545,
0.0014592945,
-0.0465639867,
-0.0253911875,
0.0685254037,
0.0740699545,
0.0513687581,
0.0239332542,
-0.0164392367,
0.0197693221,
-0.0312400125,
0.0115880277,
-0.0197667163,
-0.0020403855,
-0.0250921305,
0.0167116281,
-0.0436437614,
-0.0511088781,
-0.0646413192,
-0.0169731006,
-0.0215586107,
-0.0149266375,
-0.0623378605,
-0.0067068664,
0.0134484805,
-0.0150241097,
0.029109234,
-0.002664835,
0.0162438303,
0.0037856668,
0.0150876408,
-0.0011635253,
-0.0387312174,
-0.0266500004,
0.0258924309,
-0.0467248484,
-0.056038782,
0.0337746106,
0.0911837369,
0.011753126,
0.0388248675,
-0.0136819454,
-0.025097087,
0.0160069484,
0.0696450323,
-0.0612411089,
-0.0147142531,
0.0831441358,
0.0046801353,
0.0124189984,
0.0161405727,
-0.0135526294,
0.0042214384,
0.0470552333,
0.0115351807,
-0.0515377596,
-0.0375068374,
-0.0150607508,
-0.0306333918,
0.0444429144,
0.0217350367,
-0.0138134109,
-0.0450275317,
0.0013234649,
0.006001588,
-0.0185755454,
-0.0478940383,
0.0286233816,
0.0226745699,
-0.00324478,
-0.0238680393,
-0.018344488,
-0.0554447398,
0.0385479107,
-0.0267718453,
0.0173692256,
0.0566036627,
0.0471305922,
0.0037145815,
0.0114100967,
-0.0367012918,
0.0447394624,
0.0209391173,
0.0176490042,
0.0102735804,
0.0494765341,
0.028851483,
-0.0090311263,
0.0421506502,
0.0382753834,
-0.0480011813,
-0.0213161577,
-0.0655667782,
0.0180906542,
-0.0104933288,
0.0060492964,
0.0076776692,
-0.0308972467,
0.0145030702,
-0.0156423803,
0.0645682886,
-0.0194757972,
-0.0709624141,
0.0156265981,
0.0208086874,
-0.0187233556,
0.0256878026,
0.0549504012,
-0.0309525095,
0.0509365983,
0.0277695637,
-0.006120062,
-0.0138273146,
-0.0537397005,
0.0626352951,
-0.0009491246,
-0.0085705519,
0.0157171544,
-0.0529324524,
-0.0618116222,
-0.0212819297,
0.0079705929,
0.0130435647,
-0.025746379,
0.0226966497,
0.0359120369,
-0.0122547233,
-0.0005215602,
0.0077118999,
0.0048180041,
0.0229726974,
-0.0209235791,
-0.0415326804,
-5.521644471e-33,
0.0114597678,
-0.0419416577,
-0.038963832,
0.0163492206,
0.0021543156,
-0.000618409,
-0.0074746418,
-0.0087162927,
-0.0365232788,
0.039116703,
-0.003250794,
0.0749352574,
-0.0137255676,
-0.0088630067,
-0.0311209038,
-0.0817163289,
0.0217751563,
-0.0194229838,
-0.0147747351,
0.0407998636,
0.0122423563,
0.024590537,
0.0436851792,
-0.1075295433,
0.0169502478,
0.0171716735,
-0.0273888689,
0.0174885299,
0.000947805,
0.0246094447,
0.0185052045,
0.0562060438,
-0.0005965312,
0.0120691713,
0.0131091047,
0.0540936328,
-0.0356683731,
-0.0195835587,
0.0112338467,
-0.0424780175,
-0.0748168528,
-0.0464013852,
0.0162749682,
-0.0110282572,
-0.0077844039,
-0.040827591,
-0.003652052,
-0.0016194286,
0.0097809108,
-0.0093793198,
-0.0522314049,
-0.0011022425,
-0.0289859846,
-0.0585778356,
-0.0289794616,
0.0254651308,
0.0339205712,
0.0002556923,
0.0019986569,
0.0010154196,
-0.0041685104,
-0.0323132835,
0.008497241,
-0.0358060114,
-0.0123910885,
0.0671349391,
0.0130725736,
0.0604044572,
0.0159172714,
-0.0735884011,
-0.0068793106,
0.0492708981,
0.0517460927,
0.0913392305,
-0.0091085136,
-0.0549632907,
-0.0644293353,
-0.0006587502,
0.027807029,
0.0370599963,
-0.017126875,
-0.0158565082,
-0.0325622521,
-0.0172869973,
-0.0277447756,
-0.0544778779,
-0.0094674071,
-0.0114572337,
-0.0019568447,
-0.0124922208,
-0.0232170504,
-0.0309689529,
-0.0203405675,
-0.0503410324,
0.0260951519,
0.0592043772,
0.020256117,
-0.0302044451,
0.0058260504,
0.0372470208,
-0.0504468195,
-0.0272928346,
0.0409804136,
-0.0194861498,
0.0203535836,
-0.0068376516,
0.0792314783,
0.0348095335,
-0.0150775667,
-0.0005406246,
-0.0234961193,
0.0674931332,
0.0001123458,
0.0047852062,
-0.0067371815,
0.0285222586,
-0.0031211344,
0.0313998871,
0.0204453133,
-0.0029275485,
-0.0289998148,
-0.0228352174,
-0.034021318,
0.0373220146,
-0.0374855697,
-0.0196519103,
-0.0245749466,
-0.0265546665,
0.0372828804,
-0.0547966734,
-0.0174392052,
-0.0302231498,
2.504e-7,
-0.0250007659,
0.0375950448,
0.0386130698,
0.0312322769,
-0.0053827493,
0.0661254227,
0.0109945349,
0.1023640856,
0.0153612997,
-0.0334958769,
0.0351080149,
0.0260593742,
0.0800039396,
0.0490826331,
-0.0302140079,
-0.0081350412,
-0.1158600152,
-0.021748716,
-0.0027903584,
-0.028877398,
0.0370485969,
0.0871675164,
0.0229135677,
-0.0285961628,
0.0042476612,
-0.0126639847,
0.0276303217,
-0.0755386278,
0.0082989456,
-0.0121292295,
0.0138452621,
-0.024318805,
0.0107861152,
0.0375203043,
-0.014603423,
0.0133780986,
-0.0202272292,
0.0823196843,
-0.021082079,
-0.06068106,
0.0018716528,
-0.0284203533,
-0.0032483407,
-0.0053389515,
0.0366431326,
-0.0495676138,
-0.0174895637,
-0.01466446,
-0.0291888062,
-0.0268047936,
0.0196695309,
-0.0295827556,
-0.0231342074,
-0.0053471285,
0.0165822618,
0.0021929692,
0.0079184938,
-0.0337425098,
0.0047079325,
-0.0061500832,
0.0134945698,
-0.1048592031,
0.0071272319,
0.0251344107,
0.0123317512,
-0.0146439234,
0.0590601563,
1.712536853e-34,
0.0270268824,
-0.030424824,
-0.0062945751,
-0.0082693975,
0.0710691735,
0.0208500884,
-0.0151132746,
-0.0051805219,
0.0572050549,
-0.0044733328,
-0.0068889889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00421v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00421v2 | From PARIS to LE-PARIS: Toward Patent Response Automation with Recommender Systems and Collaborative Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T08:37:13 | 2024-03-05T03:45:22 | Jung-Mei Chu, Hao-Cheng Lo, Jieh Hsiang, Chun-Chieh Cho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | In patent prosecution, timely and effective responses to Office Actions (OAs)
are crucial for securing patents. However, past automation and artificial
intelligence research have largely overlooked this aspect. To bridge this gap,
our study introduces the Patent Office Action Response Intelligence System
(PARIS) and its advanced version, the Large Language Model (LLM) Enhanced PARIS
(LE-PARIS). These systems are designed to enhance the efficiency of patent
attorneys in handling OA responses through collaboration with AI. The systems'
key features include the construction of an OA Topics Database, development of
Response Templates, and implementation of Recommender Systems and LLM-based
Response Generation. To validate the effectiveness of the systems, we have
employed a multi-paradigm analysis using the USPTO Office Action database and
longitudinal data based on attorney interactions with our systems over six
years. Through five studies, we have examined the constructiveness of OA topics
(studies 1 and 2) using topic modeling and our proposed Delphi process, the
efficacy of our proposed hybrid LLM-based recommender system tailored for OA
responses (study 3), the quality of generated responses (study 4), and the
systems' practical value in real-world scenarios through user studies (study
5). The results indicate that both PARIS and LE-PARIS significantly achieve key
metrics and have a positive impact on attorney performance. | [
0.098137632,
0.0255710334,
-0.0279815104,
-0.0023804293,
-0.0745538548,
-0.0266734567,
0.03146144,
0.0075487676,
0.0236845873,
-0.0769404545,
-0.0208273549,
-0.0024392265,
-0.0458688363,
0.0381332785,
-0.0262278188,
-0.0120642073,
-0.0127173839,
-0.0140833091,
0.0507051945,
0.008067742,
0.0352661982,
0.0360331535,
-0.0184115209,
0.0659095868,
0.0242764782,
0.0117001869,
0.0123467194,
-0.035538666,
-0.0200783852,
-0.0670488775,
-0.0019570868,
0.0534685813,
0.0334710069,
0.0186760798,
0.0000019408,
-0.104039982,
-0.0096242139,
-0.0204483103,
0.0082119815,
0.0041651605,
0.0512306131,
0.0234083626,
-0.0066083684,
0.0325846747,
-0.0331252813,
0.0303632095,
-0.0249180514,
0.0393434204,
-0.0160503313,
0.0243595354,
-0.0312416758,
-0.0229525045,
0.0670813024,
-0.0235650837,
-0.0271508954,
-0.0458595231,
0.0238148905,
0.0126327593,
0.1079621911,
-0.0471977666,
0.0308718234,
-0.017181769,
-0.0279047154,
-0.0442955494,
0.0388254002,
-0.0024793691,
0.0063677276,
0.0103760883,
-0.0119148502,
0.0551734529,
0.100559704,
0.0328562744,
0.0010956491,
-0.0105083361,
0.0552680269,
0.0118940622,
-0.0292889867,
0.0355606861,
-0.0203046687,
-0.0077984631,
0.0365040228,
-0.0022860125,
-0.0375212356,
0.0119899875,
0.0235974304,
0.0463509262,
0.0062247198,
-0.0218051169,
-0.0066639315,
-0.0076323776,
0.0636831373,
-0.0820830315,
0.0640226901,
0.0515267998,
-0.0253801756,
0.0266884752,
0.004930228,
-0.0470109507,
0.0505800694,
-0.0723759681,
0.0754284635,
0.0041124555,
0.011938679,
0.0278533567,
-0.0245867223,
0.0144859059,
-0.0137310633,
0.0023872883,
-0.0193340611,
-0.031654641,
-0.1045838818,
-0.0141463466,
-0.0120169083,
0.0807372779,
-0.031841103,
-0.0128027853,
-0.0220389217,
0.0409096293,
-0.0492607467,
0.0306020528,
-0.0223747231,
0.0385375805,
0.0460391343,
-0.0539746508,
-0.1300772876,
0.0170017444,
-0.0559459478,
0.042076759,
-0.0216835216,
0.0137014966,
0.0352187045,
0.0266747829,
0.0065212315,
-0.0085126283,
-0.001430541,
0.0539596677,
-0.0023862873,
-0.0347483121,
-0.0379678421,
-0.0295633711,
0.0280767009,
-0.0023130693,
-0.0355082005,
-0.0783143491,
0.000296901,
0.0325347707,
-0.0527512766,
-0.0540542714,
-0.0049722763,
0.0048918165,
-0.0249686018,
0.0098698083,
-0.0036996179,
0.0233552586,
0.0243166648,
0.0219826344,
-0.0114181424,
-0.032889992,
-0.0184588544,
0.0479409844,
0.0090272408,
-0.0170519911,
0.0603145473,
0.0055782399,
-0.0344558358,
0.0099679744,
0.0166282244,
0.0499758609,
-0.0172825325,
0.0191745628,
0.0155489873,
0.0424764678,
-0.0210105088,
0.0443603173,
0.0538151227,
0.0755201951,
0.0226307269,
0.0506730601,
-0.016693458,
0.0113090007,
0.0017489695,
-0.0587777384,
0.0258661862,
0.0418274663,
-0.059187334,
-0.0216904636,
-0.022540655,
0.0144378021,
-0.0425053351,
-0.0632347986,
-0.0198215563,
0.0097648026,
0.0231409967,
0.0005404419,
0.0684515163,
0.0071015703,
-0.0148581006,
0.0044597457,
-0.0349519961,
0.017504856,
-0.0628877729,
-0.0548483506,
0.0195986498,
0.1001861021,
0.0329990648,
-0.0289119389,
0.0020248534,
-0.0257344656,
-0.0350677632,
0.0376670063,
0.0485313684,
-0.0015926303,
-0.0591263622,
-0.0281551462,
-0.0261359159,
-0.0031970306,
-0.0016845063,
0.0708339512,
-0.0434209444,
0.0246414486,
-0.0024891552,
-0.0181485936,
0.0403659754,
0.0073855342,
-0.0263946671,
-0.0341450386,
0.0204752069,
-0.0117744897,
0.0491630174,
0.0508945175,
0.0011747692,
0.0261062942,
0.0396540835,
-0.0110144122,
-0.0289246012,
0.0068415417,
0.0620163716,
0.0534022897,
0.0056822919,
0.007467737,
-0.02639433,
-0.0062377579,
0.0229741782,
-0.0178108998,
0.0107977781,
-0.01315613,
0.0010710026,
-0.041821558,
-0.0081606265,
-0.0045082462,
-0.0163906589,
-0.0198284537,
0.0301718768,
0.0270947814,
-0.0186923817,
0.0423377901,
-0.017266918,
0.0617054105,
-0.0478765443,
0.0107759777,
0.0007181433,
-0.014499302,
0.0072904234,
0.0396403112,
-0.0496464558,
-0.0116837462,
-0.0261882879,
-0.0961535648,
-0.0283481535,
-0.0084531382,
0.0127913961,
-0.0255810749,
-0.0040298817,
0.0057386509,
-0.0171461031,
-0.0305943098,
-0.0168799665,
0.0252963416,
-0.0087199239,
0.0372135416,
0.0063923197,
-0.0712669417,
-0.0187249091,
-0.0110634491,
-0.0189461429,
-0.0049399636,
0.0404432714,
-0.0284895394,
-0.0477022305,
0.025410343,
-0.0477600694,
0.0099402573,
0.0026719701,
0.0175743289,
0.0008522317,
-0.0245624296,
-0.0374797508,
0.0029353972,
0.0195946638,
0.0549550951,
0.0578482673,
0.0108708553,
-0.0696472228,
-0.0137874307,
0.0263386481,
0.031332165,
0.0071226056,
0.0046956162,
0.0365977325,
-0.0200543385,
-0.0142885903,
0.0243245549,
0.0062905191,
-0.0164565574,
0.0236817878,
-0.0113443891,
0.0172822736,
-0.0552187152,
0.0013273674,
0.0527060367,
0.0080891298,
-0.0487963818,
0.0726347044,
0.0245727394,
0.0283807926,
-0.0669115037,
-0.0317049138,
-0.02720768,
0.0716305673,
0.0029236404,
0.0015294882,
-0.0226789713,
-0.0275771189,
0.0177074615,
-0.0364479497,
0.0248983167,
-0.0195954908,
0.0307402685,
-0.0279034059,
0.0456811339,
-0.0024370626,
0.0021878995,
-0.0319972038,
-0.0213552918,
-0.0240465868,
0.0439507961,
0.0127848918,
0.0000262804,
-0.0366342776,
-0.0028852576,
0.0240644608,
0.0256518517,
0.053399805,
-0.0247185063,
0.0107429316,
0.0234795306,
0.0186075158,
-0.0268066153,
-0.0199161917,
0.0117383841,
0.0126067502,
0.0055359569,
0.0177363753,
-0.0378568582,
-0.050363943,
-0.0093822321,
-0.0074413149,
-0.0261969492,
0.0015496173,
0.040743269,
-0.0302736331,
0.0100434851,
0.0495634899,
0.0742598698,
0.0151311876,
0.0092986142,
0.0039992556,
-0.0158446394,
-0.0218580253,
0.0191001743,
0.0464914627,
-0.075363256,
0.031024646,
-0.0599750392,
-0.0022905841,
-0.0492509045,
-0.0284833722,
-0.0051618866,
-0.1132038832,
0.1055338904,
-0.010691002,
0.0294167921,
-0.0061562606,
-0.0170342419,
0.0102609321,
0.0251463261,
-0.038914822,
-0.0553382672,
0.0049105622,
-0.0344798602,
0.0023335787,
-0.0797570869,
0.0349320993,
0.0400299765,
-0.0387431681,
0.0273490846,
0.0652295053,
-0.0062962505,
-0.0173864383,
-0.0172739029,
-0.017647272,
0.0273391996,
0.028215237,
0.0166959185,
-0.0312003009,
0.0500319749,
0.0743910596,
-0.0181575213,
0.0108077778,
-0.0577151328,
-0.0174287222,
0.0539493635,
0.0856829658,
-0.0728986412,
0.0074297194,
-0.0555826984,
-0.0062294384,
0.0192920882,
0.0376266129,
-0.0026106231,
-0.0368212536,
-0.0261101425,
-0.0032698617,
-0.0208386183,
-0.0449088961,
0.046214439,
-0.0374861993,
-0.015955776,
0.026471341,
-0.0648373142,
-0.0319904312,
0.0038234044,
0.0090512726,
0.0131862331,
0.018052429,
-0.0075560859,
0.003507006,
0.0101118218,
0.0304006655,
0.0300481245,
0.0199499261,
-0.0248040371,
-0.0024433755,
0.014555457,
-0.00437098,
-0.0074280198,
0.0097923987,
0.0270764232,
-0.0439983197,
-0.0303854067,
0.0146306604,
0.0290259179,
-0.0157103371,
-0.0241629593,
-0.0661371052,
0.0570391007,
0.0246891081,
0.0200180467,
-0.0322456248,
0.0202540308,
-0.0232048016,
-0.0409435183,
-0.0313202366,
-0.0379028842,
0.0575399324,
0.0546607599,
0.0228341147,
0.0124943331,
-0.0618035123,
0.0324699469,
0.0656706989,
0.0093573509,
0.0255203992,
0.0204344671,
-0.0230479725,
-0.0098406812,
-0.0091467341,
0.0143562676,
-0.0392538384,
-0.0335264169,
-0.0039851428,
-0.0356019102,
-0.0055116401,
-0.0041790013,
-0.0406502113,
0.0082953088,
-0.0460346006,
0.0566136129,
0.0032886218,
0.0001687518,
0.0048277564,
-0.0115594305,
-0.0041293423,
0.0038340746,
0.0097617554,
0.0317649879,
-0.0320704766,
0.06076378,
-0.0263507962,
0.0128263459,
-0.0326604024,
0.0380956531,
-0.0249869823,
-0.0840347111,
-0.0070476658,
0.0551686175,
0.05626617,
0.0100434124,
-0.0283094663,
-0.0810740143,
0.0122041525,
-0.031113768,
0.0338153243,
-0.0215851162,
-0.0001743623,
0.0302662775,
0.034345001,
-0.0022809915,
-0.0027621705,
0.0165695548,
-0.0537134409,
-0.0116756978,
-0.0546272434,
-0.0171767566,
-0.0357957855,
-0.022532912,
0.013352273,
0.0389601178,
-0.0305305775,
-0.0447368808,
-0.0509058125,
0.0165257715,
0.0219329968,
-0.03806049,
-0.0070975958,
-0.0080739595,
0.0219984613,
0.0734293461,
0.0397818573,
-0.0253592655,
-0.0511168502,
0.0047396743,
-0.0449790806,
-0.0592849068,
-0.0393532142,
-5.335983955e-33,
0.0312771462,
-0.0791873708,
0.024810411,
0.0232578013,
0.0312350746,
-0.0558251441,
-0.0176053122,
0.0218982995,
0.0131883072,
0.0207278766,
-0.0432620086,
-0.003878179,
0.0119443219,
-0.0211587492,
0.0512070768,
0.029972326,
0.0219513588,
-0.005256129,
-0.0176996198,
-0.0138865001,
-0.0020628155,
-0.0004425364,
-0.0388470516,
-0.1002134532,
0.0298330095,
0.0314316414,
0.0110547775,
-0.0374436416,
-0.0472980626,
0.0813738778,
0.0136717027,
0.0514823683,
0.0282044671,
-0.0707912222,
0.009070986,
0.0258438848,
-0.0632281005,
0.0082002897,
-0.0248793419,
-0.0522387885,
0.027620174,
0.0056619467,
0.0095819663,
0.0103283366,
-0.058272168,
0.0507085398,
0.0539329052,
-0.0243802909,
-0.055545155,
-0.0260744113,
-0.0945530608,
0.022264488,
-0.007645708,
0.0353811234,
0.0418649949,
0.0179425292,
-0.0204523634,
0.0400805846,
-0.036163263,
0.0131003782,
-0.0399105586,
-0.0583929792,
0.0108254477,
-0.0452134497,
-0.0374935418,
0.0177515894,
0.0110666025,
0.0587276183,
-0.011835929,
-0.0244649593,
-0.0237734169,
0.083709605,
0.0270414054,
-0.0007151999,
-0.0157234725,
-0.007502378,
-0.0478667319,
0.060496334,
0.0216444936,
0.0048849783,
0.0390498862,
0.0097309239,
-0.0402402841,
-0.005478147,
0.0227515996,
-0.0070655285,
-0.0239487235,
-0.0156962052,
0.0092152897,
0.0060847937,
0.0091858432,
0.0050034388,
0.0388766825,
-0.0232733581,
0.0095410114,
-0.0253693182,
0.0142203281,
0.0537967607,
0.0077236979,
-0.0132258041,
-0.0738215372,
-0.0160805583,
-0.0282955486,
0.0052763261,
0.0078732986,
-0.0002059256,
-0.0141674764,
-0.0599745736,
-0.0231593065,
0.0171022508,
0.0052557723,
0.0120818308,
0.0057452051,
-0.0078808898,
-0.0247065946,
0.0242552105,
0.0347221866,
0.066854842,
0.0071023498,
-0.0370615534,
-0.0498518236,
-0.0592010245,
0.0034613397,
-0.0471209809,
-0.0156956352,
0.026134612,
0.0029028573,
0.0277603716,
0.0617811009,
0.026407158,
-0.0135553833,
-0.0087447166,
2.777e-7,
0.0563942902,
0.0534243025,
-0.0322293155,
0.0379183181,
0.0002831805,
0.0295873694,
0.0211033765,
0.035973832,
0.0461561307,
0.0262973774,
0.055558525,
-0.0392559841,
0.0004400348,
0.05964683,
-0.0543517694,
-0.0392316096,
-0.0158255827,
-0.0139028635,
-0.0766944811,
0.0557304621,
0.0890338942,
0.0078666257,
0.0042127063,
-0.0067598457,
-0.0273023862,
-0.0289835632,
0.0401246399,
-0.0255187918,
0.0149916969,
-0.0098643703,
0.1078978255,
-0.0494532213,
-0.0143045243,
0.0679865777,
-0.0252709407,
0.0387935974,
-0.0362179913,
-0.0098471362,
-0.0266299862,
-0.0007414162,
0.0109735318,
-0.0382185839,
0.0512939319,
-0.0352269039,
-0.0072245342,
0.0040821754,
-0.0284504555,
-0.0012575969,
-0.003864425,
-0.0153960614,
-0.0234778877,
0.0060425163,
0.0002509716,
-0.0190612301,
-0.0011019714,
-0.0128073534,
0.0141571574,
-0.0542490222,
0.065313153,
0.0056111519,
-0.0309884343,
-0.006314741,
-0.009155238,
-0.0004574227,
0.0521298461,
-0.0274699386,
0.0426683612,
2.046911731e-34,
0.0202144887,
-0.0253698695,
-0.0273881331,
0.0447187908,
0.0487745404,
0.034047734,
0.0347942561,
0.014860942,
0.0001080976,
-0.0740454048,
-0.0111729112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00414v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00414v1 | Prompt-Time Symbolic Knowledge Capture with Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | Tolga Çöplü, Arto Bendiken, Andrii Skomorokhov, Eduard Bateiko, Stephen Cobb, Joshua J. Bouw | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with user-specific knowledge is
crucial for real-world applications, such as personal AI assistants. However,
LLMs inherently lack mechanisms for prompt-driven knowledge capture. This paper
investigates utilizing the existing LLM capabilities to enable prompt-driven
knowledge capture, with a particular emphasis on knowledge graphs. We address
this challenge by focusing on prompt-to-triple (P2T) generation. We explore
three methods: zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, and fine-tuning, and
then assess their performance via a specialized synthetic dataset. Our code and
datasets are publicly available at https://github.com/HaltiaAI/paper-PTSKC. | [
0.015700426,
0.0389528014,
-0.0089498078,
0.0582304262,
-0.0541504286,
0.0015662333,
0.0009193582,
0.0041456386,
0.0467299111,
-0.0399520472,
-0.0068160202,
-0.0104952147,
-0.0095248092,
0.0316984206,
0.0386597551,
-0.0284716059,
0.04451105,
-0.0531052016,
0.0065812659,
-0.0205964502,
-0.0217558946,
0.0572133996,
-0.0137043251,
0.014880497,
-0.0285494998,
-0.0028408482,
-0.0359750651,
0.0023039097,
0.0058248816,
-0.0413033925,
-0.054872334,
0.0241338201,
0.0224716552,
0.0311196912,
0.0000020051,
-0.052941516,
-0.011346993,
-0.0130579453,
-0.0531109832,
-0.0080600595,
-0.006759868,
-0.0073932665,
0.0073577738,
0.0164988767,
-0.0483689867,
0.0038914101,
0.0008488907,
0.0005046077,
0.0519104823,
0.0445422307,
0.0044087684,
0.0325361155,
0.0186339896,
-0.0247137249,
0.0223124512,
-0.0318075381,
0.0250305925,
-0.0080891531,
0.0204270557,
-0.000512786,
0.0184006039,
0.0324705951,
0.0131771741,
-0.0046370397,
-0.0141504407,
0.0307460055,
-0.0247207452,
0.0075165192,
-0.044818569,
0.0935216323,
-0.0020400251,
-0.0128129479,
0.0098843453,
0.0075293551,
0.0183732361,
0.0077972631,
-0.0244929716,
0.0154283401,
-0.0527210422,
-0.0176197402,
0.0209423304,
-0.0222732816,
0.0161166899,
-0.0120668272,
-0.0240263361,
0.0466154106,
0.0457485467,
-0.0285929404,
0.0105884951,
-0.0215485319,
-0.027988581,
-0.0703846067,
-0.0154299336,
0.0395148918,
-0.038074322,
0.0239191465,
-0.0827051103,
0.0046285167,
0.0025981804,
0.0407713689,
0.0791979581,
0.0330940373,
-0.0081408201,
0.0526067466,
-0.056654688,
0.0441215374,
0.0007435511,
0.0430666134,
-0.0399146192,
-0.0264327545,
-0.0511060432,
0.0202312302,
-0.0572985709,
0.0459645987,
-0.0143391574,
-0.0116280401,
-0.0037527492,
0.0464590415,
0.0026017886,
0.0565371402,
0.0290632043,
-0.0048587155,
-0.0097677549,
-0.0044309692,
0.0162915569,
0.0222240593,
-0.0359223299,
0.0092336554,
0.0162382927,
-0.0522448383,
-0.0110019138,
0.0043831537,
0.033601258,
-0.0080928905,
0.0165227726,
0.0658025667,
0.001384079,
-0.0573507696,
-0.0226322375,
-0.0666071177,
0.0057782196,
-0.0714165568,
-0.0352525562,
-0.0475545004,
0.0951399803,
-0.0031916639,
-0.0276467334,
-0.0348340124,
0.021009095,
0.0143190809,
-0.0019236994,
0.0521919318,
-0.057983432,
0.0243679173,
-0.0021518203,
-0.0229892507,
-0.0522519872,
0.020291578,
0.0396614075,
0.038135916,
0.0451386683,
0.0067753843,
-0.0302072484,
0.0538142659,
0.0552266315,
0.0374633819,
-0.0134172123,
0.004970599,
0.0188869927,
0.0314050317,
0.0215810221,
0.0657492429,
-0.0104675237,
0.0267673284,
0.0618511066,
0.0534979142,
0.0116815371,
-0.0048355386,
0.1194513515,
0.0036538269,
0.0210491158,
-0.0559379756,
-0.0656695738,
0.0076169809,
-0.0454373695,
0.013913257,
-0.0272868685,
0.0464147851,
-0.0269323271,
0.0188217722,
0.0345669985,
-0.0145461652,
-0.0503013767,
0.031726446,
0.0368325301,
0.0233531091,
-0.0483518913,
0.0512097776,
0.0066618701,
-0.0551972613,
0.0079174368,
-0.0242485497,
0.0520758741,
0.1069261208,
0.0315052085,
0.0069361157,
-0.0064189094,
0.0057182345,
-0.0057371729,
-0.0170470309,
0.0415172316,
-0.0313403383,
-0.0030548107,
-0.0248135347,
-0.0345992781,
0.0050164605,
-0.018027775,
0.0631726012,
0.0343082435,
0.0181599334,
0.026268309,
-0.040482711,
0.0058545945,
0.0133138793,
-0.0673502162,
-0.0393282697,
0.0013953755,
0.0148451393,
0.0085450141,
0.0544776693,
-0.0009652462,
0.0113431392,
0.0328194052,
-0.0282113086,
-0.0096031306,
0.0258269552,
-0.0495909266,
-0.0374114998,
0.0474180318,
0.01455402,
-0.0254165083,
0.0136370976,
-0.0455740206,
-0.0535129309,
-0.0227975734,
-0.0007556126,
0.042113062,
-0.0247173235,
0.0016460506,
0.0545043349,
-0.008032959,
0.0199772995,
0.0634285286,
-0.0196931921,
-0.0396427736,
0.0681056455,
0.0379981697,
-0.0116796223,
-0.0212498419,
-0.0015630836,
0.0110516474,
0.0045029446,
0.0197355766,
-0.0004923979,
0.0226066094,
-0.0391178578,
0.0019926385,
-0.1083232611,
0.0205914229,
-0.0085108941,
0.0045743394,
0.0085615329,
0.0153480349,
-0.0303649399,
-0.0153990798,
-0.0549707636,
0.0258407407,
-0.0003513038,
0.0075000986,
0.0038891344,
0.0132425139,
-0.0371767767,
-0.0204327442,
0.0067559979,
-0.0227981806,
0.0174158718,
0.0074773459,
-0.0165568292,
-0.0435995571,
0.0256420411,
-0.0132741891,
0.0321279801,
-0.0108069666,
0.0074924771,
0.009076328,
-0.0683567896,
0.0231505707,
0.0262782555,
-0.010924587,
0.013280198,
0.0299398005,
-0.0124176173,
-0.0648395419,
-0.010438568,
-0.0159626715,
-0.0439963676,
0.0132159302,
-0.0110204443,
0.0148580587,
0.0395823754,
0.0284378547,
-0.0011287055,
-0.0799360648,
-0.0149397943,
0.0086165005,
-0.017710831,
-0.0529091544,
0.0008324819,
-0.0317700393,
0.0446224585,
-0.005391378,
-0.0207962096,
0.0731714442,
-0.0628549084,
0.021043133,
0.0088482173,
-0.0105404649,
-0.0263962876,
0.0863463283,
-0.0054323096,
0.0239398219,
-0.0005607741,
0.0070358654,
-0.0438822582,
0.0029845973,
-0.0011524186,
-0.0217574406,
0.0235114694,
-0.0592460036,
0.0228472967,
-0.0048251855,
-0.0389469489,
-0.0261935107,
-0.0480535068,
-0.0514030233,
0.0134949312,
-0.0109751597,
-0.0309244413,
0.0444117337,
-0.0227226932,
0.0185525883,
0.0580101945,
-0.019168755,
-0.0312983282,
-0.0556845292,
0.0201782193,
0.0704064369,
0.0115863755,
-0.0202215221,
-0.0162600651,
0.0401858948,
0.0333648063,
0.0573161319,
0.0201573651,
-0.008079662,
-0.0058066631,
0.0200718176,
-0.0472555012,
0.0076906634,
0.0302016418,
0.0245316382,
-0.0363869667,
0.0095623592,
0.114626959,
0.0152958436,
-0.0532343835,
0.0121323969,
-0.0020541274,
0.0147372847,
0.0222390722,
0.0277771596,
-0.1491917223,
-0.0503798723,
-0.0096996874,
0.0377580374,
0.0019919057,
-0.0714470521,
-0.0319371447,
-0.1786801368,
-0.0082660271,
0.0126623176,
-0.0291903205,
-0.0311701559,
0.0150220552,
0.0105242888,
0.0389191657,
-0.0047087641,
0.0111352783,
-0.0172165334,
-0.0047743944,
0.0154092889,
0.0134875672,
-0.0556236729,
0.0704684332,
-0.0259459596,
0.0619049147,
0.0060272599,
0.024040278,
0.0118186558,
0.003062563,
-0.0348307975,
0.0183003265,
0.0058722319,
0.0078532295,
0.0082882131,
-0.0225088168,
-0.0181288589,
0.0113629466,
0.0738567114,
-0.0763925165,
0.0085440436,
0.052599296,
0.0664087683,
-0.0068246908,
0.0015788294,
0.0108038774,
-0.0090233553,
0.0183775034,
0.0719445199,
0.033250507,
-0.0329393111,
0.0088779116,
-0.0110157337,
-0.0291517489,
-0.053903237,
-0.0014742272,
0.0336023867,
-0.0172884744,
0.0026397498,
-0.0812767893,
-0.0313870423,
0.0875707418,
0.0384217575,
0.0251486637,
0.0015912947,
-0.0200842936,
-0.023948133,
-0.0392606072,
0.0265639611,
-0.053811416,
0.0349967368,
-0.051102899,
-0.0243791528,
0.0061274078,
-0.0480002537,
-0.0066137859,
0.0124046793,
-0.0676038861,
-0.0509427972,
-0.0044013644,
0.0851022303,
0.0145463804,
0.080960393,
-0.0063756201,
0.0154835759,
0.0565334894,
0.0538314916,
-0.0221532211,
0.0024715452,
0.0012635603,
0.0245928727,
-0.0014143218,
0.0602420643,
-0.0796182826,
-0.0024834289,
-0.0272960383,
0.0199688599,
-0.0411331914,
-0.0445330851,
0.0436370149,
0.0733870417,
0.0159664229,
-0.0528097786,
-0.0065068547,
-0.0192772355,
0.0158596784,
-0.0494320989,
-0.0157917552,
-0.0752918348,
0.0009147497,
-0.0035167292,
-0.0522123314,
0.0283666272,
-0.0719754472,
0.0096277082,
0.0191001184,
-0.0304403547,
-0.0422092527,
0.007733007,
0.0405438468,
0.0848086476,
-0.0238707848,
-0.0573561713,
0.0326602794,
-0.0081836591,
0.0161840096,
-0.0491520166,
0.0657534823,
0.0349486805,
-0.0058288542,
-0.0204377137,
0.0536158681,
0.0007208383,
-0.0668066964,
0.0207639821,
0.0181448963,
0.086851269,
0.0209471043,
0.0391028784,
-0.0559684262,
0.0044479975,
-0.0084625091,
0.0428302288,
0.0127358539,
-0.0341384634,
0.025499586,
0.0177688599,
0.00995351,
0.0035287309,
0.0587276854,
-0.0323438235,
0.0649160296,
0.0121718654,
0.0219013989,
-0.0590506606,
0.0040814877,
0.0172637627,
0.001886077,
-0.0103089139,
-0.0122448001,
-0.0865667164,
-0.0667348132,
0.0073446515,
0.0271728523,
-0.052081462,
0.0045424495,
0.0526172742,
0.0263649076,
-0.0066851466,
-0.0164458137,
-0.0362127535,
0.0148974899,
-0.0387429334,
-0.042532105,
0.0253933687,
-6.033123002e-33,
-0.0511336252,
-0.0394696705,
0.0248863772,
0.0065707802,
-0.0139875133,
0.0102015138,
-0.032915432,
-0.0188196488,
-0.0069753933,
-0.0056325775,
-0.0345992893,
-0.0193492696,
0.0100650443,
0.0111123417,
-0.0166434329,
-0.0172180682,
0.0216768757,
-0.0031725944,
-0.0023830549,
0.0661285967,
0.0751219913,
0.0248972662,
0.0343166403,
-0.0163281802,
0.0173225366,
-0.0059704352,
-0.0001563996,
-0.0049676741,
-0.018385265,
0.0415581018,
-0.0077583226,
0.0609198175,
-0.0118283061,
0.0079333195,
-0.0023515574,
0.0245488994,
-0.0513618365,
-0.0603103004,
0.035462372,
-0.0104140881,
-0.0485507846,
-0.0343567692,
-0.0337182842,
-0.0382179059,
0.0324582979,
-0.0044546546,
-0.000985275,
0.0059444541,
-0.0371228755,
-0.0671154931,
-0.0465262234,
0.003812856,
0.0168951675,
-0.0444710925,
-0.0183352716,
0.0278196465,
0.02480831,
-0.0430652611,
-0.0063168015,
0.0106435372,
0.017937731,
-0.0104056038,
0.0528474078,
-0.0076474249,
-0.014263995,
0.043586053,
-0.0085059516,
-0.00081658,
-0.0031417448,
0.0482053794,
-0.0116229821,
0.0599700585,
0.0075763785,
0.0405708365,
-0.0142467543,
-0.0021464764,
-0.0093084024,
0.0054764184,
0.0554227419,
0.0156743452,
-0.0018337846,
-0.0402360745,
-0.0193410553,
0.0042622262,
-0.0510551818,
-0.0086043943,
-0.0292105172,
-0.0236677807,
0.0568676926,
-0.00727463,
-0.0308036376,
-0.0402522869,
0.0326600075,
-0.0284963418,
-0.0004903229,
0.0293819308,
-0.0308532137,
0.0099323485,
-0.0223487839,
0.030184105,
-0.0450272113,
-0.0281883571,
0.0105208177,
-0.031880673,
0.0349233337,
0.0476712361,
0.0161444489,
0.062550962,
-0.0445575826,
0.0105036041,
-0.0564487763,
0.0347031094,
-0.0123315426,
-0.0399417356,
0.0527640432,
0.0291208234,
0.0029328854,
0.0346935168,
0.0213754736,
-0.0304819997,
-0.0000447797,
0.0380521193,
0.0146714225,
0.0149519015,
-0.0018794391,
0.0145230135,
-0.067498982,
-0.0073368675,
0.0480440669,
-0.0167898536,
-0.0045981645,
0.0120006008,
2.737e-7,
-0.0058367471,
0.0211481471,
0.0240714066,
0.0713155344,
0.0087651834,
0.0198506601,
0.0152086802,
0.0403831154,
-0.011085256,
-0.0109290704,
0.005923728,
0.0253546089,
0.0108385794,
0.0244685411,
-0.1203640178,
0.010665765,
-0.0385869183,
-0.0079488279,
-0.0749687999,
0.0340649076,
0.0671593323,
0.0422134064,
0.0137164788,
-0.0202030633,
-0.0080486638,
-0.045229543,
0.0530463271,
-0.0146062272,
-0.0105063971,
0.0097688483,
0.0503584743,
-0.0200713612,
-0.0197156761,
0.0580427945,
-0.0104766376,
0.0089902664,
-0.0230510086,
0.05804573,
0.011852311,
-0.0092326412,
0.0087071117,
-0.0389836468,
-0.0069090589,
-0.036570102,
0.0827797055,
-0.0596066713,
-0.0075661479,
-0.0115668317,
-0.0247628484,
-0.0316597037,
-0.0437613651,
-0.0317523256,
0.0177223347,
0.0361967906,
0.0171486475,
0.0009675274,
-0.0268324576,
-0.0612889677,
0.0048000407,
-0.0137647148,
-0.0022907457,
-0.0606698953,
-0.0271699447,
-0.0374215655,
-0.0032989196,
-0.0553449355,
0.0128164487,
2.524206978e-34,
0.0046132384,
-0.0098855468,
0.0264634583,
0.0084724165,
0.0158954598,
-0.0225836337,
-0.0235805362,
0.0340036154,
0.0372912586,
-0.0844557807,
-0.0248286966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00412v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00412v1 | Hidding the Ghostwriters: An Adversarial Evaluation of AI-Generated Student Essay Detection | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | Xinlin Peng, Ying Zhou, Ben He, Le Sun, Yingfei Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities in text
generation tasks. However, the utilization of these models carries inherent
risks, including but not limited to plagiarism, the dissemination of fake news,
and issues in educational exercises. Although several detectors have been
proposed to address these concerns, their effectiveness against adversarial
perturbations, specifically in the context of student essay writing, remains
largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by constructing
AIG-ASAP, an AI-generated student essay dataset, employing a range of text
perturbation methods that are expected to generate high-quality essays while
evading detection. Through empirical experiments, we assess the performance of
current AIGC detectors on the AIG-ASAP dataset. The results reveal that the
existing detectors can be easily circumvented using straightforward automatic
adversarial attacks. Specifically, we explore word substitution and sentence
substitution perturbation methods that effectively evade detection while
maintaining the quality of the generated essays. This highlights the urgent
need for more accurate and robust methods to detect AI-generated student essays
in the education domain. | [
0.0523441844,
0.0632392019,
-0.0051305871,
0.0399072394,
-0.0627670288,
-0.0082089556,
0.0440946631,
0.0021892092,
0.0436759591,
-0.0731215179,
0.0131115615,
-0.0247719381,
-0.0077678892,
0.0361800566,
0.0555511639,
0.044784274,
0.0226382203,
0.0185670219,
-0.0278441031,
0.0207744539,
0.0130121885,
0.008614447,
0.0118828034,
0.0378355458,
0.0042460561,
-0.0258519072,
0.0072188261,
0.0220534187,
0.0061693923,
0.0011041574,
0.0347801708,
0.0544344001,
-0.039689444,
0.1083769873,
0.0000019398,
-0.0178667996,
-0.0145845329,
-0.00819977,
-0.0081275841,
0.0625916049,
0.0621709004,
-0.018589709,
-0.0267125759,
0.0209562797,
-0.0684287623,
0.0210001618,
0.0238609053,
0.043937251,
0.0651103407,
0.1129674166,
-0.0240152776,
0.0023247062,
0.0458517782,
-0.0282540098,
-0.0030678357,
-0.0084492117,
0.0442065187,
-0.0491567515,
-0.0292272586,
0.0386398621,
-0.0009024376,
0.0380895101,
0.0141969277,
-0.066938661,
-0.0024283449,
-0.0007337756,
-0.0405482687,
0.0096290112,
0.0080501735,
0.0286354497,
-0.0416698009,
-0.0668498948,
0.0199864153,
-0.0067879409,
0.0120306108,
0.0161411036,
-0.0229265001,
-0.0082775094,
-0.025499193,
-0.003482677,
0.0344244987,
-0.0507368706,
0.0222522095,
0.0477112792,
0.0393415391,
-0.0275381897,
0.0252193492,
-0.0386452824,
-0.0494351089,
-0.0081596598,
-0.0021768245,
-0.0669516549,
0.0717265755,
0.0255360287,
0.0106949918,
-0.0182485301,
-0.1004414111,
-0.0771101043,
0.0256944504,
-0.0569682941,
0.0801015049,
0.0052357106,
0.0132607399,
0.0075239814,
-0.0502432324,
0.0777191371,
-0.0270901602,
0.0403477624,
-0.003849223,
0.0425439104,
-0.0123819662,
-0.0188927799,
-0.0196482018,
0.0235930718,
0.0091345524,
-0.0120142791,
-0.0399699844,
-0.0022663514,
-0.0072431793,
0.0370777845,
-0.0439009815,
-0.0045886715,
-0.046939496,
0.0073449663,
0.0405091196,
0.0133350771,
0.0298435483,
0.0104930205,
0.0133937588,
-0.0525680222,
-0.0223597232,
0.0392923728,
0.0060307798,
-0.0102882618,
0.0123679256,
0.0277983826,
0.0071114702,
-0.0179100856,
-0.0312609971,
-0.0453115329,
0.0039385715,
-0.034661144,
0.0019036711,
-0.0465352722,
-0.0083548371,
-0.0343906321,
-0.0188897345,
-0.0845967382,
0.0060543315,
0.0296476241,
0.0121910963,
0.0337083079,
0.0155645851,
-0.0219976902,
0.0225366391,
-0.0012844915,
-0.0053367438,
0.0227392148,
0.035516724,
0.0671500489,
0.0563034788,
0.0001116315,
0.0464954488,
0.0346804373,
0.035715878,
0.0398152955,
0.0180986859,
-0.0401648693,
-0.0117164478,
0.0191237908,
0.0011916396,
0.0471588187,
0.0161366351,
-0.0336206518,
0.0949437171,
0.0222097822,
-0.0450555831,
0.0453551859,
0.0351965576,
0.0188316274,
0.0016123977,
0.0564133152,
-0.0122147053,
-0.0096055381,
-0.0318837091,
-0.0409777686,
-0.0051913415,
0.0210032538,
0.0233141668,
-0.0466831699,
-0.0088652,
-0.0196920875,
-0.0231424365,
-0.0270931572,
-0.0066200444,
0.0337359309,
-0.0492798835,
-0.0373726264,
-0.0241735876,
-0.0575440638,
0.0214481633,
-0.0730712563,
0.0274225548,
0.0579566769,
0.0883607939,
-0.0129316254,
0.0319368653,
-0.0428981334,
0.0318750329,
0.0312323123,
0.0467954241,
-0.0189121403,
-0.0089206565,
-0.034279447,
-0.0145707708,
-0.0481456704,
0.0164760947,
0.0156106642,
0.0284558423,
0.0115504256,
0.0326872021,
0.0174637828,
-0.0988649428,
0.064983353,
-0.0295936298,
-0.0393200219,
0.0347528793,
0.0237190984,
-0.0008250651,
-0.0037888659,
-0.0286714956,
0.0412331484,
0.0069533526,
-0.0510760471,
-0.0380796455,
-0.0462244414,
0.0135769229,
-0.0139238797,
0.0371925272,
-0.0540832803,
-0.0068360101,
0.0528132915,
-0.0322416611,
0.0052775643,
0.024874175,
-0.035294231,
-0.0000409198,
-0.0236746687,
0.0313349515,
-0.0119229807,
0.0356856473,
-0.0235078502,
0.0227523819,
-0.0030467804,
0.0131724253,
0.0002761504,
0.0233204328,
0.0381467454,
-0.0050893761,
-0.0030841031,
0.0059139663,
-0.012886636,
-0.0011668847,
0.0148950936,
-0.0036489579,
-0.0086921016,
-0.0531247072,
-0.0250928625,
0.0177170988,
-0.0097005144,
0.0100589246,
0.0569677688,
-0.0310833547,
-0.0006912105,
0.0256752484,
-0.0232655928,
-0.0540161282,
-0.0081423772,
0.0102964491,
0.019028645,
-0.0365326554,
0.027590815,
-0.0254170336,
-0.0031395182,
-0.0372047909,
0.0391185805,
0.0587624162,
-0.0470022857,
-0.0333094634,
0.0642159358,
0.0154959243,
0.0043179416,
-0.0079005854,
-0.0655151382,
-0.0114482874,
0.001181787,
0.0262768399,
0.1287447661,
0.0154684167,
0.0240597241,
0.0464727767,
0.0414449945,
-0.0087466519,
-0.0228588451,
-0.002907929,
0.0455805883,
-0.0209691189,
-0.0418864489,
0.0251658447,
-0.0009006711,
0.0479458123,
-0.0398589969,
0.0015500184,
0.0602832772,
-0.0308031701,
-0.0203813892,
0.0215283055,
-0.0356916636,
-0.0288301706,
-0.0257217158,
-0.0370025709,
-0.0268555451,
0.0507109277,
-0.032829646,
0.0362717733,
-0.0169948395,
-0.0162476115,
-0.0084638316,
0.0182852969,
0.0045075882,
0.0157922227,
-0.0031553006,
0.019585669,
-0.0444165766,
0.0160102565,
0.0547439493,
-0.0169717129,
0.005695987,
-0.006824227,
0.0027350138,
-0.005795374,
-0.0060942718,
-0.0524112023,
-0.087180227,
0.0180111118,
-0.0016278045,
-0.002604472,
-0.0338613912,
-0.0367103033,
-0.0443801545,
0.0077748569,
0.0787997693,
-0.071324341,
-0.0023002294,
-0.0199412405,
0.0613180548,
0.0491759665,
-0.0805304796,
0.0013877217,
-0.0291606262,
0.0458184779,
0.0910111293,
-0.0075748712,
0.0573650189,
0.0111040818,
-0.0411890857,
-0.0165628027,
-0.0110701015,
-0.000554446,
-0.0174438152,
0.01332183,
-0.0769341066,
-0.0185927041,
0.0677100047,
0.0066256737,
-0.0124009345,
0.0019334521,
0.0213893149,
0.0202785693,
0.0065742619,
-0.0085459705,
-0.0672737285,
-0.0064675398,
0.0072677899,
0.0384899229,
-0.0411705337,
-0.0247251913,
-0.0259789545,
-0.0768606514,
0.014721931,
0.0281496141,
0.0125341173,
-0.0338807181,
-0.0193540417,
-0.0256774966,
0.0063683367,
-0.0281028431,
-0.0445020758,
0.0101131601,
0.0091202045,
0.0105244303,
0.0008351858,
-0.0476690717,
-0.0498196557,
-0.0338567309,
0.0212954655,
0.0573977865,
0.0647426769,
-0.0153851127,
-0.0517376736,
0.0259021297,
-0.0012365454,
-0.0399427675,
-0.0054123797,
0.065663822,
-0.0207225829,
0.0102999983,
0.0075266273,
0.0619654916,
-0.0178983901,
-0.008266123,
0.0641077682,
0.0342311449,
-0.0129473042,
-0.0546716116,
-0.024834495,
-0.0017921163,
0.0280424803,
0.0738965198,
0.040557649,
-0.0539897531,
-0.0428114049,
-0.0614107661,
0.0079895724,
-0.0970818102,
-0.0297140032,
0.0166690145,
-0.0097164651,
-0.0075911134,
-0.0669011399,
-0.0473717079,
-0.0102410531,
-0.0020630795,
0.0332408808,
0.0179516803,
-0.0455844179,
-0.0336471237,
-0.0401499271,
-0.0288707744,
-0.016012786,
0.0430080444,
-0.0067108893,
-0.0304405093,
-0.0114811305,
-0.0012670056,
-0.0103606982,
0.0301277153,
-0.097735256,
-0.0695712194,
0.0587403476,
0.0136334682,
0.0087538045,
0.023110291,
-0.0244290698,
-0.0524760783,
0.059595257,
0.037482515,
0.0154061653,
0.0293817874,
0.0299379621,
-0.0461187214,
0.0098820338,
0.0332383364,
-0.0000824352,
-0.0103097158,
0.0592248291,
-0.0135433562,
-0.0313958526,
0.0073758853,
0.0070066955,
0.0312562287,
0.0100392429,
-0.0379382856,
0.0192557275,
-0.0254804697,
-0.0027451678,
-0.0379169956,
-0.0086348029,
-0.0422164947,
0.0061671943,
0.0537313856,
0.0028091508,
0.0024363659,
0.0237706117,
-0.0252958257,
0.0335082375,
-0.0288922042,
0.0259854663,
-0.0235458557,
0.062508449,
0.0235344488,
0.0191452485,
-0.0172843486,
0.0500988662,
0.0116446307,
0.0198082961,
-0.0046085496,
0.0205890127,
0.0286342129,
-0.0104179662,
0.0344792269,
0.045442991,
-0.0942227617,
0.0298194755,
-0.0535667427,
0.0279641058,
0.0281233341,
0.0061436663,
0.03341005,
-0.0390917473,
-0.0199302509,
-0.0203538425,
0.0440967791,
0.0202501826,
-0.0329724364,
-0.0250477549,
-0.0208790358,
-0.0093710264,
0.0534390658,
0.0845093057,
0.0066341907,
0.0607450493,
0.0315498337,
-0.0200429391,
-0.0233976562,
-0.0134806493,
0.0410775729,
-0.0070040468,
0.0236670841,
-0.0064882073,
-0.0292013157,
-0.0616488867,
0.0047831689,
0.023706032,
0.0068313805,
-0.0157167576,
-0.0232701115,
0.0477871932,
-0.0304506067,
0.0387312137,
-0.0634055212,
0.0377142467,
0.0012377715,
-0.0573552325,
-0.01528244,
-5.122131043e-33,
0.0011918701,
-0.0706102327,
-0.04519739,
0.0359528214,
0.0014125534,
0.0247004349,
-0.0392891541,
-0.0263115652,
0.0006226935,
0.0106595671,
-0.0025387285,
0.0345725305,
-0.0231332313,
0.0346108563,
-0.0216355212,
-0.0198795125,
0.0771247074,
-0.020139968,
-0.0398362093,
0.0046727555,
0.0245678928,
0.0147647597,
0.0435281135,
-0.0476592071,
0.0401652157,
-0.0455141515,
-0.0574573725,
-0.0214126557,
-0.0558886603,
0.0503491871,
0.0034671957,
0.0284835193,
0.0143962223,
0.0228240453,
-0.0046942844,
0.0235526226,
0.004342434,
-0.020075554,
-0.0132760601,
0.0067207664,
-0.0140050221,
-0.1023488045,
0.0492790416,
-0.0284827352,
-0.0150984628,
-0.0081273653,
0.029717695,
-0.0128532527,
-0.0133618871,
-0.0335725881,
-0.0399185754,
0.0122810462,
-0.0181174539,
-0.0095516089,
-0.0078729223,
0.0575700998,
0.0196737312,
0.0012959971,
-0.0582058243,
0.0237668771,
0.0178823601,
0.0413531177,
0.0120909587,
-0.0314236954,
-0.0022668389,
0.0518823974,
0.0415487848,
0.0255054981,
-0.0088202087,
-0.0146778589,
0.0233670063,
-0.0160119478,
0.1014811099,
0.0944329947,
0.0446246453,
-0.0454413928,
-0.0422314145,
0.0252925958,
0.0110383602,
-0.0185604803,
0.014144348,
-0.0293108039,
-0.0377631634,
0.0052067451,
-0.0131497718,
-0.1027806923,
-0.020771658,
-0.0244054515,
0.0503101461,
-0.0013629324,
-0.0415860228,
-0.0058406033,
-0.0141107598,
-0.0629067123,
-0.0212884173,
0.0287726242,
-0.0508335717,
-0.0146978935,
0.0026679798,
0.0145558016,
0.0027215143,
0.0242151357,
0.0271362122,
-0.0077503421,
0.0389139242,
-0.0112604583,
0.0860053822,
0.0519615933,
-0.0549664833,
0.0016617709,
-0.0231923815,
0.0253678709,
0.0419676267,
-0.0078237448,
0.0058117732,
-0.0179806501,
-0.0023709419,
0.0002275337,
0.0264242291,
0.0240161531,
-0.0371721983,
-0.0013206679,
0.0062889191,
0.0251207501,
-0.0288644116,
-0.0360538475,
-0.0374219716,
0.0264853779,
0.0173012987,
-0.1043351591,
0.0038021004,
-0.0497879423,
2.523e-7,
0.0047540348,
0.0453345142,
0.0161578357,
-0.0365384519,
0.0184739847,
0.0443530343,
-0.0073757372,
0.0345992744,
-0.0082645025,
0.0408950001,
-0.0058802944,
-0.0122469999,
0.0655347481,
0.0105384579,
-0.0939451084,
0.0358902477,
-0.0608071983,
0.0105090579,
-0.0601304248,
-0.0021801684,
0.0551592931,
0.0665528923,
0.0305426288,
-0.03634407,
-0.0056858934,
-0.0746486336,
0.0239950921,
0.0234636068,
-0.0119760223,
0.0128929196,
0.0601810515,
-0.0254544187,
0.0311108287,
-0.0077454397,
-0.0565765649,
-0.0173665173,
0.0216670502,
0.0528834015,
0.007896319,
-0.0076358006,
-0.0062389458,
-0.0351947285,
-0.0003831581,
-0.0695758089,
0.0824627578,
0.02416078,
0.0051889019,
-0.0497373007,
-0.0309643224,
-0.0334232822,
0.0233323183,
-0.0382201672,
-0.012555181,
-0.0017910512,
0.0122539271,
0.0152272321,
0.0143115632,
-0.011157156,
-0.0232742056,
-0.0660768896,
-0.0100067956,
0.0038196342,
-0.033313185,
0.0053166389,
0.0351074152,
-0.024374865,
0.0122786993,
2.478511701e-34,
0.0362558365,
-0.0361790918,
0.0335934423,
0.000372245,
0.0200114492,
0.0072421972,
0.0190905184,
-0.0001731341,
-0.0089840265,
-0.0106500378,
-0.0187417604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00402v1 | Investigating Bias Representations in Llama 2 Chat via Activation Steering | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | Dawn Lu, Nina Rimsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address the challenge of societal bias in Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on the Llama 2 7B Chat model. As LLMs are increasingly integrated into
decision-making processes with substantial societal impact, it becomes
imperative to ensure these models do not reinforce existing biases. Our
approach employs activation steering to probe for and mitigate biases related
to gender, race, and religion. This method manipulates model activations to
direct responses towards or away from biased outputs, utilizing steering
vectors derived from the StereoSet dataset and custom GPT4 generated gender
bias prompts. Our findings reveal inherent gender bias in Llama 2 7B Chat,
persisting even after Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). We
also observe a predictable negative correlation between bias and the model's
tendency to refuse responses. Significantly, our study uncovers that RLHF tends
to increase the similarity in the model's representation of different forms of
societal biases, which raises questions about the model's nuanced understanding
of different forms of bias. This work also provides valuable insights into
effective red-teaming strategies for LLMs using activation steering,
particularly emphasizing the importance of integrating a refusal vector. | [
0.0769641846,
0.0543015227,
-0.0328933336,
0.0216836203,
0.0103543596,
0.0181647465,
0.0334617831,
-0.0178556964,
0.0650870726,
-0.0482903644,
-0.0515446439,
-0.023780942,
0.0097958483,
0.0309785213,
0.0021358232,
-0.028541483,
0.0279136188,
0.0057626148,
0.0459145196,
-0.0453098416,
0.0140816914,
0.0270646457,
0.0274912771,
0.0582773387,
0.0126427598,
-0.0103754299,
0.0247914456,
0.0089156572,
0.0100765647,
-0.0153148137,
0.0535855591,
0.0591637939,
-0.0008261827,
0.0514602885,
0.0000021578,
-0.0749357417,
0.0198301412,
-0.0274833515,
-0.0125418436,
0.0052777426,
0.0643095151,
0.0246474035,
-0.0220371559,
0.0257686544,
-0.0359990224,
0.0211261846,
0.0382329673,
0.0590860322,
0.0432771668,
0.0226962697,
-0.0021490431,
0.012270961,
-0.0510915443,
-0.027339261,
0.0153597845,
-0.0147514101,
0.0421339236,
-0.0279704854,
-0.0395051092,
0.0058645359,
-0.0460220426,
-0.0118873203,
0.0319108441,
-0.0083625745,
-0.0076237628,
0.0340148807,
-0.0121577894,
-0.065961495,
-0.0136897266,
0.081028156,
0.0237052198,
-0.0074686743,
0.0234819409,
-0.0029283485,
0.0100970808,
-0.0139112361,
-0.0397647582,
0.0139359003,
-0.0051836013,
0.0147504006,
-0.00247656,
-0.0129832402,
0.0336947665,
0.033839412,
-0.0093689673,
0.0676761642,
-0.0148808528,
-0.0274034645,
0.0042125424,
0.0333380811,
0.0517902933,
-0.0572196096,
-0.0011825054,
-0.0273926184,
-0.0437267572,
-0.0020409478,
-0.0004627731,
0.0564235486,
0.0295865461,
-0.0736542866,
-0.0022172385,
0.0674853846,
-0.0089558372,
0.0181702264,
0.0238068588,
0.0005659925,
-0.0143012367,
0.0305524562,
-0.0026664464,
0.0049215648,
-0.0225972924,
-0.0030685877,
0.0042415364,
-0.0008711413,
0.0009890733,
0.0189333055,
-0.0477280617,
0.0120964861,
-0.0673300773,
-0.0021321811,
-0.0282731894,
0.0223735198,
-0.0216018315,
0.0180040412,
-0.0616203956,
0.0151823228,
-0.0645505637,
0.0237660874,
-0.0188894849,
-0.1097457856,
0.0109458268,
0.0174291823,
-0.0289586652,
-0.0334337316,
-0.0091174655,
0.0576016121,
-0.0077896155,
-0.0299986135,
-0.0055768397,
-0.0114416154,
-0.014851803,
-0.0718128309,
0.0188369062,
-0.0301165488,
0.0606113039,
0.0171355531,
-0.0024981869,
-0.0156218754,
0.0025388724,
0.0199011508,
-0.0350277461,
0.0824052468,
0.0783315971,
-0.0048867241,
0.059705317,
0.0362798795,
-0.0554147735,
0.1136786118,
0.0167640634,
0.0293837357,
0.0350797251,
0.0083287833,
0.0226896629,
0.0206333604,
0.0324331,
0.0340653025,
-0.0473742113,
0.0288572256,
-0.0277648587,
0.014464072,
0.0751422122,
0.02201299,
-0.0467589833,
-0.0258656573,
0.0486821607,
0.0685990155,
-0.0178511124,
0.0165255815,
-0.0009243671,
0.0138476156,
-0.0312141161,
0.0183224827,
-0.1025673226,
0.0401574075,
-0.0142778531,
-0.0569553152,
0.0286760479,
0.0600879937,
-0.033879865,
-0.0213344134,
0.0360492058,
0.0027555223,
0.0453479923,
0.0289700776,
0.0020875877,
-0.0145273274,
-0.0101839798,
0.0152878352,
0.041769512,
-0.0125461901,
-0.0200355612,
-0.0904468074,
0.0558742099,
0.0205405261,
0.022234045,
-0.0092430515,
-0.0182534773,
-0.0381576456,
-0.0342135653,
0.056008216,
0.0681730881,
-0.0018068939,
-0.0190389175,
-0.0430912934,
-0.0641395599,
0.0393964276,
0.0110813016,
0.0340048186,
0.0460331514,
0.0205777884,
-0.0066331886,
0.0254060104,
-0.0335847884,
0.0171563309,
0.0279162619,
-0.0040818113,
-0.0100549366,
0.0020181967,
0.0676658228,
-0.0110898996,
-0.0050600409,
-0.0239188932,
-0.0207913872,
0.0137333451,
-0.0252741557,
0.0141011812,
-0.0629696548,
-0.0028491744,
0.0077305906,
-0.0436518751,
-0.0579181723,
0.0464788415,
-0.014709847,
0.0228305068,
0.0550872386,
0.0171460342,
0.0251351651,
-0.0052098497,
-0.022268787,
-0.0161767863,
0.0299023017,
-0.0339412056,
0.0112918345,
-0.0381317586,
-0.042306263,
-0.0075067272,
-0.0546778515,
0.0122615891,
-0.0372832343,
0.0141420243,
0.0567426309,
0.0153602073,
-0.0010433185,
0.0322430991,
-0.0148743093,
-0.0239712037,
-0.0255825091,
-0.0552227944,
-0.0414729491,
-0.0022010263,
-0.0187485032,
0.0017410325,
-0.0021376563,
-0.0144183803,
-0.0128882332,
-0.0375121571,
-0.0145343971,
0.0432366095,
0.0712273568,
0.0060197557,
-0.0455448553,
-0.0255556926,
-0.051953204,
-0.0125399465,
-0.022411624,
0.0462952107,
0.04417409,
-0.034441147,
-0.0257310551,
-0.071558997,
-0.0441299528,
0.0118543301,
-0.0263113528,
-0.0380473025,
0.0258459207,
0.0523233898,
0.0197842605,
0.0546581596,
0.0247530639,
0.0414850749,
0.0544235371,
0.0337253176,
-0.0621365383,
-0.0093990741,
-0.0098709548,
0.0085011832,
-0.0057811593,
-0.0608134791,
-0.0104455398,
0.035341695,
0.0312069822,
0.0034827359,
-0.055544354,
0.0367567539,
-0.0392454341,
-0.0865809843,
-0.0275868848,
-0.0443215817,
-0.0049509527,
0.0559121706,
-0.0513468571,
-0.0625189468,
0.0610984936,
0.0459068604,
0.0001510917,
-0.0253402703,
0.0360259898,
-0.0514322482,
0.0093271695,
-0.0137255602,
0.0254213773,
0.0205941144,
-0.0060922913,
-0.057583116,
-0.0578906313,
0.0031802445,
-0.0365190282,
0.0383048393,
-0.0076842299,
0.0071752463,
0.004031003,
-0.0346220508,
-0.055002857,
-0.0065392703,
-0.0263264962,
-0.0140640764,
0.0068316436,
0.0004409463,
-0.0054495451,
0.0112324161,
0.0092916079,
-0.0072247586,
-0.0169015899,
-0.0090698181,
0.0009499963,
-0.0267755818,
0.0291938502,
0.0156987756,
0.0504154749,
-0.0381810963,
0.0326133706,
0.0322924256,
-0.0104505531,
-0.0022633865,
0.0122853573,
0.0073853554,
0.0391987674,
0.0100601604,
0.0015478553,
0.0033759421,
0.0380803607,
-0.0187705737,
0.0150963413,
0.068379201,
0.0154545503,
-0.1069385111,
0.01065272,
-0.0354416147,
0.028470546,
0.0300602093,
0.0188743956,
-0.1167742237,
0.0004728403,
0.0225215126,
0.0033424727,
-0.0384284556,
-0.0379413702,
0.0157299563,
-0.1283949316,
0.0311882887,
0.0113971373,
-0.027131971,
-0.0408189408,
-0.0267429054,
0.0119114332,
-0.0287207086,
0.0414003246,
-0.0147617161,
0.0243316609,
0.0062600016,
-0.0231201202,
-0.0235415772,
-0.025670385,
0.0432600155,
-0.0468923897,
0.0806463733,
0.0540645905,
0.0577961057,
-0.0066800481,
0.0266231652,
0.0586415343,
0.0014183348,
-0.0162742268,
-0.0170286484,
0.0231527425,
-0.0270819645,
-0.0093383156,
-0.0321735851,
0.0418941863,
0.0403893963,
0.0014206344,
-0.0066230278,
0.0443569347,
-0.0079776086,
-0.0349578261,
-0.0348141007,
0.0227117464,
0.0371865332,
0.0717498735,
0.0198557042,
-0.0621601269,
-0.0138522312,
-0.0688295141,
-0.0064512114,
0.0371441431,
-0.095345445,
-0.0274429116,
0.0037817338,
-0.0336994827,
-0.0338503271,
-0.0616601631,
0.0121511035,
-0.0184055772,
0.0134927221,
-0.0505716614,
-0.0029559578,
-0.0004876502,
0.0277131703,
0.0327469073,
-0.0419723392,
0.0256806314,
-0.0156296026,
0.0014088602,
-0.0391686335,
-0.0683790818,
-0.0036829161,
0.0164019931,
-0.0094223982,
-0.0586226098,
0.0500976704,
0.0448706076,
0.0290684663,
0.0474390164,
-0.0021356884,
-0.0435694344,
0.032769803,
0.0472633913,
-0.0284510776,
0.0369987451,
0.0558346882,
0.0851811245,
-0.0092110932,
0.0347601436,
-0.0180313513,
0.056777779,
0.0162486434,
-0.019613944,
-0.0464223102,
-0.0055228067,
0.0029160329,
-0.0356982686,
0.0388218574,
-0.0214403849,
-0.0039457637,
-0.0506482609,
-0.0049541495,
-0.0011325508,
-0.0294120926,
0.0028621668,
-0.0395888574,
0.0182153173,
0.0014974804,
-0.013444378,
-0.0397751294,
-0.037731763,
-0.0082020704,
-0.0084448699,
0.0237574503,
0.0570559017,
0.0544324853,
-0.024949614,
0.0007790222,
0.0063228626,
0.0478007011,
-0.0244073626,
0.0069981064,
0.0218992773,
0.0567694679,
0.0347884521,
-0.0104600042,
0.0082445815,
0.0037476821,
-0.0222086385,
-0.0535542667,
0.023702614,
0.0355531313,
0.0143911988,
0.0047716629,
0.0239174739,
0.0113229649,
-0.0146049028,
0.0050430065,
-0.0095548704,
-0.0053135431,
0.0065590399,
0.0464296378,
0.006598298,
-0.0069027483,
0.0037450066,
0.0323045366,
0.0044920649,
0.070406355,
-0.0119531685,
-0.0221302006,
-0.022416167,
-0.0407341868,
0.0458224863,
-0.0095308339,
-0.0160726029,
0.0052996408,
-0.0944137797,
-0.0374776646,
-0.0326514877,
0.0065307096,
0.0100932093,
-0.0537950769,
0.0074753296,
0.0410091318,
-0.0169086829,
-0.0139094451,
-0.0155606819,
-0.0447580144,
-0.0358718261,
-0.014174154,
-0.0255152732,
-6.955183342e-33,
-0.0127925938,
-0.0287368298,
-0.0072446889,
-0.0107445335,
-0.0351313278,
-0.025660757,
-0.0134941079,
0.0076252618,
-0.0252439752,
0.0212051701,
-0.0051022596,
0.0336150415,
0.0119976345,
-0.0337413885,
0.0275643766,
-0.0192300696,
0.0543331802,
-0.0279807523,
-0.0374016166,
0.0168827958,
-0.0051355087,
0.001988105,
0.0247829165,
-0.0817660019,
0.0504472218,
0.0084596714,
-0.0264785178,
0.0075497436,
-0.0391734205,
0.0369813181,
-0.0490463749,
0.051722981,
0.0198590811,
-0.0472741239,
0.0168725215,
0.0791968033,
-0.0394158512,
-0.0531105921,
0.0218762197,
0.0031473727,
-0.0128697827,
-0.0311757568,
0.0172159467,
0.0058515118,
-0.0663909242,
0.0047913333,
0.038147904,
0.00579014,
0.0241964906,
0.0451612324,
-0.0690912455,
-0.0034867434,
-0.0218540616,
-0.0074559404,
-0.0114541147,
0.0508480817,
-0.0087869046,
0.0293816235,
-0.0470240749,
0.0236251075,
0.0008737726,
-0.0337089039,
0.025897868,
0.0472251959,
0.027335763,
0.0380926766,
0.0646748841,
0.0425422452,
-0.0479498133,
-0.0987452939,
0.0347633846,
-0.0132417781,
0.012432836,
0.0592020974,
0.0125598665,
-0.0185682271,
-0.0457608104,
-0.0232586246,
0.0936910808,
0.0212685876,
0.0536447167,
-0.0078108194,
-0.0705058351,
-0.0442930199,
-0.0291065555,
-0.0814812109,
-0.0279510878,
-0.0319277383,
0.0310645793,
0.02768456,
-0.0342300832,
-0.0067967786,
0.0320765041,
-0.0471470207,
-0.0260882564,
0.0173614994,
0.0109491572,
-0.0202465151,
0.0358182862,
-0.0277613401,
-0.0913605243,
0.011395067,
-0.002664167,
-0.0029872288,
0.0048893276,
0.009199393,
-0.0198882241,
0.0197356194,
-0.0593602583,
-0.0024691888,
-0.0333233811,
0.0279570352,
0.0246783476,
-0.0005166443,
0.029128518,
0.0115088392,
0.0019830226,
0.0195698794,
0.0328396633,
0.0157041065,
-0.0190949291,
0.0030652853,
-0.0514549203,
0.0476742275,
-0.0407494977,
-0.0127073675,
-0.021565875,
0.0073167444,
0.0277232789,
-0.0593117811,
-0.0423202924,
-0.0549372621,
2.785e-7,
-0.0292950384,
0.0628176555,
0.0054817065,
0.0349257551,
0.0296933837,
0.0603641048,
0.0219927747,
0.0570206642,
0.0626353398,
-0.0194971971,
0.0053964015,
0.0502200164,
0.0042526526,
0.0199390147,
-0.0418700948,
0.004229404,
-0.0878554583,
0.0245324261,
-0.0215723813,
-0.0178193711,
0.0043991376,
0.0792884305,
0.0468136743,
-0.0121922558,
-0.0242823083,
0.0498048067,
0.0603414141,
-0.0696232244,
0.0016312653,
0.0047248611,
0.0121867722,
-0.0141586307,
0.0000143988,
0.0314686522,
0.0329157077,
0.0203890856,
-0.0339635648,
0.0349442475,
0.006449345,
-0.0171159171,
-0.0105602145,
0.0209044646,
-0.0133535471,
-0.0710736662,
0.0712515488,
-0.0381997302,
-0.0343581215,
-0.0561229177,
0.0140197771,
-0.018639205,
0.0632419065,
0.0081448928,
-0.0337447003,
-0.0063308058,
0.0120726796,
0.023756234,
-0.00179854,
-0.0684911832,
-0.0098955249,
-0.0438751392,
-0.0257180128,
-0.0711198151,
-0.0171802714,
0.0462973975,
-0.0135815982,
-0.0310059655,
0.0275124162,
2.464768749e-34,
0.0303437002,
-0.017204551,
0.0207330585,
-0.0176625792,
0.0432165861,
0.0068074265,
0.0023888112,
-0.0140724583,
0.0740758553,
-0.0266177934,
0.0136914216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00396v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00396v2 | Efficient Exploration for LLMs | 2024-02-01T07:32:24 | 2024-06-04T18:35:09 | Vikranth Dwaracherla, Seyed Mohammad Asghari, Botao Hao, Benjamin Van Roy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME, stat.ML | We present evidence of substantial benefit from efficient exploration in
gathering human feedback to improve large language models. In our experiments,
an agent sequentially generates queries while fitting a reward model to the
feedback received. Our best-performing agent generates queries using double
Thompson sampling, with uncertainty represented by an epistemic neural network.
Our results demonstrate that efficient exploration enables high levels of
performance with far fewer queries. Further, both uncertainty estimation and
the choice of exploration scheme play critical roles. | [
0.0453223251,
0.0739071667,
-0.0236665532,
0.0208459087,
-0.0449497253,
-0.0104345661,
-0.056043651,
-0.0058698314,
-0.0041728364,
-0.0137063358,
-0.0404447205,
-0.0430038497,
-0.0403299592,
-0.0153239165,
0.0241204295,
-0.0186790954,
0.0163772628,
-0.0803434551,
0.0240239985,
-0.0258948002,
-0.0443817154,
-0.0360536985,
0.0010010935,
0.0415310189,
0.0207472965,
0.0347457714,
-0.0631055608,
0.0149703585,
-0.0333003998,
-0.0342599824,
-0.0541657545,
0.0294171274,
0.0186919309,
0.0659544244,
0.0000017665,
-0.0431362279,
-0.0024869358,
-0.0039743022,
-0.0560218543,
-0.0034333493,
0.0128660155,
0.0349050574,
0.0038810747,
0.0191009454,
-0.0386190191,
0.0300192535,
0.0118725738,
0.0025022493,
0.026258599,
0.0429682434,
0.0342402905,
0.0019271201,
-0.0216207001,
-0.0267189965,
0.0639775172,
-0.0674754232,
0.0055688778,
-0.0342932791,
0.0878835693,
0.0351020992,
0.0096536372,
0.0238869581,
0.0448609069,
-0.0314052776,
-0.0256852545,
0.0249732509,
0.0220462941,
-0.0275264066,
-0.0088111777,
0.0261019431,
0.0161127504,
0.026592914,
-0.0122615965,
-0.0184363779,
0.0270775799,
0.0185153149,
-0.0289989617,
0.0468873493,
-0.0032807342,
0.0242913179,
0.0337383039,
-0.0073693581,
0.0464898236,
0.0260780025,
-0.0334000029,
0.0914254114,
-0.0098246075,
-0.0372085497,
0.0286522359,
0.0263399594,
-0.0196539592,
-0.0333164148,
-0.0160320606,
0.0379993059,
-0.0588028915,
0.0366335362,
-0.0271322578,
0.0047450038,
-0.0011650149,
0.0266822204,
0.0687411875,
0.0332151353,
0.0376510359,
0.0471641384,
0.0133712869,
0.0097458465,
-0.0200231764,
0.0628382713,
-0.031651929,
-0.0013637546,
-0.0453431904,
-0.0016365431,
-0.0531060547,
0.0753775313,
-0.0449925028,
-0.0143180722,
-0.0274204668,
0.0507622994,
0.0385978594,
0.0022931034,
-0.0029216849,
-0.0171473343,
-0.0132931666,
0.0058724559,
-0.0743213668,
-0.0515435003,
-0.0377514325,
0.0158805121,
0.0305733923,
-0.065750137,
-0.0303214733,
0.0019649062,
-0.0327384286,
-0.0198688675,
-0.0156022152,
0.093056418,
0.0001828684,
-0.0609334745,
-0.0872523412,
-0.0160512459,
0.0110768359,
-0.0246540438,
0.005502386,
-0.0546803847,
0.012559874,
-0.0321503393,
-0.0464327671,
-0.0131483888,
0.008920759,
0.0180698484,
-0.0378720462,
0.0742531344,
-0.0234697144,
0.0185406487,
0.0182043388,
-0.0072235358,
0.0212207343,
0.0942095444,
0.0483491085,
0.0474388711,
0.0295655131,
0.0522169955,
0.0309326854,
0.0272331033,
0.0182343293,
0.0076903696,
-0.0136493882,
-0.0098334281,
-0.0328587256,
0.0883745179,
-0.0040066373,
0.0875794068,
-0.0524697229,
0.0033504113,
0.0656921789,
0.042920161,
0.0358647853,
-0.0452826954,
0.0444481187,
-0.0120965643,
0.0074544661,
-0.0138130868,
-0.0405904464,
0.0196467321,
0.0096455328,
0.0191165935,
0.0283673555,
-0.0410956144,
-0.0222824626,
-0.0635641441,
-0.0220975671,
0.0265961681,
0.0103690857,
0.0289988276,
0.0437511653,
0.0018244152,
-0.0419865213,
0.0242933892,
0.0032968766,
-0.02926399,
0.0015402712,
-0.0749240741,
0.0657561123,
0.069897145,
0.0559927747,
-0.0282023493,
0.0128566315,
-0.0081004333,
-0.0322575085,
0.0509700067,
0.04711923,
-0.0198728964,
0.0333088823,
-0.0243179537,
-0.018127868,
-0.01872034,
0.0096061258,
0.0188506115,
0.0431010537,
-0.0124442,
-0.0182268731,
-0.052923236,
-0.0215585567,
0.039653033,
-0.0213892981,
-0.045152057,
0.023237735,
-0.0132403644,
0.026223192,
0.0304069854,
0.0026433829,
0.0334263891,
0.0404222272,
-0.0023396802,
-0.0227593966,
0.0097419368,
-0.032035917,
-0.0464752503,
0.0232242234,
-0.0216613468,
0.0123545872,
-0.0059527843,
-0.0027299053,
-0.0378186405,
-0.0000440734,
-0.0807788521,
0.0579706356,
-0.0425984636,
0.0201346464,
-0.0054662866,
-0.0134457108,
-0.0719070211,
0.0478321165,
-0.0454218499,
-0.0110216839,
0.0392769538,
0.0276094582,
-0.0078882053,
-0.0980712175,
-0.027944088,
0.0014975121,
0.0371413566,
0.0075495588,
0.0048181401,
0.0231412686,
-0.0386055782,
-0.0375913419,
-0.0549698398,
-0.0040591541,
-0.0072131539,
0.0051583438,
-0.0058317492,
0.0164479204,
0.0024456026,
-0.0209808853,
-0.0101682274,
0.011112716,
0.0281577874,
0.0330047756,
0.0510544144,
0.065715678,
-0.0201450586,
-0.0558117591,
-0.0185341928,
0.0076008728,
0.0184841901,
0.0138559565,
0.003539016,
-0.0689373687,
0.0014315152,
0.0047601946,
0.0238362197,
-0.0185624268,
-0.0147118308,
0.0477645211,
-0.0538409203,
-0.0450253412,
0.0474746972,
-0.0031425797,
0.0560908243,
0.0402990431,
-0.0180941746,
-0.0771587566,
0.0233786255,
-0.0096048769,
-0.0277419705,
-0.0197917931,
-0.0118948938,
0.0417243838,
0.071229361,
0.0042809923,
-0.0080177421,
-0.0287757199,
0.0460908338,
0.0161294639,
-0.0672043562,
-0.0510707274,
0.0103131691,
-0.0266571213,
0.0456293523,
-0.020469714,
-0.0533183627,
0.0947340354,
-0.00630339,
0.0079446025,
-0.0151508143,
0.003885526,
-0.0222671311,
0.0462498702,
-0.0129680037,
-0.0015541397,
0.0008122152,
-0.0395582393,
-0.0419332869,
-0.0040257643,
0.0339230821,
-0.0410537384,
0.0694324747,
-0.086042881,
0.0127115045,
0.0258781854,
-0.0336508527,
-0.060119126,
-0.0263659637,
-0.026084125,
0.0225244146,
0.043931976,
-0.0198206045,
-0.0295258313,
-0.0189582743,
0.0399558879,
0.005960329,
0.0001534048,
-0.0290090982,
-0.0151574034,
-0.020325454,
0.0034143832,
0.0487475805,
0.0553034432,
-0.0503161959,
0.0327507518,
0.0347144678,
0.0335713588,
0.02493448,
0.0044379947,
0.0134325093,
0.0316580571,
-0.0434508249,
-0.0169569403,
0.0441080928,
0.0306798834,
-0.026350854,
-0.0271225553,
0.0969411433,
0.0328886025,
-0.0373597145,
-0.0063753496,
-0.0410725735,
0.0434955545,
0.0235497523,
0.0614376888,
-0.076970458,
-0.0296253618,
0.0200239159,
0.052414,
-0.0215306245,
-0.0498890616,
0.0125876032,
-0.1604643017,
0.0122945383,
-0.0082723489,
-0.0367041603,
0.0282405075,
-0.0148780784,
-0.0182901435,
-0.0147742359,
0.0139376232,
0.0565256588,
0.0126961125,
0.0045617665,
-0.0037399887,
0.0406047516,
-0.0411098339,
-0.0133618694,
-0.0459033959,
0.0517719872,
0.0637358278,
0.0042857309,
-0.0083413413,
-0.0550653674,
-0.0196518078,
-0.0018046363,
0.0228758845,
-0.0217215177,
0.0231100041,
-0.007541087,
-0.0170437135,
0.0033036633,
0.0275304262,
-0.0250233132,
0.0078186207,
-0.0108799431,
0.0495315157,
-0.0351053365,
0.0267357882,
-0.0132456692,
-0.0087745385,
0.0210450199,
0.0702770799,
0.0217329543,
-0.0459277295,
-0.0241579879,
-0.0477068722,
-0.0468508378,
-0.0631250143,
-0.0065879552,
0.0525123067,
0.0262526013,
0.0249216352,
-0.0671539754,
-0.0493996292,
0.0424179584,
0.0566029139,
-0.0130360015,
0.0173401013,
-0.0205450337,
0.0018278123,
-0.0148334652,
-0.0157456975,
-0.0241355356,
0.0082084155,
-0.0631069541,
0.0107083907,
0.0269734804,
-0.0341451205,
0.0046175313,
0.0175436623,
-0.0862860084,
-0.0770923644,
-0.0041405321,
0.0723833665,
0.0309742633,
0.0474564806,
-0.0252084602,
-0.0510768443,
-0.0074661295,
0.0212394595,
-0.007582231,
0.0185286757,
0.0249735788,
0.0552989505,
0.0074538668,
0.0476803593,
-0.0373623446,
-0.0200362056,
0.0201325174,
0.043656975,
-0.0383513868,
-0.0421891212,
0.0238891151,
0.0223665871,
0.0307905339,
-0.0185335092,
0.0044649071,
-0.0117984088,
0.0233452078,
-0.0243880711,
-0.0165067725,
-0.0599976517,
-0.0053236708,
0.0084557505,
-0.0193224512,
0.0034979242,
-0.0166754778,
-0.0075826789,
0.0377066694,
-0.0275596324,
-0.0015146802,
0.0032083632,
-0.0090062069,
0.0202104636,
0.0045110518,
0.0044725374,
0.0548477843,
-0.0097135231,
0.0436749831,
0.0175138004,
0.0347864367,
0.0240151435,
-0.0226614308,
0.0024007366,
-0.000937103,
-0.0804370418,
-0.0933074579,
0.0134144183,
0.0557651408,
0.0568588525,
0.0331866033,
-0.0127219083,
-0.0348351784,
0.0191265643,
0.0274378303,
0.0118629411,
-0.0001648055,
-0.0112166312,
0.0834162086,
0.0412101112,
-0.0043686582,
-0.0071068951,
0.052209083,
0.0131652923,
0.0394600704,
-0.0331813991,
0.0068539781,
-0.0482413508,
-0.0099747097,
0.0363950506,
0.0326804966,
-0.0208498761,
-0.0019417586,
-0.0194184147,
-0.0298227407,
0.0075306357,
0.074864544,
0.0032052842,
-0.0275825784,
0.0652598515,
0.0633780137,
0.0279847588,
-0.0216472838,
-0.0445588641,
-0.0288182646,
-0.0011412436,
-0.0331819914,
-0.0049687531,
-5.902534396e-33,
-0.0393938906,
-0.0280547403,
0.0489366204,
-0.029154975,
-0.0516102314,
-0.0580713935,
-0.0321704373,
0.0269623119,
-0.0169644505,
0.0059642093,
-0.0370167233,
0.0266125593,
0.0188024826,
0.01795917,
0.0200173669,
-0.0205065515,
0.0331485756,
0.0021827393,
-0.0048852479,
-0.0413135961,
0.0018223417,
0.0370509624,
0.0392526351,
-0.0066613662,
0.0140368948,
0.0144105218,
-0.0118775051,
0.0558982044,
-0.0307631176,
0.0505637638,
0.0052232933,
0.0063921092,
-0.0108223781,
-0.0557069071,
-0.0168808307,
-0.0378729999,
-0.0221903361,
-0.0433588214,
0.0306193754,
0.0115188295,
-0.0434795208,
-0.0190396737,
0.0531159937,
-0.0149348658,
-0.0315224268,
0.0619743839,
-0.0163540523,
-0.0192480441,
-0.0538388304,
0.0219753701,
0.0037679479,
0.0151030524,
0.0426285602,
0.0059085498,
0.0190118365,
-0.0031416107,
-0.0276682191,
-0.0321852192,
-0.0138621796,
0.0299620964,
0.04181825,
0.0209173486,
0.0255430005,
0.0518333949,
0.0301874001,
0.0270092804,
-0.0007506471,
-0.0025835223,
-0.0338620618,
0.0028660968,
0.0197182577,
0.0358350389,
0.0142460428,
0.0527730882,
-0.0079320585,
0.0407382958,
-0.0261768214,
0.0134126842,
0.0217197146,
0.022440251,
0.0263824165,
0.0395485088,
-0.0319246948,
-0.0305814557,
-0.066831395,
-0.0101848459,
-0.0307471436,
-0.0263790842,
0.0386286229,
0.0330928415,
-0.0106334062,
-0.0637514368,
0.0038418181,
-0.0227863509,
-0.0055083046,
-0.0045664394,
-0.0129220327,
0.0228443053,
-0.0141074723,
0.0050673499,
-0.0706680715,
-0.0076714009,
-0.0294440147,
0.0159148406,
-0.0294849332,
0.0249890741,
-0.0448754542,
0.0399120599,
-0.0475112014,
-0.004457484,
-0.0392353721,
0.049420882,
-0.0094075706,
-0.0508430116,
0.0531495512,
-0.0494223088,
-0.010138927,
0.0360599197,
-0.0200585127,
-0.0286621023,
-0.0119446823,
-0.0021967543,
0.0134895956,
0.0116623482,
-0.0067915935,
0.0110870274,
-0.0191216953,
0.0107537685,
-0.0246767402,
-0.0535352789,
0.0023100388,
0.0489662848,
2.594e-7,
-0.0019207598,
0.0165444463,
0.006745459,
0.0609063208,
0.0039932067,
0.0109562567,
-0.0198072828,
-0.0206389967,
-0.0193640236,
-0.0358301625,
0.0152170239,
0.0405595712,
0.0256685521,
0.0271140952,
-0.1044423282,
-0.0512894988,
-0.0177821238,
0.0041292934,
-0.0206207689,
-0.0183237083,
0.0307747982,
0.0843136609,
0.0137839383,
-0.0012648031,
-0.0019979933,
-0.0588623807,
0.0723494142,
-0.0419693999,
-0.0322959945,
-0.0108418996,
0.0439945124,
0.0543992557,
-0.0034739799,
-0.0082814069,
0.0080816047,
0.0260156393,
-0.0334385894,
0.0296598934,
0.0271569416,
-0.026447406,
-0.0050371252,
-0.0425473191,
0.0236590765,
-0.0134513741,
0.034461692,
-0.0483653657,
-0.0099564781,
0.0085114501,
0.0782138109,
-0.0669258535,
0.0056928769,
-0.0481778383,
0.0005316921,
-0.0353507921,
0.032350447,
0.0003147332,
0.0038754493,
-0.0792169794,
-0.0028351487,
-0.0105168,
-0.0522854999,
-0.0326872766,
-0.04790131,
-0.0201579332,
-0.0266233068,
-0.0625572875,
-0.0236080121,
2.088864252e-34,
0.0690038726,
-0.0064783618,
0.0074081821,
0.0640201345,
0.0233358741,
0.0287430845,
0.0202514883,
-0.0181577504,
0.0715621188,
-0.0850193501,
-0.016789278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01771v1 | BlackMamba: Mixture of Experts for State-Space Models | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | Quentin Anthony, Yury Tokpanov, Paolo Glorioso, Beren Millidge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG | State-space models (SSMs) have recently demonstrated competitive performance
to transformers at large-scale language modeling benchmarks while achieving
linear time and memory complexity as a function of sequence length. Mamba, a
recently released SSM model, shows impressive performance in both language
modeling and long sequence processing tasks. Simultaneously, mixture-of-expert
(MoE) models have shown remarkable performance while significantly reducing the
compute and latency costs of inference at the expense of a larger memory
footprint. In this paper, we present BlackMamba, a novel architecture that
combines the Mamba SSM with MoE to obtain the benefits of both. We demonstrate
that BlackMamba performs competitively against both Mamba and transformer
baselines, and outperforms in inference and training FLOPs. We fully train and
open-source 340M/1.5B and 630M/2.8B BlackMamba models on 300B tokens of a
custom dataset. We show that BlackMamba inherits and combines both of the
benefits of SSM and MoE architectures, combining linear-complexity generation
from SSM with cheap and fast inference from MoE. We release all weights,
checkpoints, and inference code open-source. Inference code at:
https://github.com/Zyphra/BlackMamba | [
0.0393292382,
0.0867921561,
0.010852538,
0.0025371278,
-0.0259211566,
-0.0063916724,
0.0470493734,
-0.0327441581,
-0.0113013182,
-0.03533227,
-0.0172358993,
-0.0486857519,
0.0296260547,
0.033017844,
0.024597723,
-0.0496681482,
0.0269686654,
-0.040046148,
-0.0039318735,
-0.0045810053,
-0.0038530622,
0.0113563109,
-0.0179645699,
0.0650411993,
0.0068385941,
0.0155465957,
-0.0452342369,
-0.0176487975,
0.0083829639,
-0.0133573385,
-0.000996285,
0.0734828934,
0.0282803476,
0.0567244291,
0.0000019728,
-0.004333301,
-0.0048039099,
0.0057046521,
-0.0184757207,
0.0160562824,
0.0047799293,
0.0113139702,
-0.0015190776,
0.0362027884,
-0.0113887982,
-0.040585164,
0.0624135733,
0.0145791573,
0.0445952825,
0.1345504373,
-0.017386457,
-0.0168724656,
0.0389846154,
-0.0594889261,
-0.0316806287,
-0.0319615677,
0.0258663073,
-0.0213342514,
-0.0097060679,
-0.0180180855,
-0.0257153977,
0.0225501489,
0.024416225,
0.0383731239,
-0.0243506543,
0.0385375619,
0.0263280738,
-0.0406454168,
-0.02100862,
0.0484378077,
-0.0498978272,
-0.0228685401,
0.0121610127,
0.0135652134,
-0.0173244718,
0.0049673901,
-0.0124705946,
0.0434448719,
-0.0144182444,
0.0323719531,
0.0054699881,
-0.0123077706,
0.0505298525,
0.0091010844,
-0.0750928968,
0.0432141908,
0.0247939005,
-0.0007395539,
-0.0380098112,
-0.0229808986,
0.0074652042,
-0.0755247772,
0.0197475199,
0.0364131927,
-0.0288342871,
0.0075257719,
-0.0450965613,
-0.0498674959,
-0.0256985202,
-0.0204273164,
0.025066901,
0.066054076,
-0.0265029594,
0.0425517559,
-0.01616331,
0.0131755667,
-0.036976777,
0.0226717591,
-0.0262000021,
-0.013469195,
-0.0359242857,
0.00317743,
-0.00781726,
-0.0004950041,
-0.0268556867,
-0.0341545865,
-0.0555899888,
-0.0117501039,
-0.0017182473,
-0.0185742285,
0.0294568744,
0.0201693233,
-0.0474043898,
-0.0033708776,
-0.012378661,
0.0653253645,
0.0105449315,
0.0114713013,
0.0265212245,
-0.0572612211,
-0.018668687,
0.0343125463,
-0.0063357176,
-0.0128739644,
0.0247701351,
0.0429300554,
-0.018852761,
-0.0711870119,
-0.0262400024,
0.0261282735,
-0.001990176,
-0.0937702358,
0.0247769728,
-0.0696199983,
0.0598545112,
0.0075063095,
0.0173972286,
-0.0283608437,
0.0174018722,
0.0120880194,
-0.0262047406,
0.0576632917,
-0.0123266447,
-0.0301940292,
0.0007546793,
0.0102013964,
-0.0326715373,
0.0472653434,
0.0419542752,
0.0168195497,
-0.0162779558,
0.0081251953,
-0.0152934128,
0.0539825819,
-0.0091703916,
-0.0153844571,
-0.0417768918,
-0.0150824636,
-0.0258240681,
0.0191938411,
0.0385026336,
0.0732382536,
-0.0215681419,
-0.0138299419,
0.04781821,
0.0349062979,
-0.0061576818,
0.033593718,
0.0526944064,
0.0022295658,
0.024449667,
-0.0067968639,
-0.0213155225,
0.0358011723,
-0.0136988647,
0.0143109113,
0.0666961744,
0.0940673202,
-0.0316886418,
-0.0052009691,
-0.0095009934,
-0.0218685009,
-0.0402914807,
0.0131229553,
0.0772795156,
-0.025403928,
-0.0566016547,
0.0682787001,
0.0230983123,
-0.037615791,
-0.0261406582,
-0.0592078939,
0.0398912132,
0.0458120219,
0.0275573749,
-0.0194655657,
-0.0092800474,
-0.024587661,
-0.0195087641,
0.0371356755,
-0.0081256563,
0.0290208738,
0.0144408327,
-0.079326652,
-0.0342763215,
0.0351299383,
0.0195038505,
0.0419428237,
0.0565609299,
0.0045479815,
0.0524588488,
-0.0039996505,
0.0059005124,
0.022319939,
-0.0301237404,
0.0061567738,
0.0004804063,
-0.005492636,
0.0624304153,
-0.0064850762,
-0.0277890489,
0.019704625,
0.0261224937,
-0.0213074777,
-0.0236052703,
0.0001963256,
-0.0746208057,
-0.0523795411,
0.0608013272,
-0.0044350033,
0.0372450463,
0.031185234,
-0.0475381538,
-0.0944946408,
0.0125547238,
-0.0336565226,
0.0454118252,
-0.0553166755,
-0.0079394402,
0.0382333249,
0.0508228801,
-0.0051316274,
0.0454438329,
-0.0564181283,
-0.0053746789,
0.0220536012,
0.0036474126,
-0.0081626531,
0.0112370262,
-0.0326795317,
-0.0177529585,
0.0008542872,
0.020346716,
-0.0234732181,
-0.0192950051,
0.0079798056,
-0.0308502205,
-0.0949402526,
0.0219982397,
-0.0519429706,
0.0216902997,
0.0107735172,
0.0304795895,
0.0071042636,
0.0221427288,
-0.0183401294,
-0.0009350299,
-0.006979391,
0.0042599398,
-0.0252367444,
0.0073841065,
-0.0466439277,
-0.0533161797,
-0.0468029827,
-0.0082739154,
0.0595457517,
-0.0529787689,
-0.0228956975,
-0.0214023869,
-0.0346971825,
-0.0180982817,
0.0507365838,
-0.0466742851,
-0.0293479115,
0.0094590476,
-0.0428282395,
0.09254805,
0.0111374911,
0.029598536,
0.0231435169,
0.0297567025,
-0.0147800641,
-0.0040577268,
0.0301730726,
-0.0103992084,
0.0358028077,
-0.0485558994,
-0.009231816,
-0.0392392091,
0.0954477787,
-0.0249185134,
-0.0279316679,
-0.0560546964,
-0.0394430272,
0.0344126038,
-0.0135785844,
0.0288802814,
-0.009905342,
-0.0295451116,
0.0104122842,
-0.0276058558,
-0.0226014219,
0.0560690984,
-0.0698093027,
-0.0330553949,
-0.0063169883,
-0.034799967,
-0.0382345505,
0.0371863395,
0.0284101982,
0.0054285238,
-0.0286587942,
0.0230743848,
-0.0275627058,
0.0197381992,
-0.015737595,
-0.0223763715,
0.0076751527,
-0.0176655687,
0.043127045,
-0.0145031689,
-0.0176948793,
-0.0094430391,
0.0144738052,
-0.070592232,
0.0113918558,
0.0366970189,
-0.0602248646,
-0.0581106879,
0.060254626,
0.012308931,
0.0852376148,
-0.0207860507,
0.0215305444,
-0.022835331,
0.0470895469,
0.0473408364,
0.0010310478,
0.031739857,
-0.0524606034,
-0.0006987017,
0.038688913,
0.0512003079,
-0.0063198605,
-0.0627018213,
-0.019229982,
0.0320897326,
-0.0124657713,
-0.0198140647,
0.0500963777,
0.0072056879,
-0.06086386,
-0.003122861,
0.1137742922,
0.0040303413,
-0.0653464645,
-0.0082884068,
0.0344636738,
0.0208435785,
0.0034393743,
0.018468868,
-0.0611161292,
-0.0462293774,
0.0238644909,
-0.0144367032,
0.0003146355,
0.0010662654,
-0.0004828268,
-0.0698314831,
-0.0019774891,
0.0032226886,
-0.0716820806,
-0.0286982302,
-0.0545152947,
-0.0210128576,
-0.0388236791,
-0.0040428671,
0.0312268957,
-0.0067765261,
0.0074878423,
0.0523281172,
0.0011325215,
-0.0646944568,
0.0180277806,
-0.01347009,
0.0570956953,
0.0399344563,
-0.0241489857,
0.0011458088,
-0.046837654,
0.0248069372,
0.0223043542,
-0.0040970445,
-0.0042872117,
0.0186350681,
-0.0179085843,
-0.024077097,
-0.0242795683,
0.0224685948,
-0.0018770625,
0.0006338159,
-0.0286357887,
0.0712933466,
-0.0113677308,
-0.023226073,
-0.030332515,
-0.0198228937,
-0.0165070072,
0.0564497709,
0.0267537832,
-0.0290776026,
-0.0512185469,
-0.0157483388,
-0.0228738301,
-0.026145963,
0.0137948925,
0.0067631481,
0.0340219364,
-0.0987640768,
-0.0058328887,
-0.0048351353,
0.0262319762,
0.0621406995,
-0.0072240676,
-0.005380081,
0.0241285935,
0.0061577894,
-0.0661866292,
0.0421618037,
-0.0357326381,
0.0288945735,
-0.0578807555,
-0.015010993,
0.0381490812,
0.0150603829,
-0.0306317899,
0.0110589499,
-0.1289804876,
-0.0775270015,
-0.0002469129,
0.0795053393,
0.02575792,
-0.0009461391,
0.028324334,
-0.0158397444,
0.0622692816,
0.0258704443,
-0.0272170436,
-0.0125383735,
0.0428233258,
-0.0470767766,
0.0037918463,
0.0217242688,
0.0003573546,
0.0007835617,
0.0073043569,
0.0367414802,
-0.0074952827,
-0.0237189177,
-0.0308473371,
-0.0280321371,
0.05235596,
-0.0236978661,
0.0091853505,
-0.0110947499,
0.0239266846,
0.000057589,
0.0190640353,
-0.0534899794,
-0.0020416456,
0.0403868705,
0.0243105218,
0.0101149241,
-0.0003990541,
0.0545415916,
-0.0090372339,
0.0315268487,
0.0152630946,
0.0071409321,
-0.0186396986,
0.0382778682,
-0.0447819419,
-0.0079739215,
0.0002188192,
0.0349342786,
0.0024072048,
-0.0284702592,
0.0529782474,
0.0063213655,
0.0090755355,
-0.0278268382,
0.01312201,
-0.0577847622,
-0.0061330143,
-0.0344289094,
0.0502974987,
0.0973723829,
-0.0265459195,
0.0539814867,
-0.0053550471,
0.0099805044,
-0.0278689209,
0.0415776037,
-0.0201282017,
-0.0220066886,
0.0380986407,
0.0243193898,
-0.0203765705,
0.0235882644,
0.0858311802,
0.0516956821,
0.0471241847,
0.0121458629,
-0.0046532145,
-0.0330815651,
-0.0477537103,
-0.0156596489,
0.0247761719,
-0.0215285048,
-0.0061198692,
-0.043923296,
-0.056648992,
0.0085490001,
-0.0171883777,
-0.0016537532,
-0.0062190173,
0.031408336,
0.0397114307,
-0.0183101501,
-0.0039101755,
-0.0167758409,
-0.0276125409,
0.0434809141,
-0.0226613935,
0.0039913212,
-6.809512409e-33,
0.0006446468,
-0.0075303889,
0.0398592278,
-0.0532709844,
-0.0202538371,
-0.015653098,
-0.0517799631,
0.0029324065,
0.0191979408,
-0.0246386044,
-0.0306088515,
0.0110594202,
0.0142079536,
0.062542595,
0.0096060457,
0.0152672613,
0.0842328593,
0.0227442589,
-0.0093485592,
0.0219993796,
0.0122363809,
0.0527016968,
0.0558674708,
0.0067403447,
-0.040069256,
0.0191564132,
-0.001617949,
-0.0200315174,
-0.0499998741,
0.0188069865,
-0.0355690755,
0.0236134678,
0.0121122692,
-0.0355067998,
-0.0148811443,
-0.0323169343,
-0.0526118837,
0.021304002,
0.0186111871,
0.0057034036,
-0.002469071,
-0.0077453423,
0.0284574423,
0.0478254817,
0.0272005759,
-0.0339345373,
0.0263163168,
-0.0161096212,
-0.0288713984,
-0.0185160711,
0.0042750626,
0.0384360366,
0.0068893908,
0.0035267461,
0.0370408446,
0.0280594062,
-0.0239164028,
-0.0200871117,
-0.0156425256,
-0.011587631,
0.0509693921,
0.0812424272,
0.0532663241,
0.0508754775,
0.0174426567,
0.0192957353,
0.0336105265,
-0.0394634977,
-0.0363053456,
0.0025731698,
0.0498050153,
0.0368441604,
0.0304625779,
-0.0216300245,
0.0282057803,
-0.0242993329,
-0.0720066354,
0.0096004819,
0.0492410623,
0.036284212,
0.0486448035,
0.0048364531,
-0.0085829459,
-0.026327176,
-0.0158654824,
-0.0319296569,
-0.0243372638,
-0.0102298856,
0.0087053608,
0.0577665567,
-0.001128983,
0.0000103788,
0.0546446368,
-0.0240560323,
0.0052587311,
-0.0133731235,
0.001236336,
0.0062839137,
0.00700279,
0.0425902456,
-0.0859043822,
-0.0530830398,
0.0329834111,
-0.0120819015,
-0.0082440786,
-0.0185339451,
0.0054044295,
0.0353276618,
-0.0830860287,
-0.0251792632,
-0.0453203209,
0.0381836481,
-0.0141747072,
0.0717167184,
0.0433288515,
0.0214761887,
-0.0017934728,
0.01636317,
-0.0442278571,
0.0004973759,
-0.0087967766,
-0.0114304097,
0.0185417775,
0.028755853,
-0.0341761746,
0.010231331,
-0.0650160834,
-0.0076993383,
-0.0053020557,
-0.055205036,
-0.0293100532,
0.0371619835,
2.672e-7,
0.0110986903,
0.0342463404,
0.033503443,
-0.0212988183,
0.016779067,
0.0159027539,
-0.0234734956,
0.0090933759,
0.0164711215,
0.0033612312,
0.0272817854,
0.0270200856,
0.0657235682,
0.009044921,
-0.0957696885,
-0.040119648,
-0.0885287151,
0.0241817441,
-0.0638345703,
-0.0226431526,
0.0062626046,
0.1292608231,
0.035286583,
-0.0185061973,
0.0276347399,
0.0027738817,
0.0383689068,
0.0170359761,
0.0203690603,
0.0071711526,
0.0531450734,
0.0441272594,
-0.0103955064,
0.0009597886,
0.0110026021,
0.0306885969,
-0.0272749662,
0.0987153649,
-0.0006837316,
-0.0308596715,
0.0529645607,
0.0233847443,
-0.0320877433,
-0.0324143246,
0.0728962049,
-0.0090741701,
-0.0056045358,
-0.0650605187,
-0.0292774569,
0.0099335341,
-0.017079182,
0.006656433,
-0.0097894315,
0.0462713353,
0.0095952414,
-0.0392142795,
0.0103843659,
-0.082364805,
-0.029236488,
-0.0096647171,
-0.0799092278,
-0.0146590099,
-0.0653401241,
-0.002887672,
0.0217328575,
-0.027953947,
-0.0177561287,
2.852288369e-34,
0.0405618288,
-0.0231190976,
-0.0037230167,
0.0514931828,
0.0020557779,
-0.0427721962,
-0.0296039768,
0.0015470592,
-0.0349172242,
-0.0907969326,
-0.0666152462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00385v1 | Computational Morphology and Lexicography Modeling of Modern Standard Arabic Nominals | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | Christian Khairallah, Reham Marzouk, Salam Khalifa, Mayar Nassar, Nizar Habash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) nominals present many morphological and lexical
modeling challenges that have not been consistently addressed previously. This
paper attempts to define the space of such challenges, and leverage a recently
proposed morphological framework to build a comprehensive and extensible model
for MSA nominals. Our model design addresses the nominals' intricate
morphotactics, as well as their paradigmatic irregularities. Our implementation
showcases enhanced accuracy and consistency compared to a commonly used MSA
morphological analyzer and generator. We make our models publicly available. | [
0.0049084411,
0.0409613252,
-0.0505318306,
0.0117729036,
-0.0759282187,
0.0103715537,
0.0206516087,
0.0300513357,
-0.0816188678,
-0.0125788227,
0.03114512,
-0.0895651579,
0.0765810162,
-0.0176901072,
0.0610534176,
-0.0133135654,
0.0191303939,
-0.0947164372,
-0.0388554521,
0.0081716329,
0.0756230429,
0.0320502967,
-0.0117614549,
0.0012339138,
-0.042587962,
-0.0150966858,
-0.0186637025,
-0.0186032765,
-0.0021154522,
0.0206791945,
-0.0303414203,
0.0620445013,
-0.0323137939,
0.0261404961,
0.0000017742,
-0.0763955042,
-0.0256156474,
-0.0227162074,
-0.0160989724,
0.0170934126,
0.0215737522,
-0.03572217,
-0.0691011027,
-0.0167752467,
0.0187733658,
0.0317141116,
0.0643303841,
-0.0141420988,
-0.0007255377,
-0.0078281723,
0.0014389447,
-0.0785490647,
-0.0052939509,
0.0121137444,
-0.0584170558,
0.0393125266,
0.0085617099,
-0.0149531169,
0.002336124,
-0.0074768262,
-0.0100818276,
0.0181096122,
-0.0399639271,
-0.0453348942,
-0.0553923957,
-0.0196663141,
-0.012806192,
-0.0468963422,
0.0433309712,
-0.0057689655,
0.0093971891,
-0.0376434438,
0.0141464928,
-0.0082823904,
0.0161160417,
0.0094286427,
-0.0095243948,
0.0354579352,
-0.0492772385,
0.0228467733,
0.0829903185,
0.0112046944,
-0.0156447776,
0.0016251922,
-0.0368147343,
0.0384901054,
0.0517636575,
-0.0311707631,
0.0128356619,
0.0078496076,
-0.014115015,
0.0072743124,
0.0390172191,
-0.0284273047,
0.0046373992,
0.0142624835,
-0.0093301795,
-0.0487070642,
0.0418078601,
-0.0385035053,
0.046697665,
0.0282872319,
0.0132943913,
-0.0044525862,
-0.045935072,
0.0155239981,
0.0572189391,
-0.0158870108,
-0.0528977476,
0.0069095944,
-0.0058257338,
-0.0083568739,
-0.0517127328,
0.0272305757,
-0.0455765501,
0.0244379509,
-0.0436414853,
0.0079666488,
0.0213169847,
-0.0125326216,
0.0360813327,
-0.0318728834,
-0.0326061025,
-0.020909803,
-0.0027100029,
-0.0629603267,
-0.0172825716,
-0.0049022143,
-0.072230272,
-0.0644997135,
0.0224140752,
0.0124199428,
0.0098898523,
0.0286598802,
-0.0386726223,
0.0386733711,
-0.0319211036,
-0.0678155124,
0.0139949806,
0.0208091121,
-0.0358480848,
0.0292199533,
-0.043870274,
-0.0285118818,
0.029407572,
-0.0323434547,
-0.0363614969,
0.0134523828,
-0.0091381781,
-0.0069915052,
0.0344204754,
0.0501456857,
-0.0159111302,
0.0001451903,
0.0086655086,
0.0040183202,
0.056967847,
0.0116514079,
0.0228172597,
-0.0081515675,
0.0233597141,
0.0054189735,
0.013016033,
0.0403080843,
-0.0179157443,
-0.01646512,
-0.0780281499,
-0.0582587942,
0.0101475725,
0.0639129803,
-0.0254465882,
0.0592297874,
0.0105197607,
-0.0472082421,
0.0238450654,
0.0696035549,
-0.0213244148,
0.0419088453,
0.020800354,
0.026156228,
0.064047873,
-0.0152529273,
0.0540348142,
-0.0473392159,
-0.0291920993,
0.0343238413,
-0.0665643886,
0.0720785335,
0.0277292393,
-0.0499030873,
-0.039542906,
-0.0185545254,
-0.0300743487,
-0.0302224103,
0.0835685208,
-0.0233602691,
-0.0485111661,
-0.0316865146,
0.0182521157,
-0.0038887477,
-0.012519177,
-0.0536049791,
-0.0036778757,
0.0363670737,
0.0271800663,
-0.0179451257,
-0.0369184799,
0.0323969647,
-0.0604411177,
0.032589443,
-0.0352810994,
-0.0214793514,
-0.0095009878,
-0.0450558886,
0.0178099331,
0.0966146514,
0.041655574,
0.0030561313,
-0.0336804315,
0.0643078014,
-0.0067661512,
-0.0178655181,
-0.005704158,
0.0332390442,
-0.0331938863,
0.0396953672,
-0.025841685,
-0.004554831,
-0.0084417555,
0.0506858118,
-0.0263353921,
0.047010161,
0.0021909724,
-0.0534125045,
0.0001678234,
0.0001741423,
-0.0073938789,
0.0610873848,
0.0681848228,
0.0312875845,
0.0310691036,
-0.0479058623,
0.0449546464,
-0.0222864449,
0.056936767,
-0.0609044358,
0.0421515778,
-0.0537657812,
0.0760340244,
-0.018050652,
0.0348698795,
-0.0465130918,
0.022307016,
-0.0339951105,
-0.0263456013,
-0.0335082337,
-0.0586852916,
0.0188423488,
0.0084673511,
0.0272792187,
0.0075377617,
-0.0018580349,
-0.0058203926,
0.0186157208,
-0.0207936335,
0.0152179105,
-0.0655166358,
-0.0442436635,
-0.042935431,
-0.0088313827,
0.055264134,
-0.0208900515,
0.031498488,
-0.0213641115,
0.0409121588,
0.0394766815,
-0.022071382,
0.0061673508,
0.0213524662,
0.0340427868,
-0.0348109379,
-0.0008504166,
-0.0681621805,
-0.0054055788,
0.0092065306,
0.0486306623,
0.0291849524,
-0.0770106688,
0.0134145208,
-0.0773704425,
-0.0176129993,
0.0215898082,
-0.0031583349,
-0.032971587,
0.0267502908,
-0.022130616,
0.0769085735,
-0.0085223038,
-0.006317466,
0.0104872454,
0.015393828,
-0.0320383646,
-0.0304569174,
-0.0370989665,
0.0213805977,
-0.0077048372,
-0.043321602,
-0.0729789212,
-0.0162979849,
0.0531828925,
-0.0191271361,
0.0076823933,
-0.001695844,
0.0394461676,
-0.029877672,
0.0157810673,
0.0291150063,
0.0273952372,
-0.0405338556,
0.1090599075,
0.0013518566,
-0.0062859268,
0.0125287948,
-0.035636954,
0.03226633,
0.0287707057,
-0.0189122707,
-0.0380954407,
-0.0301960167,
-0.0337533765,
-0.0074641597,
0.0808326006,
-0.0209470466,
-0.0083306478,
0.0129359057,
0.0248160399,
-0.0074167354,
-0.0015641735,
-0.0579609573,
0.0231346618,
0.0219509695,
-0.0082572941,
0.029362265,
0.0226739272,
-0.04998881,
0.0199263971,
0.0214869305,
-0.0166910961,
0.0112162149,
0.056560453,
-0.0442759581,
0.0060012485,
-0.0066748392,
0.0434065275,
-0.0047632931,
0.0149234915,
0.0308052003,
-0.0065291575,
0.013994121,
0.0011720385,
-0.0274299867,
0.0208054278,
-0.0987162888,
0.0130341686,
-0.0391083919,
-0.0166699421,
0.0475443378,
-0.0358235016,
-0.0455889814,
-0.0623047724,
-0.0576901324,
-0.025475584,
0.0201328713,
0.0591831133,
0.0445927866,
0.0407459848,
0.0516218208,
-0.0014185179,
-0.0180496275,
-0.0189484544,
-0.0283305999,
-0.0756349638,
0.0195583459,
0.0557843298,
-0.0071597835,
-0.0009149805,
-0.0168584622,
0.0699995682,
-0.0648539737,
-0.0105967969,
-0.0029498318,
-0.044674471,
-0.0038596485,
-0.0065433164,
0.0369383134,
-0.018644549,
-0.0558837987,
-0.0083368449,
-0.0311856568,
0.0532363951,
0.0512598716,
0.0324441865,
-0.0380423218,
-0.0035339047,
-0.0339324027,
-0.0264153313,
0.0010109188,
0.0254233088,
-0.0230539814,
-0.0300344191,
0.0004760894,
-0.0223079938,
-0.0349946059,
-0.0021873543,
-0.0284549631,
0.0370537601,
-0.0050297789,
-0.0924593359,
-0.0341941603,
-0.0283029005,
-0.0221429653,
-0.0362593085,
0.0162403863,
0.0262893718,
0.0318077952,
-0.0002786128,
0.0052577783,
-0.0625075996,
-0.0153509108,
-0.0309447087,
-0.0269298628,
-0.0718462244,
-0.0093637491,
-0.037356548,
-0.0179132503,
-0.0727294758,
-0.0396540649,
0.0052222656,
-0.0333502665,
-0.088196069,
-0.0321075767,
0.0336311273,
0.0208899118,
0.0088510364,
-0.0241311006,
0.0062025911,
0.0214179996,
-0.037828967,
-0.0522923842,
0.034613438,
0.0232091472,
-0.0579690933,
0.0014588179,
0.0614352077,
-0.0060008876,
0.0304634757,
-0.0050556231,
0.0038404036,
-0.0327631161,
0.0496908389,
-0.0143644623,
0.0130031053,
-0.0524779037,
-0.0186024681,
-0.0263258237,
0.0233493727,
-0.0006527898,
0.0437637046,
0.0335222371,
0.0195619855,
-0.0326919928,
-0.0316882133,
0.0314771049,
0.0533848591,
-0.0068712067,
-0.0201682821,
-0.0013999426,
-0.0781474411,
-0.0323769338,
0.0293587204,
-0.0077834902,
-0.0098807747,
-0.0500599965,
0.0099744536,
-0.0352642536,
-0.0081040487,
-0.0260214172,
0.0149149168,
-0.0090188514,
0.0167398583,
0.0129189696,
0.0149069838,
-0.0316258557,
-0.03519997,
-0.005063449,
0.0110955052,
0.0173644535,
-0.0012133756,
0.023635786,
0.0214487333,
-0.0115268538,
0.0190874357,
0.0487108529,
-0.0124575663,
-0.0667335168,
0.0221542846,
-0.0222159754,
-0.0559100062,
-0.0575257204,
0.0294067878,
-0.0114519149,
0.0597011,
0.0934568495,
0.015305941,
-0.0226002224,
0.0982706696,
0.0379615501,
-0.0308454186,
0.0104790917,
-0.0092376648,
0.0173253454,
0.0016431857,
0.0092768474,
-0.0243131239,
-0.0028461374,
-0.0344285443,
0.0211926326,
0.0039852546,
-0.0066792835,
0.0403079242,
0.0140878232,
-0.0138769802,
0.0248745289,
-0.021711858,
-0.0092082769,
-0.0238070451,
-0.0076247295,
-0.0168775003,
-0.0395764895,
0.029038202,
-0.1074134409,
-0.0724806339,
0.0175691415,
0.052219864,
0.0394152477,
0.0416756272,
0.0197547711,
0.0501966551,
0.0183808692,
0.0072226734,
-0.0442418754,
-0.0126271416,
-0.0056374157,
-0.0177271832,
0.0211917609,
-5.416943557e-33,
0.0018258279,
-0.0018969735,
0.0019967076,
-0.0230386239,
0.024425881,
0.0011686484,
-0.0123720607,
0.0407960117,
0.0362068787,
-0.0110991551,
-0.0282005705,
0.0207421724,
0.0359305255,
-0.0346445516,
0.0697902292,
0.0434180722,
0.0093718171,
-0.0401562192,
0.0189049765,
-0.037033014,
0.0144144259,
0.0101821534,
0.1139757857,
-0.0297301169,
0.0032560667,
0.0141091654,
-0.0409095995,
0.0341255814,
-0.0300313458,
0.0405005813,
-0.0190945081,
0.0238334406,
0.0021370624,
0.0208796449,
0.0219994858,
-0.0362939425,
-0.0441518575,
-0.0144237997,
0.0385681875,
0.0232165493,
-0.0065179509,
-0.024708584,
-0.0672569424,
-0.0126693714,
-0.0598559119,
0.0519104265,
-0.0189045612,
-0.0115272226,
-0.0134008434,
-0.0207564011,
-0.0620112903,
0.0416895673,
0.0130146099,
0.0578995384,
0.075698249,
-0.0351834185,
0.0127020488,
0.0040577338,
0.0373856872,
0.00775168,
0.0566991381,
0.0188410841,
0.0744804889,
0.0202548411,
-0.0873369649,
-0.0277289618,
0.0362469926,
-0.0303137694,
0.0812422708,
0.0704551637,
0.0498057157,
-0.0174890608,
0.0118726268,
0.0619907267,
0.0474667884,
0.0017879442,
0.0062873531,
-0.0075948704,
0.0113044148,
0.0428560339,
-0.0203469079,
0.0133851441,
-0.0569912642,
-0.0004618495,
0.0274612792,
-0.0409733877,
0.0227545109,
0.0353564508,
-0.009374476,
-0.0079274625,
-0.0220329296,
0.1052948609,
-0.0439390093,
0.0465730093,
-0.0019969239,
-0.0581949241,
0.0198814925,
0.0112546859,
-0.0230897572,
0.0319412611,
-0.0106004486,
-0.0391650349,
0.0003824742,
-0.0006258063,
0.0362197496,
0.0122123491,
-0.0347346552,
0.0148214847,
-0.0601363517,
0.0266234744,
-0.0017105647,
0.0168420989,
0.0447799638,
0.0216407776,
0.007487677,
0.0038302422,
0.0145139592,
-0.0221158694,
0.058416456,
-0.0172333326,
-0.0011972723,
-0.0199274253,
-0.0215313956,
-0.0250619687,
0.0291006435,
0.0028554716,
-0.0356642753,
0.0038248445,
0.0379255489,
-0.0325015448,
-0.0140347686,
0.0015953905,
2.574e-7,
0.0458242856,
0.0474120006,
0.028081147,
0.0305904709,
-0.0002716721,
-0.0099695399,
0.0285771061,
-0.0036757102,
-0.0037192313,
0.0204514507,
0.0209007617,
-0.040497046,
-0.0011274396,
-0.0206719618,
-0.0445930399,
0.01247181,
0.0130068623,
-0.0024914306,
-0.0666410699,
0.0065666833,
0.0107767461,
0.0945998356,
-0.0315508284,
-0.0271434113,
-0.0466132201,
-0.0225091968,
0.0233205706,
-0.0047035017,
-0.0012964789,
0.0435776561,
0.0764635801,
-0.0750502273,
0.0348047316,
0.0016779471,
-0.0008503294,
0.0198554937,
0.0704315603,
0.036220558,
-0.0141627956,
0.0661741197,
0.0242042467,
-0.0665803775,
-0.0146960169,
-0.0020272743,
0.0328834243,
0.0655945837,
0.0044238744,
0.0121574458,
-0.0528164022,
0.059729334,
-0.0059967106,
-0.0216719303,
-0.0048373826,
0.0261943787,
0.0411512889,
-0.0058205235,
-0.005989918,
-0.0016499739,
0.0256328527,
-0.0063968911,
0.0055938712,
0.0225940477,
0.0249665733,
-0.0103903171,
-0.0132810399,
-0.0091786617,
-0.0184267405,
2.215702388e-34,
0.0243846029,
0.0206627138,
0.0367893502,
0.0754585341,
-0.0033289196,
0.006780372,
0.0174425282,
0.0659335032,
-0.0114513179,
0.0028947408,
0.0010551104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00371v1 | What Does the Bot Say? Opportunities and Risks of Large Language Models in Social Media Bot Detection | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | Shangbin Feng, Herun Wan, Ningnan Wang, Zhaoxuan Tan, Minnan Luo, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media bot detection has always been an arms race between advancements
in machine learning bot detectors and adversarial bot strategies to evade
detection. In this work, we bring the arms race to the next level by
investigating the opportunities and risks of state-of-the-art large language
models (LLMs) in social bot detection. To investigate the opportunities, we
design novel LLM-based bot detectors by proposing a
mixture-of-heterogeneous-experts framework to divide and conquer diverse user
information modalities. To illuminate the risks, we explore the possibility of
LLM-guided manipulation of user textual and structured information to evade
detection. Extensive experiments with three LLMs on two datasets demonstrate
that instruction tuning on merely 1,000 annotated examples produces specialized
LLMs that outperform state-of-the-art baselines by up to 9.1% on both datasets,
while LLM-guided manipulation strategies could significantly bring down the
performance of existing bot detectors by up to 29.6% and harm the calibration
and reliability of bot detection systems. | [
0.0930070803,
0.0409225523,
-0.0194386616,
0.0269462746,
-0.0334319547,
0.0042197523,
0.013539522,
-0.0002910608,
0.0491599888,
-0.0514957458,
-0.0368903689,
-0.0242075622,
-0.0035968998,
0.0321793705,
0.0324860923,
-0.0234987922,
0.0220108591,
-0.0158682782,
0.0167935248,
0.0045400891,
0.0258868132,
0.0009209086,
-0.0177290924,
0.0489802472,
-0.0369434468,
0.0069897445,
-0.0078606354,
0.0244767796,
0.0059902007,
0.0075364066,
0.0246422533,
0.0703460202,
0.0280678067,
0.1075800136,
0.0000018709,
-0.0306317713,
-0.0303236395,
-0.007153125,
-0.03167006,
-0.0035236769,
0.0598575361,
-0.0310713444,
-0.0119873649,
0.0375679322,
-0.0562024973,
0.0491865017,
0.0485095978,
0.0369138494,
0.0565396957,
0.130385071,
-0.0112871602,
0.0025410007,
0.0543816164,
-0.0295604784,
-0.0011402451,
-0.0404776111,
0.0373294614,
0.0008458962,
-0.0249920506,
0.0681122541,
-0.0085581709,
0.0206885189,
0.0090464512,
-0.0111795897,
0.0073862039,
-0.0235591996,
-0.0110383192,
-0.0261137709,
-0.0002745892,
0.0476072393,
-0.0230240058,
-0.0056714849,
0.0130539462,
0.0290885605,
0.0286860727,
-0.0008569622,
-0.0213651061,
0.0205702819,
-0.0025210436,
-0.0070158024,
-0.0052736076,
-0.0394642986,
0.0411725752,
0.0731388628,
-0.0180251002,
0.0090530831,
-0.0153721301,
-0.0253299829,
-0.036350321,
-0.0109607093,
-0.020124482,
-0.031242989,
0.0483305603,
0.0258886367,
-0.0468659066,
-0.0034092865,
-0.089217335,
-0.0763884708,
0.0135895414,
-0.038373366,
-0.0214199908,
0.0317617171,
-0.0134110292,
0.069751747,
-0.0203472078,
0.0199224968,
-0.0345570669,
0.0300500728,
0.0084333522,
-0.0268850196,
-0.0340956822,
-0.0154511053,
-0.006980049,
-0.0064682667,
0.0024519479,
-0.0144362655,
-0.0593472272,
0.0464070663,
-0.0292676855,
0.0052774036,
-0.0351986811,
-0.001063621,
-0.016279893,
0.0049484167,
-0.0073714931,
0.0084566884,
0.0032011697,
0.0337271877,
0.0142498733,
-0.0696538687,
-0.0308047235,
0.063136369,
-0.0250583794,
-0.0388371199,
0.0240889303,
0.0514615513,
0.0181867275,
-0.0302155353,
0.0121015832,
-0.0531990528,
-0.0177214332,
-0.0263745543,
-0.0034983119,
-0.0771412328,
0.0356615186,
0.0186603591,
-0.0017518087,
-0.0494925827,
-0.011959495,
0.0246670283,
-0.0775508434,
0.0606999621,
-0.0277662259,
0.0130846025,
0.0130657963,
0.0101984804,
-0.0535733439,
0.0679905638,
-0.0098528769,
0.0939263776,
0.0529568903,
0.0079438873,
0.0311901793,
0.0534076057,
-0.0024154622,
0.0356936119,
-0.0027725087,
-0.0148742199,
-0.0024145949,
-0.0232855286,
0.0077872043,
0.0542827137,
-0.0049367002,
-0.0245867744,
0.0960141271,
0.034459684,
-0.0617672242,
0.0074508549,
0.0553035773,
0.0418526717,
0.0185501464,
-0.0155273452,
-0.0550103448,
-0.0119805848,
-0.073201865,
-0.0819921792,
0.0362774134,
0.0629842952,
-0.0149535388,
-0.0158571564,
0.0126494477,
-0.0184191242,
0.0344802104,
0.0139540443,
0.0281812344,
-0.0020542729,
-0.0117182825,
0.0321126357,
0.0239192788,
-0.0005829023,
-0.0222293325,
-0.054529611,
-0.0252373628,
0.0406072475,
0.0050000539,
-0.0415921137,
0.0186349489,
-0.0411057733,
0.0006631872,
0.0238936134,
0.032922551,
0.016832592,
-0.0117149763,
-0.0160558484,
-0.0271818563,
-0.0207520258,
0.000347065,
-0.01914238,
0.0570094474,
0.0030342697,
0.0083746584,
-0.0035272199,
-0.0022136299,
0.0272618588,
0.008567703,
0.0184699111,
-0.0094181513,
0.0393931195,
0.0407273434,
-0.0022491333,
-0.0005634264,
-0.0187630896,
0.0210630354,
-0.0090385228,
-0.0630185604,
-0.0643413439,
-0.0055619343,
-0.0220421124,
0.044783894,
0.0086612971,
-0.0414106809,
0.0267893318,
-0.0408470593,
0.0289140008,
0.0654810295,
-0.0580854937,
0.0136632109,
-0.0125174625,
0.0037581576,
-0.0170348193,
0.0850522742,
0.0049905712,
0.0550728478,
-0.0390654467,
-0.043489486,
0.0420715772,
-0.0153307533,
-0.0272844881,
0.0137307206,
-0.0145670436,
4.29e-7,
-0.0262502488,
0.0472764522,
0.0314653479,
0.0093652876,
-0.0417110659,
-0.0639895126,
-0.1130585968,
0.0022334841,
-0.0367310382,
-0.0284750052,
0.0380198359,
-0.0034357733,
0.007106435,
0.0187695138,
-0.0085517121,
-0.00072113,
-0.0114591653,
0.0470524356,
0.0180720929,
-0.0398030952,
-0.0468457229,
-0.0214929171,
-0.0001235449,
-0.0118114473,
0.0489320494,
0.0052996851,
-0.0617253147,
0.0010125662,
-0.0052258642,
-0.0259558242,
0.0108207557,
-0.0328506343,
-0.045484852,
0.0195631273,
-0.011691994,
0.0165246688,
0.0505229905,
0.0340344943,
0.04156854,
0.0317546315,
0.0249589235,
-0.0438435376,
0.0074621025,
0.0147069544,
-0.0198846459,
-0.0571813583,
-0.0249648821,
0.0032378363,
0.0537280217,
0.0321420506,
-0.0118526723,
-0.0147041194,
0.0525280163,
-0.002306358,
-0.05208233,
-0.016492052,
-0.0159461349,
-0.0012890389,
-0.0100639295,
-0.0447282456,
-0.0627863407,
0.0861330926,
0.0020814941,
0.0273520406,
0.0070264349,
-0.0808797553,
-0.0249564182,
-0.0035231959,
0.0350932963,
0.0277369171,
-0.0295609646,
0.0170455649,
-0.0200942028,
-0.0023944336,
0.0147358458,
-0.0321398601,
0.0188643821,
0.003606268,
0.0236110035,
0.0198325403,
-0.0231646318,
-0.0637962818,
-0.0899958462,
-0.0477350578,
0.0194485951,
0.0407448374,
-0.0631825924,
-0.0698705018,
-0.0022114778,
0.0475031212,
-0.0111530721,
-0.0172850061,
0.0054657809,
-0.0282563698,
-0.0008006877,
0.0069460711,
-0.0179971866,
0.0081012398,
-0.0517475307,
0.018651342,
0.0722156316,
-0.0075919558,
-0.041225899,
-0.0242094491,
0.0007863289,
0.0206653029,
0.0114328526,
-0.012480882,
0.0083016045,
0.0591994636,
-0.0332702324,
0.0404056199,
0.0860989317,
0.0043275012,
-0.0294172373,
-0.0000475321,
0.0028604972,
0.0207388569,
0.0090965526,
-0.0123527274,
-0.0777649581,
-0.0485456958,
0.0230217669,
0.0021942954,
-0.0304210838,
-0.0286571458,
-0.0235544909,
-0.060980849,
-0.0163451303,
0.0133385547,
-0.0669331178,
-0.0479014628,
-0.0421625674,
-0.020200463,
0.0028438549,
0.041577749,
-0.0279241726,
-0.0047060112,
-0.0093310587,
-0.016367577,
-0.0442627221,
-0.0276708975,
0.0033524046,
-0.027502045,
0.0519779474,
0.0303833615,
0.0234413669,
-0.0228158142,
0.0253807288,
0.0053082542,
0.0463016517,
0.0088497018,
-0.0128379092,
0.0837873593,
-0.0270791538,
-0.013259829,
-0.0106711676,
0.0210900567,
-0.0278437119,
-0.0155628519,
0.0094278343,
0.0207072366,
0.0042405571,
-0.0056238901,
-0.0138007756,
-0.0077789347,
0.0389172733,
0.0677678734,
0.0370795466,
-0.0577769242,
-0.0078844167,
-0.0644781739,
-0.0431951992,
0.0019211269,
-0.0517795831,
-0.0002191249,
-0.0349788964,
-0.0421603844,
-0.0256488267,
-0.0090112323,
0.0371114127,
-0.0051809121,
0.0058560572,
0.0262372494,
-0.0124321664,
-0.004178308,
-0.0176088177,
0.0479308963,
-0.0526893139,
0.0715948939,
-0.0524108037,
-0.0104842484,
0.0094779395,
-0.0545444936,
0.0107130436,
0.0379747413,
-0.0944392234,
-0.0876284242,
0.0027056907,
0.0539472997,
0.0157445837,
0.0384303443,
-0.0359356143,
-0.0749478713,
0.0531700104,
0.025898505,
-0.0248685647,
0.0076467046,
0.0382433049,
0.0233638473,
0.0098266797,
0.0374111496,
-0.0208883602,
-0.0193935391,
0.0499074869,
-0.0368348733,
-0.0773234367,
0.0072129834,
0.0169024915,
0.0284227207,
0.0288845096,
0.0112239812,
-0.0271882508,
0.0163670722,
-0.0426334813,
-0.0023736064,
-0.0509798378,
-0.0018916315,
-0.005087025,
0.031011261,
-0.0053188,
0.022263309,
0.0400820374,
-0.0065634968,
0.0242700819,
-0.011542039,
0.0025369495,
-0.0343039334,
0.0292088408,
0.0549314208,
0.0089616291,
-0.0194185022,
0.0364210382,
0.0067206975,
0.0171923861,
0.0029860761,
0.0076810871,
-0.022544302,
-0.0218747966,
-0.0045263474,
-0.0056144646,
-0.0344614871,
-0.0764194205,
0.0082105687,
0.034960214,
0.0458949767,
0.0045886426,
0.0549665503,
0.0017452461,
-0.011239985,
-0.0198693331,
0.0086389491,
-0.0018773535,
-0.0111639965,
-0.0258735139,
0.0017068215,
-0.0294595864,
0.0269688033,
0.066774562,
0.0038807949,
0.0341580883,
0.0126239825,
-0.0748982355,
-0.0222613774,
-0.0144894095,
0.0193252526,
0.0224215519,
-0.0116052702,
0.0219343491,
-0.0371049121,
-0.0671440586,
-0.0399718955,
-0.0638269559,
-0.0222887304,
0.0174239427,
-0.0245983228,
0.0593000874,
-0.0220004991,
0.0294606704,
-0.0763200298,
0.013189177,
0.0505766608,
-0.0571440086,
0.0044199447,
-6.418976451e-33,
0.0263363924,
-0.044380758,
-0.0132406252,
-0.0560986325,
0.007818372,
0.0413587615,
0.0067630527,
0.0081122229,
-0.038269937,
0.0039563333,
-0.0204457529,
0.0198668521,
-0.0084292926,
0.0289393179,
-0.0257001948,
0.0157106873,
0.0580039844,
-0.0088329362,
-0.0238156095,
0.0045123161,
0.0495763943,
-0.0182006024,
0.0284296069,
-0.077918902,
0.0319370255,
0.0261405427,
-0.0234223399,
0.0239802822,
0.0022262936,
0.0438346975,
-0.0070864679,
0.0647899136,
0.0485461988,
0.0099410377,
-0.0091942204,
0.0292532444,
-0.0075402791,
0.0268057194,
-0.00066014,
0.0221482366,
-0.0021221777,
-0.0545380302,
0.0639523193,
-0.0219374131,
0.0018926675,
0.0205162317,
0.0347012058,
-0.0127930297,
0.0290536843,
0.0046648304,
-0.0146258958,
0.0213824511,
-0.0412303209,
-0.0209497567,
-0.0000789574,
0.0463949926,
0.0552871227,
0.0187207032,
-0.0798138753,
0.0426715501,
-0.0094787534,
0.0030513189,
0.0432588533,
-0.0082997186,
-0.0061679999,
0.0582138859,
0.0220316276,
0.0480051264,
-0.0449548364,
-0.0342023708,
-0.017247241,
0.0612256639,
0.0222000796,
0.0378042236,
0.0206631329,
-0.0593950413,
-0.0953568742,
0.0057241251,
0.074256368,
0.0324412771,
0.0523611605,
-0.0003484866,
-0.0551387593,
0.0053189187,
-0.0316819549,
-0.0203503259,
-0.0488228723,
-0.0188280214,
-0.0217730198,
0.0315779783,
-0.0326194651,
-0.0386480317,
0.0326803178,
-0.0795462504,
-0.0149464337,
0.04886261,
-0.0236141663,
0.0081515415,
0.0283690784,
0.0403365344,
-0.0265454482,
-0.0230461508,
0.0584983751,
-0.0760925338,
0.0053986064,
-0.012478387,
0.0420432016,
0.0302889682,
-0.0436726511,
-0.0188542716,
-0.0159933548,
0.0323012099,
-0.0140734324,
0.0226651449,
0.0321754627,
0.0195214041,
-0.023055274,
0.0263030883,
0.0288600996,
-0.0068692123,
0.0054705343,
0.0070398012,
-0.0249667224,
-0.0085654333,
-0.0236876402,
0.0016773315,
-0.026690362,
-0.0201436318,
0.0287274811,
-0.0736828521,
-0.0039003007,
-0.0453109816,
2.679e-7,
0.0045902655,
0.0633659065,
-0.0363795757,
0.0038871302,
0.0402639508,
0.0833615065,
0.0262081586,
0.0382893682,
-0.0261780862,
-0.0541313291,
-0.0203554239,
0.0865481421,
0.0361156426,
0.004054423,
-0.0299096052,
-0.0101938453,
-0.016717555,
-0.0005143031,
-0.0713385418,
-0.0134679945,
0.0037734008,
0.1049347967,
0.05645255,
-0.0382144041,
-0.0183553249,
-0.0686577857,
0.0422893912,
-0.0106596733,
-0.037406411,
0.042572476,
0.08119753,
0.0329081938,
0.0376372933,
0.0400398225,
0.0021773318,
0.0132938605,
0.0151293557,
0.0806198418,
0.0200442113,
0.0080427285,
-0.0143162301,
-0.0269787088,
-0.0005275137,
-0.0175265279,
0.0650481433,
-0.0232865773,
-0.0517912656,
-0.0473074391,
-0.0183968097,
-0.0380184315,
0.043832384,
-0.0466895625,
-0.0374035202,
0.0505739115,
0.0104094464,
0.0046588085,
-0.0083844773,
-0.0495169535,
0.0008433267,
-0.0315999202,
-0.0756950453,
-0.0485286079,
-0.008614176,
-0.003515078,
0.0554185361,
0.0049870186,
0.0507772639,
2.45535607e-34,
0.0427644216,
-0.0049338867,
0.0211161282,
0.0199093986,
0.0398129784,
0.0244036429,
-0.0374121927,
-0.004830278,
0.0216235388,
-0.0561960973,
0.0086660525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00367v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00367v2 | Don't Hallucinate, Abstain: Identifying LLM Knowledge Gaps via Multi-LLM Collaboration | 2024-02-01T06:11:49 | 2024-07-01T01:34:09 | Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yike Wang, Wenxuan Ding, Vidhisha Balachandran, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite efforts to expand the knowledge of large language models (LLMs),
knowledge gaps -- missing or outdated information in LLMs -- might always
persist given the evolving nature of knowledge. In this work, we study
approaches to identify LLM knowledge gaps and abstain from answering questions
when knowledge gaps are present. We first adapt existing approaches to model
calibration or adaptation through fine-tuning/prompting and analyze their
ability to abstain from generating low-confidence outputs. Motivated by their
failures in self-reflection and over-reliance on held-out sets, we propose two
novel approaches that are based on model collaboration, i.e., LLMs probing
other LLMs for knowledge gaps, either cooperatively or competitively. Extensive
experiments with three LLMs on four QA tasks featuring diverse knowledge
domains demonstrate that both cooperative and competitive approaches to
unveiling LLM knowledge gaps achieve up to 19.3% improvements on abstain
accuracy against the strongest baseline. Further analysis reveals that our
proposed mechanisms could help identify failure cases in retrieval augmentation
and pinpoint knowledge gaps in multi-hop reasoning. | [
0.0367070809,
0.0587624833,
-0.0338559039,
0.048295185,
-0.068940945,
0.0143272448,
-0.0021865068,
-0.0206654035,
0.0295197684,
-0.0522896275,
-0.0477710441,
-0.0361063369,
-0.0223015193,
-0.0068580289,
0.0150757087,
0.0326718166,
0.0702947378,
-0.0329268873,
-0.027399417,
-0.042761337,
-0.0319641493,
0.0196210593,
-0.0281710606,
0.017871948,
0.0005485411,
-0.0313354917,
-0.0226628743,
-0.0297513846,
-0.0079731764,
-0.0128217172,
0.0268436465,
0.0625075474,
0.0009907909,
0.0253971554,
0.0000020396,
-0.064355582,
-0.0364015549,
-0.01498562,
-0.042434521,
0.0015961722,
-0.06102404,
0.0143247051,
0.0437999032,
-0.0002171169,
-0.0525558479,
0.037583489,
0.0065012989,
0.033026237,
0.0379884355,
0.0506211296,
0.0373931937,
0.0202929173,
0.0134681398,
-0.0257001929,
0.0450931154,
-0.0438546836,
0.0297001842,
0.0590573996,
0.0214573424,
0.0199497584,
-0.0007764794,
0.0579374991,
0.0260577574,
-0.0077997767,
-0.0096844463,
0.017454695,
-0.0217638314,
-0.016471697,
-0.0112758037,
0.0538951419,
0.0420924164,
-0.0225484744,
-0.0379621796,
0.0019174728,
0.0207459275,
0.0515489578,
-0.0542613678,
-0.0029216392,
-0.0148917977,
-0.0036628298,
-0.0280308258,
-0.0506208092,
0.0604665726,
0.0090142135,
-0.0004197036,
0.1207796484,
-0.0011303932,
-0.0418540314,
-0.004403573,
0.023300441,
-0.0408240408,
-0.0291240197,
0.0136653846,
0.0533070751,
-0.0604100563,
0.0347398445,
0.0254237466,
0.0059413142,
0.0499596521,
0.009124767,
0.0053827586,
0.0255430322,
-0.0373650491,
0.0773795992,
-0.0379313752,
0.0120541183,
-0.0007425847,
0.0230733305,
-0.028738033,
-0.011251484,
-0.0658844113,
-0.0434418842,
-0.0170012042,
0.0445271358,
-0.0248801466,
0.0116230492,
0.0000913239,
0.0376206338,
-0.0302639194,
0.0300137307,
0.0034927516,
0.0193179641,
-0.0056925365,
-0.0373680182,
-0.0549216047,
0.0691233575,
-0.0226176661,
0.0373055078,
0.0170462262,
-0.0777028054,
-0.0557359122,
0.0065258294,
-0.0191074982,
-0.0237232596,
0.0019749135,
0.024472449,
-0.015908381,
-0.0273177754,
-0.0074759265,
-0.0496421792,
-0.0176336486,
-0.0864732936,
-0.0043220976,
-0.0439810753,
0.0346645191,
0.0120787825,
-0.0002550162,
-0.0369285904,
0.0151718734,
0.0056554996,
-0.0099712284,
0.0870505944,
-0.0093280999,
0.0174593125,
0.0342457183,
0.0183484815,
-0.0526483878,
0.0933487415,
-0.0147005208,
-0.0169413686,
0.0485057905,
0.0066301459,
0.0159840342,
0.0003697199,
0.0418058485,
0.0153457783,
0.0084512541,
0.0225614291,
0.0293166302,
0.0201482195,
-0.014708275,
0.031899631,
-0.028801173,
-0.0219701454,
0.0420032963,
0.0400933288,
0.0226010811,
-0.014254774,
0.0197722912,
-0.0555581339,
0.0122062815,
0.0244625583,
-0.0640434399,
0.043493744,
-0.046792917,
-0.002558969,
0.0311629232,
0.0363666601,
-0.0389970541,
-0.0376359485,
-0.0208984315,
0.0062238681,
-0.0154263098,
0.0525523424,
0.0586678386,
0.0132559976,
-0.0199575853,
0.0752276629,
0.0028795053,
-0.0340907909,
0.0314729474,
-0.0503309406,
0.0676169544,
0.0367423333,
0.0583088621,
-0.0401381925,
-0.063781634,
0.0140088452,
0.0184345748,
-0.0072995462,
0.072174482,
-0.0249237679,
0.0129136713,
-0.0307267103,
-0.0386484414,
-0.0254237354,
0.0264114402,
-0.0048421016,
0.0224779807,
-0.0066951043,
0.0252669379,
-0.074555628,
0.0423345827,
0.0247540921,
-0.0675062314,
0.0203976054,
-0.0271207187,
-0.0034847953,
0.0131821502,
0.0256028045,
0.0186560117,
0.0396076106,
0.0417481251,
-0.0140475547,
-0.0507413372,
0.0123326676,
-0.0099400515,
-0.0524319634,
0.0358044319,
0.0288464185,
-0.0289861429,
0.0036884949,
-0.0374996141,
-0.0478448756,
0.0382313132,
0.0159136169,
0.0287251193,
-0.0716010258,
0.0307051912,
0.0023237972,
-0.0189551488,
-0.0398328155,
0.0816393793,
-0.0164329391,
0.0355444811,
-0.0076145674,
0.0283279903,
0.0135723418,
-0.0352606848,
-0.0275397487,
0.0224460233,
0.0043977899,
0.0000613752,
0.0223371461,
-0.0229088496,
-0.0790439844,
-0.011881399,
-0.0819651186,
0.0044278502,
-0.0319947302,
0.0369903147,
-0.0065950551,
0.0028524122,
-0.0029173451,
-0.0262522604,
-0.0063163703,
0.0042184293,
0.0072528045,
0.041589357,
0.0128944609,
0.0406529941,
0.010352876,
-0.0263593514,
-0.0020391364,
-0.0106955217,
0.0325461887,
-0.0063978485,
-0.0004967039,
-0.072016187,
0.0020148018,
-0.074092336,
0.0213718358,
-0.0158682242,
0.0106264921,
0.0242087655,
-0.0267220922,
0.0024636798,
0.0367295146,
-0.0376102775,
-0.0139047047,
0.0719832852,
-0.0124677792,
-0.0809924752,
0.0457042195,
-0.0284269191,
-0.0220945347,
-0.0440663844,
-0.0043936786,
-0.0032061171,
0.0434257947,
0.0001610071,
-0.0370982289,
-0.0447622798,
0.0103515824,
-0.0079524191,
-0.0327236205,
-0.042086564,
-0.0298493057,
0.001782718,
0.0312795714,
-0.0222030617,
-0.0399206094,
0.10563384,
-0.0227940995,
-0.0004874797,
-0.0252023134,
0.0128204962,
-0.0497441627,
0.0737902597,
-0.0377378464,
0.0031440502,
-0.0003224357,
-0.0140337264,
-0.051900059,
-0.0080346521,
0.0108513236,
-0.0495576002,
0.0457670838,
-0.0570983142,
0.0228539724,
0.0060508274,
-0.0201486815,
-0.0450478941,
-0.0026887476,
-0.0545263812,
0.0094202412,
-0.036262054,
0.0109031256,
-0.0378639475,
-0.0059838188,
0.0022871445,
0.0019172488,
-0.0151911117,
0.0053056255,
-0.0098386165,
-0.0010574022,
0.0374383926,
0.0335955061,
0.0212822352,
-0.0526780635,
0.0298252907,
0.0622751564,
0.0412554406,
-0.0047428329,
0.0304854643,
-0.017485505,
0.0366048776,
-0.0159495603,
-0.0021294269,
-0.0103069348,
0.0636607632,
-0.0379137062,
-0.0191106368,
0.1044079065,
0.0581601113,
-0.0329477713,
-0.0092956359,
-0.0776179209,
0.0220470112,
0.0342006385,
0.0188052598,
-0.0742371678,
-0.0161682237,
0.0103162779,
0.0225068163,
-0.0040841508,
-0.0337710418,
0.0015887027,
-0.1302259117,
0.0275804792,
0.0035654095,
-0.0208800975,
-0.0254367366,
-0.0414816327,
0.0363177732,
0.0140820928,
0.0527962185,
0.0339606926,
0.0248947404,
0.0045932201,
0.0265627261,
-0.0077386517,
-0.0495750122,
0.0299212839,
-0.0090805003,
0.0757436529,
0.0396258496,
-0.002582541,
0.0302468687,
-0.0516249724,
0.0464646555,
-0.0358744375,
0.0470121503,
-0.0361535922,
0.0242151935,
0.0023583511,
0.006560517,
0.0329453237,
0.0087498575,
-0.0357768759,
-0.0296327658,
0.0169777013,
0.0733980015,
-0.0445563905,
0.0008826004,
0.0062990221,
0.0201914292,
0.0024807407,
0.0843803287,
0.0343514532,
0.0196361262,
-0.0027684232,
0.0003180726,
0.0103921406,
-0.0452526361,
0.0072737052,
0.0435946546,
0.0259921309,
0.0572040863,
-0.0302415881,
-0.0638705567,
0.0528333485,
0.0087006064,
-0.0072183441,
0.0423872992,
-0.0215052105,
-0.0051325867,
-0.0241700504,
0.0311840195,
-0.0585987382,
0.002766581,
0.0105063077,
0.0282498468,
0.0020710872,
-0.011206409,
0.003403639,
-0.032900881,
-0.1149661839,
-0.0802429169,
-0.02657138,
0.0477403887,
0.0257701054,
0.0424051136,
-0.0267059896,
-0.0598889068,
0.025272591,
0.0312002636,
-0.0113625107,
0.0156439636,
0.0021319275,
-0.0095525002,
-0.030637566,
0.0565990396,
-0.0623428263,
-0.0324342102,
0.0130817322,
0.095038712,
-0.0328697599,
-0.044036299,
0.033561945,
-0.0033973583,
0.0435754806,
0.0198889077,
0.0091574928,
-0.0218198635,
0.0427940227,
-0.0165058635,
-0.0362086259,
-0.022503417,
0.0043490361,
0.0025894342,
-0.0677370802,
0.0398088545,
-0.0087737571,
0.0081978999,
0.0768868327,
-0.0434404314,
0.0019267909,
0.0230323356,
-0.0259534512,
0.0092137586,
0.008532404,
-0.0171185732,
-0.0067875437,
0.0118847732,
0.0523926616,
0.0179805625,
0.054901056,
0.0161849074,
-0.0120538305,
-0.0289417356,
-0.0126689915,
-0.0693858862,
-0.0759707838,
0.0091443118,
0.062975727,
0.0362997353,
0.0254161451,
0.031620618,
-0.0142685054,
-0.0175824128,
-0.0032439728,
-0.0122427791,
0.0064161969,
-0.010686662,
0.057724271,
0.0312116295,
-0.0033373919,
0.0140813338,
0.073869817,
-0.0589868277,
0.0839608088,
-0.0177185312,
-0.0135977967,
-0.0213220101,
-0.0622656234,
0.0014690005,
0.0108292801,
-0.0372625403,
0.0243636165,
-0.0641106069,
-0.0826051906,
0.0062592695,
0.020654073,
-0.0377525315,
-0.0062979106,
-0.0291161407,
0.078267917,
0.0114538306,
-0.0453391336,
-0.0419400521,
0.004122565,
-0.0129216462,
0.0151263457,
-0.0130680287,
-6.759556837e-33,
-0.0406154916,
-0.0691568777,
0.0390273668,
-0.0521074794,
-0.0183955431,
-0.0006288253,
-0.033421319,
0.0027025081,
-0.0517654903,
-0.0037531834,
-0.0016747611,
0.0220520552,
0.0070157694,
-0.0020664926,
0.0506387278,
-0.0176716615,
0.0334075391,
0.0099546649,
-0.0362342261,
-0.0085214302,
0.0151182888,
0.0309731551,
0.0518475696,
-0.0271580461,
0.0730618611,
-0.0225021727,
-0.0207157452,
0.0839765668,
-0.0539535433,
0.0495788157,
0.0007434531,
0.0278687235,
0.0163711384,
-0.0369270593,
-0.0107452851,
-0.0342953838,
-0.0406881198,
-0.0459185652,
0.0617180727,
-0.0159935877,
-0.0231004972,
-0.0191333555,
0.0130441207,
-0.0033663798,
0.0157918073,
0.0002143845,
0.0078799892,
-0.0251414739,
-0.0152594522,
0.0321833342,
-0.0018994693,
0.0004055093,
-0.0125534078,
-0.024919441,
-0.0136893261,
0.0816287696,
0.0292028766,
-0.0014411651,
-0.0629878938,
0.0199828539,
-0.0120911719,
0.0076970649,
0.0801178366,
0.0228541847,
0.0045636776,
0.0533007123,
-0.0116076451,
0.0245708525,
-0.029352434,
-0.0353372321,
0.0123653924,
0.0432613865,
0.0184762031,
0.0322548561,
-0.0112604005,
0.0146724777,
-0.024090752,
0.0066763912,
0.0092425402,
0.0501463637,
0.0307387244,
0.0249197222,
-0.0383398049,
-0.0163274277,
-0.0487651415,
0.0274303984,
-0.0459386632,
-0.0396265611,
0.0248805601,
0.0173534211,
-0.0282566026,
0.0248404946,
0.0058020414,
-0.0363149568,
-0.0218693949,
0.0012191848,
0.0173690673,
-0.0005376039,
-0.0207566582,
0.0415799282,
-0.0442087352,
-0.0321057439,
0.0129568996,
0.0163439214,
-0.0023625481,
0.0118314251,
0.0311859045,
0.0010196926,
-0.0483533479,
-0.0049495045,
-0.0431430787,
0.011375634,
0.0083280792,
-0.0320329666,
0.0253502484,
0.0348463655,
-0.0221366677,
0.0280610099,
0.0357606597,
-0.0116655203,
-0.0277858265,
-0.0002150615,
-0.0166345723,
-0.0259740055,
-0.0022263692,
-0.0123833753,
-0.0053327666,
-0.0008110999,
0.0058752508,
-0.0092707667,
-0.0109896362,
0.0255353842,
2.821e-7,
0.0510545708,
0.0138187828,
0.0068233307,
0.0068546347,
0.009978517,
0.0213890877,
-0.0584892705,
-0.0057598264,
0.0546694212,
-0.0357693397,
0.0194196589,
0.0484207384,
0.0414439552,
0.0397114083,
-0.0525235347,
0.0079014143,
-0.0357703753,
-0.0340897739,
-0.0345054828,
-0.0420504808,
0.0376846977,
0.0356834084,
0.020512484,
-0.0015775774,
-0.041949641,
-0.0687373951,
0.074909769,
-0.025692774,
-0.0503119193,
0.0457808748,
0.0765207335,
0.0094468528,
0.0384170152,
0.0426503681,
0.0033240528,
0.0182163026,
-0.0215124469,
0.0127302194,
0.016160721,
-0.0580186956,
-0.0565728396,
0.0075794235,
0.0268493388,
-0.0511422865,
0.0883778855,
-0.0318114385,
-0.0112333531,
-0.0122156953,
0.0063063749,
-0.0141976597,
0.0226456597,
0.0069467095,
-0.0089983083,
0.0180513281,
-0.0031612432,
0.0124242017,
-0.0104495632,
-0.0835863203,
-0.0550699756,
0.0076641114,
-0.0606273375,
-0.0697434545,
0.0135420132,
-0.0360741951,
-0.0136141134,
-0.069249168,
0.0166899897,
2.376664988e-34,
0.0432034992,
0.0113400053,
0.0180917438,
0.0695612431,
0.0308000855,
-0.0297334157,
-0.0332811922,
0.0130166402,
0.0083855717,
-0.0756318644,
-0.0109424908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00345v1 | IndiVec: An Exploration of Leveraging Large Language Models for Media Bias Detection with Fine-Grained Bias Indicators | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | Luyang Lin, Lingzhi Wang, Xiaoyan Zhao, Jing Li, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study focuses on media bias detection, crucial in today's era of
influential social media platforms shaping individual attitudes and opinions.
In contrast to prior work that primarily relies on training specific models
tailored to particular datasets, resulting in limited adaptability and subpar
performance on out-of-domain data, we introduce a general bias detection
framework, IndiVec, built upon large language models. IndiVec begins by
constructing a fine-grained media bias database, leveraging the robust
instruction-following capabilities of large language models and vector database
techniques. When confronted with new input for bias detection, our framework
automatically selects the most relevant indicator from the vector database and
employs majority voting to determine the input's bias label. IndiVec excels
compared to previous methods due to its adaptability (demonstrating consistent
performance across diverse datasets from various sources) and explainability
(providing explicit top-k indicators to interpret bias predictions).
Experimental results on four political bias datasets highlight IndiVec's
significant superiority over baselines. Furthermore, additional experiments and
analysis provide profound insights into the framework's effectiveness. | [
0.0312742032,
0.0798278004,
-0.000472178,
0.0151025001,
0.0254391357,
0.0324758142,
0.0267431755,
-0.0009349794,
0.0412207097,
-0.0651899949,
0.0200642105,
-0.0034536358,
-0.0375548825,
-0.0128733423,
0.0126988124,
-0.0272474624,
0.0455102883,
0.0482283384,
0.079661414,
-0.0404478423,
0.0529793687,
0.0444301851,
-0.00876626,
0.0286737029,
-0.0202910155,
-0.0244632848,
0.0393566042,
0.0122820921,
0.043758411,
-0.0145580629,
0.0450776257,
0.0514742918,
0.014933168,
0.0582847558,
0.0000018027,
-0.0134694474,
-0.0060372548,
-0.0186653733,
0.0077591422,
-0.0170851648,
0.0817639306,
-0.0172748249,
-0.0065219896,
0.0327649415,
-0.0140572451,
0.0131399799,
0.0525244065,
0.0090116411,
0.0901909247,
0.0646494478,
-0.0124363238,
-0.0190956183,
-0.0427887551,
-0.0041165357,
0.0048380806,
-0.0450940132,
0.0487749316,
-0.0207946245,
-0.0815599337,
0.0220141541,
-0.0191306174,
-0.0076741744,
0.0068110554,
0.0097124847,
-0.0161380917,
-0.0183926802,
-0.0127108442,
-0.0128876856,
-0.0015260311,
0.0558831505,
0.0012031313,
-0.027517749,
-0.0111895697,
-0.0154526969,
0.0416374728,
-0.0020054923,
-0.0393002033,
0.0168689638,
-0.0081138574,
0.0319020934,
0.023431059,
-0.0163729507,
0.0258466378,
0.0617769696,
0.011682068,
0.0507644229,
0.0044436292,
-0.0171371996,
0.0264052693,
0.0196587387,
0.0263174679,
-0.0154954772,
0.0094725303,
-0.0268305577,
-0.0181222111,
0.0137919281,
-0.0263751522,
-0.0016884818,
0.0069011915,
-0.0853618607,
0.0040512644,
0.0130077386,
-0.0183693841,
0.0673080832,
0.0453303419,
-0.0093312962,
-0.0265433192,
0.0153467562,
0.0032635576,
0.0095657781,
-0.0284647644,
0.0283306055,
0.028272165,
0.0089607742,
-0.0071470891,
0.0249834526,
-0.0314410627,
0.0016970667,
-0.0518738702,
0.0073333513,
-0.0345085189,
-0.0080588358,
0.0003941439,
-0.0191125665,
-0.023219021,
0.0823861584,
-0.0379665792,
0.0664495826,
-0.0177517738,
-0.0377259068,
-0.0072201989,
0.0306802243,
-0.0094348099,
-0.0452478454,
0.0090637309,
0.0242752489,
0.0310316514,
0.0090545174,
-0.0349281691,
-0.0122276694,
0.0075954013,
-0.0740866438,
0.0283441804,
-0.0518733971,
0.0404771604,
0.0091216518,
0.0192598049,
-0.0379136167,
0.0061895549,
0.0123446146,
-0.0509749837,
0.045599252,
0.0403762199,
-0.0035723734,
0.0451721326,
0.0374499261,
0.0171228703,
0.1152511239,
-0.019469576,
0.0612564981,
0.0593721904,
-0.0199202206,
-0.00985339,
0.0336321406,
0.0392602086,
0.0410960652,
-0.0634761676,
0.0297704134,
-0.0315493494,
-0.0146434465,
0.0081586018,
0.0147964247,
-0.001609605,
-0.0286065135,
0.0876185074,
-0.0243663825,
-0.0290984623,
0.0195523743,
0.0111149466,
0.014518748,
-0.0195240788,
-0.0089898119,
-0.0698512271,
0.0338213965,
0.0061314409,
-0.0537966117,
0.0170273595,
0.0428914204,
-0.0468481369,
-0.0029357721,
0.0047537019,
0.0102458186,
0.0140558174,
0.0060177697,
0.0110443011,
-0.0303971432,
-0.0527157076,
0.0507697612,
0.0483304039,
-0.0333206207,
0.0485116504,
-0.0303115398,
0.0449072458,
0.0126752704,
-0.0139615471,
-0.0295377206,
0.0125081493,
-0.0506196693,
0.068757154,
0.0168736558,
0.0483207665,
-0.0472555235,
-0.0055358186,
-0.0222808644,
-0.0290188678,
-0.0006369243,
0.0423944071,
0.0399236605,
0.0024999348,
0.0251426436,
-0.0183179677,
-0.0026566423,
-0.0262732841,
0.0160618108,
0.0604227781,
-0.0534361564,
-0.0157538708,
0.0246112421,
0.0438376628,
0.0523784235,
-0.0236822236,
-0.0328262448,
0.0193229821,
0.0071626189,
-0.0188902058,
-0.0425068028,
-0.0215693619,
-0.0234125443,
-0.0015181395,
-0.0480804406,
-0.0377738886,
0.0391907953,
-0.0518042147,
0.0377358906,
0.0508650132,
-0.0038861614,
0.006990354,
-0.0024174887,
-0.0328639969,
-0.0637760758,
0.0004669272,
-0.0199237671,
0.0696807951,
-0.0181051418,
-0.0302365031,
0.0444023795,
-0.0425170958,
-0.0197433662,
0.0089645637,
0.00197169,
-0.0083391545,
0.0051321401,
0.012666923,
0.0420071818,
-0.0586401299,
-0.0368584655,
-0.0336362794,
-0.0485931449,
0.0140200173,
-0.0363924243,
0.0089154877,
0.0187068246,
0.0044203955,
0.0017487452,
0.0144278388,
-0.0326322801,
-0.0371767171,
-0.0163576696,
0.0440462418,
-0.0232075769,
-0.0038309214,
0.0032993273,
-0.0146046411,
-0.0382575393,
-0.0495712347,
0.0467924364,
0.0235795937,
0.0066540292,
-0.0240647737,
-0.0415669195,
-0.0322149657,
-0.0103082675,
-0.0190005861,
-0.0331169032,
0.0023620566,
0.0123734884,
-0.0362369418,
0.0681631193,
0.0464333259,
0.0513658449,
0.0404985249,
0.0123048248,
-0.0526938699,
-0.0341471769,
-0.0562130064,
-0.0035962665,
-0.0498169437,
-0.0306784268,
0.0042720581,
0.0539496653,
0.0294351615,
0.0065004099,
-0.04232876,
0.0749123469,
-0.0281356219,
-0.027341079,
0.0019088663,
-0.0138090551,
0.0111728031,
0.0039716861,
-0.032105539,
-0.0271808133,
0.0621883236,
0.0228870027,
0.0382993184,
-0.0168255176,
-0.0166916661,
-0.020454837,
-0.0197136197,
0.0111316526,
0.037660379,
-0.0439818725,
0.0035367429,
-0.0444302298,
-0.0506492741,
0.0480411872,
-0.0268366113,
0.012890839,
-0.0153001258,
-0.0185662583,
0.0156936515,
-0.0255480763,
-0.0281131212,
-0.0625396371,
-0.0068604839,
0.0045995614,
0.0272272397,
-0.0005643895,
-0.0341331884,
-0.0140508413,
0.0040153768,
-0.0660202205,
-0.0152555294,
0.0052667554,
0.0211849585,
0.0121607371,
0.0335411653,
-0.0564150326,
0.0466371849,
0.0070654107,
0.011327887,
0.0259849001,
-0.0005619841,
0.0188560709,
-0.0426110625,
0.0059250253,
0.0143305026,
-0.0222213659,
0.0301545449,
-0.0217092484,
0.0667449981,
-0.0159864686,
0.0540148169,
0.1102498323,
-0.0026650992,
-0.0734833255,
-0.0212415718,
0.0417854749,
-0.0316611417,
0.0491904654,
-0.0046880282,
-0.1259381771,
-0.0029651432,
-0.0119801853,
0.0222727023,
-0.0239372253,
-0.0407094024,
-0.0109397182,
-0.1212795824,
0.0221292526,
0.0136640007,
0.000204715,
-0.036291644,
-0.0839007124,
0.0192104634,
-0.0714245364,
-0.0032777668,
-0.0158554148,
0.0240870658,
-0.0012731436,
-0.0152271446,
-0.0251905974,
-0.0686710924,
0.014030803,
-0.0447148159,
0.0605925806,
0.0178078581,
0.0510122553,
-0.0105500109,
0.0043411087,
0.0512535907,
-0.0343676731,
-0.0349579901,
-0.038630221,
0.083836399,
-0.0714792088,
-0.0170439128,
-0.017922787,
0.0665717199,
0.0418944508,
0.018178599,
-0.0181593932,
0.0420981161,
0.0329714082,
-0.0302217808,
-0.0343251303,
0.002983571,
0.070229359,
0.0633042827,
0.0255837794,
-0.0440528654,
0.0160699505,
-0.0680595711,
-0.0210583135,
-0.0016392145,
-0.038993828,
-0.0022031683,
-0.025144482,
-0.0099498369,
0.0092728483,
-0.0289413854,
0.0246974211,
0.0016347744,
-0.0027589705,
-0.0003095043,
0.0288312435,
-0.021302985,
-0.0150949983,
0.0438260734,
-0.0020758891,
0.0105989166,
0.0161652043,
-0.0537959747,
-0.0380542241,
0.0098171728,
-0.0329968818,
0.0100587048,
-0.0575563647,
-0.0615388155,
0.0370065272,
0.0681650192,
0.0126496591,
0.0408729352,
0.0018668633,
-0.0417051166,
0.0282536782,
0.0539129116,
-0.0359641723,
-0.0239995308,
0.0225249492,
-0.018144656,
0.023015758,
0.0287464373,
-0.0458278842,
0.0407036096,
0.0382984988,
-0.0436926037,
-0.052051492,
0.002276351,
0.0057737641,
-0.0428160727,
0.0576042198,
0.0115281874,
-0.0373556986,
-0.0680306852,
-0.0358457491,
-0.0015283815,
-0.0566872321,
0.023970928,
-0.0128779318,
0.033861462,
-0.0204538107,
-0.0587717593,
-0.0415905379,
-0.039137166,
0.0130269146,
-0.0616017133,
0.074432306,
0.0007315953,
0.0497687608,
0.0415581726,
-0.01130707,
-0.0276068393,
0.0256299283,
0.0036304421,
0.0186824873,
0.0011432252,
0.0407088697,
0.0231326893,
0.0206085853,
0.0383621342,
-0.0352760851,
0.0147296516,
-0.0067349505,
-0.0344408303,
0.0052637868,
0.0206044633,
-0.0715868473,
0.0078274822,
0.0424458236,
-0.0315253288,
0.0108144833,
-0.0092361858,
-0.0089295488,
-0.0524067022,
0.044014819,
0.0405683666,
-0.027604036,
0.0324236043,
0.0284960475,
0.0083356416,
0.0404864252,
0.0337317437,
-0.0450769067,
-0.0114027681,
-0.0201843269,
0.0380335487,
0.019151086,
-0.0148235857,
0.0232794657,
-0.0466751643,
-0.0633705854,
-0.013829059,
-0.0450758077,
0.0022726106,
0.0187598262,
-0.0128117362,
0.0379635356,
-0.0073649888,
0.0125390776,
-0.03358908,
-0.0311467685,
-0.0830356404,
-0.0394514166,
-0.0092797522,
-5.899278276e-33,
-0.0050962972,
-0.0081408899,
-0.0302617587,
-0.0234588459,
0.0052759079,
-0.0083453925,
-0.0180882998,
-0.0121988598,
-0.0289888345,
0.0275573172,
0.0428370424,
0.0489561334,
0.0089136818,
-0.0004791518,
-0.0094637536,
-0.0303477496,
0.0538214333,
0.0028089799,
-0.0259449147,
0.0308140628,
0.0011239515,
-0.0062591303,
0.0561616048,
-0.1135627478,
0.0244354997,
-0.024513822,
-0.0075364532,
-0.0119770989,
0.0201575402,
0.061405167,
0.010500663,
0.057766214,
0.0484587289,
-0.064227201,
0.0298232697,
0.0781822503,
-0.0271898638,
-0.0094694467,
0.0039210492,
0.0066361907,
0.0341128856,
-0.0204005297,
-0.0224351585,
0.0111119514,
-0.0458853394,
-0.0311415717,
0.0418418907,
-0.0125339702,
0.0558361411,
0.0286471322,
-0.0501056276,
0.0080472287,
-0.0608453713,
0.0258796755,
-0.0321224034,
0.0252629742,
0.0502145998,
0.059086863,
-0.0695649236,
0.0403861254,
-0.0302377287,
0.0192051753,
0.0266983565,
-0.0097168731,
-0.0200901944,
0.067936793,
0.06492199,
0.036099568,
-0.050046064,
-0.0129688941,
-0.0082858941,
0.0206650756,
0.0298585556,
0.0808445737,
0.0298549905,
-0.053310357,
-0.0820514336,
-0.0216975268,
0.0611521378,
0.0190820768,
0.0360502042,
-0.0253562666,
-0.0154847018,
-0.0193710029,
-0.0387961566,
-0.0821531489,
-0.037876226,
-0.0070398226,
0.0111770192,
0.0279665571,
-0.0277834609,
0.0355679207,
0.0462280735,
-0.0385077074,
-0.0312656201,
0.0744425431,
-0.0281065255,
-0.0130507844,
0.016110843,
0.0272513665,
-0.0688066483,
0.0170449968,
0.0067544859,
-0.000591699,
0.0199110918,
0.004595357,
0.0236699376,
0.0235668309,
-0.0371686779,
-0.0061631859,
-0.0183029249,
0.0111047272,
-0.0169730745,
0.0417243429,
0.0254082661,
0.0233825687,
0.0045837648,
0.0257492792,
0.0048844158,
0.0121008018,
0.0494829416,
-0.0410889648,
-0.0381890088,
0.0030653391,
-0.0450650677,
-0.0550192297,
-0.0034803315,
0.008306046,
-0.0062532607,
-0.0593761429,
-0.0223603752,
-0.0324383117,
2.42e-7,
0.0105407136,
0.0695560575,
-0.0483553968,
0.0073215696,
0.02408747,
0.0282311141,
0.0174355023,
0.0196321867,
-0.0089978008,
-0.036830619,
-0.0107033998,
0.0595171489,
-0.0017944016,
0.0301393811,
-0.0601982474,
0.0107146408,
-0.0340675488,
0.0405868329,
-0.0745572075,
0.0234941728,
-0.0075518833,
0.090226233,
0.0331329443,
-0.0033097377,
-0.0033176062,
-0.0083128801,
0.0422907397,
-0.0153466361,
-0.0032792608,
0.0181477219,
0.0150687769,
0.0081816316,
0.0049223048,
0.0248935223,
-0.0207394771,
0.0045965053,
-0.036118716,
0.0643821359,
0.0103355162,
0.0014237372,
-0.0069212271,
0.0073425979,
-0.0024649608,
-0.0518918633,
0.0601171553,
-0.0410707071,
-0.0613493323,
-0.1118458956,
-0.0537224077,
-0.0249780547,
0.0556692369,
-0.0129176518,
0.025022842,
-0.0251860563,
-0.013107718,
0.0069921785,
-0.0127615845,
-0.0524741411,
0.0088617671,
0.0201675911,
-0.0412318446,
-0.0662766919,
0.0093939491,
0.0248451531,
0.0392172933,
-0.0322889164,
0.0611804985,
1.948661755e-34,
0.0416637324,
-0.0268473011,
0.0160016697,
-0.0317027383,
0.0527247787,
0.0130980564,
-0.0477900393,
-0.0179117192,
0.0280843675,
-0.0456115901,
0.0103937751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00322v1 | Bias in Opinion Summarisation from Pre-training to Adaptation: A Case Study in Political Bias | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | Nannan Huang, Haytham Fayek, Xiuzhen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Opinion summarisation aims to summarise the salient information and opinions
presented in documents such as product reviews, discussion forums, and social
media texts into short summaries that enable users to effectively understand
the opinions therein. Generating biased summaries has the risk of potentially
swaying public opinion. Previous studies focused on studying bias in opinion
summarisation using extractive models, but limited research has paid attention
to abstractive summarisation models. In this study, using political bias as a
case study, we first establish a methodology to quantify bias in abstractive
models, then trace it from the pre-trained models to the task of summarising
social media opinions using different models and adaptation methods. We find
that most models exhibit intrinsic bias. Using a social media text
summarisation dataset and contrasting various adaptation methods, we find that
tuning a smaller number of parameters is less biased compared to standard
fine-tuning; however, the diversity of topics in training data used for
fine-tuning is critical. | [
0.0573565736,
0.0356738642,
0.0199262388,
-0.0065357829,
-0.0064409063,
0.0248171277,
-0.0212849006,
-0.0366078913,
-0.0229612105,
-0.0501603484,
0.0148659674,
-0.0310018007,
-0.0002024551,
-0.0029051735,
-0.0297825672,
-0.1059210449,
0.0449216403,
0.0296800174,
0.0728635713,
-0.0091962256,
0.0578347631,
0.0166152604,
0.0122765321,
0.0105647361,
0.0031062183,
0.0319544896,
0.0344562158,
-0.0171266384,
0.0528967641,
0.0227619,
0.0099140387,
0.0425253734,
0.0042703324,
0.0212060027,
0.0000014235,
-0.0285828095,
-0.0337967202,
-0.0323006287,
0.0517391004,
0.0012338499,
0.1159595251,
-0.0319882035,
0.0273480043,
0.0378481187,
-0.0303459261,
0.0306883045,
0.0390081815,
0.0719681829,
0.0885913372,
0.0607662424,
-0.0107819047,
-0.0260550901,
-0.0219627749,
-0.0283850059,
-0.0301394407,
-0.0245535914,
0.0256282389,
-0.0033649041,
-0.0955040976,
0.0040081325,
0.0043626898,
0.0004906272,
-0.0190578457,
0.0389591865,
0.0037360319,
0.0015837367,
-0.0400456265,
-0.0207219571,
0.003323552,
0.0600495599,
0.0121695511,
-0.021127142,
0.0121838562,
-0.0183805581,
0.0461667329,
0.0301321372,
-0.05602099,
0.0228496566,
0.0035742153,
0.048835706,
0.0059688599,
0.0366246663,
-0.0161213856,
0.0381363258,
-0.0020821565,
0.0165894739,
-0.026886018,
-0.0275152922,
0.009585903,
0.0475674309,
0.0097371023,
-0.0273727197,
0.0023881521,
-0.002779494,
0.0288284328,
0.009470175,
-0.0480603352,
-0.0284112711,
0.0273543522,
-0.0838184953,
-0.0028469146,
-0.0169258937,
0.0074407058,
0.0706719458,
0.0143494131,
-0.0410991013,
0.0125724962,
0.0407227464,
-0.0221203081,
0.0124276141,
-0.0310567785,
0.0367875434,
0.0002981031,
0.0255491696,
-0.0237060264,
0.0168600492,
-0.0178845599,
-0.0131941559,
-0.0091543449,
-0.0411071703,
-0.0244852174,
0.0084207226,
0.0118124792,
-0.0161687452,
-0.0525622852,
0.0431185029,
-0.0322272405,
0.026436504,
0.0001114616,
0.0083182715,
0.0023445366,
0.0265810285,
0.0461348779,
-0.0030122194,
0.0056831697,
0.0170886144,
0.0043793609,
-0.02036543,
-0.015817143,
-0.0030921886,
0.0092466874,
-0.041088447,
0.0255505331,
-0.0411782227,
0.0156491566,
-0.0052127931,
-0.0019207267,
0.0163294002,
-0.0169570167,
0.0089065172,
-0.0666910931,
0.0246160273,
-0.0137948291,
-0.004440804,
0.0413174033,
0.015751075,
0.022847347,
0.0533411354,
0.0118884714,
0.0644507036,
0.0709962174,
-0.018367542,
0.0263740569,
0.0033809373,
0.0294406153,
0.0078975223,
0.0229854919,
0.0149154942,
-0.1048426032,
-0.0602923483,
0.0370093286,
0.054366529,
0.002100748,
0.0215998348,
0.0590811335,
0.0330758244,
-0.0203199759,
0.0310731623,
-0.0230077989,
0.0332698412,
0.0216250867,
0.0429100469,
-0.0166700352,
0.0245930981,
-0.0243579652,
0.0297269095,
0.0670924559,
0.0599110276,
-0.0375130735,
-0.0552785397,
0.0103794783,
0.0035679021,
0.0346822962,
-0.0031565775,
0.0165516082,
0.0122374026,
-0.025727028,
0.0713503882,
0.0446749777,
-0.0700729042,
0.0240617823,
-0.032515116,
0.0276434999,
0.0109737907,
-0.0354785137,
-0.0390392058,
-0.0035484638,
-0.0310871024,
0.0122540453,
0.0200574063,
0.0966145694,
-0.029631041,
-0.0471139476,
-0.0147060007,
-0.0434377417,
-0.0066468688,
0.0511159897,
0.0232295338,
0.0039129485,
-0.0073101604,
0.0313541368,
-0.0261988658,
-0.0697952434,
0.0122085633,
0.0518915765,
-0.0273563694,
-0.0100332676,
-0.0034407692,
0.0357532911,
0.059832491,
-0.0342577174,
-0.0178373009,
0.0231928769,
0.0134420963,
-0.035044454,
0.0047578681,
-0.0430606976,
0.0049926061,
0.0008831153,
-0.0786434785,
-0.0115461797,
0.0366673432,
-0.0683562905,
-0.0177496597,
0.0702158213,
-0.0318921246,
0.0041650054,
-0.0058893412,
-0.023822207,
-0.0466742516,
-0.0224033389,
-0.0304770507,
0.0505742095,
-0.0019539366,
-0.0578609519,
0.014944776,
-0.0760074779,
0.0031655438,
0.0146758957,
-0.0132782096,
-0.0224104431,
0.0118374247,
0.0284839328,
0.0645535439,
-0.0395419002,
-0.0390801355,
-0.0459503569,
-0.0831818059,
-0.0197996981,
-0.0430301391,
0.0229481384,
0.0623386167,
0.0183820967,
0.0016760684,
-0.0125154499,
-0.0539792702,
-0.0375268757,
-0.0078185666,
0.0243145432,
0.0168145914,
0.0220213868,
0.0433009155,
-0.0670621321,
-0.0209356248,
-0.0062075714,
0.0220555626,
0.0090516908,
-0.0389686339,
-0.0191339795,
0.0059763421,
-0.0234603249,
-0.0237441529,
-0.0194487609,
0.0184329748,
-0.0239536352,
0.029057635,
0.009726638,
0.0457839258,
0.0606150478,
0.011453284,
0.0360500813,
0.0525179505,
-0.0190929547,
-0.0498503894,
-0.0751551911,
0.0286297854,
-0.0027101755,
-0.0384997316,
0.0669026747,
0.0697169974,
0.0111766756,
0.0068884469,
-0.0329405889,
0.0586878695,
-0.0345750488,
-0.003462546,
-0.0189217534,
-0.0193778593,
-0.0012944496,
0.0112980381,
-0.0527501367,
-0.0268728826,
0.0387828313,
0.0246319547,
0.0801476091,
-0.0563511997,
-0.0281957053,
-0.0447396524,
-0.0013940382,
0.0162158161,
0.0176614746,
-0.0158362426,
0.0256147683,
-0.0278610289,
-0.0584544912,
0.0381405354,
-0.0248622689,
0.0430892035,
-0.0036912812,
0.0154154887,
-0.020273352,
-0.014413747,
0.0195549931,
-0.0785692036,
-0.0141577711,
0.0318582579,
0.0376785994,
0.0008566268,
-0.0130921584,
0.0186576229,
0.0357701406,
0.0059089265,
-0.0270899311,
-0.0072821202,
0.021023728,
0.0441764817,
0.0702355877,
-0.0251874328,
0.0542759858,
-0.0316370837,
-0.009994627,
0.0092850467,
0.0180156212,
-0.0109511828,
-0.0199697856,
-0.0399409197,
-0.0193560086,
-0.0729097798,
0.0305489451,
-0.0509389304,
0.0771344006,
-0.0041518356,
0.0574152954,
0.0775704533,
-0.009611005,
-0.0508964099,
-0.0167612527,
0.0320140645,
-0.0079646464,
0.0009102278,
-0.0032771709,
-0.0580614507,
0.0235292185,
-0.0243870299,
0.0283072367,
-0.0220846664,
-0.0046864673,
-0.0025398103,
-0.1112245023,
-0.0145149492,
0.0061592739,
-0.052494254,
-0.0408747643,
-0.0466220081,
0.0385814831,
-0.0803730786,
0.0156529304,
-0.0052919774,
-0.0226157494,
0.0348514505,
0.028532261,
-0.0994576365,
-0.0100453664,
-0.0303740539,
-0.0208691396,
0.007456392,
0.0493521877,
0.0388918109,
-0.0041135149,
0.0502865277,
0.0816215426,
-0.0321162492,
0.0097476104,
0.0010225679,
0.1161735132,
-0.0383562483,
0.0200673565,
-0.0004017131,
0.0464326739,
0.0149658443,
0.0019517012,
-0.0078858845,
0.0078741247,
0.0447376035,
-0.0396289565,
-0.0448939726,
0.0150604239,
0.0127850622,
0.0686266869,
0.0351360403,
-0.0278936233,
-0.0170219969,
-0.0288163573,
-0.0011186809,
-0.062012013,
-0.040596433,
-0.0389426649,
-0.0429780334,
-0.000564038,
-0.0411939472,
-0.0641688854,
-0.0147512713,
-0.0208018031,
-0.0062914779,
-0.0192653891,
0.0499564745,
0.0221750997,
-0.0063621299,
0.0436032638,
-0.0005165921,
-0.0266795978,
0.0181933921,
-0.0831562728,
0.0177818649,
-0.0124643408,
-0.0418528877,
-0.0173732322,
-0.0465705879,
-0.0483445786,
0.0100786593,
0.0651750788,
0.0235181227,
0.0571567528,
0.0248052068,
-0.0357887037,
0.0685508773,
0.030717887,
-0.0112184258,
-0.0122803375,
0.0205073785,
0.0535967387,
-0.0059340037,
0.0116426283,
-0.0305935033,
0.0575201511,
0.0321640149,
-0.0330080949,
-0.0649950802,
-0.017816402,
-0.0085752849,
0.0156914983,
0.0487428717,
0.0286896117,
-0.0172437318,
-0.0670625567,
-0.0426853932,
-0.0008189711,
-0.0177926347,
-0.0059536956,
0.0111291083,
-0.0116897216,
-0.0091278413,
-0.0518300347,
0.0143622467,
-0.0077723907,
0.0234625023,
-0.0648257136,
0.0341175571,
-0.0227199811,
0.0086061154,
-0.0331563987,
-0.004895472,
-0.0554453284,
-0.0020597575,
-0.0243954379,
-0.0066769416,
0.0198524259,
-0.0356421247,
0.004670457,
0.0296614692,
0.0266398713,
0.0127509264,
-0.0722535998,
0.0014586166,
-0.0812363997,
0.0110973474,
-0.0250761118,
-0.0760637671,
0.0582752153,
0.0251381584,
-0.0232798308,
0.0184248872,
-0.0056026806,
0.0086966921,
0.0201626532,
-0.0043552951,
0.013677503,
-0.0295176022,
0.012424551,
0.056979727,
-0.0525348745,
0.0308078919,
0.0225438233,
-0.043514926,
-0.0346691161,
-0.0028702531,
-0.0000486523,
-0.0091335159,
-0.0023337356,
-0.0260542743,
-0.0489935726,
-0.0160692837,
0.0307584461,
-0.0064263665,
0.0416517779,
0.0038612592,
-0.0059543997,
0.0505119711,
-0.0072117946,
0.0349404737,
-0.0469897576,
-0.0362652242,
-0.0298819467,
0.0155247534,
-0.017100757,
-5.830500837e-33,
-0.0172326341,
0.0084966356,
-0.0455492139,
0.0413336344,
-0.0171716101,
-0.0054754056,
-0.0292173345,
0.0241949353,
-0.0223453976,
0.0069674575,
-0.0059021721,
0.0399146229,
0.0095190713,
0.0362241268,
-0.0122397291,
0.0000791092,
0.0536368303,
-0.0006728956,
-0.0461305007,
0.0517269522,
0.0229294002,
-0.0185085312,
0.0505459309,
-0.0788888037,
0.0277020149,
-0.0014542966,
-0.0305147283,
-0.0140247559,
0.0307895578,
0.0310435779,
0.0053417524,
0.0469819047,
0.0649306178,
-0.0399303548,
-0.0339910984,
0.0738791451,
-0.0448793508,
-0.0281404983,
0.0344151668,
-0.0227063149,
-0.0047377902,
-0.0268814713,
0.0422517471,
0.0192405898,
-0.0442047678,
-0.0245325845,
0.0628060028,
-0.0229158998,
0.0280227847,
-0.0635856763,
-0.0420711525,
0.0414815769,
-0.0141615523,
0.0310290437,
-0.0192710515,
0.0517921075,
0.0277359523,
0.0445414782,
-0.0215796009,
0.0499362275,
0.0409506448,
0.033346355,
0.0094792256,
-0.0112630399,
-0.0086399503,
0.0868626162,
0.0158486608,
0.0422346257,
-0.0444623753,
-0.0017142843,
-0.0092625935,
-0.0014577794,
0.0276138578,
0.0605261438,
0.0600006096,
-0.0166180227,
-0.0541541167,
0.0230697077,
0.0222715065,
-0.0130658662,
0.0712229833,
-0.0328350887,
0.0061659296,
0.0143112652,
-0.0402297564,
-0.0538359843,
-0.0166518763,
0.0024533521,
-0.0415194072,
0.0424124599,
-0.0434612408,
0.0252770092,
0.0000579173,
-0.0445803925,
0.028746523,
0.0045749587,
-0.0427241288,
-0.0012526492,
0.010615346,
-0.033985693,
-0.0668670014,
-0.002726034,
-0.0047568032,
0.0199936889,
-0.0171338357,
-0.0166030135,
0.0676947162,
-0.0165293906,
-0.0532354601,
0.0094707822,
0.0207048114,
0.0444144718,
-0.0069748717,
0.0394356921,
0.019775128,
0.0293126516,
0.0033089558,
0.0051516243,
0.0023337575,
0.0180000942,
0.0328729711,
0.0206147004,
-0.0109733613,
0.0063078208,
-0.0249328502,
-0.0320439413,
0.0202830322,
0.0104630245,
0.0081763845,
-0.0455722623,
-0.0280943438,
-0.0049160076,
2.189e-7,
0.0480372421,
0.0670583621,
-0.0119014252,
-0.0421431065,
-0.0019512183,
0.0285578817,
0.0479009934,
0.0400630161,
0.0168143027,
-0.0523544773,
0.022675721,
0.0357462689,
0.0065873824,
0.0211961865,
-0.0577301271,
-0.0413161218,
-0.0576665252,
0.0251941066,
-0.0025263822,
0.0146414079,
0.0146979345,
0.0490163602,
-0.0074974033,
-0.0121418154,
-0.0340419523,
-0.0153496424,
0.033275824,
-0.0464998148,
-0.0395904966,
0.03679749,
0.0536233634,
-0.0163013116,
0.0026703498,
-0.006162676,
-0.0210480951,
-0.0086222133,
0.0089454949,
0.0233420748,
0.031631954,
-0.0353108644,
0.0203066189,
0.0117049553,
0.0162668079,
-0.0083003938,
0.0543652214,
-0.095029749,
-0.0421784222,
-0.1131551489,
-0.0598744005,
0.0216532052,
0.0164223518,
0.0094302399,
0.0055527976,
0.0183614083,
-0.0181220118,
0.0170594174,
-0.0051313876,
-0.0561434701,
-0.0204091258,
0.0139244599,
-0.0047263219,
-0.071779117,
0.0173652899,
0.0245709904,
0.0012130475,
-0.0485314727,
0.0443749465,
1.538650244e-34,
0.0934793204,
-0.035736382,
-0.0138713066,
-0.0499874167,
0.0204147138,
-0.0101193236,
-0.0329557583,
-0.037767794,
0.0091079818,
-0.0689821467,
-0.0054292013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01769v1 | Redefining "Hallucination" in LLMs: Towards a psychology-informed framework for mitigating misinformation | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | Elijah Berberette, Jack Hutchins, Amir Sadovnik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have become incredibly popular,
with ChatGPT for example being used by over a billion users. While these models
exhibit remarkable language understanding and logical prowess, a notable
challenge surfaces in the form of "hallucinations." This phenomenon results in
LLMs outputting misinformation in a confident manner, which can lead to
devastating consequences with such a large user base. However, we question the
appropriateness of the term "hallucination" in LLMs, proposing a psychological
taxonomy based on cognitive biases and other psychological phenomena. Our
approach offers a more fine-grained understanding of this phenomenon, allowing
for targeted solutions. By leveraging insights from how humans internally
resolve similar challenges, we aim to develop strategies to mitigate LLM
hallucinations. This interdisciplinary approach seeks to move beyond
conventional terminology, providing a nuanced understanding and actionable
pathways for improvement in LLM reliability. | [
0.0399875529,
0.0231460575,
-0.0492515713,
0.0181988217,
-0.0437705703,
0.0098938476,
-0.0363631397,
0.0239891391,
0.0495690443,
-0.0305386093,
-0.0082511995,
-0.0335350186,
0.0072245938,
-0.0371420495,
0.0466470867,
-0.0550387762,
0.0529472902,
-0.0393454991,
0.000509451,
-0.0330607221,
0.0028578676,
0.012273957,
0.0136200394,
0.0335844234,
0.008152632,
-0.0507048294,
0.0037233904,
0.0047772257,
-0.014887847,
-0.0235188603,
-0.0125996536,
0.0535019636,
-0.0092447298,
0.0613419972,
0.0000021767,
-0.0495702103,
0.0012071058,
-0.0148269217,
-0.0343175642,
0.02520792,
0.0303912908,
0.031908419,
0.0055850064,
0.0228419937,
-0.0220126864,
0.0219580345,
0.0268581808,
0.0679679289,
0.0416502878,
0.0347454809,
0.0079778871,
-0.0224442743,
0.0187464412,
0.0206236951,
0.0672131777,
-0.0182337817,
0.0364021845,
0.0125025408,
-0.0099404678,
-0.0351756513,
-0.0087397462,
0.0048930258,
-0.00197807,
0.0211593583,
-0.0527559891,
0.0130582191,
-0.0529186018,
-0.0353556834,
0.0056216321,
0.0240700357,
0.0028783311,
-0.0445928164,
0.0206309445,
-0.0002482001,
0.0286406372,
0.0307350289,
-0.0479315892,
0.0247188956,
-0.0446653925,
-0.0275043417,
0.0388411134,
-0.0169233009,
0.0523516349,
0.0123231653,
-0.0111818677,
0.0771470293,
-0.0044418974,
-0.0337322764,
0.0248108748,
-0.0015299468,
-0.0054098065,
-0.0744532347,
-0.0038424172,
0.0253579598,
-0.0459514223,
0.0066974596,
0.0090978667,
0.0391727053,
0.0584609397,
-0.1114383712,
-0.003215865,
0.0181403998,
-0.0250624698,
0.0261824094,
0.0112086078,
0.0098667098,
-0.0475892425,
0.0724212825,
0.0116541525,
0.0279308222,
-0.0471732914,
-0.0172403883,
0.0108824158,
-0.00123592,
0.0527184159,
0.0095366184,
-0.0146253621,
0.0068992889,
-0.0651273951,
0.0119181955,
-0.0650363863,
0.0134038953,
0.0044137724,
-0.0494891889,
-0.0367803052,
0.0199907236,
-0.0032594767,
0.010363413,
0.012391638,
-0.084387891,
-0.0023126642,
0.009565467,
-0.0784916356,
0.0251829885,
-0.0101870019,
0.0450432971,
0.0341248736,
0.0277110301,
-0.0653285906,
-0.0637590289,
-0.0132555878,
-0.055795487,
0.019001307,
-0.0557913817,
-0.0215589143,
0.0183833446,
-0.0109067187,
-0.0297321063,
0.0058197756,
0.0188945662,
-0.0518257469,
0.0719576403,
-0.032958135,
0.0058572209,
0.0771429911,
0.076903671,
-0.0314679407,
0.0641695485,
-0.0183580723,
0.0445830487,
0.0099699767,
0.0005341077,
0.0733512118,
0.0198911354,
-0.0257205721,
0.0049142996,
-0.0220495798,
-0.014839286,
-0.0223444775,
-0.0144468546,
0.0009441928,
0.0515754558,
-0.0272180438,
0.0057833144,
0.064632006,
0.005628882,
-0.0173080005,
0.0291465484,
-0.0127876839,
0.0066877496,
0.0062098354,
0.0454990231,
-0.0561032407,
0.0252292883,
-0.043484915,
0.0027748807,
0.041691076,
0.0010872964,
-0.0194163658,
-0.0374753624,
-0.0339183882,
0.0219375268,
0.0023060697,
0.0374573655,
-0.0099391351,
0.0071814703,
-0.0184599981,
0.0796120539,
0.0356666483,
-0.003660192,
-0.0021210411,
-0.0646431968,
-0.0234793406,
0.0768191442,
0.0348494388,
-0.0116628129,
-0.0048151324,
-0.029605018,
0.0300644543,
0.0620520413,
0.0593939163,
0.0123799983,
-0.0475979894,
-0.0178850852,
0.0063743857,
0.0078547653,
0.0311889276,
0.0095607117,
-0.0376770273,
-0.0040656035,
-0.0302581545,
-0.0192672815,
-0.0540265255,
0.0280149188,
-0.0271169171,
-0.0036877852,
-0.0739300847,
-0.0099478085,
0.0204670765,
-0.003670872,
0.0020721734,
0.037428394,
0.0105638448,
0.008570171,
-0.0296741389,
0.0318228714,
-0.0373262838,
0.0375165902,
0.0479032099,
-0.0132108396,
-0.0265253559,
-0.0398966037,
0.010790146,
0.006226311,
0.0381630659,
-0.0646320581,
0.0725450888,
-0.0044417488,
0.0377555825,
-0.0192457456,
0.0180004034,
-0.0121032512,
0.0577906333,
-0.0432625487,
0.0102757877,
0.0309269521,
-0.019477902,
0.0006792159,
-0.0025787361,
-0.0005660031,
0.0195475798,
0.0233777668,
0.0140463151,
0.0012569495,
-0.0410623476,
-0.085962534,
-0.0010902286,
-0.0612480827,
-0.0335442871,
-0.0107248183,
0.0080199232,
0.0250969473,
-0.0509390682,
-0.027859021,
0.0119520482,
0.0028559235,
0.0057393075,
0.0075712265,
0.0586640276,
0.0132337408,
-0.0040363506,
-0.0393554494,
-0.0038429867,
0.0244378597,
-0.029255243,
0.0286608674,
-0.0059910268,
-0.0436450429,
-0.0932635888,
0.0390942954,
-0.0501754172,
-0.0146011543,
-0.024271002,
-0.0072147176,
0.0299347136,
0.0280233026,
0.0374988429,
0.0365648903,
0.0250098649,
0.0345514081,
0.0587599128,
-0.021217851,
-0.047200758,
-0.0455459952,
0.0043769605,
-0.0226764772,
0.004970849,
-0.0765338019,
-0.0110499328,
0.0397199914,
0.0405920967,
0.0214715209,
-0.0500335917,
0.057300739,
-0.0495299138,
-0.0639510676,
0.0222135596,
-0.0621056072,
-0.0440492593,
0.0573390909,
-0.0309328921,
-0.0557622984,
0.071983099,
-0.0010043359,
0.0256083421,
-0.0105089629,
0.0150599601,
0.0181179252,
0.0142312264,
-0.0256199837,
0.0131969862,
0.0578056872,
-0.0342919976,
-0.0528576747,
-0.0483531877,
-0.0171549972,
-0.0504998788,
0.0271615647,
-0.0491781272,
-0.0261518657,
0.042817492,
-0.0009696037,
-0.0554497577,
-0.0180842616,
-0.0343856625,
-0.0420186706,
-0.0136922318,
0.0168982055,
-0.0326809511,
-0.0349595733,
0.030615313,
-0.0381609201,
0.0011371719,
-0.0529204383,
0.0114551103,
-0.0579028279,
0.0291923359,
-0.0013606464,
0.0974840075,
-0.0677726641,
0.0136403311,
0.0975743234,
0.0276902299,
0.0120999804,
0.02041764,
-0.0225774292,
0.031892892,
-0.007204982,
-0.0433643647,
0.0500326119,
0.0238508768,
-0.0431763418,
-0.0167232621,
0.0957079232,
0.0374762453,
-0.0456807092,
0.007321279,
-0.1084365621,
0.0451342911,
0.0280204341,
-0.0113092521,
-0.0772888958,
0.0042464901,
0.0207798611,
-0.0093305325,
-0.0464952514,
-0.0184042007,
-0.0212180726,
-0.0457310677,
0.0337784924,
0.0408018939,
0.0131289614,
0.0006405094,
-0.0082818521,
-0.0103116408,
0.0307675116,
0.0607501902,
0.0047949464,
0.0022913346,
-0.0245073456,
0.0365330279,
-0.0977002233,
-0.0049569812,
0.0243303142,
-0.0069682039,
0.0567437075,
0.0419918858,
0.0141903991,
-0.0182483532,
-0.0940508395,
0.0386161581,
0.0204637609,
-0.0006359113,
-0.0106593668,
0.0576888211,
0.0108944876,
0.0381870382,
-0.0204914287,
-0.0044375295,
-0.0256237946,
-0.0425450578,
0.0020225123,
0.0974051729,
-0.0365604647,
-0.0578055456,
-0.0019281463,
0.0457938984,
0.0131152114,
0.0610942915,
0.0136476038,
-0.0208532307,
-0.0268002115,
-0.0552729033,
0.0413915589,
0.0335195921,
-0.0674821585,
0.0411235839,
0.0468098596,
-0.0169380065,
-0.0288721882,
-0.0427381098,
0.0031765096,
-0.0082004769,
0.0236174874,
0.0481762215,
-0.0201894194,
-0.0141543932,
0.0028048346,
0.0161326211,
-0.0293702818,
0.0049997014,
-0.019713847,
0.0087603601,
-0.01761158,
-0.0187846106,
0.0407083668,
0.0293707587,
-0.0438915156,
-0.0648442134,
0.0573777594,
0.0133106895,
0.0398404375,
0.0130506186,
0.0006404633,
-0.0548044182,
0.0242185108,
0.0179411825,
-0.0004459694,
0.0136718154,
0.0360629372,
0.0526164658,
0.0117585156,
0.0333936177,
-0.0025895648,
-0.0209794659,
0.0013793716,
-0.0038304811,
-0.0546564087,
-0.010618411,
0.0541078523,
0.0001635955,
0.0059864875,
-0.0408774242,
0.0098539079,
0.0093077589,
-0.0188912805,
-0.0204075128,
-0.0234856922,
0.0329898261,
-0.0245495234,
0.0176557191,
-0.0185855422,
0.0258419067,
-0.0245722774,
-0.0505975597,
-0.0090313097,
-0.0084121954,
-0.0075744316,
0.0047997045,
0.0144409668,
0.0355192311,
-0.0035971417,
-0.0037857704,
0.0083397357,
-0.0068520112,
0.057218574,
0.0122139249,
0.0892711803,
0.0118306819,
-0.0177665167,
-0.0057371366,
-0.0172980428,
-0.0202555787,
-0.1343486309,
0.0280188862,
0.0236559343,
0.0334122553,
0.0222594272,
0.0357690454,
-0.0279153623,
0.0081756972,
0.0064176396,
-0.026860781,
0.0157569461,
-0.0302238576,
-0.0016751693,
0.0112432288,
-0.0387106016,
-0.0128035657,
0.0550145134,
-0.0433128513,
0.0397822224,
-0.0273097325,
-0.0351446569,
-0.0251789521,
-0.0381278992,
-0.0256786812,
0.0318518765,
-0.031398546,
-0.0358519815,
-0.1173903197,
-0.0422098115,
-0.0049841139,
-0.0006517665,
0.0149536831,
-0.0422258973,
0.0060145329,
0.0930749327,
0.00236908,
-0.0309311617,
-0.0088490481,
0.0201200265,
0.0387665406,
0.0236896835,
-0.015369663,
-6.41556164e-33,
0.0081159966,
-0.0576590933,
0.0204262361,
0.0003147091,
-0.0168718435,
-0.04595441,
-0.0007047351,
0.0535846762,
-0.0136591345,
0.0303455982,
-0.0011514751,
0.0228182115,
0.0134706302,
-0.030861184,
0.0437561758,
-0.0173463933,
0.0257919487,
0.0098565556,
-0.0246734265,
0.0014412577,
0.0356042646,
-0.015125433,
0.035166502,
-0.0857529417,
0.0875395015,
-0.0133807613,
0.0020085874,
0.0024000579,
-0.0307199396,
0.0117819812,
-0.005013173,
0.0445848741,
0.022703547,
-0.0389594622,
-0.0387119353,
0.0145392977,
0.0469488129,
-0.03610285,
0.0614517368,
0.0240504108,
-0.0032276101,
-0.0167142637,
0.0310715009,
-0.0138985766,
-0.0210713334,
0.0059692101,
0.016126886,
-0.0310987588,
-0.0124459649,
0.063508153,
-0.0482369326,
-0.0175106339,
0.0249514002,
0.0271180384,
-0.0052566859,
0.0417730436,
-0.0249416977,
-0.027040191,
-0.1053376794,
0.0366332121,
0.0001479196,
-0.0050749909,
0.0711725131,
-0.0099789025,
-0.0069663604,
0.0779787004,
0.0429201275,
0.0678889006,
-0.0423857123,
-0.0306141693,
-0.0015641495,
0.0461239554,
0.0467936359,
0.0137486421,
0.0261573922,
-0.0376263224,
-0.0257789083,
-0.0071313335,
0.0054650488,
0.0083923619,
0.0586395599,
0.0156806856,
-0.0727984235,
-0.0532406718,
0.0101852622,
0.0189387519,
-0.0299605504,
-0.0342601612,
0.006506844,
-0.0244340785,
0.0112247886,
-0.028059002,
0.0099400384,
-0.0268663932,
-0.0154312812,
-0.0348560996,
0.0031931116,
-0.0102583813,
0.0071265581,
0.0101939645,
-0.0096379872,
0.0005685606,
-0.0494135357,
0.0136023425,
0.0372568145,
0.0134265991,
0.0056881434,
-0.0283254366,
-0.0414321572,
-0.0045794332,
-0.0371472165,
0.0285182893,
0.0415740907,
-0.0577353388,
0.0449626297,
-0.0040935325,
-0.0129236802,
-0.0415208451,
0.0521018021,
-0.0124733616,
-0.0235908553,
0.0492963865,
-0.0593936965,
0.0095057115,
-0.0220283419,
-0.0291642938,
-0.045476716,
0.0119659817,
0.0613597892,
-0.0608812794,
-0.0352155566,
-0.0383460075,
2.855e-7,
0.002695323,
0.0692037344,
-0.0103188008,
0.032155294,
0.0401973911,
0.0372551009,
0.0144247161,
-0.0070369639,
0.0413147882,
-0.0688857138,
-0.0354383849,
0.0115580736,
0.0285195876,
0.068556942,
-0.025997499,
-0.0358462706,
-0.0174888261,
0.0312752649,
-0.0383320749,
-0.0067621092,
0.0524041094,
0.0083734114,
0.013395234,
-0.0180356894,
-0.0475726388,
-0.0144936265,
0.0451294892,
-0.0196197443,
0.0052472912,
0.0488867834,
0.0632300749,
0.0112365726,
0.0342582352,
0.0461138412,
0.0104097277,
-0.0602834709,
-0.0383287407,
-0.0136217102,
0.0007082275,
-0.0399758555,
-0.0229083858,
-0.0182015859,
0.0286706463,
-0.0796402097,
0.0243336298,
-0.0528899729,
-0.0396749899,
0.0022890733,
-0.0193006061,
-0.036929179,
0.0415014029,
0.0288521927,
-0.0353940055,
0.0183758587,
0.008860765,
0.0414342508,
0.0018693715,
-0.0499322414,
-0.0179789606,
0.0254044607,
-0.036026448,
-0.0484917872,
0.0055125766,
0.0188706052,
-0.0272980612,
-0.0548885763,
0.0139742605,
2.726798608e-34,
0.0034338275,
0.0290851723,
0.046844881,
0.0239068698,
0.0260839146,
0.0120592015,
0.0439781547,
0.0301005989,
0.027961351,
0.0023876426,
-0.0097157797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01767v1 | HiQA: A Hierarchical Contextual Augmentation RAG for Massive Documents QA | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | Xinyue Chen, Pengyu Gao, Jiangjiang Song, Xiaoyang Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As language model agents leveraging external tools rapidly evolve,
significant progress has been made in question-answering(QA) methodologies
utilizing supplementary documents and the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
approach. This advancement has improved the response quality of language models
and alleviates the appearance of hallucination. However, these methods exhibit
limited retrieval accuracy when faced with massive indistinguishable documents,
presenting notable challenges in their practical application. In response to
these emerging challenges, we present HiQA, an advanced framework for
multi-document question-answering (MDQA) that integrates cascading metadata
into content as well as a multi-route retrieval mechanism. We also release a
benchmark called MasQA to evaluate and research in MDQA. Finally, HiQA
demonstrates the state-of-the-art performance in multi-document environments. | [
0.0570360869,
0.0294585507,
0.0024211232,
0.0255434234,
-0.0010792316,
-0.0036245387,
-0.0115381135,
-0.0182678234,
-0.0191115253,
-0.0608094782,
-0.0422770232,
0.0037905138,
-0.0603648201,
0.0077779684,
-0.0028084691,
-0.0265790969,
0.0414155759,
-0.0162037741,
-0.0245199203,
-0.0131817982,
0.0167551991,
0.0412881188,
0.0155178104,
0.0219074469,
-0.0345564,
-0.0404107869,
-0.0217399541,
0.0214053355,
0.0036492348,
-0.0210034605,
0.0435577706,
0.027293982,
0.0550879128,
0.0572942756,
0.0000017605,
-0.0536763556,
-0.0351522937,
0.0286010485,
-0.0195354074,
-0.0128063401,
0.0354790799,
0.026757203,
0.0281422082,
0.0093520703,
-0.0300368443,
0.0017154186,
0.0118549513,
0.0308634657,
0.0540771745,
0.0503328256,
-0.0042510149,
-0.0484000891,
0.0496540964,
0.0066804672,
0.0420772061,
-0.053617049,
0.0101251164,
0.0642861798,
0.079034932,
0.0396585725,
0.0258253012,
0.045178473,
0.0359986722,
-0.0301563796,
0.0043197135,
0.0040579727,
-0.0264298096,
0.0451933369,
-0.007291567,
0.0772148669,
0.0504720025,
-0.0184781197,
0.0003450958,
0.0167669412,
-0.0041731093,
0.0321063176,
-0.0729842559,
0.0059403051,
-0.0311550777,
-0.0395592004,
0.0179396886,
0.0033380636,
0.0212787837,
0.0238667279,
0.0002527402,
0.0603120588,
0.0266302601,
-0.0276486576,
-0.0192980859,
0.0113406675,
-0.0351649411,
-0.0426489338,
0.0260914695,
0.0900840238,
-0.0416283458,
0.024518244,
-0.0212369971,
-0.0649718195,
0.0745372474,
-0.057566639,
-0.0268745665,
0.0170436725,
-0.0298969261,
0.0788836256,
-0.0291946679,
0.0027025149,
-0.0530342795,
-0.0244755391,
-0.0723799244,
-0.0555681214,
-0.0574331582,
-0.0531070083,
-0.0716706291,
0.0540540926,
-0.0449300744,
-0.039858222,
0.0149993887,
0.0525305644,
0.0157260746,
-0.0260111131,
-0.0099447593,
0.0225985311,
-0.03766644,
-0.0171286799,
-0.0099803433,
0.0148344506,
-0.0718663484,
0.0158410184,
0.0217682384,
-0.0356128328,
0.0100656692,
0.026967017,
0.0281948633,
-0.0219818875,
0.0006980189,
0.0052974462,
-0.0267813448,
-0.0192236304,
-0.0315377787,
-0.0424113236,
0.0003025895,
-0.03980821,
-0.005343786,
-0.0757987946,
0.0170760006,
0.0048030899,
-0.0389368422,
0.0113001969,
0.0054240725,
0.0405359976,
-0.0170786344,
0.0107490635,
-0.0022324256,
-0.0176412631,
0.0944670439,
0.0244064052,
-0.0104826931,
0.0649421364,
0.0047998331,
-0.0076697087,
0.0577763617,
0.0365771875,
0.0129325343,
0.0100669637,
0.0094001098,
0.0247083902,
-0.0016966979,
0.0617189594,
0.0107610226,
0.0138136884,
0.0221797451,
0.0533827655,
-0.053581696,
-0.0162799452,
-0.0180398561,
0.0032640079,
-0.0090998644,
-0.0156729668,
0.056902431,
0.0302020889,
0.0009474861,
0.0160394423,
-0.0067340098,
0.0431662202,
-0.0295336377,
0.0126960389,
0.0872909129,
0.0045509269,
-0.0439165309,
-0.0173382666,
0.0003822383,
0.0062165284,
-0.009844264,
0.0145104975,
0.0157797355,
0.0216428656,
-0.0163897779,
0.0196873918,
0.0150270639,
-0.019841969,
0.0175059084,
-0.0307303295,
0.044167351,
0.0496850386,
0.0878262594,
-0.0451474302,
-0.0351302773,
-0.0063281851,
0.0228717588,
0.0320070162,
0.0274547786,
-0.0348487906,
0.0069371201,
-0.0440458208,
-0.0216039028,
-0.0525823943,
-0.0038273863,
0.0294084977,
0.028612271,
-0.0029462297,
0.0385394618,
-0.0403485633,
0.0099091884,
0.0281957835,
-0.0468484946,
-0.0181954261,
0.0160556678,
-0.013547224,
-0.001959376,
0.0348425992,
-0.0040019006,
0.0232093204,
0.0438539833,
-0.0148789808,
-0.0346904621,
-0.0260658488,
-0.0297235064,
-0.0339279212,
0.0386039913,
0.0094819637,
-0.0115456833,
0.0008049295,
-0.0214146376,
-0.0606899597,
-0.0160210226,
-0.0357638486,
0.034781225,
-0.0757853016,
-0.0094032157,
0.0363817997,
0.0317384861,
-0.0336690471,
0.0589826629,
0.0121406401,
0.0306513328,
0.0245203786,
0.0378059074,
0.0366896689,
-0.0364506803,
0.0145636238,
-0.0052414648,
-0.0127726132,
0.0237983316,
0.0264756512,
-0.0027571297,
-0.0508419313,
-0.0313208513,
-0.0955823287,
0.0071380255,
-0.0349575616,
0.0184087884,
0.0352852046,
0.0346557647,
-0.0009215987,
-0.042266164,
-0.0770821795,
-0.0014527981,
0.0477286503,
0.039999716,
0.0236900877,
0.0464464724,
0.0122653488,
-0.0446974076,
-0.0178631768,
0.0060371691,
0.0401564166,
0.0035885503,
0.0061566997,
-0.0182186309,
-0.0375094675,
-0.049638655,
0.0347335152,
-0.0097892592,
0.024608966,
0.0094831642,
-0.0485335961,
0.0479999036,
0.0077376617,
0.0028701765,
-0.0063332184,
0.037557289,
-0.0107915159,
-0.0798281804,
0.0240836684,
-0.0018410543,
-0.0112849046,
-0.0102362502,
-0.0034525823,
0.0096791778,
0.01148507,
-0.0255612489,
-0.01314604,
-0.0030540465,
-0.0021924761,
0.0265086237,
-0.0368994065,
-0.0339543149,
-0.0434777327,
0.0183340404,
0.04430224,
-0.0031443364,
0.0153707238,
0.0675446391,
-0.0280678589,
-0.0234034974,
-0.0619118251,
0.0173495002,
-0.0552643649,
0.0563671961,
-0.0067729335,
0.0276279077,
-0.0635579079,
-0.0123252356,
-0.0095520001,
0.0020021887,
-0.0029556621,
-0.0391234867,
0.0014699902,
-0.0082289129,
0.0502945185,
-0.0116441669,
-0.0208446495,
-0.0342312567,
-0.0279823653,
0.0265660509,
0.0229619052,
-0.0226486754,
-0.001063705,
-0.0377763249,
-0.00539055,
0.024990743,
0.0546808057,
-0.0353579074,
-0.0315352641,
-0.0087275896,
0.1093763858,
0.0884545147,
0.0271124896,
0.0415473916,
-0.0161093548,
0.0209471136,
0.0585427918,
0.0250877906,
-0.0203506202,
0.0102827083,
-0.0272627342,
0.0131636932,
-0.0239637252,
-0.0086917235,
-0.0135699054,
0.0202829745,
-0.0793415457,
-0.0391188748,
0.0743302479,
0.070113346,
-0.0378946811,
-0.0149063263,
-0.0724146664,
0.0532640181,
0.0216778703,
0.0775352344,
-0.0929092467,
-0.0128748938,
-0.0128862141,
0.0352056399,
-0.0072979038,
0.0001854064,
0.0005905202,
-0.0771354139,
0.0524131991,
-0.0393180698,
-0.0435086079,
0.0382492393,
-0.0268640984,
0.0102983797,
0.0506025329,
0.0264398772,
0.0275796894,
-0.0256153792,
-0.0100152595,
-0.0081940787,
0.0443631709,
-0.0105657279,
0.0181484669,
-0.0069579994,
0.0103377867,
0.0400087759,
0.0119010145,
0.0186883435,
-0.0118247811,
0.037639115,
-0.0340564959,
-0.0024637606,
0.011382251,
0.0160069596,
-0.011738061,
0.0341679119,
-0.0183594208,
0.0111549692,
-0.0230680313,
0.000530077,
0.0161368642,
0.0367508493,
-0.0282992292,
0.016492093,
-0.0529725887,
0.0065693096,
0.0062148836,
0.0874129161,
0.0070990473,
-0.0082982555,
-0.042601034,
-0.0122580267,
-0.0017263911,
-0.0265818723,
0.0225316696,
0.025083635,
-0.0024460063,
0.0129005862,
-0.1024511606,
-0.0623819679,
0.0075788298,
0.0125873219,
-0.0392627195,
0.0254935212,
-0.0457267873,
-0.0199811924,
-0.0442265086,
0.0087093413,
-0.0291053671,
-0.0070171594,
-0.0225192178,
0.0115064196,
0.0490806922,
-0.0574203655,
-0.0286536776,
0.0104288394,
-0.0727453679,
-0.0317241065,
-0.0073105814,
0.0083776871,
0.0125080291,
0.0527436994,
-0.0544115491,
-0.0490288064,
0.030510813,
0.0194871221,
-0.0647415146,
-0.0005369859,
0.0042206165,
0.0093386844,
-0.0316515826,
0.0403528102,
-0.1140152961,
0.0304327775,
-0.0456345938,
0.0581117198,
-0.0030772672,
-0.0189996753,
0.0285216253,
0.0027533709,
-0.0446539558,
0.0212634411,
0.0403772108,
-0.0125960158,
0.0357980207,
-0.040472839,
-0.0456333943,
-0.0095155025,
0.0208083969,
-0.0053059803,
-0.0536915623,
0.016108688,
0.0085779494,
-0.011438854,
0.0722130314,
-0.0199842378,
-0.0060019619,
0.0163511299,
-0.0056371554,
0.004321652,
-0.0145502305,
-0.035190098,
0.0058646854,
0.0115707209,
0.0802639276,
-0.0432669744,
0.0713537112,
0.0184635483,
-0.0417219959,
-0.012289416,
0.0183919724,
-0.1244153082,
-0.0411250256,
-0.0257394891,
0.015935149,
0.008866597,
0.0133029493,
0.0527862608,
-0.004971216,
-0.0239641499,
-0.0181878395,
-0.0394288674,
0.0293287057,
-0.0407550074,
0.0230424367,
0.0367790088,
-0.0113776047,
0.0772965625,
0.0648429021,
-0.0232250448,
0.0276916474,
-0.0091688475,
-0.0032716964,
-0.0207882542,
-0.04947225,
-0.0045498116,
0.0776302889,
-0.0311223101,
0.0084995274,
-0.0111695463,
-0.0195875894,
-0.0230070855,
0.001576667,
-0.0523888879,
-0.0110527147,
0.0347393043,
0.0640649199,
0.0250466,
-0.0334964432,
-0.0615045391,
0.0320173614,
-0.0647559389,
-0.0283557214,
0.0003397846,
-6.364973506e-33,
-0.0266601704,
-0.01023906,
0.049378939,
-0.0301331766,
0.0008879993,
0.0095391218,
-0.0596985668,
-0.0308164749,
-0.0231080353,
-0.0109300436,
-0.0197980255,
0.0181479976,
0.0011608512,
0.0539770797,
-0.0279770195,
-0.0015406786,
0.0232958738,
0.0059090913,
-0.0143541489,
0.0572492406,
0.0587120913,
-0.004782117,
0.0044006007,
-0.036595732,
0.0157823972,
-0.0427021943,
0.0001993449,
0.0475879982,
-0.0241033044,
0.1031107605,
-0.0236681718,
0.012048821,
0.0413581282,
0.0005029799,
-0.000243288,
0.0046706251,
-0.0968526676,
-0.0099077327,
-0.0172367692,
-0.0155156208,
-0.0540314205,
-0.039165318,
0.0234729052,
-0.0200421233,
0.0430846885,
0.0188902356,
0.0270402338,
-0.0102194725,
-0.0275269933,
-0.0523016751,
-0.0739104971,
0.0086160451,
-0.0185951088,
0.0125362612,
-0.0415984429,
0.0707065687,
0.0088309096,
0.0628616735,
-0.0622889809,
0.0031963019,
-0.0313766934,
0.0250109136,
0.0301166214,
0.0100909527,
-0.0098798079,
0.0172120072,
0.0175770633,
0.02128198,
0.0009520129,
-0.0290635694,
-0.0090807015,
0.0075425301,
0.0119249048,
0.0482517034,
0.031161163,
0.0551856458,
-0.0385053679,
0.0685861558,
-0.0077635325,
0.0303877536,
0.0177139007,
0.0124443127,
-0.0210601632,
0.0047297962,
-0.030713236,
0.0264575388,
-0.0408199094,
-0.0292363055,
0.0423810743,
0.0122783883,
-0.0117865214,
0.008011058,
0.0494057015,
-0.029604964,
-0.003385942,
0.0477816053,
-0.0408856608,
0.0374863222,
-0.0053854696,
0.0779750049,
-0.0025923767,
0.0210067127,
0.0630377606,
-0.0316968635,
-0.0374685153,
0.0253992137,
0.0245644674,
-0.0012872835,
-0.0628727004,
0.0242253244,
-0.015906414,
0.0309304427,
-0.0594648533,
-0.0196013674,
0.0207312983,
0.0197582487,
0.0039649266,
0.0637951493,
0.0320086889,
0.0252345968,
-0.0301111098,
-0.0548283197,
-0.0078127673,
0.0078558838,
-0.0197452512,
0.0638241321,
-0.0372269675,
0.0032994684,
0.0138456533,
-0.0566868484,
0.0107047576,
0.0587796345,
2.476e-7,
0.0574848689,
0.0265404284,
0.0360162631,
-0.0178337656,
0.0351949297,
-0.0140396217,
-0.0021542027,
0.0106118126,
0.0124245621,
-0.0079569481,
-0.0080759069,
0.0475778729,
0.0261457935,
0.0260715354,
-0.051423341,
-0.0126981409,
-0.0831785053,
-0.033021763,
-0.0643574446,
-0.0232835766,
0.0344562829,
0.0554248355,
-0.0386041664,
-0.0288068522,
-0.0342293084,
-0.0550340898,
0.0675149411,
0.0382073633,
-0.0206158701,
0.0395642705,
0.0143288933,
0.0085975137,
0.031254068,
-0.0291451868,
-0.0047975108,
0.0467074737,
0.0160204563,
0.0531130172,
-0.0011326236,
-0.0552789494,
-0.0007739103,
-0.020211082,
0.0461324044,
-0.0622936264,
0.0911083221,
-0.0013966167,
0.0103724254,
-0.0071411836,
-0.0617011152,
-0.0002246853,
-0.023889441,
-0.0367621817,
-0.0209751651,
0.0307724494,
0.0095918421,
-0.0055299141,
0.0027041978,
-0.0719316378,
-0.0160993002,
0.006732482,
-0.0459533036,
-0.0184197295,
-0.0164934192,
0.0026810861,
-0.018492166,
-0.0443717837,
-0.0116998265,
2.19561521e-34,
0.0609010644,
0.0153423697,
-0.0061490429,
0.0258678775,
0.030517159,
-0.0032589696,
-0.036583744,
0.0017845593,
0.0228076167,
-0.1166926101,
0.0035474773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00271v1 | A Crucial Parameter for Rank-Frequency Relation in Natural Languages | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | Chenchen Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL | $f \propto r^{-\alpha} \cdot (r+\gamma)^{-\beta}$ has been empirically shown
more precise than a na\"ive power law $f\propto r^{-\alpha}$ to model the
rank-frequency ($r$-$f$) relation of words in natural languages. This work
shows that the only crucial parameter in the formulation is $\gamma$, which
depicts the resistance to vocabulary growth on a corpus. A method of parameter
estimation by searching an optimal $\gamma$ is proposed, where a ``zeroth
word'' is introduced technically for the calculation. The formulation and
parameters are further discussed with several case studies. | [
0.026043186,
0.0387460031,
-0.0416933484,
0.0190576538,
-0.0200888533,
-0.0180693269,
-0.0683046654,
0.0330466218,
-0.0599804744,
0.0017618296,
0.0347306356,
-0.1066666096,
0.0468053892,
-0.0140094478,
0.0021426273,
-0.0421392322,
0.0260390025,
-0.0322991498,
0.0482235625,
0.0136954011,
0.0154134277,
-0.0319565162,
-0.0114867706,
-0.0039799809,
-0.0036505221,
0.0414792337,
0.0475834757,
-0.0454764515,
0.0080024973,
-0.0128025645,
-0.0345426574,
0.0683138222,
0.0102747455,
0.0468101874,
0.0000016992,
-0.0609849207,
-0.0011393348,
0.0275118966,
0.0099995816,
-0.0168427993,
0.0837635398,
0.0098142717,
-0.0405405313,
0.0334954709,
0.0056929304,
0.0567978397,
0.0355299897,
-0.0344831236,
-0.0525739193,
0.0157774333,
-0.00482766,
-0.031515535,
0.0298788901,
-0.0306350421,
0.0002317064,
-0.0183922704,
0.0330532007,
0.0206898656,
0.0149405682,
-0.0040244935,
-0.0628446862,
0.0050731963,
-0.0376004875,
0.0282334201,
0.0349392518,
0.0002270686,
-0.0103530912,
-0.0257851146,
0.0279047117,
0.0570620485,
0.0072002686,
0.0076078591,
0.0258546062,
0.023485167,
-0.0093297884,
0.0303695593,
-0.0408913158,
-0.015217511,
0.0032047445,
-0.0205683913,
0.0198124591,
0.0067184563,
-0.0063805194,
-0.011994021,
-0.0331444442,
0.0437793992,
0.0376140736,
-0.0443134159,
0.0196752269,
-0.0877557471,
-0.0783828422,
0.0103079043,
-0.0063931192,
0.0153605361,
0.0237995014,
0.0323538668,
0.0104956403,
-0.0708062872,
0.0445137173,
-0.1021316871,
0.0012250483,
-0.0446925387,
0.0440650955,
0.0013341075,
0.0014576768,
0.0337746739,
0.0253789108,
-0.0674913004,
-0.0298301205,
0.0249700788,
-0.02716171,
-0.0061657433,
-0.0102013648,
-0.0042774025,
-0.0285856258,
-0.0255981144,
-0.0660276338,
-0.0126492381,
0.0340851918,
-0.0146293566,
-0.0387830921,
-0.01735094,
-0.0270909518,
0.0117794173,
-0.0311112367,
0.0270099156,
-0.00167972,
0.0081156278,
-0.0397946686,
-0.0241669733,
0.0371179916,
-0.0337404795,
0.0454062223,
-0.0065438813,
0.0186596438,
0.0345844887,
0.0031244291,
-0.0140588088,
0.0323249064,
-0.0084347557,
-0.0368925259,
-0.0280167423,
-0.0670834184,
-0.0709772334,
-0.0169187151,
0.0302200746,
0.0027170067,
0.0036817037,
0.0247189198,
0.0277560093,
-0.0527874082,
0.0481287502,
-0.0060539087,
0.0323651694,
0.0499702506,
-0.0040962216,
-0.0046856287,
0.0648381859,
0.0371651538,
-0.0422862247,
0.048233889,
-0.06418854,
-0.0194936283,
0.0248316526,
-0.0223208964,
0.0240946747,
-0.0018163351,
-0.0574135631,
-0.0106421188,
0.0099802576,
0.0195575524,
0.0531641655,
0.0007147567,
-0.0497079529,
0.0238571651,
0.0622270927,
0.0517082736,
0.0330221094,
-0.0390611961,
0.0097690783,
-0.0011768243,
0.0264230296,
0.0485407077,
-0.0202049818,
-0.0365885906,
-0.008736331,
0.0210521109,
0.0358680561,
0.0035256883,
-0.0297515616,
-0.0139368381,
0.0037776465,
0.0479466543,
-0.0827805102,
0.0675464794,
-0.0127504217,
0.0045305309,
-0.0317293853,
0.0485160798,
-0.0302283149,
-0.0009001804,
0.015411295,
0.0006479705,
0.0028487777,
0.0305051152,
-0.0378098451,
0.0449348278,
0.0358896926,
-0.0211339537,
0.0513594337,
-0.012314246,
0.0171840135,
-0.0004417674,
-0.013422545,
0.0193326231,
0.0495464019,
-0.0108474009,
0.003434265,
-0.0329492129,
0.0533354692,
0.0250651948,
-0.064798288,
-0.050186526,
-0.0025282179,
0.0022951742,
-0.0018825477,
-0.0197510123,
-0.0390757248,
0.0175341796,
0.000941474,
-0.0160397664,
0.0336126685,
-0.0091053462,
-0.0452528037,
0.0110188015,
-0.0094567724,
0.02239893,
0.045433823,
0.0223296229,
-0.0101888347,
0.0779175162,
0.0428604558,
0.0306908768,
0.0100974794,
0.0468316823,
-0.0377904512,
0.1015379354,
-0.0184372589,
0.0643000454,
-0.0268994141,
0.0597657226,
-0.0110551799,
0.0510057211,
0.0114357658,
0.0900380835,
0.0269690286,
-0.0330460854,
0.0648240522,
-0.0131116165,
-0.0331278071,
0.0012475087,
0.0009614842,
-0.0143098887,
0.0631068721,
-0.0422402211,
0.0002426135,
-0.0246751364,
-0.0091361571,
-0.0615317523,
0.007207707,
-0.0091183474,
-0.0371608287,
0.0098629659,
-0.0074201096,
0.0138640935,
-0.0210977271,
0.0162044726,
0.008939269,
0.0467663929,
0.0209163949,
-0.001267945,
-0.0777179226,
-0.058982417,
-0.0351175927,
-0.0000474079,
-0.0132408934,
0.0480944254,
-0.0065165102,
-0.0510686822,
0.0669980347,
-0.0971715227,
0.03840084,
-0.0370562375,
-0.0484587699,
-0.0107724313,
-0.0170799494,
0.0805014744,
-0.0485780686,
0.0701215416,
-0.0316081271,
0.0452620089,
0.0103848064,
-0.0178451929,
-0.0600268058,
-0.0505254716,
0.0309706666,
-0.0196590554,
-0.0147222644,
0.0620568506,
0.0234184526,
0.0361860693,
-0.0455014631,
-0.0102497889,
-0.0011607582,
-0.0684472769,
0.0171320327,
-0.0211432856,
0.0202466082,
-0.0397977121,
0.0334596708,
0.0030892654,
-0.0704555139,
0.0049791103,
-0.0352983512,
0.0345086642,
-0.0193985552,
-0.037691962,
-0.0200256724,
-0.0003486769,
0.0502440631,
0.0070925765,
-0.0061521437,
-0.0402241126,
-0.0311553497,
-0.0042643463,
0.0661245733,
-0.0615959205,
0.0179114453,
-0.0403095856,
0.0082979947,
-0.0346865356,
0.0064527309,
0.0057532494,
-0.0771890432,
0.0663807616,
0.0130948424,
0.0585535541,
-0.0447632484,
0.0469625108,
0.0160112772,
0.0462062731,
0.0126440348,
0.0035132472,
-0.0053956877,
0.0017675355,
0.0652719289,
0.062068738,
-0.0120917102,
0.0363318585,
-0.0191313848,
0.024989089,
-0.0056289411,
0.060020119,
0.0302526373,
0.0026037714,
-0.0143934311,
0.0026726942,
-0.0244156439,
0.0084590167,
0.0607313178,
-0.0572008528,
0.0211751442,
0.0350713842,
0.0521568395,
0.0175893586,
0.003095479,
0.044444859,
-0.020840276,
0.0564767756,
0.0106089842,
0.0163688138,
-0.0407885686,
0.0877341926,
0.0006507048,
-0.0078441938,
-0.0208742637,
-0.0374284536,
-0.030671414,
-0.1265176833,
-0.0013988109,
-0.0255333446,
0.0670455173,
-0.017603077,
-0.001076325,
0.0124154203,
0.0391410813,
-0.043359939,
0.052835457,
-0.0307562742,
-0.0051935632,
0.064564757,
-0.074263595,
-0.0146798063,
-0.0026335162,
-0.0630482137,
0.0322084352,
-0.0547914803,
0.0563697889,
-0.0893884078,
-0.0563567393,
-0.0693787411,
-0.0158419348,
-0.0178253558,
-0.0146600055,
-0.0131760389,
0.0643737167,
-0.0300716087,
-0.0094497818,
-0.0318464637,
0.0198920537,
0.009717701,
0.0118055632,
0.017807981,
0.0287040472,
-0.0094835134,
-0.0160611533,
0.0129851038,
-0.0197692364,
0.0509286933,
0.0010901014,
-0.0066195014,
0.0448576212,
-0.0079220673,
0.0414639935,
-0.0024881684,
-0.0408289284,
-0.0245142225,
0.0196028892,
-0.0259689465,
-0.0872377977,
0.0632657036,
-0.0145717235,
0.0822796449,
0.041325815,
0.0917042345,
0.0003684727,
-0.0050090966,
0.0173124764,
-0.059560027,
0.0413193665,
-0.0123850759,
-0.0626692921,
-0.0414132066,
0.0352232493,
-0.0077573094,
-0.032055907,
-0.0156338327,
-0.0097262366,
-0.0272419155,
0.0219425131,
0.014728196,
0.0272140466,
-0.0350398831,
-0.0018007047,
-0.0732155591,
-0.0038491494,
0.0172174517,
-0.0309768375,
0.020887658,
-0.003593626,
-0.0185573697,
0.012137698,
0.004332487,
-0.0265566073,
0.035959471,
-0.0441173241,
0.0728929639,
-0.0259470586,
-0.0292035379,
0.037259765,
0.0369201042,
-0.0131513383,
-0.0315399431,
-0.0359933265,
-0.025323797,
-0.0137579711,
-0.0613026842,
0.030326236,
0.0143958647,
-0.0048991609,
-0.0200842135,
0.0188935418,
-0.0721207336,
-0.0587081797,
-0.0087126857,
-0.0235192142,
-0.0058854735,
0.0034407815,
0.0179053694,
0.0027545947,
0.0347920246,
0.008022801,
0.0154563738,
-0.0067234435,
-0.020140728,
0.0657897145,
-0.0070961295,
0.0108228633,
-0.0216703154,
-0.0230946727,
-0.0015657095,
0.0292201843,
-0.0098411459,
-0.0158756953,
-0.0156278461,
-0.0337762907,
-0.0069470056,
0.0054850266,
0.0072653964,
-0.0244997907,
0.0386513397,
-0.0194971059,
-0.0214855205,
-0.0275882743,
0.0091650793,
-0.0318698809,
0.0326987207,
-0.0050590718,
0.0994673669,
0.081930995,
0.0531732813,
-0.0403014757,
0.0033204525,
-0.0539629944,
0.0252561476,
0.0279515442,
-0.0434111729,
0.0007835503,
0.0088865124,
0.0083400495,
-0.0729952678,
-0.0522383377,
0.0392214768,
-0.0256045666,
0.0386596546,
-0.0078563681,
0.0019604953,
0.0202190541,
-0.0503231622,
0.030331878,
-0.0409773327,
0.0031013514,
-0.0623284243,
0.0451423675,
0.0217386596,
-5.443861275e-33,
-0.0127591854,
-0.024040211,
-0.0161318183,
0.0645745397,
0.0001725105,
0.0207321979,
0.0089000314,
0.0165376272,
-0.0218669046,
-0.0060035125,
0.0194034781,
-0.0158180203,
-0.000726345,
-0.0316636227,
0.0140600558,
0.0212152675,
-0.0394689776,
0.0212410409,
0.0237595011,
-0.0306172185,
0.0644109324,
0.0364181027,
0.0638559908,
0.0038687249,
-0.0034797129,
0.0134878568,
0.0047144732,
0.0240948461,
0.0572479814,
0.0137620969,
0.0113398321,
0.0782024935,
0.0232862737,
-0.071930714,
-0.0051449179,
-0.0081475563,
-0.0305310581,
-0.0530299768,
0.0452314913,
-0.0209859107,
0.0448271073,
0.0650334656,
0.0205681622,
-0.0319790319,
-0.0368970037,
0.0254288353,
0.0552083738,
-0.0039035729,
-0.0466511063,
-0.0430186354,
-0.0598814748,
0.0360166989,
0.0057803816,
0.0133276638,
0.0283194128,
-0.0368254855,
0.0087815747,
-0.0209638756,
-0.0177958496,
-0.0012645157,
0.0495270006,
0.1093556732,
-0.0253585149,
0.0151354717,
-0.0293849707,
0.0600305051,
0.0293970779,
-0.0190106574,
0.0477527454,
0.0019765748,
0.0317566656,
0.0388703011,
0.0122642396,
0.0358758457,
0.0903674662,
-0.0234278012,
-0.0435019322,
0.0151730655,
0.0373131521,
0.0157755464,
0.021048503,
-0.021118138,
-0.0859568939,
-0.0146054886,
-0.0120890317,
-0.0082497913,
-0.0299556088,
-0.0200280249,
0.0263350047,
-0.0282686185,
0.0223520715,
-0.0282304939,
0.0340297297,
-0.0254724417,
-0.058610741,
0.0343309455,
0.0191276558,
0.0223883204,
-0.0239209104,
-0.0111324312,
-0.006199521,
-0.0246574376,
-0.0097381622,
0.0240675453,
0.020305749,
-0.0548193306,
-0.0259750579,
0.0095154345,
-0.0349470638,
-0.0344370492,
-0.0031086649,
-0.009191785,
0.0308301151,
0.0196235292,
-0.0035723811,
-0.0203282218,
-0.01359211,
0.0315458998,
0.0416122302,
0.0120036909,
-0.0097880494,
0.013137863,
0.0189024564,
0.0032599296,
-0.018665703,
-0.0587051958,
-0.0118474942,
0.0553883128,
0.0650215149,
-0.0194493271,
-0.0137919234,
-0.002778583,
2.704e-7,
0.0134600708,
0.018577639,
0.0255351551,
-0.0339461267,
0.0035133092,
-0.0346290804,
-0.0425576083,
0.0175819732,
-0.028089866,
0.0035797451,
-0.0220379606,
-0.0398255847,
0.0126179401,
0.0513955131,
-0.0458939821,
-0.027542077,
-0.105066888,
-0.0058344165,
-0.0203268789,
-0.0217131954,
-0.0551186316,
0.0330078825,
-0.0174660031,
-0.013038992,
-0.031040052,
-0.0339975916,
0.010776096,
-0.0517473817,
-0.0193591975,
0.0054224199,
0.0317379199,
0.0050294609,
0.0229163561,
-0.0002192186,
-0.0267069582,
0.0589646064,
0.0368094966,
-0.0117693851,
-0.0050251014,
0.0274129491,
0.0229972508,
-0.0068011465,
-0.0265563987,
-0.0023158453,
0.0107054366,
0.0527697802,
-0.0438449271,
0.0104226004,
-0.0300022177,
-0.0029415069,
-0.0005973069,
-0.0121864956,
-0.0245036073,
-0.0104112085,
0.0263519976,
0.0002261464,
-0.0331222974,
-0.0400604643,
0.0180862248,
0.0243892539,
-0.0255162604,
-0.0667842254,
-0.0097190645,
-0.0301745161,
0.0140933394,
0.0258774124,
0.0284630004,
2.298884226e-34,
0.0363147743,
-0.0135777155,
-0.0029832774,
0.0063437051,
0.0332087837,
0.0470823534,
0.0278720316,
0.0313524678,
0.032637205,
-0.1025795937,
-0.0190369096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00263v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00263v3 | Does DetectGPT Fully Utilize Perturbation? Bridge Selective Perturbation to Fine-tuned Contrastive Learning Detector would be Better | 2024-02-01T01:23:07 | 2024-02-24T13:46:21 | Shengchao Liu, Xiaoming Liu, Yichen Wang, Zehua Cheng, Chengzhengxu Li, Zhaohan Zhang, Yu Lan, Chao Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The burgeoning generative capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
raised growing concerns about abuse, demanding automatic machine-generated text
detectors. DetectGPT, a zero-shot metric-based detector, first introduces
perturbation and shows great performance improvement. However, in DetectGPT,
random perturbation strategy could introduce noise, and logit regression
depends on threshold, harming the generalizability and applicability of
individual or small-batch inputs. Hence, we propose a novel fine-tuned
detector, Pecola, bridging metric-based and fine-tuned detectors by contrastive
learning on selective perturbation. Selective strategy retains important tokens
during perturbation and weights for multi-pair contrastive learning. The
experiments show that Pecola outperforms the state-of-the-art by 1.20% in
accuracy on average on four public datasets. And we further analyze the
effectiveness, robustness, and generalization of the method. | [
-0.0254979823,
0.069126606,
-0.0045913919,
0.0622190572,
-0.030632399,
0.0243584849,
-0.0186350271,
0.0665549412,
0.0271856245,
-0.0218269583,
-0.0108986413,
-0.0449593812,
-0.0382575728,
0.0236711334,
0.0466482118,
-0.0330421403,
0.0551763736,
0.0026686424,
-0.0029465107,
0.0233715456,
0.0144216204,
0.0290936437,
-0.0040087923,
0.0267741531,
-0.0153868822,
-0.0347446389,
-0.0012429333,
0.0436140709,
0.0503618866,
-0.0553963259,
0.0278619099,
0.0834267214,
0.0058690421,
0.1031290963,
0.000002009,
-0.0336414464,
-0.0235142726,
0.0046268441,
-0.0002169915,
0.0062938174,
0.0558538735,
-0.0386366621,
-0.0295729358,
0.0401568636,
-0.0210449062,
-0.0575604029,
0.0537073165,
0.0505371392,
-0.0247011445,
0.1079067588,
-0.0335711949,
-0.0368011333,
0.0352639109,
-0.0365784951,
0.0012230548,
-0.0271964669,
0.0370370783,
-0.0304569062,
-0.0220587384,
0.0337261073,
-0.0219175108,
0.0010226021,
-0.0020747134,
0.0038078597,
-0.0242699049,
0.0485706776,
-0.0112463059,
-0.0109252902,
-0.0320360139,
0.0519443639,
-0.0592330433,
-0.0435139984,
0.0238656159,
-0.0330428928,
0.0013500339,
-0.0562281497,
-0.0031258073,
-0.0438679643,
-0.0018236432,
0.0623716414,
0.0104356613,
-0.0462334864,
0.0299637746,
0.0198443346,
-0.0185608417,
-0.001527774,
0.0331811346,
-0.0394895636,
-0.0361250341,
0.0382614136,
-0.0670078471,
-0.0488878116,
0.0067327856,
-0.0131508643,
-0.0135038495,
-0.0380681902,
-0.056542851,
-0.0635429919,
-0.0064074923,
0.0130720278,
0.0146094449,
0.0225030053,
-0.0333572589,
0.0507581979,
-0.045828037,
0.0499752574,
-0.0667658225,
0.0276951455,
-0.0047390349,
0.017628476,
-0.007544667,
0.0030351924,
-0.032592874,
-0.0103490716,
-0.0017223094,
-0.01100583,
-0.0052208626,
0.0296755936,
0.0382338502,
-0.0319247134,
0.01512093,
-0.0366548039,
-0.0422930196,
-0.0042522298,
0.04900565,
0.0456265956,
-0.0134981629,
0.0082509881,
-0.0103145456,
-0.0323585086,
-0.06485679,
0.0594878271,
0.0415774956,
-0.0045002792,
0.0384769253,
0.0472639725,
-0.0145181352,
-0.0876639336,
-0.0516182408,
-0.0085734874,
-0.0329101942,
-0.0545857809,
-0.0256508701,
-0.0528001636,
-0.0306688361,
-0.0174826328,
0.0181747098,
-0.0383797809,
-0.009480956,
0.0070952163,
-0.0297845621,
0.0748973712,
-0.0357679091,
-0.021959763,
-0.0375875197,
-0.0118139368,
-0.0454115905,
0.1222991273,
0.0198003985,
0.0223729834,
0.0205931105,
0.0234274361,
-0.0179764144,
0.0602612123,
0.0236207191,
0.0491618589,
-0.0048973979,
-0.0363672674,
0.0100094499,
-0.0270101707,
0.0805602297,
0.0425390713,
-0.0146225281,
-0.0019137731,
0.0579859726,
0.0578723401,
0.0479702242,
0.0363208614,
0.0379770696,
0.0335715041,
-0.0763446018,
0.0514237247,
0.0101320446,
-0.0204401426,
-0.0379340686,
-0.0206921231,
0.0581289306,
0.032406237,
-0.0312974602,
0.014320665,
-0.0177290626,
-0.0182598028,
-0.0278864652,
-0.0280604735,
0.0951535776,
0.0192234367,
-0.0438126512,
0.0026814644,
0.0198103078,
-0.0235772021,
0.0008161906,
-0.0784161612,
0.0472931452,
0.0245770495,
0.0467483215,
-0.0244003944,
0.0457270034,
-0.0152504798,
-0.0092907641,
0.0351007022,
0.0105637908,
0.0417624936,
0.0457447059,
-0.0365754813,
-0.0150767136,
0.0061141155,
0.0352947861,
0.0268116537,
0.0483663455,
0.044092577,
0.0128364963,
-0.0201826636,
0.0277997851,
0.0450235121,
0.0215388071,
-0.0335714184,
0.0378965065,
-0.0156677719,
0.0307557434,
0.0013434383,
-0.0188315921,
-0.0125439698,
-0.0076743667,
-0.0330389738,
0.0086621903,
-0.0059956461,
0.0055288128,
-0.0882875994,
0.0266337655,
-0.0133292051,
-0.0100706629,
0.0315638445,
-0.0428222865,
-0.0118794618,
0.0240113065,
-0.0237170737,
0.0340889245,
-0.0578138046,
0.0056395349,
-0.0210185293,
0.0714581013,
0.0009452841,
0.0661184862,
0.004199252,
-0.0081824837,
-0.0109056542,
0.0525291562,
0.0502391644,
-0.0350768864,
-0.0399625674,
-0.0314438604,
0.0079491064,
0.0036307175,
0.0024363699,
0.0599919967,
-0.0137892514,
-0.0387993865,
-0.0371126533,
0.0084904321,
-0.0337949954,
0.0113809826,
0.0540059209,
0.0138844606,
-0.0208327137,
-0.0024890499,
-0.0051767393,
-0.0231641624,
0.0285474285,
0.0095389811,
0.0173145849,
-0.0265474804,
0.0064975899,
-0.01699063,
-0.0058977399,
-0.0227142535,
0.0161841605,
0.0148261143,
-0.0295953639,
-0.0601020306,
0.0601297952,
0.0298743583,
0.0401564501,
0.0256459191,
-0.0396972559,
0.0079278639,
-0.0352867655,
0.0552100539,
0.0668841526,
-0.0119871264,
-0.0092036948,
-0.0068227956,
0.015723573,
-0.0112786312,
-0.0044047795,
-0.0138027547,
0.0042196144,
-0.0172407646,
-0.0074120858,
-0.010041574,
0.0598791614,
-0.0007868295,
-0.0161303412,
-0.0614806712,
0.008210863,
-0.0137286652,
-0.0199297201,
0.0187349748,
0.0211132281,
-0.0375643857,
0.0146112079,
-0.0245734192,
-0.0370656773,
0.0674999431,
-0.0218308512,
-0.0252235923,
-0.0467244759,
-0.0085423002,
-0.0147897899,
-0.0029341402,
0.0143278763,
0.0106539754,
0.007940379,
-0.0255129728,
-0.0411659665,
-0.0137375388,
0.0130636757,
-0.020575678,
0.0036730948,
-0.0076573915,
0.0355157889,
-0.0244362671,
-0.0416579433,
-0.0225314982,
-0.0344905443,
-0.0140758427,
-0.0196367148,
0.0273954943,
-0.048064094,
-0.0091332793,
0.0576597601,
-0.0181538481,
0.0713205487,
-0.0158580169,
-0.0092216153,
-0.0398445614,
0.0888518095,
0.0264580678,
-0.0683522597,
0.0385293365,
-0.0353566743,
0.0159017444,
0.0661070198,
0.0230074599,
0.0065679853,
-0.0371746719,
0.0016661164,
0.0093325069,
0.0388014615,
-0.007288903,
-0.0130858328,
0.0392877422,
-0.039644625,
-0.0496029295,
0.0787448734,
-0.0052875816,
-0.0957096741,
-0.0217895545,
0.0318397842,
0.0410108902,
0.006614205,
-0.0138397496,
-0.092902936,
-0.0366405547,
0.0161979962,
0.0165241566,
-0.0278135203,
0.0036564639,
-0.0198709946,
-0.0708612651,
0.0476807915,
0.0250737928,
-0.0053788014,
-0.0140709868,
-0.0171098467,
0.0392203853,
-0.02043432,
0.00194498,
-0.0069268229,
0.0163966995,
-0.0098798713,
-0.0054184436,
0.0183712542,
-0.0799563378,
-0.0227326322,
-0.0478938445,
-0.010005475,
0.0726970732,
0.0035038993,
-0.0098201158,
-0.0417035408,
0.0327522866,
-0.0246277209,
-0.0326051228,
-0.022030497,
0.0627762452,
-0.005061599,
-0.0361869112,
-0.0109898867,
0.0175018366,
-0.015547093,
-0.0227333903,
-0.0039267368,
0.0361354016,
0.0229748003,
-0.0201399941,
-0.0175219961,
-0.0140260337,
0.0028555735,
0.0531711951,
0.0322125107,
-0.0388469473,
-0.0389817655,
-0.0025264602,
0.0193954054,
-0.0668859482,
-0.0097358515,
-0.044764027,
0.0159239788,
-0.0643262193,
-0.0409519412,
0.0086726481,
-0.0069685066,
0.0382971391,
-0.0222478099,
0.0138584971,
-0.0685344562,
0.0084384345,
-0.0189953912,
0.0209252518,
-0.043733228,
-0.0111030359,
-0.0925659835,
-0.0066344631,
0.0353503861,
0.0164329205,
-0.0261962488,
0.0173193943,
-0.1282272637,
-0.0715308785,
-0.0422211066,
0.0017219624,
0.0146387881,
0.0056767925,
-0.0549213029,
-0.0272236522,
0.0512607321,
0.0397896841,
0.0021710854,
0.0538386069,
0.0181753915,
-0.0711440742,
-0.0151014645,
0.0272293743,
-0.011235307,
0.0239111837,
0.0146729294,
0.0115842307,
-0.0454821363,
-0.000216474,
0.0070998305,
-0.0020909456,
0.0975893363,
-0.0300278552,
0.0434870794,
-0.0507593527,
-0.0187278278,
0.0118911043,
0.0209564064,
-0.0485810451,
0.0465243459,
0.0425961614,
-0.0088346358,
-0.0457783118,
0.0000684057,
-0.0276261661,
0.0403277986,
-0.0582338944,
-0.0008755482,
-0.0051408955,
0.0179306827,
0.0352470614,
-0.009371276,
0.007753788,
0.0225499645,
0.0090468405,
0.0209617186,
-0.025392767,
0.039212469,
0.0426799096,
-0.0114707025,
-0.0076407166,
0.0383732319,
-0.038238816,
0.0054677855,
-0.0691444427,
0.0332846381,
0.0910678953,
0.0224483591,
0.0664061978,
-0.0225464161,
-0.0328103378,
-0.0263825636,
0.0118736075,
-0.0053231614,
-0.0085430909,
-0.0052789012,
-0.0011014773,
-0.0046477816,
0.0365036763,
0.078287147,
-0.0388541259,
0.0351641364,
0.009796083,
-0.0187325832,
-0.0226091836,
0.00493753,
0.0004837648,
0.0046945298,
0.0083664935,
0.0518532172,
-0.0034725314,
-0.0637373477,
0.0022669025,
-0.0152991647,
-0.0141478973,
0.0168162584,
0.0014988276,
0.0155564556,
-0.0182260498,
-0.0157831553,
-0.0210484676,
-0.0242562108,
0.0150535023,
-0.0128386058,
-0.0019009066,
-6.66257635e-33,
-0.030013755,
-0.0202720165,
-0.0539684445,
-0.0043876707,
-0.0007580543,
0.0028475132,
-0.0058352877,
-0.0169107709,
-0.0071243155,
-0.0078975148,
-0.0074445326,
0.0516311973,
0.0096198404,
0.0168532934,
-0.0165710188,
-0.0435179286,
0.0510351919,
-0.0166164432,
-0.0187698137,
0.036880292,
0.0113732005,
0.0153591679,
0.0566132665,
-0.0635531917,
-0.0171062704,
0.0235752631,
-0.0458395556,
-0.0169062167,
-0.0194409918,
0.063473776,
-0.0209304914,
0.0166182257,
0.0169433653,
0.0123130931,
-0.0199458674,
0.0388709903,
-0.0318771936,
-0.0071258303,
-0.0225745905,
-0.0026092445,
0.0009950179,
-0.042292133,
0.0113801211,
-0.008510951,
-0.0065506506,
-0.0095854653,
0.0166183263,
-0.0355552696,
0.0075730956,
-0.0180073325,
-0.0052296044,
0.0538419299,
0.0029588235,
0.005745267,
0.0332751833,
0.0311323274,
0.0127348267,
0.0574553534,
-0.0246404912,
0.0073444359,
0.0484751835,
0.0578025058,
-0.0089088697,
0.0560133867,
0.0225438308,
0.0180908069,
0.0358470306,
-0.0480437204,
0.053311497,
-0.062187694,
0.036290545,
-0.0378232561,
0.0500666313,
0.066108346,
0.0511937067,
-0.004276834,
-0.0787268654,
-0.0129954061,
0.00559184,
-0.0026149834,
0.0473327413,
0.0338332728,
-0.0549246594,
-0.0109992335,
0.0077905641,
-0.1211025715,
-0.0510667749,
-0.0263844039,
0.0246069357,
0.0496838838,
-0.0349573977,
-0.0181851536,
0.0273100231,
-0.0355216786,
-0.0003427702,
-0.0163987018,
-0.0393530279,
0.000270864,
0.0135288797,
0.0254571512,
-0.0314413793,
-0.0210618414,
0.0429570265,
0.0268557817,
0.007339085,
-0.0079366509,
0.0348481163,
0.0242379028,
-0.071952939,
0.0059523848,
-0.0212697852,
0.0235420354,
-0.0085535543,
0.0156156495,
0.0175824966,
-0.0228563864,
0.022577228,
0.0903838873,
0.073139362,
0.01350486,
-0.0270892177,
0.0254331324,
-0.0079627875,
0.0524203926,
-0.0508815832,
0.0148537233,
0.0058940593,
0.0141697694,
0.0649326444,
-0.0567228608,
-0.0182651319,
0.0138605488,
2.696e-7,
0.0418104939,
0.0147202769,
0.0201256163,
0.0034183781,
0.0069963844,
0.0292483587,
-0.024974674,
0.0193759315,
0.0017783473,
0.0551888235,
0.0214878041,
0.0100341821,
0.0381190516,
0.0037785664,
-0.0877801999,
0.0720730349,
-0.0631554425,
0.0187818892,
-0.0600940324,
-0.0146794058,
0.0502782613,
0.0868665725,
0.0408961959,
0.0053618955,
0.0352043845,
-0.0787803009,
0.0570831224,
-0.0038080104,
0.0420676172,
-0.0178638957,
0.0373156928,
0.0519013256,
-0.0016543637,
0.0037020873,
-0.0010484933,
0.0494411364,
-0.032787919,
0.048655685,
-0.0006287081,
-0.0364219658,
0.0253498405,
0.0054892311,
0.0052401046,
-0.0671060905,
0.08225739,
-0.0352761932,
0.0041447114,
-0.0307493061,
-0.0194747373,
-0.0623811223,
0.0249025561,
-0.0491875522,
-0.0638576522,
0.0028529339,
0.0291189849,
0.0073537799,
-0.0297351982,
-0.0784251988,
0.0088920286,
0.0178322848,
-0.0401992761,
-0.0360981263,
-0.0245089531,
0.0118402187,
0.0213459041,
-0.017542297,
-0.0002921403,
2.749235627e-34,
0.0375380479,
-0.0365058705,
-0.0132025778,
0.0265328791,
0.0207636971,
-0.0013522209,
-0.0073644854,
-0.0356247239,
0.0124261584,
-0.0593653508,
0.0037341057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00253v2 | A Survey on Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-01T00:33:21 | 2024-05-06T01:10:01 | Hanchao Liu, Wenyuan Xue, Yifei Chen, Dapeng Chen, Xiutian Zhao, Ke Wang, Liping Hou, Rongjun Li, Wei Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent development of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has attracted
growing attention within the AI landscape for its practical implementation
potential. However, ``hallucination'', or more specifically, the misalignment
between factual visual content and corresponding textual generation, poses a
significant challenge of utilizing LVLMs. In this comprehensive survey, we
dissect LVLM-related hallucinations in an attempt to establish an overview and
facilitate future mitigation. Our scrutiny starts with a clarification of the
concept of hallucinations in LVLMs, presenting a variety of hallucination
symptoms and highlighting the unique challenges inherent in LVLM
hallucinations. Subsequently, we outline the benchmarks and methodologies
tailored specifically for evaluating hallucinations unique to LVLMs.
Additionally, we delve into an investigation of the root causes of these
hallucinations, encompassing insights from the training data and model
components. We also critically review existing methods for mitigating
hallucinations. The open questions and future directions pertaining to
hallucinations within LVLMs are discussed to conclude this survey. | [
-0.0005934788,
0.0572373681,
-0.0026973651,
0.0502115525,
-0.0318130068,
0.0401045792,
-0.0159081928,
0.015554768,
0.0054870201,
-0.0456378311,
-0.0115897348,
-0.0684441924,
0.0322973765,
0.0014267421,
0.0138768908,
-0.0776181966,
0.0178550333,
-0.060116861,
-0.0472713113,
-0.0015596852,
0.0043843412,
-0.0049189632,
0.0163001325,
0.0328524895,
-0.0400784574,
-0.06675715,
-0.0036366258,
0.0315876007,
0.0229617413,
0.0112626972,
-0.0488252975,
0.0359976143,
0.0093002245,
0.0385759585,
0.0000020588,
-0.0345444195,
0.0170925204,
0.0001048126,
0.0176310614,
0.0220405348,
0.0147520462,
-0.046624884,
0.0058593214,
-0.0029516423,
-0.021157803,
-0.0139579223,
0.0524684377,
0.0758100674,
0.0446568318,
0.0543875955,
-0.0077974964,
-0.0309830382,
0.0049846862,
0.0137549974,
0.0463061593,
0.0099641923,
0.0530826971,
0.0394280069,
-0.0252413377,
-0.055542212,
-0.0395177081,
0.0140449107,
0.0398266315,
-0.0003983216,
0.0042514317,
0.0554033741,
-0.0640501827,
-0.0302017853,
-0.0076225451,
0.0462921895,
-0.0676654205,
-0.0375786722,
0.021068858,
0.0044665355,
0.0032888362,
-0.0319448188,
-0.0180434808,
0.0645175055,
-0.0035995459,
0.0107280109,
0.0102303531,
0.0042164228,
0.0330014415,
-0.0088816341,
-0.0532220416,
0.0123206843,
0.0145903919,
-0.0171588492,
-0.0009271454,
0.0331532918,
-0.0255494174,
-0.0725380555,
-0.0006484159,
0.015722774,
-0.0435058884,
-0.0186058395,
-0.0759381503,
0.0087532429,
-0.0008830402,
-0.0734000504,
0.0495975912,
-0.0162642747,
-0.0838329867,
0.0382824577,
-0.0441729873,
0.0765271336,
-0.0279548578,
0.0506698228,
-0.0183604788,
0.0126381684,
-0.0061562574,
0.0088313418,
-0.0409144573,
-0.0132197673,
-0.0320767984,
-0.0581243373,
-0.016264746,
0.0046207141,
-0.0512248613,
0.0336497016,
-0.03600429,
0.0357474051,
0.0087853065,
-0.0417391136,
0.0151313106,
0.0059622303,
0.0151576512,
-0.0151658012,
0.0089763394,
-0.0800381005,
-0.0102134543,
0.0643037036,
-0.0346446112,
0.0078129265,
-0.0281816311,
0.0558691099,
0.0079824217,
0.0039381031,
-0.0437345169,
-0.0191452447,
-0.0453352146,
-0.0639773533,
0.0200339798,
-0.0610199198,
0.0086315246,
-0.0130861364,
0.0030218442,
-0.0084961262,
0.0384883657,
0.0076659922,
-0.0156216575,
0.0717983544,
-0.0414884277,
0.0093018226,
0.0098944725,
0.026599016,
0.0137724066,
0.0675425157,
0.0341087542,
0.0607724898,
-0.0091292765,
-0.0085767275,
0.0630840212,
0.0178511646,
-0.0197726097,
0.0133327739,
-0.0900844559,
-0.0155959055,
0.0030451254,
0.0334146246,
0.0330194123,
0.0925323963,
-0.031725876,
-0.0272742324,
0.0788071901,
0.0078234207,
0.005572102,
-0.0160390697,
0.046406813,
-0.0066744564,
-0.0073831421,
0.0550828539,
-0.0624430068,
0.0458876155,
-0.0102411648,
0.013939946,
0.0028719069,
0.0236058775,
-0.0291968081,
-0.0522516817,
-0.0284200814,
-0.0127825746,
-0.023938084,
0.0147037106,
0.0130806873,
0.0039071296,
-0.0443128012,
-0.0118654408,
0.0068502137,
-0.0130524421,
0.0211962536,
-0.0302118342,
-0.0023280021,
0.097831063,
0.0421963893,
0.0119596953,
-0.0152894398,
-0.0233628415,
0.0338623971,
0.0694236085,
0.0117255868,
-0.0058428426,
0.0104941456,
-0.0625672564,
-0.0062417849,
0.0115366224,
0.0275420174,
-0.0027920422,
-0.0503554791,
-0.0116901295,
0.0086250668,
-0.0182309225,
-0.060302604,
0.0477781668,
-0.0195363704,
-0.0019329125,
-0.0288345814,
-0.0054121711,
-0.0033188085,
-0.0244956389,
-0.0258394368,
0.0261252727,
0.0001441039,
-0.0533091053,
-0.0282454416,
0.0304999072,
-0.0462848283,
0.0044957343,
0.0216200426,
-0.0361722633,
0.0117882872,
0.0003054062,
-0.007531648,
-0.0279287919,
-0.0055764937,
-0.0482089743,
0.0079197409,
-0.0334250219,
0.0475190356,
0.0138659561,
0.0537424535,
-0.0244457182,
0.0736200139,
-0.0426368117,
-0.0158926602,
0.0461224988,
0.0177741908,
-0.0050666956,
-0.010778334,
-0.0045609344,
0.0164139606,
0.0100452108,
0.0180791467,
-0.0128503451,
-0.0333072767,
-0.0579559952,
-0.011826505,
-0.0657561347,
-0.0234281514,
-0.0425633527,
-0.04497917,
0.0216460787,
-0.0439027175,
-0.0161357243,
-0.012510336,
-0.0193073899,
0.0344357267,
0.0233715903,
0.0272312853,
0.0125286998,
-0.0096637085,
-0.0157794394,
-0.0034807459,
0.0148195429,
0.0069474992,
0.0555061772,
0.0056370362,
-0.0545170866,
-0.0972385705,
0.0551725514,
-0.0371296667,
0.0289313402,
-0.0130393468,
0.0183800571,
-0.007517233,
-0.0064006005,
0.0698587522,
0.0936569199,
0.0211319402,
0.0432365537,
0.0794267356,
-0.021283282,
-0.0144270044,
-0.0318771228,
0.0096762497,
-0.0043970845,
-0.0186187718,
-0.0414383747,
-0.0004198059,
0.026161626,
0.0013535676,
0.0253205746,
-0.0767899826,
0.0424284451,
-0.0430047661,
-0.0836365074,
0.0015882918,
-0.0175208617,
-0.0111759407,
0.0448261574,
-0.0265897978,
-0.0673851594,
0.032140471,
-0.0273990799,
0.0084349914,
0.0162950959,
0.0220269356,
-0.0024353983,
0.0457995348,
0.0433723703,
0.0328135826,
-0.0019168571,
0.0026195922,
-0.0570205227,
0.0039461423,
-0.0556441694,
-0.0307332035,
0.0613013953,
-0.0367499962,
-0.0123972381,
-0.009787119,
-0.0305727981,
-0.0668552816,
-0.0099227196,
0.0024133336,
-0.0229631513,
-0.0517829396,
0.0023262936,
-0.0442346632,
0.0275016371,
-0.0124495309,
-0.0163787492,
-0.0247844663,
-0.0293577239,
-0.006559473,
0.0176650546,
0.0990242586,
-0.0114116753,
0.0652055144,
-0.0726837739,
0.0234075431,
0.0831548423,
0.0292072743,
0.066744484,
-0.0496274382,
-0.0111462148,
0.0160904359,
0.0229623485,
-0.0216579344,
0.0242058653,
0.0211275537,
-0.072773315,
-0.0290226676,
0.0879527852,
0.0288715623,
-0.050222788,
0.0122178663,
-0.03324119,
0.0738515109,
0.0047533894,
-0.0040289913,
-0.0660363883,
0.0022963388,
-0.0247246437,
-0.0126864193,
-0.0064228927,
-0.0022212486,
-0.0113886753,
-0.0638548136,
0.0754172206,
0.0416714773,
0.0030575518,
-0.0476871207,
0.0431886055,
0.0041276258,
0.016471263,
0.0326664336,
-0.0169843547,
0.0015103222,
-0.0134724379,
0.0301133338,
-0.0085295429,
-0.004153851,
0.0049359319,
-0.0355689116,
0.0426442139,
0.0818846002,
0.0105600813,
0.001222354,
-0.0842472762,
0.0131363887,
-0.0100021446,
0.0126463128,
0.0317308195,
0.0518761948,
-0.0027641524,
-0.0128674917,
0.0249175634,
0.0102136023,
-0.0332525298,
-0.0271446612,
0.0084124701,
0.0215602461,
-0.0559182353,
-0.0683590248,
-0.0296232998,
0.0448531322,
-0.0065446463,
0.0576974787,
0.0388921611,
-0.0417200588,
-0.0705297291,
-0.0043942635,
0.0425472818,
-0.0486434884,
-0.039328862,
0.0450544432,
0.0738662258,
-0.0309290104,
-0.0749196336,
-0.0437906384,
0.0026619611,
0.0423516892,
-0.0065749101,
0.0086201411,
-0.0232562684,
-0.0374163948,
-0.0188068449,
0.0426505618,
-0.0294843335,
0.0205573253,
-0.0179153141,
0.0165622532,
0.0068355571,
-0.039725475,
0.0240471717,
0.0328400694,
-0.1170904785,
-0.0509460233,
0.0305725448,
0.0448774286,
0.0244406927,
0.0793707073,
0.0069582858,
-0.0405627005,
0.0454273894,
0.0463375747,
0.0690289363,
0.0535993017,
-0.0154692112,
-0.0111702867,
0.0026357751,
0.0342001282,
-0.0075923405,
-0.0039149076,
0.0332910828,
0.0159606747,
-0.011972921,
0.0185920745,
0.032049194,
-0.0339251161,
0.0099522639,
-0.0327220298,
0.0119866775,
-0.0130638639,
-0.0155991018,
-0.0230170526,
-0.0312907659,
-0.046874702,
-0.0149800405,
0.0356065035,
0.0208345801,
0.0181602389,
-0.0044554328,
-0.0121957036,
-0.0212142244,
-0.0622262731,
-0.0569297448,
0.0138035333,
-0.0311311465,
0.0443009846,
0.0078220526,
-0.0167207476,
0.0289359428,
-0.0186910126,
0.0300588179,
0.0329634249,
0.0732668862,
0.0213114358,
-0.0172881857,
-0.0156461373,
0.0291212425,
-0.0258472525,
-0.0959047675,
-0.0275200624,
0.0513332188,
0.0571587682,
-0.0021383844,
0.0729353428,
-0.0464967415,
0.0207065456,
-0.0387084894,
0.0163365379,
0.0548876598,
-0.0501039736,
-0.0124992551,
0.0154403308,
-0.0422758497,
-0.0149203874,
0.0577218495,
0.0130415019,
0.0241505876,
0.0088900765,
-0.001910882,
-0.0150014181,
-0.0597509593,
-0.0110412017,
-0.0288053919,
-0.0269157458,
-0.0213781763,
-0.0540286414,
-0.0411956422,
0.0091724563,
0.0213055443,
0.0329693407,
0.0067117731,
0.0361590236,
0.0627103671,
-0.0281691309,
-0.0048410674,
-0.0059454171,
-0.0373482369,
0.032055337,
-0.0184916854,
0.0048415144,
-5.946703229e-33,
-0.0161771253,
-0.0200663619,
0.0497158431,
-0.0381572731,
-0.0295991264,
0.0029079902,
-0.0085912282,
0.0132923881,
0.0186119378,
0.0272153541,
0.0409071296,
0.0228714999,
0.0182667766,
0.0325073972,
0.0013843008,
-0.0184036307,
0.0508543625,
0.0081419908,
-0.0200040843,
0.016371306,
0.0119654052,
0.0004752902,
0.0010255625,
-0.0801347047,
-0.0085623702,
-0.0108818645,
-0.0353742912,
-0.0114351353,
-0.0096755093,
0.0536974445,
-0.0467279889,
0.0232985523,
0.0230025612,
0.0219252948,
-0.0566196069,
0.0067699845,
0.021001257,
0.0061925962,
-0.0046881028,
0.0543583818,
-0.0890859962,
0.0001224303,
0.0483260304,
-0.0124578411,
-0.0046943082,
-0.032632526,
0.0454946905,
-0.0532413609,
-0.0413884521,
0.0314008445,
-0.070953317,
-0.0141940918,
0.0151824588,
-0.0203969739,
0.0451605506,
0.033047121,
-0.0134629272,
0.0166297853,
-0.0623416565,
0.0017240901,
0.0016584864,
-0.0049349065,
0.0859190449,
0.0536334813,
0.0106359944,
0.0728538111,
0.0991950333,
-0.0106937336,
-0.0530719049,
-0.0215335693,
0.0089228302,
0.0472563505,
0.0312732682,
0.0087810382,
0.0335957147,
0.006586188,
-0.0131240804,
-0.0137174362,
-0.0939313546,
0.0219818838,
0.0804943815,
-0.0055731046,
-0.028922921,
-0.0283644367,
-0.0043250886,
0.000618326,
-0.0335497335,
0.0043203966,
0.048308596,
0.0215798728,
-0.0083120698,
0.000354478,
0.0448405594,
-0.0382852592,
0.0218033902,
-0.0022621423,
-0.0434406251,
0.0440881476,
0.0068719517,
0.0238488037,
0.007921326,
-0.0251575485,
0.0559501089,
0.0078477776,
0.0147314034,
0.0225355867,
0.0279410332,
-0.0054572853,
-0.0344945267,
0.0058496329,
-0.0450002812,
0.018789323,
0.0142237041,
0.0376707427,
0.0512475446,
-0.0185176823,
-0.0348290876,
0.0053472784,
0.0172839426,
-0.0011943157,
0.0233152304,
0.019069599,
-0.0319086015,
0.003194775,
-0.0171314757,
0.0113794403,
-0.0553118996,
-0.0325914957,
0.0497912653,
-0.0622027069,
-0.0160939414,
-0.0116436882,
2.603e-7,
-0.0211217124,
0.0425844789,
0.0239056107,
0.0097408686,
0.0148450444,
0.0218150038,
0.0192987677,
0.0286835097,
0.0100605767,
-0.0374215655,
-0.0011859355,
0.0349721573,
0.0545022003,
0.0094602136,
-0.023936877,
0.0155786751,
-0.0248472653,
0.0117891626,
-0.0673289597,
-0.0349502601,
0.044330541,
0.0372681282,
-0.0305034779,
-0.0403377861,
0.0703139007,
-0.0408676118,
0.0884776264,
-0.0113410978,
-0.0068653477,
0.0160484128,
0.0181556586,
0.0324283317,
-0.0009193927,
0.0507575683,
0.0031683038,
-0.05043054,
0.0381813683,
0.0157065745,
-0.0313131511,
-0.0195406154,
-0.0302480087,
0.0307595469,
0.012210072,
-0.0706213191,
0.0638711378,
-0.032823775,
-0.010392312,
-0.02007672,
-0.0301403254,
-0.0010386393,
0.0581582747,
-0.011871662,
-0.0103845866,
0.0106359031,
0.030912403,
0.0477694608,
-0.0305552389,
-0.0527220666,
0.0010879155,
-0.0237497818,
-0.0196576733,
-0.0020586955,
-0.0385999493,
0.0244795438,
0.018681027,
-0.0368159413,
-0.0428133309,
2.653829566e-34,
0.005137038,
-0.0078003835,
0.0352153741,
-0.0053434893,
-0.0072047864,
-0.0010889682,
0.0079941871,
0.0168780908,
-0.0292876624,
-0.0344555341,
-0.0187126286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00251v1 | Efficient Non-Parametric Uncertainty Quantification for Black-Box Large Language Models and Decision Planning | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | Yao-Hung Hubert Tsai, Walter Talbott, Jian Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Step-by-step decision planning with large language models (LLMs) is gaining
attention in AI agent development. This paper focuses on decision planning with
uncertainty estimation to address the hallucination problem in language models.
Existing approaches are either white-box or computationally demanding, limiting
use of black-box proprietary LLMs within budgets. The paper's first
contribution is a non-parametric uncertainty quantification method for LLMs,
efficiently estimating point-wise dependencies between input-decision on the
fly with a single inference, without access to token logits. This estimator
informs the statistical interpretation of decision trustworthiness. The second
contribution outlines a systematic design for a decision-making agent,
generating actions like ``turn on the bathroom light'' based on user prompts
such as ``take a bath''. Users will be asked to provide preferences when more
than one action has high estimated point-wise dependencies. In conclusion, our
uncertainty estimation and decision-making agent design offer a cost-efficient
approach for AI agent development. | [
0.0071106213,
0.0712495521,
-0.0014704765,
0.0095677786,
-0.0796884596,
-0.0048735151,
-0.0111824991,
-0.0170369484,
0.0418853872,
-0.0332463458,
0.0030444162,
-0.0613618679,
-0.0175698828,
0.0213752389,
-0.0031711615,
-0.0176341981,
0.0167630948,
-0.0811564848,
0.0133560235,
-0.0440564193,
-0.0343745872,
-0.0358485878,
-0.0072717895,
0.0417617187,
-0.0161685925,
-0.0299885385,
-0.024171805,
0.0021275766,
0.017360948,
-0.0203824155,
-0.0227686595,
0.0614707954,
0.0067249355,
0.0409883931,
0.0000024703,
-0.0643999055,
-0.0439339057,
-0.0179135688,
-0.0629210249,
-0.0280548576,
-0.0007069723,
0.0804985166,
-0.0082208663,
0.0098766312,
-0.0103581967,
0.0564892255,
0.0399832651,
0.0301097054,
0.0233239122,
0.0095052691,
-0.0042824438,
-0.0108140754,
0.0043453155,
0.0037786218,
0.0335821658,
-0.0462978631,
0.0234276019,
-0.0479864515,
0.0079259016,
-0.0376051962,
-0.0172449723,
0.0196396019,
0.0230274666,
-0.0171122476,
-0.0379081108,
0.0228736866,
-0.0361859798,
-0.0329074338,
-0.0258436352,
0.0306646936,
-0.0236589517,
0.0050675739,
0.0040412056,
-0.0150181409,
0.013521309,
0.0071435836,
0.0015486677,
0.0170089267,
-0.0317411013,
-0.0102755632,
-0.0178086665,
-0.0035528482,
0.0258495696,
0.0426285677,
-0.0216150545,
0.1492751539,
-0.008431253,
-0.0160836633,
0.0433811583,
-0.0072789635,
-0.0249932762,
-0.0834123418,
0.0118871452,
0.0191934332,
-0.0860379115,
0.0306898132,
0.0112031614,
0.058477141,
-0.005301225,
-0.0474248938,
0.0030135296,
0.0143739665,
0.0109352209,
0.0396103002,
0.0062940046,
0.0737161189,
-0.0139919501,
0.0043049878,
-0.0052136616,
0.018957695,
0.0086597716,
0.0136153186,
-0.0488381386,
0.0416428484,
-0.0096166087,
0.0059512784,
-0.0874071121,
0.010419745,
-0.0614112429,
0.0708914548,
0.0074337577,
0.0019556624,
0.0295849871,
-0.0388820842,
-0.0587567128,
-0.0511998795,
-0.0262125265,
0.0232079253,
-0.0054071909,
-0.048530668,
0.0301114935,
0.0234575719,
0.0114404447,
-0.0143857729,
-0.0061941841,
0.0805667266,
0.0104474612,
-0.0442064442,
-0.0162583124,
-0.0203910358,
-0.03247796,
-0.0710098222,
-0.0462485328,
-0.0693958402,
-0.0122156534,
-0.013377673,
-0.0176993683,
-0.060214527,
0.0021516052,
-0.0056362809,
-0.0074673505,
0.0717952475,
0.0479863212,
0.0043365317,
-0.011465882,
0.0083491849,
-0.0487477817,
0.058359202,
0.0609448142,
0.0972226262,
0.0258046109,
0.0071987119,
0.0669394359,
-0.0098642251,
-0.0230813548,
0.0184312016,
-0.0119358897,
-0.0182637293,
-0.0080410307,
0.0126029281,
-0.0382115804,
0.0637949258,
-0.0369424671,
-0.0014276411,
0.0711864829,
0.0253180973,
0.0197176039,
-0.053742826,
0.0416598246,
0.0219183285,
-0.0059642796,
-0.0217196662,
-0.034840215,
0.0106728682,
-0.0045017819,
-0.016167989,
0.0386565626,
0.0419892073,
-0.0110672303,
-0.0574414954,
0.0078208977,
-0.0440435745,
0.0262491126,
0.0357755646,
0.0482922122,
-0.0542240664,
-0.0412944146,
0.0093071936,
0.0261965618,
-0.0204322543,
-0.0134524433,
-0.0845714137,
0.0553454831,
0.0913308561,
0.0492065027,
-0.0306071993,
0.0490277335,
-0.0266670231,
0.00795474,
0.0099686431,
-0.0137209585,
-0.0087092379,
0.02422392,
-0.0316325836,
-0.0348715782,
0.0407230258,
0.0212923437,
0.0559102222,
-0.0017900034,
0.0282045063,
-0.0156313796,
0.0259035304,
-0.0312371626,
-0.0083096679,
0.0508936495,
-0.0474030599,
0.0093500493,
-0.0114990734,
0.0786502808,
0.0003162207,
-0.0105845714,
0.020080382,
0.0093115941,
0.023085393,
-0.0463873111,
0.0099509582,
0.0116202552,
0.0416959673,
0.044774197,
0.0016856791,
-0.0158592723,
-0.0131129082,
-0.009793587,
-0.0484145321,
-0.0079372972,
-0.0115447324,
0.0335054845,
-0.0024415385,
0.0468301736,
-0.0235576108,
0.0024693978,
-0.046734903,
0.0329195783,
-0.0436121225,
0.002503277,
-0.0163746309,
0.0453480147,
-0.0231817998,
-0.029120693,
-0.0295358598,
0.0214677732,
0.0191320051,
0.0293033142,
0.0442131869,
-0.0008311684,
0.0003447699,
-0.0329324938,
-0.0724173784,
-0.0384223126,
0.0023624857,
-0.0079788258,
-0.0441985577,
-0.0018633333,
0.0014681227,
0.0085525997,
-0.01067416,
0.0480923057,
-0.0244814325,
0.043537952,
-0.0048378734,
-0.0058676419,
-0.0614277124,
-0.0338791683,
-0.0186901428,
-0.001746602,
0.0090604536,
0.0104614785,
-0.0339808613,
-0.0651791617,
0.0589800365,
-0.0193259809,
0.0180191025,
-0.0173713118,
-0.0517912135,
0.0268692505,
-0.0165467653,
0.0245447587,
0.0542614944,
0.0016462186,
-0.0092312861,
0.0968138874,
-0.0240120683,
-0.0594468527,
0.0226636343,
-0.0229776278,
-0.0109928073,
-0.0140881715,
-0.0408935286,
0.0371062905,
0.0343179256,
-0.0358952843,
-0.0026438492,
-0.0440300331,
0.0160836596,
0.000788736,
-0.057182949,
0.0040402147,
-0.0329982452,
-0.0326696709,
0.1047225967,
0.0303327851,
-0.0596336126,
0.0729328915,
-0.0296272859,
0.0282452852,
0.0308894869,
0.0005680174,
0.0266745146,
0.0214227624,
0.0185998362,
0.0249355901,
-0.03271183,
0.006006002,
-0.0513788275,
-0.0432426184,
0.0530441999,
-0.0300408658,
0.0425120443,
-0.0648878142,
0.010202379,
0.0226847846,
-0.0483486243,
-0.0340515077,
-0.0500349887,
-0.0488434844,
-0.0414710641,
0.0113750231,
-0.0641336143,
-0.0016075032,
-0.0028049767,
0.0334920138,
0.027650686,
-0.0154494876,
-0.0203440581,
-0.0162219815,
-0.0555255413,
0.0410236791,
0.0176960472,
0.0630363896,
0.0088541573,
0.0379393436,
0.0392914303,
0.0481168702,
0.050416369,
0.0043007545,
-0.018170435,
0.0327123068,
-0.0083877947,
0.0172897652,
0.0595748127,
0.0321085528,
-0.0006020419,
-0.0144924792,
0.0982225984,
0.0226825662,
-0.0498499051,
0.019450549,
-0.0899648964,
0.054895591,
-0.0197159983,
0.0226806775,
-0.0529836342,
-0.0293619074,
0.0083069038,
0.0252299272,
-0.0575951524,
-0.0589448623,
0.0167505536,
-0.1032981575,
0.0468984842,
-0.0172726046,
0.0191707239,
-0.0096720904,
-0.0379709452,
-0.0079466775,
-0.0136970971,
0.0243203528,
0.0065316358,
0.041959431,
-0.0352681614,
-0.0034942948,
-0.0459591076,
-0.0290568173,
0.0477037244,
-0.0144002736,
0.0253587924,
0.0352118984,
0.0256436411,
-0.0372010879,
0.0072206683,
0.0177500434,
0.0279303845,
-0.0366104208,
0.0093132872,
0.0113039929,
0.0267274603,
0.0171986371,
0.0051825829,
0.0170542784,
-0.0003883067,
-0.031674929,
0.0056011276,
0.0762378424,
-0.0419994704,
-0.0349652618,
0.0241841748,
-0.0028690377,
0.0634023845,
0.0646294504,
-0.0435213447,
-0.0761212558,
-0.053235814,
-0.0428847075,
-0.0231786557,
-0.0103389798,
-0.0151526127,
0.0306203905,
-0.0050476082,
-0.043088343,
-0.0415500067,
-0.0178718027,
0.0170644186,
0.0469644666,
-0.0211191699,
0.0037559064,
0.0575139448,
0.0305962972,
-0.0009571442,
-0.0090905875,
-0.0207512788,
0.0492262729,
-0.0384931006,
0.0568762757,
0.0420831777,
0.0012267572,
-0.0164942928,
0.0359395295,
-0.0014854014,
-0.0879801959,
0.0524387024,
0.1033695489,
0.0365699045,
-0.0014527221,
-0.0264978223,
-0.0579585955,
0.0489196628,
-0.0090955794,
0.0221390296,
0.0023787718,
0.0459930189,
0.0737620369,
-0.0065662833,
0.0482409075,
-0.0373969115,
0.0032725481,
0.0211256761,
0.0168323386,
-0.079733707,
-0.0478222594,
-0.0014279351,
0.024099458,
0.001383298,
-0.0364253819,
0.0292961299,
-0.0129719796,
0.0428870656,
-0.0239250548,
-0.0102552902,
-0.040293429,
0.010901168,
0.0344985351,
-0.0424944647,
0.0264948346,
-0.0553756654,
-0.0018394004,
-0.0678243563,
0.0316473953,
-0.0184764303,
0.0457971469,
0.018229844,
0.085783653,
-0.0498314612,
0.0168629978,
0.0210528877,
0.0089859534,
0.021338664,
0.0581237227,
0.0393394977,
0.0093967486,
-0.0639754012,
-0.0127192969,
-0.0023127629,
-0.0199571028,
-0.1009620652,
0.0123897186,
0.0130220782,
0.0166050661,
0.0297769513,
0.0142860422,
-0.072521992,
0.0162295531,
-0.014632388,
0.0065224646,
0.0433069356,
-0.0066112881,
0.0311261229,
0.0392312035,
-0.0331287198,
0.0158945713,
0.0532485098,
0.0097766621,
0.02120867,
-0.0607978664,
-0.0629224852,
-0.031250108,
-0.0599775054,
-0.0540386103,
0.0226207413,
-0.051464919,
-0.0188997444,
-0.0815414563,
-0.0515321903,
-0.0356010422,
0.0133320531,
0.0206406154,
-0.0516807325,
0.0168823469,
0.0333025008,
0.0134662269,
0.0142289475,
-0.0661932155,
-0.0479796454,
-0.003772608,
-0.0059010559,
-0.026996607,
-7.136533468e-33,
0.0179217756,
-0.0546146631,
0.000589166,
-0.0393719971,
0.0378495455,
-0.0262388233,
0.0089377211,
0.0446391106,
0.0229882244,
0.0251643769,
-0.018159071,
0.0130396429,
0.0369170234,
-0.0178459715,
0.0358250998,
-0.0125669977,
0.0165573172,
0.0103071369,
-0.0400891341,
-0.0046803704,
0.054892499,
-0.0287373848,
0.0026553308,
-0.0612689555,
0.015610558,
0.0297996532,
-0.0469077043,
0.0398639143,
-0.0282711387,
0.0064786486,
0.0046332628,
0.0076500163,
-0.0084345965,
-0.0114875203,
0.0083713252,
0.0036046018,
0.0021212937,
-0.0264398921,
0.0002411047,
0.0261708871,
-0.0134823974,
-0.0288566947,
0.0043446086,
0.0062028775,
-0.0502839983,
0.0323964059,
-0.0292590037,
-0.0028150792,
-0.0138803078,
0.0101371929,
-0.0197640788,
0.0313607082,
0.0187473893,
-0.0156161599,
0.0234459639,
0.0583838485,
-0.021889722,
-0.0445207097,
-0.030688243,
0.0152315339,
0.0185542032,
-0.0164473522,
0.0547122508,
0.0026949716,
0.0143440301,
0.0439953171,
0.0548953637,
-0.0121512683,
-0.0231790971,
-0.0088533573,
-0.023507854,
0.0331610814,
0.0271599498,
0.0602252148,
0.018574778,
0.0140301818,
-0.0670655146,
0.0265742019,
0.0281431489,
0.0763915181,
0.0609571673,
0.0266618785,
-0.0602760725,
-0.0335372724,
-0.0237089936,
-0.0118733337,
-0.0151923466,
-0.0319608301,
0.0112937158,
-0.0060910406,
-0.0343958549,
-0.0186335538,
0.0413076468,
-0.0039939969,
-0.0400584526,
-0.0145132104,
0.0023358238,
0.0264318455,
0.0069733877,
0.0335521251,
0.0156885237,
-0.0328516737,
-0.028012801,
-0.0004213372,
0.0132969394,
0.048015099,
-0.0333539099,
0.011495213,
-0.0267987065,
0.014445846,
-0.0279086046,
-0.0115865748,
0.0270574894,
-0.0181204919,
0.0598163381,
-0.0392062329,
-0.0165034868,
0.0150572946,
0.0024804708,
0.003292565,
0.0256980993,
0.0084456233,
-0.0298214592,
0.0103479391,
-0.0167932622,
-0.0451736301,
-0.035087321,
0.0027087037,
0.0468137339,
-0.0142541854,
0.0024393939,
-0.0098049296,
3.332e-7,
-0.0415595546,
0.0275637899,
-0.0397578441,
0.0481880456,
0.0103968149,
0.0486076735,
0.0250682924,
-0.0311024375,
-0.0068523991,
-0.0262185447,
0.0410807133,
0.0148095498,
0.0410876051,
0.0309309103,
-0.0569459423,
-0.0781849176,
-0.0062237983,
0.0149762398,
-0.042077519,
-0.0181272328,
0.0485637188,
0.0847371444,
0.0175692458,
-0.0229329076,
-0.0004423068,
-0.0180911291,
0.0237261783,
-0.0649998859,
0.0027447462,
0.0450840518,
0.0487024374,
-0.0219835825,
0.0156814419,
0.0422076173,
0.0151714617,
-0.0234558471,
-0.0159592982,
0.0578430668,
0.0000499222,
0.0200003888,
-0.0107377851,
-0.032900691,
0.0098737786,
-0.0438523926,
0.0558215193,
-0.0378723443,
-0.0397597998,
-0.0174753703,
0.0248120241,
-0.0442752726,
0.0356092788,
-0.0149216624,
0.0009160286,
0.0037995963,
-0.0356692299,
0.0078658285,
0.0398671702,
-0.0303771812,
0.0072570452,
0.0225377455,
-0.0121813836,
-0.0624810383,
0.0010780755,
0.0275207087,
0.0054585775,
-0.0811161697,
0.0167907942,
2.972831871e-34,
0.0176392384,
0.0102039622,
0.0225085951,
0.0432299562,
0.0660617054,
0.0268955398,
-0.0114779221,
0.017553309,
0.0726744235,
-0.0495485291,
-0.019061042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00235v1 | Exploring the limits of decoder-only models trained on public speech recognition corpora | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | Ankit Gupta, George Saon, Brian Kingsbury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The emergence of industrial-scale speech recognition (ASR) models such as
Whisper and USM, trained on 1M hours of weakly labelled and 12M hours of audio
only proprietary data respectively, has led to a stronger need for large scale
public ASR corpora and competitive open source pipelines. Unlike the said
models, large language models are typically based on Transformer decoders, and
it remains unclear if decoder-only models trained on public data alone can
deliver competitive performance. In this work, we investigate factors such as
choice of training datasets and modeling components necessary for obtaining the
best performance using public English ASR corpora alone. Our Decoder-Only
Transformer for ASR (DOTA) model comprehensively outperforms the
encoder-decoder open source replication of Whisper (OWSM) on nearly all English
ASR benchmarks and outperforms Whisper large-v3 on 7 out of 15 test sets. We
release our codebase and model checkpoints under permissive license. | [
-0.029967783,
0.1023763195,
0.0280236192,
0.0605796948,
0.003713358,
-0.0043168566,
0.0391715281,
-0.0137959663,
-0.0281276349,
0.0045903698,
-0.0743740276,
0.0025599033,
0.0241282564,
0.0220079254,
0.0031049429,
-0.0019888422,
0.0082471911,
-0.0566182323,
-0.0458391011,
-0.0147770224,
-0.0004258865,
0.0086059254,
-0.0167701989,
0.0415383726,
0.0221301112,
0.0147929182,
-0.0009354486,
0.0176894125,
0.0175679307,
-0.0173582435,
-0.0065737227,
0.0006453045,
0.0171240531,
0.0551643856,
0.0000018154,
-0.0222081244,
-0.0165597852,
0.0124863628,
-0.0628658682,
0.0190389063,
0.0034054487,
-0.041290503,
-0.0206730682,
0.0617153794,
-0.0109979585,
-0.0625882298,
0.0396954268,
0.0159699079,
0.0427645817,
0.0704705641,
0.0014008139,
-0.0551584065,
0.0402816497,
-0.0334024243,
-0.0495573655,
-0.0669536367,
-0.0166912135,
-0.0389116108,
-0.0305268206,
0.0108349808,
-0.038356673,
0.0582995303,
0.0297079626,
0.0087595582,
-0.0150508741,
0.0129441759,
-0.0389290936,
-0.042059768,
-0.0302749947,
0.0575405024,
0.0246094372,
-0.0439004451,
0.0025457412,
0.0118883327,
-0.0160342027,
-0.0522263348,
-0.010015225,
0.0555477552,
-0.0031214533,
0.0370485745,
0.0074483003,
0.0393995121,
0.0370755196,
-0.0228287596,
-0.0072343941,
0.0290929805,
-0.000653018,
-0.021244863,
0.0001878275,
0.0016670204,
0.0167488996,
-0.0125882998,
0.0653963685,
-0.0255223159,
-0.004937368,
-0.0073628756,
-0.0365311876,
-0.0399006978,
-0.0276479572,
-0.0203115512,
-0.0038279041,
0.0498438403,
-0.0344440751,
0.0155654354,
0.0035408761,
0.0641853958,
-0.0145597858,
0.0366885848,
-0.0308562685,
-0.0363117307,
-0.022678094,
0.0159586426,
-0.0452639386,
0.0149299251,
-0.0413000025,
-0.0334119685,
-0.0108335428,
-0.0048747631,
0.009918401,
0.0026789396,
0.0854669809,
0.0103655523,
-0.0465059504,
-0.0152616212,
0.0512507483,
0.0566121191,
0.0470440388,
0.0216061492,
-0.0014860033,
-0.0685686171,
-0.0094997268,
0.0107752914,
0.0236457605,
-0.0053325496,
-0.0114496658,
0.0446266122,
-0.0191933587,
-0.0134127401,
-0.0316046551,
0.0244906899,
0.0007044292,
-0.0325612016,
-0.0321564674,
-0.0192474611,
0.0439851843,
0.0294184797,
0.0495680086,
-0.0693404153,
-0.0032918779,
-0.0183712058,
0.0044896225,
0.0787961036,
-0.0014455591,
0.0113933943,
0.0207283534,
-0.0055308533,
0.0114349686,
0.0435425341,
0.0508395508,
0.0075205765,
0.0240148827,
-0.0482778624,
0.012645687,
0.0742799789,
-0.0035170135,
0.012522296,
0.0291256215,
0.006094805,
-0.0060817227,
0.0008775613,
0.0602929071,
0.057944607,
-0.02356546,
-0.0526236184,
0.041503951,
0.0119211618,
0.032113865,
0.0168492962,
0.01706562,
0.048641827,
-0.0057793036,
-0.045618508,
0.0036831922,
-0.018857969,
0.0002053984,
-0.0003492367,
0.0359573364,
0.0315420516,
-0.0382428728,
0.0078053754,
-0.0085630361,
-0.0351210721,
0.0060780644,
0.0433007516,
0.0758727193,
0.0148255778,
-0.0622300394,
0.1083384454,
0.0014185937,
-0.0575663485,
0.0191193763,
-0.0417681746,
-0.0082438421,
0.039192196,
0.0442589633,
0.0009151815,
-0.0066292239,
-0.0482284427,
-0.0102788275,
0.0481412038,
-0.0010721544,
-0.0117377574,
0.0660501346,
-0.0823038667,
-0.0150528317,
0.0460415371,
-0.0101884473,
0.0561674945,
-0.0056727077,
0.0024289938,
0.0165324137,
-0.0599696562,
-0.016084671,
-0.0013651475,
-0.0241806265,
-0.0288633984,
0.0383374169,
-0.0146041922,
0.0756600648,
0.034110155,
-0.0223732442,
-0.0124462284,
0.042358689,
-0.041143842,
0.0201668255,
0.0237639304,
-0.0392413177,
-0.0214891937,
0.0175073091,
-0.010909752,
0.0339943618,
0.0942201316,
-0.0242512245,
-0.0552229099,
0.0161416214,
-0.0373258516,
0.0694705099,
-0.0257915836,
0.0369197503,
0.0130332699,
0.007880195,
0.0222320613,
-0.0459095947,
-0.0168832205,
-0.0084692985,
-0.0254001562,
0.0053221066,
0.018084893,
-0.0530639254,
-0.0368407704,
0.0233849864,
-0.0471395515,
0.0332789607,
-0.0030270244,
-0.0083717536,
0.009498422,
-0.0086703608,
-0.0576809794,
-0.0259338394,
-0.0445597805,
0.0363290235,
0.0072513605,
0.0264682714,
-0.0017333038,
-0.0370922983,
0.0038175138,
-0.0095740538,
-0.0165839046,
0.003179821,
-0.0535209514,
-0.016716687,
-0.0197468437,
-0.0265187155,
-0.0063692704,
0.0364936702,
0.0168452282,
-0.0318850279,
0.0061731278,
-0.1002720892,
0.0451143682,
0.0544401594,
0.0392228551,
-0.0166848041,
-0.0451364666,
0.0089301392,
0.0296524782,
0.0245363303,
0.0077776061,
-0.0180095769,
0.0078861117,
-0.0125722867,
-0.0018084192,
-0.0646143258,
-0.009869908,
0.0105210384,
-0.0437620692,
-0.069322072,
-0.0214160867,
-0.0011716381,
0.0605473258,
0.0199833475,
0.0286566615,
-0.0554234721,
-0.0348458216,
-0.0191854835,
-0.0360398293,
-0.0030212922,
-0.0218184888,
-0.030454265,
0.0213783011,
-0.013209709,
-0.028763067,
0.0038993785,
-0.1090867668,
-0.0339102335,
-0.0196303744,
-0.0112647945,
-0.0458924845,
0.0225228257,
-0.007171242,
0.0100452704,
0.0045096399,
-0.0793007389,
0.0343220346,
0.0358652063,
0.0086460086,
-0.0620810054,
0.0182789117,
-0.01706063,
0.0140834954,
-0.0248321984,
-0.0640379116,
-0.024722727,
0.0087233512,
-0.0577989593,
0.0235986654,
0.0303722396,
-0.0315219872,
-0.0357089713,
0.0598124601,
-0.0016396284,
0.0830700994,
0.0297054872,
0.0140656605,
-0.0154656814,
0.0321459807,
-0.0014964733,
0.0232580453,
-0.0048831808,
-0.0295858867,
0.0158052556,
0.0290008131,
0.0889825746,
0.0018322793,
-0.0677621812,
-0.0209805686,
0.0662448034,
0.0276860762,
0.0150104193,
0.0157535467,
0.0324278101,
-0.0288755875,
-0.0228090808,
0.0947917774,
-0.0075442116,
-0.038330134,
-0.0110135544,
0.0157610681,
0.0146158598,
0.0172391105,
-0.0137956534,
-0.0659091026,
-0.0381301455,
0.0537509695,
0.0803139284,
0.0485677272,
-0.0057386584,
0.0015882038,
-0.1126772389,
0.0553855412,
0.0069951112,
-0.0445685163,
-0.0352516063,
-0.0690840632,
-0.0476411954,
-0.083707504,
0.0519536249,
0.0074729477,
0.0047844625,
-0.0267003868,
0.039476525,
-0.0372101478,
-0.0706230476,
0.0185892843,
-0.0329959318,
0.0829768181,
0.0480271243,
-0.0186497215,
-0.0160953756,
-0.0381871015,
0.0072136447,
-0.0027844207,
-0.0207535066,
-0.0198182687,
0.0382516645,
-0.0162515286,
-0.0184392445,
0.0105067352,
0.0252462253,
-0.0643932372,
-0.0005553862,
0.0017306065,
0.0413923748,
-0.0046402737,
-0.0134074921,
0.0428154282,
-0.0340988412,
-0.0168374944,
0.0801568404,
-0.0030337228,
-0.0135088349,
-0.0104980161,
0.0061899703,
0.0451422147,
-0.0274979044,
-0.0181033239,
0.0106857819,
0.0194546469,
-0.077390328,
-0.0190780256,
-0.0041628736,
0.0272493735,
0.0142376581,
0.0157811269,
-0.0225537382,
0.0565213971,
-0.003772422,
-0.0476809368,
0.0120834829,
-0.0365243927,
0.0249676798,
-0.0981810465,
-0.0151759423,
0.0515834093,
-0.0103466921,
-0.0173981022,
0.0153577775,
-0.0741569027,
-0.0506806001,
0.0214824118,
0.0026698357,
0.0202232208,
0.0462779365,
-0.0410584845,
-0.0285998285,
0.0526745804,
-0.0034057344,
-0.0737388432,
0.028992705,
0.0604558401,
-0.0267552603,
-0.0197232477,
0.0303464644,
-0.0510677882,
0.0004357932,
0.0234855488,
0.0227076989,
-0.014583244,
-0.0299145281,
0.0012377547,
0.0297579989,
0.0534299798,
-0.0251813829,
0.0165270213,
-0.0267487671,
0.0288417228,
0.0170073956,
0.056462951,
-0.0364464559,
-0.0099878544,
0.0757790506,
-0.0074944319,
-0.0222901925,
0.0679752454,
-0.0092221638,
0.0121681346,
-0.0398341417,
0.0439828299,
0.0528195612,
-0.0242461152,
0.0363103561,
-0.0100322263,
0.0010348501,
0.0284475666,
0.0412488617,
0.039062269,
0.0083426805,
0.0056921504,
-0.0245168693,
0.03975036,
0.0262102131,
0.0338286869,
-0.0334640443,
-0.0411056615,
-0.0319739766,
0.030500209,
0.0185684226,
0.0167537034,
0.0875521675,
0.0181245413,
0.0350401476,
-0.0331372656,
0.0181651637,
-0.0294430535,
-0.0190169793,
0.0378100686,
-0.0034050075,
-0.0189912859,
0.0674402788,
0.0675333515,
0.0281617809,
0.0406259447,
-0.0215024389,
0.0351161659,
-0.0394372009,
-0.0419939533,
-0.0001864274,
-0.0104630841,
-0.0420260578,
-0.0316606089,
0.0193413254,
-0.0562923886,
0.0176466312,
-0.0073733437,
0.0281515084,
-0.0228208154,
-0.0074970527,
0.0309396349,
-0.0218436681,
-0.0162690058,
-0.0036983653,
-0.0418963097,
-0.0040293145,
-0.0354617536,
0.00406424,
-6.358383391e-33,
-0.008381607,
0.0436470807,
0.0128183784,
-0.0055455184,
-0.0201912299,
0.0154265966,
-0.0344394073,
-0.0122071821,
0.0057743727,
-0.0365909748,
-0.0253078081,
0.0160307605,
0.0371610075,
0.0607879125,
0.0053227213,
-0.0141673628,
0.1087271869,
-0.0345190689,
-0.0221153796,
0.0127832731,
0.0231711082,
0.0433290005,
0.0153066479,
-0.017313756,
-0.0295724068,
-0.0171799753,
-0.0175947659,
-0.0179068744,
0.0292518046,
0.0347535834,
-0.0228784662,
0.0367235355,
0.0008050947,
-0.0681764483,
-0.0187884569,
0.0093709594,
-0.0942810178,
0.077415362,
-0.0266464483,
0.062071126,
0.0209947564,
-0.0095593743,
0.0166231617,
0.0113689676,
-0.0235222895,
0.0006146213,
-0.0195204075,
-0.0028663361,
0.0079783052,
-0.0592946671,
0.0086363275,
0.0359258167,
-0.0218964573,
-0.0190811884,
0.0901073366,
0.0239207894,
-0.0213989001,
0.0142671578,
-0.1055422947,
0.0085945027,
0.0136489365,
0.011815533,
0.0781613514,
0.0352316536,
-0.0242523383,
-0.010759973,
0.0411719419,
-0.0629874989,
0.0200800542,
0.0043905014,
0.018757388,
0.0593861714,
0.0114719793,
0.0095529947,
0.0202219859,
-0.0260768775,
-0.0210039448,
-0.022326123,
-0.0158554427,
0.0184708424,
0.0271497611,
0.0444645248,
-0.0493918918,
-0.0194860492,
-0.0514001846,
-0.0449832715,
-0.0218119044,
0.0140562812,
0.0679642707,
0.034713801,
-0.028124677,
-0.0056433748,
0.0669008344,
-0.0534271561,
0.0149073265,
0.0051146992,
0.0443307236,
0.0183721967,
-0.0385720767,
0.0399380811,
-0.0685000345,
-0.026391834,
0.0373043679,
0.0190720893,
0.0031395243,
-0.0430974029,
0.0042109238,
0.0551141687,
-0.0687721223,
0.0012336143,
-0.0180949941,
0.0374168195,
-0.0089362646,
0.026218297,
0.0460348278,
-0.0058995094,
-0.0072169304,
0.0360399261,
-0.0230865497,
0.0409175828,
-0.0167145189,
0.0110953124,
0.0265532602,
0.0038165057,
-0.0155426729,
-0.0043123793,
-0.0018927295,
0.0159447007,
0.0308333542,
-0.0173545815,
-0.011468498,
0.0123420684,
2.512e-7,
-0.0237975158,
0.0043671778,
0.0532275625,
-0.0206408054,
0.009069046,
0.0240077935,
-0.0237606503,
0.0230361558,
0.002279744,
0.0001730212,
-0.0293415114,
0.0064258305,
0.1036801189,
0.0202081241,
-0.0874789059,
-0.0193842631,
-0.0594836958,
0.0272621345,
-0.021602245,
-0.025306968,
-0.0027689971,
0.1039454415,
-0.0267595071,
-0.0288875252,
0.0100399358,
-0.0150866527,
0.0305927787,
-0.030050071,
0.0015265292,
0.0162822325,
-0.0117293652,
0.0282738227,
-0.0202610679,
-0.0289216619,
-0.0235743169,
0.0192714352,
-0.0138041331,
0.0633083954,
0.0004717135,
-0.0578657016,
-0.0002371203,
0.0047391253,
-0.0373150371,
-0.0070313686,
0.0526380837,
-0.0155043863,
-0.0292065982,
0.0081482371,
-0.0597456694,
-0.0084964847,
-0.0383664519,
-0.029390702,
0.023133304,
0.0161039364,
0.0352002531,
-0.04330476,
-0.0258405972,
-0.0357158668,
0.0072546941,
-0.0527808554,
-0.0607613847,
-0.0119909048,
-0.0288090389,
0.0173919797,
-0.0148431836,
0.0077723288,
0.0213750545,
1.843858513e-34,
0.0590360798,
-0.0144963907,
0.0243636798,
0.0127101429,
0.0101387976,
-0.0413972363,
0.0310054459,
0.0140926326,
-0.0633297935,
-0.0910931528,
-0.0232699588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00234v1 | Are Generative AI systems Capable of Supporting Information Needs of Patients? | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | Shreya Rajagopal, Subhashis Hazarika, Sookyung Kim, Yan-ming Chiou, Jae Ho Sohn, Hari Subramonyam, Shiwali Mohan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Patients managing a complex illness such as cancer face a complex information
challenge where they not only must learn about their illness but also how to
manage it. Close interaction with healthcare experts (radiologists,
oncologists) can improve patient learning and thereby, their disease outcome.
However, this approach is resource intensive and takes expert time away from
other critical tasks. Given the recent advancements in Generative AI models
aimed at improving the healthcare system, our work investigates whether and how
generative visual question answering systems can responsibly support patient
information needs in the context of radiology imaging data. We conducted a
formative need-finding study in which participants discussed chest computed
tomography (CT) scans and associated radiology reports of a fictitious close
relative with a cardiothoracic radiologist. Using thematic analysis of the
conversation between participants and medical experts, we identified commonly
occurring themes across interactions, including clarifying medical terminology,
locating the problems mentioned in the report in the scanned image,
understanding disease prognosis, discussing the next diagnostic steps, and
comparing treatment options. Based on these themes, we evaluated two
state-of-the-art generative visual language models against the radiologist's
responses. Our results reveal variability in the quality of responses generated
by the models across various themes. We highlight the importance of
patient-facing generative AI systems to accommodate a diverse range of
conversational themes, catering to the real-world informational needs of
patients. | [
0.0959281772,
0.0589442328,
-0.0306163821,
0.0007467254,
-0.0022341544,
0.0211370848,
-0.0205979962,
0.0188278463,
-0.010463194,
0.0239467155,
0.0005369103,
-0.044705078,
-0.0001055263,
0.0445224606,
-0.0094767036,
-0.1131111458,
-0.0094899414,
0.0140050044,
0.0513029471,
0.0085716862,
0.0096419137,
0.0168080721,
-0.0318945646,
0.0605014861,
-0.0286377221,
-0.0128477132,
0.0142158316,
0.0066532986,
0.024236884,
-0.0535977148,
-0.019369442,
0.013038503,
0.0019798393,
-0.0194935352,
0.000001921,
-0.0361674428,
0.0107488241,
0.003260399,
-0.0174035951,
-0.0486407578,
0.0552871861,
-0.0409886613,
0.0086961444,
0.0019227481,
-0.0670004934,
-0.0186482836,
0.0555042513,
0.0361841097,
0.0545380339,
0.041658435,
-0.026460927,
0.016544342,
0.0222126357,
-0.0158307254,
0.0425472483,
-0.036140956,
-0.0090635763,
0.0620494448,
0.037126746,
-0.0087337298,
0.0057328385,
0.072274901,
0.0089416197,
-0.0020897388,
0.0291843805,
0.0839179754,
0.0194719899,
-0.0307381283,
-0.0061571789,
0.0695457086,
0.0288815908,
0.0206237361,
-0.0050665317,
-0.013607583,
0.0119237965,
0.0343799219,
-0.0435475595,
0.0166405831,
-0.0305994898,
-0.0128555866,
-0.019851638,
0.0110230949,
-0.015660353,
-0.0048117391,
0.0124292169,
-0.0681723803,
0.0105413599,
0.0033771084,
-0.0366519056,
0.0005077047,
-0.0294697713,
-0.07339634,
0.0124699995,
0.051712539,
-0.0492928214,
0.0246738642,
-0.0049125208,
-0.0081283972,
0.0421464927,
-0.0326799341,
-0.0156946164,
0.0036695036,
-0.0333578996,
0.0315542296,
0.0358907841,
0.0083755804,
-0.0308598895,
0.0041370806,
-0.0473009683,
-0.0051257396,
-0.0422143005,
-0.0459515676,
-0.0513453893,
0.0086851828,
-0.023601003,
-0.0375022031,
-0.0184532758,
0.0201031398,
0.0093638776,
0.0134962136,
0.0363845266,
0.0633539185,
-0.04216462,
0.03191939,
-0.0608990379,
0.0228346698,
-0.0648507774,
-0.0178440735,
0.0088905105,
-0.0668414086,
0.033529155,
0.03368048,
0.0161892511,
0.0123284301,
-0.0121382046,
0.0266643036,
-0.0065959641,
0.00286688,
-0.0050528627,
-0.0477245115,
-0.0236301217,
-0.0264972802,
0.032804627,
-0.0397540331,
0.0321959816,
0.021154115,
0.0073697553,
-0.0387622006,
0.018647328,
0.0119704204,
-0.0274480544,
0.0732577965,
-0.0366233438,
0.029066857,
0.0526026674,
0.0467714667,
0.0408368036,
0.0044247787,
0.0223094895,
0.0072581084,
0.0256020054,
-0.0261044353,
0.0490295514,
-0.0168235414,
-0.0016506419,
-0.0449980758,
-0.0096283993,
0.0212199409,
-0.0538821891,
0.0769109204,
-0.0355881378,
0.0889873207,
-0.0117550995,
-0.0031616995,
0.0290875956,
0.0748776197,
0.0377310812,
0.0452728346,
0.0422091968,
-0.0241639204,
-0.0241762269,
0.0332852267,
0.0056299288,
0.0636223853,
0.0278955791,
-0.0051663751,
-0.0257956292,
-0.0190528464,
-0.0385602862,
-0.0737990662,
-0.0261871926,
0.0197103862,
-0.017829245,
0.0192442816,
0.0247541144,
0.0189526156,
-0.0305943601,
-0.0479940213,
0.0143932477,
-0.0425518453,
-0.0186708793,
-0.0837495402,
0.0157882459,
0.155406639,
0.0724890232,
-0.006633787,
-0.0516799055,
0.0171181951,
0.0137220947,
0.0282614846,
0.0412854217,
-0.017452348,
-0.0060565672,
-0.0206028577,
-0.0153663876,
0.0059553273,
0.001971713,
-0.0049353424,
-0.0033987788,
0.0048402194,
-0.024193773,
-0.0260479003,
-0.0061242459,
0.0404174887,
-0.0218388103,
-0.0215430632,
-0.0154389068,
0.0242199339,
-0.0170340501,
0.0238724723,
-0.0294410251,
0.029848095,
0.0241729412,
0.0027888019,
-0.0281699635,
0.0482853949,
-0.0580055602,
0.0017406169,
0.0018338086,
-0.0664554685,
0.0020469145,
-0.0484406054,
-0.0136305345,
-0.0166387446,
-0.0036091767,
-0.0746571645,
0.014266328,
-0.0104223061,
-0.0144892829,
0.0824873894,
0.0120038111,
-0.0197119378,
0.0482475199,
-0.0261366256,
-0.0213554353,
0.0135213044,
-0.0157545656,
-0.0010802696,
-0.0626040921,
-0.0038799883,
0.0220135953,
0.0086146109,
0.0012668909,
0.0048017087,
0.0167197194,
-0.0423922576,
0.0042372774,
-0.1334417611,
-0.0368559062,
0.0129616121,
-0.0295924395,
0.0411607549,
0.0339756906,
-0.0174315162,
-0.0454728231,
-0.0566162653,
0.0147149889,
0.0323371291,
0.0086195143,
0.0664631203,
0.0494831167,
0.0177323669,
-0.0622074828,
-0.0077829682,
-0.009713673,
0.0154554788,
0.0736314952,
-0.0225680098,
-0.0064766188,
0.0026014664,
-0.0671929196,
0.0254680291,
0.0046946071,
-0.02248553,
0.0481364839,
-0.0479163863,
0.0018999361,
0.0418671072,
0.0260217339,
0.0629748031,
-0.0007116836,
-0.0176885892,
-0.0374031551,
0.0242545605,
-0.0214491356,
-0.0603753626,
0.0420337953,
-0.073911801,
0.0018449696,
0.0438193493,
0.0197312329,
0.0295345411,
-0.0529898778,
0.0276264939,
0.0004860786,
-0.0065968372,
-0.0450896285,
0.0213681553,
0.014949793,
0.052059941,
-0.0037677183,
-0.0283719078,
0.0985079333,
0.0123399384,
0.0103799356,
-0.0414733961,
-0.0146484198,
-0.0146053126,
0.0781458318,
-0.0169647895,
0.0352523476,
0.0517432094,
0.0084222639,
-0.0457146429,
-0.0014200608,
0.026392078,
-0.0472448915,
0.014498624,
-0.0347007625,
0.0017100988,
0.0077865338,
-0.0269094408,
-0.0537301414,
0.0036487086,
-0.0001777816,
-0.0152810328,
0.0106907301,
-0.0261734258,
-0.0230050944,
0.000935751,
0.0106875785,
0.0183418728,
0.0431723036,
-0.0522925444,
0.0088432701,
0.0779428557,
0.0848706737,
0.0360037945,
-0.0313639231,
0.0110336542,
0.0445582606,
0.0499979146,
-0.0136586353,
0.0031827176,
-0.0283127986,
-0.0234132223,
-0.0123941414,
0.0273157936,
0.0120631773,
0.0144738238,
0.0181631111,
-0.0197502933,
-0.0125603154,
0.0770213008,
0.0472402088,
-0.0160725657,
0.0134579642,
-0.0324572474,
-0.0068297009,
-0.0201289747,
0.0373212509,
-0.0656339154,
0.0128491325,
-0.0305793006,
0.0315442681,
-0.0232443772,
-0.0107639367,
-0.0078564622,
-0.0191732664,
0.070558168,
-0.0404192135,
0.0073202266,
-0.0223464519,
-0.0034050182,
-0.0080781253,
0.0210017357,
-0.0418511815,
-0.030662166,
0.005119314,
0.0125332838,
-0.0038387915,
-0.0195510909,
-0.0431533828,
-0.000746157,
-0.0111294473,
0.0126648899,
0.0881948173,
0.0578066781,
0.0147052463,
-0.0595472679,
-0.0567909889,
0.0558268689,
0.0671358705,
-0.0056229657,
0.0846844614,
0.0028425001,
0.0057065035,
-0.0579878502,
0.0349711664,
-0.01507778,
-0.0043223593,
0.0179143697,
0.0249366611,
-0.046867732,
-0.0302533358,
-0.0742608979,
0.0462677069,
0.0454044417,
0.0388939567,
0.0262179859,
-0.0143442098,
-0.0278422274,
0.0000615602,
0.102720663,
-0.0364327878,
-0.0210573282,
-0.0089311879,
0.0167865139,
-0.0286761113,
-0.111995697,
-0.0410913117,
0.0272350423,
-0.0037961158,
-0.0158647038,
-0.0212753713,
-0.0211949516,
0.0107993986,
-0.059236329,
0.029436443,
0.0133366175,
-0.0213574637,
-0.0155641017,
-0.0816505477,
0.0301249456,
-0.0343561731,
-0.0024086807,
0.0219514482,
-0.0207221191,
0.0146942139,
-0.0495888479,
0.0618747175,
0.0228587389,
-0.0285513233,
0.0083363708,
-0.0402455665,
0.0176391043,
0.0592668913,
-0.0268161986,
-0.0171198417,
-0.0229443554,
-0.0000589763,
0.0031867486,
-0.0050671268,
-0.0122544784,
0.0228749625,
-0.0054002898,
0.039610222,
-0.0358033702,
-0.0270013828,
0.0358584858,
0.0197123997,
0.0154516865,
-0.0319711417,
-0.0304036345,
-0.0056747887,
-0.0045621744,
-0.0198063422,
0.0090381261,
-0.0347494967,
-0.0080358591,
0.0073107164,
0.0120163672,
-0.0032767393,
-0.0023606797,
-0.0616704002,
-0.0225406326,
-0.0612970777,
0.0116971554,
0.0484199002,
-0.0131132426,
0.0140684182,
-0.0173502974,
0.006382999,
0.0032258555,
-0.0101844016,
0.0319694765,
0.0320558771,
0.0705447048,
-0.0080449348,
-0.0066693155,
0.0219283458,
0.0487641282,
-0.0294001736,
-0.0983621702,
-0.0133157577,
0.0574598722,
0.0380599722,
0.0416680872,
-0.0225931555,
-0.0204005111,
0.0190549716,
0.0084374286,
0.0065839705,
0.0123113403,
-0.0320285149,
0.0327888951,
0.0124666132,
0.0255671237,
-0.0356733799,
0.0825281814,
-0.0456081182,
0.0407319553,
-0.0459105559,
-0.0333328843,
-0.0525500998,
-0.0262403395,
-0.0145693719,
-0.0036366321,
-0.0194647107,
0.0461216457,
-0.0481969677,
-0.0578155555,
-0.0251779258,
0.0146945091,
-0.0199216586,
-0.0309048127,
0.0738098025,
0.052074939,
0.0005265944,
-0.038159959,
-0.0248871762,
0.0734447986,
-0.0616779588,
-0.001716724,
-0.0438647643,
-5.742720061e-33,
-0.0127077661,
-0.0476962179,
0.0486254618,
-0.0252669752,
0.0339218602,
0.0355875157,
-0.0487534814,
0.0068156496,
-0.013581329,
0.005854995,
-0.0261737332,
0.0014933057,
-0.0091190208,
0.0348606594,
-0.0159481317,
-0.0320899151,
0.0540049411,
-0.014447595,
-0.0295948908,
0.0333180204,
-0.0239873193,
0.0066780834,
-0.0176871698,
-0.1104135513,
-0.0092155971,
-0.0089812903,
-0.0002479982,
0.0160647947,
0.022560982,
0.0530629046,
-0.0419354215,
0.0367102809,
0.0510110371,
0.0088502252,
0.0000939006,
0.0370697118,
-0.0882067531,
-0.0343146287,
0.0218066592,
-0.0230551399,
-0.0951687843,
-0.0065163001,
0.0285118558,
-0.0252324697,
0.0184626244,
-0.0043929154,
0.0527536459,
-0.0063848789,
0.0281038769,
-0.0168262944,
-0.0299487319,
0.0223382711,
-0.0091687851,
-0.031223407,
-0.0303883087,
0.0366828516,
-0.0010049881,
0.024724219,
0.001876089,
0.033822827,
0.0451992489,
0.0035358679,
0.0581184477,
-0.0185680706,
-0.007654204,
0.0150716174,
0.0544287339,
-0.0233463738,
-0.0803668424,
-0.0030203382,
-0.0624784604,
0.0316072218,
0.0429679006,
0.0432575904,
0.0104753571,
-0.0070681749,
-0.0392731763,
0.0559240356,
-0.0690875202,
0.0598751083,
0.0128619904,
0.0115627628,
-0.0563291572,
0.0337687954,
0.0039959019,
-0.0172057655,
-0.0358502269,
-0.0561078154,
0.0438400172,
0.0325335823,
-0.0042986874,
0.0086947633,
-0.0209990833,
-0.01137204,
0.0271778293,
0.0101390518,
0.0213068333,
0.0225148425,
-0.0363697447,
-0.0245625824,
0.0056337635,
0.0211360138,
0.0733330175,
-0.0029989264,
0.0234426968,
0.033847928,
0.0185787957,
-0.0297102053,
-0.0329107456,
-0.0052687302,
-0.0020721103,
0.0292660072,
-0.0376710743,
-0.0155510101,
0.0218344703,
0.0349260569,
-0.0480724238,
-0.0083740866,
0.001387315,
0.0333049633,
-0.0622920319,
-0.0641819537,
-0.0331901237,
-0.0121782366,
-0.0642468259,
-0.0105243726,
-0.0357134491,
0.0001330839,
0.0411247052,
-0.0401531905,
-0.0321185924,
0.0143560441,
2.742e-7,
0.0591351315,
0.020375317,
0.0416486971,
0.0014108652,
0.0180262849,
-0.0174473822,
0.0270828772,
-0.0130787333,
-0.0021086191,
-0.0311475247,
0.0497613065,
0.0400281139,
-0.0192100871,
0.017814815,
-0.0215343013,
-0.0187831316,
-0.0460032448,
-0.00909412,
-0.0075766686,
0.0015468466,
0.1293600798,
0.0203548837,
-0.041993618,
-0.0279816464,
0.0219229665,
-0.0265219565,
0.0349773876,
-0.0533580445,
0.0355693884,
0.0096265413,
0.0206043888,
0.0175373759,
0.00893794,
0.0357872806,
-0.0110670226,
-0.0548043214,
0.0167105701,
0.040332593,
-0.0458356477,
-0.0245746579,
0.0104921516,
0.0263144579,
0.0252564345,
-0.0474185646,
0.0429630168,
-0.0533635281,
-0.0257215258,
-0.0042669219,
-0.0044224961,
-0.0015397895,
0.0194410104,
-0.0626723692,
-0.0659287572,
0.0141357612,
0.0293159503,
0.0229048226,
-0.0228107404,
-0.0497711077,
0.0193264205,
-0.0037117957,
-0.0313685648,
-0.0329989903,
-0.0073529398,
-0.0447336212,
-0.0229256898,
0.00151599,
-0.0106648672,
1.760895933e-34,
0.0177558083,
0.042016875,
-0.0073626824,
0.019260237,
0.0336655639,
0.0076967156,
-0.0095421253,
0.0006399031,
0.0446260385,
-0.0399561636,
-0.0277470332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15514v2 | Large Scale Generative AI Text Applied to Sports and Music | 2024-01-31T22:47:01 | 2024-02-28T00:03:57 | Aaron Baughman, Stephen Hammer, Rahul Agarwal, Gozde Akay, Eduardo Morales, Tony Johnson, Leonid Karlinsky, Rogerio Feris | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address the problem of scaling up the production of media content,
including commentary and personalized news stories, for large-scale sports and
music events worldwide. Our approach relies on generative AI models to
transform a large volume of multimodal data (e.g., videos, articles, real-time
scoring feeds, statistics, and fact sheets) into coherent and fluent text.
Based on this approach, we introduce, for the first time, an AI commentary
system, which was deployed to produce automated narrations for highlight
packages at the 2023 US Open, Wimbledon, and Masters tournaments. In the same
vein, our solution was extended to create personalized content for ESPN Fantasy
Football and stories about music artists for the Grammy awards. These
applications were built using a common software architecture achieved a 15x
speed improvement with an average Rouge-L of 82.00 and perplexity of 6.6. Our
work was successfully deployed at the aforementioned events, supporting 90
million fans around the world with 8 billion page views, continuously pushing
the bounds on what is possible at the intersection of sports, entertainment,
and AI. | [
0.0215840973,
0.0479803309,
-0.0093406728,
0.0217654165,
-0.0045214836,
-0.01723448,
-0.0152236503,
0.0141122239,
-0.0283490438,
-0.0286811795,
0.0121648796,
-0.0128879678,
-0.0396180414,
0.0927820355,
0.0023240356,
-0.0799263939,
-0.0311582386,
-0.0417798944,
0.0299879629,
-0.0187483355,
0.0325223617,
0.0269978046,
-0.0082501601,
-0.0111647295,
-0.0634548962,
-0.012314911,
-0.0211070906,
0.0039593098,
-0.011387811,
-0.0269993804,
-0.0857678279,
0.0211742911,
0.0351989903,
-0.026634777,
0.0000017989,
-0.0399324559,
0.0371634662,
-0.0329907648,
0.0182261635,
0.0493388921,
0.0460337624,
0.0128713064,
0.0129783135,
-0.0007702564,
-0.0411540717,
0.0226666015,
0.0400412083,
-0.0040623499,
0.0624030568,
0.0675952882,
-0.0372372307,
-0.034462288,
0.0290813241,
-0.014317546,
0.016434053,
-0.0580638833,
-0.0123627214,
0.0301589426,
0.00021232,
0.0118327225,
-0.0017788807,
0.0510547981,
0.0131090488,
0.0033847364,
0.0428432375,
0.0598138496,
-0.0107658608,
0.0058464329,
0.0049114861,
0.018646013,
0.0057798503,
-0.0192361344,
0.0173507091,
-0.0030023984,
0.0052202968,
-0.0405609719,
-0.0443611518,
0.0521251708,
-0.01170626,
0.0041266829,
-0.0353812538,
-0.0069784261,
-0.0191567875,
-0.0174575243,
-0.001994224,
-0.0483464561,
0.0407207273,
-0.0125512136,
-0.0753619671,
0.0329784639,
0.0196668822,
-0.1067546681,
0.0313955322,
0.0093132453,
-0.0393449068,
0.0049137804,
-0.0472954437,
-0.032984294,
-0.0628014505,
-0.0518770218,
0.0579101443,
0.0008096042,
0.0204739012,
0.0420845784,
0.0161739569,
-0.0352620035,
-0.0058229249,
-0.0474413969,
-0.0053533339,
-0.0087298108,
-0.0426512137,
0.0013452949,
-0.000063343,
-0.0037616745,
-0.0685068965,
-0.0502287932,
-0.0174357947,
0.0335542597,
0.0253011417,
0.0362598523,
0.0302621648,
0.024002308,
-0.0069137337,
-0.0369005501,
-0.0143566495,
-0.0010938107,
-0.0836233348,
0.0092311781,
0.0325641148,
-0.029461123,
0.0144158676,
0.0197761804,
0.0636918992,
0.0204022843,
0.0172253959,
0.0291779749,
-0.0308877137,
0.0418458432,
-0.0115098758,
-0.0274383575,
-0.0229379106,
-0.0453575738,
-0.0430812426,
-0.069050923,
0.036141526,
-0.0180374123,
-0.0098329755,
-0.0235839933,
-0.0193165261,
0.0186825357,
-0.0156152798,
0.0274773967,
0.0033031628,
0.0486719422,
0.0270034987,
-0.0067564105,
0.0495471731,
0.0189088881,
0.0351772383,
0.0697834864,
0.0450958349,
0.0167392157,
0.0484676398,
0.0498207249,
0.0007349745,
-0.027163554,
-0.0567815602,
-0.0067975777,
-0.0470326729,
0.0566517338,
-0.0031019605,
0.0537377931,
-0.0007464429,
0.0056776819,
0.0988921672,
0.013015965,
0.0131258676,
0.0145510696,
0.1105051041,
0.0171933174,
-0.0014193542,
-0.0112561528,
0.0117200222,
0.0781689137,
0.0286128558,
0.0427836291,
0.0619506799,
0.0149067957,
-0.0322833024,
-0.0687584728,
0.019041799,
-0.0129838474,
-0.0369186588,
0.0377034843,
0.0361532159,
-0.0084624365,
-0.0279644299,
-0.0257459506,
-0.0060249362,
-0.0530477352,
0.0591677241,
-0.0415521003,
0.0263649728,
0.1175308451,
0.0083703576,
-0.0137335341,
0.0405698679,
-0.0023390758,
0.0059818355,
0.0592811145,
0.0252886731,
-0.0355507806,
0.0028285601,
-0.041743774,
-0.0013650415,
0.0027382534,
0.0184172243,
0.0581550784,
-0.0468365178,
0.0409114063,
-0.0095340256,
0.0301839747,
-0.0476336628,
0.01169407,
-0.0403217562,
-0.0773776025,
0.0060800537,
-0.0157482456,
-0.0028849528,
0.0615980327,
-0.0451607071,
-0.0074649248,
0.0220423359,
-0.0026983761,
-0.0123517644,
0.0377851874,
0.0061211158,
0.0143410815,
-0.005470579,
-0.0447595194,
-0.0011926931,
0.0220652092,
-0.0306778271,
-0.0383677743,
0.0342888348,
0.0122578265,
-0.0105267456,
-0.0065937992,
0.0047103837,
0.0198947545,
0.0191558525,
0.0197964329,
0.0414689928,
0.0427513607,
-0.0391754061,
-0.0015525591,
-0.0216078479,
0.0261040274,
-0.0514587536,
-0.0035885344,
0.0388355628,
0.0314601772,
0.0038606895,
0.0430392772,
-0.0240175426,
-0.0369620435,
0.0006507951,
-0.1101907119,
0.0161255356,
0.003752555,
0.0005914509,
0.0299589131,
0.032227464,
-0.011819155,
0.0012972917,
-0.0347306319,
-0.0307675116,
0.016553428,
0.0105322255,
-0.0140454713,
0.0371562019,
0.0214036573,
-0.017772058,
-0.0177607127,
-0.0021353604,
0.0334650613,
0.029505074,
-0.0015894008,
-0.0533991419,
-0.0121811833,
-0.0614380129,
0.0201820917,
0.0136065055,
0.0277991034,
0.0119575989,
-0.020480115,
0.0512568839,
0.0683561265,
0.0150039317,
0.0186678581,
0.008612345,
-0.0508521833,
0.0057738824,
0.0288263075,
-0.0048990129,
-0.011506171,
-0.0458044447,
-0.0199098662,
0.0544432811,
-0.0049786181,
0.0442371927,
0.0279451441,
-0.0392510109,
0.0321879275,
0.0019007785,
0.0172084887,
0.0043691257,
-0.0148496004,
-0.0179944988,
0.0378384367,
0.0149749536,
0.008628088,
0.0178018808,
0.0037699947,
0.0137254633,
-0.0405596532,
-0.0549869351,
-0.0237627942,
0.0825978816,
0.0146301435,
0.0544175655,
-0.0324683674,
-0.010943383,
-0.0155769037,
0.0333639458,
0.0632563755,
-0.019055035,
-0.0186161511,
-0.001895932,
-0.0119257122,
0.0217269268,
-0.0537796989,
0.012385332,
-0.0092870025,
-0.0418863967,
-0.0530439131,
0.0655331016,
-0.0353972092,
-0.0540034845,
-0.0392797031,
0.0245893076,
0.0241008438,
-0.0266590472,
-0.0297255982,
0.0114243934,
0.0472713299,
0.0213358421,
0.0066298242,
-0.059380725,
-0.0447865836,
-0.0093325488,
0.0206205696,
0.0300762821,
0.0168550722,
0.011229841,
-0.0164350178,
0.0015857762,
-0.0083702225,
-0.0451953486,
0.0665823445,
0.0400614738,
-0.0256092362,
0.0417020768,
0.1133982167,
0.0494840592,
-0.0597159676,
-0.0194282811,
0.0382776521,
-0.0328326635,
-0.0053003244,
0.0437089391,
-0.1076823398,
0.0000130407,
0.0106879445,
0.0406372361,
0.0045055305,
0.0084626228,
-0.0376130193,
-0.0742091089,
0.0654136166,
0.0031625512,
0.0287499633,
-0.0465866439,
-0.0166931469,
-0.0056992141,
-0.0199442375,
-0.0352066606,
0.0063235094,
0.0003486272,
0.0430660807,
-0.0009772948,
-0.0049157818,
-0.0331993029,
-0.0059266114,
-0.0508684628,
0.0758648366,
0.0313071981,
0.0830518603,
-0.0079374062,
-0.0300647169,
-0.039002873,
0.0871947557,
0.0292855408,
0.0091628432,
0.0807937533,
-0.0268150158,
0.0182206631,
-0.0263663568,
0.0221204422,
0.0409451798,
0.01319547,
0.0744494349,
0.040893659,
0.0377566703,
-0.005357129,
-0.0208094753,
0.0109296711,
0.0117995944,
0.0293540508,
0.0329169147,
-0.0629632398,
-0.0109603945,
-0.0346417874,
0.0535330139,
-0.0958429947,
-0.0620841235,
-0.0240242705,
-0.0015565499,
-0.0850851387,
-0.0338368043,
-0.0139420368,
0.0051010149,
0.0284346715,
0.0211185776,
0.0151052121,
-0.0195858069,
-0.0363919772,
-0.0784730911,
-0.0350034945,
-0.0017081241,
-0.0344674252,
0.0015655293,
-0.0481036715,
0.0490802787,
-0.048249159,
-0.0226720776,
0.0543382391,
-0.0271606054,
-0.014894953,
-0.0056712665,
0.0262839831,
0.014821453,
0.0319268033,
0.0254443642,
-0.0314847492,
-0.022459995,
0.0602418482,
-0.0136424983,
0.0410938524,
-0.0250903238,
0.0193701163,
-0.0081615774,
0.0030724106,
-0.030662518,
0.0592161343,
-0.022299245,
0.0232360363,
-0.0057810997,
-0.0020463469,
0.0105494233,
0.0327820964,
-0.0015143121,
-0.0265489519,
-0.0328519344,
-0.0291147679,
-0.0425908566,
-0.0892028958,
0.0035751592,
-0.0300990455,
-0.005186676,
0.0249726325,
0.0562000647,
-0.0487487614,
0.0428125113,
-0.0225665309,
-0.0291057155,
-0.1027609929,
0.0122868912,
0.0327843614,
-0.056749817,
0.0060360604,
-0.0071199718,
0.002356732,
0.0211984236,
0.0070507573,
0.0162178371,
-0.0039065019,
-0.048622787,
0.0299368855,
-0.0305853076,
0.0263132341,
0.011998022,
-0.0469304509,
0.0273034777,
-0.0135058295,
0.0632499605,
0.0901755095,
0.0056146667,
-0.0000627056,
-0.0046693734,
-0.0072675515,
0.0069177579,
0.0237614512,
0.0095564667,
-0.0609438904,
-0.0664853007,
0.0025332198,
-0.0075564957,
-0.0075165783,
0.0545637608,
-0.0036678738,
-0.0091373399,
0.0093529653,
-0.0635039136,
-0.0652453229,
0.0098705795,
-0.027258575,
0.0003327563,
-0.0071390015,
0.0213671252,
-0.047395654,
-0.0042530675,
0.0027870482,
0.0134159392,
0.0021112615,
-0.0237819944,
0.0103321727,
0.0511672385,
0.0078157503,
0.0079037845,
-0.0348265134,
0.018732613,
-0.0936606899,
-0.0437074043,
0.0057170959,
-5.599985292e-33,
-0.0035154014,
-0.021966638,
0.0114082843,
0.033040639,
-0.0584654771,
0.0048923097,
-0.0512635633,
-0.0306477286,
0.0351573862,
0.0164985675,
-0.0145953149,
0.0081772171,
0.0026092855,
0.0102395499,
0.0554313436,
-0.0412818827,
0.0809637979,
-0.0598363653,
-0.040909607,
0.0549020469,
0.023836622,
0.034406051,
-0.0274050161,
-0.0897414461,
-0.0144592142,
-0.0402174853,
-0.0357244797,
-0.0115710692,
0.0602435395,
0.0153008942,
0.0072252373,
-0.0053483211,
0.007657351,
-0.0539254546,
-0.0065409169,
0.0206019133,
-0.0360520184,
-0.0194074437,
0.0018837943,
0.0041825073,
-0.0051078438,
0.0085768579,
0.0259138756,
-0.0096846763,
-0.0260046422,
-0.0183059331,
0.0547145233,
-0.0203033108,
0.0283197686,
-0.1068857014,
-0.0420635231,
0.0250180755,
-0.0181359071,
-0.0052181436,
0.0516277626,
-0.0084043238,
0.0110683097,
0.0304043572,
-0.0232803281,
0.0414469503,
-0.0295117293,
0.0266301371,
0.0220651086,
0.0011760227,
0.0014513599,
0.0142489951,
0.0568457879,
-0.0387436897,
-0.0875219926,
0.0304090995,
-0.0337908119,
0.0196299069,
0.0231532957,
0.0334079526,
0.0340905935,
-0.0103966407,
-0.0283516087,
0.0317346267,
0.0263541248,
-0.0175314713,
-0.0137895122,
0.0432542935,
-0.0424840041,
0.0378947407,
-0.0386543758,
-0.0277071334,
-0.0360414796,
-0.0660885349,
0.0180553999,
-0.0108235842,
0.0113354158,
0.0297659971,
0.0032085162,
0.0147277862,
-0.0353999436,
0.032761205,
-0.0235368237,
0.0920737013,
-0.0286059454,
0.0011340389,
-0.0186672583,
0.0106426589,
0.0316768661,
0.0426875688,
0.0135700675,
-0.0063827052,
0.0082415603,
0.0922840089,
-0.0154968891,
0.0017529493,
0.027548831,
0.0078206509,
0.0271747634,
0.002259433,
0.0163066797,
0.0370320417,
-0.0179079212,
0.0111267641,
0.0058606602,
0.0185904503,
0.0045171003,
-0.0535533205,
0.0133246332,
-0.0084407441,
-0.0431906693,
0.0205910355,
-0.0355408229,
-0.0107939336,
0.0106652724,
-0.0428376272,
-0.0500997491,
0.0093594464,
2.723e-7,
-0.0099411886,
0.0734648481,
-0.0211099871,
0.0170975626,
0.0101454854,
0.0210210141,
-0.0098579321,
0.0394177511,
-0.0201613642,
0.0435729474,
0.0552253015,
0.0498193763,
0.0508286692,
0.0335813873,
-0.098307915,
-0.0339726172,
-0.0609586835,
-0.0049432786,
-0.0604732409,
0.0178654566,
0.0547518991,
0.0340353847,
0.062709786,
0.019963013,
0.0528241172,
-0.0125493472,
0.0376420058,
0.0193805378,
-0.0232220907,
-0.0155371279,
-0.0065404857,
-0.0071292557,
-0.0779349953,
-0.0126775345,
-0.0597494021,
-0.0031984721,
0.0449990481,
0.0417292528,
-0.0250236299,
0.017940063,
-0.0087152738,
0.0111571327,
-0.0251091775,
0.0130827129,
0.0237641521,
0.0158079322,
-0.0422931239,
-0.0490910187,
-0.0651244521,
0.0072535183,
-0.022370575,
-0.0170479361,
-0.0303664468,
0.010945051,
-0.0142450184,
0.00072918,
0.0254135095,
-0.0401370488,
0.0297363214,
0.0061476543,
-0.0356326625,
0.0028279088,
-0.029602915,
0.0211580023,
0.0121326884,
-0.0615919456,
0.0242268462,
2.136581746e-34,
0.0456733182,
0.0268568154,
-0.050537549,
-0.042147655,
-0.0026580051,
0.0045550978,
-0.0282900166,
0.0001115238,
0.0240497384,
-0.0546143316,
-0.0234466866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00179v1 | De-identification is not always enough | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | Atiquer Rahman Sarkar, Yao-Shun Chuang, Noman Mohammed, Xiaoqian Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | For sharing privacy-sensitive data, de-identification is commonly regarded as
adequate for safeguarding privacy. Synthetic data is also being considered as a
privacy-preserving alternative. Recent successes with numerical and tabular
data generative models and the breakthroughs in large generative language
models raise the question of whether synthetically generated clinical notes
could be a viable alternative to real notes for research purposes. In this
work, we demonstrated that (i) de-identification of real clinical notes does
not protect records against a membership inference attack, (ii) proposed a
novel approach to generate synthetic clinical notes using the current
state-of-the-art large language models, (iii) evaluated the performance of the
synthetically generated notes in a clinical domain task, and (iv) proposed a
way to mount a membership inference attack where the target model is trained
with synthetic data. We observed that when synthetically generated notes
closely match the performance of real data, they also exhibit similar privacy
concerns to the real data. Whether other approaches to synthetically generated
clinical notes could offer better trade-offs and become a better alternative to
sensitive real notes warrants further investigation. | [
0.0589867681,
0.0966954082,
-0.0162523296,
0.0207327046,
-0.0502822474,
-0.0002893967,
0.0714457333,
0.0016843932,
0.0070047062,
-0.0106660156,
0.0095550446,
-0.0732506141,
-0.0167977065,
0.0235219952,
0.04235892,
-0.0111388629,
0.0357919894,
-0.0131268715,
0.0237364322,
-0.0235725213,
-0.0486910045,
-0.0102878036,
0.0133126471,
0.0155569436,
-0.0078756055,
-0.0136332223,
0.0074892654,
-0.018642908,
0.0141141023,
-0.0383166075,
-0.0124500794,
0.0797989815,
0.0045728348,
0.0567250624,
0.0000019576,
-0.0075484104,
-0.0494368486,
0.0564711802,
-0.0711734071,
-0.0225277692,
0.0397145934,
-0.042656891,
0.009656271,
-0.0268584695,
-0.0326521434,
-0.0596761741,
0.0314545371,
0.0312766396,
0.0350900814,
0.1136411726,
-0.0247920025,
-0.0195867643,
0.0028275929,
-0.0378112346,
0.0482385606,
-0.0228444822,
0.0445811637,
-0.0151489275,
0.0127934096,
-0.0004420735,
0.037971817,
0.028524138,
-0.0235671271,
0.0158990305,
0.0133528719,
0.0455532409,
-0.0197184067,
-0.0094199087,
0.0171045978,
0.0117986286,
0.0078465305,
-0.0181495566,
0.0665787533,
0.0201896988,
0.0238791555,
0.004890562,
-0.0109508438,
0.0578791089,
-0.0384311676,
-0.013912878,
0.0246463977,
-0.0051570418,
0.0421697348,
-0.0360196009,
0.009746098,
-0.0664074123,
0.0238830615,
0.0045705941,
-0.0493651442,
-0.0550060607,
-0.0315275155,
-0.050956402,
0.0378768928,
0.0051014293,
0.019190887,
0.0117888022,
-0.1021396071,
-0.0702904612,
0.0458032861,
-0.0520241857,
0.0239143856,
-0.0291502252,
0.045533739,
0.0126800612,
-0.0158526693,
0.0171690937,
-0.0331784077,
0.0426447317,
-0.0045955111,
0.0329406783,
-0.0014444533,
-0.0076426021,
0.0097577749,
0.0576293431,
-0.0283198953,
0.0036960009,
-0.0588722639,
0.0373297036,
-0.0225207563,
0.0593225397,
-0.0034319912,
0.0136965523,
-0.0544778332,
0.0069434717,
0.0165937059,
-0.1006705612,
0.0150228934,
0.0041002603,
-0.0048723733,
-0.052788116,
0.0258671995,
-0.0053654746,
0.0371368788,
0.011352676,
-0.0086394222,
0.0706398115,
0.0346250609,
-0.0105540967,
-0.0090164505,
-0.0933745205,
-0.0080152098,
-0.0103690727,
0.024699999,
-0.0517876707,
0.0365338959,
-0.0216981508,
-0.0242702216,
-0.0815353394,
0.0021717211,
0.0352040306,
-0.0321402065,
0.047339987,
-0.0549825393,
0.005902986,
-0.015950771,
0.0377679989,
0.0381461829,
-0.0228866953,
0.0374818034,
-0.0155028086,
0.0239720233,
-0.0265230555,
0.0618466996,
-0.0063440762,
0.0454049706,
-0.0608744733,
0.014006,
0.0204830728,
0.060747318,
-0.0147147328,
-0.0556623936,
0.0775248036,
-0.0011451546,
-0.073355183,
0.0705131665,
0.0579685085,
0.0150147853,
0.0560850166,
-0.0335911363,
-0.0353890732,
-0.00879688,
-0.0059106485,
-0.0136757344,
-0.0094549768,
-0.0187944267,
-0.0127269467,
-0.0185929984,
-0.0392145105,
-0.0050646244,
0.0043717255,
-0.0105328886,
-0.0578323454,
-0.0098326486,
-0.0029426639,
-0.0036116564,
0.0287628509,
0.0233553071,
0.0117422035,
0.0336486474,
-0.0510271043,
-0.0270182416,
-0.06481947,
0.0061178352,
0.0699626356,
0.072657086,
-0.019252127,
0.0026014857,
-0.0458977073,
-0.0410027057,
0.0211514272,
0.0023321356,
-0.0169401262,
0.0346994027,
-0.0352741592,
0.0008173081,
0.0161927696,
0.0198670216,
0.0164323021,
0.0244110506,
-0.01195106,
0.0058774156,
-0.0218668617,
-0.0142070465,
0.0181199443,
-0.061266169,
-0.0454802066,
0.0613780916,
-0.0013791714,
0.059385851,
0.0498062782,
-0.0158523805,
0.0479816757,
0.0336440764,
-0.0089782262,
0.0174703039,
-0.0374418013,
-0.0026491317,
0.0057726628,
-0.0327795967,
-0.0272159223,
0.0115645761,
0.0032602318,
-0.0072577777,
-0.0093747787,
-0.0320578441,
-0.0398954079,
0.0144113237,
-0.0192525182,
0.0257193781,
0.0509102754,
0.0124116093,
-0.0372189507,
0.0341363549,
-0.0276555419,
0.0060120192,
-0.0153833106,
-0.0285335109,
0.0086930525,
-0.0553184673,
-0.0156406816,
-0.0053246235,
-0.0289189033,
0.0212093685,
-0.0100455247,
-0.0502934158,
0.0139284637,
-0.0402646102,
-0.0498483442,
0.0166361127,
0.0047439253,
0.0302164406,
0.0184404105,
0.0241267271,
-0.0187513605,
-0.0349049047,
-0.0484190732,
-0.0498956181,
-0.0022228973,
0.0230683908,
0.0107583432,
0.0423085168,
-0.0110519212,
-0.0000122875,
-0.026876729,
-0.0193189848,
0.0437494777,
-0.0151117817,
-0.0310410243,
-0.0125954626,
0.0240856931,
-0.0294552073,
0.0317744091,
-0.015615778,
-0.0003663656,
0.0009422394,
-0.0085744569,
0.0256498735,
0.0385089926,
0.0133964764,
0.0217447001,
0.0283482298,
0.0220209695,
0.0163970198,
-0.0205153394,
-0.0567077249,
-0.0100333039,
0.0078715207,
-0.0557715371,
0.0087759737,
-0.0001598439,
0.053877417,
-0.0426416695,
-0.0166671388,
0.0369329229,
0.0150449341,
0.0036208245,
0.0223834626,
-0.0058439411,
-0.0145043852,
-0.0072926516,
-0.0233045835,
-0.0438035242,
0.0647805855,
-0.0087820953,
0.0580813736,
-0.0061795623,
-0.0319058709,
0.031473536,
0.0457374193,
0.0337374732,
0.0322783999,
0.0530320816,
-0.0119057391,
0.0208496172,
0.0189932752,
0.0362349413,
-0.081561625,
0.0139588499,
-0.0061744717,
-0.00765535,
-0.0030019803,
-0.0297481027,
-0.0531320088,
-0.0722704753,
0.0292528477,
-0.0103404708,
-0.0031233493,
-0.0064514587,
-0.0025129314,
0.0030467073,
0.0029036154,
0.0736077577,
0.0260251723,
0.0158039499,
-0.0289562698,
0.0042062299,
-0.0138426041,
-0.0836440623,
-0.0049767364,
-0.0409677774,
-0.00543044,
0.0810974911,
0.021322595,
0.0783927292,
0.0203013998,
-0.0495010689,
-0.0381609797,
-0.0271296389,
-0.0379685834,
0.0421848595,
-0.0001166309,
-0.0252228156,
0.0023666003,
0.073613584,
0.0074662585,
-0.0613545105,
0.0185970664,
0.0685791001,
-0.0303366072,
-0.0335056745,
-0.0246850532,
-0.0769702569,
0.0285332166,
0.0132098151,
0.0403289534,
-0.078100279,
-0.0521985851,
-0.0163822751,
-0.0654314831,
0.0342403501,
0.0032477819,
-0.0095483474,
-0.0350695439,
-0.0369133912,
0.021065684,
0.0142754912,
-0.0439429842,
-0.0254153647,
-0.0107804798,
-0.018900983,
-0.002044579,
-0.0327631384,
-0.0830426291,
-0.0370365009,
-0.0507007129,
0.0696231425,
0.0481650308,
0.0241436455,
0.0153986393,
-0.0351579115,
0.0118078841,
0.0324329436,
-0.0203756392,
0.0349472016,
0.1032111272,
0.0144912666,
-0.0093754865,
-0.0420577787,
0.0701638684,
0.0242122449,
-0.0161444843,
-0.0096431067,
0.0006393155,
-0.0607585981,
-0.0329503343,
-0.0061030309,
-0.002220243,
0.0419297777,
0.0460832193,
0.0086010965,
0.0173508897,
0.0130240498,
-0.0064038294,
0.0908296928,
-0.0033741391,
0.0115665169,
0.0356143415,
-0.0369053632,
-0.0639455318,
-0.0590624623,
0.0145091908,
-0.0171195809,
0.0221294072,
0.0210901015,
0.0301188882,
0.0220719762,
-0.0321117975,
-0.0551130921,
-0.0088180592,
-0.0393249691,
-0.0053614723,
-0.0253548101,
-0.0419104807,
0.0232142303,
0.0013464761,
-0.0227729939,
-0.0064314604,
-0.0469976142,
-0.0492917895,
0.0395595282,
0.0566753186,
0.0240866952,
0.0002062565,
-0.0008839404,
-0.0421684645,
0.0356937535,
0.0550141893,
-0.0150778303,
-0.0188321248,
0.0061269058,
-0.049948398,
-0.0211052336,
0.0091806278,
0.0007321583,
0.0077242451,
0.0671784282,
-0.0368838347,
-0.0252907034,
-0.0049960255,
-0.0076668533,
0.0481586717,
0.0326619036,
0.0170829985,
0.0341643877,
-0.0216014199,
0.04075142,
-0.0738707259,
0.0147004426,
0.0028622549,
-0.0323415138,
0.0135407094,
0.0272082407,
0.0055245725,
-0.0097366627,
-0.0348753594,
-0.0180995259,
-0.0650074482,
0.0084531261,
0.051391907,
0.0059772045,
0.0342157744,
-0.0245597735,
-0.0279452093,
0.0708912984,
0.0300861876,
0.0334961712,
-0.0126700681,
0.0159964319,
-0.0108194863,
-0.0006030978,
-0.0119196028,
0.0317359269,
-0.0452651307,
-0.0167166367,
-0.0289468821,
0.0259467047,
-0.0156266242,
0.033307109,
-0.0169684906,
-0.0488435403,
0.0069335853,
-0.0372451134,
0.0293414276,
-0.0194858648,
-0.036170274,
0.0018633917,
-0.0075756926,
-0.0040285727,
0.0079071447,
0.10669709,
0.0371635854,
0.0532154702,
-0.0350707732,
-0.0446252562,
-0.0536537357,
-0.0207151417,
0.0112710986,
-0.012887029,
-0.0375174545,
-0.0307071153,
-0.0428324342,
-0.0436512753,
0.0384125859,
0.0133497007,
0.0225927588,
0.0069793067,
0.0183304101,
-0.0088745132,
0.0042757131,
-0.0266014021,
-0.0440325215,
0.0469377004,
0.0023623558,
-0.0362927243,
0.0142403198,
-5.687183831e-33,
0.0234574452,
-0.0232036803,
-0.0362105295,
0.0077954675,
0.0097651556,
0.0281571504,
-0.0317341648,
-0.0154762827,
0.0296063162,
-0.0251628254,
-0.0390330218,
-0.0007757663,
0.0156025551,
0.0465938002,
-0.0387667306,
-0.0300115272,
0.0370620377,
-0.0087619806,
-0.0069617741,
0.0582126528,
0.0337114967,
0.028791612,
0.0198106617,
-0.0860839412,
0.0383463353,
-0.0404894277,
-0.0052587613,
-0.0126187513,
-0.0427227318,
0.0559543222,
-0.0232450254,
-0.038382668,
0.0315883569,
0.0109473588,
-0.0026560943,
0.0446682535,
-0.0630552471,
0.0114217084,
-0.0096132969,
-0.0519871004,
0.0203442741,
-0.102454938,
0.0311529115,
-0.0543339401,
-0.0198484659,
-0.0076711602,
-0.0053328536,
-0.0317552797,
-0.0338692665,
-0.0813078657,
0.0119175585,
0.0282805376,
0.0022845983,
0.0168751609,
0.044745706,
-0.0145389829,
-0.0164758842,
-0.040267121,
-0.0201518424,
0.0256898813,
0.0576099344,
-0.0021115798,
-0.0246394724,
-0.0018340118,
0.0242939964,
0.0391800292,
0.0593345203,
0.0288529303,
-0.0083936388,
0.0311270766,
-0.0592928603,
0.0319914035,
0.0647395626,
0.0634121373,
0.0388940945,
-0.0426482186,
-0.0700182319,
0.0317324437,
-0.0904137865,
-0.034652181,
0.0967465118,
-0.0122858211,
-0.0643963814,
0.0044722026,
-0.021800559,
-0.0283859428,
-0.010030794,
0.0229758844,
-0.0150160799,
0.0265556406,
-0.0529661514,
0.026843084,
0.0105036953,
-0.0403220318,
-0.0031359617,
-0.0106921867,
0.065756239,
-0.0132254828,
-0.0397869386,
-0.0340931378,
-0.0135253752,
-0.0201825202,
0.0631266758,
-0.0172912441,
0.0448027924,
0.0244263243,
0.0531242639,
-0.0239180084,
-0.0670514777,
-0.0088023562,
0.0210717544,
0.0590059198,
0.0182315353,
0.0157951862,
0.0557025336,
-0.006798408,
0.0288805142,
0.0275646746,
0.0058999397,
0.0236616954,
-0.0484306328,
0.0312106516,
-0.0218206234,
-0.0037403463,
0.0240863189,
0.0126419934,
-0.0000309158,
0.0517091155,
0.0799643993,
-0.0071027456,
0.024677366,
-0.0261420682,
2.827e-7,
0.0278626997,
-0.0178087596,
0.0464657918,
-0.0335617624,
0.0432159156,
0.026575014,
0.0346297994,
0.0804375783,
0.0031567768,
-0.0279549602,
0.0074813133,
-0.0209161844,
0.0560874827,
0.0437729731,
-0.0688261315,
-0.0028500413,
-0.0527735278,
-0.0104275504,
-0.0428109542,
0.0083074421,
0.0345500372,
0.0600848496,
-0.0133564221,
-0.0083308434,
-0.0136895617,
-0.0114257969,
0.0094536692,
-0.0441283397,
-0.0116506601,
0.0179574843,
0.0510589108,
0.0280358754,
0.0159284566,
0.0418012291,
-0.0487795919,
-0.0169071965,
-0.0291640572,
0.1187335327,
0.0056298864,
0.0490334183,
0.0363919623,
-0.0621034391,
-0.0025445875,
0.0100285532,
0.0339982025,
-0.0274125263,
-0.0394278094,
-0.004346685,
-0.0194218904,
-0.0525900833,
0.0424919352,
-0.0159128122,
0.0020815628,
0.0107959174,
0.0114311622,
0.0308387503,
0.0244533885,
-0.0457717292,
-0.0124506429,
-0.0141284922,
-0.0449863374,
0.0041328715,
0.0519643761,
-0.0102468384,
0.0249453392,
-0.0349091589,
0.0483963415,
2.573266189e-34,
-0.0192989316,
0.0076375366,
-0.0393649153,
-0.0148272784,
0.0128939431,
-0.0207667649,
0.0506633855,
0.0211357959,
0.0138288448,
-0.0594936237,
-0.0244364552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00160v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00160v2 | Emergency Department Decision Support using Clinical Pseudo-notes | 2024-01-31T20:31:56 | 2024-04-29T21:37:34 | Simon A. Lee, Sujay Jain, Alex Chen, Kyoka Ono, Jennifer Fang, Akos Rudas, Jeffrey N. Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Multiple Embedding Model for EHR (MEME), an
approach that serializes multimodal EHR tabular data into text using
pseudo-notes, mimicking clinical text generation. This conversion not only
preserves better representations of categorical data and learns contexts but
also enables the effective employment of pretrained foundation models for rich
feature representation. To address potential issues with context length, our
framework encodes embeddings for each EHR modality separately. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of MEME by applying it to several decision support tasks
within the Emergency Department across multiple hospital systems. Our findings
indicate that MEME outperforms traditional machine learning, EHR-specific
foundation models, and general LLMs, highlighting its potential as a general
and extendible EHR representation strategy. | [
0.0006266421,
0.0302803013,
0.0029810537,
-0.0327122621,
0.0080831377,
0.0570142418,
0.0081448667,
0.0075317067,
-0.0000236075,
-0.0494701304,
0.002802236,
-0.0607162714,
-0.0329457894,
0.060876444,
0.0327018872,
-0.0579852127,
0.0165016875,
0.0219070725,
0.0169928167,
0.0473610349,
0.0031195055,
0.015086838,
-0.0134424558,
0.0758592933,
-0.0195916183,
0.0273847338,
-0.0608047955,
0.0198025554,
0.0458738059,
-0.0752281696,
-0.0104092192,
0.0214955155,
0.0702420622,
-0.0345262662,
0.0000019056,
0.009193562,
-0.0366081409,
0.0108247623,
-0.0533173457,
-0.0777414516,
0.0345239826,
-0.0962855145,
0.014027101,
0.0143714556,
0.0062034028,
-0.06945768,
0.0311670303,
0.0614437014,
0.0393095724,
0.0489279442,
-0.0257006809,
-0.000417446,
0.0053883018,
-0.0263373312,
0.0106253317,
0.0007968033,
-0.0102563109,
-0.0188012179,
0.0098889563,
-0.0105428752,
-0.0008262817,
0.0229435805,
0.0273456592,
0.0638083071,
0.0550369062,
0.0635009259,
0.0264845006,
0.0328402519,
-0.0209273845,
0.0788990334,
-0.0018614503,
0.0237206277,
0.0195899401,
-0.0077052861,
-0.0078324517,
-0.0069912146,
-0.0254468359,
-0.0203112084,
-0.0169070326,
-0.0090098586,
-0.0166145116,
0.0455323495,
0.0270878226,
-0.0220824927,
-0.0015917725,
-0.0542978495,
0.0061442428,
-0.0404753014,
0.0087397685,
-0.017706532,
-0.0061143246,
-0.0174799096,
0.0213000141,
0.0416251533,
-0.0497601815,
0.0089110062,
-0.0392228812,
-0.0025461791,
0.0686460808,
-0.0161153655,
0.0640426725,
0.0211644359,
-0.0183214396,
0.0155408019,
-0.0143479686,
-0.0121896528,
-0.0445055254,
0.0186890792,
-0.0328712948,
0.0214202218,
-0.0509348847,
-0.0129238069,
-0.0191289,
0.0271800216,
-0.0012874184,
-0.0128220627,
-0.0533157662,
0.0196903199,
0.0259838272,
0.0372157395,
0.0134918336,
0.0422983915,
-0.025665259,
0.0438106917,
-0.0180176403,
-0.0011333543,
0.0113717476,
-0.0005231064,
0.0195207167,
0.013445613,
0.0340680517,
0.0169214122,
0.0231322404,
0.0046875989,
-0.0218976531,
0.0729035735,
-0.0003670812,
-0.0270472914,
-0.0354455374,
-0.0416281521,
-0.0211127512,
0.0035026527,
0.0276288502,
-0.0419530459,
0.0474464819,
0.0073902532,
0.0030172649,
-0.0272662416,
0.0080642626,
0.0055499179,
-0.0290543977,
0.0540938862,
-0.0583255291,
0.0040195673,
0.0572668165,
0.037990734,
0.0015405756,
0.0048266584,
0.0213330034,
0.0106575647,
0.0078483224,
-0.0609881245,
0.0059338603,
-0.0119787175,
-0.0048825825,
-0.0653293282,
-0.0089325868,
0.0026872398,
-0.0211748667,
0.0683573037,
-0.004258106,
0.0113698095,
-0.0357449688,
-0.0163606163,
0.0397720449,
0.0678345263,
0.0436677299,
-0.008994828,
0.0560893677,
-0.0163409151,
-0.0429321006,
-0.0253658853,
-0.0177266579,
0.0313965566,
0.0456378646,
0.0038991591,
0.0176135972,
-0.0223975889,
-0.0519835353,
-0.0345176049,
-0.030049935,
-0.0254943278,
-0.0310845245,
-0.0235037841,
0.0170127433,
-0.0596116371,
-0.0568378158,
0.0371066332,
0.023991175,
-0.0058868453,
-0.0158829652,
-0.0415569358,
-0.019321112,
0.1481338143,
0.0236945022,
-0.0339409932,
-0.0446058847,
-0.0566521846,
0.0375536978,
0.0060816389,
0.0296921972,
-0.0213160906,
0.0287829861,
-0.0584215634,
-0.0345126204,
0.0047450755,
0.0379327349,
-0.0036644985,
-0.0616221838,
0.0362579785,
0.0025225382,
0.0040490371,
-0.0168781169,
0.0214146003,
-0.0401046053,
-0.0185186416,
-0.0163451713,
0.0308854319,
0.0152550563,
0.0261356775,
-0.0112286592,
0.0230219942,
0.0380124673,
-0.0435167812,
-0.03370836,
-0.0076167108,
-0.0769947842,
-0.0064474787,
-0.0169515349,
0.0030702017,
0.0273827463,
-0.0280405674,
-0.0378324464,
-0.0194875188,
-0.0589382313,
-0.0565722138,
0.0266022794,
-0.0296550151,
0.0048822719,
0.0943940803,
-0.0259750616,
-0.0272312947,
0.0360341929,
-0.0448344089,
0.0052630808,
-0.0020974732,
0.0001591864,
0.0230057053,
-0.0344670191,
0.0069630612,
0.0065691546,
0.015764432,
0.0319463499,
-0.0269472264,
0.0089118704,
-0.0226312261,
-0.0043299184,
-0.1512935311,
-0.0141454739,
0.0086174021,
-0.013009741,
0.0348787643,
-0.0207374133,
0.012039802,
-0.0300224256,
-0.0574758947,
-0.0199698675,
0.0248928089,
0.0240639821,
0.0268615671,
0.0395323113,
-0.0108292056,
-0.0074630328,
-0.0082613062,
-0.0281497631,
0.0309883486,
-0.0384072624,
-0.0315456912,
-0.0346105993,
-0.0499774404,
-0.0031170431,
-0.0367666148,
0.0020459911,
-0.0008275334,
0.0203180965,
-0.0270014871,
0.0242334679,
0.0000923369,
-0.0001440808,
0.0912733749,
0.0233670399,
-0.0157932062,
-0.0297871847,
0.0060874093,
-0.0406199917,
0.0331109986,
0.0135805588,
-0.0532405674,
-0.0101352278,
0.0287501197,
0.0058363848,
0.044740174,
-0.0359836593,
-0.0312936194,
0.0179560091,
0.0134516638,
-0.0921338871,
0.0376224071,
-0.02069683,
0.0239171628,
-0.0024772647,
-0.0304389335,
0.0302887298,
0.0172873735,
0.0396311954,
-0.0129555808,
-0.052082222,
-0.0493753664,
0.0330589749,
-0.0197242778,
0.0308189001,
0.00030688,
-0.0147428615,
0.0064683431,
0.0282709952,
-0.0424433611,
-0.0569714159,
0.0333410762,
0.013594537,
-0.0178632718,
-0.0105114561,
-0.0379060991,
-0.0404741913,
-0.0445067696,
-0.0027024148,
0.0143937366,
-0.0284338761,
0.0344021916,
-0.068436794,
0.0180795174,
-0.0092084846,
0.0859801471,
0.0470314324,
-0.033440318,
-0.0101786572,
0.0718044788,
0.0209816657,
0.0244488604,
-0.0086713536,
-0.0449564308,
0.0445108637,
0.0684215724,
-0.0123661794,
-0.006976956,
-0.0310202781,
0.0383309349,
-0.0315860547,
-0.0079378858,
-0.020868117,
0.0322126001,
0.0124305822,
-0.0371403918,
0.0326451212,
0.0725518987,
0.022980677,
-0.0596298799,
0.0249217823,
-0.0189869981,
-0.0161663834,
-0.0095174126,
0.0130336871,
-0.0091770012,
-0.0341407694,
-0.0055816779,
0.0107341865,
0.0073133479,
-0.0347320847,
0.0365676694,
-0.0226843581,
0.0560577027,
-0.006105253,
-0.0488969386,
-0.0275942516,
-0.0126358038,
0.0050616236,
0.017905768,
-0.0115520358,
-0.0186355561,
-0.0350839198,
-0.0364457816,
0.0185111091,
-0.0183605906,
-0.0833669081,
-0.0349010639,
-0.0384403951,
0.035788469,
0.0362053141,
0.0221784208,
-0.0188431088,
-0.0328418128,
-0.013990486,
0.025676351,
0.0244001802,
-0.0117739765,
0.0581219643,
-0.0181260314,
-0.0095607322,
-0.0285306051,
0.0092033911,
-0.0140294842,
-0.0458486937,
0.0064148824,
0.0971371233,
-0.0552814491,
-0.004453396,
-0.0709381774,
-0.0057031754,
0.0434503183,
0.0427790582,
-0.0058315508,
-0.043915581,
-0.0188534409,
-0.004468454,
0.0558354445,
0.0258812197,
-0.0033105223,
0.0432021841,
-0.0465672687,
-0.0414745398,
-0.0325236246,
-0.0393928997,
0.040704675,
0.0186990611,
0.0011360284,
-0.0032875128,
0.0067034671,
-0.0205013137,
-0.0623778999,
0.0173408613,
0.0170428362,
-0.0072692661,
-0.0579421446,
-0.0427976437,
0.036145065,
0.0030648736,
-0.0008920913,
-0.0189227946,
0.0308269653,
0.0206281524,
-0.0151958801,
0.0742142573,
0.0131677864,
-0.0275946353,
0.0512197129,
-0.0157691445,
0.048542466,
0.0430892855,
-0.0552712157,
-0.0165485665,
-0.0090485057,
-0.0114456378,
-0.0409656949,
0.0052278414,
-0.0172333643,
0.044617366,
-0.0221046917,
0.0332305655,
-0.0160825271,
-0.0173333604,
-0.0022576181,
-0.0182550084,
0.0007126064,
-0.0343494006,
-0.0268514715,
-0.0232392754,
0.0285113472,
-0.0345439911,
0.0244038235,
-0.0304976311,
0.0176408291,
0.0003026656,
0.0020750647,
0.009624471,
-0.0027783336,
0.0065497402,
-0.0036805121,
-0.0577634647,
0.0363294855,
0.004902178,
0.0108497022,
0.0016342158,
0.0287355315,
-0.0344817527,
0.0419562683,
-0.022982128,
0.0086512761,
-0.0165049806,
0.0796429589,
-0.0072150244,
0.0295547079,
-0.0165407304,
0.0844186917,
-0.0159819536,
-0.0439357311,
-0.0320270658,
-0.0033002836,
0.0376524515,
0.0209390763,
-0.0011505923,
-0.0258731432,
-0.0045176381,
-0.0334318094,
0.037044432,
0.0158558879,
0.0218359306,
0.0558015443,
0.0218578223,
-0.0178649146,
-0.0167797916,
0.0609811395,
0.0321897864,
0.0331671685,
-0.00462774,
-0.0326308347,
-0.057814125,
0.0150932483,
0.1087719947,
0.037348114,
-0.0438044816,
-0.0332138017,
-0.0650920495,
-0.0427263044,
0.0724912807,
-0.0087007303,
-0.0467117876,
-0.0097735636,
0.0565279052,
0.0150205223,
0.0260165259,
0.0228297301,
-0.0139232473,
0.0160172917,
-0.0413915664,
-0.0002929326,
0.0061599216,
-5.725717637e-33,
-0.0088047041,
-0.0499089286,
0.0348208733,
-0.0629159808,
0.0229607243,
0.0492990464,
-0.0084717451,
0.0081797019,
0.0544013977,
-0.0118199009,
0.0085163685,
-0.0358267762,
-0.001041873,
0.0168200117,
0.0207253285,
-0.0433593392,
0.0400517285,
-0.007809625,
-0.0035314658,
0.0259980019,
0.024757605,
0.0544217713,
0.0297892019,
-0.1073036939,
-0.0216153841,
0.0039845817,
-0.00457785,
-0.0124301538,
0.0093791084,
0.0632856414,
-0.0691067874,
0.0408138894,
0.041064851,
-0.0431216583,
-0.0025733663,
0.0533292033,
-0.0709072873,
-0.0123463729,
-0.00257396,
-0.0459918194,
-0.0425640494,
-0.0714293495,
0.0136531414,
-0.0144748846,
0.0157880094,
-0.0246987268,
0.0131448917,
-0.0184810944,
-0.0316710845,
-0.0270082597,
-0.0182369705,
0.0460564084,
-0.0030086106,
0.002534345,
0.0117643289,
0.0230587181,
-0.0038219036,
0.0306162238,
-0.0576019734,
-0.0352557488,
-0.0285483468,
-0.0380575135,
0.0023337526,
-0.0257857647,
-0.0489824936,
0.091250591,
0.0017176231,
-0.0101998048,
-0.0726753697,
0.0424335375,
-0.0436106063,
0.0898484364,
0.0319790654,
0.0543690249,
0.0450311936,
-0.0159235578,
-0.0700536519,
0.0651864633,
-0.0666524917,
0.0171993021,
0.0573284104,
-0.0119469082,
-0.0597732402,
0.0039104726,
0.0101212822,
0.0164665561,
-0.0031279679,
-0.0507844351,
0.0713648945,
0.0341003276,
0.0114864847,
0.0571132377,
0.0302943867,
0.0135972733,
0.0188448075,
0.0128802219,
0.0389211178,
0.0214909967,
-0.0177647416,
-0.025822876,
-0.0457533486,
-0.03514833,
0.051863268,
-0.0326463953,
0.0391976573,
0.0143633382,
0.0512821302,
0.0124281729,
-0.0348287858,
0.0091613755,
0.0530265756,
-0.0048371735,
-0.0097255083,
0.0145060867,
0.054277353,
-0.0081287762,
-0.0149510419,
0.0474331155,
-0.0260263421,
-0.0007698133,
-0.0141205834,
-0.0583926328,
0.008335921,
0.0395554081,
0.0201703645,
0.0028333026,
-0.0530131049,
-0.0021567487,
0.0112464558,
-0.0301147569,
0.0140888458,
0.0074531659,
2.542e-7,
0.0580606982,
-0.003006838,
0.0374887027,
-0.0381057039,
0.0375517383,
0.0153850634,
-0.0074346545,
0.036109671,
-0.0084066009,
-0.043780189,
0.0659928992,
0.0323355906,
0.049100291,
0.059836559,
-0.0349591784,
-0.0562409498,
-0.0516444743,
0.0011973,
-0.0255416743,
0.0171685815,
0.1232270375,
0.0756068528,
-0.0351943858,
-0.0426253974,
0.0067965449,
0.0259156749,
0.069049418,
-0.0574827679,
0.0325004384,
-0.0361241885,
-0.0153501788,
0.0487402901,
-0.0364097916,
0.0306580774,
-0.0104302177,
-0.0123463878,
0.0327654108,
0.0915517882,
-0.0410716012,
0.0038865365,
0.0121371681,
-0.0059776618,
-0.0063513378,
-0.015851032,
0.0538341701,
-0.0578924753,
-0.022529576,
0.0311705787,
-0.0463533364,
0.0146687068,
0.0436953753,
-0.0322245508,
-0.0376164429,
0.0170798972,
0.0265923664,
-0.0122122495,
-0.0198199823,
-0.0758748874,
0.0159673225,
0.066195555,
-0.0199012812,
-0.022917157,
0.0033812108,
-0.0138152335,
0.0404734723,
-0.0802732855,
-0.0152161298,
2.39153591e-34,
0.0282992516,
0.0062320232,
0.0080668274,
0.0352861658,
0.0234258901,
-0.0223000739,
0.0417922959,
-0.0238422472,
0.0306305513,
-0.0645260513,
-0.0248544253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00159v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00159v2 | Dolma: an Open Corpus of Three Trillion Tokens for Language Model Pretraining Research | 2024-01-31T20:29:50 | 2024-06-06T18:46:40 | Luca Soldaini, Rodney Kinney, Akshita Bhagia, Dustin Schwenk, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Ben Bogin, Khyathi Chandu, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Valentin Hofmann, Ananya Harsh Jha, Sachin Kumar, Li Lucy, Xinxi Lyu, Nathan Lambert, Ian Magnusson, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Abhilasha Ravichander, Kyle Richardson, Zejiang Shen, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Oyvind Tafjord, Pete Walsh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Iz Beltagy, Dirk Groeneveld, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information about pretraining corpora used to train the current
best-performing language models is seldom discussed: commercial models rarely
detail their data, and even open models are often released without accompanying
training data or recipes to reproduce them. As a result, it is challenging to
conduct and advance scientific research on language modeling, such as
understanding how training data impacts model capabilities and limitations. To
facilitate scientific research on language model pretraining, we curate and
release Dolma, a three-trillion-token English corpus, built from a diverse
mixture of web content, scientific papers, code, public-domain books, social
media, and encyclopedic materials. We extensively document Dolma, including its
design principles, details about its construction, and a summary of its
contents. We present analyses and experimental results on intermediate states
of Dolma to share what we have learned about important data curation practices.
Finally, we open-source our data curation toolkit to enable reproduction of our
work as well as support further research in large-scale data curation. | [
0.0329471342,
0.087308228,
-0.0118094934,
0.0115334773,
-0.0159260668,
0.0289439466,
0.015932804,
0.02011857,
-0.0071063186,
-0.0593205728,
-0.0190208405,
-0.0161727499,
-0.0126695586,
0.0278266817,
0.0434667692,
-0.0379770175,
0.0636275932,
-0.0441922694,
0.0095880963,
-0.0176201314,
0.0188846961,
0.0288839824,
0.0136546092,
0.0421670787,
-0.0227761213,
-0.0157894008,
0.0096453037,
0.0016193386,
-0.0260595586,
-0.0237558577,
0.0257092882,
0.0594681911,
0.0108823003,
0.071123749,
0.000001898,
-0.0641646311,
-0.0177601632,
-0.0025312747,
-0.0130715081,
0.0144316861,
0.0715840235,
-0.0173106529,
-0.0114977276,
0.0313082449,
-0.0338667817,
-0.0331673138,
0.054462675,
0.0031435839,
0.0477647223,
0.0788519233,
-0.0113264658,
-0.0369214118,
0.0461503565,
-0.0111963861,
-0.0156843495,
0.0141394241,
0.0272978991,
0.0053840452,
0.0023435554,
-0.0003932818,
-0.0117022293,
0.0222001784,
-0.0029017976,
-0.0078776302,
0.0018771129,
0.0451043546,
-0.0570357405,
-0.0670443103,
-0.0069868425,
0.0749716759,
0.0134245902,
-0.0649119243,
0.0279078539,
0.0063393288,
-0.0269345399,
0.0060390807,
-0.0413789712,
0.006486197,
0.0297182482,
0.0401259176,
0.0136922365,
-0.0390183963,
0.0452082008,
0.0005874813,
-0.025974229,
0.0529997125,
0.0337558798,
-0.0453818478,
0.0212241635,
0.019750081,
-0.0068800547,
-0.0890843198,
0.0338573083,
-0.0215379987,
-0.0051951613,
0.0150490515,
-0.0656326115,
-0.0822198465,
0.0498071648,
-0.0148357581,
0.0331226029,
0.0047294488,
-0.0492895879,
0.0162360817,
0.0369996466,
0.0010508847,
-0.013551808,
0.0136072859,
-0.0488999709,
-0.0224511269,
-0.0413496159,
0.0078037214,
-0.0526194051,
0.0087214187,
-0.0185653474,
-0.007515524,
-0.0288372077,
0.0048025488,
0.0140044205,
-0.0048458208,
0.0380506031,
-0.0161191337,
-0.0237619542,
0.0064456849,
0.0037865876,
-0.0070381262,
-0.0432549231,
0.0326019078,
-0.0032832173,
-0.0844295025,
-0.0087356437,
0.0089874156,
0.0182422511,
-0.0622915328,
0.0168505739,
0.0157657787,
0.0221588425,
-0.0232830998,
-0.0174976625,
-0.0119153429,
-0.0093212137,
-0.0500378199,
-0.0026321914,
-0.0892169401,
0.0304701608,
0.0189447924,
0.0325016379,
-0.0540006161,
-0.015603709,
0.0093812905,
-0.0492101796,
0.0533617921,
-0.0895466357,
-0.0005935202,
0.018921433,
-0.0259233303,
0.0332025588,
0.0723739043,
0.0369476601,
0.002438772,
0.0787655041,
-0.0154029001,
-0.0124999546,
0.0562760606,
0.04736913,
0.0151711544,
-0.0026381607,
0.0124617172,
-0.0034109373,
0.01964554,
0.0445165746,
0.0451929048,
-0.0200011358,
-0.019342402,
0.0350421295,
0.0798383579,
0.0182721708,
0.021727331,
0.0415889509,
0.0159250759,
0.0263056383,
-0.0564497225,
-0.0357187092,
-0.0325811394,
-0.009105484,
0.0120477127,
0.0173458643,
0.0631030872,
-0.0142927812,
-0.0115702432,
-0.0477210656,
-0.0192463361,
-0.0049458514,
-0.0103802644,
0.0526805967,
0.003829085,
-0.01292603,
0.0800407454,
0.0671412647,
-0.0659388602,
0.032749109,
-0.0091815274,
0.0224595629,
0.0300195143,
0.0372614451,
-0.0491315387,
-0.0114196967,
-0.0165157132,
0.0427688733,
0.0406937152,
0.0562066212,
-0.0174065568,
0.002373293,
-0.0469802059,
-0.0042853691,
0.005180731,
0.0234136283,
0.0023573539,
0.0156105999,
-0.0029307429,
-0.0031760114,
-0.0571252033,
-0.0556486733,
0.0532235354,
-0.0403269529,
0.0053346101,
-0.0304745808,
-0.0375656933,
0.0336725041,
0.0325686969,
-0.0315912403,
0.0069220201,
0.051002197,
-0.0087309573,
0.0153044909,
0.0385499746,
-0.0348803438,
-0.0120778959,
0.0708042309,
-0.0263747498,
-0.0045037675,
0.0571925864,
-0.039569892,
-0.0388527997,
0.02621435,
-0.007545514,
0.0903407037,
-0.0394146107,
0.0286575891,
-0.0064228196,
0.0075334413,
0.0049896045,
0.0283353347,
-0.0129374731,
0.0131795323,
0.010573254,
-0.0185435694,
0.0094521651,
-0.0477994867,
-0.0393078439,
0.0147439446,
-0.0126274396,
0.0293700974,
0.0154179279,
-0.0094274078,
-0.0820044801,
0.0009544825,
-0.1102269441,
-0.0259064436,
-0.0395627171,
0.0287997145,
0.0228465348,
-0.0074632065,
-0.0354792513,
-0.0058223209,
-0.0109609775,
-0.0152476886,
-0.004646867,
0.015783824,
0.0214995258,
-0.0176332127,
0.0114534637,
-0.0580094531,
-0.0383156873,
-0.0156009346,
0.047530137,
0.0125162695,
-0.00755679,
-0.0152860507,
0.0130767273,
-0.0193321109,
0.0208581667,
0.0142390598,
-0.0396967866,
0.0028405124,
-0.0178088509,
0.0317885391,
0.007657873,
-0.0048451559,
0.0152541073,
0.0372538939,
-0.0260857381,
-0.0581109412,
-0.0074843168,
-0.0030998616,
-0.014344763,
-0.0494133793,
-0.0274520367,
0.0288601778,
0.0735321194,
-0.0238023102,
-0.0207595546,
-0.0486582629,
0.0167094506,
-0.0545043759,
-0.0255617984,
-0.0216228589,
0.0181057733,
-0.0310862493,
0.0440958515,
-0.0266389232,
-0.0462568589,
0.0446347184,
-0.0546500906,
-0.0056410292,
-0.0527942926,
0.0117772035,
-0.0276027117,
0.0099868886,
0.0169117078,
-0.0001142632,
0.0210795291,
-0.0131485146,
-0.0008970585,
0.0384782068,
-0.0068353699,
-0.0123224258,
0.0184637774,
-0.0206361953,
0.0330905467,
0.0015579116,
-0.0312816054,
-0.0208097026,
-0.0606504902,
-0.0629920512,
0.0177973695,
0.0301835444,
-0.0254687835,
-0.0331356153,
-0.0264646653,
-0.0160076842,
0.0517933741,
0.0158889201,
-0.0008462098,
-0.0030556335,
0.0235450137,
0.0431127474,
0.0049517299,
0.0246349629,
-0.0258990508,
-0.0262109246,
0.031727992,
0.0557250455,
-0.0075251805,
-0.0346909724,
0.0357677825,
0.0594370365,
-0.0602446869,
-0.0082501555,
-0.0002359333,
0.041349493,
-0.0257436596,
-0.0311725549,
0.1191496551,
0.0387099236,
-0.0597737357,
0.0007963714,
0.0004663614,
0.0247686971,
0.0250238348,
-0.0001232619,
-0.1044009626,
-0.0241096802,
0.0101431692,
0.0264831111,
0.0186472926,
-0.0345639996,
-0.002971014,
-0.1184839904,
0.0212393552,
0.0056930617,
-0.0406783298,
0.0187929217,
-0.0498061925,
-0.0189106017,
-0.0559950992,
0.0271882731,
0.0169666316,
-0.0304776616,
0.0216212459,
0.0355394632,
0.0015664266,
-0.0517499037,
0.0344144329,
-0.0598847792,
0.0643822476,
0.0479542986,
0.0451037921,
-0.024704691,
-0.0152400853,
0.0287804529,
-0.0169367343,
-0.0276233349,
-0.0182307661,
0.042072922,
0.0010953217,
-0.015210961,
0.003742181,
0.0435900502,
-0.0484254621,
-0.0250097942,
0.0100891739,
0.0777531788,
0.0234182123,
-0.0046394272,
-0.0143041508,
-0.0222423319,
0.0122091584,
0.0790103078,
0.0188120995,
-0.0429880954,
-0.019034313,
-0.0159041937,
0.0073589566,
-0.0465058945,
-0.0127859917,
0.0010334319,
-0.0247237999,
-0.0169134811,
-0.1016868129,
-0.0377898514,
0.0333204605,
0.0218333304,
0.0261165779,
-0.0126337316,
0.0252997614,
-0.014736319,
-0.0441424623,
0.0716267303,
-0.0336479396,
0.0062566618,
-0.1074939966,
-0.0577660948,
0.0168759208,
0.0153385112,
-0.0387080871,
-0.0122212525,
-0.0966680124,
-0.0701849833,
0.0449641496,
0.0466082506,
0.0238004047,
0.0326151922,
-0.012094466,
-0.0802380443,
0.047850363,
0.0375554934,
-0.0735373423,
0.0169130955,
0.0389152318,
-0.0192676689,
0.0048038643,
0.0258675572,
-0.0486937836,
0.0177420042,
0.0136386072,
0.0001039189,
-0.0147556514,
0.0047715767,
0.0233067069,
0.036357116,
0.069213964,
-0.0440203547,
-0.0142611088,
-0.0619398765,
0.0129755037,
-0.024192486,
0.0090625845,
-0.0381440297,
0.0321381427,
0.0301973149,
-0.0194109306,
-0.011325662,
0.0617286265,
-0.036560718,
0.0467808284,
-0.0552614443,
0.00778666,
0.0375446007,
0.0348167382,
0.0506016873,
-0.0110912826,
-0.002607805,
-0.0042784521,
-0.044253733,
0.0399069823,
-0.0467931852,
0.0001750768,
-0.0088560451,
0.0149840014,
-0.0006427743,
0.0450741909,
-0.0369250663,
-0.0128756007,
-0.0089379866,
0.023291016,
0.0709292218,
-0.0361439548,
0.10530065,
-0.0239965171,
-0.0243637059,
-0.0409042761,
0.0101886028,
0.0024093029,
-0.0154521493,
0.0122599034,
0.0018093104,
-0.053196799,
0.0026317909,
0.0968585759,
-0.0003989724,
0.0321997404,
0.0429362394,
0.0187391452,
-0.0026278985,
-0.0020513588,
-0.0031675296,
0.0234305337,
-0.0331037939,
-0.0316778161,
-0.0448812358,
-0.0690789521,
0.0060184482,
0.0129745007,
-0.0173370373,
0.0173397083,
0.037745256,
0.0652111247,
-0.0091037014,
0.0286063049,
-0.0354497209,
-0.0132603636,
-0.0043740994,
-0.0381107479,
-0.0052326252,
-6.494533555e-33,
0.0097571099,
0.0326257274,
0.0060705547,
-0.0259952899,
-0.0200595632,
-0.0094797108,
-0.0128264483,
-0.0074666212,
-0.016713256,
0.0165637955,
-0.0365308262,
0.0138771869,
0.0257151518,
0.0281202812,
0.0145566743,
0.0229291115,
0.043276649,
-0.0155826295,
-0.0272981785,
0.0137048485,
0.0545507185,
0.0350363106,
0.0594018959,
-0.0391461253,
0.0325293876,
-0.0098138163,
0.0102698011,
0.0105151264,
0.0146551123,
0.0567337945,
-0.0406240746,
0.0420427881,
0.0102191605,
-0.0093025863,
-0.0532990918,
0.0153245348,
-0.0746026114,
-0.0317917541,
0.0517494716,
0.0111934571,
0.0178646147,
-0.0182283781,
0.0352806225,
-0.0202278271,
-0.011556983,
0.0109611377,
0.0365938321,
0.0097815841,
-0.0134102842,
-0.0201655403,
-0.0619033612,
0.0264252182,
-0.0214331336,
0.0079852389,
0.053247638,
0.0211267434,
0.0189460255,
0.0357725732,
-0.0504178926,
0.0357687026,
0.0133656124,
0.036977075,
0.0650492236,
-0.0045540929,
0.0314490199,
0.0640060008,
0.0240523815,
-0.0089125223,
0.0226703901,
0.0537165254,
0.0572980158,
0.029390702,
0.022524979,
0.0696886778,
0.0398614518,
-0.0514453426,
-0.0579654202,
-0.0046010143,
0.0031703752,
0.0298551153,
-0.0225722361,
0.0165549908,
0.0034664518,
-0.0231798459,
-0.0416502059,
-0.0258607417,
-0.0225741379,
-0.0120818932,
0.0194290653,
-0.0119938534,
-0.0341620632,
0.0034421487,
0.0188790709,
-0.0294384118,
-0.0478330962,
0.0369528793,
0.0007499664,
0.0073459414,
-0.0115645388,
0.0454389602,
-0.0852495134,
-0.0295394305,
0.0049601588,
-0.0004528744,
0.0265891273,
-0.007750975,
0.0164350215,
0.0206740089,
-0.0420169048,
0.0173875112,
-0.0272447057,
0.0069692633,
0.012928552,
0.0038417489,
0.0552730337,
0.0420547314,
0.0189087987,
0.0188822057,
0.057258904,
0.0005321639,
-0.0440097749,
0.0110231573,
0.0031822654,
0.0192761663,
-0.0130992113,
-0.0268005952,
-0.0561690256,
0.0187313184,
0.0768836439,
-0.0466615036,
-0.0184311233,
-0.0036994698,
2.471e-7,
0.0612485893,
0.0556268431,
0.0426283926,
-0.0057917223,
0.0052779079,
0.0126713822,
-0.0276912842,
0.0465388261,
0.0199942421,
-0.0003066906,
-0.0298602637,
-0.0120887319,
0.053599529,
0.0488104932,
-0.0993838534,
-0.0240957942,
-0.0847462043,
0.0240890011,
-0.0756871179,
-0.0038178808,
-0.0051759407,
0.1093950421,
0.0188563708,
-0.0141934231,
-0.01259703,
-0.0499803387,
0.0465363599,
-0.0439770371,
0.0033224996,
0.0424270444,
0.0231989156,
0.0088396501,
0.0230469778,
-0.0164900497,
-0.0338473432,
0.0125770196,
-0.0089264382,
0.0366027579,
0.0046140254,
0.0018312667,
-0.0042917561,
-0.037533123,
-0.0325485505,
-0.0721200109,
0.0595380999,
-0.0286922529,
-0.0105206966,
-0.03858779,
-0.0248924959,
-0.0126536675,
0.017687751,
-0.046580527,
-0.0026168923,
0.0513450131,
0.0234329123,
-0.0038742959,
-0.032148771,
-0.0815423429,
-0.0448180623,
0.0094844578,
-0.0472763516,
-0.0585538261,
-0.0232731812,
-0.0085628647,
0.0184513927,
-0.0281147715,
0.0377151966,
2.170677281e-34,
0.0406937487,
0.0053552128,
0.0063126278,
0.0360328183,
0.0200549439,
-0.049381014,
0.0400507003,
0.0209966358,
-0.0290404577,
-0.0745821223,
-0.0001134214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00157v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00157v3 | Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges | 2024-01-31T20:26:32 | 2024-04-05T04:06:51 | Janice Ahn, Rishu Verma, Renze Lou, Di Liu, Rui Zhang, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for assessing the fundamental
cognitive capabilities of human intelligence. In recent times, there has been a
notable surge in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) geared towards
the automated resolution of mathematical problems. However, the landscape of
mathematical problem types is vast and varied, with LLM-oriented techniques
undergoing evaluation across diverse datasets and settings. This diversity
makes it challenging to discern the true advancements and obstacles within this
burgeoning field. This survey endeavors to address four pivotal dimensions: i)
a comprehensive exploration of the various mathematical problems and their
corresponding datasets that have been investigated; ii) an examination of the
spectrum of LLM-oriented techniques that have been proposed for mathematical
problem-solving; iii) an overview of factors and concerns affecting LLMs in
solving math; and iv) an elucidation of the persisting challenges within this
domain. To the best of our knowledge, this survey stands as one of the first
extensive examinations of the landscape of LLMs in the realm of mathematics,
providing a holistic perspective on the current state, accomplishments, and
future challenges in this rapidly evolving field. | [
-0.0276291668,
0.1076483428,
-0.0193784758,
0.0562469102,
-0.0814653262,
0.0205678754,
0.0115698082,
0.0306063127,
-0.024931442,
-0.0220510215,
0.0031612499,
-0.0237080548,
0.0064135399,
0.0094880257,
0.0099818967,
-0.0243000984,
-0.003930232,
-0.080416508,
0.0246685464,
-0.0209525507,
-0.0412114635,
-0.0050567244,
-0.014120671,
-0.001796736,
-0.0558823273,
-0.0740140676,
0.0299870223,
-0.0602928847,
-0.0063155359,
-0.018014865,
-0.0507085174,
0.0432740077,
0.028374197,
0.0424418934,
0.0000020615,
-0.0651092976,
-0.016998319,
0.0071094544,
-0.0489481725,
0.0020647303,
-0.0165312123,
-0.023458086,
0.0047026691,
0.0163453054,
-0.0769343898,
0.0139504978,
0.0015105624,
-0.0024939526,
0.0558402874,
0.0243808012,
-0.0000665484,
-0.0624417588,
0.0426863544,
0.0075214333,
0.0125895301,
-0.0377548747,
0.0467169471,
0.0332561769,
0.0336098485,
-0.0107149705,
-0.0206867773,
0.0289878547,
0.0380498059,
-0.0262384079,
-0.0605314225,
-0.0101080313,
-0.0304252673,
0.0251500923,
-0.0041171601,
0.0441575535,
0.0068852282,
0.0049085622,
0.0115294969,
0.0165471006,
-0.0020387503,
0.0373038165,
-0.0713909417,
0.0575846732,
-0.0066015688,
0.0004480905,
0.0014303151,
-0.0037641642,
0.0105640348,
0.0267938375,
-0.0686792433,
0.119578585,
0.0222854,
-0.0404595658,
-0.0275652595,
-0.0284408629,
-0.1085139439,
-0.0506269336,
0.0404382572,
0.0779522359,
0.0184960067,
0.0270087197,
-0.0282140691,
-0.0543409213,
-0.0261288602,
-0.0299490057,
0.0381490886,
0.0512305722,
0.0512011647,
0.0279493127,
0.0009206547,
0.0740619525,
-0.0197839439,
0.0101472009,
-0.0186562166,
0.0270701218,
-0.010359644,
-0.0274900291,
-0.0447358415,
0.0510178655,
0.0076434487,
0.0232864972,
-0.0402510911,
0.0186446216,
-0.0494550243,
0.0296113491,
-0.0151356077,
-0.0377818383,
0.0379162692,
-0.0410622805,
-0.0206320956,
-0.0252012201,
-0.027944874,
0.0166142099,
-0.0319957845,
0.0070769838,
0.0025177889,
0.0322040953,
-0.0153716803,
-0.034457922,
0.0305709373,
0.0837749168,
0.0500581674,
0.0127992732,
-0.0065012397,
-0.0310940947,
0.0168885551,
-0.1054505631,
0.006841281,
-0.0979809985,
0.0591828413,
0.0285823978,
-0.0419510193,
-0.0483790524,
0.0059466786,
0.0063940003,
0.0226221308,
0.0468031317,
0.0373604037,
0.0434616394,
0.0521300435,
-0.0182832181,
-0.001166741,
0.0216715485,
0.0491163544,
-0.0275813527,
0.0133346189,
-0.0000584843,
0.0064848829,
0.0563097522,
0.0160532687,
-0.0066997949,
-0.0353160873,
0.0090700844,
0.0261336118,
0.0451411717,
-0.0464951545,
0.0824411958,
-0.0130058629,
-0.0466676429,
0.0170862749,
0.0884691402,
-0.0209847651,
0.0059392238,
0.0308369305,
-0.0041527604,
0.0630176663,
-0.0072037484,
-0.0449549332,
0.0030520738,
-0.0504267439,
-0.0086107543,
-0.008502543,
0.032606028,
-0.0138294585,
-0.0790897608,
-0.0311528575,
0.0055029793,
-0.0202069059,
0.0150585463,
0.0992197692,
-0.0492230058,
0.0157395694,
0.0296966173,
-0.0129494956,
-0.0098586623,
-0.0143723721,
-0.0519614965,
0.0273389183,
-0.0190980323,
0.0443706475,
-0.0566980094,
-0.0244147144,
0.006589381,
0.0304080416,
0.0052874065,
-0.0023706923,
-0.004200662,
-0.0437488817,
-0.0049618874,
0.0125201875,
0.0048551792,
0.013805463,
-0.0192111414,
0.0276121646,
0.005015797,
-0.0082304012,
-0.0217037871,
0.0107634803,
0.0151508991,
-0.0434349179,
-0.0088039115,
-0.0035478068,
0.0035714835,
0.0203698259,
-0.0068893828,
0.0103762466,
0.050365001,
0.0319874026,
-0.0473360121,
-0.0161234643,
-0.0169540681,
-0.0294235554,
-0.0099690305,
0.0689948872,
-0.0400893278,
-0.0291878507,
0.0037506602,
-0.0280373562,
-0.0136660282,
0.0790604353,
-0.0454114676,
-0.0021667825,
-0.0187102258,
0.0413726754,
-0.0072379317,
-0.0264902189,
-0.0275748447,
0.0880583376,
0.0127475187,
0.0249927193,
0.0278107077,
-0.0135111185,
0.0161607992,
-0.0136532253,
-0.0101784067,
0.0019329692,
-0.01484136,
0.0195602886,
-0.0310697965,
-0.0017425549,
0.0131996386,
-0.0064953659,
-0.0038585069,
-0.0096901096,
-0.0032400701,
0.0665486604,
-0.0138700306,
-0.0641877502,
-0.0128002269,
0.0136958938,
-0.0218968503,
-0.0048299544,
0.0380569547,
-0.0043369029,
0.0230011214,
0.0197358411,
-0.0219058879,
0.0060082041,
-0.0414106548,
-0.0561317168,
0.0654527694,
0.011532899,
0.0321110897,
-0.044224225,
0.0376895741,
-0.0508415774,
0.0184688438,
-0.0190487672,
0.0473794602,
0.0169804152,
-0.0295855217,
0.0464911237,
0.0587768517,
-0.0150892232,
0.0305700488,
0.0178038795,
-0.0386822335,
-0.0282852445,
-0.0084490441,
-0.0283217654,
0.0181734581,
-0.0083321854,
-0.034573365,
-0.0116114365,
0.0642429367,
-0.0287172273,
-0.0331881568,
-0.0128175896,
0.0641631484,
-0.051917091,
0.0272393059,
-0.0363818295,
-0.0044566374,
-0.0003496425,
0.0638575181,
-0.0070411977,
-0.0374730267,
0.0478322431,
-0.0090935361,
0.0238634553,
-0.0567825772,
-0.0010182916,
-0.0946718082,
0.0425018258,
-0.0044529373,
-0.0075196396,
-0.0349542573,
-0.0223718956,
-0.0021497398,
-0.0104779834,
0.0203285422,
-0.0123717627,
0.0696099401,
-0.0394938253,
0.0331708975,
-0.0095059993,
-0.0492457822,
-0.012875597,
0.019775454,
-0.0155738192,
0.019483041,
0.0012714787,
-0.025999248,
-0.0382050276,
0.0383204073,
0.0160774272,
-0.0114971055,
-0.0319600776,
-0.0109160505,
-0.0148460353,
-0.0125430785,
0.0120701026,
0.0278043654,
0.05095293,
-0.0381717272,
0.0065046311,
0.0424089245,
0.0405277386,
0.0178840961,
0.013626718,
0.0360961892,
0.021152541,
-0.0406450108,
-0.0383049771,
0.0325725339,
-0.0181743894,
-0.0578808896,
-0.0029280195,
0.0815077573,
0.0518083982,
0.0005769522,
-0.0011826733,
-0.0651390702,
-0.0245685168,
0.0165986605,
0.0214939155,
-0.0799237117,
-0.0095270043,
0.0027791702,
-0.0391072035,
-0.0048964159,
-0.0487622805,
0.0000994151,
-0.1069815606,
0.0372270085,
0.0187434964,
-0.022312317,
-0.018179521,
-0.0299178176,
0.0230427552,
0.022024896,
-0.018454155,
-0.0035799027,
-0.0161918309,
-0.0036979138,
0.0275384746,
-0.0277705062,
-0.0179490093,
0.0134812249,
-0.0125443088,
-0.041631531,
-0.0045624753,
0.0449773446,
-0.0267083701,
-0.0671972483,
0.0011534974,
0.0449431799,
-0.0316904336,
-0.0113817891,
-0.0382136852,
0.0170510747,
0.0097529963,
-0.024499625,
0.0512531884,
-0.0649565533,
-0.0389247276,
0.0598907173,
0.1384682655,
-0.0244898126,
0.0130238486,
-0.0236987118,
0.0055310163,
-0.0508167148,
0.0636188388,
0.0039980793,
-0.0168941226,
-0.0582503341,
-0.03664371,
-0.0284017362,
-0.0241648871,
-0.0266576465,
0.0118005546,
0.0508475155,
0.0119458269,
-0.0130718779,
0.0152182737,
0.0679931417,
0.0217632614,
0.0193909705,
-0.0217475053,
0.0338902399,
-0.0042648623,
-0.030295467,
0.0164306797,
-0.0513028912,
0.0480750725,
-0.0613215193,
0.055974856,
-0.0031788477,
-0.031170452,
-0.0388774015,
0.0061350171,
-0.0957759321,
-0.035111431,
0.0010583969,
0.0166660864,
0.0225169882,
-0.041086413,
0.0081964592,
-0.0189583842,
0.0032574935,
0.0182719827,
-0.0321240798,
0.025911795,
-0.0020907714,
0.0271274224,
0.0036458587,
0.0248363167,
0.0329020843,
0.0233225487,
0.0077205165,
0.0400544368,
-0.0419020839,
-0.0245360378,
0.0190445185,
0.0592404343,
-0.0255235769,
0.0555042662,
-0.0155268973,
0.0119656418,
0.0062050158,
-0.0592955165,
-0.0210682768,
-0.054153759,
-0.0056294804,
-0.0254547149,
0.0029731228,
0.0110910591,
-0.0150252692,
0.0310051367,
0.0206599478,
0.0025396014,
0.0741848126,
-0.0338910632,
0.0031202876,
0.0489055514,
-0.0148740169,
0.0598532148,
0.0083431136,
-0.0221680496,
0.0563030131,
0.0032565037,
0.0569108874,
0.0294776764,
0.0218278151,
-0.0561747551,
-0.0266254414,
-0.0241999645,
-0.1053017527,
0.0277057644,
0.0436067656,
0.0454256274,
0.0429920293,
-0.0293907449,
-0.0466353856,
-0.0122132199,
-0.0093263835,
0.0057208291,
0.0479698926,
-0.0045216503,
0.0222193375,
0.0413729846,
0.0130812041,
-0.0440311953,
0.0370728411,
-0.0334087424,
0.0144954138,
0.0281111374,
-0.0010151984,
-0.0023801129,
-0.0316209123,
-0.0047121025,
-0.0215217639,
-0.0108279623,
0.0131336832,
-0.1045077369,
-0.0843024328,
0.0162927378,
-0.0020275533,
-0.025575595,
0.0039021568,
0.028041862,
0.0604494251,
-0.0175166875,
-0.0048806663,
0.0122594126,
0.0290768668,
-0.0680409819,
-0.0307746567,
-0.011278295,
-5.187166003e-33,
-0.0213200394,
-0.0773864537,
0.0465773754,
0.0207619183,
0.022084767,
-0.040326193,
-0.0003776422,
0.0518487059,
-0.0023112204,
-0.0080795735,
-0.0045712781,
0.0066303061,
0.0082392571,
0.0022330254,
-0.0039966861,
0.0056031025,
-0.0227533393,
-0.0310905501,
-0.018337775,
-0.0161553696,
0.0171851832,
-0.0406983234,
0.0376287177,
-0.0455850028,
-0.0150232846,
0.007982255,
0.0164545104,
0.0590409227,
-0.0601021871,
0.0747140124,
-0.0179534871,
0.0245574657,
0.0140291778,
-0.0054543577,
-0.0204867627,
0.0166775156,
-0.0331552811,
-0.0164223909,
0.023310978,
-0.004497366,
-0.0268567186,
-0.0536537245,
0.0202662516,
0.0290717892,
-0.0614136383,
-0.0220925193,
0.0248431042,
-0.0454274751,
0.009039606,
-0.0047425032,
-0.0268442165,
0.0424783826,
-0.0286238696,
-0.0012763885,
0.02187513,
0.0084219221,
-0.0353105702,
0.0131497309,
0.0000338141,
0.0357112102,
0.040436592,
-0.0082279593,
0.0478450879,
-0.0374783799,
0.0038241183,
0.0119244214,
0.0174880791,
-0.0452848263,
0.0034453587,
-0.0121404817,
0.032011345,
0.0663598254,
0.0692932606,
-0.0050150841,
0.0334214009,
0.0360849835,
-0.0544932336,
-0.0144923665,
-0.0043284795,
0.0314113833,
0.0486610569,
-0.0005337721,
-0.0296952352,
-0.0313721821,
-0.0413055494,
0.0467357971,
-0.0587788448,
0.0036229605,
-0.0025530492,
-0.0381171815,
-0.0033562204,
0.033492025,
0.0455647297,
-0.0476065837,
-0.0341453478,
0.0049648378,
0.0319057629,
0.0417299829,
0.0084060235,
0.0471296348,
-0.0485347472,
-0.0134851197,
-0.0369638726,
-0.0225587264,
0.0168998074,
-0.0013497607,
-0.009337984,
0.0010661762,
-0.011016475,
-0.0052146828,
-0.0352466628,
0.0060541579,
0.0461522192,
0.0333831534,
0.0508950092,
0.0243379679,
0.0239075869,
0.0233916603,
-0.0231284965,
-0.044052016,
-0.0049989396,
0.035017781,
-0.0121825375,
0.0377921611,
-0.0058603683,
-0.0135005256,
-0.0249603484,
-0.0188367665,
0.0325901248,
-0.0432272553,
0.0087473635,
0.0071350825,
2.604e-7,
0.037877243,
0.0615852401,
0.0193820689,
0.0278484002,
0.0241777431,
-0.0045979437,
-0.023416277,
-0.0438146517,
0.0144158676,
0.0245157667,
0.0039675329,
0.0800052732,
0.0264175087,
0.0444525592,
-0.0217791628,
0.0299203619,
-0.0159833301,
-0.0296211913,
-0.0841853619,
0.0364642777,
0.0757281035,
0.0433957838,
0.0151492674,
-0.0046247379,
-0.0327559263,
-0.0638664067,
0.0406204499,
-0.0110594137,
-0.0092723705,
0.0276902616,
-0.0062151365,
-0.0335176401,
0.018707782,
0.0346092843,
0.0295006093,
0.0231267177,
0.0266109593,
0.0629219785,
0.0295328144,
0.0354826041,
-0.0197207499,
-0.0159248877,
-0.0111723952,
-0.0098046958,
0.0649124384,
-0.0949950963,
-0.0818072781,
0.013518854,
0.0193098299,
-0.0467805453,
0.0004928331,
0.0020560105,
0.060929697,
0.0027947826,
0.0392005146,
-0.0261698999,
0.0314801745,
-0.0566602424,
0.0350813158,
0.0338423662,
-0.0725707933,
-0.0440668054,
-0.0423944928,
-0.005186189,
0.0405463688,
-0.0276444815,
-0.0180997923,
2.890823692e-34,
0.035542395,
-0.0026967945,
0.015451449,
0.0364818387,
0.0312596299,
-0.0042055189,
-0.0505067445,
0.0362931415,
0.0120359659,
-0.1032834724,
0.0048588542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00149v1 | The Impact of Language Adapters in Cross-Lingual Transfer for NLU | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | Jenny Kunz, Oskar Holmström | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modular deep learning has been proposed for the efficient adaption of
pre-trained models to new tasks, domains and languages. In particular,
combining language adapters with task adapters has shown potential where no
supervised data exists for a language. In this paper, we explore the role of
language adapters in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer for natural language
understanding (NLU) benchmarks. We study the effect of including a
target-language adapter in detailed ablation studies with two multilingual
models and three multilingual datasets. Our results show that the effect of
target-language adapters is highly inconsistent across tasks, languages and
models. Retaining the source-language adapter instead often leads to an
equivalent, and sometimes to a better, performance. Removing the language
adapter after training has only a weak negative effect, indicating that the
language adapters do not have a strong impact on the predictions. | [
-0.0182222649,
0.0252987109,
-0.007424511,
0.0380176008,
-0.0187424272,
0.0169365034,
0.0741624683,
-0.0367974639,
-0.0303527694,
-0.0178506132,
-0.0625972003,
-0.0416960195,
-0.0195659008,
0.0084148645,
-0.0267638303,
-0.0250546113,
0.0694543645,
-0.0263858233,
-0.0484121554,
0.0155844353,
-0.0253081713,
0.0080289226,
-0.0035586432,
0.0125267096,
0.0422618948,
0.0163588114,
-0.0203996059,
0.0056762975,
-0.0100188851,
0.0007731973,
-0.0283075422,
0.0328416005,
0.0246879421,
0.0456383079,
0.0000020665,
-0.0407902412,
-0.0425384976,
-0.0005456353,
-0.0618828349,
-0.0138758384,
0.0375980698,
-0.0625168756,
0.0214708988,
-0.0091984989,
-0.0117196338,
-0.0644698665,
0.0650263652,
0.0532597043,
0.014276376,
0.0782864764,
-0.0135752615,
-0.012075915,
0.0029370862,
-0.0240448769,
0.0276283845,
-0.0811280459,
0.0044097467,
0.0110655539,
-0.0063219606,
-0.0230425205,
-0.0445744991,
0.026149109,
0.0444200449,
0.0123274447,
-0.0240524523,
0.0048774187,
-0.0436246842,
-0.0247046817,
-0.0194337144,
0.0770312399,
-0.0509839728,
-0.0300972182,
-0.0440600775,
-0.0129861254,
-0.0116888909,
-0.0209857635,
-0.0646189973,
-0.0075264615,
0.0432995968,
0.0032707371,
0.0482525937,
0.009570702,
0.0592487045,
-0.0098099755,
-0.035847351,
0.0854896605,
0.0110372854,
0.0108612599,
0.0484845042,
0.0251889601,
0.0263979454,
-0.0407363288,
-0.0034057978,
0.0283716749,
-0.0050067571,
0.0214856099,
-0.0574826896,
-0.0513736531,
-0.0172596741,
-0.0291279182,
0.0558270924,
0.0690869987,
-0.0507915057,
0.0556776412,
-0.0677032918,
0.0406623855,
-0.0038852401,
0.0151860984,
-0.0498660579,
-0.0584429726,
-0.0695130825,
0.0124923568,
-0.0230712816,
0.0361696668,
-0.0359527506,
0.0143998442,
-0.0172126144,
0.006375988,
-0.009353471,
-0.0392076485,
-0.013436473,
-0.0169143286,
-0.0836977288,
-0.0235819481,
-0.0158495195,
0.0922152698,
-0.0207893811,
0.0289265029,
-0.0204397626,
-0.0576112717,
-0.0273983963,
0.0292375237,
0.0314115584,
-0.0519721694,
0.0348048843,
0.05182302,
-0.0300877467,
-0.0295553226,
-0.0211638007,
0.0201897118,
0.0050288709,
-0.0749620274,
0.0432563201,
-0.044238355,
0.0406792685,
-0.0181124993,
0.0212816428,
-0.0486848503,
-0.0212294608,
-0.0293762982,
-0.0173634533,
0.0888246149,
-0.0007383168,
-0.016039446,
-0.0237570591,
-0.0159029495,
-0.0081312126,
0.1076888517,
-0.0140983006,
0.008007721,
0.0117217572,
-0.0521485731,
-0.0222888179,
0.0151832821,
0.0086925365,
0.0130801108,
-0.0100755692,
0.0059564705,
0.0103866542,
-0.0117918076,
0.0481651947,
-0.0213594195,
-0.0174778551,
-0.0065411697,
0.0071741128,
0.0056004799,
0.0120750666,
0.0353382789,
0.0589511804,
-0.0352508239,
-0.0299435761,
0.045057375,
-0.0582870096,
0.0376261435,
-0.0072083515,
-0.014904215,
-0.0324996114,
0.0331645086,
-0.0509304665,
-0.0126603125,
0.0236286446,
-0.0161243826,
0.0309584662,
0.0170321036,
0.0744837597,
0.0357487164,
-0.030678248,
0.0710470751,
0.0425479636,
-0.0291051622,
0.0449892431,
-0.010388935,
-0.0017209586,
0.0156218223,
-0.0213135369,
-0.0063989917,
-0.0604057014,
-0.0085344063,
0.0309691317,
0.0199205931,
0.0513555855,
0.0014469798,
0.0891300589,
-0.0520526282,
-0.0273097046,
-0.043235641,
0.0039203893,
0.0585182384,
-0.0416398421,
0.031419348,
0.0212991722,
-0.0651375279,
-0.0334459841,
0.0168774314,
-0.0836286992,
-0.0311248265,
0.0482307188,
0.0278334133,
0.0055012177,
0.0065365611,
-0.0010516468,
-0.0343265645,
0.0119697778,
-0.0506864823,
-0.0034756784,
0.0421469398,
-0.0348482803,
-0.032560695,
0.0360507257,
-0.0250627734,
-0.0104180966,
0.0361853801,
-0.0206758026,
-0.0681390539,
0.0496172234,
0.0365856625,
0.0397705287,
-0.0276214331,
0.0167207588,
-0.0417163745,
0.0660715699,
0.0118631218,
0.0058990573,
0.0471535921,
-0.0160854273,
0.0072863712,
-0.0453087911,
0.0377947651,
0.0076626865,
-0.0437994152,
0.0273677353,
-0.042400036,
-0.0125375884,
0.0104590235,
0.0185007211,
-0.0297777392,
0.0183507428,
-0.0919129327,
0.0278567746,
-0.0349181667,
0.0126266424,
0.0273448713,
0.0466501638,
-0.002568223,
-0.0311017614,
-0.0274628401,
0.0156656429,
0.0059684692,
0.0199208707,
0.0039654104,
0.0125077246,
0.0208036024,
-0.0410886481,
-0.0127986688,
0.005460084,
0.0408782624,
-0.0237093531,
-0.0274188574,
-0.0162900947,
0.01845056,
-0.0332319587,
0.0145453736,
-0.0074650212,
-0.0321483202,
-0.0383772627,
-0.0083120605,
0.0180520155,
0.0431229174,
-0.0727096647,
0.020915674,
0.0748826489,
-0.0231602155,
-0.0431936532,
0.0308331661,
-0.0046170098,
0.0022934929,
-0.0544748493,
-0.0264832173,
-0.0067420015,
0.0694541335,
-0.0425209031,
-0.0266600922,
-0.0566285588,
-0.004680803,
-0.0006200685,
-0.0322320722,
-0.0110411085,
0.0292534009,
0.0218347609,
0.0441161133,
-0.0264954809,
-0.0047177253,
0.0389649346,
-0.0359151997,
-0.0184364431,
-0.0630826652,
-0.022847645,
-0.0567619652,
0.0198828653,
0.0094181951,
0.0021461933,
0.0131066041,
-0.0288244747,
-0.0469947457,
0.0014763261,
0.0190699957,
0.0150515288,
0.0379903242,
-0.0332160294,
-0.0004846583,
-0.0389299206,
0.0016908637,
-0.0337556675,
0.0015177132,
-0.0163050685,
0.0443369597,
0.0026685572,
0.0075422125,
-0.0777896419,
-0.0032508224,
0.0422853865,
0.0277091879,
-0.0006326017,
0.027635498,
-0.0327866301,
0.0154104596,
0.0255484898,
0.030211091,
0.0039855842,
-0.0099578174,
0.0367183797,
-0.0077862618,
0.0478793047,
0.0043905033,
-0.0435810797,
0.007708916,
0.0477136709,
0.0001339656,
-0.0351446271,
0.0158021543,
0.0645108595,
-0.0532345809,
0.0082452502,
0.0840442032,
-0.0186309721,
-0.0426790565,
-0.0181718189,
-0.0427854657,
-0.0032710603,
0.0242511164,
0.0354944877,
-0.0929217115,
-0.0537711047,
0.0085173966,
-0.033721488,
0.0395066701,
-0.0213927738,
-0.0185281988,
-0.1002048999,
0.0033049658,
-0.033209987,
-0.111371778,
-0.0201977585,
-0.0497502238,
0.0118070673,
-0.0219243951,
0.0469591729,
-0.0539041758,
0.009440355,
-0.0168187767,
0.0344963409,
-0.0187572893,
-0.0491915159,
-0.0043574362,
-0.0323163457,
0.0451581962,
0.0316483118,
0.0212738998,
-0.0539210923,
0.0166571625,
0.0310872272,
-0.0236795247,
-0.0037704671,
-0.0113499369,
0.0460410453,
0.0358208157,
-0.0254821274,
0.0678211674,
-0.0082885846,
-0.0544538721,
0.0099290162,
0.0044715605,
0.0948408544,
0.0118261827,
-0.0361549482,
0.0141139729,
-0.0160002094,
0.0093757259,
0.0648472905,
0.0248623714,
-0.0180902239,
-0.0339322127,
0.0069814846,
-0.0536473431,
-0.0705181286,
-0.019895101,
0.0250773598,
-0.0654362813,
-0.0337640606,
-0.0120578744,
-0.0722997785,
0.0463903733,
0.0503828637,
0.02523968,
0.0149088129,
-0.013686303,
-0.0060019018,
-0.0120087974,
0.0378497578,
-0.0299493484,
0.0052098092,
-0.0156167429,
0.006739533,
0.0072753625,
-0.018869523,
0.0172865596,
0.0047587231,
-0.0518886931,
-0.0301990788,
0.0038402476,
0.0320225805,
0.0134680774,
0.0763289705,
-0.0127116069,
-0.0319802873,
-0.0074455915,
-0.0089051863,
0.0255618691,
-0.0069534271,
0.0492659099,
-0.0320113637,
0.0003509732,
0.0615658201,
-0.0166016296,
0.0141906952,
0.0558452792,
0.0173485409,
-0.0132010002,
0.0180629082,
0.0049478956,
0.0045739543,
0.0270833187,
0.0087161073,
-0.0230160095,
-0.0196876805,
0.0266836472,
-0.0136150019,
-0.007163363,
-0.0225770399,
-0.0297004953,
0.0542166345,
0.0030360441,
0.0316828191,
0.0353476815,
-0.0195000395,
0.0450448543,
-0.0168666486,
0.0331919082,
0.0537137128,
0.0245233905,
-0.0195997059,
0.0389386229,
-0.0082456097,
-0.0047243908,
0.0549262539,
0.0501156449,
-0.0495613553,
-0.0052654278,
0.0010617466,
0.0181246102,
-0.0355249383,
-0.019047942,
-0.0550170876,
-0.0296318047,
0.0055736252,
-0.0091470126,
0.0211508218,
-0.0567659624,
0.0668443143,
0.0207843259,
-0.0020424067,
-0.0360602699,
0.0230858307,
-0.0079645971,
0.0059901699,
0.0238024108,
-0.0047026542,
0.0033537699,
0.021293737,
0.0714224279,
0.0125093814,
0.0598269887,
0.0157938171,
0.029159084,
-0.016505437,
0.0022857469,
0.0514294989,
0.0071509043,
-0.0171822663,
0.0150223607,
-0.0140239354,
-0.0505199283,
0.0319454744,
-0.0637673214,
-0.0012837164,
0.0118837655,
-0.0012942827,
0.0688909143,
-0.0012108629,
-0.0068180831,
-0.007474279,
0.027215708,
0.0212657489,
0.0114495102,
-0.0098986803,
-6.443666975e-33,
-0.0185497664,
0.0248417836,
0.015285844,
-0.0189297553,
0.0161830857,
-0.0022804227,
-0.0400688238,
0.0012927694,
-0.0386771671,
0.009690417,
-0.0024917824,
0.0028853698,
0.0356729291,
0.0330027938,
-0.0011063648,
-0.0525590964,
0.0510340035,
0.022890145,
-0.0161118265,
0.0184569545,
0.0366697609,
0.0649560392,
0.1134169176,
-0.0332095698,
0.0257016458,
0.0530836172,
0.0385274142,
0.0048086541,
0.0448848382,
0.0319819301,
-0.0032203691,
0.0692759156,
0.0439414456,
-0.0545501113,
-0.0219237003,
-0.0168708637,
-0.0894372091,
-0.0349648893,
0.03926621,
0.0526240021,
-0.0141584994,
-0.0354137048,
0.0195318237,
-0.0048349081,
0.0479844585,
-0.0418867469,
0.0299617853,
-0.0296664033,
-0.0285611339,
0.0176238474,
-0.1069305241,
-0.0082412148,
-0.0297355093,
0.0017754725,
0.0633797944,
0.098142229,
-0.0153924366,
0.002170692,
-0.0589531846,
0.0012710474,
-0.0419936962,
0.0431061499,
0.0604008064,
0.0008695932,
-0.0393326655,
0.0248774216,
0.0512620658,
0.0080575375,
0.0071535055,
0.0119774714,
0.0603222251,
0.0376923904,
0.0220769662,
0.0809551626,
0.0653289035,
-0.0019862175,
-0.0729269385,
0.0252800602,
0.0143270167,
0.035358686,
-0.01091458,
0.0195276868,
0.0149458796,
-0.0082681514,
-0.0372990109,
-0.0401092619,
-0.0306312274,
-0.051916182,
-0.0040330337,
-0.027674336,
-0.0436376706,
0.0114049735,
0.0816187784,
-0.0554399975,
0.0037154946,
0.0166919082,
0.0034644366,
-0.010402387,
0.015781194,
0.0299021862,
-0.0502294153,
-0.0459035449,
0.0085086264,
0.0096562374,
0.0273427162,
-0.017406309,
0.0658730417,
0.0145824123,
-0.0333914682,
-0.0258100946,
-0.0594366528,
-0.0091571957,
0.0211569406,
0.0921798572,
0.0067585246,
0.0299512073,
-0.0253296923,
0.0290993657,
0.025250474,
-0.0140682114,
-0.0107749961,
-0.0039762231,
0.0102130417,
0.0163461249,
-0.041784659,
-0.0262814444,
-0.0364369266,
-0.0281746499,
0.0179390833,
-0.0605529733,
-0.0172473639,
0.0176949352,
2.72e-7,
0.0450859442,
0.0056977947,
0.0145538719,
-0.0429793857,
-0.0003203064,
0.029866077,
-0.033534728,
0.008555647,
0.0102229584,
0.0009849934,
-0.010127184,
0.0370819084,
0.05313389,
0.035932079,
-0.0404403582,
-0.0073549543,
0.0176882688,
0.0090884492,
-0.0054069525,
0.0026319176,
-0.0065910793,
0.09634763,
-0.0293040164,
-0.01799611,
0.0083105592,
-0.0207167454,
0.0438526683,
-0.0314331837,
-0.0337463394,
0.0140860155,
-0.001423971,
0.0148646794,
-0.0090825493,
0.0394247547,
-0.0304987673,
0.0435239077,
0.0285111293,
0.0216939803,
0.0129507147,
-0.0271976925,
-0.0089876568,
0.018833138,
-0.0040653739,
-0.0367655493,
0.1027497128,
-0.049966231,
-0.0386417061,
-0.0403606258,
-0.0406391621,
0.0474859886,
0.0330642797,
0.0017208913,
-0.0126106031,
0.0311168674,
0.0459609181,
-0.0359268226,
-0.0724502504,
-0.005422459,
-0.0076071811,
0.0147256721,
-0.0319373608,
0.0069589727,
-0.0137633383,
-0.0525563844,
0.0325429887,
-0.0576261096,
0.0200613271,
2.064474351e-34,
0.0118572814,
0.0352060348,
0.0357976407,
0.0126358261,
0.0054033836,
-0.0364711173,
-0.0514587425,
-0.0042295814,
0.0006013203,
-0.0640767142,
-0.0020328392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00898v1 | An Early Categorization of Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | Sippo Rossi, Alisia Marianne Michel, Raghava Rao Mukkamala, Jason Bennett Thatcher | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models and AI chatbots have been at the forefront of
democratizing artificial intelligence. However, the releases of ChatGPT and
other similar tools have been followed by growing concerns regarding the
difficulty of controlling large language models and their outputs. Currently,
we are witnessing a cat-and-mouse game where users attempt to misuse the models
with a novel attack called prompt injections. In contrast, the developers
attempt to discover the vulnerabilities and block the attacks simultaneously.
In this paper, we provide an overview of these emergent threats and present a
categorization of prompt injections, which can guide future research on prompt
injections and act as a checklist of vulnerabilities in the development of LLM
interfaces. Moreover, based on previous literature and our own empirical
research, we discuss the implications of prompt injections to LLM end users,
developers, and researchers. | [
0.0251451693,
0.0497011542,
-0.0017310443,
0.0573625378,
-0.0322197787,
-0.0205599982,
0.028306907,
0.0025394852,
0.0674020797,
-0.0270464607,
-0.0133544328,
0.010123047,
0.0064553646,
0.0371133089,
0.0601196401,
-0.0034403529,
0.0623220801,
-0.0410755873,
-0.0326079391,
-0.0101181315,
-0.0362898596,
-0.0139517924,
-0.001528897,
0.066564694,
-0.0113606174,
-0.0346009172,
-0.0314287208,
0.0387127995,
-0.0130331442,
-0.0155775258,
-0.0171642229,
-0.0006667338,
0.0058009475,
0.0393701047,
0.0000019974,
-0.0496205725,
-0.0015697203,
0.0492526554,
-0.077155754,
0.0161388777,
-0.01388078,
0.0152408443,
-0.0444003008,
0.040100988,
-0.0015001986,
0.0303968843,
0.0240008533,
0.0103595452,
0.0749690384,
0.0728117079,
0.0032156487,
0.0560647659,
0.0642782673,
0.0105234701,
0.0272624809,
-0.02327515,
0.0075466195,
-0.0522014089,
0.0458509922,
0.049807217,
0.0089104334,
-0.006187134,
0.0303749517,
-0.0310922675,
-0.0393106863,
0.0326235853,
-0.0070196437,
-0.0405374467,
-0.0441071764,
0.0181203336,
-0.0154990274,
0.0229714829,
0.0187043492,
0.0143004032,
0.0235987324,
0.0217342656,
0.0014985561,
0.0368933268,
-0.0146513432,
-0.0239742771,
0.026684029,
-0.0484625548,
0.023600556,
-0.0133643914,
-0.0259668902,
0.0562965721,
0.0474846177,
-0.0175472852,
-0.0042076055,
-0.0488621071,
0.0248684566,
-0.0832371786,
-0.0520735607,
0.0377528258,
-0.0369547009,
0.0230936911,
-0.0573048927,
0.0092596011,
0.0297872107,
-0.0272729397,
0.0046683336,
0.0650694594,
-0.0258675702,
0.0218794625,
0.0248926766,
0.0590984114,
-0.029952066,
0.0497404262,
0.0502804443,
0.0195869692,
0.0067390092,
-0.0217964277,
-0.0142235681,
0.0267732274,
-0.0112073179,
0.0221393574,
0.0072313515,
0.0996732414,
-0.015660692,
0.0687258989,
-0.0576297343,
-0.02614999,
0.0050656982,
0.0154631976,
0.0076269698,
-0.0532677248,
0.0083452407,
-0.0344012491,
0.008016577,
-0.1294748783,
-0.0200246926,
0.010743008,
-0.0620407425,
-0.0095606139,
-0.0070530525,
0.1166545451,
0.0192491896,
-0.0178970732,
-0.0208187476,
-0.0988111943,
-0.0102236466,
-0.0239203926,
-0.0100213708,
-0.0527754948,
-0.0170704573,
-0.0090510333,
-0.0316108689,
-0.0611855201,
-0.0024802545,
0.0203632917,
-0.0392023623,
0.0573615506,
-0.0457731895,
-0.0159782115,
0.0346084572,
0.0507996939,
-0.0387445465,
0.0305538084,
-0.0000995564,
0.0388126485,
0.0345650539,
-0.0163812786,
0.0733871683,
0.0420092903,
-0.0292946175,
0.0456890315,
0.0017904949,
0.0187815744,
0.0532782264,
-0.0019153237,
-0.0268768538,
0.0548029244,
-0.0016551379,
-0.0228321273,
0.0796478838,
0.0817670971,
-0.0553401634,
-0.0050418004,
0.0222596321,
0.0091089439,
0.0043790257,
0.0137214009,
-0.0766499415,
-0.0221325736,
-0.0653470978,
-0.0121405059,
-0.0082878014,
0.0246387068,
-0.001526891,
-0.0239854045,
0.0092480155,
-0.0252320301,
-0.0269090366,
0.0060165524,
0.0083300248,
-0.0030583364,
0.0093868207,
0.0259509943,
-0.0004729304,
-0.0406372435,
-0.028653875,
-0.102462709,
-0.0122042503,
0.0606716499,
0.0660575107,
-0.0189846586,
-0.0425894,
-0.01134123,
0.0070178839,
0.0404155664,
0.0311390646,
0.0281693619,
-0.0260179993,
0.0241432041,
-0.0139877442,
-0.0048812944,
0.0011764998,
0.0453219824,
-0.0238975063,
0.0109842392,
-0.0270245317,
0.0140359271,
-0.0030321844,
0.0241962709,
-0.0232641697,
-0.0726237074,
-0.0266690273,
0.0427269861,
-0.014099638,
0.0170571581,
-0.0098295165,
0.0139513314,
0.0605818182,
0.0199694745,
-0.0143986149,
-0.0176471956,
-0.0155696729,
0.0369922891,
0.0504204519,
0.0111424522,
-0.0282475296,
0.0118825473,
-0.0173063744,
-0.0184332952,
0.0282351486,
-0.0334191583,
0.0469207875,
0.0042076432,
0.0177929197,
-0.0072459891,
0.0176199786,
-0.0375425071,
-0.0125725828,
0.0068707336,
-0.0107878149,
0.0375016481,
0.0627184585,
-0.0096659493,
-0.040192157,
-0.0533015057,
0.0565677136,
-0.0065248888,
0.0169356521,
-0.0088271741,
0.0235616062,
-0.0056206053,
-0.0319908261,
-0.0583259463,
-0.0073252171,
-0.0036312423,
0.0333378538,
0.0144353397,
0.0342234932,
-0.0499881282,
-0.0142111229,
-0.0223778579,
-0.0264323037,
-0.0125462571,
0.0368551388,
0.0472914316,
-0.0183592904,
-0.0537124686,
-0.0008346002,
0.0153781269,
-0.0367754214,
0.0453087687,
-0.0234339181,
-0.0550150909,
-0.0493518189,
0.0570977591,
-0.0112466328,
0.0066033076,
-0.0261226445,
-0.0318346135,
0.0351746865,
0.0096157473,
0.0086524487,
0.068932265,
0.0044415975,
0.0693203732,
0.0579506233,
0.0095078377,
-0.0589029044,
-0.0165670309,
0.0565039851,
-0.0512322932,
-0.0266689714,
-0.0026626585,
0.0500345007,
0.0453035422,
0.0089037241,
-0.0053688935,
-0.0138803506,
0.049365934,
0.013592694,
-0.0299531538,
0.0042089885,
-0.0536105037,
-0.0713749602,
0.0428952351,
0.0056229951,
-0.0876352489,
0.0520256832,
-0.0956582129,
-0.0040140534,
0.0088236583,
-0.0473211929,
-0.0105306264,
0.0258123912,
-0.032612972,
-0.0115018506,
0.0440928377,
-0.061026372,
-0.0499642566,
-0.005321878,
0.0170511417,
-0.0298405737,
0.0376267806,
-0.0249675941,
-0.0257484801,
-0.0415692329,
-0.0423169322,
-0.0426236689,
-0.0565521382,
-0.0136884507,
-0.0273019187,
0.0201640129,
-0.0297282673,
0.0218130071,
-0.0317119472,
0.0220059436,
-0.0154307764,
-0.0049207471,
-0.0250463691,
-0.0476119108,
-0.034611702,
0.0159986038,
-0.004453938,
-0.0119258957,
0.0115398951,
0.052879855,
0.0692499727,
0.014620238,
-0.0136253666,
-0.0234785508,
-0.0098886946,
0.0344062299,
-0.0238796808,
-0.0031312618,
0.0469367504,
0.0406344756,
-0.0406589061,
-0.0070201834,
0.0573226325,
0.0166749507,
-0.0588212498,
0.0063692387,
-0.0231367704,
0.032814417,
0.036770463,
0.038754303,
-0.1103726327,
-0.002241838,
0.0467406847,
0.0410565436,
-0.0253617316,
-0.0110278092,
-0.0251387227,
-0.1213586181,
0.0354631431,
-0.0031017857,
-0.0133719016,
-0.0153055713,
-0.0164275374,
0.0085846744,
0.0572616383,
0.0633976609,
-0.0161146112,
-0.0056482037,
0.009421018,
0.0194893386,
-0.0476392657,
0.0052519864,
-0.0073741977,
-0.0312287826,
0.0856232867,
0.0442022309,
-0.0102197966,
-0.0097360071,
0.0420799591,
0.0910998136,
0.0212207716,
-0.012974388,
0.0125111714,
0.0133180339,
0.0099611655,
-0.0158433635,
0.0224046968,
0.0119445082,
-0.0241432916,
-0.0109776305,
0.0348614752,
0.0487312116,
-0.0665924326,
0.0261446759,
-0.0245451573,
-0.0271622837,
0.0344387479,
0.0381461643,
0.0351360738,
-0.0358624794,
-0.0151821729,
-0.1000672802,
-0.0106854979,
0.0363594331,
-0.0576237366,
0.0124813467,
-0.0003436174,
-0.0512818806,
-0.0283883996,
-0.0269815437,
-0.0005600948,
0.0111707794,
0.0586882979,
-0.0092488341,
-0.0221941192,
0.0175867714,
0.0286819004,
-0.0024277247,
-0.0461638011,
0.0282701235,
-0.0565381274,
0.0523271263,
-0.0051550162,
-0.0375388563,
0.0084964857,
0.0141717996,
-0.0215831622,
-0.0906895548,
0.0068277493,
0.0570321605,
0.0310057867,
-0.0011718897,
-0.0333155245,
-0.0250596628,
0.0556780547,
0.0427947752,
-0.0227973312,
0.0334579013,
0.05004365,
0.0486916862,
0.0197566263,
0.0006781098,
-0.0504761413,
-0.0490526408,
0.0569274463,
-0.0307198446,
-0.0511653051,
-0.0695959851,
0.0055859778,
0.0599025227,
0.0294825695,
-0.0044174115,
0.0356834158,
0.0114720762,
0.0181843583,
-0.0428958945,
-0.0109110652,
-0.0096733067,
0.0004224051,
-0.0568995364,
-0.0064865458,
0.0457375422,
-0.0169803444,
0.0026672471,
0.0564382374,
0.0050586485,
0.0456548966,
0.021873273,
0.0319491066,
0.0436661541,
0.0268627778,
0.0062645441,
0.0683404803,
0.0171605572,
0.0309988614,
0.005171556,
0.0422733799,
0.0016990933,
-0.0024511141,
0.0029606128,
0.0408131815,
-0.0829443783,
-0.0989854485,
0.0747744367,
0.0682825521,
0.0119617209,
0.0481119938,
-0.027815586,
0.0030785855,
0.0044153477,
-0.0220712088,
-0.0318513699,
0.0098102251,
-0.0219225679,
0.0088560581,
-0.0157414787,
-0.0149426684,
-0.0081338082,
0.0487220697,
-0.0019650022,
0.0591332242,
0.0131358551,
-0.0287697837,
-0.0424244404,
-0.0095744049,
0.0511994399,
-0.0234838035,
-0.0212432779,
-0.0667827353,
-0.0666962266,
-0.0684238821,
-0.0087718107,
-0.0072357957,
0.0007836858,
0.0018819105,
-0.0033251087,
0.0420580395,
0.0405439623,
0.0141202267,
-0.0536919981,
0.0238010343,
-0.0208461378,
-0.0691945404,
0.0337068774,
-5.265691597e-33,
0.0065389937,
-0.0601221323,
-0.0066267261,
0.0302326195,
0.0043374444,
0.0098690158,
-0.0107779223,
0.0261060968,
-0.0216156524,
-0.0279523134,
-0.034054786,
-0.0102957301,
0.0205990076,
-0.0079887481,
-0.0040707807,
-0.0185301173,
-0.0101156635,
0.0092905862,
-0.0215813741,
0.0187035445,
0.0426779687,
0.0007428501,
-0.0024039596,
-0.0380432755,
0.0447830036,
-0.019595949,
0.001000676,
0.0009321306,
-0.0243113991,
0.038543839,
0.0103521841,
0.0155891832,
-0.0134731475,
-0.0246566348,
-0.0060405382,
0.0800548792,
-0.0032229598,
-0.0427231304,
-0.0119699389,
0.0050182012,
0.0092982706,
-0.091470018,
0.0087653194,
-0.0338926502,
-0.0244780052,
0.0146470144,
0.0141609963,
-0.0102690607,
-0.0171756689,
-0.0207967721,
-0.0182649847,
-0.018643124,
-0.0232740119,
0.0041158111,
-0.0018767953,
-0.0046648807,
0.0339303426,
-0.0086092036,
-0.0195829533,
0.0308586154,
0.0134898443,
0.0075889886,
0.0553215705,
0.0147094652,
-0.0004341517,
0.0367555246,
0.0287473071,
0.0009592142,
-0.0189676154,
-0.001112117,
-0.010219451,
0.022715928,
0.0104909856,
0.0260471348,
-0.0214984249,
-0.0199866183,
-0.0209291596,
0.0205708276,
0.0505466498,
0.0214391965,
0.0140408576,
-0.0051606358,
-0.0733903497,
-0.0109789437,
-0.010777072,
-0.0057505756,
-0.0251377765,
-0.0308094416,
0.0110933715,
-0.0391180255,
0.0306717176,
-0.0592499897,
0.0136869214,
-0.0469718538,
0.0061107138,
-0.0372777618,
-0.0020945498,
-0.0336132683,
-0.0087396922,
0.0069466219,
0.0330678597,
0.0009999231,
-0.0086489245,
-0.0520686507,
0.0494455472,
0.0084533086,
-0.0201627295,
0.0374504626,
-0.078184031,
-0.0192887876,
-0.0310663227,
0.0254503191,
0.0301698651,
0.0397458337,
0.0454298183,
-0.0542811044,
0.022122249,
0.0083141774,
0.030491367,
0.0101727154,
-0.0515292734,
0.026898725,
-0.0405386277,
-0.0083383145,
-0.0204469506,
0.0203232579,
-0.0314974114,
0.0925899968,
0.042021323,
-0.0502328016,
-0.006977703,
-0.0482648611,
2.808e-7,
-0.0158170145,
0.0264712945,
0.0329403505,
0.0510340966,
0.0240055658,
0.0571562424,
-0.0205185898,
0.0548268557,
-0.0049116649,
-0.0271285493,
-0.0186979715,
0.001826376,
0.0340118706,
0.0093454206,
-0.0839207172,
-0.0087061552,
-0.0439761989,
-0.0086477501,
-0.0876175538,
0.0114315609,
0.0601275451,
0.0519665144,
-0.0145332702,
-0.0404492952,
-0.0042184712,
-0.0615058839,
-0.009745473,
-0.0376647115,
-0.0353716239,
-0.0110038966,
0.0606827214,
0.0307823662,
0.033382941,
0.0469372831,
-0.0176513363,
-0.0281267297,
-0.0445650779,
0.0285534095,
0.0337221846,
-0.0168261789,
-0.0117105097,
-0.0588754527,
-0.0058860183,
-0.0183601603,
0.0426625125,
0.0153923258,
-0.0271079689,
-0.0180240814,
0.0019627558,
-0.0792400017,
0.0200286843,
-0.0341663547,
0.0056610587,
0.0146160899,
-0.0002157584,
-0.0011581776,
0.0306259375,
-0.0393000431,
-0.0221607815,
-0.0308254603,
-0.0315313824,
-0.0707463846,
0.0049551888,
0.0311393421,
0.0087442538,
-0.0128085176,
-0.008864182,
3.000536345e-34,
-0.0300495848,
-0.0347422995,
0.0342458151,
0.0292720981,
0.0334523432,
0.0333674625,
0.0203398149,
0.0257675033,
0.0321564525,
-0.0235258173,
-0.0285337623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00143v1 | Making a Long Story Short in Conversation Modeling | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | Yufei Tao, Tiernan Mines, Ameeta Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Conversation systems accommodate diverse users with unique personalities and
distinct writing styles. Within the domain of multi-turn dialogue modeling,
this work studies the impact of varied utterance lengths on the quality of
subsequent responses generated by conversation models. Using GPT-3 as the base
model, multiple dialogue datasets, and several metrics, we conduct a thorough
exploration of this aspect of conversational models. Our analysis sheds light
on the complex relationship between utterance lengths and the quality of
follow-up responses generated by dialogue systems. Empirical findings suggests
that, for certain types of conversations, utterance lengths can be reduced by
up to 72% without any noticeable difference in the quality of follow-up
responses. | [
0.0746681318,
0.0161773879,
-0.0316595994,
0.0149119357,
-0.0357325673,
-0.0130950566,
0.0147099318,
-0.0109805204,
-0.0251820255,
-0.0266373027,
-0.0040454403,
-0.0547008216,
0.0154811274,
0.0507332347,
-0.000575094,
-0.0895006731,
0.0091944309,
-0.018663913,
0.050840117,
0.0006168163,
0.0432379432,
0.0114104655,
-0.0156013081,
0.0633535981,
-0.012366714,
-0.018705612,
-0.0568885095,
0.0151142739,
-0.0257760379,
0.0036780797,
0.0351144485,
0.0737987533,
0.0043458594,
0.0464836545,
0.0000017552,
-0.0450331718,
0.0244851504,
-0.0277814288,
-0.0304785334,
0.0496014468,
0.0070581622,
0.0412483364,
0.0038977521,
0.0401760563,
-0.0388628989,
0.0078134527,
0.0432846211,
0.0699082911,
0.0626400411,
0.0530839562,
-0.0092956545,
-0.0003894896,
0.021482829,
-0.0273047946,
0.0035154046,
-0.0403294228,
-0.0218609944,
0.0323453732,
0.0200696904,
0.0174467117,
-0.0024834147,
0.0233267061,
0.0052949348,
-0.0202737171,
-0.0113414396,
-0.0004110671,
-0.0131544424,
-0.0030654878,
-0.0092306128,
0.0614757761,
0.0537852272,
0.0077851526,
-0.005178554,
-0.0185314566,
0.0273593366,
-0.0391360149,
-0.0707154796,
-0.0157116167,
-0.0103647867,
-0.0500479676,
-0.0717301741,
0.0140117202,
-0.0330406204,
-0.0209229346,
-0.0172652919,
0.0222061481,
-0.0061243228,
-0.0388863906,
-0.0706174523,
-0.0120395441,
0.0488812588,
-0.0643610954,
-0.0068136929,
0.0020599861,
-0.0582577325,
0.0196237937,
-0.0270371884,
0.036873363,
0.037909206,
-0.0165514387,
0.021452697,
0.0278785005,
0.0315685235,
-0.0086720949,
0.049289614,
0.0245110914,
-0.0143571524,
-0.0222369935,
-0.0064104204,
-0.0026895686,
-0.0531856865,
-0.0344293341,
-0.0176500082,
0.0115744593,
-0.0402184464,
-0.0371599272,
-0.0267811697,
0.0490199737,
0.040547248,
-0.0100270007,
0.0205834191,
0.0239662565,
-0.0128268432,
-0.0088614244,
-0.0382939503,
0.046415627,
-0.0391450375,
0.0112967081,
0.0349969491,
-0.0599345155,
0.0033939369,
0.0141151026,
0.0180078391,
-0.0193626005,
-0.0202361699,
0.0596812293,
-0.005650003,
-0.0291563962,
0.0207675155,
-0.0256686192,
-0.047066126,
-0.0838248581,
-0.0322456509,
-0.0334647633,
0.0250683837,
0.0333810598,
-0.025129661,
-0.0067795827,
0.0003657872,
0.0232377686,
-0.0343406014,
0.0072703422,
-0.0024983268,
0.0553575829,
0.0595129505,
0.0116291558,
0.0140121337,
0.0278246216,
0.0746256113,
-0.0094397403,
0.0662336573,
-0.0494099185,
0.050168097,
0.0425779819,
-0.010333579,
0.0098615242,
0.0366872661,
0.0353214704,
-0.0072132568,
0.0284959488,
0.0074062105,
0.054718174,
-0.0306676142,
-0.0238295402,
0.1020493582,
0.0740480274,
0.015133353,
0.0396039449,
0.0457929634,
0.0414324552,
0.0145931868,
0.0640826523,
-0.0148074077,
0.0063560498,
0.0092326542,
0.045659814,
0.0512512848,
0.0261813458,
-0.0242244937,
-0.0340935923,
0.0035367208,
0.0150486249,
0.0099149747,
-0.0102925198,
-0.0145453392,
-0.0134209134,
-0.0587829612,
0.0317080878,
-0.0332624912,
-0.0868425891,
-0.0449336618,
-0.0372261442,
-0.0075703291,
0.1100058034,
0.0241754428,
0.0240085963,
-0.022622969,
-0.0481547341,
0.0041609309,
0.0447063893,
0.0569509789,
0.0045211702,
0.0455672182,
-0.0353883579,
0.0122342128,
0.0072922963,
-0.000465239,
0.0243487749,
0.0031949542,
0.0047347862,
0.0246605985,
0.0050501819,
-0.0033774071,
-0.0153724616,
-0.0498445965,
0.0007038331,
-0.0194835979,
-0.005088198,
0.0256588794,
0.0195859149,
-0.016105039,
0.0059546856,
-0.001067785,
0.0417357869,
0.0017041831,
0.0399837978,
-0.0486351252,
-0.0015229882,
0.0263576247,
-0.0126820626,
0.0005453233,
-0.0119443424,
0.0093919234,
-0.0554299355,
0.0129601452,
-0.0792117268,
0.0545899495,
-0.022309348,
0.0192308854,
0.0117255151,
0.019336259,
-0.0126733165,
-0.010951749,
-0.0103662042,
0.0151227005,
0.0036915911,
-0.0142452503,
0.0158639047,
-0.0767165571,
0.0139329117,
0.0332626179,
-0.0046805958,
0.0182372872,
0.0397168808,
-0.0110144168,
-0.0540759265,
-0.0437566154,
-0.1192188635,
0.0177757237,
-0.0102872597,
-0.0070436914,
0.0145389736,
0.0473808348,
-0.04036019,
-0.0152684906,
-0.0679002553,
-0.0495366827,
0.0604796,
0.0171024259,
0.0357055925,
0.0153587684,
-0.0355346315,
-0.0591309667,
-0.0067729931,
-0.0030103296,
0.0425444283,
-0.0184698403,
-0.0136991115,
-0.0361699015,
-0.0239413586,
-0.0317657255,
0.0078638019,
-0.0245728157,
-0.0649604201,
0.0157294068,
0.0226017889,
0.0736617371,
0.050839182,
0.0820794106,
0.0378735773,
-0.0430553891,
-0.0319869295,
-0.0278854594,
0.033176668,
-0.0267232247,
-0.0076714447,
-0.034013126,
-0.0575453229,
0.0367246494,
0.0378059112,
0.0257623028,
0.0425263457,
-0.0492821522,
0.017106628,
0.049249351,
-0.0355217978,
0.0293756183,
-0.0116257323,
-0.0431284495,
0.0528920554,
0.0038024958,
-0.0412987247,
0.0465468839,
-0.0483629704,
-0.0355106853,
-0.0089469654,
-0.0337272435,
-0.027281804,
0.0493942536,
-0.001014033,
0.0081846844,
0.0141189396,
-0.0215426348,
-0.0372487679,
-0.0208861865,
0.0447204523,
-0.0333801806,
0.0608901978,
-0.0133804074,
-0.0226875264,
0.0227145385,
-0.035622254,
-0.0034444353,
-0.0445526689,
-0.0315944217,
-0.0188053176,
0.0416778401,
-0.0504676029,
-0.0303484965,
0.0355646014,
0.0227390826,
0.0434649698,
-0.0532013103,
0.0185258109,
-0.0207044464,
0.0195903629,
0.0399343148,
0.0096126618,
-0.0021987017,
-0.0369276367,
0.0708184689,
0.0171470903,
0.0109428978,
0.0170832034,
0.01619469,
-0.0559016429,
-0.0048133172,
-0.0228009801,
-0.0640887395,
0.0380739681,
0.0770004168,
-0.043763753,
-0.0116996607,
0.1056937799,
0.0153372651,
-0.0071496242,
-0.0097017521,
-0.0367342122,
0.0870524421,
-0.0033690361,
0.0270513352,
-0.0343827643,
-0.0028327182,
-0.0052727601,
0.0150377257,
-0.0447615422,
-0.0059830537,
-0.031716805,
-0.1025269404,
0.0192607101,
-0.0086776353,
-0.0656598434,
-0.0061623785,
-0.0173519272,
-0.001386738,
0.0279720053,
0.0302769262,
0.0002399815,
-0.0206409749,
-0.0047876444,
0.001131685,
-0.0802788734,
-0.0113127511,
0.0047995332,
0.0064165774,
0.0629738048,
0.0684684664,
0.0428179502,
0.0284258407,
-0.0216318592,
0.013286869,
-0.0079214033,
0.0272739232,
0.0394274816,
0.06630072,
-0.0224444903,
0.0205294862,
-0.0675555915,
0.0362600982,
0.0104196146,
0.0193947516,
0.0473521836,
-0.0128908381,
-0.0387583598,
0.0009976025,
-0.038771309,
0.0500240028,
0.0350723453,
0.0595837533,
0.064457871,
-0.068208918,
-0.060639523,
-0.0407198891,
0.0002550962,
-0.0625712648,
0.0000849152,
-0.0255475603,
0.0020993913,
0.0083192727,
-0.0332433656,
-0.1025823802,
-0.0121402936,
-0.012008667,
-0.0315094329,
0.0194636676,
-0.0093198232,
0.0315075144,
-0.0064761145,
-0.0349058509,
0.006394458,
0.0261640847,
-0.0684328973,
0.0007909372,
0.0275269877,
-0.0374110229,
0.0118112052,
0.0007903789,
-0.0802176222,
-0.0564685762,
-0.0210290011,
0.0481504686,
0.0355689935,
0.0546624362,
0.0335258953,
-0.0369858369,
-0.0593198612,
-0.0158915147,
-0.0066384091,
0.0140448082,
0.0379412286,
0.0642643273,
-0.0059293392,
0.0148067363,
0.0095197819,
0.0065840273,
-0.0388082638,
0.0262350291,
-0.0407624617,
-0.113083303,
-0.0325823314,
-0.0059687621,
0.0154999644,
0.0355601944,
-0.0064031077,
0.0264011361,
0.0209388044,
-0.0619939715,
0.0114203747,
-0.0381427817,
-0.0097827902,
-0.036301408,
-0.0125868507,
-0.0081522074,
-0.026513312,
-0.0821656212,
0.0275137909,
-0.0408575721,
-0.0051766448,
-0.002622569,
-0.0354007408,
0.0123833437,
-0.0273989514,
-0.033988785,
0.0216198917,
0.020918848,
0.0162056964,
0.0336202569,
0.0879129693,
0.000643236,
-0.0307790823,
0.0484658442,
0.0564006418,
-0.0996932462,
-0.025243327,
-0.0150401341,
0.0282649603,
-0.0124436356,
0.003371346,
0.0603672676,
0.0054412419,
0.0431280248,
-0.0294770692,
0.0685708895,
0.0132958675,
-0.0184531901,
-0.0145652909,
0.0318306983,
-0.0415221788,
-0.0047614337,
0.0782532021,
0.0274795387,
0.0181221291,
-0.0168629009,
-0.029215198,
-0.0522218384,
-0.0330312476,
-0.0018482774,
0.0323482938,
0.027558608,
-0.0094820224,
-0.0721742362,
-0.0300720111,
0.0143484334,
0.0039458354,
0.0478911474,
-0.0424652956,
0.0244145039,
0.063664116,
-0.0074207415,
-0.0204150826,
-0.0264801029,
-0.0110597899,
-0.0255627036,
-0.0047787218,
-0.0283292104,
-5.503258638e-33,
-0.0036413295,
-0.043141976,
0.0191568527,
0.0208106413,
-0.0613508821,
-0.0393560641,
-0.0269921571,
0.0342841074,
-0.0018152571,
-0.0048342003,
-0.0543520115,
0.0462583713,
0.0039562569,
0.0352741666,
0.0026902761,
0.0019612638,
0.0643448085,
0.0095754033,
-0.0382951796,
0.0387043953,
0.0198010057,
-0.0005974499,
0.0040841047,
-0.0625059754,
0.0377101488,
-0.0543032922,
0.0024086891,
-0.0183906388,
0.0044356748,
0.0622411445,
-0.0112197679,
0.0433859453,
0.0294957478,
-0.0320047066,
-0.0212883838,
0.0364565961,
-0.0070666294,
-0.001046656,
0.0363381729,
0.0155483354,
0.0265034065,
-0.0221739803,
-0.0019331801,
-0.0168728251,
-0.0107318275,
-0.021141408,
0.0389656015,
-0.0050529847,
-0.0058599077,
0.0071305358,
-0.0372413509,
0.0181943793,
-0.0327693336,
-0.064855352,
-0.0419951975,
0.0824153349,
0.0173599031,
-0.0298673082,
-0.0224064961,
0.0374117382,
0.0001442698,
-0.0027270655,
0.0130864298,
0.027707886,
0.0146236354,
0.0155074261,
0.0270835776,
0.0462637134,
-0.046013277,
-0.0379603729,
-0.0078622615,
0.0296138544,
0.019914953,
0.0616165698,
-0.0188901275,
-0.0212088004,
-0.0052681076,
0.0226340108,
0.0070232973,
0.0089754257,
0.0173127893,
0.0036804054,
-0.0540559255,
-0.0298307035,
-0.0133470353,
-0.0098473411,
0.0024850033,
-0.0504898913,
0.0323480554,
0.0005111858,
0.0124942921,
-0.0246508047,
0.05202334,
-0.02897585,
-0.0285107493,
0.0116744535,
-0.0656794161,
0.0313850604,
-0.0064740023,
0.0095563168,
-0.0049149003,
0.013961615,
0.0220927875,
0.0554499067,
0.0058564912,
0.0133582326,
0.0002343721,
-0.0005521016,
-0.0703043044,
-0.0104348427,
0.0059978175,
0.053989742,
-0.0392782874,
0.0067512929,
0.0068785693,
0.0013766632,
-0.0362086222,
0.0817160755,
-0.0189682115,
-0.0032336835,
-0.0522655956,
-0.0602332875,
0.0096903797,
0.0142442668,
-0.0470298044,
-0.0080884257,
-0.0214472767,
-0.0220593661,
0.0159435496,
-0.0207239874,
-0.0157678947,
-0.0349038355,
2.406e-7,
-0.0077596372,
0.0515865535,
0.0545581765,
0.0062641264,
0.0426539406,
0.0451458842,
0.0340251476,
0.0111115547,
0.0265528988,
-0.0070624761,
0.0045419899,
-0.012752573,
0.0648260713,
0.0039328285,
-0.0839598849,
-0.0429399237,
-0.1092509478,
0.0037689921,
-0.0453668498,
0.0189286042,
0.0633249879,
0.0207585059,
0.0075101661,
0.0206172876,
-0.0103272991,
0.0176629107,
0.0333134718,
-0.0404954962,
-0.0130135491,
0.0182243399,
0.0456318855,
-0.0309111532,
0.0171447527,
0.0215850994,
-0.0032289647,
0.0254691858,
0.0109629435,
0.0757292882,
-0.0097112628,
-0.0441864133,
0.0072607519,
-0.004380079,
-0.0167444404,
-0.0479961857,
0.034637522,
-0.0250650402,
-0.0238223206,
-0.0196201485,
-0.0176746901,
-0.0316815935,
0.0290062055,
-0.0253287442,
-0.0199444704,
0.031510219,
-0.0023513795,
-0.0097608417,
0.053201288,
-0.0514790229,
0.0065079411,
0.0067289099,
-0.0375173278,
-0.0608609654,
-0.0403422713,
-0.0285548773,
0.0451868176,
-0.0411922559,
0.0102045899,
1.749638967e-34,
0.0499307215,
-0.0014517597,
0.0413629413,
0.0377512164,
0.0471463576,
-0.0170786008,
0.0676394403,
0.0118518621,
0.0558197498,
-0.0624074563,
-0.0330717824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00126v1 | Common Sense Reasoning for Deep Fake Detection | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | Yue Zhang, Ben Colman, Ali Shahriyari, Gaurav Bharaj | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | State-of-the-art approaches rely on image-based features extracted via neural
networks for the deepfake detection binary classification. While these
approaches trained in the supervised sense extract likely fake features, they
may fall short in representing unnatural `non-physical' semantic facial
attributes -- blurry hairlines, double eyebrows, rigid eye pupils, or unnatural
skin shading. However, such facial attributes are generally easily perceived by
humans via common sense reasoning. Furthermore, image-based feature extraction
methods that provide visual explanation via saliency maps can be hard to be
interpreted by humans. To address these challenges, we propose the use of
common sense reasoning to model deepfake detection, and extend it to the
Deepfake Detection VQA (DD-VQA) task with the aim to model human intuition in
explaining the reason behind labeling an image as either real or fake. To this
end, we introduce a new dataset that provides answers to the questions related
to the authenticity of an image, along with its corresponding explanations. We
also propose a Vision and Language Transformer-based framework for the DD-VQA
task, incorporating text and image aware feature alignment formulations.
Finally, we evaluate our method on both the performance of deepfake detection
and the quality of the generated explanations. We hope that this task inspires
researchers to explore new avenues for enhancing language-based
interpretability and cross-modality applications in the realm of deepfake
detection. | [
0.0151613466,
0.0522069745,
-0.0085347425,
0.0559239872,
-0.0013693149,
0.0328405388,
0.061046306,
0.0349649154,
0.003619981,
-0.0043961843,
0.0068965238,
-0.0375423022,
0.0071494025,
0.0868609324,
0.0478119217,
-0.0785915703,
0.0017807201,
-0.0215828884,
0.0391130559,
0.0126797026,
0.0617829897,
0.0322132893,
-0.0036981718,
0.0525977537,
-0.0673226416,
-0.0387056619,
-0.0117494166,
0.0359232426,
0.0692478418,
0.0479394756,
-0.0106336465,
0.0037334089,
0.0054350998,
0.0244314969,
0.0000020446,
-0.0199491624,
-0.017402567,
0.0015302848,
-0.0334704295,
0.0039836941,
0.0085680112,
-0.0382238738,
-0.0400013477,
-0.0143374484,
-0.0295128152,
-0.0040848353,
0.0525346324,
0.0760971606,
0.06275139,
0.0623197481,
-0.0352707282,
-0.0380115844,
0.0005048905,
0.015588019,
0.0207859762,
-0.0561459959,
-0.0180998165,
0.0045340387,
-0.0553606488,
-0.0165231805,
-0.0120165292,
-0.0212288816,
0.0162640736,
-0.070462577,
0.0037234977,
-0.0060172142,
-0.0578630641,
-0.0489726327,
0.0347899906,
0.0649891496,
-0.0844770446,
-0.0168168657,
0.0148687083,
-0.0348076373,
0.0089933993,
0.0570476241,
0.0307657663,
0.020714486,
-0.0133367358,
0.0276922099,
-0.0326364674,
-0.0016356336,
0.0463395119,
0.0034321679,
-0.0307964366,
-0.0065235314,
-0.016360214,
0.0557874404,
-0.0197315328,
-0.0143900262,
-0.0281435065,
-0.03109744,
0.0165032595,
0.0168704353,
0.0130024627,
-0.0451516286,
-0.0494076908,
-0.0065990761,
-0.0290458258,
0.0039250441,
0.0343415663,
0.0072689313,
-0.0823635459,
0.0559802726,
-0.0003227984,
0.0680671185,
-0.0235987622,
0.0474651679,
-0.0252566803,
-0.0206258241,
-0.0298499521,
-0.0267301276,
0.0183730554,
-0.0687064305,
-0.0048785061,
-0.0014891641,
-0.0194957312,
-0.0261111371,
-0.0494357906,
0.0023408521,
0.0075308871,
0.0444659889,
-0.0515225232,
-0.0165254977,
-0.0407729931,
0.0257096253,
0.0178405698,
0.0231720209,
-0.0184910744,
-0.0667269975,
-0.024398258,
0.0564446561,
0.0280668829,
0.0078659104,
0.0395090431,
-0.0209379271,
0.0097116875,
0.0042910366,
-0.0341044888,
-0.0054879901,
-0.0389418975,
-0.0309048146,
-0.0018918824,
-0.046386458,
-0.0043131523,
-0.0775303319,
0.0121002672,
-0.0207937025,
-0.025617687,
-0.0170908943,
-0.0096523277,
0.0707189739,
-0.0161867589,
-0.0068790899,
0.0408472754,
0.0081777479,
-0.0176378563,
0.015796043,
0.0186967943,
0.0447925925,
0.039446868,
-0.0283697397,
0.0460376218,
-0.006512905,
0.0106092133,
0.0021238576,
-0.032286495,
-0.0434406959,
-0.0416320562,
0.0414266065,
0.0436335877,
-0.0126259271,
0.0029811282,
-0.0332876258,
0.0497592837,
0.0294880606,
0.012082669,
-0.0237696543,
0.0349155627,
0.0387547091,
-0.0216857735,
-0.0042384416,
-0.0455545112,
0.0599031001,
-0.0135034136,
-0.0003396307,
-0.049929224,
0.0282308608,
-0.0466511995,
-0.0376720466,
0.0104084164,
-0.0299950335,
0.0001319537,
-0.0023763464,
0.0263562575,
0.0172902197,
-0.0117094014,
-0.008884537,
-0.0329490378,
-0.0129423589,
-0.006988307,
-0.096840933,
0.0343898274,
0.0617634542,
-0.0155193182,
0.0269821845,
0.0100770053,
-0.0056218202,
0.0177214295,
0.0011258409,
-0.0151414666,
0.0104292361,
0.0345873199,
-0.0182465613,
-0.0289075579,
-0.0476505198,
-0.0064198524,
-0.0152196027,
-0.0497756898,
-0.0138912546,
0.0368052274,
-0.0189003684,
0.0050443835,
0.0104530305,
-0.0063045244,
0.0055334684,
-0.0290931296,
0.0547673181,
0.0073170294,
0.0099088373,
0.031578701,
-0.0115064643,
0.0192539636,
-0.0250552408,
0.0156050706,
0.0062782848,
0.015984904,
-0.017382089,
0.0430671871,
-0.0972217023,
-0.0332892649,
0.0589404702,
-0.0576397814,
-0.0201351475,
0.0098269982,
-0.0271912981,
-0.0096995831,
-0.0512390472,
-0.019276252,
0.0064310227,
0.0164016895,
0.0219502877,
0.0926008523,
0.0151490951,
-0.0385948531,
-0.0104372418,
0.0077936039,
0.002700404,
-0.0325146466,
0.0037969789,
-0.0007979876,
0.0060938313,
-0.0101531716,
-0.0216950532,
0.0008189247,
-0.0484818518,
0.0373762622,
-0.0340312868,
-0.0138883479,
-0.0240959078,
-0.0247054845,
0.0069333767,
-0.028606195,
0.0173906516,
-0.0166807547,
-0.0634241402,
0.0192969162,
-0.0463918671,
-0.0442581587,
0.0184016768,
-0.0193049312,
-0.0189603288,
-0.0137626082,
0.0290237125,
0.0199236181,
0.0451785959,
0.0269212015,
0.0331091322,
-0.0611887164,
0.0066429237,
-0.0259126741,
0.0384466834,
-0.0114759756,
-0.0468955189,
0.0117512913,
0.0094223265,
-0.0157053787,
0.0730786845,
0.0393951498,
0.0338988751,
-0.0166173838,
0.0360075124,
-0.0054300465,
-0.0322383456,
0.0181512143,
0.0346019417,
-0.0154109467,
-0.0855481848,
-0.0262034368,
0.0089373281,
-0.0035014923,
0.0055089784,
-0.0647178218,
0.0576246232,
0.0382223912,
-0.0384871922,
0.0062038237,
-0.025140604,
0.0052119885,
0.0593702383,
-0.0259352047,
-0.0600831136,
0.0919985026,
-0.0213147532,
-0.0088816816,
0.0596241988,
-0.0158300865,
0.0045925165,
0.0490609258,
0.0126627786,
0.0236350875,
0.0411313437,
-0.013952517,
-0.015940344,
-0.0171991382,
0.0613155812,
-0.0191735774,
0.0276157968,
-0.0470118299,
-0.0123843485,
0.0188238379,
0.0361469239,
-0.0420186222,
-0.0555086993,
-0.050592646,
-0.0321736373,
-0.0573005527,
-0.0440416373,
-0.0210962221,
0.0204176698,
0.0270373505,
0.0147304796,
0.010845799,
0.0135893598,
0.0154668605,
0.0133969849,
0.1069852188,
0.043485947,
0.0137322973,
-0.013856547,
-0.0189164076,
0.0692005754,
-0.0136957914,
0.0065826545,
-0.0799130276,
-0.0083780568,
-0.0033585532,
0.0765221789,
0.0100727612,
-0.0093437228,
0.0056140139,
-0.0374570228,
-0.0019459659,
0.0668892786,
-0.0067199683,
0.0083831027,
0.0338113718,
-0.0001142773,
0.0012551671,
0.0065777809,
-0.0063813427,
-0.0466600768,
-0.0553094149,
0.0255070217,
0.0124904709,
-0.0309754703,
0.0186196044,
-0.0040549049,
-0.0473516732,
0.0751282945,
0.0150355715,
0.0060410127,
-0.043383006,
0.0195745248,
0.005136271,
-0.0369718559,
0.0168700349,
-0.0160496458,
0.0376979187,
0.0045232172,
-0.0171343945,
0.0553117767,
-0.0522032976,
0.0222859737,
-0.017728515,
0.0415224358,
0.0492460467,
0.0309321973,
-0.0017627603,
-0.1193559766,
-0.0444556884,
-0.0234930329,
0.0441806987,
0.0184537619,
0.0550822392,
-0.0059664277,
-0.0387832485,
-0.0239732098,
0.0788085014,
-0.03791425,
-0.0027645584,
-0.0414077155,
0.0314644314,
-0.0340974405,
-0.0362772271,
-0.0205528587,
-0.0112308236,
-0.0074688392,
0.0431554392,
0.0227674842,
-0.0011342168,
-0.009879414,
0.0071899854,
0.0136982072,
-0.0110980244,
-0.0976065248,
0.0493443944,
0.0295736808,
-0.0692406446,
-0.0125209223,
0.0169176906,
-0.0167161319,
0.0498057678,
-0.0408778489,
-0.0555244051,
0.0034988574,
-0.0038912529,
-0.0285083447,
0.0959212855,
0.010608213,
0.0475864783,
0.0026191261,
0.0069376007,
-0.0073969853,
-0.0493899919,
-0.0157845113,
0.0111001013,
-0.0276996642,
-0.0153062446,
-0.001483816,
0.0586516708,
0.0176153295,
0.0667182133,
-0.0205682293,
-0.070672676,
0.0043052477,
0.0076660947,
0.00550461,
-0.0157886036,
0.0562515557,
-0.0695601031,
0.0127203623,
0.0483552851,
-0.0046204249,
0.0152264154,
0.0036080887,
-0.0272748005,
-0.0646030679,
-0.0356043875,
0.0340241604,
-0.000894258,
0.0497725308,
-0.0287987944,
0.0371919088,
-0.0207045302,
0.0001009983,
0.0087318392,
-0.0048302077,
-0.0493588783,
0.0247477721,
0.0025465251,
-0.0166717675,
0.010977569,
-0.0536059365,
-0.0511902794,
0.0204498898,
-0.0090925666,
0.001976866,
-0.0013721631,
0.0525849015,
-0.0164528247,
0.0284686927,
0.0490715541,
0.024988275,
-0.0077740666,
0.0527570136,
0.0198058374,
0.0487933941,
0.0473559126,
-0.0250155255,
-0.0050525172,
0.0058832746,
0.0063356147,
-0.0220364388,
-0.0017132965,
-0.0001692061,
0.0181554742,
-0.0600115173,
0.0033298479,
0.023693867,
-0.0063416651,
0.000602581,
0.0675091445,
0.0385145321,
-0.0593605861,
0.0149027202,
0.0235060267,
-0.0228649769,
-0.0177056752,
0.0456090644,
0.0003835602,
-0.0286487397,
-0.0123782447,
-0.0243188087,
-0.0429970101,
0.0199152958,
0.0275073797,
0.026157869,
-0.018297473,
0.0166219715,
-0.0524038821,
-0.0808431953,
0.0002116711,
0.0079722796,
-0.0114745032,
0.0644133687,
0.0265534185,
0.0549415722,
-0.0246695224,
-0.0071932273,
-0.0089143021,
0.0149766095,
-0.0099348007,
0.0159079973,
0.020213373,
-6.512913878e-33,
0.0445674695,
-0.0443388,
-0.0296033081,
-0.0318119787,
-0.0002868194,
0.0365485884,
-0.0271781795,
-0.0241601393,
-0.0137374885,
0.0757196322,
0.0184450969,
0.0679274946,
-0.0006222998,
0.0227447227,
-0.0593053736,
-0.0307876896,
0.0210715402,
0.0347418934,
-0.0229438227,
0.0226407312,
0.0471352004,
-0.014835421,
0.0802999735,
-0.0736140832,
0.0075750584,
-0.0109794801,
-0.0592151731,
0.0259130113,
0.0004781385,
0.0614544265,
-0.0112686707,
0.011285943,
0.0017883121,
-0.0059903702,
0.0285581928,
-0.014451596,
-0.0083201593,
0.0006083372,
-0.0106543442,
0.0212454721,
-0.0533626415,
-0.0181221869,
0.0472375453,
-0.0186915509,
0.02863588,
-0.0227569174,
0.068475157,
-0.0418340527,
0.0409146398,
0.0009321522,
-0.0333531983,
-0.0001945712,
-0.026211489,
-0.0245685056,
0.0514475591,
0.0551334545,
0.0014788316,
0.0060747131,
-0.0705290586,
0.0097498056,
-0.033726044,
-0.033926554,
0.0700418651,
0.0012741371,
-0.0108606759,
0.0593230017,
0.0319460966,
-0.042428989,
-0.0590290166,
-0.0119149778,
0.0211456958,
0.0655183196,
0.0649406537,
0.0942461267,
0.0526146963,
-0.0266377814,
-0.064729467,
0.0071101245,
-0.0881764665,
0.0345156118,
0.0020865067,
0.0135946963,
-0.0383432508,
0.0163564235,
-0.0081356354,
0.0138526373,
-0.061586652,
-0.0076551931,
-0.0100805797,
-0.0162802041,
-0.0750125498,
0.054628849,
0.0072479551,
-0.0281050391,
0.0525016189,
-0.0285003837,
-0.0038682562,
-0.0011591312,
0.0148626454,
0.0439745188,
0.0279172901,
-0.0421904549,
0.0772250071,
0.0103103435,
0.0553308949,
0.0074638487,
0.0298398361,
0.0344112366,
0.0192026515,
-0.0166501217,
-0.0451280922,
0.0141403694,
-0.0248706769,
0.0275181159,
-0.0021323317,
0.0187050495,
-0.0488805361,
-0.009544299,
-0.0243624952,
-0.0015644564,
-0.0138040548,
0.0341697261,
-0.0272849202,
0.0099915946,
-0.0415317751,
-0.0308569148,
-0.0222982839,
-0.0955117643,
0.0517876409,
-0.0785434544,
-0.0205339957,
0.0165470932,
2.766e-7,
-0.0327320658,
0.0062385085,
0.0187885948,
-0.0339845233,
0.0031352933,
0.0954929441,
0.018720217,
-0.0141443145,
0.0053580999,
-0.0958748162,
0.0142163066,
0.0399919301,
0.0302502196,
-0.0059348969,
-0.0107083302,
0.0391487069,
0.0307183806,
-0.0219814349,
-0.01376299,
0.0316525511,
0.0299368277,
0.0551507175,
0.0358021036,
-0.0523964837,
0.1094263569,
-0.020967491,
0.0171397459,
0.0009460879,
0.0191303995,
-0.0329551175,
0.0522212535,
-0.0158098042,
0.0020796128,
0.0585393608,
-0.0064711128,
-0.0329868868,
0.0203906577,
0.0153356362,
-0.0463237688,
-0.01707468,
-0.0707532838,
0.0019605923,
0.0169523321,
-0.0744303614,
0.0415789001,
-0.0013883353,
-0.0236796755,
-0.0450633839,
-0.0630628243,
-0.0120384218,
-0.0102420626,
-0.0008727894,
-0.0034985391,
0.0439450964,
0.0425883643,
-0.0458762273,
-0.0155854421,
-0.0498844087,
-0.0300837439,
-0.009437535,
-0.0347040333,
0.0514470004,
-0.0456277579,
-0.0192318764,
0.091515623,
-0.0041935961,
-0.0301093366,
2.053445138e-34,
0.0094048809,
0.0216351245,
0.024288157,
-0.0328484438,
0.0163120814,
0.0485927276,
-0.0161277279,
-0.0086108865,
0.0167887025,
-0.0103853531,
-0.0246348158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00123v1 | Comparing Template-based and Template-free Language Model Probing | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | Sagi Shaier, Kevin Bennett, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The differences between cloze-task language model (LM) probing with 1)
expert-made templates and 2) naturally-occurring text have often been
overlooked. Here, we evaluate 16 different LMs on 10 probing English datasets
-- 4 template-based and 6 template-free -- in general and biomedical domains to
answer the following research questions: (RQ1) Do model rankings differ between
the two approaches? (RQ2) Do models' absolute scores differ between the two
approaches? (RQ3) Do the answers to RQ1 and RQ2 differ between general and
domain-specific models? Our findings are: 1) Template-free and template-based
approaches often rank models differently, except for the top domain-specific
models. 2) Scores decrease by up to 42% Acc@1 when comparing parallel
template-free and template-based prompts. 3) Perplexity is negatively
correlated with accuracy in the template-free approach, but,
counter-intuitively, they are positively correlated for template-based probing.
4) Models tend to predict the same answers frequently across prompts for
template-based probing, which is less common when employing template-free
techniques. | [
0.0445462167,
-0.0245516747,
-0.0260105468,
-0.0159552637,
-0.0553409532,
0.0238626152,
0.0405545533,
0.0141380811,
-0.0179939996,
-0.0420785174,
-0.0628802031,
-0.0618189014,
0.0225268286,
0.02940947,
0.0391024649,
-0.0235589836,
0.0346862264,
-0.0066841138,
0.0570292994,
-0.0096189771,
-0.0115395542,
-0.0099372528,
0.0088794427,
0.0337121375,
0.062371783,
-0.0260278843,
-0.0062536523,
-0.0021758354,
-0.0197538063,
-0.0112680681,
0.0134492777,
0.0893767998,
0.032769952,
0.0131097669,
0.0000021449,
-0.0451656431,
0.0079277279,
-0.0002752207,
-0.0285721514,
0.043025367,
0.0352583788,
0.0326278023,
0.0348361433,
0.0480857603,
-0.027067868,
-0.0518141426,
0.0249517597,
0.0176305324,
-0.0044172048,
0.0201981161,
-0.0171569977,
0.0165096689,
0.0024474857,
-0.0251281522,
0.002228583,
-0.028115239,
0.0279768743,
0.0064851954,
0.047404591,
0.0285094045,
-0.0079097496,
0.040826451,
0.0071995277,
0.0105865626,
-0.0006325539,
0.0273047984,
0.060185574,
-0.0485711098,
-0.0097648688,
0.0411120169,
0.0029594589,
-0.0189004391,
0.0058198315,
-0.006915627,
0.0196856856,
0.0939980894,
-0.0591344945,
0.0284429863,
0.0141330762,
-0.0022783615,
0.0523822829,
-0.0217310432,
0.0137607027,
-0.0126206754,
-0.0210678596,
0.0477587767,
0.0278175343,
-0.0413117819,
-0.0029652969,
-0.0081342179,
0.001474213,
-0.0561982803,
0.0041981149,
0.0082928417,
-0.0152976643,
-0.0070845634,
0.008982379,
-0.0464774892,
0.0427406691,
0.0207732506,
0.0704088807,
0.0324142948,
-0.0093898587,
0.0340539254,
0.014009485,
0.0420991331,
0.0031589528,
0.0189437605,
-0.045995865,
0.024844829,
-0.0475513265,
-0.0398517586,
0.0022515536,
0.0160685796,
-0.0120248813,
-0.0343481787,
-0.0247005541,
-0.0053014779,
0.0393699408,
-0.0489270166,
-0.0157291908,
0.0174114797,
-0.0120489132,
0.0399082713,
-0.0350569561,
0.0169061162,
-0.0263124965,
0.0341741815,
-0.0154904369,
-0.0551667809,
-0.0056131585,
0.0252748132,
-0.0132854534,
-0.044884678,
0.0164793879,
0.02949485,
-0.0153838871,
-0.036621131,
0.062099658,
-0.005172973,
-0.0406970605,
-0.0568443313,
0.0163155124,
-0.0890471488,
0.0173754431,
0.0703517571,
-0.0017389781,
-0.0368078239,
-0.0035362625,
0.0105849225,
-0.0606055409,
0.0200738609,
0.0165223796,
0.0543057397,
0.0162412859,
0.0062904274,
0.026788976,
0.0343462676,
-0.0148123596,
-0.0343303718,
-0.0097508514,
-0.0628966317,
0.0346398316,
0.0425608456,
-0.0092760697,
-0.0017258476,
-0.0292061102,
0.031143235,
0.0446230322,
0.0159654915,
0.0409977436,
0.0398222208,
-0.010003808,
0.0025330377,
0.0494517349,
0.089511998,
0.013075118,
-0.0279568974,
0.0293891858,
0.0302534271,
0.054640919,
0.0322362371,
-0.031356927,
-0.0228961073,
-0.0132559231,
0.0172334872,
-0.0092844656,
0.0136506716,
-0.0326050781,
-0.0241766423,
-0.0674076304,
0.0106218681,
0.0212665461,
0.0035990728,
0.0548464991,
-0.0180327054,
-0.0247295871,
0.0500789173,
0.0057163411,
-0.0249770693,
-0.0219603106,
-0.0461178757,
0.0148398951,
0.0291201063,
0.026353484,
0.0018513991,
-0.0485897027,
0.0073382389,
-0.0225993153,
0.0672305003,
0.015649844,
0.0042506247,
0.0085965637,
-0.0295249354,
-0.0168902036,
-0.0239749774,
0.0155408029,
-0.0159327984,
-0.0097277733,
-0.0070456192,
-0.0025939099,
-0.0422899798,
-0.0413672589,
0.0233388841,
-0.0335850082,
0.0114587042,
-0.0134977829,
-0.0170694347,
0.0034736455,
0.0132028339,
-0.0238913428,
0.0697617829,
0.0482955202,
-0.0428675078,
0.0028957818,
-0.0012099958,
-0.0497434996,
-0.0239712447,
-0.0020175562,
-0.0004201771,
0.0088221552,
0.0225808881,
0.0251552202,
-0.0450984798,
-0.0070761903,
-0.0591813959,
0.0970868021,
-0.0189996436,
0.0350613073,
-0.0471334122,
0.0010486417,
-0.0486841574,
0.0539054237,
-0.019906316,
0.0456302315,
0.0329670161,
-0.0282829758,
-0.0000551257,
-0.04341368,
-0.0210450049,
-0.0278048497,
-0.0069429325,
-0.0115232421,
0.0080403425,
0.0062229075,
-0.0537782162,
-0.0056981575,
-0.087898545,
-0.0297161769,
-0.004316038,
0.0263347831,
0.0440438911,
0.000569649,
-0.0224773549,
0.0073119765,
-0.0461319908,
-0.0460732877,
0.0230906587,
0.0615067147,
0.0173551328,
-0.0187585969,
-0.004864037,
-0.0499566421,
-0.0261553973,
-0.0498041585,
0.0457963794,
0.0087280488,
-0.0194843076,
-0.0309757777,
0.0773255602,
-0.0254247766,
-0.0340779983,
0.0034189022,
-0.0367826074,
0.0302756391,
-0.0168637764,
0.0765843764,
0.0245897509,
-0.0368697084,
0.0087731164,
0.0380545072,
-0.02032323,
-0.0528848507,
-0.0225561336,
-0.0249726102,
0.0132282991,
-0.0077559394,
-0.0612687171,
-0.0105552692,
0.0984813944,
0.0383170582,
0.0101233535,
-0.0375438742,
0.0461736284,
-0.0523887649,
-0.0111557022,
-0.0697087571,
0.0088247955,
-0.0257342607,
0.0821171477,
-0.0206973609,
-0.0597814098,
0.0617509671,
-0.0201763958,
0.0023936254,
-0.0682778209,
0.0142541723,
-0.0107445447,
0.0120682269,
0.0058520129,
0.0027429049,
0.0443139784,
-0.0657154173,
-0.0474193096,
-0.0047300896,
-0.0004458551,
-0.0360595323,
0.024489427,
-0.0230282079,
-0.010166198,
0.0240149982,
-0.0110363849,
-0.0248592943,
-0.0248410199,
-0.0099296002,
0.0211000629,
0.0678635985,
-0.0075301109,
-0.0116610648,
0.0470720269,
0.0287456661,
0.0129479282,
-0.0386844762,
0.014859505,
-0.0175093301,
0.0666383952,
0.0726284534,
0.0263548512,
0.0484570451,
-0.0424478203,
0.0210327599,
0.0101592559,
0.0395075046,
0.022588158,
0.0265063215,
0.0068128863,
0.0503861047,
-0.0272196978,
-0.0584908687,
0.0168854576,
0.0331053585,
-0.038879618,
-0.0163119342,
0.1341081709,
0.044030942,
-0.0401845835,
-0.0003112803,
-0.0659175888,
0.0137150045,
0.0418738127,
0.011420073,
-0.0272353571,
-0.0209240709,
0.0101750251,
0.0115874307,
-0.0193241443,
-0.0016184469,
-0.0044791829,
-0.0833772719,
0.0155615276,
-0.0220661126,
-0.0151707698,
0.0087160487,
-0.0650976896,
0.0336433239,
0.0349221677,
0.0191260874,
0.036790546,
-0.0325630307,
0.0307861157,
0.0085446304,
-0.0798382089,
-0.0989169553,
0.044694189,
-0.0246813465,
0.0454637781,
0.0536534227,
-0.0187268853,
-0.0535361394,
-0.033854682,
0.0404521301,
-0.0327469334,
0.025728941,
-0.0412670672,
0.0134157576,
0.0474522337,
0.01278817,
-0.0615000315,
0.0264043547,
-0.041499164,
0.0277297981,
-0.0189710185,
0.0783958659,
-0.0104362955,
-0.0218413882,
-0.0364433639,
-0.0202925783,
0.0077907816,
0.1208658144,
0.0675284341,
-0.0776112974,
-0.0054646446,
0.0175826382,
-0.0004513855,
0.0429194793,
-0.0424717776,
-0.0186172407,
-0.0104571646,
-0.0075396919,
-0.0545026027,
-0.0446889102,
0.0690895543,
0.020889014,
0.0292014685,
0.0468774326,
-0.0374042168,
-0.0387241542,
-0.0329300798,
0.0476761758,
0.0361824632,
0.0285352878,
-0.1106244177,
-0.0154344803,
0.0068098288,
-0.0285896808,
-0.0222953837,
0.0166401826,
-0.0647755265,
-0.0567052104,
0.0116172861,
0.0025237161,
0.0308416821,
-0.0191366896,
0.0028799025,
-0.0246222243,
0.0537604801,
-0.0017109759,
-0.0618028715,
0.0388446562,
-0.0041513066,
-0.0439851806,
-0.0019564286,
0.007121433,
-0.0334004536,
0.0047023688,
0.0216821413,
0.0396742672,
0.0006529972,
-0.0284066424,
0.0064488761,
0.0196116306,
0.0818338618,
0.0273344275,
-0.0109876357,
-0.0219490938,
-0.0144745717,
-0.0110306758,
-0.0113422964,
-0.0216648728,
-0.0377887972,
0.000450428,
0.0302016269,
-0.0355400071,
-0.0104355374,
-0.0903536603,
0.0528473184,
-0.0657100007,
0.0222773254,
-0.0383276977,
0.0043133711,
0.0159004796,
-0.0101968721,
-0.0024765753,
0.0309004523,
-0.0365327932,
0.0266373772,
0.0068748551,
0.0702285916,
-0.0355501771,
0.0012293319,
0.0011543862,
0.0367195532,
-0.043110963,
-0.0409017913,
0.0160134323,
-0.0106736086,
0.0032445134,
-0.0254925415,
0.0673270002,
0.0015993841,
0.0110031795,
-0.0358591825,
-0.0124171106,
0.0227006283,
0.0078676343,
0.0655393675,
0.011739701,
-0.0246583913,
-0.0356664881,
0.080669269,
0.0548122451,
0.0035806075,
0.010192601,
-0.035248924,
-0.0283884108,
0.0094570834,
0.0307747237,
0.0160745997,
-0.0550840534,
-0.0174651574,
-0.0927286744,
-0.0480520353,
0.0239429399,
-0.004882317,
-0.0184294526,
-0.0321849845,
-0.0076272832,
0.06678579,
0.0064160293,
-0.0544016324,
-0.0368156545,
0.0658030808,
-0.0087861875,
-0.029357234,
-0.0142221032,
-6.919286683e-33,
-0.0197249129,
-0.0444452874,
-0.0118470006,
-0.0278225355,
0.0162914954,
0.0423024036,
-0.0477545112,
0.0394756496,
-0.0171874668,
0.0141508356,
-0.0240127426,
-0.001056456,
0.0253699496,
-0.0159083754,
0.0430637039,
0.0023076367,
0.0093461871,
-0.0109469704,
-0.0296588466,
-0.0055673667,
0.0190822538,
0.0353565849,
0.0602133907,
-0.0125429295,
0.0542539358,
-0.0325313285,
0.0529139228,
-0.0068610799,
-0.0280199442,
0.0385509022,
-0.0361362435,
0.0384564102,
0.0443761647,
-0.0529640988,
-0.0256765764,
0.0067459126,
-0.0511538237,
-0.0489509329,
0.0829136223,
-0.0207329299,
-0.0345793255,
-0.0078807073,
0.0323589817,
-0.0117860436,
-0.0291995145,
0.015265299,
0.0413290896,
-0.0181537177,
-0.0070049139,
0.0168683492,
-0.0360420384,
-0.0092891818,
0.0059830556,
-0.0284889527,
-0.0101826014,
0.0649755821,
-0.0380435251,
0.0144169033,
-0.0359348245,
0.0336565599,
0.0497280248,
0.0518173538,
0.052938804,
0.0312139802,
0.0367809385,
0.0362819172,
-0.0159350056,
-0.0226603597,
-0.0259658806,
-0.0152078606,
0.0586065389,
0.0252859574,
0.0444092192,
-0.00801735,
0.0231779609,
0.0192943625,
-0.0575443879,
0.0280871671,
0.0431490466,
0.0307741705,
0.0417183489,
-0.0320819616,
-0.0257804338,
-0.0718612298,
-0.0234503578,
-0.013574264,
-0.0446180888,
-0.0197552387,
0.0278355367,
-0.0444392413,
-0.0185154136,
-0.0392720588,
0.042255763,
-0.0020146526,
-0.021072166,
-0.0015753994,
-0.02439305,
0.0317612663,
0.0016349042,
0.0376916714,
-0.098516956,
0.0104531748,
0.001947775,
0.0449189097,
0.0205102284,
0.0128883943,
-0.0246011466,
-0.0104032513,
-0.0496034324,
-0.0312498119,
-0.0147786262,
-0.0109997736,
0.0027132803,
-0.0166320316,
0.0546013154,
0.0010338485,
-0.0022965451,
0.019159697,
0.0461661667,
-0.0235705413,
-0.0577497296,
0.0327865742,
-0.0027440172,
0.0205507837,
-0.0078536151,
-0.0068798224,
-0.0182806309,
0.014800312,
0.0445974506,
0.0086465422,
-0.0164359324,
0.0161412153,
2.773e-7,
0.08120884,
0.0682799816,
-0.0189420078,
0.0072238855,
0.0247730333,
0.0274880249,
-0.0221340768,
0.0028225067,
0.0298643187,
-0.0112813488,
-0.0094338227,
-0.019158816,
0.0365148224,
0.0025903694,
-0.0623074993,
0.0418413505,
-0.0771216601,
0.0350679755,
-0.0439893641,
0.0253308862,
-0.0069599445,
0.049233105,
-0.0300763641,
-0.0176150929,
-0.0352642313,
0.0042699431,
0.0382729061,
-0.0307739042,
-0.011155826,
0.0318825021,
-0.002240232,
0.0261905771,
0.0320060588,
0.0821080208,
0.0203795116,
0.0234689042,
0.0299972612,
0.0245600212,
-0.0098695094,
-0.0070609106,
0.0123496931,
-0.0287931953,
0.0033711405,
-0.1029557288,
0.0645248368,
-0.0651279688,
-0.040399529,
-0.020051932,
0.0072652106,
0.0046532843,
0.0420912839,
-0.0179411955,
-0.0125804925,
0.0120812766,
0.0225534867,
-0.0332191475,
-0.0165214241,
-0.0155841671,
-0.0373272859,
-0.0139281917,
-0.0437919088,
-0.0554525182,
-0.0339294933,
-0.031933222,
-0.0103893625,
-0.0776366964,
-0.0113014597,
3.074582846e-34,
0.0385465696,
0.0089317802,
0.0285388082,
0.0250261929,
0.014557939,
-0.011733192,
0.0123165259,
0.0184263028,
0.0020997718,
-0.1353867799,
-0.0165189132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18070v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18070v2 | Do Language Models Exhibit the Same Cognitive Biases in Problem Solving as Human Learners? | 2024-01-31T18:48:20 | 2024-06-17T15:08:05 | Andreas Opedal, Alessandro Stolfo, Haruki Shirakami, Ying Jiao, Ryan Cotterell, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abulhair Saparov, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | There is increasing interest in employing large language models (LLMs) as
cognitive models. For such purposes, it is central to understand which
properties of human cognition are well-modeled by LLMs, and which are not. In
this work, we study the biases of LLMs in relation to those known in children
when solving arithmetic word problems. Surveying the learning science
literature, we posit that the problem-solving process can be split into three
distinct steps: text comprehension, solution planning and solution execution.
We construct tests for each one in order to understand whether current LLMs
display the same cognitive biases as children in these steps. We generate a
novel set of word problems for each of these tests, using a neuro-symbolic
approach that enables fine-grained control over the problem features. We find
evidence that LLMs, with and without instruction-tuning, exhibit human-like
biases in both the text-comprehension and the solution-planning steps of the
solving process, but not in the final step, in which the arithmetic expressions
are executed to obtain the answer. | [
0.0309667476,
0.0256775413,
-0.0389995836,
0.0292553864,
-0.0713207498,
0.0152408145,
0.0075697321,
0.0041932636,
-0.0212032758,
-0.0237175804,
0.0080979299,
-0.0147333434,
0.0161907561,
-0.0197428726,
0.0254400913,
-0.033839412,
0.0472355299,
-0.0559265055,
0.0665670186,
-0.0028301866,
-0.0637567937,
-0.0132109011,
-0.0467221253,
-0.0128245419,
-0.0174647421,
-0.0326970592,
0.0111318789,
-0.0707036331,
-0.0215950999,
-0.0269079283,
-0.0363692679,
0.0378405675,
0.0309627131,
0.0295460951,
0.0000020654,
-0.0595387593,
0.0300796721,
-0.0172423292,
-0.0394505784,
0.0426327214,
0.0222010706,
0.010529995,
-0.0033515382,
0.0179755911,
-0.0368174575,
0.0366394632,
0.0267086402,
0.0251510907,
0.0029906179,
0.0240967944,
0.0024100367,
0.0033365574,
0.015865745,
0.0124160014,
0.0679730028,
-0.0482518226,
0.0221921764,
0.0542795211,
0.0364377722,
-0.0149555821,
-0.0524837598,
0.0152766416,
0.0339907221,
0.0301763006,
-0.0442316085,
-0.0056845662,
-0.0056627942,
0.0099303313,
-0.0213413369,
0.020099923,
0.0029744273,
-0.0142818065,
-0.0227467138,
-0.0058502448,
0.0103202714,
0.0324179977,
-0.081875883,
0.0717392042,
0.0080209691,
-0.0005871948,
0.0163984392,
-0.035535939,
0.011320631,
0.0371386223,
-0.0016061963,
0.0873284191,
-0.0099655809,
-0.036787264,
0.0213742424,
0.0158782415,
-0.0439188778,
-0.0483550578,
0.026076382,
0.0622073077,
-0.0097596822,
0.038661126,
-0.0045697642,
-0.0195666719,
-0.0212305523,
-0.0515792668,
0.0686280057,
0.0815942287,
0.0502122939,
0.0077860462,
-0.0207161196,
0.0663094893,
-0.0274816845,
0.037899822,
-0.03877455,
0.068946287,
-0.0019510628,
-0.0574464537,
-0.0333830751,
0.0198828056,
0.0082840398,
-0.0105861388,
-0.037520919,
0.0149351768,
0.0136970384,
-0.0155405244,
-0.0172273144,
-0.0169791188,
0.0367123336,
-0.0186060574,
-0.0634208918,
0.0126669332,
-0.0480235443,
0.0536191314,
-0.0442145988,
-0.0132157169,
-0.0029595885,
-0.0076547423,
-0.0234913118,
-0.0271877199,
0.0174932592,
0.0670031086,
-0.0353540853,
0.0167859811,
-0.012660359,
-0.0256424677,
0.0205860492,
-0.0749046206,
0.0320999026,
-0.049014803,
0.0074856165,
0.0655723736,
-0.0163081959,
-0.0302035082,
0.0085066911,
0.0073934384,
0.011065986,
0.0133573618,
0.0571411252,
0.0403047055,
0.0530816317,
-0.0060430109,
-0.0149732316,
0.0579719245,
0.0803264529,
-0.0195554178,
-0.028030837,
-0.018000789,
-0.0102208154,
0.0332473367,
-0.0018975408,
-0.0063412362,
-0.048959706,
-0.0292272866,
0.018502038,
0.0593932234,
0.021448737,
0.0593291037,
-0.0164541528,
0.0011254027,
0.0546432398,
0.0659579784,
-0.0256620198,
0.0177548937,
0.0011555419,
-0.0289688315,
0.061657425,
0.0319889747,
-0.0754931718,
0.0616125613,
-0.0311343018,
-0.0093900142,
-0.0184887834,
0.0125405872,
-0.0085577713,
-0.036394909,
-0.0397018269,
0.0495360196,
0.0215705894,
0.0221724994,
0.0382392555,
-0.015682023,
-0.0211313982,
0.0281724241,
-0.0337583683,
-0.0027520105,
0.0170675293,
-0.0539628752,
0.0475948676,
0.0094265211,
0.0571422018,
-0.0129145831,
-0.0016863659,
0.0318544321,
-0.0182382055,
0.0127533805,
0.0420425534,
0.0099940533,
-0.0308801513,
-0.0216305852,
-0.0065979958,
-0.0354357064,
0.0073053031,
-0.032619033,
0.0200321861,
-0.0092761479,
-0.0014980269,
-0.0265237875,
-0.0131228855,
0.0461461656,
-0.0582359247,
-0.0345601328,
-0.0752101839,
0.0096885953,
-0.0107116513,
-0.0178979747,
0.0182045642,
0.0618518479,
0.0008899031,
-0.0122187305,
-0.0039385143,
0.006839389,
-0.0807556063,
-0.0069691734,
0.0499335192,
-0.055379536,
-0.0070236567,
0.0167608876,
-0.0035732961,
-0.0023657326,
0.0885032713,
-0.0871864781,
0.0219707582,
0.0316140726,
0.0602558702,
-0.0195291359,
-0.0487606004,
-0.0375068299,
0.083933048,
0.0052154539,
0.0379991718,
0.0057752766,
-0.0184089839,
-0.003615801,
-0.0205442645,
-0.0025206327,
-0.0086724218,
-0.011230737,
-0.004184986,
-0.0274620876,
-0.0250458475,
-0.0663655624,
-0.0065234993,
-0.0073262113,
-0.0344537683,
0.0376802906,
0.0520668998,
0.0050897892,
-0.044636704,
-0.0211318694,
0.0052168765,
-0.008368928,
0.0198675599,
-0.0039799628,
0.0444634408,
0.0171404239,
0.008965306,
-0.0167399701,
-0.0475060381,
-0.0280664247,
-0.0700382963,
0.0240069199,
0.05269612,
-0.0119693018,
-0.0607730225,
0.064290598,
-0.026791364,
0.0152295381,
-0.0007646776,
0.0115294876,
0.0266718585,
0.0087008066,
0.0445246361,
0.0928396136,
0.0014774008,
0.0355043821,
0.0523907952,
-0.040434137,
-0.0600924902,
0.0036252448,
-0.0016845666,
-0.0103866793,
0.0053583253,
-0.0719987676,
-0.0260978956,
0.1106187776,
0.0189364254,
-0.0074059241,
0.002908899,
0.0784584433,
-0.0487882979,
-0.0126214931,
-0.0424467251,
-0.0657744035,
-0.0247949511,
0.0465478897,
-0.0229782388,
-0.0492944755,
0.070652321,
0.0318365507,
0.0070859632,
-0.066681765,
0.0593984649,
-0.0459671468,
0.0460788608,
-0.0009735101,
-0.0036732196,
-0.0285658017,
-0.0101154167,
-0.0946651548,
-0.0090985326,
0.0166600384,
-0.0228778999,
0.0484590866,
-0.0659020692,
-0.0233786721,
-0.0172940921,
-0.0321223773,
-0.0313828439,
0.013721291,
-0.0218932107,
0.0161399823,
0.0335396081,
-0.0210737027,
-0.0471598916,
-0.0143850846,
0.0691867918,
0.0065155681,
-0.0354809538,
-0.0135738421,
-0.0050261565,
-0.013136398,
0.0277196057,
0.013243326,
0.0503032468,
-0.0569691472,
0.0078686513,
0.0186117906,
0.0639734715,
0.0060807667,
0.0183303971,
0.0467591062,
0.0578838289,
-0.0272708945,
-0.0190040581,
0.065979518,
0.0254114214,
-0.0581111275,
0.0128349047,
0.070654273,
0.0750389695,
-0.0198417623,
0.0229044035,
-0.0823710933,
-0.0284073856,
0.0247215554,
0.01488443,
-0.0476020426,
0.0006499985,
0.023087034,
-0.0421412401,
-0.0151014458,
-0.0419089124,
-0.0238773823,
-0.0984018296,
0.0053360215,
0.0144046228,
-0.0367878117,
0.0076267268,
-0.0207986943,
-0.0065932968,
0.0348259434,
0.0133733731,
0.0239262618,
-0.0302025639,
0.022104077,
0.0089444593,
0.004183223,
0.009430212,
0.0259019658,
0.0045135077,
0.0089100013,
0.00606095,
-0.0102128033,
-0.0490244292,
-0.0601213649,
0.0714394376,
0.0084711555,
0.0075418549,
-0.0245856531,
-0.008671022,
0.0108919013,
0.0193181355,
-0.0500792898,
0.0113877114,
-0.0055241333,
-0.0454659946,
0.0229865499,
0.1002836972,
0.0099502439,
-0.0117141968,
-0.0078113861,
0.0233396851,
-0.0212262925,
0.055992648,
0.0309746191,
-0.0480276234,
-0.0111453375,
-0.0120999692,
-0.0332288407,
0.0099494467,
-0.0455230027,
0.0115074366,
0.041135788,
0.0397177152,
-0.0354302526,
-0.0157545302,
0.0726126432,
0.0256094877,
0.0258175954,
-0.0204895902,
0.0279414561,
-0.0312674381,
-0.0316747762,
0.0291377772,
-0.0091387583,
0.0419667922,
-0.0568232872,
0.015815977,
-0.0313860588,
-0.0688855127,
-0.0126510961,
0.006582302,
-0.067959547,
-0.057378497,
0.003346998,
-0.0093733827,
0.0306969713,
-0.0708243549,
0.0364095382,
-0.0574612208,
-0.0201661605,
-0.0105071589,
-0.0326234587,
0.0249694344,
-0.0440512002,
0.0463041849,
0.0314324796,
-0.0127896313,
-0.0014450215,
0.0165681485,
0.0230805539,
0.066715546,
-0.0318790898,
0.0025519892,
0.0249025729,
0.0303968713,
0.0185214225,
0.0036397984,
0.01744771,
-0.0229062829,
-0.0011982899,
-0.0307627991,
-0.0305515062,
0.0137009323,
-0.0504970364,
0.0054599936,
0.0071234,
0.0025969807,
-0.0355584398,
-0.0007814341,
0.0228215028,
0.0223141573,
0.0587869585,
-0.0121976687,
0.0193899963,
0.0234712753,
0.0181369781,
0.0168444682,
0.0061533875,
-0.0421645828,
0.0522702523,
0.0500845052,
0.0779799446,
-0.0098647075,
0.0159429498,
-0.0914333165,
-0.0575313941,
-0.0214769263,
-0.0740163773,
0.0302860588,
-0.0054652537,
-0.0051855654,
-0.0358700231,
-0.0255613942,
-0.0645990148,
0.0132358763,
-0.0064343731,
-0.0427582413,
-0.0034430802,
-0.0070094052,
0.0589669682,
0.0296249893,
0.0458216071,
-0.0494114719,
0.0170644149,
-0.0063768295,
0.0387080647,
-0.0152674243,
-0.0023184505,
0.0072775707,
-0.0338897482,
0.0223755185,
-0.0002089854,
-0.0064016855,
0.0168227646,
-0.0850694105,
-0.0525073633,
-0.0428994447,
0.0062663811,
0.0130408602,
-0.0484700315,
0.0204712804,
0.037475694,
-0.0416366868,
-0.0528417863,
0.0272882152,
0.0573644266,
-0.0367343947,
-0.0256855357,
-0.060240984,
-5.699202893e-33,
-0.0317589045,
-0.0544891246,
0.0522978194,
-0.0061594211,
0.0241932571,
-0.0361981876,
-0.0388059281,
0.0827118084,
-0.038435705,
-0.0133604622,
-0.0189493857,
-0.0268302392,
0.009109199,
-0.0318741277,
0.0232780445,
0.0097461222,
-0.0263748802,
-0.0266185366,
-0.0409808718,
-0.0809848905,
0.0018128878,
-0.049915392,
0.0499978997,
-0.013273376,
0.0166393891,
0.0034797457,
0.0288427006,
0.0058573862,
-0.0314715467,
0.0264728069,
-0.0134503776,
0.0324220918,
0.041081477,
-0.0030560803,
-0.0180842225,
0.0182114895,
0.0108368983,
-0.0372876041,
0.0868661478,
0.0208920073,
-0.0241321363,
-0.0362236686,
0.0339082889,
0.0080401823,
-0.0480407029,
0.0011300951,
0.0065904181,
-0.0350924172,
0.0095109437,
0.0444763601,
-0.0848850608,
-0.0076058372,
-0.0225832835,
-0.001667512,
0.0100795217,
0.0092615169,
-0.0432564691,
-0.0283380933,
-0.033254467,
0.0556652732,
0.0493588969,
0.0106233442,
0.0326250531,
0.0095567759,
-0.0039772019,
0.0208912808,
0.0565215349,
0.0151673155,
-0.042950213,
-0.0266144499,
0.025731381,
0.0201316811,
0.0605168529,
-0.0098269461,
0.0697452947,
0.0376355313,
-0.0243673064,
-0.0324547328,
0.0352014266,
0.0605343767,
0.0510472022,
0.0158086419,
-0.0436331034,
-0.0322992578,
-0.0649308115,
0.0245222561,
-0.0536900237,
-0.0022998666,
0.009629623,
-0.0358502418,
0.04548572,
-0.0373480618,
0.0078042345,
-0.0028199567,
0.0011817707,
0.0085614566,
0.0185318906,
0.0440650545,
-0.0135429259,
0.0080238739,
-0.0774889886,
-0.0322921202,
-0.0122274086,
0.0252678115,
0.0273853317,
0.0343024507,
-0.0305565093,
0.0026928394,
-0.0248913616,
-0.0202466026,
-0.0452491492,
-0.0328854546,
0.0704663694,
-0.0304459147,
0.0282752756,
-0.0104251849,
-0.0122994957,
-0.0560907759,
-0.0179490671,
-0.0731950626,
-0.0061447746,
0.0311011337,
-0.0393925309,
0.0174937509,
-0.0056711482,
-0.0099555133,
-0.0279940087,
0.0462710634,
0.0115630403,
-0.0360584855,
-0.0117472094,
0.00051956,
2.831e-7,
0.0255081691,
0.0693731755,
0.0159048121,
0.0489939637,
0.0314691588,
0.0001378899,
-0.0180526674,
-0.0652464032,
0.0535161868,
-0.0068773925,
-0.0186143108,
0.0565447286,
0.0144061344,
0.0009231844,
0.0165189989,
0.0357050225,
-0.0036464019,
0.0605271198,
-0.0324813984,
0.044320453,
0.0220554881,
-0.0118172541,
0.013859272,
0.0074525462,
-0.0586886704,
-0.0158966258,
0.0252118669,
-0.0393101051,
0.0295383912,
0.0017621281,
-0.0325393751,
-0.0047122487,
0.0363397449,
0.0645225495,
0.0206295326,
0.0266506225,
0.0097068129,
0.0380757935,
0.0211585928,
0.0322511271,
-0.017879935,
-0.0250724498,
-0.0441028178,
-0.0495193116,
0.0449937247,
-0.0464492589,
-0.0306218583,
0.0208900366,
0.0353489146,
-0.0170796067,
0.0161488876,
-0.004430532,
0.0493883677,
0.0022700678,
0.0234217588,
0.0063322661,
-0.0117183793,
-0.0272472166,
-0.0311095286,
0.0319946781,
-0.0456205644,
-0.0414041132,
-0.0569587611,
0.0248797555,
0.0332649015,
-0.0148989018,
0.0060885339,
2.169613138e-34,
0.0136254421,
-0.0100722471,
0.0460531861,
0.0086855991,
0.0199074056,
-0.0101004848,
-0.0113585163,
0.0424756184,
0.058656577,
-0.0532708429,
-0.0132839121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18059v1 | RAPTOR: Recursive Abstractive Processing for Tree-Organized Retrieval | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented language models can better adapt to changes in world
state and incorporate long-tail knowledge. However, most existing methods
retrieve only short contiguous chunks from a retrieval corpus, limiting
holistic understanding of the overall document context. We introduce the novel
approach of recursively embedding, clustering, and summarizing chunks of text,
constructing a tree with differing levels of summarization from the bottom up.
At inference time, our RAPTOR model retrieves from this tree, integrating
information across lengthy documents at different levels of abstraction.
Controlled experiments show that retrieval with recursive summaries offers
significant improvements over traditional retrieval-augmented LMs on several
tasks. On question-answering tasks that involve complex, multi-step reasoning,
we show state-of-the-art results; for example, by coupling RAPTOR retrieval
with the use of GPT-4, we can improve the best performance on the QuALITY
benchmark by 20% in absolute accuracy. | [
0.0260881856,
0.0197858363,
0.0003095649,
0.023027828,
-0.014668732,
-0.0059273276,
-0.0916726664,
-0.0279817004,
-0.0325163864,
-0.0411509499,
0.0106120417,
-0.013449749,
0.0051949639,
0.0021717956,
-0.0098116808,
-0.0716257468,
0.0376311652,
0.0061524818,
0.0467407033,
0.0068628108,
0.0355717316,
0.0357612409,
0.0334315225,
0.0118844919,
0.0040010484,
-0.0212817378,
-0.0217027869,
0.0057181981,
0.0118280472,
-0.0272104852,
0.0149038387,
-0.0201758444,
0.0557581782,
0.0369242691,
0.0000019921,
-0.014042573,
-0.0554620251,
-0.0056691295,
0.0003342245,
-0.0231840555,
0.0154881896,
-0.0234627221,
0.0368318483,
0.0317503847,
-0.0191967916,
-0.0477040522,
-0.0024163339,
0.0628580526,
0.0720021948,
0.0801835582,
-0.0085311988,
-0.0695870519,
0.0729308352,
-0.01404374,
-0.01312117,
-0.026142329,
-0.0020107571,
0.0164327025,
0.0158582926,
0.0393073224,
0.0003208544,
0.0175413042,
0.042324286,
0.0153393922,
0.0127923749,
0.0349994488,
-0.0586277321,
0.0438475646,
0.0144412359,
0.0476019233,
0.0086942641,
-0.0418965369,
-0.0012618575,
0.0045755473,
-0.0103419302,
-0.0230964441,
-0.069862783,
0.0362892933,
-0.0384356156,
0.0164334606,
0.0128511991,
0.0057498156,
0.0268656239,
0.0265244078,
-0.0462934226,
0.087717168,
-0.0006916845,
-0.0491084903,
-0.0095682805,
0.0203901716,
-0.0013676907,
-0.0330642387,
0.0010001794,
0.058567062,
-0.0360886343,
0.0264800396,
-0.0100713074,
-0.0390344039,
0.023825733,
-0.0126667973,
-0.012122171,
0.0560690947,
0.0126404678,
0.0626318306,
-0.0294547733,
0.0277960356,
-0.0089559508,
-0.0097473394,
-0.034890376,
-0.0576555766,
-0.0599669814,
-0.0372781605,
-0.0559619777,
0.0674782097,
-0.0646617115,
-0.0116958348,
-0.0004525819,
0.0492814146,
0.015813997,
-0.0287555046,
-0.0180311874,
0.0070745139,
-0.0311437063,
0.0074949949,
-0.0192291904,
0.0231719669,
-0.0557756536,
-0.0054207072,
0.042847883,
0.0016895547,
-0.0089184633,
-0.0143641569,
0.022771433,
-0.0129685104,
-0.0050069354,
0.0045412891,
-0.0084759053,
-0.0318420306,
0.0072281202,
-0.039418485,
0.0054112705,
-0.035817802,
-0.0073762191,
-0.0753044263,
0.0314777307,
-0.0014394099,
-0.0228195675,
0.0274933074,
-0.0053062672,
0.0741215423,
-0.0161110573,
0.0503364615,
0.0001347697,
-0.0081930608,
0.0258006807,
0.0109485369,
-0.0115307728,
0.0340522937,
0.0266497284,
0.0417100117,
0.0397658758,
0.0212625489,
0.0154560627,
-0.0047684098,
0.00195364,
-0.0112024024,
0.0509669296,
0.0243872162,
-0.0798958465,
-0.0105251344,
0.0059999363,
0.0343659259,
-0.0352737084,
0.0147542208,
0.0190596469,
0.0632352382,
0.0040610521,
0.0067871534,
0.012875719,
0.0123408902,
-0.0085126534,
0.0077280854,
-0.0522109643,
0.0296540707,
-0.0674838945,
0.0588143729,
0.0146028483,
0.0198273249,
-0.0283437259,
-0.0383397192,
-0.0080274595,
0.0278716292,
0.016680181,
0.0229802784,
0.0404083505,
0.0173155274,
-0.0327642635,
0.0199767891,
-0.0008400748,
-0.0555381551,
-0.000395393,
-0.0283680633,
0.033527609,
0.0575954467,
0.0654796734,
-0.048496969,
0.0029432396,
0.0133221485,
0.013562589,
0.0265814383,
0.0042764288,
-0.0096540255,
0.0025807042,
-0.043225348,
-0.0379907116,
-0.0239049383,
0.0048685195,
0.0171314627,
0.0531510003,
-0.0120712761,
0.0563772097,
-0.0357042663,
0.0059494399,
0.0258025993,
-0.0101407571,
-0.0070740706,
0.0040592821,
-0.012801609,
0.0166333616,
0.0161711052,
0.0144439712,
0.0183914229,
0.0446042605,
-0.0257388148,
-0.0698642135,
-0.0060716895,
-0.0535939001,
-0.0494555719,
0.0208473261,
-0.0022559003,
-0.0140751349,
0.0381992422,
-0.0442616008,
-0.0587391071,
0.0083763655,
-0.0553788655,
0.0843174383,
-0.0603510737,
0.0046437443,
0.0384340547,
-0.023158187,
-0.025979396,
0.1110633463,
-0.0161034055,
-0.0041094669,
-0.001854641,
-0.0104556736,
-0.0079813125,
-0.0251948852,
-0.0440252051,
-0.0169324614,
-0.0119470106,
0.0150878374,
0.0581311323,
-0.0182846319,
-0.0501191206,
0.0056098164,
-0.0835043639,
0.0310428962,
-0.0343605317,
0.0221198611,
0.0191894732,
0.0247816779,
0.0190060902,
-0.002528016,
-0.0510299653,
-0.0182332881,
0.0138630318,
0.0437911116,
0.0265599955,
-0.014930903,
0.0014599318,
-0.0395676605,
-0.0399677455,
-0.017075019,
0.016434636,
-0.050350979,
-0.0344718955,
-0.0206090286,
-0.0147930039,
-0.0506293774,
0.0257780291,
-0.0310596488,
0.0248730686,
0.0112280203,
-0.0600693114,
0.0412652008,
0.0482163914,
0.004528651,
0.0201747678,
0.0241622142,
0.0027693361,
-0.0603593029,
0.0301714782,
-0.0120634492,
0.0022142266,
0.0525084212,
-0.0126362722,
0.0212354958,
0.0540456213,
-0.0125536742,
0.0015478792,
-0.0244989302,
-0.0120904921,
-0.0012535456,
0.0191041175,
-0.0454603024,
-0.0482975394,
-0.005626413,
0.0250610746,
-0.0670336932,
-0.0446432643,
0.0811953694,
-0.0263010263,
-0.0232439209,
-0.0451803207,
-0.0079077426,
-0.0590360276,
0.0844764188,
0.0100407926,
-0.0033292433,
-0.0213553943,
-0.0286003202,
-0.0041359547,
-0.0229933318,
0.011625939,
-0.0398544632,
0.0684326217,
-0.0150357932,
0.0422730297,
-0.0023410728,
-0.040096201,
-0.0167053267,
-0.0236575343,
-0.0163589716,
0.0422133096,
-0.0210298318,
-0.0071685174,
-0.0502157472,
-0.0002382351,
0.0602447465,
0.0327743851,
-0.0271220785,
-0.0324258208,
-0.0158261117,
0.0442781933,
0.0533961765,
-0.0134439981,
0.0175863709,
-0.0287503935,
0.0311811138,
0.0868746862,
0.0593996495,
-0.0260323603,
-0.0352835469,
-0.0196361933,
0.0088010449,
-0.0336092152,
-0.0243935827,
-0.0112867178,
0.0216002893,
-0.086418286,
-0.0153000224,
0.0975620896,
0.0355799533,
-0.042244032,
-0.0373481326,
-0.0489607267,
0.0659264699,
0.0192472935,
0.0329804718,
-0.0324273519,
-0.0355230272,
0.0346352234,
0.0235026758,
0.0295923129,
-0.0239421856,
0.0272295792,
-0.1173278317,
0.0198995378,
-0.0042952257,
-0.1050501317,
-0.0384499058,
-0.0371474847,
0.0020841376,
0.0229132492,
-0.0183132421,
0.0589805022,
-0.0227649994,
0.0024714326,
-0.0083467411,
-0.0546450317,
0.060414888,
0.0298833624,
-0.019825561,
-0.0477693304,
0.0745559186,
0.0284231249,
0.0240560807,
-0.0031059124,
0.030639641,
-0.0758746192,
-0.0027949824,
-0.0043537258,
0.0064283269,
-0.0314610414,
0.0289268643,
-0.0370724313,
0.0177067351,
-0.0132699795,
0.0009986827,
0.0002630236,
0.0848446712,
-0.0047639315,
0.0059527634,
-0.0455364175,
-0.0260894671,
-0.0443333797,
0.0726522505,
0.0153420558,
0.0326973163,
-0.0722075403,
-0.0286742188,
0.0217131451,
-0.0077672075,
-0.0043940074,
0.000472101,
-0.0096394224,
0.0336437523,
-0.0715697855,
-0.0623403862,
0.0254652333,
0.0123784253,
-0.0499135256,
0.0016856939,
-0.0235107932,
-0.0232504569,
-0.0693465695,
0.0289603733,
-0.0479553975,
0.0171494167,
0.008741688,
0.0271308795,
0.0533219576,
0.0016967949,
-0.0134595353,
0.0281139184,
-0.0198416226,
-0.0466600396,
-0.0512220263,
0.0225682128,
0.0186961293,
0.0692467019,
-0.0107355425,
-0.0081505449,
0.0414208025,
-0.0377446935,
-0.0523108765,
0.0107800262,
0.0205558836,
0.0410388634,
0.0046015256,
0.0440036058,
-0.0900329575,
0.0086963158,
-0.0303482786,
0.0632396117,
-0.0272103939,
-0.0009770475,
0.0213952828,
0.01969181,
0.0316019915,
0.0278888047,
-0.0100946715,
-0.0020636257,
0.0103991097,
-0.0461557582,
-0.0274545942,
-0.0262548421,
0.0407071859,
-0.0027144062,
-0.0248393398,
-0.014645597,
0.0376999341,
0.0303785782,
0.0329621509,
-0.015183052,
-0.0258260835,
0.0076930751,
-0.0372789539,
-0.0086420281,
-0.000493505,
-0.0440960564,
-0.0449367985,
-0.0096679861,
0.0418943837,
-0.0134209171,
0.0114162182,
0.0272821561,
0.004077706,
-0.0565208793,
0.0081595378,
-0.110579215,
-0.0397715196,
-0.0234428849,
-0.0184030551,
0.0200070739,
-0.0311963093,
0.0466818772,
0.0039339978,
-0.0178396571,
-0.0081728678,
-0.010279092,
0.0294484459,
-0.0610518418,
0.0206270963,
0.0500080027,
-0.0180155337,
0.02082262,
0.0608138703,
-0.0366659053,
0.0073014772,
-0.0011116078,
-0.0110072419,
-0.0158619937,
-0.0075294091,
-0.0148422299,
0.0574416555,
0.0037702231,
-0.0185746606,
-0.0337525234,
-0.0568136796,
0.0053294864,
0.0133967465,
-0.0182576794,
-0.0151459742,
0.0399346985,
0.0563694611,
0.041189108,
-0.0539447814,
-0.0257658493,
0.0015945885,
-0.0393203534,
-0.0054442463,
-0.0256594755,
-6.258547186e-33,
-0.0300149154,
-0.0006630466,
0.0293438323,
0.0063497508,
-0.0549069978,
0.0277731773,
-0.0546357185,
0.0026275374,
-0.0113350004,
0.0081835696,
-0.0348372236,
0.0350670815,
-0.0075967279,
0.0516681075,
0.010614478,
0.0202697851,
0.016694732,
0.0060096001,
-0.0293837134,
0.0235451758,
0.064673163,
0.0244590025,
0.0144232977,
-0.0239454135,
-0.0047053443,
-0.0103071062,
0.0238181446,
0.0467078388,
-0.0102154342,
0.0482269712,
0.0118419435,
0.0242537744,
0.0436314754,
-0.0370464027,
-0.0270801857,
0.0343808271,
-0.1395654827,
-0.0248483103,
0.0117758596,
-0.0518363379,
-0.0775931552,
0.0023441704,
0.0630623773,
-0.0197976585,
0.0760470703,
-0.0568867624,
0.0323001705,
-0.0283637419,
-0.0519815683,
-0.0421600193,
-0.0245328322,
0.0278051309,
0.0071085282,
0.0044567203,
0.0161306169,
0.0556351654,
0.0226561036,
0.0553389117,
-0.0547023118,
-0.0118799992,
-0.0502651073,
0.034573216,
0.0077691451,
0.0091948267,
0.0142822471,
0.0504604243,
0.0185433719,
0.0039866008,
-0.0453322977,
-0.0145119838,
-0.0157711506,
0.0212819558,
0.0348170996,
-0.0033981446,
0.0378436223,
0.0251013841,
-0.0370224342,
0.0422435626,
0.0056241667,
0.0884139985,
0.0046247174,
0.056005694,
-0.0430608355,
-0.0266236346,
-0.0282493122,
0.0324781798,
-0.039580252,
-0.0085665165,
0.0156884007,
0.0300732851,
0.0022272712,
-0.0182886627,
0.019241957,
-0.0157805029,
0.0362944193,
0.0546913445,
-0.0134706702,
0.0110920835,
-0.0028032043,
0.0369440727,
-0.0189742371,
0.0251319092,
0.0009722844,
-0.0098492177,
-0.0417950898,
0.0198753215,
0.0248755813,
-0.0086711748,
-0.0728888214,
0.0106712356,
-0.0062668165,
0.0218980778,
-0.0496412627,
0.0210947841,
0.03808726,
0.0399239473,
0.0242260434,
0.0597323701,
0.0017327258,
0.0237576347,
-0.0343196802,
-0.0108800437,
0.0057922946,
-0.0082838563,
0.0172339249,
0.0367785916,
-0.0109079396,
0.0371041521,
0.0239291023,
-0.0545157492,
-0.0044918018,
0.0331960693,
2.685e-7,
0.039100647,
0.0165952034,
0.0589843318,
0.0332678221,
0.0180579778,
0.0102453958,
0.0184931308,
0.0157604571,
0.0437298976,
-0.0419961959,
-0.0056431661,
0.0353654698,
0.0692905262,
0.0356207564,
-0.1179409772,
0.0046798866,
-0.0800292715,
-0.0468213856,
-0.0235257614,
-0.0369774662,
0.0322044566,
0.0848926306,
0.0152189313,
0.0007897039,
-0.0200154111,
-0.0443807729,
0.0582142286,
0.0190930236,
-0.0040746932,
-0.0176091548,
0.0266599581,
0.0415553115,
0.0058304337,
-0.0208353084,
0.0038076565,
0.0479872636,
0.0157100949,
0.0476739965,
-0.0169005468,
-0.0446135066,
0.0287940819,
-0.0316508226,
0.0049827769,
-0.0201498922,
0.0779445767,
-0.0355592482,
0.0173277184,
0.0052574826,
-0.056617301,
0.0000393124,
-0.0191749167,
0.0301759988,
-0.0372860357,
0.0447424799,
-0.0181305893,
-0.0047931997,
-0.0006948064,
-0.1248519719,
-0.01911081,
0.0177846625,
-0.0300365444,
-0.001447367,
-0.0309974775,
0.0278222617,
-0.0054481174,
-0.0535312518,
-0.0248174816,
2.399739575e-34,
0.0580138192,
-0.0165131222,
-0.0033619551,
0.0516954549,
0.050200209,
-0.0132779889,
-0.0012005164,
-0.0040128306,
0.0219190177,
-0.099780947,
-0.0255095959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18058v1 | LongAlign: A Recipe for Long Context Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | Yushi Bai, Xin Lv, Jiajie Zhang, Yuze He, Ji Qi, Lei Hou, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Extending large language models to effectively handle long contexts requires
instruction fine-tuning on input sequences of similar length. To address this,
we present LongAlign -- a recipe of the instruction data, training, and
evaluation for long context alignment. First, we construct a long
instruction-following dataset using Self-Instruct. To ensure the data
diversity, it covers a broad range of tasks from various long context sources.
Second, we adopt the packing and sorted batching strategies to speed up
supervised fine-tuning on data with varied length distributions. Additionally,
we develop a loss weighting method to balance the contribution to the loss
across different sequences during packing training. Third, we introduce the
LongBench-Chat benchmark for evaluating instruction-following capabilities on
queries of 10k-100k in length. Experiments show that LongAlign outperforms
existing recipes for LLMs in long context tasks by up to 30\%, while also
maintaining their proficiency in handling short, generic tasks. The code, data,
and long-aligned models are open-sourced at https://github.com/THUDM/LongAlign. | [
-0.0009114522,
0.0856305435,
0.0078998245,
0.0505872183,
-0.0438565798,
0.0117466701,
0.0164902136,
-0.0240634326,
-0.0158749335,
-0.0391587354,
-0.0540584773,
-0.0632582977,
-0.000265261,
-0.0127516212,
0.0682393238,
-0.0222150013,
0.0349683054,
-0.0290769953,
-0.0465374105,
0.0077288351,
-0.0002197495,
0.0179624893,
-0.0120072337,
0.0259433594,
-0.0037801869,
-0.0302244667,
-0.0394811966,
0.0290152878,
0.0021589906,
-0.0281205047,
0.038332507,
0.0373068415,
0.0193669721,
0.0166366231,
0.0000018057,
-0.0381165706,
-0.0225359909,
-0.0172437895,
-0.0599197708,
0.0138769243,
0.0168183148,
-0.0277490616,
-0.0072854096,
0.0439254865,
-0.0233532302,
0.0208662003,
0.032615833,
0.01154193,
0.0466782078,
0.1049453989,
0.0120352777,
-0.0338659659,
0.0216916073,
-0.0695736185,
0.0322360136,
-0.0532740988,
0.0118252207,
-0.0190290995,
0.0193560831,
0.0215420853,
-0.0386968069,
0.0388088338,
0.0346507765,
0.0001583788,
-0.0235985331,
0.0093154721,
-0.0328643881,
-0.0019238016,
0.0095668314,
0.0781962126,
-0.0182083566,
-0.0127662951,
0.0003207752,
0.0055023334,
0.0157711115,
-0.0707185343,
-0.0269436296,
0.0234276615,
0.0256682783,
0.0029176711,
0.0266703963,
-0.0208581686,
0.0357321128,
-0.0144281024,
-0.0554211773,
0.0407081582,
0.0242338367,
-0.0217630863,
-0.0338572673,
-0.0282283742,
-0.0178121086,
-0.046274472,
-0.0299076848,
0.0372414477,
-0.0528681129,
0.0388824195,
-0.0552611463,
-0.0123963831,
0.0191546604,
-0.0219272226,
0.0142141106,
0.0580222122,
-0.0259402394,
0.0525642149,
-0.0254435875,
0.0595526285,
-0.0067590554,
0.0203652382,
-0.0590827465,
-0.00066381,
-0.032387808,
0.0251031108,
-0.0351823494,
-0.0159536935,
-0.0483918525,
-0.0263854377,
-0.0470879599,
0.0314182043,
0.0107781608,
0.0360228382,
0.0397083201,
-0.0109748608,
-0.0568041429,
-0.0061170142,
0.0190765243,
0.0463313237,
-0.0174257532,
0.005808413,
0.0162696764,
-0.0427349508,
-0.0267354436,
0.0328492373,
-0.0068601696,
-0.0436682962,
0.0123416074,
0.0684052855,
0.0107680913,
-0.0395093597,
-0.0580452979,
-0.0173450727,
-0.0350087173,
-0.0721304268,
-0.0244887061,
-0.0706305429,
0.04500046,
-0.0087534189,
0.0037130243,
-0.030672485,
0.0057092523,
0.0017166381,
0.0184702519,
0.0918340608,
0.0373289324,
0.0165875982,
0.0067817369,
0.0035988847,
0.0398168042,
0.0901566967,
0.0017831911,
0.0120364921,
0.0256224498,
-0.0075142523,
-0.0310282167,
0.0452877581,
0.0355605967,
0.0087823179,
-0.0418403894,
0.0396008492,
0.0500632636,
0.0674932897,
0.0432311967,
0.0450603776,
0.0011057882,
-0.0283815116,
0.0256891977,
0.0311093871,
0.0652410015,
-0.0319916159,
0.0421879292,
0.0041266656,
-0.0422146842,
0.0081927469,
-0.0749398842,
0.0153686432,
0.0093866037,
0.0350366905,
0.0471192077,
0.0268098973,
-0.040389929,
-0.0164051428,
-0.0155105488,
-0.0237714928,
-0.0153059671,
0.0123904618,
0.0179428123,
-0.0013521448,
-0.048779238,
0.0436907522,
0.0204601884,
-0.0344156958,
0.001321094,
-0.001836505,
0.0036572905,
0.067586638,
0.0050472198,
-0.0314509235,
-0.0801208317,
0.0011676288,
0.0223075561,
0.0254308525,
0.0045394483,
-0.0129534854,
0.0307608657,
-0.0510594584,
-0.0311821606,
0.0054640193,
0.0047486955,
-0.0047741439,
0.0425722599,
0.0074474472,
0.0298432782,
-0.0327211656,
-0.0031632243,
0.0442133546,
-0.0903455541,
-0.0694212466,
-0.0381760038,
0.0334224775,
0.0284523144,
0.0020970448,
-0.0027887046,
0.0182012431,
0.0483635515,
-0.0368786342,
0.0231132768,
-0.0288010333,
-0.0742202252,
-0.0589625351,
0.0650276616,
0.0015946159,
-0.0297549814,
-0.0158211105,
-0.0490243547,
-0.0572245717,
-0.0051227841,
-0.0199231356,
0.0376921929,
-0.0065200184,
0.036371313,
0.0206508692,
0.002317087,
-0.0610550866,
0.0290745217,
-0.0140165556,
0.0230710842,
0.0302619599,
0.0278723016,
-0.0229064506,
-0.0579439402,
-0.0063201524,
0.0090189381,
0.0033860805,
-0.0051081986,
-0.0122009814,
0.0165036581,
-0.0465444215,
-0.0345829315,
-0.0999655575,
0.0492817834,
-0.0462263674,
0.0502957068,
0.0285447091,
0.017556319,
-0.0098504117,
-0.012864734,
-0.0753751844,
-0.0189326424,
-0.005976689,
0.0193791464,
0.0288900863,
0.0228363741,
-0.0535254963,
-0.0598053411,
-0.0208315589,
-0.0223024003,
0.0127181439,
-0.0438388959,
-0.0009162265,
-0.0675079823,
0.0235595014,
-0.0073178019,
0.0277004279,
-0.0315917134,
-0.0450908095,
-0.0338051878,
-0.0299239829,
0.0397880301,
0.0656469092,
0.0189621747,
-0.0023708385,
0.0098510748,
-0.0035845854,
-0.040770527,
0.0106994836,
-0.0201085713,
-0.0309187546,
-0.0622970648,
-0.0107936701,
-0.0202059001,
0.0612816773,
-0.0266182087,
0.0069538075,
-0.0470818169,
-0.0459347926,
0.0107485326,
0.0112392381,
-0.0037272251,
0.0147534525,
-0.017940782,
-0.0001958616,
-0.0344661325,
-0.0439155176,
0.0508051589,
-0.0519104153,
-0.0030988848,
-0.02623141,
-0.0391502231,
-0.0676313266,
0.0717755333,
0.0179591849,
0.0173510276,
-0.0112931747,
-0.0349554755,
-0.0691906437,
0.003858028,
-0.0116091501,
-0.0228332411,
0.0668385252,
-0.0321656615,
0.008837794,
-0.0274109282,
-0.0308651216,
-0.0289699193,
-0.0081133693,
0.0142119322,
0.0055540428,
0.0507505722,
-0.0271830112,
-0.018584596,
0.0124047389,
0.0109042702,
0.0585847385,
-0.0095541114,
0.041618675,
-0.0379859582,
0.0039205779,
0.0561425462,
0.0237854104,
0.0057272702,
-0.0357956514,
0.0097150598,
0.0344111621,
0.0640075281,
-0.0157997198,
-0.0278572254,
-0.0067548747,
0.0350796022,
-0.0363469943,
-0.0098147932,
0.0195433255,
0.0690319464,
-0.0755484998,
-0.0126343733,
0.1036915183,
-0.002662536,
-0.0573203713,
0.012254932,
0.0256072059,
0.0406906568,
0.0337095186,
0.0262507554,
-0.0956119001,
-0.0427995548,
0.0168156829,
0.0149958003,
0.039367754,
-0.0091164326,
0.0026799664,
-0.1326233447,
-0.0021801989,
0.0268494617,
-0.0629244819,
-0.0357432179,
-0.0259765945,
0.0044058128,
-0.0118424287,
0.0541887097,
0.0530151278,
-0.0352121629,
-0.0225146282,
0.02767184,
0.0151217328,
-0.04464316,
0.0201937631,
-0.0553465597,
0.099820599,
0.0408290811,
-0.0030723095,
0.0319052003,
-0.0069789812,
0.0665017813,
-0.014854948,
-0.0160348378,
0.0212765392,
0.0341445953,
-0.0413039736,
-0.0175180361,
0.0411437601,
0.0472533442,
-0.057204593,
0.0216037743,
0.0212331526,
0.0705510378,
-0.0113107599,
0.0379559472,
-0.0126227522,
-0.0277928449,
0.0236114189,
0.0729983971,
0.0354584306,
-0.0046992674,
-0.0330026932,
-0.0178827345,
-0.0276101846,
-0.0323336422,
0.0126296701,
0.0290977359,
-0.0475259051,
-0.0095882472,
-0.0487424023,
-0.0333114155,
0.0401142165,
0.0590908714,
0.0107320137,
0.0062117861,
-0.0089197792,
-0.0311521888,
-0.0638075247,
0.0342716016,
-0.0448295549,
0.0419968292,
-0.0924212411,
0.0040029176,
0.0284044836,
0.0124020725,
0.0124501055,
0.0339957215,
-0.1132719219,
-0.0824735314,
-0.0078108031,
0.0239887964,
0.011750401,
0.0766565055,
0.0019944736,
-0.0105002401,
-0.0012596404,
0.0289347358,
-0.0352920294,
0.0197779164,
0.0209700167,
-0.0041265646,
-0.0011091501,
0.0444931239,
-0.0362790227,
0.007531039,
-0.0031205826,
0.0620560385,
-0.0250724312,
-0.0344483517,
0.0052901711,
0.0026887653,
0.0060576461,
-0.0146439997,
-0.0060469043,
-0.00905139,
0.0692665651,
-0.0224265251,
-0.0255006868,
-0.0059152124,
-0.0015784125,
0.028653292,
-0.0067783953,
0.0368777104,
-0.0091335708,
0.0193553809,
0.0181896258,
-0.0362489782,
0.0520643629,
-0.0081685316,
-0.0043270094,
0.0438158847,
0.0259015206,
-0.005393187,
0.0101259081,
0.0190495588,
0.0531696267,
-0.0409212075,
0.0203163661,
0.0439644717,
0.03468211,
-0.0218308792,
0.0265928265,
-0.0331561342,
-0.0041228733,
-0.0287812185,
0.0055481698,
0.0689832792,
-0.0453187227,
0.0279565789,
0.0049635982,
-0.0129327206,
-0.0326856002,
0.046642676,
-0.0334733874,
0.0150832124,
0.018390825,
0.0553618558,
-0.0188663453,
0.015481798,
0.0744930282,
0.0240679365,
0.0565583296,
0.0332624689,
0.0153870378,
-0.0285744872,
-0.0311583318,
0.0196594317,
0.0183733925,
-0.0301061794,
-0.001024378,
0.0100078657,
-0.0800557807,
-0.0073175305,
0.0159198176,
-0.0184651408,
-0.0039853486,
0.0561543033,
0.0577904023,
-0.0104336394,
0.0015298983,
-0.0115844095,
0.0154426433,
0.0121808629,
-0.0514237359,
-0.0111555969,
-5.976244504e-33,
-0.0384380259,
-0.0155113386,
0.0534265935,
-0.0221773684,
-0.0599408634,
0.0033825191,
-0.0337759778,
-0.0132090757,
-0.0001256806,
-0.0027627409,
-0.0153397508,
0.0080852676,
0.0083940905,
0.0543893762,
0.0221549757,
-0.0298990533,
0.0307136048,
0.0168571826,
0.00958692,
0.0115338331,
0.0141642466,
0.0387189016,
0.0423356183,
-0.0242524799,
0.0019437602,
0.0027015477,
0.0129861869,
0.0384843461,
-0.0007779858,
0.069818221,
-0.0012938122,
0.0072660851,
0.0118235182,
-0.0411374159,
-0.025587108,
0.0131346211,
-0.0822312459,
0.0084378608,
0.0192540195,
0.0085525643,
-0.0382670648,
-0.0518828854,
0.0410312675,
-0.016466707,
-0.0198434778,
-0.002866901,
0.0145690944,
-0.0392067097,
-0.0236603878,
0.0157971699,
-0.0392633826,
0.020472642,
0.0000110423,
-0.0464323387,
0.0340694264,
0.0131474352,
0.0241176765,
0.0222291239,
-0.0280587245,
-0.0007415112,
-0.0205690637,
0.1114202365,
0.0841588601,
0.0396271385,
0.0069962847,
0.0218994562,
0.002657417,
-0.0171813592,
0.0126213776,
-0.017340105,
0.008981565,
0.0544586629,
0.0201486964,
0.011259201,
0.0379993506,
-0.0028516557,
-0.0445570461,
-0.0022959954,
0.0000131337,
0.0252675153,
-0.0026392643,
0.0340107121,
-0.0319590978,
-0.0112285968,
-0.0291419979,
0.0073957657,
-0.0237327795,
0.0054530627,
0.0399188213,
0.0232119579,
0.0084318863,
-0.0078005157,
0.0451447554,
-0.0300911814,
-0.0352851301,
0.0279744361,
-0.0034898445,
-0.0149262659,
-0.0079447934,
0.0476563685,
-0.0511401817,
-0.0382619724,
0.0101695014,
0.0014062746,
0.0161874983,
-0.0124181276,
0.0613558814,
0.0174762048,
-0.0630963668,
-0.0088779787,
-0.0610027984,
0.0140200788,
-0.0390036926,
0.0307117887,
0.0464214087,
0.0133161666,
0.0080020828,
0.095984377,
0.0119177634,
-0.0246767551,
-0.0073310332,
-0.0466435738,
-0.0024603966,
0.0128282011,
-0.0309456941,
0.013337275,
-0.0325467214,
0.0248804223,
0.010461377,
-0.0519477539,
-0.0040762825,
0.0201506726,
2.527e-7,
0.0428152047,
0.0247582011,
0.0884084851,
0.0294045191,
0.0002367285,
-0.000092813,
-0.0335608609,
0.040525388,
-0.0320741199,
-0.0210785121,
0.0026727347,
0.0146476198,
0.0515336208,
-0.0095660733,
-0.0862126648,
0.0166667551,
-0.0484966636,
0.0185323041,
-0.0620282926,
-0.0002429599,
0.0248952117,
0.1404785067,
-0.0058764275,
0.0023123957,
0.0083754165,
-0.0206598062,
0.012212418,
-0.0278173927,
-0.0165635459,
0.0309608504,
-0.011876449,
0.0073975311,
-0.0021066493,
-0.0207118504,
-0.0135159874,
0.0215617567,
-0.0188645069,
0.0837302431,
0.0155224185,
-0.0402463228,
0.0056949668,
-0.0093194423,
-0.0304575711,
-0.0180808604,
0.0421083979,
-0.0396912061,
-0.0029941925,
-0.0384337753,
-0.0129462201,
-0.0121584348,
0.0166913439,
0.0048133465,
0.0236709639,
0.0261333156,
0.0601873323,
-0.0315798707,
-0.029258186,
-0.1025414765,
-0.0349824764,
0.0256317463,
-0.0388514735,
-0.0017211334,
-0.0378731079,
-0.0030463636,
0.015862653,
-0.0612111762,
-0.0288576782,
2.78573243e-34,
0.0289799646,
-0.0150271328,
0.0172803998,
0.0430589914,
0.0255942475,
-0.0396251827,
-0.0595388226,
0.0403825603,
0.0202964861,
-0.0727085471,
-0.0417789519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18046v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18046v2 | Multipath parsing in the brain | 2024-01-31T18:07:12 | 2024-06-06T13:40:47 | Berta Franzluebbers, Donald Dunagan, Miloš Stanojević, Jan Buys, John T. Hale | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans understand sentences word-by-word, in the order that they hear them.
This incrementality entails resolving temporary ambiguities about syntactic
relationships. We investigate how humans process these syntactic ambiguities by
correlating predictions from incremental generative dependency parsers with
timecourse data from people undergoing functional neuroimaging while listening
to an audiobook. In particular, we compare competing hypotheses regarding the
number of developing syntactic analyses in play during word-by-word
comprehension: one vs more than one. This comparison involves evaluating
syntactic surprisal from a state-of-the-art dependency parser with LLM-adapted
encodings against an existing fMRI dataset. In both English and Chinese data,
we find evidence for multipath parsing. Brain regions associated with this
multipath effect include bilateral superior temporal gyrus. | [
0.0069805686,
0.0638190508,
-0.0419313312,
0.0158404466,
-0.0294680875,
0.0175208189,
0.0236711409,
0.0145621318,
0.0045210072,
0.0069063664,
-0.0093424683,
-0.0354368091,
0.0505686365,
0.0093432488,
0.0508257337,
-0.0506018661,
0.0268449113,
-0.0325093195,
-0.0113266213,
0.0166200362,
-0.0342562385,
0.008978351,
-0.0458387844,
0.0138244769,
-0.0196305308,
-0.0605080836,
0.0261812061,
-0.0179101117,
-0.0181416404,
-0.0280797612,
-0.0381779894,
0.0543367192,
0.0167341866,
-0.0002310874,
0.0000019552,
-0.0395633318,
0.0293475129,
0.0053812061,
0.0009824286,
-0.0007887125,
0.0005674086,
0.0013075515,
0.0136505896,
-0.0191841349,
-0.0239203442,
0.0014909594,
0.0001682357,
0.05998905,
-0.0248374306,
0.0270939767,
-0.0289125424,
-0.0606918857,
0.0153748989,
-0.0301405527,
0.0270677712,
0.00951281,
0.0123392269,
0.0079622073,
-0.0169815961,
-0.0011903499,
-0.0497777909,
0.0040767821,
0.0270629376,
0.0540904701,
-0.021274142,
0.0644559413,
0.038568262,
0.0258668456,
-0.0066072131,
0.0446066521,
0.041735433,
-0.0404818319,
-0.0125657562,
-0.0034965149,
0.0043272399,
0.0165914707,
-0.0356106944,
0.0639043748,
-0.0594004244,
0.03470378,
0.0462998264,
-0.0854963511,
0.0027957133,
-0.0313025601,
0.0143231228,
0.0898547918,
-0.0248324685,
-0.0643730611,
0.0309180748,
0.0269741379,
-0.1022122577,
-0.0330688171,
0.0236480702,
-0.0294733383,
-0.0233304482,
0.0150393462,
-0.0146358889,
-0.0483102091,
0.0026446956,
-0.0610068962,
-0.020592289,
0.043708086,
-0.0561762527,
0.0124654071,
0.0016461856,
0.0189941898,
-0.0441353954,
0.0359777436,
-0.0323528834,
0.0674268082,
-0.0275121555,
-0.0379109718,
-0.0210719518,
0.0243209098,
-0.0597329699,
-0.0223271437,
-0.0343161225,
-0.0155929001,
0.0265421476,
-0.0435481071,
-0.0232282132,
-0.0010898196,
-0.0236963239,
0.0581136681,
-0.0227047857,
0.0055293064,
-0.0363639854,
0.0671593025,
-0.0305338595,
-0.0301965512,
-0.039633777,
0.0623259507,
-0.0283985492,
-0.0334586538,
-0.0267820098,
0.0300213993,
-0.0342545249,
-0.0073444629,
-0.0449433848,
-0.0300535578,
-0.0236167237,
0.0000443535,
0.0332817771,
-0.0596874394,
0.0184524339,
0.0497404635,
-0.0234607086,
-0.0224296134,
-0.0154201509,
0.0152376294,
-0.0356359817,
0.0200264826,
0.0368618742,
0.0087634195,
0.0245965272,
0.0100626452,
-0.0254314989,
0.0232604463,
0.0448232628,
-0.0551574714,
-0.0374785848,
0.0037483554,
-0.0406948812,
0.0188505333,
-0.0672483742,
-0.0423496477,
-0.0583991744,
-0.0493430272,
-0.031031521,
0.0273517855,
0.0741635039,
0.0302983373,
-0.0372850448,
0.0017357909,
0.002853875,
0.0596313179,
-0.0279504638,
-0.0068585048,
0.0270508975,
-0.0064783315,
0.0250111595,
0.077301003,
-0.0196858924,
0.0277277995,
0.0355074778,
0.0017847419,
-0.0523064956,
-0.0145726819,
0.0367556997,
0.0006799353,
-0.0081281941,
-0.0082137613,
0.0216161851,
0.0050498047,
0.0223380607,
0.0007273163,
-0.0264023766,
0.0297953244,
0.015180517,
0.000824699,
-0.004870913,
0.0270182379,
-0.0245532375,
0.0317983478,
0.0067929402,
-0.00748447,
0.0044757621,
0.0088079525,
-0.005286599,
0.0670374036,
-0.0242240559,
0.043700438,
0.0575796738,
-0.0078270137,
0.0201001298,
0.0076350691,
-0.0023583926,
0.0041383146,
-0.0701974779,
-0.0268330686,
-0.0462424904,
0.0032963681,
-0.0043999366,
0.0513503291,
-0.0294047091,
0.0244133398,
-0.0132177398,
-0.0065403292,
0.0384631753,
-0.0338381976,
-0.0403327905,
0.0291839819,
0.0096179405,
-0.0220912471,
0.0035480517,
0.0441588126,
-0.0669240206,
-0.0378155485,
-0.0041621355,
-0.0057817549,
-0.0592690781,
0.0030073584,
0.0201391783,
-0.0138212303,
0.0145038124,
-0.0216764286,
0.0488327555,
-0.0173318796,
0.0079058129,
0.0018833622,
0.0663518235,
-0.0469158255,
0.0444985516,
-0.0121502401,
0.0361013003,
-0.0352995247,
-0.005972391,
0.0311280768,
-0.0076063732,
-0.0284544639,
0.0477754287,
-0.0126270764,
-0.0608929545,
-0.0460414104,
-0.0047244783,
-0.0586720333,
-0.0265152175,
-0.0493320748,
-0.0111390045,
0.0399955288,
0.0390447192,
0.014762721,
-0.0259744171,
0.0024322814,
0.0157434028,
0.0322088413,
-0.0029421747,
0.0051417742,
0.0303207003,
-0.0031996211,
-0.001726303,
0.0011616943,
-0.0079483986,
-0.0108272377,
-0.0667480454,
0.0321877562,
0.0045230361,
-0.0494694822,
-0.0635022521,
0.0354933254,
-0.0136436624,
-0.0028063243,
0.0122130672,
0.0021551768,
0.0562802218,
0.0227853265,
0.0754686818,
0.0551120117,
-0.0404298678,
0.0394005589,
0.0631084964,
-0.0441732742,
-0.0034841825,
-0.0009910397,
0.0305498056,
0.0277016107,
-0.0531250648,
-0.0115988925,
-0.0158963948,
0.1034216657,
0.0960350186,
0.016369123,
0.0058234599,
-0.0199239682,
-0.0602501482,
-0.0414353907,
-0.0140097467,
-0.0620964766,
-0.0710210875,
0.0409024581,
-0.0444981493,
0.0118063278,
0.0812156647,
-0.0096737584,
-0.0356786773,
-0.0491244867,
0.0393512398,
-0.0049356446,
0.0611306839,
0.0159709081,
-0.0090004653,
0.0251642205,
-0.0930160359,
-0.0675373599,
0.026605932,
-0.0001779031,
-0.0041057668,
0.0409980677,
-0.0538975298,
0.0022925462,
0.0194760375,
-0.019652009,
-0.0057259747,
-0.0137223853,
0.0210641474,
-0.0065343422,
0.0100901732,
0.0246423725,
-0.0016612337,
-0.0279453751,
0.0398071967,
0.0207126401,
-0.0329720378,
-0.0281584766,
-0.0190669801,
0.0471088812,
-0.0107433349,
0.0172451511,
0.0109273465,
-0.0426286496,
-0.0216849986,
0.046770256,
0.0118501699,
0.0355083309,
-0.009118814,
0.032132484,
0.0206302796,
-0.0079981992,
-0.0643311143,
0.0176262483,
-0.0064198896,
-0.0312051829,
-0.0081481468,
0.0867151916,
0.0107891448,
-0.0300096795,
0.0358919911,
-0.030095296,
0.0373919383,
0.0177906323,
0.0064382842,
-0.060299404,
0.0077217701,
0.0099234972,
0.0127338432,
-0.0027536824,
-0.027698312,
0.0156264678,
-0.0336989984,
0.0403163172,
-0.0003386902,
-0.0446348414,
0.0475634113,
0.0009735471,
0.0005302418,
0.0568874404,
0.0531771071,
0.0070908261,
-0.0180255473,
0.0239182841,
0.0252701361,
0.0040128171,
-0.0081008887,
-0.0230988991,
0.0030824861,
0.0459296219,
0.0168062449,
0.0190627538,
-0.0570454821,
-0.0106587084,
0.039081689,
0.0265813377,
0.0269254968,
-0.0277577359,
0.0200855564,
0.0689500123,
0.0142465904,
-0.0418403111,
0.0051226048,
-0.0073377951,
-0.0645342171,
-0.016098896,
0.0541810989,
-0.036136996,
0.0076408987,
0.0413791612,
0.0378908888,
-0.0194350872,
0.0497819446,
0.0378579386,
-0.0392639376,
0.0010615874,
-0.0070033059,
0.0463113338,
-0.0490837619,
-0.021146901,
0.0417586118,
0.0169990715,
0.0194056295,
-0.0609432086,
-0.0399654694,
0.005955196,
-0.0045894398,
0.0116597051,
0.0428726412,
0.0571214035,
-0.0616937801,
-0.021330338,
0.0143967215,
0.0476733409,
-0.0014773902,
-0.0242425054,
-0.0255966205,
-0.0174647998,
-0.0049668308,
-0.0327099338,
0.0395425633,
-0.0548445061,
-0.0377793089,
0.0574954525,
-0.0053769723,
0.017679438,
-0.0142117599,
-0.0029731281,
-0.0261591636,
-0.0338871107,
0.01987263,
-0.0305899922,
0.1062920094,
-0.0356899127,
0.0299343951,
0.015830094,
-0.0045765266,
0.0081003066,
-0.0192932151,
0.0010385363,
0.032060504,
0.017102126,
0.041495204,
0.0393212028,
0.023952825,
0.0767088458,
-0.0207448155,
0.0499771647,
-0.0610449724,
-0.000760368,
-0.0287505873,
0.0411566012,
-0.0015878696,
-0.0262639765,
0.048989825,
0.0298252478,
-0.0483046733,
-0.0270235464,
0.0150154661,
-0.0078207608,
0.0146238552,
-0.0217258111,
-0.0277409926,
-0.0572921969,
-0.0029364396,
0.0394133665,
0.0045494288,
0.0016839836,
-0.0260762889,
0.0010914861,
0.0258751698,
0.0499171242,
0.0210029408,
0.0035926332,
-0.0360361971,
-0.0507300533,
-0.0141976764,
-0.0422318652,
0.0592624471,
-0.0224350132,
0.0213689301,
-0.0208048094,
0.0931477994,
-0.0395536311,
0.0587455034,
-0.0119722867,
-0.0117216464,
-0.0373130776,
-0.0158163384,
0.0300493743,
-0.0035844101,
0.0119319651,
-0.0330076627,
0.1053388566,
-0.0130848587,
0.0099421656,
-0.0314646475,
-0.0086693903,
-0.0315976255,
-0.0717959031,
-0.0408434644,
0.0113931848,
-0.0595784336,
0.0320806466,
-0.0402368344,
-0.0291976463,
-0.0089309644,
-0.0181049462,
0.0445744246,
-0.0457124226,
-0.0137883648,
0.0441114381,
-0.0055239173,
-0.0913915411,
0.0207682308,
0.0256524589,
-0.0019056653,
-0.0664504841,
-0.0459184125,
-6.105340232e-33,
-0.0544503406,
-0.0093484325,
0.0087495726,
0.0503472835,
-0.0437358506,
-0.0181311816,
-0.0577489547,
0.0565746017,
0.0433435701,
0.0005968357,
-0.0126135023,
0.0097813755,
0.0292270295,
0.0241195653,
0.0875286832,
0.0177984331,
-0.0085147191,
-0.0300837569,
0.0077649374,
-0.0308714081,
0.0869565904,
0.0354473479,
0.1029578373,
-0.0286875106,
0.0108007928,
-0.0009850753,
-0.0003910338,
0.0103822611,
-0.0802870542,
0.047700014,
-0.0217610449,
0.0458251871,
0.0723321587,
0.0066580139,
-0.0179007035,
-0.009874871,
-0.04026049,
-0.0189730488,
0.0752447024,
0.0378474891,
-0.0595926121,
-0.0076513006,
0.0729333162,
-0.0349142887,
0.0275880005,
0.042513106,
0.043865107,
-0.0352628045,
0.0176379234,
0.0391242318,
-0.0726107061,
-0.0483378023,
-0.0051461346,
0.0350654535,
-0.0134284021,
0.0370491445,
-0.0534185767,
-0.0153188659,
-0.0446903817,
-0.0289261825,
-0.019454876,
0.0663196072,
-0.0220196843,
0.0173524059,
0.0367042013,
0.0444757231,
0.0436728783,
-0.0420153402,
-0.0141068725,
0.0241957139,
0.0694282651,
0.0171453357,
-0.0555908829,
-0.0172580704,
0.0503848307,
-0.0262294561,
-0.0231470224,
-0.0225264654,
0.067489326,
0.0373504646,
-0.0058478513,
-0.0022556873,
0.0352008417,
-0.0333791934,
-0.0138068208,
-0.017391637,
-0.0335864946,
-0.0431738608,
0.0037568097,
-0.0349533856,
0.060443569,
-0.0230401289,
0.0545625836,
0.0184499491,
-0.0188813489,
-0.0585115775,
-0.0314703658,
0.0396592803,
0.0162276402,
0.0205198862,
-0.0266440623,
-0.0237723142,
0.0161712058,
-0.0290373005,
0.073120974,
-0.0063771643,
0.0291640647,
-0.0263115726,
-0.016910661,
0.0091114352,
-0.0312819555,
-0.0326043516,
0.0420420617,
0.0033661569,
0.0356800035,
0.0210501384,
-0.0231362265,
-0.0092221452,
0.0032213354,
0.0231634919,
-0.0724674538,
-0.0088256998,
-0.0479657985,
0.0393915065,
-0.0079186419,
-0.0224707071,
0.0222052597,
-0.0158308446,
0.0413739644,
-0.0625019297,
-0.0482768975,
0.0328030325,
2.852e-7,
0.0652061924,
0.0541876368,
-0.0006148034,
0.0339249894,
0.0535861291,
-0.0324034728,
-0.0376508795,
0.016252635,
-0.0016187649,
-0.0258971769,
-0.0439791791,
0.0299432166,
0.0192007795,
0.0057515451,
-0.0515832715,
-0.0118390406,
-0.0394310504,
0.0574309379,
-0.0529315658,
-0.0014467213,
0.0521948598,
-0.0045374902,
-0.0425644554,
-0.0156322923,
-0.0370882861,
0.0324228778,
0.0689121187,
0.0098701008,
0.0106361955,
-0.004756771,
-0.0163920652,
-0.0494236685,
0.0242887679,
0.041244287,
0.0215008799,
-0.0083027072,
0.0106056491,
0.0316190161,
0.0322407857,
0.0011568108,
0.0184596032,
0.0458907336,
-0.0212863088,
-0.0208691861,
-0.0067717736,
-0.0651619881,
-0.0739674047,
0.0674128905,
-0.0195163805,
0.0073377048,
0.0313033499,
0.0232740138,
-0.0027683969,
0.0009000045,
0.0164723191,
0.0018963218,
-0.0181283709,
0.0048875534,
-0.0169829763,
0.082791537,
-0.066566363,
0.0127636874,
-0.0054245824,
-0.0164449997,
0.0168938376,
-0.034522973,
-0.0476194955,
2.286028634e-34,
-0.0291469041,
-0.0018690299,
0.068471536,
0.0240911338,
0.0049545853,
-0.0326817669,
-0.0136580216,
0.0355228484,
-0.0567525402,
-0.0802578181,
-0.0175399948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18045v1 | SpeechComposer: Unifying Multiple Speech Tasks with Prompt Composition | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | Yihan Wu, Soumi Maiti, Yifan Peng, Wangyou Zhang, Chenda Li, Yuyue Wang, Xihua Wang, Shinji Watanabe, Ruihua Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advancements in language models have significantly enhanced
performance in multiple speech-related tasks. Existing speech language models
typically utilize task-dependent prompt tokens to unify various speech tasks in
a single model. However, this design omits the intrinsic connections between
different speech tasks, which can potentially boost the performance of each
task. In this work, we propose a novel decoder-only speech language model,
SpeechComposer, that can unify common speech tasks by composing a fixed set of
prompt tokens. Built upon four primary tasks -- speech synthesis, speech
recognition, speech language modeling, and text language modeling --
SpeechComposer can easily extend to more speech tasks via compositions of
well-designed prompt tokens, like voice conversion and speech enhancement. The
unification of prompt tokens also makes it possible for knowledge sharing among
different speech tasks in a more structured manner. Experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed SpeechComposer can improve the performance of
both primary tasks and composite tasks, showing the effectiveness of the shared
prompt tokens. Remarkably, the unified decoder-only model achieves a comparable
and even better performance than the baselines which are expert models designed
for single tasks. | [
0.0029376314,
0.0515074283,
0.0046498459,
-0.0234068502,
-0.0273120999,
-0.03399425,
0.0612473786,
0.0005814562,
-0.0643910766,
-0.0281774793,
-0.041986458,
-0.0129141873,
0.0396165475,
0.0356231742,
0.0225726925,
-0.0925741047,
0.0272095148,
-0.0689139217,
0.0002203636,
-0.0060807816,
-0.0086111547,
0.0278456248,
-0.032191202,
0.0636980757,
-0.0306096859,
0.0009747493,
-0.0250809714,
0.0025906672,
-0.0093491301,
0.0244925283,
-0.003324311,
0.0196985248,
0.0260663629,
-0.0096495487,
0.0000019668,
-0.0453995839,
0.0059610819,
0.0030186109,
-0.0347637385,
-0.0103599699,
0.0425237827,
0.0129206283,
0.0056234421,
0.0820605978,
-0.0069249938,
-0.0280481912,
0.0541796051,
0.0396339074,
0.0384038575,
0.0480762906,
-0.0089341793,
-0.0055066221,
0.0271388553,
-0.0084378868,
-0.0285389684,
-0.0060394998,
-0.0234408788,
-0.0443022996,
0.0243851915,
-0.0266073849,
-0.0187854562,
0.0517382063,
0.011833501,
0.0057820124,
0.0281290114,
0.0045588822,
0.016930839,
-0.0646771193,
-0.0698505864,
0.0207404383,
-0.0403650627,
-0.0173669867,
0.0245300718,
0.0157742016,
0.0155904228,
-0.0211292226,
-0.0231073555,
0.0118540404,
-0.0008662403,
0.0038295491,
-0.0056353598,
0.0402519852,
0.0087994086,
-0.0326859206,
-0.0434797555,
0.0343995206,
0.0355645865,
-0.0147738475,
-0.02871681,
-0.0290791709,
0.0122764828,
-0.0524469577,
0.0614127293,
0.0325856023,
-0.068490386,
0.0003590817,
-0.0638546646,
-0.0557131656,
-0.0111985058,
0.0228400528,
0.0254247207,
0.0656655654,
-0.0432976708,
0.0104729934,
-0.0091252169,
0.0533674061,
0.0178052261,
-0.0129552241,
-0.0436185971,
-0.0482142307,
-0.0237666648,
-0.0159169585,
-0.0561820604,
0.0640007704,
-0.0799499899,
-0.0622811802,
0.0123228608,
0.0287802871,
0.0091022318,
-0.0219300706,
0.0705780908,
0.0145205585,
-0.019069761,
-0.0320759974,
0.015320926,
0.0191196389,
-0.004232313,
0.0605848022,
0.0342104249,
-0.0679399967,
0.0014655215,
-0.0012664102,
0.0348284766,
0.0106643299,
-0.0268908031,
0.0640918165,
-0.0437611528,
0.0074039092,
-0.0036383558,
-0.0420397148,
0.0003872505,
-0.0289906915,
-0.0437331647,
-0.0527655631,
0.0576234348,
0.0111405496,
0.003087797,
-0.0115246736,
0.0045927949,
-0.0104982248,
0.0135572013,
0.0757495686,
-0.0235697012,
0.0401947834,
0.0728439763,
0.001306164,
-0.0160539374,
0.0437652431,
0.0325632319,
-0.0024424619,
-0.0032500329,
-0.0187530965,
0.0041302745,
0.0565003008,
-0.0181684885,
-0.0465719216,
0.012476203,
-0.0268909428,
-0.0032260062,
-0.029239919,
0.0381922275,
0.0529568829,
-0.0339010991,
0.0497254767,
0.0543271415,
0.0425243154,
0.0190699659,
-0.0012726588,
0.05860544,
0.0367844962,
-0.0079911314,
-0.0090307454,
-0.0361282416,
-0.0006895172,
-0.0290321484,
0.0013435894,
0.0412673466,
0.0560350716,
-0.0328084938,
-0.0303573124,
0.0305533689,
-0.0530619361,
0.0055695274,
0.0246333275,
0.0360158719,
0.0232172217,
-0.081602253,
0.0427407287,
-0.0041935174,
-0.1034415439,
0.0363711938,
-0.0249229576,
0.0056387344,
0.07451199,
0.0107840737,
0.0148070976,
-0.0127406027,
-0.0201360751,
-0.0191919934,
0.0242162906,
0.0291369166,
-0.0074300487,
0.0450893268,
-0.0612648204,
-0.0240603182,
0.0397543013,
0.0123444619,
0.0506057218,
-0.0175595786,
-0.0028025678,
0.0199966226,
0.0068693398,
0.0512376837,
0.000318866,
-0.0014374146,
0.0132087693,
0.0241706893,
0.0026723251,
0.0393510908,
0.0077139162,
-0.0088030817,
0.0313448012,
0.009266898,
-0.0537915118,
-0.0216842052,
0.0522737242,
-0.0645092279,
-0.0356548093,
0.0372590832,
-0.0059856637,
0.0368010253,
0.04108046,
0.0116688153,
-0.1225112006,
0.0056650201,
-0.0236737579,
0.0541074015,
-0.005346647,
0.0547696166,
0.0147667825,
0.0033234775,
0.0302609261,
-0.0109357759,
0.0105122244,
-0.0244060606,
0.0773685798,
0.0458718427,
-0.0226443764,
-0.0622813292,
-0.0159775149,
0.0012394128,
-0.0425745733,
0.03255786,
0.013557015,
-0.025052255,
0.007395403,
-0.0336629935,
-0.1097950637,
0.0100628324,
-0.0091017755,
-0.0097870082,
0.0213353317,
0.0377595536,
0.0178635977,
-0.0186621696,
-0.0392630287,
-0.0452717505,
0.004986329,
-0.0193315055,
-0.0586282127,
-0.0330128968,
-0.0415703431,
-0.0263158381,
0.0149728088,
0.030566847,
0.0047964696,
-0.0354375876,
-0.058097329,
-0.0447797664,
0.0117043396,
0.0335607864,
0.053362783,
0.0053626411,
0.0014951478,
-0.0010736382,
0.00003909,
0.0721672475,
0.0166348871,
0.0224215183,
-0.0217634197,
0.0140379686,
-0.0273540448,
-0.0768354833,
0.0189006645,
0.0051160823,
0.0140217049,
-0.0145106865,
-0.0250866544,
0.0143428864,
0.0220802501,
0.0716937259,
0.0245185643,
-0.0810157284,
-0.0239153337,
-0.0118171368,
-0.0568400584,
-0.0343156494,
-0.049697265,
-0.0656718463,
0.0339676999,
-0.0227945391,
-0.0318840593,
0.0119046401,
-0.0786567926,
-0.0317667983,
-0.0002891093,
-0.0175118782,
-0.0068686926,
0.0208832063,
-0.0224106759,
0.0114989989,
-0.0186570305,
-0.0578884929,
-0.0111348666,
0.0329091363,
-0.0176605787,
-0.0754391551,
-0.0008330869,
-0.0511792824,
-0.0139569147,
-0.0167050641,
-0.0437256061,
-0.0475286134,
0.0430047475,
-0.0320336893,
0.0680373162,
0.0282370709,
-0.0249816664,
0.0087382942,
0.0333101228,
0.0018576609,
0.0628317446,
0.0026958147,
0.0228070449,
-0.0392940678,
0.0178809632,
0.0302958395,
0.0381514318,
-0.0420064293,
-0.0094094034,
0.0408809185,
-0.0106261317,
0.0963743776,
0.0231199954,
-0.0247136168,
-0.0033897073,
0.0599656217,
0.0020309261,
-0.0255210213,
0.049405925,
0.0586588159,
-0.0454312898,
0.0205509346,
0.1288916618,
0.0122259781,
-0.0118259676,
-0.0247384179,
-0.0039614695,
-0.0012009448,
0.0027669151,
-0.0039199712,
-0.0479216874,
-0.032355424,
0.0654933676,
0.0253915451,
0.025028795,
0.0357149206,
-0.0374543853,
-0.0967229605,
0.0324775912,
0.0150080342,
-0.0385959968,
-0.0491266958,
-0.0277166106,
-0.022098979,
0.0051379516,
0.0343670994,
0.0312941037,
0.0077986978,
-0.0273460764,
0.0419942401,
-0.0472667739,
-0.039836444,
0.0086458083,
-0.0110225305,
0.0978437588,
0.0713437051,
0.0036585701,
0.0168690141,
-0.0082055228,
0.0136025902,
0.0086654127,
0.0094256485,
0.0007613885,
0.0056300424,
0.0014522842,
-0.0014691908,
0.0241383892,
0.0491356365,
-0.0520728081,
-0.0033767556,
0.013356356,
0.0543638095,
0.0068822922,
-0.0083789472,
-0.0249692071,
-0.0015799165,
0.00855204,
0.0626984462,
0.019968085,
-0.0506701507,
-0.0339936577,
-0.0130882328,
0.0002290723,
-0.0682855472,
0.0026082646,
0.0248015672,
0.0096677998,
-0.0455314629,
-0.0299075432,
0.0184845049,
0.0447278693,
0.0313053057,
0.0297744628,
0.0375118218,
0.013611123,
0.0039173616,
-0.0270581711,
-0.033930596,
0.0060069561,
0.0264727362,
-0.0867154002,
-0.0187764987,
0.0185277145,
-0.0566032007,
0.0055336943,
0.0203833673,
-0.0281376578,
-0.0493779443,
-0.0260027479,
0.0185320247,
0.0258381367,
0.0417681262,
-0.0544093437,
-0.0553518385,
0.0596236698,
0.0340550616,
-0.0577658154,
0.0294203851,
0.0520846844,
-0.0127057098,
-0.014765474,
0.0079992125,
-0.063453421,
0.0184481554,
-0.0235887561,
0.0070852619,
0.0030739761,
-0.0567102432,
0.0120410295,
0.0452386923,
0.0156167075,
-0.0279290751,
0.0597479418,
-0.0227253772,
0.0062577841,
-0.0033619823,
0.0256124251,
-0.0575350821,
0.041532129,
0.0301438775,
0.0173852444,
0.0291465167,
0.0119477259,
0.0040719076,
-0.0023800994,
0.002155439,
0.0137038687,
-0.0069612549,
0.0158364009,
0.0352116451,
-0.0093053114,
-0.0216165744,
0.0094389841,
0.0026518661,
-0.0352244861,
-0.0260032602,
0.0005264145,
-0.020030953,
0.0079322197,
-0.0004394483,
0.0247549601,
-0.0471937694,
-0.0590237081,
-0.0254158545,
0.0377422385,
0.0193951279,
0.0393754691,
0.057202857,
-0.007032421,
0.0348408706,
-0.03326004,
0.0364898629,
0.0073544392,
-0.0171284787,
0.0081551941,
-0.003989351,
-0.0150384009,
-0.0421694107,
0.0574478358,
-0.0295914318,
0.0398588292,
-0.0471349806,
0.0248119906,
-0.0361446403,
-0.0344019271,
-0.0040648901,
0.0315945633,
-0.0361217,
-0.0180803873,
-0.0186887272,
-0.0330185257,
0.0258355625,
-0.0030876927,
0.0198312532,
-0.0201230552,
0.0456223041,
0.0002244485,
-0.0622616261,
-0.0138287405,
-0.0053007156,
-0.0312359408,
0.0280232076,
-0.0023512288,
0.0037065481,
-5.795119926e-33,
-0.0428716354,
0.0332072973,
0.0338912793,
-0.0180504769,
-0.0187921263,
-0.0161708221,
-0.0176257044,
0.0045085154,
-0.0110482369,
-0.0262680613,
-0.0332244076,
-0.0068860333,
0.0294672269,
0.040643923,
-0.0006102978,
0.0485519767,
0.1181143746,
-0.0270713903,
-0.0063183815,
0.0142187187,
0.0303337518,
0.0325703062,
0.0050813914,
-0.0348204561,
-0.034099482,
0.0011001504,
-0.0374432728,
-0.0145123862,
0.0259206612,
0.0144908438,
0.0133343004,
0.0488470532,
-0.0100625874,
-0.0655421242,
-0.0599009059,
0.0902259052,
-0.0807180852,
-0.0020564345,
0.0560568497,
0.0301421285,
-0.0473389141,
-0.0455772616,
0.0138152456,
0.011331087,
-0.0003114362,
-0.0052586505,
0.0170225762,
-0.0233838726,
-0.0072145001,
-0.0458542444,
-0.0244651586,
0.0092530278,
-0.019937383,
-0.0408725962,
0.0599910356,
0.0689267367,
-0.0188959446,
-0.0302182119,
-0.0310546327,
0.0508311056,
0.019536661,
0.0310663581,
0.0486395769,
0.0498002879,
-0.0246598441,
0.0180468,
0.0385367051,
-0.061575409,
-0.009905328,
0.0093953395,
0.0143366167,
0.0750789493,
0.032679446,
0.0265177581,
0.018186029,
-0.0629739538,
0.0212012231,
0.0081127202,
0.0411455519,
-0.0371315107,
0.036215011,
0.0309639852,
0.0013668269,
-0.0042827823,
-0.091219604,
-0.0100807659,
-0.0224529058,
-0.0002865538,
0.0805666223,
0.0435674712,
0.0007460785,
-0.0410037972,
0.0746600181,
-0.0057202717,
0.0393104777,
0.0330086723,
-0.0089996299,
0.0352768973,
-0.0311439391,
0.0096748071,
-0.0237102751,
-0.0461604968,
0.0879047737,
0.0072559915,
0.000866428,
0.0040565156,
-0.0472608954,
0.0452465825,
-0.055580467,
0.0047201095,
-0.0214582346,
0.0472367741,
0.0231740959,
0.0054495572,
0.0440361276,
-0.000175286,
-0.0307917278,
-0.0014598279,
-0.0406547002,
-0.014109754,
-0.022337079,
-0.0101095317,
-0.0213037319,
0.0133403651,
-0.027125407,
0.0119511727,
-0.0330699719,
-0.0040685423,
0.0596307777,
0.0256446432,
-0.0218015295,
0.0133996159,
2.692e-7,
-0.0163478386,
-0.0194755401,
0.0240322277,
-0.0138090849,
0.0209030211,
0.0037077183,
0.0043384167,
0.0340523086,
0.0097921342,
-0.0017801637,
-0.0263596103,
-0.0095056351,
0.057904873,
-0.005897677,
-0.0963728949,
-0.0549798124,
-0.0613241121,
0.0136098061,
-0.0238066744,
0.0211385861,
0.0358391069,
0.0780862719,
-0.0141580096,
-0.022999648,
-0.0076146014,
0.0093373228,
0.0181915686,
-0.0229725707,
0.0057116118,
0.0188190956,
0.00251658,
-0.0193699673,
-0.0089366036,
0.0242752898,
-0.0298830736,
0.0363163389,
0.0439930335,
0.0856178254,
0.0077672661,
-0.0476281717,
0.0074025951,
0.0260938648,
-0.0472370647,
0.0121619878,
0.0542592257,
-0.0086269677,
0.0358196124,
-0.0409059785,
-0.0593259521,
0.0491081402,
-0.0397917405,
-0.0070796059,
0.0076736407,
0.0245339256,
-0.0037631481,
0.0220458787,
-0.0186196044,
-0.0722856969,
-0.0225096252,
-0.0078909369,
-0.0802055523,
-0.050624419,
-0.0387940295,
-0.0166234765,
0.0084798206,
-0.0619159639,
-0.0051184362,
2.274945467e-34,
0.0134069743,
-0.0246057417,
0.0407992043,
0.0336332098,
0.0091709718,
-0.046794381,
-0.0256910734,
0.0568315834,
0.0110233165,
-0.0519031994,
-0.0672404543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18040v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18040v2 | Enhancing End-to-End Multi-Task Dialogue Systems: A Study on Intrinsic Motivation Reinforcement Learning Algorithms for Improved Training and Adaptability | 2024-01-31T18:03:39 | 2024-03-25T23:03:58 | Navin Kamuni, Hardik Shah, Sathishkumar Chintala, Naveen Kunchakuri, Sujatha Alla Old Dominion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | End-to-end multi-task dialogue systems are usually designed with separate
modules for the dialogue pipeline. Among these, the policy module is essential
for deciding what to do in response to user input. This policy is trained by
reinforcement learning algorithms by taking advantage of an environment in
which an agent receives feedback in the form of a reward signal. The current
dialogue systems, however, only provide meagre and simplistic rewards.
Investigating intrinsic motivation reinforcement learning algorithms is the
goal of this study. Through this, the agent can quickly accelerate training and
improve its capacity to judge the quality of its actions by teaching it an
internal incentive system. In particular, we adapt techniques for random
network distillation and curiosity-driven reinforcement learning to measure the
frequency of state visits and encourage exploration by using semantic
similarity between utterances. Experimental results on MultiWOZ, a
heterogeneous dataset, show that intrinsic motivation-based debate systems
outperform policies that depend on extrinsic incentives. By adopting random
network distillation, for example, which is trained using semantic similarity
between user-system dialogues, an astounding average success rate of 73% is
achieved. This is a significant improvement over the baseline Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO), which has an average success rate of 60%. In addition,
performance indicators such as booking rates and completion rates show a 10%
rise over the baseline. Furthermore, these intrinsic incentive models help
improve the system's policy's resilience in an increasing amount of domains.
This implies that they could be useful in scaling up to settings that cover a
wider range of domains. | [
0.0503064618,
0.050778687,
-0.0138505641,
-0.0011259579,
-0.0281281862,
0.0125752855,
-0.0107760793,
-0.0150517132,
-0.0092401179,
-0.0153707676,
-0.03951234,
-0.0090939365,
-0.0375067107,
0.0523773395,
0.0065835887,
-0.0752429962,
0.0400647484,
-0.0335595906,
0.0792590752,
0.0048852102,
0.0201213639,
-0.030647587,
-0.0228334237,
0.0651141927,
0.0099337129,
0.005349549,
-0.0489494316,
-0.0160373934,
0.0517419837,
-0.0617486537,
0.0173208583,
0.0141444039,
0.0697508827,
0.0487070195,
0.0000023017,
-0.0748673677,
-0.033709459,
-0.0373332612,
-0.0282925945,
-0.0614899881,
0.0481090099,
0.0893103182,
0.0174766872,
0.036024984,
-0.0321883373,
0.0367127284,
0.0421624705,
0.0841632113,
0.0541382208,
0.0437924117,
-0.0009572175,
-0.026248483,
-0.0124770952,
-0.0023827532,
0.0219620727,
-0.047386378,
-0.0060559125,
0.0201811921,
0.0051176231,
-0.0268842392,
-0.0021369488,
-0.0412190296,
0.0314889215,
-0.0284597389,
0.0043801572,
0.0384726413,
-0.0148473671,
-0.0251217615,
-0.0365973264,
0.0892639607,
-0.0107603399,
0.0233307853,
0.0118445428,
-0.011917132,
0.0091622779,
-0.0336955227,
-0.0490040518,
-0.0126688378,
-0.0214882307,
0.0150081189,
0.0108131943,
0.0576433502,
0.0045019109,
0.0135268942,
-0.0338295773,
0.0139129646,
-0.027032068,
-0.0546324663,
0.0437261797,
-0.0012591138,
0.0477577895,
-0.0577392466,
-0.0048004929,
0.0240108576,
-0.08591564,
0.0278652832,
-0.0013590705,
0.0141836675,
-0.0010592325,
-0.01942176,
0.014733674,
0.0325211994,
-0.0149911353,
0.0377984233,
0.0188652016,
0.0372663066,
-0.0105260676,
0.0441214927,
-0.0089244321,
0.0323605724,
-0.0813214704,
0.0081843324,
-0.0614654124,
0.0525377616,
-0.056387227,
-0.0533166751,
-0.0188141093,
0.0530422404,
-0.0318037122,
0.0227723885,
0.0117679201,
0.0497717001,
-0.0276007745,
0.0255204272,
-0.0839916393,
0.0211099368,
-0.0571060963,
0.0466607362,
0.05613859,
0.0231306646,
-0.0171666257,
0.0112064416,
0.0161760785,
0.0031143904,
0.0074000931,
0.1062080264,
-0.0261699464,
-0.0379072316,
-0.0228964537,
-0.0258513559,
-0.0024436645,
-0.0543360934,
-0.0091255875,
-0.024879219,
0.0236528851,
-0.0521663725,
-0.0348576009,
-0.0293760281,
0.0047640665,
-0.0071909199,
0.0024502531,
0.0539337322,
0.0312457401,
-0.0254627261,
0.0245417729,
0.0129209254,
-0.0282554477,
0.0366322398,
0.0468973517,
0.0467521064,
0.0384679027,
0.0089311488,
0.0033455011,
-0.0072553428,
0.0155543471,
0.0307555199,
0.0772596002,
0.0084862253,
-0.014068977,
0.0270170216,
0.0002244777,
0.0471788421,
-0.0621375665,
0.0288171414,
0.0528408661,
0.0563697405,
0.0058096074,
-0.055117026,
0.007146304,
0.043604482,
-0.0057339137,
-0.0262772832,
-0.0077021397,
0.059456449,
0.0827724561,
-0.0026761182,
0.0938118547,
0.0072303545,
-0.0396576375,
-0.0661855787,
0.0449235551,
0.0141673125,
0.0571534783,
0.0511326194,
0.0596477985,
0.0106590316,
-0.0703906342,
-0.0499498472,
0.0213403534,
0.0012177798,
-0.024371041,
-0.0826607421,
0.048685804,
0.0554269329,
0.0152013609,
0.0055281697,
-0.0185299367,
-0.0686887652,
-0.0311049819,
0.0454273708,
0.0221396554,
-0.0542144068,
0.0260736756,
-0.0389490053,
-0.0706511438,
-0.0321583413,
-0.0020066514,
0.0478380993,
-0.0120094214,
-0.0083543407,
-0.0216687173,
0.013227256,
-0.0245809145,
0.0043974258,
-0.0081290631,
-0.0025522329,
0.0160734113,
0.0097877029,
0.0468865186,
0.0344525129,
0.0068154135,
-0.0232598037,
0.0111477878,
0.010580672,
0.0064939465,
0.0530989021,
-0.0201918632,
-0.0177458897,
0.0305715147,
-0.0328037404,
0.0017984945,
-0.0160437282,
-0.0097829113,
-0.0384855941,
0.0417439565,
-0.0262518469,
0.0217276793,
-0.0345658101,
0.0129260253,
-0.0064090812,
-0.0143859666,
-0.045720581,
0.0345103331,
0.0170041211,
-0.0183249507,
0.0335768871,
-0.0118386094,
0.0568168201,
-0.0997639894,
0.0173687246,
-0.0113073848,
-0.0052088872,
0.0167499427,
0.0298077706,
0.0146185867,
-0.0594549105,
0.0101835076,
-0.0714139193,
-0.0021853177,
-0.0153188659,
0.0034037733,
0.0032151109,
0.0132248234,
0.0099772569,
-0.0428592935,
-0.0220357124,
-0.0032818245,
0.0371728092,
-0.005029087,
0.0445129946,
0.0534403957,
-0.0272459686,
-0.042170886,
0.02499667,
0.0034839844,
-0.0106214369,
0.0096294759,
0.0408205204,
-0.0475113019,
0.0019331541,
-0.0397505276,
0.0047032302,
-0.0314188898,
-0.0253654998,
0.0584595762,
0.0101503562,
0.0073450995,
0.0292762723,
0.027599059,
0.0220932607,
0.0119098397,
-0.0057425955,
-0.1009010226,
0.0435727276,
-0.0317358859,
0.0210232455,
-0.0468689613,
0.0128224632,
0.0469081625,
0.0643418133,
-0.0072924476,
0.0408817008,
-0.0517868921,
0.061071489,
0.0092044752,
-0.0418355651,
-0.0534974411,
0.0199836046,
-0.0420255437,
0.017513264,
-0.0228650756,
-0.0404399633,
0.0990239456,
0.0418021493,
-0.0081113605,
-0.0759200826,
-0.0468069762,
-0.0165720042,
0.0306939986,
-0.0488842353,
0.0140468217,
0.0320435874,
-0.0527202487,
-0.0427056924,
-0.0072276103,
0.0238996223,
-0.0319711603,
0.0453676619,
0.0045866435,
0.0055199028,
0.0114709493,
-0.0701229498,
-0.0678439587,
-0.0276613515,
-0.0086084688,
-0.0363659486,
0.0015861876,
-0.0180574358,
0.0013343361,
-0.0081756171,
0.0236143041,
0.0025042028,
0.0096360222,
-0.0335543789,
-0.0127441613,
-0.0047224909,
0.054710336,
0.0213191882,
0.0045293621,
-0.0195103195,
0.0349654444,
0.010321606,
0.0215225294,
-0.0660550371,
-0.0181320328,
0.0270984918,
-0.0042380928,
-0.0190884247,
0.0325716212,
0.0252011884,
0.057783626,
-0.039257545,
-0.0176815111,
0.0659986213,
0.0270976201,
-0.0255416036,
-0.0128216697,
-0.0476425067,
0.0467453972,
0.0151699763,
0.0444936827,
-0.0617305003,
-0.0241584182,
-0.0055685388,
0.0575060211,
-0.0164934713,
-0.0417582132,
0.0023508279,
-0.0890542567,
-0.001112142,
-0.029183669,
-0.047584217,
0.0051077972,
-0.02716011,
-0.0016864209,
-0.0141811585,
0.0046626385,
-0.0024258727,
0.0276931189,
-0.0250581875,
0.0308988746,
0.0561817624,
-0.0046700654,
0.0011760875,
-0.0350106023,
0.057262376,
0.0707343519,
0.0445082225,
0.0150576616,
-0.0212956909,
-0.0069502848,
0.0316338874,
0.0146227432,
0.0042782351,
0.0455015041,
-0.0163458735,
-0.0034981398,
-0.0312612988,
0.0485873222,
0.0108060045,
-0.0277740993,
0.0127148749,
0.0620266274,
-0.0418207869,
-0.0015371479,
-0.0237331744,
-0.0028093471,
0.0715302378,
0.0552513525,
-0.0209516194,
-0.049584005,
-0.051488474,
-0.0397988893,
-0.0555148236,
-0.0739741251,
0.0194620024,
-0.0241202023,
-0.0264947675,
0.0580719784,
-0.0436750725,
-0.064680852,
0.0027461895,
0.0385763831,
-0.0142449467,
-0.0117604937,
-0.0181365721,
0.0580202937,
0.0105458414,
-0.0120382821,
-0.0064182179,
0.0079023773,
-0.0379010327,
-0.0058473176,
0.0140617304,
-0.0471016988,
-0.0299043339,
-0.0208041444,
-0.0462290682,
-0.0482936986,
-0.0584141761,
0.0822545886,
0.0208359826,
0.0523749962,
0.0204430725,
-0.0051643811,
0.017028477,
-0.015967641,
-0.029398527,
-0.0527579337,
0.060213916,
0.0676174611,
-0.0174421594,
0.0033021003,
-0.0500659682,
0.0092808455,
-0.0176686402,
0.0328896567,
-0.0072087557,
-0.0047746687,
0.022755336,
-0.0202306844,
0.0214166306,
0.0025910481,
-0.0544740185,
-0.0347230844,
0.0255672447,
0.0270700511,
-0.0229424741,
-0.0429477766,
-0.0103064608,
0.0019452665,
-0.0007197798,
0.0202988051,
-0.0173767768,
0.0118433107,
0.0068570296,
-0.0056955484,
-0.0085603744,
0.0276393406,
0.0108917458,
-0.0079049869,
0.0043331771,
0.0181073695,
0.0383438841,
0.0441731736,
0.0304736253,
0.0025761898,
0.0808713436,
0.0319929309,
-0.0111387121,
-0.0030097908,
0.0281491,
-0.0658033267,
-0.0290464163,
0.0098445769,
-0.0073197996,
0.0184780415,
0.0589874834,
0.0095852185,
-0.0249327421,
0.0273069683,
0.0205733888,
0.0175222345,
-0.0327522531,
-0.0046382667,
0.0086265048,
0.0242947359,
-0.0031044954,
0.0010118516,
0.0597024821,
-0.0303001739,
0.0392888598,
-0.0549861975,
0.0157608241,
-0.0598621927,
0.0116350465,
-0.0085247857,
0.0872419998,
0.0128292907,
-0.0075366325,
-0.0246430524,
-0.0150755867,
-0.064803496,
0.0370408073,
-0.0037377158,
-0.0138723608,
0.0824587271,
0.0099542858,
-0.0210820548,
-0.0055270121,
-0.0062929732,
-0.0515456051,
0.00004421,
-0.0062441458,
-0.0428340435,
-5.932839007e-33,
0.0193547513,
-0.0116959512,
0.0595193692,
0.0145685226,
-0.0480219275,
-0.0691117048,
-0.0388370752,
-0.0006201997,
-0.0071641994,
0.0212300196,
-0.0146827763,
0.00330539,
0.0128659084,
-0.0064503555,
0.0105963489,
-0.033963412,
0.0735295266,
-0.008830945,
-0.0296199564,
0.0438799895,
0.0738864541,
0.0028391534,
0.0305201709,
-0.074458614,
0.0214927588,
0.0423188619,
0.0134497182,
0.043151021,
0.0296083894,
0.0330182426,
0.0109064104,
0.0188020729,
-0.0016165974,
-0.0601510368,
-0.0099937683,
0.0356347412,
-0.061795447,
-0.0753636584,
0.0095106615,
-0.0453985743,
-0.0442861579,
-0.0393042862,
0.0042889924,
-0.0002468533,
-0.0125282919,
0.010503835,
0.0005971105,
0.0186145026,
0.0152418911,
0.0084571522,
-0.0389117561,
-0.0178972892,
-0.0449326634,
-0.019426059,
0.0012938847,
0.0442979261,
-0.0096694464,
-0.0095299175,
-0.0134407552,
0.0710432827,
-0.045044478,
-0.0291562527,
0.0369999222,
0.0178609043,
0.0115910368,
0.050866887,
0.0254628584,
0.0190998446,
0.0008363558,
-0.0313923135,
0.0064045331,
0.046077054,
0.0044056601,
0.0367675684,
0.0299807638,
-0.0011361638,
-0.0414896011,
0.0515159108,
0.038336318,
0.045121666,
0.006668509,
0.0321104825,
-0.0134623656,
-0.0213509202,
-0.0417634025,
-0.0049023414,
-0.0053879148,
-0.079268761,
0.0573984943,
0.0567153767,
0.0124662621,
-0.021476442,
0.0371903889,
-0.0693335533,
-0.0091294618,
0.0589697622,
-0.0277063008,
0.0154426433,
0.0175869744,
-0.0762984529,
-0.0964604169,
-0.0387033485,
-0.0057009594,
0.037099909,
0.0233600847,
0.0077704499,
-0.0154674975,
-0.0069939811,
-0.0260412861,
0.0238683801,
-0.0217493773,
0.0385486931,
-0.0170517955,
0.0274616908,
0.0164587628,
0.0059659164,
-0.0276535805,
0.0381650627,
-0.0019098771,
-0.0090421494,
-0.043282412,
-0.0245584156,
0.004621963,
0.0098126074,
-0.019919673,
0.0089716138,
-0.0513061956,
0.0021571859,
-0.0245142933,
-0.0666831732,
-0.0188560691,
0.0119817425,
3.015e-7,
-0.0750000477,
0.0317480937,
0.0203208067,
0.0277896151,
0.0191578604,
0.0469859838,
0.000810109,
0.0146048451,
0.0116588129,
-0.0327815339,
0.0179505236,
0.0154587766,
0.0046105338,
0.0073283887,
-0.0982799828,
-0.083789058,
-0.0360521339,
-0.0125837652,
-0.0283206329,
0.0098267198,
0.0274193231,
0.0354743414,
0.0334329344,
0.0118402299,
0.0407745503,
-0.0116266944,
0.018935347,
-0.0096866898,
0.0019909677,
-0.0036615254,
-0.0227619801,
-0.0064040013,
-0.0190598331,
-0.0082263434,
-0.0214329716,
0.0687046498,
-0.0291956216,
0.0208185837,
0.0004875293,
-0.072679691,
-0.0401101783,
0.0101193422,
0.0366469808,
-0.0373989604,
0.0166477673,
-0.0591828302,
-0.0238341913,
-0.0055501014,
0.0103503931,
-0.0338472836,
0.0194525681,
-0.0155951381,
-0.0228046998,
-0.0363835171,
-0.0073631927,
0.0333238095,
0.0145150814,
-0.0921812057,
0.03836371,
-0.0002148058,
-0.0193072241,
-0.0740781873,
-0.0420851298,
0.0219146442,
0.011578572,
-0.0422477461,
-0.0141697945,
2.320627657e-34,
0.0005013173,
-0.0209026989,
0.027030807,
0.0167957433,
-0.0161868725,
0.0310987569,
-0.0151898554,
-0.0253462251,
0.0890453458,
-0.0405960716,
-0.0143799754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18034v1 | Paramanu: A Family of Novel Efficient Indic Generative Foundation Language Models | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | Mitodru Niyogi, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present Gyan AI Paramanu ("atom"), a family of novel language models for
Indian languages. It is a collection of auto-regressive monolingual, bilingual,
and multilingual Indic language models pretrained from scratch on a single GPU
for 10 Indian languages (Assamese, Bangla, Hindi, Konkani, Maithili, Marathi,
Odia, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu) across 5 scripts (Bangla, Devanagari, Odia,
Tamil, Telugu) of varying sizes ranging from 13.29M to 367.5M.The models are
pretrained with a context size of 1024 on a single GPU. The models are very
efficient, small, fast, and powerful. We have also developed an efficient most
advanced Indic tokenizer that can even tokenize unseen languages. In order to
avoid the "curse of multi-linguality" in our multilingual mParamanu model, we
pretrained on comparable corpora by typological grouping using the same script.
We performed human evaluation of our pretrained models for open end text
generation on grammar, coherence, creativity, and factuality metrics for
Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit. Our Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit models
outperformed GPT-3.5-Turbo (ChatGPT), Bloom 7B, LLaMa-2 7B, OPT 6.7B, GPT-J 6B,
GPTNeo 1.3B, GPT2-XL large language models (LLMs) by a large margin despite
being smaller in size by 66 to 20 times compared to standard 7B LLMs. To run
inference on our pretrained models, CPU is enough, and GPU is not needed. We
also instruction-tuned our pretrained Bangla, Hindi, Marathi, Tamil, and Telugu
models on 23k instructions in respective languages. Our pretrained and
instruction-tuned models which are first of its kind, most powerful efficient
small generative language models ever developed for Indic languages, and the
various results lead to the conclusion that high quality generative language
models are possible without high amount of compute power and humongous number
of parameters. We plan to release our models at https://www.bharatgpts.com. | [
0.0208239909,
0.0396840014,
-0.0126739256,
0.0202002022,
-0.0499849655,
0.0016873819,
0.01386551,
-0.0072007659,
-0.0248797107,
-0.0351081267,
-0.0288655143,
-0.0701004341,
0.0175628513,
0.0577524677,
0.0217568744,
-0.0508335307,
0.0252201278,
-0.0295129344,
0.0220313873,
0.0166435838,
0.0141225774,
0.0538911596,
-0.0211661644,
0.0394369476,
-0.0465741046,
-0.0361642949,
0.0020155471,
0.0033372275,
-0.0119353924,
-0.0299488809,
-0.0313003063,
0.0625597984,
-0.0133974208,
0.0341637619,
0.0000022425,
-0.0574960187,
0.0025996114,
-0.0289164186,
0.0255435053,
0.0233404972,
0.0683462769,
0.0015774049,
-0.0093832333,
0.034597598,
-0.0227589794,
0.0055754911,
0.0626829192,
0.0144838858,
0.0239398684,
0.0873991176,
-0.0304116625,
-0.0442270301,
0.0387568958,
-0.025581684,
-0.0415360071,
0.0489420742,
-0.0226397682,
-0.0234742742,
-0.0061061303,
-0.021540381,
-0.0252409149,
-0.0122874416,
0.024078723,
-0.0206577778,
0.0018482822,
0.0378522389,
-0.0360024646,
-0.0568713807,
0.0273744334,
0.0290522724,
-0.0658087954,
-0.0540928282,
0.0101452414,
-0.003746826,
-0.0464750305,
-0.0630075186,
-0.0423292555,
0.0666939467,
-0.0226562768,
0.0571907572,
0.1042393222,
0.0207829103,
0.0061324099,
0.0102535207,
0.0395715609,
0.0056957775,
0.0488507338,
0.0191457886,
-0.0364211574,
0.0174898766,
-0.0291183181,
-0.0588908009,
-0.0136748981,
0.0173351672,
-0.0360307693,
0.0274223294,
-0.0647571832,
-0.0475897603,
0.0338269472,
-0.0380232818,
0.0147064049,
0.0487985648,
-0.0003561139,
-0.0098167751,
-0.044349771,
0.036236804,
0.002363679,
0.0163451582,
-0.0210740101,
-0.0083027696,
0.0385337435,
-0.041956991,
-0.0349270366,
0.020287158,
-0.0550907888,
-0.0170925837,
-0.0581520014,
0.0370988846,
0.0069299564,
-0.0452202931,
0.0253223013,
-0.005720933,
-0.069308579,
-0.0177466795,
0.0270158201,
-0.011563669,
-0.0496068224,
0.0145240324,
0.0266348347,
-0.1070439667,
0.0114271771,
0.0582005121,
-0.022665957,
-0.0206168238,
-0.0054185675,
0.0325163044,
-0.0271801483,
-0.0185774863,
-0.0758352876,
-0.0082012666,
0.0091089467,
-0.0831123069,
-0.0266609341,
-0.0967848301,
0.0545674264,
0.0420209244,
-0.0081504369,
-0.0429768823,
0.0193792563,
0.0331376381,
0.0073419181,
0.0083431862,
-0.0082988134,
-0.0031101487,
0.0463001654,
-0.0037402643,
0.0525528565,
0.0492871664,
0.0490913987,
0.0445606895,
0.0194360744,
-0.0185834207,
0.0164506361,
0.0269030873,
-0.0075265905,
0.0216055866,
-0.022391038,
-0.0064315288,
-0.0040471158,
0.0545035042,
0.0365816839,
0.0868817642,
-0.0105335088,
0.0385697894,
0.0385826901,
0.0344713368,
0.0159885343,
0.0843210518,
0.0719637722,
-0.0018833318,
0.0228836909,
0.0142111294,
0.0023866065,
0.0364490934,
0.0104415948,
0.0237600673,
0.0690634176,
0.0576047599,
-0.0027796829,
-0.0159504171,
-0.0159724504,
-0.0441085324,
-0.028044207,
-0.0616563223,
0.0394039601,
0.0170980096,
-0.0641455948,
0.0038641205,
0.0552257448,
-0.1033156216,
0.03544477,
-0.031617526,
0.0675412342,
0.0249848664,
0.0367287621,
0.0167640522,
0.0031936932,
0.0053698085,
0.0193965342,
0.0687911287,
0.0242498294,
-0.0003380313,
-0.0061630788,
-0.0538013019,
0.0543301441,
-0.0110535976,
-0.0144620957,
0.0494857617,
-0.0255813189,
0.0323691778,
0.0166686419,
0.0133163836,
-0.0260583498,
0.051207494,
-0.043752566,
0.0006244654,
-0.0098277591,
-0.020061098,
0.0405685306,
-0.0010814919,
-0.0371388271,
0.0099163437,
0.0193613563,
-0.030947132,
-0.0067000282,
0.0413756482,
-0.0439221822,
-0.039837651,
0.0137140891,
-0.0217831638,
0.0535119697,
-0.0186117534,
-0.0070736529,
-0.0687323511,
0.0434202254,
-0.0022789757,
0.0311765783,
-0.0607207753,
0.0375567973,
0.0066515664,
0.0081286002,
0.0062188376,
0.0458366387,
-0.0026800903,
0.0017589666,
0.0278578196,
0.03872668,
0.0801168308,
-0.0698395967,
0.0150485588,
0.0299812704,
0.0187088158,
0.0086821886,
0.0296309832,
0.0158625469,
-0.0162462834,
-0.0494084619,
-0.1189371422,
0.0098987948,
-0.0358489417,
-0.0080408026,
0.0072729904,
0.0334745534,
-0.0182394106,
0.0071625002,
-0.0138536589,
0.0015926042,
0.0677099377,
-0.0073945248,
0.0340968333,
-0.0265118722,
0.0130815636,
-0.0310217552,
-0.0034568319,
0.0049879807,
0.0553379357,
0.0385360792,
-0.0389268547,
-0.0071257502,
-0.0048231869,
-0.0376980565,
0.0007968203,
0.0017914182,
-0.0824371576,
-0.0024561011,
-0.0361465588,
0.0629886761,
0.0159139819,
0.0332460701,
0.0026050881,
0.0098159658,
0.0029070349,
0.0024347578,
-0.0201455597,
0.0094459951,
0.0123959994,
0.0174065717,
-0.0138695203,
0.0139234848,
0.051268246,
0.028811954,
-0.0125121865,
-0.044672735,
-0.0063558044,
-0.0357394032,
0.007425955,
0.0197565351,
0.0361691304,
-0.0180191621,
0.0386334211,
-0.0107623497,
-0.0681547225,
0.0292685162,
-0.0831159428,
-0.00111676,
-0.0485596806,
0.0081990706,
-0.0394287296,
0.0132737895,
0.0225028284,
0.028784791,
-0.0209664777,
0.0011242063,
-0.0446796976,
0.0914493278,
-0.0047319485,
-0.0155686829,
0.0088207526,
-0.0635686889,
0.0350969322,
-0.0345955789,
-0.0413664877,
-0.0359548815,
-0.0326058716,
0.0303393696,
-0.0104881134,
0.0595427528,
-0.0003413144,
0.0332677439,
0.0553060137,
-0.0142209129,
0.023039069,
-0.0348071828,
0.0169432368,
0.0107884351,
0.002416047,
0.0670187101,
-0.0199336987,
-0.0192012936,
-0.0055650156,
0.0197294913,
0.0098182447,
0.0266564805,
0.0113266902,
-0.0465279594,
0.01140121,
0.0101485681,
-0.0108514875,
-0.0234873835,
0.013187957,
0.0264678188,
0.0021793209,
-0.0194902457,
0.096707575,
0.0188778192,
0.0059859594,
-0.0069192625,
-0.0297029521,
0.0352876745,
0.0067076627,
0.0259727761,
-0.0685549676,
-0.0129364636,
0.0123953251,
-0.0149747403,
-0.0108499862,
-0.0048300838,
-0.0408642665,
-0.1245910004,
0.0230165254,
0.0203865469,
0.0012205238,
-0.0223340038,
-0.0036826553,
-0.062267527,
0.0086520277,
-0.0203337241,
0.0440710299,
-0.0336593576,
0.007896686,
0.0429242589,
-0.0217256285,
-0.0212543048,
-0.044806093,
-0.0160515551,
0.0107471971,
0.0411037318,
0.0004901181,
-0.0301013552,
-0.0309852511,
0.0229319185,
0.0039485549,
-0.0015318304,
-0.0230226889,
0.0349055268,
-0.0111559741,
0.0045296331,
-0.0127988979,
0.0436889827,
-0.0134438379,
-0.0302236099,
-0.00305247,
0.018226482,
-0.0094343331,
-0.0243889596,
-0.0020472084,
-0.0039368127,
0.006940925,
0.0343226381,
0.0293011721,
-0.048798576,
-0.059880916,
-0.0412710905,
0.0077485694,
-0.0709636211,
0.0163653046,
-0.0025489908,
-0.0002657575,
-0.0452402271,
-0.0558046065,
-0.0471216664,
-0.0096169943,
0.0510539003,
0.0262731109,
0.0280873366,
-0.0440616831,
-0.0112299398,
-0.0128275035,
-0.0198498331,
-0.0001284449,
0.0019025275,
-0.1250248253,
-0.0074650422,
0.0122379996,
-0.0453953594,
-0.022268109,
0.0241250098,
-0.0459942557,
-0.0627037436,
0.0145722795,
0.0511869527,
0.0154300909,
-0.0119493697,
-0.0015507808,
-0.0540293455,
0.0463320166,
0.0112369712,
-0.0250747297,
0.0306753125,
-0.0033174329,
-0.0027460016,
-0.0059471303,
0.0376901552,
-0.0135250241,
0.0283724573,
-0.0171455964,
0.0341174714,
0.0374559052,
0.0127455471,
0.0320777185,
0.0362306014,
0.0135059739,
-0.1012538821,
0.0346300192,
-0.0788581967,
-0.0230912101,
-0.0172442961,
0.0030927504,
-0.037343666,
0.0110418117,
0.0633854419,
0.014962906,
-0.0205903947,
-0.0426007248,
0.0082422281,
0.0225252248,
0.002004676,
0.0197586063,
-0.0028910935,
0.0735922754,
0.0198419057,
-0.0205714796,
-0.0314916708,
-0.0103814285,
-0.0505473875,
0.013325124,
-0.0395655781,
0.0712994188,
0.0047512143,
0.0080355909,
0.0311556775,
0.0435940251,
0.0519076958,
0.003975438,
-0.0501136854,
0.043362692,
0.0774412826,
0.0270015839,
0.0746589005,
-0.0546108782,
0.0196722765,
-0.0348885916,
0.0703290328,
0.0136994477,
-0.0356297791,
0.0129784979,
-0.0205909517,
-0.0474146418,
-0.018576378,
0.090557985,
0.0176523216,
-0.0024921566,
0.0212750603,
0.0109209577,
-0.0349492766,
-0.0083053624,
-0.0526643582,
0.0098296814,
0.0236063283,
0.0236800183,
-0.053873945,
-0.0202860869,
-0.0060353433,
-0.0067117186,
0.02203824,
-0.0346714258,
0.0317294784,
0.045231685,
0.0034149068,
0.0067797857,
-0.0359144658,
0.0266442578,
-0.0431729257,
-0.0059800916,
-0.0108574452,
-6.348966212e-33,
-0.0536015071,
0.0005441425,
0.0028441902,
-0.021427948,
-0.0082324836,
-0.0223413631,
-0.0539442375,
-0.0131372325,
0.0324075706,
-0.0010100738,
-0.010525085,
-0.007270894,
0.005526708,
0.0279476214,
0.0166242737,
0.0240771547,
0.0501536429,
0.017707957,
-0.030809531,
0.0420214161,
0.0624757223,
0.0223773066,
0.0462032221,
0.0036432466,
-0.0372862816,
-0.0630418509,
-0.0058640842,
0.0074176728,
-0.0330293924,
0.0150294406,
-0.0265020896,
0.0413473248,
0.0262665544,
-0.0113223623,
-0.0092921397,
0.000452049,
-0.0400245599,
-0.0297285262,
0.0123107536,
0.0377355143,
-0.0268064048,
-0.0476049371,
0.018299453,
-0.003047765,
-0.024593994,
0.0082442779,
-0.0091091236,
0.0126176802,
0.0036245661,
-0.0288351551,
-0.1074680239,
0.0400698781,
0.0127491131,
0.0105008241,
-0.0051469333,
0.0029895608,
-0.0171174482,
-0.0073613338,
-0.0347150862,
0.001393988,
0.0156527851,
0.0649338067,
0.0653160661,
0.0219807643,
-0.0263393577,
0.0289319921,
0.0066499668,
-0.035644453,
-0.0089904154,
0.0726268217,
-0.0085714487,
0.026323203,
0.0064513017,
0.064456664,
0.0381509513,
-0.0801192597,
-0.0653437972,
0.0216049813,
0.0292817056,
0.0152899744,
0.0273814071,
-0.0097025335,
-0.0031768798,
-0.0371626727,
0.0215617251,
-0.0558574498,
-0.005933173,
-0.0408102274,
0.0662678406,
-0.0119081149,
0.0061926856,
-0.0264323782,
0.0407593548,
0.0091312909,
0.0177294109,
0.0253337212,
-0.080297403,
0.0350388698,
-0.0217583049,
0.0339287706,
-0.0378597416,
-0.0817760751,
0.0060036466,
0.0081326449,
0.0146940341,
-0.0066536199,
0.0156046739,
0.017965395,
-0.0545168519,
0.0145404479,
-0.0551660322,
0.0535405055,
0.0394208282,
0.0242539924,
0.0081858486,
0.0112769883,
-0.0177413244,
0.0071157445,
0.0077961045,
0.0217783004,
-0.0161199737,
-0.0688098967,
0.0033278794,
0.0073784017,
-0.0453035459,
0.0423899069,
-0.0488946363,
-0.0082987295,
0.0474797301,
-0.0543720424,
-0.0232411902,
0.0359254293,
2.942e-7,
-0.0004916855,
0.0326809958,
0.0568308011,
-0.0246407334,
-0.0113877133,
0.0003611016,
-0.0303439591,
0.028539151,
0.0006093874,
0.0513909608,
-0.0159202795,
0.0043190434,
0.0531241298,
0.0204003956,
-0.0913071483,
0.0422106832,
-0.102634728,
0.0231804587,
-0.0767268538,
-0.0214627944,
-0.0373369306,
0.0640207529,
0.0036455358,
-0.0015287206,
0.0087841218,
-0.0187607501,
0.0643422008,
0.015422035,
-0.0044421772,
0.0394722447,
0.0216382928,
-0.0041986061,
-0.0362806395,
-0.0419828892,
-0.0141078755,
0.0182002466,
0.0290854666,
0.0589386411,
-0.0207935963,
0.0270390343,
0.0823527426,
-0.0005288703,
-0.0096822893,
-0.0644481778,
0.0426477082,
0.0369823389,
-0.0138984779,
-0.0174173974,
0.0023227376,
0.0140795056,
-0.006964264,
-0.0395380259,
-0.0092209354,
0.0106412489,
0.0119378902,
-0.0536736324,
-0.0289650392,
0.0043665715,
-0.049641341,
0.0148380175,
-0.0290133767,
-0.0447643697,
-0.0378929898,
0.0329919681,
0.0321137011,
-0.0460580736,
0.0023611444,
2.756867845e-34,
0.0556813069,
-0.0216353592,
0.0203273259,
-0.0179205313,
0.0460934825,
-0.019771982,
-0.0040885112,
0.0158712212,
-0.0049363244,
-0.0462081619,
-0.0385331623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18028v2 | Evaluating the Capabilities of LLMs for Supporting Anticipatory Impact Assessment | 2024-01-31T17:43:04 | 2024-05-20T23:34:39 | Mowafak Allaham, Nicholas Diakopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Gaining insight into the potential negative impacts of emerging Artificial
Intelligence (AI) technologies in society is a challenge for implementing
anticipatory governance approaches. One approach to produce such insight is to
use Large Language Models (LLMs) to support and guide experts in the process of
ideating and exploring the range of undesirable consequences of emerging
technologies. However, performance evaluations of LLMs for such tasks are still
needed, including examining the general quality of generated impacts but also
the range of types of impacts produced and resulting biases. In this paper, we
demonstrate the potential for generating high-quality and diverse impacts of AI
in society by fine-tuning completion models (GPT-3 and Mistral-7B) on a diverse
sample of articles from news media and comparing those outputs to the impacts
generated by instruction-based (GPT-4 and Mistral-7B-Instruct) models. We
examine the generated impacts for coherence, structure, relevance, and
plausibility and find that the generated impacts using Mistral-7B, a small
open-source model fine-tuned on impacts from the news media, tend to be
qualitatively on par with impacts generated using a more capable and larger
scale model such as GPT-4. Moreover, we find that impacts produced by
instruction-based models had gaps in the production of certain categories of
impacts in comparison to fine-tuned models. This research highlights a
potential bias in the range of impacts generated by state-of-the-art LLMs and
the potential of aligning smaller LLMs on news media as a scalable alternative
to generate high quality and more diverse impacts in support of anticipatory
governance approaches. | [
0.0440734923,
0.0679959878,
-0.0420630574,
-0.0250536818,
-0.0558312088,
-0.0109399138,
0.0088925986,
-0.014053992,
0.0586305372,
-0.0442083813,
0.0701670125,
0.0520476513,
-0.0331865363,
0.0470150784,
0.0093839262,
-0.0426312424,
0.0389454998,
0.007986092,
0.0115698902,
-0.0142827043,
0.0088723218,
0.0123680951,
0.015153449,
0.0626551658,
-0.0266004968,
-0.015123751,
0.0095757488,
0.0199020598,
0.0246570818,
-0.0479260162,
0.003427383,
0.0286337044,
0.029248327,
0.0130636515,
0.0000024949,
-0.069107376,
-0.002865284,
0.0191298034,
0.012960068,
0.0134556396,
0.0667507499,
0.0181132723,
0.0176613573,
0.0015658324,
-0.0254931822,
0.0731216073,
-0.0007086452,
-0.0338331275,
0.0131640593,
0.00781646,
0.0076551298,
-0.0359242931,
0.0704558641,
0.0080883866,
0.0057343892,
0.0007473645,
0.0220859908,
0.0120319994,
-0.0049588457,
0.0002472543,
0.0148375724,
0.0573602319,
0.0189895127,
-0.0072745676,
0.0008908483,
-0.0200116728,
0.0104997745,
-0.0307491776,
-0.0017619848,
0.0405851752,
0.0916571021,
0.0039436929,
-0.000791869,
-0.0459633879,
0.0596576408,
0.0440331511,
-0.0521622971,
0.0105890743,
-0.0190892462,
-0.0161699019,
0.0370023288,
0.0103619192,
0.0396082811,
0.0585484467,
0.0033538842,
0.0877224356,
-0.0215706751,
-0.0444624573,
-0.0100438017,
0.0145742651,
0.0338139944,
-0.0175312031,
-0.00223219,
0.0016102912,
-0.0190964472,
0.0147258984,
0.0044068722,
-0.0069814529,
0.0142875258,
-0.0547580086,
0.0249974355,
0.0211234521,
-0.0097862128,
0.0139563717,
0.0261879489,
-0.0081139132,
-0.0463436544,
0.006996383,
0.0068273535,
0.0290585998,
-0.0690061077,
-0.0129422834,
0.0026532481,
0.0464570783,
-0.0453354567,
-0.0124377152,
0.0210070517,
0.0152179822,
-0.0782574713,
0.0279414728,
-0.006575597,
0.0223781187,
0.0203350876,
-0.0292283483,
-0.0386411734,
0.0024321417,
-0.0537383817,
0.084102951,
-0.0143523095,
-0.0119326496,
0.0084102126,
0.0136810932,
0.0030121848,
-0.0001959129,
0.0081368284,
0.0882874727,
0.0539704524,
-0.0009584809,
-0.030598389,
-0.0621793345,
-0.0058772787,
-0.0483193882,
0.0107576204,
-0.0590485074,
-0.0472760946,
-0.0017382217,
0.0125437817,
-0.0540076829,
-0.0072858757,
0.0066174557,
-0.0346413665,
0.0010757199,
-0.0652865842,
0.0350467786,
0.0276300106,
0.0255163517,
-0.0049825879,
0.073658891,
0.022159921,
0.0582551584,
0.0100743352,
0.003920991,
0.0303631239,
0.0138329733,
-0.0147073632,
0.0276248567,
-0.0454457402,
0.0086864764,
-0.0641932487,
-0.0097884731,
0.0004466304,
0.033702042,
0.0045215553,
0.0775891319,
0.0719228461,
0.0118858954,
-0.0291260015,
0.021094501,
0.0323238559,
0.0034642315,
-0.0191328991,
0.0036711935,
-0.0234203525,
-0.0013320001,
-0.0352948308,
-0.027204698,
-0.0022788541,
0.0103011616,
-0.0223401599,
-0.0472741872,
0.0161604304,
0.0121763255,
0.0664770305,
0.0469078496,
0.013257768,
-0.0214574076,
-0.0367996767,
-0.0262919348,
-0.0314978324,
-0.0030634073,
0.0068169557,
-0.0696791187,
0.043012131,
0.0849738345,
0.0642239302,
-0.0369556434,
0.011227889,
-0.0270793308,
-0.0229027718,
0.0234171469,
0.0068743154,
-0.0047965217,
-0.0678608343,
-0.0001146807,
-0.0419520438,
-0.0388548486,
0.0389684997,
0.0237258971,
0.0039631156,
0.007539256,
-0.008156592,
0.0144289071,
-0.0407645553,
0.0274594221,
-0.0112330746,
0.0115107289,
-0.0591557473,
0.0139999725,
0.0407783464,
0.0566706806,
-0.0121834828,
0.0305891968,
0.0130038653,
0.0008965352,
-0.0531287156,
-0.0258902833,
0.0054964721,
0.0928253382,
-0.0150355622,
-0.0380336791,
-0.0074628815,
0.0498844907,
0.0008713108,
-0.0130675938,
0.0610875562,
-0.0277288985,
0.0120711671,
-0.005484839,
-0.0082074255,
-0.0662885085,
-0.0244294126,
-0.0156078059,
0.0356479734,
-0.0461722389,
-0.0435091816,
0.0150594031,
-0.0223523639,
0.0174316894,
0.0297173541,
-0.0535518229,
0.0080034658,
0.0060215895,
0.0158214215,
0.0905685201,
-0.0415301025,
-0.0196339041,
-0.0377214476,
-0.0666064322,
-0.0054759048,
-0.0225745663,
0.0065952661,
-0.0040711584,
-0.0218120068,
-0.0117287217,
0.0297267567,
0.0237382948,
-0.0441497676,
0.0042530531,
0.0550212972,
-0.0175906103,
0.0053611621,
-0.0342818275,
-0.0262100771,
0.0009000538,
-0.0270243771,
-0.0034173138,
0.0374847911,
-0.0624589324,
-0.0361121744,
0.0060537313,
-0.0310401656,
-0.0303102937,
0.0129301464,
-0.0311436579,
0.0250220411,
0.0264389403,
-0.0226690229,
0.0285213068,
-0.0020991196,
0.0578102171,
0.0403090008,
-0.0015666265,
-0.0528083816,
-0.0103287222,
-0.0054720836,
0.0064054164,
-0.0291935001,
-0.0445111543,
-0.0154914614,
0.0262963343,
0.0187956076,
0.0106291557,
-0.0510261729,
0.075976707,
-0.0761125833,
-0.0744150132,
-0.0061757648,
-0.096803613,
-0.0240240376,
0.0541170277,
-0.015209266,
-0.059848696,
0.0331335887,
0.0303382054,
0.0681677982,
-0.0131903579,
-0.0089329556,
-0.0153168887,
0.0613827407,
0.0082884477,
0.0148291709,
-0.0134287365,
-0.0131803416,
-0.041635707,
-0.0186796542,
0.0209767092,
-0.0036490313,
0.00079649,
-0.0742849484,
-0.0095845424,
0.0103831068,
-0.017111633,
-0.0040782439,
-0.0388490148,
-0.0037563527,
0.0454985648,
0.0657048821,
0.0185415037,
-0.0278766379,
-0.0132352943,
0.0750076771,
-0.0020137297,
0.006092458,
-0.0152009455,
-0.0216126796,
-0.0411968082,
-0.000337253,
-0.03266735,
0.0472186916,
0.0429255702,
0.0334248021,
0.0083254362,
0.0117975473,
-0.0115312142,
-0.0346438251,
0.0175983272,
0.011133302,
-0.012486564,
-0.021903744,
0.024462482,
0.0542771369,
-0.0370646715,
0.0113860294,
0.0546474122,
0.0054082815,
-0.0281323176,
0.0170968696,
0.0023425159,
-0.0424096957,
0.0298127905,
-0.0249276608,
-0.0954137743,
0.0177636389,
0.0233334433,
-0.0010501544,
-0.0939202607,
-0.0625434592,
0.0283054095,
-0.0882714763,
0.053078413,
-0.0122678326,
0.0465909764,
-0.0022455053,
-0.0217815172,
-0.0131688602,
-0.0225201603,
-0.041846931,
-0.0064956653,
0.0079794787,
-0.0107042473,
0.0138145424,
-0.0817442387,
-0.0411752686,
0.0110201687,
-0.0024316749,
0.0453092158,
0.0969758108,
0.0282040704,
-0.0656524003,
0.0339314416,
0.029146539,
-0.0079184491,
0.0082839662,
0.0235856343,
0.0120196147,
0.0181406587,
0.0358290859,
-0.0366251506,
0.0075427778,
0.0489149392,
-0.0402384922,
0.0554937385,
0.0734452158,
-0.0319504179,
-0.0310714487,
-0.0389180332,
-0.0008239782,
0.0237818044,
0.0319490731,
0.0034707822,
-0.0482286997,
0.0015974493,
-0.008041542,
-0.0110258684,
-0.0107966634,
-0.0326571427,
0.0006195924,
-0.0017066663,
-0.0078031835,
-0.0054999352,
-0.0997845158,
-0.0281077139,
-0.0294764694,
0.0360331088,
-0.0004003682,
0.0404276252,
-0.0052770032,
0.0202337243,
0.0287682768,
0.0108713694,
-0.001399922,
-0.0026019441,
-0.0089566112,
-0.0174748711,
0.040751081,
0.0016717783,
0.0471610166,
-0.0260724593,
-0.0621071383,
0.0512065366,
0.043972183,
0.0330261886,
-0.023958154,
0.0133288298,
-0.0394220501,
0.0656986162,
0.0150528857,
0.002174885,
0.0048126094,
0.0391135551,
0.004615657,
-0.0117898611,
0.0051439987,
0.0040699709,
0.010904259,
0.005660289,
0.0202111248,
-0.055731304,
-0.0078501897,
0.0328605287,
0.0046920655,
0.0509735383,
-0.0642507449,
-0.0198596306,
-0.0237681493,
-0.0473582819,
-0.0378139429,
-0.0207178853,
-0.0131141292,
-0.0090057878,
0.0230210163,
-0.0117582874,
-0.0178156309,
0.0447002836,
-0.045635812,
0.0071162255,
-0.0707115307,
0.0799569115,
-0.0097980732,
0.0624559447,
0.0040565901,
-0.0050853333,
-0.0545874499,
0.0098340185,
-0.0505686849,
-0.0083081704,
0.0169072337,
0.0408183895,
-0.0084286463,
0.0342767872,
0.0268388204,
0.0289079286,
-0.0180088338,
-0.062169861,
-0.0244099367,
0.0617117919,
-0.011078123,
0.0433372483,
-0.0188527498,
-0.0181195997,
-0.0190584138,
-0.0150206778,
0.0008635385,
0.000100678,
-0.0435588025,
0.0216604043,
0.0081334775,
-0.0693518147,
-0.0067308946,
0.0435488224,
-0.0564357191,
0.0696511567,
-0.0165771451,
-0.0255908463,
0.0038236091,
-0.0818658993,
0.0232408792,
0.0315502658,
-0.0037840856,
-0.00187681,
-0.0947370008,
-0.0056611798,
-0.0248238184,
0.0028821989,
0.002096181,
-0.0378475338,
-0.0047100554,
0.0206880737,
0.0049925041,
-0.0576930195,
-0.0328014158,
-0.0111837592,
-0.0922624245,
-0.0003237191,
0.0172055308,
-6.621934367e-33,
-0.0141457524,
-0.017148098,
0.046678476,
-0.031929478,
-0.0384482853,
0.007441835,
-0.0014401635,
0.0524582528,
-0.0437518097,
0.0371826291,
0.0175532512,
-0.0117452154,
0.0001030693,
-0.0236852858,
0.0335536711,
0.0060057412,
0.051107958,
0.0142760128,
0.0176587272,
0.0103860991,
0.0000011765,
-0.0206591971,
0.0101442048,
-0.0797131285,
0.0893141255,
-0.0129575897,
-0.05021929,
-0.0503667258,
-0.0078084162,
0.0051662265,
-0.0040476951,
0.0543612726,
0.0304505844,
-0.0700176805,
-0.0149544822,
0.05836422,
-0.0008417991,
-0.0199460369,
0.0532306023,
-0.0395480357,
0.0299525149,
-0.0711309314,
0.0100887716,
0.00171554,
-0.0869384781,
0.0439887717,
0.0277627856,
-0.0575794242,
-0.0033281632,
-0.0275602285,
-0.1038540304,
0.0246603321,
-0.0431499258,
0.0365346186,
-0.0438853465,
0.072641179,
0.0121015869,
0.0763232484,
-0.0698789284,
-0.0045374441,
0.0297878515,
-0.0216417704,
0.0496395119,
-0.0430939905,
0.0201233476,
0.0434853584,
0.0215989519,
0.0307158567,
-0.0488399602,
-0.0216083881,
0.0280079078,
0.0237510949,
0.0288224127,
0.0709305629,
-0.0084910979,
-0.0592532158,
-0.0548518933,
0.0070567839,
-0.0169175174,
0.0552601963,
0.0579745583,
-0.0078762854,
-0.0575815141,
-0.0227594823,
-0.0509786904,
-0.0671170801,
0.0023568147,
-0.0294086635,
0.0179416016,
-0.0131278113,
-0.0299738608,
0.0400377288,
0.0255406536,
-0.0498966724,
0.0260831174,
0.0182720143,
-0.0412072875,
0.0243268386,
0.0112549933,
0.0397847258,
-0.0627315566,
0.0066958866,
-0.0129367355,
0.0208644755,
0.0696745738,
0.0108902333,
0.010049101,
0.0100348173,
-0.0264556725,
-0.0154920202,
-0.0252776276,
0.0274145659,
0.0291224886,
-0.0607724413,
0.0472899042,
0.036409948,
0.0233722404,
-0.0097855302,
0.0440929234,
0.017856786,
0.0034618613,
-0.0399125777,
-0.0348931402,
0.008072162,
-0.0281048901,
-0.01261466,
-0.0260864813,
0.0330615193,
0.0216550529,
-0.0187559035,
-0.019993579,
0.0190434922,
3.125e-7,
0.0314597487,
0.05959047,
-0.0185261294,
0.0087798731,
0.0059037278,
0.0305359364,
0.023941353,
0.0186685845,
-0.0039544725,
-0.0339234099,
0.055258628,
-0.0012895125,
0.0192176942,
0.019402504,
-0.0270142518,
0.002382857,
-0.0645795986,
0.002418767,
-0.0870773345,
0.051562883,
0.0315326452,
0.0168076586,
0.0355246216,
0.0175717752,
-0.044275213,
0.0150373382,
0.0228601452,
-0.0476619042,
-0.0371920988,
0.0008843715,
0.0257910788,
0.0333504751,
0.0160385929,
0.0312448665,
0.0192156993,
-0.0130295819,
-0.0193174277,
0.0214103963,
-0.0060048606,
0.0140560437,
0.0036445451,
-0.0395551845,
0.0183639638,
-0.0557231791,
0.0839340314,
-0.0299257562,
-0.0522518866,
-0.0244956408,
-0.0368325263,
-0.0174114071,
0.0670365021,
-0.0168534163,
0.0206861962,
-0.007431386,
-0.018268792,
-0.0016795936,
-0.0015011178,
-0.0353640988,
0.0278511774,
0.0383097418,
-0.025877893,
-0.0882425234,
-0.0101110293,
0.0107829655,
0.0005395506,
-0.0720883831,
0.0550407544,
2.744507935e-34,
0.0262906011,
-0.0059686732,
0.0046818466,
-0.0365513489,
0.0489291959,
0.0519720316,
-0.0445203595,
-0.0120591046,
-0.0074487054,
-0.0748953596,
0.006154424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18018v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18018v4 | On Prompt-Driven Safeguarding for Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T17:28:24 | 2024-06-03T06:52:58 | Chujie Zheng, Fan Yin, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Kai-Wei Chang, Minlie Huang, Nanyun Peng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prepending model inputs with safety prompts is a common practice for
safeguarding large language models (LLMs) against queries with harmful intents.
However, the underlying working mechanisms of safety prompts have not been
unraveled yet, restricting the possibility of automatically optimizing them to
improve LLM safety. In this work, we investigate how LLMs' behavior (i.e.,
complying with or refusing user queries) is affected by safety prompts from the
perspective of model representation. We find that in the representation space,
the input queries are typically moved by safety prompts in a "higher-refusal"
direction, in which models become more prone to refusing to provide assistance,
even when the queries are harmless. On the other hand, LLMs are naturally
capable of distinguishing harmful and harmless queries without safety prompts.
Inspired by these findings, we propose a method for safety prompt optimization,
namely DRO (Directed Representation Optimization). Treating a safety prompt as
continuous, trainable embeddings, DRO learns to move the queries'
representations along or opposite the refusal direction, depending on their
harmfulness. Experiments with eight LLMs on out-of-domain and jailbreak
benchmarks demonstrate that DRO remarkably improves the safeguarding
performance of human-crafted safety prompts, without compromising the models'
general performance. | [
0.0363931544,
0.0637523308,
-0.0156077305,
0.0430467427,
0.0004569589,
0.0104661742,
-0.00044991,
0.0029389018,
0.0528160185,
-0.0386588015,
-0.021544246,
-0.0667682216,
-0.0450200252,
-0.0055504781,
0.0292274151,
-0.018949518,
0.0826715454,
-0.063992247,
0.0025489491,
-0.0029122536,
0.0104581676,
-0.0181161258,
0.0256369859,
0.0609032847,
-0.0047992244,
-0.0178860482,
0.0007554968,
0.0168656241,
-0.0064010201,
-0.037451487,
0.0221595783,
0.0431857295,
0.0121247005,
0.0676882267,
0.000002069,
-0.0460402146,
-0.0103001371,
0.018260641,
-0.041554641,
0.011346343,
0.0227528457,
-0.0589366816,
-0.0202726275,
0.0428541489,
-0.0186454523,
-0.0036237326,
0.0572453514,
0.0452476516,
0.0757150576,
0.074567169,
0.0087271677,
0.0278676935,
0.0268029179,
-0.0035338385,
-0.008483462,
-0.0402236357,
0.0046630255,
-0.0302896332,
-0.0034914007,
0.0308008622,
-0.0220303759,
0.023405429,
0.0244402401,
-0.0367733687,
-0.0440877639,
-0.0094422586,
-0.0298184697,
-0.0432434157,
-0.0076565584,
0.0646864399,
-0.0517771766,
-0.0074610864,
-0.0056848964,
-0.0160482898,
0.0303612556,
0.0229197741,
-0.0165153705,
0.0338085219,
0.0105282655,
-0.0088305529,
-0.0077492907,
0.005665401,
0.0633961186,
-0.006875121,
-0.0242212433,
0.0507470332,
0.0195959713,
-0.0275994949,
0.010400949,
-0.0362805873,
-0.0222710185,
-0.0497716628,
0.0032912125,
0.0044585709,
-0.0655736774,
0.0215899255,
-0.0511267185,
-0.0067726574,
0.0402772389,
-0.0481697582,
0.0235907175,
0.0391496792,
-0.0089576747,
0.0247907247,
0.0020519928,
0.0254123155,
-0.0247657336,
0.0676086098,
-0.0054390929,
0.0314539447,
0.0052753366,
-0.0153698688,
-0.0307114441,
0.0277964156,
-0.0138682015,
0.0273975953,
0.0115047283,
0.0620022789,
-0.0205636993,
0.0238474626,
-0.0202422962,
0.0055516036,
-0.0142054232,
-0.0078024724,
0.0068251439,
-0.0277237743,
-0.0378477275,
-0.0061787106,
0.011452591,
-0.0620868243,
-0.0245100148,
-0.0126454718,
-0.0316202603,
-0.0304101706,
-0.0299804043,
0.1130040735,
0.0344162658,
-0.0077304286,
-0.052446112,
-0.0674557239,
-0.0050931275,
-0.0302560981,
-0.0015576266,
-0.0258417744,
-0.000665598,
-0.0062727882,
-0.0152998762,
-0.0828807652,
0.0033624715,
0.0409049951,
-0.0403239876,
0.0656888932,
0.0155857643,
-0.0155864293,
-0.0118450783,
0.0462709144,
-0.0365275815,
0.0801566094,
0.0263611786,
0.0407160036,
0.0446676314,
-0.0110505922,
0.0311893653,
0.0443015173,
0.0146185299,
0.0426922776,
-0.0481421426,
0.0223256629,
0.0630074143,
0.0069393753,
-0.0019092461,
0.0604137704,
-0.0237888023,
-0.0369063839,
0.0617271438,
0.0461288393,
-0.0276960973,
-0.0023812554,
0.0235837363,
-0.0035081268,
-0.0357728638,
0.0012056903,
-0.1111854389,
-0.0064900909,
-0.0646990836,
-0.0229720827,
-0.009585253,
0.0125959944,
0.0002975433,
-0.0231978558,
-0.0080643408,
-0.0090154065,
-0.0031367335,
0.0261579137,
-0.0101673352,
-0.0013664565,
-0.0251718294,
0.0371882133,
0.016337527,
-0.0361783318,
-0.0385484584,
-0.0591443591,
0.0223345011,
0.0685164556,
0.0454172529,
-0.0217449591,
-0.0321890227,
-0.025569316,
0.0039036735,
-0.0029793677,
0.0361909196,
-0.0223695505,
0.0513797924,
-0.0314220563,
-0.0547222309,
0.0261411797,
0.0284508411,
-0.00425833,
0.0146138007,
0.0012546098,
0.0266282931,
-0.0116681186,
-0.0664059594,
0.0463566966,
-0.0038623998,
-0.055472862,
-0.0015312076,
0.0295343548,
-0.0106262928,
0.0009718181,
-0.0024803318,
0.017862903,
0.0392452404,
0.0007149649,
0.0213568434,
-0.0314245187,
-0.0808526799,
0.002308846,
0.0363226011,
0.0155894989,
-0.02419696,
0.0280064773,
-0.0196038987,
-0.004351344,
-0.0069291713,
-0.027826013,
0.042927999,
-0.0101988418,
0.0245862361,
-0.0158430189,
-0.0235659722,
-0.0488761216,
0.0262169056,
-0.0146332858,
-0.0232601892,
0.0198781434,
0.014550454,
0.0260177273,
-0.0071274382,
-0.057846386,
0.0212871358,
-0.0177127644,
0.0642611086,
0.0323676169,
0.0068530105,
-0.0237101018,
-0.0037691731,
-0.0488725416,
0.0037632554,
-0.0347301029,
0.0035938167,
0.0061841342,
0.032184694,
-0.0178530533,
-0.02945018,
0.0091504995,
-0.0359306335,
-0.0072469246,
0.0512939803,
-0.0037196458,
-0.0012491329,
-0.0328298211,
-0.0229848158,
-0.0092969295,
-0.0211989768,
0.0342256948,
-0.0375432409,
-0.0100989165,
-0.047411494,
0.0324396417,
0.0125373174,
0.0336214937,
-0.0077903247,
-0.0376832299,
0.0177818649,
-0.0161362775,
0.0092266491,
0.0724405721,
-0.0020005787,
0.01304424,
0.0912643746,
0.0179975014,
-0.0707302392,
0.0049265302,
0.0186837651,
-0.0475709699,
-0.0175544918,
0.0023788125,
0.0164802223,
0.0416319445,
-0.0168321095,
-0.0201524217,
-0.0556331649,
0.002489429,
-0.0274207368,
-0.0406453349,
-0.0284145102,
-0.0398960821,
-0.0450257286,
0.0509460121,
-0.0042327475,
-0.0629239976,
0.0865725353,
-0.0175740775,
0.0218057372,
-0.0047563761,
-0.0122686578,
0.0098205023,
0.0610403754,
-0.0103311157,
0.0212950483,
0.0498185679,
-0.0491610579,
-0.0597246811,
-0.0078425929,
0.0381024592,
-0.0268632006,
0.0508394167,
-0.0268020835,
-0.0253167022,
-0.0165216476,
-0.0525574014,
-0.0633989275,
-0.0953869,
-0.0240047742,
-0.0233502276,
0.0027912075,
-0.0112642664,
-0.0092123523,
-0.0012646751,
-0.0029864134,
0.0121620866,
-0.0358619317,
0.0059062447,
-0.0208663177,
-0.0313148536,
0.0477997512,
-0.0098889628,
0.0124993632,
-0.0329272747,
0.0629928261,
0.0702640489,
0.0421507917,
-0.0378522873,
-0.00536014,
0.0230032727,
0.0616536215,
-0.000298726,
-0.0259567816,
0.0613716915,
0.0487221107,
-0.0528168902,
-0.0309663191,
0.073113054,
0.0321203806,
-0.038500905,
0.0232517701,
-0.0344106294,
0.0764089823,
0.0322346762,
0.030710673,
-0.0505528972,
-0.0351669416,
0.04017701,
0.0507360697,
0.0181426741,
-0.0201475024,
-0.0047435379,
-0.1174492389,
0.0276835114,
0.0301634818,
0.0059811482,
-0.0165718291,
-0.0203138795,
-0.0205988064,
0.0000140014,
0.0592399091,
0.0043923524,
-0.0235758293,
-0.0097545162,
0.0228753388,
-0.0087548485,
-0.0222705305,
0.011214152,
-0.0723251179,
0.0330040269,
0.0924833417,
-0.0274049547,
0.0090411277,
-0.0108485408,
0.0497476421,
0.0262582432,
-0.0058326488,
0.001478153,
0.0116627812,
-0.0104517862,
-0.0040132185,
0.0072623338,
0.0200228039,
-0.0045929244,
-0.0358313508,
0.0382485874,
0.091018416,
-0.0288586821,
0.0121237263,
-0.048551023,
-0.0194897298,
0.0356990211,
0.0629742518,
0.0402477048,
-0.0347345471,
-0.024820013,
-0.0633385107,
-0.0168838501,
-0.030195944,
-0.0215179846,
0.0161198992,
-0.0003204578,
-0.0403975807,
-0.0227270573,
-0.0181619301,
-0.0055916552,
0.0306611937,
0.0498294905,
-0.0405983403,
-0.0075093247,
0.0090111792,
-0.0043493016,
0.0277967509,
-0.0453864262,
0.0320606269,
-0.0750937611,
0.0656441525,
0.0072978651,
0.02038984,
-0.0180008188,
-0.0017545592,
-0.0292072836,
-0.0965701044,
0.01092235,
0.072792016,
0.0235916972,
0.0119050005,
-0.041564405,
-0.0870596096,
0.0472351611,
0.0633772761,
-0.0644696131,
-0.0200067647,
0.0458286554,
-0.0668368265,
0.0031272403,
0.0357731245,
-0.0606259517,
-0.0370476432,
0.0178655889,
0.0143025303,
-0.0377880149,
-0.0306812506,
0.0164806247,
0.0379735194,
0.0353686027,
-0.001146979,
0.011482114,
-0.0075638643,
0.0228923243,
-0.0090952087,
-0.0349700488,
-0.0164584704,
0.0622794144,
0.0252115801,
-0.0390797257,
0.0064733578,
-0.0085420618,
0.0106517486,
0.0453711823,
-0.0304938536,
0.0266204365,
0.0315216295,
0.0323587209,
0.0525354259,
0.0229312889,
-0.0230374038,
0.0673248768,
0.0102889491,
0.0152477613,
-0.0416224487,
0.0336047374,
0.0149551518,
0.0373884402,
-0.036228817,
0.0483975373,
-0.0741046146,
-0.0898062363,
0.0050348924,
0.0297417305,
0.0037328526,
-0.0151904942,
0.0157832298,
-0.0011908952,
-0.0057049035,
-0.0441456363,
-0.0119797057,
0.0142926592,
-0.0475408547,
0.0503909066,
0.0232058894,
-0.0067759557,
-0.0147700561,
0.0728661865,
0.0091488706,
0.0600858219,
-0.0015514101,
-0.0313693881,
-0.0433470346,
-0.0222450662,
0.0810360461,
0.0285103247,
-0.0573715419,
-0.0201409962,
-0.0919314101,
-0.0824601501,
-0.0399674959,
0.0168198124,
-0.0153049557,
-0.0131703438,
0.0011484422,
0.0344460495,
0.0234991759,
-0.0177763104,
-0.0363202021,
-0.0089055896,
-0.000976429,
-0.0213539265,
-0.015260662,
-5.861449399e-33,
-0.0078244759,
-0.0020314322,
-0.0181634482,
-0.0626889318,
-0.006289796,
-0.0300612058,
-0.0110794445,
0.0152169345,
-0.0174368918,
-0.0019797825,
-0.0466714278,
0.020368332,
0.0008469287,
0.0010540262,
0.0206588525,
-0.0474978425,
0.0142731154,
-0.0143554546,
-0.0408871733,
0.0366309471,
0.0280100778,
0.0213097073,
-0.0215535741,
-0.0517839007,
0.0498807132,
-0.0059244772,
-0.0039689946,
0.0283908937,
-0.0389206894,
0.0769145638,
0.0000471074,
0.0257728919,
-0.0092269396,
-0.0387847312,
-0.0145862149,
0.0511063673,
-0.0416638106,
-0.0342854485,
0.0044152029,
-0.0102634486,
-0.022527894,
-0.0645926148,
0.0425747931,
-0.0020900809,
-0.0127307717,
-0.021656882,
-0.015083761,
0.0017053867,
-0.0503995083,
-0.0065044058,
-0.0465131439,
0.0042714728,
-0.0029595576,
-0.0371150039,
0.0402901061,
0.0207126271,
0.0333761275,
0.0096704774,
0.0138194636,
-0.0063762707,
0.0028939191,
0.0226193778,
0.0530666709,
0.0274348017,
-0.0360986628,
0.0565409884,
-0.0387667567,
-0.0203571953,
0.0287380666,
-0.0267218761,
0.0174552221,
0.0486571491,
0.0116136754,
0.0505207777,
0.0332527496,
-0.0509788357,
-0.0603991076,
0.0273194592,
-0.011317757,
0.0428832695,
0.013104097,
0.0061149658,
-0.0327355042,
-0.0384715684,
-0.0534984097,
0.0079526044,
-0.0312807001,
-0.0181639418,
0.050776355,
-0.0036271147,
-0.0346119851,
-0.0475387648,
0.0225368552,
-0.0559285767,
-0.0163678508,
0.0413437411,
0.0113557698,
-0.0468720347,
0.0079964586,
0.0636634901,
-0.0037472101,
-0.015801264,
0.0041875537,
-0.0619021021,
0.0262568295,
0.001555442,
0.047721643,
0.0506876446,
-0.0697726309,
-0.0035359466,
-0.0329686031,
0.0351203531,
-0.0054159551,
0.0493379906,
0.0488489978,
-0.0163213145,
0.0281840619,
0.0369222686,
0.0210740324,
-0.0115645118,
-0.0490789376,
0.0254410263,
-0.0079639899,
0.0112565728,
-0.0081245033,
-0.023196321,
-0.0048876372,
0.0464496315,
0.0653079301,
-0.0716987774,
-0.0174634494,
-0.0027717091,
2.766e-7,
0.0188865867,
0.0207395852,
0.0270292889,
0.0392300412,
-0.0099107372,
0.0940977037,
-0.0216266681,
0.0676557794,
0.005642754,
-0.0121184615,
0.0153359808,
-0.0091444599,
0.0280548651,
0.0434323885,
-0.0780232102,
0.0109977517,
-0.0644591376,
0.0254997332,
-0.0373614021,
-0.0170133542,
0.0544558465,
0.1108591408,
-0.0197746977,
-0.0194253176,
0.0047135735,
-0.0588807613,
0.0249587763,
-0.0412019864,
0.0107422918,
-0.0115989428,
0.0277578458,
0.0330645889,
0.0293113235,
-0.0050773197,
-0.0124414796,
0.025840126,
-0.0200164448,
0.0816159323,
0.0015872268,
-0.0102479663,
-0.019403642,
-0.0381649807,
-0.0043823542,
-0.066206418,
0.0702586249,
0.0071307966,
0.0029738171,
-0.0272474587,
0.0310654845,
-0.0534321629,
-0.0042278245,
-0.0226109829,
-0.0226349011,
0.0121231927,
0.0214251429,
0.0124672959,
0.0220053867,
-0.0759926289,
-0.0330537111,
-0.0188560672,
0.0065942947,
-0.0605476089,
-0.0240763426,
0.0603992119,
0.0165717117,
-0.0603882968,
0.0031671526,
2.914284217e-34,
0.0382835865,
-0.0472059101,
0.0441672094,
0.017584525,
0.0588723943,
0.0163481161,
0.0297008939,
0.0051676333,
0.047312934,
-0.0434245057,
-0.0372121148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18001v1 | Desiderata for the Context Use of Question Answering Systems | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior work has uncovered a set of common problems in state-of-the-art
context-based question answering (QA) systems: a lack of attention to the
context when the latter conflicts with a model's parametric knowledge, little
robustness to noise, and a lack of consistency with their answers. However,
most prior work focus on one or two of those problems in isolation, which makes
it difficult to see trends across them. We aim to close this gap, by first
outlining a set of -- previously discussed as well as novel -- desiderata for
QA models. We then survey relevant analysis and methods papers to provide an
overview of the state of the field. The second part of our work presents
experiments where we evaluate 15 QA systems on 5 datasets according to all
desiderata at once. We find many novel trends, including (1) systems that are
less susceptible to noise are not necessarily more consistent with their
answers when given irrelevant context; (2) most systems that are more
susceptible to noise are more likely to correctly answer according to a context
that conflicts with their parametric knowledge; and (3) the combination of
conflicting knowledge and noise can reduce system performance by up to 96%. As
such, our desiderata help increase our understanding of how these models work
and reveal potential avenues for improvements. | [
0.0573474169,
0.0145543376,
-0.0203737039,
0.0511702448,
-0.0199260544,
0.0094456384,
0.0292265564,
-0.0167303924,
-0.0158271249,
-0.0411173292,
-0.0301481467,
-0.0013686202,
-0.0188288353,
-0.0024770985,
-0.0109867081,
-0.0305874962,
0.0474289022,
-0.0196287818,
-0.0214576703,
-0.0267000776,
0.0094339997,
-0.0052404348,
0.0135463923,
0.0268669315,
0.0100323781,
-0.0106892502,
-0.011132976,
0.006773219,
0.0252561271,
-0.0341824591,
0.0253207795,
0.0196707509,
0.0191248618,
0.0366668068,
0.0000020665,
-0.0527841933,
-0.0117007494,
-0.0083382893,
-0.0586663522,
-0.0136141153,
-0.0192701779,
0.0137416273,
0.0336060934,
0.018839512,
-0.0646043792,
0.0236205161,
0.0326324478,
-0.0124245174,
0.0302263256,
0.0015130608,
0.0004438165,
-0.0239317715,
-0.0166130029,
-0.0029378992,
0.0509900041,
-0.0952355862,
0.0508365296,
-0.0110100117,
0.0006060389,
0.0134376613,
-0.023044249,
0.0243370943,
0.0322097912,
0.0551173277,
-0.0227996185,
0.0055851,
-0.002613001,
0.025699148,
-0.0097878817,
0.100889802,
0.044417683,
-0.0242249947,
-0.0130391652,
-0.0019799275,
0.0216041431,
0.0031081524,
-0.043542102,
-0.0278735366,
-0.0174178984,
-0.0413997099,
-0.0150748827,
0.0541419201,
0.0003402678,
0.0361606777,
0.0019518571,
0.0445045605,
-0.0069599566,
-0.0649962798,
-0.0129674571,
0.0047080209,
-0.0296904072,
-0.0736471936,
0.0221577156,
0.0767497197,
-0.0315087326,
0.0414850973,
-0.0057248534,
-0.0272392463,
0.0532699302,
-0.0230511501,
-0.0443564467,
0.0299139787,
0.0042466111,
0.0700768158,
0.0135454508,
0.0274851639,
-0.0009301381,
-0.0109533798,
-0.0486942232,
-0.0433009081,
-0.0444995835,
-0.0073648132,
-0.0532156341,
0.0538151935,
-0.0508622676,
-0.0012048,
-0.0433035716,
0.0565639623,
0.0036781251,
-0.0118733905,
-0.0254800562,
0.0444848388,
-0.0003985266,
0.0162581187,
-0.0463332236,
0.0097074201,
-0.0797832236,
0.050871335,
-0.0088996375,
-0.0583315752,
0.0054474324,
-0.0089996783,
0.0182692669,
-0.0348108485,
0.0076114582,
0.0435749143,
0.0354569666,
-0.0486800782,
-0.0109160542,
-0.0312816463,
-0.0243872721,
-0.0390255116,
-0.0782812536,
-0.0546136685,
0.0244977549,
0.0578158088,
-0.0160657298,
-0.00813221,
-0.0042104032,
0.0534373559,
-0.0111819208,
0.1083598584,
0.0003231638,
-0.0018614674,
0.0536516234,
0.0380047262,
-0.0112408781,
0.0584656894,
0.014373091,
0.0046024001,
0.067430988,
0.018131651,
0.0324958079,
-0.0043016085,
0.0145624811,
0.0125380894,
0.0097909737,
0.0954636484,
-0.0169593804,
-0.0231876783,
-0.0193501487,
0.0391358957,
-0.0246409401,
-0.0544284731,
0.035172388,
0.0517839938,
-0.0088808583,
0.0148422681,
0.0178776961,
-0.0073158485,
0.0108690625,
-0.0043240637,
-0.0214088503,
-0.00337514,
-0.0641637519,
0.0130136237,
0.00150406,
0.0093104765,
-0.0449346192,
-0.0616228655,
-0.0171289798,
-0.0069534746,
0.0147250537,
0.0692718625,
0.0358051248,
-0.0149678402,
-0.0125775104,
-0.0049437922,
-0.0068152687,
-0.0075382357,
-0.0288427826,
-0.0329836234,
0.0601292551,
0.0524647906,
0.068949081,
-0.0737311095,
-0.0116306441,
0.0106065786,
0.0247629993,
-0.0107956063,
0.0237037875,
-0.0217454676,
0.0228376109,
-0.0215451345,
-0.0462862328,
0.001183725,
-0.017284343,
-0.0002477954,
0.0372050293,
0.0410600454,
-0.002025635,
-0.0418487601,
0.0186120886,
0.0061720503,
0.0102539603,
-0.0331423953,
-0.0211095084,
-0.0007096146,
0.0353688672,
0.0122711593,
0.0265954491,
0.015626464,
0.0459788926,
0.0030271658,
-0.0063048741,
0.0098640891,
-0.0633550659,
-0.0361122787,
0.0133521594,
0.0234405175,
-0.0192321651,
0.0327024199,
-0.0186326783,
-0.0371752419,
0.0016333812,
-0.0534843132,
0.0080194343,
-0.0519934632,
-0.0260287523,
0.000421816,
0.0155222435,
-0.0802246556,
0.0793328658,
-0.0148728173,
0.0191601235,
0.0282373838,
0.029183194,
0.0145578524,
-0.0486539863,
-0.0177541021,
-0.0303569157,
0.0025334852,
0.0109125171,
0.0176040698,
-0.0143203316,
-0.059272822,
0.0128605729,
-0.1044322401,
0.0018168607,
-0.0282779913,
0.0123690655,
0.0460571013,
0.0418211222,
-0.0144541087,
-0.0471211411,
-0.0492964014,
0.0366919003,
0.0225823484,
0.0450916775,
0.0454795174,
0.034057688,
-0.0070018647,
-0.0661709085,
-0.0098351743,
-0.0020663519,
0.0300304089,
0.0035444926,
0.0065879403,
-0.0613144077,
0.0111475745,
-0.0588121191,
0.0436810739,
0.0025327776,
0.0100786854,
0.0192234516,
-0.0018255678,
0.006797337,
0.034953855,
-0.0104295127,
0.0225320812,
0.0250461474,
0.0185080171,
-0.0578717403,
0.0248485673,
-0.0374442935,
-0.0119573362,
-0.0147484671,
-0.0393928289,
0.0010709154,
0.0247535445,
0.0075517795,
-0.0180031564,
-0.0165834762,
0.0700989589,
0.0010733854,
-0.039234627,
-0.1047047973,
0.0014475695,
-0.0001469633,
0.0859341472,
-0.0046419441,
-0.0073842267,
0.0844770819,
0.0296699144,
0.0024610749,
-0.0534659699,
-0.0149378963,
-0.0483953431,
0.0345316716,
-0.0206312332,
0.018994756,
0.0151123954,
0.0029873324,
-0.048030816,
-0.0459383093,
-0.0059242882,
-0.0622354187,
0.0251733456,
-0.0500175506,
0.0329225883,
-0.0069551668,
-0.062283814,
-0.0782321319,
-0.0463986285,
-0.0354873911,
0.0146723082,
-0.0218967013,
-0.006045938,
0.0172767304,
0.0351584703,
0.0232585389,
0.0342805535,
-0.0048217932,
-0.055700928,
-0.0175572522,
0.0750359222,
0.0713349581,
0.0575732887,
0.0471505374,
0.0172380824,
0.0236891098,
0.0698989704,
0.0582511872,
-0.0362090319,
-0.0079149008,
-0.0367336124,
0.0319754034,
-0.0314162076,
0.0042056041,
0.0304832719,
0.0533985496,
-0.0474725142,
-0.0352421589,
0.0969897136,
0.0506339893,
-0.0225360226,
-0.009643984,
-0.0463446006,
0.0067021749,
0.0215698052,
0.0279633757,
-0.0752027258,
-0.0633971319,
-0.0249850545,
0.0639085323,
-0.0054718698,
-0.0356784537,
-0.0046709776,
-0.0727160797,
0.0031240308,
-0.0504796878,
-0.0763580576,
-0.0311576128,
-0.0392077416,
0.0224759243,
-0.0135396542,
0.027240565,
0.0164523199,
-0.0151580218,
0.007367142,
-0.0175045673,
0.0144096101,
-0.0211182944,
0.0427041054,
-0.0156064359,
0.0128549151,
0.0505940206,
-0.0157315526,
0.0313612185,
-0.0387097187,
-0.004887017,
-0.0842504203,
0.0131736817,
-0.0227892082,
0.0095276618,
-0.0040729307,
0.0023351172,
-0.0461971983,
0.0113334646,
-0.0479323752,
-0.0033106653,
0.0533087663,
0.0424855538,
-0.0054272851,
0.0192630626,
-0.034266185,
0.013896876,
0.0402733274,
0.0880079418,
0.0254191794,
-0.0369432271,
-0.0704688951,
-0.0207085013,
-0.0076364246,
-0.010837731,
0.004912708,
-0.0256073456,
0.0227657314,
0.0198134296,
-0.0757861435,
-0.0733691901,
0.0378473811,
0.0245956611,
-0.0288548097,
0.0452369861,
-0.0101714982,
0.0285420902,
-0.0361395925,
-0.0082502281,
-0.0353770554,
-0.0021267626,
-0.0092746932,
0.0166892223,
0.0227177516,
-0.0373806879,
-0.0272219833,
0.0261342265,
-0.0746409819,
-0.0264352001,
0.0039355764,
0.022580443,
0.0296234414,
0.0206525419,
-0.0314376801,
-0.039211493,
0.0182066858,
0.0246921554,
0.0022835536,
0.0172609109,
0.0225875992,
0.0360659808,
-0.0152355134,
0.0316443816,
-0.0697738677,
0.01710888,
0.0176441278,
0.0438161157,
-0.1069371849,
-0.0294809379,
0.024783738,
-0.0324071012,
-0.0004873633,
0.0197326057,
-0.0511340871,
0.0324737243,
0.0433871113,
-0.0125137391,
-0.0035086253,
0.0029885089,
-0.0098538669,
-0.0029623965,
-0.0170168858,
0.009140566,
0.0117638214,
-0.0387839749,
0.0323580354,
-0.0497626141,
-0.0023261334,
0.0503567979,
0.0299586207,
-0.0042979973,
-0.018143449,
-0.0198519006,
-0.000316591,
0.0262123998,
0.0657858923,
0.0143393548,
0.0738833919,
-0.010993612,
-0.0517390221,
-0.0082316548,
0.0499354228,
-0.1098641902,
-0.0127260517,
-0.0002224159,
0.0339393765,
0.0286328867,
0.0305047818,
-0.0196084827,
0.0110942321,
-0.0200429764,
-0.0050449967,
-0.0344853774,
0.0497013405,
0.0107495608,
0.0689841881,
0.0568428934,
-0.0091334023,
0.0567207858,
0.0551070124,
0.0100628613,
0.0308512151,
-0.0167173818,
-0.0312945098,
-0.0391940214,
-0.0049777059,
-0.0252783597,
0.0551190153,
-0.0235289317,
0.0221761223,
-0.0577624738,
-0.0663170815,
0.0104704555,
0.0019183613,
-0.0055568609,
-0.0059115202,
0.0520200618,
0.0518885069,
0.0320236012,
-0.044116918,
-0.0116682053,
0.0400694497,
-0.0636517406,
-0.0216098931,
-0.0503754131,
-6.410792806e-33,
-0.0015795656,
-0.0425197929,
0.011374726,
-0.0263367891,
0.0200812053,
0.009030492,
-0.0025717737,
-0.0209227316,
-0.0545533448,
-0.0249184947,
-0.0324603245,
0.0177345909,
0.006440754,
0.0037775484,
-0.024559753,
-0.0855517387,
-0.003665403,
0.0004502082,
-0.0147368638,
0.0168717802,
0.0563870594,
0.0044045956,
0.0207097903,
-0.0562691465,
0.0229427349,
-0.0314048268,
0.0071782381,
0.0404397696,
-0.0224700533,
0.0718122572,
-0.0233449601,
0.0688149408,
0.043163754,
-0.009802321,
0.0177574493,
0.0605634265,
-0.0838168785,
-0.0268262736,
0.0237449538,
-0.00425858,
-0.0521675386,
-0.0248349495,
0.0342496559,
0.000787715,
-0.0024995126,
0.0376153775,
0.0124344165,
-0.0270320866,
-0.0137510803,
-0.0271410868,
-0.0203360822,
-0.0000203675,
0.0051153898,
-0.0163480863,
-0.0425768085,
0.0803641826,
0.0142540978,
0.0494747199,
-0.0568668582,
-0.0184239428,
0.0115577411,
-0.0080287149,
0.0502024554,
0.0075939139,
-0.0183160491,
0.0046179295,
0.0046072612,
-0.0206832401,
-0.0222009271,
-0.0658015162,
-0.0569953024,
0.0099577447,
0.0722168535,
0.0613901652,
0.0136834048,
0.0245649572,
-0.0777628571,
0.0363289565,
0.0000301347,
0.0086520379,
0.0399811342,
0.0046501933,
-0.0784263909,
-0.0026411901,
-0.0460047275,
0.0416745692,
-0.0664329231,
0.011665225,
0.0653223768,
0.0252131317,
-0.0311620682,
0.0030442681,
0.0032618663,
-0.0555117987,
0.0003703686,
0.0367185958,
0.0149491224,
0.0061599058,
0.0404525734,
0.0235344917,
-0.041213952,
0.0467729047,
0.0244609881,
0.0195409749,
-0.0199550018,
-0.0026766947,
0.0102483761,
-0.0324800275,
-0.0298451316,
-0.0051465565,
-0.0103547974,
0.0637857243,
-0.027920153,
-0.0542329997,
0.0356892496,
0.0384881273,
-0.0098236026,
0.0275752284,
0.0384694114,
0.0012566872,
-0.0332737863,
-0.0369282924,
-0.0239737183,
0.0158981048,
-0.0239471812,
-0.0017777402,
0.0094069708,
0.0307421554,
0.0075641181,
-0.0127608106,
-0.0017592696,
0.0425387621,
2.595e-7,
0.06602671,
-0.0043552993,
0.0209648218,
0.0298595857,
0.0416226201,
0.0371644199,
0.0284331534,
0.0232859347,
0.016927572,
-0.0000604383,
0.0234737974,
0.0229060072,
0.0183190163,
0.02158764,
-0.030259572,
-0.0392359383,
-0.032370612,
0.0037272284,
-0.0333583243,
0.0240057129,
0.0660206228,
0.0672320276,
-0.0176697839,
-0.000640961,
-0.0417152457,
-0.0438693091,
0.0312080402,
-0.0253666621,
0.0426593982,
-0.0047747046,
0.0255128331,
0.0038220929,
0.0274240542,
0.0245419033,
0.0178266726,
0.0016366064,
0.0025055334,
0.0359644555,
0.0053771469,
-0.075375244,
-0.0276971478,
-0.01413297,
0.0454873592,
-0.0893164948,
0.1126363128,
-0.046716623,
0.0078075654,
-0.0170060676,
0.0145408092,
-0.0018503561,
0.0358108021,
0.0132895056,
-0.0323397368,
-0.0259508323,
0.0005559407,
-0.0032507989,
0.0116500314,
-0.0694486052,
0.0027242906,
0.0105041116,
-0.0041265809,
-0.0362053178,
-0.0422636867,
-0.0293604266,
0.0246481504,
-0.0459521376,
-0.0101944553,
1.959010468e-34,
0.0299889073,
0.0076017035,
0.0077692755,
0.0420425795,
-0.0058603692,
-0.001280557,
-0.0271602273,
-0.0140290083,
0.0663225278,
-0.0772724599,
-0.0105314618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17979v1 | Entity Linking in the Job Market Domain | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Natural Language Processing, entity linking (EL) has centered around
Wikipedia, but yet remains underexplored for the job market domain.
Disambiguating skill mentions can help us get insight into the current labor
market demands. In this work, we are the first to explore EL in this domain,
specifically targeting the linkage of occupational skills to the ESCO taxonomy
(le Vrang et al., 2014). Previous efforts linked coarse-grained (full)
sentences to a corresponding ESCO skill. In this work, we link more
fine-grained span-level mentions of skills. We tune two high-performing neural
EL models, a bi-encoder (Wu et al., 2020) and an autoregressive model (Cao et
al., 2021), on a synthetically generated mention--skill pair dataset and
evaluate them on a human-annotated skill-linking benchmark. Our findings reveal
that both models are capable of linking implicit mentions of skills to their
correct taxonomy counterparts. Empirically, BLINK outperforms GENRE in strict
evaluation, but GENRE performs better in loose evaluation (accuracy@$k$). | [
0.0131015191,
0.0400138013,
-0.0239464827,
-0.03356722,
0.0260468666,
0.0136495698,
-0.0020467588,
-0.0113379061,
0.0232939851,
-0.0419583619,
0.0007394305,
0.0391717516,
0.0102675753,
0.0269765407,
0.0764716119,
-0.023636207,
0.0238566753,
0.0096371686,
-0.0173925608,
-0.0023294976,
-0.0193331856,
0.0543507077,
-0.0114142485,
0.0680712387,
-0.0312397219,
-0.0045030792,
0.0586615503,
0.0002063021,
0.0577386767,
0.0047547268,
0.0115459422,
0.041347973,
-0.0021947382,
0.0192573592,
0.0000019049,
-0.0188737977,
0.0156889744,
0.0140668228,
-0.043575082,
-0.0331702381,
-0.014011696,
-0.0466316119,
0.0215367377,
-0.0042114463,
-0.0021072945,
-0.0370413326,
0.0164419562,
0.0050100288,
0.0391309485,
0.0320946649,
0.0014641769,
-0.0398497432,
0.0196589176,
-0.0610741973,
0.001033422,
-0.0177116804,
0.021175405,
-0.0649293289,
-0.0109367352,
0.0420128182,
-0.0131015303,
0.0594226383,
0.0377830826,
-0.011269738,
0.052670151,
0.0369784869,
-0.0374628529,
0.0014528501,
0.0477611497,
0.0679475591,
0.0088941772,
-0.0256696809,
0.005693065,
0.0092316838,
0.0387226418,
0.0605883449,
-0.0221046004,
-0.003390146,
0.0115553215,
-0.0191433392,
-0.0084345983,
-0.0042425315,
0.0306541175,
0.00756153,
0.0638320073,
0.043209713,
-0.0017998484,
-0.0378216095,
0.0551955998,
0.02217751,
0.0280466676,
-0.0545590371,
0.050610818,
-0.0075314189,
-0.0388437845,
0.0089272,
-0.0424807742,
0.0176183321,
-0.0078265388,
-0.0411782339,
-0.0726455823,
-0.0135542946,
-0.002075833,
0.033097297,
-0.0396595001,
-0.0339781158,
-0.0070901136,
-0.0096590314,
-0.0117913336,
-0.0670826882,
-0.0809134543,
-0.0325170197,
-0.0651757792,
-0.0091970824,
0.0004652792,
-0.013093573,
-0.0401539616,
-0.0597739927,
-0.0592230558,
0.0569386072,
-0.0042788922,
0.014606772,
-0.0376370251,
0.0104961563,
-0.0623516738,
0.0035525276,
-0.0343275964,
0.0254789274,
-0.0036687851,
0.0049234601,
-0.0087820049,
0.0106795998,
0.0039320691,
-0.0558528379,
0.0189607795,
0.0243206527,
0.0504600331,
0.0289525054,
-0.0166595988,
-0.0669441819,
0.0211047735,
-0.0390687063,
-0.0299091134,
-0.0488213487,
0.0461907201,
-0.0076910267,
-0.0024569277,
-0.0820235983,
0.0167426113,
0.0257136505,
-0.0712730661,
0.0705622733,
-0.020197304,
-0.0332093313,
0.0268123876,
0.0006379103,
0.0338030793,
0.03184513,
0.0649447441,
0.0275469162,
0.0236826967,
0.0003574501,
0.021797847,
0.0184627194,
0.0192596614,
-0.0629906878,
0.0268810969,
0.008871193,
-0.0110338656,
0.0732539594,
0.0793918073,
0.0045163929,
-0.0427524745,
-0.0262445826,
0.0372715071,
0.054836493,
0.0326737016,
0.026144959,
0.0958048105,
0.0198393017,
0.0084370086,
-0.0401414894,
-0.0349804014,
0.0450721756,
0.0114643862,
-0.0074848896,
0.0146870827,
0.0118033262,
-0.0604173988,
0.0083212927,
0.0120570464,
0.0087639224,
-0.0031992325,
0.0426644422,
0.0345193446,
0.0344904624,
-0.023200959,
0.0993386433,
0.0154941371,
0.0000515696,
0.0116116004,
-0.0136665674,
-0.0662633553,
0.0813435465,
0.0270381942,
0.0364914089,
-0.0313777775,
-0.0601913296,
-0.0058527309,
0.0570980981,
0.0412007459,
-0.0644965246,
0.0049649938,
-0.0204888768,
-0.0058031692,
-0.0007946797,
0.0004292288,
-0.0014580431,
0.0049570673,
0.0426991656,
0.0293777827,
-0.0586921461,
-0.014222227,
0.0238563046,
-0.0093927532,
-0.0246016271,
-0.0094906697,
0.0363823697,
-0.0642023459,
0.0274733584,
0.0084054703,
-0.0028981767,
0.0108968532,
-0.019811606,
-0.0005153866,
0.0194082912,
-0.0023211734,
-0.0182968229,
0.0024358938,
-0.0538722649,
-0.0594894662,
0.0122843413,
-0.0333192162,
-0.0180953462,
0.0204768553,
0.0065308721,
0.006168568,
-0.0142634688,
-0.0136869,
-0.0019389612,
0.0191391502,
-0.0083020488,
0.0540326834,
0.0185713209,
0.0228888206,
-0.0317240059,
0.0028808489,
-0.0049136016,
-0.096824348,
-0.0193305388,
-0.0268283319,
0.0373301171,
0.0210341532,
0.0097283795,
-0.0079844072,
-0.0551489592,
-0.0119345523,
-0.0201301407,
0.030981455,
-0.0146139655,
0.0067713466,
-0.0053513367,
-0.0440425612,
-0.0009891978,
-0.0239599869,
-0.0209073499,
-0.0165820532,
-0.0313785225,
-0.0095644956,
0.0304980278,
-0.0035765651,
0.0056475294,
-0.0239929575,
-0.0229232684,
-0.0312134754,
0.044877287,
0.0283405166,
-0.0100086611,
-0.0582134724,
0.0174165387,
-0.0233380422,
-0.0010860934,
0.003839867,
0.0263827406,
-0.0296056755,
0.0588809326,
0.011123484,
0.0265262891,
-0.0531673394,
0.0188299417,
0.0244601499,
-0.0040860516,
-0.0334083587,
0.0251521226,
0.010985041,
0.0425647311,
-0.0406981856,
-0.0177340321,
-0.0031504629,
0.0322882347,
-0.0141490465,
-0.0208042916,
-0.0226626508,
0.0003486762,
0.0153358253,
-0.0108838603,
-0.0212604813,
0.011935913,
0.0067250403,
0.001897025,
-0.0253890455,
-0.0094109951,
0.0135642691,
0.0158699788,
0.0085021555,
0.0060060378,
-0.025109848,
-0.0219685994,
0.016097948,
0.0073828087,
-0.0041280282,
0.0146383261,
-0.0524913408,
-0.0352129601,
0.0804519877,
0.0099060815,
-0.0086003887,
0.0116209323,
-0.015174821,
0.0327493958,
0.0417398773,
-0.0099321883,
-0.0209222101,
-0.0089641642,
-0.0157676805,
0.0529071055,
0.0008470469,
-0.0000448324,
-0.0484791137,
-0.0021346966,
0.0062441234,
0.0345166363,
0.0346999951,
-0.0478159562,
-0.0009449074,
0.04947602,
0.077084288,
0.0343452729,
0.008558535,
-0.014429342,
-0.0194128342,
0.0144488038,
0.0133223571,
0.0234448239,
-0.0146701345,
-0.0213346016,
0.0203081369,
-0.1119211987,
-0.0287482012,
0.0036307268,
0.0119845858,
-0.0607521571,
-0.0170879755,
0.1058460847,
0.0284291394,
-0.0523206815,
0.0248236246,
0.0493818037,
-0.0160512403,
0.0276008509,
0.0415221229,
-0.0561281443,
-0.0092990668,
0.0003056593,
0.0119429491,
0.0413922444,
-0.053195864,
-0.0128873577,
-0.1168633625,
0.0394770801,
-0.0532233343,
-0.0127618462,
-0.0638612285,
-0.0592622273,
0.0075696809,
-0.0376954861,
0.0171898529,
-0.0307158083,
-0.0132923946,
0.0341547392,
0.0352240652,
0.0026538416,
-0.0670147911,
0.057724081,
-0.093528524,
0.0963737443,
0.0242468342,
0.0431514941,
-0.0010745595,
-0.0054598982,
0.0089090168,
-0.0193420704,
-0.0311891455,
0.0231270231,
0.0863190442,
-0.0602850541,
0.001054444,
-0.0048939865,
0.011958058,
-0.0289593432,
-0.01452641,
-0.0262780283,
0.037734814,
0.0194656271,
-0.0031539386,
0.0078339661,
-0.0030512412,
-0.0125055052,
0.0962485522,
0.0031696579,
-0.0433393717,
0.0074045788,
-0.0488207862,
0.0137496646,
-0.0210182741,
-0.0704752207,
0.025583405,
-0.0231932495,
-0.0174691509,
-0.0423004702,
-0.0825847611,
0.0625420064,
0.0161083601,
-0.0179019719,
0.0043561305,
0.0271163601,
-0.0285788924,
-0.0628370717,
0.0529965721,
-0.0314086787,
0.0468026735,
-0.0097622806,
-0.0511648133,
-0.0071634199,
-0.0201110952,
-0.0620214902,
0.0074651041,
-0.1116339043,
-0.0024064728,
-0.0328831673,
-0.0059882607,
0.0159037467,
0.0455640964,
-0.0396093093,
-0.0734176487,
0.0110990722,
0.0856313929,
-0.0753070116,
0.0230378974,
-0.0299628694,
0.0289819688,
-0.0092560966,
0.0495947003,
-0.0618320629,
0.0051613776,
0.0024138771,
0.0413555913,
-0.0215350352,
-0.0203419831,
-0.0057593263,
-0.0225532316,
0.008296472,
0.0012595981,
0.0314874016,
-0.0652203485,
-0.0264472216,
0.0265524182,
-0.0206787325,
-0.0159201957,
-0.0139684342,
0.0616040118,
0.0185769666,
-0.0110548129,
0.03610548,
0.0433428474,
0.0278668571,
-0.0943670943,
-0.0173087772,
-0.0162921585,
0.0129595567,
-0.0272327457,
0.0073591778,
0.0107923653,
-0.0247016698,
0.0303171631,
0.0848340839,
-0.017052751,
-0.0155695574,
0.0115027288,
0.0158743169,
0.0160840284,
0.0284317061,
-0.0259456299,
-0.0544040948,
0.0067324713,
0.023464296,
0.0487825908,
-0.0389025137,
0.0656311661,
0.0071937479,
-0.0204111934,
0.0332264937,
0.0037648496,
0.0070590926,
0.00440853,
0.0292220712,
-0.0052921041,
-0.0132870032,
0.0206166245,
0.0569902062,
0.0120696044,
0.0607297048,
-0.0092672389,
-0.0314615704,
-0.0239136592,
0.0003214207,
-0.0128889149,
0.0059699072,
-0.0130237537,
0.0313367881,
-0.0573348291,
-0.088055253,
0.0023351717,
-0.0315890089,
-0.0057245316,
0.0117054638,
0.0569721721,
0.0197725333,
0.0084733628,
-0.0149556333,
-0.0066067874,
-0.0624863803,
0.0168362092,
-0.020148119,
-0.0734747052,
-6.013145843e-33,
-0.062618576,
-0.0309812482,
0.017315913,
0.0047112857,
0.0082164286,
0.0279481802,
0.0185107701,
-0.0432684161,
-0.0570332408,
-0.0055890647,
0.0132141327,
0.0440060236,
0.0009243452,
0.0093240747,
0.0417477973,
-0.0235420614,
0.0615070276,
0.0151118245,
-0.0072563114,
-0.0013002839,
0.0126197739,
0.0145830717,
0.1077403054,
-0.0677437559,
0.0441328138,
0.0283717029,
-0.0164501313,
0.0121536981,
0.0396864191,
0.0651252195,
-0.0012705448,
0.0419990793,
0.0141541967,
-0.0522062927,
0.003656517,
-0.011383119,
-0.1358245611,
-0.0258848015,
0.0019788323,
0.0152151659,
-0.0005739289,
-0.0453644395,
0.0598460808,
0.0212476775,
0.0080076568,
-0.0373535044,
0.080032751,
0.0045008822,
0.0107582919,
-0.0369806178,
-0.0269401204,
0.0283314195,
-0.0159436017,
-0.0051788627,
0.0182640739,
0.0129658366,
-0.0128583377,
0.0198023487,
-0.1284632236,
-0.0114543149,
-0.0332113169,
0.0427788161,
0.0348288342,
-0.0453667901,
-0.0007352379,
0.0445589125,
0.0423125662,
0.00300318,
-0.0131891668,
0.0226513539,
0.0327918455,
0.0054474412,
-0.0227887128,
0.0090971943,
0.0617078133,
-0.0054933731,
-0.0569304191,
0.0293498579,
0.0218741838,
0.0356894359,
-0.0391599052,
-0.0024520727,
-0.0326486938,
-0.0370337255,
-0.0531714298,
-0.0292246863,
-0.0137844039,
-0.0053888531,
0.0159548428,
0.026234718,
0.0525111221,
0.069114171,
-0.0311993957,
-0.0181207955,
-0.0083450163,
0.0130825462,
-0.0343896896,
0.0098737869,
0.0515690222,
0.0010477615,
-0.0953660011,
0.0052545844,
0.0206121244,
0.0090779522,
0.045372732,
0.0378899314,
0.0341319889,
0.0159985479,
-0.0803979859,
0.0121163428,
-0.0011719447,
-0.0087952614,
-0.0272874087,
-0.0262411088,
0.0371878073,
0.0133257434,
0.0067656869,
0.0110439332,
0.0310453493,
0.0002733661,
0.0114305746,
0.0358673893,
0.0258937962,
0.0088649616,
0.0063407929,
0.0057177991,
-0.0132032875,
-0.0336373337,
0.0118217431,
-0.0766475126,
-0.020323541,
-0.0212976132,
2.563e-7,
0.0583763197,
0.0429459214,
-0.0276155472,
0.0715995803,
0.0019352464,
-0.0050098579,
0.0559844933,
0.0429784395,
0.0016057466,
0.0089146839,
-0.0275576655,
0.0293132979,
0.0274176039,
0.0036776657,
-0.0559451692,
-0.0102293538,
-0.0265579391,
0.0121237934,
-0.0322015472,
-0.0512030795,
0.0115783187,
0.0538459234,
0.0491927117,
0.0083597731,
-0.0112721436,
-0.0485455096,
0.05981718,
-0.0092873126,
0.0024559661,
0.0295372885,
-0.0242996421,
0.0444214232,
-0.0419492051,
0.0786195546,
-0.0267621595,
0.0522052236,
0.064875707,
0.0331653804,
-0.0270529129,
0.0037517406,
-0.0194019768,
-0.0388691798,
-0.0212248862,
-0.0000893714,
0.0493872575,
-0.0388285667,
-0.0154982535,
0.0138679706,
-0.0525365807,
0.0520131849,
-0.0036855815,
0.0123946229,
-0.0443733744,
-0.0189845897,
0.0368811414,
-0.0020775548,
-0.0226570889,
-0.0608204938,
-0.0048544914,
0.0531132668,
-0.0244138725,
-0.0489848033,
0.0201173872,
-0.0294242799,
0.0140063176,
-0.0394564979,
-0.0163403023,
2.255829908e-34,
0.0189195704,
0.0486375913,
-0.0171081126,
0.0209903512,
0.0200625081,
-0.0198562462,
-0.0425837077,
-0.0162134711,
-0.0012010833,
-0.03789033,
-0.0235473905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17974v1 | GUMsley: Evaluating Entity Salience in Summarization for 12 English Genres | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | Jessica Lin, Amir Zeldes | cs.CL | cs.CL | As NLP models become increasingly capable of understanding documents in terms
of coherent entities rather than strings, obtaining the most salient entities
for each document is not only an important end task in itself but also vital
for Information Retrieval (IR) and other downstream applications such as
controllable summarization. In this paper, we present and evaluate GUMsley, the
first entity salience dataset covering all named and non-named salient entities
for 12 genres of English text, aligned with entity types, Wikification links
and full coreference resolution annotations. We promote a strict definition of
salience using human summaries and demonstrate high inter-annotator agreement
for salience based on whether a source entity is mentioned in the summary. Our
evaluation shows poor performance by pre-trained SOTA summarization models and
zero-shot LLM prompting in capturing salient entities in generated summaries.
We also show that predicting or providing salient entities to several model
architectures enhances performance and helps derive higher-quality summaries by
alleviating the entity hallucination problem in existing abstractive
summarization. | [
0.0409049131,
-0.0143287973,
0.050728716,
-0.01842192,
0.0041662315,
0.0305333473,
-0.0501980931,
-0.0391102172,
-0.012004558,
-0.0442565419,
-0.031205507,
0.0125379339,
-0.0110375369,
-0.0387286432,
0.0201716479,
-0.0637710318,
0.0351305157,
0.0215913411,
0.0091071818,
0.0119345225,
0.0286058076,
0.0291429721,
-0.0027666946,
0.0173185095,
0.0039357748,
-0.0264149699,
-0.002335988,
0.0202919226,
0.0786497667,
-0.0159141757,
0.049396351,
0.0357959904,
0.0106088845,
0.0133357476,
0.000001786,
-0.066122219,
-0.024125319,
0.0067544314,
-0.0099088559,
0.0262965187,
0.0301258247,
-0.0109117506,
0.0059210975,
-0.0236736964,
0.0034539544,
0.0272543766,
-0.0067519937,
0.0725726336,
0.075145252,
0.0784727558,
-0.0058355657,
-0.0529398508,
0.0385094583,
-0.0244325288,
-0.024360748,
-0.0250956472,
-0.0059857843,
-0.0397293158,
-0.0203520507,
0.0098421052,
0.0210087765,
0.0264283177,
0.0036562355,
0.0012339399,
0.0680151582,
0.0232996922,
-0.0931363925,
0.0009156007,
0.0323311239,
0.0859891698,
0.0410318524,
-0.0074682762,
0.0447460189,
0.0330615304,
0.0152496537,
-0.042175997,
-0.0410047546,
0.0274835043,
-0.0231892113,
0.0250730477,
0.0389014967,
0.0483530462,
-0.0226886906,
0.0398973487,
-0.0129386699,
0.0313899517,
0.0124424072,
-0.0039931545,
0.0406043045,
0.0394491181,
-0.0374715179,
-0.0693482608,
0.0168160964,
0.0302899033,
-0.0328089334,
-0.0180713367,
-0.0301216468,
-0.0025278281,
0.0255417787,
-0.0835600197,
-0.0437484831,
-0.0091233347,
-0.0110076852,
0.0481634215,
-0.0049722614,
-0.0212082434,
-0.0034769929,
0.0235346183,
-0.0202510767,
-0.0282081272,
-0.0300453696,
0.0241074059,
-0.03535337,
0.0997906625,
-0.0399086624,
-0.0226131435,
-0.0328285769,
-0.0045936625,
0.0008488397,
0.0137661165,
-0.0043621631,
0.0313041434,
-0.0061776708,
0.0134368045,
-0.0207103137,
0.0344865434,
-0.0714930743,
-0.014139914,
0.0179246962,
0.0225929711,
0.0010478185,
-0.0017149405,
0.0141198691,
-0.0251206364,
0.0216343775,
0.0005271642,
0.0055113249,
-0.0779344961,
-0.0779421479,
-0.0225956943,
0.0077781393,
-0.053606078,
-0.0196306966,
-0.0529834852,
-0.0078740939,
-0.008951514,
-0.0080977846,
-0.038352944,
0.0081831301,
0.0239471681,
-0.0505810305,
0.0206108578,
-0.0435759276,
-0.0236469861,
0.0285867788,
0.0006471141,
0.0209436193,
0.0541318059,
0.0281545967,
0.0493228436,
0.0699834153,
0.0373154134,
-0.012694018,
-0.0143455919,
0.0006418852,
0.0254990328,
0.046917256,
-0.0024988684,
-0.084152177,
-0.0071257851,
0.0655250177,
0.0462188721,
-0.0137474574,
-0.0078181541,
0.0336972475,
0.0729134902,
-0.0082729189,
0.0251960289,
0.0204360336,
0.0328034088,
0.0346421637,
0.0842800289,
-0.0304602049,
0.0593589544,
-0.0407697372,
0.02938921,
0.1172595322,
0.0148626855,
-0.0416107886,
-0.036413081,
0.0229283217,
0.0202966835,
-0.0260258596,
0.0201992411,
0.0110676289,
0.013636631,
-0.0309612509,
0.0471735448,
0.0403465033,
-0.0950348228,
0.0194610041,
-0.00157146,
0.0282370821,
0.0655059516,
0.0391801856,
-0.0468515754,
-0.0329524539,
-0.0158674326,
0.0178189352,
0.0339778699,
0.0332850181,
-0.0344745591,
0.0317166559,
-0.0229480136,
-0.0005717159,
-0.0286422782,
0.0386894234,
0.009653898,
0.0025079367,
-0.0169808827,
0.0378689207,
-0.029002659,
-0.0584796593,
0.0131395683,
0.0090909237,
-0.0188812166,
-0.0241605248,
0.0043690614,
-0.0122956615,
0.0685889423,
-0.0170748234,
0.0011909694,
0.0197049752,
-0.0145095885,
0.0069790813,
0.0181432385,
-0.0013130959,
-0.009729947,
0.0459131785,
-0.0441593491,
0.0062704496,
-0.0111000342,
-0.0117358975,
-0.0465630963,
-0.0010051619,
-0.0373774208,
0.019899549,
-0.0360204466,
0.0196840148,
0.0268367119,
0.0017854668,
-0.038685143,
0.073756434,
0.006818986,
-0.0033614498,
0.0092895553,
-0.0416532196,
0.0009895208,
-0.0473299362,
-0.0449934304,
-0.009665139,
0.0338870399,
0.0078102308,
0.066752173,
-0.021323828,
-0.0666493848,
-0.0040904507,
-0.1072126254,
0.0246373378,
-0.0304183997,
0.0243325625,
0.0259883087,
0.0102602961,
-0.0072464282,
0.0055185654,
-0.0286046844,
-0.0610132366,
-0.0151985073,
0.0158906784,
0.0210129991,
0.0280065723,
0.0510513857,
-0.0810005441,
-0.0214664713,
-0.0093240328,
0.0360507965,
0.0050502843,
-0.0156549215,
-0.0149120288,
0.026414942,
-0.0334233083,
-0.0176348165,
0.013220313,
0.0263325609,
-0.0096469996,
-0.0037045509,
0.0453509614,
0.0395890251,
0.0195308086,
0.0227100756,
-0.0054224199,
-0.0259262566,
-0.0330800489,
0.0199135244,
0.0050393003,
0.0300247092,
0.0321119502,
-0.0182252768,
0.0534532592,
0.0398730896,
-0.0204911623,
-0.0334687643,
-0.0391663387,
0.0147392834,
0.0009091704,
0.0103167351,
-0.0252807513,
0.0064610015,
0.0000220939,
0.0192755032,
-0.0404682234,
0.0043866658,
0.0540676937,
-0.0161712766,
0.0081038224,
-0.0580202565,
0.0171896201,
-0.0579420328,
0.020183729,
-0.0232275687,
0.0014924437,
-0.0064740148,
-0.0417754874,
-0.0074943085,
0.0120183937,
0.0131590525,
-0.0229625534,
0.094688803,
-0.0283089597,
0.0169671401,
-0.0024991722,
0.012395842,
-0.020312218,
-0.0109490706,
-0.0373931006,
0.0095654139,
0.0269744266,
0.0127581041,
-0.0182063431,
-0.0317578278,
0.0353900492,
0.053770151,
-0.0147035811,
-0.0310325157,
-0.0029884665,
0.0291346032,
0.0768456459,
0.0330083296,
0.0376917832,
-0.0149796642,
0.0353299789,
0.0352772772,
0.0139261438,
-0.0424577333,
0.0089427028,
0.0015811636,
0.0119968485,
-0.1381244808,
-0.0248091519,
-0.030574793,
0.0699269772,
-0.0339305364,
-0.0058002765,
0.112498723,
0.0263484921,
-0.0589536428,
-0.0133002913,
0.0136099039,
0.0044726175,
0.0202957951,
0.0055096303,
-0.0291287024,
-0.0247121938,
-0.0140855415,
0.0204812996,
0.0260450114,
-0.0636229962,
-0.0100703249,
-0.0721548423,
0.0125342058,
-0.0028515628,
-0.0698493347,
-0.0006464581,
-0.0445084162,
0.0239471234,
-0.0355616473,
-0.0060890531,
0.0165163074,
-0.0233851708,
0.0329481587,
0.0046162545,
-0.0260879174,
0.0253778771,
0.0074370964,
-0.072253719,
0.0051537906,
0.0797381997,
0.0529411174,
0.0025551917,
-0.0076253316,
-0.00810917,
-0.0493382476,
-0.0157149639,
0.0186246,
0.1074518561,
-0.0325777791,
0.0286057014,
-0.0492007136,
0.0444886424,
0.023231037,
-0.0097242761,
0.020227557,
0.0073201214,
0.0170265324,
0.0042655929,
-0.0534774847,
0.0294230059,
-0.0388345793,
0.0732437447,
0.0313971974,
-0.0210667476,
-0.0035784359,
-0.0328918435,
0.0170902237,
-0.0677679554,
-0.0275033265,
-0.0177030601,
-0.0636346787,
-0.0132054919,
-0.0869023129,
-0.0830228999,
0.0111777605,
-0.0165478997,
0.0114806704,
-0.0010759097,
-0.0116810324,
0.0124841202,
-0.0488552861,
0.0330009088,
-0.0227013845,
0.0001523287,
-0.0583532192,
-0.0274523702,
0.0853815749,
-0.0174960718,
-0.0141105978,
-0.0113323731,
-0.0255451929,
-0.0488764755,
-0.043610312,
0.0367092304,
0.0148082916,
0.0411158502,
-0.0120541574,
-0.0415058807,
0.0316026509,
0.0175339058,
-0.0365331396,
0.0314624123,
0.0256212074,
0.0674105585,
-0.0304761771,
0.0409785062,
-0.0499869324,
0.0391621776,
-0.0199588444,
0.0559966601,
0.0126867983,
-0.0402881503,
-0.0024980565,
0.0433460586,
-0.0002331741,
-0.0178329442,
0.0119503699,
-0.0477446765,
-0.0161708705,
0.0193218477,
-0.0177293904,
-0.0135426782,
0.0241573863,
-0.0202270001,
0.0105585912,
-0.0373522416,
0.0667035729,
-0.0169950929,
0.0367203467,
-0.07027179,
-0.0210666209,
-0.0142578557,
-0.0292812064,
-0.0664402694,
-0.0042238901,
-0.0327589028,
-0.0218071286,
0.0002005149,
0.037967477,
-0.0169181973,
-0.0036886344,
0.0192610361,
-0.0010038663,
0.0010255409,
0.0361439548,
-0.0615923181,
0.0370355733,
-0.0498378649,
0.0493401177,
0.0574310422,
-0.0503229015,
0.0886969864,
0.0211964883,
-0.0295523424,
-0.0090118367,
0.0146510173,
0.019205967,
0.0132493526,
-0.048368711,
0.0238104202,
0.0115963034,
-0.0014561894,
0.0562875159,
-0.0612359196,
0.0160047971,
0.0451283306,
-0.0114091383,
-0.0529937409,
-0.0412005596,
-0.035500057,
0.0329215303,
0.0155365048,
0.0094394954,
-0.0700836629,
-0.0210833345,
0.073777616,
-0.0141395768,
-0.00954655,
-0.0120717725,
0.0364938453,
0.0089114094,
0.0071568969,
-0.0089962548,
-0.0399784259,
-0.0443824381,
-0.0150614409,
-0.0036224339,
-0.0019864896,
-6.15979464e-33,
-0.053545855,
0.0202887077,
-0.0183158331,
0.0369341299,
-0.0569371618,
0.0212206319,
-0.0410258844,
-0.0046123941,
-0.0097930543,
0.006624084,
-0.046379257,
0.0279534943,
0.0094024492,
0.0274976026,
-0.0148229413,
-0.002822676,
0.0351333618,
0.0345605724,
-0.0608834773,
0.04219478,
0.0221494716,
0.0130845699,
0.0760881677,
-0.0580359362,
0.065219447,
0.0100193908,
-0.0211216137,
-0.0206120033,
0.0390865766,
0.0146417087,
0.0065110913,
0.0325296521,
0.0143510839,
-0.0351114236,
-0.0092493119,
-0.0272427276,
-0.1135549396,
-0.0386530943,
0.0390222929,
-0.0225799046,
-0.0152385868,
-0.0821399093,
0.0394487642,
-0.006328525,
0.0253274571,
-0.026447881,
0.064798899,
-0.0332470872,
-0.0112955151,
-0.0932368711,
-0.0404413082,
0.0225422308,
-0.019614175,
-0.0260170139,
0.0128945857,
0.007018513,
0.0034696585,
0.0115374271,
-0.0662021935,
0.0323935002,
0.0429206565,
0.0032288756,
-0.0055358252,
-0.033140149,
-0.0074435584,
0.062249843,
-0.0077498872,
-0.0160335544,
-0.0384884626,
0.0237930585,
-0.001637467,
0.0154404398,
0.0023044723,
0.0455321223,
0.0400163084,
0.0463269837,
-0.0372843184,
0.1098601297,
-0.0131840175,
0.0070588104,
0.0053538186,
-0.0120510543,
-0.0177570563,
-0.021870058,
-0.0173935145,
-0.0059858696,
-0.0334029794,
-0.0053133396,
-0.0265256781,
0.0014901562,
-0.0328218415,
0.0112706339,
-0.0190313552,
-0.0317872427,
0.0014360447,
0.047856506,
-0.00449721,
0.0174999833,
0.0191190187,
-0.0547456481,
-0.0284989718,
0.0383818932,
0.0259243585,
-0.0341243856,
0.0042395294,
-0.009692248,
0.0541819669,
-0.0050850385,
-0.0308696833,
0.0066641024,
0.016662173,
0.0421312191,
-0.0337256081,
0.0084750978,
-0.0041340953,
0.013771465,
0.0030433307,
0.0542932823,
0.0341575369,
0.0190682989,
-0.0387899987,
0.0072163907,
0.038884744,
0.0369700678,
-0.0013365807,
0.0427501202,
0.033241801,
-0.0017194909,
-0.0217375699,
-0.0417034328,
-0.0264651962,
-0.0265801214,
2.489e-7,
0.0205454659,
0.0043496578,
0.0705369487,
-0.0270021874,
-0.042539984,
0.0222156681,
0.0141882561,
0.0571443141,
0.01393086,
-0.0348453112,
0.0137741556,
0.0331520885,
0.0480512716,
0.0272627044,
-0.1115472019,
-0.0451967269,
-0.0157515835,
-0.0229550954,
-0.0429621153,
-0.0313624665,
0.0383737981,
0.0485114567,
0.0327949747,
-0.007144969,
-0.0040704077,
0.0178632792,
0.0200190023,
-0.0285331346,
0.0020254271,
0.0319040455,
0.038198974,
0.0308573078,
-0.0409500152,
-0.0180347208,
-0.0137601877,
0.0095137684,
0.0727870017,
0.0254136939,
0.0342103057,
-0.0688756928,
0.0029538127,
-0.0259337984,
0.0381445102,
0.0176587217,
0.0643803105,
-0.0289504379,
-0.0003082643,
0.0192393679,
-0.0664758533,
0.0242126118,
-0.0250112452,
-0.0238844715,
-0.0336980894,
0.0224595331,
-0.0061884518,
-0.003502239,
0.0035382661,
-0.0860205442,
-0.0374087654,
0.039747417,
0.0226001944,
-0.0300098117,
0.0159065276,
-0.0093040969,
-0.0351182707,
-0.0936743915,
0.0049797855,
2.145514355e-34,
0.0644864291,
0.0063202758,
-0.0181758069,
0.0274231248,
0.0172672011,
-0.0105098933,
-0.0331362933,
-0.0584970042,
0.0266458634,
-0.0425337069,
0.0050456901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08795v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08795v1 | Ontologia para monitorar a deficiência mental em seus déficts no processamento da informação por declínio cognitivo e evitar agressões psicológicas e físicas em ambientes educacionais com ajuda da I.A* | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | Bruna Araújo de Castro Oliveira | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The intention of this article is to propose the use of artificial
intelligence to detect through analysis by UFO ontology the emergence of verbal
and physical aggression related to psychosocial deficiencies and their
provoking agents, in an attempt to prevent catastrophic consequences within
school environments. | [
0.0224843994,
0.023193296,
-0.0026340857,
0.0114905741,
0.0032094764,
-0.0013511617,
0.0466526337,
0.0074765324,
0.026050536,
-0.0432569571,
0.0507080927,
0.0342905074,
-0.0413728729,
0.0474295504,
-0.0051037823,
-0.0531399176,
-0.0187645834,
-0.0448747352,
-0.02487587,
0.0245521069,
-0.0347775146,
0.0177384131,
-0.0250616539,
0.0062581031,
-0.0386646986,
-0.0433731675,
0.0505415201,
-0.041702386,
0.0384089872,
-0.0181068014,
0.0076441048,
0.024272766,
0.0163029954,
0.0217113532,
0.0000020647,
-0.0443085134,
0.0027204519,
-0.0116476957,
-0.0025071376,
-0.0601136014,
0.0008450897,
-0.0170437545,
0.0169221815,
0.0066862614,
-0.06628149,
0.0051746564,
-0.0114946878,
0.0408533402,
0.0141283125,
0.0004871243,
0.0014496132,
-0.046790611,
0.0602334067,
0.0190997478,
0.006052006,
0.0939490572,
0.0177389141,
0.0084466664,
-0.0139657343,
-0.0282708146,
0.0092834281,
0.0007850218,
-0.0124812182,
-0.0371819697,
-0.0201327074,
-0.0417923443,
-0.0147124315,
-0.0045794025,
0.0047774827,
-0.0025262877,
0.021101268,
0.0025931266,
0.0300641377,
0.0479121283,
-0.0073196637,
0.0258571543,
-0.0130533269,
-0.0023844263,
-0.0296489168,
-0.0348606855,
0.0709125996,
0.0394895785,
-0.0007674267,
0.0091170985,
0.032979697,
0.0846616551,
-0.0441690385,
-0.010875023,
0.0008055952,
0.0035006104,
0.0273875967,
-0.0269916467,
-0.0292943921,
0.012849086,
-0.0370641053,
-0.0091442848,
-0.0367016904,
-0.0568111949,
-0.0072607449,
-0.0543717258,
-0.0272077043,
0.0165595748,
-0.0010519013,
0.0000618858,
0.0693363026,
0.0473328717,
0.0117610553,
0.0021850367,
-0.0297232307,
0.0446373969,
-0.1194903776,
0.0052908263,
-0.0400158502,
0.0223413911,
0.0550059602,
0.0198540892,
-0.0202081669,
-0.0061291368,
-0.0731696188,
-0.0074566412,
-0.0463764369,
0.0101103522,
0.0406057909,
-0.0003625249,
0.0301329922,
-0.0497853011,
-0.0050172149,
-0.0234095659,
-0.0547236986,
-0.0701347739,
0.0676528439,
0.0235472098,
-0.0303164143,
0.0040709684,
-0.0321047492,
0.0974795371,
0.0501210727,
-0.039473895,
-0.0450508632,
-0.0580623746,
0.0168600138,
-0.0407555178,
0.0239963904,
0.0168470182,
-0.0277215187,
-0.0331869312,
-0.0165148489,
-0.0233124141,
0.0042801653,
-0.0103142736,
-0.0133927371,
0.0339366533,
-0.0388263687,
-0.0354642123,
0.0575983673,
0.0387917981,
-0.0477776453,
0.0134945838,
-0.0048225466,
-0.0270413328,
0.0047800452,
-0.0041336468,
0.0409811288,
-0.0258206781,
0.0359784253,
0.0147650903,
-0.0191185623,
0.0121456217,
-0.0613157079,
0.0327829383,
-0.0202684533,
-0.0381212644,
-0.0322683528,
0.0745881572,
-0.0195792988,
0.0077461586,
-0.070326671,
0.0357741974,
0.0606953539,
-0.0111119449,
-0.0164955594,
-0.0186656117,
-0.0151977902,
0.0188536756,
-0.0498032682,
-0.0470017232,
-0.0289273001,
0.0209594239,
0.0117676482,
-0.0480997525,
-0.0181009267,
0.0189577006,
-0.0616837293,
0.0251997244,
0.0208763853,
0.0057735308,
0.0423780866,
-0.0308933537,
0.0295653716,
0.0251549296,
-0.0311332494,
-0.0226848274,
0.0542493761,
0.0519837327,
0.0057463795,
-0.0369132198,
-0.0357066654,
-0.0800967216,
-0.0489893407,
0.0100553613,
-0.0659482554,
-0.0337645374,
-0.0325727463,
0.029554408,
0.0229919329,
-0.0069636563,
0.0258978028,
0.0151252206,
-0.0377435945,
0.0561021082,
0.0185171794,
0.040009588,
-0.0754961818,
0.0227938946,
0.01337774,
-0.06548132,
-0.0260810442,
0.0273755882,
0.0742414147,
0.0179137327,
0.0058235172,
-0.0283973049,
0.0128912861,
-0.0168301798,
-0.0111166593,
-0.0248435028,
0.0257777665,
0.0698686242,
0.0155125884,
-0.0421469919,
0.0281537902,
0.0135917803,
0.0420181826,
0.0091998745,
0.053199213,
-0.0026331483,
0.0557944477,
0.0095972847,
0.0339447744,
-0.0069444333,
0.040879041,
0.0107121058,
0.0188896768,
0.0031797579,
-0.0063176858,
-0.0212836172,
-0.068258822,
0.0494059362,
-0.0077840593,
-0.0174947269,
-0.006823197,
-0.0303614978,
0.0137671633,
-0.0016672808,
-0.0163758378,
0.0151959313,
0.0497751385,
0.0087367324,
-0.0116047673,
0.0012506794,
-0.0201303605,
-0.0089928685,
-0.0713354722,
-0.0360640846,
0.0112344157,
0.0561519414,
-0.0065728053,
0.0284762811,
0.0046927668,
-0.0352652706,
0.0243458729,
-0.0236547813,
-0.0168519076,
0.0100740688,
-0.0538124368,
0.0353304707,
0.0486258268,
-0.0332319848,
-0.0518928766,
0.0281353481,
-0.0760320798,
0.0204516631,
-0.003205762,
-0.0627154633,
0.0418270342,
0.040610712,
0.0164949708,
0.0658871606,
0.015779864,
0.0874423012,
0.0982424319,
0.0096526416,
0.0141006308,
-0.0263640601,
0.0626103058,
0.0304767136,
-0.0270903092,
-0.0351203345,
0.0024466712,
0.0385067835,
0.0127177034,
-0.0274380445,
-0.0221774243,
0.0959046111,
-0.0727458447,
-0.0081280787,
-0.02582312,
-0.1114903614,
-0.0119554903,
0.0545480847,
0.028512286,
-0.0248275567,
0.0056094374,
0.0114973625,
0.0172214806,
-0.0300407913,
0.0005535135,
0.0580507964,
0.0184175875,
0.025567282,
0.0185707733,
0.0148627097,
0.0111239394,
0.0512369424,
-0.0255303401,
0.0444011949,
0.0105203968,
-0.0883985534,
-0.0747332275,
0.0149220861,
0.0266017485,
0.0248015691,
-0.0697589666,
0.0768042281,
0.0053215069,
0.01731514,
-0.0768466592,
0.0245240498,
-0.0498975776,
-0.021209307,
0.0206214134,
-0.0111684967,
-0.0025854993,
-0.0336922444,
0.0266968198,
-0.0728851333,
0.0410204045,
-0.0800931901,
0.0273726936,
-0.0143045951,
-0.0538033098,
0.0175355114,
-0.0563076138,
-0.0489041321,
0.0007748252,
0.012645443,
-0.0054759574,
0.0210674256,
-0.0156370047,
-0.0203612633,
-0.0158479456,
-0.0086595006,
-0.0067813355,
0.034580674,
0.0256338362,
0.0355344675,
0.0265805069,
-0.0033456383,
-0.129669711,
-0.0320803486,
-0.0180781372,
0.0007467674,
0.0640609339,
-0.0458643623,
0.0381109342,
-0.0427183248,
-0.026773978,
0.0226460285,
0.0407968424,
0.0564607158,
-0.0079276022,
-0.0152263464,
-0.0293647777,
0.0825047046,
0.0143757043,
-0.0472812653,
-0.0214603543,
-0.0210568681,
0.0379518755,
0.0152567215,
0.0210179221,
-0.0020056628,
0.0388429277,
0.009133731,
-0.0289438739,
-0.0117807956,
-0.0115353251,
0.0418168232,
-0.0172595736,
-0.0466833599,
-0.0441277549,
0.0165575575,
0.0138443159,
-0.0112978835,
0.0360953622,
-0.0119312238,
0.0078895483,
-0.051661741,
0.0537474789,
-0.0099424869,
0.0295393225,
0.0779534429,
0.0934502557,
-0.0502829067,
-0.0073006977,
-0.0353534818,
-0.0246518198,
0.0041286675,
-0.012424075,
-0.0450677313,
-0.0039790161,
0.0011962258,
0.0033860374,
-0.032513991,
0.0448240265,
-0.0293096174,
-0.0008314466,
-0.0104551306,
-0.1506422609,
-0.0205491986,
-0.0020426649,
-0.0092620896,
0.0608450361,
0.0093620028,
-0.0518615134,
-0.007514271,
0.0206327382,
-0.0032825628,
0.0207939148,
0.0414804481,
-0.0055772699,
-0.0238146298,
-0.0054140049,
-0.0182383861,
0.0194459949,
-0.0060659591,
-0.0416827612,
0.0154112708,
-0.0194532443,
0.0742631927,
0.0244848616,
0.0249751117,
0.0118993027,
0.0078454735,
0.005112546,
0.0410525016,
-0.0443025008,
-0.0176002476,
0.0102824131,
0.0003123252,
0.0136369886,
0.0137121892,
0.0032065168,
0.0469773188,
0.0126764355,
0.000529192,
-0.0325911343,
-0.117831476,
-0.0461418517,
-0.049077075,
0.0166625474,
0.0382322595,
-0.0314237215,
-0.0359800421,
-0.021670416,
-0.0371179171,
-0.0052636974,
0.0112364097,
0.0400229059,
0.0331448279,
-0.0084957546,
0.0201413389,
-0.015223328,
-0.0616021901,
-0.0787862539,
-0.033401981,
0.008164593,
0.0667872727,
0.0180210099,
0.0288334116,
0.030167643,
0.0409795195,
0.0060592918,
-0.0085401582,
-0.0024737478,
0.0171915255,
-0.0150589077,
0.0349964723,
0.0294677317,
0.0529221445,
0.0085288556,
0.0252445582,
0.0781571493,
-0.0339302681,
-0.0100127291,
-0.0187835041,
-0.0245974939,
-0.0009325851,
-0.0034387752,
-0.0269591417,
0.0025121514,
0.0195970256,
0.0027486368,
-0.01675855,
-0.0234317742,
0.0338100344,
-0.0042985864,
0.0024531239,
0.0161894858,
0.0080885114,
-0.0175776388,
0.0202099867,
0.0320654735,
-0.0105278371,
-0.0100070778,
0.0494642332,
0.0445297509,
0.0019140079,
-0.0106330616,
0.023440836,
-0.0149652259,
-0.01097525,
0.0157932658,
-0.0008038112,
-0.0359430388,
0.0149261914,
0.0104854479,
0.0294591077,
-0.0017807774,
-0.0631259531,
-0.0195823591,
0.0241135694,
-0.0170571785,
0.0171542931,
0.0083035547,
-5.374174664e-33,
-0.0323239937,
-0.0712325051,
0.0217310861,
0.0551195927,
-0.0466896705,
-0.0403309464,
0.0381201319,
0.0189246777,
-0.0403776206,
0.0010517131,
0.0878319144,
0.0012694629,
-0.018570181,
-0.0489381701,
0.0515175983,
0.0209090356,
-0.0219401922,
-0.0151926205,
0.0012795299,
-0.0268814173,
0.0228163954,
-0.0163101628,
0.0401065126,
-0.09661863,
0.037771713,
-0.0061657508,
0.0187827237,
0.0332747549,
-0.0086098593,
0.0001160205,
-0.0249686576,
0.0055993353,
0.0262438636,
0.0099691283,
0.0489375927,
-0.018464053,
0.0372694172,
-0.0567701012,
0.0475778729,
-0.0042983866,
0.0232484415,
-0.0580007546,
-0.0493576191,
0.0357531048,
0.0152741028,
-0.0145369228,
0.0409826003,
-0.0341562629,
0.0051237643,
-0.0040070522,
-0.0583472699,
-0.0088559547,
-0.0089805471,
-0.0180345215,
0.0103858178,
-0.008182914,
-0.0158506725,
-0.035740722,
-0.0279766228,
0.0416601524,
-0.0171821304,
-0.0243174229,
-0.0225290582,
-0.0317453854,
0.0495451614,
-0.0121150753,
0.0256116204,
-0.0212387946,
0.027527431,
-0.0051002526,
0.0677915663,
0.0335048437,
0.0171655547,
-0.0141512211,
-0.0007456665,
-0.0193001218,
-0.0361801721,
-0.0407554246,
0.0190663356,
-0.0013818841,
-0.0012250589,
-0.0026838041,
-0.0217132028,
-0.0035276206,
0.0811812505,
-0.0110911177,
0.0064649563,
0.0022839203,
-0.0189794991,
-0.035780739,
-0.0309720356,
0.0036929294,
-0.0236086901,
0.0145872571,
0.0766159892,
0.0032426238,
0.0160933193,
0.0091380347,
0.0072124954,
0.0069418144,
-0.0329301544,
0.0289859679,
-0.011139838,
-0.0071304431,
0.0421668291,
0.0084167691,
-0.0157536268,
-0.0247510802,
0.0112234512,
0.0158862825,
0.0308914054,
0.0432178639,
0.027231127,
-0.0022346892,
0.0108461864,
0.0059178299,
0.0190392565,
-0.0021581652,
0.0239903573,
-0.0149602285,
-0.0479846112,
0.0400950015,
-0.0004071778,
-0.0355559066,
-0.0388461463,
-0.0327324681,
-0.0178977624,
-0.0232066028,
-0.0201990455,
-0.0571979918,
0.0132173654,
-0.0529433563,
2.802e-7,
-0.0565405078,
0.0584183894,
0.0244124942,
-0.0181058347,
0.0185174104,
0.0028205952,
0.0467916243,
0.0231373906,
0.0362032726,
0.0108468821,
0.019443851,
-0.0452489555,
-0.0057247807,
0.0579176657,
-0.0148213143,
-0.0238544233,
0.0610973798,
-0.0981341749,
-0.0633918941,
0.0278754495,
0.0377340727,
-0.0431747884,
0.0551418252,
0.0081015937,
-0.0142059829,
0.0059099062,
-0.0723726079,
0.0733626559,
0.0063343318,
-0.0221291371,
0.0465015359,
0.0676550642,
-0.0293332692,
0.0483469144,
0.0050187013,
-0.0147094708,
-0.0107383979,
-0.0130495941,
-0.0239519775,
0.0435010158,
0.0157554056,
-0.0362240374,
-0.0151142385,
-0.0168117713,
0.0412126966,
-0.0028388668,
-0.0156238293,
0.067063041,
-0.0231380053,
-0.032482814,
-0.0321682915,
-0.0125942761,
-0.0053218785,
0.0280965529,
0.0478466451,
-0.0104578417,
0.0368015207,
0.0230609924,
0.0529314093,
0.0904861763,
0.0034759846,
-0.0365398973,
0.0415364057,
-0.0044733463,
0.0314070173,
-0.0043339469,
0.0108246719,
1.996881819e-34,
-0.0264556594,
0.0565190725,
-0.0094267465,
-0.1322128773,
-0.0090087652,
0.0377433859,
-0.0700610578,
-0.0065569244,
0.0261025522,
-0.0156469326,
0.0207646899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17922v1 | [Lions: 1] and [Tigers: 2] and [Bears: 3], Oh My! Literary Coreference Annotation with LLMs | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | Rebecca M. M. Hicke, David Mimno | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coreference annotation and resolution is a vital component of computational
literary studies. However, it has previously been difficult to build high
quality systems for fiction. Coreference requires complicated structured
outputs, and literary text involves subtle inferences and highly varied
language. New language-model-based seq2seq systems present the opportunity to
solve both these problems by learning to directly generate a copy of an input
sentence with markdown-like annotations. We create, evaluate, and release
several trained models for coreference, as well as a workflow for training new
models. | [
0.0539314076,
0.0357597843,
-0.0059199408,
0.0117723504,
-0.0314499401,
0.0159996226,
0.0052354345,
0.0043635522,
0.0464867949,
-0.0885661691,
-0.0077139977,
0.0546813011,
-0.0226142202,
0.0066939499,
0.0318786949,
-0.0116033731,
0.0283467714,
-0.022925159,
0.0426028222,
0.0231180359,
0.0154616991,
0.0530472249,
0.0207858328,
0.0352876,
-0.0285240784,
-0.0559625216,
-0.014228126,
0.0407922938,
0.0262180548,
-0.0166594964,
0.01015581,
0.0442975871,
0.0210609995,
0.0381659679,
0.0000017107,
-0.0495001189,
-0.0224798154,
-0.0091634868,
0.0266281236,
0.0371457711,
0.0248715933,
0.0006429796,
0.001819485,
-0.0027436283,
-0.0094157504,
0.0038003367,
0.0363050811,
0.0606823266,
0.083018288,
0.068126671,
-0.0110393427,
-0.0145423198,
-0.0176744349,
-0.0248873234,
-0.0246428549,
-0.0401165932,
0.0247883927,
0.0306883566,
0.0189960096,
0.0503561869,
0.0124035943,
0.0330781117,
-0.0058626817,
-0.0439667664,
-0.0002954952,
0.0044650254,
-0.0445472226,
0.0284179989,
-0.0160412155,
0.0293201283,
0.0516392998,
-0.0246602409,
0.0072061908,
0.0163119566,
-0.0349346511,
-0.0050340621,
-0.0394462235,
0.0241195131,
-0.0095410012,
0.0278591812,
0.038852673,
0.0078540221,
0.0010674255,
-0.0107461112,
0.0113168871,
0.0394902341,
0.0254117176,
0.0249529686,
0.0325942785,
-0.0031936259,
-0.0748154446,
-0.0838550329,
0.0463700481,
0.0300599299,
-0.0040264199,
-0.0174059588,
-0.0570107922,
0.0054185088,
-0.0026007155,
-0.0319291465,
0.0464048944,
0.0044105328,
-0.0004906731,
0.030052213,
0.0068103294,
0.0330079533,
0.0066593811,
0.0182579607,
-0.0351219811,
-0.0087043205,
-0.0204086453,
-0.009818079,
-0.0637464598,
0.0408415981,
-0.0439212732,
-0.0478940345,
-0.0393053293,
0.0073479102,
0.0487077311,
0.0218355786,
-0.0018553144,
0.0070573678,
-0.0342718996,
0.0064321114,
-0.0047543067,
0.0041474137,
-0.0106823388,
0.0109315841,
-0.0288594868,
0.0031575742,
0.0010482161,
0.0296357162,
0.0015238461,
-0.0602936447,
-0.0035977222,
0.0661478415,
0.0107884659,
-0.0237070974,
-0.0489673503,
-0.0313572213,
-0.022842424,
-0.0257361252,
-0.0602719821,
-0.0574716516,
-0.0033320633,
-0.0041883681,
0.0088735772,
-0.0845066607,
0.0472987369,
0.0298443232,
-0.0439165942,
0.0477774255,
-0.0263342932,
-0.0187728833,
0.01508947,
-0.0053412085,
0.031104017,
0.0518557131,
0.0856592879,
0.018382458,
0.0618165135,
0.0187675636,
-0.0191612635,
0.057090234,
-0.0220514536,
0.0169589892,
-0.0400747433,
-0.0326900855,
-0.0071324906,
0.0249461923,
0.0195676852,
0.0927098244,
-0.0161766931,
-0.0031300685,
0.0843990073,
0.0791065544,
-0.0017000817,
0.0074804788,
0.0326730348,
-0.0014922112,
0.0144072948,
0.0474507026,
-0.0514517911,
0.0098809153,
0.0276506711,
0.0018394648,
0.0139315426,
-0.0107100019,
0.015178293,
-0.0204205755,
-0.0491225459,
-0.0063028107,
-0.037073113,
-0.0379845798,
0.0137607912,
0.0207802765,
-0.0491109267,
0.0260069836,
-0.0088825775,
-0.0637495965,
0.0200228896,
0.0032007922,
0.0026215522,
0.0267400909,
0.0595313944,
-0.019073436,
-0.0306473635,
-0.0223640129,
0.031051334,
0.0640611872,
-0.0042600972,
-0.0563714877,
0.0055277706,
-0.0344790667,
0.0167363733,
-0.0329408199,
0.0337377638,
-0.0204910152,
-0.0037088604,
-0.0056891995,
0.0043066884,
-0.0032470583,
-0.0509161577,
0.0508564785,
-0.0568406954,
-0.0183853712,
-0.0250817537,
-0.0219626259,
-0.0030737123,
0.0106622996,
-0.0194688737,
0.0244513657,
0.0589241795,
-0.0630748942,
-0.0197563209,
0.0398792401,
-0.0159311667,
-0.0334259048,
0.0746290982,
-0.0812627301,
0.0037798395,
-0.0003860167,
-0.0222470909,
-0.0455777049,
-0.0248506628,
-0.0333468392,
0.0609789081,
-0.0482817851,
-0.0005523841,
0.034863431,
-0.0298746284,
-0.0716473758,
0.0352494307,
0.0049630543,
-0.0032210178,
0.014199134,
0.0009017458,
0.0044058184,
-0.0166741721,
-0.0080360286,
-0.0401250906,
0.0524890795,
-0.0288946275,
0.011061904,
-0.0061715059,
-0.0349031463,
-0.051419165,
-0.0684086159,
0.0441122316,
-0.0276615229,
0.0135910269,
0.0323003568,
-0.0116874818,
-0.0014052307,
-0.0046002739,
-0.0094156181,
-0.0309062935,
0.0087817339,
-0.002275194,
0.0497620516,
0.0156364832,
-0.0177047439,
-0.0472101122,
0.0077926465,
-0.0422629602,
0.0589538403,
0.0133207366,
-0.0012712381,
-0.0370815545,
0.0303267781,
-0.0050460808,
0.0263213553,
0.0000821856,
-0.0022453233,
0.009850922,
-0.0022251906,
0.0103341201,
0.0494889095,
0.0031574445,
0.0312650092,
0.0263541676,
-0.0555531271,
-0.0130086793,
0.010437971,
0.0185099561,
-0.0422330871,
-0.0363534465,
-0.0337643176,
0.0106845768,
0.0685219169,
-0.0115837883,
-0.0063550575,
-0.0216906257,
0.0666850507,
0.016266197,
-0.0202404987,
0.0094496403,
-0.0366327912,
-0.0295132361,
0.0529304817,
-0.028880436,
-0.0128427995,
0.0348955058,
-0.0556046516,
-0.0057276185,
-0.0028442275,
0.0118173817,
-0.0601932816,
0.0824214444,
0.0002884582,
0.0086034341,
0.0264831576,
-0.0407712683,
-0.0395782925,
0.0035718081,
0.041104503,
-0.0091908583,
0.045163881,
-0.0267770644,
0.0140459128,
-0.017829895,
0.0229969844,
-0.04140535,
0.0427688919,
-0.0775431767,
0.0060065938,
0.00066566,
0.0059565525,
-0.0247056298,
0.0089195631,
-0.0379679315,
0.0278666858,
-0.0246596467,
-0.0020861146,
-0.0482735299,
0.0387322716,
0.065870434,
0.0010227135,
0.0002359267,
-0.0475558601,
0.0511081964,
0.0517328978,
-0.0783230141,
0.0164563544,
-0.0078275725,
0.0268141497,
0.0440976694,
-0.0811007097,
-0.0084328828,
-0.0237301886,
0.0436695591,
-0.0461969301,
-0.0327241495,
0.1325115263,
0.0328790098,
-0.0385537669,
-0.0008969263,
-0.0246365573,
0.0172850918,
0.0540143438,
-0.0069974526,
-0.0632568225,
-0.0286334883,
0.0157462917,
0.0183780249,
0.0231348723,
-0.061125651,
-0.0168912802,
-0.0805102661,
0.0511339083,
0.0204612948,
-0.0849378556,
0.005398402,
-0.007959947,
0.0081466725,
-0.0310685672,
-0.0341215581,
0.0198493395,
-0.0411805063,
0.033012569,
-0.0159295462,
0.0260248929,
0.0513849407,
-0.0343353972,
-0.0649639294,
0.014585007,
0.0365063138,
0.0499156527,
0.0247539748,
0.0149352597,
0.0315886773,
-0.0368274935,
-0.0374901742,
-0.0143099129,
0.0191023685,
-0.0404528342,
0.0062456145,
-0.0191154201,
0.0732719526,
0.0205446556,
-0.0538813099,
0.0489172041,
0.0367945768,
0.007369549,
0.0181552302,
-0.0343331099,
0.0568889938,
-0.0017323612,
0.0755206496,
0.0599435829,
-0.0151602086,
-0.0322880708,
-0.0387462862,
0.0217652861,
-0.0601669587,
-0.0781252459,
0.0185368992,
-0.0502201058,
0.0026952182,
-0.0898051262,
-0.0305683631,
0.0356872082,
0.0296349898,
0.0471353307,
0.0261774305,
-0.017979281,
-0.0129983872,
-0.0327373594,
-0.0126225296,
-0.0309308656,
-0.0312514007,
-0.0472439751,
0.0246866196,
0.0601140931,
-0.0019435006,
0.0135799013,
0.0412999913,
-0.077520743,
-0.0537847243,
-0.0216777939,
0.0281604137,
0.0269844271,
0.0327817202,
-0.0218687672,
-0.0300678778,
-0.0296228267,
0.0419095904,
-0.0110137286,
0.0429277532,
0.004915792,
0.0357980803,
-0.0236974675,
0.0490569286,
-0.0124739185,
0.04589184,
-0.0156622436,
0.0582868643,
-0.0304079838,
-0.1068428755,
0.0129833966,
0.0034239436,
0.016757749,
-0.0344909057,
-0.0034448183,
-0.0077505442,
0.0260858256,
-0.0368773825,
-0.0336616226,
-0.0441697761,
0.0543787256,
-0.0101367049,
0.0112256724,
-0.0292533636,
-0.0130554913,
-0.045393195,
0.0868692324,
-0.0568376482,
0.0213029068,
0.0442265049,
-0.0047194664,
-0.0341790505,
-0.020500889,
-0.0178143233,
0.0278948322,
-0.0170166213,
0.0789559931,
-0.0056100725,
0.0165265519,
0.0197018608,
0.0005339489,
0.0172879994,
0.0067967214,
-0.0492101461,
-0.006528202,
-0.043384511,
0.0066512777,
0.0706980526,
-0.0242152736,
0.1074558794,
-0.0026790011,
-0.0317667946,
-0.0144951493,
0.0577687882,
0.0261377003,
0.0135675855,
-0.0376401693,
0.0119017819,
0.006214615,
0.0502449982,
0.0291486904,
0.0183294192,
0.018235879,
0.0688908026,
-0.0529664122,
-0.0207601525,
-0.0415416881,
0.0021964461,
-0.0129794395,
0.0314902663,
-0.019572271,
-0.0651982948,
-0.0519999452,
0.1122100651,
0.0307837445,
0.0109353103,
0.0146187739,
0.0011721711,
0.0110271769,
0.0246931929,
-0.0144062676,
-0.0586826093,
0.0430845581,
0.0116317905,
-0.0581752099,
-0.0182042532,
-5.319353648e-33,
-0.0776132643,
-0.029187426,
0.00342484,
0.0342976712,
-0.0502498634,
0.0152713209,
-0.0137922568,
-0.0109299505,
0.054584261,
0.0147829531,
-0.0228850655,
-0.0163498819,
0.000402608,
-0.0094775846,
-0.0049607861,
0.0192054119,
0.0554000102,
0.0114492923,
-0.0403902829,
-0.0116927614,
0.0443767048,
0.0428005382,
0.0839094371,
-0.0645843595,
0.0123056341,
-0.0433337949,
-0.0197448581,
0.0033497789,
0.0229723938,
0.0324910209,
-0.0113288984,
-0.0047626998,
-0.0113173071,
-0.0045451391,
-0.0051249284,
-0.0221796595,
-0.0928962827,
-0.0195483752,
0.0439035632,
-0.0020781197,
0.0145888813,
-0.060768757,
0.039268773,
-0.0206421651,
0.0184066053,
-0.0184810087,
0.0641402006,
-0.0268532429,
-0.0287878495,
-0.043156743,
-0.0667055175,
0.020160079,
-0.0232708883,
0.0049035419,
-0.0046117334,
0.049866993,
0.0135851512,
0.0315302722,
-0.0232146289,
0.0017403307,
0.0076861694,
0.0561721325,
-0.0123523353,
0.0077333366,
-0.0141532747,
0.0552162156,
-0.0448483005,
-0.0269175395,
-0.0276065189,
0.0587541759,
-0.0027238373,
0.0210812222,
0.0283035431,
0.0889521018,
-0.0200923141,
0.030933354,
-0.0823820159,
0.0426116213,
0.0108333211,
0.0190879386,
0.0125171961,
-0.0136829894,
0.0220438018,
-0.0133477589,
-0.0693349317,
-0.0466019623,
0.0059401989,
-0.0281971656,
0.0107344557,
-0.015563977,
-0.0566428527,
0.0228645988,
0.0108926902,
-0.0181170143,
-0.0305930879,
-0.0380021632,
-0.010903853,
0.0339756124,
-0.0239924118,
0.0219576508,
0.0012778166,
-0.0032473595,
0.0319938995,
-0.0195940696,
0.0533526763,
-0.0177319217,
0.0337828323,
-0.0060251444,
-0.0559578463,
-0.0102052242,
-0.00912253,
0.0148467468,
-0.033311855,
0.0203139503,
0.0039680637,
-0.0260953493,
0.0088822283,
0.0206644703,
0.0015407878,
0.0109230028,
-0.0510734655,
-0.0088124517,
0.0308515467,
0.0259646177,
-0.0198381711,
-0.0008077626,
0.001161442,
0.0249122102,
-0.0119983042,
-0.0657002479,
0.0005613377,
-0.0105933957,
2.347e-7,
0.0531353354,
0.0031900737,
0.0500582904,
-0.0240824409,
-0.002144621,
0.0041595735,
-0.030826211,
0.052537635,
0.0205811076,
-0.0609017164,
0.0023523003,
0.0335607342,
0.0101569965,
0.0295116324,
-0.1215613782,
-0.0144611644,
-0.0717410669,
-0.0099623902,
-0.0477005728,
-0.0089809466,
0.0242523514,
0.0511285588,
0.0488394871,
-0.003636651,
-0.0100596026,
-0.0221165214,
0.0490143932,
-0.0270742401,
-0.0304049253,
0.0453068167,
0.0335483365,
0.0089138588,
-0.0185095426,
-0.0024042134,
-0.005382807,
0.0139957229,
0.0437448174,
0.0849286616,
0.0106621617,
-0.0222336203,
-0.0205116663,
0.0043077939,
0.0201544855,
0.0079668248,
0.0577496476,
0.0094650686,
-0.0069547738,
-0.0660612658,
-0.041870635,
0.0066855792,
0.0138244824,
-0.0071543013,
0.0022447091,
0.0452135503,
0.0137415407,
0.0246369503,
-0.0090657156,
-0.0660826713,
-0.0366677344,
-0.0094392374,
0.0018094972,
-0.0426950157,
-0.0115747135,
-0.0228969771,
-0.0656147823,
-0.0680264905,
-0.0205941871,
2.32532114e-34,
0.0469603911,
-0.0158278402,
-0.005510238,
0.0986488685,
0.0103224507,
-0.0143513577,
0.0011193547,
0.0127310073,
0.0108948611,
-0.0306956507,
-0.0182654168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17919v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17919v3 | LOCOST: State-Space Models for Long Document Abstractive Summarization | 2024-01-31T15:33:37 | 2024-03-25T12:52:42 | Florian Le Bronnec, Song Duong, Mathieu Ravaut, Alexandre Allauzen, Nancy F. Chen, Vincent Guigue, Alberto Lumbreras, Laure Soulier, Patrick Gallinari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State-space models are a low-complexity alternative to transformers for
encoding long sequences and capturing long-term dependencies. We propose
LOCOST: an encoder-decoder architecture based on state-space models for
conditional text generation with long context inputs. With a computational
complexity of $O(L \log L)$, this architecture can handle significantly longer
sequences than state-of-the-art models that are based on sparse attention
patterns. We evaluate our model on a series of long document abstractive
summarization tasks. The model reaches a performance level that is 93-96%
comparable to the top-performing sparse transformers of the same size while
saving up to 50% memory during training and up to 87% during inference.
Additionally, LOCOST effectively handles input texts exceeding 600K tokens at
inference time, setting new state-of-the-art results on full-book summarization
and opening new perspectives for long input processing. | [
0.0194792449,
0.0478836894,
0.0233544204,
0.0114988787,
-0.0190805085,
-0.0084998375,
-0.0007753093,
-0.0200671405,
-0.0525487475,
-0.0394727103,
0.0362959802,
-0.0479111038,
0.024096638,
0.0492618643,
0.0115694525,
-0.0971215665,
0.0159406513,
-0.0266216788,
-0.0189291202,
0.0003906216,
0.0187083334,
0.000457638,
0.0345322341,
0.0214921944,
0.0238753185,
-0.0286639892,
-0.0336088575,
-0.0087936139,
0.0182617214,
-0.0385476016,
-0.0140959574,
-0.002702819,
0.0553548001,
0.0019394226,
0.0000018643,
-0.0292550512,
-0.0295742285,
0.0001785843,
0.0235915445,
0.0193702783,
0.015339856,
-0.0638486743,
0.0229311101,
0.0071597747,
0.0081883809,
-0.0263776872,
0.016878888,
0.0563854054,
0.0497782566,
0.0820299312,
-0.0153787648,
-0.0365045965,
0.0654663593,
-0.050346408,
0.01540861,
-0.0347115174,
0.0046668523,
-0.0174892563,
0.0229647215,
0.0173178483,
-0.0452452414,
0.0361707844,
0.0657001063,
0.0092586186,
0.0156209385,
0.0615854971,
0.0119197881,
0.0188264046,
0.0052814623,
0.052551847,
-0.0180876181,
-0.0177271683,
0.0303343926,
0.0315956362,
-0.0142418835,
-0.0296551809,
-0.0434003137,
0.0497179367,
-0.0350648724,
0.0052512623,
0.0441072173,
0.0515167229,
-0.0057703136,
0.0258309413,
-0.0641735271,
0.0135493474,
0.0167522281,
-0.0433605202,
-0.0427199863,
0.0002441022,
-0.0273888018,
-0.0519385263,
0.0463062674,
0.0598984212,
-0.0056315958,
-0.0112997089,
-0.0790317357,
-0.0672579184,
-0.0103429221,
-0.0008524103,
-0.0123318927,
0.0376426354,
0.0232525375,
0.0324969925,
-0.031818524,
0.0352267735,
-0.0003841684,
-0.0087881507,
-0.0529874563,
0.0015972259,
0.0049560745,
0.0002692991,
-0.0525668971,
0.0342321768,
-0.0477205142,
-0.0489152595,
-0.0298005976,
0.0176097769,
0.0275521036,
-0.0011482068,
-0.0200377218,
0.0189140886,
-0.0436501838,
-0.0189050417,
0.0167437028,
0.0238732733,
-0.0183335636,
-0.0327850319,
0.0596589521,
0.0191247445,
-0.0282184035,
0.0196677148,
0.030399682,
-0.0101419715,
-0.0164373778,
0.0301910527,
-0.0276576839,
-0.0360979326,
-0.0056005642,
-0.0410849564,
-0.0125784213,
-0.0567411855,
0.003555892,
-0.0593406521,
0.0103082033,
0.0208568089,
0.0033695546,
-0.0008322225,
-0.0029144876,
0.0351171941,
-0.0079632169,
0.0181256589,
-0.0028171539,
-0.0239734203,
0.0339770168,
0.0317002758,
0.0225784946,
0.0152452197,
0.034224581,
0.0595598705,
0.0001481735,
0.0232469868,
0.014775496,
0.0235004891,
0.0102018006,
0.0185279995,
0.0077788471,
-0.0055286107,
-0.0532542914,
-0.0021446459,
0.0546636656,
0.0739091858,
-0.0366295874,
0.0072306963,
0.0489290431,
0.050381504,
-0.0048978352,
0.0389070399,
0.0599060506,
0.0235899724,
0.0000571351,
0.0376714468,
-0.0015906539,
0.05123128,
-0.0034405987,
0.0628218576,
0.0714401677,
0.0223593526,
-0.0318531953,
-0.0230131876,
0.0148392124,
-0.025336666,
0.0077242712,
-0.0118129067,
0.0505168736,
0.0325679071,
-0.0931196362,
0.0422170982,
-0.0095267324,
-0.0696036145,
0.0315734558,
-0.0069036987,
0.0433960073,
0.0621330477,
0.0612683259,
-0.0210936479,
-0.0241580848,
-0.0190081168,
-0.010840591,
0.0647007897,
0.0070098932,
0.0036342386,
-0.0258084033,
-0.0666464418,
-0.0074884775,
-0.0149139659,
0.0049365503,
-0.0011044028,
0.0156491566,
0.0234301686,
0.0607593618,
-0.0065372656,
-0.0384771712,
0.0226216856,
-0.0497566201,
-0.0321940817,
-0.0227991324,
-0.0082997018,
0.0267889202,
0.001870623,
-0.0013428031,
0.0430637635,
0.0253395066,
-0.0533340871,
-0.0040051444,
0.002786329,
-0.0925508067,
-0.0545414723,
-0.0061779218,
-0.0537099093,
0.02285989,
0.0468084663,
-0.0160255488,
-0.0796782151,
0.0077637942,
-0.0788809061,
0.0500466414,
-0.0252062902,
0.0001947958,
0.0634383932,
0.0139453243,
-0.0080017019,
0.0645798817,
-0.0390277505,
0.0040182048,
0.0418745391,
0.0299993586,
-0.0142338276,
-0.0271366052,
-0.032183826,
-0.0259718969,
0.0133854775,
-0.0269589983,
0.0439010821,
0.0024473127,
0.0017222825,
-0.0052203783,
-0.0811898485,
-0.0047546346,
-0.0238537714,
0.0153304152,
0.0310494546,
0.0467026979,
0.0165463854,
0.0163852721,
-0.0505418666,
-0.0015962606,
0.0253459178,
0.0037914009,
0.0091632707,
-0.0008437708,
-0.0180575512,
-0.0342117697,
-0.0316504315,
0.0162443109,
0.0307679009,
0.0003406408,
-0.0064229132,
-0.043222025,
0.0450540408,
0.0174524058,
0.0026470439,
-0.0373106226,
0.0079402868,
-0.0110689932,
-0.0295502525,
0.0852432474,
0.0251884572,
0.0539994314,
0.0243531205,
0.0194516536,
-0.0090351114,
0.0125363665,
0.0122748557,
-0.0319076851,
0.0506805032,
-0.0013197578,
-0.0251176711,
0.0276735239,
0.065706417,
0.0043409537,
-0.0045232642,
-0.0440277159,
-0.054691352,
0.0097382776,
-0.0110779023,
-0.019879574,
-0.0380551256,
-0.0175651684,
0.0046716603,
-0.036634516,
-0.0088234264,
0.0538635403,
-0.0444052778,
-0.0002795443,
-0.0396167636,
0.0234104823,
-0.0566669889,
0.0470529236,
0.0484851226,
0.0138117736,
-0.0203606486,
-0.0110827144,
-0.0057682232,
0.0169837307,
-0.0211143978,
0.0023121899,
0.0583390221,
-0.0194778927,
0.027382277,
-0.0353939496,
-0.0168652441,
-0.0059811878,
-0.0203972813,
0.0036184425,
0.0052299746,
0.0449026078,
-0.0231236927,
-0.0426759087,
0.0395488329,
0.0224831495,
0.0983719602,
-0.0312540606,
-0.0153345196,
-0.0265003741,
0.0655467361,
0.0843690038,
0.0015778014,
0.010812087,
-0.09777309,
0.0138839399,
0.0670701414,
0.0235099457,
-0.012018864,
-0.0187211614,
-0.0250943992,
-0.0001513429,
-0.0380143784,
0.0244484209,
0.0212894436,
0.0277602058,
-0.0850522965,
-0.0452614576,
0.0992146358,
0.0141706895,
-0.0721526369,
0.0037716797,
0.0219893381,
0.0612360388,
-0.0206916705,
-0.0106627569,
-0.0763861164,
-0.0230510831,
0.0001447305,
0.0131280264,
0.0173700973,
-0.0181154069,
0.0188339818,
-0.0546906739,
0.0000544315,
0.0174328052,
-0.0723288432,
-0.0413667671,
-0.0100745661,
-0.0105223646,
0.0267831758,
-0.0081971874,
0.0475984327,
-0.0316012427,
0.0090518212,
-0.0042057862,
-0.0177249424,
0.0126446774,
-0.0212375317,
-0.0036893429,
-0.0282120928,
0.0605395101,
0.0113800773,
-0.0031566769,
-0.0035494436,
0.0270194467,
-0.0221954789,
-0.0166957229,
-0.0044446634,
0.0484390184,
-0.0237245802,
0.033193592,
-0.0348915868,
0.0634490103,
-0.0148879997,
-0.0002772894,
0.0153591102,
0.0279057827,
-0.0106166536,
-0.0111715579,
-0.0561956093,
-0.0018582087,
-0.0232530162,
0.0732597187,
0.0347062349,
-0.0188068189,
-0.0941660404,
-0.0197532419,
-0.0195948798,
-0.1011362076,
0.0019648722,
-0.0435906351,
0.0051499209,
-0.0327082649,
-0.0693380162,
-0.0505814254,
0.0084993802,
0.0004671885,
-0.0240471307,
-0.0049746381,
0.0199532118,
-0.0259414595,
-0.0512258485,
0.0211702026,
-0.013927483,
-0.0036552108,
-0.0492538512,
-0.0106830457,
0.0352926515,
-0.0203667991,
-0.0176405888,
0.0347705819,
-0.0770566538,
-0.0305290874,
-0.0136092184,
0.0381131805,
0.0156610496,
0.055892989,
0.0270169899,
0.0233050697,
0.0903053656,
0.0043141022,
-0.0206707157,
0.0379610062,
0.0099781165,
0.0232258514,
-0.0029251459,
0.0226526204,
-0.0236067604,
0.018867353,
-0.0259145387,
0.0195589382,
-0.0135216601,
-0.0138884364,
-0.0169540439,
-0.0278277993,
-0.0145581113,
-0.0263388604,
0.0269310065,
-0.0249418691,
-0.0002552689,
-0.0245035496,
0.012895179,
-0.0446075127,
0.0299583729,
0.0084845582,
0.0137871373,
-0.0007799279,
0.068833068,
0.0564737953,
0.0006181003,
-0.0353223644,
0.0221662764,
-0.0314475372,
-0.0257790722,
0.0134266904,
-0.0313823111,
-0.0444662198,
-0.0425512008,
-0.0397767797,
0.0261615943,
-0.0175914131,
0.0465767309,
0.044142928,
0.0251155626,
-0.0018552024,
0.0212861691,
-0.0762504563,
0.0331099182,
-0.049622871,
0.0112822996,
0.0378807485,
-0.0471568592,
0.070280537,
-0.0211789683,
0.0142619088,
-0.0289063603,
0.0399798676,
0.0153324492,
-0.0157359112,
-0.0270974729,
0.0258188825,
0.0219439287,
0.0152649656,
0.0942285806,
0.0082731256,
0.0220148154,
0.0337336957,
-0.0072735753,
-0.0467636585,
-0.004796335,
-0.021944318,
0.030099269,
0.0038640378,
0.001954298,
-0.0196571946,
-0.0262455866,
0.046454154,
0.0125821056,
0.0096084457,
-0.0122787422,
0.0589577854,
0.0262339879,
-0.0093918303,
-0.0178151615,
-0.0313515961,
0.0257907081,
-0.0047762129,
-0.0304576494,
-0.0455244444,
-5.70036149e-33,
-0.0290371068,
-0.0197213609,
0.0254206173,
-0.0102847051,
-0.0849801451,
0.0041867159,
-0.0939876437,
-0.0415913314,
0.0511353463,
-0.012713341,
-0.0094009573,
-0.0114970729,
-0.0138913756,
0.0778610408,
-0.0025951767,
0.0130054764,
0.0489714071,
0.0261243191,
-0.0236469507,
0.0686826259,
0.0599322505,
0.0267321616,
-0.0074749719,
-0.0003842772,
-0.0023865583,
-0.0386546142,
0.020099774,
-0.0463560857,
-0.0107790446,
0.0107800718,
-0.0366151743,
-0.001716014,
0.0390697196,
-0.0355790108,
-0.0512486324,
0.048061341,
-0.0932198912,
0.0161611736,
0.0036582917,
-0.0362584665,
-0.0652066171,
-0.0613039583,
0.0386269838,
0.0149870217,
0.0251313187,
-0.0327586755,
0.0378341414,
-0.0434138849,
-0.0245508365,
-0.0757180899,
-0.071061708,
0.0210306384,
-0.026798958,
-0.0116508259,
0.0424168594,
0.0685915649,
-0.0101574864,
0.0069270907,
-0.027561985,
-0.0031127429,
0.0310678761,
0.0763361305,
0.0233963188,
0.0358855724,
0.0109945331,
0.030764116,
-0.0231809095,
-0.0215717163,
-0.0491712429,
0.0496941395,
-0.0045314995,
-0.0074412781,
0.0063147782,
-0.019808216,
0.0627539754,
0.0190298799,
-0.0606752522,
0.0559323542,
-0.0221592616,
0.0415561609,
0.058369644,
-0.005464667,
-0.0093826335,
-0.0004125212,
0.0114519019,
0.0310665853,
-0.0010438166,
0.0036427123,
0.0118856998,
0.0615751706,
-0.0157297552,
-0.0047536823,
0.0627894327,
-0.0094124218,
0.0304384138,
0.02053844,
-0.0121926293,
0.0084876558,
-0.0005457401,
-0.0217600688,
-0.0477071404,
0.0003702345,
0.0204237364,
-0.0043871282,
-0.0410671271,
0.0155906202,
0.0440551154,
0.0092819761,
-0.0363939293,
-0.0092468169,
-0.0303943455,
0.0207366943,
-0.0319835097,
0.0779157057,
0.0218961276,
0.0078815576,
-0.0060922876,
0.0629548132,
-0.0628039911,
-0.0021506581,
-0.0291796066,
0.0095045632,
0.0165460445,
0.0326015353,
-0.0264430735,
0.022767419,
-0.048415795,
0.0342168361,
0.0179273393,
-0.0687458515,
-0.0093805455,
0.0354412496,
2.438e-7,
0.007839649,
0.0076700193,
0.0873050913,
-0.0035797933,
0.021619169,
-0.0115300305,
0.0314268731,
0.0421424508,
0.0044064573,
-0.0100074904,
0.0176082943,
0.0242612679,
0.0517418832,
-0.0067288335,
-0.1151108742,
-0.007084589,
-0.0858447179,
-0.0269311965,
-0.0408032015,
-0.0348654054,
0.061815761,
0.0682701468,
-0.0313721038,
0.0083388686,
0.0303478036,
0.002871885,
0.0500926897,
0.0255175121,
-0.0064033526,
0.0078591751,
0.0330110341,
-0.0099068368,
-0.0314048119,
-0.0451043993,
-0.0125291981,
0.0143349599,
0.0080274241,
0.0599819086,
0.0303711072,
-0.0449817888,
0.0457538366,
0.0008763664,
-0.0181526095,
-0.0001903751,
0.0544004962,
-0.0406307839,
0.014658167,
0.0062143719,
-0.0624026246,
0.0301538203,
-0.0595684014,
0.0323739201,
-0.0176920742,
0.0383075848,
0.0028851901,
-0.0273513589,
0.02456812,
-0.0790457278,
-0.0139472019,
0.0047165961,
-0.0641589984,
-0.0177579056,
-0.0673990026,
0.0144560607,
0.0066127358,
-0.0688404441,
-0.0432600975,
2.71539769e-34,
0.0822911039,
-0.0270241294,
-0.0311767291,
-0.0050707064,
0.0144820595,
-0.0446249731,
-0.0011671063,
0.0004240388,
0.015155416,
-0.1079466492,
-0.055663038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17911v1 | SNNLP: Energy-Efficient Natural Language Processing Using Spiking Neural Networks | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | R. Alexander Knipper, Kaniz Mishty, Mehdi Sadi, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As spiking neural networks receive more attention, we look toward
applications of this computing paradigm in fields other than computer vision
and signal processing. One major field, underexplored in the neuromorphic
setting, is Natural Language Processing (NLP), where most state-of-the-art
solutions still heavily rely on resource-consuming and power-hungry traditional
deep learning architectures. Therefore, it is compelling to design NLP models
for neuromorphic architectures due to their low energy requirements, with the
additional benefit of a more human-brain-like operating model for processing
information. However, one of the biggest issues with bringing NLP to the
neuromorphic setting is in properly encoding text into a spike train so that it
can be seamlessly handled by both current and future SNN architectures. In this
paper, we compare various methods of encoding text as spikes and assess each
method's performance in an associated SNN on a downstream NLP task, namely,
sentiment analysis. Furthermore, we go on to propose a new method of encoding
text as spikes that outperforms a widely-used rate-coding technique, Poisson
rate-coding, by around 13\% on our benchmark NLP tasks. Subsequently, we
demonstrate the energy efficiency of SNNs implemented in hardware for the
sentiment analysis task compared to traditional deep neural networks, observing
an energy efficiency increase of more than 32x during inference and 60x during
training while incurring the expected energy-performance tradeoff. | [
-0.0174562726,
0.0385749526,
0.0106037818,
0.0854761079,
-0.0178769305,
-0.0259316824,
-0.0056468346,
0.0064948937,
-0.0106734931,
-0.0213280339,
-0.0427909493,
0.0167089272,
-0.0013996626,
0.0503468886,
0.0024196922,
0.0035524224,
0.0785385743,
0.0273048095,
0.0258912127,
-0.0059857965,
0.0244208295,
-0.0214020852,
-0.0343801752,
0.0352034047,
-0.0182536859,
0.0095447833,
-0.0215779729,
0.0107895518,
0.0326461904,
-0.0333190896,
0.0236763265,
0.0196562521,
-0.0038981012,
0.0364261344,
0.0000018258,
0.0332131833,
0.030762542,
0.0128207877,
-0.0055816527,
0.0024090107,
-0.003151658,
-0.0349345542,
-0.0302968491,
-0.0102425031,
0.0042987876,
-0.0282002315,
0.0917426571,
0.030580977,
0.0029655234,
0.0519177392,
-0.0252235383,
-0.0338187441,
0.0484541841,
-0.0118707269,
0.0672407076,
0.0289430246,
-0.0192185696,
-0.0543691218,
0.006723226,
0.0460942239,
-0.0540366732,
0.0495739058,
0.0252847634,
-0.0023732155,
0.0290539451,
0.0467334911,
-0.0482464433,
0.0295714494,
-0.0472659767,
0.0405522622,
-0.042491477,
0.0299049299,
0.0082529029,
-0.0043196613,
-0.0758477375,
-0.0775689632,
0.0161580238,
-0.0389304794,
0.0069002048,
0.0617537536,
0.0008983387,
0.0071611274,
0.0531380996,
0.0009825099,
0.0399725102,
0.0484114997,
-0.0000268812,
0.0088741761,
0.0099836215,
0.0239943676,
0.0297174938,
-0.0045540077,
0.0331420042,
0.0139090605,
0.0116416607,
-0.0110653499,
-0.0737982541,
-0.0265856441,
-0.0109748552,
-0.0915214419,
0.0141017055,
0.0528184399,
0.0437695421,
0.0403359011,
-0.0286383852,
-0.0401614867,
-0.0310871862,
0.0131773148,
-0.036299821,
0.0254630074,
-0.0190447476,
0.0390077606,
0.0024614709,
0.0208587926,
-0.0512438603,
-0.079116255,
-0.0578100272,
0.0013089642,
-0.0131419878,
-0.0110026412,
-0.0519661568,
0.0254285,
0.0362049118,
-0.0029774571,
-0.0088757267,
0.0417439826,
-0.0189091917,
-0.0170181915,
0.016456604,
-0.0616806038,
-0.0150225796,
0.0233742986,
0.0130895013,
0.0031135825,
0.0484829918,
0.0287451558,
-0.0083200317,
-0.0489370264,
-0.0649488196,
0.0348136909,
-0.0087488908,
0.0228549484,
0.0006701448,
-0.0918570235,
0.0518774502,
0.0162469894,
-0.0257100556,
-0.005151805,
0.0476646461,
0.0252971165,
-0.0141440462,
0.071174629,
-0.047243949,
-0.0342844799,
0.0146505088,
-0.0237479843,
-0.0146391084,
0.0551493019,
0.1019946039,
0.0095784562,
0.0244934782,
0.0077028866,
-0.0135394335,
0.0026189971,
0.0413539261,
-0.0237884,
-0.0182448532,
-0.0672137812,
-0.0587426051,
0.0007954336,
0.0661984906,
0.0615841001,
-0.0371791795,
-0.0533290282,
0.0443731509,
0.0319330767,
-0.0518149473,
0.0344056785,
-0.0038260384,
-0.0136388615,
0.0020980989,
-0.0607697219,
-0.017482236,
0.0596487075,
0.0118055772,
-0.0338845029,
-0.0006769417,
-0.0138832666,
-0.0559709817,
-0.0375806242,
0.0006400096,
-0.027758345,
0.0187757313,
0.0431566052,
0.0267561749,
-0.01776498,
-0.0341890752,
0.0710900649,
-0.0057806596,
-0.0114513282,
-0.0384242311,
-0.0411441624,
-0.0238303337,
0.0775702223,
0.0022971237,
-0.0008011467,
0.0159468763,
0.014103042,
-0.0677418336,
0.0395687781,
0.0114186695,
0.007958482,
0.0636701733,
-0.0898931399,
0.0208880473,
-0.0173780397,
-0.0014234136,
0.0119234994,
0.0329110138,
0.0115838759,
0.0067176893,
0.039353177,
-0.0570444688,
-0.0128254788,
0.0054387916,
-0.042282816,
0.0447552055,
-0.0241189785,
0.0173002463,
-0.0373430997,
-0.0110285021,
0.0225853734,
0.027449023,
-0.0704425797,
-0.0135505302,
-0.0080898833,
-0.0249060448,
-0.0331567191,
-0.0225843284,
-0.0062453123,
0.0181046333,
0.0222556051,
-0.0106572276,
-0.0122422604,
0.0073756827,
-0.0558370166,
0.0580876656,
-0.0275966581,
-0.0159282517,
0.015688628,
0.0326736234,
0.0081110029,
0.0131903831,
0.0008366142,
0.0289419517,
-0.0087116761,
0.0044453572,
0.0098819397,
-0.0293661039,
-0.0715516135,
-0.0046738666,
0.0015367942,
-0.0087144133,
-0.0044764443,
-0.0252858289,
0.0037825939,
0.0134951919,
-0.0800961182,
-0.0016751438,
-0.0016931309,
0.0168161187,
-0.0156095522,
0.0097143529,
0.0197145194,
0.0152698243,
-0.0187671911,
0.0240116939,
-0.041848544,
0.0299213827,
0.0278522111,
0.0066570011,
-0.0076357941,
-0.0508611798,
-0.0658438355,
-0.004880101,
0.0275014974,
-0.0182757471,
-0.0386315025,
0.0044313408,
0.0433918163,
0.0119656986,
0.0135607859,
-0.002946964,
-0.0580011457,
0.010254086,
0.0192409121,
0.0486203283,
0.062226776,
0.0012753588,
0.0043497668,
-0.0145337014,
-0.0187617037,
-0.0015741589,
0.0548328049,
-0.006181669,
0.0662629902,
-0.0161518026,
0.0107029099,
-0.0210363921,
0.0624081194,
-0.0000380111,
0.0211298894,
-0.0239225179,
-0.0565413088,
0.0080982344,
-0.0596407838,
-0.0170474872,
0.0071504796,
0.0025154606,
-0.0017165312,
-0.0118233897,
-0.0229995362,
0.0279409494,
0.0161760747,
0.0138919502,
-0.0470523089,
-0.0234461352,
-0.0115007106,
0.0375017039,
0.0421716906,
0.0647757202,
-0.0691557303,
0.0262915082,
0.0125724962,
-0.0323819853,
-0.023809839,
-0.0324567556,
0.0437846147,
0.0210077241,
0.0280500222,
-0.0391705595,
-0.0390021354,
-0.0031877074,
-0.0029190073,
-0.0308937095,
-0.0214717723,
0.0618586764,
-0.0307516847,
-0.0160109922,
0.022033276,
0.0171373617,
0.0337826349,
-0.0031005035,
-0.0283165649,
-0.0132312942,
0.0251856633,
0.016349731,
-0.0408748128,
0.0389998816,
0.0091385832,
0.0017646791,
0.1049614102,
0.039483089,
0.0530020893,
-0.1250521839,
-0.0091767386,
0.0026758569,
0.0403193086,
-0.0230373144,
-0.0115971891,
0.0242048055,
-0.030520279,
0.0052061169,
0.0585925058,
0.0196860768,
-0.0482451767,
0.0037178486,
0.0416285023,
0.0086010909,
-0.0290697105,
-0.0066174841,
-0.0240336638,
-0.0380601287,
-0.0246940441,
0.0038853232,
-0.0080041485,
-0.0104293404,
-0.0322801396,
-0.0440370068,
-0.0036597238,
-0.0057556531,
0.0469544604,
-0.0283972397,
-0.0101576094,
0.0026275238,
0.0061566387,
-0.0198977944,
-0.0146125043,
0.0339728408,
-0.0111767724,
-0.0002161224,
-0.0244622361,
-0.0134101342,
0.0207652319,
-0.0386617109,
0.0457976572,
0.0695422217,
0.0101332618,
-0.0477956831,
-0.0592871718,
0.0215859637,
0.01245037,
0.0026811957,
-0.0139875896,
0.0380576886,
0.0148241846,
-0.0603825152,
-0.0085767526,
-0.0201386474,
-0.0474661589,
-0.0201608296,
-0.0424663574,
0.0419061631,
-0.0234591067,
-0.0011915022,
-0.0616976433,
0.0303719845,
0.0242669675,
0.053688623,
0.0008771231,
-0.0435698219,
-0.06499663,
-0.0076651759,
-0.0122945001,
-0.0990862623,
-0.0110806711,
0.0016280044,
0.0453532524,
-0.0728606582,
-0.0226420388,
-0.0379761197,
-0.0208810735,
0.0260612145,
-0.0218168367,
-0.0421279222,
0.0384475775,
0.0134765953,
-0.0452130958,
0.0107013034,
0.010074297,
0.0206876863,
-0.0793304741,
-0.0332170799,
0.0522550121,
0.0347716846,
-0.0008308674,
0.0092212828,
-0.1059856266,
-0.0230831951,
-0.0017722208,
0.0335719027,
0.0123850945,
-0.01043915,
0.0346153639,
0.0405745916,
0.0159137771,
0.0957688317,
-0.0103914486,
0.0346010402,
0.0142278923,
0.0085881138,
-0.0079355277,
0.0274830684,
0.0086588105,
0.0611642189,
-0.0374614857,
0.0180617031,
-0.0321756266,
-0.0300735198,
-0.0226862598,
-0.0187207721,
0.0273963641,
0.0204449762,
0.0089597525,
0.0212606862,
-0.0184757598,
0.029438857,
0.0700635612,
-0.0675971881,
-0.0444661975,
0.0070847366,
0.0054535661,
-0.0377740227,
-0.018727662,
0.0662286803,
-0.0667707399,
0.0129813142,
-0.0094030416,
0.0106470296,
0.000965744,
-0.0402307585,
0.0239500012,
-0.0419889949,
0.0317170657,
-0.0054058512,
0.012800104,
-0.0248588137,
0.0077403788,
0.0365556739,
0.0056805215,
-0.0697013587,
0.0305698868,
-0.0310172085,
-0.0326771289,
0.0439001806,
-0.0294991136,
0.0062425341,
0.0222577844,
-0.0000718892,
-0.0448031314,
-0.0117795076,
-0.0243171807,
0.0216023233,
-0.003073595,
0.0190963689,
0.003573464,
0.0504951105,
0.0173027888,
-0.0566221662,
0.0363336429,
-0.0388727039,
-0.0084284134,
0.0606553294,
-0.0081239156,
0.0015354363,
-0.0065059261,
-0.0853266418,
-0.0074507203,
0.0242878087,
-0.0187550392,
-0.0310182385,
-0.022046864,
0.0470052026,
0.0058902777,
0.0494835712,
-0.0153767522,
0.0699250102,
0.0470793173,
0.019287888,
-0.0323650055,
0.0185541026,
0.0140729919,
0.0182399359,
-0.0232929531,
-0.0271640904,
-5.665430206e-33,
0.0234779827,
-0.0079163006,
0.0449103042,
0.055586718,
-0.0131558711,
0.073746793,
-0.0348622575,
-0.0348632745,
-0.0500906259,
-0.0085183559,
-0.0180622023,
0.0396166369,
0.0200556275,
0.0504502542,
0.0430438444,
-0.0478682369,
0.0313052461,
-0.0060010776,
0.0412856974,
0.0187805519,
0.0471294746,
0.0156505723,
0.0801485479,
-0.041785676,
-0.0045099836,
0.0383449756,
0.0094436882,
-0.0769462362,
0.0244078618,
0.0166039094,
-0.071853742,
0.085515283,
0.0079479525,
-0.0165308528,
0.017217746,
0.0346147455,
-0.059980154,
-0.0275303125,
-0.0316323526,
0.0093254708,
-0.0493495055,
-0.0142881004,
0.0521483161,
0.0222052392,
-0.019890422,
-0.0057947095,
-0.0066863489,
-0.0099405861,
-0.0088985497,
-0.0287810732,
-0.0356744677,
0.0182426106,
0.0411556363,
0.0081334999,
0.0110260816,
-0.0069871391,
-0.0358133502,
0.0292853694,
-0.1165120751,
0.0137911122,
-0.0007147318,
0.0813009366,
-0.0194570478,
0.0219599959,
0.0295023546,
0.0536698289,
0.0778603405,
-0.0135623105,
-0.0080965022,
0.0771149099,
0.0603131875,
0.024132004,
0.0414842665,
0.0216469802,
0.1255902946,
-0.0515173972,
-0.0532219857,
-0.0088800266,
0.0717385486,
0.0056073256,
0.0496883988,
0.0036720086,
-0.0444022566,
-0.0454089306,
0.0143027259,
0.0379781611,
-0.0159835313,
-0.0411940366,
-0.024369102,
0.0286271665,
-0.0186645612,
0.0219875593,
0.0255179144,
-0.0155961858,
0.0171276927,
0.0253849681,
0.0341693982,
0.0258640274,
0.0359092057,
0.0013192618,
-0.0493884608,
-0.0197341871,
-0.0352967195,
-0.012537566,
0.0090725934,
0.0125537897,
-0.0198328868,
0.0898933858,
-0.0300238337,
-0.0333115421,
-0.0498763025,
-0.0122633036,
0.0208762549,
0.0364120081,
-0.0107493317,
-0.0108193327,
-0.002307923,
0.029504884,
-0.0508895479,
0.0323558897,
0.0019625004,
0.0317913964,
-0.0093599334,
0.032696858,
0.0045078639,
-0.0025264134,
-0.0488746949,
0.0348728262,
-0.0394396,
-0.1290879846,
-0.0268517062,
0.0351362117,
2.737e-7,
0.0075004129,
-0.0065858797,
-0.0123781757,
-0.0145332962,
0.0315409079,
0.037454132,
0.0665677339,
0.0271118581,
-0.0093055153,
-0.0510929078,
-0.0155181224,
0.0540017523,
-0.0006472894,
0.0502787381,
-0.0675545186,
-0.0576940365,
-0.0185847674,
0.0537997931,
0.015780516,
-0.0119010974,
0.034004651,
0.0493343771,
0.0154642966,
-0.0352407172,
0.0471851192,
-0.0026599737,
0.0508965217,
-0.006801574,
0.0220367759,
-0.0231064092,
-0.0567422956,
-0.0066061392,
0.0061361408,
0.0148383044,
0.0070707859,
-0.0374927446,
-0.0213735271,
0.0073290458,
-0.0279751644,
-0.0462657474,
0.0059321094,
-0.0188857317,
-0.0264950208,
-0.002750363,
0.0350294933,
-0.0046086037,
-0.0535696223,
-0.0354635119,
0.0170815475,
-0.0060967766,
0.0332895927,
-0.000245879,
-0.0383411013,
-0.0374956913,
-0.0095814457,
-0.0434425063,
-0.0308491345,
-0.0491780564,
0.0419590212,
-0.00876885,
-0.0182052385,
-0.0109505476,
-0.0884549245,
-0.0001185236,
0.0357513428,
-0.0061025256,
-0.0291593689,
2.414849958e-34,
0.019849062,
-0.0436020494,
-0.0002493688,
0.0475127026,
-0.0228329636,
0.0302389748,
0.0011819782,
-0.0621722415,
-0.0190848541,
-0.0182232298,
-0.0656490549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17902v1 | Revisiting speech segmentation and lexicon learning with better features | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | Herman Kamper, Benjamin van Niekerk | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We revisit a self-supervised method that segments unlabelled speech into
word-like segments. We start from the two-stage duration-penalised dynamic
programming method that performs zero-resource segmentation without learning an
explicit lexicon. In the first acoustic unit discovery stage, we replace
contrastive predictive coding features with HuBERT. After word segmentation in
the second stage, we get an acoustic word embedding for each segment by
averaging HuBERT features. These embeddings are clustered using K-means to get
a lexicon. The result is good full-coverage segmentation with a lexicon that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ZeroSpeech benchmarks. | [
-0.0630198792,
0.0384208634,
0.0297920238,
0.0172675606,
-0.0016959467,
-0.0359596051,
0.0263213608,
-0.0134612815,
-0.0794967562,
0.0031379256,
-0.0075741457,
-0.030003095,
0.0142593989,
0.0127684167,
0.0185037181,
-0.0914673656,
0.0094800638,
-0.0390259288,
0.0039081611,
-0.0207674913,
0.0262717437,
-0.0069510667,
-0.0633387193,
-0.0284503754,
-0.0754971877,
0.0032111222,
-0.0392521694,
-0.0137228025,
0.0014916385,
-0.0371669084,
-0.0225610696,
0.0052421344,
-0.0008814739,
0.010811165,
0.000001936,
-0.0463669039,
-0.0234052539,
-0.0260241237,
-0.0433099903,
0.0071920562,
0.0385330357,
-0.0153400078,
0.0009118175,
-0.0153989475,
0.0291662309,
0.0067490465,
0.008013838,
0.025780214,
-0.0160077512,
0.0492261387,
-0.0150243202,
-0.0468666404,
0.0140039949,
-0.0004437652,
-0.0310684759,
0.0203081425,
-0.0052126488,
-0.0086517483,
0.0004303119,
-0.0492013618,
-0.026424095,
0.0426877588,
0.0053044586,
-0.0254318323,
0.0595365688,
0.0524146594,
-0.083116442,
-0.0416987613,
-0.0095049981,
0.0554610491,
0.0007710153,
0.0511796474,
0.0358983688,
-0.0010531782,
-0.0318048783,
-0.0476981141,
-0.0095403688,
0.0216212273,
0.0499512702,
-0.0075236582,
-0.0118186176,
0.0649455562,
0.0238074288,
-0.0159689654,
-0.0236277822,
0.0366909802,
0.0069788583,
-0.0542332195,
0.0134081496,
-0.0046265577,
-0.0246700644,
0.0150962975,
0.0041611088,
-0.0214258637,
0.0456621982,
0.0092085376,
0.0099248309,
-0.0177375004,
-0.029136477,
0.0039549223,
-0.0550398752,
0.021987468,
-0.0103799924,
0.0179404896,
-0.0076397699,
-0.0317123607,
0.0246478692,
0.0036276693,
-0.0527047999,
0.0150304874,
-0.0264718048,
0.0031230929,
-0.0521982796,
0.0251101535,
-0.0126013821,
-0.0148064196,
-0.0365989245,
-0.0057068728,
0.0193934944,
-0.0152015453,
0.0363591276,
-0.0081686825,
-0.0425057076,
0.0140992021,
0.0301333852,
-0.0096170977,
-0.0603169948,
0.0185137242,
-0.0004293661,
-0.007136778,
-0.0180060957,
0.0202387832,
0.0011725521,
-0.0233938769,
-0.0198117308,
0.0351533145,
-0.0134528233,
-0.0347803868,
-0.0406891927,
-0.051011987,
-0.0658563823,
-0.0154615641,
-0.0151682813,
-0.0714241192,
-0.0115543567,
-0.0299686864,
0.0294146109,
0.0368169509,
-0.0303432439,
-0.0697873384,
0.038596537,
0.0484417826,
0.0115220789,
0.0213825088,
0.0171934441,
0.0175960958,
0.0625061542,
0.0870561823,
0.0453823879,
-0.0131439865,
0.0449433289,
0.0296939556,
-0.0352178104,
0.0515836067,
-0.0085932324,
0.004084208,
-0.0673764274,
-0.0484616198,
0.0512616076,
0.036046423,
0.0677005351,
-0.0133464569,
-0.0427801199,
-0.0548406802,
0.022692496,
0.0944376886,
0.0359918885,
0.0308022611,
-0.0241147336,
0.0354015604,
-0.0381792486,
0.0021894737,
0.0595666356,
-0.0542341359,
0.0031296066,
0.0242527016,
0.0721848011,
-0.0139037957,
-0.0403594561,
-0.0254107509,
-0.0159874987,
-0.0439792685,
0.0331031084,
0.0252660718,
0.0715604499,
0.0189508181,
-0.0005913714,
0.0772260129,
-0.0097994423,
-0.0578288995,
-0.0160054155,
-0.0085030999,
0.0337908827,
0.0148169221,
0.0250597429,
-0.0669830069,
-0.0055055828,
-0.0335459411,
-0.0069415178,
0.0441376381,
-0.0140277827,
-0.0315659456,
0.0643889084,
-0.0748220608,
-0.0211841986,
-0.0020404735,
0.0000401956,
-0.0214505121,
-0.0039246147,
0.0336315781,
0.0032323301,
-0.0565654263,
0.074653022,
0.004414923,
-0.0064076376,
-0.0317218713,
-0.0098173441,
0.0019391259,
0.064077206,
0.0435400158,
-0.0301673152,
-0.0251803119,
0.0234685466,
-0.0341671035,
0.0313922316,
-0.0038283882,
-0.0898142457,
-0.0783735141,
0.0377076827,
-0.0397955626,
-0.0049760207,
0.0164511744,
0.0249218885,
-0.0843142569,
0.0363081358,
0.0185461361,
0.052040793,
-0.0343173258,
0.0146531677,
0.0096430499,
0.0356943011,
0.0287722852,
0.023839036,
-0.0180261265,
-0.0139475362,
-0.0241103452,
-0.0073936763,
-0.0116176065,
-0.0743807405,
-0.0382738896,
0.01177656,
-0.0266352668,
-0.0096848337,
-0.0207485072,
-0.0230686907,
-0.0197012499,
0.0176991969,
-0.0749698058,
0.0025340212,
-0.0217719283,
-0.0256931968,
-0.0329577513,
0.031566482,
-0.0181392413,
0.0037497366,
0.0040407749,
-0.0364845917,
0.0121896351,
-0.0137882028,
-0.027909454,
-0.0123537667,
-0.0237364098,
-0.010396854,
-0.0229575429,
0.028105028,
-0.0065598004,
-0.0368188769,
-0.0007079307,
0.0153375408,
0.0348490737,
0.0168172158,
0.0055536646,
0.008837658,
-0.0153921014,
-0.0223265551,
-0.0077115819,
0.0095600504,
0.0450059548,
0.0042485818,
-0.0144144734,
-0.0220096316,
-0.0314568169,
0.0213767532,
-0.007465316,
0.0058355168,
0.0734361112,
0.0046870769,
0.0253907628,
-0.017879732,
0.1004711688,
0.0360169075,
0.0004379248,
-0.0095528793,
-0.1030074582,
-0.03462556,
-0.0522115156,
-0.0246552136,
-0.0003398297,
-0.0308887772,
-0.001091661,
-0.0069222478,
-0.0247652847,
0.0150059974,
-0.053483177,
-0.0290257186,
-0.0627713427,
-0.0774481967,
0.0225377548,
-0.0103529571,
-0.0056639002,
-0.0090130316,
-0.0250303261,
-0.0292121954,
-0.0114702871,
-0.0235830583,
0.0167281702,
-0.007111968,
0.0554799773,
-0.004809889,
0.017289184,
0.006857174,
-0.008145784,
-0.0252532084,
-0.0085407551,
-0.0037701514,
0.0653985217,
0.0243391804,
-0.0382494852,
0.007588218,
0.0665103123,
0.0202112291,
0.0640971735,
0.0421560258,
0.0059226989,
0.0073150313,
0.0763435587,
0.013304974,
0.0325668044,
-0.0382096171,
-0.0042823744,
0.0397045575,
-0.0016297485,
0.1071811095,
-0.002929481,
-0.0176670291,
0.0131657179,
0.00710988,
-0.0298365578,
-0.0233897343,
0.0024415147,
0.0466098823,
-0.0276344307,
0.0123875756,
0.1063379496,
0.0296277106,
-0.007261063,
0.0079087252,
-0.0152051821,
0.0073321401,
0.0229153242,
-0.0577840917,
-0.0115393195,
-0.0221540313,
0.0145418914,
0.0659568235,
0.0212367382,
-0.0163687319,
0.0203625131,
-0.0643631816,
0.0286314338,
0.0179067608,
-0.0362460464,
0.0342037529,
-0.0495175533,
-0.0071194144,
-0.0624433979,
-0.026596874,
-0.0177681725,
-0.0100207124,
-0.0528631806,
0.0330356769,
-0.075686343,
0.0396157652,
0.0017806259,
-0.0260983203,
0.0333350934,
0.040445786,
0.0228090007,
-0.006985751,
0.0141929649,
0.0215317104,
-0.0474758856,
-0.0468876213,
-0.0089888331,
0.0158694685,
-0.0241307616,
0.0371997729,
0.0380691029,
0.0442283899,
0.0076822052,
0.0197165348,
0.0262400694,
0.0790272355,
-0.0043026884,
0.0694069341,
-0.0214767754,
0.0334756151,
0.0016660871,
0.0711588189,
-0.0069476329,
0.0054144729,
-0.0188593771,
0.0125824325,
0.036095012,
-0.0097426027,
-0.0074158786,
-0.0061288588,
-0.0191302877,
-0.026574349,
-0.0448021106,
-0.0147376638,
0.059254311,
0.0816574693,
-0.011124189,
0.0091391616,
-0.0191679429,
-0.0008772587,
-0.0873248428,
0.0008424604,
-0.0241796803,
-0.0252951533,
-0.0605960377,
-0.0262381267,
0.0424465872,
-0.0363270082,
-0.001458483,
0.0171413999,
0.001365301,
-0.0613400787,
0.0162166115,
-0.0105539355,
0.0077003725,
0.0851839036,
-0.0364839025,
0.0069589391,
0.1489794701,
-0.0198111683,
-0.0431663953,
0.0120421397,
0.0697955489,
0.0581300184,
-0.0066541792,
0.0293394011,
-0.036085315,
0.029630024,
-0.023505874,
-0.0083333701,
-0.0728989616,
-0.0226421263,
-0.0635145009,
-0.0018400674,
0.0715341568,
-0.0109390896,
0.0504322834,
-0.0496000201,
0.0233382806,
0.0244167298,
0.0567150526,
-0.0177553687,
0.03313189,
0.0209077541,
-0.0041259555,
-0.0187827479,
0.0606350899,
-0.0384750813,
-0.0297759492,
-0.0001824388,
0.0660009235,
0.0479620807,
-0.0151511757,
-0.0123708881,
0.0172308907,
0.038471356,
0.0153340055,
0.0081131896,
0.0100639286,
0.0341767557,
0.0083969533,
-0.0020909691,
0.0345737822,
-0.0332229175,
0.0002757401,
0.002126521,
0.0240458865,
-0.0190750286,
0.0312442724,
-0.0287591722,
-0.0794085711,
-0.0084611187,
-0.0020916406,
-0.000326993,
-0.0088562677,
-0.0029120336,
-0.0505730174,
-0.0169662964,
0.0018359998,
0.0395287573,
-0.0374688618,
0.0536694378,
0.0574095361,
-0.0259271227,
0.0138479341,
0.0066421363,
0.0406873748,
-0.0562291369,
0.00932582,
0.0284423586,
0.031387195,
-0.0195882544,
0.0189509932,
0.0102485884,
-0.0521258228,
0.0459025986,
-0.0482306257,
0.0230477024,
-0.0009584759,
0.0729202479,
0.0004228355,
-0.0202549193,
0.0186389536,
0.0292314403,
-0.037644159,
0.0194665175,
-0.0422847196,
0.0623053052,
-6.646977539e-33,
0.0029704052,
0.0030134136,
-0.0203524642,
-0.0280196276,
-0.0183596518,
0.0460137874,
0.0236908067,
0.0193888824,
0.0462267362,
-0.0037243774,
-0.0217656307,
0.0290726665,
0.031145215,
0.0685414374,
0.0200508144,
-0.0234896075,
0.0936707035,
-0.0338996239,
-0.0558438823,
-0.005069328,
0.0337035172,
0.0584175661,
0.0244890396,
0.0154684931,
-0.0354675315,
-0.0023087936,
0.0273971334,
0.0165827367,
0.0740813836,
0.0195014905,
-0.0334781371,
0.0380759686,
0.0055229487,
-0.0398836695,
-0.0255966261,
0.0081602922,
-0.0817743018,
-0.0049309446,
-0.0198061764,
0.0071327491,
-0.0189697891,
0.0272796415,
0.0295643825,
0.0395117328,
0.006643197,
-0.0273795854,
0.031639114,
-0.0377961211,
-0.0674736425,
-0.0303477254,
-0.01802014,
0.0531861149,
-0.0310966559,
-0.045656424,
0.1128210276,
-0.0452040471,
0.0031226687,
-0.0484964177,
-0.0602633916,
0.038407743,
0.0046676253,
0.0408612937,
0.0415821038,
0.0338424183,
0.0183079988,
0.0199093521,
0.0452754386,
-0.0643040985,
0.0554661937,
0.0183777865,
-0.0197503082,
-0.0045105182,
-0.0118379891,
-0.0462018661,
0.0162602141,
-0.0425920561,
0.0128172673,
-0.0226801187,
0.0178607255,
-0.0185693707,
0.0185209122,
0.0683758929,
-0.0545208231,
0.0084275752,
0.0032267852,
-0.0379045494,
0.0100033972,
0.0160674565,
0.0163343437,
0.029749224,
-0.0230009146,
-0.0007668554,
0.0448072627,
-0.0035577938,
0.0549457967,
0.0048437128,
-0.0061877896,
0.0092424564,
-0.0041999575,
-0.0113147218,
-0.0596417896,
-0.0082011018,
0.0289152842,
0.0350103043,
-0.0215658788,
-0.012938167,
-0.0303128455,
0.0328240804,
-0.0017718771,
-0.0085717402,
0.0266337991,
0.0263372865,
-0.0453082249,
0.0417804159,
0.0588062741,
-0.0197273456,
0.0148672285,
0.0556995124,
-0.0038144328,
-0.0189417098,
0.01237405,
-0.00110652,
-0.0213300455,
0.0301412661,
-0.0487247258,
0.0012986535,
0.0150560634,
-0.04747805,
0.0438226648,
-0.0538884774,
-0.0018751663,
0.0114374189,
2.806e-7,
-0.0549752116,
-0.0101933433,
0.0375736058,
-0.0775327235,
0.0119346566,
0.0138118882,
0.0217011068,
-0.0180736687,
-0.0932967886,
-0.0362667479,
0.0208849777,
0.0288364906,
0.0856817663,
0.0270833224,
-0.0940196216,
0.0094556194,
-0.0049080867,
0.0293195993,
-0.0548316538,
-0.0202684104,
-0.0329829231,
0.0805671364,
0.0159987155,
-0.0165929403,
0.0156919975,
-0.034463387,
-0.0524755642,
0.0150347231,
-0.0140512399,
-0.047153689,
0.032499291,
0.0495274253,
-0.0031184333,
-0.0328801349,
-0.0024801991,
0.0482615717,
0.0471542887,
0.0475050248,
0.0063067181,
-0.0695198998,
0.0337106884,
0.017247919,
-0.0373508446,
0.0619768649,
0.0515268594,
0.0144998608,
0.0003304386,
0.0077157258,
0.0225412883,
0.0110418992,
0.0438187569,
-0.0138300629,
0.0366382599,
0.0315050967,
0.0072010756,
-0.0039857873,
-0.0129718678,
-0.0393974409,
0.041943118,
0.0253196806,
-0.0651084483,
-0.0118162679,
-0.0245129149,
0.0312883146,
0.011850086,
0.002354421,
-0.0199469812,
2.30499496e-34,
0.0326206945,
-0.0129484674,
-0.0409780852,
0.0107139116,
-0.002607336,
-0.0417674631,
-0.039213825,
-0.0418312922,
0.0132713122,
-0.0217414331,
-0.0353270397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17897v1 | Employing Label Models on ChatGPT Answers Improves Legal Text Entailment Performance | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | Chau Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The objective of legal text entailment is to ascertain whether the assertions
in a legal query logically follow from the information provided in one or
multiple legal articles. ChatGPT, a large language model, is robust in many
natural language processing tasks, including legal text entailment: when we set
the temperature = 0 (the ChatGPT answers are deterministic) and prompt the
model, it achieves 70.64% accuracy on COLIEE 2022 dataset, which outperforms
the previous SOTA of 67.89%. On the other hand, if the temperature is larger
than zero, ChatGPT answers are not deterministic, leading to inconsistent
answers and fluctuating results. We propose to leverage label models (a
fundamental component of weak supervision techniques) to integrate the
provisional answers by ChatGPT into consolidated labels. By that way, we treat
ChatGPT provisional answers as noisy predictions which can be consolidated by
label models. The experimental results demonstrate that this approach can
attain an accuracy of 76.15%, marking a significant improvement of 8.26% over
the prior state-of-the-art benchmark. Additionally, we perform an analysis of
the instances where ChatGPT produces incorrect answers, then we classify the
errors, offering insights that could guide potential enhancements for future
research endeavors. | [
0.0641153008,
0.0304525234,
0.0065731723,
0.016548628,
-0.0698179826,
0.0412141979,
0.0038599048,
0.0198242962,
0.0837035626,
-0.0653572083,
-0.0065971841,
-0.0014873112,
-0.0296561625,
0.0002537875,
-0.0177443661,
-0.0250408798,
0.05656505,
-0.0094541088,
0.0756235793,
-0.0168392844,
0.0380849242,
0.0100706723,
0.0216873158,
0.0112690199,
-0.0496229976,
-0.0167031549,
-0.0003794898,
-0.0061088414,
-0.0003724421,
0.0025278742,
0.0394550748,
0.0842822492,
-0.0008479825,
0.0344260782,
0.0000018822,
-0.0492066704,
-0.0003977202,
0.0101938434,
-0.0010498862,
0.003836965,
0.0062135635,
-0.0102493521,
-0.0009170325,
0.0104970215,
-0.0268985685,
0.0225868374,
0.0221438296,
0.0591138266,
0.0578412861,
0.0629830211,
-0.004762948,
-0.0212537963,
0.0510812588,
-0.0292435326,
0.0567275137,
-0.0674839169,
0.0458860397,
0.0242450293,
0.0305400472,
0.0010969789,
0.0159757193,
0.0398063585,
0.0511899069,
-0.0114394836,
-0.04903806,
0.0181165449,
-0.0603398457,
0.0047277943,
0.0032521493,
0.032790862,
0.0208937451,
-0.0624921657,
0.0035228948,
0.0058112512,
0.0438775569,
0.018893674,
-0.0256058387,
0.0551561639,
-0.0310769361,
0.0008973065,
0.0296582785,
0.0279175341,
-0.0072195269,
0.0350251794,
0.0127065778,
0.1171000823,
0.0067382008,
-0.0654778928,
0.0210406072,
0.0301356819,
-0.0417211726,
-0.0594855212,
0.0285993386,
0.0270848703,
-0.0164298285,
0.0242169593,
-0.0693917051,
-0.0295798518,
0.0461180508,
-0.0639006048,
-0.0646271706,
0.0036585268,
-0.0400778428,
0.1004936174,
-0.0488265455,
0.0317195915,
0.0267424509,
0.0388297215,
-0.0188443828,
-0.0750870556,
-0.0275103617,
-0.0342417322,
-0.0390187576,
0.0483122282,
-0.0472053587,
0.0037462302,
-0.0135753611,
0.0015774905,
-0.0228893906,
0.0146262376,
-0.0034666106,
0.006724711,
-0.0165550243,
-0.0231462121,
-0.0392625332,
-0.0313682444,
-0.0403424613,
0.0474694446,
0.007691327,
-0.025745729,
0.0063372524,
0.0009141825,
0.0009140898,
-0.0071902326,
0.0372816883,
0.0989192724,
-0.0165954661,
-0.0018812984,
-0.030632725,
-0.0744002163,
-0.0493870936,
-0.0779587701,
-0.0349903144,
-0.0617714673,
0.0175873395,
-0.0120189255,
-0.0118051162,
-0.0333325714,
0.0231318157,
0.0725703388,
-0.0484631546,
0.0731470138,
0.0108071221,
-0.0144875366,
-0.0139753902,
0.0381849594,
0.0039006534,
0.0204015337,
0.0083223237,
0.0308336876,
0.0336122103,
0.0242801141,
0.0420334749,
0.0237241201,
0.0273153652,
0.0277249776,
0.0156275313,
0.019699337,
0.0287447944,
-0.0121797016,
-0.0403802358,
0.0649292395,
-0.0027761278,
-0.0334013551,
0.0417322479,
0.0234052707,
-0.0239454173,
-0.0127968602,
-0.009281856,
-0.008293394,
0.0394335948,
0.0064396556,
-0.0763155296,
0.034952525,
-0.0797637329,
0.0049057924,
-0.030007964,
0.0154570015,
-0.0226568878,
-0.056170702,
-0.013562941,
0.0065169362,
-0.0133578582,
0.0030325106,
0.0268800948,
0.015557142,
-0.0174237248,
0.0067971507,
0.0436267667,
-0.035516113,
-0.0279784445,
-0.0313577875,
0.0290610865,
0.032366138,
0.0418737084,
-0.0189000629,
-0.0450160243,
-0.0058247363,
0.0392773487,
0.0354055092,
0.0245444793,
0.0014572046,
-0.0325695425,
-0.0168126114,
-0.0332490951,
0.0316647328,
0.0501763895,
0.0143528245,
0.0326714776,
0.014353971,
0.0402448922,
-0.0594444908,
-0.0032209547,
0.0354479179,
0.0132624879,
-0.0317974165,
0.0051111216,
-0.0125708552,
0.0370418094,
-0.0030495003,
0.0044010864,
0.0001571318,
0.0199987255,
0.0103121717,
-0.0670692548,
0.0007316619,
-0.0255518761,
-0.0400067829,
0.0217280649,
-0.0416040197,
-0.0373417772,
-0.0233248174,
-0.0555156022,
-0.0453513898,
-0.0538470559,
-0.0302741136,
-0.0255471971,
-0.0662832707,
-0.0514534041,
0.0159506015,
-0.0392593369,
-0.0442262739,
0.067892924,
0.017876992,
0.0045035542,
0.0053306697,
0.0086335819,
0.0221677572,
0.0071809134,
-0.0260023344,
-0.0326643623,
-0.0278702956,
0.0180616435,
0.0425079614,
0.0473836511,
-0.0276876893,
-0.0507204309,
-0.0928095579,
0.009420421,
-0.0225843154,
-0.009814241,
0.0092383968,
-0.0289923158,
-0.0119273458,
-0.0217237771,
-0.0502991267,
-0.035252627,
0.0146191893,
0.0202109758,
-0.0000998541,
-0.0403655693,
0.0015366005,
-0.0051902262,
-0.0070310342,
-0.0397510864,
0.008888524,
0.0219150819,
-0.054711435,
-0.0221020784,
0.0272131413,
-0.0340453424,
0.0050948695,
-0.0180260036,
0.0087438691,
-0.0074863262,
0.0124722617,
-0.0004150521,
0.0116751473,
0.0071704057,
-0.0239063017,
0.0252218898,
-0.0072331904,
-0.045496881,
0.005037942,
-0.0217477567,
-0.0116886878,
0.0216610674,
-0.010677035,
-0.0100966049,
0.0355331227,
0.0022793054,
-0.0082114795,
-0.0590579659,
-0.0008315303,
-0.022381369,
-0.0028561754,
-0.0531001501,
-0.0046311985,
-0.016532341,
0.0302433725,
-0.0022000615,
-0.0667669103,
0.087860249,
0.000667182,
0.0277745537,
-0.0689393133,
-0.0216798764,
-0.0306150019,
0.0723444149,
0.0270326771,
0.0084501356,
0.0365563408,
-0.0273820572,
-0.0245402232,
-0.0174846854,
0.0568684526,
-0.0337101445,
0.0431319885,
-0.0507209636,
0.0408302099,
-0.0059052445,
-0.0282694269,
-0.0488916263,
-0.0664508715,
-0.0096360259,
0.0261593312,
-0.0359660685,
-0.0007240761,
-0.0279984139,
0.0012741089,
-0.0046038334,
0.0307261534,
-0.0165506639,
-0.0053299642,
-0.0478426367,
0.0200300813,
0.0708836615,
-0.0164680909,
-0.0308598485,
-0.0183639582,
-0.0199896097,
0.0520461909,
-0.0139116067,
0.0022149966,
0.0306038316,
-0.0016445158,
-0.0179113857,
-0.0123961689,
-0.0040794802,
0.0382554904,
0.0056741475,
-0.0625591874,
-0.0008580164,
0.0988706127,
0.0298214871,
-0.0008121632,
-0.019043399,
0.0219131969,
0.0640841946,
0.0293098502,
0.0195268504,
-0.1033633128,
-0.0454402678,
0.006118428,
0.0106361751,
-0.0256625637,
-0.0166183077,
-0.018325761,
-0.0729043558,
0.062382903,
0.0108090704,
-0.0479662567,
-0.0188339986,
-0.034622591,
0.0106494147,
-0.0102961101,
0.0145638594,
-0.0049585742,
0.0081556113,
0.0096864663,
0.0218542423,
-0.0411646031,
0.0146230124,
0.0473157875,
-0.0358948857,
0.0518089645,
0.0361670256,
0.0045701885,
-0.0195172075,
-0.0240420047,
0.0575578883,
-0.0001862381,
-0.0200169589,
-0.0110683907,
0.0365006439,
0.0027564957,
0.0129068894,
-0.0494068302,
0.0544625819,
-0.0294732302,
-0.0231545009,
0.051051829,
0.0988172591,
-0.0286036767,
-0.0343872495,
-0.044872649,
-0.0070728227,
-0.0129449274,
0.0816660747,
0.0044505103,
-0.0007100928,
-0.0620939583,
-0.0405276157,
-0.0355894528,
0.0051894067,
-0.0313057899,
-0.003841307,
-0.0219614096,
-0.0143822031,
-0.0502582602,
-0.0245854221,
0.0240641274,
0.0178298373,
0.0020531227,
0.0186760165,
0.0380417295,
-0.0031428579,
-0.0203344878,
0.0094791707,
-0.0696035698,
0.010436737,
-0.0113250492,
0.0305856243,
0.0258682761,
0.0022389721,
-0.028003728,
0.023164805,
-0.0497943796,
-0.0216357335,
0.0032897175,
-0.0118781198,
0.0212282669,
0.0184721518,
-0.077775754,
-0.0111721242,
0.0268549565,
0.0961479843,
-0.0199027807,
0.0158549715,
0.0442281254,
-0.0256036818,
-0.0071402616,
0.0234744195,
-0.0291953702,
0.0378767028,
0.0220917016,
0.0279972069,
-0.0138410376,
-0.0254752245,
0.0572733022,
0.041681096,
0.0323891975,
0.0296344534,
-0.0012626016,
-0.0168224666,
0.0166300554,
0.0012623215,
-0.0438313819,
-0.0129923597,
0.0184880085,
0.0163005572,
-0.0003605167,
-0.0378960855,
0.0380345099,
0.0001323788,
0.0379804522,
-0.0329682007,
-0.0296823513,
0.0346867107,
0.0049578962,
-0.0082297111,
-0.0519169122,
-0.0091134813,
0.0407354385,
-0.0003776767,
0.0461912528,
-0.0117906388,
0.0374145135,
0.0393862873,
-0.0216848888,
0.0100259082,
-0.0208846219,
-0.0913642123,
-0.003576068,
-0.0324172489,
0.0868958384,
0.0272446219,
0.0120109804,
0.0064245919,
-0.0477455109,
-0.01812586,
-0.0134031372,
0.0212585256,
0.0320456997,
-0.0193750337,
0.0548394993,
0.0062640952,
-0.0335851312,
0.0220077299,
0.0370610505,
0.0152430097,
0.0574544072,
0.0218680166,
-0.0330469795,
-0.0147138732,
-0.0312142428,
-0.0227201842,
-0.0082156332,
-0.0236765612,
-0.015830731,
-0.0530880988,
-0.0289134067,
-0.0122463703,
0.0202830322,
-0.002393964,
0.0347151682,
0.0216631852,
0.048934754,
0.0228970852,
-0.0520403534,
-0.0104237124,
0.0157213993,
-0.004995524,
-0.0289576277,
-0.0043451604,
-6.321930576e-33,
-0.0391194262,
-0.0564745814,
-0.0015060881,
0.0263209045,
0.0139758475,
-0.0172512773,
-0.0124655422,
0.0012152024,
-0.0123860892,
0.0363596641,
0.0060626855,
0.0412184,
0.0231974106,
0.0110888677,
0.0341589823,
-0.080501765,
-0.0090540843,
0.0203717351,
0.0115697449,
0.0311170965,
0.0298153404,
-0.0039267815,
0.0311243292,
-0.1117188111,
0.0515075251,
0.0070523228,
-0.0358418226,
-0.004963614,
-0.0938756242,
0.0503260754,
-0.0073757293,
0.0400094055,
0.0241282694,
-0.011282797,
0.0039163679,
0.0532879792,
-0.096865572,
-0.0359909758,
0.0144613273,
-0.0209149048,
-0.0152844917,
-0.0087347506,
0.0200834684,
-0.002178258,
0.0073873173,
0.0043091201,
0.0549073629,
-0.0308487639,
-0.0264980625,
-0.0675502494,
-0.066785112,
0.0567567423,
0.0188740864,
0.012274242,
-0.0140602691,
0.0410636626,
0.0166664012,
0.013917326,
-0.0433996432,
-0.0100755151,
0.008122446,
0.0097177401,
0.024029633,
-0.0531589873,
-0.0291329082,
0.0428095534,
-0.0260461941,
-0.0092282398,
-0.0539888553,
-0.0268600862,
0.0143227391,
0.0768315196,
0.0888297558,
0.0403223857,
0.0442492403,
0.0320217758,
-0.084317714,
0.0009214134,
0.0261138249,
0.0174529981,
0.0056631947,
-0.0250177886,
-0.0672997162,
-0.0326118991,
-0.0279124491,
0.0210170373,
-0.032914605,
0.0068284692,
0.0419337116,
0.0056764395,
0.0151504064,
-0.0274578743,
-0.0219666325,
-0.051467631,
-0.0004412889,
0.0052487627,
-0.0148505382,
0.0012436756,
-0.0071310755,
0.077142179,
-0.0677932724,
-0.0228811335,
0.0343829207,
-0.0058642142,
-0.0179954264,
-0.0104409484,
0.0912412256,
-0.0013550781,
-0.0635510981,
-0.0104016289,
0.0083711026,
0.0353740454,
-0.0019667074,
-0.0388245285,
0.0328129679,
0.0259923879,
0.021772109,
0.0241516028,
0.0173372924,
0.0157928821,
-0.0499096625,
-0.0037886612,
-0.0143845398,
-0.0220334549,
0.0040052594,
0.0257145911,
-0.0049603782,
-0.0015913644,
-0.0017761274,
-0.01404393,
0.0287762973,
0.0662664548,
2.647e-7,
0.0537149124,
0.0364345238,
-0.0127757834,
0.0036128995,
-0.0176762789,
0.0510322042,
-0.0032363236,
0.0379150249,
0.0193155017,
-0.0610614158,
0.0112235639,
-0.006616958,
0.0699024424,
0.0661242902,
-0.0599156208,
-0.0472606532,
-0.0622023456,
-0.053514827,
-0.0432201438,
0.0320047624,
0.0954465345,
0.09419889,
0.0554172657,
-0.0228672568,
-0.0104950238,
-0.0390449204,
0.0524431244,
0.0110233566,
-0.0166199915,
-0.0130175697,
0.07046251,
-0.0115129976,
0.0318124108,
0.0798090994,
-0.0010060061,
0.0165529456,
0.0147474343,
0.0467663035,
0.0028149488,
0.0191150047,
-0.0440066643,
-0.0280647278,
0.0144109335,
-0.0280407444,
0.1029714495,
-0.0345479213,
0.0086299367,
-0.0217819195,
-0.0189604927,
-0.0263005625,
0.0103811985,
0.018945815,
-0.0192147903,
-0.0183796287,
0.0295199715,
-0.0042510652,
-0.0108160824,
-0.0879953727,
-0.0125555256,
0.0217547603,
-0.0243495945,
-0.0048886146,
-0.0142869009,
0.0478534587,
0.0558605418,
-0.0971859097,
0.0036813612,
2.539826359e-34,
0.0401031375,
-0.0130482838,
0.00715166,
-0.0007712533,
0.0164239332,
0.0482888781,
-0.001247652,
0.0112559972,
-0.0132876579,
-0.0665880963,
0.0053837248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01766v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01766v2 | LLM Voting: Human Choices and AI Collective Decision Making | 2024-01-31T14:52:02 | 2024-05-15T14:50:37 | Joshua C. Yang, Damian Dailisan, Marcin Korecki, Carina I. Hausladen, Dirk Helbing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC, 68T05, 91B14, 91C20, I.2.7; J.4; K.4.1 | This paper investigates the voting behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, their biases, and how they align with human
voting patterns. Our methodology involved using a dataset from a human voting
experiment to establish a baseline for human preferences and a corresponding
experiment with LLM agents. We observed that the methods used for voting input
and the presentation of choices influence LLM voting behavior. We discovered
that varying the persona can reduce some of these biases and enhance alignment
with human choices. While the Chain-of-Thought approach did not improve
prediction accuracy, it has potential for AI explainability in the voting
process. We also identified a trade-off between preference diversity and
alignment accuracy in LLMs, influenced by different temperature settings. Our
findings indicate that LLMs may lead to less diverse collective outcomes and
biased assumptions when used in voting scenarios, emphasizing the importance of
cautious integration of LLMs into democratic processes. | [
0.0338824317,
0.0580448769,
-0.0283286255,
0.0209925696,
-0.0324245691,
0.0130737647,
-0.0154235456,
-0.004723419,
0.0367869548,
0.002350539,
-0.0076722056,
-0.037269786,
0.0220350996,
0.0075287684,
0.0271763802,
-0.0781033784,
0.0019492415,
-0.0318967402,
0.0448404402,
-0.0437171943,
0.0168603677,
0.0246325899,
0.021741204,
0.03967949,
0.0129838148,
0.0193995684,
-0.0253362805,
-0.0256597474,
0.0366820134,
-0.0258688033,
-0.025703948,
0.019664634,
0.0119227152,
-0.0018627533,
0.0000022571,
-0.0335478373,
0.0209914632,
-0.0134429373,
-0.0180473123,
0.0090951249,
0.0444075167,
0.0754112154,
0.0017286728,
0.0255459826,
-0.0565192215,
0.0166977588,
0.0531129166,
-0.0027748791,
0.0256796312,
0.0267174952,
-0.0030308282,
-0.0169615038,
-0.0024844625,
-0.0186484139,
-0.0323075689,
-0.0245366916,
0.0035912371,
-0.0685247034,
0.0084889578,
0.0118813636,
0.0134974765,
-0.0126144718,
-0.0026994888,
0.0032785565,
-0.0141363675,
0.0392492861,
-0.003168249,
-0.0312937982,
0.0185269602,
0.0720340163,
0.0430297181,
-0.0297989193,
-0.0178096592,
-0.0197387412,
0.0198877305,
0.0206928309,
-0.0286971908,
0.0172945857,
0.0107485726,
0.0514229983,
0.0231422447,
0.01990881,
0.0201863088,
0.0407414213,
-0.0402614735,
0.1430179328,
-0.0026141382,
0.0099529158,
-0.0218476411,
0.0249516815,
0.0080182226,
-0.078826867,
-0.0010009208,
0.0127639435,
-0.0593069233,
0.0331130922,
-0.0048384992,
0.0613503829,
0.0248296801,
-0.0629000962,
0.0466949344,
0.0410101861,
0.0238007791,
0.0348132364,
0.0561354533,
0.0556504987,
-0.0289670974,
0.0452795103,
-0.0323686376,
-0.0249939449,
-0.0109699862,
-0.0120216161,
0.0367335714,
0.0099474285,
0.0016833962,
0.0297138356,
-0.0355298705,
0.0244203173,
-0.0429587923,
0.0328217186,
0.0027985936,
0.0046880357,
0.0118242428,
-0.0318346433,
-0.1027650312,
0.0784737468,
-0.0758005381,
0.0545620546,
0.0248193294,
-0.0345173292,
0.0220371801,
0.0046689035,
-0.0043803407,
-0.0089719649,
0.0055298437,
0.0681384504,
0.011498969,
0.0085645039,
0.015790984,
0.0038666129,
0.0120018134,
-0.0911545902,
-0.0384306423,
-0.0624318011,
0.0354782231,
0.0227770079,
0.0241112709,
-0.0299574174,
-0.0046852822,
0.0160135701,
-0.0122946016,
0.0685139894,
-0.0075472174,
0.0503296591,
0.0346160755,
0.0097557884,
-0.0114606125,
0.0487555973,
0.0620319843,
0.0652460977,
0.0270499848,
-0.0385517925,
0.0467056744,
0.030706102,
-0.0367456041,
0.0349139944,
-0.0333757102,
0.0313280076,
-0.0416005701,
-0.0003077081,
0.0194300581,
0.0707542002,
-0.0067232852,
-0.0031374248,
0.1110709831,
0.0772354528,
-0.0514381565,
-0.0137241865,
-0.015642006,
0.0196606647,
-0.0002009906,
0.0239437465,
-0.0517015792,
0.0572393723,
-0.0149289845,
-0.016608147,
0.0218607448,
0.0352435447,
-0.0436334461,
-0.0315614864,
0.0002570009,
-0.0226557758,
0.0374822281,
0.036759194,
0.0141444877,
-0.0508358218,
-0.0151409348,
-0.002784587,
0.0437918827,
-0.0490284525,
-0.0287520643,
-0.0634168759,
0.0435365103,
0.0746136978,
0.01855601,
0.0071807322,
-0.0036796911,
-0.0222724583,
-0.0214673877,
0.0462169275,
0.0641791895,
-0.0248831194,
-0.0447103381,
-0.0482460074,
-0.0167974122,
0.0403785557,
-0.0058908719,
0.0832735375,
-0.018289661,
-0.0043741628,
-0.0394840501,
0.0016134676,
-0.0094743511,
0.0021098619,
-0.0095307911,
-0.0055758669,
-0.0402558707,
0.0140613103,
0.0801828578,
0.0047652936,
0.010462923,
-0.0023022478,
0.0171958432,
-0.0040248772,
-0.0351002999,
0.0122069186,
-0.038000986,
0.0624998882,
0.0192551836,
-0.0088256504,
-0.0058138995,
0.0250864681,
-0.0133491941,
-0.0280667469,
0.0543402061,
-0.0052382895,
-0.006998165,
-0.009360238,
0.0180629864,
-0.0499018691,
-0.0223242845,
-0.0578823499,
0.0652135685,
-0.0056476686,
-0.0210399404,
-0.011230127,
-0.0114319185,
0.0122353928,
-0.0267341398,
-0.0049933922,
0.0769562647,
0.0446977876,
0.025667157,
0.0544129275,
-0.036476966,
-0.0197946206,
-0.0473441109,
-0.0668716505,
-0.028059518,
-0.009236454,
0.0132678151,
0.011627702,
-0.020311391,
-0.0069880872,
0.0229328331,
-0.0526361465,
-0.0016035993,
-0.0200140458,
0.0051725684,
0.0340090878,
-0.0074177878,
-0.0282245874,
-0.0522729792,
0.0013449639,
-0.0200103335,
0.0162398629,
0.0086798724,
0.0008541842,
-0.0351946354,
0.0142049864,
-0.0531792119,
-0.0315411128,
-0.0449982509,
-0.0369096547,
0.0409253836,
0.0007444263,
0.0259076748,
0.0326827504,
0.0216847584,
0.0446448252,
0.086059548,
0.0304049198,
-0.0941004679,
-0.0221514404,
-0.0299175028,
0.0148449577,
-0.0495552048,
-0.0411840901,
-0.004147477,
0.053447824,
0.0142037794,
0.016232172,
-0.0321289338,
0.0687349215,
-0.0250277724,
-0.0361233912,
-0.0026340911,
-0.0566957444,
-0.0320636109,
0.0794408992,
0.0089783482,
-0.071870327,
0.0725845844,
-0.0123041347,
0.0307193287,
-0.0321834609,
-0.0017716076,
-0.0338806175,
0.0521388911,
0.0051056929,
0.0046338332,
-0.0266278964,
0.0039443383,
-0.0724741817,
-0.064569518,
0.0388831198,
-0.0560719445,
0.0787858441,
-0.0455637127,
0.0040122052,
-0.00421526,
-0.0433538444,
-0.015038888,
-0.0315375999,
-0.0504484959,
0.0112052811,
0.0550560243,
-0.0458385684,
-0.0100001972,
-0.0098636951,
0.0466987118,
-0.0347875319,
0.0031762638,
0.0141340438,
0.0057073305,
-0.0243492797,
0.0337438658,
0.0413116552,
0.024853576,
-0.0324457176,
0.0028853863,
0.016376812,
0.0564925559,
-0.0054375106,
-0.0397397242,
-0.0399083719,
0.0446174331,
-0.0095505435,
-0.0262243636,
0.0153670274,
0.0414203294,
-0.0245859027,
0.0673954934,
0.0700866878,
0.024376234,
-0.0799125284,
0.0028632041,
-0.0128981639,
0.0550817661,
0.0337717906,
0.0101820622,
-0.0458021201,
0.013683795,
0.019268306,
0.0150497491,
-0.0372299701,
-0.0109332427,
-0.003127208,
-0.1031645909,
0.0226848628,
0.0038587393,
-0.0028944986,
0.0041559143,
-0.0641465783,
0.0255002398,
-0.0244413782,
0.0148276137,
-0.0044490397,
0.0363049135,
0.0093024364,
0.0142121501,
-0.0478972681,
-0.0258091744,
0.0165377129,
-0.0375796594,
0.0848386288,
0.0996720493,
0.0849162415,
-0.0349972732,
-0.034158539,
0.0031995226,
-0.0138665214,
-0.0149543704,
0.0117519125,
0.0167192835,
0.0035418826,
0.0061537772,
-0.0485368334,
0.0129895099,
0.0189907122,
0.0223127417,
0.0215838328,
0.055458881,
-0.0332299732,
-0.0358494036,
0.0138753289,
-0.0261525866,
0.0163330119,
0.0523754619,
0.0260580312,
-0.0513149947,
-0.0258947983,
-0.0567798913,
-0.0087576667,
0.0006488838,
-0.0530300811,
-0.0353089906,
-0.0006242541,
0.0079283435,
-0.0310168955,
-0.0553055592,
-0.0052197007,
0.0154929487,
0.0252447631,
0.0405161232,
0.0465466082,
-0.0066866102,
0.0374936759,
0.0099311993,
-0.0104376329,
0.0354793034,
-0.0230485536,
-0.0615545884,
0.0072600842,
-0.0209913086,
0.0097565856,
-0.0059140553,
0.0083442964,
-0.065522857,
0.0161948726,
0.033798296,
0.0354000367,
0.0138974981,
0.0159763582,
-0.0822241753,
0.0406342596,
0.0043402342,
0.004808499,
0.0195961986,
-0.0026689549,
0.0481311381,
0.0020452673,
0.0463492051,
0.0077952403,
0.0227916036,
0.0308910888,
-0.0213534385,
-0.0574519858,
-0.0384883173,
0.0304234941,
0.0181891322,
-0.018932255,
-0.0433243848,
-0.0009696186,
-0.0176475048,
-0.0134432791,
-0.0308017489,
-0.0132310353,
-0.0143165635,
-0.0451364666,
0.0508876517,
-0.0138820801,
0.0014222318,
-0.0184502788,
-0.0246588793,
0.0146272508,
0.012965031,
0.0707301721,
-0.0028628609,
0.0752492696,
0.029612964,
0.022287719,
-0.0039783791,
0.0161125828,
-0.0203581043,
0.0399231017,
0.0200658217,
0.039104037,
0.0022110757,
-0.0393983833,
0.0090608299,
0.0307645835,
-0.0450341031,
-0.0722265169,
0.0255998839,
0.0106611,
-0.014220532,
-0.0054168175,
0.0522100404,
-0.0203056671,
0.0171490181,
-0.0215346944,
0.0041031619,
-0.0061644707,
-0.0024597531,
0.0018168857,
0.0163449179,
-0.0594195426,
-0.0029252956,
0.0679218173,
-0.0206520353,
0.0159739256,
-0.0256102066,
0.0032266157,
-0.0125336768,
-0.0342167392,
-0.0189890806,
-0.0068451036,
-0.0443014614,
-0.0583269075,
-0.0738568977,
-0.0138425874,
-0.022365896,
-0.0067871669,
-0.0092696529,
-0.0218098518,
0.0087347412,
0.0362154283,
-0.0249646958,
0.0415220372,
-0.0457746387,
-0.0256999247,
-0.0604390278,
0.0184506141,
-0.0103131607,
-6.794908361e-33,
-0.0411995314,
-0.0352743864,
0.0252496004,
-0.0278987549,
0.0005728717,
-0.0246676318,
-0.037591137,
0.0399322957,
-0.030882759,
0.0184017662,
-0.0130260782,
-0.0055167233,
0.0157954618,
-0.0246580094,
0.0207179226,
-0.0287266001,
0.0260651466,
0.0033669225,
-0.041315347,
0.0180396009,
0.0332186222,
-0.0356600657,
0.0125092138,
-0.0807809755,
0.0292277001,
0.0323600881,
-0.0385447331,
-0.0311784949,
-0.0328809507,
0.0251252167,
-0.0229549557,
0.0133030787,
0.0195499156,
-0.0347840674,
-0.0214523245,
0.0540863089,
0.0145518556,
-0.0164583679,
0.0078335945,
-0.0095207291,
0.0328560993,
-0.0363067873,
-0.0153969256,
-0.0104028499,
-0.0531726554,
0.0283150338,
0.0268331841,
-0.0209291149,
0.0088290414,
0.0433498286,
-0.0269311499,
0.0067445249,
-0.009338025,
0.0243887622,
-0.0246640593,
0.0306642931,
-0.0093697477,
0.0503105037,
-0.0703545883,
0.0575306565,
-0.0040931213,
-0.0270209145,
0.0500043407,
-0.0089689456,
0.021902388,
0.0713812411,
0.0714727268,
0.0270104948,
-0.0960672945,
-0.0520640127,
0.0062358486,
0.0528592803,
0.0805349648,
0.0644605011,
-0.0078998348,
-0.0357853845,
-0.0237480029,
0.0205580443,
0.0313256755,
0.0042400006,
0.0493400507,
0.0109626176,
-0.0685197115,
-0.0449974388,
-0.0213274788,
-0.0497543029,
-0.031914901,
-0.0297332853,
-0.0005529813,
-0.0125365499,
-0.0117655834,
-0.0299708117,
0.0359972045,
-0.0636615232,
-0.0233896859,
0.0120996656,
-0.0368095599,
0.0214194562,
0.0232663676,
-0.0173323005,
-0.0483501889,
-0.0005699529,
-0.0364892446,
0.0238446482,
0.0144993169,
0.028431965,
-0.0290074907,
0.0201149825,
-0.0440514944,
-0.0270959735,
-0.0329169631,
-0.0312475283,
0.0276399478,
-0.0277215298,
0.053629607,
-0.0162184741,
0.0244430229,
0.0041246745,
-0.0054515321,
0.0146993836,
-0.0099617438,
0.0000069886,
-0.0879966021,
0.0049334588,
-0.0256168544,
-0.0250221733,
-0.0483806953,
0.0130233364,
0.0527201444,
0.0045888503,
-0.0195966922,
-0.0319012068,
2.89e-7,
0.0147746317,
0.09670531,
-0.0457067266,
-0.0164308418,
-0.0087040626,
0.0824392512,
-0.0278042518,
0.0122665968,
-0.0206661988,
-0.0327700116,
0.0179495588,
-0.0002061951,
0.0529732779,
0.0551140569,
-0.0832529515,
-0.0044136145,
-0.0242885463,
0.004784001,
-0.0394968055,
0.0156168975,
0.0298956167,
0.0603266321,
0.0672516599,
-0.0095252544,
-0.0199294351,
0.0078330031,
0.0311486609,
-0.0848099366,
-0.0246279016,
0.033256717,
0.0254896544,
-0.0539678521,
-0.0165138114,
0.0246051289,
0.016893262,
0.0021808697,
-0.0298308711,
0.0337648019,
-0.0190721918,
-0.0480695032,
-0.026286792,
-0.0201507304,
0.003750134,
-0.0707231462,
0.0530432053,
-0.014020578,
-0.0774817392,
-0.0461782441,
-0.0127930073,
-0.0185388196,
0.0339663327,
0.0000338731,
0.0184392352,
0.0004567114,
-0.0093403012,
-0.0115949512,
-0.0073373811,
-0.0474863611,
-0.0108988089,
-0.0400295556,
-0.0405898094,
-0.0836341083,
-0.0357205868,
0.0416398384,
0.0343443602,
-0.0271935035,
0.017141426,
2.336534254e-34,
0.0162439588,
0.0069699017,
-0.0036473186,
0.0140340067,
0.0426717661,
0.0306463763,
0.0051921234,
0.0182205439,
0.0437642969,
-0.0781897977,
-0.0044455314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17882v2 | I Think, Therefore I am: Benchmarking Awareness of Large Language Models Using AwareBench | 2024-01-31T14:41:23 | 2024-02-16T09:47:38 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Yuli Lin, Siyuan Wu, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do large language models (LLMs) exhibit any forms of awareness similar to
humans? In this paper, we introduce AwareBench, a benchmark designed to
evaluate awareness in LLMs. Drawing from theories in psychology and philosophy,
we define awareness in LLMs as the ability to understand themselves as AI
models and to exhibit social intelligence. Subsequently, we categorize
awareness in LLMs into five dimensions, including capability, mission, emotion,
culture, and perspective. Based on this taxonomy, we create a dataset called
AwareEval, which contains binary, multiple-choice, and open-ended questions to
assess LLMs' understandings of specific awareness dimensions. Our experiments,
conducted on 13 LLMs, reveal that the majority of them struggle to fully
recognize their capabilities and missions while demonstrating decent social
intelligence. We conclude by connecting awareness of LLMs with AI alignment and
safety, emphasizing its significance to the trustworthy and ethical development
of LLMs. Our dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/HowieHwong/Awareness-in-LLM. | [
0.0206247289,
0.0562581904,
-0.0379887484,
0.0386616215,
-0.0258104596,
0.0150658013,
0.0055550528,
-0.0139345666,
0.0462639667,
-0.0230166186,
-0.0278767738,
-0.0113095297,
-0.053601604,
0.0445766971,
0.0524634272,
0.0147511568,
0.0647756681,
-0.0344389789,
0.0389655381,
-0.0059278836,
-0.0008224339,
0.0204899646,
-0.0037637565,
0.0261476096,
-0.0057236236,
-0.0345333777,
-0.03229535,
-0.01436383,
0.0398936495,
-0.0175839067,
-0.0253954045,
0.0406420492,
0.0210645199,
0.0624809265,
0.0000020612,
-0.0859665051,
0.0115283057,
-0.011484568,
-0.0518476143,
-0.0062690675,
0.040475253,
0.0174951144,
-0.0060895002,
0.0108525185,
-0.0806831568,
0.0151032722,
0.0128646279,
0.0015408809,
0.0073665786,
0.0385060571,
-0.0025704291,
0.0386529081,
0.0269824807,
-0.0165433791,
-0.040232677,
-0.054578308,
0.0309775472,
0.0134493066,
-0.0332208797,
-0.0136051085,
-0.0316041969,
0.0556803048,
0.0104771126,
-0.0364779234,
-0.000938931,
0.0035639696,
-0.0111645898,
-0.0299677104,
-0.0035817325,
0.0242501069,
0.0617156178,
-0.0159173105,
0.0016734021,
-0.0014596158,
0.0328500606,
0.0194090493,
-0.0297079273,
0.0236393623,
-0.0081391511,
0.0046291682,
0.0338608436,
0.0110601084,
0.0453075245,
0.0146476869,
0.0041823518,
0.0836324319,
-0.0298129581,
-0.0263405908,
0.0256857779,
-0.005426283,
-0.0117336819,
-0.0807918459,
-0.0197505187,
0.0443693884,
-0.0307914279,
0.031790901,
-0.0009079489,
-0.0345664099,
0.0210982561,
-0.0627940372,
0.0635105148,
0.0395951644,
0.001567802,
0.0359734371,
0.0591815449,
0.0859340876,
0.0018495034,
0.0413504764,
-0.0232573021,
0.0119221108,
-0.0170311574,
-0.017221896,
-0.007061475,
0.0072199591,
0.0080730375,
0.0323282182,
-0.0309831016,
0.0430620126,
-0.0414248109,
0.0421630032,
-0.0610095412,
-0.0107121542,
0.0109202284,
-0.0077632009,
-0.0249462649,
0.0267571919,
-0.0297104344,
-0.0187889952,
0.006820593,
-0.0991538763,
0.0419449843,
0.0059138127,
-0.0303179715,
-0.0085187536,
0.0034877541,
0.0810929686,
0.0155651104,
-0.043595884,
0.0015769533,
-0.0119093955,
0.0170089826,
-0.0456094109,
0.0117602218,
-0.0542330518,
0.0098415585,
0.0206452422,
-0.0130024171,
-0.0546101592,
-0.0098362966,
-0.0002052138,
0.005751031,
0.0209575612,
-0.0194909722,
0.0376397185,
0.0246591698,
0.0142226033,
0.0036732201,
0.0971748307,
-0.0078657633,
-0.0069819409,
0.0408162884,
-0.0043829186,
-0.0005891633,
0.0343909971,
-0.0153053291,
0.0067324527,
-0.0254033357,
0.0172325894,
-0.0234980509,
0.0353180952,
0.0232978854,
0.0635027662,
0.0223505311,
-0.0157839451,
0.0633719191,
0.0622966997,
-0.0288235508,
0.0335386544,
0.0327780992,
0.0088873934,
0.045710247,
0.0239995494,
-0.0628155619,
0.0173840225,
-0.018149443,
-0.0180115383,
-0.0285086967,
0.0099240579,
-0.0219847355,
-0.040553391,
-0.0355982371,
0.0118849641,
0.0097108204,
0.06038405,
0.0188138243,
-0.0397891663,
0.0245714653,
-0.012411519,
0.0129830204,
-0.0464930832,
-0.0021457265,
-0.0691687539,
0.0239905249,
0.0545391738,
0.024899438,
-0.0578005947,
-0.0484726839,
-0.0141081419,
0.0065834434,
0.0644398406,
0.1094617024,
-0.0388752446,
-0.0066990955,
-0.0070907203,
-0.0086290259,
-0.0315323062,
0.0101046879,
0.0133397486,
-0.0169266611,
0.0132278418,
-0.0077235815,
-0.0555277467,
-0.0731418654,
0.0406831242,
-0.0848911926,
0.0223350376,
-0.0606732778,
-0.004621062,
0.0304606929,
0.0456377491,
-0.0150954286,
-0.013276468,
0.036656227,
-0.0120788403,
0.0014895427,
0.0551645048,
-0.008821357,
0.048419442,
0.0551323295,
-0.0359383002,
-0.0242909547,
0.0597143471,
0.0167322587,
-0.028701596,
0.0441424176,
-0.0252173953,
0.0546240136,
-0.0326641537,
0.0329802595,
-0.0820204392,
0.0022460017,
-0.0213570707,
0.0393942669,
-0.0193085242,
0.0071616578,
0.0099554816,
-0.0375960805,
0.0278414208,
-0.0067791021,
-0.0511360243,
0.0159567911,
0.001043373,
0.0006246463,
0.0145701971,
0.0213933773,
-0.0747366548,
0.0005726693,
-0.1142297387,
-0.026426781,
-0.0174521562,
0.0192741994,
0.0180031508,
-0.0144863483,
-0.027115969,
0.0198674519,
-0.0249258354,
0.0180727039,
0.0158629287,
0.0159950256,
0.0275578797,
0.0047120033,
-0.0103682261,
-0.0363711715,
0.0069837337,
-0.0376670584,
-0.012629495,
0.0277344044,
-0.0264238287,
-0.0418741591,
0.0500463806,
-0.0495763905,
0.0096019534,
-0.0284591671,
-0.0395971462,
0.0268665608,
0.0155598912,
0.0016873496,
0.0612717792,
0.0093781995,
0.0464677848,
0.0728305131,
0.0287016928,
-0.0535372421,
0.01207936,
0.0422259606,
-0.0059167743,
-0.0650335252,
-0.0397446416,
0.0170297585,
0.0464457087,
0.000854769,
-0.0045805294,
0.0021934025,
0.0132060004,
-0.0506820567,
-0.1040244326,
-0.043650534,
-0.0123985494,
-0.0187131055,
0.0516930372,
-0.0055725728,
-0.047459241,
0.0653099716,
0.0027591155,
-0.01728734,
0.0013578319,
-0.0305371583,
-0.006278621,
0.0860221162,
-0.0122699412,
0.0361952297,
-0.0266714301,
-0.0280946773,
-0.0647542328,
-0.0008985254,
-0.0165174082,
-0.0303536262,
0.0449984148,
-0.0470448993,
-0.0104822647,
0.011058188,
-0.0107406387,
-0.0690117553,
-0.018723039,
-0.0753942952,
0.0193965361,
0.0088917557,
-0.0574867651,
0.0036527864,
-0.0254496615,
0.0506369136,
0.004089254,
0.0108646173,
-0.0024358735,
-0.0167905334,
-0.0593438298,
0.0487597957,
0.0294399448,
0.079189308,
-0.0584407225,
0.0526033863,
0.0389359854,
0.0254138522,
-0.0045733526,
-0.0090571726,
-0.0246203188,
0.035061039,
0.0018744888,
0.0086693838,
0.0312798023,
0.0749703646,
-0.0330979228,
-0.0316608697,
0.1259816587,
0.0124578141,
-0.0458702371,
0.0155385789,
-0.0587334409,
-0.0167693663,
0.0495423563,
0.0371513776,
-0.0543336049,
0.0005107797,
0.0039205644,
0.0048894724,
-0.0403644219,
-0.0734311789,
-0.0064839879,
-0.0673627704,
0.0125227049,
-0.023019921,
-0.0540540703,
0.0013592502,
0.0109924739,
0.0396319702,
0.0201331601,
0.0160490647,
0.018080255,
-0.0055277869,
-0.0385685489,
0.0036138205,
-0.0292154737,
-0.0536351725,
0.0308413357,
-0.0772350654,
0.089519836,
0.0712003931,
0.0315464921,
-0.0476944186,
-0.0398818813,
0.0276741888,
0.0118038841,
0.0247712582,
0.0136643527,
0.0113207605,
-0.0415357612,
-0.0094844513,
-0.013514623,
0.0020232308,
-0.0326976925,
0.0320355892,
0.018148426,
0.0920177624,
-0.0379986763,
-0.0419277586,
-0.0119819744,
-0.0131916013,
-0.0213940497,
0.0816270113,
0.0511502139,
-0.027710462,
0.0220194589,
-0.0274346266,
0.0093949791,
0.0015536477,
-0.003981187,
0.0440598316,
0.0143912295,
-0.0529010855,
-0.051496271,
-0.0505015105,
0.0254135393,
0.0092441235,
0.0470256545,
0.0052420986,
0.0387912504,
-0.0112878019,
-0.0514400974,
-0.0084817195,
-0.0190191399,
0.0309884902,
-0.0242946111,
-0.0057814042,
-0.0266591553,
-0.015807515,
-0.0023878624,
0.0215274543,
-0.0379530229,
-0.0765219107,
0.0620248877,
0.0232589915,
0.0290377345,
-0.0079472438,
-0.0231391862,
-0.0589184836,
-0.0111757861,
-0.0052406397,
-0.0145885162,
0.0698231533,
0.0084431116,
-0.0179799572,
-0.0028489614,
0.0651573837,
-0.0210761111,
-0.0024423643,
-0.0030762134,
0.0082587935,
-0.0203214437,
-0.0459739119,
0.0045186952,
0.0469068103,
0.0013599049,
-0.0387847312,
-0.0038250147,
-0.0334856436,
-0.038328819,
-0.0383531302,
-0.0224149879,
-0.0199398715,
-0.0186471306,
0.0166999958,
0.0094281808,
0.039552331,
0.0172658749,
-0.0357102863,
0.0099519193,
-0.0006964202,
0.0349845327,
-0.0339078233,
0.0423239917,
0.0053480226,
0.0264793467,
0.0052774311,
0.0281320512,
-0.0064250962,
0.0240372568,
0.0416471362,
0.0601771958,
0.0167747997,
-0.0075516528,
0.0192146897,
0.0218502712,
-0.0366259627,
-0.089428857,
0.0485235564,
0.0676591322,
0.0769769996,
0.0082759857,
0.054279387,
-0.0383460447,
0.0213367864,
0.005396035,
-0.0074286885,
-0.0039729928,
-0.0571494997,
0.0304307062,
0.0272841714,
-0.0126479194,
0.0145073468,
0.0488798618,
-0.0323052332,
0.0388426334,
-0.015633462,
-0.0048708441,
-0.0173942558,
-0.0002602538,
0.0278886519,
0.0296747889,
-0.0463337824,
0.0295081604,
-0.0848948732,
-0.0810720026,
-0.0065094563,
0.0404803492,
-0.0040942868,
-0.0658514276,
0.0080004632,
0.0650831163,
0.0059476374,
-0.0150598343,
-0.0423109978,
-0.0098050954,
-0.0467088819,
-0.0096840346,
-0.0083466023,
-6.056719949e-33,
-0.0214646198,
-0.0267239232,
0.0075609325,
-0.0196009222,
-0.0451455973,
-0.0111915208,
-0.0494739525,
0.0374648087,
-0.069624342,
0.0298940614,
-0.0373542495,
0.0589245297,
-0.0027183322,
-0.0241439026,
0.0450366102,
-0.0251636617,
-0.0067936741,
-0.0242340211,
-0.0047745691,
0.0052286079,
0.0242967289,
0.0103066443,
0.0667637512,
-0.0920216069,
0.0563659109,
-0.0092818644,
0.0126932142,
0.0442495309,
-0.0135708777,
0.0102982214,
-0.0179284997,
0.0618610829,
0.0391614512,
0.0024120668,
-0.0068757576,
-0.0096619986,
0.0096210726,
-0.0158009585,
0.0629980713,
-0.0004745178,
-0.0281612538,
-0.0369693786,
0.0266635772,
-0.0128790494,
-0.0599510744,
0.0365869179,
0.0105633494,
-0.0244961455,
0.0399980731,
0.0157454628,
-0.0265341513,
-0.0024885621,
-0.034336742,
0.0153000001,
-0.0057153865,
0.0127095189,
-0.0053797434,
-0.0314962976,
-0.017668575,
0.0237114206,
-0.0019591015,
0.0013547732,
0.1207270697,
-0.0014110742,
0.0160105415,
0.0777336955,
0.0293540787,
0.0612269677,
0.0351613648,
-0.0095489463,
0.0497046746,
0.0387132913,
0.0367502645,
0.0443841517,
-0.0452239215,
-0.0173388496,
0.0024660195,
0.0047910898,
0.0403245687,
0.0149147892,
0.034824755,
-0.0193829983,
-0.08488819,
-0.0194485243,
-0.0158268027,
-0.0097945426,
-0.0141526312,
-0.0163399391,
0.0177159831,
-0.0493471809,
0.0066054622,
-0.0391281657,
0.0117567154,
-0.0457612798,
0.0394693911,
0.0003231858,
-0.0311008114,
0.0375618562,
0.0193646383,
0.0434139408,
-0.045463331,
-0.0156054525,
-0.0390633419,
0.038154345,
0.0297542773,
0.0106854569,
-0.0027606604,
0.0033254684,
-0.007528686,
0.0055697393,
-0.0367163122,
0.0205402989,
0.0150700705,
-0.0255020801,
0.0228263251,
-0.0295594987,
-0.007124207,
-0.002250375,
0.022689756,
-0.0286056362,
-0.0480846576,
0.0224797707,
-0.0441181473,
-0.0057608662,
-0.050782185,
-0.0406295806,
-0.0462730899,
0.0472964123,
0.0688220412,
-0.040418338,
-0.0044454415,
0.0085060745,
2.82e-7,
0.0326610729,
0.0380667336,
-0.0070346659,
0.0043126615,
0.0189176239,
0.0437895991,
-0.0543550886,
0.0555551909,
0.0052281409,
-0.020062888,
-0.0155946221,
0.0304544698,
0.055890277,
0.0162112936,
-0.0729622468,
-0.0587865636,
-0.0458098985,
-0.0053864885,
-0.0500756279,
0.0238181874,
-0.0077342237,
0.0142997764,
0.0116059761,
-0.0203449614,
-0.0206447411,
-0.0553415976,
-0.0031422889,
-0.0363265872,
0.0125134569,
0.0086548049,
0.0310861561,
0.0260560457,
0.0133516425,
0.0265235864,
0.0113670751,
-0.0085789906,
-0.0151185952,
0.0615339838,
0.0180011541,
0.0439533591,
-0.0142173162,
-0.0006949179,
-0.0084052086,
-0.0604228266,
0.035289783,
-0.0327031352,
-0.0518962219,
-0.038285248,
0.0227041803,
-0.0515001342,
-0.0164949223,
0.0021500029,
-0.0119782267,
0.0388662294,
0.0022582584,
-0.0658439994,
-0.0002499031,
-0.0130297784,
-0.0003020825,
-0.035606537,
-0.0179925095,
-0.0810526088,
-0.0322752222,
-0.0017463266,
-0.0103114517,
-0.0549329519,
0.0221563727,
2.318757198e-34,
0.0241126902,
0.0249051005,
0.0111176269,
0.0177521333,
0.0436819568,
0.0064619975,
-0.078938581,
0.0132375387,
0.0079883114,
-0.0760220662,
0.0067344117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17858v1 | Probing Language Models' Gesture Understanding for Enhanced Human-AI Interaction | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | Philipp Wicke | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has affected various disciplines
that got beyond mere text generation. Going beyond their textual nature, this
project proposal aims to investigate the interaction between LLMs and
non-verbal communication, specifically focusing on gestures. The proposal sets
out a plan to examine the proficiency of LLMs in deciphering both explicit and
implicit non-verbal cues within textual prompts and their ability to associate
these gestures with various contextual factors. The research proposes to test
established psycholinguistic study designs to construct a comprehensive dataset
that pairs textual prompts with detailed gesture descriptions, encompassing
diverse regional variations, and semantic labels. To assess LLMs' comprehension
of gestures, experiments are planned, evaluating their ability to simulate
human behaviour in order to replicate psycholinguistic experiments. These
experiments consider cultural dimensions and measure the agreement between
LLM-identified gestures and the dataset, shedding light on the models'
contextual interpretation of non-verbal cues (e.g. gestures). | [
0.0376331136,
0.020611994,
-0.0545579977,
0.0409141555,
-0.0433042347,
0.0408586599,
0.0502675027,
0.0363475308,
0.0336205214,
-0.0594924167,
-0.0587812625,
-0.057591334,
0.0517855249,
0.0212718267,
0.0358902477,
-0.0402017497,
0.032041762,
-0.0760639459,
-0.0111397039,
0.0354642048,
0.016793713,
0.0233728606,
-0.0270952024,
0.0581726246,
-0.0418963097,
-0.0104677835,
-0.0501541197,
-0.01230828,
-0.0015786459,
-0.028839564,
-0.0540009476,
0.0368795395,
0.0362207703,
0.0234828163,
0.0000020752,
-0.0329158306,
0.0718280524,
-0.027311936,
-0.0191819649,
0.0418484956,
0.0684334114,
-0.0133011369,
-0.0049978131,
-0.0179350637,
-0.0324381739,
0.0003385502,
0.0271501746,
0.0626238883,
0.0170479026,
0.011681458,
-0.0015233884,
0.032053709,
-0.0063925521,
-0.0063525294,
-0.0039234599,
0.0104775922,
0.0391473137,
-0.0066255573,
0.0339652337,
0.0074201729,
-0.0077728159,
0.0293494519,
0.0017534374,
-0.030899791,
-0.0503811389,
0.0490619056,
-0.0252722353,
-0.0473240055,
-0.007430566,
0.0266730748,
0.0612822436,
-0.0162926447,
0.0218853783,
-0.018888535,
0.0010161212,
0.0351293832,
-0.0354790501,
0.0468306132,
0.0056305625,
-0.0045101456,
0.0300448369,
-0.016135633,
0.0122223552,
0.0115580261,
0.033437442,
0.0595677048,
-0.0074062566,
-0.0084863082,
-0.0175936762,
-0.02443159,
0.0225812048,
-0.0869737491,
0.0271991957,
0.0226834547,
-0.0340606533,
0.0247476473,
-0.0316607617,
0.0110581657,
0.0211903919,
-0.0262170807,
0.0432879142,
0.0517153218,
-0.0130394036,
0.0283305291,
0.0370795801,
0.0579251759,
-0.0076035629,
-0.0136306724,
-0.0322726406,
0.0159118176,
-0.0025433106,
-0.0433634222,
0.0032267692,
-0.0211755913,
-0.0180782881,
-0.020833211,
-0.0078714937,
0.033383362,
0.0009889636,
0.0113163032,
-0.0181527473,
-0.0079377582,
-0.0012759661,
0.0117490077,
-0.0139462473,
0.0092548179,
-0.0279036574,
0.054203622,
-0.0061977776,
-0.0803972632,
0.0125753405,
0.0218062308,
-0.0180925746,
-0.0173305441,
-0.0297257081,
0.0538438186,
-0.0099237915,
-0.0287380964,
-0.0186073277,
-0.0108281849,
-0.0107629951,
-0.0314860269,
-0.0318564177,
-0.0362787433,
0.0182911344,
0.0031984278,
-0.021132173,
-0.0101897083,
0.0121694272,
0.0131105185,
-0.0098941866,
0.0225018933,
0.0026388459,
0.0546001829,
0.0645059124,
0.004868296,
-0.0057515353,
0.0503002852,
0.0353474841,
0.0268402882,
0.021418089,
-0.0031241835,
0.0213256124,
0.0720633641,
-0.0597315319,
0.0093811341,
-0.0357796699,
-0.0203148648,
0.0117059331,
0.0142703215,
0.0492518619,
0.0414369777,
-0.0396664813,
0.0011221743,
0.0564434156,
0.1294284314,
-0.0428237692,
0.0022005343,
0.042841211,
-0.0164110996,
0.033140976,
-0.0225126073,
-0.0416540094,
-0.01447153,
-0.0159290731,
-0.0221705493,
-0.0370602012,
0.0183762368,
-0.0314034633,
-0.0168674123,
-0.0257702898,
-0.0281970017,
0.0116040381,
0.0309208557,
0.0673330352,
-0.033038713,
0.0320318341,
-0.0652031675,
0.0119678574,
-0.0265709311,
0.0043408633,
-0.0397509672,
0.0403320007,
0.0636880919,
0.0183888189,
-0.0033387626,
0.0051736073,
-0.0033691209,
0.0259210393,
0.0555185564,
0.0207618456,
-0.0123850796,
0.0233342685,
0.0172240529,
0.0170726776,
-0.0021910977,
0.0135870837,
0.0359811001,
-0.0435690694,
0.0324904062,
0.0107523091,
-0.0189163648,
-0.01015124,
0.0402267091,
-0.0740103126,
-0.0043031713,
-0.0131225912,
-0.0130623048,
0.004769525,
0.0550760701,
-0.0452036448,
-0.025438128,
0.014253458,
-0.0156613272,
0.0548817441,
0.0309365634,
-0.0208462663,
0.0260996763,
0.0064223241,
-0.0219458323,
-0.0294988714,
0.0039275778,
0.0254311226,
-0.0468074121,
0.0296310894,
-0.0057206661,
0.0257863887,
-0.0371684283,
0.0036677448,
-0.0051041315,
-0.0061932756,
-0.0090506664,
-0.0013557029,
-0.0030738146,
0.0094982805,
0.0293138158,
-0.0003736288,
0.026462758,
-0.0572460406,
-0.0330119804,
0.0462351032,
-0.0038717177,
-0.0090322513,
0.0324125253,
-0.0069904318,
-0.0482316613,
-0.0047681401,
-0.1157046705,
-0.0090299295,
-0.0087393513,
0.0133211296,
0.0296258479,
0.0054548346,
-0.0557321012,
-0.0051979334,
-0.0173271559,
-0.0329559296,
0.0228250008,
0.0162840914,
0.033095777,
-0.0399558172,
-0.0218463074,
-0.0402164869,
0.0111904787,
-0.0169719122,
0.024904944,
0.0315888748,
-0.0314620547,
-0.0494179651,
0.0006485774,
0.0030421631,
0.0105384318,
-0.032983169,
-0.030635424,
0.0469994247,
0.0042670206,
0.0087541444,
0.0752866343,
-0.0252187587,
0.0411032215,
0.0678483695,
-0.0416316688,
-0.0339261703,
-0.0377708897,
0.0342810526,
0.0400235802,
-0.0550538339,
-0.0799514502,
0.0220755693,
0.0862986296,
0.0232797861,
0.038241528,
-0.0115497839,
-0.0282929726,
-0.0263597798,
-0.0764223486,
-0.0286847185,
-0.0386779979,
-0.0533236749,
0.0591359772,
-0.0121964663,
-0.0564187765,
0.0376380794,
-0.0630716011,
-0.0357466675,
0.0496631041,
-0.0400795005,
-0.0290849805,
0.1051122546,
0.0068813134,
-0.0010211938,
0.0077091041,
-0.0356221013,
-0.0167843625,
0.0214256607,
-0.0189710781,
0.0010968525,
-0.0043640472,
-0.0807854384,
-0.0140896998,
-0.0116899619,
0.0370802619,
-0.0201523863,
0.0071375002,
-0.0445013046,
0.0108376797,
0.0065243859,
-0.0400176831,
0.0281502642,
0.023361301,
0.0542902239,
0.0375315957,
-0.0015541734,
0.0101547148,
-0.0360022187,
-0.0318445191,
0.0583665632,
0.006654344,
-0.0621180646,
-0.0176507588,
0.0393810272,
0.0239408333,
0.0156966895,
0.0096171023,
-0.0285706781,
0.0228232332,
0.045930706,
-0.0321305767,
-0.0629450008,
0.0463676192,
0.0447265133,
-0.0236703176,
0.0178681519,
0.1162251234,
0.0468283109,
-0.0513978004,
0.0387365036,
-0.0353872702,
-0.0030397919,
0.0062727113,
0.0164941531,
-0.0753319114,
-0.0011881592,
0.0157731548,
-0.0139962807,
-0.0267212,
-0.0410689823,
-0.0124912895,
-0.0915284008,
0.0352779552,
-0.0241058525,
-0.0537782349,
-0.0019860703,
-0.0441510864,
0.0677951798,
0.0181275085,
0.015861908,
-0.0107796881,
0.0001865095,
0.0008251657,
0.0231216475,
-0.0383359976,
-0.0367093906,
0.0368396491,
-0.0213428549,
0.0633763149,
0.0225479156,
0.032210499,
0.012615338,
-0.0181146674,
0.0254199002,
0.0098271742,
0.0514474399,
-0.0266158246,
-0.024639532,
0.0031091492,
0.0157698784,
-0.0117459241,
0.0355546325,
-0.0652577803,
-0.0455421209,
0.0454647802,
0.0720449388,
-0.0712474659,
0.0016406236,
-0.0052348296,
-0.0618516468,
0.0095613776,
0.0227832366,
0.0471190587,
-0.0725604668,
-0.0303008594,
-0.0168486144,
-0.0216567311,
0.0655006766,
-0.0372841805,
0.0107890936,
-0.0002586184,
-0.0772872642,
-0.0304726884,
-0.0954804495,
0.0451043993,
0.0066496213,
0.0311752316,
0.0376905426,
0.026260227,
-0.0151072526,
0.0177740585,
0.0404767022,
-0.007931252,
0.0766600147,
-0.0042734239,
-0.0241596587,
-0.0032276136,
-0.0550307967,
0.0007529391,
-0.0326551571,
-0.0390213132,
-0.071780473,
0.0198876038,
0.0244945288,
0.0220672395,
0.0255802888,
-0.003311936,
-0.0582374521,
-0.0222616475,
0.0177835748,
-0.0144047597,
0.0496501327,
-0.0349975377,
0.0086391224,
0.0126282489,
-0.0044509717,
0.0015124159,
0.02072048,
-0.0051998422,
-0.0021135374,
-0.0824862495,
-0.0682981536,
0.0154704871,
0.0262741689,
0.0310004279,
-0.0160922743,
-0.0041909232,
-0.0335697755,
-0.0314670913,
-0.0440481044,
-0.0000064713,
-0.0472232103,
-0.0350997895,
0.0004220531,
-0.0010681687,
0.0144093549,
-0.0378772207,
-0.0545676574,
0.002339937,
0.0045802984,
0.0661942437,
0.0205134917,
0.0743155777,
-0.0215967242,
0.0343114026,
0.0026846544,
0.0347964056,
-0.0536765456,
0.0212568305,
0.0125691397,
0.0761414021,
0.0164788831,
-0.0276104044,
0.0281044282,
0.0462986678,
-0.0348722711,
-0.0510167517,
0.0420678742,
0.0223223604,
0.0336879417,
-0.0341717936,
0.0521767512,
-0.072485283,
0.045587562,
-0.0122803496,
0.0477135591,
0.0109940041,
-0.0575208738,
0.032969363,
0.0157714933,
-0.0357099846,
0.0167602152,
0.044863224,
-0.042456951,
0.0049138796,
0.0263148937,
-0.0258516744,
-0.0226318017,
-0.0212468915,
0.0730457082,
-0.0229906291,
-0.0512620211,
0.0058988635,
-0.0503388271,
-0.0519792475,
-0.0165052917,
0.0212369785,
0.0209998172,
-0.0727495998,
0.0204627179,
0.0283434857,
-0.0028033757,
0.0076657473,
-0.0399409048,
-0.0207245965,
-0.0398785509,
-0.0300832335,
-0.0920041278,
-5.884633086e-33,
-0.0257854369,
-0.0706932098,
0.0200007595,
-0.0206836183,
-0.0507236458,
0.0052025388,
-0.0504495949,
0.0284938961,
0.0098819947,
-0.0195577256,
-0.0458452739,
0.0170163307,
0.0028036202,
-0.0225085579,
0.0365053043,
-0.006196849,
0.0200085007,
-0.0220577177,
-0.0078623826,
0.0163281914,
0.0083930204,
-0.0335224792,
0.0521103665,
-0.0741102472,
0.0651901141,
-0.0154214082,
-0.0231260844,
-0.0193203613,
0.0128681352,
0.0298275035,
-0.068611674,
0.0311327185,
0.0415691733,
0.0214362554,
0.0005915542,
0.0586643368,
0.0085627511,
-0.0343503132,
0.0383825898,
0.0710402876,
0.001062108,
-0.0140766064,
-0.0234229676,
-0.0031762687,
-0.0450295396,
0.0642180219,
0.0404407606,
-0.0215778612,
0.0064899679,
-0.0047799121,
-0.0049967268,
0.025720099,
-0.0420770347,
-0.0185685642,
0.0066194222,
0.0586630516,
-0.0443430766,
-0.0204538293,
-0.0361413322,
0.0371158086,
0.0476203486,
-0.0013305276,
0.0991954431,
0.0216009151,
0.0597751774,
0.0439428389,
0.0330546759,
0.0092620701,
-0.0216087177,
-0.0129112191,
0.0562450439,
0.0192605462,
-0.0459370539,
0.0614261925,
0.0192581676,
-0.0252319463,
0.0019162195,
0.0015971961,
0.0796278641,
0.0351048373,
0.0037346601,
-0.0021545873,
-0.0094434936,
-0.0147074563,
-0.0336022861,
-0.0227882564,
-0.0063844169,
-0.033079274,
0.0416449197,
-0.0318471044,
0.0650859028,
-0.023146823,
0.0427428074,
-0.02977507,
-0.0265033189,
-0.0270332135,
-0.0100672906,
0.0548133515,
0.0447289348,
-0.0052727633,
-0.0556597784,
-0.0318448581,
0.0083632339,
-0.0119068362,
0.0542231426,
0.0347311608,
-0.0441822149,
0.0231832825,
-0.025715081,
-0.0071126204,
-0.0030277038,
-0.0246879272,
-0.0002246955,
-0.028620502,
0.0497066639,
-0.025346471,
-0.040834967,
0.0238244925,
-0.0154782413,
-0.0270476807,
-0.0393436812,
0.0053625694,
-0.04161264,
0.0015717123,
-0.0539618693,
-0.0163374431,
-0.0311237723,
0.0174124353,
0.0751021355,
-0.0287435204,
-0.0045380332,
-0.0039559607,
2.797e-7,
0.002200532,
0.0456188731,
-0.0067503173,
0.069639951,
0.0394558907,
0.0279645324,
-0.0205689333,
0.0277472269,
0.0404565334,
0.0030348932,
0.0336462222,
-0.0028352074,
0.0341661386,
0.0019063203,
-0.0631156415,
0.0461005718,
-0.0300610103,
-0.0100659253,
-0.0741332769,
0.0564708151,
0.0242431145,
0.0298956595,
-0.0222150665,
0.0052453778,
-0.0209581219,
-0.0179685298,
0.0291845128,
-0.0999174565,
0.0248508621,
-0.0152755566,
0.0361319222,
-0.0467572138,
0.0085688774,
0.0383541659,
0.0133801633,
-0.0093101393,
-0.0124422824,
0.043660827,
-0.0606358945,
0.015420109,
0.0084609678,
-0.0114637809,
-0.0319820158,
-0.0625736266,
0.0712113231,
-0.028394904,
-0.0216633286,
-0.0090117808,
0.0069668116,
-0.0106438259,
-0.0105700381,
-0.0111277644,
0.0258223731,
0.0467597172,
0.0073779705,
-0.0459425934,
0.0031727322,
0.0183206201,
-0.0144475317,
-0.0150152827,
-0.0334176347,
-0.0487361923,
-0.0445524417,
0.0017252156,
-0.0126079004,
-0.0500374585,
-0.0121673336,
2.22338879e-34,
-0.0121640405,
0.0016503759,
0.0077313501,
0.0640709773,
0.0364813246,
0.0069379425,
0.0329341926,
0.0800134763,
0.0613646209,
-0.0602628589,
-0.0349752195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03366v1 | Uncertainty-Aware Explainable Recommendation with Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | Yicui Peng, Hao Chen, Chingsheng Lin, Guo Huang, Jinrong Hu, Hui Guo, Bin Kong, Shu Hu, Xi Wu, Xin Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Providing explanations within the recommendation system would boost user
satisfaction and foster trust, especially by elaborating on the reasons for
selecting recommended items tailored to the user. The predominant approach in
this domain revolves around generating text-based explanations, with a notable
emphasis on applying large language models (LLMs). However, refining LLMs for
explainable recommendations proves impractical due to time constraints and
computing resource limitations. As an alternative, the current approach
involves training the prompt rather than the LLM. In this study, we developed a
model that utilizes the ID vectors of user and item inputs as prompts for
GPT-2. We employed a joint training mechanism within a multi-task learning
framework to optimize both the recommendation task and explanation task. This
strategy enables a more effective exploration of users' interests, improving
recommendation effectiveness and user satisfaction. Through the experiments,
our method achieving 1.59 DIV, 0.57 USR and 0.41 FCR on the Yelp, TripAdvisor
and Amazon dataset respectively, demonstrates superior performance over four
SOTA methods in terms of explainability evaluation metric. In addition, we
identified that the proposed model is able to ensure stable textual quality on
the three public datasets. | [
0.0373932421,
0.0492773019,
0.003305593,
0.0326943733,
0.011756883,
0.0047752736,
0.0338434577,
0.0035885763,
0.0275222026,
-0.0210027266,
-0.007233277,
-0.0338949338,
-0.0241318345,
0.0469603315,
0.0099941473,
-0.0483365171,
-0.002630854,
-0.041021008,
0.0274428856,
0.0088108359,
0.0036831263,
0.0446642488,
0.0241929367,
0.0378978923,
0.0491586402,
-0.0182479862,
-0.0176632274,
-0.0017090989,
0.014215529,
-0.0279158689,
-0.0167972501,
0.0116163231,
0.0470892936,
-0.0363417044,
0.0000024295,
-0.0173539147,
-0.0297529679,
-0.0013059459,
-0.0532239787,
0.0039199241,
0.0068344697,
0.0726023018,
0.0323585682,
0.013803863,
0.0113597782,
0.0265512168,
0.0304651186,
0.1000415236,
0.0402036943,
0.0393096134,
-0.009736714,
-0.0359448828,
0.0043383017,
-0.0409299098,
0.0583711676,
-0.026283931,
0.0030187164,
-0.0270087309,
-0.0099042188,
0.0485587306,
0.0184909683,
-0.0373893455,
0.018301947,
-0.0483469479,
0.0445161574,
0.016304357,
0.0190218203,
-0.0151458047,
0.0076886308,
0.0633365586,
-0.0057358178,
-0.0111510381,
-0.0057437718,
-0.0034177813,
-0.0134206787,
0.0219126604,
-0.0486557595,
-0.0205962621,
-0.0138478661,
0.0480475053,
0.0017414177,
0.0016292733,
0.0737228394,
0.0167006832,
0.0108125322,
0.1071563438,
-0.0007019021,
-0.0108863218,
0.0017835681,
-0.0106357578,
-0.0623100922,
-0.040427804,
0.0131506687,
0.0176787283,
-0.0864450932,
0.0065030125,
0.0398354642,
0.036959216,
-0.0075979526,
-0.0001314907,
0.0477560274,
0.0262338687,
-0.0152692776,
0.0661507621,
0.0128038973,
0.0703517273,
0.0042752712,
-0.0109169222,
-0.0411438383,
-0.009892513,
-0.0456039086,
-0.0027957221,
0.0051806765,
0.0309270285,
-0.04381622,
-0.0137511007,
-0.0437905341,
0.0262663625,
-0.0110858064,
0.0254194289,
0.0375046879,
0.0172816869,
-0.0205108337,
-0.0186619777,
-0.0814442411,
-0.0071248608,
-0.0472881347,
0.0348137505,
0.015853079,
0.016729882,
0.0027088358,
0.0493157133,
0.0155022554,
-0.0447316729,
-0.008468329,
0.0205172021,
0.0028440326,
-0.021907663,
-0.0681149811,
-0.044974409,
-0.0150722452,
-0.077373676,
-0.0632592738,
-0.0225030761,
0.0065265517,
0.0139950681,
-0.0028107001,
-0.0474447608,
0.0124733513,
0.009153448,
-0.0467272624,
0.0814074874,
-0.0133142704,
0.005271263,
-0.013513431,
0.0225461256,
-0.0197221562,
-0.0056279181,
0.0107190572,
0.0768537298,
0.0632331222,
-0.0222895108,
0.0213118233,
-0.0481907167,
0.0094414344,
0.0208712313,
0.005135885,
0.0101541374,
-0.0422630683,
0.0224424861,
0.0280217733,
0.0534669198,
-0.0314247608,
0.032104861,
0.0811823383,
0.024858946,
0.0096248938,
0.0389530845,
0.058130499,
0.0436685197,
-0.0414520837,
0.0043905536,
-0.0371933356,
0.0546282232,
-0.0253776461,
-0.0044409498,
0.0530896895,
0.0017074017,
-0.0525004007,
-0.060055878,
0.0080711562,
-0.0432375781,
0.0340468809,
0.0328932405,
0.0376151241,
-0.0396583714,
-0.0711010322,
0.001005744,
0.0327816233,
-0.0373140126,
0.012946425,
-0.0443083048,
0.1225725785,
0.1278082132,
0.0256554056,
-0.0195652992,
0.0134141417,
-0.0519122817,
0.0247556493,
-0.0147508495,
0.0153717166,
-0.005632143,
0.0223761331,
-0.0674060956,
-0.0598721653,
-0.0022808036,
0.0098361727,
0.009626233,
-0.0136947986,
-0.0010609381,
0.0365793183,
-0.0490230173,
-0.0529294834,
-0.0091910632,
-0.0029678207,
-0.0375680327,
0.0231352095,
-0.0000710689,
0.0464256518,
0.028550256,
0.044885844,
-0.0135114193,
0.0133430464,
-0.0144822747,
-0.0288599227,
0.0062632612,
-0.0147578837,
0.0115035083,
0.0271453559,
0.0094148917,
0.016225256,
0.0308163073,
-0.0286154747,
-0.0585100539,
-0.0294920634,
-0.0128759928,
0.0074939923,
-0.0317137577,
0.0072091287,
0.0171121042,
0.0051743407,
-0.0405700542,
0.050108768,
0.0168993119,
0.0202463921,
-0.0120596169,
-0.0061971294,
0.0179498307,
-0.0391492508,
0.0036849803,
0.0166227613,
0.0201283954,
0.0003120487,
0.0238026958,
0.0061220154,
-0.025058629,
-0.0156684425,
-0.0586963631,
0.0075789397,
-0.0069436482,
0.0088277264,
-0.0152247949,
0.0103927776,
0.0194283798,
-0.0110684186,
-0.0580150485,
0.0040027597,
-0.0249962248,
-0.0015175242,
0.0345948339,
0.0145346085,
-0.0391612053,
-0.0382086486,
-0.0023774465,
-0.0223797597,
0.0422520228,
0.0043877438,
0.010591846,
-0.0884786472,
0.0008522893,
-0.012331198,
-0.0426554345,
-0.0203792229,
0.0034224696,
-0.0273506027,
0.0142092276,
0.0302746184,
0.0077997255,
0.0111337313,
0.0452211238,
0.0369438305,
0.0111607146,
-0.0450756736,
0.0104181487,
-0.0275821276,
-0.0234532952,
-0.0324969627,
-0.045515269,
-0.0203010719,
0.0274046771,
-0.0287868548,
-0.0130935758,
-0.0806561336,
0.0146726891,
-0.0049658939,
0.0384697802,
-0.0419554189,
-0.0455384329,
-0.0078440178,
0.0750606135,
-0.0119562391,
-0.0490845889,
0.0889483616,
-0.0321524031,
-0.012061242,
-0.0338423215,
-0.0311903805,
-0.0341624953,
0.0453074872,
-0.0139065767,
0.0343434401,
0.0091941943,
-0.0169673394,
-0.0122822048,
-0.0074590184,
0.0450153761,
-0.0225680489,
0.0368576236,
-0.0309638605,
-0.0154284118,
0.0231334269,
-0.0380770937,
-0.0200340953,
-0.0702965632,
0.0065664155,
0.003475833,
0.030217506,
-0.0228226781,
-0.0298043396,
0.0021679781,
-0.0117576504,
0.0221534781,
-0.0338558964,
-0.0346755348,
-0.006108562,
-0.0122393211,
0.0613277704,
0.0075491839,
0.0046687294,
-0.0313579105,
0.0316828266,
-0.0113552446,
0.0130234864,
-0.0567805246,
-0.0185515434,
0.0115985554,
0.0261418838,
-0.0339581445,
-0.0290969796,
0.0370556861,
0.0584588014,
-0.0105305109,
0.0177148543,
0.1197667569,
0.0254482403,
-0.0905597731,
0.0021546104,
0.00705089,
0.0076235877,
0.0130958976,
0.0260763131,
-0.0252073836,
-0.0297699459,
-0.0007835638,
0.0578957759,
0.0281900093,
-0.0051223338,
-0.0146621065,
-0.0758131891,
0.0472876392,
-0.0189438779,
0.0133497333,
-0.0435261652,
-0.0849637389,
-0.0233721193,
-0.0373565145,
0.0501478165,
0.0141370017,
0.0082239909,
0.0208434016,
0.0114512108,
-0.0065566264,
-0.0361797959,
0.0331159607,
-0.0404013619,
0.0424636565,
0.0520161428,
0.0441927053,
0.003194045,
-0.026098216,
-0.0160784125,
-0.0082201846,
-0.0142685669,
-0.0077288169,
0.0546531975,
0.0066462532,
0.0142967459,
-0.0388031229,
0.0755720511,
-0.0572024658,
-0.021420151,
-0.010467804,
0.0739217773,
-0.0104572624,
0.0072244336,
0.0160263628,
-0.0340414755,
0.0365145579,
0.1024100482,
0.0079605244,
-0.0436502099,
0.0000647644,
-0.0638071224,
-0.0370238088,
0.0097615505,
0.0055130669,
-0.0103369765,
0.0097493269,
0.002147234,
-0.030789027,
-0.0424102359,
-0.0157590322,
0.0266037937,
0.0024541912,
0.0593895651,
-0.022381397,
-0.0283674151,
-0.0107197315,
0.0329742767,
0.0187390093,
0.0382759199,
-0.0369628668,
0.0158377513,
0.0006087867,
-0.0674319565,
-0.0070289709,
0.0010757062,
-0.0269345418,
-0.0160248037,
-0.0717860088,
0.0373860039,
0.0267105699,
0.0494165085,
-0.0459853746,
-0.078262642,
-0.0256910864,
-0.0070733125,
-0.0457970276,
-0.0500092246,
0.0216980502,
0.0570453256,
0.0260755215,
0.0519381091,
-0.0381865613,
-0.0156355388,
-0.0137701081,
0.0080768717,
-0.0138675543,
-0.0139422594,
0.0367204063,
0.0322592221,
0.0643946752,
-0.0178740211,
0.0308547411,
-0.0536631159,
0.0194433667,
-0.023672726,
-0.0300501511,
-0.0498104654,
0.0438701101,
0.0619509742,
-0.0376297049,
-0.0265900586,
-0.0366276614,
-0.0128804902,
-0.0001660003,
-0.0483125336,
0.013068906,
-0.0451238938,
-0.0341275521,
0.0114492187,
0.0155368149,
-0.0069515333,
-0.0143035883,
0.0342631266,
0.0280025154,
0.0187443346,
0.0895328149,
0.0220517963,
-0.0042699776,
-0.0128953811,
0.0226654783,
-0.0090182871,
-0.0671406984,
0.009033991,
0.0060698893,
0.0106222769,
-0.0467414856,
0.0729335472,
-0.018412387,
-0.0089119878,
-0.0268301163,
0.0682564154,
0.0383282118,
-0.002289643,
0.0421284959,
0.036184445,
-0.0456681512,
-0.0009407774,
0.1061976403,
-0.0016689779,
-0.0241690334,
-0.0086357212,
-0.0758223087,
-0.0239412431,
0.0011575787,
-0.0160928909,
0.0783530846,
-0.0431601815,
-0.0163736511,
-0.0037578489,
-0.0543020517,
-0.0359912589,
-0.0458648652,
0.0183126535,
-0.0438119657,
0.0226919279,
0.0791615993,
-0.0234043375,
-0.0065617217,
-0.070113346,
-0.0463955402,
-0.0148997633,
-0.0029115162,
-0.0287299007,
-7.030664773e-33,
0.0229460094,
-0.0521676764,
-0.0063154711,
-0.0072337673,
-0.0004597636,
0.0049749655,
-0.0456543565,
-0.0116929188,
0.0223787446,
0.0429781415,
0.0061525297,
0.0123144547,
0.0129728904,
0.0260361377,
-0.0027823129,
-0.0361973383,
0.055388879,
0.0579916537,
-0.0193804912,
0.0555713437,
0.0697291568,
0.0238108505,
0.0177506674,
-0.0712757483,
0.0676026791,
0.0073862555,
-0.0341218449,
0.0241344012,
0.0009982759,
0.0746001601,
-0.0217858907,
0.0649143383,
0.0072332849,
-0.0679868013,
0.0255424194,
-0.0078025316,
-0.0602808557,
0.0050710361,
0.0550111085,
-0.0089025367,
-0.0216446742,
-0.0402809978,
-0.032480415,
-0.0057400428,
0.0111439712,
0.0063661714,
0.0394289121,
-0.0241302717,
-0.0310560279,
-0.0101706646,
-0.0143896546,
0.0215648841,
-0.0279336218,
-0.0326648578,
0.040188849,
0.0298510268,
-0.0125812059,
0.0581444018,
-0.0234453846,
-0.0086283488,
-0.0243179239,
0.0329141505,
0.0237736721,
-0.045748461,
-0.0571157113,
0.0351996683,
-0.0204063393,
-0.0115443449,
-0.0387802832,
0.0202529449,
-0.0724022686,
0.0574574471,
0.0404902622,
0.0356354974,
-0.0053625666,
-0.0122962184,
-0.0782990232,
0.0402664393,
0.0273260549,
-0.0071039777,
0.0619165897,
0.0395503081,
-0.042384252,
-0.0516417511,
-0.0275476072,
-0.0174906086,
-0.0510381609,
-0.0456214212,
0.018796593,
0.015214405,
-0.0375042483,
0.0066916659,
0.0016918234,
-0.0534475595,
-0.0422331728,
0.0219505299,
-0.0548857115,
-0.026128469,
0.0216915496,
0.0225092545,
-0.032665845,
-0.0068125338,
-0.0129890339,
-0.0269430596,
-0.0231696982,
0.0159927011,
0.0508599654,
0.0209599603,
-0.0290248133,
0.0097292103,
-0.0315287299,
-0.0239348058,
-0.0400290899,
0.0225454923,
0.0208521038,
0.0146681862,
-0.0281904377,
0.0963207707,
0.0325176753,
0.0297717787,
-0.0014842938,
-0.0546153821,
-0.0177575089,
-0.0108117145,
0.0008620953,
-0.0345207378,
0.0011029872,
-0.0411188193,
0.0419355668,
-0.0532161854,
-0.0244150218,
-0.0138982236,
2.993e-7,
0.0092170108,
0.0551334433,
-0.0290068202,
-0.0131451339,
0.0187090021,
0.0491668098,
0.0406523608,
-0.0012407433,
0.0022516896,
0.025580883,
0.0315877907,
0.002358011,
0.0483220108,
0.0121040326,
-0.0313543677,
-0.0104054129,
-0.0340188146,
-0.0330681093,
-0.0724507198,
0.0252602976,
0.0557259507,
0.0890975744,
0.0587643944,
-0.0004458028,
0.0288766436,
-0.0045102187,
0.0440755822,
-0.0838781521,
-0.0278612431,
0.0194856618,
0.0749073178,
-0.0019016094,
-0.0017232846,
0.0044200285,
-0.0327760652,
-0.0048207678,
-0.0065608756,
0.0513770059,
0.0073348964,
-0.0026123596,
-0.0039401548,
-0.0183091424,
0.0347823128,
-0.1005782932,
0.0726098567,
0.0066183228,
-0.0449800119,
0.0146699045,
-0.042757608,
-0.0483546741,
0.0112151233,
-0.0197548401,
0.0037523692,
0.0080921045,
-0.0072480901,
-0.0184361562,
0.0081425281,
-0.0545445569,
-0.0128457407,
0.0112269083,
-0.0207569543,
-0.0125539182,
-0.0381928496,
0.0038136784,
0.0518555157,
-0.0737999752,
0.0239680633,
3.004015073e-34,
0.0505388938,
0.0258146785,
-0.0020012311,
0.0012895371,
0.0528635792,
0.0268129352,
-0.0408369377,
-0.0033236586,
0.0597665906,
-0.0209590904,
-0.0143666891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17839v1 | Global-Liar: Factuality of LLMs over Time and Geographic Regions | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | Shujaat Mirza, Bruno Coelho, Yuyuan Cui, Christina Pöpper, Damon McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The increasing reliance on AI-driven solutions, particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs) like the GPT series, for information retrieval highlights the
critical need for their factuality and fairness, especially amidst the rampant
spread of misinformation and disinformation online. Our study evaluates the
factual accuracy, stability, and biases in widely adopted GPT models, including
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, contributing to reliability and integrity of AI-mediated
information dissemination.
We introduce 'Global-Liar,' a dataset uniquely balanced in terms of
geographic and temporal representation, facilitating a more nuanced evaluation
of LLM biases. Our analysis reveals that newer iterations of GPT models do not
always equate to improved performance. Notably, the GPT-4 version from March
demonstrates higher factual accuracy than its subsequent June release.
Furthermore, a concerning bias is observed, privileging statements from the
Global North over the Global South, thus potentially exacerbating existing
informational inequities. Regions such as Africa and the Middle East are at a
disadvantage, with much lower factual accuracy. The performance fluctuations
over time suggest that model updates may not consistently benefit all regions
equally.
Our study also offers insights into the impact of various LLM configuration
settings, such as binary decision forcing, model re-runs and temperature, on
model's factuality. Models constrained to binary (true/false) choices exhibit
reduced factuality compared to those allowing an 'unclear' option. Single
inference at a low temperature setting matches the reliability of majority
voting across various configurations. The insights gained highlight the need
for culturally diverse and geographically inclusive model training and
evaluation. This approach is key to achieving global equity in technology,
distributing AI benefits fairly worldwide. | [
0.0560114346,
0.0691162646,
-0.0376442187,
0.0000237761,
-0.0501105227,
0.0071296687,
0.050560642,
-0.0176414065,
0.0381627567,
-0.0330285691,
0.0096965767,
-0.0280684438,
0.0349220708,
0.0166380852,
0.0063344254,
-0.0455737151,
0.0696485564,
0.0072843339,
0.0244909413,
-0.048744753,
-0.0108974418,
0.0190709252,
0.0001400508,
0.0447028503,
-0.0260200184,
0.0192630775,
0.025844872,
-0.0226919875,
0.0140807768,
-0.000374872,
0.0004273639,
0.0331276022,
0.0117918449,
0.0426093936,
0.0000020866,
-0.0350706279,
-0.0319388062,
0.0022260647,
-0.0306002852,
0.0307255369,
0.0353968292,
0.0277674068,
-0.0021187656,
0.0287018679,
-0.057056386,
0.0021054898,
0.0376543626,
-0.0002255829,
0.0440141857,
0.0611118972,
0.0059595718,
0.0282774344,
0.0067473189,
-0.003952384,
-0.031485375,
-0.0201669652,
0.0259580575,
-0.0057158982,
-0.0476453565,
0.0180450361,
0.0108749596,
0.0439682268,
0.0220003724,
0.0165758282,
-0.0232272074,
0.0424954407,
-0.0646366477,
-0.02368889,
0.0204887111,
0.0027327428,
0.0801818594,
-0.0123371007,
-0.0139521677,
0.0075026676,
-0.00427859,
0.0104950732,
-0.0261627827,
0.0373778939,
-0.0336352736,
0.0485075302,
0.0288053043,
-0.0046565426,
0.0284599327,
0.0523453318,
-0.0438265502,
0.1478444636,
-0.0152642773,
-0.0652907565,
-0.0066653946,
0.037678007,
0.0115681812,
-0.0330294855,
0.0114642354,
-0.0174766481,
-0.0189540237,
-0.0025950647,
0.0113929985,
0.0498072132,
0.0195939094,
-0.0521904007,
0.0205218326,
0.0311563928,
-0.0097053973,
0.0321122967,
0.0326851457,
0.0633111745,
-0.0017704815,
0.0449812748,
-0.0025107621,
-0.0371559262,
-0.0213632714,
-0.0002541396,
0.0465757512,
0.0102266045,
-0.016402768,
0.0533187278,
-0.0554169416,
-0.0219299514,
-0.0536397621,
0.0190142859,
-0.0140306391,
-0.0033349537,
-0.0289752688,
-0.0102334302,
-0.0778739601,
0.0426798314,
-0.035702277,
0.022347752,
-0.010310444,
-0.0843246728,
0.0096938843,
-0.0060446328,
-0.0184223242,
-0.0034065477,
-0.0010039621,
0.0276121162,
0.0045133107,
-0.0005207333,
-0.0643169731,
-0.0082159573,
-0.0037106397,
-0.0646673813,
-0.0016458443,
-0.0347132273,
0.0122738779,
-0.0038618043,
-0.001145007,
-0.017399583,
-0.0228782501,
0.0214067306,
-0.0366277769,
0.0161078684,
-0.0066423616,
0.0264888331,
0.0722597986,
0.0182904527,
-0.0047421674,
0.0941143483,
0.0255409889,
0.052490782,
0.0769374445,
0.0236860644,
0.0057921931,
0.0033085544,
0.0280177537,
0.0707227215,
-0.0071296664,
0.0064768502,
-0.0293762404,
-0.0133344932,
0.013088542,
0.0488258637,
-0.006760878,
-0.0128274709,
0.0857109725,
0.0131084593,
-0.0119422888,
0.0149761187,
0.0023180884,
0.0409503169,
-0.0118485522,
0.0067941784,
-0.0742728636,
-0.0167886093,
-0.0556462072,
-0.0053398008,
0.0601206422,
0.0826539248,
-0.0179786701,
-0.0392271131,
-0.0048965216,
0.0223981328,
0.036876563,
0.0215730611,
0.0304459371,
-0.0725731924,
0.0088561689,
0.0208021495,
0.0579457283,
-0.0277333111,
-0.0219411161,
-0.0677137971,
0.0207658224,
0.0249294341,
0.0016401189,
-0.0023857041,
-0.0064069047,
-0.0040911138,
0.0014572119,
0.0307681002,
0.0435025655,
0.0153313279,
-0.0091848755,
-0.0131238606,
-0.0532813407,
0.0178303178,
0.0281086285,
0.043501839,
0.0673381984,
0.0775725245,
0.0048826374,
-0.0607576706,
-0.002003558,
0.0142985424,
-0.0198420156,
0.0170170888,
-0.0216710065,
0.019267723,
0.0390464589,
0.0116593074,
-0.0319195017,
-0.0169577915,
-0.0089170793,
0.0119737238,
-0.0374054797,
0.0021040833,
-0.0392254852,
0.0640841722,
0.0178187676,
-0.0190808289,
0.0286641009,
0.0335856229,
-0.0087809386,
-0.0049860878,
0.0253998078,
0.0194874238,
0.0220509563,
-0.0234544948,
-0.005864772,
-0.0484144762,
0.017017927,
-0.0109025799,
0.0438800789,
-0.0362853631,
-0.0123429997,
0.0005807596,
-0.0299092773,
0.0492726825,
-0.0298901889,
0.0077877147,
0.0412541106,
0.0286863744,
-0.0059899683,
0.0610045902,
-0.0057756794,
-0.024684377,
0.0070821578,
-0.1153343394,
-0.0141251711,
-0.0326921344,
-0.0060352744,
-0.000492907,
-0.0183307249,
-0.0423317738,
0.01842927,
-0.0399755836,
-0.0400091223,
0.016225988,
0.0551620834,
0.0157473423,
-0.0219531246,
0.0256196205,
-0.0317011029,
-0.0140197035,
-0.015744241,
0.0287244581,
0.0192948766,
-0.0393677838,
-0.0310006794,
-0.0122959428,
-0.0746800005,
0.0344692096,
-0.0554833598,
-0.0220698416,
0.0096796555,
0.0229485855,
-0.0315136611,
0.0406202301,
0.0260718595,
0.0284921322,
0.0537175871,
0.0097120944,
-0.0731966421,
0.00361638,
0.0099025704,
0.0022911693,
-0.0078589255,
-0.0955964848,
0.0017529927,
0.0307208169,
0.0539329536,
0.0091867605,
-0.0240351986,
0.031506151,
-0.0799247399,
-0.0717232302,
-0.0315199234,
-0.0113066398,
-0.0000458373,
0.0729261339,
-0.0283813551,
-0.0922158584,
0.0544206128,
-0.0183358062,
0.0513215549,
-0.0274728443,
-0.0404716209,
-0.0196828097,
0.0245069936,
-0.0181650035,
0.0227709077,
-0.0029666584,
-0.0004889814,
-0.0441309772,
-0.0638746321,
0.0625386909,
-0.028018415,
0.0192954931,
-0.0421837345,
-0.0019785811,
-0.0102207903,
-0.0560867488,
-0.0152452448,
-0.0574298948,
-0.0051931674,
0.0039799386,
0.0257109217,
-0.0637255833,
-0.0435604677,
0.013303386,
0.0724741891,
0.0426254719,
-0.0344997756,
0.0052426136,
0.0217382964,
-0.0615703017,
0.0272546913,
0.0118597839,
0.0351060666,
-0.007215227,
-0.0395680666,
0.0227744114,
0.01636515,
-0.0051353229,
0.0068216259,
-0.0116601,
0.0363106355,
-0.0216976609,
-0.0458217822,
-0.0192002486,
0.0341023356,
-0.0285676494,
0.0144099593,
0.093298845,
0.0041470034,
-0.0749855861,
-0.0227090847,
-0.0068773343,
0.0202682074,
0.0102171674,
0.0087709418,
-0.1200001687,
0.0282704476,
0.0261076931,
0.024888441,
-0.0710822791,
-0.0208595507,
-0.0100274971,
-0.10608197,
0.061745476,
0.0174013041,
-0.0068390947,
-0.0526119731,
-0.0679793134,
-0.0252369009,
-0.0274367835,
0.0390251279,
-0.0172924772,
0.0164424852,
0.0169406459,
0.0141453966,
-0.0855810419,
-0.0398388766,
0.0280221514,
-0.0305288136,
0.0289196465,
0.0573865436,
0.0316831321,
-0.0255647432,
-0.0347750708,
-0.0084079895,
0.0222297553,
-0.0133239431,
-0.0140429903,
0.0420476757,
-0.0161074288,
0.0072093378,
-0.0281568114,
-0.026339462,
0.0359848104,
0.0214884691,
0.0128393061,
0.0448567122,
-0.0139753828,
-0.0026894943,
-0.0186860655,
-0.0086327605,
0.011172737,
0.0539953709,
-0.0264844056,
0.0030147091,
-0.0175321344,
-0.0505042225,
0.0208076276,
-0.004594279,
-0.0308481548,
0.0511710495,
-0.0269755144,
-0.0368278325,
-0.0119640343,
-0.0491544828,
-0.0210013259,
0.0143496552,
-0.0079504494,
-0.022091642,
0.0612779297,
0.0066438406,
-0.0159256626,
-0.0072518168,
-0.0462840572,
0.0135875344,
-0.0038370236,
-0.0174320582,
0.0050329273,
-0.0149258822,
0.0069802618,
0.0166419353,
-0.0304060243,
-0.0441689752,
0.0391167253,
0.0101204012,
0.0337316692,
0.042094402,
-0.0083289798,
-0.0063845934,
0.0779079571,
0.0247408301,
-0.0015071301,
0.0310007352,
0.0188274756,
0.0252864212,
0.0001347323,
0.024820175,
-0.0303295758,
0.0051071839,
0.0050633107,
-0.0180341657,
-0.0355802104,
-0.022985097,
0.0449108072,
0.0059804008,
0.0485101677,
-0.015074227,
-0.0316005647,
-0.0423455834,
-0.0066314437,
-0.0037035155,
-0.0096212169,
0.0000705602,
-0.0017985046,
0.0362725891,
0.009402643,
-0.0072532203,
0.0140426429,
-0.0239091627,
-0.0061373222,
-0.0567488521,
0.0052295206,
-0.0310820565,
0.0656278282,
-0.0156981833,
0.007391117,
-0.0341027677,
0.0088655511,
-0.0110987946,
0.0508359037,
-0.0070510306,
0.0324889682,
0.0150177497,
-0.017912209,
-0.0030405757,
0.0240485016,
-0.0832056999,
-0.0531260781,
-0.032476943,
0.0097863832,
0.0628801882,
0.0182949957,
0.0223469138,
0.0000657543,
-0.0138776116,
0.0061439383,
-0.0277574137,
0.0226269439,
-0.0200855806,
-0.0107566118,
-0.0217250474,
-0.0563935935,
0.0577757508,
0.0667412207,
0.0043136361,
0.0459358729,
-0.011491267,
-0.0683129132,
0.0031908897,
-0.0536041744,
-0.0081705032,
-0.0143205756,
-0.0123104444,
-0.0264581069,
-0.0896628946,
-0.0487226732,
-0.0030211522,
0.0035552632,
0.0008472292,
-0.0378082655,
-0.0210099351,
0.1059796289,
-0.0062074871,
-0.0247900374,
-0.0678498596,
-0.0160074905,
-0.0405701846,
0.0033282898,
-0.0065460624,
-7.133288369e-33,
-0.0119083691,
-0.005314033,
0.0159976017,
-0.0437840037,
-0.0359556042,
0.0216659196,
0.015195909,
0.0051303068,
-0.0811995193,
0.0303271245,
-0.0154955853,
0.025792703,
0.0252738167,
-0.0159489233,
0.0082711233,
-0.0143155083,
0.0131800342,
0.0110988189,
-0.0402531177,
0.019970255,
0.0588825643,
-0.010897045,
0.0829384997,
-0.0927543268,
0.0616901331,
0.0046642497,
-0.033349596,
0.0147274025,
-0.0366238877,
0.0303568672,
0.0015816577,
0.07520964,
0.0394128338,
-0.0441529527,
0.0080951042,
-0.0470951088,
-0.0379805937,
-0.0250801351,
0.0211877879,
-0.0102388486,
0.0202641115,
-0.0048440481,
-0.0008352246,
0.0059305178,
-0.0722114891,
0.0332115218,
0.0312563106,
-0.000942408,
-0.0085427966,
0.0009169066,
-0.0041783559,
0.0267980322,
0.000480895,
0.0527640097,
-0.0729563013,
0.0625192821,
0.0145219341,
0.0609057993,
-0.0869341344,
0.040922612,
0.063368693,
0.0150554609,
0.0673876405,
-0.0302996803,
0.0102784643,
0.0778495371,
0.0255220886,
0.0235544499,
-0.0740946531,
-0.0843359753,
0.0315161273,
-0.0276793763,
0.0007509198,
0.0956591517,
-0.002382183,
-0.0607632957,
-0.0570675693,
0.0170049071,
0.0364114568,
0.0455585979,
0.0118014133,
-0.0131925996,
-0.0870466232,
-0.0498862602,
-0.0177909192,
-0.049903702,
-0.0219648145,
-0.0224889796,
0.0347392149,
0.0165989492,
0.0170522388,
0.0352283008,
0.0214663539,
-0.0284253303,
0.0005281102,
-0.0023230512,
-0.0022885811,
-0.0104505727,
0.0222850069,
0.0264312774,
-0.0639562234,
-0.0144025031,
-0.041457165,
0.0513209812,
-0.0153435692,
0.0230284929,
-0.0119390599,
0.0165238567,
-0.059643738,
0.01451323,
-0.024657337,
0.0152874896,
-0.006216465,
-0.0605063774,
0.014300677,
-0.0236706324,
0.0081930235,
0.020273976,
0.0279137418,
0.0515444502,
-0.0338443629,
-0.0115768034,
-0.0224510636,
0.0355516449,
0.006748118,
-0.0091881501,
-0.0331154764,
0.0206587985,
-0.0027883081,
-0.0461838171,
-0.0101628369,
-0.0206758305,
2.798e-7,
0.0077564395,
0.0563733131,
-0.0047804178,
0.0200184193,
-0.0035258047,
0.0528804548,
0.0092749828,
-0.0006573692,
0.0212691296,
-0.0052340501,
-0.0149064315,
0.0331493877,
0.032953579,
0.064558208,
-0.0526228696,
0.0202587433,
-0.0672843754,
-0.0090612182,
-0.0568074137,
0.0219024681,
-0.0007106147,
0.0630041733,
0.0412557572,
-0.00141437,
-0.0099361213,
-0.0460539535,
0.0340156332,
-0.0412862636,
-0.0415802039,
0.0045896834,
0.0589773655,
0.0063097086,
0.0396236256,
0.0008746227,
-0.0066988175,
0.01161646,
-0.0323408209,
0.0347562842,
0.0104269022,
-0.0076506273,
-0.0414633192,
-0.0372445732,
0.0123568876,
-0.1087378412,
0.073783204,
0.0169949587,
-0.0374672338,
-0.0354560129,
-0.0147076305,
0.0028992186,
0.0725832433,
-0.0158563405,
-0.0268227402,
0.0062765512,
-0.0138544822,
0.0330174714,
0.0018586688,
-0.0314980708,
0.0158924498,
-0.0379760303,
-0.0199587606,
-0.0735034198,
0.0071205134,
0.0206606016,
0.0099118091,
-0.0153300762,
0.0608414002,
2.723161233e-34,
0.032537207,
0.0134953251,
0.0176655389,
-0.0206319094,
0.0692741126,
0.0341734253,
0.003277364,
-0.0191357825,
-0.0039501372,
0.0018992113,
-0.0019994751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01765v1 | LLMs Simulate Big Five Personality Traits: Further Evidence | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | Aleksandra Sorokovikova, Natalia Fedorova, Sharwin Rezagholi, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; J.4; I.2.1 | An empirical investigation into the simulation of the Big Five personality
traits by large language models (LLMs), namely Llama2, GPT4, and Mixtral, is
presented. We analyze the personality traits simulated by these models and
their stability. This contributes to the broader understanding of the
capabilities of LLMs to simulate personality traits and the respective
implications for personalized human-computer interaction. | [
0.0544709563,
0.0181485321,
-0.0478511266,
0.013665285,
-0.0090780808,
0.0034809716,
0.0270891078,
-0.0186225362,
0.0447811224,
0.0107208136,
-0.0410961099,
-0.0139697548,
-0.0249741655,
0.000932886,
0.0249817632,
-0.0611962713,
0.0569678545,
-0.027900232,
0.0049866098,
-0.0171969254,
-0.0039687622,
0.0355037898,
0.0157509893,
0.0282270759,
0.0069381571,
-0.0209756214,
0.0072380123,
-0.0084169405,
0.021632053,
-0.0175513234,
0.0118930964,
0.0607194863,
0.0280475467,
0.0148629397,
0.0000017972,
-0.03698764,
0.0104606366,
-0.0097521702,
0.0242480859,
0.0405900814,
0.1033030823,
0.0873647705,
-0.0010036395,
0.0565438978,
-0.0369297415,
-0.0224483628,
0.0152101498,
0.0567770153,
0.072796464,
0.0305748042,
-0.0055484758,
-0.036691498,
-0.015578758,
-0.0035209041,
0.0305653252,
0.0025152625,
0.0226749945,
-0.0135926744,
0.024291534,
0.0351658799,
0.011134279,
-0.0263097864,
-0.0159557406,
0.0149072688,
-0.0371167213,
-0.0046155578,
-0.0346482508,
-0.0197337735,
-0.0223311875,
0.0288623478,
0.0410684459,
-0.0267631523,
-0.0060527232,
-0.0096274633,
0.0317377783,
-0.0154139772,
0.0065235817,
0.004904666,
-0.0220273044,
-0.0323598832,
0.0370078906,
0.0140353087,
-0.0206856951,
-0.0071625845,
-0.0038828291,
0.0549000017,
0.0064023016,
-0.0339554586,
0.0073123281,
-0.0257094074,
0.0292407162,
-0.0278901663,
0.018711118,
0.0032209549,
-0.0161873717,
0.0136615792,
-0.0421096534,
0.0324843563,
0.0405260436,
-0.0532433614,
0.0060648634,
0.0177852474,
-0.0255981758,
-0.0200015958,
0.0562685914,
0.0289896708,
0.0069006933,
-0.0305371918,
-0.008029487,
0.0035628339,
-0.0526266582,
-0.0058447006,
0.0273776315,
0.0195090789,
0.0293444581,
-0.0284399427,
-0.0814721435,
0.0454245545,
0.0028336565,
-0.0000236286,
0.0043039662,
-0.0229966417,
0.0126873152,
0.045949515,
-0.0565129742,
0.0004432201,
-0.0751618892,
0.0018311775,
-0.0054396116,
-0.04982052,
0.0671337619,
-0.0138067566,
-0.0093864044,
-0.0361480527,
0.0490941554,
0.057410948,
0.0244688764,
-0.0336450413,
-0.0415251739,
-0.0330627114,
-0.0073699439,
-0.0582811572,
0.0162760373,
-0.0286377594,
0.0391014367,
-0.0082054771,
-0.0096853804,
-0.0313455313,
-0.0009848732,
0.0395504721,
0.0016079135,
0.0375425108,
-0.0197126959,
0.0045499625,
0.0277107712,
-0.0003496192,
0.0300354883,
0.0240863878,
-0.030871287,
0.0226697922,
0.0261160638,
-0.0591893569,
0.0519127585,
0.0490388051,
-0.0298392363,
0.0157861877,
-0.0144077996,
-0.0330593772,
0.0230616312,
0.0021137353,
0.0493623242,
0.0523829162,
-0.0213963687,
0.0051280181,
0.095853433,
0.0853479132,
0.0516119413,
0.0573475994,
-0.0088578286,
0.0309361797,
0.0698028281,
-0.0285903551,
-0.0271253847,
0.0266860966,
-0.0275724214,
0.0121634752,
-0.0384704731,
0.0477359481,
-0.0013857837,
-0.0253630243,
-0.0207817703,
-0.0158529412,
0.0190254506,
0.0116724651,
-0.0280703045,
-0.0543522276,
-0.0028906756,
-0.0115726097,
0.026540786,
-0.0682849437,
-0.0568065867,
-0.0451477543,
0.0090508172,
0.1423734576,
0.0060037398,
0.0057107336,
-0.0031956017,
-0.0315017067,
-0.0607031621,
0.0234276317,
0.0506633148,
0.0042598266,
-0.0169452615,
-0.0626077503,
0.0332117602,
0.0012467933,
-0.0133874044,
0.0173646826,
-0.0112973833,
0.017760003,
-0.0158338174,
0.0601471104,
0.0161386859,
-0.0224589352,
-0.0576939322,
-0.043392431,
-0.0241754595,
0.0093003754,
0.0359760895,
0.0256421398,
0.0147113614,
-0.0167222358,
-0.0078272959,
0.009547649,
0.0133444555,
0.0397320837,
0.0117682293,
0.0406750031,
0.0256480686,
0.0207943786,
0.0160980616,
0.0165375751,
0.0322794989,
0.0018141132,
-0.0048033437,
-0.0408557467,
0.0549946837,
-0.0137750283,
0.0277402308,
-0.0409914032,
0.092904456,
0.0136057157,
0.0388247631,
-0.0309553295,
-0.0148949455,
0.0280828346,
-0.0114106806,
-0.0237453561,
-0.0634862185,
-0.041299656,
-0.0340935886,
0.018366823,
0.0526052266,
-0.0164323915,
0.0075926296,
-0.0503904559,
-0.0745215267,
-0.0436717495,
-0.0039267824,
0.0409163907,
0.012046149,
0.0154870255,
-0.0094283391,
-0.0613696799,
0.0241057333,
-0.0364945792,
-0.012840217,
0.0077711614,
0.0273858961,
0.029245032,
-0.0264513344,
-0.0397140048,
-0.0578749292,
-0.0144543406,
-0.0417584144,
0.0033363665,
-0.0375198163,
0.0433613807,
-0.0001267341,
0.0061002756,
-0.0506741591,
0.0153093869,
-0.0094844867,
-0.0670847744,
0.0356958695,
-0.0090242745,
0.0527596176,
0.0497048311,
0.0421527587,
0.0524698347,
-0.0001573675,
-0.018924607,
-0.0178246126,
0.0059023537,
-0.0055088527,
-0.0109054716,
-0.0324721895,
-0.0909965932,
-0.0266663227,
0.0505232587,
0.003299447,
0.0350608155,
-0.0223656502,
0.0518521443,
0.0350457579,
-0.0409562737,
0.0689117387,
0.0300035719,
-0.0425917208,
0.0520273149,
0.0417163931,
-0.0084157009,
0.0380981155,
-0.0236898866,
0.0189346597,
-0.005806651,
-0.0433251709,
-0.0067619942,
0.023732353,
-0.011427382,
-0.0294460636,
0.0406942591,
-0.0010733786,
0.0180507321,
-0.0592409298,
0.0146008991,
-0.0444512367,
0.0207303092,
0.0150928739,
-0.0693093762,
0.052925203,
0.0076684072,
0.0088783726,
-0.0459405854,
-0.0584731698,
-0.0258563645,
0.0469569415,
-0.0212423801,
-0.0240554195,
-0.0184889045,
0.0306146257,
-0.0319560319,
-0.0285711996,
0.0058682808,
0.0185902566,
-0.0418922976,
0.0645912439,
0.0334803946,
0.0025526229,
-0.0691987872,
-0.03064996,
-0.0331192203,
-0.0416964777,
-0.0053303461,
0.0002789254,
0.0087732906,
0.028087182,
-0.0101019768,
-0.0400366746,
0.0277388636,
0.0106677664,
0.0032752776,
0.0169879701,
0.1130789593,
0.0194115378,
-0.0061703823,
0.0221101418,
-0.0282158945,
0.0188431665,
0.0384532139,
0.0724520981,
-0.0277951322,
-0.0057924693,
-0.0262490474,
0.0199225303,
-0.0386882983,
-0.0291038807,
-0.0031068828,
-0.0801818296,
0.0257012192,
0.0086320397,
-0.0531635061,
0.0057064015,
-0.0045723575,
0.0008168804,
-0.0110446587,
0.007589737,
-0.0300303381,
0.0013075712,
-0.0279770661,
-0.0093108872,
-0.089837417,
-0.0242515169,
0.0945600495,
-0.0204500668,
0.0564034544,
0.0149065591,
0.0264010616,
-0.0306105539,
-0.0732760504,
-0.0683763698,
0.0192899387,
0.0260613672,
0.0152544277,
0.0353482626,
-0.0219877791,
0.0302317068,
-0.1127673313,
-0.0074634594,
0.0115960119,
0.0352476873,
0.0188874062,
0.037970107,
-0.0140114361,
-0.0531183183,
-0.0511430502,
0.0288941506,
0.0298963133,
0.0236527231,
-0.019560203,
-0.1021753252,
-0.0146957748,
-0.0186846536,
-0.024725724,
-0.0102542173,
-0.0875440836,
-0.0173482299,
0.0415094234,
-0.0342920758,
-0.0151597075,
-0.0933787376,
-0.0226158146,
0.0206395239,
-0.0139123509,
-0.0255657732,
-0.0211773477,
0.0185610745,
-0.0040065697,
-0.0178426951,
0.0010051257,
0.0197656397,
-0.037986435,
-0.0032793055,
0.071584262,
-0.0575967915,
0.016399743,
0.031664975,
-0.0623221174,
-0.0429212302,
0.0434729308,
0.0407480039,
0.0272106566,
-0.0087372167,
0.0213632304,
-0.059051726,
0.0061679431,
-0.0109781194,
-0.0132694608,
0.0719022304,
-0.0000100425,
0.0483195931,
0.0139631899,
-0.0016633258,
-0.0104860766,
0.0316051729,
-0.0260619316,
-0.0214832742,
-0.0162418708,
-0.0861394182,
-0.0229671411,
0.0413172916,
-0.0394983888,
-0.0059335981,
-0.0029926295,
0.0001588245,
-0.0176425353,
-0.0720549673,
0.0044198595,
0.0188289732,
-0.06300129,
-0.0163117442,
0.0050790245,
-0.0218567979,
-0.073721379,
-0.0242625717,
0.0063017081,
-0.0270753056,
0.0249124561,
0.0117452899,
0.0328117348,
-0.0269333702,
0.0033560276,
-0.0352378078,
-0.0069998768,
0.0072125932,
0.0524578653,
0.0017261243,
0.0818363577,
-0.0511799529,
-0.0077275913,
-0.0160487443,
0.0601740405,
-0.0205711424,
-0.0230836179,
0.0111769531,
0.0134165026,
-0.0156347267,
0.0077850451,
0.0355223119,
-0.0346747488,
0.0136332652,
-0.0350852497,
0.0437451154,
-0.002776,
-0.0304499567,
0.0257664975,
0.0053960681,
-0.0160798915,
-0.0497011095,
0.0166864097,
0.0278961156,
-0.0136471363,
-0.003659694,
-0.0450402759,
-0.0682789385,
0.029196823,
0.015162196,
0.0246052463,
-0.0171793699,
-0.0443981625,
-0.0954694524,
-0.08840096,
0.0677517429,
0.0151950568,
-0.0160444174,
-0.0393527262,
0.0218777899,
0.0440946594,
-0.0112230778,
-0.0176266469,
-0.0407864377,
0.0012715656,
-0.0330253877,
0.0052769529,
-0.0046590273,
-5.45329425e-33,
-0.0339538865,
0.0162268896,
0.0521707796,
0.0270276517,
-0.0224831607,
-0.0729352236,
-0.0202102698,
0.0411449634,
-0.0296068657,
-0.0203340631,
-0.0440621674,
-0.016736066,
0.0123277875,
-0.0546043143,
0.0314145535,
0.0304228719,
0.0205820557,
-0.0054838732,
-0.0127034355,
-0.0095482031,
0.0026796253,
-0.011208497,
0.055105038,
-0.0683799759,
-0.0031366944,
-0.0393071286,
-0.0159650724,
-0.0322301649,
0.0211610533,
0.0585663095,
0.0039196787,
0.0485890806,
0.0171463136,
0.0100485971,
-0.0054011387,
0.0206875578,
-0.0145015931,
-0.0548162423,
0.0385913812,
0.0041334117,
0.0315866023,
-0.0519358106,
0.0108044576,
-0.0180349313,
-0.0466134362,
-0.0105171558,
0.0450173579,
-0.0093823122,
0.017497886,
0.0328548774,
-0.0290579926,
-0.0125372978,
-0.008349956,
0.0166008882,
-0.018892454,
0.0058098366,
-0.0432106368,
-0.0002088312,
-0.0529573634,
0.0707230344,
-0.0094918357,
-0.0365760513,
0.0291991755,
0.0271261092,
0.0383815952,
0.0294459201,
0.072218664,
0.0638693348,
-0.008909367,
-0.0303301606,
0.0568341427,
0.0465160906,
-0.0106826955,
0.0720213205,
-0.0486894734,
-0.0828134194,
0.0374267623,
0.0079889232,
0.137074396,
-0.0715476647,
0.0469040908,
0.0160410497,
-0.0543939956,
-0.0375388898,
0.0185248069,
0.0415560827,
-0.0168136768,
-0.0534151867,
0.0254955459,
-0.0581672564,
0.0097322613,
-0.0167806856,
0.0381923839,
-0.0193743873,
-0.024039764,
0.0063853678,
-0.0385257043,
0.0329485834,
-0.0212008134,
-0.0234976411,
-0.0352019034,
0.0006853282,
-0.0259528644,
0.0093553169,
0.0587000102,
0.0276198722,
-0.0281786658,
0.0288947802,
-0.080076918,
-0.029668605,
0.0377407931,
0.0085426364,
0.0225525182,
0.0085043889,
0.0177576989,
-0.0279191546,
0.0089863529,
0.0076848092,
-0.0063195624,
0.0072802817,
-0.0482020974,
-0.0004335014,
0.0413196534,
-0.0066796686,
0.0001881109,
0.008922793,
-0.0723945275,
0.0397205465,
0.0386790708,
-0.0301962942,
0.0101266569,
-0.0071077258,
2.523e-7,
-0.0456268191,
0.0725233555,
-0.0395899452,
0.0354048721,
0.0259508565,
0.058478225,
0.0188929662,
0.0031227942,
0.0547200218,
-0.0147542683,
0.0216862727,
0.0276157986,
0.0270835292,
0.0338039249,
-0.0310230348,
0.0227399766,
-0.0047539175,
0.0292367171,
-0.0363963172,
0.008801287,
0.0602246895,
0.0528902672,
0.040076822,
0.0021232658,
0.0061083599,
0.0423262082,
0.0073422478,
-0.0089422865,
-0.0277794786,
0.0132979238,
-0.0400913134,
-0.0101815974,
-0.0086374041,
0.0442346893,
0.0027484591,
-0.0182617344,
-0.0109381462,
0.0696405172,
-0.0427286066,
-0.0032625641,
0.050409805,
-0.0067266445,
-0.0448606387,
-0.0212757234,
0.0064468943,
0.0252753887,
-0.038811516,
-0.0312412642,
-0.0325175188,
-0.0490885302,
0.0193303768,
-0.0145422174,
-0.0016218572,
0.0136267599,
-0.0092065921,
-0.016703004,
-0.0137386834,
-0.028080022,
0.0278636962,
0.0007524633,
-0.0451749489,
-0.0765858144,
-0.0075002336,
0.019970905,
0.0506168678,
-0.0254347678,
0.03239315,
1.85334512e-34,
-0.0014048396,
0.0404426828,
0.0318594426,
-0.0014483002,
0.0714769885,
0.0397050977,
0.0449104197,
0.0487141758,
0.0483170375,
-0.0550535731,
-0.0172390267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17827v1 | Neural Machine Translation for Malayalam Paraphrase Generation | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | Christeena Varghese, Sergey Koshelev, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.7.0; I.2.7 | This study explores four methods of generating paraphrases in Malayalam,
utilizing resources available for English paraphrasing and pre-trained Neural
Machine Translation (NMT) models. We evaluate the resulting paraphrases using
both automated metrics, such as BLEU, METEOR, and cosine similarity, as well as
human annotation. Our findings suggest that automated evaluation measures may
not be fully appropriate for Malayalam, as they do not consistently align with
human judgment. This discrepancy underscores the need for more nuanced
paraphrase evaluation approaches especially for highly agglutinative languages. | [
0.0646646768,
-0.0133634228,
-0.0238383207,
0.0594025105,
-0.072106123,
-0.0208703503,
-0.0379944146,
0.0104224011,
-0.0423003882,
-0.0455611646,
0.0041369153,
-0.0193402935,
0.0244862251,
-0.046300102,
0.0302244015,
-0.0769499168,
-0.0060172784,
-0.0182148814,
-0.0144313127,
0.0262311939,
-0.0055151121,
0.0404786021,
0.0052211732,
0.0553382933,
0.0240331087,
-0.0192793179,
0.0324281566,
0.0283619948,
0.0153535157,
-0.0389515348,
0.0171006881,
-0.0067610377,
0.0041536544,
0.0411135517,
0.0000015408,
-0.0615708344,
0.0133353481,
-0.022469474,
0.0300705545,
0.0302147269,
0.0704390183,
-0.0271883272,
0.0436183289,
0.027521247,
-0.0420070738,
0.0409800261,
0.0256190337,
-0.0242766589,
0.1086532101,
0.0417641439,
-0.0175874606,
-0.0811830536,
-0.0180970971,
0.02583923,
-0.0137179811,
-0.0247655567,
-0.0161556173,
-0.0256101228,
-0.0051741209,
-0.0512043238,
-0.0094706221,
0.0548828766,
-0.0325011387,
0.0173130501,
0.0183367133,
-0.0163371619,
-0.014987913,
-0.0175418407,
0.0273170695,
0.0742661282,
-0.0608215295,
-0.0244629383,
-0.024914002,
0.0013092058,
-0.0470975935,
0.0315029435,
-0.0554453321,
0.0315523148,
-0.0385568254,
0.0421314053,
0.0260038339,
0.0445120633,
-0.0089135105,
0.0339000076,
0.0663903579,
-0.0152368424,
0.0274287537,
-0.016338475,
-0.0643576607,
-0.0037213711,
-0.022113245,
0.0171290189,
0.0174423587,
0.0140303606,
-0.0060150409,
0.0263079423,
-0.0298410691,
-0.0690125376,
0.0430320166,
-0.1035391316,
0.0718859732,
0.037313886,
0.0219079256,
0.0132840481,
-0.0351817124,
0.0333034657,
-0.0283397026,
0.0586390905,
-0.0321890116,
-0.0208550505,
-0.0034667256,
-0.0085622258,
-0.0354404487,
0.0509976968,
-0.0280621294,
0.0054233014,
-0.0701187477,
-0.0044050035,
0.0395891666,
-0.03988076,
0.020886004,
0.0165055841,
-0.0458170921,
-0.008761459,
-0.0177423358,
-0.0129382778,
-0.0149500109,
0.020252645,
-0.0273706801,
-0.0595481545,
-0.0201623086,
0.016380202,
-0.0066359658,
-0.0578465648,
-0.0322836079,
0.0458367765,
-0.0125777619,
-0.0435517095,
-0.0410140231,
0.0010821896,
0.0102892611,
-0.0658366606,
-0.0223496091,
-0.0398842841,
0.066847153,
0.0176292416,
-0.0061997552,
-0.0367679559,
0.0128334416,
0.0442191474,
-0.0157794897,
0.0473821089,
0.001516239,
-0.0031051436,
0.0011502934,
0.0214609466,
0.0332030021,
-0.0177415274,
0.0385349505,
0.0285613202,
0.0385584049,
-0.0108224861,
-0.0176160708,
-0.019963311,
0.0015535789,
0.0022069637,
-0.0400667116,
0.0446212813,
-0.0354855098,
0.0854215771,
-0.0021279389,
0.0703845993,
-0.0249194149,
-0.0034396108,
0.060762886,
0.0686227754,
-0.0022757463,
0.0809663087,
0.0692724064,
0.0309180114,
0.0506427735,
0.0287865233,
-0.0080885356,
0.0161315966,
-0.0138998888,
0.0586484708,
0.0307260267,
0.0638561547,
0.00582032,
-0.0108986944,
-0.0203062724,
-0.0386589244,
-0.0269760024,
-0.030200351,
-0.0266686529,
-0.0034044131,
-0.0669278055,
0.0332944207,
-0.0332410671,
-0.0810908824,
0.0427812897,
-0.0635670945,
0.0287755523,
0.0583181344,
0.0644413903,
0.0008948356,
-0.0154581247,
0.0009615702,
-0.0195298828,
0.0635148883,
0.0249332804,
-0.0007037546,
0.0415264294,
-0.041176267,
0.0412769318,
-0.0303153824,
0.0013203975,
-0.0049575469,
-0.0253365487,
0.0022086133,
0.0683062896,
-0.0104594436,
-0.0721810013,
0.0534234755,
0.0249871127,
-0.0325070769,
0.0076542674,
-0.0040723658,
0.0423251204,
0.0125567466,
0.0171257406,
0.0164730791,
0.0005297133,
-0.016254155,
-0.0048719901,
0.0469183289,
-0.0185780209,
-0.0538709573,
-0.0333890468,
-0.0918304324,
0.0228831768,
0.0644198731,
-0.0030774917,
-0.0421276577,
0.0202889107,
-0.0519454554,
0.0513445586,
-0.0391832665,
0.0693316087,
-0.0550780632,
0.0082719522,
-0.0296097416,
0.0332046375,
0.0300998297,
-0.0262975134,
0.0256648306,
-0.0400535502,
0.0720992833,
-0.0093065407,
-0.0188223887,
-0.0089703742,
0.0853481144,
0.0445050634,
-0.0119616091,
-0.008314658,
-0.0335268117,
-0.0360530317,
-0.0572668202,
0.0036434582,
0.0012761005,
-0.0166232754,
0.0501860343,
0.0231822114,
0.0011664276,
-0.0232261773,
0.0580204464,
-0.0085318116,
0.053542234,
0.006956703,
0.0428515039,
0.0161753669,
0.0293613523,
-0.0725451261,
-0.0241947807,
0.0035443893,
0.0739393532,
0.0330126174,
-0.0179664772,
-0.0450619273,
-0.0210767742,
-0.0371730849,
-0.0501727238,
0.0212947261,
-0.057566233,
-0.0047851563,
-0.0300958101,
0.0086255576,
0.028386768,
0.0326553509,
-0.027657086,
0.0225845221,
0.0279986653,
-0.0194764361,
-0.0533571541,
-0.0210739113,
-0.0246838573,
-0.0017928833,
-0.0041082962,
0.0320873298,
0.0145541634,
0.0507302694,
-0.0198513363,
-0.0403309427,
0.0337549746,
0.0040967194,
0.0227342006,
-0.0087699024,
0.0276333224,
-0.0439803973,
0.0326922424,
-0.0048790863,
-0.0376634263,
0.1003846675,
-0.0422894098,
0.0156234289,
-0.0910084918,
-0.0099901119,
-0.0573061854,
-0.001274456,
-0.0403391011,
0.0105590411,
-0.0347602144,
0.0113117844,
-0.0378636084,
0.011212524,
0.0301924925,
-0.0013778574,
0.0533046685,
-0.0726205334,
0.0058398363,
-0.0068638842,
-0.0158180688,
-0.0141762663,
-0.103451781,
-0.0000783685,
-0.0096221389,
-0.0010906935,
0.0063382261,
0.0080045126,
0.0475493222,
-0.0261223335,
-0.0139160296,
-0.0270627718,
-0.0088657988,
-0.0259617325,
0.0086925747,
0.0626483113,
0.0293490198,
0.0195183903,
0.006393855,
0.0290777329,
-0.0547169559,
0.0290464181,
0.0226618703,
-0.0446215905,
-0.004841927,
-0.010069862,
-0.0445525683,
-0.0173142459,
-0.0030228549,
-0.0019746884,
0.0056666979,
-0.0012416499,
0.0622893237,
0.030296918,
0.0016339328,
-0.0055480031,
-0.0585655048,
-0.0018834242,
-0.010820386,
0.0353123993,
0.0186886098,
-0.0065185521,
-0.0346244127,
0.00714985,
0.0513167381,
-0.0223496612,
-0.0408654362,
-0.056575574,
-0.0263724606,
0.0103353485,
-0.0075504365,
-0.0449157283,
0.0137373563,
-0.040473152,
0.0060997042,
0.0268485304,
0.0189685766,
-0.0748665705,
0.0306523088,
-0.0213703141,
0.0082676671,
-0.0500725955,
0.0032800287,
-0.0772476867,
-0.0212408565,
0.0335812829,
0.0335998461,
0.0004198349,
-0.0118362298,
0.0084344707,
-0.0704983324,
0.020407306,
0.0216001421,
0.0365445055,
-0.0113623776,
0.0186058413,
-0.0193077344,
-0.0137053663,
0.0043253712,
0.0132764336,
0.0298203509,
0.063644439,
-0.001321429,
-0.0112939896,
-0.0264473651,
0.0270483885,
-0.0302960332,
0.0459567383,
0.0544393808,
0.0037148988,
-0.034999501,
0.028661171,
0.0035385529,
-0.0626924559,
-0.0323581733,
0.0195339657,
-0.0572349057,
0.0199680496,
-0.0693501756,
-0.0645819157,
-0.0196741186,
0.033529982,
0.0525003076,
0.0656551048,
0.0023269744,
0.0005751444,
-0.0026727468,
-0.0161146335,
-0.016960552,
0.024228083,
0.0102893226,
0.0243683271,
0.0466677956,
-0.0026368105,
0.0007677159,
-0.0326172113,
-0.036307361,
-0.0410838015,
-0.0037804986,
0.0584528409,
0.0323788635,
0.0060050325,
-0.0083186226,
-0.0399656147,
0.0095213214,
-0.0008613089,
-0.0248245038,
0.0257783756,
-0.0167839527,
0.0213199873,
-0.0213817656,
0.0572914481,
-0.021051202,
-0.0435243919,
-0.0013412795,
0.035920579,
0.0124854119,
-0.0489054359,
0.0622550622,
0.012042582,
0.0165964421,
-0.0896778628,
0.0181586407,
-0.0121763945,
0.0056869262,
0.0168716442,
0.007143321,
-0.0043859682,
-0.0136129586,
0.0589573383,
0.03237883,
-0.0213327426,
-0.0097600026,
-0.0418307334,
0.0198264942,
-0.0077766338,
0.0154333757,
-0.0103306752,
0.0565831251,
-0.0245655365,
0.012477464,
-0.0264473818,
-0.0322316363,
-0.0774252266,
-0.014327189,
0.0024887647,
0.0509676337,
-0.0044309422,
-0.0076843761,
-0.0117224595,
0.0748380646,
0.0170150995,
-0.0279070325,
-0.0174843259,
0.0484973975,
0.0578741655,
-0.0122937914,
0.0723578855,
-0.0002959008,
0.0057586525,
0.0118719786,
0.070389092,
-0.0344472677,
0.0315036476,
0.0340957567,
-0.0337709859,
0.0158455092,
0.0020175115,
0.0467930175,
0.0147346947,
-0.0082988702,
0.0126664294,
-0.0385540463,
-0.0242493954,
-0.0648091361,
-0.0409044996,
0.0378952473,
0.023190951,
-0.0147163402,
-0.0613021739,
-0.0288168304,
0.0139880665,
0.0271663312,
0.0317146406,
-0.03427938,
0.0327060744,
0.0557608753,
0.0175939072,
-0.0222685542,
-0.0719137713,
0.0384497978,
-0.0233453289,
-0.0021153274,
-0.0642067567,
-5.256299764e-33,
-0.0323617905,
0.0420929044,
0.0062093884,
-0.0018573223,
-0.0331096426,
-0.0497006364,
-0.0314389355,
-0.0338284411,
0.0097613139,
-0.0312488303,
-0.0164510738,
0.0128975231,
0.008096166,
0.000516355,
0.0456317626,
-0.0121396519,
0.0348449945,
0.0196691249,
-0.013960233,
-0.0030450241,
-0.0078480272,
0.0299745519,
0.0699593574,
-0.0388519205,
0.0207096562,
-0.0669501275,
0.0238988362,
-0.0019574007,
-0.0214115772,
0.0124393748,
-0.0156890284,
0.0566001274,
0.0357426554,
0.0162423123,
-0.0400042981,
-0.0409914218,
-0.0350821912,
-0.0093030389,
0.0851574913,
0.0175074097,
-0.0670271143,
-0.0328534134,
0.0547645427,
-0.0250480659,
-0.0227358472,
0.0452852882,
0.0558512807,
0.001639597,
0.0118917236,
0.0231750775,
-0.0666965917,
0.0042777797,
-0.0032472031,
0.0159606356,
0.0079653105,
0.0803713277,
-0.0366934799,
0.0203625113,
-0.0682996511,
0.0008968129,
-0.0310823731,
0.0058228397,
0.0294225104,
-0.0036173195,
-0.0229796972,
-0.0131287379,
0.0120923817,
-0.047208678,
0.0126266461,
0.0736761391,
-0.0154672842,
0.0219849609,
0.0371004045,
0.0730123594,
0.0316668227,
-0.0439248756,
0.0182687417,
0.0151940789,
-0.0162919462,
0.0223684646,
0.0399127491,
-0.029519286,
-0.007692059,
-0.0194910318,
-0.002801778,
-0.0291347597,
-0.015281233,
-0.0491350032,
0.0420601033,
-0.0251392312,
-0.0351243615,
0.030244831,
0.0597711913,
-0.032122992,
0.0479230471,
-0.0435170792,
-0.0235481244,
0.0240414329,
-0.0010991972,
0.0200105663,
0.0066561722,
-0.021922119,
-0.0171448532,
0.0470205098,
0.0448656902,
-0.0163395163,
0.0122299651,
0.0003660359,
-0.0068046488,
0.0169542171,
-0.0445463769,
-0.046596244,
-0.0314046405,
-0.0562751181,
-0.0293466374,
0.0417277738,
-0.0040031872,
-0.0253399722,
0.0222175326,
-0.025763372,
-0.0028159369,
0.0283400733,
0.0683289319,
0.0225021504,
-0.0188329257,
0.0287781637,
-0.055341024,
0.0153698418,
-0.0052761422,
-0.0546289161,
0.0129207401,
0.0123980837,
2.396e-7,
0.0092207929,
0.030795617,
0.0332996696,
-0.0668547526,
-0.0223313663,
0.0001461693,
-0.0140721183,
-0.0082179131,
-0.0155808125,
0.0265521295,
0.0317367502,
-0.0003049025,
0.0044941385,
-0.0209665131,
-0.1271111071,
-0.011630157,
-0.1107369587,
-0.0065264818,
-0.0546299219,
-0.0388371646,
0.0363493338,
0.049769599,
0.0340854786,
-0.0313659757,
-0.0274024084,
-0.0347400904,
0.0519773439,
0.0099775065,
-0.0183904357,
0.0182912834,
0.0319636352,
0.0099296337,
-0.0137740746,
-0.0010093226,
0.0154745746,
0.0075214785,
0.0634649992,
0.0537959188,
-0.0110224672,
0.0213851798,
0.0097462703,
-0.0399924815,
0.0144492825,
-0.0818523541,
0.0093339337,
-0.016358722,
-0.0074444748,
0.0233143419,
-0.0065328544,
0.0351443999,
0.0395179763,
-0.0342985168,
-0.0363735072,
-0.0015438752,
0.0079206638,
-0.0399334691,
-0.0056501515,
-0.0171072409,
-0.0286522955,
0.0286263544,
-0.0220937543,
-0.0203888305,
-0.013392617,
-0.0008874447,
0.0740375966,
-0.0560941063,
0.0198844336,
1.31367463e-34,
0.0534769781,
0.0108455261,
0.0757145658,
-0.020257663,
0.0239110626,
0.0115279621,
-0.0032158552,
0.024217749,
0.0252338108,
-0.0264476761,
-0.0260497686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17824v1 | A Survey of Pre-trained Language Models for Processing Scientific Text | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | Xanh Ho, Anh Khoa Duong Nguyen, An Tuan Dao, Junfeng Jiang, Yuki Chida, Kaito Sugimoto, Huy Quoc To, Florian Boudin, Akiko Aizawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The number of Language Models (LMs) dedicated to processing scientific text
is on the rise. Keeping pace with the rapid growth of scientific LMs (SciLMs)
has become a daunting task for researchers. To date, no comprehensive surveys
on SciLMs have been undertaken, leaving this issue unaddressed. Given the
constant stream of new SciLMs, appraising the state-of-the-art and how they
compare to each other remain largely unknown. This work fills that gap and
provides a comprehensive review of SciLMs, including an extensive analysis of
their effectiveness across different domains, tasks and datasets, and a
discussion on the challenges that lie ahead. | [
0.0362248421,
0.03848451,
0.011782161,
0.015365635,
-0.037573766,
0.0083134435,
0.0259804949,
-0.0011606596,
0.0117894914,
-0.0476833954,
-0.0961258486,
-0.0151482876,
-0.0073985364,
0.0565253906,
0.00243707,
-0.0172006059,
0.0623195134,
-0.0357293859,
0.0548247881,
-0.0017274667,
-0.0132245887,
-0.0045355116,
0.0030063235,
-0.0075836517,
0.0353479385,
-0.0327797681,
0.0493168086,
-0.0182025097,
0.0420654044,
-0.042846743,
0.024059616,
0.0769315809,
0.0112602795,
0.0576243326,
0.0000018473,
-0.0475107171,
-0.0198721178,
0.0005471066,
0.0040181917,
0.0551677272,
0.0674493462,
-0.0466178805,
0.0189445242,
-0.0203632545,
-0.0402540118,
-0.0220060293,
0.0381263159,
-0.0060924753,
0.000898518,
0.0303008854,
-0.0090601528,
-0.0692242905,
0.0348618291,
0.012332405,
-0.0144165261,
0.0106781423,
0.0693415254,
-0.0058708121,
0.0110040465,
0.0713394433,
-0.0025509633,
0.0861230716,
-0.0132886171,
-0.0135425273,
-0.0047003594,
0.0443155393,
-0.0314576179,
-0.0124092596,
-0.0212529358,
0.0623592101,
-0.0383848511,
-0.057129845,
0.0127171427,
-0.034923926,
-0.0660863295,
-0.0106113777,
-0.0355928838,
0.0304208715,
0.0215945486,
0.0068846103,
0.0324793383,
0.0275991596,
0.017570287,
0.0242666248,
-0.04512541,
0.0981464237,
0.0395907573,
-0.0417999513,
0.0075746542,
-0.002973211,
0.0101690255,
-0.0251257252,
0.0578228794,
0.0164527372,
0.0098907426,
0.0213852599,
-0.050327301,
-0.0479390286,
0.0389836989,
-0.0235230196,
0.0348329879,
-0.0101661012,
-0.0058161868,
0.0531246588,
-0.0162401292,
0.0127466284,
0.0039802277,
0.0310246535,
-0.0009953413,
0.0077927429,
0.0022163454,
-0.0249950793,
-0.0113957534,
-0.0193849877,
-0.0368653387,
-0.0223740656,
-0.0191846732,
-0.0187663697,
0.0479060262,
-0.0407358408,
-0.0205835085,
-0.0484045036,
-0.0048869653,
-0.0083252704,
0.0065652984,
0.0471371226,
0.0296844523,
0.0143148452,
-0.0173218101,
-0.0626174584,
-0.0216427967,
0.0222993363,
0.0112714143,
-0.0292864218,
0.0184785407,
0.0228154808,
0.0533636995,
-0.082710892,
-0.0034341877,
-0.0020434055,
-0.0100797238,
-0.0600712411,
0.0230415538,
-0.0358627401,
0.0451249629,
0.02320995,
-0.0083724493,
-0.0259292424,
0.008249606,
0.0125749595,
-0.0547868274,
0.0625292584,
-0.0719826147,
-0.0117034139,
0.0053511788,
-0.0191764049,
0.0460088067,
0.035930749,
0.0024881917,
-0.0208991505,
0.0376707762,
-0.0141114285,
0.0058170385,
0.0403812416,
0.0078651607,
0.006287517,
-0.0260779746,
0.0126575697,
-0.0197417457,
0.0211464055,
0.0313446298,
0.0319803618,
-0.0186045282,
-0.0353377014,
0.00882091,
0.072375834,
0.0363066271,
0.0059841303,
0.0411244854,
-0.0092901094,
0.0714904815,
-0.0322229415,
0.0077879941,
0.0061928704,
-0.0334606916,
0.0090524871,
0.0012787547,
0.0393448509,
-0.024914965,
-0.0294873137,
-0.0204559267,
-0.0110927373,
-0.0121656712,
-0.0359556973,
0.0796237513,
-0.0331706256,
-0.0339226425,
-0.0307674669,
0.0466925465,
-0.065235883,
0.0259176306,
-0.0014712251,
0.0122710261,
0.027174633,
0.0571958907,
-0.0572331026,
-0.0581877939,
0.0263301563,
0.0049545132,
0.0441182181,
0.0408231579,
0.0193337705,
-0.0199582055,
-0.0543144122,
-0.0441219769,
-0.0067478903,
0.0067132404,
0.0108343344,
0.0076305722,
0.005529908,
0.0029826367,
-0.0079529854,
-0.0478505343,
0.0692156777,
-0.0703127533,
-0.0167084597,
-0.0331625119,
-0.0600619689,
0.037662413,
-0.0024717168,
-0.0280376859,
0.0416780263,
0.0723271444,
-0.0294389483,
0.0266742948,
0.0026175957,
-0.0213265251,
-0.0488814041,
0.0514785647,
-0.0068959114,
0.0057094474,
0.040733356,
-0.0028929564,
-0.005452076,
0.0077301445,
0.0291385967,
0.0141995559,
-0.0427613929,
0.0119378269,
-0.0133997286,
0.0077836714,
-0.0432352982,
0.0326071791,
-0.0219305903,
0.0694993734,
0.0069649131,
-0.0055084298,
0.0194141194,
-0.0178763624,
-0.0425870456,
-0.0242312308,
0.0226171482,
-0.0252966341,
-0.0035364833,
-0.0107175643,
-0.0288565364,
0.0061892034,
-0.0122516863,
-0.0104314536,
-0.0153033799,
0.0075161499,
0.022362845,
-0.0366535783,
-0.0450650044,
0.0094517851,
0.0208712257,
0.0079788715,
0.0095138531,
-0.007296904,
0.036192704,
-0.0241339691,
0.0266390573,
-0.0471599959,
-0.0378883071,
-0.0261536613,
0.0365234725,
0.0342575945,
-0.0431922637,
-0.0520235263,
0.0314495452,
-0.0107016191,
0.0175299328,
-0.0004163669,
-0.008695838,
-0.0088268798,
-0.0568067096,
0.0214701369,
0.0344576053,
0.0105675003,
0.0014134509,
0.0522081926,
-0.0037672559,
-0.027237244,
-0.0134201245,
-0.0319166183,
0.0388153605,
0.0048134662,
0.0391993672,
0.0695333704,
0.0653086603,
-0.0728772879,
-0.019515397,
0.0236129798,
0.0268105213,
-0.0339953378,
-0.0323911794,
0.0214700494,
0.0060213641,
-0.0217813123,
0.0533920042,
0.0176655147,
-0.0478633828,
0.0393721685,
-0.0743479729,
-0.027443625,
-0.1165586635,
0.0130195171,
-0.0343084037,
-0.006125106,
0.0362485647,
0.0027248496,
0.0126796085,
-0.0097682448,
-0.0040970412,
0.0411911383,
-0.0477432832,
-0.0051638996,
-0.0345027708,
-0.032662861,
0.0397372432,
-0.0052403468,
0.0613533929,
-0.0063321278,
-0.0383465849,
-0.0434686616,
0.0316120833,
0.0205011982,
-0.0432076044,
-0.0584628619,
0.0479200855,
-0.0030034087,
0.0585401468,
-0.0279909316,
0.0115187401,
-0.0477556475,
0.009534305,
0.0436987765,
-0.017053321,
0.0591415875,
-0.0185204893,
-0.016903596,
0.030352775,
0.0043022162,
-0.0187365972,
-0.0093285739,
-0.0173756257,
0.0530625656,
-0.0557719059,
0.0189230591,
-0.0184838008,
0.0388231464,
-0.0515275449,
-0.0151834851,
0.1308387369,
0.0434135683,
-0.0478103571,
-0.0251073446,
0.0095943203,
0.0067938846,
0.0094082681,
0.0127636045,
-0.0719668493,
-0.0074272756,
-0.0216542017,
-0.0274240542,
0.0151788034,
-0.0426693894,
-0.02156711,
-0.0690553114,
0.0413719863,
0.0239304658,
-0.0541857518,
0.000439494,
-0.0566145889,
-0.0196658801,
-0.006894873,
-0.0226726886,
0.0165619664,
-0.0438547432,
0.0110478522,
0.0203389786,
-0.0193600766,
-0.0835464448,
0.0189039987,
-0.0299632717,
0.0183097105,
0.0378043875,
0.0221816506,
-0.0302701816,
-0.0321186818,
0.055757232,
-0.0084419483,
-0.0197766237,
-0.0365100019,
0.0003393427,
-0.0069335508,
-0.007099845,
0.0109765427,
0.0418742895,
-0.0591827072,
-0.00389454,
-0.0051763947,
0.0957398117,
-0.0266219229,
-0.0145948753,
-0.0735953748,
0.0342368446,
-0.0119800782,
0.0929488987,
0.011330259,
-0.0252495743,
-0.0579254627,
-0.0065047503,
0.0165683292,
-0.001230692,
-0.0683866218,
-0.0038423217,
-0.037060041,
0.0006654017,
-0.0376829021,
-0.013109684,
0.0669307783,
-0.0055485722,
-0.0054724193,
0.0128332451,
0.0049126758,
-0.0232858602,
-0.0301499031,
0.0154498201,
-0.0302466471,
-0.0085368389,
-0.0819516405,
-0.0263606384,
0.0635357201,
0.043336682,
-0.0358634554,
-0.0052790679,
-0.0233442783,
-0.0523229241,
-0.0058962484,
0.0615347587,
0.0157482754,
-0.0235860385,
-0.015891077,
-0.0353975631,
0.0461812206,
0.0256460663,
-0.0479551479,
0.0183937736,
-0.0129444543,
-0.013043656,
-0.0166346133,
-0.0233332533,
0.006043938,
0.0514432415,
0.0243738201,
0.0282251034,
-0.0165094081,
-0.0727071688,
0.0200740118,
0.0294845458,
0.095656462,
-0.0176609624,
-0.0159364343,
-0.0245431121,
-0.0214773472,
-0.0406246893,
0.0228071678,
-0.0361426808,
0.0069660991,
0.0173113644,
0.022266442,
-0.0378651954,
0.0048251254,
-0.0609004498,
0.0284771267,
-0.0418057702,
0.0570508055,
0.0414340496,
0.0080707753,
0.0241355971,
-0.0200288314,
-0.0034762064,
-0.0168847535,
-0.0282199122,
0.0044508209,
0.003089373,
0.0139318202,
0.0208958555,
0.0269994885,
-0.026768811,
0.0391929448,
-0.1077566668,
-0.0275012497,
-0.0363505594,
0.0180248339,
0.0211454276,
0.0125053423,
0.0335705951,
-0.0454630554,
-0.0307405163,
-0.0671722069,
0.0247847624,
0.0331500769,
0.0193872079,
0.063558653,
0.0038762814,
-0.0416579768,
-0.0208863858,
0.0699967071,
0.0485901982,
0.0377627388,
0.0479369387,
0.0079330802,
-0.0114081288,
-0.0175379924,
-0.0701160505,
-0.0132145165,
-0.0294357315,
0.0126500949,
-0.0595997609,
-0.0208326317,
0.0595350489,
0.0099629397,
-0.0155298626,
-0.0374080092,
0.0128645441,
0.0503671691,
-0.0225134399,
0.0159049761,
-0.0025191358,
0.03245572,
-0.0136726489,
-0.056742873,
-0.0000433278,
-5.697221083e-33,
-0.0066741896,
0.0032530352,
0.0256784633,
0.0335973576,
0.0154054631,
0.026009379,
-0.0177316666,
-0.0077797957,
-0.0135562429,
0.0147569198,
0.0116927652,
-0.0005640755,
0.0022855075,
0.0011751815,
0.0025757423,
0.0456347503,
0.0225917455,
-0.034583088,
0.0070110257,
0.0028734826,
0.019793354,
0.0607710034,
0.0628395006,
-0.0620315075,
0.0123524452,
-0.0010956188,
0.0499938317,
-0.0092156995,
-0.0085158395,
0.0433785282,
-0.0651369691,
0.010221133,
-0.0004287161,
-0.0372057408,
-0.0635118708,
0.0187249407,
-0.059023574,
-0.0057152482,
0.0060523655,
-0.0089116627,
-0.0203387178,
-0.0093164677,
0.0307618454,
0.0068302504,
-0.0283102859,
-0.0083086202,
0.0390427001,
-0.0091519607,
-0.0270465501,
-0.049753543,
-0.0641359389,
0.0445249379,
0.0231694411,
0.0373053066,
0.0620700866,
0.0101577733,
-0.0151130632,
0.1067773923,
-0.0127876895,
0.0517804697,
0.0739562437,
0.030365983,
0.0077936505,
-0.0319723152,
0.0364830941,
0.0502682664,
0.010237338,
-0.0388266258,
0.0242874902,
0.0188814159,
0.0711925626,
-0.0010437903,
0.053726688,
0.011541808,
0.0278913118,
0.023529483,
-0.0766345188,
0.0197924841,
0.008424798,
0.0070685274,
0.0048265401,
0.0240302943,
0.0389460213,
-0.0037611893,
-0.0112153478,
-0.0172605477,
-0.0125986412,
-0.022270333,
0.0103590665,
-0.0367621146,
-0.0445988216,
0.04659684,
0.0457360744,
-0.048599869,
-0.0453467593,
0.0101515697,
0.0336317234,
0.0381834395,
-0.0059435703,
0.0689643621,
-0.111014612,
-0.0226119291,
0.016694285,
-0.033165928,
-0.0074090199,
-0.0257817097,
-0.0069973958,
-0.0041736821,
-0.0348146483,
-0.0105896685,
0.0194159355,
-0.047284212,
0.0505958423,
0.0897034481,
0.0073135588,
0.017787924,
0.0450630523,
0.0444900133,
0.0445398986,
-0.0049433494,
0.0118689053,
0.0200910736,
-0.0006113545,
0.0426310748,
-0.0186470896,
-0.0415813103,
-0.0441097021,
-0.0132909724,
-0.0168442652,
-0.0520619713,
0.0338592753,
-0.0047345455,
2.356e-7,
0.0928220078,
0.0669592246,
0.0365990549,
-0.0609028675,
0.0290835388,
-0.0206082333,
-0.0188497435,
0.0044706129,
0.0075009856,
0.0309786983,
-0.0117796948,
-0.0313739702,
0.0077848285,
0.0030266289,
-0.0593294241,
-0.0086244652,
-0.0556208789,
-0.0296441969,
-0.0685637444,
-0.0404482037,
0.0177233778,
0.0699522048,
-0.0267587993,
-0.0003879783,
-0.0188221484,
-0.0268956162,
0.0610942058,
-0.0539432168,
-0.0010079324,
0.0603070408,
0.0084873289,
0.0106366882,
-0.000506358,
0.0243340153,
-0.0227178466,
0.0253675878,
0.0195806734,
0.0695448294,
-0.0127666993,
-0.0126534775,
0.0627208203,
0.0211662501,
0.0089205736,
-0.037852481,
0.0558604263,
-0.0548465475,
-0.0166457389,
-0.022963129,
-0.0225016456,
-0.0101965116,
0.0268011037,
-0.0245608874,
0.0016658012,
0.0233804174,
0.0155617502,
-0.001387029,
-0.0267246664,
-0.0895425975,
-0.005073423,
0.0222102534,
-0.0260169283,
-0.0394022763,
-0.0384039134,
-0.0228723492,
0.0509436615,
-0.0465980805,
-0.0027487318,
2.340980699e-34,
0.0726634786,
-0.0153394742,
-0.0092020174,
0.0537742712,
-0.0371201187,
-0.0112038581,
0.0009495128,
0.037927229,
-0.0240160488,
-0.1004103124,
0.0329443365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17809v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17809v3 | SWEA: Updating Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models via Subject Word Embedding Altering | 2024-01-31T13:08:45 | 2024-04-23T01:08:44 | Xiaopeng Li, Shasha Li, Shezheng Song, Huijun Liu, Bin Ji, Xi Wang, Jun Ma, Jie Yu, Xiaodong Liu, Jing Wang, Weimin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The general capabilities of large language models (LLMs) make them the
infrastructure for various AI applications, but updating their inner knowledge
requires significant resources. Recent model editing is a promising technique
for efficiently updating a small amount of knowledge of LLMs and has attracted
much attention. In particular, local editing methods, which directly update
model parameters, are more suitable for updating a small amount of knowledge.
Local editing methods update weights by computing least squares closed-form
solutions and identify edited knowledge by vector-level matching in inference,
which achieve promising results. However, these methods still require a lot of
time and resources to complete the computation. Moreover, vector-level matching
lacks reliability, and such updates disrupt the original organization of the
model's parameters. To address these issues, we propose an detachable and
expandable Subject Word Embedding Altering (SWEA) framework, which finds the
editing embeddings through token-level matching and adds them to the subject
word embeddings in Transformer input. To get these editing embeddings, we
propose optimizing then suppressing fusion method, which first optimizes
learnable embedding vectors for the editing target and then suppresses the
Knowledge Embedding Dimensions (KEDs) to obtain final editing embeddings. We
thus propose SWEA$\oplus$OS method for editing factual knowledge in LLMs. We
demonstrate the overall state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of SWEA$\oplus$OS
on the \textsc{CounterFact} and zsRE datasets. To further validate the
reasoning ability of SWEA$\oplus$OS in editing knowledge, we evaluate it on the
more complex \textsc{RippleEdits} benchmark. The results demonstrate that
SWEA$\oplus$OS possesses SOTA reasoning ability. | [
0.0451478884,
0.0666908026,
0.0059316508,
0.0620869435,
-0.0560301468,
-0.0032224888,
-0.0137164295,
-0.0336374454,
-0.023711076,
-0.066598475,
-0.0388773605,
0.0000475608,
0.0205576029,
0.0267118681,
0.0123598333,
0.0083635841,
0.0783424526,
0.0024560387,
-0.0394571982,
-0.0195757411,
-0.0255238619,
0.004413418,
-0.0007027033,
0.0062433616,
-0.0080683772,
-0.0026324538,
-0.0134306774,
-0.0097713377,
0.0203360133,
0.0553660318,
0.0022660291,
0.0776499063,
0.0281960648,
0.0831449032,
0.0000022649,
-0.0339919366,
-0.0426880121,
0.0167386159,
-0.0469473489,
0.0436444655,
0.0286118425,
-0.0243163873,
-0.0245352704,
0.0024710554,
-0.014247315,
-0.0316880755,
0.0793775395,
0.0388022475,
0.0858985186,
0.1035117805,
-0.0044351383,
-0.0111199003,
0.0350004807,
-0.0368994959,
-0.0647028983,
-0.0320114568,
0.0572107956,
-0.0128980186,
-0.0618847348,
0.019693071,
-0.0433983617,
0.0346209332,
0.0054430892,
-0.0371539257,
0.0401480719,
-0.0026809692,
-0.0612328611,
0.0041459659,
0.0146401254,
0.0555330068,
-0.0086674336,
-0.0254955348,
-0.0249314643,
0.0100035882,
-0.0024779667,
0.0359740667,
-0.0086316261,
-0.0130447708,
0.0581985265,
0.0284311082,
0.0036611278,
-0.0777609274,
0.0495994836,
0.0256539993,
-0.0405664109,
0.058177501,
0.0635219663,
-0.0441832654,
-0.0410340056,
-0.0262770914,
-0.013244505,
-0.0711857155,
-0.0050734417,
0.0261955392,
-0.0198749974,
0.0367008671,
-0.0473668166,
-0.0438677222,
-0.0207451507,
-0.0637422353,
0.0425237007,
0.0527800247,
0.0070985956,
0.072175242,
-0.0494563691,
0.0281366035,
0.0073035774,
0.0132201575,
-0.0527754799,
0.0015577875,
-0.0230409838,
-0.0080163488,
-0.0324889719,
0.0289910547,
-0.0686570406,
-0.0009107207,
-0.0326659046,
0.0107621523,
-0.0090259919,
0.0340227261,
-0.0055580502,
-0.0048198202,
0.0016414002,
-0.0265315454,
0.0005503129,
0.0568929613,
-0.0022830586,
0.010134236,
-0.0389985181,
-0.0094953785,
-0.034968365,
-0.0133419735,
0.0186608396,
-0.0197061673,
0.0170585867,
0.0213820674,
-0.025037894,
-0.0386499614,
-0.0313370675,
-0.0117162308,
-0.0091034761,
-0.053882543,
0.000874948,
-0.0592875779,
0.0589474849,
-0.0140151717,
-0.0436680876,
-0.057241112,
0.009652487,
-0.0091969371,
-0.0687958077,
0.1026877612,
-0.0054904185,
0.0155134052,
0.0205000099,
0.0003797171,
0.0005494553,
0.0527656414,
0.0157465786,
-0.0094135962,
0.0624165051,
-0.010796749,
-0.0353780016,
0.0434681363,
0.0343703888,
0.038790457,
-0.0474389158,
0.0008675547,
0.015511537,
0.0014711794,
0.0152071649,
0.0238236394,
-0.0150032351,
-0.029527558,
0.0666914508,
0.0347943455,
0.0033558698,
0.0569454469,
0.0284614451,
-0.0085455645,
0.0151965953,
0.0015303561,
-0.0464084148,
0.0070389025,
-0.042414099,
-0.0019976634,
0.0003964242,
0.0390556119,
-0.0018448128,
-0.0390891246,
-0.0259996783,
-0.0080426168,
0.00948756,
0.0031793977,
0.040642377,
0.0162860528,
-0.0282050278,
0.0763505176,
0.0495945327,
-0.0696510449,
-0.0087450966,
-0.0485105962,
0.0161830485,
0.0409857593,
0.0623200536,
-0.0469896011,
-0.0655426383,
0.0044516139,
-0.0181456897,
0.0303790979,
0.050554622,
-0.0205265898,
0.0024470156,
-0.0320802629,
-0.0277058594,
-0.0227956753,
0.034075357,
0.0020541768,
0.0367682464,
-0.019796228,
0.026299892,
-0.0226687137,
-0.0106781758,
0.0250907782,
-0.046434205,
-0.010289262,
0.0265112314,
0.0205766521,
-0.0027043868,
-0.0112599479,
-0.017595062,
0.0035167951,
-0.0046523483,
-0.0150760757,
-0.0638188645,
-0.0021559275,
0.0014999484,
-0.0406638645,
0.0638264269,
0.005660661,
-0.0314369537,
0.0335582905,
-0.0457673483,
-0.0172380675,
0.0274771452,
-0.027909115,
0.0456895195,
-0.0422064587,
0.0436677597,
-0.0081760781,
-0.0010236556,
-0.0114413518,
0.0476925448,
-0.0416329168,
-0.025993159,
0.0176106542,
-0.0042779082,
0.0106623704,
-0.0005289912,
-0.0356022976,
0.0015029199,
0.0147573659,
-0.0192338992,
0.0045086071,
-0.0162992347,
-0.0132847773,
-0.045089867,
-0.0610487238,
-0.0048664678,
-0.026381623,
0.0006253197,
0.0199212674,
0.0226966478,
-0.0037858726,
-0.0023187746,
0.0148978056,
-0.0126078725,
-0.0453820899,
0.0286306944,
0.0206730757,
-0.0091029825,
0.0006741265,
-0.0458420813,
-0.0037183347,
-0.0210484136,
0.0619212277,
-0.0208011623,
-0.0108527979,
-0.0668904409,
0.0294163283,
-0.0735038891,
0.0245641246,
0.011504259,
-0.0390170626,
-0.0386406519,
0.0128731467,
0.1223425642,
0.0625483319,
-0.0122061316,
0.0250175521,
0.0900945812,
-0.0267843697,
-0.0046112831,
0.009748078,
-0.0185808968,
-0.0091233542,
-0.0134217311,
-0.0234763492,
0.0074844989,
0.0355770662,
-0.0023634841,
-0.0523384549,
-0.0438170657,
0.0343488082,
-0.0077562388,
-0.0188355446,
-0.0288307071,
-0.0051497067,
-0.0228654146,
-0.017945569,
-0.0535347834,
-0.029541418,
0.0604000166,
-0.0411942787,
0.0251243059,
-0.0564492419,
-0.0230108928,
-0.035821069,
0.0152705079,
-0.0038873439,
0.0390195996,
-0.0605142787,
0.0337498337,
-0.0640714243,
-0.0045207357,
0.0264041983,
-0.0227513667,
0.0402874239,
-0.0656269714,
0.0180540197,
-0.0019188529,
-0.0330763943,
-0.03126131,
-0.0544791035,
-0.0021643655,
0.0193572454,
-0.009161233,
-0.0580599271,
-0.0190206133,
-0.0212139208,
0.0293530654,
0.0761841387,
0.0021378645,
0.0162441414,
-0.0309397895,
-0.008744874,
0.0586655177,
0.0325919464,
0.0206643809,
0.0114450809,
0.0256169122,
0.0457538515,
0.0340225473,
-0.0719899684,
-0.0478281341,
-0.0029567818,
0.0207475498,
-0.0376078561,
0.0109187765,
-0.0344095565,
0.0496556386,
-0.0318346955,
0.0053581907,
0.1280474067,
0.0504193753,
0.0017627963,
0.0162965972,
-0.0487563014,
-0.0208212771,
0.0566790253,
0.0507262535,
-0.0438934937,
-0.0170443095,
0.0249319002,
-0.0100845648,
0.0034911307,
-0.0357588604,
-0.0340710655,
-0.1151302904,
0.0366758704,
0.0007906292,
-0.0037994168,
-0.0341672637,
-0.0299713369,
0.0193155073,
-0.0121762464,
0.0047537875,
0.0100137452,
0.0142509714,
-0.0191905256,
-0.0504673086,
0.0147935478,
-0.0228596125,
0.0051626144,
-0.0302866884,
0.0550404266,
0.0177678354,
0.0286842342,
-0.008924122,
-0.0489196256,
0.0211176537,
0.0347942896,
-0.0267606545,
-0.0178680494,
0.0256769266,
-0.0166639891,
-0.01202338,
0.0099972682,
0.0471839756,
0.0252321493,
-0.0430053025,
-0.0084285783,
0.0943210199,
0.0104191285,
0.0222072564,
0.0030490626,
-0.0272293929,
-0.0168413091,
0.0927109197,
0.0470799617,
-0.0348930955,
0.0259613022,
-0.0220266003,
-0.028939642,
0.0289372634,
-0.0264010392,
-0.0361659266,
-0.0309069026,
-0.0034210272,
-0.0697391033,
0.0043273177,
0.0346588492,
0.0075783301,
0.0235709641,
-0.0120738205,
0.0217603948,
-0.0311141536,
-0.0411832072,
0.0380196087,
-0.0622316785,
0.0305659063,
-0.0066970633,
0.0122107025,
0.0366135985,
-0.0185756888,
-0.0311727636,
-0.0245157871,
-0.0506893769,
-0.0716807842,
0.0108651929,
0.0264480859,
0.0110233165,
0.0487170853,
-0.0321923159,
-0.0442116112,
0.048338145,
-0.0015796353,
-0.0217237454,
0.0546962656,
0.0338330939,
-0.0141133098,
-0.009362285,
0.0613994636,
-0.0282869916,
-0.0115921423,
0.0591180064,
0.0478443094,
-0.0216638818,
-0.0183134507,
0.0173796974,
0.022670202,
0.0549770482,
0.0230352525,
0.0044256384,
-0.0590088293,
0.0582726337,
-0.058765009,
-0.0383413807,
-0.0333350524,
0.002257088,
0.0029665676,
0.0035991385,
-0.0182447154,
0.0012975718,
-0.0168703869,
0.0362294093,
-0.0025881582,
-0.0160007924,
-0.0110651068,
-0.0066383253,
0.0276801847,
0.0321803764,
-0.0084845359,
0.0217483658,
0.0071752314,
-0.0053565605,
-0.0416170619,
0.029279191,
0.0237378757,
-0.0216572247,
-0.0880649909,
0.0350349136,
-0.0522828028,
-0.0039777444,
-0.0024568748,
0.0642572194,
0.0348215103,
-0.0282941721,
0.0042454773,
-0.0340906866,
-0.0603064261,
-0.0156555492,
0.028983172,
0.0094661005,
-0.0296599697,
0.0263799764,
0.007148766,
-0.0171351004,
0.0530704409,
0.0479243584,
-0.0268352479,
0.1017014533,
-0.0340881869,
-0.0114983208,
-0.0362271108,
-0.0541801415,
0.0181601513,
0.0070008473,
-0.0590479448,
0.0354728326,
-0.0836006925,
-0.0974658728,
0.0055083442,
0.004074065,
-0.0551746674,
0.018344678,
-0.0051476108,
0.0556450039,
-0.0242586192,
0.0089691468,
-0.0145511571,
0.013328407,
0.0156363659,
-0.0297573525,
0.0109531004,
-6.958054487e-33,
0.0029766154,
0.0021778697,
0.0187321957,
0.0003771744,
-0.0190096553,
0.0164554566,
-0.0277952608,
0.0131983273,
-0.0137468288,
0.0098511055,
-0.0162515398,
0.0131845474,
-0.0081895562,
0.0161472932,
-0.0344884843,
-0.0039158226,
0.0738020912,
0.009299472,
-0.0371821485,
-0.0254637357,
0.0342729352,
0.0237789098,
0.0867311656,
-0.0431652218,
0.0361813493,
0.02510285,
0.0070843175,
0.0723761693,
-0.0369213782,
0.0341636539,
-0.0144729381,
0.0217332132,
-0.0010938867,
-0.0393185243,
-0.0130032562,
-0.0289956853,
-0.0491655543,
-0.0040072058,
0.0338764526,
0.0280383471,
-0.0327860899,
-0.0467207432,
0.053558439,
0.0180281308,
-0.0220268164,
-0.026215544,
-0.0005029447,
-0.0241386406,
0.0154666454,
0.0537126549,
-0.0874547213,
0.0325475521,
0.0054773879,
-0.0232501402,
-0.0087436549,
-0.042456802,
0.0419919863,
-0.0116461115,
-0.0662045181,
-0.007481325,
0.0093702506,
0.0432898365,
0.056518957,
-0.024785798,
-0.0106070489,
0.0546015836,
-0.0012359334,
-0.0209247991,
-0.019144699,
-0.0031175285,
0.0385257117,
0.0372932367,
0.0604161024,
0.0705299675,
0.008640823,
-0.0124436542,
-0.0643894151,
-0.0075957282,
-0.0050708917,
0.0447516441,
-0.0117652547,
0.0325355679,
0.0004965668,
-0.001880415,
-0.068238914,
0.0070117498,
-0.0661675483,
0.0059998604,
-0.0016452868,
0.0360081829,
-0.0590024516,
-0.0188336298,
0.0016900412,
-0.0376160182,
0.0287168343,
0.0063468143,
0.0085532144,
0.0149513017,
0.0069523645,
0.0140548088,
-0.0275285784,
0.019272361,
0.0294944029,
-0.0264520105,
-0.0158542618,
0.00027465,
0.0701691434,
0.052058924,
-0.0605094098,
0.0154283298,
-0.0027523756,
-0.0195240341,
-0.0103395991,
0.0143809058,
0.0201343428,
0.0286843479,
-0.0001593332,
0.0192109738,
0.0546140037,
0.0654405504,
-0.0221180562,
-0.0169726778,
0.0198260564,
0.0089434478,
-0.0075678932,
0.0254195556,
0.008031873,
0.0142310178,
0.0306526795,
-0.0581956357,
-0.0090973312,
0.0051618465,
3.108e-7,
0.0528278686,
0.059037406,
0.0185495038,
0.0015845887,
0.0093072476,
0.0411571451,
-0.0342322551,
0.0207539406,
0.0167218316,
0.0066395663,
0.0089273863,
0.0280287862,
0.0287102647,
0.0001938076,
-0.0684666634,
0.0034947675,
-0.0492710918,
-0.0091404058,
-0.0330138057,
-0.0185516495,
0.0184722543,
0.0892671123,
0.0580526814,
-0.0049224012,
-0.037543226,
-0.0296318624,
0.0638072491,
-0.014459786,
-0.0420452282,
-0.0034709452,
0.0405481495,
0.0265977997,
0.0286578517,
-0.0018980461,
-0.0484737717,
0.0711025298,
0.023464337,
0.0732772723,
-0.0133860679,
0.0333138406,
-0.0431081653,
-0.0202898048,
-0.0206717383,
-0.0150848869,
0.0866372734,
-0.0442592949,
-0.0234272908,
-0.0622285604,
-0.0113681545,
0.0423654132,
0.011056073,
-0.0312805437,
-0.0169979725,
0.0178208146,
0.0257583205,
0.0310857873,
-0.0124161746,
-0.0626772046,
-0.0168023519,
-0.0274473205,
-0.0305185802,
-0.05487765,
-0.0114428988,
-0.0314675905,
0.0774900913,
-0.0602849238,
0.0061116228,
3.23870252e-34,
0.0290505271,
0.0145311253,
0.011357489,
0.0159218349,
0.0505322255,
-0.0380665734,
-0.0131971063,
0.0134906406,
0.0101634292,
-0.0816657096,
-0.0248859394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17755v1 | CauESC: A Causal Aware Model for Emotional Support Conversation | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | Wei Chen, Hengxu Lin, Qun Zhang, Xiaojin Zhang, Xiang Bai, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Emotional Support Conversation aims at reducing the seeker's emotional
distress through supportive response. Existing approaches have two limitations:
(1) They ignore the emotion causes of the distress, which is important for
fine-grained emotion understanding; (2) They focus on the seeker's own mental
state rather than the emotional dynamics during interaction between speakers.
To address these issues, we propose a novel framework CauESC, which firstly
recognizes the emotion causes of the distress, as well as the emotion effects
triggered by the causes, and then understands each strategy of verbal grooming
independently and integrates them skillfully. Experimental results on the
benchmark dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and show the
benefits of emotion understanding from cause to effect and
independent-integrated strategy modeling. | [
0.0680900067,
-0.0022607949,
-0.0319394618,
0.0056698211,
-0.0132225631,
0.0346375033,
0.0087123876,
-0.0249297619,
0.0022120846,
-0.0397173278,
-0.0018717617,
-0.015958976,
-0.020890383,
0.0172530673,
0.0051123276,
-0.099956885,
0.0131346136,
0.0417381153,
0.0889624283,
0.0147344852,
0.0572108291,
0.0083202021,
-0.029551385,
0.0133936638,
-0.0539588109,
0.000552487,
-0.049305141,
0.0243426133,
0.0270951558,
-0.0395679288,
0.0588475354,
0.0411581546,
-0.0019146393,
-0.019945275,
0.0000021649,
-0.0221493784,
0.0037854228,
-0.0296924133,
0.0556383803,
-0.0676090717,
0.0595378131,
-0.0283115972,
0.005066575,
0.0198520813,
-0.0157660749,
0.0064169816,
0.0182244387,
0.1251804233,
0.0988965258,
0.0626934469,
-0.0438534394,
-0.0224054921,
-0.0232102294,
-0.0181817301,
-0.0228837822,
-0.0290591456,
0.0154756084,
-0.0355445407,
0.0219397917,
-0.0637827143,
-0.0208203122,
0.0000246942,
-0.0284032933,
-0.0141618354,
0.0194336977,
-0.0277658738,
0.0090569044,
-0.0511990264,
-0.0019347362,
0.0783958286,
0.0271348339,
0.0593858995,
0.0188312065,
-0.0265638381,
0.0402135402,
0.0147684738,
-0.029603608,
-0.021851439,
-0.0110042207,
-0.0086772526,
-0.0038156975,
0.0582486652,
-0.0036040873,
0.0276484787,
0.0320388824,
0.0482647493,
-0.0648047626,
-0.0400907956,
0.0205308609,
-0.0075688488,
0.0380323194,
-0.0421792157,
-0.0054653264,
0.0480629727,
-0.0667216554,
0.0221916307,
-0.0092119062,
0.0134300571,
-0.0274829604,
-0.037111029,
0.0125396177,
0.0273679048,
-0.0371126868,
-0.0044876537,
0.0429848135,
-0.0016469506,
0.0008357881,
-0.0692915767,
0.0173986051,
0.0360943116,
-0.0532794781,
-0.0051595918,
-0.0358226486,
-0.0101814028,
-0.0780681893,
-0.0353341475,
-0.0372822843,
0.0196741428,
-0.0590411425,
-0.0099752266,
-0.0345342532,
-0.0020623724,
0.0032997096,
0.0554180518,
0.0111805489,
0.0249183811,
-0.0409535132,
0.0218080133,
0.0413165689,
-0.088623926,
0.0094311656,
0.0053603579,
0.0232894532,
-0.0250886157,
-0.0024194196,
0.0148377214,
0.0046106619,
-0.0129295858,
-0.0383478515,
-0.0332733132,
-0.0324180126,
-0.0593621209,
-0.0034583097,
-0.0084501738,
0.0251466222,
-0.0254079569,
0.0086794887,
-0.0102253314,
0.0275733266,
-0.0377835557,
-0.0733954757,
0.054186698,
-0.0074399468,
0.0185034648,
0.0014411877,
0.0603470504,
0.0513273068,
0.0636169016,
-0.0221719816,
0.0381678045,
0.0330565572,
-0.0410283953,
0.0294753052,
-0.0093866913,
0.0010601063,
-0.0363272689,
-0.005803226,
-0.0318680555,
-0.0029307415,
0.04346288,
0.0256357286,
-0.0075131613,
-0.0088271322,
0.0207475908,
0.0192196686,
0.024315564,
-0.0037003702,
0.0533588231,
0.0014076948,
0.0354319587,
0.0032741877,
0.0097078513,
-0.0326381214,
0.0186528377,
-0.0372361019,
-0.022065036,
0.0062029422,
-0.0249575227,
-0.0517445952,
-0.0576645136,
-0.0122916643,
-0.0343336165,
-0.0304979477,
0.0116311628,
0.0018762314,
-0.0207029469,
0.0066925888,
-0.0204619989,
0.0243508499,
-0.0392903052,
-0.022511404,
-0.0184206981,
-0.0037439526,
0.0864329338,
0.0198038314,
-0.0344143808,
-0.0413633548,
-0.0275461953,
0.0192334317,
0.0110975672,
0.0478051268,
-0.0032926314,
0.0421031639,
-0.0278778877,
-0.0236416217,
0.0118599022,
0.0209579431,
-0.0004489703,
-0.0427366123,
0.0068410421,
-0.0401063412,
0.0940831602,
0.0096524302,
0.0365372673,
0.0076857316,
0.0023931516,
-0.0318053104,
0.0014978433,
0.0632864907,
0.0405827314,
-0.0315815173,
-0.0266087502,
0.0167787019,
-0.0299968477,
-0.016756909,
0.0747705847,
-0.0148958825,
0.006978014,
0.0028740345,
-0.0001707385,
-0.0528723784,
0.0003716031,
-0.0496838056,
-0.0450488925,
0.06529513,
-0.0261483118,
0.0351081938,
-0.0065058256,
0.0120268436,
-0.0137635572,
0.0160751995,
0.0184804332,
0.0088366093,
-0.0034696234,
0.0080388086,
-0.0344632305,
-0.0205394533,
-0.0190947317,
-0.0733020678,
-0.0211742576,
-0.0116447778,
0.0019501901,
-0.0481935143,
-0.0007343572,
0.0060501834,
-0.0679456443,
-0.0336091705,
-0.1006129459,
-0.010195083,
-0.0075227227,
-0.0162745342,
0.0063775135,
0.0124925617,
-0.0358159542,
-0.0381046571,
-0.0415586531,
0.0087496713,
0.0409264378,
-0.0107906861,
-0.0042576184,
0.0208274163,
-0.0090281814,
-0.0827234834,
0.0236898977,
-0.0158312842,
-0.0214353036,
0.01150552,
-0.0627890453,
-0.0335333124,
0.0166124944,
-0.0519418381,
0.0494674891,
-0.0360705517,
-0.073740527,
-0.0222682264,
-0.0136986719,
0.0098307459,
0.0372042507,
0.0519965068,
0.0629283041,
-0.0189062096,
-0.0063374098,
-0.0545218773,
0.0407598577,
-0.0320747383,
0.056099847,
-0.0652317852,
-0.0519334711,
-0.0196180809,
0.0577818826,
0.0012212,
0.0423817858,
-0.0550970733,
-0.0377304181,
0.0519443564,
-0.0578945391,
-0.0508793481,
-0.0124776158,
-0.0003650807,
-0.0037898277,
-0.0069455681,
-0.0622680411,
0.0356554277,
0.0313909426,
-0.0434746444,
-0.003863038,
-0.0180010013,
0.003876538,
0.0642446503,
-0.0254296754,
0.0076643862,
0.0430058837,
-0.0174347125,
-0.0016514499,
-0.0780231282,
-0.0109297121,
-0.032015726,
-0.05501635,
-0.0550415441,
-0.0128671853,
0.0616329685,
-0.0104968837,
-0.0462345928,
-0.0392548032,
-0.044342503,
0.0080287103,
-0.007886366,
-0.0081234938,
-0.0404008217,
-0.0189679973,
0.0540929958,
0.0250139385,
-0.0079648765,
-0.0163713377,
0.0039981832,
0.0269814488,
0.0646104813,
-0.0072421995,
0.0396880656,
-0.0101992767,
0.0506690219,
0.0604204722,
0.0206509773,
-0.0074014296,
0.0399169326,
0.0120837195,
-0.0049311304,
0.0167160574,
-0.0094773192,
-0.0175057296,
0.0347684175,
0.0002519165,
-0.0143562928,
0.1249013767,
0.0193335637,
-0.0113262683,
0.0119998464,
-0.053328868,
0.0055846651,
0.0190036744,
0.0148378778,
-0.0367135555,
0.0155864786,
-0.0059665046,
0.0371678621,
-0.012141278,
-0.0142373117,
0.0096230069,
-0.0312344022,
0.0691427439,
-0.0119514028,
-0.0050497698,
0.0223965496,
-0.015294998,
0.048381757,
0.010288558,
-0.0086164214,
-0.026391631,
0.014984794,
-0.0121907908,
0.0288319625,
-0.0297176354,
-0.0386943333,
-0.0028079099,
-0.0195856653,
0.0680440515,
0.0251532272,
0.0957758948,
0.0123205325,
-0.0013294428,
0.0241066907,
0.0384715647,
0.0104056438,
-0.0312299095,
0.0425024815,
-0.0123293726,
0.0208284706,
-0.0156191345,
0.0690909177,
-0.0241496507,
0.0344123766,
0.0292929932,
0.0221783798,
-0.0725909472,
-0.0125485193,
-0.0171598978,
0.0309916735,
0.0472650081,
0.0536728911,
0.0267748274,
-0.04838752,
-0.009113973,
0.0154681262,
0.0108943293,
0.0565330423,
-0.0356947854,
-0.0365055092,
0.0079329703,
-0.0085386466,
-0.0529666319,
-0.098593384,
0.0138375238,
0.0358775109,
-0.03013069,
-0.0326518267,
-0.043041341,
0.0163179189,
-0.0382038839,
0.0447952896,
0.0216650832,
0.0446712673,
-0.0070150904,
-0.014231205,
-0.0319491997,
-0.0252735857,
0.0074228183,
-0.0398011021,
0.0749462992,
-0.0529069565,
0.0176020078,
0.0540712662,
0.0309525654,
0.0471167006,
0.0032436377,
-0.1034934148,
-0.0297448467,
0.0164007116,
-0.030635763,
0.0277925823,
0.0220903456,
0.0184465013,
0.001887104,
0.0355950706,
0.0070087058,
0.0954772457,
-0.0052698208,
0.0121862311,
0.0118741132,
-0.0405880511,
-0.0268377624,
-0.0095996,
0.0484773703,
-0.0072246823,
-0.0292974375,
-0.0063013267,
-0.0265404992,
-0.0237909053,
0.0008894159,
-0.0619181059,
0.0152783496,
-0.0559556223,
0.0311094467,
-0.0265565161,
-0.0681978539,
-0.0653640702,
-0.0446580276,
-0.0255180579,
0.0171724651,
0.0282284282,
0.0030574568,
-0.0183390472,
0.0331801102,
0.0346490294,
-0.0071024029,
0.0118745724,
0.0267780926,
0.0033912838,
0.0932628065,
0.0426743329,
-0.0086312927,
0.0372723155,
0.0334975533,
-0.0341129303,
-0.0364941098,
0.0033385919,
-0.0011282931,
0.0205955524,
-0.0133909024,
0.0320951082,
-0.0164203327,
0.0169082098,
0.0134719508,
0.0291306134,
-0.003064946,
-0.0535470322,
0.0412914604,
0.0291498266,
-0.0309128426,
0.003725149,
-0.010945905,
-0.0476507545,
0.0544381589,
-0.0336089768,
-0.0064521022,
-0.0462353267,
0.0009821297,
0.0816962123,
0.0492934473,
-0.0248997957,
0.0341653451,
-0.0852150247,
-0.0303187016,
0.0099489558,
-0.0375600643,
0.0056145722,
-0.049440369,
0.0645657405,
-0.0052895634,
-0.0110562239,
0.0184965096,
-0.0417713411,
0.0112587363,
-0.0610933118,
-0.0257202554,
-0.0261036512,
-5.542917613e-33,
0.0172097441,
0.0004088935,
-0.0244304352,
0.0112358509,
-0.04592897,
0.0194851905,
-0.0459267311,
0.0083245048,
0.0116942655,
0.0614503585,
0.0140344705,
0.0924935788,
0.0115632778,
-0.0046587372,
0.0115041034,
0.0341876373,
0.0269922242,
-0.0104269674,
-0.0000721391,
0.0487684757,
0.0481633767,
0.0696974099,
0.0084861321,
-0.1165700629,
0.0481977761,
0.0093055218,
-0.0313789211,
0.0426826254,
0.0607440919,
0.0078102308,
-0.0074212286,
0.0122654634,
0.025429355,
0.0103150103,
0.044800356,
0.0605886169,
-0.0194832012,
-0.0284621716,
0.0207245555,
-0.0200912505,
-0.0675409809,
-0.0029575436,
-0.0316854045,
0.0117988987,
0.0250311699,
-0.0038766842,
0.0220176876,
-0.011707603,
0.0402628481,
-0.005784201,
-0.0181699153,
-0.0018939205,
-0.0392424762,
-0.0208082832,
0.0193337966,
0.0716575533,
-0.0285977442,
0.010125163,
0.0149952834,
0.0172615871,
-0.0385250002,
-0.0116616841,
-0.0000018891,
-0.0234350916,
-0.01180455,
0.0739076659,
0.0301917866,
-0.0088116536,
-0.00537366,
0.0214248579,
-0.0098773427,
0.0764204785,
0.021567205,
-0.0037125614,
-0.0463308915,
0.0103449589,
-0.0088945776,
0.0222925618,
0.0623800755,
0.0173218288,
-0.0121925883,
0.0034768994,
-0.0429530926,
0.0093795825,
-0.0200155769,
-0.0126929916,
0.0005971813,
-0.0223008823,
0.0449038222,
0.0087457113,
0.0187987983,
-0.0324750468,
-0.0140708778,
-0.0344133377,
0.0353153795,
0.007482531,
-0.0128890108,
0.0537798777,
0.0096516777,
-0.0101371286,
-0.0391518362,
-0.02794425,
0.0123375598,
-0.0034094339,
0.0573845021,
-0.0212131925,
0.0153250499,
-0.0006971209,
-0.0116184941,
-0.0190198664,
-0.0258404668,
0.1019389033,
-0.0257371366,
-0.0122731552,
-0.0314252339,
0.0216889195,
-0.034968283,
0.0232684426,
0.0377920978,
0.0363092385,
-0.0293584727,
-0.0334803127,
-0.0073157721,
0.037573576,
-0.0436058864,
-0.0264014248,
-0.0180014577,
-0.0167391375,
0.0146922441,
-0.0055310023,
-0.0082376339,
-0.0151258307,
2.833e-7,
-0.0409522392,
0.0241479483,
0.03112364,
-0.0226390697,
0.0620845892,
0.0250519793,
0.0041709235,
0.0475321002,
0.019366201,
-0.0252709128,
0.0412338972,
0.0278935097,
0.0491201319,
-0.023439195,
-0.0459910706,
-0.042857606,
-0.000116096,
-0.0663523003,
-0.0019997898,
0.0066794311,
0.057323996,
0.037626382,
0.045752909,
0.0004336179,
0.005156274,
0.076716654,
0.0281043481,
-0.0488734506,
0.0324004702,
0.0353389569,
-0.010480226,
-0.0539749488,
-0.0202360954,
-0.0009065382,
0.0014343481,
0.0452803895,
-0.0539121516,
0.0807440057,
-0.0390055217,
-0.0294732079,
0.0140566593,
0.0498282649,
-0.0241019614,
-0.028016042,
-0.0035915861,
-0.0894399956,
-0.0475620925,
-0.01618357,
-0.0386691727,
-0.0138025992,
-0.0318091437,
0.0305507295,
-0.0335540436,
0.0546416901,
-0.0195198152,
-0.015052001,
-0.0017718411,
-0.0782970563,
0.0250231251,
0.030952571,
-0.0225877725,
-0.0405036025,
-0.031744983,
0.0571459047,
-0.0110176215,
-0.0360864624,
-0.0030452765,
1.686504589e-34,
0.0176146701,
0.0281715859,
-0.0149678644,
0.0277415756,
0.0227965973,
0.0147101274,
-0.0762282088,
0.0262717512,
0.0544509776,
-0.0406716205,
0.0075296382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17716v1 | Enhancing Large Language Model with Decomposed Reasoning for Emotion Cause Pair Extraction | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | Jialiang Wu, Yi Shen, Ziheng Zhang, Longjun Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction (ECPE) involves extracting clause pairs
representing emotions and their causes in a document. Existing methods tend to
overfit spurious correlations, such as positional bias in existing benchmark
datasets, rather than capturing semantic features. Inspired by recent work, we
explore leveraging large language model (LLM) to address ECPE task without
additional training. Despite strong capabilities, LLMs suffer from
uncontrollable outputs, resulting in mediocre performance. To address this, we
introduce chain-of-thought to mimic human cognitive process and propose the
Decomposed Emotion-Cause Chain (DECC) framework. Combining inducing inference
and logical pruning, DECC guides LLMs to tackle ECPE task. We further enhance
the framework by incorporating in-context learning. Experiment results
demonstrate the strength of DECC compared to state-of-the-art supervised
fine-tuning methods. Finally, we analyze the effectiveness of each component
and the robustness of the method in various scenarios, including different LLM
bases, rebalanced datasets, and multi-pair extraction. | [
0.0139949042,
0.1291118711,
0.0032461029,
0.0592853017,
-0.0080098454,
0.0500371978,
-0.0041251224,
0.0032562956,
0.0422301181,
-0.0397293679,
-0.0235454272,
0.0346691534,
-0.0401687548,
0.0025871871,
-0.0028432445,
-0.0622998737,
0.007278332,
0.0269272123,
0.0586291775,
-0.0056499965,
0.0146167763,
0.0570570119,
0.0092949802,
-0.0016844845,
-0.0398654342,
-0.0583948381,
-0.0112769697,
0.0414933898,
0.0385937914,
-0.0182839632,
0.0009260773,
0.0204243623,
0.0323423408,
-0.0011466331,
0.0000022915,
-0.0398926809,
-0.0310583133,
-0.0219681524,
-0.0056881211,
-0.0063540004,
0.0317475274,
-0.0076611619,
-0.0118072918,
-0.0061441879,
-0.0139372358,
-0.0187172107,
-0.014898967,
0.0997801721,
0.0771218762,
0.1177940443,
-0.0408663303,
-0.0397556536,
-0.0149289295,
-0.0182474703,
0.025717916,
-0.0235976242,
0.0459693931,
-0.0086427219,
-0.0039786049,
-0.0366789848,
-0.002682033,
-0.0244533587,
0.019581778,
-0.0005165901,
-0.0182606112,
0.0095036253,
-0.0275013819,
-0.0317415781,
-0.0014262581,
0.0879629478,
-0.0278158486,
-0.0060576471,
0.0273053534,
-0.0161294583,
0.010547664,
0.0032456173,
-0.0189987868,
0.0242269263,
-0.0266388115,
0.038396176,
0.0619219691,
-0.004560695,
0.0282704886,
0.0314935111,
-0.0481394008,
0.0363779813,
-0.0148801906,
-0.0326592699,
0.040370699,
0.0166098047,
-0.0473530367,
-0.0184698738,
0.0095956987,
-0.0011885994,
-0.0283021238,
0.032265,
-0.0246826373,
-0.0380558893,
-0.0411448926,
-0.0473709516,
-0.0346855223,
0.018035559,
-0.0026286384,
0.0670597181,
-0.0159571655,
0.0049662134,
-0.0199936647,
0.0105349608,
-0.0403078496,
-0.0086170221,
-0.0332443379,
0.0109291794,
-0.0073601189,
0.0279675927,
-0.0548833869,
-0.0431332402,
-0.0352299549,
-0.0008207866,
-0.0136689134,
0.0157297347,
0.0096897418,
0.0026077984,
0.001112978,
-0.0256639048,
0.0003519269,
0.014033596,
-0.040206857,
0.0376151726,
0.0270263478,
-0.0218979754,
-0.0104728388,
0.0049518985,
0.017906284,
-0.0184562206,
0.0377836339,
0.0066431235,
0.0036403809,
-0.0171989296,
-0.0440554246,
-0.0457518138,
-0.0096183317,
-0.0380779281,
-0.0042337119,
-0.0506558269,
0.0335129611,
0.0022170388,
0.0072371084,
-0.0468505248,
0.0302748624,
-0.015938621,
-0.0684878826,
0.0655731931,
0.0022141803,
-0.0188013073,
-0.0119983908,
0.0122496653,
0.0246200599,
0.0506135412,
0.0362375379,
0.0838107839,
0.0505046695,
0.0185235683,
0.0058458499,
0.0151033485,
0.0169199761,
-0.0265155807,
-0.0175004825,
-0.0359492265,
-0.0016630808,
0.0341713689,
0.0493752137,
0.0325890295,
-0.0341782793,
0.0183000825,
0.0139900828,
0.0279187802,
-0.0043105492,
0.0608228371,
-0.0058596251,
0.0184047408,
0.0038299719,
-0.0241802782,
-0.0263833255,
0.0099915219,
-0.0071520936,
-0.004679353,
0.0109954011,
0.0157387592,
-0.0254756827,
-0.0437103622,
-0.0082861586,
-0.0242476892,
-0.034158919,
0.016881356,
0.0478170924,
0.0105675077,
-0.0608925186,
0.0106394272,
0.03360245,
-0.0805506259,
-0.0374449603,
-0.0154984128,
0.0288745351,
0.0335695818,
0.0401195809,
-0.0557760298,
-0.022276314,
-0.0224834923,
-0.0118141593,
0.0234376378,
0.0061698146,
-0.014297273,
0.0300562419,
-0.05013052,
0.0073440652,
-0.0212374236,
0.0090059806,
-0.0173152015,
-0.0329338759,
-0.0177645069,
0.003865246,
-0.0065020383,
0.006534942,
0.0245590266,
-0.03967648,
-0.0260716416,
0.0018394396,
0.0436355025,
0.0472246483,
-0.0046357922,
0.0035462836,
-0.0074054664,
0.0246292017,
-0.0531764552,
-0.0241578817,
0.0352333598,
-0.0288409982,
-0.0851908401,
0.0378172472,
-0.0166826677,
-0.0455955453,
0.0190978348,
-0.0721642077,
-0.010352321,
0.0155059919,
0.0167665984,
0.0151647404,
-0.0118986294,
0.0153783904,
0.0125977136,
0.011573107,
-0.0142213553,
0.0874392986,
-0.0009320005,
-0.023399774,
0.0012163264,
-0.0070234304,
-0.000644653,
0.027153112,
-0.0273130517,
0.0087057529,
0.0176127031,
-0.0254060198,
0.0126344357,
-0.0215350371,
-0.0769300386,
-0.0676673651,
-0.0795309618,
0.0118498644,
0.0124846697,
0.0150865987,
0.0106080826,
-0.0152208498,
-0.0226810593,
0.0197427794,
-0.0199817494,
0.0121013159,
0.0167006478,
-0.011939452,
0.0288388282,
-0.031538289,
0.0089481333,
-0.0578287952,
0.0313453861,
-0.0519504175,
0.0502207167,
-0.0050089294,
0.0020506964,
-0.01919006,
0.1032725126,
-0.0178959984,
0.0218384806,
-0.0067648347,
-0.0335714258,
0.0009092567,
-0.044315923,
0.0165970717,
0.1209107786,
-0.0241277851,
0.0646603331,
0.0034551586,
-0.015546211,
-0.052948691,
0.0490550473,
-0.0392781459,
0.0284586083,
-0.0186580084,
-0.0101606185,
-0.0339398533,
0.0747116953,
-0.0303259324,
0.0009565938,
-0.0361822732,
0.0295727607,
0.0162278898,
-0.0191364903,
-0.0419845581,
-0.0580602027,
0.0050463695,
0.0371501483,
-0.0368196629,
-0.0452891961,
0.0461176969,
0.0266357604,
-0.004860363,
-0.0738109276,
0.0340377763,
-0.0556062646,
0.1045584679,
-0.0182513539,
-0.0091375094,
-0.0023022515,
0.0202525351,
-0.0399314538,
-0.0382917784,
-0.0140576353,
-0.0220524576,
0.0315166228,
-0.052738186,
-0.0156245036,
0.0146777863,
-0.0669083148,
-0.0355106778,
-0.04970612,
-0.05660595,
-0.0332260802,
-0.0031800491,
-0.0171307996,
0.0120702228,
-0.0590719916,
0.0360001661,
-0.0417843834,
0.0056881988,
-0.0295379851,
0.00290383,
0.030626446,
0.0678768009,
-0.0267401859,
0.0218637269,
-0.0328466073,
0.0619962253,
0.0572634228,
0.0371635519,
0.0171281621,
-0.0334501639,
0.0291614663,
-0.006263854,
0.0404525325,
-0.0145550165,
-0.0414079763,
0.0004584129,
-0.0536518879,
0.0126913972,
0.1229227111,
0.0253235102,
-0.0549174771,
0.0037839888,
-0.0230398234,
0.0412156247,
0.0193051472,
0.0284246728,
-0.0517637283,
-0.0432405211,
0.0107518593,
-0.0173043236,
0.0161589831,
-0.0429219529,
0.012258634,
-0.1218667775,
0.0222501252,
0.0037243033,
0.0234072246,
-0.00515584,
-0.0382581092,
0.0222803392,
-0.0061595202,
-0.0446520001,
-0.0174388122,
0.0137170535,
-0.0016993388,
0.0036734948,
-0.0140690906,
-0.0418561473,
0.0291002318,
-0.0162943508,
0.0243976936,
0.0311206114,
0.0925337225,
0.0137348287,
-0.0341707207,
0.0614652485,
-0.014961171,
-0.0055506979,
-0.0115484502,
0.0447524972,
-0.0328118429,
-0.0169289019,
-0.042488154,
0.0844586641,
-0.0544632412,
-0.0073833233,
-0.0155660463,
0.0927731842,
0.0009113277,
-0.0305645652,
-0.0136466539,
-0.0049705761,
-0.0253712777,
0.0682865754,
0.0393693335,
-0.0408052653,
-0.0383763388,
-0.0159487557,
0.0004850957,
-0.0102267954,
-0.0186384618,
-0.0245815478,
-0.0111524751,
-0.0052729435,
-0.079958804,
-0.0545492545,
0.0353103764,
0.0285363793,
-0.0188164618,
-0.0084422957,
-0.0002212555,
-0.0075770267,
-0.0143694784,
0.0528020337,
0.0204304904,
-0.0014431196,
0.013769296,
0.0325411297,
0.0119511429,
0.0023175047,
-0.0119295996,
0.0081391158,
-0.0506866314,
-0.043119695,
0.0003997881,
0.0291911587,
0.0099674501,
0.0661250129,
-0.0103057735,
-0.0267880876,
-0.0206253193,
0.0649441704,
-0.0076322812,
-0.0110027036,
0.0442147925,
0.0383835733,
0.0110451216,
0.0383355469,
-0.0260259099,
0.0442820899,
0.0408780426,
0.03170361,
-0.0257284585,
-0.0410421155,
0.0336888433,
0.0396781899,
0.0617484152,
0.003448654,
-0.0347042531,
-0.0520916544,
-0.0156849027,
-0.0450593084,
-0.0270920452,
-0.0556720421,
0.0405965187,
0.0229320619,
0.0041971081,
-0.0610301308,
-0.0566234253,
0.0405721292,
0.0122868689,
0.0153078409,
0.0340929329,
0.0146808159,
0.0191552527,
0.0065132375,
0.0033881245,
-0.0058049206,
0.0059263231,
0.0152018275,
0.0222142301,
-0.0281764288,
0.0547372922,
0.0568495244,
-0.0266672354,
-0.0048633032,
-0.0082623186,
-0.0216759387,
-0.0147844963,
0.018790355,
-0.0305489544,
0.0549327284,
-0.0424683392,
0.0599272437,
-0.0380521193,
0.0065989997,
0.0293752309,
0.0325448699,
0.02383673,
-0.018949382,
0.0047614546,
0.0139988065,
-0.0324699022,
-0.0031067247,
0.0317299441,
-0.0786396563,
0.0680940226,
0.0201730411,
-0.0076189209,
-0.0509026721,
-0.0152837178,
0.0362493992,
-0.0067407265,
-0.0087619685,
0.0416483618,
-0.0667613596,
-0.050090868,
0.0099049387,
-0.0263909791,
0.0022227867,
-0.0237722714,
0.0207410119,
0.0818686262,
-0.0178699717,
0.0123695163,
-0.0242970418,
0.0315341316,
-0.0606995784,
-0.0647920147,
-0.022351265,
-6.181443573e-33,
0.0010483694,
-0.0074726203,
-0.021791324,
0.0257153362,
-0.0366115905,
0.0241772439,
-0.0465134196,
0.0029963027,
0.0012056857,
0.0739683658,
-0.03291234,
0.0294976085,
-0.0031728959,
0.0108561441,
-0.0157395247,
-0.0109916106,
0.0334323235,
0.0029471198,
0.0039146943,
0.016682798,
0.0742252022,
0.052945938,
0.0252018906,
-0.1135499477,
-0.0190417171,
0.0050717448,
-0.031942945,
0.0055676959,
0.0258762669,
0.0229938347,
-0.0083418693,
0.0079627223,
0.0157257598,
-0.0123619121,
0.0151522579,
0.0483310223,
-0.0384715833,
-0.0130577367,
-0.0029916295,
-0.0286936071,
-0.0439072847,
-0.0542871356,
0.0048259124,
0.0273742508,
0.0046756119,
-0.0289454125,
0.0195531808,
-0.0355989449,
-0.0064641498,
-0.0835628062,
-0.0499231815,
0.031243043,
-0.023351118,
-0.0097684087,
0.0219881069,
0.0223648194,
-0.0208097231,
0.0547035187,
-0.0302830096,
-0.0111303693,
-0.007315882,
0.0110541461,
0.00059297,
-0.0296010952,
0.006152743,
0.1061734706,
-0.0031259372,
0.0201854501,
-0.0484244674,
0.0483725481,
0.0136907101,
0.070903331,
0.0375742689,
0.056557022,
0.0283388272,
0.0021323578,
-0.0884765238,
0.0236354321,
0.0385145992,
0.0335997865,
0.0452712737,
0.014794643,
0.0032683411,
0.0144483279,
-0.0121539505,
0.0230313055,
-0.021286048,
-0.0054632742,
0.0127623174,
0.0137302633,
-0.0226682685,
-0.0231723096,
-0.011648274,
-0.0294662323,
0.003557116,
0.0656451657,
-0.0281761233,
0.0322463699,
0.0059023737,
0.0114257801,
-0.0499771833,
-0.0176035054,
0.0137548652,
0.025584219,
0.0701448843,
0.034920834,
0.0461426973,
-0.029518215,
-0.0480310358,
-0.0118119521,
-0.0635923445,
0.0118330009,
-0.0526501946,
0.0184754394,
-0.0201930068,
0.0386125855,
-0.0117421616,
0.0087543605,
0.0209624972,
0.0539416447,
0.0013006475,
0.0095680729,
-0.0055241222,
0.0245291069,
-0.011705867,
-0.0366419367,
0.0015419695,
-0.0275601745,
0.0176639669,
-0.0676020458,
-0.0178734493,
-0.0064112116,
2.964e-7,
0.0164729282,
0.0520422347,
0.0312525257,
-0.0069877328,
0.0175196752,
0.0577711463,
0.0002995878,
0.0006020723,
0.0504616052,
-0.025086062,
0.0332190543,
0.021573171,
0.0766868293,
-0.0061729802,
-0.1044258103,
-0.00366621,
-0.0212202761,
-0.0337771326,
-0.0532427356,
-0.0059277317,
0.0894417316,
0.0986240283,
0.0562080704,
-0.0203536879,
0.0172175504,
0.040034391,
0.0462650917,
-0.0543719269,
-0.0294700675,
0.0209778808,
-0.0150507465,
-0.0538510568,
-0.0191704147,
0.0109064858,
-0.0066496227,
0.0149072492,
-0.0056444793,
0.0638261437,
0.0274342299,
-0.0096455254,
0.0193143003,
0.0072166743,
0.0134054488,
-0.0620461479,
0.0589250289,
-0.0506422557,
-0.0404776894,
-0.0218608249,
-0.0482072495,
-0.0015462345,
0.0163548272,
-0.0061701788,
-0.0278927833,
0.0110641439,
0.0029727749,
-0.0267665181,
-0.0169572588,
-0.1084487066,
-0.0204013903,
0.0163152814,
-0.0257309098,
-0.0219506752,
-0.0104781557,
0.0503778756,
0.0474315993,
-0.0611233301,
-0.0175123513,
2.975447576e-34,
0.0101642171,
0.0117500061,
-0.0079728281,
0.0363268442,
0.0786251426,
-0.0011355834,
-0.0635855272,
0.02398449,
0.0308279898,
-0.08235614,
0.0297002774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17703v1 | WSC+: Enhancing The Winograd Schema Challenge Using Tree-of-Experts | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | Pardis Sadat Zahraei, Ali Emami | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; K.4.1 | The Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC) serves as a prominent benchmark for
evaluating machine understanding. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at
answering WSC questions, their ability to generate such questions remains less
explored. In this work, we propose Tree-of-Experts (ToE), a novel prompting
method which enhances the generation of WSC instances (50% valid cases vs. 10%
in recent methods). Using this approach, we introduce WSC+, a novel dataset
comprising 3,026 LLM-generated sentences. Notably, we extend the WSC framework
by incorporating new 'ambiguous' and 'offensive' categories, providing a deeper
insight into model overconfidence and bias. Our analysis reveals nuances in
generation-evaluation consistency, suggesting that LLMs may not always
outperform in evaluating their own generated questions when compared to those
crafted by other models. On WSC+, GPT-4, the top-performing LLM, achieves an
accuracy of 68.7%, significantly below the human benchmark of 95.1%. | [
0.0736180097,
0.0751573071,
-0.0221042167,
0.0480268225,
-0.0556027144,
0.0174662601,
0.0032873133,
-0.0357213654,
0.0249709617,
-0.0409651026,
-0.0065886006,
-0.0618743077,
-0.0160866734,
0.0401765183,
0.0161746982,
-0.0311931949,
0.0673163831,
-0.0406950973,
0.0118276188,
-0.0081234835,
-0.0013673285,
0.0204597805,
0.001277908,
0.0293768905,
-0.0297267009,
-0.0258121789,
-0.0285809264,
0.0181931015,
0.0033280067,
-0.0519672036,
0.0250521507,
0.0781406537,
0.0158160795,
0.070974648,
0.0000021843,
-0.0709988773,
-0.0292409044,
-0.0141570885,
-0.0412895568,
-0.0118201245,
0.0478109121,
-0.016170973,
0.0237914659,
0.0132466117,
-0.0451670513,
0.0183788948,
0.0233009029,
0.071910657,
0.069094114,
0.1074215099,
0.0036626577,
-0.0244199224,
0.0130255353,
-0.012044359,
0.0104620606,
-0.0595664494,
-0.0140230656,
0.0197044332,
-0.0366038047,
0.0049397307,
0.0000859836,
0.0073164506,
0.0244584586,
-0.0077570574,
-0.0016474434,
0.0122323232,
-0.0480927378,
-0.0336618721,
-0.0145323174,
0.0857759491,
-0.0105650667,
-0.0177091248,
-0.0173175167,
-0.0076483213,
-0.0004247903,
-0.0024872513,
-0.011208646,
0.0355076119,
-0.0256409887,
0.0040082107,
0.0293879118,
-0.0052037598,
0.0183993913,
0.0125659704,
-0.0051830509,
0.0807079151,
0.0071452931,
-0.0442527831,
0.0327549987,
-0.0156850833,
-0.0463192537,
-0.0829969868,
-0.0160926953,
0.0242988281,
-0.083998546,
0.0353238285,
-0.0479993597,
0.0191203263,
0.0432730615,
-0.0346721672,
0.055267103,
0.0254339259,
-0.0100079849,
0.033286605,
0.0170936212,
0.0500854403,
0.0164680984,
-0.018554993,
-0.051019337,
-0.0267121848,
-0.0413342007,
-0.0223339889,
-0.0370393358,
0.0094292182,
-0.0483991913,
0.0002385864,
-0.0299346708,
0.0047523179,
-0.0135356886,
0.0087392554,
0.0316019803,
0.051570788,
-0.0165556222,
-0.000378032,
-0.0456996746,
0.0023487427,
-0.0365246162,
0.0142303528,
-0.0159114581,
-0.0437734611,
-0.0062204385,
0.0387484431,
-0.0315614343,
-0.0180323571,
0.0199627057,
0.0569101721,
-0.009327936,
-0.0231947303,
-0.0254477598,
-0.0495854616,
-0.0354092345,
-0.0714635551,
-0.0009054566,
-0.055164054,
0.0255200099,
0.0086511355,
-0.0174579769,
-0.0447137617,
0.0162831955,
0.0378863364,
-0.0215451308,
0.0548504218,
-0.0332330018,
0.0098109758,
0.0339347981,
0.023405401,
-0.0571564473,
0.0644054487,
0.0115006929,
0.0499253906,
0.0362565592,
0.0208263472,
0.0173459668,
0.0327616297,
-0.0076858136,
-0.0031606941,
-0.0003849419,
0.0525795147,
-0.0483986549,
0.0336937495,
0.0191817321,
0.0615344457,
0.0092433495,
-0.0147185829,
0.0425674878,
0.0291381534,
-0.038864851,
0.0065133912,
0.0547987372,
0.0193648729,
0.0147786662,
0.0159518328,
-0.0702937916,
-0.0152163347,
-0.0512894094,
-0.0092249727,
-0.0514127575,
0.0216326769,
0.0030383207,
-0.0526499078,
-0.0314261951,
0.024409702,
-0.0085456222,
0.0124784438,
0.0244008321,
0.0075787865,
-0.0349090248,
0.0368821546,
0.0096165519,
-0.0521353818,
-0.0133815892,
-0.0389769897,
0.0352841951,
0.0438562967,
0.0490819775,
-0.0296421032,
-0.0403136611,
0.0008951307,
0.0038990923,
0.0673470423,
0.0364178009,
-0.038770318,
0.017395217,
-0.033048261,
-0.0237618163,
-0.0419225171,
0.042116195,
0.0041572601,
0.0305428114,
-0.0369455367,
0.0389324427,
-0.0759897083,
-0.0707569271,
0.0509844385,
-0.0155286659,
-0.0348556638,
-0.0031415967,
0.0022761044,
0.0185860824,
0.0045722928,
-0.0254899077,
0.0128360018,
0.0120549062,
-0.0351269618,
-0.0243507773,
-0.0117753698,
-0.0667959601,
-0.0304544643,
0.0305493977,
-0.0403765626,
-0.0459655263,
0.0310914069,
-0.0433495343,
-0.0299679451,
-0.0042410423,
-0.0126382643,
-0.0000558477,
-0.0608622991,
0.0194945708,
0.0093404735,
-0.0079200985,
-0.0496042334,
0.1092228666,
-0.006893727,
-0.0072626197,
0.0396374986,
-0.0341983698,
0.0398256108,
-0.0152635165,
-0.0170644466,
0.0199258942,
-0.0085429512,
0.0042639095,
0.025644416,
0.0339218229,
-0.0865593776,
-0.0271577165,
-0.095978789,
0.0138846375,
-0.022995824,
0.0306127612,
0.0375618488,
-0.0332572982,
-0.0232269447,
0.0121310847,
-0.0630882978,
-0.0310414489,
0.0170465298,
0.0092255855,
0.0272159521,
-0.0449562334,
0.0005300441,
-0.0331284218,
-0.0037980424,
-0.0478034802,
0.0457905941,
-0.0099439984,
0.0356807448,
-0.0317923874,
0.0086645018,
-0.0394650474,
0.0053438819,
0.0073813219,
-0.0101329433,
0.0343913808,
0.0086011346,
0.0288424119,
0.0305277444,
0.0275424458,
0.0593382753,
0.0469403304,
-0.0255290233,
-0.0185992885,
0.0034934548,
0.004803,
-0.0073502725,
-0.018346915,
-0.0675980747,
0.0216495097,
0.0623715371,
0.036303997,
-0.0059435512,
-0.0243895669,
0.0437914766,
-0.0486081876,
-0.0421864428,
-0.0610209741,
-0.0379502065,
0.0087049371,
0.0667970106,
-0.0413996987,
-0.0460720919,
0.0879152492,
-0.0493688919,
0.0090318415,
-0.051500123,
-0.0081206681,
-0.0461866632,
0.1012172401,
-0.0007542392,
0.0286978334,
0.0363358073,
-0.0067783827,
-0.0715952665,
-0.0215863343,
0.001459337,
-0.0272347294,
0.0219898187,
-0.0541342832,
-0.0071756048,
0.005845319,
-0.0114722652,
-0.0753883943,
-0.0616728887,
-0.0319893025,
0.0193805676,
0.0272404216,
-0.0051370868,
-0.0086257132,
-0.0036933292,
-0.0084550707,
0.0070465622,
-0.0372878686,
-0.0103865648,
-0.0056213229,
0.0584910177,
0.0573301613,
0.014410004,
0.0297667943,
-0.0200435743,
0.044784151,
0.0356617756,
-0.0064250175,
0.0187561866,
-0.0280351564,
0.0409501754,
-0.0069557494,
-0.0184328798,
-0.0154962046,
-0.0082692131,
0.0608655028,
-0.0534647964,
-0.0121181151,
0.138689369,
0.059929356,
-0.0046973131,
0.0327638611,
-0.0375645049,
0.0266320556,
0.0435994267,
0.0278857015,
-0.0903145373,
-0.0451015346,
0.0100311181,
0.0096414685,
-0.0376983285,
-0.0523006655,
-0.0333629511,
-0.1226312965,
0.0328993462,
-0.0231653936,
-0.0283157602,
0.0109431706,
-0.0006058023,
-0.010432085,
0.0021247703,
0.0309274998,
0.0329599865,
0.0125478571,
0.0107469698,
0.0089487396,
-0.0166952424,
-0.0413222276,
0.0490590446,
-0.0136045264,
0.0476038791,
0.0566076785,
0.0209052246,
0.0194016099,
0.0054539796,
0.02551746,
-0.0298125818,
0.0093254987,
-0.0303026382,
0.0496640652,
0.0089702969,
-0.0255305301,
-0.0151563212,
0.0282442104,
-0.0335659124,
0.0166329965,
0.0459972993,
0.0656945184,
-0.0177305825,
-0.0370650589,
-0.0202453099,
-0.0132795498,
0.0133331986,
0.1050698161,
0.0293740258,
-0.009093185,
-0.0305391047,
-0.0399522297,
-0.0181645174,
-0.0036678154,
-0.0481014401,
0.0693377554,
0.0325011984,
-0.0058581824,
-0.0505292602,
-0.0739987567,
0.0535533316,
0.0159106776,
-0.0023485131,
-0.0040995358,
-0.0596458018,
0.0166548379,
-0.0433157086,
0.038444005,
-0.0259870887,
-0.0145954145,
-0.0366302282,
-0.0001397562,
0.0102257272,
-0.0231344923,
-0.0422139056,
0.0489005148,
-0.0626072735,
-0.073207967,
0.0088040596,
0.0375694409,
0.0290850233,
0.0017178844,
-0.0171553232,
-0.0332299061,
0.0064185779,
0.0385842286,
-0.018343864,
0.0059535853,
0.0259742737,
-0.0183696747,
-0.0014289467,
0.0641180947,
-0.0224097222,
0.0694498569,
-0.0082932925,
0.0693519637,
-0.0013058521,
-0.0223078579,
0.0676955879,
0.0433287807,
-0.0115762958,
-0.0341646746,
-0.0086100688,
-0.0203524549,
0.0153340083,
-0.0447627343,
-0.0449645072,
-0.0225835312,
0.0192994066,
-0.0142425839,
-0.0263940673,
-0.0024741341,
-0.0354661681,
-0.0422424302,
0.0377102047,
-0.0173622966,
-0.0036185805,
0.0536530986,
0.0149646373,
-0.0053466498,
0.0021469644,
-0.0357877128,
0.0165458601,
-0.0190343764,
0.0425805263,
0.019154096,
0.0505385995,
0.0108804945,
-0.0008954491,
-0.0234096237,
0.0173210707,
-0.0291625001,
-0.0642766654,
-0.0059569059,
0.0242413413,
0.0569119602,
-0.0082454067,
0.0397757702,
-0.0111150732,
0.011294513,
0.0025461419,
-0.0025765533,
0.0234385263,
-0.0213004909,
0.030076202,
0.0297694504,
-0.0286185518,
0.0007693052,
0.0798417181,
0.0355033726,
0.0464464873,
0.0365559198,
-0.0148536731,
-0.0543354973,
-0.0142339934,
0.0252893455,
0.0190480892,
0.0090210503,
0.0327266268,
-0.0854853988,
-0.0771793649,
0.0151853273,
0.0229265261,
0.0213785954,
-0.0001125564,
0.0434275605,
0.0926669985,
-0.0064982306,
-0.0007480232,
-0.0171429198,
0.0089709014,
-0.0079397913,
-0.0203871727,
-0.0316040665,
-6.999993187e-33,
-0.0137632927,
-0.0502862968,
0.0160275586,
-0.0472260974,
0.0047541908,
0.0020867165,
-0.0511469319,
0.0084577771,
-0.0303915534,
0.0173711479,
-0.0063998634,
0.0062396936,
0.0049387245,
0.0223594997,
0.0159403551,
-0.0233550165,
0.0374105871,
0.0098972796,
-0.0283172801,
0.0019091842,
0.0367436223,
0.0175038036,
0.0689789355,
-0.0451424383,
0.0348418541,
-0.0026259611,
-0.0385697186,
0.041621305,
-0.0123862466,
0.034121491,
-0.0367652886,
0.0833814368,
0.039703656,
-0.0132219922,
0.0149763925,
-0.0214898605,
-0.064159885,
-0.0454299524,
0.043844413,
-0.0460418761,
-0.0456653945,
-0.0255538784,
0.0315146931,
-0.0088284072,
-0.0054332186,
0.0036034365,
0.0215431228,
-0.0076492974,
0.0131252678,
-0.0270496234,
-0.0649932995,
0.0184216425,
-0.007872628,
-0.0219314508,
-0.0261836313,
0.0536175258,
-0.0105269523,
0.025061002,
-0.0195118468,
0.0002942615,
0.0423749648,
0.0421688445,
0.0508903526,
-0.0234408714,
-0.0204287507,
0.0723700523,
0.0121295573,
0.008768985,
0.0066373027,
-0.0090658292,
0.0019115735,
0.0478391536,
0.041416768,
0.0435227826,
0.0484574959,
-0.0088027511,
-0.0574169941,
0.0244623311,
0.0514963083,
0.0158051755,
0.0052106269,
-0.0498191565,
-0.0467316769,
-0.0184285101,
-0.0482795052,
-0.0298756622,
-0.0377857499,
-0.0259854775,
0.0500899702,
-0.0156981871,
-0.0065294313,
-0.0142895589,
0.0214406624,
-0.0065166098,
0.0132327648,
0.018605141,
-0.0071266382,
-0.0073793572,
0.0197225939,
0.0635010079,
-0.0244706254,
-0.0085183429,
0.0029657308,
0.0172661226,
0.0291124117,
0.0205108114,
0.0350551382,
0.0037725768,
-0.0503317378,
0.0089788698,
-0.0302003287,
0.0348197967,
-0.0509758033,
0.0111548211,
0.0102473591,
0.0320093036,
-0.0334309936,
0.025896376,
0.0217881147,
0.0078772986,
-0.0535091721,
0.0001233635,
0.001099971,
0.0206128471,
-0.0106143598,
-0.0115246847,
-0.0069594332,
-0.0285715014,
0.0306140874,
-0.0553069748,
0.0092432983,
-0.031602677,
2.88e-7,
0.0352683067,
0.0749909729,
0.0039200927,
0.0785481334,
-0.0102796834,
0.027014954,
0.0042620492,
0.0200434346,
0.0030180886,
-0.0667565167,
0.0182342082,
0.0132472757,
0.0299503282,
0.0594329312,
-0.0774314776,
0.0168711767,
-0.0948357731,
-0.0025341234,
-0.0553682595,
0.0260623861,
0.0716718733,
0.1039348394,
-0.0016143991,
-0.0355721451,
-0.0260935072,
-0.016680235,
0.0246350318,
-0.0118212374,
0.016422037,
0.0148022417,
0.0584964566,
0.0031379662,
0.0179142188,
0.0415425189,
0.0144032286,
0.0140631879,
-0.0104120532,
0.0358924158,
-0.0265295301,
-0.0216199737,
-0.0089926813,
-0.0259682629,
0.0023252196,
-0.0747876391,
0.0768080205,
-0.039155487,
-0.0353209861,
-0.0115566067,
-0.0198230632,
-0.0176685397,
0.0094791222,
-0.0368592218,
0.0038975601,
0.0110487323,
-0.0112741841,
-0.0193422195,
0.0182050709,
-0.0427716486,
-0.0298446566,
0.0221232548,
-0.0104862675,
-0.0375516601,
-0.0099663874,
-0.001059555,
0.0113988062,
-0.0537488498,
0.0163535513,
2.71263459e-34,
0.0694428012,
0.009246124,
-0.0006325161,
0.02124965,
0.0431906134,
0.0034722716,
-0.0141904801,
-0.0155530777,
-0.0012278714,
-0.0698396116,
-0.028516531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17692v1 | Mitigating the Problem of Strong Priors in LMs with Context Extrapolation | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | Raymond Douglas, Andis Draguns, Tomáš Gavenčiak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become important tools in a variety of
applications, from data processing to the creation of instruction-following
assistants. But despite their advantages, LMs have certain idiosyncratic
limitations such as the problem of `strong priors', where a model learns to
output typical continuations in response to certain, usually local, portions of
the input regardless of any earlier instructions. For example, prompt injection
attacks can induce models to ignore explicit directives. In some cases, larger
models have been shown to be more susceptible to these problems than similar
smaller models, an example of the phenomenon of `inverse scaling'. We develop a
new technique for mitigating the problem of strong priors: we take the original
set of instructions, produce a weakened version of the original prompt that is
even more susceptible to the strong priors problem, and then extrapolate the
continuation away from the weakened prompt. This lets us infer how the model
would continue a hypothetical strengthened set of instructions. Our technique
conceptualises LMs as mixture models which combine a family of data generation
processes, reinforcing the desired elements of the mixture. Our approach works
at inference time, removing any need for retraining. We apply it to eleven
models including GPT-2, GPT-3, Llama 2, and Mistral on four tasks, and find
improvements in 41/44. Across all 44 combinations the median increase in
proportion of tasks completed is 40%. | [
0.0141507946,
0.0613349862,
-0.0334306359,
0.0121207396,
-0.0292020179,
0.0202478785,
-0.0343785025,
-0.0152316969,
-0.019477386,
-0.0272631943,
-0.0242265463,
-0.0337148122,
0.0029400212,
0.0006467603,
0.04475189,
-0.0714125037,
0.0479723178,
-0.0987395346,
-0.0241060853,
-0.0122198528,
-0.0359092653,
-0.0234685875,
0.0027877628,
0.0446689874,
0.0388975814,
0.0059626177,
-0.030541949,
0.0003489577,
0.0164111629,
-0.0123120816,
-0.0169502813,
0.0129780304,
0.0326142386,
0.0022725882,
0.0000021203,
-0.0378717892,
0.005568197,
-0.0176474731,
-0.0373931453,
-0.0035005559,
0.0081605474,
-0.0086192684,
-0.0056872615,
0.0325382426,
-0.0155084562,
-0.0161961224,
0.0419746898,
0.0311848577,
0.0442541055,
0.0826383159,
0.0077496143,
-0.0046751006,
0.0244812109,
-0.0314724259,
0.0493412986,
-0.0603533313,
0.0183950458,
-0.0380138569,
0.0464946739,
0.0288745724,
-0.010403513,
0.0203063656,
0.028977057,
0.0096197082,
-0.0349895731,
0.0539644472,
0.065801926,
-0.0165896546,
-0.0295581017,
0.0317625515,
-0.0391466618,
-0.0087902006,
-0.0098725213,
-0.0400985256,
0.0153888594,
0.0176964793,
-0.0589031018,
0.0326469429,
-0.0147332735,
0.0296383984,
0.0373586565,
-0.0352023356,
0.0473804846,
0.0023359624,
-0.0174996201,
0.0861602798,
0.0252874475,
-0.0294778403,
-0.0139532769,
-0.009216154,
-0.0370550007,
-0.0639276877,
-0.0064162011,
0.0636686236,
-0.0372212715,
0.031611599,
-0.0520484149,
-0.0018796773,
0.0238957517,
-0.0265960675,
0.0481341183,
0.0694817677,
-0.0578748956,
0.0042486656,
-0.0101812249,
0.0399542227,
-0.0287399087,
0.0223402102,
-0.0338661857,
0.0322343893,
-0.0348169394,
-0.0115886191,
-0.0265167207,
0.0203901026,
-0.0535505451,
0.0096793268,
-0.0259038471,
0.0753095448,
-0.0119348345,
0.0110840984,
0.0071889427,
-0.0105836941,
-0.0659647584,
-0.0097719124,
-0.0193287395,
-0.0035752,
-0.0282480065,
0.05156276,
0.0308442246,
-0.0688014403,
-0.0384814478,
-0.0122610657,
-0.0217413213,
-0.0229006596,
-0.0146137569,
0.1092984155,
-0.0196983349,
-0.0328440331,
-0.0636154935,
-0.0362615623,
-0.0138702998,
-0.0581103638,
0.0122533524,
-0.0405341536,
0.0100957742,
-0.0005137484,
-0.0029136969,
-0.0124438396,
-0.002388885,
0.0174196735,
-0.0488723665,
0.0822164789,
-0.002423791,
0.0076024812,
0.0538823567,
0.0352642238,
-0.0663884878,
0.0637838542,
0.0089483084,
0.0204525013,
0.0057670963,
0.018145578,
0.0285291951,
0.0283368379,
0.0017151588,
0.0291297194,
-0.0050794077,
-0.0113895135,
0.0102864942,
-0.0235847645,
0.0308353901,
0.0677792206,
-0.0269130804,
0.0197794195,
0.0835818276,
0.0260830428,
-0.0185385887,
-0.01618178,
0.0809821784,
-0.0256424546,
-0.0253811441,
0.0806983709,
-0.1077306569,
-0.0239984486,
-0.0263765138,
0.0220352355,
0.0036279452,
0.0271874629,
-0.0282354113,
-0.0418396108,
0.0041274107,
-0.0187603906,
-0.0209030882,
-0.0060430299,
0.0658886284,
0.0139855752,
-0.0235901102,
-0.0087023573,
0.0253774729,
-0.0374078192,
0.0218373444,
-0.0954642445,
0.0165542439,
0.060382802,
0.0219799057,
-0.0487355255,
-0.0246352982,
0.0032248662,
-0.0136294682,
-0.0008556121,
-0.0066859857,
-0.0021968787,
0.0402589589,
-0.0240072422,
-0.0145811792,
-0.0090714153,
0.0350965522,
0.0434195511,
-0.0264915098,
-0.0113773877,
0.0245655086,
-0.0071733855,
0.0311403815,
0.0452187732,
-0.0245764684,
-0.0457258262,
0.0013094477,
-0.0164076667,
0.0469913296,
-0.0085187051,
0.0171244908,
0.032930389,
0.0475638099,
-0.0111524304,
-0.0053479443,
0.0167830139,
-0.0831913203,
-0.0281550195,
0.0231132656,
0.0301701669,
0.0225437656,
-0.0374389477,
-0.0303783808,
-0.0595023409,
0.0030875576,
-0.0444185585,
0.0666437075,
-0.0115711866,
0.0494256243,
0.0286050439,
-0.0228190757,
-0.0392011479,
0.0674934387,
-0.0329152085,
-0.0170714576,
0.0778543949,
0.0130722476,
-0.0121989772,
-0.0664647967,
-0.017273562,
-0.0106322132,
-0.0010444982,
-0.0014575102,
-0.0039365711,
-0.0153457318,
-0.0242921952,
-0.0219429601,
-0.0552869439,
-0.0120497867,
-0.0362901688,
0.0228721499,
0.0185237583,
0.0282972679,
-0.0279150363,
-0.0182279684,
-0.0035213353,
-0.0245590694,
0.0222146753,
0.0465751626,
0.0064927819,
0.0628270581,
-0.0255734138,
-0.0462105758,
-0.0098757036,
-0.0146031631,
0.0207394343,
-0.0181755107,
0.010538578,
-0.1044653803,
0.035237588,
0.001392991,
0.0507700592,
-0.0454420112,
0.0005940016,
0.0311744623,
-0.021292951,
0.09535449,
0.0639909506,
-0.0066031017,
0.0156858135,
0.0738126338,
-0.0211956073,
-0.0249481164,
0.0124374572,
-0.0422891006,
-0.0631896704,
-0.0338419415,
-0.0428179577,
-0.0111943148,
0.0639496669,
0.0258678887,
-0.0090626441,
-0.0407544188,
-0.0015718505,
0.0054117204,
-0.04130527,
0.0018824786,
-0.0634820908,
-0.0472843423,
0.028862441,
-0.0251397733,
-0.100600794,
0.0719868019,
-0.0533807464,
0.0349511281,
-0.0027630276,
-0.0305542368,
0.0093138767,
0.0287639648,
0.0228102896,
-0.0172823202,
0.0023046189,
-0.021966327,
-0.0631590784,
0.0059364429,
0.0144692995,
0.0000939344,
0.0535136797,
-0.079465434,
-0.0215765238,
-0.0083104689,
-0.0354138613,
-0.0656599328,
-0.0242482536,
0.0073768958,
0.0058563882,
0.0150178168,
-0.003520143,
0.0096182115,
-0.0045549031,
0.0194312856,
0.0514640175,
-0.0290887207,
-0.0064232983,
-0.0455622599,
-0.008488914,
0.0313149057,
-0.0129142497,
-0.013901961,
-0.0741098002,
0.0242580082,
0.0255323984,
0.0968516022,
-0.0446502604,
-0.0337329321,
0.0170770604,
0.0122998394,
0.0000313084,
-0.0330009758,
0.0708828047,
0.0958204493,
-0.0354753174,
-0.0329394527,
0.0847098753,
-0.003764014,
-0.0412846729,
0.0224706139,
-0.0161056481,
0.0445159674,
0.0053063431,
0.0178387538,
-0.0583559908,
-0.0199356806,
0.0481048375,
0.0535341091,
-0.0218045451,
-0.0266067777,
-0.00470644,
-0.1039601639,
0.0372346863,
0.0045291553,
-0.0242128409,
-0.0060996339,
-0.0681032389,
0.0130560994,
0.0032012621,
0.0297468118,
0.0172739811,
-0.0131789483,
0.001922451,
0.0314992368,
0.0110450732,
-0.068745397,
0.0015463096,
-0.0285563469,
0.0407654718,
0.0542384461,
-0.0267693195,
0.0042169788,
-0.0098997308,
0.0490710065,
-0.0354863293,
0.0240431037,
0.0056875823,
0.0134811755,
-0.018637849,
0.0012547127,
0.0421540067,
0.0594378188,
-0.0117827039,
-0.0411402993,
0.0287404526,
0.0698594376,
-0.0441551544,
0.0042758873,
-0.0266998988,
-0.0171621647,
0.045024842,
0.0583516434,
0.0372077376,
-0.0413031168,
0.0109070679,
-0.0351034664,
-0.0058175274,
0.0352996103,
0.0435018875,
-0.0068759131,
-0.0277025029,
-0.0392749459,
-0.0444523022,
-0.0347587019,
0.0175089762,
0.0527350418,
0.0107258875,
0.0091850534,
-0.0121221915,
-0.0062943483,
0.0058429195,
0.0207725409,
-0.0240109004,
0.0053851283,
-0.0555400625,
-0.0187856536,
-0.0008803897,
-0.0334037654,
-0.0171170421,
0.0126874438,
-0.1370602548,
-0.1038274989,
0.0076006679,
0.1062932834,
0.0331669748,
0.0533377826,
-0.0051507414,
-0.0432479307,
0.0269446932,
0.0186699945,
-0.020845294,
0.0384843834,
0.0389972217,
-0.0118956519,
0.0204068404,
0.0168041345,
-0.0362060443,
0.018659614,
0.0488932729,
0.0113971503,
-0.0381728821,
-0.0370774046,
0.021578541,
-0.0005288136,
0.0607418157,
-0.0383831039,
0.0242142808,
-0.0310041271,
0.0212544966,
-0.0291310996,
0.0126043726,
-0.0380048454,
0.0327065401,
0.0177485589,
0.0140228178,
0.0172279458,
-0.0527772158,
-0.0328967944,
0.0503020622,
-0.0481012166,
0.0151371714,
0.0526209883,
0.0275995936,
0.0286654346,
0.0079750139,
-0.0161402989,
0.0074709854,
-0.0071225478,
0.0266697016,
0.0021319466,
0.0627749339,
0.0168677922,
-0.0044362005,
-0.0090575246,
0.0299604069,
-0.1027822196,
-0.0664190277,
-0.0335088708,
0.0378243476,
0.0277288985,
0.0050943829,
0.0217478704,
-0.0208147727,
0.0162586756,
-0.0371662229,
0.0294631515,
0.0314628556,
-0.0291889794,
0.0204116572,
0.0405118093,
-0.0006529454,
0.033585716,
0.0752818361,
0.0069764419,
0.0701434985,
-0.0152042266,
0.0033568803,
-0.0298730899,
-0.0367025696,
0.0305551533,
0.0532542914,
-0.0123383664,
-0.0261042584,
-0.022935627,
-0.0709894076,
-0.0273193177,
0.0250304677,
0.0218347106,
-0.0132853584,
0.0373044014,
0.0421992168,
-0.0241069533,
-0.0353039876,
-0.0192986075,
-0.0095372098,
0.0434498899,
0.0075857732,
0.0005244074,
-6.425775217e-33,
-0.0457905829,
-0.007867462,
0.0191890877,
-0.0321123488,
0.0066777435,
-0.0111824404,
-0.0298652835,
0.019427659,
-0.0071957801,
-0.0173343271,
-0.0307097118,
0.0001298942,
0.0232088808,
0.0091640428,
0.0148282433,
-0.0054690191,
0.0400672667,
0.0011407005,
-0.0338719636,
0.0257044882,
0.0273704715,
0.0157690253,
0.0410664864,
-0.0390158407,
0.03245157,
0.0024761839,
-0.0494061746,
0.0244952198,
-0.0434346385,
0.0636303723,
-0.0180828273,
0.0380692892,
0.0226759184,
-0.0384239517,
-0.053262528,
0.0304621086,
-0.0318248756,
-0.0394958332,
0.0381964184,
-0.0428149477,
-0.0294379592,
-0.0388156325,
0.0457458012,
0.0046911794,
-0.020449657,
0.0111675272,
0.020201683,
-0.04334962,
-0.0073473789,
0.0517793298,
-0.0322646089,
0.0100253662,
0.0157221369,
-0.0150530022,
-0.0214288309,
0.0145261781,
-0.0060436311,
-0.0120921424,
-0.0094124675,
0.0316853151,
0.090229407,
0.0354430862,
0.0610412173,
0.0472205877,
-0.0075240424,
0.0134719526,
0.0326062925,
0.0097186314,
-0.0120790061,
-0.027147647,
-0.0099537373,
0.0303244852,
0.0064754523,
0.0028506925,
0.0382898152,
-0.0064392141,
-0.0351815782,
0.0166678745,
0.0206632167,
0.0410817116,
0.0353455432,
0.0239404514,
-0.0333970375,
-0.0335775055,
-0.0432485342,
-0.0166581161,
-0.0119154314,
-0.0111712702,
0.0490868986,
0.0384500958,
0.0029687562,
-0.0080594523,
0.0435255915,
-0.0025086761,
0.0103858002,
-0.0150838383,
-0.0263105761,
-0.0108395005,
-0.0042375624,
0.0072793141,
-0.0476375557,
-0.0480513573,
0.0360787697,
0.0017520924,
-0.0018012106,
0.0264752489,
0.0042670798,
0.0453547202,
-0.0584059618,
0.0031427573,
-0.0437632725,
0.0185102616,
0.0204831939,
0.0393225402,
0.0680726394,
-0.0324901938,
-0.0075206058,
0.0701863393,
-0.0069424491,
-0.0453290381,
-0.0282245409,
-0.0128671275,
0.0007890172,
0.0357862934,
-0.0319964066,
0.0022087495,
0.0101340916,
0.0086502749,
0.0308783446,
-0.0601069778,
-0.0154451849,
0.0056349491,
2.911e-7,
0.0182699729,
-0.0138139771,
0.0283547081,
0.0354357176,
-0.005084293,
0.0274301153,
-0.0260808561,
0.0462565534,
0.0311015546,
-0.0271748863,
0.0183395389,
0.0256601889,
-0.0074677016,
0.0138876559,
-0.0506217182,
-0.024419453,
-0.0737767294,
0.0085412841,
-0.0451632366,
-0.004351797,
0.0471506678,
0.0976675749,
0.0108827641,
-0.0180900618,
0.003607719,
-0.0329666138,
0.043083366,
-0.0394321233,
-0.001745785,
-0.0065052547,
0.0306177903,
0.0407533981,
0.0104487156,
0.0308370534,
-0.0234003458,
0.0019244073,
-0.0401954614,
0.0527703278,
-0.021144582,
-0.0189321078,
0.0244563017,
0.007102218,
-0.0010882739,
-0.0353388488,
0.0479018278,
-0.0286040977,
0.0133521743,
-0.0076998132,
-0.0295052715,
-0.0403953381,
-0.0242109932,
-0.0280519873,
0.0071367035,
0.0073588756,
-0.0078027803,
0.04456494,
-0.0076103201,
-0.0806747749,
-0.0036231957,
0.0193502679,
-0.0641677678,
-0.0736146644,
-0.0367506519,
-0.012490497,
0.0406497866,
-0.0739405677,
-0.0191152077,
2.797631785e-34,
0.0220203158,
-0.0283896383,
0.0270364601,
0.0431061722,
0.0146398777,
-0.0040325322,
-0.0100563336,
0.0432332009,
0.0502098314,
-0.0632282123,
-0.0659623891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17686v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17686v2 | Deductive Beam Search: Decoding Deducible Rationale for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-01-31T09:16:35 | 2024-02-04T13:18:34 | Tinghui Zhu, Kai Zhang, Jian Xie, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements have significantly augmented the reasoning capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) through various methodologies, especially
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, previous methods fail to address
reasoning errors in intermediate steps, leading to accumulative errors. In this
paper, we propose Deductive Beam Search (DBS), which seamlessly integrates CoT
and deductive reasoning with step-wise beam search for LLMs. Our approach
deploys a verifier, verifying the deducibility of a reasoning step and its
premises, thus alleviating the error accumulation. Furthermore, we introduce a
scalable and labor-free data construction method to amplify our model's
verification capabilities. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach
significantly enhances the base performance of LLMs of various scales (7B, 13B,
70B, and ChatGPT) across 8 reasoning datasets from 3 diverse reasoning genres,
including arithmetic, commonsense, and symbolic. Moreover, our analysis proves
DBS's capability of detecting diverse and subtle reasoning errors and
robustness on different model scales. | [
0.0114573343,
0.0705214217,
-0.0121883089,
0.0438398682,
-0.0327692181,
0.0056506447,
0.0070528556,
-0.0021746731,
0.0361144803,
0.0259205159,
0.0106079606,
0.024460597,
0.025296323,
0.0192856453,
0.0001731559,
-0.0005356892,
0.0367394872,
-0.0461397022,
0.0200905353,
-0.0250826497,
-0.000137033,
0.0232681129,
-0.0421284102,
0.0056782383,
-0.0033712359,
-0.0120508419,
-0.0361307226,
-0.0011771113,
0.0360167883,
-0.0493997447,
-0.0147627993,
0.0138324266,
0.0079551218,
0.0763671324,
0.0000024773,
-0.0286187269,
-0.0257958136,
0.0053585027,
-0.0946248844,
-0.0049202666,
-0.0176040567,
0.0071479524,
0.0076507675,
0.041742444,
-0.0010598993,
-0.0197597761,
0.0354554132,
0.024957886,
0.066879496,
0.0545406155,
0.0160989184,
-0.0536305197,
0.02065848,
-0.0010987849,
0.0207954068,
-0.0693621784,
0.0249369759,
0.0592126437,
0.0413453281,
0.039924968,
-0.0009764323,
0.0351022743,
0.0195947755,
-0.0102130212,
-0.0545441769,
0.0255004615,
-0.0147663839,
-0.0274709649,
0.016084671,
0.0529112965,
0.0067853322,
-0.0887224302,
0.0068603079,
-0.0027483667,
-0.0224155616,
0.0210649408,
-0.0221698675,
0.0465670303,
-0.0253912956,
0.0061812662,
0.0595156401,
-0.0104352329,
0.0637053624,
-0.0032905203,
-0.0825065002,
0.0597071759,
-0.0124686118,
-0.0444654338,
-0.0064455047,
0.0027124586,
-0.0408445187,
-0.0856358409,
0.0358735435,
0.0249002147,
-0.0491839722,
0.0440381542,
-0.013909962,
0.0028109851,
0.0008751357,
0.019206183,
0.0165195111,
0.0393567905,
0.0277787205,
0.0383717492,
-0.0334818289,
0.0448443033,
-0.0331261754,
-0.0158304628,
-0.0262389872,
-0.0332853235,
-0.0647928268,
-0.0172616541,
-0.0193558354,
0.0417357199,
-0.0095236246,
-0.0058148825,
-0.0201821886,
-0.0184857585,
-0.0186277144,
0.0190426894,
0.0308699999,
-0.0338088647,
0.0600974821,
-0.0221641697,
-0.0048686918,
0.0437966213,
-0.0430447347,
0.0053597502,
0.0459756032,
-0.0523440428,
-0.0069697201,
-0.0245343223,
-0.025630163,
-0.0107982112,
0.0211995188,
0.0298231263,
0.0046231993,
0.0019644597,
-0.0370572321,
-0.0353147425,
-0.0236423537,
-0.062425971,
0.0249541961,
-0.0864148885,
0.0267239362,
0.0316025093,
-0.0106887547,
0.0077652661,
0.0192633271,
0.0318364091,
-0.043987155,
0.0687737614,
-0.0105796484,
0.0257099103,
0.0005456585,
0.0191919971,
-0.0249018632,
0.0178929325,
0.0153973103,
0.0292335693,
0.0339790359,
0.0292714071,
0.0221355427,
0.0094527211,
0.0402861051,
-0.0115105947,
-0.0067316988,
0.0201542377,
-0.0131588504,
-0.0026873932,
-0.0185753983,
0.0231205244,
-0.0628097951,
0.0194046721,
0.0256363694,
0.0600718521,
0.0544625148,
-0.0148457028,
0.0161286555,
0.0190899223,
0.0088546816,
-0.0213412251,
-0.0342321694,
0.00417529,
-0.0750721991,
-0.0126379766,
0.0026771801,
0.0116011845,
-0.0073910044,
-0.0240099709,
-0.0189752616,
0.0409402475,
-0.0074185864,
0.0398900099,
0.043258734,
0.0042389012,
-0.0192698911,
0.0764493197,
0.0213417169,
-0.07623595,
-0.050970681,
-0.045336321,
0.0383833759,
0.01841552,
0.0790421218,
0.017002156,
-0.0098030251,
0.0261485577,
0.009962514,
0.0211300738,
0.0222742688,
0.008482106,
-0.0275577251,
-0.0579729863,
-0.0271570086,
0.0229034964,
0.0200423654,
-0.0174198337,
0.0165040903,
-0.0164471939,
-0.020063309,
-0.0465684086,
0.0025541091,
0.0050194715,
-0.0199514721,
0.0207290053,
-0.0099067073,
0.0131329577,
0.0433412418,
0.0010228561,
0.0010533991,
0.012678355,
0.0019679053,
-0.002622759,
-0.0319194905,
0.0296176784,
-0.0392684415,
-0.047670152,
0.0153649738,
-0.0396903381,
-0.0483124964,
-0.0145669496,
-0.0419871397,
-0.029471064,
0.0348282047,
-0.0519327633,
-0.0551627874,
-0.0244953744,
0.0342030525,
-0.0205409992,
-0.0377400741,
-0.0010404827,
0.1092295721,
-0.01486322,
-0.0095890276,
-0.0537422597,
-0.0073086293,
0.0332851857,
-0.0157694053,
-0.0099495836,
0.0615422241,
-0.0001937788,
-0.011178148,
0.0162898879,
0.0113787493,
-0.0068935053,
-0.0245105233,
-0.0566613525,
-0.0063897735,
0.0207244977,
0.0089619132,
-0.0052762018,
-0.0036043141,
0.022230722,
0.027518915,
-0.0047424203,
0.0103598135,
0.0489820056,
-0.011235767,
0.0193371624,
-0.011335142,
-0.0445096157,
0.006941786,
-0.0369624346,
-0.0472813025,
0.0519729555,
-0.01696443,
0.0072868899,
-0.038813144,
0.0781973898,
-0.0384583063,
-0.0013880738,
-0.011047733,
0.0044117123,
0.0411593132,
-0.0151559198,
-0.0292988624,
0.061557401,
-0.0104242656,
-0.025196068,
0.0543029346,
-0.0511046834,
-0.0511617661,
0.0139273843,
-0.0080661876,
0.0348730311,
-0.0053762859,
-0.0303588957,
-0.0113809444,
0.0324067436,
-0.0115046771,
0.0093803229,
-0.0555877611,
0.0078004021,
0.0059692031,
-0.0031070455,
-0.0479753166,
-0.0248928573,
0.0128169572,
0.0867829323,
-0.0198427569,
-0.0027651067,
0.0486847349,
-0.0208919365,
0.0357360505,
-0.0631867573,
0.0191087164,
-0.0194463655,
0.0453203544,
-0.0297122616,
0.0046886182,
-0.0147365592,
0.0004597249,
-0.000427726,
-0.0219984315,
0.0625620037,
-0.0480988026,
0.0725841522,
-0.0660309047,
0.0243770257,
-0.0024905398,
-0.0613552593,
-0.0598264262,
0.0177368149,
-0.0576061308,
-0.012251094,
-0.0315077491,
-0.019089777,
-0.050257232,
-0.0096887918,
0.0377512611,
0.0137009844,
0.0061535458,
-0.0116547411,
-0.0239408277,
0.0435206667,
-0.0272549875,
-0.039481245,
0.0704398826,
-0.0310658403,
-0.0070123831,
0.0483213775,
0.0640858337,
-0.0052256114,
-0.049067121,
-0.0012537605,
0.0113939028,
-0.003508582,
-0.0344049335,
-0.0092131989,
0.0315775536,
-0.0764108077,
-0.0153419469,
0.0892226622,
0.0232899915,
-0.0217820201,
0.006237105,
-0.0305275973,
0.0193989649,
0.0058799558,
0.0303437002,
-0.1282183975,
-0.0647364557,
0.0564957522,
-0.0105081424,
-0.0098060668,
-0.0491296127,
-0.0047957073,
-0.1529531181,
0.0154480161,
0.0197102241,
0.0532824621,
-0.0112496018,
-0.0341089703,
0.0085145412,
0.005324848,
-0.0384225138,
0.0488997772,
0.0260162931,
-0.0050928183,
-0.0072613703,
0.0005858538,
-0.0617313981,
0.0470205843,
-0.0216252208,
0.0553707182,
0.0179910772,
0.0277052131,
0.027697688,
-0.0779490322,
0.0096284021,
-0.0339343846,
-0.0101693645,
-0.0256239362,
-0.0168061666,
0.0111575117,
0.0189058967,
-0.0432819314,
0.0362979993,
-0.0228268802,
-0.0393562987,
0.0248607993,
0.1023609266,
-0.0295199864,
-0.0170004461,
-0.0095657269,
0.0167721827,
-0.0298230536,
0.0607168898,
0.0083375648,
0.0152097028,
-0.0548804738,
-0.0327351801,
-0.0702401474,
0.0056380183,
-0.0451891869,
0.0107234232,
0.0482046381,
0.0492985733,
-0.0266256351,
0.0283176191,
0.0032938439,
0.0510450006,
-0.0348383226,
-0.010602124,
-0.007925475,
0.0116104344,
-0.0154854301,
0.0212507658,
-0.0709664822,
0.0349802971,
-0.0189503934,
0.0937536284,
-0.0322864614,
-0.0451074801,
-0.0335472152,
0.0595877692,
-0.0484563708,
-0.0521910079,
-0.0005965843,
0.0204543788,
0.0343399756,
0.0312497318,
-0.0372508466,
-0.0114129689,
0.0546364449,
0.0204084609,
-0.0241810065,
-0.0049881926,
0.0408463925,
0.0018224939,
0.0096616792,
0.0283255652,
-0.0047762897,
0.0140382284,
0.0089815753,
0.0759678632,
-0.0226704609,
0.0047528343,
0.0271465033,
0.0505867265,
-0.0071879611,
0.0062937234,
-0.0286864657,
-0.045721896,
0.045575615,
-0.0255160332,
-0.0149319079,
-0.0309968684,
0.0368822031,
0.0294333696,
-0.0259577073,
0.0081543876,
-0.0375580117,
0.0058286362,
0.0199786555,
0.0232398007,
0.0238644406,
0.0045934762,
0.0541603416,
0.026618341,
-0.0434106886,
0.0207239073,
0.0034003293,
0.0193659663,
0.0350907892,
-0.0223301649,
0.0874333233,
0.0642518774,
-0.0297791362,
-0.0413604937,
0.0136118392,
-0.058266256,
-0.0424250215,
0.0510582775,
-0.0096273413,
0.0508950278,
0.0346701778,
0.0420480445,
-0.0367070399,
-0.0190164205,
0.0090211546,
0.0056392984,
0.018126674,
-0.0297421459,
0.0070346869,
0.0463514477,
-0.0022570218,
-0.0176195614,
0.0527418368,
-0.0526028164,
0.0234374907,
0.010940155,
-0.0140569545,
-0.0325662792,
-0.0683462769,
-0.0602218397,
0.0100349383,
-0.0219956487,
-0.0163879488,
-0.0701533183,
-0.0704460591,
-0.0358464122,
0.0201840494,
0.0098759923,
-0.0053223749,
0.0254529696,
0.0666164011,
0.02400418,
-0.0224990565,
0.0097141797,
-0.0240638684,
-0.0315563865,
-0.0075055389,
-0.0191519409,
-6.863602781e-33,
0.0060872212,
-0.038518697,
0.0365884304,
0.0141174104,
-0.0132027725,
-0.0104477117,
-0.0609414093,
-0.003238806,
-0.0186315402,
0.0464386344,
-0.0304007251,
0.0440897457,
0.0158663001,
0.0104740467,
-0.0001835344,
0.0320900381,
0.0443497598,
0.0263156574,
-0.0352745764,
0.0103266165,
0.0602759123,
-0.0215272401,
0.0013782479,
-0.0614490733,
0.005446679,
-0.0078811608,
-0.0331816189,
0.060356427,
-0.0845904052,
0.0434831195,
0.015130314,
-0.001421415,
-0.0080952002,
-0.0373957939,
0.0143264337,
-0.0156369433,
-0.0754885301,
0.0000622458,
0.0298849493,
-0.0420042612,
-0.0278583169,
-0.0298417248,
-0.0303269774,
0.0094966479,
-0.0381789915,
-0.0158627313,
-0.0164174009,
-0.0164295807,
0.0156488009,
0.0154097741,
0.0111676631,
0.0388509594,
-0.0108548794,
-0.0142835435,
0.0121631296,
0.0234620553,
-0.0254022516,
-0.0272721536,
-0.0518661104,
0.0398061462,
0.0081831068,
-0.0127972858,
0.0738260001,
-0.0544006303,
0.0058216681,
0.047787942,
0.0500152521,
-0.0358051695,
-0.0039966069,
-0.0018630479,
-0.0029388219,
0.0572961047,
0.0689440668,
0.0269435439,
0.0486365519,
0.0449234992,
-0.0807716846,
-0.0362444967,
-0.0097906236,
0.1084409058,
0.0477043428,
-0.002522446,
-0.0333462469,
-0.0107113589,
-0.0530697405,
-0.0019865376,
-0.0489128642,
0.0004207476,
0.0049982793,
0.0310723335,
-0.0248408634,
-0.041614186,
0.0308687799,
-0.0520002097,
0.0221998356,
0.0914465189,
0.004294564,
-0.0074550076,
0.0019175281,
0.0445394516,
-0.040909335,
-0.0027905579,
0.0040568314,
0.0003732407,
0.0006620246,
0.0205898229,
0.0099052759,
-0.0158219915,
-0.0220380425,
-0.0018230337,
-0.057597287,
-0.0008670923,
-0.0653719455,
0.0289905015,
0.0846424997,
0.0206605047,
0.0106009245,
0.0057088151,
-0.000376199,
0.0297293998,
-0.0282856245,
0.0528981946,
-0.0070052464,
0.0268406793,
0.0008052526,
0.0093719056,
-0.0611230694,
-0.0405044742,
0.0384344719,
-0.0480695069,
0.0095440485,
0.0519839041,
3.177e-7,
-0.0236724149,
0.0647044182,
0.0119498866,
0.0694551766,
0.02135095,
0.0559702069,
-0.0171855092,
-0.0458509102,
0.0124496855,
-0.0458121113,
-0.0061496571,
0.0595321693,
0.0720448717,
0.0458057933,
-0.0211654715,
-0.0303462073,
-0.0268783327,
-0.0697936565,
-0.0421832912,
-0.023294203,
0.0046516117,
0.0358637795,
0.0345671251,
-0.0279147979,
0.0144713903,
-0.0168958772,
0.0293889772,
0.0201327018,
-0.0044661402,
-0.0113080312,
0.0238126982,
-0.0197014716,
0.0210573412,
0.0563551858,
-0.004548796,
0.014801031,
-0.0386967435,
0.0402666777,
0.0210440047,
-0.0115016187,
-0.0358901508,
-0.0299156513,
-0.0049677431,
-0.04273564,
0.0600509718,
-0.0324825905,
-0.0326841734,
0.0361947604,
-0.0046602613,
-0.056381505,
-0.0210990291,
0.0182220098,
-0.01056585,
-0.0133996429,
0.0082359891,
0.0287993439,
0.0031764435,
-0.0832389146,
0.0001057132,
0.0054355445,
-0.0308506191,
-0.0216165707,
0.0008468933,
-0.0016632422,
0.0366507471,
-0.0714147687,
-0.0122475242,
3.401648307e-34,
0.0339262597,
-0.0159950145,
0.0179695152,
-0.034747161,
0.060549546,
0.0081329159,
-0.0424020179,
0.0135539081,
0.0494291931,
-0.1171364114,
-0.0154214697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17671v1 | Contextual Feature Extraction Hierarchies Converge in Large Language Models and the Brain | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | Gavin Mischler, Yinghao Aaron Li, Stephan Bickel, Ashesh D. Mehta, Nima Mesgarani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC | Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have sparked interest in the
parallels between large language models (LLMs) and human neural processing,
particularly in language comprehension. While prior research has established
similarities in the representation of LLMs and the brain, the underlying
computational principles that cause this convergence, especially in the context
of evolving LLMs, remain elusive. Here, we examined a diverse selection of
high-performance LLMs with similar parameter sizes to investigate the factors
contributing to their alignment with the brain's language processing
mechanisms. We find that as LLMs achieve higher performance on benchmark tasks,
they not only become more brain-like as measured by higher performance when
predicting neural responses from LLM embeddings, but also their hierarchical
feature extraction pathways map more closely onto the brain's while using fewer
layers to do the same encoding. We also compare the feature extraction pathways
of the LLMs to each other and identify new ways in which high-performing models
have converged toward similar hierarchical processing mechanisms. Finally, we
show the importance of contextual information in improving model performance
and brain similarity. Our findings reveal the converging aspects of language
processing in the brain and LLMs and offer new directions for developing models
that align more closely with human cognitive processing. | [
0.0227695722,
0.0434799902,
-0.0342248008,
0.0728061944,
-0.0200399775,
0.0581532232,
0.0155490274,
0.0220708363,
-0.0072686849,
-0.0093891909,
-0.0562481619,
-0.027359711,
0.0031123233,
0.043338567,
0.0372801311,
-0.0051843463,
0.0277964529,
-0.0624442287,
-0.0089076981,
-0.024106672,
-0.0356266275,
-0.0110613555,
0.0080483714,
0.0210562497,
0.0405110531,
-0.018966442,
0.0089090839,
-0.0397497788,
-0.0196994916,
-0.0104000736,
-0.0533620417,
0.0402802266,
0.0418070778,
0.0502336174,
0.0000019313,
-0.0423607789,
0.058636155,
0.0040029897,
-0.0478700362,
0.0334055237,
0.0141872773,
-0.0120065287,
-0.0133581338,
-0.059460219,
-0.0207385644,
-0.0160007291,
0.0217118356,
0.0382275954,
-0.0253951978,
0.0380794667,
-0.0038593737,
-0.05429006,
0.0667253733,
-0.0091497283,
0.0208912939,
-0.034597978,
0.0273905527,
-0.0086919153,
-0.0057164286,
0.0095283445,
-0.041626025,
0.0306143407,
0.0197156928,
0.0343239941,
-0.0241039675,
0.0871759877,
0.0498734899,
-0.0131880865,
-0.0020798743,
0.0634043217,
-0.0238646548,
-0.022507377,
-0.0068429275,
0.0172687769,
-0.0244548284,
-0.0123356236,
-0.0505457185,
0.031800054,
0.0101401247,
0.0522167236,
0.0489743799,
-0.0367708318,
0.0596660934,
-0.0009329708,
-0.0214396417,
0.0512176678,
0.0135165649,
-0.0442528985,
0.0169115495,
0.0070777787,
-0.0443038419,
-0.0130734788,
0.020642817,
-0.0060384218,
-0.005401006,
0.0103397723,
-0.0210229922,
-0.0231343154,
0.011022157,
-0.0397705436,
0.0504875034,
0.0437221378,
-0.0233047269,
0.0468553007,
-0.0537973344,
0.0813757479,
-0.0729784444,
0.0282444507,
-0.0358137116,
-0.0024243989,
-0.031165516,
-0.0142989624,
0.0380813181,
0.0369211845,
-0.0261268374,
-0.0426236466,
-0.0248782821,
0.0261158645,
0.0009968524,
-0.0278447382,
-0.0067318492,
0.025734337,
0.0081420336,
0.016468361,
-0.0508111753,
-0.0162359513,
-0.0083313631,
0.023449447,
-0.0076659895,
-0.0157891046,
-0.0091713443,
0.0340911224,
-0.0015194317,
-0.0352208018,
0.0140252821,
0.0701942518,
-0.0020395387,
-0.034055654,
-0.0337256454,
0.0184315816,
-0.0063470621,
-0.0128391841,
0.0456641428,
-0.0400361568,
0.0594888404,
0.0187536683,
-0.037300285,
-0.0363879167,
-0.0189627204,
-0.0100320857,
-0.0593718886,
0.0498729907,
-0.0207014084,
0.0109325144,
0.048038397,
0.0004856777,
-0.0027277907,
0.0058430666,
0.0365799367,
0.0118565038,
-0.0008718169,
-0.0013488369,
-0.0513019376,
0.0327862427,
-0.0223334357,
-0.0152468318,
-0.0465982892,
-0.0285950843,
0.009489255,
0.0594256371,
0.0780339837,
0.0345974788,
-0.0425245464,
-0.0788990185,
0.0666111261,
0.1078252047,
0.0022417526,
0.0335660614,
0.0486811623,
-0.0234665796,
-0.0082928473,
0.0147785731,
-0.077835232,
0.0309806168,
-0.0211486463,
0.0062032524,
0.0055644149,
0.006566471,
-0.0133891525,
-0.0251721907,
-0.0085599059,
0.0170795452,
-0.0086030839,
0.0262671113,
0.0297741126,
-0.0464965254,
-0.0224918146,
0.0269740596,
0.0506119803,
0.0055147568,
-0.0068739327,
-0.0735033974,
0.039732147,
0.0460727327,
0.0130723445,
-0.0025637471,
0.0119960187,
0.0478610657,
-0.007643891,
0.063511692,
0.0051006456,
0.0017511501,
0.0568184778,
-0.0041525802,
-0.0005016145,
-0.0028929287,
-0.0049793543,
0.0063045132,
-0.019049149,
-0.0305325501,
-0.0031757774,
-0.0153007507,
-0.0084016593,
0.0586846657,
-0.0692038313,
-0.0224135239,
-0.0279283542,
-0.007255055,
0.0318992771,
-0.0237804912,
-0.0223062746,
0.01084607,
0.0177783538,
-0.0556441583,
0.0017738603,
0.0003656342,
-0.0578160323,
-0.0333462991,
0.0309444088,
0.031847965,
-0.0045425952,
0.0173032545,
-0.0011304482,
0.0019057845,
0.0158071928,
-0.0173733924,
0.0611759983,
-0.0526293889,
0.0216538869,
-0.048122853,
0.0266608633,
-0.0454706773,
0.07089784,
-0.0350914747,
-0.0099857654,
0.018115798,
-0.0032610623,
-0.0187849794,
-0.0214071386,
-0.0276850201,
0.0364153869,
0.0092100361,
-0.0239831675,
-0.0523835942,
-0.0113373175,
-0.0339401029,
-0.0059137647,
-0.0788486227,
0.0021303883,
0.0216686241,
0.0073153898,
0.0087699778,
-0.0370809622,
-0.0076432056,
0.010865882,
0.0033161498,
0.0183041207,
0.001215813,
0.0268596131,
0.0091078104,
-0.0077466876,
-0.0289952438,
-0.0608425885,
-0.0338936001,
-0.0260225683,
0.0814564228,
-0.0303585306,
-0.0257395599,
-0.0627215058,
0.0604845919,
-0.0153747695,
0.0367638431,
-0.0130503755,
-0.0089080753,
0.02812922,
-0.0330290012,
0.0087817898,
0.0975970328,
-0.0096691856,
0.0428467952,
0.0943432972,
0.0070552179,
-0.0156748276,
-0.0248456728,
-0.0277930535,
0.0048393393,
-0.0625540763,
-0.0159494653,
0.0061317496,
0.0875699595,
0.0411425866,
-0.0015990674,
-0.005087066,
0.0177009888,
-0.0153876198,
-0.0388039425,
-0.0334899724,
-0.0036823256,
-0.0577266514,
0.0560209081,
-0.058247976,
-0.0273303818,
0.0539370961,
-0.0235473625,
0.0241984073,
0.0032829843,
-0.0149550252,
-0.0259553697,
0.0592165217,
0.0419101305,
0.0364096649,
-0.0304581299,
-0.0281953067,
-0.0234569777,
0.0295873489,
-0.0356187932,
-0.023341231,
0.0324635655,
-0.0370704941,
-0.0062816553,
0.014644294,
-0.0221157186,
-0.0308293644,
0.0097454581,
-0.0284943897,
0.0406772085,
0.0039676549,
0.0066699297,
-0.0312242545,
-0.0298982151,
0.0306501742,
0.0482794493,
-0.0028297221,
-0.0103099179,
-0.0252151228,
0.0534753948,
0.0114455055,
0.0409577712,
0.0478808209,
-0.0246428531,
0.0571719818,
0.0648859963,
0.014383994,
0.0404347442,
-0.044816453,
0.0455684252,
0.0343949869,
-0.0188149959,
-0.0231678039,
0.0201185346,
0.0062437444,
-0.0617991611,
0.0009724658,
0.132522881,
0.0248839911,
-0.045788113,
0.0127688795,
-0.02810915,
0.0187212229,
0.0349679776,
0.0073902262,
-0.0303549673,
-0.0085098809,
0.0026916941,
-0.0102132466,
-0.0072902222,
-0.0373748168,
0.0153090023,
-0.0690171048,
0.0360230729,
-0.0160158705,
-0.0702997819,
-0.006920692,
-0.0286748856,
0.0201847963,
0.0418334976,
0.0548339672,
0.0280108862,
0.001204562,
-0.0341252089,
0.0191637203,
0.0100224568,
-0.0605062433,
0.0591790266,
-0.0481085926,
0.0706629977,
0.0549585521,
0.0393125117,
-0.0091181332,
-0.0083159599,
0.0311128944,
-0.0007711446,
0.0419239998,
-0.0233252514,
0.0285232365,
0.0314831771,
-0.0008226181,
-0.0360997431,
-0.0032255526,
-0.0218571126,
-0.0446546078,
-0.0339997374,
0.0793005377,
-0.0125981746,
-0.0461864583,
0.0093905507,
0.0178509224,
-0.0607294068,
0.0690015182,
0.0742083341,
-0.0611626878,
-0.040929921,
0.0135487132,
-0.0120277973,
-0.0041196593,
-0.0665714741,
0.0237591714,
0.0170738567,
0.0117588714,
-0.0310065486,
0.0039230576,
0.0075496323,
-0.0165073145,
0.0188340954,
0.0083340909,
0.0267276578,
-0.0792533159,
-0.0290872958,
0.0231557246,
-0.0175803099,
-0.0312248468,
-0.0688774958,
0.0007052494,
0.0194949713,
-0.0492903814,
-0.0210053679,
0.0046955268,
-0.079680793,
-0.0702816173,
0.0346429422,
-0.0168096963,
0.0157855544,
0.0159807093,
0.0232671127,
-0.0839163139,
0.0555002727,
0.0101370076,
-0.0025897191,
0.0639895573,
-0.0360322073,
0.0059988503,
0.0110274209,
0.0310447626,
-0.0151007809,
0.0120265121,
0.0423599966,
0.0167757571,
-0.0009589963,
0.0073721143,
0.0114165256,
0.0055077435,
0.0623349547,
0.0155799249,
-0.010960076,
-0.0362210125,
-0.0098698502,
-0.0021909198,
0.0253203567,
0.0057076691,
-0.0647273958,
0.0490493476,
0.0313680097,
-0.0038776174,
-0.0174306817,
0.0302805938,
0.0360142179,
-0.0424493775,
0.0061759227,
-0.0338859558,
-0.0068654157,
0.0068376558,
0.0464160815,
-0.0113079492,
0.0351173505,
-0.0508264229,
0.0309710614,
-0.0097333807,
0.0274109188,
-0.021084113,
-0.0343571343,
-0.07072898,
0.0248235296,
-0.0929529518,
-0.0697785541,
-0.0009059467,
0.0230034236,
0.030472653,
-0.0183170568,
0.0250046421,
-0.003936165,
-0.0051387516,
-0.0215222221,
-0.0328473262,
-0.0322164744,
-0.0009771311,
0.0644474477,
0.0336825475,
0.0002384602,
-0.0276430827,
0.0446072146,
0.0309085194,
0.0106947692,
0.0145459659,
-0.0038015319,
-0.001712575,
-0.0277958978,
0.0011156151,
0.0284027867,
-0.0709146634,
-0.0004750155,
-0.0239206869,
-0.0731302723,
0.0076551959,
0.0151184453,
0.019685898,
-0.0349987298,
-0.0247860141,
0.0471331775,
-0.0040538302,
-0.0290890727,
0.0016868443,
0.0087082386,
-0.0268429779,
-0.0427384749,
-0.0025147963,
-6.273898408e-33,
-0.0313325115,
-0.0057953168,
0.0186691433,
0.0079311552,
-0.0251221247,
0.0131345065,
-0.0361772589,
0.0282821003,
-0.0383237638,
0.0024018502,
-0.0194744002,
-0.0128830653,
0.0085092736,
0.0087733828,
0.0019468217,
-0.0136259915,
0.0046013067,
-0.0402752683,
0.0406942964,
-0.012018648,
0.0358018279,
0.0167338978,
0.055481527,
-0.0769230351,
-0.003960676,
0.0178304929,
0.0325298086,
0.0626909584,
-0.0087503735,
0.0570421666,
-0.0953930095,
0.0577068031,
0.0655124187,
-0.0083521632,
-0.0180839971,
0.0138177257,
-0.0372185968,
-0.0058095618,
0.0429623723,
-0.0210143831,
-0.0224109106,
-0.0416736975,
0.0856671333,
-0.0097796032,
-0.0273717325,
-0.0281027462,
0.0297636352,
-0.036766436,
-0.0532759577,
0.014393894,
-0.1046365574,
-0.0031804945,
0.0106201293,
0.0402356908,
0.0317949206,
-0.0053346418,
-0.0394711643,
0.0679425374,
-0.0686114505,
0.0002470398,
-0.0071652397,
0.0211280882,
0.0468987823,
0.0216939561,
0.049114868,
0.0802609846,
0.1048253924,
0.0060706171,
-0.0380198359,
-0.0288504101,
0.0679772273,
0.0627428666,
0.0147713702,
-0.0018928983,
0.0477836058,
-0.0146216601,
-0.0455490015,
-0.0311151668,
0.0075962637,
0.0005398323,
0.04907161,
0.0043998379,
-0.0264438409,
-0.0034561304,
-0.0556745678,
-0.0081504621,
-0.0592025891,
-0.0169901382,
0.0359716602,
-0.0357928649,
0.0170899052,
-0.0329099894,
0.0170638375,
-0.0518316291,
0.0252045318,
-0.0014455939,
-0.005889432,
0.020848386,
0.02520133,
0.0127901388,
-0.0374909937,
-0.0478009805,
-0.0197599959,
-0.0385288075,
0.0366459899,
-0.000754273,
-0.0191888213,
0.0038658646,
-0.013935064,
-0.0172830112,
-0.0446977206,
-0.0615676492,
0.049039308,
0.0236508399,
0.0118575636,
-0.0131234424,
-0.0123380097,
-0.0135035384,
0.0296846703,
-0.0100115929,
-0.0395469889,
0.0172648486,
-0.0192718655,
0.038036406,
-0.0160388928,
-0.0073777349,
-0.01375644,
0.0146570588,
0.044616852,
-0.0505608544,
-0.0255406927,
0.0270870887,
2.692e-7,
0.0417665169,
0.0648774579,
-0.005979354,
-0.0010891077,
0.0519315079,
0.0153548531,
0.0014662748,
0.0004058435,
0.039575763,
-0.0445435196,
-0.0227249563,
0.0715057477,
0.0390418172,
0.005382583,
-0.0381621569,
-0.0135090314,
-0.0346693955,
0.0099087181,
-0.0520703979,
0.0004645075,
0.0266481992,
0.058757253,
-0.0108624958,
-0.0594004877,
0.0153864613,
-0.0135035273,
0.0804972425,
-0.0731464624,
0.0208954662,
-0.0087919347,
-0.0590136237,
0.0018517178,
0.0205950011,
0.0245779194,
0.0201367773,
0.0430111848,
0.0044051786,
0.0486936681,
0.0175140966,
-0.0011493575,
0.007641837,
0.0110884793,
0.0191759001,
-0.0690099895,
0.0754804164,
-0.0533388704,
-0.0673751533,
-0.0437731035,
0.0058304761,
-0.0111953272,
-0.0078919465,
-0.0127970874,
0.0018470611,
-0.0159999561,
0.0133120362,
-0.0219077598,
-0.016116051,
-0.0604141913,
-0.0244179536,
0.0390184782,
-0.1003303006,
-0.0234459322,
-0.0579921864,
-0.0146427527,
0.0662932694,
-0.0281451363,
0.0074301716,
2.497519812e-34,
-0.0198235717,
0.0235634279,
0.061647404,
0.03238599,
0.0189378932,
0.0119555676,
0.0221722461,
-0.0210425407,
-0.0068146014,
-0.0960718393,
-0.0014129172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17658v1 | Document Structure in Long Document Transformers | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | Jan Buchmann, Max Eichler, Jan-Micha Bodensohn, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long documents often exhibit structure with hierarchically organized elements
of different functions, such as section headers and paragraphs. Despite the
omnipresence of document structure, its role in natural language processing
(NLP) remains opaque. Do long-document Transformer models acquire an internal
representation of document structure during pre-training? How can structural
information be communicated to a model after pre-training, and how does it
influence downstream performance? To answer these questions, we develop a novel
suite of probing tasks to assess structure-awareness of long-document
Transformers, propose general-purpose structure infusion methods, and evaluate
the effects of structure infusion on QASPER and Evidence Inference, two
challenging long-document NLP tasks. Results on LED and LongT5 suggest that
they acquire implicit understanding of document structure during pre-training,
which can be further enhanced by structure infusion, leading to improved
end-task performance. To foster research on the role of document structure in
NLP modeling, we make our data and code publicly available. | [
0.0324781239,
0.0142187467,
-0.0081953565,
0.0433895774,
-0.0217628721,
0.0072916644,
-0.0082187708,
0.0085763736,
-0.0140577601,
-0.0418563522,
-0.0445418023,
-0.0129495822,
0.0218302682,
-0.0033167349,
0.0156988204,
-0.0436305441,
0.0373689272,
-0.0348378792,
-0.0270324908,
0.0523067638,
0.0192589127,
-0.0161634032,
0.0170736294,
-0.0088102752,
-0.0138034793,
-0.0523303859,
-0.0383059345,
0.0050965492,
-0.0147071239,
-0.0388356037,
0.0073701628,
0.0504699834,
0.0046041007,
0.0389087684,
0.0000016714,
-0.0185736064,
-0.0268553868,
0.0336333923,
-0.0263688955,
0.0218906477,
0.0486068763,
-0.0739877522,
-0.0037118464,
-0.0055874274,
-0.0074140998,
-0.0187796559,
0.0360114425,
0.1146551222,
0.0158200283,
0.0905672312,
-0.0206417535,
-0.0403094478,
0.0444807224,
-0.0300414022,
0.0340185538,
-0.0064363419,
0.0159550048,
-0.028615946,
-0.003238091,
0.0287121162,
-0.0368741117,
-0.0130224666,
0.0382534564,
-0.0036699339,
0.0189243499,
0.0423174128,
-0.008601849,
-0.0076445909,
-0.0077285944,
0.0366950072,
0.0049280734,
0.004940372,
0.0202708319,
-0.0111139929,
-0.0137151014,
0.008949684,
-0.0571273156,
0.0160359014,
-0.0271065067,
-0.0069390633,
0.0600874908,
0.0271687098,
0.0085883616,
-0.0067137112,
-0.0340069793,
0.0857386217,
0.0045183292,
-0.0478881896,
0.0091970861,
0.0246960539,
0.0081718098,
-0.0641009212,
0.017971525,
0.0063903416,
0.019874664,
0.0216246583,
-0.017587956,
-0.0469718724,
0.02265485,
-0.0399060063,
0.0033027015,
0.0106220916,
-0.0401547737,
0.0396185108,
-0.0668135136,
0.035508614,
-0.0409282446,
0.0332744382,
-0.0181846321,
0.0033813308,
-0.0395332016,
-0.0322840251,
-0.0320756324,
0.0027751764,
-0.0460914336,
-0.0683097467,
0.0023016275,
0.0088079507,
0.0334206857,
-0.025928352,
0.0006380129,
0.0057606399,
-0.0703120902,
0.0029152676,
-0.0042081852,
0.0552536249,
-0.0292815715,
0.0007694354,
0.023491811,
-0.0046451273,
-0.0423928611,
0.0374235623,
-0.0084658517,
-0.0565754548,
0.0009964852,
0.0419005975,
-0.0212111399,
-0.050548058,
-0.0122180153,
-0.0232560206,
-0.0424434617,
-0.0603196472,
0.0868506506,
-0.0508842506,
0.0049555618,
0.0210261364,
0.0305318274,
0.020381432,
0.0020772561,
0.0280610714,
-0.0041375477,
0.0680416301,
0.0109852087,
-0.0303868763,
0.0040439242,
0.0153356437,
-0.0057277796,
0.0751378983,
0.007576745,
0.0318603851,
0.0247501563,
-0.0335374996,
0.0032934335,
0.0142344637,
-0.000928534,
-0.006317039,
0.0142969741,
0.0109117199,
-0.0399389118,
-0.0054510664,
0.0366689526,
0.0284249447,
-0.0409766845,
-0.0034175408,
0.0293814708,
0.0613319352,
0.0524423756,
-0.0063157715,
-0.0000884084,
-0.0286500212,
0.0001017035,
0.0686340407,
-0.0354189239,
0.0213260688,
-0.0023111824,
0.0250006728,
-0.0231706761,
0.0107210008,
-0.0108095165,
-0.0105309179,
-0.0477093086,
0.0022451819,
0.0248487443,
-0.047908064,
0.0710146502,
0.0843334794,
-0.0131887347,
0.0294833612,
0.0004570268,
-0.0350795798,
0.0014926076,
-0.0248786379,
0.0087885903,
0.0250580739,
0.0480129942,
-0.0191205144,
-0.0136883305,
-0.001578153,
0.0031205872,
0.0641196147,
0.0168277621,
-0.0196700692,
0.0100409742,
-0.0278887879,
-0.016407283,
-0.0380348191,
0.0176990964,
-0.0104678338,
0.0294839554,
-0.0213389806,
0.0315676108,
-0.0780956447,
-0.0000368781,
0.053270001,
-0.022978127,
-0.0181866754,
0.0017098838,
-0.0116348676,
0.0041046925,
-0.016542498,
0.0014258492,
0.013501822,
0.0391446725,
-0.0168237109,
-0.0165505204,
-0.0259502865,
-0.0650507286,
-0.0268922355,
-0.0035760324,
-0.0392964222,
-0.0021290523,
0.0216433574,
-0.0221083146,
-0.0320905373,
-0.0188246574,
-0.0437947065,
0.0371990614,
-0.0202358104,
0.0185064748,
0.018876683,
0.0408037379,
-0.0311950296,
0.0458000004,
0.0231360272,
-0.0049958159,
0.0241612643,
-0.0124883037,
-0.0079322122,
-0.0092238532,
-0.0041590082,
0.017699806,
-0.0109497402,
-0.0515877083,
0.0392234661,
-0.0026275448,
-0.0565798283,
-0.03343888,
-0.0941040292,
0.0299861487,
-0.0370919667,
0.0462157875,
0.0278487876,
0.0118849594,
-0.0062117265,
-0.0261280015,
-0.0327912681,
-0.0246999916,
-0.0038966853,
0.0398906656,
0.0302090663,
-0.0039909799,
-0.0000917701,
-0.0266242456,
-0.0585722923,
-0.0412836783,
0.0712772682,
0.0078894198,
-0.068794407,
-0.058302138,
0.0082614115,
0.0283048786,
0.0031725445,
-0.0347837284,
-0.0140434597,
0.0008290295,
-0.0136166355,
0.1007825807,
0.0827023983,
0.0213935282,
0.0269718058,
0.0343289226,
-0.0103433011,
-0.0096286498,
0.0092170844,
-0.0316764489,
0.0454328246,
-0.0569191389,
-0.0022065667,
0.0265048314,
0.0898946226,
-0.0024705145,
0.0192184448,
-0.0072373981,
-0.0147965671,
-0.037438266,
-0.0218410566,
0.0401692092,
-0.0373033024,
-0.0076213293,
0.0373895429,
0.0012471059,
-0.0387154296,
0.061588522,
-0.0541776344,
-0.0359588303,
-0.0555160604,
0.0206285473,
-0.0485260077,
0.0554562882,
0.048512172,
-0.0277452301,
0.0161545202,
-0.0555261187,
-0.027039241,
0.0414724164,
0.0070993211,
0.0019146437,
0.0336123183,
0.0162796658,
0.0155087505,
-0.0361687317,
-0.0438566729,
-0.0270374287,
-0.0195370223,
0.0092664976,
0.015289342,
0.0347728617,
-0.025688054,
-0.0406380743,
0.0256948061,
0.0500003695,
0.0778454319,
-0.0421002693,
-0.0285954606,
-0.0363140777,
0.0612135343,
0.0468927696,
-0.0302626174,
0.0733679906,
-0.089291431,
0.00905775,
0.053018745,
0.0260911845,
0.0204866622,
-0.0036816893,
-0.0242985431,
0.00023226,
-0.0476054251,
-0.0234495401,
-0.0005296076,
0.0269495957,
-0.0894593671,
-0.0289639253,
0.0849156678,
0.0345524028,
-0.0664197206,
-0.0102663785,
-0.0311107337,
0.0293245725,
0.0200451855,
0.0058658654,
-0.0951318741,
-0.0256233793,
0.0400152542,
0.0158220213,
0.0073047099,
-0.017889386,
0.0160943475,
-0.0719567463,
0.0499668531,
-0.026860062,
-0.0059420941,
-0.0054030051,
-0.0596410409,
0.0111992508,
0.0028537649,
0.037686795,
-0.000777657,
-0.0570004806,
-0.0141472928,
0.0116477869,
-0.0404761434,
0.0141668711,
0.0110710124,
-0.012497982,
-0.0085988753,
0.0819396675,
-0.0167433061,
0.0138197942,
0.0039093951,
0.0279567987,
-0.0249179918,
0.0250706933,
0.0110181896,
0.0537505187,
-0.0167653132,
0.0356240347,
-0.0328679904,
0.0231872033,
-0.043918971,
-0.0000550675,
-0.0066011259,
0.0467849933,
-0.0088919103,
-0.0525958091,
-0.0288547538,
-0.0068295165,
-0.0229748338,
0.0619679727,
0.0304198768,
-0.0038457094,
-0.0551447347,
-0.0129422378,
0.0201974437,
-0.0074618761,
-0.0150034698,
0.0268823113,
-0.0092418212,
0.0101797869,
-0.0793769881,
-0.0728886351,
0.0108485036,
-0.0024398495,
-0.0228411593,
-0.0040808055,
-0.0015834827,
-0.0419292711,
-0.0636705831,
0.0447320752,
-0.0116776917,
0.0061157495,
-0.0640985519,
0.0162107926,
0.02842783,
0.0041545331,
0.0005885009,
0.0444965996,
-0.0983274058,
-0.0431812592,
0.0327039436,
-0.0092157042,
0.0216932185,
0.0540584251,
-0.0186262261,
-0.0215171203,
0.05048161,
-0.0028789386,
-0.074372232,
0.024547644,
0.0196102597,
-0.0606306866,
-0.005112459,
0.0085417544,
-0.020171212,
0.0233890843,
0.0009386406,
0.0192882381,
0.030835567,
0.0115352869,
0.0112557486,
0.0179764424,
0.0553404689,
0.0284236651,
0.0229997132,
-0.0241656415,
0.0283309817,
-0.0534458272,
-0.0264126677,
0.0019805017,
-0.0034635279,
0.0220881552,
0.0301836003,
-0.0077915429,
0.1003422588,
0.0059555583,
0.0480110459,
-0.0445440374,
0.0060632988,
0.0499523431,
-0.0487732515,
0.0167915169,
0.0082245572,
0.0151651083,
-0.0032294418,
0.003309841,
0.0681578889,
-0.0166679975,
0.0774068534,
0.052066613,
0.0037515557,
-0.0292090513,
0.0131068844,
-0.0885129869,
0.0009994915,
-0.0335386544,
-0.0097136572,
-0.0083300536,
-0.0455430374,
0.0762264207,
-0.0505388603,
-0.0022715039,
0.0133982776,
0.0163223334,
0.0068677054,
-0.0074497964,
0.0072110733,
0.0311796945,
-0.0087758144,
-0.0092097735,
0.0753252059,
0.0284438469,
0.0228670016,
0.0060643954,
-0.0195241738,
-0.0221960787,
-0.0152171589,
0.0266540013,
0.0088896183,
-0.0080150478,
-0.0270553231,
-0.0261479467,
-0.0180265531,
0.0508349054,
-0.0186188221,
0.0083022779,
-0.0343147889,
0.019802494,
0.0773252174,
-0.0014540296,
-0.0718124062,
-0.009988131,
-0.0145510612,
-0.0005706576,
-0.0247489549,
-0.0121679688,
-5.998802608e-33,
-0.0420426726,
-0.0444805697,
0.004467418,
0.0229698941,
-0.0234312173,
0.0507417917,
-0.0426259525,
-0.0248852056,
0.0261915922,
0.0423504002,
-0.0355218165,
0.0374636389,
0.0265994109,
0.0158841778,
0.0299205035,
-0.0096638566,
0.0488371849,
-0.0144306133,
-0.0489183627,
0.0118040936,
0.0211737491,
0.0093590282,
0.0759724304,
-0.017936606,
0.0211371984,
0.0338065401,
0.0170799643,
-0.0172741152,
-0.0173130166,
0.0698680654,
-0.036243055,
-0.0197434258,
0.0446106791,
-0.0509800538,
-0.034028843,
0.056331262,
-0.1018778831,
0.0213532969,
0.0011008856,
0.0243539717,
-0.0624421388,
-0.0130212242,
0.0397543721,
-0.0159157384,
0.0623104684,
-0.061661493,
0.0501892231,
-0.0007077219,
0.0124328472,
-0.0362687223,
-0.0942741558,
0.0395727046,
-0.0028575277,
0.0015221242,
0.0307740588,
0.0261111315,
0.0095010381,
0.0476742983,
-0.0530867241,
-0.0320413634,
-0.0014673034,
0.0767879412,
0.0139579512,
0.0288339015,
-0.0238092896,
0.0386074744,
0.0388518721,
0.0622711778,
-0.0158616751,
-0.0246059448,
0.0424820147,
0.0265255459,
0.0454888307,
-0.006921493,
0.0891893283,
0.0574195534,
-0.0376744121,
0.0127329556,
0.0179090258,
0.0432917848,
0.0131123429,
0.0105117057,
-0.0230276603,
-0.0038446281,
-0.0236605797,
-0.0007773974,
-0.0248164944,
-0.0122940019,
0.0153648285,
0.0435647555,
0.0004634989,
-0.003479447,
0.0497678667,
-0.0053028059,
0.0233279541,
0.0035646087,
-0.034753792,
0.054334119,
-0.0167420935,
-0.0049896473,
-0.0558259971,
-0.0010963862,
0.0507530347,
0.0161941405,
-0.0061460552,
-0.0099591529,
0.0672421604,
0.005670764,
-0.0817158967,
-0.0051012887,
-0.010044178,
0.0219420437,
0.0052154548,
0.0315650441,
0.0485277884,
0.0125732981,
-0.0222415347,
0.0818005502,
0.02943369,
0.0236881431,
-0.0361683331,
-0.0156806558,
0.0067193783,
0.0114684226,
-0.0155226197,
-0.0186456144,
-0.0463791378,
-0.0166494697,
0.0446605384,
-0.0612317994,
0.0038603577,
0.0432900451,
2.399e-7,
0.0513990968,
0.0478451848,
0.086067766,
0.0228772312,
0.020260267,
-0.0078157205,
0.0038505998,
0.0330308303,
0.0051660025,
-0.041369915,
-0.0260616113,
-0.0128623489,
0.0546822101,
0.039093025,
-0.0919088125,
-0.0338864475,
-0.0730588213,
-0.0193948485,
-0.0632558912,
-0.0522779189,
-0.0034898338,
0.0669635311,
-0.054468438,
-0.0077475635,
0.0015540759,
-0.0229396205,
0.0678207576,
0.019129904,
0.0077768434,
0.0307509601,
0.0364324003,
-0.0337372199,
0.0121889012,
0.0070507526,
-0.006477512,
0.034880273,
0.0055861445,
0.0500453673,
0.0256546643,
-0.0241370592,
0.0080157798,
-0.0093306834,
-0.0133771058,
-0.0204264186,
0.0467620455,
-0.0908012092,
-0.034961313,
-0.029008558,
-0.0595406182,
-0.0326780938,
-0.0157179125,
0.0112286983,
0.0088644447,
0.0519909486,
0.0170174353,
-0.0040072929,
-0.0189330671,
-0.0855597407,
-0.0271994565,
0.0104665942,
-0.0317906365,
-0.004571246,
-0.0493013337,
-0.0276307743,
-0.0070832805,
-0.0621638857,
-0.0432332158,
2.556330805e-34,
0.0279883202,
-0.0065825051,
-0.014961536,
0.0133040473,
0.0561612174,
-0.0559552573,
0.0036634067,
0.0082851527,
-0.0251511876,
-0.1167765334,
-0.027204724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17633v1 | Navigating the OverKill in Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | Chenyu Shi, Xiao Wang, Qiming Ge, Songyang Gao, Xianjun Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Xun Zhao, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models are meticulously aligned to be both helpful and
harmless. However, recent research points to a potential overkill which means
models may refuse to answer benign queries. In this paper, we investigate the
factors for overkill by exploring how models handle and determine the safety of
queries. Our findings reveal the presence of shortcuts within models, leading
to an over-attention of harmful words like 'kill' and prompts emphasizing
safety will exacerbate overkill. Based on these insights, we introduce
Self-Contrastive Decoding (Self-CD), a training-free and model-agnostic
strategy, to alleviate this phenomenon. We first extract such over-attention by
amplifying the difference in the model's output distributions when responding
to system prompts that either include or omit an emphasis on safety. Then we
determine the final next-token predictions by downplaying the over-attention
from the model via contrastive decoding. Empirical results indicate that our
method has achieved an average reduction of the refusal rate by 20\% while
having almost no impact on safety. | [
0.0374060273,
0.0537730232,
-0.0193113349,
0.0402015224,
-0.0103304135,
0.0322071761,
-0.0168314539,
0.0000393716,
-0.0162533168,
-0.0425282158,
-0.0401927009,
-0.020454688,
-0.0158194434,
0.0140191885,
0.0161982048,
-0.035927169,
0.0615582913,
-0.0665526241,
0.0151547519,
-0.0053228582,
-0.0103710378,
0.0146982893,
0.0056284871,
0.0533703752,
0.0228790306,
-0.0333507098,
-0.0116531542,
0.0232701059,
-0.0168735683,
-0.050905332,
0.0103356969,
0.0559021942,
0.0013458995,
0.032556776,
0.0000019991,
-0.047057081,
0.0104549583,
-0.0103480043,
-0.0587117299,
0.0310494117,
0.0636700466,
-0.0327893831,
-0.0067766611,
0.0154643813,
-0.0260004774,
-0.0387971364,
0.0494105332,
0.0709198788,
0.0259333923,
0.0571693629,
0.0041307225,
-0.0249943696,
0.0160945021,
0.0023926001,
-0.0371428691,
-0.0474209823,
0.018464243,
-0.0093074404,
0.0046732449,
0.0112586832,
-0.0550926775,
0.0649248064,
0.0213398356,
0.014899076,
-0.036727909,
0.0355490036,
-0.0024957352,
-0.0360652693,
-0.0251424108,
0.0660246983,
-0.0564613864,
-0.0253740139,
0.0101151867,
-0.023462018,
0.0000789062,
-0.044648502,
-0.0154681476,
0.0036415872,
-0.0036198737,
0.0107165892,
0.0399297327,
0.0352324918,
0.0239989255,
0.0002587601,
-0.0219543986,
0.0423828848,
0.0137109524,
-0.0212700535,
0.0308078323,
-0.0126832416,
0.0001300043,
-0.0522530228,
-0.0028745884,
0.0083080921,
-0.071150139,
0.0213979762,
-0.0449506566,
-0.0314738601,
0.0394161902,
-0.082976073,
0.029895734,
0.0450958945,
-0.0321372636,
0.0316748656,
-0.0091357836,
0.0141266109,
-0.0178181827,
0.0175357666,
-0.0350385569,
0.0196315274,
-0.0127817094,
-0.0113284448,
-0.0618848391,
0.0236666296,
-0.0188966747,
-0.0144861061,
-0.0191251449,
0.0315764211,
0.0067703133,
-0.0253080707,
0.0051882057,
0.0254100617,
-0.0465640835,
-0.0130905518,
0.0152954636,
0.0244021509,
-0.0221516415,
-0.0033151633,
-0.0075844568,
-0.0680435672,
-0.006096181,
-0.0103894891,
-0.0215553492,
-0.0536520891,
-0.0107532805,
0.0927500799,
-0.0178246778,
-0.0273400508,
-0.0300853942,
0.0013687673,
-0.0292888507,
-0.0380225778,
-0.0219783355,
-0.0511469021,
0.0048864335,
0.0097594382,
-0.0052441512,
-0.0425773971,
0.0136700394,
0.0016838151,
-0.0498471297,
0.0875309929,
0.0139090987,
0.0095718289,
0.0186864436,
0.0216196831,
-0.0146849686,
0.0987104177,
0.0119042518,
0.0312683545,
0.0232539047,
-0.0053647417,
0.0383448265,
0.0327110551,
0.0041091512,
0.0119802691,
-0.0484440774,
0.0205928758,
0.0032095355,
-0.0079756156,
0.0701681003,
0.0878266618,
-0.0159189198,
-0.0404094309,
0.0572528504,
0.0171164218,
0.0009482888,
0.0095439171,
0.0456523187,
0.0378457457,
-0.023444334,
0.0231733657,
-0.0822599232,
0.0152880158,
-0.0383883417,
0.0052709645,
0.0094104754,
0.0203772373,
-0.0312448107,
-0.0229093935,
0.0020869919,
-0.0016034257,
0.0304348804,
0.0302726068,
0.0512455814,
0.0075990008,
-0.0503301956,
0.0142300697,
0.0232435409,
-0.0316321179,
-0.008029893,
-0.0734139681,
0.0031912981,
0.0754740983,
0.052390296,
0.0206610393,
-0.0185705405,
0.0108542992,
0.0048506185,
0.0402948558,
0.0446435958,
-0.0051632412,
0.0447645821,
-0.03599317,
-0.0436344817,
0.0292646531,
0.0164274555,
0.0041654287,
0.0038580033,
-0.0021844378,
0.0084143933,
-0.0213762317,
-0.0616868138,
0.0424585231,
0.0028343054,
-0.0781067982,
-0.0088328365,
0.0113150487,
0.0042832517,
-0.0188149828,
-0.0076626339,
0.0177094042,
0.0145774707,
-0.014805628,
0.006374293,
-0.0082105566,
-0.0802262351,
-0.0268758181,
0.0205676388,
-0.0056821182,
-0.0128996652,
0.0542047806,
-0.0106085883,
-0.0267063752,
0.0111629283,
-0.0720774978,
0.059220884,
-0.0019919761,
0.037021488,
-0.0060415058,
-0.0061476654,
-0.035409309,
0.0452347919,
-0.0177952871,
-0.0167902447,
-0.0000649001,
0.0064582406,
0.0036655825,
-0.0467738546,
-0.0605797246,
0.0205019936,
-0.0160853863,
0.0290909596,
0.0206455979,
0.0102024395,
-0.0346039645,
0.004720639,
-0.05347142,
-0.0178088993,
-0.0299925059,
-0.0032538795,
0.0281354375,
0.0013577868,
-0.0281727184,
-0.0300822984,
0.0084473612,
-0.0157032069,
-0.006197033,
0.0455130115,
-0.0134090614,
0.0229388177,
-0.0166560151,
-0.039142549,
-0.0304728597,
-0.0103535112,
0.0311854966,
-0.0471714102,
-0.0398501083,
-0.0407857336,
0.0761940181,
0.0258962195,
0.0450567044,
-0.0039236019,
-0.0809536129,
0.0287101101,
-0.0018768434,
0.0085619837,
0.0875997692,
0.014296256,
0.0025638335,
0.0917848721,
-0.0086268224,
-0.0707854182,
0.0157247391,
-0.0225911811,
-0.0681796595,
-0.0168776847,
-0.0393982641,
-0.0130582899,
0.0988116115,
0.0184689071,
0.0218904261,
-0.0727411509,
-0.0194583088,
-0.0417137146,
-0.0812062323,
-0.0208283011,
-0.0242759604,
-0.0316361859,
0.0512537658,
0.0063348808,
-0.0310806278,
0.0897054151,
0.0161228944,
0.0026762481,
-0.0168004297,
0.0025223871,
0.0076792166,
0.0539373271,
-0.0341068916,
0.0222178195,
0.0537450835,
-0.0750047043,
-0.0387808979,
-0.050722044,
-0.0087963464,
-0.0297857281,
0.0619741008,
-0.0275690779,
-0.0063777831,
0.0004467119,
-0.0619677193,
-0.0659099668,
-0.0424457937,
-0.0582841076,
-0.0119880326,
0.0305627026,
-0.0234461799,
-0.0055704424,
-0.0034035454,
0.0019971712,
0.0314417593,
-0.035045173,
-0.0121888677,
-0.0202674083,
0.0004399148,
0.0880396962,
-0.0323525406,
0.0436595641,
-0.0306246169,
0.066878058,
0.0806392729,
0.0220814683,
-0.0084449947,
-0.0223515145,
0.0263119396,
0.0538044982,
-0.0099570062,
-0.0156912543,
0.0578059852,
0.0210141707,
-0.0653774887,
-0.0298366565,
0.090251483,
0.0215474907,
-0.0555896983,
0.0302246176,
-0.0405668281,
0.0449237451,
0.0256592482,
0.026728807,
-0.0390168987,
-0.0486329868,
0.0164415482,
0.0538393967,
-0.014121592,
-0.0184160825,
0.0150495721,
-0.1192034334,
0.0379591212,
0.0148784909,
-0.0402033404,
-0.0043031075,
0.0028728219,
0.0102305943,
-0.025194589,
0.0375570059,
0.0402961783,
-0.0298587233,
-0.0226318296,
0.0224995874,
-0.0107433135,
-0.0409133919,
0.0331542566,
-0.0382312387,
0.0670733079,
0.0803690255,
0.0078198826,
-0.0006732378,
-0.0108725252,
0.0349739566,
-0.0313227959,
0.016103439,
-0.0229950231,
0.0621689856,
-0.0191935189,
-0.0035661513,
-0.0330331251,
0.0022274929,
-0.0074127084,
-0.023716582,
0.0121435877,
0.059337642,
-0.028988177,
-0.0387819111,
-0.0349729545,
0.019990731,
0.0421899706,
0.0931565538,
0.0411355346,
-0.0524331331,
-0.0479897447,
-0.0246320944,
-0.0226662382,
-0.0670743063,
-0.0401670262,
0.0004900242,
-0.0093711866,
-0.0453016348,
-0.0416938141,
-0.0546834134,
0.0313591175,
0.0006139486,
0.0156080648,
-0.0061291922,
-0.0200766847,
0.0162323806,
-0.0255325437,
0.0099368859,
-0.0142521178,
-0.0029987756,
-0.0703939199,
0.033246357,
0.0152061358,
-0.0015184414,
-0.0010399608,
0.0318896323,
-0.0271024033,
-0.0853378028,
0.0346563607,
0.0681670457,
0.0257324018,
0.0151592446,
-0.0283324551,
-0.0906058326,
0.0330648161,
0.0490689874,
-0.0505447946,
0.006636973,
0.0613091476,
-0.0254593883,
0.0129669979,
0.0445317551,
-0.0433316156,
0.0115453545,
0.0385048054,
0.0623472072,
-0.0551850572,
-0.0274368916,
0.0319353603,
0.0090607861,
0.038466651,
-0.0342293233,
0.0036293408,
-0.0161177237,
0.0159806367,
-0.0204330254,
-0.0089947032,
-0.0277666375,
0.0427237377,
0.0163234621,
0.0100190649,
-0.0096442625,
-0.0204507876,
-0.0357762016,
-0.0001721607,
-0.0076268073,
0.0055459673,
0.0214558356,
-0.0021908432,
0.0554068945,
0.0208502226,
-0.0501156747,
0.038671881,
0.0252370145,
0.0343225561,
0.0051299161,
0.0339489169,
0.0126634566,
-0.0008638425,
-0.0199414082,
0.0340380333,
-0.0551756285,
-0.0709355921,
-0.0102183055,
-0.0295122955,
0.0258286987,
-0.0165455174,
0.0436700583,
-0.023388274,
0.0071637584,
-0.0387014709,
0.0141027123,
-0.00774195,
-0.0146707455,
0.0172213688,
0.0413544811,
-0.0172247943,
-0.0187229794,
0.0671872348,
-0.0141117955,
0.0532705486,
0.0419321731,
0.0050000446,
-0.0260138307,
-0.0264695864,
0.0319198295,
0.026444938,
-0.0596753508,
-0.0027629484,
-0.079995133,
-0.080423981,
-0.0240372624,
0.0325325206,
-0.0093356259,
-0.0162518099,
0.0349764563,
0.0244074687,
0.0167287756,
-0.0494981557,
-0.0378920212,
0.0153022036,
0.004703037,
-0.0218613725,
-0.0413246937,
-6.164680289e-33,
-0.0172737241,
-0.0045771012,
0.0067596929,
-0.0341127962,
-0.001306025,
-0.0072845132,
-0.025365442,
0.0417200439,
-0.0362560153,
0.0189535469,
-0.0347365476,
0.0289440285,
0.0186493471,
0.0011713038,
0.043496497,
-0.0206380058,
0.0309724025,
-0.0094734589,
-0.0281710103,
0.0160432085,
0.0335779898,
0.0383309983,
0.0500090607,
-0.0800991058,
0.0058369027,
0.0251445621,
-0.0070368429,
0.0213424042,
-0.0100460658,
0.0658436343,
-0.0253427327,
0.0553740114,
0.0085300272,
-0.0235135052,
-0.037221022,
0.0369877331,
-0.0589179657,
-0.015134058,
0.0532492548,
-0.0075853267,
-0.0240389705,
-0.0472872742,
0.0305746309,
-0.001472063,
-0.0398395546,
-0.0308821592,
0.0065559573,
-0.0275845788,
-0.0190259032,
-0.0142493155,
-0.0693374649,
0.0129137207,
-0.0002000195,
-0.0349487513,
0.03304483,
0.0704175532,
-0.0152954431,
0.0229986235,
-0.0350188762,
0.0105692092,
0.0468107872,
0.0373428576,
0.0826260671,
0.0491251163,
-0.0115858139,
0.0422002338,
0.0026314505,
-0.0097950343,
0.0097453576,
-0.0401012264,
0.0418644324,
0.059195742,
0.0336022414,
0.029498307,
0.0579867549,
-0.0272285081,
-0.0311899018,
-0.0002855636,
-0.0300961453,
0.0584991835,
0.0457530096,
0.011989207,
-0.0815567523,
-0.0493683778,
-0.009211095,
-0.0143242935,
-0.0362561345,
-0.0402282476,
0.0533187687,
0.0031174398,
-0.0122654848,
-0.0108455615,
0.0340407938,
-0.0340646394,
0.0177069865,
0.0195947569,
0.0087129464,
0.0034812954,
-0.0101297395,
0.0327584222,
-0.0280208047,
0.0023837062,
0.0005956747,
-0.0191614516,
0.0132754343,
0.013859449,
0.0166234747,
0.0260041244,
-0.0718341097,
-0.0168905668,
-0.0205747746,
0.0165429786,
0.0146537293,
0.0097450754,
0.0563682057,
-0.0106854299,
0.0029441721,
0.0159448739,
0.0076615149,
-0.0333327167,
-0.0598048829,
0.0056175175,
0.003579942,
0.0296956711,
-0.010821051,
-0.0059940265,
-0.0330541506,
0.0494821221,
0.0561936982,
-0.0540086366,
-0.0268624537,
0.0377789736,
2.663e-7,
0.0398266949,
0.0408870392,
0.0202301033,
0.0368665755,
-0.0281301346,
0.0700969771,
-0.0007643341,
0.0506926887,
0.0368062481,
-0.0071910322,
0.0244805533,
0.0353692546,
0.0567581095,
0.0323812403,
-0.0705452785,
0.0100588398,
-0.067336306,
0.0166483298,
-0.0480632819,
-0.0305530149,
0.06290856,
0.099969998,
-0.0071146088,
-0.0152828675,
0.0059572607,
-0.0166939162,
0.0045469832,
-0.0495182052,
0.0181033537,
0.0035092621,
0.0067117885,
0.0079148849,
0.0223821364,
0.031810578,
-0.0034349994,
-0.0144579876,
-0.0082694087,
0.0752787516,
-0.0222472511,
-0.0640147775,
0.0085166367,
-0.0193609893,
-0.0116624078,
-0.080065757,
0.0523470715,
-0.0623977184,
-0.0120472098,
-0.0284667183,
0.0040675434,
0.0083308555,
-0.0173510816,
-0.0467268713,
-0.0185148716,
0.0048132641,
0.0403997079,
0.0080753742,
-0.0025396773,
-0.0691352934,
-0.0179045387,
0.0276657809,
0.0033063567,
-0.0780514628,
-0.0275396537,
0.0445416197,
0.0213066358,
-0.0464674011,
-0.0035420384,
2.23327006e-34,
0.0408239067,
0.0082797455,
0.0372889489,
0.027030047,
0.0150795467,
0.0215923376,
-0.0146923279,
0.0277671888,
0.0352008939,
-0.0735009983,
-0.0492937826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17632v1 | What Do Self-Supervised Speech and Speaker Models Learn? New Findings From a Cross Model Layer-Wise Analysis | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | Takanori Ashihara, Marc Delcroix, Takafumi Moriya, Kohei Matsuura, Taichi Asami, Yusuke Ijima | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning (SSL) has attracted increased attention for learning
meaningful speech representations. Speech SSL models, such as WavLM, employ
masked prediction training to encode general-purpose representations. In
contrast, speaker SSL models, exemplified by DINO-based models, adopt
utterance-level training objectives primarily for speaker representation.
Understanding how these models represent information is essential for refining
model efficiency and effectiveness. Unlike the various analyses of speech SSL,
there has been limited investigation into what information speaker SSL captures
and how its representation differs from speech SSL or other fully-supervised
speaker models. This paper addresses these fundamental questions. We explore
the capacity to capture various speech properties by applying SUPERB evaluation
probing tasks to speech and speaker SSL models. We also examine which layers
are predominantly utilized for each task to identify differences in how speech
is represented. Furthermore, we conduct direct comparisons to measure the
similarities between layers within and across models. Our analysis unveils that
1) the capacity to represent content information is somewhat unrelated to
enhanced speaker representation, 2) specific layers of speech SSL models would
be partly specialized in capturing linguistic information, and 3) speaker SSL
models tend to disregard linguistic information but exhibit more sophisticated
speaker representation. | [
-0.0250066854,
0.0501082316,
-0.0085399095,
0.0368477739,
-0.0143849179,
-0.0109299514,
0.0704438686,
-0.0410735384,
-0.0292737521,
-0.0154552506,
-0.0942342579,
0.0159996469,
0.0295330081,
-0.0321522094,
0.0066680475,
-0.0621738769,
0.028777495,
-0.0338893458,
-0.011705067,
-0.0295378286,
-0.0028172878,
-0.0038628676,
-0.0116237598,
0.0228019226,
-0.0184126142,
-0.0297200326,
-0.0230480377,
0.0019402059,
0.0046340432,
0.0248307176,
-0.0245560408,
0.0418320112,
0.0577125959,
0.0161038376,
0.0000019095,
-0.0229493249,
0.0049920678,
-0.0147047127,
-0.0740341246,
0.0443479456,
0.0226694979,
0.0165841021,
-0.0266155116,
0.0088925399,
-0.0074089942,
-0.0376025178,
0.0073960493,
0.0528194755,
0.0315296464,
0.032512188,
0.0224012565,
-0.0531714819,
0.0055283285,
-0.0007963308,
0.0155621925,
-0.0212756712,
-0.0118558425,
-0.0316913426,
-0.0195581168,
-0.0039886548,
-0.0203570463,
0.0595505424,
-0.0045841844,
-0.0056848475,
0.0484358706,
0.0229618251,
0.0091871228,
-0.0285994336,
0.0255367216,
0.0144577157,
0.0086567523,
-0.0020321333,
-0.0083586331,
0.0060115396,
0.0066880262,
-0.0109944372,
0.0209020637,
0.0044577857,
0.0384387448,
-0.0074093151,
-0.0320718102,
0.0888708159,
0.0313811935,
-0.0257088002,
-0.020358311,
0.059253078,
-0.0316116996,
-0.0363718979,
-0.006282982,
-0.0411019623,
0.0594245903,
0.0198089406,
0.0242383592,
-0.0265168678,
0.0193870161,
-0.0123618459,
-0.0171510503,
-0.0061916579,
-0.0100374809,
-0.0418052524,
0.0229630452,
0.0074440683,
-0.0574948564,
0.0021881738,
-0.0243898276,
0.0772478208,
0.01400059,
0.0150475074,
-0.0063360524,
0.0160931423,
-0.0448012203,
-0.0030403633,
-0.045997642,
0.0433559157,
-0.0020341342,
-0.0098461509,
-0.0339701474,
0.0157029778,
-0.0485891849,
0.0041934266,
-0.0146280816,
0.0342147909,
-0.0185296908,
0.0042218212,
-0.0069422326,
0.0307696108,
0.0187386721,
0.0264376067,
0.0045573097,
-0.0367573202,
-0.0040655285,
-0.0066063222,
0.0512266792,
-0.0056093228,
-0.0007378981,
0.0640490651,
0.0369491838,
-0.0406518951,
-0.0063638487,
-0.0064344509,
-0.0435865261,
-0.0431474671,
0.000954412,
-0.0450842753,
0.0078497417,
-0.023505073,
0.0199435875,
-0.0380052738,
-0.0204484705,
-0.035094779,
0.0407084785,
0.0586755425,
0.0091945399,
0.0272571165,
0.0465034731,
0.016635377,
0.0185715128,
-0.0035334723,
0.0254176557,
-0.0109049277,
-0.0172782131,
-0.1035699323,
0.009739046,
0.0204142593,
0.0436848626,
-0.0317162238,
-0.0217331313,
0.0223377254,
0.0002603515,
0.0450186916,
0.0615738332,
0.0012459368,
-0.0337971374,
-0.0761752427,
0.0912663341,
0.0713854581,
0.03964727,
0.0362639576,
0.0366231948,
0.0233613774,
0.0553267747,
0.0388577655,
-0.040216472,
0.0102041643,
0.0047899317,
-0.0078427084,
0.0136307124,
0.0022141119,
-0.0588748865,
-0.0474540256,
0.0085965721,
-0.0377503,
0.00475212,
0.0064174202,
-0.0020879067,
0.0281466637,
-0.0163381416,
0.0272388719,
0.0131522492,
-0.0204276871,
-0.0011061643,
-0.0723179132,
-0.007118098,
0.0243830476,
-0.0387596823,
0.0023639973,
0.0030812777,
-0.0383522362,
-0.0420636758,
0.0262450203,
0.0112990867,
0.0185180046,
0.0788605362,
0.0101883803,
-0.0307719503,
-0.0438582674,
0.0069887787,
0.0611622147,
-0.0352695584,
-0.0411939137,
0.029520547,
-0.0565345325,
0.0040422361,
-0.0129060401,
-0.0008437803,
-0.0664808527,
0.0430130288,
0.0123998728,
0.0398653708,
0.0315234624,
-0.0379333571,
0.0140532162,
0.0179086123,
-0.0008138869,
-0.0305933766,
0.0006398716,
-0.1210333779,
-0.032984253,
0.0157935787,
-0.0300096329,
0.0209804904,
0.0827939436,
0.0229860228,
-0.0534529798,
0.0788402334,
-0.0441418253,
0.035012126,
-0.0550668985,
0.0071522193,
0.0124406051,
0.0525556058,
0.0392288528,
0.0438949428,
0.0310564451,
-0.0426747911,
0.0049940692,
0.0595719181,
0.0166941769,
-0.0744423866,
-0.0327195749,
-0.023827726,
-0.0375278592,
0.0462370329,
-0.0031575819,
-0.0367868654,
-0.0311544109,
-0.0011371414,
-0.0714064687,
-0.0138924606,
-0.0251681581,
-0.0093898978,
0.0034186393,
-0.00375126,
-0.0092001567,
-0.039438419,
-0.0159437675,
-0.0902918875,
-0.0173302703,
-0.0150377639,
-0.0423896089,
0.0128094591,
-0.0072474969,
-0.0340959094,
-0.0125546716,
0.0083904313,
0.0174993724,
-0.0332853831,
-0.0082431491,
0.0014317294,
-0.021894265,
-0.0064098323,
0.0042330413,
0.0369166285,
-0.0161906928,
-0.0072842087,
0.0159085356,
-0.0109782713,
0.0590964369,
0.0375576429,
0.0251937862,
0.0101434411,
-0.0260554459,
-0.0573761761,
0.0276983697,
-0.0123549737,
0.0505220145,
-0.0377369374,
0.0232967939,
-0.0214301236,
0.0744924992,
0.035036277,
0.0093457894,
-0.0420570001,
-0.0012868391,
-0.0113970488,
-0.085412696,
-0.0134133035,
-0.0219493061,
-0.0268733297,
0.0140687469,
0.0032822802,
-0.0449805185,
0.0302308593,
-0.0741477683,
-0.0329933539,
-0.0303684324,
-0.0741037428,
0.0036525954,
0.0155301727,
-0.0038363126,
0.0372845195,
0.0191473775,
-0.0285477508,
-0.0007511719,
-0.026144769,
0.036217466,
-0.0331907384,
-0.037594486,
0.035415329,
-0.0150642004,
0.0109983413,
-0.0292797312,
-0.0372557044,
-0.0357801318,
-0.0098353857,
0.0150614399,
-0.0124295698,
0.0099793784,
0.0020590497,
0.0067851483,
0.0137515971,
-0.0099700261,
-0.0235990491,
0.0061205947,
-0.0082407976,
0.0317774341,
0.0043825111,
0.0380486846,
0.0254237428,
0.0194424242,
0.0598273389,
-0.0313921645,
0.0738200098,
0.0423188135,
-0.0597521886,
0.0393626466,
-0.0022154825,
-0.0035998209,
-0.0356458202,
0.0384370312,
0.0423128866,
-0.0454637744,
0.0107530328,
0.1235087216,
0.0085623479,
-0.0038321721,
-0.0261737332,
-0.0154171614,
-0.0337815396,
-0.0012019633,
0.0120156603,
-0.00106512,
0.0091788955,
0.0052462541,
0.025822293,
0.0036951106,
0.0261286367,
0.0111205941,
-0.0748209208,
0.0541029647,
0.0174471345,
-0.040076796,
0.0084772501,
-0.0615164228,
-0.0142938951,
-0.0387525111,
0.0742884502,
-0.018101899,
-0.0408231765,
-0.035640493,
0.0522076301,
-0.0750824064,
-0.0098338714,
0.0630385801,
-0.0175447073,
0.0797642171,
0.067839615,
0.0304010622,
-0.0165328085,
-0.049151592,
-0.008315132,
-0.0370501131,
0.0270902943,
-0.0146318683,
0.0652676523,
0.0127792303,
-0.0142345242,
0.0012770097,
0.0364758112,
0.0167639535,
-0.0135809882,
-0.0434837304,
0.0386707783,
-0.0074460297,
-0.0203338116,
-0.0114257829,
0.0596263595,
-0.0054668649,
0.0699906126,
0.0599805117,
-0.0335768275,
-0.0425991006,
0.0270947088,
0.0636021867,
0.0001676735,
-0.0536830127,
0.0697923675,
0.0414970927,
-0.0607011095,
0.0176763553,
-0.0608462654,
-0.0274938066,
0.0182154085,
-0.0170985293,
-0.0041175028,
-0.0266542304,
-0.0054881466,
-0.0109934565,
0.0375035703,
-0.0247917511,
0.0223174319,
0.007121481,
-0.0266223326,
0.0423682816,
-0.050857123,
-0.0148192933,
-0.0140689425,
-0.047957845,
-0.0351512283,
0.0342360996,
0.0211097337,
0.0193326082,
0.0818522796,
-0.0246313605,
-0.0573694035,
0.1125056148,
0.0219202582,
-0.0775290653,
0.0179422628,
0.0947867483,
-0.0237163138,
-0.027505802,
0.0301979799,
-0.0189278405,
0.0693441108,
-0.0256486218,
-0.0438550524,
-0.0032752922,
-0.0630486757,
0.033152476,
-0.0171793867,
0.0483867005,
0.0130249774,
0.0417698324,
-0.0057828329,
0.0003206953,
-0.0079910867,
0.0301490147,
-0.0148577299,
-0.0537269898,
0.0407874957,
0.0485927463,
0.02592903,
0.0226300731,
-0.0530971773,
0.0393398777,
-0.0347585566,
0.0147551131,
0.0055280896,
-0.0333329923,
-0.0592754707,
0.0646803752,
-0.0044653537,
0.0203877594,
0.0489687808,
0.0068600615,
0.0425678454,
-0.0036768802,
-0.032874763,
0.0552381538,
-0.0128517551,
0.0173000656,
-0.0806380659,
-0.0496294051,
-0.0103385225,
-0.0182495117,
0.0080446238,
-0.0365420058,
0.0184058268,
0.0193038583,
0.0355168916,
-0.0281784274,
0.002865904,
-0.0332756899,
0.026733838,
0.0384559669,
-0.0243785009,
-0.0190252271,
-0.0480061807,
0.0260133129,
0.0371218622,
0.0325208046,
-0.0188661218,
0.0388456024,
-0.0422262661,
-0.0319153145,
-0.009621474,
0.0100712925,
-0.0234728847,
-0.0533353537,
-0.0208649486,
-0.0859821737,
0.0519591235,
-0.0205381904,
0.0212687217,
-0.0077239615,
0.0208469797,
-0.0002686963,
-0.0204710104,
-0.0007034565,
0.0230546966,
-0.0414395258,
0.0211766846,
0.0072441106,
0.0748516023,
-6.083872766e-33,
-0.0424984097,
0.0414085053,
0.0179352593,
-0.0041684248,
0.0107936719,
0.0304980893,
-0.0092499694,
0.0405261591,
0.0020633047,
0.0061425348,
-0.0122271031,
0.0003615909,
0.0337814577,
0.0191937089,
-0.0240339749,
-0.0071574925,
0.0953361169,
-0.0340117216,
0.0125942053,
0.0050087092,
-0.0006163372,
0.031487029,
0.0337344557,
-0.1096956655,
-0.0203641113,
0.0073917657,
-0.0190388653,
-0.0555941276,
0.0088638775,
0.0756103992,
-0.0435251519,
0.015809048,
-0.0101530254,
-0.0408898816,
-0.0774236992,
0.0463110209,
-0.0932696164,
-0.0313945375,
0.001853316,
0.0189822596,
-0.0413668342,
-0.0263858419,
0.044647187,
0.0244171843,
-0.0444758162,
-0.0549055077,
0.0509914123,
0.0238802154,
-0.0092040319,
-0.0223911647,
-0.0049918634,
0.0153942378,
-0.0221023392,
-0.0340247601,
0.0950515792,
0.0565470643,
-0.0256217793,
-0.0039596376,
-0.0483671464,
0.0123487143,
-0.0114823459,
0.0064569567,
0.0557208732,
0.0369690359,
0.0185002405,
0.0550219864,
0.0873169377,
-0.0384383127,
0.0241762977,
-0.0473257452,
0.0703749433,
0.065909639,
0.0232011788,
0.0039852639,
-0.0062485803,
-0.0146475099,
-0.023216363,
-0.0187053829,
-0.0147829913,
-0.0271205306,
0.0071439641,
0.0311396029,
-0.0128880134,
0.0096090743,
-0.0811291188,
-0.0574452914,
-0.0093590179,
-0.0203922987,
0.0437073149,
0.0070005604,
-0.0186565071,
0.0156459212,
0.0617290623,
-0.0662448108,
-0.0018962688,
-0.0233937707,
-0.0311133247,
-0.0072433637,
0.025878083,
0.0269767288,
-0.0263798591,
-0.0209243055,
0.0256716218,
0.0223738104,
0.0264026951,
-0.0170771703,
-0.0073912246,
0.0498810969,
-0.0613180138,
-0.020308204,
-0.0242587831,
0.006121594,
-0.0159668494,
-0.0175936203,
0.0494856574,
0.0202445965,
-0.017220784,
0.0013080549,
0.0025666964,
0.0233000461,
-0.013923374,
0.0124498997,
0.0059543243,
0.0273940451,
-0.0119212577,
-0.030099472,
-0.0231825449,
-0.0251394045,
0.050363414,
-0.0287720356,
-0.0020555865,
0.004537046,
2.619e-7,
-0.0388655066,
0.0020040174,
0.0384979881,
-0.0190264117,
0.0789765269,
0.0604693666,
-0.0098461816,
0.0296669323,
0.0269412603,
-0.0199525133,
-0.0066042491,
0.0323584825,
0.0500852913,
0.0215228312,
-0.0531672761,
-0.0017526571,
-0.0735905766,
0.0113339936,
-0.0231447369,
0.0347370915,
0.0071126083,
0.0753371119,
0.0118521545,
-0.0339612924,
0.0027339556,
-0.0045079309,
0.0734662637,
-0.0339868963,
0.0005156265,
-0.0108690038,
0.0085062953,
0.0232164953,
0.0038291095,
0.0228049606,
-0.0067277169,
0.0599422306,
-0.0067155105,
0.0432944074,
0.0064735105,
-0.0622070841,
-0.0149328662,
0.0614581779,
-0.0295697618,
-0.0151979821,
0.0529226102,
-0.0273815617,
-0.036639981,
-0.0472046509,
-0.04164619,
0.0282629579,
0.0431866124,
0.0129163144,
0.0234330986,
-0.0013446234,
-0.018181514,
-0.024977861,
-0.0383451469,
-0.0505460128,
-0.0348235294,
0.0133256782,
-0.074668102,
-0.0113516618,
-0.0592073202,
0.0162620414,
0.068421714,
-0.0180268548,
0.0220520515,
1.433372557e-34,
-0.0309834145,
0.0010883251,
-0.0070616817,
-0.0265998486,
-0.0571842603,
-0.0434648171,
0.020385785,
0.0263520963,
0.0322439373,
-0.0264901947,
0.0006834547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17623v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17623v2 | Neighboring Perturbations of Knowledge Editing on Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T06:49:36 | 2024-05-27T03:52:43 | Jun-Yu Ma, Zhen-Hua Ling, Ningyu Zhang, Jia-Chen Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their exceptional capabilities, large language models (LLMs) are
prone to generating unintended text due to false or outdated knowledge. Given
the resource-intensive nature of retraining LLMs, there has been a notable
increase in the development of knowledge editing. However, current approaches
and evaluations rarely explore the perturbation of editing on neighboring
knowledge. This paper studies whether updating new knowledge to LLMs perturbs
the neighboring knowledge encapsulated within them. Specifically, we seek to
figure out whether appending a new answer into an answer list to a factual
question leads to catastrophic forgetting of original correct answers in this
list, as well as unintentional inclusion of incorrect answers. A metric of
additivity is introduced and a benchmark dubbed as Perturbation Evaluation of
Appending Knowledge (PEAK) is constructed to evaluate the degree of
perturbation to neighboring knowledge when appending new knowledge. Besides, a
plug-and-play framework termed Appending via Preservation and Prevention (APP)
is proposed to mitigate the neighboring perturbation by maintaining the
integrity of the answer list. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of APP
coupling with four editing methods on four LLMs. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/mjy1111/PEAK. | [
0.0529857129,
0.0525987744,
-0.0267149657,
0.0326216146,
-0.0281592309,
0.0117949648,
-0.0334047526,
-0.0039958465,
0.0206254702,
-0.0481830649,
0.008113144,
-0.0106799342,
0.0242029615,
-0.0237929728,
0.0312840492,
-0.0260689631,
0.0979769155,
-0.0432010442,
-0.0217148829,
-0.0170864202,
0.0045895088,
-0.0251374617,
0.0107150329,
-0.0117270043,
0.0234636478,
-0.0359443054,
-0.0336605534,
-0.004150942,
0.0224010367,
-0.026566036,
-0.0277147759,
0.0700754896,
-0.0450854264,
0.0778772831,
0.0000022361,
-0.0568600781,
-0.0540968254,
0.0179422423,
-0.0449634381,
0.0434160568,
-0.0174957737,
0.0154483523,
-0.0320902914,
0.0049388753,
-0.0321815312,
0.0222914107,
0.0453841761,
0.0150608122,
0.0988184884,
0.0615964234,
0.0257158838,
0.0443443395,
0.0373254232,
-0.0176482294,
0.0647936314,
-0.027046632,
0.0647309795,
0.0115137538,
-0.0162384138,
0.0226448104,
-0.0101157604,
0.0373160839,
0.0027616632,
-0.0582109615,
-0.0018998358,
0.012074043,
-0.0313040242,
0.0175463054,
0.0057099485,
0.0239650663,
0.0252288356,
-0.0521854386,
-0.0171168186,
0.0075178682,
0.0354008861,
0.0348970294,
-0.03103045,
-0.0219388716,
0.0006572122,
-0.042001728,
-0.0023126709,
-0.1066879556,
0.0431306958,
0.0143137816,
0.0271117352,
0.0595307648,
0.0263650101,
-0.0414176583,
-0.0632506087,
0.0016043985,
-0.0328658074,
-0.1375778019,
-0.0165267233,
0.0641555861,
-0.0126325591,
0.0100894161,
-0.0245738402,
-0.0192336645,
0.0536570698,
-0.056128718,
0.0074676732,
0.0186930727,
-0.011308278,
0.0463321581,
-0.0381790921,
0.0345889591,
-0.0117661674,
-0.0061855325,
-0.0506418347,
0.0345952921,
-0.0399594381,
-0.0487450585,
0.0123892156,
0.0700477958,
0.0058447667,
0.0373750478,
-0.0124135027,
0.0390927419,
-0.0162391253,
0.0346441492,
-0.0454993434,
-0.0052083926,
0.0061872858,
-0.0216344129,
-0.0567123331,
0.0437311083,
-0.0030550121,
0.0491900072,
0.0209121946,
-0.0129295653,
-0.0163558926,
-0.0383796468,
-0.000756915,
-0.002353501,
0.0264620017,
0.0295335911,
-0.0325906165,
0.0082900552,
-0.0551551878,
-0.0814928561,
-0.0074593262,
-0.0434305966,
-0.0393440612,
-0.082027629,
0.0274001062,
0.0053767222,
-0.046443034,
-0.0558088683,
0.004766291,
0.0371784903,
-0.0373311527,
0.0418226384,
-0.0533366688,
0.0377960093,
0.0635183528,
0.0139050111,
-0.0412285738,
0.0434896685,
0.0195203405,
-0.0183726847,
0.0424002074,
-0.0184433945,
-0.0009728271,
-0.0061770123,
0.0314359218,
0.0264363661,
-0.0045142393,
0.0375017785,
0.0272174478,
0.007834251,
-0.021970138,
0.0338808782,
-0.0276749339,
-0.0013426037,
0.0907399058,
-0.0183736477,
-0.0308221653,
0.0421588905,
-0.0402837731,
-0.0621451102,
0.0277166683,
0.043150451,
-0.0552124679,
0.0379092433,
-0.0496671535,
-0.0019957244,
0.0210377518,
-0.0017407626,
0.0003815189,
-0.0184516795,
0.0084218429,
0.0336337984,
0.0059310086,
-0.0084080854,
0.0036891147,
0.0221982822,
-0.007724504,
0.0662886277,
-0.0041670334,
-0.0372256339,
0.0238917898,
-0.0311149266,
0.0070227338,
0.0547606125,
0.0552622266,
-0.0550458543,
-0.0721542388,
-0.0198423397,
-0.0150448112,
-0.0089028776,
0.0775272995,
-0.0216765031,
-0.0243520346,
0.0222548805,
-0.0344328061,
-0.0138564408,
0.031236561,
-0.0134680234,
0.0277648661,
0.0174535699,
-0.0023880978,
-0.0199062843,
-0.0239031874,
0.0177144054,
-0.0466703847,
-0.0058495044,
-0.0198688004,
-0.0101421159,
-0.0258820597,
0.0110024102,
-0.0325142518,
0.0230078083,
0.021584332,
0.0279902276,
-0.0550962016,
-0.0104481243,
0.0069350624,
0.0017464209,
0.0694734529,
0.0284488164,
-0.0341099352,
-0.0027381191,
-0.021662781,
-0.0358267762,
-0.0159688164,
-0.0426970758,
0.0623385943,
-0.0395383351,
0.0387539305,
-0.0059280954,
-0.0370002389,
-0.0133388909,
0.0558860153,
-0.0195975471,
0.0122745,
0.0267780963,
-0.0222164858,
-0.000763486,
-0.0140617611,
-0.0018898459,
-0.0084417854,
-0.0003074117,
0.0088381888,
0.0259549376,
-0.0262376498,
-0.0368603803,
-0.0327894874,
-0.0844299793,
-0.0093122423,
-0.0093333879,
0.0204166211,
0.0074853967,
0.0087193185,
-0.0058970158,
-0.0155901806,
-0.0024943629,
0.0005958054,
0.0154312234,
0.0809994414,
0.0132979192,
0.0332708582,
0.0205988418,
-0.0389136374,
0.0049953577,
0.0017871384,
0.0194836557,
0.0261270329,
-0.0130743133,
-0.0639100894,
-0.0076263901,
-0.1038750485,
0.012299262,
0.0288593471,
-0.0222558286,
-0.0185156316,
0.012956541,
0.0756843388,
0.0346225537,
0.0197947137,
-0.0465585813,
0.0814820454,
-0.0117229046,
-0.0179716032,
-0.0001176908,
-0.0146501986,
-0.0548848994,
-0.013984073,
-0.0093492838,
-0.0104778195,
0.0314951241,
-0.0065011922,
-0.0482800379,
-0.0175375938,
0.0273254942,
-0.0304947589,
-0.0551537238,
-0.0484422781,
-0.0505535267,
-0.0263827369,
0.0486295298,
-0.0353686623,
-0.0494905934,
0.0609338097,
-0.0041410755,
0.0564282686,
-0.0369335897,
0.013079131,
0.0003251243,
0.0450756103,
0.0117285317,
0.0479331128,
-0.0046391739,
0.0132207079,
-0.1068876237,
-0.0103726508,
0.0586271361,
-0.0487927906,
0.0469994359,
-0.0779731274,
0.0118195871,
-0.0088167703,
-0.0084510082,
-0.057333678,
-0.0477033071,
0.0035031708,
-0.0340222493,
-0.00985373,
-0.029896101,
0.0096555622,
-0.0433243439,
0.0880968645,
0.0471523702,
-0.0089289267,
-0.0195120331,
-0.015364089,
0.0252830833,
0.0882505551,
0.0188236963,
0.0778166056,
-0.0465175472,
0.0346814469,
0.0941280723,
0.0457136817,
-0.0186384209,
0.0431036204,
-0.0252783336,
-0.0175563227,
-0.0643709674,
-0.0322462469,
0.0087055378,
0.0298062004,
-0.0557533763,
-0.0084564583,
0.0636394694,
0.0469832234,
-0.0306997243,
0.0145302601,
-0.0468065739,
0.0076200385,
0.0354289375,
0.0749749541,
-0.0806948021,
0.0131592173,
0.0372705162,
-0.0087498026,
-0.023462275,
-0.0593787394,
-0.0208589826,
-0.104700394,
-0.010213661,
-0.000509911,
-0.0445746817,
-0.0177722033,
-0.0318228118,
0.0025365602,
0.0590748377,
-0.0037149861,
0.048165787,
-0.0053465259,
-0.0015737417,
0.0071831886,
-0.0230016652,
-0.0007462576,
0.000130645,
0.0148473857,
0.0470574647,
0.0455455519,
-0.003605251,
-0.0227615219,
-0.0091719851,
0.0562507287,
0.0137617588,
-0.0088183219,
-0.0053071785,
0.0273189191,
0.0352257267,
0.0273397062,
0.0005441285,
-0.0201482568,
0.0401391573,
-0.0438913628,
0.058700189,
0.0833164155,
-0.0149694765,
-0.0012329275,
0.0088417893,
-0.0392435044,
-0.0027917754,
0.0483639985,
0.0068861959,
-0.0090430165,
0.0218124576,
-0.044889167,
-0.0067118611,
0.0177743323,
-0.0060583311,
-0.0096986312,
-0.0147840232,
0.040015772,
-0.0922880247,
-0.0283903778,
-0.0217266474,
-0.0167604238,
0.0407359786,
0.0493562557,
0.0064314893,
-0.0029582679,
0.0027596527,
-0.0342733972,
-0.0223342385,
0.0236736368,
-0.0078470167,
0.0012617586,
-0.009953903,
-0.0095076822,
-0.0089976313,
-0.0571045689,
-0.0871795043,
-0.0547545329,
0.032855399,
0.0466699116,
0.0264479686,
0.0407032408,
0.0195299219,
-0.0420267843,
0.0137220584,
0.0215420276,
-0.0243472569,
0.0712772533,
0.001140944,
-0.0193815697,
0.0001725507,
0.0195724908,
-0.0544650331,
-0.0306159426,
0.0258648638,
0.0138520263,
-0.0491273627,
-0.0226058252,
-0.0024320434,
0.0235890951,
-0.0047645681,
0.011407149,
0.0037990252,
-0.0049273483,
0.0712265745,
-0.0139707774,
-0.0177147221,
0.0083456924,
-0.0205879491,
-0.0177036654,
0.0157948341,
0.0284897741,
0.014000481,
0.0295165591,
0.0258895382,
-0.0155854961,
-0.0348376371,
0.02659663,
0.0078229252,
0.0434785224,
0.0324876793,
-0.0229069088,
0.0028718421,
-0.0010056017,
0.0455978625,
-0.0178490467,
0.0331265591,
0.0275911726,
-0.0364521295,
0.0030535222,
0.0075892662,
-0.1012388915,
-0.0602704138,
-0.0102414852,
0.0338276364,
0.0344004892,
0.0119736213,
0.0405807868,
-0.0295277312,
-0.0186976846,
-0.0446619578,
-0.011967388,
0.0280873179,
-0.0243321043,
-0.0121088997,
0.017218262,
-0.0033859811,
0.0538391881,
0.0617402904,
-0.04863251,
0.0886323377,
-0.0169704519,
-0.0154801114,
-0.0131298443,
-0.0348661579,
-0.0267428961,
0.01941167,
-0.0394403338,
-0.0048958515,
-0.0739409178,
-0.0690668151,
-0.0118462536,
0.0163781922,
0.0063816831,
-0.0007004513,
-0.0149457697,
0.0138267633,
0.0113735888,
0.0102327839,
-0.0214008074,
0.0266539715,
-0.0325284079,
0.0280641224,
0.0251639467,
-6.447141296e-33,
-0.0053877095,
-0.0208289176,
0.019471487,
0.0125924414,
-0.0278191455,
0.0148434713,
-0.0443728343,
0.0124965999,
-0.0050630788,
-0.0012680055,
-0.0128712459,
0.0323350392,
-0.0138922501,
0.0009996499,
0.0062830122,
-0.0281770378,
0.0468125232,
0.0262499359,
-0.0350941494,
0.0190926325,
0.0289494209,
-0.0130568445,
0.046835389,
-0.0291127767,
0.0719445571,
0.0033139565,
0.0129388226,
0.0323822089,
-0.083862938,
0.0499402061,
0.0048002014,
0.0418993086,
-0.0077433577,
-0.0541731976,
-0.0497982726,
-0.0340674557,
0.0017588018,
-0.0494491309,
0.0151907224,
-0.0036501014,
-0.0172833875,
-0.0173405614,
0.026293952,
0.0133139929,
-0.0063881977,
-0.0312366337,
0.0043560588,
-0.0204472803,
-0.0227282383,
0.0432202071,
-0.0171071216,
0.0138867339,
0.0333091766,
-0.0119646201,
-0.0317750163,
0.007198255,
0.0335245058,
-0.0544870496,
-0.1010988504,
-0.000773184,
0.058304809,
0.0681975782,
0.0316206142,
-0.026731791,
-0.0000713516,
0.0479689874,
0.0333524607,
0.0461891778,
0.0039547486,
-0.0023909295,
-0.0380153842,
0.0010642941,
0.0628121495,
0.0465714335,
0.026968196,
-0.0096443119,
-0.0276050474,
-0.0020083417,
-0.0195189901,
0.0446994752,
-0.0160977412,
0.0088757034,
0.0275293626,
0.0015721378,
-0.0654480979,
0.061544016,
-0.0389887951,
-0.0094515122,
0.0168769863,
0.031284105,
-0.0262113232,
-0.0132843545,
0.0184099544,
-0.0276578441,
-0.0239182841,
0.0088241966,
-0.0079702977,
0.0052492209,
0.0206608716,
0.0195328947,
-0.0326328315,
0.0512069203,
0.0044685779,
-0.0179323331,
0.0101296073,
0.0117554823,
0.0400970206,
0.0508411415,
-0.0673034936,
0.0308171641,
-0.0085102906,
0.029649036,
0.0056527779,
-0.0610507242,
0.0236058962,
-0.0009683163,
0.0081642848,
0.0037658075,
0.0727824941,
0.0266183224,
-0.0383654237,
0.0283375122,
0.007685666,
0.0039966037,
0.002848997,
0.0204267856,
-0.0212169699,
0.0282748975,
-0.0233298875,
-0.0332838446,
0.0003257109,
-0.0184708927,
3.002e-7,
0.0248089693,
0.0489205942,
0.0261538383,
0.0012104728,
0.0618517324,
0.0457142815,
-0.0355071165,
0.0031651109,
0.0603336915,
0.0083506536,
-0.0071511311,
0.0006734218,
0.0215602834,
0.050101243,
-0.023572376,
-0.0192615557,
-0.0673058406,
0.0007132115,
-0.0309398007,
-0.0190607812,
0.0401081704,
0.0226701517,
0.0164598338,
-0.0050667864,
-0.0464955196,
-0.0284511596,
0.0769045204,
-0.0047541698,
0.0088988123,
-0.0018815174,
0.0454512015,
0.0125320423,
0.0360304266,
0.0422035046,
-0.0503217578,
-0.0352901034,
-0.0165468249,
0.0173153672,
-0.0323785469,
0.0018588437,
-0.0133637553,
0.0024045832,
0.0160951726,
-0.0695464909,
0.0793844163,
-0.0276014749,
0.02545847,
-0.0204116385,
-0.0448356308,
-0.0133617176,
0.0111688469,
0.0099924263,
-0.0281277988,
0.0030538624,
-0.0030952834,
0.0934452862,
-0.0132094705,
-0.0231369827,
-0.0870479867,
0.0221023075,
-0.0079750642,
-0.0858631879,
-0.0474825799,
-0.0262121689,
-0.0235647205,
-0.0999055803,
-0.011433661,
2.804749036e-34,
-0.0149520645,
-0.015756296,
0.0300098993,
0.0277023967,
0.0118536418,
-0.0203246847,
0.0117278816,
-0.0057696942,
0.0173959341,
-0.0759185702,
-0.0303651597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17602v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17602v1 | Assertion Detection Large Language Model In-context Learning LoRA Fine-tuning | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | Yuelyu Ji, Zeshui Yu, Yanshan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we aim to address the task of assertion detection when
extracting medical concepts from clinical notes, a key process in clinical
natural language processing (NLP). Assertion detection in clinical NLP usually
involves identifying assertion types for medical concepts in the clinical text,
namely certainty (whether the medical concept is positive, negated, possible,
or hypothetical), temporality (whether the medical concept is for present or
the past history), and experiencer (whether the medical concept is described
for the patient or a family member). These assertion types are essential for
healthcare professionals to quickly and clearly understand the context of
medical conditions from unstructured clinical texts, directly influencing the
quality and outcomes of patient care. Although widely used, traditional
methods, particularly rule-based NLP systems and machine learning or deep
learning models, demand intensive manual efforts to create patterns and tend to
overlook less common assertion types, leading to an incomplete understanding of
the context. To address this challenge, our research introduces a novel
methodology that utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a vast
array of medical data for assertion detection. We enhanced the current method
with advanced reasoning techniques, including Tree of Thought (ToT), Chain of
Thought (CoT), and Self-Consistency (SC), and refine it further with Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) fine-tuning. We first evaluated the model on the i2b2 2010
assertion dataset. Our method achieved a micro-averaged F-1 of 0.89, with 0.11
improvements over the previous works. To further assess the generalizability of
our approach, we extended our evaluation to a local dataset that focused on
sleep concept extraction. Our approach achieved an F-1 of 0.74, which is 0.31
higher than the previous method. | [
0.0623382106,
0.0514940731,
0.0156158078,
0.0027831104,
-0.0449998118,
0.0326030105,
-0.0326717906,
0.0100582503,
0.0039605317,
-0.0227096248,
0.0251296777,
-0.0690268949,
0.0091197435,
0.0036680854,
-0.0043486259,
0.0041888482,
0.0398277901,
0.0210902989,
0.0630867854,
0.0247396231,
-0.0260101426,
0.0136840921,
-0.0335042998,
0.0300181434,
-0.0275796652,
-0.0510150492,
0.0298724081,
-0.0091224564,
0.0336824395,
-0.121784851,
-0.0208464675,
0.038120579,
-0.0179223325,
-0.0122068273,
0.0000022125,
-0.0715737641,
-0.0324343629,
-0.0000512146,
-0.0297659263,
-0.0414132923,
-0.0061553586,
-0.0201870054,
-0.0038653968,
0.002424299,
-0.0420504808,
-0.0492813513,
0.0134369778,
0.0752062127,
0.0261273682,
0.0835344866,
-0.0314985961,
-0.0096636312,
-0.0150769372,
0.0089302119,
0.0168679189,
-0.0647019967,
0.0791879818,
0.0243422948,
0.0033595287,
-0.0591963008,
0.0155498162,
0.013161324,
-0.0220391043,
0.0312024038,
-0.0188486446,
0.0212833565,
-0.0440493971,
-0.0287808888,
0.0107649658,
0.0597740337,
-0.0050992123,
-0.0220609903,
0.0032882413,
0.0007606908,
-0.0185652263,
-0.0164849255,
-0.0394868925,
0.0351206027,
-0.0344353803,
0.0254495833,
0.0619846024,
0.0272205211,
0.0228948984,
-0.015830541,
-0.0792134255,
0.0289123617,
-0.0021121278,
-0.0463663824,
0.0470627658,
-0.0053024148,
-0.0517329946,
-0.050012853,
0.0296170451,
0.0229859166,
-0.0490549915,
0.0151666896,
0.0018367441,
-0.0340734534,
0.0670414269,
-0.0616064481,
0.0044515119,
0.0173044074,
-0.0236159861,
0.0484257676,
-0.0483861044,
0.0063185981,
-0.0217293184,
0.0062470846,
-0.0092640761,
-0.0043986584,
-0.0418049134,
0.0046933857,
-0.0155971795,
0.0180501807,
0.0121903773,
-0.0048402902,
-0.0667621568,
-0.0117356833,
-0.0221856609,
0.0472723022,
-0.0238065477,
0.0178490356,
0.0070742564,
-0.0123088025,
-0.0022496942,
0.0187302288,
0.0427409299,
0.0159203112,
-0.0169224124,
-0.0383610725,
0.0064796926,
0.0304277502,
0.0339931212,
0.0121782077,
0.0475254357,
0.0108082248,
0.0343430303,
-0.0155031215,
-0.0362708829,
-0.0173026677,
-0.0248758327,
-0.0327105932,
-0.0173597746,
-0.0663982332,
-0.0199331231,
-0.0126871224,
0.0227830168,
-0.0337367691,
0.0251539499,
0.0303529408,
-0.0176520739,
0.0395272784,
-0.041030407,
-0.0074840016,
0.0006120196,
0.0338098332,
0.0391929708,
0.0008690612,
0.046923317,
-0.0200666692,
0.0138346506,
0.0052513336,
0.0238150973,
0.0058013927,
0.000856058,
-0.0632179976,
0.0158573687,
0.0340431333,
-0.0061795758,
0.0529271103,
-0.0712395459,
0.0783319846,
0.0264028013,
-0.0114756329,
0.0322789103,
0.0375195444,
-0.002344541,
-0.0036412401,
0.0125557976,
-0.0520532131,
0.0121891266,
-0.024794165,
0.0056781978,
-0.0214919634,
0.0033379069,
-0.0101320017,
-0.0439854376,
-0.0059802975,
-0.0011473668,
-0.0571379475,
-0.0923831686,
0.0129457107,
-0.0486798175,
-0.0072041065,
0.0429395214,
0.0060948059,
-0.0624094307,
0.0272538792,
0.0287039895,
-0.0005433459,
-0.0351998881,
-0.0507147349,
0.0246948581,
0.0099287406,
0.0428787433,
-0.0427859202,
0.0002024261,
-0.0471252464,
0.0393559523,
0.0449815132,
0.0134848636,
-0.0181369763,
0.0086576352,
-0.0337510929,
0.0009794794,
0.0533759929,
0.018125305,
-0.031321317,
-0.0077065113,
0.0309262108,
-0.0306886565,
-0.0279244948,
-0.0697631314,
0.0569033846,
-0.0122971851,
-0.0362408981,
0.0253716987,
0.0113049382,
0.0474203937,
0.0232909061,
-0.016804222,
0.0078624198,
0.0245539229,
-0.0472060442,
-0.0615299679,
0.0248679891,
-0.0829931125,
-0.0275446177,
0.0347209983,
0.0030773028,
-0.0385744907,
-0.0498329885,
-0.0484824553,
-0.0138805974,
-0.0456848294,
-0.0312662274,
0.0289123859,
0.0016428821,
0.0285596494,
0.0358186178,
0.0271311421,
-0.0386017524,
0.0446687788,
-0.0186521951,
-0.0139734838,
0.0089084227,
-0.0160642006,
0.0240621287,
0.0079245614,
-0.0236254577,
0.0175108016,
-0.0393287279,
-0.0045184884,
-0.0081486562,
0.034519501,
-0.0377701558,
0.0143705551,
-0.1366207153,
0.0111086247,
-0.0099570807,
0.021033654,
0.0050561451,
0.0109636458,
-0.0096212029,
-0.0158580523,
-0.0453144424,
-0.0278429668,
0.0162296891,
0.0157942809,
0.0366723612,
0.0385280363,
-0.0180259924,
-0.0367998928,
0.024874201,
-0.0742516518,
0.0205320921,
-0.0111959213,
-0.0333405323,
0.0084505007,
0.0068901065,
-0.035346929,
0.0071779634,
-0.0033393747,
0.002281545,
0.0264138151,
-0.0268530417,
0.0093203969,
0.07497558,
0.0166798364,
0.0177288484,
0.0466903001,
0.0055273296,
0.0031853302,
0.0293696858,
-0.0263425056,
-0.0053095855,
0.0021717772,
-0.0380343199,
-0.0040325113,
0.0904411152,
0.0548357554,
-0.0103734089,
-0.0226568189,
-0.0352522507,
-0.0235248022,
0.0363864601,
-0.0020040469,
0.0093348734,
-0.0239071138,
0.0411046296,
-0.0059005152,
-0.0079513919,
0.0930852145,
-0.0331671834,
0.0115648434,
-0.0725897551,
-0.0233641397,
-0.0425537862,
0.0342744812,
-0.0067174169,
0.0028800247,
0.0363259614,
-0.0062133977,
0.0254161153,
-0.0115476493,
0.0161015242,
-0.047725521,
0.0433595069,
-0.0444280356,
0.0280265827,
0.0036219663,
-0.0652010068,
-0.0592775196,
-0.0123798288,
-0.0203448273,
-0.0184429139,
-0.0522249788,
0.0297043212,
-0.0432060473,
0.0126219057,
-0.0293776505,
0.0803084448,
0.0223001447,
-0.0228575263,
-0.0134547371,
0.0225781798,
0.0308555681,
-0.0032351236,
0.0190404095,
0.0141322827,
0.0352368839,
0.084045656,
-0.0223781299,
0.0687495321,
-0.0241763238,
0.0148361884,
-0.0186066851,
-0.0098396651,
0.0124532115,
0.0250266641,
0.0460986793,
-0.0699243322,
-0.0041098017,
0.1248403192,
0.0272934306,
0.0020140735,
0.0289517622,
-0.0317369513,
-0.0112514477,
-0.001867812,
-0.0005808111,
-0.1036853418,
-0.0429330803,
0.0029057434,
-0.0043122568,
-0.0411329493,
-0.0429111943,
0.0248029996,
-0.0313919485,
0.0182789043,
-0.021971669,
-0.0281817876,
-0.0207474306,
-0.0729635358,
0.0266585592,
-0.020736495,
0.0131942574,
-0.0085328724,
0.0008912124,
-0.0216059797,
-0.0016233252,
-0.0921308324,
-0.0558177717,
0.0602719374,
-0.0237592608,
0.0442111529,
0.0252382401,
0.048352953,
-0.0063393768,
-0.022541929,
0.025105359,
-0.0338845961,
-0.0191983189,
-0.01583107,
0.0129673658,
0.0044844034,
-0.0014003143,
-0.0409118608,
0.0259988774,
-0.0424916074,
-0.0116833504,
0.0122115891,
0.0952471644,
-0.0328200385,
-0.0695839301,
-0.0461624339,
0.0341441073,
0.0171244573,
0.0539857969,
-0.0080517251,
0.0254451185,
-0.031823013,
0.0214898251,
0.0025737521,
0.0011835424,
-0.0014954385,
0.0467370823,
-0.0149145303,
0.0379937887,
-0.0631811246,
-0.0014145281,
0.0138220256,
0.0096974494,
0.016763974,
0.0410656147,
0.0252307467,
0.0186833274,
-0.0972300619,
0.0464749709,
0.0472165756,
-0.0055992291,
-0.0046052458,
-0.0064193131,
0.0659827664,
0.0396681689,
-0.0184077434,
0.0331297182,
0.0071567572,
0.0010093644,
-0.0233611483,
0.02521489,
0.0147705255,
0.0364696309,
-0.0007034008,
0.0253446493,
0.0570351109,
0.0269850362,
0.0006074847,
-0.0244432874,
0.0181407575,
-0.0032730943,
0.0068320935,
0.0277795661,
-0.001672597,
0.0442356132,
0.0122704627,
0.0428198762,
0.0080694826,
-0.0216851495,
0.0349830799,
0.0428581126,
0.0186700746,
0.0046746386,
-0.0435007811,
-0.0047719446,
0.0106987217,
-0.0344043523,
-0.0001591397,
0.000616307,
0.0272245687,
0.0115195084,
0.0010689179,
-0.0254281685,
0.0356862918,
-0.0419602282,
-0.0507173613,
-0.0137921488,
0.0414876863,
0.0016045825,
0.0216385573,
0.0369011275,
-0.0343345329,
-0.0353682674,
-0.0146124503,
0.0188374911,
0.0348931998,
0.0034890757,
0.0511294641,
0.0305468496,
0.014576585,
-0.0249770675,
0.0394355804,
-0.013044171,
0.0013713727,
-0.0437606722,
-0.0370771177,
0.0494368523,
-0.0110982666,
0.0348631293,
-0.0301411264,
0.0127784414,
-0.0025807726,
0.0290680397,
-0.0311790407,
0.022953419,
0.0262987185,
0.0126371486,
-0.0177156553,
0.0200519618,
0.0229047444,
0.0158213209,
0.0535452999,
0.0091203628,
-0.0426662043,
-0.0637685359,
-0.0078358101,
-0.0053361794,
0.0379268229,
-0.0380523838,
0.0278778244,
-0.0586190149,
-0.0452518053,
0.0574769191,
0.0085963262,
0.0063372916,
0.0204534959,
0.0030263672,
0.0549489595,
0.0269193593,
-0.0405973718,
0.0151785156,
0.0174818486,
-0.0018947336,
-0.0237086806,
0.0048668217,
-6.146133927e-33,
0.0049245195,
-0.0549404621,
0.0218113419,
0.0003958397,
-0.0094094947,
0.0288919397,
-0.0673882663,
-0.0136224041,
-0.0217771567,
0.0616612248,
-0.0330152772,
0.0014772747,
0.016257504,
0.0522421114,
0.0126093812,
0.0046654665,
0.0273747873,
0.0320030935,
-0.0240504388,
-0.0005684468,
-0.0048847464,
0.0444925502,
0.0768838227,
-0.1078977212,
0.0038256615,
0.0217906553,
0.0155918449,
0.0080043608,
-0.0543345883,
0.0554378666,
-0.0662441626,
0.0506355613,
0.0609962903,
0.0013040744,
0.0311384536,
0.0038748055,
-0.0790887848,
-0.0129812593,
0.0100429859,
-0.0331914648,
-0.0544252172,
0.0083054192,
0.0478670411,
0.0124684582,
-0.0140179619,
0.017493628,
0.0203353539,
-0.0616164878,
0.03231287,
-0.0492532067,
-0.0571074709,
0.0569602586,
0.0135978516,
0.0140593257,
-0.0173437204,
-0.0325961001,
-0.0495603234,
0.0192506649,
-0.0684188977,
-0.0302164294,
-0.0506088808,
0.026695272,
-0.0067163673,
-0.0489984155,
-0.0463854633,
0.0773140341,
0.0045049535,
-0.0044875531,
-0.0484133624,
0.017963931,
-0.0399546735,
0.0431448407,
0.0560548082,
0.0368743576,
0.0221826993,
0.0030780751,
-0.1321769953,
-0.0053681661,
-0.0058434042,
0.0453691967,
0.0379653387,
-0.0261416156,
-0.0603447668,
-0.0000468033,
-0.0120358719,
-0.0237578414,
-0.0232677218,
0.02178335,
0.0323040038,
0.0241391361,
0.0136072151,
0.0307151936,
0.0102216452,
-0.022496786,
-0.0031051934,
-0.0398204289,
0.0109965838,
-0.0155888982,
-0.0153123792,
0.015446784,
-0.0239387825,
-0.0182363838,
0.0104340538,
-0.0043343646,
0.0634851009,
0.014679458,
0.0588233061,
-0.0199856441,
-0.0459842905,
-0.0137855336,
0.0248066466,
-0.0063862531,
-0.0194722917,
0.0535929725,
0.0168158654,
0.0175184105,
0.00208039,
0.0885079131,
-0.0235535093,
-0.0013518338,
-0.044128336,
-0.0056185736,
0.0175670423,
-0.0178163536,
-0.0404065661,
-0.0357347801,
-0.0228968505,
0.0493934117,
0.0071845194,
-0.0721130222,
0.0207034741,
-0.0006567354,
3.011e-7,
0.0361269303,
0.0681609586,
0.006819542,
-0.0529827587,
0.0584193505,
0.0179344676,
0.0003425911,
-0.0068465518,
0.0087110419,
-0.0614744127,
0.0218026824,
-0.0048503503,
0.0299615543,
0.0310393218,
-0.0556867719,
-0.0488653779,
-0.053498026,
-0.0240778886,
-0.0441679582,
-0.0134849781,
0.0796109512,
0.0796586722,
-0.0333289206,
-0.037015412,
0.0134225171,
-0.0118651502,
0.0216224864,
-0.0039599393,
0.0204878487,
0.0410298407,
0.0262031443,
-0.0019777152,
0.030484885,
0.0667972788,
-0.0111297294,
0.0157883074,
-0.0327241272,
0.0981282145,
-0.0537844561,
0.0302450899,
0.0175703298,
0.0234844498,
0.0265826713,
-0.0599615611,
0.0792022869,
-0.0744940042,
-0.0606413223,
-0.004408027,
-0.0211129338,
-0.0311766751,
0.0570281148,
0.0121543491,
-0.0153868273,
0.0194287412,
0.0355694108,
0.0299242456,
-0.0585349537,
-0.0980384573,
-0.0032919836,
0.0347708724,
-0.0307158437,
0.0060486775,
0.056237936,
-0.0295245387,
-0.0108474996,
-0.0793725252,
0.0100288093,
2.999518119e-34,
0.0359795354,
0.0093861409,
0.0123258093,
0.0170718543,
0.0453677252,
0.0077177999,
-0.0118576204,
0.0080885105,
-0.0012350277,
-0.0832435563,
-0.001114971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17600v1 | Good at captioning, bad at counting: Benchmarking GPT-4V on Earth observation data | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | Chenhui Zhang, Sherrie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Large Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
on complex tasks involving visual input with natural language instructions.
However, it remains unclear to what extent capabilities on natural images
transfer to Earth observation (EO) data, which are predominantly satellite and
aerial images less common in VLM training data. In this work, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark to gauge the progress of VLMs toward being useful tools
for EO data by assessing their abilities on scene understanding, localization
and counting, and change detection tasks. Motivated by real-world applications,
our benchmark includes scenarios like urban monitoring, disaster relief, land
use, and conservation. We discover that, although state-of-the-art VLMs like
GPT-4V possess extensive world knowledge that leads to strong performance on
open-ended tasks like location understanding and image captioning, their poor
spatial reasoning limits usefulness on object localization and counting tasks.
Our benchmark will be made publicly available at https://vleo.danielz.ch/ and
on Hugging Face at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mit-ei/vleo-benchmark-datasets-65b789b0466555489cce0d70
for easy model evaluation. | [
0.023426624,
0.0867538676,
0.013566209,
0.0696282759,
-0.0099841235,
0.027681401,
-0.0004180001,
-0.092226319,
0.0122008985,
-0.0094164638,
0.0079636015,
-0.0267532691,
0.0074903858,
0.0619390942,
0.0081618754,
-0.0592119582,
0.0318095684,
-0.0697898045,
0.0000932777,
-0.012875516,
-0.0129147191,
-0.013761309,
-0.0097080534,
0.0092533948,
0.0151614621,
0.0043014721,
-0.0074983565,
0.0191672873,
0.0706102997,
-0.033453051,
-0.0094185406,
0.0312434584,
0.0537642725,
0.0240418538,
0.0000018239,
-0.0140878418,
-0.0087404111,
0.0304673351,
0.0072022248,
0.007993415,
0.0202599727,
-0.0793219656,
-0.0157274604,
-0.0048226835,
-0.0137659637,
-0.0524164587,
0.072244361,
0.0232589711,
0.0633895695,
0.0770929977,
0.0013404654,
-0.0214904156,
0.0465541668,
-0.0058118622,
0.0223964527,
-0.0442875326,
0.0148262382,
0.0469503924,
-0.0336861908,
0.013285514,
-0.026332872,
0.0492844693,
0.0467272103,
-0.0233957302,
-0.0232141092,
0.0784438476,
-0.0680441409,
-0.0095053595,
-0.0613782592,
0.0151146883,
-0.0117285075,
0.0183616132,
-0.0064640953,
0.0081808334,
-0.0230462477,
-0.030377822,
-0.0628140271,
0.0170634426,
0.0197504051,
0.0043119513,
-0.0573032834,
0.0207037926,
-0.0110301431,
0.0240722932,
-0.0364775658,
0.0238567796,
0.0160522759,
0.0319329984,
-0.0240386333,
0.0082541779,
-0.040373262,
-0.0355794542,
-0.0068350499,
0.0178161431,
-0.0061318302,
-0.011705271,
-0.0428005829,
0.0414242372,
-0.0302655268,
-0.0418141633,
0.0295293964,
0.0323889367,
-0.0532878786,
0.1260339767,
-0.023737736,
0.0952927396,
0.014874774,
0.0445643514,
0.0337320901,
-0.0525596738,
-0.0588111579,
-0.0244726036,
-0.0360948071,
-0.0168354101,
-0.0288154669,
-0.0433226861,
0.008128915,
0.0154855624,
0.0128877703,
0.0153367938,
-0.0189939812,
0.0052256137,
-0.0398848057,
-0.0340447836,
-0.0023253439,
0.0119684637,
0.014292812,
-0.0044710422,
0.0039353985,
-0.0955010578,
0.0181562845,
0.0112999333,
0.039832212,
-0.0146821663,
-0.0317814872,
0.0390888564,
0.0099474108,
-0.0409267768,
-0.0322816558,
0.0330561399,
-0.0469633266,
-0.0409737676,
0.0167258997,
-0.0609897636,
-0.0269974433,
-0.0420915969,
0.0064807739,
-0.0167055745,
0.0200513378,
-0.0127166389,
0.003941332,
0.0730293095,
-0.0185477715,
-0.0085153747,
0.0072121876,
-0.0193032082,
0.0154501526,
0.1078942642,
0.0463026613,
0.0503443144,
0.0420115441,
0.008159779,
0.0353076905,
0.0238290913,
-0.0222577173,
0.0679939985,
-0.0402740464,
0.0259542484,
-0.0522582717,
0.0098169399,
0.0207797755,
0.0240267105,
0.0017560518,
-0.0141748739,
0.0888830498,
0.0089847771,
-0.0256986655,
-0.017316239,
0.0212413408,
0.0375920683,
-0.0219659116,
-0.0255204923,
-0.0840432122,
0.0803330988,
-0.0361673869,
-0.0199681167,
-0.0285698622,
0.0063490984,
-0.03217154,
-0.0377786979,
-0.0223617069,
0.0176870953,
-0.0159688145,
-0.0209184811,
0.0473890118,
-0.0445807576,
0.013496683,
-0.0182402786,
-0.0175582208,
-0.0142449746,
0.0198779367,
-0.026953917,
0.016771039,
0.0249027479,
-0.0171750486,
-0.0000548838,
-0.052742634,
0.0064859353,
0.0513507128,
0.0635574013,
0.0395110287,
0.0377086326,
0.0338310376,
-0.0221287366,
-0.0561386645,
-0.0195889361,
0.0037629565,
0.0088949976,
0.0346093774,
0.0182644855,
0.0535820089,
-0.0659137294,
-0.0249487441,
0.0325545445,
0.0439902097,
-0.0128803411,
-0.0008654257,
0.0352404863,
-0.0078570778,
-0.016330203,
-0.0178061128,
-0.0182503629,
0.0137460651,
0.0025096517,
-0.0167862996,
0.0279205907,
-0.0113123544,
-0.036065653,
0.0417613164,
-0.0545594618,
-0.0351940393,
0.086750932,
-0.0575816408,
-0.0360096581,
0.0185876638,
-0.0379417054,
-0.00178602,
-0.0471739806,
-0.0359990671,
-0.0144618368,
0.0087253042,
-0.0144943641,
0.0313047506,
-0.0214377455,
-0.0302231889,
-0.026656596,
0.0213941,
0.0190471616,
-0.0094412081,
-0.0085330065,
-0.043262478,
0.0117751695,
0.005702992,
0.0180038437,
0.0393929109,
-0.0475329384,
-0.0091918912,
-0.0808401406,
0.0139237363,
-0.0512690172,
0.0139204552,
0.017122237,
-0.0296140183,
-0.0153860971,
-0.0213143025,
-0.028406376,
0.0052206279,
0.0112438202,
0.0181475747,
-0.0003115283,
-0.0152610186,
-0.0196868517,
-0.0262710284,
0.0211158488,
0.0115220463,
0.0013481604,
0.0316427499,
-0.0626700521,
-0.024664674,
-0.0131430384,
-0.0372443944,
0.0202600863,
-0.0314277634,
-0.0301806498,
0.0185723901,
-0.0278441384,
0.0052606221,
0.0184888709,
-0.0022364426,
0.0299230553,
-0.0012498454,
0.0093969889,
-0.0191089045,
-0.0020220415,
-0.0245194156,
-0.075081706,
0.0009627551,
0.0074516158,
-0.0405752733,
-0.0022090382,
-0.0479046442,
-0.0088682184,
-0.0391929001,
0.0400416926,
-0.0198235437,
-0.0348464809,
-0.0468692631,
0.0372953936,
0.0058758361,
0.0153156267,
-0.0442126915,
-0.0738243312,
-0.01755674,
-0.0266638007,
-0.0246118773,
-0.0103868712,
0.0011483933,
-0.0352076367,
0.071380496,
0.0521420427,
0.0273362063,
0.0044091479,
0.012807738,
-0.0282152873,
-0.0531344973,
-0.0382379703,
0.0284697544,
0.039492555,
-0.1259394437,
0.0515748039,
-0.0453928262,
-0.0040390068,
-0.0231467187,
0.002501257,
-0.0374880843,
0.0355655774,
-0.0478759967,
-0.0366521478,
-0.0000418214,
0.0370267443,
0.0547097288,
0.0616920814,
-0.0217963327,
-0.0105530722,
-0.0268711131,
-0.0060473387,
0.0746557713,
0.0474172644,
0.0175029933,
-0.0197062511,
-0.0074484004,
0.0211791657,
0.0121874101,
0.0272583123,
-0.0776033029,
0.0408178121,
-0.0153947519,
0.0429863483,
0.0263957195,
-0.0036839824,
0.0854374319,
-0.0585343279,
-0.0164598264,
0.0850263312,
-0.0009685257,
-0.01129831,
-0.0070065223,
-0.0057836706,
0.0050449641,
0.0405155756,
-0.0314902738,
-0.0310128573,
-0.0424531214,
-0.0024703005,
-0.0271918755,
0.0374583714,
-0.0056017423,
-0.0297371894,
-0.0860587582,
0.0709737018,
0.0162868034,
-0.0883945674,
-0.0495940298,
-0.0031769858,
0.011455752,
-0.0493657552,
-0.0600519441,
-0.0383269861,
-0.0050085741,
0.0315842405,
0.0218360759,
0.0085665733,
-0.0205208138,
-0.0016410833,
-0.0669567287,
0.0006749334,
0.0487657115,
0.0113973869,
-0.010737624,
-0.0578347445,
0.0186224058,
0.0375338905,
-0.0105748,
0.0358280875,
0.0347202346,
-0.0113800187,
-0.0333999544,
0.0407220498,
0.0355488956,
-0.0533428788,
0.0098467525,
0.0109331403,
0.0280959792,
0.0018722555,
-0.0009330663,
-0.025333738,
-0.0145550184,
0.0190445147,
0.0257509854,
0.0184004679,
0.0389608033,
-0.0471556969,
-0.01469093,
-0.0046877814,
-0.0388296358,
-0.0327900611,
0.0241215397,
0.0075968821,
-0.0491811782,
-0.0220205989,
-0.0304270424,
0.0697764456,
0.039117489,
-0.0228988323,
-0.0485584959,
0.0559388027,
0.0059579667,
-0.0336927474,
0.0583480112,
-0.0508453548,
0.0465057008,
-0.0377984606,
-0.0136492867,
0.0205608979,
0.0095805014,
-0.0120331747,
0.0096668899,
-0.0891297609,
0.0115303257,
-0.033909414,
0.0792642012,
0.0171876475,
0.0068150703,
-0.0129785873,
0.0247631725,
-0.0134202596,
0.0212477501,
-0.0019632345,
0.0263391864,
-0.0031604986,
-0.0195200965,
0.0079602012,
0.0248279683,
-0.0343356654,
0.0107200053,
0.038689293,
-0.0103036398,
-0.0290615205,
-0.0041263467,
-0.0222997572,
-0.0040451796,
0.0987089947,
-0.0034896669,
-0.0207332484,
-0.0033413486,
-0.0035343159,
0.0229601953,
-0.0101918774,
-0.0631904379,
0.0203945152,
0.0217043143,
0.0716280192,
-0.0076419013,
0.0369223133,
0.0166551284,
-0.005165549,
-0.0346598476,
-0.0360645652,
0.0407137387,
-0.0181465279,
0.0035003526,
0.0166522749,
-0.0349639654,
-0.0100479098,
0.0135092763,
0.0331728756,
0.0333895199,
0.0063613118,
0.0430774242,
0.0082454132,
-0.0070030079,
0.0535978116,
-0.0453703925,
-0.0945634097,
-0.0387933291,
0.0321920589,
0.0573561303,
-0.0248237886,
0.0407203883,
-0.0266574752,
-0.0054987078,
-0.0600846596,
0.0058973366,
0.040570233,
-0.0416693129,
0.0493849963,
0.0080557885,
-0.0088166595,
0.027293561,
0.0717357248,
0.043713592,
0.0290959589,
0.0234009139,
0.0122504374,
-0.0142166791,
-0.0090857074,
0.0288986042,
-0.0223093573,
0.0176490806,
0.0578114204,
-0.018978484,
-0.0345614851,
-0.0211445969,
0.0125111211,
0.001141521,
0.0276479218,
0.0177650582,
0.0192236938,
-0.0337999128,
-0.0265528951,
-0.0271550231,
-0.0490046144,
-0.0333144404,
0.051828932,
0.0289702266,
-5.514340611e-33,
-0.0469485633,
-0.0426959358,
0.0577793159,
0.0039368626,
-0.0053049941,
0.0252300426,
-0.0227825847,
0.0049000247,
-0.008527386,
0.0135884592,
0.0287493151,
0.0178999808,
0.0194057412,
0.0304287896,
0.0148128774,
0.0247047376,
0.0358782969,
-0.0141645428,
-0.0350248851,
-0.0191220492,
0.0104814721,
-0.0152219972,
0.0741987601,
-0.047608152,
-0.0442977175,
0.0724924281,
-0.0075946697,
0.0092973961,
-0.0084712151,
0.0291747861,
-0.0231820606,
-0.006386342,
0.0134314494,
-0.009720346,
-0.0632915571,
0.0128387567,
-0.0161229651,
-0.0209130011,
0.0172011554,
0.0525094755,
-0.0445753671,
0.007051344,
-0.0052890233,
-0.0037245634,
0.0177000184,
-0.0354207791,
0.0458946079,
-0.0364900194,
-0.0435381159,
0.0170271434,
-0.0438226126,
0.0614684373,
-0.0092417747,
-0.0449207835,
-0.0103310235,
-0.0087464517,
0.0128655517,
0.0467496477,
-0.0427195579,
-0.0018070224,
0.0545840152,
0.005105095,
0.054437194,
0.0156519264,
0.0124825928,
0.0756007656,
0.0265734904,
-0.0515203364,
-0.0257498343,
-0.03050109,
0.0210920274,
0.0469130203,
0.0588507503,
0.0459012985,
0.0329731107,
0.0430488363,
-0.0482881516,
0.0036595275,
-0.0713982433,
0.0950394645,
0.0185814407,
0.0195743814,
0.0180732869,
0.0188672934,
-0.0318790339,
-0.0041645896,
-0.0372700803,
0.023190476,
0.0551561154,
0.0271956623,
-0.057994321,
0.0478759706,
0.0351239443,
-0.0232575145,
-0.0033835797,
0.0177617371,
-0.00651894,
0.0517740659,
0.0268310085,
0.0580755621,
-0.0762124807,
-0.0019996047,
0.0352563113,
0.0461736247,
-0.0359460041,
0.0085160723,
0.0257860925,
0.0645342469,
-0.0291508231,
0.0002206441,
-0.088656798,
-0.0119993612,
-0.0491597876,
0.0231018085,
0.0090485169,
-0.0386692882,
-0.0206773486,
0.0254752245,
-0.0421158932,
-0.0465677641,
0.0059879231,
-0.0213566944,
-0.0093047488,
0.0199302174,
-0.0038320064,
-0.0138767315,
-0.0515878424,
-0.0337394439,
0.0046759467,
-0.0123192817,
0.0139325969,
0.0340497196,
2.593e-7,
0.0129404245,
0.0320657045,
0.0522735417,
-0.0160583593,
-0.0004444067,
0.0455351546,
-0.0624351539,
0.0379310064,
0.0008606885,
0.0070612016,
0.0014416133,
0.0617180765,
0.0594868436,
0.0059331944,
-0.0183065869,
0.0527976789,
-0.0209683049,
-0.0004297187,
-0.0643134341,
-0.024704583,
0.0467926934,
0.076341629,
-0.0281485692,
0.0035080349,
0.0554631837,
-0.0729699284,
0.074364908,
-0.0480385721,
-0.0102365231,
-0.0107811131,
0.0011067423,
0.0552257746,
0.0015251106,
0.0082905162,
0.0053839372,
-0.0155134136,
0.0472076982,
0.0753737837,
-0.0452499352,
0.0093120644,
-0.0186417084,
-0.002464002,
-0.0094078789,
-0.0655477121,
0.0831677318,
-0.042436067,
0.0067251069,
-0.0060705016,
-0.0100863017,
-0.0025917857,
0.0256931502,
-0.0076792953,
-0.0635161698,
-0.0198755786,
0.0296763014,
-0.0352149457,
-0.0385419205,
-0.0353241935,
0.0329168439,
-0.0226749014,
-0.0059127491,
-0.036261227,
-0.0675242618,
0.0122903232,
0.0308034327,
0.0551692694,
-0.0237992872,
1.74902895e-34,
0.0106788604,
0.0038296962,
-0.0029504921,
-0.0537237525,
0.0047265468,
0.0198804494,
-0.0291244555,
-0.0200326834,
-0.0452811867,
-0.0176234189,
0.011286879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17597v1 | SPECTRUM: Speaker-Enhanced Pre-Training for Long Dialogue Summarization | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | Sangwoo Cho, Kaiqiang Song, Chao Zhao, Xiaoyang Wang, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-turn dialogues are characterized by their extended length and the
presence of turn-taking conversations. Traditional language models often
overlook the distinct features of these dialogues by treating them as regular
text. In this paper, we propose a speaker-enhanced pre-training method for long
dialogue summarization, which leverages the inherent structure of multiple-turn
dialogues. To support our study, we curate a diverse dataset that includes
transcripts from real-world scenarios, movie or TV show transcripts, and
dialogues generated by a Large Language Model. We then perform a pre-training,
which encompasses the detection of speaker changes, and masked utterance
generation. Experimental results of fine-tuned models demonstrate that our
model achieves state-of-the-art performance on downstream benchmarks with long
context, surpassing baseline models and highlighting the effectiveness of our
approach. Our findings highlight the importance of curating pre-training
datasets that exhibit diversity and variations in length distribution to ensure
effective alignment with downstream datasets. | [
0.0296840612,
0.0394137725,
0.017325392,
0.0167808365,
0.0065735956,
-0.0179362837,
-0.0012066507,
-0.012393605,
-0.0120890997,
-0.0460316502,
-0.0184564088,
-0.0052309972,
0.0013235874,
0.0450796075,
0.009662793,
-0.0912744105,
0.0158598311,
-0.0483079553,
0.0191987846,
-0.0030601448,
0.0376727581,
0.0055781389,
-0.0049999407,
0.0127222128,
-0.0282618459,
-0.0065569989,
-0.0280167218,
0.0096032638,
0.0559359044,
-0.0089686234,
0.0198495556,
0.0504149199,
0.0449681282,
0.0113570727,
0.000001835,
-0.0453131311,
-0.0191061124,
-0.0181222782,
-0.0401925966,
0.0472877212,
0.0062172464,
-0.0241094064,
0.0184881166,
0.0267649014,
-0.0238058008,
-0.0082562631,
0.0168169569,
0.0478727296,
0.0951827243,
0.0767010897,
-0.0117073599,
-0.0372795984,
0.0009604277,
-0.0431498736,
-0.0196066238,
-0.0396040604,
-0.0051343222,
-0.0045169746,
-0.0084964801,
-0.0205858778,
-0.0239477083,
0.0269964132,
-0.0040025176,
-0.031499695,
-0.0007796069,
0.0119714886,
-0.0568648987,
0.0382089615,
0.017116854,
0.1113098711,
-0.0098588597,
0.0259823389,
0.0272722486,
-0.0067436057,
-0.0025633229,
-0.0446668155,
-0.03990357,
0.0138781965,
0.0520889834,
-0.0193191804,
-0.0495680086,
0.0581441037,
-0.0268243067,
0.0023971696,
-0.0594686419,
0.0020337759,
0.0154782152,
-0.0235035829,
-0.0775558576,
-0.0237033572,
0.0016277933,
-0.0720419437,
-0.0024759101,
0.0171306767,
-0.0387769938,
0.0090930043,
-0.0531103276,
-0.0059587345,
-0.0157141369,
0.0024314225,
-0.0094301905,
-0.0035621792,
-0.0395121239,
0.0455095172,
-0.0118488427,
0.0238256529,
0.0139602255,
-0.0018572046,
-0.0468488336,
-0.0090178819,
-0.0147708748,
0.0116953403,
-0.0584005527,
0.001845935,
-0.0618842877,
-0.0553773567,
-0.0316183008,
0.0233453903,
0.0077448809,
0.0001615741,
-0.0005151139,
0.0162930246,
0.013155126,
-0.0271737035,
0.0187309887,
0.0345981829,
-0.0162046812,
-0.0249976888,
0.0372144543,
-0.0338805802,
-0.0346893668,
0.0328241549,
0.0227273069,
-0.0041676746,
-0.0017399816,
0.0437322296,
-0.0204398744,
-0.0367402993,
0.0303491596,
-0.0263147764,
-0.0728212595,
-0.0435462147,
-0.0176135693,
-0.019239353,
0.064209342,
-0.0251381546,
-0.0003838945,
-0.0020597437,
0.0102716088,
-0.0132891759,
-0.0221679136,
0.0411702208,
0.0125829205,
0.0285896771,
0.0454063714,
0.0035416132,
0.0211623088,
0.0412740186,
0.0553688742,
-0.0068196822,
0.0616609491,
-0.0181124266,
0.0169363841,
0.0694110766,
0.0275360644,
0.0307687093,
0.0339877829,
0.0157498121,
-0.0264128279,
0.0117828837,
0.0399182811,
0.0406222269,
-0.04791319,
-0.0181075186,
0.0436511189,
0.048036579,
-0.0010145851,
0.0173051432,
0.0441816486,
0.0605594367,
0.0047073546,
0.0611681417,
-0.018334331,
0.0021779102,
-0.0188809019,
0.041374106,
0.0653699934,
0.0119552156,
-0.0490597934,
0.0023133969,
0.0212159194,
-0.0146169662,
0.0190648455,
0.0167670064,
-0.001657984,
0.0233601034,
-0.0675603747,
0.0891911834,
-0.0011791374,
-0.0866018236,
-0.0001019366,
-0.0164250024,
-0.0248631574,
0.0650030002,
0.0316055454,
-0.040873874,
-0.0106481109,
-0.0517908596,
0.0080453949,
0.0321219228,
0.0344045572,
-0.0349223018,
0.0604539141,
-0.0497854203,
0.0119783748,
-0.0180722587,
-0.0059802211,
0.0250055585,
-0.0065660416,
-0.0128015326,
0.0489018187,
0.0098434305,
-0.0066479319,
0.0165976696,
-0.0376503691,
-0.0243448187,
-0.0052585821,
-0.0086039351,
0.0203729495,
0.0109971371,
-0.0405501686,
-0.0200702026,
0.0156378467,
-0.006596847,
0.0096710688,
0.0498677567,
-0.0903952867,
-0.0736812651,
0.0254263822,
-0.0425080657,
0.0053563421,
0.0346235931,
-0.0400664359,
-0.0724955201,
0.0233279262,
-0.0269227587,
0.0247089025,
-0.0240875892,
0.0333006978,
0.0343286209,
0.042765487,
-0.0124200722,
0.0171040744,
0.0172537807,
-0.0330210365,
0.022996638,
0.0147409867,
0.0207805056,
-0.0609666221,
-0.0006787617,
0.015382343,
0.0143593969,
0.0032090971,
0.0384542756,
-0.0096737696,
-0.0383390598,
-0.0250741784,
-0.1167286038,
-0.0093451766,
-0.0238317605,
-0.0321136303,
0.0301821306,
0.0302090421,
-0.0168272462,
-0.0066512404,
-0.0538979433,
-0.0687525123,
0.0603873581,
-0.0217257962,
-0.0131511819,
0.0315211043,
0.010548166,
-0.0589342155,
-0.0171162318,
0.0207593571,
0.0755338147,
-0.0353277139,
-0.0137801692,
-0.0154320523,
-0.0073247789,
-0.0056818859,
0.0222125296,
-0.0250050407,
-0.0087544639,
-0.0342966281,
0.0202932823,
0.0778016001,
0.0287535656,
0.0709912404,
-0.0076787234,
0.0014043116,
-0.0547932088,
-0.0132125914,
0.0257669054,
-0.0162062868,
0.0056565758,
-0.0233831424,
0.0027866797,
0.0472043604,
0.0163838677,
0.0232215803,
0.0137768229,
-0.0443219543,
-0.0266548544,
0.0188948046,
-0.0391486697,
-0.0062509701,
-0.0469980761,
-0.0491006337,
0.0252913181,
-0.0347777046,
0.005691662,
0.0583956577,
-0.065154016,
-0.0242379699,
-0.0333343334,
-0.0282694157,
-0.0615007691,
0.0290000942,
0.0223901998,
0.0226034001,
-0.014331121,
-0.0222012494,
-0.0300592817,
-0.0425932594,
0.0298795886,
-0.0198953096,
0.0899794474,
-0.0245479196,
0.0058611925,
-0.0133321686,
-0.0067495559,
-0.0305817239,
-0.0642627552,
-0.0167239625,
0.000889284,
0.0538504906,
-0.0318373702,
-0.0120952455,
0.0360744372,
0.001579288,
0.0736319348,
-0.024845941,
0.0279741548,
-0.0204802975,
0.0663239062,
0.0410359316,
-0.0226181876,
-0.0038286529,
-0.0484392457,
0.0697189793,
0.0048447554,
0.0271948352,
-0.0210560374,
-0.0095350584,
-0.0200859886,
-0.0100869061,
-0.0357073583,
0.009093035,
-0.0092054084,
0.0709289238,
-0.0212203581,
0.0125490241,
0.1143788099,
0.0067510754,
-0.0291836467,
-0.0096342014,
0.0076826815,
0.0386943594,
0.0068470463,
0.0121035399,
-0.085747458,
-0.0232288949,
0.0001626863,
0.0148485862,
0.0214597806,
-0.0308111198,
-0.0426091813,
-0.0790405199,
0.0215527322,
0.0288890507,
-0.0502328351,
0.0058399201,
0.0131318774,
0.0004589546,
-0.0098643843,
0.0319883488,
0.0014793455,
-0.0157265626,
-0.0172337163,
0.0031889291,
-0.070472233,
0.0020764542,
0.0210614838,
-0.0140552679,
0.026394682,
0.0414174199,
0.0364487171,
0.0314575955,
0.0312813334,
0.0425952412,
-0.0428206958,
-0.0003046911,
0.0363597311,
0.089630492,
-0.0271516517,
-0.0199018493,
0.0069457181,
0.0529252365,
0.0320448242,
-0.0243544113,
0.0266867578,
-0.0218188222,
0.0035411017,
-0.0038992115,
-0.0013524741,
0.0730865896,
0.0027474565,
0.0602443144,
0.0547025278,
-0.0346779823,
-0.0131162312,
-0.0165952183,
0.0088628307,
-0.0610263981,
-0.0250202455,
-0.022275582,
0.0023677368,
0.0209390763,
-0.0619351566,
-0.0493938141,
0.0245353803,
-0.0297780037,
-0.022428982,
-0.0115107987,
-0.0062246486,
0.01282648,
-0.0114350067,
0.0170659851,
-0.0456602536,
0.0038338224,
-0.0521350875,
-0.0220298171,
0.0666031986,
-0.0179679934,
-0.0080069182,
0.0459101014,
-0.0976708904,
-0.0654854253,
0.0120905014,
0.0304329395,
0.0227430798,
0.1014896482,
0.0153149618,
-0.0037517992,
0.0523856394,
-0.0045180731,
-0.0261993203,
0.0447001979,
0.0530897006,
0.0204907935,
-0.0443508439,
0.0112217572,
-0.0317848101,
0.0404365808,
-0.0340427943,
0.007440554,
-0.0638972148,
-0.118269287,
-0.0102770682,
0.0057822876,
0.0134853125,
-0.0002870318,
0.0161171108,
-0.0160638355,
-0.0074848016,
-0.0352738909,
-0.0113291768,
-0.0305776279,
0.0161349997,
-0.024947634,
-0.0088491431,
0.004321442,
0.0447555222,
-0.0626243576,
0.016252188,
-0.0314156823,
-0.011224404,
-0.0208181497,
-0.0583411902,
-0.0043846136,
0.0168338232,
-0.0293761436,
0.0191006195,
-0.0197331142,
0.0027799902,
0.0008628624,
0.0471922308,
0.0015559943,
-0.0143404026,
0.0178993829,
0.0431646258,
-0.0819397792,
0.0012401215,
-0.0243401751,
0.0071590152,
0.0301676225,
-0.0467220917,
0.0822641477,
0.0359138958,
0.0113340868,
-0.0125041129,
0.0443609804,
-0.0222019982,
-0.0196315367,
-0.0263220072,
0.0205515213,
-0.0025193018,
0.0556708574,
0.0806909278,
0.0075752968,
0.0229528528,
0.0276645068,
0.0204470623,
-0.0614471883,
-0.0528409518,
-0.00599973,
0.0286774617,
-0.0022048787,
-0.010010777,
-0.0145313293,
-0.0107838297,
0.0225524958,
-0.0226873644,
0.008182521,
0.005250982,
0.0504643992,
-0.0019290607,
0.0052450295,
0.0100044189,
-0.0068707457,
-0.0115108136,
0.0263750535,
0.0099504758,
0.0078863921,
-5.45998465e-33,
-0.0426627025,
0.0046598422,
0.0026255515,
0.010834978,
-0.0640881583,
0.0060406439,
-0.0396469906,
0.0073380452,
0.0028415266,
0.0011692755,
-0.0267557502,
0.0251898747,
0.0064292066,
0.0587784201,
-0.0330612473,
-0.0218563005,
0.0936823338,
0.0008374723,
-0.0196993314,
0.0654316843,
0.0119710835,
0.0299540572,
0.0281740949,
-0.0641461909,
-0.0098437341,
-0.0519735888,
-0.0410443991,
-0.0141624473,
0.0083912453,
0.0185847618,
-0.0151235349,
0.0000208898,
0.0025733083,
-0.0387776941,
-0.0795614496,
0.008978935,
-0.0616921335,
0.0181287434,
0.0121083753,
0.0155951343,
-0.0211076345,
-0.0235989243,
0.0007602887,
-0.0254003853,
0.0335859694,
-0.057320483,
0.0447754301,
-0.0488054939,
-0.0116691459,
-0.0438069552,
-0.0315698981,
0.0275777951,
-0.0554161519,
-0.0648104101,
0.0146924751,
0.0811731145,
0.0290961266,
-0.0133107398,
-0.0701800361,
0.057241749,
0.0363128595,
0.0107796965,
0.0232502259,
0.0500833541,
0.0022765496,
0.0655731782,
0.0149736581,
-0.0133588584,
0.0087363124,
-0.0098964404,
-0.0125498949,
0.0271866936,
-0.0051709944,
0.0336458012,
0.0174877234,
0.001062621,
-0.0390417464,
0.020796651,
-0.0380022116,
-0.0060406993,
0.0117503442,
0.0071033402,
0.0340750776,
-0.0233784672,
-0.0311549902,
-0.0048925919,
0.0152899493,
-0.0164161883,
-0.0081710275,
0.0556933507,
-0.0239108764,
-0.0218946133,
0.065112412,
-0.0232963841,
0.0200005434,
0.0337870941,
-0.0597716086,
0.0030882668,
-0.0043573612,
0.0208916273,
-0.0193779469,
0.0045390264,
0.0941521898,
0.0235054195,
0.0091972267,
-0.0094998209,
0.0275804624,
0.0193515327,
-0.0538404062,
0.0248264968,
0.0413295962,
0.0531455651,
-0.0515471101,
0.0331639312,
-0.0263916962,
0.0217697062,
-0.0145261502,
0.0967664495,
-0.0171676334,
-0.0043360251,
-0.003482304,
-0.0089186504,
0.0410794541,
0.0532518029,
-0.0580373965,
0.0357234105,
-0.0014444393,
-0.0017962494,
0.0792865604,
-0.0344787166,
-0.0113697946,
-0.0166381858,
2.361e-7,
0.0190331265,
0.0149319833,
0.0912276134,
-0.0020134621,
0.0165165514,
0.0283891596,
0.0057052677,
0.0188735519,
0.0353698805,
0.0072857202,
0.0314688385,
0.037830919,
0.0627585128,
-0.0030805238,
-0.0794246718,
-0.0601247922,
-0.0981622264,
-0.0356585346,
-0.0397330746,
-0.0404697396,
0.0471011922,
0.0756246224,
-0.0058947979,
0.0165505726,
-0.0092341062,
-0.0143886963,
0.0655498356,
-0.0235778298,
-0.0497048758,
0.0274359994,
0.0239951499,
-0.0040426957,
-0.047152631,
-0.0046061901,
-0.014548813,
0.0167999156,
0.0204423796,
0.0543474928,
0.0225665476,
-0.0271719601,
-0.0114666121,
0.0527094081,
-0.0258327033,
0.0033222463,
0.0604768395,
-0.0663893223,
0.0005010033,
-0.054577332,
-0.0589209981,
0.0142934266,
-0.0063937609,
-0.0278693363,
-0.0138053596,
0.0527576171,
0.0162305105,
0.0181787126,
0.0175137408,
-0.1166314334,
-0.0497006364,
0.0170404948,
-0.0335336365,
-0.0110757509,
-0.0043831957,
-0.0492420122,
0.0184015352,
-0.0275158361,
0.0310565121,
2.157068179e-34,
0.0566525161,
0.027640814,
-0.0159960706,
0.0056632073,
0.025186481,
-0.0633929521,
0.0274854191,
-0.0305139534,
0.0367090292,
-0.0660206005,
-0.0303790644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17588v1 | Local and Global Contexts for Conversation | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | Zuoquan Lin, Xinyi Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The context in conversation is the dialog history crucial for multi-turn
dialogue. Learning from the relevant contexts in dialog history for grounded
conversation is a challenging problem. Local context is the most neighbor and
more sensitive to the subsequent response, and global context is relevant to a
whole conversation far beyond neighboring utterances. Currently, pretrained
transformer models for conversation challenge capturing the correlation and
connection between local and global contexts. We introduce a local and global
conversation model (LGCM) for general-purpose conversation in open domain. It
is a local-global hierarchical transformer model that excels at accurately
discerning and assimilating the relevant contexts necessary for generating
responses. It employs a local encoder to grasp the local context at the level
of individual utterances and a global encoder to understand the broader context
at the dialogue level. The seamless fusion of these locally and globally
contextualized encodings ensures a comprehensive comprehension of the
conversation. Experiments on popular datasets show that LGCM outperforms the
existing conversation models on the performance of automatic metrics with
significant margins. | [
0.0342047475,
0.0584462807,
-0.0064998497,
0.0450991504,
0.0026846074,
0.0010187263,
0.0254778434,
-0.0127824349,
-0.0306166764,
-0.0433415808,
-0.056194853,
-0.0330994166,
0.0108600343,
0.0588116907,
-0.0177185163,
-0.061574325,
0.0148482937,
-0.0028608921,
-0.0228106007,
0.0079451939,
-0.0198444314,
0.0019475727,
-0.0270163845,
0.0560676008,
-0.0048193014,
-0.001748639,
-0.0372619703,
0.0241721217,
0.0287454166,
0.0037330964,
0.0286317971,
0.034214396,
0.057370685,
0.0026589069,
0.0000018483,
-0.0097223092,
-0.0062957723,
-0.0608096756,
-0.0102771781,
-0.0450329781,
-0.0053545958,
-0.0178023744,
0.0028919776,
0.0191546716,
-0.0706408396,
-0.0132477144,
0.0218226444,
0.0815703347,
0.0654597804,
0.0663752854,
-0.0260950308,
-0.0686895698,
0.0183406938,
-0.0252085701,
0.0060094916,
-0.0673420355,
0.0057006041,
0.0452621132,
-0.0445644557,
0.018824026,
-0.0428629592,
-0.0011147256,
0.03309213,
-0.0456869155,
0.024724422,
0.0262833256,
-0.0143374316,
-0.0077682324,
-0.0085038496,
0.1196738482,
-0.0027599391,
0.0078147594,
-0.0187654905,
-0.0079405624,
-0.0179391727,
-0.047604505,
-0.0587948933,
0.0302656554,
0.0143694328,
0.0102976663,
-0.0419679582,
0.0626820326,
-0.0376232937,
-0.001002833,
-0.0523914099,
0.0465286672,
-0.0139390705,
-0.0102626858,
-0.034933947,
0.0013482578,
0.0289652701,
-0.0591158457,
0.0246579517,
0.0433008894,
-0.0458529256,
0.0110604661,
-0.0095903398,
0.0514265075,
-0.0110562611,
-0.0257584117,
-0.0391743816,
0.0238629133,
-0.0245550498,
0.0505314581,
0.0136106825,
0.0529992841,
-0.0415392369,
-0.0054648169,
-0.0210338291,
-0.0405982062,
-0.0454033427,
0.0019970636,
-0.0411048792,
0.0057044579,
-0.1128875613,
-0.0392920636,
-0.022470478,
0.0430112965,
0.0090147136,
-0.0093683479,
0.0113063678,
0.0286153499,
-0.0426366702,
0.0006071623,
0.0058960919,
0.062989451,
-0.0375385731,
0.0313146487,
0.025058886,
-0.0553180091,
-0.0322536193,
0.0407060273,
0.0389460512,
-0.035093192,
-0.0300155263,
0.0325222202,
-0.0139176557,
-0.0325396284,
0.0014582111,
-0.0020761995,
-0.0504826009,
-0.0395432971,
-0.0037686443,
-0.0014547374,
0.0459581949,
-0.0157023612,
-0.0042459997,
-0.0001252767,
-0.0041087209,
-0.0102690859,
-0.0073038582,
0.0179376826,
0.0350240543,
-0.0163737312,
0.0501369052,
0.0326986089,
0.0250272434,
0.0453701504,
0.0293033812,
0.0271862317,
0.0396331139,
-0.0097087761,
0.0155678848,
0.0163587071,
0.0265080705,
-0.0114038168,
0.0006429831,
0.0304512698,
-0.0013322604,
0.0274971034,
0.0148466304,
0.0216295365,
-0.0617735796,
-0.0175880063,
0.0530538373,
0.0467923135,
-0.0064713359,
0.0219212826,
0.0386857428,
0.0426586159,
-0.0332671255,
0.0160052907,
-0.0164336339,
0.0271712039,
-0.0011301152,
-0.019011654,
0.0202084295,
0.0158733502,
-0.0579808913,
-0.0139494231,
0.045097094,
-0.0274780821,
-0.0055805901,
-0.0208476223,
0.0216336977,
0.0466387346,
-0.0710050091,
0.0685467869,
0.0012850111,
-0.0546567217,
-0.0158574041,
-0.009539295,
0.014896322,
0.0013427545,
0.033772219,
0.0253128447,
-0.0380232483,
-0.0642869771,
0.0079877274,
0.0529924482,
-0.0078479098,
-0.0219561514,
0.0797746554,
-0.047797665,
-0.0361903459,
-0.0317911245,
-0.0142545691,
0.0112942178,
0.0099838134,
-0.0154044833,
0.0230930969,
-0.0062320214,
0.0782273561,
-0.0074055591,
0.0021623215,
0.011150199,
0.0350434706,
0.0027819066,
0.025715664,
0.0214003045,
-0.0081990007,
-0.0301634576,
0.0372714326,
-0.0052310945,
-0.0309623983,
0.0440009423,
-0.1045556068,
-0.0652124956,
-0.0057346271,
-0.0383084156,
-0.0111256381,
-0.0075305249,
-0.0242219064,
-0.0520522371,
0.011457013,
-0.0140788155,
0.0641949475,
-0.0339686871,
-0.0029289534,
0.0047488641,
0.031143235,
-0.0114950836,
0.0544211827,
-0.000023408,
-0.0139796007,
0.0211760774,
0.035292048,
0.0225777701,
-0.0427005328,
0.0083345538,
-0.0120752668,
-0.0278724711,
-0.0257431585,
0.0268271714,
0.0288691167,
-0.0615954883,
-0.0381476767,
-0.1206479818,
-0.0144476127,
-0.0173403993,
-0.033682134,
0.0284991469,
0.0371247754,
0.0047618672,
-0.0371603034,
-0.0413206667,
0.0100407563,
0.0290334597,
0.0029449426,
0.049206242,
0.0129534956,
-0.0096862931,
-0.0347987413,
0.0159065928,
0.0345114321,
0.0741391182,
-0.009457821,
-0.0107618058,
-0.0193156768,
-0.0023482461,
-0.0243928395,
0.03999082,
-0.0380317532,
-0.035533648,
0.0113003682,
0.0116153425,
0.0393229127,
0.0576740503,
0.0622805767,
0.0455977134,
-0.0168188699,
-0.0343963876,
-0.0361205786,
0.0139836995,
-0.0442339741,
-0.0290741716,
-0.0406093635,
0.0241692625,
0.0077566118,
0.0599843226,
0.0152780637,
0.0295442194,
-0.0342586562,
-0.0201824643,
0.0294147395,
-0.0215481874,
-0.0406128168,
-0.023917798,
-0.0209647063,
0.0613674149,
-0.0247078408,
-0.0326243527,
0.042455893,
-0.0239374097,
-0.0334011801,
-0.0160056595,
-0.001485883,
-0.032997068,
0.0440382138,
-0.0219641067,
0.0146838278,
-0.002608597,
-0.0587827042,
-0.0266838744,
-0.01066727,
0.0096236253,
-0.008910072,
0.0514893644,
-0.0254701208,
-0.0072706603,
0.0065468159,
-0.045986861,
-0.0670464262,
-0.0293008555,
-0.0119543374,
-0.0083480533,
0.0034679484,
-0.0270918831,
-0.0550036468,
0.0083027147,
0.003854011,
0.043730516,
-0.0171449445,
0.0106116338,
-0.0179566275,
0.0620412529,
0.0345358029,
0.044969935,
-0.0113302609,
-0.0014441106,
0.0656457841,
0.032537818,
0.0013463482,
-0.018969208,
-0.0295409877,
-0.0007463935,
-0.0017422703,
0.0353976861,
-0.0023201462,
0.0025784844,
0.0698380843,
-0.002006673,
-0.0488205776,
0.1166281328,
0.0247479323,
-0.0605151653,
-0.0194685571,
-0.021415228,
-0.0224346835,
-0.0012403162,
0.005105786,
-0.0947034806,
-0.0283295307,
-0.0241285227,
-0.0449652448,
0.0335320309,
-0.0239839889,
0.0141216991,
-0.0796667412,
0.0007352594,
0.0005910157,
-0.0605598465,
-0.034586709,
0.0136032933,
-0.0016649866,
-0.0114301043,
0.0375409499,
-0.010614424,
0.0144980242,
-0.0464781038,
-0.0196394827,
-0.0043611648,
-0.0404839516,
0.0404095985,
0.0102536762,
0.0256473217,
0.032156568,
0.0415363312,
0.0478096828,
-0.0029789726,
0.0285764188,
0.0026262056,
0.013629457,
0.0007519637,
0.0466234684,
-0.0303224716,
0.0060105212,
-0.0048210537,
0.0140040824,
-0.0312034693,
-0.0337618813,
-0.0048375451,
0.0106392438,
-0.0432349257,
0.0281721093,
0.0129789924,
0.0511379056,
0.0398131907,
0.0586298257,
0.025615884,
-0.0010032027,
-0.0080049401,
-0.0172010809,
0.0121578891,
-0.0150204096,
0.0000892208,
-0.0068821441,
0.0435768515,
0.0066189026,
-0.050511796,
-0.032679569,
0.0021756503,
0.0178927127,
-0.0219741445,
-0.0456063598,
0.0060661333,
0.004149084,
-0.0237224158,
0.0286888164,
-0.0479389913,
-0.0032410428,
-0.028364474,
-0.0004171072,
0.0814734027,
-0.0113058724,
-0.0298156943,
0.0342308953,
-0.0622701012,
-0.0123182638,
-0.0355446264,
0.0380757414,
0.0206387397,
0.0593593344,
-0.0032287394,
0.0057437206,
0.0106831901,
-0.0433624983,
-0.046539709,
0.010434703,
0.0542281382,
0.0442379713,
-0.0135551021,
0.0328116082,
-0.039075356,
0.054949034,
0.0106440727,
0.0281226747,
-0.0468262173,
-0.0971619785,
-0.007704461,
-0.0934491009,
0.0757163689,
0.0289449207,
-0.0202100091,
-0.0076769507,
0.0431773812,
-0.0325779766,
0.01439879,
-0.0645913258,
-0.002785217,
0.0115752583,
-0.0064916541,
0.0221707858,
-0.0011682413,
-0.0649723783,
0.0525253117,
-0.0262201782,
-0.0126781417,
0.0221541803,
-0.0088989325,
-0.0120342346,
0.0232474692,
-0.0336227044,
-0.0026324803,
0.0428753532,
0.0301879514,
0.0212885458,
0.1157401577,
0.0101160929,
-0.0119600389,
0.014514327,
0.0274715312,
-0.0831057578,
0.0244068261,
-0.0378551297,
0.0021167127,
0.0399152935,
-0.0071097384,
0.0256437659,
0.0363909826,
0.0295746587,
0.0009786137,
0.09461274,
-0.0255672652,
-0.0792467147,
0.0404030681,
-0.0101680057,
-0.0159658492,
0.0530617312,
0.0561905205,
-0.0315736569,
0.0097989123,
0.0116590764,
0.0398341455,
-0.047656659,
-0.0152375391,
0.0126362378,
0.0223760922,
0.0112142125,
0.0398225076,
-0.022536464,
-0.0253496952,
0.0078315828,
-0.0193317477,
-0.0098518357,
0.0330220498,
0.0640046075,
0.0277080759,
0.0011309522,
-0.0178685207,
-0.0266529843,
0.015760228,
0.0170972031,
-0.0106367357,
-0.0466158576,
-5.9003792e-33,
-0.0339414217,
-0.0366873033,
0.0027167429,
0.0184949283,
-0.0534601212,
0.0007285051,
-0.0561996475,
0.0044769221,
-0.0306140706,
0.0087554501,
-0.0078774765,
0.055474706,
0.006783864,
0.0738660768,
-0.0267616231,
-0.0398291722,
0.0530169792,
0.0137712788,
-0.0003136015,
0.0536719933,
0.0212701466,
0.0140554709,
0.0729553998,
-0.0924642906,
-0.0167068969,
-0.0087811481,
-0.0174345411,
0.0327540748,
0.0505351536,
0.0484600291,
-0.0346881486,
0.0204357281,
0.0093573155,
-0.0506870672,
-0.0111377947,
0.047393024,
-0.0523055494,
-0.0079725273,
-0.0092594409,
0.0133336093,
-0.0119072441,
-0.00256102,
-0.0157849323,
-0.0040967711,
0.0318184011,
-0.0426482074,
0.0189233404,
-0.0074518579,
-0.0237706807,
-0.0160426497,
-0.0396822952,
0.0107750772,
-0.0298937373,
-0.0488253422,
-0.0350094102,
0.0611880124,
0.0311244614,
-0.0016879963,
-0.0125008132,
0.0357060246,
-0.003754358,
-0.0112780277,
0.0163218006,
-0.0166734904,
0.0059648352,
0.0680078194,
-0.0068676388,
0.002428588,
-0.0432226248,
-0.0539606772,
-0.0214211736,
0.0316087641,
-0.0027460097,
0.0683989972,
-0.0175953005,
0.0128771663,
-0.0700068474,
0.0240686648,
0.0014378835,
0.0530950464,
-0.0129151195,
0.0208706073,
0.032252416,
-0.0059605562,
-0.0059420206,
-0.0030301881,
-0.0061671161,
-0.0168738775,
0.0170839485,
0.0272690281,
0.0078677842,
0.0112584494,
0.0663001761,
-0.0807777271,
0.0212531388,
0.0793021992,
-0.0094575491,
-0.0069892472,
-0.0042520114,
0.0273334831,
-0.0096539594,
-0.0343732499,
0.0714046434,
0.0202776305,
0.0081828572,
0.021001013,
0.0115967821,
0.0074436362,
-0.0522681475,
-0.0112023689,
-0.0135559933,
0.0083702337,
-0.0681893602,
0.0433114804,
-0.0046037054,
0.0304082874,
-0.0428970382,
0.1242857799,
-0.0349715501,
0.0175307449,
-0.035693828,
-0.0445192382,
0.0439364351,
0.0481298566,
-0.0456057899,
-0.0134839229,
-0.0093045477,
-0.016935885,
0.0609826669,
-0.0343826562,
-0.0152783403,
-0.0143212872,
2.505e-7,
0.002307313,
0.0209418833,
0.0668504611,
-0.0396147296,
0.0379317701,
0.0350982361,
0.0118519124,
0.016834626,
0.0286451075,
-0.0248936266,
0.0379536711,
0.003551028,
0.059528742,
-0.0002274581,
-0.0822671354,
-0.010162971,
-0.0973797739,
-0.0535398945,
-0.015439284,
-0.0110473996,
0.0504861772,
0.0769425258,
-0.013851936,
0.0086843586,
-0.0165426508,
0.006047423,
0.0794540718,
-0.0521044172,
-0.0116141364,
0.0133777941,
-0.0346465632,
-0.0069586257,
0.0030852512,
0.0064297523,
-0.0153302513,
0.0454988889,
0.0056598559,
0.0701511577,
-0.0062323101,
-0.091779463,
-0.0069206343,
0.0155554339,
0.0056687249,
-0.0527891591,
0.0338046812,
-0.1003559679,
-0.0178609937,
0.0006351345,
-0.0340664312,
0.0183444973,
0.0213226341,
-0.0054778634,
-0.0202257782,
0.0141149424,
0.0293415692,
0.0266582165,
0.0282454547,
-0.1137052253,
0.0234775804,
-0.0132188052,
-0.0592117161,
-0.0233983546,
0.009454499,
-0.0606785715,
0.0335222408,
0.0438164473,
0.0247642305,
1.898319832e-34,
0.0129789254,
0.0014978255,
0.0013751088,
0.0550686195,
0.0248498879,
-0.0291318558,
-0.013093804,
-0.0226673353,
0.0409943983,
-0.0689507127,
-0.008112317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17585v1 | Propagation and Pitfalls: Reasoning-based Assessment of Knowledge Editing through Counterfactual Tasks | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | Wenyue Hua, Jiang Guo, Mingwen Dong, Henghui Zhu, Patrick Ng, Zhiguo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME | Current approaches of knowledge editing struggle to effectively propagate
updates to interconnected facts. In this work, we delve into the barriers that
hinder the appropriate propagation of updated knowledge within these models for
accurate reasoning. To support our analysis, we introduce a novel
reasoning-based benchmark -- ReCoE (Reasoning-based Counterfactual Editing
dataset) -- which covers six common reasoning schemes in real world. We conduct
a thorough analysis of existing knowledge editing techniques, including input
augmentation, finetuning, and locate-and-edit. We found that all model editing
methods show notably low performance on this dataset, especially in certain
reasoning schemes. Our analysis over the chain-of-thought generation of edited
models further uncover key reasons behind the inadequacy of existing knowledge
editing methods from a reasoning standpoint, involving aspects on fact-wise
editing, fact recall ability, and coherence in generation. We will make our
benchmark publicly available. | [
0.0433050729,
0.0003691869,
-0.0133890538,
0.0230023954,
-0.0629018918,
-0.0099479156,
0.010456753,
-0.0362753011,
-0.0109796152,
-0.0463022403,
-0.004027016,
-0.0008855888,
0.0177697297,
0.0435607992,
0.0244337581,
-0.0567383543,
0.0709470212,
-0.0199790131,
0.0134937717,
0.0021698244,
-0.0190201271,
-0.0324385576,
-0.0275062639,
0.0009640146,
-0.0277349912,
-0.0659992471,
-0.0439265333,
0.0281184725,
0.0634242147,
0.0107943099,
-0.0212182272,
0.0505330712,
-0.0137509955,
0.0328565389,
0.0000023399,
-0.0294344891,
-0.0469397083,
0.0194854811,
-0.0770177245,
0.0028465556,
-0.0427625291,
0.0174544584,
-0.0285955109,
0.0091146259,
-0.0208572596,
0.0602296926,
0.037471097,
0.0433293693,
0.0934809372,
0.0991926268,
0.0071717263,
-0.0013310298,
0.0200208295,
-0.0264440048,
0.015252322,
-0.018559169,
0.031383127,
0.0461140722,
-0.026297316,
0.029942492,
-0.0298478734,
0.0390778892,
0.033776056,
-0.0335900895,
0.0124046011,
0.0102885915,
0.0004567658,
0.0009699838,
0.010903406,
0.0317926258,
0.0411610678,
0.0025219971,
-0.0228237957,
-0.0101991873,
0.0389785208,
0.0166792031,
-0.0175038446,
-0.0115131466,
-0.0138754109,
-0.0371481888,
-0.0271153376,
-0.0603747666,
0.0353610888,
-0.0032903454,
0.0073155328,
0.0557765402,
0.0096300673,
-0.048261378,
-0.0426259302,
-0.021664042,
-0.0214802306,
-0.0882254764,
0.0179729089,
0.0059567126,
-0.0326214172,
-0.0001472895,
-0.0354978181,
0.0092802821,
0.0034494048,
-0.0339121781,
0.0266753584,
0.0449163057,
-0.0134276263,
0.0556049496,
-0.0174091961,
0.0188970603,
-0.0198838133,
0.0311070867,
-0.0031232324,
0.029044129,
-0.0636848658,
-0.0351976268,
-0.0280457195,
0.0476411134,
-0.0594562851,
0.0347321741,
-0.0304805804,
-0.0060358341,
-0.0739462674,
0.0417310931,
0.0096104937,
0.0191265587,
-0.0175808854,
-0.0379943214,
-0.0412948132,
0.0244247932,
-0.0367055498,
0.0357677303,
0.0363815054,
0.0058354777,
-0.0094830506,
-0.0577800311,
0.007411215,
-0.0162176862,
-0.0086572152,
0.0450238027,
-0.0211800151,
0.0056715379,
-0.0580140688,
-0.0889270157,
0.0029888414,
-0.0829398707,
-0.0168597884,
-0.0611443296,
0.0155301634,
-0.0244508907,
-0.0414594449,
-0.0659145489,
0.0011322231,
0.0084504802,
-0.0213180333,
0.0786064565,
-0.0395169184,
-0.0024641089,
0.0404013023,
0.0280027352,
-0.0541592576,
0.0533391871,
0.0320341662,
-0.008633527,
0.0458521917,
0.024242755,
0.0053840913,
-0.0162921213,
0.0424577557,
-0.0241436046,
0.000893307,
0.0281946473,
-0.0166814886,
0.0514432751,
-0.0064475937,
0.0061050863,
-0.0349315926,
-0.0057804692,
0.0787398815,
-0.0427888185,
0.0189011078,
0.0154662998,
0.0038498759,
-0.0318917297,
-0.0046770889,
0.0128875645,
-0.0527117811,
0.0630585849,
-0.0391609669,
0.0253868606,
0.0014352929,
0.0085386382,
0.0028834925,
-0.048070237,
-0.0008464635,
0.047531981,
0.009151971,
-0.0050064679,
0.0284563135,
0.0330214128,
-0.0185282622,
0.0022561525,
-0.0020903184,
-0.0390448458,
-0.0084295683,
-0.0320017487,
-0.0363386348,
0.0857128948,
0.0738498047,
-0.059245456,
-0.0868088976,
-0.0343402587,
0.0012143,
0.0008712788,
0.0492773317,
-0.0142674064,
-0.0258144327,
-0.007072398,
-0.0376895927,
-0.052141469,
0.0352115184,
-0.0061585363,
0.0378920436,
-0.0097739156,
0.0183555614,
-0.0107776737,
0.032272622,
0.0022127966,
-0.0427153781,
0.0295357797,
-0.031512402,
0.0303560104,
-0.0309417117,
0.0246813856,
-0.0171122868,
0.0101678055,
0.0023333845,
0.0246571451,
-0.0310888495,
0.0244202502,
0.0067739659,
-0.0490561128,
0.057175763,
-0.0293100271,
-0.0548431352,
0.0275297184,
-0.0311093293,
-0.02034688,
0.0285684336,
-0.0148228975,
0.0337891802,
-0.026498165,
0.0407732427,
0.0084251761,
-0.0729263872,
0.0285732429,
0.0622700155,
-0.0144197494,
-0.027501367,
0.0033685802,
-0.008964519,
0.0081876134,
-0.0579359904,
0.0241777934,
-0.008764511,
0.001818348,
-0.0324970037,
-0.0220265724,
-0.0242751352,
-0.0502785146,
-0.0004095693,
-0.0533757694,
-0.0007416263,
-0.0285665542,
-0.0090443371,
0.0416773856,
0.0053190957,
0.0025811356,
0.0006343186,
0.0229500681,
0.0029369842,
-0.035704501,
0.0456053726,
0.0158021078,
0.0157939959,
0.0246948283,
-0.0234519001,
0.0070338212,
-0.0234968737,
0.0216492079,
0.0115144197,
0.0048784008,
-0.0345456488,
0.019334102,
-0.0791337788,
0.0016926727,
0.0053752759,
-0.016548384,
0.0109574748,
0.0301039051,
0.057587754,
0.0507575162,
-0.0102042509,
0.0030628196,
0.0479531139,
-0.0331293307,
-0.0094836736,
0.0423211269,
0.008628645,
0.0184751227,
0.0052670236,
-0.0183519851,
-0.0425885431,
0.0271416269,
0.0025608465,
-0.0358256884,
-0.0403810069,
0.0533944145,
-0.0004605793,
-0.0341324992,
-0.0516270995,
-0.0354569554,
-0.0077028456,
0.0397223607,
-0.0652628466,
0.0032474222,
0.0960054249,
0.0042726249,
0.0386865139,
-0.0162519533,
0.0318228789,
0.0217694715,
0.0720908567,
-0.0055743577,
0.0311517864,
-0.0189367533,
0.0346446112,
-0.0554277636,
-0.0263093654,
0.0688611344,
-0.0266678743,
0.0111571765,
-0.0805301294,
-0.0100780111,
0.0157852564,
-0.0315909497,
-0.0406593122,
-0.0012393482,
0.0090017281,
0.0109278839,
0.002911099,
-0.0425842628,
-0.0179678798,
-0.005651989,
0.0440376215,
0.0820449442,
0.0021505677,
-0.0256262347,
-0.0150319412,
-0.0240628589,
0.0449111946,
0.0288152024,
0.0478006713,
-0.0040901131,
0.0283574611,
0.0550912991,
0.0239691995,
-0.0811830387,
0.0121188322,
0.0043483502,
-0.0681523383,
-0.0708680376,
-0.0024844883,
-0.018743325,
0.055049587,
-0.0700732321,
-0.0369520374,
0.0621875115,
0.0549163334,
0.0362623148,
0.0156683866,
-0.0601108149,
-0.0072002895,
0.0622634441,
0.0304323472,
-0.0714090094,
-0.0236515682,
0.0572556853,
0.0164189078,
-0.0346242711,
-0.0736566186,
-0.0216336362,
-0.0887689143,
0.0481944084,
-0.0155978147,
0.009277842,
-0.0653826222,
-0.0214170255,
0.0169556402,
0.0130313914,
-0.0601653457,
0.0618538484,
0.0324413143,
0.0106139071,
-0.0276433993,
0.0017880003,
-0.0296084881,
0.0151321488,
-0.0137396799,
0.0253394768,
0.0452715158,
0.0172042325,
0.0425834805,
-0.0119815506,
0.0338197872,
0.0347196646,
0.0289870556,
-0.0132599287,
0.0530565977,
-0.0133560989,
0.0208536927,
-0.0023869202,
0.0238817129,
0.0344998762,
-0.0697558373,
0.0265306551,
0.1136925817,
-0.024205653,
0.0218726415,
-0.0126574645,
-0.0070337891,
0.0141285369,
0.0652068108,
0.0298088025,
0.0126693826,
0.006413402,
-0.0501481071,
-0.0064213886,
-0.0237304196,
0.0126480721,
-0.0238781758,
0.0229489189,
0.029227918,
-0.0768717453,
-0.0508162603,
0.0331137851,
0.0515414253,
0.0167993605,
-0.0059264889,
0.0285023283,
0.0006858004,
-0.0488462113,
-0.0291912351,
-0.025688393,
0.0228571389,
0.0101014357,
-0.0072128903,
-0.0194734521,
-0.044854518,
-0.0302993618,
-0.0274264775,
-0.0375245623,
-0.041996289,
0.01560238,
0.0489607938,
0.0355529748,
0.059614908,
-0.0008433116,
-0.0228084922,
-0.0093884189,
0.0090228012,
-0.0362718217,
0.0333043709,
0.03863113,
-0.0282053743,
-0.0001833467,
0.0415804312,
-0.0380623415,
-0.0344516486,
0.0349001065,
0.0495373867,
-0.0381635688,
-0.0070795855,
0.0188256893,
0.0056690886,
0.0289603006,
0.0262103453,
-0.0119314091,
-0.0553522706,
0.0777709186,
-0.0606061146,
-0.0281207245,
-0.0107482551,
0.0181030836,
-0.001046709,
-0.0015056229,
0.000137984,
0.015580493,
-0.0054678158,
-0.000411048,
0.0102655301,
-0.0208854266,
0.0191617478,
0.0195598248,
0.0393010192,
-0.0006374589,
-0.0075061405,
0.0136117833,
-0.0130014038,
0.03741486,
-0.0248798151,
0.040063858,
0.0396579988,
-0.0237657484,
-0.0598169826,
-0.0014757295,
-0.1026603952,
-0.0318528302,
-0.0170306712,
0.0489745922,
0.0354944654,
0.0102426494,
0.0030215571,
-0.0423094593,
-0.0378048383,
0.0041413587,
0.0383505709,
0.0359130502,
-0.0336573459,
-0.0009773992,
0.0165764783,
0.0024169597,
0.0247937497,
0.044946827,
-0.0793539137,
0.1156258211,
-0.0462472811,
-0.0579371601,
-0.0431778803,
-0.0675216913,
-0.0348425359,
0.0185007937,
0.0008122423,
-0.0183519349,
-0.0960244909,
-0.0505012311,
0.0001392437,
0.0412913114,
-0.0084972689,
0.0150667233,
0.0039967741,
0.0484184138,
0.0095376736,
-0.0445659421,
-0.0118450141,
0.0110878218,
-0.0335710123,
0.0134828938,
-0.0026754837,
-6.283440483e-33,
-0.0413898006,
-0.0083450433,
0.0503740795,
-0.01754147,
-0.0242537279,
-0.0205736477,
-0.0469314307,
0.006624416,
-0.0046306476,
0.0404561833,
-0.0233642329,
0.0342887975,
-0.0022014668,
0.0018115578,
-0.0181305707,
0.0135619473,
0.0827937871,
0.0245921388,
-0.0475854836,
0.004647926,
0.0474250652,
0.0187318921,
0.0575412288,
-0.066736728,
0.0419707671,
0.0297709461,
-0.0067500891,
0.0469280258,
-0.0896668211,
0.0230896715,
0.0210574288,
-0.0045161871,
0.0093233921,
-0.048412282,
-0.0097525464,
-0.0653320625,
-0.0379914306,
-0.0156326611,
0.015574296,
0.0139189977,
-0.0256945454,
-0.0455753878,
0.0427835062,
0.0328147933,
-0.0161437429,
-0.0443401374,
0.0120928278,
-0.0338385925,
0.027612213,
0.0319305919,
-0.0741839632,
0.007182654,
-0.0201574881,
-0.0503448993,
-0.0299970489,
0.0115017798,
0.0234710518,
-0.0615087226,
-0.12493857,
0.0038107643,
0.057695739,
0.0230336618,
0.0721403733,
-0.0138512105,
0.0022097852,
0.0481141731,
-0.0004573858,
0.0537754968,
-0.020119559,
0.0214265604,
-0.0349763744,
0.0645703152,
0.0428496897,
0.0908479318,
0.0376872197,
-0.0076271594,
-0.0582393929,
-0.0051142303,
-0.0926015452,
0.0451383553,
0.0010097072,
0.0158449579,
-0.0133282412,
0.0199494138,
-0.0640149117,
0.011041116,
-0.0268296674,
-0.0217990335,
0.0251298565,
0.0254347567,
-0.0257696528,
0.019258121,
-0.0132280681,
0.0040685912,
0.0113071753,
0.0392014049,
-0.0141444262,
0.0399798006,
0.0033091193,
-0.0082644448,
-0.0446905941,
0.0532163046,
0.047121428,
0.031076422,
0.0154657792,
-0.0106259212,
0.0566793866,
0.0274392106,
-0.0421846509,
0.01096131,
-0.0339442156,
0.0479885489,
-0.0013086814,
-0.0442692786,
0.0211582873,
0.0076830373,
-0.0062000877,
0.0027313929,
0.0440629758,
0.0226156991,
-0.0355708785,
0.0439305343,
0.0028633615,
0.0077248681,
0.0145081505,
0.0234129,
-0.0067725843,
0.0102677494,
-0.003335637,
-0.0455461666,
-0.0150960758,
0.037267223,
2.976e-7,
0.0293700118,
0.0429515056,
0.037285611,
0.0103553636,
0.041394297,
0.0577725805,
-0.0405119285,
-0.0234395619,
0.0455197133,
-0.0185845699,
0.0091129355,
0.0526946895,
0.0150553137,
0.0324182846,
-0.005537515,
-0.0152214253,
-0.0288731623,
-0.0284901727,
-0.0407813154,
-0.0321154781,
0.0630555674,
0.0000953673,
0.0445683822,
-0.0067571956,
0.0121421292,
-0.0167979598,
0.0580473244,
-0.0015952265,
0.0071880436,
-0.0161162931,
0.0421275944,
0.0045912755,
0.0020999194,
0.0477850214,
-0.0190488473,
-0.0146483919,
-0.0491522625,
0.013957601,
-0.0352942236,
0.0086048273,
-0.0418795124,
-0.0068154796,
0.0027830761,
-0.0378181227,
0.0711490884,
-0.0323728658,
0.002354112,
0.0058027417,
-0.0230992939,
0.0272079129,
-0.0140116503,
-0.0068517178,
-0.0091643771,
-0.017074829,
-0.0105149159,
0.0436555333,
-0.0116731049,
-0.0337695777,
-0.0515369773,
0.0470496789,
-0.0111837676,
-0.0588522106,
-0.0274779629,
-0.0128332544,
0.0338628329,
-0.073620826,
-0.019451905,
2.548986031e-34,
0.0065588146,
0.021580521,
0.0273996834,
-0.0069642123,
0.0468875691,
-0.0266882814,
-0.0128013734,
-0.0335355662,
-0.013548268,
-0.0319686756,
-0.0308331288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17574v1 | Scavenging Hyena: Distilling Transformers into Long Convolution Models | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | Tokiniaina Raharison Ralambomihanta, Shahrad Mohammadzadeh, Mohammad Sami Nur Islam, Wassim Jabbour, Laurence Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs), epitomized by
architectures like GPT-4, has reshaped the landscape of natural language
processing. This paper introduces a pioneering approach to address the
efficiency concerns associated with LLM pre-training, proposing the use of
knowledge distillation for cross-architecture transfer. Leveraging insights
from the efficient Hyena mechanism, our method replaces attention heads in
transformer models by Hyena, offering a cost-effective alternative to
traditional pre-training while confronting the challenge of processing long
contextual information, inherent in quadratic attention mechanisms. Unlike
conventional compression-focused methods, our technique not only enhances
inference speed but also surpasses pre-training in terms of both accuracy and
efficiency. In the era of evolving LLMs, our work contributes to the pursuit of
sustainable AI solutions, striking a balance between computational power and
environmental impact. | [
0.0253376886,
0.0928209126,
-0.0047948472,
0.0669888929,
-0.0237985048,
0.0179624874,
-0.0367658101,
-0.0131092183,
-0.0221915655,
-0.0346577577,
-0.0568320416,
-0.0174311642,
-0.0152866803,
-0.0052002352,
0.0130234715,
-0.0324389078,
0.0408283882,
-0.0199486371,
-0.0433190875,
0.0100091752,
-0.0214595944,
-0.0030762372,
0.0460639969,
0.0265134126,
0.0000511864,
-0.0184246153,
-0.0197747592,
0.0000230372,
0.0224888884,
-0.0067199646,
0.0005251779,
0.0468201488,
0.0031092986,
0.0546272211,
0.0000022401,
-0.0132371886,
-0.0067401212,
-0.0002857747,
-0.0209479816,
0.0347080566,
0.0433862507,
-0.0131093934,
0.0039896476,
-0.0103719775,
-0.0267731193,
-0.0436847135,
0.0466217361,
0.0463672392,
0.0678031221,
0.0642845035,
-0.0078292601,
-0.073320657,
0.0314366333,
-0.0652999952,
-0.0148342373,
-0.0820047185,
0.0311628133,
-0.0472795516,
-0.0332246311,
0.009134708,
-0.0461078249,
0.0610808879,
0.0353025422,
0.0379019044,
0.0055226879,
0.0251388475,
-0.0646146238,
-0.0089234496,
-0.0241901241,
0.0754530877,
-0.0586977527,
-0.0233771279,
-0.0144404285,
0.0162175354,
-0.0252982453,
-0.0411410853,
-0.0595858432,
0.0225921012,
0.0171880815,
0.0211007744,
0.0174953137,
-0.0056378511,
0.0261398386,
0.0017598552,
-0.050511688,
0.0402303636,
0.0207614135,
-0.0175929498,
0.0259410758,
0.0104985526,
-0.0396373868,
-0.0440611392,
-0.0014852216,
0.0462868698,
0.0148701947,
0.010026346,
-0.0436513834,
-0.0070618768,
-0.0057026981,
-0.0234587956,
0.0072022462,
0.0343530737,
-0.0168911386,
0.0429727212,
-0.0371764638,
0.0153107168,
-0.085281238,
0.0089573022,
-0.0447269566,
-0.0261369757,
-0.0421081036,
-0.002947622,
-0.0625733659,
0.0113433292,
-0.0372833349,
-0.0275806542,
-0.0060460144,
0.0130642522,
-0.0053980551,
-0.059539903,
0.0235435478,
0.0200293344,
-0.0304242428,
-0.0163200423,
0.0017071997,
0.0761760622,
-0.0200423189,
-0.0015312647,
-0.0047039213,
-0.0691493452,
-0.0343542472,
0.0274811778,
0.0101164738,
-0.0379935093,
0.0006207942,
0.0824239478,
-0.0211300906,
-0.0560388006,
-0.0373075381,
0.0146464938,
-0.0145064509,
-0.0817296132,
0.0333881564,
-0.0299318153,
0.0224173628,
-0.0393822119,
0.0227123052,
-0.0088319592,
0.0082771555,
0.0051484271,
-0.0605225563,
0.0652019754,
-0.0080169728,
0.012615799,
-0.0122822905,
0.0085580377,
-0.0072379103,
0.0802244917,
0.0401056409,
0.0326989554,
-0.0144641763,
-0.0260979682,
0.0066238116,
0.0466494374,
0.0153851202,
0.0174482521,
-0.0135220047,
-0.0095721437,
-0.0437895283,
-0.0168569889,
0.0492597744,
0.0683381855,
-0.0299277026,
0.0207381081,
0.0558093451,
0.0461802855,
0.0449415073,
0.0521043949,
0.0324907117,
-0.0088787097,
-0.0266019013,
0.0004126377,
-0.0747746676,
0.0307047274,
0.0063073416,
-0.0066784429,
-0.0036715758,
0.0626843646,
-0.013672539,
-0.0179220177,
0.0205325969,
-0.0065139355,
0.0101525849,
0.0089498349,
0.0100706005,
0.0196130611,
-0.0278730262,
0.0670315474,
0.0309686996,
-0.0494886078,
-0.0059208912,
-0.0576266162,
0.0238060337,
0.0373881198,
0.0219516251,
-0.0063013677,
-0.0070463698,
-0.0055874516,
-0.0108717382,
0.0281998031,
0.008793233,
0.0110781947,
0.0194171313,
-0.0372372419,
-0.0280008819,
-0.0261795837,
0.0138081769,
-0.0064390022,
0.0441220887,
0.0139084589,
0.0408976935,
0.007750914,
0.0160820596,
0.0388879515,
-0.0019715023,
-0.0572524928,
-0.0168178119,
0.0307278447,
0.0324439257,
-0.0110374019,
-0.0078522637,
0.0023031721,
0.0504237376,
-0.0278615821,
-0.0339263305,
0.0212691277,
-0.0326236002,
-0.0253833905,
0.0303032212,
-0.0395299383,
0.0164518282,
0.0575577244,
-0.0362017192,
-0.0278473757,
0.0111808032,
-0.0472620092,
0.1203308776,
-0.0225487966,
0.0396041088,
-0.0116885751,
0.0382863805,
-0.0227778014,
0.0726486817,
-0.0064618271,
-0.0413215309,
-0.0136715509,
-0.0168626588,
-0.0168100223,
0.0104281949,
-0.0173101109,
0.0265230965,
0.0058389064,
0.0032604779,
0.0223282911,
-0.001733611,
-0.0286576468,
-0.009464277,
-0.0810237825,
0.0193948988,
-0.0568282865,
0.0313760489,
0.0268329382,
0.0188130178,
0.0109814126,
-0.0064726654,
-0.0149664907,
0.0235328991,
-0.0237244423,
0.026619317,
0.0142053114,
-0.0161032248,
-0.0197302848,
-0.0285415519,
-0.0481576994,
0.0035939796,
0.0652812198,
-0.0303795692,
-0.0216573384,
-0.0317406431,
-0.0004941825,
0.0229169782,
0.0259613488,
-0.0108854482,
-0.0421492904,
-0.0132993553,
-0.0092078503,
0.0259449892,
0.0688511953,
0.0248250421,
0.003547366,
0.0452558547,
0.0163100082,
-0.0015221126,
0.046115391,
-0.0470172614,
-0.035116002,
-0.0361276343,
0.0182489417,
0.0169473011,
0.0745119825,
-0.0692291185,
-0.015273477,
-0.0406565405,
-0.0033431961,
0.0210050493,
-0.0299718417,
0.0108128879,
-0.0152807822,
-0.0057799243,
0.0182929151,
-0.0335376784,
-0.0315773785,
0.0395570584,
-0.0275073051,
-0.0062177796,
-0.0318543836,
-0.0008537929,
-0.0414886735,
0.0813455582,
0.0175673869,
0.0155793279,
-0.0025962926,
0.0072719706,
-0.0318894126,
0.0200632624,
-0.034500096,
-0.0063882279,
0.0903840587,
-0.0079714945,
0.0192437116,
-0.0090624979,
-0.0590384305,
-0.0357285775,
-0.000214303,
-0.046860978,
0.0121264569,
0.0400644168,
-0.0175333731,
-0.0407464206,
0.0319145247,
0.0271944553,
0.0529897474,
-0.0086463857,
-0.0096841669,
-0.0366297141,
0.0619952343,
0.0508955158,
0.0300253127,
0.0389172845,
0.0017809389,
0.0304606874,
0.070200339,
0.0364689082,
0.0249721389,
-0.0110343285,
0.0083908094,
0.0334514938,
-0.0263141412,
-0.0154635673,
-0.0026683647,
0.040134564,
-0.0847372934,
-0.0210791137,
0.0743283629,
-0.0210763644,
-0.045691818,
0.0315297358,
0.029476855,
0.0241529327,
0.0305056274,
0.0299774744,
-0.0825205222,
-0.0700916648,
0.0151090594,
0.011740596,
0.0191582385,
-0.0217266958,
0.0031517812,
-0.0972987264,
0.0394464992,
0.0145769296,
-0.0263489671,
-0.0003130193,
-0.0101477467,
0.0105209677,
-0.0437028408,
-0.0145764854,
0.0156663619,
-0.0279129073,
-0.0236224532,
-0.003861483,
0.0090949293,
0.0011026241,
0.0192848481,
-0.003539385,
-0.0015981152,
0.0813584328,
0.0243947655,
0.0142788542,
-0.0589131005,
0.0168158729,
-0.0427038856,
-0.0085240137,
0.0187985785,
0.0474263616,
-0.0242714472,
-0.0289627574,
0.0117788697,
0.0368124433,
-0.0568834953,
-0.0046269754,
-0.0044611073,
0.0805999413,
0.0276103318,
-0.0496858843,
-0.0115053318,
-0.0258482583,
-0.0038850841,
0.0782695711,
0.0392743088,
-0.0201714542,
-0.0738155544,
-0.0057163625,
-0.0285506248,
-0.0133201145,
-0.0302451253,
0.0257499516,
-0.0028776866,
-0.0907131881,
-0.0417312458,
-0.0330367908,
0.0106528746,
0.021545196,
-0.0014457578,
-0.0371076353,
0.0654892027,
0.0215668865,
-0.0597847514,
0.0260342713,
-0.0490847081,
0.0021459998,
-0.0425183885,
0.0233341176,
0.0374629796,
0.009704438,
-0.022505885,
0.0468424708,
-0.11575488,
-0.0515500829,
0.0128924279,
0.0544558726,
0.0208850242,
0.0382903591,
-0.0061037955,
-0.0060787918,
0.0312397014,
0.0179709662,
-0.0317750201,
0.0374293886,
0.0097538233,
-0.0168215632,
0.0038303537,
0.0528640896,
-0.0123700919,
0.0515131801,
0.0150291808,
0.0599379018,
-0.0300606359,
-0.0106478464,
0.028006861,
0.0013021284,
0.0303869862,
0.0038851309,
0.0230539907,
0.013286816,
0.0250606202,
0.0224771667,
0.0043139132,
-0.0657050833,
-0.0145557281,
0.0243558642,
0.0129655674,
-0.0036639154,
0.0418354124,
0.0364005975,
-0.0137547962,
-0.0428407229,
0.0169609003,
0.0002203812,
-0.012229654,
0.0181402508,
-0.0085255057,
-0.0096951816,
-0.0246988609,
0.0076259281,
0.0421729237,
-0.0258086585,
0.0239556897,
0.025172824,
-0.0042378362,
-0.0363747627,
0.0335246548,
-0.0817103535,
-0.0552422591,
-0.018927671,
0.0223905426,
0.0354084335,
-0.0293324273,
0.0439875387,
-0.0255947784,
-0.0370829552,
-0.0177699793,
-0.0146923074,
-0.0243769437,
-0.0215663817,
0.0120844692,
0.0205838867,
-0.0294818524,
-0.0176112093,
0.0574202649,
-0.035218183,
0.0662369356,
0.0056591281,
-0.0096235052,
-0.0206269827,
-0.0709908903,
-0.0115907472,
0.0046919561,
0.0193605945,
0.0094972532,
-0.042096328,
-0.0877989978,
-0.0096662287,
-0.0359200649,
0.0001904021,
-0.0381249376,
0.0305128079,
0.0395386256,
0.0139265098,
-0.0953710675,
-0.0018406409,
-0.0126716346,
-0.0263367556,
0.0013628723,
0.0072883056,
-7.005686987e-33,
0.0011571578,
0.0073817926,
0.01104852,
-0.0347040221,
-0.0861069709,
0.0224227104,
-0.0183519851,
-0.0468957685,
-0.0427599289,
0.014991493,
-0.0159024466,
0.0079952879,
-0.0008744083,
0.0435355157,
0.0034302427,
0.0072712451,
0.0411482267,
0.0076151853,
-0.0237045344,
0.0537862442,
0.0156897213,
0.043149028,
0.0625740886,
0.0127228452,
-0.085883148,
0.0152972704,
0.0052553024,
0.0341624394,
-0.016508596,
0.0095091555,
-0.0406292938,
0.0234016888,
0.0290139802,
-0.0695404559,
-0.0010386871,
0.0656963214,
-0.0850484371,
-0.0020044926,
0.0116383759,
-0.0044843438,
-0.0326341093,
-0.0324720852,
0.0542587675,
0.0232971329,
0.0241940841,
-0.0480457358,
-0.0036374624,
-0.0183097534,
-0.0127529735,
-0.019995207,
-0.1021992415,
0.003131693,
-0.0172639303,
-0.0235280152,
0.0325002559,
0.0301236212,
-0.0059206225,
0.0483903475,
-0.0567791648,
-0.0073784804,
0.0234973691,
0.0444789305,
0.0495358445,
0.0328743123,
0.0050455253,
0.0358559489,
0.025076516,
-0.0135845281,
-0.0733860061,
-0.0204022489,
0.0252032373,
0.0575535931,
0.0034165545,
-0.0236098077,
0.0694253668,
-0.0155589394,
-0.0692531615,
-0.0430926979,
0.0195273515,
0.0752470642,
0.0081749074,
0.0147823421,
0.015564234,
0.0036197088,
-0.0356230401,
0.0247734487,
-0.0228532143,
-0.0046594325,
0.0237511452,
0.0204767901,
-0.036891792,
0.0519931391,
0.0208640229,
-0.0586619675,
0.041498594,
0.0358882062,
-0.0137789696,
0.0370550416,
0.0093089864,
0.0499102473,
-0.0258301385,
0.0041072471,
-0.0017501391,
0.0083869556,
0.0007380321,
-0.0218305141,
0.0445629731,
0.0325573161,
-0.0605442002,
-0.027755294,
-0.0634384006,
0.0260057691,
0.0174948107,
0.0141941337,
0.0430249833,
0.0405933745,
0.0050443918,
-0.0053268624,
0.0098846182,
0.0209048428,
-0.0376132168,
0.0312269107,
0.0222611856,
0.0233851038,
-0.0077351667,
-0.0073812902,
-0.0422788374,
0.0291375034,
0.0121289315,
-0.1066170186,
-0.033094421,
0.0451903492,
3.02e-7,
0.0276677739,
0.0271305945,
0.0267360937,
-0.0050655133,
0.0310651176,
0.0074929572,
0.029098548,
0.039909739,
-0.0122866854,
-0.0203880705,
-0.0077649406,
0.0599706769,
0.0563909262,
0.0022440399,
-0.075944975,
-0.0423211567,
-0.0647151917,
-0.0276509393,
-0.0445132293,
-0.0437330604,
0.0211775918,
0.1204135194,
0.0139486548,
-0.0295572188,
0.0275413487,
0.0154958945,
0.0549064316,
-0.0024487169,
0.0443351641,
0.0464839004,
-0.0116377398,
-0.0041037169,
-0.0318743661,
0.0054898877,
0.0102291768,
0.0293112304,
0.0008067479,
0.0768657848,
-0.0063160253,
-0.0374681838,
-0.0031203162,
0.0067013651,
0.0074105919,
-0.0532635711,
0.0836258233,
-0.063016057,
-0.0260393433,
-0.062258631,
-0.0203823559,
0.0029181656,
-0.0109181413,
0.0196420588,
0.0332654826,
0.0178334415,
0.0071117571,
-0.0179867372,
-0.0347113535,
-0.1139719039,
0.0073748119,
0.0076528629,
-0.0488387607,
-0.0369831137,
-0.0714374185,
-0.0464965776,
0.0531168804,
-0.0334732868,
0.017002102,
2.608463061e-34,
0.0184218958,
-0.0118164178,
0.0310395248,
0.020960005,
0.0233715884,
-0.0194108281,
0.0302488692,
-0.009065154,
-0.003531493,
-0.1015120372,
-0.0150704393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17536v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17536v2 | PipeNet: Question Answering with Semantic Pruning over Knowledge Graphs | 2024-01-31T01:37:33 | 2024-05-17T01:06:46 | Ying Su, Jipeng Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is well acknowledged that incorporating explicit knowledge graphs (KGs)
can benefit question answering. Existing approaches typically follow a
grounding-reasoning pipeline in which entity nodes are first grounded for the
query (question and candidate answers), and then a reasoning module reasons
over the matched multi-hop subgraph for answer prediction. Although the
pipeline largely alleviates the issue of extracting essential information from
giant KGs, efficiency is still an open challenge when scaling up hops in
grounding the subgraphs. In this paper, we target at finding semantically
related entity nodes in the subgraph to improve the efficiency of graph
reasoning with KG. We propose a grounding-pruning-reasoning pipeline to prune
noisy nodes, remarkably reducing the computation cost and memory usage while
also obtaining decent subgraph representation. In detail, the pruning module
first scores concept nodes based on the dependency distance between matched
spans and then prunes the nodes according to score ranks. To facilitate the
evaluation of pruned subgraphs, we also propose a graph attention network (GAT)
based module to reason with the subgraph data. Experimental results on
CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.0182127878,
-0.0058053616,
0.0151818804,
0.0331686027,
-0.0269111916,
0.0012720485,
-0.0205448028,
0.0109560732,
0.0537368134,
-0.0021352682,
-0.0105941724,
0.0527388155,
-0.0336152874,
0.0149375396,
0.0065584523,
-0.0202750992,
0.0243319031,
0.0283543337,
0.0245710723,
-0.0144089507,
0.0230643842,
0.0641592741,
-0.0153436968,
0.0096825985,
0.0118123302,
-0.0422036797,
-0.0067224219,
0.0375849791,
0.0138105731,
-0.0131996628,
0.0186977815,
0.0325341485,
0.0072692763,
-0.022752326,
0.0000019626,
-0.0007781996,
0.0193249136,
0.0122909732,
-0.0690539181,
0.0072976318,
-0.0491732992,
0.0149358306,
0.0490268953,
0.0056816959,
-0.0281703565,
-0.0253590662,
0.0246209763,
0.0371266939,
0.0690469369,
0.0408557467,
0.0025763174,
-0.0269227959,
-0.0107410634,
0.0096105793,
0.019815987,
-0.0593505539,
0.0147241987,
0.0252442043,
0.031571079,
-0.0008487549,
-0.0344764479,
0.0067726616,
0.0352130644,
-0.0144960294,
0.055291757,
0.0425440595,
-0.0289962683,
0.0455932319,
0.0418717116,
0.1267795414,
0.0027283651,
-0.0544470176,
0.0148751149,
-0.0241740551,
-0.0176727176,
-0.0063641933,
-0.0469729714,
-0.0517520942,
-0.0207800623,
-0.0186769459,
-0.0199959911,
-0.0108432397,
0.024053622,
-0.0056300382,
-0.0170523077,
0.094588086,
-0.0064269355,
0.0092561226,
0.0356273092,
0.0172558464,
-0.05188784,
-0.0375817195,
0.0108053805,
0.0425675921,
-0.0409002602,
0.0131123532,
0.0018405307,
0.0225516055,
-0.0236241911,
0.0015282119,
-0.0326940417,
0.0420136824,
0.0544619225,
0.0650855675,
-0.024389565,
0.0438032597,
-0.0321173333,
0.0320264548,
-0.0450624973,
-0.0477549545,
-0.0435865931,
-0.0253118034,
-0.0693643987,
0.0446014628,
-0.0392912999,
-0.0220231488,
-0.0185325295,
-0.0002310768,
-0.027608037,
-0.02324076,
0.0477339216,
0.0712576956,
0.0290142,
-0.006344582,
-0.0310362913,
0.0666053817,
-0.0815819725,
0.0058616996,
-0.0132551957,
-0.0129466075,
-0.0412029959,
0.0144793028,
0.0433974713,
-0.0450540967,
-0.0026876843,
0.0426424369,
0.0312070437,
0.0059304014,
-0.0132130347,
-0.0523462929,
0.0121613471,
-0.0226989724,
0.0012729889,
-0.0588300265,
0.0343530439,
0.0002875207,
-0.0329194702,
-0.0294087846,
0.0116353445,
0.0216699075,
-0.0503889285,
0.030758597,
0.0029200239,
-0.0069020963,
-0.0085584568,
0.0170815811,
-0.0147522539,
0.0425194316,
0.0108284112,
-0.0035831977,
0.0245481785,
-0.0126709789,
-0.0684134439,
0.0003025851,
0.0790863931,
-0.0198576506,
0.0517694466,
0.0321364552,
-0.0507204011,
0.0170376394,
0.0258982629,
0.0162074734,
-0.0275474302,
-0.0346150771,
0.0090416064,
0.0390286297,
-0.014122244,
-0.0065344297,
0.0313683748,
0.0329700336,
-0.0096062338,
0.037147902,
-0.0384544991,
0.0495222583,
-0.0015317238,
-0.0024458952,
-0.0208592191,
-0.0355805829,
-0.0420559868,
0.0067538363,
0.0165738184,
0.0304247886,
0.0223433152,
0.0381840989,
0.0163818784,
0.0303876754,
-0.0454787761,
0.0694312453,
0.0327585228,
0.0069320379,
0.0159958694,
0.0033535028,
0.0097740926,
0.0662766472,
0.0567714497,
-0.0001109241,
-0.0310420003,
0.0125040105,
0.0158476401,
-0.0362343006,
0.0065911906,
-0.0334792174,
-0.0031623428,
-0.0437181555,
-0.015701497,
-0.0325653218,
-0.0236283913,
-0.0307069197,
0.061410632,
0.0307048205,
0.0074893534,
-0.0884088278,
-0.006761387,
-0.0026314596,
-0.0034852081,
0.0071527027,
0.0073070126,
0.0036262751,
-0.0208666325,
0.018356951,
0.0148996552,
0.0447393358,
0.0286905393,
-0.0040637264,
-0.022549402,
-0.0088132983,
-0.0366811007,
-0.0674114004,
0.0368102156,
-0.0294433907,
-0.0202714335,
0.0121120205,
-0.0474046879,
-0.0420397371,
0.0255730934,
-0.0512098335,
0.0450905561,
-0.0020436989,
-0.0606239699,
0.0405362658,
-0.0176704656,
-0.0315205567,
0.070248127,
0.0051737451,
0.033102937,
-0.0388549045,
-0.0308452491,
0.0180446189,
-0.0429361574,
0.012474278,
-0.0060872994,
0.0062059918,
-0.0168065596,
0.0290874634,
-0.0120501164,
-0.0834093913,
0.0523086712,
-0.0710145682,
0.0288659446,
-0.0123306932,
0.0467380434,
0.0180483852,
0.0310972966,
0.029399462,
-0.0292861685,
-0.0405091643,
0.0336908773,
0.0206805896,
-0.0067105317,
0.0186373722,
-0.0050489651,
0.0201611109,
0.0078974832,
-0.0511963181,
-0.0151881976,
0.0624885,
-0.0053005987,
0.0178933833,
0.0108271223,
0.0318067111,
-0.0591146722,
0.0095002241,
0.002135915,
0.0264300406,
-0.020629352,
-0.0104295257,
-0.0181162804,
0.0332188495,
-0.0464294963,
0.0101973806,
-0.0017982133,
0.0066858903,
-0.04526392,
0.0303593278,
-0.0348758735,
0.029070681,
-0.0225132238,
-0.0023921777,
-0.0271206237,
0.0241425801,
0.0063620941,
-0.0357755646,
-0.0527144372,
0.0395256318,
0.017442679,
0.009918361,
-0.0367799513,
-0.0113668274,
0.0415402837,
0.0033448259,
-0.0598250441,
0.0246924516,
0.0831868052,
0.0289785769,
-0.0039239144,
-0.0141489375,
0.0096655274,
-0.0410775952,
0.0630394369,
0.0082185268,
0.0081412559,
-0.0316556469,
-0.02902041,
-0.0498052835,
-0.0344142541,
0.0393310264,
0.0031730349,
0.0376329236,
-0.0003884863,
0.0444300324,
0.0010958265,
-0.0055188299,
-0.0253436714,
0.0182301905,
-0.038627699,
0.0456534624,
-0.0038301609,
-0.0062777204,
0.0003432561,
0.0194427595,
-0.0015649389,
-0.0071559823,
0.0139469858,
0.0212210715,
-0.0086255381,
0.0739155784,
0.0383186825,
0.0169136841,
0.0447406992,
0.0168937091,
0.0410099365,
0.0597820915,
0.019669069,
-0.0285393447,
0.0058286022,
-0.0150615834,
-0.0116143944,
-0.0519664921,
-0.001202865,
-0.0480265841,
0.0643847957,
-0.0556421168,
-0.01503105,
0.0778666362,
0.0330901779,
0.0244195461,
0.016115807,
0.0184826627,
0.0484537594,
0.0080825761,
0.0441849232,
-0.0690413788,
-0.0433728099,
-0.0116928248,
0.0279268436,
0.0499504693,
-0.0896808431,
-0.0030017986,
-0.0871448591,
-0.0021038745,
-0.0058197398,
-0.0753298402,
-0.0718455166,
-0.0484342575,
0.0145997042,
0.011863376,
-0.039090354,
-0.0026726956,
0.0139465937,
0.0143191116,
0.0202245079,
0.0105034299,
-0.0037512826,
0.050552059,
-0.0117032388,
0.0139754871,
-0.0122340322,
0.0497245379,
0.0259188339,
-0.009664339,
-0.0129247289,
-0.0713244006,
-0.0139881754,
-0.0267737396,
0.0298003051,
-0.006368502,
-0.0021486119,
-0.0496832691,
0.0155206928,
-0.0717850029,
-0.0166770015,
-0.0130223967,
0.1043290794,
-0.0123915188,
-0.0584001392,
-0.0047385711,
0.0158130657,
-0.0082793506,
0.0564723462,
0.0333352536,
0.0508141853,
-0.062110275,
-0.0206903368,
-0.008755303,
-0.0786289349,
-0.034209732,
0.0211640894,
0.0152230533,
0.0266481973,
-0.0432982892,
-0.0263047423,
0.050363034,
0.0022134273,
-0.046872519,
0.001298958,
0.0353228152,
0.0123895844,
-0.0628910363,
0.0336961672,
-0.035811834,
0.035704881,
0.0108568193,
0.0090019796,
0.0157227311,
0.011255933,
-0.0347305462,
0.0259370022,
-0.0701395497,
-0.0416659005,
-0.0585714951,
0.0014084092,
0.0084387669,
0.0504614152,
-0.0510824583,
-0.001666799,
0.0231949314,
-0.0011851859,
-0.0920587629,
-0.0014828064,
0.0079456959,
-0.0400020815,
-0.0240296498,
0.0604100265,
-0.0446297452,
-0.0136442762,
0.0367199816,
0.0738424435,
-0.0212770887,
-0.0274434127,
0.0021513384,
0.0473247506,
-0.0417268798,
0.0536531396,
0.0193769,
-0.0592771657,
0.0189510342,
0.0207110047,
-0.020007398,
-0.0105031403,
-0.0027328103,
-0.0065854616,
-0.028699819,
-0.0232650079,
-0.0167952571,
0.0192215201,
0.0168832429,
-0.0124374218,
-0.0273835585,
0.0321585909,
-0.0393487327,
0.0520745479,
-0.0095234439,
-0.0302346647,
0.0052211229,
0.0147166932,
0.0524856672,
-0.031031765,
-0.0088271517,
0.0466142707,
-0.0069709634,
-0.020793369,
-0.018679237,
-0.0495607443,
-0.0519141741,
0.0039450624,
0.0394300222,
0.0163264144,
0.0099230129,
-0.0030447615,
0.013189259,
-0.032922212,
-0.0100309709,
0.0222595185,
0.0164757874,
-0.0216951612,
0.0583213679,
0.0384080335,
0.0068430468,
0.0020489385,
0.0342764445,
-0.0068858406,
0.0638641939,
0.0186183024,
-0.0579830781,
-0.0403624661,
-0.0717029348,
-0.0421435386,
0.0719868317,
0.0078406297,
0.0526628233,
-0.0594288148,
-0.0929456353,
-0.0406228304,
-0.0031462521,
-0.0411444083,
-0.0030093677,
0.0622985587,
-0.0004008393,
0.0553370379,
-0.0437836498,
-0.008035819,
0.0292452667,
-0.0850582942,
-0.0221789982,
0.0047161356,
-5.938213955e-33,
-0.0310919434,
-0.0741056651,
0.0281867348,
0.0094030323,
-0.0597488545,
0.0106402952,
-0.0643976331,
-0.0308231413,
-0.0612435415,
0.0299254749,
-0.0140392911,
0.032820344,
-0.0153324613,
0.0020395319,
-0.0519977733,
-0.0397666208,
-0.0042773201,
0.0050910325,
-0.0058541084,
0.0691479072,
0.0400053523,
0.0252205208,
0.0390970781,
-0.0152867138,
0.0165202543,
-0.021317292,
0.0238702856,
0.034286093,
-0.044877328,
0.0410108231,
0.0059591052,
0.0499992929,
0.0209197942,
-0.0218924116,
0.0155546339,
0.0152220195,
-0.1431796402,
-0.0571614876,
0.0237533916,
0.0035861954,
-0.0803064406,
-0.0230951142,
0.023285713,
0.0180939324,
0.0695071518,
-0.0558076985,
0.0351969302,
0.0221917443,
-0.0415057167,
-0.0022599704,
0.0079249544,
0.0223812964,
-0.0465572961,
0.0053726989,
-0.0407983363,
0.006185032,
0.0016961617,
-0.0012296267,
-0.0651431531,
-0.0035506503,
-0.0283022467,
0.0060105282,
0.0106533375,
-0.0200842358,
0.0023183278,
0.0185583439,
-0.0093283178,
-0.038794782,
-0.0384380817,
0.0424917042,
-0.0027811606,
0.0183666572,
0.0382869728,
-0.0294840392,
0.0093630087,
-0.0071676942,
-0.1266763359,
0.0020985217,
-0.0080615133,
0.0816024095,
-0.0168655273,
0.0040318561,
-0.0001893165,
-0.0518044233,
-0.0227988251,
-0.0030495059,
-0.0258915257,
-0.0233069155,
0.0025670603,
-0.020002041,
-0.0366296545,
0.0273015536,
-0.0090284366,
-0.0576077141,
0.0308349822,
0.1001507267,
0.0249268804,
-0.0096535869,
0.0270667877,
0.0520803891,
-0.0698874965,
0.0544492491,
0.0276267715,
-0.0519170538,
0.0213650856,
0.0263423696,
0.0047384757,
-0.0140374815,
-0.0115342932,
0.0035742137,
-0.0669696182,
0.0328850523,
-0.0600868128,
0.0158992745,
0.024098184,
0.0575536005,
0.0099918181,
0.020992171,
0.0377045646,
0.0332277715,
0.0070117773,
0.0644300357,
0.0197512861,
0.019404944,
-0.0190410502,
0.0051974696,
-0.0212245136,
0.0292454939,
-0.0158577487,
-0.049011074,
-0.0231991652,
0.0428738259,
2.616e-7,
0.0612570681,
-0.0231193043,
0.0437839627,
0.0563190505,
0.0169019029,
0.0122282375,
0.037928924,
0.0252587292,
0.0025395001,
-0.0416617095,
0.025577331,
0.0653876439,
-0.021422388,
0.0352485403,
-0.0893071666,
0.0209274013,
-0.0282094479,
-0.0554837137,
-0.0224631913,
-0.0323366523,
0.0333985686,
0.0381738804,
0.0338051021,
-0.0065810913,
0.0024848238,
-0.037448965,
0.0239511617,
0.0437149554,
0.0202073883,
0.0001449549,
0.0327846855,
-0.028309375,
-0.0269639622,
0.0720801428,
0.0032699553,
0.013126323,
0.0330055356,
0.0279566068,
-0.0221789312,
-0.0255065188,
-0.0377487317,
-0.0566313826,
0.0470440537,
-0.0446034856,
0.1023550108,
-0.0100508388,
-0.0296872761,
0.028103292,
-0.0133235762,
-0.0307826735,
-0.0149679165,
0.0144870216,
-0.0095057208,
-0.0095805982,
0.0279084463,
-0.0221954472,
0.0234419834,
-0.0887536779,
0.0072348146,
-0.0005739709,
-0.0062562739,
-0.0493869856,
0.0194962379,
0.0069216695,
0.0228364076,
-0.0358799584,
-0.0041424665,
2.322196207e-34,
-0.016381992,
0.0477128066,
0.0066826893,
-0.0060000434,
0.0331200324,
-0.0334186144,
-0.0154552115,
-0.0290986374,
0.0460033007,
-0.0811989531,
-0.0102316579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17514v2 | How Useful is Continued Pre-Training for Generative Unsupervised Domain Adaptation? | 2024-01-31T00:15:34 | 2024-04-01T20:40:40 | Rheeya Uppaal, Yixuan Li, Junjie Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in scale have enabled the emergence of powerful
generative language models, and the ability to fine-tune these models on
various tasks by casting them into prompts or instructions. In this landscape,
the problem of Unsupervised Domain Adaptation (UDA), or the problem of
leveraging knowledge from a labeled source domain to an unlabeled target
domain, has been left behind, with recent UDA methods still addressing
discriminative classification. In particular, two popular UDA approaches,
involving Continued Pre-Training (CPT) and learning domain invariant
representations, have been under-explored in the generative setting, signaling
a gap. In this work, we evaluate the utility of CPT for generative UDA. We
first perform an empirical evaluation to measure the trade-offs between CPT and
strong methods promoting domain invariance. We further evaluate how well the
benefits of CPT extend to different architectures, tuning methods and data
regimes. We then motivate the use of CPT by studying to what degree it benefits
classification performance on the target domain. Finally, we attempt to
understand the mechanism behind which CPT improves classification performance
on the unlabeled target domain. Our findings suggest that a implicitly learns
the downstream task while predicting masked words informative to that task. Our
work connects the body of UDA research with that of instruction tuning,
enabling an initial step towards a wider applicability of modern language
models. | [
0.0360967778,
0.0586162955,
-0.0269602742,
-0.0217773132,
-0.0033749864,
0.0308600739,
0.0539300777,
-0.0174742024,
-0.0094169956,
-0.0715312958,
-0.078377068,
-0.0313224532,
-0.0531777553,
0.0363416113,
0.0205057282,
-0.0462423675,
0.0515193455,
-0.0261116624,
-0.0403229557,
-0.0144890202,
-0.0328638442,
-0.0271131024,
-0.0173624661,
0.0071655312,
-0.0031812466,
-0.0304212999,
0.0189656224,
-0.0270968713,
-0.0226453841,
0.002430384,
0.0220768452,
0.0709808767,
0.0566027984,
0.0046359189,
0.0000021183,
-0.0695617571,
-0.0164757986,
-0.0325891785,
-0.0103420652,
0.017442666,
0.031351693,
0.0067535271,
-0.0141970357,
-0.009387101,
-0.0517972186,
-0.0860071555,
0.0746187568,
0.0280327015,
0.0154652502,
0.0744433254,
-0.0188690498,
-0.0280818194,
-0.0054700519,
-0.0633743852,
-0.0352254696,
-0.072065264,
0.0221428163,
-0.0331025794,
-0.0309750997,
0.0171129405,
-0.0547913425,
0.020429695,
-0.0087387031,
-0.0029121945,
-0.0008398746,
0.0520022549,
0.0161277838,
0.0083003324,
0.0021647033,
0.0370041616,
-0.0116884373,
-0.0442429669,
-0.0061277389,
-0.004003142,
0.0084862513,
0.0297129825,
-0.011068942,
-0.0213271677,
0.050513953,
0.0018396043,
-0.0034309886,
0.0212487467,
0.0179635808,
-0.0047369245,
-0.0055791023,
0.0212340821,
0.0329231396,
-0.0178617816,
0.0102382228,
0.0418402888,
-0.0526826158,
-0.0554854535,
0.0010022096,
-0.0007077239,
0.0103487493,
0.0188103653,
-0.0683514923,
-0.0348963961,
-0.0353718214,
0.0248427726,
0.0476431325,
0.0198212434,
-0.0571895726,
0.0256081298,
-0.0475989543,
0.0329230316,
-0.0151406527,
0.0554334372,
-0.0442535803,
0.0256294701,
-0.0648383498,
-0.0270309914,
-0.0464321375,
0.0168064702,
-0.0073209913,
0.0123784496,
-0.0253800619,
0.042141363,
-0.0022516483,
-0.0625725165,
0.0015400014,
0.0024932998,
-0.069939889,
-0.0128892493,
-0.019011749,
0.0208025463,
-0.0434844568,
0.0545143336,
0.005643581,
-0.0561147593,
-0.0310926903,
0.0190322176,
0.0271199532,
-0.0369697064,
0.0217152797,
0.0970343426,
-0.0291189682,
-0.0538454466,
-0.0264055356,
0.0404724553,
-0.030814182,
-0.0520412847,
0.0718923062,
0.0020925151,
0.0146543467,
0.0006003975,
0.0020975152,
-0.1083736867,
-0.0370189175,
-0.0308040716,
0.0093277404,
0.0804135799,
0.0203195289,
-0.0017352999,
0.0307441968,
0.0070990515,
-0.0018829041,
0.0464346744,
-0.0097673694,
-0.0009004818,
0.0183281824,
-0.0154278874,
0.0286564659,
0.0339987539,
0.0444226041,
0.0228939299,
0.0247892179,
-0.0007759482,
0.0284021441,
-0.0116129611,
0.0704353973,
-0.0251603834,
-0.0002275093,
-0.0062294318,
0.0430815555,
0.0316205882,
0.0212446768,
0.0447089523,
0.0710693598,
-0.0029622775,
-0.0295925327,
0.0501750112,
-0.0483879112,
0.0082725864,
-0.0126299141,
-0.0160790533,
-0.0064086532,
-0.0018229532,
-0.0616371445,
-0.039996013,
0.0251072329,
-0.0006216574,
0.007211661,
0.0070897816,
0.0578583516,
0.0589579605,
-0.0196705796,
0.0275421999,
0.0503045544,
-0.0388308987,
0.0310711917,
-0.0594327487,
0.0065103155,
0.0090312762,
0.0092778439,
-0.0494709685,
-0.0070052496,
0.0228937026,
0.0519278981,
0.0372002982,
0.0412440896,
-0.0167172179,
0.0202645082,
-0.0295848344,
-0.0393175706,
-0.0260680094,
0.0300498586,
0.0725568831,
0.0108883698,
0.0007260392,
0.0166941993,
-0.0511624478,
0.0195254963,
0.0609193966,
-0.0433866531,
-0.0833901316,
0.0351046845,
0.0264804903,
0.0073089572,
-0.0137693016,
-0.0360185131,
-0.0002177648,
0.001669056,
-0.0274181273,
-0.0115840519,
0.0054356386,
-0.0764344633,
-0.0186166577,
-0.0016094152,
-0.0102365334,
0.0086381482,
0.0177055839,
-0.0075868941,
-0.0360795036,
0.0579906814,
0.0021254488,
0.0339417942,
-0.0490640104,
0.0211592186,
-0.0047139022,
0.0421112627,
-0.0340124033,
0.0549147688,
0.0491565019,
-0.0300060585,
-0.0060736025,
0.0199858677,
0.0045343088,
-0.0170941334,
0.0403602943,
0.0024186196,
0.0059974091,
0.0106355138,
0.0073098061,
0.0091179824,
-0.0218522977,
0.0113060996,
-0.0489974208,
0.0035576276,
-0.047305882,
0.0201210268,
0.0249238703,
0.0276603028,
-0.0293249097,
-0.0163733661,
-0.0293173976,
-0.0216850825,
-0.0163565557,
0.0314764902,
0.0046769199,
0.0065813824,
0.0160396975,
-0.0234047975,
0.0053707329,
0.011259337,
0.0352435522,
-0.0327446796,
-0.0159191918,
-0.053147383,
0.0757086426,
0.0004855648,
0.066904895,
-0.0028423893,
-0.0004801798,
-0.0239099748,
0.0030162546,
0.0878095701,
0.0394281149,
-0.0200586002,
0.0250272937,
0.0618757382,
0.0082635405,
-0.0213162284,
0.0095735099,
-0.0631793514,
-0.0606567152,
-0.0018270174,
0.0471076034,
0.0429710522,
0.0701168999,
-0.002210004,
-0.051006645,
-0.0672039613,
0.0092582935,
-0.0352779962,
-0.0443941765,
-0.0273727756,
0.0033790129,
-0.0095057506,
0.0323161893,
-0.01260598,
-0.0487499051,
0.0608076081,
0.0026515147,
-0.0010552974,
-0.0658981577,
-0.0019012585,
-0.0095808087,
0.0549180135,
0.0318719149,
0.0078457091,
0.0526120774,
-0.0290618632,
-0.0631270334,
0.0415408835,
0.0052900119,
0.0167336557,
0.0317666605,
-0.0543137863,
0.0205330532,
0.0128285363,
-0.0359505862,
-0.0413660929,
-0.0707314089,
0.0224151704,
-0.0053934823,
-0.0124240825,
0.0168945584,
-0.0252572931,
-0.0036967669,
-0.002873258,
0.0746641383,
0.0047389437,
-0.0102084586,
-0.0146392081,
0.0356632359,
0.023624992,
0.0207773279,
-0.0074428376,
-0.0142325228,
-0.0213751998,
0.0203895606,
0.0062011047,
-0.0389848538,
-0.0051593012,
0.0404563174,
0.0427211747,
-0.0300794225,
-0.0237209331,
0.0191905685,
0.0607862025,
0.0117730862,
-0.0554185621,
0.0855765417,
0.0139226168,
-0.0248698965,
0.0158756934,
0.0031331768,
0.0195400957,
0.0293985587,
0.0357907191,
-0.0452358909,
-0.0511017665,
-0.0173288938,
0.0219955985,
0.0148640247,
-0.0136424229,
-0.0023020378,
-0.1131769195,
0.031681031,
0.0095964475,
-0.0129372533,
0.005200169,
-0.0189607441,
0.0111162588,
-0.0058185197,
-0.0199447181,
-0.0384877063,
-0.0144864395,
-0.0041925129,
0.0379268937,
-0.0143521652,
-0.0754720569,
0.0173016116,
-0.037679825,
0.0056142034,
0.1232801899,
-0.017585054,
0.0215796605,
-0.0377239846,
0.0706082433,
-0.0290842503,
0.0171212573,
-0.0061050765,
0.0536557958,
-0.0165589936,
-0.0099859089,
0.0300534628,
0.0306549314,
-0.0429283939,
-0.029912848,
0.0124317789,
0.0214752462,
0.0070961947,
-0.0298559852,
-0.0115751419,
-0.0172288436,
0.0039423932,
0.0493751578,
0.0162946507,
-0.0503912568,
-0.0133363931,
-0.0097458577,
0.0274791885,
-0.0391955525,
-0.0429690145,
-0.0022048801,
-0.0370536409,
-0.0475992113,
-0.0602649823,
-0.0278915931,
0.0152941849,
0.0229327437,
0.0391974039,
-0.0394043364,
-0.0133786155,
0.0134095596,
-0.03372683,
0.0247897543,
-0.0664572194,
-0.0050934115,
-0.054690931,
-0.0675309896,
0.0486798808,
-0.0533175766,
-0.0323747993,
0.0250527505,
-0.0460665897,
-0.0474290773,
0.026233729,
0.0164560433,
0.0139089227,
0.0512860939,
-0.0184926037,
-0.0485978462,
0.0672681257,
0.036058858,
-0.0251067132,
0.0322741978,
0.0338139683,
-0.0349713713,
-0.0016695057,
0.0132303396,
-0.0364702344,
0.0893132165,
0.0760243908,
0.004912925,
0.03684818,
0.0000319795,
0.0203709658,
-0.0415237546,
0.0954523161,
-0.0105734607,
0.01412954,
-0.0593038425,
-0.0022969909,
0.007507449,
-0.0134716043,
-0.0243977327,
-0.0459099375,
0.0526775271,
0.0298679881,
-0.0299079586,
0.058302898,
-0.0232666694,
0.0586919747,
-0.0535179377,
-0.0124292569,
0.0283741243,
0.0370737985,
-0.0310162976,
0.0344756469,
0.0081919329,
0.0261041149,
0.0167203583,
0.0497648232,
-0.0423402637,
0.0335908569,
0.0009579488,
0.0168059152,
-0.0194667429,
0.028426975,
-0.0720922425,
0.0195032265,
-0.06070875,
0.0157314222,
0.0532019399,
-0.0682959557,
0.0472283661,
-0.0064962846,
-0.0091586709,
-0.0331985913,
0.0026511159,
0.0197819322,
-0.0163716022,
0.0165856052,
0.0017213502,
-0.016256256,
-0.0196025316,
0.0807502195,
0.0339878686,
0.0619526505,
-0.008795375,
0.0160998683,
-0.044172287,
-0.0292980652,
0.010498954,
0.0186336227,
0.0139465984,
0.0340882763,
-0.0237874053,
-0.0595494807,
-0.035985589,
-0.0328259207,
0.0196610168,
0.0059334734,
0.0497957766,
0.0451820605,
-0.0375754014,
-0.0318431109,
-0.0289997142,
-0.0029038629,
0.0418203287,
0.0161270387,
-0.016278604,
-6.547494718e-33,
-0.0542568974,
0.0252708085,
0.0120741203,
0.00909031,
0.0073171104,
-0.0358496346,
-0.0416189171,
0.0065199304,
0.0169398803,
0.0083163846,
-0.0119835371,
-0.0148403095,
0.0227140654,
0.0263607409,
-0.0191694349,
-0.0259972792,
0.072115086,
-0.0070142816,
-0.0308278967,
0.0193424653,
0.0102359597,
0.0306707136,
0.0467273928,
-0.0819856748,
-0.0027592403,
-0.0001124895,
-0.0026555762,
-0.0094543369,
0.0461059287,
0.0334946625,
-0.0379457138,
0.0169154853,
0.0210214239,
-0.0534643009,
-0.0295082256,
0.0062646326,
-0.1224544123,
-0.0145086572,
-0.0021867834,
0.0165731981,
-0.0206593331,
-0.055416733,
-0.0093899108,
0.0087345941,
-0.0487906672,
-0.0181709975,
0.0292518567,
-0.0294814445,
-0.0038798735,
-0.0482467413,
-0.0893468559,
0.005293509,
0.0156511217,
-0.0459911451,
0.0183060449,
0.0199510865,
0.0179169979,
-0.0059172278,
-0.0694582015,
0.0419213176,
0.0149881365,
0.0495763458,
0.0689093247,
0.0364934467,
0.0105086779,
0.0309598818,
0.0236319304,
-0.0140123013,
0.0062148217,
-0.0114006717,
0.0277491845,
-0.015042739,
-0.0267028231,
0.0060823229,
0.052116856,
-0.0444453731,
-0.0513572656,
0.019464653,
-0.0569075234,
-0.0356698036,
0.0144971069,
0.0204025004,
-0.0105019333,
-0.0336485952,
-0.034247335,
0.0037265364,
-0.0198636372,
-0.0220261589,
0.0545412898,
0.0205418523,
-0.0204588044,
0.0245171804,
0.0314414166,
-0.0418882743,
-0.0305067804,
-0.0247627478,
-0.024161892,
0.0006394146,
0.0089362264,
0.0082864994,
-0.0301129855,
-0.0372871011,
0.0533714034,
0.01081587,
-0.0079495711,
-0.0142330574,
0.0425196365,
0.0419040248,
-0.0710312128,
-0.0067341705,
-0.0213723313,
0.0126368944,
0.0366150849,
0.0253834873,
0.0033789671,
0.042802494,
-0.0254427772,
0.0620614402,
0.0482291393,
-0.0638226271,
-0.0241969507,
0.0287167579,
0.0093484744,
0.0381313786,
-0.0400909483,
-0.0183200054,
-0.0061637163,
-0.0117589328,
0.0417886041,
-0.0850403979,
-0.0236506648,
-0.0261437129,
2.831e-7,
0.0360286683,
0.0353352316,
0.0035438791,
-0.0207435787,
0.0246218331,
0.0435752943,
-0.012948269,
0.0473640636,
0.0353614837,
0.0146124251,
0.0080401096,
0.0373469554,
0.0146326795,
-0.0096571827,
-0.0289273709,
0.01289743,
0.029915031,
0.0485475212,
-0.0132244993,
0.0155551331,
0.0371394753,
0.1042196527,
0.0048771272,
-0.0077445148,
0.0051186513,
-0.0408909693,
0.1041245982,
-0.0194893312,
0.0201846138,
0.0239528194,
-0.0122001925,
0.0415615328,
-0.0135710714,
0.0244103093,
-0.0348583236,
0.0431477316,
0.0413238816,
0.0577610284,
0.0057236357,
-0.0160620194,
0.0100207571,
0.041418042,
0.017672386,
0.0114251589,
0.0856317878,
-0.1038872674,
-0.026914712,
0.0098095573,
-0.0184928644,
0.0149907796,
-0.0218827482,
0.009930375,
-0.0278100129,
0.0215870738,
0.034390077,
0.0453554876,
-0.032822378,
-0.0864949524,
-0.0112633388,
0.0132616945,
-0.0476253629,
-0.0110476911,
-0.029119378,
0.0034125715,
0.0529628098,
-0.0484410264,
0.0198919494,
2.490057489e-34,
-0.007386358,
0.0207585022,
0.0156922415,
-0.0184281468,
-0.0219013765,
-0.040846739,
0.0437715538,
-0.0061940649,
0.0240963064,
-0.0656697601,
-0.0026372746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17511v1 | Linguistically Communicating Uncertainty in Patient-Facing Risk Prediction Models | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | Adarsa Sivaprasad, Ehud Reiter | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper addresses the unique challenges associated with uncertainty
quantification in AI models when applied to patient-facing contexts within
healthcare. Unlike traditional eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
methods tailored for model developers or domain experts, additional
considerations of communicating in natural language, its presentation and
evaluating understandability are necessary. We identify the challenges in
communication model performance, confidence, reasoning and unknown knowns using
natural language in the context of risk prediction. We propose a design aimed
at addressing these challenges, focusing on the specific application of
in-vitro fertilisation outcome prediction. | [
0.0241588596,
0.0832194313,
-0.0228065271,
-0.0373473875,
-0.003808555,
-0.0048953341,
-0.0067069698,
-0.0321981013,
0.0028770573,
0.0252148882,
0.0408983678,
-0.0365219377,
0.0001624156,
0.0462001041,
-0.0185284913,
-0.0666722432,
0.0181049556,
-0.0028936041,
0.0576351546,
0.0315299071,
-0.0077792117,
0.0082988385,
-0.0288184956,
0.0365874618,
-0.0391021632,
-0.0069405618,
-0.0051984061,
0.0262340494,
0.0181573946,
-0.1091017574,
0.0146941692,
0.0127342204,
0.0050473874,
-0.0387122966,
0.0000019252,
-0.0655433461,
-0.0125995148,
0.0254380144,
-0.0761630908,
-0.054912962,
0.0315555073,
-0.016690461,
-0.0032825058,
0.0115253106,
-0.0065199952,
0.0268369187,
0.0616307408,
0.0533814058,
0.0185732022,
-0.0062256539,
-0.0183203798,
0.0167298894,
0.0187321175,
0.0030351295,
-0.0064916983,
-0.0592995845,
0.0013562109,
0.003847657,
0.0350998007,
0.0163433906,
0.0047157472,
0.0618507899,
0.0147846015,
-0.0202345848,
-0.027429061,
-0.0042977254,
0.0431520529,
-0.0638479143,
-0.0379221141,
-0.0031300338,
0.0053368285,
0.0264763087,
-0.0201111007,
-0.0116428658,
0.0126390047,
-0.005949202,
-0.0566308573,
-0.0035898942,
-0.0305116419,
0.0021526134,
-0.0174357705,
0.063276507,
0.0360818841,
0.0169579256,
0.0365828164,
0.0596883334,
0.0018126243,
0.005081546,
-0.0028104919,
0.0012567249,
-0.0036621739,
-0.0095484434,
0.0101815434,
0.0478563868,
-0.0603295565,
0.0364202261,
0.0222505424,
-0.0108998828,
0.0622583255,
-0.0796688497,
0.0249004923,
0.0145575712,
0.0360798687,
-0.0329566561,
0.0181342792,
-0.0041320794,
0.0102296099,
-0.0132397143,
-0.0246407352,
0.0053380094,
-0.0522437133,
-0.026457414,
-0.0148032745,
-0.0150725078,
0.0001245555,
0.0396560729,
-0.0834808722,
-0.0092166439,
-0.0873283818,
0.0065682228,
0.0267334655,
0.02515704,
-0.0555394553,
0.0001010057,
-0.0447451845,
-0.0300533064,
-0.0368365087,
0.0250487924,
0.0041508107,
-0.0806202739,
0.0117913093,
0.0054029915,
-0.0173171274,
0.025846703,
-0.0520206094,
0.083595477,
0.0155488076,
0.0081509193,
0.0083956197,
-0.0272459462,
-0.0521438345,
-0.0094821192,
-0.0284349844,
0.0074395714,
0.0016360824,
0.0215421859,
0.0054853014,
-0.0909258574,
0.0228270162,
-0.0210199729,
-0.0033744394,
0.0729530677,
-0.0496155992,
0.0022837566,
0.0027176,
0.0375934839,
-0.0180588365,
0.024921637,
0.0392903425,
-0.009300719,
-0.0026948007,
-0.0096360762,
0.0296678338,
-0.0472996235,
0.0138468565,
-0.0396940075,
0.0031412859,
0.0000799016,
-0.0452529714,
0.038002979,
-0.0351161137,
0.0362817533,
0.0569633916,
0.0322098397,
0.0280987043,
0.0331682079,
0.0136333285,
0.0017178978,
0.0516042784,
0.0007881335,
-0.0274706502,
-0.0330244265,
0.0074024778,
0.0084078461,
-0.0050218045,
0.0267569479,
-0.0365462266,
-0.0167085305,
-0.0150311366,
-0.0842312649,
-0.0631412715,
-0.0414204746,
0.0070189401,
-0.003049002,
0.0064148977,
0.0081762103,
0.0103847384,
0.0358903408,
0.0648196265,
-0.0037958156,
-0.0338889919,
-0.0768029243,
0.008185097,
0.0731933042,
-0.0023064828,
-0.0484321155,
-0.0258921441,
-0.0158007313,
-0.0126667842,
-0.0172199905,
0.0311309863,
-0.0143062137,
0.004875198,
-0.0077057509,
-0.0085908063,
0.0352834649,
0.0223826282,
-0.0189426709,
-0.0215645973,
0.00566595,
-0.0097909281,
-0.0227508079,
-0.0566962324,
0.0331789441,
-0.0168073829,
-0.0192759652,
-0.0151870009,
-0.0371001698,
0.0423741974,
-0.0032631131,
0.0169149805,
0.0417639054,
0.028207887,
0.0157920159,
-0.0515057296,
0.0370192826,
0.0074120359,
0.009967641,
-0.0265657362,
-0.0179607812,
-0.0174689554,
-0.0536830649,
-0.0703132749,
0.0017985912,
0.0063981167,
-0.0545234159,
-0.0083926152,
0.0151121113,
0.0140495542,
0.0303784646,
-0.0126550253,
-0.0549309403,
0.0031820228,
-0.0107125491,
-0.0336725861,
-0.0055918102,
-0.0492444038,
0.0145961503,
-0.027792424,
0.0258874167,
-0.0130511094,
-0.0049257171,
0.0100872675,
-0.0008804727,
0.0334929489,
-0.0093013709,
0.0069409297,
-0.0522364937,
-0.035895247,
0.0146741448,
0.0109562883,
-0.0257649738,
-0.009352305,
0.0187137257,
-0.0150797041,
-0.0051372298,
0.0287012737,
0.0030799978,
-0.0035558955,
0.04556318,
0.0461128503,
-0.0091531426,
-0.009999577,
-0.015972862,
-0.0406202897,
0.0473541543,
0.0625289604,
-0.0114046382,
-0.0294964705,
0.0181570593,
-0.0438663214,
-0.0411207415,
0.0160522833,
0.0153058162,
-0.0030383472,
0.015153748,
-0.0304019023,
-0.0092903189,
-0.0098397834,
0.067835778,
0.0199767724,
0.0248864796,
-0.0081368862,
-0.0026178423,
-0.0662136152,
-0.0446438938,
0.0324950628,
-0.032160446,
-0.008481917,
0.0184841342,
0.0165097527,
-0.028084645,
-0.0208066739,
0.0527761355,
-0.0376134776,
-0.0098803667,
-0.0141683128,
-0.0207772199,
0.0250223074,
0.1029019803,
0.01854847,
-0.0524134897,
0.1153297946,
0.032052353,
0.0526783466,
-0.0526737683,
-0.0546046123,
0.0039367466,
-0.0266079623,
-0.0287438054,
0.0186468177,
0.047848843,
0.014279291,
-0.031078605,
-0.0206895601,
-0.024808377,
0.0025590127,
0.0067164521,
-0.0661518723,
0.0066300952,
0.0620238408,
-0.0654792562,
-0.0326412655,
-0.0104193613,
-0.0402093083,
0.0203304477,
0.0268001817,
0.0159981865,
-0.0066813962,
0.0392856672,
-0.0325935297,
-0.0173121858,
0.0029724166,
-0.0473399498,
-0.0099379793,
-0.0516106002,
0.0013256422,
0.0025374927,
0.0548118763,
-0.0103321718,
0.0149130598,
0.0207073819,
-0.0087634381,
0.0200323369,
-0.0274264682,
0.0320903473,
-0.0377164371,
-0.0194619484,
-0.0098094521,
0.0686796457,
0.0374288149,
-0.0457550399,
-0.022944795,
0.0840056688,
0.0178363863,
0.0560472757,
0.0495330021,
-0.0657326728,
-0.0073542548,
-0.0341597348,
0.0359177738,
-0.0251837298,
-0.0002205605,
-0.0132545205,
-0.0002540014,
-0.0318039767,
-0.0190973375,
0.0097088264,
0.0008706254,
0.0382762216,
-0.0023605872,
-0.0164108966,
-0.0359579138,
-0.080400303,
-0.0147327567,
-0.0298804063,
-0.0021354598,
-0.0367495455,
0.0264406949,
-0.0187696405,
0.0144902207,
-0.0875475332,
-0.0974279121,
0.0277901888,
0.0049704085,
0.0474004112,
0.0711122081,
0.0258932617,
-0.0111123174,
0.008122067,
-0.030386759,
0.0066413083,
0.0193988215,
-0.0025409707,
0.0696799085,
0.0524525233,
0.0009547234,
-0.0720864907,
-0.0001501764,
0.0017407322,
-0.026375046,
-0.0191651452,
0.0736518949,
-0.0626347438,
-0.0427438393,
-0.0547249131,
0.0615499727,
0.0758478045,
0.0594241992,
0.0019240715,
-0.0210693665,
-0.0189569332,
-0.0263643358,
0.0563827232,
0.0416866727,
0.0129998345,
0.0142068043,
-0.0110923806,
-0.0413990505,
-0.0308798756,
-0.0209348872,
-0.0125161698,
0.004393965,
0.0472915433,
-0.025669435,
0.0746546984,
0.0033487494,
-0.0430852361,
0.047908254,
0.0675953627,
-0.0040533477,
0.0034563276,
0.0381446145,
0.0414201394,
0.0001596627,
-0.0184050314,
0.0279974286,
0.0207339693,
-0.0111191235,
-0.0128638968,
0.1075232551,
0.0322981961,
-0.0364913866,
-0.0144760953,
-0.0500352308,
0.0487340726,
0.0091649899,
0.0077101365,
-0.054154817,
0.0261781793,
0.0497375689,
-0.0038340599,
0.0329922698,
-0.01928645,
0.0334157348,
-0.0099822143,
0.0094003463,
-0.0427841991,
-0.0220245142,
0.0018594672,
0.0059962166,
0.0258209184,
-0.0253109094,
-0.0413477682,
-0.0053539798,
0.0025887575,
-0.0438949615,
-0.0039677126,
-0.0062304321,
0.0252807867,
0.001052376,
0.0056076492,
-0.0108898152,
-0.0383214727,
-0.0451786332,
-0.0633843616,
0.0331488587,
0.0211203415,
0.0317163579,
0.0206426531,
-0.0080667846,
0.039808739,
0.0178421903,
0.0076102475,
-0.0143032502,
0.0341891721,
0.0335231125,
0.0330518894,
-0.0117098903,
0.0066830073,
-0.0095226634,
0.0256655738,
-0.0155622065,
-0.1020696759,
-0.0264977831,
0.0097232768,
-0.0357742347,
-0.0121307662,
0.0099445004,
-0.0635923818,
0.0049507394,
-0.0394922569,
0.0464549214,
0.0282812808,
0.0273700319,
0.0603136532,
0.0082549453,
-0.0304226372,
-0.08834102,
0.0357012898,
0.0057024644,
0.0359920077,
-0.0773725137,
-0.0696061999,
-0.0282953512,
-0.0221282411,
-0.0046352339,
-0.0049795606,
-0.0145382676,
0.0292995665,
-0.0794319063,
-0.040200945,
0.0484281592,
-0.0116246659,
0.0061550201,
-0.0435928889,
0.0369985066,
0.0145581728,
0.0173964761,
-0.0192062631,
0.0010891057,
-0.0178089961,
-0.0081329579,
0.0064806226,
-0.0433885157,
-5.33624036e-33,
-0.0123423953,
-0.0605404079,
-0.020377636,
-0.0238761846,
0.0517028794,
0.0243527517,
-0.056565091,
0.0314927921,
-0.0025861403,
0.0900481641,
0.0093216468,
0.0069964416,
0.0130944299,
0.0456537232,
0.0186936855,
-0.0471474081,
0.0155818705,
0.0128901768,
0.0273940489,
-0.0027100637,
0.0130657479,
0.0419887714,
0.0027048218,
-0.1124871522,
0.0750666484,
0.0249719415,
-0.002490286,
0.025420595,
0.0036516658,
0.0127876829,
0.0228031836,
0.0347508602,
0.009851505,
-0.0370976441,
-0.0363741964,
0.0200783145,
-0.0078010443,
-0.047201395,
0.0004415366,
-0.0065517593,
-0.0495925583,
-0.0166654438,
0.0265842825,
-0.0051979502,
-0.0631335899,
0.0151950112,
0.0405627973,
-0.0413221344,
0.0361326449,
-0.034051802,
-0.0079375608,
0.0190109983,
-0.0437722541,
-0.0240346771,
0.0141469324,
0.0510600097,
-0.0538072363,
-0.009184354,
0.0053431457,
-0.024903506,
0.0034044543,
-0.0083548371,
0.0694192499,
-0.0414863937,
-0.0186043773,
0.0292012356,
-0.0103672286,
-0.0085576382,
-0.0547540076,
-0.0061675021,
-0.0795395672,
0.0389483385,
0.0583098158,
0.0307357237,
-0.0129075227,
0.0086864941,
-0.1259044409,
0.0405701883,
-0.0769579485,
0.0668490306,
0.0097233243,
-0.0039708181,
-0.0925741866,
-0.0204558838,
-0.03516379,
-0.0401286855,
0.0011854569,
-0.0308719203,
0.0115719019,
-0.0639105216,
0.0003449048,
0.0265722666,
-0.0180884562,
0.0047491551,
0.0042977361,
-0.0430812053,
0.0643649548,
-0.0299627017,
0.0000593705,
0.0370605402,
0.0359437242,
0.0277596153,
-0.001092716,
0.0196006037,
0.0556825772,
0.0231087003,
0.0220972076,
-0.0083905188,
-0.0158985723,
-0.0034711447,
0.0057201907,
-0.0115755321,
0.004806817,
-0.0142179718,
0.0051220688,
0.0347049646,
-0.0086027579,
0.0804014131,
0.0344055332,
0.028707644,
0.0225251745,
0.0019316542,
-0.0117989033,
-0.0083034681,
-0.0351658762,
-0.0360775031,
-0.020683825,
-0.0141878463,
0.0066350508,
-0.0613475554,
0.0011587291,
-0.0052295025,
2.729e-7,
0.1054903641,
0.0633919686,
0.0084955292,
0.0345440879,
0.034994863,
0.009965946,
0.0046696826,
-0.0234039109,
-0.0131410565,
-0.020845687,
0.0539209992,
0.0172009375,
0.0336686261,
0.0005101532,
0.0122416634,
-0.0609040707,
-0.0429776274,
0.0049608308,
0.0019241162,
0.0133433174,
0.0797724575,
0.0674655065,
-0.0101991659,
0.0015076054,
0.0063847443,
0.0390287116,
0.0133975362,
-0.0496792085,
0.0359315574,
0.0701169074,
0.048864536,
0.0123388944,
0.0178842898,
0.0505350791,
-0.0204559341,
-0.0804069787,
0.0029090804,
0.0817186683,
-0.0420184843,
-0.0018140894,
0.0305547398,
0.01052712,
0.0740287453,
-0.0321616568,
0.0066493754,
-0.0439719371,
-0.0953670666,
0.0026177817,
0.0426527001,
-0.0145283118,
0.0864431262,
-0.0024881628,
-0.0153320227,
0.0076035587,
-0.0075561879,
0.0365330577,
-0.0063283737,
-0.0163374916,
-0.0247760974,
0.0559917279,
-0.0063431594,
-0.0311633013,
0.0296518076,
-0.0168983787,
0.036614053,
-0.0710698739,
0.01831639,
2.157861638e-34,
0.0466847606,
0.0216666702,
-0.0186831597,
0.0061532678,
0.0621447936,
0.034780506,
0.012150052,
0.0041623618,
0.0749181211,
0.0118214786,
-0.0087865302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17505v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17505v3 | Arrows of Time for Large Language Models | 2024-01-30T23:46:35 | 2024-06-03T17:35:04 | Vassilis Papadopoulos, Jérémie Wenger, Clément Hongler | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We study the probabilistic modeling performed by Autoregressive Large
Language Models (LLMs) through the angle of time directionality, addressing a
question first raised in (Shannon, 1951). For large enough models, we
empirically find a time asymmetry in their ability to learn natural language: a
difference in the average log-perplexity when trying to predict the next token
versus when trying to predict the previous one. This difference is at the same
time subtle and very consistent across various modalities (language, model
size, training time, ...). Theoretically, this is surprising: from an
information-theoretic point of view, there should be no such difference. We
provide a theoretical framework to explain how such an asymmetry can appear
from sparsity and computational complexity considerations, and outline a number
of perspectives opened by our results. | [
0.0082445173,
0.0592503175,
-0.0125475014,
0.0237362161,
-0.083600007,
0.033340849,
-0.0285944268,
-0.004891871,
-0.0524050929,
-0.0243517701,
-0.0001308632,
-0.0794593692,
0.0352503583,
-0.0012176086,
0.0065077562,
-0.0178683512,
0.0370724052,
-0.0899301544,
-0.0135692572,
-0.0492841117,
-0.0354227796,
-0.0552998111,
-0.0166134965,
0.0420429632,
0.0387688503,
0.0115466444,
-0.0123648103,
-0.0253536273,
-0.0404927544,
-0.0301690921,
-0.0560202301,
0.0253480952,
-0.0219990369,
0.0703194886,
0.0000015345,
-0.0408019386,
0.0325397067,
0.0131980479,
-0.0506213754,
0.0486459807,
0.0012757124,
-0.0038865879,
-0.0093276259,
0.0308653675,
-0.0124963699,
-0.0303860493,
0.0572856106,
0.0259239636,
-0.0388678834,
0.0478086136,
0.0125149153,
-0.0269676242,
0.0385204889,
-0.0634211153,
0.0496219844,
-0.042218253,
-0.0007412501,
-0.0307667162,
-0.0198699236,
0.0010278716,
-0.0718147978,
0.0448861569,
0.0064108437,
0.0383603387,
0.0063485974,
0.0599256307,
0.0434456095,
-0.0052015786,
-0.0196949393,
0.0176362619,
-0.0268003643,
-0.0059939991,
-0.0168134738,
-0.0068544191,
-0.0150754945,
0.0264988635,
-0.0407517925,
0.0140070887,
0.0222923774,
0.0298893936,
0.0727292597,
0.0225171745,
0.0637479946,
-0.0114338826,
-0.0370656177,
0.0623316541,
0.0269932672,
-0.0267504547,
-0.0191083401,
0.0043040286,
0.0167944338,
-0.0422928445,
-0.0655870885,
0.0359939523,
0.0272996984,
0.0103381258,
0.0052296077,
0.0406489111,
0.0001609392,
-0.0067935339,
0.0553883612,
0.0059209303,
0.0314981341,
0.042751424,
-0.0156723112,
0.0397753529,
-0.0069792061,
-0.0080521004,
-0.0174611043,
0.0026551897,
-0.0280614179,
-0.0186841786,
0.0076754047,
0.0080771446,
0.0298229735,
-0.0127852652,
-0.0442940034,
0.0032113735,
0.0228288285,
-0.0143363401,
0.0107047362,
-0.0209983811,
-0.0353402384,
-0.0185441747,
-0.0598522238,
0.027228022,
-0.0039482024,
0.027638603,
-0.0304623432,
-0.0191818811,
-0.0272973739,
0.0203120224,
-0.0048700264,
-0.0151050715,
-0.0023956443,
0.0459483005,
-0.0102332365,
-0.0197856221,
-0.0318723544,
0.0076638814,
-0.022302201,
-0.0439292751,
0.0150090056,
-0.0380205326,
-0.0051544923,
0.0567563251,
-0.0186163448,
-0.0153860589,
0.0122547923,
-0.0259575322,
-0.0325885676,
0.0683907196,
0.0418735631,
0.0345454514,
0.0090970416,
-0.0257231295,
0.023999624,
0.0695326626,
0.0245316382,
-0.0182244591,
0.0141148176,
-0.0300355647,
-0.0052444292,
0.0422319993,
0.0100153061,
0.0210422743,
-0.0294244029,
-0.0200728998,
0.0430834778,
0.0453101881,
0.0495701171,
0.0690997466,
-0.0096144518,
-0.0318663679,
0.0416999422,
0.0535861216,
0.04860311,
0.0001554146,
0.0371594578,
-0.0188534334,
0.0071175667,
0.0513796844,
-0.0307262316,
0.0174578279,
-0.0050118044,
0.0257807411,
0.0317917615,
0.0077415411,
-0.0360133424,
-0.028624462,
0.0021766655,
-0.0213111639,
0.0086006392,
-0.0048569669,
0.0614998192,
-0.0250327736,
-0.0430120379,
0.030351596,
0.0202873927,
0.0180383977,
0.0028893154,
-0.0637239441,
-0.0069158208,
0.0120096635,
0.0139999455,
0.0103532523,
0.0282813478,
0.0000130831,
-0.0082152048,
0.0070497743,
0.0267388728,
0.0093057752,
0.0220729057,
-0.0040700673,
-0.0056002075,
0.0323061571,
0.0152987698,
0.0203370284,
-0.00540207,
0.0422988161,
0.0115979407,
-0.0190814938,
-0.0234257579,
0.0273165256,
-0.0614500158,
-0.0461692475,
-0.0002373263,
0.0094313743,
0.0583759509,
-0.0183320716,
-0.0392695367,
0.0451081358,
0.0265690479,
-0.0761188492,
-0.004576283,
0.0389250778,
-0.0591415949,
-0.0167978853,
0.0506376885,
-0.0021484853,
0.0203729309,
0.0162524581,
0.0201638509,
-0.0629249066,
0.0604167581,
-0.0264154654,
0.1272565275,
-0.0105767576,
0.0326317772,
-0.0093806265,
0.0321648568,
-0.0295413937,
0.0440838076,
-0.0314728729,
0.0485895984,
-0.0201021414,
-0.0032091409,
-0.002193809,
-0.009230311,
-0.0013820848,
0.037084531,
0.0129889194,
-0.0256384332,
0.0033212849,
-0.0504583903,
0.0180743262,
-0.0492801405,
-0.0471478179,
-0.0401826575,
-0.0249305982,
0.0296403281,
-0.0379014947,
-0.0178103,
0.014131791,
-0.0040947981,
-0.0285709221,
0.0183970574,
0.0107262218,
0.0351422802,
0.029437365,
0.0211280994,
-0.0678465515,
-0.0343491286,
-0.0469151139,
-0.0037609017,
0.0542736389,
0.0141128888,
-0.011947399,
-0.04188646,
0.0461551435,
0.0025887915,
0.0226128548,
-0.0407834128,
-0.033564724,
-0.0044022151,
-0.0291114338,
0.0609320924,
0.0573768057,
0.0325718485,
0.0427016877,
0.0364898518,
-0.0066843643,
0.000223432,
-0.0199660696,
-0.0400955305,
-0.0247995164,
-0.059793748,
-0.0571253784,
-0.0054057492,
0.0820612535,
-0.0088612679,
-0.0128665231,
-0.0250601731,
-0.0036281135,
-0.0294809695,
-0.0269581117,
0.0015331812,
0.0194889549,
-0.0181476977,
0.0281301998,
-0.0214231685,
-0.0762178451,
0.0296399035,
-0.0384707935,
0.0153130526,
0.0126223722,
-0.0276426189,
-0.0455166362,
0.1141999587,
0.0307152774,
0.0150342723,
-0.0095447386,
-0.041015815,
-0.040629115,
-0.011854968,
0.0563648567,
-0.0142355692,
0.0426869579,
-0.0244985651,
0.0247367676,
-0.0065130992,
-0.0370747522,
0.0045269486,
-0.0759514719,
-0.042632401,
-0.008266543,
0.0207593199,
-0.0589345358,
-0.0088524884,
0.030724695,
0.0115246512,
-0.0060425294,
-0.0223334674,
0.0010420131,
0.0120723136,
0.0070027146,
0.0520295426,
-0.0182172749,
0.0146461157,
-0.0530386642,
0.0572178476,
-0.0097601553,
0.0662903935,
0.0535376705,
-0.0213482473,
-0.0079523101,
0.0196231399,
-0.0225564782,
-0.072639212,
0.0447883606,
0.0118238628,
-0.0164447539,
-0.0000324043,
0.0937611461,
-0.0038306508,
-0.0589444824,
0.0265739635,
0.0031265037,
0.0281391628,
0.0211775918,
-0.0203296635,
-0.0219128188,
-0.0276042689,
0.0115628652,
0.0055100084,
-0.0132339336,
-0.0390551388,
0.0005821378,
-0.1119553968,
-0.0251136757,
0.0109113576,
-0.0228719059,
-0.0580393411,
-0.0293598436,
-0.0303324163,
-0.0127046471,
0.0259494428,
0.0176125783,
-0.0555478632,
0.0124192294,
0.0347639956,
-0.0617427528,
-0.0219183713,
0.0226288866,
-0.0160160847,
0.0878049582,
0.0264798645,
-0.0022776958,
-0.0404063426,
-0.0278394017,
0.0215664506,
-0.0093959263,
0.0156622231,
0.002187615,
0.0042174063,
0.0319544561,
-0.0162990596,
-0.0042621056,
0.0068881712,
0.0063743046,
0.0403813496,
-0.0136394538,
0.0589191541,
-0.029022269,
-0.0509461239,
0.0088610807,
-0.0234146137,
-0.0000698423,
0.1061389223,
0.0069431132,
-0.0313256644,
-0.0655770153,
-0.0109186666,
0.025862053,
0.0265951995,
-0.0306472164,
0.0131043568,
0.0273029562,
-0.0523882248,
-0.0313717723,
0.0067640846,
-0.0188158881,
0.0672539696,
0.0048807375,
0.06957452,
-0.0010701169,
0.0072651473,
-0.0173699297,
-0.0382395908,
-0.0043552513,
0.01242238,
-0.0976893976,
0.0008851503,
0.0374341197,
-0.0137839783,
-0.0292622019,
-0.0183748379,
-0.1044263989,
-0.0770965591,
0.0403762572,
-0.0257821009,
0.0305579621,
0.0411810614,
0.0378959365,
-0.0543916374,
0.0211263914,
0.0346586592,
0.0233554784,
0.0531069264,
0.0130347814,
0.0372649953,
0.0101640187,
0.0647894517,
-0.0282413326,
-0.0178938471,
-0.0112443771,
0.0081999516,
-0.0475667678,
-0.0262182616,
-0.0147675592,
0.0198860783,
0.0633121133,
0.0041057453,
-0.014840317,
0.0200077016,
0.0093821445,
0.0077797505,
0.0149129247,
-0.0170831438,
-0.0126983728,
0.0670946762,
0.0120104458,
-0.0056340857,
0.0091127735,
0.0258703511,
0.013583743,
-0.0273080692,
0.0005518817,
-0.0313753113,
-0.0060500875,
0.0447230898,
0.0121457409,
-0.009521042,
0.0339501314,
0.0007230042,
0.0197421126,
0.0307671372,
0.0048133167,
0.0058528897,
0.048393134,
-0.0519248284,
-0.0567661561,
-0.1148468405,
-0.0724676028,
0.0401851796,
-0.0010447457,
0.0618840307,
-0.015924463,
0.0412063561,
-0.0559974127,
0.0137540214,
-0.0125232199,
0.0104587004,
-0.0023096185,
-0.009410033,
0.0588014722,
-0.002661411,
-0.0191937927,
0.0361137949,
0.1050074026,
0.0772498921,
0.0668428466,
0.0249250084,
-0.0113405064,
-0.0058827866,
-0.0413369872,
0.0172246546,
-0.0155801009,
-0.0095446855,
0.0163290724,
-0.0484071709,
-0.0705487877,
-0.0049802195,
-0.0205299035,
0.0151718073,
-0.0439372323,
0.0111569008,
0.0699353665,
0.0102040432,
-0.0302628651,
-0.0429260843,
0.0388262831,
0.0133367237,
-0.0090577817,
-0.0223347191,
-6.090578594e-33,
0.0068744509,
-0.0026555916,
-0.0100663854,
-0.0058288942,
0.0213793293,
0.0021057553,
0.0101946695,
0.0353323817,
-0.0419956855,
0.0033192872,
-0.0135162836,
0.0276273806,
0.0120077152,
0.0225956663,
0.0306269042,
-0.0246312302,
0.0413524024,
-0.0312513225,
0.0212924164,
0.0204866603,
0.0114063649,
0.0139043694,
0.0341210179,
-0.0190334823,
-0.0103524784,
-0.0119601944,
-0.0058450392,
0.0321472809,
0.0150965014,
0.0478033274,
-0.0261174552,
0.0283981096,
0.0173928104,
-0.0277798176,
-0.0168527495,
-0.0426702574,
-0.0142585058,
-0.0265599322,
0.0178050194,
0.0021231675,
-0.0009818305,
-0.0243705884,
0.0314295962,
0.0041980674,
-0.08031068,
-0.0137910638,
0.0036483605,
0.009386328,
-0.075235717,
-0.0108825238,
-0.0101955933,
0.0372635424,
-0.004418313,
-0.0162791032,
0.0184980333,
-0.0165711343,
-0.0025835908,
-0.0183851887,
-0.0171131101,
0.0156557336,
0.0230554454,
0.0875361934,
0.0128192138,
0.0524249896,
0.0292405561,
0.0500496663,
0.0887912437,
0.0146986507,
-0.031178318,
0.0074113477,
0.0284868293,
0.0053195409,
-0.0062021236,
-0.0420450605,
0.09779834,
0.0074147298,
-0.0737991408,
-0.039929688,
0.0544605963,
0.0507324599,
0.0276794396,
0.0142128048,
-0.0838045627,
-0.0462838747,
-0.0510766506,
-0.0400480665,
-0.0067952308,
0.0112895463,
-0.0001099029,
0.0306153838,
0.0461526588,
-0.0416609533,
0.0456974171,
-0.0198723748,
-0.0748062432,
0.0107957125,
-0.0076556345,
0.0179611593,
-0.00489798,
0.0386990197,
-0.0658267885,
-0.0226321146,
-0.0539159477,
0.03586559,
0.0018421992,
-0.0056305169,
-0.0021195903,
0.0301635507,
-0.097833626,
-0.0478689931,
-0.0244632401,
-0.0074859853,
0.0347416922,
-0.0417116024,
0.0793932453,
-0.0553804524,
0.004376852,
0.0365646891,
-0.0026387067,
0.0045173559,
0.0053448575,
-0.0142793385,
-0.000063289,
0.0164895207,
-0.0191492271,
-0.0251170937,
-0.0466273502,
0.0059517561,
0.0641327649,
-0.0488179699,
-0.0286614224,
0.0183944162,
2.381e-7,
0.0143631101,
0.0283143651,
0.02278612,
0.0674888492,
0.0519282855,
0.0210130233,
-0.0109786205,
-0.0006421626,
-0.0290619135,
0.0288534332,
0.0011777276,
0.0259512868,
0.0421557464,
-0.0172426403,
-0.0230833106,
-0.0142585253,
-0.0927538052,
0.0478302911,
-0.0450627655,
-0.0023835672,
0.0021047296,
0.0891776234,
-0.018342115,
0.0006173243,
-0.0105147734,
-0.0682908446,
0.0679661557,
-0.0476797782,
0.023719145,
0.0057780454,
0.031803593,
0.0022260598,
-0.0075636753,
-0.0005584955,
-0.0054811635,
0.016653046,
-0.0416795388,
0.0029268505,
-0.019929165,
-0.0248645544,
-0.0066490453,
-0.0175681133,
-0.017697081,
-0.0135169616,
0.0960310623,
-0.0261806995,
-0.0678375363,
-0.0611477122,
0.0317045525,
0.0260147117,
0.0277859662,
0.0218888428,
-0.0287202932,
0.0002702467,
0.0138646252,
-0.0379343107,
0.0119336667,
-0.0727802143,
-0.0182077326,
0.0136826001,
-0.0376638472,
-0.0521708615,
-0.0602900386,
0.0382708982,
0.0741775781,
-0.01855205,
-0.0126812868,
2.307933007e-34,
0.0793823227,
-0.0344761461,
0.0157971419,
0.0231473818,
0.03178408,
-0.0297393762,
0.0237785112,
0.0017674514,
0.0281351618,
-0.1094255,
-0.0246234443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01763v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01763v2 | When Large Language Models Meet Vector Databases: A Survey | 2024-01-30T23:35:28 | 2024-02-06T01:25:18 | Zhi Jing, Yongye Su, Yikun Han, Bo Yuan, Haiyun Xu, Chunjiang Liu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This survey explores the synergistic potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) and Vector Databases (VecDBs), a burgeoning but rapidly evolving
research area. With the proliferation of LLMs comes a host of challenges,
including hallucinations, outdated knowledge, prohibitive commercial
application costs, and memory issues. VecDBs emerge as a compelling solution to
these issues by offering an efficient means to store, retrieve, and manage the
high-dimensional vector representations intrinsic to LLM operations. Through
this nuanced review, we delineate the foundational principles of LLMs and
VecDBs and critically analyze their integration's impact on enhancing LLM
functionalities. This discourse extends into a discussion on the speculative
future developments in this domain, aiming to catalyze further research into
optimizing the confluence of LLMs and VecDBs for advanced data handling and
knowledge extraction capabilities. | [
0.0099892244,
0.0760010555,
-0.0498030819,
0.0569494627,
-0.0202010814,
0.021645762,
0.0162205677,
0.0247803312,
-0.0280646607,
-0.0427889377,
-0.0055546127,
-0.0827065632,
-0.0292732101,
-0.0222448241,
-0.0097072953,
-0.0196634959,
0.0438875332,
-0.0533295609,
-0.0088718859,
0.003755752,
-0.0062800809,
0.016340334,
0.0264894851,
-0.0021315517,
-0.0019906177,
0.00139017,
0.0103839571,
-0.0398423523,
-0.0223391131,
0.0217452236,
-0.0234776977,
0.0245985147,
0.056975238,
0.0644811392,
0.0000020866,
-0.0155122429,
-0.0517219156,
0.0217812695,
-0.024499543,
0.0343585424,
0.0262594707,
-0.0414726548,
-0.0229138769,
-0.0311115161,
0.0042710397,
-0.0485067926,
0.0171776637,
-0.0317217819,
0.0297239181,
0.0193176437,
-0.0168786477,
-0.0545389727,
0.0215872899,
-0.0024634476,
-0.0250878576,
-0.0289002452,
0.0589853078,
0.042531468,
0.0296150204,
0.0223767404,
-0.0211860538,
0.0568452552,
-0.037555635,
-0.0119448788,
-0.0077599897,
0.0283659715,
0.0341381095,
0.0514992885,
-0.0008821572,
0.0177812986,
-0.0010953698,
-0.0042314846,
0.0613107644,
0.0227847956,
-0.0459723957,
0.0052176802,
-0.0457610004,
0.0573018156,
-0.013962361,
0.0104031954,
0.0200948492,
-0.0603163317,
0.0202815011,
0.0118970433,
-0.0595041774,
-0.0024703424,
0.0442384556,
-0.0374637246,
-0.0332500413,
-0.0472095534,
-0.0009975031,
-0.0442734547,
0.0185246132,
0.0075952918,
0.0182508565,
0.0495165065,
-0.0054888208,
-0.0649378523,
0.0392772704,
-0.1240862608,
0.0959039852,
0.0155509925,
-0.0120146098,
0.0630415753,
0.012132463,
0.0524271652,
-0.062515229,
0.0192859061,
-0.0274459105,
-0.0221921839,
-0.0486864783,
-0.0136381779,
-0.0126607222,
0.0508770719,
-0.0118831499,
-0.0000524778,
-0.0280655716,
0.0448075533,
0.032224521,
0.0191999637,
-0.0394381434,
-0.0225254446,
0.0453842208,
-0.0131438794,
-0.023951618,
0.0352364331,
0.0034889944,
-0.0289359391,
-0.0425767861,
-0.0283701885,
-0.0098766107,
0.0035292152,
0.0160621926,
-0.0659994185,
0.0404385403,
-0.0043934016,
0.0324934199,
-0.032443881,
-0.0021039404,
-0.0023788039,
-0.04596233,
-0.0702399164,
0.0143549433,
-0.0714475065,
0.0701455623,
0.0474566109,
-0.0398803465,
-0.0311826319,
-0.016916804,
0.0123300422,
-0.0743402764,
0.0221401937,
0.0002747174,
0.0236194618,
0.0220739339,
-0.0057061734,
0.0688594803,
0.0111128259,
-0.0219728872,
-0.0039879982,
0.0058239987,
-0.0350729786,
-0.0120326439,
0.0258685797,
0.025124507,
-0.0018439287,
-0.0704962909,
0.0612033457,
0.0573774762,
0.0071834647,
0.0142812068,
0.0657333285,
-0.0275538135,
-0.047980193,
0.05613501,
0.0425439365,
0.0029363586,
0.0349548385,
0.0366350003,
0.0011500076,
0.0186601374,
-0.0372985117,
0.0024553942,
-0.012933448,
-0.0377656631,
-0.0100428611,
0.0093463324,
0.0376236103,
-0.0085650347,
-0.0069797793,
-0.0464202985,
-0.0228214748,
-0.0011366844,
0.0188086107,
0.1001903489,
-0.04835492,
0.0292695947,
0.0640803799,
0.0201753564,
-0.0455846526,
-0.0098268725,
-0.0209208205,
0.0454439148,
0.0328646749,
0.0345020406,
-0.0391743444,
-0.0214433558,
0.0165169444,
0.0143788178,
-0.0128532946,
0.0430719592,
-0.0036390165,
-0.0136956386,
-0.0295911096,
0.0259844195,
0.0279439483,
0.0158243254,
0.0229030121,
-0.00402606,
0.012349193,
-0.0043230355,
-0.0277254991,
-0.0461200997,
-0.0114788534,
-0.0193721838,
0.0051437686,
-0.0218202565,
-0.0176169034,
0.0305365734,
0.033917997,
-0.0358040147,
0.0070644929,
0.0567388162,
-0.0704061836,
-0.0367962904,
-0.0084322197,
0.0091189789,
0.0612069592,
0.0455515832,
0.0543108582,
0.0236555096,
-0.0513050556,
0.013735855,
0.0090108253,
0.0190824885,
-0.0285565015,
0.0271800756,
-0.0552107356,
0.0433575958,
-0.0106425015,
0.0107618235,
-0.0248284955,
0.0830103084,
-0.0157330334,
0.029384708,
0.0432250351,
-0.0206876565,
0.0198434535,
-0.0218847487,
-0.0191229749,
0.0643552542,
0.0238017719,
0.0334048755,
0.0092440937,
-0.0750580952,
-0.0005079327,
-0.0077940687,
-0.0470229648,
0.0377411433,
-0.0034141587,
0.0327826589,
-0.0329528637,
0.0154410042,
-0.0005250944,
0.0480554774,
-0.0315579884,
-0.0079031028,
0.0153736407,
0.0334337391,
0.0004469994,
0.0164400171,
-0.0384222083,
-0.0068764426,
-0.0409056842,
-0.0176035576,
0.051667437,
-0.0348849669,
-0.0072650537,
-0.037226662,
-0.0004918823,
-0.0617412962,
0.0316546969,
-0.037766166,
0.0196794644,
-0.0329915546,
-0.1141324937,
0.0239960179,
-0.0111089544,
-0.0097101079,
0.0105755348,
0.0577605031,
-0.0531187057,
-0.0323821567,
-0.0071713417,
-0.0495403148,
-0.0108397864,
-0.0434914939,
0.0245843977,
-0.0095621282,
0.0248954147,
-0.008335338,
0.0067202146,
-0.0302035473,
0.0151122026,
-0.0089751454,
0.0198298823,
-0.0398173258,
-0.0047272369,
-0.020958541,
0.0414686501,
0.0087489299,
-0.0283144005,
0.0297245421,
-0.030747449,
0.0024064928,
-0.0209070724,
-0.0376295671,
-0.0584803559,
0.0416430831,
-0.0045447596,
0.0287293028,
-0.0490634143,
0.0075153527,
0.0228909645,
0.0227039754,
-0.03791067,
-0.0556235798,
0.0614441074,
-0.0214143358,
0.0383378938,
-0.0083578257,
-0.025665231,
-0.0377117731,
-0.0156457387,
-0.0159194302,
0.0069401888,
0.0641275495,
-0.0319431052,
0.0192455761,
0.0538934097,
0.0135633461,
-0.0009855157,
0.0176841617,
0.0074245567,
-0.0186194442,
0.0397587456,
0.0193599183,
0.0069731623,
0.0043076132,
0.0142477341,
-0.0266308524,
0.0546382107,
0.0238001738,
-0.0299607106,
0.0143886982,
-0.0094782701,
0.0653972477,
-0.0230345614,
-0.015737066,
0.0013521218,
-0.0504449047,
-0.0571325272,
-0.0237691328,
0.0878075585,
0.0468596704,
-0.0395702831,
-0.0046807746,
0.012132233,
-0.0242653806,
-0.0102175605,
0.0449307486,
-0.0991553888,
0.0331288241,
-0.0156208938,
0.0058907727,
0.017784562,
-0.02185807,
-0.0070885466,
-0.1075270995,
0.0396616012,
0.0174922366,
0.0124373883,
-0.0362313278,
-0.0477474704,
-0.0009445774,
0.0105415089,
0.0239499155,
0.0171929505,
-0.0257389825,
-0.0261820797,
0.024676986,
-0.0491967723,
-0.0525592901,
0.0357809328,
-0.0421128049,
0.0332192555,
0.0365608297,
0.0591187477,
-0.0159522258,
-0.0704924241,
-0.0690653846,
-0.0581141375,
-0.0164598189,
-0.0492308736,
0.0112906788,
0.0005757751,
-0.020517692,
-0.0032637499,
-0.004685035,
0.0123851169,
-0.0086927991,
-0.0127427652,
0.0780947879,
-0.0317786187,
-0.019476315,
-0.0025703246,
-0.0328625366,
-0.0382235199,
0.086794056,
-0.0032057655,
-0.0257038195,
-0.0138902748,
0.0009296967,
-0.0259617474,
0.007527424,
-0.0631062463,
0.0028753618,
-0.0096801724,
-0.0165564865,
-0.0261811204,
0.0081395227,
0.0408986695,
-0.0001155533,
-0.0088544618,
0.0337649025,
0.0187615976,
-0.0382577963,
-0.0726123229,
-0.0105797881,
-0.0500599667,
0.028048519,
-0.0213281624,
0.0065992665,
0.0243162327,
-0.0193954986,
-0.0342107862,
0.0183702074,
-0.0534750074,
-0.0829753056,
0.0488101169,
0.0352398343,
0.0100305276,
0.0464626551,
0.0296886731,
-0.0485763997,
0.031905584,
0.0139966635,
-0.0016178373,
0.0056757084,
-0.0126085049,
0.0024510168,
-0.0049481476,
0.0246578548,
-0.0360901579,
0.0071555367,
0.0269398186,
0.0045547755,
-0.0336528942,
-0.025667211,
0.0128512448,
0.0472794361,
0.0263200793,
0.0270736143,
-0.0260532778,
-0.0234983917,
0.0156898871,
-0.0770693123,
-0.0087580737,
-0.0200021453,
-0.0353771932,
-0.0093296533,
0.0109986383,
-0.0433854051,
0.0228256341,
0.0198736787,
0.0027140416,
-0.036871966,
0.0235489402,
-0.0036504788,
-0.0012692248,
0.0651959628,
-0.0200843271,
0.0129924975,
0.0207051914,
-0.0024296995,
0.0547395982,
-0.0635098517,
0.041315157,
0.0188912749,
-0.0301788673,
-0.0183094963,
0.0238048527,
-0.0261874255,
-0.0662958175,
0.0397608206,
0.0252382327,
0.0766581967,
-0.0298176855,
0.0575308688,
-0.0617348179,
-0.0280910693,
-0.0154394563,
-0.0173269454,
0.0452200249,
-0.0017020757,
0.0199474972,
0.0402395055,
-0.0488845445,
-0.0106551144,
0.0250182487,
-0.0041333432,
0.049151212,
-0.0140999043,
-0.026116766,
-0.007495041,
-0.02297212,
0.0184682105,
0.0074022152,
-0.0430972986,
-0.0260352846,
-0.1170633584,
-0.0356309079,
0.0483731553,
-0.000706654,
-0.0444419459,
-0.0519111045,
-0.0025730575,
0.0508719236,
0.0368079357,
0.0142185865,
-0.037868198,
0.0276632831,
-0.0907583833,
-0.0284202527,
0.0389943048,
-6.262657743e-33,
0.0098119676,
0.0161774214,
0.0142055517,
-0.0092678349,
-0.0205429066,
0.0072798408,
-0.0106718196,
-0.0075800004,
0.0205311198,
-0.0362915322,
-0.015383224,
0.0022790467,
0.0061113206,
-0.0008315283,
0.0181809533,
0.0098509267,
0.0519073717,
0.0064450605,
0.0389308855,
0.0380102023,
0.0758757219,
0.0356829166,
0.0431364179,
-0.1085794717,
0.0411176309,
-0.0314342789,
0.0485513471,
0.0393250398,
0.0277091209,
0.0621668063,
-0.0477469228,
0.0395529084,
0.0012986825,
-0.0499814302,
-0.0009296914,
-0.0213694386,
-0.0597300977,
0.0627509356,
0.0383275449,
-0.0015265131,
0.038441807,
-0.030212611,
-0.0021003382,
0.0153612932,
0.0076030707,
0.029335063,
0.0054444317,
-0.0451376475,
-0.0482559167,
-0.0305297282,
-0.0306756087,
0.0215065591,
0.014126421,
0.0581113063,
0.1206342503,
-0.0696023405,
0.0208134111,
0.0134507436,
-0.0811351836,
0.0287555512,
-0.0070142965,
0.0263115168,
0.050586693,
0.0260246471,
0.009699339,
0.0513980724,
0.0553789288,
-0.0340158604,
-0.0039434368,
0.0531633161,
0.0263626371,
0.0628170669,
-0.0074972804,
0.0390711948,
0.0205030199,
-0.0112486426,
-0.0481651202,
0.0060353149,
0.0216228198,
-0.0066902777,
0.0447104238,
0.000191095,
-0.059289027,
-0.049721349,
-0.0094865179,
0.0160610303,
-0.0321280099,
-0.0049217618,
0.0264416505,
0.0004947944,
-0.0336668789,
0.0457086451,
0.0491001233,
-0.0332843103,
-0.0878277123,
0.0454485081,
0.0164201818,
-0.0126554919,
-0.004766624,
0.0260735359,
-0.0326919779,
-0.0365057401,
-0.0277828369,
-0.0501868837,
-0.0021104577,
0.0136719607,
0.0161910579,
0.0107182711,
-0.0363829732,
0.0076647988,
-0.028041942,
-0.0089251017,
-0.0393652543,
0.0425630733,
0.0165129844,
0.039226789,
0.02847578,
0.0256279986,
0.0776832253,
0.0164029133,
0.011696781,
-0.020773543,
0.0209338441,
-0.0122000491,
0.0050292481,
0.0089023057,
-0.0080861356,
0.0009758701,
0.0751030222,
-0.0365279429,
0.0096886009,
-0.014907388,
2.697e-7,
0.0466180891,
0.0733682811,
0.0150064351,
0.0119509958,
0.000822623,
0.0118684731,
-0.0173012074,
0.0014716173,
0.0095729101,
0.0347170532,
0.0338922143,
0.0461835898,
0.0296025183,
0.0380478986,
-0.0640898868,
0.0183245279,
-0.0243910588,
-0.0146974912,
-0.0831395388,
0.0077635054,
0.0322996676,
0.0799530372,
-0.000857272,
-0.0268526934,
-0.011655665,
-0.0131533174,
0.0457690805,
-0.024565123,
0.0002968701,
0.0198188517,
0.0264033452,
0.0154970717,
-0.03066165,
-0.0275337435,
0.0237907283,
0.0575396195,
-0.0093818791,
0.0722134709,
0.0004126243,
0.0217662826,
0.0188646186,
-0.0356102772,
-0.0278544314,
-0.0148922941,
0.0682246536,
-0.0370792411,
-0.0152772758,
-0.0272351075,
-0.0202111509,
0.0133474525,
-0.0419500433,
0.0254773647,
0.0041188328,
0.0268226247,
-0.0056598363,
-0.0251119472,
0.0243744571,
-0.0815050676,
-0.0031941044,
0.0688291863,
-0.0383706503,
-0.0262072105,
-0.0079435753,
0.0429708585,
0.01341624,
-0.0712346956,
0.0192657374,
2.912288173e-34,
0.0199133009,
0.0411745273,
-0.0327747613,
0.026968101,
0.0098783793,
-0.0123216445,
-0.0081684636,
0.023812212,
-0.0195461325,
-0.1133149117,
-0.01607107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17498v2 | Improving QA Model Performance with Cartographic Inoculation | 2024-01-30T23:08:26 | 2024-02-01T20:43:02 | Allen Chen, Okan Tanrikulu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | QA models are faced with complex and open-ended contextual reasoning
problems, but can often learn well-performing solution heuristics by exploiting
dataset-specific patterns in their training data. These patterns, or "dataset
artifacts", reduce the model's ability to generalize to real-world QA problems.
Utilizing an ElectraSmallDiscriminator model trained for QA, we analyze the
impacts and incidence of dataset artifacts using an adversarial challenge set
designed to confuse models reliant on artifacts for prediction. Extending
existing work on methods for mitigating artifact impacts, we propose
cartographic inoculation, a novel method that fine-tunes models on an optimized
subset of the challenge data to reduce model reliance on dataset artifacts. We
show that by selectively fine-tuning a model on ambiguous adversarial examples
from a challenge set, significant performance improvements can be made on the
full challenge dataset with minimal loss of model generalizability to other
challenging environments and QA datasets. | [
0.0319278799,
0.0836739391,
-0.0554964095,
0.0578113012,
-0.0026663104,
0.0438848324,
-0.008122812,
-0.0474703163,
-0.0144198593,
-0.0085076829,
0.0142291626,
0.0173598658,
-0.0217050146,
0.0085570831,
0.0322373733,
-0.0460486859,
0.0299171824,
-0.0148506751,
-0.0757217705,
0.0013259304,
-0.0356503166,
-0.0151364403,
0.0007522026,
0.0140287476,
0.0021660242,
-0.0175418165,
-0.0520059802,
0.0247707926,
0.0394727141,
-0.0369539261,
0.0417504124,
0.0054598134,
0.0249775946,
0.012269415,
0.000002431,
-0.0138322255,
-0.0289138108,
0.0089905215,
-0.0620717369,
-0.0152216488,
-0.0071538524,
-0.0024563274,
0.0334134772,
0.0210523084,
-0.0250299927,
-0.0078257667,
0.0502258167,
0.0628920421,
0.0535918139,
0.0398702025,
-0.0166808907,
0.0001817493,
-0.0066577294,
-0.035304293,
-0.0074609909,
-0.058465682,
0.0211083684,
-0.0020137776,
-0.0167921204,
-0.0103177009,
-0.0157298017,
0.0020014464,
0.0426951721,
0.0870341882,
0.0030704166,
0.0072514103,
-0.0109014483,
0.0463309996,
-0.005585711,
0.0867753327,
-0.0275383666,
0.0192748066,
0.0113902297,
-0.0002200202,
0.0041312338,
0.0071700048,
-0.0282973852,
-0.0284684282,
-0.0230643116,
0.0109905656,
-0.0459882654,
0.0070945858,
0.0319135748,
0.0165412743,
-0.0576840639,
0.0343402922,
-0.0189696085,
-0.0061620544,
-0.0170189198,
-0.0155792618,
-0.0481235757,
-0.0326729864,
-0.0252886899,
0.0365485847,
-0.0593680777,
0.0016849027,
0.0166866351,
0.0186770968,
0.0255485568,
0.0311433468,
0.0521892421,
0.00615517,
-0.0169754401,
0.0271721464,
0.0065283482,
0.0411126204,
-0.0336217098,
0.0663633943,
-0.0351763368,
-0.0245357025,
-0.0375097655,
0.0228139646,
-0.0475405529,
0.0017594462,
-0.0375904143,
0.0375984199,
-0.0043443386,
0.0218874514,
-0.039699018,
0.0389145128,
-0.0704852268,
0.0668401867,
-0.0373762101,
0.0035758088,
-0.0332549401,
-0.0381454751,
-0.0475633405,
0.0363470763,
0.005913863,
-0.0284021255,
-0.0183848888,
-0.0171051305,
0.0115201399,
-0.0255735386,
-0.0198837537,
0.0818725452,
0.0334278494,
-0.025207527,
-0.0455373935,
-0.0130518768,
0.0000085999,
-0.0523751155,
0.0408459678,
-0.0485582873,
-0.0215988308,
-0.0103480509,
-0.0235924181,
-0.0088903802,
-0.032701876,
-0.0177695919,
-0.0255005695,
0.112180829,
0.0266935993,
-0.0084785726,
0.0639240146,
0.040533103,
-0.0035192289,
0.0851720646,
0.0066744154,
0.0554705486,
0.0042206589,
-0.0008326818,
0.0130505553,
0.0021033101,
0.0262988172,
0.0289246161,
-0.0273809098,
0.0496034138,
0.0136816772,
0.0117145609,
0.0084975259,
0.0065615936,
-0.0529572405,
-0.0064546159,
0.0178711284,
-0.0160374548,
-0.0272751451,
-0.0072605647,
-0.0187056344,
-0.0127856657,
-0.0483250879,
0.0041869148,
-0.0412418135,
0.0003813572,
-0.0026475182,
-0.0181821119,
-0.0329078399,
0.0169120952,
-0.0569464974,
-0.0568556041,
-0.0067577655,
-0.0241168737,
0.0300386045,
0.0280682035,
0.0078107961,
0.0405410565,
-0.008663971,
-0.0265278444,
-0.009972156,
0.0008938974,
-0.0424148031,
-0.0473288111,
0.0540869348,
-0.024786327,
0.0401193649,
-0.0725703537,
-0.0591983907,
-0.0195593238,
0.053401608,
-0.009970542,
0.0659209788,
-0.0353706181,
0.0103935888,
-0.0454713181,
-0.0720519945,
-0.06727276,
0.0288524833,
0.0227440968,
0.0349880047,
-0.0036225282,
0.0281100497,
-0.0737656578,
0.0037418294,
0.0307474993,
-0.0254956931,
-0.031307485,
-0.003789647,
0.0491609201,
0.0299725235,
-0.0437384024,
-0.0006161252,
-0.0036005746,
0.0156311244,
-0.0313953757,
-0.0235798657,
0.0255081132,
-0.0256566387,
-0.0144548547,
0.0000728303,
-0.0506285131,
-0.0460100323,
0.052342359,
-0.0728040338,
0.0005270849,
-0.000378991,
-0.0109117283,
0.0443670526,
0.0118143298,
-0.0115826754,
0.0038651275,
0.020974502,
-0.0473081544,
0.0527622402,
-0.0010129452,
-0.0096061807,
0.0740383491,
0.0315088183,
0.0345239379,
0.0400572754,
0.0042383238,
-0.0038488773,
-0.0238103345,
-0.0134079717,
-0.0245516002,
-0.0244831443,
-0.0426886566,
-0.0126325721,
-0.0305632707,
0.0212406497,
-0.0052784132,
0.00588965,
0.015689401,
-0.0312801972,
-0.0160878468,
-0.0260370355,
-0.015859358,
-0.0103593413,
0.0009571599,
0.0394816399,
0.0257353708,
0.0355468169,
0.0237558726,
-0.0097185578,
0.0246496126,
-0.0181339271,
0.0519449301,
-0.0050502378,
0.0374796763,
-0.037162967,
0.0544302277,
-0.0139897577,
0.0518421493,
-0.0485729538,
-0.0232899114,
0.003835571,
0.0092559485,
0.0028660535,
0.0590339936,
-0.0286559649,
0.0090976832,
0.0577684045,
-0.0149165187,
-0.0332131609,
0.0301277824,
-0.0010995183,
-0.0289485492,
-0.0057099694,
-0.0419800133,
-0.0181428511,
0.0332870781,
0.0036690626,
-0.0186231099,
-0.0164034329,
0.0790848434,
-0.0114208627,
-0.0193427578,
-0.0365340859,
-0.0262481607,
0.0168846436,
0.0743167475,
-0.0670766234,
-0.0223859679,
0.0602874681,
0.0026132534,
0.0149319787,
-0.0385208242,
0.019743653,
-0.0328673907,
0.0316707753,
0.0058251568,
0.0196993276,
0.0324729867,
0.002666275,
-0.0642901286,
-0.0563290752,
-0.0518836789,
-0.0201152433,
0.012091375,
-0.0165087692,
-0.0498347469,
-0.0155205196,
-0.1004648507,
-0.081719093,
0.0068588811,
0.044742059,
0.0236820914,
0.0275583602,
0.0152148753,
0.0065079145,
0.0176002122,
-0.0150023326,
0.0637288541,
-0.0347685479,
-0.0268678851,
-0.032313548,
0.0303146653,
0.0657003,
0.0920775682,
0.0326389633,
-0.02244322,
0.004699579,
0.0125304181,
0.0547987185,
-0.0157527644,
-0.0170814227,
0.038619522,
-0.0088419076,
-0.0036658915,
0.00411093,
0.0301727913,
0.0484209359,
-0.0468410701,
-0.0599722974,
0.0531818308,
0.0503968634,
0.0019053142,
0.0060901553,
-0.0270989649,
0.0128886774,
0.0445550308,
0.0461750068,
-0.0606515929,
-0.0285994001,
0.028183585,
0.0214558728,
-0.0120520266,
-0.0261790678,
0.0322585702,
-0.1045574993,
0.0614365265,
-0.0194559284,
-0.0967256576,
-0.0327193998,
-0.0180086624,
-0.0193248559,
-0.0410014875,
0.0127928704,
-0.0232437141,
0.0047140662,
-0.0065195034,
0.0446901321,
0.0044228281,
-0.0270618331,
0.0085054198,
-0.0552217737,
0.0083518503,
0.0687749088,
0.0270403735,
0.001227291,
-0.0034557574,
-0.0240336731,
-0.0060973838,
0.0456940122,
0.0273787789,
0.0753471702,
0.0124381986,
-0.0358961187,
0.0284629446,
0.0248562265,
-0.0459307767,
-0.0159250125,
0.0387503728,
0.0544088148,
-0.0002515762,
0.0469031781,
-0.0259684026,
-0.0255009905,
0.0394895896,
0.0058218017,
0.0350463577,
0.0030820516,
-0.0576345809,
-0.0541670695,
0.0406991541,
-0.0701528415,
0.032965716,
0.0638215765,
0.0396790542,
-0.0157912206,
-0.0336814411,
-0.0937617719,
-0.0021789907,
0.0397291332,
0.025112642,
-0.043912258,
-0.0559999831,
-0.0108780665,
-0.0429349095,
0.0426810868,
-0.0259603541,
0.0027369452,
0.0357604362,
0.0203047991,
-0.0080095977,
-0.0565632172,
-0.0198790226,
0.0483256839,
-0.0911304578,
-0.0480971411,
0.0398804806,
0.0608616248,
0.0224128421,
0.0834544301,
-0.0381924473,
-0.0173277259,
0.0519380942,
0.04840675,
0.0068618804,
-0.01927769,
0.0526611805,
-0.0272665955,
-0.0058592153,
-0.0039318181,
-0.0341332071,
0.0297789089,
0.0554585941,
0.0120843546,
-0.0607070848,
0.0649037287,
0.0297475792,
-0.0398495272,
0.0880569145,
0.0054503917,
-0.0491108857,
-0.014456613,
0.0578352138,
0.0292343069,
-0.0088959131,
-0.0034603819,
-0.0149527583,
-0.0323762223,
0.014280349,
0.024036007,
-0.0196844041,
0.0245797019,
0.0381692275,
-0.0522493459,
0.0126291597,
0.075623937,
0.0235328879,
0.0141253797,
0.03427881,
0.0009498397,
0.0233310424,
0.0273046903,
0.0385178067,
-0.0115163606,
0.0451276004,
0.0414777696,
0.0574913584,
-0.0269395728,
-0.0082775373,
-0.0737063885,
-0.0581011586,
-0.026315067,
-0.0008646101,
0.0563806854,
-0.0559700951,
-0.0657066181,
-0.0180807952,
-0.0109260455,
0.0162169617,
-0.0209043398,
0.0115722343,
-0.0240168367,
0.0308772568,
0.0302534699,
0.0014769804,
0.0026277837,
0.0388468578,
0.0005408624,
0.1236306876,
-0.0415320583,
-0.0255075134,
-0.0336756818,
-0.0103707844,
0.1004548073,
-0.0041109757,
0.0058700633,
0.0075133392,
-0.0401842073,
-0.1053708941,
0.0175306816,
0.0248291064,
-0.0069089616,
0.0061917151,
0.0068494491,
0.0507784821,
-0.026044406,
-0.0342770666,
-0.0157735776,
0.0003082941,
-0.0527650751,
-0.0111189596,
-0.0038824305,
-6.714568465e-33,
-0.015664842,
-0.0390691757,
0.0392212458,
-0.0714306384,
0.0400101617,
0.0362407751,
-0.0193983875,
-0.0517583527,
-0.0188058484,
-0.0221781712,
-0.0331172608,
-0.0020658912,
-0.0018530214,
0.0190896783,
-0.0063820682,
-0.0202971064,
0.0422698036,
0.0177973118,
-0.0174511988,
0.0060244077,
0.0006644025,
0.0141363936,
0.0101208435,
-0.0712594166,
0.004915983,
-0.0213918742,
-0.0291905943,
0.021650929,
-0.0364219807,
0.0518835671,
-0.0183083434,
0.0154726058,
0.0272305943,
-0.0425728038,
-0.00781033,
-0.0118358517,
-0.0566381849,
-0.0481101386,
-0.0243622847,
0.0231336392,
-0.0195819121,
-0.0461588018,
0.0441976748,
-0.0082340315,
0.0171035174,
0.0205476396,
0.0352055877,
-0.0313618891,
-0.0237891637,
0.0274878517,
-0.0447630733,
0.0140909469,
-0.0461716913,
-0.0325622819,
0.0048074545,
0.0598044656,
0.0434284061,
0.0370537266,
-0.0495140143,
0.0125578865,
0.0631827936,
-0.0461249501,
0.0462375209,
0.0167755876,
-0.0064208121,
0.0382669605,
0.0246592183,
0.0185482949,
0.0037879923,
-0.0404823646,
-0.0067577963,
0.059948884,
0.0451983102,
0.0688980147,
0.0390967354,
-0.0257204697,
-0.0887465104,
0.0576761402,
-0.054326456,
0.0199957862,
0.0211350545,
0.0014061669,
-0.0659544915,
-0.0046989233,
-0.0536948703,
-0.0370560922,
-0.0344057195,
0.0017167723,
0.0620333366,
-0.0012207662,
-0.009241851,
0.0586730093,
-0.0022035653,
-0.0511187427,
-0.0088799354,
0.012801609,
-0.0036293098,
-0.0310011972,
-0.0165825784,
0.0265429821,
-0.040641211,
-0.0491102114,
0.0098425234,
0.0071429634,
0.0444712602,
0.0234213024,
0.0604731105,
0.0148332734,
-0.0625901073,
0.0118017755,
-0.0426014699,
0.0266488995,
0.000218326,
-0.0006030743,
0.0286675449,
0.0092195617,
0.0044400175,
0.0133529678,
0.0151181286,
-0.0127197243,
-0.0221692305,
-0.0404928252,
-0.0495114252,
0.0259672981,
-0.0074532898,
-0.0456798188,
0.0251737479,
0.0160639491,
0.01699684,
-0.0647614375,
-0.0139168622,
0.0029715814,
3.021e-7,
0.0072876127,
0.037124902,
0.0151517605,
-0.0010337589,
0.016095968,
0.0334969871,
-0.0442785025,
0.0200804584,
-0.0269137435,
-0.0036984156,
0.0434523597,
0.052395869,
0.01390009,
0.0547327474,
-0.0710622892,
0.015149286,
-0.0435249619,
0.0052157142,
-0.0451081917,
0.0146720009,
0.0356104523,
0.0825922042,
-0.0036956593,
-0.0257111005,
0.0177292395,
-0.0119649153,
0.0146663683,
-0.0421246551,
0.0367887765,
0.0213110223,
-0.0206266977,
0.0324874111,
0.0151447495,
0.0312431511,
0.0053513879,
-0.0247470494,
0.0234571844,
0.0247720797,
0.0004799579,
-0.0616566353,
-0.018478198,
0.0122376187,
0.0029574304,
-0.0749635771,
0.0890490636,
-0.0636562258,
-0.0448778793,
-0.013373116,
-0.008352357,
0.0044186823,
0.0317036472,
0.0262681134,
0.0080620004,
-0.0423196629,
-0.0242342521,
-0.0092538148,
0.0018004264,
-0.0646973848,
0.0173558295,
0.0138416328,
-0.0098526813,
-0.0081007909,
-0.0192387626,
-0.0156382192,
0.028512923,
-0.031583827,
-0.0150310416,
2.951772155e-34,
0.0041947206,
-0.0053695636,
0.0264963657,
-0.0181110147,
0.0564887486,
-0.0203654189,
0.0335289389,
0.001072256,
0.0246248189,
0.0023379391,
-0.0066001527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17477v1 | Detecting mental disorder on social media: a ChatGPT-augmented explainable approach | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | Loris Belcastro, Riccardo Cantini, Fabrizio Marozzo, Domenico Talia, Paolo Trunfio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | In the digital era, the prevalence of depressive symptoms expressed on social
media has raised serious concerns, necessitating advanced methodologies for
timely detection. This paper addresses the challenge of interpretable
depression detection by proposing a novel methodology that effectively combines
Large Language Models (LLMs) with eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) and
conversational agents like ChatGPT. In our methodology, explanations are
achieved by integrating BERTweet, a Twitter-specific variant of BERT, into a
novel self-explanatory model, namely BERT-XDD, capable of providing both
classification and explanations via masked attention. The interpretability is
further enhanced using ChatGPT to transform technical explanations into
human-readable commentaries. By introducing an effective and modular approach
for interpretable depression detection, our methodology can contribute to the
development of socially responsible digital platforms, fostering early
intervention and support for mental health challenges under the guidance of
qualified healthcare professionals. | [
0.0363446437,
0.0169772953,
-0.0353256129,
0.0107396888,
0.0087011512,
0.026069833,
0.0228968505,
0.0177918263,
0.0750438869,
-0.0172258299,
0.0369906537,
0.0256826729,
-0.0459110439,
0.032524623,
-0.0037040028,
-0.074780032,
-0.0206072815,
0.0272904616,
0.045090653,
0.0070512705,
0.0417949744,
0.0211285129,
-0.0111553175,
0.0550961047,
-0.0042308797,
-0.0310418662,
-0.0109890029,
0.0051918421,
0.0034503692,
-0.0225792546,
0.0001644255,
0.0210185535,
0.0163701568,
0.0127886282,
0.0000019593,
-0.0092970571,
-0.0208353195,
-0.0043093357,
-0.0132176299,
-0.0227344148,
-0.013923252,
-0.0440572947,
0.0316997953,
0.0241697952,
-0.0277778618,
0.0151302563,
0.0418081246,
0.0761293098,
0.1042716429,
0.056618318,
-0.022429103,
-0.0117258718,
0.0050693853,
0.0069725835,
0.0070124948,
-0.0172347929,
0.0247861333,
0.0409352444,
0.0257111546,
-0.0022221608,
-0.0218826141,
0.0386582129,
-0.0260257833,
-0.0077816714,
0.0029491046,
-0.0110949995,
0.0025288269,
-0.0386871435,
0.0132776611,
0.0772677585,
0.0235205665,
-0.0067097452,
0.0371648818,
-0.0020918702,
0.0046691573,
0.0144514171,
-0.0415936746,
-0.0141053163,
-0.0068632667,
0.0367512703,
0.0359476171,
0.0064851777,
0.0409455262,
0.0213953424,
-0.0004884848,
0.041443564,
-0.0370452404,
-0.0272611678,
-0.0470612757,
-0.0142089287,
-0.0617272332,
-0.051067166,
0.0515616871,
0.0591711737,
-0.0421616808,
0.0252161548,
-0.0263095982,
-0.0770091936,
-0.0094477916,
-0.0085736876,
-0.0223347303,
0.0288742855,
-0.0496514626,
0.0235756487,
0.0377809256,
0.0410581045,
-0.0026192281,
-0.0058714538,
-0.0098609338,
-0.0364313759,
-0.0968938321,
-0.007552518,
-0.0462877825,
0.0076345825,
-0.0022885918,
-0.0416424498,
-0.0333875306,
0.0408834442,
-0.0251611006,
-0.0162665527,
0.0365095995,
-0.0110579543,
-0.007945234,
-0.0002501743,
0.0198621154,
0.0300825443,
-0.036043793,
-0.0371128507,
0.002008101,
-0.0335924104,
0.0104563935,
0.0162551366,
0.0146731073,
-0.0136153987,
-0.0178948846,
0.0414216258,
0.0557068847,
-0.0181710199,
-0.0265241936,
-0.0377350934,
-0.0275850389,
-0.0124790454,
-0.0211681928,
0.0000085873,
0.0018197981,
0.040893387,
-0.0002856631,
-0.0249659922,
0.0357782394,
-0.0105479341,
-0.0447381139,
0.0657737628,
-0.0815163702,
0.0321651101,
0.0029474543,
0.0223815162,
-0.0291722007,
0.0652822703,
0.032168854,
0.0227185171,
0.0476089902,
-0.05777812,
0.0335981026,
-0.0019882508,
0.0274638589,
-0.0306028947,
0.0227880552,
-0.0160043351,
-0.0863464773,
0.0322996937,
-0.0061451425,
0.0185932163,
0.0009625409,
0.0327235572,
0.0600704066,
0.0593685806,
0.0355559029,
0.0701086,
0.0124202128,
0.0552197918,
-0.0246085972,
0.0110031143,
-0.0202528555,
0.0291308146,
-0.0243691262,
-0.0159961972,
-0.0034648494,
-0.0171250831,
-0.0129751954,
-0.0613262355,
-0.0231899396,
-0.0192277431,
0.0398809984,
0.0055330344,
0.007870486,
-0.0244506206,
-0.0184153859,
0.0854934305,
0.0433650203,
-0.0309854932,
-0.0384336635,
-0.0731983036,
0.0526829921,
0.1079588756,
0.0182008799,
-0.0526065677,
-0.0122068981,
-0.0090068113,
0.0499770567,
0.0455584116,
0.0019032157,
0.0359970927,
0.0227264799,
-0.0224466547,
0.0092724822,
0.0003852659,
0.0125538064,
-0.0222761352,
-0.0157663412,
-0.0102165332,
-0.0257093702,
-0.0317760333,
-0.0339805819,
0.0256843232,
0.0127697159,
-0.0367663801,
-0.0055662305,
0.0134019908,
0.0378577672,
0.0414889641,
0.0253370628,
0.0130574545,
-0.001424412,
-0.0156877935,
-0.0586131886,
0.0342484899,
0.0171526428,
-0.0419537537,
0.0112876231,
-0.0256088004,
-0.0273219645,
0.0638009384,
-0.0393195525,
-0.0393345132,
0.0537963808,
-0.0932255983,
0.0694942921,
-0.0219536908,
-0.040310543,
-0.0000442306,
0.0252358168,
0.0092629995,
0.0499215834,
-0.0193306804,
-0.0073639792,
-0.0003435218,
-0.0305207744,
-0.037919119,
-0.0280436631,
-0.0099799084,
-0.017321134,
-0.0049199401,
0.0100162355,
-0.0200108159,
0.0001349314,
-0.0133613758,
0.0017157245,
-0.1272961199,
0.0046091382,
-0.029400656,
0.0028213474,
0.0214503389,
0.0091246134,
0.0035354097,
-0.0088077104,
-0.0136258742,
0.0396183915,
0.0271153189,
0.0144771924,
0.0433471426,
0.0073894542,
-0.0332650021,
-0.0462494381,
-0.0144516937,
-0.0441223122,
0.0365387276,
-0.0104051018,
-0.0701614469,
-0.0612160861,
-0.0150274066,
-0.0427182615,
0.0022867103,
-0.0064574657,
-0.0586929247,
0.0117444135,
-0.0110895028,
0.0034316489,
0.0268359669,
0.0185295995,
0.1043793112,
-0.0109329801,
0.0210126303,
-0.0263704751,
0.0135382274,
-0.0209501702,
-0.0072338367,
-0.0233057309,
-0.0513993949,
0.0069351844,
0.0827741921,
0.0014419863,
-0.002569335,
-0.0767061263,
-0.0122216232,
-0.0025075024,
0.0082944147,
-0.0057591768,
-0.0263570324,
0.0074513364,
0.0055841547,
-0.004165031,
-0.0521165431,
0.0688739717,
-0.0008032502,
-0.0260182936,
-0.0168360546,
-0.0480017364,
-0.0399417728,
0.0293576084,
-0.0011072095,
0.0286125969,
0.0233918019,
-0.0446944386,
0.0564787313,
-0.0255724601,
-0.0068215113,
-0.0172689557,
0.0134842554,
-0.0281532649,
0.0071151755,
0.0677045584,
-0.0071640308,
-0.0142762177,
-0.0669748187,
-0.0719897524,
0.0023156649,
0.0101460665,
-0.0299134459,
-0.0438086204,
0.0138619281,
0.0231890939,
-0.0040382324,
-0.0142937936,
-0.0166667253,
-0.0104405051,
-0.00310411,
0.0248428974,
0.0115419282,
0.0328208879,
-0.025027765,
0.0306238364,
0.0319296494,
-0.0264070574,
-0.0057643959,
-0.0341417752,
-0.0054062745,
-0.0427473746,
-0.027428668,
-0.0161103979,
-0.008278342,
0.0509046242,
-0.0314971916,
0.0077753095,
0.1214444935,
0.0055755377,
-0.0032590125,
0.0384484604,
-0.022155026,
-0.0203754511,
-0.0237735752,
-0.0107328305,
-0.0264647231,
-0.0590785965,
-0.0406514034,
0.0568273552,
-0.0145172691,
-0.0093235942,
0.0128995348,
-0.0023614923,
0.0300462972,
-0.0232892558,
0.0168587714,
0.0043980111,
-0.0331783108,
-0.0020797111,
-0.0248899125,
0.0017448326,
-0.0277928114,
-0.0053769136,
-0.0044869971,
0.0086041782,
-0.089407675,
-0.0283846352,
0.0551736318,
-0.0068860617,
0.0531177558,
0.0435134508,
0.0794517323,
0.0052700234,
-0.0380636416,
-0.0194452386,
0.0256893784,
0.019798344,
0.0039250115,
0.0810538381,
-0.0067496626,
-0.0199005324,
-0.0807743073,
0.053112682,
-0.0604455955,
-0.017185118,
-0.0263574552,
0.0749247745,
-0.0268288907,
-0.0320010558,
-0.0216063671,
0.0380623117,
0.0403813608,
0.0845332891,
0.0786398202,
-0.0524547175,
-0.0356012583,
0.0119184265,
-0.0014160478,
-0.0216985364,
-0.0248594768,
-0.0111745382,
-0.0052345358,
-0.0510224253,
-0.0554262474,
-0.0525383055,
0.0244473014,
-0.0248711929,
-0.0326605737,
-0.0373925269,
0.0164370444,
0.0203233585,
-0.0491173267,
0.0656213984,
0.0429743193,
0.005057442,
-0.0086883372,
-0.029388519,
0.0117684482,
-0.0261356086,
-0.0008243664,
-0.0010719548,
-0.045281399,
0.0055945949,
0.0424894355,
0.0058556455,
0.0253591482,
-0.0081136962,
-0.011348187,
-0.0780801922,
-0.0202901084,
0.0138287609,
0.0046389308,
-0.0189881269,
0.0439679436,
0.0596074276,
0.0287868604,
0.0707587227,
-0.0116499281,
0.0194398444,
-0.0123393917,
-0.0111189149,
-0.0446994305,
0.0298791677,
-0.002393344,
0.0194608495,
0.0301785637,
0.0152144609,
-0.0588889718,
0.0016714016,
-0.0360072665,
0.0005691139,
0.0067261546,
-0.0610098466,
0.0046697562,
-0.0058138589,
-0.0276116133,
-0.0217080638,
-0.0474026911,
-0.0594807155,
-0.0730295256,
-0.0636667609,
0.0640989766,
-0.0256087985,
-0.0054574246,
-0.0140706683,
-0.0162508581,
-0.0254997369,
0.0235230885,
-0.0206895266,
0.0132848015,
0.0121072186,
0.1021344736,
0.0092496322,
0.0002883483,
0.0359246284,
0.0400170609,
-0.0522182547,
-0.09127184,
-0.0058060447,
0.0160968136,
0.0343738832,
0.0028599983,
0.0963551626,
0.0045098905,
0.0020292518,
0.0176824927,
0.0626707822,
-0.0084459977,
-0.0464239977,
-0.017042987,
0.004024046,
-0.0200741962,
-0.0281485226,
0.0689327344,
-0.0233146362,
-0.0018624988,
0.0483665243,
-0.0230588075,
-0.0150338421,
0.0076243049,
0.020759128,
0.0490899086,
-0.016714165,
0.0119315488,
-0.0202694442,
-0.0642683804,
0.0127741918,
-0.0411929339,
-0.0274245813,
-0.0300532579,
0.0146892592,
0.0469167084,
0.0138296215,
-0.0316269621,
-0.0634130612,
0.0428906679,
-0.042069044,
0.0003580519,
-0.0270420685,
-5.818744056e-33,
0.0186409298,
-0.0473823138,
-0.0275282487,
-0.0072099143,
0.0007551503,
0.0292491727,
-0.0681562945,
0.0117131481,
0.0145773143,
0.0574278645,
0.0273096561,
0.084323585,
-0.0100276107,
0.0511264913,
-0.025399955,
-0.0337986648,
0.0112509802,
0.0264160465,
0.0053296252,
0.0485269912,
0.0393809043,
0.0592189617,
0.0465749875,
-0.0854873806,
0.0392281115,
-0.0140438555,
-0.0064517227,
0.0230113044,
0.0594485961,
0.0481203236,
-0.026351409,
0.053874366,
0.0481302515,
-0.0072699063,
0.004561069,
0.0473387167,
-0.0391945615,
-0.025132101,
0.0228395183,
0.0013351095,
-0.0467826091,
-0.0029163668,
0.0289840121,
-0.0239828918,
0.0181833766,
-0.0150698703,
0.0527345091,
-0.0167470295,
0.0376232266,
0.0092023872,
-0.0098151173,
0.0153153092,
-0.0535995662,
-0.0276641231,
0.0090598259,
0.0219706539,
-0.0098092323,
0.0329016559,
-0.0305473786,
-0.0244926885,
-0.0002788792,
-0.0233130567,
0.0408306606,
-0.0651310235,
-0.0217085313,
0.0294505153,
0.014738881,
0.0020184582,
-0.0610399842,
-0.0081559634,
-0.0390692838,
0.0621251762,
0.0816074982,
-0.0231259055,
0.0065734903,
0.0140816513,
-0.0426185839,
0.0009941739,
0.010563978,
0.0179527961,
0.0457282811,
0.0211252756,
-0.0650957897,
-0.002715789,
0.0233801417,
-0.0040966175,
-0.0284888539,
-0.0338788889,
0.0008417384,
-0.029569732,
-0.0404520817,
0.0031095771,
-0.0051195328,
-0.0495217405,
0.0157842655,
-0.0038142228,
0.0149944089,
0.0100286044,
0.0005739492,
0.0132665625,
0.0090876454,
-0.0109687727,
0.0109221218,
0.0218693614,
0.0498286039,
0.0145218587,
0.0349932685,
-0.0183742885,
0.0164565202,
-0.0122694978,
-0.0330177285,
0.0005926783,
-0.0648737699,
0.035056103,
-0.0049361032,
0.0338875428,
-0.0376250632,
0.0187545493,
0.0333117768,
0.0421736054,
-0.040802151,
-0.0239452738,
-0.0236612521,
-0.0253875814,
-0.0214226265,
-0.0592613779,
-0.0272110812,
0.0118851587,
0.0218955949,
-0.0789772272,
-0.0058079506,
-0.0055596707,
2.663e-7,
0.0484824516,
0.083808817,
-0.0082641281,
-0.0080613485,
0.0488770753,
0.0197962858,
0.0377730131,
0.0352423191,
0.0061792848,
-0.0466494858,
0.0154191274,
0.0462298244,
0.0477462225,
0.0322452225,
0.0102229128,
-0.0678723678,
-0.0345629491,
-0.0352792032,
-0.057015799,
0.0252514891,
0.094561331,
0.067504026,
0.0258818064,
0.0033013003,
0.0421291441,
-0.0192761421,
0.0246071145,
-0.0324289687,
0.0370044112,
0.0276550651,
0.058919128,
-0.0073896889,
0.0268903319,
-0.0246671122,
-0.0070934487,
-0.0042134998,
-0.0135411443,
0.0637913868,
-0.0599513985,
-0.0099589191,
-0.0072145304,
-0.0064737294,
0.0186639354,
-0.0461963303,
0.0488072708,
-0.0689677447,
-0.0845864341,
-0.0196007118,
-0.0078952406,
-0.0653663874,
-0.0147026656,
-0.0002979335,
-0.0231142286,
0.0475356057,
-0.0120238727,
-0.0366907828,
0.01388497,
-0.0896730721,
-0.0386497714,
-0.0188113917,
-0.0681327656,
0.0197854862,
-0.0383658744,
-0.0261061247,
0.0456517972,
-0.0703450069,
0.0310638789,
2.145622721e-34,
0.0240699202,
0.0371006839,
0.0050871684,
0.0323618427,
0.0482858345,
0.0402896814,
0.0009260947,
-0.012344162,
0.0461193696,
-0.0768965706,
-0.0046181185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00075v1 | D-Nikud: Enhancing Hebrew Diacritization with LSTM and Pretrained Models | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | Adi Rosenthal, Nadav Shaked | cs.CL | cs.CL | D-Nikud, a novel approach to Hebrew diacritization that integrates the
strengths of LSTM networks and BERT-based (transformer) pre-trained model.
Inspired by the methodologies employed in Nakdimon, we integrate it with the
TavBERT pre-trained model, our system incorporates advanced architectural
choices and diverse training data. Our experiments showcase state-of-the-art
results on several benchmark datasets, with a particular emphasis on modern
texts and more specified diacritization like gender. | [
-0.0225215275,
0.0593604743,
-0.0057413862,
0.0653636307,
-0.0074962215,
0.0259764921,
0.0463475212,
0.0023903497,
-0.014164404,
-0.0660766661,
-0.0506523401,
-0.0908005312,
0.0267040189,
-0.000010206,
0.0227085315,
-0.0180547684,
0.019528538,
-0.0317266509,
-0.0354631655,
-0.0116974646,
0.026974583,
0.0221742056,
0.0023972567,
-0.0043189549,
0.0197353866,
-0.0038962357,
0.0634630024,
0.0205995645,
0.0160656404,
0.0058311597,
0.0305016413,
0.0415932313,
-0.0352169052,
0.0514887609,
0.0000017725,
-0.0284556895,
-0.0038820684,
-0.0155443503,
0.0109816901,
0.0055186609,
0.0581099056,
-0.0532361455,
-0.0658359081,
0.0151476422,
-0.0404271185,
-0.0313558504,
0.0515802912,
0.0228146166,
0.0537921824,
0.0524121709,
-0.0032769514,
-0.0385903977,
0.0495873354,
-0.0155034121,
-0.0576163791,
0.0262465943,
0.008221643,
-0.0671587586,
-0.0600350052,
0.0066107153,
-0.0236297753,
0.0308931004,
0.0303907059,
-0.0105712861,
0.0016854682,
-0.0093993973,
-0.0139329256,
-0.0011578749,
0.0216391999,
-0.0022660487,
-0.0168143846,
-0.0311240144,
0.0128817186,
0.0245929845,
-0.0321543179,
-0.0374530628,
0.0021537959,
0.021321889,
-0.0301401298,
0.0141733401,
-0.001654562,
-0.0112066176,
0.0469576493,
0.0201459937,
-0.0605554394,
-0.0051798746,
0.060303051,
-0.0663943291,
0.0056000124,
0.0232899562,
-0.0164630786,
-0.0213910285,
0.0528533719,
0.0019563194,
0.023516465,
-0.0291854162,
-0.0145230861,
-0.0666494593,
-0.0144546311,
-0.0195684936,
0.0455280989,
0.0425740294,
-0.0464968979,
-0.0453281403,
-0.0680744126,
0.0401719213,
0.0404794663,
0.0282188281,
-0.0124658877,
0.0106063439,
-0.012903261,
-0.0002451041,
-0.0434933752,
0.0249199327,
-0.0087086419,
0.0427885279,
-0.0687559843,
-0.0131276473,
0.0303008184,
-0.0495112166,
0.0002635974,
-0.0256009754,
-0.0192954764,
-0.023870172,
0.0459991358,
-0.0156286396,
-0.0356889442,
-0.0027736574,
-0.047469411,
-0.0390468352,
0.0107067861,
0.0167235341,
-0.0007668303,
-0.0347972102,
0.0194113664,
0.0010012883,
0.0089973481,
-0.0525726676,
-0.0555424877,
0.0344498083,
-0.0448946469,
0.0140921744,
-0.0360988714,
-0.0477090254,
-0.0173948482,
-0.0245221183,
0.0049986346,
-0.0383066125,
-0.0158307329,
0.0354228579,
0.0079098996,
0.086449109,
0.0205136761,
-0.0423107632,
0.0329285935,
0.0038305034,
0.0295501947,
0.0125982286,
0.0557367951,
-0.0008218471,
0.0261849407,
0.0031887998,
0.0241521951,
0.0622216128,
0.0035761693,
0.0268008467,
-0.0533264093,
-0.0020147639,
0.0039246101,
0.0276854597,
0.0394995362,
0.054371912,
-0.032600686,
-0.0591315366,
0.0922106877,
0.0862945169,
0.0408148058,
0.0424317457,
-0.0057938802,
0.002551415,
0.0427937619,
-0.0052900477,
-0.0215163007,
-0.0118308105,
0.0270460211,
0.0035138433,
-0.0111171594,
0.0452814586,
-0.0147114601,
-0.0519144088,
0.0101146176,
-0.0403920785,
-0.0278741904,
-0.0287057161,
0.0180313345,
0.0675631613,
-0.04192302,
0.0738688633,
-0.0109452857,
-0.066695109,
0.0477684215,
-0.02295251,
0.0088654906,
0.0418951139,
0.0649698079,
-0.0476039425,
-0.0652044713,
-0.0281247627,
-0.0100657092,
0.0785034671,
-0.0177137665,
0.0316321105,
0.0057981336,
-0.0791846365,
0.0263679624,
0.0139038814,
0.0123684471,
0.0106523549,
-0.01110039,
0.0326550119,
0.0185226426,
-0.0079915542,
-0.0518435277,
0.0462905318,
-0.0079798885,
-0.0335044153,
-0.004002111,
-0.0016004,
0.0179111585,
-0.0196047854,
-0.0236631334,
-0.0212111734,
-0.0135464752,
-0.06769301,
-0.0194817744,
-0.0369701087,
-0.0282440223,
-0.0096340515,
0.0336499773,
-0.0398691595,
-0.0261352379,
0.0448771752,
-0.0006898522,
-0.0266566463,
0.0199834574,
-0.030950252,
-0.0284687057,
-0.0418465249,
0.0280087702,
0.0161905158,
0.0352448225,
-0.0205118861,
-0.0032194229,
0.0217416547,
0.000557813,
0.0402383171,
-0.0188144427,
0.0174076688,
0.0258997716,
-0.0745687634,
-0.0056357733,
-0.0102424165,
0.0012925998,
0.0074205198,
0.000270428,
0.0278350189,
-0.0576142371,
-0.0645877942,
0.003033255,
-0.0280263107,
0.0473193526,
0.0088128746,
0.0386028551,
0.0005126856,
-0.0080432845,
-0.0281646717,
-0.0398978665,
-0.0015507118,
-0.0069472874,
0.0586134791,
-0.0299307909,
-0.0149231479,
-0.0603378452,
-0.0110653974,
-0.0195041951,
0.0485980771,
0.0216350555,
0.0044455049,
-0.0032843207,
-0.0497402437,
0.0214521363,
0.028375702,
0.0322271399,
-0.0545346886,
0.0168209467,
0.0258306097,
0.0559269302,
0.0187076218,
0.0132554919,
-0.0321205035,
-0.0336590372,
-0.0244680829,
-0.0498036221,
-0.0007241031,
0.0174096804,
0.0098894099,
-0.0710374042,
-0.0341965854,
0.0123971514,
0.0370354205,
-0.0203794651,
-0.0168724973,
-0.0348393917,
0.0072386377,
-0.0446522906,
0.0283712838,
0.0317413881,
-0.0126115093,
-0.0351913422,
0.0134980613,
-0.0222382788,
-0.0246051494,
0.0469284281,
-0.0164443497,
-0.032812614,
-0.0411464721,
0.0424413383,
-0.0456028655,
-0.0036440836,
0.0003551006,
0.0155120771,
-0.0441339985,
-0.0503026992,
-0.0648146644,
-0.0039621145,
-0.012108936,
-0.0347677134,
0.0770936012,
0.0124531016,
-0.0043015778,
-0.0116712097,
-0.0551778004,
-0.0211899951,
0.0109436568,
-0.0206596795,
-0.0154156862,
0.0321474969,
-0.0077920272,
0.0019745796,
0.0160943735,
-0.0914390087,
0.0596596897,
0.0314507745,
-0.0093990723,
-0.041877564,
0.0393786654,
-0.0340571254,
-0.0446141958,
-0.0063267597,
0.0031734635,
0.0518590026,
0.00119065,
-0.0396338627,
-0.0001559066,
-0.0441369228,
-0.0051999507,
0.0609147549,
-0.0449022055,
-0.0241795573,
-0.040180631,
-0.036279723,
-0.0450543351,
-0.0229643881,
0.1176791266,
0.015261149,
-0.0649128258,
-0.0186580066,
-0.0151824011,
-0.0196570735,
-0.0159966648,
-0.0003432252,
-0.0983753279,
-0.0180778001,
0.0180747975,
0.0468266644,
0.0438936539,
-0.0177636221,
0.0367052443,
-0.0334566087,
-0.0332982279,
0.0162561536,
0.026954595,
-0.0281812958,
0.0135757439,
-0.0320521593,
-0.0366336256,
0.04793147,
0.0210215971,
-0.0266174711,
0.0113551244,
-0.0080420477,
-0.0455959626,
0.0028874576,
0.0204399265,
-0.0691868588,
0.0391202644,
0.0580892675,
0.0511590205,
-0.0671119764,
-0.0249492712,
0.0153633347,
-0.0457420759,
-0.0562418029,
-0.0159910601,
0.0081563806,
0.0017777297,
-0.0197203141,
0.0095060496,
0.014528947,
-0.0257244222,
-0.0118425526,
-0.0089157075,
-0.0039366595,
-0.002308209,
0.0177691728,
0.0226809997,
0.0483255945,
-0.0555185229,
0.0636163279,
0.0026554987,
-0.0434711576,
-0.0275058448,
-0.0261645336,
-0.0243808199,
-0.0818059966,
-0.0669412613,
-0.0129029332,
0.0302206594,
-0.0287959017,
-0.1165409535,
-0.0475653186,
-0.0389586426,
0.0206204951,
0.0249587093,
-0.0310594104,
0.0210477337,
-0.0053607491,
-0.0424733087,
-0.0007783849,
0.0200809073,
0.0283958782,
-0.0707485229,
-0.0047045387,
-0.0081317984,
-0.0475722663,
0.0146879796,
0.0112988679,
-0.0113430461,
-0.0220725033,
0.0741652921,
0.0088980226,
0.0164035186,
0.0473404154,
-0.0507455878,
-0.0485950895,
0.0736050382,
0.0236118473,
-0.0082242424,
0.0020319063,
0.0833197981,
0.0073449104,
-0.012506023,
0.0323898792,
0.0327260755,
0.0451787636,
0.06051955,
-0.0297950115,
-0.0092177503,
-0.030147789,
-0.0272835605,
-0.0340426117,
0.0448763818,
-0.0213660616,
0.0068311649,
-0.0599525198,
0.0065248995,
0.0102642197,
0.0330949761,
-0.0273751765,
0.0458688773,
0.0703332722,
-0.0037078445,
-0.047706522,
0.0251132213,
0.0086574499,
-0.0657213405,
-0.0242408942,
0.0578588285,
0.0445006825,
0.036163561,
-0.0201203711,
0.0094052115,
0.0208455827,
0.0192626659,
0.0124308765,
0.0473397598,
-0.0239283796,
-0.018281579,
-0.0172903948,
0.0156210605,
-0.0091090351,
0.0439868495,
-0.0238355137,
0.0006355831,
-0.0421062112,
-0.0166911669,
0.038679935,
0.028797457,
0.0421973914,
-0.0029035881,
-0.0064169094,
0.0043091704,
-0.0246069524,
0.0338335223,
0.0593890175,
-0.0098210014,
-0.0071295514,
-0.0096231047,
-0.0345272124,
0.0519455485,
-0.0086796712,
0.0373496562,
0.0413289219,
-0.0424598195,
-0.0270644184,
-0.0160600878,
0.020683201,
-0.0090164253,
-0.0442362353,
0.0002320488,
-0.0323002376,
-0.0399256088,
0.0482100807,
0.0160838123,
0.0102587976,
-0.0132591939,
0.0103588365,
0.0304145664,
-0.0100615788,
0.0262262113,
-0.0204522759,
-0.00915833,
0.0572326072,
-0.0664089844,
-0.0332347006,
-5.599651378e-33,
-0.0126265278,
0.0547647141,
-0.0047790534,
-0.0046914709,
-0.0024304085,
0.0222910941,
0.0001961751,
-0.0404088311,
-0.0036097558,
0.0120601151,
-0.0052210609,
0.0577335097,
0.0279585291,
0.0122160129,
0.0225523487,
0.0008254083,
0.0632235557,
0.0169334225,
-0.0328283831,
-0.0056310068,
-0.0088241175,
0.1007089391,
0.075024344,
0.0444279984,
0.0443690978,
-0.0257147066,
0.0045196684,
0.0037293767,
0.0518124178,
0.0423923768,
-0.0165159944,
0.0544850901,
0.0014593466,
-0.0288894158,
0.0114082871,
0.0663294792,
-0.0575673208,
0.0040022316,
0.0003461078,
0.0768467635,
-0.004057359,
-0.03521863,
0.0137501368,
0.0099315783,
-0.0444864407,
-0.0011145094,
0.0272973366,
-0.0323871523,
0.0315889381,
-0.041853305,
-0.0662254691,
0.0436409824,
-0.0125026414,
-0.0331884511,
0.066291213,
-0.0094959754,
-0.0114008877,
0.0256214645,
-0.0958560333,
-0.0513275452,
-0.0138514536,
0.0662034154,
-0.0107322875,
0.0020950881,
-0.0690530837,
-0.0053208545,
0.065516077,
-0.0061438195,
0.0549019389,
0.0086367028,
0.0203900244,
-0.0114652188,
0.0710248947,
0.0270400047,
0.0363099948,
-0.0017514488,
-0.0216962192,
0.0120759988,
0.0271947589,
0.0037081141,
0.0229429584,
-0.0182602871,
-0.0143413283,
-0.0020403909,
-0.0051157628,
-0.0526117198,
-0.0131782787,
0.0481750518,
0.0222060289,
0.0069293887,
-0.0151332598,
0.0245749392,
-0.0052619586,
-0.0666505024,
0.0222871918,
0.008924257,
0.0046646409,
-0.0194357727,
-0.0257286374,
0.0363956951,
0.0110582951,
-0.0404150113,
0.0264998693,
0.0033357672,
-0.0194801614,
-0.0115610044,
0.0499891974,
-0.0025371639,
-0.0800606087,
-0.0153792631,
-0.0233330652,
0.0444798842,
0.0188793018,
0.0775736868,
-0.0176882558,
0.0057825726,
0.0339595415,
0.0312954001,
0.0438849926,
-0.0376563109,
-0.0021671867,
0.0413942225,
0.0187152065,
0.0074949316,
0.009476793,
-0.0167686827,
0.0263319109,
0.0601038858,
-0.0038657465,
-0.0704579577,
0.0072267898,
0.0104239415,
2.535e-7,
0.0816537142,
0.0402290933,
0.03248059,
-0.0353637896,
0.0148923639,
0.0024238934,
0.0137726758,
0.0343009159,
0.0027367037,
0.0671498254,
0.0125563024,
0.0087219188,
0.097814247,
0.0096557811,
-0.0544573478,
-0.0670543611,
-0.0473995022,
0.0380511656,
-0.0408188552,
0.009743154,
0.0311163049,
0.0978738964,
-0.0104002059,
-0.0488006622,
0.0281500462,
-0.0495041832,
0.0214188434,
-0.0044972547,
0.0485833175,
0.0619849451,
0.08085078,
-0.0168037117,
0.0127321715,
0.0035368379,
-0.0346834809,
0.0275220014,
0.0140642459,
0.0371437222,
0.0132634863,
0.0196600929,
-0.0014409377,
-0.0240892898,
-0.0400524028,
-0.0387177505,
0.0298498888,
-0.0105537632,
0.0190952476,
0.0632663593,
-0.0553746,
-0.0221523587,
0.0432177708,
-0.0027569088,
-0.0796195641,
0.0363843106,
0.0741401762,
0.021758439,
-0.012198397,
-0.0824268758,
0.0020426675,
0.0214610081,
-0.018674124,
0.001315771,
-0.0084353788,
-0.0155524546,
0.0095672682,
-0.0411903374,
-0.000942302,
2.42683472e-34,
0.0698206723,
-0.0350018181,
0.0089394497,
0.0312429853,
0.0179612543,
0.008002039,
0.0537024736,
-0.0189329367,
-0.0178513154,
-0.036202237,
-0.0093509611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17464v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17464v2 | Efficient Tool Use with Chain-of-Abstraction Reasoning | 2024-01-30T21:53:30 | 2024-02-26T20:26:40 | Silin Gao, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Ping Yu, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Olga Golovneva, Koustuv Sinha, Asli Celikyilmaz, Antoine Bosselut, Tianlu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | To achieve faithful reasoning that aligns with human expectations, large
language models (LLMs) need to ground their reasoning to real-world knowledge
(e.g., web facts, math and physical rules). Tools help LLMs access this
external knowledge, but there remains challenges for fine-tuning LLM agents
(e.g., Toolformer) to invoke tools in multi-step reasoning problems, where
inter-connected tool calls require holistic and efficient tool usage planning.
In this work, we propose a new method for LLMs to better leverage tools in
multi-step reasoning. Our method, Chain-of-Abstraction (CoA), trains LLMs to
first decode reasoning chains with abstract placeholders, and then call domain
tools to reify each reasoning chain by filling in specific knowledge. This
planning with abstract chains enables LLMs to learn more general reasoning
strategies, which are robust to shifts of domain knowledge (e.g., math results)
relevant to different reasoning questions. It also allows LLMs to perform
decoding and calling of external tools in parallel, which avoids the inference
delay caused by waiting for tool responses. In mathematical reasoning and Wiki
QA domains, we show that our method consistently outperforms previous
chain-of-thought and tool-augmented baselines on both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution test sets, with an average ~6% absolute QA accuracy
improvement. LLM agents trained with our method also show more efficient tool
use, with inference speed being on average ~1.4x faster than baseline
tool-augmented LLMs. | [
0.0033433773,
0.0300310683,
-0.0112524433,
0.0474944226,
-0.0312298182,
0.0289933253,
0.0004703866,
-0.0223558005,
-0.0185882282,
-0.0393663347,
-0.0082024047,
0.0122971535,
-0.0247937832,
-0.0006132195,
0.0181366783,
-0.0560943522,
0.0234952699,
-0.0361228324,
-0.0159486365,
-0.0083746202,
-0.0367395319,
0.0104652708,
-0.0389913656,
0.0248742215,
-0.0074347272,
-0.0558220409,
-0.0254013371,
-0.0275692567,
0.0190248396,
-0.0218708869,
-0.0059618969,
0.0372274518,
0.033214435,
0.0299346112,
0.0000023419,
-0.0552444868,
-0.00797721,
0.0212027766,
-0.0625335127,
-0.0116316527,
-0.0554618426,
-0.0327154882,
0.0263861623,
0.0202501714,
-0.0548397377,
0.0193670131,
0.0104157282,
0.0116899693,
0.0636022985,
0.0640911236,
0.0142145734,
-0.0199435465,
0.0206619743,
-0.0104771275,
-0.0096821953,
-0.0772794485,
0.0166431908,
0.0538592674,
0.0407761708,
0.0269636288,
-0.0122129321,
0.0404913723,
0.0823293328,
-0.0076606106,
-0.0178114008,
0.0264919698,
-0.0056321868,
-0.0059917234,
0.0117783146,
0.0679890141,
-0.0155427791,
-0.0240775608,
0.0003531198,
-0.0184361599,
0.0111018168,
0.0349525884,
-0.0479494892,
0.04902751,
-0.0348893218,
-0.0125729498,
-0.0154540222,
-0.0269041117,
0.0388752259,
0.0304649789,
-0.0501617305,
0.0938599259,
-0.0211127754,
-0.011845042,
0.0271527395,
0.0259302333,
-0.0261062458,
-0.0743108392,
-0.0014669272,
0.0684497878,
-0.0267134011,
0.0456303284,
-0.0107719572,
-0.00723327,
-0.0233386103,
-0.0088205514,
0.0085427398,
0.0650362447,
0.0051277112,
0.0309638418,
-0.0378103815,
0.0099901166,
-0.0210183244,
0.0450522788,
-0.0306933764,
-0.00488747,
-0.0699798167,
-0.0112492014,
0.0032876714,
0.0583547056,
-0.0213058945,
0.0008805793,
0.0061824173,
0.0350463167,
-0.0305595975,
0.0244570915,
0.0022961979,
-0.0153148659,
0.0139235193,
-0.0446619764,
-0.0628335625,
0.0409712978,
-0.0733516142,
0.0399054959,
0.039153453,
-0.0288055632,
-0.0356145799,
-0.0101394663,
-0.0217071697,
-0.0194952004,
0.0012658074,
0.1074424461,
-0.0057320953,
0.0398141779,
-0.0491779931,
-0.0616220199,
0.0620036125,
-0.0767551735,
0.0205232427,
-0.0756841972,
0.0481750593,
0.0440002717,
-0.0237815045,
-0.018217789,
0.0097599104,
0.0202843528,
-0.0087929415,
0.0592033342,
0.0134358611,
-0.0012588048,
0.0032065546,
0.0146025689,
-0.0739071146,
0.0586695224,
0.0071546813,
0.0156874061,
-0.0088609671,
0.0224783421,
-0.0017465551,
0.0358464643,
0.017107863,
-0.0023373521,
0.0148048736,
0.0263942983,
-0.0191643294,
0.035689678,
0.0331020691,
0.0006385338,
-0.053305719,
-0.0062808222,
0.0124608176,
0.0160152614,
0.0013056063,
0.0152613679,
0.0653082952,
-0.0070578195,
0.0270608403,
0.0088424683,
-0.0992715135,
0.0369236432,
-0.0266071837,
0.0185188353,
-0.0278778039,
0.0028846764,
-0.0229747631,
-0.0526225865,
-0.017892465,
0.0175523087,
-0.0206966829,
0.0195197016,
0.0408195518,
0.0308678243,
-0.0109153623,
0.081534259,
0.0170854796,
-0.0169080663,
-0.0227232557,
-0.0483439118,
0.0148063824,
0.0298509039,
0.0404636376,
-0.0196788479,
-0.0386932567,
-0.0100125046,
0.046806138,
0.0234611444,
0.0160518792,
-0.0368418097,
-0.0149978204,
-0.0456028432,
-0.0441414416,
-0.0352446027,
0.0011795955,
0.0167055838,
0.0673060194,
-0.0075169364,
0.0137127256,
-0.077192761,
0.0230873302,
0.0340122357,
-0.0196195822,
-0.0357623734,
-0.0394111276,
0.024910748,
0.0172908194,
-0.0070886603,
0.0073040584,
0.0211063884,
-0.0108875204,
-0.0228314996,
-0.0560110286,
0.0049816966,
-0.0338859782,
-0.0190449432,
0.042783875,
-0.0246384237,
-0.0417057388,
0.0186216589,
-0.0682418346,
-0.0071029253,
0.0419631451,
0.0215411671,
0.0349022634,
-0.0101060132,
0.0007597608,
0.0283162054,
-0.031198591,
-0.0023258617,
0.0997530371,
-0.0243391879,
-0.0394883752,
0.0071182572,
0.0248115193,
-0.0053467019,
0.0162080266,
0.0465651788,
0.0089274952,
0.0014985383,
0.0181293003,
-0.0282903407,
0.018594766,
-0.0482644141,
0.0046417103,
-0.0241122302,
-0.0048566395,
-0.0176695585,
0.0308020487,
0.0071142386,
-0.0213653743,
0.0161228124,
-0.0086703952,
-0.0148500577,
0.0284250416,
-0.0323409699,
0.0131757213,
0.0084786173,
0.006811874,
-0.0002107868,
-0.0034414085,
-0.0089418422,
-0.0483671427,
0.048959583,
0.0044570216,
0.0028869179,
-0.0374666713,
0.0307033062,
-0.0423285514,
0.0082817608,
-0.0182529502,
0.017275976,
0.0311342441,
-0.0126260528,
-0.0054639168,
0.0830578282,
-0.0359770842,
0.0149046211,
0.0594100393,
0.0111738015,
-0.0835027099,
0.0347590148,
0.0068102726,
-0.0263058655,
-0.0303245503,
0.0214751028,
-0.0045122989,
0.0640834719,
-0.0205564927,
0.0078859385,
-0.029263705,
0.0139460769,
0.0143783577,
-0.0254554413,
-0.0289351735,
-0.0316684395,
-0.0032299722,
0.0549505614,
-0.008005715,
-0.0179363191,
0.082030952,
0.0081988825,
0.0009548559,
-0.0526830368,
0.0181051046,
-0.041768305,
0.0550471023,
-0.0171980727,
-0.0118187089,
-0.0152431671,
0.0025583762,
-0.0608722121,
-0.0133948326,
0.0466951169,
-0.0059933639,
0.0505356006,
-0.0731483772,
0.0173686687,
-0.0109299589,
-0.0533350222,
-0.063369073,
0.0355785936,
-0.0609884001,
0.0212356187,
-0.0473776348,
-0.0382165201,
-0.007053019,
-0.0187238008,
0.0343631282,
0.0183666497,
-0.0128195444,
-0.0129809882,
-0.0212764684,
0.033354234,
0.0332622193,
0.031172052,
0.0464955233,
-0.0480614156,
0.0415963568,
0.0471597984,
0.0476606973,
-0.0230119098,
-0.031199269,
-0.0009205133,
-0.0206013359,
-0.0375433601,
0.006797459,
0.0237168763,
0.020442808,
-0.1031112373,
0.0112305759,
0.0927180424,
0.0289217364,
-0.0102807702,
0.0030609942,
-0.0586286671,
0.0360879824,
0.0307886545,
0.0446009412,
-0.1046114266,
-0.0397283398,
0.0277437009,
0.009023658,
0.0285879672,
-0.0530618466,
0.0022821857,
-0.1332192868,
0.0247291718,
0.0078759603,
-0.0079835784,
0.0152104143,
-0.0268735997,
0.027309427,
0.0258088242,
-0.0116645098,
0.0413282141,
0.0107583152,
0.0176442061,
0.019991979,
0.0149956727,
-0.0256591626,
0.0496780872,
-0.0184258837,
-0.0102987941,
0.0220958777,
-0.0109965969,
0.0089629432,
-0.0553354062,
0.0886751637,
0.0034216125,
0.010359264,
-0.0252265334,
0.0099722501,
-0.015024269,
0.0031199052,
0.000418438,
0.0704065785,
-0.040996749,
-0.0289739519,
0.0318538062,
0.1209007427,
-0.011888423,
-0.022699343,
-0.0005608918,
-0.0057722889,
-0.0238932986,
0.0450228378,
0.0200936012,
0.0024133064,
-0.0373073556,
-0.0536440313,
-0.0773575231,
-0.0277470294,
-0.0268589407,
0.0235296134,
0.0201826766,
0.0085751563,
-0.0567488,
-0.049327895,
0.0761946738,
0.0484562069,
0.0053805537,
-0.0222657882,
0.0360980742,
0.0114258239,
-0.044612892,
0.0414121263,
-0.0630379394,
0.0214351173,
0.0276252739,
0.0117833326,
-0.0072750356,
-0.0265832115,
-0.0248003304,
0.0437111668,
-0.0458040573,
-0.0505117886,
-0.0379447304,
0.048512768,
0.0288819764,
0.0614254586,
-0.0215706509,
-0.0092025306,
0.004872221,
0.0012339917,
-0.0453569852,
0.0031665845,
0.0279615987,
0.0165565051,
0.0097179487,
0.0521815382,
-0.0429980494,
0.0044975742,
-0.0107803065,
0.0591944084,
-0.0218552183,
-0.0066769109,
0.0295193344,
0.0088659516,
-0.0463499799,
0.0317927375,
0.0148744443,
-0.002282168,
0.0573503524,
0.0036136257,
-0.0243606642,
-0.014017744,
0.0237304065,
-0.0251132734,
-0.0150687741,
0.0202451292,
-0.0181052051,
0.0494980179,
0.0361018069,
0.0286171697,
0.0078518474,
-0.0020854753,
0.0423759185,
0.0311807282,
-0.0221087132,
-0.0048405589,
-0.0172512215,
-0.0012621775,
0.0643238053,
-0.0394909382,
0.0575633571,
0.0468854941,
0.0083327098,
-0.0666207373,
-0.029964285,
-0.051225584,
-0.1227788925,
0.0250114501,
-0.0162574109,
0.0104387933,
-0.0052061779,
0.005078271,
-0.0513708517,
-0.0164018665,
0.0306178443,
0.016038917,
0.0077564269,
-0.0077272342,
0.026837863,
0.0443583988,
0.0116958497,
-0.0377806164,
0.0378778428,
-0.0524124242,
0.0568006225,
-0.017180616,
0.0068127313,
-0.0418395624,
-0.0538161248,
-0.051115796,
-0.001689074,
0.0068054381,
-0.0227573272,
-0.0738416836,
-0.1053999439,
-0.0353028663,
0.011177931,
-0.0413040444,
0.0032250329,
0.0320094973,
0.0659058839,
0.013054451,
-0.0425978042,
0.0077948654,
0.0079101771,
-0.0175838489,
-0.0287710149,
-0.0175325591,
-6.229015095e-33,
-0.020310238,
-0.0283486694,
0.0654719844,
0.0191207621,
-0.0055961274,
-0.0092676934,
-0.0573389009,
-0.0095385993,
-0.0348279588,
0.0207672007,
-0.0084981313,
0.0212247185,
0.0105396947,
-0.0130023938,
0.0209060814,
-0.0046157185,
0.0168324951,
-0.0078362497,
-0.0389242023,
-0.0167625155,
0.017864218,
0.0075468207,
0.0459010713,
-0.0669065639,
-0.0027291635,
0.0147489458,
0.0067144316,
0.0326942466,
-0.0514658466,
0.0493199304,
0.0099865412,
0.0019361309,
0.0207461379,
-0.026762709,
-0.0063351002,
-0.0072881295,
-0.1044981256,
-0.0235949103,
0.0287363585,
0.0042354441,
-0.0555484928,
-0.0342271924,
0.052745752,
0.0219866671,
0.0080497973,
-0.0537464842,
0.0119658569,
-0.0237385277,
0.0112486854,
0.0027406176,
-0.0588304698,
0.013951147,
-0.0152286757,
-0.0271659102,
-0.0062010004,
0.0190049112,
-0.0061198128,
-0.0049335635,
-0.0432024933,
-0.0045558428,
0.0243986938,
-0.0048103519,
0.084508948,
-0.0162331015,
-0.0106590092,
0.0504183359,
0.0100181717,
-0.0323589407,
-0.0353063457,
0.0207865499,
0.026377229,
0.068657577,
0.0274153985,
0.0037840086,
-0.0053791599,
0.044655297,
-0.0662372783,
0.0257896241,
0.0027949729,
0.0872618333,
0.0135754729,
0.0059988135,
-0.035596136,
0.0082920771,
-0.0597837418,
0.0218341835,
-0.0403546505,
-0.0400795788,
0.035003338,
-0.0100031272,
-0.0112672746,
-0.0161427893,
0.0024290325,
-0.026509244,
-0.020948492,
0.0381349549,
-0.0032022104,
0.0269436892,
0.0001713395,
0.0351490751,
-0.0412081741,
0.0064885314,
-0.0043210541,
-0.0068071461,
0.0277889855,
0.0054159714,
0.0231834147,
0.0111756232,
-0.048672162,
-0.0241796095,
-0.0864010453,
-0.0042955359,
0.0197861008,
0.0399802849,
0.044513911,
0.0483585708,
-0.0078581506,
0.0248561054,
-0.0367455184,
-0.045344431,
-0.0318618976,
0.0656007007,
0.0025521205,
0.0121790022,
-0.024481792,
-0.0140465247,
-0.0229286645,
0.0042241337,
0.0475434773,
-0.0673350617,
0.0043238103,
0.035379786,
3.006e-7,
0.0473012328,
0.0329038166,
0.0107936542,
0.0660870299,
0.0006438391,
0.0245622899,
-0.0191502515,
-0.0211167894,
0.027768448,
-0.0653772354,
-0.0000706828,
0.0809763372,
0.0220723189,
0.0420685224,
-0.0757931173,
0.006252286,
-0.0005609097,
-0.0393831506,
-0.0614131875,
-0.0212327875,
0.0308538917,
0.0589044988,
0.0307405274,
-0.0176701192,
0.0066600079,
-0.0384268835,
0.0452799276,
0.0122829052,
0.0057852292,
-0.00131602,
-0.0362108871,
0.0050744913,
0.0447309874,
0.0427867807,
0.0135483192,
0.0351735316,
-0.0141922478,
0.0730784312,
0.0139054721,
-0.0088015189,
-0.0516267121,
-0.054358609,
0.0238147099,
-0.0363037027,
0.0703017041,
-0.0602055266,
-0.0267097522,
0.0116071301,
0.0069801719,
-0.0282498766,
-0.0529862307,
0.0175212864,
0.0355215594,
0.0216280296,
-0.0056261686,
0.0016468697,
0.0058820751,
-0.0691599697,
-0.037859831,
0.0479241014,
-0.0231413916,
-0.0596766435,
-0.027346354,
-0.0218190998,
0.0149316834,
-0.0492477156,
-0.0244934615,
2.91424932e-34,
0.0198229626,
-0.0147683453,
0.0430549569,
0.0969112813,
0.0463405736,
-0.0057515348,
-0.0085161673,
0.027324561,
0.0342627764,
-0.0851788819,
-0.0230683219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17461v1 | Synthetic Dialogue Dataset Generation using LLM Agents | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | Yelaman Abdullin, Diego Molla-Aliod, Bahadorreza Ofoghi, John Yearwood, Qingyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Linear programming (LP) problems are pervasive in real-life applications.
However, despite their apparent simplicity, an untrained user may find it
difficult to determine the linear model of their specific problem. We envisage
the creation of a goal-oriented conversational agent that will engage in
conversation with the user to elicit all information required so that a
subsequent agent can generate the linear model. In this paper, we present an
approach for the generation of sample dialogues that can be used to develop and
train such a conversational agent. Using prompt engineering, we develop two
agents that "talk" to each other, one acting as the conversational agent, and
the other acting as the user. Using a set of text descriptions of linear
problems from NL4Opt available to the user only, the agent and the user engage
in conversation until the agent has retrieved all key information from the
original problem description. We also propose an extrinsic evaluation of the
dialogues by assessing how well the summaries generated by the dialogues match
the original problem descriptions. We conduct human and automatic evaluations,
including an evaluation approach that uses GPT-4 to mimic the human evaluation
metrics. The evaluation results show an overall good quality of the dialogues,
though research is still needed to improve the quality of the GPT-4 evaluation
metrics. The resulting dialogues, including the human annotations of a subset,
are available to the research community. The conversational agent used for the
generation of the dialogues can be used as a baseline. | [
0.0315374024,
0.0263596941,
-0.037414372,
0.0636661723,
-0.016888123,
0.0090779178,
-0.0076425751,
-0.006350758,
0.0171991624,
-0.0240548011,
0.0149503397,
0.0231794566,
-0.024657663,
0.0485100895,
0.011437417,
-0.0734265074,
0.0013671718,
0.007074005,
-0.0025497836,
0.0158791207,
0.0245871432,
-0.0066926274,
-0.0338479578,
0.0318910554,
-0.0358033404,
-0.0007463124,
-0.050001204,
0.0049939947,
0.0228956379,
-0.0126813231,
-0.0066798129,
0.0354412198,
0.0375147685,
-0.0202570502,
0.0000023175,
-0.0559328385,
-0.0108773196,
-0.0091941608,
-0.0482630357,
-0.0318535827,
0.0231472068,
0.0361011662,
0.0121821193,
0.0107903834,
-0.0491089374,
0.039891962,
0.0321232378,
0.0374558754,
0.1102500558,
0.0764734149,
-0.0024133699,
-0.0098326718,
0.0089785317,
0.0274076946,
0.0328272246,
-0.0557699539,
-0.0069664363,
0.0485110469,
0.0366292186,
0.0037543122,
0.0194500182,
-0.0111712962,
0.0262699574,
-0.0140827363,
0.022002425,
-0.0053550065,
-0.0572787747,
0.0077167181,
-0.040346995,
0.0869033188,
0.0521543175,
0.0092995223,
0.0306645222,
-0.0245688055,
0.0467660874,
-0.0114088571,
-0.0293681007,
0.0214394275,
-0.0403970703,
-0.0059528826,
-0.0588645078,
-0.0134339137,
-0.0222708154,
-0.0295587461,
0.0027276804,
0.0534129068,
-0.0157135427,
-0.0380636901,
0.0063806134,
-0.0196984466,
0.0069786892,
-0.04806716,
-0.0022969574,
0.0465541147,
-0.0683737472,
0.0283793919,
-0.018359676,
0.0153444419,
-0.0046651671,
-0.0495586544,
0.0512564033,
0.0450833514,
0.0112279048,
-0.0029293122,
-0.0043384186,
0.0905782729,
0.0029477943,
0.008013092,
-0.0381207466,
0.0406393856,
-0.072358571,
0.0060225874,
-0.0614074022,
0.0710535944,
-0.0574312024,
0.0299228467,
-0.0305921938,
0.0721775368,
-0.0139988996,
0.0348842479,
-0.0321086496,
-0.0019826884,
0.0064219763,
-0.0054435558,
-0.0815333128,
-0.0301884804,
-0.0403927118,
-0.0146366619,
-0.0065411311,
-0.066631943,
0.0001307836,
0.0352820605,
-0.0166572612,
-0.0001537206,
-0.0189074557,
0.1073254943,
-0.0114328517,
0.0195290595,
-0.0422155112,
-0.0554306135,
0.0264132451,
-0.0539072454,
-0.0642323196,
-0.0622265004,
0.0322078653,
-0.011376448,
-0.037897937,
-0.0179921482,
0.0049067959,
0.0236672629,
0.0261016134,
0.0784452185,
-0.0405263528,
0.0095892074,
0.065072991,
0.012216947,
-0.0354986414,
0.0466632731,
0.0351588726,
0.0283455234,
0.0347639285,
-0.0192379784,
0.0308209136,
0.030437246,
0.0051675714,
-0.0138249313,
0.01112328,
0.0561966039,
0.0105520841,
0.0335438512,
-0.0390405729,
0.0443438739,
-0.0490373075,
0.0296220891,
0.0230205916,
0.0599188395,
0.0184177887,
0.0398170575,
0.0487861782,
0.0495409109,
0.0011813204,
0.0160969701,
-0.0044441321,
0.0316666774,
-0.0194031056,
-0.0058298898,
0.0322720483,
-0.0202511996,
-0.0272620432,
-0.0788674727,
-0.0009169625,
0.014615804,
0.0118660936,
-0.0021015287,
0.0008270249,
-0.0167099256,
-0.0658437163,
0.0491625257,
0.0034396385,
-0.0825330839,
-0.0412502624,
-0.0318818986,
0.0288720056,
0.0874461234,
0.0327961147,
-0.0245891791,
-0.0409494936,
0.000124438,
0.0197403263,
0.0219674259,
0.0781916454,
-0.0269721467,
-0.0298668146,
-0.0429698266,
-0.0259246975,
-0.032986369,
-0.0182375442,
0.0195057839,
-0.0026823576,
-0.0159797464,
0.0243772473,
0.0272767637,
-0.0414605699,
0.0293130632,
-0.0521375984,
-0.018933326,
0.0427900739,
0.0062605613,
0.0339492224,
0.0477928668,
-0.0087103816,
0.0220517702,
0.0383466668,
0.0031213067,
-0.0361318439,
0.0165503938,
-0.0049725394,
-0.0053254417,
0.0403081998,
-0.0691328421,
-0.0003754461,
0.010922377,
-0.0277540497,
-0.0316020735,
0.0182978231,
-0.0610228702,
-0.014668881,
-0.0502087586,
-0.0024509814,
0.0139821526,
-0.0286140814,
-0.0432614461,
0.0601940379,
0.0339240842,
0.012725723,
0.0340349935,
0.0498960428,
0.0419888943,
-0.0884306207,
0.0199548025,
0.0108918538,
0.0187033024,
0.0140731586,
0.0080635166,
0.0376647338,
-0.0401888005,
-0.0152342599,
-0.0812726766,
0.0132745821,
0.0132236863,
0.01845113,
0.0342460088,
-0.0243983939,
-0.0170591511,
-0.0275012534,
-0.0854339972,
0.0159577541,
0.0168480556,
-0.0126695344,
0.0753420517,
0.0431024581,
-0.0325581878,
-0.0228832327,
0.0237804763,
-0.0155732157,
0.0023653135,
0.0375467129,
-0.0089388201,
-0.0681644306,
0.0334979668,
-0.0222808756,
0.0053392476,
-0.0211401898,
-0.0062248078,
0.0161950234,
0.0021573813,
0.0059636082,
0.0113054402,
0.0061316928,
0.0640605018,
0.0118739242,
-0.0259885397,
-0.0628285483,
0.0441565104,
-0.0204885621,
-0.0056561646,
0.0061909254,
-0.035229139,
0.0459117815,
0.0133960377,
0.0254483093,
0.0254826955,
-0.0372758247,
0.0385483317,
0.0543659553,
0.0008737575,
-0.0415010303,
-0.025743857,
-0.0295096934,
0.0875223577,
-0.0070969001,
-0.0429339558,
0.0786378309,
-0.0137030678,
-0.012090967,
-0.0341588706,
-0.0347730815,
-0.0593768582,
0.0220790207,
-0.021904422,
-0.0091747344,
-0.0433894098,
0.006129229,
-0.0122382771,
-0.0286538508,
0.0229879282,
-0.0247526504,
0.0711772889,
-0.0906782746,
0.0043412382,
-0.0070526316,
-0.0290119275,
-0.0532168373,
-0.0303911492,
0.0102937631,
-0.0194541495,
0.0277766809,
-0.0097309416,
0.0020728093,
-0.0007354695,
0.0031821756,
0.026893599,
-0.0240834765,
-0.0115632052,
-0.0136718201,
-0.0264851637,
-0.0008260644,
0.0472913124,
-0.0130753014,
-0.020052094,
0.0786301717,
0.0219932124,
-0.0206316486,
-0.0028011717,
-0.0385589525,
0.0028587822,
-0.004031959,
-0.0125411451,
0.0096154455,
0.0375850089,
0.0292074755,
-0.029797392,
-0.0044263289,
0.0958995149,
0.0407431312,
-0.0517709218,
-0.0132845324,
-0.0409681313,
0.0086742956,
0.012742836,
0.0466240905,
-0.0865501389,
-0.0060564922,
-0.0340944231,
0.0472035371,
-0.0411122926,
-0.0477993935,
-0.0433921926,
-0.1017379984,
0.0521116108,
-0.0081785414,
-0.0200751144,
-0.0016653965,
-0.0172444042,
-0.020751344,
-0.0173846204,
0.0044763801,
0.0213984475,
0.023031719,
0.0098407678,
0.0095114298,
-0.0329493061,
-0.0010029078,
0.0110673448,
0.0334279761,
0.0343324468,
0.0575297289,
0.0298555233,
0.0040001078,
-0.0399747118,
0.0576885305,
0.0672175288,
0.0139261065,
-0.0083887065,
0.0431516692,
-0.0178288259,
-0.0107709374,
-0.006471517,
0.0490064658,
-0.0478368998,
0.0011362605,
0.0649784431,
0.0224120449,
-0.0503193475,
0.0529336855,
-0.0109903431,
0.0412953794,
0.0237080827,
0.045677878,
0.0340261534,
-0.0089926282,
-0.0141233094,
-0.0565696135,
-0.0182203148,
-0.0362257212,
-0.0226561539,
-0.010097974,
-0.0273277201,
0.0314849243,
-0.0538923293,
-0.0518421493,
0.049889762,
0.0230254773,
-0.0059690881,
-0.033710748,
-0.0135671617,
0.0351499878,
-0.0250489153,
0.0178095177,
-0.0011669402,
0.0203576256,
-0.0144042382,
-0.0220723934,
0.0165215377,
-0.0772824064,
-0.0103517966,
0.0485730357,
-0.0660880432,
-0.051349137,
-0.0606530495,
0.0494255014,
0.0275044274,
0.0358815826,
0.0066362959,
0.0070774155,
-0.026627643,
0.0430720486,
-0.0081815002,
-0.0267339386,
-0.0227491502,
0.0941857249,
-0.0010191618,
0.0034100839,
-0.0402711071,
0.0196689684,
-0.0249724984,
-0.0038279716,
-0.0456280932,
-0.0915924236,
0.0403335504,
0.0386947617,
-0.0232959501,
0.015055743,
-0.0627363473,
-0.0154277664,
0.0322679393,
-0.0474853367,
-0.0440934896,
-0.0622117519,
0.0075425766,
-0.0449876375,
-0.0182859898,
0.0757609606,
-0.0441784486,
-0.0713312924,
0.0364679992,
-0.0064299316,
0.0263624396,
0.0094638821,
-0.0039708619,
-0.0006380986,
-0.0097627509,
-0.0141703608,
0.0066976026,
0.0056178789,
0.0367989466,
0.0339527726,
0.0729790106,
0.0307699777,
0.0270909853,
0.0363587365,
0.0186986439,
-0.0456731245,
-0.0598466732,
-0.028782554,
0.0009569656,
-0.002710009,
0.0381249823,
-0.0074576321,
-0.0352365971,
0.0109719029,
-0.0014162889,
0.0423542485,
-0.0036324165,
-0.0123310219,
0.0397793837,
0.0368689224,
-0.0009394691,
-0.0736997426,
0.0482893363,
-0.0124569265,
-0.0024784994,
-0.0336086787,
-0.0268743448,
-0.085772723,
-0.0192533601,
0.0190835465,
0.0103083216,
0.0100526391,
-0.0319343209,
-0.064692013,
-0.0332425013,
-0.0319352038,
0.0379674956,
0.014437275,
-0.0160715226,
0.0770678744,
0.0359112807,
-0.0021508571,
0.0170971807,
-0.0227322504,
0.0113984151,
-0.0464225821,
-0.0199128222,
-0.038099017,
-5.675869697e-33,
-0.0441580527,
-0.0730969086,
0.0522324331,
0.0713304132,
-0.0237140935,
-0.0393645316,
-0.0258560944,
0.0454710312,
0.0018688703,
-0.0193877127,
0.0121282749,
-0.0245972089,
-0.0058431122,
-0.022217622,
-0.0103466483,
-0.0229688175,
0.0183285866,
-0.0112098902,
-0.0370925255,
0.0104725212,
0.0144991912,
-0.0074112988,
0.0161903687,
-0.0620539114,
0.0600241534,
-0.0355729237,
-0.0129749142,
0.0329043157,
-0.0077612139,
0.0461283177,
-0.0120625813,
0.0521385781,
0.0277399458,
-0.0309040863,
-0.0370506309,
0.0267806407,
0.0108082052,
-0.0631204844,
0.0480440669,
-0.0121031553,
-0.029115973,
-0.0330829434,
0.0313633494,
-0.0078147948,
-0.0685335472,
0.0129949218,
0.0411385074,
-0.0233937111,
0.0284436271,
0.0299457442,
-0.0326972865,
0.0307396259,
-0.0501558371,
-0.0449461825,
0.0159143619,
0.0253987797,
-0.0131131215,
-0.0231607594,
0.0209033173,
0.047131367,
0.0495659895,
-0.0242384374,
0.0451863967,
-0.0132378256,
0.0000885603,
0.0193342697,
0.0376078598,
0.0316742659,
-0.0672181547,
-0.019144468,
-0.0474458151,
0.0493693985,
0.035735067,
0.0759961382,
0.0105600981,
0.0103996415,
-0.0088880872,
0.0698003322,
0.0179050285,
-0.0181994773,
0.0019998476,
-0.0081672864,
-0.0142711187,
-0.0097611519,
-0.0445324183,
0.0212434754,
-0.0243180376,
-0.0551593155,
0.0224315897,
-0.0283189565,
0.043271672,
-0.0239963457,
-0.0147645921,
-0.0221690498,
0.0193719435,
-0.0159821082,
-0.0417086966,
-0.0002385536,
-0.0019420949,
-0.0284069218,
-0.0391084962,
-0.0122111281,
0.0191782564,
0.0559652857,
0.0403999761,
0.0111582046,
-0.0094625112,
-0.0086963167,
-0.0196329914,
0.0222228449,
-0.0578293763,
0.0412935689,
-0.0157172624,
0.0325825438,
-0.0244885813,
-0.005948443,
-0.0382729918,
0.0732198358,
-0.050054431,
-0.0509136394,
-0.0422321446,
-0.0114466343,
0.0095687397,
-0.003651005,
-0.0225228909,
0.006415369,
0.0054422156,
0.0528833941,
0.0502112098,
-0.001243448,
0.0041174903,
-0.0140260737,
2.873e-7,
0.0045616352,
0.0065927589,
0.0544430614,
0.0370617099,
0.0126173189,
0.0309256408,
-0.0205141995,
0.024269864,
-0.0062233242,
-0.0406820178,
0.0362656601,
0.0202111974,
0.0471012369,
0.028422853,
-0.0815978423,
-0.017763136,
-0.0235071406,
-0.0455610715,
-0.0582154319,
0.0290425401,
0.1492919028,
-0.0027899873,
0.0072994116,
0.0067617223,
-0.0207068417,
0.0089551546,
0.0161598567,
-0.0488459915,
-0.0237151757,
0.0137927914,
0.0123274624,
-0.0187240168,
0.0020351182,
0.0500308014,
0.0047024041,
0.0085337106,
-0.0021051969,
0.0681536794,
0.0150165521,
-0.0757329464,
0.0247783847,
0.0154930362,
0.008140116,
-0.0126104075,
0.0077987406,
-0.0105084358,
-0.0303496998,
0.0051832744,
-0.0104706297,
-0.0363336839,
-0.0189116001,
-0.0487725921,
0.0226463508,
0.0105182556,
0.0023848379,
-0.0258152001,
0.0480019972,
-0.0299795698,
0.0095517049,
-0.0135572525,
-0.0732112527,
-0.0622848906,
-0.0305431392,
0.0214761123,
0.0140607078,
-0.0220129788,
0.0189678241,
2.459560299e-34,
0.0301127806,
0.0203149244,
0.0200143494,
0.0346786268,
0.0464211479,
0.0232752208,
0.0062738466,
0.0265343711,
0.038076736,
-0.0444655828,
-0.0163820237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17435v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17435v3 | Can Large Language Models Replace Economic Choice Prediction Labs? | 2024-01-30T20:49:47 | 2024-03-07T16:47:00 | Eilam Shapira, Omer Madmon, Roi Reichart, Moshe Tennenholtz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.HC | Economic choice prediction is an essential challenging task, often
constrained by the difficulties in acquiring human choice data. Indeed,
experimental economics studies had focused mostly on simple choice settings.
The AI community has recently contributed to that effort in two ways:
considering whether LLMs can substitute for humans in the above-mentioned
simple choice prediction settings, and the study through ML lens of more
elaborated but still rigorous experimental economics settings, employing
incomplete information, repetitive play, and natural language communication,
notably language-based persuasion games. This leaves us with a major
inspiration: can LLMs be used to fully simulate the economic environment and
generate data for efficient human choice prediction, substituting for the
elaborated economic lab studies? We pioneer the study of this subject,
demonstrating its feasibility. In particular, we show that a model trained
solely on LLM-generated data can effectively predict human behavior in a
language-based persuasion game, and can even outperform models trained on
actual human data. | [
0.0298340265,
0.1036725044,
-0.0342428945,
0.030327633,
-0.0142607307,
-0.007272582,
0.0075532254,
0.0216337349,
0.0420509093,
-0.0059482027,
-0.0246854443,
-0.0146102803,
0.0122532416,
0.0403793193,
0.0397916958,
-0.0212929137,
-0.0014890411,
-0.0302812215,
0.0384808183,
-0.0482794754,
-0.0290880017,
-0.0304536447,
0.0033873171,
0.0295186508,
0.012339578,
0.0127721773,
-0.0338370577,
-0.0506897941,
-0.0038413885,
-0.0396624804,
0.0051867366,
0.0323595107,
0.0498139672,
-0.0089789387,
0.0000018807,
-0.0455802456,
0.0165180862,
-0.0400900729,
-0.0602192283,
-0.007127326,
0.075899668,
0.0430309288,
0.0307725407,
0.0070666056,
-0.0670648217,
0.0477959588,
0.0505619459,
0.0069067851,
0.0300479792,
0.041213505,
0.0041528125,
-0.024710536,
0.0047514006,
-0.0453638434,
0.0092732431,
-0.0292358603,
0.0328871645,
-0.0486338921,
0.008294859,
-0.0088843256,
-0.0144489063,
-0.0162352864,
-0.0053495304,
0.0076907896,
-0.0417005122,
0.0669479817,
-0.0290425774,
0.0019720022,
-0.0250023864,
0.045972459,
0.0087050088,
-0.0169767961,
0.0287523381,
-0.0034843446,
0.0406286754,
0.008595041,
-0.0195921585,
0.0262096506,
0.0215045791,
0.0530705787,
0.0310804117,
0.0085067721,
0.0422218591,
0.0431063436,
0.0144257396,
0.0880135968,
-0.0352345631,
-0.0362946428,
0.0289182551,
0.0382962078,
0.0076249414,
-0.0651300922,
-0.0416734107,
-0.0039566206,
-0.0707112774,
0.0131408954,
0.0011526449,
0.0353559405,
0.0016206509,
-0.0624446124,
0.0521552637,
0.0369982347,
0.0175262596,
0.0176745392,
0.0311726574,
0.0493693948,
0.0062146252,
0.000927206,
-0.0116745317,
0.0287098158,
-0.0180102997,
0.0067565655,
-0.01790113,
0.0260566548,
-0.0226103794,
0.0005841152,
-0.0531197824,
-0.0079783536,
-0.0682068616,
0.0558368303,
-0.0245747995,
0.0460950062,
-0.0189477764,
-0.0074285492,
-0.1053599119,
-0.0175312832,
-0.0340802968,
0.034806978,
0.0305251703,
-0.0090573821,
0.0259992797,
0.0179617349,
-0.028309362,
-0.0125106238,
0.0541942753,
0.1129494533,
0.024618743,
0.0138931582,
-0.0239799917,
0.0022136329,
0.0049910001,
-0.0773196891,
-0.0012632309,
-0.055802308,
0.0393232033,
-0.0044669504,
0.0006948736,
-0.0697003454,
0.0035499388,
-0.0056979824,
-0.048613023,
0.0895063356,
0.046378389,
-0.0031759257,
0.0066312151,
-0.0191944428,
-0.0141240954,
0.0547395088,
0.0328952149,
0.0622119419,
0.0324871764,
-0.0259352978,
0.0410316996,
0.0603733957,
-0.0003262143,
0.0121820327,
-0.0451880097,
-0.0133984778,
-0.0411474556,
0.0433762856,
0.0215582699,
0.0345016494,
-0.0199633129,
-0.0282818154,
0.0953801349,
0.057971172,
0.0131203914,
0.0101805404,
0.008181016,
0.0480501875,
-0.001063825,
0.01759886,
-0.0222983472,
0.0043330039,
-0.0247030705,
0.0005025669,
0.0169215519,
-0.008432094,
-0.0236593895,
-0.0342488997,
0.0351484157,
-0.0515384339,
0.059083946,
0.0545257404,
0.0250417273,
-0.06148839,
-0.0404027067,
0.0265082959,
0.0776404366,
0.0110359685,
-0.019408334,
-0.0627384186,
0.066646494,
0.0808429495,
0.0258562341,
-0.0161380749,
0.0493653901,
-0.0325459428,
-0.0426632836,
0.0600456931,
0.078767173,
-0.039660465,
0.0005722503,
-0.0208724085,
-0.007766482,
-0.0023591234,
0.0174924806,
0.0652893186,
0.0211979635,
-0.0352272056,
-0.0315290578,
0.0174786299,
-0.0062104333,
0.0136436317,
-0.0411299765,
-0.0480012074,
0.0010665499,
-0.0114665162,
0.0593625717,
-0.0190648194,
-0.0080606109,
-0.0034400194,
0.0136871999,
-0.0046805157,
-0.0224675946,
-0.0144083351,
0.0000788164,
-0.00607544,
0.0158123728,
-0.0004286537,
-0.0131141767,
0.0076885507,
-0.0220602136,
0.0123841539,
0.0028116987,
-0.0120621035,
0.060709741,
-0.0054888381,
-0.0114455335,
-0.0202054922,
-0.0085467473,
-0.0267276503,
0.0529713109,
-0.0013961071,
-0.0107940091,
-0.0008750067,
-0.0309914425,
-0.0366433561,
-0.0787069723,
0.0319948681,
0.0152687915,
0.0275095329,
0.0402563959,
0.0404740088,
-0.0024090637,
-0.0285820216,
-0.0245692618,
-0.0590021722,
-0.0290562045,
0.0251187887,
-0.0118151875,
-0.0177081171,
-0.0564363599,
-0.0123100402,
0.01119164,
-0.0503010191,
0.0239554942,
0.0363698304,
0.0284850709,
0.030720856,
0.0179120246,
-0.0025189572,
-0.0331699811,
0.0053440966,
-0.0039718705,
0.0499951765,
0.0167595875,
0.0075542065,
-0.0472869352,
-0.0009208674,
-0.0112500964,
0.0191367231,
-0.0244221371,
-0.0208420549,
-0.0045615584,
-0.0066007632,
0.0262750853,
0.0547371246,
0.014361213,
0.038364049,
0.0555592552,
0.0025185975,
-0.0817995667,
0.0085092112,
-0.0388922803,
0.0026523485,
-0.0931489691,
-0.0451715626,
0.0185930338,
0.0691349879,
-0.0052481587,
0.0206900444,
-0.0053895032,
0.0676402003,
0.0314372107,
-0.0570243932,
-0.0571076386,
0.0002032542,
-0.048941303,
0.0534036867,
0.0047788108,
-0.0553257465,
0.076760754,
0.0072917645,
0.0056214798,
0.0173978433,
-0.0216630101,
-0.0147640454,
0.01239827,
0.0149582718,
-0.0241004042,
-0.0237379055,
0.0194768757,
-0.0414688401,
-0.0529097319,
0.0250362139,
-0.0232196953,
0.0521379933,
-0.0497768596,
-0.0059411698,
0.0247957129,
-0.0605132729,
-0.0464207977,
-0.0799440965,
-0.0590340607,
-0.0143329129,
0.0384394638,
-0.0294707362,
-0.0419131629,
-0.0383983515,
0.0202024635,
-0.0125955613,
0.0147087378,
-0.0154248197,
0.0240264796,
0.0203393381,
0.0493565649,
0.0284283422,
-0.0046203788,
-0.0649384037,
0.0153999329,
0.0173324719,
-0.0249891579,
-0.0003453981,
-0.0125619881,
0.0185666271,
0.0305264741,
-0.006471158,
0.025244277,
0.0818168223,
-0.0394781083,
-0.0291037243,
0.0113254767,
0.0792888626,
0.0055994936,
-0.0251961406,
0.0075145736,
-0.0001791951,
0.0412660763,
-0.0004112056,
0.0300566535,
-0.0675748959,
-0.02396111,
0.020165557,
0.0383901484,
-0.0213253237,
-0.0386055522,
0.0009838636,
-0.1216689199,
0.0270499028,
-0.0128174946,
0.0007837255,
0.0030790439,
-0.0406165868,
-0.0197621398,
-0.0753824934,
0.0128369322,
-0.0217316207,
0.0116545605,
0.0006122941,
-0.007133401,
-0.0206629578,
-0.0080485987,
0.0417878143,
-0.0143789761,
0.0454060733,
0.0553265624,
0.0625708103,
-0.0512840673,
-0.0122920889,
0.0087068379,
0.0475183651,
-0.0188875142,
0.011470234,
0.0552130342,
0.0076323329,
0.0052578216,
-0.0076718675,
0.0413902178,
0.0178141147,
-0.0223179404,
0.0367168263,
0.0082568042,
-0.0082970634,
-0.0716910958,
0.0646549091,
-0.0063626515,
0.0453892648,
0.0743120089,
0.0085125659,
-0.093896769,
-0.0253832042,
-0.0668764859,
-0.049635224,
-0.009178794,
-0.0745779723,
-0.0364419743,
0.010920641,
0.0271437056,
-0.0376367569,
-0.0522905327,
-0.0072953091,
-0.0122752711,
0.0126806656,
0.0021117667,
0.0235377885,
0.0191013999,
0.035529092,
0.0262783561,
-0.0497269221,
0.0001846503,
-0.033179041,
-0.0154897291,
-0.000618284,
-0.0775877759,
-0.0253153779,
0.0006184505,
-0.0203710254,
-0.0811567903,
0.0108016096,
0.0704641193,
0.02749696,
0.0561100803,
0.0299161561,
-0.0016926148,
0.007655072,
0.0351433158,
-0.0223092604,
0.0072256788,
0.0538159944,
0.0468764938,
-0.0042526331,
0.0217357781,
-0.0149942301,
0.0410901718,
0.0216498654,
0.0118805524,
-0.0632671788,
-0.0509211421,
0.0322571546,
-0.0103142019,
0.0348763503,
-0.0522246957,
-0.0097924694,
-0.0085356757,
0.0001869096,
0.0117965005,
-0.0164011624,
-0.0103914021,
-0.0822829828,
0.0404098593,
0.0122213447,
0.0242184959,
-0.0242913961,
-0.0309917945,
0.0070392638,
0.0065845111,
0.037977431,
0.0260586385,
0.0337395445,
0.0569047183,
-0.0059695961,
0.0169914905,
0.0374251008,
-0.008983301,
0.0623203963,
0.0306485035,
0.0349485278,
0.0340751931,
-0.0317960568,
0.0149515616,
-0.0351136401,
0.0038810978,
-0.0604758672,
-0.000048404,
0.0242708493,
0.0195696428,
-0.0475766696,
0.0005139589,
-0.0586007088,
-0.0238360204,
-0.0197788924,
0.0012105859,
-0.0438748486,
-0.0513278656,
0.0031438957,
0.0055560432,
-0.0677465051,
0.0143563105,
0.0755006298,
0.0391588472,
0.0318750367,
-0.0248183552,
-0.0018436079,
-0.029933922,
-0.0254026279,
0.0201096553,
-0.0187301822,
-0.0182619616,
-0.0001641417,
-0.0630021691,
-0.0374135263,
-0.0330107585,
0.0375219062,
-0.0031262445,
-0.0416122936,
0.022550242,
0.0113539444,
-0.0225477759,
0.089677535,
-0.0392524227,
0.059974283,
-0.0255321972,
-0.0255938042,
-0.0719621032,
-5.523573384e-33,
0.0170783941,
-0.0557374246,
0.0353405476,
-0.0097616799,
0.0312567912,
-0.0233079661,
-0.031681478,
0.0081426455,
-0.0043931096,
0.0195471887,
-0.0073307469,
-0.0423069634,
0.0137427486,
-0.0011966005,
0.0253830589,
-0.0396083631,
0.0218623728,
-0.0196736362,
-0.0365944989,
-0.0176333152,
-0.0169100612,
0.0033744897,
0.0318361335,
-0.0481306612,
0.0166024044,
-0.0091849612,
-0.0088982759,
0.0072608455,
-0.017361382,
0.0377405062,
-0.011374292,
0.0321068875,
0.0085484805,
-0.0515432432,
-0.0076594474,
0.031620618,
-0.0207480229,
-0.0222505853,
-0.0076385788,
-0.055964265,
0.0009924546,
0.0007729623,
0.0040299399,
0.0019775599,
-0.0434029028,
0.0304496661,
0.0265960116,
-0.044898577,
-0.0064267395,
0.0282563884,
-0.026033245,
-0.0042338702,
-0.018684702,
0.0086569823,
0.0323319957,
0.0943350121,
-0.0156791806,
0.0412230305,
-0.0165602677,
0.0889257416,
0.0273470525,
-0.0388265885,
0.0266811904,
-0.0224025659,
0.0385134146,
0.0557993352,
0.0424703769,
-0.0047968235,
-0.0422014408,
-0.0299152099,
0.0035559041,
0.0597439073,
0.0418616943,
0.0578145757,
0.0058758138,
-0.0292212516,
-0.0101437066,
0.0260818396,
0.0819254816,
-0.0156520419,
0.0008541255,
0.023896344,
-0.0356366299,
-0.0585009716,
-0.0472931787,
-0.0365355164,
-0.0041103028,
-0.027625775,
0.0250208918,
0.0090430044,
0.0220711678,
-0.0189882983,
0.0345998406,
-0.0509958118,
-0.068020612,
0.0022072124,
0.0172657929,
0.02210778,
0.0069386051,
-0.0341716558,
-0.0655681714,
-0.0444665514,
-0.0385610871,
-0.0016345329,
0.0161412153,
0.0137594584,
-0.0013350515,
0.0019596519,
-0.0162617844,
0.0220810436,
-0.0165118407,
-0.002321122,
0.053184934,
-0.017246807,
0.0386440419,
-0.0252716132,
0.0127589824,
-0.0203081481,
-0.0387338102,
-0.0144499186,
-0.0094834045,
-0.0296338033,
-0.0320020765,
0.035339158,
-0.0107053006,
0.0117233647,
-0.0439864434,
0.0446235873,
0.0259154197,
-0.0242659207,
-0.0014035418,
-0.0620663278,
2.487e-7,
-0.0101450002,
0.0769048259,
-0.0378040187,
0.0177409928,
-0.011097189,
0.0818436891,
-0.0582552962,
0.0052945828,
0.0195075031,
-0.0229080766,
0.032936994,
0.0246305056,
0.0614447333,
0.0119972536,
-0.0938266516,
-0.0061820471,
-0.0499904715,
0.0016901472,
-0.0339557678,
-0.0116427131,
-0.0012335164,
0.0475663692,
0.0602859929,
-0.0202785134,
0.0056531676,
-0.0100480812,
0.0493923873,
-0.1066246852,
-0.016321484,
0.0089607304,
-0.0128876837,
-0.003356667,
-0.012666286,
-0.0110538602,
-0.0178827439,
0.0021069383,
-0.0485514663,
0.0449777469,
0.0419615693,
-0.0262329299,
-0.0118736736,
-0.0191296227,
-0.0030738616,
-0.0153967813,
0.0359645896,
-0.0716161579,
-0.0483226515,
-0.0494736694,
0.003542552,
-0.0140357725,
0.0094781676,
-0.0346509926,
0.0126912566,
-0.0282410756,
0.0052539152,
-0.0081772162,
0.0351099931,
-0.0089288726,
-0.0408214182,
0.0278721265,
-0.0672660917,
-0.0501989014,
-0.0129105793,
0.0525184534,
-0.0036091115,
-0.0735484362,
0.0237170327,
2.016548391e-34,
0.0385127589,
0.0228438154,
-0.0031232997,
0.0085032936,
0.0464648455,
0.0187624171,
0.0256767087,
0.024580583,
0.0655228198,
-0.0525164977,
0.0032205419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00070v1 | EvoMerge: Neuroevolution for Large Language Models | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | Yushu Jiang | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Extensive fine-tuning on Large Language Models does not always yield better
results. Oftentimes, models tend to get better at imitating one form of data
without gaining greater reasoning ability and may even end up losing some
intelligence. Here I introduce EvoMerge, a systematic approach to large
language model training and merging. Leveraging model merging for weight
crossover and fine-tuning for weight mutation, EvoMerge establishes an
evolutionary process aimed at pushing models beyond the limits of conventional
fine-tuning. | [
0.008060596,
0.0961882323,
-0.0002191282,
0.0433810502,
0.0124207148,
0.0503226034,
-0.0034934569,
-0.0159174819,
-0.021372281,
-0.0110388203,
-0.0315652527,
0.0262621734,
-0.0183022302,
0.0483942069,
0.0684288591,
0.0016249253,
0.0633797199,
-0.0366204418,
-0.0366546027,
-0.0181746893,
-0.0317935571,
0.0235888716,
0.0189509615,
0.0119934278,
0.0362271704,
0.0175431948,
-0.0089338478,
-0.0022245774,
0.0192020126,
0.0021209584,
-0.0000225432,
0.0400673449,
0.0275943819,
0.1045526192,
0.0000017215,
-0.0447605178,
0.0167775545,
0.0010909302,
-0.026460411,
0.0145277372,
0.049054645,
0.0021342232,
-0.0202465076,
0.0073582013,
-0.0326109044,
-0.0117207887,
0.0435403176,
0.0359745845,
0.068098709,
0.061685279,
0.0000262789,
-0.0649340376,
0.0562170371,
-0.0494324341,
0.0182316806,
-0.0117158052,
0.0384808369,
0.0029952528,
-0.0002717803,
-0.0049466905,
-0.0028121732,
0.0148411691,
0.0293855835,
-0.0273641329,
0.0035874494,
0.0398079194,
-0.0307631474,
-0.025596315,
-0.012743664,
0.0522115938,
-0.0402072296,
-0.0339854844,
-0.0181637816,
0.0288736504,
0.0253282543,
-0.0497486964,
-0.0424702428,
-0.0279637184,
0.0323380455,
0.0363098308,
0.0407357961,
-0.0828883871,
0.0664508045,
0.0217826311,
-0.0369124897,
0.0471720658,
0.0689537749,
-0.0079567367,
0.0026400115,
-0.0208899807,
-0.0247003268,
-0.0418236181,
-0.0087432116,
0.0250676591,
-0.0175422076,
-0.0024521898,
-0.0601207092,
-0.0370484889,
-0.0007125728,
-0.0093089072,
0.0474576578,
0.0325722024,
0.022566732,
0.0496744774,
-0.0477392115,
0.0142654292,
-0.0357958153,
0.0191684999,
-0.048928611,
-0.0007794707,
-0.0618249215,
0.0108933561,
-0.0329330079,
-0.0242241025,
-0.0374981649,
-0.031901639,
-0.0378590785,
-0.0180472918,
0.0100988569,
-0.0361754857,
0.0236231517,
0.008701032,
-0.0263326466,
-0.013727922,
-0.0131034572,
0.0485547781,
0.0010867441,
0.0384444818,
0.0133349458,
-0.0034112604,
-0.0156250615,
-0.0113065867,
-0.0110912602,
-0.0285207387,
0.0301014427,
0.0509891957,
-0.0196349081,
-0.0150370756,
-0.0303077102,
0.0105054053,
-0.0040894691,
-0.0376739241,
-0.0149512878,
-0.0584438518,
0.0665984303,
-0.0469408296,
-0.0165395979,
-0.0413500927,
-0.0016162219,
-0.0304280128,
-0.0341445282,
0.0678841025,
-0.0397664011,
0.0190250166,
0.0382085592,
-0.0112640085,
-0.0121119097,
0.0538312271,
0.0317932479,
-0.0181823093,
-0.0124676805,
-0.015640825,
-0.0358116105,
0.0341825858,
0.0153609719,
0.0533835255,
-0.0183468945,
-0.0265857447,
0.0258925669,
0.0242230035,
0.0678067282,
0.0407023616,
-0.0443383791,
-0.0347575359,
0.0612792745,
0.0316693336,
0.0567784384,
0.0357527956,
0.0465362258,
-0.0522253886,
-0.0050447038,
-0.0359676145,
-0.0568021834,
0.0075895814,
-0.041670911,
0.0064945673,
0.0230779275,
0.0801018476,
-0.0168241188,
-0.0282575209,
-0.0030397531,
-0.0044885376,
0.0224142969,
0.005675477,
0.0460235216,
0.0180770271,
-0.0200018752,
0.0395846777,
0.059461087,
-0.0273398291,
0.0033171689,
-0.0596915185,
0.0361418836,
0.0434806496,
0.0128867207,
0.0212646686,
-0.0157201122,
0.0161942337,
-0.0026128953,
0.0601093061,
0.0696849823,
-0.016840389,
0.0423932672,
-0.0425875038,
-0.0212391987,
-0.0060945437,
0.0205607358,
0.0160672273,
0.0103142522,
0.0141193001,
-0.003965361,
-0.000801098,
-0.0614668019,
0.0516573973,
-0.071531944,
-0.0110320533,
-0.0284164082,
-0.0443149656,
0.0203462504,
-0.017638484,
-0.0219104141,
0.0192230474,
0.0141611015,
-0.019968586,
-0.0374671407,
0.0208148882,
0.0030365624,
-0.0153844832,
0.0681033358,
-0.0003788612,
-0.0104742059,
-0.0044548749,
-0.044356782,
-0.0458291359,
0.0142264441,
-0.0234236438,
0.0891705304,
-0.0377552174,
0.0644981265,
-0.0278480072,
0.0097124577,
-0.0253869295,
0.0590537898,
-0.0075446735,
-0.0318343602,
0.012372599,
0.0029968056,
0.0190301035,
-0.0167416222,
-0.0201936401,
0.0186916701,
0.0048065237,
0.0125630302,
-0.0157730598,
0.0129540218,
-0.0223576445,
-0.0516839661,
-0.0945863202,
0.0396541059,
-0.0079445224,
0.0313716158,
0.0350243896,
0.0014621164,
-0.0092641274,
0.0162695684,
0.0083425231,
0.0462021045,
-0.0052593369,
0.0190124623,
0.0153909214,
-0.006898663,
0.0073242276,
-0.0484274626,
-0.0436487384,
-0.0368084125,
0.0779898763,
-0.0043593808,
0.0275379419,
-0.0926093385,
0.0162622165,
-0.0581387244,
0.0386456549,
-0.0080536213,
-0.057258822,
-0.0022369169,
-0.0160597228,
0.0435458533,
0.0864310488,
0.0201687589,
-0.0156638902,
0.060107924,
0.0096260458,
-0.0139461532,
0.0110510904,
0.002665194,
0.0058152312,
-0.0677834526,
-0.0213296823,
0.0009800032,
0.0679559857,
-0.0556076802,
-0.035861399,
-0.0539286099,
0.0265536699,
-0.0099280681,
-0.0455517843,
0.0132680768,
-0.0100312214,
-0.0198322926,
0.0184171051,
-0.0616869181,
-0.0272466391,
0.0547803193,
-0.0158211365,
-0.00407113,
-0.0719723329,
-0.0160267241,
-0.0361072272,
0.0323533304,
0.0201241691,
0.0324540474,
-0.0207053889,
0.0074545573,
-0.0518584289,
-0.0062185912,
0.0056991735,
-0.0075150873,
0.0498293787,
-0.0298388936,
0.0335826762,
0.011023961,
-0.0491929166,
-0.0064658076,
0.0003615639,
-0.047932677,
0.00145963,
0.0252698977,
-0.0672874004,
-0.0812108815,
-0.0008178398,
0.0063067907,
0.0696125031,
-0.0252758171,
-0.0050740079,
-0.0116582299,
-0.0008460715,
0.081450589,
0.039862588,
0.0500430949,
-0.0426507741,
0.0372767597,
0.0413643196,
0.0045470474,
0.0173407607,
-0.0653670579,
0.051959984,
0.0269800723,
-0.022011131,
-0.0014952128,
-0.0140553471,
0.0250570048,
-0.0557509847,
0.0182419382,
0.0913176909,
0.0068819779,
-0.0308105759,
0.008165569,
-0.0568432845,
0.0506582074,
0.0312695056,
0.0630656481,
-0.060010884,
-0.0481172912,
0.0085348757,
-0.030291168,
0.0206856821,
-0.0301846806,
-0.0157001093,
-0.1229522452,
-0.0058538825,
0.0349148065,
-0.0524801388,
0.0121613545,
-0.0097922254,
-0.0073913322,
-0.026580153,
0.0312632695,
0.0239915289,
-0.026325468,
-0.0186082609,
-0.0085667688,
0.0375584476,
-0.0494210422,
0.0243432969,
-0.0600228757,
0.080185324,
0.055043295,
0.0185358543,
-0.0056624515,
-0.0707974657,
0.0885104463,
-0.0130120525,
-0.0144598922,
-0.0032188646,
0.0492341779,
0.0172565281,
-0.023596026,
0.0009533369,
0.0314301625,
0.0051706489,
-0.0310631767,
-0.0078480048,
0.0423140004,
0.0138685266,
-0.0634196624,
-0.0173403695,
-0.0234827753,
-0.023282392,
0.0526900142,
0.0130568985,
-0.0451425873,
-0.0216978863,
-0.0046431338,
-0.052682478,
-0.0153429685,
-0.0365718454,
0.0533616543,
0.0121642994,
-0.0617632866,
-0.0599108785,
-0.0058711157,
0.0450231805,
0.0378413238,
0.0377111472,
-0.0040641646,
0.0018613922,
-0.0586649701,
-0.0347729288,
0.0612422638,
-0.0198885053,
-0.0194832608,
-0.0758367628,
-0.0074664894,
0.0426793993,
0.0005191093,
-0.0171282757,
0.0042921714,
-0.0814852789,
-0.0996422172,
-0.0078247637,
0.060031984,
0.03213723,
0.0395283103,
-0.0206374377,
-0.0536253303,
0.0427359305,
0.0160435624,
0.0122883553,
0.0221118014,
0.0055452632,
-0.0505271554,
0.0074448083,
0.0266337004,
-0.0216450524,
0.0233652182,
0.0132130012,
0.0286886916,
-0.0305638369,
-0.0026352899,
-0.0093485061,
-0.0057151988,
-0.0141191557,
-0.0218781214,
-0.0155504253,
-0.0629333258,
0.0163138602,
-0.0097279185,
0.0049321973,
-0.0402561314,
-0.016103426,
0.0381249078,
0.024546681,
0.0230229571,
0.0153392134,
0.0400801487,
-0.0087017808,
-0.0219168551,
-0.0042307843,
-0.0267999563,
0.0312046949,
0.0254100766,
-0.0071570203,
0.0091552781,
0.0471228957,
-0.0070553226,
0.0443008691,
-0.0414801985,
0.0258067138,
0.0372397974,
-0.0163212474,
-0.0286990292,
0.0534939058,
-0.0767149776,
-0.0397012122,
-0.0224786885,
0.0053033829,
0.0474647209,
0.0028752831,
0.1040703803,
0.001872247,
-0.0524809696,
-0.0049153818,
-0.0123716928,
-0.0343002789,
0.0029126089,
0.0546221435,
0.0242886189,
-0.0037640291,
0.0017157259,
0.0352224521,
-0.003131767,
0.0646674484,
0.0040430012,
0.0271911211,
-0.0080767088,
-0.0323268287,
0.0152409729,
-0.0404313095,
-0.0389862843,
-0.0179966055,
-0.0013426731,
-0.077474542,
-0.0110547123,
0.0573462248,
-0.0204729922,
0.0345063955,
0.0091575682,
0.0386564769,
-0.0158327334,
-0.0239712503,
0.0062896167,
-0.0294704344,
-0.0006735821,
-0.0450826287,
-0.0043516504,
-6.014910921e-33,
-0.0036811323,
0.0134073142,
0.0492572412,
-0.0108981645,
-0.0639419332,
-0.0235027373,
-0.0402138457,
-0.0098058088,
-0.0391959697,
0.0148343015,
-0.0086741298,
0.0436865985,
-0.0079142768,
0.0062150136,
0.022103088,
-0.0036597643,
0.0476275496,
0.0125482641,
-0.0128272418,
-0.0088717919,
-0.0317297392,
0.0284361187,
0.040404737,
-0.0110953888,
-0.0286317151,
0.0547603816,
-0.0047213114,
0.0438678041,
-0.0209564064,
0.0577960014,
-0.0319411829,
-0.0023141548,
-0.0007994132,
-0.02576348,
-0.0268717594,
-0.0218291618,
-0.0402223505,
-0.0139883384,
0.0074404501,
-0.019106267,
-0.0291689113,
-0.0362838395,
0.0695971251,
0.0122910924,
0.0085553722,
-0.0240077376,
0.031292785,
-0.0467270352,
-0.0014614115,
0.0142794009,
-0.074696891,
0.0006892555,
0.0112864925,
0.0013850615,
0.0101587661,
-0.0330662206,
0.0142353904,
-0.0039016258,
-0.0249648131,
0.0216941312,
0.0095650991,
0.0356589146,
0.0590700731,
0.0217625108,
0.0237431377,
0.0518461168,
0.028755581,
-0.0388892516,
-0.011724866,
-0.0202114768,
0.0816919878,
0.0636490509,
0.0572036169,
0.01372902,
0.0249213111,
-0.0187533963,
-0.0376572944,
0.0220146235,
0.024250662,
0.0369306132,
-0.0189643502,
0.056156829,
0.0248810351,
-0.005320319,
-0.0517953523,
-0.0317296386,
-0.0457663462,
-0.0079991836,
0.0008491265,
-0.01573365,
-0.0237325002,
-0.0156321321,
0.0228857305,
-0.0318882801,
-0.0245188717,
0.0162749626,
-0.0162053294,
-0.0053125801,
-0.0091485372,
0.0467607863,
0.0115906615,
-0.0466743596,
0.0187345166,
0.0365340002,
0.0332864486,
-0.0110067884,
0.0271660164,
0.0283463374,
-0.0598556325,
0.0205743834,
-0.0221777949,
-0.0010331358,
0.0339133814,
0.0690862387,
0.0242162142,
0.0120521309,
0.0197802782,
-0.030396536,
0.0371804833,
0.0087284427,
-0.0495443307,
0.0557172522,
0.0557900891,
0.029571997,
-0.0231106915,
0.0124140698,
-0.0227609389,
0.0504882224,
0.0259540025,
-0.0647820979,
-0.0498450771,
0.0460935757,
2.464e-7,
0.0448605865,
0.0330232382,
0.0042695981,
-0.0273881685,
0.0210718419,
0.0299952254,
-0.0301350225,
0.0137544768,
0.0370587073,
-0.0058721374,
-0.0126149682,
0.0588749982,
0.0616979077,
-0.0003308807,
-0.066123493,
-0.0215165261,
-0.0635064617,
0.0117889717,
-0.0796547979,
-0.028823195,
0.0073850648,
0.1108120233,
0.0384792984,
-0.0523572974,
0.0203532614,
-0.0427382961,
0.05063596,
-0.0104380716,
0.0214792602,
0.0305038262,
-0.0386385471,
0.0364890508,
-0.0161562245,
-0.0038573935,
-0.0187551267,
0.0168745127,
-0.0372852124,
0.0549195409,
-0.0356305949,
0.0135711795,
0.0082284352,
0.0124856764,
-0.0326844044,
-0.0387118645,
0.0615745932,
-0.0548386164,
-0.0399847738,
-0.0753070787,
-0.0200584456,
-0.0360871442,
0.0253218375,
-0.0463698357,
-0.0030968131,
0.0445801578,
0.0206632167,
-0.0073344829,
-0.0258754212,
-0.0800792724,
-0.0220065527,
0.0125406878,
-0.0639640838,
-0.0424527675,
-0.0367337354,
0.0081396643,
0.0184979886,
-0.0594103821,
0.0211062878,
2.324056335e-34,
0.0042328406,
0.0005909313,
0.0584682114,
-0.0054849368,
0.0388387479,
0.0046254061,
0.0056250636,
-0.0131126978,
0.004496234,
-0.0826944411,
-0.0247391332
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.