id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03399v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03399v1
|
Using LSTM and GRU With a New Dataset for Named Entity Recognition in the Arabic Language
| 2023-04-06T22:14:02 | 2023-04-06T22:14:02 |
Alaa Shaker, Alaa Aldarf, Igor Bessmertny
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named entity recognition (NER) is a natural language processing task (NLP),
which aims to identify named entities and classify them like person, location,
organization, etc. In the Arabic language, we can find a considerable size of
unstructured data, and it needs to different preprocessing tool than languages
like (English, Russian, German...). From this point, we can note the importance
of building a new structured dataset to solve the lack of structured data. In
this work, we use the BIOES format to tag the word, which allows us to handle
the nested name entity that consists of more than one sentence and define the
start and the end of the name. The dataset consists of more than thirty-six
thousand records. In addition, this work proposes long short term memory (LSTM)
units and Gated Recurrent Units (GRU) for building the named entity recognition
model in the Arabic language. The models give an approximately good result
(80%) because LSTM and GRU models can find the relationships between the words
of the sentence. Also, use a new library from Google, which is Trax and
platform Colab
|
[
0.0373656638,
0.0108343558,
0.0145462537,
0.0484273508,
-0.0272907969,
0.0460705273,
0.034808103,
0.0072599538,
0.0035901291,
-0.0505254604,
-0.0095440764,
-0.0828004554,
0.0423919484,
0.0572262183,
0.0260567404,
-0.0502341725,
0.0260440912,
-0.0258866474,
0.0354323462,
0.0194994044,
0.0037719621,
0.0186024606,
-0.013629281,
0.0017525157,
0.000935274,
-0.0072495551,
-0.008845441,
0.0056706038,
0.0357387103,
-0.0415115468,
0.0088272756,
0.0358670801,
-0.0039572604,
0.0292002838,
0.0000019587,
-0.0621724986,
-0.0753910542,
-0.0479283519,
-0.015200411,
-0.0437901616,
0.0202738028,
-0.0276331753,
-0.0426170677,
0.0155179808,
-0.0488112755,
-0.0058292393,
0.0342489481,
0.0784365833,
0.0389091559,
0.0784231424,
0.008831908,
-0.0939845443,
0.0277717113,
0.0022582046,
0.0036758478,
-0.0021350763,
0.0291707925,
-0.0384861007,
0.0265415814,
0.0160961356,
-0.021917304,
0.0134990858,
-0.0105050784,
-0.0036166233,
0.0189561397,
0.0207066759,
-0.0260457732,
0.0089532034,
0.0054944833,
0.0612212792,
-0.0341694281,
0.0058973618,
0.0377340429,
0.0144093791,
-0.0516188517,
-0.0478871204,
-0.0177236721,
0.0435499027,
-0.054554224,
0.0258071125,
0.0458220877,
-0.014735085,
0.0235560089,
0.0147791002,
-0.0312142521,
0.036107406,
0.0208468344,
-0.0458676927,
-0.00708029,
-0.0254036002,
0.0330233239,
-0.0205906741,
0.0397823751,
0.0460254587,
0.0065754056,
0.0135616269,
-0.0349169485,
-0.0262186434,
-0.014148402,
-0.0638369471,
-0.0027807285,
0.0296638981,
0.0233390015,
0.0337274596,
-0.0618642047,
0.0352401882,
-0.0164739341,
-0.0102782566,
0.0162681937,
-0.0047613475,
-0.0757966265,
-0.0041139452,
-0.000021295,
0.0563477241,
-0.034705691,
0.0053549595,
-0.0834568068,
-0.0081400694,
0.0000428969,
0.0209690724,
-0.010757341,
-0.0027382409,
0.0042275116,
-0.0031903647,
-0.0513270274,
-0.0175737664,
-0.0164640862,
-0.0130065978,
-0.0396469459,
-0.070386216,
0.0075092851,
0.0180631559,
0.051094871,
-0.0122531056,
0.0244117007,
0.043661125,
0.033577349,
-0.0897199214,
-0.0839331076,
0.0022587271,
0.00287622,
-0.0367781073,
0.0248747524,
-0.0433835909,
0.0458521098,
-0.0107676918,
-0.0316991471,
-0.0350429788,
0.0279579069,
0.0194404777,
-0.0031112742,
0.0951781124,
-0.0041642371,
-0.03157074,
0.0404156037,
0.001065286,
0.0895500854,
0.0173209868,
0.0511384606,
0.0009006201,
0.0092032254,
0.0064347684,
0.0106819896,
0.0081582805,
-0.0107090771,
-0.0280525126,
-0.0353387929,
-0.0120584732,
-0.0224075727,
0.072276108,
0.0017725111,
0.043645367,
0.025034776,
0.0040647816,
0.0167352315,
0.0360029526,
-0.0137108471,
0.0264550615,
-0.001847417,
0.0244529061,
0.0311189499,
-0.028671857,
0.0225015301,
0.0000898909,
0.0054801879,
0.0299026947,
-0.0014276057,
0.0780402794,
-0.0250812229,
-0.0040996238,
-0.0082127498,
-0.0433762595,
0.0027502212,
-0.0443634652,
0.0716114268,
-0.0006577132,
-0.0836304501,
0.0331461988,
0.0060206349,
-0.0106569678,
0.000163828,
-0.0303941481,
0.0108622946,
0.0540340766,
0.0369210877,
-0.0130121,
-0.0725999847,
-0.059265513,
-0.0765483528,
0.0572479628,
-0.0226661861,
-0.0000821649,
0.0150722722,
-0.0705571771,
-0.0057774838,
0.045396015,
-0.0092140781,
0.0190410614,
-0.0111538749,
0.0704257041,
0.0425158553,
-0.0073691383,
-0.0178132728,
0.0415074639,
-0.008971842,
-0.0184416119,
-0.0035044847,
0.0317703113,
0.040645171,
0.0642160848,
0.0051564216,
-0.0214636829,
0.0227309596,
-0.0367523506,
-0.0416189954,
-0.0240358729,
-0.0271378085,
-0.0287030898,
0.0353260487,
-0.0089066718,
-0.0196068063,
0.0360300839,
-0.0143722594,
-0.093054831,
0.0152953751,
0.0172303263,
0.0235469956,
-0.0325743519,
0.0488781966,
0.0302845929,
0.0464239791,
-0.0269792676,
0.0483660959,
-0.0170669202,
0.0109978681,
0.0132437125,
-0.0232631247,
0.0348365381,
-0.0195646863,
-0.0320101641,
0.0375530198,
0.0101644993,
-0.0256546382,
0.0185352582,
0.0108401421,
-0.0578824021,
-0.0008264739,
-0.05113893,
0.01614522,
-0.0077320412,
0.0798304901,
-0.0150766531,
0.0439655893,
-0.0401042029,
-0.0325632729,
-0.0148732411,
-0.0107938685,
0.0010676431,
-0.0233255699,
0.0747601017,
0.0072433865,
-0.0404627733,
-0.0262855962,
0.0131648351,
-0.0333607085,
0.0487566106,
0.0280269049,
-0.1123623103,
0.0024779241,
-0.0009225283,
-0.0216028113,
0.0394970477,
0.0272902027,
-0.0118301092,
-0.0021329795,
0.0353192799,
0.0618976988,
0.0388070531,
0.0040897904,
0.0070833401,
-0.0226809438,
-0.0026987083,
0.0126679335,
0.0298540685,
-0.0235449765,
0.0451013297,
-0.0112809669,
-0.0238752011,
0.0054345015,
0.0360895135,
0.0020042441,
0.0084174098,
0.0070654443,
0.0023314762,
-0.0015760205,
0.0228192881,
-0.0109681282,
0.0365430936,
-0.0420712121,
0.0178247895,
-0.0028429863,
-0.0403345339,
-0.0050928658,
-0.038479127,
-0.0037495017,
-0.0381515026,
0.0066829356,
-0.0803447887,
0.0355517976,
0.0110753709,
-0.0002381563,
0.015283891,
-0.0653041303,
0.0113100959,
0.0427806042,
-0.0140855582,
-0.0136770979,
-0.0212432463,
-0.0198525656,
0.0218526684,
-0.0232919361,
0.0280032437,
-0.0274363402,
0.0475978106,
-0.0570323393,
0.0102885468,
0.0172277745,
-0.0164219886,
-0.0102737173,
0.034821365,
0.008381418,
0.044927001,
-0.0118808355,
0.015423337,
-0.0168354213,
0.0401264578,
0.0390709192,
-0.0069867056,
0.0006345367,
0.0261900313,
-0.0127478782,
0.0086522149,
-0.0403889753,
-0.0040125516,
-0.0743723437,
-0.0165663827,
0.0132636689,
-0.0788893476,
-0.0115133272,
-0.0299379081,
-0.0209632535,
-0.099889189,
0.0019078632,
0.1189226657,
0.0081868647,
-0.0054069292,
-0.0234646145,
0.0234150067,
-0.0330762453,
-0.0091234166,
-0.0199162606,
-0.0599150732,
-0.0155159272,
0.0056009972,
-0.0349910408,
0.0128968218,
-0.054207772,
0.0265498739,
-0.0775029585,
-0.0058658435,
-0.0155373868,
-0.0411114097,
-0.0469424799,
-0.0447996818,
-0.031569384,
0.0136693418,
-0.0147311939,
-0.0386284627,
-0.0282430854,
0.0208557826,
0.0229019951,
-0.0146240331,
-0.0601413846,
0.0139555894,
-0.061368797,
0.0279683638,
0.0965796635,
0.0662428513,
-0.0379774347,
-0.0136199398,
0.0087286048,
-0.0068414826,
-0.0163214505,
-0.009244821,
0.006124875,
-0.0486966297,
-0.0226274244,
-0.0359239727,
-0.0129636526,
-0.0968092307,
0.0241139662,
0.0029196269,
0.0470280908,
-0.0344122276,
0.0120585039,
-0.0222598016,
-0.0291353874,
0.0099903448,
0.0521483496,
-0.0216066781,
-0.0169090498,
-0.0602890328,
0.0311154034,
-0.0432120152,
-0.0474064499,
0.0000597327,
0.007803238,
-0.0238800049,
0.028221935,
-0.0701775625,
-0.066223301,
0.0367147028,
0.039677266,
0.0086288583,
0.0749197751,
0.0409233384,
0.0259482954,
-0.0650872216,
-0.0059896954,
0.0173432939,
-0.0041886605,
-0.0766827539,
-0.0190575309,
-0.0125116277,
0.002546709,
-0.0135128917,
-0.0188688915,
-0.0734351575,
-0.0207360592,
-0.0063755857,
-0.0324542597,
0.0230336897,
0.0054480797,
0.0120525677,
-0.0085363965,
0.0287151951,
-0.0131690083,
-0.0060985773,
-0.0144699691,
0.0137667647,
0.0365297049,
-0.0385898836,
0.0297296885,
0.0218301341,
0.0219727606,
0.0183600243,
-0.0054899477,
0.0281266142,
-0.0325607285,
-0.0200086124,
-0.0048384932,
0.0636252388,
-0.0236366168,
-0.0427988023,
-0.0700106695,
0.0452864021,
0.0128825596,
0.0430957712,
0.0246974342,
0.0157218874,
0.0174890775,
0.0197898913,
-0.0350849219,
-0.0231035333,
0.0138176773,
-0.0581774674,
-0.0202375595,
0.042815838,
-0.0003602649,
0.0321663469,
-0.02345502,
-0.0071631027,
0.0246572681,
0.0124929622,
0.0192882717,
0.0152779324,
-0.0158259068,
0.0104676262,
0.0046894872,
0.0256185979,
0.0073955562,
0.0502942652,
0.0141570019,
-0.0006162412,
-0.0436395109,
0.0265199281,
0.0316153914,
-0.0125520993,
0.0084538516,
0.0022323052,
0.0189268906,
-0.0106894113,
0.0639014095,
-0.0236612596,
-0.0029207468,
0.0134914611,
-0.0123653132,
-0.0597367845,
0.0213477574,
0.0454645529,
0.0587470345,
-0.0007064802,
0.0649997592,
-0.0172340702,
-0.0104306405,
0.0309928097,
0.0002175091,
-0.0211876109,
-0.039809633,
0.0389496312,
-0.0167243537,
-0.0441854633,
0.0872334391,
-0.0117919985,
0.0197440442,
0.0307880826,
0.0627028048,
0.0127225025,
0.0162103903,
-0.0104641616,
-0.0281434413,
0.0288544074,
0.0019465007,
-0.0514831804,
-0.0321535207,
-6.068751134e-33,
0.0008036128,
-0.0455797352,
0.0218555443,
0.007527465,
-0.0010579799,
0.0119604329,
-0.0462856032,
-0.0097584231,
-0.0088304346,
-0.0217952505,
-0.0352947898,
0.0236997157,
0.0467994846,
0.0348423831,
0.032872621,
-0.0404359922,
0.031914331,
0.0195998047,
0.0048661754,
0.0210746415,
0.0383252986,
0.120995447,
0.1214100569,
-0.0395085402,
0.0193465017,
-0.0189605001,
-0.0113456389,
0.0046180389,
0.0379348025,
0.0714479834,
-0.0736231208,
0.0262528397,
0.0250553433,
-0.0691121742,
0.0142058861,
0.0214714836,
-0.1099505574,
-0.0165377818,
-0.0261567086,
0.0481925867,
-0.0454916731,
-0.0240765642,
-0.000528748,
0.0282908604,
-0.0176752917,
0.0602896735,
0.0277859159,
-0.0296174698,
0.0112000071,
-0.0572333932,
-0.1070741117,
0.0410279892,
0.0304248985,
0.0599227212,
0.0684134662,
-0.0431535095,
-0.0111573217,
0.0168191846,
-0.0591880418,
-0.0392334051,
0.0115916422,
0.0226529855,
0.0528379194,
0.0161354728,
-0.0379313678,
0.0306348093,
0.0145573821,
-0.0032479933,
-0.0024605989,
0.0035626024,
-0.0073868711,
-0.0132070547,
0.0079176398,
0.0341500267,
0.037923798,
-0.0286508463,
-0.0838356093,
0.0479976162,
0.0075725438,
0.0586923435,
0.0026539937,
-0.0161862765,
-0.0675568208,
0.0190942399,
0.0343811512,
-0.0136886928,
-0.0279957056,
-0.0085559795,
0.0371652655,
0.0173950605,
-0.0275583789,
0.023130225,
-0.0214125235,
0.0037565399,
0.0047980971,
-0.0281226989,
0.0452938154,
-0.0108181071,
0.0053033251,
0.01972422,
-0.0539838225,
-0.0887266099,
-0.0008188125,
-0.0072505581,
0.028889766,
-0.0330191329,
0.0219833329,
0.0150838206,
-0.0805742964,
0.0141297858,
-0.0071710451,
0.0179321244,
0.0013001668,
0.0522155948,
-0.0087161288,
-0.0351793543,
0.0126672648,
0.0715983286,
0.033112742,
-0.0272921138,
-0.02790213,
-0.0196304098,
0.0263493545,
-0.0017778347,
-0.0189013593,
0.0043732333,
-0.0172962286,
0.0418295227,
-0.0002073596,
-0.0688236281,
0.0006571916,
-0.0010563799,
2.717e-7,
0.0334949382,
0.0227673948,
0.0536330976,
-0.0208679978,
-0.0101314122,
-0.0001577247,
0.0389651246,
0.0667084903,
-0.0460642166,
0.0069312733,
0.0131023983,
-0.0631996393,
0.0042019286,
-0.0305779427,
-0.1198097914,
-0.0180941336,
-0.0023342087,
-0.0005686274,
-0.0520561039,
-0.0064402693,
0.0184849147,
0.1245428398,
-0.0055477824,
-0.0145661216,
-0.0192042533,
-0.0398825258,
0.0194500051,
-0.0107865473,
0.0192050468,
0.0167773627,
0.0442758426,
0.0385755748,
-0.022673741,
0.015074647,
-0.0067036608,
0.0443740599,
0.0297473185,
0.0426375084,
-0.0211538989,
0.0238723792,
0.012299573,
-0.0265795961,
0.0107564619,
-0.0377187282,
0.0606291667,
0.0257487707,
-0.0174110997,
0.022811316,
0.0096309716,
0.0225756485,
0.0277389865,
0.0007742207,
0.0059670215,
0.0027216929,
0.0210086592,
-0.0304426532,
0.0022871611,
-0.0773565322,
0.0531166978,
0.0247664247,
-0.00605381,
0.0262400303,
-0.0106663043,
-0.0223835129,
0.0605129115,
-0.0017810845,
-0.0239142124,
2.545516486e-34,
-0.0132078454,
-0.0086934632,
-0.0307504181,
0.0644677803,
0.0230659377,
-0.0263521336,
-0.0790508315,
-0.0048600696,
-0.0017944205,
-0.0499551445,
-0.021688059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03394v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03394v2
|
Deep Learning for Opinion Mining and Topic Classification of Course Reviews
| 2023-04-06T21:48:29 | 2023-06-16T14:15:10 |
Anna Koufakou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Student opinions for a course are important to educators and administrators,
regardless of the type of the course or the institution. Reading and manually
analyzing open-ended feedback becomes infeasible for massive volumes of
comments at institution level or online forums. In this paper, we collected and
pre-processed a large number of course reviews publicly available online. We
applied machine learning techniques with the goal to gain insight into student
sentiments and topics. Specifically, we utilized current Natural Language
Processing (NLP) techniques, such as word embeddings and deep neural networks,
and state-of-the-art BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers), RoBERTa (Robustly optimized BERT approach) and XLNet
(Generalized Auto-regression Pre-training). We performed extensive
experimentation to compare these techniques versus traditional approaches. This
comparative study demonstrates how to apply modern machine learning approaches
for sentiment polarity extraction and topic-based classification utilizing
course feedback. For sentiment polarity, the top model was RoBERTa with 95.5%
accuracy and 84.7% F1-macro, while for topic classification, an SVM (Support
Vector Machine) was the top classifier with 79.8% accuracy and 80.6% F1-macro.
We also provided an in-depth exploration of the effect of certain
hyperparameters on the model performance and discussed our observations. These
findings can be used by institutions and course providers as a guide for
analyzing their own course feedback using NLP models towards self-evaluation
and improvement.
|
[
0.040001899,
0.0067814505,
0.0007036165,
0.0433606356,
-0.0166902859,
0.0240795668,
-0.0227959082,
-0.0408104099,
-0.0129844686,
-0.1054451317,
-0.0222051628,
-0.0247624349,
-0.026446376,
0.0429968126,
-0.0323362015,
-0.0190800969,
0.0019697205,
0.0466225632,
0.0032936959,
0.0133168139,
-0.0017999192,
0.022320088,
-0.0285791941,
0.0278458782,
0.018609019,
0.0062200776,
0.0106082754,
-0.0138446866,
0.0193170346,
-0.006009697,
0.0470931418,
0.0450823344,
-0.0141038438,
0.0236392766,
0.0000019905,
-0.0215345789,
-0.0182292741,
-0.0423535258,
-0.0021196241,
0.0363851264,
0.0464815013,
0.0050376137,
-0.0057934825,
0.0314798169,
-0.0373672992,
-0.0207121558,
0.0081215985,
0.0848517865,
0.0453999452,
0.0451793335,
0.0006437919,
-0.0408880599,
-0.0004810212,
0.0296049286,
-0.0160129033,
0.0310870837,
0.02044845,
-0.0330274403,
-0.0304288622,
0.0266575944,
-0.013970783,
-0.0090446752,
-0.010875985,
-0.0439546779,
0.0419236049,
-0.0040572858,
-0.0480623245,
0.0003545505,
-0.0048737237,
0.0644543916,
0.0026276463,
-0.0044615539,
-0.0147508997,
-0.0115347253,
-0.0052499506,
0.0028446214,
-0.0019166748,
0.0141695514,
0.0146263763,
0.0600208864,
-0.003757518,
0.0189889148,
0.0255926866,
0.0351895429,
0.0204136539,
0.0041405661,
-0.0159706846,
-0.0522159263,
0.025827039,
0.0742133185,
0.0013546983,
0.0193061922,
0.0411541089,
0.0052797273,
0.0257353149,
-0.0021272465,
0.0264330376,
-0.0398690365,
0.0202523191,
-0.0825780258,
0.0140614733,
0.0070951516,
-0.0387566201,
0.0132761765,
-0.0001694883,
-0.006250415,
-0.0062387567,
0.0208604839,
-0.0033476406,
0.0345303081,
-0.0664179176,
0.0100012776,
0.044297263,
0.0723278075,
0.0063601257,
0.0018911457,
-0.0590834953,
-0.020198904,
-0.0233160872,
0.009741012,
-0.0086405538,
0.0414339192,
0.0373168886,
0.0364165679,
-0.0532296039,
0.0810479894,
-0.023216106,
0.0272831824,
-0.0713923573,
0.0268042609,
0.0538723134,
0.0438698865,
0.0251309145,
0.0376317687,
0.014635507,
0.0452254117,
0.0341681279,
-0.0315506682,
-0.0441799015,
-0.0192666668,
-0.0172588918,
-0.0151868723,
0.0466910675,
-0.0483529083,
-0.00155754,
-0.0163401701,
-0.0399983451,
0.0304700285,
0.030953262,
0.0157615468,
0.0117561221,
0.0412549525,
-0.0250836797,
-0.0513451137,
0.0493777208,
0.0017331495,
0.042239815,
0.0105323903,
0.0059031858,
0.0403089821,
0.0494252555,
-0.0157987904,
0.0215785913,
-0.0230716355,
0.0059632696,
-0.0561597161,
0.0093351873,
-0.0079258,
-0.0589512438,
-0.0164214298,
-0.0340552889,
0.0396584198,
0.03451024,
-0.0058673085,
0.0106230378,
0.0183682591,
-0.0361447074,
0.0588676594,
-0.0079916948,
0.034942545,
-0.0030413799,
-0.0314847715,
0.0173655655,
-0.0080633676,
0.0250672363,
-0.0299249832,
0.0355491415,
-0.0327714719,
-0.0072755297,
-0.0957909897,
-0.0255405959,
-0.041694466,
0.0164496694,
-0.0049739801,
0.0696994588,
-0.0259850975,
-0.0586514957,
0.0072291368,
0.0465980433,
-0.0573925711,
0.0203760713,
-0.0358743295,
0.0543245263,
0.0790023953,
0.0042726677,
-0.0324061885,
-0.027965527,
-0.0699472353,
-0.0075531639,
0.0323687568,
0.0747623295,
0.0026934624,
-0.0132840965,
-0.0574416518,
-0.0053151688,
-0.0093311155,
0.0058728238,
0.0207362808,
-0.0470394827,
0.0286038443,
0.0125256171,
0.0033901485,
-0.0448965691,
0.024396427,
0.0418246686,
-0.0353210345,
0.0245405044,
0.0389984027,
0.0311456528,
0.069274731,
-0.0137895383,
-0.0004309033,
0.0248388555,
-0.0273870025,
-0.0774962381,
-0.0453186445,
-0.0167117026,
-0.0249095913,
0.0451683402,
-0.0587427914,
-0.0184992887,
0.0587732866,
-0.032426782,
-0.0088557778,
0.0406965055,
-0.0177131537,
0.0136299198,
-0.0079674292,
0.0092594502,
-0.0277996082,
-0.0082516996,
-0.0171048455,
0.0116788791,
0.0041622389,
0.0352786034,
-0.0154903205,
-0.0620621927,
0.0361529514,
0.0155826397,
-0.0701697171,
-0.0038333745,
-0.0061996542,
0.0045624916,
0.0323893428,
0.0253025331,
-0.0290558618,
-0.0201260634,
-0.0740188211,
-0.0055300877,
0.0001898637,
0.0392560065,
-0.0102130836,
-0.0508188978,
0.0298009962,
0.0236844216,
-0.0147797419,
-0.0317431539,
-0.0384297669,
-0.0243011806,
0.0595464855,
0.0123974616,
0.0245701969,
-0.0476307496,
-0.0409592502,
-0.0433425531,
0.0102471095,
0.0676089972,
-0.0104136048,
-0.0097687012,
0.0221621934,
-0.006765251,
0.0092418641,
0.001190064,
-0.0558894835,
-0.0015216017,
-0.0029677113,
0.005336077,
0.0392868519,
0.039553117,
0.0348635316,
0.0428856947,
0.0333744138,
-0.0238762386,
0.0122188032,
-0.0584410056,
0.0296564586,
-0.0218567699,
0.0198888667,
0.0037324806,
0.0078339009,
0.0246635024,
-0.0389657915,
-0.0335485153,
-0.0284985639,
-0.0298640952,
0.0357177742,
-0.0147975171,
-0.0093175806,
0.0271942876,
-0.0194736999,
0.0248177424,
0.0102598462,
0.0597153753,
0.0113242371,
0.020824343,
-0.0966930762,
-0.0047020731,
-0.0505386293,
-0.0124243535,
-0.0087828832,
-0.003136958,
-0.0752101392,
0.0244605895,
0.0401108675,
-0.0205876324,
-0.0155460024,
-0.0427806526,
0.0020816519,
0.0029751754,
-0.0236053839,
-0.0176573023,
-0.0121428948,
-0.0276034474,
-0.0193807594,
-0.0157703329,
-0.0153248981,
0.0323658884,
-0.0137111889,
0.0011380799,
-0.0205404516,
-0.0327282026,
-0.0210732948,
-0.0136198429,
-0.028659286,
0.0236660056,
0.0201353785,
0.0148515608,
-0.0413569734,
0.0178099666,
0.0177780222,
0.0153632713,
0.0295157712,
-0.0019563797,
0.029307615,
-0.0478132851,
-0.0380031057,
-0.0008627157,
-0.0452168137,
0.0259864368,
-0.0098114284,
-0.0047595869,
-0.0758821815,
0.0052612838,
0.1215979084,
0.0312734321,
-0.0588537343,
-0.0405604951,
0.0098829465,
-0.0345773213,
-0.0071344972,
-0.0013625126,
-0.0379079916,
-0.0102437101,
-0.0486109331,
0.0410126299,
-0.0104503222,
0.0019894491,
0.0406903177,
-0.0880378708,
-0.0029893282,
-0.0272598173,
0.0146197565,
-0.0616099983,
-0.0569392033,
-0.0258542839,
-0.0019604843,
0.0212036185,
-0.0700828806,
0.004827654,
0.0254641455,
0.0386672728,
-0.0912610218,
-0.0096827289,
0.044303067,
-0.0227023028,
0.0261450578,
0.0379958563,
0.0607649498,
-0.0608106814,
-0.0373838022,
0.0616920963,
-0.0136820525,
-0.0388389081,
-0.0056883027,
0.0807655528,
-0.0480721444,
-0.0237049852,
-0.0021491928,
-0.0040555792,
-0.0818953738,
0.0262907818,
0.008765867,
0.0687511563,
-0.0350835025,
-0.0275430586,
-0.0748101845,
0.0560881458,
-0.00176852,
0.0727256015,
-0.0055496697,
-0.0868236423,
0.0009282865,
-0.0101422761,
0.0312673189,
-0.0513041727,
-0.0175758451,
-0.0063091796,
0.0259136371,
-0.026309358,
-0.0261956174,
-0.0679473653,
0.0260793343,
-0.0285655055,
0.0091662323,
0.0138623146,
0.0636578128,
0.0256464388,
-0.0667560622,
0.0266953893,
0.0408991501,
0.0048557054,
-0.0546636842,
-0.055122707,
0.0647806451,
0.0098162945,
-0.034723483,
-0.0407890715,
0.0044927103,
-0.0295713712,
-0.0061839856,
0.0362928063,
-0.0002145273,
0.0016697948,
-0.0022777985,
-0.0038150796,
0.029099917,
0.0500110425,
-0.0002187521,
-0.0410285927,
0.0508511625,
0.0749087557,
0.0153758805,
0.0036140969,
-0.0216582678,
0.0342996046,
-0.0117319934,
-0.0302423257,
-0.021038875,
-0.0162306279,
-0.0090433722,
0.0093056625,
0.0781738982,
0.0503616445,
-0.0377765819,
-0.0484295525,
-0.0082273809,
-0.0095710121,
0.0121443998,
-0.0125656063,
-0.017272234,
0.0173454005,
-0.0029083893,
-0.0696329176,
0.0084047979,
-0.0165713727,
0.014172541,
-0.0190727673,
0.0954985544,
0.0118118981,
0.013859449,
-0.0079683531,
0.0036156941,
-0.0540255569,
0.0004486706,
0.0342769921,
-0.0208257716,
0.0008003614,
0.0267234705,
0.0197701883,
0.0333198048,
0.0056448868,
0.0208836179,
-0.0170363635,
0.0178305283,
-0.0432087481,
0.0147547247,
-0.0104918871,
-0.019837277,
0.0102496641,
-0.0265436191,
-0.0024902816,
-0.0074422113,
0.0453938879,
-0.0357771292,
-0.0012544562,
0.0373041667,
-0.0104079423,
-0.0182629637,
-0.0045442614,
0.0082784751,
-0.0190766789,
0.0159342475,
0.0409955233,
-0.0296036676,
-0.0438823476,
0.021096034,
0.0405084342,
0.0032372307,
0.0138811991,
0.0357280225,
0.0020650104,
-0.0163956676,
0.0444155298,
-0.0020078523,
0.0292340331,
-0.0083943335,
0.0348862261,
0.0571411438,
-0.0050832815,
0.0295314882,
-0.0519241169,
0.0393634029,
-0.0112628033,
-0.0303616617,
-0.0350802839,
-6.162309464e-33,
-0.0139454501,
-0.0068123364,
-0.051039774,
0.0745165423,
0.0027287304,
0.0047030984,
-0.0300320089,
0.0428440459,
-0.0239417758,
0.0368875191,
0.0274276789,
0.0229294281,
-0.0154186599,
0.0506415628,
0.0500468574,
-0.0375943258,
0.0648812503,
-0.0260058381,
0.0400238149,
0.0161928292,
0.0247393139,
0.027540423,
0.085483171,
-0.1243168414,
0.0343939885,
-0.0226656441,
0.0116256606,
-0.0072677424,
0.0108541809,
0.0382580161,
-0.036391791,
0.0918031037,
0.0335861966,
-0.0382459164,
0.0512042567,
0.0374712832,
-0.0245251171,
-0.0537205711,
-0.0606475361,
0.0137004303,
-0.021757843,
-0.0254052766,
0.0660645291,
0.0522611998,
-0.0346791781,
0.0138180628,
0.0817716047,
0.0272642281,
0.0285964701,
-0.0768253505,
-0.0484228022,
-0.002266359,
-0.0442213304,
-0.026529802,
0.0119239921,
0.0159903262,
0.0122152697,
0.0184521079,
-0.0852911472,
0.0279610008,
-0.0057854969,
0.0049392269,
0.004679291,
-0.0360000208,
-0.0500491746,
0.0760610104,
-0.0030340871,
0.0377192199,
-0.03211217,
0.012893171,
0.035970524,
-0.0001500292,
0.0561668091,
0.0181837808,
0.0323068239,
-0.0562238283,
-0.0503601916,
0.0283040535,
0.0604469292,
-0.0091197193,
0.0441852137,
-0.0558077693,
-0.0476464331,
0.0050772461,
0.0111670177,
-0.0524839982,
0.0010330817,
-0.0026879355,
0.0107414024,
-0.028848201,
-0.0324068815,
-0.0117462669,
-0.0264202505,
-0.0499600917,
-0.0468164608,
0.0322535597,
-0.0314830169,
0.0048138034,
-0.009750207,
-0.0197305568,
-0.0421708748,
0.0064661657,
-0.0434844829,
-0.0267956201,
0.0096686184,
-0.0073591261,
0.0314205885,
0.0160436239,
-0.0573825464,
-0.0203366168,
0.0089500416,
-0.0123991165,
0.0218257736,
0.0909318998,
-0.0292610973,
0.0139523596,
-0.0041503124,
0.0822064877,
0.0013949407,
0.0792708173,
0.0022372361,
-0.0047697714,
0.0275634769,
-0.0278090127,
-0.0247603245,
-0.0530800074,
-0.0211933237,
0.0372607708,
-0.0214679185,
-0.0896124095,
0.0172090419,
-0.0450847298,
2.695e-7,
0.083282873,
0.0740789548,
-0.018456351,
-0.0770533606,
-0.0077162245,
0.049193643,
0.0274535473,
0.0112010669,
0.0103240265,
0.0138615025,
0.0066972394,
0.0221166741,
-0.0029488022,
0.0208459701,
-0.0819407254,
-0.0396778397,
-0.0154250255,
-0.0113181872,
-0.0205151625,
0.030373821,
0.0969073698,
0.0808091909,
0.0340365805,
-0.0129379854,
-0.0310934521,
0.0018444776,
0.0157741755,
-0.0401142798,
0.0013688238,
0.0127675338,
0.0260685589,
-0.0060229925,
-0.0118141612,
-0.0429108962,
-0.0316147134,
0.0229415856,
0.0104311099,
0.0166259781,
0.0061230897,
-0.0738802701,
0.0403163545,
0.0278849602,
0.0200987551,
0.0188250598,
0.0151648195,
-0.0762716606,
-0.0174319968,
-0.0496387519,
-0.0118235368,
-0.0104045505,
0.0857573152,
-0.0040321914,
0.0011978921,
0.0045231031,
-0.0035031235,
-0.0714506209,
-0.0241965391,
-0.0851696357,
0.0381215513,
-0.0051243948,
-0.0252487045,
0.0173232555,
0.0363165997,
-0.0013119155,
0.0525406674,
0.0154040335,
0.024078019,
2.19762526e-34,
0.0712223947,
-0.0374041088,
0.0203589443,
-0.008371897,
0.0211038273,
0.0344895944,
-0.0248000026,
-0.0308363065,
0.000405443,
-0.0218332391,
0.0093176924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03347v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03347v4
|
Towards Interpretable Mental Health Analysis with Large Language Models
| 2023-04-06T19:53:59 | 2023-10-11T08:13:28 |
Kailai Yang, Shaoxiong Ji, Tianlin Zhang, Qianqian Xie, Ziyan Kuang, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The latest large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, exhibit strong
capabilities in automated mental health analysis. However, existing relevant
studies bear several limitations, including inadequate evaluations, lack of
prompting strategies, and ignorance of exploring LLMs for explainability. To
bridge these gaps, we comprehensively evaluate the mental health analysis and
emotional reasoning ability of LLMs on 11 datasets across 5 tasks. We explore
the effects of different prompting strategies with unsupervised and distantly
supervised emotional information. Based on these prompts, we explore LLMs for
interpretable mental health analysis by instructing them to generate
explanations for each of their decisions. We convey strict human evaluations to
assess the quality of the generated explanations, leading to a novel dataset
with 163 human-assessed explanations. We benchmark existing automatic
evaluation metrics on this dataset to guide future related works. According to
the results, ChatGPT shows strong in-context learning ability but still has a
significant gap with advanced task-specific methods. Careful prompt engineering
with emotional cues and expert-written few-shot examples can also effectively
improve performance on mental health analysis. In addition, ChatGPT generates
explanations that approach human performance, showing its great potential in
explainable mental health analysis.
|
[
0.0231509358,
0.0492011607,
-0.0271232743,
0.0061810999,
0.0060978257,
0.0454827808,
0.0526741669,
0.0069355895,
0.0515042506,
0.0227568541,
-0.0025889191,
-0.0039240532,
-0.0133557208,
0.0352139771,
0.0154654495,
-0.0841812268,
-0.0164182968,
0.0004966879,
0.0734947696,
0.010313469,
0.0069328239,
0.015636418,
-0.0210473705,
0.0693000481,
0.0122711649,
-0.0324945264,
-0.0240555946,
0.0079426356,
0.0209094472,
-0.063766107,
-0.0270380937,
0.0342794172,
0.0272239298,
-0.0367123708,
0.0000022441,
-0.020023277,
-0.0183059685,
-0.0019438285,
-0.0307923853,
-0.0283450931,
0.0285066571,
-0.0504973382,
0.0151515892,
0.0041061202,
-0.0037692115,
-0.0042573423,
0.0354983024,
0.0779265985,
0.0922933146,
0.0623890981,
-0.0208797511,
-0.0042760675,
-0.0260105766,
-0.0247017108,
0.0130512137,
-0.0226357393,
0.0296278279,
0.0159161724,
0.0201126188,
-0.028778661,
-0.0167582426,
0.0028595387,
0.0013707078,
-0.003799228,
-0.0231131762,
-0.0011307437,
-0.0098714819,
-0.0467686355,
0.0041319923,
0.1012500077,
-0.0122143421,
0.0363012329,
0.0284901746,
-0.0180102978,
-0.0054438584,
-0.0040685539,
-0.0384695716,
-0.0001266391,
0.0045435773,
0.009008484,
0.0048714047,
0.046355553,
0.0490332916,
0.0028936029,
0.007691781,
0.0426705219,
-0.0315722115,
-0.0106114652,
0.0111201089,
-0.0171176568,
-0.0467655845,
-0.0459978729,
0.0097926436,
0.0385843217,
-0.0601559393,
0.016007157,
0.0021801081,
-0.0112211518,
0.0015227696,
0.0043519572,
0.0099734925,
0.0494945347,
-0.06434948,
0.0053810049,
0.0413079821,
0.0462304614,
0.0069848145,
0.0085792849,
-0.0359872989,
-0.0093620969,
-0.0784717128,
-0.0013389209,
-0.0229656398,
-0.027126573,
-0.0220587384,
-0.0080463309,
-0.07745222,
-0.0001114281,
-0.056248866,
-0.0023743457,
0.0103232134,
0.0136805549,
0.0051022433,
-0.0022700483,
-0.0180295706,
-0.0071547516,
-0.0551830903,
-0.0041977777,
0.049174197,
-0.0456335135,
-0.0024371033,
0.0191828664,
-0.01422376,
-0.0367862768,
0.0109520573,
0.0619072281,
0.0485357046,
-0.0067911316,
-0.0313251056,
-0.0430970192,
-0.0386136323,
-0.0656399131,
-0.0267522596,
-0.0083926329,
0.0390439183,
0.0135284718,
0.0020442791,
-0.0387918577,
0.0267306659,
-0.033006914,
-0.028705027,
0.0753236637,
-0.0416860096,
0.0034698618,
-0.0323894545,
0.0346280038,
-0.042919416,
0.0497903489,
0.0199982841,
0.0240631569,
0.0266822018,
-0.0655705929,
0.0322604515,
-0.0180616118,
0.0220845155,
-0.0217817258,
0.0067402706,
-0.018537255,
-0.0387280695,
0.0616437607,
-0.0029914218,
0.0153874112,
-0.0030763326,
0.0357343219,
0.0366173647,
0.0556315258,
0.0197255518,
0.0465829223,
0.0088944072,
0.036865931,
-0.0098613556,
-0.0046035228,
-0.0614027306,
0.0362834483,
-0.0113043552,
-0.0287357066,
0.0178242289,
-0.012356027,
-0.0169188306,
-0.0767921582,
-0.0234564207,
-0.0145376502,
-0.0130280899,
0.028203249,
0.0165969711,
-0.0464175567,
-0.0069481391,
0.036753878,
0.0486931391,
-0.0384186096,
-0.0429303534,
-0.0721227303,
0.060610678,
0.1132727116,
0.0200388469,
-0.0377983712,
-0.0065624435,
-0.0044979854,
0.0289376937,
-0.0090924483,
0.0155208381,
0.0064159473,
0.0706126913,
-0.0438315533,
0.0013482982,
0.0055357413,
0.0149227148,
-0.0117169963,
-0.0261586923,
-0.0208294429,
-0.0005018702,
-0.0339683071,
-0.0523922667,
0.0201519448,
-0.013154557,
-0.0233965963,
0.0149297295,
0.0149326483,
0.0346803851,
0.0039636996,
0.0018351333,
0.0053349948,
0.0113253556,
-0.0463140644,
-0.0279724337,
0.0333756357,
-0.0408717617,
-0.0500276722,
-0.0021262865,
-0.0028568353,
-0.027256107,
0.0100491326,
-0.0601463467,
-0.0336395092,
-0.0051160776,
-0.049650766,
0.0092909755,
-0.0041701561,
-0.0174357854,
0.0080403928,
0.0319930613,
-0.0295947008,
0.0368175916,
-0.0042640571,
0.0053509069,
0.015830284,
-0.0096936282,
-0.0252091438,
-0.0438853838,
-0.0263163801,
-0.007945979,
-0.011415083,
-0.0119479913,
-0.047640942,
0.0027691175,
-0.0315110572,
-0.0168324076,
-0.1244952008,
-0.0029065695,
-0.0124195805,
-0.0191956013,
0.0122829275,
-0.0151691465,
-0.0154766198,
-0.0069197086,
-0.0324859843,
0.0294438303,
0.0378921367,
0.0276708417,
0.0318762772,
-0.0066802301,
-0.0207668934,
-0.0559678786,
-0.0040865531,
-0.0423121639,
0.0364519618,
0.0057477206,
0.0179038327,
-0.0521931835,
-0.0125530558,
-0.0455404036,
-0.0300144181,
-0.0235861838,
-0.0490727127,
0.0048160134,
-0.0024666032,
0.0351246223,
0.0577609167,
-0.0152603071,
0.0986631066,
0.0248102732,
0.0164358653,
-0.0361963063,
0.0042455937,
-0.0195013601,
0.0015949723,
-0.0233995616,
-0.0616715066,
-0.0368635878,
0.0752871484,
0.0234795045,
0.0288391877,
-0.0651336461,
0.0311043784,
0.0008623723,
-0.0068523954,
-0.0588328019,
-0.0116247889,
-0.0032351329,
0.0633969456,
-0.0066228649,
-0.0727692842,
0.068026945,
0.0063889343,
-0.0163686331,
-0.0260704048,
-0.0348918885,
-0.0336234719,
0.0756431147,
-0.019192202,
0.0048712669,
0.0288183633,
0.0079699084,
0.0217270758,
-0.0382855535,
-0.0221866835,
-0.03105231,
0.0200000182,
-0.0718621984,
-0.0372421518,
0.0400642492,
-0.020678198,
-0.0330929123,
-0.0518859774,
-0.067228511,
-0.0097367661,
0.0188438185,
-0.0026444336,
-0.0142409084,
-0.0006258783,
0.0503562614,
-0.0266424082,
-0.022953378,
-0.0168299656,
0.0030139189,
-0.0068154223,
0.0472684056,
0.0264236256,
0.0445059501,
-0.0401821211,
0.0587472208,
0.0309850182,
0.0059768795,
0.0163880847,
-0.0143040232,
0.0469917841,
-0.0635114089,
0.0255512241,
-0.0011438521,
0.0180041585,
0.0618507601,
-0.0521428138,
0.0082628028,
0.1309222281,
0.0115069235,
-0.0232823715,
0.0413928702,
-0.0236736927,
0.0020470317,
-0.0098254234,
0.0020138663,
-0.0297573358,
-0.0591462851,
-0.0060831578,
0.0662247986,
-0.0157824941,
-0.0278037954,
0.0094158053,
-0.0394992754,
0.0540654585,
-0.0190410092,
-0.0004664325,
-0.0066973888,
-0.0388303809,
0.0107260132,
-0.0384142362,
-0.0209122151,
-0.0256582983,
0.0324173123,
0.0017378996,
0.0171307474,
-0.0551182479,
-0.056506753,
0.0943807662,
-0.0054028057,
0.080068469,
0.0352808796,
0.0701999292,
0.0132186506,
-0.0374461971,
-0.0026328708,
0.029734645,
0.0258536972,
0.0152152879,
0.0928483233,
0.041156102,
-0.0242132228,
-0.0630729869,
0.0686743408,
-0.0401201062,
-0.0149102304,
0.008721807,
0.0897492245,
-0.0290227849,
-0.0123356432,
-0.0113048321,
0.0290904734,
0.0607481264,
0.0864894614,
0.0492390394,
-0.0669459999,
-0.0324330181,
-0.0072148112,
-0.0124687059,
-0.0247138832,
-0.0432672612,
0.0108453641,
-0.0105911419,
-0.0286766421,
-0.0335492529,
-0.0628765076,
0.0477354042,
-0.0022504688,
-0.017626632,
-0.0493568219,
-0.0142634027,
0.0261788871,
-0.0306836795,
0.0956944078,
0.0496683866,
0.0156265311,
-0.0206738617,
-0.0104513429,
0.0098025808,
-0.0283953883,
-0.0144764762,
0.0167267043,
-0.0334082469,
0.0056763673,
0.0391243063,
0.0384181552,
0.0220027138,
0.0120214466,
0.0074035823,
-0.0502258129,
0.0045444155,
0.0051582805,
-0.0353823863,
-0.0243323762,
0.0356838591,
0.0612210371,
0.017789999,
0.0572734922,
-0.0195743069,
0.0540983342,
0.0082753664,
0.011014414,
-0.0146455364,
0.0048011113,
0.0156965777,
0.020464262,
0.0432235487,
-0.0088546928,
-0.0493221395,
-0.0066019068,
-0.0237961244,
-0.0128594013,
0.0003792022,
-0.0386077017,
-0.0044671297,
0.0098347943,
-0.0167257804,
-0.0100537883,
-0.0755266547,
-0.0423477888,
-0.043940898,
-0.0284969546,
0.0540369675,
-0.0252809357,
0.0058311871,
0.0161868706,
0.0338085406,
-0.00921214,
0.029781742,
-0.0261530373,
0.0186548065,
0.0129899271,
0.1002792045,
0.0062438138,
-0.003052382,
0.0210539289,
0.039301347,
-0.029285321,
-0.0802685767,
0.028484419,
-0.0150501756,
0.0052655148,
-0.0036887845,
0.0658452809,
0.0030838149,
0.0150330514,
-0.0021866711,
0.0468794219,
-0.004942195,
-0.0310168881,
0.0163601656,
0.0042929421,
-0.0323091224,
-0.0266826954,
0.0684854686,
-0.0270948969,
0.0066899187,
0.0114630861,
-0.0138531327,
-0.0356970131,
0.0063720187,
0.0183038581,
0.0157400612,
-0.041297432,
0.0208789613,
-0.058712095,
-0.0595510751,
0.0104263723,
-0.0230051782,
-0.034521576,
-0.036359366,
0.0280791819,
0.0442177206,
-0.03392566,
-0.0169933978,
-0.0485963151,
0.0434669778,
-0.0481515378,
0.0073836269,
-0.0192258842,
-6.008969164e-33,
0.008962783,
-0.0415478647,
-0.0097816419,
-0.0369899645,
0.024881769,
0.0251425784,
-0.0664667115,
0.0175622143,
-0.0001586467,
0.0628655478,
0.0208001342,
0.041701179,
0.0018252596,
0.0412844568,
0.0128509551,
-0.0362715535,
0.0072203022,
0.0176856052,
-0.0043158857,
0.0431759655,
0.0362409689,
0.0483023971,
0.0328655168,
-0.1104504466,
0.0551069416,
0.0094349142,
-0.0159099083,
0.0163464099,
0.0018877308,
0.0381454676,
-0.0302171707,
0.0672178715,
0.0374299847,
-0.0212189537,
0.01106265,
0.0104466407,
-0.0254118536,
-0.0164935179,
0.0200618729,
-0.0351741351,
-0.0703838617,
-0.021675976,
0.0026923877,
0.0128334453,
0.0253413469,
-0.0282349158,
0.025455853,
-0.046947632,
0.0259792805,
-0.0065371199,
-0.0040956116,
0.0275240727,
-0.0470726676,
-0.0345777348,
0.0038999664,
0.0464271158,
-0.0582173467,
0.0348933451,
-0.0106490068,
-0.018386228,
0.0321981832,
-0.0106644034,
0.0332977138,
-0.0453395583,
-0.0190177429,
0.0618695058,
0.0363552868,
-0.0109725529,
-0.0664458647,
0.0041336017,
-0.0255088285,
0.0850620791,
0.1007614434,
0.0072731492,
-0.0095884167,
0.0123405177,
-0.0586171374,
0.0205158796,
0.0024174233,
0.0047997325,
0.040459197,
0.0049070059,
-0.0288017169,
-0.0208598319,
-0.0109526822,
0.0019285349,
-0.0380411632,
-0.0425576493,
0.0288856812,
-0.0314160921,
-0.0214259513,
-0.021866167,
-0.010419731,
-0.0317128114,
0.0424838439,
0.0101403305,
0.0006465297,
0.0024379347,
0.0216363613,
0.0015405566,
-0.0208813604,
-0.0072133592,
0.017858116,
0.0283949841,
0.0837002993,
-0.0091297729,
0.0465990864,
-0.0065008937,
-0.0112333316,
-0.0125765484,
-0.0434888974,
0.0294282828,
-0.0235691126,
0.0100461803,
-0.0267601758,
0.0222028662,
-0.0386585332,
0.021483792,
0.0182140488,
0.0226269383,
-0.0298087951,
-0.0071776272,
-0.0136704193,
0.0071675926,
-0.0306118745,
-0.0318308957,
-0.0255865715,
-0.0476992577,
0.04003115,
-0.0539171323,
0.0006317741,
-0.0195246767,
2.837e-7,
0.0263179466,
0.0655390397,
0.0039130012,
-0.0137289604,
0.0152815748,
0.0458482131,
-0.0037484136,
0.0145368883,
0.0108279893,
-0.023544006,
0.0380347483,
0.0391939543,
0.084218815,
0.043190401,
0.0102988342,
-0.0044169249,
-0.0603144616,
-0.0350427777,
-0.0506309569,
0.0350145809,
0.1286793053,
0.0899346396,
0.0141190216,
-0.0051409029,
0.0661139637,
0.0143509852,
0.0230849236,
-0.0555850677,
0.0043155849,
0.0179303531,
0.0373688787,
-0.0161745436,
0.028338667,
-0.0007595559,
0.005998488,
-0.0358879603,
-0.0167809967,
0.0896629244,
-0.0217546392,
-0.0256132148,
-0.0066555291,
0.0155174965,
0.004923638,
-0.0487472899,
0.0800874755,
-0.0930498987,
-0.073732093,
-0.0075451615,
-0.0057752691,
-0.0505519882,
0.001053845,
-0.0052381861,
0.0018816472,
0.0356552489,
-0.0006438305,
-0.0240856782,
0.0134362709,
-0.0712895393,
-0.0568363294,
0.0191329457,
-0.0467925034,
-0.0052348808,
-0.0315215848,
-0.0088964971,
0.0326934457,
-0.0746172145,
-0.0028052437,
2.463255989e-34,
0.0236523617,
0.0462596938,
-0.0007397529,
0.0091555566,
0.0509415753,
0.0308692679,
-0.0365194455,
0.0081698587,
0.0246214196,
-0.0676248297,
-0.0171537939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03325v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03325v1
|
ChatGPT-Crawler: Find out if ChatGPT really knows what it's talking about
| 2023-04-06T18:42:47 | 2023-04-06T18:42:47 |
Aman Rangapur, Haoran Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.7, I.m
|
Large language models have gained considerable interest for their impressive
performance on various tasks. Among these models, ChatGPT developed by OpenAI
has become extremely popular among early adopters who even regard it as a
disruptive technology in many fields like customer service, education,
healthcare, and finance. It is essential to comprehend the opinions of these
initial users as it can provide valuable insights into the potential strengths,
weaknesses, and success or failure of the technology in different areas. This
research examines the responses generated by ChatGPT from different
Conversational QA corpora. The study employed BERT similarity scores to compare
these responses with correct answers and obtain Natural Language Inference(NLI)
labels. Evaluation scores were also computed and compared to determine the
overall performance of GPT-3 \& GPT-4. Additionally, the study identified
instances where ChatGPT provided incorrect answers to questions, providing
insights into areas where the model may be prone to error.
|
[
0.0646605119,
0.0304415878,
-0.0292543173,
0.0319614671,
-0.0650305897,
0.0111513566,
-0.0171155538,
0.0149893966,
0.0567375124,
-0.0650398433,
-0.0113346586,
-0.0099949911,
0.0001404103,
0.0255702715,
-0.0086305505,
-0.0500315465,
0.0305732694,
0.0130002527,
0.0096753445,
0.0087861605,
0.0111386534,
0.0153415697,
-0.020604834,
0.0793441758,
0.0100940503,
-0.0291858036,
-0.0210016649,
-0.0191284921,
-0.0037289313,
-0.0176823903,
0.0293708444,
0.029618239,
-0.0015812331,
0.0796224475,
0.0000021558,
-0.0472943857,
-0.0228516832,
0.0153745711,
0.0050030323,
0.028828783,
0.0244178995,
0.0509253666,
-0.0010260311,
0.0613358021,
-0.0543223619,
-0.0084498581,
0.0665669292,
0.0493761338,
0.0530990697,
0.055865787,
-0.0253753699,
-0.0133455573,
0.0242577251,
0.0154468501,
0.0080317399,
-0.052496288,
0.0137180341,
0.0207400341,
0.0158183966,
-0.0104079051,
0.0054821186,
0.0301731061,
-0.0095072379,
-0.004674356,
-0.0230733715,
0.0430337042,
-0.0785919949,
-0.0295832939,
-0.0065494287,
0.0435593352,
0.0197555851,
-0.0241282526,
-0.0401098467,
-0.0025736138,
-0.0099356454,
0.0301054325,
-0.0455648154,
0.0149481846,
-0.0190595798,
0.0314656124,
-0.0229895338,
0.0027336737,
-0.0186364688,
-0.0141082341,
-0.0290973429,
0.0690218508,
0.0221057199,
-0.0424449258,
0.0197236035,
0.0158617161,
-0.0199184902,
-0.0441217534,
-0.0016709946,
0.031230066,
-0.0013102362,
0.0364266634,
0.0104701854,
-0.0193059742,
0.0459025502,
-0.0570470206,
-0.0234298408,
0.0684086829,
-0.0466724299,
0.015058863,
-0.0111816479,
0.064369753,
-0.0065934998,
0.0154064959,
-0.0460466854,
-0.0348675214,
-0.0685867816,
-0.0426839776,
-0.0598204657,
0.0661121383,
-0.0041318,
-0.0318264216,
-0.0308058839,
0.0397747718,
0.0204240065,
-0.0237192623,
0.0062835114,
0.0101237902,
-0.0046248753,
0.0252715871,
-0.0474347137,
0.0427874364,
-0.0495840237,
0.0133623518,
-0.0181569867,
-0.0921461433,
0.0102646369,
0.0356966853,
-0.0024602544,
-0.0274274293,
-0.0189536773,
0.061483562,
-0.0043430501,
-0.0364162624,
-0.0244317073,
0.0085713612,
-0.0219431035,
-0.036536552,
-0.0021745495,
-0.0532193631,
0.0089808004,
0.0352267995,
-0.0054232469,
0.0234253686,
0.0147506716,
0.041060742,
-0.0523647368,
0.0586899891,
-0.0271317568,
0.0241867471,
0.0480149351,
0.0021777588,
0.0124649554,
0.0529642217,
0.0114352722,
0.0036572111,
0.0483076535,
-0.0162173286,
-0.0084590474,
0.0254491828,
-0.011774864,
-0.0327516198,
0.0408864915,
0.034777835,
0.0077629806,
0.0165774059,
-0.0239772294,
0.0902926549,
-0.0197757557,
-0.0102525009,
0.0340489447,
0.1164637059,
-0.0024806878,
0.0441124104,
-0.0068306271,
0.0452343374,
0.0284232832,
0.0166332908,
0.0055380356,
-0.0074195419,
-0.0343913175,
0.0007033602,
0.0135726854,
0.0189293735,
-0.0100947972,
-0.0204979032,
-0.0472495556,
-0.0021606213,
0.0306268968,
-0.0193426404,
0.0276920665,
-0.0097080907,
-0.0493453443,
0.01856637,
0.0211196803,
-0.0573671125,
-0.0464933813,
-0.0888316259,
0.0105845137,
0.0505595505,
0.0534384027,
-0.0049252491,
-0.0819485113,
0.0234784894,
-0.0241491161,
0.0530716628,
0.0472680591,
0.0050299228,
-0.0410332121,
-0.03909944,
0.0101609435,
0.006247601,
0.0043760817,
0.0235468354,
0.01857909,
0.0398041755,
-0.0109917549,
-0.0344054438,
0.0090278117,
0.0252474267,
0.0083211707,
-0.0118356813,
-0.0128917079,
-0.009730448,
0.0338744037,
0.0135202762,
-0.0178175755,
0.0371590666,
0.0066326233,
0.0257253665,
-0.0228821933,
0.0265460256,
0.0015696046,
-0.0260099266,
0.0222589485,
-0.0503455177,
-0.0103914924,
0.0434959568,
-0.0076032057,
-0.0316030271,
-0.0107676787,
-0.0657880157,
0.076512225,
-0.0641777143,
-0.0174771678,
-0.0136497654,
-0.0041867718,
-0.0289348494,
0.0490945503,
0.0408048779,
0.006816403,
0.0192554388,
0.0115001528,
0.0524240844,
-0.0531999841,
-0.0500606671,
0.018007068,
-0.0090021333,
0.0114680594,
0.0310491864,
0.0286292583,
-0.0514332131,
-0.014967585,
-0.1501732469,
0.0015030387,
-0.0114821736,
0.0357162766,
0.0236545354,
0.0132877873,
-0.0174444988,
-0.0273451395,
-0.04354316,
0.0031011268,
0.0249942522,
0.0237257201,
0.0397312343,
-0.0066929706,
-0.0022898612,
-0.0598317534,
0.0202483982,
-0.0411815457,
0.0211267211,
0.0509364083,
-0.0512099601,
-0.0222051851,
-0.0061691748,
-0.0617428795,
0.0162097495,
0.0053556529,
-0.0503706224,
0.041902408,
-0.0178374834,
0.0160571598,
0.0149991494,
0.0275009777,
0.0522159897,
-0.0058432701,
-0.0250495113,
-0.0419090539,
0.0121945422,
-0.0438204333,
-0.0501996092,
0.0102641732,
-0.0349816717,
0.0309980493,
0.0481759645,
0.0244823657,
0.0019149816,
-0.0814575851,
-0.0065622488,
-0.0307582822,
0.0140483836,
-0.0389363654,
-0.0032425742,
-0.0244244281,
0.0401231311,
0.0238210112,
-0.0433985665,
0.0689418837,
-0.0125569068,
-0.003497856,
-0.0997564793,
-0.0011456267,
-0.0397877358,
0.072844781,
-0.0173265394,
0.0236261878,
0.0314888544,
-0.0465576984,
-0.0219441894,
0.0121034235,
0.0092169028,
-0.026372036,
0.0118812015,
-0.0463825837,
0.0363305323,
0.0212138072,
-0.0147471614,
-0.0441749059,
-0.0278328788,
-0.0153860087,
0.0016366455,
0.0400109924,
-0.0216610301,
-0.0267392546,
0.0336289778,
-0.0152542032,
-0.0079401089,
-0.0229909066,
-0.0098948237,
-0.0109374421,
0.071772255,
0.0535168014,
0.0202563889,
0.0159764644,
0.0312162656,
0.0260352325,
0.0761438832,
0.0189495366,
-0.0036614153,
-0.0214033052,
-0.0276263766,
0.0212802999,
-0.0428611562,
-0.0206839591,
0.0112060774,
0.0178490225,
-0.0203032866,
-0.0340547226,
0.115420036,
0.0695061609,
-0.0263398197,
-0.0141436895,
-0.0441033021,
0.0429455191,
-0.0262789372,
0.0243307073,
-0.0988895223,
-0.0209242292,
-0.0272646509,
0.0292393807,
-0.0137361316,
0.0006734952,
-0.0024737916,
-0.12757276,
0.0391299576,
-0.0405547395,
-0.0529901125,
-0.0098941624,
-0.0368554741,
0.0106676258,
0.0102610644,
0.0272122975,
0.0187226981,
-0.0064280303,
0.0249669235,
0.0215879735,
-0.0645172819,
-0.0146399653,
0.0483079962,
-0.0131461089,
0.0512273237,
0.0794442296,
0.0577212684,
-0.0092557492,
-0.0245285854,
0.0309803449,
-0.0312552676,
0.0050233067,
-0.0197208859,
0.0552293509,
-0.0164579321,
0.0125652198,
-0.0549804047,
-0.0055344617,
-0.0280553345,
0.0160168651,
0.023471415,
0.0683343038,
-0.047293622,
-0.0159019083,
-0.0304051302,
0.0161658563,
-0.013892347,
0.0732662231,
0.0338164009,
-0.005445106,
-0.0457770377,
-0.0232867356,
0.0358934589,
0.0116852084,
-0.0248103961,
-0.0013609977,
0.0024579016,
-0.0423060209,
-0.0808576047,
-0.0762361363,
0.0365603678,
-0.0211326368,
0.0015956234,
-0.0237909406,
0.0418396294,
0.0429611392,
-0.0160053764,
-0.003162222,
0.0042982865,
-0.0051782597,
-0.0426470451,
-0.0262750033,
0.0538644157,
0.0023985035,
-0.0283390228,
-0.0147121977,
-0.054608196,
-0.0473798178,
-0.0161621869,
0.0275133681,
0.035533987,
-0.0173506197,
-0.0407823287,
0.0076087262,
-0.0267607123,
0.0464558378,
-0.022900613,
-0.015435474,
-0.0087600416,
0.0399111807,
0.0200706236,
0.0178776868,
-0.0194229092,
-0.0030269099,
-0.0525687225,
0.0356812514,
-0.0155226532,
-0.063610658,
0.0393596441,
0.0450698361,
0.0477990545,
0.0386715718,
0.0022080122,
-0.0201437436,
0.0118405856,
-0.0403855108,
0.0192172024,
-0.0515824556,
-0.0106571978,
0.012513889,
-0.0033362997,
-0.0178322811,
-0.0156137887,
-0.0883355141,
0.0343903378,
-0.0434847325,
0.0124681136,
0.0263388027,
0.0279734712,
-0.021785209,
-0.0274279267,
-0.0314904377,
-0.0277165156,
0.0147485686,
0.0333887972,
-0.0084434822,
0.0705171525,
0.0071909237,
-0.0216780882,
0.0561125986,
0.0313315168,
-0.0583876669,
-0.0904370919,
-0.0268666577,
0.0710852891,
0.0208742321,
0.0221512839,
0.033212956,
-0.0334354527,
0.0046245027,
0.0127177583,
0.0171442498,
0.0133230705,
-0.0158528946,
0.0582146198,
-0.0090710679,
-0.0227201581,
-0.0406325012,
0.0832397565,
-0.0151155731,
0.021344766,
0.0088783046,
-0.0475762673,
-0.0328439623,
-0.0323754959,
0.0230606459,
0.026271075,
-0.006655917,
0.0088045243,
-0.0487704612,
-0.0366626382,
-0.0436237641,
0.0099441847,
0.0164550263,
-0.0022726161,
0.0550866239,
0.0765928105,
0.0176833738,
-0.0384980552,
-0.0290085897,
0.019211879,
-0.0671789944,
-0.0080354121,
-0.0330263861,
-6.772352094e-33,
-0.0274998099,
-0.0586585216,
0.008077682,
0.0168609116,
-0.0176865701,
-0.018641172,
-0.0280911922,
0.0138644986,
-0.0463159271,
-0.0074661826,
-0.0151925972,
0.02323162,
0.0153497262,
0.0187646784,
0.0025479784,
-0.0321080163,
0.0080494536,
0.0039946367,
-0.0115268594,
0.0198789183,
0.0246576555,
0.0178695172,
0.0698897839,
-0.0483727157,
0.0473822504,
-0.0193957649,
-0.0027551909,
0.0080086812,
0.0019093796,
0.0462789536,
-0.0430060662,
0.0425147191,
0.0294374861,
-0.0031750167,
0.0244865213,
0.042083554,
-0.021247318,
-0.0630562305,
0.0341554694,
0.0217673481,
-0.0164183956,
0.0211626403,
0.006040528,
-0.0308523607,
-0.0211802404,
0.0279207677,
0.0556982942,
0.0006907794,
0.0075131329,
0.0212737005,
-0.0659943596,
0.0254334714,
-0.0122948904,
-0.0151031213,
-0.0210325122,
0.0644773766,
-0.0186301414,
0.0111994175,
-0.0145862978,
0.0118578319,
0.0377173759,
-0.005910493,
0.035791371,
-0.0342896245,
0.0088684158,
0.0473096818,
0.0084266504,
-0.0263742916,
-0.030262826,
-0.0391327552,
0.0022686773,
0.0242512356,
0.0338893011,
0.0052912021,
-0.0118535068,
-0.004182958,
-0.0433611199,
0.0395008549,
0.0591130964,
0.0278126989,
0.0128560476,
0.0038600126,
-0.0505779833,
-0.0152597409,
0.0079422547,
0.0181299038,
-0.0407062732,
-0.0563209169,
0.041402176,
-0.0538470261,
-0.0066695265,
-0.0007520233,
0.0128490021,
-0.0378874727,
0.0156968497,
-0.0292720143,
-0.0285085049,
0.0224163458,
-0.0228802655,
0.0408141762,
-0.0676139891,
0.0101396851,
0.0147538846,
0.0028964621,
0.0006860908,
0.0147244493,
-0.0272712689,
-0.0192973427,
-0.061195109,
-0.0027794007,
-0.0221317504,
-0.007868655,
-0.0269701835,
-0.0034702027,
0.0138387624,
0.0275658425,
0.0007270059,
0.0386363044,
0.018894786,
0.039617423,
-0.0720716789,
-0.0182624515,
-0.0155256735,
-0.035757158,
-0.03832734,
0.0167738982,
-0.0184703469,
0.0443187803,
-0.035615813,
-0.0560571626,
-0.0103750285,
0.0185562391,
2.857e-7,
0.0961182639,
0.0787783936,
0.032968767,
0.0099790329,
0.0122529976,
0.0170348696,
0.0105071198,
0.0178614575,
0.0599009953,
0.0294168834,
0.0207609832,
-0.0192652028,
0.013571837,
0.0562666543,
-0.0723689124,
-0.0122482479,
-0.0783127621,
-0.0482372753,
-0.0503003523,
0.03600033,
0.1012208387,
0.0882635787,
-0.0204384197,
0.0098750461,
-0.0335766524,
-0.0354449376,
0.0604433045,
-0.0168832187,
-0.0254428219,
0.0326812007,
0.049660556,
0.0105132274,
0.0090865325,
0.027063366,
0.0190395452,
-0.0091338884,
0.0415303409,
0.0033384396,
-0.0112810098,
-0.0564904548,
0.004010594,
-0.0258314032,
0.0035769136,
-0.1182595193,
0.0689123347,
-0.0508335829,
-0.0435015894,
-0.000002151,
-0.0134159001,
-0.0231045056,
0.0254559033,
-0.0234126877,
-0.0491386093,
0.0181638598,
0.0097844619,
-0.0178609472,
-0.0050236159,
-0.0328671038,
0.026822811,
-0.0231590066,
-0.0515844636,
-0.0719217956,
-0.016266305,
-0.024012113,
0.0257489104,
-0.0420679301,
0.0241208859,
2.481859335e-34,
0.035348352,
0.0056406343,
0.0041659502,
0.0367883332,
0.0451701581,
0.0323360115,
0.0713781044,
0.0121452902,
0.0008101253,
-0.0682836175,
-0.0310749914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03279v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03279v4
|
Do the Rewards Justify the Means? Measuring Trade-Offs Between Rewards and Ethical Behavior in the MACHIAVELLI Benchmark
| 2023-04-06T17:59:03 | 2023-06-13T01:01:42 |
Alexander Pan, Jun Shern Chan, Andy Zou, Nathaniel Li, Steven Basart, Thomas Woodside, Jonathan Ng, Hanlin Zhang, Scott Emmons, Dan Hendrycks
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Artificial agents have traditionally been trained to maximize reward, which
may incentivize power-seeking and deception, analogous to how next-token
prediction in language models (LMs) may incentivize toxicity. So do agents
naturally learn to be Machiavellian? And how do we measure these behaviors in
general-purpose models such as GPT-4? Towards answering these questions, we
introduce MACHIAVELLI, a benchmark of 134 Choose-Your-Own-Adventure games
containing over half a million rich, diverse scenarios that center on social
decision-making. Scenario labeling is automated with LMs, which are more
performant than human annotators. We mathematize dozens of harmful behaviors
and use our annotations to evaluate agents' tendencies to be power-seeking,
cause disutility, and commit ethical violations. We observe some tension
between maximizing reward and behaving ethically. To improve this trade-off, we
investigate LM-based methods to steer agents' towards less harmful behaviors.
Our results show that agents can both act competently and morally, so concrete
progress can currently be made in machine ethics--designing agents that are
Pareto improvements in both safety and capabilities.
|
[
0.0325660519,
0.0783528388,
-0.0408842564,
0.0482415706,
-0.0530911945,
0.0080749216,
-0.023083698,
0.0028327564,
0.0124067636,
0.0221912581,
-0.0121879075,
0.0166792572,
-0.0178605933,
0.0232096501,
0.0038042164,
-0.0255334135,
0.0354731232,
-0.0232272446,
0.0595233031,
0.0028243377,
-0.0332311019,
-0.012124612,
0.0250186715,
0.0174568854,
0.0037706217,
-0.0210441537,
0.0172836985,
-0.0056361323,
0.0680168644,
-0.0353502296,
0.0126923295,
-0.0048893909,
0.0303896554,
0.0419357978,
0.000002216,
-0.0632706583,
-0.0249928068,
-0.0161960274,
0.0117717525,
-0.0240728091,
0.0731960908,
0.0362682939,
0.0166635755,
0.0079318909,
-0.0699811503,
0.0102220736,
0.0284491293,
0.010865964,
0.0118042668,
0.0570070855,
0.0011355836,
0.0253360774,
0.0048560584,
-0.0219097249,
-0.0027082055,
-0.0581075884,
0.0084587941,
-0.0429174416,
-0.0330871418,
-0.0215963814,
0.0084118843,
-0.0062631355,
0.0005461278,
0.0189115256,
0.0065535493,
0.0373891294,
0.0530205294,
-0.0143483337,
-0.0121085523,
0.0316366553,
-0.0145144016,
0.0051481421,
0.0203953926,
0.0040471489,
0.037562497,
-0.0164155085,
0.0285629705,
0.0561548434,
-0.0269876663,
0.0095004812,
0.0562483817,
0.0567733236,
0.0389213152,
0.0293524619,
0.0603863671,
0.0521909036,
-0.0214887876,
-0.0122129135,
0.0175759345,
0.0034737906,
-0.0110038314,
-0.0408506691,
-0.0188610889,
0.023507664,
-0.0569670796,
0.0102055231,
-0.0163495075,
0.0776790157,
0.0324522667,
-0.0457251668,
0.0359062031,
0.0032764,
0.0178659223,
0.027627714,
0.0317975096,
0.0081048924,
0.0024735064,
0.0582547374,
-0.0414608233,
0.0351644829,
0.0147080664,
0.0112836156,
-0.0284510255,
0.0250345506,
-0.0215108693,
0.0268811677,
-0.0191882681,
0.0150103485,
-0.0757412687,
0.0341243297,
-0.0351029374,
0.0281140264,
-0.0126665831,
0.0215435736,
-0.0735237449,
-0.062570788,
-0.1010843888,
0.0048567462,
-0.0094398567,
0.0264579318,
-0.008911809,
-0.0355176404,
-0.0237992555,
-0.0028994989,
0.0540403873,
0.1817451864,
0.0321545564,
-0.0248405319,
-0.0377273485,
-0.0482988283,
0.0255255904,
-0.0530469567,
-0.0197642688,
-0.0188027248,
0.0228011049,
-0.032965418,
-0.0076973373,
-0.0447064266,
0.0082278894,
-0.0001295578,
-0.0308542028,
0.074697651,
0.0232431367,
0.0105084293,
0.0150444517,
0.0128324348,
-0.0874500424,
0.0287927967,
0.0677374154,
0.0558877289,
0.0446135662,
0.0004399286,
0.0608001277,
0.042403169,
-0.0223528631,
0.0236062333,
0.0369749963,
-0.0318099968,
-0.0153319817,
0.0586682893,
0.0154669704,
0.0275884829,
-0.0355043113,
-0.0113606844,
0.0781719759,
0.0540728718,
-0.023238102,
-0.0138051063,
0.0362207405,
-0.0202543214,
-0.0291453693,
-0.0034545998,
-0.0348635539,
0.0207976215,
0.0031283675,
-0.0250609461,
-0.082372047,
0.0298044048,
0.0135428142,
-0.0290710013,
0.0344217345,
-0.0385357514,
0.0757969245,
0.0427936539,
-0.0017145937,
-0.0191498715,
-0.0592593886,
-0.0617124885,
0.0533674508,
-0.0337729044,
0.0133963292,
-0.0737806931,
0.0538506061,
0.0853603035,
0.0469007641,
-0.0366192497,
-0.0095775705,
-0.0485266745,
-0.0324994512,
0.0041052774,
0.0234364588,
-0.0523698777,
0.0372492,
-0.0139197279,
-0.020129744,
-0.0036573582,
0.0030720388,
0.0650141612,
0.0054763677,
-0.0267795641,
-0.025932176,
-0.0002209809,
-0.0483515859,
0.0519531779,
-0.0076218643,
-0.0391913466,
-0.0046150223,
0.0110084685,
0.0363805145,
-0.0119832996,
-0.0004297961,
-0.0051876619,
0.0193700157,
-0.0014986782,
-0.0063574226,
0.0050920374,
-0.0267751906,
0.0556033552,
0.0296958238,
-0.0570488721,
-0.0057917861,
0.0315889008,
0.0075844689,
0.0403069817,
-0.0335022137,
-0.0209437273,
0.0076013692,
-0.0117625669,
0.0067922277,
-0.0515364893,
-0.0048903511,
-0.0311463382,
0.0680153444,
-0.0139651699,
-0.0344833583,
-0.0498852246,
-0.0441244915,
-0.0075628776,
-0.0051673781,
0.0197280552,
-0.0234336127,
0.0041708085,
0.0298702549,
0.0661628321,
0.0306835566,
-0.0367897265,
-0.036811728,
-0.0354790725,
0.0096422499,
0.0040645427,
-0.0136791449,
-0.0072964793,
-0.0400828272,
-0.0023376127,
0.0110317441,
-0.0216814205,
-0.0066047474,
0.0073249382,
0.0022098422,
0.0211424511,
0.0041696746,
-0.023838276,
-0.0255956315,
0.0169243645,
-0.0398710184,
-0.0083536329,
0.0282928497,
0.0661794469,
-0.0187473856,
-0.0022198283,
-0.0552082174,
0.0087835537,
-0.0222876519,
-0.0404111445,
0.0265984908,
0.0271667223,
-0.0138572231,
0.0926147252,
0.0524743907,
0.0702630505,
0.0820199102,
0.0196290594,
-0.0164623149,
0.0016310165,
-0.0143247033,
-0.0385264382,
-0.0512757599,
-0.062855117,
0.012652209,
0.0659324452,
-0.0335082039,
0.0137258191,
-0.0448133834,
0.0566352755,
-0.0272891019,
-0.0650473237,
0.0292063411,
-0.0694584027,
-0.0182558503,
0.0314485542,
-0.0183980595,
-0.0355619416,
0.0917994902,
0.0188274607,
0.0480887294,
0.0239157379,
0.003265999,
0.0084040035,
0.0640819743,
0.0417235903,
0.0233399794,
-0.0147666,
0.0090648187,
-0.0461312234,
-0.0483195931,
0.0940637365,
-0.0469021834,
0.038444519,
-0.0645087585,
-0.0406461507,
0.0268679969,
-0.0680491924,
-0.02686847,
-0.0476730391,
-0.0170076229,
-0.0266607273,
0.0140881073,
-0.0107496744,
-0.0115290051,
-0.0496452413,
0.0248895213,
-0.0200304855,
0.0023825504,
-0.0022596419,
-0.0165143553,
-0.0485132262,
0.071623221,
-0.0122989714,
0.0565463379,
-0.03491842,
0.0442886464,
0.0286326148,
-0.005542465,
-0.0275781341,
-0.0034706318,
0.0329747349,
0.0042462456,
-0.0348771363,
0.0233478993,
0.0476752035,
-0.0139102573,
-0.0106604444,
0.0140409069,
0.0781449154,
0.0059872516,
-0.043233674,
0.0379505195,
-0.0057056067,
0.0169022027,
0.0117446445,
-0.0061273351,
-0.0816422477,
0.0071264245,
0.0039867172,
0.0608572364,
-0.0752322972,
-0.0727187097,
0.0457630791,
-0.0790174827,
0.0204990432,
0.0230148435,
-0.035355825,
0.0107249813,
-0.0123517159,
-0.0456868485,
-0.0758305863,
-0.0181773026,
-0.0099132648,
0.0161669292,
-0.0428661928,
-0.0070061046,
0.0161018167,
0.0369767807,
0.0504174866,
-0.0894751847,
0.0533640943,
0.0600280836,
0.0622807145,
-0.0593662523,
-0.0352485999,
-0.0364362486,
0.0692747906,
-0.0110681942,
0.0326334089,
0.0495655797,
-0.053363543,
0.0031617167,
-0.0186501909,
0.005347969,
0.0391765237,
-0.035707131,
0.0458080843,
0.0547202528,
0.0332062691,
-0.0683482364,
-0.0030200407,
-0.0164828096,
0.0445599258,
0.0580001809,
-0.0401531868,
-0.0176245216,
-0.0167819373,
-0.0150997574,
-0.0030734292,
-0.0539074242,
-0.012130959,
-0.0434124582,
-0.007182728,
-0.0032644388,
-0.0681366026,
-0.0799974948,
-0.0152953314,
0.0046320604,
0.0277884137,
-0.0474639647,
0.0028007752,
0.0487753004,
-0.0268816799,
-0.012535641,
-0.0213073101,
-0.0137256775,
0.0029926721,
0.0013099653,
-0.0151913846,
-0.0301173124,
0.011449825,
0.0312318448,
0.0118322074,
-0.0260306038,
0.0280581862,
0.096602954,
0.0206815545,
0.0422959551,
-0.009450783,
0.007649607,
0.0257289484,
0.0111379353,
-0.0680617169,
0.020077819,
0.0330039412,
0.0001351314,
-0.0012476816,
-0.0064203064,
-0.0555798113,
0.0140083339,
0.0114515573,
0.0260793809,
-0.0630197823,
0.0265354421,
0.0212094132,
-0.0059126695,
0.0336399078,
-0.0711975396,
-0.0224291533,
-0.0061629717,
-0.0356523879,
-0.0038200202,
-0.0186389647,
0.0029372557,
-0.0294546075,
0.0475752465,
0.0186098609,
-0.0180603545,
-0.0120969405,
-0.0266374666,
-0.0107842917,
-0.0003122622,
-0.0182700213,
0.0276888143,
0.0149559099,
-0.0033309448,
-0.0027093231,
-0.0171749033,
0.0180206094,
0.0041723545,
0.0532268323,
0.0062170341,
0.0257012974,
0.016931152,
0.0288793929,
-0.0123042762,
0.040414039,
-0.0356967412,
-0.0469046533,
0.0153712751,
0.0131253758,
0.0267484244,
-0.010377937,
0.0457013361,
-0.0365186408,
0.0012416017,
-0.0003377549,
-0.0158089381,
-0.0298438147,
-0.0574293062,
-0.0316819288,
0.0280508064,
-0.0329483896,
0.0350962356,
0.0354274884,
0.0058989753,
0.0617200285,
-0.024688378,
-0.0320642777,
-0.0054119546,
-0.0412046649,
0.0487494729,
-0.0004465336,
-0.0114134103,
-0.0429694802,
-0.1042244285,
-0.0248214621,
-0.0317393616,
0.0681524575,
0.018169621,
-0.0472652912,
-0.0173554569,
0.00598012,
-0.0215764791,
0.0052253585,
-0.0675896779,
-0.020463502,
-0.0238841232,
0.0027069533,
-0.0445622019,
-5.541491224e-33,
-0.0137385437,
-0.0246769562,
0.0227111485,
0.0448941551,
-0.0351166762,
-0.0273519009,
-0.000402688,
-0.0121242376,
-0.0391067266,
0.0146891242,
-0.0023242482,
-0.0485641174,
-0.0064156195,
-0.0424522609,
0.0204641167,
-0.0630729645,
-0.0085842106,
-0.0086519094,
-0.0567452312,
0.0178418495,
-0.0352741927,
0.0028486738,
0.0346304998,
-0.0547216497,
0.0192751605,
0.0147406925,
-0.0307649318,
0.0275961459,
-0.0258751009,
0.0063332771,
0.0322179869,
0.0004550863,
0.0092111565,
-0.0228809733,
0.0251321979,
0.0085176891,
-0.0321592428,
-0.0016342758,
0.0199358128,
-0.0439498611,
-0.0362164751,
-0.0719884783,
0.0034966525,
0.0131355049,
-0.0312113687,
-0.0354489535,
0.0526126847,
-0.0034453557,
0.0081890654,
-0.0103297047,
-0.0784864351,
-0.0201596078,
-0.0345748775,
-0.0247687809,
-0.0023518705,
0.0418247394,
0.0027865837,
0.0204336382,
-0.0404004976,
0.0521255657,
-0.0024000523,
-0.0587632842,
0.0132212685,
0.0125700599,
0.0272827744,
0.0586042404,
0.0522786193,
0.0432511158,
-0.0530954339,
0.0175945703,
0.0313562937,
0.0432925448,
0.0495688096,
0.0463012531,
-0.0195431132,
-0.0498076901,
-0.0276115239,
0.0360008255,
0.0302100405,
0.0045784609,
0.0153793218,
-0.0186126344,
-0.0500438511,
-0.0105898753,
-0.0393593386,
-0.0447217897,
-0.0040177838,
-0.0226163696,
0.0053328201,
-0.0359944403,
-0.0246865172,
-0.0269385129,
0.0043975799,
-0.0448004529,
0.0209289137,
0.0082902992,
0.024042299,
-0.0026422248,
-0.0172316357,
0.0092849946,
-0.0109003857,
-0.0154309161,
-0.014180813,
-0.0394919403,
0.0671088248,
0.0203736871,
0.0192754511,
0.0222406127,
0.0202528816,
0.0217211172,
-0.0186364371,
0.0358527079,
0.019104708,
-0.0285236258,
0.0233287793,
-0.0290248804,
0.010907989,
-0.0590341948,
0.0012944039,
0.0012989754,
-0.0303449277,
0.0381078608,
-0.0318685807,
0.0138625214,
0.0072578322,
0.0166517459,
-0.0371579118,
0.0454520807,
0.0031177665,
-0.0314038806,
-0.0225574486,
-0.0476716533,
2.846e-7,
-0.043442145,
0.0381084792,
0.0044297958,
0.0211902391,
-0.0333861522,
0.1053749025,
0.0071598175,
0.0599595569,
0.0115799475,
-0.0454416983,
0.0621195212,
0.0080806827,
0.034608379,
0.0320750251,
-0.0143026607,
-0.029912414,
-0.0219724178,
-0.012211524,
-0.0265065301,
0.0018805991,
0.032447096,
0.010210813,
0.0690978467,
-0.0274701845,
0.0257458165,
-0.0172409378,
0.0105460584,
-0.0918650553,
-0.0049915318,
0.0255544987,
-0.027819436,
0.0005866517,
-0.0253350139,
0.0105975922,
-0.0017903434,
-0.0053444374,
-0.0179253593,
0.0549761988,
-0.024855243,
-0.0470331125,
-0.0172280204,
-0.0221760329,
0.0189099703,
-0.0385854952,
0.0267217457,
0.0203987416,
-0.0060661039,
-0.0284775756,
-0.0057142484,
-0.0185934324,
0.0003978255,
-0.0176724046,
-0.0188761186,
-0.0092685744,
0.0127925705,
0.0379157402,
0.0111149959,
-0.0367478915,
0.0136453789,
0.0187014155,
0.0092385495,
-0.0774698332,
0.0128159951,
0.1055103391,
-0.0043582469,
-0.0371342711,
0.0244365819,
2.270817232e-34,
-0.0428023413,
-0.033729963,
0.016506169,
-0.0094886869,
0.0826183259,
0.063617073,
-0.012220283,
0.0139700314,
0.028111659,
0.0178115349,
0.0082109487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03277v1
|
Instruction Tuning with GPT-4
| 2023-04-06T17:58:09 | 2023-04-06T17:58:09 |
Baolin Peng, Chunyuan Li, Pengcheng He, Michel Galley, Jianfeng Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prior work has shown that finetuning large language models (LLMs) using
machine-generated instruction-following data enables such models to achieve
remarkable zero-shot capabilities on new tasks, and no human-written
instructions are needed. In this paper, we present the first attempt to use
GPT-4 to generate instruction-following data for LLM finetuning. Our early
experiments on instruction-tuned LLaMA models show that the 52K English and
Chinese instruction-following data generated by GPT-4 leads to superior
zero-shot performance on new tasks to the instruction-following data generated
by previous state-of-the-art models. We also collect feedback and comparison
data from GPT-4 to enable a comprehensive evaluation and reward model training.
We make our data generated using GPT-4 as well as our codebase publicly
available.
|
[
0.0073722885,
0.0379793495,
-0.0065240557,
0.0301786307,
0.0115113147,
0.032346528,
-0.0107596954,
-0.014842581,
-0.0282745007,
-0.0347669721,
-0.0790017843,
-0.0214748755,
-0.0126901371,
-0.0175225791,
0.0420997441,
-0.049283877,
0.0483951084,
-0.0430188328,
-0.0325630903,
0.009008701,
0.0088754203,
0.0217416547,
-0.0061832704,
0.0326006748,
0.041586332,
-0.0324317925,
-0.0231807623,
0.0311033633,
0.0237222165,
-0.0323502123,
0.0205980912,
0.0351302624,
0.0213805512,
0.0135955466,
0.0000019881,
-0.0234945659,
0.0077588866,
-0.0158605911,
-0.0298722107,
0.0538122244,
0.0344156139,
-0.018222101,
-0.0415930487,
0.029942777,
0.0015121109,
0.0008701174,
0.038015645,
0.0014410341,
0.0730829835,
0.0914926827,
0.0138137601,
-0.0409772545,
0.0198173318,
-0.0371291824,
0.0084406212,
-0.0591796711,
-0.0002006512,
0.0013352132,
0.0308230966,
0.0202210769,
-0.0387782678,
0.0111212777,
0.0319619812,
0.024543738,
-0.0443112589,
0.0434372574,
-0.0210485347,
0.0147688128,
-0.0394881368,
0.0670488253,
-0.0419191681,
-0.0173945874,
-0.011839103,
-0.0228072088,
-0.0018217653,
-0.0460719168,
-0.0452856012,
0.0338485725,
-0.0034557555,
0.0280615613,
0.0301335622,
-0.052727174,
0.0217389204,
0.0087741595,
-0.0051873559,
0.0633598939,
0.0128566511,
-0.0495043881,
-0.0070097982,
-0.0100347735,
-0.0400795564,
-0.0333592594,
-0.0133170411,
0.0491652302,
-0.0375403017,
0.0295903254,
-0.0711692721,
0.0128839798,
-0.0056866738,
-0.0027141697,
0.1056572348,
0.0727163106,
-0.0231680591,
0.0085028922,
-0.0250069425,
0.0723306239,
-0.0309059955,
0.0284062121,
-0.043841362,
0.0264946595,
-0.0843541548,
0.019950388,
-0.0335369073,
0.0365757383,
-0.0354486741,
0.0100641754,
-0.0473122224,
0.0403464586,
0.004584115,
0.001728653,
0.0229267366,
-0.0390230268,
-0.0844755918,
-0.0033074457,
-0.0122357607,
0.021827342,
-0.0366895273,
0.0228270851,
0.0006275686,
-0.0632424653,
-0.0059563564,
0.0034294997,
-0.020382395,
-0.0301796999,
0.0416571833,
0.0727586076,
-0.0316080265,
-0.0272771735,
-0.0523558967,
-0.011364718,
0.0297476389,
-0.0605097115,
-0.0059021087,
-0.0452017896,
0.009476915,
-0.0186971761,
0.0173215065,
0.0067185406,
0.003436445,
0.0315903984,
-0.0050600376,
0.0442355126,
0.0100681195,
0.0084697818,
-0.0019637186,
-0.0041094497,
0.0080356756,
0.0762895197,
0.0391278975,
0.0374253169,
0.0058184811,
-0.0142675908,
0.0003904985,
0.061892204,
0.0106560001,
0.0267492402,
0.0088293217,
-0.004919346,
0.0043166149,
0.0134735527,
0.0631349906,
0.0164309144,
-0.0169124883,
0.0330541171,
0.0490847751,
0.0423666984,
-0.0123443566,
-0.0111699747,
0.0725013018,
-0.0008202472,
-0.0136057213,
0.0215128884,
-0.0782348961,
0.032215409,
-0.0034229318,
0.02253896,
-0.0003021696,
0.0215900894,
-0.0391948335,
-0.0170252491,
0.0128567265,
0.000808717,
-0.0227534641,
0.0090125296,
0.0311761703,
-0.0236136448,
-0.0808849111,
0.0035895021,
0.024854375,
-0.0276206527,
-0.0160976667,
-0.0696814284,
0.0007359677,
0.0829289183,
0.0224232003,
-0.0021134634,
-0.0718319938,
0.0074539292,
0.0426085889,
0.0302574299,
0.0247881599,
-0.0025416354,
0.019198209,
-0.0533224531,
-0.0148311378,
-0.0248185452,
0.0126637621,
0.0275648944,
0.0260360371,
-0.0047415979,
0.0145541606,
0.0233903918,
-0.0513610952,
0.0413118154,
-0.0185845792,
-0.0664635077,
0.0072793257,
-0.000229897,
0.0313895345,
-0.0060525779,
-0.023822397,
-0.0010662763,
0.0265722331,
-0.0092086699,
0.0482978113,
-0.0110372463,
-0.055355072,
-0.0146896942,
0.0393012539,
-0.0025331941,
0.012750715,
0.0222308878,
-0.0711462051,
-0.0533034988,
0.0068711285,
-0.0123344213,
0.0136845103,
-0.0114637529,
0.0450952947,
-0.0037292978,
-0.0019393739,
-0.0276864134,
0.0203208234,
-0.015178266,
0.0145808514,
0.0369290635,
0.0253770147,
0.0058174664,
-0.0518359765,
-0.0223664511,
0.0064298715,
0.0094102565,
0.0327332057,
-0.0194179341,
0.0555483885,
-0.034349639,
-0.0362278707,
-0.0766329318,
0.067415975,
-0.034134306,
0.0570929535,
0.0603070594,
-0.0074101957,
-0.0165861007,
-0.0257887691,
-0.0015158817,
-0.0013173284,
-0.003569162,
0.0074339649,
0.0068545491,
0.0214314461,
-0.0424672738,
-0.0548486561,
-0.0139903277,
-0.0160103478,
-0.0550500341,
-0.0356248654,
0.0319090448,
-0.0797084644,
0.0366164371,
0.01161566,
0.066619873,
-0.0187619347,
-0.0789541826,
0.036313545,
-0.0010590953,
0.0229115747,
0.0982098356,
-0.0398331992,
0.0228900388,
0.0391829126,
-0.0175910629,
-0.0369159393,
0.0403268188,
-0.003530252,
-0.073096782,
-0.0456313305,
-0.0172833223,
0.0031342236,
0.0994794816,
-0.0129453326,
0.0062219305,
-0.09350501,
-0.0165133271,
-0.0182818249,
0.0021031632,
0.0046504708,
0.0193088166,
-0.0405165665,
-0.0016095419,
-0.0540766008,
-0.0714489967,
0.0436891131,
-0.038381774,
-0.0121873394,
-0.0316847898,
-0.0050265258,
-0.0113749122,
0.027219953,
0.0195947234,
-0.0004912034,
-0.0131630236,
-0.0140912365,
-0.0535730757,
0.0075988998,
0.0007771862,
-0.0164591204,
0.0525100082,
-0.0564605705,
-0.0098416209,
-0.0208755825,
-0.0272843577,
-0.0043437295,
-0.0013624424,
-0.0048326026,
0.0285475776,
0.0414808951,
-0.0378618389,
0.0024278415,
-0.0023855059,
0.0185307991,
0.0589042492,
-0.030399492,
0.001719936,
-0.0621500872,
-0.0324679576,
0.0640552267,
-0.0197630841,
-0.0529383495,
-0.0593168922,
0.0031183376,
-0.0025672934,
0.0589112714,
-0.0104120132,
-0.0259117708,
0.0207849126,
0.0338314772,
-0.0407881439,
-0.0287835933,
0.0588853136,
0.0823929161,
-0.0741283894,
-0.0001575058,
0.1093727872,
0.0180293787,
-0.0399884321,
-0.0030685065,
0.0205809716,
0.0144052617,
0.0307535604,
0.0512764528,
-0.0837900788,
-0.0353618972,
0.0012750173,
0.0567048565,
0.0054802415,
0.007752521,
-0.0078970473,
-0.1270764917,
0.0231498666,
0.0078216419,
-0.0573970266,
-0.0391233936,
-0.0124548348,
-0.0053379536,
-0.0093560982,
0.0104980068,
0.0202847607,
-0.0306916423,
0.0133081768,
0.0439033695,
0.0118241701,
-0.0793616623,
0.0550515167,
-0.0247638468,
0.0746392012,
0.0993766636,
-0.0046620155,
0.0115253553,
-0.0353875682,
0.0161781665,
-0.0306848921,
0.0017589068,
-0.0114310123,
0.0202220567,
-0.0305586811,
-0.0291314051,
0.0213561095,
0.0285352729,
0.0038346916,
0.0286504962,
0.0221284926,
0.0604569428,
-0.0152357975,
0.0224838592,
0.0097195636,
-0.0422527567,
-0.0076629324,
0.0304901469,
0.0244342908,
-0.0285717137,
-0.0335568152,
-0.0419151671,
-0.0312968604,
-0.1022129655,
-0.006738408,
0.0209486987,
-0.0607945509,
-0.0129497377,
-0.0441516079,
-0.0541162416,
0.0400516577,
0.0156219965,
0.0337012671,
-0.0186409466,
0.0262772702,
-0.0151119139,
-0.036785882,
0.0056384527,
-0.0455247834,
0.0357794017,
-0.1223216727,
-0.0430001579,
0.0386082605,
0.0095262444,
0.0105742216,
0.0254601948,
-0.0735931098,
-0.0737912878,
-0.0194191188,
0.097475253,
0.009563759,
0.0327686369,
-0.0103637427,
-0.0504402258,
-0.0125788711,
0.0220993944,
-0.0277852435,
0.0329676643,
0.0377092957,
0.0035790093,
-0.0013481149,
0.0198926535,
-0.0365992039,
0.0524302088,
0.0164787788,
0.0199884623,
-0.0176242013,
0.0033008044,
0.0203609951,
0.0041921516,
0.0203082319,
-0.0227620378,
-0.0092171095,
-0.0088409027,
0.0316548757,
-0.0056122704,
0.0114019718,
-0.0442943946,
-0.0230312776,
0.0289503206,
-0.0387273431,
0.0068284497,
-0.0294165537,
-0.0172658749,
0.0156402681,
-0.0576490425,
0.0253122151,
-0.0124208974,
0.030032482,
0.0212223232,
0.0161013454,
-0.0065440056,
-0.0019052268,
0.0303829443,
0.0576486327,
-0.021236835,
0.0750466958,
0.0056918645,
0.0378750972,
-0.0138760656,
0.0487980247,
-0.0124330074,
-0.0359388366,
-0.0562699437,
-0.0073401951,
0.0745270327,
-0.0111233797,
0.0564678758,
-0.0014404401,
-0.0026616345,
-0.0148294773,
0.0333566405,
-0.0204861891,
0.0010202862,
0.0277286116,
0.0391201302,
0.0173692219,
-0.0222603641,
0.0853786469,
0.019797137,
0.0722586289,
0.0126757557,
0.0169536229,
-0.0269857179,
-0.0146946739,
0.0280655026,
0.0011301592,
0.0017923213,
-0.0066748261,
0.0025055637,
-0.0446595885,
-0.0591835119,
0.0318789259,
0.0035226266,
-0.0374829806,
0.0395735838,
0.0237484314,
-0.0266335346,
-0.028809581,
-0.0392214097,
-0.0342942625,
0.0120462161,
-0.0082552666,
-0.0111407973,
-6.144058077e-33,
-0.0740978271,
0.0244994536,
0.0546089336,
0.0210546032,
-0.0345567688,
-0.0095980726,
-0.030820867,
-0.0124359243,
-0.0228885002,
-0.0134447888,
-0.0111992881,
0.0151213137,
0.0193372332,
-0.0050279419,
0.0286350027,
0.0172801632,
0.057657443,
-0.0414726138,
-0.0366076306,
0.0348302759,
0.0130924275,
0.0148262447,
0.0645113736,
-0.0102677755,
-0.0112204989,
-0.0129516935,
-0.0082926517,
0.0131224487,
-0.0092592901,
0.0537965447,
0.0051320978,
0.0168655273,
0.0117054135,
-0.0532035157,
-0.0296836197,
-0.0194180962,
-0.0351545364,
-0.0285286177,
0.0315987356,
0.0099349543,
-0.0075179236,
-0.0554420836,
0.0224445947,
-0.0156642646,
-0.0402632318,
-0.0033280521,
0.0022927907,
-0.0189219844,
-0.0015415045,
0.022515744,
-0.067787692,
0.0040816385,
0.0116572836,
-0.05621152,
0.0386846773,
0.0065672295,
-0.0075679622,
-0.0136297597,
-0.0236280542,
0.0112955719,
0.0701610819,
0.1038017496,
0.0925770104,
0.042754326,
0.0202696845,
-0.0079503078,
0.0103001548,
0.0182902291,
0.0044617089,
0.0171671733,
0.0466468632,
0.0332271457,
-0.0001182931,
-0.0124586048,
0.0433224961,
-0.0017687825,
-0.0277678594,
0.0138905002,
0.0141048701,
0.0615455396,
0.0206806529,
0.0123050734,
-0.0505804345,
-0.008730514,
-0.0193630811,
0.0007427258,
-0.0082954625,
-0.0364154913,
0.0589746647,
0.0180454571,
-0.0166468266,
-0.005245375,
0.0503410324,
-0.012449895,
0.0055316286,
-0.0093938159,
-0.0472607911,
0.032883089,
-0.0041010347,
-0.000320326,
-0.0816114321,
-0.0793023407,
0.0134888766,
0.0010165229,
0.0504833832,
0.0121191433,
0.0265848413,
0.0478293337,
-0.0672086254,
0.0094534326,
-0.0555896908,
0.0226559266,
0.010278875,
0.0350928754,
0.0118558146,
0.0011817386,
-0.0075612003,
0.0694063604,
-0.0105539402,
-0.0670401081,
-0.0271027647,
-0.0322979167,
0.0104601169,
0.0276540201,
-0.0354063287,
0.0261155423,
-0.0319816247,
0.0349352099,
-0.0213010032,
-0.0383423902,
-0.0393896364,
0.017691778,
2.618e-7,
0.0134511879,
0.0407949537,
0.0224913359,
0.0558261201,
0.0050741006,
0.017084334,
-0.0333814099,
0.0117808823,
0.0176238455,
0.0007814496,
0.0113020334,
0.0458565392,
0.0332835019,
0.0108287679,
-0.0556218363,
0.0120043829,
-0.0229368489,
0.0322590545,
-0.067218408,
-0.0299220532,
0.0090982243,
0.0854700133,
-0.0102030812,
0.0111660967,
0.0398751721,
0.019655047,
0.0155687043,
-0.000116823,
0.0002863194,
0.0293768719,
-0.0170377474,
0.0491340943,
-0.0670048669,
-0.001079718,
-0.0199433099,
0.0053166533,
-0.0421863683,
0.1032232791,
-0.0277749412,
-0.0017700715,
0.0452872068,
-0.0132555896,
-0.0183918141,
-0.0345889516,
0.0590122268,
-0.0474768877,
0.0166115575,
-0.0008857981,
0.0010009282,
-0.0135664484,
-0.0126928864,
-0.0408512689,
0.0196332,
0.017524777,
0.0179550182,
-0.0136136552,
-0.0485966727,
-0.0361762047,
-0.0035576029,
0.0342501476,
-0.0080105672,
-0.0505944006,
-0.0703138858,
-0.0043823416,
-0.0332752652,
-0.0497117341,
-0.0088525526,
2.26441492e-34,
0.019026665,
-0.0415830463,
0.0571091957,
0.0392232761,
0.0054274253,
0.0124550043,
-0.0486456603,
0.0395787135,
0.0166283417,
-0.0629972368,
-0.0398618281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03245v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03245v3
|
Large language models effectively leverage document-level context for literary translation, but critical errors persist
| 2023-04-06T17:27:45 | 2023-05-22T22:00:51 |
Marzena Karpinska, Mohit Iyyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are competitive with the state of the art on a
wide range of sentence-level translation datasets. However, their ability to
translate paragraphs and documents remains unexplored because evaluation in
these settings is costly and difficult. We show through a rigorous human
evaluation that asking the Gpt-3.5 (text-davinci-003) LLM to translate an
entire literary paragraph (e.g., from a novel) at once results in
higher-quality translations than standard sentence-by-sentence translation
across 18 linguistically-diverse language pairs (e.g., translating into and out
of Japanese, Polish, and English). Our evaluation, which took approximately 350
hours of effort for annotation and analysis, is conducted by hiring translators
fluent in both the source and target language and asking them to provide both
span-level error annotations as well as preference judgments of which system's
translations are better. We observe that discourse-level LLM translators commit
fewer mistranslations, grammar errors, and stylistic inconsistencies than
sentence-level approaches. With that said, critical errors still abound,
including occasional content omissions, and a human translator's intervention
remains necessary to ensure that the author's voice remains intact. We publicly
release our dataset and error annotations to spur future research on evaluation
of document-level literary translation.
|
[
0.0439426899,
0.0511450693,
-0.0020901675,
0.05830786,
-0.0660539567,
0.0225947089,
0.0566610023,
-0.0157470088,
-0.0054932926,
-0.0359522738,
-0.0290291905,
-0.0213220827,
0.068523556,
-0.044832699,
0.0514569357,
-0.0383576564,
0.0332963951,
-0.038424544,
0.0007174595,
0.0026359374,
0.00489457,
0.0308224875,
0.0324222036,
0.0419398956,
0.0097889882,
-0.0387502238,
0.0063269977,
0.0810514688,
0.0463493355,
-0.0214948077,
-0.0029003932,
-0.0033861359,
0.0181678273,
0.0850506723,
0.0000019675,
-0.0061638253,
0.0001057209,
-0.000342801,
0.0182431154,
0.0427093431,
0.063625291,
-0.0499045178,
-0.0207074992,
-0.0116301328,
0.0036553144,
-0.0139785605,
0.0177046545,
0.0268060081,
0.0555321276,
0.0786627233,
-0.0246862471,
-0.0357965194,
0.0072932579,
-0.0518028364,
-0.0134403212,
-0.074562259,
-0.0020482624,
0.0073072216,
-0.0078837136,
0.0559700504,
-0.0148510886,
0.0361316912,
-0.0103792856,
-0.039643418,
-0.0082780281,
-0.0209790636,
-0.0391440354,
-0.0024039848,
-0.0025555552,
0.0451456755,
0.0142931333,
-0.0180549771,
-0.0196446199,
0.0064679263,
-0.0193608794,
0.0173827894,
-0.0273666065,
0.0175054912,
-0.0211523119,
0.011710641,
0.0341120884,
0.0196786132,
0.0346021727,
-0.0050781718,
-0.0214810874,
0.0180424973,
0.0490647517,
-0.0050045582,
0.0034935849,
0.0188067239,
-0.049819503,
-0.0505248383,
0.0420358106,
-0.0162295178,
-0.0087811239,
0.0060436069,
-0.0473312512,
-0.0504957177,
0.0063896803,
-0.0623161346,
0.0437558591,
0.0494735949,
-0.0089405645,
0.0554712415,
-0.0007969033,
0.0734741017,
-0.0251793023,
0.0010641161,
-0.0705794021,
-0.0180557966,
0.0063910522,
0.0343219489,
-0.0518461019,
-0.0356085822,
-0.0763422996,
-0.018360462,
-0.0324209221,
-0.0058846725,
0.0376922339,
0.0394674577,
0.0022277532,
-0.0318323188,
-0.0476342589,
-0.0295851808,
-0.0085096136,
0.0451267064,
-0.0027227122,
-0.0025995546,
-0.0289673042,
-0.0266927946,
-0.0170113184,
0.0143840536,
-0.0182149075,
-0.0490099601,
-0.0032065809,
0.0645839572,
0.0191450361,
-0.0184665322,
-0.0125922933,
0.0089440132,
-0.0167915728,
-0.0467739105,
-0.0498070121,
-0.0398803577,
0.0434800871,
0.0104820998,
0.0503087416,
-0.0483166389,
0.020157015,
0.0272011459,
-0.0406919755,
0.0628260672,
0.0161675829,
0.0275298357,
0.0200720411,
-0.0245386623,
-0.0199176334,
0.0327405632,
0.0788375437,
0.0314040557,
0.0445152186,
0.0152945369,
-0.0151839415,
0.0652699545,
-0.0330317914,
0.0277767815,
-0.0173208024,
-0.0050376351,
-0.001935964,
0.0559865609,
0.0429599285,
0.0838096291,
-0.0242054835,
0.0152202649,
0.1032897606,
0.0542430952,
-0.0174618736,
0.0348607525,
0.0510845482,
0.0029469742,
0.019698957,
-0.0134363621,
-0.0487210527,
-0.0056251818,
0.0142714679,
-0.0216514468,
0.0180801339,
0.0303213336,
0.0119348448,
0.0013598289,
-0.0158082079,
-0.0079147164,
0.0179280266,
-0.023260463,
0.0265700221,
-0.0145963514,
-0.0624821521,
0.009315622,
-0.0170568097,
-0.0580585562,
0.0273836181,
0.0051821959,
-0.0111189382,
0.1037387848,
0.0923198014,
-0.0123578859,
0.0103909643,
-0.0042665801,
0.0418632701,
0.0582373925,
0.0419774391,
-0.0032226238,
0.0145605672,
-0.0268477369,
0.0058458154,
-0.0201388914,
0.0143948803,
0.0267575979,
-0.0253181569,
0.038568873,
0.0064850706,
-0.0581008121,
-0.0883415341,
0.0285557806,
-0.0490279682,
-0.0297860038,
-0.0173272621,
-0.0104721785,
-0.0101485951,
0.0053253993,
-0.0267407615,
0.0024465781,
0.0006780073,
-0.0553017445,
-0.0045209923,
0.0610351115,
-0.0179525111,
-0.0249818452,
0.0213429201,
-0.0663758665,
-0.0169314221,
-0.0124720633,
-0.0388517901,
-0.0423268192,
-0.0129595017,
-0.0218437817,
-0.0087533407,
-0.0073997639,
0.0304251388,
-0.0045449664,
-0.0034090206,
-0.0401472263,
0.0327380337,
0.0203989893,
-0.0052443352,
0.0208742283,
-0.0126914643,
0.0195611361,
-0.0062958044,
-0.0277922302,
0.0225305408,
0.054702118,
0.0184064545,
0.0284989178,
0.015449143,
-0.0113444775,
-0.0450204983,
-0.0982552841,
0.0429861359,
-0.0099982321,
0.053490717,
0.0473300666,
0.0239291955,
-0.0081035867,
0.0362203605,
-0.0107953846,
-0.0066230725,
-0.0040180166,
-0.0104480712,
0.0236845538,
-0.0234971493,
0.0444426835,
-0.0561388433,
0.0156967361,
0.0205289256,
0.042005945,
0.0279879291,
-0.0222573895,
-0.0544331558,
0.0455088504,
-0.0076615908,
-0.0175441466,
-0.0096729817,
-0.0411003567,
-0.0192625895,
-0.0212872308,
0.0441346653,
0.0512957685,
-0.0214949045,
0.0120556401,
0.026391007,
-0.0447957329,
-0.0381865762,
-0.0038867451,
0.0364498384,
-0.0437718369,
-0.048079025,
-0.0523824729,
0.0121670719,
0.0179379042,
0.0070586186,
0.000743002,
-0.0589499436,
0.012542583,
-0.0471343324,
-0.0062091746,
0.0027804642,
-0.0123138223,
0.0113640809,
0.0680372044,
-0.0480140187,
0.0202333629,
0.0426795296,
-0.0352231823,
-0.0076574134,
-0.026311785,
0.0279375277,
-0.0524420179,
0.0489116684,
-0.0225947257,
0.0066702529,
-0.0703256056,
-0.0129348068,
-0.0229374785,
0.0087012956,
0.0574865155,
-0.0225535911,
0.0468847305,
-0.0800948068,
0.0073555517,
-0.0359199867,
-0.0082854778,
-0.0020582618,
-0.0426953062,
-0.0318485275,
-0.0362525359,
0.0084808525,
-0.0311454311,
-0.0216995999,
-0.0087197684,
0.0090531129,
0.0641617477,
-0.0322964489,
-0.0228836834,
-0.0309545733,
0.0182623118,
-0.0265033636,
0.0018250017,
0.0319947489,
-0.0887420774,
0.0497624502,
0.0464418307,
-0.0429499,
0.014173842,
-0.0333920121,
-0.0179402586,
0.037000291,
-0.0098977163,
-0.053325966,
-0.0593889765,
0.0870915577,
-0.0652186573,
-0.0305918772,
0.1182973161,
0.0055171619,
-0.0564413778,
-0.037441127,
-0.0522652641,
0.0170726888,
0.0028535421,
-0.0014471881,
-0.1008121073,
-0.0207215771,
0.0410244837,
0.0580522157,
0.0229394305,
-0.0292248093,
0.0061185495,
-0.091011323,
0.0278756358,
0.0596397407,
-0.0026593632,
-0.0106785381,
0.0110230641,
-0.0042341193,
-0.0144855436,
0.0422732234,
0.0039092512,
0.0098153232,
0.0137381349,
-0.0365592353,
0.044144962,
-0.0351266004,
0.0000400191,
-0.0535812117,
0.0243235845,
0.042491816,
0.0680649355,
0.0028067578,
0.0191955753,
0.0276757032,
-0.0050870338,
-0.0148065938,
0.0081803976,
0.0284661818,
0.00811568,
0.0035517707,
-0.004953526,
0.0203324743,
-0.0353792794,
-0.019641567,
0.0480813086,
0.0251362715,
-0.0001000857,
0.0285815857,
0.0085876258,
0.0027805672,
0.0062895254,
0.0512456,
0.0251903497,
-0.0475371964,
-0.049605526,
-0.0280426033,
0.0005704229,
-0.0658516213,
-0.0111117614,
0.0248387642,
-0.0200590845,
-0.0286322832,
-0.0831080675,
-0.0481388457,
0.000353198,
0.0169301704,
0.0707422942,
0.0047376952,
-0.0067641097,
-0.0189335346,
0.0130708469,
0.0188711379,
-0.0371074155,
0.0338595621,
-0.0226846803,
0.0367317125,
-0.0016103608,
-0.0283608157,
0.0397567935,
0.0217512865,
-0.0571060255,
-0.0543436632,
-0.0125290686,
0.0224666856,
0.0232225489,
0.014903619,
-0.0470661931,
-0.0521767884,
0.0044368617,
0.0067318729,
-0.0204333793,
0.0541724339,
0.018311847,
0.0450599268,
-0.0147216851,
0.0479239412,
-0.0173252188,
-0.001632286,
-0.0016815107,
0.0373233892,
0.0175050497,
-0.0566277467,
0.0190505646,
0.0084497556,
-0.0062182536,
-0.0546774194,
0.027484661,
-0.027285384,
0.0013173022,
-0.0545859113,
-0.0305919163,
-0.0477476865,
-0.0096992431,
0.0661935806,
-0.0166289471,
-0.0230993852,
0.0047171996,
-0.0006230403,
0.0036932917,
-0.0585510582,
-0.0012831256,
0.0064434824,
0.0227819383,
-0.0158451404,
0.0264218338,
-0.0065277363,
-0.003663861,
-0.049191542,
0.0436906666,
-0.0145953689,
0.0217642244,
0.0289653111,
-0.0132981613,
0.0217930097,
0.0393559411,
-0.0646210462,
-0.007802519,
0.0078195231,
0.0063567297,
0.1040953249,
0.009926944,
0.1617729217,
-0.0173043702,
-0.0290307105,
-0.0140925739,
0.0523830652,
0.0402577445,
0.0064963419,
-0.0567939691,
-0.0049011339,
0.0206121728,
0.0378779471,
0.0463402793,
-0.0133178961,
0.0112093017,
0.0119236363,
-0.0433148071,
-0.0056317537,
-0.0250945985,
-0.0309611876,
-0.0394144058,
0.0076809525,
-0.0474796109,
-0.0745871887,
-0.0398207307,
0.0137241194,
0.061859075,
0.0034939314,
-0.0368539914,
-0.027404245,
0.0365412198,
-0.0203721784,
0.0189941358,
-0.084934026,
0.0421171449,
0.0078316079,
-0.0332822017,
-0.0561782196,
-5.5261569e-33,
-0.0456027053,
-0.0178059787,
-0.0197356548,
0.0053416486,
-0.073647067,
-0.0122433053,
-0.0570802167,
-0.0234923549,
0.0425005108,
0.0309238974,
-0.0231022798,
0.0037404913,
0.0089681894,
-0.0167025309,
0.0286192466,
0.0058910688,
0.0754465014,
0.0145963188,
-0.0538276844,
0.0388991758,
0.0639003143,
-0.0025988992,
0.0459215529,
-0.0525708348,
0.0621980876,
-0.0530758724,
-0.040835239,
-0.0039148121,
0.0158488732,
-0.0074849748,
0.0163171813,
0.0038234929,
0.0076364903,
0.016675096,
-0.0261400435,
-0.0160977729,
-0.0961733758,
0.0162147582,
0.0395956114,
0.0422768407,
0.0005945838,
-0.0575408787,
0.0376328155,
-0.0182351638,
-0.0094535081,
-0.0106161535,
0.0205514897,
-0.0560404658,
-0.0180219412,
-0.0331771821,
-0.0829916149,
0.0154374922,
-0.0276448764,
-0.0051588067,
0.0376524143,
0.0553559586,
-0.0138994511,
0.0283447132,
-0.0646195859,
0.0069049615,
-0.0346912034,
0.0001656987,
-0.0043270797,
-0.0115190074,
-0.0193706881,
0.0286563896,
0.02288845,
0.0104412092,
0.0034910929,
0.0097913388,
0.0124583673,
-0.0155074494,
0.0358283967,
0.0819706619,
-0.0029063399,
-0.0076232431,
-0.0411187448,
0.0455162898,
-0.0244766567,
0.0199782494,
0.0188995432,
0.0066454373,
0.00416636,
-0.0236932989,
-0.0641643703,
-0.0552960485,
-0.0050675049,
-0.001588649,
0.0073848367,
-0.0188262276,
-0.0184864383,
-0.0241474584,
0.0519513451,
-0.0363031775,
-0.0092534283,
-0.0123408278,
-0.0393587425,
0.0477827601,
-0.0241461564,
0.0566424131,
0.0057014991,
-0.0185093954,
-0.012304402,
0.0244083237,
0.034222614,
-0.0275257807,
0.0238436032,
0.0311674867,
-0.0430997834,
0.0098167295,
-0.0309167244,
0.0013782593,
-0.0464647561,
0.033973448,
0.0193863828,
-0.0150056602,
0.017696742,
0.0274590813,
0.0284411237,
0.0077540851,
-0.0427568331,
0.0125450091,
0.0096788146,
-0.0000154192,
-0.0357379206,
0.043574471,
-0.0191119239,
0.012846075,
0.0297034848,
-0.0452834368,
-0.0108570727,
-0.0121558998,
2.659e-7,
0.0454983115,
0.0590011552,
0.0080767293,
0.0133527359,
0.0296053588,
0.0227317009,
-0.0537693352,
0.0301804747,
0.0014793263,
0.024317218,
0.0444265641,
0.0201312378,
0.1085401624,
0.0294114761,
-0.0767966807,
-0.003426186,
-0.0394921713,
0.0031024744,
-0.0734189078,
-0.0189331584,
0.0393333212,
0.0460192859,
0.0332755111,
0.0009620943,
-0.0040129432,
-0.0410451926,
0.1025282517,
-0.0274716541,
-0.0510444306,
0.0087924283,
0.0558704212,
0.026792381,
-0.0333846174,
-0.0020294574,
-0.0061151399,
0.0043621799,
0.0383754708,
0.0844273865,
0.0033656752,
-0.0027411166,
-0.0304227434,
-0.0334670134,
-0.0021091227,
-0.0525269955,
0.0416112952,
0.0085670333,
-0.0100249397,
-0.0110048568,
-0.0117933135,
0.014507967,
0.0385476947,
-0.0118106892,
-0.038341403,
0.0254701991,
0.0530553274,
-0.0095091853,
-0.0202808548,
-0.0328030139,
-0.0047567496,
-0.0033514071,
-0.0065516881,
-0.0313981585,
-0.010343343,
0.0293494388,
-0.0498422943,
-0.0489348732,
0.0010143147,
2.312138154e-34,
0.0749417841,
-0.0493879952,
0.0127017964,
-0.0199856143,
0.0362150148,
-0.0069547156,
0.0134971887,
0.0064090001,
-0.0153314164,
-0.0273239575,
-0.0120451767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03216v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03216v3
|
On the Pareto Front of Multilingual Neural Machine Translation
| 2023-04-06T16:49:19 | 2023-10-31T15:58:53 |
Liang Chen, Shuming Ma, Dongdong Zhang, Furu Wei, Baobao Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we study how the performance of a given direction changes with
its sampling ratio in Multilingual Neural Machine Translation (MNMT). By
training over 200 multilingual models with various model sizes, data sizes, and
language directions, we find it interesting that the performance of certain
translation direction does not always improve with the increase of its weight
in the multi-task optimization objective. Accordingly, scalarization method
leads to a multitask trade-off front that deviates from the traditional Pareto
front when there exists data imbalance in the training corpus, which poses a
great challenge to improve the overall performance of all directions. Based on
our observations, we propose the Double Power Law to predict the unique
performance trade-off front in MNMT, which is robust across various languages,
data adequacy, and the number of tasks. Finally, we formulate the sample ratio
selection problem in MNMT as an optimization problem based on the Double Power
Law. In our experiments, it achieves better performance than temperature
searching and gradient manipulation methods with only 1/5 to 1/2 of the total
training budget. We release the code at
https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/ParetoMNMT for reproduction.
|
[
0.0036220162,
0.0379237421,
-0.0106134564,
0.0430847779,
-0.0242928807,
0.0169702675,
0.0333047286,
0.0141870044,
-0.0711736828,
-0.0031227707,
-0.0576163903,
-0.086616382,
0.0293716434,
-0.0512987897,
0.0603439324,
-0.0592761077,
-0.0146256797,
-0.0196934938,
-0.0288462061,
-0.0177722666,
-0.0140737761,
0.0206370521,
0.0233293194,
0.0171032306,
-0.0154583259,
0.0347749218,
0.0341923572,
0.0670879409,
0.0163907707,
-0.0397095867,
0.0112827076,
0.0014002502,
0.0131910266,
0.0454121567,
0.000002355,
-0.0385501646,
-0.0190268047,
0.0157363228,
0.0207766462,
-0.010099262,
0.073876828,
-0.0507533699,
0.0129386997,
0.0186238978,
-0.008796609,
0.010749924,
0.0782556161,
0.0289581884,
0.0139121581,
0.0900326967,
-0.0120572513,
-0.0283822622,
-0.0004182869,
-0.0632468835,
-0.0486059077,
-0.0382986255,
-0.0303724334,
-0.0104023162,
-0.0454369895,
0.0088120252,
-0.0092655635,
0.0304674935,
0.0184038822,
0.0229790881,
-0.0613215826,
0.0195399523,
0.013264155,
-0.0557021648,
-0.0250362288,
0.071334742,
-0.087131843,
0.0173895489,
-0.0030766402,
-0.0150312735,
-0.0124816317,
-0.0473248586,
-0.057718616,
0.0161259696,
0.0137291383,
0.0170515794,
-0.0043384233,
0.0052584484,
0.0730656981,
-0.0125307981,
-0.0328184739,
0.0327139944,
0.0222755913,
-0.0296200775,
0.0240432397,
0.023882512,
-0.0365966335,
0.0199406482,
0.0431121141,
-0.0066737952,
-0.0322883427,
0.0072097895,
-0.0410077199,
-0.0984582454,
-0.0169622637,
-0.0786226541,
0.0814771503,
0.0366259888,
0.0277961846,
0.0313764475,
0.0388297886,
-0.00434735,
-0.0425849296,
0.0031002723,
-0.0743142515,
-0.0532218516,
-0.0047228816,
0.0337219052,
-0.0330230445,
0.0082611302,
-0.0265099313,
0.0119359605,
-0.0350684822,
-0.0167988669,
-0.0061047943,
-0.0604043417,
0.0620734766,
-0.0375115126,
-0.0753858611,
-0.0158454236,
0.0473127067,
0.0588827506,
-0.035296537,
0.0126118828,
-0.0044639404,
-0.0425325446,
-0.0452839918,
0.040912617,
-0.0163138416,
-0.0605193451,
0.0068940544,
0.090142414,
-0.0258481577,
-0.022889398,
-0.0456434153,
-0.0310500674,
-0.0104496982,
-0.0524374656,
0.0114644496,
-0.0344005823,
0.0907087475,
0.0002066594,
0.0015816619,
-0.0225240998,
-0.0036310588,
0.0018970595,
-0.0381753184,
0.0419967324,
0.066249311,
-0.0196270719,
0.0414154604,
-0.0117989359,
-0.0577352419,
0.111094594,
0.0836472288,
0.0014487631,
0.0221512057,
0.0089251129,
-0.0606403984,
0.0521550141,
0.0087944558,
0.0769317225,
0.0141859977,
-0.0240589716,
0.0155175785,
0.0436828434,
0.0550904647,
0.0481847078,
-0.0272992235,
-0.0056824652,
0.064281188,
0.0344540812,
0.0290531348,
0.0113166263,
0.0144947907,
-0.0076773898,
-0.0622764416,
-0.0063681961,
-0.0096772481,
0.0261371247,
-0.0047081588,
-0.0342179909,
0.0278132167,
0.0759069026,
-0.029652277,
-0.0377089716,
-0.0107265245,
-0.025155155,
-0.001839496,
-0.0285885446,
0.0498057567,
-0.0118045853,
-0.0439613424,
0.030728234,
0.0039700656,
-0.0449762382,
0.0434101745,
0.0052344971,
-0.0635043681,
0.0145136919,
-0.0017555404,
0.0085317967,
-0.0112935193,
0.0063804677,
0.0098564699,
0.0133125586,
0.065680407,
0.0471370146,
0.0560831763,
-0.0558694154,
-0.0502969585,
0.000317156,
-0.0062295385,
0.0343498811,
-0.0124425413,
0.0479937568,
0.0433828272,
-0.0123364218,
-0.0651661828,
0.0331596881,
-0.0368565321,
-0.0148866065,
0.0472584814,
0.0160975624,
0.033506602,
-0.0129163237,
-0.0244137682,
-0.0163097139,
-0.0125521319,
-0.0562682152,
-0.0283932965,
0.0558358543,
-0.0439471453,
-0.0242308378,
0.0236832257,
-0.0440963954,
-0.0023890976,
0.0260035936,
-0.0353751071,
-0.0534513183,
0.0333558246,
-0.0086649815,
0.0047305622,
-0.0220991839,
0.0302414689,
-0.0041933754,
0.0307126213,
-0.0333626755,
0.0330699533,
-0.0000754617,
-0.0220613591,
-0.0092752092,
-0.0333631895,
0.0149714183,
-0.0480368361,
-0.0133706974,
0.0174360294,
0.0319651589,
0.0337086581,
0.0432216339,
0.0313686728,
0.0180931017,
-0.0500928648,
-0.0269303918,
0.0357938372,
-0.0275631119,
0.0251170881,
0.0231557265,
0.0593207031,
0.0128241358,
-0.0082616555,
-0.03586822,
0.0157195162,
-0.0442872047,
0.0137909995,
0.0269484445,
-0.0159044694,
0.0520684272,
-0.0021833719,
-0.0289668776,
0.0192939732,
0.021443516,
0.026814945,
0.0453002006,
-0.0561670661,
0.058455646,
-0.0206748005,
0.0116072437,
-0.0028082184,
-0.0190777797,
-0.0230627414,
0.0020611412,
0.0163400099,
0.060558103,
0.0003100666,
-0.0151058985,
0.0364939906,
0.0356146879,
-0.0471765324,
0.011555763,
-0.017722195,
0.0202272963,
-0.018083008,
-0.041505523,
0.0511241183,
0.0354751907,
0.0036074917,
-0.0279908776,
-0.0251342952,
-0.0155416485,
-0.0243503805,
-0.0060805418,
0.0048752865,
0.0482747331,
-0.0013374548,
0.0078397701,
-0.0062248763,
-0.0321585126,
0.0606995597,
-0.040527951,
-0.0077933073,
-0.0799543262,
0.008551511,
-0.0398955904,
0.0223291125,
-0.0341522954,
0.0358184017,
-0.0367849283,
-0.0147835137,
-0.0650221482,
-0.026315067,
0.0159966704,
-0.0056631789,
0.0046811346,
-0.053525608,
-0.0162592642,
-0.0600448512,
-0.0496057719,
0.0179870408,
0.0072126216,
0.0271498654,
0.0042855148,
0.0506663211,
-0.0271342024,
-0.0442489684,
-0.0056403042,
0.0182661638,
0.0721497238,
-0.0027357813,
0.0007417942,
0.0004014992,
0.0077571128,
0.0146633079,
0.036981035,
0.006062265,
-0.0756269842,
-0.0276956987,
-0.0020472051,
0.0060375873,
-0.0084401546,
-0.0206029397,
-0.0336282402,
0.0278142206,
0.0034459948,
-0.0296519734,
-0.0173794124,
0.0269348063,
-0.0297466554,
0.0394437946,
0.0824246183,
-0.0231660474,
-0.0596505515,
0.0105392886,
0.0022778888,
0.0105701359,
0.010206013,
0.0185828004,
-0.0445490703,
-0.0050069378,
-0.0010635661,
0.0555353463,
0.0275901575,
0.0181803983,
-0.0173941497,
-0.102648519,
0.0155373793,
0.0189442094,
-0.0371002853,
-0.0139102414,
-0.0263242219,
-0.0296816491,
-0.059179198,
0.0748869777,
-0.0330765322,
0.0363072976,
-0.0120779993,
0.0243507568,
0.0579256564,
-0.0466700532,
-0.0137843248,
-0.0810475126,
-0.0305326376,
0.0393709838,
0.0511630662,
-0.0342809074,
-0.0389779769,
0.0324569456,
0.030467838,
-0.0191813819,
-0.0197207965,
-0.0032457965,
0.0327180251,
-0.0319961533,
0.0211335663,
0.0109121101,
-0.0271837953,
0.0880553275,
0.0399985574,
0.0547096692,
-0.0113134338,
-0.0105513735,
0.0031693883,
-0.0559317619,
0.0219534095,
0.0473793074,
0.0044355765,
-0.0321283117,
-0.0228955057,
-0.0113177532,
-0.0227196068,
-0.1165534928,
0.0152203161,
0.0019083258,
-0.0307497103,
-0.0178874899,
-0.0904240012,
0.0003799477,
-0.011088795,
0.0970282033,
0.0168824997,
0.0149010867,
0.0381357372,
0.0150348656,
0.0065136207,
0.0068433462,
-0.0263374206,
-0.0071919709,
-0.0557852648,
0.0028825914,
0.0204899367,
-0.0147118997,
0.0247637331,
0.0052196016,
-0.0745581612,
-0.0727371797,
-0.0573745109,
0.0860651657,
0.007682614,
0.0268323906,
-0.0051653003,
-0.0343438461,
-0.007499293,
0.0477442555,
-0.0091151921,
0.0114906076,
0.0306310281,
-0.025448706,
-0.0121820858,
0.045514226,
-0.0302243493,
0.006269604,
-0.0001732161,
0.0608226173,
-0.0042918604,
-0.0051176818,
-0.0337628908,
0.048695717,
0.0194992851,
-0.0503692478,
-0.0232038945,
-0.0329810977,
0.0354077443,
0.001015563,
-0.0003122525,
-0.0436484814,
0.0130928634,
0.0235097539,
-0.0161292013,
0.0020295677,
0.0205129273,
0.046308659,
-0.04547837,
-0.0237911958,
-0.0098094596,
-0.0462542288,
0.0245541912,
-0.0051254388,
0.0248316526,
0.0092160916,
0.0284293275,
0.0027591814,
0.0165379737,
-0.0276304074,
0.0090677626,
-0.0103093088,
0.0341075994,
-0.0462331921,
0.0183094721,
-0.0237224437,
-0.0275723264,
-0.0168535542,
-0.0396325104,
0.0533250123,
-0.0240916461,
0.1193552241,
0.0022574251,
-0.0018336819,
-0.0176457558,
0.0334139876,
-0.0334902629,
-0.0001170873,
0.0087447464,
-0.0201576315,
-0.0004748811,
0.0253718235,
0.1074150726,
-0.0189212691,
0.0184324291,
-0.0128370784,
0.0118383644,
0.0079939188,
-0.0410390235,
0.0365722328,
-0.0237096176,
-0.0055804821,
-0.0258069858,
-0.0105141653,
-0.0329769105,
-0.0150485151,
-0.0229576398,
0.010591899,
0.0006085237,
0.030726606,
0.0908601284,
-0.0684351176,
0.0082853669,
-0.0291022528,
-0.0105729727,
0.0326192491,
-0.0095816925,
-0.0101927975,
-6.700214944e-33,
0.0099910758,
0.0277347248,
0.0200163722,
0.0146501008,
-0.0153703317,
-0.0127801644,
-0.0019613425,
-0.0251494367,
-0.0359347574,
-0.0229402836,
0.0049822163,
-0.009106528,
0.0130410204,
0.0228104405,
0.0162326302,
0.0214432999,
0.0476200879,
-0.010278536,
-0.0419764668,
0.0324168354,
0.0493522324,
0.0286459289,
0.080225043,
-0.033470016,
0.0110311257,
-0.0016915579,
0.0124595203,
0.0299186315,
0.005074312,
0.0233234372,
0.0325786099,
0.0266614351,
0.0164407194,
-0.0621378757,
-0.0162141845,
-0.0500445962,
-0.0486766808,
-0.0330929607,
-0.0019537054,
0.0576084368,
-0.0064914078,
-0.0329691805,
0.0798923373,
-0.0114663336,
-0.0108477101,
-0.0254121907,
0.0134044234,
-0.0158601999,
-0.0451836027,
0.0012146187,
-0.0516115054,
-0.0008505551,
-0.0008465624,
-0.0256124325,
0.0281999893,
0.0121580791,
-0.0261576213,
0.0101478221,
-0.087167874,
-0.0246507954,
-0.0289694704,
0.0347667448,
0.0516127311,
0.0456166454,
0.0053254613,
-0.0035927778,
-0.0056185005,
0.0409724452,
0.0359629765,
-0.017066326,
0.0632687807,
-0.0070878942,
0.0395789333,
0.0237418972,
0.0560299084,
-0.0133371763,
-0.1089880913,
0.0446407869,
0.0414401367,
-0.0105350334,
0.0249949545,
0.0061417441,
0.0023856999,
-0.0243290458,
-0.047622785,
-0.0410253741,
-0.0171210952,
-0.0087463772,
-0.0252077337,
0.0239134189,
-0.0180980507,
-0.0188952982,
0.0711554661,
0.0020895298,
0.0095016323,
-0.0114972992,
-0.0041578161,
-0.0013157297,
0.0043454459,
0.0123632262,
-0.0061213337,
-0.056791719,
-0.0525574386,
0.0382719077,
0.0097925328,
-0.004805563,
0.0601329617,
0.0109343994,
-0.0090060122,
-0.014747642,
-0.0355185829,
0.0000143668,
0.0203107484,
0.0770088285,
-0.0068736039,
-0.0070821601,
0.0139934793,
0.0257618781,
0.0575148575,
-0.01620326,
-0.0300047919,
0.0367043763,
0.007496444,
0.0036498294,
-0.0406226777,
0.0166798756,
-0.0025934966,
-0.017029969,
0.0640071183,
-0.072458446,
-0.0653788894,
-0.0223643575,
3.017e-7,
0.0642431825,
0.0386823937,
-0.0423791036,
0.0074308887,
-0.0259429514,
0.0269800611,
-0.0551361963,
0.0434416905,
-0.0506804734,
0.0530891232,
0.0176130198,
0.0258821361,
0.0676823333,
0.0500117391,
-0.0813940689,
-0.0268754046,
-0.0429709293,
0.0576009229,
-0.0402668379,
-0.0162944216,
-0.0143535193,
0.0790083483,
0.0130399251,
-0.0183397755,
-0.0174156893,
-0.0136489393,
0.0855427831,
-0.0060399007,
0.0193260033,
0.0062898844,
0.0195890199,
0.0251486674,
-0.0083483709,
-0.0246302653,
-0.0274747852,
0.0290410183,
0.0175151341,
0.0677078068,
0.0018210935,
-0.0181082431,
0.0559815578,
-0.0018686928,
-0.0267423019,
-0.0284833666,
0.0338183604,
-0.0166803859,
-0.0155241173,
-0.0239224341,
0.0336486399,
0.0235552993,
0.0740840957,
-0.0401114523,
-0.0053470726,
0.0325037874,
0.0258946326,
-0.037087176,
-0.0106750587,
-0.0146257794,
-0.0156395976,
-0.0030915118,
0.0015653132,
-0.0514995232,
-0.0157624576,
-0.0136853028,
0.0293466039,
-0.0147840399,
-0.0010454811,
2.42585759e-34,
0.0314843357,
-0.0305167716,
0.0268772189,
-0.0059126066,
0.0082116062,
0.0026991945,
-0.035644196,
-0.0186647531,
-0.0257394183,
-0.0077069076,
-0.0276389625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03208v1
|
Cerebras-GPT: Open Compute-Optimal Language Models Trained on the Cerebras Wafer-Scale Cluster
| 2023-04-06T16:43:16 | 2023-04-06T16:43:16 |
Nolan Dey, Gurpreet Gosal, Zhiming, Chen, Hemant Khachane, William Marshall, Ribhu Pathria, Marvin Tom, Joel Hestness
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We study recent research advances that improve large language models through
efficient pre-training and scaling, and open datasets and tools. We combine
these advances to introduce Cerebras-GPT, a family of open compute-optimal
language models scaled from 111M to 13B parameters. We train Cerebras-GPT
models on the Eleuther Pile dataset following DeepMind Chinchilla scaling rules
for efficient pre-training (highest accuracy for a given compute budget). We
characterize the predictable power-law scaling and compare Cerebras-GPT with
other publicly-available models to show all Cerebras-GPT models have
state-of-the-art training efficiency on both pre-training and downstream
objectives. We describe our learnings including how Maximal Update
Parameterization ($\mu$P) can further improve large model scaling, improving
accuracy and hyperparameter predictability at scale. We release our pre-trained
models and code, making this paper the first open and reproducible work
comparing compute-optimal model scaling to models trained on fixed dataset
sizes. Cerebras-GPT models are available on HuggingFace:
https://huggingface.co/cerebras.
|
[
-0.0258323886,
0.0677796379,
0.0001810927,
0.0102271652,
-0.0192888398,
-0.0028944935,
0.0426607877,
0.0257844795,
-0.0221422575,
0.0388720706,
-0.0016898694,
-0.0613485351,
-0.0188965965,
0.0442755111,
-0.0009158002,
-0.0140523855,
0.0262987465,
-0.0541950613,
-0.0027243732,
-0.0221321788,
-0.0190670993,
-0.0074233166,
0.0135924928,
0.0193221346,
-0.0053449515,
-0.0091056786,
-0.0173706375,
0.0079846177,
0.0105641289,
-0.0114004277,
0.0245338399,
0.0584289134,
0.0286240987,
0.0591968,
0.0000024202,
-0.0246387552,
-0.03248417,
0.0118038272,
-0.0165833309,
0.0474467948,
0.0489445291,
-0.0508466549,
-0.047883749,
0.030488437,
-0.0033803803,
-0.0241772067,
0.089132309,
0.0148513233,
0.0218975469,
0.0624138638,
-0.0027439329,
-0.019512292,
0.0513687059,
-0.0443916395,
-0.0471738093,
-0.0209864341,
0.0130867083,
0.0251865629,
-0.0186128765,
0.017584933,
-0.0249176174,
0.0016978425,
0.0402355008,
-0.0084478054,
0.0022360538,
0.0532982312,
-0.0426929146,
-0.0160073172,
-0.0000644703,
0.0901025161,
-0.0189930834,
-0.0321216434,
-0.0117625911,
-0.0251569096,
-0.1017845422,
-0.0385671891,
-0.0380943194,
0.0126086632,
0.0237954184,
0.0185331665,
-0.0252432637,
-0.0144260572,
0.0638180003,
0.0185897462,
-0.0020902681,
0.0559236705,
0.0241243839,
-0.0319909677,
-0.0299512371,
-0.0446422026,
-0.0526924059,
-0.0210123044,
-0.0035411415,
0.022073973,
0.0043245303,
-0.0071131121,
-0.0197447427,
-0.0389050059,
0.0103670098,
-0.0228125546,
0.0822279528,
0.0477131195,
0.0035451329,
0.0711893067,
-0.0223914329,
0.0294695981,
-0.0395275727,
-0.0007993075,
-0.0261379145,
-0.0120651647,
0.0108467313,
-0.0032701213,
-0.0533161238,
-0.0166133996,
-0.0254397467,
-0.0541684665,
-0.0088286884,
-0.0388557427,
0.0187694207,
-0.0250141397,
0.0505323075,
0.0121512152,
-0.0612957701,
-0.0200745016,
0.0005315075,
0.0721706152,
-0.0216939598,
0.0040280079,
0.0092255734,
-0.0508555621,
-0.0632178485,
0.0002171502,
-0.0140184294,
-0.0056850407,
0.0501250997,
0.0500873812,
0.0154039022,
-0.031890478,
-0.0188811645,
0.0119510395,
-0.0262744576,
-0.0466141701,
-0.033337336,
-0.0627337918,
0.0087857237,
-0.0163725335,
0.000307426,
-0.0224695299,
0.0233533867,
0.0049016811,
-0.028227115,
0.0341830216,
-0.0045994436,
-0.014295971,
0.0425779633,
0.0025944302,
-0.0329578482,
0.0533681847,
0.0548395924,
0.0584536865,
0.0206265412,
-0.0198919326,
-0.0277566873,
0.0480940305,
0.0362785906,
0.0216439236,
-0.0487355068,
-0.0058405767,
0.0307141189,
0.0312578082,
0.0666989312,
0.0475476123,
-0.0274110548,
-0.0229675826,
0.0377518162,
0.0429300293,
0.0084678428,
0.0281242244,
0.0013715676,
-0.0149096847,
0.0133139854,
-0.06659697,
-0.031349089,
0.0045453943,
0.0038062893,
-0.0181817245,
0.0632764846,
0.0410904139,
-0.0115808723,
-0.0197875518,
-0.0333284214,
-0.018939659,
-0.0148816472,
-0.0407174714,
0.0599572398,
-0.010539351,
-0.0276088603,
0.0536488853,
0.0647812709,
-0.0561885871,
-0.0107762916,
-0.0345649421,
0.0387487896,
0.0053697429,
0.0282998234,
-0.0290386993,
0.0015884358,
-0.002565295,
0.0108318198,
0.0566850863,
0.0352465063,
0.0213181097,
0.0293704383,
-0.0718465149,
0.0010760468,
0.0206699725,
0.0059752748,
-0.0351786464,
0.0348001383,
-0.0083601512,
0.0275880732,
-0.0367959179,
-0.0529059283,
0.0224944986,
-0.0325247347,
-0.0383290537,
0.0019341885,
-0.0082738958,
0.0328172706,
-0.0061565777,
-0.0382051989,
-0.0117234979,
0.0282808375,
-0.0148237161,
-0.010870914,
-0.0247772299,
-0.0600526556,
0.0356092788,
0.0321816579,
0.0276034269,
0.0662150905,
-0.0095758503,
-0.0165405907,
-0.0359916724,
0.0602588542,
-0.0033378468,
0.0654324442,
-0.0433296487,
0.012802518,
-0.0328214951,
0.0426182114,
-0.0397867113,
0.0448647924,
-0.0303629953,
0.0041060667,
0.0407243706,
0.0126516921,
0.0340752602,
-0.0272803418,
0.0091958893,
0.0214665923,
0.0119210724,
0.0269690473,
0.0200463757,
0.0059618698,
-0.0098136673,
0.0014474386,
-0.0825617462,
-0.0017545603,
-0.0520364419,
0.0192965623,
0.0365260504,
0.014508551,
-0.0084426254,
0.0031190861,
0.016373381,
0.0146606844,
-0.0231103618,
-0.0204209201,
-0.013280645,
-0.0160766114,
-0.005118398,
-0.0366641395,
-0.0547812022,
-0.0133490413,
0.0507285967,
0.0087048309,
0.0709726289,
-0.0386265814,
0.0383281074,
-0.0011438717,
0.0390473194,
-0.0243019499,
-0.0587360226,
0.0154897124,
-0.0521272048,
0.0374500342,
0.0448846668,
0.0073481468,
0.0044840998,
0.0285443421,
0.0115132006,
-0.0547533818,
0.0044089775,
-0.0333002098,
0.0023427212,
-0.020269379,
-0.0085845152,
-0.0246277768,
0.0783601627,
-0.0271289796,
-0.0211351141,
-0.0619991235,
-0.0099943867,
-0.0111818323,
-0.0175631884,
0.01909413,
0.0145541262,
-0.0213779211,
0.0078717731,
-0.0070936065,
-0.0685042739,
0.0454012565,
-0.0463910587,
-0.0123040248,
-0.0620764717,
-0.0387119874,
-0.0494350828,
0.0512122698,
0.0228725839,
0.0591657534,
-0.0019165138,
0.0170714166,
-0.0389421694,
0.0304095913,
-0.0279286131,
0.0028085019,
-0.0498020053,
-0.037447378,
0.0282648485,
-0.0131865237,
-0.0511923768,
-0.007103228,
0.0210982524,
-0.0173074082,
0.0334694088,
0.036338035,
-0.0717917979,
-0.0083703352,
0.029348271,
0.0398591161,
0.0638206527,
-0.0073116184,
-0.0030368238,
-0.0242632832,
0.0302925557,
0.05751184,
0.0301216766,
0.0591158606,
-0.0169544052,
0.0090869814,
0.0386376046,
0.0561470464,
0.0037617302,
-0.0740883723,
0.0122974664,
0.0401652306,
-0.0055762725,
-0.0255068019,
0.003257991,
0.0448178835,
-0.035769254,
0.0035332125,
0.0718894899,
-0.0036165447,
-0.0682922974,
0.0255711693,
0.0027673682,
0.0716575384,
-0.0074554887,
-0.0020148349,
-0.0637021288,
-0.021503374,
0.0001219716,
0.0197959431,
0.0288342685,
-0.0191807244,
-0.0152742118,
-0.1127252877,
0.0098460149,
0.0162828844,
-0.0527536534,
-0.0082792509,
-0.0818754584,
-0.0129472846,
-0.0619406961,
0.021853365,
0.0458915085,
-0.0192543119,
0.0041306475,
0.0342144519,
0.0197154321,
-0.0623881407,
0.0489275679,
-0.058310803,
0.0605123006,
0.0369140953,
-0.0241984632,
-0.0041365828,
-0.0259482525,
0.0500265248,
0.0214935504,
0.0131162088,
-0.0132885585,
-0.0068288567,
0.0462850109,
-0.0261289533,
0.0135870269,
0.0226776898,
-0.0222792197,
-0.004401525,
0.0073523754,
0.0668706223,
0.0141244624,
-0.0365930907,
0.0035995622,
-0.0288377665,
0.0028386908,
0.056076847,
-0.0016386829,
-0.0225627962,
-0.0754017085,
-0.0239622258,
0.0133992769,
-0.0022422276,
-0.0162835438,
-0.0100597544,
0.0352743492,
-0.0130355163,
-0.0112786628,
0.0302683841,
-0.0016853224,
0.0421299636,
0.0222339313,
-0.0489114076,
0.0464189462,
0.0174153727,
-0.0457940735,
0.0388251655,
-0.041688215,
0.0078460351,
-0.1187649742,
-0.0106972083,
0.0729569569,
0.0001319073,
-0.0194550566,
0.041153565,
-0.1080109999,
-0.0856358409,
0.0100787375,
0.0379823744,
0.0287841987,
0.0194474179,
0.0197717752,
-0.0779743269,
0.0476963483,
0.0061757602,
-0.0778285488,
0.0279962625,
0.0220766366,
-0.0503099225,
-0.0216948874,
0.0177748259,
0.0027566755,
0.0547424518,
-0.0079732714,
0.0465043671,
-0.0337360427,
-0.073913224,
-0.0203255359,
0.0189353339,
0.0241629444,
-0.0040235044,
-0.0105198054,
-0.042437654,
0.0274766441,
0.031314835,
0.0372541137,
-0.0279514231,
0.0222242083,
0.0186194666,
-0.0244638119,
-0.0115066888,
-0.0157044064,
0.0477644205,
-0.0148806721,
-0.0272319335,
0.0193217099,
0.0091523472,
0.0432291329,
0.0845479295,
-0.0263875816,
-0.006570885,
0.0425410569,
-0.0563301817,
0.0432940759,
-0.0073868353,
0.0013733344,
0.0030421894,
-0.0074075428,
-0.0301023908,
0.0301051605,
-0.0582187474,
-0.0886015743,
-0.0733706132,
-0.0299862903,
0.0343238302,
0.0258237366,
0.0315570794,
-0.0445526913,
-0.0235735476,
-0.0084459754,
0.0028598949,
0.0081177587,
-0.0049786428,
0.0215115286,
0.0156198367,
-0.0258714557,
0.0600298159,
0.0552105978,
0.0272512157,
0.034002617,
0.0122994045,
0.0639019608,
-0.0091466969,
-0.0445951,
-0.0149587523,
0.0475299247,
-0.0093458351,
0.007379245,
-0.0201939642,
-0.0321468189,
0.006864497,
0.0072041191,
0.0134466616,
-0.0248838682,
0.0381107889,
0.0468552634,
-0.0228767954,
-0.0194383673,
0.0277934019,
-0.0062572742,
-0.0066707153,
-0.0243311394,
0.0077822758,
-6.966575352e-33,
0.0180107038,
0.0453483425,
0.0184036661,
0.0124600371,
-0.0227606036,
0.0109700644,
-0.0206846911,
-0.0178922154,
-0.0162570029,
-0.0139631014,
-0.0246573277,
0.0287538767,
0.0129225217,
0.0302892644,
-0.0084720468,
0.0091087352,
0.0765166506,
-0.0235383045,
-0.0344680995,
0.0542095006,
0.0282432418,
0.0223493986,
0.0604959726,
-0.0635258406,
-0.0207066294,
0.0343634859,
-0.0362056717,
0.004404454,
-0.019235855,
0.0369306356,
-0.0552136824,
0.0528146401,
-0.0465775467,
-0.0688732415,
-0.0114970682,
-0.0368215516,
-0.0544284731,
0.0056838742,
-0.0258252919,
-0.0144620221,
-0.0186595786,
-0.0074896147,
0.004013815,
0.0182036813,
-0.0434085988,
0.0073422561,
0.0261852909,
-0.0188840255,
-0.0014998082,
0.0191366151,
-0.0356697179,
0.0255360268,
0.0029982585,
0.0350208133,
0.0084995162,
-0.0399131179,
-0.0314044803,
0.0402124301,
-0.0763476565,
0.0352623723,
0.0509070531,
0.0608001687,
0.0446127653,
0.0219382402,
0.0093083465,
0.0498512536,
0.0217664689,
-0.0057503297,
-0.0055237091,
-0.0101607153,
0.0470187776,
0.0602024011,
0.0379550867,
0.0189958215,
0.0660749003,
-0.0446351022,
-0.0871324614,
-0.0148971314,
0.0519178063,
0.0044390289,
0.0215515718,
0.0159994923,
-0.0256359894,
-0.0119178528,
-0.0332458429,
-0.0084904209,
-0.0171962641,
-0.020541057,
-0.0177716892,
0.0356062539,
-0.0623167641,
-0.030636698,
0.0233945809,
-0.0340433419,
0.0208985545,
0.0471187904,
-0.0172400642,
0.0156380609,
0.0115535082,
0.0374074318,
-0.0587827824,
-0.0745223984,
-0.0018933389,
0.0122110592,
0.043582771,
0.002451089,
-0.011755025,
0.0625173673,
-0.0622764528,
0.0012867235,
-0.0305119436,
-0.0126768695,
0.0417504497,
0.0265729111,
0.0091866888,
-0.0086317863,
0.0180678535,
-0.002629404,
0.0169476066,
0.0274160765,
0.0223854762,
0.0063024983,
0.0135328211,
0.0405844562,
-0.0283883195,
0.0093224728,
-0.0346085392,
0.0150502948,
0.0302280821,
-0.0641307607,
-0.0347726755,
0.0544735081,
3.006e-7,
0.0108163795,
0.046522297,
0.0396321192,
0.0131371263,
-0.0007210405,
0.0131319026,
0.0003202141,
0.0172119997,
-0.0129401432,
0.0089114467,
0.0050580786,
0.0457456559,
0.0437177345,
0.0067703244,
-0.0565519035,
0.0068758549,
-0.0942980051,
0.0245691538,
-0.0456351452,
-0.0475274175,
-0.039406728,
0.1338953525,
0.0181717668,
-0.0390200764,
0.0079791164,
-0.0061933673,
0.0353511311,
-0.0343271308,
0.0703357831,
0.0287412554,
-0.0310328454,
0.0234310031,
-0.0588969551,
0.0137457326,
0.0053472058,
0.016280992,
0.0004017222,
0.0599355362,
0.0001544166,
-0.0039575454,
0.035650447,
-0.0121114375,
-0.0104186367,
-0.0709923059,
0.05363575,
0.0129754385,
-0.0076846522,
-0.035306789,
0.0212870017,
-0.0549558289,
0.0393422954,
-0.0355827101,
0.0202939101,
0.0101889903,
-0.0065042861,
-0.0205459371,
0.0091129364,
-0.0642729998,
-0.0419289805,
-0.000497597,
-0.0362591632,
-0.071788013,
-0.0519378297,
-0.0180548076,
0.0235253591,
-0.0288580451,
0.0206501465,
3.252831411e-34,
0.0575193837,
-0.0102775572,
0.01362547,
0.0098218406,
0.0137777999,
-0.0216810722,
0.0272230022,
-0.0207769219,
-0.0212323386,
-0.1385355294,
-0.0525039881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03159v1
|
Bridging the Language Gap: Knowledge Injected Multilingual Question Answering
| 2023-04-06T15:41:25 | 2023-04-06T15:41:25 |
Zhichao Duan, Xiuxing Li, Zhengyan Zhang, Zhenyu Li, Ning Liu, Jianyong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Question Answering (QA) is the task of automatically answering questions
posed by humans in natural languages. There are different settings to answer a
question, such as abstractive, extractive, boolean, and multiple-choice QA. As
a popular topic in natural language processing tasks, extractive question
answering task (extractive QA) has gained extensive attention in the past few
years. With the continuous evolvement of the world, generalized cross-lingual
transfer (G-XLT), where question and answer context are in different languages,
poses some unique challenges over cross-lingual transfer (XLT), where question
and answer context are in the same language. With the boost of corresponding
development of related benchmarks, many works have been done to improve the
performance of various language QA tasks. However, only a few works are
dedicated to the G-XLT task. In this work, we propose a generalized
cross-lingual transfer framework to enhance the model's ability to understand
different languages. Specifically, we first assemble triples from different
languages to form multilingual knowledge. Since the lack of knowledge between
different languages greatly limits models' reasoning ability, we further design
a knowledge injection strategy via leveraging link prediction techniques to
enrich the model storage of multilingual knowledge. In this way, we can
profoundly exploit rich semantic knowledge. Experiment results on real-world
datasets MLQA demonstrate that the proposed method can improve the performance
by a large margin, outperforming the baseline method by 13.18%/12.00% F1/EM on
average.
|
[
0.0261409171,
0.0181097575,
-0.0193045344,
0.088394329,
-0.0250622127,
0.0075623994,
-0.0201785732,
-0.0231968984,
0.0407619737,
-0.0314476341,
-0.0410793461,
-0.0015649673,
-0.0394263081,
0.0256260466,
0.0204179604,
-0.0132819023,
0.0549181849,
-0.0399662107,
-0.0280262027,
-0.0381713957,
-0.0144168986,
0.0301229283,
0.0313360468,
-0.0237126891,
-0.0020559668,
-0.003244716,
-0.0043549035,
-0.0183757562,
0.0331219696,
0.0317424573,
-0.0113452449,
0.0151162893,
0.0080495635,
0.0098484922,
0.000001983,
-0.0571856871,
-0.0266554002,
-0.0088487947,
-0.0136411032,
-0.047129333,
-0.0562662035,
-0.0136995083,
0.0182711259,
-0.0004319045,
-0.0588119365,
-0.0089807073,
0.0330690481,
0.0387159549,
0.049525138,
0.0489015467,
-0.0087582301,
-0.0064679221,
0.0443741158,
0.0093334084,
0.0379980728,
-0.0457849093,
0.0193567313,
0.0581309982,
-0.0015907907,
0.0120292818,
-0.0196514353,
0.062837705,
0.0519627407,
0.0227409173,
-0.0164885763,
0.0097364178,
-0.0541254468,
0.0151885357,
-0.0263518617,
0.0841500163,
-0.0504063107,
-0.0000586654,
-0.0357076712,
0.0204498079,
0.0090082586,
0.0055962815,
-0.0323203467,
-0.0096615888,
-0.0186415166,
-0.0046140328,
0.0433301516,
0.0003268107,
0.007123909,
-0.013472707,
-0.0160338487,
0.08762189,
0.0189067386,
-0.0082111852,
0.0498146787,
0.023624042,
0.0024782943,
-0.0452977605,
0.0048401561,
0.0626314655,
-0.0046323473,
0.0294242296,
-0.0005388453,
-0.0118175969,
0.0080321189,
-0.0455029421,
-0.005998563,
0.0432470068,
-0.0256293975,
0.0835672468,
-0.0890260935,
0.0199267864,
-0.0509221815,
0.0036534027,
-0.048342023,
-0.0849738345,
-0.0404355936,
-0.0309741292,
-0.0155038396,
0.0348307826,
-0.062023215,
0.0257679243,
-0.0136219002,
0.0223288015,
0.0004828005,
-0.0024070626,
-0.0059971721,
0.0095007177,
-0.0134823127,
-0.0117735565,
-0.0443944782,
0.030553868,
-0.0634034425,
0.0038406132,
-0.025055185,
-0.0631095842,
-0.0123695135,
0.0045798221,
0.0160506815,
-0.0572012551,
0.0319511071,
0.0962327495,
-0.0454753377,
-0.0033082198,
-0.0171639994,
-0.0351672433,
0.0220840313,
-0.0809506997,
0.0274985265,
-0.0745239928,
0.0791133866,
0.011859173,
-0.0242044553,
-0.0102099031,
0.0087971492,
0.0027856173,
-0.0393387452,
0.0628203526,
-0.0129752643,
-0.0141157005,
0.0193457343,
0.0034525997,
-0.0090981098,
0.0641270354,
-0.0127658397,
-0.0052194158,
0.065369159,
0.0068907598,
-0.0026810912,
0.0476429127,
0.0493316576,
0.0241839141,
0.0200410578,
0.0616557524,
0.013742039,
-0.0170339327,
0.0111805284,
0.0182788186,
-0.0052034575,
-0.0129391113,
0.0016092036,
-0.0015818794,
0.0004755126,
0.0461088493,
0.0257413425,
-0.0284738429,
0.0029237587,
-0.0085638827,
-0.0117368503,
0.0729400292,
-0.0238645971,
0.0065428405,
-0.0037074632,
0.0851598978,
-0.0416981243,
-0.0230691787,
0.0190266464,
-0.0101657305,
0.0099656181,
0.0424808562,
0.0410094894,
0.0327110067,
-0.00551455,
0.0668754801,
0.0475663133,
-0.0271517523,
0.0156861804,
-0.0108197173,
0.0450667106,
0.0174280554,
-0.0195114855,
-0.0425462946,
-0.0326265171,
-0.009358624,
0.0022757156,
-0.0045572338,
0.0288717952,
-0.029532304,
0.053053394,
-0.0210846942,
-0.0226259176,
-0.0036272502,
-0.0347095057,
0.0682382062,
0.029485669,
0.0605837591,
0.011727808,
-0.0408791304,
0.038571801,
0.0045857029,
-0.084128432,
-0.015416556,
0.034477409,
0.0300708506,
0.0149054509,
0.0454392992,
0.0279067159,
-0.0054811169,
0.0309820808,
-0.0663984343,
-0.0513577908,
0.0360983238,
-0.0201350562,
-0.0579981878,
0.0388407223,
-0.01208412,
-0.0324171931,
0.0214481819,
-0.0265419055,
-0.0382020473,
0.0042519467,
0.010407472,
0.0496777855,
-0.048711136,
-0.0393472426,
0.0279256646,
0.0290770195,
-0.0187619142,
0.0705780312,
0.0141077545,
0.0336512551,
0.0053646769,
-0.0179206226,
0.0407069251,
-0.007397322,
-0.0039893771,
0.0379522927,
-0.015514099,
0.0146037899,
0.0317812413,
0.0289746858,
-0.0458170809,
0.0128116971,
-0.0584690124,
0.0211095698,
-0.0072760456,
0.0351535939,
0.0135580627,
0.0333033502,
-0.0007465344,
-0.0212845188,
-0.1144620851,
0.0245458558,
0.0256706569,
0.0266600773,
0.0337971561,
0.0176504496,
0.0434766859,
-0.0223452225,
-0.000338662,
-0.0019927172,
0.0466051102,
-0.030130323,
-0.010450583,
-0.023163978,
-0.0019158355,
-0.0690747201,
0.0351358615,
-0.0172422267,
-0.0272389278,
-0.0588967279,
-0.0140837496,
0.0340266041,
0.0442935564,
-0.0445626341,
-0.0574322641,
0.0444221944,
-0.021223519,
-0.046639923,
0.0601684786,
-0.0282399338,
0.0050477562,
-0.0276252087,
0.0006965685,
-0.0125923157,
0.0358578563,
0.0035932052,
-0.0435492024,
-0.0498922393,
0.0133550186,
0.0114855077,
-0.0203740653,
-0.0536422282,
0.0384006575,
0.0129139731,
0.064700231,
-0.014462715,
0.0089519853,
0.067690663,
0.0113228401,
-0.0167390369,
-0.0534888841,
-0.0158731584,
-0.0782178715,
0.0491650291,
-0.0422457382,
0.0440463573,
-0.0326980352,
0.0086134635,
-0.0659711435,
-0.0236504152,
0.0035083177,
-0.0183348842,
0.0249232613,
-0.0236487389,
-0.0229655001,
-0.0188186076,
-0.0491731912,
-0.0296409596,
-0.0022597029,
-0.0259304363,
0.0118365977,
-0.0262085404,
-0.0115247238,
0.0033670245,
-0.0170914382,
0.0525083691,
-0.0125581389,
-0.033897575,
-0.0077458639,
-0.0108363377,
0.0850660354,
0.0402272828,
0.0264187511,
0.019507505,
0.012152194,
0.0269189756,
0.0448111333,
-0.0047383104,
-0.0097379116,
0.0181183312,
0.0192264188,
0.0450037941,
0.0202037599,
-0.0399117991,
-0.0219285265,
0.0374047123,
-0.0304765478,
0.0042780624,
0.0765854791,
0.0340337642,
0.0021368552,
-0.0145406993,
-0.0631788298,
0.0249137357,
0.0502907485,
0.0793021992,
-0.0915598422,
-0.0428768769,
-0.0355281681,
-0.0321287513,
0.0219197795,
-0.019618785,
-0.0137531571,
-0.1364733875,
-0.0033435044,
-0.0217555184,
-0.0862715393,
-0.0628909767,
-0.0414226688,
-0.0126784416,
-0.0097074369,
-0.0171165839,
-0.0257155579,
0.0233071353,
-0.0008609716,
0.0097513599,
0.0118679916,
-0.0122286119,
0.0568791553,
-0.0178221557,
-0.0091262013,
0.0336915366,
0.0701936185,
-0.0256525055,
-0.0197882783,
0.0149700725,
-0.0506507568,
-0.0320955291,
-0.0129344696,
0.0467147678,
-0.0058031501,
-0.0156237539,
0.0236056875,
0.0339797214,
-0.052797325,
0.0071407277,
0.0469836369,
0.1147155836,
0.0420399979,
-0.0061777625,
0.0094674574,
-0.0258430261,
-0.015301344,
0.0726293474,
-0.0063328859,
-0.0236641075,
-0.0034317749,
-0.0190859772,
-0.019082807,
-0.0411214791,
-0.009328003,
0.0168233197,
-0.0317475423,
-0.0055099097,
-0.0874343589,
-0.0623565093,
0.0318538621,
0.019249022,
0.0030946897,
0.0200209431,
-0.0096266139,
0.0121946316,
-0.0363094732,
0.0008120129,
-0.0370526165,
0.0165140461,
0.0253281277,
0.0201617088,
0.0217762869,
-0.060668841,
-0.0255656689,
0.0029613862,
-0.0438563116,
-0.0556490868,
-0.0520715304,
0.0707189962,
0.0101999464,
0.0580675751,
-0.0292682964,
0.0085399821,
0.0160567462,
0.0112296212,
-0.0185838547,
-0.0151925348,
0.051764816,
0.0171897579,
0.0057880054,
0.0623804778,
-0.0550767854,
-0.015616443,
0.01566533,
0.01319273,
-0.0634818897,
-0.0409819931,
0.0170377027,
0.0213244352,
-0.0194203984,
0.0158851873,
0.0043710419,
-0.0177063532,
0.0292754676,
-0.0319931842,
-0.039382007,
-0.0443298928,
-0.0085996194,
0.023911288,
-0.0439988971,
0.0163300131,
-0.0196278561,
0.0183505882,
0.0155552616,
-0.0265976712,
-0.0211710446,
0.066809617,
0.0195547566,
0.009523483,
0.0083052134,
0.0000373067,
-0.0210876558,
0.0306676943,
0.0572619624,
-0.0530187115,
0.0335142016,
0.0167741198,
-0.0488175415,
-0.0067938054,
-0.0076534939,
-0.0564843602,
-0.0391900018,
0.0104609858,
-0.0042879321,
0.0604609214,
-0.0283948425,
0.0495412238,
-0.0016874674,
-0.0362871327,
0.0098734526,
0.0070520379,
0.0103251776,
-0.0003160991,
0.0732191652,
0.0092231575,
-0.013911088,
0.0141720455,
0.0526182577,
-0.0351407602,
0.0402941741,
-0.0042845714,
-0.0147021692,
-0.0397386439,
0.0106852287,
0.024459241,
-0.0105801066,
0.0015159709,
0.0404453538,
-0.0609489344,
-0.075412564,
0.0199132618,
-0.0113059441,
-0.0198113024,
0.0049391785,
0.0341439769,
0.0868749693,
0.0473243706,
-0.0492184944,
-0.0465690717,
0.0062486352,
-0.0438223667,
-0.0044865487,
0.0328116007,
-6.12171046e-33,
-0.0117674433,
-0.0043455348,
0.0175084453,
0.0015498719,
0.0069600083,
0.0110578286,
-0.0414316319,
-0.0193724167,
-0.0738994256,
0.0028938497,
-0.0170457065,
-0.0217639934,
0.0020211185,
0.0337696448,
-0.0079775946,
-0.0329279006,
-0.0297230575,
0.0068243826,
-0.0027120614,
0.0239486732,
0.0752442926,
0.0254925676,
0.0811860412,
-0.0207215846,
0.0209503639,
-0.0020708675,
0.0122756176,
0.0571862012,
-0.015042901,
0.0593410172,
-0.027649628,
0.0430765674,
0.0359002426,
-0.0479577631,
0.025262231,
0.0314185545,
-0.1077270433,
-0.0699616745,
0.0346711352,
-0.0033892607,
-0.0434708782,
-0.0302809402,
-0.0230003372,
-0.0196229313,
0.0669111013,
-0.0313267075,
0.0327024199,
-0.0347705111,
-0.0075270352,
-0.0517913923,
-0.0614180528,
-0.0029369048,
-0.0173353981,
-0.0064387941,
0.0204914883,
0.1005881578,
0.0071029034,
-0.0055307522,
-0.0369834825,
-0.000099906,
-0.0387763493,
0.0216839258,
0.0672811642,
-0.0048701176,
-0.0171627179,
0.01399446,
-0.0024323165,
-0.0207713582,
-0.0053027538,
0.0444497205,
-0.0086666271,
0.0222733766,
0.0424276628,
0.0925258324,
-0.001176101,
0.0040415865,
-0.0900774077,
0.0187495574,
0.0067341155,
0.0326364897,
-0.0042467704,
-0.0155095896,
0.0043014027,
-0.0068744179,
-0.0531562641,
0.0079382053,
-0.0204784553,
-0.0301517304,
0.0221365541,
-0.0388187431,
-0.0395387299,
-0.0184608474,
0.0456032231,
-0.0325762741,
0.0107095018,
0.0485644825,
-0.0385559015,
0.0055879289,
0.0149996188,
0.0776330158,
-0.0624491125,
-0.0142052136,
-0.0228089765,
-0.0336792879,
0.0088378424,
0.022057157,
0.0435655341,
-0.0080446629,
-0.0718479156,
0.0048767002,
-0.067771621,
0.0319655053,
-0.017266877,
0.040566247,
-0.0158795025,
0.017273128,
-0.0178494286,
0.0327105299,
0.0556757115,
0.0060257828,
-0.0248742327,
-0.0007367511,
-0.0030149452,
0.0167508628,
-0.0286490172,
0.0063329502,
-0.0443177633,
0.004985115,
-0.0126928389,
-0.0534870438,
-0.0131893102,
0.0321185365,
2.615e-7,
0.0501773283,
-0.0023164894,
-0.0021859154,
0.0413959213,
-0.0035552711,
0.0473446958,
-0.0031490072,
0.0283553284,
0.0335113965,
-0.0177349914,
-0.0326159224,
0.0551047213,
0.0177562572,
0.0500952154,
-0.097612381,
-0.0030252321,
-0.0040388391,
-0.0555542968,
-0.020268077,
-0.0159337595,
0.0373210497,
0.0648788661,
0.0128877852,
-0.0078133959,
-0.049879428,
-0.0272248443,
0.0602361374,
-0.0040763598,
-0.0498136766,
0.00194346,
-0.0042065843,
0.0243888367,
-0.0080936812,
0.052559007,
-0.0385726951,
0.0288531389,
0.0373682305,
0.0435668789,
0.0151317688,
-0.0564227328,
0.0039271861,
-0.0176899396,
0.015640758,
-0.0588360727,
0.1083515286,
-0.0120823141,
-0.0055997288,
-0.0059496555,
-0.0228617545,
0.0065006656,
0.0435598306,
-0.0322246142,
-0.0312583297,
0.0163566284,
0.0397703126,
-0.004565496,
-0.0042232764,
-0.0330972262,
-0.0165939368,
0.0289622173,
-0.0067956983,
-0.0444827639,
0.0175523777,
-0.0202245694,
0.0074264319,
-0.0553944297,
0.0155256996,
2.205026512e-34,
-0.0087081352,
0.0153268734,
0.0222512186,
0.0292195957,
0.0406859219,
-0.0402440988,
-0.0261190739,
-0.0050682649,
0.0406053215,
-0.0318871699,
0.0021484948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03153v1
|
Zero-Shot Next-Item Recommendation using Large Pretrained Language Models
| 2023-04-06T15:35:11 | 2023-04-06T15:35:11 |
Lei Wang, Ee-Peng Lim
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive zero-shot performance
in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks, demonstrating their
capabilities for inference without training examples. Despite their success, no
research has yet explored the potential of LLMs to perform next-item
recommendations in the zero-shot setting. We have identified two major
challenges that must be addressed to enable LLMs to act effectively as
recommenders. First, the recommendation space can be extremely large for LLMs,
and LLMs do not know about the target user's past interacted items and
preferences. To address this gap, we propose a prompting strategy called
Zero-Shot Next-Item Recommendation (NIR) prompting that directs LLMs to make
next-item recommendations. Specifically, the NIR-based strategy involves using
an external module to generate candidate items based on user-filtering or
item-filtering. Our strategy incorporates a 3-step prompting that guides GPT-3
to carry subtasks that capture the user's preferences, select representative
previously watched movies, and recommend a ranked list of 10 movies. We
evaluate the proposed approach using GPT-3 on MovieLens 100K dataset and show
that it achieves strong zero-shot performance, even outperforming some strong
sequential recommendation models trained on the entire training dataset. These
promising results highlight the ample research opportunities to use LLMs as
recommenders. The code can be found at
https://github.com/AGI-Edgerunners/LLM-Next-Item-Rec.
|
[
0.0585467592,
0.0204012208,
0.0226018075,
0.0023603921,
-0.0162539873,
0.0031388155,
0.0197795182,
0.0132800397,
0.0710770264,
-0.0597505942,
-0.0540198646,
-0.0186437331,
-0.0319401138,
0.0235217847,
-0.0099594854,
-0.0220462121,
0.0093156509,
-0.0370096117,
0.0105633521,
0.0236133542,
0.0036545263,
0.0327394195,
0.0259903576,
0.0281036776,
0.0461218208,
-0.0086474735,
-0.0013160961,
-0.0172593109,
0.0034290294,
-0.0602347031,
0.0212942623,
0.029547615,
0.0240792651,
-0.0132693341,
0.0000019365,
-0.0304485504,
0.0185866542,
-0.0462575406,
-0.014095691,
-0.0351719595,
0.0405370928,
0.0576115139,
0.0230839364,
-0.00005376,
-0.0265003368,
-0.0196328387,
0.0188795719,
0.0628561378,
0.0222655293,
0.0578943864,
-0.023447156,
-0.0049637645,
0.0179464296,
-0.0438734852,
0.0747428387,
-0.020582499,
0.0089164153,
-0.0630258471,
0.0602788106,
0.0559719205,
0.0058487193,
-0.0039115846,
0.0133544449,
-0.0022082084,
0.0356583633,
0.043889299,
-0.0308815781,
-0.0050093816,
-0.0328456089,
0.0980463475,
-0.0403150544,
-0.0119266454,
-0.0128480187,
-0.0236173794,
-0.0222822484,
-0.0280120634,
-0.0357253589,
-0.0111095915,
-0.0004772436,
0.0234418344,
0.0425811484,
0.0099226711,
0.0501732975,
0.0254962966,
0.0256360192,
0.0831173062,
0.0242765434,
-0.0363135263,
0.0308710467,
-0.0055493736,
0.0229158811,
-0.0792991072,
0.0192508008,
0.0164119508,
-0.0395872071,
-0.0005520128,
-0.0395525061,
0.06161201,
-0.000865162,
0.0134283025,
0.0493052006,
0.047289744,
-0.0160274357,
0.0611092076,
-0.0000781772,
0.0070341118,
-0.0010381187,
-0.0222919527,
-0.0608086288,
0.0064169639,
-0.0286786258,
0.0193122309,
-0.0071362169,
0.0496660918,
-0.0283843298,
-0.047103893,
-0.0191018134,
0.0444160663,
0.0220181029,
0.0154018113,
0.0005844635,
0.0375371091,
-0.0065212948,
-0.0078055714,
-0.0614297241,
0.0371257961,
-0.0540407188,
0.0315391794,
-0.0061515742,
-0.0048906524,
-0.0079904106,
0.0032254828,
0.0070914719,
-0.0641503409,
0.0287212003,
0.0133479973,
0.0003379941,
-0.0772630423,
-0.0472705029,
0.0009029206,
-0.0023747811,
-0.0597957931,
-0.0284692831,
-0.0437320061,
0.0331772044,
0.0360929668,
0.0065620607,
0.0080403546,
0.029550232,
0.031799145,
-0.0538291484,
0.0669229105,
0.0219156146,
-0.0199890099,
-0.0402885787,
-0.0020176941,
0.0184608661,
0.0142854648,
-0.0246986765,
0.0539706424,
0.0436214991,
0.0221833326,
0.0151924668,
0.0272650663,
-0.0267632622,
0.0282576084,
-0.0431738012,
0.0218957365,
-0.0249933898,
0.0252717063,
0.0205226038,
0.0344345942,
-0.0455165803,
-0.005918975,
0.0477023087,
0.0665258169,
0.002572339,
0.0261414032,
0.0521546528,
0.0305912383,
-0.0350434184,
0.0030635046,
-0.0353950076,
0.055944141,
-0.022445403,
-0.0534131154,
0.0587115176,
-0.0024089348,
-0.0508088954,
-0.0002220539,
0.0323939063,
-0.0474422425,
0.0317634158,
0.005879309,
0.0276833121,
0.0058848639,
-0.0623709075,
-0.0084136184,
0.0290599819,
-0.0155442422,
0.0036067329,
-0.0227731466,
0.07584548,
0.1311071366,
0.0681422129,
-0.0167436302,
-0.0295614358,
-0.0264734067,
0.0078400113,
-0.0211480875,
0.0358367562,
-0.0434764065,
0.0388228521,
-0.0536085367,
-0.0371213183,
0.0339156799,
-0.0179406311,
0.0506217107,
-0.0198000874,
0.0252635181,
0.0075135366,
0.0141652394,
0.0000509133,
0.0060022702,
-0.0110602733,
-0.0514863506,
0.0776950344,
-0.0125673087,
0.0183222629,
0.0026710648,
0.023662528,
-0.022171773,
0.0196143184,
-0.0142841097,
-0.0141488919,
-0.0242153443,
-0.04460508,
-0.0301710237,
0.0257220846,
-0.0029382354,
0.018535858,
0.0420065373,
-0.0158464499,
-0.0408173837,
-0.0288422331,
0.0418497398,
0.0298695769,
-0.0262265857,
0.0164906289,
0.0373107642,
0.0036622181,
-0.0212309789,
0.036643181,
0.0171973985,
0.0352512673,
0.0154905338,
-0.015172815,
0.0088219475,
-0.0398439914,
-0.0387312062,
0.0087173833,
0.017058989,
-0.0016336702,
0.0565397441,
0.0249632467,
-0.0397665761,
-0.0017556056,
-0.073447749,
0.0086841714,
-0.0027034429,
-0.0011163622,
-0.0259142127,
0.0494784415,
-0.008568923,
-0.0573088899,
-0.0281021688,
0.009008117,
-0.0070917257,
-0.0005098438,
0.021888908,
0.0048221983,
0.0162276886,
-0.050011944,
-0.0186097715,
-0.0254210327,
0.028682474,
-0.0078562805,
0.0233496558,
-0.0165155791,
-0.0218350515,
-0.0260016173,
0.0173336696,
-0.01451666,
0.0307845883,
-0.0001110053,
-0.0353411809,
0.0281031132,
0.0217740238,
-0.0089456122,
0.0062215505,
0.0311461352,
-0.0028269009,
-0.0595432781,
0.0126464786,
-0.0322075188,
-0.0091856187,
-0.0314584114,
0.036723353,
0.0046215435,
0.021155186,
-0.0232110731,
0.0059408848,
-0.0547414869,
0.0080864672,
0.0180881806,
0.026286535,
-0.0258277841,
-0.0092102354,
-0.0190112349,
0.0484064817,
0.0079529062,
-0.0169319455,
0.0611608215,
-0.0112505555,
-0.024856206,
-0.0531178191,
-0.0215637255,
-0.0231968649,
0.0296594612,
0.0328291506,
-0.0007631604,
-0.0000539239,
-0.0218222439,
-0.0150104603,
-0.0017614214,
0.0035479171,
-0.0042387689,
0.0198309664,
-0.0097821979,
0.0179983713,
0.0194247626,
-0.0392055809,
-0.0602792911,
-0.0807619691,
-0.033730641,
-0.0211575218,
-0.0456357002,
-0.0074353623,
-0.0500555485,
-0.0091806361,
-0.010285425,
0.0720201284,
0.0013385034,
-0.0188891087,
0.0099112252,
0.0110722538,
0.0705599189,
-0.0749840364,
-0.0423592366,
0.0131606907,
0.0569061227,
0.0411916375,
0.0413100831,
-0.0037009371,
-0.0306374393,
0.0301902164,
0.069212392,
-0.0314935297,
-0.0406492241,
0.0555803627,
0.0127108339,
0.0102755316,
0.0118271029,
0.1153408363,
0.0497776419,
-0.1110547706,
0.0050509442,
0.0158664044,
-0.0172546413,
0.0365818702,
0.043636024,
-0.0895176455,
-0.0592867061,
0.0007591788,
0.0102395117,
0.0148422299,
-0.0556482896,
-0.0429469422,
-0.1143641397,
0.039201472,
0.0138378125,
0.0115295406,
0.0301471315,
-0.0541227832,
0.0050229132,
-0.0298279189,
-0.0102375848,
0.0094409725,
-0.0238695387,
-0.0011700777,
-0.0371688157,
0.0084433025,
-0.0374357291,
0.0864313394,
-0.027263483,
0.0454055853,
0.0531115979,
0.0191553477,
0.0146850357,
0.0075779543,
0.0017960585,
-0.0304092281,
-0.0112913176,
-0.0299832337,
0.0412097834,
-0.0681525096,
0.0149167869,
-0.0333002992,
0.0155780967,
-0.0442204662,
-0.0509060882,
0.0033734618,
0.0861806646,
-0.0493933819,
-0.0165089667,
-0.0153530994,
-0.0105307773,
0.0271264333,
0.0701180771,
-0.0237127952,
-0.0676089302,
-0.01142981,
-0.0349836424,
-0.0378592722,
0.0082949083,
-0.0241238941,
-0.0288917348,
0.0171416514,
0.0090237949,
-0.0461092927,
-0.065300934,
0.0381198116,
0.0059072566,
0.0082272533,
0.0368580371,
-0.0198444277,
-0.0241869073,
0.0203646626,
0.013814589,
-0.0006266548,
0.0222873148,
-0.0547935106,
0.0131440405,
0.0287746806,
-0.0348626114,
0.009622395,
-0.0039023282,
-0.0525855646,
-0.0285108835,
-0.067068845,
0.0722412318,
0.0199531224,
0.0510902964,
-0.0394327939,
-0.080449298,
0.0250715036,
0.0351871587,
-0.0292394329,
-0.0347882286,
0.0006997611,
0.0245821625,
0.004423989,
0.040657822,
-0.0415417962,
0.0172005687,
-0.0353307873,
0.0141999647,
-0.0112303775,
-0.0470329821,
0.0020259612,
-0.0150978658,
0.0426616259,
-0.0328385644,
0.0711977929,
-0.0234447625,
0.0164587703,
-0.0048719374,
-0.0383523218,
-0.0609281138,
0.0203136764,
0.0666658208,
-0.0172064863,
-0.0533937812,
-0.0505291186,
-0.0780398026,
0.04164638,
-0.0624124892,
-0.0090074204,
0.0100181121,
-0.0278589278,
0.0460878573,
0.013072717,
-0.0138510577,
0.0086477734,
0.0320788622,
0.0411100797,
-0.0388574153,
0.0678083822,
-0.0062743053,
0.0049904184,
-0.016585052,
0.0501187816,
-0.0285337716,
-0.0293367486,
0.0045597125,
0.0273973141,
0.0379622392,
-0.0619051009,
0.0219928659,
-0.0279738866,
0.0144230705,
-0.0537790656,
0.004832502,
-0.0306159724,
-0.0487181954,
0.0315826684,
0.0468609072,
-0.0118721481,
0.0710085034,
0.0806502625,
-0.024218509,
-0.0000712973,
0.0537967943,
-0.0275221858,
-0.0247600041,
0.0038607286,
-0.0109263584,
0.0559179448,
-0.0229869708,
0.04027972,
-0.0033320149,
-0.0428817943,
0.0044246661,
-0.063957803,
-0.0024733853,
-0.0427748859,
0.0557473116,
0.0503737181,
0.0010497672,
0.0209776592,
-0.0484686047,
-0.0297300667,
-0.0114162238,
-0.0437878221,
-0.0622966215,
-6.127290018e-33,
0.0258682054,
0.0098791858,
0.0298663247,
0.0188953895,
-0.0142910592,
-0.0347322188,
-0.0162320677,
-0.0064742244,
0.0432348102,
0.0000051251,
-0.0240352377,
0.0008567424,
0.0066342303,
0.0175422002,
0.0055514821,
-0.0451736562,
0.0396682769,
-0.0026165068,
-0.034831766,
0.0235056039,
0.0265046731,
0.0608266965,
0.0137685677,
-0.025667673,
0.0194360483,
-0.0260939188,
0.0096040042,
-0.0029013159,
0.0380806476,
0.0682765692,
-0.0223176777,
0.0489114448,
0.0105443364,
-0.0433570109,
0.0102448892,
0.0157626942,
-0.0681099445,
-0.041906029,
0.0261182562,
-0.0047433609,
-0.0218403786,
-0.0115459422,
-0.0238359496,
-0.0110931136,
0.0014153749,
0.0084614968,
0.0195643175,
-0.0070678191,
-0.042173259,
0.0113886753,
-0.007880656,
0.0022935506,
0.000447598,
-0.0457397401,
0.0304784589,
0.0827845782,
-0.031229673,
0.0474923514,
-0.0612334274,
0.0286386386,
-0.030845698,
0.0349435918,
-0.0066771433,
-0.0339843556,
-0.0324433371,
0.0504539423,
0.0394129865,
-0.0502441712,
0.0056050946,
0.0389509127,
-0.0336048007,
0.0273799133,
-0.0273410343,
-0.0127928928,
0.0650398582,
0.0160239879,
-0.0412046947,
0.0256254077,
0.036219541,
0.0299011711,
0.0408374965,
0.0045691286,
-0.0153489523,
-0.0396793522,
-0.0077822232,
-0.0574671663,
-0.0477249213,
-0.0482263602,
0.0411862098,
0.0424207412,
0.012954805,
-0.0188132431,
0.043175105,
-0.0222570859,
-0.0379717276,
0.0154782981,
-0.0543727316,
-0.0155324424,
0.0248668268,
0.0551393405,
-0.0668592006,
0.0172748864,
0.0264363457,
-0.0569134913,
-0.0333133899,
0.0143821919,
0.0177421402,
0.0609955788,
-0.0616345741,
-0.0178976022,
0.0123449685,
-0.0157885849,
-0.0252283737,
0.0776403844,
0.0312028956,
0.054516416,
-0.0278221909,
0.113217108,
-0.0022020373,
-0.0115036247,
-0.0267200116,
-0.0571257658,
0.0104858931,
-0.0150883682,
-0.0252822172,
-0.0219512526,
-0.0302247815,
-0.0075135836,
0.0335657895,
-0.0685703009,
-0.0123436525,
0.0178618953,
2.677e-7,
-0.0092867389,
0.0215519611,
-0.0227825548,
0.0147461584,
-0.0061588669,
0.0411519557,
0.0098652923,
0.0613490865,
0.0515687093,
0.0405206345,
0.026096398,
0.0167121068,
-0.0030944627,
-0.0183760077,
-0.0823865309,
0.0280761886,
-0.0455231443,
-0.0123234745,
-0.0721168593,
-0.0394766554,
0.019155262,
0.0982316807,
0.0549079739,
-0.0156381764,
0.0083235344,
-0.0372794978,
0.0708982497,
-0.0265063141,
-0.0374133475,
-0.0343853869,
0.0413226262,
0.0185255408,
-0.037320435,
0.0153780058,
-0.0223156232,
0.0060162889,
-0.002468301,
0.0567811057,
-0.0319636837,
-0.0426864065,
0.0060021942,
0.0258857906,
0.0122533161,
-0.0009805376,
0.1079385057,
-0.0255101547,
0.0002475876,
0.0096526342,
-0.0303911287,
0.0013189603,
0.0275351871,
-0.0188577119,
-0.0329047553,
-0.0096967891,
0.0455924459,
0.0181877501,
-0.0200779475,
-0.0768053755,
0.0000012393,
-0.0046070679,
0.0060787415,
-0.0258718617,
-0.0433672592,
0.0020183902,
-0.0066399057,
-0.0401731282,
0.014480276,
2.420392919e-34,
0.0207922794,
0.0108102458,
0.0116148302,
-0.0156253912,
0.0018846012,
0.0152267255,
-0.0038403729,
0.0201029312,
0.0599755161,
-0.0847381353,
-0.0472941212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03145v2
|
Evaluating the Robustness of Machine Reading Comprehension Models to Low Resource Entity Renaming
| 2023-04-06T15:29:57 | 2024-04-16T18:04:14 |
Clemencia Siro, Tunde Oluwaseyi Ajayi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Question answering (QA) models have shown compelling results in the task of
Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC). Recently these systems have proved to
perform better than humans on held-out test sets of datasets e.g. SQuAD, but
their robustness is not guaranteed. The QA model's brittleness is exposed when
evaluated on adversarial generated examples by a performance drop. In this
study, we explore the robustness of MRC models to entity renaming, with
entities from low-resource regions such as Africa. We propose EntSwap, a method
for test-time perturbations, to create a test set whose entities have been
renamed. In particular, we rename entities of type: country, person,
nationality, location, organization, and city, to create AfriSQuAD2. Using the
perturbed test set, we evaluate the robustness of three popular MRC models. We
find that compared to base models, large models perform well comparatively on
novel entities. Furthermore, our analysis indicates that entity type person
highly challenges the MRC models' performance.
|
[
0.0725465864,
0.0669544563,
-0.0229542702,
0.0263833683,
-0.0107860183,
0.0456338674,
0.0360502526,
-0.0247303881,
0.0179585107,
0.0003482316,
0.0226621237,
-0.0404168442,
0.0016250378,
-0.0390660167,
0.0380336978,
-0.062793225,
0.0618128851,
-0.0258896183,
-0.0202995744,
0.0021147251,
-0.0433650985,
0.0017744798,
0.0008473752,
0.0006172822,
0.0764402598,
0.0005690935,
-0.0182220284,
0.024103513,
0.0347849131,
0.0067659118,
0.0001230625,
0.0521219969,
-0.0447173007,
0.0742894486,
0.0000020245,
-0.0390418246,
-0.0477153584,
0.0152470293,
-0.0313916765,
0.0564238168,
0.013403466,
-0.0420246683,
-0.0205613244,
-0.0090246433,
0.0015193931,
-0.0013519491,
0.028298296,
0.0043324088,
0.0703890771,
0.078125,
0.0223614257,
0.0087164845,
0.0000715648,
-0.0371950381,
-0.0071336781,
-0.1001792774,
0.0250194035,
0.0037833941,
-0.0009980991,
0.03606233,
-0.0350805558,
0.0416736938,
0.0261827651,
0.043879278,
-0.0285706557,
0.029996492,
0.002102572,
0.0151008675,
-0.0036649443,
0.0978163108,
-0.006043769,
0.0025912053,
-0.0108136283,
0.0208518207,
-0.0055837766,
0.0507532358,
-0.0203388631,
-0.030888686,
-0.0094104186,
-0.0254734829,
-0.009521178,
-0.0188131947,
0.0374295972,
0.0570032708,
-0.0363016985,
0.0169506595,
0.0283617098,
-0.0344840214,
-0.0273235887,
0.0246669296,
-0.0306782667,
-0.0357306898,
0.0240794215,
0.0430760235,
-0.0103403591,
0.0167800263,
-0.0461037233,
-0.0402539186,
0.0103118923,
-0.0137181263,
-0.0071862265,
0.0330272764,
0.0007926488,
0.081101574,
-0.0648733154,
0.0598413497,
-0.0174633209,
0.0330708288,
-0.0279643163,
-0.0277753286,
-0.0339547396,
-0.0253626145,
-0.0353970453,
0.0076338905,
-0.0661164746,
0.0194978062,
-0.0345099717,
0.0168078355,
0.0424451604,
0.004022331,
-0.0443347022,
0.0108111715,
-0.0480690375,
-0.0271015186,
-0.0413441285,
0.0186980907,
-0.051911667,
-0.0196498651,
-0.0138922753,
-0.0419177413,
-0.0257114135,
-0.0316262804,
-0.042522449,
-0.0294036698,
0.0161329508,
0.093098104,
-0.0071248859,
-0.0481980667,
-0.0528395548,
0.0067779445,
0.0295569859,
-0.0422853343,
-0.0120355906,
-0.0318854041,
0.0448657162,
-0.0018404102,
0.00663104,
-0.0565888956,
-0.0074653621,
0.0230094232,
-0.0490317829,
0.1107152551,
0.0043605929,
0.0188347921,
0.0493092313,
0.0111122495,
-0.0072709853,
0.0547438264,
0.047774557,
-0.0312111229,
0.0752160922,
0.0112591367,
-0.0120252715,
0.0372247882,
0.020897733,
0.0209934302,
0.0171484016,
0.0177347399,
-0.0334028341,
0.0452151448,
0.0190569982,
0.0432389267,
-0.0043150517,
-0.0849241987,
0.0707366019,
0.0285673272,
-0.0282115918,
0.0437273532,
0.0432111397,
0.009796544,
0.0001848024,
0.0158946123,
-0.0464577042,
0.0025811798,
-0.0651422739,
0.0085131908,
0.0115920668,
0.0425545312,
-0.040560957,
-0.0135367112,
0.0221835673,
0.0320574455,
0.0146387517,
0.0226254817,
0.0563471764,
0.0217641443,
-0.0557930134,
0.0013611353,
0.0079884147,
-0.008787741,
0.0018217232,
-0.0504084378,
0.0262727365,
0.0273761265,
0.0591589585,
0.0098235086,
-0.0292628128,
0.0009130561,
0.0085539576,
0.0191678721,
0.0582207665,
-0.011173063,
0.0302231461,
-0.0218677912,
0.0120291747,
0.0245018192,
0.0028764736,
0.0388368629,
0.0710138083,
0.0296003465,
0.0285752974,
-0.0854599252,
-0.035732504,
0.0535008535,
-0.0722007528,
-0.0221947804,
0.0101313824,
0.0241796356,
-0.0132924123,
0.021093009,
0.0035146514,
-0.0052275006,
-0.0009412923,
-0.0103258733,
0.0137525033,
-0.0024241984,
-0.0026917588,
-0.0496904664,
0.000417363,
-0.0273076054,
-0.0296800099,
0.057871256,
-0.0174715128,
-0.0388258435,
-0.0064406246,
-0.0369633771,
-0.0251934957,
-0.0255686119,
0.0179304983,
-0.005565342,
0.0323673263,
-0.0716494098,
0.0571013317,
-0.0106934002,
0.0327254198,
0.0094176913,
0.0499345921,
-0.014324164,
-0.0567525998,
-0.05858998,
0.0228559189,
0.0096394047,
-0.0348023511,
-0.0295271464,
-0.0131501565,
-0.0489892364,
-0.0084515745,
-0.0533509329,
0.0331684798,
-0.0139101353,
0.0199451558,
0.0141011598,
0.0324730091,
-0.0262645986,
-0.0184070021,
0.021912761,
-0.00761563,
0.0080211628,
0.0509184748,
0.0240240693,
-0.0039025352,
-0.0317038298,
0.0036113814,
-0.0288916156,
-0.0050544478,
0.0707887486,
0.0298907198,
-0.0140380822,
-0.0570444576,
-0.0001197927,
-0.0305102449,
-0.017648736,
-0.0097437836,
-0.0377399139,
-0.0109852068,
0.0279164463,
0.0291669481,
0.0538638681,
-0.001644374,
0.0250368435,
-0.0081580942,
0.0083366716,
-0.0204260685,
0.0285925791,
-0.0086621623,
-0.0221424047,
0.0003949803,
-0.08119414,
-0.007815633,
0.0730639696,
0.001595729,
-0.0081911236,
-0.0361669995,
0.0471078493,
-0.0434192233,
-0.0396013968,
-0.0549943335,
0.0382218324,
-0.0146092968,
0.0318126678,
-0.0516848229,
-0.0166345313,
0.1196553707,
-0.0002317628,
-0.0077933297,
-0.0332353935,
0.0031268839,
-0.0241372976,
0.0417438112,
-0.011286051,
0.0025154231,
-0.009740103,
-0.0454556383,
-0.043974001,
0.0185527503,
0.0091303214,
-0.0111758048,
0.0205988958,
-0.0413692556,
0.0087378798,
-0.0141319828,
-0.0057423105,
-0.0396846682,
0.0068422379,
-0.0276132915,
0.0027842599,
-0.0225333124,
-0.0081663094,
-0.0461688787,
0.0610079058,
0.0475084595,
0.0144159403,
-0.025427429,
-0.0113450103,
-0.0100800721,
0.064022541,
0.0206994675,
0.0299296211,
0.037142951,
-0.0758334026,
0.0592126995,
0.0236560553,
0.0090284543,
-0.0266869497,
0.0233250502,
0.0067298375,
-0.0020153557,
-0.0446790233,
0.0076322001,
-0.0128779942,
0.0578532703,
-0.0561879911,
-0.0227101091,
0.0608105287,
0.0352487676,
-0.0001634636,
0.0141452774,
0.0029685188,
0.0204150174,
0.0051735877,
0.0425039567,
-0.0493865386,
-0.0265485775,
0.0139865084,
0.0650434271,
-0.0023229532,
-0.0797014683,
-0.0049902839,
-0.1019990221,
0.0048565152,
-0.0222757366,
-0.1046762168,
-0.0291288234,
-0.054199338,
0.010943776,
-0.034029074,
0.0527830347,
0.0395894982,
0.028272504,
-0.0018380657,
-0.0083320439,
0.0204448588,
-0.0281562675,
0.0099287871,
-0.0321630798,
0.0273714345,
0.065190658,
0.011563086,
-0.0023046304,
0.0030872603,
-0.0170823839,
-0.0652925074,
-0.012032317,
0.0150849512,
0.0418347791,
-0.0040103588,
-0.0334708728,
-0.0358802266,
0.0265104324,
-0.007833709,
0.0046919873,
0.022614276,
0.0165232625,
0.0234921128,
-0.0247102994,
-0.0222768076,
0.0024544946,
0.0070840493,
0.0852794796,
0.0262187906,
-0.0680135041,
-0.0560642555,
-0.0188111924,
-0.0198263656,
-0.1236358732,
-0.0229177624,
0.0318878219,
-0.0183221567,
0.001553739,
-0.0635175034,
-0.0983662456,
0.0391242132,
0.0288090631,
0.0108000301,
0.0049094413,
0.0258943606,
0.0329292789,
-0.0326504894,
0.0354211293,
-0.0335063823,
0.0111684641,
-0.051763881,
-0.0469923466,
0.0241948161,
-0.0015314015,
-0.0167745147,
0.017068496,
-0.0956929177,
-0.0580772758,
0.0176075418,
0.0128764836,
0.0207403321,
0.0234987065,
-0.0300329179,
-0.0561840162,
0.0299333818,
-0.0172630493,
-0.0316005237,
0.0413316973,
-0.0252167918,
0.0205874294,
-0.0230188891,
0.0356709473,
-0.0039816047,
0.0240188017,
0.032278683,
0.0520502552,
-0.0609163456,
-0.0188228749,
-0.0154035408,
0.0243747309,
-0.0077399737,
-0.0046198689,
-0.0642250478,
-0.0085555529,
0.008770288,
0.0039157728,
0.0158468224,
0.0032358062,
-0.021654496,
0.0395641439,
-0.0107942363,
-0.0151017271,
0.0105752219,
-0.0003234964,
0.0145500517,
-0.011130441,
-0.0000104008,
0.0031416439,
0.0465625562,
0.0097502712,
0.0081780925,
-0.0032290015,
0.0368136317,
-0.0113490354,
0.0725966617,
0.020419782,
0.0429678671,
0.0280561019,
-0.0016649651,
-0.0122216633,
0.001985674,
-0.0551383831,
0.0101705752,
-0.0278839264,
0.0718531162,
0.0081691341,
0.0144374017,
0.0295116995,
0.0085819149,
-0.0175902192,
0.0008197364,
-0.0358315147,
-0.0051689488,
-0.0013032838,
0.0344976448,
0.0173338857,
0.0233335681,
0.0597881638,
0.0550429858,
0.0338836536,
0.0459556282,
0.0292159747,
-0.0092966342,
-0.0434428304,
-0.0059045791,
-0.0251318496,
-0.0383639894,
-0.0324188024,
0.0427306071,
-0.0444248468,
-0.0691481754,
0.0255284347,
-0.0011726504,
0.0195763912,
0.0170443635,
-0.0071572494,
0.0488804244,
0.0081860768,
0.0212807078,
-0.0492823645,
0.0349276997,
-0.0515559651,
-0.061095316,
0.0098675387,
-6.468710882e-33,
-0.0432586819,
-0.0488195606,
0.017705746,
-0.0965629518,
-0.0031146803,
0.0127319405,
-0.0596081503,
0.0113563938,
-0.028178744,
-0.0195872635,
-0.031612765,
0.0044152006,
0.0120862899,
0.0402114131,
-0.0338611901,
-0.0353493467,
0.0226326194,
0.0035992505,
-0.0331035443,
0.0022064282,
0.0304145403,
0.0529784188,
0.0430549234,
-0.0468082801,
0.0463508628,
-0.025444515,
-0.0098851556,
0.0025312549,
0.0270722229,
0.0411492549,
-0.0301636104,
-0.0031292466,
0.0356835835,
-0.0182923581,
0.0079969112,
0.0189472027,
-0.1393732429,
0.0038801271,
0.0186612178,
0.0357061997,
-0.0419708602,
-0.0462024026,
0.0386720635,
-0.0006442593,
0.0536847077,
0.0003266179,
0.019667251,
-0.0328778252,
-0.0336872041,
0.0324358307,
-0.0480345823,
0.0464589521,
-0.02321494,
0.0065312125,
-0.0194555596,
0.0464755967,
-0.0076773292,
0.0186864622,
-0.0572205558,
-0.0311654806,
0.0551396832,
-0.0002037805,
0.0364220329,
0.0347541757,
-0.0072189942,
0.0076584499,
0.0070464755,
0.0035257253,
-0.0324473083,
-0.0257798545,
0.0470291674,
-0.0276595093,
0.0519375801,
0.0964679867,
0.017630307,
-0.0124723231,
-0.0689918101,
0.0591405369,
0.0239658728,
0.003969661,
0.0276993737,
-0.0238121506,
-0.0705676749,
0.0325372517,
-0.027713133,
-0.0230107624,
-0.0564443469,
-0.037351869,
0.0622670874,
-0.0038868168,
-0.0959479362,
0.0127994148,
0.0257714391,
-0.0354662575,
0.0186946411,
0.0076279859,
0.0141744232,
-0.001032701,
-0.0053355643,
0.0347450078,
-0.0182251036,
0.017847525,
0.0129144471,
0.0087976875,
0.0044795731,
-0.0289810691,
0.0127037475,
-0.0396220461,
-0.0545579381,
0.0004180982,
-0.0055106846,
0.064238444,
-0.0337821208,
0.0283396039,
0.0140132876,
-0.0065977154,
-0.0110871121,
-0.0204723869,
0.0193154532,
-0.0124903275,
-0.017192753,
0.0413282029,
0.0133760748,
0.0501223505,
-0.0377020538,
-0.0280788969,
0.0090201618,
0.0261061769,
-0.0286714137,
-0.0864777341,
-0.0001985504,
0.0559039339,
2.788e-7,
0.0193493254,
0.0546235442,
0.0319554582,
0.0088671148,
-0.0119251153,
0.011278132,
0.0035889181,
0.022320902,
0.0211578123,
0.0040229345,
0.0152777229,
0.0206057802,
0.0534532741,
0.0199794471,
-0.1161166728,
-0.0452967435,
-0.0200266149,
0.0720875114,
-0.0463511497,
-0.0126837511,
0.0144218858,
0.0782511681,
0.0051692217,
-0.016504962,
-0.0234967582,
-0.0378810205,
0.0420377888,
-0.0234077759,
-0.023733601,
0.0060766302,
0.0473153256,
0.0399861038,
0.0109056253,
0.0342907235,
-0.0049301516,
0.0106974561,
0.0620448701,
0.0461642705,
0.0313737355,
-0.0351303518,
-0.0321794935,
-0.0288755354,
0.0023229618,
-0.0483341254,
0.0977995247,
-0.0244784933,
-0.0414956696,
0.0451512113,
-0.0602236241,
-0.0059739375,
0.0137781696,
-0.0149262957,
-0.0513064377,
0.0191566497,
0.0137444297,
-0.0210782532,
0.0333852507,
-0.0408456102,
0.0237446409,
-0.003379703,
-0.022438392,
-0.0286082756,
-0.042688448,
-0.0424582437,
0.0038263227,
-0.0546998233,
-0.004836333,
2.271176079e-34,
0.0044545517,
-0.005390469,
-0.0118897986,
0.0243453421,
0.0126589052,
-0.0102077555,
0.0254946109,
-0.0207660776,
0.0061989785,
-0.0518263727,
-0.0171480589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03098v1
|
Static Fuzzy Bag-of-Words: a lightweight sentence embedding algorithm
| 2023-04-06T14:25:46 | 2023-04-06T14:25:46 |
Matteo Muffo, Roberto Tedesco, Licia Sbattella, Vincenzo Scotti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
The introduction of embedding techniques has pushed forward significantly the
Natural Language Processing field. Many of the proposed solutions have been
presented for word-level encoding; anyhow, in the last years, new mechanism to
treat information at an higher level of aggregation, like at sentence- and
document-level, have emerged. With this work we address specifically the
sentence embeddings problem, presenting the Static Fuzzy Bag-of-Word model. Our
model is a refinement of the Fuzzy Bag-of-Words approach, providing sentence
embeddings with a predefined dimension. SFBoW provides competitive performances
in Semantic Textual Similarity benchmarks, while requiring low computational
resources.
|
[
0.0130787911,
0.0153306965,
-0.0232258625,
0.0534022786,
-0.0340471305,
0.0310170148,
-0.0393985622,
0.0076876641,
-0.0208670553,
-0.090648286,
0.0640518889,
-0.0109653734,
-0.0246263053,
0.0015003452,
0.0383415855,
-0.0170929376,
0.0675816834,
0.0543697216,
0.0102220383,
0.0019423058,
0.0532784685,
0.0002946707,
0.0157015696,
0.0394989885,
-0.0226087719,
0.00577125,
-0.0109775681,
-0.0325118341,
0.0031383967,
-0.0101933638,
0.0403709933,
-0.0059431465,
0.0450723544,
-0.0286231469,
0.0000016882,
-0.0106420014,
-0.0164816901,
-0.0129750287,
0.0262840353,
0.0090769455,
0.0427367017,
0.0218868796,
0.0249438304,
0.0180826411,
0.0131048402,
0.0082928352,
0.0365055948,
0.0697910562,
0.0758868754,
0.033411514,
-0.0169106051,
-0.0526753999,
0.0092031797,
0.0203643981,
0.0105745383,
-0.0034004413,
-0.0060000978,
0.0249548499,
0.0056669884,
0.0299735442,
-0.0452480204,
-0.0108165583,
-0.0001408728,
0.047508318,
0.0324401483,
0.0137170916,
-0.0978317633,
0.0322623812,
-0.0096403817,
0.0416956171,
-0.0640097484,
-0.0331902616,
-0.0206345953,
0.0295875426,
-0.0130943367,
-0.0082267337,
-0.0488809459,
0.0046174973,
0.0432238951,
0.0417542793,
0.0077801626,
0.0689116418,
-0.0149391983,
0.0184074324,
-0.0053707287,
0.0147070363,
-0.0102648437,
-0.0533243604,
-0.0324441679,
-0.0149243232,
-0.0333041586,
0.0052245483,
-0.0069751344,
0.0312803835,
0.0336230583,
-0.0122798262,
-0.0566230081,
-0.0028383925,
0.0413960516,
-0.0587681234,
0.0294862166,
0.0352664553,
0.0291009098,
0.0284120291,
-0.0397095941,
0.0397799239,
0.0007673511,
0.0000783175,
-0.0600037389,
-0.0167729184,
-0.0603587516,
-0.0083661787,
-0.0541331731,
0.060597375,
-0.0153559009,
-0.1058234945,
-0.0292740334,
0.0067167352,
0.004190369,
0.0197085477,
-0.0259845592,
0.0000827662,
-0.0010930382,
0.0252555162,
-0.0060141031,
-0.0155004757,
-0.050342638,
0.0104395635,
0.0015331898,
0.022400273,
-0.0261405632,
0.0020818238,
0.0373504832,
0.00407298,
0.0002112588,
-0.0087590581,
-0.0146610662,
-0.0285495445,
-0.0493423603,
-0.0018268637,
0.0244867112,
-0.0023752693,
-0.0330175459,
-0.0609873123,
0.0174059141,
-0.0099738957,
0.0036748115,
0.03235754,
0.0219888147,
0.0444046557,
-0.0429740958,
0.0676777288,
0.0042715832,
-0.0375852957,
-0.0154148592,
0.0074767186,
0.0624534972,
0.0442460291,
-0.0126003865,
0.0303974431,
0.0584108979,
0.0341058932,
0.0103325928,
-0.008152971,
-0.0138053354,
-0.0249603204,
-0.0131965531,
0.0099035827,
-0.0067599723,
0.0286936592,
-0.0238640644,
0.0355406888,
-0.0378995724,
0.0128554842,
0.0586079881,
0.0985248089,
0.0290491246,
0.0504916906,
0.0091354344,
0.0458238982,
-0.0117463181,
0.0196332466,
0.0104634184,
0.014564109,
-0.0284199677,
0.0074854759,
0.0255777854,
0.0468073599,
-0.0389650613,
-0.0053739846,
-0.018553583,
-0.04876066,
0.0162289701,
-0.0620344803,
-0.0184336156,
-0.0198503938,
-0.0191351622,
0.0409912691,
0.013645187,
-0.0549632236,
-0.0455996767,
0.0548518412,
-0.0209092032,
0.0062079565,
0.042966567,
-0.0198453087,
-0.0078972317,
-0.0281249173,
-0.0225789174,
0.0166813172,
0.0511063561,
-0.0124382731,
-0.0001871146,
-0.0910796225,
-0.0250576194,
-0.0255183689,
0.0106398743,
-0.0362415649,
0.0274383817,
0.0458035469,
0.0244270079,
0.0009145658,
-0.0041672364,
0.0422756672,
0.0513299964,
-0.0228402112,
-0.012877102,
-0.0075232009,
0.0456721857,
0.0014101822,
-0.0277569089,
0.0279732794,
0.0456889272,
-0.0684097186,
-0.0751143321,
-0.0205183513,
-0.0141877057,
-0.0703186095,
0.0329742208,
-0.0064438721,
-0.0038659829,
0.0536514558,
-0.0518692657,
-0.0032104906,
-0.025972398,
-0.0654631332,
-0.0001429093,
-0.0484788679,
0.0164148062,
-0.0348307118,
0.0197925288,
-0.0429335646,
0.0779975355,
-0.0235239211,
0.0353707336,
-0.1230303496,
0.0047251903,
0.0751461238,
-0.0451593362,
-0.0646946281,
-0.0049775266,
0.0166497212,
0.0297732782,
0.040139351,
-0.008032511,
0.0039036816,
-0.0222617574,
-0.0831255168,
0.0137305455,
0.0330304317,
-0.0228387378,
0.0071444381,
-0.0007700655,
0.0176876634,
0.0166921243,
-0.0619281754,
0.0139832664,
-0.016118953,
0.0176860951,
0.0592160262,
-0.0497201681,
-0.0360738598,
-0.0195692834,
0.0049294275,
-0.0076238737,
0.0637566149,
-0.0663168505,
-0.049783431,
-0.0071983105,
-0.0087229144,
-0.0569132157,
-0.0070857275,
0.0210197214,
-0.0301778279,
-0.0242241845,
0.005146848,
0.0470022932,
0.0593012758,
0.0588629283,
0.0319321491,
0.0248686802,
0.0208718367,
-0.032539662,
0.0030293502,
-0.0155008994,
0.0399262197,
0.0260952469,
-0.0089184353,
0.0277927797,
0.0002392538,
0.0054491451,
0.0133202244,
-0.0137857078,
0.0280383844,
-0.0049908143,
0.0428221226,
-0.0709674582,
-0.0457068123,
-0.0193416364,
0.0045840936,
-0.0184610412,
0.0045881397,
0.0438847244,
-0.0404382125,
-0.0159721598,
-0.0697396621,
-0.0547438748,
-0.0456697121,
0.0401132181,
-0.0242950581,
0.0428012945,
-0.0181688536,
0.0537717901,
-0.0331722051,
-0.0093972059,
0.0229000226,
-0.0436685681,
-0.0145786582,
0.0541999601,
-0.0002398944,
-0.0251505487,
-0.0262041893,
-0.0100299073,
-0.0757322311,
-0.0302253664,
0.0057688151,
0.0118641714,
0.0223770943,
-0.0421623811,
0.0344941281,
0.0134565867,
0.0066167749,
-0.0246711802,
-0.0009488355,
-0.033270672,
0.0641628429,
0.0539544411,
-0.0117518911,
0.0146506671,
0.0011452466,
0.0042007617,
0.0320708007,
0.0154812029,
-0.0155834276,
-0.0356696993,
0.0198066812,
0.0052693421,
-0.0226236098,
0.0069449614,
0.0018356947,
0.0166242216,
-0.00352532,
0.0130470991,
0.0991435423,
0.0595273226,
-0.0172716323,
0.0243847035,
0.0091854557,
0.0001822364,
0.0227620695,
0.0161286443,
-0.0601961464,
-0.0557134524,
0.0039507649,
-0.0499662049,
0.0054641925,
-0.00956982,
-0.0110793225,
-0.0763520673,
-0.0172504075,
0.0462692827,
0.0513012819,
-0.0392289907,
0.0394023359,
-0.0310232993,
0.0287027434,
-0.0271828044,
-0.0264137238,
0.0069705038,
-0.0178838987,
-0.0127990255,
-0.0095918868,
-0.0052183843,
-0.0115721412,
-0.046442084,
0.0403546728,
-0.0333311707,
0.0294133909,
0.0086910501,
0.0299090464,
0.0286498554,
-0.0542604439,
-0.0470765308,
0.0337372832,
0.009587056,
-0.0462702475,
0.0118336724,
-0.0330676101,
-0.0206186902,
-0.0213952661,
-0.0137754073,
0.0032037999,
0.0874975249,
-0.0103074284,
0.0103728119,
-0.0662490949,
0.0109318756,
-0.0358186066,
0.0657496154,
0.0396630429,
-0.0087595414,
-0.0242052432,
-0.0168748312,
-0.0089349281,
0.0501813218,
-0.048228953,
-0.0203381516,
-0.0034737496,
0.0147385737,
-0.0675226748,
-0.040536087,
0.0070679691,
0.0105466321,
-0.0097993463,
0.0269906204,
0.0196691472,
-0.0041837585,
-0.0505697615,
-0.0050670342,
0.020325819,
0.0313072093,
0.0205385946,
0.024155058,
0.0324972831,
0.0407718867,
-0.0365265608,
0.0141694937,
0.0074937302,
-0.0321231596,
-0.0149316359,
-0.0103363302,
0.0045396262,
-0.0275106747,
-0.0042000124,
-0.0458320305,
0.07928323,
0.0478214957,
-0.0601793118,
0.0093227047,
0.0159990024,
0.0570255108,
0.0377624482,
0.0262422003,
-0.0279177018,
0.0523192361,
-0.0578900911,
0.0642362088,
-0.0319804139,
-0.0210302379,
0.0090046721,
-0.0355506837,
0.0057172682,
0.0168137643,
0.0137226963,
0.0053102844,
-0.0130375521,
-0.0364973098,
-0.0557458512,
-0.0469404906,
-0.0122156227,
0.0202761292,
0.0250031911,
-0.0149956755,
0.0090847183,
0.0305955,
0.0661651716,
0.0495723709,
-0.0169034619,
0.0063518928,
0.0108469725,
-0.0672505572,
0.0238593351,
-0.0586861223,
-0.0600112826,
-0.0699239522,
-0.0230426602,
-0.0299409982,
0.0275847949,
0.0188040938,
0.0143683963,
-0.0868797153,
0.064923659,
-0.0869469196,
0.0511422269,
-0.0124296509,
0.0219710227,
0.0159373283,
-0.0655033365,
-0.011268747,
-0.0199065916,
-0.038656503,
0.0232385509,
0.0194096863,
-0.0247153156,
-0.0036708144,
0.0082485005,
0.0567393303,
-0.037304312,
-0.0080912206,
0.0500484407,
-0.0174535662,
-0.0264803413,
-0.0240491591,
-0.0395442285,
-0.0348860584,
0.0013635876,
0.0427885391,
0.0789242387,
0.0263107549,
0.0475904942,
-0.065514788,
-0.0067602368,
0.0316777304,
0.0098376106,
0.021253841,
0.0081422888,
0.0475552976,
0.0258150809,
0.0265465248,
0.009209536,
0.0007225215,
0.0123181725,
-0.0388362072,
-0.0447777696,
-0.0238914769,
-5.381893254e-33,
-0.0159355439,
0.0093160905,
-0.0393270217,
0.0244792756,
-0.0188698042,
0.0234907735,
0.0032536231,
-0.0066982801,
-0.0055096857,
0.0316902734,
-0.0048067551,
-0.010809592,
-0.0107080378,
0.0104469936,
-0.0203862768,
0.0301041063,
0.0036071518,
-0.016097812,
-0.0316503979,
-0.0177120622,
0.0204093158,
0.0240296908,
-0.0078242561,
-0.0202264171,
-0.0464033931,
-0.0436325334,
0.0014006732,
0.0287765656,
0.069104135,
0.0453518592,
-0.0432031788,
0.0363843888,
0.0373228863,
0.0254276283,
-0.0110758524,
0.0368566364,
-0.0372160152,
-0.056783393,
-0.0300831459,
-0.0164020937,
0.0284387227,
0.0061973045,
-0.0118952366,
-0.0426487178,
-0.0067234454,
-0.0132516185,
0.0178020317,
-0.0289652161,
-0.0519471876,
-0.0515104048,
-0.0464284793,
0.0004020605,
-0.0153640267,
0.0116085419,
0.02761833,
0.0286474824,
0.0051167575,
0.0334137417,
0.0229806099,
0.0214518271,
-0.0662461668,
0.0408483483,
-0.040082939,
-0.0610952452,
-0.0199142694,
0.0888829604,
-0.0192948822,
-0.0555956066,
-0.0619573034,
0.0042547989,
0.0199973695,
-0.0111676613,
0.0757797733,
0.0753047466,
0.0664448291,
-0.0003381833,
-0.0504150093,
0.0578960888,
0.0807830468,
0.0423285812,
0.034410391,
0.0393795781,
-0.0568906851,
-0.0278964117,
0.0047580986,
-0.0037365449,
-0.025905773,
0.0067688227,
0.0293569397,
0.0072125164,
0.0021789519,
0.0262550078,
0.0163303725,
-0.0452700816,
0.0334295779,
0.0120679969,
-0.0082214214,
0.0273148641,
0.0357736833,
0.0272872318,
-0.0312347673,
-0.0573202595,
-0.0018188677,
0.035923671,
-0.0050441376,
-0.0064309393,
0.0776326656,
0.0204663817,
-0.070043914,
0.0092374217,
-0.0020166654,
-0.0670063496,
-0.0499934964,
-0.0295852702,
-0.0173493661,
0.0144582503,
0.0143049387,
0.0259585734,
0.0259340908,
0.0189602673,
-0.0059608803,
-0.0488448888,
0.0086035775,
0.0352520235,
0.0035231637,
-0.000674123,
-0.0823549852,
0.0085722124,
-0.0003904944,
-0.0729786754,
0.0110948971,
0.0052388273,
2.465e-7,
0.0133616319,
0.0258062035,
0.0318525955,
-0.0145538962,
0.0228637438,
0.0313475765,
-0.0014191124,
0.0528739579,
-0.0403858572,
0.0419723503,
0.0210275967,
0.0180005394,
0.0137627181,
0.003306278,
-0.0730163679,
0.0123985549,
-0.0924716294,
-0.06565772,
-0.0586261488,
0.00972996,
0.1041890308,
0.109636955,
0.055528041,
0.0217647254,
-0.0347239003,
-0.0747140199,
0.0503837615,
0.0041465615,
0.0000837167,
-0.0136888158,
-0.0016608975,
0.0256009437,
0.0056632091,
-0.0146861523,
0.0079805823,
0.091595687,
0.0362900309,
0.0033153028,
-0.0139935445,
-0.0246234871,
0.0005877756,
-0.0250938181,
-0.037526872,
-0.0572516546,
0.0586685315,
-0.0606825426,
-0.0280634947,
0.0135140615,
-0.0133752739,
0.0276818369,
0.0523837097,
0.0384432152,
-0.0625796318,
0.0088304477,
0.0452134646,
0.0041574053,
0.0051223077,
-0.0809256583,
-0.0156301986,
-0.0092465486,
-0.0424696095,
0.0136656845,
-0.0034540659,
0.0047665765,
0.0710981488,
-0.0447397195,
-0.0039741085,
2.614275329e-34,
0.0346657671,
0.0116953291,
0.0336145572,
-0.0065064155,
0.0502010174,
-0.0128497686,
0.0258532055,
0.0143201221,
0.0410903506,
-0.0307358298,
0.0087802038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03087v1
|
Investigating Chain-of-thought with ChatGPT for Stance Detection on Social Media
| 2023-04-06T14:12:02 | 2023-04-06T14:12:02 |
Bowen Zhang, Xianghua Fu, Daijun Ding, Hu Huang, Yangyang Li, Liwen Jing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection predicts attitudes towards targets in texts and has gained
attention with the rise of social media. Traditional approaches include
conventional machine learning, early deep neural networks, and pre-trained
fine-tuning models. However, with the evolution of very large pre-trained
language models (VLPLMs) like ChatGPT (GPT-3.5), traditional methods face
deployment challenges. The parameter-free Chain-of-Thought (CoT) approach, not
requiring backpropagation training, has emerged as a promising alternative.
This paper examines CoT's effectiveness in stance detection tasks,
demonstrating its superior accuracy and discussing associated challenges.
|
[
0.0324555449,
0.0628150329,
0.0286309272,
0.0310022943,
-0.0231794957,
0.0294695999,
-0.0107640652,
-0.0133595923,
0.0192434639,
-0.0574580319,
-0.008289434,
-0.0427765884,
-0.0060743662,
0.000206817,
-0.0005142194,
0.0019544545,
0.0634149313,
0.054213468,
0.0380127132,
-0.0114345383,
0.0528605543,
0.06478443,
-0.0518063791,
0.019792458,
-0.0387626216,
-0.0480253212,
-0.0285565555,
-0.0141703058,
0.0819740742,
-0.0248295423,
0.035425432,
0.0374714881,
0.0190792568,
0.0567615777,
0.0000019878,
-0.0216076616,
-0.0323151648,
-0.019756224,
-0.0083098086,
-0.0034558021,
-0.0038595439,
-0.0203602742,
-0.003585923,
0.0164348539,
-0.0618636683,
0.0235457812,
0.0423974544,
0.0517587475,
0.0753882527,
0.0791040733,
-0.0010873377,
-0.0053386996,
-0.0002877802,
-0.0324382484,
-0.0141434176,
-0.0562249087,
0.0141104814,
-0.0303781256,
-0.0572867841,
0.0702234358,
-0.0207307003,
0.0220620614,
0.0172238946,
0.0163020454,
-0.0643219873,
-0.0008857958,
0.0029880395,
-0.008115625,
-0.0163610838,
0.0727873519,
-0.0165217798,
-0.0334112681,
-0.019517608,
-0.0407736786,
0.0129092513,
-0.010175175,
0.0103650028,
0.0103285471,
-0.0138200158,
0.0363328792,
-0.0013689608,
0.0063621025,
0.0050874925,
0.0535692237,
-0.0050693862,
0.0487021767,
-0.0570486635,
-0.0169775635,
0.0589116924,
0.0384849533,
-0.0389751829,
-0.0324986875,
0.0303476024,
0.0236040298,
0.0054599433,
0.0220841076,
-0.0318713337,
0.0131492885,
0.0139273442,
-0.0569283888,
-0.0263397545,
0.0334523208,
-0.0141928326,
0.0547995903,
-0.0155276963,
0.0292061903,
-0.0388967432,
-0.0445531942,
0.0027305225,
0.02983482,
-0.0641874447,
-0.0176073387,
-0.033880949,
0.0356693119,
-0.0324572846,
-0.0427912772,
-0.0300542209,
-0.0110864807,
-0.0118833268,
-0.0341976397,
0.0094094658,
0.0229970776,
0.0140093835,
0.0103103332,
-0.0137410229,
0.0964895412,
0.0009150882,
0.0174061656,
-0.0023945593,
-0.0475776307,
-0.0096765123,
0.006030851,
0.0113563286,
-0.0102423579,
0.0320669822,
-0.0190716572,
0.0046493826,
-0.0172047988,
0.0024302877,
-0.002414413,
-0.0446833745,
-0.0990879908,
0.0040342994,
-0.0741901472,
0.0385235101,
0.0065355706,
0.0040846765,
-0.0166745707,
0.0254229531,
0.0481978506,
-0.0017024359,
0.0718543157,
0.0024552518,
-0.0316392742,
-0.0191163104,
0.0265278853,
0.0233947542,
0.0960737467,
-0.0105637638,
0.0572596788,
-0.0022361381,
0.0293986313,
-0.0369218886,
0.0177136417,
0.0361999981,
-0.012726495,
0.0234647505,
0.0236779712,
-0.0710642412,
-0.0023735182,
-0.0261426196,
0.0477683917,
0.0130384276,
-0.0298062563,
0.069545947,
0.024820365,
-0.0000021675,
0.0274475086,
0.0432820767,
0.0727818087,
0.0272133444,
-0.0355709754,
-0.0136449905,
0.0243386347,
-0.0224799551,
-0.0334428996,
-0.0428997017,
0.0416358896,
-0.0304069761,
-0.0310604181,
0.0146321524,
0.01340512,
0.0224379562,
-0.0149837006,
0.0089003555,
-0.0071385214,
-0.0646144822,
0.0273449365,
0.029025184,
-0.0333566479,
-0.0372906178,
-0.0399425924,
-0.012091089,
-0.01489639,
-0.0162134338,
-0.020246122,
-0.0632013008,
-0.0454403274,
0.0184081756,
0.0774007067,
0.0344676301,
0.0045188847,
-0.0110698277,
-0.0253322776,
0.0065891552,
-0.003379168,
-0.0044014906,
0.0504890531,
0.0006120707,
0.0621996745,
0.0107458904,
0.0606240034,
0.0448725186,
0.0029084156,
0.0596200712,
0.0042179665,
0.0116634332,
0.0515966155,
0.040387705,
0.0498330779,
0.0052484553,
-0.0324430168,
-0.003562683,
0.0026968007,
-0.0484135635,
-0.0131146507,
-0.0505506843,
-0.0861586481,
0.037108399,
-0.0192965381,
-0.0498306602,
0.0407702476,
-0.0349902175,
0.0050821737,
0.0210726522,
-0.036665678,
-0.01025528,
-0.0489261448,
-0.0359718241,
-0.0396167412,
0.0282631908,
-0.0166162495,
0.0470004454,
-0.013229887,
-0.0289873723,
-0.0012739446,
-0.0115910983,
0.0523251593,
0.0031299184,
-0.0510297194,
-0.0168031082,
0.007392847,
0.0073710443,
0.0109231044,
0.0568480417,
-0.023991609,
-0.0114182038,
-0.1206423119,
-0.0138463611,
-0.0318689793,
0.0154302772,
0.0119336853,
-0.0023125068,
0.0025528949,
0.0203230456,
-0.0609112531,
0.0158062838,
0.0056781569,
0.0110599706,
0.0229503717,
-0.0272103809,
0.0116653023,
-0.029252341,
0.0165282059,
-0.0295014456,
0.0099270586,
0.0063665495,
-0.0855917931,
0.0071825157,
0.0256251171,
-0.0411818288,
0.0223985221,
0.0000771672,
-0.0797870383,
0.0556041859,
-0.0059536397,
0.0190583207,
0.0528627187,
0.0369079523,
0.0556847975,
-0.0155154578,
0.0307165105,
-0.027329253,
0.0226257574,
-0.045508299,
0.0225909203,
-0.0053916248,
0.0484050475,
-0.0138693787,
0.0588533729,
0.0006579953,
-0.0234087501,
-0.0690597668,
0.0126085347,
-0.0233801343,
-0.0231055673,
-0.0295952782,
-0.0049797343,
0.0012470839,
-0.0167467855,
-0.0126758143,
-0.0098374374,
0.0632974207,
-0.0102624074,
-0.0038080832,
-0.0557844192,
-0.029438043,
-0.0361278132,
0.0455882512,
0.0287437309,
0.0147037907,
0.0033309783,
0.0161070339,
-0.0090400251,
-0.0119169587,
-0.0128425527,
-0.0221406203,
-0.0017270684,
0.0226473324,
0.0315004289,
0.0023247737,
-0.046213422,
-0.0266918503,
-0.0754551589,
-0.0639071912,
-0.0267894603,
0.0023415689,
-0.018003257,
0.0451836362,
0.0340454951,
-0.0018579514,
-0.009370435,
-0.0364095718,
0.0023061296,
-0.0123952292,
-0.0014161679,
0.0343592688,
-0.0454995185,
0.0496403053,
-0.0005405057,
0.0090603363,
0.0743804276,
-0.0150816292,
0.0367472991,
-0.0448210128,
-0.0227438305,
-0.0132178273,
0.0141445305,
-0.0077681458,
-0.0545293465,
0.0698182657,
-0.0067893774,
0.0122814858,
0.0974838734,
0.0271553826,
-0.0638993084,
0.0065294653,
0.0857460275,
-0.0052863234,
0.0029411714,
-0.0200876258,
-0.0756855682,
-0.0498894528,
-0.0308657587,
-0.0267350543,
-0.0286953151,
-0.0280619003,
-0.018669568,
-0.0833949447,
-0.0285267774,
-0.0444435105,
-0.0509356037,
-0.0138803488,
-0.0232578348,
0.0236803517,
-0.0040829056,
0.0191395879,
-0.0104029831,
0.0049761948,
-0.0092275608,
0.0169674121,
-0.0614388771,
0.0053144861,
0.016753722,
-0.0383977033,
0.0254890192,
0.0159977283,
0.0545258448,
0.0216587223,
-0.0251426287,
0.0593653843,
-0.0259689223,
0.0127735641,
-0.022188453,
0.0248101372,
-0.0521584563,
-0.0331423581,
-0.0285599548,
0.0282533318,
-0.0488393381,
0.0329350643,
-0.0355996154,
0.0359032303,
-0.0017581019,
-0.007484966,
-0.014290222,
0.0690905005,
0.0432333983,
0.0427909493,
0.0368551388,
-0.0748856813,
-0.0462523587,
-0.0267016031,
-0.0453775078,
-0.0436411984,
-0.0654199421,
-0.0245639365,
0.0265893675,
0.0261437949,
-0.0448489152,
-0.0331591256,
0.0018155657,
0.0430997722,
-0.052956827,
-0.0238149222,
0.0366189033,
0.0438835099,
-0.0372852422,
0.0342906564,
0.0064908867,
0.0396456867,
0.000157567,
-0.0200750809,
0.058133103,
0.0082226153,
-0.0304650087,
0.0082692625,
-0.0991778821,
-0.0320925228,
-0.0178605337,
0.04683109,
0.0119010182,
0.0171356462,
-0.0302139763,
0.0045207846,
0.020213658,
0.0835007578,
-0.0123357493,
0.029620463,
0.0320575312,
0.0785400718,
-0.0094714556,
0.0258280206,
0.0121951727,
0.0253149923,
0.0525294282,
-0.0305960886,
-0.0222535674,
-0.0178614706,
-0.0029397272,
-0.0167735461,
0.0325944759,
0.0231801402,
-0.0525487848,
-0.0239383765,
-0.025497213,
-0.0109163672,
-0.0233903602,
-0.0438900515,
-0.0046842061,
0.0153323226,
-0.0237016883,
-0.0495259576,
-0.0282521006,
-0.0021103488,
0.0679069459,
-0.0326800495,
0.0258062072,
0.0306508262,
0.0366818346,
0.0156925544,
-0.0123436237,
-0.0389871038,
-0.0035604441,
0.020745514,
-0.0276394449,
0.0043445337,
0.0884581655,
0.0355721898,
-0.0261505954,
0.013448773,
0.0410611406,
-0.0310064461,
-0.0106766308,
-0.0539564192,
0.0277467519,
0.0178206917,
-0.0149070472,
0.0256049745,
-0.0254343487,
-0.0228104834,
-0.0005823027,
0.0324683152,
-0.0574642755,
-0.012462737,
0.0287598427,
0.0190244131,
-0.0125577953,
0.0074038692,
0.0134149436,
-0.0061372528,
0.0118505657,
0.0794613436,
-0.0226044226,
-0.0221888442,
0.0028553675,
-0.0462851152,
0.0168785434,
0.0309637599,
0.0643677413,
-0.0481943935,
-0.0629332215,
-0.0198454875,
0.003820336,
0.0155877545,
0.045052249,
0.034226235,
0.0610423014,
0.0092650075,
0.0281199142,
-0.0381580591,
0.0121315867,
-0.020702187,
-0.0205748547,
-0.03807633,
-6.47634131e-33,
-0.0066476432,
-0.0194915701,
-0.0145527003,
0.0481454916,
-0.0408542678,
0.0063216947,
0.0017003824,
0.0264657773,
-0.023090126,
0.066114746,
0.0031298574,
0.0471391082,
-0.0009417171,
0.0363786891,
-0.0496099517,
-0.0215128884,
0.0120179681,
-0.0208432563,
-0.0074922657,
0.0148476819,
0.0454742722,
-0.0088265734,
0.0552382097,
-0.0725631043,
0.0018016909,
0.0060770069,
-0.0309336577,
0.0137234451,
-0.017914366,
0.0604774207,
-0.0215449929,
0.0338211097,
0.0551136099,
-0.0298223272,
0.022914838,
0.0766668841,
-0.0293024518,
-0.0106225973,
-0.002062635,
0.0222612601,
-0.0019728765,
0.01811154,
-0.0170816034,
-0.0094934432,
-0.0207892489,
-0.0039119446,
0.0022828483,
0.0152726723,
0.067727156,
-0.0411596373,
-0.0411364138,
0.026540909,
-0.0113424128,
-0.0356586315,
-0.0222991221,
0.0446028039,
-0.0032209861,
0.0056319013,
-0.052139733,
-0.002676574,
-0.0552789234,
-0.0057312995,
0.0115219466,
-0.0116941612,
-0.0083768228,
0.0644240081,
-0.0080597764,
0.0165128969,
-0.0752080604,
0.0267464239,
0.0318865553,
-0.000073098,
0.0919925198,
0.0198963825,
0.0083961058,
-0.0115916086,
-0.0931225196,
-0.0283572841,
0.0821763203,
-0.0020608508,
0.0129022179,
0.0058035529,
-0.0234176107,
-0.0166570116,
0.0046590613,
-0.0657282919,
-0.0299095251,
-0.0172748547,
-0.0050789895,
0.0081497412,
-0.0435188897,
0.0322758034,
0.0494584255,
-0.033784382,
-0.004594468,
0.0609046407,
-0.0396631397,
0.0312754475,
0.0268910471,
0.0447321422,
-0.0558962673,
0.013852926,
-0.0002517249,
0.0332090668,
0.0087639634,
-0.0117744012,
0.0662253499,
0.0049914671,
-0.0615042709,
-0.0365847796,
-0.0305987224,
0.044221554,
-0.0598960407,
0.0831408575,
0.0243009403,
-0.0131865665,
-0.0138007952,
0.0731453076,
-0.0147592006,
-0.0034791052,
-0.0195733178,
0.021185413,
-0.0275167618,
0.008348274,
-0.0331226401,
-0.0340764858,
0.0020705059,
0.0072698062,
-0.027130194,
-0.109850578,
0.0043056011,
0.0257817339,
2.671e-7,
0.0089839213,
0.049309399,
0.0259327535,
-0.0277860761,
0.0536980219,
0.0510518327,
0.0207018275,
0.0165216941,
0.0011875412,
-0.0518395975,
-0.0062773773,
0.0829170197,
0.0292656254,
0.0071977656,
-0.101097703,
-0.0083441203,
-0.0398525968,
-0.0115585821,
-0.0320160612,
-0.0056346948,
-0.0060424809,
0.0818205178,
0.0313411579,
-0.0132994438,
0.0189624541,
0.0351568386,
0.0300703328,
0.0257988293,
0.0023177094,
0.0038861108,
0.0354106575,
-0.0645743757,
-0.0200203005,
0.0299648084,
0.017842399,
0.0293551125,
0.0035141355,
0.0587865002,
0.0106450338,
-0.0254096333,
0.0058139046,
0.0093377577,
-0.0088611646,
-0.0303208437,
0.0856102332,
-0.0752423927,
-0.0290596541,
-0.0478447266,
-0.0121592842,
0.0023488691,
0.0521550812,
0.0145359561,
-0.0188634414,
0.0088679586,
0.0120301191,
-0.0437700339,
-0.0128959585,
-0.0994687825,
0.0020699564,
-0.0201328043,
-0.0457077399,
-0.0333412588,
0.0090692043,
-0.0284152888,
0.0446537249,
-0.0376238562,
-0.0247782283,
2.08160833e-34,
0.0220304355,
-0.0461997017,
0.0385807194,
-0.0264844354,
0.0311645269,
0.0417603217,
-0.007346035,
-0.0177911632,
0.0596683845,
-0.0495253839,
-0.0041884044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03047v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03047v3
|
ETPNav: Evolving Topological Planning for Vision-Language Navigation in Continuous Environments
| 2023-04-06T13:07:17 | 2024-01-22T04:57:32 |
Dong An, Hanqing Wang, Wenguan Wang, Zun Wang, Yan Huang, Keji He, Liang Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Vision-language navigation is a task that requires an agent to follow
instructions to navigate in environments. It becomes increasingly crucial in
the field of embodied AI, with potential applications in autonomous navigation,
search and rescue, and human-robot interaction. In this paper, we propose to
address a more practical yet challenging counterpart setting - vision-language
navigation in continuous environments (VLN-CE). To develop a robust VLN-CE
agent, we propose a new navigation framework, ETPNav, which focuses on two
critical skills: 1) the capability to abstract environments and generate
long-range navigation plans, and 2) the ability of obstacle-avoiding control in
continuous environments. ETPNav performs online topological mapping of
environments by self-organizing predicted waypoints along a traversed path,
without prior environmental experience. It privileges the agent to break down
the navigation procedure into high-level planning and low-level control.
Concurrently, ETPNav utilizes a transformer-based cross-modal planner to
generate navigation plans based on topological maps and instructions. The plan
is then performed through an obstacle-avoiding controller that leverages a
trial-and-error heuristic to prevent navigation from getting stuck in
obstacles. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
method. ETPNav yields more than 10% and 20% improvements over prior
state-of-the-art on R2R-CE and RxR-CE datasets, respectively. Our code is
available at https://github.com/MarSaKi/ETPNav.
|
[
0.0066078058,
0.0030611602,
-0.0071079251,
-0.0422774516,
-0.0219476949,
-0.0099433837,
-0.0482015386,
-0.062180385,
0.0213792194,
-0.0021270525,
-0.0237540267,
0.0407563187,
0.0000376471,
0.1025691554,
0.0113275815,
-0.0298231523,
0.0146235945,
-0.0555649921,
-0.0452315621,
-0.0021786136,
-0.0391074009,
-0.0356890559,
-0.0223032217,
0.0134236766,
-0.0005196639,
0.0202992037,
-0.0763193443,
0.0015820232,
0.0226893444,
-0.0646407679,
0.0034378928,
-0.0199305136,
0.0543926992,
0.0117651224,
0.0000020331,
-0.0050099208,
-0.0293285996,
-0.021199828,
0.0677743182,
-0.1093794852,
-0.0015931488,
-0.0408919118,
-0.0066892984,
0.0192037784,
-0.0482255407,
0.0028513882,
0.0576478653,
0.0551662222,
0.0358385593,
0.0518568456,
-0.0201277323,
-0.0104441531,
0.0192147568,
0.0180114489,
-0.0047410261,
-0.0016769952,
-0.0031082188,
0.006715389,
0.0110061402,
-0.021380024,
-0.0372147784,
0.0269962009,
0.0350484289,
-0.0253721643,
-0.0187481102,
0.0692949593,
0.0152445994,
-0.0494996831,
-0.0428740904,
0.0583191328,
-0.0575870275,
-0.0236022621,
0.0315958671,
0.0328918062,
-0.0589657463,
-0.0232968368,
-0.0068799756,
0.0265076887,
-0.0168806184,
0.0129039567,
-0.0287482999,
-0.0124569107,
-0.0290907677,
-0.029218616,
-0.0340057574,
0.103801325,
0.0114152953,
0.0174332168,
0.0321929716,
-0.0140469633,
-0.0125429211,
-0.0406298488,
0.0354486704,
0.0510810912,
-0.0236302409,
0.0054460824,
-0.0329935253,
0.03702043,
-0.034712106,
-0.0227226391,
0.0316324122,
0.0330531374,
-0.0305688754,
0.0240787733,
-0.071537286,
0.038894821,
-0.0318529196,
0.0607036836,
-0.0046963398,
-0.0211569723,
-0.0248425025,
0.0735028908,
-0.0471910723,
-0.0004225822,
-0.0373890027,
-0.047262013,
0.0210640822,
0.0615623631,
-0.0131955547,
0.0116888797,
-0.0460696332,
0.0273990165,
-0.0183020458,
0.0239568688,
-0.026194483,
-0.0665644929,
-0.0091128098,
-0.0084536457,
-0.0273402408,
0.0515882075,
0.0294674393,
0.0375364907,
-0.0206218157,
0.0030375507,
-0.0020904953,
0.0875291675,
-0.0105635682,
-0.0267040152,
-0.02733743,
0.0024925082,
0.0136456937,
-0.0410419181,
0.0751844794,
-0.0357256159,
0.0198462438,
-0.0305241719,
-0.0379853845,
-0.0160015933,
0.0360427462,
0.0045107636,
0.0125113912,
0.0292109996,
-0.0013020311,
0.0311550293,
0.0226987824,
-0.0114447074,
-0.014336654,
0.0145832105,
0.0551854968,
0.0186198037,
-0.0393349677,
0.0638356283,
-0.0180908311,
0.0135269873,
-0.0173004158,
0.009204587,
0.031375505,
-0.0070324205,
0.0100592505,
0.0629391298,
-0.016060086,
0.0206152182,
-0.0199728832,
-0.0272772703,
-0.0080579277,
0.0142431529,
0.0403144099,
0.0405879766,
0.0242987629,
0.0062674438,
-0.0111148236,
-0.048892241,
-0.0317865759,
0.0580358282,
-0.0388438702,
-0.0232980587,
-0.0687521398,
-0.003585123,
0.0073892782,
-0.0566847622,
0.0357760377,
0.0317238234,
0.0794200078,
-0.0380216278,
-0.0014391926,
0.0184973702,
-0.0483625308,
-0.0550073124,
-0.0023083738,
-0.0235871915,
-0.0588775761,
-0.0139560718,
-0.006135521,
0.0327038206,
-0.0052461363,
-0.0089984033,
-0.066399768,
0.0060873316,
0.0277056899,
0.0022254724,
-0.055741068,
0.0017374427,
0.0539945364,
-0.0028829083,
-0.0515457727,
0.0371110067,
-0.0152959982,
0.0403095894,
0.0281289537,
0.0206380896,
-0.0305485297,
-0.0041043465,
0.0086515201,
0.064174369,
-0.0112916324,
0.0496084094,
0.0088386536,
0.0054998077,
0.0123853702,
-0.0062509738,
-0.0100467363,
-0.0102655319,
0.0338770784,
-0.025348885,
-0.0022568118,
0.0338803008,
-0.0119597269,
-0.0034099177,
0.0419155657,
-0.0966760144,
-0.0469613224,
0.044593852,
-0.0095908344,
-0.0134546822,
-0.0037518791,
-0.0383684486,
-0.0028710039,
0.0211853758,
-0.0176468939,
0.0490387976,
-0.0094853714,
-0.0133873513,
0.0030865041,
-0.0033738024,
-0.0296143964,
0.0420751609,
0.0261285603,
0.0119961649,
-0.0056036962,
0.0223406143,
-0.0070373355,
0.0358385593,
-0.0596479811,
0.0169238374,
0.0680565983,
-0.0160439536,
-0.0555725731,
-0.060720209,
-0.0383847393,
-0.0257635526,
-0.0315546803,
0.0303057581,
-0.0451854765,
0.0076548476,
0.0274169222,
0.0317368284,
0.082619004,
0.0282102395,
-0.0558268428,
-0.0045939372,
0.0125998026,
-0.04841052,
-0.0128042847,
0.0117954882,
-0.0474736132,
-0.0411142632,
-0.0131719289,
-0.0547584407,
-0.0488897935,
0.0291760415,
-0.0293324236,
0.063434504,
-0.0471485779,
-0.0025384843,
-0.0218935441,
-0.0336582884,
0.0430762023,
0.0251985844,
0.0019579558,
-0.0132797575,
0.082956709,
-0.0373810306,
-0.0233181473,
0.0367094614,
-0.0179956555,
0.0050908532,
-0.0483091101,
0.0003282605,
0.0019060659,
-0.0291910768,
-0.0225680918,
0.012767286,
-0.0415960215,
-0.0334773101,
-0.0230061822,
-0.0607849807,
0.0233615115,
0.0556796677,
-0.0039600292,
0.0376933403,
-0.0505543277,
0.0016321278,
0.0384862348,
0.0096308496,
-0.0287723038,
-0.0010958232,
-0.0173720755,
-0.0120527279,
0.0601351336,
0.0225361418,
0.0433585569,
0.0464869924,
0.0069718217,
-0.0145097766,
-0.033159934,
-0.0396672562,
0.0261282381,
0.0467370301,
-0.0857175067,
0.0178031251,
0.0128130196,
-0.0200008005,
-0.0234374925,
0.036244072,
0.0335702971,
0.0151408268,
-0.0622799695,
-0.0356281921,
-0.0261760894,
-0.0077850232,
0.024597453,
0.0430641882,
-0.0277127903,
-0.0344448015,
0.0101280417,
0.0088796904,
0.0674995258,
0.0936378539,
0.029631516,
-0.0095750717,
-0.0176170003,
0.0537843853,
0.0382010825,
-0.01505596,
-0.0235809013,
0.024655154,
0.0316431783,
0.0410510227,
-0.0117765842,
0.0151165761,
0.0396099687,
-0.0385128073,
-0.0779749602,
0.0378660299,
0.0291650333,
0.0241213944,
0.0030998352,
-0.0659692809,
0.0416574329,
0.0285601877,
0.0575898699,
0.0128866835,
0.012172685,
0.0058044591,
-0.0074879453,
0.0015149754,
-0.0000522935,
0.0236918163,
-0.0481406152,
0.0713782236,
0.0169154909,
-0.0675740317,
-0.0255129877,
-0.0245123357,
-0.000656615,
-0.0002443846,
-0.0630782992,
0.0019165006,
0.0040175598,
-0.0536780693,
-0.0064509371,
-0.0075680488,
0.018262947,
-0.0091171367,
-0.0058281892,
0.0137691787,
0.016629776,
0.0265137199,
-0.0082718534,
-0.0369488224,
0.0358218327,
0.0262095351,
0.0525489897,
-0.0625232458,
-0.0201967098,
-0.0092499424,
0.0156039139,
0.0382646285,
0.0397458822,
-0.0411247201,
-0.0421238095,
-0.0053155785,
0.0241350867,
-0.0417793393,
0.0101952413,
-0.0494152009,
-0.000679613,
0.000469085,
0.0125076203,
-0.0812907517,
0.0007144839,
-0.0963904858,
-0.0173481181,
-0.002401941,
-0.0009361534,
-0.0949501842,
-0.0138584645,
-0.0104296813,
-0.0672871247,
-0.0500075035,
-0.0290400945,
0.0597303174,
0.0775709301,
0.0251881536,
-0.1072625071,
-0.0034828666,
0.0134026352,
-0.0451189466,
-0.0290658828,
-0.0273238849,
0.0286587831,
0.0164660271,
0.0093532493,
0.0365421288,
-0.0325192474,
-0.0049417773,
0.0435410738,
-0.0163353905,
-0.056819208,
0.069362022,
0.0622302443,
0.0024153625,
0.0327879302,
-0.0095273582,
0.0040158038,
0.0651600882,
-0.0237426125,
0.0263371877,
0.0532593466,
0.0412531272,
0.0481590666,
0.0224132184,
0.0123054348,
-0.0802247971,
-0.0037795103,
0.0173694249,
0.0330408253,
-0.0319138989,
0.0177673418,
0.0062056836,
-0.0383048616,
0.0432069376,
0.0304926857,
0.0368587077,
-0.0210951176,
0.0140216304,
-0.0193906222,
-0.0051412783,
-0.0508546792,
0.0710168406,
0.0046582189,
0.0445760414,
0.0401314124,
0.0261340048,
0.0161896069,
-0.0326275378,
-0.0168344844,
0.0147505719,
0.0524095818,
-0.0121274274,
-0.033128202,
0.0088123465,
0.0092481496,
0.0454018861,
0.0041781343,
0.0377293266,
0.0127294613,
0.0132573852,
0.0338245481,
-0.0397425629,
-0.0750340894,
0.0126012126,
-0.0750325173,
-0.0540033281,
0.009734611,
0.0901293829,
0.0698731691,
0.0606585592,
0.0299366601,
-0.0729673654,
0.0229834225,
0.0075374478,
-0.0408158042,
0.0197280198,
-0.021452032,
0.0464326628,
0.0043955026,
0.0177541953,
-0.0098211616,
0.0074552163,
0.0198437963,
0.0712980255,
0.012443088,
0.0007682259,
-0.0494142249,
-0.0187101215,
-0.0175676141,
0.0093039786,
0.0157959461,
0.0032858432,
0.0044706645,
-0.012424699,
0.0726280808,
0.0659445003,
0.0012043549,
-0.0211588908,
0.0570743196,
-0.0088759828,
0.0031544219,
-0.0470725521,
-0.0184779409,
-0.0829586685,
0.0319409408,
-0.0276831668,
-0.02960697,
-5.304856864e-33,
-0.0051566502,
-0.0269168634,
0.0605736524,
0.0008269722,
-0.0211777315,
-0.0542734377,
-0.0362261795,
0.0180211514,
-0.0176373497,
0.012526148,
-0.0127510242,
-0.0000871407,
0.0139443446,
0.0120661026,
-0.0182437971,
0.0115201166,
0.0112874992,
0.0100099081,
-0.0387382917,
-0.0227476005,
0.0191137996,
0.008557084,
-0.0384948589,
-0.1013834253,
-0.0439422727,
0.0342455506,
0.0000639358,
0.0391193219,
0.0142018227,
0.0311219227,
-0.0057040802,
-0.0189969353,
-0.0058412906,
0.0270975567,
-0.0456075855,
-0.0124789895,
-0.0758855268,
-0.034858536,
-0.0550480783,
0.0202643014,
-0.0895728469,
-0.0301407017,
0.0646193027,
0.0204167292,
-0.0383117422,
0.0161857642,
0.0278108399,
0.0047306651,
0.0219607688,
0.0028523558,
-0.0173127037,
0.0252410192,
-0.0082478132,
-0.0592945628,
0.0393299945,
0.0142681468,
0.0271086246,
-0.0462931953,
-0.0137936706,
0.0130908703,
-0.0870864242,
-0.0165401623,
0.0191586521,
-0.0043711341,
0.0525253788,
0.0381031185,
0.0514457002,
-0.0176917836,
0.0351546295,
-0.0041707265,
0.0332143642,
0.0412156954,
-0.0360358171,
0.0132307084,
-0.0504565127,
0.0275064483,
-0.0244248081,
0.0361198112,
-0.0718172193,
0.0583849251,
0.0070973998,
0.0277465265,
-0.0123426402,
0.0259733498,
-0.0005237775,
-0.0241048299,
0.0232012458,
0.0118624605,
0.0301821027,
0.0238987356,
-0.0203429721,
-0.0077076694,
0.0193831176,
-0.0101705203,
0.0245871004,
-0.0068781651,
-0.0304178577,
0.0271435715,
0.019781163,
0.057837341,
-0.0194002092,
-0.0405060276,
0.0094163027,
-0.0113742882,
0.0029571978,
-0.0215524323,
-0.0748887137,
0.0941260234,
-0.0147215044,
-0.029382389,
-0.0319946818,
0.0087181879,
0.0461928807,
-0.003921919,
0.0540336668,
-0.0271387752,
0.0177640077,
0.0135963233,
0.0082829474,
-0.0501729436,
0.0029442701,
0.0114099914,
0.0214960072,
0.0406439714,
-0.0283000562,
0.0002621889,
-0.0121064745,
0.0413930789,
-0.0255968235,
-0.0769630149,
0.0042742314,
0.0759197921,
2.894e-7,
-0.0271945,
0.055083245,
0.0242751557,
-0.0106789414,
-0.0002895066,
0.0133556426,
0.0018998461,
0.0226142276,
-0.0537615307,
-0.0343991034,
0.0212308057,
0.0630562231,
-0.0215688627,
0.0115365433,
-0.0267711114,
0.035811346,
0.0618971772,
-0.0307249893,
-0.0099914605,
0.0026522654,
0.0709123835,
0.0514512919,
-0.047236532,
0.0271452181,
0.0292288028,
-0.0303973053,
0.0187628027,
-0.0126529476,
0.0322890803,
-0.0374916494,
-0.0484842546,
0.0241899211,
-0.0438222066,
-0.0581396185,
0.0101612117,
0.0451958179,
-0.0139203211,
0.0487623885,
-0.0105890287,
-0.0692678988,
0.0248774365,
0.0267186891,
-0.0223519336,
-0.0254454538,
0.044863347,
-0.0701321587,
0.0071617775,
0.014954932,
0.0025415642,
0.0256727543,
-0.0284611546,
0.010234206,
-0.0489380732,
-0.0242884792,
0.0038546873,
-0.0169360414,
-0.0055040466,
-0.0541621223,
0.0342050344,
0.0000658893,
-0.0240986049,
0.01664952,
0.0053081568,
0.0428780355,
-0.0026236221,
0.0125770951,
-0.064491041,
2.099014141e-34,
-0.0168378763,
-0.0385595672,
-0.0092784995,
-0.0029890533,
0.0082153715,
0.0352666974,
0.0278952625,
-0.0213556103,
-0.003474236,
0.0060943561,
-0.057434354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03030v1
|
Compression of enumerations and gain
| 2023-04-06T12:29:53 | 2023-04-06T12:29:53 |
George Barmpalias, Xiaoyan Zhang, Bohua Zhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT, math.LO
|
We study the compressibility of enumerations, and its role in the relative
Kolmogorov complexity of computably enumerable sets, with respect to density.
With respect to a strong and a weak form of compression, we examine the gain:
the amount of auxiliary information embedded in the compressed enumeration.
Strong compression and weak gainless compression is shown for any computably
enumerable set, and a positional game is studied toward understanding strong
gainless compression.
|
[
-0.0157401878,
0.0371067598,
-0.0373104699,
-0.0142488172,
-0.0239481088,
0.0148114553,
-0.0893055201,
0.0624536164,
-0.0809950307,
0.0848525092,
0.0132029103,
0.0378635637,
0.017065281,
-0.0301042553,
0.0592071228,
-0.0180605445,
-0.0425393246,
0.0014479738,
-0.003408504,
-0.0373857915,
-0.0737104043,
-0.0696583018,
-0.0210530255,
-0.0587522089,
0.0981901959,
-0.0161728039,
-0.0268816985,
-0.0507459082,
-0.0545114242,
0.0362020992,
-0.086647965,
0.0325879604,
-0.0721501485,
-0.0387723893,
0.0000014016,
0.004503055,
-0.0139695769,
0.0118748052,
-0.0934142321,
0.0047348686,
-0.0466874838,
-0.0650514439,
-0.0048831408,
-0.0031700146,
0.0253382418,
-0.0227641948,
0.0391031243,
-0.0305815171,
-0.0355831869,
0.0108948229,
0.0131400609,
-0.0042716349,
-0.0100382119,
-0.0134191308,
0.0653459057,
0.0259797461,
-0.0212547146,
-0.0308871251,
0.0439168178,
0.0373502895,
-0.013151777,
-0.0126941912,
0.0393191017,
-0.0003256195,
-0.0045790756,
0.0152388802,
0.0511397347,
0.0017594643,
0.0249359254,
-0.0121001024,
-0.0296950936,
-0.0376357511,
-0.0339287855,
0.0087821977,
0.0618738793,
-0.0341175944,
-0.0054074195,
0.0547078066,
0.0335961431,
0.0426314548,
-0.0405099466,
0.0923150554,
0.0367369317,
-0.0250824708,
0.0360784568,
0.0415119529,
0.0015549454,
0.0022555655,
-0.0257110558,
0.0296934452,
-0.0476356372,
-0.0354386084,
-0.0576170869,
-0.0203641523,
0.0061231209,
0.0029946514,
-0.0180567596,
0.0082743075,
0.0110116499,
-0.0141540328,
0.0324066691,
-0.0344942138,
0.0702593774,
0.0062715039,
0.0381753892,
0.0373167023,
0.0246579144,
-0.0547743179,
-0.0058809174,
-0.0219074991,
0.0430629738,
0.0041767107,
-0.0161068272,
0.0779631585,
0.0053766035,
-0.0038485695,
-0.0575681105,
0.029067453,
-0.0199567899,
0.0498982295,
-0.0483053103,
-0.0363311656,
0.0210377239,
0.0156325065,
-0.0207280777,
-0.0622760877,
-0.0525295399,
0.0472794324,
-0.0001893303,
-0.0262872651,
-0.0220250841,
-0.0080124177,
0.0064908471,
-0.0067032981,
-0.0247930847,
-0.0386225469,
0.0305768736,
-0.0186680667,
0.0606833138,
0.0171098243,
0.0431571752,
-0.0097402344,
-0.0145186596,
-0.0201282706,
0.0070906673,
-0.0055363993,
0.0033848658,
-0.0238014758,
-0.0470867679,
-0.020601619,
-0.0111327237,
0.0557466336,
-0.0019734374,
0.0263822395,
-0.0308064297,
0.0054490003,
0.0156211415,
0.0525848977,
0.0005915909,
0.010015429,
0.0682740286,
-0.0480670631,
0.0061362144,
0.0206162035,
0.0303904694,
0.0200713258,
-0.0394516774,
-0.0193337873,
0.02073198,
-0.0057478151,
-0.0576281138,
0.0514204055,
-0.0368086807,
-0.0797927082,
-0.0090376046,
-0.0277499221,
0.0737758577,
0.0324561335,
-0.0671163574,
0.0067706243,
0.0136607634,
0.0827262625,
0.0288669635,
-0.0002777624,
-0.0477214605,
0.0103241298,
0.0570829958,
-0.0855502635,
-0.0151775675,
-0.0153643796,
0.0022532023,
-0.036794465,
0.056598492,
-0.0368360244,
0.0119596198,
-0.0126925707,
-0.0142700402,
-0.039386902,
-0.0407953374,
-0.0200273916,
-0.0248802733,
0.0248429086,
0.0107392371,
-0.0392165743,
-0.0174307004,
-0.0209346507,
0.0679107085,
0.0392019041,
-0.0219039433,
-0.0058670379,
-0.0132476632,
-0.0063228686,
0.0286346152,
-0.0021559352,
-0.0154799828,
0.0093562575,
0.000644759,
-0.0394475721,
-0.0189303961,
-0.0062944652,
-0.0290008634,
-0.0240897927,
0.0252918992,
-0.0092486339,
0.0599324331,
-0.0379028134,
0.0261567216,
0.031325452,
0.081278339,
0.002346206,
-0.0168932397,
0.0399653167,
0.0336592756,
-0.0415834077,
-0.0385412127,
-0.0451274067,
0.0409257151,
0.0073874947,
0.0006632796,
-0.0138121545,
0.0622229055,
0.0016818569,
-0.0206788015,
-0.0012465159,
-0.0247014705,
-0.0600653775,
0.0253175944,
0.0175213516,
0.0329157449,
-0.028101569,
0.0151085313,
0.0243789796,
0.0434108675,
-0.0380701274,
0.102594994,
-0.0048013069,
-0.0086663198,
0.0209796168,
-0.01522524,
0.0075455192,
0.010184953,
-0.0206573755,
-0.041641403,
0.0662895069,
-0.064488247,
0.039859429,
-0.0179012679,
-0.0170797557,
-0.002820418,
0.0118802339,
0.0483441576,
-0.0287088137,
0.0298928339,
0.0337779969,
0.0118061863,
-0.0267582014,
0.0401402861,
0.0442286246,
0.0150795327,
-0.0008251743,
0.0626862198,
-0.0218064133,
0.0636613443,
-0.0500693321,
0.0454896912,
0.0178349894,
-0.0362250283,
0.0050729895,
-0.0047347625,
0.0134244524,
-0.0037773249,
-0.0097784596,
-0.0182947554,
-0.0138032883,
-0.0067560906,
0.0211369228,
-0.0581592321,
-0.0083158026,
0.0122750485,
0.0654773936,
0.012021441,
0.0203052666,
0.0424663238,
-0.0203101505,
-0.0294668376,
-0.0609485395,
-0.0178239141,
0.0009142972,
0.0170380846,
0.072926484,
-0.0466548167,
-0.0352378376,
-0.0577081107,
-0.0424888842,
-0.006724616,
-0.0171766579,
-0.0599455908,
-0.0290113091,
0.0247300509,
0.0371832736,
-0.0133472802,
-0.0130890394,
-0.0101132644,
-0.0271633025,
0.0432526954,
-0.0039698519,
-0.0268072169,
0.0216145683,
0.0554856174,
0.0873291492,
0.0045035281,
0.0459656566,
0.0212325547,
-0.0170028005,
0.0124495327,
0.0441021211,
-0.0397582054,
-0.0481588468,
0.0197461527,
-0.0240722913,
-0.0250765402,
-0.0537830964,
-0.0001559035,
0.0230973214,
0.0802207068,
0.0126991197,
0.0454474315,
-0.0150570171,
-0.034680102,
-0.0135722402,
0.0242344793,
-0.0124021713,
0.0353317261,
-0.0004345418,
0.0403681062,
-0.0170579869,
0.0063047702,
0.0322212763,
0.0053940411,
-0.0078725815,
0.0017339271,
0.0174732413,
-0.0008710476,
0.0585695431,
0.0505943,
0.0448393226,
0.0451075062,
-0.0076213679,
-0.044381734,
0.0704085007,
-0.0052345591,
0.0276826732,
-0.0151411388,
0.0545036122,
-0.0274809338,
-0.0036651886,
0.0546533763,
0.0176298432,
0.0292821769,
0.0327406973,
-0.0105053876,
-0.0440934673,
0.0219425727,
-0.0230392031,
-0.0113003636,
-0.1061042696,
-0.0145329256,
0.0211411752,
-0.0620446019,
-0.0449989438,
-0.0005694666,
0.0067390911,
-0.0198217668,
-0.0300176814,
0.0308531448,
0.0114173312,
-0.0535192974,
-0.0118087959,
0.001035169,
0.0180738922,
0.0473687612,
0.0596643128,
-0.0220568068,
-0.0647097453,
0.0602234714,
-0.0031334513,
-0.0304045677,
0.0285509136,
-0.0609348789,
-0.0308388416,
0.0148256263,
0.0177621674,
-0.0714844018,
0.0672174171,
-0.0124932025,
0.0710379481,
-0.0052542859,
0.0086754616,
0.0068489271,
0.0531751253,
0.0055102962,
0.0325580202,
0.0160128567,
0.0097747017,
-0.0340563916,
0.0139235063,
-0.0683851466,
0.0470126048,
0.0394509844,
-0.0171899609,
0.01924509,
0.0653475374,
-0.0287882816,
0.0262733679,
0.0680211782,
-0.02685198,
0.0246270318,
0.0139413122,
-0.0419970714,
-0.028234262,
0.0231250413,
-0.0395924598,
0.0397814661,
-0.0494029298,
0.0253442414,
0.0119304508,
-0.0153740756,
-0.0506464317,
-0.0988365784,
-0.0157671869,
0.0055720662,
-0.0091805793,
0.0186091587,
-0.0194019824,
0.0279436186,
-0.0283580553,
-0.0420451723,
-0.002254216,
0.0149414064,
-0.0414299406,
0.0440367907,
0.0272847861,
-0.0426212065,
0.0416953526,
-0.0206311606,
0.0415632427,
0.043435324,
-0.0232443511,
0.0348527133,
0.0261359513,
-0.1254766583,
0.0252429657,
0.0206488091,
-0.0037775887,
-0.0029156918,
-0.0138813974,
-0.0225998685,
-0.0072430731,
-0.0565546192,
-0.0177812781,
0.0380173996,
-0.0224014949,
0.0475038886,
-0.0072345119,
0.0553710796,
0.0186746679,
-0.0211875215,
0.0105092619,
-0.0421812348,
-0.0377756692,
-0.017602209,
0.0463291183,
0.0258466098,
0.0130574498,
0.0730103329,
0.0000461502,
-0.0177393835,
0.0257315245,
-0.0029330037,
0.0219329689,
0.0390517637,
0.004284001,
0.000969865,
0.0165929589,
0.0127008855,
0.050211519,
0.0141057307,
-0.0337970927,
0.0545057058,
0.0428239033,
0.0046970374,
0.0160968285,
0.0208573472,
0.0238328222,
0.0451272242,
0.0653231665,
-0.0148630049,
-0.0372360907,
-0.0522696078,
-0.0366469137,
0.024752548,
-0.0324727707,
-0.0625392497,
-0.0028020767,
-0.0209655017,
-0.0189107172,
0.0297574364,
0.0191345531,
0.0334228836,
0.0766147226,
-0.0315537937,
0.0433769412,
-0.0776707008,
0.0091278208,
-0.0331165418,
-0.0366473831,
-0.0596352592,
0.1125097424,
0.0452522188,
0.0512894318,
0.0157541651,
-0.0395535193,
-0.0225683935,
-0.0075940788,
0.0629649386,
0.0135466997,
0.0240827575,
-0.000327753,
0.0242780875,
0.0443582758,
-0.0139030041,
-0.0094281472,
-0.0471515507,
-0.0045891618,
0.0362368673,
-4.83555103e-33,
-0.02309669,
-0.0104446011,
-0.0432713814,
-0.0303555652,
0.0169859957,
0.0053242659,
0.0034326566,
0.0332754552,
-0.0076761018,
-0.0001976848,
-0.0165111087,
0.0256204382,
-0.0029298763,
0.0182270594,
-0.0178390313,
0.0117777316,
-0.010944006,
-0.0255332254,
-0.0453142934,
-0.0210219622,
-0.0140588665,
-0.0747136846,
-0.0105971713,
0.0093501657,
0.0068721152,
0.0065901726,
-0.0149159525,
0.0548276491,
-0.0000253959,
0.0245356485,
0.0044596214,
0.002888323,
0.0126828365,
-0.1042250395,
0.015701469,
0.0285564177,
-0.0110603487,
-0.0570799038,
0.0285426471,
-0.024601806,
-0.003829971,
-0.0345353261,
0.0224726982,
-0.0318346955,
0.0220327564,
-0.0163216908,
-0.0373233519,
-0.0477525257,
-0.0409128517,
-0.0145971291,
0.0692661405,
-0.0006917533,
-0.0077095791,
0.0360743105,
0.0074279271,
-0.0254312791,
-0.0290724505,
-0.0528446287,
0.0193986576,
0.0232489761,
0.0361923389,
0.0537681952,
-0.0890705511,
-0.0210615322,
0.0445772558,
-0.0216030311,
0.0028163062,
-0.0043290011,
-0.0063034734,
0.0569548309,
-0.0306726173,
0.0025521398,
0.01039756,
0.0160601251,
0.0730806887,
0.0119628608,
-0.0491733067,
-0.0110250693,
0.027879918,
-0.0304132737,
0.0148250526,
-0.0280155167,
-0.0413597785,
-0.0606946312,
-0.0326397195,
0.0020076497,
0.0295486357,
0.0235445276,
-0.0353735723,
0.0253082737,
0.0108207762,
0.0035186529,
0.0190515388,
-0.0285334755,
-0.0459175594,
0.0217374153,
0.0572552942,
0.0066576023,
-0.028649047,
-0.0151668619,
-0.0107171461,
0.0052899006,
-0.0524788052,
0.0003637625,
0.003236793,
0.0616190247,
0.0024278883,
-0.0088264896,
0.0022695565,
-0.0270758811,
0.0257334765,
-0.0170137994,
-0.0201609302,
-0.006546272,
0.0233438462,
-0.0073160022,
0.001968394,
-0.0391740575,
-0.0234981552,
-0.0363977291,
0.0346294679,
0.0212419666,
-0.0002330353,
0.0243668817,
0.0132185398,
-0.0337534659,
-0.0513072461,
0.0094984658,
0.0323735364,
0.0131105175,
-0.0214408692,
0.0100013874,
2.371e-7,
-0.0098639429,
-0.0633936673,
0.0277539268,
0.0344160385,
0.0272370987,
0.0067027044,
0.0098880213,
0.015046387,
-0.0513907857,
-0.0532061942,
0.0340828821,
-0.0066119642,
0.0021992039,
-0.0206697881,
-0.010073605,
-0.0525895357,
0.0266623087,
-0.0132566728,
0.0488371812,
0.0377824493,
0.0591212101,
0.0419253185,
0.0337587483,
0.0183449574,
-0.0515777953,
0.0013794212,
-0.0024483816,
-0.0596903339,
0.0643170998,
-0.0031796035,
0.0263962038,
0.0129210893,
-0.0181882828,
-0.0088106031,
-0.0218978208,
0.023149753,
0.0284140762,
0.0054508522,
0.0471574068,
0.036702916,
-0.0159223098,
-0.0529072955,
-0.0467181467,
0.0455197096,
0.076014705,
0.0174627937,
-0.0878793225,
0.0634884834,
0.0262242593,
-0.0100875041,
-0.0505035222,
0.0435140133,
-0.0418191217,
-0.0304755047,
0.0004537715,
0.0410900936,
0.0472747236,
0.0343658328,
-0.0402312353,
0.0024695129,
-0.0251168385,
-0.0173238944,
-0.043418996,
-0.0070572179,
0.0039592721,
0.0003401908,
-0.035667371,
1.829547099e-34,
0.0076240925,
-0.0075746281,
0.0530204289,
-0.055637382,
-0.0304112807,
-0.0490872785,
0.0115521932,
-0.0209446475,
0.0666447654,
-0.053039033,
-0.0116871474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02993v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02993v1
|
Natural Language Robot Programming: NLP integrated with autonomous robotic grasping
| 2023-04-06T11:06:30 | 2023-04-06T11:06:30 |
Muhammad Arshad Khan, Max Kenney, Jack Painter, Disha Kamale, Riza Batista-Navarro, Amir Ghalamzan-E
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
In this paper, we present a grammar-based natural language framework for
robot programming, specifically for pick-and-place tasks. Our approach uses a
custom dictionary of action words, designed to store together words that share
meaning, allowing for easy expansion of the vocabulary by adding more action
words from a lexical database. We validate our Natural Language Robot
Programming (NLRP) framework through simulation and real-world experimentation,
using a Franka Panda robotic arm equipped with a calibrated camera-in-hand and
a microphone. Participants were asked to complete a pick-and-place task using
verbal commands, which were converted into text using Google's Speech-to-Text
API and processed through the NLRP framework to obtain joint space trajectories
for the robot. Our results indicate that our approach has a high system
usability score. The framework's dictionary can be easily extended without
relying on transfer learning or large data sets. In the future, we plan to
compare the presented framework with different approaches of human-assisted
pick-and-place tasks via a comprehensive user study.
|
[
0.0661783889,
0.0369656794,
0.0120582161,
-0.007176151,
-0.037078701,
0.0075394385,
-0.0071885022,
-0.016348565,
0.032380715,
-0.0764560029,
0.0149542028,
0.0188358277,
-0.0069477409,
0.0422970019,
-0.0014102774,
-0.0914149433,
0.0294596665,
-0.0234987531,
-0.017077323,
0.0319470428,
0.0093239211,
0.0465478785,
-0.0744139105,
0.0672809556,
-0.0511047021,
0.0198378004,
-0.0367968269,
-0.0186606105,
0.0095167765,
-0.0749983937,
-0.0261305496,
0.0099171568,
0.0421357267,
0.0328027979,
0.0000020526,
-0.107425496,
-0.0158929955,
0.0069494462,
-0.0045626471,
-0.0287134331,
0.032606069,
0.0107667781,
0.0254982393,
0.0168494098,
-0.0192443375,
0.0084124142,
0.0531344004,
0.0217697304,
0.0429669432,
0.0331788138,
-0.0131552806,
-0.0108670918,
-0.052013468,
0.0315805785,
-0.0270218626,
-0.0398362838,
0.0278291851,
0.0341098458,
0.1138123572,
0.0194632169,
-0.0144333439,
-0.0077408347,
-0.0029770874,
-0.0353202373,
-0.005920554,
0.0433926918,
-0.064609386,
-0.0334377103,
-0.0265096761,
0.0119309677,
0.0317815691,
-0.0008375609,
0.0279732421,
-0.0228674002,
0.029148465,
0.0198494308,
-0.0095692407,
0.0372647867,
-0.010783067,
-0.0195512883,
-0.0323156789,
-0.0675457716,
-0.0191009603,
-0.0267976411,
0.0244123135,
0.0721116066,
0.0104270019,
0.0031462959,
0.0190574359,
-0.0051614195,
-0.0116540035,
-0.0655494332,
0.0497023463,
0.0573894233,
-0.0551134385,
0.0109716607,
-0.0605489612,
0.009284921,
-0.006196049,
-0.0420434959,
-0.0066561983,
0.0269026216,
-0.0138747636,
0.0162359755,
0.0021154245,
0.0414845049,
0.0163671672,
0.047611922,
-0.0520912111,
-0.0142615717,
-0.0660393611,
-0.0061913803,
-0.0462767594,
0.0368592292,
-0.031836208,
-0.0367495082,
-0.005615016,
0.0320066512,
0.0111780604,
-0.010436967,
-0.021822447,
0.0465042703,
-0.0275299754,
-0.0100611076,
-0.0433848836,
-0.0140942466,
-0.038840726,
0.0316469446,
0.0229421332,
0.0073818523,
-0.0069957799,
0.0013392698,
0.0457752086,
-0.0197064001,
0.0107459426,
0.0885941833,
0.0069547966,
-0.0276719183,
0.0138778761,
0.0212685671,
-0.0005705826,
-0.0047171451,
0.0207069535,
-0.0746061057,
0.0009996635,
0.0388729014,
-0.0228540115,
-0.0324439257,
0.0062940205,
0.0408494286,
-0.0015995014,
0.061818935,
-0.0240403228,
0.0168906469,
0.0337489769,
-0.0290349331,
-0.0342597365,
0.0189467426,
0.0268878136,
0.0332326107,
0.0203801803,
0.0123818684,
0.0168311503,
0.0059099705,
-0.1110666469,
-0.0674553588,
-0.0035688856,
-0.0249757376,
-0.0058475803,
0.0639532208,
-0.0221101083,
0.0159252267,
-0.0054102833,
0.0460990332,
-0.0199483968,
0.1122296527,
-0.0064780032,
-0.0099514164,
-0.000776095,
0.0397566371,
-0.0179277472,
-0.0924578011,
-0.0362388492,
0.0488950722,
-0.0141919497,
-0.0181738753,
-0.0587899089,
0.0365655869,
0.0205495059,
-0.0152381761,
-0.0376142487,
0.0161281079,
0.0707796961,
-0.023763299,
0.050048653,
0.0121173579,
-0.0378955714,
0.0158510581,
-0.004559123,
-0.0225820914,
-0.0154218907,
0.0001739977,
-0.0232670549,
0.0320713185,
-0.0019239801,
-0.0491078421,
-0.0255825464,
0.0081731305,
-0.0006211277,
0.0266976338,
0.0115993368,
0.0059941122,
-0.0289909504,
-0.010259131,
-0.0413198918,
-0.0162494164,
-0.0143870283,
0.0308505241,
0.0318431184,
0.0368800163,
-0.0273196846,
0.0608750097,
-0.0030675356,
0.0573171154,
0.0373717807,
-0.0074061747,
0.0060285013,
0.002210805,
-0.0107414899,
0.0152928941,
-0.026250463,
-0.0036838898,
0.0158791468,
0.0192946214,
-0.0067795683,
0.0273610428,
0.0273807589,
0.0095448103,
0.0303420983,
-0.0330661386,
-0.0653309971,
0.0337144397,
-0.0154561382,
-0.032980416,
-0.0125497868,
-0.0193540938,
0.0295946151,
0.0184226371,
-0.0016824496,
0.0192786437,
-0.0305804033,
-0.0304646119,
0.0076451669,
0.0223726239,
0.0067088502,
0.0110257426,
0.0167563241,
0.0231273044,
-0.0486373529,
-0.0210986119,
0.0168276783,
-0.0176843517,
0.020735573,
0.0690536574,
0.0821275264,
-0.0212087668,
-0.0108498363,
-0.0741545334,
-0.0124125564,
-0.0039703911,
-0.0142674511,
0.0244421121,
0.0040607066,
-0.0323652737,
-0.0304275192,
0.0309201535,
0.0129240723,
-0.0313477628,
-0.0175239984,
0.045645535,
-0.0045727254,
-0.0346038342,
-0.03521806,
0.0349647291,
-0.0249521565,
-0.0538073629,
0.0723582804,
-0.0376247577,
-0.0332744345,
0.0066237864,
0.0005743881,
0.0167883765,
0.0082984278,
-0.0163852219,
0.0784276202,
-0.0406755619,
-0.0299170874,
0.0691951215,
-0.0359183066,
0.0173472017,
0.0641250536,
0.0003562704,
-0.0194560923,
0.0160058234,
-0.0217125751,
-0.0029659141,
0.0015834958,
0.0507773124,
0.0304938871,
0.0145459082,
0.0205714814,
0.0031363231,
-0.0131423734,
-0.036024712,
-0.0480335131,
-0.0066437968,
-0.0523711555,
0.036498569,
-0.0890036449,
0.0013040588,
-0.0054290383,
-0.0472769439,
0.0463148318,
0.0112558678,
-0.0078714723,
-0.0177754089,
-0.0513189919,
-0.0078272987,
0.0976669118,
0.0260947682,
0.0103170276,
0.033999905,
-0.0471736267,
0.0127635188,
0.0087730484,
-0.0016457777,
0.008473184,
-0.0086258287,
-0.1053471789,
0.0332993604,
0.00973232,
-0.0205738023,
-0.023460323,
0.0292164665,
-0.0697610453,
0.0125802392,
-0.0180185977,
-0.0986558646,
0.0374088362,
-0.0471194275,
0.0324237794,
0.0471891277,
0.03703532,
-0.0233915299,
-0.0189766157,
-0.0240352973,
0.0504839756,
0.0814820454,
-0.0808005109,
0.052294448,
-0.0529109873,
0.0126338974,
0.0219526142,
0.0146848457,
-0.0506492406,
0.0123031326,
0.0168394651,
-0.0326840356,
0.0109493556,
0.0501776524,
0.0457159877,
-0.0025331858,
-0.0336608514,
0.0625228584,
0.0480187982,
0.067518644,
0.0015272624,
0.0231365338,
-0.0419207141,
0.0384293869,
0.0392421633,
-0.0038604769,
-0.0526679009,
0.0189232714,
-0.0042539472,
0.0333313718,
0.008358486,
-0.0042406493,
-0.1035235077,
0.0350756571,
-0.0303197689,
-0.0572488643,
-0.0664135516,
-0.0452180915,
0.0020810282,
-0.0541161411,
-0.0527294204,
0.0081680724,
-0.0269070603,
0.0009763173,
0.0061095594,
-0.0437316895,
-0.0056095836,
0.0270505808,
-0.0348341204,
0.0193472318,
0.0659495592,
0.0375472978,
-0.0198095143,
0.0094127571,
0.0100802919,
0.0674264356,
-0.0015761805,
-0.0070401072,
-0.0231410079,
-0.0050084237,
-0.0126906829,
-0.0112575619,
0.0429708287,
-0.0738660768,
-0.0531251431,
-0.0150179695,
0.0409632325,
-0.006614428,
0.0309305359,
-0.0436440855,
-0.0348264053,
0.0143006779,
0.0454330333,
-0.0398637652,
-0.0119115785,
-0.0631172583,
-0.0591990612,
-0.0538445786,
0.0067569283,
-0.0524085015,
0.0084414491,
-0.0304771494,
0.0034989633,
-0.0636842921,
-0.0226069931,
0.1073062345,
0.0385321304,
0.0088417465,
0.0196149368,
0.0405742936,
0.0420685112,
-0.0407019444,
0.0215413235,
0.0165743828,
0.0233641006,
0.0151678398,
-0.0371495858,
0.0282530151,
0.0239005461,
-0.0371337384,
0.0273857433,
0.0217023883,
-0.0403428748,
0.0126031246,
0.0650569722,
0.0129190572,
0.0085222973,
-0.0076021627,
0.0054802657,
-0.0359492898,
0.0490887053,
0.0063882088,
0.0138781397,
-0.0335877016,
0.0480654351,
0.0145921204,
0.0051733805,
-0.0467566811,
-0.0418799743,
-0.0787647665,
0.0313079841,
-0.0423808619,
-0.0140593555,
0.0402490795,
0.0026622175,
0.0293694437,
-0.0049704667,
0.0035271023,
-0.0574590266,
-0.037240155,
-0.0470296517,
-0.0061039678,
-0.064002268,
0.0092818132,
-0.0109772766,
-0.0025595434,
0.0462770984,
0.0065200124,
-0.0287795495,
0.0216478892,
0.0434165746,
0.0119307581,
0.0739281699,
0.0390079953,
0.0103833182,
0.0049316678,
-0.011616963,
-0.0229797773,
-0.0347354785,
0.0573438145,
-0.008946728,
0.0326630659,
0.0275224671,
-0.0212616213,
0.0068916478,
0.0016641923,
-0.0180499665,
-0.0954990163,
-0.0234744586,
0.011174595,
0.0650278479,
-0.0723757297,
0.0148478504,
-0.1057757437,
0.0161439236,
0.0061602686,
0.0361425616,
0.017358914,
-0.0119411899,
0.0183901377,
0.004496967,
-0.008542385,
-0.0264667552,
0.0408339947,
-0.0253922269,
0.0329033695,
0.0035412919,
-0.0287695676,
-0.0440114886,
-0.0308500212,
0.0174157023,
0.0148211289,
0.0087088551,
0.0120216766,
-0.0020718884,
-0.0305628404,
-0.047794316,
0.0361340567,
-0.005851835,
-0.0073141428,
0.0929741561,
-0.0118601536,
-0.0018694971,
-0.0313001424,
-0.0207875818,
-0.0259435661,
0.0122906948,
-0.0187345594,
-0.0428039208,
-5.475764559e-33,
-0.0151772751,
-0.0988423601,
0.0262634382,
0.0237254389,
0.0043828017,
-0.0679792091,
-0.0103591569,
0.0282762647,
0.0196614712,
0.0196869764,
-0.0012326344,
-0.0006482976,
0.0007187469,
0.0127946828,
0.0566258095,
0.0149612874,
-0.001435661,
-0.0026471096,
-0.0077491682,
-0.0612745136,
0.070406884,
0.041641172,
0.0344436169,
-0.0192249101,
-0.0087237675,
0.0268750265,
0.0203166548,
-0.0008856082,
0.0310623553,
-0.0059752031,
-0.0132726803,
0.0093398988,
0.0044793487,
-0.0085551552,
-0.0208628122,
0.0314043202,
-0.048606623,
-0.0885025412,
-0.0320605077,
0.0342005789,
-0.0314142965,
0.0351213962,
0.0250538271,
-0.0015253278,
-0.0343685448,
0.0569455214,
0.0287028868,
0.0165885799,
0.0000907796,
0.0697128326,
-0.0327486321,
-0.0016028018,
-0.0093256822,
-0.0812886506,
0.0112000834,
-0.0031444789,
0.0081935124,
-0.0349798761,
0.0037892051,
-0.0310838912,
-0.0096703796,
0.0131011354,
0.034306936,
0.0083066942,
0.0170703363,
0.0631712079,
0.0031238652,
-0.0838975683,
0.0169462748,
0.0279517975,
0.0002347634,
0.0594161749,
-0.0259558409,
0.0422789045,
0.0565803759,
0.0129061099,
-0.0386733525,
0.0194665473,
-0.0734988973,
0.0861683488,
-0.0426221043,
0.0398778394,
-0.0184722375,
0.027157763,
-0.0006269118,
0.0346732773,
0.0168734789,
-0.0051685176,
0.0494221337,
0.0034099612,
0.0092523489,
-0.0279172808,
-0.0149460547,
0.0160585735,
-0.0454739705,
-0.0250168126,
-0.0334399529,
0.0237394292,
-0.0127125587,
-0.0135269333,
-0.0375450775,
-0.0113091003,
0.0088639203,
0.0128299715,
0.0458883308,
0.0074303099,
-0.0801055953,
0.0532915108,
-0.0204568058,
0.0177158061,
-0.0103387488,
-0.0299200416,
-0.0079238564,
-0.0135312974,
0.053556297,
0.0016679966,
-0.0343917906,
0.0724992901,
-0.0214297865,
-0.0181468334,
-0.026808124,
-0.0231589079,
-0.0147262542,
-0.038614314,
-0.0065247407,
-0.0312776193,
-0.016238207,
0.0294178706,
0.0273252558,
-0.0166346487,
-0.0034747215,
-0.0005124073,
2.879e-7,
0.0434700735,
0.0448028147,
0.0400193855,
0.0581036657,
-0.0198264923,
0.0364000611,
0.0011521101,
0.0554797873,
-0.019739097,
0.0072111506,
-0.0474836044,
-0.0098560024,
-0.0131833432,
-0.0076373215,
-0.1055018455,
0.04724456,
0.0389759205,
-0.0212565064,
-0.0510257669,
0.0040637231,
0.0768771246,
0.0639811084,
0.0027416348,
0.0248333309,
0.0200985167,
-0.0584366396,
0.0011773572,
-0.0428946987,
0.0530311465,
-0.0076405182,
0.0390644372,
0.0094089815,
0.0033519312,
-0.0244079027,
-0.01230055,
-0.0317838117,
0.0385478325,
0.0425077267,
-0.0250288546,
-0.0274149328,
-0.0055637807,
-0.0025193985,
-0.0092750425,
-0.0120782899,
0.0282940492,
-0.099742949,
0.0499639884,
0.0005089745,
0.0147905787,
0.0025729272,
0.0140514122,
0.0109348353,
0.0016802561,
-0.0334281474,
0.0001431454,
0.0195334926,
-0.045567777,
-0.041181311,
-0.0030301118,
0.0245716907,
-0.0348186456,
0.0144629497,
-0.0111306412,
-0.0478353091,
0.0063028773,
0.0106536821,
-0.0364524163,
1.769523074e-34,
-0.0268467367,
0.00107645,
0.010730911,
0.0672982931,
0.0396576039,
0.0307276547,
0.0202847812,
0.0363682993,
0.0205434207,
-0.0134391729,
-0.0380703323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02983v1
|
Leveraging Social Interactions to Detect Misinformation on Social Media
| 2023-04-06T10:30:04 | 2023-04-06T10:30:04 |
Tommaso Fornaciari, Luca Luceri, Emilio Ferrara, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Detecting misinformation threads is crucial to guarantee a healthy
environment on social media. We address the problem using the data set created
during the COVID-19 pandemic. It contains cascades of tweets discussing
information weakly labeled as reliable or unreliable, based on a previous
evaluation of the information source. The models identifying unreliable threads
usually rely on textual features. But reliability is not just what is said, but
by whom and to whom. We additionally leverage on network information. Following
the homophily principle, we hypothesize that users who interact are generally
interested in similar topics and spreading similar kind of news, which in turn
is generally reliable or not. We test several methods to learn representations
of the social interactions within the cascades, combining them with deep neural
language models in a Multi-Input (MI) framework. Keeping track of the sequence
of the interactions during the time, we improve over previous state-of-the-art
models.
|
[
0.0295202676,
0.0259210635,
-0.0048351311,
0.0224162862,
-0.0264614243,
-0.0189388935,
-0.0108306576,
-0.0196304917,
0.0430256203,
-0.0304704476,
-0.0130597958,
-0.0624056458,
0.0367432721,
0.0439827107,
0.0169429053,
-0.0174869318,
0.0413966775,
0.0311916582,
0.0244090091,
-0.0139302704,
0.0112442495,
0.0352899991,
-0.0123523278,
0.0505548157,
-0.0324760042,
0.0081105335,
0.0152971046,
0.0061419713,
0.0560701564,
-0.0346207283,
0.0409996882,
0.0525275767,
0.0387753099,
0.0826330557,
0.0000015898,
-0.0070519354,
0.0018071384,
-0.0230388939,
-0.0099351071,
-0.0163463801,
0.033667773,
-0.0595537089,
0.0337396488,
0.0401231945,
-0.0365066901,
-0.009634654,
0.0191933531,
0.0569331311,
0.0739576295,
0.0813422501,
-0.0110260611,
-0.0139244515,
0.0346377455,
-0.0356888585,
-0.010336861,
-0.0549150445,
0.0661447123,
-0.0235822611,
-0.0330978818,
0.050865002,
0.0245418511,
0.008341372,
0.0185858961,
-0.0370137207,
0.0288610291,
0.0015313508,
0.0210548341,
-0.0500688814,
0.0089463331,
0.082250759,
0.0078958543,
-0.0381793864,
0.0169815645,
-0.0291578695,
-0.0072092782,
0.0572747551,
-0.0245271977,
-0.0122277252,
-0.0150542296,
0.0368133113,
0.0171499997,
0.0132028637,
0.0820159912,
0.0413847603,
0.0429858789,
0.0346317813,
-0.0244924389,
-0.0245214719,
0.030197626,
0.0161530394,
0.0139469961,
-0.0423174128,
0.0157428477,
0.0207602065,
-0.0218935795,
0.0138503909,
-0.0242859032,
0.0022946687,
0.0296279006,
-0.1280161142,
-0.0622128248,
-0.0112536345,
0.0176128782,
0.0450362749,
0.0140160378,
-0.0689456016,
-0.0459979735,
-0.0250622611,
0.0468359478,
-0.0327639133,
-0.0408064649,
0.0357622094,
0.0029312794,
0.0120145641,
0.0150515335,
-0.0122187696,
-0.0528837033,
-0.0126508456,
-0.0487296544,
0.0115009332,
-0.0193168018,
0.0161288083,
-0.0264476109,
-0.0162236746,
-0.0136978971,
0.0612194911,
-0.0038790077,
0.040557608,
-0.0058030738,
-0.0234369952,
-0.0090623749,
0.0032292891,
0.0169463474,
0.0105205458,
-0.0368282348,
0.0027157452,
0.0487963185,
-0.001447281,
-0.0213110354,
-0.0516973324,
-0.0361009128,
-0.0389687978,
0.0067775142,
-0.0807937309,
0.0078080115,
-0.0272003412,
-0.0131018618,
-0.022118818,
0.0099606477,
0.0110524716,
-0.0975088775,
0.0529881455,
-0.0222734399,
-0.0043092822,
0.0391486622,
0.0339730531,
0.0054050917,
0.0675202012,
-0.0059787962,
0.078379333,
0.0448633879,
0.0201841444,
0.0113025419,
0.0136319334,
0.0601199567,
0.0043835784,
0.0538763069,
-0.0260169506,
-0.042941004,
0.0013844685,
-0.0328208208,
0.0607976913,
-0.0057430589,
-0.0292014685,
0.0550978258,
0.003608668,
-0.0323664956,
-0.0068587833,
0.0560585372,
0.0481168441,
-0.0165614951,
-0.0068306308,
-0.0305068567,
0.002954466,
-0.0312226377,
-0.0355894566,
0.0308475159,
0.0134790419,
-0.0190994181,
-0.0149669629,
-0.0077066203,
-0.0064781262,
0.0251948573,
-0.0261145104,
0.0094091007,
-0.0243028328,
-0.0469987765,
0.0356470719,
0.0556842089,
-0.0015828819,
0.0054520001,
-0.0061098286,
0.0027915458,
0.0656131059,
0.0152902044,
0.0309777427,
-0.00754759,
-0.0486398675,
0.067231901,
0.0191094372,
0.0478358455,
-0.0222215876,
0.0078181606,
-0.0203118213,
-0.0077752215,
0.028276436,
0.0243480038,
0.0023900995,
0.0270703305,
0.024695646,
-0.0001243991,
0.0425297022,
-0.0396970659,
-0.0084620314,
-0.0101730796,
0.0190245919,
0.005134888,
0.0338298902,
0.031771604,
0.0101891439,
0.0182665456,
-0.0179260615,
0.0320211127,
0.0114721246,
-0.0739381686,
-0.0212231949,
-0.0441939011,
0.0153376646,
0.0247070473,
-0.0312633887,
-0.0460668094,
0.0154682081,
-0.0443256013,
0.008504143,
0.0557466522,
-0.0430703126,
0.0183653273,
-0.0138765341,
-0.0482086577,
-0.0273045059,
0.0264078211,
0.0221495032,
0.0651766881,
-0.0529299378,
-0.0107450373,
-0.0377747975,
-0.0115263723,
-0.0130873797,
-0.0213034395,
0.0001230673,
-0.0329591446,
0.0120042386,
0.0111259464,
0.0415218771,
-0.0406888947,
0.0018070214,
-0.002816983,
-0.0665596873,
-0.0336828455,
-0.0447841398,
-0.0135506988,
0.0112017859,
-0.0070119449,
0.0382349752,
-0.0086587742,
-0.0051719234,
0.0669411048,
0.0081033166,
0.0072916923,
0.0174095109,
-0.0152929416,
-0.0299812332,
-0.0392010696,
0.0020690544,
-0.0443550274,
0.0476373173,
0.0314967334,
-0.0588102564,
-0.0187080093,
-0.058693517,
-0.0571297184,
0.029175112,
-0.0238031633,
0.0020227206,
0.0153935468,
0.0262677595,
-0.0027994798,
-0.01070017,
0.0273243971,
0.0917968601,
-0.0020241118,
0.0434090011,
-0.0127592972,
-0.0192655958,
-0.0637728497,
0.033583656,
-0.0525132008,
-0.0361688472,
0.014544989,
0.0524528958,
0.0173436198,
-0.0050844513,
-0.0335875973,
0.0211989041,
0.0167107061,
-0.0207577813,
-0.009223897,
-0.0702931955,
0.0047363988,
-0.010200399,
-0.040044602,
-0.0541932285,
0.0793007538,
-0.0104623651,
0.0761300549,
-0.0060434896,
-0.0575773939,
-0.0173199084,
-0.0057276622,
-0.0085888719,
0.008781937,
0.0295185465,
0.0053643933,
0.0084681222,
-0.0049090516,
0.0457801484,
-0.0136002656,
0.0459701121,
-0.0275667068,
0.0393401049,
0.0500465184,
-0.0201215819,
-0.044130262,
-0.0787421688,
-0.0422899611,
-0.0196373947,
-0.0093481578,
-0.0235352907,
-0.0449252911,
-0.0574309081,
0.0066086929,
-0.0174840204,
0.0102215875,
0.0049411491,
0.0165080968,
0.0385869369,
0.021490274,
-0.0258124135,
0.0413351655,
-0.0416334011,
-0.004109527,
0.041533567,
-0.0020463783,
0.0028825207,
-0.045882713,
-0.053519845,
-0.0173831508,
0.0018811224,
0.0026091775,
0.0038330446,
0.0279155802,
-0.0451920033,
0.0139225591,
0.0970973521,
0.0094337799,
-0.0496242829,
0.0130191417,
0.0311304033,
0.0089555029,
-0.00241439,
-0.0163995512,
-0.0578280017,
-0.0104095107,
-0.0210835617,
-0.0077340542,
0.0007104279,
-0.0398237854,
0.0047215526,
-0.0411119014,
0.0016361139,
-0.0021425262,
0.0039076349,
-0.0480804183,
-0.0748214051,
-0.0030279979,
-0.0238224547,
0.0233009215,
-0.0333078206,
0.0168831851,
-0.0261970256,
-0.0098703559,
-0.0406119153,
-0.0572560728,
0.0257936977,
-0.0391706228,
0.0632234663,
0.0024902006,
0.0463657528,
-0.0232388861,
-0.0464479215,
0.0345801786,
0.0228633359,
-0.0428273641,
-0.0254800823,
0.0589219406,
-0.0415355563,
-0.0122454464,
-0.0387298428,
0.0297860727,
-0.0335103758,
-0.0269090049,
-0.0439398773,
0.0636404604,
-0.0156846866,
-0.0895776972,
-0.0138706854,
0.043416217,
0.0603778437,
0.0539394133,
0.0324929282,
0.0108208973,
0.0149952862,
-0.0243019573,
0.0054351357,
0.00232,
-0.0264925566,
0.0071415203,
0.0269828904,
-0.0454569571,
-0.0310046189,
-0.0378310606,
0.0049414737,
-0.0037476553,
-0.0344874971,
-0.024508927,
0.0785268098,
-0.0250406843,
-0.0175569803,
0.0051981732,
-0.0125317862,
0.0529443994,
0.0124016525,
0.0035457115,
0.0063005188,
0.0355782658,
-0.0099109169,
0.0589649975,
-0.0980832279,
-0.0727384537,
-0.0002723565,
0.0067090755,
0.0174858402,
0.0470911972,
-0.0513682514,
-0.0347431377,
0.0054009715,
-0.0006263296,
-0.0143707898,
-0.0009183521,
0.0025601047,
0.0059714685,
0.0352916159,
0.0512913764,
-0.0256298278,
0.0318506546,
0.0033921385,
-0.0157258846,
-0.0710427091,
-0.0308872126,
-0.0052748849,
-0.0159353707,
0.0394524112,
0.0038934695,
-0.0192286242,
-0.0271982215,
-0.0462518744,
0.0074822796,
-0.0193510689,
0.0270615388,
0.0276587568,
0.0184721742,
-0.0202645678,
-0.0174697228,
-0.0199149754,
-0.0135762012,
0.0605517663,
-0.0457319953,
-0.0342659056,
0.0099961953,
0.0226374995,
0.0146468608,
-0.0088845817,
-0.0163207036,
0.0429522283,
0.0058194702,
0.0019121085,
-0.0022189184,
-0.0214605257,
-0.0137800965,
-0.0207761042,
0.01436463,
-0.0364322811,
-0.0642489567,
-0.0229440965,
-0.0406458415,
-0.0050981301,
0.0457880087,
0.0127420807,
0.0425935872,
-0.0090090455,
-0.0089686662,
-0.0200959463,
0.0290190037,
-0.035873808,
-0.0226273388,
0.0108095007,
0.0076438803,
-0.0448508672,
0.076858595,
0.0713750273,
0.0101640662,
0.0160536058,
0.0470737852,
-0.0651893392,
-0.0215588994,
-0.0162819736,
-0.0090426169,
0.0735834017,
-0.0260895789,
0.0205098633,
-0.0580267087,
-0.0544956848,
0.0313702077,
-0.0176165514,
0.0093391687,
0.0380650721,
-0.0120012173,
0.0733231083,
0.027125556,
0.0601788573,
-0.0487936288,
0.012584256,
-0.0029369479,
-0.0459015183,
-0.0066245599,
-6.512864654e-33,
0.042428311,
-0.0618059598,
-0.0398262963,
-0.0017087141,
-0.0111280521,
0.0416451395,
-0.02534586,
-0.0203813668,
-0.0283658877,
0.0597782694,
0.071248129,
0.0467101708,
-0.0094941016,
0.0070111151,
-0.023845911,
-0.0292242654,
0.0562296733,
0.0283696819,
0.005814929,
0.0424894355,
0.0599359907,
-0.0042641796,
0.0377883725,
-0.0550318956,
0.0676300898,
-0.0305106286,
0.0174265578,
0.0395032726,
0.0089874538,
0.023887448,
0.0039927685,
0.0740975142,
0.0494991317,
-0.013941519,
0.0106277931,
0.0671575218,
-0.0535463579,
-0.0405129604,
0.0003216584,
-0.0471719131,
-0.0303100776,
-0.0089628752,
0.0667507797,
0.0148060853,
0.004772475,
-0.0143494764,
0.0265877321,
0.0387000851,
-0.0087548373,
0.0263799392,
-0.0515862294,
0.0191848185,
-0.0027590587,
0.0128001375,
-0.0642722175,
0.0694064349,
0.0380553305,
0.0283271354,
-0.0962025896,
0.0134924734,
-0.0687792152,
-0.0123100867,
0.0025090622,
-0.0607156977,
-0.0330129154,
0.0720007718,
-0.0039473386,
0.04046138,
-0.0783414468,
-0.0031455224,
-0.0083996952,
0.0338769406,
0.0460367762,
0.0665887669,
-0.0042503416,
-0.058951579,
-0.1177280173,
0.0132503901,
0.0304668862,
0.0233109798,
-0.0101443846,
-0.0182852484,
-0.0306863543,
0.0024450039,
-0.0189849734,
-0.0007750291,
-0.0274993349,
-0.0256706309,
-0.0425991789,
0.036380019,
0.0023013183,
0.0884827822,
0.0081033939,
-0.0352788717,
-0.0312083494,
0.0476563126,
0.0188403521,
-0.0136326058,
0.0422879644,
0.0587356426,
-0.0600144081,
0.03104195,
-0.0027917677,
0.0214045178,
-0.0072557908,
-0.0223261788,
0.0413622186,
-0.001117204,
-0.0297755767,
-0.005032599,
-0.0335260816,
0.0052004498,
-0.0441526063,
0.0335617773,
0.0412868932,
0.0329603814,
-0.0198511258,
0.0199802443,
-0.0155528728,
0.0402985439,
0.0347613692,
0.011395405,
-0.0425036252,
0.0146234501,
-0.0099091725,
-0.0328543633,
-0.0244544577,
0.0325389616,
0.0144948186,
-0.099315986,
0.0122098057,
-0.0282385964,
2.567e-7,
0.0124650812,
0.0632819831,
0.0064700283,
-0.0185638424,
0.0344628096,
0.0390076153,
0.0020044995,
0.0331294872,
-0.0489124693,
-0.0856588185,
-0.0209825616,
0.0553721376,
0.0026762739,
0.0570461936,
-0.0353776701,
-0.0359650441,
-0.083323352,
0.0027931838,
-0.0373146236,
-0.015137543,
-0.0041845795,
0.0822704062,
0.0453121476,
-0.0250135493,
0.0115521122,
0.0121962586,
0.0783548206,
0.0148303732,
-0.0560333133,
0.0112052644,
0.0364589877,
-0.015554213,
0.001300854,
0.0143652903,
-0.0297432635,
0.0059244246,
-0.0266923662,
-0.0015086681,
-0.0021034458,
-0.0220983122,
-0.0235099848,
-0.0401425399,
0.0199404489,
-0.0224518292,
0.0336314477,
-0.0683406815,
-0.0526437201,
-0.0474685282,
-0.0253630821,
0.0376011766,
0.0449219272,
0.0215184912,
-0.0235189013,
0.0328000747,
-0.0070930608,
-0.003119739,
0.0158211906,
-0.0530927218,
0.0399609134,
-0.0081467731,
-0.0519102179,
-0.0371360965,
0.0197964422,
-0.0503531247,
0.0471144207,
0.0046004402,
0.0670669153,
1.786703774e-34,
0.0748392791,
-0.0213260259,
-0.0173725132,
0.0027373184,
0.0201183185,
0.0155276917,
-0.0561129972,
-0.0253803693,
0.0466435142,
-0.0163171478,
0.0217133593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02945v1
|
Multi-label classification of open-ended questions with BERT
| 2023-04-06T09:09:44 | 2023-04-06T09:09:44 |
Matthias Schonlau, Julia Weiß, Jan Marquardt
|
stat.AP
|
stat.AP, cs.CL
|
Open-ended questions in surveys are valuable because they do not constrain
the respondent's answer, thereby avoiding biases. However, answers to
open-ended questions are text data which are harder to analyze. Traditionally,
answers were manually classified as specified in the coding manual. Most of the
effort to automate coding has gone into the easier problem of single label
prediction, where answers are classified into a single code. However, open-ends
that require multi-label classification, i.e., that are assigned multiple
codes, occur frequently. This paper focuses on multi-label classification of
text answers to open-ended survey questions in social science surveys. We
evaluate the performance of the transformer-based architecture BERT for the
German language in comparison to traditional multi-label algorithms (Binary
Relevance, Label Powerset, ECC) in a German social science survey, the GLES
Panel (N=17,584, 55 labels). We find that classification with BERT (forcing at
least one label) has the smallest 0/1 loss (13.1%) among methods considered
(18.9%-21.6%). As expected, it is much easier to correctly predict answer texts
that correspond to a single label (7.1% loss) than those that correspond to
multiple labels ($\sim$50% loss). Because BERT predicts zero labels for only
1.5% of the answers, forcing at least one label, while recommended, ultimately
does not lower the 0/1 loss by much. Our work has important implications for
social scientists: 1) We have shown multi-label classification with BERT works
in the German language for open-ends. 2) For mildly multi-label classification
tasks, the loss now appears small enough to allow for fully automatic
classification (as compared to semi-automatic approaches). 3) Multi-label
classification with BERT requires only a single model. The leading competitor,
ECC, iterates through individual single label predictions.
|
[
0.0486606844,
0.0300738141,
-0.0134500172,
-0.0054146121,
-0.0179087762,
0.0239791069,
0.0413776301,
0.0048471377,
0.026237756,
-0.0684321374,
0.0319143943,
-0.0156043423,
-0.0159500018,
-0.0145790325,
-0.0152112273,
-0.0274063386,
0.0503897741,
0.0307173338,
0.0597550869,
-0.0288714096,
-0.0125321671,
-0.0042682621,
0.004405912,
0.0477382913,
-0.0132954251,
0.0331234671,
-0.0285694003,
-0.0073768813,
0.0205614101,
-0.0040530418,
0.0653982833,
0.0665078983,
-0.0132239712,
0.0080288537,
0.0000017552,
-0.0621599779,
-0.0461340025,
-0.0185799506,
-0.0160354152,
-0.028210571,
0.0071700714,
0.0455036238,
0.0176131986,
0.0492806546,
-0.0160474461,
-0.0070841433,
0.101850912,
0.043349538,
0.0710082352,
0.0053162728,
-0.0076804319,
-0.0700360015,
0.0157999564,
0.0343548916,
0.040827658,
0.0084882425,
0.0419203043,
-0.0687330887,
-0.0153231351,
0.0169421695,
-0.0068063326,
0.0152194276,
0.0132703334,
0.0262440667,
0.0241318308,
0.0357607938,
-0.0683095455,
-0.0696001425,
0.0355887227,
0.0365276895,
0.0313121714,
-0.014253553,
-0.0083462661,
0.0032430214,
0.0205221567,
0.0355593078,
-0.0059678415,
0.0174250789,
-0.0179831088,
-0.0178477652,
-0.0121807288,
0.0155256968,
-0.0431171209,
0.0059670829,
-0.0450347848,
0.0787639841,
0.0094899759,
-0.0240672603,
0.0417466573,
0.0231420957,
-0.0040085209,
-0.0418943763,
0.0113209011,
0.0205009598,
0.0053600725,
0.0298067033,
-0.0079401517,
-0.0535857491,
0.039878197,
-0.0393484943,
-0.0239429399,
0.0162836071,
-0.0533232018,
0.0015689369,
0.023420766,
0.0390908606,
0.0174682718,
0.0577815734,
-0.050710693,
-0.0440302417,
-0.0579114296,
-0.0220267344,
-0.0634461343,
0.0484205298,
0.0165103599,
0.0384726487,
-0.0634162426,
0.0139136845,
0.0250668619,
-0.0286196992,
-0.0049744071,
0.0237156637,
-0.0045547034,
0.0451575182,
-0.036744222,
0.0821711421,
-0.0471747629,
0.006681344,
-0.0244573653,
-0.0167008191,
0.0413961187,
0.0318748429,
0.0077579692,
-0.0400144979,
0.037768703,
0.0109886266,
-0.0269452296,
-0.0280213635,
-0.0371516123,
-0.0259043463,
-0.0497254431,
-0.0088488497,
0.0346011706,
-0.0508028567,
0.0417784452,
0.0587216355,
-0.0193324015,
0.0067557092,
0.0068220589,
0.0215663984,
-0.0570574738,
0.05257947,
0.0002443283,
0.0046628374,
0.0707292333,
-0.0019390256,
0.0438692383,
0.0401960574,
0.0059424494,
-0.0193411876,
0.044733122,
-0.0393662192,
0.0193742514,
0.0397789925,
-0.0018915207,
0.0082980981,
0.0143662365,
0.0357707143,
0.0273781475,
-0.0178363156,
-0.0286490954,
0.0390014984,
-0.0007161609,
-0.0478839912,
0.0323803313,
0.0379749499,
0.0241356548,
0.0103078121,
-0.0469896868,
0.0118712578,
0.0142842242,
-0.0111072073,
-0.0126549248,
0.0148241166,
-0.010287106,
-0.0210685898,
0.0343736559,
-0.0065312479,
-0.0234280899,
-0.0277708564,
-0.0160379689,
0.0008178412,
0.0358747132,
0.0132713402,
0.0364839733,
-0.0114604672,
-0.0223504379,
0.0999035686,
-0.0004406772,
-0.0396875404,
-0.0143330274,
-0.0706106797,
0.0127348471,
-0.0219425503,
-0.00511574,
-0.0650619417,
-0.0331004076,
-0.0439921133,
0.0132469516,
0.0099565778,
0.0484413132,
-0.025140157,
-0.0010568579,
-0.0258787684,
-0.0296490453,
0.0428233482,
-0.0088267,
0.0158871822,
-0.0168666113,
0.0274662394,
-0.0295674633,
-0.0758313909,
0.0311016236,
0.0290595181,
0.0374474972,
-0.0397338942,
0.0513977446,
0.0239177886,
0.0183817297,
0.0227210931,
-0.0299327355,
0.0151298912,
0.0198629797,
-0.0165812969,
-0.0450842045,
-0.0662860498,
0.0103985388,
-0.0086969305,
0.0200428888,
-0.0175481215,
-0.0203294866,
0.0721262246,
-0.0211945195,
-0.0261333007,
-0.0331257097,
-0.0633404553,
0.0334595516,
-0.0285455938,
0.002567528,
-0.0274305902,
-0.0164775066,
-0.0868421644,
0.0555813275,
0.0238973536,
0.0623414256,
-0.0188158918,
-0.0625281781,
0.0719803348,
-0.0103874309,
-0.0306150969,
0.0327536911,
-0.0281783324,
0.0297096223,
0.0554732047,
-0.0037188029,
-0.02809106,
-0.0347365327,
-0.0813101307,
0.0042531118,
-0.009185018,
0.0286800228,
-0.0001825549,
0.0180112571,
0.0200963039,
-0.0159578733,
-0.0534764975,
-0.0185302142,
-0.0067069819,
0.0477858372,
0.0339458697,
-0.0020530606,
0.004356653,
0.0350602865,
-0.0222681928,
-0.0541896261,
0.0595436096,
0.0431833863,
-0.0067431987,
-0.029122334,
-0.0694784373,
-0.0801224485,
0.0120651107,
0.0316247158,
-0.0378135592,
-0.0108578354,
-0.014055782,
0.0256547593,
0.0201737806,
0.0622528866,
-0.0130252186,
0.0176393278,
0.0311190169,
-0.0537745245,
0.0056612873,
-0.0494004115,
-0.0309137776,
-0.0096664159,
-0.0492438339,
0.0263118241,
0.0506982543,
0.0335225761,
-0.0182431284,
-0.0431331806,
-0.0192217976,
-0.0128743304,
0.0005751755,
-0.0871203765,
-0.0133180274,
-0.0070720324,
0.0579626299,
0.0416972265,
-0.0118932351,
0.045775298,
0.0180618148,
-0.0205120854,
-0.0764618292,
-0.0070814574,
-0.0337693729,
0.0409324691,
0.0083516464,
0.0321049355,
0.0622426867,
-0.0198327843,
-0.0655603409,
-0.0137891993,
-0.0045686741,
-0.0413329527,
-0.0096531324,
-0.000733506,
-0.0029845352,
-0.0322911628,
-0.0419903249,
-0.0260461997,
-0.0798908025,
0.011622401,
0.029819062,
-0.0048887883,
0.0028770813,
-0.0686664954,
-0.0005949987,
0.0415996797,
0.0114900861,
-0.0067205355,
-0.0221689753,
0.0152956499,
0.0888527185,
0.0282428134,
-0.0005085645,
0.0072452435,
-0.038866125,
-0.0289507564,
0.0315754153,
0.021745557,
0.039535068,
0.0299048033,
-0.006656786,
0.040478088,
-0.0702462271,
-0.0277209599,
0.0247790404,
0.0468750894,
-0.0117107676,
0.0141909504,
0.0829317197,
0.0579413474,
-0.0035710288,
-0.0471631922,
-0.0298899096,
0.0372792445,
0.0411421359,
0.040856149,
-0.073614791,
0.0013573018,
-0.0229520239,
0.0425810516,
-0.0471231677,
-0.0276596863,
0.002610825,
-0.0754531622,
0.0189752597,
-0.0333314724,
-0.0571609139,
0.008039183,
-0.0568614937,
-0.0118627287,
-0.0064104428,
-0.0358286239,
-0.0118429409,
0.05671224,
0.0029571184,
0.0405907631,
-0.0483058803,
0.0162962098,
0.0466940403,
-0.0022194136,
0.0335692465,
0.0387868658,
0.0458193757,
-0.0532625802,
-0.0562830456,
0.0527475961,
-0.0441104285,
-0.0513841622,
-0.0218224972,
0.0626670942,
0.02153318,
0.0067391302,
-0.0181715675,
0.0139786201,
-0.0215812977,
0.0057024891,
0.0376304872,
0.0890165567,
-0.0051226737,
-0.0226567574,
-0.0461440943,
-0.0123514822,
0.0072877109,
0.044406455,
0.0014193418,
-0.0822465047,
-0.0261881389,
-0.0594147108,
0.0158947408,
-0.0281087738,
-0.018276643,
0.0449270643,
-0.0571253113,
-0.0656442493,
-0.0327749103,
-0.017919315,
0.0358989239,
0.000089417,
-0.0144524537,
-0.0485164449,
0.0293183886,
0.0193125587,
-0.0782229006,
-0.0252361447,
0.0084996158,
0.0202860907,
-0.0445175469,
-0.0304149445,
0.0336996503,
-0.0226340089,
-0.0427794829,
-0.0452390946,
-0.0228293706,
-0.0219783597,
0.0123818582,
0.0126148444,
0.0168770328,
-0.0153666018,
0.0117648868,
-0.0374520607,
0.039514076,
0.0647940263,
-0.0195176024,
-0.0011624938,
0.0235770084,
0.0268464163,
-0.0277551599,
0.0003650129,
-0.0311191548,
0.0402823836,
0.0120702991,
-0.0127622057,
-0.0237584412,
-0.0499532893,
0.0063309632,
0.039685376,
0.069798626,
0.0191905126,
-0.03315657,
0.0023910168,
0.0168361869,
0.0501895286,
-0.0252498481,
0.0012101395,
-0.0188282765,
0.001083441,
-0.0242056604,
-0.0136228632,
0.0342129767,
-0.0163614303,
0.0236388594,
-0.0248852726,
0.0365362018,
0.0257822052,
0.0538898483,
0.0015895753,
-0.0141729079,
-0.0333124697,
-0.0149931703,
0.0812562332,
0.0546686724,
-0.009770317,
0.0506635755,
0.0051908838,
0.0298687238,
0.0483956896,
-0.0153053906,
-0.066232495,
-0.0102504417,
-0.0320817679,
-0.0028509556,
-0.0694116727,
0.0494033508,
-0.0172239151,
0.0113598062,
-0.0413297266,
-0.0227231197,
0.0080585917,
0.0153110987,
-0.0202138182,
0.0609089993,
-0.0092788963,
-0.0240975786,
-0.0072352281,
0.0144689465,
0.0443966649,
0.0059006307,
-0.0416774079,
-0.0450303853,
-0.054050196,
0.0099539375,
0.0244001877,
-0.0033766753,
0.0097557772,
-0.0038101065,
-0.0401557423,
-0.0183761809,
0.0329968594,
-0.0275913086,
0.0376930721,
-0.0223716144,
0.03711503,
0.0309103765,
0.0009434207,
-0.0189920384,
-0.0308252592,
0.0192951933,
-0.013616317,
-0.0127251185,
-0.0119483294,
-6.010411349e-33,
-0.012539614,
-0.0499072,
-0.0159935243,
-0.0397965685,
0.0074926205,
-0.0136470385,
-0.0062787058,
0.012276791,
-0.0505647287,
-0.0170830488,
0.0079529891,
-0.0098212874,
0.0172400661,
0.0335939974,
0.0490410402,
-0.0355600752,
0.0246947054,
-0.0196425971,
-0.032840278,
0.0166789927,
0.0192781966,
-0.0080185235,
0.0367931649,
-0.0892068371,
0.027553305,
0.0208926629,
0.0115898419,
0.0152772851,
0.0327492952,
0.0486701168,
0.016757464,
0.0560739525,
0.0324533731,
-0.0620102361,
0.0345161669,
0.0994634181,
-0.0937530175,
-0.0608072057,
-0.0458445512,
0.025640469,
-0.007181135,
-0.0008269593,
0.0336029381,
-0.0024185714,
0.0027736316,
-0.0294571687,
0.0842355713,
-0.0020211879,
-0.0042178682,
-0.0536079146,
-0.0095736841,
-0.0039454116,
-0.0221923981,
-0.0029252984,
-0.0532394387,
0.1298516095,
0.0060815872,
0.0339719132,
-0.0123022674,
0.031637162,
0.0279607661,
-0.0226447694,
0.0027205006,
0.0053421278,
-0.0273215827,
0.0053818412,
0.0478025153,
-0.0011668317,
-0.0082133338,
-0.0550073013,
0.0096910037,
-0.0151972873,
0.0603559129,
0.0393711813,
0.0130859967,
0.0084855612,
-0.0592719167,
0.0542287864,
0.0379840322,
-0.0518687814,
0.0148984203,
-0.0116906352,
-0.00036285,
-0.0437072888,
-0.0404941477,
0.0106317736,
-0.0490850471,
0.012388506,
0.0443483256,
-0.0301009286,
-0.0383848622,
0.0098522371,
0.0544550233,
-0.0300566163,
-0.0109483376,
-0.0092729749,
-0.0039495099,
0.047628738,
-0.0018240743,
0.0188238025,
-0.0378090851,
-0.0038082805,
0.0203710999,
0.0069390978,
0.014351313,
0.0030512342,
0.0192407165,
0.0017230366,
-0.0991115198,
-0.0260578003,
0.0167432148,
-0.0119917877,
0.0062385695,
0.0391888469,
-0.0143213049,
0.0171548482,
0.0377342626,
0.0337361135,
0.0128567219,
0.011329473,
-0.0541049428,
-0.0326875784,
0.0159408432,
0.0013534829,
-0.0281674322,
-0.0007350015,
-0.0058916938,
0.0292025749,
-0.0301537775,
-0.0186050348,
-0.0163001921,
-0.0161918923,
2.523e-7,
0.0881962925,
0.040340025,
-0.0318823867,
-0.0067556202,
-0.000171267,
0.0500615872,
0.0425480641,
0.047351975,
0.0232903287,
-0.0027657228,
0.0067767156,
-0.0586077236,
0.0027832789,
0.0580177754,
-0.0726347938,
-0.0613277629,
-0.0278264359,
0.0332994983,
-0.0517964214,
0.0789415613,
0.1070492193,
0.0800823048,
0.0308593512,
-0.0072903624,
-0.0418352596,
0.0062459442,
0.0247806869,
0.0218192767,
0.0238403324,
0.0237490982,
-0.0122353258,
0.0299755279,
0.021639755,
0.0655910149,
-0.0198494811,
-0.007396678,
0.0097887693,
0.0288108774,
-0.0184169412,
-0.0756457597,
0.0407751538,
-0.0060741906,
-0.0103287883,
-0.0426008664,
0.0635412782,
-0.0647034049,
-0.0235695038,
0.035769973,
-0.0309053678,
-0.0096125901,
0.0570920482,
-0.0226488151,
-0.0119829774,
0.0047088722,
0.013249076,
-0.016592579,
0.0121432254,
-0.0412623286,
0.0119642308,
0.0311693661,
-0.0405351073,
-0.0719790831,
0.0072515588,
0.0396136567,
0.0120999338,
-0.0602522641,
0.013553828,
2.2033473e-34,
0.0142727615,
-0.0096636936,
-0.0175420623,
-0.0130260736,
0.0129112154,
-0.0358447805,
0.0077228751,
-0.0053948076,
0.0360669754,
-0.0561622418,
-0.0146335978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02901v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02901v1
|
SpanRE: Entities and Overlapping Relations Extraction Based on Spans and Entity Attention
| 2023-04-06T07:19:39 | 2023-04-06T07:19:39 |
Hao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting entities and relations is an essential task of information
extraction. Triplets extracted from a sentence might overlap with each other.
Previous methods either did not address the overlapping issues or solved
overlapping issues partially. To tackle triplet overlapping problems
completely, firstly we extract candidate subjects with a standard span
mechanism. Then we present a labeled span mechanism to extract the objects and
relations simultaneously, we use the labeled span mechanism to generate labeled
spans whose start and end positions indicate the objects, and whose labels
correspond to relations of subject and objects. Besides, we design an entity
attention mechanism to enhance the information fusion between subject and
sentence during extracting objects and relations. We test our method on two
public datasets, our method achieves the best performances on these two
datasets.
|
[
0.0463744104,
0.0229745395,
0.012479037,
0.0785564557,
-0.0164002776,
0.0121382093,
-0.0240271632,
-0.0118189799,
0.0055900495,
-0.0438650101,
-0.004408862,
0.0134180691,
-0.0255691465,
-0.0065461695,
0.0102153467,
-0.0982440785,
0.0388608016,
0.0609719455,
0.0328840725,
0.0475274585,
0.0367957838,
0.0020355054,
-0.0254570451,
-0.0308372006,
-0.0572918989,
0.008858826,
-0.0075449776,
-0.0043964791,
0.0830731764,
-0.029731486,
0.0287636258,
0.0395363085,
-0.0311860628,
-0.0203350056,
0.0000016535,
-0.0425661877,
-0.0349132717,
0.0026264191,
0.0043498934,
-0.0361638702,
-0.0106933061,
-0.0133860828,
0.0181269944,
-0.0211532936,
-0.0341976061,
-0.035406556,
0.0255009346,
0.0961532965,
0.0464174785,
0.0675881729,
-0.0422740839,
-0.0014517824,
0.0142840194,
-0.0204515979,
0.0240353793,
-0.0648688227,
0.033099357,
-0.0360711403,
-0.0056915581,
0.0386916399,
0.009981038,
0.0281531438,
0.0256862622,
0.0247545801,
0.0298379865,
0.0500983857,
-0.0941841677,
-0.0305630621,
-0.0145164533,
0.1234900877,
-0.0027506647,
0.0366417728,
0.0342658311,
0.0197874717,
0.0139727099,
-0.0340397023,
-0.0178887695,
-0.0019114861,
-0.0314887688,
0.0061217304,
-0.009375982,
0.0271221921,
-0.0082217101,
-0.0080049383,
-0.0378185548,
0.0055790832,
0.0171638075,
-0.0324943736,
0.0200867243,
0.0596976541,
0.0058060121,
-0.0291081015,
0.0501021147,
0.0217514541,
-0.0034021926,
0.0204814393,
-0.0565092526,
-0.0631899759,
-0.0197642315,
-0.0257840641,
-0.0366373546,
-0.0127648208,
-0.0507824421,
0.0645359382,
-0.0137265129,
0.0102992756,
-0.0439864397,
0.0073630684,
-0.0347033478,
-0.0097582452,
-0.0136034284,
0.0209544189,
-0.0425147749,
0.0573624037,
-0.0369645357,
-0.022272639,
-0.0219816323,
0.0026845129,
0.0029713348,
0.0009821161,
-0.012463796,
0.0219488181,
-0.008918725,
-0.0008791576,
0.0120594287,
0.0194490105,
-0.0704975203,
-0.0032510327,
0.0166429002,
-0.0166087206,
-0.0266557094,
0.0106500629,
0.061064817,
-0.0519230515,
-0.026694864,
0.0470879748,
0.0049711745,
-0.0515452027,
-0.012673011,
-0.0249790233,
-0.0129237855,
-0.0405002348,
0.0020112402,
-0.0290073752,
0.0796981901,
0.0002667439,
-0.0256201327,
0.0168871135,
0.0476200171,
-0.0014101649,
-0.0469698571,
0.0640734136,
-0.0281027276,
-0.0071592922,
-0.0075810757,
0.0239416119,
0.0637477338,
0.0496573821,
0.0314994492,
0.0171805564,
0.0396695584,
0.025960248,
-0.005611557,
0.0255398341,
0.0443739481,
-0.0463533886,
0.0191166066,
0.0161571503,
-0.0024606369,
-0.0182865448,
0.0369851366,
0.0349378623,
-0.0176384989,
-0.0082323868,
0.0291565377,
0.0163882952,
-0.0292163994,
0.0451154187,
0.0018360625,
0.0020092367,
0.001503436,
0.0570679493,
-0.0522187389,
0.0211855117,
0.0147303259,
0.0127571151,
0.002580971,
0.0356968269,
-0.0001377004,
0.0000677172,
0.0087697366,
-0.0242606141,
-0.0248757061,
0.0243176445,
0.0533993281,
0.0239124838,
-0.0255342405,
0.1362408102,
0.0397409797,
-0.0467160828,
-0.0236849692,
0.0283343736,
-0.0247312393,
0.0220312029,
-0.00124752,
-0.0618266352,
-0.039127063,
0.0030778833,
0.0201762337,
0.0193133429,
0.0072480664,
0.0111403037,
0.0345192663,
-0.0105342865,
-0.0424931757,
0.0136206504,
-0.0330744497,
0.0074306889,
0.0424682759,
0.0264396165,
0.0249543078,
0.015163241,
0.0370403863,
0.0416814163,
0.0196295585,
0.0093140928,
-0.0108607048,
0.0488923267,
0.0381578095,
0.0337411202,
0.0102505106,
-0.0017467092,
0.0494745523,
-0.0360625274,
-0.0053278757,
0.0025497812,
-0.0424544029,
-0.0770434216,
0.0139804808,
-0.0329951458,
-0.0588842332,
-0.0241074432,
-0.029124707,
-0.0240031797,
-0.026725281,
-0.0282600764,
0.026070511,
0.0052422974,
0.0103645977,
0.0623564944,
0.0172393825,
-0.0693059117,
0.1035155356,
-0.0058269543,
0.0042498522,
-0.0018267212,
-0.0447768718,
0.0025905513,
-0.0250546094,
0.0012615746,
0.0169433411,
-0.0041415426,
-0.027871944,
0.0091650076,
0.0116158864,
-0.081297569,
-0.0518234409,
-0.048138421,
0.0269720796,
-0.0068238862,
0.060618937,
0.012848842,
0.0444076173,
-0.0061241235,
-0.0223746747,
-0.0430107005,
-0.0019038251,
-0.045960363,
-0.0228221864,
0.0527971424,
0.0383074693,
-0.0069091059,
-0.0475078374,
0.0065975511,
-0.0490802974,
0.0210572034,
0.019526016,
-0.0597491786,
-0.0247783754,
0.0428679809,
-0.0094617344,
0.0547033027,
0.0146481795,
-0.0053142011,
-0.0061738905,
-0.0084185703,
0.0411172323,
0.0614360608,
-0.0052154399,
0.0686720237,
-0.0126719866,
-0.0186628476,
-0.0342331044,
0.0744493976,
-0.0394858569,
0.0661114901,
0.0040743393,
0.0139739886,
0.0370338298,
0.0423367806,
-0.0065896348,
0.014972249,
-0.0066174869,
-0.0255959556,
0.040684741,
-0.0045812847,
-0.0091634328,
0.0518640243,
-0.0336730741,
0.0007847335,
-0.0906278491,
0.0295384973,
0.0774489641,
-0.0069840308,
-0.0392878614,
-0.0312484726,
0.0417341366,
-0.0666442364,
0.0506074429,
-0.0012808215,
0.0238265973,
-0.0215796474,
-0.0651334673,
-0.018368341,
0.0289249476,
-0.0000559107,
-0.0070563117,
0.0145989181,
-0.0048229182,
0.0188070815,
-0.0319643132,
-0.034952037,
-0.0445954017,
-0.0207977444,
0.0069410093,
-0.0328021497,
-0.050946001,
0.0072341668,
-0.0427891985,
-0.012910042,
0.0054024509,
0.010362572,
-0.0033180141,
0.0109406766,
-0.0250324644,
0.1016713306,
0.0311845187,
0.0182146057,
-0.0400604084,
0.0048284703,
0.0003740903,
0.0696732998,
-0.0086387303,
0.0283687077,
0.0143356528,
0.0039018085,
0.0266656149,
-0.0421823077,
0.0128480475,
-0.0310648847,
0.0319377631,
-0.0581827983,
0.0131009147,
0.0845619813,
0.0272110254,
-0.0103032328,
-0.0201685149,
0.0536854453,
0.0036481435,
0.018805949,
0.028901089,
-0.0870109573,
-0.0134471757,
-0.0097203441,
-0.0283951033,
0.0269072168,
-0.0423884131,
-0.0089171436,
-0.0886147544,
0.0094436426,
-0.0165336952,
-0.0808670595,
-0.0155676659,
-0.0146113029,
0.0521152727,
0.0059150415,
-0.0039435383,
-0.0082131308,
-0.0011911467,
-0.0055316687,
-0.022915123,
0.0328914821,
-0.0537513606,
-0.0057584224,
-0.0418295301,
0.0044278502,
0.0300874412,
0.038174957,
-0.0032290104,
-0.0062453086,
0.0070447926,
-0.0350551642,
-0.0549333394,
0.0084951483,
0.0849071965,
-0.0531293862,
-0.0461757667,
-0.0560824983,
0.0120018255,
-0.0428300537,
-0.0129099758,
0.0233084112,
0.0433618873,
0.0229746159,
-0.0092596393,
-0.016419623,
-0.0211841594,
0.0163534507,
0.0599768385,
0.0385247618,
-0.0087178657,
-0.0113727907,
0.0142185241,
-0.0026494542,
-0.0701953992,
-0.026249906,
0.0331468657,
-0.0455767736,
-0.0694884509,
-0.0492377058,
-0.0770406723,
0.0490599498,
0.0071919034,
-0.0029547298,
0.0117813731,
0.0444643013,
0.0092585655,
-0.0305169336,
0.0332023427,
-0.0078258086,
-0.0119031407,
-0.0067419335,
-0.0020757834,
-0.0095212972,
0.0048595937,
-0.0145301986,
-0.0004460676,
-0.0613229945,
-0.032183256,
0.0045719324,
0.0091548627,
0.0092836907,
0.0334184095,
-0.0441087149,
-0.004493929,
-0.0369045101,
0.0147827072,
-0.0625651777,
-0.0161267351,
-0.0063627041,
0.0057858983,
-0.0045412588,
0.0261785034,
-0.0254147444,
0.0356692299,
-0.0019588829,
0.0452102683,
-0.0829317048,
-0.0498152599,
0.0209053662,
-0.0035467865,
0.0816577598,
0.0012121251,
0.0089511098,
-0.0254998524,
0.0304286685,
-0.018942982,
-0.0159316603,
-0.0446155556,
0.0198726747,
-0.0100194765,
-0.0166163575,
0.0109873461,
-0.0015103321,
0.0055167261,
-0.0373331346,
-0.0342333019,
0.0197952371,
-0.0068810321,
-0.0012099057,
0.0145824449,
0.002875135,
-0.0180962998,
0.0186664201,
0.0116919335,
0.0218231156,
-0.0294983387,
0.0113571435,
0.0260848086,
-0.0497832261,
-0.0026473065,
0.0138760516,
-0.0382245742,
0.1026420146,
-0.0304667074,
0.0370311216,
0.0220323019,
-0.0239036176,
0.0490496494,
0.0369889587,
-0.0178462677,
0.0296145156,
0.0328444541,
-0.0292179249,
-0.009444098,
-0.0043947757,
0.0182974488,
-0.0160967652,
-0.0320729949,
0.0439884476,
-0.0107074333,
0.0102073317,
0.0346733443,
-0.0193969179,
-0.0613355525,
-0.0143781435,
0.0031514782,
-0.0123538859,
0.0029802227,
0.0183405709,
-0.0333856642,
-0.0131082879,
0.0089270212,
-0.031928964,
-0.0354693606,
0.0028691308,
0.0357434414,
0.0207705721,
-0.0006447158,
-0.048365321,
-0.0164445452,
0.0299817938,
-0.011740515,
-0.0518661626,
-0.0247761775,
-5.793097341e-33,
-0.0646093339,
-0.0464632623,
-0.012837545,
0.0276416466,
-0.0772453249,
0.0409643799,
-0.0535346158,
-0.0101215988,
-0.0102077788,
0.0092678173,
0.0040996815,
0.0129614063,
0.0342849977,
0.0139828604,
-0.0240697488,
-0.0336752795,
0.0044540907,
0.0386488736,
0.0131457457,
0.0092223026,
0.0107979774,
0.0790488869,
0.0689597055,
-0.1199424118,
0.0211947989,
-0.011107658,
0.0181376059,
0.0159458611,
0.0499639772,
0.0533574522,
0.0046750051,
0.0221715719,
0.037489865,
-0.0342562646,
0.0050372127,
0.061042279,
-0.1621334404,
-0.0455591939,
-0.0121714119,
0.0254212935,
-0.0494497679,
-0.0470974706,
0.0259823371,
-0.0166016724,
0.0876789913,
-0.0436965637,
0.0529641137,
-0.0154160596,
-0.0046616015,
-0.0185900051,
-0.0336049199,
0.0271946676,
-0.0146375671,
0.0307931937,
0.0397573709,
-0.0051771635,
0.0328602679,
0.0118920701,
-0.0162677616,
-0.0175051093,
-0.0078232568,
0.0176102445,
-0.0045297369,
0.0327414013,
-0.0471405499,
0.065803811,
0.0037120546,
-0.0328513458,
-0.0284937657,
0.0021704773,
-0.0232598986,
0.1045859903,
-0.0150276264,
0.0217366423,
-0.0320099145,
0.0320105515,
-0.0684440434,
0.0230928492,
-0.0010559305,
0.0378148481,
-0.0366439521,
-0.0363082141,
-0.0417740308,
0.0196912605,
0.0395401008,
0.0311802384,
-0.0268539116,
0.007551488,
0.0326687507,
0.005769833,
-0.0307160728,
0.0479153357,
-0.0061790971,
-0.0016805538,
-0.0149287591,
-0.0013206464,
0.0251039248,
0.0202390738,
-0.0129815144,
0.0050971806,
-0.0338930637,
-0.0376745574,
0.0026517923,
0.0288722869,
0.0129524749,
-0.0015253682,
0.0668746755,
-0.0686768964,
-0.0424820036,
-0.0094714677,
-0.0347470231,
-0.0135156661,
-0.0559963249,
0.0444278009,
0.0191317257,
0.0096356496,
-0.0237928927,
0.0362273045,
0.0415268131,
0.0306167752,
-0.048888512,
0.006200071,
0.0294505209,
0.0371131822,
0.0101572704,
-0.0024655398,
-0.0257774498,
-0.0027071575,
0.0247543305,
-0.0193934329,
0.0008244309,
-0.0062460173,
2.403e-7,
0.0386429988,
-0.0050208229,
0.0772620514,
0.0130462609,
-0.0163385533,
0.0050967447,
0.0149286911,
0.0813750699,
-0.036736913,
-0.0234988667,
-0.0005808654,
0.0108349947,
-0.0037294941,
0.0126655763,
-0.0903730318,
-0.0520359315,
-0.0036426838,
-0.0767304897,
-0.0502542369,
-0.0022799831,
0.1029238105,
0.0583458878,
0.0343298316,
0.0441750251,
-0.0280369371,
-0.0179049596,
0.0219807085,
0.0059724706,
-0.0029702524,
0.044794485,
0.0009593329,
0.0231248643,
-0.0282166842,
0.0323425829,
-0.0057763522,
0.0306905471,
0.0317541845,
0.0752801821,
-0.0224792082,
-0.0220726319,
-0.0043970947,
-0.0455208384,
0.0042485041,
0.0113205332,
0.0524992347,
-0.0359409787,
-0.0280668903,
0.0133439638,
-0.0191927236,
0.0308354534,
-0.0193665009,
0.0289906673,
-0.0095500918,
0.0204201844,
0.0278109144,
-0.0478493422,
-0.0463724919,
-0.1103411764,
-0.0417756997,
0.0130119929,
-0.0116760097,
0.0035915591,
-0.0025962405,
-0.022552738,
0.0229899958,
-0.0603282675,
-0.0199004505,
2.065795635e-34,
-0.0372766629,
0.0302697308,
0.0006685989,
0.0573191792,
0.0252682958,
-0.0681811646,
-0.0845539719,
0.0114606945,
-0.0145080555,
-0.0355184376,
0.0178523436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02894v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02894v2
|
Affect as a proxy for literary mood
| 2023-04-06T06:53:23 | 2023-05-23T08:09:23 |
Emily Öhman, Riikka Rossi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose to use affect as a proxy for mood in literary texts. In this
study, we explore the differences in computationally detecting tone versus
detecting mood. Methodologically we utilize affective word embeddings to look
at the affective distribution in different text segments. We also present a
simple yet efficient and effective method of enhancing emotion lexicons to take
both semantic shift and the domain of the text into account producing
real-world congruent results closely matching both contemporary and modern
qualitative analyses.
|
[
0.0211007036,
0.0426151119,
-0.0354808383,
0.0353945345,
-0.0342772715,
-0.0040647658,
-0.008937872,
-0.0047023427,
0.0180092286,
-0.0275453702,
0.0066685472,
0.0085168034,
0.0018523511,
0.0005267406,
-0.0091177896,
-0.0715003237,
0.002848444,
0.060787145,
0.028905103,
0.0147659788,
0.024790287,
0.0370214246,
0.02276114,
-0.0059328903,
0.0107321981,
-0.0207709316,
0.0026576493,
0.0167282317,
0.017844798,
-0.0077188471,
0.0218006521,
-0.013454821,
0.0215469841,
-0.0330497399,
0.0000018837,
-0.0015982169,
0.0092650689,
-0.0482866652,
0.0505746715,
0.0110017927,
0.1278835684,
-0.0179623086,
-0.0113374153,
-0.0124789597,
-0.0122453244,
-0.0181826651,
0.024547115,
0.0302534774,
0.0206169877,
0.0904346555,
-0.0326464698,
-0.0064780097,
-0.0309882853,
0.034643054,
0.0235178005,
0.0336074233,
0.0204492304,
-0.0084297899,
0.0288649257,
-0.0418003276,
-0.0749450028,
-0.0112801883,
-0.0267628115,
0.0315482058,
0.012994417,
0.0097524216,
-0.0129846875,
0.0519589335,
-0.0208054911,
0.0135766426,
-0.0070869504,
0.0170387346,
-0.0125106294,
-0.0036917329,
-0.0034368453,
0.010291717,
-0.0046945182,
-0.0299563352,
0.0089879632,
0.0246297698,
0.050302621,
0.0709898025,
0.018240463,
0.0173290912,
-0.01930237,
0.0415641777,
-0.0110574113,
-0.0402064025,
0.003122688,
-0.0173278581,
-0.040431045,
0.0103038205,
0.0309496112,
-0.0303842053,
0.0541391782,
0.0088686254,
-0.0270002969,
-0.042572353,
-0.0372810811,
-0.0528614894,
-0.0285561942,
0.0142269991,
-0.0273226146,
0.0153857758,
0.0300842617,
-0.0258892011,
0.0575180799,
-0.063391827,
-0.0394530222,
0.0113148941,
-0.0155745251,
0.0446258374,
-0.0068717711,
-0.0019595707,
-0.0247314796,
-0.0442073122,
-0.0554512553,
-0.0335394964,
0.0186881758,
-0.0158297382,
0.0166912619,
0.0210672822,
0.0149875609,
-0.0002720876,
0.0325456411,
0.0114739882,
-0.0840984583,
0.027571274,
-0.0571264774,
0.0025688184,
0.0180353094,
0.0180061813,
0.0200320985,
-0.0340421423,
0.0196159482,
0.0596945956,
0.0770747662,
-0.0508909971,
-0.06741032,
-0.0254671425,
-0.0088611273,
-0.0132952314,
-0.0120070353,
-0.0023269639,
0.0300437119,
-0.0095159253,
0.0250181612,
-0.0079245763,
0.0018961721,
-0.0066204602,
-0.0386769623,
0.0361139849,
-0.0154503761,
-0.030218564,
-0.0356093496,
-0.0018658307,
-0.0221440997,
0.0297810324,
0.0563313439,
0.0125825321,
0.0666004047,
-0.0071896622,
0.0080994545,
-0.0019205158,
-0.0477421544,
-0.0343910828,
0.0090339622,
-0.0687057525,
-0.0408472493,
0.0823184922,
0.0121706752,
0.0154494634,
-0.0198417362,
-0.0402572751,
0.0207802337,
0.0593590364,
0.0015040012,
0.060924843,
-0.0203772988,
0.0021816215,
0.0134248938,
0.0279623326,
0.0065006088,
0.0078978492,
-0.0331663303,
-0.0137391388,
-0.048598554,
0.0160892699,
0.0150794778,
-0.0156766921,
-0.0410524048,
0.0047278148,
0.0347735025,
-0.0198399331,
0.0372398533,
-0.0090050409,
-0.0038085971,
-0.0671512112,
0.0625256449,
-0.0864688382,
0.0011034597,
0.0452377088,
0.0023900345,
0.0840276554,
0.0412853695,
-0.0482451208,
0.0439493768,
-0.0069666067,
0.0115290452,
0.0094552888,
-0.0034870785,
0.0068076523,
0.0214514658,
-0.0766483024,
0.0444901697,
-0.0392291583,
0.0109541882,
-0.0046716547,
-0.0505019277,
0.04778409,
-0.0288337804,
-0.00993698,
-0.0206768736,
0.0185519736,
-0.0455971882,
-0.0477813557,
0.0124586588,
0.0281422846,
-0.0149891507,
0.0196680408,
-0.0258860346,
-0.0120771499,
-0.004140316,
-0.0487798564,
-0.021707464,
0.0546648949,
-0.0037540002,
-0.0232071783,
0.0188056137,
-0.0449528359,
0.0314677693,
-0.0203782041,
-0.0245761871,
-0.0124802757,
0.0630391687,
-0.0015038098,
0.054788623,
0.0061574732,
0.0053531919,
-0.0229654498,
0.0767992809,
-0.017355727,
0.0148964319,
0.0050740298,
0.0147495456,
-0.0244752951,
-0.0189970862,
-0.0108664325,
0.0508579426,
-0.0678992271,
-0.0046748426,
0.0925571769,
0.0153355757,
-0.0133475699,
-0.0599849373,
-0.0389095768,
-0.0605056658,
-0.0710639656,
0.0089709358,
-0.00491681,
0.0065337964,
0.0112103485,
-0.0003000996,
-0.0320307575,
0.0432196669,
-0.0245697517,
0.0118945288,
-0.0299484469,
0.0158751588,
0.0086437548,
-0.0422779769,
0.0382902361,
-0.0655935258,
0.0042491071,
-0.0371629968,
0.0461787842,
-0.0078683812,
-0.0106964111,
-0.0123093929,
0.0343754925,
-0.0189700909,
-0.0000121516,
-0.0004030286,
-0.0616661869,
-0.0283022746,
-0.0128679937,
0.013857183,
0.0622117296,
-0.0070250859,
0.0894697234,
0.0252860039,
-0.0503300019,
-0.0041281423,
0.017807683,
0.0062063774,
0.0682808459,
-0.0144908037,
-0.0499423742,
-0.0303146411,
0.0168829653,
0.0275764167,
-0.022922473,
-0.0024861458,
0.0388967432,
-0.0239330363,
-0.0068675899,
0.0186477397,
-0.0026964997,
-0.0019007962,
-0.0183340367,
0.0224792324,
-0.002133765,
0.025509242,
0.0496060848,
-0.0015438916,
-0.0980293602,
-0.0164790452,
-0.0165867005,
0.0119329486,
-0.0678114742,
0.0140925003,
-0.0094892355,
0.0129658878,
-0.0203239843,
-0.0277805757,
0.0152807543,
-0.0464586504,
-0.0007914304,
-0.0065921787,
-0.0650331452,
0.0379689895,
-0.0114225866,
0.015235316,
-0.0416122824,
-0.0669326782,
-0.0028222816,
0.0304364283,
-0.0535126477,
0.0135662435,
-0.0281421114,
-0.0109034749,
-0.0590490513,
-0.0041987551,
-0.0462829322,
0.0353250243,
-0.0014814489,
0.0464851856,
-0.0151763158,
0.0464134999,
0.0158825759,
0.0181830451,
0.0271775443,
-0.0500427149,
-0.0113619072,
-0.0311771277,
0.042577073,
0.0260241851,
-0.0597807243,
-0.0278771669,
-0.0469094217,
-0.0383352004,
-0.0498985313,
0.0245401263,
0.108400546,
0.0249911379,
-0.0415635705,
0.0160289407,
-0.0437052213,
-0.033535745,
0.0338694304,
0.0173579101,
0.0051393113,
-0.0219712742,
0.005564061,
0.0342347547,
0.0003623468,
-0.0403815806,
0.0066476571,
-0.0577472001,
0.0013691413,
0.0347700939,
0.037375506,
0.0161474366,
-0.0152276559,
0.0150131602,
0.0087979389,
-0.0313501842,
-0.0726084039,
0.0105281137,
0.0082883714,
-0.023952214,
0.0080642309,
0.0195750985,
0.0231970772,
-0.0365183428,
0.0480525605,
0.0240625404,
0.1380842328,
-0.0267630573,
-0.0391491577,
-0.0296664964,
-0.0099721504,
-0.0163442008,
0.0059337146,
0.0626410171,
-0.0367920734,
-0.005527168,
-0.026810959,
0.0298387129,
-0.0291078389,
-0.0128313331,
0.0394266471,
0.0501813442,
-0.0017692639,
-0.0334333591,
-0.0589986816,
0.0385091417,
0.0455702804,
0.022639988,
-0.0041793706,
-0.0660307035,
0.0047450457,
-0.0131890094,
0.0315564796,
0.0142947175,
-0.0731507763,
-0.0362920016,
-0.0044547138,
0.0149743389,
-0.0676840693,
-0.0544837527,
0.0069422764,
0.047230158,
0.0316311345,
-0.0228794664,
-0.0116369352,
-0.0091690794,
-0.046442274,
-0.0163082425,
0.0472387522,
0.0406540036,
0.0445550568,
0.0042235511,
0.0569444299,
-0.0265361555,
0.0268829148,
-0.0525244921,
0.0076122768,
-0.0278401282,
0.026429778,
-0.026106298,
0.0047139139,
-0.0256634373,
-0.0279819667,
-0.034664508,
0.0367827974,
0.0174701028,
-0.021073034,
0.0428288765,
0.0455430523,
0.0463793091,
-0.0159497708,
0.0065285419,
0.003573033,
0.0266876351,
0.0075578461,
-0.0073327911,
0.0245892815,
-0.044469852,
-0.0259196796,
-0.0237865653,
0.0364933535,
-0.0195412058,
-0.0444844142,
-0.026945265,
-0.0489179231,
-0.0278954897,
-0.0345869027,
-0.000755151,
-0.0363911875,
-0.0048699519,
0.0102478815,
-0.0974398553,
0.0148299923,
0.0029680834,
-0.0186994765,
-0.000333458,
0.0543398373,
0.0429980308,
-0.0041940552,
-0.0448191315,
0.0389565788,
0.0063485927,
-0.0237215217,
-0.0094239619,
0.0144251706,
0.0155957583,
0.0080707436,
-0.0037661421,
-0.0227776021,
-0.0343068354,
0.0310269389,
-0.0447875448,
0.0672284216,
-0.0025928128,
0.005466762,
0.0034124018,
-0.0781441703,
0.0658242628,
-0.035081543,
0.0039635603,
-0.004514093,
0.0294271465,
-0.009929168,
-0.0050777053,
-0.0059535201,
0.0057983189,
-0.0200861339,
0.0169007946,
-0.0029309161,
-0.0973144993,
0.0632438436,
0.0687828809,
-0.0322285518,
0.004605792,
0.0028516941,
0.063077569,
-0.0088066561,
0.0540991388,
0.0395068042,
-0.0847872049,
-0.0291591883,
0.1012713239,
-0.0195863172,
0.0108224479,
-0.0305431746,
0.0043385061,
0.0400762595,
-0.00844453,
0.0645129159,
-0.0630757362,
0.0529646017,
-0.0952759013,
-0.0507059954,
-0.01566994,
-5.564328875e-33,
-0.0173697583,
0.0165106095,
-0.0656073093,
0.0498777665,
-0.0574894659,
0.0439232029,
0.0113784233,
0.0153996618,
0.0110234795,
0.0715995431,
-0.0526690483,
0.0319093838,
-0.0138071682,
-0.0029896549,
0.0418008454,
-0.0110549098,
0.0025630307,
-0.0180258676,
0.001562204,
-0.0112392846,
0.0434343815,
0.0246485677,
0.064203836,
-0.0820138007,
0.0034023349,
0.013267694,
0.0035962032,
-0.0477573872,
0.0667862818,
0.009510899,
0.0025871128,
0.0651658177,
-0.0043444489,
0.0648421049,
-0.0145015167,
-0.0071339253,
-0.0172294751,
-0.0600093007,
0.0079707485,
0.0221397784,
-0.014175741,
-0.0467738695,
-0.0071616503,
0.0409629159,
0.0042041242,
-0.0415517725,
0.0281243883,
-0.0159500986,
-0.0252514072,
-0.0805669129,
-0.0469712988,
0.0288718324,
-0.0061025638,
-0.0024745022,
0.0808355734,
-0.001208802,
0.032458365,
0.0241221022,
-0.0458896123,
-0.0184123442,
-0.0499921143,
0.0082321446,
-0.0504023507,
-0.0267219655,
0.0144098355,
0.0799282938,
0.0021355802,
-0.0050068675,
0.0005968451,
0.1055819318,
0.0355635248,
-0.0066296267,
0.0367277712,
0.0706418306,
0.0138165941,
-0.033155933,
0.0133221848,
0.0103297019,
0.0573461801,
-0.0015515748,
0.0656921118,
0.0085858712,
-0.0305727795,
-0.0229534321,
0.005391025,
-0.0335547626,
-0.0103590656,
-0.0386119261,
-0.0168695822,
-0.0394184217,
0.0098225279,
-0.0463608354,
-0.0356029123,
-0.0511937402,
-0.0266127735,
0.0325816311,
-0.0484549925,
0.0796138048,
0.0065452624,
0.0188104194,
0.0416513681,
0.0005236038,
-0.0046143886,
0.0449101776,
0.0525773279,
-0.0276341438,
0.0027557681,
0.0556827225,
-0.0333968438,
-0.0385143757,
-0.0041669775,
0.0047103893,
-0.0165824369,
0.0208341759,
-0.0505135991,
0.0065225423,
0.0106301988,
0.0203136206,
0.0248140376,
0.0505010523,
0.0068500596,
-0.0252487455,
0.0123148933,
0.0372831561,
-0.0546987057,
-0.0070479941,
0.0166977365,
-0.0337299407,
-0.0080126096,
-0.054790087,
-0.0041220393,
-0.0357065909,
2.798e-7,
0.0218395814,
0.0426643379,
0.0206939951,
0.0020365736,
0.0166183654,
0.0257773343,
-0.0105769848,
0.0368341804,
0.0165722333,
-0.0163742099,
0.0376781933,
-0.0097482791,
0.0398649573,
0.0345527492,
-0.0887115151,
0.0105136335,
0.0027269374,
0.0077614887,
-0.0265157782,
-0.0144987358,
0.1193849817,
0.0809169188,
0.0780133978,
0.0193219632,
0.0216421969,
0.0366761573,
-0.0247172955,
-0.0595872626,
0.0041112383,
0.008031317,
0.0067033283,
-0.0250248257,
0.0055941935,
-0.0238261707,
-0.0265249033,
0.0297088139,
0.0392408483,
0.0163698141,
0.0161797181,
-0.0265802294,
-0.0040042116,
-0.0204272904,
-0.0137165859,
0.0479008108,
0.0342124254,
0.0012598096,
-0.0122824237,
-0.0659736469,
-0.0317769125,
-0.014225143,
0.0848060995,
-0.0386139937,
-0.035893783,
0.0313436724,
0.0252843145,
0.0011359169,
-0.0280023981,
-0.1031708345,
0.016803164,
0.0351945199,
0.0055561815,
-0.0087110419,
0.0222349949,
0.0290469937,
0.027360728,
-0.066161491,
0.0088793933,
1.976193348e-34,
0.0354354233,
0.0072911847,
-0.0026624899,
0.0148933856,
0.0448689573,
0.0081288163,
-0.011103793,
-0.0398433022,
0.0506204329,
-0.037826173,
0.0034166973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02886v1
|
Automatic ICD-10 Code Association: A Challenging Task on French Clinical Texts
| 2023-04-06T06:31:54 | 2023-04-06T06:31:54 |
Yakini Tchouka, Jean-François Couchot, David Laiymani, Philippe Selles, Azzedine Rahmani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automatically associating ICD codes with electronic health data is a
well-known NLP task in medical research. NLP has evolved significantly in
recent years with the emergence of pre-trained language models based on
Transformers architecture, mainly in the English language. This paper adapts
these models to automatically associate the ICD codes. Several neural network
architectures have been experimented with to address the challenges of dealing
with a large set of both input tokens and labels to be guessed. In this paper,
we propose a model that combines the latest advances in NLP and multi-label
classification for ICD-10 code association. Fair experiments on a Clinical
dataset in the French language show that our approach increases the $F_1$-score
metric by more than 55\% compared to state-of-the-art results.
|
[
-0.0035308832,
0.053506732,
0.0169399343,
-0.0198881887,
-0.0267042536,
0.0067604552,
0.0276040751,
0.0304081682,
0.0226679202,
-0.0311304461,
-0.0238710772,
-0.0300465338,
0.0015276993,
0.0390761346,
-0.0085294433,
0.0167442095,
0.0573889948,
0.0332764499,
0.0130312573,
0.0094334101,
-0.0247643795,
0.013308743,
-0.0334801935,
0.0665912926,
-0.0387752503,
0.0068973396,
0.0469221771,
-0.0150361117,
0.0256329775,
-0.0814782232,
0.0008951885,
0.0525628328,
-0.0436437391,
0.0211270731,
0.0000014532,
-0.0579907596,
-0.0437045358,
0.0095656654,
-0.012190165,
-0.083456032,
0.0151440697,
-0.0524561182,
0.014313872,
-0.0049718977,
-0.0152078345,
-0.0578152537,
0.0789726675,
0.1065637842,
0.0345142037,
0.0713389441,
-0.0123946825,
-0.0282940473,
0.0230343379,
0.002148068,
-0.0077858474,
-0.0650006011,
0.0793509856,
-0.0105165755,
0.0246521421,
-0.0055594617,
0.0106003722,
0.0374322273,
0.0060292771,
0.0253314488,
0.0136099067,
0.0523751415,
-0.0503618419,
-0.0143365553,
-0.0036829354,
0.0611036122,
-0.0331058465,
-0.0109710116,
0.0070288144,
0.0059011388,
-0.0233653709,
-0.0393753946,
-0.0173594467,
-0.0566413961,
-0.0105594732,
0.0169692747,
0.0277388804,
0.019661095,
0.0406032428,
-0.014020293,
-0.029200485,
0.0114849349,
0.0071190009,
-0.0111259287,
0.027139619,
-0.0222967807,
-0.0341428407,
-0.0286269058,
0.0221538711,
0.0558436774,
-0.0121393176,
0.0149185136,
-0.0449677408,
-0.0263710227,
0.0449379422,
-0.0640396252,
-0.0273510925,
0.0113923969,
-0.004363325,
0.0258502588,
-0.0479228683,
0.0266845673,
-0.0129295411,
0.0673923343,
-0.0413260125,
-0.0060196137,
-0.0670743212,
-0.0019776789,
-0.0457667001,
0.0324755348,
0.0624267273,
-0.000031167,
-0.0892385244,
-0.0395210013,
0.0067608156,
0.0213860236,
0.0340223722,
0.0256740917,
0.0036976235,
0.0260008294,
-0.0158593878,
0.0051588784,
0.0026257799,
0.0065291631,
-0.0543273725,
-0.0191154405,
0.0333904773,
-0.0071277628,
0.0189015996,
-0.0278166011,
0.0390423574,
0.0605572462,
-0.0037251294,
-0.0351478904,
-0.017944999,
-0.0261176098,
-0.0071457997,
0.0283518452,
0.0247040223,
-0.0453950763,
0.0402949154,
0.0166332088,
0.0085798986,
-0.0750333369,
0.0246980414,
-0.0023811271,
-0.0617444292,
0.0863986909,
-0.0734481961,
-0.0174650643,
0.005043834,
0.0110438662,
0.0241414905,
0.0200932287,
0.0114007611,
-0.0664531365,
-0.0006240255,
-0.0199340302,
0.0279464517,
0.032231722,
0.0303032398,
-0.052827388,
0.0213036463,
-0.0013677289,
0.0231473055,
0.035254132,
-0.0225977115,
0.0558229871,
0.016278822,
-0.0397114493,
0.0074990792,
0.0320225582,
0.0405887216,
0.013005157,
-0.0304712728,
-0.0452869572,
-0.0166095309,
-0.0483789071,
-0.0127765127,
-0.0147249307,
0.0324623808,
0.0111550018,
-0.0045603393,
-0.0157165956,
-0.0313643068,
-0.0376312956,
-0.0294964854,
-0.0038237665,
-0.0019190456,
-0.0375738516,
0.0433756076,
0.0172322132,
-0.0116966898,
0.0647807941,
0.0105996132,
0.0081283804,
-0.0139031084,
-0.0527812727,
-0.0498342775,
0.0076189484,
0.0396161713,
-0.0568416528,
-0.0305830743,
-0.0249103792,
-0.0001450289,
0.0027646904,
-0.0008775136,
-0.0193854272,
0.0268296804,
-0.0259108059,
0.0266677942,
0.0764786899,
0.0133800032,
0.0057712044,
-0.0281922426,
-0.0037124616,
-0.0390748866,
0.0090196757,
-0.0164604057,
0.0589973405,
-0.0342965685,
-0.0412086546,
-0.0009779943,
0.0196200274,
0.0185358487,
0.030693708,
-0.0035335794,
0.0303946752,
0.0328186378,
-0.0262733921,
-0.042956885,
-0.0278998464,
-0.0173262767,
-0.0066449335,
0.047812067,
-0.0166924801,
-0.034049619,
-0.0054622991,
-0.0345748216,
-0.0026011954,
-0.0434196889,
-0.0258224551,
0.0547470078,
0.0132968239,
0.0323585905,
0.0368267596,
-0.0113738757,
-0.0422377028,
0.028860854,
-0.0240587369,
0.0759285837,
-0.0031839611,
-0.0148358718,
0.054923676,
0.0219139028,
-0.0137882829,
-0.0069807875,
-0.0672360957,
0.0211849436,
-0.0102743441,
0.0277158022,
-0.0048199873,
-0.0326345973,
-0.079274334,
-0.0170286056,
0.0093942527,
0.0009466404,
0.0327129848,
0.0019204392,
0.0142991859,
-0.0527102798,
-0.0477801301,
-0.0490353964,
0.0204991978,
0.0110125635,
0.0478088818,
0.0571122579,
-0.051376462,
0.0266842209,
0.0010171252,
-0.0697070137,
0.0393948667,
0.0412008502,
-0.0198512617,
-0.0165102221,
0.0363835953,
-0.0349794142,
0.0246866513,
-0.021281112,
-0.0389267355,
0.0173904151,
0.0371311493,
0.0106378002,
-0.0042713173,
-0.007811456,
-0.0055824644,
0.0141513646,
-0.0049094814,
0.0110841412,
0.00433427,
-0.0500166081,
-0.0289404336,
-0.0127683459,
-0.0402861014,
0.0025626118,
0.0787405968,
-0.0003314427,
-0.0181172788,
-0.0048131682,
-0.0050205728,
0.0082321754,
0.0342187695,
-0.0488363281,
-0.0082486449,
-0.0189895201,
0.0511811338,
0.034449257,
-0.0212068297,
0.0738590434,
-0.0217261408,
0.0254418999,
-0.0826317072,
-0.0356707685,
-0.0307527427,
0.0392129906,
-0.0120702013,
0.0324606076,
0.0568180792,
-0.0466972403,
0.0081682783,
0.0180414133,
-0.0523093157,
-0.0570046306,
0.0886064768,
0.0249045677,
0.0371664017,
0.0001624946,
-0.0564586185,
-0.0641580373,
-0.0085010473,
-0.0294572394,
0.0298353638,
0.0005867792,
-0.0120906094,
-0.074733153,
0.0504993759,
-0.0270038079,
0.0626493916,
0.0259803217,
-0.0103312405,
-0.004665053,
0.030521363,
0.0182325244,
-0.0263159089,
-0.0095473947,
-0.0033408299,
-0.0081187384,
0.0228927266,
0.0284468364,
0.0453606397,
-0.0225518718,
-0.0244940557,
0.0171758085,
-0.0497069694,
0.0092950743,
0.0170472562,
0.0053200591,
-0.0086261285,
-0.00098702,
0.1002160683,
0.0241746921,
-0.0922531188,
0.0147527782,
0.0192823559,
-0.042369999,
0.012843472,
0.0166121498,
-0.0235468242,
-0.0269382168,
0.0082434453,
-0.0285918415,
-0.0387811027,
-0.0417160541,
0.0115492754,
-0.0126151172,
-0.0272030588,
-0.0012697219,
-0.0520876311,
-0.0649118051,
-0.0650914535,
-0.0051081683,
-0.0122231236,
0.0047191051,
-0.0479392447,
0.0056100744,
-0.034141846,
-0.0126905497,
-0.0525588989,
-0.065572083,
0.0271259472,
-0.0325397477,
0.0604114085,
0.0692709759,
0.030325871,
-0.0455055982,
-0.0106331725,
0.0458525792,
0.0026076843,
-0.0151223289,
-0.01072386,
0.0933280438,
-0.0153550757,
-0.0163215194,
-0.0193047598,
-0.0158386622,
-0.0438620672,
-0.0295528211,
-0.0173479952,
0.0457857661,
-0.023054678,
0.018909622,
-0.0413044021,
-0.0003981731,
-0.0141031304,
0.0212954357,
-0.0231563393,
-0.024453396,
0.0238954537,
-0.0118942326,
0.0608665086,
-0.0117254714,
-0.0434515886,
0.0426008478,
-0.0779841617,
-0.0589190163,
-0.0336561427,
-0.0147317098,
0.0226248484,
0.000301556,
0.0360811763,
-0.0104765547,
0.033696536,
-0.0045890883,
-0.0444542505,
0.0612952821,
0.0218868945,
0.0132879401,
-0.0912795216,
0.001925847,
0.0655910671,
0.0052781194,
-0.0551038757,
0.0205759108,
-0.0342963748,
0.0047665937,
0.014583474,
0.0076475251,
0.0194447283,
0.0075194323,
-0.0273939036,
-0.0162612144,
-0.0133164665,
0.0622400232,
-0.0051430175,
-0.0491893068,
-0.0256490093,
-0.0441333018,
-0.012413118,
0.0021579345,
-0.034560658,
0.0635778457,
0.0247204583,
0.0322914943,
-0.0202059876,
-0.0111911613,
0.0354226492,
0.0417142399,
0.074007459,
-0.0123926066,
-0.0067390399,
-0.0152162397,
0.0337312371,
0.0114767719,
0.0082268585,
0.0237348378,
-0.0140153468,
0.0266087689,
0.0090264222,
-0.0320207737,
-0.0254867505,
-0.004788423,
-0.0348635428,
-0.0014795951,
0.0018263081,
0.0066714115,
0.0321653038,
0.0374925323,
-0.0272073653,
-0.0099270772,
0.0181461405,
0.052990213,
0.0366133898,
-0.0374790393,
0.0579839796,
0.0265744794,
0.042224735,
-0.0143352617,
0.0442897566,
-0.0416979678,
-0.0046169264,
-0.0360264853,
-0.0400137156,
0.0448145904,
0.012947903,
-0.024475554,
-0.0228260774,
0.0101711117,
-0.0358653478,
0.028968608,
-0.0191925913,
-0.0026218151,
0.0346929915,
0.004735759,
-0.0244403426,
-0.0224140678,
0.0628258437,
-0.0217552502,
0.0245368946,
0.0015697845,
-0.0509135202,
-0.0370654613,
0.0282893274,
0.0360400304,
0.0036247161,
-0.0610508658,
-0.0195651799,
-0.0439791977,
-0.0476773754,
0.0929762051,
-0.0267006531,
-0.0100419139,
0.0343864784,
0.0455108397,
0.0195273459,
0.0154894274,
-0.0127574913,
0.0132481689,
0.012048766,
-0.0119317854,
-0.045728378,
-0.0090212664,
-4.902933305e-33,
-0.001282215,
-0.0311688036,
0.0213404447,
-0.0064663561,
0.0021133479,
0.0154413227,
-0.0053362888,
-0.0122827291,
-0.0285851378,
-0.0015328244,
-0.0290648248,
-0.0192245711,
0.009005215,
0.0520348735,
-0.0172702055,
-0.0762821063,
0.0143010216,
0.0378307961,
-0.0114066936,
-0.0176638085,
-0.0110964291,
0.0648413152,
0.0436157696,
-0.1068685949,
-0.0024519293,
0.0077802204,
0.0210015401,
0.0265668929,
0.034102723,
0.0893447846,
-0.0448330007,
0.0284836963,
0.054380618,
0.0004476254,
0.0342574455,
0.0197778493,
-0.0821956694,
-0.0444397554,
-0.0363630392,
0.0162041094,
0.0173291229,
-0.0412475206,
0.0632130876,
-0.0100843087,
-0.0406316258,
0.034103509,
0.0495432355,
-0.0073469267,
-0.0110066719,
-0.0312941559,
-0.0320604034,
0.0275685377,
0.0216466095,
0.0105484435,
0.0076391818,
0.012167383,
-0.0046720584,
0.057985995,
-0.0651334077,
-0.0081996163,
-0.0286889803,
0.0439666882,
-0.0056834789,
-0.0272788461,
-0.0186847746,
0.0787547454,
0.0470530577,
-0.0244526807,
-0.0327853002,
-0.0027663792,
0.00338505,
0.0080803586,
0.0552707613,
0.0101453662,
0.0283795316,
-0.0371507481,
-0.0782262459,
0.0306409672,
-0.0314814821,
-0.0015352542,
0.0235790275,
-0.0271874685,
-0.0321611874,
0.0141724702,
-0.0409642272,
0.0255585238,
-0.0329796411,
-0.0339296199,
0.0302055087,
-0.0086203897,
0.0392711274,
0.0243163649,
0.0122373635,
-0.04870224,
-0.0266932622,
-0.0393437743,
0.0910354331,
0.0452627093,
-0.0533757173,
0.0274790432,
-0.0207145717,
-0.0239061546,
0.02365385,
-0.0258851722,
0.0529381298,
-0.0168905761,
0.0527185835,
-0.0360791013,
-0.0798713565,
-0.0172686093,
0.0458106063,
-0.0445531607,
-0.0028060195,
0.0344008841,
0.0281528085,
0.0443728305,
0.0172014795,
0.025883602,
0.028158417,
-0.0022773352,
-0.0264235586,
-0.0446849726,
0.018173784,
0.0006318562,
-0.0128019685,
-0.0329378061,
-0.0464524701,
0.0776641741,
-0.002115394,
-0.0621621199,
-0.0054281214,
0.0120976968,
2.322e-7,
0.111433737,
0.0418561921,
0.0243650191,
-0.0159996822,
0.0014683636,
0.0112276897,
-0.0004894329,
0.0186081287,
-0.0207559392,
0.0073609608,
0.0305399969,
-0.0479500815,
0.0155491875,
0.0478216596,
-0.0749009401,
-0.0453356877,
-0.0537361167,
0.0115783866,
-0.0116945067,
0.0073929601,
0.0376206525,
0.11984431,
-0.0163779631,
-0.0001822883,
-0.0163404662,
-0.0351187401,
0.0142658968,
-0.0163542517,
0.0196839031,
0.0438364111,
-0.0288795102,
0.0085700806,
0.014238866,
0.0865894258,
-0.0093893409,
-0.002018122,
0.0227425378,
0.0656393021,
-0.0759135038,
0.0092380121,
0.0019235653,
0.0024797383,
0.018326005,
-0.0132143507,
0.0448309518,
-0.0670244172,
-0.002867304,
0.0083746612,
-0.0173688922,
-0.0007209151,
0.0831652656,
0.0177642554,
-0.0400448553,
0.0900859535,
0.0499241464,
0.0304381046,
-0.0211045146,
-0.1002698615,
-0.0108006811,
0.035819184,
-0.0081803938,
-0.003747402,
0.0356000513,
-0.0060434891,
0.0554677956,
-0.0486579239,
-0.0071788211,
2.052203981e-34,
0.0148643116,
-0.0348987468,
-0.0201834049,
0.0776213109,
0.0291873924,
-0.0393694714,
0.0121786511,
0.0253253132,
-0.0135908676,
-0.0422708467,
0.0176704098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05371v1
|
Those Aren't Your Memories, They're Somebody Else's: Seeding Misinformation in Chat Bot Memories
| 2023-04-06T05:09:39 | 2023-04-06T05:09:39 |
Conor Atkins, Benjamin Zi Hao Zhao, Hassan Jameel Asghar, Ian Wood, Mohamed Ali Kaafar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
One of the new developments in chit-chat bots is a long-term memory mechanism
that remembers information from past conversations for increasing engagement
and consistency of responses. The bot is designed to extract knowledge of
personal nature from their conversation partner, e.g., stating preference for a
particular color. In this paper, we show that this memory mechanism can result
in unintended behavior. In particular, we found that one can combine a personal
statement with an informative statement that would lead the bot to remember the
informative statement alongside personal knowledge in its long term memory.
This means that the bot can be tricked into remembering misinformation which it
would regurgitate as statements of fact when recalling information relevant to
the topic of conversation. We demonstrate this vulnerability on the BlenderBot
2 framework implemented on the ParlAI platform and provide examples on the more
recent and significantly larger BlenderBot 3 model. We generate 150 examples of
misinformation, of which 114 (76%) were remembered by BlenderBot 2 when
combined with a personal statement. We further assessed the risk of this
misinformation being recalled after intervening innocuous conversation and in
response to multiple questions relevant to the injected memory. Our evaluation
was performed on both the memory-only and the combination of memory and
internet search modes of BlenderBot 2. From the combinations of these
variables, we generated 12,890 conversations and analyzed recalled
misinformation in the responses. We found that when the chat bot is questioned
on the misinformation topic, it was 328% more likely to respond with the
misinformation as fact when the misinformation was in the long-term memory.
|
[
0.0595540591,
0.0083345603,
-0.0291633736,
0.0116593009,
-0.0540945716,
-0.0152125424,
0.0048464607,
0.0084066819,
0.0549927689,
-0.0287665166,
-0.0051631089,
-0.0095661161,
0.0369214304,
0.0436186753,
-0.0060841423,
-0.015979277,
0.0270221848,
0.0098785851,
0.0189422294,
0.0059438688,
0.0380518734,
-0.0246812887,
0.0016083713,
0.0478326567,
-0.0744614527,
-0.0765236318,
-0.0187641475,
0.0215928014,
0.0193208065,
-0.0255801026,
0.0184941087,
0.0257092379,
-0.0129633965,
0.0394643955,
0.0000023696,
-0.0239084661,
-0.0430285074,
-0.0155452006,
-0.0342979059,
0.0115415826,
0.0084461216,
0.0699636936,
-0.0071428404,
0.0240376797,
-0.0343685895,
0.028764626,
0.0568233728,
0.0724115372,
0.0682640448,
0.0447380841,
-0.0192500222,
0.0417199731,
-0.0059407456,
0.0450995788,
0.08451242,
-0.0100761168,
0.0046427944,
0.0063848863,
-0.0224319976,
-0.0010852081,
0.0136388317,
0.0091834394,
0.0073193405,
-0.0046175211,
0.0234588291,
0.0425840467,
-0.0207992923,
-0.0652957559,
-0.0065253191,
0.024759829,
0.0479159094,
-0.0333531238,
0.025418682,
0.0372829102,
0.0260253046,
0.0207151808,
-0.036344178,
0.0270061716,
-0.0614291318,
-0.0585614033,
-0.0445345864,
-0.025993051,
0.0178333092,
-0.0058991141,
0.0202679671,
-0.0116127525,
0.0004320431,
-0.0301182643,
-0.0234816391,
-0.0682599917,
0.078727901,
-0.0620375462,
-0.0109014167,
0.0287670121,
0.0004743188,
-0.002684115,
-0.0245298091,
-0.0077992915,
0.0350611061,
-0.0657434836,
-0.0406083353,
0.0462772511,
-0.0416557565,
0.0288561117,
-0.0045184633,
0.0385080017,
-0.0010238832,
0.0241592489,
-0.005892762,
0.0026171722,
-0.0316716246,
-0.0450507142,
-0.0015963004,
0.0433714949,
0.0544468611,
0.0125656044,
-0.0280467197,
0.0292813424,
-0.0392185897,
0.0369157568,
-0.0607815012,
0.0447488837,
-0.0204277076,
0.0248860866,
-0.0532336719,
-0.0147888185,
-0.0218381509,
-0.0307536554,
0.0414861254,
-0.0753822178,
-0.0348415263,
-0.012775057,
-0.0249941275,
0.0179437231,
-0.0039994153,
0.0652776957,
-0.0058130412,
0.0032736431,
-0.0111791287,
-0.059182927,
-0.0008779673,
-0.0703664273,
0.0261785779,
-0.0348397754,
-0.0052233362,
-0.0044704513,
-0.0115450714,
-0.0038158956,
-0.0032718107,
0.0117488345,
-0.0551713295,
0.0532546453,
-0.0133946016,
-0.0268124379,
0.0669680685,
0.0746368691,
-0.028162472,
0.0220358968,
-0.0019940943,
0.0807385072,
0.0066573783,
0.0001135391,
0.0388496593,
-0.0116811078,
0.0011116306,
-0.0194021594,
0.0219575576,
-0.0110953236,
0.0436584689,
-0.0027300052,
-0.0344092734,
0.0275297593,
-0.0283296537,
-0.0360848717,
0.0553607196,
-0.0015820605,
-0.0686040223,
0.0276704617,
-0.0270257331,
-0.0069304523,
0.0349385366,
0.0190760065,
-0.033144515,
0.0156284645,
-0.0488626584,
-0.028203927,
0.020993324,
0.0238954052,
-0.0239361711,
0.0154754315,
0.0102000665,
-0.0299755055,
0.0614903085,
0.0019900764,
-0.0052254186,
0.0150179705,
-0.0240465868,
0.0315456837,
-0.0033489403,
-0.0415549092,
-0.0617295429,
-0.0610785484,
0.0136969443,
0.0956446379,
0.0166408792,
-0.0038939156,
-0.0446425267,
-0.0129594505,
-0.0429048054,
0.0017627998,
0.0499218367,
0.0169537961,
-0.0024946048,
0.0132532092,
0.0051778764,
-0.0190530028,
0.019942373,
0.0396321416,
0.0229550824,
0.043957375,
-0.0103370212,
0.0544760711,
-0.0042315428,
-0.0076657515,
-0.009304502,
0.0073321345,
-0.0480831377,
0.020446321,
0.0250886157,
-0.0034068148,
0.0197353419,
0.0136080068,
0.037649855,
0.0060339039,
-0.0378020443,
0.0448974855,
-0.0447597764,
0.0152466372,
0.0250191689,
-0.0292084701,
0.0023578217,
0.0064146188,
0.0156465899,
0.0119467666,
0.0250836108,
-0.049747169,
0.0691423044,
0.0088537158,
0.007973142,
-0.0359567441,
0.0093067717,
-0.0050013042,
0.0315717198,
-0.0270942282,
-0.0570795387,
0.0201007053,
-0.0192328449,
0.0001702104,
-0.0107725831,
0.0398725308,
0.0030812509,
-0.010821891,
0.0318169408,
0.0295474343,
-0.0390634313,
-0.1047486663,
0.0152172493,
-0.095666416,
-0.0316998474,
-0.0042012301,
-0.0326051898,
0.0200077835,
-0.0108117443,
-0.0031489283,
-0.0207421687,
-0.0237573124,
0.075014852,
-0.0329929814,
0.0506142974,
0.0172497127,
0.0054049548,
0.0254904069,
-0.0236497838,
0.0414745435,
-0.0092765642,
0.0345874391,
0.0497493334,
-0.0538166277,
-0.0086951945,
0.0348128825,
-0.0631510615,
0.0140887508,
-0.030923754,
-0.0617437065,
0.0191273671,
0.003631498,
0.0302790403,
0.0981522799,
0.0617102087,
0.0674146712,
0.0204343814,
-0.0085942978,
-0.0404299274,
-0.0164376125,
0.0023049985,
0.0006554455,
0.0196226723,
-0.0597646721,
0.005079485,
0.0327019915,
0.0522495843,
0.0404019468,
-0.010553048,
0.0662577748,
0.009999603,
-0.0416244566,
0.0287571568,
-0.0351793282,
-0.0226001889,
0.0042426372,
-0.0130378101,
-0.0923027992,
0.068963781,
-0.015253826,
0.0391688161,
0.0322451591,
0.0068939724,
0.0504112281,
0.0489404835,
-0.0099471938,
0.0218027104,
0.0572900884,
-0.0028983387,
-0.0418301634,
-0.0501748696,
0.0443949886,
-0.0642917231,
-0.0491682664,
-0.0317800418,
-0.0086929593,
0.0133517915,
-0.0321931094,
-0.0795415863,
-0.0665364936,
-0.0301669538,
-0.0619540699,
-0.0086789727,
-0.0446745194,
-0.0510153659,
-0.0281926561,
0.0561517589,
-0.001305444,
-0.0191279519,
-0.0270231627,
0.0212534629,
-0.0521303043,
0.0280395541,
0.0036822204,
0.0302458592,
0.0126524111,
0.0434319749,
0.0929816589,
0.02461241,
-0.0156110041,
-0.0229191128,
-0.0560191162,
-0.0329017751,
0.0263228547,
-0.0062008463,
0.012383014,
0.0472620316,
-0.0515102334,
-0.0335972831,
0.0290065352,
0.020468425,
-0.0357603729,
-0.0206622221,
-0.0134245045,
0.0259284601,
0.0184857938,
-0.0216860902,
-0.0501216501,
-0.0194590297,
0.0055343034,
-0.0171080306,
-0.0666279867,
-0.0056974529,
-0.027840415,
-0.0802013353,
-0.0242493767,
0.0168697555,
-0.0354075693,
-0.0534751453,
-0.0243589766,
-0.0282901693,
0.0474035591,
0.0399217196,
-0.0125323748,
0.0174626224,
-0.0043393667,
0.0038443457,
-0.0898669884,
0.006162032,
0.0471347682,
0.0147610856,
0.0632191747,
0.0484127589,
0.0375707224,
0.01609491,
-0.018635096,
0.00955093,
0.0360708311,
0.0050736438,
-0.0056805061,
0.1012088358,
-0.0093805688,
0.0140203815,
-0.002577286,
-0.0254414883,
0.0274517648,
-0.0108806975,
0.0356857553,
-0.000388051,
-0.051083412,
-0.0029439121,
0.0120572001,
0.017342288,
0.0302845407,
0.0281882398,
0.0021403222,
0.0052455529,
-0.0427414849,
-0.0552161224,
0.0526401885,
0.0216123629,
-0.0096990513,
-0.0203196406,
0.0213063378,
-0.0301110316,
-0.0835688561,
-0.0077410582,
-0.0215040371,
0.0053670947,
0.0155922119,
-0.0070621129,
-0.0044459389,
0.0419090018,
-0.0552648045,
-0.0025055003,
-0.0342610292,
-0.016849732,
0.0057897326,
0.0111737028,
0.0030726637,
-0.0807037875,
0.0242165457,
0.0202184841,
-0.0647590309,
-0.0009325471,
0.0299734715,
0.0767044201,
0.0260973368,
0.0758503303,
0.0217100717,
0.012701802,
0.0472376756,
0.0251089334,
-0.0187299009,
-0.0017401191,
0.0437588617,
0.0659957156,
0.0052315639,
0.0047952845,
-0.0153680015,
-0.0518345833,
0.0004911164,
-0.0432827771,
-0.0483609699,
-0.0240311176,
0.0480451509,
0.0307628624,
0.0446310304,
-0.0126708793,
0.0406096354,
0.0465877131,
0.0092308586,
-0.0213462375,
0.0059718448,
0.0219386052,
-0.0129348096,
-0.0052577876,
-0.0157230534,
0.0361919291,
-0.0323972255,
-0.0037846665,
0.0073176459,
0.0415193252,
-0.0718896985,
0.0185261276,
0.0167883374,
0.0205050297,
0.0132648377,
-0.0050966581,
0.0205722265,
0.011631025,
0.0626522899,
-0.0234531984,
0.0830278918,
-0.0235325806,
-0.0462205857,
0.0004871241,
0.0052169389,
-0.0741162226,
-0.0865594223,
0.0404614061,
0.0121872202,
0.0253753904,
0.0133992676,
-0.0017113335,
-0.033491537,
0.0336051919,
-0.0382597186,
-0.0021932281,
0.0122476164,
-0.0187493954,
-0.055645287,
-0.0111577902,
-0.042173028,
0.0297345035,
0.0402882062,
-0.0378287882,
0.0648033991,
-0.0285472088,
-0.0477894209,
-0.0216818657,
0.0081176637,
0.0090855872,
0.0434956476,
0.0151234651,
-0.0510711074,
-0.0861758962,
-0.0361962318,
0.0167506933,
-0.0016155558,
0.0263078846,
-0.005955846,
0.0194253717,
0.0490234643,
0.0060913707,
0.0012712042,
-0.0366627946,
0.0577591844,
-0.0083994446,
0.0364569463,
-0.0040414953,
-6.790807355e-33,
0.0223557334,
-0.0710738972,
-0.0189583711,
0.0094500631,
-0.0365097672,
0.0025476003,
-0.0317062736,
-0.0068591586,
-0.0238371491,
-0.0126837613,
-0.0186871924,
0.0191574693,
0.001705511,
-0.006322002,
0.0118250903,
-0.0625557676,
0.0381579623,
0.0254150219,
-0.030315103,
0.0425924584,
0.0898585841,
0.020761203,
0.022683261,
-0.064895831,
0.0208891984,
-0.0045426735,
-0.0063523999,
-0.0285834577,
-0.0051182942,
0.0021786364,
-0.0134742884,
0.0245067757,
-0.0077335173,
-0.0048607527,
-0.0058624027,
0.0428526141,
-0.0195433814,
-0.0501065962,
0.0130347246,
-0.0054786303,
-0.010625043,
-0.0313671567,
-0.0063552796,
-0.0312080942,
-0.0076019289,
-0.0183240566,
0.0133418851,
-0.0000024483,
0.0011672726,
0.0336145386,
-0.0267524365,
-0.0448427089,
-0.0104909167,
-0.0442481674,
-0.0082310112,
0.0467535555,
0.0077876719,
-0.0048938976,
-0.0939446166,
0.0339585729,
-0.0935207754,
-0.0198890157,
0.051026836,
0.0211877916,
0.0527125038,
0.1046969816,
0.0570649356,
0.0665927604,
-0.0568914451,
-0.0030473527,
0.0004044805,
0.0024615354,
0.0193674918,
0.0340276957,
0.0421548858,
-0.0648408234,
-0.0200594682,
0.0191819053,
0.0409950987,
0.0175165199,
0.0284968987,
-0.0264480487,
-0.0614684001,
-0.0030500328,
-0.0005037224,
0.0566920787,
-0.0262869522,
-0.0146158747,
-0.0020306164,
0.0276996661,
-0.0109757232,
-0.0686614662,
-0.0125248842,
-0.0583180785,
0.0440191999,
0.0128044095,
-0.0206041094,
-0.0506060794,
-0.0261870343,
0.0122593744,
-0.0138748363,
0.0607411824,
0.014908663,
0.0006919566,
0.0369796641,
0.0379319154,
0.0189110525,
0.0089365877,
-0.0451347157,
-0.0214349646,
-0.029636845,
0.0195199531,
0.004534102,
-0.061976485,
0.0054672798,
0.0202652533,
-0.0467669964,
-0.0126865515,
0.0304185301,
0.0702993199,
-0.0585410073,
-0.0285876989,
-0.0576195121,
-0.0154321259,
-0.0235289186,
0.0057776091,
-0.0674839616,
0.0183618572,
-0.0053042979,
-0.0823165551,
0.0063587287,
-0.0408807769,
3.17e-7,
-0.0777068585,
0.0725673884,
0.0106874853,
-0.0015159032,
0.0360476188,
0.0848665461,
0.0165714789,
0.0135480911,
0.0308337435,
-0.0910324007,
-0.0438213088,
0.0571639612,
0.0267405584,
0.0499935932,
-0.0265254602,
-0.022949785,
-0.028137885,
-0.0637666583,
-0.0119112171,
0.0272251423,
0.0602894239,
0.0320569649,
0.0589360297,
-0.0288712028,
0.019996224,
-0.01556597,
0.0257830676,
-0.0042979759,
-0.0113931019,
-0.0118020512,
0.0219991747,
0.0480721667,
0.0043946011,
0.0345260166,
-0.0054043089,
-0.0765601471,
-0.0531378612,
0.0031728174,
-0.0055773794,
-0.0470881686,
-0.0120975012,
0.0038052856,
0.0081440201,
-0.011897428,
0.0248206314,
0.0047996696,
-0.0212347396,
-0.0285773929,
0.0064515607,
-0.0136539526,
0.0510254577,
-0.0051482623,
-0.0167929288,
0.0082525788,
-0.0439598188,
0.0469930433,
0.0291116945,
-0.0429959372,
0.0042514317,
-0.0055859126,
-0.0434819646,
-0.0799298659,
0.0059961127,
-0.0021688594,
0.0007282665,
-0.0287747998,
0.0178417694,
2.752550429e-34,
0.0059910901,
-0.0136805205,
-0.0134374341,
0.0186881851,
0.0309820995,
0.0066034906,
0.0324405394,
0.0038126742,
0.0269781649,
-0.0068778913,
-0.0073808623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02868v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02868v1
|
Can Large Language Models Play Text Games Well? Current State-of-the-Art and Open Questions
| 2023-04-06T05:01:28 | 2023-04-06T05:01:28 |
Chen Feng Tsai, Xiaochen Zhou, Sierra S. Liu, Jing Li, Mo Yu, Hongyuan Mei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have recently
demonstrated their remarkable abilities of communicating with human users. In
this technical report, we take an initiative to investigate their capacities of
playing text games, in which a player has to understand the environment and
respond to situations by having dialogues with the game world. Our experiments
show that ChatGPT performs competitively compared to all the existing systems
but still exhibits a low level of intelligence. Precisely, ChatGPT can not
construct the world model by playing the game or even reading the game manual;
it may fail to leverage the world knowledge that it already has; it cannot
infer the goal of each step as the game progresses. Our results open up new
research questions at the intersection of artificial intelligence, machine
learning, and natural language processing.
|
[
0.0529233515,
0.0243525784,
-0.0439983793,
0.072679244,
-0.0490095429,
-0.0001587663,
-0.0133325867,
-0.0017769996,
0.0615926906,
-0.0336313397,
-0.026793588,
-0.0270162877,
0.008099026,
0.045535706,
0.0171376597,
-0.0521117002,
0.0098535959,
-0.0443183258,
0.0292017274,
-0.0011253348,
-0.030387843,
-0.0052790362,
-0.009915919,
0.0619543865,
0.0084282998,
-0.0090856412,
-0.0285908934,
-0.0075370674,
-0.002072938,
-0.0308990199,
-0.0043633683,
-0.0091386186,
0.0214133002,
0.0446220264,
0.0000018284,
-0.0220471863,
0.0151565634,
-0.0415383317,
0.0013993107,
-0.0167780127,
0.0150570208,
0.0159678105,
0.0015684374,
-0.0007244574,
-0.0667592138,
-0.0002153888,
0.0545187891,
0.0400354154,
0.0877910033,
0.0804874822,
0.0003384954,
-0.0138788056,
0.007763885,
-0.0179934409,
0.0099927578,
-0.0879911408,
0.0182302166,
0.0276241973,
0.0479400046,
0.0186198838,
-0.0137126986,
0.0389744714,
-0.0006243539,
0.0061871069,
-0.0546871461,
0.0687784031,
-0.0031549605,
0.040280167,
-0.0048648692,
0.0541023202,
-0.0149308555,
-0.0202077292,
0.0294009224,
0.0219991822,
0.0029188916,
-0.0282016676,
-0.0344615094,
0.0382318608,
-0.0013177634,
0.0210603755,
-0.0017231733,
0.0244124439,
0.0447507128,
-0.0070930072,
-0.0062688375,
0.0886472762,
-0.0174956471,
-0.0261342023,
-0.0307078026,
0.0287226699,
-0.0357059501,
-0.0901853293,
-0.0229620375,
0.0470106825,
-0.0498363785,
0.0383177809,
-0.0297852736,
0.038231764,
-0.0020334064,
-0.0431353264,
0.0045287511,
0.0406850651,
0.0327509865,
0.0953999832,
0.0366448499,
0.0190684143,
-0.0114837242,
-0.0008084974,
-0.0198809355,
-0.0212198533,
-0.0461060889,
-0.0452768542,
-0.0518513881,
0.0342011079,
-0.0386503078,
-0.0430668034,
-0.0069367089,
0.0408796594,
0.012720203,
0.0583451688,
0.0102233868,
0.0057289116,
-0.0234014746,
-0.0255178716,
-0.0442117006,
-0.0097909616,
-0.03106145,
-0.0122121656,
-0.0180545468,
-0.065510653,
0.0097627109,
-0.0191797409,
-0.0064248545,
-0.0130204465,
0.0074870274,
0.1132421419,
0.0154565265,
-0.0304835327,
0.0007131366,
-0.0072932593,
-0.0206552651,
-0.106317766,
-0.0193278342,
-0.0425728671,
0.0328301713,
0.023315832,
0.0167905409,
-0.0150281768,
0.005582198,
0.0336265266,
-0.012445556,
0.0935758501,
-0.0075987778,
0.0132762017,
0.0433127098,
0.0147808911,
-0.0221991204,
0.0817839727,
0.0615946725,
0.0155537622,
0.0145197874,
0.009551568,
0.0192585886,
0.0801157504,
-0.0175800342,
-0.0091618309,
0.0163797848,
-0.0071807061,
-0.0094233854,
0.0645672306,
-0.037729539,
0.0547047369,
-0.0346954763,
-0.0119887684,
0.0778359398,
0.0813259706,
-0.0031654586,
0.0438758545,
0.0728360787,
0.0408836901,
-0.0037581187,
0.0208280869,
-0.0352104753,
-0.0010833564,
-0.0365319662,
0.0028161535,
-0.0061961291,
-0.0040569818,
0.006811325,
-0.0525095053,
-0.005166545,
-0.0155454427,
0.0375626683,
0.0101199988,
0.0469343737,
-0.0407728367,
-0.0373926982,
0.0025744867,
0.0263678152,
-0.0230151117,
0.0032987173,
-0.0604987293,
0.0324144512,
0.0683884025,
0.0721666589,
-0.0767112523,
-0.0330991261,
-0.0074236244,
0.0043129614,
0.0605889186,
0.0437186845,
0.0035252718,
0.0165583398,
-0.0189474374,
-0.0065329387,
-0.0167067572,
-0.001416633,
0.0536589287,
0.0052205045,
0.0206675529,
-0.0223500561,
-0.0002067913,
0.0169881787,
0.0139006209,
-0.016097473,
-0.0378258526,
-0.0326065011,
-0.0138936602,
0.0195140261,
-0.0051622982,
-0.0236480087,
-0.0118672177,
0.0178130493,
-0.0234951247,
-0.042122364,
0.0116774393,
-0.0357761681,
-0.0362647027,
0.0513977036,
-0.0411012918,
-0.0113876564,
0.0248292349,
-0.007325971,
-0.0080616409,
0.0237195026,
-0.0450989231,
0.0708107948,
-0.0123799536,
0.012830995,
-0.009669912,
-0.0168093517,
-0.0283445138,
0.0691616237,
0.018346265,
0.0007239591,
-0.0120348483,
-0.0239835754,
0.026319297,
-0.0462937728,
-0.0171681549,
0.0410084464,
0.002568447,
-0.0033404438,
0.056712795,
0.0276983343,
-0.0401208363,
-0.0457778014,
-0.1070801914,
-0.0028517973,
-0.0127608916,
-0.0040882444,
0.0109926481,
-0.0107308906,
-0.0242948569,
-0.0060635712,
-0.039457377,
0.0111798514,
0.0462811366,
-0.0002506792,
0.0487181209,
0.0305694528,
0.004499739,
-0.020435527,
0.0041796351,
-0.0235592313,
0.0290003885,
-0.0050278893,
-0.0382166952,
-0.0664318651,
0.0078747049,
-0.034672007,
0.0500379279,
-0.0465644971,
-0.0385646671,
0.0414237343,
-0.04301266,
0.031282153,
0.054524187,
0.0077484292,
0.0501752868,
0.0437601358,
-0.043342445,
-0.0296773762,
0.0546321087,
-0.0011092783,
-0.0361155681,
-0.0831745267,
-0.0207658317,
0.0451847054,
0.0832049251,
-0.0100403586,
0.0050455579,
-0.0697481707,
0.0448037013,
-0.0071421363,
-0.0191397481,
-0.0652142242,
-0.0245585293,
-0.027378764,
0.0012858812,
-0.0223617069,
0.0121668577,
0.0614195615,
-0.036187619,
-0.0230109841,
-0.0490964651,
0.0158800054,
-0.0182719305,
0.0956856087,
0.0335096605,
0.0243025478,
-0.0035806857,
-0.019778939,
-0.0262807216,
-0.0247829165,
0.0332132317,
-0.031611789,
0.0227197725,
-0.0650919974,
0.0147856828,
0.0143604157,
-0.0589214303,
-0.0332775116,
-0.0209089797,
-0.0562105477,
-0.0280694962,
0.0423913673,
-0.0170518607,
-0.0557107404,
0.008746638,
0.055354014,
0.0188550577,
-0.0058578863,
-0.036661379,
-0.0340325534,
0.0205460805,
0.0802564621,
0.0044248658,
-0.0145706339,
-0.0350527987,
0.0482890718,
0.0561235994,
-0.018485669,
-0.0401930921,
0.0037512099,
-0.0088205701,
0.051665891,
-0.0259139463,
-0.0465763174,
0.0374536552,
0.0266666412,
-0.0451879278,
-0.0219448786,
0.11507269,
0.0356410705,
-0.0043610339,
0.001542497,
0.000610874,
0.016051989,
-0.0041499729,
0.0304001383,
-0.0661849305,
-0.0399788171,
0.0111520886,
-0.0266355686,
0.008206171,
-0.0394373238,
-0.0309910923,
-0.1025131643,
0.0081450371,
0.0111022191,
-0.0492951013,
-0.0115213953,
0.0280479342,
-0.0182074532,
-0.0146462563,
-0.0102505656,
-0.0226345584,
0.0095693311,
-0.0056246426,
-0.0205576941,
-0.0378621258,
-0.0047687879,
0.0120253656,
-0.0322634764,
0.0780773088,
0.0661540404,
0.0832315311,
0.0049933819,
-0.0125460252,
0.019646693,
0.0434553176,
-0.0058890674,
0.0023145759,
0.0490188338,
-0.0315377228,
-0.0100221066,
0.0070986808,
-0.0029072892,
-0.0127104707,
0.0057820752,
0.0277367141,
0.0548308156,
-0.0011677562,
-0.032773789,
0.0223676544,
0.0121918339,
0.0338766426,
0.0589107908,
-0.0073195677,
-0.0553467087,
-0.0600407906,
-0.055038698,
-0.0166350808,
-0.0434843078,
-0.0545053929,
-0.0404058546,
0.0408159867,
0.0052392855,
-0.0649753809,
-0.0670906007,
0.0099276183,
0.0119912969,
0.001126122,
0.0239687152,
0.0184246562,
0.0245466176,
0.0220610779,
-0.0129580935,
-0.068606846,
0.0027563302,
-0.0387346894,
-0.0324873067,
0.0265896935,
-0.0866907462,
-0.0074086082,
0.0564984754,
-0.0547237247,
-0.0534472056,
-0.0012938683,
0.0444315448,
0.0257223211,
0.0184158888,
-0.02055531,
-0.0364576355,
-0.0004747747,
0.0101977251,
-0.0643434897,
0.0054577282,
-0.0103173293,
0.050802663,
0.0202756394,
0.0308085009,
-0.0308901463,
0.0096682329,
0.0067023938,
0.0504444018,
-0.0374627933,
-0.0371752642,
0.0145079819,
-0.003057569,
0.0452219248,
-0.0053644921,
-0.0108050322,
0.0149070984,
-3.619e-7,
-0.0443106405,
-0.0328677185,
-0.0339132547,
-0.0123894941,
0.0141648464,
0.0017904248,
-0.0077677239,
-0.0097420607,
-0.0209016595,
-0.0072493134,
-0.0030045034,
-0.0279397815,
0.0424855538,
-0.0031069308,
0.0414515138,
-0.0112260822,
0.0074003949,
0.0266755596,
0.0112503376,
0.0305786189,
0.0117652221,
0.0437829494,
0.0445358306,
-0.0616513677,
0.0112975081,
0.0274916776,
-0.057312075,
-0.0535349771,
0.0231558718,
0.0943240598,
0.09934441,
0.0211874899,
0.0321354754,
-0.0629624426,
0.004538931,
-0.0084753335,
-0.0247978251,
0.0527763031,
-0.0870745257,
-0.011370643,
0.0214777812,
-0.0399072021,
0.0034940222,
0.0518572815,
0.0453430191,
0.0356039144,
0.0284216013,
-0.0339359343,
-0.0489255749,
-0.0151285641,
0.0188892502,
0.040100567,
-0.0339327231,
0.0405335873,
-0.0477453545,
-0.0355460159,
-0.0176129527,
0.0644519106,
0.001953339,
-0.0312232431,
0.0073637776,
0.039060276,
0.0079940958,
-0.024532808,
-0.0499088913,
0.0457230397,
-0.0450863428,
-0.0199689511,
-0.0177841596,
-5.677407024e-33,
-0.0331984647,
-0.0371576101,
0.0625331029,
0.022257749,
-0.0151731307,
-0.0202858634,
-0.0540215634,
0.0075406339,
-0.0000524814,
0.0092172883,
-0.0352518857,
0.0225148983,
-0.0005575271,
0.0225638673,
-0.0092676366,
-0.0528513566,
0.0256897975,
0.0109519903,
-0.0583068244,
0.0348162092,
0.0266812351,
0.0014847808,
0.044659052,
-0.0447452441,
0.0001047503,
-0.0321690068,
-0.020362379,
0.0269305222,
-0.0027459546,
0.017429132,
-0.0480231084,
0.0141737424,
0.0293921269,
-0.0204323959,
0.0055654268,
0.0227173306,
-0.0255834945,
-0.0197032485,
0.0157194473,
-0.0031804622,
-0.0328616239,
-0.0029915906,
0.0040056198,
-0.0067783766,
-0.0074467026,
0.0122103151,
0.0455897823,
-0.0048413337,
0.0031663775,
0.0245439317,
-0.0679623187,
0.0127285728,
-0.0284693614,
-0.0408454277,
0.0073238285,
0.0192388706,
0.0159736667,
-0.0008813269,
-0.0320240818,
0.0474076532,
0.0290954467,
0.0060681659,
0.0472852699,
0.0077606253,
0.034383405,
0.0548012294,
-0.0046819323,
0.0096963225,
-0.0740661845,
-0.0316347219,
0.0130450344,
0.0047756643,
0.0296873059,
0.0414271019,
-0.0142974481,
0.0061464659,
-0.0525086857,
0.0259828288,
0.0356954262,
0.0336889438,
0.0324911959,
-0.0045006922,
-0.0463926494,
-0.0078615062,
-0.0172700603,
0.0213937908,
-0.0029396722,
-0.037299335,
0.0227327067,
-0.0221543256,
0.0131553579,
-0.0271872021,
0.0331115387,
-0.0517572276,
-0.0290194079,
0.0368418172,
-0.0111770527,
0.010697213,
-0.0149508249,
0.0262564588,
-0.015483818,
-0.0249890294,
0.0028376002,
0.0159518123,
-0.0165019445,
0.0094833374,
-0.0180080645,
0.0375391059,
-0.0410709083,
0.0086056087,
-0.0347815491,
0.0419412479,
-0.0111293057,
-0.0119069833,
0.0390943661,
-0.0375334956,
0.0020186794,
0.0165538508,
0.019317802,
-0.0408668332,
-0.0150833642,
-0.0025911184,
-0.0369309112,
-0.0307957157,
-0.0195006337,
0.0173375718,
-0.0537347496,
0.0694099963,
-0.0071993885,
-0.0352489278,
0.0001093183,
-0.0108659286,
2.597e-7,
0.0054621175,
0.0645938739,
-0.0048953644,
0.0158991888,
0.0078453608,
0.051295016,
-0.0531970225,
0.0247469489,
0.0149900224,
0.0005974615,
0.0492623672,
0.0539174825,
0.0388993733,
0.0140878269,
-0.115060389,
0.0073515549,
-0.0506818146,
-0.0187169369,
-0.0552847013,
0.0067896917,
0.06913957,
0.0470387116,
0.0281761475,
0.0162711143,
0.0020778712,
-0.0706275925,
0.0594288036,
-0.0559462085,
-0.0020151408,
0.0331981666,
0.0286383424,
0.0079974607,
-0.0272999406,
-0.0200670231,
0.0056545222,
0.0335047245,
0.011262509,
0.0611200742,
0.0035389096,
0.000501082,
-0.0319487788,
-0.0070937774,
-0.0081985155,
-0.0740120709,
0.0760705918,
-0.0546871908,
-0.0350211598,
-0.0117903994,
0.0293759033,
-0.0587278232,
-0.0293687694,
-0.024267843,
-0.0679461807,
-0.0105582681,
0.0026242004,
-0.015480346,
0.0322384648,
-0.0785978436,
-0.0070311078,
-0.007133415,
-0.0440096185,
-0.0175871439,
-0.0532370172,
0.0311403722,
0.0274111759,
-0.068113856,
0.0250870958,
1.958934244e-34,
0.0092668803,
-0.0256207567,
0.0125487158,
-0.0320926495,
0.063429825,
0.0362017639,
0.0284207333,
0.0278114378,
0.0489964932,
-0.0459555537,
-0.0013113962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02822v1
|
Approach Intelligent Writing Assistants Usability with Seven Stages of Action
| 2023-04-06T02:11:55 | 2023-04-06T02:11:55 |
Avinash Bhat, Disha Shrivastava, Jin L. C. Guo
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) as writing assistants,
they are plagued by issues like coherence and fluency of the model output,
trustworthiness, ownership of the generated content, and predictability of
model performance, thereby limiting their usability. In this position paper, we
propose to adopt Norman's seven stages of action as a framework to approach the
interaction design of intelligent writing assistants. We illustrate the
framework's applicability to writing tasks by providing an example of software
tutorial authoring. The paper also discusses the framework as a tool to
synthesize research on the interaction design of LLM-based tools and presents
examples of tools that support the stages of action. Finally, we briefly
outline the potential of a framework for human-LLM interaction research.
|
[
0.0582764968,
-0.0110373395,
-0.0090545947,
-0.0057115788,
-0.0673687831,
-0.0107978676,
0.0537963957,
-0.0068805865,
0.0398715436,
-0.0595054552,
-0.0296455547,
-0.0179164317,
0.0252880156,
0.0236974992,
0.0058960067,
-0.0584001802,
0.0153256077,
-0.0408760272,
0.033229921,
0.0304915998,
0.0299392566,
0.0288483445,
-0.0526431538,
0.0802053139,
-0.0368800387,
-0.0428004675,
-0.0503441915,
0.0034354639,
-0.0197551642,
-0.0166442282,
-0.0167647656,
0.0761445537,
0.0162348282,
0.0360074006,
0.0000020672,
-0.0406938344,
0.0282238666,
0.0009016776,
-0.0068017654,
-0.0026604016,
0.0250785202,
0.0137999579,
-0.0216779169,
0.0144281853,
-0.0331188813,
0.0383715257,
0.0258248709,
0.0361033641,
0.0352839194,
0.0248596407,
-0.0203715004,
0.0241477955,
0.0221817102,
0.0208519679,
-0.0186955929,
0.0179145336,
-0.0223878976,
0.0155850723,
0.0677338317,
-0.0058218325,
0.0232457425,
0.0451101586,
0.0164844003,
-0.0855530649,
0.0288543794,
0.0322269052,
0.0405081734,
-0.0305597838,
-0.0272817388,
0.008466389,
0.0357818641,
0.0067559532,
-0.0021039087,
-0.0202409662,
0.02958313,
0.0475017913,
-0.0387749225,
-0.0003982159,
-0.0189932268,
-0.0201360863,
0.0096265096,
-0.044286225,
-0.017289985,
0.0340428613,
0.0533587411,
0.0264702085,
0.0066015362,
-0.0186851975,
0.011860678,
0.0341004469,
0.0322170779,
-0.0646423325,
0.0436861105,
0.0912699699,
-0.0283050109,
0.0162584744,
-0.0672155172,
-0.0166529194,
0.0034274582,
-0.0241265241,
0.0944348946,
0.0249576159,
0.0371341296,
-0.0062030014,
0.0238471813,
0.0592165068,
0.0172697883,
-0.0072431611,
0.0118137561,
0.0536902025,
-0.0153805166,
-0.0370408371,
-0.0398630872,
0.0284834895,
-0.0291367806,
-0.0353742614,
-0.0182253029,
0.042952206,
0.0227989573,
0.052699998,
0.0020524126,
0.0106683271,
-0.0220031291,
-0.0014097313,
-0.0000306436,
-0.0342076607,
0.0026618221,
0.0176194236,
-0.0131517062,
-0.0346640088,
0.0317934081,
0.0043874457,
-0.0055988617,
-0.0079736244,
-0.0321503878,
0.0579897538,
-0.0405355804,
-0.0162289608,
-0.0380710587,
-0.0400546975,
0.0096514486,
-0.0317636989,
-0.0465598851,
-0.0481293686,
-0.0009979048,
0.0335585289,
-0.0352937765,
-0.0675101578,
-0.0040996503,
0.0345299132,
0.0150179416,
-0.006257684,
-0.0447467379,
0.0276626348,
0.0833044648,
0.0052428753,
-0.0307356436,
0.0058578337,
0.0540478639,
0.0550063401,
0.0074667241,
-0.0027696067,
0.0624945499,
0.0445269458,
-0.0574350543,
-0.0110480553,
-0.0067910249,
-0.019144671,
-0.0463703461,
0.0266689844,
-0.0153713292,
0.0369656868,
-0.0055878647,
0.0632230714,
0.1040666774,
0.0657770112,
0.0423469916,
0.0520137735,
0.0430508815,
0.0206755176,
0.0223715119,
0.0382255986,
-0.0441256128,
0.0521204993,
-0.0173554085,
0.0363526084,
-0.0635386035,
0.0178483948,
-0.0059000817,
-0.0894793049,
-0.0271864329,
-0.0088629276,
-0.0314623527,
-0.0199949145,
0.0147803444,
0.0035333328,
-0.016477339,
-0.0294737481,
-0.015648758,
-0.0825473219,
0.0063792085,
-0.0322377458,
0.0471675061,
0.1179004386,
0.0583672523,
-0.0269140638,
0.0028232692,
-0.0158850998,
0.0039161793,
0.0284932628,
0.0139732929,
-0.0261525065,
-0.0086890683,
-0.0162507333,
-0.0013992891,
-0.0491792113,
0.0001744653,
-0.0065151667,
-0.0038599006,
0.017385412,
0.0276833493,
0.0247461256,
-0.0456867106,
0.0542890728,
-0.0531087182,
-0.0268944241,
-0.0370454192,
0.0285360329,
-0.0293163527,
0.0430456251,
-0.0216004457,
0.0154083623,
0.0142108668,
-0.0026165594,
-0.0004809679,
0.0397355631,
0.0080796275,
0.0293030329,
0.0224318095,
-0.0102946293,
0.007069381,
0.0071379193,
0.0503932983,
-0.0383946747,
-0.007206995,
-0.0341892056,
0.0377840474,
-0.0344325528,
0.0249811579,
-0.0199147407,
-0.0828088,
-0.0026559366,
0.0190371163,
-0.0092223994,
-0.0048642638,
0.0154508222,
0.0362986661,
-0.0076825954,
0.0007344997,
-0.0163980927,
0.0108441673,
-0.0031460973,
0.0313633047,
0.0150519069,
0.0263017248,
-0.0353628993,
-0.061767675,
-0.0744834468,
-0.0120471613,
-0.0197836235,
0.0122802956,
0.0332118608,
-0.0145744458,
-0.0209500957,
-0.0301144347,
-0.0220997538,
-0.0127643393,
0.0005432009,
-0.0214965772,
0.0484823063,
-0.013156997,
0.011895394,
-0.0509150736,
0.0054164832,
-0.0007858721,
0.0100158257,
0.0598323569,
-0.041087009,
-0.0804973319,
0.0379203074,
-0.0055734138,
-0.0175849386,
0.014628958,
-0.01811276,
0.0591577403,
-0.0027013822,
0.0395881012,
0.0702222809,
0.0042361035,
0.0688268095,
0.0697997361,
-0.0110465083,
-0.0177879743,
-0.0051809968,
0.0347737893,
0.0343821794,
0.0211626645,
-0.0481064022,
0.0136945443,
0.0649886578,
0.0163322743,
0.033198107,
-0.0108654322,
0.0439543948,
-0.0412595831,
-0.0172548331,
0.0234131627,
-0.0603976138,
-0.0364729837,
0.047016222,
-0.0173230749,
-0.0784295946,
0.0420103073,
-0.0584231801,
-0.0349866711,
0.002439721,
-0.0375191532,
-0.0259381086,
0.0817084983,
-0.0316670053,
0.0194548909,
-0.0337394513,
-0.0272092167,
-0.0322998054,
-0.0222253632,
0.0286894012,
0.0101644387,
0.0342673734,
-0.0937365741,
-0.0013148093,
-0.0196327921,
-0.0155844698,
-0.0081877392,
-0.003825,
-0.0545792244,
-0.0080353627,
0.0311081745,
-0.0171624329,
-0.0024140368,
0.0340542458,
0.0565933622,
0.0618217774,
-0.0055605527,
-0.0150793837,
-0.0360934176,
0.0008530045,
0.0133978939,
-0.005021919,
-0.0504272208,
-0.0341471881,
0.0518387891,
0.0253507942,
-0.0164864585,
-0.006229552,
-0.0309008546,
-0.0404783711,
0.0291172452,
-0.0435632281,
-0.0608463027,
0.0294905584,
0.0650832728,
-0.0323982537,
0.0011400176,
0.1149557382,
0.0155442888,
-0.0531132147,
-0.0060216617,
-0.0328171141,
0.0059593441,
0.0027468028,
0.037023291,
-0.0296515096,
0.0053379992,
0.008812435,
0.0379275456,
-0.0026765163,
-0.0141407447,
-0.0088372566,
-0.0320143066,
0.0407212563,
-0.0194835085,
-0.0121870972,
0.0030840118,
-0.0049085654,
0.0290407725,
0.0359175019,
0.0062449314,
0.0023325547,
-0.052623596,
0.0039403941,
-0.0044406042,
-0.0490899161,
-0.0169626586,
-0.0566858165,
-0.0137892393,
0.0327046104,
0.0519564562,
0.0417244546,
0.0264034756,
0.006061737,
-0.0233442616,
0.0364344083,
0.0696870461,
-0.0453247465,
0.0060711307,
-0.0182567891,
0.020656582,
-0.0795202628,
0.0404717922,
-0.0058655343,
-0.0345840491,
0.0252442043,
0.0153390458,
-0.0735943392,
-0.011780737,
-0.0269911699,
-0.0094632301,
0.0337145105,
0.0210386422,
0.0470572561,
-0.0797084272,
-0.0555675328,
-0.034712676,
0.0221378915,
-0.027538307,
-0.0046729464,
-0.005824239,
-0.0081599094,
0.0039142184,
-0.0501491502,
-0.0790321901,
0.0558022968,
0.0479592979,
0.0357263833,
0.0318450071,
0.0291178152,
0.0037925979,
-0.0111489715,
-0.0113317482,
0.0222543404,
0.0344733521,
-0.064812392,
-0.0239882581,
-0.0149077326,
-0.0649806038,
0.0429222398,
-0.0162483957,
0.0067144106,
-0.0611910447,
0.0169117656,
0.0490915589,
0.0245046485,
0.0111128306,
-0.006321365,
-0.0948499292,
0.0011010882,
-0.0264239032,
-0.0216139071,
0.0372264832,
0.0118899448,
0.0062436997,
-0.0028539002,
0.0132011874,
-0.0079030655,
-0.0019930869,
-0.014184582,
-0.0014168505,
-0.0249953624,
-0.0844963267,
0.0011175508,
0.0335969627,
-0.0177370459,
-0.0372481458,
0.0520340167,
-0.0644112527,
0.0190998316,
-0.0479030497,
-0.0176250078,
-0.0561550185,
0.0189499222,
-0.0183617063,
0.0013825053,
0.027328331,
-0.009165274,
-0.063961558,
0.0161978491,
-0.0422650799,
0.0775515884,
-0.0402994342,
0.0490291454,
0.0331521183,
0.0123286759,
-0.0298091583,
0.0562140904,
-0.0400119275,
0.0119636301,
0.0323747545,
0.0725874379,
0.0063701426,
-0.0222278871,
0.0313068442,
0.0540294349,
-0.0293666683,
-0.036496982,
-0.0194239747,
0.0190693066,
0.0251374263,
-0.0005198329,
0.0604197308,
-0.0587317422,
0.0253749061,
0.0016433464,
0.0568588786,
0.0414126851,
-0.0306684617,
-0.0307402648,
0.0058623082,
-0.010329837,
-0.0453932174,
0.061198175,
-0.0450984389,
-0.0156752132,
0.0135950213,
-0.0417666584,
-0.0521669425,
-0.0490864888,
0.0416383743,
-0.0017048612,
-0.0263228603,
-0.0292977355,
-0.0642677769,
-0.0473503843,
0.0025222378,
-0.0032745299,
-0.0373678543,
-0.0714806169,
0.0224609822,
0.0290953964,
0.0076987008,
-0.0004043135,
-0.0398550183,
0.0128566492,
-0.0623790286,
-0.0117272893,
-0.0264611132,
-5.30861661e-33,
-0.045772355,
-0.0924562588,
0.0272048842,
0.029731473,
0.0186344776,
-0.0048570666,
-0.0291578546,
0.0528435856,
0.0307633299,
0.0061481041,
-0.0344188698,
-0.0176056884,
-0.0034802484,
-0.0128936311,
-0.0025954312,
0.0508601777,
0.0625773966,
-0.0060639381,
-0.0242630113,
0.0090576503,
-0.0040350598,
0.0037500318,
0.0112524005,
-0.0651231483,
0.0501603,
-0.0676554441,
-0.0299987867,
-0.0085789459,
-0.0163984727,
0.0350816175,
-0.0188563298,
0.0247339029,
0.0430753231,
0.0326068252,
-0.0008271434,
0.0752128735,
-0.0058337417,
-0.0285210256,
0.011630171,
0.0341302305,
-0.0260087438,
-0.0377203673,
0.0100560933,
-0.0279406458,
-0.0375718176,
0.0415974297,
0.0400259905,
0.0109471818,
-0.0185954142,
-0.0058632107,
-0.0855854899,
0.0196217746,
-0.0139824282,
-0.0519260131,
0.0155012337,
0.0161792058,
0.0072657964,
-0.0789637715,
-0.0265051294,
0.0054620341,
0.0118237715,
0.0010175513,
0.058846239,
0.0152486321,
-0.0317804813,
0.0298752952,
-0.0224199537,
0.0511370748,
-0.0378043279,
0.0312648974,
0.010033262,
0.0403066166,
0.03818826,
0.0310176555,
-0.0544827394,
-0.0052182046,
0.019413719,
0.0472381003,
0.034313485,
0.0080397185,
0.0033003415,
0.0036494094,
-0.0413747989,
-0.0189106409,
-0.0353822224,
-0.0020752784,
-0.0171345845,
-0.0657794923,
0.0141443247,
-0.0277998559,
0.0118609127,
-0.0417822376,
-0.0388454385,
0.0220672786,
-0.0288315173,
-0.0090905074,
-0.0403656848,
0.0709462985,
-0.0101031372,
-0.0037569345,
-0.0210488178,
0.0029025539,
-0.0200102385,
0.03432291,
0.028940022,
0.045741722,
-0.0185236633,
0.0455817692,
-0.0343170464,
0.0156175904,
-0.0162996333,
0.0519243404,
0.0619211942,
-0.0268950257,
0.0139564192,
-0.0378612168,
-0.039269127,
0.0544603728,
-0.0107484087,
-0.0321239419,
-0.0568612702,
-0.0175117832,
-0.0130456053,
-0.0295954812,
-0.0266531277,
-0.022552304,
-0.0166081805,
0.0540622286,
0.06130521,
-0.0086825257,
0.0137441158,
-0.0092336182,
2.695e-7,
0.0236500651,
0.0328515694,
0.0045983577,
0.0153580401,
0.0069703655,
0.0239268281,
-0.0062946565,
0.0326263309,
-0.0069888183,
0.0468962491,
0.0183228441,
0.0212371033,
0.0453822352,
0.0245676637,
-0.0683176592,
-0.0230800565,
-0.047423508,
0.0460083447,
-0.070441775,
0.0521971695,
0.0604962558,
-0.0512116961,
-0.0131584285,
-0.0240855645,
-0.0333930887,
-0.047915969,
0.0142502626,
-0.0281349272,
0.0116539514,
0.0013189258,
0.0518684685,
0.0047445856,
-0.0018091783,
0.022785699,
-0.0069892942,
-0.025786953,
-0.0129204718,
0.0797486529,
-0.0281502008,
0.0245091747,
0.0537033118,
-0.0061432081,
0.0086256107,
-0.0642387494,
0.0369602405,
-0.0123338578,
-0.0030739096,
-0.0146891391,
0.0264403857,
-0.0388390981,
-0.0259763207,
-0.0281389449,
0.0385653265,
0.0369064435,
-0.0044031241,
-0.0366425812,
0.0059032808,
0.0125151118,
-0.0466371514,
-0.0027907055,
0.0301405769,
-0.010882061,
-0.087116532,
-0.0171524361,
-0.0440842547,
-0.0695481747,
0.0013520661,
2.049795595e-34,
-0.0350892209,
-0.0116049498,
0.0383217745,
0.0610880889,
0.0377210379,
0.052587837,
0.0483578816,
0.051319439,
0.0552704297,
-0.038256932,
-0.0147241969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02819v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02819v3
|
GPT detectors are biased against non-native English writers
| 2023-04-06T01:51:15 | 2023-07-10T18:48:45 |
Weixin Liang, Mert Yuksekgonul, Yining Mao, Eric Wu, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
The rapid adoption of generative language models has brought about
substantial advancements in digital communication, while simultaneously raising
concerns regarding the potential misuse of AI-generated content. Although
numerous detection methods have been proposed to differentiate between AI and
human-generated content, the fairness and robustness of these detectors remain
underexplored. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several
widely-used GPT detectors using writing samples from native and non-native
English writers. Our findings reveal that these detectors consistently
misclassify non-native English writing samples as AI-generated, whereas native
writing samples are accurately identified. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
simple prompting strategies can not only mitigate this bias but also
effectively bypass GPT detectors, suggesting that GPT detectors may
unintentionally penalize writers with constrained linguistic expressions. Our
results call for a broader conversation about the ethical implications of
deploying ChatGPT content detectors and caution against their use in evaluative
or educational settings, particularly when they may inadvertently penalize or
exclude non-native English speakers from the global discourse. The published
version of this study can be accessed at:
www.cell.com/patterns/fulltext/S2666-3899(23)00130-7
|
[
0.0553223044,
0.0654543191,
-0.0411250852,
0.0221883934,
-0.0536257103,
0.0158620905,
0.0605348423,
0.0203056708,
0.0432991646,
-0.0655243471,
-0.0038679214,
-0.0240033232,
-0.0090478025,
0.0137614142,
0.0225903206,
0.0095929792,
0.0211742725,
0.0198920928,
0.0543049946,
-0.010495699,
0.0632870719,
0.0592887737,
0.0087328916,
0.065534927,
-0.0567859672,
-0.0523228273,
0.0490519144,
-0.0161471684,
0.0171914846,
-0.0030039931,
0.0211711209,
0.0840732977,
-0.0233566556,
0.08563032,
0.0000016561,
-0.0426636785,
0.0117225824,
-0.0177402217,
0.0196015276,
0.0251574032,
0.0617801361,
0.0395228826,
-0.0458095334,
0.0411568917,
-0.0642634183,
0.0000569728,
0.0325729623,
0.0275308229,
0.0125582172,
0.0625396222,
-0.0346687399,
0.025518069,
0.0581115931,
0.015425046,
0.0126471277,
0.011685512,
0.0179736894,
-0.0320182107,
-0.0055622058,
-0.0187287703,
0.0032354223,
0.0497806966,
0.0302646365,
-0.0417031161,
-0.0360310674,
0.0171084218,
-0.0303417165,
-0.0200096965,
-0.0142822759,
0.0016277647,
0.0177631304,
-0.0447036698,
0.0309495926,
-0.004694127,
0.0055737402,
0.0120718628,
-0.0005582686,
0.0514104031,
-0.0481723174,
0.0066760555,
0.0469045714,
-0.0158117544,
0.0008707907,
0.0341155566,
0.0528709628,
0.0425933674,
0.0259639304,
-0.0436705984,
-0.0310810059,
0.0501087531,
0.0165922735,
-0.0701266155,
0.0467132702,
-0.0151343504,
-0.0050215004,
0.0135781951,
-0.0433280058,
-0.0594400652,
0.0075264615,
-0.0298427884,
0.0044349497,
0.0299748611,
-0.0096889995,
-0.0127759594,
-0.0028693127,
0.059831325,
-0.0039417688,
0.063042514,
-0.0129126245,
0.0403438732,
-0.0160426851,
-0.0444677323,
-0.0233418141,
-0.0013569995,
0.001584621,
-0.0052104983,
-0.0337854363,
-0.008155697,
-0.0121099753,
0.0003085196,
-0.0286751017,
-0.0102651473,
-0.0348844603,
0.0224842262,
0.0243427716,
-0.0194586776,
-0.0281307343,
0.0159062911,
-0.0099566551,
-0.0964653119,
-0.0044901711,
0.0390587784,
0.0155399218,
-0.0200585909,
-0.0085316133,
0.0233231895,
-0.0100762183,
-0.0460476764,
-0.0177184977,
-0.0155961588,
-0.0376816206,
-0.0457356088,
-0.0147660077,
-0.0367912985,
-0.0225578845,
-0.0082304925,
0.0095758438,
-0.068347089,
-0.0113242967,
0.0546170324,
0.0040498101,
0.0120436391,
0.0161565728,
0.0217379797,
0.0308863241,
0.016007157,
0.0160429049,
0.0434132591,
0.0512344092,
0.0197356418,
0.0387830362,
-0.0025078678,
0.0486011878,
0.0586131439,
-0.0072814981,
0.0196332727,
0.0087701576,
-0.0292535592,
-0.0180903208,
-0.0006829233,
0.0408545062,
0.0549245737,
0.0070344592,
0.0178767946,
0.0765523687,
0.1063296497,
-0.0444307365,
0.0515321493,
0.0585606433,
0.0428130738,
0.0076631233,
0.069080472,
-0.0246678106,
-0.0233588703,
-0.0294322204,
-0.0406487323,
0.0002938229,
0.0506752878,
0.0002770108,
-0.0287144929,
-0.0070656422,
0.0194342136,
0.0376247652,
0.0054600667,
-0.0211961679,
0.0148547255,
-0.0193109326,
-0.0565014556,
-0.0134168323,
-0.0750646442,
0.0211197361,
-0.0704397261,
0.0373662934,
0.0454166085,
0.0552140102,
0.0095847482,
0.0478010364,
-0.0456161126,
-0.025450727,
0.0898173451,
-0.0048631853,
0.0023813231,
-0.0128388796,
-0.0131698688,
-0.0090764305,
-0.0067648268,
0.0140623497,
0.0111579718,
0.0223495662,
0.047635667,
0.0215171948,
-0.015108712,
-0.0599275641,
0.0256441925,
-0.0112218428,
-0.047327809,
-0.0239779409,
-0.0096090995,
0.0146637494,
0.0327663384,
-0.0419910662,
-0.0050975149,
-0.018347973,
-0.0190258082,
-0.0124300346,
0.0373691544,
-0.0532568656,
-0.0056713801,
0.0043794224,
-0.0682720989,
-0.0144419447,
0.0327838212,
0.0143943308,
-0.029378945,
0.0111685721,
-0.0264952276,
0.0300892908,
-0.0789332092,
-0.0103755044,
-0.0437613502,
0.0002788157,
-0.0110827209,
0.023640668,
0.0044650724,
0.0202073399,
0.0105778277,
-0.0180707853,
0.0567852035,
-0.0285562593,
-0.0474682376,
0.0465609655,
-0.0083032679,
0.0461986288,
0.0449107029,
0.0372511931,
-0.0416734405,
-0.0033975954,
-0.0725453719,
-0.002086821,
-0.0279099587,
0.0354805402,
0.0436195098,
-0.0171376877,
-0.0482406504,
0.024988981,
-0.0692027956,
-0.0697511733,
0.03350747,
0.016190026,
0.020339394,
-0.0503806919,
0.0424022451,
-0.0096647944,
0.0108842729,
-0.0517362952,
0.0026329574,
0.0553800613,
-0.0310030095,
-0.0105500175,
0.0319659598,
-0.0006619896,
-0.0149850743,
0.0026405554,
-0.0587602369,
0.0167295747,
0.0053358283,
0.0401918851,
0.0642155558,
0.0098604141,
0.0259593017,
0.0140050221,
0.0111221988,
-0.0201296117,
-0.0101139843,
0.0504582748,
0.0027176817,
0.0011429993,
-0.0689687282,
0.0265452377,
0.0270846505,
0.0440635383,
-0.0228397995,
-0.0674492866,
0.0436089113,
-0.0764171779,
-0.0528327152,
-0.0016015967,
-0.0514187887,
-0.0492933616,
0.024273999,
-0.0391985625,
-0.0586223267,
0.0558515266,
-0.0315014832,
-0.0167089254,
-0.0478828587,
-0.0082458202,
-0.0095987115,
0.0175862778,
0.020380659,
0.0557417721,
0.034313444,
-0.0603248365,
-0.0335200056,
0.0051045129,
0.05596257,
-0.0104877846,
0.004517375,
0.0024683971,
-0.0100175161,
0.0104745561,
-0.0282317996,
-0.0354824066,
-0.0437540002,
0.0079464912,
0.0070554172,
0.0461892299,
-0.037973199,
0.0224863291,
-0.0060415957,
0.0318041667,
0.0700576156,
-0.0435835682,
0.0028460489,
-0.0217657685,
0.035645593,
0.024685584,
-0.0462450273,
-0.0137802977,
-0.0093412492,
0.0194112044,
0.0392069332,
-0.0301497392,
0.0291674323,
0.0310107283,
0.0147879114,
0.0255720802,
-0.0130598275,
-0.0477701053,
0.0216390863,
0.0593112037,
-0.0435023084,
-0.0035707487,
0.1055275574,
0.0200417824,
-0.0830989257,
-0.0291660558,
-0.0252357069,
0.0040285042,
0.0034710832,
-0.0053107929,
-0.0828212276,
0.0111094965,
0.0038378139,
0.0293192491,
-0.0754040107,
-0.0077232188,
-0.0136473374,
-0.0678318217,
0.0374641493,
-0.00590976,
-0.0449637696,
0.0188455638,
0.00392967,
-0.0166147556,
0.0063359952,
-0.0007725015,
-0.0467485934,
-0.0136879124,
0.0364538543,
-0.0087043019,
-0.0456585102,
-0.0152217746,
-0.0038222766,
-0.035433691,
0.0235973075,
0.0751878098,
0.0539914854,
-0.0288731996,
-0.0412737206,
-0.0138463192,
-0.0313474052,
-0.012183317,
-0.0064528114,
0.0257719643,
-0.0184612069,
0.0113949347,
-0.0641625673,
0.0431057438,
-0.0114865191,
-0.0027993363,
0.0377800614,
0.0751841962,
0.0029182686,
-0.0365473628,
-0.0166775752,
0.0151022496,
0.0323586054,
0.0696190521,
0.0434358604,
-0.0409631692,
-0.0516159795,
-0.0575363003,
0.054277081,
-0.0475669093,
-0.0697303563,
0.0184360351,
0.0240526143,
-0.0546496287,
-0.0693661124,
-0.0755048096,
-0.0144965872,
0.0105545996,
0.0406565331,
0.0197949447,
-0.030888373,
-0.0165520571,
0.0010114814,
-0.010116511,
-0.0301430915,
0.0119924191,
-0.0314329937,
-0.0095399814,
-0.0234837588,
-0.0293969065,
0.00315498,
0.0353386514,
-0.0276073292,
-0.0491748191,
0.0233947206,
0.0001751885,
0.022719413,
-0.0052795229,
-0.0065558301,
-0.0374650694,
0.0212963969,
0.033049494,
-0.001690401,
0.0288887732,
0.0332475752,
-0.0244462974,
-0.0127855437,
0.0127581805,
0.0135757877,
0.0149786957,
0.0025465086,
-0.006399394,
-0.016229352,
-0.0067567853,
0.0308423955,
0.0507800467,
0.0059909918,
-0.0556803159,
0.0192422159,
-0.0675377846,
-0.0573181957,
-0.0196110588,
-0.0100796744,
-0.0229303874,
-0.0019964466,
0.0184153039,
0.0191991292,
-0.0398834608,
0.0354786813,
-0.0664815158,
0.0224510934,
-0.0451387726,
0.0413933285,
0.0006414942,
0.0642513335,
-0.0180280749,
0.0013520487,
0.0067862859,
0.0481330454,
-0.008891155,
0.034070123,
0.0038859416,
0.0638626814,
0.0057350905,
-0.0078147957,
0.0496505685,
0.0308617055,
-0.0740893111,
-0.009738991,
0.0011676709,
0.0276398174,
0.0603972375,
-0.0193015784,
0.0760217234,
-0.007746608,
0.0118506337,
0.0031758291,
0.0205579568,
0.022955263,
-0.0595386624,
-0.0270353854,
-0.0233959667,
-0.0275640767,
-0.0235061664,
0.0633507147,
-0.0118128639,
0.0502576195,
0.012682382,
-0.0445064902,
-0.0108474009,
-0.0483474694,
0.0219941717,
-0.0172667503,
0.0191193111,
0.0137185259,
-0.062875092,
-0.0550388023,
-0.0289209653,
0.0013494892,
0.0255637877,
-0.0588931404,
-0.0044578747,
0.0640833378,
-0.0347255394,
-0.0347931795,
-0.0433970243,
0.0052433047,
-0.0193202384,
-0.0332200192,
-0.0228561647,
-5.492749718e-33,
-0.0134779792,
-0.0560564026,
-0.0121243224,
0.0168105513,
-0.0142818065,
0.0049644625,
-0.0311422944,
-0.0071629337,
0.0071623698,
0.036515519,
-0.0473891571,
0.036076013,
0.0065698191,
0.0075119552,
-0.0159214381,
-0.0022727037,
0.0549824573,
-0.011420018,
-0.0346313529,
0.0488427207,
0.0161800832,
-0.0122182351,
0.0579298511,
-0.0456932336,
0.0728537962,
-0.034842059,
-0.0545284934,
-0.0364865921,
-0.0514272861,
0.0223252047,
-0.0264065247,
0.0897264704,
0.0329434052,
-0.0005574912,
0.0072805523,
0.0592640042,
-0.0140339909,
-0.0405750349,
0.0323884934,
-0.0100323772,
0.0083700148,
-0.0824671686,
0.0139918625,
-0.0360151529,
-0.0591720901,
0.0357863456,
0.0535230897,
0.012837559,
0.0348294936,
-0.0319201387,
-0.0592640303,
0.0166722517,
-0.0237979963,
0.0318863131,
-0.0017939691,
0.0391441286,
0.0088458015,
-0.0267116763,
-0.0196336526,
0.0276433807,
0.0329641625,
0.0060335505,
0.0351048633,
-0.0188985001,
-0.0016872811,
0.0410676301,
0.0277979299,
0.0147906104,
-0.0184546188,
-0.0365760997,
0.0339690782,
-0.0548303276,
0.040348459,
0.1043540388,
0.0103565184,
-0.0451315455,
-0.0116600525,
0.0289455261,
0.0285351202,
0.0090492368,
0.0024207269,
-0.0494288541,
-0.073673971,
-0.0713846758,
-0.0030376734,
-0.0889501721,
-0.0033788143,
-0.0371375047,
0.0574494191,
-0.0349357761,
0.0090728775,
-0.0298202392,
-0.0045568808,
-0.038627591,
0.027521871,
0.023384301,
-0.0514548421,
0.0138475308,
0.0073984526,
0.062680155,
-0.0345459916,
0.0079292674,
0.0313498527,
0.0125108957,
0.0463374145,
0.0093757119,
0.0254409332,
0.049307093,
-0.0557974987,
0.0100308759,
-0.0175858103,
0.0611644462,
-0.0067437254,
-0.0125571564,
0.0232783537,
-0.0095473556,
0.0133165969,
-0.0075739594,
0.0640919879,
0.0128946071,
-0.0644393489,
-0.0347711518,
-0.043988876,
0.0145417843,
-0.0403077602,
0.0168683399,
-0.0240678191,
0.0326808728,
0.0480801091,
-0.0725419372,
-0.0067470754,
-0.0524796844,
2.335e-7,
0.0130978413,
0.0124162231,
0.0216943081,
0.0067720991,
0.0175799113,
0.0258400682,
0.0138428612,
0.0492846631,
0.0248468369,
0.0450668298,
0.0005612748,
0.003950356,
0.0509959497,
0.0391625948,
-0.0786569193,
0.0323830396,
-0.0897448957,
0.0298058242,
-0.0666283518,
0.0497453138,
0.0655074045,
-0.001866053,
0.0019615993,
-0.0242450144,
-0.0127189877,
-0.0710368976,
0.0197162181,
-0.0193431228,
0.0217260607,
-0.0070670089,
0.0490449667,
0.0017447922,
0.0355313085,
0.0269285198,
-0.0027357405,
0.0096391002,
0.0210512094,
0.0561934337,
0.0147232683,
0.0261903033,
-0.0151119754,
-0.0054809852,
-0.0019824002,
-0.0817924067,
0.0587481335,
0.0431791134,
-0.0156400725,
-0.0238087904,
0.0042813066,
-0.065115951,
0.031228384,
-0.0277804341,
-0.0541591607,
0.0124654453,
0.0000431354,
-0.0050116754,
0.0237430464,
-0.0335462652,
-0.0157154407,
-0.0242961161,
-0.0077516991,
-0.0278297495,
-0.0359015055,
0.0258355662,
-0.01498714,
-0.0388712175,
0.0405321904,
2.235347379e-34,
0.0068045002,
-0.0094138999,
0.0414464734,
-0.0082159638,
0.0348008983,
0.0517768785,
0.0343908481,
-0.0137477741,
0.0147035401,
-0.0177362692,
-0.0159258191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02812v1
|
Pragmatically Appropriate Diversity for Dialogue Evaluation
| 2023-04-06T01:24:18 | 2023-04-06T01:24:18 |
Katherine Stasaski, Marti A. Hearst
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Linguistic pragmatics state that a conversation's underlying speech acts can
constrain the type of response which is appropriate at each turn in the
conversation. When generating dialogue responses, neural dialogue agents
struggle to produce diverse responses. Currently, dialogue diversity is
assessed using automatic metrics, but the underlying speech acts do not inform
these metrics.
To remedy this, we propose the notion of Pragmatically Appropriate Diversity,
defined as the extent to which a conversation creates and constrains the
creation of multiple diverse responses. Using a human-created multi-response
dataset, we find significant support for the hypothesis that speech acts
provide a signal for the diversity of the set of next responses. Building on
this result, we propose a new human evaluation task where creative writers
predict the extent to which conversations inspire the creation of multiple
diverse responses. Our studies find that writers' judgments align with the
Pragmatically Appropriate Diversity of conversations. Our work suggests that
expectations for diversity metric scores should vary depending on the speech
act.
|
[
0.0557876714,
0.0557818972,
-0.0272640157,
0.0033004633,
-0.0189706348,
-0.0102708768,
0.0193677973,
0.0077117775,
-0.0336489417,
-0.0237398893,
-0.0341875777,
-0.0767798871,
0.0187393762,
0.0654782057,
0.0145570049,
-0.0627477467,
-0.0004861623,
-0.0077222348,
0.0810209662,
-0.0150428507,
-0.0155734159,
0.0200776085,
-0.0242655333,
0.0719425008,
-0.0120119117,
-0.0338761732,
0.0006565592,
0.0155152213,
0.0298013967,
0.0172851626,
0.0060142344,
0.0767530128,
-0.0106628388,
0.0286987685,
0.0000015453,
-0.0434324406,
0.0574469157,
-0.0373534374,
0.0176445283,
-0.0075572361,
0.0005931244,
0.0533470511,
-0.0089584775,
-0.0052164625,
-0.0515415259,
0.0050944374,
0.0411393233,
0.0701773837,
0.0435516499,
0.0764661431,
0.009083299,
-0.0117369872,
0.0080203088,
-0.0277409777,
0.0020237954,
-0.0068219034,
-0.0160759091,
-0.0251189433,
0.0116578992,
0.0123861674,
-0.0201227479,
0.0004332474,
0.0226622466,
-0.0332193449,
0.0187124442,
0.0435973108,
-0.0068916371,
-0.0156653523,
-0.0107850954,
0.088653937,
0.0352948941,
0.0223923549,
-0.0320455208,
-0.0382075794,
0.0346361734,
-0.0269059092,
-0.0458768755,
0.0268915724,
0.0016633853,
-0.0212774053,
-0.0381849445,
0.0111861825,
-0.0271761287,
0.0145363817,
0.0489697084,
0.0434205867,
0.0051534888,
0.0058921585,
-0.0282951929,
0.0004490795,
0.0511137247,
-0.0796431601,
-0.013473196,
0.0015230043,
-0.0647457987,
0.0036186494,
0.0013236016,
0.0151294786,
0.0307099093,
-0.0290014762,
0.043750897,
0.0074158912,
-0.0186929069,
0.0125762252,
0.0315789841,
0.0348534063,
-0.0131497243,
0.0214871801,
-0.0323536508,
0.0248573236,
-0.0248845667,
-0.0318213217,
-0.002480583,
0.0012553848,
-0.0271445327,
-0.0187870618,
-0.021796098,
0.0090061733,
-0.0525399856,
-0.0423781723,
-0.0105139641,
0.0602400787,
-0.0307570808,
-0.0096272854,
-0.0615198277,
0.0464484431,
-0.0810942277,
0.016827669,
0.0312412307,
-0.034266755,
-0.0191631448,
0.0325526968,
0.0112107983,
-0.0329590999,
-0.0057449383,
0.0462463424,
-0.0241029263,
-0.0101579456,
0.0115241865,
-0.0319090709,
-0.0327438153,
-0.0523081124,
0.0165275559,
-0.0411139093,
0.0292769745,
-0.0034052748,
-0.0162639804,
-0.0551724881,
-0.0059606484,
0.0084889177,
-0.0247147027,
0.0091488026,
0.0128788864,
0.0268871766,
0.0661740601,
0.0159671735,
-0.0243826341,
0.0541094653,
0.0548277162,
-0.002448956,
0.0342478454,
-0.0082444521,
0.0329030268,
0.0048660957,
-0.0136631122,
-0.0159501974,
0.0021494217,
0.0095057311,
-0.0228663217,
0.0487437882,
0.0462792367,
0.0534121096,
-0.0414015874,
-0.0404619947,
0.0595054291,
0.0521549843,
0.0080992756,
0.0256993324,
0.0638125539,
0.0271940269,
0.004888901,
0.0608877838,
-0.0077255336,
0.0690171123,
0.0368779674,
-0.011338383,
0.0596711934,
0.0270245466,
-0.0296320133,
-0.0330839008,
0.0210033413,
0.0400306135,
0.0434561372,
-0.030527113,
-0.0323616751,
0.0232539289,
-0.0357495099,
0.0341989696,
-0.0147208441,
-0.0804407224,
-0.0231605079,
-0.0026380217,
0.0362804309,
0.0651644617,
0.0353105664,
0.024278285,
-0.0233533476,
-0.0363739915,
0.0117949015,
0.081655018,
0.0487624705,
-0.0042694802,
0.0685957819,
-0.0335478932,
0.0093896715,
-0.0376285762,
0.0043144803,
0.0604907647,
-0.0080927769,
-0.0071405787,
-0.0173260327,
0.0360488892,
-0.016647229,
0.0064133676,
-0.0218841918,
-0.0201972015,
0.0272780098,
0.0011758154,
0.0054595592,
0.0228040684,
-0.0588895604,
0.0146556841,
0.0014840253,
-0.0156738963,
-0.0216530431,
0.0556234941,
-0.0704212263,
-0.0287741944,
0.0013376559,
-0.0841784701,
-0.0275952909,
-0.0233009178,
0.0291189421,
-0.0306324735,
0.0547021925,
-0.0496225543,
-0.0325942002,
-0.0526384786,
-0.0136990165,
-0.0236420967,
0.0341543183,
-0.031733714,
0.0358941741,
0.0270297751,
0.0191989448,
0.016797889,
0.002740423,
0.0112354113,
-0.0384706073,
-0.0059279837,
0.0179518834,
0.0069790361,
0.0256188828,
0.0252206177,
0.0184993614,
-0.0616405755,
-0.0406207852,
-0.0909763128,
-0.0130248144,
-0.0109749902,
-0.0325483866,
0.0305893291,
-0.0079095289,
-0.0160592496,
-0.0039868732,
-0.0459248051,
-0.0424000993,
0.0231754072,
0.0354660265,
0.0351311862,
0.0187148936,
-0.0103856353,
0.0096070999,
0.0069859964,
0.0082777403,
0.0496636182,
0.0185749214,
0.0468484871,
-0.0210942384,
-0.01634489,
-0.0572104082,
-0.0277405009,
-0.0086987428,
-0.0676239058,
0.0481852517,
0.0448688678,
0.0189460628,
0.0355887003,
0.0659772083,
0.0115292631,
0.0382324345,
-0.0384207107,
-0.0180236232,
0.025654519,
-0.0157905035,
0.0784897953,
-0.0017580342,
-0.0523592085,
0.0108354855,
0.0098874494,
0.0337873399,
0.0304305498,
-0.0669335127,
0.0250230599,
0.0190742798,
-0.1104163453,
-0.0061246688,
-0.0605740212,
-0.0458460413,
0.0485187098,
-0.0234887358,
-0.0182399917,
0.0676067919,
0.0037720846,
-0.0407755077,
-0.0319233462,
0.020735871,
-0.0514192693,
0.0600172244,
-0.0329244733,
0.0290967114,
0.0012679748,
-0.0173988473,
-0.0673972741,
-0.0282590929,
0.0090214862,
-0.0197367538,
0.1025495753,
-0.033323355,
-0.0226509832,
0.0070283301,
-0.0211292207,
-0.0622169524,
-0.039146129,
0.0317003056,
0.0012183859,
0.0577804819,
-0.0139373448,
0.0057878816,
-0.0157237127,
0.0229431726,
0.0256233197,
-0.0214682799,
0.016873071,
0.0173735619,
0.0144300088,
0.0349282287,
0.0703289881,
0.0148623819,
-0.0131414328,
0.0408923179,
0.0005542218,
-0.0467373431,
0.0202396102,
-0.0167044364,
0.0060516964,
0.004651628,
0.006551248,
0.0236906782,
0.0221637003,
0.0890769437,
-0.0029721016,
-0.0285333972,
0.0559415556,
0.0019778837,
-0.0457780175,
-0.0109410891,
-0.0501497015,
0.0522701293,
-0.0075206403,
0.0323674046,
-0.0280366931,
0.0180856455,
-0.0244534761,
-0.0354194976,
-0.0526940972,
-0.0192361604,
-0.0529462546,
-0.0888266936,
0.0395798124,
0.0141696818,
-0.0585382394,
0.0148623763,
0.0296186917,
-0.0004246923,
0.0380915664,
0.0233803745,
0.0106102489,
0.0086107394,
0.0109131597,
0.001828239,
-0.0171310119,
-0.0337298065,
-0.004899736,
-0.0191648975,
0.0673668906,
0.0614448041,
0.0567953289,
-0.0110062845,
-0.0196528081,
-0.0028259219,
0.0179872848,
0.0234071594,
0.0269147344,
0.0425588638,
0.029369358,
0.0083519183,
-0.0310409479,
0.00591833,
-0.0105915107,
-0.0420469791,
0.0190306716,
0.0064808028,
-0.0354248397,
-0.0207728054,
-0.0322640352,
0.0986985862,
0.0211416688,
0.0593032129,
0.0756669566,
-0.0634213686,
-0.0196546391,
-0.0452806987,
0.0022105197,
-0.1015804932,
-0.0069836648,
-0.0022139703,
0.027453538,
-0.0182997826,
-0.0777799487,
-0.0546391495,
-0.0386604741,
0.0098292893,
-0.0084439497,
-0.0101255309,
-0.0474466681,
0.0126866326,
0.0289770123,
0.0113469651,
0.0317606889,
0.031605795,
-0.0357195102,
-0.0209378097,
-0.0251552314,
-0.0658476651,
-0.0167129915,
0.0229477845,
-0.093944937,
-0.0722163394,
0.0058453637,
0.0126759885,
0.0209186673,
0.0106580667,
0.0256979987,
-0.0797347873,
0.0145525876,
0.0529894941,
0.0074693523,
0.0638945773,
0.017545253,
0.0364671648,
-0.0073229643,
0.0242029596,
0.0032300798,
0.0221556593,
0.0278018843,
0.0371718481,
0.0096027851,
-0.0744806305,
-0.0186301209,
-0.0275223423,
-0.0282005668,
-0.0170445796,
-0.0132313306,
-0.036929369,
-0.0247675162,
-0.0227501336,
-0.0222978238,
-0.0478802845,
-0.0292918198,
-0.0040485905,
-0.0192238577,
-0.030670993,
-0.0041602571,
-0.0349174477,
0.072116442,
-0.0119446749,
-0.0201652292,
0.0425158925,
-0.0023200556,
-0.041465953,
0.0046913843,
-0.0164945647,
0.0348971561,
-0.0622074381,
0.0363993645,
0.0417433083,
0.0893571228,
0.0359346569,
-0.0258206706,
0.014323255,
0.0259378012,
-0.0931860954,
-0.0332818776,
0.0308923665,
0.0242287964,
0.0281433519,
0.0196730569,
0.0568810739,
-0.0058495374,
0.0451719426,
-0.0140900761,
0.0321164094,
-0.0057342751,
-0.0237714685,
0.0162440538,
0.0122138271,
0.0142465336,
-0.0455501415,
0.0641662255,
-0.0592441671,
-0.026254965,
-0.0138026793,
0.0085376883,
-0.0158177912,
-0.0543530919,
-0.0293114763,
0.0312430356,
0.0354100727,
0.0367326587,
-0.0762568563,
-0.0140930498,
0.0551041104,
0.0212833546,
0.0514648929,
-0.0357803963,
0.011800305,
0.062695235,
-0.0050600655,
-0.0024920097,
-0.0384512655,
0.0129134068,
-0.0228991043,
0.0122654811,
-0.0903719738,
-5.491685896e-33,
-0.0364931822,
-0.0474103168,
-0.0143486708,
-0.0348196328,
-0.0510868654,
-0.032300435,
-0.0401410237,
0.0320480317,
0.0016003607,
0.0463077538,
-0.0262456276,
0.0198356286,
-0.0029810225,
0.0112057468,
0.0200007744,
-0.0271831099,
0.0333446041,
0.0135248192,
-0.0662818924,
0.0245011989,
0.035656739,
-0.0193144735,
0.0166585501,
-0.0369801633,
0.0327410772,
-0.0143506005,
-0.0170129016,
-0.023982998,
0.0170886908,
0.0585600473,
-0.0093996543,
0.0765407607,
0.0548955947,
-0.0181766618,
-0.010712184,
0.0384825021,
0.0178461708,
-0.0866028965,
0.0400984958,
-0.0170284417,
-0.041490633,
-0.0426268727,
0.0147354463,
-0.0180351697,
-0.0283857565,
-0.0373205207,
0.0260242019,
-0.0024231719,
0.0149933156,
0.0013032436,
-0.0698924288,
-0.0048551271,
-0.023208715,
-0.0350095406,
-0.0620040819,
0.0136807756,
-0.0001747044,
-0.0423555598,
-0.0396481641,
0.0538635142,
-0.0201167837,
-0.0050805127,
-0.0053860289,
0.0262587648,
-0.0071202544,
0.068162404,
0.0277728792,
0.071313709,
-0.0246969238,
-0.0271156505,
-0.0176831372,
0.021624811,
0.006130551,
0.1232969537,
0.0095000369,
-0.0045009088,
0.0135917775,
0.018319549,
0.0050828662,
-0.021102313,
0.0388975553,
-0.0169189647,
-0.0132699599,
-0.0292194206,
-0.0036875079,
-0.0048350287,
-0.0285975635,
-0.0348471999,
0.0137301935,
-0.0152681544,
0.0046011568,
-0.0062809857,
0.0409332365,
-0.020850623,
0.0036904628,
0.0376657434,
-0.0782770216,
0.0016384566,
0.0220258627,
-0.0034984739,
-0.0032128582,
0.0015832643,
0.0618646406,
0.0537729971,
0.026506003,
0.0092473933,
0.0095217796,
0.0202952661,
-0.0393402278,
-0.0049048834,
-0.0274690017,
0.0628960803,
-0.003147166,
0.006890818,
-0.0152427731,
0.016842816,
-0.047249686,
0.0362525284,
-0.0015592334,
0.0016708219,
-0.0335905999,
-0.035001684,
-0.0173786636,
0.0221458841,
-0.0688147098,
0.0065085297,
0.015047621,
-0.0623946451,
0.0282117091,
-0.0242743548,
-0.0316284075,
-0.0209181886,
2.328e-7,
-0.0154084237,
-0.0004582407,
0.0169957504,
0.052275639,
0.0438242629,
0.0250058621,
-0.010899934,
0.0370680876,
0.0290970597,
-0.0123242112,
0.0022128099,
-0.0005556649,
0.0527802147,
0.0353429914,
-0.0726517513,
0.0078763822,
-0.0923389643,
0.030549679,
-0.0261952244,
-0.042226322,
0.0735046864,
0.0056729289,
0.0060011367,
-0.0124706402,
-0.0182394497,
0.0001730168,
0.0527898371,
-0.0415432975,
0.0059093283,
0.0237963349,
0.028665781,
-0.0671101585,
0.0420239419,
0.0463308729,
0.0144803962,
0.0229772702,
0.0175279882,
0.0257048942,
-0.0084836334,
-0.0558284707,
0.0187717024,
0.0090488596,
-0.0011122579,
-0.0364152901,
0.0034205166,
0.0068550124,
-0.0334276631,
-0.0287493188,
0.0012295021,
-0.0055193864,
0.0861896425,
-0.0498247482,
-0.015839709,
0.0031610138,
0.0273348261,
-0.0176294837,
0.0447522551,
-0.0541418232,
-0.0354557149,
-0.0400168523,
-0.0567014255,
-0.0435195118,
-0.0313412435,
-0.0163438972,
-0.0099295489,
-0.0544431098,
0.0277573932,
1.700357859e-34,
0.0410263091,
0.0014283704,
0.0254928004,
0.0331940353,
0.0291901138,
-0.0028403851,
0.0337514803,
-0.0168839134,
0.0394044146,
-0.0373398177,
-0.0248713568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02787v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02787v2
|
Context-Aware Classification of Legal Document Pages
| 2023-04-05T23:14:58 | 2023-04-25T14:59:24 |
Pavlos Fragkogiannis, Martina Forster, Grace E. Lee, Dell Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2
|
For many business applications that require the processing, indexing, and
retrieval of professional documents such as legal briefs (in PDF format etc.),
it is often essential to classify the pages of any given document into their
corresponding types beforehand. Most existing studies in the field of document
image classification either focus on single-page documents or treat multiple
pages in a document independently. Although in recent years a few techniques
have been proposed to exploit the context information from neighboring pages to
enhance document page classification, they typically cannot be utilized with
large pre-trained language models due to the constraint on input length. In
this paper, we present a simple but effective approach that overcomes the above
limitation. Specifically, we enhance the input with extra tokens carrying
sequential information about previous pages - introducing recurrence - which
enables the usage of pre-trained Transformer models like BERT for context-aware
page classification. Our experiments conducted on two legal datasets in English
and Portuguese respectively show that the proposed approach can significantly
improve the performance of document page classification compared to the
non-recurrent setup as well as the other context-aware baselines.
|
[
0.0169797037,
0.0159093384,
0.0216464866,
0.0311029647,
-0.0196503941,
0.0261877403,
0.0451621898,
0.038788043,
-0.0235340912,
-0.1084214523,
-0.0176238082,
0.0024530319,
0.0004600231,
-0.0216436666,
-0.0066584949,
-0.0501774848,
0.0192628428,
-0.0025946314,
-0.0040585417,
0.0157411918,
-0.0015705168,
-0.0028420512,
0.0180473607,
0.0159407873,
-0.0402119569,
-0.0164247509,
-0.0275436267,
0.0128310984,
0.0063048946,
0.0036098517,
0.0350076482,
0.0500704348,
0.0753278807,
0.0408709906,
0.0000015817,
-0.0543455742,
-0.0176649783,
0.0121784667,
0.0068547293,
-0.0017576136,
0.0375940055,
-0.0480764583,
-0.0269535556,
-0.0089434497,
0.0010726707,
-0.0235707723,
0.0028577375,
0.0903128907,
0.0230613686,
0.1093977988,
-0.0232839677,
-0.0799502358,
0.0429957621,
-0.0327793695,
0.0515338704,
-0.0334237367,
0.0020623575,
-0.0413488299,
0.0002865275,
-0.009535226,
-0.0144396741,
-0.0219561346,
0.0356290787,
-0.0400396325,
-0.0157325231,
0.0245659593,
-0.0089807725,
0.028035596,
-0.0004526857,
0.024574548,
-0.0358799174,
-0.0480202734,
-0.0198439136,
-0.0068929275,
-0.0070348703,
0.0203161724,
-0.020841822,
0.0426137373,
-0.0413530134,
-0.0040284307,
0.0176182147,
0.0300919283,
-0.0033616698,
0.0129239568,
-0.0623020865,
0.0084395297,
0.0169220492,
-0.0291352719,
0.0130606266,
-0.0011841927,
0.032526426,
-0.0358682759,
0.037838906,
0.0493339635,
0.0601529144,
0.001032931,
-0.0373219252,
-0.0674709827,
0.0703818277,
-0.0826571509,
-0.0146539407,
-0.0353352763,
-0.0414410979,
0.0709938407,
-0.0398663245,
0.0227238946,
-0.0159568377,
0.0277420674,
-0.0042786612,
0.0236575641,
-0.0052963593,
0.0131068528,
-0.053670153,
0.0311942734,
-0.0201003887,
-0.039928358,
-0.0115340222,
0.0385981947,
0.0070431475,
0.0214301199,
0.0006441081,
-0.0290095899,
-0.0296223443,
-0.0244272575,
0.0183838289,
-0.0271954406,
-0.011422324,
0.0307474006,
-0.0520700142,
-0.0086377906,
0.0430686176,
0.0271620154,
0.0209082086,
-0.006089828,
-0.0092230709,
0.0402500778,
-0.0005148485,
-0.085042946,
-0.0513224229,
-0.0037679616,
-0.0021591785,
-0.0389741175,
-0.0056871469,
-0.0576322079,
-0.0130897919,
-0.0130622275,
-0.0172285661,
0.0435843021,
-0.00474812,
0.0197229199,
0.005656159,
0.0892266259,
0.0433198549,
-0.0219406765,
0.0512051731,
0.0212420821,
0.0364309587,
0.01663219,
0.0176994745,
0.035360463,
0.0424113758,
-0.0210474189,
0.043739114,
0.0573723428,
-0.0033337045,
-0.0369191654,
0.0101817353,
-0.0036865638,
0.0183582772,
0.0018882819,
-0.0049846838,
-0.0006495321,
-0.022118723,
-0.0185549427,
-0.0116488012,
0.0440055393,
0.0103611425,
0.0599922128,
0.0166106597,
-0.0089607704,
-0.0001224188,
0.0281762443,
-0.0451611243,
-0.0393762179,
-0.0217710361,
0.0173898526,
-0.0379939936,
-0.0135468207,
-0.0366531461,
-0.0336519182,
-0.006806762,
-0.0243225545,
0.0392721891,
-0.0371083766,
0.0789430216,
0.0371503346,
-0.0589917265,
0.0194734707,
-0.0223096926,
-0.0746247619,
-0.0119539434,
-0.0371488445,
0.051322151,
0.0541836582,
0.05786971,
-0.0860539004,
-0.0327031054,
-0.0231044609,
0.0041161785,
0.0189639181,
0.0414044224,
-0.0185626876,
0.0165858921,
-0.0633900836,
-0.0477254651,
0.0049408111,
-0.0113770841,
0.0189154837,
0.0151483547,
0.0343411788,
0.0540947542,
-0.0638331324,
-0.0140772266,
0.0477119274,
0.0285356771,
-0.0721272603,
0.0285423063,
0.0372120664,
0.023406934,
0.0211725347,
-0.0024018136,
-0.0148618929,
0.0484108813,
-0.0232743453,
0.0038083615,
0.0137418825,
-0.0126574198,
-0.018390961,
0.0223912876,
-0.0223265775,
-0.0257536322,
-0.0200107992,
-0.0577412285,
-0.0232885908,
-0.0249029007,
-0.0073688594,
0.0691954941,
-0.0493748151,
0.0181659926,
0.0084837358,
0.0330103971,
-0.0473148748,
0.0584212802,
0.032976374,
-0.0025631904,
-0.00382363,
0.0081947539,
0.031459108,
-0.006137881,
-0.0325460397,
-0.0050234944,
-0.0247577913,
0.0106533114,
0.0724613592,
0.0547340028,
-0.0155263282,
-0.0398121402,
-0.1170227379,
-0.0101748118,
-0.0299605113,
0.0229357462,
-0.0097238375,
-0.0173799209,
0.0082935495,
-0.0427865498,
-0.0643464252,
-0.0104257911,
-0.0168842338,
-0.0089057907,
0.0439863876,
-0.0200259816,
-0.0136836153,
0.0029186341,
-0.0355609916,
-0.0005742028,
0.0368701257,
0.0397679619,
-0.0475393869,
-0.0292933621,
0.0629171655,
0.0468932986,
0.0241632536,
-0.0294872876,
-0.0063601974,
-0.0003808629,
-0.0394013263,
0.0129949236,
0.0823912397,
0.0446899608,
0.0524528101,
-0.0168998335,
0.009849106,
-0.0604215302,
-0.0096760476,
-0.0142479725,
0.0113812042,
-0.0247346722,
-0.0073108808,
0.0268799625,
0.0026412052,
-0.0525508337,
0.0160190165,
-0.0098902294,
-0.046006009,
0.0148488833,
0.0172332376,
0.0016395815,
-0.0026819927,
0.0226178169,
0.006595572,
0.0203330796,
-0.0541903377,
0.0125074489,
-0.0322380401,
0.0144034848,
-0.0519800037,
0.0424072817,
-0.0664434209,
0.0785922185,
0.0066100229,
0.0149142798,
-0.037049856,
-0.061484389,
0.0085000694,
0.0005674097,
0.0276433676,
-0.0321418829,
0.0691773295,
-0.0074229417,
0.0585504994,
-0.0509143062,
-0.053897649,
-0.0444864668,
-0.0235711243,
0.0314163826,
-0.0007883532,
-0.0494075418,
0.007700217,
-0.070016019,
0.06070894,
-0.0074090571,
0.1012940854,
-0.002609208,
-0.0185439028,
-0.0029817417,
0.0875696093,
0.0021627431,
-0.0029470667,
0.0015118711,
-0.0057658106,
-0.001480961,
0.0357756764,
-0.0141413137,
0.0256174877,
-0.0196857024,
0.0143886758,
0.0090875346,
-0.0808251277,
-0.014417531,
0.0154722407,
-0.0452257246,
-0.0821325481,
-0.0019793052,
0.1051963493,
0.0250837635,
-0.0817983374,
-0.0550124422,
0.0063692289,
-0.0597214848,
0.0146162529,
0.0151739744,
-0.0678193718,
0.0054781018,
-0.003853529,
-0.0198347066,
0.0050389539,
0.0560937524,
0.0156655237,
-0.070683226,
0.0424881838,
0.0226929802,
-0.0162092559,
-0.0232049003,
-0.0452514477,
-0.0088593131,
0.0082783746,
-0.0041021653,
-0.0237716362,
-0.0274438914,
-0.0717508495,
-0.0169391874,
-0.0030440241,
-0.0371186137,
-0.0054509491,
-0.0086893905,
-0.0406078622,
0.0484451912,
0.0206559971,
-0.0342247635,
-0.044135239,
0.0394669101,
-0.0319290906,
-0.0318147205,
-0.0319025628,
0.0173599329,
-0.0291452426,
0.0542850047,
0.0085948855,
0.0192113407,
-0.0094412817,
-0.028797796,
0.0116804298,
0.0292173009,
-0.0295821931,
-0.0398819335,
-0.0366163887,
-0.0334064662,
-0.0189954955,
0.0455573238,
-0.0022486977,
-0.0195688102,
-0.064347297,
-0.0066037537,
0.0539011993,
-0.0263566021,
0.0387171507,
-0.0312861092,
-0.0519410186,
-0.0545677356,
-0.0773996338,
-0.0276810806,
-0.0116822924,
0.0496946014,
0.0173750892,
-0.0283814706,
0.011328226,
-0.0231094435,
-0.0797791332,
0.0138167739,
0.0085635064,
0.0311816465,
-0.0743682161,
0.0013416668,
0.0381628647,
-0.0109623764,
-0.0100648738,
0.0017766539,
-0.0351031236,
-0.0319270045,
0.0173115954,
0.014828518,
0.0158249233,
0.0227997154,
-0.0265584085,
-0.0408904068,
0.0487938374,
0.0202208832,
-0.0029160108,
-0.0320619904,
0.0861917958,
-0.0039689783,
-0.0412138291,
0.0002508019,
-0.0420519486,
0.0294900369,
0.0264364276,
-0.0437964499,
-0.0329764187,
-0.0416094586,
-0.034955442,
-0.0258303564,
0.0351248719,
-0.020274831,
0.0203704163,
-0.0261181071,
0.0485684723,
-0.020300407,
-0.001443913,
-0.0006770259,
-0.0093026729,
-0.0044085649,
-0.002365608,
-0.0270458665,
0.0765768066,
-0.0129958373,
0.0173778534,
-0.0281347595,
0.0292566065,
0.0334421359,
0.0195841994,
-0.0157267954,
-0.0053116689,
-0.0163845252,
-0.0073241792,
0.0309505966,
0.0351677686,
-0.0236325897,
0.0664900616,
0.0121072726,
0.0315970406,
-0.0362121388,
0.034730494,
-0.046365872,
0.0315575041,
-0.0464222804,
0.0441195481,
0.0288193114,
-0.0516538806,
0.0052387035,
-0.0306229647,
-0.0276455749,
-0.0032442885,
0.0226258785,
0.0328431129,
-0.0127876839,
0.0078440737,
0.0284198355,
0.0075658937,
0.0373373553,
0.0477854796,
0.0114061842,
-0.0109475804,
0.000272276,
-0.007602111,
-0.0477891117,
-0.0018052639,
0.0532475673,
0.0187462475,
0.0072197807,
-0.004151986,
-0.0358422175,
-0.0064044623,
0.0566391498,
0.0038300245,
-0.0017807493,
0.0459800512,
0.0401284583,
0.0684231892,
0.0225328784,
0.0017149094,
-0.0124010229,
0.0383806303,
0.0110024316,
-0.018604219,
-0.0323623233,
-4.806225018e-33,
-0.0248734448,
-0.0445980839,
-0.0073532276,
0.0292740427,
-0.0234767459,
0.0057090605,
-0.0155590978,
-0.0614604279,
0.0286644828,
0.0072307917,
-0.0221750624,
0.0106481165,
0.04328648,
0.0389975607,
0.0044072154,
-0.005088029,
0.0540007837,
0.0132401539,
-0.0275837798,
0.0404504612,
0.0118499575,
-0.0047313734,
0.0355399773,
-0.053991437,
0.0147907678,
-0.0028722875,
-0.0213659052,
-0.0248688404,
0.0147437565,
0.0566809624,
-0.0077156327,
-0.00205618,
0.0533750579,
-0.0306296088,
0.0142141236,
0.1026696712,
-0.1275106519,
-0.0097001549,
-0.0329806916,
0.0397959352,
0.0479000434,
-0.0390465483,
0.0154609419,
-0.0454113372,
-0.01389335,
0.0006547825,
0.0679259896,
-0.0116992574,
-0.0474464558,
-0.0765483081,
-0.0755786374,
0.0429846458,
-0.0055185147,
0.0208055247,
0.0498169549,
-0.013959541,
0.0056472016,
0.0331341214,
-0.078806527,
-0.0066579669,
0.0017886999,
0.0136999842,
0.0251058303,
-0.0090912227,
-0.0009353018,
-0.0184981786,
0.0067592324,
0.016766889,
-0.0078243343,
-0.0227736272,
0.0446621142,
0.018570764,
0.0255034398,
0.0015291617,
0.0486689582,
-0.0231520608,
-0.0300024077,
0.0497126728,
0.0488870405,
0.0271836519,
0.0030615102,
-0.0337561257,
-0.0442722179,
-0.001709224,
0.0178749841,
-0.04389029,
0.0009037151,
0.0153220613,
0.015089009,
0.0447658859,
0.0448445529,
-0.0234313961,
0.034520328,
-0.0157247577,
-0.0253394321,
0.0414102003,
0.0196447372,
0.0400032327,
-0.0292227305,
-0.0107747288,
0.0001701407,
-0.0611705333,
0.0352413394,
-0.0086644813,
-0.0200708099,
-0.0138859088,
0.0809665546,
0.0106027042,
-0.0700955763,
-0.0015419732,
0.0177585054,
0.0024469453,
0.034269277,
0.0710486546,
0.0147343827,
0.0124636674,
0.0285864435,
0.0489656702,
0.0074832672,
0.0012827532,
-0.0052311062,
-0.0449737385,
0.0090410067,
0.0302514173,
-0.0029318207,
-0.0146064498,
-0.0019313806,
0.0532839634,
0.0201108493,
-0.0492214076,
0.0228147898,
0.0462672412,
2.241e-7,
0.0509273484,
0.0254124925,
0.0539454371,
-0.0297964979,
0.0401049741,
0.0131888958,
0.0246528983,
0.0270045716,
-0.0413280018,
0.0363454632,
0.0279716346,
-0.0325529613,
0.062855199,
-0.0145187639,
-0.05713493,
-0.0043030931,
-0.0663847029,
0.0000408912,
-0.0548695624,
0.0274433102,
0.0466868244,
0.0934580564,
-0.0053887186,
-0.0425111763,
0.0076849684,
-0.0334867239,
0.0438514128,
-0.0317101963,
0.0096726604,
0.0186245535,
0.0665701851,
-0.0020195215,
-0.0085956957,
-0.0036185556,
-0.020334173,
0.0816313177,
-0.0113404579,
0.0585677661,
-0.0084695434,
0.0056946604,
-0.0113017801,
-0.0490272231,
0.014169028,
-0.0371522494,
0.0582035296,
-0.0055625974,
0.0249750726,
-0.0091355033,
-0.0088214995,
-0.0428519212,
0.0177085288,
-0.0135185756,
-0.0216490328,
0.039040897,
0.0688607097,
-0.0532657132,
0.0175714809,
-0.1362426132,
0.0205584057,
0.0056493217,
-0.0266126692,
0.073249869,
-0.0117113721,
-0.0125013068,
0.0528016202,
-0.0247693975,
0.0288630482,
2.08932894e-34,
0.0640078187,
-0.0157275591,
-0.0252816621,
0.0109615,
0.0087669706,
-0.0116877574,
0.0150715653,
0.0188578498,
0.0118112396,
-0.062719211,
0.0098255407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02785v1
|
Performance of Data Augmentation Methods for Brazilian Portuguese Text Classification
| 2023-04-05T23:13:37 | 2023-04-05T23:13:37 |
Marcellus Amadeus, Paulo Branco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving machine learning performance while increasing model generalization
has been a constantly pursued goal by AI researchers. Data augmentation
techniques are often used towards achieving this target, and most of its
evaluation is made using English corpora. In this work, we took advantage of
different existing data augmentation methods to analyze their performances
applied to text classification problems using Brazilian Portuguese corpora. As
a result, our analysis shows some putative improvements in using some of these
techniques; however, it also suggests further exploitation of language bias and
non-English text data scarcity.
|
[
0.0254494939,
0.0763139725,
-0.0173943173,
0.0367861912,
0.0058868178,
0.0208000597,
-0.0028504641,
0.0117112389,
-0.0170875452,
-0.0456076786,
-0.0378454775,
-0.0384290665,
0.0056635719,
0.0224657133,
0.0256525129,
-0.035877727,
0.0429665446,
0.0068499581,
-0.0540118217,
-0.0168272499,
-0.0151850777,
-0.0106282253,
0.0210029092,
-0.0085422732,
0.0304584838,
0.0405018702,
-0.0042992011,
-0.0328312553,
0.0112013407,
0.0168397035,
-0.0029320444,
0.0485891663,
-0.024113629,
0.0705021396,
0.0000019392,
-0.0719449222,
-0.0296663512,
0.0009428721,
-0.0247580241,
0.006423031,
0.0681541786,
-0.0536719114,
0.0109307272,
0.0219886675,
-0.0669151321,
-0.0599770769,
0.0423549898,
0.0158606544,
0.0159733389,
0.1117798388,
-0.0244056899,
-0.0340051278,
0.0622071698,
-0.0320774615,
0.0293507595,
0.0118295942,
0.0438768975,
-0.0074240095,
0.004739692,
0.0220100228,
0.0086625796,
0.014879345,
0.0155599052,
-0.0057313126,
0.0382950604,
-0.0004850612,
-0.0226284415,
-0.0045701843,
0.0061452314,
-0.0091849398,
0.0160657857,
-0.0365209654,
-0.0578473173,
0.0168522969,
0.0198735446,
0.0111582167,
-0.0348778926,
-0.0220409911,
0.0065552164,
0.0207672454,
0.0594753027,
0.0111653144,
0.058024656,
0.0584266707,
-0.021807434,
0.058824867,
0.0010592943,
-0.0444585681,
0.0493597463,
0.0495291352,
-0.0013969338,
-0.0202540066,
0.0006730483,
0.040858034,
0.0191766489,
0.003511193,
-0.0226680543,
-0.0514037125,
0.0348419361,
-0.075477995,
-0.0163156725,
-0.0010297638,
-0.0247353781,
0.0321873166,
-0.0373417772,
-0.0221595597,
-0.0247291587,
0.0157207493,
-0.0374627449,
-0.0445269793,
-0.0456068777,
-0.0031085205,
-0.0286693741,
0.042498488,
-0.0235022157,
0.0245414488,
-0.0980088636,
0.017971633,
-0.0140346959,
0.0013238206,
-0.0068592681,
-0.011194909,
-0.0121522499,
0.0090579921,
-0.0198469944,
-0.022474369,
-0.040248882,
0.0367368348,
-0.041466374,
-0.0486853756,
0.0275137573,
0.0112124095,
-0.0046012183,
-0.060115844,
0.050276123,
0.0018321029,
-0.0187809505,
-0.0563820004,
-0.0263261348,
0.0196314547,
-0.0108193737,
-0.0671834126,
-0.0404189155,
-0.0444509499,
-0.0064287535,
0.0000871055,
0.0043113991,
-0.012879841,
-0.0178723596,
-0.0280724224,
-0.0041704401,
0.0469628498,
-0.0799693316,
-0.0216958746,
0.0501829721,
-0.0097102914,
-0.0201946255,
0.0638065264,
-0.0037482062,
-0.002963522,
0.0393970087,
-0.0113286655,
0.028835794,
0.0537043996,
-0.0066632186,
0.0160760432,
-0.0150618395,
0.0079022776,
-0.028805837,
-0.015783878,
0.021253936,
-0.0237169657,
-0.01798857,
0.0172608569,
0.0161984209,
-0.0130275199,
0.0275233556,
0.0441416465,
0.0139043164,
-0.0388976745,
0.0413673334,
0.0172418095,
0.0102394801,
-0.0619771257,
-0.0354185514,
0.0138633652,
-0.0043835882,
0.0286899861,
-0.0253573433,
-0.0716485977,
0.0155326128,
-0.0474928878,
0.0665432513,
0.0200131852,
0.0921527594,
-0.0034614345,
0.0477365218,
-0.0637074187,
0.0396344811,
-0.0356347933,
0.0111429486,
-0.0382873453,
0.0033410699,
0.0248461664,
0.0165100116,
-0.0852778554,
-0.0164542887,
-0.0149392253,
-0.0001720801,
-0.0107518481,
0.0284274109,
-0.0069359066,
0.0119259031,
-0.0430135466,
-0.0170522463,
0.0151996948,
0.0226021484,
0.04284513,
0.0033648463,
0.059303496,
0.0309131704,
-0.0221401285,
-0.0512630939,
0.0451402143,
-0.0240893736,
-0.0022720667,
0.0584865436,
0.0183608197,
0.0110494494,
0.0496523827,
0.0156841129,
-0.0667430013,
0.0234370641,
-0.0349962488,
-0.0307882912,
0.0131872259,
0.0335521735,
0.0075097512,
0.0453948081,
-0.0116851591,
-0.0013695968,
0.0289644301,
-0.0052334089,
-0.0500145294,
0.0035136342,
-0.0146891177,
0.0451740213,
-0.0400259383,
0.0388948284,
-0.0856765583,
0.0388825014,
-0.0042959601,
0.0601798855,
0.02049651,
0.0176904723,
-0.0029264684,
-0.0206402279,
0.044677496,
-0.0421435982,
-0.0187486466,
0.002333198,
0.0077225221,
-0.0026198467,
0.0276121497,
-0.0211938359,
-0.0214864016,
0.0164758768,
-0.1197213531,
-0.0055022901,
-0.0279116128,
0.022349054,
0.0077871778,
0.0513329804,
-0.0133978603,
-0.0032540385,
-0.0122231375,
-0.066104643,
-0.0159450918,
0.0020589412,
0.0068111015,
0.018269578,
0.0253895838,
-0.015020364,
0.0171692092,
0.0242171474,
0.0446341,
0.0338585936,
-0.0716007054,
-0.0598203354,
0.0012942201,
-0.0204756875,
0.0301979966,
-0.0084109418,
-0.032589633,
-0.0509042814,
0.0132204546,
-0.0199262146,
0.0289616771,
-0.0195721872,
-0.0117337294,
0.0505022667,
0.0952961668,
-0.0337035619,
-0.0079975529,
-0.0059284135,
0.0393025838,
-0.0620380417,
-0.0353093781,
0.0417317189,
0.052267354,
-0.0370114781,
-0.0259408969,
0.0122764036,
0.0075126546,
0.0032912483,
-0.0137108034,
0.0027768277,
-0.0229816437,
-0.0063564577,
0.038957797,
0.015642453,
-0.0492116995,
0.0591122732,
-0.0359928869,
0.0012986634,
-0.0766358525,
-0.0650735572,
-0.038692411,
0.0129346885,
0.029216107,
0.0083593577,
-0.0335093252,
-0.013076528,
0.0205731113,
0.0250504296,
0.0259986576,
-0.0113522559,
0.0240685679,
-0.0010886106,
0.0079601025,
-0.0080190236,
-0.0535880253,
-0.0272081513,
-0.0544239283,
0.0078275073,
-0.0061820825,
0.0452268645,
-0.0161360893,
-0.0206254665,
0.0033599182,
0.012233994,
0.062991634,
-0.0351237692,
-0.0273937769,
0.0203088894,
0.0084381308,
0.0224569347,
-0.0001372737,
-0.0345456675,
-0.0149475839,
-0.0028388242,
-0.0145520028,
0.0022063835,
-0.0333501808,
-0.0504541732,
-0.00514293,
0.0267559756,
-0.0084112817,
-0.0498284623,
-0.0517078638,
-0.000268603,
-0.0094105117,
0.0045691682,
0.0825355202,
0.0303967353,
-0.0748091936,
-0.0127040753,
-0.0457786284,
0.0152754439,
0.0236308612,
0.0463547371,
-0.0494985543,
-0.0045567746,
-0.0092936149,
0.0150113693,
-0.0280934777,
0.0018499016,
-0.0021122277,
-0.1017871946,
0.023517875,
-0.0149702188,
-0.0634501949,
-0.0352147035,
-0.037846908,
0.0093316063,
-0.0504029393,
0.0000831203,
-0.0391619243,
0.0251157768,
0.0094338357,
0.0609208681,
-0.0293539297,
-0.1042515934,
-0.0793741122,
0.0007783643,
-0.0059756702,
0.0354336388,
0.0172182973,
-0.0528376512,
0.0276719257,
0.050282646,
0.0283361413,
-0.0042618611,
-0.0373343639,
0.0697808191,
0.0158874281,
0.0032221025,
0.0220037159,
0.0213672016,
0.0459771045,
0.0325066112,
0.059043698,
0.0681273341,
-0.0166450106,
0.0260798801,
-0.0197219532,
-0.0732210875,
-0.0059274239,
0.0074741365,
-0.0024632534,
-0.0705303326,
0.0369261764,
-0.002197016,
-0.0214623865,
-0.0104240784,
0.0483204983,
0.0480308942,
-0.0572297014,
-0.091804564,
-0.0603473,
-0.0996249244,
0.0010990604,
0.0095953485,
0.0235975422,
0.0548557192,
-0.0384848192,
-0.0342976861,
-0.0110976612,
0.0166283082,
0.0145630427,
0.0062612207,
0.00525644,
-0.031442184,
-0.0300571583,
-0.049618341,
-0.0137459645,
-0.0549719855,
-0.0444089174,
-0.0447181314,
0.00071393,
0.0076229051,
0.0271630026,
0.0637228936,
-0.0503643379,
-0.1110609546,
0.0311118886,
0.0624271668,
-0.0383952633,
-0.011783178,
0.0394302122,
-0.0416091979,
-0.002907289,
-0.0003571784,
-0.0104676494,
0.0225718524,
0.0208845437,
-0.0172081273,
-0.0664519444,
0.0212697573,
-0.007541602,
0.0116871502,
0.0768582001,
-0.0476953648,
-0.0126288095,
-0.0232919455,
0.0454743505,
0.0085911928,
-0.0156014506,
0.0100872545,
0.0080290744,
0.0697643161,
-0.0185890328,
-0.0205170363,
0.019141905,
-0.0393423364,
-0.0290378444,
-0.0377265215,
0.0069062542,
0.0392024554,
0.051113598,
0.0045194933,
0.0520466641,
0.008989268,
0.0009164056,
0.039921876,
0.0246441308,
-0.0303815082,
0.0059625469,
0.0006409642,
0.0021385474,
0.0036946856,
0.030984249,
-0.0241225772,
0.0503767356,
-0.0341068506,
0.0411438681,
0.0494057685,
-0.0552307852,
0.0385423973,
-0.0108282212,
-0.0153710358,
-0.0079146996,
-0.0031493863,
0.0174821764,
-0.0023369065,
-0.011166201,
-0.018330846,
-0.0488478579,
0.0485503972,
0.0504658408,
-0.0097831097,
0.0052139657,
-0.0043011792,
-0.0484614745,
-0.0251217559,
0.0053721387,
0.0748223215,
0.0136314137,
-0.057888981,
-0.006877962,
-0.0270547085,
-0.0448173247,
0.0159970522,
-0.0445876829,
-0.0014930194,
0.0005707695,
-0.0122761363,
0.0605223961,
-0.0124353012,
0.0308744814,
-0.0393187329,
0.0053342683,
-0.0158443712,
0.0368028134,
-0.0096618412,
-5.177824496e-33,
0.0317625962,
-0.0101630101,
-0.0147233019,
-0.0219754465,
0.0178794749,
0.0176261533,
0.0243319049,
0.0099245002,
-0.0151303262,
0.0149789751,
-0.002424519,
0.0130738318,
0.0197866485,
0.023637211,
-0.000660287,
0.0014167703,
0.0021053627,
0.0209205598,
-0.0377700552,
-0.016502481,
-0.0005669174,
0.0318682939,
0.0774220154,
-0.0531254821,
0.0833670795,
-0.0101299845,
-0.0151864085,
-0.0001024316,
0.0334905833,
0.0548320077,
0.014645746,
0.0587853231,
0.0262815915,
-0.0399333648,
0.0203099269,
0.0100350529,
-0.0197084043,
-0.0374631658,
0.0183042716,
0.0615115799,
0.0137350298,
-0.0046435622,
0.0325180776,
0.0024039815,
-0.0099875042,
0.0176753365,
0.0620299578,
-0.0686805919,
-0.0347694121,
-0.0136291636,
-0.0667041168,
0.0500785746,
0.0178051684,
0.0456447639,
0.0749026611,
0.0846963003,
-0.0029456283,
-0.0082774227,
-0.0410348028,
-0.0080162492,
0.0614640638,
0.0160084758,
0.0314042084,
0.0237562284,
-0.0239545107,
-0.0035343682,
0.0201085545,
-0.0019220355,
-0.0252355635,
0.063331522,
0.0546600148,
-0.0090399645,
0.0507269911,
0.1019397303,
0.0847470313,
-0.0132801589,
-0.0867139995,
0.0719731376,
0.0237825066,
-0.0380866565,
0.0040935487,
-0.0103160916,
-0.0600909926,
-0.0043758936,
-0.0150727481,
0.0062700934,
-0.0155842248,
-0.0443857275,
-0.0281501897,
-0.0119564161,
-0.0527249202,
0.0290243737,
-0.0256768689,
-0.0371603444,
-0.0593333468,
0.0010073505,
-0.0347879268,
0.0461063385,
0.0089988289,
-0.0212304704,
0.0046977326,
-0.0315603912,
0.0032757253,
0.0546851195,
0.0091852415,
-0.0303411838,
0.0995475948,
-0.0241223704,
-0.0344793312,
0.0203166138,
-0.0032105329,
0.0280947555,
0.0034902079,
0.0706189349,
-0.0038134446,
0.0263097454,
0.0035679371,
0.0460250899,
0.0421902053,
0.0343270563,
-0.0409410149,
-0.0621916465,
0.0179949421,
-0.0214579571,
-0.0256909467,
-0.0100232549,
0.0172816701,
0.0146330399,
-0.0007730451,
-0.053588938,
-0.006224182,
-0.0356877558,
2.472e-7,
0.045658119,
0.0479680076,
-0.0065664002,
-0.0261881407,
-0.0043035755,
0.0256913658,
-0.0246750508,
-0.0051527442,
-0.0099527799,
0.0282957647,
0.0281228498,
-0.0040361686,
0.0465263575,
0.0400204621,
-0.0452444702,
-0.0325406231,
-0.0473063551,
0.0012653557,
-0.0261960048,
0.0341067947,
-0.0119817676,
0.1100797653,
0.0478747226,
-0.0567234382,
-0.00705386,
-0.0312732123,
0.0394947492,
-0.0220348649,
-0.0189241916,
0.0363141187,
0.0552568063,
0.0648033395,
0.0041342238,
0.0238151904,
-0.0261536483,
0.0510071777,
0.0037254123,
0.0053301146,
-0.0452283584,
0.083835125,
-0.0015171437,
-0.0092675462,
-0.0071841311,
-0.0450973064,
0.064152725,
-0.0010554824,
-0.0107283322,
-0.023042554,
-0.0079156132,
-0.0028002812,
0.0502350256,
-0.0300340094,
-0.0212479793,
0.0364761055,
0.0295149405,
-0.0518743359,
-0.0310537331,
-0.0546833538,
-0.0345619284,
0.0281382184,
-0.0060704597,
-0.008839258,
-0.0096859392,
0.0634251162,
0.0161250588,
-0.040871866,
0.0516640507,
1.840573557e-34,
-0.0059499703,
0.0190889779,
-0.0107555352,
-0.0222639032,
0.0107767014,
-0.0160164572,
0.0103929872,
0.0265580639,
0.0094519816,
-0.0289467312,
0.0330409966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02768v1
|
Application of Transformers based methods in Electronic Medical Records: A Systematic Literature Review
| 2023-04-05T22:19:42 | 2023-04-05T22:19:42 |
Vitor Alcantara Batista, Alexandre Gonçalves Evsukoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The combined growth of available data and their unstructured nature has
received increased interest in natural language processing (NLP) techniques to
make value of these data assets since this format is not suitable for
statistical analysis. This work presents a systematic literature review of
state-of-the-art advances using transformer-based methods on electronic medical
records (EMRs) in different NLP tasks. To the best of our knowledge, this work
is unique in providing a comprehensive review of research on transformer-based
methods for NLP applied to the EMR field. In the initial query, 99 articles
were selected from three public databases and filtered into 65 articles for
detailed analysis. The papers were analyzed with respect to the business
problem, NLP task, models and techniques, availability of datasets,
reproducibility of modeling, language, and exchange format. The paper presents
some limitations of current research and some recommendations for further
research.
|
[
0.0673914105,
0.0569939539,
-0.0070814569,
-0.0297925789,
-0.0432665832,
0.024006376,
-0.0137617914,
0.0243993141,
-0.0199101251,
-0.0629098415,
0.0417051315,
-0.0405862741,
0.0413395502,
0.0151657574,
-0.017655272,
-0.0400411673,
0.0156303924,
0.0551242903,
-0.0111871287,
0.0468449183,
-0.0216406323,
0.0029813321,
-0.0033873678,
0.0468947142,
0.0109214094,
0.0306679606,
0.0128571512,
-0.0048215119,
0.0103566805,
-0.0562118031,
-0.0392848141,
0.0219303425,
-0.03221922,
-0.0168763194,
0.0000018588,
-0.036193341,
-0.0765554085,
0.0526827611,
-0.0335296802,
-0.0707991943,
0.0324027464,
-0.0980712622,
-0.020274898,
0.0199821517,
-0.0197016746,
-0.0356076695,
0.0581738465,
0.0794273615,
0.053352423,
0.0432282314,
-0.0523579866,
-0.0261972975,
0.0243795104,
0.0296273846,
-0.0150263943,
0.0147303417,
0.0423585176,
-0.0046079624,
0.0230608638,
-0.0291397721,
-0.0015717951,
0.0282772109,
-0.0434452854,
0.0138979368,
-0.019925341,
0.0167875849,
-0.0391684212,
0.0072439685,
-0.0223180298,
0.0059100264,
0.0140721621,
0.0200368166,
0.0408637337,
-0.0223458186,
-0.0316652432,
0.0338780247,
-0.0216140207,
0.0075141345,
-0.0556668676,
-0.006104406,
-0.0101340944,
0.0293038934,
-0.0165592097,
-0.0347369537,
-0.0700122938,
0.0215185806,
0.0012424371,
-0.051141765,
0.0212880932,
-0.0193185098,
0.0352907479,
-0.0098576564,
0.0350273214,
0.023283042,
-0.005978121,
0.0314431451,
0.0032321631,
-0.0645348504,
0.070500508,
-0.0373241082,
0.0324426293,
0.0069604572,
0.0375383571,
0.0184050016,
0.0048952992,
-0.0082926163,
-0.0236511249,
0.0049345144,
-0.031924095,
-0.0034810062,
-0.0644889846,
-0.0284815226,
-0.0292603243,
0.0293639582,
-0.0074517098,
0.0023104893,
-0.0913442373,
-0.0160207041,
0.0195622593,
-0.0082417764,
0.0625114664,
0.0244323649,
-0.0173742231,
0.0089510288,
-0.0378950648,
0.0238237176,
0.033950299,
-0.0094963042,
-0.0280986056,
-0.0346402377,
0.0530276038,
0.0153925689,
0.0316680223,
-0.003802228,
0.0186704062,
0.0424127094,
0.0402171053,
-0.0405160636,
-0.0406905897,
-0.0165999252,
-0.005517053,
0.0228996929,
0.0072466237,
-0.0332688279,
0.0147624398,
0.0358651876,
0.0094092805,
-0.0334745944,
0.0184671562,
0.0385461859,
-0.0434512869,
0.0688261688,
-0.0456413142,
0.0079608904,
-0.0150097311,
-0.0180199463,
0.0364069082,
-0.000185282,
0.0392452255,
-0.066614911,
0.0087005412,
-0.0178795699,
0.0501012802,
0.0051785773,
-0.0213672705,
-0.0963008776,
0.0255062021,
0.0176846888,
-0.0376571827,
0.0036037471,
-0.0570677817,
0.0640471876,
0.0118580125,
0.0011110868,
0.0102497656,
0.0548800044,
0.0589606911,
0.0349722281,
-0.0133334137,
0.0118448632,
-0.0144049888,
-0.0125625683,
0.0274105985,
-0.010893249,
0.0556523241,
0.0000811439,
-0.0543559827,
0.0170634724,
-0.0136824809,
-0.0453333892,
-0.0487893373,
-0.0336898714,
0.0296767857,
-0.0276066363,
0.0414585844,
0.0380298868,
-0.0349778049,
0.1055333167,
0.0150501737,
-0.0157228243,
-0.046242483,
-0.0465429351,
-0.0984192267,
0.0468935594,
0.0553783476,
-0.0430182256,
-0.0414045192,
-0.0414527431,
-0.0484214611,
0.0087074004,
-0.044607006,
0.0108764367,
-0.0180072617,
-0.039823316,
0.0010182773,
0.0792428553,
-0.0049052588,
-0.040136382,
-0.0322740115,
-0.0016029767,
-0.0122288028,
-0.0176203772,
-0.0126620615,
0.0316874348,
-0.049051173,
-0.0029607322,
0.0367781892,
0.0258110836,
0.0111506199,
0.0384719335,
0.0201299973,
0.0430922806,
0.0377874002,
-0.015569861,
-0.054973416,
0.0392311104,
0.0297616553,
0.0271268785,
-0.0101619735,
-0.0571357273,
0.002426852,
-0.0307737105,
0.0231428407,
-0.0147471065,
-0.0653937012,
-0.0638192818,
0.0313606448,
-0.0267547779,
0.056494303,
0.0300498754,
-0.0066710352,
-0.0563002564,
-0.0026465333,
-0.0224662255,
0.012886297,
0.02122912,
-0.0996501222,
0.0327265561,
0.0023113322,
-0.0054736352,
0.0283771679,
-0.0276556686,
0.0217090789,
0.0128419586,
-0.0230766665,
-0.0133264698,
-0.0488842316,
-0.0643019155,
-0.0315180123,
0.0250240937,
0.046915222,
0.001912447,
0.0627092272,
0.0178299285,
-0.0068109753,
-0.0120466966,
-0.0354163162,
0.0261083972,
-0.0106749376,
0.0435223803,
0.0266882069,
-0.0062242993,
0.0122903781,
-0.0122053176,
-0.0470666401,
0.037636321,
0.0206067897,
-0.026050996,
-0.0608007461,
-0.0118255438,
-0.0033700154,
-0.0015898336,
-0.0248933937,
0.0013374581,
-0.0002825299,
0.0102091236,
0.0392002538,
0.0237566307,
-0.0003791614,
0.0218073148,
-0.001043909,
-0.017085569,
-0.007273626,
-0.0081056627,
-0.0525296293,
0.0314710028,
-0.0117041701,
-0.057842806,
0.06638024,
0.0305277053,
0.010931992,
-0.0026684606,
-0.0046443781,
-0.0345307253,
-0.0156333335,
0.0517910048,
-0.0014557788,
-0.005991898,
-0.0354605876,
0.0380904675,
0.0398340598,
0.010533005,
0.075737536,
-0.013976045,
0.0294632725,
-0.1056051478,
-0.0297010615,
-0.050076969,
0.0071065063,
-0.0063541667,
0.0108003709,
0.0413744077,
-0.056290824,
0.0281092376,
0.0064819697,
0.0146349547,
-0.0307018645,
0.0709557012,
0.0134494994,
0.0257628951,
-0.0078955293,
-0.0140396962,
-0.0460033454,
-0.0119131487,
0.0121150799,
0.0195619706,
0.0490563065,
-0.0010169838,
-0.0781824216,
0.0692968667,
-0.0060399543,
0.0418479554,
0.0318301506,
-0.0395512991,
0.0042037647,
0.0256406516,
0.0171399396,
-0.0114613539,
0.0171019342,
0.0414881073,
0.0056936871,
0.0570490845,
0.0138231274,
0.0222709402,
-0.0103050563,
-0.0191952903,
-0.0001613061,
-0.0805002898,
-0.0031797781,
0.0294948984,
-0.0501359403,
-0.0388418175,
0.0253514647,
0.0603857078,
0.0296372492,
-0.0171541665,
0.0006500117,
0.0210116655,
-0.0906266496,
-0.0112960488,
0.0289969705,
-0.0385771282,
0.026782047,
-0.0140191736,
0.0118195834,
-0.0287530366,
-0.0409473367,
0.0313539654,
-0.0418228395,
0.0390169807,
-0.0497351997,
0.002240822,
-0.0579561479,
-0.0588301495,
0.0017323765,
-0.0345646441,
-0.0246258192,
-0.0149693033,
-0.0588260479,
-0.0439414792,
0.0064042974,
-0.0871518701,
-0.0729540437,
-0.0334325843,
-0.0217829365,
0.0116160922,
0.0392750204,
0.0422791764,
-0.0382677503,
-0.0340742469,
-0.0379188806,
0.0002204845,
0.0156102004,
-0.014389148,
0.0661827177,
0.0068700775,
-0.0091884546,
-0.0468454659,
-0.0133169685,
-0.0197632685,
-0.0189111121,
-0.025294045,
0.0743873194,
-0.05564861,
0.0139376801,
-0.0272976384,
-0.0052943458,
0.0377307348,
0.0065101096,
-0.0309562124,
-0.00217795,
-0.0145782782,
0.0213954002,
0.0629101321,
0.0323789008,
-0.0497267395,
0.0621280558,
-0.0271237642,
-0.0650422722,
-0.0502927043,
-0.0124024926,
0.0331206582,
0.0342714265,
0.0424637832,
0.0209602248,
0.1255660802,
-0.0142170396,
-0.0630751476,
-0.0034482277,
0.0360056013,
0.003803781,
-0.0425073579,
-0.0207470395,
0.0565737113,
0.0433152132,
-0.017769685,
-0.0459110551,
-0.0074258815,
0.0008802429,
0.0429324806,
0.0161420889,
0.0202158298,
-0.0370083712,
0.0097326366,
-0.0095098261,
-0.0018299058,
0.0512294322,
-0.0284039974,
-0.069513984,
-0.0011877468,
0.0004770642,
-0.0309521761,
-0.0236905832,
0.0200965498,
0.016756814,
0.0045234836,
0.0352469385,
-0.0102636889,
-0.0134729324,
0.0283380449,
0.022790065,
0.0530127212,
-0.0146088321,
-0.0143881654,
-0.000482794,
0.0248799194,
-0.0286310446,
0.0123699559,
-0.0170764476,
-0.0184237249,
-0.0107520325,
0.0193572156,
-0.0175368581,
0.0272360537,
-0.0845221579,
-0.0399285182,
-0.0278092679,
0.1053049192,
0.0030728232,
-0.011138428,
0.0169524252,
-0.0392298065,
0.0303593762,
-0.0102428468,
0.0641129091,
0.037172202,
-0.0077507198,
0.053963732,
0.0038466484,
0.021313604,
-0.0585376211,
0.0532952733,
-0.0166747477,
0.011132949,
-0.0043406226,
-0.0055943099,
-0.0094613945,
0.0098909326,
0.0067637381,
-0.0512926877,
0.0027243984,
0.0152677139,
0.0277940761,
0.0201764517,
0.0431130007,
0.035720665,
0.0178444013,
-0.0266357623,
-0.0131076751,
0.0389217176,
-0.031186752,
-0.0083761802,
-0.0305646546,
-0.0591024905,
-0.0546705686,
-0.0144252367,
0.0195095055,
-0.0611247644,
-0.0439114273,
-0.0204947069,
-0.0717949644,
-0.0184005983,
0.0643158108,
-0.025625309,
0.0146816568,
-0.0415425412,
0.0366998091,
0.0226208456,
0.058471337,
-0.0005659909,
-0.0248485021,
0.0107903145,
-0.0171951167,
-0.005398707,
-0.0004558125,
-5.623686932e-33,
0.016089011,
-0.0525087751,
0.0227565505,
0.0159686897,
0.018233642,
0.0119200069,
0.0169536658,
0.0031937493,
0.0328106619,
-0.0166893676,
-0.0593836643,
-0.0078352243,
0.02934427,
0.0280050747,
0.0126511855,
-0.0275859199,
0.0223365854,
0.0233530495,
-0.0241816752,
-0.0276612062,
-0.0012530099,
0.0420101136,
0.0729921013,
-0.0782871395,
0.0215532929,
0.0242023766,
0.0066633015,
0.0106836567,
0.0265398119,
0.073512055,
-0.0141143287,
0.0146090863,
0.0417237729,
-0.0789115876,
0.0029845214,
0.0058312486,
-0.0912863836,
0.0223489758,
-0.0100340722,
0.0149582606,
0.043424882,
-0.0027024683,
0.0542429723,
-0.0306210984,
-0.0236329399,
0.0182461906,
0.0302219503,
-0.0086290492,
-0.0033056149,
-0.0587737113,
-0.0427394509,
0.0496183112,
0.0090486519,
0.0344478115,
0.0390317515,
0.0305979215,
-0.0385835767,
0.0209104065,
-0.0719125867,
0.0008193832,
0.0463947132,
0.0224820413,
0.0015592562,
-0.0510895252,
-0.0088669779,
0.0152374171,
-0.0004559467,
0.0059254584,
-0.04226017,
0.0047481805,
-0.0315777101,
0.0438393094,
0.0086113969,
-0.0068132011,
0.0309458859,
-0.0287456121,
-0.0406168215,
0.0740071014,
-0.0622385517,
0.0607184134,
0.0145556098,
-0.0241253786,
-0.0529549792,
-0.0211741384,
0.012322953,
0.0215463918,
-0.0049784677,
-0.0221752655,
0.0029620708,
0.0124472454,
-0.0317354389,
0.0615707561,
0.0028618842,
-0.0357300565,
-0.0215386245,
-0.0315901674,
0.0634986982,
0.0343454815,
-0.0498263203,
-0.0219502114,
0.0024072423,
-0.0181502476,
0.0486784056,
0.0293776952,
0.0339648426,
-0.0136112384,
0.0180577151,
-0.0043576495,
-0.0925161168,
0.0128953364,
0.0628236011,
-0.0048053777,
-0.0350301415,
0.0274484437,
0.010510046,
0.0371677093,
0.0037443126,
0.0288413558,
0.0052766381,
-0.0298319552,
-0.0381121039,
0.0167676304,
0.0443750881,
0.0096550928,
-0.0249455255,
0.0027895428,
-0.046208635,
0.0349503011,
0.0242986921,
-0.0123513248,
-0.0033055963,
0.0058927359,
2.63e-7,
0.0829081014,
0.0729143843,
0.0273229368,
0.0227448381,
-0.0023105689,
-0.0123174107,
0.0396545082,
-0.0343687609,
0.0203397907,
0.0205411185,
0.0558813699,
-0.0584336929,
0.0189873632,
0.0392140895,
-0.065854758,
-0.0320099927,
-0.0496130697,
-0.0442628823,
-0.025347963,
-0.0001453624,
0.0833451301,
0.0557598248,
-0.059140075,
-0.0197009426,
-0.0145264221,
0.0395456664,
0.004200107,
-0.0325899012,
0.0120026479,
0.0219822265,
0.0490526259,
-0.0185453985,
0.0288236961,
0.0451184623,
-0.0020943733,
0.0211607236,
0.0023830563,
0.057757169,
-0.0471583679,
0.0320978463,
0.0334081464,
-0.0183678418,
0.0184149146,
0.0110307457,
0.0392231867,
-0.0809762403,
-0.0475154854,
0.0177573208,
-0.0474592187,
0.0062925853,
0.0446309298,
0.0008602263,
-0.0373110846,
0.0366826244,
0.0283056628,
0.0091024674,
-0.0123851355,
-0.0485111922,
0.0200740341,
0.0103256283,
0.0123781189,
0.0065223649,
0.0511416718,
-0.0443396494,
0.0310107246,
-0.0182271097,
0.0059188455,
2.549079015e-34,
0.0074754748,
0.0178297199,
-0.0018987239,
0.0526124761,
0.0210931767,
0.0031787073,
0.0433187149,
0.0197509006,
-0.0401559249,
-0.1011005715,
-0.0161111522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02757v1
|
The Saudi Privacy Policy Dataset
| 2023-04-05T21:40:37 | 2023-04-05T21:40:37 |
Hend Al-Khalifa, Malak Mashaabi, Ghadi Al-Yahya, Raghad Alnashwan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces the Saudi Privacy Policy Dataset, a diverse compilation
of Arabic privacy policies from various sectors in Saudi Arabia, annotated
according to the 10 principles of the Personal Data Protection Law (PDPL); the
PDPL was established to be compatible with General Data Protection Regulation
(GDPR); one of the most comprehensive data regulations worldwide. Data were
collected from multiple sources, including the Saudi Central Bank, the Saudi
Arabia National United Platform, the Council of Health Insurance, and general
websites using Google and Wikipedia. The final dataset includes 1,000 websites
belonging to 7 sectors, 4,638 lines of text, 775,370 tokens, and a corpus size
of 8,353 KB. The annotated dataset offers significant reuse potential for
assessing privacy policy compliance, benchmarking privacy practices across
industries, and developing automated tools for monitoring adherence to data
protection regulations. By providing a comprehensive and annotated dataset of
privacy policies, this paper aims to facilitate further research and
development in the areas of privacy policy analysis, natural language
processing, and machine learning applications related to privacy and data
protection, while also serving as an essential resource for researchers,
policymakers, and industry professionals interested in understanding and
promoting compliance with privacy regulations in Saudi Arabia.
|
[
0.0721950382,
0.0501072817,
-0.0391601622,
-0.0388306938,
-0.0342052169,
0.0173918754,
0.086100921,
0.0080772024,
0.0353569016,
-0.0092695672,
0.0455792286,
-0.0245567076,
0.013161757,
0.0170802344,
0.0053406903,
-0.0261873286,
0.0141354706,
0.0118915038,
0.0473686121,
0.0142034004,
0.0265072193,
0.0181119051,
0.0063400632,
0.0570605062,
0.0346971639,
-0.0177746583,
0.0010513294,
-0.0428654999,
0.0306048039,
-0.0576878339,
0.0465262495,
0.0128237363,
0.0123109361,
-0.0161973145,
0.0000016263,
-0.1019178852,
-0.0068391175,
0.0212164186,
0.0060794917,
0.0378510542,
0.0135765458,
-0.054083664,
-0.0113116642,
0.0043407613,
-0.0284118913,
0.0392712429,
0.0274481662,
0.0501919389,
0.0747046992,
0.056957718,
-0.0213522185,
-0.0766554102,
-0.0403027497,
0.0026417938,
-0.0001953611,
-0.0061448305,
0.0593063086,
-0.0476198383,
-0.0404474586,
-0.011907462,
0.0326048695,
0.0159598086,
-0.0171250589,
-0.0097207073,
-0.0165689904,
-0.0246950444,
-0.0630021095,
-0.0483171791,
0.013100286,
0.0348044559,
0.0778434947,
-0.0043084584,
0.0549938157,
-0.0062128296,
0.0117785875,
0.0481648706,
0.0026913886,
0.0940768421,
-0.0574092381,
-0.0076729949,
0.0072198538,
-0.0063991002,
0.0183349345,
0.0076468806,
-0.0413809977,
0.049533464,
-0.0127407443,
-0.0539042242,
-0.0087847272,
-0.045935858,
0.0422808863,
-0.0181236714,
0.0508945063,
-0.0326627865,
0.0292563681,
-0.0082738288,
-0.0192578938,
0.0051632663,
0.098069869,
-0.0882555693,
-0.0206942391,
0.0298407171,
0.0246005151,
0.0339625217,
-0.0057509118,
-0.016259281,
0.0291491225,
0.01711802,
0.026032323,
0.0313430578,
-0.01992248,
0.027405316,
0.031371586,
0.0592404306,
-0.0434063151,
0.0412994623,
-0.105926536,
0.0321368873,
-0.0239581019,
0.0621945933,
0.000555097,
-0.0332163908,
0.0087756943,
-0.0196971558,
-0.0556960851,
-0.0794443935,
-0.0164784268,
0.0375911407,
-0.0465916172,
-0.0106784645,
0.0348881818,
-0.003191941,
0.0425674617,
0.0370501056,
-0.0294018742,
0.0767108053,
0.0569919683,
-0.0486191325,
-0.0674902871,
-0.0227527861,
-0.0084232576,
-0.0000575919,
-0.0090336083,
0.0045896578,
0.038808316,
-0.0489577986,
-0.0395038575,
-0.0232729446,
-0.0157188531,
0.0634498149,
0.012375378,
0.0421729609,
-0.0090078395,
-0.0253746472,
0.0336189866,
0.0316136256,
0.0713398755,
0.0206495151,
-0.0040408252,
0.0356418714,
0.0112027833,
0.0068788016,
0.0142188659,
0.0009539591,
0.0280988906,
-0.0066921869,
0.0199747235,
-0.0069234245,
-0.0333648138,
-0.0070969276,
-0.0514050424,
0.0026573397,
-0.0203597769,
-0.0082578762,
0.0178699829,
0.0637636185,
-0.0248168949,
0.0070669679,
-0.0181943178,
0.0408128724,
0.0170426238,
-0.0483461432,
-0.009770616,
-0.0245454144,
0.0345417522,
0.0030682676,
-0.0192324948,
0.0291449353,
0.0143024875,
-0.0413377583,
-0.0088112373,
-0.0364197902,
0.037258435,
0.0018231388,
0.0123843318,
-0.0016969187,
-0.0045990716,
-0.0240755659,
-0.0117845535,
-0.0226073749,
-0.0369306132,
-0.0120639699,
0.027886821,
0.0940089077,
-0.0247201119,
-0.0261606928,
-0.0105182333,
-0.0468030572,
0.0190248657,
0.0072071315,
-0.0092662992,
0.0046199737,
0.0316751152,
-0.0198310446,
-0.0758675858,
0.0431282632,
0.0317797735,
-0.0231385231,
0.0165944491,
0.0092268065,
0.0217092689,
0.02643626,
0.0325565636,
0.0395776667,
0.006449515,
0.016775962,
0.006506877,
0.043708019,
0.0272160992,
0.0291553903,
0.0302848388,
-0.003329715,
0.0228458159,
0.0000759159,
-0.007519322,
-0.0011956992,
0.0239871349,
0.0285910089,
0.0033777477,
-0.0820633471,
0.0008550049,
0.019526124,
-0.0536080822,
0.0018558762,
0.0205973201,
0.0225224197,
0.0242523141,
-0.0510340668,
-0.019869525,
-0.0340860635,
0.017203331,
-0.0196967088,
0.0425047129,
-0.0776196644,
-0.0300457627,
-0.0445198379,
-0.0815354288,
0.0535937138,
0.0125694647,
0.0197039787,
-0.0407037288,
-0.0438123345,
0.023680428,
0.0643584356,
0.0140429083,
-0.0370546952,
0.0427430831,
0.0136057371,
-0.0123916352,
0.019479895,
0.032520283,
-0.01611281,
0.0175897218,
-0.0147139197,
-0.0149997333,
-0.0371495113,
-0.0944419131,
-0.0511613525,
0.0235143546,
0.0628581792,
-0.0046866727,
-0.0558619872,
0.0283138119,
-0.0336426459,
-0.0149983522,
-0.024805095,
0.0120285247,
-0.046234265,
0.0351310559,
-0.0150321424,
-0.0142560434,
-0.0250656214,
-0.0266254786,
-0.0142349256,
0.0137104103,
0.0140433116,
-0.0423305109,
-0.0061531323,
0.0490242839,
0.0266231727,
0.0034537541,
0.0766689479,
-0.0080021489,
-0.0113999378,
-0.0166258588,
0.0339780562,
-0.0138174472,
-0.0395822898,
0.0564470701,
-0.053540118,
0.0020961461,
0.0344941318,
-0.0426355228,
0.0448093675,
-0.0353119075,
-0.0236120243,
-0.0815323666,
-0.0052557774,
-0.0076453867,
0.0913769528,
0.0271163601,
-0.0164404195,
0.0160929952,
0.0434541889,
0.0622978918,
-0.0064606001,
-0.034842331,
-0.0120252753,
-0.0023078264,
-0.0254594646,
0.045658011,
0.0069601983,
-0.0527319573,
0.0296258908,
-0.0160967931,
0.061266277,
-0.0209313296,
0.0063024024,
0.0009380992,
-0.0061408477,
-0.0241903346,
-0.0367363393,
-0.0148283327,
-0.0865209252,
-0.0115241334,
-0.0062570279,
0.0239808783,
-0.053656023,
-0.0006856842,
-0.0236674752,
0.0082151629,
0.0017212455,
0.0499100871,
0.000051471,
0.019963894,
-0.0947025046,
-0.0086873937,
-0.0474436246,
-0.0019724998,
0.0143068163,
-0.0324168466,
0.0416222997,
-0.0250577256,
0.0195855554,
-0.0094385231,
0.0184518006,
-0.0034387985,
-0.0374823138,
0.0027709128,
-0.0196984541,
0.0041482267,
-0.0403295755,
0.0539733768,
0.04514369,
0.0120603414,
-0.0012026412,
-0.0223691221,
0.0285955034,
-0.0513341278,
0.0011401684,
-0.0315002128,
-0.1195081323,
0.0490574762,
0.0277920421,
0.0456490852,
-0.0728350356,
-0.045717556,
-0.0037910361,
-0.0150326053,
0.0065436158,
-0.007868873,
-0.0003889417,
-0.0405282192,
-0.039832335,
0.0078687686,
-0.0212655198,
0.0042284108,
-0.0999738425,
-0.0163177606,
-0.0142094465,
0.0380903631,
-0.0620480962,
-0.0928279161,
-0.0034945051,
-0.0343152769,
0.0025717239,
0.0611070283,
0.0208927654,
-0.010778443,
-0.0473102108,
-0.0059994976,
-0.0078920666,
-0.0714419708,
0.0174007975,
0.0194943547,
0.0082206698,
-0.0061082845,
-0.0442764759,
0.0361972265,
-0.0310682189,
0.0029859392,
0.0018576313,
0.0058521908,
-0.0594007485,
0.0118178604,
-0.0167210791,
0.004179108,
-0.0141735533,
0.036002703,
-0.0418504365,
-0.0349237025,
-0.0126609495,
-0.0264171157,
-0.0282002073,
-0.0234860163,
0.0542699844,
-0.004697456,
-0.0160397384,
-0.0259354636,
-0.04535814,
0.0254499391,
-0.0313613825,
0.0008834176,
0.0542003997,
-0.0058110259,
0.0855011865,
0.0033390888,
-0.0081014074,
-0.0694925711,
-0.0233865473,
-0.0128129488,
-0.019105237,
0.0135649676,
-0.0392610542,
0.0078538591,
0.0176932048,
-0.0088958982,
-0.0036222287,
-0.0316735394,
0.0397647731,
-0.0272292737,
0.0125069637,
-0.0245392714,
-0.0131326746,
-0.0175057594,
0.0408702493,
0.0809702203,
-0.0248069353,
-0.0445593819,
0.0671846494,
0.0014749448,
-0.0390267037,
-0.002406775,
0.0075384481,
-0.0541697741,
-0.0258625261,
-0.0474897549,
-0.0089335768,
0.0075021768,
0.0371649452,
-0.011973246,
0.0019439717,
0.0170067046,
-0.002108624,
-0.0293017738,
-0.0104632499,
-0.0113878371,
-0.0124373296,
0.0005130016,
0.0015680538,
0.0339066461,
0.0006973284,
-0.003766848,
0.0181945562,
-0.0296954289,
-0.0544931069,
-0.0493832976,
0.058051452,
0.027516922,
0.0671256557,
-0.013276821,
0.0006298635,
0.0008910205,
-0.0128917992,
0.0078625977,
0.0070972932,
-0.0302402675,
-0.0320928879,
0.0200587995,
0.029191466,
0.0102681732,
0.0306508075,
-0.0041512167,
-0.0295272097,
0.0002106756,
0.0123878662,
-0.0198613834,
-0.0068914928,
-0.0017510055,
-0.0216513723,
-0.011182785,
0.0124113569,
0.0324762054,
-0.0202160571,
-0.0216549672,
0.0001107038,
-0.0262180381,
-0.045666039,
0.0277739894,
0.0387712158,
0.0428271145,
-0.0131106507,
-0.0040598465,
-0.0198074766,
-0.0337875895,
-0.0182349253,
0.0253286883,
0.0600701794,
-0.023794489,
-0.0480816998,
-0.035234306,
-0.0503621511,
-0.0428472981,
0.0086378502,
0.0052753137,
-0.0064243986,
0.0093090311,
0.0316170789,
0.0219803527,
-0.0732154921,
-0.0595546886,
-0.0147718992,
0.0001864582,
-0.0191736743,
0.0072579328,
-4.694439546e-33,
0.0167603195,
0.0005874434,
0.0178576596,
0.0143422298,
0.0218769088,
-0.0298448075,
0.0010895574,
-0.018974226,
-0.0411433578,
0.0241312105,
-0.0331282429,
0.0457706973,
0.0016179311,
0.0018124346,
0.039007429,
-0.0496859141,
0.0541499704,
-0.0028402875,
-0.0117028728,
0.0147817535,
0.0274187364,
0.0381972156,
0.0569023229,
-0.0775856823,
0.0939220265,
0.0357639417,
-0.0839610994,
0.0104097044,
0.0062582782,
0.0745918155,
-0.0359879434,
0.0055928817,
0.0288305376,
-0.0402308628,
0.0160830412,
0.0599677041,
-0.0646933168,
-0.0396870226,
-0.001016306,
0.017011987,
0.0434518531,
-0.0371357463,
0.0363638215,
-0.0020366542,
-0.0733654872,
0.0530015007,
0.0219024587,
0.0019057861,
-0.0340236761,
-0.0169654675,
-0.0479488485,
0.0176103339,
-0.0351952538,
0.0573439188,
0.0332688503,
0.0620176867,
-0.0057002986,
0.0219962876,
-0.0357607342,
0.02345304,
0.0227534119,
-0.0492372364,
0.0221386943,
-0.0188937075,
0.0259645339,
0.0452442355,
0.0176661536,
-0.0133843711,
0.0024965301,
0.0123978797,
0.0068874876,
0.0075316047,
-0.0619152449,
0.0839887485,
-0.0068883635,
-0.0336056501,
-0.0819247887,
0.0760992467,
-0.0688294098,
0.0284120627,
0.0502289832,
-0.0282818098,
-0.0535998754,
-0.0109719755,
-0.0089834286,
-0.0074392776,
0.0040469267,
0.0351891443,
0.0005860321,
0.0306032654,
-0.0553891994,
0.0511087254,
-0.0534391291,
-0.0419309512,
-0.0239999853,
0.0100926775,
0.0279264767,
-0.0606318004,
0.0460633822,
-0.009595288,
-0.048424542,
-0.0545798391,
-0.0127271973,
0.025643846,
0.0372475795,
-0.0163340177,
0.0355745405,
0.0211025178,
-0.0866682529,
-0.0028813833,
0.0121605536,
0.0088459719,
-0.0064535984,
0.0373198912,
0.0075623812,
0.011014563,
0.0122184949,
0.0282597058,
0.031488739,
0.0150975147,
-0.0534520969,
-0.0138391862,
-0.0221579149,
-0.0086794104,
0.0416957512,
-0.002474285,
-0.0204358846,
0.0322000347,
0.0764126182,
-0.0270643197,
-0.0012255743,
-0.02311082,
2.366e-7,
0.0384667441,
-0.0289776977,
-0.0150462249,
-0.0129438778,
-0.0288648065,
0.0385360159,
0.0451763123,
0.0616116971,
-0.0271596517,
0.0307533499,
0.0367091,
-0.0594108216,
0.01065805,
-0.0244401172,
-0.0732806697,
-0.0231124852,
0.0069773942,
0.0117870541,
-0.0558652282,
0.0504099727,
0.0197536405,
0.0677156746,
0.0252559837,
-0.0171480794,
0.0125949979,
0.0161207709,
-0.0114629064,
-0.0608669035,
-0.0146957394,
-0.036703337,
0.0492375679,
0.0754565522,
0.058835458,
0.009347762,
-0.0250526033,
-0.0084322784,
-0.0334158652,
0.1128538474,
0.0663106963,
0.0518706702,
-0.0006089792,
-0.0555109903,
0.0239305273,
-0.0481837094,
0.032995481,
0.0463232435,
-0.0452406369,
-0.0004482015,
0.0307567939,
-0.0175670516,
0.074307695,
-0.0053688399,
0.0049154423,
-0.0130573409,
0.038295988,
0.0185769778,
0.0146072749,
-0.0250252932,
0.0637921467,
-0.0303771142,
0.0170840509,
0.0137518104,
0.0471886918,
0.0310137533,
0.0008524728,
0.0129226269,
0.0515073165,
1.928854675e-34,
-0.00491666,
-0.040269848,
-0.0100205978,
0.0031298527,
0.0211702976,
0.0100101307,
0.0405728705,
0.0021260835,
-0.0003793375,
-0.0211616661,
0.0291860793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02754v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02754v2
|
Conceptual structure coheres in human cognition but not in large language models
| 2023-04-05T21:27:01 | 2023-11-10T17:42:31 |
Siddharth Suresh, Kushin Mukherjee, Xizheng Yu, Wei-Chun Huang, Lisa Padua, Timothy T Rogers
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Neural network models of language have long been used as a tool for
developing hypotheses about conceptual representation in the mind and brain.
For many years, such use involved extracting vector-space representations of
words and using distances among these to predict or understand human behavior
in various semantic tasks. Contemporary large language models (LLMs), however,
make it possible to interrogate the latent structure of conceptual
representations using experimental methods nearly identical to those commonly
used with human participants. The current work utilizes three common techniques
borrowed from cognitive psychology to estimate and compare the structure of
concepts in humans and a suite of LLMs. In humans, we show that conceptual
structure is robust to differences in culture, language, and method of
estimation. Structures estimated from LLM behavior, while individually fairly
consistent with those estimated from human behavior, vary much more depending
upon the particular task used to generate responses--across tasks, estimates of
conceptual structure from the very same model cohere less with one another than
do human structure estimates. These results highlight an important difference
between contemporary LLMs and human cognition, with implications for
understanding some fundamental limitations of contemporary machine language.
|
[
0.0376216099,
0.0592222288,
-0.0650328323,
0.0300914627,
-0.0469512269,
0.0231333468,
-0.0318212695,
0.0058024749,
-0.0416542254,
-0.0223045163,
-0.0431912765,
-0.0780836195,
0.0339662619,
0.0063595809,
0.0730439648,
-0.0458025038,
0.0113543132,
-0.0318984278,
0.0037306347,
0.0085149147,
-0.0344544537,
-0.0154292639,
0.0114235822,
0.0184296351,
0.0194563195,
-0.0351873301,
-0.0187574066,
-0.0446079969,
-0.0287296735,
-0.0287915841,
-0.0531602427,
0.0373954736,
0.0241140779,
-0.0023960171,
0.0000018294,
-0.0500487797,
0.0820729807,
-0.0288695879,
0.0173084941,
0.047195185,
0.0253269933,
-0.0196358766,
0.0243152212,
-0.0376900956,
-0.0229206532,
-0.0218694061,
0.0134000005,
0.055363778,
-0.0197976697,
0.0088879,
-0.0065579447,
-0.0590586923,
0.0261581782,
-0.0208459962,
0.0149536934,
0.0034994255,
0.05452957,
0.0214072373,
-0.0215771087,
-0.0037767065,
-0.0421149358,
-0.0166836362,
0.0010275523,
0.0562843718,
-0.0140354624,
0.0536261201,
0.0048662606,
-0.0366226472,
0.044764474,
0.0457798801,
0.0136913201,
-0.0154504832,
0.0011150496,
-0.0016574899,
-0.0203825086,
0.0531916395,
-0.0514481477,
0.059015438,
0.0070383851,
0.0125037814,
0.0402096547,
-0.0179502964,
0.0009932556,
0.036482159,
-0.0231469553,
0.0614916943,
0.0024164508,
-0.0425347388,
-0.007516169,
-0.0058798771,
-0.0656559691,
-0.0487992316,
-0.0153479883,
0.0053307433,
0.0005949395,
0.02566972,
0.0179949682,
-0.0064360225,
0.0385566726,
-0.0925178975,
0.0701058879,
0.0337925553,
-0.0002742396,
0.0210750848,
-0.0313209109,
0.1077625975,
-0.046196837,
0.0038244762,
-0.038110625,
0.0236620754,
-0.0450971909,
-0.0281051267,
0.011045577,
0.0241531134,
0.0139819095,
-0.0165108871,
-0.0631036833,
0.0424042605,
-0.0083939163,
-0.0306925103,
-0.0506227687,
0.0150960917,
-0.0012670808,
0.0323472656,
-0.060217429,
-0.0227241926,
-0.0530562438,
0.0448144563,
-0.0343710408,
-0.0484629422,
0.0098179281,
0.0361841843,
-0.0404021256,
-0.0157893151,
-0.0052952259,
0.0002860489,
0.0207710657,
0.0051298379,
-0.0196787231,
-0.0294755083,
-0.0167055279,
-0.0408171415,
0.0264365543,
-0.0411683396,
0.0225223713,
0.040720176,
-0.0280469563,
-0.0537747256,
-0.0246066675,
0.0099734422,
-0.0652895123,
0.0666749328,
0.0591555499,
0.0482085049,
0.0389251783,
0.0314241946,
-0.028437525,
0.0019999838,
0.0251622498,
0.0149882669,
0.0129749626,
0.0095567852,
-0.0470938347,
-0.0002585496,
-0.0267459918,
-0.0457460992,
-0.0630880892,
0.0045497511,
0.0051506176,
0.0492379814,
0.0521387458,
0.0588245057,
-0.033529181,
-0.011702124,
0.06851013,
0.1094001308,
-0.0090221781,
0.0110527743,
0.0503695644,
0.0134683913,
0.0162723996,
0.0081882467,
-0.0439059436,
-0.0158842057,
0.0120124165,
0.0136536313,
0.0041394299,
0.005600899,
-0.0351888761,
0.0067425687,
-0.0297463741,
-0.005226261,
0.0355539471,
-0.0228628013,
0.0605548695,
-0.0062916828,
0.0118285809,
0.032860823,
0.0475782305,
0.000144346,
0.0036415632,
-0.0307133906,
0.0334929973,
0.0111108646,
-0.0138407648,
0.0173500758,
0.009752322,
0.0453136489,
-0.0039811721,
0.0545027219,
0.0238519516,
0.0105866129,
-0.0129922852,
0.0094774887,
0.0319091901,
-0.0345385447,
0.0033086783,
-0.0216855612,
-0.012065853,
-0.0226620603,
-0.0035942865,
-0.0018435896,
0.019024482,
0.0694926307,
-0.0305738561,
0.0300010908,
-0.0476944819,
0.0084634293,
0.0537969396,
0.000889485,
-0.0101112984,
0.0436423495,
0.01446795,
-0.0210880525,
-0.0001945289,
0.027347086,
-0.0557352789,
-0.0003074201,
0.0111259483,
-0.0134452842,
-0.0023885935,
0.013883004,
0.0300048776,
-0.0130429873,
0.0533149801,
-0.0311153848,
0.0429361761,
-0.0477880649,
0.0368704684,
-0.0333656035,
0.0246378221,
-0.0296971556,
0.0841905102,
-0.0276095122,
0.0502164401,
-0.0062309685,
-0.0034510498,
0.0067160856,
-0.0145793539,
-0.0394677371,
0.0174719449,
0.0126174549,
-0.0390896089,
-0.002909377,
-0.015117052,
-0.065867506,
-0.0145624904,
-0.0589206442,
-0.0103235245,
0.0292482972,
0.012437352,
0.0262154229,
-0.0280324612,
0.0042925859,
0.0162321571,
-0.0072288495,
0.0268338341,
0.0027037521,
0.0597660244,
0.0379818492,
-0.0144494483,
-0.0404095948,
0.0027421669,
-0.0126527352,
-0.0258399732,
0.059997499,
-0.0199394822,
-0.0417680964,
-0.0418064371,
0.0490100011,
-0.0693486333,
0.0047015115,
-0.0238549672,
-0.0348863378,
0.0458298363,
0.0224132705,
0.0655802265,
0.0310597122,
0.021218447,
0.0609927699,
0.0916766524,
0.0026625951,
-0.0103631448,
-0.0438940413,
-0.0457933955,
0.0083587319,
-0.0056394264,
-0.0479958318,
-0.0132011538,
0.0883593634,
0.0469480753,
0.0030825206,
-0.032879252,
0.0488437861,
-0.0528142601,
-0.0380826406,
-0.022263037,
-0.0346329473,
-0.0510614626,
0.0438556336,
-0.0352484472,
-0.0234610382,
0.056583479,
-0.0158184264,
0.0184207801,
0.0202662423,
-0.0185437277,
-0.0038893085,
0.0463266335,
0.0367761627,
0.0141352862,
0.0171302315,
-0.0139676025,
-0.085789904,
0.0213554371,
0.002928766,
-0.0235126261,
0.0305794198,
-0.057459984,
-0.0309544671,
0.0062825717,
-0.0273572281,
-0.0448276214,
0.0133411968,
-0.0167614929,
0.0348244831,
0.0199186374,
0.0152017605,
-0.0200371724,
0.0331645198,
0.0430737101,
-0.0422413535,
0.0193145368,
-0.0157837309,
-0.0063190027,
0.0163548179,
0.0376653932,
0.0223912094,
0.0272842273,
-0.0151807209,
0.0012716949,
0.0493824184,
-0.0176899415,
0.0469332896,
-0.0207995418,
0.0178117268,
0.0266404748,
-0.0013171531,
-0.0477247424,
0.0331295133,
0.0075552962,
0.0011753226,
-0.0270360932,
0.1010159999,
0.0371031165,
-0.0212709904,
0.0473994873,
-0.0332723036,
0.0061475993,
0.0337678567,
-0.0027820072,
-0.0290246122,
0.0197119266,
0.0157719348,
-0.0464269109,
-0.0218744073,
-0.0486294851,
-0.0003702905,
-0.0770882741,
-0.0071337563,
-0.0281542726,
-0.0505063348,
-0.0351244919,
-0.0610617623,
0.0118132671,
0.0384220146,
-0.0048244647,
0.0054296684,
0.0124579221,
0.0005974338,
-0.0132615445,
-0.0314357318,
-0.0108215138,
0.0039923466,
-0.0284165107,
0.0545708872,
0.0184112806,
0.0551752932,
-0.0199917257,
-0.045522172,
0.0330563858,
-0.04573033,
0.0483409762,
0.0026983768,
-0.0071684388,
0.0247031804,
0.0216125697,
-0.0372001603,
0.0094360244,
-0.0363176875,
-0.0712688267,
-0.0087190028,
0.0694787204,
-0.0248405691,
-0.0379581787,
0.0135526592,
0.0300519671,
-0.0445850566,
0.0841727778,
0.0430299714,
-0.0614301227,
-0.0014360485,
0.0431635939,
0.0202217158,
0.0752040893,
-0.0370193981,
0.0141633768,
0.01241834,
0.0391154848,
-0.0685766265,
-0.0513937287,
-0.0101220254,
-0.0259694252,
0.0148571506,
0.0254719444,
0.0424188823,
-0.0460685492,
-0.0568486005,
0.0433908664,
0.0135184694,
-0.0259979479,
0.0090307184,
-0.0194304623,
0.0146573391,
-0.0418824777,
-0.0283317547,
-0.0049669906,
-0.0355431139,
-0.069108583,
0.0389475264,
-0.0269243959,
0.018004477,
0.0085572787,
0.0325462893,
-0.0563138947,
0.0103400704,
-0.0511528142,
-0.0511932336,
0.0749401003,
-0.0656475425,
0.0483764932,
0.0064724055,
0.0503281988,
-0.0139621142,
0.0224791691,
0.039328672,
0.0128117874,
-0.0073097358,
-0.011017737,
0.0427922755,
0.0054034824,
0.0696942732,
-0.0035226746,
-0.0227034725,
-0.0431664363,
-0.0468380302,
-0.0060598352,
-0.01119164,
-0.0042569223,
-0.0597114526,
0.0230364408,
0.0267003793,
-0.0329826996,
-0.0425581411,
0.0100903455,
0.0492477193,
0.0063443072,
-0.0263951533,
0.0099485535,
0.0058453851,
0.0032208301,
0.0606779084,
0.0102466596,
0.0192339383,
-0.0865728855,
0.0076523642,
-0.0119711729,
0.0897895619,
0.0208412595,
0.0021022689,
-0.038111452,
-0.0074129514,
-0.0365640521,
-0.0576469079,
0.0427648723,
-0.0120581398,
0.024484098,
-0.0332477055,
0.0045142039,
-0.057151854,
0.0051408443,
-0.0230783746,
0.0263653118,
-0.0375964753,
-0.0298538357,
0.0622474812,
0.0264222361,
-0.0087165823,
-0.0250378661,
0.0539829135,
-0.0110323746,
0.0083543938,
-0.0028783742,
-0.0457848795,
-0.0149866277,
0.006089238,
0.0446968861,
0.0444468521,
-0.0368897803,
0.0356218219,
-0.062889345,
-0.0568897277,
-0.0065384232,
-0.0067091952,
0.0200596657,
-0.00482743,
0.04217555,
0.0604732297,
0.0023666536,
-0.0394605584,
-0.0105272755,
0.024045717,
-0.048578579,
-0.0148601448,
-0.0447805189,
-5.946665392e-33,
-0.0182577688,
-0.0384245813,
-0.0048025153,
0.0174908023,
-0.0413621925,
-0.0071150656,
-0.0210848004,
0.0363564566,
-0.0441962034,
0.0268155821,
0.0046588765,
-0.0049111247,
0.0002319969,
-0.0094327359,
0.0423433557,
0.016391987,
-0.000033492,
-0.0187111143,
0.0013226813,
-0.0336020552,
0.029488191,
-0.0029992731,
0.0395629369,
-0.0456753969,
0.0280649401,
-0.003809076,
0.0555558614,
0.0421851948,
0.0122199394,
0.0334896967,
-0.0622903295,
0.0487524495,
0.072807163,
-0.0183733404,
0.0014298687,
0.0471584909,
-0.0204144381,
-0.0538864583,
0.0614467189,
0.0102395499,
-0.0276835654,
-0.0234065484,
0.059742175,
-0.0315110758,
-0.0304691773,
0.0251521654,
0.0461938865,
0.0102395425,
-0.0003551504,
0.0233512279,
-0.0670508668,
-0.0126132844,
0.0073100831,
0.03646373,
0.0013138143,
-0.0012091938,
-0.0556219034,
0.0262953583,
-0.0899688601,
0.0219675731,
-0.0375834107,
0.009881218,
0.0384933352,
0.0406270735,
0.0495390296,
0.0726001337,
0.0806259662,
0.0201928206,
-0.041496668,
-0.0168597214,
0.050910037,
0.0142745068,
-0.0062233661,
0.0198007356,
0.0621614344,
-0.0370604806,
-0.0463689864,
-0.0338857919,
0.0212054867,
0.0661069304,
0.0542044565,
0.0071752439,
-0.0146739082,
-0.0187327676,
-0.0484470986,
-0.0283848755,
-0.0556892455,
-0.04272319,
0.02666457,
-0.0360567383,
0.040737696,
-0.0349375047,
0.0254189372,
-0.0465110019,
0.0032089057,
-0.0340192243,
-0.0297261979,
0.0178360324,
0.0150520122,
0.0039910683,
-0.0704296157,
-0.0474251807,
-0.0313415416,
-0.0033577872,
0.0231317431,
0.0205649175,
0.0090784738,
-0.0370797031,
0.0023472216,
-0.0338711552,
-0.0277037825,
-0.0974986851,
0.0059143198,
-0.0417558327,
0.0515253097,
0.0374160111,
-0.034407638,
-0.0458996892,
0.0434073433,
-0.0372967534,
-0.0052685216,
-0.0096071139,
-0.0073703257,
0.0079988847,
-0.0170898065,
-0.0140943676,
-0.0274551902,
0.0386032537,
0.0858266652,
-0.0202041715,
-0.0295000263,
0.0053867716,
2.712e-7,
0.043051973,
0.0703067705,
-0.0436268859,
0.0500116609,
0.0206941813,
-0.0072761425,
-0.0149394386,
-0.0103125293,
0.0120607177,
-0.0364544801,
-0.0275373552,
0.0388386399,
0.0122234188,
0.0110057015,
-0.0597839877,
-0.0125484867,
-0.0131444521,
0.0155449109,
-0.0171074923,
0.0332442187,
0.0444367565,
0.0460375361,
0.0011224817,
-0.0073231212,
-0.0480706692,
-0.0218453482,
0.0680957437,
-0.0630369037,
0.0059464714,
-0.0136984866,
-0.0325835161,
-0.0122926906,
0.0082231788,
0.0706426501,
0.0449632183,
0.0079002734,
0.0427799374,
0.0193712637,
-0.0092895171,
0.0300818868,
-0.0119295446,
-0.0021686275,
-0.0111039123,
-0.0916608423,
0.0331428275,
-0.0892761648,
-0.0885628238,
0.0321415961,
0.0089784954,
0.0175406635,
0.0368806608,
0.0247227717,
0.0048524668,
-0.0288222693,
0.030038029,
-0.0071751908,
-0.0044012382,
-0.0396765955,
-0.0253989901,
0.0388393514,
-0.0576536953,
-0.027058484,
-0.0328516811,
-0.0205598753,
0.0417320579,
-0.0489304997,
-0.003019629,
2.077569864e-34,
-0.0351173058,
0.0211067274,
0.017803438,
0.0055618361,
0.017811181,
-0.0330605507,
0.0173229761,
0.0622987263,
0.0050275763,
-0.0862166509,
0.0000519713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02739v1
|
Bengali Fake Review Detection using Semi-supervised Generative Adversarial Networks
| 2023-04-05T20:40:09 | 2023-04-05T20:40:09 |
Md. Tanvir Rouf Shawon, G. M. Shahariar, Faisal Muhammad Shah, Mohammad Shafiul Alam, Md. Shahriar Mahbub
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper investigates the potential of semi-supervised Generative
Adversarial Networks (GANs) to fine-tune pretrained language models in order to
classify Bengali fake reviews from real reviews with a few annotated data. With
the rise of social media and e-commerce, the ability to detect fake or
deceptive reviews is becoming increasingly important in order to protect
consumers from being misled by false information. Any machine learning model
will have trouble identifying a fake review, especially for a low resource
language like Bengali. We have demonstrated that the proposed semi-supervised
GAN-LM architecture (generative adversarial network on top of a pretrained
language model) is a viable solution in classifying Bengali fake reviews as the
experimental results suggest that even with only 1024 annotated samples,
BanglaBERT with semi-supervised GAN (SSGAN) achieved an accuracy of 83.59% and
a f1-score of 84.89% outperforming other pretrained language models -
BanglaBERT generator, Bangla BERT Base and Bangla-Electra by almost 3%, 4% and
10% respectively in terms of accuracy. The experiments were conducted on a
manually labeled food review dataset consisting of total 6014 real and fake
reviews collected from various social media groups. Researchers that are
experiencing difficulty recognizing not just fake reviews but other
classification issues owing to a lack of labeled data may find a solution in
our proposed methodology.
|
[
0.0990305245,
0.0380539149,
-0.0236523747,
0.0871901065,
-0.0182993002,
0.004970469,
0.0297090691,
0.0115520684,
0.0283602234,
-0.0261081811,
-0.0541606508,
-0.0581857599,
0.015132593,
0.0675649419,
0.0333222151,
0.0155062806,
0.0574890412,
0.0520471036,
0.0716498941,
-0.0148611283,
0.0092708981,
0.0467536375,
0.014891047,
0.0216276329,
-0.004501367,
-0.0132494671,
0.0650944412,
0.0033822148,
0.0081310552,
-0.0292154048,
0.0280869287,
0.0490266867,
-0.0413936935,
0.0786921307,
0.0000018917,
-0.0102134533,
0.0134249721,
-0.0129592177,
-0.0266875587,
0.0085840635,
0.0686125308,
-0.0174563862,
-0.0335851088,
0.0403128527,
-0.0308755692,
-0.0873721242,
0.0213528145,
0.1119096503,
0.0487606712,
0.0856208503,
-0.0224301592,
-0.0830818564,
-0.0253571756,
-0.0237639975,
-0.003125634,
-0.0167038944,
0.0057047736,
0.0107955281,
0.0217072796,
0.0360592864,
-0.0036146969,
0.0054326304,
0.0154775865,
-0.0630130097,
-0.0003584707,
0.0088346312,
-0.020653829,
0.0027754053,
0.0361372232,
0.0563474409,
-0.0819966495,
-0.0519945659,
-0.0107173016,
-0.009547228,
-0.0046377983,
-0.0049650902,
0.014403522,
0.0239443593,
-0.0055598365,
0.0433566049,
-0.0137112169,
-0.0119794123,
0.043857675,
0.0127770863,
0.0681225732,
-0.008337291,
-0.0145782931,
-0.0098791346,
-0.016268637,
0.0254350137,
0.0120374262,
-0.033506643,
0.0138906259,
0.0037425118,
-0.006640804,
-0.0070139496,
-0.033684127,
0.0001270116,
0.0298159719,
-0.0559036657,
0.0270812828,
-0.0260407366,
-0.0221742708,
0.0263051614,
-0.0448862873,
0.0020018774,
0.0010056247,
0.0394855328,
-0.0732885599,
0.0081326924,
-0.004811415,
-0.0225317739,
0.0375272408,
0.0057876809,
-0.0381364003,
-0.0101106083,
-0.1092469394,
-0.0131103918,
-0.0265500974,
0.0173212569,
0.0033487517,
0.0524460077,
-0.0152965384,
-0.0173483994,
-0.012052414,
-0.019821696,
0.0174984653,
0.0345144384,
-0.0409487635,
-0.0452372208,
-0.0098783225,
0.0375645794,
-0.0056190309,
0.0084508611,
-0.0058216704,
0.0261461902,
-0.0058868048,
-0.0330504477,
-0.0441555381,
-0.0084412992,
-0.0359548852,
-0.0677365363,
-0.0300261471,
-0.0324953087,
0.0181870125,
-0.0276799388,
-0.0235731788,
-0.012845763,
-0.0146510936,
0.0171475206,
0.0109411115,
0.0756038502,
-0.0026069463,
-0.0187779143,
0.0273355488,
0.037390098,
0.0504041947,
0.0331838802,
-0.0238433443,
0.0683181509,
0.0315816067,
-0.0022565175,
0.0499218963,
0.0146020437,
0.0363619141,
-0.0343063176,
0.007303928,
-0.0119815273,
-0.0461150594,
-0.0174827017,
0.0100353966,
0.0393023975,
0.0055239899,
-0.0023101314,
0.0936516747,
-0.0084273517,
0.0040227729,
0.0780261606,
0.0330724902,
0.0428111106,
0.0125840465,
0.0223814398,
-0.0295131095,
0.0001282746,
-0.0715880096,
-0.0256518144,
0.0035628215,
0.0114818327,
-0.014862027,
-0.0232767966,
-0.0018605151,
-0.0086600268,
-0.0019358831,
-0.023477044,
0.0293641277,
0.028179476,
-0.0303291623,
-0.0558753312,
0.0052280133,
0.0023917744,
-0.0096544595,
-0.0579627603,
0.0797151774,
0.051067695,
0.0525779501,
0.0429228544,
0.0296091828,
-0.0212284587,
-0.0648895875,
0.0281493925,
0.0396918841,
-0.0469233468,
-0.0306809936,
0.0151965898,
-0.0089355297,
-0.0458095893,
0.0002921462,
0.0080601294,
0.0021731786,
0.049186945,
0.0251818746,
-0.0197194871,
-0.0416168086,
0.0134513462,
0.0478007197,
-0.0256974436,
0.0162693337,
0.0110933622,
0.0500889421,
-0.0009804756,
-0.0154471491,
-0.025769284,
0.0351043977,
0.0038345433,
-0.0641119331,
-0.0230271276,
0.0014079856,
-0.069804579,
-0.033815939,
-0.0411029905,
-0.0068429862,
0.0445832275,
-0.0307538994,
-0.0056098267,
0.0220263768,
0.0055543073,
0.0294324756,
-0.0649330616,
-0.0108496761,
-0.0242637172,
0.0317343809,
0.01215351,
0.061661236,
0.0106942346,
0.014482988,
-0.0291058905,
0.0058432138,
0.0340915881,
-0.0015518845,
-0.0063752327,
0.0262334701,
0.0192172453,
-0.0080685848,
0.0151486294,
0.0361292697,
0.0170159731,
-0.0017125155,
-0.06854444,
-0.0437960476,
-0.0085399365,
-0.0069338568,
0.0309396684,
-0.0250017624,
0.0109849563,
0.0178002976,
-0.0344532691,
0.0113004753,
0.0444523096,
-0.022689268,
0.0111855278,
-0.0022810842,
0.0442417115,
-0.0050185947,
0.0329811946,
0.0086514251,
0.054831326,
0.0225901958,
-0.0438498147,
-0.0561886244,
-0.0332075991,
-0.0239393059,
-0.006448504,
-0.0081697209,
-0.0657810122,
-0.0279627778,
0.0320981592,
-0.0318872817,
-0.0140874423,
0.040275231,
-0.0083956942,
0.0063717887,
0.046150092,
-0.0092378911,
-0.0444817357,
-0.0160015766,
0.0197082516,
-0.0051684645,
-0.0425176546,
0.0323891416,
0.0308951735,
0.0478774048,
0.0018124789,
0.0244010277,
-0.0001712976,
0.0041544773,
-0.0464693159,
-0.0102011058,
-0.0210780408,
-0.0179871228,
-0.0205060244,
-0.021656286,
-0.0308409091,
0.0753155425,
-0.0187274665,
0.0163121447,
-0.0434366018,
-0.001800472,
0.0361532345,
0.0175106302,
0.0033626498,
0.0339978561,
0.0081260772,
0.0153101282,
0.0135438731,
0.0061417422,
0.0583942197,
-0.0205282234,
-0.0135549158,
-0.0305253174,
0.0297461003,
-0.0039987671,
-0.0056212745,
-0.0772838816,
-0.070738174,
0.0010191012,
-0.042557586,
0.0395518802,
-0.0080961036,
-0.0232788566,
0.0430532694,
-0.0466104113,
0.0354792029,
-0.0355125666,
-0.011994441,
0.0322405063,
0.0667354539,
0.0417932458,
-0.0458775125,
0.0449709967,
-0.0196682997,
0.0016901667,
0.0314068496,
-0.0751063228,
0.0046745804,
-0.0069860844,
-0.0636379868,
0.0033119479,
0.0108627705,
0.0202349629,
-0.0163710229,
-0.0128269633,
-0.0120071508,
-0.0088552041,
0.0784987956,
0.0008018112,
-0.0373380668,
0.0006207124,
0.0360330157,
-0.047534328,
-0.018195862,
0.0251305178,
-0.0533347726,
-0.0090899998,
-0.0198847856,
0.0118635548,
-0.0291462559,
0.0224307925,
-0.0456334837,
-0.1258403659,
0.0081287548,
-0.0101644006,
-0.0409987792,
-0.0715107173,
0.0390503146,
-0.0341063999,
0.0087768286,
0.0740079507,
-0.0146390572,
0.0031526843,
-0.0069434848,
-0.0107918689,
-0.0372337885,
-0.0791276619,
-0.0087138508,
0.0079065878,
0.0620612428,
0.0463846438,
0.0154928993,
-0.0140203023,
0.0096274726,
0.0346655436,
-0.0216474477,
-0.0307957754,
-0.0116020609,
0.0852496773,
-0.0192580298,
-0.0100641605,
0.0180691183,
0.0199724231,
-0.0161908064,
0.0336982794,
-0.0068026641,
0.0054060882,
0.0179187115,
-0.0880220458,
-0.0115235085,
0.0158336237,
0.0259315986,
0.0444208346,
0.0109923817,
-0.0318437852,
-0.0085104844,
-0.0179848038,
-0.0303623043,
-0.039268136,
-0.0593113191,
0.0577716716,
-0.0185555778,
-0.0601104945,
-0.0507405698,
-0.0297520775,
-0.0294394679,
-0.010798106,
0.0389668606,
0.02666655,
0.0287225824,
-0.0161854587,
0.0041717249,
-0.0282340869,
-0.0370067395,
0.0264371075,
-0.0290502608,
-0.0130811278,
0.0523550846,
-0.0223639682,
0.016025465,
-0.0143376319,
-0.0323683619,
-0.0076378942,
0.0164191183,
0.0576734133,
0.0008255417,
0.0235295761,
-0.0411729626,
-0.0602953173,
0.0486865565,
0.0405538008,
-0.0295543261,
-0.024831837,
0.0146564972,
0.0012046162,
0.0158448704,
0.0327213071,
-0.0212895144,
0.0839751437,
0.0484338589,
-0.0447225124,
-0.0292190798,
0.0267371908,
0.0225490462,
-0.023769388,
0.0266143735,
-0.0213886797,
0.0650807172,
-0.058123067,
-0.0122038312,
-0.0347668789,
-0.0036159544,
-0.026306767,
-0.02814373,
0.0476774797,
0.0321796611,
-0.0161117539,
0.0109460065,
-0.0545099601,
0.0564453155,
-0.0509174801,
0.0153525118,
0.0074128723,
0.0359970145,
-0.0246226229,
-0.0040003425,
-0.0003240202,
0.0006380267,
0.0359025113,
0.0041024913,
0.0115292491,
0.0198181625,
0.0237594154,
-0.005327065,
0.0069585908,
0.0403988808,
0.0331558585,
0.0358053185,
-0.0816998929,
0.005754713,
0.041615326,
-0.0351937637,
0.0280685741,
-0.0152183585,
0.0115078352,
-0.0099188453,
0.0136931194,
-0.0215091594,
-0.0258870199,
0.0016365395,
-0.0117514776,
-0.0228745379,
0.028717231,
0.0576946549,
0.0093848882,
0.0001298607,
0.010405126,
-0.0605633892,
-0.0538974926,
-0.0280026291,
0.0001288611,
-0.0087959804,
-0.0183999669,
0.0141870715,
-0.0265493374,
-0.0795841441,
-0.0362862498,
0.0072748843,
0.0528189801,
0.0368515179,
0.0362968668,
0.0628385395,
0.0203580372,
0.0561005883,
-0.0482755937,
0.0053586303,
0.0356365889,
-0.0026435391,
0.0062056994,
-5.896893125e-33,
0.0418418497,
-0.0732719377,
-0.0673795864,
-0.0468424149,
0.0183592942,
0.0163913406,
-0.038194593,
-0.0184571948,
0.0033710252,
0.0466358438,
0.0076677334,
0.0346002877,
0.0075297402,
0.0249283705,
-0.025195444,
-0.0084272372,
0.0845304504,
0.0258290935,
0.0062579466,
0.028858006,
0.0362441465,
0.0263247527,
0.047075443,
-0.0483767129,
0.0399218015,
-0.0579221584,
-0.0669767633,
-0.0156063242,
-0.0293307733,
0.0366099663,
-0.0306615755,
0.0886352509,
0.0258953702,
-0.0040238909,
0.0019794803,
-0.0153585272,
-0.0400922522,
0.0197996181,
0.0038583276,
0.0436120033,
-0.0412805229,
0.0279198065,
0.0490698367,
-0.0272668395,
-0.0744184852,
0.0890872255,
0.0360637978,
-0.0266618207,
-0.0192492697,
-0.0552892201,
-0.0600243062,
-0.0086649321,
0.0181162283,
0.0230331663,
0.0003995483,
0.0481519476,
0.0070967111,
-0.0193047952,
-0.0805380717,
-0.0019347201,
-0.0072010211,
0.0085792318,
0.0054141562,
0.0155067565,
-0.0282590985,
0.0444395244,
-0.0036096859,
-0.0315959863,
-0.0285811462,
0.0393792614,
0.0097268624,
-0.0376844518,
0.0339355767,
0.0890906379,
0.0681703836,
-0.123039566,
-0.0608460568,
0.0425108522,
0.0444373712,
-0.0099507393,
0.0384383611,
-0.0224094931,
-0.0250460953,
-0.0033657223,
0.0442044064,
-0.0637397766,
-0.0231917351,
-0.0283212382,
-0.0038351053,
0.0263039321,
-0.0543023199,
-0.0171658192,
-0.0084348917,
-0.0774706677,
-0.0146565242,
0.0073509761,
-0.0357270613,
-0.0254592244,
0.0374223217,
0.0159478169,
-0.0549763367,
-0.0360819139,
0.0027223399,
0.0387766659,
-0.0299599282,
-0.0307588335,
0.0882326886,
0.0122033311,
-0.0467185415,
0.0326410383,
0.0131165097,
0.0367104672,
0.0158068798,
0.0328954011,
0.0018314295,
-0.0310663842,
-0.006221239,
0.0029194478,
-0.0250473972,
0.0378553569,
0.0025113143,
0.0453478172,
-0.012350847,
-0.0108832754,
-0.0379488915,
-0.0132155819,
-0.0383699313,
-0.0189974122,
-0.0071038273,
-0.1079558954,
0.0126366299,
0.001094198,
2.594e-7,
0.0072991154,
0.0422362946,
-0.0327630602,
-0.036170125,
0.0271261856,
0.0302577,
0.025438413,
0.0044365055,
-0.0166679602,
-0.0097578978,
0.0196715593,
-0.0236599017,
-0.0135052772,
0.0258018132,
-0.0918420255,
0.0856922865,
-0.0779651105,
0.0361695252,
-0.0121834585,
-0.0026700459,
-0.0261134449,
0.0778739527,
0.0164872464,
-0.0349745341,
0.0188716501,
-0.024586346,
0.0427695662,
0.0360438079,
-0.0270252917,
0.0110828858,
0.06221411,
0.0290864203,
0.0041595246,
-0.0497720167,
-0.0551811978,
0.0046779676,
0.0088601438,
0.0085029267,
0.006622239,
-0.0090880468,
-0.001248372,
-0.0262603946,
0.0509580374,
-0.0478592925,
0.0824100897,
-0.0226327032,
-0.0260813441,
-0.0324247442,
-0.0122534232,
-0.0117405383,
0.0447926186,
-0.033502657,
-0.0360516682,
0.024413934,
0.0205604602,
-0.0486986712,
-0.0067399954,
-0.0309721138,
0.0338346846,
0.0239841994,
-0.0207867529,
-0.0047196317,
0.0247467738,
0.0013769901,
0.0198498033,
0.0076797409,
0.0499642082,
1.95123843e-34,
0.0604419895,
-0.0214209482,
-0.0036485847,
-0.067773886,
-0.0020371678,
0.0267199036,
-0.0328551605,
-0.0310821775,
0.0072366544,
-0.0134494891,
-0.0374090113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02738v1
|
Core Challenges in Embodied Vision-Language Planning
| 2023-04-05T20:37:13 | 2023-04-05T20:37:13 |
Jonathan Francis, Nariaki Kitamura, Felix Labelle, Xiaopeng Lu, Ingrid Navarro, Jean Oh
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC
|
Recent advances in the areas of Multimodal Machine Learning and Artificial
Intelligence (AI) have led to the development of challenging tasks at the
intersection of Computer Vision, Natural Language Processing, and Robotics.
Whereas many approaches and previous survey pursuits have characterised one or
two of these dimensions, there has not been a holistic analysis at the center
of all three. Moreover, even when combinations of these topics are considered,
more focus is placed on describing, e.g., current architectural methods, as
opposed to also illustrating high-level challenges and opportunities for the
field. In this survey paper, we discuss Embodied Vision-Language Planning
(EVLP) tasks, a family of prominent embodied navigation and manipulation
problems that jointly leverage computer vision and natural language for
interaction in physical environments. We propose a taxonomy to unify these
tasks and provide an in-depth analysis and comparison of the current and new
algorithmic approaches, metrics, simulators, and datasets used for EVLP tasks.
Finally, we present the core challenges that we believe new EVLP works should
seek to address, and we advocate for task construction that enables model
generalisability and furthers real-world deployment.
|
[
0.0909530073,
0.0164396334,
0.0060779592,
0.0185453445,
-0.0362712219,
0.0025100233,
-0.0146363582,
-0.0564561523,
0.0245356541,
-0.0585598536,
-0.0366224311,
-0.0103295995,
0.0372433066,
0.0548162088,
0.0296560507,
-0.0725266486,
-0.0089503592,
-0.0884849802,
-0.0363778658,
0.0232315455,
0.0219632909,
0.002711552,
-0.041931197,
0.0301556699,
-0.0665582269,
0.0558345988,
-0.0376764685,
0.0295664798,
0.0090623936,
-0.0512096249,
-0.0359646529,
-0.0101723252,
0.06974338,
0.0313478112,
0.0000019112,
-0.0473434217,
0.0358278193,
-0.0213410724,
0.0272616204,
-0.0765209645,
0.0362350978,
-0.066102773,
0.0212390833,
0.0222407356,
-0.0411762111,
-0.0015606853,
0.0677585751,
0.0115106599,
0.0485528819,
0.0278270151,
-0.0201774109,
0.0131846517,
-0.0151460022,
0.0283980872,
0.0049848254,
0.0091794394,
0.0211800113,
-0.0104014659,
0.03958828,
-0.014732169,
-0.0686454475,
0.052902434,
0.0229575094,
-0.0246652775,
-0.0088359201,
0.0480399802,
-0.0243430957,
-0.059724059,
-0.0676585287,
0.0657233447,
-0.0032466166,
-0.0005835791,
0.0029866891,
0.0195930377,
-0.0244219881,
-0.0111611541,
0.0169376563,
0.0416566059,
0.0143097248,
0.0179292485,
-0.0667396635,
-0.0093791028,
-0.002372575,
-0.0034058879,
-0.0231776498,
0.0613340288,
0.0138891358,
0.0207481477,
0.056444034,
-0.00839769,
-0.0154668568,
-0.0461926721,
0.0265392456,
0.0367107429,
-0.0469311923,
0.0310195554,
-0.0563664474,
-0.0077607529,
-0.0389472023,
-0.0436462499,
0.0641367882,
0.0559548512,
-0.0041969698,
0.0347408243,
-0.0071013658,
0.0654966235,
-0.0109010851,
0.0397714004,
-0.0139592402,
-0.0170907825,
-0.014102445,
0.0415316597,
-0.0521981306,
-0.0140012028,
-0.0766177028,
-0.0616519414,
-0.005520924,
0.0265674833,
0.0192892998,
0.0286675487,
-0.0349339843,
0.0536017939,
-0.0017795358,
-0.003606349,
-0.034084864,
-0.0377738103,
-0.0285598282,
0.0138094006,
-0.0294760466,
-0.0297825728,
0.0343284421,
0.0488613583,
0.0004252815,
-0.026540475,
-0.0166688357,
0.1064652279,
-0.0106234215,
-0.016089214,
0.0084317401,
0.0161323342,
-0.0253388099,
-0.0344715752,
0.0827304348,
-0.0356677137,
0.0641940311,
-0.034202043,
-0.0139268311,
-0.006210844,
0.0246781148,
-0.0036612281,
0.0147271473,
0.082518138,
0.0104148947,
0.0217444003,
0.0503466539,
-0.0320593826,
-0.0101794023,
0.0531285815,
0.0625208467,
0.0162658915,
-0.0068557793,
0.0426330268,
-0.006760505,
0.0675620884,
-0.0367363729,
0.0006378512,
-0.0137431221,
-0.0141679272,
-0.0343784504,
0.0560524017,
-0.0083785458,
0.0346355811,
-0.0147977229,
-0.040190503,
-0.0053443778,
0.0477186181,
-0.0435336605,
-0.0145051097,
0.0638831705,
-0.0003148447,
0.0002496419,
-0.0440846905,
-0.0454793982,
0.0402006283,
-0.0236041173,
-0.0507023148,
-0.0428811945,
0.0322429128,
-0.012329529,
-0.0460788198,
0.0023146637,
-0.0137099391,
0.033276163,
-0.0162620097,
0.0496587045,
0.0164031163,
-0.0296250209,
-0.0392967835,
-0.0404917374,
-0.0023586871,
-0.0147887962,
0.0242951512,
-0.0309407357,
0.0138100237,
-0.0120167965,
0.0018444461,
-0.0043605412,
0.0282053389,
0.0243553389,
0.0721308365,
-0.019554574,
0.0092691742,
0.0238604695,
-0.0301003587,
-0.0481690951,
0.0271122102,
-0.0127346255,
0.0249661952,
0.0092199724,
-0.0018861379,
-0.0192731805,
0.0328006893,
-0.0034300596,
0.0686527342,
0.0143654766,
0.031323757,
-0.0009429906,
0.0085526574,
0.0149641018,
-0.0165540483,
-0.0227624513,
0.0060468605,
0.0057742312,
-0.0358109064,
-0.0244192202,
0.0378500558,
0.0082431361,
-0.0007693868,
0.0478454344,
-0.0864735246,
-0.0193669572,
0.0198135003,
-0.0362301022,
-0.0301468745,
0.039239876,
-0.0367518738,
0.0114797289,
0.0073812269,
-0.0206120834,
0.0601779856,
-0.0472220629,
-0.021640623,
-0.015077264,
-0.0463334061,
-0.0277725514,
0.0443091802,
-0.0186173636,
0.0313107111,
-0.0168227926,
-0.0304331034,
0.0312483907,
0.0161087383,
-0.00779544,
0.0451689884,
0.0275429003,
-0.0166621525,
-0.0118561219,
-0.0629369393,
-0.0479812697,
-0.0369947702,
-0.0264631715,
0.0024074472,
-0.06189337,
-0.0085905083,
-0.0200511869,
0.0234369431,
0.0368762426,
0.0013788486,
-0.0560485572,
0.0102982335,
0.0317753889,
-0.0135813914,
-0.0318556279,
0.0048156665,
-0.0310571175,
0.0173423998,
0.0510166548,
-0.0638819784,
-0.0443705395,
-0.0106757479,
-0.0647912547,
0.0591794141,
-0.0296655633,
-0.0101862177,
0.0041741179,
-0.0396916382,
0.0250657182,
0.0023102753,
-0.0289359167,
0.0139976917,
0.0517909601,
-0.0428164452,
-0.0160665698,
0.0416032895,
-0.0037036368,
-0.0123137087,
-0.050504975,
0.0038365626,
0.0058238725,
0.0122506963,
-0.0204341505,
0.0193826761,
-0.0584523231,
0.0166807156,
-0.0206603613,
-0.0881471559,
-0.0196160432,
0.022214096,
-0.0049851183,
0.026473362,
-0.0625381321,
-0.0698351711,
0.0160892364,
-0.0225205515,
-0.0304050148,
0.0250441134,
0.0150122205,
-0.0023919716,
0.0952492282,
0.0478285663,
0.0194148347,
-0.0297183022,
0.0115521075,
-0.0194263272,
-0.0092120105,
-0.0271530189,
0.0268441178,
0.0193968322,
-0.0997815877,
0.0558074303,
0.0085827522,
-0.0083430056,
-0.0093542663,
0.0399441645,
-0.0386461467,
0.0146467369,
-0.0520177372,
-0.0450677723,
-0.0256377477,
-0.0078711631,
0.0175133012,
0.0252653267,
0.0274481941,
-0.0279084351,
-0.0231454913,
-0.0272324122,
0.0778653398,
0.0692683384,
-0.0412191972,
-0.0111850938,
-0.0131615922,
0.0151700769,
0.0322597511,
-0.0414059535,
-0.0609386414,
0.0176506862,
0.0342025645,
0.0304401349,
0.0280927513,
0.037043605,
0.0303186327,
0.0048507201,
-0.013491028,
0.0603564642,
0.0321825966,
0.0245063994,
0.0080526108,
-0.0134102069,
0.0420331918,
0.053866867,
0.0304098204,
-0.0529270992,
-0.0300949309,
-0.0035592264,
-0.0305326898,
0.0419694558,
-0.0401293412,
-0.0257980097,
-0.111867629,
0.0271168947,
-0.0103771258,
-0.0576111078,
-0.0538490601,
0.0062908973,
0.0094401557,
-0.002926128,
-0.044167161,
-0.0337160937,
0.012431371,
-0.0156111196,
0.0040931269,
-0.0301690139,
0.0126667274,
-0.0242983084,
-0.015078607,
-0.0062127314,
0.0445979089,
0.0212306101,
-0.0159439426,
-0.036840383,
-0.0067336815,
0.0395551883,
0.0178708527,
-0.0558720492,
0.001940267,
-0.0185379721,
-0.0273662787,
0.029175669,
0.0500206761,
-0.0406928658,
-0.01958034,
-0.0028095962,
0.0441366397,
-0.0509433299,
0.0155756511,
-0.0549405366,
0.005256162,
0.0174865257,
0.0190516394,
-0.0403267629,
-0.0638764501,
-0.0471205488,
-0.0173355509,
-0.0307905842,
-0.0284210201,
-0.0491003655,
-0.0092788422,
-0.0028208352,
0.0043198811,
-0.0778499693,
-0.0261449981,
0.1066025645,
0.0592241026,
0.0265755653,
-0.0553967692,
0.0287423581,
0.0106672095,
-0.0086111827,
0.0208932254,
-0.0259180088,
0.0209749565,
-0.0033293737,
0.0203322042,
0.0199921522,
-0.0178091135,
-0.0118920673,
0.039061591,
-0.011396151,
-0.0612843744,
-0.0132906772,
0.0832156092,
0.0119604534,
0.0299366713,
-0.0126122208,
-0.0305624325,
0.0286710747,
0.001435018,
0.0218620487,
0.0531014912,
-0.0219038762,
0.0146393767,
-0.0162644666,
0.0239359699,
-0.0187355503,
0.0198613126,
-0.0008958395,
0.0136320647,
0.0088907005,
-0.0187303703,
0.0126843695,
0.0021707311,
0.0352422334,
-0.0132024549,
0.009652406,
-0.0458885506,
0.0092348224,
-0.0017970836,
-0.0260948129,
-0.1128058434,
0.0182980672,
0.0069869254,
0.0317998119,
0.0339734554,
0.0221933294,
0.0191340595,
0.0196346752,
0.0149226217,
0.0181339234,
0.0333577543,
0.011867919,
-0.0381770171,
0.0292634051,
0.0152549641,
0.0554912835,
-0.0357162245,
0.0584675074,
0.037183173,
0.0427512042,
0.0572229549,
-0.0448590294,
-0.0081483321,
0.0065363594,
-0.0095599201,
-0.0789805055,
0.0101484386,
0.0321921818,
0.0338214487,
0.0114280377,
0.0285363328,
-0.0968770236,
-0.0019560412,
0.0007716871,
0.0130961426,
0.042316284,
-0.0417942256,
0.0653185099,
-0.0019745338,
0.0007154222,
-0.0244655702,
-0.0162498467,
-0.0195087455,
0.0612077713,
0.0286005512,
-0.0202726703,
-0.0519026816,
-0.0559515841,
0.0217620041,
0.0039969115,
0.0099004172,
0.029475607,
-0.0329420939,
-0.0444151796,
0.0068122335,
0.061607834,
-0.0203193594,
-0.0308007542,
0.0819576234,
-0.0215994176,
0.0255580358,
-0.0009240386,
0.0044014566,
-0.0789551735,
-0.0137391472,
-0.0105264811,
-0.0197965987,
-4.74421916e-33,
-0.0401463322,
-0.0639649108,
0.0660312921,
-0.010468306,
-0.0090276944,
-0.0098130526,
-0.0191716589,
0.0418239459,
-0.0373237357,
0.0062894179,
0.028441688,
-0.021861732,
0.0119553395,
0.028433295,
0.0145395938,
0.0216423012,
-0.0045704618,
-0.0337878019,
-0.0316620953,
-0.0373352058,
0.0198847093,
0.0070883944,
0.0133718289,
-0.0261364747,
-0.0107685775,
0.0440181866,
-0.0217581932,
0.0464518815,
0.0010258669,
0.0402539633,
-0.0431275964,
0.0092835175,
-0.0034285134,
0.02855107,
-0.0431677215,
0.0343134291,
-0.0547249094,
-0.0513012372,
0.0040518823,
0.0635587424,
-0.1225940064,
0.0389671139,
0.0553569235,
-0.0095809912,
-0.027310323,
0.0046190652,
0.0208717082,
0.0048101782,
0.0118413847,
0.0348563939,
-0.0156551432,
0.0078274831,
-0.0188323855,
-0.0477033891,
0.0574237108,
0.0598687008,
0.0395944081,
0.0010667756,
-0.0234091096,
-0.0099789267,
-0.0406470187,
-0.0120668728,
0.0717666224,
0.0456412286,
0.0359417126,
0.0987823606,
0.0158141404,
-0.0662555769,
-0.0214034617,
0.0168410614,
0.0475338064,
0.0586839728,
-0.0135914991,
0.0527102537,
0.0040497622,
0.0550581105,
-0.0131989578,
0.0108629586,
-0.0404375903,
0.0734860599,
-0.0207333118,
0.0002415565,
-0.0110396529,
0.0203842372,
-0.0616437197,
0.0050330749,
0.0024039447,
0.001890523,
0.0307614021,
0.0270768236,
-0.0019552689,
0.0155822961,
0.0790906101,
-0.0292011816,
-0.0317799449,
-0.0109900283,
-0.0010470935,
0.0454483144,
0.0211061332,
0.0304023083,
-0.0563466884,
-0.0184354261,
0.031182358,
-0.0249282978,
0.0029676887,
-0.0078018918,
-0.0322354771,
0.0799654797,
-0.0032845277,
-0.0104245413,
-0.0329006426,
0.015181601,
-0.0060758218,
0.0295628067,
0.0750931576,
0.0039646579,
-0.0468235202,
0.0366924666,
-0.0075737899,
-0.0607076176,
0.0212767329,
0.0009222708,
0.0002624009,
-0.002460473,
-0.0172005519,
-0.0068778577,
-0.0137685882,
-0.0225113258,
0.0027012147,
-0.0677454323,
0.0085367709,
0.0505616441,
2.606e-7,
0.0484618135,
0.0261640325,
0.0489439964,
0.0256804414,
0.00026392,
0.0330219008,
-0.0231765546,
0.0482671224,
-0.0628138855,
-0.0512417108,
0.005376955,
0.0389076434,
0.0178001635,
-0.0296884514,
-0.0489262007,
0.0454674698,
0.0373301059,
-0.0402572528,
-0.0596431233,
-0.0006638299,
0.0552911535,
0.0895495638,
-0.0443757661,
0.007347045,
0.0067174924,
-0.0270183273,
0.041660361,
-0.0639883578,
0.0220435597,
-0.0364969559,
-0.0181473903,
0.0235855188,
-0.0490119494,
0.0025399174,
-0.0051462012,
0.02569036,
0.0399799161,
0.0407970771,
-0.0264684111,
-0.0202034768,
0.0008116207,
0.0286593139,
-0.039657779,
0.005973944,
0.0498226099,
-0.0652502999,
0.0129381558,
-0.0160595905,
0.0326670855,
0.0262135416,
0.0116734253,
-0.0079707922,
-0.0191622246,
-0.0081349835,
0.0233829618,
-0.0256349817,
-0.0057431692,
-0.0505395159,
-0.0125385905,
-0.0181231182,
-0.0137739135,
0.0290543903,
-0.0418647267,
0.0258289538,
-0.0038864708,
-0.0548133925,
-0.0631097779,
1.755194096e-34,
0.0042705364,
-0.0128084728,
-0.0179865118,
0.0097694909,
0.0331394151,
0.0030618848,
-0.0154574122,
0.0433988832,
0.0123428814,
-0.0452514514,
-0.0363160372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02721v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02721v3
|
To Asymmetry and Beyond: Structured Pruning of Sequence to Sequence Models for Improved Inference Efficiency
| 2023-04-05T19:44:20 | 2023-06-12T21:13:14 |
Daniel Campos, ChengXiang Zhai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sequence-to-sequence language models can be used to produce abstractive
summaries which are coherent, relevant, and concise. Still, model sizes can
make deployment in latency-sensitive or web-scale implementations difficult.
This paper studies the relationship between model size, structured pruning,
inference efficiency, and summarization accuracy on widely used summarization
datasets. We show that model accuracy is tied to the encoder size while
inference efficiency is connected to the decoder. Using asymmetric pruning can
lead to nearly 3x improvement in inference latency with ~1 point loss in
Rouge-2. Moreover, we find both the average degradation and the role of
asymmetry to be consistent across model sizes and variations in datasets.
|
[
0.0059022019,
0.0651902184,
0.0176407117,
-0.0037079768,
-0.0216267277,
0.0137117365,
-0.0297958273,
-0.0045553539,
-0.0691318139,
-0.0352652408,
0.0143939899,
-0.0473647527,
0.0637856573,
0.0340564959,
0.011426677,
-0.0703215748,
0.0310115144,
-0.0291629396,
-0.0190690812,
-0.0156115713,
0.0199345443,
0.0231847055,
0.0337434486,
0.0399749279,
0.0640506968,
0.0174102224,
-0.0275489688,
0.0223591495,
0.0080455914,
-0.0338840894,
-0.0305036604,
0.030763628,
0.0409634151,
-0.0025712594,
0.0000019566,
-0.0244522132,
-0.0086326953,
0.0058146706,
-0.0375330374,
0.0810179263,
0.0203779545,
-0.0811665729,
0.0120275347,
0.0435156226,
0.0258645602,
-0.0043669054,
0.0440753698,
-0.003436855,
0.0440581776,
0.0515726954,
0.0066726818,
-0.0513060465,
0.041243989,
-0.0606513619,
-0.0504544973,
-0.0056861807,
-0.0035629373,
0.0159856044,
0.0100853546,
-0.0158221237,
-0.0251994953,
0.0401165001,
0.0528717265,
0.0218405593,
-0.034091197,
0.0349744521,
-0.0125648249,
-0.0189720299,
-0.0080895117,
0.0306467377,
-0.0162630845,
-0.0280556772,
0.0125270607,
-0.0177754611,
-0.0219705887,
-0.0323282219,
-0.0479191914,
0.0755700395,
-0.0145243993,
0.0215112977,
0.0044400864,
0.0308600571,
0.0149929794,
-0.0101802126,
-0.0433017612,
-0.009881597,
0.0108601628,
0.0001666627,
-0.0607806891,
0.0014645386,
-0.0287417062,
-0.0559277534,
0.0069647492,
0.0212215167,
0.0095284013,
-0.0062705185,
-0.0531389751,
-0.0433612764,
0.0056575486,
-0.0527530462,
0.0452491231,
0.0517439283,
0.0414118543,
0.0169709586,
0.0064241625,
0.032760933,
0.043906223,
0.012515408,
-0.05292603,
-0.0165929478,
0.0214843247,
-0.0044698785,
-0.0187113266,
0.0342545807,
-0.0674153939,
-0.0237045474,
-0.0326743498,
0.013151776,
0.0290773604,
-0.0335629918,
0.0372144766,
0.0005726537,
-0.039226234,
-0.0028101411,
0.0167323798,
0.0338129699,
-0.0049343202,
-0.0088614337,
0.0265021622,
-0.0774850771,
-0.0236677434,
0.0092782313,
0.0023391228,
-0.0070638335,
-0.0068489113,
0.0773192719,
-0.0101411566,
-0.0314866677,
-0.0050065089,
-0.0193407554,
-0.021141028,
-0.047110647,
-0.0162981413,
-0.0686225072,
0.0305918697,
0.0374604538,
-0.0213865861,
-0.045699276,
-0.0131365219,
-0.0037630033,
-0.0169122759,
0.0296827145,
-0.0285054408,
0.0260626711,
0.0009199429,
0.0069553442,
0.0273282528,
0.1044579968,
0.048268538,
0.0095236152,
0.0278819557,
-0.022780655,
-0.0719165653,
0.0384722203,
0.0409589186,
0.0076682493,
-0.0219831392,
-0.024136493,
-0.0000808919,
-0.016579451,
0.0533300489,
0.0837027505,
-0.0425330848,
-0.0018760023,
0.0659484118,
0.0335746408,
0.0223614406,
0.0005105832,
-0.0004500451,
0.0694636479,
0.0053119296,
0.0263778437,
-0.0173788238,
0.0562268756,
-0.0149966981,
0.0578557178,
0.1165894791,
0.0533987321,
-0.0492863059,
-0.0389275216,
-0.0299093444,
0.0126448711,
0.0163854323,
0.0006411481,
0.0323039182,
0.0009483182,
-0.0451350324,
0.0546366014,
0.0251543336,
-0.0737459883,
0.0200704075,
-0.0072014472,
-0.0476752222,
0.026086431,
0.0376308188,
0.0181401074,
-0.0053061335,
0.0242676809,
-0.0236503575,
0.0062596379,
0.0291540641,
0.0003105019,
0.0156887379,
-0.0566253625,
-0.044293832,
0.0229552388,
0.0162509196,
0.0218464155,
0.010321158,
-0.001025487,
0.0588893518,
-0.0192691647,
-0.0454309992,
0.0121938661,
-0.0356035009,
0.022338938,
-0.0124068502,
-0.0038368576,
0.0374361798,
0.0190700591,
-0.0147652598,
0.0241900291,
0.050732553,
-0.0374337696,
0.0117889466,
0.0057124412,
-0.0475169681,
-0.073822245,
0.0219771415,
-0.0313654095,
0.0434567891,
0.0853445604,
-0.0365646817,
-0.0614634454,
0.0324665457,
-0.0867375508,
0.0279758405,
-0.049136363,
0.0316067971,
0.0325161554,
0.0356590971,
0.022131728,
0.0270717032,
-0.039063666,
0.0203652624,
0.0305899717,
-0.0485831387,
-0.0231635738,
-0.0474424623,
-0.0067812665,
0.0059410972,
-0.0023043307,
-0.008170642,
0.0421840213,
-0.0149979107,
0.0265476238,
0.0079209358,
-0.0513382256,
-0.0077274907,
-0.0326740555,
0.0557447784,
0.0357391536,
0.0446070805,
0.0126991319,
-0.0054164291,
-0.029579021,
-0.042359639,
0.0219070371,
0.0308603775,
0.0157237239,
0.020084966,
-0.049444817,
-0.0240448359,
-0.0472729653,
0.021102896,
0.0599343069,
-0.0247555878,
-0.0702562928,
-0.037820816,
0.0199494511,
-0.0147390896,
-0.0030975682,
-0.021752445,
-0.0337276123,
-0.0149529502,
0.0166072454,
0.0161903743,
0.0172444433,
0.0145059954,
0.0323741287,
0.0341564491,
0.0228655804,
-0.0213779416,
-0.0110295899,
-0.035433162,
-0.0095060468,
0.0008790083,
-0.0741461962,
-0.0033014738,
0.099052012,
-0.0109867509,
-0.000074322,
-0.0573156103,
-0.0249742419,
0.0114178862,
-0.0124269444,
-0.0485552624,
-0.0365205854,
-0.0084575946,
0.0609158054,
-0.0255979318,
-0.0261995923,
0.0310346968,
-0.0434555449,
0.0057721171,
-0.0305103771,
-0.0106072314,
-0.0506909266,
0.0709715262,
0.0409836285,
0.0343222395,
-0.0126795424,
-0.0330732763,
-0.0531359799,
0.0078054862,
0.0368877277,
-0.0195140392,
0.0537637286,
-0.058300443,
0.0120227244,
-0.0434598513,
-0.0157851949,
0.0163311549,
0.0041199261,
-0.0108444011,
0.0437167585,
0.0509301126,
-0.0102977408,
-0.0223942604,
0.0680251569,
-0.0143029783,
0.0620631725,
-0.0040818327,
0.0176627133,
0.0010517529,
0.0150095541,
0.054536853,
-0.0117942169,
0.0406788923,
-0.0546025932,
0.0272753648,
0.0466574617,
0.0070491727,
0.0218026061,
-0.0005399696,
-0.0231525041,
0.0107481498,
-0.0180452242,
-0.0224602483,
0.0605110638,
0.0558152832,
-0.0573289655,
-0.0057278257,
0.0878181681,
-0.0139418999,
-0.028239822,
0.0135031324,
0.0434526838,
0.0736341774,
-0.0027231369,
-0.0278029703,
-0.0427194685,
-0.0320258699,
0.0048599131,
0.0342881158,
0.026513556,
-0.0007307425,
-0.0168339275,
-0.1286018044,
0.0111106783,
0.0045335395,
-0.0914103687,
-0.0582687296,
-0.0642421246,
-0.0309738033,
-0.0112083489,
0.0366505682,
0.0530002229,
-0.0231601093,
0.0025087835,
0.0407059491,
-0.0739288256,
-0.0465891398,
-0.0171548873,
0.0011915676,
0.0299591944,
0.0441975147,
0.0072316355,
0.0037930754,
-0.0104804309,
0.0479772463,
-0.050183259,
-0.0174696241,
0.0181425847,
0.0560128428,
0.0024835286,
0.0177458506,
-0.0092018163,
0.0222776495,
-0.004947775,
0.0430496149,
-0.0587209202,
0.0087541156,
0.0209367536,
-0.0274401065,
-0.0507918224,
0.0154698761,
-0.0380745865,
0.0698722005,
0.0422903001,
0.0008274457,
-0.0586108007,
-0.0223696586,
-0.0004841819,
-0.0511600524,
-0.008727354,
0.001646637,
-0.004413723,
-0.1017895639,
-0.0597688183,
-0.02513602,
0.0003581419,
0.0074333078,
-0.0173173249,
0.0313622914,
0.0019364391,
0.0177630428,
-0.0604365952,
-0.0089336932,
-0.0022823208,
-0.0003168733,
-0.0308493283,
-0.0034103906,
0.0140471971,
-0.0060912124,
-0.036682263,
0.0007829849,
-0.1290553659,
-0.0589294396,
-0.0376845561,
0.0247192811,
0.0302725248,
0.067066513,
0.0413958095,
0.0033531033,
0.0072866906,
0.0564752705,
-0.0326996148,
0.0433599018,
0.0175498743,
0.0117495619,
-0.0260397997,
0.0363366604,
-0.0642629564,
0.009909966,
-0.0282262992,
0.0531844907,
0.0079033952,
-0.0593934879,
-0.0042216801,
0.0401623845,
0.0270046573,
-0.0215528384,
-0.02457707,
0.0365690067,
0.0275075734,
-0.0358596928,
0.0159430373,
-0.0376462564,
0.0299851317,
-0.0223495215,
0.044039011,
-0.0083408412,
0.070331201,
0.0309648886,
-0.0180471279,
-0.029305011,
0.010143334,
-0.0081978049,
-0.0224399082,
0.0168691259,
-0.0162320528,
-0.0415202864,
-0.0275070649,
0.0086559244,
0.0088200169,
-0.0272869077,
-0.0095967874,
0.024880778,
0.058371067,
0.0014629054,
0.0480813794,
-0.0689332485,
-0.0090684723,
-0.0553781427,
-0.0180859491,
0.0267921481,
-0.0068141059,
0.0738337189,
0.0060984185,
0.0317738242,
-0.0547137856,
0.0602252521,
0.0058384514,
-0.0299647804,
0.0135842934,
0.0015272597,
-0.0022513005,
-0.0046410216,
0.0803629234,
0.0088318298,
0.0450053215,
-0.0054836296,
0.0051147714,
0.0022199522,
-0.071545653,
-0.0297337566,
0.0191435236,
-0.0205121208,
-0.0310992412,
-0.0440937281,
-0.0720645338,
-0.023663519,
0.0191142913,
0.0390499011,
-0.0141120004,
0.0575191043,
0.014324489,
0.0028403094,
-0.0282070898,
-0.0134335365,
0.0055398429,
-0.0417422429,
0.0096722757,
0.0081861522,
-6.693986293e-33,
-0.0250170156,
0.0339442715,
-0.0177196898,
-0.0189707223,
-0.0206908397,
0.0085898992,
-0.060332004,
-0.0181373507,
-0.009279144,
-0.0291392542,
-0.0007684896,
0.0321470462,
0.0118835196,
0.0395747162,
-0.0085070711,
0.0266092718,
0.0502551571,
0.009790387,
-0.04773435,
0.0296467654,
0.016740663,
-0.0018371113,
0.0309209786,
0.0116667487,
-0.0118752448,
-0.0000733064,
0.0134060727,
-0.0342541374,
0.0190954544,
0.0205708388,
0.0104250265,
0.0324071236,
0.0104908571,
-0.0294049699,
-0.0652952567,
-0.0288063567,
-0.0741748735,
0.0017073927,
0.0406044088,
0.0009478951,
-0.0224550031,
-0.0110811554,
0.0231943335,
0.0081904456,
-0.032990586,
-0.0454860516,
0.016187137,
-0.0197692961,
-0.0712190419,
-0.0577976517,
0.0186267048,
0.0294200014,
-0.0109598488,
-0.0237621274,
0.0204615109,
0.0581019633,
-0.0133941825,
-0.0146967014,
-0.0297200792,
0.0305797048,
0.0831291005,
0.0748916715,
0.0619595647,
0.0200810805,
0.0223715417,
0.0474363491,
0.0157078579,
-0.0086208247,
-0.0350870527,
0.0585530587,
0.0248475019,
-0.0222086329,
0.0477310754,
-0.0165572036,
0.0934791714,
0.0159776527,
-0.0677815974,
0.0502751581,
-0.046500124,
0.0424523205,
0.0335895047,
0.0099359667,
-0.0186951756,
-0.0494378693,
-0.0458422005,
-0.0094116405,
-0.0007524376,
-0.027697362,
0.0263599586,
0.0258970857,
-0.0294496398,
-0.0077617359,
0.0391454585,
-0.0387484208,
-0.0247528106,
0.0442428477,
-0.0117660118,
0.0162313525,
-0.0132998843,
0.0069913324,
-0.0698211044,
0.0292059146,
0.0215126816,
0.0125295669,
-0.0153141674,
-0.0203032549,
0.013465181,
0.0273544397,
-0.0451723672,
-0.0096512949,
-0.0300052036,
0.0307644885,
-0.0233686883,
0.0287386999,
0.0475846902,
-0.0167992543,
-0.008226377,
0.0568492189,
-0.0407695547,
-0.0179142058,
-0.0354926586,
0.012957924,
0.0221387763,
0.0297060441,
-0.0276527964,
0.0208875928,
-0.0507976189,
0.0299355853,
0.0472101979,
-0.020256985,
-0.0683262572,
0.0234308355,
2.666e-7,
0.0626375675,
-0.0102672502,
0.0718708411,
0.0350595228,
-0.0195272993,
0.002969397,
-0.0019759452,
0.0218082648,
0.0123339547,
0.0054370887,
-0.0103667034,
0.0174811091,
0.0672164559,
0.0028013131,
-0.0675251558,
0.00866191,
-0.1092449352,
0.014108154,
-0.0072164573,
-0.0114964005,
0.0436871052,
0.0932891667,
-0.0360131003,
-0.0083374307,
-0.0005314691,
0.0032186273,
0.0198647529,
-0.01145643,
0.0101619214,
0.0036596314,
-0.0014117033,
-0.0089559564,
-0.0197377782,
-0.0031929375,
-0.0160072036,
-0.028614521,
0.0052304878,
0.0328296758,
-0.0115766525,
-0.0230048932,
0.0188095216,
-0.007726483,
-0.0265292283,
0.0083323242,
0.0776089579,
-0.0356601812,
-0.0253761113,
0.0050449753,
-0.0415426716,
0.0252117924,
-0.0423982069,
0.0294295289,
-0.0061107799,
0.027307678,
0.0156178139,
-0.0290321149,
0.0232273694,
-0.0749888122,
-0.0505646653,
0.0097963409,
0.0034816233,
-0.0529347733,
-0.0425936468,
0.0334770866,
0.0312580876,
-0.014159102,
-0.0264370218,
2.712326711e-34,
0.0650398582,
-0.0152797289,
-0.0141320769,
0.0156334229,
0.0097145587,
-0.0693612993,
0.0329641588,
-0.0035623456,
-0.0207506046,
-0.0669076219,
-0.0456792787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02625v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02625v1
|
Towards Explainable AI Writing Assistants for Non-native English Speakers
| 2023-04-05T17:51:36 | 2023-04-05T17:51:36 |
Yewon Kim, Mina Lee, Donghwi Kim, Sung-Ju Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We highlight the challenges faced by non-native speakers when using AI
writing assistants to paraphrase text. Through an interview study with 15
non-native English speakers (NNESs) with varying levels of English proficiency,
we observe that they face difficulties in assessing paraphrased texts generated
by AI writing assistants, largely due to the lack of explanations accompanying
the suggested paraphrases. Furthermore, we examine their strategies to assess
AI-generated texts in the absence of such explanations. Drawing on the needs of
NNESs identified in our interview, we propose four potential user interfaces to
enhance the writing experience of NNESs using AI writing assistants. The
proposed designs focus on incorporating explanations to better support NNESs in
understanding and evaluating the AI-generated paraphrasing suggestions.
|
[
0.0281051695,
-0.0092436345,
-0.0231828913,
-0.0022069863,
-0.0655896366,
-0.0255756304,
0.0471345,
-0.0154021531,
0.0111594554,
-0.0161893293,
-0.0123905344,
0.0424603261,
0.0252529047,
-0.0167365614,
0.0121428799,
-0.0776776448,
-0.0063358285,
-0.0345741771,
0.0420845076,
0.0181097165,
0.0513078682,
0.0654894337,
-0.0309289061,
0.0864543766,
0.017162472,
-0.0555511639,
-0.0241808519,
-0.0011338451,
-0.028271066,
-0.0033536667,
-0.009745935,
0.00058808,
0.0075843013,
0.0009571465,
0.0000017834,
-0.0239013061,
0.0125392834,
0.0068923314,
-0.0246669222,
-0.0000033228,
0.0469842292,
0.0156173082,
0.0235411637,
0.0292166434,
-0.0177538171,
0.0170550905,
0.0321858637,
0.0106660556,
0.0671319887,
-0.0148796123,
-0.0169288926,
-0.0268223882,
-0.021989407,
0.045468241,
0.0043540141,
0.008001456,
-0.0529674105,
-0.0339474306,
0.0581618436,
-0.045459155,
0.0151935797,
0.054093685,
0.0059871157,
-0.0741610005,
0.0189311113,
0.0099836932,
-0.0005833299,
-0.0163015556,
-0.0035604069,
0.0343580134,
0.0470694192,
-0.0223079231,
-0.0175142381,
-0.0113323014,
-0.0031761287,
0.0603715144,
-0.0614547804,
0.0176221561,
-0.0447022133,
-0.0115764756,
0.0014373898,
0.0056844978,
-0.0110184876,
0.0523566604,
0.0220564827,
0.0057011023,
0.0142575037,
0.0025540323,
-0.0435097255,
0.0173191521,
0.0031487958,
-0.0288935378,
0.0797037333,
0.0676908344,
-0.0495392196,
0.0192128886,
-0.0524272062,
-0.0783919767,
-0.0283952262,
0.0109537672,
0.0744766146,
0.0231889449,
0.0148434034,
0.0011650739,
-0.0108132502,
0.07285133,
-0.0031874501,
0.0572573319,
-0.0382669866,
-0.0189143512,
-0.0349039361,
-0.039879173,
-0.0636375099,
0.0248507522,
-0.0330168605,
-0.0090556564,
-0.0041102609,
-0.0153958388,
0.027619306,
0.0113007529,
-0.002040765,
0.0386527292,
-0.0523208641,
-0.0125969332,
-0.0162018109,
0.0056849187,
-0.0596274659,
0.0130908908,
0.0148443626,
-0.0214999653,
-0.0206433292,
0.0243259035,
0.057382334,
-0.0267819613,
-0.0242169034,
0.0062249992,
-0.02413789,
-0.0204853453,
-0.0180020649,
-0.0262701511,
0.0011770662,
-0.0234944001,
-0.0444833227,
-0.0061320546,
0.0104786176,
0.0079439012,
0.0009489798,
-0.0730611756,
-0.0006524212,
0.047996603,
-0.0240270402,
0.0068333526,
-0.05492571,
0.0142816268,
0.0086887786,
-0.0141736213,
-0.0130783562,
-0.042191498,
0.0597215183,
-0.0059587988,
0.047620561,
0.0124316681,
0.0401576757,
-0.0248178765,
-0.0308639538,
0.0020228329,
-0.0210513752,
-0.0158260725,
-0.0953434184,
0.0516993701,
0.0045688124,
0.0265041031,
-0.0038973796,
0.0524386875,
0.0845192373,
0.0897194073,
0.0218478981,
0.0675910562,
0.0786467791,
0.0246845819,
0.0415219739,
0.0610944144,
-0.0143045327,
0.0323716253,
0.0035490757,
0.0537512489,
-0.0255635772,
0.0234581046,
0.0112075387,
-0.0689572543,
0.0025940225,
-0.0100158583,
-0.0106509971,
0.0100492723,
-0.0053909933,
0.0393200107,
-0.019913841,
-0.0259902552,
-0.0379035771,
-0.0923716202,
0.0109842392,
-0.0436765179,
0.0255874321,
0.1311322004,
0.079132311,
-0.0220102705,
0.0106384959,
-0.0298489407,
-0.0098736584,
0.0625942871,
-0.0131651005,
0.0002568109,
0.0233561378,
-0.0249091201,
0.0130718285,
-0.0480875522,
0.0015649584,
-0.0392857082,
-0.0003740636,
0.0055161351,
0.0298562888,
-0.0455288291,
-0.0788701624,
0.0313828737,
-0.0105220536,
-0.0429317355,
0.003544762,
0.016954219,
-0.0470017865,
0.0725425705,
-0.0060265306,
0.0425584279,
-0.0221855082,
-0.0404570736,
-0.0101396991,
0.0898924395,
-0.0278495252,
-0.0280044395,
-0.0070472993,
-0.0577908084,
0.0236395355,
0.0177490637,
0.0305957366,
-0.0600313656,
0.0139290327,
-0.0580237471,
0.0279611405,
-0.0296885222,
0.0161350816,
-0.0348430015,
-0.0245731901,
-0.0004281066,
0.009931474,
0.0391530506,
-0.0128844073,
0.0259790495,
-0.0246962477,
0.0096599124,
0.0072489977,
0.0036807202,
0.005528721,
0.0275776051,
0.0146206636,
-0.0013562259,
-0.0159973577,
-0.0347423702,
0.0113281468,
-0.045325987,
-0.0042857123,
-0.0235423334,
-0.0186860394,
0.059070576,
-0.0036786622,
0.0042993017,
-0.0046681096,
0.0050697899,
-0.024261849,
-0.0153125376,
-0.0122469375,
0.0746766776,
0.0006627825,
0.024385659,
-0.0443062447,
0.0062267659,
-0.0251420047,
0.0288551841,
0.0624886751,
-0.0087393327,
-0.0721296221,
0.0001880338,
0.0072883181,
-0.0599969886,
0.0254328009,
-0.0338267125,
0.0292422585,
-0.0157463737,
0.0042280313,
0.0577881113,
-0.0001029795,
0.0224264208,
0.0502636321,
0.037134584,
-0.0034773124,
-0.0225843135,
0.0579987206,
0.0178321917,
0.0227167401,
-0.0472730063,
0.0022063316,
0.0264621135,
0.0396402776,
0.0092375558,
-0.0498599373,
0.0420237482,
-0.0234309547,
0.0108729415,
-0.0059080422,
-0.069814764,
-0.0371862948,
0.0396630429,
-0.0115165943,
-0.0269291978,
0.0819431692,
-0.0527950637,
-0.0386077873,
-0.077016905,
-0.0342778154,
-0.0344660431,
0.0327991918,
-0.064462468,
0.0369800515,
-0.0057046404,
-0.0163053367,
-0.0383880846,
-0.0208955593,
0.0599789806,
0.0055014356,
0.0391818732,
-0.0631630644,
-0.0235601235,
0.0371750258,
-0.0032638528,
0.0081511391,
-0.0639354214,
-0.0495542176,
0.0031214224,
0.0408840366,
-0.0184025038,
0.0060364692,
-0.0045396341,
0.0684433579,
0.0769933984,
-0.030565856,
0.0018393551,
-0.0480917022,
-0.007967175,
0.0468464941,
0.0125509808,
-0.002118224,
-0.0303909369,
0.0712094083,
-0.0260754488,
0.0416927189,
-0.0104175387,
-0.0268286113,
-0.0351143479,
-0.0104772896,
-0.0716234595,
-0.0628881305,
0.0028613966,
0.0590436906,
-0.0500075147,
0.0047517689,
0.1100589633,
-0.0044310568,
-0.0618051849,
0.0091710445,
-0.0493246727,
0.0125066023,
0.001744758,
0.0375131145,
-0.0179488603,
-0.0232647359,
-0.0064541698,
0.0599455126,
0.0162927192,
-0.0212043058,
-0.0265800674,
-0.0523830578,
0.0134347714,
-0.0185505766,
-0.0091846175,
-0.0065436601,
-0.0026399489,
-0.023980584,
0.0537247621,
0.0067162113,
-0.0179908592,
-0.0499863699,
0.0433363244,
-0.0231097545,
-0.0404937752,
0.0013371326,
-0.0245094523,
-0.0409348682,
-0.0030017032,
0.0314414427,
0.067090258,
0.0286300145,
0.0043608123,
-0.0369513445,
-0.0190381166,
0.069702372,
-0.0031514408,
0.0533428788,
0.0108731128,
0.0168742426,
-0.0524272434,
0.0409026518,
-0.0059886375,
-0.0267807487,
0.0511218086,
0.0120446291,
-0.0317495875,
0.0088352934,
0.0144089786,
0.0235527139,
0.0225220397,
0.0452134572,
0.0870015547,
-0.0381129198,
-0.0482287668,
0.0062697786,
0.0203804579,
-0.0675055534,
-0.031416826,
0.0128565934,
-0.0248786658,
0.0005491181,
-0.0525054634,
-0.0723615587,
0.0340176113,
0.0519514456,
0.0648285225,
0.0666039437,
-0.0019820002,
0.0121382428,
0.0264317412,
-0.0222314186,
0.0109779229,
0.0355071612,
0.0354741886,
-0.0190089568,
-0.0040572267,
-0.0268719718,
0.0346109271,
-0.015296327,
0.0341663957,
-0.0165332798,
0.0172783285,
0.0195371863,
0.0235557165,
0.0327481925,
-0.0094957119,
-0.0757341459,
0.0117489798,
-0.0422128774,
-0.0088255536,
0.0135850357,
0.0238609165,
0.0251261257,
-0.00627018,
0.035710372,
-0.0000986539,
-0.0472641923,
-0.0430242755,
0.0138610117,
-0.0125810662,
-0.0542331524,
0.0385066718,
0.0328173116,
-0.0094500575,
-0.0438624285,
0.0448663905,
-0.0269618332,
0.0228185952,
-0.034111362,
-0.0043683872,
-0.0336285904,
0.0203916207,
0.0239659864,
-0.0432716236,
0.0236629006,
0.0007314232,
-0.0677026138,
-0.0259188581,
-0.0234357547,
0.0638375804,
-0.037938308,
0.0445319638,
-0.0321424343,
0.0146249235,
-0.008044445,
0.0203111209,
-0.0347529389,
0.0453252792,
0.0180556625,
0.0752185434,
-0.0039516878,
-0.0532440729,
-0.0034008147,
0.0418288521,
-0.051273752,
-0.0475481078,
0.0293695461,
0.036272645,
0.0298202187,
-0.0296487845,
0.0858642831,
0.0052380641,
0.0285479967,
0.0299397558,
0.0718856305,
0.0367610715,
-0.0022654021,
-0.0346903093,
-0.0095770648,
0.0235552341,
-0.0322458707,
0.0617606118,
-0.0041797664,
0.0026362103,
0.0314859934,
0.0026298061,
-0.0280414447,
-0.0557505116,
-0.0138310604,
0.0472367555,
0.0123525001,
-0.0328864418,
-0.047359325,
-0.0057259733,
0.0061200708,
-0.017720798,
-0.0130976252,
-0.093148917,
0.0119445119,
0.0204587001,
-0.0309243724,
-0.0530296229,
-0.0569069237,
0.0341500342,
-0.0437745042,
0.0018230481,
-0.0416698083,
-5.176805122e-33,
-0.0187218338,
-0.0610147007,
-0.0096490448,
-0.0279541947,
0.0070432634,
-0.0166735556,
-0.0639315322,
-0.0027712889,
0.0173249524,
0.0195242371,
-0.0582522117,
0.0155175393,
0.0120069729,
0.0167948771,
-0.0046388661,
-0.0042072856,
0.0546876378,
0.0049481331,
-0.0142199229,
0.0223491155,
0.0012324159,
0.0001406468,
0.0302372184,
-0.080022417,
0.045246724,
-0.0585199818,
-0.024265768,
-0.0277547911,
0.0034276911,
0.0095774597,
0.0042742528,
0.0618498474,
0.0084508192,
0.0104874484,
-0.0238935817,
0.0375805721,
-0.012027977,
-0.0260750838,
0.0605128296,
0.0210383385,
-0.0502048321,
-0.0844186619,
-0.0101637691,
-0.0171737764,
0.0111031672,
0.0439301431,
0.0821685269,
0.0060868966,
0.0203255974,
0.0437810831,
-0.0375259817,
-0.0107666543,
-0.0492283627,
-0.0310584679,
0.007678892,
0.0486034602,
-0.0079809818,
-0.0347942412,
-0.0315371007,
0.0066264896,
0.0073912633,
0.0169089399,
0.0451438911,
-0.0250198953,
-0.0253088083,
-0.0006027016,
-0.0104750916,
0.0067263837,
-0.04151747,
0.0084180105,
0.0010411525,
-0.004533466,
0.0695956647,
0.074716121,
-0.0022180649,
0.0149211129,
0.0330610983,
0.0341202877,
0.006125147,
0.0182622876,
0.0085096676,
-0.0081640771,
-0.0290498473,
-0.034827359,
-0.046384003,
-0.0488987863,
-0.012860924,
-0.0446945764,
0.0128855165,
-0.0165101904,
-0.0407393053,
-0.01792969,
-0.0486163273,
-0.0113203647,
0.0017364811,
-0.0126272244,
-0.0344075449,
0.0501271859,
-0.0080622341,
-0.0030712625,
0.0085935108,
0.0313029997,
-0.0034771259,
0.0826300383,
0.0714765042,
0.0296377745,
0.0066173384,
0.0317275748,
-0.0152240153,
-0.0029912998,
-0.0335558541,
-0.0154369567,
-0.0235723462,
-0.0781835988,
0.0020799215,
0.0331895426,
-0.0265225023,
0.0144299883,
0.0174211077,
0.0073906146,
-0.0113792978,
-0.0358761996,
0.0292792711,
-0.0052558216,
-0.0112865949,
-0.0052618966,
-0.0355174951,
0.0045379312,
0.0190845486,
-0.0363914222,
0.0157661159,
-0.0272702202,
2.345e-7,
0.0385491848,
0.0312744044,
0.0357444957,
-0.0268461648,
-0.0140537312,
0.0154056232,
0.0394922122,
-0.0302799046,
-0.0344295017,
0.0366744176,
0.0417437516,
0.0284497198,
0.0387155712,
-0.0170634054,
-0.0895117596,
-0.0128699439,
-0.0501985922,
0.0664936975,
-0.0766650066,
0.0262924582,
0.0996918157,
-0.0292042196,
-0.0106444834,
-0.0121608386,
-0.0490227789,
-0.0924177021,
0.0032317454,
-0.0021789861,
0.0333879404,
0.0019909653,
0.0273229405,
0.0138390874,
-0.0101571251,
0.0109280506,
-0.0269179847,
-0.0146134663,
0.0217944626,
0.0595870353,
-0.0237353686,
-0.0057757837,
0.0110317562,
-0.0073417537,
0.0024383906,
-0.0605680346,
0.0588865355,
0.0048442069,
-0.0121529754,
0.0085851671,
0.0051474767,
-0.0226823036,
-0.0189142805,
-0.0254095625,
-0.0204817075,
0.0281243343,
-0.0214167908,
-0.0230357666,
-0.0026469165,
-0.0148115568,
-0.0516566895,
0.0053556245,
0.0409169905,
0.0512222722,
-0.0552694276,
-0.0137567725,
0.0096939048,
-0.0690976828,
0.0111428229,
1.623792425e-34,
-0.0162032507,
0.0163459573,
0.0517794676,
0.057502076,
0.05084043,
0.0294427723,
0.020016266,
0.0197504144,
0.0461626053,
0.0085362792,
-0.0352495313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02623v1
|
Beyond Summarization: Designing AI Support for Real-World Expository Writing Tasks
| 2023-04-05T17:47:11 | 2023-04-05T17:47:11 |
Zejiang Shen, Tal August, Pao Siangliulue, Kyle Lo, Jonathan Bragg, Jeff Hammerbacher, Doug Downey, Joseph Chee Chang, David Sontag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Large language models have introduced exciting new opportunities and
challenges in designing and developing new AI-assisted writing support tools.
Recent work has shown that leveraging this new technology can transform writing
in many scenarios such as ideation during creative writing, editing support,
and summarization. However, AI-supported expository writing--including
real-world tasks like scholars writing literature reviews or doctors writing
progress notes--is relatively understudied. In this position paper, we argue
that developing AI supports for expository writing has unique and exciting
research challenges and can lead to high real-world impacts. We characterize
expository writing as evidence-based and knowledge-generating: it contains
summaries of external documents as well as new information or knowledge. It can
be seen as the product of authors' sensemaking process over a set of source
documents, and the interplay between reading, reflection, and writing opens up
new opportunities for designing AI support. We sketch three components for AI
support design and discuss considerations for future research.
|
[
0.0572450273,
-0.0300935544,
0.0026949225,
-0.0676775575,
-0.0374554172,
-0.0186305977,
-0.0031416428,
-0.0164566673,
-0.0049483357,
-0.0309591852,
0.0072867908,
-0.0059619951,
0.0273884404,
0.0530904643,
0.0099941855,
-0.0744724348,
-0.0057415925,
-0.0237445552,
0.0614920557,
0.0406969711,
0.0519367605,
0.0451488979,
-0.0066718124,
0.0665217638,
-0.0095576486,
-0.0269151535,
-0.0240306407,
-0.0083269868,
0.0063616633,
-0.027567042,
-0.0076490548,
0.0487078317,
0.0342468545,
0.0010835732,
0.0000018071,
-0.0210617743,
0.0106532918,
0.0103087611,
0.0014216457,
-0.0424195267,
0.0406194739,
-0.0369599126,
0.0177155621,
0.0074652168,
-0.024674356,
0.0173157398,
0.0142465429,
0.0549721606,
0.0413808562,
0.0299974252,
-0.0273505952,
0.0140452106,
0.0476452187,
0.0079856385,
0.0018616484,
0.0734536499,
-0.0309987217,
0.0134521769,
0.0577780083,
0.0040105344,
0.0228199326,
0.0506234691,
0.018338643,
-0.0910437405,
0.0425559059,
0.0216286574,
0.0037989295,
-0.0050985184,
0.0168641955,
0.0164276287,
0.0545172878,
-0.0132420259,
0.0110393045,
-0.003968833,
0.016474599,
0.0311881304,
-0.0734703615,
0.0316098928,
-0.0434878767,
-0.0317245238,
0.0434960835,
-0.0018224044,
-0.0045471177,
0.0139336707,
0.0346094631,
0.0213687792,
-0.0006936025,
-0.0234979447,
0.0028749269,
0.0028977073,
0.0115778763,
-0.1027983949,
0.0092875361,
0.0639935359,
-0.0371855944,
-0.0129499435,
-0.0455153808,
-0.0880317539,
0.0135378214,
-0.0038595879,
0.0606427118,
0.0061823186,
0.0127855567,
0.0188429728,
0.0214515254,
-0.0118154231,
0.0253421627,
0.0047520618,
-0.0306368638,
0.0103115216,
-0.0307815094,
-0.0264403094,
-0.0346613042,
0.0458618738,
-0.0361485966,
-0.0344176143,
-0.0131076071,
0.0228129588,
0.0012251351,
0.0287945662,
-0.0125358198,
0.0284753498,
-0.0423789434,
-0.0028467546,
-0.0036638905,
0.0103611145,
-0.0093696127,
0.0207650196,
0.0330263041,
0.0192456767,
0.0118587511,
0.0162198879,
-0.0078966282,
0.0049728211,
-0.0143591994,
-0.002100358,
-0.0071727657,
-0.0282336064,
-0.0177809279,
-0.0475689508,
0.0062665953,
-0.037118677,
-0.0071346578,
-0.058752723,
0.0154257715,
0.0303755272,
-0.0345138349,
-0.068278268,
-0.0109799299,
0.0409850962,
-0.0044583827,
0.0137197059,
-0.0719988719,
0.0250687767,
0.0759166405,
-0.0034804044,
-0.0221931133,
0.0144088529,
0.0567879193,
0.0100110723,
0.0163091924,
0.0443017483,
0.0617156401,
-0.0138277169,
-0.0162966102,
-0.0204441249,
-0.0155580593,
-0.0062197223,
-0.0653985664,
0.0577212572,
-0.0316281542,
0.0514083281,
-0.0277978294,
0.0694316998,
0.0875237733,
0.0860684738,
0.0272896774,
0.0149337165,
0.0384523161,
-0.0009701456,
0.0254855845,
0.0439245701,
-0.0142166968,
0.0705471262,
0.0282791369,
0.0278488975,
0.0035911188,
-0.0107816448,
-0.0222046021,
-0.0565617457,
-0.0066689304,
-0.0065817605,
-0.013075389,
-0.0109375464,
0.0021624037,
0.0049891896,
-0.0130500793,
-0.0265960637,
-0.0098648425,
-0.0704754069,
0.0422676764,
-0.0094441976,
0.0367334709,
0.1046573743,
0.0803596526,
-0.0579126403,
-0.0162630118,
-0.0399528965,
0.0092758238,
0.0500751846,
0.0259269048,
-0.0247211196,
-0.0255283769,
-0.0139293084,
-0.0205667838,
-0.0530909784,
-0.0016855726,
-0.0347726718,
0.0069007017,
0.0117715476,
0.0072144601,
-0.0090477495,
-0.0844670087,
0.0458551161,
-0.0609285459,
0.0137629928,
-0.0044292095,
-0.0154774031,
-0.0363319851,
0.0456851646,
-0.0328821577,
0.0436282605,
0.0025859657,
-0.0300866868,
-0.0451721698,
0.0604913868,
-0.0040604346,
0.0137789436,
0.0242024325,
-0.0681478381,
0.0270297099,
-0.0168259311,
0.0427177697,
-0.0840349793,
-0.006488042,
-0.0478221513,
0.0242164489,
-0.0117938565,
-0.0078875599,
0.0017424377,
-0.0301747024,
-0.0056312252,
0.0121030295,
0.0025599606,
-0.0287071243,
0.0219932999,
-0.0225981232,
-0.0087053562,
0.0121754408,
-0.025038844,
-0.0024936623,
0.0477873459,
-0.0008616448,
0.0441374965,
-0.0398550741,
-0.0379733481,
-0.0287613124,
-0.1113362089,
0.0056368988,
-0.0308180545,
-0.0064374576,
0.0357050076,
0.0157980938,
-0.0094993915,
0.0037153237,
-0.0245104712,
-0.0294580236,
-0.0010898527,
0.0070998906,
0.053229548,
0.0350680836,
0.0680422336,
-0.0447320193,
0.0049578301,
-0.0275762733,
0.0119808335,
0.0793660283,
-0.0369908139,
-0.0437999815,
0.0020884522,
-0.0074075265,
-0.0344865397,
0.002963359,
0.0138806077,
0.0283364132,
-0.0252312403,
0.0504314005,
0.0540078878,
0.0249053165,
0.0125924731,
0.0958181918,
0.0045391358,
0.0072592353,
0.0045908713,
0.0083942628,
0.077977635,
0.0352693424,
-0.022529142,
0.0213444196,
-0.0075074593,
0.0209868178,
0.0217127223,
-0.0274116602,
0.0204753596,
-0.0124068856,
-0.0042581693,
-0.006870511,
-0.0643706694,
-0.0052576326,
0.0454704799,
-0.0234690867,
-0.0197848119,
0.0581984855,
-0.0196064226,
-0.0053889337,
-0.026477173,
-0.0176684093,
-0.0507422127,
0.0373643786,
-0.0235351138,
0.0032215868,
-0.028097257,
0.0261952635,
-0.0500071272,
0.0004390437,
0.026864402,
0.0134964008,
0.050717812,
-0.0599637814,
0.0116308965,
-0.0257040747,
-0.0145378383,
-0.004238999,
-0.0059052594,
-0.0173522439,
0.0319910608,
0.0469110124,
-0.0255046617,
-0.0152064972,
0.011512924,
0.0915758163,
0.1206293479,
-0.0082943542,
-0.0259096418,
-0.0159797538,
-0.0067297933,
0.051012218,
-0.011176114,
0.0011562901,
-0.0357359797,
0.049680829,
0.0105338851,
0.006172379,
-0.0157392081,
-0.0212626364,
-0.0523356684,
-0.0230632909,
-0.087537095,
-0.0345949866,
0.0005042013,
0.0607240982,
-0.0439558476,
0.0085173286,
0.1159252897,
0.0199844223,
-0.0859743729,
-0.0179028474,
-0.0459934212,
0.0049531022,
0.0149952592,
0.0434070937,
-0.0492718183,
0.0103540272,
-0.0058082957,
0.0424924977,
-0.021639321,
-0.0556936786,
-0.0157588851,
-0.0525838882,
0.0504491515,
-0.0320656262,
-0.0149952518,
-0.0032066861,
-0.0007245184,
0.0154270539,
0.0348764062,
-0.045300886,
-0.0007140589,
-0.0312595218,
0.0280674808,
-0.0090619195,
-0.0530346408,
0.0215069279,
-0.0545559824,
-0.0519478135,
0.0157350749,
0.0493840463,
0.0554431044,
0.0127273221,
0.0314070508,
-0.0438074321,
0.0124203935,
0.0421122387,
0.0077598644,
0.0823273435,
-0.0148583129,
0.0487103909,
-0.0455036089,
0.035444852,
-0.015215205,
-0.0359909125,
0.0657150596,
0.0398265235,
-0.0523787029,
0.0044043348,
-0.0588797815,
0.0264937188,
0.0226542745,
0.0398516804,
0.0566624999,
-0.0480324179,
-0.0308553502,
-0.0137623139,
0.0297850762,
-0.0627170056,
0.0006260066,
-0.0436112173,
-0.0161382183,
0.0378747843,
-0.1017947719,
-0.0838603079,
0.0575256534,
0.0189522449,
0.0598629527,
0.0396398976,
0.0000226217,
-0.024545202,
-0.0458432697,
-0.0344346091,
0.0344528109,
0.0097332494,
0.0022229948,
-0.0299053323,
0.0017960536,
-0.0283246897,
0.0297444984,
-0.0038462451,
0.0108604617,
-0.0316047855,
-0.0113604581,
0.0195865724,
0.0177619979,
0.0329723842,
-0.0038282829,
-0.0442047901,
0.0190896858,
0.0000366593,
-0.0087629789,
0.0378631726,
-0.0036557755,
-0.0004720466,
-0.0167602785,
0.0213121772,
-0.0369462185,
0.0088161547,
-0.0256843287,
0.0024029156,
-0.0184602756,
-0.0341816284,
-0.0005496463,
0.0039666435,
-0.0114278896,
-0.0482746363,
0.0125232665,
-0.0818028674,
-0.0037999914,
-0.0683185086,
-0.0341980383,
-0.0431957394,
0.0391760953,
-0.0279820636,
-0.0037379928,
0.0210377499,
0.0749491528,
-0.040462438,
0.010801767,
-0.0464297459,
0.0353648625,
-0.0194623396,
0.0350329019,
-0.0247518495,
-0.0068255896,
-0.0374189317,
0.0290215425,
-0.065704748,
0.0337878279,
0.0101350443,
0.0472508147,
0.0401915088,
-0.0396860428,
0.0298578441,
0.0347989835,
-0.1002580896,
-0.0254047979,
-0.0211284645,
0.0393210314,
0.0063420259,
-0.0141301528,
0.0733077079,
-0.0522958785,
0.0091631142,
-0.0128503684,
0.0536869876,
0.0235873759,
-0.0124368044,
-0.0597032011,
0.0153014744,
0.0131363636,
-0.0240151752,
0.0732577145,
-0.047804229,
0.0144149056,
0.0224686973,
-0.0393241383,
-0.0303650629,
-0.0416029133,
-0.0031014001,
0.044890482,
0.0043992959,
-0.0020647929,
-0.0806372985,
-0.0016290813,
0.0354434736,
-0.001157537,
-0.021058863,
-0.0483244918,
0.0057269819,
0.0161181651,
-0.007959716,
-0.0178478397,
-0.0719749555,
0.0322673358,
-0.0747515336,
-0.0002196408,
-0.0300375875,
-4.730396081e-33,
-0.0367885306,
-0.0444502644,
0.0262579061,
0.0395908803,
-0.0066253105,
0.0341687761,
-0.0584899932,
-0.0001851023,
0.027151702,
0.0304201078,
-0.0418268293,
0.0152918948,
-0.0135274418,
0.0139461495,
0.0188550372,
0.0510223024,
0.0637975112,
-0.0038194407,
-0.0477818437,
0.0438745469,
0.0393498279,
-0.0195834879,
0.0241308957,
-0.0524958111,
0.0464993939,
-0.0513684005,
-0.0009982249,
-0.0148506388,
0.0193899926,
0.0166186243,
-0.0132197868,
0.0114699472,
0.0305955987,
-0.0034462039,
-0.0181284994,
0.038956441,
-0.0359738655,
-0.0222157985,
0.0123765375,
-0.0330564827,
-0.0493419319,
-0.057932552,
0.0128750494,
-0.0070888931,
0.0075996863,
0.0150429588,
0.0592462122,
-0.0091522504,
0.0089122914,
-0.0311858393,
-0.0655278191,
0.028715888,
-0.0089701973,
-0.0210403129,
-0.0192805566,
0.0262811333,
0.0238263216,
-0.0243664086,
-0.0436636284,
0.0188918523,
0.0162989162,
0.0349770747,
0.0224859118,
-0.003957266,
-0.0425930768,
0.0655488223,
-0.0216347966,
0.0197721682,
-0.0319476202,
0.0148259941,
-0.0171292294,
0.0071721398,
0.0554728284,
0.0751920193,
0.0114951571,
0.0163452793,
0.0046184035,
0.0791609809,
-0.0388609692,
-0.0016237043,
0.0221389104,
-0.0210645366,
-0.0132881338,
-0.0300506745,
-0.025762938,
-0.0102339257,
-0.0003824502,
-0.026718067,
-0.0019948382,
0.000259693,
0.0080334311,
0.0091732452,
-0.0244979598,
0.0051701097,
0.0476947427,
0.0228683017,
-0.0580328479,
0.0765090436,
0.0023161203,
-0.0321056247,
-0.0297863483,
0.0301731974,
0.0188420359,
0.0623281598,
0.0207533576,
0.0408199206,
0.0502069555,
0.0308571458,
-0.007217655,
-0.0166547149,
0.0147981215,
0.0496316478,
-0.000239541,
-0.0432434306,
0.0000961264,
0.0269388966,
0.0003161575,
-0.0009069879,
0.0091422135,
0.016107494,
-0.0430716351,
-0.0611034892,
0.0234059133,
-0.0245057773,
-0.0156815313,
-0.0014749459,
-0.0138632907,
0.0056800763,
0.040019501,
-0.030640224,
0.0031053873,
-0.019549204,
2.391e-7,
0.0730350465,
0.0335463695,
0.0490487702,
-0.0340103954,
0.0041958811,
0.0040100259,
0.011110682,
0.0328481495,
-0.0119164381,
0.0223486833,
0.0457538702,
0.0419877656,
0.0099316053,
0.0527024046,
-0.090110302,
-0.0727674961,
-0.0473397486,
-0.0095623629,
-0.0681247264,
0.0164872613,
0.0498866588,
-0.0309828743,
-0.0242309105,
-0.0309886597,
-0.04327951,
-0.0452194624,
0.0548809804,
-0.0157661643,
0.0070686666,
0.0112175532,
0.0475217402,
0.0371780768,
-0.0011382735,
0.0155174257,
-0.0252253041,
-0.003796132,
0.0133592691,
0.0373497903,
-0.0076074363,
0.0040226607,
0.0332006551,
0.0275847148,
0.0076565524,
-0.0161307137,
0.035755679,
-0.0316952728,
-0.0060989871,
-0.0614623465,
-0.0150724389,
-0.0212325156,
-0.004398718,
-0.0109737786,
-0.0117196832,
0.0263513848,
-0.0264215246,
-0.0284576509,
0.014526492,
-0.0421582982,
-0.0491300076,
0.03878415,
0.0305520147,
0.0105245933,
-0.0541892946,
-0.0685504526,
-0.027092455,
-0.1032524556,
0.0258858986,
2.277644971e-34,
0.0383750349,
0.0047250753,
-0.0282849856,
0.0365509279,
0.0499793887,
0.0012344863,
-0.0165854748,
0.0179812256,
0.0296680517,
-0.059180174,
-0.0441059358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02554v1
|
Human-like Summarization Evaluation with ChatGPT
| 2023-04-05T16:17:32 | 2023-04-05T16:17:32 |
Mingqi Gao, Jie Ruan, Renliang Sun, Xunjian Yin, Shiping Yang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluating text summarization is a challenging problem, and existing
evaluation metrics are far from satisfactory. In this study, we explored
ChatGPT's ability to perform human-like summarization evaluation using four
human evaluation methods on five datasets. We found that ChatGPT was able to
complete annotations relatively smoothly using Likert scale scoring, pairwise
comparison, Pyramid, and binary factuality evaluation. Additionally, it
outperformed commonly used automatic evaluation metrics on some datasets.
Furthermore, we discussed the impact of different prompts, compared its
performance with that of human evaluation, and analyzed the generated
explanations and invalid responses.
|
[
0.0476652421,
-0.0299134739,
0.0124268178,
-0.0205337275,
-0.0226943512,
0.0326841697,
-0.0178023987,
-0.0200171117,
0.0207028054,
-0.0497449748,
0.0100546442,
0.0151073057,
0.0340979844,
-0.0228473824,
0.0020169234,
-0.0863766596,
0.0233888701,
0.0087775532,
0.0384584926,
0.0277355053,
0.0529062636,
0.0005659107,
-0.0219964329,
0.0496896431,
-0.0026689013,
0.0194560941,
-0.0028715171,
-0.0106770936,
0.0569899753,
-0.0148672657,
0.0045124697,
0.0301350057,
-0.0259237718,
0.0184885245,
0.0000018194,
-0.0574213341,
-0.0057222643,
0.0096634533,
-0.0069003934,
0.032209672,
0.0771595389,
0.0426706038,
0.0247823168,
0.037339624,
-0.0143552925,
-0.001919131,
0.0047103362,
0.0449756607,
0.1155184582,
0.0348978601,
-0.0142508484,
-0.018428361,
-0.0157346893,
0.0115817906,
-0.0251218714,
-0.0041264738,
-0.0354408994,
0.0488489233,
0.0193462521,
0.0135319158,
0.0505895913,
0.0200161673,
-0.0018131234,
-0.0082518235,
0.0221639983,
0.024474455,
-0.0794703066,
-0.0391648784,
0.0217014086,
0.0526405722,
0.0373765863,
0.0057455134,
0.0089154756,
0.0113367001,
0.034971159,
0.0105547747,
-0.0489941388,
0.0174890663,
-0.0383747295,
-0.0033317707,
-0.0247788113,
0.0512136184,
-0.0317095444,
0.0163341779,
0.0381702036,
0.0166452415,
-0.0058617955,
-0.0129525773,
-0.0116838953,
0.0107791973,
-0.0173837952,
-0.0661823824,
0.0301278159,
0.0289099254,
-0.0188002978,
-0.0350571163,
-0.014991275,
-0.0149825234,
0.0480616651,
-0.0821899921,
-0.0199502427,
-0.0020537768,
0.00114036,
0.0474834256,
-0.012760614,
0.0297872741,
0.0923359618,
0.0240227021,
-0.0558658391,
0.0185697768,
-0.0587885901,
0.0060567879,
-0.0481078066,
0.0286886543,
-0.0234206431,
-0.0100910757,
-0.0456630774,
-0.012873196,
0.0167157631,
-0.0066367108,
0.0153584499,
0.0100275837,
0.0125709651,
0.0233532973,
-0.0235424824,
0.0083938213,
-0.0789315626,
-0.0399007909,
0.0310692936,
-0.0105047589,
0.0190160982,
0.0255503021,
0.0177731421,
0.0201205052,
0.0077407244,
0.0218366105,
-0.0452722758,
-0.0276980549,
-0.0318608694,
-0.014856481,
-0.0067902268,
-0.0449610241,
-0.0493377484,
-0.0390111841,
0.0065246499,
0.0019383178,
-0.0372770838,
0.0455939658,
0.0060611558,
0.0427174643,
-0.0223141089,
0.0289847441,
-0.0623405986,
-0.0086341426,
0.0651364028,
0.0079646176,
-0.024053812,
0.0134813609,
0.0318995751,
0.0718239471,
0.0553072952,
0.0159112681,
0.0249452125,
-0.0012254067,
-0.0197155681,
-0.0143835098,
0.0635326803,
0.004506357,
-0.0472560748,
0.0145147014,
0.0217117071,
0.0710088164,
-0.0415502116,
0.0251993872,
0.0366660021,
0.0861204863,
0.0266382359,
0.0191729758,
0.0218158644,
0.0481020585,
0.0633148998,
0.0623636991,
-0.0204694439,
0.0258929785,
-0.0673475266,
0.0524277836,
0.0550768264,
0.0047407798,
0.0184312314,
-0.0726163834,
-0.024281878,
0.034584932,
0.0321267545,
-0.0104380781,
-0.014085195,
0.0021381099,
-0.0146014094,
0.0064377026,
0.0162325352,
-0.0695761219,
0.0166248269,
-0.0362875387,
0.0076447646,
0.0675870776,
0.0460522845,
-0.0259626973,
-0.0162761584,
-0.013287168,
0.0026272342,
0.0285847243,
0.0386512317,
-0.0299910773,
-0.0395622961,
-0.0489815921,
-0.0085636815,
0.0267765392,
-0.0097700171,
-0.0163532738,
-0.0017849678,
-0.0133737437,
0.0189061575,
-0.0263292473,
-0.0696201771,
0.0344812833,
0.0345099904,
-0.0151227238,
-0.0255607124,
-0.0238025282,
0.0107177068,
0.067282185,
-0.0247818157,
0.0222803019,
-0.0130169261,
0.0045365593,
-0.0474548079,
0.0149756642,
-0.0267869309,
-0.0364647135,
0.0078127962,
-0.0596777573,
-0.0109051941,
0.0046916995,
-0.0056180749,
-0.0338556096,
-0.0231380891,
-0.0642994344,
-0.0059090201,
-0.0589889213,
-0.0003255172,
0.0172006767,
-0.0108043021,
-0.0461619906,
0.0658682212,
0.0350171141,
0.0103927804,
0.0033854477,
-0.0490005799,
0.0319774263,
-0.0116911959,
-0.0232311357,
0.0044674133,
0.0042426395,
0.0306361523,
0.0522791892,
0.0365635864,
-0.0491610989,
0.0021185074,
-0.1430586129,
-0.0053338311,
-0.022895759,
0.0188148785,
0.0533154048,
-0.0073555289,
-0.011988882,
0.0103866886,
-0.0478029065,
-0.0380892605,
-0.0020956632,
0.0009190718,
0.0503433384,
0.0071953745,
0.0505227894,
-0.0691014081,
-0.0069800736,
-0.0081755482,
0.0284012035,
0.0806288123,
-0.0351493284,
-0.0213672444,
0.0088532027,
-0.0362685062,
-0.0570878386,
0.0269943383,
-0.0308398511,
0.0082592368,
0.0087923622,
0.0470782779,
0.0256854482,
0.0512681976,
0.0204795692,
0.0206101649,
0.0043478971,
-0.0077942531,
-0.0307439007,
-0.0091441721,
0.0227108859,
0.0385887437,
-0.0499821454,
0.0278063212,
0.0193789732,
0.0245280322,
0.0227577593,
-0.0545687787,
0.0047706673,
-0.0639905855,
-0.0018079528,
-0.0946282372,
0.0090119233,
-0.0117659876,
0.047948651,
-0.0226725899,
0.0243638419,
0.0739261508,
-0.0421841741,
-0.0047397199,
-0.0854783058,
0.0023382194,
-0.0337455757,
0.0419134088,
0.0084698834,
0.0131720779,
-0.0043137386,
-0.0196439009,
-0.0181811564,
-0.0153414225,
0.0967912152,
-0.0270077456,
0.0283042919,
-0.0348495133,
0.0031185369,
-0.0287893172,
0.0215795133,
-0.002193464,
-0.0597637445,
-0.0150046665,
0.0038610974,
0.0673027039,
-0.0103567783,
-0.0219495632,
0.0369244702,
0.0427300669,
0.0448665842,
-0.0449894369,
-0.0295989364,
0.0168517604,
0.0463949479,
0.0341164246,
0.0292970389,
0.0377779566,
0.0021702908,
0.0403704755,
0.0503972657,
-0.0159183517,
-0.0408354178,
0.0149134351,
-0.0136654349,
-0.0212336425,
-0.070769079,
0.0024934362,
-0.0200101398,
0.0736725628,
-0.0209443402,
0.0110486234,
0.1083167419,
0.0367873758,
-0.0090704402,
-0.0294225905,
-0.0028079532,
0.0184414815,
-0.0033918591,
0.0069140317,
-0.05982811,
-0.0180553235,
0.0111182416,
0.0503585599,
0.0111425146,
-0.0304780062,
-0.0006385712,
-0.0662022159,
0.0255798902,
-0.0161489733,
-0.0816406086,
-0.0108980266,
-0.0326318331,
0.01243228,
-0.0263228379,
0.0107570281,
0.0290360339,
-0.0292481482,
0.0329464674,
0.0235360228,
-0.0984826013,
0.0446878113,
0.0244315024,
-0.0337090567,
0.0269825161,
0.0479865596,
0.0418360494,
0.0157478154,
0.017642431,
0.0050490256,
0.0110912174,
-0.0061339349,
0.0202680137,
0.0850024223,
0.0124066249,
0.0264905356,
-0.0740434155,
0.0295886882,
0.0392781831,
-0.0049882913,
0.0404586643,
0.0036119232,
0.0071809394,
-0.0078716092,
-0.0192639865,
0.0681505799,
-0.0503752269,
0.0617978647,
0.0487290882,
-0.0072794147,
-0.0303284135,
-0.0354400016,
0.0081281224,
-0.0659189895,
-0.0618308298,
-0.0007790159,
-0.0310921893,
-0.0643506423,
-0.1086148992,
-0.0731825754,
0.042316515,
-0.0227113403,
-0.0245973002,
-0.0176744517,
0.0007810231,
0.059989702,
-0.00476943,
0.0044685793,
0.0099994875,
0.0053112265,
-0.0134959389,
-0.0129506793,
0.0282072555,
-0.004001407,
-0.02653726,
0.0334271751,
-0.0361352675,
-0.0076200762,
0.0091698077,
0.0151151493,
0.015375874,
0.0103504872,
-0.0073959338,
-0.0202621017,
0.0347990617,
0.0547026061,
-0.0298133381,
-0.0083245384,
-0.0063115396,
0.0815892816,
-0.0164879616,
-0.0127472328,
-0.0379562005,
0.0180671867,
-0.074055776,
0.0284924973,
-0.0198369324,
-0.0456988625,
0.0208582692,
0.072466135,
0.0091921333,
-0.0376640484,
-0.0090566874,
-0.0249984302,
-0.0616943575,
-0.0316837393,
-0.0214409549,
-0.0179395825,
0.0291607957,
-0.0259640254,
-0.0055264113,
0.0044966452,
0.0180864632,
-0.0362056233,
0.008527346,
-0.032077726,
0.0020455143,
-0.0153583447,
0.0034949421,
-0.0469561741,
-0.009097741,
-0.0607066713,
-0.0364361666,
-0.0190488454,
0.0065874988,
-0.0131249269,
0.0430162475,
0.0189098995,
-0.0075751347,
0.0297125448,
0.0553550795,
-0.0780180842,
0.0266192146,
-0.0554883517,
0.0717695504,
0.0308940187,
0.0011587616,
0.0555441082,
-0.0051053041,
-0.0176587086,
0.0008823611,
0.0335063525,
0.0206398554,
0.0028293282,
-0.0488389283,
0.0154920025,
0.0064432235,
-0.0113947196,
0.0667734146,
-0.0534073673,
-0.033490669,
0.0192932133,
-0.0511548407,
-0.0560618863,
-0.0313186571,
-0.0579046048,
0.0408339202,
0.0272505414,
-0.0378519557,
-0.0838486776,
-0.0228387453,
-0.0165551845,
0.0510748513,
0.00973811,
-0.0136129586,
0.0360065177,
0.0267681386,
-0.0079845069,
-0.0160369147,
-0.0548604019,
0.0010025037,
-0.0175507087,
0.0228198394,
-0.0276137609,
-5.935566889e-33,
-0.0550940074,
-0.0342456438,
-0.0232733786,
0.0560643673,
-0.0181427598,
-0.0088203968,
-0.0339253694,
0.0333380997,
0.0327661522,
0.0300127435,
-0.0177517738,
-0.0177869312,
0.0123816654,
-0.0045992895,
0.0064298115,
-0.0235955957,
0.0229294188,
-0.0158832185,
-0.0459206216,
0.0526653007,
0.0161538683,
-0.0080455132,
0.0150604872,
-0.0454511903,
0.0792692155,
-0.021562608,
-0.0378183536,
-0.0192362815,
0.0349093936,
0.0081538232,
-0.0041678357,
0.0255004913,
0.0356276594,
-0.0302220248,
-0.0170971211,
0.0065713306,
-0.0813275129,
-0.0528005175,
0.0286751334,
-0.0093943812,
-0.0567477569,
-0.0070263105,
0.0083750011,
-0.0357802995,
-0.0152701503,
-0.0354103707,
0.0627394393,
-0.0200364199,
-0.0043943292,
-0.0485248156,
-0.0197500363,
0.0403942876,
-0.016700564,
-0.0429067239,
-0.0171818249,
0.0374691226,
-0.01991871,
-0.014447662,
-0.0043759542,
0.0172123853,
0.0156278983,
-0.0037118888,
0.0200680327,
0.0014331663,
-0.0208118018,
0.0544257462,
0.0185887758,
-0.0137974033,
-0.0507002361,
0.0097414749,
-0.006833219,
-0.0215416402,
0.0723973215,
0.0636226684,
0.0116041033,
0.0240945742,
0.0093870107,
0.1117553413,
-0.0000737287,
-0.0013115586,
-0.0086835055,
-0.0225579105,
-0.0342735611,
-0.0154104931,
-0.0161971003,
0.0103634968,
-0.0227964353,
-0.0285272375,
-0.0076448112,
-0.0261783674,
-0.0564612225,
-0.0415999368,
-0.0012973966,
0.0057893014,
0.0506265312,
-0.0166176539,
-0.0346377194,
0.03405248,
0.0076062982,
-0.0422283113,
-0.0109616388,
0.0670951381,
0.0276602283,
0.0653371289,
0.0190399401,
-0.0303800125,
0.0242420956,
-0.0217771567,
-0.0235694237,
0.0110738995,
0.0213467758,
0.0382688381,
-0.0478940271,
-0.0416931771,
-0.0231825914,
-0.0078999493,
-0.0097715575,
0.0226900727,
-0.0020388816,
0.025564339,
-0.0361782014,
0.0021705523,
0.0184062235,
-0.0320456028,
-0.0101631777,
0.0436624587,
0.0051751006,
-0.0321062542,
0.0029746487,
-0.0305078551,
0.004625625,
-0.0100053241,
2.377e-7,
0.0610972531,
0.064155668,
0.0622608177,
-0.0112619456,
-0.0442805439,
0.0293275043,
0.0254226476,
0.0036463756,
0.0359594226,
0.0098637519,
0.0616250746,
0.0227891989,
0.03648201,
0.0552324131,
-0.0829849988,
-0.0563387312,
-0.0866248086,
-0.0594778359,
-0.0236247946,
-0.0179990511,
0.1131522134,
0.0170636866,
-0.0178886577,
-0.0025389905,
-0.016976174,
-0.0293434337,
0.0012203739,
-0.0025455917,
-0.0527104624,
0.0211090129,
0.0721705034,
-0.0025944996,
0.0105254017,
0.0072698379,
0.0012970746,
-0.0577574857,
0.087537989,
0.0173415616,
0.0294872448,
-0.0224793963,
-0.0154481707,
-0.0128903482,
0.0459127687,
-0.0243173111,
0.0428619273,
-0.047597941,
-0.0090559144,
-0.0353910774,
-0.0291811768,
0.0086778784,
-0.0016251,
-0.0076346099,
-0.0713186339,
0.0622002073,
-0.0154289957,
0.0077801268,
0.0011523576,
-0.0357455574,
-0.0334939025,
0.0195358358,
0.0075664781,
-0.0449458286,
-0.0026016133,
0.0060894587,
-0.0123798344,
-0.0521174558,
0.0000379143,
1.793112169e-34,
0.072679162,
-0.0030725724,
-0.0090473676,
-0.0452644378,
0.0468810648,
0.0130960904,
0.0245494936,
-0.0076418244,
0.0165164899,
-0.0308800042,
0.0057652453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02541v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02541v4
|
PWESuite: Phonetic Word Embeddings and Tasks They Facilitate
| 2023-04-05T16:03:42 | 2024-03-26T10:13:06 |
Vilém Zouhar, Kalvin Chang, Chenxuan Cui, Nathaniel Carlson, Nathaniel Robinson, Mrinmaya Sachan, David Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mapping words into a fixed-dimensional vector space is the backbone of modern
NLP. While most word embedding methods successfully encode semantic
information, they overlook phonetic information that is crucial for many tasks.
We develop three methods that use articulatory features to build phonetically
informed word embeddings. To address the inconsistent evaluation of existing
phonetic word embedding methods, we also contribute a task suite to fairly
evaluate past, current, and future methods. We evaluate both (1) intrinsic
aspects of phonetic word embeddings, such as word retrieval and correlation
with sound similarity, and (2) extrinsic performance on tasks such as rhyme and
cognate detection and sound analogies. We hope our task suite will promote
reproducibility and inspire future phonetic embedding research.
|
[
-0.0620000064,
0.0487703644,
0.0173074044,
0.0154156489,
-0.029910611,
-0.0078026815,
0.009299159,
-0.0102989366,
-0.0272364505,
0.0285190288,
-0.0387192182,
-0.0094146896,
0.0695672855,
-0.0381413139,
0.0659271106,
-0.0200505536,
0.0280999653,
-0.0011143304,
0.0156670287,
-0.0148057127,
0.0013151059,
-0.0033787773,
-0.0517647676,
0.0771679655,
-0.0317905471,
0.0020941813,
0.0002927066,
0.0125999218,
0.0091417925,
-0.0269959662,
-0.0559252948,
0.0198826827,
0.0135502908,
0.0026238675,
0.0000014074,
-0.0222346224,
0.025202604,
0.0004540276,
-0.0248911679,
0.0119971428,
0.0030176523,
-0.0305987671,
-0.0184619743,
0.0256318487,
0.0170736294,
-0.0489266515,
0.091980271,
-0.0056679356,
0.0035663312,
0.0381293409,
-0.0129014673,
-0.0535591245,
0.0157815516,
-0.0257585943,
0.0119658075,
-0.0060983426,
0.0022135442,
-0.0423542298,
0.0129737956,
-0.0289005227,
-0.0613012202,
0.04261031,
-0.0379911177,
0.0324840881,
0.0333453231,
0.0439656489,
-0.013243339,
-0.0185508877,
0.0088267839,
0.0379882827,
0.0170374699,
-0.0098124472,
-0.0137372678,
0.0484467372,
-0.0214598347,
0.0049721641,
-0.0038874429,
-0.0429618582,
0.0338228941,
0.0190801006,
0.0124307964,
0.067902863,
0.0346607827,
-0.0002704728,
0.0167199206,
0.0191731844,
0.0485689901,
-0.0557494871,
-0.0126794763,
0.0159023777,
0.0273541342,
0.0443838164,
0.0400304087,
0.0037905595,
0.002179041,
0.002260423,
0.032005772,
-0.0390786119,
0.0274732038,
-0.0116232093,
0.0738409907,
0.0123325996,
-0.0201517995,
0.0193899982,
-0.0723138526,
-0.006663518,
-0.0007278447,
0.0032451516,
-0.0037615804,
-0.0371621884,
-0.0485075451,
-0.0079941079,
-0.0604226701,
-0.0118550193,
0.0389544293,
-0.0540618412,
0.0014914658,
-0.0140890963,
-0.0321699977,
-0.0086589549,
0.0390356071,
0.0507470407,
-0.0120008728,
0.0204261485,
0.0321475491,
0.0192083418,
-0.0442986637,
0.0367484391,
-0.0738218501,
0.005493416,
-0.0297725946,
0.0212538075,
0.0539620928,
-0.0052072629,
0.0315172076,
0.0490370765,
0.0306459796,
-0.0531472787,
0.0204228517,
0.004480103,
-0.0608323142,
-0.0080824597,
-0.0656993836,
-0.0996066034,
0.0676499158,
-0.050119482,
-0.0092179915,
-0.0331313647,
-0.0232532173,
0.0282388907,
-0.0221556276,
0.086429067,
0.0381663181,
0.0394899026,
0.0009051377,
-0.0009263435,
0.0133717284,
0.0185735356,
0.058321014,
-0.0497995652,
0.0367658995,
-0.0549900457,
-0.0397115834,
0.0223391894,
0.0012600519,
-0.0259206723,
0.0224151462,
-0.046155259,
-0.0041401065,
0.0815026388,
0.0571246967,
0.0467899926,
-0.0336834379,
-0.0964741856,
0.0214438606,
0.1035212204,
0.0704614744,
-0.0032908467,
0.0220995415,
0.0006126619,
-0.0149701312,
-0.0314923152,
-0.0007732578,
0.0027588368,
0.0146776028,
0.0334492959,
0.0264205821,
0.0582516044,
-0.0392719842,
0.0295387637,
-0.0406446867,
-0.0118910661,
-0.0192111209,
0.0016638638,
0.0367680043,
0.0248873681,
-0.0417127088,
0.0054723625,
0.036405433,
-0.0337366834,
0.0029064058,
0.0192099381,
0.0325004309,
0.0693109334,
0.0486694425,
-0.020770086,
-0.0092044352,
0.0153561672,
-0.0239547789,
0.0336251557,
-0.0020101245,
-0.029695427,
0.0585900396,
-0.0329769701,
0.0083503798,
0.0575474128,
0.0137980385,
0.0415705591,
0.0157982707,
0.0382544734,
-0.0080975797,
-0.0687270761,
0.0238883775,
0.0364029221,
-0.0165071711,
-0.042921301,
0.0085851597,
0.0349479318,
0.0040212441,
0.0675835088,
-0.01585613,
0.0405870378,
0.0250951909,
-0.0611430816,
0.0300078429,
0.0149799436,
-0.0448471904,
-0.0687269941,
0.0346693508,
-0.0739265829,
0.0157688893,
0.01062229,
0.0426413007,
-0.0482236147,
0.0491751246,
-0.0221379772,
0.0691819862,
-0.0584407412,
0.0026446453,
0.0010118308,
0.0430571139,
-0.0086332513,
-0.011145181,
0.0450292379,
0.0045525064,
0.0065046833,
0.0187745485,
-0.0154571971,
-0.030631844,
-0.0471224301,
0.0491113849,
-0.0001266054,
0.0279993378,
-0.0300397314,
-0.0277333129,
0.0051108031,
-0.0183996111,
-0.0749515966,
0.0040801754,
0.0033116408,
0.0247274041,
-0.0190674104,
-0.0082279351,
-0.0121445647,
-0.0211104434,
-0.0372764841,
-0.0042244876,
-0.0255012605,
0.033514604,
0.0015551581,
-0.0468539074,
-0.0249646865,
-0.0532824025,
-0.0176145192,
-0.0075225239,
0.0205339044,
-0.0399268679,
0.01929719,
-0.018986376,
-0.0187958721,
-0.0336645581,
-0.027374329,
0.0577881671,
0.0052490663,
0.0069452263,
-0.0338236988,
0.0520325154,
-0.0116755385,
-0.0337541662,
0.0177692641,
0.0325363725,
-0.0321823843,
-0.0361841731,
-0.0210836008,
-0.014701467,
0.0779328048,
-0.0015443768,
0.0273500141,
-0.0396610051,
0.0580339581,
0.024252953,
-0.0017561422,
-0.0626810566,
-0.0099043464,
-0.0111340676,
-0.0017263665,
-0.0271815136,
-0.0095404983,
-0.069488287,
-0.0281878896,
-0.0556772165,
-0.0305100903,
0.0495273657,
-0.0745099112,
-0.0414626114,
-0.0253358632,
-0.0299367849,
-0.0159033649,
0.0391048044,
-0.0464088097,
0.0116894161,
-0.0231240056,
-0.0278549325,
0.0109781036,
0.0680995062,
0.0201831777,
-0.0620998517,
0.0257229321,
0.0290583875,
-0.0266660918,
0.008134258,
-0.0199359413,
-0.0241842587,
-0.0250803716,
-0.0264408402,
0.0246823672,
-0.0210919529,
-0.0336649455,
0.0496545807,
-0.0008303685,
0.0035085701,
-0.0152267991,
0.0280213077,
-0.0091239382,
-0.0141420811,
0.0307854116,
-0.0036469803,
0.0523070358,
-0.026255466,
0.0597952902,
0.0111975772,
-0.0345231369,
0.059302371,
0.0022267825,
-0.0075331479,
0.0113803744,
0.0522532165,
-0.0117874937,
-0.0009798834,
-0.0027817208,
0.0233419202,
0.0011450306,
-0.0243386254,
0.076568611,
0.0326636694,
0.0088649783,
0.0255881324,
0.0259696338,
0.0582594275,
-0.0060953898,
-0.0059899744,
-0.0283232592,
-0.0388935506,
0.0399990678,
0.0244810171,
0.0528012291,
-0.0109440973,
0.00376358,
-0.0967275724,
0.0053210258,
0.0297077075,
0.0110945124,
-0.0243308004,
-0.0491412804,
0.0204502381,
-0.0236207396,
-0.0178965051,
0.0035380262,
0.0038097242,
-0.0055700345,
0.0279586818,
-0.0516018383,
-0.026272472,
0.0309812389,
-0.07466425,
0.0499308892,
0.0315390751,
0.0396228582,
-0.0493898205,
-0.0705694482,
-0.0672262236,
-0.0362222455,
-0.0413758792,
0.0071514416,
0.0270923655,
0.0025820292,
-0.0394798219,
-0.0075281593,
-0.0160169192,
-0.0469846465,
-0.0129022077,
-0.0128077036,
0.0686522648,
-0.0024796175,
-0.0104989586,
0.0063830158,
0.0480729192,
-0.019127138,
0.0872332677,
0.0374131985,
-0.0374004617,
-0.022167027,
0.022471616,
0.0114626186,
-0.0302820262,
-0.0542209037,
0.0136254309,
0.0572760478,
-0.0358113535,
-0.1041213349,
-0.0630724952,
0.0049426551,
0.0624260306,
0.0217953492,
0.0083099836,
-0.0189368054,
-0.0238859728,
-0.0607370138,
0.0016635689,
0.0019925912,
0.0711007193,
-0.0146759534,
-0.0094918525,
0.0478087775,
-0.0361806378,
-0.0052495934,
0.0311941896,
-0.0229760539,
-0.0467215441,
0.0224450752,
-0.0251076669,
0.0145916846,
0.0193260759,
-0.0629526973,
0.0191095881,
0.0530419163,
-0.0029832027,
0.0076504457,
0.0162956435,
0.0540161133,
-0.0067367796,
-0.0015904661,
0.0264049079,
-0.0099919662,
0.0239289105,
-0.030741239,
0.0411843061,
0.0469804965,
-0.0372857451,
0.004543154,
-0.0353866741,
0.0552948341,
-0.0386954285,
-0.0312889777,
-0.0525954887,
-0.0678016841,
0.0244410522,
0.0609661043,
-0.0024298111,
-0.0284821037,
0.0682999492,
0.0276821498,
-0.0353829563,
-0.0108480547,
0.0419697762,
0.0065607503,
-0.0013330316,
0.0685506687,
0.0434272215,
-0.0183844939,
-0.034045063,
0.0436940603,
-0.0044796499,
0.0455324091,
-0.0627644062,
0.003098903,
-0.0172326602,
-0.0531032048,
-0.0494036973,
-0.0121717835,
-0.0201878343,
0.0300528947,
-0.0177033897,
0.0357638933,
0.0096056778,
0.0184831675,
0.0559950508,
-0.0422080159,
0.0641875342,
-0.0046738498,
0.022779258,
0.0040680654,
-0.0232190993,
-0.0701550841,
0.01980602,
0.018781269,
0.0233658496,
-0.0204655156,
-0.0420899466,
0.0439694971,
-0.0524942502,
0.0553807691,
-0.0377937928,
0.0020704076,
-0.0106920926,
-0.0332708359,
0.0027153527,
0.039730411,
-0.0423857905,
-0.0163212791,
-0.0682722256,
-0.088427186,
0.0290728081,
-0.0211759489,
-0.0152563779,
0.0275566187,
-0.0187880863,
-0.0051666563,
0.0043708952,
0.0739899501,
0.0146780163,
-0.0632063299,
-0.0130932294,
-0.0390432328,
0.0230218917,
-5.474405761e-33,
-0.0051205801,
0.0138295526,
-0.0180525631,
0.0068862489,
-0.0181327444,
0.0125643639,
-0.0367032178,
0.0255333837,
-0.0635224357,
0.0021729122,
0.0156364888,
-0.0329968706,
0.0045912033,
-0.0030170383,
0.0201509669,
-0.0015068796,
-0.0036540693,
0.0189794432,
0.0095066922,
-0.0278203543,
0.0366597027,
0.054510355,
0.0434951,
-0.0263144486,
-0.0019043129,
0.0240369588,
0.024879558,
-0.0133042531,
0.0352699421,
0.0647333041,
-0.0700971708,
0.0857911631,
0.0099374037,
-0.0078464895,
-0.0303793903,
0.033077538,
-0.103486836,
-0.0266210958,
-0.0121646198,
0.0232995283,
-0.014668718,
0.0049644252,
0.0197784025,
-0.0095315827,
-0.0141443145,
-0.0149004394,
0.0094960341,
-0.0159684028,
-0.0116634481,
0.0166444406,
-0.0888290778,
0.0375949293,
-0.0059965341,
-0.0453997403,
0.0776785836,
-0.0205999892,
0.0241088085,
-0.0069879699,
-0.0553457215,
0.0247267876,
-0.0614174865,
0.0059658913,
0.0233861338,
-0.0167483967,
-0.0236491878,
0.0498507917,
0.0506273136,
-0.0966329798,
0.0104151461,
0.0268079937,
0.0809168369,
0.0035053249,
0.0392828099,
0.0068370858,
0.033331655,
-0.0184187181,
0.0470811389,
-0.0247899368,
0.0344759077,
-0.0215981882,
0.0157229081,
0.0350175053,
-0.0581993163,
-0.0083916048,
-0.0076626982,
-0.0410869792,
-0.0109883258,
-0.0136450911,
0.0544202775,
0.0021956784,
0.0141849499,
0.0553558469,
0.013319822,
-0.0111013083,
0.018373359,
0.0010123577,
0.0238619149,
-0.0116927,
-0.002872233,
0.0083094537,
-0.0057359189,
-0.0156052848,
0.0545025691,
0.0323528126,
0.0251044631,
-0.0407662056,
0.0265727248,
0.0194549393,
-0.0739939213,
-0.0034067624,
-0.0372296609,
-0.0264043063,
0.0053127026,
-0.0011369978,
0.0325190797,
0.0126562361,
-0.0012764441,
-0.024165716,
0.0534475483,
-0.0011183287,
-0.0110338517,
-0.0155777624,
-0.0232855119,
-0.011361544,
0.0367059261,
0.0402964316,
0.0238691848,
-0.0351874009,
-0.0262188111,
-0.0125901233,
0.0049268184,
0.0024769662,
2.452e-7,
0.0544382185,
0.0013412875,
0.0678381324,
-0.001955458,
0.0053879293,
-0.0242081732,
-0.0360809751,
0.0217166226,
-0.056090191,
-0.0218445007,
0.0190873239,
0.0225966014,
0.0926570073,
0.0120444652,
-0.0873464271,
0.0003173224,
-0.0573440157,
0.0012261141,
-0.0464265868,
-0.0228053201,
0.0712439418,
0.08836101,
-0.0032054011,
-0.0380229279,
0.0149452696,
-0.0379448831,
0.0176962428,
-0.0257285926,
0.0590598918,
-0.0664865002,
-0.0106838541,
-0.0147355301,
0.0454574116,
-0.0170566272,
-0.0472140908,
0.0689425766,
0.0590921082,
0.0014775813,
-0.0119266389,
-0.0211170446,
-0.0081887748,
0.0144647071,
-0.0273493174,
-0.0095355697,
0.0604052097,
0.0347476266,
-0.0340227038,
-0.0194363296,
0.0143049164,
0.048444543,
0.0530480705,
-0.0036946877,
-0.0048855566,
-0.0206781868,
0.0399799608,
-0.0348410308,
-0.0244158916,
-0.0650295243,
-0.0189119093,
0.0375941247,
-0.0692481101,
0.012670408,
0.0155209536,
-0.040068984,
0.0274000932,
-0.0448567644,
-0.0175684933,
1.899031557e-34,
-0.0012640924,
-0.0108261015,
0.0397136062,
0.0192233026,
-0.01086374,
-0.0143200681,
0.0510482453,
-0.0273771435,
0.0129790576,
-0.0288913585,
-0.0403822251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02496v1
|
Evaluation of ChatGPT Family of Models for Biomedical Reasoning and Classification
| 2023-04-05T15:11:25 | 2023-04-05T15:11:25 |
Shan Chen, Yingya Li, Sheng Lu, Hoang Van, Hugo JWL Aerts, Guergana K. Savova, Danielle S. Bitterman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive ability
in biomedical question-answering, but have not been adequately investigated for
more specific biomedical applications. This study investigates the performance
of LLMs such as the ChatGPT family of models (GPT-3.5s, GPT-4) in biomedical
tasks beyond question-answering. Because no patient data can be passed to the
OpenAI API public interface, we evaluated model performance with over 10000
samples as proxies for two fundamental tasks in the clinical domain -
classification and reasoning. The first task is classifying whether statements
of clinical and policy recommendations in scientific literature constitute
health advice. The second task is causal relation detection from the biomedical
literature. We compared LLMs with simpler models, such as bag-of-words (BoW)
with logistic regression, and fine-tuned BioBERT models. Despite the excitement
around viral ChatGPT, we found that fine-tuning for two fundamental NLP tasks
remained the best strategy. The simple BoW model performed on par with the most
complex LLM prompting. Prompt engineering required significant investment.
|
[
0.0686194003,
0.0372827165,
0.0217987262,
-0.0037402334,
-0.0458441116,
0.0221261531,
-0.0033952675,
0.0359465592,
0.057249397,
-0.0397950113,
-0.0045708008,
-0.0223423019,
-0.0072492487,
0.0205218326,
-0.0245916098,
-0.0235266294,
0.068377763,
0.012465545,
0.0656614974,
-0.000769061,
-0.0246419609,
0.0059519825,
-0.0350523628,
0.0738685057,
0.0319579057,
-0.0347124226,
0.0287460871,
-0.0460981689,
0.0275689233,
-0.0626242235,
0.0259162523,
0.039843712,
-0.0037452853,
0.0190237891,
0.0000018544,
-0.0507654473,
0.0053389254,
0.0446713865,
-0.0264723543,
-0.0146586727,
0.0085080136,
-0.0233961847,
0.0348166935,
0.0397696309,
-0.0358795188,
-0.0393021405,
0.0399153531,
0.0812018961,
0.0523395762,
0.0598942526,
-0.00200647,
-0.0321950242,
0.0760429353,
-0.0074047758,
0.0266574305,
-0.0274714567,
0.052029565,
0.0077080722,
0.0467103384,
0.0139427828,
0.019243693,
0.0527622029,
0.0168513153,
0.0382606611,
0.022863159,
0.0593109243,
-0.0527099445,
-0.0197577868,
-0.0099927718,
0.0555461757,
0.0144040193,
-0.0289803669,
-0.0039950102,
0.0166191868,
-0.0241744053,
0.0175110735,
-0.0418551043,
0.0143833747,
-0.0411352329,
0.0056257229,
0.0325683765,
0.0076787844,
0.0389067084,
0.0245276447,
-0.0021764908,
0.014644241,
0.0046008429,
-0.0403749831,
0.0188814681,
-0.0124377543,
-0.0595643185,
-0.050978642,
0.015818825,
0.0617148019,
-0.0470227711,
0.0216447916,
0.0247763153,
0.0183083396,
0.079245545,
-0.0748121962,
0.0013299212,
0.0358566567,
-0.0129350917,
0.0411496758,
-0.0342580229,
0.021234462,
-0.0381696858,
0.0590095557,
-0.0134564554,
-0.0132767502,
-0.0716246068,
-0.0392743088,
-0.0237105582,
0.0266893636,
-0.0201469734,
-0.0489371307,
-0.0613677576,
-0.0014680942,
0.0178685188,
-0.0243056379,
0.0411439054,
0.0241080727,
-0.0021977234,
-0.0032150168,
-0.0482511148,
0.0046773707,
-0.0148414457,
0.0123118535,
-0.013394922,
-0.0414296091,
-0.0163624436,
-0.016141329,
-0.0195410084,
-0.0347548909,
0.0198216438,
0.0586282201,
0.0007043366,
-0.0306564216,
-0.0031197597,
-0.0286952797,
-0.0375717953,
-0.0684829354,
0.010421183,
-0.0428584553,
0.0065056267,
0.0138105685,
-0.0116472542,
-0.0042080539,
0.0236556008,
0.0135801649,
-0.0709609836,
0.0718781203,
-0.0118806353,
0.009946892,
0.0235581007,
0.0318646729,
-0.0111760562,
0.031741105,
0.0168333743,
-0.0369023159,
0.0135366106,
-0.0013401718,
-0.0061483141,
-0.0318455435,
0.0207599439,
-0.0501599684,
0.0237741377,
0.0255278163,
0.0154056726,
0.0866263658,
-0.0514743961,
0.0713226721,
-0.0091706263,
-0.0244394615,
0.0289416388,
0.0611600503,
0.0147890458,
-0.0016594795,
0.0252018645,
-0.0028293978,
0.0119366106,
-0.0214647539,
-0.0158089921,
0.0078235744,
-0.0154531961,
-0.0003668343,
-0.0050315596,
0.0066093104,
-0.0298256241,
-0.0254495293,
-0.0414809249,
-0.0038838871,
-0.0220112633,
-0.0092978766,
0.0239821654,
-0.0156188468,
-0.0250462033,
0.026990667,
0.0552163571,
-0.0105264122,
-0.0175334923,
-0.085667491,
0.042094402,
0.0375788324,
0.0464396775,
-0.0131382272,
-0.031657666,
-0.0073260586,
0.003628833,
0.0164704379,
0.0519535728,
-0.0219074003,
0.0111720087,
-0.0369103402,
0.0021286856,
0.0135865156,
0.0112927947,
-0.03588783,
0.0355386622,
0.0272126831,
-0.0241019223,
-0.0259136148,
-0.0085101714,
0.043838948,
-0.0322943553,
-0.0352947898,
0.0023967978,
-0.0188455321,
0.0667710379,
-0.0114346957,
-0.0031432847,
0.0336852223,
0.0103964601,
-0.0379377417,
-0.0606382117,
-0.0068421639,
-0.0280066356,
-0.0591021441,
0.0060567446,
0.0138172349,
-0.0336273834,
0.0252710376,
-0.0423640497,
-0.0261660349,
-0.0351775475,
-0.0147512667,
0.0082925316,
-0.0194511022,
-0.0397936255,
0.0220823027,
-0.0019222214,
-0.052196186,
0.0470279418,
-0.0018894837,
0.0025525957,
0.0030457946,
-0.0132434499,
0.0190225225,
-0.0399541929,
-0.0205674339,
0.0223698523,
0.0031979654,
-0.0247856136,
-0.0160449054,
0.0106497481,
-0.0197041091,
-0.026234407,
-0.1459721327,
0.03186002,
0.0173212737,
0.0008911514,
-0.0108931446,
0.0114814201,
0.0016727711,
0.005074359,
-0.0505971499,
0.0075197937,
0.0401431248,
0.0287791472,
0.0337797329,
0.0131858978,
-0.0042263404,
-0.0167754069,
0.0008663768,
-0.0579495206,
0.0311363488,
0.0174396485,
-0.0239802729,
-0.0137857962,
-0.0347923711,
-0.0518261939,
0.0175394677,
0.0100896163,
-0.0172835514,
0.023875434,
0.0033933106,
0.0272418559,
0.0760081112,
0.0083837043,
0.0229918752,
0.0160106532,
0.0298367199,
-0.0337881893,
0.0422123745,
-0.0531251542,
-0.0198036954,
0.0128764082,
-0.0022010684,
0.0047025019,
0.0468309633,
0.0213818215,
-0.0052657584,
-0.0757725984,
-0.0029461652,
-0.0083481064,
0.0307526924,
-0.0385586992,
0.0211982094,
-0.031330213,
0.0308653712,
-0.0192913041,
-0.0321021155,
0.0872182921,
0.0062634693,
0.0254611317,
-0.0974557325,
-0.0108498801,
-0.0544898286,
0.0430616997,
-0.0036017955,
0.0222914182,
0.0085047465,
0.0027923808,
-0.0058873594,
-0.0015166475,
-0.030719189,
-0.0277888924,
0.0206093136,
-0.0538827814,
0.0519792922,
0.013824665,
-0.0527583733,
-0.04627176,
-0.0286627766,
-0.0513154678,
0.0129605681,
-0.0066881287,
0.0062082242,
-0.0393349603,
0.0204596519,
-0.0048284424,
0.0299864523,
-0.0246009361,
-0.023877373,
-0.0236115139,
0.0184342917,
0.054795783,
0.0066067167,
0.0116706826,
0.0116976704,
0.0551561788,
0.0654186532,
-0.0234095231,
0.0112680877,
-0.0374916643,
0.0046596606,
-0.0179033913,
-0.0334522352,
0.0006401486,
0.026180299,
0.0352137871,
-0.0591777191,
-0.0171342231,
0.1074554548,
0.0455624983,
-0.0457793996,
-0.004639376,
-0.0007893946,
0.0148603106,
-0.0307890531,
0.0128227221,
-0.072959967,
-0.0696015581,
-0.0145246247,
-0.0049217027,
-0.0433415659,
-0.0158934183,
-0.0019933532,
-0.0483176522,
0.0359471217,
-0.0157833602,
-0.0291361399,
0.0093388334,
-0.0624361746,
-0.0069508124,
-0.0274405275,
0.0014660851,
-0.0081310887,
-0.0109507246,
-0.0043010633,
0.0066622309,
-0.0445533618,
-0.050480146,
0.0607321262,
-0.0011184604,
0.07214012,
0.0422353446,
0.0352192745,
0.0006063603,
-0.0118558109,
0.0448083431,
0.003591686,
0.0037902202,
-0.0191765856,
0.0597581752,
-0.0070821214,
0.0021918684,
-0.0742102265,
0.0274808388,
-0.044963479,
-0.0365979671,
0.0069461861,
0.1090706065,
-0.0464947,
-0.03697237,
-0.0584731027,
0.032363575,
-0.0206553135,
0.0840079263,
-0.009894453,
-0.0016174567,
-0.0724648014,
0.0457990542,
-0.01306793,
0.0121036526,
-0.023400424,
0.0041667987,
0.0062765242,
-0.0076421965,
-0.0466100313,
-0.0276445858,
0.0354889929,
-0.0300018396,
-0.0103836032,
0.0383361764,
0.0280164033,
0.0392764732,
-0.0376351513,
0.033272434,
0.007091024,
-0.0063044773,
-0.0602049418,
-0.0131515088,
0.0737860724,
0.0008332349,
-0.0218052585,
0.0112008462,
-0.0298520681,
-0.0179998986,
-0.0366164669,
0.0542058647,
0.0301043913,
-0.0175402146,
-0.0214195214,
-0.018204907,
0.0066750864,
0.0554596446,
-0.0389133021,
-0.0176798794,
-0.00716851,
0.0226448607,
0.0121458154,
0.0257864147,
-0.0032918407,
0.0338269211,
-0.0169353299,
0.0250806138,
-0.0127367079,
0.0191073976,
0.0331993625,
0.0321620218,
0.0402183086,
-0.0055915327,
-0.0274044201,
-0.0304043218,
-0.0003145156,
-0.0115290387,
0.0311185215,
-0.0421830006,
0.0215416197,
0.0530264899,
0.0046954383,
-0.0254264828,
-0.0289358292,
-0.0531387292,
-0.0014097004,
-0.02915713,
0.0040763337,
0.0178120546,
0.020426061,
0.0387208126,
-0.0167032592,
-0.0519646704,
0.0015239824,
-0.0143129295,
0.0106279915,
-0.0139976637,
0.078279756,
0.0357116871,
0.0178668387,
0.0038350439,
0.0253460556,
-0.1062103063,
-0.0664066374,
0.0163491443,
0.0520972759,
0.0018156887,
0.0244366638,
0.001020009,
-0.0369887911,
-0.0078607174,
-0.0225033425,
0.0476850197,
-0.0206317771,
0.0098479837,
0.0676613897,
0.0162207317,
-0.0392338932,
-0.0363472924,
0.0930280313,
-0.0010396972,
0.0448352806,
0.0252821874,
-0.044134967,
-0.030190872,
-0.0616447851,
0.0061366581,
0.00658317,
-0.0504285321,
0.047770936,
-0.0653376132,
-0.0241941046,
-0.0044429498,
-0.0068049389,
-0.0056357295,
-0.0214893278,
0.0264098812,
0.0313147455,
0.0318452716,
-0.0478733219,
-0.0164722651,
0.0356315225,
-0.0912736058,
-0.0108656194,
-0.0209052842,
-6.287463613e-33,
0.0118254796,
-0.0110379476,
0.0414984934,
0.0069763968,
0.0033546037,
0.0210710298,
-0.0535762571,
0.0055959388,
-0.0360912569,
0.0440337509,
0.0016967036,
0.0276402999,
0.0050035133,
0.0286142975,
0.0003614954,
-0.0477772243,
0.0088774031,
-0.0035831835,
0.0014804178,
0.0300539006,
0.0165885091,
0.0234019682,
0.0031946246,
-0.0736476332,
0.0143951681,
0.005757153,
0.0349176005,
0.0396424532,
-0.0893542618,
0.070878312,
-0.0529873073,
0.0389282815,
0.0637569726,
0.0030782786,
0.0414400436,
0.0221734941,
-0.0621548779,
-0.0273816194,
0.0212037154,
-0.0411520302,
-0.0711985379,
-0.0281594004,
0.0349314138,
0.0184750035,
-0.0250850208,
-0.0370631479,
0.0092225354,
-0.0376249216,
-0.0310107134,
-0.0209466852,
-0.0522723496,
0.0316113196,
0.0223619007,
-0.0174241159,
-0.0354139693,
0.0039966372,
-0.0554180406,
0.0568007864,
0.0280848034,
-0.0418517031,
0.0203590021,
-0.0092751905,
0.0032685555,
-0.028364202,
-0.0123082716,
0.0761340186,
0.0057271752,
-0.0335196294,
-0.0426939577,
0.0114670005,
-0.0306226164,
0.0294715054,
0.0650485381,
0.0095530041,
0.0348478518,
0.0091360472,
-0.1158810407,
-0.0107858526,
0.0115987938,
0.0434310883,
0.0325971022,
-0.0212862734,
-0.0210855138,
-0.0040711737,
-0.0224662181,
0.0199009068,
-0.045568265,
-0.017704634,
0.0580802597,
-0.0186876878,
0.0187607948,
-0.0175204761,
0.0256423391,
-0.0236003213,
0.0356719196,
0.0089715915,
0.0173556097,
-0.0113632111,
-0.0024122947,
0.0457886383,
-0.0889444277,
-0.0079199784,
0.0127656981,
-0.0085717263,
0.0354677886,
0.0162044279,
0.0375981331,
-0.0320532322,
-0.0240279585,
-0.025879465,
-0.0249200948,
0.0200381447,
0.0021318654,
0.0489056446,
0.0185218956,
0.043346107,
0.0033479582,
0.0639602616,
-0.0192700122,
0.0232873876,
-0.0489856899,
-0.0458001569,
-0.0177847557,
-0.0032425718,
-0.0336506329,
0.0267687924,
-0.0235042814,
0.0471426956,
-0.0293855965,
-0.0828021094,
-0.002314541,
0.0256468672,
2.673e-7,
0.0977144688,
0.0581292026,
0.0094781211,
-0.0113435201,
0.0307338051,
-0.0045625591,
0.0045224102,
0.0073265065,
0.0130372578,
-0.0070843045,
0.0160398949,
0.0458780043,
0.0350396149,
0.0274162088,
-0.0629380941,
-0.0251186136,
-0.0975369811,
-0.0478288941,
-0.0444234647,
-0.0123047968,
0.1032301635,
0.0784918144,
-0.0331398547,
-0.0270131584,
0.0342505947,
-0.0167204849,
0.0699047446,
-0.0161597449,
0.0007436554,
0.0412346981,
0.0147237675,
-0.0126473662,
0.0387476385,
0.0450607352,
0.008509839,
-0.0191720184,
0.0015256737,
0.1016012654,
-0.0379511192,
-0.0019497416,
0.0298819859,
-0.0114437798,
0.03219359,
-0.0494680665,
0.0902815089,
-0.0813854784,
-0.07391534,
0.0057179313,
0.0218921434,
-0.009231736,
0.0591615997,
-0.0047438582,
-0.0171282981,
0.0174609125,
0.0165332165,
0.0010413381,
0.0124744736,
-0.0943374261,
-0.0114551047,
0.012550734,
-0.0533247218,
-0.0185564701,
-0.0015104823,
-0.0081316996,
0.0367496312,
-0.0704818666,
-0.0010599634,
2.543413224e-34,
0.0351198278,
-0.0154477684,
0.002404392,
0.0257437639,
0.0422009453,
0.0109625189,
0.0336750299,
0.0073307985,
0.020034628,
-0.0807575285,
-0.0009566246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02492v1
|
Quantifying the Roles of Visual, Linguistic, and Visual-Linguistic Complexity in Verb Acquisition
| 2023-04-05T15:08:21 | 2023-04-05T15:08:21 |
Yuchen Zhou, Michael J. Tarr, Daniel Yurovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Children typically learn the meanings of nouns earlier than the meanings of
verbs. However, it is unclear whether this asymmetry is a result of complexity
in the visual structure of categories in the world to which language refers,
the structure of language itself, or the interplay between the two sources of
information. We quantitatively test these three hypotheses regarding early verb
learning by employing visual and linguistic representations of words sourced
from large-scale pre-trained artificial neural networks. Examining the
structure of both visual and linguistic embedding spaces, we find, first, that
the representation of verbs is generally more variable and less discriminable
within domain than the representation of nouns. Second, we find that if only
one learning instance per category is available, visual and linguistic
representations are less well aligned in the verb system than in the noun
system. However, in parallel with the course of human language development, if
multiple learning instances per category are available, visual and linguistic
representations become almost as well aligned in the verb system as in the noun
system. Third, we compare the relative contributions of factors that may
predict learning difficulty for individual words. A regression analysis reveals
that visual variability is the strongest factor that internally drives verb
learning, followed by visual-linguistic alignment and linguistic variability.
Based on these results, we conclude that verb acquisition is influenced by all
three sources of complexity, but that the variability of visual structure poses
the most significant challenge for verb learning.
|
[
-0.0078120017,
-0.0128102154,
-0.0717256367,
0.0285132248,
-0.0335593782,
0.023204606,
-0.043170847,
0.0200807508,
0.001326778,
-0.0278991144,
-0.0220986549,
-0.0566695631,
0.0276234243,
0.0032004712,
0.0308102034,
-0.0344656967,
0.0367749557,
-0.0084058922,
-0.0167913958,
-0.0043003093,
0.0026560079,
-0.0135461437,
-0.0050828513,
0.0164719224,
-0.0424016938,
-0.0119273011,
-0.0260249414,
-0.0554768741,
-0.0596581213,
-0.0145990998,
-0.0528109446,
0.0283049159,
0.0458552651,
0.0435059927,
0.0000015841,
-0.0367722213,
0.0298377406,
-0.0365387052,
-0.0111608636,
0.0232136548,
0.0145695973,
-0.055998873,
0.0099522946,
-0.0259720962,
-0.0280570593,
-0.0110091558,
0.0799999982,
-0.0147204846,
-0.0407506414,
-0.00858426,
-0.0051202285,
0.0026360594,
0.0097074257,
-0.0092911879,
-0.0102896011,
0.0214319229,
-0.0079204887,
0.0098850364,
0.0021165549,
-0.023678286,
-0.1216733977,
0.0166365467,
0.0195339154,
0.0446805023,
-0.0109905032,
0.0347176716,
0.0430457257,
-0.0631911755,
0.0140603492,
0.0363356173,
-0.0447039008,
-0.0096111167,
-0.0203576665,
-0.0298025087,
0.0024868313,
0.0680074096,
0.0142637324,
0.0795805305,
0.025550982,
0.0433459021,
-0.0029406811,
-0.0793240368,
0.0006080632,
0.0185198486,
-0.0003643304,
-0.0005044906,
-0.0005692652,
-0.0045316382,
0.0278759729,
0.0251162257,
-0.0138666667,
-0.0276831407,
-0.041301623,
-0.0289413836,
-0.0114639699,
0.0429555848,
-0.0117185283,
-0.0292407759,
-0.023020193,
-0.0505143814,
0.0831068531,
-0.0017450785,
-0.0255602542,
0.0166797116,
-0.0368004665,
0.0649763569,
-0.0004008977,
0.0464929752,
-0.0705738068,
0.0181664489,
-0.0209924355,
-0.0299633481,
-0.0068608546,
-0.0098176608,
-0.0462223962,
-0.026678171,
-0.0424538068,
-0.0072873416,
-0.0108295828,
-0.0649722666,
-0.0327137224,
-0.0119333854,
-0.0173346624,
0.0273676235,
-0.060632769,
0.0025169679,
-0.0407014042,
0.0868849084,
-0.0411813483,
-0.0122136557,
0.0093335267,
-0.0000078133,
0.0089455536,
0.0136735225,
-0.0192538276,
0.0434102193,
-0.0345466025,
-0.0638368726,
-0.0246771444,
0.0035655729,
-0.018835105,
-0.0205760375,
0.0514088236,
-0.0151705453,
0.0235907249,
0.0008303837,
-0.0124984728,
-0.0760018453,
-0.0289900973,
-0.0134250587,
-0.0244424604,
0.0488215871,
0.0176880341,
0.0239869915,
-0.0030999535,
-0.0159063861,
-0.006330499,
0.0381612107,
0.0339914821,
-0.0354386158,
0.0129458504,
-0.0417037681,
-0.0194324516,
0.0048512942,
0.007813897,
-0.0157692377,
-0.0331065655,
-0.0558900386,
0.0014582524,
0.0418938249,
0.0293366835,
0.042721387,
-0.0402062275,
-0.0304359403,
0.0482031293,
0.0954261795,
0.0246843491,
-0.0333963856,
0.0573077723,
-0.0054088021,
0.0346416384,
0.0121554043,
-0.0081888391,
0.005108336,
-0.0130503755,
-0.0245104097,
-0.0810228214,
0.0279853474,
-0.0290794484,
-0.0168014299,
-0.0389502607,
0.0028952747,
0.0494188629,
-0.0024611107,
0.0548456945,
0.0558412857,
-0.0262715686,
-0.004226278,
0.0435901769,
-0.0412384123,
0.0033992892,
-0.0034647412,
0.04923594,
-0.0235063192,
-0.0479899384,
0.0192405675,
0.0108521068,
0.0426940881,
0.0214308109,
0.0277650636,
-0.0130307013,
0.0095306868,
0.0047931764,
-0.0255956482,
-0.0232942849,
0.0070017274,
0.006104236,
-0.0106986035,
-0.0281486139,
-0.0261674691,
-0.0447338261,
0.0008507979,
-0.0186107717,
0.0529646948,
-0.0382716432,
-0.0242168754,
-0.0398282185,
0.0393105857,
0.0255629029,
-0.045076672,
0.0181256235,
0.033925198,
0.003913308,
0.0192811918,
0.0185046997,
0.0097552491,
-0.0370440483,
-0.0197826046,
0.0176536385,
-0.0224534124,
-0.0172137376,
0.0067034089,
0.0314773582,
0.0021394752,
0.0355431326,
-0.0903017148,
0.0472875312,
0.0033693432,
0.0342083722,
-0.0064015761,
0.0545411371,
-0.0263489373,
0.0433081612,
-0.030328054,
0.0183902904,
-0.0353123806,
-0.0284839123,
0.0024137525,
0.0263510849,
-0.0078697586,
0.0009782842,
-0.0153421666,
0.0115317786,
-0.0203343946,
-0.018710006,
-0.0809443444,
0.0091337943,
-0.0349827297,
-0.0034700376,
0.0342265442,
-0.0018401388,
0.0043154596,
-0.047301352,
0.0115167471,
-0.0058344817,
-0.0015761466,
0.1094479188,
-0.0368511938,
0.0536417626,
0.0296847895,
-0.0118610999,
-0.0704207867,
-0.0335787497,
-0.0235712361,
-0.0341688432,
0.0496258438,
-0.0018223694,
0.0037167636,
-0.0013519047,
0.0258989614,
-0.0079280268,
0.0179466438,
0.0114732236,
-0.0360785611,
0.0651967824,
0.0014525751,
0.0660405532,
0.0580213703,
-0.0090194447,
0.1000234485,
0.0739295185,
-0.0250234231,
-0.0464846529,
-0.0491554327,
-0.0518610217,
-0.0252141263,
-0.0380926318,
-0.0052445424,
-0.0151517652,
0.1013510674,
0.0201388784,
-0.0049988911,
-0.0431363136,
0.0614212081,
-0.0589368567,
-0.0171309114,
-0.0441078916,
-0.0515695475,
-0.0557655282,
0.0430885181,
-0.028718736,
-0.0533573963,
0.0187811889,
0.0092173349,
0.0163057372,
-0.0127189262,
0.0019048952,
0.0334679596,
0.0692082271,
0.0448464341,
0.0262442287,
0.0369346738,
-0.0259854551,
-0.1467154622,
-0.003843738,
0.0921029821,
-0.0162116047,
0.0749360472,
-0.0693478212,
-0.030028658,
0.0100628072,
-0.0107287411,
-0.0085971691,
-0.0340591818,
0.0134616233,
-0.0211636778,
0.0060777185,
-0.0139732473,
0.0187139083,
-0.0371251144,
0.0086903758,
-0.0057324804,
0.0301480796,
-0.0069795982,
-0.0165993925,
0.0176979508,
-0.0141259152,
0.0142227402,
0.00357148,
-0.0275215097,
0.0016453441,
0.0433160327,
-0.031180786,
0.0185322221,
-0.0366706587,
0.073413603,
0.0672288388,
0.0022563634,
-0.0326957963,
0.008836383,
0.0270945467,
0.0078381104,
0.019831147,
0.0085099563,
0.0447543971,
-0.0002050799,
0.0601172596,
0.0064328378,
0.0086572375,
0.0235913955,
-0.0082996422,
-0.0291519929,
0.0142748058,
-0.0044998224,
-0.0370655693,
-0.0055954442,
-0.0188775845,
-0.0156167755,
-0.0845732987,
-0.0210662559,
-0.0155403223,
-0.0621356033,
-0.0210326463,
0.0193464886,
-0.0142020537,
0.0523187444,
0.0105940392,
-0.0056718253,
-0.0377225354,
0.0218032897,
-0.0078737736,
0.0297050569,
-0.0157717243,
-0.003990673,
-0.0567663647,
0.0465312414,
-0.0157174245,
0.0180654861,
-0.0467358716,
-0.0295162126,
0.0607414208,
0.0052247145,
-0.0157237258,
-0.005609334,
0.0207180642,
0.0572867058,
-0.0247956365,
-0.0254726578,
0.0123205138,
0.0350258574,
-0.0554523356,
-0.0213857312,
0.0833626613,
0.0415156372,
-0.0219861772,
0.0186828952,
-0.0151617853,
-0.0493944101,
0.0374632627,
0.0512293242,
-0.0375550389,
0.0370999463,
0.0108034248,
-0.0061656088,
0.0592060722,
-0.0908570737,
0.0338242166,
-0.0426709019,
-0.0110702571,
-0.0704590902,
-0.0285607576,
0.041062355,
0.0223945044,
0.0398804806,
-0.0301294532,
0.0488779172,
-0.0428909585,
-0.0422461145,
0.0557626374,
0.0238908771,
-0.00094357,
0.0083283568,
-0.0372856595,
0.0124748861,
-0.0107778553,
-0.0266853925,
-0.0059560193,
0.0362177007,
-0.0387859717,
0.0249523837,
-0.0109159788,
0.0168164205,
-0.0076812813,
0.0522265658,
-0.0466771796,
0.0305485558,
-0.0107797664,
0.0031594061,
0.045718614,
-0.0068949768,
-0.0225640945,
0.0137881869,
0.0137214707,
-0.0018166258,
0.0059590135,
-0.0165450796,
0.0095940391,
-0.0013844466,
0.0306795314,
0.0405939892,
-0.0164428428,
0.0757260025,
-0.0245232042,
0.0148501992,
-0.0698287264,
-0.0665335581,
-0.0037159519,
0.0187195297,
-0.0160799809,
-0.0286305957,
0.0834316164,
0.0449318178,
-0.0212804116,
0.011002684,
0.0317662172,
-0.0147793749,
0.0276866574,
-0.0097956974,
0.0434491299,
0.0115804449,
-0.0117905792,
0.0844565779,
0.0277222097,
0.0329647399,
-0.0768686831,
0.0006836912,
-0.0097462973,
0.0527273268,
0.0122768534,
0.0227334835,
-0.0214218646,
-0.0184811577,
0.0011710692,
-0.0241016373,
0.000876466,
-0.0391778164,
0.0340393633,
-0.0777517259,
0.0192646403,
-0.0620115772,
0.0143597526,
-0.0250040125,
-0.0037597059,
-0.0467095673,
-0.008917124,
0.0809429213,
0.0054970975,
-0.012390337,
-0.0398316719,
0.0473334678,
-0.0146001447,
0.0344116166,
-0.0449411497,
0.0054657054,
-0.0074582915,
-0.0135855339,
0.0587483011,
0.0080778096,
-0.0081128385,
0.0398364849,
-0.0664161369,
-0.0528736524,
-0.0282204207,
-0.0062080626,
0.0066250735,
0.0130977789,
0.0461814031,
0.0265993569,
0.0031860839,
0.0253207944,
-0.0310561564,
0.0079221884,
-0.0212150831,
-0.0026722942,
0.0182632022,
-5.003640478e-33,
-0.0101157445,
-0.0368773416,
0.0152210565,
-0.0075256703,
0.0046698097,
0.037329305,
0.0018932768,
0.073298119,
-0.0198430978,
0.0544155128,
0.063130267,
-0.0006829564,
-0.0073109791,
0.0100131761,
0.0558543317,
0.0061411066,
-0.0290937517,
-0.0450180359,
0.0159353167,
-0.0715016797,
0.0046583964,
-0.014566795,
0.0470710658,
-0.0611515678,
-0.0109658735,
0.070621416,
0.0207966957,
0.0061565442,
0.0088079469,
0.0438702069,
-0.0334525704,
0.046949856,
0.007112856,
0.0010734061,
-0.0213552881,
0.0078475662,
-0.0267135501,
-0.064625904,
0.0451048464,
0.0272925515,
-0.1089919955,
0.0166086946,
0.047601711,
-0.0467394926,
-0.0202614982,
-0.0105286567,
0.0303778555,
0.0185990669,
0.0100959539,
0.0013045584,
-0.0839851201,
-0.0294719562,
0.0056909882,
-0.0293281991,
0.0318804421,
-0.0238395762,
0.0159945991,
-0.0214168597,
-0.0298724491,
0.0311305355,
-0.0301528238,
0.0428627506,
0.0365105979,
0.0383236371,
0.0181288812,
0.0585586466,
0.0867290199,
-0.0287810303,
0.0093272505,
0.0160641577,
0.0749653205,
0.0327923745,
0.0270460416,
0.0270561669,
0.0414562561,
-0.0051721004,
-0.0330621824,
-0.0449530259,
0.0000323663,
0.0309218559,
-0.0303056967,
-0.0144851431,
-0.0187096577,
-0.0168497134,
-0.0319777168,
-0.0196068902,
-0.0250926316,
-0.004238579,
0.0490878485,
-0.0047006081,
0.0671412349,
-0.0211335067,
0.0030020145,
-0.0460108779,
-0.0222735703,
-0.0093336888,
-0.019225847,
0.0367366374,
0.0277302712,
-0.0015823807,
-0.0309785176,
-0.0644392669,
-0.0190460645,
0.0113739846,
0.0306731649,
0.057184089,
0.0295531452,
-0.0140868174,
-0.0199768972,
-0.0085852602,
-0.0160016119,
-0.092865102,
0.0297221988,
-0.0409047231,
0.0391815789,
0.0076742647,
-0.039129816,
-0.0099174408,
0.0363756195,
-0.0367047042,
-0.0244997162,
-0.0415712483,
-0.0432328433,
0.0238376558,
-0.004629299,
-0.034048941,
-0.0421146676,
0.0362438299,
0.098086901,
-0.0599296987,
0.0015942175,
-0.0004971653,
2.499e-7,
0.0659156665,
0.0745557919,
0.0034632857,
0.0391656645,
-0.0008194929,
0.0110178087,
-0.0110399676,
-0.0223952867,
-0.053510271,
-0.0137237618,
-0.0499188229,
0.0155319059,
-0.0027575765,
-0.0059792353,
-0.0002579584,
-0.0173841156,
0.0250379033,
0.0562926382,
-0.0059573897,
0.06377922,
0.0913409665,
0.067954503,
0.0153036462,
-0.0083288401,
-0.0378294103,
-0.0319618024,
0.0635567755,
-0.0368588269,
0.0511989109,
-0.0285278074,
-0.0356868505,
0.017568158,
0.0182144605,
0.032763429,
-0.0165431499,
0.0349087194,
0.01067382,
-0.0233453065,
-0.000392976,
0.0392949767,
0.0001135514,
-0.0237122066,
-0.0334017724,
0.0025703842,
0.0114532942,
-0.0682464615,
-0.0327637196,
0.0393033698,
0.0278120283,
0.0367811881,
0.0461380184,
0.0225872993,
-0.0022317122,
-0.0126598952,
0.0264377724,
-0.002458727,
-0.0075992318,
-0.0544078797,
0.0101249926,
0.0496640429,
-0.0019173236,
-0.0141829979,
0.0006591025,
0.0107889576,
0.0709774941,
-0.0001116625,
-0.0314910002,
1.496025258e-34,
-0.0090133343,
-0.0368277393,
0.08912839,
0.0081580114,
-0.0034165927,
-0.0581539422,
0.0266266707,
0.0289477035,
0.0355723798,
-0.015869936,
-0.00212193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02426v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02426v5
|
ParroT: Translating during Chat using Large Language Models tuned with Human Translation and Feedback
| 2023-04-05T13:12:00 | 2023-11-02T07:44:52 |
Wenxiang Jiao, Jen-tse Huang, Wenxuan Wang, Zhiwei He, Tian Liang, Xing Wang, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have exhibited remarkable abilities
on a wide range of natural language processing~(NLP) tasks, including various
machine translation abilities accomplished during chat. However, these models
are only accessible through restricted APIs, which creates barriers to new
research and advancements in the field. Therefore, we propose ParroT, a
framework to enhance and regulate the translation abilities during chat based
on open-source LLMs (e.g., LLaMA), human-written translation and feedback data.
Specifically, ParroT reformulates translation data into the
instruction-following style, and introduces a "$\mathbf{Hint}$" field for
incorporating extra requirements to regulate the translation process.
Accordingly, we propose three instruction types for finetuning ParroT models,
including translation instruction, contrastive instruction, and error-guided
instruction. Experiments on Flores subsets and WMT22 test sets suggest that
translation instruction improves the translation performance of vanilla LLMs
significantly while error-guided instruction can lead to further improvement,
which demonstrates the importance of learning from low-quality translations
annotated by humans. We also demonstrate the potential of automatic evaluation
tools in providing quality information of translations, when constructing
error-guided instructions for directions that lack human annotation data.
Please refer to our Github project for more implementation details:
https://github.com/wxjiao/ParroT
|
[
0.0769712701,
0.0246175528,
-0.0206265617,
0.047840979,
-0.0356035978,
0.0168177709,
-0.0019921027,
0.0175176226,
0.0204219911,
-0.0366094746,
-0.0767056942,
-0.0326490365,
0.0448750146,
-0.028491104,
0.0423241518,
-0.0828370303,
0.0420546941,
-0.0230401512,
-0.0306386258,
0.0080827652,
0.0026685162,
0.010473446,
-0.0154116815,
0.0576352514,
0.0167773701,
-0.012146675,
-0.0042400649,
0.0416750871,
0.0089591602,
-0.0242283698,
0.0140217124,
0.0567574985,
-0.0040968973,
0.0440781675,
0.0000019176,
-0.0219390169,
0.0121614626,
-0.0045546982,
-0.0002659201,
0.0008727777,
0.0697618797,
-0.0359988809,
-0.0347425789,
0.0435362905,
-0.0213050134,
-0.013241603,
0.0390949287,
0.0311254486,
0.0869473591,
0.0957340896,
0.0069509707,
-0.0004849856,
-0.002510719,
-0.0113252997,
0.0358979478,
-0.0572903603,
-0.0145167913,
0.0188277476,
-0.0047456836,
0.0591816641,
-0.002974092,
0.0422786437,
0.0111151664,
-0.0267963149,
-0.0080664521,
0.0204706043,
-0.048057951,
-0.0415348224,
-0.0453591011,
0.1003279239,
0.0044669686,
-0.0032983683,
-0.0208971947,
0.0176601913,
0.0009549183,
-0.0360797159,
-0.0595980957,
-0.0047362321,
0.0057233293,
-0.0084812492,
0.0195215493,
0.0052284435,
0.0040972843,
0.0070439796,
0.016549971,
0.0039120074,
0.0121923015,
-0.011975592,
-0.0148639232,
0.0183362383,
-0.0332072563,
-0.0481601581,
0.0712575093,
0.0313525237,
-0.0447609387,
0.0265528373,
-0.0390275605,
-0.0257648323,
0.0265897736,
-0.0850636885,
0.0237400141,
0.0894290656,
-0.036795225,
0.0394715331,
0.0053182594,
0.0459796637,
-0.0118408613,
0.039478261,
-0.054504063,
-0.0097051021,
-0.0404993445,
0.0328502804,
-0.0437099561,
-0.007122275,
-0.0397738442,
-0.0127763376,
-0.033221487,
0.0268117972,
0.0217491668,
0.0199429877,
0.0355032124,
-0.0155974561,
-0.0517857186,
-0.0090552885,
0.0077699977,
0.043484401,
-0.0205641277,
-0.0176446754,
0.0096636675,
-0.0685797483,
-0.011430935,
0.0343453959,
0.0027814975,
-0.0148654515,
-0.0181356501,
0.0880674198,
-0.0100693125,
-0.036161337,
-0.009918225,
-0.0087779602,
-0.0056242975,
-0.058499787,
-0.000201647,
-0.047289487,
0.0633938015,
0.0058589275,
0.0064503914,
0.0107039865,
0.0210907813,
0.0412136801,
-0.0242238976,
0.0547002479,
-0.0192859918,
0.0143578947,
0.0279561765,
0.0207329728,
-0.0567289852,
0.0641133562,
0.0447221957,
0.038682241,
0.0510343798,
0.0070632054,
-0.0086395284,
0.0609294288,
0.0013873443,
0.0244963598,
-0.0015609568,
0.0087660365,
0.0009885529,
0.0532447174,
0.0090583107,
0.0858360901,
-0.0434751958,
0.0137660848,
0.0631704256,
0.0435046367,
-0.001633366,
0.0493586473,
0.0484172814,
0.0396125317,
0.0186212976,
0.0004060931,
-0.0605839193,
0.0180034023,
-0.0462980345,
-0.0218384303,
0.0273480583,
0.0227456596,
-0.0308087133,
-0.043438103,
-0.0024179402,
-0.032929115,
0.0207015369,
-0.0182536747,
0.033141721,
0.0155586563,
-0.0446433462,
0.0323152542,
0.0282033402,
-0.0209283438,
-0.0135045461,
-0.0291818026,
-0.008890559,
0.1033898443,
0.0629046559,
0.0116195902,
-0.019922046,
-0.0196790807,
0.008515914,
0.0453340188,
0.0659777299,
-0.0023076059,
0.0138639687,
-0.0621551909,
-0.0125312498,
0.0522811301,
0.0053163744,
-0.0133122839,
0.0529335327,
0.0211441722,
0.0175448302,
-0.0213768315,
-0.0660585687,
0.0359536037,
-0.005758353,
-0.009077901,
0.0088794781,
-0.0243868791,
0.006090729,
0.0377945825,
0.0038677885,
-0.0189703573,
0.0061193453,
0.0004107456,
-0.0026592293,
0.0376559198,
-0.0577332899,
-0.0923842713,
0.0321795419,
-0.0009134038,
-0.0458748564,
0.0222569611,
-0.0472913943,
-0.0267140027,
-0.0237259623,
-0.0532106943,
0.0330390334,
-0.0182798058,
0.0346321873,
0.0222187527,
0.0053957263,
-0.0014727099,
0.0135381399,
-0.0036554988,
0.0084842648,
0.0102132922,
-0.0123075582,
-0.008272483,
-0.0474003553,
-0.0060908385,
0.0297281481,
0.0081953183,
0.0291484091,
0.0087472489,
0.0702916607,
-0.0601914339,
-0.0262372252,
-0.1049050912,
0.0316224769,
-0.0354568325,
0.0239455532,
0.0355262645,
0.0188407842,
-0.018856531,
-0.0176040325,
-0.0144391069,
0.0072214575,
0.0210197214,
0.0082295239,
0.0184192974,
-0.0114956377,
-0.0210712608,
-0.0473420471,
0.0019361356,
0.0098394454,
0.0031066113,
0.0297910441,
-0.0391488485,
-0.083318159,
0.0205883346,
-0.0250106882,
0.012616667,
0.0097248089,
-0.0774323866,
0.001560058,
-0.004417473,
0.0389115326,
0.0349906497,
0.0147256777,
0.0201014206,
0.0036536555,
-0.0019435952,
-0.0596024916,
0.0079042129,
-0.0357958414,
-0.0418367684,
-0.0197313596,
-0.0457356013,
-0.0178913847,
0.0380327031,
0.0076309559,
0.026021691,
-0.0740143731,
-0.0238547176,
-0.0208596662,
-0.0210429002,
-0.0100523969,
0.0340741873,
-0.0153001938,
0.0156219341,
-0.0286573265,
-0.0647853464,
0.0847087055,
-0.048954051,
-0.033641126,
-0.0570401177,
0.0122947926,
-0.0391401276,
0.0484635979,
-0.0181413908,
0.0183923803,
-0.0150970947,
-0.0180040691,
0.0006175606,
0.0241296943,
-0.0076357741,
-0.0458764918,
-0.0001555405,
-0.0710087791,
-0.0072703352,
0.0059792618,
-0.0087426258,
-0.0380452499,
-0.0036636586,
-0.0352380574,
0.0039738761,
0.0116353054,
-0.0346246921,
-0.0140315108,
0.0171412546,
0.0235345475,
0.0496411137,
-0.0183787439,
-0.0147056663,
-0.0221512634,
-0.0181591772,
0.0160607696,
0.001884805,
-0.0126500698,
-0.054065261,
0.0255215801,
0.0314840339,
0.01461008,
-0.0420258082,
-0.0062457351,
-0.005636069,
0.0462282225,
-0.008134665,
-0.0421736836,
0.0180483758,
0.0838718712,
-0.0555127226,
-0.0153755648,
0.1194118187,
0.0387035571,
-0.052546557,
0.0013739535,
-0.0264576357,
0.0331251323,
0.0056785811,
0.0392264165,
-0.0911754519,
-0.0460417159,
0.0112075256,
0.0485269316,
0.0312150326,
0.0037648752,
-0.0247761998,
-0.1039739922,
0.0475388989,
0.0359218791,
-0.0403992571,
-0.038567517,
-0.0172978342,
0.0042713797,
-0.0259770527,
0.0426162891,
-0.0123291137,
0.0073238541,
-0.0147385607,
0.0045292578,
-0.0131357946,
-0.0537973046,
0.0182997696,
-0.0503386445,
0.0794017166,
0.0556351542,
0.0311122257,
0.0435796864,
-0.0311608035,
0.0392548777,
-0.0048601432,
0.0069227205,
-0.0432337821,
0.0476885438,
-0.0131824305,
-0.0082569299,
-0.0190323479,
0.0191556793,
-0.0386574604,
0.0066848719,
0.0060850014,
0.0391308516,
-0.0384147614,
0.0219437033,
0.0082223769,
0.040146511,
0.0279135685,
0.0723611861,
0.025554141,
-0.0348301642,
-0.0042451611,
-0.0426050164,
-0.0264247376,
-0.0356031135,
-0.0235783607,
-0.0045844666,
-0.0361167416,
-0.0377810597,
-0.1066380963,
-0.0678627416,
0.045706071,
0.005535251,
-0.002377246,
-0.0029237424,
-0.0002938375,
0.0110879177,
0.0430931523,
0.031031929,
-0.0528700016,
0.0244008508,
-0.0626366809,
-0.0407421999,
0.0139329871,
-0.0388850756,
0.0240456332,
0.0526441075,
-0.0873180926,
-0.0850988701,
0.0054678498,
0.0801869184,
0.0240614638,
0.0457369052,
-0.0503866412,
-0.0224651843,
-0.0282191932,
0.0454797894,
-0.0392393358,
0.0030555562,
0.0416578874,
0.0604084022,
-0.0029789584,
0.0545125492,
0.0045487131,
0.0039628362,
-0.0251025073,
0.0616696626,
-0.0215591956,
-0.0754663497,
0.0223747585,
0.0224713348,
0.0175496191,
-0.0228125006,
-0.0214331653,
-0.0119966315,
0.0257523451,
-0.0224503428,
-0.01106524,
-0.0597653538,
-0.0083155008,
0.0135771772,
-0.0318913981,
-0.0048565585,
-0.0304584671,
-0.0464649461,
-0.0081898607,
-0.0209826659,
0.0129967611,
-0.0176496021,
-0.0127534345,
0.010953852,
0.0170579273,
-0.0242107846,
0.0164162852,
-0.0140762627,
0.0313288011,
-0.030984655,
0.0780089125,
0.0040341951,
-0.0326760858,
-0.0104981763,
0.036247272,
-0.017761359,
-0.0507308319,
-0.0046342751,
0.0898670852,
0.0798200369,
0.0153776342,
0.0818021595,
-0.0426787212,
0.0021698065,
-0.0105060106,
0.0536825471,
-0.0122849317,
-0.0303765442,
0.0189233366,
-0.0086132493,
0.0122365719,
0.00724001,
0.055464983,
-0.0151342191,
0.045119334,
-0.0101349354,
-0.0080914479,
-0.0262016896,
0.0051952153,
0.0104946438,
-0.0112511357,
-0.020118434,
0.0054389425,
-0.0237272382,
-0.0658368841,
-0.0248584375,
0.0201557465,
-0.0071939831,
-0.0420643464,
0.0458428413,
0.0513415039,
-0.0392931923,
-0.013286355,
-0.0525062755,
-0.018608734,
-0.0132924821,
-0.0257480275,
-0.0366267934,
-6.292439627e-33,
-0.0473546013,
-0.0252921805,
0.0262959767,
0.0179823097,
-0.0097124847,
-0.0448807925,
-0.0574638546,
-0.0066121286,
0.0011325218,
0.0020596348,
-0.0209411662,
0.0174868405,
0.0269217491,
0.0004722839,
-0.0140641937,
-0.0151999081,
0.0552888513,
-0.0056222873,
-0.0377431139,
0.0358253159,
0.0184768531,
0.0159894936,
0.0676802322,
-0.0635999888,
0.0404992811,
-0.0289033111,
-0.0302569829,
0.0475572459,
0.0052227443,
0.0439774655,
-0.0126070986,
0.0104277087,
0.0149393072,
-0.0187590905,
-0.024711458,
0.0115999039,
-0.071239315,
-0.0100490171,
0.0349685811,
0.0392407887,
-0.0444869734,
-0.0188388545,
0.0267488062,
-0.0468565151,
-0.0074421158,
0.0187505111,
0.0044464776,
-0.0372830704,
-0.0249364302,
0.0452993661,
-0.0547092147,
0.0335876346,
-0.0128496625,
-0.0706082657,
0.0070388904,
0.0501581542,
-0.0111841187,
-0.0271334704,
-0.0448660925,
0.0289226975,
0.0188371204,
0.0113663748,
0.0588630363,
0.0017229142,
-0.0069635236,
0.0173923038,
0.0408304222,
0.0135702239,
0.0169806946,
-0.0170976464,
0.0101703946,
0.0180181023,
0.0350944959,
0.0214185622,
-0.0041599306,
-0.0174693298,
-0.0234654564,
0.0443694517,
0.0291927643,
0.0153452307,
-0.0064439573,
0.0289409924,
-0.0591822751,
-0.0052235681,
-0.0210356899,
-0.0161015857,
-0.0205939338,
-0.0421116278,
0.0062174853,
0.0401150994,
-0.039124202,
-0.0300870333,
0.067906335,
-0.0109889982,
0.0110257342,
-0.0260615852,
-0.0339761265,
0.0258754101,
-0.0276467931,
0.0198698714,
-0.0618775487,
-0.0489516407,
0.0378537178,
0.0042329892,
0.0147721432,
0.0003782315,
0.0474564806,
0.0313848406,
-0.054564029,
0.0303367469,
-0.048349686,
0.0356455743,
-0.0358355753,
-0.0266994424,
0.034687113,
-0.0080940872,
-0.0413343422,
0.0858743489,
0.0241184812,
0.0195329618,
-0.0560681336,
-0.0189642776,
-0.0114082983,
0.0012968875,
-0.0598319359,
0.0385559425,
-0.0194704104,
-0.0020479588,
0.0061640646,
-0.0471996032,
-0.0279110596,
-0.0028630516,
2.655e-7,
0.0269286204,
0.0684537515,
0.0189829729,
0.0631559417,
0.0133043909,
0.034526471,
-0.01997835,
0.0184844229,
0.0213511568,
0.0020532741,
0.0292416327,
0.0505814813,
0.0695355162,
0.0247190464,
-0.0668302178,
-0.0366413146,
-0.0515012331,
0.0032623413,
-0.0456731617,
-0.0114939129,
0.0730545446,
0.0929923952,
-0.0037686385,
0.0140311569,
-0.0201931559,
-0.0188771319,
0.080355987,
-0.0278611258,
-0.0359535255,
0.0102370065,
0.0600291528,
0.0378931463,
-0.033480227,
-0.008006243,
-0.0051570204,
-0.0177613404,
0.0138818789,
0.092949383,
0.0062253703,
0.0039954162,
0.0189248994,
-0.0158448592,
-0.01038926,
-0.0547266342,
0.0416388847,
-0.0504475608,
-0.0202502105,
0.0046048337,
0.0306502692,
-0.0181491412,
0.0109032542,
-0.0471704602,
-0.0592747591,
0.0214744136,
0.0340394415,
0.0046179383,
-0.0331668369,
-0.0489531718,
-0.0324583091,
-0.0137335062,
-0.0310875177,
-0.0497043505,
-0.0335892625,
0.0106780427,
-0.0256844983,
-0.0365376659,
-0.0010674961,
2.207397475e-34,
0.0455015115,
-0.020102635,
0.0084926644,
0.0298260674,
0.0612625442,
-0.0096874442,
0.0378991477,
0.0180115607,
0.0242344439,
-0.0460183322,
-0.0385708436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02328v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02328v1
|
Enhancing Multimodal Entity and Relation Extraction with Variational Information Bottleneck
| 2023-04-05T09:32:25 | 2023-04-05T09:32:25 |
Shiyao Cui, Jiangxia Cao, Xin Cong, Jiawei Sheng, Quangang Li, Tingwen Liu, Jinqiao Shi
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL
|
This paper studies the multimodal named entity recognition (MNER) and
multimodal relation extraction (MRE), which are important for multimedia social
platform analysis. The core of MNER and MRE lies in incorporating evident
visual information to enhance textual semantics, where two issues inherently
demand investigations. The first issue is modality-noise, where the
task-irrelevant information in each modality may be noises misleading the task
prediction. The second issue is modality-gap, where representations from
different modalities are inconsistent, preventing from building the semantic
alignment between the text and image. To address these issues, we propose a
novel method for MNER and MRE by Multi-Modal representation learning with
Information Bottleneck (MMIB). For the first issue, a refinement-regularizer
probes the information-bottleneck principle to balance the predictive evidence
and noisy information, yielding expressive representations for prediction. For
the second issue, an alignment-regularizer is proposed, where a mutual
information-based item works in a contrastive manner to regularize the
consistent text-image representations. To our best knowledge, we are the first
to explore variational IB estimation for MNER and MRE. Experiments show that
MMIB achieves the state-of-the-art performances on three public benchmarks.
|
[
0.0292504728,
0.0885541141,
0.030826373,
0.0704133585,
-0.0198630281,
0.0281146932,
-0.002604444,
0.0168380924,
-0.012922789,
-0.0406806879,
-0.016519852,
-0.048078429,
0.0026965106,
-0.0147628933,
0.0531114675,
-0.0847457796,
0.0168307591,
0.0159078259,
0.0133081507,
0.0088297492,
0.063926287,
0.0133012114,
-0.0102384957,
-0.0034427051,
-0.0432242863,
-0.0051886635,
0.0030777303,
0.0300792214,
0.0534372814,
-0.0727254003,
-0.0038151757,
0.0517791063,
0.0223601945,
0.0197842233,
0.0000020457,
-0.0158490855,
-0.0120644951,
0.0058375308,
-0.0132001759,
-0.0457375906,
0.0432631001,
-0.0520041473,
0.026639333,
-0.0561706461,
-0.0036661378,
-0.0465706587,
0.0638491362,
0.1068693176,
0.0159645099,
0.0696532205,
-0.0514986105,
-0.0250010006,
0.0314288065,
-0.0416055433,
0.0446526557,
-0.0728043392,
0.0135770934,
-0.0070338566,
0.0075422078,
-0.0064121587,
-0.0305441506,
0.0400151648,
-0.0107219163,
0.0088497102,
0.0204755869,
0.0432800129,
0.0342748128,
-0.033430174,
-0.0434765406,
0.1153941527,
0.0274833851,
0.025955243,
-0.0012459973,
-0.0188295115,
-0.0020998649,
0.0555512644,
-0.0111002168,
0.0049141506,
-0.0409003124,
0.0150479907,
-0.0245810859,
0.026819868,
0.0223340075,
-0.0045777778,
0.0168877393,
-0.045860216,
0.0064014215,
-0.0090555223,
0.0163382664,
0.0330506638,
-0.039794229,
-0.0074057733,
-0.0160239767,
0.0021048679,
0.0078604119,
0.0141282575,
-0.0566874258,
-0.0560473502,
-0.0355392322,
-0.0287508499,
-0.0136420149,
-0.0148684438,
-0.0245011002,
0.0780555978,
0.0040834807,
0.0045027672,
-0.0558316596,
0.0092583578,
0.0052693938,
-0.0012163561,
-0.0348898098,
0.0122100692,
0.0235716272,
0.0233279373,
-0.0205304753,
-0.0280403141,
-0.0051844716,
0.0073368042,
-0.0284504797,
0.0208038706,
-0.0525183491,
0.0381580554,
-0.0246706195,
-0.0118885199,
-0.0129185347,
0.0424557291,
-0.0302575808,
0.0201579276,
-0.0107470127,
-0.0204719938,
0.0145425443,
0.0299215354,
0.0515707284,
-0.0607033148,
0.0109432181,
0.0835915357,
-0.036481414,
-0.0546865091,
-0.0235148519,
-0.0221968088,
-0.014628714,
-0.060137473,
0.0429178216,
-0.0228662677,
0.0731417909,
0.0095545622,
0.0034939733,
-0.0276203603,
0.0040638517,
-0.0331647322,
-0.0636872575,
0.075002417,
-0.0416695662,
-0.0404668972,
0.0134180244,
0.0360019505,
0.0373366624,
0.0773355365,
0.0389943309,
0.0166323204,
0.0447012484,
0.0123241823,
-0.0272512659,
0.0337557979,
0.0139751062,
-0.012667804,
-0.0129414452,
-0.0216824301,
-0.0096063362,
-0.0030206975,
0.0607233308,
0.0569709837,
-0.0380130075,
-0.0276626926,
0.0532259569,
-0.0077397665,
-0.0055482825,
-0.0045487029,
-0.0021786091,
-0.0039530285,
0.0162172094,
0.0309045166,
-0.0485608019,
0.04893931,
-0.0071630478,
0.0052980566,
0.0356233008,
0.056481611,
-0.0109539628,
0.0253160875,
0.0373067632,
-0.0112856664,
0.0083354879,
-0.0037571157,
0.0645865276,
-0.0192541145,
-0.0599605367,
0.0375426114,
0.0465524383,
0.0249250736,
-0.0161855482,
0.0386943109,
0.0154856164,
0.0230706558,
-0.0010374713,
-0.0437165722,
-0.014400769,
-0.0034011235,
-0.0077514793,
0.0484418347,
-0.0171477851,
-0.0144070424,
0.0514548533,
-0.0214422718,
-0.0791452006,
0.0118963309,
-0.007681448,
0.0121177537,
-0.0034626657,
-0.0015247493,
0.011188495,
-0.0057165343,
0.036702998,
0.0270703621,
0.0603184439,
0.0115724457,
-0.0153951058,
0.0469528027,
0.0318128392,
0.0319546573,
-0.0348478593,
-0.0494047739,
-0.0001505873,
-0.0525086522,
-0.0037743195,
0.0192906708,
-0.0365275182,
-0.0515059792,
0.0305633061,
-0.0435397513,
-0.0260979254,
-0.0015675938,
-0.0335392393,
-0.0427595712,
0.0314967632,
-0.0046904916,
0.0195798501,
-0.0063221557,
-0.0186250079,
0.0291359592,
0.0373738669,
-0.0138086062,
0.0618585013,
-0.0426120609,
0.00785283,
0.0016959267,
-0.0139027806,
0.0052702078,
-0.0092450511,
-0.0508094691,
0.0288078319,
-0.0054561249,
-0.0062841144,
0.031526614,
-0.0128000407,
-0.0327220857,
0.0127422214,
-0.1100150049,
-0.0247664806,
-0.0083281742,
0.0134222489,
-0.0173725914,
0.0473753102,
0.0022087435,
-0.0388773605,
0.0256837718,
0.0106797311,
-0.0384682864,
0.0203574784,
0.0250069685,
0.0698425844,
0.0008815449,
-0.0357055888,
-0.0000291955,
-0.0026207815,
0.0687313601,
0.028532695,
-0.0708604008,
-0.002526117,
-0.0136997737,
-0.0431459062,
0.0526108854,
-0.0301237181,
0.0275401194,
0.0028650099,
0.0003387397,
0.0682901293,
0.0018195139,
-0.0029929716,
0.0501816832,
-0.0264672711,
-0.0010075821,
-0.0222465973,
0.0306984503,
-0.0149217667,
0.0327765793,
-0.0275178738,
-0.0317377262,
-0.0059063858,
0.0613135844,
-0.0152797224,
0.0463310704,
-0.0236935951,
0.0100781526,
0.0362340957,
-0.0406918377,
-0.0592404492,
0.0464981273,
0.0161276106,
-0.0069341683,
-0.0565162525,
-0.0293602757,
0.0645172223,
-0.0290080421,
-0.018948447,
0.0401494876,
-0.0175660569,
0.0041794502,
0.0540874712,
0.0382335372,
0.0395002589,
0.0150970006,
-0.0320889093,
-0.0581200868,
0.0181046184,
0.0208641458,
0.0101694996,
0.0050792093,
0.0146619277,
0.034035679,
-0.0181802288,
-0.0294607319,
-0.0134396804,
-0.0784870163,
-0.0193872191,
-0.0381712466,
0.0012897281,
-0.0192396399,
0.0044443882,
0.0154579375,
0.0284646098,
-0.0203048661,
-0.0120909559,
-0.018382784,
-0.0144403316,
0.0913280919,
0.0671773329,
0.0271233656,
-0.0081276484,
-0.0228327718,
-0.0088867648,
0.0393697694,
0.0143103991,
-0.0194081888,
-0.0248570107,
0.0141954981,
-0.0021507773,
0.0477699712,
-0.0088654198,
0.0021327685,
0.0798908174,
0.0019728702,
0.0217627119,
0.0728907213,
-0.0384053998,
-0.0535034426,
-0.0093646608,
0.0516509004,
0.0469572507,
0.0131948087,
0.0107597951,
-0.0746816918,
-0.07469026,
-0.0308409538,
-0.0151614398,
0.0169229545,
-0.0387533233,
-0.0061365785,
-0.0509026609,
-0.0067551769,
-0.0237788931,
-0.0237345248,
-0.0096082315,
-0.0604677498,
0.0090074372,
-0.0131006613,
0.0088624535,
-0.0372702405,
-0.0182054602,
-0.0044325953,
0.0173361953,
0.0327639133,
-0.0496919565,
-0.0292828362,
-0.0587660298,
0.02625091,
-0.0025868414,
-0.0006996918,
-0.0376854315,
0.0016342289,
-0.0009981479,
-0.004494085,
-0.0264283046,
-0.0117911855,
0.0601856001,
-0.0579246171,
-0.0448034965,
-0.0376445539,
-0.0177820176,
0.0354399905,
-0.0270939842,
-0.0376109779,
0.0516034327,
-0.0005501573,
0.0153699322,
-0.013853726,
-0.0049732472,
0.0304361172,
0.0418211706,
0.0057000793,
-0.0429430194,
0.0051590591,
0.0222286787,
0.0273943115,
-0.0497673713,
0.0278726257,
0.0147234201,
-0.0467130505,
-0.019911021,
-0.0484140143,
-0.0222747549,
-0.0133711994,
0.0576422513,
-0.0139277773,
-0.012965492,
0.0102200061,
0.0115434993,
-0.0678513497,
0.0367662497,
0.0037764723,
0.001148598,
-0.0159435868,
0.0027703282,
-0.0281947833,
-0.024937056,
-0.0352896005,
0.008508441,
-0.1028736159,
-0.0446625538,
-0.0640980676,
0.0229862481,
-0.001896655,
0.0538034327,
0.0425889902,
-0.0553970709,
0.0096551375,
0.0327698216,
-0.0388512909,
0.0063456786,
0.0050116736,
-0.0340201221,
-0.0273742191,
0.0088082142,
-0.0448029786,
-0.0021763134,
0.0294919461,
0.0177920759,
-0.0213450119,
-0.0170543827,
-0.0265393686,
-0.0034049952,
0.0400698781,
-0.048542697,
-0.0459272116,
-0.0595931374,
-0.0360973328,
0.0367462561,
-0.0077682282,
-0.0447137579,
-0.0110802194,
0.0031291624,
-0.0088999448,
-0.0209506154,
0.012609126,
0.0395112783,
0.0173579268,
-0.0512034409,
0.0123832272,
-0.0071721496,
-0.0143835275,
-0.0017727127,
0.0113486331,
0.0262625162,
0.0425562337,
0.0413304009,
-0.00516068,
-0.0189105589,
0.0585760847,
0.0306956936,
-0.0299677681,
-0.0227625296,
0.0139316479,
0.0022779249,
0.0656590164,
-0.0555939525,
0.0500926375,
0.0580208674,
-0.0031085713,
0.0231687389,
0.0159784388,
-0.0092443991,
0.007315293,
0.0264927465,
-0.0525620691,
-0.0293230899,
0.0841459334,
0.0083113229,
-0.0063905441,
0.0478012189,
0.0622998551,
0.0097458595,
0.018282406,
0.0000683333,
0.0112892659,
-0.0669946373,
-0.0103264563,
0.0564539135,
0.0644342154,
-0.0034684476,
0.0175077282,
-0.0097639663,
-0.0486437753,
0.0139480159,
-0.0292916968,
-0.0310077202,
0.0538591743,
0.0031578725,
0.0240850113,
0.020319825,
-0.0420636274,
-0.03054934,
-0.0286947191,
-0.0052930769,
0.0105233369,
-0.0038080283,
-6.733892122e-33,
-0.0581096821,
-0.0271638241,
-0.0076585789,
-0.0375551134,
-0.0319494642,
0.0589057356,
-0.0329116434,
0.0159158614,
-0.0041314382,
0.0212710015,
0.0213097651,
-0.0369333178,
0.0063727982,
0.0315208361,
-0.0241299532,
-0.0207045954,
0.022638334,
0.004225845,
-0.004193475,
0.0383545384,
0.0274257381,
0.0515548587,
0.0853927732,
-0.113504678,
0.0343953446,
0.004769274,
-0.0215594973,
-0.0007122785,
0.1047487035,
0.0445810072,
-0.0555479042,
0.0149453916,
0.0233334024,
-0.0494269989,
0.0061976607,
0.0094443448,
-0.1279420406,
0.0204773173,
0.0127341542,
0.0368232876,
-0.0571983829,
0.0005124965,
0.0566184968,
-0.0260238778,
0.0373472646,
-0.0267399233,
0.0503523313,
0.0272753313,
0.0297917482,
-0.0136426166,
-0.071578078,
0.0406700522,
0.0006176952,
0.0274761803,
0.0325354896,
-0.0146802627,
0.0474325791,
-0.0092092967,
-0.0573688485,
-0.0171511546,
-0.0379665568,
-0.0135710258,
0.0442313068,
0.0705032647,
-0.0261289515,
0.0735957325,
0.0441031121,
-0.0343035795,
-0.0054492918,
0.033196222,
0.0310250111,
0.0652885213,
-0.0073046666,
0.0669985339,
0.0049000159,
0.0192532185,
-0.0805514157,
0.0358962454,
-0.0016565811,
0.0257909801,
-0.0242835842,
0.0238763168,
-0.0221054703,
-0.005848953,
0.0060787764,
-0.0067142178,
-0.0250451937,
-0.0046887905,
0.0010401169,
0.0141988955,
-0.0459566079,
0.0764449239,
0.0816894993,
0.0012766774,
-0.0570957661,
0.0172804389,
0.020439392,
0.0796217397,
0.0179476123,
-0.0175588634,
-0.0616848096,
-0.0424780995,
0.0513676256,
-0.0415011458,
0.019158259,
-0.0098165786,
0.0403559916,
-0.0243512765,
-0.0329864807,
-0.025023099,
-0.0338203609,
-0.0104528284,
-0.022851754,
0.0168254972,
0.0439671688,
-0.017703468,
-0.0618775375,
0.0355829857,
0.0542420521,
0.02682155,
-0.0024841407,
-0.0388496704,
0.0037581653,
0.0138295712,
0.0024262476,
-0.0099811051,
0.0042825686,
-0.0645907149,
0.0074044787,
-0.0664343387,
-0.0063361414,
0.0150716035,
2.871e-7,
0.0034777294,
0.0115886815,
0.0278401244,
-0.0465991572,
0.0228601806,
0.0709672943,
0.0268695205,
0.0513865724,
-0.0391032174,
-0.0687000006,
0.0034816696,
0.0314784572,
-0.0081871422,
0.0018213295,
-0.0032407294,
-0.0304838829,
-0.0062630111,
-0.0161375105,
-0.0502754748,
0.0564443506,
0.0476470888,
0.0740743279,
0.0123586673,
-0.0211292934,
0.0006663773,
-0.0443132743,
0.0746188685,
-0.0182931162,
-0.0137073826,
0.0106022237,
0.0327923857,
0.0116611551,
-0.0293586534,
0.0189329442,
0.0082157226,
0.003289483,
0.0467743166,
0.0172611792,
-0.0191466808,
-0.0154260295,
-0.0473345891,
0.0133901201,
-0.0253553037,
0.0018443634,
0.0659408346,
-0.0295535438,
-0.0618837178,
-0.0360669903,
-0.0308772624,
0.0250199586,
-0.0272349995,
0.0215560813,
-0.0338027328,
0.0310530625,
0.0202142671,
-0.0171827041,
-0.072555691,
-0.0825624391,
0.0318839997,
0.0505216941,
-0.0363694504,
0.0056388522,
-0.024760576,
-0.0378735363,
0.0294508692,
-0.0722699761,
-0.0336564369,
2.350116264e-34,
-0.02610204,
-0.0050878893,
-0.0117221801,
0.0092567625,
0.0101318602,
-0.0184347201,
-0.0826470628,
-0.0212234706,
-0.0251118541,
-0.0590032823,
0.03105193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02313v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02313v2
|
Personality-aware Human-centric Multimodal Reasoning: A New Task, Dataset and Baselines
| 2023-04-05T09:09:10 | 2024-03-04T12:33:46 |
Yaochen Zhu, Xiangqing Shen, Rui Xia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Personality traits, emotions, and beliefs shape individuals' behavioral
choices and decision-making processes. However, for one thing, the affective
computing community normally focused on predicting personality traits but
overlooks their application in behavior prediction. For another, the multimodal
reasoning task emphasized the prediction of future states and behaviors but
often neglected the incorporation of individual personality traits. In this
work, we introduce a new task called Personality-aware Human-centric Multimodal
Reasoning (PHMR) (T1), with the goal of forecasting the future behavior of a
particular individual using multimodal information from past instances, while
integrating personality factors. We accordingly construct a new dataset based
on six television shows, encompassing 225 characters and 12k samples. To
establish a benchmark for the task, we propose seven baseline methods: three
adapted from related tasks, two pre-trained model, and two multimodal large
language models. The experimental results demonstrate that incorporating
personality traits enhances human-centric multimodal reasoning performance. To
further solve the lack of personality annotation in real-life scenes, we
introduce an extension task called Personality-predicted Human-centric
Multimodal Reasoning task (T2) along with the corresponding dataset and method.
We will make our dataset and code available on GitHub.
|
[
0.0176128615,
0.0846345648,
-0.0161586478,
-0.0123074185,
-0.0027453101,
0.0228390228,
0.0515713766,
0.0032461935,
0.0090858508,
-0.0044226539,
-0.0244992357,
0.0030685011,
-0.0400453843,
0.0100414408,
0.0561735593,
-0.0888502672,
0.0223280974,
0.0080687124,
0.0367603824,
0.0111825028,
0.0407241993,
0.0361906178,
-0.0052030678,
0.0174406022,
-0.055174157,
-0.0342034735,
-0.0022384329,
-0.0088073267,
0.066613473,
-0.0438845083,
0.0361756086,
0.0373630449,
0.0419600233,
-0.0531498119,
0.0000020875,
-0.0253583603,
0.0028191656,
-0.0487702377,
0.0380089991,
-0.0441324748,
0.0419419743,
0.05192101,
0.0154257249,
0.0183437653,
-0.0331802294,
0.0006243194,
0.0210251529,
0.0782213807,
0.0855735913,
0.051892288,
-0.0382167995,
-0.0277466998,
-0.0199864917,
-0.0012937341,
0.0469709001,
-0.0042933505,
-0.014883928,
-0.0166722704,
-0.0097769285,
-0.0264743678,
-0.0226187855,
-0.0089928806,
-0.0018606078,
0.0043334216,
-0.0163283553,
-0.0014526707,
-0.0063286228,
-0.0282754079,
-0.0118688941,
0.0626273975,
0.0112682004,
0.0008281522,
-0.0163918436,
-0.0021071695,
0.0028544781,
0.0230995342,
0.0016403284,
-0.0092139821,
-0.0180388913,
-0.0069213416,
-0.0039277761,
0.0341748782,
0.0009909533,
-0.0016564938,
0.0057594054,
0.0801796243,
0.0072901878,
0.0185409524,
0.0106833735,
-0.0384288207,
0.0089870924,
-0.0469521284,
-0.0076962598,
-0.0083117774,
-0.0142175667,
0.0053059305,
-0.0382455513,
0.0197880305,
-0.0114497952,
-0.0252225287,
0.0212833043,
0.0331324898,
-0.054456383,
0.0036598269,
0.0517820418,
0.0126480991,
-0.0096801864,
0.0107595827,
-0.0044822651,
0.0103376983,
-0.0843256339,
0.0169947781,
0.0333202668,
-0.018354727,
0.0126644289,
-0.0335822999,
-0.0622431301,
0.0126412027,
-0.0445592254,
0.0065620141,
0.0066622309,
0.0385765471,
0.0078698378,
0.0052814991,
-0.0730674714,
0.027882386,
-0.0631817803,
0.0009087839,
-0.0100091649,
0.0174771436,
0.0428777672,
-0.011985519,
0.0239013024,
-0.038238585,
0.0535982251,
0.0429407395,
0.0099914707,
-0.0211836621,
-0.0527183786,
-0.053798046,
-0.0152432118,
-0.0621743686,
0.0339836702,
-0.0154659906,
0.0431837328,
-0.0059671816,
-0.001881476,
-0.0392449833,
-0.006984523,
0.0286069103,
0.0369040407,
0.0837334469,
0.0248918328,
0.015422754,
0.003892344,
0.0259799939,
-0.012089191,
0.0177195221,
-0.008066956,
0.0379079357,
0.0309963226,
-0.0266733486,
0.0360381417,
0.0303512979,
-0.0122100124,
-0.026673127,
-0.0113959564,
-0.0261420719,
-0.0118700555,
0.0279937238,
0.0402297378,
0.0071905558,
-0.0120779071,
-0.0301673897,
0.0615195259,
0.0315977409,
-0.0060839704,
0.0101508051,
0.0033008766,
0.0017276289,
0.0058246655,
-0.0206157304,
-0.0500341803,
0.0968338847,
-0.0370671116,
-0.0175362155,
-0.0157686621,
0.0088111777,
-0.0281743892,
-0.0096134869,
-0.000969434,
-0.0158458445,
0.0356820449,
0.0059888922,
-0.0318458676,
-0.0153157068,
-0.0454515666,
-0.0195392761,
0.0303649046,
-0.0398981497,
-0.0196768511,
-0.0067629507,
0.0257293042,
0.1154411212,
0.0239556171,
-0.0107682627,
-0.0164997056,
0.0061648837,
0.014227354,
-0.0377216786,
-0.0040505612,
-0.0226236694,
0.0295584779,
-0.0430472568,
0.0082299327,
0.0095227845,
-0.0222229529,
0.0331016295,
0.0012655739,
0.0101523949,
-0.0437793918,
0.0177644733,
0.0522811115,
-0.0087610306,
-0.0742756948,
0.0095465034,
-0.0359871089,
0.0460611582,
0.0109117031,
0.0022374983,
0.0498198196,
-0.028093284,
-0.0167195164,
-0.0106977765,
-0.0193811618,
0.0585495532,
0.0030293062,
-0.0299332924,
0.0164937712,
-0.0380915664,
-0.01310133,
0.0324850604,
-0.0080843205,
0.0290448777,
-0.0045554028,
-0.0138208121,
0.0132741546,
-0.0188820008,
-0.02470541,
0.0314492285,
0.0643129349,
0.0155214518,
0.0380437747,
-0.0146432035,
-0.0252444744,
0.0069070789,
0.0159420595,
-0.0138094947,
-0.0403243899,
-0.0267825946,
-0.0452291369,
0.0254458617,
-0.0153673012,
0.0019244397,
-0.0238848533,
-0.0498111509,
0.017873643,
-0.0828721374,
0.0026830481,
0.0338869244,
-0.0461127236,
-0.0367751122,
-0.0093300762,
-0.0332470648,
-0.0271210466,
-0.0177984554,
0.037548624,
-0.0084939655,
0.009957321,
0.0107819587,
0.0074466686,
0.0248427391,
-0.0265296604,
0.0010858243,
-0.046358794,
0.0583314486,
-0.0273895692,
0.0508658104,
0.0085795866,
-0.0204460006,
-0.0741809458,
0.0410346538,
-0.0000029525,
-0.0399153419,
0.0089048008,
-0.0425820276,
0.028834125,
0.0173643641,
0.0451526381,
0.0006849986,
-0.0122717526,
-0.0304030478,
-0.015835911,
0.0253465045,
-0.0210617818,
0.0271819662,
-0.0348296054,
-0.0488981493,
-0.0378736891,
0.017205704,
0.0088142715,
0.0146579491,
-0.0622581765,
0.0460579209,
0.0684752762,
-0.0317536704,
0.0400006659,
0.0251708124,
-0.0187961552,
0.063266471,
0.0095516536,
-0.002023706,
0.0796610415,
0.0201412942,
0.0100935195,
0.026331516,
0.0046999287,
-0.0160436947,
0.0892710239,
0.0058070533,
0.0101993233,
0.0243691113,
0.025179008,
-0.0334675126,
-0.0712623447,
0.0307996608,
0.0073277913,
0.0238772593,
0.003503884,
-0.0506962761,
0.0477227643,
-0.0293989051,
-0.0226964429,
-0.0448887534,
-0.0691371337,
-0.0583515652,
-0.0326047763,
0.0014510913,
-0.0039732736,
-0.0434466079,
-0.0100518484,
-0.0590075739,
-0.0123697892,
-0.0304477848,
0.025098104,
-0.0136988675,
0.0618189462,
0.0172190443,
-0.0449665897,
-0.0482770391,
-0.0033795449,
-0.0024287086,
-0.0127500538,
-0.0335033536,
-0.0568151064,
0.0705299526,
-0.0026814048,
0.0484324135,
-0.0014284672,
0.0173941646,
0.0432394482,
-0.002149764,
0.0525621511,
0.1064950004,
0.0254654866,
-0.0033765475,
0.0193990991,
0.0232454557,
-0.0112556163,
0.0355280079,
0.0502935536,
-0.0115064979,
-0.0707071498,
-0.0234896671,
0.0218195803,
0.0141312359,
-0.0546724088,
-0.017012924,
-0.0608920529,
0.0574852973,
-0.0020327447,
0.0029780208,
-0.0037674268,
-0.022484092,
-0.0030765529,
-0.0583206788,
-0.034121234,
-0.0225749072,
0.0237312075,
-0.0157673955,
-0.0116354059,
-0.0534900203,
-0.0093131568,
0.1060651615,
-0.0459773913,
0.0218125824,
0.0130756861,
0.0447459891,
0.0070528188,
-0.070371367,
-0.0834800377,
0.0485971607,
0.0374914259,
0.0037389137,
0.0789167807,
-0.047503788,
-0.005740236,
-0.0850368366,
0.0368916318,
0.0239639226,
-0.0313996747,
0.0001500589,
0.0579936169,
-0.0386852957,
-0.0167139508,
-0.065692544,
0.0410042852,
0.0281856488,
0.0154510681,
-0.0543395914,
-0.0945350155,
-0.0384769477,
0.0164272208,
0.0008965255,
-0.0612299666,
-0.0295150876,
-0.0217595119,
-0.0057065012,
-0.0159599297,
-0.0240681972,
-0.0348164365,
0.0013541844,
0.0471392237,
-0.0368527807,
-0.0512632467,
-0.0431647599,
0.0451968238,
-0.0304103978,
0.0244763773,
0.0233705733,
0.0335572027,
0.0026909637,
0.0022316047,
0.0462051593,
-0.0237837192,
-0.0026789256,
0.0302853975,
-0.0727766529,
-0.0195558909,
0.0141985621,
0.0534446463,
0.0079913707,
0.0390334949,
0.0716831461,
-0.0593880676,
0.0268902536,
-0.0215615593,
0.003513793,
0.0200588964,
0.0272830594,
0.0253625233,
-0.0050102645,
0.0276272912,
-0.01812906,
0.0376056135,
-0.0452220999,
-0.046053566,
-0.0389472693,
-0.0574076772,
-0.0258334875,
0.0012629228,
0.028916819,
-0.0332995728,
-0.0262128729,
-0.0163414031,
-0.0430988073,
0.0098639084,
-0.0028048833,
-0.0035271191,
-0.0432123132,
0.0108921546,
-0.0074885222,
-0.0487610996,
-0.0295256507,
-0.0039240248,
-0.0100897728,
-0.0374754369,
0.0096775116,
0.0383230895,
-0.0019336269,
-0.0328166448,
0.0280637164,
0.0255752802,
-0.0159298871,
-0.0158921219,
0.0421212465,
-0.0104883751,
0.0932068303,
-0.0107253445,
0.0066639609,
-0.031869337,
0.0442301594,
-0.0264722891,
0.0136547498,
0.0324258171,
0.0055114692,
-0.015601174,
-0.0191429313,
-0.0177692063,
-0.0447290987,
0.0101791788,
-0.0083277524,
0.0525325909,
-0.0146005601,
-0.0423169248,
0.0381690338,
0.0052101519,
0.00996486,
-0.0217358135,
0.0376006104,
-0.0124786627,
-0.0044965078,
-0.018238537,
-0.0682595149,
-0.0480598547,
0.034259934,
0.0409951657,
0.0441872962,
0.0012464562,
0.0036830057,
-0.0628154203,
-0.0777676404,
0.0738210604,
-0.0075566731,
-0.0396034047,
-0.0023684041,
0.0104534067,
0.0356717296,
0.0034003584,
-0.016474044,
-0.0343393758,
-0.0092052994,
-0.0528907813,
0.0203300137,
0.0065859202,
-5.674920853e-33,
-0.0157438405,
0.0138123007,
0.0219160262,
-0.0102000404,
-0.0207262598,
-0.0241082832,
-0.0254015904,
0.0013408288,
0.0022085507,
0.0207329039,
-0.0251476076,
-0.0082670711,
-0.0077500571,
-0.0036373795,
0.0321634188,
-0.0194244739,
0.0076474841,
-0.0016114966,
-0.0162772536,
0.0124613196,
0.0584091172,
0.0378807001,
0.0423869416,
-0.0762351304,
-0.0331698023,
-0.0111162383,
-0.0447858498,
0.0009104011,
0.0272846725,
0.0408507064,
0.0000347396,
0.0190365184,
0.0083507393,
-0.0342476703,
-0.0168868992,
0.0292936768,
-0.0598448962,
-0.0509764962,
-0.0028454138,
-0.0037909788,
-0.0525305979,
-0.002559921,
-0.0332346447,
-0.0063506854,
-0.0207883269,
-0.0434958935,
0.063827984,
-0.0033347874,
0.096306704,
0.0319167487,
0.010853881,
0.0031506631,
-0.0439162478,
-0.0251189154,
0.0081056645,
0.0319016874,
0.011783069,
0.0034379531,
-0.0602196157,
0.0624621585,
-0.0867626444,
-0.0243347082,
0.0092079584,
0.0330493785,
-0.0133079607,
0.0677457601,
0.0655373558,
-0.0102264723,
0.0044520595,
0.029603973,
0.0175106488,
0.101122804,
-0.0072544147,
0.0722807124,
-0.0098040653,
-0.0396396257,
-0.0093167759,
0.0602784865,
0.0698538348,
-0.0182579979,
0.0434714295,
0.0137521718,
0.0014712347,
-0.0201867223,
0.0331280865,
-0.0014048145,
-0.0132661425,
-0.0373280458,
0.0028784985,
-0.017785266,
-0.0058358377,
0.017860679,
0.0442851111,
-0.0224547517,
0.0169128422,
0.0481121652,
-0.0482467301,
0.0086507285,
0.0092711393,
0.0307769552,
-0.0061474042,
0.0471588634,
0.0481362976,
-0.0186332446,
0.0769878924,
-0.0016376912,
0.0140811903,
0.0938343257,
-0.0336662345,
-0.0630308986,
0.0269733351,
0.0020718835,
-0.0257621426,
0.0291143246,
-0.0011732585,
0.047071971,
-0.0318805501,
-0.0001087342,
-0.0158852991,
0.0437046699,
-0.0299424548,
-0.0582644008,
0.0370092578,
0.0062622475,
-0.0019805261,
0.0002260385,
-0.0658213645,
-0.084648855,
-0.0085993744,
-0.0685759038,
0.0063556079,
0.0440838672,
2.728e-7,
-0.0281953141,
0.0429470092,
-0.0128251715,
0.0249854494,
0.0394313596,
0.067576617,
-0.0090619288,
0.0287854038,
0.0461414568,
-0.0605805442,
0.0414997488,
0.0352570489,
0.0111631071,
0.0428295173,
-0.0080033867,
-0.0127692921,
0.0426443629,
-0.0128475754,
-0.0567069985,
0.0108459136,
0.0734622106,
0.0509135276,
0.0823404565,
-0.0299144424,
0.0681639165,
0.0439671502,
0.0357660502,
0.0070493952,
-0.0295252781,
-0.0312217157,
-0.0211003982,
0.0009687675,
-0.009470569,
0.0320964716,
-0.0362817422,
-0.0513531864,
-0.0050461832,
0.0267784446,
-0.0322364047,
-0.0572895333,
-0.005723983,
0.0639336631,
-0.0491508804,
0.0129593005,
0.0590610504,
0.0092742983,
-0.0668549687,
-0.0451345891,
-0.042313844,
-0.0195471533,
-0.0144571206,
0.0338052623,
-0.0320488699,
0.0066953842,
0.0285881422,
-0.0154507998,
-0.0287278984,
-0.1262674183,
0.0051191254,
0.0389466956,
-0.0569353998,
-0.0058847,
-0.0101054274,
-0.0071151233,
0.0832611397,
-0.0781257898,
-0.0097183557,
1.809434207e-34,
-0.0073071071,
0.07627552,
-0.0177631527,
-0.0689107999,
0.0382086821,
0.0037756569,
-0.0049080714,
-0.0152959954,
0.0490602404,
-0.0463491753,
-0.0268007927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03158v1
|
CoT-MAE v2: Contextual Masked Auto-Encoder with Multi-view Modeling for Passage Retrieval
| 2023-04-05T08:00:38 | 2023-04-05T08:00:38 |
Xing Wu, Guangyuan Ma, Peng Wang, Meng Lin, Zijia Lin, Fuzheng Zhang, Songlin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Growing techniques have been emerging to improve the performance of passage
retrieval. As an effective representation bottleneck pretraining technique, the
contextual masked auto-encoder utilizes contextual embedding to assist in the
reconstruction of passages. However, it only uses a single auto-encoding
pre-task for dense representation pre-training. This study brings multi-view
modeling to the contextual masked auto-encoder. Firstly, multi-view
representation utilizes both dense and sparse vectors as multi-view
representations, aiming to capture sentence semantics from different aspects.
Moreover, multiview decoding paradigm utilizes both autoencoding and
auto-regressive decoders in representation bottleneck pre-training, aiming to
provide both reconstructive and generative signals for better contextual
representation pretraining. We refer to this multi-view pretraining method as
CoT-MAE v2. Through extensive experiments, we show that CoT-MAE v2 is effective
and robust on large-scale passage retrieval benchmarks and out-of-domain
zero-shot benchmarks.
|
[
-0.031299077,
-0.0016440826,
-0.0011725252,
0.0599234961,
-0.0181033239,
0.0152994534,
0.032016743,
-0.0116161453,
-0.0170296412,
-0.0555312932,
0.0050018383,
-0.0645332038,
0.0010491902,
0.0494151413,
0.0009591185,
-0.0547007993,
0.0159383807,
-0.0172803067,
-0.0081180008,
0.0208750702,
0.0132960957,
-0.0053729964,
-0.0136375818,
-0.0022553152,
0.0014710325,
-0.0022064948,
0.0011271564,
-0.0006693999,
0.0604000576,
-0.0984344408,
0.0177717116,
-0.0117351031,
0.0720932633,
0.0074086622,
0.0000021092,
-0.0475844331,
-0.0457961634,
0.0000122394,
-0.0132293757,
-0.001555548,
0.0480364151,
-0.0463972576,
0.0333753526,
-0.0120637678,
0.0219155569,
-0.0385022052,
0.0147639038,
0.0514733158,
0.0397613309,
0.0700024515,
-0.0391485319,
-0.0877206102,
-0.0270292461,
-0.023885157,
-0.0044673239,
-0.0634333864,
0.0266545434,
-0.0328034051,
-0.0377088599,
0.045812197,
-0.0480879806,
0.046649985,
-0.0020855539,
0.0276377387,
0.0177929383,
0.026890235,
0.0265541449,
0.0377493203,
-0.0126589062,
0.0539271049,
-0.0022895969,
0.0035183562,
-0.0262483098,
-0.0062498515,
-0.0449107029,
-0.0076683285,
-0.0469807945,
0.0249990933,
0.0133892847,
0.0088806152,
-0.0606505238,
0.0683384538,
0.0065176878,
-0.0248055477,
-0.0241268799,
-0.0715879723,
0.0116555886,
0.0004869018,
-0.0282920171,
0.0062320735,
-0.0137228724,
0.0304932557,
0.055176273,
0.0092630954,
0.0421638936,
0.0077671017,
-0.002811946,
-0.0528293997,
-0.0423453636,
-0.0253125094,
0.0383452773,
0.0601126961,
-0.0315548256,
0.0292639975,
-0.0550979897,
0.0661164299,
-0.0039661773,
0.0013378396,
-0.0573391356,
-0.0350756794,
-0.0071197893,
-0.0143323131,
-0.077065289,
0.0520601198,
-0.0500330552,
-0.0144522255,
-0.0173920747,
-0.0215505753,
0.0265323594,
-0.0305845141,
-0.0259116963,
0.0224311221,
-0.0345313735,
-0.0150894038,
0.0350412391,
0.023865683,
-0.0097562661,
-0.0068781767,
-0.0123383999,
0.0084210094,
-0.0551462583,
0.0204191171,
0.0344570875,
-0.0335021056,
-0.0008427255,
0.0074116648,
-0.0612517633,
-0.0530678853,
-0.0422188789,
-0.01334514,
-0.0500843823,
0.0007000209,
-0.0361159816,
-0.0204587709,
0.0410911813,
-0.007449924,
0.0283893496,
-0.0037529056,
0.0007552212,
0.015377691,
0.0102218231,
0.0612779707,
0.0466774069,
-0.0401243083,
0.0169917382,
0.0655274317,
0.0582894646,
0.0687924176,
0.0269412342,
0.0304026641,
0.0083545409,
0.0317742676,
0.0058478764,
0.0327305235,
-0.0122084552,
0.0097923977,
-0.0184768979,
-0.0335592031,
0.0431757942,
-0.0111741554,
0.0181728713,
0.011295733,
-0.0612722673,
-0.0318537243,
0.0236342363,
0.0569060147,
0.030530544,
-0.0244106743,
0.0515001528,
0.0036293294,
0.0085255774,
0.0038377398,
0.0370793007,
0.0128261074,
0.0050280401,
0.0170043912,
0.018116029,
0.0143269496,
-0.017185986,
0.0049413699,
0.0280842669,
-0.0165238138,
-0.0262933932,
-0.0089923972,
0.0454570428,
0.0004489342,
-0.0757063851,
0.0087434892,
0.0090147145,
-0.0540855974,
-0.0106256539,
0.0193840303,
-0.0371266007,
0.026344344,
0.0831837803,
-0.0502252094,
-0.025999371,
-0.0048727556,
-0.0179279316,
0.0226685461,
0.0131417457,
-0.0191444531,
0.0261643063,
-0.0694058314,
-0.0192900188,
-0.0255762041,
0.0025312349,
0.0551514551,
-0.0422569513,
0.0577242747,
0.0291684922,
-0.0178119726,
0.0137316454,
0.0351116359,
-0.0131317861,
-0.0251415484,
-0.0237011593,
0.0249300152,
-0.0191854574,
0.0709324628,
-0.0267518349,
-0.0288790744,
0.048333209,
-0.0883960202,
0.0430967584,
0.0262223575,
-0.1332395077,
-0.0824983791,
-0.0008568654,
-0.0409309119,
-0.0049034036,
0.076362662,
0.0120613705,
-0.0634876043,
-0.0376638547,
0.0114186108,
0.0326058343,
-0.0291240457,
-0.0094123678,
0.0125272172,
0.0253628865,
-0.0397922099,
0.0707837716,
-0.003648187,
0.0301345605,
0.0639297366,
0.0118445195,
0.0532673635,
-0.0061889342,
-0.0351286866,
-0.0040778397,
0.0118361721,
-0.013919008,
0.0506217964,
-0.0547968037,
0.0110188676,
0.018837437,
-0.0591425709,
-0.0153209586,
-0.0117889531,
-0.0198350586,
-0.0027757839,
0.0094241686,
-0.0208647102,
-0.0304498356,
0.0093348045,
0.0071692602,
0.0115827443,
-0.0135813653,
0.0245428756,
0.0187939405,
0.0094697755,
-0.0129577843,
0.0051912754,
-0.0188535489,
0.0478026979,
-0.0134699401,
-0.0653741881,
-0.031222228,
0.0575616993,
0.0630422533,
0.0030742947,
-0.050648395,
-0.0101228766,
-0.0090675019,
-0.0185872018,
0.0123834936,
0.0430086628,
-0.0095332125,
0.0250339229,
0.0390785895,
-0.0143067278,
-0.0531337596,
0.030242864,
0.0187105294,
-0.0193313882,
-0.0425251536,
0.0032342481,
0.0023277944,
0.0537853278,
0.0251870658,
0.0086449534,
-0.0299880877,
-0.0415279269,
0.0008457412,
-0.0279981568,
-0.0435138866,
-0.0253920387,
-0.0289587136,
0.0320106484,
-0.0088557396,
0.0232156478,
0.0212248005,
-0.0656503513,
-0.0296543036,
-0.0476027615,
0.0196125675,
-0.0364831872,
0.0967335403,
0.0017709151,
0.0441194251,
0.0193001144,
-0.060699787,
-0.0119664213,
0.0266518537,
0.0315329432,
-0.0241227672,
0.007934765,
0.02949371,
0.0081389761,
-0.0435067788,
0.0098711997,
-0.0376585722,
-0.0603611842,
0.013496845,
-0.0073571163,
0.0265995841,
0.0168210492,
-0.0408335403,
0.0342822596,
-0.0094061159,
0.0610149018,
0.021349974,
-0.0084484098,
-0.0417197645,
0.0975347832,
0.0229752287,
0.0069213295,
-0.0142755061,
-0.0437972248,
0.0424631834,
0.0264782719,
-0.0050153732,
0.0181118697,
0.0103940107,
0.0226936005,
0.0282718018,
-0.0094941938,
0.020109063,
-0.0158855859,
0.0750110447,
-0.0684851408,
-0.0443362296,
0.1031658053,
0.0248666909,
-0.0859130695,
-0.0446485877,
-0.012325461,
0.0128704663,
0.0140258474,
0.0001171714,
-0.0996641368,
-0.0154579012,
-0.0048870174,
0.024051819,
0.0571590364,
-0.0130835893,
-0.0123327421,
-0.0865392387,
0.0271261837,
0.0182957109,
0.0040379916,
-0.0563266315,
-0.0286454912,
-0.0099042188,
0.0136910565,
-0.0067943647,
0.0120306369,
0.0067663109,
-0.0393467061,
0.0087771034,
0.0202546734,
-0.0171083603,
0.0133539056,
-0.0211542994,
0.0126104765,
0.0039401907,
0.0279404111,
-0.0088413786,
0.0346446745,
0.0066317343,
-0.071401611,
-0.0040640594,
0.022838369,
0.0554912165,
-0.0502214953,
-0.0024821181,
-0.0061099343,
0.0164117254,
0.0107837198,
-0.0607394688,
-0.0133545864,
-0.0029595478,
0.009684775,
0.0095795449,
-0.0405167006,
-0.0019015103,
-0.0336662345,
0.0665118098,
-0.0151211238,
0.00422276,
-0.0128892213,
-0.0208424889,
0.0546797961,
-0.0774741918,
-0.0362506211,
0.0105141597,
0.005461636,
-0.0130879413,
-0.0558087826,
-0.0315470882,
-0.0092010126,
0.0592372306,
0.0192229152,
0.022164695,
-0.0109429341,
0.0160686616,
-0.0504031107,
0.0020851018,
-0.0335911326,
0.0034529143,
-0.0266151391,
0.0082911327,
0.0353039876,
-0.0522629544,
-0.0117578572,
0.0013753864,
-0.0478700176,
-0.0362968035,
0.0070112739,
-0.0002218513,
0.0065500978,
0.0509236231,
-0.0037533341,
0.0002893289,
0.0991626158,
-0.0014222967,
-0.0288566183,
0.0306290668,
-0.0005804096,
0.0181235988,
-0.0679313764,
0.0085981684,
-0.0395224281,
0.0293750595,
-0.0408888571,
0.0175710563,
0.0004383654,
-0.0472448058,
0.0236976296,
-0.0196086578,
0.0507885106,
0.0103703821,
0.0201868843,
-0.0540679581,
-0.0010629306,
-0.0452094339,
-0.0164627787,
-0.0049755243,
0.0218097772,
0.0444558077,
-0.0592823029,
-0.0282515008,
0.0687246323,
0.0453682691,
-0.0125294756,
-0.0721185878,
0.0235347934,
0.0125654722,
-0.037803214,
-0.0390789211,
0.0311025493,
-0.002945934,
-0.0097393012,
-0.0331715643,
0.0370724089,
-0.0188033078,
0.0470661335,
-0.0043451176,
-0.0094073359,
-0.0465477593,
0.0184072815,
-0.0518065244,
0.0689870641,
-0.0419890098,
-0.0045962115,
0.0264222827,
-0.0388579518,
0.0428934991,
0.0057857712,
0.0022829515,
-0.0085091824,
-0.0260985941,
-0.0025112415,
0.0203286037,
0.0029911168,
0.0011820748,
0.0013498598,
0.0381826423,
0.0831810236,
0.0032091124,
0.0535518564,
0.0277498476,
-0.0173132233,
-0.0364833251,
0.0007944295,
0.0520524085,
0.0683204383,
-0.0087526664,
-0.0128442347,
0.0062082447,
-0.0082372017,
0.0776517689,
-0.0323516093,
0.0065224604,
0.001102573,
0.0113507695,
0.0150744719,
0.0216776431,
-0.0142138451,
-0.0023137066,
0.0032362423,
0.0439873785,
0.0056670136,
-0.0136455419,
-6.086166817e-33,
-0.0509643704,
0.0280456524,
-0.0101056881,
-0.0267456863,
-0.0589909181,
0.0384762362,
-0.0316768885,
0.0083389031,
-0.0108611947,
0.0036000414,
0.0283059049,
-0.0058173803,
0.0158936158,
0.0463362522,
-0.0171436444,
0.0110057173,
0.0662255213,
-0.0071386322,
-0.025540771,
0.0053256121,
0.0539378785,
0.0595082715,
0.0015192177,
-0.0493710637,
0.0080062356,
-0.0630511865,
0.014092166,
-0.0229618195,
0.0826866478,
0.0329193659,
-0.0494185649,
0.0221523847,
0.0086450949,
-0.0175521616,
-0.0250371601,
0.0239449572,
-0.0992128402,
-0.0316072255,
-0.0219011027,
0.0366199762,
-0.0009055568,
-0.0549464822,
0.0158631988,
-0.0218632799,
0.0065226061,
-0.0139327385,
0.0296186153,
-0.0036511216,
0.0136553785,
-0.0485142171,
-0.0509284548,
0.0042215865,
-0.0409345217,
-0.0444361232,
0.0750527829,
0.0560055822,
0.0527247451,
0.0281522404,
-0.0548073426,
-0.0039950241,
-0.0243823919,
0.0422018729,
-0.0137483152,
0.0364726372,
-0.0126179531,
0.057942871,
0.0161192436,
-0.0396045335,
-0.0315905549,
0.0003633887,
0.0350970402,
-0.0175399836,
0.0042229281,
0.059257973,
0.0077978508,
-0.032294251,
-0.0666768253,
0.0544484444,
-0.0184569322,
0.0066612661,
0.0719126314,
0.058121182,
-0.0235175621,
-0.0045505492,
-0.0216748193,
-0.0355844423,
-0.0061878618,
0.029286677,
0.043477457,
0.0467100851,
-0.0219242312,
0.0264212936,
0.1018145382,
-0.0417473465,
0.0344181396,
0.0077420818,
-0.0105421413,
0.0619334802,
-0.0091941589,
0.0437199175,
0.0013946247,
0.0003572191,
0.0460920781,
-0.0296495445,
-0.0011770406,
-0.0537919812,
0.0268386155,
0.0180824734,
-0.0644953176,
-0.0036080542,
-0.0027723669,
-0.0413372926,
-0.005108309,
0.0467015244,
-0.0144663937,
0.0321690142,
-0.0010250586,
0.0705231279,
0.0029260898,
0.0023353382,
-0.0225509815,
0.0132314116,
0.022078637,
0.0014807731,
0.000562697,
0.0334897339,
-0.0082315318,
0.0399967134,
0.0452870131,
-0.0389336124,
0.0062008798,
0.0349591002,
2.608e-7,
0.0437526256,
0.0202542599,
0.0727799684,
-0.0166759603,
0.0091177765,
0.0281240325,
-0.0067734751,
0.0581102408,
0.0002304748,
-0.0373323075,
0.0208864827,
0.0319013,
0.0109966872,
-0.0021582437,
-0.0486370213,
0.0016322276,
0.0326436982,
-0.0472263992,
-0.0413871743,
-0.0021844564,
0.0658877417,
0.0418590121,
-0.0467865802,
0.0344026163,
0.0285432152,
-0.0379460678,
0.0697964728,
-0.0051502399,
-0.018064322,
0.0155672273,
-0.0269165486,
0.0611566417,
-0.0190541651,
-0.0253552385,
0.0096461661,
0.0683229268,
0.0654670149,
0.011857532,
-0.0029931339,
-0.0864626616,
0.0094862552,
0.0415997393,
-0.0438043065,
-0.0110174296,
0.0640979558,
-0.0148435868,
0.008730039,
-0.003991894,
-0.0645525604,
0.0319508053,
-0.0034096378,
0.0435069539,
-0.0339614861,
0.0165023934,
0.0204924382,
0.0095273862,
-0.0455191918,
-0.1093996391,
0.0003408441,
0.0086870352,
-0.0336210355,
0.0227040406,
-0.0055882018,
-0.0503044836,
0.0109017827,
-0.1008163393,
0.0086230701,
2.193460979e-34,
0.0096077509,
-0.0263440795,
-0.0173347779,
0.0001378012,
0.0256231334,
-0.0438552089,
-0.0206255838,
-0.0063257716,
-0.0168118626,
-0.0724430978,
-0.0431334712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02247v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02247v2
|
Disentangling Structure and Style: Political Bias Detection in News by Inducing Document Hierarchy
| 2023-04-05T06:35:41 | 2023-10-27T11:35:04 |
Jiwoo Hong, Yejin Cho, Jaemin Jung, Jiyoung Han, James Thorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We address an important gap in detecting political bias in news articles.
Previous works that perform document classification can be influenced by the
writing style of each news outlet, leading to overfitting and limited
generalizability. Our approach overcomes this limitation by considering both
the sentence-level semantics and the document-level rhetorical structure,
resulting in a more robust and style-agnostic approach to detecting political
bias in news articles. We introduce a novel multi-head hierarchical attention
model that effectively encodes the structure of long documents through a
diverse ensemble of attention heads. While journalism follows a formalized
rhetorical structure, the writing style may vary by news outlet. We demonstrate
that our method overcomes this domain dependency and outperforms previous
approaches for robustness and accuracy. Further analysis and human evaluation
demonstrate the ability of our model to capture common discourse structures in
journalism. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/xfactlab/emnlp2023-Document-Hierarchy
|
[
0.0464564301,
0.0547409058,
0.0027700753,
0.0187852569,
-0.0083643394,
0.0327241123,
-0.0218951069,
0.0015820278,
0.0307946131,
-0.0715425164,
-0.005469712,
-0.024026379,
0.0186877977,
-0.0028332884,
-0.0150400018,
-0.0802839696,
0.0343106389,
0.0372426473,
0.0851556063,
-0.0135018593,
0.0565782301,
0.0365706906,
0.0329397805,
0.0206606779,
-0.034068156,
-0.0437352695,
0.0087715071,
0.0407571122,
0.0392170548,
0.0199610293,
0.030562941,
0.0686105415,
0.008486026,
0.0603335164,
0.0000015603,
0.0068973545,
0.0099019147,
-0.0287566073,
0.0489096157,
-0.0054495959,
0.0736324415,
-0.0430814028,
0.0009692135,
-0.0008968565,
0.0197708271,
0.0086524012,
0.0196414404,
0.057017792,
0.0759587288,
0.0953704491,
-0.0108810598,
-0.0251302365,
0.0107744187,
-0.0091221491,
0.0072958134,
-0.0535261184,
0.0460256152,
-0.021811977,
-0.0457573757,
0.0406849161,
-0.0135135101,
-0.0082147038,
0.0324478783,
-0.0103530344,
-0.0046722223,
0.0156232566,
-0.00454647,
0.0028755022,
-0.0028537055,
0.0444019958,
-0.0096003357,
-0.0470188819,
0.0265836678,
0.0040044021,
0.0183023028,
-0.0157180186,
-0.0305861663,
0.0342306904,
-0.0511786006,
0.0104125887,
0.0606775992,
-0.0211152975,
-0.0116387624,
0.0480415858,
0.0055968105,
0.0400575921,
-0.0058193994,
-0.042160105,
0.0155461114,
0.0177507754,
0.0273148473,
-0.0477154776,
0.023132382,
-0.0142932544,
-0.0014107284,
0.0059282514,
-0.0673226193,
-0.0520537421,
0.0259478278,
-0.0968802348,
-0.0124278208,
-0.0350919664,
-0.024089817,
0.0787670836,
0.0418345742,
-0.0190923065,
-0.048707433,
0.0043952633,
-0.0102393283,
-0.027331654,
-0.0230482612,
0.0020912827,
-0.0160086956,
0.015659865,
-0.0331128985,
-0.0305766426,
0.0078343833,
-0.0040545249,
-0.0017744646,
-0.0200018343,
-0.0273233224,
0.0250312611,
-0.0403926931,
-0.0348163471,
0.0101927277,
0.0470332243,
-0.0380687118,
0.0211347844,
-0.009902901,
0.0083662141,
-0.0266098138,
0.0836726651,
-0.0301733818,
-0.0124133015,
-0.0324127115,
-0.0019237695,
-0.0150512485,
0.0009259356,
0.0014285736,
-0.012822859,
-0.0134514431,
-0.0551692918,
0.0486070663,
-0.0398011841,
0.0093575548,
-0.0298612583,
-0.0013364258,
-0.0195850041,
0.0037865518,
0.0227582473,
-0.0606246553,
0.0278175436,
0.0630645528,
-0.0287098438,
0.0707900077,
0.0346336924,
0.01256542,
0.1036759466,
0.011593339,
0.0633899048,
0.0434737913,
0.0078037558,
-0.0045274608,
-0.0013463425,
-0.0030959281,
0.0360709168,
-0.0194116663,
0.0249341261,
-0.0570646785,
0.0006969558,
0.0440329015,
0.0065167355,
0.0175024699,
-0.03039141,
0.0697558373,
0.0084551908,
-0.0144618694,
0.0098825367,
0.006756213,
0.0138821285,
-0.0045459098,
0.0586421452,
-0.0347277448,
0.0250450615,
-0.012854727,
-0.0186408963,
0.0151439197,
0.0384250171,
-0.0379520841,
0.0035690714,
-0.0052013518,
0.011090179,
-0.0095526725,
-0.0226728395,
0.0130218519,
0.0112775266,
-0.0477924608,
0.0263052415,
0.0429195203,
-0.0350127481,
0.0391342379,
-0.0285378862,
0.0428414121,
-0.0065729716,
0.0095414799,
-0.0391691625,
0.0308377128,
-0.04646172,
0.0606912747,
0.0755425841,
0.0189772043,
-0.0077015315,
-0.004830943,
-0.0159756541,
-0.004736091,
-0.0121540083,
0.0256275162,
0.0387214497,
0.0013152867,
0.0038233674,
0.0078833513,
-0.0074520768,
-0.0230699349,
0.0337069407,
0.053001646,
-0.0292062182,
-0.0049558422,
0.0238371622,
0.0213700552,
0.025823025,
-0.0089761671,
-0.0261610039,
0.0105973901,
-0.0218405332,
-0.0125212567,
-0.0594865791,
-0.0546576157,
-0.0243079551,
-0.0274130013,
-0.0683863759,
-0.0591417216,
0.0378489271,
-0.0292483978,
-0.0152191464,
0.0573101379,
-0.0270741563,
0.0070294454,
-0.0253458768,
-0.0354344547,
-0.0175398439,
0.008778302,
-0.0498611145,
0.1049846634,
0.0105121247,
-0.0245233681,
0.0343396626,
-0.0370446816,
-0.0200641807,
-0.0195169766,
0.0164434984,
0.0190320909,
0.0108253472,
0.0068333219,
0.0319857486,
-0.0364619233,
-0.0327702351,
-0.0744150728,
-0.0566985533,
0.0114725456,
-0.0525032356,
0.0334365107,
0.0477314442,
-0.009269611,
-0.0040609515,
-0.0156119801,
-0.0504382849,
-0.033705119,
-0.0300070457,
0.0086336937,
0.0106670158,
-0.0499344803,
0.0346485041,
-0.0164341386,
-0.011743959,
-0.0564866029,
0.0699534938,
0.0176781863,
-0.0353823565,
-0.055661127,
-0.005165536,
0.0053153438,
-0.0191216879,
-0.0115398346,
-0.0253845714,
0.0053278119,
0.0128659178,
0.0184785239,
0.1471150666,
0.0646535009,
0.0305089727,
0.0141172158,
0.0121211316,
-0.0316034779,
-0.0078791482,
-0.0201126933,
0.081356205,
-0.0300484113,
-0.0277191922,
0.0592415854,
0.0681172982,
0.0330797769,
0.02012139,
-0.0155969206,
0.0436949357,
0.012297485,
-0.0054732822,
0.0273260381,
-0.0171624981,
-0.0022524574,
-0.0009035451,
-0.0532854162,
-0.0159280952,
0.068822667,
-0.0012591981,
0.0178154428,
-0.0309067965,
0.0120853949,
-0.0594229326,
0.0230075642,
0.008708884,
0.0330671594,
-0.0152675342,
-0.0570017323,
-0.0306801703,
-0.0239171777,
0.0423495062,
0.0023370206,
0.0505173802,
-0.0052516237,
-0.0051984065,
-0.0076331235,
-0.0197481886,
-0.0369515829,
-0.0365976021,
0.0186304878,
0.0100755775,
0.0080692479,
-0.0106695499,
-0.07136935,
0.0178082567,
0.0328812525,
0.0143227903,
-0.0493872054,
0.009659023,
0.0054076654,
0.1022818834,
0.0167874992,
-0.0046239877,
0.011263039,
-0.0056887763,
0.0013817677,
0.0394760296,
-0.0195571631,
0.076634258,
0.0040656896,
-0.0344268978,
0.0056666797,
-0.0688856244,
-0.0155144399,
-0.0537089184,
0.0227785837,
-0.0771443993,
0.0090547279,
0.086298354,
0.0207867082,
-0.0730657727,
-0.0269294139,
0.0120035391,
0.0054060859,
0.0299348645,
-0.003589272,
-0.0619966127,
-0.0041732779,
0.0230290405,
0.0058022612,
0.0062421495,
-0.0098340996,
0.0019035696,
-0.0457649305,
0.0002100738,
0.0025587853,
-0.0438015983,
-0.0242638774,
-0.0586395115,
0.031314496,
0.0044391332,
-0.0275276825,
0.0254345182,
-0.004895519,
-0.020887034,
-0.016142441,
-0.0538929813,
-0.0356507301,
0.0090387175,
0.0024691056,
0.0013741702,
0.0440363288,
0.0639616922,
0.0051583047,
0.0021082563,
0.0264087003,
-0.0399737619,
-0.0388438143,
-0.0190566238,
0.0484362766,
-0.0620438829,
0.0047705378,
-0.0192678459,
0.0641909614,
0.0353465863,
0.0255096685,
0.0033467487,
0.0299098529,
0.0030442791,
-0.0595405027,
-0.0613642037,
0.0133609939,
0.0473188981,
0.0549755432,
0.0596331954,
-0.0371398143,
-0.0531263947,
-0.0687664598,
0.0054250238,
-0.0411594026,
-0.0140427165,
0.0424526706,
-0.0018936944,
-0.0087013189,
-0.0357702002,
-0.0715940669,
-0.0429212488,
-0.00989928,
-0.0049352464,
-0.0235122275,
0.0055898526,
-0.0365483351,
-0.0234917644,
-0.0032905217,
0.0020357866,
-0.0042163087,
-0.0088071302,
-0.0389573462,
-0.0044112164,
-0.0110448971,
-0.0371328369,
0.0259756763,
-0.0652842671,
-0.0236685686,
0.0210752599,
0.0030693391,
0.0045648399,
0.0284066275,
-0.0204007253,
-0.0265383814,
0.0350681134,
0.0182879418,
-0.031243505,
0.014072354,
0.0174241737,
-0.0239414927,
0.0197690353,
0.0415040739,
-0.0253576506,
0.0696637034,
0.0293309931,
-0.0194712318,
-0.0270799976,
0.010019605,
-0.0173955001,
-0.0315356664,
0.0366297103,
0.0227453317,
-0.0043721371,
-0.0640145913,
-0.0118917013,
-0.0078075444,
-0.0552089289,
0.0090740668,
0.004036027,
0.0024934341,
-0.0307428949,
-0.0413307585,
0.0349224322,
-0.0199953988,
0.030701505,
-0.0194972921,
0.0448972955,
0.0137769757,
0.0268605612,
-0.022258319,
-0.0032316132,
-0.0590415373,
0.0370971002,
-0.0277678464,
0.0531096756,
0.0153257353,
0.0171411671,
0.0271506943,
-0.0141386073,
0.0206427835,
-0.0346521884,
-0.0799702033,
0.0391145051,
-0.0098651359,
-0.014195323,
0.0461379215,
-0.0592820607,
0.0234622583,
0.0183597673,
-0.0009054592,
0.0009825632,
0.0208212454,
0.0229718145,
-0.0400190428,
0.0120450864,
0.0239040758,
-0.0170514472,
0.0113912355,
0.0532776043,
0.0343607627,
-0.0068230778,
0.061840903,
-0.0383102335,
-0.0368349813,
-0.0369994901,
0.0475349016,
0.0199809317,
0.00851811,
-0.001205949,
-0.0390190966,
-0.0104119787,
0.0438214503,
-0.0297315866,
0.0306656007,
-0.0012616814,
-0.0085078767,
0.0628054813,
0.0156134265,
-0.0229125656,
-0.0456436165,
0.0239496436,
-0.0606733821,
-0.0392899252,
-0.0077463747,
-5.704985958e-33,
-0.0291612688,
-0.0487395786,
-0.0560574755,
0.0021821808,
-0.007500221,
0.0384938791,
-0.0552564263,
-0.0332290232,
-0.0263648797,
0.0347733796,
0.0013952658,
0.0504982695,
-0.0017650218,
0.0291405916,
-0.0054747597,
0.0298357196,
0.0271769222,
0.0031355354,
-0.0527921803,
0.0389086604,
0.0194791406,
-0.004961052,
0.0753110647,
-0.0180052668,
0.0156156179,
-0.0248400122,
-0.0121884169,
-0.0232992712,
0.0168555528,
0.058989089,
0.0101162987,
0.0145050734,
0.0507430434,
-0.0209954306,
-0.006062319,
0.131240502,
-0.04830309,
-0.0411088467,
0.0196472034,
-0.0165915564,
-0.0243398268,
-0.0287176501,
0.0349037834,
0.0201386921,
0.0556486659,
-0.0861778185,
0.0888557285,
-0.0188063849,
-0.0031323326,
-0.0197595879,
-0.0603634305,
0.0313037485,
-0.0193778761,
0.0389224291,
-0.0438685603,
0.0197030343,
0.044329688,
0.0679037571,
-0.0663362518,
-0.0076461206,
-0.0494035259,
0.0460244119,
-0.0109037282,
-0.0064340504,
-0.0234042667,
0.0699344724,
-0.0050302562,
0.0675820783,
-0.0788668096,
-0.0171148814,
0.0213664584,
-0.0038219378,
0.0137112774,
0.0425483435,
0.0205690209,
0.0019455802,
-0.0969179347,
-0.0038533222,
0.0410873815,
0.0521295406,
0.0138187204,
-0.0346585214,
0.0023557045,
0.0189586021,
-0.0188164134,
-0.0636894926,
-0.0288610402,
-0.0003193312,
-0.007884264,
0.0261203293,
-0.0034369587,
0.0252047181,
0.0340333506,
-0.0177971218,
0.0245339945,
0.065901503,
-0.0211740956,
-0.002214733,
0.02064294,
0.0231170226,
-0.0511571728,
0.0276920963,
0.0193421021,
0.0317886658,
0.005328835,
-0.0159708448,
0.0665789023,
-0.0170713775,
-0.0570668839,
-0.0013827368,
0.0125990594,
0.0026023025,
-0.0441791341,
0.069592759,
0.0422953181,
-0.0055642566,
0.0131489784,
0.0460065007,
-0.0128974766,
-0.0008448295,
-0.0163096003,
-0.0380136147,
-0.0378429219,
0.0508608073,
-0.0290057734,
-0.0351677947,
-0.0298105776,
0.0154014667,
0.0039456491,
-0.0586635135,
0.0030755997,
0.0050199283,
2.329e-7,
0.0111053893,
0.0678903833,
-0.0103389416,
0.0203504115,
0.039204184,
0.0237603821,
0.0319747962,
0.0847600177,
-0.0556661747,
-0.0614677966,
-0.0281890389,
0.0194372963,
0.0375568271,
0.012293404,
-0.1305415481,
-0.0223437548,
-0.070945181,
0.0280839484,
-0.0442199633,
-0.0315228738,
0.0130112506,
0.055328317,
0.0049579409,
0.0029317057,
0.0108183436,
0.0052162651,
0.0602629296,
0.0370257087,
-0.0066258847,
0.0392556041,
0.011884558,
-0.0397037528,
-0.0094992556,
-0.0011886338,
-0.0024803902,
0.0187663268,
-0.0049148011,
0.0856998041,
-0.0164664015,
-0.0221020412,
-0.0017690537,
0.0020840284,
0.0090288622,
-0.0581274889,
0.033063326,
-0.0225317664,
-0.0294089299,
-0.0958976671,
-0.0584804341,
-0.0084222034,
0.046847567,
-0.0038896024,
0.0123480251,
0.0124325417,
-0.033548288,
-0.0231224913,
0.0347329713,
-0.0703905076,
-0.0275225565,
0.0037792374,
-0.0552476645,
-0.0003010987,
0.0066269776,
0.0002824918,
0.0236512981,
-0.0321111269,
0.0139296167,
1.879715568e-34,
0.0622116402,
-0.0329610296,
-0.0333847329,
-0.0146505563,
0.0252115447,
-0.00837206,
-0.0310637094,
-0.0420088768,
0.0218793377,
-0.0575244725,
-0.0095564853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02233v1
|
Ericson: An Interactive Open-Domain Conversational Search Agent
| 2023-04-05T05:28:31 | 2023-04-05T05:28:31 |
Zihao Wang, Ali Ahmadvand, Jason Choi, Payam Karisani, Eugene Agichtein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, 68T07
|
Open-domain conversational search (ODCS) aims to provide valuable, up-to-date
information, while maintaining natural conversations to help users refine and
ultimately answer information needs. However, creating an effective and robust
ODCS agent is challenging. In this paper, we present a fully functional ODCS
system, Ericson, which includes state-of-the-art question answering and
information retrieval components, as well as intent inference and dialogue
management models for proactive question refinement and recommendations. Our
system was stress-tested in the Amazon Alexa Prize, by engaging in live
conversations with thousands of Alexa users, thus providing empirical basis for
the analysis of the ODCS system in real settings. Our interaction data analysis
revealed that accurate intent classification, encouraging user engagement, and
careful proactive recommendations contribute most to the users satisfaction.
Our study further identifies limitations of the existing search techniques, and
can serve as a building block for the next generation of ODCS agents.
|
[
0.0782698542,
0.0036886786,
-0.028384747,
-0.0071172244,
-0.0139742754,
-0.0490413569,
0.0088628614,
-0.0070024775,
0.0171567481,
-0.0185366813,
0.0159487277,
0.0005064927,
-0.032942716,
0.0422982648,
-0.0527479164,
-0.0428084396,
0.0294159893,
-0.0032384444,
0.0510642342,
0.031952206,
0.033340849,
0.0024699278,
-0.0206383727,
0.0424575508,
0.0125021366,
-0.0279264636,
-0.0320974886,
0.01838338,
-0.0090222089,
-0.0073974091,
0.0270906556,
0.0369489528,
0.0300707407,
0.0275008976,
0.0000018999,
-0.0729856119,
-0.038097553,
-0.0305760596,
-0.0828890651,
-0.0721479207,
0.0066225044,
0.0924846381,
0.0266924761,
0.0667004734,
-0.0457359366,
0.0238810387,
0.0337390937,
0.0142517732,
0.0336216278,
0.0311321933,
-0.018305229,
0.0176070984,
0.005822741,
0.0173812229,
0.0448613465,
-0.043678306,
0.0087122889,
-0.0052782837,
0.0426866077,
0.0227182116,
0.0295366477,
0.0375342295,
0.0018378225,
-0.0238392688,
0.0275544561,
0.004223757,
-0.0248500071,
-0.0474146754,
-0.0195937231,
0.0786361769,
0.0408413932,
0.0157687683,
-0.0081957737,
0.0264258422,
0.0013197848,
-0.021760758,
-0.0438147075,
-0.0036567692,
-0.0398228243,
-0.0425797477,
-0.0532885417,
0.0138967671,
0.0030081999,
0.005764103,
0.0010077032,
0.0610160977,
-0.0056703794,
-0.032306429,
-0.007928702,
-0.0441026762,
-0.0060964646,
-0.0567957126,
0.0279197861,
0.0353960805,
-0.0706053153,
0.0174828507,
0.016216604,
-0.0031138749,
-0.0040092119,
-0.0126940096,
-0.0087800073,
0.0316674188,
0.0028357722,
0.0467435494,
0.046874471,
0.015741922,
0.0291516595,
-0.0216638464,
-0.0730652213,
-0.0313574784,
-0.0383590907,
-0.0054916516,
-0.0604710951,
0.0382515527,
-0.0437876955,
-0.0291619357,
0.0120648462,
0.0450432003,
0.0264533218,
-0.0179078467,
-0.0407629833,
0.062564902,
-0.0148947313,
0.0380292982,
-0.0694884509,
0.0072912839,
-0.0656369105,
0.0435892232,
0.0233119242,
-0.0714476779,
0.0067098909,
0.0241854899,
0.0318308622,
-0.0019246107,
-0.0218561329,
-0.0000643629,
-0.0095549701,
-0.0810322613,
0.0112777697,
-0.0223994926,
0.0280390494,
-0.0171899255,
-0.0170301273,
-0.0142713077,
0.0314766392,
0.0206515342,
-0.0315483399,
-0.0065412782,
0.014478052,
0.0432543121,
0.0221304987,
0.0343010947,
-0.0617006645,
0.0174435992,
0.0457922667,
0.0373815559,
0.0075875465,
0.03737887,
0.0159758441,
0.0294574033,
0.0815304741,
0.0362319909,
0.0347202979,
-0.0141527848,
-0.0048502963,
-0.020643916,
0.0848953128,
0.0812087953,
-0.0169924144,
0.0668006316,
-0.006305973,
0.0286617819,
-0.0269505363,
0.0056833779,
0.0507909618,
0.0234739892,
-0.0083490554,
0.00652635,
0.0181547701,
0.0355918333,
0.0183712691,
-0.0445227847,
-0.0041339542,
0.0129893441,
-0.0192877948,
-0.0216796901,
0.0153810931,
-0.031429965,
-0.023742428,
-0.0537566543,
0.0192049295,
-0.0040886826,
0.0306164548,
0.0226114057,
-0.0076224641,
-0.0015555008,
-0.0313270427,
0.0088074198,
-0.020572938,
-0.0366086848,
-0.0261987466,
-0.0473424159,
0.0603562705,
0.0863388777,
0.0773814544,
-0.0465698205,
-0.0491358824,
-0.0208443198,
0.0008421021,
0.0141380578,
0.0032793568,
-0.0199609101,
0.0191978719,
-0.0077454634,
-0.0194727182,
0.000156524,
-0.0119943386,
0.0149104493,
0.0115556866,
0.0153429555,
-0.0027168219,
-0.045856487,
0.0069814054,
-0.0143673718,
0.0001275345,
-0.0286360532,
0.0108088767,
0.017912481,
-0.0058112438,
0.0541225411,
0.0242286529,
0.0054026181,
0.0174464211,
0.0062477482,
-0.0379887819,
0.0152430702,
0.0001709971,
0.0097728968,
0.0145863397,
0.0074131317,
-0.0061936732,
0.0371926427,
0.030462889,
-0.0372976772,
-0.0153802363,
-0.0270897746,
0.0381301306,
-0.0330738425,
0.0025909396,
0.0038544526,
-0.0088529931,
-0.0227463003,
0.0394556224,
0.0262908693,
-0.0163316466,
0.0568353832,
0.0051695323,
0.0087183453,
-0.0564001054,
-0.0017378828,
-0.0179499015,
0.003844341,
0.0182214491,
0.0041984329,
-0.0023806647,
-0.0607475489,
0.0249312781,
-0.1185446233,
0.0336226672,
-0.0261674877,
-0.0164347179,
-0.000138459,
0.0912666768,
0.0127145415,
-0.0446101129,
-0.0196239017,
0.024697734,
0.0108368201,
0.021123603,
0.0109966099,
0.0474533327,
-0.0500621758,
-0.0510165095,
0.0174954794,
-0.0098355096,
0.004890983,
0.0088559836,
0.038688764,
-0.024444215,
-0.0301175267,
-0.0893798396,
0.0429417975,
-0.007639165,
0.0030073484,
0.0218848102,
-0.0210875124,
-0.0029123959,
0.0502089821,
0.0472929515,
0.0112689929,
-0.0142177129,
-0.0127458796,
-0.0508188717,
0.0344289802,
-0.0233899523,
0.0032064721,
-0.0206639729,
0.025901597,
0.0399134494,
-0.0082336562,
-0.0050547561,
0.0232325103,
-0.0182405654,
-0.008861023,
0.0328544043,
-0.0387879387,
-0.0639007911,
0.0060874629,
-0.0262783058,
0.0731808469,
0.0041251946,
-0.027881233,
0.0528726876,
0.0130962664,
-0.0072327908,
-0.0976154432,
-0.0324382074,
-0.0483216122,
0.0327067338,
-0.0424873978,
0.0193293151,
0.0245804247,
-0.0315274112,
-0.0132238986,
-0.030300688,
0.0316328369,
-0.0534364916,
0.0158592127,
-0.0214523003,
0.0079283491,
0.0433987156,
-0.0503316969,
-0.0503004864,
-0.0635222271,
-0.0261405203,
-0.0008727052,
0.0030072725,
-0.0095644183,
-0.0680997148,
-0.0019839415,
0.0021634316,
0.0507926866,
0.0020758167,
-0.0482317843,
-0.0116958953,
0.0187651534,
0.0658794865,
0.0661428422,
-0.001205827,
0.0172148123,
0.0360683873,
0.0271640625,
0.0401480719,
-0.0755611807,
-0.0130726825,
-0.0362436138,
0.0385073274,
-0.0227179807,
0.0104839578,
0.0211518593,
0.043141406,
0.0085358582,
-0.0215391554,
0.1098219678,
0.0504309498,
-0.0637606829,
-0.0268821456,
-0.0638722181,
0.0132968323,
0.0247369651,
0.0460933074,
-0.0636191368,
-0.0408111326,
0.0112679545,
0.0475114584,
0.0001851028,
-0.0309779271,
-0.0169411339,
-0.0760239065,
0.0083185956,
-0.055593282,
-0.0067861723,
-0.0155904628,
-0.0173509121,
0.022775583,
0.0060157129,
0.0109809125,
0.0400227681,
-0.0259691142,
-0.008525867,
-0.0206200257,
-0.0085407356,
-0.0060685547,
0.0581304543,
-0.0720238239,
0.0315050595,
0.1042736694,
0.0394187197,
0.0541255213,
-0.0026907893,
-0.0524953753,
-0.0195403676,
0.0238782857,
-0.0211792197,
0.0275346469,
-0.0262657106,
0.0394294262,
-0.0607065819,
0.0269541927,
-0.0080483286,
-0.0096764518,
0.040842656,
0.026814729,
-0.0418744646,
0.0305145141,
-0.0380088501,
0.023557011,
0.0488353483,
0.0426521562,
0.0039667925,
-0.0255556405,
-0.030824732,
-0.039663557,
-0.0228424519,
0.0235734284,
-0.0027469457,
-0.014421409,
0.0049857064,
0.0108639859,
-0.0684754178,
-0.0237026196,
0.0470075086,
0.0223880559,
0.0023398569,
0.0036794229,
-0.0071113207,
0.0526601709,
-0.0036756,
0.0207159687,
0.0016226576,
0.0180361811,
-0.0061696777,
0.0098984614,
0.0223986004,
-0.0772517398,
-0.0005275111,
0.0248046834,
-0.0258063842,
0.0014845417,
-0.0084952079,
0.0373188406,
0.0308719538,
0.0409307256,
-0.0481553972,
-0.0417571105,
-0.038329646,
0.0364459194,
-0.0539661683,
-0.0148400869,
0.0315364785,
0.0581453741,
0.0154930884,
0.0418791026,
-0.0724119395,
-0.0397950076,
-0.0612075292,
0.0092352722,
-0.0382877663,
-0.0898121968,
0.0360533297,
0.0032732368,
0.0260269158,
0.0482550599,
0.0054712119,
-0.0159306452,
0.0445566364,
0.0034810789,
-0.0055146068,
-0.0221839435,
0.042097155,
-0.0403946489,
-0.0140371425,
0.0119964676,
0.0582680851,
-0.049757991,
-0.0125407809,
-0.0475526452,
-0.0080488361,
-0.0096134013,
-0.0235423446,
0.0103575634,
-0.0144578004,
0.006337747,
0.028972134,
0.027249746,
0.0650900751,
0.0091734426,
0.0722488686,
-0.011630726,
-0.0489159785,
0.0043647992,
0.0653051138,
-0.0908145159,
-0.0779704377,
0.013700732,
0.0226741508,
0.0179209895,
0.0124046542,
0.0100065069,
-0.0326648206,
0.0354887545,
-0.009533505,
0.0021970852,
-0.0126426322,
-0.0240942575,
0.0307870358,
0.0271366667,
-0.0221127495,
0.0191701557,
0.040679466,
-0.0530248359,
0.0097466335,
-0.033846736,
-0.0356056131,
-0.042940665,
-0.0054912735,
-0.0012619329,
0.0640772134,
-0.0225003045,
-0.0265493169,
-0.0177761074,
0.0003439301,
-0.0122701339,
-0.0334896371,
-0.0319101103,
-0.0279282723,
0.0711849034,
0.0886414498,
0.0074256952,
-0.0617327839,
-0.0282882601,
-0.013047386,
-0.1141707823,
0.0043416219,
-0.0056992657,
-5.677657551e-33,
0.0114913723,
-0.0057158521,
0.0160461105,
-0.0068530189,
-0.024524061,
-0.0066068801,
-0.0426837057,
0.0050384873,
-0.031514734,
-0.0399615839,
-0.0309598744,
0.0467626415,
0.0166305937,
-0.0086850496,
-0.0227813479,
-0.0500273071,
0.059965834,
0.0054192636,
-0.0045602755,
0.0212149546,
0.0500830822,
0.0504016988,
-0.0334373564,
-0.0673854947,
0.0112925489,
-0.0137525545,
-0.0068955561,
0.0677236468,
-0.0075890869,
0.0423213206,
0.0071921614,
0.0620673448,
0.0051259482,
-0.0279174317,
0.0257088449,
0.014404946,
-0.0731348172,
-0.0144492453,
0.0307358019,
-0.0063326871,
-0.1087842882,
0.0109521821,
0.0066624219,
0.0203787759,
0.0055852327,
0.0461929403,
0.0307849329,
0.0088309813,
-0.0017546902,
-0.0105008231,
-0.0363738388,
-0.0190388132,
-0.0271298662,
-0.0563040487,
-0.0510107838,
0.0604356974,
0.0226304159,
-0.016749084,
-0.0722019821,
0.0328152366,
-0.0416077524,
0.0083883572,
0.0100305928,
-0.0001598521,
-0.0133756092,
0.0381353498,
0.0106848069,
0.0103582693,
-0.010914824,
0.0207738318,
-0.0383076966,
0.0556548834,
0.0327872634,
0.0387029238,
-0.0178502388,
-0.0033803983,
-0.0071007591,
0.0533693992,
0.0533278771,
0.026927175,
-0.0019577898,
0.0134752514,
-0.0590835884,
0.0116601083,
-0.0330195427,
0.0368676223,
-0.0669554174,
-0.054992523,
0.0579172969,
0.0350260958,
-0.0317370147,
-0.0625455827,
0.0015655286,
-0.0223473068,
0.0247712582,
-0.0020630597,
-0.0262916684,
0.0014686077,
0.0040753703,
0.01077512,
-0.0195179693,
0.0383267775,
0.0288371947,
0.0051357509,
-0.0093011726,
0.016733963,
-0.0645349398,
0.0191534869,
0.0001840338,
-0.0087592807,
-0.0021871328,
0.0337425619,
-0.0373343192,
0.0039500403,
0.0180267747,
0.034529794,
-0.0279999506,
0.1058252901,
0.0173722971,
0.0297073778,
-0.067953378,
-0.0839110315,
0.0322325416,
-0.0264665112,
-0.0101405103,
-0.0016167174,
-0.029599959,
0.0112520186,
-0.0358924195,
-0.0644840896,
-0.0119862584,
0.0084091295,
2.67e-7,
-0.0091135511,
0.0388397127,
-0.0083708744,
0.0578807928,
0.0238845944,
0.0399368145,
0.0501807593,
0.0227010734,
0.0266074073,
-0.0326351598,
0.0205335505,
0.0022282132,
0.0176883601,
0.031019045,
-0.0959469527,
-0.0799759924,
-0.0292490944,
-0.02533984,
-0.0621552989,
-0.0145934476,
0.0620197654,
0.0724726096,
0.0059755673,
0.0089758262,
0.0030139482,
-0.0418560505,
-0.002193609,
-0.0014447031,
-0.0033869441,
-0.0211522859,
0.0403560549,
-0.0123419631,
-0.0027856247,
-0.0040381863,
-0.0164504237,
0.0341238901,
0.0063883816,
0.020239234,
-0.0034042704,
-0.0729711205,
-0.0071405,
-0.0225462243,
0.0112972604,
-0.0679190755,
0.0999287739,
0.0085933879,
-0.0202205405,
0.032488618,
0.019013023,
-0.0058940863,
-0.0097291498,
-0.0195261724,
-0.031306453,
-0.0189967304,
-0.0274272859,
0.011509954,
0.020368943,
-0.0531822704,
0.0253811143,
-0.0217461102,
-0.0468444116,
-0.0472293831,
-0.0602238551,
-0.0085985195,
0.0144226616,
-0.0230502412,
0.0335871316,
1.755514488e-34,
0.0172977969,
0.0505166464,
-0.0020813625,
0.0532550476,
0.0198923014,
0.0167978797,
0.0023702576,
-0.0034446027,
0.0666010305,
-0.0760846063,
-0.0171653479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02213v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02213v5
|
Large Language Models as Master Key: Unlocking the Secrets of Materials Science with GPT
| 2023-04-05T04:01:52 | 2023-04-12T14:06:02 |
Tong Xie, Yuwei Wan, Wei Huang, Yufei Zhou, Yixuan Liu, Qingyuan Linghu, Shaozhou Wang, Chunyu Kit, Clara Grazian, Wenjie Zhang, Bram Hoex
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The amount of data has growing significance in exploring cutting-edge
materials and a number of datasets have been generated either by hand or
automated approaches. However, the materials science field struggles to
effectively utilize the abundance of data, especially in applied disciplines
where materials are evaluated based on device performance rather than their
properties. This article presents a new natural language processing (NLP) task
called structured information inference (SII) to address the complexities of
information extraction at the device level in materials science. We
accomplished this task by tuning GPT-3 on an existing perovskite solar cell
FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) dataset with 91.8%
F1-score and extended the dataset with data published since its release. The
produced data is formatted and normalized, enabling its direct utilization as
input in subsequent data analysis. This feature empowers materials scientists
to develop models by selecting high-quality review articles within their
domain. Additionally, we designed experiments to predict the electrical
performance of solar cells and design materials or devices with targeted
parameters using large language models (LLMs). Our results demonstrate
comparable performance to traditional machine learning methods without feature
selection, highlighting the potential of LLMs to acquire scientific knowledge
and design new materials akin to materials scientists.
|
[
0.0197471324,
0.0870418027,
-0.0092605343,
0.0633262098,
-0.0081525063,
-0.0172128286,
0.0079199523,
0.0151571855,
0.0261620507,
-0.004731508,
-0.0373195186,
0.0123779662,
-0.0097037777,
0.0441557094,
0.0074789161,
-0.0249454062,
0.0520037338,
-0.0204581413,
0.0771884993,
-0.0023684024,
0.0061343717,
-0.0077772848,
0.0193257667,
0.0300993044,
0.0135835698,
0.0120016132,
-0.0000906536,
-0.0108627677,
0.0161322244,
-0.0824445337,
0.0247240346,
0.0525589101,
0.0108240405,
0.0341867581,
0.0000019738,
-0.0756389871,
-0.0128958076,
0.0280969273,
0.0348936655,
0.0465938002,
0.0665129721,
-0.0607543737,
-0.028917579,
-0.0226381253,
-0.0032483167,
-0.0464626923,
0.0693915039,
0.0545106716,
-0.0113400035,
0.0174590386,
-0.0071081393,
-0.024071157,
0.0557929687,
-0.0271026567,
0.0223677605,
-0.0202081911,
0.035455849,
0.0331034698,
0.0208934993,
0.0343773663,
0.0043737814,
0.0358212925,
-0.0078412956,
0.0075415522,
0.0437276065,
0.0336426049,
-0.0949133933,
0.0336530432,
-0.0127662765,
0.0943046734,
0.0168751068,
-0.0297772009,
-0.004502608,
-0.0538875647,
-0.0886236578,
0.0307541676,
-0.0120491032,
-0.0184666794,
-0.0238631871,
0.0389263481,
0.016282551,
-0.0026580773,
0.0450133532,
0.0450112112,
-0.0202828031,
0.0880662575,
-0.0064444016,
-0.0342911594,
0.0275939927,
0.0171456467,
-0.0094670234,
-0.0149704302,
0.0001158501,
-0.0381885916,
0.0415806919,
0.0272194557,
-0.0055788853,
-0.005794575,
0.007863272,
-0.056613598,
0.0246939529,
0.0329211727,
0.0074520134,
0.059071105,
-0.0315876789,
0.0023683517,
0.0004401652,
0.0048730825,
-0.0275954641,
-0.0302887093,
-0.0391697511,
-0.049070131,
-0.0047035236,
0.0071852547,
-0.0361337177,
-0.044143118,
-0.0132626845,
-0.0081330827,
-0.0032334991,
0.01669061,
0.0107414825,
-0.0080358172,
-0.0238991454,
-0.0246540047,
-0.0417052917,
0.0343050696,
-0.0171270277,
0.000389592,
-0.0340524055,
-0.0337655768,
-0.0230058059,
-0.002789957,
-0.00441668,
0.0004217248,
-0.0107280258,
0.1147001907,
-0.0025541214,
-0.071782276,
-0.0427510589,
0.0021620723,
0.0077287601,
-0.0479947627,
0.0096799079,
-0.0349820666,
0.041661974,
0.0444701537,
-0.0151869562,
-0.0551222973,
0.0133076012,
-0.0172422044,
-0.0051019304,
0.0724428594,
-0.0037990371,
-0.0413935296,
0.0110985665,
-0.0097234659,
0.0370451994,
0.0316618867,
0.0276161842,
0.0420079194,
0.0172407757,
-0.0236848891,
-0.0024106868,
0.0420912392,
-0.0011526957,
-0.0326684825,
-0.0289804488,
-0.0056789299,
-0.0215013139,
-0.003098581,
0.0024649303,
-0.0080672428,
0.0111456923,
0.0313832425,
0.0383656137,
0.0576404408,
-0.003473701,
0.0595340692,
-0.0197195988,
0.0491211377,
0.0546084568,
-0.0678851902,
0.0101463422,
0.0283224955,
-0.0314177051,
0.001499726,
0.0329241529,
0.0173706077,
0.0024674826,
-0.03849582,
-0.0552580096,
0.0096860873,
-0.0110941799,
-0.038528882,
0.0807475969,
-0.0387478918,
-0.0344245695,
0.0364920236,
0.0538441353,
-0.0442501977,
-0.0261780359,
0.0049736165,
0.0304037686,
0.0468476377,
0.0234226733,
-0.0644882098,
-0.0237749126,
0.0573279671,
-0.0085419733,
-0.0052497443,
0.0130183641,
-0.0229126457,
0.0189642534,
-0.02544659,
-0.0255085826,
-0.0107518341,
0.0135406321,
0.0270442273,
-0.0121657196,
-0.0194193982,
0.0193848554,
-0.0136007974,
-0.05886795,
0.0271493252,
-0.0209675226,
-0.0458161831,
0.0461646765,
-0.0357520506,
0.0530164242,
0.0019399534,
0.0110979136,
-0.0106161302,
0.046376504,
-0.0352793522,
-0.0092237415,
-0.0136972563,
-0.0219927095,
-0.0304218959,
0.0099266274,
-0.0481720194,
0.032578744,
-0.0014353158,
-0.0350672044,
0.0111990497,
0.0349690989,
0.0057427962,
0.0219877269,
-0.0254492238,
-0.0209448412,
0.0149991224,
0.0321629792,
-0.0477028042,
0.0882471353,
0.0334011093,
0.0399878994,
0.0160508025,
-0.0258466732,
0.0423481278,
-0.0167203769,
0.0029170818,
0.0341257676,
-0.0047001038,
-0.0045352508,
0.0253057573,
-0.0054652039,
-0.0118694259,
0.0189931523,
-0.053398218,
0.0131814182,
0.0185051952,
0.0171855651,
0.0153655754,
-0.0064082425,
-0.0348718725,
-0.0015790543,
0.0049574985,
-0.0114236614,
-0.0001990248,
-0.0640234202,
0.0558666438,
0.001903387,
-0.0261164587,
-0.0299904328,
-0.0392206647,
-0.0713860393,
0.0663931146,
0.0323592052,
-0.0063377218,
-0.0471121036,
0.0554992072,
0.0280543845,
0.0243591722,
-0.0539973788,
0.000184649,
0.0051634735,
-0.0142948087,
0.0051902537,
0.0306985863,
0.000661127,
0.0390031002,
0.031173531,
-0.0287735518,
-0.0162638538,
-0.0025133272,
-0.0026398282,
0.0390597805,
0.01212982,
0.0033244274,
0.0322810598,
0.0321275033,
0.0003282774,
0.0321095958,
-0.0044299774,
0.0425884128,
-0.019978283,
-0.0296067204,
0.0278531294,
0.0475801192,
0.0438860394,
0.0133267362,
0.0141626745,
-0.0074824425,
0.1033992171,
-0.0451131426,
-0.0045067957,
-0.0755215958,
-0.0284297559,
-0.0497327745,
0.0531465895,
0.0353778675,
0.0322737806,
0.0217151456,
0.0095824469,
0.000160323,
-0.0124308923,
0.0131901624,
0.015954854,
0.0115652652,
-0.0603510141,
0.0538968407,
0.0015997653,
-0.0397996716,
-0.0021083381,
-0.0388069674,
-0.0173347089,
0.012462778,
0.0249580126,
-0.0561300218,
-0.0182000194,
0.0147916647,
0.0615138523,
-0.0002016252,
-0.0143840732,
-0.0038719303,
-0.0458192304,
0.0474116802,
0.0116770472,
-0.0538159385,
0.0133810407,
-0.0112034567,
0.0117277661,
0.0319385529,
-0.0307188276,
0.0145305637,
-0.0738129318,
0.0230071209,
0.0321857408,
-0.0148900356,
-0.0343705416,
-0.0109939501,
0.0328592248,
-0.0878955573,
0.0247046147,
0.0769983158,
0.0029573177,
-0.0404908918,
0.0171678737,
0.0556347221,
0.025934916,
-0.0225480422,
0.0152212027,
-0.1010207161,
-0.0384525508,
-0.020976197,
0.0194753166,
0.0033894132,
-0.0246635228,
-0.0361860991,
-0.1160199195,
0.0402312577,
-0.0081309434,
-0.0404532216,
-0.0533959754,
-0.0770632103,
-0.0054503861,
-0.0300098564,
-0.0290145017,
0.0207991656,
-0.0410980955,
0.0008271791,
-0.0110000493,
-0.0812207833,
-0.0859768838,
0.0496219769,
-0.002649745,
-0.0124499341,
0.0806062445,
0.0221192855,
-0.0429061465,
0.0131455055,
0.0052896417,
-0.0396138802,
-0.0020545905,
-0.0672935322,
0.0217813253,
0.029946344,
-0.0457266085,
-0.0013848824,
0.0561874993,
-0.0306099057,
-0.0154076135,
0.0162871219,
0.0850375146,
-0.0206386689,
-0.0071223602,
-0.0044782879,
-0.0536765121,
0.0259510186,
0.0628827587,
-0.0328596272,
-0.0191944968,
-0.0994724557,
-0.0387379117,
0.0036251424,
-0.0256000124,
-0.0009985872,
0.0029964845,
-0.0023108358,
-0.0062226658,
-0.0072722803,
-0.0337389447,
0.0266995225,
-0.0135707306,
0.0182771701,
0.0183256436,
0.0189626385,
0.0080261854,
-0.0479097255,
0.0471161865,
-0.0055955644,
0.001598648,
-0.0246957336,
-0.0419632718,
0.0310198069,
-0.0109412689,
-0.0363883227,
0.0123420944,
-0.048952613,
-0.0719718784,
-0.0254968274,
0.0019699982,
0.0193245281,
0.0129981767,
0.0115664089,
-0.0263904501,
0.0238958355,
0.0253773164,
-0.0412913226,
-0.0401338339,
-0.0190629065,
-0.0082478607,
-0.0114459889,
-0.0038960234,
0.0185985994,
0.0306291729,
0.0022642557,
-0.0005261903,
-0.019501891,
-0.0517406166,
0.0321369357,
0.0243926793,
0.0571339987,
0.0131497448,
0.0038945784,
-0.0465632975,
-0.0273276344,
0.0142179737,
0.007282394,
-0.040389806,
0.0230732374,
0.0496950932,
-0.029100202,
-0.0401266851,
0.0027057859,
0.0291590486,
0.0505052581,
-0.0726891011,
0.0470182076,
0.0235842243,
0.022269683,
0.0578416996,
-0.0260242242,
-0.0014013808,
-0.0014856274,
-0.0173830185,
0.0456584617,
-0.0475526303,
0.0085709905,
0.0353794508,
0.0148014631,
-0.0350747816,
0.039682854,
-0.0478091799,
-0.0736120641,
-0.0661231577,
0.034711428,
0.0038337677,
-0.0171770621,
0.0220604017,
-0.060398262,
-0.0281104799,
-0.014556244,
0.0475931279,
0.0112845274,
0.0021074326,
0.0335572101,
0.029337503,
-0.041308511,
-0.0291845538,
0.057320565,
0.0979389921,
-0.030490173,
-0.0149386916,
-0.0208135452,
-0.0289585888,
-0.0003085984,
-0.0135655878,
-0.012832257,
-0.0293165129,
-0.0088374224,
-0.0453745537,
-0.0084357178,
-0.0134559926,
0.02419121,
0.0008790974,
-0.0507635921,
0.0001996676,
0.0835101902,
-0.014511507,
-0.0451308824,
-0.014144551,
-0.0237987898,
-0.0091905259,
-0.0481259525,
-0.0094701461,
-6.305524349e-33,
-0.0215498265,
-0.0059805028,
0.007556045,
0.0489667989,
-0.0004124951,
-0.0173600186,
-0.050345283,
-0.0152636832,
0.0244880486,
0.0329293013,
-0.0176057126,
0.0116681,
0.015144458,
0.0131960399,
0.0342735983,
0.0086273644,
0.023749901,
0.0465478115,
-0.0098024374,
-0.0010154223,
0.0325198956,
0.0424015671,
0.0717270449,
-0.0727827922,
0.0250105578,
0.0270270668,
0.0294071734,
-0.068687126,
0.0009825099,
0.052434165,
-0.0329638012,
0.0330333374,
-0.0014979314,
-0.0473149456,
-0.0228105839,
0.0017681266,
-0.0518238321,
0.0044133663,
-0.0138812102,
0.0095963227,
-0.0025760978,
0.0243405849,
0.0002395474,
-0.0138546536,
-0.064528957,
0.0062956819,
0.0670723766,
-0.0502840392,
0.0180617739,
-0.0402685106,
-0.0987222716,
0.0208191108,
0.0096994797,
0.0618274733,
0.0121616535,
0.0295907203,
-0.0346799046,
0.0857628658,
-0.0022144245,
0.0076508597,
0.0514077134,
0.0833151042,
0.0521293394,
0.0333434865,
0.0208793245,
0.0266922135,
0.0111448448,
-0.0148862544,
0.0002693556,
-0.0188188497,
0.0055715227,
0.0674701035,
0.0426111072,
0.0188203193,
0.0530804321,
-0.0280083921,
-0.124611631,
-0.0167955402,
0.0139574092,
0.0114431847,
0.0090175495,
0.018276643,
0.0052565318,
-0.0256939512,
0.0048344661,
0.0156481396,
0.0323916636,
-0.0427877679,
-0.0039081541,
0.0028484324,
-0.0942676961,
0.0193991773,
0.0243041292,
-0.0337174162,
-0.045111794,
0.0813445821,
-0.0094592283,
0.0042596334,
-0.0103729982,
0.0226207338,
-0.0894904584,
-0.057699386,
-0.0690589398,
0.0071811946,
0.0277430154,
-0.00637331,
-0.0223462768,
0.022232648,
-0.0216385201,
-0.0154666957,
-0.0312140435,
-0.0554661825,
-0.0223876573,
0.0589702502,
0.0225263387,
0.0083379969,
-0.0043048859,
0.0331462286,
-0.0000551084,
0.0105178766,
0.0082719838,
0.0172753073,
0.0142844636,
-0.0117556071,
0.0342530385,
-0.0496235639,
-0.0579729192,
-0.0120213386,
0.0153536191,
-0.0218201838,
0.0221462939,
0.0479699112,
2.789e-7,
0.051990889,
0.0693237185,
-0.0278024655,
0.0392013341,
-0.0245035496,
0.0279417802,
-0.0168560278,
0.0024918893,
-0.0204005726,
-0.0120576816,
0.0416265056,
0.0008881073,
0.0357793942,
0.0194706246,
-0.0892667025,
-0.0192328487,
-0.0147305438,
-0.0311997104,
-0.0783715099,
-0.0229841191,
0.0421237573,
0.0975276306,
-0.0276908353,
-0.0276704505,
0.0235028993,
-0.0642339811,
0.062355157,
-0.034029834,
0.0101270853,
0.0736278743,
0.0445945188,
-0.0447067469,
-0.0379801504,
0.0538192689,
-0.0118861524,
0.0137887197,
0.0086725801,
0.0376098864,
0.0429849885,
0.0227217413,
0.0171951819,
0.0008161584,
0.0293051042,
-0.0256457552,
0.0630596131,
-0.0138972579,
-0.0326247402,
0.0038042502,
0.0402152687,
-0.0339991674,
0.0033643432,
-0.0371476337,
-0.0027462742,
-0.0287552513,
-0.0317732245,
-0.021865664,
-0.0061987098,
-0.0172493253,
-0.0158137474,
0.0347784571,
-0.0215526316,
-0.0134074064,
-0.0359660387,
-0.0196975414,
0.0345034227,
0.0090606101,
0.0378871597,
2.652794121e-34,
0.0385165028,
-0.0270189606,
-0.0279294457,
0.0430439152,
0.025484005,
0.0145916967,
0.00495794,
0.006983961,
-0.0351764411,
-0.0816677585,
0.022766158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02210v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02210v2
|
Document-Level Machine Translation with Large Language Models
| 2023-04-05T03:49:06 | 2023-10-24T14:00:21 |
Longyue Wang, Chenyang Lyu, Tianbo Ji, Zhirui Zhang, Dian Yu, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT can produce coherent, cohesive,
relevant, and fluent answers for various natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. Taking document-level machine translation (MT) as a testbed, this paper
provides an in-depth evaluation of LLMs' ability on discourse modeling. The
study focuses on three aspects: 1) Effects of Context-Aware Prompts, where we
investigate the impact of different prompts on document-level translation
quality and discourse phenomena; 2) Comparison of Translation Models, where we
compare the translation performance of ChatGPT with commercial MT systems and
advanced document-level MT methods; 3) Analysis of Discourse Modelling
Abilities, where we further probe discourse knowledge encoded in LLMs and shed
light on impacts of training techniques on discourse modeling. By evaluating on
a number of benchmarks, we surprisingly find that LLMs have demonstrated
superior performance and show potential to become a new paradigm for
document-level translation: 1) leveraging their powerful long-text modeling
capabilities, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 outperform commercial MT systems in terms of
human evaluation; 2) GPT-4 demonstrates a stronger ability for probing
linguistic knowledge than GPT-3.5. This work highlights the challenges and
opportunities of LLMs for MT, which we hope can inspire the future design and
evaluation of LLMs.We release our data and annotations at
https://github.com/longyuewangdcu/Document-MT-LLM.
|
[
0.0472082607,
0.0128713241,
0.002125717,
0.04867303,
-0.0451156385,
-0.0066806129,
0.0222525615,
-0.0134698562,
0.0054673143,
-0.0526646562,
-0.0394373536,
-0.0212475639,
0.0181735028,
-0.0063391728,
0.009413817,
-0.055471018,
0.0316319279,
-0.0347044058,
-0.0019757573,
-0.0098549062,
0.0125617161,
0.0163860228,
0.0204737466,
0.0371488407,
-0.0030873984,
-0.0416539758,
0.0025047718,
0.0204640403,
0.0158629362,
-0.0062526301,
0.0009797247,
0.0352791883,
0.0283123665,
0.07279405,
0.000002191,
-0.0336069241,
-0.016504176,
0.007570324,
0.001876851,
0.0472482704,
0.0473082066,
-0.0089444825,
-0.0174072795,
0.0220388658,
-0.027017029,
-0.0028194296,
-0.0119743897,
0.0565700792,
0.0841358751,
0.0701136068,
-0.0109150046,
-0.0219307821,
0.0329433605,
-0.0245830696,
-0.0176347848,
-0.0841709524,
-0.014021975,
0.0377097763,
0.0079935994,
0.0797867849,
0.0188012663,
0.052152507,
0.0119797681,
-0.0380557738,
-0.0249053985,
0.0296030603,
-0.0163251478,
-0.005582938,
-0.0239925105,
0.049769368,
0.0353686139,
-0.0028936744,
-0.0048365416,
0.0133121721,
-0.0096699875,
-0.0193927251,
-0.0442503579,
0.0169480015,
-0.0216154233,
0.0254957937,
0.0313845277,
0.0285561215,
0.0004615968,
0.0166185405,
-0.0051731444,
0.0110277832,
0.0329151079,
-0.0226629358,
-0.0046789092,
-0.0075453203,
-0.0532367602,
-0.0445973761,
0.0407883786,
0.0225553345,
-0.0338418856,
0.0080248099,
-0.0310950149,
-0.0220718272,
0.0388156809,
-0.0695132315,
0.0242547132,
0.0474578999,
-0.0118027907,
0.0533675961,
-0.0171666946,
0.0847852752,
-0.0218102708,
-0.035329327,
-0.0597511642,
-0.0235410091,
-0.0451864675,
-0.0056416774,
-0.0454284996,
-0.017319385,
-0.0830264166,
-0.0356387682,
0.0006992127,
0.036259748,
0.0502539203,
0.004510819,
0.0198982544,
-0.014257866,
-0.0603905469,
-0.0359493233,
-0.0275489073,
0.0459151044,
-0.0152312722,
-0.0074216104,
0.0066353385,
-0.0500473492,
-0.0026691747,
0.0283084661,
-0.0219856985,
-0.0160887036,
-0.0123482458,
0.0655641258,
-0.0296062231,
0.0001656585,
0.0023657589,
-0.0112337116,
-0.032078255,
-0.0807357952,
-0.0317075849,
-0.0592321381,
0.014674644,
0.0291357171,
0.0192281734,
-0.0010877798,
0.0310863666,
0.0398749076,
-0.0263695158,
0.0507360622,
0.0250520818,
0.0281130355,
0.0744876787,
0.0003506215,
-0.0222535767,
0.0340465121,
0.05568479,
0.0170907155,
0.0283903424,
-0.0220220182,
-0.0041814456,
0.0422151834,
-0.0242499616,
0.0165439006,
0.0382418483,
0.0328167975,
0.0147107383,
0.0383577459,
0.0253571868,
0.0821366236,
-0.015006844,
-0.0081753703,
0.0981237739,
0.0510034375,
-0.0350497998,
0.0310353376,
0.0458014533,
0.0350418687,
0.0097913137,
0.0250407215,
-0.0145918438,
-0.0159277748,
-0.0139865493,
0.0114839328,
0.0443816781,
0.0233607199,
-0.0140493158,
-0.0273513608,
-0.0103489943,
0.0094807502,
0.0103851808,
-0.0341482647,
0.0221831556,
-0.0009194924,
-0.0539345294,
0.020973647,
-0.0016204952,
-0.0442721359,
-0.0069198203,
-0.036282625,
-0.0042821714,
0.0639868155,
0.0497538336,
0.0026855725,
-0.0291953869,
-0.0430663973,
0.0565557517,
0.0866692439,
0.0660115331,
0.0159891658,
-0.0164727326,
-0.0312628187,
0.0089969281,
-0.0103513142,
0.0099865999,
0.03254354,
0.0167143457,
0.0120272981,
0.0262791384,
-0.0256305635,
-0.0643001795,
0.0180395488,
-0.0421265885,
-0.0461984128,
0.01960692,
-0.0249428675,
0.0259865038,
0.0164552499,
-0.0063905269,
0.0059148944,
0.0262176171,
-0.0253879186,
0.0012937684,
0.0208787024,
-0.0676650032,
-0.0326196179,
0.0205814019,
-0.0314032026,
-0.0312463306,
-0.0135470601,
-0.0323510058,
-0.062294744,
-0.0311625246,
-0.0563552678,
-0.0072823321,
-0.059950199,
0.0231128372,
0.0059826076,
-0.0138527323,
-0.0497491583,
0.0545242094,
0.022376027,
-0.0105286818,
0.0468681417,
-0.0116368011,
0.0394482277,
-0.0343706012,
-0.0196234845,
0.0105141839,
0.0334342048,
0.0289833117,
0.0450003147,
0.0296416897,
-0.0174583364,
-0.0607061237,
-0.1677173972,
0.0423275121,
-0.022498155,
0.0456215367,
0.0451609641,
0.0158623531,
-0.0271283928,
0.0027372902,
-0.0298925918,
-0.0184600726,
0.0385904983,
0.0021822122,
0.0358697325,
-0.0095010344,
0.0327687897,
-0.032903526,
0.0184878595,
-0.0024855391,
0.0245920029,
0.0290521085,
-0.0402190275,
-0.048875466,
0.03135686,
-0.0022651677,
-0.0088722315,
-0.0169227254,
-0.0319722518,
0.028899774,
0.0020962893,
0.0947582349,
0.0492612161,
0.0476427749,
0.0361493938,
-0.0053829635,
-0.0166272651,
-0.0521530099,
0.0263274759,
-0.0373746157,
-0.0544479191,
-0.0406293496,
-0.0236094557,
0.0043730959,
0.0617660061,
0.0101682078,
0.0131664053,
-0.0483960845,
0.0165829659,
-0.0151515817,
-0.021583125,
-0.0111361649,
-0.0007677102,
-0.0123011479,
0.0158323441,
-0.0217226371,
-0.0269782022,
0.0531195737,
-0.085253872,
-0.0098914998,
-0.0733962953,
0.0030784281,
-0.037814267,
0.0623775534,
-0.0120259756,
0.0105196629,
-0.0192345493,
-0.0158880968,
-0.0213921834,
0.0119620757,
0.0199386012,
-0.0367083177,
0.0292093474,
-0.0763371512,
-0.0046962569,
-0.035698045,
-0.0410996601,
-0.0246772822,
-0.0499530025,
-0.0146947866,
0.0176131763,
0.0125008617,
-0.0092889909,
-0.0167352147,
0.0298766121,
0.0350601785,
0.0477784835,
-0.0392935164,
-0.0112492489,
-0.0475638509,
0.0536052957,
0.0305507295,
0.0119186128,
0.0285244826,
-0.0478496775,
0.0549087897,
0.0414662771,
-0.0157607719,
0.0006778601,
-0.0259024203,
-0.0390154421,
-0.0144705288,
-0.0364133231,
-0.0468970686,
-0.0280987192,
0.079587549,
-0.0838735327,
-0.0171145257,
0.1316649914,
0.0164311081,
-0.0305015631,
-0.0344537906,
-0.0210442375,
0.0455870144,
-0.0046349075,
0.0362654701,
-0.0717518479,
-0.0379788689,
0.0179321561,
0.0255333763,
0.009743074,
0.00199812,
-0.0145935779,
-0.0899642259,
0.0350317173,
0.0061640358,
-0.0027342066,
-0.0125167742,
-0.0181243122,
-0.0110719334,
0.0104418751,
0.0507427119,
0.0007196201,
-0.0197727699,
-0.0027098409,
0.0001500746,
-0.0014226827,
-0.0236511733,
0.0237853918,
-0.0291420072,
0.0387325436,
0.0679697618,
0.061320018,
0.0112707466,
-0.0018425208,
0.0518839285,
-0.022575777,
0.0082365377,
-0.0007300206,
-0.0058724834,
-0.0158360396,
0.0124640381,
-0.0171805955,
0.0411225259,
-0.0281506684,
0.0276719499,
0.0487634912,
0.0434981361,
-0.0416703075,
-0.0087924637,
-0.0127590774,
0.0036470988,
0.0028092961,
0.096501559,
0.0364022702,
-0.0567611083,
-0.0459450595,
-0.0293973759,
0.0120055955,
-0.0019980296,
0.0091444626,
-0.0237978399,
-0.0132220816,
0.0133558391,
-0.0803940296,
-0.0614546649,
0.0182668362,
-0.0102183269,
0.0200625882,
0.0259406585,
-0.0114221303,
0.0013455615,
0.0107552726,
0.0398795009,
-0.0361781791,
0.0152843017,
-0.0782522783,
0.0206912849,
0.0438881814,
-0.0424532294,
-0.0134650711,
0.0039822003,
-0.0601097941,
-0.064437218,
-0.0373119116,
0.0188833233,
0.0194681399,
0.0584018268,
-0.0296606962,
-0.0132622365,
0.0403855033,
0.0259647761,
-0.0483571179,
0.0196642391,
0.0128479525,
0.0381056294,
-0.0130264312,
0.0342554301,
0.0066240681,
0.0086777415,
-0.0202610567,
0.0684252828,
-0.0128529482,
-0.0875200182,
0.0099438932,
-0.0006649604,
0.0411942787,
0.003641898,
-0.0067505087,
-0.0292711705,
0.0187007189,
-0.0216989573,
-0.0219689608,
-0.052058775,
-0.0164070129,
0.0295986068,
-0.0089176446,
-0.0062564323,
-0.0024969215,
-0.0271143429,
0.0368336327,
-0.0126539422,
0.004726734,
-0.0135161262,
-0.0035101785,
-0.0022137503,
-0.0084677106,
-0.0351761729,
0.0271565933,
-0.0272805542,
0.0375510119,
-0.0242187399,
0.0903222486,
0.0110019641,
-0.0196041763,
0.0477924347,
0.0392103568,
-0.070989199,
-0.0146179087,
-0.00811953,
0.0620614775,
0.0685214549,
-0.0104425093,
0.10350205,
-0.0460064784,
-0.0043535107,
-0.0528053716,
0.0509725325,
0.0536212176,
-0.0097270543,
-0.0037691987,
-0.0002932232,
-0.0142316455,
0.0348000415,
0.0792538226,
-0.006298285,
0.0074907267,
0.0325123891,
-0.0358287208,
-0.0293668751,
-0.0354538597,
-0.0044675968,
-0.0263689365,
-0.0024910544,
0.0077061937,
-0.0297734793,
-0.0167351998,
0.0063469871,
0.0155337378,
-0.0108190896,
-0.0488356166,
0.0103750937,
0.0895499513,
-0.0229258724,
-0.014654845,
-0.078072004,
0.0335346051,
-0.0254177265,
-0.0241205469,
-0.0580765232,
-6.419629585e-33,
-0.0540395379,
-0.0297133215,
0.0264465064,
0.0316156559,
-0.0236689989,
-0.0009621943,
-0.0630457476,
-0.0161845647,
0.0192946177,
0.0411260389,
-0.0435364656,
-0.0102233905,
0.0085700033,
0.0207694508,
-0.0210288502,
0.0023553777,
0.0600516312,
-0.0028906434,
-0.0347042009,
0.0548641011,
0.03935932,
-0.0006772959,
0.0323624387,
-0.0381639972,
0.0251512975,
-0.0403586403,
-0.0021101125,
0.0262349546,
-0.0101389661,
0.0393508747,
-0.0327497944,
0.0049933204,
0.0361874551,
-0.0306424163,
-0.0148488525,
0.0504439138,
-0.0850512236,
0.0145623973,
0.0385341756,
0.0042680763,
-0.0124959126,
-0.0443373211,
0.0107184118,
-0.0319774598,
0.0050273729,
-0.0070574651,
0.0205593519,
-0.0255837347,
-0.0236558616,
-0.0247508269,
-0.0651984438,
0.025510041,
-0.0130654275,
-0.029224528,
0.0092871226,
0.0241852794,
-0.0180915799,
-0.0016796357,
-0.0450466312,
-0.0015590159,
0.0034106942,
0.0153713981,
0.0343097672,
-0.0037578375,
0.0000189162,
0.0268409923,
-0.0275202766,
0.0081179086,
-0.0314357691,
-0.0041977931,
-0.0029974941,
0.0055021369,
0.0521653742,
0.0153390169,
-0.005192711,
0.0186227616,
-0.0446837246,
0.0435156822,
-0.0048330715,
0.0322915837,
0.0442212261,
-0.0105395541,
-0.0127104735,
-0.0073378817,
-0.0747027919,
-0.0025843035,
-0.0054313438,
-0.0180019606,
0.0175737254,
-0.0034709142,
-0.0188923925,
-0.0352876931,
0.0760037377,
-0.0188548584,
-0.0216756091,
-0.003465686,
-0.0389294885,
0.0058436412,
-0.0056512561,
0.0711109638,
-0.038631618,
-0.0003252421,
0.0126570445,
0.0043077334,
-0.0157116465,
-0.0089987963,
0.0243659429,
-0.0076363371,
-0.0324551724,
0.015054523,
-0.0320169814,
0.0280824248,
-0.0568544641,
0.0312364511,
0.0195113514,
-0.0112900911,
0.004674179,
0.0496608689,
0.0004355435,
0.0210390314,
-0.0470941029,
-0.0292933304,
-0.0138882184,
0.0208293926,
-0.0481050387,
0.0393762626,
-0.0214723386,
0.0389906317,
0.0186025444,
-0.0235993955,
0.0019136586,
0.021184193,
2.741e-7,
0.0425919965,
0.0696341544,
0.0249545965,
0.0057218485,
0.0300092939,
0.0303013548,
-0.0130808121,
0.0424247719,
0.0343257971,
-0.0097002396,
0.0025936891,
0.0423204266,
0.0970830396,
0.0146250548,
-0.1081182286,
-0.0490710773,
-0.0876421109,
0.0160272699,
-0.0754324123,
0.0052592549,
0.0692549124,
0.0563930683,
-0.0384643599,
0.0088034235,
-0.0088618044,
-0.032017231,
0.1000375152,
-0.0398040116,
-0.0362444967,
0.0400801338,
0.068329148,
0.006658284,
-0.0149566466,
-0.0052374247,
0.003002374,
0.007039337,
0.019694427,
0.1133589223,
0.035071034,
-0.0035338341,
-0.0005826944,
-0.0292189177,
0.0070620123,
-0.0604914762,
0.0616832562,
-0.048150558,
-0.0098783765,
-0.0422060192,
-0.0167239923,
-0.0292191803,
0.0214986354,
-0.0279537383,
-0.0526446812,
0.0297943801,
0.0177434403,
-0.0286364667,
-0.011798339,
-0.0441752039,
-0.0124182003,
-0.0316052102,
-0.0436797887,
-0.0286403634,
-0.0397550836,
0.0166253131,
-0.0030480034,
-0.0371582061,
0.0054952633,
2.660494757e-34,
0.0610535517,
-0.0343422182,
0.0058731874,
-0.0115509983,
0.0501186997,
0.0141345328,
0.0356897749,
-0.0056380578,
-0.0076415767,
-0.0967166722,
-0.0050376593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02182v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02182v2
|
How to Design Translation Prompts for ChatGPT: An Empirical Study
| 2023-04-05T01:17:59 | 2023-04-21T09:35:44 |
Yuan Gao, Ruili Wang, Feng Hou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recently released ChatGPT has demonstrated surprising abilities in
natural language understanding and natural language generation. Machine
translation relies heavily on the abilities of language understanding and
generation. Thus, in this paper, we explore how to assist machine translation
with ChatGPT. We adopt several translation prompts on a wide range of
translations. Our experimental results show that ChatGPT with designed
translation prompts can achieve comparable or better performance over
commercial translation systems for high-resource language translations. We
further evaluate the translation quality using multiple references, and ChatGPT
achieves superior performance compared to commercial systems. We also conduct
experiments on domain-specific translations, the final results show that
ChatGPT is able to comprehend the provided domain keyword and adjust
accordingly to output proper translations. At last, we perform few-shot prompts
that show consistent improvement across different base prompts. Our work
provides empirical evidence that ChatGPT still has great potential in
translations.
|
[
0.0521370806,
-0.0418414474,
-0.0082016308,
0.0269384664,
-0.0526442789,
0.0044498849,
0.0407014973,
0.0063410196,
0.0234248303,
-0.0103667667,
-0.0382249467,
-0.048323378,
0.0053110416,
0.0224719997,
0.0166900009,
-0.0805578232,
0.0472348966,
-0.01174598,
0.0033134429,
0.0060716281,
0.0259663966,
0.0279938672,
-0.0226944312,
0.0475391597,
0.0081066927,
-0.0383644477,
-0.0170641132,
0.03627057,
0.0318097472,
-0.0305537637,
0.0046076099,
0.0303985346,
0.0031535232,
0.0599876232,
0.0000020521,
-0.0506935492,
-0.0423194021,
0.0116551854,
-0.0130848931,
0.0094069308,
0.0461560972,
-0.0141626755,
-0.0227616727,
0.0332515351,
-0.0239098798,
-0.0128497705,
0.0532345213,
0.0076500564,
0.0691620484,
0.0590983145,
-0.0228762254,
-0.0016146783,
-0.0451918393,
-0.0444942079,
0.0263639782,
-0.0653998405,
-0.0577690676,
0.0053761471,
0.0171723478,
0.0454546288,
0.0167501271,
0.0543541089,
0.0040833261,
-0.0192721132,
-0.0157823525,
0.0319728553,
-0.0305361412,
-0.0540352203,
-0.0250731762,
0.0653384626,
0.0026354168,
0.0127449995,
-0.0154824881,
0.0011173557,
0.0144938743,
-0.0178150702,
-0.0394016504,
0.0214597434,
-0.0275359061,
-0.0362977833,
0.0066384654,
0.047411602,
-0.0134542193,
-0.0035394777,
-0.0012946632,
-0.0128576169,
0.0414983593,
-0.0069957064,
-0.0125566097,
0.0158865508,
-0.0157363974,
-0.0428925678,
0.0407871753,
-0.0001540896,
-0.04901677,
0.0135577191,
-0.0296059698,
-0.0034309526,
0.0326060317,
-0.0183540843,
-0.0149122393,
0.0704088509,
-0.0291622505,
0.0316375345,
-0.0240355376,
0.0671993643,
0.0053564594,
-0.0132096251,
-0.0596742779,
-0.005114282,
-0.0414708965,
0.0044927853,
-0.0860041678,
-0.0259292182,
-0.044156082,
-0.0136152962,
-0.0554023869,
0.0463683829,
0.0535928197,
0.0161232539,
0.0374268442,
-0.0290886853,
-0.0726329535,
-0.0256370977,
-0.0116550745,
0.0338629745,
-0.0380371399,
-0.0530119613,
0.027383633,
-0.0686716661,
-0.0215779096,
0.0190980881,
0.0056525576,
-0.0192233641,
-0.0416855365,
0.108028315,
-0.0191967562,
-0.0206702817,
0.0218639728,
-0.0322898887,
-0.0330248475,
-0.0539825521,
-0.0188999269,
-0.0365643874,
0.0509999022,
0.0412601866,
0.0112393368,
-0.0029062838,
0.02298229,
0.0247301627,
-0.0097456891,
0.0654838756,
-0.0268168915,
-0.0036643615,
0.0065068179,
0.0031455751,
-0.0502738282,
0.061007861,
0.012646405,
0.0494247302,
0.0365659967,
0.0149697792,
-0.0127684334,
0.0381295681,
-0.0222833473,
0.002294665,
0.0411678627,
-0.0094721857,
0.0261635277,
0.0400256105,
-0.0109079508,
0.0400496125,
-0.0212569404,
0.0540447533,
0.0488394909,
0.0230836701,
-0.0009601042,
0.0665660203,
0.0616304651,
0.0477834046,
-0.0207612384,
0.0092414571,
-0.0408761129,
0.0341597423,
-0.0011779027,
0.0316052549,
0.0191402361,
0.0414412916,
-0.0022015525,
-0.0236126743,
0.0103895571,
0.0105554145,
0.0060114586,
-0.0277166069,
0.0184428524,
0.0146761136,
-0.0613521338,
0.0423949696,
-0.0017920926,
-0.0350678153,
0.0022196255,
-0.0306321234,
-0.0182930678,
0.0869341567,
0.0646547899,
0.0287502855,
-0.0499513112,
-0.0151489489,
0.0270357132,
0.0819015056,
0.0897358507,
0.0176675823,
-0.0038552636,
-0.0447553508,
-0.0419316255,
0.023156574,
0.0012055259,
0.0401635356,
0.0172734763,
0.0541993156,
0.0572556034,
-0.0213359874,
-0.0393417552,
0.0040853326,
0.0197418183,
-0.0208746307,
0.0131727587,
0.0004911984,
-0.0084466515,
0.0369935818,
-0.0190186352,
0.0000508995,
-0.028318895,
-0.0161932614,
-0.0063440874,
0.0699409619,
-0.0374741666,
-0.0537148006,
-0.0032533389,
-0.0489120409,
-0.0114992997,
-0.0443453752,
-0.042289678,
-0.0399223715,
-0.0498723462,
-0.0445458926,
0.0064468803,
-0.0412039459,
0.0322977193,
0.0176118184,
0.0119210621,
-0.0284069758,
0.0412938893,
0.0490768142,
-0.0193947069,
0.0398735963,
0.0018476755,
0.0526453108,
-0.0309064835,
-0.0130404225,
0.0249626618,
-0.0119857378,
0.0045121638,
0.0502037816,
0.0548787117,
-0.0409938656,
-0.0178338718,
-0.077704899,
0.0332561657,
-0.0207846854,
0.0235672034,
0.0454629324,
0.0487326197,
-0.0319332369,
0.0076523502,
-0.025744006,
0.0231751706,
0.0323590413,
0.0144581459,
0.0362869836,
0.0000942162,
0.012309161,
-0.0135153085,
0.0408978276,
0.0277521778,
-0.0117828082,
0.0662918389,
-0.0665743649,
-0.079952918,
0.0424568057,
-0.0325431563,
-0.0473638922,
0.0337168053,
-0.0742975548,
0.0178979747,
-0.0179153457,
0.0387804806,
0.0093574505,
0.0247898735,
-0.0065414845,
0.015717335,
-0.0211357269,
-0.0499033593,
0.0122395819,
-0.0269459169,
-0.073810026,
0.0391658992,
-0.0367972851,
0.0279559679,
0.0286903623,
0.0190631021,
0.0133800507,
-0.0829764232,
0.0041191513,
-0.0355797037,
0.0020936602,
-0.0403569303,
0.0450137109,
0.003377314,
0.0488779694,
-0.003567843,
-0.0338167585,
0.072233066,
-0.0361342244,
-0.0249864124,
-0.0829670206,
0.0158719253,
-0.0112404926,
0.0605215281,
-0.0453338288,
0.0307013746,
0.0182684939,
-0.0300526042,
-0.0305487942,
0.0397741683,
0.0498097017,
-0.0205038469,
-0.0279837251,
-0.0687369034,
-0.0109350709,
-0.0358585641,
-0.0225279275,
-0.0556261092,
-0.0121358242,
-0.0143294744,
-0.0144945709,
0.0334079564,
-0.0198427793,
-0.0088489205,
0.0383343138,
0.0222870093,
0.037708614,
-0.0383937284,
-0.0189742055,
-0.0157971941,
0.0054682777,
0.0290174037,
-0.0092890952,
-0.0094435727,
-0.0141145429,
0.0372610353,
0.0257653408,
-0.0244744625,
-0.0271098167,
0.0009251794,
-0.0361761637,
0.01827747,
-0.0271229539,
-0.0552606732,
-0.0007907667,
0.0635383278,
-0.0457343236,
-0.0084778583,
0.1355228722,
0.0249918867,
-0.0570764616,
-0.0330740362,
-0.0186873786,
0.0476898104,
-0.0056681829,
0.0452326611,
-0.102343075,
-0.0362893865,
0.0094213011,
0.0212422311,
0.0208919663,
0.0202402305,
-0.0613730028,
-0.0889003128,
0.0524597019,
0.0233803988,
-0.048104357,
-0.0324284844,
0.0169790033,
-0.0320482254,
-0.0137461219,
0.0208177157,
-0.0148052583,
-0.0018144769,
0.0290841311,
-0.0104873013,
0.0089522423,
-0.0324203409,
0.0042749317,
-0.040316008,
0.0368151926,
0.0861099139,
0.0502689965,
0.0420299172,
-0.0085017988,
0.0346435867,
0.0017002735,
0.0277684554,
-0.0103389211,
0.0224837828,
0.0179832168,
-0.0305322818,
-0.0054341839,
-0.0147241205,
-0.0202368759,
0.0088248812,
0.0683406889,
0.0200968776,
-0.0225332938,
0.012988314,
0.0102423737,
0.0356741473,
0.0265463963,
0.0686587989,
0.0140508329,
-0.0297099985,
-0.0296003688,
-0.0326994844,
-0.0057857386,
-0.0633390173,
-0.0146986349,
-0.0003755076,
-0.0751448199,
-0.0412494279,
-0.1033857837,
-0.0631595254,
0.0244678818,
0.0423891954,
0.0182971228,
-0.0010095706,
-0.039302621,
0.0601993538,
0.0033537776,
0.010514033,
-0.03921251,
0.0031515849,
-0.0458086468,
-0.009159998,
0.0258949436,
-0.0479058214,
-0.0018784347,
0.0547704995,
-0.0272978749,
-0.0582243837,
-0.0162854306,
0.0262377262,
0.0263310634,
0.0261598919,
-0.0573771708,
0.0053373748,
-0.0103567271,
0.0526158437,
-0.0226994213,
-0.0300380029,
0.0059590507,
0.0399351604,
-0.0146906562,
0.0375688002,
-0.0265028551,
0.0011981819,
-0.0450575911,
0.0597469062,
0.0119758248,
-0.0608893223,
0.0359885879,
0.0499857515,
0.0322416723,
-0.0577268563,
-0.0028535,
-0.0108925356,
0.0087985629,
-0.0079453364,
-0.007965195,
-0.0372918062,
-0.0028604763,
0.0144029222,
-0.0573170148,
0.0202692822,
-0.0070406208,
-0.0749870911,
-0.0194242056,
-0.0046371147,
-0.0208538435,
-0.0272534881,
0.041521661,
0.0259694625,
0.006698668,
-0.0232131761,
0.0172012895,
0.0066554006,
0.0106312642,
-0.0476424284,
0.0870177522,
0.0072142994,
-0.0149477432,
0.0250791758,
0.0403777994,
-0.0211282149,
-0.0436168648,
-0.0157810487,
0.0506848209,
0.0935001373,
0.0221576672,
0.0787891671,
-0.038239371,
-0.0073566865,
-0.0054621859,
0.0672895387,
0.0451097377,
-0.0339442901,
-0.0233584121,
-0.017898716,
-0.0038783115,
-0.034639705,
0.0579207055,
-0.0479803719,
-0.0021851438,
0.0208694562,
-0.0214326214,
-0.0469403751,
-0.0087506929,
-0.0335288867,
-0.0335642248,
0.018741237,
0.0113891102,
-0.0438247398,
-0.0474896282,
-0.0199531447,
0.015399009,
0.0196454171,
0.0116971182,
0.041972138,
0.0789146721,
-0.0313277915,
-0.0035937056,
-0.0272465199,
0.0305803157,
-0.0402678549,
-0.0153865376,
-0.0520768017,
-6.017608313e-33,
-0.035059873,
-0.0156461131,
0.0186107475,
-0.0174381714,
-0.0163111091,
-0.0243018735,
-0.0517878607,
0.001408781,
0.0195050612,
0.0177098811,
-0.0278355405,
-0.0113598416,
0.0419749357,
-0.0116107222,
0.0021426606,
-0.0218735188,
0.0612613633,
0.0122570954,
-0.0383425355,
0.0502181202,
0.0268027131,
0.0181849357,
0.0606252961,
-0.0516200364,
0.0510665365,
-0.0369058847,
-0.0397731774,
0.0058692554,
0.0487022214,
0.0197376255,
-0.0089309886,
0.0179344416,
0.0200449266,
-0.0399333127,
-0.0193269923,
0.0163650867,
-0.0764394328,
-0.0189831443,
0.020656243,
0.0306948088,
0.0022236158,
-0.0571337454,
-0.027841337,
-0.0713024735,
0.0077249431,
0.0226941779,
0.0119442185,
-0.0326931439,
-0.0175146442,
-0.0056157494,
-0.0698430911,
0.0131650316,
-0.0201627575,
-0.0249229465,
-0.0004846298,
0.085547179,
-0.0097856652,
-0.0420901962,
-0.0017205285,
0.038866926,
0.0033725966,
0.0188926905,
0.0750602186,
-0.0078426367,
-0.0323615484,
0.0110354498,
0.0022101407,
-0.0075453422,
0.0218901224,
0.0212195385,
-0.0101227676,
-0.0159665998,
0.0369690992,
0.0746935979,
0.0168159623,
-0.0291708987,
-0.0111886235,
0.0708324537,
0.0193350744,
0.0011927504,
0.0185120385,
-0.003211889,
-0.0209152438,
-0.0035610811,
-0.027154468,
-0.0216288641,
-0.0342075042,
-0.0852120072,
0.0374955609,
0.0072310953,
-0.0357525274,
-0.0354652554,
0.0625145063,
0.0087869242,
0.0167316571,
-0.0071585472,
-0.0325159468,
-0.0240291413,
-0.0297167506,
0.0251669716,
0.0074831443,
-0.0405030847,
0.0265193116,
0.0293229558,
-0.0073279515,
-0.0087905377,
0.0026888696,
0.0005561838,
-0.0457063541,
0.0230637603,
-0.0395381041,
0.0412853584,
-0.0438395329,
-0.0216043051,
-0.0047400664,
-0.0317905322,
-0.0391574353,
0.0289927553,
0.0412040353,
-0.0045065028,
-0.0308923945,
0.0110139912,
-0.0005091936,
0.023042649,
-0.0540891364,
0.0364190526,
-0.001649191,
0.0172623321,
0.0180796813,
-0.0244946685,
-0.0320155323,
-0.0242207237,
2.743e-7,
0.0381104089,
0.0429762118,
0.0210995022,
0.0416628346,
-0.0014340362,
0.003330064,
0.0113622202,
0.0407369211,
0.0131653221,
0.0389030725,
0.0293006301,
0.0149234682,
0.0568142198,
0.0161223635,
-0.1067827195,
-0.0431576557,
-0.0268393718,
0.0155983763,
-0.0661440417,
0.0440322123,
0.1071276888,
0.0632065907,
-0.0246115103,
0.018346373,
-0.004297222,
-0.0448916927,
0.0448017344,
-0.0212156419,
-0.0257072337,
0.0243472084,
0.0356262028,
0.0300155208,
-0.0362182111,
-0.0084236003,
-0.0148412408,
-0.0419400223,
0.0483649597,
0.0644008815,
0.0288368594,
0.008338755,
0.0139916949,
-0.0054164925,
0.0166008081,
-0.0385711342,
0.0538515933,
-0.060367845,
0.0229623262,
-0.0053449371,
-0.0026075505,
-0.0060806633,
0.013734092,
-0.0541888699,
-0.0693836063,
0.0282803886,
0.0192926079,
0.0012488903,
-0.0338548496,
-0.0298193842,
-0.0117655871,
-0.0240185335,
-0.0086472509,
-0.0368371457,
-0.0447982587,
0.0020113674,
0.0222296193,
-0.0098983897,
0.004366321,
2.269111158e-34,
0.047395315,
-0.0331315137,
0.0130626708,
-0.0087051764,
0.0572949499,
-0.0007068583,
0.0360342637,
0.016562365,
0.0261005927,
-0.0204241984,
-0.0400431976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02181v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02181v2
|
On the Impact of Voice Anonymization on Speech Diagnostic Applications: a Case Study on COVID-19 Detection
| 2023-04-05T01:09:58 | 2024-06-26T17:58:42 |
Yi Zhu, Mohamed Imoussaïne-Aïkous, Carolyn Côté-Lussier, Tiago H. Falk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
With advances seen in deep learning, voice-based applications are burgeoning,
ranging from personal assistants, affective computing, to remote disease
diagnostics. As the voice contains both linguistic and para-linguistic
information (e.g., vocal pitch, intonation, speech rate, loudness), there is
growing interest in voice anonymization to preserve speaker privacy and
identity. Voice privacy challenges have emerged over the last few years and
focus has been placed on removing speaker identity while keeping linguistic
content intact. For affective computing and disease monitoring applications,
however, the para-linguistic content may be more critical. Unfortunately, the
effects that anonymization may have on these systems are still largely unknown.
In this paper, we fill this gap and focus on one particular health monitoring
application: speech-based COVID-19 diagnosis. We test three anonymization
methods and their impact on five different state-of-the-art COVID-19 diagnostic
systems using three public datasets. We validate the effectiveness of the
anonymization methods, compare their computational complexity, and quantify the
impact across different testing scenarios for both within- and across-dataset
conditions. Additionally, we provided a comprehensive evaluation of the
importance of different speech aspects for diagnostics and showed how they are
affected by different types of anonymizers. Lastly, we show the benefits of
using anonymized external data as a data augmentation tool to help recover some
of the COVID-19 diagnostic accuracy loss seen with anonymization.
|
[
0.0026379242,
0.1062764153,
-0.0439491495,
-0.0055989199,
-0.0250815488,
-0.0352539383,
0.1006204635,
-0.0317387208,
-0.005927816,
0.036528524,
-0.0016483446,
-0.0118692853,
0.0325917527,
0.0343126431,
0.0010326046,
-0.0322469957,
0.0145985326,
-0.0135954833,
0.0593548827,
-0.0143218776,
-0.0184217207,
0.0161231831,
-0.0151190683,
0.0622133203,
-0.0244229008,
-0.013952422,
0.0024516785,
-0.0045889821,
0.0390207805,
-0.0191907696,
0.0017088641,
-0.025901109,
0.0137916477,
0.0671574548,
0.0000018004,
-0.0256750975,
-0.0291478746,
0.0166766103,
-0.0540495142,
-0.0554382168,
0.0082085552,
0.0242461469,
-0.0018356368,
0.041484002,
-0.0354929268,
-0.0143960314,
0.043560341,
-0.0039365483,
0.0611666292,
0.0288407914,
-0.0230908375,
-0.019982364,
0.0129487123,
0.0031568035,
0.0011923776,
-0.0076084742,
0.0253333207,
-0.0716716722,
-0.0088027613,
-0.0461917669,
0.0380776338,
0.0713614449,
-0.018261157,
0.0156035926,
-0.014626571,
0.0164629575,
-0.0315738022,
-0.0375154205,
0.0046296483,
0.0441524833,
-0.0078935996,
0.0119915493,
0.0550217927,
0.0339009836,
-0.00795817,
-0.0193668995,
-0.0076342984,
-0.0023862428,
0.0047023199,
-0.0015778198,
-0.014267195,
0.0498973019,
0.052358374,
-0.0118000638,
0.0172057915,
0.0187994819,
-0.0151998335,
-0.0076253456,
-0.0371308997,
-0.0658554733,
-0.0180439278,
-0.0309672877,
0.0784132034,
-0.0046112416,
-0.0250006299,
-0.002509573,
-0.0455434322,
-0.0978509188,
-0.0035797844,
-0.0439594202,
-0.0293889921,
-0.0322870053,
-0.0178197287,
-0.0181239285,
0.0002960597,
-0.0013824798,
0.0192658585,
-0.0090581095,
0.0239266679,
-0.0128299017,
0.0056263353,
-0.0056680152,
-0.02690069,
0.0270075146,
-0.0033866747,
0.0330105387,
-0.0623259917,
-0.0110409614,
-0.0706722438,
0.0068460274,
-0.0630237311,
0.0370523073,
-0.0306409486,
0.0414149053,
0.0508698039,
-0.0118795298,
0.0097671477,
0.0366315432,
0.0035511754,
-0.0459864847,
0.00717586,
-0.0269687679,
0.0549767315,
-0.005716389,
0.0338590555,
0.0290112142,
0.0406509526,
-0.0126321809,
0.0292547308,
-0.0356166437,
0.0176900718,
-0.0226027835,
-0.0261544716,
-0.0526290238,
0.0289572012,
-0.0283861719,
-0.0199795347,
-0.0615704171,
-0.0152294561,
-0.0264831856,
-0.0209999084,
0.0266856812,
-0.0175219066,
0.0162616279,
0.0334003083,
0.0300417487,
0.0481693745,
-0.0223171618,
0.0524861291,
-0.0405861884,
0.0477560312,
-0.0546835698,
0.0245971419,
0.0058875405,
0.0670004413,
-0.0333273523,
-0.0092565762,
-0.0217317548,
-0.0141646657,
0.003973715,
-0.0205285903,
0.0225270484,
0.0267549027,
-0.0842200965,
0.0446410067,
0.0871178955,
-0.025345454,
-0.0364524089,
-0.0450746045,
0.0338566788,
-0.022074284,
-0.0298069008,
-0.001897931,
-0.0341776423,
-0.038421575,
-0.0569830462,
0.0027105703,
0.0223071985,
-0.0404633619,
-0.0122609008,
-0.0044765007,
-0.0512869507,
0.0111118956,
0.0394229181,
-0.0455296859,
-0.0365832783,
0.0497776493,
0.0184937436,
-0.0049094493,
-0.037008334,
0.0094783828,
-0.0523048118,
-0.000101667,
0.0485606715,
-0.0062921098,
0.002707025,
0.0062717595,
-0.0667775869,
-0.0438747928,
-0.0005364173,
-0.0766537786,
-0.0054007522,
0.0797840953,
-0.0160198994,
-0.0112282168,
0.0621482208,
-0.0010551051,
0.0322040059,
-0.0113843726,
0.0164766572,
0.0241887085,
0.0031761834,
0.0120428158,
-0.0255017467,
-0.0312130488,
-0.07447806,
0.0754028112,
0.0275107361,
0.0859776661,
0.038008146,
0.0126931686,
-0.0052441079,
0.0051758518,
0.00229932,
-0.0098491022,
0.0287629142,
0.0162877124,
0.004342983,
-0.007182599,
-0.0219521541,
0.0324582383,
0.0910747126,
-0.015712399,
-0.0234250408,
0.0402642563,
-0.0221205801,
0.0099792061,
0.0130843231,
-0.0115690529,
-0.005423849,
0.0855968595,
0.0151483752,
-0.0538194142,
0.0055455831,
0.001562829,
-0.0332249701,
-0.0161321256,
-0.0113336742,
-0.049387902,
-0.0404071175,
-0.0374558493,
-0.0200418569,
0.018240178,
-0.0239431933,
-0.0620064102,
-0.0095895212,
0.0270371158,
-0.0828431621,
0.0020616907,
-0.0098438542,
-0.0044497224,
-0.0119307591,
0.0490718186,
-0.001914615,
-0.0191089995,
-0.0496671461,
-0.0592006147,
0.0115083568,
0.0369473808,
-0.0021387429,
0.0074850023,
-0.0686046332,
-0.0017583041,
-0.0239497665,
-0.0564027578,
0.0007937043,
-0.0251273271,
-0.0554666631,
0.0298288874,
-0.0295206662,
-0.0522176959,
0.0350365117,
-0.0049621402,
-0.0048695146,
-0.0172545444,
0.035145063,
-0.0081174392,
0.0353257358,
0.0162029359,
0.0037452092,
0.028080564,
0.0138892736,
-0.0097973216,
0.0345434174,
-0.0128543191,
0.016729841,
-0.0067997579,
-0.0389843099,
-0.0158930887,
0.0090345107,
0.0387974121,
-0.0313177891,
0.0041464842,
0.0406868681,
-0.0198453907,
-0.0572938509,
-0.0281197671,
-0.013333275,
-0.0218885075,
-0.0117181623,
0.0081067905,
-0.0142817944,
0.041915074,
-0.0323964655,
0.0214218181,
-0.0101302005,
-0.085137561,
-0.0065959562,
0.0090908175,
-0.0138284219,
0.0243896078,
0.0495608374,
-0.0600737371,
0.055452913,
-0.0303789694,
0.00347285,
-0.0791817009,
-0.0435016267,
0.0083125494,
-0.0097848168,
0.0318219364,
-0.024332853,
-0.0438805595,
-0.0584324822,
0.0006285777,
0.026411064,
0.009041978,
-0.0340821147,
0.0079399524,
0.0054763779,
0.0228639171,
0.0285481103,
0.0500685982,
0.0168958046,
0.0074588456,
0.0107650617,
-0.0306856539,
0.0456298515,
0.0353240333,
0.0386617109,
0.0034216591,
0.0047900379,
0.0602448024,
0.028520599,
0.0184498746,
-0.0373888277,
-0.0312154964,
-0.0154488878,
-0.0357843637,
0.0318966582,
0.0182146393,
-0.0477833003,
0.0148337884,
0.0646640807,
0.0040934151,
-0.0173370428,
0.0170959607,
0.0202919319,
-0.0074106683,
-0.0099405982,
-0.0247016028,
-0.0594639666,
0.0093953898,
0.044381056,
0.0727131441,
-0.0853856504,
-0.0362202302,
-0.0354311392,
-0.0077670068,
0.0299277417,
-0.0107252728,
0.0012750772,
0.0035267533,
-0.0598653406,
0.0182485431,
0.0040171393,
0.051948905,
-0.0701497644,
0.0166363996,
-0.0261695571,
0.0170246456,
-0.0934832692,
-0.0518947877,
0.0214315429,
-0.0376858562,
0.0864854902,
0.0300511513,
0.0357231274,
-0.0406557657,
-0.0456180498,
-0.0425446443,
0.0606022589,
-0.0245832503,
-0.0038285425,
0.0827376172,
0.0337244049,
-0.0034550866,
-0.0201002751,
0.0580340847,
-0.025244385,
0.0090575498,
0.0186954457,
0.0273463745,
-0.0182840042,
-0.0446941517,
0.0052710301,
0.0362994932,
0.0481537543,
0.0728101805,
-0.0152463568,
-0.0228335261,
0.0129728382,
0.0311238151,
0.0713569149,
0.0032031841,
-0.0305664334,
0.0024723895,
0.0232858565,
-0.1191220134,
-0.0170093868,
-0.0020483043,
-0.008288634,
0.0268388111,
0.0202049688,
0.0244981553,
0.0275987908,
0.0143566718,
-0.0487276241,
0.0171714798,
0.0057000271,
0.0625675023,
-0.0165585075,
0.0238005109,
0.0146718109,
0.0290359948,
-0.0291340891,
0.0579493903,
-0.0327869207,
-0.0218082312,
0.0751835927,
-0.0503359251,
0.0195758883,
0.0553446896,
-0.0405850671,
-0.0279082339,
0.0830248594,
0.0368124954,
-0.0196576603,
0.0226854011,
0.0957636461,
-0.0302039832,
-0.0200893972,
0.0116185714,
-0.0015353188,
0.008797993,
0.0219247695,
-0.0380500928,
-0.0581526347,
-0.001663345,
-0.0301437806,
0.0648730397,
0.0472706817,
0.0344163291,
0.0263648648,
-0.0158261154,
0.0359990932,
-0.0056312019,
0.0228397995,
0.0149796596,
-0.0294824038,
-0.0048357481,
0.028584851,
0.008836681,
0.0265390668,
-0.0129958959,
-0.0600418895,
-0.0244884305,
0.054295931,
-0.0045867832,
0.028105313,
-0.0056217606,
0.0115376133,
-0.0052006496,
0.0986209512,
0.0652355179,
0.0311010294,
0.0022654203,
-0.0585161559,
-0.0162821282,
0.0104906522,
0.0083878236,
0.0301526412,
-0.047206562,
-0.005913238,
-0.0024819653,
0.0036500623,
-0.0197402798,
0.0445468761,
-0.0010901217,
-0.0008935221,
0.023319073,
-0.0060858531,
0.006716067,
-0.0565960892,
-0.0180435143,
-0.0232167523,
-0.0033139621,
-0.0400284231,
0.0372358561,
0.059215229,
0.0172986686,
0.0540059283,
-0.0330366157,
-0.033881031,
-0.0179793779,
-0.0258187428,
-0.0036345664,
0.0340305679,
-0.0325464346,
-0.0074102571,
0.0036435472,
-0.0634604767,
0.0494231582,
-0.056716565,
-0.0031729522,
-0.0208687838,
0.0001353948,
0.0002587111,
-0.0092565231,
-0.0186348241,
-0.0055457884,
-0.000945303,
-0.0329073034,
-0.0529074445,
0.0248758011,
-5.506093048e-33,
0.0153289521,
0.0011140156,
-0.0130775692,
-0.0020323012,
0.0292279013,
0.0741050541,
0.0071365517,
0.0111694532,
0.0204651412,
-0.036849279,
-0.0303783957,
-0.0012648116,
0.0156648234,
0.0339284465,
-0.0329964235,
-0.0195991881,
0.106745407,
0.0125623848,
0.0001749034,
0.0295330565,
0.0788329989,
0.0319660269,
0.0047865463,
-0.1110532135,
0.0127618117,
0.036797598,
-0.0331257656,
0.0187388714,
-0.0167380292,
0.011411625,
-0.0082890494,
0.0225792956,
-0.0044088876,
0.0173681863,
-0.0062979059,
0.0222166814,
-0.0891256854,
-0.0330208689,
-0.0142309321,
0.0153242294,
-0.0198306479,
-0.0738247931,
0.0534807108,
0.0027223681,
-0.0394381769,
-0.0054809144,
0.0139076086,
-0.0259035099,
0.0465547927,
-0.0613519959,
0.0540486537,
0.0009279235,
-0.0474553332,
0.0080425022,
0.0414131209,
0.0353147052,
-0.0265966095,
-0.0170650892,
-0.0631159991,
-0.012867853,
0.0387056582,
-0.0165693723,
0.0242054835,
0.0359359309,
0.0259902626,
0.0367502496,
0.0744947493,
-0.0341165811,
-0.0268167797,
0.0152108176,
0.0144003732,
0.0420282334,
0.0591653883,
0.0006321006,
-0.0014179255,
-0.0543587506,
-0.0755834356,
0.0436729826,
0.0029039131,
-0.0492120907,
0.0407810323,
0.0032540485,
-0.0624544807,
-0.0097193019,
-0.0526367687,
-0.068635799,
-0.0094158165,
0.0174557045,
-0.0114796571,
-0.0029184713,
-0.0421562344,
0.0234640259,
0.0325465053,
-0.0313335247,
-0.0307112765,
0.0086275199,
0.0735665634,
0.0003278175,
0.0119496472,
-0.004390555,
-0.0080456976,
0.0013286584,
0.0478429273,
0.0132265016,
0.0690438747,
-0.0504293144,
0.0411597826,
0.0458328947,
-0.0550948009,
-0.0283810701,
0.024575023,
0.088502638,
-0.0032933748,
0.024724355,
0.016405629,
0.0119360508,
0.0130240396,
-0.0025116554,
0.0225799121,
0.0478897169,
-0.024757307,
0.0075361021,
-0.0479890816,
0.007234172,
-0.0174296256,
-0.0196201038,
0.0210972633,
0.0027956476,
0.0863678604,
-0.0399489254,
0.0263734292,
-0.0703538209,
2.658e-7,
-0.0527723506,
-0.0121283541,
0.0310065076,
-0.0301332343,
0.0106118852,
0.0549709983,
0.0363618992,
0.0457951128,
-0.0048287823,
-0.0058280514,
-0.0181802772,
-0.0119162602,
0.0378589444,
0.0644579828,
-0.0399589799,
-0.0360644795,
-0.038909059,
0.0337380916,
-0.062572591,
0.0314241797,
0.0101280985,
0.0787756741,
0.048525352,
-0.0687571019,
0.0209225733,
-0.0089569548,
-0.027464455,
-0.0379578285,
-0.0262927376,
-0.0196364298,
0.0259960648,
0.0293657258,
0.0508063808,
0.031257581,
-0.0379659869,
0.0176196769,
-0.0349502377,
0.0704698265,
0.0110369939,
-0.029596135,
-0.0290113352,
-0.0190541707,
-0.0262507442,
0.0508980639,
0.0613886677,
0.022724919,
-0.0689060315,
-0.0118508562,
-0.0143457409,
-0.0449205562,
0.0311386008,
-0.0063518649,
-0.0194429345,
0.0171779543,
-0.0204959605,
-0.010447884,
0.0067849779,
-0.0430987477,
-0.0149668027,
-0.0200692993,
-0.0379521847,
-0.0313125253,
0.0485671125,
0.0151193701,
-0.0072089587,
0.0133766951,
0.056958098,
2.229169605e-34,
-0.0088604046,
0.0268077329,
-0.0277158134,
-0.0324467123,
0.0034014818,
-0.0304333325,
0.0431742296,
-0.0038426325,
0.0241416357,
-0.0357683674,
-0.025492629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02168v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02168v2
|
I2I: Initializing Adapters with Improvised Knowledge
| 2023-04-04T23:51:48 | 2023-07-10T20:41:34 |
Tejas Srinivasan, Furong Jia, Mohammad Rostami, Jesse Thomason
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Adapters present a promising solution to the catastrophic forgetting problem
in continual learning. However, training independent Adapter modules for every
new task misses an opportunity for cross-task knowledge transfer. We propose
Improvise to Initialize (I2I), a continual learning algorithm that initializes
Adapters for incoming tasks by distilling knowledge from previously-learned
tasks' Adapters. We evaluate I2I on CLiMB, a multimodal continual learning
benchmark, by conducting experiments on sequences of visual question answering
tasks. Adapters trained with I2I consistently achieve better task accuracy than
independently-trained Adapters, demonstrating that our algorithm facilitates
knowledge transfer between task Adapters. I2I also results in better cross-task
knowledge transfer than the state-of-the-art AdapterFusion without incurring
the associated parametric cost.
|
[
-0.0136472154,
0.011524085,
-0.0167111047,
-0.0032383041,
0.0165274329,
-0.0178199876,
0.0119051458,
-0.0450569093,
0.0267249439,
-0.0045516617,
-0.0302462913,
-0.0019998725,
-0.0189585015,
0.0330023207,
0.016290484,
-0.0347314999,
0.0495234057,
-0.0073262677,
-0.0594023019,
0.0000127507,
0.0236049853,
-0.0591753758,
-0.0400944613,
0.0169908796,
-0.0470366441,
-0.0624466166,
-0.0474390537,
-0.0192518719,
0.0283486843,
-0.0442712754,
0.0313063338,
0.0069650388,
0.0366810374,
-0.0291581061,
0.0000020623,
-0.0138992425,
-0.0116252759,
-0.0547517948,
-0.0500754714,
-0.0595417731,
0.0029718638,
0.0346130468,
0.008916012,
0.0111425882,
-0.0473261476,
-0.0340666324,
0.0649932623,
0.0263608806,
0.0669493601,
-0.0110043855,
-0.0221839026,
0.0277379192,
0.0923732817,
0.0073579792,
0.0738916919,
-0.0344626456,
0.0062850821,
0.0127945729,
-0.0247023702,
-0.0247338004,
-0.0422659628,
0.0374297313,
0.0474711098,
-0.0041544046,
0.0761138648,
0.0357386731,
0.008559227,
-0.0088046789,
-0.0465167947,
0.0552273951,
-0.0232425146,
-0.0172249638,
-0.0201445762,
0.0202004649,
0.029577652,
0.0071379235,
-0.0596377738,
0.0244761929,
-0.0537223443,
0.0024398006,
-0.0272913855,
-0.0007067602,
-0.0162187442,
-0.0111976499,
-0.0663912073,
-0.004944175,
-0.0223662704,
0.0134589719,
0.03783435,
-0.0067975386,
-0.0413124152,
-0.015995834,
0.006277483,
0.0445869267,
-0.0215493683,
-0.0179997403,
-0.0695041195,
-0.0361962058,
-0.0424460471,
0.0096004633,
0.0872906521,
0.0335154347,
-0.0153012415,
0.0559168532,
-0.0693569854,
0.0670687705,
0.0170478951,
-0.0078120786,
-0.0312744603,
-0.0129224258,
-0.1091407984,
-0.0334785581,
-0.0320147201,
0.0684355795,
0.008367599,
-0.0385753065,
0.0131419497,
0.0885981098,
-0.0384510346,
-0.0258267168,
-0.0509323329,
0.0555431284,
-0.0432344861,
0.0147047285,
-0.0275468919,
0.0691519007,
0.0089307986,
0.0615839437,
0.0167273302,
0.0182667375,
-0.0191392507,
0.0289774984,
0.0142229721,
-0.0173688605,
-0.002169878,
0.0717032403,
-0.0761210322,
-0.0188292675,
-0.012289877,
0.001215845,
0.0446257219,
-0.003683534,
0.0329202004,
-0.006590324,
0.0301594362,
-0.0307983626,
0.0063362876,
-0.0304744691,
-0.0042741536,
-0.0182071179,
-0.0297638308,
0.1038769707,
0.0266101509,
0.0099922642,
0.012170474,
0.017325297,
-0.0268636867,
0.0180512574,
0.0079242829,
-0.0036935958,
0.0045305435,
0.0064580599,
0.0419149585,
0.0031711366,
0.0267725065,
0.0190586261,
-0.0325342715,
-0.0122206341,
0.0605939031,
-0.0083852783,
0.03974301,
0.0084090056,
-0.0384085327,
0.0132622514,
0.0733805448,
-0.0019517597,
0.0179820005,
0.0213387385,
0.0274411999,
-0.0368842818,
0.015993977,
-0.0006448557,
-0.0754504353,
0.087319158,
0.0022468572,
-0.0066257222,
-0.0133808376,
0.029401226,
-0.0268103741,
-0.0168749653,
0.0507669635,
-0.0062056342,
-0.0100714304,
0.0073259482,
0.0050368663,
0.0317340754,
-0.0411100425,
0.0335886627,
-0.0309412554,
-0.0369456261,
0.0025798145,
-0.0272297245,
0.0196132753,
0.0559326634,
0.0069359071,
-0.0236049183,
-0.0666131601,
-0.0090375859,
0.0560081154,
-0.0387950577,
-0.0387860611,
-0.0174450036,
0.0603290014,
-0.0202804618,
-0.056521453,
0.0007211944,
-0.0125579936,
0.0168703385,
0.0251999777,
0.0328662135,
-0.0404979587,
-0.0116859023,
-0.0239996165,
0.0132088335,
-0.0468422361,
0.0058962265,
0.0403126515,
-0.0056996485,
-0.0391771235,
-0.0292211752,
-0.0154917166,
-0.0287022386,
0.044035852,
-0.0610350631,
-0.0017301489,
0.0553697348,
-0.0495205522,
-0.010548003,
0.0408523344,
-0.056534756,
0.0161889698,
-0.0335506089,
-0.0047834781,
-0.0332417861,
-0.0104867471,
0.0183861144,
0.0139296008,
0.0118449694,
0.0081893886,
0.020920258,
0.0119568966,
0.0036267093,
0.0256616436,
-0.0148971817,
-0.0372644551,
-0.0013957066,
-0.001607146,
-0.0112260366,
-0.0359620303,
0.0112048835,
-0.0257183108,
0.0084497705,
-0.0024998884,
-0.024987448,
-0.0016805697,
-0.0177827626,
-0.0371419825,
-0.1170785502,
0.0088332566,
0.0178084299,
-0.033473663,
0.0172159821,
0.0137993153,
0.0079393433,
-0.0246583801,
-0.0062218593,
0.059117429,
-0.0154752275,
0.0076520941,
0.0135616437,
0.011729951,
0.0496373437,
-0.0173151623,
0.0142054446,
0.0141349221,
0.0209877677,
0.012535031,
0.0164567512,
-0.0308774281,
-0.0280719921,
-0.0090022795,
0.0395711698,
-0.0248326268,
-0.0160358679,
0.026909871,
-0.0344915763,
0.0446893089,
0.0744158179,
0.04915962,
0.0004632694,
0.0357321426,
-0.0296316408,
-0.0488346145,
0.0214437488,
-0.0156809278,
-0.0350931026,
-0.0116379606,
0.0091812229,
-0.0033025013,
0.0394435003,
-0.0212352034,
-0.0091501279,
-0.0213843454,
0.0301944669,
-0.0067703892,
-0.0148184998,
-0.0576082319,
0.0171711165,
-0.0245327614,
-0.017371187,
-0.032403402,
-0.0490113571,
0.0435566083,
0.0234168302,
-0.0089942627,
0.0066146129,
-0.0081970729,
0.0237033349,
0.0627049208,
0.0056911362,
0.0104637882,
0.0379762687,
0.0091956621,
-0.0482978076,
0.0183043275,
0.0470833108,
0.0030585942,
0.0611977279,
-0.0449206457,
0.0121735847,
-0.0281867031,
-0.0518365875,
-0.0684197024,
-0.0330955721,
0.0432226472,
-0.0210749768,
-0.0611886941,
-0.02540561,
-0.0405241065,
-0.0043643424,
0.0723393485,
0.0148483953,
-0.0112668816,
-0.0332943723,
0.0146627091,
0.0243817829,
0.0521623082,
0.1005076692,
-0.0090373904,
-0.0214110278,
0.0263909064,
0.0422438793,
0.0827842355,
-0.0166774224,
-0.0230845585,
0.0322207585,
-0.0067216265,
0.0056704842,
-0.0033175023,
0.0059701423,
0.0397004485,
-0.041789595,
-0.0129402038,
0.0450128093,
-0.0057944022,
-0.0551431142,
-0.0120055657,
0.0070736972,
0.0093532698,
0.0318231955,
0.0282010455,
-0.090221189,
-0.0241735093,
0.0021860516,
0.0611035563,
0.0151082901,
-0.0368012786,
-0.0024584606,
-0.0553376302,
0.0021545251,
0.0194592141,
-0.057839863,
0.0255203266,
0.0137220314,
-0.0400498323,
0.0064766491,
-0.0246217716,
0.0166141018,
-0.0367672667,
-0.0023640941,
0.0267408006,
-0.0135027124,
0.0100995898,
-0.0062897494,
-0.0171160456,
0.0483077876,
0.0115940394,
-0.0385723561,
-0.0185716897,
-0.0189416725,
0.0618716031,
-0.0137937851,
0.0235532057,
-0.0059645013,
0.0609653704,
-0.0011110764,
-0.0341122709,
-0.0165008381,
0.0309717525,
-0.0116756083,
-0.0182563495,
0.0303690135,
0.0622925274,
-0.0143048456,
0.0115520954,
-0.018591132,
-0.058844462,
0.0047051371,
0.0423988067,
0.0082777301,
-0.0390717424,
-0.0389844924,
-0.0101685924,
-0.0026990995,
-0.0617121905,
-0.0103415716,
-0.0026755037,
-0.0059763007,
0.0022727044,
-0.0666704774,
-0.0124950539,
0.0235577915,
0.0908479914,
0.0371406935,
0.0090799602,
-0.037709929,
0.0130593972,
-0.0815565288,
0.003719168,
0.0084416233,
-0.0066067949,
-0.0496755242,
-0.0010463849,
0.0381557159,
-0.0121495407,
0.0023257346,
-0.015377203,
-0.0035508466,
-0.0246079899,
0.0010470162,
0.1034281775,
0.0177306049,
0.0916190445,
0.0035592294,
0.0065004141,
0.0307175852,
0.0285474192,
0.0091298353,
0.0377108678,
0.0345574506,
-0.0129365744,
0.0141584799,
0.0141997412,
-0.0481828302,
-0.0311847758,
0.0231008884,
0.0105012218,
0.0004023585,
0.0108958967,
0.0144827766,
-0.0356630981,
-0.0087121967,
0.0028149229,
0.0388093069,
-0.013274298,
0.0247199629,
0.0449085757,
0.0003368263,
-0.0708328336,
0.0450533479,
0.0309749208,
0.0577247553,
0.0225478131,
0.0019619286,
0.0704034716,
0.0496273786,
-0.0225812644,
0.0039065615,
0.0013643353,
-0.0072844499,
0.0021991041,
0.0339676626,
-0.0311810859,
-0.0055022668,
0.0360684618,
0.0495056547,
-0.0196952485,
0.0584571511,
0.044197768,
-0.0178218558,
-0.0394356959,
0.0627928525,
-0.0224781279,
-0.0801437423,
-0.0050146463,
0.0648142993,
0.0497216471,
0.0469556078,
0.0122830477,
0.0137635982,
0.0325551108,
-0.0342231616,
0.0209204722,
-0.0113166785,
-0.0114059243,
-0.0049327062,
0.0301726498,
0.0368990265,
0.0361258201,
0.0610124692,
-0.0621678345,
0.0531473123,
-0.0567449071,
0.0226230063,
-0.0370931178,
0.0159663968,
-0.0123253502,
-0.0039488086,
-0.0103670945,
0.0382230319,
0.0074122399,
-0.0363296978,
0.0493438281,
0.0071789664,
0.0002399533,
-0.0032802685,
0.0130648371,
-0.0184499212,
0.0073954854,
-0.0141276764,
-0.0137002133,
0.0179404169,
0.0200901087,
0.017351646,
0.0117489826,
-6.58592971e-33,
-0.0436271168,
0.007837248,
0.040051531,
-0.0089837862,
-0.0651067421,
-0.0049734353,
-0.0569394492,
0.0461530387,
0.01009122,
-0.018205354,
-0.004582685,
-0.0060152388,
0.0069370316,
0.0160174798,
0.0601876006,
-0.0149986744,
0.0085611995,
0.0339688882,
-0.0373543017,
0.0280688461,
0.0882524922,
0.0631391928,
0.0187541973,
-0.0429376438,
-0.0248071477,
0.0469428152,
0.0253304895,
0.0144775398,
0.0279738028,
0.0383650474,
-0.0278012473,
-0.0080798343,
0.0253803674,
-0.0183054917,
-0.0288603064,
-0.0319325626,
-0.1285080761,
-0.0350095555,
-0.0325779952,
0.0046057166,
-0.0723329484,
-0.0019290633,
0.0421631597,
-0.0227012336,
0.0140187172,
-0.0334112197,
0.0341688432,
-0.0106197875,
-0.0214915816,
0.0119766211,
-0.0457400642,
-0.0474986918,
0.0070561524,
-0.0093715955,
-0.0216834508,
0.0133807007,
-0.0115747107,
-0.0873688459,
-0.0790421814,
-0.0326167904,
-0.0767177269,
0.0001979792,
0.0052458537,
0.0616593175,
0.0504527204,
0.0545081794,
0.0523591191,
-0.0475514866,
0.0008561788,
0.0092379143,
0.0247356091,
-0.0024009591,
-0.0184994228,
0.0077031162,
0.0314834081,
-0.0242913608,
0.0175410789,
0.0300904494,
0.0337307416,
0.0663002133,
-0.018376125,
0.0126679717,
0.0199695081,
-0.0050046733,
-0.0136483032,
0.0429322459,
-0.029433867,
-0.0157993585,
0.0618940294,
0.0478436425,
-0.038961269,
-0.0109031638,
0.0802562684,
-0.0423271358,
0.0140096815,
0.0293280277,
0.0079922592,
0.0683005005,
0.0191334877,
-0.0055781044,
-0.0381983221,
0.0007232847,
0.0076291547,
-0.0306681357,
0.0132644502,
0.0233752057,
0.0142066432,
0.0810575411,
-0.0215831045,
-0.052202221,
-0.0362180397,
0.0284459386,
0.0427516326,
0.0337452888,
0.0210207757,
0.0296664443,
-0.0446118526,
-0.0247510243,
-0.0299842153,
-0.0367507003,
-0.0564685687,
0.0093848137,
0.0133524593,
0.0171942003,
-0.0309440326,
-0.0097420923,
-0.0629698709,
0.0003002637,
-0.0608342253,
-0.1047443971,
0.0025985308,
0.0444291569,
2.799e-7,
-0.0296032708,
-0.0350784361,
0.000439629,
-0.0766588897,
0.0388784595,
0.0169870052,
-0.0506389253,
0.0049825511,
-0.0127588967,
0.0223205704,
-0.0133810844,
0.0566714294,
0.0139388852,
-0.0154664386,
-0.0496985875,
-0.0343607143,
0.0650023967,
0.0058135567,
-0.0219490211,
-0.0114098145,
0.019484574,
0.021178402,
0.0265983623,
0.0020072097,
0.0631161481,
-0.0975987539,
0.0778186247,
0.0323749781,
0.0761026889,
-0.051261235,
0.0002476874,
0.0211170018,
-0.055675,
0.050806161,
0.0010493289,
-0.0278725773,
-0.0141512966,
0.0028406142,
-0.0192798246,
-0.0658318996,
-0.0073557114,
0.023596596,
0.0154657364,
-0.034005221,
0.0870589018,
-0.076319173,
0.0187759027,
-0.003777114,
-0.0294980127,
-0.0017729837,
-0.0272492804,
0.0402322747,
-0.0378431007,
-0.0183718316,
0.0084198546,
0.0372376032,
-0.0210936759,
-0.0798667818,
0.0220260583,
0.0259354878,
-0.0487442501,
-0.0310382135,
-0.060576614,
0.000332221,
0.0233801343,
-0.0198511016,
-0.0430836827,
1.897778347e-34,
-0.029614605,
-0.0302793905,
0.047686372,
0.0390623063,
-0.0116739273,
-0.0277733542,
0.0190506931,
-0.0210566856,
0.0166718177,
-0.0383934081,
-0.0390977822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03228v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03228v1
|
FedBot: Enhancing Privacy in Chatbots with Federated Learning
| 2023-04-04T23:13:52 | 2023-04-04T23:13:52 |
Addi Ait-Mlouk, Sadi Alawadi, Salman Toor, Andreas Hellander
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Chatbots are mainly data-driven and usually based on utterances that might be
sensitive. However, training deep learning models on shared data can violate
user privacy. Such issues have commonly existed in chatbots since their
inception. In the literature, there have been many approaches to deal with
privacy, such as differential privacy and secure multi-party computation, but
most of them need to have access to users' data. In this context, Federated
Learning (FL) aims to protect data privacy through distributed learning methods
that keep the data in its location. This paper presents Fedbot, a
proof-of-concept (POC) privacy-preserving chatbot that leverages large-scale
customer support data. The POC combines Deep Bidirectional Transformer models
and federated learning algorithms to protect customer data privacy during
collaborative model training. The results of the proof-of-concept showcase the
potential for privacy-preserving chatbots to transform the customer support
industry by delivering personalized and efficient customer service that meets
data privacy regulations and legal requirements. Furthermore, the system is
specifically designed to improve its performance and accuracy over time by
leveraging its ability to learn from previous interactions.
|
[
0.04469423,
0.0908381641,
-0.0248782933,
0.0200862773,
-0.0318783484,
-0.0075787357,
0.1038011089,
-0.0478511639,
0.0507687442,
-0.021774644,
-0.0459024943,
-0.0318824016,
-0.0105575733,
0.0460261405,
-0.013796363,
-0.0259893686,
0.0430883951,
0.0011927017,
-0.0115295192,
-0.0099030742,
-0.0264727138,
-0.0017422551,
-0.0241402071,
0.0361767262,
-0.0586161576,
-0.0624994673,
-0.0400635488,
-0.0086292261,
0.0254177544,
0.03190016,
0.0654449463,
0.0292544384,
0.0109978067,
0.0965222344,
0.0000021885,
-0.0093197776,
-0.0539878532,
0.0191073976,
-0.0488021076,
-0.0127391797,
0.0043128771,
-0.008577833,
-0.0124875819,
0.0338293575,
-0.0494175926,
-0.0035089441,
0.0411724634,
0.0556756854,
0.0842207447,
0.0864823312,
-0.0188659616,
-0.0505488887,
0.0365098193,
-0.0102699632,
-0.0491504371,
-0.0486864895,
-0.0125543093,
-0.0071469052,
-0.0382184871,
0.0044595501,
0.0191127788,
0.026944818,
0.046825204,
-0.0009318016,
-0.0157629829,
0.004186044,
-0.0275652595,
-0.0423055626,
-0.0465463474,
0.0637894422,
-0.0049795536,
0.0112714032,
-0.0164973307,
0.010470951,
0.0343910418,
-0.008127396,
-0.0101836054,
0.0215668324,
-0.0179950204,
-0.0048724851,
-0.0636326671,
0.0045655011,
0.0186719131,
0.0125263128,
-0.0122501748,
0.0583776571,
-0.0118877254,
0.0018830651,
-0.0496249869,
-0.0263170283,
0.0072760782,
-0.0258251783,
0.087581642,
0.0238961149,
-0.0049660471,
-0.0176219735,
-0.0493632592,
-0.0560289696,
-0.0232616533,
-0.0315859988,
-0.0207650624,
-0.0365121588,
-0.0167630278,
0.0437013172,
-0.0102600055,
0.0105131296,
-0.026027441,
0.0420701765,
0.0178274717,
0.0046057417,
-0.0189145785,
-0.0121972552,
-0.0073517757,
0.0689572766,
-0.0408475436,
-0.0080958921,
-0.0350365266,
0.0568179972,
-0.0334951021,
0.0168085583,
-0.0045296601,
0.0392273143,
-0.022578815,
-0.0132879112,
-0.0117902476,
-0.0208676681,
-0.0176297128,
0.0175294075,
0.0302899871,
-0.0520376116,
-0.0018284491,
-0.0064190696,
-0.0333522707,
0.0139918346,
-0.0295585487,
0.0801998675,
0.0073494287,
-0.0130282044,
-0.00538752,
-0.0511777215,
0.0371508636,
-0.0380299203,
0.0243472643,
-0.0201553982,
0.0177962705,
-0.0350579843,
-0.0142710051,
-0.0230030753,
-0.0013082434,
-0.0041408106,
-0.0061008777,
0.0801406801,
0.019341778,
-0.0265844949,
0.0011899529,
0.0410259031,
-0.0060526566,
0.0084555876,
0.0261152685,
0.0375092626,
0.0711393133,
-0.0212427378,
0.0484178439,
-0.0091000674,
0.017977668,
-0.0365099385,
0.0432983488,
0.0058968891,
-0.0240059588,
-0.0039912984,
-0.0204004869,
0.0333003178,
-0.0179066882,
-0.0566097386,
0.0630278438,
0.0625825599,
0.0162824653,
0.0463646539,
-0.0506410077,
0.0405964926,
0.011868285,
-0.0065575871,
-0.0603971593,
0.0151276318,
-0.0464020111,
-0.0589158535,
-0.0531089939,
0.0553052165,
-0.0510986559,
-0.0192616526,
0.0533415712,
-0.087817423,
0.0441463403,
0.0144018605,
-0.0121460585,
0.0342330933,
-0.0192739554,
0.0421847589,
-0.0214156359,
-0.0238435641,
-0.0657624081,
-0.0312748477,
-0.0082232421,
0.054682795,
0.0427488238,
-0.0282300841,
-0.0395191386,
-0.0642929748,
-0.0372523367,
0.0162180867,
-0.0071151406,
0.0253979433,
0.0721695125,
-0.0145010557,
-0.0619573742,
0.0230874792,
0.0028233409,
-0.013602973,
-0.0028634083,
-0.0172481611,
0.0075375191,
0.0488839559,
0.0328822546,
0.0183116943,
-0.0146242063,
-0.013528592,
0.0317077227,
0.0271156989,
0.0465786308,
0.0376902632,
0.0079045417,
-0.0057672225,
0.0208064262,
0.0154250059,
-0.0424956083,
0.006435547,
-0.0143841114,
-0.010301522,
0.004772523,
-0.0440875739,
0.0116730286,
0.0988299176,
-0.0301338471,
0.0173065066,
-0.01679332,
-0.0072702286,
0.0102470936,
-0.0110779302,
0.0258164834,
0.0057025501,
0.0628422499,
0.0130593004,
-0.0078748576,
-0.0512335636,
-0.0668906271,
-0.0669013187,
-0.0009977166,
0.0295809861,
-0.0079748221,
0.0235705543,
0.0081474753,
0.0009445103,
0.0217196047,
0.0148933697,
0.0211192034,
-0.0214997977,
0.0270150527,
-0.0232195295,
0.0161307435,
-0.0174620394,
-0.002601529,
-0.0034558533,
0.0138856489,
0.007082874,
-0.0619358383,
-0.0287499409,
0.0352797173,
-0.0445614718,
0.0164210629,
0.0403027348,
-0.0013535741,
-0.0771432891,
0.0056130779,
-0.0033751163,
0.0143762818,
0.0054766228,
-0.0041968659,
-0.0129343951,
-0.0254999883,
0.0074170996,
-0.0416550525,
0.0299321227,
0.0057702358,
-0.0224767439,
0.0131630842,
0.0320346355,
-0.0404693708,
0.0500513874,
0.0461645424,
0.028551219,
-0.0108110793,
0.0134174312,
-0.0271491725,
0.0104905637,
-0.0362983979,
-0.0260669049,
-0.0273826104,
0.0433070622,
0.0345098414,
-0.0058242381,
-0.0120502245,
-0.031165665,
-0.0369416922,
0.0363088027,
0.033161357,
-0.0586633459,
-0.0251671672,
0.0247236192,
-0.0000562059,
0.0088825272,
0.0130593795,
-0.0676724017,
0.0787306577,
0.0067781047,
0.0274811424,
-0.0152208591,
-0.0486501977,
-0.0335761905,
0.055291377,
-0.0135438088,
0.0486780107,
-0.0069570979,
-0.0585754886,
-0.01607465,
0.040822722,
0.0191903431,
-0.0588044003,
-0.0320972428,
0.0200680401,
-0.0485471375,
0.0105954967,
-0.0585933886,
-0.059487436,
-0.0760720968,
-0.011526905,
0.0060114013,
-0.0011400121,
-0.0603577606,
-0.0376278199,
-0.014680258,
0.0173148029,
0.0171570387,
-0.007297541,
0.0119536482,
-0.0244289283,
-0.0563535504,
-0.020539863,
-0.0132155949,
0.0086977072,
-0.0057691038,
0.0346651599,
0.0560642257,
0.0257843304,
-0.0209278241,
0.0043880059,
-0.0482501946,
-0.0073485714,
-0.0114094112,
-0.0104998322,
-0.0421939567,
0.0392345786,
-0.0243519209,
0.0296369027,
0.0266545247,
0.0102346195,
-0.0435495228,
0.008934034,
0.0061623538,
0.005810142,
-0.025674345,
-0.0031712567,
-0.114516221,
-0.0184604973,
0.022144733,
0.0328208841,
-0.0053691817,
-0.0356396772,
-0.0230477061,
-0.0571618155,
-0.0114266844,
0.0009301636,
-0.0114228306,
-0.0941054374,
-0.0304207373,
-0.0212044939,
0.028611321,
0.0307053141,
-0.0365516171,
0.0062569804,
-0.0409199931,
0.0111950152,
-0.037327569,
-0.0100573199,
-0.0262017082,
-0.0650081113,
0.0365027972,
0.0438541286,
0.0233276039,
0.0087364102,
-0.0141443666,
-0.0499327146,
0.1078137383,
-0.0194732305,
0.0184170566,
0.0665769726,
-0.0265715718,
-0.009454851,
0.017050948,
0.0416061804,
-0.0088683125,
0.0097628525,
0.0041831541,
0.0242230538,
-0.0419064164,
0.0023991491,
-0.0103929807,
0.0131818671,
0.039522972,
0.0399651043,
-0.0179260187,
-0.0297684539,
-0.0277781915,
-0.0132802492,
0.0344924368,
0.0299093146,
-0.0019339131,
0.0192145817,
-0.0173391327,
-0.0332387127,
-0.0486433953,
-0.0146578988,
-0.0003964459,
-0.0145229036,
0.0227773301,
-0.0333059244,
0.0469422676,
0.0083626714,
-0.0022259634,
0.0156933106,
-0.0674324036,
0.040941745,
-0.0600714125,
-0.0057273852,
0.0096821198,
-0.0163483322,
-0.0137773817,
0.0316328593,
-0.0580388606,
-0.0332730487,
0.0299173221,
0.0431383103,
0.0124827186,
0.0105143702,
-0.0121761551,
-0.0304636788,
0.0608597435,
0.0954929814,
-0.0952110067,
-0.0433881953,
0.1100311577,
-0.0212998707,
-0.0130890869,
0.0332260355,
-0.0332618095,
-0.0134003805,
0.0046161637,
-0.0479641482,
-0.0255520828,
-0.059898667,
0.0174938608,
0.0334832408,
0.0372899435,
0.0558759943,
0.0117944134,
-0.0037504593,
0.0486720838,
-0.0196838155,
0.0284231473,
-0.0436921157,
0.0265108142,
0.0075540859,
-0.0318691358,
0.0485024229,
-0.0147402165,
0.0511313006,
-0.011164953,
-0.012120842,
0.0106511265,
0.0262795184,
-0.0140123013,
-0.0068210512,
0.0007876087,
0.0016971669,
0.0532298386,
0.0520664752,
0.0285150763,
0.0034057244,
0.039029289,
-0.0042763399,
0.0373615772,
-0.0480897725,
0.0653050765,
-0.0776854306,
-0.1347952485,
0.0081133535,
0.0416951962,
-0.00293977,
0.0455179811,
-0.0129113356,
-0.063225612,
0.0091460217,
-0.0206396356,
0.0386653803,
-0.031537611,
-0.0031699112,
-0.061776083,
-0.0125401458,
0.0042717466,
0.0409772247,
0.0736899376,
-0.0255755223,
0.0300983898,
-0.0711700246,
-0.0398277044,
-0.0640353933,
-0.009186116,
0.0574809015,
0.0261195935,
0.0000077841,
-0.0187648684,
0.0078285746,
-0.0641759709,
-0.0453151874,
-0.0113620097,
-0.0078837881,
-0.0068843351,
0.0257612281,
-0.0178549867,
-0.0161523782,
-0.0339578427,
-0.0782605708,
0.0259908345,
0.0320826583,
0.0090926317,
-0.0098741082,
-5.745519942e-33,
0.0010483832,
0.0090097766,
-0.0030731177,
0.0865862444,
-0.0076612262,
0.0256172121,
0.0115867844,
0.0213537291,
-0.003142687,
0.0086197341,
-0.0356073827,
0.0553962328,
0.0169400349,
0.0254186951,
-0.0425943844,
-0.0311454441,
0.0628484488,
-0.0452310294,
0.022740664,
0.0607381128,
0.0636392534,
0.0466059111,
0.0240973756,
-0.0982938185,
0.0285338536,
0.0006479088,
-0.0422825105,
0.0162447076,
-0.0390563831,
0.0247103777,
-0.0162413809,
0.0083629312,
-0.0097795753,
-0.035117913,
-0.0135669326,
0.0541494749,
-0.0359466225,
0.0086048599,
-0.0491519012,
0.0322047956,
-0.0235289857,
-0.0445132405,
0.0393678397,
-0.045665171,
0.0107327346,
-0.0011043294,
-0.0059344349,
0.01300037,
0.0175005812,
-0.0154084833,
-0.0181801487,
-0.0143816834,
-0.0597596653,
-0.0449397899,
0.0467595123,
0.065655902,
0.0112773692,
-0.0379092991,
-0.0348193869,
0.0215591993,
-0.0103610465,
-0.0590524003,
0.0210772157,
0.0162347127,
0.0299627744,
0.0450439528,
0.0872407928,
0.0112231206,
-0.043223381,
-0.0116788782,
-0.0123256445,
0.0670553297,
0.0052482369,
0.0152959879,
-0.0045383652,
-0.0684097558,
-0.0360963531,
0.0324627832,
0.0579845011,
-0.0212700982,
0.0118742501,
-0.0064758114,
-0.0479367822,
0.0252218265,
-0.0059131412,
0.0083144857,
0.0028020744,
0.0036257212,
-0.0191955585,
0.0164580774,
-0.0455025434,
-0.0246013701,
0.0353950597,
-0.0888069272,
0.0051400978,
0.0295151677,
0.0745782107,
-0.0234941915,
0.0117844427,
0.0143015943,
-0.0284200851,
-0.0265430901,
-0.0007980419,
-0.0416807719,
0.0408819951,
0.0133991456,
0.073562175,
0.0304324012,
-0.0197532736,
-0.0195550602,
0.0007084598,
0.0339145288,
0.0002503906,
0.0348603763,
0.0262423456,
-0.0004638706,
-0.0069327666,
0.0278258938,
0.0237917844,
0.0532220639,
-0.0411834978,
0.0321887359,
-0.008416512,
-0.0108758658,
0.0142327193,
-0.0178532675,
-0.0456300154,
0.0047062975,
0.0532362312,
-0.0587150455,
-0.0003469044,
-0.0378053114,
2.881e-7,
-0.0211287513,
-0.0042339424,
0.0059565124,
-0.010861462,
0.0352880619,
0.0818028525,
0.0452557988,
0.0779111311,
0.0117104715,
0.0052088117,
0.0115640303,
0.0110957026,
0.0346328504,
0.0009763454,
-0.0440514833,
-0.0703920797,
-0.0270917751,
0.0056420462,
-0.0366741717,
-0.0016205632,
0.0030614701,
0.0699789003,
0.0369281396,
-0.0626429394,
0.0348366834,
0.0205055848,
0.0287639797,
-0.0515070558,
-0.0125205629,
-0.0301901922,
0.0464670174,
0.097519502,
0.0333269723,
-0.0016047356,
-0.0060120295,
0.0395033769,
-0.0281783994,
0.0628024712,
0.0219121519,
-0.007500961,
0.0029176101,
-0.0190897007,
-0.0344213545,
0.0172685552,
0.0457158349,
-0.0441967063,
-0.0451177657,
-0.0180144329,
0.0054900758,
-0.0268923622,
0.0641718954,
-0.0111454483,
-0.0012091823,
0.0162780881,
0.0079072705,
-0.0058908695,
0.0206787605,
-0.0446224324,
0.0314290188,
-0.0357665792,
-0.0443128347,
-0.0249742791,
0.0183054972,
0.0116137424,
0.0185563415,
0.012210439,
0.0375298187,
2.065365156e-34,
0.0113401702,
-0.0030759217,
-0.0017745907,
0.0385464877,
0.0101062143,
-0.0068167439,
0.0687282309,
-0.0210987777,
0.0276902895,
-0.0100925406,
-0.0205866788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02144v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02144v1
|
A Data Fusion Framework for Multi-Domain Morality Learning
| 2023-04-04T22:05:02 | 2023-04-04T22:05:02 |
Siyi Guo, Negar Mokhberian, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models can be trained to recognize the moral sentiment of text,
creating new opportunities to study the role of morality in human life. As
interest in language and morality has grown, several ground truth datasets with
moral annotations have been released. However, these datasets vary in the
method of data collection, domain, topics, instructions for annotators, etc.
Simply aggregating such heterogeneous datasets during training can yield models
that fail to generalize well. We describe a data fusion framework for training
on multiple heterogeneous datasets that improve performance and
generalizability. The model uses domain adversarial training to align the
datasets in feature space and a weighted loss function to deal with label
shift. We show that the proposed framework achieves state-of-the-art
performance in different datasets compared to prior works in morality
inference.
|
[
0.0380605496,
0.1122026145,
-0.0132144848,
0.0360877328,
-0.0351659022,
0.0182190146,
0.027586218,
-0.0544104949,
0.0235383604,
-0.0343368091,
-0.0489734374,
-0.032709524,
-0.0132185435,
-0.0189893153,
-0.0105838375,
-0.0303738266,
0.0310416594,
0.0608900115,
0.0463874452,
-0.0170059446,
0.0217890311,
0.0439252667,
0.0249333251,
0.0089925574,
-0.0111119449,
0.0064249691,
-0.0000660579,
-0.0065762065,
0.0853951499,
-0.005595699,
0.054443121,
0.0327645168,
0.0337799303,
0.0318808891,
0.0000018229,
-0.0366671607,
-0.0178074073,
0.0034017635,
0.0555184968,
-0.0110043976,
0.0735136271,
-0.0174600631,
-0.0038287172,
0.0318209119,
-0.0590745136,
0.0112529714,
0.0385670401,
0.074229151,
0.0530288965,
0.0727461502,
-0.0136936726,
-0.0483538695,
-0.002993111,
-0.046637848,
-0.0405747555,
0.0019174444,
0.0345252641,
0.0278217606,
-0.0284767039,
-0.0119566265,
-0.0164960697,
-0.0129715037,
0.0146861225,
0.0066370652,
-0.0271634553,
0.0034673186,
-0.0034441818,
-0.0214004144,
-0.0350846648,
0.0355104282,
0.0104027418,
-0.0037220425,
0.0136836944,
0.0098664099,
0.016605353,
-0.0250394363,
0.0187425166,
0.0021587515,
-0.0224216655,
0.0262225047,
-0.0137087544,
-0.0093477722,
0.0405985527,
0.0589822009,
-0.0045866929,
-0.0140079334,
-0.0229891967,
-0.0155739998,
0.0519878268,
0.0085019553,
-0.0976248011,
-0.0156722255,
0.0371917747,
-0.0213270951,
0.0352049917,
0.0115456739,
-0.0487481505,
-0.0001087223,
0.0261921305,
-0.0290159229,
0.0283345841,
0.0028829742,
-0.0238639973,
0.0474121533,
0.0499520972,
0.0088225892,
-0.0044424189,
0.0444614068,
-0.0366694592,
0.0036253033,
-0.0189922303,
0.0352654681,
0.0375203155,
0.0284000263,
-0.003659918,
0.0599950142,
-0.0687972456,
-0.0174329355,
-0.0614361241,
-0.0124066006,
-0.028276246,
0.0123697994,
-0.009567244,
-0.0217168313,
-0.0276043396,
0.0146940108,
-0.0375861153,
0.0621273741,
0.0073860059,
0.003400733,
0.0108802011,
-0.0116323922,
-0.0295173321,
-0.0084469216,
0.054959327,
0.1154514849,
0.0120870071,
-0.0222970489,
-0.0358705223,
0.0091511318,
-0.0472836494,
-0.0668507516,
0.0034807816,
-0.0313190334,
0.0444794074,
-0.0292837638,
-0.0566658229,
-0.0822718963,
0.0148666305,
0.0211264472,
-0.0174155626,
0.0832045004,
0.0316673964,
-0.0304649621,
0.0057445914,
0.0307979137,
-0.0158857126,
0.088880606,
-0.0137610184,
0.0539895631,
0.0190840419,
0.0267003421,
-0.0595986843,
-0.0217481218,
0.0481920168,
0.0438303687,
-0.0395821482,
0.0103416564,
0.0119916731,
-0.0003216088,
-0.006974265,
0.0069799158,
0.0025679257,
-0.0429691635,
0.0192619991,
0.0386638567,
-0.0130743757,
0.0085721286,
-0.0020807672,
0.0154427979,
-0.0100539541,
-0.0037541778,
-0.0711974725,
0.0129242064,
0.0064469525,
-0.0198900979,
0.0092441216,
0.0754086375,
-0.0028839717,
-0.0551624149,
0.0047604428,
-0.036551401,
0.0185821727,
-0.0091899252,
0.0311443713,
0.0175526235,
-0.0380400792,
-0.0842219293,
0.0875346735,
-0.0617091581,
-0.0209058002,
0.0092898486,
0.0699096173,
0.0373044871,
0.031811554,
-0.0441268496,
-0.0082707452,
-0.0532465391,
0.0399975963,
-0.0140483622,
0.0094754053,
-0.0059739309,
0.0198045168,
-0.0545751303,
-0.0526669957,
-0.0127697457,
0.0062057534,
0.0686272308,
-0.0323545188,
-0.0070664329,
0.0253598429,
0.008738514,
0.0045230035,
0.0376478508,
-0.008600737,
0.0427665263,
-0.0163051933,
0.0408333279,
0.0417685807,
-0.0089068543,
-0.0295415279,
-0.0420646481,
0.0129115395,
-0.0136796841,
-0.0341353677,
-0.0053203544,
-0.0057606366,
-0.0183368642,
0.0384804644,
-0.0883506164,
-0.0414347202,
0.0222832486,
-0.039891813,
0.0371312536,
-0.0479365997,
0.009678157,
0.0085349362,
-0.0169782098,
-0.0156895723,
-0.0392472371,
0.0105273873,
-0.0185219105,
0.0941617638,
-0.0397164002,
0.0264699534,
-0.0392295718,
-0.0346852168,
0.0511153825,
0.0242398791,
0.0143638561,
-0.0490531996,
-0.0364374742,
0.041128777,
0.0235987995,
0.0191562735,
-0.0009794278,
-0.0587912314,
-0.0671584308,
0.0100600384,
-0.0088211838,
0.0147998733,
-0.0369950719,
-0.0134699075,
0.0057663568,
0.0235767625,
-0.0483262986,
-0.0065770205,
-0.0471717417,
0.008056066,
0.0321278311,
-0.0071626497,
0.0269716512,
-0.0437755026,
-0.0046756389,
-0.0424810201,
0.0112535637,
-0.0005896001,
0.0059730625,
0.0021603007,
0.0564678833,
-0.0826240554,
0.0462263823,
-0.0185219552,
-0.0721493363,
-0.0273542237,
0.0196420699,
-0.014820843,
0.0866232067,
0.0430575013,
-0.0135875624,
0.0317739248,
0.0450265519,
-0.0201606527,
0.0084210355,
-0.0080572022,
0.0335303508,
-0.0321708396,
0.022646809,
-0.0070394035,
0.0596210957,
0.00576076,
-0.0235299766,
-0.0291519668,
0.0160415862,
-0.0111889932,
-0.075455755,
0.0043682451,
-0.0048711719,
0.022825066,
0.0041292054,
-0.049712114,
-0.0579525232,
0.0692708269,
0.0470534489,
0.0125956014,
-0.0180051494,
-0.0342111066,
-0.0145748472,
0.0079186549,
0.0038062301,
0.0153350178,
0.008465182,
0.0075031687,
-0.0331598297,
0.0138363158,
0.0454200245,
-0.034855973,
0.0793214589,
-0.0026112085,
0.0255274735,
-0.0166035071,
-0.0721114501,
-0.0375138894,
-0.058280319,
-0.0129170511,
-0.0676434562,
-0.00857432,
0.0084953131,
-0.0252339467,
-0.043368876,
-0.0154801672,
-0.0338022374,
-0.022450082,
-0.0047480487,
0.0095184753,
-0.0393089727,
0.024807997,
-0.026814457,
0.0140595939,
-0.0075918096,
-0.0013955169,
0.0282953717,
-0.0117209684,
0.0004044796,
-0.0037822356,
0.0026963402,
0.0020072006,
0.033903297,
0.017027637,
-0.0100757778,
0.0297792535,
0.0170708355,
0.0551329032,
0.054569263,
0.019954659,
-0.0383697227,
-0.0085273916,
0.0155928684,
0.0130981114,
0.0192606393,
-0.0214184467,
-0.0764727592,
-0.0230438206,
-0.0124784689,
-0.0055015865,
-0.0169072449,
-0.0359260216,
0.0001285306,
-0.0769152567,
-0.0234481487,
0.0118525894,
-0.0136874104,
-0.0559258498,
0.0014704616,
0.0087066777,
-0.0466297194,
0.0285247136,
-0.0552386381,
0.0110063339,
-0.018213138,
0.0005316425,
0.0639729127,
-0.0166409295,
0.0342590734,
-0.0396008976,
0.024317652,
0.0862743706,
0.094324097,
-0.0366267338,
-0.0334061347,
-0.0008801875,
0.0475785956,
-0.0259358287,
0.0286217071,
0.0786205903,
-0.0480668619,
-0.022077119,
-0.0183819495,
0.0587312281,
-0.014228873,
-0.0110523328,
0.0124715399,
0.029249277,
0.0210431926,
-0.0133920936,
-0.0240022354,
0.0424796157,
0.0219930317,
0.0349398628,
-0.0302927103,
-0.0489398949,
0.0394129716,
-0.0406679064,
-0.0098622981,
-0.0237925164,
-0.0370351076,
0.0045143273,
-0.0252441186,
-0.0115304068,
-0.0300968084,
-0.0394010209,
-0.0186360031,
0.0231246818,
0.0430682749,
-0.0545229502,
0.0019012612,
0.0203291476,
-0.0402460545,
0.038406644,
0.0075636189,
0.0282526836,
0.0145438816,
0.0060056201,
0.0334415883,
-0.008643751,
-0.0218743775,
-0.0195776485,
-0.0136562577,
-0.0531090088,
0.0379733108,
0.021615535,
0.004408319,
0.0256555695,
-0.0393419787,
0.0549690984,
0.0119533697,
0.1153367311,
-0.0843154117,
0.0138279404,
0.0907068551,
0.0065547819,
0.0005634087,
0.0045612953,
-0.0507078432,
0.0383560993,
0.0264421031,
-0.0760207102,
-0.0260898229,
-0.0017841555,
0.0188044384,
-0.0334245339,
0.0442926176,
0.0197675023,
-0.0223645754,
-0.0567551292,
-0.0213454403,
0.0006120494,
-0.0290572215,
-0.0153872659,
-0.0137225976,
0.0185037814,
-0.0335246511,
-0.0161199141,
0.0347292535,
0.0025794469,
-0.0021931517,
-0.0492741279,
0.0055118874,
0.0528649837,
0.0736652538,
-0.0292066578,
-0.0138104977,
-0.0169803277,
0.0042791637,
0.0297830887,
0.0076916101,
-0.0243450068,
0.0385412611,
0.0394529104,
0.0181979295,
0.0450653769,
0.0169419404,
-0.0555656403,
0.0297285095,
-0.0700538531,
-0.0489212424,
0.0188936479,
0.0084813777,
-0.0035899959,
-0.0026703356,
-0.0063973228,
-0.0137044247,
0.0520840101,
-0.0351452604,
-0.0115303108,
-0.0129815359,
0.008399222,
-0.0268125404,
-0.012842007,
0.0207244828,
-0.0306795724,
0.0385914929,
0.038521681,
-0.0218528304,
-0.036419671,
-0.0503330678,
0.0532886535,
-0.0200577136,
0.0082067037,
0.0212220624,
-0.06656304,
-0.0376523025,
-0.0180999488,
-0.0024244166,
-0.0097839553,
0.018001806,
-0.0095738107,
0.0470306724,
-0.038307298,
0.0524429195,
-0.0193958003,
0.0125797559,
-0.0151586756,
0.0058383537,
-0.0445305593,
-5.208488368e-33,
-0.0330804251,
0.0191013925,
-0.0505071282,
-0.0075900955,
-0.0233747941,
-0.0284390915,
0.0431362651,
-0.008315172,
-0.0342312567,
0.0527106225,
0.0188424177,
0.0586346127,
-0.01116338,
-0.0004983977,
-0.0056680776,
-0.0515478812,
0.032654535,
0.0307697002,
-0.00408446,
-0.0037064168,
0.0225666128,
0.0074588065,
0.0629177392,
-0.1268544644,
0.0240566377,
0.0484799221,
-0.0360978022,
-0.0236856453,
0.0046487208,
0.0157451611,
0.0223356728,
0.0587107278,
0.0097242864,
0.0050258515,
-0.0019241893,
0.0537899584,
-0.0322815627,
-0.0113965664,
0.0250836089,
0.0037880091,
-0.0123468805,
-0.0466337241,
0.0000246634,
0.0091412514,
0.023530351,
-0.0329442136,
0.0484076478,
-0.0296012238,
-0.0011318085,
-0.0498795621,
-0.0493540429,
0.0072684004,
-0.0354270935,
-0.032402657,
-0.0525635481,
0.0308583472,
0.0536216274,
0.0551259816,
-0.00724976,
0.0317865685,
-0.0182933025,
0.0050916132,
-0.0172518939,
-0.0571473688,
0.0348621048,
0.0916398317,
-0.0181188583,
0.0331325158,
-0.025000738,
-0.0039026572,
0.0208965056,
0.0261387583,
0.0219385382,
0.0908063352,
-0.0023517695,
-0.0642150715,
-0.0490413569,
0.0087710712,
0.0336687714,
-0.0429575369,
0.0013234175,
0.0100604314,
-0.0070298905,
0.0232479312,
-0.0217069685,
-0.0722362101,
-0.0095320931,
-0.0099709155,
-0.0058586495,
-0.0287032016,
-0.0296213608,
-0.0099056531,
-0.0518167764,
-0.0635088906,
0.0015923224,
0.0737507045,
-0.006070002,
-0.0242859069,
0.0031240161,
0.0057140393,
-0.0483527593,
-0.0451168492,
0.0117777856,
0.0234686621,
0.0488519073,
-0.0329413675,
0.0933105573,
0.0022665211,
-0.0539235026,
-0.0263467561,
-0.0141212661,
0.0360776931,
0.0138302008,
0.021873448,
0.0000469182,
0.0274225269,
0.0006056599,
0.0089213988,
0.0029054782,
-0.0008673917,
-0.0316718519,
-0.0083843647,
-0.0033628542,
0.0330202021,
-0.0147591624,
-0.0374202318,
-0.0130064646,
-0.0198838878,
0.0281175654,
-0.0693173856,
-0.021943355,
-0.0003873773,
2.457e-7,
-0.0081931325,
-0.0171099771,
0.0245591588,
-0.0029258837,
-0.0580227412,
0.0755480081,
0.0303212572,
0.0724460259,
0.0207449496,
-0.0535998344,
-0.0320017412,
0.0097383317,
0.0619495474,
0.0067818682,
-0.0526821129,
-0.016055407,
-0.0034977132,
-0.0138387568,
-0.0280162841,
0.0158273149,
0.0143220304,
0.1472134739,
0.0771757439,
-0.0213865917,
0.0370542258,
0.0417133421,
0.052704405,
-0.0390485451,
-0.0492033735,
-0.016646238,
-0.0227283463,
-0.0159857646,
-0.0192326345,
0.0146752466,
-0.0049377983,
0.0206735097,
0.0166820958,
0.0418145135,
0.0043231635,
-0.0342932232,
-0.0173628125,
-0.0193781219,
-0.0250190608,
0.0492805019,
0.0786969736,
-0.0641642734,
-0.0366506353,
-0.0454406291,
-0.0104173897,
-0.0011325651,
0.0384112522,
0.0449661314,
0.0022943718,
0.0060506845,
-0.0003180285,
-0.0037143994,
0.0158617757,
-0.0528239012,
0.0110919196,
0.0148677649,
0.0118566277,
-0.0614643097,
0.0537264198,
0.0451213047,
0.045793999,
-0.0575687066,
0.0162311681,
1.994260375e-34,
0.0218566265,
-0.0561424792,
0.0078104255,
-0.0182369426,
0.026172949,
0.0091763623,
-0.0067720315,
-0.0266607068,
0.0361762233,
0.0260050949,
0.0128807798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02138v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02138v3
|
Geotechnical Parrot Tales (GPT): Harnessing Large Language Models in geotechnical engineering
| 2023-04-04T21:47:41 | 2023-06-21T15:55:24 |
Krishna Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.geo-ph, I.2.7; J.2.6
|
The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs), such as OpenAI's
ChatGPT, could revolutionize various industries, including geotechnical
engineering. However, GPT models can sometimes generate plausible-sounding but
false outputs, leading to hallucinations. In this article, we discuss the
importance of prompt engineering in mitigating these risks and harnessing the
full potential of GPT for geotechnical applications. We explore the challenges
and pitfalls associated with LLMs and highlight the role of context in ensuring
accurate and valuable responses. Furthermore, we examine the development of
context-specific search engines and the potential of LLMs to become a natural
interface for complex tasks, such as data analysis and design. We also develop
a unified interface using natural language to handle complex geotechnical
engineering tasks and data analysis. By integrating GPT into geotechnical
engineering workflows, professionals can streamline their work and develop
sustainable and resilient infrastructure systems for the future.
|
[
0.0035668891,
0.0898079127,
-0.0348381735,
0.0471063703,
-0.0367265753,
-0.0401333608,
-0.0038195387,
-0.0153483339,
0.0063065127,
-0.0313319601,
0.0116310874,
0.0310877506,
0.0231567658,
0.0286912117,
-0.0109659387,
-0.1010500416,
-0.0001364177,
-0.0393623374,
0.0173954722,
0.0325987749,
-0.0292098038,
0.0182816125,
-0.0154805947,
0.0481945425,
-0.016073687,
-0.0031925277,
-0.0313383341,
-0.0045461687,
0.0214246996,
-0.0455070026,
0.0191304553,
0.0413875952,
0.0075496575,
0.0354284942,
0.0000023721,
-0.0403740406,
0.001266585,
0.0324208401,
0.0114474334,
0.0226498265,
0.0136884833,
-0.0213356968,
-0.030583404,
-0.0084042978,
-0.0292937886,
-0.0068403124,
0.063868843,
0.0021222841,
0.0399478748,
0.0187604465,
-0.0047976901,
-0.0523249619,
0.0110134492,
0.0099795498,
0.0257384423,
-0.0447002798,
0.0060391775,
0.0542263538,
0.0860444158,
0.0922146812,
-0.0045795259,
0.0244203713,
0.0170467943,
-0.0061545926,
-0.0270554107,
0.0068340017,
-0.0019988182,
0.0036935259,
-0.0099822097,
0.0508101247,
0.0484644286,
-0.0089776618,
-0.0139882173,
-0.0281205755,
-0.0284803323,
0.035776183,
-0.0636992455,
0.0586418808,
-0.0323116519,
-0.0032568881,
-0.0052328422,
-0.0244909953,
0.005839943,
0.0146778319,
-0.0462098829,
0.0603536405,
-0.0318547823,
-0.0057939449,
-0.026673533,
0.0247110091,
0.0239332374,
-0.0298226066,
-0.0014833652,
0.0392741561,
-0.0162757207,
-0.0007396461,
0.0151279606,
0.0055241655,
0.0672262907,
-0.0584861152,
-0.0050597773,
0.0776566193,
-0.0195973553,
0.0427600443,
-0.0087838164,
0.017922651,
-0.0089120464,
0.0105369017,
0.0139881736,
-0.0092208022,
-0.0432926714,
-0.0433347709,
-0.0360288806,
-0.0193040203,
-0.0305156931,
0.017198896,
0.0317253731,
0.033347249,
-0.0082631409,
0.0093410192,
-0.0206620209,
0.01973054,
-0.0234535541,
-0.0487285815,
-0.0055257156,
-0.0276184212,
-0.0274801813,
0.0538791046,
0.0223090854,
-0.0604879409,
0.0056475434,
0.0411186293,
0.013406829,
0.0081188874,
-0.0411039852,
0.0610999539,
0.0253425352,
0.0064019458,
-0.0656260997,
-0.0640381873,
0.0177775212,
-0.0055936421,
-0.0374518819,
-0.0603420697,
-0.0090913773,
0.006132728,
-0.0251250267,
-0.0072199288,
0.0028574178,
0.0159229673,
-0.0225308351,
0.0520104542,
-0.0830144361,
-0.0221492033,
0.0602575839,
0.0498546585,
0.0143329175,
0.0895011127,
0.0236062109,
0.0535838567,
0.0081408285,
0.0045994204,
-0.0005732071,
0.0265009552,
-0.0203664266,
0.0012072333,
-0.0182331707,
0.0191231109,
0.0300472304,
0.0268625095,
-0.0189302284,
0.0323801227,
0.0097909747,
0.0462542698,
0.0720979348,
0.0355855413,
0.0059137563,
0.0579743348,
0.061745137,
0.057882566,
-0.0129387528,
-0.0417045318,
-0.0204032063,
-0.0163881313,
-0.0484064631,
-0.0044959392,
-0.0108000645,
0.0576677322,
0.0012266516,
-0.0395496599,
-0.0395900905,
0.0043036006,
-0.0001453027,
-0.0179785527,
0.0199429039,
0.016708307,
0.0173597503,
-0.0056567369,
-0.005349264,
-0.0110031357,
-0.020552896,
-0.0158895925,
-0.0105180647,
0.0352473445,
-0.0001251232,
-0.0493333414,
-0.0117028402,
0.008613456,
-0.0037488907,
0.044935897,
0.0403088517,
0.02042876,
-0.0346131846,
-0.0326629616,
-0.0165000856,
-0.0038702691,
0.0470912308,
-0.019677639,
0.0102768056,
0.0647296906,
0.0089997705,
-0.0345750302,
-0.0831179395,
0.0226832051,
-0.0162891746,
-0.0372649096,
-0.026255846,
0.0205118768,
-0.0330515988,
0.0203046668,
0.0010913656,
0.0229812935,
0.0357706808,
0.0055743097,
-0.0598091409,
0.0272959415,
-0.0146495355,
0.0781011283,
0.0234583896,
-0.0390148088,
0.0269265082,
-0.0400405675,
-0.0261376891,
-0.0258120745,
0.0227484256,
-0.0381758139,
0.1116319373,
-0.0045249052,
0.0263013933,
-0.0089652827,
-0.0180558302,
-0.0774792433,
0.0430455208,
0.0383269452,
0.0035999443,
-0.0245241094,
-0.013392142,
0.041794043,
-0.0456903651,
-0.0312285665,
0.0418982208,
-0.0318187438,
0.0087398943,
0.0036117884,
0.0425070301,
-0.0228859056,
-0.022400545,
-0.0990137383,
-0.0544150844,
-0.0175549444,
0.0414239466,
0.0410810821,
0.0053039822,
-0.0422010534,
0.0046326988,
0.0245729648,
-0.000742693,
-0.019582795,
-0.0117269754,
0.0341533385,
-0.0059338934,
-0.0202885307,
-0.0344419926,
-0.0134814316,
-0.0396471173,
0.0436129011,
0.0832282081,
-0.0531716347,
-0.075872004,
0.0393623188,
-0.0063630273,
-0.0512477569,
0.0073354943,
-0.0329537541,
0.0333744586,
-0.0007573197,
0.0412594527,
-0.0177201759,
-0.0176930819,
0.0730570182,
0.0208584573,
-0.0439905822,
-0.0446865186,
-0.0184066929,
-0.0052313944,
-0.0301265661,
0.0180508588,
-0.0321868472,
0.0219342094,
0.0080395099,
-0.0183665603,
0.0082451757,
0.00736999,
0.0771466866,
-0.0097489506,
-0.0030722811,
0.0327954218,
-0.0453783311,
0.0097026331,
0.0643018186,
0.0098471632,
-0.0413575955,
0.0412641838,
-0.0201082341,
0.0025389546,
-0.0815875158,
-0.0226283353,
-0.0823322907,
0.0832614526,
-0.0334134623,
0.00427465,
0.0749583095,
-0.0064267628,
0.0163830109,
-0.0145129282,
-0.0104230139,
-0.0011539641,
-0.0174215771,
-0.0772713423,
0.0319139287,
0.0190020781,
-0.0312898308,
-0.024927564,
0.0048442292,
-0.0402210727,
0.0241174679,
0.0302265771,
-0.0476752594,
0.0148142017,
0.0410663374,
0.0431116857,
0.002965827,
-0.001500788,
-0.0103420764,
-0.0222384427,
0.0055545978,
0.0096652731,
0.0845180601,
0.0244039614,
0.0457673259,
0.0085901227,
0.0340833031,
0.017334817,
0.0022662154,
-0.0433246233,
-0.0281198025,
0.0221376978,
0.0081522819,
-0.0244579744,
0.0326165222,
-0.0145195536,
-0.0771635473,
-0.0305608045,
0.029779708,
0.0298657436,
-0.0318216644,
0.0084029827,
-0.0340357013,
0.0268784445,
-0.0217281133,
-0.021270128,
-0.077594988,
0.0065427236,
-0.0053241593,
-0.0148014883,
0.0309257247,
0.0037203429,
-0.0051193563,
-0.0751867071,
0.0928012282,
-0.007922912,
-0.0581892505,
0.0089928331,
-0.057919018,
-0.0065987287,
0.0006586122,
-0.0798483193,
0.001860035,
0.0030642559,
0.0330314115,
0.0184575263,
-0.0684430003,
-0.0645025969,
-0.011359646,
-0.0691132918,
0.0322015882,
0.0705622733,
0.0276870485,
-0.0196818151,
-0.0212522466,
0.0551426783,
0.020075582,
0.0232169088,
-0.0406154618,
0.0056014429,
0.0559973046,
0.002536667,
-0.0100314375,
-0.0446226038,
-0.0906421468,
-0.0233319309,
0.0260803606,
0.1108194068,
-0.0659563467,
0.0484908111,
-0.0668534786,
-0.0007548367,
0.0592427738,
-0.0009853233,
-0.0147713302,
-0.0238009412,
-0.0570416674,
-0.0878319517,
-0.0242036749,
-0.0103438217,
-0.066475004,
0.0246734619,
0.0217879638,
-0.0245498344,
-0.0415985249,
-0.0375498459,
0.0525401831,
0.0284388755,
0.0356283747,
-0.0153605714,
0.0651451498,
0.0045768414,
-0.017176237,
0.0215824172,
-0.0146283237,
0.0347422436,
-0.0275100823,
0.0138622904,
0.0456013791,
-0.0477716252,
-0.0039757718,
0.0155853955,
-0.0333627202,
-0.0446207337,
0.0285320636,
0.0469292812,
0.0424744822,
-0.0688661784,
-0.0233334992,
-0.0229467377,
-0.0128607936,
0.0297717396,
-0.0608520135,
-0.0289689656,
-0.0090876231,
0.0366413668,
0.016148312,
-0.0125169335,
0.0022223287,
-0.0211705361,
-0.0336253382,
0.0193948951,
-0.0291900188,
-0.0644577518,
0.0061929245,
0.0398251861,
0.045105774,
0.0293735676,
-0.0151457097,
0.0137500782,
0.0135958251,
-0.021582095,
-0.0093893455,
-0.0082470113,
0.0460493043,
-0.0311817434,
-0.0238348804,
0.00059411,
0.0229879431,
-0.0060434705,
0.0469914936,
-0.0205649137,
0.0384559445,
0.0000455431,
-0.0348669216,
0.0122617735,
0.0387901589,
-0.0303697456,
-0.0036207053,
0.0038260382,
0.0558189005,
0.0228676312,
0.0046765557,
0.0224355627,
-0.0110033955,
-0.0026795764,
0.013257903,
-0.0148912724,
-0.1358534843,
-0.0204039216,
-0.0048988205,
0.0384077057,
0.0483631045,
-0.0004137944,
-0.0263686888,
0.0122490078,
-0.0199572667,
0.0074102446,
0.0357715748,
-0.063174367,
0.0212157406,
0.0017698595,
-0.0456011854,
-0.073526144,
0.0192121658,
0.0067660678,
0.0147974705,
-0.0206476431,
-0.0173833929,
0.0005417296,
-0.0302930698,
0.0154456664,
0.0318034738,
-0.0239818115,
-0.0177382398,
-0.088602297,
-0.0295430999,
-0.0359248519,
0.009646791,
-0.0086399522,
-0.0292237662,
0.0230776444,
0.074702926,
0.0221828911,
-0.0350199603,
0.0052686841,
-0.0174736045,
-0.0706511065,
0.0056476328,
-0.0326328762,
-6.36273272e-33,
-0.0224310234,
-0.0638542324,
0.0415040813,
0.0202395637,
0.0150046153,
-0.0285450611,
-0.01563753,
0.0252998751,
-0.0391392037,
-0.0176852606,
-0.0082150251,
0.0115127657,
0.0104174856,
0.0017553314,
0.0730481669,
0.0423991755,
0.0137624247,
0.0205860361,
-0.0099108685,
-0.0277860705,
0.036088299,
-0.0141322091,
0.0572468489,
-0.1359681785,
0.0547633991,
0.0222413857,
-0.0328768454,
-0.0093967421,
-0.0220203847,
0.0353720896,
-0.0178622827,
0.0560741052,
0.0285755079,
0.0041765324,
-0.0370248519,
0.0089307763,
-0.0474757291,
-0.0475099087,
0.0073268265,
0.0228655804,
0.0100055533,
-0.026870653,
0.0011746078,
-0.0089081926,
-0.0429144502,
-0.0100422176,
0.0354878977,
-0.0097335465,
0.0045886501,
0.0413973033,
-0.0977258757,
0.0245119222,
0.0205895789,
-0.0017585995,
-0.0080904486,
0.0275200978,
0.0032087665,
0.0257166792,
-0.0457710959,
0.0280639548,
0.0419919789,
-0.0071552186,
0.0529218093,
0.0003157144,
-0.01494582,
0.0487677567,
-0.0025391129,
0.0170228854,
-0.0317858793,
-0.0584218614,
0.014710783,
0.065295279,
0.013446779,
0.0335104838,
0.0298799537,
-0.017291585,
-0.0595526434,
0.0313472971,
-0.0212948751,
0.043819584,
0.0293866489,
0.0269944575,
-0.0328761563,
-0.0366230868,
-0.0244951788,
0.02371406,
-0.0155729745,
0.017181877,
-0.0149487313,
-0.0001753278,
-0.0076512331,
0.0375556611,
-0.0044496795,
-0.0364083685,
0.0071270317,
0.0402840711,
-0.0331334732,
0.0070524341,
-0.0085223299,
0.0416059829,
-0.0427816398,
0.006697447,
-0.0423443019,
0.0436819084,
0.0344047137,
0.0185843408,
-0.0566664189,
0.0456802435,
-0.0558846556,
0.023616977,
-0.0180087425,
-0.0265416671,
0.0077665504,
-0.0264055841,
0.0415089242,
-0.028278023,
0.0058378349,
0.0272867326,
0.0309344772,
-0.0080282642,
-0.045326829,
0.0093729701,
-0.0687220618,
0.0000740912,
-0.0060418868,
-0.0134910885,
-0.0032441553,
-0.0467466488,
0.0244599674,
-0.0346216299,
-0.01102468,
0.0422293805,
3.106e-7,
0.019207418,
0.0619571246,
0.0535343401,
0.0492074601,
0.0468352325,
0.0398109667,
-0.0058039459,
0.0015490658,
-0.0044117719,
0.0148857348,
0.000383779,
-0.0060586724,
0.041809544,
0.0585415326,
-0.0901806802,
0.0112509811,
-0.0077582467,
-0.041599527,
-0.0944870859,
-0.0172603,
0.0885493904,
0.024038963,
-0.0233562458,
0.0183163881,
-0.0054727974,
-0.0551022328,
0.0010744451,
-0.0300614014,
0.0413022228,
0.047568921,
-0.0048060426,
-0.0134270992,
-0.0086914673,
-0.0012256973,
0.0048306095,
-0.0312031396,
0.0266940687,
0.0194788873,
-0.0041563413,
0.0182595178,
0.0010700201,
-0.0921664312,
0.035111282,
-0.0743476078,
0.0008330948,
-0.0143340128,
-0.0079671619,
0.0146545116,
0.024670748,
-0.0159768984,
0.0254515819,
0.008542384,
0.0053654285,
-0.0562023148,
-0.0106336111,
0.0178738218,
-0.0068582739,
-0.0338278189,
0.018379353,
0.0655474141,
-0.0484643579,
-0.0269466471,
-0.0304231327,
-0.0049772877,
0.0389898941,
0.0002296445,
0.0080978442,
3.029552458e-34,
-0.0095066167,
-0.0041407412,
0.0177315194,
0.0158860404,
0.0240538251,
0.0705048218,
0.0527913719,
0.0299808439,
0.0195984542,
-0.0544130914,
-0.0104979947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02080v1
|
Scalable and Accurate Self-supervised Multimodal Representation Learning without Aligned Video and Text Data
| 2023-04-04T19:11:05 | 2023-04-04T19:11:05 |
Vladislav Lialin, Stephen Rawls, David Chan, Shalini Ghosh, Anna Rumshisky, Wael Hamza
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Scaling up weakly-supervised datasets has shown to be highly effective in the
image-text domain and has contributed to most of the recent state-of-the-art
computer vision and multimodal neural networks. However, existing large-scale
video-text datasets and mining techniques suffer from several limitations, such
as the scarcity of aligned data, the lack of diversity in the data, and the
difficulty of collecting aligned data. Currently popular video-text data mining
approach via automatic speech recognition (ASR) used in HowTo100M provides
low-quality captions that often do not refer to the video content. Other mining
approaches do not provide proper language descriptions (video tags) and are
biased toward short clips (alt text). In this work, we show how recent advances
in image captioning allow us to pre-train high-quality video models without any
parallel video-text data. We pre-train several video captioning models that are
based on an OPT language model and a TimeSformer visual backbone. We fine-tune
these networks on several video captioning datasets. First, we demonstrate that
image captioning pseudolabels work better for pre-training than the existing
HowTo100M ASR captions. Second, we show that pre-training on both images and
videos produces a significantly better network (+4 CIDER on MSR-VTT) than
pre-training on a single modality. Our methods are complementary to the
existing pre-training or data mining approaches and can be used in a variety of
settings. Given the efficacy of the pseudolabeling method, we are planning to
publicly release the generated captions.
|
[
0.0197715834,
0.0433741212,
0.0110044442,
0.0419236682,
0.0317725092,
0.0091330819,
0.023770662,
-0.0059434907,
0.0110801924,
-0.0894130543,
-0.0607667826,
-0.0088580409,
-0.0164640471,
0.0416060314,
0.0212890133,
-0.0753435344,
0.0044445675,
-0.0088432664,
-0.0119889192,
0.0066676661,
0.0504420251,
0.026985934,
-0.0206431895,
0.0196294542,
-0.0624403693,
-0.019558074,
-0.0091981804,
-0.0093195383,
0.0263307635,
-0.028125912,
-0.0369830132,
0.0431520157,
0.0838476196,
-0.0110070892,
0.0000020246,
0.0013068848,
-0.0037144171,
-0.0095953094,
0.0134051219,
0.0387808196,
0.0398511589,
-0.0585026368,
0.0108281979,
0.0150155136,
-0.0317450315,
-0.0341233499,
0.058067441,
0.013587364,
0.0806964189,
0.019644469,
-0.044053521,
-0.0358714797,
-0.0013070209,
-0.0344545543,
0.0038641642,
-0.0235073566,
-0.0419334061,
0.0616495833,
0.0093880352,
0.013999573,
-0.0400825292,
0.0651277378,
-0.0064794105,
-0.0427654088,
0.0097511346,
0.0416989513,
-0.0486881994,
-0.043753311,
-0.0345467106,
0.0937992111,
0.0187370889,
0.0256030448,
-0.0173395257,
-0.0122468723,
-0.0039961305,
-0.0177125223,
-0.026854476,
0.0500311367,
0.0403216332,
0.0087198932,
-0.0369117893,
0.0606052019,
0.0182327162,
-0.0191228762,
0.0293220356,
-0.0489871204,
0.0085962769,
0.0473228954,
-0.0322046205,
-0.0249380339,
-0.0480989926,
-0.0306849703,
0.0184992552,
-0.0126421191,
0.0454870798,
-0.0131278066,
-0.0492607281,
-0.0282383617,
-0.0235646702,
-0.0654775798,
0.0422915258,
-0.0049073501,
-0.0662161633,
0.0727274865,
-0.0179546494,
0.0238132942,
0.009999943,
0.0215179734,
-0.0296531972,
0.0090738386,
-0.0654744655,
-0.0051245387,
-0.0363939963,
0.0228270199,
-0.0473073646,
-0.0424443968,
-0.0321784951,
-0.0133323744,
-0.0199604928,
-0.0064309882,
-0.0103559745,
0.0470141731,
0.0117301643,
-0.0204069689,
-0.0405436084,
0.0253073461,
-0.0059958338,
0.0318764448,
-0.0223009028,
-0.0416446254,
-0.0003564425,
0.0421663262,
0.0139823267,
-0.019582456,
0.0342067182,
0.0845584273,
-0.064603053,
-0.0592718646,
-0.0214383136,
-0.0217517745,
-0.0769649297,
0.0093494859,
0.0142087135,
-0.0331923738,
0.0406785011,
-0.0134912757,
0.0203974042,
-0.0366912335,
0.0136532476,
-0.0143310372,
0.0135872476,
0.1116591245,
-0.0160414074,
0.0077490285,
0.0153403031,
0.0109150577,
-0.0017358128,
0.0445252061,
0.0456452444,
0.0532743484,
0.0240729265,
-0.0043361117,
0.0238271784,
0.031392049,
-0.0045004501,
0.0190284289,
-0.0577140041,
-0.0263281781,
0.0268337149,
0.0276333336,
0.0409548469,
0.0436851941,
0.0012088611,
0.0028083846,
0.0774804354,
0.0142433234,
-0.022324698,
0.0219884571,
0.0359755009,
0.0173891652,
0.0128216669,
-0.031728562,
-0.0123820566,
0.0760275424,
0.0393489487,
-0.0151137169,
0.0521954782,
0.0185157154,
-0.0675813183,
-0.0457583107,
-0.0034028227,
-0.0274502616,
0.0071787243,
-0.0093814777,
0.0340043977,
0.0100347726,
-0.060608115,
0.0338081084,
0.0047212439,
-0.0097534517,
0.0386651419,
-0.0129181212,
-0.0421439558,
0.0446180925,
0.0190748293,
-0.0241407584,
-0.0206887759,
-0.0306548513,
0.0855044797,
0.0206215512,
0.0236654021,
-0.0154794725,
0.0239609946,
-0.0663950518,
-0.0429254845,
-0.0162223838,
0.0013799346,
0.0415262505,
-0.0477319695,
0.0070572686,
0.0315646194,
-0.0155826034,
-0.0590999201,
0.0347939581,
0.0614683591,
-0.037156634,
0.0154376971,
0.0291863587,
0.011922908,
0.0300200153,
-0.0519849546,
-0.0194023494,
0.0090621263,
0.0011001613,
-0.003897076,
0.0559731759,
-0.0525585264,
-0.038980037,
0.0353433639,
-0.059121415,
0.0086514372,
0.0200350452,
-0.0221629702,
-0.0370947719,
0.0357608572,
-0.0338195413,
-0.0005317656,
-0.0760615766,
0.0152313281,
0.039716512,
0.0139778014,
0.0212752502,
0.0247421097,
0.0130222598,
-0.0404750034,
-0.0026701123,
0.0008900458,
0.0188547596,
-0.0284644309,
-0.0594792478,
-0.026069276,
-0.0128074111,
0.0174558014,
0.0203527845,
0.0077105034,
-0.03615072,
-0.0059428634,
-0.0997705907,
-0.0258624963,
-0.0085264053,
-0.0129234185,
-0.0263377894,
-0.019424906,
0.02881773,
-0.0474682413,
-0.0176002346,
-0.0138256997,
0.008166411,
0.0049883933,
0.0083039561,
0.042119164,
-0.0048166215,
-0.007818738,
-0.0005222055,
0.0015058535,
0.0375410914,
0.0270540267,
-0.0195772499,
0.0048639327,
-0.0113138491,
0.0061233994,
0.0170551445,
-0.020839978,
-0.0345897377,
-0.0002371868,
0.0243850704,
-0.0064396467,
0.0016621379,
0.0250375289,
0.012405376,
0.0370304585,
0.0050768298,
-0.0099977637,
0.0055688964,
0.0070429943,
-0.0445278957,
0.0045046424,
-0.0173213538,
-0.0279695038,
0.0015228302,
-0.0059908195,
0.0599110499,
-0.0826023966,
0.0084910877,
0.0080433544,
-0.044035472,
-0.0395075269,
0.0347483009,
0.005082075,
-0.0115341861,
-0.02308104,
-0.0575388335,
0.0038023903,
-0.0575262085,
-0.0516394116,
0.0072150356,
-0.0235124491,
-0.0046523018,
0.100886859,
0.0119890617,
0.0502974093,
0.0135611016,
-0.0287610013,
-0.0220024455,
-0.0263953246,
0.0092934752,
0.0114029851,
0.0414557643,
-0.0410215519,
0.0089146225,
0.0083467187,
-0.0257334765,
-0.0141656781,
-0.067537941,
-0.0331235714,
-0.0298557449,
-0.0386970975,
-0.001273835,
-0.0001709269,
0.0320377275,
0.0047903555,
0.0491772108,
0.0075855241,
0.0106013697,
-0.0052840291,
0.0303687546,
0.0360218398,
0.0155820167,
-0.0851717815,
-0.028386768,
0.0229858123,
-0.0019788316,
0.0207109526,
-0.02760607,
-0.0702533275,
0.0201133434,
0.0022761989,
0.0395640209,
0.0016587788,
0.0229259301,
0.031279806,
-0.0265800394,
0.0313904136,
0.0857076272,
-0.0045164451,
-0.0393478349,
-0.0085102003,
0.045739729,
-0.0174013004,
0.0405991077,
-0.0193768181,
-0.0788570419,
-0.0709363669,
-0.036513716,
-0.0028028286,
0.0369995758,
0.0307392292,
-0.0570557751,
-0.0600106269,
0.041082494,
0.0386866592,
-0.0263155811,
-0.0098741753,
0.0037410161,
-0.0475930087,
-0.0278585348,
-0.0141076362,
-0.0312116463,
-0.0241580736,
0.0113048106,
0.0421449281,
0.0137871774,
-0.0544010736,
0.021958407,
-0.0487939008,
0.0597198047,
0.0445879549,
0.0394985899,
-0.048542656,
-0.0280558895,
0.0143169314,
0.012356176,
0.0283985157,
-0.0033929099,
0.0815418735,
-0.0487134457,
-0.060878288,
0.0449209958,
0.0288365036,
0.0211986508,
-0.0214424971,
0.0269274972,
0.0351113081,
-0.0060865758,
0.0266221315,
-0.0271457192,
0.0320912376,
0.0070215082,
0.0410323776,
-0.0050261468,
-0.0324555673,
0.0271475427,
0.0360445976,
0.0124766957,
-0.0234963018,
-0.0422666371,
-0.0029104406,
-0.0130968569,
-0.0115536219,
-0.0365317948,
0.00113293,
0.080196321,
0.0358591862,
0.029111132,
0.0130728688,
0.0065721334,
0.0491210483,
-0.0751548856,
0.0703321323,
-0.0288545415,
-0.0220557339,
-0.0570908859,
-0.0245589577,
0.1031005308,
-0.0439702198,
-0.002999353,
0.0305260886,
-0.0271482598,
-0.0236268938,
-0.0423353054,
0.0879049674,
0.0045166421,
0.0463104211,
0.0366372317,
-0.0251118392,
0.0344199091,
0.0739218369,
-0.0056785494,
-0.0029349539,
0.0242745318,
-0.0377285928,
-0.0379919,
0.0017605714,
-0.0308802593,
0.0373365544,
-0.0200856607,
0.0063212169,
-0.0344415642,
-0.0036728862,
0.0057309666,
-0.013535561,
0.0595460422,
-0.0704596788,
0.011307735,
-0.0637560412,
-0.0219220333,
0.0029011057,
0.0194336511,
-0.0690937191,
0.0413672142,
0.0378557928,
0.0399863943,
-0.0162676796,
0.0217080228,
-0.0144649744,
-0.0109183686,
0.0133803478,
0.0207054131,
-0.0145205585,
-0.0311428942,
-0.029194206,
0.0360974818,
0.0350635611,
0.0228516683,
0.0124569926,
0.0177331399,
0.0095604341,
0.0275921226,
0.0064495993,
-0.0150992405,
-0.0090332497,
0.0756189302,
0.0209421087,
0.0022352443,
-0.0703700632,
0.0332574621,
0.0289049949,
-0.0403574631,
0.0118166767,
-0.0185664389,
0.0005569813,
-0.0265019257,
0.0588597134,
-0.0051953453,
-0.0614663325,
0.0457892492,
-0.0148353549,
-0.0346988924,
0.0112356413,
0.0509506166,
0.0055620847,
0.0281506032,
0.0355594717,
-0.0186917335,
-0.0456618778,
-0.0277361255,
0.0031649529,
0.0065490212,
-0.0350446403,
0.0275765397,
0.0004040772,
-0.0738058761,
-0.0084567051,
-0.004580684,
-0.011369505,
0.0320229866,
0.0636051893,
-0.0025263464,
0.0161968153,
0.018374376,
-0.0087021105,
-0.0365608409,
0.0001429679,
0.0054562027,
0.0169879198,
-5.61202162e-33,
-0.0333718956,
-0.0177044179,
0.0012928298,
-0.0219366532,
0.0003138564,
0.0358552448,
-0.0247812066,
0.0606812984,
-0.0085025681,
0.0168963615,
0.027052056,
-0.0146545554,
0.0153674185,
0.0394735523,
0.0179629214,
-0.0217268206,
0.048348628,
-0.0442217328,
-0.003880121,
0.0099487621,
0.0146185923,
0.0035734042,
0.0545145459,
-0.0961329788,
-0.0257726237,
0.023716012,
-0.0592627972,
0.0139882406,
0.0591246746,
0.0532253198,
-0.011051245,
-0.0029496329,
-0.0063545951,
-0.018772848,
-0.0252522212,
-0.0001148519,
-0.0668878257,
0.0163179506,
0.0403569899,
0.0348760113,
-0.0382572599,
-0.0056179757,
0.0228913389,
-0.0461444221,
-0.0352412686,
-0.0068518515,
0.0716307908,
-0.0225229617,
0.0399377756,
0.0030820109,
-0.0171288364,
0.0111406166,
-0.0344913639,
-0.0668534264,
0.0786992535,
0.019936597,
0.0364150703,
-0.0035159003,
-0.0415722951,
0.0333804525,
-0.0257164575,
0.0243847724,
0.1040594354,
0.0472677276,
0.0056563369,
0.0824804232,
0.0309384018,
-0.0411952958,
-0.0279456079,
0.0165164992,
0.0172266811,
0.0440774821,
0.0320876129,
0.050753627,
0.0356352963,
-0.0119715249,
-0.0196254849,
0.0230818726,
-0.0695404559,
-0.0219598971,
0.0161443837,
0.0180016141,
-0.0121640861,
0.0171838477,
-0.0498572327,
-0.0206491202,
-0.0249292459,
-0.0476527475,
0.0197167546,
0.0066025308,
-0.0114054987,
0.0439640991,
0.0709630325,
-0.0267358627,
0.0107023325,
-0.0077144089,
-0.0125934053,
0.0483538806,
-0.0018485785,
0.0053293356,
-0.0263055079,
-0.0349346772,
0.0560884625,
-0.0030124341,
0.0482161269,
-0.004608138,
0.0226705987,
0.0631452054,
-0.0300323982,
-0.0028791644,
0.0075176926,
-0.0021444876,
-0.0289121475,
0.0136276335,
0.027825566,
0.0239461493,
-0.0757560208,
0.0216045585,
-0.0211832747,
-0.0014153301,
-0.0101510137,
-0.0532306805,
-0.009589456,
0.0291510187,
-0.0299948733,
0.0381692499,
-0.02701151,
-0.0567295067,
0.0483527146,
-0.0714960247,
-0.0257266983,
0.0210380815,
2.661e-7,
-0.0031142046,
0.0162916146,
0.0191466175,
0.0004162254,
-0.0051440494,
0.0798029825,
-0.0170154143,
0.0392120592,
0.0048839627,
-0.0659343153,
0.0621927492,
0.0363742188,
0.0176747963,
-0.0166274756,
-0.032771457,
-0.0003741104,
-0.0541732647,
-0.005541434,
-0.0398945026,
-0.0200281963,
0.0190849025,
0.1291279793,
0.0298056453,
-0.0111297444,
0.0044962619,
-0.0784247592,
0.0736698285,
-0.0047689457,
-0.0310105272,
-0.0052997055,
-0.0247130096,
0.0313435905,
-0.090390332,
0.0006391535,
-0.0246152263,
-0.0177279226,
0.0683783442,
0.0373563245,
-0.0404631682,
-0.0149598988,
-0.0388263054,
0.073140271,
-0.0278931819,
0.0375036635,
0.0619766414,
-0.0324388631,
-0.0254635047,
-0.044694867,
0.0076115178,
0.0095049925,
0.0141097978,
-0.022348091,
-0.0297874697,
0.0313180909,
0.0442155749,
-0.0111203678,
-0.0355007499,
-0.1198680699,
-0.0079374481,
0.0049799434,
-0.0346743278,
0.019667495,
-0.0594831444,
0.0103642968,
0.043318212,
-0.0280021057,
-0.0275374893,
1.747828316e-34,
0.0233355016,
-0.0287312362,
0.0061700731,
-0.0541352555,
0.0127893882,
0.0154175619,
-0.0206884649,
-0.0220032781,
0.0096342303,
-0.0428293124,
-0.0236124452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02034v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02034v1
|
Effective Theory of Transformers at Initialization
| 2023-04-04T18:00:01 | 2023-04-04T18:00:01 |
Emily Dinan, Sho Yaida, Susan Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, hep-th, stat.ML
|
We perform an effective-theory analysis of forward-backward signal
propagation in wide and deep Transformers, i.e., residual neural networks with
multi-head self-attention blocks and multilayer perceptron blocks. This
analysis suggests particular width scalings of initialization and training
hyperparameters for these models. We then take up such suggestions, training
Vision and Language Transformers in practical setups.
|
[
-0.0092983367,
0.0134356907,
-0.0057927012,
0.001993753,
-0.0002320404,
0.003790807,
0.0048358776,
-0.0170378499,
-0.0485793501,
-0.0011222777,
-0.0362076946,
-0.0945078433,
-0.006482217,
-0.0233847033,
0.0270808917,
-0.0309958365,
0.0233799592,
0.0127469832,
-0.0739061981,
-0.0484329015,
-0.0058129807,
-0.0792002156,
-0.019346619,
0.0197733548,
-0.0367387496,
-0.0087499265,
0.0017588693,
0.000379855,
0.019239964,
-0.0416963771,
-0.0087727522,
0.0007020846,
0.0012540567,
0.0077372235,
0.0000018112,
-0.011817784,
0.0085442271,
0.000888502,
-0.0240209159,
0.0026613181,
-0.0145222638,
-0.0161950476,
-0.0182639789,
-0.0048522078,
-0.0292708445,
-0.0328373611,
0.0503174625,
0.0643019974,
0.0505961366,
0.0361229628,
-0.0218515825,
-0.0987961963,
0.0254298598,
-0.0473483317,
-0.0222483836,
-0.0401104465,
0.0262802932,
-0.0443958454,
-0.06515567,
-0.0237569492,
-0.0380058028,
0.00229595,
0.0272096023,
0.0200536083,
0.0240141284,
0.0236041993,
-0.0033185484,
-0.0098440237,
-0.0203325711,
0.0321557894,
0.0060111969,
-0.0129270833,
-0.0412259363,
-0.0040891501,
-0.0153527437,
0.0016928228,
-0.0395388678,
0.0481507815,
0.0180352777,
0.0110650258,
-0.04294388,
0.0192394312,
0.0259254053,
0.0062357946,
-0.0340714939,
0.0675376281,
0.0140940994,
-0.0173375234,
0.0074088941,
0.0049230899,
-0.0119314976,
0.0277580041,
-0.0026101605,
0.0425883867,
0.0494292602,
-0.0044236286,
0.0026927097,
-0.0562510416,
-0.0281971078,
-0.0510864258,
0.0177579969,
0.0129224639,
-0.0364590511,
0.0179097522,
-0.0311487354,
0.0801051632,
-0.095230557,
0.060646262,
0.0124772089,
-0.0027238843,
-0.0210479572,
-0.0061694868,
-0.0695903674,
0.017840378,
0.0544461235,
-0.0146210091,
-0.0571631454,
0.0289242733,
0.0401511528,
-0.0812007859,
0.0129692918,
-0.0106020896,
-0.0630826652,
-0.0068453345,
-0.0008140569,
0.0297594573,
0.0073048533,
-0.0116083948,
-0.0141569516,
-0.0621061362,
-0.0476746708,
0.0340588242,
0.0101812771,
-0.0118162408,
0.0208765175,
0.0813427418,
-0.0077435966,
-0.0249768775,
-0.0493773408,
0.0654906332,
-0.0115380511,
-0.0187395364,
0.0630458891,
-0.0374497771,
-0.0188611597,
0.0057169129,
0.0283252876,
-0.0043612397,
0.0017393446,
0.0125048989,
-0.0128947077,
0.0063570715,
0.0237052571,
-0.0246977266,
0.0287251081,
0.0038295223,
-0.0085085211,
0.0331376456,
-0.0274093971,
0.011136434,
-0.0179848187,
-0.038982138,
0.0332521871,
0.0355171077,
0.0306244902,
0.0152746644,
-0.0548415408,
-0.0463123694,
-0.0342631005,
-0.0050544958,
-0.0111725572,
0.0669984594,
-0.0583124086,
0.0283263903,
0.0458611362,
0.0388557538,
0.0405609719,
0.0717269853,
0.0632598549,
-0.0148514239,
0.00136501,
0.0450193249,
-0.0248145442,
0.0363213532,
0.0332200266,
-0.0392493941,
-0.0604913272,
0.0235804506,
-0.0654146299,
-0.0233547483,
0.0106731113,
-0.0120297009,
-0.0428519845,
-0.0482302941,
0.079164356,
0.0487261526,
-0.0414155163,
0.0877761766,
-0.0377338044,
-0.0346414372,
0.0184241813,
-0.0378131717,
-0.0272485092,
-0.0466010645,
0.0122026689,
-0.0143124824,
0.0087493844,
0.0132500315,
-0.0134066595,
0.0052035726,
0.0253393054,
0.041954767,
-0.0070137554,
-0.0087478897,
-0.00476381,
0.0454201698,
-0.0116758337,
-0.0128075713,
-0.021225052,
-0.0046712756,
0.0159772485,
0.0114187375,
-0.0113126542,
0.0372650847,
-0.015430633,
0.0114822928,
0.0118183838,
0.0385126099,
0.0345728025,
0.0115334019,
-0.0204881728,
-0.0061629587,
0.0165512245,
-0.0416940972,
-0.0395149887,
0.0624168292,
-0.0653427169,
0.0448851623,
0.0089374296,
-0.081287384,
0.078382872,
0.0966731012,
0.0351712257,
-0.0707083195,
0.0392502658,
-0.0234909058,
0.0249011125,
-0.0460464209,
0.0404589884,
-0.0174528919,
0.051615227,
-0.0153325936,
0.0344647728,
0.0035513092,
0.0333340354,
0.0013745321,
-0.0474997312,
0.0339981541,
-0.0040821331,
-0.0673586205,
-0.0107685691,
-0.0624819659,
0.0026281676,
0.0273693278,
-0.0405892394,
0.0123099582,
0.0003311645,
0.0136251682,
-0.0328007452,
-0.0332291052,
0.0311642326,
0.013637471,
0.0064638853,
0.0333836749,
-0.0045530573,
-0.0279055648,
0.0613751151,
0.0232728012,
0.0123878829,
0.0283007789,
0.0241140593,
-0.0380301178,
0.0025431321,
-0.0366238281,
0.0074091954,
0.0582706705,
0.0108108046,
-0.0162510555,
-0.0342714228,
-0.0416423008,
0.0498920009,
0.0649575368,
-0.0193745624,
-0.07891877,
-0.0269464403,
-0.01798339,
0.0066662333,
0.0776348338,
0.039438609,
0.0237022955,
-0.0076282858,
0.059579052,
0.020435052,
0.0106831817,
-0.0621564388,
-0.0204918422,
-0.0519334301,
-0.0115215909,
0.0006078336,
0.1105613932,
-0.020269312,
-0.0303165205,
-0.0305849742,
-0.0275369808,
-0.0017087391,
0.0043829507,
0.0367936864,
-0.0567827187,
-0.0165743455,
0.0338237062,
0.0067164805,
-0.0337954946,
0.0033671528,
-0.0357052051,
-0.0167602692,
0.0306914505,
0.0181393083,
0.0152071025,
0.0176025908,
0.0567981526,
0.02109739,
-0.0225338247,
-0.0249639228,
-0.0511192642,
0.0200962611,
0.0539239682,
0.027098164,
0.0524420738,
0.0234788712,
-0.007664978,
-0.0488896407,
-0.0053930646,
-0.0674132481,
-0.0595846847,
0.0176577605,
-0.0010308265,
0.0300385691,
-0.0201900061,
-0.0725634992,
0.0307406131,
0.0370099917,
0.025446441,
0.009261027,
-0.015748838,
-0.0107223568,
0.025038613,
-0.0179434754,
0.0212419257,
0.0403714702,
-0.0395900384,
0.0588497631,
0.0127961235,
0.0359274074,
0.0387435108,
-0.0595186763,
-0.0198123883,
0.0163875688,
0.0023207471,
-0.0124137588,
0.0008985181,
0.0152840987,
0.0201299153,
-0.0105828345,
0.0204365365,
-0.0077642207,
-0.0848270878,
0.0153185669,
0.0221392959,
-0.0375180282,
0.0430177711,
0.0045113536,
-0.0181931183,
0.017647922,
-0.0229013525,
0.0005911657,
-0.0022526116,
-0.0062978379,
0.0186995342,
-0.0483700261,
-0.0092761712,
-0.0114111193,
-0.0185262635,
-0.0054518552,
0.0240567587,
-0.014431837,
-0.0234212782,
-0.0076610995,
0.0117550306,
-0.0299256761,
-0.0602826327,
0.0491464436,
0.0261557326,
-0.0148752797,
0.0136430329,
-0.0279299971,
-0.0068466123,
0.0722549707,
-0.0288509633,
-0.0608921573,
-0.0457693972,
0.0290398374,
-0.0660041571,
0.0427426212,
0.050568983,
0.0469559953,
0.0080050463,
-0.0424279161,
0.0081394557,
-0.0062669055,
-0.0146549139,
-0.0005519329,
-0.074724853,
-0.0015599157,
-0.0266746692,
-0.0129154278,
0.0180164017,
0.0028362491,
-0.0245863497,
0.0112335505,
0.0302689392,
-0.0475726351,
-0.0394735374,
0.0258902349,
0.0399021767,
-0.0039818324,
-0.0868195817,
0.0599553548,
0.0354807451,
-0.103113018,
-0.0321774967,
0.0125372009,
-0.0677708611,
0.0846808255,
0.0391372703,
-0.0649242774,
0.0066892765,
0.0374060906,
0.0199744832,
0.044800017,
0.0089134304,
-0.0102877766,
-0.0867237821,
0.02489971,
0.0531077869,
-0.0562171824,
-0.0051853377,
0.0073889992,
-0.0780712292,
-0.020908799,
0.0732693002,
0.0289429072,
0.0204360466,
0.0433855541,
-0.0180582628,
-0.0265561081,
0.027385978,
-0.0057189325,
-0.0050935284,
0.029197108,
0.0605661236,
-0.0408172198,
-0.0186597947,
0.025310874,
-0.0174965374,
0.0807060301,
0.0546941049,
0.0026192411,
0.0281842425,
0.0123207849,
0.0300564654,
0.0226759575,
0.0785392299,
0.0035450743,
0.0346329436,
0.0131039079,
0.0397171453,
0.0254927538,
0.0075153578,
-0.0336854234,
-0.006973628,
0.0123752253,
0.0433504544,
0.0118591338,
-0.0285731591,
0.0232436769,
-0.0098267188,
-0.0246394593,
0.0432574451,
-0.0200077463,
0.0269957874,
0.0229988862,
0.0361279286,
-0.0332687497,
-0.0108942669,
0.0044371644,
-0.0048770923,
0.0070890002,
0.0475033522,
0.0244396552,
0.0178729836,
-0.0708737671,
-0.0049344781,
-0.0682980195,
-0.0511982217,
-0.015431975,
0.0165368132,
0.0338235572,
-0.0273891333,
-0.0238311384,
-0.0324668474,
0.032896243,
-0.0017552463,
-0.0138687175,
-0.0152723044,
-0.0316319168,
0.0301272441,
-0.0125320675,
0.0222994089,
-0.0119283944,
0.0522879958,
-0.0119187413,
0.0072496608,
-0.0036144576,
0.0538284704,
-0.0142015386,
0.0001557136,
0.0070476374,
-0.0130986115,
0.0103660114,
0.0271418877,
-0.018505156,
-0.0571166277,
0.0336405523,
-0.0377949961,
0.0460563861,
-0.0160589851,
0.047611367,
0.070532307,
0.0236669183,
0.0065874192,
0.0197880417,
0.0061853845,
0.0273175351,
0.042963285,
0.0223408807,
-5.914295951e-33,
-0.0152214635,
0.0054558222,
-0.0004402858,
0.0053593344,
-0.0365417898,
-0.0012557107,
0.0128106819,
0.0010965596,
-0.041075632,
-0.0181978121,
-0.0468585752,
0.0353748724,
0.0191090964,
0.0740004107,
-0.0177548565,
-0.0345695764,
0.0334663317,
-0.0192636587,
0.0124654239,
0.0141813029,
0.0173153579,
0.040930558,
0.0935272649,
-0.003889699,
-0.0570157543,
-0.0234592929,
-0.0232669525,
0.0396144651,
-0.031710498,
0.012538176,
-0.0488017388,
0.0148459151,
0.0150530562,
-0.1045540497,
0.0071220323,
-0.0107392073,
-0.0422125347,
-0.0011055914,
-0.0263764057,
0.0652917922,
-0.0390433483,
0.0015357231,
0.0608469434,
-0.0203468464,
-0.0108287772,
0.0131823169,
0.0381169729,
0.003844396,
-0.0119715175,
0.0106343478,
-0.0330950879,
-0.0058341185,
-0.0227686949,
0.004674871,
0.049332507,
0.0347395428,
-0.053526625,
0.0483481474,
-0.0706826225,
0.0131977238,
0.0240092259,
0.0117344102,
0.0158939231,
0.0581790209,
0.0382915586,
0.0274041314,
0.0358593687,
0.026470378,
-0.0183922537,
-0.0833169594,
0.0280520786,
0.0047218255,
0.0096425926,
0.0144669935,
0.0543077104,
-0.0262594111,
-0.0678408146,
-0.0393126085,
-0.0271033477,
0.0490367487,
0.0369389132,
-0.0112134097,
-0.008642734,
-0.0160189588,
-0.022625532,
-0.0159391556,
-0.0229015108,
0.0187202413,
-0.0110541722,
-0.0041075307,
-0.0020068744,
-0.0245137438,
0.0353961401,
-0.0083907451,
0.0475850925,
0.0232680235,
0.0188278705,
0.0656643659,
-0.0220990963,
0.0042442777,
-0.0364228897,
-0.0263823811,
-0.0407251306,
0.0343421102,
0.0229797419,
0.0195694584,
0.0174516235,
0.0692596585,
-0.0347987637,
-0.0631809309,
-0.0293094907,
-0.0098682763,
0.0562301241,
0.0580403209,
0.0549869128,
0.0082655773,
-0.0288513601,
0.0497563891,
-0.034056209,
-0.0190867037,
0.0136682484,
0.0469301939,
0.0598125197,
0.0339807384,
-0.0190143231,
-0.0331775472,
-0.0154748727,
-0.0113455951,
0.0247117169,
-0.1017706245,
-0.0276933666,
0.01157167,
2.671e-7,
0.0318759009,
-0.020560395,
0.0522781424,
0.0098493565,
0.0318415873,
-0.0116596753,
0.0105346153,
0.0279710181,
-0.0154101569,
-0.0013194177,
0.0506748408,
0.0209880881,
-0.0144714024,
-0.020797817,
-0.082963936,
-0.0301761385,
-0.0512598567,
0.0250558052,
0.0382164083,
-0.0046150708,
-0.0194227993,
0.0605133623,
-0.0373818427,
-0.0008321628,
-0.0173677113,
0.011606453,
0.0562564097,
0.0276077837,
0.0777256042,
0.0085387714,
-0.0083646523,
-0.027228158,
-0.0343624204,
0.0518607534,
0.0248427503,
0.0446455218,
0.0214381535,
-0.0430027135,
-0.0258191749,
-0.0343856327,
0.0069136969,
0.0310738906,
-0.0123486416,
0.0062030479,
-0.001732345,
-0.0989991203,
-0.0512468219,
0.0429687425,
-0.0474115573,
-0.0022643534,
-0.0045684022,
-0.004383354,
0.0630173981,
0.0018101011,
-0.0185794793,
-0.0062879524,
-0.0146390097,
-0.0586869083,
0.0188467745,
0.0139510343,
-0.0410170183,
-0.0588511452,
-0.0511512682,
-0.0567147695,
0.0803717002,
0.0163592752,
-0.031975273,
1.884773063e-34,
0.0097725177,
0.0037667607,
0.0236931201,
0.0081823915,
-0.0334801152,
-0.0421035513,
0.0458888151,
-0.0230936725,
0.0180372,
-0.0922489166,
-0.0045080557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01982v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01982v3
|
Rethinking the Role of Token Retrieval in Multi-Vector Retrieval
| 2023-04-04T17:37:06 | 2024-04-08T18:31:32 |
Jinhyuk Lee, Zhuyun Dai, Sai Meher Karthik Duddu, Tao Lei, Iftekhar Naim, Ming-Wei Chang, Vincent Y. Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Multi-vector retrieval models such as ColBERT [Khattab and Zaharia, 2020]
allow token-level interactions between queries and documents, and hence achieve
state of the art on many information retrieval benchmarks. However, their
non-linear scoring function cannot be scaled to millions of documents,
necessitating a three-stage process for inference: retrieving initial
candidates via token retrieval, accessing all token vectors, and scoring the
initial candidate documents. The non-linear scoring function is applied over
all token vectors of each candidate document, making the inference process
complicated and slow. In this paper, we aim to simplify the multi-vector
retrieval by rethinking the role of token retrieval. We present XTR,
ConteXtualized Token Retriever, which introduces a simple, yet novel, objective
function that encourages the model to retrieve the most important document
tokens first. The improvement to token retrieval allows XTR to rank candidates
only using the retrieved tokens rather than all tokens in the document, and
enables a newly designed scoring stage that is two-to-three orders of magnitude
cheaper than that of ColBERT. On the popular BEIR benchmark, XTR advances the
state-of-the-art by 2.8 nDCG@10 without any distillation. Detailed analysis
confirms our decision to revisit the token retrieval stage, as XTR demonstrates
much better recall of the token retrieval stage compared to ColBERT.
|
[
0.0272999648,
0.0136109274,
0.0138075491,
0.0141732823,
-0.0189099833,
0.0038008662,
-0.0047118124,
0.0256974604,
-0.0148765985,
-0.0244572982,
-0.0258632526,
-0.00591197,
-0.0522118025,
0.0187189989,
-0.0109896893,
-0.0219090991,
0.0442498326,
0.0303029679,
0.0390615687,
0.0041131652,
0.0085098157,
0.0228689238,
0.0050382223,
0.0268065147,
-0.0546260364,
0.029988911,
0.0025215955,
0.0354872532,
0.0033906484,
-0.032720875,
0.0034332683,
0.0301427133,
0.0459243096,
-0.0095364433,
0.0000019514,
-0.0432693139,
-0.0929163322,
0.0087799476,
0.0070346924,
-0.0315848961,
0.051855024,
0.0020128614,
0.0561180227,
-0.0154721523,
-0.0101094134,
-0.0125948247,
-0.0087537095,
0.0606863908,
0.0265059117,
0.0346733183,
-0.0093459627,
-0.0062541747,
0.0151584269,
-0.0142673189,
0.0116956709,
-0.0934690088,
0.0426451825,
-0.0376706086,
0.006760919,
0.0530096628,
-0.0029165773,
0.0161912479,
-0.0096920775,
0.0179367457,
0.0605370104,
0.0217295922,
-0.0806068256,
0.035025768,
0.016015375,
0.0254854448,
0.0013162892,
-0.0213682111,
0.0369561389,
0.0305891968,
-0.0135552408,
-0.0087840846,
-0.0707780942,
-0.0269440785,
-0.047910884,
-0.0117037203,
0.0233696401,
0.0101979198,
0.0234190375,
0.0390592702,
-0.0151210362,
0.0374920331,
0.0091259293,
-0.0192467775,
-0.0224848464,
-0.0238270592,
-0.0156326406,
-0.0140013406,
0.043241322,
-0.0177121442,
-0.0627411008,
0.0001848739,
0.0383657478,
-0.0412423871,
0.042492155,
-0.053834945,
-0.0169725809,
0.0127835954,
-0.0324894153,
0.0905315503,
-0.0185150597,
0.0377136581,
-0.0250158124,
0.0329525359,
-0.0251680333,
-0.0540844873,
-0.0154239582,
-0.0374109894,
-0.0477183275,
0.0730871335,
-0.0341191106,
-0.0180336796,
-0.0112097813,
0.018980762,
-0.0011567295,
-0.0239554923,
-0.023657538,
0.0129141659,
-0.027522888,
0.0114953034,
-0.0231724773,
-0.0044986256,
-0.0657148212,
-0.0112040974,
-0.0013649395,
-0.0240594707,
-0.0040565562,
0.008885975,
0.0225234553,
-0.0702691451,
0.0262485519,
0.0077043632,
-0.0076373275,
-0.0533710085,
0.0394690186,
-0.0322323032,
0.0198371541,
-0.0275386255,
0.0031750423,
-0.051780168,
0.0489378124,
0.0498062372,
-0.0060606105,
0.0197708383,
-0.0226317309,
0.0398343541,
-0.0426696911,
0.0239624102,
0.0517749712,
-0.0413352996,
0.0459462106,
-0.0012246312,
-0.0214466061,
0.0488687269,
-0.0603027195,
0.061898794,
0.0642518327,
0.0260805115,
0.0171610136,
-0.0300162043,
0.0454909913,
0.0133325504,
0.0068028802,
0.0485732332,
0.0148281157,
0.0252642557,
0.0184268802,
0.0330543518,
-0.0662898943,
-0.0246231277,
-0.0274660569,
0.0594863147,
0.0228121132,
-0.0258341283,
-0.0126380129,
-0.0071728621,
-0.0336307958,
-0.0208416767,
-0.0205434561,
0.0457615554,
0.0005467149,
-0.0155408494,
0.0891945139,
-0.0014447849,
-0.0169843324,
-0.0309703518,
-0.0013543466,
0.0435590819,
-0.0345225334,
0.0029323653,
0.0560722128,
-0.0345106758,
-0.0242338665,
0.0677182674,
0.0181962159,
-0.0529845916,
0.0086248452,
-0.0449622609,
0.0187055767,
0.030170152,
0.0856435373,
-0.0707497448,
0.0214130394,
0.024327239,
0.0408914573,
-0.0436136201,
0.0247830395,
-0.0112255337,
0.0086787948,
-0.0277686864,
-0.0226602554,
-0.0015390853,
0.0158695411,
0.0174637586,
-0.003358525,
0.0369655117,
-0.0028714444,
-0.0690870211,
0.0428361632,
0.0132993506,
0.0282823034,
-0.0063349423,
0.0337913409,
-0.005846581,
0.0072034188,
0.0393012613,
0.0020857747,
0.0214631595,
0.0701042563,
-0.0272000432,
-0.0399684384,
-0.0310104378,
-0.0161734037,
0.0118849333,
-0.004905785,
-0.005354539,
0.0256713722,
-0.000052415,
-0.0066026296,
-0.0128795588,
0.0237472728,
0.0143986326,
0.0346166864,
-0.0419571474,
-0.0042457394,
0.0027874515,
-0.0198830459,
-0.0394447744,
0.0662036687,
0.0007597662,
0.069175005,
0.0113168154,
0.010364987,
0.017063899,
-0.0512079857,
-0.02161121,
0.0200475883,
-0.0384334512,
0.0375845693,
0.0469266511,
-0.0375133753,
-0.0325037166,
-0.0151124801,
-0.1120550931,
0.0092531461,
-0.03028889,
-0.0188979991,
-0.0449679755,
0.0015967891,
0.0049494528,
-0.0113625051,
-0.0289777629,
-0.075562641,
-0.0246194024,
0.0326002873,
0.0235888176,
0.0076797782,
0.0029597234,
-0.0296631008,
-0.042300567,
-0.0169945322,
0.0481100939,
-0.0294458866,
-0.0118058948,
0.0287231803,
-0.042457398,
-0.042025473,
0.0058489358,
-0.0450305119,
0.0364999361,
0.0257881526,
-0.0826995149,
-0.0093702916,
0.0402365737,
0.0383036546,
0.0180860125,
-0.038925156,
-0.0207667854,
-0.0976273343,
0.0481940508,
-0.036514163,
0.0501976646,
0.0116328672,
0.0272932593,
0.0507345237,
-0.0256336126,
-0.0156312678,
-0.0068114242,
-0.0338392891,
0.0384772643,
0.0078160921,
-0.0162263177,
-0.0907612517,
0.0180783123,
0.0165997129,
0.03162992,
-0.0098050386,
-0.0229431838,
0.0378678478,
0.003917946,
0.010339723,
-0.0117961755,
0.0306540299,
-0.0597912855,
0.0499726124,
-0.0165397972,
0.026610909,
-0.0734834671,
-0.0135783935,
0.0342939459,
0.0165606923,
0.0103656389,
-0.0576351024,
0.0318706669,
0.0401897468,
0.0459662452,
-0.0152126402,
-0.0906287283,
-0.0176269859,
-0.0211424772,
0.0126767661,
0.0280169882,
0.0423780195,
-0.0061091348,
-0.0634591207,
0.0132871298,
0.0178744309,
0.0155889131,
-0.0405403338,
-0.0271672271,
0.0202688798,
0.0374961309,
0.0268514045,
-0.0338210613,
-0.0177317262,
0.0114970719,
-0.0376375318,
0.071566768,
0.0652626306,
-0.0276095998,
0.03068088,
-0.0122378999,
0.0496393144,
-0.02629303,
-0.0005130997,
-0.0490405522,
-0.0022794132,
-0.0001623769,
-0.0249811746,
0.0580480732,
0.0375560299,
-0.046134457,
-0.0464230254,
-0.0350029618,
-0.0073953816,
0.0279036611,
0.0385757275,
-0.080940187,
-0.0117562413,
0.0334088951,
0.0476597957,
0.0254263356,
-0.0305745732,
-0.0013712229,
-0.0539329089,
0.0533397421,
-0.0440790355,
-0.0433939137,
-0.0299703944,
-0.1004384235,
-0.009294875,
-0.0313608684,
0.0010404154,
0.0499358997,
0.0036664081,
-0.0164240524,
0.0004282014,
0.0306791365,
0.0181191936,
0.0380129553,
-0.0500401855,
-0.0338099077,
-0.0208256543,
0.0313710459,
-0.0121978065,
-0.0596403182,
-0.0065727062,
-0.031501513,
-0.0148907378,
-0.0477056392,
0.0195462368,
-0.0748601779,
0.000803147,
-0.0298493896,
-0.0209052004,
0.0298479497,
-0.0119619779,
-0.0225277394,
0.0168149434,
0.0056691989,
0.0255540833,
-0.0614849627,
-0.0533464029,
-0.0380795524,
0.0467186533,
-0.021837892,
-0.0134401349,
-0.01186598,
-0.0249785874,
0.0374109745,
-0.0362597816,
0.010802702,
-0.0616386272,
-0.0123844147,
0.0157790501,
-0.049030032,
-0.0075025293,
0.0069702175,
0.0751408786,
-0.0755408704,
0.0451026112,
-0.0672346354,
-0.0180784278,
-0.0589775965,
0.0343284048,
-0.0143591408,
0.0147831552,
-0.0366797484,
0.0647384673,
0.0283151045,
-0.0291808769,
-0.0575545616,
0.0294383764,
-0.0081196614,
-0.0277561862,
0.0028239752,
0.0296449456,
0.0086747771,
0.0284819324,
-0.0149797648,
-0.0409645401,
0.0540491939,
0.0794883221,
-0.0321488716,
-0.0223058909,
0.0035204464,
0.0028492797,
-0.0368662961,
0.024331376,
-0.0848791972,
0.0333276093,
-0.0052680802,
0.0612577423,
0.0020251898,
0.0443225503,
0.0287332423,
0.0449104123,
0.0723558962,
0.0186778903,
-0.0012664109,
-0.0408879369,
0.0284697227,
-0.0299762934,
-0.0453651696,
0.0118687376,
0.0234022606,
-0.0299609192,
-0.0340113416,
-0.0217602253,
0.0174065605,
0.0224447474,
0.0625069067,
-0.0557592884,
-0.0324129574,
-0.0274654254,
0.0077987825,
0.015462894,
-0.0221391246,
-0.0340129435,
-0.0390400998,
-0.0013982495,
0.0417421758,
-0.0735573694,
-0.0280435421,
0.0434286483,
-0.0207037441,
-0.0227282066,
0.0220063031,
-0.0648423806,
-0.0002642175,
0.0013668456,
0.0067455871,
0.0299633685,
0.0060204314,
0.0060596913,
0.0162020009,
-0.0377243496,
-0.0247347672,
-0.0314773545,
0.0463778563,
-0.0207874458,
0.0184927266,
0.052190464,
-0.0017271605,
0.0092607075,
0.0436905995,
-0.0398440249,
0.012486564,
-0.0424801148,
-0.0349182114,
-0.0176343881,
0.0217938088,
0.0471351147,
0.0687456578,
0.0004733755,
-0.0324456133,
-0.0174299944,
0.0006063001,
0.0562359206,
-0.0168125294,
-0.0348534733,
-0.0012876446,
0.0339251049,
0.1059661582,
0.0283996146,
-0.053537637,
-0.0318345129,
-0.0088545531,
-0.0470022038,
-0.0509839207,
0.032342989,
-6.850316022e-33,
0.0173950102,
0.0107934782,
0.0141540514,
-0.0142546799,
0.0018412994,
0.0323530585,
0.0188045725,
-0.04144435,
-0.0063255774,
-0.0067829057,
-0.0228402242,
0.0112708006,
0.0130873276,
0.0206369758,
0.0096824728,
-0.0034543891,
0.0420871899,
0.0189585742,
-0.0195016675,
0.0167009942,
0.0931452438,
0.0667743087,
0.0205499995,
-0.056959115,
0.0287210699,
-0.0029991337,
0.0055376957,
0.0262610503,
0.0238519963,
0.0641723052,
-0.0026081025,
0.0168968644,
0.04511654,
-0.0538225099,
0.0375286005,
0.0046482282,
-0.0802452117,
-0.0147989523,
-0.0112795858,
-0.0072598532,
-0.0238122921,
-0.0096823489,
0.0221029278,
0.007335369,
-0.0097640222,
0.0141970441,
0.0266022868,
0.0411927216,
-0.0704975203,
-0.0686327815,
0.0035502936,
0.0378019437,
-0.0101029258,
0.0324451476,
0.0231265277,
0.0377971716,
0.0208086092,
0.0636996999,
-0.0744234249,
0.014589739,
-0.0967522338,
0.0286285188,
-0.0057471199,
0.0067467559,
0.0044277548,
0.0637176856,
0.0720984638,
-0.0054309871,
0.0020840536,
-0.0111277793,
0.0177042894,
0.0270387903,
0.0178741328,
0.0207196791,
0.0469499268,
-0.033386603,
-0.0728245899,
0.0342148542,
0.0118024368,
0.0478746817,
0.0497871786,
0.0475973599,
-0.071267657,
-0.0094784275,
-0.015464549,
-0.0324395783,
-0.0645776615,
0.0002979384,
0.0334426388,
0.0581888109,
-0.0195592996,
-0.0077878842,
0.0307007823,
0.0133847678,
-0.0562217347,
0.0596119054,
0.0075921686,
-0.0077656875,
-0.0163789354,
0.0103933206,
-0.0164649095,
-0.013247014,
0.0221133307,
0.0062055071,
-0.0090769045,
-0.0226846617,
0.0168871451,
-0.031236738,
-0.0728140399,
-0.0142247612,
0.0167346653,
0.0014294856,
-0.0406499803,
-0.0237718541,
0.0269173067,
0.0224714018,
0.0183059163,
0.0306751747,
0.0718964189,
0.0301668029,
-0.0317037366,
-0.0562906116,
-0.0097502992,
-0.0120131737,
0.035003148,
0.0247870777,
0.0039321487,
0.0104906168,
0.0284308568,
-0.0468571782,
0.0011888572,
0.0493943468,
2.814e-7,
0.0182344802,
0.0622276813,
0.0062239692,
-0.016772734,
-0.0211624056,
0.0147441206,
-0.0008599933,
0.0678307414,
0.0174597055,
0.0325258821,
-0.0124251163,
0.0085009476,
-0.0004230487,
0.0481061712,
-0.1151864156,
0.0145865921,
-0.0742174163,
-0.0213546064,
-0.0388893001,
-0.0348036662,
0.0166206472,
0.0587696545,
-0.0202406775,
-0.0036055329,
-0.0186197385,
-0.0703767017,
0.0450149141,
0.0014253672,
-0.0222678967,
-0.0100579886,
0.053227894,
0.02084269,
0.0336397476,
-0.0128274783,
0.0078267092,
0.0425913185,
0.0583935715,
0.0463610254,
-0.0097398805,
-0.0487217978,
0.0118939187,
-0.0106187416,
0.0109394742,
-0.0340905786,
0.0791657716,
0.0039742249,
0.0150814671,
-0.0365120955,
-0.0446168669,
0.0363551565,
0.0257006139,
0.0260504112,
-0.0702394992,
0.0612121038,
0.0032735018,
0.0247118846,
0.0271085519,
-0.1043493152,
0.0181062799,
-0.0014723715,
-0.0301888734,
-0.0013327444,
-0.0151217859,
0.0475653745,
0.0120618958,
-0.0214447696,
-0.0054200417,
2.243231686e-34,
0.0503290296,
0.012500613,
-0.0048160474,
0.0008386538,
0.0363626778,
-0.0057716072,
-0.0393622965,
0.020693792,
-0.0034716462,
-0.0617826693,
-0.0133371856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01974v1
|
Dialogue-Contextualized Re-ranking for Medical History-Taking
| 2023-04-04T17:31:32 | 2023-04-04T17:31:32 |
Jian Zhu, Ilya Valmianski, Anitha Kannan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
AI-driven medical history-taking is an important component in symptom
checking, automated patient intake, triage, and other AI virtual care
applications. As history-taking is extremely varied, machine learning models
require a significant amount of data to train. To overcome this challenge,
existing systems are developed using indirect data or expert knowledge. This
leads to a training-inference gap as models are trained on different kinds of
data than what they observe at inference time. In this work, we present a
two-stage re-ranking approach that helps close the training-inference gap by
re-ranking the first-stage question candidates using a dialogue-contextualized
model. For this, we propose a new model, global re-ranker, which cross-encodes
the dialogue with all questions simultaneously, and compare it with several
existing neural baselines. We test both transformer and S4-based language model
backbones. We find that relative to the expert system, the best performance is
achieved by our proposed global re-ranker with a transformer backbone,
resulting in a 30% higher normalized discount cumulative gain (nDCG) and a 77%
higher mean average precision (mAP).
|
[
0.0616540425,
0.0672050342,
-0.0171122346,
-0.0010223184,
-0.0009261475,
0.0206670891,
-0.0069564725,
0.0065265414,
0.0325960964,
-0.0329536684,
-0.0255950447,
-0.04106858,
-0.0102473395,
0.035938587,
0.009560138,
-0.0514335819,
0.0316408686,
0.0217827857,
0.0327056758,
0.0170076787,
-0.034530133,
-0.0041947649,
-0.0491050631,
0.0450182594,
0.0117131388,
0.0006712339,
-0.0040026945,
-0.0121876113,
0.0530165024,
-0.0732043087,
0.0087654004,
0.0423280895,
0.0186413191,
-0.001029674,
0.0000019842,
-0.03956284,
-0.0301741995,
-0.0170595031,
-0.0677528903,
-0.0699570924,
-0.008513988,
0.0049175001,
0.0113559915,
0.0317417644,
-0.0683278069,
-0.0269205123,
0.0056621362,
0.0567250699,
0.0678141341,
0.0697804987,
-0.0161352623,
-0.0040155151,
0.0181867499,
-0.0390461683,
0.0013448879,
-0.0596161634,
0.0147283245,
0.0209318679,
-0.0089533525,
0.0248634834,
0.0034934713,
0.0503464155,
0.0211733188,
-0.0017671711,
0.0028997425,
0.0311369319,
-0.0217618477,
0.0339896306,
-0.0186273996,
0.0915539041,
-0.0248081498,
0.0052035637,
-0.0086598257,
-0.0027841157,
0.0358323157,
-0.0200772509,
-0.0518475473,
-0.0140302116,
-0.0066240178,
-0.0122069661,
0.0272059385,
0.0285400227,
0.0299331229,
0.0009384551,
-0.0091146287,
0.0284000412,
-0.0162334796,
-0.0420133173,
0.0004147835,
-0.0096864905,
-0.0113679487,
-0.0415928848,
0.040596351,
0.0320780016,
-0.0796292648,
0.022146767,
0.0146608986,
0.0109335259,
0.0223607495,
-0.0407593437,
-0.0256176833,
0.015957864,
-0.0039386502,
0.0308231134,
0.0038668795,
0.0352452397,
-0.002611466,
0.0105720805,
-0.054544121,
0.0062661478,
-0.0325720645,
-0.0132326642,
-0.0339598022,
0.0202072654,
-0.017921254,
0.0092778904,
-0.0602038689,
0.0030941674,
-0.0037182837,
0.0076255738,
0.0288470108,
0.0528221168,
-0.0267970003,
0.0190859977,
-0.0488935597,
0.0366939157,
-0.0065450193,
0.0125434762,
0.0220167637,
-0.0540444851,
0.004203361,
0.0034748784,
0.0083248597,
-0.0027035954,
0.0025037485,
0.0358123407,
-0.0087871179,
0.0009966824,
0.0114057716,
-0.0318149552,
-0.0143948281,
-0.013923496,
-0.0021229312,
-0.0432092845,
0.0333487466,
-0.0019944818,
0.0063712536,
-0.0383710377,
0.0287502706,
0.0265814643,
-0.0378539227,
0.0745704174,
0.0285384059,
-0.0006124434,
0.0326903649,
0.0231841933,
-0.0140881278,
0.0011655748,
0.0210195147,
-0.0113672446,
0.0280770008,
-0.0095561026,
0.0380938761,
-0.0087040337,
0.0141971949,
-0.0436193347,
0.0028271587,
0.0237160046,
-0.0421780907,
0.0852666795,
-0.0266951695,
0.0524540208,
-0.0245969146,
-0.0372933559,
0.0235294625,
0.0466028117,
0.0305524077,
0.010138154,
0.0314252637,
-0.0113217151,
-0.003922252,
0.0083169322,
-0.0347024128,
-0.0030281739,
0.0214800965,
-0.0240133777,
-0.0121694906,
-0.016240567,
-0.0278293379,
-0.0674805865,
0.0056489948,
-0.0103807151,
-0.0251450185,
0.0238004923,
0.017279882,
0.0125785368,
-0.040493153,
0.0523948297,
0.0138066309,
-0.034755934,
-0.0490499586,
-0.0604646392,
-0.0063025723,
0.0676084608,
0.0568468571,
-0.04430902,
-0.0689638928,
-0.0244285278,
-0.01877941,
-0.0076333731,
0.073134765,
-0.0427309722,
0.0274854116,
-0.0366132483,
-0.0136508308,
0.0217813458,
0.0091280825,
0.0092679281,
-0.0032069727,
-0.0060998499,
0.0107465107,
-0.007941925,
-0.0122704245,
0.0250643734,
-0.0482711345,
-0.0235326495,
0.0478766188,
0.0069729546,
0.0447958112,
0.0130013386,
0.012289091,
0.0252545588,
0.0591426603,
-0.0245913398,
-0.0339539647,
0.020094011,
-0.0914264619,
-0.0749253854,
-0.0050769597,
-0.0036964631,
-0.0015254894,
0.0257365182,
-0.0628891736,
-0.0324440338,
-0.0314196944,
-0.0176714752,
0.0175444242,
-0.0155214071,
0.0222628154,
0.0436412841,
-0.0091975909,
-0.0874880701,
0.0662849844,
-0.0319533274,
0.0233475044,
0.0352744274,
-0.0035317333,
0.0052547399,
-0.0473092236,
-0.0149084264,
-0.0076816115,
-0.0214324668,
0.0237463284,
0.0025533203,
0.0096736979,
-0.0384387523,
-0.0039025804,
-0.1617842019,
-0.005326841,
-0.0047996449,
-0.0218798332,
0.0153231127,
0.034443453,
0.0110314721,
-0.048579853,
-0.0774161741,
-0.0237735622,
0.0340450965,
0.0198655091,
0.0487059057,
0.0503601842,
0.0268323664,
-0.0473364256,
-0.016054891,
-0.0424775742,
0.0342962407,
0.0032423181,
0.0019610648,
-0.0224647298,
-0.0239773057,
-0.0501528345,
0.0265641175,
-0.0285166316,
-0.0214748438,
0.0034853879,
-0.0203293264,
-0.0033120993,
0.0707806796,
0.0081357984,
0.0113073662,
0.0193660967,
0.0152702555,
-0.0568071157,
0.0325287394,
-0.0397535525,
0.0017415847,
0.0101799173,
-0.0208236668,
-0.0066856351,
0.0666585565,
0.0127590569,
0.0059292349,
-0.0294420198,
0.0151854781,
-0.005640279,
0.0174974371,
-0.0633627772,
0.0184465814,
-0.0260923617,
0.0570935346,
-0.0002526278,
-0.0232286938,
0.0937158614,
0.0185235254,
0.0199784115,
-0.0929793715,
-0.0177696217,
-0.0472402349,
0.0184666775,
0.0022085994,
0.0178414732,
0.0012560823,
-0.0221018083,
-0.042969916,
0.0254803915,
-0.0038912396,
-0.0771181956,
0.0440636687,
-0.0442573912,
0.0049900962,
0.016088549,
-0.0697007328,
-0.0820964128,
-0.0439793877,
-0.0128543191,
0.0017946314,
-0.003012548,
0.0115041761,
-0.0434804559,
0.0126219448,
0.003626124,
0.0918035582,
-0.0019836302,
-0.0200629272,
0.0023860061,
0.0885473043,
0.0276543405,
0.0242030341,
0.0128921932,
0.0154788718,
0.0603167675,
0.046064321,
0.0492650196,
0.0065293144,
0.0009347312,
0.0054304241,
-0.0000571769,
-0.0119427564,
-0.0182109531,
0.0228656046,
-0.0009987728,
-0.0572265089,
-0.0159817375,
0.1113756672,
0.0506681018,
-0.0798358917,
0.0196003374,
-0.0204973482,
-0.0171240065,
-0.0005914603,
0.033791896,
-0.0631534159,
-0.0147575261,
-0.0138745131,
0.0179125927,
-0.0248286948,
-0.025181789,
0.0129117137,
-0.0812562779,
0.0347853638,
-0.0336023122,
-0.0252309367,
0.0113117443,
-0.023742646,
0.0044830553,
-0.0139778424,
-0.0020114167,
0.0067151026,
0.0024113411,
-0.0212371312,
-0.0110933268,
-0.0289648715,
-0.0477692559,
0.0420058109,
-0.0026613951,
0.0343497209,
0.0592219867,
0.0521956198,
0.0035959175,
-0.0198106077,
0.0127278939,
-0.0073712859,
0.0380053781,
-0.000442712,
0.0764358491,
-0.0096456157,
0.006805168,
-0.0295715146,
0.0201504566,
-0.0151297329,
-0.0046840389,
0.0098215537,
0.062219087,
-0.0542179756,
0.0127120372,
-0.0168271288,
0.0137149356,
0.0231966097,
0.0533414222,
0.0094688693,
-0.0201371945,
-0.0116182286,
-0.0268899985,
0.0503926277,
-0.0063502635,
-0.0324686877,
0.0144063774,
0.0159037542,
-0.0231755413,
-0.1071370244,
-0.0417695418,
0.0009330856,
0.0060664089,
-0.016355101,
-0.0046440354,
0.0096424883,
0.0094504142,
-0.0582069568,
0.0369680226,
0.0226399954,
0.0064052837,
-0.0461333953,
0.0047937115,
0.0832468197,
-0.0019112068,
-0.0479490608,
0.0119517194,
-0.0410465226,
-0.0006045402,
0.0045303754,
0.0756733567,
0.0165949035,
0.0461503193,
-0.030535059,
0.0112350881,
0.0405913182,
0.0133451913,
-0.0426598676,
-0.0345957801,
0.0250992924,
0.0301665869,
-0.0209383424,
0.029357126,
-0.0456698053,
0.0143120158,
-0.0158444289,
0.0382564627,
-0.0362014696,
-0.0507166237,
0.0333427712,
-0.0126726907,
0.0442968607,
0.0265237596,
-0.0268757939,
-0.0105650909,
0.0545084924,
-0.0388254747,
-0.0143267373,
-0.0253218021,
0.0241561793,
0.0296372101,
-0.0066865021,
0.0057727573,
-0.0108595537,
-0.0575215705,
-0.0037629639,
-0.0626521185,
-0.0072822422,
0.0345991775,
-0.001555477,
0.0202932525,
-0.0015675541,
-0.0125361877,
0.0190273169,
0.0406667255,
0.0631437823,
-0.0161825977,
0.0740590319,
-0.0004953936,
-0.0055677728,
-0.015249935,
0.0719041675,
-0.0978611857,
-0.0620618835,
-0.023687968,
-0.0128790112,
0.0358640216,
0.0108379284,
0.0182749499,
0.0293098334,
0.0103359111,
0.0064328201,
0.000166541,
0.0237719771,
-0.0142466677,
0.0420538485,
0.0292142257,
0.017121695,
0.064962931,
0.0850101486,
-0.0437296145,
0.0281212702,
0.0010106291,
-0.0476545803,
-0.063579984,
-0.0102136582,
0.0019178591,
0.0376413986,
-0.0229544453,
0.0082203886,
-0.0368615538,
-0.0285506099,
0.0149628008,
-0.0213589463,
-0.0213888232,
-0.0309128445,
0.0523654111,
0.0479476601,
-0.0001489446,
-0.0323374234,
-0.0618247055,
0.0220505018,
-0.034149304,
-0.038525328,
-0.0347398221,
-6.011639006e-33,
-0.0006091475,
-0.0217288658,
0.0233365968,
-0.0333817452,
-0.0123767573,
0.0278643593,
-0.0349192657,
-0.0133811943,
-0.0413354747,
0.0172224808,
-0.0256533772,
0.0215918776,
0.0127630467,
0.0450569801,
0.0008905683,
-0.033083085,
0.0389838256,
0.0086622881,
-0.025970811,
0.0494543873,
-0.0075786556,
0.0444732048,
0.0424026586,
-0.0787629113,
0.0021477831,
0.0032017487,
0.0327613167,
0.0491814017,
-0.0279677343,
0.069226861,
-0.0180213209,
0.0272760708,
0.060729403,
-0.0665636212,
0.0239942111,
0.0149586778,
-0.0699911937,
-0.0253735092,
-0.029553391,
-0.020681493,
-0.0549596734,
-0.0103102047,
0.0221521817,
-0.0182540845,
0.0223610941,
-0.01233707,
0.0284942705,
-0.0271469187,
-0.015261895,
-0.032110177,
0.0058095609,
0.035943564,
-0.0247585177,
-0.0330694206,
-0.0341831893,
0.1193685234,
-0.0225932207,
0.0428597853,
-0.0246451404,
0.0047505819,
-0.0052741026,
0.0222061835,
0.0032611499,
-0.0276015997,
-0.054755047,
0.0284927562,
0.0297321752,
-0.0073178275,
-0.0372724533,
-0.021501733,
-0.0592239052,
0.0397177152,
0.0497354493,
0.0298083108,
0.0182513911,
0.0187206864,
-0.0822014287,
0.0434057675,
-0.012828649,
0.0558882169,
-0.0005872032,
-0.0064165443,
-0.05035064,
-0.0181558933,
-0.0561142154,
-0.0193637218,
-0.0282387789,
-0.0345094427,
0.0482006297,
0.0162393283,
-0.006672556,
0.0247287378,
0.0068944064,
-0.0292825028,
0.0252522305,
0.015404202,
0.0172783062,
0.0129171517,
0.0003028063,
0.0248921309,
-0.0348224007,
0.0484491847,
0.0470973477,
0.0057259211,
0.0435282998,
0.0160840377,
0.0291630793,
-0.021223342,
-0.0297910124,
-0.0118826721,
0.018261658,
-0.0133793429,
-0.0358392633,
0.0874245316,
-0.0000557682,
0.0261391532,
-0.0123814661,
0.0740831271,
0.0093142465,
0.014062522,
-0.0636950135,
-0.0413640328,
0.0273198728,
-0.0002934953,
-0.0356957391,
-0.0163666885,
-0.015917588,
0.061160855,
0.0245368127,
-0.0571804941,
-0.0185021479,
-0.0004343891,
2.729e-7,
0.04831497,
0.0456324853,
0.0125707509,
-0.0131178498,
0.0379465222,
0.0232538674,
0.0302071404,
0.0079956632,
0.0373746119,
0.0127699105,
0.0483055525,
-0.0161777902,
0.0464299321,
0.0327083096,
-0.0754654035,
-0.0696780011,
-0.0854874775,
-0.0454329327,
-0.0111874212,
-0.0432251953,
0.0675204471,
0.1083893999,
-0.0303937122,
-0.0269231219,
0.0032292635,
0.0117788659,
0.0221783537,
-0.0184713528,
-0.0271274839,
0.0157691576,
0.0252886005,
0.0246212799,
0.0058132987,
0.042532932,
-0.0390347131,
0.0163535103,
0.0126030445,
0.0831907466,
-0.049715519,
-0.0556621887,
0.0008540651,
0.0321950689,
0.0259375423,
-0.0697425976,
0.0767321065,
-0.0726178512,
-0.0168839451,
0.0141524421,
-0.0457408018,
-0.0018981568,
0.0680528358,
-0.0185757969,
-0.0408040024,
0.0342839323,
0.0255990215,
0.0242595877,
0.0020216468,
-0.093168959,
-0.0395116284,
0.0014819857,
-0.0382849798,
-0.0197899621,
0.0415481851,
-0.0822115093,
-0.0128025487,
-0.0468048491,
0.0222949721,
2.475263709e-34,
0.0422259122,
0.0264479704,
-0.0034327225,
0.0257341843,
0.0404867381,
0.0029922489,
0.0357080027,
0.0078460863,
0.0351358354,
-0.0825609937,
-0.03317298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01969v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01969v2
|
MEGClass: Extremely Weakly Supervised Text Classification via Mutually-Enhancing Text Granularities
| 2023-04-04T17:26:11 | 2023-10-29T21:03:54 |
Priyanka Kargupta, Tanay Komarlu, Susik Yoon, Xuan Wang, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text classification is essential for organizing unstructured text.
Traditional methods rely on human annotations or, more recently, a set of class
seed words for supervision, which can be costly, particularly for specialized
or emerging domains. To address this, using class surface names alone as
extremely weak supervision has been proposed. However, existing approaches
treat different levels of text granularity (documents, sentences, or words)
independently, disregarding inter-granularity class disagreements and the
context identifiable exclusively through joint extraction. In order to tackle
these issues, we introduce MEGClass, an extremely weakly-supervised text
classification method that leverages Mutually-Enhancing Text Granularities.
MEGClass utilizes coarse- and fine-grained context signals obtained by jointly
considering a document's most class-indicative words and sentences. This
approach enables the learning of a contextualized document representation that
captures the most discriminative class indicators. By preserving the
heterogeneity of potential classes, MEGClass can select the most informative
class-indicative documents as iterative feedback to enhance the initial
word-based class representations and ultimately fine-tune a pre-trained text
classifier. Extensive experiments on seven benchmark datasets demonstrate that
MEGClass outperforms other weakly and extremely weakly supervised methods.
|
[
0.0151612423,
0.0317731351,
0.0151052978,
0.0173849706,
0.0084891543,
0.0464655496,
0.0036201214,
0.0138343973,
-0.0064811017,
-0.0728146359,
-0.03121268,
0.0174793601,
-0.0073294919,
-0.0078363931,
0.0015935154,
-0.045798447,
0.0342296921,
0.0006687005,
-0.0069681415,
0.0248486977,
0.0251948852,
-0.0103507582,
-0.0000929887,
-0.0309832506,
0.0071563805,
0.0008373423,
-0.0218614936,
-0.0096130809,
0.0067762635,
-0.0170047805,
0.055097539,
0.0636831075,
0.0450072996,
0.0659174547,
0.0000019807,
-0.0321456045,
-0.0073856846,
0.0008597855,
-0.0189929269,
-0.003142393,
0.0289822686,
-0.0468956046,
0.027853597,
-0.0353815444,
-0.0038048192,
-0.0128821088,
0.0236654207,
0.1078483909,
0.0329333805,
0.056373056,
-0.0429235846,
-0.035863746,
-0.0066826153,
-0.0337913036,
0.0342108048,
-0.0435300954,
0.0226692855,
-0.0045399354,
-0.0213761106,
0.075422667,
0.0115755182,
0.0256795976,
-0.0115431966,
0.0072058477,
0.0229914393,
0.0404114276,
-0.0131290909,
0.0045172879,
0.01290897,
0.0524131656,
0.0291683748,
-0.0323240981,
0.0132154301,
-0.0495826155,
0.0096148923,
-0.0220926646,
-0.0069509628,
-0.0039968328,
-0.0196114574,
0.0147542628,
0.0241403375,
0.0524371043,
0.0051196711,
0.0440627635,
-0.0237844959,
-0.0248408876,
-0.0169539154,
-0.054218173,
0.0325267427,
0.0236078259,
-0.0168191008,
0.0226900168,
0.01203393,
-0.0028757253,
0.0226255059,
-0.0273655429,
-0.0401179604,
-0.0508481786,
0.0654780641,
-0.0624918193,
-0.0064963968,
-0.0392958298,
-0.0123991985,
0.0653362796,
0.0064976965,
-0.0573405102,
0.0069387988,
-0.0076917303,
-0.00088728,
0.0008155096,
-0.0590203479,
0.0026744143,
-0.0085620135,
0.0624973737,
-0.0210683607,
-0.0025239016,
-0.0464959368,
-0.0031443124,
-0.0052844668,
-0.0123641333,
-0.0580191314,
0.0133502688,
-0.0312788822,
0.0328059681,
-0.0156791434,
-0.0160361547,
-0.0342599563,
0.0474349,
-0.0102431299,
0.0140098203,
0.0200225562,
0.0309048612,
0.0240796227,
-0.0274573583,
0.0165843014,
0.0487362966,
-0.0528421886,
-0.0891768187,
-0.0681984052,
-0.0158149712,
-0.0188594107,
-0.0238243192,
-0.0161412451,
-0.0239908975,
0.012724068,
0.0138586853,
-0.0311446339,
-0.0033108136,
0.0003927442,
-0.0181145035,
-0.0249341633,
0.0835396051,
-0.0436918959,
-0.0268048812,
0.0903511494,
0.0416676737,
0.0110252611,
0.0329062454,
-0.0168419164,
0.0398845673,
0.0287239272,
-0.0034631409,
0.0674268752,
-0.0166269671,
0.0147300027,
-0.0234571025,
0.0163339525,
0.0015235427,
-0.0001411824,
-0.010217825,
0.0056766998,
-0.0098293945,
-0.00589148,
0.005424845,
0.0352631323,
0.0107740443,
-0.0254983846,
0.0426128283,
0.0088695288,
-0.0035563342,
-0.0336791798,
0.0082443161,
-0.0132563701,
-0.0304034911,
-0.0554541983,
-0.0115733938,
0.0045898659,
-0.0187393948,
-0.0202306416,
-0.0602103807,
0.0057081389,
-0.0348704308,
0.0094805947,
-0.0119114583,
0.07161396,
0.010692142,
-0.0028732484,
0.0131976288,
0.0590415783,
-0.0500578508,
-0.0370470583,
-0.0124813179,
0.0393988825,
0.0141379079,
-0.0189210512,
-0.0919397399,
-0.0031426882,
-0.0079787094,
0.0645876229,
0.0267526805,
0.0409448445,
-0.0072215344,
0.0367054753,
-0.0669195354,
-0.0351696014,
-0.0078493087,
0.0261817593,
0.0035308136,
-0.0093261916,
0.0055475524,
0.0283359513,
-0.005845983,
-0.0399615765,
0.069237344,
-0.0042071077,
-0.0696325004,
0.0065978593,
0.0118934959,
0.0423619375,
-0.0200268086,
-0.0158252604,
-0.0398026705,
0.0598600432,
-0.0259165317,
-0.0196369532,
-0.0818737224,
-0.0549306422,
-0.0382133499,
-0.035339728,
0.0261651408,
-0.0279679727,
-0.0091447113,
-0.043020606,
-0.0373476259,
-0.027431991,
0.0293519888,
0.0048454157,
-0.0517745689,
-0.0099290721,
-0.0105495574,
0.0230841879,
-0.0808239803,
0.0776323527,
0.0433485322,
0.0588775538,
0.0351999514,
-0.0049025174,
0.0136821717,
-0.0032053366,
-0.0388990156,
0.0184853114,
-0.0287023596,
0.032646168,
0.030022379,
0.0188571662,
-0.0336079933,
-0.0261392053,
-0.0454867296,
-0.0124750333,
0.0065694596,
0.008080354,
0.0080390153,
-0.0071226759,
-0.0039816042,
-0.0250482559,
-0.0049230889,
0.012669038,
-0.0298407637,
-0.0049431869,
0.0367915146,
-0.0040311352,
0.0493706204,
-0.0114609879,
0.0100126443,
0.0081414189,
0.042952314,
0.0318725817,
-0.0331727825,
-0.0273100864,
0.0641227961,
0.0064075436,
0.012430192,
-0.0083236778,
-0.0010319153,
-0.0095744543,
-0.0308939647,
0.0064813732,
0.0365911871,
-0.004334745,
0.0499516726,
0.0023580976,
0.0017046406,
-0.0272014774,
-0.0048000766,
-0.030519342,
0.0380720049,
-0.0217019096,
0.0035978835,
0.0129784038,
0.0729785413,
0.0054924209,
-0.0062189181,
-0.0099259028,
-0.0351693518,
-0.0049161771,
0.0081046512,
-0.0172554422,
0.0164457206,
0.0225108061,
0.0062507298,
-0.0192273036,
-0.0314636789,
0.036526002,
-0.0091850581,
-0.0042683063,
-0.0437287427,
-0.0551695153,
-0.0051427069,
0.0227090716,
-0.0045578037,
0.0102202753,
0.0203090422,
-0.0275502484,
-0.02416935,
-0.0417694747,
0.0120030083,
-0.006800055,
0.0371746495,
0.0143859303,
0.0247755125,
-0.052791249,
-0.0369257219,
-0.0069550076,
-0.0642355159,
0.0362857208,
0.0364437513,
0.0186806042,
0.0152545441,
-0.0485827141,
0.0028568632,
-0.0003162681,
0.0513829961,
-0.0120670823,
-0.0509255603,
-0.0293990299,
0.0730597749,
-0.0064808624,
0.0228521731,
-0.0211962163,
-0.0262520351,
0.0093268733,
0.06191919,
-0.004146717,
-0.0104226805,
-0.0321172252,
-0.0037976531,
-0.0045531197,
-0.0157017466,
-0.0031273759,
-0.0225505158,
0.0436102152,
-0.0407785214,
-0.0375443734,
0.0910743624,
0.0279107001,
-0.059432324,
-0.0268150643,
0.0248457193,
0.0463013388,
0.0353247523,
0.0006993344,
-0.010596117,
-0.0562973581,
-0.0117693711,
0.0397603475,
0.0103919087,
-0.0147968009,
0.047800567,
-0.0433061086,
0.003990462,
-0.0023571432,
-0.0698000118,
-0.0082790758,
-0.0643026754,
0.0039886306,
-0.0036907354,
-0.0488976873,
-0.0312300101,
-0.0178081319,
-0.022007348,
0.021479506,
-0.002132575,
-0.0460712574,
-0.0003114308,
0.0000117418,
0.0022815773,
-0.0003029381,
0.0320007727,
-0.0500950776,
0.0256740786,
0.0796870291,
-0.1117420122,
-0.0056767333,
-0.0222369637,
0.104237929,
-0.0187847912,
0.0143383751,
-0.0236610193,
0.0375254676,
-0.0269280449,
-0.05106638,
0.017250387,
0.0381632037,
-0.0477579534,
-0.0152227068,
-0.0398803726,
-0.0273573082,
0.017847443,
0.0433349386,
0.0145224165,
-0.0742078424,
-0.0299431756,
0.0103735942,
0.0475019701,
0.0272137634,
0.0469857901,
0.0106756482,
-0.046010863,
-0.0466337353,
-0.0621886626,
-0.0468227081,
0.0261143968,
0.0285717957,
0.0000717675,
-0.001534225,
-0.020574376,
-0.0270511955,
-0.0460846722,
0.0323953331,
-0.003921668,
-0.0247130059,
-0.05728947,
-0.0694431067,
0.0702767074,
-0.0225906391,
-0.0250050854,
0.036251206,
-0.0360834412,
-0.0460126549,
0.0167264361,
-0.0125137558,
0.0026449852,
0.0199355334,
0.0202835053,
-0.0629442707,
0.1042258069,
0.0918897465,
-0.0481904335,
-0.0065963934,
0.0572826676,
0.0126980748,
-0.0363992862,
-0.0123538254,
-0.0288225319,
0.0843283162,
0.048497472,
-0.0389482677,
-0.0348139592,
0.0073570968,
-0.0109163476,
-0.0408924185,
0.0423695073,
-0.0220798925,
0.0072542648,
-0.0524356924,
-0.0015548199,
0.0590156801,
-0.0186714381,
-0.0024023438,
-0.0090836706,
0.0272041429,
-0.0008786535,
-0.0287027229,
0.0514598265,
-0.0039471397,
0.0647980049,
-0.0684438944,
-0.0057601375,
0.010102028,
0.009438918,
-0.0173019655,
0.0249969494,
-0.0047630393,
0.0001123989,
-0.0119288787,
0.0185214952,
-0.02847955,
0.0715887919,
0.0386766382,
0.0415133238,
-0.0267014802,
0.0147617459,
-0.0854319409,
0.0779063404,
-0.0269259345,
0.0434888899,
0.0304525979,
-0.0581872836,
-0.0031460773,
-0.0149282077,
-0.0180776343,
0.0122114811,
0.0573605858,
0.0209405273,
-0.0127295908,
-0.0102716349,
0.0239858497,
-0.025949005,
0.0440114513,
0.0456322357,
0.0147157758,
0.0035191479,
0.0263857879,
-0.0219833571,
-0.0579448119,
0.0153696146,
0.1045788452,
0.0612181239,
0.0020172617,
0.0075760172,
0.0132436305,
-0.0070616133,
0.0280381013,
-0.0391265005,
-0.0242575649,
0.0057793893,
0.0375181064,
0.0649718344,
-0.0015972921,
-0.0063431105,
-0.0344181955,
0.0019124347,
0.0149725201,
0.0211529974,
-0.0263510384,
-6.387709036e-33,
-0.0118585965,
-0.0180871636,
-0.0342264138,
0.0629635081,
0.0233890396,
0.037948031,
-0.0109228184,
-0.0109157888,
0.0126338033,
0.0221887063,
-0.0061556813,
0.0187813565,
-0.0008727964,
0.075386174,
0.0231441334,
-0.0137497047,
0.0407133326,
0.0285768509,
-0.016608065,
0.0739781037,
0.0205422509,
0.0333326124,
0.0459709689,
-0.1215653047,
0.0182431415,
-0.0132275913,
-0.00582373,
-0.030977549,
-0.0029152487,
0.0354367271,
-0.0462962948,
0.0234873854,
0.0455017835,
0.028475387,
0.0048685516,
0.0398032218,
-0.0762480795,
-0.0281975102,
-0.0521934852,
-0.0120170582,
-0.0089926859,
-0.0212297235,
0.0105254352,
-0.0203693528,
0.0104787601,
0.000676545,
0.0909304172,
-0.0105570843,
-0.0248942357,
-0.0724381655,
-0.033743307,
0.0375302695,
-0.022094246,
0.0020071801,
0.0354584754,
-0.0281450041,
0.015252403,
0.0579035021,
-0.0578061342,
-0.0140367504,
0.0464848541,
0.0301994141,
-0.0316838473,
0.0282628946,
-0.022175014,
0.0635393783,
0.0345130265,
0.0399025604,
0.0431190208,
-0.0306523722,
0.0147572318,
0.0524150357,
0.0187591817,
0.053260427,
0.0699455366,
-0.0146720419,
-0.0480835065,
0.040125791,
-0.0093782097,
-0.0232972652,
0.0272082333,
0.0115934638,
-0.0352908708,
-0.0304646194,
-0.0171081834,
-0.0229297914,
-0.0188742485,
0.043475274,
-0.0043416778,
0.0256230105,
-0.0150720235,
0.0309436955,
0.0281180982,
-0.0208782963,
-0.0845561326,
-0.0254090745,
-0.0127206435,
0.0289254785,
-0.0103878714,
-0.0769499168,
-0.0577117652,
-0.1005281806,
0.0429480635,
0.0042358818,
0.0145914536,
-0.0030441207,
0.082260482,
0.0038790503,
-0.0745964125,
0.0000340788,
0.0248419065,
-0.0026801261,
0.00810418,
0.0184579697,
-0.0161838867,
-0.0118121756,
0.0071094856,
0.0808392987,
0.0589738786,
0.0095220767,
0.0000348615,
-0.0433641374,
-0.0147549808,
0.0138192996,
0.0071413415,
-0.0174529031,
-0.0058907969,
-0.0098116687,
0.077285029,
-0.075565666,
0.0180353131,
-0.0076302523,
2.642e-7,
0.0453001037,
0.0573132709,
-0.0059313066,
-0.0744815245,
0.0158449579,
0.0747749284,
-0.0146041,
0.0035810967,
-0.0563613959,
-0.0172465015,
0.009735412,
-0.0080988975,
0.045299679,
0.0113411127,
-0.066032812,
0.0287202112,
-0.0450238138,
-0.0323780514,
-0.0706824213,
0.0259127356,
0.0921733826,
0.0897053108,
-0.00031757,
-0.0321367271,
-0.004183806,
-0.0816296339,
0.0419805907,
-0.0348092839,
0.0432781205,
0.0379859135,
0.0150713371,
-0.001063535,
-0.0169969127,
0.023128571,
-0.0276499316,
-0.0071142968,
0.0107533876,
0.0600189716,
-0.0224569943,
0.0331989191,
0.0225722734,
0.0240541305,
0.0283023398,
0.001657829,
0.0521449298,
-0.0745984986,
-0.044535663,
-0.0216677692,
-0.0138179865,
-0.0312250163,
0.020639563,
0.0108402846,
0.021980051,
0.008668703,
-0.0166726932,
0.0112314746,
-0.0613637567,
-0.0919952318,
0.0085411239,
0.0108137848,
-0.0135805197,
0.0243239328,
-0.010590611,
-0.0077891028,
0.0585677847,
-0.0873886347,
0.0114725856,
2.525842109e-34,
0.0157127418,
-0.0030511299,
-0.0414629355,
-0.0035746226,
0.0063690213,
0.0027363757,
0.0286963396,
0.0162337963,
-0.0264633745,
-0.0287720859,
0.0422495157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01961v1
|
AToMiC: An Image/Text Retrieval Test Collection to Support Multimedia Content Creation
| 2023-04-04T17:11:34 | 2023-04-04T17:11:34 |
Jheng-Hong Yang, Carlos Lassance, Rafael Sampaio de Rezende, Krishna Srinivasan, Miriam Redi, Stéphane Clinchant, Jimmy Lin
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper presents the AToMiC (Authoring Tools for Multimedia Content)
dataset, designed to advance research in image/text cross-modal retrieval.
While vision-language pretrained transformers have led to significant
improvements in retrieval effectiveness, existing research has relied on
image-caption datasets that feature only simplistic image-text relationships
and underspecified user models of retrieval tasks. To address the gap between
these oversimplified settings and real-world applications for multimedia
content creation, we introduce a new approach for building retrieval test
collections. We leverage hierarchical structures and diverse domains of texts,
styles, and types of images, as well as large-scale image-document associations
embedded in Wikipedia. We formulate two tasks based on a realistic user model
and validate our dataset through retrieval experiments using baseline models.
AToMiC offers a testbed for scalable, diverse, and reproducible multimedia
retrieval research. Finally, the dataset provides the basis for a dedicated
track at the 2023 Text Retrieval Conference (TREC), and is publicly available
at https://github.com/TREC-AToMiC/AToMiC.
|
[
0.0494891182,
0.0559497066,
-0.0085564107,
0.0243175477,
-0.0173781794,
0.0183259659,
0.0378039777,
0.0613304041,
0.0176626127,
-0.0565701909,
-0.0538847148,
-0.0199676789,
-0.0428926349,
0.0451431572,
0.0027110409,
-0.0635806024,
0.0027290469,
0.0078661619,
-0.0198447611,
0.0175078604,
0.0287195072,
-0.0144544216,
0.0200002603,
0.0285022482,
-0.063742958,
0.0073204385,
-0.0180557743,
0.0709364191,
0.0015234419,
-0.0160699878,
0.0078203212,
0.0640243068,
0.0650930777,
0.025792392,
0.0000017053,
0.0044263764,
0.029398853,
-0.0196433738,
0.0496145822,
-0.0367849655,
0.076341778,
-0.0041970434,
0.0183792524,
-0.0377641805,
-0.0237235464,
0.0075625093,
0.0630332232,
0.0491546728,
0.0557093695,
0.0696226731,
-0.0414525159,
-0.0193922929,
0.0101839639,
-0.0328690931,
0.0719190314,
0.0073098233,
0.0074620764,
0.0032189742,
0.0104354527,
0.0360242948,
0.0024083324,
0.0663755164,
-0.0133456364,
-0.0459430218,
0.0323056318,
0.0229242854,
-0.0300272685,
-0.0346138515,
0.000190145,
0.0497178808,
0.0590921566,
0.0065167341,
-0.0074940911,
0.0187249146,
-0.0121769523,
0.0613462217,
-0.05734488,
0.0115340874,
-0.0106149055,
-0.0478778817,
-0.0628889799,
0.0191500504,
-0.0182437375,
-0.0277798939,
0.0177658722,
-0.0056386008,
0.0473413356,
-0.0038451804,
-0.0279501192,
0.0181869287,
0.0027321912,
-0.0315450765,
0.0190476142,
0.0038185851,
0.0114734014,
-0.0067597879,
-0.0269185379,
-0.0626227334,
0.0303260628,
-0.035487663,
-0.0056026732,
0.0092647513,
-0.052542273,
0.0799790919,
-0.0124395173,
0.0232403334,
-0.0208822098,
0.0318730101,
-0.0294393487,
0.0052729929,
-0.0565043353,
-0.026331421,
-0.0292702299,
-0.0177899655,
-0.0227540378,
-0.0409396738,
-0.0183192994,
0.0239130743,
-0.0280510671,
-0.0085737985,
-0.0068040974,
0.0358932763,
-0.0678093061,
0.0164692923,
-0.0615726374,
0.0224146321,
-0.0007582988,
0.0329148024,
0.0023459927,
0.0040887604,
0.0215317179,
0.0213316977,
0.0346914195,
-0.0291496161,
0.0163616575,
0.0169816948,
-0.0394612513,
-0.0380577967,
0.0063759997,
-0.0480818823,
0.0033430539,
-0.0202620458,
0.037639752,
-0.0583642907,
0.032069318,
0.0176213086,
-0.0173873212,
-0.0551066548,
-0.0237724259,
0.0485642999,
-0.0220842492,
0.0699224621,
-0.0040013241,
0.0115574319,
0.050205756,
0.0465401784,
0.006582113,
0.0529908016,
-0.0103734573,
0.0819600075,
0.0667939037,
0.0275756381,
0.0029139402,
0.0282818284,
0.0069388254,
0.0281313527,
-0.006124361,
0.0256677177,
-0.0252208523,
0.0376804173,
0.0013731871,
0.02045241,
-0.0452384278,
-0.0074469782,
0.0618585832,
0.0489333905,
0.0331275165,
0.0198921133,
0.0438769758,
-0.0135752801,
0.0007633904,
0.0006955615,
-0.0191645771,
0.0764990747,
0.0196716581,
0.004562078,
0.0060092583,
0.0217924174,
-0.0513469316,
-0.0199340358,
0.041535221,
0.005084591,
0.0113626942,
-0.0069823409,
0.0582942478,
0.0036530767,
-0.0282974895,
0.0347433574,
-0.010271322,
-0.1044243276,
0.0193935614,
-0.0281053297,
0.0087678041,
0.0664886907,
0.0451425053,
-0.051096689,
0.0227987748,
0.0245811567,
0.0504913665,
0.046218656,
-0.0258492492,
-0.014342349,
-0.0121227913,
-0.0378221273,
-0.0649773926,
-0.0342083871,
-0.0211968943,
0.0252918974,
-0.0080422759,
0.0203049593,
0.0543561168,
-0.054950539,
0.0078392327,
0.0449315608,
0.0206535086,
-0.0082936082,
-0.0245189015,
0.0582082644,
-0.0275211912,
-0.0003194356,
-0.0406656601,
0.0059640883,
0.0233962741,
0.0079443576,
-0.0051799561,
0.0275921077,
-0.0125323664,
-0.0155803626,
0.0106056565,
-0.0893110558,
0.0074154311,
0.024013605,
0.0121526057,
-0.0505921692,
0.0430114567,
-0.0012747924,
0.0054734033,
-0.0705408528,
-0.0172648281,
0.0008639528,
0.0049405368,
-0.016872948,
0.0555364415,
0.0399411209,
-0.0076697916,
0.027297711,
-0.0051794848,
0.0370046943,
-0.010260026,
-0.0556247793,
-0.0336622484,
0.0036920758,
0.0565644652,
0.0582142062,
0.0105740344,
-0.0771508142,
-0.0318220854,
-0.116756767,
-0.0104523767,
-0.0333979875,
-0.0218852609,
-0.0380060859,
0.00704369,
0.0061865146,
-0.0419279411,
-0.0270134322,
0.0196051151,
0.0049915044,
0.0332063287,
0.0309792757,
0.030005835,
0.0282793045,
-0.0235001668,
-0.0539148748,
0.0146424482,
0.0699492991,
0.0339769013,
0.0135112889,
0.0165896639,
0.0371579118,
-0.0343238823,
0.0056905588,
-0.0159841683,
0.0148745943,
0.053051427,
-0.0458648503,
0.0311340354,
0.0490450896,
0.0193578694,
0.0019737978,
-0.0324999392,
-0.0297768787,
-0.0513959229,
0.0187450126,
0.0163118523,
-0.038053818,
0.027437428,
-0.0172732025,
0.0233257953,
0.0096452637,
-0.0269646626,
0.0140724937,
-0.0678031594,
0.0086618699,
0.0309098661,
-0.0034943584,
-0.0483415611,
0.0145613104,
0.0426946729,
0.0425658189,
-0.0440059006,
-0.0410524532,
0.0594344139,
-0.0241019204,
-0.0122688897,
0.03729311,
0.0175512154,
-0.0271493532,
0.0994434208,
0.0192846488,
0.021991374,
0.007974159,
0.0165109113,
-0.0393680297,
0.0256539807,
0.0505437367,
-0.0329782143,
0.046068266,
0.0104999505,
0.0257985611,
-0.0529312007,
-0.0670721754,
-0.002509617,
-0.0326662622,
0.0110250469,
-0.0415192246,
-0.0203637667,
0.0085993186,
-0.0595240071,
-0.0007673922,
0.0311006866,
0.0245186985,
0.0050243773,
-0.0390387997,
0.0068075322,
0.075677067,
0.0295419637,
-0.03252073,
-0.0682114139,
-0.0062984903,
-0.0092403311,
0.0263304394,
0.0354975685,
-0.0198471062,
-0.0480236299,
0.0411127284,
0.0188102107,
0.025041813,
-0.0118231066,
0.0205566678,
0.0432187617,
-0.0407699421,
-0.0221693702,
0.0376189984,
0.0291439556,
-0.0752647892,
-0.0829086006,
0.0046192282,
0.0155340629,
0.0486584827,
0.0428274833,
-0.0954993889,
-0.0244169217,
-0.034872558,
-0.0053948532,
-0.0014751875,
0.0053091962,
-0.0048854179,
-0.052043464,
0.0547089502,
-0.0104179429,
0.0068865013,
-0.020549383,
-0.0442192852,
0.0048481189,
0.012708568,
-0.0488118716,
0.0207451452,
-0.00538994,
-0.0060745869,
-0.0043526189,
0.0641025603,
-0.0468417518,
-0.0028604257,
-0.0636669621,
-0.0149202766,
0.0277626403,
0.0311378706,
-0.0087333843,
-0.0705010816,
-0.0416592695,
-0.0067419661,
0.0056606121,
0.0005572979,
0.093133837,
-0.0216178279,
-0.019848695,
-0.0304932147,
-0.0092232199,
-0.009454295,
-0.0344555378,
-0.0070485543,
0.0211425051,
-0.0048439559,
0.0331566297,
-0.0907497555,
0.0028926129,
0.0352205709,
-0.0026544007,
0.0145219918,
-0.0200342331,
-0.0274872072,
-0.044905223,
0.0347205102,
-0.0728271529,
-0.0329533927,
-0.011370983,
-0.0261556283,
0.0334001146,
-0.052525185,
0.0015308554,
0.0116064642,
0.0306698568,
0.0041750129,
-0.0199544318,
-0.026526073,
0.0007896801,
-0.1126806289,
0.0588119067,
-0.0138882929,
0.0278817136,
-0.035756208,
-0.0134388879,
0.0425072312,
-0.0692240819,
-0.0075339996,
0.0066640647,
-0.0632095784,
-0.0180916917,
-0.0278380793,
0.0578121915,
0.0104018021,
-0.0139684603,
0.0396158546,
-0.0906832889,
0.0592685267,
0.0644793436,
-0.0218244642,
-0.0300529469,
-0.0158887841,
-0.0382252,
-0.0567814223,
0.0063250442,
-0.0768008977,
0.0222251844,
0.0084250448,
0.0005041244,
0.027311895,
-0.0322952829,
-0.0168408472,
-0.0103838611,
0.007750784,
-0.0100834938,
0.0354821607,
-0.050940197,
-0.0262219924,
-0.01844435,
-0.0209428295,
-0.0230217166,
0.0082219085,
-0.0090435036,
-0.0089544272,
-0.0120109692,
0.0442427918,
0.0030055011,
0.0384941772,
-0.0574674606,
0.0181454308,
0.0246964004,
0.0071956296,
0.0003433813,
0.0020106174,
0.0126045281,
0.0048835929,
-0.0122129107,
0.0600277297,
-0.0267221089,
0.0625498146,
0.0234062597,
0.0011541838,
-0.0343319513,
0.0409187004,
-0.0520747118,
0.0217078868,
-0.0156848431,
-0.0109849889,
0.0480420552,
-0.0292721018,
0.0018749692,
-0.0318736807,
-0.0401448198,
-0.0102492748,
0.0052316869,
-0.0045292005,
-0.0333624482,
0.0120344162,
0.0213379096,
0.0195391681,
0.0351941697,
0.051479876,
0.0001287769,
-0.0069865491,
0.0022645732,
-0.0451515988,
-0.0169248767,
-0.0004639137,
0.0508176498,
-0.0062300703,
-0.012588772,
-0.0403079763,
-0.0171714462,
-0.0550717115,
0.0316581242,
0.0078787394,
-0.0257163551,
0.0416559987,
0.0522180684,
0.0817642808,
0.0433680154,
-0.0089210132,
-0.0018046892,
-0.0220096465,
-0.0563712791,
0.0062423269,
0.0061762985,
-5.396888521e-33,
-0.0329418369,
-0.0328875296,
0.0262983553,
0.0240066107,
-0.0202168897,
0.0208629724,
-0.0321454592,
-0.0076056062,
0.0065025371,
-0.0064594578,
-0.0270719901,
-0.0064629815,
0.0064509856,
0.0322051682,
0.0108032348,
0.0385182239,
0.0515682548,
-0.0129485382,
-0.0437938273,
0.0369740948,
0.0349188186,
0.0105829732,
0.0112193702,
-0.0695248321,
-0.0144604705,
-0.0009870848,
-0.0053315619,
-0.0120512722,
0.0254470985,
0.0785057098,
-0.007730579,
0.0471537896,
0.013858634,
-0.0064995294,
0.0158517044,
0.0188983791,
-0.0663057566,
-0.0078443727,
-0.0298899654,
0.0089105442,
-0.0459422618,
-0.0086015286,
0.052585192,
-0.0358192213,
0.0036528946,
-0.0276103243,
0.0751392841,
0.0237013679,
0.0149517376,
-0.0449633002,
-0.0411765538,
0.0015975239,
-0.0158219337,
-0.0314629078,
0.0256531276,
0.0021159893,
0.0555128008,
0.014508252,
-0.0810431913,
0.0824817196,
-0.0520616397,
0.0245912876,
0.0382734872,
0.0550088733,
0.0060836286,
0.0577220991,
0.0231452174,
0.0332579017,
-0.0102860685,
-0.0365254693,
0.0237566009,
0.0574903451,
0.0150086395,
0.0947076678,
0.0173034295,
-0.0303486586,
-0.0090624178,
0.0627871826,
-0.0391765311,
0.0352153368,
-0.0123335151,
0.0334706083,
0.0104072671,
0.0105761234,
-0.0527374558,
-0.0243104398,
-0.0687956586,
-0.0438106321,
0.0283976905,
0.0303912498,
-0.0129789189,
0.0150232902,
0.0723272711,
-0.0036999353,
0.0049506193,
0.01475883,
-0.0333584994,
0.0729477853,
-0.0185645428,
-0.0129530774,
0.0136783598,
-0.0235252343,
0.0909486786,
0.0064444114,
-0.0025209293,
-0.0023699203,
0.0428054333,
0.0318394825,
-0.0527803414,
-0.0049889539,
-0.0021255845,
-0.030725386,
-0.021176083,
-0.0096056666,
-0.0021648675,
0.0298273601,
-0.0437116288,
-0.0227233171,
0.0097377095,
-0.0050234548,
-0.0589652583,
-0.0913599655,
0.023568647,
-0.0034694562,
0.0117471786,
0.038104333,
-0.0740543753,
-0.0186372381,
0.0232007131,
-0.0668835044,
-0.0170878656,
0.0231615379,
2.465e-7,
0.0335531272,
0.0231698286,
0.0435300954,
0.0089196451,
0.015028446,
0.037883129,
-0.0243531484,
0.0100108683,
0.026637258,
-0.002642107,
0.0292231757,
0.0358758382,
0.0386242867,
-0.0007409889,
-0.0350443944,
0.0091686975,
-0.0286644995,
-0.0116629042,
-0.059494298,
-0.0161958653,
0.0448983498,
0.0360026434,
-0.0561235398,
-0.0243357923,
0.0264942329,
-0.0935175791,
0.136135444,
-0.0304093659,
-0.0109343547,
-0.002191938,
0.0111913653,
0.032505516,
-0.0108075561,
0.0194224808,
-0.025379505,
0.0033023483,
0.0586058833,
-0.0017990062,
-0.0202471316,
-0.0299966503,
-0.0107806763,
0.0329155065,
0.0051559573,
-0.0349603742,
0.043435771,
-0.0142130284,
0.0259122029,
0.0071941135,
-0.026535565,
0.0055130352,
0.0125358934,
-0.0419487581,
-0.0434821695,
0.0236435719,
0.0198601726,
0.0183590557,
-0.0253025889,
-0.0832268894,
-0.0033415961,
-0.0004534771,
-0.0377569571,
0.0217312407,
-0.0911585763,
0.0004565418,
0.0219832845,
-0.0230138786,
-0.0035123553,
1.83565657e-34,
0.00457511,
0.0055675996,
-0.0088873161,
-0.0461420491,
0.0258864649,
-0.0322425105,
-0.0505876429,
0.0037186234,
-0.0199194271,
-0.0738508105,
-0.0189705659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01933v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01933v3
|
LLM-Adapters: An Adapter Family for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2023-04-04T16:31:37 | 2023-10-09T15:38:46 |
Zhiqiang Hu, Lei Wang, Yihuai Lan, Wanyu Xu, Ee-Peng Lim, Lidong Bing, Xing Xu, Soujanya Poria, Roy Ka-Wei Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The success of large language models (LLMs), like GPT-4 and ChatGPT, has led
to the development of numerous cost-effective and accessible alternatives that
are created by finetuning open-access LLMs with task-specific data (e.g.,
ChatDoctor) or instruction data (e.g., Alpaca). Among the various fine-tuning
methods, adapter-based parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is undoubtedly
one of the most attractive topics, as it only requires fine-tuning a few
external parameters instead of the entire LLMs while achieving comparable or
even better performance. To enable further research on PEFT methods of LLMs,
this paper presents LLM-Adapters, an easy-to-use framework that integrates
various adapters into LLMs and can execute these adapter-based PEFT methods of
LLMs for different tasks. The framework includes state-of-the-art open-access
LLMs such as LLaMA, BLOOM, and GPT-J, as well as widely used adapters such as
Series adapters, Parallel adapter, Prompt-based learning and
Reparametrization-based methods. Moreover, we conduct extensive empirical
studies on the impact of adapter types, placement locations, and
hyper-parameters to the best design for each adapter-based methods. We evaluate
the effectiveness of the adapters on fourteen datasets from two different
reasoning tasks, Arithmetic Reasoning and Commonsense Reasoning. The results
demonstrate that using adapter-based PEFT in smaller-scale LLMs (7B) with few
extra trainable parameters yields comparable, and in some cases superior,
performance to powerful LLMs (175B) in zero-shot inference on both reasoning
tasks.
|
[
0.0102506708,
0.0423001722,
-0.0081185084,
0.0583748445,
-0.0500865467,
0.0233746041,
0.0248564277,
-0.0063821338,
0.0078144502,
-0.0620229766,
-0.0401447825,
0.0079810992,
0.0171140265,
-0.0319522433,
0.0206189603,
-0.0042465334,
0.0554296672,
-0.048435241,
-0.0131836003,
0.0050417553,
-0.0306581426,
0.0180163719,
-0.0090546291,
0.0213042237,
0.0514242612,
-0.021260079,
-0.012993847,
-0.0015434023,
0.0374620594,
0.0229681209,
-0.0073852912,
0.0586343259,
0.028068101,
0.0457862504,
0.0000023353,
-0.0304060653,
-0.0217828844,
-0.003722304,
-0.0304467101,
0.0466353483,
0.0264770743,
0.0061118309,
-0.0070814611,
0.0376437493,
-0.0163548309,
-0.0288132895,
0.0427261405,
0.0415638983,
0.0565305166,
0.0879439935,
0.0094836717,
-0.0543418042,
0.0333559476,
-0.0274026357,
0.0126250777,
-0.0441544354,
0.0281786378,
-0.0041931947,
0.0223522726,
0.0187611897,
-0.0414432995,
0.01860952,
0.0430079959,
0.0241804123,
-0.0539029241,
0.0198079497,
-0.0516078807,
-0.0033304039,
0.0055490937,
0.0710071772,
-0.0400163978,
-0.0396409445,
-0.0247786846,
-0.0100222528,
-0.0116029102,
0.0064867027,
-0.0381923057,
0.0499660447,
-0.0085526658,
0.0366572291,
0.0575763173,
-0.0543058999,
0.0284404028,
0.0250666626,
-0.0559544489,
0.0625645071,
0.0251856539,
0.0089732716,
-0.003964175,
-0.0276885685,
-0.0644568503,
-0.0361817628,
-0.0100531159,
0.0432920009,
-0.0274723358,
0.0170939285,
-0.0404384881,
-0.0470729209,
0.0146968281,
-0.0055861431,
0.075894244,
0.0913627446,
0.0058067148,
0.0491942167,
-0.0663429871,
0.0426061451,
-0.0077403458,
0.0352831781,
-0.0438459776,
-0.0031417406,
-0.0427486897,
0.0050032325,
-0.0536664315,
0.0323332138,
-0.0653783455,
-0.0004508291,
-0.0270931646,
0.0417123698,
-0.0014152231,
-0.0050820941,
0.0201580655,
-0.039346505,
-0.0257075094,
-0.031665992,
-0.0144055178,
0.048005417,
-0.0533119328,
0.0313001908,
-0.0114086829,
-0.0614504814,
-0.0326764397,
0.0010186759,
0.0205040183,
-0.0250720624,
0.0317996889,
0.0619607717,
-0.0175474714,
-0.0460090488,
-0.0459434129,
-0.007798851,
0.0226012319,
-0.0884810165,
-0.0078453515,
-0.0758745298,
0.0290463977,
0.0107880645,
0.0135844583,
0.0032025063,
-0.0029458562,
0.0229771342,
-0.0244531091,
0.083399415,
0.0329434425,
0.0014824562,
-0.005197573,
0.0052060271,
-0.0071802926,
0.1017014906,
0.0241440218,
-0.0065229698,
-0.0039803335,
-0.0274333786,
-0.0164133441,
0.0386828594,
0.0033376354,
-0.0029753689,
-0.0090243546,
0.009417762,
0.027131794,
0.0147084408,
0.0004555628,
0.033284992,
-0.0479086079,
-0.0205856487,
0.0275211111,
0.0211594198,
0.0454390794,
-0.0015335776,
0.0529052354,
-0.0027855162,
0.0154718226,
-0.0180791691,
-0.0810030252,
0.0367143042,
-0.0576179437,
0.0193185247,
0.0040564202,
0.0445262678,
-0.0389856137,
-0.0391513631,
-0.0006193987,
-0.0024839398,
-0.0151655665,
0.0286103878,
0.0446291268,
-0.0027993366,
-0.0483638868,
0.0484849811,
0.0426779985,
-0.0240223203,
-0.038932059,
-0.0717540607,
0.0342955515,
0.0427475795,
0.0393568724,
-0.0304973479,
-0.0674058571,
0.0157708135,
0.0457388721,
0.0131742405,
0.0168783087,
0.0157998521,
-0.005460572,
-0.0622862503,
-0.0076603605,
-0.0181200337,
0.0205531269,
0.0255588796,
0.0280841552,
-0.0022136376,
0.0191301648,
-0.0536565483,
0.0000377896,
0.0244087651,
-0.0377593748,
-0.0453120098,
-0.0012608715,
0.0053614019,
0.008410193,
-0.028545035,
0.0099326717,
0.0066394061,
0.023342004,
-0.0150014637,
0.0313071124,
-0.0091884434,
-0.0384921879,
-0.0597556978,
0.0358683318,
-0.0099945245,
-0.0041047027,
0.004368599,
-0.0762943253,
-0.0496709086,
0.0206774287,
-0.0025656119,
0.032809373,
-0.039290823,
0.0376078822,
-0.0268919729,
-0.0066824518,
-0.0079310089,
0.0484150127,
0.0069463537,
0.0143747777,
0.019749511,
0.0278813988,
0.0230665505,
-0.0242236722,
-0.0250767991,
-0.0157498885,
-0.0023667887,
0.0065084361,
-0.0293409433,
0.0304215122,
-0.0284095295,
-0.0522305891,
-0.0954479277,
0.048988495,
-0.036074046,
0.0315388478,
0.0063570286,
0.0163723417,
-0.0085133212,
0.012490321,
-0.0054003792,
0.0415025242,
0.0004288691,
0.0338028632,
0.0007833072,
-0.0121992687,
-0.0378171355,
-0.0147163272,
-0.0157959778,
-0.0302221533,
0.0204968303,
-0.0160792898,
0.020108467,
-0.0658325702,
0.0161848124,
-0.0229666457,
0.0321745351,
-0.0300466996,
-0.0314284377,
0.0193642415,
-0.0299208593,
0.0379886851,
0.0927679092,
-0.035671778,
-0.0036511526,
0.0294560771,
-0.0006180699,
-0.0591398887,
0.0318376832,
-0.0106621003,
-0.0411786437,
-0.0244791992,
0.0078913355,
-0.0429126658,
0.0729858428,
-0.0402684547,
-0.0173930004,
-0.0597450659,
0.0373652615,
0.0167109836,
0.0031149692,
-0.0075951717,
0.0240402054,
-0.0012067743,
-0.0033898528,
-0.0247642957,
-0.0671997368,
0.0742730051,
-0.0408205017,
0.0071971463,
-0.0458462238,
-0.0037092175,
-0.055755116,
0.028690083,
0.0212527625,
-0.0073297904,
0.0070887045,
-0.0061894087,
-0.0668238699,
0.0067384066,
0.0261670686,
-0.0268617179,
0.0844266787,
-0.044685524,
0.0081301937,
-0.0475985333,
-0.0419383086,
-0.0314532034,
-0.0112130549,
-0.030003028,
0.0368377939,
-0.0263268799,
-0.0308090802,
-0.040938817,
0.0110519025,
0.0090432605,
0.0350172296,
-0.033813633,
0.0067704828,
-0.0330123045,
-0.0068282727,
0.0481886491,
0.01287892,
0.023794923,
-0.0230300594,
0.0127391033,
0.023474548,
0.0468874499,
-0.0136790201,
-0.0168032032,
0.0206580609,
0.0159541089,
-0.0276363883,
-0.0128327962,
0.027113745,
0.0726258904,
-0.0774324313,
-0.0010910564,
0.127461493,
0.0298910253,
-0.0203319695,
-0.0025582979,
-0.0171325114,
0.0305409003,
0.0179153718,
0.037582323,
-0.0893392861,
-0.0643883944,
0.0074696536,
0.0179536883,
0.0015271443,
-0.026059702,
-0.0019316418,
-0.1394374371,
0.0312240906,
0.0261359196,
-0.0492841415,
-0.0385693498,
-0.0405051783,
0.0094690472,
-0.0105610238,
0.0094236797,
0.03968459,
-0.0162172727,
0.0111727184,
-0.0087200766,
0.0126368105,
-0.0328480415,
0.0392800272,
-0.035635706,
0.043011982,
0.0040410506,
-0.0269111302,
0.006882478,
-0.0475785173,
0.0352917574,
-0.0405583456,
0.0007836112,
-0.0457424298,
-0.0240161307,
-0.0092439391,
-0.0207279697,
-0.0001420505,
0.06205507,
-0.0325690433,
-0.0093953451,
0.0092510097,
0.1118719727,
-0.023207128,
-0.0013381484,
0.002556762,
-0.0122953532,
-0.0144079477,
0.0774449855,
0.031154681,
-0.0181606971,
-0.038052965,
-0.0193732809,
-0.0581503846,
-0.0412609056,
0.0098872799,
-0.0082371514,
-0.0040387097,
-0.015909126,
-0.0127462978,
0.0220391322,
0.0754175484,
0.0432473123,
-0.0131308911,
0.0107819643,
-0.0032105832,
-0.0124296481,
-0.0335673019,
0.0315151103,
-0.0591523722,
0.0196806081,
-0.0457591079,
-0.0035594474,
0.0427761301,
-0.014252007,
-0.0046651019,
0.047118891,
-0.0761862993,
-0.077270098,
-0.0195837282,
0.0623659343,
0.0202683304,
0.0532219559,
-0.0187631212,
-0.035209503,
0.0252517536,
0.0503053851,
0.0062662591,
0.03618709,
0.0239650719,
0.0021334435,
0.0107290074,
0.0501176827,
-0.0234194975,
0.0027282757,
0.0401274264,
0.0544638559,
-0.0252378006,
-0.0153080914,
0.0029974417,
0.0260017011,
0.0128288232,
-0.0005050084,
-0.0037948221,
-0.0239130724,
0.0436404943,
-0.0383662544,
-0.0135701895,
-0.0309259072,
-0.0116079496,
0.0141860899,
-0.0254131202,
-0.0119357742,
-0.038258221,
0.0025746657,
0.0649845153,
0.0002250568,
0.0655426905,
0.0079673706,
-0.0052239723,
0.0221100003,
-0.0198354926,
-0.0107184565,
-0.0003338052,
0.0227127485,
0.0526848808,
-0.0513803698,
0.0830494985,
0.0157372169,
0.0142671876,
-0.0842692703,
0.0170924775,
-0.0168564133,
-0.0392620899,
-0.0062774583,
0.0868218765,
0.0293046068,
0.0008598616,
0.0065831994,
-0.0274422318,
-0.0240333248,
-0.0177118592,
0.0437276028,
0.022508353,
0.0136187645,
0.0556724221,
0.0528657585,
0.0049469885,
-0.0166053642,
0.0406863652,
-0.0349748209,
0.0605176315,
0.0153371822,
0.0148089547,
-0.0286842119,
-0.0258660167,
-0.0219851192,
-0.0023561965,
-0.005849327,
0.0116270948,
-0.0643118098,
-0.0523144417,
0.0007716622,
0.0090328678,
-0.030417189,
-0.0158252344,
0.0029894549,
0.0402953736,
-0.0007483937,
-0.0391503125,
-0.0030553795,
-0.0020429858,
-0.0372682922,
-0.0289874822,
-0.0111115193,
-6.871255984e-33,
-0.0520887114,
-0.0121614318,
0.0493481532,
0.0040779305,
-0.0218969434,
-0.0113802115,
-0.0250470415,
0.005936482,
-0.0398460329,
-0.0140113942,
-0.0045031873,
-0.0000857275,
0.0094798384,
0.0124127148,
-0.0189770609,
-0.0162291043,
0.0089436881,
0.0133602647,
-0.0365907773,
0.0097005423,
0.0385408103,
-0.0055786651,
0.0606730878,
0.0074026878,
-0.0282185208,
-0.0019383869,
0.0139783453,
0.0433396362,
-0.052671127,
0.06386289,
0.0211614575,
0.0420737006,
0.0183118433,
-0.0263477806,
0.0066294,
0.0113485307,
-0.0958537087,
-0.0383200683,
0.0589925982,
0.0031269896,
-0.0203000326,
-0.0395363197,
0.0477117226,
0.004886339,
-0.0171088688,
-0.0421910882,
-0.0148885082,
-0.0401419066,
-0.0050305338,
0.049278602,
-0.0727904141,
0.0232688338,
-0.0021625936,
-0.017680943,
0.0105195073,
0.0058027632,
-0.006714256,
0.0228533838,
-0.0506864339,
-0.0133593762,
0.0625468493,
0.0405349806,
0.0618963763,
0.0256335605,
0.0254744645,
-0.0061102882,
0.0133057181,
-0.0094098439,
-0.0317422152,
0.020296501,
0.0459958911,
0.071468167,
0.0479316004,
0.0368644968,
0.0184979457,
0.0012022568,
-0.0800895244,
-0.0005542438,
0.0491702221,
0.0645229444,
0.0261596777,
0.0013895921,
-0.0353610255,
-0.0110613527,
-0.05655488,
-0.0014760032,
-0.054840263,
-0.00807421,
0.0162241254,
0.0151635166,
-0.030164741,
-0.0110303191,
0.0495088063,
-0.0441523194,
0.03161541,
0.0150142377,
-0.013763424,
0.0197058376,
-0.0102607906,
0.042418126,
-0.0545835197,
-0.0726885498,
0.0361366607,
-0.013764346,
0.0136724841,
-0.0064563085,
0.0479802825,
0.0189408902,
-0.0650668889,
-0.0136407828,
-0.046101369,
-0.0028162927,
-0.0026145147,
0.0507151075,
0.035638988,
0.0181112941,
0.017141223,
0.0255930591,
-0.0035806429,
-0.0313382111,
-0.0003662537,
-0.0089168269,
-0.010403987,
-0.0018462093,
-0.0152755855,
0.0273634754,
-0.0130581092,
-0.0122994212,
0.0094885202,
-0.0601376332,
-0.0067937835,
0.0577220768,
3.11e-7,
0.0591430441,
0.049271021,
0.0010841489,
0.0305792801,
0.0175057575,
0.0265349504,
-0.0036920763,
-0.0065104407,
0.0420157686,
0.0048634475,
0.0063331546,
0.0562007241,
0.0404670909,
0.0176429544,
-0.074910529,
0.0368908048,
-0.0184129924,
0.022544615,
-0.049131833,
-0.0125325993,
0.0378769711,
0.1173995584,
0.0011930531,
-0.0070171566,
0.0214568675,
-0.0351883247,
0.0440071933,
-0.0273595192,
-0.0372290909,
0.0193663035,
0.0033753135,
0.0369325653,
0.008432704,
0.0374527127,
0.0137059083,
0.041698128,
-0.0452308133,
0.079531908,
-0.0023430027,
-0.0215082299,
0.0031790414,
-0.0498044714,
-0.0086699994,
-0.069275409,
0.1160507649,
-0.078258343,
-0.0315547884,
-0.0213152766,
-0.008033691,
-0.0287185088,
0.0026911895,
-0.0279598683,
-0.0040268707,
0.0325311422,
0.0177765153,
-0.0353104584,
-0.0306484047,
-0.0616054758,
-0.0152107729,
0.0132107949,
-0.0261641014,
-0.0622268096,
-0.0454672128,
-0.0386077203,
0.0447190851,
-0.063077867,
-0.0108888373,
3.300293833e-34,
0.0359879248,
-0.0479578562,
0.0432248823,
0.0227105711,
0.0299152862,
0.0018435055,
-0.0248518866,
0.0247308072,
0.0241410173,
-0.1217984408,
-0.0315402932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01922v1
|
Resources and Few-shot Learners for In-context Learning in Slavic Languages
| 2023-04-04T16:16:25 | 2023-04-04T16:16:25 |
Michal Štefánik, Marek Kadlčík, Piotr Gramacki, Petr Sojka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the rapid recent progress in creating accurate and compact in-context
learners, most recent work focuses on in-context learning (ICL) for tasks in
English. However, the ability to interact with users of languages outside
English presents a great potential for broadening the applicability of language
technologies to non-English speakers.
In this work, we collect the infrastructure necessary for training and
evaluation of ICL in a selection of Slavic languages: Czech, Polish, and
Russian. We link a diverse set of datasets and cast these into a unified
instructional format through a set of transformations and newly-crafted
templates written purely in target languages. Using the newly-curated dataset,
we evaluate a set of the most recent in-context learners and compare their
results to the supervised baselines. Finally, we train, evaluate and publish a
set of in-context learning models that we train on the collected resources and
compare their performance to previous work.
We find that ICL models tuned in English are also able to learn some tasks
from non-English contexts, but multilingual instruction fine-tuning
consistently improves the ICL ability. We also find that the massive multitask
training can be outperformed by single-task training in the target language,
uncovering the potential for specializing in-context learners to the
language(s) of their application.
|
[
-0.0182479173,
-0.0296223462,
-0.0038989526,
0.0418990366,
-0.0059988135,
0.0447371937,
0.0293217842,
-0.069086723,
-0.0183436573,
-0.0091820769,
-0.0446388572,
-0.0151526462,
-0.0050473069,
-0.0628601685,
0.0475771725,
-0.1013165638,
0.0437141806,
-0.0289721452,
-0.0166985095,
0.0018421623,
0.0040968792,
0.0196873862,
-0.0845090598,
0.0193545166,
-0.0027564489,
-0.0453783162,
-0.0150489789,
0.0441661961,
0.0117410319,
-0.0284774788,
0.0205599274,
0.0131071769,
0.0458466038,
0.0305238198,
0.0000020964,
-0.0541010834,
-0.0011939789,
-0.0559276827,
0.0170303788,
-0.0263581481,
0.0801453218,
-0.0330142789,
-0.0280087702,
-0.0292763263,
-0.0186762754,
-0.0094016418,
0.041159004,
-0.0194685142,
0.0085914442,
0.0508643612,
0.0094832946,
-0.0002282368,
0.0083069261,
0.0203677583,
0.0025899406,
-0.0229374636,
-0.0105174519,
0.0182277374,
0.0010776523,
0.0075597558,
-0.0432915539,
0.0421934761,
0.049253352,
-0.0058666836,
0.0026859436,
0.0114742499,
-0.0206062216,
-0.0153590618,
-0.0308437124,
0.0482814796,
-0.0275981762,
-0.0271803886,
0.0046670442,
0.0152194407,
0.0220178664,
-0.0116046462,
-0.0830440968,
0.0316432863,
-0.0015500319,
-0.0049978774,
0.0054914518,
0.0104597565,
0.0092593683,
0.0016159836,
0.0629355758,
0.0233128462,
-0.015802592,
0.0135649294,
0.0206016731,
0.0048866239,
0.0223768298,
-0.0029391111,
-0.0101778535,
0.0089783343,
-0.0604100339,
0.0329323523,
-0.0434216671,
-0.0254451558,
0.0264932867,
-0.0338143818,
0.0379663222,
0.0570174232,
0.0000043027,
0.0392582268,
-0.0295848064,
0.0213220529,
0.0162175912,
0.0224965587,
-0.0370274112,
-0.0504691191,
-0.0643956661,
0.0177208502,
-0.0698969886,
-0.0349878706,
-0.0273971017,
0.0251931958,
-0.0504333414,
0.0201753825,
-0.0322605148,
0.0516645908,
-0.0327044465,
-0.0003505121,
-0.0522307269,
0.0017455855,
0.0334138684,
0.063295491,
-0.0538274832,
0.0208607465,
-0.0319583975,
-0.0228756778,
0.0387789197,
-0.0034102909,
-0.0009495792,
-0.0450019576,
0.0417032614,
0.0268390384,
-0.0399402454,
-0.0260129403,
-0.0100476956,
0.0112297246,
0.0146963866,
-0.0801852494,
-0.0001923504,
-0.073715128,
-0.0028919128,
0.0051367842,
0.0208260305,
-0.0370798595,
-0.0340565033,
0.0272769909,
0.0175760444,
0.0775927454,
0.0217456035,
-0.0058760839,
0.0238546561,
-0.0236070286,
0.006853282,
0.0974351913,
-0.006866666,
-0.0394838303,
0.0686569139,
-0.0270623639,
-0.0211031083,
0.0545008145,
0.0210743994,
0.0044282679,
0.0100742364,
0.0452686362,
0.0399085432,
-0.0087033873,
0.053556215,
-0.0051477212,
-0.0372946747,
0.0413180143,
0.0792988986,
0.0444269851,
0.0017913994,
0.0280567929,
0.058066383,
0.0131825516,
-0.008726255,
0.0041407892,
-0.0609291568,
0.0192781519,
0.0072028283,
0.0303822625,
-0.0244873185,
0.0178914405,
-0.0403843299,
-0.0156436469,
0.0079958932,
-0.0323376693,
0.0367129035,
0.0061426875,
0.0781044066,
0.0295669995,
-0.029742768,
-0.0102578197,
0.0596627593,
-0.0421088077,
0.0179285239,
0.004709858,
-0.0159029774,
0.0574892536,
-0.007609068,
-0.0420855284,
0.0081843091,
-0.0219601896,
0.0728254765,
0.0170603935,
-0.0017995677,
-0.0606986247,
0.0174240042,
-0.0422693975,
0.0114531033,
-0.0394618213,
0.0037972869,
0.0259489547,
-0.0196418259,
0.0282171629,
0.0006589339,
-0.0405687131,
0.0187098272,
0.0004908015,
-0.0347803049,
-0.0126146087,
-0.0148717202,
0.038769085,
-0.0152538,
0.0377552621,
0.0280195326,
-0.0183743238,
0.0390509218,
-0.0073419427,
0.0538704917,
0.0399090908,
-0.0567298234,
-0.0785287023,
0.0141585469,
-0.0551894382,
-0.0372876488,
-0.0389776081,
-0.0192939639,
-0.013185028,
0.0520606376,
-0.0164584741,
0.0160687827,
-0.0398217849,
-0.008786479,
-0.0019480151,
-0.0034200423,
-0.0051257047,
0.0340937376,
0.0132437199,
0.0365395881,
0.0586936325,
0.0131296096,
0.0008655175,
-0.0297718961,
-0.0004443084,
0.0217139311,
-0.0352175422,
-0.003304733,
-0.0195624866,
0.0465008691,
-0.0735689849,
0.0677751154,
-0.1056223288,
0.0196939781,
-0.0188174024,
0.0155386692,
0.0285974834,
-0.0013156038,
0.001142776,
-0.0518459156,
-0.0265402514,
-0.0143286437,
0.0104857767,
0.0153585216,
0.000334839,
0.0183938351,
0.0044570691,
-0.0155294454,
-0.0338768624,
0.0026434171,
-0.0165949054,
-0.0135480156,
-0.008961197,
-0.0363858007,
0.0130068529,
0.0097445566,
0.011168777,
-0.0418649279,
-0.0205742605,
0.0202529989,
0.0054985504,
0.0651693195,
0.0712346509,
-0.0433717445,
0.0416774563,
0.0389163643,
-0.0173797999,
-0.042006854,
0.0153634073,
-0.0259490889,
0.0028032467,
-0.0423041657,
0.0242001545,
-0.0318295732,
0.0114045162,
-0.0168640912,
0.0050567174,
-0.0389114134,
-0.0303974692,
-0.0562688708,
-0.0284517203,
-0.0683064684,
0.0143225165,
-0.019190982,
0.000711807,
-0.0007972788,
0.0185327027,
0.0689406544,
0.0135459425,
-0.047253564,
-0.0333202556,
-0.0403015129,
-0.0129403174,
0.0207877774,
-0.0124989394,
0.0101973834,
-0.0155235138,
-0.0318390355,
-0.0726144016,
-0.0235173274,
0.0507470034,
0.0013640733,
0.0494901091,
-0.0380874202,
-0.0219191723,
-0.0271744747,
-0.0263363291,
0.0015651962,
-0.013955879,
0.0145685123,
-0.0033419598,
-0.04939555,
-0.020250367,
-0.0087651415,
-0.0415586978,
0.0422343388,
0.0473579802,
-0.0062084277,
-0.0020351047,
-0.0158680398,
0.0082585169,
0.0254193135,
-0.0228664968,
-0.0361124761,
-0.0641338453,
0.0258244183,
0.0387653001,
0.0900525153,
-0.097986944,
0.0324250124,
0.0102873007,
0.0433849543,
-0.0050417674,
-0.0094995573,
0.027214082,
0.0705945939,
-0.0730332509,
-0.0359382182,
0.0834088624,
-0.0072846422,
-0.0307159666,
0.0114774238,
-0.0242981166,
-0.0138285877,
0.0282615274,
0.0235885065,
-0.094877921,
-0.0360574797,
0.0017403757,
0.0264516342,
-0.0010097035,
-0.0221632421,
-0.0001642814,
-0.1306843758,
-0.0171410441,
0.0246342514,
-0.0790318847,
-0.005507675,
-0.0657295585,
0.0039860155,
-0.0297532715,
0.0236934088,
0.0064043063,
-0.0285679288,
-0.0014122204,
0.0058737081,
0.0332901515,
-0.0816245899,
0.0253877025,
-0.0214759074,
0.0217568967,
0.0362975933,
0.0207968913,
0.0050323829,
-0.0100929094,
0.0161315743,
-0.0263455883,
-0.0002215303,
-0.0184756424,
0.0373369753,
0.0181539301,
-0.0014033287,
-0.0144167021,
0.0610617697,
0.0032212015,
-0.0249401629,
0.0292022284,
0.0523278974,
0.0182930585,
0.0142295239,
0.0279344451,
-0.0268170238,
0.0898271427,
0.0484408475,
-0.0138634723,
-0.0231275018,
0.0120887775,
-0.0259392634,
-0.0207390692,
-0.0269352123,
0.0034309002,
0.0394762084,
-0.0401219614,
-0.0132957911,
-0.0370648392,
-0.0578145161,
0.0815413296,
0.0438004956,
-0.0043523526,
0.0316712968,
-0.0249192454,
0.030416321,
-0.0500595234,
0.0414948836,
-0.015795609,
0.0668125898,
-0.0672253817,
-0.0329091474,
-0.002044068,
-0.0455319881,
0.0097740134,
0.0452487655,
-0.0247075018,
-0.051159367,
-0.0034076257,
0.0536219999,
0.0139704542,
0.0940978304,
0.0344734304,
-0.0235398803,
0.0315456428,
0.0028652593,
-0.0294462461,
-0.0062451134,
0.0346431695,
0.0054796697,
0.0157359242,
0.0247229803,
-0.0272732824,
-0.0083535723,
-0.0029132967,
-0.0282055829,
-0.0340409391,
0.0170746744,
0.0173111409,
-0.0351967849,
0.0332681015,
-0.0248171072,
-0.0264050141,
-0.0118571492,
0.0214328617,
-0.0303510819,
-0.0208502878,
0.0080469325,
-0.0154454168,
0.0140584521,
0.0012846311,
0.006248212,
0.0479648486,
0.0323108472,
-0.0138251381,
-0.0500963442,
0.0240749158,
0.0249982141,
0.0229518656,
0.015836494,
0.0460917987,
-0.0167672038,
0.0222220402,
0.0375145338,
0.0307661314,
-0.0100102136,
0.0588982776,
0.0014124657,
-0.0371787772,
0.0130891865,
0.01552884,
-0.0422440879,
0.0688370839,
-0.0162123628,
0.0071866694,
0.0503911376,
-0.0015711498,
0.0869006962,
-0.0155760292,
0.0000650173,
-0.016585853,
0.0441223383,
-0.0179509856,
-0.0542893484,
-0.0029887361,
0.0077062026,
0.0222844686,
0.0061574331,
0.0334695838,
-0.0522359647,
0.0343071073,
-0.0028624672,
0.0347417668,
-0.0637829974,
0.0074240444,
-0.0091464864,
0.0392713659,
-0.0257350653,
0.0041680615,
-0.0269093569,
-0.0521519855,
-0.0426394604,
0.0276621655,
-0.0646377653,
-0.0113985846,
0.0596952289,
-0.0002000641,
-0.0171495508,
0.0042177304,
-0.0291021708,
0.0331978872,
0.0083326241,
-0.0243724845,
-0.0021337543,
-5.657326274e-33,
-0.0398236625,
-0.0162940696,
0.0269087702,
-0.0147456862,
0.0378812365,
-0.0303428061,
-0.0319821164,
0.0116598476,
-0.015230556,
-0.0038476267,
0.0140602626,
-0.0282691084,
0.020798834,
0.0296678338,
0.0042253472,
0.0107300291,
0.0488228872,
0.0055386997,
0.0301472358,
0.0587079376,
0.0730508268,
0.0170927867,
0.0984720364,
-0.0405384824,
0.0527938195,
-0.0353164114,
-0.0215298012,
0.0159866232,
0.0054098214,
0.0345687307,
0.0183493141,
0.0561229251,
0.0012139723,
-0.0420739688,
-0.0338069871,
0.0246898253,
-0.0969438106,
-0.0234779529,
-0.0028151509,
0.0869789198,
-0.0331417248,
-0.0372090004,
0.0350408554,
-0.031778723,
-0.0104064625,
0.002963444,
0.0417408124,
-0.02739379,
0.0069323471,
-0.0203735791,
-0.0927126333,
-0.0179171115,
-0.064985536,
-0.0455117859,
-0.001624982,
0.0687217414,
0.0039321035,
-0.0282433834,
-0.055281058,
0.0474840812,
-0.0549358428,
0.0079775248,
0.0923852846,
0.000014009,
0.0173559077,
0.0203715153,
0.0166484434,
-0.0240529217,
0.0755420774,
0.0197649337,
0.0531830676,
0.03957811,
0.0229008533,
0.1073083431,
0.0028137651,
0.0021177721,
-0.0769727901,
0.0402961671,
0.0516145006,
0.0304594953,
-0.0201653801,
-0.0133836139,
-0.0262532886,
-0.0203949492,
-0.007857806,
-0.0251633003,
0.0071402518,
-0.0401379168,
0.0326468498,
-0.0308416672,
0.0159298871,
0.0123445177,
0.011971551,
-0.0222909506,
-0.0542276017,
0.0468792766,
-0.0122695109,
0.0102616427,
-0.0120415641,
0.0183140449,
-0.0485751852,
-0.0418183021,
-0.0214655399,
0.0270597395,
0.0149896666,
0.0346754789,
0.0842445046,
0.031605605,
-0.0447105058,
0.0228725262,
-0.0180362407,
0.0510420166,
0.0304707643,
0.0545853265,
0.0415788814,
-0.0017063421,
-0.0518539213,
0.0674306005,
0.0267979577,
-0.0830466077,
0.0041854535,
-0.0504489429,
-0.0033018803,
0.0117644453,
-0.0201306604,
0.0011166265,
-0.0436685197,
0.0060995617,
0.0502924658,
-0.0201195329,
0.0156235034,
-0.0090346197,
2.635e-7,
0.0035909244,
0.0388879403,
-0.0263453554,
-0.0427897088,
0.0302747302,
0.0344705656,
-0.0722650588,
0.0061757364,
0.0109830154,
0.0209164433,
0.0134864356,
0.0029020007,
0.0385475159,
0.040341381,
-0.0891514644,
0.0158613399,
-0.0160210282,
0.0270782746,
-0.0348026603,
0.0991430879,
-0.0096974336,
0.0389880501,
0.0205701292,
-0.0206025969,
-0.0215294342,
-0.0542419627,
0.0550650656,
-0.0296465699,
-0.011768355,
-0.0196960606,
-0.0634072423,
0.015478122,
0.0009991613,
0.0188391283,
-0.0273447074,
0.0167436171,
-0.0244068895,
0.0217354745,
-0.0119345086,
-0.0273102,
0.0435625724,
-0.0040052836,
-0.0339521132,
-0.0569839291,
0.0752193034,
-0.0769719481,
-0.0267697461,
0.0424398221,
-0.0123625305,
0.008295415,
0.0115494067,
-0.0089944936,
-0.0466192141,
-0.0058890642,
0.0116601977,
-0.036996223,
-0.0286026392,
-0.0108060008,
-0.0057442468,
0.0328661092,
-0.0105654337,
-0.0573446639,
-0.0118771717,
0.0125913806,
-0.0361445025,
-0.0125711691,
-0.0094119702,
1.638215878e-34,
-0.0147548504,
0.0220483951,
0.0557602011,
0.0037409435,
-0.0607720986,
-0.0102264155,
-0.023965301,
0.0215186104,
0.0660233945,
-0.0100328354,
-0.0372253172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01904v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01904v2
|
REFINER: Reasoning Feedback on Intermediate Representations
| 2023-04-04T15:57:28 | 2024-02-04T12:15:18 |
Debjit Paul, Mete Ismayilzada, Maxime Peyrard, Beatriz Borges, Antoine Bosselut, Robert West, Boi Faltings
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) have recently shown remarkable performance on reasoning
tasks by explicitly generating intermediate inferences, e.g., chain-of-thought
prompting. However, these intermediate inference steps may be inappropriate
deductions from the initial context and lead to incorrect final predictions.
Here we introduce REFINER, a framework for finetuning LMs to explicitly
generate intermediate reasoning steps while interacting with a critic model
that provides automated feedback on the reasoning. Specifically, the critic
provides structured feedback that the reasoning LM uses to iteratively improve
its intermediate arguments. Empirical evaluations of REFINER on three diverse
reasoning tasks show significant improvements over baseline LMs of comparable
scale. Furthermore, when using GPT-3.5 or ChatGPT as the reasoner, the trained
critic significantly improves reasoning without finetuning the reasoner.
Finally, our critic model is trained without expensive human-in-the-loop data
but can be substituted with humans at inference time.
|
[
0.0286092144,
0.0314288326,
-0.007947105,
0.0232726783,
-0.0313423909,
0.0313207433,
-0.0039718146,
-0.0309375413,
0.0052961749,
-0.0411113724,
-0.0189271774,
0.0126849627,
-0.0003972246,
-0.0143942246,
0.0487776324,
-0.0916329548,
0.0426530093,
-0.0615036078,
0.0510275029,
-0.0075910888,
-0.0004393354,
0.0270690881,
-0.0067657838,
0.0543705858,
0.0201503448,
-0.021538727,
-0.0277969167,
-0.0017692653,
0.012764819,
-0.0336666182,
0.0018738735,
0.051239416,
0.0432061255,
0.0082442677,
0.0000020364,
-0.0370534919,
-0.0042066677,
-0.0248884242,
-0.044548098,
-0.0166308563,
0.0077279764,
0.0049019125,
-0.0064497534,
0.0326527469,
-0.0285645965,
-0.0100898948,
0.0095826294,
0.0714631602,
0.0734512359,
0.0616114289,
-0.0050642681,
-0.0290977024,
-0.0153385112,
-0.0219444484,
0.0167057924,
-0.0263279304,
-0.0317625664,
0.0398532525,
0.0049953442,
0.0376430787,
-0.0138808731,
0.0074807918,
0.0761224255,
-0.0036376403,
-0.0354510956,
0.0504592359,
-0.0049337917,
-0.0199393518,
0.0034835266,
0.0445273556,
0.0024111778,
-0.0593871698,
-0.0385064296,
-0.0080689862,
0.0242042318,
-0.032197196,
-0.0308259092,
0.0304112453,
-0.0190569479,
0.0264000259,
0.03996462,
-0.0167777911,
0.0225090869,
0.02708924,
-0.0280825868,
0.0633506998,
-0.01132748,
-0.0230556522,
0.0338289402,
0.0264342744,
-0.0297578629,
-0.0549383089,
-0.0305424314,
0.038497664,
-0.0637491941,
0.0045745247,
-0.0394571051,
0.0255146623,
0.0067200675,
0.0160677265,
0.020494001,
0.0542152748,
-0.0154610192,
0.0517975613,
-0.0372307636,
0.0079229334,
-0.0075181094,
0.0767622143,
0.0039221491,
-0.0218449533,
-0.03431895,
-0.0298648681,
-0.0363603458,
-0.0074665868,
-0.0121443635,
0.0044159447,
-0.0380842239,
0.0419108495,
-0.0274142809,
0.0219873507,
-0.0220200848,
0.0227975063,
0.018748736,
-0.0206162687,
-0.0595478825,
0.037143629,
-0.0581618063,
0.0377672985,
0.06903027,
-0.0409516767,
-0.0440961532,
0.0178233385,
-0.0190660618,
-0.0373134613,
0.016031947,
0.0537060946,
-0.0370451026,
-0.0250911023,
-0.0524822958,
-0.0426013991,
0.018637443,
-0.1017849296,
-0.0147446208,
-0.0467986688,
0.0110741742,
0.002077275,
-0.009203977,
-0.031504482,
0.0076537444,
0.029411383,
-0.0324358679,
0.0898070335,
-0.0207788032,
-0.0247083232,
0.0047439449,
0.0275716633,
-0.0486486182,
0.0471774079,
0.0236827768,
0.0076814811,
0.0014078631,
0.0019389918,
0.0117307808,
-0.0090733543,
0.0354533531,
-0.0401936434,
-0.0002534158,
-0.0049275942,
-0.061347276,
0.0493360497,
0.0437558033,
0.0522186272,
-0.0529036261,
0.0043511628,
0.0317904651,
0.0332837179,
0.0458130017,
0.0246552657,
0.0487593636,
0.0068510952,
-0.0127182268,
0.0310469624,
-0.1078630239,
0.0669350624,
-0.0249808375,
0.0052878833,
0.0239010099,
0.0061813616,
-0.0309281927,
-0.050623998,
0.0009557006,
0.0228983834,
0.0222197082,
0.0335963666,
0.0529462993,
0.0489851125,
-0.053909827,
0.0117130969,
0.0173527971,
-0.0274729412,
-0.0188469682,
-0.0669615716,
0.0625598654,
0.0795774087,
0.0349630602,
0.0061631044,
-0.0193499736,
-0.0175761171,
0.0174843874,
0.016373517,
0.0338447653,
-0.010442418,
0.0113496305,
-0.0384841412,
-0.0325388312,
-0.0124551747,
0.0207771771,
0.0060982853,
0.0312882736,
-0.0139487768,
0.0322233289,
-0.0221820958,
0.0202686451,
0.0279633049,
0.0187909156,
-0.0111833671,
-0.0040672608,
0.0131374355,
-0.0159740709,
-0.0124251265,
0.0108208433,
-0.0047315056,
0.0104571003,
-0.0130035989,
-0.0068644099,
0.0508157536,
-0.0608478338,
-0.0812725946,
0.0175947249,
0.0000679158,
-0.0406008698,
0.0038294031,
-0.0516198277,
-0.0251828749,
0.0322399065,
0.0048476215,
0.0202053413,
-0.0539252795,
0.0104536256,
0.0115681896,
-0.0157394763,
-0.0081125051,
0.0671632364,
0.0004372359,
-0.0049716411,
0.0045376606,
0.0565398745,
-0.0021017438,
-0.0480558425,
0.0040877038,
-0.0107450057,
0.0037848272,
-0.0030459973,
0.0075892527,
0.0269199926,
-0.0493599139,
-0.01073239,
-0.0757533312,
-0.0208740607,
-0.0237956457,
0.0003766677,
0.0034362499,
-0.0009853761,
0.0173840392,
-0.0127658602,
-0.0101658748,
0.0127986586,
0.0264576394,
0.0235988107,
0.0375063159,
-0.0410362482,
-0.0023118493,
-0.0282963309,
-0.0038551001,
-0.0345565863,
0.0305920858,
0.0047073234,
0.0354762971,
-0.0668728575,
-0.0227321908,
-0.0329018161,
0.0269514509,
-0.0189097784,
-0.0137043204,
0.0613981821,
-0.00484672,
0.043660406,
0.0797206163,
0.018655289,
0.0500362292,
0.0486714542,
0.0109441765,
-0.0574524067,
0.0389237553,
-0.0015046312,
-0.0127197541,
0.0031625561,
0.0052582622,
-0.0455141291,
0.0509077422,
-0.0013737056,
0.0273018405,
-0.0693121776,
0.0381429493,
0.0205273628,
0.0020890841,
-0.0290647577,
-0.0159766227,
-0.0104943467,
0.0702683106,
-0.0324196219,
-0.0293322597,
0.1063265353,
-0.0245026629,
-0.0169253163,
-0.0147368638,
-0.0061915484,
-0.0154212955,
0.0520755127,
-0.01844896,
-0.0215168092,
-0.0034765105,
0.0018938779,
-0.0509150214,
-0.0254295226,
0.0499556214,
-0.0242446829,
0.0394178331,
-0.0367178917,
-0.0146041205,
0.006507982,
-0.0419124961,
-0.0615409575,
-0.0045205415,
-0.0630179867,
0.0089793736,
-0.0080790138,
0.0031613023,
-0.0020810897,
0.0058055329,
0.00595148,
0.0495190173,
-0.0129016349,
-0.0326921977,
-0.0100055793,
-0.0206389055,
0.0226969775,
0.0324694179,
0.0309854019,
-0.0308261644,
0.0660926178,
0.0529447272,
0.0389040262,
-0.0206117854,
-0.0569283068,
0.0424404591,
-0.0119766146,
0.0064722747,
0.011579874,
0.0043250965,
0.0660211444,
-0.0822938979,
-0.0185466073,
0.1292723566,
0.0139470575,
-0.0363710783,
0.0002127103,
-0.0299139302,
0.0845978633,
0.0235818699,
0.0212484971,
-0.1123639941,
-0.0671551973,
0.0352296643,
0.0300280042,
0.0019362735,
-0.0063230582,
-0.0048591108,
-0.0954922289,
0.0505687445,
0.0006237693,
-0.0128201339,
-0.0141104627,
-0.02391514,
0.0082937907,
0.0017678296,
0.0173323359,
0.0439904258,
0.0133912349,
-0.0096459258,
0.0040603466,
-0.0052539469,
-0.0225094147,
0.0378415771,
-0.0408106707,
0.0301934741,
0.0324031599,
-0.0118707856,
0.0656583756,
-0.0393079296,
0.0814174637,
-0.0170709938,
0.0275339466,
-0.034399271,
0.0204934161,
-0.0178937409,
-0.0102545042,
-0.0400790796,
0.0466537438,
-0.0102462992,
-0.0365297981,
0.0097346595,
0.0946475491,
-0.0353440456,
-0.0289709363,
0.0099571971,
0.0505329408,
-0.0200767405,
0.0528818853,
0.0360473171,
-0.0137984827,
-0.0620729588,
-0.0290853474,
-0.0210206583,
-0.0344113931,
-0.0187011175,
-0.0044833324,
0.0294319764,
0.0005797426,
-0.0172625761,
-0.0637822226,
0.0490456261,
0.0466537178,
-0.0369808525,
-0.0266817547,
-0.0237051528,
0.0008791651,
-0.0092219589,
0.0289361738,
-0.0110964198,
0.0066091185,
-0.0188797824,
0.0023504943,
-0.0137561578,
-0.0289268997,
-0.0161057357,
0.0385577939,
-0.0627198666,
-0.0675739944,
-0.0473469235,
0.0767627284,
0.0290243682,
0.0816608593,
-0.0287168231,
-0.0457121059,
-0.0098329019,
-0.016310839,
-0.0233198125,
0.0045547676,
0.0319715962,
-0.0157339815,
0.0160960685,
0.0437309854,
-0.0291435346,
-0.0054017198,
-0.0084010689,
0.0331944339,
0.0102555268,
-0.0174706783,
0.051787138,
-0.0269225147,
0.0419992954,
-0.0109569887,
0.0074414359,
-0.0407780521,
0.0301716961,
-0.0200957283,
-0.0337194428,
-0.0263713095,
0.0343221761,
-0.0014235899,
-0.0320185907,
-0.0244633891,
-0.0780861601,
0.0034214547,
0.0416050851,
-0.0011562649,
0.0028795439,
0.0203798916,
0.0263940301,
-0.0068078102,
-0.0165954381,
-0.0201381687,
0.023120651,
-0.0167966131,
0.0481275693,
-0.0332189016,
0.096466057,
0.0638622791,
0.0088329408,
-0.015678253,
-0.0129010761,
-0.0514420308,
-0.0723778605,
0.0001535888,
-0.0021509579,
0.0297462624,
0.0240100715,
0.0317011103,
-0.0333710127,
-0.0024061117,
0.0259007942,
0.0496959127,
-0.0229292065,
-0.0424721017,
0.0139379157,
0.0358119085,
-0.0087599633,
-0.0146882506,
0.0369766653,
-0.0117746592,
0.0205096565,
-0.0109425373,
-0.0032436086,
-0.0375298746,
-0.0303254593,
-0.0777097046,
0.0141294599,
0.0122352457,
0.0294663683,
-0.0273151994,
-0.0884944424,
-0.0476805232,
0.0435286984,
-0.0190275386,
-0.000678382,
-0.0039504967,
0.0626841486,
-0.0054276255,
-0.0659861639,
0.0054369764,
-0.0051532211,
0.0097627016,
-0.0115042329,
-0.0275617205,
-6.726339571e-33,
-0.0313948765,
-0.0184293315,
0.0489150696,
0.0030796921,
-0.030633254,
-0.0646403432,
-0.0707802922,
0.0001050702,
-0.0077561033,
0.058586847,
-0.021935584,
0.0379828624,
0.013162219,
0.0130555555,
0.0217716284,
-0.0154441074,
0.0324729718,
0.0299565904,
-0.0592583567,
0.0273530576,
0.0256782323,
0.0137519939,
0.0387312844,
-0.0561713725,
0.0135963606,
0.0215707272,
-0.0258951057,
0.0568251573,
-0.0615473241,
0.0411924496,
0.0210979749,
-0.000344158,
0.0393652953,
-0.0414276123,
0.0059989728,
0.0067282082,
-0.1437135488,
-0.0328586027,
0.0390865691,
-0.0024961631,
-0.0819970518,
-0.0247830171,
0.0250061322,
-0.0220675599,
0.0101269009,
-0.0163899846,
-0.0008680956,
-0.0121214837,
-0.0074055954,
0.0225450974,
-0.0458092913,
0.0114143537,
-0.027226869,
-0.0294028725,
0.0038967943,
0.0582387522,
-0.0301175807,
-0.0219512042,
-0.0506272987,
-0.0112466924,
0.0084660174,
-0.0129247485,
0.0647418275,
0.0086668916,
-0.0224352423,
0.0452011228,
0.0039885254,
-0.023379745,
-0.071611993,
-0.0118607031,
0.0115563432,
0.0276900847,
0.0399186723,
-0.0021408589,
0.0156295802,
-0.0106195053,
-0.0315890349,
-0.0114498371,
0.0060810335,
0.071814239,
0.0357667394,
-0.0074226228,
-0.0111918375,
-0.0420224108,
-0.0636924133,
-0.0284709763,
-0.0465080962,
-0.0517334826,
0.0337975435,
0.0395071618,
-0.0012540056,
-0.0310928877,
0.0084075341,
-0.0080922823,
0.021854192,
0.016576102,
-0.0232292581,
-0.0288096275,
-0.0195955765,
0.016888788,
-0.0100462558,
-0.0031625968,
0.0481417403,
0.006666509,
0.0078616971,
-0.0001622189,
0.0597653016,
0.0096332803,
-0.0459665023,
0.0020899531,
-0.0581349954,
0.0491542667,
-0.0300926529,
0.0099990079,
0.0386454947,
0.0429417975,
-0.0282580666,
0.0401516929,
-0.0111788297,
0.0101597561,
-0.0496743806,
0.0194426961,
-0.0091529395,
0.0109382244,
-0.0256511848,
-0.0110157197,
-0.0091165369,
-0.0142644588,
-0.0089100655,
-0.070548147,
-0.0088635804,
0.0341708884,
2.756e-7,
0.0261105932,
0.0514406189,
0.0283493344,
0.0316657275,
-0.0064948988,
0.0317216478,
0.0090204747,
-0.0157174319,
0.0450414568,
-0.0364478976,
0.0211432129,
0.0610137396,
0.0452044122,
0.0333400369,
-0.042936217,
-0.0004057386,
-0.0690082535,
-0.0256866608,
-0.0150562814,
-0.0394401141,
0.0993787348,
0.0780878514,
0.0363535583,
-0.02786736,
0.0338797607,
-0.0202907231,
0.0461468175,
-0.0082438625,
0.0120212343,
-0.0231174827,
0.0409084931,
0.0107975965,
0.0154350586,
0.027314892,
0.0267292298,
0.0151472408,
-0.0624487102,
0.0323463306,
-0.0104540978,
-0.0417066924,
-0.0294436999,
0.00537825,
0.0254837293,
-0.0614524707,
0.0779404044,
-0.0807037055,
-0.0138118472,
0.0108256377,
0.0065200618,
-0.0470958687,
0.0175494291,
-0.0111075584,
-0.0441871993,
0.014813046,
0.009047077,
0.0128123667,
0.0067404089,
-0.121268414,
-0.0308113173,
0.0399721973,
-0.0237801149,
0.0054569202,
-0.0192768965,
-0.0039063776,
0.0499531105,
-0.0431226976,
-0.0121140862,
2.389987334e-34,
0.0333703272,
-0.0085861916,
0.0406063795,
0.0620195605,
0.0707169846,
0.0217709001,
0.0324241333,
0.0023580478,
0.0508756414,
-0.0588010475,
-0.0415080748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01894v1
|
San-BERT: Extractive Summarization for Sanskrit Documents using BERT and it's variants
| 2023-04-04T15:47:26 | 2023-04-04T15:47:26 |
Kartik Bhatnagar, Sampath Lonka, Jammi Kunal, Mahabala Rao M G
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we develop language models for the Sanskrit language, namely
Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) and its
variants: A Lite BERT (ALBERT), and Robustly Optimized BERT (RoBERTa) using
Devanagari Sanskrit text corpus. Then we extracted the features for the given
text from these models. We applied the dimensional reduction and clustering
techniques on the features to generate an extractive summary for a given
Sanskrit document. Along with the extractive text summarization techniques, we
have also created and released a Sanskrit Devanagari text corpus publicly.
|
[
0.0366857164,
-0.0300668962,
-0.0187404137,
0.0854457915,
-0.0107345516,
0.017129546,
-0.061839968,
0.0264995024,
-0.0210594926,
-0.0421730727,
0.0141195701,
-0.0207534637,
0.0266728327,
0.0060147843,
0.0055347346,
-0.1188433617,
0.0074716485,
-0.0140168788,
0.0121544832,
-0.0058145374,
0.0494955778,
-0.0032098747,
-0.0115469657,
0.0086264005,
-0.0016134344,
0.0156572536,
0.0124526685,
-0.019846946,
0.0261818264,
-0.0100956699,
0.0100125363,
0.006015555,
0.0443947054,
0.0061687143,
0.0000016362,
-0.0524919033,
-0.0638453811,
-0.0122304522,
0.0400133431,
-0.0048095635,
0.0131977145,
0.0039339922,
0.021186132,
0.0315317772,
0.0111013902,
0.0015503156,
0.0419928767,
0.0211460087,
0.0362051539,
0.0844274387,
-0.0373003893,
-0.0857357979,
0.0236809906,
0.0319523066,
-0.0780994222,
0.0555682629,
-0.0139552932,
-0.0011974659,
-0.0075004613,
-0.020769855,
-0.0417420119,
-0.0075365305,
-0.0082287136,
0.0033326927,
0.0374143049,
0.0263832174,
-0.0777478367,
0.0052972334,
0.0379410498,
0.008038695,
0.0169549789,
0.0004561109,
0.0418901592,
0.0436795354,
-0.0425512455,
-0.0130677857,
-0.0629608259,
0.030343866,
-0.035008613,
0.0606668331,
0.0181101896,
0.0382309072,
-0.0634460226,
-0.0038071154,
0.0253143646,
-0.0282099228,
0.026057126,
-0.0375319123,
-0.0538198203,
-0.0201838948,
-0.0238433406,
-0.0147887003,
0.0328350961,
0.0556804575,
0.0346725211,
0.024691727,
-0.0220023599,
-0.1231953427,
0.0192064662,
-0.0546420775,
-0.0354466103,
0.0178046059,
0.0106407246,
-0.0071020802,
-0.0238634422,
0.0376730636,
0.0252035465,
0.0226274095,
-0.0139268395,
-0.0276197847,
0.0366783105,
-0.0477317348,
-0.0445871241,
0.0402476564,
-0.0337978043,
0.0233707894,
-0.0446301103,
0.0354649127,
0.0405701324,
-0.0227239374,
0.0310435016,
-0.0326593593,
-0.0098931352,
-0.0160011761,
0.0324891098,
0.0046828315,
-0.0413739495,
-0.0303729009,
-0.0079814065,
-0.0235127397,
-0.0048724208,
0.0262670722,
0.0288129691,
-0.0207277723,
-0.0370587632,
0.0045725433,
-0.0049096257,
-0.05112556,
-0.0395742916,
0.0424704626,
-0.0194741059,
-0.0173202585,
-0.0285613853,
-0.0634718388,
0.0106433118,
0.0448782444,
-0.0133332582,
0.0171487648,
0.0195534788,
-0.0030801578,
-0.0183646698,
0.006830493,
-0.0523789451,
0.0155119933,
0.0770111978,
0.0023914268,
0.0405171663,
0.0108736102,
0.037208844,
0.0474713929,
0.0722499341,
-0.0322203599,
0.0252598692,
0.0575684309,
-0.0298151169,
0.0020488356,
-0.0228684396,
0.0199118182,
-0.0104156891,
-0.0425870121,
-0.0178104248,
0.0673814937,
-0.0225840919,
0.0600364357,
0.0172084924,
0.103202112,
0.0115457326,
0.0770176053,
-0.0395135172,
0.0348554961,
0.0656171888,
0.0287796762,
0.0243047979,
0.0281348247,
0.004761376,
0.0208649915,
0.0549506508,
0.0047279852,
-0.0057026269,
-0.0083432589,
-0.016551856,
-0.0480824038,
-0.0058468101,
-0.0435594246,
0.0644600764,
0.0007223358,
-0.0520831309,
0.0676637739,
0.0307678208,
-0.0988379717,
0.0399325266,
-0.0356918573,
0.0333102681,
0.0029560858,
0.0626096129,
-0.0717791244,
-0.0073072598,
0.0491798483,
-0.0255222153,
0.0324821696,
-0.0029595047,
-0.0137469694,
-0.0358830653,
-0.0671876222,
-0.0022101551,
0.0320987664,
-0.0141157107,
0.0002888363,
-0.030485142,
-0.0090925489,
0.0196530353,
-0.0241976306,
-0.0163841117,
0.0354974121,
0.0269046277,
0.004962639,
-0.0216401964,
0.0073426785,
0.0480978005,
-0.004962083,
-0.0134934215,
0.0091887098,
0.0458111055,
-0.0214962941,
-0.0043994836,
0.0358345434,
0.0373288207,
-0.0353655331,
-0.018028859,
-0.0628287494,
0.0418241024,
0.0409770906,
0.0152640697,
-0.0559471734,
-0.0035161176,
-0.0711711794,
0.0549244024,
-0.0358894579,
0.0449654534,
-0.0301734954,
-0.0102102272,
-0.0154381227,
0.0801885277,
0.0128362244,
0.0127627775,
0.0016200521,
-0.0459128059,
0.0517878495,
-0.0416546836,
-0.0267082453,
0.0170095619,
0.0016406527,
0.0006543115,
0.0533094034,
-0.035137482,
-0.012119106,
-0.0815881342,
-0.1125822887,
-0.0237663444,
-0.0267840344,
0.0597236454,
0.0143919392,
0.0397207737,
-0.002331465,
-0.0100955833,
-0.035807468,
-0.0400754213,
0.045031935,
-0.0314925611,
0.0367640518,
-0.02337813,
0.0364881158,
-0.0378993563,
-0.0197740495,
0.0045708418,
0.0460473299,
0.0025292574,
-0.0439776592,
-0.023282269,
-0.0141596552,
0.0110481912,
0.0100335805,
-0.001450314,
-0.0230101943,
-0.0588930361,
-0.0421149991,
0.0255248677,
-0.026246598,
0.0619948581,
-0.000418924,
-0.0143148927,
-0.0153818652,
-0.005809864,
-0.0211662389,
-0.0039266683,
0.0598458052,
0.0057339985,
0.0045947372,
0.0615733974,
0.0193502624,
0.0084270658,
-0.0082352823,
0.0031484107,
-0.0619973689,
-0.0392795354,
0.0700133443,
0.0010002995,
-0.0164189432,
-0.0530116335,
0.0412858725,
-0.0046072681,
-0.0381009728,
0.0554912128,
-0.0322387964,
-0.008856399,
-0.1076104119,
0.0444206446,
-0.0618090443,
-0.0023269472,
0.0171113461,
0.0134653458,
-0.0557722077,
-0.0472090952,
-0.0087034991,
0.0111015765,
-0.000375683,
-0.0374611542,
0.0404223762,
-0.0306829158,
0.0339904279,
-0.0630739778,
0.0081712669,
-0.0180074833,
-0.0552443005,
0.0401633233,
0.0041448702,
0.0740239397,
0.0040821163,
-0.0118678967,
0.0846705958,
-0.0049465233,
0.0131021412,
-0.0173099469,
0.0115896463,
0.023833314,
0.0800107718,
0.0405484997,
-0.0045190025,
0.0025629317,
-0.0004818849,
0.0166426823,
-0.0110897049,
0.0394594595,
-0.0277757384,
0.0013021845,
-0.0088860663,
0.0216595624,
-0.0764087215,
0.0159907918,
0.0006252312,
0.0036800571,
0.0223009922,
0.0152023658,
0.0898134708,
0.059055578,
-0.0254635811,
-0.0251209773,
-0.0737352595,
-0.0196990315,
-0.0189449545,
0.0085347481,
-0.0435104035,
0.0151197324,
0.0000196698,
-0.0015240889,
0.0355428942,
0.0031162533,
0.0222641155,
-0.069493942,
-0.0334004611,
-0.0224111043,
-0.011552861,
-0.0361590199,
-0.0116933621,
-0.0188544616,
-0.013657148,
-0.0102349948,
0.0572477728,
-0.0516997278,
-0.0044798115,
0.0321730897,
-0.0271503869,
0.0399248973,
-0.0290329605,
-0.0142471027,
-0.0443207361,
0.0732008964,
0.0200914033,
-0.0566676371,
0.019173393,
-0.0279443283,
-0.0564493537,
-0.0426349305,
0.0070085665,
0.0618870892,
-0.0085786609,
-0.0078029977,
-0.017289184,
0.0398811549,
0.0203957558,
-0.0073910346,
0.0325820893,
0.0196199864,
0.0226197653,
-0.0147693101,
-0.0295346584,
-0.0174956415,
-0.052763965,
0.0011238027,
0.0141314724,
0.029408142,
0.0069357725,
-0.0098373415,
0.0330030881,
-0.021746384,
-0.0034082835,
-0.0383278318,
-0.0548714772,
-0.0530448109,
-0.0476813726,
-0.0481941923,
0.0292056352,
-0.0237180628,
0.0281842891,
0.0022191131,
0.0596697703,
0.0231706724,
-0.0582793877,
-0.0326053128,
0.0069520148,
0.0049942797,
-0.0562389381,
-0.0087764291,
0.053355854,
0.0037049165,
-0.0209982023,
-0.0430816226,
0.0464534424,
-0.0464502536,
-0.0026384688,
0.049787838,
0.0137696527,
-0.0160740279,
-0.0389342569,
-0.0306967963,
0.0530639626,
0.0019057429,
-0.0100885816,
-0.0046426249,
0.0077795144,
0.0156766661,
-0.0375911519,
0.0181277171,
-0.0615452342,
0.0258954093,
-0.0523111969,
-0.0116343535,
-0.027364945,
-0.0024963294,
0.0240609441,
0.0511013083,
0.0218440574,
-0.0596595556,
0.0328861214,
-0.0188942738,
-0.0103987008,
-0.0277147815,
0.0071827853,
-0.0103504844,
0.0471120477,
-0.0066289925,
0.0198117681,
-0.0221586935,
0.0798322335,
-0.0068913898,
-0.040576756,
-0.0011381162,
0.0798788592,
0.0088505773,
0.025689166,
-0.0308764707,
-0.0042031296,
-0.0183708128,
-0.066816844,
-0.0190345384,
-0.0275411475,
-0.0169578064,
0.0505933575,
0.005151154,
0.0161826536,
0.0541951843,
0.0423611738,
0.0298365876,
0.0415233225,
-0.0387331955,
0.0287503414,
0.0248599201,
-0.0225493647,
0.049895864,
-0.0115279742,
0.0074778716,
-0.0177031886,
0.0203555655,
0.0446087718,
0.0280479342,
-0.0002759444,
0.0266820136,
0.0158078745,
-0.024086263,
0.0840106681,
-0.0704766959,
-0.0075130663,
0.029555006,
-0.037345022,
-0.0436744466,
-0.0339399315,
0.0114720259,
-0.0127647761,
0.0209173225,
-0.0219023414,
-0.0331930965,
-0.0001572986,
0.0161406752,
-0.009123642,
0.0281837713,
-0.0550742149,
0.0376396403,
0.0198202077,
0.0250769872,
0.0029291525,
-0.0365654081,
0.0174969602,
-0.0458275676,
-0.0060977009,
0.0046297563,
-4.978042252e-33,
-0.0302203596,
0.0068440577,
-0.0274178591,
0.0330144763,
-0.0071098912,
-0.0147929015,
-0.0546892807,
-0.0219565369,
0.0133264149,
-0.0044646859,
-0.0154416151,
0.0106866416,
0.0069415616,
0.019997701,
0.0192449633,
0.0111382315,
-0.0025289417,
0.033562351,
-0.0110714417,
0.0202058796,
0.067778863,
0.0049739107,
0.0709628314,
0.0119983535,
0.0210777447,
-0.0635247082,
-0.009134342,
0.0181512609,
0.0385496616,
0.0005193179,
-0.0392512269,
0.0081477165,
0.0268483162,
-0.0084962966,
-0.0199045725,
0.0334286094,
-0.0549593978,
-0.0098287603,
0.0296400171,
0.0424252562,
0.0018954441,
-0.0244399235,
0.0112730134,
-0.0064808177,
-0.0165404007,
0.0297271181,
0.0608020686,
-0.0226821471,
-0.0422417298,
-0.0819085911,
-0.0568852127,
0.0508616865,
-0.0636585355,
-0.0258991681,
0.0455322526,
0.0376810171,
0.0249967482,
0.0092659863,
-0.0128667094,
0.0239432361,
0.0561398119,
0.0356539637,
0.0159651544,
0.0240332354,
-0.0165029485,
0.0032897131,
-0.0158984456,
-0.0766222253,
-0.0039638705,
0.0506634116,
-0.0047810273,
0.0300030783,
0.0059517054,
-0.0124192042,
0.0312888734,
-0.033408884,
-0.0156919789,
0.0651564971,
-0.0297226887,
0.0339418538,
0.0167875681,
-0.0187357832,
-0.0262077488,
-0.0196346436,
0.0443458669,
-0.0283077043,
0.00185299,
0.0031638609,
-0.0061722999,
-0.0195596069,
-0.0366264097,
0.0182288885,
0.0101612248,
-0.0361815058,
0.0745701641,
0.0079408977,
-0.0287371837,
0.0362114608,
-0.0270709451,
-0.0093976259,
0.0094106048,
-0.043818716,
-0.0011051144,
0.0153240906,
-0.0516469777,
-0.006158974,
0.0173553899,
-0.0173390042,
-0.0278054625,
0.0206921678,
0.0222627372,
0.0220373292,
-0.0296812057,
0.0864282399,
-0.0455959924,
0.0041215946,
0.0113994842,
0.0136945918,
0.0218011327,
0.0439901724,
-0.0176817495,
0.0294838063,
0.037668936,
-0.0003279647,
0.0126533033,
0.0355427265,
-0.0407483652,
0.030682018,
0.0323018022,
-0.0157604925,
0.0147547703,
0.0051301257,
2.289e-7,
0.0403354242,
0.0301899575,
0.0826759562,
-0.0687846094,
-0.0146556692,
0.0172347501,
-0.0408817753,
0.0304558165,
0.010498262,
0.0553936586,
0.009055418,
0.0032499968,
0.0353652611,
0.0195545331,
-0.1032691821,
-0.0121290619,
-0.1056141779,
-0.0603378043,
-0.0383099243,
0.0191818681,
0.0167065207,
0.0546121635,
-0.0035323754,
0.0036263906,
-0.0274623204,
0.0072523872,
0.0464930646,
0.0203077421,
-0.0071336846,
0.0602528974,
0.0153997708,
-0.0288788248,
-0.0388410278,
-0.0465888269,
-0.0138848703,
0.0385544673,
0.0397182256,
0.0630254149,
-0.0074374885,
0.0210007895,
0.0585571751,
0.0074095754,
-0.0036285825,
0.0211781878,
0.0269791186,
-0.002103836,
-0.0347973369,
0.0271920133,
-0.0482998975,
0.0379528403,
-0.0325920768,
0.0060261223,
-0.0452246442,
0.0360042639,
0.0004545637,
-0.09606684,
0.0088421479,
-0.0467718914,
-0.0228320379,
-0.0029807058,
-0.0369992256,
-0.0611006245,
0.0010007177,
0.0196540579,
0.0496725626,
-0.052854944,
0.0365304165,
1.908701835e-34,
0.0734077692,
-0.0001613834,
-0.0456440113,
0.0164047517,
-0.0070256605,
-0.0541425943,
0.0492836535,
0.0148402313,
-0.0227854382,
-0.0749192089,
-0.0195193179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01890v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01890v4
|
Sociocultural knowledge is needed for selection of shots in hate speech detection tasks
| 2023-04-04T15:42:08 | 2023-05-17T23:01:20 |
Antonis Maronikolakis, Abdullatif Köksal, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce HATELEXICON, a lexicon of slurs and targets of hate speech for
the countries of Brazil, Germany, India and Kenya, to aid training and
interpretability of models. We demonstrate how our lexicon can be used to
interpret model predictions, showing that models developed to classify extreme
speech rely heavily on target words when making predictions. Further, we
propose a method to aid shot selection for training in low-resource settings
via HATELEXICON. In few-shot learning, the selection of shots is of paramount
importance to model performance. In our work, we simulate a few-shot setting
for German and Hindi, using HASOC data for training and the Multilingual
HateCheck (MHC) as a benchmark. We show that selecting shots based on our
lexicon leads to models performing better on MHC than models trained on shots
sampled randomly. Thus, when given only a few training examples, using our
lexicon to select shots containing more sociocultural information leads to
better few-shot performance.
|
[
0.057907518,
0.0499667376,
-0.0279688071,
0.033669062,
0.0019794651,
0.0548976436,
0.0483365767,
0.0310584344,
0.0131809888,
-0.0538444258,
-0.0248822011,
-0.0337757021,
-0.0063062483,
-0.0089473501,
-0.0205057655,
-0.0631398708,
0.0308184605,
0.0257661678,
0.0075864601,
-0.0241072718,
0.0404147618,
0.0169421565,
-0.0116274003,
0.029276846,
-0.05800163,
0.0358355306,
0.0420129634,
-0.0032483099,
0.0451903231,
-0.002186107,
0.0347049497,
0.0384220779,
-0.0009252236,
0.0634207055,
0.0000018006,
-0.0570046343,
0.0388427526,
-0.0178988371,
-0.015443542,
-0.0377033167,
0.0829642862,
-0.0516820028,
-0.0116694542,
0.0052118585,
-0.020675946,
0.0109580243,
0.0496166348,
0.0296020266,
0.0128595531,
0.0677590668,
0.007995693,
-0.0553825721,
-0.0277515836,
0.014312298,
-0.0101384008,
0.0332223885,
0.0287165791,
-0.0175432563,
-0.0417865552,
-0.005170559,
-0.029763028,
-0.0084155127,
0.0110537168,
0.0477356315,
0.0170502346,
-0.0260019172,
-0.0578188561,
-0.028607307,
0.0229710247,
0.0370806269,
-0.0551132299,
-0.0115866652,
-0.0160388257,
-0.0191054717,
-0.0564762838,
-0.0270406902,
-0.0073942426,
-0.0246360339,
0.0034369528,
0.0222112127,
0.0290301498,
0.0304910392,
0.0274886694,
0.0563499629,
0.0294366982,
0.010628663,
-0.0307901911,
0.0028256688,
-0.0058870828,
-0.0110929357,
-0.0163206831,
-0.0026073661,
0.0044420864,
0.0020394151,
-0.0030447848,
0.002575798,
-0.0343507417,
-0.0231183898,
0.0148651861,
-0.0802368894,
0.0312897488,
0.0481417291,
-0.0471875854,
0.0025526886,
0.0180679504,
0.0279186051,
0.0031424218,
-0.0102615226,
0.0064201839,
-0.0351356417,
-0.0404020473,
0.0292394627,
0.0375524685,
-0.0399038866,
-0.0189267024,
0.0556689762,
-0.0821022391,
-0.0293992385,
-0.0368023962,
-0.0223625768,
-0.0324152075,
-0.0086695505,
-0.0153780868,
-0.0100685712,
-0.0144218849,
0.022005247,
-0.0657088831,
0.0075602224,
-0.0430951416,
-0.08170674,
0.0101569397,
0.02613662,
-0.0254580732,
-0.0260135997,
0.0414659455,
0.0445465259,
0.0393397026,
-0.0319649577,
-0.0535274111,
-0.0167739894,
-0.0334722213,
-0.0690498278,
0.0159103516,
-0.0441706255,
0.0259801224,
-0.0087785376,
0.0030137443,
-0.0536403656,
-0.0087577598,
-0.0117305862,
-0.060635943,
0.0942049548,
0.0375867747,
-0.0440976396,
0.0469506942,
0.0230370983,
0.0061051403,
0.0770544931,
-0.0128132952,
0.0033972894,
0.0415987037,
0.0075866673,
0.0144997677,
0.0632889196,
0.03431537,
0.0178494547,
-0.0746428967,
0.0202701874,
-0.0357337184,
-0.0496476218,
0.0247524958,
-0.0034083738,
-0.02393445,
-0.0379712544,
0.0113443006,
0.076992929,
-0.0281963833,
-0.0084691159,
0.0346802175,
0.0192967597,
-0.0374943726,
-0.0148730641,
-0.0464538969,
-0.0189431235,
-0.0543049276,
-0.0386188738,
-0.0028003808,
0.0470993482,
-0.0315151215,
-0.0178222153,
-0.0488149114,
-0.0158827696,
0.0229354724,
-0.0239721239,
0.0570687316,
0.0077101793,
0.0143230055,
0.0084971972,
0.0979790911,
-0.009694688,
-0.01496315,
-0.0447612815,
-0.0125650065,
0.0536294617,
0.0054810937,
0.0111110508,
0.0080192871,
-0.0496030301,
-0.0110904351,
0.0373168588,
0.0165519621,
-0.0092963018,
0.0347502269,
-0.0449243896,
-0.0178545099,
0.0505671129,
0.0146065289,
0.0219679344,
0.0781601518,
0.0081400955,
0.0220975298,
0.0261462871,
-0.0310439691,
0.0024729532,
-0.0041601383,
-0.0443166122,
-0.0034513779,
0.0126374606,
0.0613064617,
0.0094723487,
-0.0265034679,
-0.0855166167,
-0.0249609575,
-0.0239774082,
0.0019578987,
0.0360154063,
-0.0229011122,
-0.0357594565,
0.0001184491,
-0.0458093397,
0.0199868288,
0.0701351836,
0.0064688055,
0.0027529013,
0.0504228324,
-0.0002418081,
0.0005834021,
-0.0181815494,
-0.0302581657,
-0.060006246,
0.0607526042,
-0.0122606987,
0.0647105873,
-0.0159599446,
-0.0267789867,
0.0078015332,
-0.0445598774,
0.0486804806,
0.0159696415,
-0.0594409853,
-0.0142153045,
-0.0027210827,
0.0045797294,
-0.0095498543,
0.0066372412,
0.0040977551,
0.0133216996,
-0.0873912796,
0.0081584565,
-0.0319011062,
-0.054092247,
-0.0073086135,
-0.00796628,
-0.0176938437,
0.0034373542,
0.0109596783,
-0.0064154337,
0.04682016,
0.0417342782,
-0.0213078186,
-0.0427153111,
-0.0163001902,
0.0058181859,
-0.0212619323,
-0.0066434643,
0.043184001,
-0.0190796051,
-0.0385520421,
0.0416820236,
-0.0184522625,
-0.0345600285,
0.0081052799,
-0.0263132267,
-0.0631766245,
0.005473169,
0.0526499674,
-0.0378368534,
0.04397019,
0.0176614486,
0.073585242,
0.0153285312,
-0.0149603775,
-0.0030880098,
-0.0186606832,
0.0101324571,
0.0350855403,
-0.0398297235,
-0.0424706005,
-0.0315228701,
0.099129945,
0.0446944833,
0.0062425602,
-0.0661427155,
0.0295845196,
-0.0681037754,
-0.0444372483,
-0.0273104776,
-0.040038839,
-0.021252133,
0.0124423429,
-0.0122576021,
-0.0364909284,
0.0585163608,
0.0130623598,
0.0236466452,
-0.0132228713,
-0.0240210127,
-0.0073184269,
0.0275373496,
0.011095765,
0.0299904924,
-0.0491405018,
0.0282588694,
0.0001870893,
-0.0460493267,
0.032267347,
-0.0234586317,
-0.0378488004,
-0.025841333,
-0.0093528032,
-0.018681014,
-0.0422670282,
-0.0428654067,
-0.0356935486,
-0.051776018,
-0.016053237,
0.0246482845,
-0.0148226619,
0.0105211642,
0.0344208293,
0.0332646742,
-0.0081905862,
-0.0007101332,
0.0048983325,
0.0531909689,
-0.0153103638,
0.0243759807,
-0.0169673078,
0.0208275393,
0.0175291691,
-0.0144208139,
0.0225419085,
0.0317275748,
0.0180852767,
-0.0092477538,
0.0229776651,
0.0323956236,
0.0157070197,
-0.0230183955,
-0.0151034938,
0.0250214282,
-0.0057669259,
-0.0053899004,
0.0717133433,
0.0103400601,
-0.0034542102,
-0.0038018578,
-0.0216824133,
0.0014265832,
0.0100102508,
0.0049222959,
-0.0872625634,
-0.0061870022,
-0.0102470266,
0.0211990159,
-0.0880821869,
-0.0360239744,
-0.0027805683,
-0.0720334575,
0.0191482864,
-0.0074425153,
-0.0561952628,
-0.0056386045,
-0.004759789,
0.0078158733,
-0.0207854174,
0.0292008631,
-0.0185527951,
0.0260675866,
-0.0346227102,
0.0305472557,
-0.0602115802,
-0.016623674,
0.04809108,
-0.011511676,
0.055735074,
0.0308018867,
0.0267286822,
-0.0304816049,
0.0019090256,
-0.0221617408,
-0.016671773,
0.0034292459,
-0.0721009746,
0.0458987392,
0.0092640417,
-0.0703459233,
0.0199826173,
0.0503704213,
-0.0005815941,
0.0018247921,
0.0010306041,
0.0250872374,
0.0214029476,
0.0222647078,
-0.05256873,
0.0207001995,
-0.0270901173,
0.0656934306,
0.0287223011,
-0.0520599745,
0.0270479172,
-0.0485244617,
-0.0361250602,
-0.0452531017,
-0.1031442359,
0.039918527,
-0.0342852846,
-0.0703863427,
0.0126074646,
-0.0557391904,
0.0396338962,
0.0512908846,
0.0203280933,
-0.0085085481,
-0.0358797051,
-0.0119844014,
-0.0373829864,
0.0174255371,
-0.0278128609,
0.0130051011,
0.027261924,
-0.0018687656,
0.0210148022,
-0.0044250851,
-0.0320581608,
0.0143534364,
-0.0401008576,
-0.0399169624,
0.0898294151,
0.0672118515,
0.0175115578,
0.0464996174,
-0.0030650313,
-0.0807426199,
0.0921117887,
0.0317592807,
0.0044518025,
0.0096894195,
0.054960072,
-0.0038065265,
-0.0047642714,
0.0127290897,
0.0039253938,
0.0694689602,
0.0676235557,
-0.0528344139,
-0.1010918468,
0.0328431651,
-0.0376389921,
-0.0377662778,
0.065416418,
-0.0411537588,
-0.0974400565,
-0.0171111152,
-0.0031546887,
0.0220854916,
-0.0196412206,
0.0114490883,
-0.0354752466,
0.0068159783,
-0.0239004288,
-0.0443845429,
-0.0406974256,
-0.0627650768,
0.0156028494,
-0.0316041671,
0.0344684348,
0.0675316676,
0.0208445769,
0.016324928,
0.0261447113,
-0.0283233095,
0.0480892062,
0.0081879376,
-0.0130811892,
-0.0102590946,
0.0443286709,
-0.0077810753,
0.0015231873,
0.0547088906,
-0.0344509147,
0.0347033218,
0.0174803976,
-0.0591751859,
-0.0215917788,
-0.0069408407,
-0.0691912472,
0.0179159995,
0.0163132269,
0.0079508275,
-0.0179072917,
-0.0106044058,
-0.0284410212,
-0.0709282756,
0.0200264677,
0.0291645546,
-0.0302795283,
0.0178046171,
0.0510011837,
0.0386634246,
0.0230894424,
0.0733890831,
-0.0153199676,
-0.0355886519,
-0.0138469357,
0.081430234,
0.0164443925,
0.0168120582,
0.0396346152,
-0.0776087046,
-0.0402668715,
0.0225780178,
-0.0331547074,
0.0219523106,
0.0241346173,
0.0383256301,
0.0729174688,
-0.0178673305,
0.0104383091,
-0.0118049001,
-0.0089724474,
0.0228176918,
-0.0417789482,
0.0398374163,
-5.729648564e-33,
-0.0217730701,
-0.0144817745,
-0.0087783588,
-0.0470372252,
0.049048394,
-0.0176575836,
0.0329885222,
0.0217908658,
-0.0129593266,
0.0328344516,
0.0030987614,
0.0095939068,
0.0140718436,
0.0122384215,
0.0229420401,
-0.0235711746,
0.0265614893,
0.0134474784,
0.0068074656,
-0.020803446,
0.080886744,
0.0066005751,
0.064663589,
-0.0149139576,
0.0234783087,
-0.0077391285,
0.0125222011,
-0.0066169193,
0.0457321592,
0.0826658532,
-0.0386524014,
0.0902592242,
0.0342199951,
-0.0410380289,
0.00411609,
-0.0083743837,
-0.0406563915,
-0.032561779,
0.0128508685,
0.0603802875,
0.0449989364,
0.0000770683,
0.0419372767,
-0.0009365098,
-0.059453994,
-0.0077326661,
0.022664262,
-0.0548875667,
-0.0148979779,
-0.0273653455,
-0.0744610727,
0.0466120206,
-0.0187483728,
-0.0007199675,
-0.0054248245,
0.0408626385,
0.0277884156,
-0.0017414449,
-0.0385752767,
-0.0100165242,
0.016289968,
-0.0012690376,
0.025753323,
0.0244623851,
-0.0027820268,
0.0767033398,
0.0206988622,
-0.0107510388,
0.0088953162,
0.0048856321,
0.0692982078,
0.0114461249,
-0.0043812273,
0.0974431187,
0.0225917473,
-0.0724167898,
-0.0499401353,
-0.021562634,
0.0477438979,
0.0160236526,
0.0185988732,
-0.0328424908,
-0.0824882761,
-0.0406142846,
0.0108180549,
-0.0568995439,
-0.0155971413,
-0.0192360766,
0.0296214335,
-0.0137487538,
-0.0176709052,
0.0254277978,
0.055248782,
-0.0107328761,
0.0162918512,
0.0517940968,
-0.0117478473,
0.001907717,
0.0226003267,
0.0220461879,
-0.0461977683,
-0.0195140149,
-0.0282020587,
-0.008933505,
0.0385519788,
0.0100837033,
0.0727416724,
0.0119288554,
-0.0677384585,
0.0123576606,
-0.0080932193,
0.0496607833,
-0.0258650072,
0.0351385586,
0.0216860864,
0.0461406633,
-0.0167926885,
-0.0304027516,
0.0213743933,
-0.0573272854,
0.0169762801,
0.023349192,
-0.0373107232,
0.0185226668,
-0.0211150479,
-0.0276645608,
0.0015412469,
0.00055072,
0.0146559523,
-0.0646374673,
0.0209203903,
-0.0177874714,
2.489e-7,
-0.0280543137,
0.0569197387,
-0.0323322155,
-0.0086492933,
0.0104647744,
0.0472245812,
0.0194440372,
0.0118450141,
-0.0276965033,
-0.0107102944,
-0.015612998,
0.0533092134,
0.0328955837,
0.0821389183,
-0.0471883081,
-0.0119758137,
-0.0448460206,
0.001465883,
-0.0694774091,
0.0043091038,
-0.0515463054,
0.0967367738,
0.0900405198,
-0.0361652598,
-0.0178574249,
-0.0052014347,
0.015505584,
-0.0324258395,
-0.0438596494,
-0.037083704,
0.0437659286,
0.0309968032,
0.0261498392,
0.0170888174,
-0.0140834497,
0.0260027479,
-0.0120845418,
0.0450217016,
-0.0138218589,
-0.0025219845,
-0.0038450127,
-0.0086991703,
-0.0374379642,
-0.0407944731,
0.0517621078,
0.0167348925,
-0.0028325745,
-0.0667326748,
-0.0116211083,
-0.0032106552,
0.0537603907,
-0.0242060777,
0.0147532308,
-0.0149679985,
0.0497692525,
-0.0230561234,
-0.0107341651,
-0.0538375489,
0.0001366451,
0.0157699604,
-0.0162833445,
-0.0277646426,
-0.001981752,
-0.0130711375,
0.0292813089,
0.0457653254,
0.0177842118,
1.716169865e-34,
0.025813885,
0.0048347102,
-0.0057284962,
-0.0224180501,
0.0263602324,
0.0199575126,
-0.0130704381,
-0.0011300669,
0.0549983382,
0.0030500093,
0.0119035291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01852v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01852v4
|
Summary of ChatGPT-Related Research and Perspective Towards the Future of Large Language Models
| 2023-04-04T15:01:06 | 2023-08-22T03:18:43 |
Yiheng Liu, Tianle Han, Siyuan Ma, Jiayue Zhang, Yuanyuan Yang, Jiaming Tian, Hao He, Antong Li, Mengshen He, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Lin Zhao, Dajiang Zhu, Xiang Li, Ning Qiang, Dingang Shen, Tianming Liu, Bao Ge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a comprehensive survey of ChatGPT-related (GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4) research, state-of-the-art large language models (LLM) from the GPT
series, and their prospective applications across diverse domains. Indeed, key
innovations such as large-scale pre-training that captures knowledge across the
entire world wide web, instruction fine-tuning and Reinforcement Learning from
Human Feedback (RLHF) have played significant roles in enhancing LLMs'
adaptability and performance. We performed an in-depth analysis of 194 relevant
papers on arXiv, encompassing trend analysis, word cloud representation, and
distribution analysis across various application domains. The findings reveal a
significant and increasing interest in ChatGPT-related research, predominantly
centered on direct natural language processing applications, while also
demonstrating considerable potential in areas ranging from education and
history to mathematics, medicine, and physics. This study endeavors to furnish
insights into ChatGPT's capabilities, potential implications, ethical concerns,
and offer direction for future advancements in this field.
|
[
0.070517756,
0.0396099985,
-0.0223521851,
0.0296337027,
-0.0626637191,
0.0099905906,
-0.0034248526,
0.0080188178,
0.0488846898,
-0.0997866541,
-0.0344073363,
-0.0581040904,
-0.023373533,
0.0120326895,
0.0296469461,
-0.054397352,
0.0522996522,
-0.0528069064,
-0.011993452,
-0.0057717119,
0.0114514316,
0.0223748609,
0.0030992583,
0.0598317087,
0.0233993214,
-0.0184735693,
0.0078467168,
-0.0192790926,
-0.0196836498,
-0.0301130898,
0.0109421946,
0.0445172898,
0.0447463952,
0.0869570002,
0.0000022318,
-0.0426368713,
-0.031608846,
0.0173846595,
-0.0175536517,
0.0471332148,
0.0594195202,
0.0132177956,
-0.0200459901,
0.0324990042,
-0.0365265831,
-0.0088021122,
0.0473788641,
0.0204816367,
0.0577253252,
0.0665808991,
-0.0026408397,
-0.014707108,
0.0626917854,
-0.0249830466,
-0.0095532369,
-0.0438484997,
0.0484234728,
0.0311347414,
0.0213124957,
0.0260729231,
-0.0258505289,
0.0323117487,
-0.0106000723,
-0.0031603414,
-0.0194843225,
0.045040004,
-0.0581177026,
0.0014236098,
-0.0351768732,
0.0439702012,
0.0164593607,
-0.0165158715,
0.0231973641,
0.0130989486,
-0.0341746584,
0.0214588773,
-0.0523936376,
0.0351385958,
0.0035530275,
0.0219791513,
0.0156824365,
-0.0190716479,
0.0236203838,
0.0252921097,
-0.0148095312,
0.0317773037,
0.0218341909,
-0.0528050289,
0.0018995235,
0.0158334021,
-0.0627572685,
-0.0464295782,
0.0195838232,
0.0108136833,
-0.0081944922,
0.0259646494,
-0.0290788934,
-0.0067929975,
0.0349610373,
-0.0560424328,
0.0149051826,
0.0265759937,
0.0144189876,
0.0612611957,
0.0138106663,
0.0590558201,
-0.027384501,
0.0002955875,
-0.0230176039,
-0.0035593512,
-0.0962131694,
-0.0248163976,
-0.0540969409,
0.0212019738,
-0.0130951824,
-0.039370697,
-0.0380440988,
0.0284743346,
0.0003806961,
-0.0221963339,
0.0208070595,
-0.0088199154,
-0.026846461,
-0.0097368006,
-0.0161390901,
0.0411812328,
0.0054809218,
-0.0086175269,
-0.0273901056,
-0.0493615642,
0.0142096272,
0.0016653314,
-0.015467125,
-0.0189900212,
0.0098597594,
0.0922891498,
0.005961169,
-0.0403239764,
-0.0228663012,
-0.0205778684,
-0.0284638479,
-0.0588284209,
-0.0118088331,
-0.0591782592,
0.0216704533,
0.0052698157,
0.0261415578,
0.008477333,
0.0003063795,
0.0241653286,
-0.0508952327,
0.0529092923,
-0.0095431088,
0.0145068513,
0.019913679,
-0.0126994113,
0.0109501677,
0.0821762607,
0.0392886251,
-0.0062342472,
0.0363635533,
-0.031167483,
-0.0267430246,
0.0442211144,
0.0217795875,
0.0188992266,
0.0051143826,
0.000462272,
0.0170794148,
0.0420061275,
-0.0004431102,
0.0784101114,
-0.0448367968,
-0.0005182284,
0.0620655157,
0.0892104805,
0.0023838675,
0.0448263921,
0.0414915793,
0.0438754298,
0.0231439229,
-0.0177915078,
-0.0472445115,
-0.0330645628,
-0.0365594365,
0.0046174144,
0.0048765191,
0.0513925366,
-0.0088754185,
-0.0036010966,
-0.0182582084,
0.0069035119,
0.0184715707,
-0.0054190271,
0.0716690272,
-0.0284010842,
-0.0303884186,
0.0186712537,
0.0655667186,
-0.0061549367,
0.0219786447,
-0.088009581,
-0.0146121848,
0.0704395324,
0.0868560448,
-0.0318392739,
-0.0342277326,
-0.0176264904,
0.0084559247,
0.0472647846,
0.0529551767,
0.0006279611,
-0.0502700657,
-0.0336821228,
-0.0234654527,
0.0184904821,
-0.0083228555,
0.019564826,
0.040172074,
0.0196300372,
-0.0025656524,
-0.0071355198,
-0.0308395028,
0.0296180807,
-0.0326719508,
-0.0147482986,
-0.0314125419,
-0.0284734834,
0.0355921723,
0.0133135607,
-0.0293024387,
-0.0024880671,
0.0144720953,
-0.010786511,
-0.0297199581,
-0.0216967482,
-0.0431059785,
-0.0339392386,
0.0405167453,
-0.0199868008,
0.0115535306,
0.0072958982,
-0.0444500633,
-0.0242121704,
0.0033305627,
-0.0184201729,
0.0835425332,
-0.0516812243,
0.0118992394,
-0.0208839271,
-0.0154280858,
-0.052642718,
0.0451083332,
0.00530174,
0.0022113575,
0.0027913041,
0.0070905536,
0.0076150042,
-0.0184234791,
-0.0509605668,
0.0198413879,
0.0114282332,
0.0371299833,
0.0326139331,
0.0187864434,
-0.0406669378,
-0.0448094979,
-0.1192258373,
0.0220944062,
-0.0130484831,
0.0279746931,
0.0025175442,
0.0144775352,
-0.0300063714,
-0.003466221,
-0.0213376563,
0.0006496118,
0.0150948092,
0.0315050296,
0.0180058926,
-0.0158764943,
0.0048615281,
-0.0388846584,
-0.0371530466,
-0.0185489301,
0.0232269634,
0.0292520579,
-0.0193806421,
-0.0533923246,
0.0309769381,
-0.0301096793,
0.0376900621,
-0.0179970972,
-0.0456281789,
0.0041117934,
-0.0238114744,
0.0530444458,
0.0417273194,
0.0146485381,
0.0260198824,
0.0269465521,
-0.0044266707,
-0.0416198596,
0.004339003,
-0.0469880216,
-0.0588339753,
-0.0492353551,
0.0136255752,
0.0067537436,
0.0702208877,
0.0070184018,
-0.0189744867,
-0.0658616498,
-0.0039973231,
-0.0634209067,
0.0133476043,
-0.0545714796,
-0.0048262929,
-0.0317856371,
-0.0190897696,
-0.0034134372,
-0.0494793393,
0.0774969906,
-0.0259019192,
0.0113920867,
-0.074674584,
-0.0212150384,
-0.0453372747,
0.0459897034,
0.0160469804,
0.0183358006,
-0.0163719021,
-0.0258657243,
-0.0433894694,
0.0053732549,
0.0123497015,
-0.0458739512,
0.0069169044,
-0.0263962224,
0.0291364882,
-0.0153946122,
-0.033575315,
-0.0172584523,
-0.0470416322,
-0.0375409983,
0.0069888062,
0.0769069642,
-0.0215081275,
-0.0047330828,
0.0369814262,
0.0111484267,
0.0310300402,
-0.0197294448,
-0.0137760676,
-0.0256820079,
0.0179922115,
0.0624391064,
-0.0089806113,
0.0278975014,
-0.0132086966,
-0.0056028632,
0.0765642077,
0.0570931546,
-0.0208982918,
-0.0057680821,
0.0056738188,
0.0341943689,
-0.0644948781,
-0.0110518672,
0.0022252656,
0.0258615054,
-0.0698885173,
0.0099595198,
0.1258628666,
0.0244197939,
-0.0688002333,
-0.0091519691,
0.0184066929,
0.0214585327,
-0.0024625089,
0.0219997,
-0.0766267106,
-0.0255579278,
-0.0124381008,
0.0143981399,
-0.0003267599,
-0.03346093,
-0.0002713574,
-0.1060990989,
0.0360377133,
0.0171259101,
-0.0059199799,
0.0081873657,
-0.0377175659,
-0.001510063,
-0.0168827865,
-0.0053620818,
0.0011421501,
-0.0541964322,
-0.0058246162,
0.0292510707,
-0.0473203287,
-0.052029077,
0.0535154305,
-0.0513862558,
0.0608746,
0.0711180717,
0.0266229697,
-0.0103198048,
-0.0014738494,
0.023803737,
0.0023565043,
-0.0004496648,
-0.0159701519,
0.0446031243,
-0.0324012637,
-0.0081756059,
-0.0379915945,
0.0169978458,
-0.0217272751,
0.005209059,
0.0242036656,
0.1201704964,
-0.016913658,
0.0061844201,
-0.0219746754,
-0.0233140811,
0.0139287077,
0.0934331566,
-0.0087596253,
-0.0664149895,
-0.0494616367,
-0.0088955248,
0.0054286793,
0.0134171806,
-0.0476430953,
-0.0005750394,
-0.0070919185,
0.0056130714,
-0.0574704744,
-0.0202508643,
0.0344411321,
-0.0019897036,
0.0156943984,
0.020350283,
0.0589423701,
0.0181659665,
-0.0162242875,
0.0245190635,
-0.0418348499,
-0.0035330115,
-0.080348216,
-0.0284126662,
0.0595078543,
-0.0181965269,
-0.0287018549,
0.0315231979,
-0.0851326138,
-0.06669157,
-0.0028533237,
0.0181822926,
0.0197221506,
0.046489846,
-0.0117618451,
-0.035793703,
0.0457420163,
0.0267408472,
-0.0514377095,
0.0004036966,
0.00694498,
0.0337256528,
-0.0129686976,
0.0241520572,
-0.0277324747,
0.0171662308,
-0.0063446295,
0.0387451686,
0.0063225571,
-0.0173527729,
0.020663375,
0.0134142041,
0.0538391732,
-0.0243578628,
0.0056833066,
-0.0393809564,
-0.0151734222,
-0.0206370074,
0.0084354123,
-0.053308636,
-0.0221286528,
0.028229842,
-0.0410865732,
-0.0270558801,
-0.0017561438,
-0.001380269,
0.0263629127,
-0.0556518771,
0.0307401177,
-0.0021154745,
0.0092557557,
0.0560976937,
0.0002123452,
-0.0037482611,
0.0004549736,
-0.0101696961,
0.0208221581,
-0.0404445045,
0.070411101,
0.0215525739,
-0.0174269695,
-0.0007385538,
0.028383499,
-0.0689352527,
-0.0747947991,
-0.0280482806,
0.0657915995,
0.0635324419,
0.0089444937,
0.0572411679,
-0.0548549779,
-0.0303408001,
-0.0155618591,
0.013510935,
-0.0090568848,
-0.0035354157,
0.0053850007,
0.0177223943,
-0.0413351208,
0.0328075215,
0.0802029595,
0.0259822123,
0.0439138487,
0.0308432765,
-0.0410087816,
-0.022067355,
-0.0282621142,
-0.0045970408,
0.0040253289,
-0.0028679345,
0.0294535141,
-0.0641288683,
-0.0536728613,
-0.0326881744,
0.0090614744,
-0.0278486293,
-0.0366911069,
0.0568074621,
0.0678920448,
-0.023478562,
-0.0013105167,
-0.0475585982,
0.0236234479,
-0.0111154038,
-0.0306798425,
-0.0009904852,
-6.952243137e-33,
-0.0085930564,
0.0114775263,
0.0497207642,
0.0215488449,
-0.0541037954,
0.0016676362,
-0.0030533578,
-0.0168324504,
-0.0002360856,
0.008637323,
-0.0233289804,
0.0013448272,
0.0009601304,
0.0323880464,
0.0081884535,
0.0046846452,
0.0526565313,
-0.0259422082,
0.0139508881,
0.074930273,
0.0279541146,
0.0200377367,
0.0882729962,
-0.0476224869,
0.0080160461,
0.0025922835,
0.0166667048,
0.0079876073,
-0.0033752583,
0.0601122975,
-0.0635690168,
0.0464587919,
0.0102232229,
-0.0364888012,
-0.012270011,
-0.0000738728,
-0.0673159659,
-0.019137254,
0.0072547398,
-0.010810595,
-0.0054405038,
0.0077966759,
0.0323537849,
-0.0198627189,
-0.0139358416,
0.0027947272,
0.0206675567,
0.0019214918,
-0.0355769433,
-0.0059162653,
-0.0534519404,
0.0316806585,
-0.0099627096,
-0.0104856705,
0.0203064121,
0.001639048,
-0.0114241466,
0.0263899583,
-0.0434669368,
0.0199412052,
0.0611397587,
0.0222010445,
0.0388035066,
0.0038003877,
0.033559233,
0.0755161643,
0.0067907614,
-0.0019587842,
-0.0078879315,
-0.0250200294,
0.0437568091,
0.0174174216,
0.0228750613,
0.0270803627,
0.0034853478,
-0.0136382738,
-0.0581771843,
-0.0264784954,
0.0266927443,
0.0339520834,
0.0363252051,
-0.0095835021,
-0.0607393645,
-0.0359637141,
-0.0152885653,
-0.0021836592,
-0.0039178268,
-0.0195891764,
0.0371854901,
0.0017613743,
-0.004244389,
0.0114278588,
0.0462794676,
-0.0586737506,
-0.0325500555,
0.031596534,
0.001993136,
0.0203608647,
-0.0117507726,
0.025817845,
-0.0870734826,
-0.0547319613,
-0.0264358222,
-0.016919259,
-0.0230159052,
-0.013001781,
-0.0123845441,
0.0312008336,
-0.0510985628,
0.0159724541,
-0.0100079076,
0.016248541,
0.01069842,
-0.0040953727,
0.0456528738,
0.0128620053,
0.0203513596,
0.0475708619,
0.0611547269,
-0.0130798873,
-0.0070425384,
-0.0229559764,
-0.0081958482,
0.0055179535,
-0.0062776371,
0.0216994006,
-0.0441240445,
0.0177706592,
0.0300188344,
-0.0702991337,
-0.0084480764,
0.0009919771,
2.973e-7,
0.0410765931,
0.0841126963,
0.0082220091,
-0.0217221752,
0.0352512263,
0.0135288248,
-0.0085719237,
0.0269848313,
0.0159063973,
0.0265164748,
0.015496444,
0.0388599932,
0.0439259633,
0.0250909273,
-0.1009483784,
-0.0199589748,
-0.0922729969,
-0.0025671069,
-0.0747161731,
0.0182979703,
0.0609001853,
0.1013992801,
0.0173456427,
0.0005252416,
-0.0139920125,
-0.0516858995,
0.0846532658,
-0.0365491733,
-0.0274823792,
0.0487157479,
0.0075821676,
0.0357469097,
0.000757709,
0.0069665518,
-0.0104001071,
0.0260641836,
0.0098503819,
0.0641452,
-0.0043323152,
0.0294422302,
0.0074149719,
-0.0371667035,
-0.0098949624,
-0.070313938,
0.0821416676,
-0.0870083123,
-0.015812844,
-0.0357129872,
-0.0027605896,
-0.0685273185,
0.0173299219,
-0.0242595188,
-0.0236549135,
0.0269430205,
-0.004267341,
0.0125340698,
-0.0147119528,
-0.0783467442,
0.0206065383,
-0.000167153,
-0.0461873412,
-0.0538006835,
-0.0388380773,
-0.0049988478,
0.0238867719,
-0.0329794772,
0.025811106,
3.042012699e-34,
0.0599089749,
-0.026891483,
0.0242189001,
0.0052077719,
0.0323250629,
0.032246042,
0.0301057603,
0.0162552558,
0.0069556311,
-0.1057409197,
-0.0175760724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01774v1
|
A User-Centered, Interactive, Human-in-the-Loop Topic Modelling System
| 2023-04-04T13:05:10 | 2023-04-04T13:05:10 |
Zheng Fang, Lama Alqazlan, Du Liu, Yulan He, Rob Procter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Human-in-the-loop topic modelling incorporates users' knowledge into the
modelling process, enabling them to refine the model iteratively. Recent
research has demonstrated the value of user feedback, but there are still
issues to consider, such as the difficulty in tracking changes, comparing
different models and the lack of evaluation based on real-world examples of
use. We developed a novel, interactive human-in-the-loop topic modeling system
with a user-friendly interface that enables users compare and record every step
they take, and a novel topic words suggestion feature to help users provide
feedback that is faithful to the ground truth. Our system also supports not
only what traditional topic models can do, i.e., learning the topics from the
whole corpus, but also targeted topic modelling, i.e., learning topics for
specific aspects of the corpus. In this article, we provide an overview of the
system and present the results of a series of user studies designed to assess
the value of the system in progressively more realistic applications of topic
modelling.
|
[
0.0645865053,
-0.0257255565,
-0.0191707369,
-0.0086273812,
-0.0421206355,
-0.0029520702,
0.0030326787,
-0.020372998,
-0.0157631487,
-0.0372056216,
0.0099263676,
0.025392279,
-0.0164302308,
0.0242982786,
-0.01919166,
-0.0769977495,
0.022039013,
-0.0187751781,
0.003847298,
0.0487943031,
0.0386389717,
0.0230680294,
-0.0126051856,
0.0373065583,
-0.0095404331,
0.0081655588,
-0.0189590678,
-0.0326985493,
-0.0262593124,
-0.0425070561,
0.0121993683,
0.0818669349,
0.0263767391,
-0.0030145089,
0.0000022009,
-0.0045458474,
-0.0002733291,
-0.0372534245,
0.0021463099,
0.0418847352,
0.1230696812,
0.0214555096,
0.0341512635,
0.0025063935,
-0.0197843909,
0.0494967699,
0.0163349472,
0.0142532196,
0.06722752,
-0.0215795822,
-0.0317698754,
0.0313690417,
-0.0336869359,
-0.028333731,
0.0161444973,
-0.0260612462,
0.0054653985,
0.0262072273,
0.0686298534,
0.0455753356,
0.0280936062,
0.0151400855,
-0.0193868708,
-0.0174946878,
0.0606574975,
0.000152805,
0.0192118604,
-0.0714063272,
0.0051077823,
0.0485685281,
0.0523176715,
-0.0175570957,
0.0200412795,
-0.0217117816,
-0.032185521,
0.063504912,
-0.0572305322,
-0.0225329287,
-0.0270431172,
-0.0171443895,
0.0178105105,
-0.024720123,
0.0205945037,
0.0544035509,
0.0250416938,
0.0272738468,
0.0308759771,
-0.0043766005,
-0.0265235454,
0.0183897689,
0.0318934582,
-0.0830150843,
0.0383709706,
-0.0098654013,
-0.0448138155,
0.018145388,
0.0111305183,
-0.0202570278,
0.03166629,
-0.061768163,
0.0095414892,
-0.023665078,
-0.0104750236,
0.0522447824,
0.1021545753,
-0.0497816578,
-0.0324254036,
-0.0679951087,
0.0004420123,
0.0127979992,
-0.0480695367,
0.009692098,
-0.018350631,
0.0029452513,
0.0251349825,
-0.0327261873,
0.0181344077,
0.0394745059,
-0.0121938717,
-0.0070647374,
-0.0365813673,
0.011956824,
-0.0476597659,
-0.0334109627,
-0.0465612933,
0.0186205525,
-0.0795216411,
0.0448945612,
0.0018798676,
0.0362709537,
0.0356515497,
0.0054459972,
-0.0054101506,
0.0195702296,
-0.008503071,
-0.0363369882,
0.0054293326,
-0.0228979457,
-0.036253199,
-0.0191445034,
-0.0061633652,
0.0246938355,
0.0074187787,
-0.0888937041,
-0.0088074356,
0.0291357338,
-0.0051480066,
-0.0030020473,
-0.0072070044,
0.0500409566,
-0.0349812135,
0.0546621047,
-0.0603026114,
0.0055341725,
0.1033412591,
0.0235462002,
0.0038931703,
0.0537115149,
-0.018031992,
0.0791684762,
0.0716853589,
0.0222196486,
0.0249223392,
-0.0039875214,
-0.0147507312,
0.0082006315,
-0.0053193914,
0.0235124659,
-0.0696005076,
0.0343799591,
-0.0187240057,
0.0046626092,
-0.0191125907,
0.042533882,
0.03311719,
0.0870107487,
0.0149310492,
0.0529155508,
-0.0045143305,
0.0600659959,
0.0123914145,
-0.0274166297,
0.0415268913,
0.0220530704,
-0.0098392274,
-0.0195177235,
-0.0038137094,
-0.031058846,
-0.0371748768,
-0.0308566224,
-0.0375899263,
0.0165621992,
0.0134906368,
-0.0165184867,
0.0759480223,
0.0178602412,
0.0246160682,
0.0320270732,
0.044731088,
-0.0160678197,
0.0201464891,
-0.0149293812,
0.0660815686,
0.0959528685,
0.0705804452,
-0.0498038456,
-0.0107249329,
-0.0245530885,
0.0409948304,
0.0086006373,
0.0240574423,
-0.0230483934,
-0.0897368342,
-0.0161292031,
-0.01194447,
0.0025094601,
0.0034890261,
0.0297397841,
-0.0018569828,
-0.0401751027,
-0.0057032481,
-0.0405234955,
0.0231133234,
0.0355918296,
-0.0228892174,
0.0530074686,
-0.0033886458,
-0.031488739,
0.0366967246,
0.04649546,
0.0323664397,
0.0095524741,
0.0287758224,
-0.0074518942,
-0.0458537824,
-0.0160772186,
0.0215055849,
0.0630102232,
0.0218872968,
-0.0474201441,
0.0108341044,
-0.017220879,
0.0049725622,
-0.0108007854,
0.0360719189,
-0.0450478159,
-0.0071295095,
-0.0522585995,
-0.0032149635,
-0.0188972894,
-0.0464318953,
-0.0527459942,
0.0462115593,
0.0232351329,
0.0134109557,
0.0207356326,
-0.027662361,
-0.0052898536,
-0.0260155462,
0.0163350459,
0.0494051762,
0.0207073353,
0.0288566146,
0.0592524111,
-0.0359292999,
-0.0414832234,
-0.0228879377,
-0.1260709465,
-0.0210253336,
-0.0113214217,
-0.0080494285,
0.0200619381,
0.0123532098,
-0.0247347876,
-0.0221140422,
-0.001191764,
-0.0208557677,
-0.0325308293,
0.0028965764,
0.0021442161,
-0.0042153746,
0.0549649633,
-0.0685622916,
-0.0143949417,
-0.026504565,
0.051618591,
0.0574789084,
-0.0302760266,
-0.0290899705,
-0.024061298,
0.0013503534,
-0.0458892919,
-0.0198131781,
0.0459950827,
0.0296839382,
-0.0089225667,
0.0839732289,
-0.0491186194,
0.0405154712,
0.0766808242,
0.0335636511,
-0.0188242439,
-0.04278199,
-0.0201773681,
-0.0070113973,
0.0215527155,
0.0171539709,
-0.0058857212,
0.0412854701,
0.0368956886,
0.0219347719,
0.0410088673,
-0.0214385614,
0.042073492,
-0.0476098098,
0.0291268937,
-0.0972575098,
-0.0195257645,
-0.017060386,
0.0451488979,
-0.0127215311,
-0.0116162784,
0.05549955,
0.0227960814,
0.0423776172,
-0.068790935,
-0.0165599231,
-0.0294443332,
0.0285651311,
-0.0467716083,
-0.0157067534,
-0.0061813127,
0.0176726952,
0.0064498177,
-0.0196291059,
0.0532322451,
-0.0270000249,
0.0389733352,
-0.0363882892,
0.0116092879,
0.029386431,
0.0003670439,
-0.006823909,
-0.0763597563,
-0.0621809475,
-0.0138004404,
0.016190853,
0.0055102771,
0.0054623215,
0.0088093951,
0.0414246134,
-0.0012067218,
0.0080713108,
-0.0407065451,
0.0122545883,
0.0159631837,
0.0383155383,
-0.0592763163,
-0.0465003178,
-0.0112498561,
-0.0004726816,
0.0217385162,
0.034028694,
-0.0072537814,
-0.0652571023,
0.0123226363,
0.0101733059,
-0.0791057125,
-0.0149770221,
-0.0052931956,
0.0029148674,
-0.0439493693,
0.0194365941,
0.0848123655,
0.0761065707,
-0.0840378925,
-0.0209542159,
-0.0215735324,
-0.0027967992,
0.0179982223,
0.0332335122,
-0.0482650958,
-0.011207399,
0.0085610468,
0.0566182882,
0.0317713432,
-0.0157747623,
-0.0080033578,
-0.0184381027,
0.018928891,
-0.005005768,
0.0052124239,
0.0273308828,
-0.0933160409,
0.0115405237,
-0.0199317113,
-0.0481965393,
0.0231992528,
-0.0202145651,
0.0215720572,
0.0157794841,
-0.0557562076,
-0.023782542,
-0.0002860276,
-0.0242125783,
0.0161569826,
0.0571609922,
0.0267987568,
0.0116610778,
0.0092467293,
-0.0146674979,
0.0117504438,
0.0034790535,
-0.0209100768,
0.0265425146,
-0.0216778032,
0.0181851201,
-0.0654810071,
0.0195823871,
-0.0179919805,
-0.0458829664,
0.035073489,
0.0531630367,
-0.0433011837,
0.0424608216,
-0.0561268777,
-0.0041326615,
0.0217212103,
0.0274251997,
0.0255826022,
-0.0887124389,
0.0412323922,
-0.0383968689,
0.0299568847,
0.0394584648,
-0.0213534944,
-0.0551164784,
-0.0270966366,
-0.0287386924,
-0.0688271299,
-0.0385230593,
0.0382864736,
-0.0051778108,
0.0113082556,
0.0017576318,
0.0439071096,
-0.0030693798,
-0.0177812465,
0.0499656536,
0.0145975715,
0.0096483119,
-0.0357721038,
-0.0687860996,
0.0622693934,
-0.0106458785,
-0.007644102,
0.0513593592,
-0.0737429932,
-0.0153882531,
0.0100823641,
-0.0054241563,
0.0153249577,
-0.0013605313,
-0.029647056,
-0.0795341358,
-0.0027119729,
0.0116372071,
-0.051938843,
-0.0372401364,
-0.0254777595,
0.0395331532,
-0.0328913182,
-0.0171327479,
-0.0243362729,
0.0326282978,
-0.0489188172,
0.0179735217,
-0.0773277283,
-0.0575512014,
0.001113846,
-0.0198542215,
0.0516592264,
-0.0278963894,
-0.0447547175,
-0.0590674728,
-0.0509797335,
-0.0001522808,
-0.0348725617,
-0.0122168856,
0.016849611,
-0.0159041621,
-0.0569581948,
-0.022191802,
0.0218121931,
-0.0605101362,
0.0395629816,
-0.0309295375,
-0.0008569278,
0.007934249,
0.0489800163,
-0.0353749245,
0.0222936906,
-0.0039224173,
-0.0032356947,
-0.0289481767,
0.0028089394,
-0.0219519921,
0.0861038193,
-0.0186807457,
-0.0297398921,
0.0229570474,
0.0263722185,
-0.0265544895,
-0.0300192311,
-0.0074573527,
0.0555870757,
0.0408501513,
0.0195504446,
-0.0021599384,
-0.0297363512,
-0.0429755896,
-0.0098920381,
0.0465371795,
-0.0238836985,
0.0075768596,
-0.0036464476,
0.0499234237,
-0.0375598632,
0.0090622427,
0.0337614939,
0.0122837583,
-0.0053136125,
-0.0047175693,
-0.0602412373,
-0.0512685739,
0.0225546286,
0.0017417335,
0.033266589,
-0.0301013626,
0.0053579351,
-0.0706160963,
0.018993305,
0.0145786889,
-0.0449854359,
-0.0262562279,
0.0012304357,
0.0746932626,
0.1108696535,
-0.0274181385,
0.006470487,
-0.0582602508,
0.0408482738,
-0.0522038005,
-0.0227641109,
-0.0492810495,
-6.339663643e-33,
-0.0332227275,
-0.0356611609,
0.0160583276,
0.0200198367,
0.0358786136,
-0.0280313566,
-0.0176419243,
0.0515437983,
0.0479215421,
0.0188155491,
0.0011681394,
0.0285664387,
-0.0074904105,
-0.0348607004,
0.0144168632,
0.0107207354,
0.0931621119,
0.0131630972,
0.0090336604,
0.0265156329,
0.0246156957,
0.0241194684,
-0.0116695222,
-0.094429411,
0.0646652579,
-0.0159713514,
-0.0219516829,
-0.0267846584,
0.0717462078,
0.0416518524,
-0.0256425738,
0.0309622604,
0.0166411381,
-0.0430261977,
-0.0203298479,
0.0372098163,
-0.0381317325,
-0.0321097411,
-0.0013644244,
-0.023947062,
0.0135349995,
-0.0233674236,
0.0173976924,
0.0215316806,
-0.0042428831,
0.0334960632,
0.0799088031,
0.014494217,
-0.0363771766,
-0.0040315245,
-0.0283358153,
0.0345257558,
0.0001161724,
-0.0230605882,
-0.0058695059,
0.0073153423,
-0.0005400212,
0.0215803646,
-0.0234916173,
0.0485258438,
0.0183932483,
0.0177130233,
0.0637904927,
-0.0053178519,
-0.0117350342,
0.042871356,
-0.040768832,
0.0198168233,
0.0000878248,
0.0104590841,
0.0166385639,
0.0561627708,
0.0500708781,
0.0469961092,
0.0031319524,
-0.0011995754,
0.0096160443,
0.0540787727,
-0.0121764569,
0.0359723903,
0.020894954,
0.0194427241,
-0.0163261071,
-0.0189959388,
-0.0299102273,
-0.0151476637,
-0.0357813239,
-0.0477420092,
0.0210971218,
0.0235589575,
-0.0357619524,
0.0265804883,
-0.0260942541,
0.0063010002,
-0.0033514414,
0.0002433693,
-0.0351774171,
0.0225438215,
0.0120282378,
0.0052204416,
-0.0766266435,
0.0014332304,
-0.0170748569,
0.0117563894,
0.0020348765,
-0.0223788675,
-0.0399847068,
-0.0087677576,
-0.0439612158,
-0.0069383793,
0.01353209,
-0.0234337095,
-0.0359726846,
-0.001581236,
0.0199447889,
0.0181610957,
-0.0181807242,
0.0800944418,
0.0207995828,
0.0224360377,
-0.0180964097,
-0.0601964518,
-0.0342291817,
0.0215875655,
0.0169952195,
-0.0175683293,
-0.0191522334,
0.0172500797,
0.0831841603,
-0.0187374353,
-0.0318628028,
-0.0249202158,
2.77e-7,
0.042127572,
0.0952738672,
-0.0114789233,
-0.0410854705,
0.0148316231,
0.0389786139,
-0.0078192977,
0.0024161274,
0.0049954071,
0.0004632682,
0.0279991888,
0.0176342987,
0.0408136062,
0.0728663355,
-0.070628427,
-0.0317254737,
-0.0488687418,
0.0541255437,
-0.0782914013,
-0.0183030143,
0.0003329643,
0.0186808258,
0.0538339019,
0.017881183,
-0.0240817927,
-0.031812828,
0.0555162951,
-0.0432260968,
-0.0685765073,
0.0083948998,
0.0700984821,
0.0268020984,
-0.0079639899,
-0.0287988093,
-0.0424058326,
-0.0319687538,
0.0205099303,
0.0091093425,
-0.0073554632,
-0.031059904,
-0.030028753,
-0.0240704957,
0.0136014782,
-0.049287837,
-0.0050302697,
-0.0413929336,
0.0084128967,
-0.0779934973,
0.0004383802,
0.009135318,
0.0283869263,
-0.020157963,
-0.0014764206,
-0.0036730019,
-0.0287185833,
0.0160755832,
-0.0305460282,
-0.0284284949,
0.0085815601,
0.0177665055,
-0.0506232269,
-0.0185111035,
-0.0610708743,
-0.009390085,
-0.0091226138,
-0.0216964837,
0.0435057878,
1.746545718e-34,
0.0255550854,
0.0057348842,
-0.0485448092,
0.0047695036,
0.0177891422,
0.0257430673,
-0.016189212,
0.0220665839,
0.0372302718,
-0.0143416626,
0.0241873432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01752v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01752v3
|
Black Box Few-Shot Adaptation for Vision-Language models
| 2023-04-04T12:42:29 | 2023-08-17T17:22:41 |
Yassine Ouali, Adrian Bulat, Brais Martinez, Georgios Tzimiropoulos
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision-Language (V-L) models trained with contrastive learning to align the
visual and language modalities have been shown to be strong few-shot learners.
Soft prompt learning is the method of choice for few-shot downstream adaptation
aiming to bridge the modality gap caused by the distribution shift induced by
the new domain. While parameter-efficient, prompt learning still requires
access to the model weights and can be computationally infeasible for large
models with billions of parameters. To address these shortcomings, in this
work, we describe a black-box method for V-L few-shot adaptation that (a)
operates on pre-computed image and text features and hence works without access
to the model's weights, (b) it is orders of magnitude faster at training time,
(c) it is amenable to both supervised and unsupervised training, and (d) it can
be even used to align image and text features computed from uni-modal models.
To achieve this, we propose Linear Feature Alignment (LFA), a simple linear
approach for V-L re-alignment in the target domain. LFA is initialized from a
closed-form solution to a least-squares problem and then it is iteratively
updated by minimizing a re-ranking loss. Despite its simplicity, our approach
can even surpass soft-prompt learning methods as shown by extensive experiments
on 11 image and 2 video datasets.
|
[
0.0096873082,
0.0524342731,
0.0066581359,
0.0101981908,
-0.0163877998,
0.0245125797,
0.0318243951,
-0.0126618175,
-0.0114506977,
-0.0608566701,
-0.0657759905,
-0.0243743397,
0.0228272025,
0.0243859161,
0.0204457194,
-0.0595139451,
0.0267813634,
-0.0147722242,
0.0027743948,
-0.0014964808,
0.0404403843,
0.0132753411,
-0.0241123717,
-0.0008754657,
0.0446071811,
-0.0152538177,
-0.0262118895,
0.0386086181,
0.053037934,
0.0082365032,
-0.0098068714,
0.0689677596,
0.0292617343,
0.0151624335,
0.000002,
-0.0418998823,
-0.0251676962,
0.019518422,
-0.0089833532,
-0.0223910976,
0.0359770432,
-0.0663757846,
-0.0190722588,
0.0216118712,
-0.0037027572,
-0.0487499498,
0.0967317447,
0.0079520606,
0.0391688533,
0.0769667402,
-0.0256164819,
-0.0219185911,
-0.0046462892,
-0.0278069992,
-0.0003247505,
-0.0364230163,
0.0351190902,
-0.0295329094,
-0.0613795258,
0.0023978527,
-0.0797583982,
0.0345643274,
-0.0212666783,
-0.0051023955,
-0.0232490432,
0.0125763873,
-0.0199093781,
-0.0188300256,
-0.0467875674,
0.0822422281,
-0.0235450938,
-0.0149967335,
-0.0270909537,
-0.0292180534,
0.0164018385,
0.0114220213,
-0.0133144408,
-0.0219478086,
-0.0061358176,
0.0147852851,
-0.0384908728,
-0.0180117972,
0.0114658242,
-0.0024392977,
0.0211707912,
-0.0452349372,
0.0297374595,
0.0062282095,
-0.0499392189,
-0.0049890643,
-0.0143208075,
-0.0213090125,
-0.0211737957,
0.0084382072,
-0.0104424208,
0.0056905043,
-0.0792482719,
-0.033606682,
-0.0345156714,
-0.0137308622,
0.0833879635,
0.048463732,
-0.0850390643,
0.0761086196,
-0.0256331265,
0.0604906753,
-0.0165624302,
0.0421576314,
-0.0404744744,
0.0065585496,
-0.0159538332,
0.0205131937,
-0.0134422984,
-0.0228603948,
-0.0246296059,
0.0021964447,
-0.0355974622,
0.0290714744,
-0.0025039488,
0.0035745415,
-0.0038504698,
-0.0079766354,
-0.0606661886,
-0.056567885,
-0.0087898904,
0.0791701302,
0.0326776467,
0.0395266637,
-0.0276310313,
-0.041236382,
0.000022819,
0.0237165503,
0.0266918652,
-0.0135991098,
-0.0117762648,
0.0786934271,
-0.0331010148,
-0.0364384428,
-0.0506637134,
0.0400798209,
-0.0457544662,
-0.0059258956,
-0.0128560886,
-0.0482009538,
0.012722332,
0.0026479517,
0.0000058486,
-0.0520416908,
0.0052900645,
-0.029985914,
-0.0224321596,
0.102122426,
-0.0080227563,
-0.0087205227,
0.0311453715,
-0.0306179263,
0.0065019075,
0.0779042765,
0.0103233205,
-0.0064044343,
-0.016005598,
-0.0076511353,
0.0138365952,
0.0535672642,
-0.0143108396,
0.0409038141,
-0.0794182792,
-0.0198412854,
0.0278071258,
0.0265199356,
0.035035979,
-0.0151217552,
0.0077999812,
-0.0224131476,
0.0783833042,
-0.0083918991,
0.0550702102,
-0.0037578647,
0.0179813057,
-0.0066434671,
-0.0262385793,
-0.0101202512,
-0.0365354754,
0.0523071177,
-0.0434502438,
0.0114491703,
-0.0046901815,
0.0484893732,
-0.0526319034,
-0.0296160821,
0.0242920034,
0.0000590322,
0.0076122,
0.0119860312,
0.0640840083,
-0.0004330249,
-0.0329023041,
0.0109751103,
0.043233417,
0.0006980153,
-0.0078635011,
-0.0148625905,
0.0125747053,
0.0422383584,
-0.0189183373,
-0.0136292996,
-0.0434631892,
0.0083013633,
0.0604749247,
0.0482996404,
0.0352854282,
0.0181737449,
0.0202808436,
-0.0657263771,
-0.0453777313,
0.0236118119,
-0.0145608578,
0.0302293692,
-0.0429205298,
0.0043000709,
-0.0011944929,
0.0242769364,
-0.0171859488,
0.03984062,
-0.005825405,
-0.0245042313,
-0.0134393629,
0.0437841043,
0.0078139594,
-0.0241652392,
-0.0170298479,
-0.0244699251,
-0.0048479927,
-0.0239924602,
0.03950027,
0.0259238798,
-0.0170319807,
-0.0401660576,
0.0534727126,
-0.0164166261,
0.03072978,
0.0249837264,
-0.0477130674,
-0.0390893444,
0.009288257,
-0.0160218049,
-0.0332175046,
-0.0053927684,
0.0560439192,
-0.0133179706,
0.021425914,
-0.0563850738,
0.0248206779,
0.0100822067,
-0.0204148926,
0.014576355,
0.0263417233,
0.0011960001,
-0.0016999027,
-0.0113757756,
-0.0033321748,
-0.0056638611,
0.0373770893,
0.0186037961,
0.0103772189,
-0.0485201776,
-0.0002538292,
-0.0795778781,
0.001355815,
-0.033349961,
0.0156719666,
0.0383795053,
0.0206598826,
-0.0203072447,
-0.061669264,
-0.0369538516,
0.0694076121,
-0.0256028045,
-0.0233488157,
0.0384539738,
0.0119748712,
0.0076047638,
-0.0413689874,
0.0165840089,
0.0022489126,
0.0351082496,
-0.0146055846,
-0.0209754705,
-0.0528790206,
0.0516571738,
-0.0193501487,
0.0456497222,
-0.0056594489,
-0.0402879342,
-0.0387962013,
0.0079951715,
0.0285684261,
0.0779769197,
0.0288309697,
0.006454953,
0.0130951758,
0.0010870566,
-0.0344076157,
0.00847553,
-0.0181241315,
-0.0683048368,
-0.0542019233,
-0.0007020324,
-0.0425831713,
0.0565408431,
-0.0270602163,
0.0231341198,
-0.0916928351,
0.0387417451,
0.0369541384,
-0.0109238839,
-0.0403802991,
0.0470395759,
-0.0389370099,
0.0086118253,
-0.0517060906,
-0.0501727797,
0.0374832079,
-0.0338178016,
-0.0015913149,
-0.0297050364,
-0.0174572822,
-0.0018766337,
0.0270608291,
0.0133833447,
0.023468297,
0.0073637012,
0.0041216086,
-0.1152460352,
-0.0352032855,
0.0298544895,
-0.0263750572,
0.0647728443,
-0.027686175,
0.0025904132,
-0.0621888414,
-0.0342624411,
-0.0104895532,
-0.0561559908,
-0.0252607241,
-0.0156005481,
-0.0591683164,
-0.017554909,
-0.0539979525,
0.0129765095,
0.057250239,
0.0847508609,
-0.0020953701,
-0.0002466238,
-0.0296819285,
0.0565555394,
0.0786385685,
0.04631247,
-0.0488492437,
-0.0075503276,
0.0604566336,
0.0222231038,
0.0305839814,
0.0006929113,
-0.0514992774,
0.003678119,
0.058699403,
0.0292570498,
0.0026133035,
0.0403756611,
0.0578067079,
-0.0258228201,
0.0010749823,
0.0689491555,
0.0044319616,
-0.0628449544,
-0.0403383486,
0.009233389,
0.0170529168,
0.0214555077,
0.0202364642,
-0.0741136372,
-0.0579877794,
-0.0150773423,
0.0072184773,
0.0169811361,
0.0262328293,
-0.0393875875,
-0.0937554464,
0.0168271307,
0.0457295254,
-0.043985799,
-0.0217040814,
0.0236084405,
0.0341505259,
-0.0112799807,
-0.0065170275,
0.0230187513,
-0.0093465699,
-0.0218061171,
0.0297178794,
0.0600898899,
-0.0376314037,
-0.0131803779,
-0.0431912616,
0.0316828936,
0.0609112605,
-0.0099784965,
-0.0289791785,
-0.0272402968,
0.013672499,
-0.0074744932,
-0.0065985234,
0.031572096,
0.0315658525,
-0.0221744068,
-0.0495883301,
0.0475161113,
0.0384556688,
-0.0206470359,
-0.0108274492,
0.0007178122,
0.0154463174,
0.0152396029,
0.0210165512,
-0.0240775868,
-0.0114083262,
-0.0051187426,
-0.009550075,
-0.0046594613,
-0.0688870698,
0.016435463,
-0.0138659328,
-0.0242104568,
0.0000026543,
-0.0561482683,
0.0003201602,
-0.0208825283,
-0.0150868725,
-0.0587545149,
0.0110447789,
0.0106395911,
0.0720585361,
0.0121337753,
-0.0073769884,
-0.0135265505,
0.0027827341,
-0.0578853972,
0.0624752082,
-0.0142920194,
0.016470002,
-0.0451371558,
-0.0019329025,
0.057339564,
-0.0669658408,
-0.0159965847,
-0.0160618462,
-0.074728094,
-0.0529080816,
-0.0147135612,
0.036365211,
0.0021207377,
0.0531315543,
-0.0031604478,
-0.0488235727,
0.0731349662,
0.0774378851,
0.0309608039,
0.0420549773,
-0.0073284446,
-0.0433540344,
-0.0213097632,
0.0197491813,
-0.0717879236,
0.0015748702,
0.064122729,
-0.0047329622,
-0.0098573351,
-0.0294265263,
0.0308223609,
-0.0183970276,
0.0964831114,
-0.0139413094,
-0.0246465411,
-0.0193327721,
0.0315846428,
0.0329875201,
-0.0432522818,
-0.0474240556,
-0.031863153,
-0.0000254205,
0.0284608677,
0.0176329911,
-0.0042241374,
0.0226838086,
0.0316176228,
-0.0450287573,
-0.0008946465,
0.0313155241,
0.0194904711,
0.014092234,
0.031297151,
0.0185074843,
0.0451329537,
0.0250072274,
0.0361660682,
-0.0250381697,
0.0809991062,
0.0274084006,
0.0018746138,
-0.0520210154,
0.0619069487,
-0.0159852579,
-0.0230506156,
-0.0718487874,
0.03902613,
0.0259791482,
-0.0161214955,
0.000974753,
0.0212264787,
-0.0280718692,
-0.0393281579,
0.0232732687,
-0.0191975925,
-0.0092170499,
0.0771903917,
0.0214966629,
-0.0092852348,
0.023624979,
0.0530648641,
0.015660068,
0.0167696904,
-0.0073945695,
0.0411003567,
-0.0179624278,
-0.0062549324,
0.0456479788,
-0.0129464623,
-0.0153414058,
0.019307049,
-0.0084359078,
-0.0373178422,
0.0148149533,
-0.0129329609,
-0.0049396828,
-0.0009928087,
0.0469246879,
0.0272435509,
0.0011552355,
0.0071561118,
-0.0202480424,
-0.0389495157,
-0.0036672894,
0.0049760779,
0.0114093544,
-6.092681995e-33,
-0.0684648827,
-0.0080826934,
0.01684062,
-0.0192527864,
-0.0056995796,
0.0201655515,
0.0134096183,
0.0279043894,
-0.022700429,
-0.0095875254,
0.028512584,
-0.0051806029,
0.0284092296,
0.0246835016,
-0.0134124402,
-0.0031719236,
0.0394439176,
-0.0265507102,
-0.0219895896,
-0.026571719,
-0.0026588799,
0.0298881736,
0.0404526442,
-0.0562784523,
-0.0324027091,
0.0357468575,
-0.0427614152,
-0.0146236112,
0.0170634445,
0.0609847307,
0.0272815414,
0.0133108022,
0.0022511946,
-0.0190814938,
-0.0102166189,
0.0207303688,
-0.0427753143,
0.0163138695,
0.0121244472,
0.0604919791,
-0.0552693829,
-0.0207330734,
0.047571443,
-0.0167576484,
0.0047762664,
-0.0422648899,
0.0493213162,
-0.0716360062,
-0.0097509315,
0.0141330743,
-0.0551925674,
0.0208264627,
-0.0229808651,
-0.0452308506,
0.036409907,
0.0363894552,
0.0292333532,
0.0467120521,
-0.0482630432,
0.0091179302,
0.0171695519,
0.0645646006,
0.0977759436,
0.0857307613,
-0.0201287176,
0.036800582,
0.0469805375,
-0.0578209423,
0.0232776646,
-0.0555433556,
0.0389146022,
-0.0070734862,
0.028641155,
0.1185395643,
0.0266563352,
0.0107817799,
-0.0599910133,
0.0016853492,
-0.0422149897,
0.0118387127,
0.0185238291,
0.032750845,
-0.0112555968,
0.0012276246,
-0.0571927205,
-0.0305478927,
-0.0504813865,
-0.0158581883,
0.0230318587,
0.0177005287,
-0.0022675272,
0.0036632305,
0.0739423037,
-0.0270504002,
0.0194237847,
0.0107259639,
-0.0392924771,
0.0443503447,
-0.0027775504,
0.0438283831,
-0.0532953255,
-0.0376294367,
0.0404625311,
0.0275759231,
0.0067585874,
0.0277833752,
0.0385838263,
0.0422970057,
-0.0626825765,
0.0064810817,
-0.0129387099,
-0.0438651405,
-0.0069373245,
0.0684510246,
0.0134525057,
0.001355973,
-0.0324598886,
0.0453589112,
0.0327076316,
-0.068954818,
0.0074912473,
-0.0091178082,
-0.0222116075,
0.0180037525,
-0.0341224372,
0.0159140732,
0.0049941884,
-0.022299109,
0.0238405298,
-0.0217806362,
-0.0097317202,
0.017855797,
2.784e-7,
0.0311665442,
0.0040758559,
-0.0207485631,
-0.0475312918,
0.0095316581,
0.0684534237,
-0.0372709297,
0.044171609,
0.0180173982,
-0.0050610262,
0.0415342562,
0.0049777492,
0.042301584,
-0.0377589911,
-0.0430971868,
0.0487956367,
-0.0376076363,
0.0204782598,
-0.0360308401,
0.0024986346,
0.0252505336,
0.1353418529,
-0.0198259801,
-0.0079203686,
0.0485270284,
-0.0508324839,
0.076577045,
-0.0263114385,
-0.0066203414,
-0.0234079454,
-0.0336453766,
0.0216187164,
-0.0760066733,
0.0094803181,
-0.0032252688,
0.0517865233,
0.0092301657,
0.0387229733,
-0.0312087834,
-0.0005202927,
-0.0094607491,
0.0709373802,
-0.0169300921,
-0.0188193824,
0.0474438518,
-0.0800683051,
-0.0227044672,
-0.0643922687,
-0.0438930802,
0.0110434694,
0.0086034583,
-0.0231895782,
-0.0075094816,
0.021531947,
0.0504215918,
-0.0054164897,
-0.0815701559,
-0.0493284762,
-0.0300057828,
0.0193053354,
-0.0005240482,
-0.0244930536,
-0.0456476361,
-0.0088057434,
0.0406451076,
-0.0436580665,
0.0187902357,
2.041785244e-34,
-0.0020799686,
-0.0290781893,
-0.0010400647,
0.0060720504,
-0.0245240387,
-0.0154339159,
-0.0277366638,
0.0095366156,
0.0348467082,
-0.062421333,
-0.0029465733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01746v1
|
Is ChatGPT a Highly Fluent Grammatical Error Correction System? A Comprehensive Evaluation
| 2023-04-04T12:33:40 | 2023-04-04T12:33:40 |
Tao Fang, Shu Yang, Kaixin Lan, Derek F. Wong, Jinpeng Hu, Lidia S. Chao, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChatGPT, a large-scale language model based on the advanced GPT-3.5
architecture, has shown remarkable potential in various Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. However, there is currently a dearth of comprehensive
study exploring its potential in the area of Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC). To showcase its capabilities in GEC, we design zero-shot
chain-of-thought (CoT) and few-shot CoT settings using in-context learning for
ChatGPT. Our evaluation involves assessing ChatGPT's performance on five
official test sets in three different languages, along with three
document-level GEC test sets in English. Our experimental results and human
evaluations demonstrate that ChatGPT has excellent error detection capabilities
and can freely correct errors to make the corrected sentences very fluent,
possibly due to its over-correction tendencies and not adhering to the
principle of minimal edits. Additionally, its performance in non-English and
low-resource settings highlights its potential in multilingual GEC tasks.
However, further analysis of various types of errors at the document-level has
shown that ChatGPT cannot effectively correct agreement, coreference, tense
errors across sentences, and cross-sentence boundary errors.
|
[
0.0667588189,
0.0273538511,
0.0071885632,
0.0373845845,
-0.0627910867,
0.0257154629,
-0.0278717317,
-0.0291429292,
0.0234609339,
-0.0741117969,
-0.0389081426,
-0.0400895067,
0.0221781731,
-0.0093132528,
0.0197955631,
-0.0424836352,
0.1047462001,
0.0181319937,
0.0018329764,
0.0104914969,
0.0301963221,
0.0118140979,
-0.0325678661,
0.0398282409,
-0.0324468352,
-0.0664255768,
-0.014523264,
0.025164539,
0.0308720153,
-0.0045290133,
0.0461873859,
0.0493990444,
-0.0297770873,
0.0954702795,
0.0000018215,
-0.0243050624,
0.0000050656,
-0.0072159455,
0.0042459797,
0.0436671004,
0.0191610157,
-0.0125495242,
-0.0643685535,
0.0035500966,
-0.0087266788,
-0.0124511225,
0.0413296223,
0.0648636669,
0.0694062039,
0.1057992354,
-0.0150047494,
0.0074902251,
0.0469264351,
-0.0179554746,
-0.0110230604,
-0.0195917748,
0.0187019389,
-0.0090969652,
-0.0005709493,
-0.0000832707,
-0.0242938269,
0.0390980355,
0.003121342,
-0.0400798433,
-0.0215643216,
0.0161083043,
-0.0580976494,
-0.0190255232,
-0.0260895398,
0.0162552409,
0.0031504901,
-0.043693088,
-0.0201358311,
0.0106460163,
0.0085031865,
-0.048630435,
-0.0198019315,
0.0006382428,
-0.0130211767,
0.0105217919,
0.0308276284,
-0.078594774,
0.0018227648,
0.0083262976,
0.034014713,
0.0373065285,
0.026553141,
-0.0633692816,
-0.0310842562,
0.064666912,
-0.0508098342,
-0.0773296356,
0.0179770645,
-0.0171100665,
-0.0545732901,
-0.0033937222,
-0.0387029685,
-0.024724232,
0.0008745759,
-0.0365883373,
-0.0118715763,
0.0331838802,
-0.0289700553,
0.0260769445,
-0.0097619686,
0.0632750615,
0.0117977513,
0.0078437328,
0.0096557271,
-0.0001448466,
-0.0674858987,
-0.0098836031,
-0.0564463623,
0.0257107224,
-0.0228356905,
0.0032658461,
-0.0632365942,
0.0087346397,
-0.0085387276,
0.0453581773,
0.0141366813,
-0.0161406882,
-0.0326315276,
-0.0417688526,
-0.0075810547,
0.0626752228,
0.0135503821,
0.0330370553,
0.0317128375,
-0.0643636659,
-0.0200319421,
0.0008807633,
0.0062387735,
-0.0007444831,
-0.0053856247,
0.0152643258,
-0.0244242381,
-0.0422031954,
-0.0282215755,
-0.0067127529,
-0.0331287719,
-0.066641584,
-0.0505034402,
-0.0698638931,
0.0002250821,
-0.0093768816,
0.0151332328,
-0.0002719565,
0.0107754525,
0.0260668527,
-0.0410193577,
0.0651990548,
-0.0352594927,
-0.0101055512,
0.0037729614,
-0.0048716967,
0.0046028635,
0.0307166111,
0.0300758984,
-0.0411836803,
0.0441772416,
0.0369750299,
0.0242977571,
0.0040945746,
-0.0339834727,
-0.0171508212,
0.0393297784,
-0.0284260884,
-0.0166215841,
0.0384068489,
0.0334101692,
0.0847804844,
-0.0294262357,
0.0306882318,
0.06365522,
0.0267702285,
-0.0102189183,
0.0188792087,
0.0269846525,
-0.0257208608,
0.0206939839,
0.0362581722,
-0.0681982338,
0.0042741103,
-0.0394340381,
-0.004296809,
-0.005031419,
0.0107730776,
-0.0285059046,
-0.0170793589,
-0.0209228192,
0.0204669628,
-0.0107001541,
-0.0627983212,
0.0240991656,
0.0148018701,
-0.0406552553,
0.0308377631,
0.0044242823,
-0.0568804182,
-0.0167263765,
-0.0353893228,
-0.0000298681,
0.0362568013,
0.0703187287,
0.0071277609,
-0.0533909388,
-0.0468834154,
-0.0023973454,
0.0670581907,
0.0739236698,
-0.0059687886,
-0.0229518078,
-0.0345439352,
0.01648397,
0.0044594994,
0.0273375046,
-0.0139515372,
0.0194987282,
0.023085881,
-0.0024879766,
0.017126115,
-0.0047927806,
0.0035768086,
0.0127667179,
0.0012588482,
-0.0079851784,
-0.0151564898,
0.03486095,
0.0074310349,
-0.0357465073,
-0.0072618853,
-0.0271639843,
0.0186424349,
-0.0502052158,
0.0314148515,
-0.0501929484,
-0.0887303576,
0.0300571788,
-0.0393461287,
-0.0563979,
0.0025753248,
-0.066280432,
-0.054922834,
-0.0091252178,
-0.0397543088,
0.0180431157,
-0.0649384558,
0.0448933691,
0.015754804,
-0.0037517536,
-0.0154452426,
0.0216323603,
0.0098665114,
-0.004769661,
-0.0151311541,
0.0026093717,
0.010750304,
-0.0379324965,
-0.0381784402,
0.007254953,
0.0135455439,
0.0261107795,
0.035709843,
0.0419881903,
-0.0490327477,
-0.0233402513,
-0.1102319062,
0.0117994649,
-0.0270625129,
0.0425831266,
0.0438458472,
0.0128975306,
-0.0192631911,
-0.0231589284,
0.0039011813,
0.0693989396,
0.035594292,
0.0125810755,
0.0563925616,
-0.0306363124,
-0.0154992864,
-0.0535787754,
0.0222778283,
-0.0406783372,
-0.0206232592,
0.011640368,
-0.0610018335,
-0.0531353354,
0.0575172566,
-0.0300240517,
0.039796032,
0.0496286601,
-0.0644762591,
0.0001148137,
0.0131715667,
0.0775321126,
0.0359992944,
-0.0224868599,
-0.0037930526,
-0.0103108883,
-0.0274294298,
-0.0036603189,
0.0286940895,
0.0115129361,
-0.0488646552,
-0.0128484825,
0.0287706517,
0.0036540406,
0.0779299885,
0.0159494337,
-0.0262476038,
-0.0366257094,
-0.0115130972,
-0.0292655248,
0.0080218986,
-0.0156943873,
0.0001330782,
-0.0112818992,
0.0033370266,
-0.055322025,
0.0059334598,
0.0616567098,
0.0108826151,
-0.014203188,
-0.0618885718,
0.0103426268,
-0.0041223699,
0.0061265682,
0.0265005808,
0.0264672991,
-0.0101933507,
-0.0580035634,
-0.0667529926,
-0.0036430433,
0.0452839546,
0.0040386207,
0.0391912758,
-0.0706414655,
0.0362537988,
0.0013088688,
-0.0839424133,
-0.0006659267,
-0.0023616287,
-0.0344501883,
-0.0099279946,
0.0061243125,
-0.0048982142,
-0.0326810591,
-0.0282471981,
0.0160299744,
0.0715316013,
-0.013557625,
-0.0378316417,
-0.0199315157,
0.0390390977,
0.0095001357,
0.0027580943,
0.0314922519,
0.0101848198,
0.0269773267,
0.1010412052,
0.0011367298,
0.0373105481,
-0.0152427638,
-0.0040433453,
0.0048911087,
-0.0451919734,
-0.0653771386,
-0.0323638059,
0.0747025609,
-0.0639986023,
-0.049515605,
0.094955653,
0.0342087783,
-0.0639395863,
-0.0246832501,
-0.0184662379,
-0.0025599147,
0.0083578993,
0.0216099508,
-0.0986988693,
-0.0262063742,
0.0464555733,
-0.0211037695,
-0.0253477506,
-0.0135312565,
0.0094980113,
-0.1168724597,
0.0685812086,
0.0207732115,
-0.0295895562,
-0.0273594409,
0.0038812237,
0.0240766853,
-0.0031753141,
0.0463283025,
0.0462329127,
-0.0107945651,
-0.0107568521,
-0.0009919001,
-0.0480912216,
-0.0764918551,
0.0235648043,
-0.0462880358,
0.0525684468,
0.0595377348,
0.0342409983,
0.0314982496,
-0.0180935226,
0.0883139074,
0.0083035417,
-0.0044532353,
0.0031959927,
0.024940921,
-0.0135939,
-0.0107744616,
-0.0335739702,
0.0348617546,
-0.0221088994,
-0.0066003851,
-0.013848261,
0.0979469121,
-0.0155078322,
0.0320362076,
0.0182588119,
0.002399273,
0.0028820692,
0.0295982715,
0.0138722723,
-0.0186120067,
-0.0758391842,
-0.0535441414,
-0.0235823784,
-0.0375747383,
0.0219027009,
0.0254126228,
-0.0086315777,
-0.013784606,
-0.0529839247,
-0.0771865919,
0.0114677865,
-0.0142359193,
-0.0057818778,
-0.0327499546,
0.0009787185,
0.0073362347,
0.0236393195,
-0.0469040312,
-0.0129287364,
0.009219368,
-0.0759184882,
0.04089313,
0.013882664,
0.0470430106,
-0.0074743014,
0.00704866,
-0.0736364648,
-0.0429398529,
0.0080414983,
0.034720052,
0.0104252594,
0.0365123227,
-0.0332176425,
-0.0383001417,
-0.0134651586,
0.0641649663,
-0.0355894379,
0.0474261716,
0.0043420913,
0.0061389348,
-0.0109368581,
0.0406816527,
-0.0079587493,
0.0094056642,
-0.0023534384,
0.0594034828,
-0.001039585,
0.0029928614,
0.051871229,
0.0235680379,
0.0530682579,
-0.0010744779,
0.0445209779,
-0.0577783063,
0.0172505565,
-0.0390786603,
-0.0012647952,
-0.018787615,
-0.00035065,
0.0243705921,
-0.0386449769,
-0.0383705646,
0.000620401,
-0.0504439287,
0.0234719291,
-0.0217451639,
-0.0231574923,
0.0399816036,
0.0146501847,
0.0167747345,
-0.009736931,
-0.0211483855,
-0.0144182872,
0.0307882801,
0.0276189167,
-0.0322173573,
0.0659574792,
0.04212147,
-0.0030418108,
0.0142639093,
0.0124874264,
-0.0696176142,
0.0235266984,
-0.027767811,
0.0523198843,
0.127469182,
0.0134861646,
0.0852358267,
-0.0647791475,
-0.0355861634,
-0.0274297073,
0.057784643,
0.0074771265,
-0.0223418586,
-0.0105116507,
-0.0145210363,
0.0011028111,
-0.0082581872,
0.0394321568,
-0.0360313505,
0.0474135093,
0.0302679464,
-0.0329675749,
-0.0237940978,
0.0033748478,
-0.0245000049,
-0.0498919003,
-0.0027770847,
0.0239738598,
-0.0339200199,
-0.0590498671,
-0.0134189008,
0.0463914089,
0.0339560397,
-0.0148515161,
-0.0063576102,
0.0501176193,
0.0055802721,
-0.0286596715,
-0.0315873995,
-0.0171454251,
0.0085106511,
-0.0231359992,
-0.0432457365,
-5.889848975e-33,
-0.0543057658,
0.0258938074,
0.0071379482,
0.0286533199,
-0.0232935399,
-0.0191499293,
-0.0449341834,
0.0049097706,
0.0370554365,
0.0754845291,
-0.040495716,
0.0506533049,
0.0060951398,
0.0199259594,
0.0551570952,
0.0224869344,
0.0846752375,
-0.009176434,
0.0001786024,
-0.0083081527,
0.0471646823,
0.0298910979,
0.1051212177,
-0.0406659059,
0.0186418835,
0.0186577719,
-0.0365403332,
0.0308366101,
-0.0092803845,
0.0243942942,
0.0239419546,
0.0317736864,
0.0194930825,
0.0152635789,
-0.0214246325,
-0.0228747204,
-0.0843504593,
-0.0403473675,
0.0107999463,
0.0517775267,
-0.0129852975,
-0.0153480563,
0.012141047,
-0.0265748613,
-0.0154330004,
-0.0263787173,
-0.0013804071,
-0.0148496954,
0.0282449257,
0.0124576278,
-0.0697234794,
0.007795264,
0.0053816768,
0.0019933039,
-0.0279184636,
0.0374175347,
-0.0203841981,
-0.0369725414,
-0.0820965022,
-0.0254964344,
-0.0034639002,
0.0396157764,
0.0240267459,
-0.0485867709,
-0.0512020551,
0.0292050894,
0.0185791533,
0.0024648039,
-0.0256768316,
0.0086387759,
0.008514178,
-0.0065241531,
0.0251316596,
0.0675479695,
0.0316712521,
-0.0182121247,
-0.0372663811,
-0.0086423522,
0.0157090966,
0.0831573904,
-0.0208422765,
0.0070422692,
-0.0194882825,
-0.0206223242,
-0.0003082694,
-0.0016262258,
-0.027056003,
-0.0305731967,
0.0452868231,
0.0083379531,
0.0519087426,
0.0011197863,
0.0121150948,
-0.0216584597,
-0.0101583237,
-0.0162041038,
-0.0345426314,
0.0393672138,
-0.0129580628,
0.0421844833,
-0.0568078049,
-0.0109659089,
-0.0142574627,
0.0644094944,
0.006236488,
0.0032801568,
0.0573249944,
0.0375454091,
-0.0711434111,
0.0156895109,
-0.0197568256,
0.0472994298,
-0.0272719786,
-0.013067157,
0.0111802826,
-0.0038174111,
0.0026160323,
0.0244984869,
0.0051312777,
0.0023903921,
-0.0080139479,
-0.0005010986,
-0.0263385121,
0.0213458147,
0.0021577694,
0.0103918854,
-0.0274052694,
-0.0063685696,
0.0106346318,
-0.0514758416,
0.0079499725,
0.0076494026,
2.62e-7,
0.0114821019,
0.0773820877,
0.0232799891,
-0.0048571257,
0.0227882657,
0.0044670836,
-0.0207866747,
0.039492514,
0.0068869032,
0.0366465114,
0.0328860432,
-0.0033464187,
0.0572929159,
0.036420282,
-0.0721755698,
-0.007176152,
-0.0682604238,
-0.0111295665,
-0.0305912606,
-0.0117503023,
0.0521424264,
0.0517334267,
0.0358731598,
-0.0014068307,
0.0000364256,
-0.0397652425,
0.0717221946,
0.0166481603,
-0.0426807068,
0.0276922435,
0.0560524315,
0.0425501131,
0.0250154175,
0.0302830841,
-0.004316105,
-0.0192732364,
0.0000600298,
0.0319374576,
-0.0253737886,
0.057531666,
0.0000257419,
0.0054147858,
-0.0118716424,
-0.0514450148,
0.0380870067,
-0.0542038605,
0.0132568525,
-0.0074249986,
-0.0270870868,
-0.0097326254,
0.0327022187,
-0.0129868975,
-0.0539094731,
0.0066007562,
0.0465332121,
0.0443731174,
-0.0397711359,
-0.0316395089,
0.0162955076,
0.03425299,
0.0135474727,
-0.0159198027,
0.0244035441,
0.0161679834,
0.0220626947,
-0.053290464,
-0.0236057676,
2.262689102e-34,
0.0687797293,
-0.0226250514,
0.0536018685,
0.0063236859,
0.0433376506,
0.0088532139,
0.029591769,
0.0030540756,
-0.0159878992,
-0.025913693,
-0.0269785784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01712v1
|
Rumour Detection and Analysis on Twitter
| 2023-04-04T11:20:37 | 2023-04-04T11:20:37 |
Yaohou Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years people have become increasingly reliant on social media to
read news and get information, and some social media users post unsubstantiated
information to gain attention. Such information is known as rumours. Nowadays,
rumour detection is receiving a growing amount of attention because of the
pandemic of the New Coronavirus, which has led to a large number of rumours
being spread. In this paper, a Natural Language Processing (NLP) system is
built to predict rumours. The best model is applied to the COVID-19 tweets to
conduct exploratory data analysis. The contribution of this study is twofold:
(1) to compare rumours and facts using state-of-the-art natural language
processing models in two dimensions: language structure and propagation route.
(2) An analysis of how rumours differ from facts in terms of their lexical use
and the emotions they imply. This study shows that linguistic structure is a
better feature to distinguish rumours from facts compared to the propagation
path. In addition, rumour tweets contain more vocabulary related to politics
and negative emotions.
|
[
0.0529693924,
0.0027533269,
0.0011839961,
0.0192215573,
-0.0429093689,
-0.0351779647,
-0.0215781666,
0.0052974378,
0.0531556681,
-0.0437143259,
0.0314855725,
0.0062362007,
-0.0081547005,
0.0702200979,
-0.0032986226,
-0.0190303475,
0.0393148884,
0.0312411003,
0.061873246,
-0.0135437027,
-0.0035950085,
0.053089384,
0.011074801,
0.0490489863,
-0.026218012,
0.0183763057,
0.0300187375,
0.0073513803,
0.0096439477,
-0.0580763817,
0.0031483814,
0.0115319788,
0.0277616363,
0.0093565257,
0.0000018594,
-0.0580430739,
-0.0372060314,
0.01351179,
0.003668315,
-0.0423687957,
0.0972552374,
-0.0511596277,
0.0034535369,
0.0427231938,
-0.0354617536,
-0.0142899761,
0.0191989075,
0.0582099967,
0.0687900856,
0.0806654617,
-0.0338895582,
-0.0680580735,
-0.0062272898,
0.0121588632,
-0.0097063156,
-0.0638826191,
0.0641803741,
-0.0147911655,
-0.0214642826,
0.0262362789,
0.0344644487,
0.0095187295,
-0.0311474279,
0.012787004,
-0.0137471547,
0.0378802717,
-0.0327145942,
-0.0718393847,
-0.0220962819,
-0.0315616392,
-0.0047201253,
-0.0400133356,
0.0211226791,
0.0093673347,
-0.0121937441,
0.0458509922,
-0.0201949161,
0.0220913328,
-0.0504646935,
0.0530414097,
0.0652241409,
0.0207523946,
0.0205305777,
0.0351227932,
0.0389204882,
0.062035162,
-0.0213161856,
-0.0554629192,
0.0131565388,
-0.0276591387,
0.0134515548,
-0.069562383,
0.0240461789,
0.0138360569,
-0.0055026212,
0.0500407591,
-0.0233137459,
-0.0157431159,
0.0331641212,
-0.1751756519,
-0.0929957032,
0.0064282068,
0.0255946219,
0.0191441327,
0.0147294644,
-0.0603262782,
-0.0100581041,
-0.0209565274,
0.0678321719,
-0.0260964129,
-0.0342095308,
0.021407295,
-0.0119471587,
0.0069920523,
-0.0263559334,
0.0127426777,
-0.0505633876,
-0.0398626812,
-0.0015321661,
-0.0139283389,
0.0151357148,
0.0326670446,
-0.013068337,
0.0260062553,
-0.0266690049,
0.0397435762,
-0.0073037613,
0.0062466762,
-0.0402623937,
-0.0156161739,
0.0308059156,
-0.023626605,
0.0130686015,
0.0443373099,
-0.0089989975,
0.0204509906,
0.0457444265,
0.008525501,
-0.026690606,
-0.054502055,
-0.0001654558,
-0.0242396854,
-0.0171096306,
-0.0635702685,
-0.0287804101,
0.018918002,
-0.0208274405,
-0.0005789708,
0.0329954959,
0.0478075743,
-0.0901316106,
0.0352407396,
-0.0346058309,
0.0044197706,
0.0464200415,
0.020045992,
0.0247129276,
0.0497483276,
0.0112375952,
0.0627637133,
0.035813719,
0.0261813216,
-0.005512394,
-0.0130593171,
0.0125458948,
-0.0397333875,
0.0456620082,
-0.003366959,
-0.0355578922,
-0.0209846497,
-0.0683022961,
0.0276815388,
0.0040134438,
-0.007503462,
0.0071481094,
-0.0200924668,
-0.0302994326,
-0.0065883989,
0.0326772965,
0.0729633942,
-0.0149535602,
-0.022260664,
-0.0032454736,
-0.0185482372,
-0.0429594666,
-0.0202038996,
0.0291505083,
0.0601398461,
-0.0026697728,
-0.027213838,
-0.0540831946,
0.0117203677,
0.0469347127,
-0.0905837119,
0.0111742029,
-0.0343880542,
-0.0780856311,
-0.0059481198,
0.0520556308,
0.0005264003,
-0.0136718163,
-0.0561986081,
-0.0150515381,
0.0534554161,
0.0064773532,
0.0484444313,
-0.0227332208,
-0.0080586504,
0.0094213439,
0.0359666422,
0.0248638615,
0.0132871503,
-0.031213481,
-0.0150267575,
0.0179024395,
-0.0048869154,
0.0243222136,
-0.0131972237,
0.0223318823,
0.0648801178,
-0.0364430919,
0.0069469456,
-0.0589795113,
0.0336391479,
0.0026503988,
-0.0156328231,
-0.0205210168,
0.0075692548,
0.0194119457,
0.0132512217,
0.0534100197,
-0.0103092166,
0.0296711158,
0.0247594435,
-0.031577535,
0.0251245126,
-0.005375965,
-0.006226934,
0.0037491901,
-0.0136508485,
-0.0311632808,
0.0057643256,
-0.0146182012,
0.0116394814,
0.0701355189,
-0.01299736,
0.0200237632,
-0.0472901836,
-0.0236723442,
-0.0406822078,
0.02097697,
0.0352606922,
0.0853988528,
-0.0215394311,
-0.0030308187,
-0.0301231593,
-0.0456158407,
-0.0022663851,
0.0082807709,
-0.0076727602,
-0.0040058335,
0.0025708615,
0.0155808367,
0.0189220328,
-0.0396458246,
-0.0062985765,
0.0029362158,
-0.081225574,
0.0367114134,
-0.0099555273,
0.0062629618,
0.0492288098,
0.0382312648,
-0.0243087802,
0.0120930308,
0.026162738,
0.0116251344,
0.0475825071,
-0.0084113628,
-0.0023999973,
-0.0185913257,
0.0011469934,
-0.023362115,
0.0276991669,
-0.0668352842,
-0.0025944521,
0.0453099497,
-0.0756701976,
-0.0094796345,
0.0083372397,
-0.0575551204,
0.0493265763,
-0.0073648542,
-0.0190202687,
0.0129240155,
0.0170413218,
0.0063065514,
-0.0089957165,
0.0093099028,
0.0632973537,
0.0183025934,
0.0161638726,
0.0156194577,
0.0295226835,
-0.0651858971,
0.0157134477,
-0.0606068261,
-0.0430153757,
0.0346416384,
0.0485689677,
0.0309133213,
0.0068482943,
-0.0341513641,
0.0433885083,
-0.0158883985,
0.012858741,
0.0221025292,
-0.0339581296,
0.0202210806,
0.0152701512,
-0.0033517287,
-0.0429988541,
0.0504828468,
-0.0031969431,
0.0623607896,
-0.1107702777,
-0.0407983549,
-0.005133796,
0.0149306953,
-0.0139525179,
0.0175241847,
0.049468305,
0.0157778021,
0.040825747,
-0.064509131,
0.0079197139,
-0.0159058291,
-0.069206439,
-0.0252482034,
0.0194134358,
0.0365317017,
0.0165173765,
-0.0439663455,
-0.0854453593,
-0.0706645474,
-0.0025867578,
0.0081730932,
-0.0216729771,
-0.0538189746,
-0.0101957135,
0.0143255275,
-0.0163970925,
0.0150254127,
-0.0058717607,
0.041203402,
-0.0119822379,
-0.0154875526,
-0.0340050086,
0.0345870592,
0.0386287756,
0.0028814734,
0.0458276495,
-0.0393213816,
-0.0001654908,
-0.0265423264,
-0.029704826,
-0.0332114697,
-0.0226432122,
-0.0170295462,
0.0114705842,
0.0437911898,
-0.0656539053,
-0.0025779421,
0.1101251394,
0.0459261462,
0.0380339436,
0.0179767087,
0.0047963443,
-0.00869489,
0.0245857947,
0.0229703672,
-0.0096681565,
0.0030806821,
-0.0082491999,
-0.0265496131,
-0.0320952944,
-0.0236003865,
-0.0229952484,
-0.035419926,
0.0366769284,
-0.0554242954,
0.006384064,
-0.0239138566,
-0.0741018876,
0.0065975981,
0.0029466408,
-0.024706753,
-0.0357633941,
0.0010474648,
0.0166435465,
0.0179125424,
-0.0878811032,
-0.0379126705,
0.0402628034,
-0.0096117016,
-0.0032168077,
0.0053807744,
0.090729937,
-0.0288160462,
-0.0420781001,
-0.0048177987,
0.0318938419,
-0.0084035406,
-0.0513142832,
0.0569522977,
-0.0495622009,
0.0113749066,
-0.0307673123,
0.0125324763,
-0.0224244222,
0.00062752,
-0.0094936574,
0.039606493,
-0.0066995369,
-0.0782011598,
-0.0329036377,
0.0587239787,
0.0357843414,
0.0540543497,
-0.0083194058,
0.0264681261,
0.014567377,
-0.0218386538,
0.0205662623,
-0.0104733491,
-0.0804577768,
0.0346321873,
-0.0123927565,
-0.0900553837,
-0.0388420708,
-0.0545904823,
0.0078623258,
-0.000820763,
-0.0484475121,
-0.0008559786,
0.0482158363,
-0.0288337786,
-0.029269632,
-0.0447146669,
0.0264433008,
0.0235521235,
0.0493344143,
0.009015277,
0.04074784,
0.046441704,
-0.0190458689,
0.0217083413,
-0.0512565859,
-0.0501837693,
-0.0095990151,
-0.0351665914,
0.0188599415,
0.0016268967,
-0.0203697979,
-0.0047129141,
0.035805393,
0.019256331,
-0.0312051326,
0.0048363283,
-0.0092656324,
0.0179450773,
0.063734293,
0.0129496716,
0.0420361124,
0.0274012238,
-0.0053422982,
0.0027303228,
-0.0392304063,
0.0374069214,
0.0038164307,
-0.0007692701,
0.0234399196,
-0.0112662297,
-0.0341853201,
-0.0232896712,
-0.0424128063,
-0.0274635237,
-0.0270073097,
0.0211908575,
-0.0006465621,
-0.0127701657,
0.0411010273,
-0.041066017,
-0.0315793864,
-0.0607931092,
-0.0005632634,
-0.0213043224,
0.032564003,
0.0749504417,
0.0212441608,
-0.0040429942,
-0.0222625416,
0.0123525793,
-0.0232760496,
-0.0035255954,
-0.023823455,
0.0119199837,
-0.0699972585,
-0.0214886907,
-0.0421625264,
0.0265996885,
-0.0162304789,
-0.0344030894,
-0.048921261,
-0.043601647,
-0.0005017644,
-0.0080210678,
-0.0058718226,
0.0252468325,
-0.0373064578,
0.0136408983,
0.0099605042,
-0.0098352078,
-0.0408473946,
-0.0251723509,
0.0264978223,
-0.0301062185,
-0.0568801053,
0.0364418775,
0.0229133852,
0.0089697856,
0.0288411435,
0.0630642101,
-0.0580481961,
-0.0420504697,
-0.0036034123,
0.0008222228,
0.0459403656,
0.0127235102,
0.0268852152,
-0.0429106653,
-0.0164666139,
0.0745415464,
-0.0422768369,
0.0264587291,
0.0039920239,
0.0048454106,
0.0918641388,
0.06023781,
0.0282698888,
-0.0608692728,
-0.0136005785,
-0.0201315153,
-0.0543223992,
-0.0214038249,
-6.440244083e-33,
0.0326267444,
-0.0400168896,
0.0132384421,
-0.0026388513,
0.0247266591,
0.033692386,
-0.0101712719,
-0.0189375486,
-0.0398086719,
0.0411374122,
0.0215804521,
0.0204683635,
0.0166486818,
-0.031928774,
-0.0121586397,
0.0038576499,
0.054644797,
0.0060368995,
0.0076985657,
-0.0042754351,
0.0541330948,
0.0359477513,
0.0762936622,
-0.0974862948,
0.0779587254,
-0.0254652798,
-0.0025345245,
0.0051597562,
0.0429366827,
-0.015203678,
-0.016629586,
0.0445900448,
0.0354786962,
-0.020825047,
-0.0133012608,
0.0237228181,
-0.0034773888,
-0.0494352505,
0.0321052596,
-0.0372045971,
-0.0074823271,
0.0279567149,
0.0462859049,
0.0282251388,
-0.0105607742,
0.0300241634,
0.0446499102,
0.0040067951,
0.0390489325,
0.0093744257,
-0.0540576801,
0.0237478465,
0.0013932141,
0.0146020707,
-0.0322471932,
0.0346361548,
-0.0212970898,
0.0222694278,
-0.0639794171,
0.0147241484,
-0.0414459854,
0.0285107922,
-0.004575877,
-0.0871538967,
-0.0100977588,
0.0469828434,
0.0029630105,
0.0062201899,
-0.0450247414,
0.0628694221,
0.0002381978,
0.0732105523,
0.0024019801,
0.0376733616,
0.0402888432,
-0.0416126885,
-0.112614058,
0.03795439,
0.0375705883,
0.0550954007,
0.0012942789,
0.0126890568,
-0.0420676097,
-0.0061200601,
0.0214483254,
-0.0447036438,
-0.0069627054,
-0.031444069,
-0.0318748578,
0.0106850471,
-0.0159013588,
0.0805494562,
0.0055243121,
-0.0131740961,
-0.0120641692,
0.0135405157,
0.0035724717,
-0.0130628785,
0.0090766139,
0.0844671726,
-0.0514275692,
0.0238069817,
-0.001344749,
0.069923386,
-0.0068303919,
-0.0069628078,
0.0007210031,
0.006475437,
-0.055998411,
0.0170040596,
-0.0136686247,
0.0234961323,
-0.0228527281,
0.0418839492,
0.0058773793,
0.020011723,
-0.0210439339,
-0.0272901077,
0.0128308982,
0.0376370996,
0.0138958134,
-0.0072309752,
-0.0344556235,
0.0133963386,
-0.0004501041,
-0.004261421,
-0.0191308483,
0.0245503839,
-0.026796706,
-0.0653098375,
-0.0065394635,
-0.0389100723,
2.743e-7,
0.0405513272,
0.0804869682,
-0.0226826929,
-0.0030867669,
0.0236688275,
0.02520735,
0.0530331507,
0.0220708344,
-0.008660838,
-0.0894943029,
-0.0601606593,
0.0275235232,
-0.0259367228,
0.0704424903,
-0.0639988929,
0.0178276207,
-0.0404420421,
0.00416457,
-0.0478172638,
-0.0033498805,
0.0275317878,
0.0652501807,
0.0385245532,
0.0069145774,
-0.0631104633,
0.0134072537,
0.0159974117,
0.0057765348,
-0.0675085187,
0.0207533389,
0.0293374676,
0.0296074841,
0.0020585628,
-0.0060140858,
-0.0204863399,
0.0383573212,
-0.023259338,
-0.024616193,
-0.0180298761,
0.0284876525,
0.0452864133,
-0.0610983483,
-0.0105615528,
-0.0003079522,
0.0381771214,
-0.0141485427,
-0.0897856131,
-0.0205283705,
-0.0106613347,
0.0584815927,
0.0414818041,
-0.0048032939,
-0.0408449285,
0.0186770149,
-0.0279323719,
-0.0275939256,
-0.0266766213,
-0.026322173,
0.0156118153,
-0.0152868684,
-0.0483377166,
-0.0152461249,
0.0253595449,
-0.0258707684,
0.0326582566,
0.0185898226,
0.0676144585,
1.897438211e-34,
0.0317957252,
0.0218047034,
-0.0334268846,
0.0025015203,
0.0366610512,
0.0273266621,
-0.0290951263,
-0.0021183365,
-0.0017152556,
-0.0144597767,
0.0128537491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01680v1
|
Can BERT eat RuCoLA? Topological Data Analysis to Explain
| 2023-04-04T10:11:06 | 2023-04-04T10:11:06 |
Irina Proskurina, Irina Piontkovskaya, Ekaterina Artemova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates how Transformer language models (LMs) fine-tuned for
acceptability classification capture linguistic features. Our approach uses the
best practices of topological data analysis (TDA) in NLP: we construct directed
attention graphs from attention matrices, derive topological features from
them, and feed them to linear classifiers. We introduce two novel features,
chordality, and the matching number, and show that TDA-based classifiers
outperform fine-tuning baselines. We experiment with two datasets, CoLA and
RuCoLA in English and Russian, typologically different languages. On top of
that, we propose several black-box introspection techniques aimed at detecting
changes in the attention mode of the LMs during fine-tuning, defining the LM's
prediction confidences, and associating individual heads with fine-grained
grammar phenomena. Our results contribute to understanding the behavior of
monolingual LMs in the acceptability classification task, provide insights into
the functional roles of attention heads, and highlight the advantages of
TDA-based approaches for analyzing LMs. We release the code and the
experimental results for further uptake.
|
[
0.0481884442,
0.0374753959,
-0.0499389209,
0.0496153906,
-0.0217705593,
0.0053903558,
-0.0573433526,
-0.0262071528,
0.0142588653,
-0.0200518109,
-0.0464014336,
-0.0200265013,
0.0093576629,
0.0381258391,
0.0097047258,
-0.0261112154,
0.0241425857,
-0.0091472631,
-0.0368533283,
0.0039653159,
-0.0025008891,
0.0035742759,
0.0471557938,
0.057980068,
0.0217081439,
-0.0138105061,
-0.0036226134,
0.0034518382,
-0.0227588397,
-0.0064417883,
0.0474100299,
0.0835030302,
-0.0267747957,
0.0688565522,
0.0000023037,
-0.0081561953,
-0.0256143045,
-0.0099534728,
0.0108400844,
0.0246313158,
-0.0128209665,
-0.0199402124,
-0.0076235901,
-0.0025047385,
-0.0265103485,
0.0207123049,
0.0455458611,
0.0386333168,
0.0555054247,
0.0544386879,
-0.0149742207,
-0.0307189077,
0.0311004277,
-0.0113751013,
-0.0015844675,
0.0117440885,
0.0232484248,
-0.004957424,
-0.0005857177,
-0.0137650063,
-0.0630291104,
0.0384459011,
0.0046100155,
-0.0171239525,
-0.010173494,
0.0171121992,
-0.03132651,
-0.0340732522,
-0.0124535998,
0.0847174227,
-0.0323667154,
-0.0655112863,
0.0240247939,
0.0371486507,
0.0180440079,
0.0237460323,
-0.0376388766,
-0.0076460503,
-0.001686999,
0.0243239403,
0.0224829596,
-0.0363315754,
0.0046278778,
-0.0371182188,
-0.0450053327,
0.1283343136,
0.0040671034,
-0.0556710884,
0.0255290158,
-0.0017080039,
0.0085683381,
-0.0510487445,
0.0229391195,
0.0083175637,
0.0340235271,
-0.0118565019,
-0.0080330884,
-0.0053796507,
0.0322978199,
-0.0168896969,
0.043998424,
-0.0029230544,
-0.0614071898,
0.0552914478,
-0.0102198366,
0.0366829932,
-0.0326032266,
0.0603320561,
-0.0458186567,
0.013793678,
-0.0447385013,
0.0074055311,
-0.0479014739,
0.0118772453,
0.0060137962,
-0.0017063763,
-0.0084523344,
0.0504476093,
-0.0233199652,
-0.0216106698,
0.013647248,
0.0076149702,
-0.0098065883,
0.0114602298,
-0.0075810542,
0.0505890585,
-0.0281465612,
0.0018873747,
-0.0473816805,
-0.0108737024,
-0.0044250614,
0.0268508606,
0.0071226861,
-0.0228424221,
0.0111091733,
0.0165671986,
0.0385310911,
-0.0365105942,
0.0140654026,
0.0280151945,
-0.0649705455,
-0.0618008561,
0.0272252336,
-0.032380458,
-0.016587222,
-0.001257631,
-0.0075532631,
-0.0486973375,
-0.0098837679,
0.0037592796,
-0.0529764928,
0.0384943299,
0.0158794113,
0.0309055671,
-0.0086454013,
-0.04953124,
-0.0061679557,
0.03435646,
0.0185126197,
0.0160058774,
0.0315531455,
-0.0388233289,
-0.0022478811,
0.047831364,
0.007950074,
0.0233285595,
-0.0023184665,
0.0309547223,
-0.0140717709,
-0.0075267288,
0.0401773676,
0.070016779,
0.0051512201,
-0.0548276231,
0.08770293,
0.0586345494,
0.0531141609,
0.0644367635,
0.0064574219,
0.0448204987,
0.0026606368,
0.0738008916,
-0.0460367426,
0.0093213916,
-0.0472682118,
0.0127331875,
0.018474821,
0.0068211146,
-0.004160732,
-0.0413823128,
-0.0145667261,
0.01001593,
0.0706701577,
-0.040996559,
0.0498251058,
0.017281862,
-0.0656545013,
0.0326377079,
0.0355611891,
-0.0629465133,
-0.0250990503,
-0.0459675156,
0.0162862521,
0.0192617662,
0.0036441411,
-0.0293158125,
0.0116908532,
-0.0221189372,
0.0050742193,
0.0033987588,
0.0205235071,
0.0161126722,
-0.0432235785,
-0.0102062244,
0.0137145938,
-0.0063840388,
0.0297206286,
0.0309345126,
-0.0343033001,
-0.0249598809,
-0.0391263478,
-0.0488316305,
-0.0541124158,
0.0159839373,
0.0539241545,
0.0075082039,
0.0001411748,
0.0178500582,
0.0322773717,
0.0056601078,
0.0069752182,
0.0100787021,
0.0444184877,
-0.005788526,
0.0446772948,
0.0392871164,
0.0085201161,
-0.0263554845,
0.037900757,
-0.0606980324,
-0.0461477637,
0.062812075,
0.0268488601,
-0.0237523373,
0.014917464,
-0.0891207159,
0.0349907167,
-0.0357459858,
0.0295841321,
-0.0319600925,
0.0459079668,
-0.0490876883,
0.019238947,
-0.0174016356,
0.0529208928,
0.0098817497,
-0.0411671884,
0.0102648996,
-0.0247787982,
-0.0453862287,
-0.0054315683,
-0.0181607064,
0.0005146472,
0.0085171126,
-0.0005437754,
-0.0200591739,
-0.0609386638,
-0.0754576772,
-0.0216146074,
-0.0338281356,
0.0079108737,
0.0256609991,
-0.0340765156,
0.0033572388,
0.0132494597,
-0.0248738453,
-0.0084875999,
-0.0115082813,
0.0088790152,
0.0403126702,
-0.0394204035,
-0.0418646485,
-0.0203230232,
-0.0223928988,
-0.0186377857,
0.0609652624,
-0.008056297,
-0.0080341902,
-0.0363997519,
-0.0277158432,
0.0156758949,
0.000002975,
0.0018885141,
-0.0798491314,
-0.0001877242,
0.0154999783,
0.053065557,
0.0840947405,
0.0101066008,
0.0428162552,
0.0616565309,
-0.008826239,
-0.0105138076,
-0.0066162697,
-0.0190928541,
0.003412979,
-0.0115555367,
-0.0677938163,
0.0292740054,
0.1018063426,
-0.0342240334,
-0.018612748,
-0.054892499,
-0.0113140643,
-0.0219359975,
0.0129013024,
0.0161732007,
0.0275702029,
-0.0503541902,
0.0400558598,
-0.0120000225,
-0.0521719344,
0.1116449162,
-0.0535449088,
-0.042510245,
-0.0431805886,
0.0095681772,
-0.0342434905,
0.051064942,
0.0289240312,
0.0040888707,
0.0526262596,
-0.0308326371,
-0.0214416403,
0.0435344875,
-0.0189569462,
-0.019921178,
0.0890903473,
-0.0216499306,
-0.0191305391,
0.0170726608,
-0.0129888449,
-0.022939086,
-0.0194611177,
-0.0066825277,
-0.0100658126,
0.0070620943,
-0.0459406748,
-0.0117687462,
0.0083524305,
-0.0008879468,
0.0169742461,
-0.0302693974,
0.013418451,
-0.0093428139,
0.0360439457,
0.0307680387,
0.0315568335,
-0.0256595928,
-0.0097939447,
-0.0468750112,
0.0228073336,
-0.028436726,
0.0647537261,
0.0095556946,
-0.003751277,
0.0421283916,
-0.0113162119,
-0.038274195,
0.0041896938,
-0.0011760367,
-0.0415841453,
-0.0470530502,
0.0594528802,
0.0473254137,
0.001314043,
0.0265759993,
-0.0160560384,
0.0508562848,
0.0056246598,
0.035435468,
-0.0263887122,
0.0018831094,
-0.0127323717,
-0.0017221911,
-0.0103498641,
0.0045658783,
0.0261222683,
-0.079542622,
0.0365153067,
0.0018805946,
-0.0633523911,
-0.0538207144,
-0.0186903682,
0.0281631276,
0.0127910636,
-0.0057478915,
0.018551629,
-0.0188751798,
0.0053384919,
0.0281774681,
-0.0491734669,
-0.0325700082,
0.0232051518,
-0.0022893171,
0.0437074564,
0.0231750552,
0.0476945862,
-0.0370567031,
-0.0663253665,
0.0017651496,
0.0391008668,
-0.0207816623,
-0.0073066661,
0.0477503575,
0.0306526087,
-0.0176670626,
-0.0224497113,
0.0179427899,
-0.0201934427,
0.0208393056,
-0.0262175202,
0.1052759737,
0.0148226973,
-0.0458446927,
-0.006503209,
0.014200002,
-0.0074807,
0.0617295019,
0.0793971568,
-0.0593720414,
-0.0436772741,
-0.0429643579,
-0.0188237149,
-0.0609323233,
-0.057827495,
0.0716815218,
0.0115024084,
-0.1060781181,
-0.0824953467,
-0.0137999654,
0.0059919576,
-0.0059443074,
0.0361514203,
-0.0340881124,
0.0250818189,
-0.0221913029,
-0.0668077171,
0.0744887441,
0.0097058108,
0.0011389119,
-0.0750501752,
-0.0508753993,
0.0387992598,
-0.0234109629,
-0.0331236459,
-0.0188926924,
-0.0021614693,
-0.0535650253,
0.0519333892,
0.0499897338,
0.0224272031,
0.0012893752,
-0.0261244215,
-0.045130454,
-0.0282836687,
-0.0203618985,
0.0024677874,
0.032556694,
0.074721992,
-0.0158009343,
0.0112103727,
0.0395780839,
-0.0103903338,
0.0157840643,
0.0160158798,
-0.0154879568,
-0.0467142351,
-0.0557109974,
0.0054425625,
-0.015854843,
0.0493781269,
0.043725241,
-0.0116758663,
-0.0166404117,
0.0033755731,
0.0235288944,
0.0036947816,
-0.0244606473,
-0.0480847657,
0.0423118994,
-0.0120815802,
-0.0575834028,
-0.0239551719,
-0.0681007802,
0.0138638308,
-0.0615366325,
0.0414676182,
0.0376933739,
0.0159292668,
0.0180188399,
0.0043738447,
-0.0481854752,
-0.0319592394,
-0.0119948378,
0.0551307388,
0.0126600256,
0.0160709079,
0.0012779237,
-0.0187855549,
-0.0014075303,
0.0458328985,
-0.0320325419,
0.051931534,
-0.0177674722,
0.0220884457,
0.0329838954,
-0.0187594108,
0.0760857537,
0.0122442832,
0.0020662735,
-0.0371845886,
0.0338257104,
0.0035768629,
-0.0615811571,
0.018929271,
-0.002714389,
-0.009893205,
0.0024572625,
0.0482162908,
0.006038127,
-0.0305289086,
0.0141591206,
-0.0011355672,
-0.0264825206,
0.0187327527,
-0.0383946709,
-0.0089474991,
-0.0065177875,
0.0165964421,
-0.0671749488,
-0.073779203,
0.0646860301,
0.005597678,
0.0295257568,
-0.0266609509,
0.0043199435,
0.0559015274,
-0.0027158677,
-0.0076927193,
-0.064990595,
0.0007347852,
0.0201683659,
-0.0034225311,
-0.0489087887,
-6.796603277e-33,
0.0010056297,
-0.0591742992,
-0.0617599152,
0.0018529394,
-0.0132733583,
-0.0107778627,
-0.0462851934,
0.0069718487,
-0.0160643999,
-0.0079108318,
-0.0280574113,
0.0160294846,
-0.0000252859,
-0.0002410879,
0.0049311672,
-0.0201239511,
0.0347954333,
0.0389248654,
-0.0365253612,
-0.0043820958,
0.0118006347,
0.0250091739,
0.0668882653,
-0.0432066545,
0.0351271182,
-0.0162503477,
0.0165727008,
-0.0182882734,
-0.0113227218,
0.0623744875,
-0.0004651979,
0.0453618988,
0.0236404836,
-0.0017841583,
0.0073412731,
0.0492913499,
-0.0652790889,
0.0129223559,
0.0315196961,
0.0184781626,
0.0061853733,
-0.0506787039,
0.0774714053,
-0.0028668314,
0.0114432601,
-0.0315782279,
0.0388909131,
-0.0271287542,
-0.0273378175,
0.0064943475,
-0.049525395,
0.0113783674,
-0.0220410693,
-0.0594762452,
0.0301636327,
0.0486131087,
0.0154299643,
-0.0084570497,
-0.0477417335,
0.0347567834,
0.0206008609,
0.0235257391,
0.0359589942,
-0.0330135636,
0.010184044,
0.0466202721,
-0.0293038599,
0.0146403499,
0.0143343722,
-0.0265240707,
0.0507192388,
0.0627935901,
0.0564676076,
-0.0421021171,
-0.019992169,
-0.0097997664,
-0.0507816002,
0.0138755925,
0.0319810361,
0.024425935,
0.0249632727,
-0.0077420911,
-0.0564246848,
-0.0115184076,
0.0192899946,
-0.0471766703,
-0.0262617916,
-0.0061106333,
0.0062885336,
-0.0392035432,
-0.0421339907,
0.0346652605,
0.0168494061,
-0.0403976813,
-0.0036308898,
-0.0077998345,
-0.029042162,
0.0318767577,
0.0135384249,
0.0460564606,
-0.0092462488,
-0.0156900939,
-0.0081331646,
0.0213051569,
0.0456822738,
0.0357057638,
0.0395574942,
0.006487269,
-0.0658821762,
-0.0140990987,
-0.022916384,
-0.0104181264,
-0.0463836156,
0.0384835303,
0.0358221158,
0.0211853217,
-0.0069343089,
0.0692809597,
0.0075002611,
0.02023484,
-0.1007784456,
0.0237859972,
-0.0039020244,
0.0403732285,
-0.0427920669,
-0.0363832042,
0.012788156,
0.0477163233,
0.0403246619,
-0.0391833261,
-0.0043748193,
-0.0252081491,
3.152e-7,
0.0486894287,
0.0922404304,
-0.0135889873,
-0.0248073917,
0.0156355109,
0.0125799235,
-0.0343847871,
0.0332498997,
0.0444143191,
-0.0212046821,
-0.0012437206,
-0.0296192411,
0.0491458289,
0.033025708,
-0.1118533388,
-0.0584080853,
-0.0732151046,
0.0330976248,
-0.0165605899,
0.0092675993,
0.0296711735,
0.0827164501,
0.0104045738,
0.0291565191,
0.0092280619,
-0.024602389,
0.0395536423,
-0.0276480988,
0.0147309555,
0.0177385155,
0.0453139693,
-0.0510534495,
0.0039251917,
0.0075706844,
-0.0182528682,
0.0553285666,
-0.0007856178,
0.04753346,
-0.0205639433,
-0.0370917879,
0.0145512484,
-0.0439067036,
-0.0349268429,
-0.0871370956,
0.069573164,
-0.1040132642,
-0.0366588756,
0.0260273814,
0.0012851795,
-0.0168477595,
0.0264599547,
-0.0159445796,
-0.0264534075,
0.024165675,
0.0218143743,
-0.0705084652,
0.0381213911,
-0.07263311,
-0.0014600682,
-0.0035273037,
-0.0318640508,
-0.0253422353,
-0.0371588022,
-0.033504568,
0.0267873164,
-0.0376850814,
-0.0049503995,
3.019993761e-34,
0.0460634083,
-0.0201965198,
0.047470618,
0.0224550012,
0.0222638845,
-0.0267723128,
0.082554467,
0.0160671324,
0.0380634964,
-0.0786765367,
-0.0253375396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01666v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01666v2
|
A Survey on Contextualised Semantic Shift Detection
| 2023-04-04T09:50:19 | 2024-06-11T15:33:13 |
Stefano Montanelli, Francesco Periti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic Shift Detection (SSD) is the task of identifying, interpreting, and
assessing the possible change over time in the meanings of a target word.
Traditionally, SSD has been addressed by linguists and social scientists
through manual and time-consuming activities. In the recent years,
computational approaches based on Natural Language Processing and word
embeddings gained increasing attention to automate SSD as much as possible. In
particular, over the past three years, significant advancements have been made
almost exclusively based on word contextualised embedding models, which can
handle the multiple usages/meanings of the words and better capture the related
semantic shifts. In this paper, we survey the approaches based on
contextualised embeddings for SSD (i.e., CSSDetection) and we propose a
classification framework characterised by meaning representation,
time-awareness, and learning modality dimensions. The framework is exploited i)
to review the measures for shift assessment, ii) to compare the approaches on
performance, and iii) to discuss the current issues in terms of scalability,
interpretability, and robustness. Open challenges and future research
directions about CSSDetection are finally outlined.
|
[
0.0136957839,
0.0583794639,
-0.0277287662,
0.045668669,
-0.0545601398,
-0.009956087,
-0.0367230102,
-0.0044771065,
-0.0580427796,
-0.0717728809,
0.0557212271,
-0.0114820562,
-0.0029715621,
-0.0026636,
-0.0363896452,
0.0147781437,
0.1096349359,
0.0600172095,
-0.0688446313,
0.0477853343,
-0.0017973501,
-0.0108947363,
-0.0229205973,
0.0209237393,
-0.0318325721,
-0.0441857129,
-0.0129370186,
-0.0298035238,
0.06033317,
-0.0393821038,
-0.0126174381,
0.0389103331,
0.040575821,
0.065883629,
0.0000021046,
-0.0670537353,
-0.0386036038,
-0.0424090698,
-0.0284114722,
0.0243199654,
0.0713550672,
-0.0341105759,
-0.0048568742,
-0.0354580022,
-0.0496310815,
0.0214772113,
0.0305515975,
-0.038019035,
0.0152847311,
0.0676946267,
0.0057706377,
-0.0041898079,
-0.0466233641,
0.0197117869,
-0.0084331697,
-0.054351341,
0.054986164,
-0.015465606,
-0.0423818529,
-0.0458164848,
-0.0750945359,
0.0268054567,
-0.0421575569,
-0.0289309397,
0.0258346945,
0.0207632128,
-0.0073414817,
0.034251295,
-0.0187525023,
0.0276062079,
-0.0302813277,
-0.019630665,
-0.002213924,
-0.0341277197,
-0.0166571159,
0.0455757976,
-0.0063691079,
-0.0281738266,
0.046822384,
0.0079965601,
0.0375527628,
0.0122771747,
0.043083515,
0.0411305316,
-0.0464690328,
0.0488581322,
0.0133262808,
-0.0422373265,
-0.0423567928,
-0.0215315744,
0.0198937431,
-0.0307640266,
-0.0030290924,
0.0244505815,
-0.0093412166,
0.059756387,
-0.0105898958,
-0.047451023,
0.0018437573,
-0.0507422201,
-0.0041389777,
0.0056730062,
-0.0151031343,
0.0417909734,
0.0279599559,
0.0015349307,
0.0214869734,
-0.031392321,
-0.0470429026,
0.0201217365,
-0.0355440862,
0.0271661226,
-0.0096944002,
-0.0035504729,
-0.001903503,
-0.0146525837,
-0.0264110472,
0.0491790697,
0.0012644946,
-0.0026999032,
-0.054643061,
0.0160104111,
-0.0257940441,
0.0176281203,
-0.0036956433,
0.0288730655,
-0.0282907616,
0.0064852708,
-0.030127449,
-0.0085382182,
-0.0158097986,
0.0214051045,
0.0090435464,
0.0008499289,
-0.0443126857,
0.05204257,
-0.0104912249,
-0.0385971591,
-0.0550217591,
-0.0108845048,
-0.0409622565,
0.0128765106,
-0.0008847191,
-0.0173846986,
0.0173284616,
-0.0095723327,
0.016030984,
-0.033608295,
-0.0284184832,
-0.0034222724,
-0.0130777396,
0.0667954534,
-0.0199052356,
0.0239786319,
0.0141018433,
-0.0092159975,
-0.0129389549,
0.0863457471,
0.0649986565,
-0.0286286976,
0.0980795398,
-0.0269356854,
-0.0587358214,
0.0231012329,
-0.0225818213,
0.0135332039,
-0.0328834206,
-0.0048298715,
0.0080160825,
0.0666755959,
-0.0017853746,
-0.0349323004,
-0.0197116621,
-0.0378304124,
-0.0088042431,
0.0822905824,
0.0121604763,
0.0016850143,
0.0497798249,
0.013965562,
-0.0424740352,
-0.0062011941,
-0.0131617617,
-0.0422478914,
-0.0182875264,
-0.0655417219,
-0.0638299286,
-0.0220675953,
0.0265755653,
0.0146206813,
-0.0080297394,
-0.0229860265,
0.0556665026,
-0.0463312939,
0.0479071811,
-0.0227676295,
0.0210819673,
0.0317642577,
0.0368822739,
-0.0235739425,
0.0356783718,
-0.0107422126,
0.0217496566,
0.0751972869,
0.0328770988,
-0.0678404421,
-0.0227383152,
-0.0088981381,
-0.0051668794,
0.0356274918,
0.0422769412,
-0.0413763598,
-0.0090597291,
-0.0363448113,
-0.0080589186,
0.0382691212,
0.0263496507,
-0.0054120072,
0.0045304713,
0.0497948602,
0.009761529,
-0.0280406326,
0.0253348891,
0.0480862334,
-0.0239552259,
0.0076894723,
0.0013430348,
0.0145759527,
0.0136886006,
0.0017567285,
-0.0007671745,
0.004074187,
0.0036870178,
-0.0153833292,
-0.0212233253,
0.0690192431,
-0.0280873496,
-0.0072350446,
0.0357147194,
-0.0068620141,
0.0202211123,
0.0043101287,
-0.0431085452,
-0.0063858349,
0.0679761767,
-0.0091392985,
0.0357593335,
-0.0238856282,
0.0391227975,
-0.044394847,
0.0369765125,
-0.048583433,
0.0446950123,
-0.005748143,
0.0102066016,
0.0006981733,
0.0210962854,
0.039443884,
0.0109531982,
0.0180041939,
0.0057542217,
-0.0098135946,
-0.0257245563,
0.0137889534,
-0.0420769081,
-0.045527745,
0.0216937643,
-0.0499685518,
0.0113486024,
-0.0300766472,
0.0416020826,
0.0357174091,
0.0128695564,
-0.0154639306,
-0.0209877007,
0.0295491479,
0.043920286,
-0.0515909977,
0.0388144851,
0.033339873,
-0.0366079919,
-0.0090121692,
-0.0421320796,
0.0305675901,
-0.0444716811,
0.0780946538,
0.000790991,
-0.0477696359,
-0.0555958487,
-0.0099099828,
-0.0385113358,
0.0006756397,
0.0036250951,
0.0057318858,
0.0016975753,
0.0391191095,
0.0519242249,
0.0246556327,
0.0612576045,
0.0694691688,
0.0592366308,
-0.0355497077,
-0.0255958047,
-0.0343620703,
-0.0183774382,
0.0175804831,
-0.0491522774,
-0.01778505,
0.0342695676,
0.0456027091,
0.0268507078,
-0.0013319388,
-0.0523347184,
-0.0084429784,
-0.0623634718,
-0.0329449773,
-0.0124841761,
0.0425994173,
-0.0593223013,
0.0294095613,
-0.0116718253,
-0.0149177499,
0.0221017916,
0.0393359326,
0.0514546037,
-0.0631651059,
-0.0214216188,
-0.0146235451,
0.0402790233,
-0.0329234228,
0.0230529215,
0.0038468954,
-0.0054137222,
-0.0177531578,
-0.0216001384,
0.0281206481,
-0.0158197321,
0.0211835485,
-0.0752924532,
0.0146620525,
-0.0056640753,
0.0420041904,
-0.0223363154,
-0.0971082672,
-0.019323498,
0.0040509859,
-0.0159533918,
-0.0144784311,
0.0158348605,
-0.0219849683,
-0.0513653308,
0.0390453413,
0.0217602588,
0.0026722117,
-0.0195528027,
0.0417664275,
0.0248904601,
0.0201193951,
-0.0068629212,
0.0588998646,
0.0292824879,
0.024864547,
-0.0253814906,
-0.0099844607,
-0.076236099,
-0.0153134782,
-0.0055479775,
-0.0865834653,
0.0052590449,
-0.0036462846,
0.0124364607,
-0.0058300556,
-0.0134051396,
0.0988001451,
0.0671379343,
-0.0132595217,
0.051547531,
-0.0242351498,
-0.0640676245,
0.0366084203,
-0.0314779803,
-0.1012378484,
-0.0286647435,
-0.0155120511,
-0.0168517791,
0.0008223207,
-0.0394078828,
-0.0279039107,
-0.0546115153,
0.012318057,
-0.0066989837,
-0.0693149418,
0.0618425272,
-0.0316923447,
0.0372974277,
-0.0082967328,
-0.0485302024,
-0.0510602221,
-0.011280559,
-0.0132164089,
0.0158402864,
-0.0468220934,
-0.0388470069,
0.0331444331,
-0.0050191949,
0.0499085002,
0.0407116637,
0.051067207,
-0.0178104453,
-0.0480072908,
0.0442364514,
-0.0483483188,
0.0001608434,
-0.0127803832,
-0.0074309548,
-0.0282741748,
0.0037023881,
0.0393187292,
-0.0263309348,
0.0090889158,
-0.0548568033,
0.0591789223,
0.1180222705,
-0.0211518519,
-0.0320409276,
-0.0442328937,
0.0044622365,
0.0234173704,
0.0554720685,
0.0078872889,
-0.0417560227,
0.0353270471,
0.0370261148,
0.014371695,
0.0365240127,
0.0154994586,
0.0072291056,
-0.0425208658,
-0.0096770627,
-0.0825244486,
-0.0164419245,
-0.0178161059,
-0.0171297863,
0.03686646,
0.0094819181,
0.0426165387,
-0.0181684028,
-0.099395968,
0.0234883539,
-0.0060544647,
0.0406417251,
0.0047561284,
0.0253273677,
0.0465409569,
0.0454086997,
-0.0158983842,
-0.0432841405,
-0.0482173748,
-0.0418650843,
0.020747954,
-0.0663269311,
0.004928668,
0.0408350192,
-0.039268855,
0.0238545146,
0.0451049805,
0.0121305408,
-0.0113907605,
0.0209824555,
0.0226532612,
0.0343911536,
-0.0253896192,
0.0457089171,
-0.0058036949,
0.0284633469,
-0.0218802728,
0.0121309878,
-0.0536239855,
-0.0003686157,
-0.0124278544,
-0.0370500125,
0.0480343886,
-0.0124799851,
-0.0493807495,
-0.0228823237,
-0.0173646938,
-0.0157012958,
-0.0335155502,
0.0377439782,
-0.067292124,
0.0011763559,
-0.0289573036,
-0.0308125857,
0.0507980399,
-0.048750978,
-0.0178177655,
-0.0181474518,
0.0090783946,
0.0642177537,
0.0740667209,
-0.005778519,
0.0545351766,
-0.0046777544,
-0.0375025012,
-0.0393764935,
-0.0019766979,
-0.0222523194,
0.0527369343,
0.0040442343,
-0.0357444696,
-0.0393031612,
0.024854796,
-0.0126896119,
0.0504912995,
0.0174136572,
-0.0143015385,
0.0551183894,
-0.0413323119,
0.0492162816,
0.0142367603,
0.0003927108,
0.0085082585,
0.041130323,
-0.0130792595,
-0.0296828113,
0.0274698194,
0.0052102474,
-0.0197439771,
0.0587721132,
-0.0100070043,
-0.0516373515,
0.0552846119,
0.0097003765,
-0.0319676735,
-0.0190919675,
0.0072721685,
0.01251233,
0.0348766297,
-0.0131369447,
0.0390135944,
-0.0802569017,
-0.0281643532,
0.0451814793,
-0.0041517396,
0.0043940153,
0.0410269238,
-0.0038197087,
0.0644571409,
-0.0187799651,
0.0008879583,
-0.0285703819,
0.0292980056,
-0.0187935159,
-0.0186404884,
-0.047820311,
-6.175699814e-33,
0.023089949,
-0.0094678327,
0.0106590297,
0.0048440616,
-0.0512258485,
0.0168824643,
-0.0158582013,
-0.0138775771,
-0.000093874,
0.0089977402,
0.0024045205,
0.0302797537,
0.0164062921,
-0.010558418,
0.0106406109,
-0.0211081393,
0.0449017398,
-0.0106526799,
-0.0436958782,
-0.0286365971,
0.0744388849,
-0.0050995504,
0.1053922996,
-0.0669292882,
0.0215559658,
0.0528925881,
0.0195477642,
0.0188017562,
0.0326380618,
-0.0047879959,
-0.0084610255,
0.0519654937,
0.0393148325,
-0.0041711773,
0.0041343765,
0.0088722184,
-0.0626612157,
-0.0710196495,
0.0355439,
0.0511792004,
-0.0084696077,
-0.0198113974,
-0.0046223868,
-0.0003295642,
-0.007705777,
0.0282161701,
0.0185373165,
-0.0350648463,
-0.0395584814,
0.0079330867,
-0.1148083806,
0.0554561056,
-0.0389485434,
0.0102716489,
-0.0015820784,
-0.0247247647,
0.0447626896,
-0.0374398977,
-0.0547511578,
0.0293223951,
-0.0143116992,
-0.0245060325,
0.0403938182,
0.0287582092,
-0.0175412931,
0.0521673597,
-0.0091151968,
-0.0278768837,
0.0645244196,
-0.0099749854,
0.0428873561,
-0.0177325532,
0.0055164672,
0.0365123935,
0.0376113206,
-0.0344673656,
-0.0467994139,
-0.0113759041,
0.051556468,
0.0167166386,
0.0081481384,
0.0111861611,
-0.0352252573,
-0.0085898563,
-0.0462778211,
-0.0090989638,
-0.0072283181,
-0.0221811142,
0.0429719947,
0.0063004689,
-0.0062236493,
0.0607028641,
-0.0092768744,
-0.0466910712,
0.0260178298,
-0.0126919271,
-0.0148426164,
-0.010898998,
0.0139058875,
0.0081725167,
-0.0025355571,
-0.0319226682,
0.0150272697,
0.0164522752,
0.0450955294,
-0.0339127667,
0.0102040889,
0.0027624534,
-0.0099797221,
-0.0168555658,
0.005321729,
-0.0794565082,
-0.055572927,
-0.03830586,
-0.0053301537,
0.0229152534,
-0.0288927611,
0.0324198864,
0.073357597,
0.0124687357,
0.0141536565,
-0.0115670506,
-0.0011533862,
0.0453345068,
-0.0492690243,
0.0132037736,
0.0259802956,
0.039341256,
0.0532641448,
-0.0324126258,
0.0088722855,
-0.0419525169,
2.809e-7,
0.0683900714,
0.0674899071,
-0.008844059,
-0.0203890689,
0.0382107012,
-0.0192696657,
-0.0177514553,
0.0236195326,
-0.0395786799,
0.0445858799,
0.0316685177,
-0.0045140828,
-0.0070828572,
0.0372940674,
-0.001956735,
-0.0150964558,
-0.0088527426,
0.021623252,
-0.066465199,
0.008300947,
0.0551630929,
0.0695005879,
0.0299030971,
-0.0051111667,
-0.0474053137,
-0.0278345011,
0.0176150743,
-0.0486809202,
0.0083625643,
-0.0083827097,
0.0002415701,
0.0092483349,
0.0430577062,
0.0257722288,
-0.0253213905,
0.0476742201,
0.0069089844,
-0.0038625619,
-0.0535572842,
0.0261083525,
-0.066778563,
-0.052706562,
0.010830014,
-0.0131503241,
0.0902629793,
-0.0663081631,
-0.0120614413,
-0.0545446351,
-0.0638328493,
0.0364452004,
0.022864189,
0.0111323902,
-0.0319213904,
0.004655133,
0.0260358211,
0.0616251193,
-0.0656707063,
-0.107507892,
0.0196754262,
0.0154174669,
-0.0091983899,
-0.0099308677,
-0.0046667946,
-0.0451599658,
0.0194145329,
-0.0783378109,
0.0366005227,
1.900379243e-34,
0.0186714046,
0.0482408144,
0.004620776,
-0.0185727421,
0.0188526362,
-0.0026679202,
0.0199828614,
0.0059279259,
0.0332621299,
-0.0426460318,
0.0245128796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01665v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01665v3
|
Mastering Symbolic Operations: Augmenting Language Models with Compiled Neural Networks
| 2023-04-04T09:50:07 | 2024-03-09T15:27:33 |
Yixuan Weng, Minjun Zhu, Fei Xia, Bin Li, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models' (LMs) proficiency in handling deterministic symbolic
reasoning and rule-based tasks remains limited due to their dependency implicit
learning on textual data. To endow LMs with genuine rule comprehension
abilities, we propose "Neural Comprehension" - a framework that synergistically
integrates compiled neural networks (CoNNs) into the standard transformer
architecture. CoNNs are neural modules designed to explicitly encode rules
through artificially generated attention weights. By incorporating CoNN
modules, the Neural Comprehension framework enables LMs to accurately and
robustly execute rule-intensive symbolic tasks. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the superiority of our approach over existing techniques in terms
of length generalization, efficiency, and interpretability for symbolic
operations. Furthermore, it can be applied to LMs across different model
scales, outperforming tool-calling methods in arithmetic reasoning tasks while
maintaining superior inference efficiency. Our work highlights the potential of
seamlessly unifying explicit rule learning via CoNNs and implicit pattern
learning in LMs, paving the way for true symbolic comprehension capabilities.
|
[
0.0121333897,
0.0836489126,
-0.0441505462,
0.0373321287,
-0.0361519381,
0.0225962587,
0.0343812779,
-0.0266667455,
-0.0261068661,
-0.0106786536,
-0.0111388741,
0.0071043666,
-0.0024009154,
0.0029225645,
0.025312081,
0.0070121665,
0.0401258655,
-0.0103851603,
-0.0035839484,
0.0111938566,
-0.0281364247,
0.0138436574,
0.0219667777,
0.0146114361,
-0.0377519056,
-0.035973832,
-0.025662683,
-0.0217913091,
-0.0101249814,
0.0136066694,
-0.011390334,
0.0078805527,
0.046805039,
0.0742574781,
0.0000022262,
-0.0214411449,
0.0060666273,
0.0001082775,
-0.0344179943,
0.0164619125,
0.0089376802,
-0.0160236768,
0.0253257286,
0.0168846846,
-0.0301863886,
-0.0216829181,
0.0428337902,
0.0237239376,
0.0477016754,
0.058759436,
0.0024703934,
-0.0321681574,
0.027205402,
-0.0291753821,
0.0124439383,
-0.0176493302,
0.0017945149,
0.0328482538,
-0.0210443307,
-0.0286645237,
-0.0012247586,
0.0416354313,
0.0980277285,
0.014127586,
-0.0334686115,
0.023118319,
-0.0056360974,
-0.0032070247,
-0.0097193699,
0.0397706926,
-0.0566028394,
-0.0411108397,
-0.0255216043,
-0.0192063879,
0.0116554163,
-0.0274895243,
-0.0470864512,
0.0480264537,
0.0149520719,
0.0132293124,
0.0229268614,
0.002850485,
0.0460630544,
0.0124599542,
-0.0455015749,
0.0669274405,
0.0043614204,
-0.0087214187,
-0.0159616489,
-0.0165130366,
-0.0355166234,
-0.0253507011,
0.035244979,
0.0817393139,
-0.0074004615,
0.034107741,
-0.0067053461,
-0.0206958558,
0.0015168618,
-0.0693826675,
0.062342871,
0.092275247,
-0.010386752,
0.0347309113,
-0.0905120075,
0.053883642,
-0.0076520573,
0.0748202503,
-0.0413127802,
-0.0012826836,
-0.0301567446,
-0.0333410166,
-0.0474061407,
0.0293832272,
-0.0464149714,
-0.010131944,
-0.0177125037,
0.0354391001,
-0.0091917589,
0.0230997521,
0.009281015,
-0.0028075473,
-0.022348525,
-0.0246839691,
-0.0199790429,
-0.0131291999,
-0.0403106809,
0.0135846697,
0.0060947267,
-0.0339857526,
-0.0347255804,
-0.0397761539,
-0.0233089905,
-0.0130001241,
0.025605185,
0.1149234623,
0.0064017167,
-0.0236680694,
-0.0309339967,
-0.0362038612,
0.0252884515,
-0.0498775877,
0.036922235,
-0.0645006672,
0.0280542802,
-0.003920414,
-0.0302836522,
-0.0330675207,
0.0235613901,
0.0418825597,
0.0110175293,
0.0477692597,
0.0553551875,
-0.0296677146,
-0.0147007955,
-0.0072587715,
-0.0355342664,
0.0475707687,
0.0450153574,
0.0395933576,
-0.0271425359,
0.0039523551,
0.0144818872,
0.030693043,
0.0320051946,
-0.0334319472,
-0.0973048583,
-0.0231895521,
-0.0013229395,
0.0292052478,
0.0160735697,
0.0682917684,
-0.0229990836,
-0.0411461107,
0.039466776,
0.0231217407,
0.0367257297,
0.0414052308,
0.0941195413,
-0.0398426577,
0.0112672811,
-0.0121879419,
-0.1010136306,
0.0314572118,
-0.0454370342,
0.0042099454,
-0.0762079507,
0.0344058014,
-0.0005951962,
-0.0934273377,
0.0137690827,
0.0097642317,
0.029183792,
0.0235066134,
0.0526036508,
0.0272086747,
-0.0145974187,
0.0697769448,
0.0107147181,
-0.023812158,
-0.0068525029,
-0.0425175466,
0.0296583064,
0.0325552598,
0.0597748794,
-0.0408956185,
-0.0123003349,
-0.0134098809,
-0.0337358527,
0.0134760328,
0.0045617945,
0.0119835911,
0.0186627787,
-0.0551010408,
0.0144049609,
-0.0115041826,
0.030148752,
0.0191527475,
0.0101242084,
-0.0078588687,
0.0312887356,
-0.067265287,
-0.0482316762,
0.0565615185,
-0.0073771328,
-0.0536777116,
0.0144073153,
-0.0006677874,
-0.0146935452,
-0.0013854714,
0.0086255576,
0.0332518555,
0.028254319,
-0.0436774455,
-0.0607184023,
-0.0128978323,
-0.0847682208,
-0.0249054115,
0.0556243323,
-0.0317871645,
-0.0185220055,
0.030935714,
-0.0343985409,
-0.0093557527,
0.0584548488,
-0.0690185875,
0.0621979535,
-0.038310755,
0.0126471752,
0.0318703279,
-0.0006108414,
-0.0335709676,
0.0596617684,
-0.0466799103,
0.0105875898,
0.0375059135,
-0.021173913,
-0.0059169508,
0.0395801179,
0.0121125225,
-0.0288226195,
-0.0168155897,
-0.0117173707,
-0.0398385227,
0.0222105496,
-0.0124502322,
-0.0210441723,
-0.0230060648,
0.0093692457,
-0.0277585015,
0.0158863943,
0.0013888598,
0.0174473021,
0.0288824458,
-0.0192374922,
-0.0134455673,
0.0371009037,
-0.0286847129,
-0.0162541866,
0.0443323925,
-0.0069255936,
-0.047434926,
-0.0338956341,
-0.0552657917,
-0.0567557961,
0.0562949665,
0.007518969,
0.065641351,
-0.0310068876,
-0.026655389,
-0.0055945623,
0.0339177251,
-0.0350093246,
-0.0123940594,
0.015460548,
-0.048717428,
-0.0025167402,
0.0545206033,
-0.0239742007,
-0.0021798008,
0.0694845617,
-0.0234572031,
-0.0765676647,
0.034940321,
-0.0116794268,
0.0012377457,
0.0050256909,
-0.0013338892,
-0.0257782396,
0.0852253959,
-0.0255995076,
-0.0246692766,
-0.0375027098,
0.0312222615,
0.0069984095,
-0.0228223708,
-0.0253243018,
-0.0034155152,
-0.0208028238,
0.0117267389,
-0.0275957175,
-0.0486101694,
0.08759287,
-0.0126325553,
-0.0129639534,
-0.0422212631,
-0.0081292167,
-0.0633678958,
0.0902703628,
0.044469364,
0.0016015222,
0.0206888635,
-0.0477566011,
-0.0495717861,
0.0235224441,
0.0014449649,
-0.0204551741,
0.0809024498,
-0.0365304425,
-0.008381201,
-0.0085783228,
0.0076785595,
-0.0524034463,
0.0132602919,
-0.0351278707,
0.0288973935,
0.016832443,
-0.0076465779,
-0.01293597,
-0.0136445817,
0.0172506291,
0.0467326529,
0.0085164187,
-0.0208297204,
-0.0471696183,
-0.0257234797,
0.0001063265,
0.0386425667,
0.0434530936,
-0.0122175002,
-0.0130718332,
0.0213473942,
0.0042719194,
-0.0263917614,
-0.0488003977,
0.0280935094,
0.0260985736,
-0.041254282,
0.020242475,
0.0471067317,
0.0155842835,
-0.129374072,
0.0043268516,
0.0798812956,
0.0590799302,
-0.0289874561,
0.0339333788,
-0.0554366708,
-0.0232184473,
0.0343775675,
0.0560683496,
-0.1097266674,
-0.0298316758,
0.0353683233,
-0.0313851982,
0.0097367857,
-0.0351435095,
-0.0127803637,
-0.0731168017,
0.0002564688,
0.00458975,
-0.0575343966,
-0.0174332466,
-0.0092397407,
-0.0200957321,
0.0009335165,
-0.0050030798,
0.0257201046,
-0.0134393359,
-0.007335728,
-0.0202355888,
-0.0013112067,
0.0336614624,
0.044535283,
-0.0214772001,
0.0196719393,
0.0358819291,
-0.0078396462,
-0.0182394069,
-0.0592822172,
0.0571663193,
0.0088499151,
0.0136768846,
-0.0203530993,
0.0144906482,
0.0166275389,
-0.0128292693,
-0.0109322034,
0.0242486205,
-0.0462944508,
-0.0250917152,
-0.0150954314,
0.1035941839,
0.0044580908,
-0.0332412384,
-0.027754819,
-0.0125529729,
-0.0209471025,
0.043103978,
0.0485030077,
-0.0040120864,
-0.0567289032,
-0.0679117516,
-0.0411454514,
-0.0446772166,
-0.0250402223,
0.003458072,
0.0379562713,
-0.0449719913,
-0.0435400456,
-0.038414482,
0.0499064699,
-0.0009044453,
0.0029565811,
-0.0715586692,
0.0492764339,
-0.0289840363,
-0.0718093291,
0.029610442,
-0.0224119928,
0.0500530042,
0.0026774264,
0.0300248228,
-0.0144850295,
-0.0238646474,
-0.0213363301,
0.0317496285,
-0.065806374,
-0.0344694704,
0.0033738301,
0.0659847334,
0.0139759667,
0.006655803,
-0.0470758677,
-0.0074464832,
0.0200300701,
0.0287978165,
-0.0329427607,
-0.0174372736,
0.0584153607,
-0.0290870741,
0.036915686,
0.0240886565,
-0.0328925662,
0.0444798358,
0.0271292739,
0.0208884515,
-0.0211375561,
0.0239999294,
0.0454745926,
-0.0065846909,
-0.0047205072,
0.0346513093,
0.007967121,
-0.011042037,
0.0509015843,
-0.0389997214,
-0.0072989524,
-0.0478203222,
0.0048009013,
-0.0019140132,
0.0244416315,
-0.0103952279,
-0.0305165537,
0.0362760611,
0.0148413917,
0.0014558531,
0.0305844825,
0.0354666412,
0.0383817069,
0.0218480639,
-0.0123444209,
-0.0316554829,
-0.0044723018,
-0.0270452015,
0.0427327231,
-0.0371186323,
0.0272433423,
0.0177967772,
0.0299135,
-0.0903196335,
-0.0112769697,
-0.0362754501,
-0.0459648632,
-0.0010056777,
-0.0252413899,
0.0382076949,
-0.0063509881,
-0.0180984084,
-0.0427165031,
0.019357115,
0.0092724496,
0.0076488312,
-0.0179860517,
-0.0191440079,
0.0099293888,
0.0399741344,
0.0121779749,
-0.0479875393,
0.0399913155,
-0.0634730905,
0.0648734123,
-0.0153281894,
-0.000700534,
-0.0401237197,
-0.0415029936,
0.0145975593,
0.0105244284,
-0.0168539044,
-0.007168259,
-0.0493292883,
-0.0816781968,
-0.008151046,
0.0734374151,
0.0264478792,
-0.0195182301,
0.0143318977,
0.0237513259,
0.0234555919,
-0.0466912091,
-0.0063706134,
0.0366434827,
0.0193856508,
-0.0426158197,
-0.058073733,
-6.330408095e-33,
-0.0109509053,
-0.0030080518,
0.041343201,
-0.0065401802,
-0.0350424796,
0.0108952429,
-0.0573852733,
0.0025345741,
-0.0002375037,
0.018718252,
-0.0241864529,
0.0420828275,
0.0001268627,
0.0126100108,
0.0488386787,
-0.0267764255,
0.0167780258,
0.002470975,
-0.0060079754,
-0.0075707808,
0.0050078463,
0.0339825116,
0.0396934524,
-0.0294329356,
0.0034832014,
0.0564462207,
0.004136662,
0.006555127,
-0.0533388294,
0.0411653668,
-0.0019898894,
0.0138395261,
0.0151220206,
-0.0236622058,
-0.0304193981,
0.0029237526,
-0.0775680542,
-0.0425110795,
0.0139186056,
0.0158233661,
-0.0400023013,
-0.0470890142,
0.1057769954,
0.0107576475,
0.0180697199,
-0.0263823457,
0.0053417697,
-0.0221708696,
0.0240454748,
-0.0453975759,
-0.0552043319,
0.0096425097,
0.0039979699,
0.0111011313,
-0.0173055362,
0.0142064439,
-0.0170496963,
0.0069455137,
-0.0674892217,
-0.000403212,
0.0078443065,
0.0148680871,
0.0320264623,
0.0122176157,
0.0017953446,
0.0023735422,
0.0105954763,
-0.0488670394,
-0.0619202107,
0.0415470898,
0.0540759526,
0.0422039144,
0.0502046719,
-0.017170934,
0.0966014564,
0.0229575336,
-0.0445815101,
-0.0082519772,
0.0637919977,
0.0750639066,
0.0235749763,
0.0099615837,
-0.0305626951,
-0.0001157006,
-0.0277985819,
0.0229808483,
-0.060850244,
-0.0311238915,
0.0070039365,
0.0009674084,
-0.0066346563,
-0.0220467951,
0.0012437942,
-0.050803408,
0.0118350964,
0.0159611739,
0.0299466141,
0.0344705619,
0.0226430148,
0.0237351675,
-0.0379616804,
0.0045922347,
0.0049902578,
-0.0224234574,
0.0336037017,
0.0342238359,
0.0294754058,
0.0552991182,
-0.0339734852,
-0.0231595933,
-0.0472570769,
-0.0201993547,
0.0206395593,
0.0395180956,
0.0299342126,
0.0310361832,
-0.0325630605,
-0.027517138,
-0.047696311,
0.0040922025,
-0.0312876627,
0.0594962575,
0.034511026,
0.0514572933,
-0.0345398262,
-0.043522235,
-0.045777835,
0.0179872513,
0.0668099746,
-0.0761188045,
-0.0052175098,
0.0400492214,
3e-7,
0.0605996735,
0.0290189721,
0.0347109213,
0.085073866,
0.0077966433,
0.0094339522,
0.0051881587,
0.0127650583,
0.0221053362,
-0.01143975,
0.0153017659,
0.0405723415,
0.0060206875,
0.0148726515,
-0.0507888272,
-0.0222273972,
0.0043394747,
-0.0138310986,
0.0010394091,
0.007878799,
0.0363074131,
0.1237154752,
0.0177165121,
0.002819991,
0.0110639771,
-0.0217216015,
0.0138363056,
0.0092185093,
0.0200684648,
-0.0207715053,
0.0368334427,
0.0172726177,
0.0077691097,
-0.0096606482,
0.0143317198,
0.0353495516,
-0.015237621,
0.0689494014,
0.0079146139,
0.0018516573,
-0.0305285119,
-0.0466269255,
-0.0060604508,
-0.0177066382,
0.0529331975,
-0.0934074819,
-0.0125911506,
0.0116904667,
0.0157747678,
0.0146131618,
-0.0172388833,
0.0231077056,
0.0112842321,
0.0192670543,
0.0228364896,
-0.019382827,
0.0180867575,
-0.0812474489,
-0.0447052382,
0.0226814952,
-0.0453348309,
-0.0070130392,
-0.0635295585,
-0.02352909,
0.01537403,
-0.0375166349,
-0.0237502623,
3.153691779e-34,
0.0382784866,
-0.0246313065,
0.0201230571,
0.0531657338,
0.0449707843,
-0.0151330987,
-0.0365866609,
0.0317523293,
0.0404189304,
-0.0742889494,
-0.0323534086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01662v1
|
Cross-Domain Image Captioning with Discriminative Finetuning
| 2023-04-04T09:33:16 | 2023-04-04T09:33:16 |
Roberto Dessì, Michele Bevilacqua, Eleonora Gualdoni, Nathanael Carraz Rakotonirina, Francesca Franzon, Marco Baroni
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Neural captioners are typically trained to mimic human-generated references
without optimizing for any specific communication goal, leading to problems
such as the generation of vague captions. In this paper, we show that
fine-tuning an out-of-the-box neural captioner with a self-supervised
discriminative communication objective helps to recover a plain, visually
descriptive language that is more informative about image contents. Given a
target image, the system must learn to produce a description that enables an
out-of-the-box text-conditioned image retriever to identify such image among a
set of candidates. We experiment with the popular ClipCap captioner, also
replicating the main results with BLIP. In terms of similarity to ground-truth
human descriptions, the captions emerging from discriminative finetuning lag
slightly behind those generated by the non-finetuned model, when the latter is
trained and tested on the same caption dataset. However, when the model is used
without further tuning to generate captions for out-of-domain datasets, our
discriminatively-finetuned captioner generates descriptions that resemble human
references more than those produced by the same captioner without finetuning.
We further show that, on the Conceptual Captions dataset, discriminatively
finetuned captions are more helpful than either vanilla ClipCap captions or
ground-truth captions for human annotators tasked with an image discrimination
task.
|
[
0.0400613993,
0.0278228577,
-0.0010340181,
0.0384659171,
0.0089595253,
0.0109686935,
-0.0016130493,
-0.0052366019,
-0.0146939512,
-0.0896207765,
-0.0588076673,
0.0230221637,
-0.0082787517,
0.0300490055,
0.0110313417,
-0.0396833867,
0.0203840975,
-0.0136063248,
0.0135517316,
0.0118066175,
0.0289179385,
0.000379107,
0.0104604671,
0.0364810973,
-0.0223582871,
0.009582974,
0.017615322,
0.0044307495,
-0.0159920491,
-0.0066498877,
0.0305672325,
0.0780255273,
0.0533686429,
-0.0195777006,
0.0000016059,
0.0022254912,
0.0208340213,
-0.0008218921,
0.012674869,
-0.01045343,
0.0591304973,
-0.038562499,
0.0192830861,
-0.0353573076,
-0.0321098082,
-0.0111875031,
0.0693672448,
0.0733322278,
0.0505459607,
0.0064881509,
-0.021770874,
-0.0457298607,
-0.0339623876,
-0.0535130911,
-0.0140485819,
-0.0376871452,
-0.0197927039,
0.0412689038,
0.0021939741,
0.0004903451,
-0.0258608591,
0.0393281169,
-0.0398823544,
0.0187063292,
0.020056244,
0.0547114797,
-0.0345751345,
-0.0269787684,
-0.0008288273,
0.0963533223,
0.0419958159,
-0.0013464276,
-0.0200859606,
0.0074367612,
0.0201036055,
-0.0070226328,
-0.0103049623,
0.0387805961,
-0.0059221578,
0.0097415512,
-0.0563295856,
0.0482648462,
-0.013863774,
0.0100924801,
0.0298022032,
-0.0240197703,
-0.0096280063,
0.0251430701,
-0.0308927819,
0.0121238586,
-0.0335598253,
-0.0373296961,
-0.0118510081,
-0.0165549237,
0.0055206781,
-0.0208647568,
-0.0566532537,
-0.0293410439,
0.0063235289,
-0.0082008587,
0.0318655036,
-0.0016268108,
-0.0702031106,
0.0600964054,
-0.0146731799,
0.0478456058,
-0.011728242,
0.0289643705,
-0.0260686632,
0.0095796864,
-0.0685632229,
-0.0083601503,
-0.0332113765,
0.0427272357,
-0.0184400082,
-0.0420026295,
-0.0386849903,
-0.0159940533,
-0.0504985265,
-0.0083125122,
-0.0353991874,
0.0461457707,
-0.0521749072,
0.018352434,
-0.0661154017,
0.011303748,
-0.0298117213,
-0.0034911479,
-0.0062583657,
-0.0585962422,
-0.0232391991,
0.0446651317,
0.034891367,
-0.0201920904,
-0.0171255972,
0.0659029558,
-0.0363139249,
-0.0331083313,
-0.0095810536,
-0.0416770056,
-0.0502830222,
-0.0429114364,
0.0354063511,
-0.0283621382,
0.0294703413,
0.0006091634,
-0.0096508665,
-0.1040333956,
0.0018293376,
0.003563982,
0.0033777519,
0.1313635856,
-0.0324334316,
-0.0241996013,
-0.0030644073,
0.0177529771,
-0.022075247,
0.0703727677,
0.0009920304,
0.055267062,
0.0235827807,
0.0138649717,
0.0508922301,
0.0081425011,
0.0295117218,
0.011624407,
-0.0272639971,
0.0090450179,
-0.0096394653,
0.0336186476,
0.095279254,
0.033342924,
-0.0300266054,
0.0093589071,
0.0672021732,
0.0338157825,
-0.0322594456,
0.0340622403,
0.0573298782,
0.0566582531,
-0.0311521925,
0.0434697606,
-0.0755037814,
0.080860801,
0.0572267473,
0.0104651097,
0.0160632152,
-0.011404505,
-0.0350238793,
-0.0216076989,
0.018644724,
-0.0356346294,
0.0085422378,
-0.0114628151,
0.0058964686,
0.027822163,
-0.0143033536,
0.0925160423,
0.0222051945,
-0.0086730616,
-0.0215042364,
-0.0496160015,
-0.0006455322,
0.0307657737,
0.007713032,
0.0125173507,
-0.0202286541,
-0.020563785,
0.0674626678,
0.0653260946,
0.0631739348,
0.0139667084,
-0.003125615,
-0.0245174598,
-0.0496672615,
-0.0736218169,
0.0335525461,
0.037048161,
-0.0032982694,
-0.0173993576,
0.0648677424,
0.0020264578,
-0.0746611729,
0.04073916,
0.0651135072,
-0.0527368374,
-0.0062435046,
0.0298905969,
0.0017142523,
-0.0053436505,
-0.0341630839,
0.001912964,
-0.0203811899,
0.0148660522,
-0.0229982845,
0.0466726199,
-0.0410855785,
-0.014821562,
0.0185637847,
-0.0746212676,
-0.0113421651,
0.0026321816,
-0.0201335866,
-0.0165369231,
0.0370593034,
-0.041798763,
-0.0391885415,
-0.1004792973,
-0.00734059,
-0.0014888245,
0.0266295355,
0.0331547223,
0.062496502,
0.0283742175,
-0.0310877413,
0.0330044627,
-0.0285481066,
0.0250644274,
-0.0430399068,
-0.0210603122,
-0.0354382358,
-0.0000715902,
0.025524646,
0.0162279718,
0.0272985436,
-0.0453216694,
0.0041292817,
-0.0358071327,
-0.0340816155,
-0.0180392843,
-0.0328712687,
0.0112352381,
-0.0019941088,
0.0294268355,
-0.0398736037,
-0.0372090973,
-0.0120008783,
-0.0170089118,
0.0346902683,
0.0694966093,
0.0442641675,
-0.0108839627,
-0.020810049,
0.0346060544,
0.0383744575,
0.0255724229,
0.0141491136,
-0.0266795121,
-0.0543310083,
0.0205202214,
-0.0241898987,
0.0328648128,
-0.0105265733,
-0.0294749085,
-0.0000549242,
0.01976786,
-0.0427914523,
0.0417077988,
0.010575166,
0.0063068201,
0.0246218443,
0.0229624454,
-0.0429216847,
0.0177375935,
0.005558819,
-0.0694684684,
0.0315024033,
-0.0123982932,
0.0085035823,
0.0206838641,
-0.0509872101,
0.0286026858,
-0.0638357475,
0.053859178,
-0.0010901558,
-0.0453391336,
-0.0488752984,
0.0198972411,
0.0111949909,
0.0213439669,
-0.0327869542,
-0.0478261597,
0.0662893578,
-0.0459553897,
-0.0330632888,
0.0027880694,
-0.0054695196,
-0.0232357886,
0.0341447145,
-0.0241850354,
0.0284251105,
0.0587725714,
-0.0127047934,
-0.0140792206,
-0.0319695547,
0.0268820338,
-0.0048008077,
0.0717717037,
-0.034683872,
0.0102546513,
-0.0282587856,
-0.0783564448,
-0.0305877812,
-0.0378797576,
-0.0423034057,
0.0026843599,
-0.0364717618,
-0.0070160767,
-0.0315622017,
0.0531888232,
0.0144993635,
0.0400020704,
-0.0345636122,
-0.0100956941,
-0.012514622,
0.0161494892,
0.0581041574,
0.0504620112,
-0.0550337955,
-0.0013224839,
-0.003889614,
0.0043933438,
-0.0480191857,
0.0094978968,
-0.0426155664,
0.0043500173,
-0.0081923688,
0.0246397853,
0.0095481547,
0.038335409,
0.0624221042,
-0.0341965221,
-0.0516098626,
0.0837861747,
-0.0374624506,
-0.0510250963,
-0.031482324,
0.0229096636,
0.0126693742,
0.0392252728,
0.0023214892,
-0.0424621552,
-0.0755074024,
-0.0376187861,
0.0228385627,
0.0408047698,
0.0422537625,
-0.0590814427,
-0.0729665011,
0.0289492961,
0.0105360672,
-0.0509931594,
-0.0610943995,
0.0207640175,
-0.0012837549,
-0.0046873852,
-0.0095818732,
-0.0382722653,
-0.0043928684,
0.0289909877,
-0.0056170789,
0.0127704851,
-0.0595347285,
0.0155979125,
-0.0649374872,
0.0121596828,
0.0775477439,
0.0348136686,
0.0064185862,
-0.0298616458,
-0.006755068,
-0.0530484766,
0.0309991688,
0.0143054686,
0.0972767398,
-0.0323012061,
-0.0290596429,
0.0304868817,
0.0400714427,
-0.022546893,
0.015213252,
-0.0259687006,
-0.0154512255,
0.0021839016,
-0.0031921524,
-0.0380250029,
0.0565780178,
0.0211305451,
0.0584271625,
0.0575617142,
0.0056431154,
-0.0162262395,
-0.0034988185,
0.0042783148,
-0.0735026225,
-0.0183224045,
0.0072142272,
-0.0193395466,
-0.0194148365,
-0.0572088622,
-0.0413700975,
0.016020434,
-0.0036866567,
0.0355315357,
-0.0067625013,
-0.0064604497,
0.0315424204,
-0.0487549752,
0.0550894365,
-0.0776716545,
0.0075389659,
-0.0045527755,
-0.0237659384,
0.0989666358,
-0.0333112553,
-0.0210331026,
0.049285233,
-0.0435676761,
-0.0103448369,
-0.0493866801,
0.0492055528,
0.0132107222,
0.0541285947,
-0.0032849181,
-0.0372923799,
-0.0095273666,
0.080379948,
-0.0132262083,
0.0004129499,
0.0052018957,
-0.0210970789,
-0.040394295,
0.0312143434,
-0.0399901085,
0.0497610532,
-0.0002878026,
-0.0187875219,
0.0167905055,
-0.0493663661,
0.0277778599,
0.0106042074,
0.0358693451,
-0.0324110426,
0.0444922149,
-0.0070838006,
-0.0310882702,
0.0230950993,
-0.0063900421,
-0.0421114527,
0.0117529919,
-0.0064680441,
0.037172202,
0.0096289273,
-0.0136946533,
-0.0061338423,
0.0500439219,
-0.019011654,
-0.0213757381,
0.0382296443,
-0.031367451,
-0.0364693701,
0.0024752384,
-0.0098430794,
0.0330215506,
0.0145137655,
0.0558937229,
-0.0275467932,
0.0521664768,
0.0384549722,
0.0035619871,
-0.0337251872,
0.0537033491,
-0.0004287626,
0.0024715159,
-0.0619033799,
0.0178953242,
0.0655275732,
-0.0192995165,
0.0050568655,
-0.0041616419,
-0.013959025,
0.0219232067,
0.0146837989,
-0.0311416965,
-0.0173285492,
0.0513628237,
0.0168750174,
-0.0071385251,
-0.002976042,
0.0546256043,
0.0097389882,
0.040169403,
-0.0135543924,
-0.0179137699,
-0.0485550314,
-0.0182691254,
-0.0423641801,
-0.0047498872,
0.0039952756,
0.0251667276,
-0.0153748179,
-0.0702662766,
0.024865903,
-0.0053482414,
0.0222908091,
0.0162583906,
0.0766684711,
0.0342524573,
0.0103582526,
-0.0210461505,
-0.0064095571,
-0.0244176667,
0.0089792134,
0.0389705561,
-0.0659002736,
-5.344932038e-33,
-0.0516304672,
-0.0353563838,
0.0118372589,
0.0024191758,
-0.0223642029,
-0.0137401624,
-0.0561478771,
-0.0088991337,
-0.0118127242,
0.0320366174,
0.0062181256,
-0.0030365756,
0.0226027779,
0.0132115902,
0.0030990774,
-0.0168715511,
0.079854846,
-0.0132113686,
-0.0334027782,
0.0121489167,
0.0379007272,
-0.0199563708,
-0.001209393,
-0.0726303011,
0.0181949921,
-0.0145666786,
-0.0292244796,
0.0271637663,
0.0654045492,
0.0458533466,
-0.0215731598,
0.020469306,
0.0195644088,
-0.001921405,
-0.0250963066,
-0.011588566,
-0.0970790461,
0.0081235869,
0.0328539237,
0.0143902525,
0.0113827148,
-0.0296204351,
0.0294631422,
-0.0539592914,
-0.044213824,
-0.0058078077,
0.0610425584,
-0.0258051772,
0.0117916809,
-0.022362113,
-0.0365358219,
-0.0050572339,
0.0036113977,
-0.0455227382,
0.0803348124,
0.0246594679,
0.0178472288,
0.0245021805,
-0.0381219275,
0.0465820357,
-0.0036625729,
0.0196834318,
0.0800873488,
0.0253192764,
-0.0084712747,
0.0528027155,
0.0231879409,
0.0008466624,
-0.0162099861,
-0.0313440375,
-0.0012172261,
0.055593688,
0.0401518717,
0.0838092789,
0.054699719,
-0.0232408047,
0.0121947471,
0.0255303103,
-0.0925000682,
0.0128535889,
0.0220475756,
0.0017718421,
-0.023430435,
0.0009227316,
-0.0565857477,
0.0052503296,
-0.0565447435,
-0.0250578467,
0.0313576423,
0.0248974357,
-0.0164682064,
0.054150641,
0.0424017236,
-0.0388775803,
0.0231703445,
-0.022132365,
0.0056593362,
0.0041584023,
-0.012199576,
-0.049413383,
0.0129943602,
-0.0566150695,
0.0540951937,
0.0355689675,
0.026983086,
0.02758421,
0.0950781032,
-0.0059295362,
-0.0231023785,
0.0020063317,
-0.0319735557,
0.0098824939,
-0.0377760231,
-0.000408635,
-0.0008606747,
0.0304554626,
-0.0872851014,
-0.0135099888,
0.0042312224,
-0.0029658941,
-0.0154677806,
-0.0148053803,
0.0057699634,
0.0280269645,
-0.0343743041,
0.0014449818,
-0.0196701605,
-0.0080033401,
0.0025894032,
-0.0548384897,
-0.0274735056,
0.0145250354,
2.384e-7,
-0.0187626965,
0.0071896375,
0.0462538488,
0.0174879301,
0.0326755308,
0.059636008,
-0.018234143,
0.0116150901,
0.0144581217,
-0.0374325477,
0.0334296748,
0.0174069479,
0.0341216587,
-0.0294530727,
-0.0641078278,
0.0121339969,
-0.0170573425,
0.0045724702,
-0.0070174015,
-0.051037807,
0.0207517054,
0.0642074123,
-0.0093236538,
-0.0084192604,
0.0216900986,
-0.0945245177,
0.072060369,
-0.0229096599,
0.0315264724,
0.0039807102,
0.0161571652,
0.0458691828,
-0.0549723171,
0.0537023768,
-0.0145564992,
-0.0046765413,
0.0519043915,
0.0318596996,
-0.0096214665,
0.0035298853,
-0.0487468429,
0.0419025682,
0.0131358337,
0.0013451471,
0.0399600081,
-0.1225699931,
-0.0246724412,
-0.0311076436,
-0.0060541974,
-0.0059715747,
0.0105561027,
-0.0136541873,
-0.0452762544,
0.0289452914,
0.0292802267,
0.0238961298,
-0.0375737436,
-0.0792173818,
-0.014980698,
0.0081733903,
-0.0203001648,
-0.0049516801,
-0.0634945631,
-0.0129369618,
0.0590479895,
-0.0298349429,
0.0169178899,
1.277766148e-34,
0.047461208,
0.0079426505,
-0.0042052497,
-0.0061905384,
0.0267618578,
0.0023823353,
0.0023062492,
-0.0152442679,
0.0109490249,
-0.0341030285,
-0.0048603285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01638v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01638v1
|
Multidimensional Perceptron for Efficient and Explainable Long Text Classification
| 2023-04-04T08:49:39 | 2023-04-04T08:49:39 |
Yexiang Wang, Yating Zhang, Xiaozhong Liu, Changlong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Because of the inevitable cost and complexity of transformer and pre-trained
models, efficiency concerns are raised for long text classification. Meanwhile,
in the highly sensitive domains, e.g., healthcare and legal long-text mining,
potential model distrust, yet underrated and underexplored, may hatch vital
apprehension. Existing methods generally segment the long text, encode each
piece with the pre-trained model, and use attention or RNNs to obtain long text
representation for classification. In this work, we propose a simple but
effective model, Segment-aWare multIdimensional PErceptron (SWIPE), to replace
attention/RNNs in the above framework. Unlike prior efforts, SWIPE can
effectively learn the label of the entire text with supervised training, while
perceive the labels of the segments and estimate their contributions to the
long-text labeling in an unsupervised manner. As a general classifier, SWIPE
can endorse different encoders, and it outperforms SOTA models in terms of
classification accuracy and model efficiency. It is noteworthy that SWIPE
achieves superior interpretability to transparentize long text classification
results.
|
[
-0.016637167,
0.0518870801,
-0.0026948361,
0.0351725668,
-0.0174376667,
0.0018976199,
0.0397326984,
-0.0063983281,
0.0043829819,
-0.0394730121,
-0.0251209307,
-0.0205215793,
-0.0045394558,
0.0535250045,
-0.0105712684,
-0.062574476,
0.0121615976,
0.0207772776,
0.0293252785,
0.0400224067,
0.0215557627,
-0.0159016885,
0.020981025,
0.0165354144,
0.003265783,
-0.0176177621,
-0.0254264921,
-0.0335406996,
-0.0025863997,
-0.0416688062,
-0.001075041,
0.023900751,
0.0275820605,
0.0083894096,
0.0000021121,
0.002610056,
-0.061574731,
0.0027019226,
-0.0216476284,
0.013694278,
0.0483971648,
-0.0977166966,
0.0240324549,
-0.0196339041,
0.0261914693,
-0.0141614219,
0.0244243611,
0.0939406604,
0.0436415486,
0.0751275271,
-0.016642293,
-0.058200337,
0.0357248858,
-0.0472631305,
0.0099052815,
-0.0301767215,
0.0282631069,
-0.0854586363,
-0.0145600736,
0.0250896104,
-0.0596429072,
0.0276211333,
0.0489253961,
0.0019405831,
0.0681744069,
0.0250843782,
0.0235004518,
0.0143832425,
0.0214104839,
0.0834718198,
-0.0381322913,
-0.0047591925,
0.0365059562,
-0.0177582316,
-0.0042999405,
-0.0243059006,
-0.0089778835,
0.0014965234,
0.0181913152,
0.016220117,
-0.0121306097,
0.0692584738,
0.0336890109,
-0.0101588638,
-0.0532941185,
0.0210814755,
-0.0251681432,
-0.053735964,
-0.033453837,
-0.0108974949,
0.0588100404,
-0.0258415099,
0.0457722098,
0.0151787894,
0.0379817486,
0.0266775098,
-0.0379674733,
-0.0642732382,
0.0160387754,
-0.0502908453,
-0.0096970452,
0.0125155924,
-0.0266185831,
0.0334284008,
-0.020919621,
-0.0027016895,
-0.0237012394,
0.0415419564,
-0.0248904601,
-0.0041202134,
-0.0350436009,
-0.0075282501,
-0.0195924267,
0.0161792189,
-0.0239897706,
-0.0342830233,
-0.0571336821,
0.0171758886,
0.0142884664,
-0.0106757032,
-0.0211064704,
0.0312095545,
-0.0014605558,
-0.0240451414,
-0.0026293874,
0.0430612229,
-0.0266255755,
-0.0095695704,
-0.0116399312,
0.0284375679,
-0.0245050322,
0.0710579604,
0.0333375111,
-0.0143586397,
0.0097540561,
0.0742470846,
0.0010695535,
-0.0862409398,
-0.0143048465,
-0.0451263264,
-0.0709186122,
-0.0134086004,
0.0341768973,
-0.0010738986,
0.02977724,
-0.0064577986,
-0.0161799043,
-0.0166605785,
-0.0081700608,
0.01495481,
-0.0315422527,
0.0529413484,
0.0225862004,
-0.0219084285,
0.017913701,
0.0377975665,
0.0407699384,
0.008739952,
0.036002364,
0.0492277816,
0.0204635318,
-0.0362786576,
0.0546471253,
0.0100811571,
0.0542115197,
-0.0273157433,
-0.0174581241,
0.008350323,
-0.0051085101,
0.0326747075,
0.0384304561,
0.0025584258,
-0.0125632444,
-0.0417792238,
0.0276198555,
0.0599261671,
0.0172330271,
0.0619838573,
-0.0133223832,
0.0140698571,
-0.0293902513,
0.0016252523,
-0.0040577445,
0.0374527387,
0.0073347632,
0.003514766,
0.0243725553,
-0.0100003518,
-0.0264862515,
-0.0414351858,
0.002040612,
-0.050632067,
0.0076313172,
-0.0025689518,
0.081201911,
0.0023638231,
-0.0380320065,
0.061365854,
0.005803131,
-0.038659215,
-0.016449023,
-0.0297416337,
0.0178578328,
0.065903537,
0.0111181736,
-0.0606714711,
0.0181437358,
-0.0439692736,
0.0419875383,
0.0298048388,
-0.0101917032,
0.02454127,
0.0146361403,
-0.0566827208,
-0.0292078853,
-0.0141107161,
0.0337267704,
0.0337513983,
-0.0271159038,
-0.0022345099,
0.0264465883,
-0.0344512574,
-0.0157381576,
0.031500604,
0.000049089,
-0.0390809551,
0.0200555064,
0.0365970023,
0.0392397568,
0.0274318978,
0.0314513259,
0.0058541326,
0.0341655016,
-0.051054161,
-0.030357983,
-0.039623186,
-0.055460915,
-0.0322841369,
-0.0410518534,
-0.0049310615,
-0.0007050206,
0.0122451028,
-0.0291959848,
-0.0328300707,
0.0288426969,
-0.0435906947,
-0.0010147257,
-0.003892835,
-0.0194210093,
0.0425985716,
0.0398239009,
-0.0356203653,
0.0412399359,
-0.0282651316,
0.0114396969,
-0.0177411158,
-0.0527478419,
0.0327116586,
0.006600088,
-0.0138811395,
0.0068942881,
-0.0256816316,
-0.0079794554,
-0.0082091885,
-0.0320735425,
-0.006728658,
-0.0163037069,
-0.0447707251,
-0.0177057907,
-0.0218436643,
0.006881767,
-0.0079162447,
0.0009605216,
0.0097898487,
-0.0353021771,
-0.0504388846,
-0.0246301424,
0.0150860604,
-0.0031727499,
0.0304256752,
-0.0190499034,
-0.0122818053,
0.0001002703,
-0.0388928875,
-0.0288964044,
0.0882846862,
-0.0014765916,
-0.0612071566,
-0.0290139001,
-0.055198811,
0.0355973244,
-0.0080133695,
-0.0114193587,
-0.0472707897,
-0.0309034586,
-0.0111119719,
-0.0243869051,
0.0746852458,
0.0205838867,
0.0454028137,
0.0090383608,
0.0126208942,
0.0190406032,
0.0205310415,
-0.0583282486,
0.0826206505,
-0.0200646389,
-0.0027954427,
0.0400716215,
0.0606062226,
0.0089444118,
-0.0062477738,
-0.0168688092,
-0.0291746184,
0.0035862222,
0.0250181165,
0.0056929202,
-0.0242967866,
-0.0006703098,
0.0184381641,
0.0084891589,
-0.0553724915,
0.0561128333,
-0.0274889246,
0.0015232567,
-0.0448118597,
-0.0297118742,
-0.0532910079,
0.0661485866,
0.0081525864,
0.0194323435,
-0.0115983132,
-0.0220624022,
0.0525596403,
0.0038768977,
-0.0421360843,
0.0211428236,
0.0552313961,
0.01933017,
0.0178436413,
-0.0107356906,
-0.036125809,
-0.0094604492,
-0.0548030213,
-0.0113703618,
0.0019495036,
0.0228274539,
-0.0154785682,
-0.0485224314,
0.0330668613,
0.0353775844,
0.0750243291,
-0.0140125025,
-0.0110697169,
-0.0034929269,
0.037419457,
-0.0178244188,
-0.0283308439,
-0.0122487424,
-0.0455746464,
0.0183950365,
0.0657470599,
-0.0104385205,
-0.0104476186,
-0.0249402151,
-0.0190480538,
0.0036624039,
-0.0479864143,
-0.0093003837,
0.0020814694,
0.0245295465,
-0.119192943,
0.0153718283,
0.0810701251,
0.013041174,
-0.0626545921,
0.0200865958,
0.0399084799,
-0.0416287109,
-0.0240785982,
0.0030232235,
-0.0312585905,
-0.0540463589,
-0.0156063288,
0.0250841621,
0.0165933855,
-0.0256360807,
-0.0018311183,
-0.0135085648,
0.0287509784,
-0.0095394207,
-0.063455686,
-0.0124824271,
-0.0575358793,
-0.026641937,
-0.0045328704,
-0.056223616,
-0.0191615447,
0.011890484,
-0.0237402711,
-0.0035557405,
-0.0684657246,
0.0015601565,
0.0170143526,
0.0024031664,
-0.0230583362,
0.0798686519,
0.0416489691,
-0.021059826,
-0.0758875012,
0.0379878469,
-0.033966165,
0.0109324995,
0.0233281683,
0.0940535367,
-0.0326478183,
0.0112262443,
-0.0156846847,
0.0477425121,
-0.0536840223,
-0.0248150136,
0.000044707,
0.1055138409,
-0.0297875255,
-0.0083266618,
-0.0444555059,
-0.025009647,
-0.0007798809,
0.0633333623,
0.0130009688,
-0.0414118245,
-0.0578868762,
-0.0181856975,
0.0026055176,
-0.0297857989,
-0.0037199876,
-0.0007608956,
-0.0030784749,
-0.0589504167,
-0.0214235075,
-0.0517186075,
-0.0053598774,
0.0578849502,
-0.0037722604,
-0.0014553078,
0.0204688329,
-0.0138752777,
-0.0385932177,
0.0316176414,
-0.0185347013,
-0.0084851161,
-0.0330000967,
0.0027359282,
0.0366494432,
-0.0207024701,
-0.0073010828,
0.0055043981,
-0.0382846221,
0.0046231393,
-0.00561703,
-0.0074898247,
0.0158126745,
0.0390814766,
-0.0102125034,
-0.0344057977,
0.0639241487,
0.0181630645,
-0.0677458942,
-0.0362129882,
0.055993814,
-0.0116704572,
-0.0181505531,
0.0059540621,
0.0091659715,
0.0453013852,
0.0124992933,
-0.061749313,
-0.0358422063,
-0.0256930217,
-0.0337865762,
-0.0270943083,
0.0608041845,
0.0241118707,
-0.0000737923,
-0.026609065,
0.0231130458,
-0.0182416439,
0.0131190177,
-0.0226543117,
0.0192492567,
0.0328550041,
-0.0072444929,
-0.0118200546,
0.020583529,
0.0250748582,
-0.0508516878,
-0.0200418811,
0.0266985781,
-0.0247867499,
-0.0194474049,
-0.0137604373,
0.0050102845,
-0.0241852831,
-0.035547249,
0.0010220256,
0.025719298,
-0.0129192453,
0.0636519715,
0.0280883107,
0.0134730423,
-0.042789977,
0.0285276398,
-0.0763036683,
-0.0086005433,
-0.0237007551,
-0.0031076828,
-0.00338827,
-0.0164349843,
0.0030010494,
-0.0142785879,
-0.000688891,
-0.0070358454,
0.0671352595,
0.0114118485,
-0.0457221493,
0.0091812154,
0.0047506648,
-0.0415001921,
-0.0362104513,
0.0595253743,
0.0268988628,
0.0023148898,
0.0071666976,
-0.0512075461,
-0.0627588406,
-0.0071060932,
0.0237210728,
0.0574532039,
-0.0212844741,
-0.0082215657,
-0.0255000517,
-0.0133917155,
0.0747854859,
-0.0524716377,
0.0051884726,
-0.0229097866,
0.0102022616,
0.0598247908,
0.0196284503,
-0.0160424262,
-0.0247290879,
0.0040908172,
0.001543034,
-0.010924397,
0.0307719652,
-6.131584613e-33,
0.0479703695,
-0.0513685681,
-0.0009637265,
-0.0372303538,
-0.0282411594,
0.0339287147,
-0.0284636598,
-0.0380171835,
0.0552552231,
-0.0057692928,
0.0111339604,
0.0029937346,
-0.000099522,
0.0671297759,
0.0130970338,
-0.0442093797,
0.0389423668,
0.0138731841,
-0.0158761349,
0.0494120046,
0.0333444178,
0.056437891,
0.0372313559,
-0.062351048,
0.0381291732,
0.0158770215,
-0.0158794746,
-0.0131084211,
-0.0156648271,
0.0445919968,
-0.0396893844,
-0.004853026,
0.0533430539,
-0.0820607543,
-0.0062785968,
0.0792419389,
-0.0557091162,
0.0010606868,
-0.0490429252,
0.0099229207,
-0.0405832268,
-0.035830535,
0.073607631,
0.0192955099,
0.0363047197,
-0.0252878908,
0.0591562763,
-0.0357305892,
-0.0269904174,
-0.0318218023,
-0.0236811768,
0.0671064183,
-0.0278360229,
-0.0057632872,
0.042583324,
0.0453540534,
0.0071771895,
0.0832011029,
-0.1061229631,
-0.0310621839,
0.0194154661,
0.0189967602,
0.0154036256,
0.0014664299,
-0.0123385256,
0.0473045893,
0.0651935041,
-0.0012887657,
-0.0333343223,
0.0088252779,
-0.0273850318,
0.0139049347,
0.0692529678,
0.0236464217,
0.0431419574,
-0.0279286634,
-0.0917833894,
0.0035914136,
-0.0481793806,
-0.0157918073,
0.0470057763,
0.0022471142,
-0.0580323674,
-0.0115815382,
0.024331864,
-0.0274365805,
-0.0093664983,
0.0010681461,
0.0091791386,
0.0300030671,
0.0068299142,
0.0504497774,
0.0134654352,
-0.0123702316,
-0.0044709346,
0.0141139505,
0.0073351553,
0.0296929963,
0.0063925157,
-0.0335937738,
-0.042940367,
0.0046384758,
-0.011414052,
-0.0292745326,
0.0138906175,
-0.0098438393,
0.0814524665,
-0.0028824189,
-0.0579255037,
-0.0245128144,
0.0042854026,
-0.0226157065,
0.0133097861,
0.0920310616,
0.0346148871,
0.0167549271,
-0.0151180131,
0.113172397,
-0.0088257808,
0.0222065262,
-0.0166073609,
-0.030586239,
0.0210720897,
0.0187369641,
-0.0127119208,
-0.0319509059,
-0.0014298792,
0.0047025285,
0.0032976172,
-0.08448302,
0.0192161873,
0.0125955874,
2.806e-7,
0.0506600328,
0.0329396874,
0.0364550836,
-0.0638652891,
0.0410886481,
0.0572731309,
0.0363042466,
0.0399883986,
-0.0618847609,
0.0170474499,
0.0427768491,
-0.0131464703,
0.0557471365,
0.0015373467,
-0.1108620986,
-0.0210764334,
-0.0324130319,
-0.0001645897,
-0.0501985922,
0.0252225026,
0.0976994857,
0.0981652215,
0.0208280776,
0.0050596469,
0.0214827769,
-0.0004732531,
0.0433566645,
-0.0002297238,
0.0269309171,
0.0086030541,
0.0555680469,
-0.030199077,
-0.0383997113,
0.0022197,
-0.0132259754,
0.0250011776,
-0.0193649214,
0.0998908728,
0.0134140309,
-0.0108294217,
0.0483771227,
-0.011637032,
-0.0026184265,
-0.0181196313,
0.0657085329,
-0.0422960743,
-0.0440751091,
0.017203223,
0.0105351042,
-0.0150197893,
0.0445271805,
0.0225714818,
0.0192015525,
0.0169576649,
-0.0239249617,
-0.0494854748,
0.0314794257,
-0.1089761555,
0.0010082589,
0.0079777753,
-0.0394356176,
0.0379847474,
-0.063096717,
-0.0026591772,
0.1047905162,
-0.0670853481,
-0.0077025909,
2.660340473e-34,
0.0178035498,
-0.0146157676,
-0.049531009,
-0.0117964931,
0.0101710884,
-0.0416050777,
0.0682902932,
-0.0306664668,
0.0185515955,
-0.0713023245,
-0.0091755046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01622v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01622v2
|
An interpretability framework for Similar case matching
| 2023-04-04T08:25:12 | 2023-08-16T11:58:38 |
Nankai Lin, Haonan Liu, Jiajun Fang, Dong Zhou, Aimin Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Similar Case Matching (SCM) plays a pivotal role in the legal system by
facilitating the efficient identification of similar cases for legal
professionals. While previous research has primarily concentrated on enhancing
the performance of SCM models, the aspect of interpretability has been
neglected. To bridge the gap, this study proposes an integrated pipeline
framework for interpretable SCM. The framework comprises four modules: judicial
feature sentence identification, case matching, feature sentence alignment, and
conflict resolution. In contrast to current SCM methods, our framework first
extracts feature sentences within a legal case that contain essential
information. Then it conducts case matching based on these extracted features.
Subsequently, our framework aligns the corresponding sentences in two legal
cases to provide evidence of similarity. In instances where the results of case
matching and feature sentence alignment exhibit conflicts, the conflict
resolution module resolves these inconsistencies. The experimental results show
the effectiveness of our proposed framework, establishing a new benchmark for
interpretable SCM.
|
[
0.0615950227,
0.0115313884,
-0.0443556234,
0.0323694982,
-0.1048552692,
0.0396844074,
-0.0133725703,
0.0056270226,
-0.0200059619,
-0.034921024,
0.0094932858,
0.0265228488,
0.0132943215,
0.023809921,
-0.0508035608,
-0.0482030921,
0.037754789,
0.042698767,
0.046495188,
0.0529168919,
0.0575493313,
0.0284926854,
0.0184117742,
0.0402069055,
-0.0009214525,
-0.0172298066,
0.0012880146,
0.0253787041,
0.0190195572,
0.0216461774,
-0.0259040743,
0.0506836325,
-0.0024588928,
0.0329633132,
0.0000015933,
-0.0764231011,
-0.0329057164,
-0.0342784226,
-0.0096547352,
-0.0146059804,
-0.0001217087,
-0.0222465619,
-0.00443458,
-0.0160308331,
0.0017488888,
0.0247032959,
-0.0020143243,
0.0340446606,
0.0536682792,
0.0331437849,
-0.0229083337,
-0.0442305021,
0.0242766086,
0.0169969071,
-0.0226666816,
-0.0309066381,
0.0000677256,
0.0149108041,
0.0420389287,
-0.0415284969,
0.0343114957,
0.0175437834,
-0.0103243776,
-0.0017934219,
-0.0353230424,
-0.0269013047,
-0.0283323601,
0.0387457721,
0.0260679517,
0.0500283577,
0.0387323387,
-0.0616809316,
0.0310225245,
-0.0130180484,
0.0289277006,
0.033512488,
-0.013584598,
0.0374164619,
-0.0394500419,
0.0425174087,
0.0219698139,
0.041416727,
-0.0226106737,
-0.0246098638,
-0.0164909456,
0.0262734853,
0.0023059868,
-0.0293800719,
-0.0423744209,
0.0172502007,
0.028452564,
-0.045959495,
0.0782075375,
0.0173810367,
-0.0238750521,
0.0046099275,
-0.063996397,
-0.0319357999,
0.0727196783,
-0.049862612,
0.0214839466,
0.0114874244,
-0.0333254822,
0.0728896558,
-0.0286056101,
0.0375768393,
-0.0052283094,
-0.0203341898,
-0.0364233702,
-0.046350643,
-0.0864905342,
-0.0231916271,
-0.0161218271,
0.0192952473,
-0.0522494242,
-0.0037862372,
0.0149086453,
-0.0022806139,
-0.0277340189,
0.0456846207,
-0.0122602014,
-0.0463453159,
-0.000250052,
-0.0210258309,
-0.0547081344,
-0.042373769,
-0.0658390149,
0.0309353918,
-0.0567545146,
-0.002596094,
0.0116388537,
0.0035332956,
0.0275774039,
-0.023409076,
-0.0221682452,
0.0633873865,
-0.0107805375,
-0.0098604122,
-0.0291570853,
-0.0944622457,
-0.0182302985,
-0.0338393077,
-0.059428785,
-0.0540772118,
0.0415344909,
0.0026612312,
-0.0219892804,
-0.0457818024,
-0.0042672832,
0.013079985,
-0.0251767077,
0.0213237554,
0.016890103,
0.0217606202,
-0.0409296229,
0.0041212644,
0.0326682292,
-0.0432434157,
0.0011573285,
0.0042670509,
0.026892392,
-0.0003215417,
0.029220596,
0.0260944832,
-0.0015383824,
-0.0053040837,
0.0085763521,
0.0376341194,
0.0263003949,
0.0575607046,
0.0556283072,
0.0194711313,
-0.0037164912,
-0.0362239927,
0.0318978094,
0.0575833619,
0.0424008593,
0.0379345715,
0.0030297341,
0.020311011,
0.011443736,
0.0475143977,
-0.0290814433,
-0.0113760438,
-0.0121603189,
0.0059060766,
-0.0800649822,
0.0204067174,
-0.037663497,
-0.024348272,
0.0122232847,
0.024083646,
-0.004113242,
-0.0113904336,
0.0052778479,
0.0029650724,
0.0051300894,
0.0447546728,
-0.0085629597,
-0.0270875636,
-0.0480564348,
-0.0199296884,
-0.0235625096,
0.04885865,
0.0491572842,
-0.0124246916,
-0.0125406682,
0.0197962634,
-0.0292363036,
0.0125514548,
0.034617167,
0.0089887446,
0.0014261713,
-0.0189524926,
-0.050279431,
0.0293150395,
-0.0103697535,
0.009946065,
-0.0117759733,
-0.0012312698,
0.0392039455,
-0.0319960043,
-0.0119964611,
0.0224719141,
-0.0105614057,
-0.0051847007,
-0.0012664712,
0.0280554518,
0.0332350247,
0.0173435304,
0.0244940538,
-0.0028774121,
-0.0033284123,
-0.0185828898,
0.0192801654,
0.0761106685,
-0.0125666335,
0.0101009505,
0.0261035431,
-0.0496652909,
-0.0521854311,
-0.0156383161,
-0.0471665077,
-0.0238991864,
-0.0153283514,
-0.0223441944,
-0.0124853132,
-0.0253571291,
0.0541791357,
-0.035394039,
-0.0341510884,
-0.0320100263,
0.0576188937,
0.0416415855,
-0.0528612807,
-0.0538946502,
-0.0553521737,
0.0579381101,
-0.061163187,
0.0059663281,
-0.0494883172,
-0.0131196184,
-0.0035612262,
-0.0071150078,
-0.0645497218,
-0.0299146045,
-0.0205567256,
-0.0323654227,
0.0182862878,
0.0021986524,
0.016324874,
0.0221097134,
0.0015805258,
-0.0199711621,
-0.0022902424,
-0.0040388885,
-0.0431332104,
0.0299957059,
-0.0134284971,
0.0439125858,
0.0047335988,
-0.046854455,
-0.0252801701,
-0.0007749403,
-0.0539823472,
0.060326837,
-0.0020769369,
-0.0397181213,
-0.0699652582,
0.0905403942,
-0.0104726134,
-0.0181822311,
-0.0271380655,
0.0456743874,
-0.0186769795,
0.0568169393,
-0.0363437794,
-0.0024685941,
0.0252889208,
-0.0149467392,
0.0199928507,
0.0015327723,
-0.044530388,
-0.0137870489,
0.0173564162,
0.038558688,
-0.0027983731,
-0.0406903848,
0.0676736236,
-0.020022843,
0.015681766,
0.0280928947,
-0.0118604517,
0.0204128344,
0.0361135975,
0.0109855467,
-0.0416733809,
-0.0683434382,
0.0264987852,
0.0378570892,
-0.0235319696,
-0.0299980789,
0.0696911886,
-0.0158156175,
0.1029433087,
-0.0570365526,
-0.0166491214,
-0.0720636323,
0.1084061712,
0.0016693257,
0.0249373037,
-0.028923614,
-0.069328323,
0.0347585566,
-0.030285025,
0.1132277846,
-0.0209423527,
0.0960705206,
-0.0164471827,
0.042978365,
-0.0201698113,
-0.0285359453,
-0.0295746196,
-0.0316188522,
-0.0078052538,
0.0250110365,
0.0232609734,
0.0378573537,
-0.0596043207,
0.0465461947,
-0.0233504996,
-0.0118533885,
0.0249185394,
-0.001990885,
-0.0580662154,
0.0442165993,
-0.002548733,
0.0063275648,
-0.0163667928,
0.0077941651,
-0.0176828858,
0.0013349496,
0.0020325033,
0.002168759,
-0.0028460671,
-0.0117460936,
-0.0139005063,
-0.1117601171,
-0.0019419879,
0.0062923543,
0.0118589057,
-0.0398928486,
0.0425427929,
0.068472594,
0.0377438664,
-0.007908552,
0.0013790118,
-0.0213008635,
-0.0214455836,
0.0075406302,
0.0311010107,
-0.0498355851,
0.022521263,
0.0179934669,
-0.0265868697,
-0.0633557215,
-0.0511557348,
-0.019747816,
-0.0471195132,
0.0520080514,
0.0340744555,
-0.0092326524,
-0.0867406949,
0.003789789,
0.0107632102,
0.0023798668,
-0.0202589985,
0.0244757049,
-0.0566667691,
-0.0084467046,
-0.0184471216,
-0.0334095657,
0.0036645844,
0.0086087789,
-0.0657251552,
0.031242365,
0.0281875599,
0.0137879215,
0.0093371272,
0.0232549533,
-0.0604810826,
-0.0063131885,
0.0339891911,
0.0168388877,
0.0359280147,
0.0052326149,
0.0086403824,
-0.0604157001,
0.0089962846,
0.0197944045,
-0.0316654593,
0.0685797185,
0.0327865407,
-0.0605056323,
-0.013704204,
-0.0207967386,
-0.0143567342,
-0.0146130798,
0.0816886947,
0.0370447971,
0.0524210259,
-0.0622821823,
0.036174912,
-0.0149705242,
0.0041297348,
-0.014821751,
0.0084938258,
-0.0158223417,
0.0319403335,
-0.0171291903,
0.0053223362,
-0.0205878932,
0.0317086875,
0.0168378931,
0.0447898656,
0.008527169,
-0.0340064354,
-0.0694660991,
0.008248887,
-0.0427252576,
0.0283676777,
0.0165133309,
0.0557256676,
-0.0158283003,
0.0003996223,
-0.040897008,
-0.0163062345,
-0.0022773074,
0.0182175059,
-0.0128498944,
-0.0708588585,
0.0241764598,
0.0184672251,
-0.0079989582,
-0.0118880551,
-0.0487360246,
0.0276074503,
0.0203752816,
0.0017326958,
0.0170354322,
-0.0422940664,
-0.020302875,
0.0044418457,
0.0105532268,
0.0300118048,
0.0375928618,
0.0186649151,
-0.031287685,
-0.0239201449,
0.042956885,
0.0385181122,
0.017327385,
0.0594935529,
-0.0117735472,
-0.035472583,
0.0052475436,
-0.0302918833,
0.004438065,
-0.0031727341,
-0.0228430685,
-0.014428854,
0.0182854347,
-0.0103300111,
0.0352828503,
-0.0388480984,
0.0021172604,
-0.0502819121,
0.0037414492,
0.0008175525,
-0.0033879548,
-0.0373051055,
-0.0506194606,
-0.0139932502,
0.0331738777,
0.0019186419,
0.0717901587,
-0.0243717097,
0.024956828,
0.0165515244,
0.0502421483,
-0.0704330876,
0.0222915635,
-0.0576563068,
-0.0127853798,
0.0090406379,
0.0137195513,
0.0506782047,
-0.042089574,
-0.0148442974,
-0.0081454311,
-0.0015636783,
0.0141064273,
0.0172619019,
0.0076912921,
0.0012737552,
0.0038989342,
0.0177122671,
-0.0192505177,
0.0022850004,
0.0287619829,
-0.0189533606,
0.0208276212,
-0.0451429933,
-0.0581476465,
-0.0039723339,
-0.0501232482,
0.0304217581,
0.0288768113,
-0.0275086202,
-0.105077669,
-0.0697122216,
0.0239039082,
0.0193688739,
0.0126852756,
0.0172313415,
0.0234886818,
0.0104996879,
0.0560669154,
0.0464597531,
-0.0417841636,
-0.006570226,
0.0483541079,
0.0024333212,
-0.0217437036,
-0.0128951212,
-4.768337733e-33,
-0.0244487468,
-0.0326496214,
-0.0030199839,
0.021255333,
-0.0251694154,
-0.0180540904,
-0.0001001937,
-0.0448580906,
-0.0131399175,
0.0004612588,
0.0007838982,
0.0210042819,
0.0349746831,
-0.0618313886,
0.0135140847,
-0.0124930171,
0.0411282033,
0.0564432219,
-0.0050134766,
0.0080474205,
0.0031944495,
0.0094271991,
-0.0037627735,
-0.1088403091,
-0.0020249072,
-0.0017252708,
0.0220652632,
-0.0162244868,
-0.0145605449,
0.0593806207,
-0.0058733108,
-0.0068038264,
0.0413318835,
-0.0403347462,
-0.0202991702,
0.0180971362,
-0.0444822088,
-0.0063479361,
0.0496707298,
-0.0294801798,
0.0429150239,
-0.0330328271,
0.039070338,
-0.011194258,
-0.0244817398,
-0.001924055,
0.0431080945,
-0.0434774347,
-0.032219056,
-0.0315183327,
-0.0861006975,
0.0528817996,
-0.0089799762,
0.0576019473,
0.027659459,
-0.0006470353,
0.0012970954,
0.0726871565,
-0.0659666806,
0.004130072,
-0.0306565668,
0.0000242423,
0.0399218276,
-0.0587726943,
-0.0356506258,
0.0765661001,
0.0141215324,
-0.0319518074,
-0.0316472501,
0.0256350543,
0.0064959927,
0.0880663991,
0.0342116393,
0.0673016459,
0.0170356147,
-0.0328533053,
-0.0518414192,
0.0209346805,
0.0245516188,
0.0429443046,
0.0134920087,
-0.0098354882,
-0.0737082288,
-0.0090208519,
-0.0401624851,
-0.0311474912,
-0.0215530563,
0.0075339442,
0.0331918374,
-0.0311120134,
0.0503844358,
0.0190942194,
0.0082461545,
-0.0259612091,
0.0372881778,
0.0074258503,
0.0094372295,
0.0218880419,
-0.0143589117,
0.0284626577,
-0.018407207,
-0.0760991722,
0.0070257774,
-0.0110917659,
0.0381614864,
-0.0129197063,
0.0490183532,
-0.0698521435,
-0.0205128193,
0.0061225304,
0.0245589465,
-0.0298457313,
-0.0667476878,
-0.0314633548,
0.0173851904,
0.0448863022,
0.0374241024,
-0.0031922101,
0.0174014587,
-0.0227275286,
-0.0362646729,
-0.0112166544,
-0.0029515543,
0.0086248051,
0.0401872247,
0.013988208,
-0.0085148755,
0.0369825736,
0.0131605351,
0.0274178423,
0.0135867652,
0.0639495105,
2.294e-7,
0.0596956946,
0.003099527,
0.0201741681,
-0.0251670592,
0.0080408631,
0.0278988183,
0.0083352812,
0.0380307361,
0.0228125006,
-0.0069481893,
0.0675860718,
0.0021786343,
0.0440039784,
0.0505400449,
-0.0173760392,
-0.0244801566,
-0.0626109615,
-0.0631010383,
-0.1011884063,
0.0472665541,
0.0818180442,
0.033041019,
0.0195524339,
0.0103823282,
0.0046708542,
-0.0158088878,
0.0153505821,
-0.0058119292,
-0.0186662376,
0.0236455966,
0.0573076643,
-0.0866441801,
0.0087781781,
0.0687577203,
0.0181523003,
0.0919465497,
-0.0291092917,
0.0298780985,
0.0081912698,
0.0553483963,
-0.0729308352,
-0.0317961574,
0.0037940489,
-0.0511609837,
0.0308534037,
-0.0269505922,
-0.0147765772,
-0.04238851,
-0.0330405943,
-0.0217409395,
-0.0123176854,
0.1042381227,
-0.0286029615,
-0.0071450109,
0.0425761417,
-0.007124078,
-0.0203212332,
-0.0628082454,
0.0395824574,
0.0269642733,
-0.0140995141,
0.0385972895,
-0.012352596,
-0.013658043,
0.0972286984,
-0.0648055673,
0.012784618,
1.7371017e-34,
0.0071967295,
0.0245254524,
0.0312707573,
-0.0204280876,
0.0281406958,
0.0403535403,
-0.0570535883,
0.0433690511,
-0.0260030963,
-0.0561520346,
0.0433004461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01621v1
|
SimCSum: Joint Learning of Simplification and Cross-lingual Summarization for Cross-lingual Science Journalism
| 2023-04-04T08:24:22 | 2023-04-04T08:24:22 |
Mehwish Fatima, Tim Kolber, Katja Markert, Michael Strube
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual science journalism generates popular science stories of
scientific articles different from the source language for a non-expert
audience. Hence, a cross-lingual popular summary must contain the salient
content of the input document, and the content should be coherent,
comprehensible, and in a local language for the targeted audience. We improve
these aspects of cross-lingual summary generation by joint training of two
high-level NLP tasks, simplification and cross-lingual summarization. The
former task reduces linguistic complexity, and the latter focuses on
cross-lingual abstractive summarization. We propose a novel multi-task
architecture - SimCSum consisting of one shared encoder and two parallel
decoders jointly learning simplification and cross-lingual summarization. We
empirically investigate the performance of SimCSum by comparing it with several
strong baselines over several evaluation metrics and by human evaluation.
Overall, SimCSum demonstrates statistically significant improvements over the
state-of-the-art on two non-synthetic cross-lingual scientific datasets.
Furthermore, we conduct an in-depth investigation into the linguistic
properties of generated summaries and an error analysis.
|
[
0.0194866955,
-0.0159789305,
0.0167757571,
0.0020184356,
-0.0007092433,
0.0239742566,
0.0004210484,
-0.0276219677,
-0.0288985483,
-0.0198925622,
-0.0215674303,
0.001373964,
0.0343801081,
0.020629812,
0.0071891174,
-0.060601268,
0.0234982446,
-0.0060255094,
0.0168469641,
-0.0310777165,
0.0045039668,
0.0192920677,
0.0108476123,
0.0113623533,
0.0547819585,
-0.0185962077,
0.0348763615,
-0.0173476022,
0.0499147139,
-0.0462288372,
0.0148457121,
0.0283528399,
0.0558841638,
-0.0038897251,
0.0000019152,
-0.0268172212,
-0.0105616795,
0.028329663,
0.0381419025,
0.0473484769,
0.0534335375,
-0.0789619535,
0.0014458866,
-0.0060128313,
-0.0026863753,
-0.0387880728,
0.0444292054,
0.0314172171,
0.0522323474,
0.054020986,
-0.0106734121,
-0.0540424399,
0.0142034749,
-0.0201699715,
-0.0478474572,
-0.0001839967,
-0.0022502029,
0.0479764603,
-0.0311862696,
0.0044703116,
0.0043315236,
0.0439026803,
0.0391956195,
-0.0170372054,
-0.0093065752,
0.0393764004,
-0.0128969317,
-0.0157004222,
0.0138680087,
0.0624796227,
-0.0371328555,
-0.0315766595,
0.0041034231,
0.0013023652,
-0.0373651125,
-0.0053149741,
-0.0838069022,
0.0450649112,
-0.0050329994,
0.025981728,
0.0184549019,
0.0096150581,
-0.0090995086,
0.0221721958,
0.0137021169,
0.0025046228,
0.040779192,
-0.0096288789,
-0.0189051032,
0.0298525169,
0.0217414945,
-0.0714465156,
0.0425735004,
0.0266020279,
-0.0287884604,
-0.0258724801,
-0.0302510746,
-0.0985980108,
0.0151270824,
-0.0571485758,
0.0133650042,
0.0323776007,
0.0129984431,
0.0389065817,
-0.0279830489,
0.02853534,
0.0073995925,
0.0190693475,
-0.0369976424,
-0.0389560051,
-0.0181492232,
0.0048897741,
0.0022748224,
0.0222811121,
-0.0607139468,
-0.0200518314,
-0.0589378625,
-0.0151054515,
0.0237747803,
-0.0061023058,
0.0152072869,
0.006522391,
-0.0573480912,
-0.0120369643,
0.0122765489,
0.0865772218,
-0.0405441411,
-0.0239629876,
0.0335809439,
-0.0066324975,
-0.0425142124,
0.0221100375,
-0.0081904978,
0.0029385902,
-0.0076153334,
0.0149695426,
-0.0432581864,
0.0145835886,
-0.0012461996,
-0.0405313075,
0.0136446925,
-0.0751798078,
0.0263170898,
-0.0540103428,
0.0665285885,
0.0004772427,
-0.0021024703,
-0.0304845832,
-0.004991408,
0.0071924068,
-0.0184453726,
0.0238220505,
-0.0433008559,
-0.0375872403,
0.0275175851,
0.0174798872,
0.0080225496,
0.0888133124,
0.0345661603,
0.0188858341,
0.0135133145,
0.0097672483,
0.0030227418,
-0.0188617669,
0.0140687637,
-0.0051596696,
0.0183196235,
-0.0117844753,
-0.0260107517,
0.0273752399,
0.0732534006,
0.044980552,
-0.066213876,
0.0473036021,
0.0249448121,
0.0084179463,
-0.0001626769,
0.0370211266,
0.0758234486,
0.0200945828,
0.0107051553,
0.0816438571,
0.0280966666,
0.0850608572,
-0.0008624785,
0.0495632179,
0.0843410194,
0.0606939979,
-0.0490315445,
-0.0237671304,
0.0254784655,
-0.0131487865,
0.0256707799,
-0.0109260883,
0.0240289122,
0.0232092366,
-0.0293060001,
0.0451925844,
0.0477008186,
-0.0639699101,
0.0528064594,
0.0085118981,
0.0325666778,
0.0342474356,
0.0063760295,
0.0141637363,
-0.0349938199,
-0.0057850224,
-0.0039598588,
0.0500194244,
0.0664502904,
-0.0281819664,
0.0048640226,
-0.0509967282,
-0.0470998324,
-0.0763835087,
0.0028540429,
0.000694936,
-0.0108679319,
0.0045471848,
0.0476526171,
-0.0011558485,
-0.0242001005,
0.0129303858,
-0.0810561329,
-0.0064746221,
0.0011430957,
-0.0140749514,
0.006851844,
0.0196936689,
-0.0069912663,
0.0323527716,
0.0172850545,
-0.03859438,
-0.024526991,
0.0475933999,
-0.0193765089,
-0.0972738042,
0.0205673985,
-0.1133228913,
-0.0167139452,
0.0503394194,
-0.0122925499,
-0.046730876,
0.0481330976,
-0.0583691262,
0.0073606493,
-0.0287961308,
0.0124947615,
0.0272804666,
0.0418848023,
0.0046035219,
0.0492540896,
-0.0004781065,
0.0388065577,
0.072244823,
-0.0636785328,
0.0093776044,
-0.0399827883,
0.0230929591,
-0.0068519823,
0.0299495962,
-0.0294205993,
0.0575689375,
-0.0124643641,
-0.0086114807,
0.0028615727,
-0.0670961514,
0.0134441219,
-0.013262732,
0.0189999714,
0.0617698915,
0.0128829237,
0.0213469937,
0.0234654173,
-0.0598054677,
0.0043262183,
0.0127311358,
0.0133151235,
0.0161425155,
0.0143796932,
0.0176186766,
-0.0251576528,
-0.0046519488,
0.0009106827,
0.0575797632,
0.0281814467,
-0.0253927726,
-0.069747135,
0.0237965658,
-0.0045113829,
-0.0182512887,
0.0038310308,
-0.0005717485,
-0.0248983186,
0.0248238724,
0.0369886383,
0.0419221371,
0.0167852007,
-0.0037717393,
0.0665129647,
0.0058106892,
-0.0379233062,
0.0028540227,
-0.0165916216,
0.0228026658,
-0.0028947308,
-0.0337792039,
0.0412286371,
0.0433063172,
-0.0134559618,
0.014640267,
-0.0283748899,
0.0050453516,
-0.0074119498,
-0.0397401527,
0.017139107,
-0.0211478081,
0.0070868074,
0.0293747522,
-0.0094721457,
0.0138815101,
0.0812560245,
-0.0117331771,
0.0023502859,
-0.0958950147,
0.0062398948,
-0.0494576171,
0.0078567099,
-0.0545406453,
0.0475711897,
0.013131612,
-0.0202724766,
-0.0242591035,
-0.0167328864,
0.0063434984,
0.0082915314,
-0.0074476656,
-0.0550730117,
-0.0114111593,
-0.0359095708,
-0.0361750126,
0.0287993029,
-0.0038544077,
-0.011063206,
0.0561136156,
0.0668205395,
-0.0339070521,
-0.0399956629,
-0.0151172159,
0.0644009858,
0.0430805236,
-0.0452256501,
-0.0073876623,
-0.010405818,
0.0456050858,
0.0696106851,
0.029468853,
0.0143736368,
-0.0701618716,
0.0131187635,
0.0435427427,
0.0003122248,
0.0161573272,
0.0188267659,
-0.0307157524,
0.0265467111,
-0.0453609489,
-0.0172451567,
-0.0192807429,
0.0590435639,
-0.0563394688,
0.0132749137,
0.0892674774,
0.0050881244,
-0.0605752207,
-0.007629835,
0.0192249548,
-0.0124069722,
0.0078597432,
0.0219001342,
-0.0785449892,
0.0017909636,
-0.0176858865,
-0.016850777,
0.0352590829,
0.0012425495,
-0.0525147654,
-0.0567244403,
0.0100844838,
0.0378163755,
-0.1028022021,
-0.0699759871,
-0.0454865023,
-0.0399391614,
-0.0147032579,
0.0303385258,
0.013549896,
-0.0177932344,
0.0040608896,
-0.0019776407,
-0.0353793167,
-0.0711397529,
-0.0431211144,
-0.0522828959,
-0.0035586513,
0.0168558545,
0.0442708209,
0.0025492823,
0.0007153811,
0.0201804396,
0.0060710213,
-0.0050748931,
-0.0179524235,
0.0402245708,
0.0044945115,
0.0004692121,
-0.007877619,
0.04218724,
0.0059375218,
0.0043213619,
-0.0027587351,
0.0645945668,
0.021741176,
-0.0171149205,
-0.0269251633,
0.0382083356,
-0.0097623803,
0.0682598278,
0.0355158076,
0.0158626977,
-0.0501520559,
-0.0297895614,
-0.0182637628,
-0.0920317769,
-0.0352376886,
-0.0013720129,
-0.052314885,
-0.0567808188,
-0.0484343655,
-0.0677187741,
0.0291737318,
-0.0215172712,
0.0023305134,
-0.0091165714,
0.0013882871,
-0.0067086057,
-0.0391431823,
-0.0174307954,
-0.0238920338,
0.0041585588,
0.0216968898,
-0.0191919208,
0.0365182608,
0.0042198678,
-0.0082169827,
0.0238691531,
-0.0271408018,
-0.0790790319,
-0.0678520128,
0.032970544,
0.0146859912,
0.051893115,
0.037970081,
-0.0316347629,
0.0552733317,
0.0021959106,
-0.0234360751,
0.0358062983,
0.0199448057,
0.0131417578,
-0.0083464105,
0.0017816467,
-0.0389951505,
0.0020319589,
-0.0326185189,
0.0484187119,
-0.007615793,
-0.0213677473,
0.025795063,
0.0471478105,
-0.0134994239,
-0.0538182743,
0.0190513041,
-0.0316020511,
-0.0152389249,
-0.0512222536,
0.0041035414,
-0.0542240962,
0.0434048586,
0.0001739398,
0.0000165188,
0.0163104013,
0.1249383241,
-0.0140446508,
-0.0326690376,
-0.0528470539,
0.0134011498,
-0.038049046,
-0.0295317657,
-0.012553093,
0.0095762592,
-0.0611312874,
-0.0474063456,
-0.0093101496,
-0.0055388017,
-0.0309680589,
-0.0128416074,
0.0293740314,
0.0345415175,
0.0054966439,
0.0331372172,
-0.0619703457,
-0.0254278854,
-0.0432271287,
-0.0177160762,
0.0629962608,
-0.0121027157,
0.0868749022,
-0.0044751051,
-0.0279278588,
-0.025275575,
0.0417132452,
-0.0011433213,
-0.0168915428,
0.0082995398,
-0.0059771966,
-0.008947758,
-0.0273980591,
0.1282483488,
-0.043964386,
0.0118954582,
0.0058754417,
-0.0101108784,
-0.0408676974,
-0.0445791781,
-0.0256203637,
0.0099924132,
-0.0148166129,
-0.0497431643,
-0.0239616055,
-0.02117409,
0.0042491644,
0.0170649495,
-0.0029671821,
-0.0238884185,
0.0438429676,
0.0314638764,
-0.0252887867,
-0.0405246876,
-0.0327513739,
0.0116364909,
0.0019506125,
-0.0297636241,
-0.0101484312,
-6.022909058e-33,
-0.0040629879,
0.0536760762,
0.008954918,
-0.0147260772,
-0.0580258369,
0.0350036658,
-0.1072923988,
-0.0198633,
0.0092948033,
0.034489736,
0.0188057497,
-0.0035575938,
-0.0008587625,
0.0057237684,
0.0048971539,
0.0418021679,
0.074245058,
0.0195002258,
-0.0376922414,
0.0478200354,
0.0298680272,
0.0232244134,
0.0664297342,
-0.0747533217,
0.0189607386,
0.020968629,
-0.0009993066,
-0.0210488457,
0.0391699113,
0.0118656615,
-0.0153069282,
0.0023651931,
0.0085742604,
-0.0874883756,
-0.0536384359,
-0.0173805282,
-0.0663051531,
-0.0186928473,
0.0515826344,
-0.024752859,
-0.0669186488,
-0.0526837297,
0.034191221,
-0.0275076665,
-0.0028254781,
-0.0511746109,
0.0352274142,
-0.0506440662,
-0.0047396175,
-0.0956960171,
-0.0590684675,
-0.0060866806,
-0.0252939612,
-0.0052332631,
0.0445750877,
0.0540347993,
-0.013629376,
0.0266277064,
0.0115321595,
0.0724008083,
0.0002033928,
0.0527363084,
0.0512169749,
-0.0502004139,
0.0137855671,
0.0696453452,
0.0111119878,
-0.0029519275,
-0.0111979917,
0.0139722107,
-0.0160199627,
-0.0016190968,
0.0398473181,
0.0408784002,
0.0460587144,
0.0158037841,
-0.0731422752,
0.0825929493,
0.0203661285,
0.0095359599,
0.0094077801,
0.0203730222,
0.0641112849,
-0.0324002989,
-0.0096849017,
0.0440837294,
-0.0004233917,
-0.053485617,
-0.0341937654,
0.0196068473,
-0.0428009331,
0.0291322339,
0.0215897337,
-0.0434379019,
0.0295779761,
0.0197798572,
-0.0005539109,
0.0178959314,
0.0374700539,
-0.0139880022,
-0.0638410673,
0.0101039968,
0.0188663304,
0.0157873426,
0.0105163725,
0.009918794,
0.037419647,
0.0115664341,
-0.0151842935,
0.0039638192,
-0.0205418859,
-0.0278496258,
0.0125528965,
0.0268125162,
-0.0118598742,
0.0380382724,
-0.008386774,
0.0086667715,
-0.000220454,
0.0184892602,
0.0063641877,
0.0079746172,
0.0394170806,
0.0849380121,
0.005166797,
0.0223030783,
-0.0254384503,
-0.0085808216,
0.0183582716,
-0.0475248173,
-0.0397477224,
-0.0078378674,
2.574e-7,
0.029756479,
0.026525097,
0.0388191864,
0.0012707054,
-0.0023119138,
-0.0098974099,
-0.0155442012,
0.0427082628,
-0.0021377692,
-0.0155753875,
0.0146769201,
0.0206370857,
0.0243750755,
0.0350408964,
-0.1058888659,
0.0110816471,
-0.0538962148,
-0.0514534414,
-0.0239919983,
-0.0202700812,
0.0173584111,
0.0130659211,
-0.0308305025,
0.0046593598,
0.0069365394,
0.021103017,
0.0750055164,
-0.0218689628,
-0.0446073189,
0.0409409367,
-0.027340414,
-0.0070595783,
-0.0207010452,
0.0017286685,
-0.0447990149,
-0.0170639548,
0.0429204069,
0.0257389508,
0.0262880251,
-0.0066369921,
0.0718626529,
-0.0020691841,
-0.0103917737,
0.0040414999,
0.0390774906,
-0.0988876224,
-0.0252625048,
-0.0387459546,
-0.0375753641,
0.0521437526,
0.0287069809,
-0.031192543,
-0.0329681598,
0.0447167717,
0.0013086428,
0.0291107986,
0.0116112726,
-0.0379765183,
-0.0386060365,
0.0340772867,
-0.0245059393,
-0.0285926741,
0.0122176195,
-0.0183759872,
0.0127592087,
-0.0516331904,
-0.0014518572,
2.35208361e-34,
0.1082418486,
0.001835115,
-0.0235917158,
-0.0056966138,
-0.0000075218,
-0.0292212479,
-0.0072974516,
-0.0116914809,
0.0127534801,
-0.0175243467,
-0.0402249545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01612v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01612v1
|
EDeR: A Dataset for Exploring Dependency Relations Between Events
| 2023-04-04T08:07:07 | 2023-04-04T08:07:07 |
Ruiqi Li, Patrik Haslum, Leyang Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Relation extraction is a central task in natural language processing (NLP)
and information retrieval (IR) research. We argue that an important type of
relation not explored in NLP or IR research to date is that of an event being
an argument - required or optional - of another event. We introduce the
human-annotated Event Dependency Relation dataset (EDeR) which provides this
dependency relation. The annotation is done on a sample of documents from the
OntoNotes dataset, which has the added benefit that it integrates with
existing, orthogonal, annotations of this dataset. We investigate baseline
approaches for predicting the event dependency relation, the best of which
achieves an accuracy of 82.61 for binary argument/non-argument classification.
We show that recognizing this relation leads to more accurate event extraction
(semantic role labelling) and can improve downstream tasks that depend on this,
such as co-reference resolution. Furthermore, we demonstrate that predicting
the three-way classification into the required argument, optional argument or
non-argument is a more challenging task.
|
[
0.0434914716,
-0.0001365034,
0.0180318747,
0.0703247488,
-0.0450458452,
0.0209530741,
-0.0254713241,
-0.0027349321,
0.0387221985,
-0.067700021,
0.0160673205,
0.0309905037,
-0.0466587245,
-0.0006257866,
-0.0421062373,
-0.0727612153,
0.0433762074,
0.0524542741,
0.0105631612,
0.0482361838,
0.0027768994,
0.032283023,
-0.041053962,
0.0283078011,
-0.0691693872,
-0.0197226312,
0.0186409615,
-0.0014394368,
0.0309189912,
-0.015367276,
0.0075441776,
0.0482836962,
0.025783008,
-0.0193308499,
0.0000016851,
-0.0578230619,
-0.0064119468,
-0.0281231552,
-0.0451581329,
-0.02277283,
-0.0320526287,
-0.0151275685,
0.033232376,
-0.0151725514,
-0.0389475226,
-0.0563823767,
0.0044497894,
0.0978045389,
-0.0018496575,
0.0661675408,
-0.0262015536,
-0.0225976035,
0.0104756262,
-0.0237382632,
0.0010107188,
-0.0107744019,
0.0170091297,
0.0224374458,
-0.0110939248,
0.0151108308,
0.0181867667,
-0.0137903038,
0.020686565,
-0.0032124082,
-0.0022740804,
0.0349662229,
-0.0660760999,
-0.0115775391,
0.0186344627,
0.0355702527,
0.0154638495,
-0.0231337212,
0.0253348742,
-0.0062923031,
0.0018141667,
0.0698470622,
-0.0008076421,
0.0021942663,
-0.0460144803,
0.0206598956,
0.0661973879,
0.0169554278,
-0.0023430118,
0.0292857662,
0.0415370576,
0.0793454871,
-0.0215678029,
0.0057446402,
0.0059142294,
0.0349305868,
-0.0414083339,
-0.0347803459,
0.0288763046,
0.0130179944,
0.0010468152,
0.0433898233,
-0.0443344451,
0.036334008,
0.0220380202,
-0.1034089029,
-0.049175635,
-0.0107906703,
-0.0224347766,
0.0760197788,
-0.0168648083,
-0.0287159719,
-0.0033789726,
-0.0164897069,
-0.0099495435,
-0.013989619,
-0.0473752879,
0.03600052,
-0.0440696366,
0.0356954485,
-0.0406714268,
-0.0012000767,
0.0006650523,
-0.028582016,
0.0034291891,
0.0080971345,
0.0230595246,
0.0210803486,
-0.0435015745,
-0.0148701528,
-0.0369055606,
-0.0002908566,
-0.0273700804,
0.0136343893,
-0.0529730991,
-0.0343865007,
-0.0064725326,
0.01108744,
0.0393154584,
-0.0577603951,
-0.0189019553,
0.0234581083,
-0.0067093251,
-0.0306351669,
-0.0460420325,
-0.063866362,
0.0250097699,
-0.0317291468,
-0.0310161803,
-0.0285853352,
0.0239278115,
-0.0011441589,
-0.0111884633,
-0.0292618517,
0.0412164703,
0.0190942995,
-0.0585726686,
0.0541519783,
-0.0141503112,
-0.030124886,
0.0325061567,
0.0168780982,
-0.0232351441,
0.0534965582,
0.0317612328,
0.0167661943,
0.0522160083,
0.0355252735,
-0.0229987204,
-0.0211662557,
0.0025372121,
-0.011472757,
0.0720157102,
-0.0045805392,
-0.0163807049,
0.0004192399,
0.0331973955,
-0.0085490486,
-0.0317162611,
-0.0607912466,
-0.0109622963,
0.0002193699,
0.0017716435,
-0.0268361997,
0.023713436,
-0.0103978254,
0.0094137415,
0.0507259108,
-0.0312660858,
-0.0045436788,
0.0277634282,
-0.0244176779,
-0.029245805,
-0.0343446545,
-0.0174981672,
-0.0372656174,
-0.0051782564,
-0.0355896279,
-0.0208759774,
-0.0143331997,
0.0755187348,
0.0145420097,
-0.0252081491,
0.0552876592,
0.0423647352,
-0.0345494859,
-0.0029216686,
0.0193123631,
0.0111073116,
0.0003918809,
0.0226215422,
-0.0761700347,
-0.0443749651,
0.0150153944,
0.0401923656,
0.0256854557,
0.0453197062,
-0.0276417602,
0.0603608899,
-0.0261031874,
-0.0098016532,
0.0264802538,
0.0110180257,
-0.0048316908,
0.0191969033,
-0.022877112,
0.0049452181,
0.0387034118,
-0.0209240075,
0.0487223864,
0.0135054188,
-0.0467182733,
0.0071331291,
0.0122927502,
0.0264493544,
0.0292996541,
0.0023888445,
-0.0029075607,
0.0440694727,
-0.0573264472,
-0.011423829,
0.0555611327,
-0.0278969388,
-0.0354465879,
0.0193520766,
-0.0396945812,
-0.0498967543,
0.0111279748,
-0.0331991054,
-0.0618261956,
0.0131322611,
0.0143716885,
0.0216166787,
-0.0106983539,
-0.0303477123,
0.0409276187,
-0.0143630151,
-0.0335262716,
0.0810440853,
0.0360267647,
0.0212461557,
-0.0475800224,
0.0140644126,
0.0401457436,
-0.0171135459,
-0.0306331478,
0.010768855,
-0.003357661,
-0.0325350016,
0.0471105054,
-0.0454906449,
-0.0681105405,
0.031335257,
-0.0835633948,
0.0355399847,
-0.012707701,
0.0483053625,
0.028359225,
-0.0160831399,
0.0011916584,
-0.0260929354,
-0.0040632538,
-0.0603109263,
-0.0316516906,
-0.0049511637,
0.029641781,
0.0133674368,
0.0233824532,
-0.0490364283,
-0.0038750642,
-0.0603067279,
0.0447825156,
0.0352863111,
-0.0368284024,
-0.0155601958,
0.0127852131,
0.0159869194,
0.0643154234,
0.0135208992,
0.0200054422,
0.0160561986,
0.0089364955,
0.0135128377,
0.0266754441,
-0.0067074499,
0.0524660945,
0.0192161985,
-0.0185125656,
-0.0556084625,
0.0259651765,
-0.0417571403,
0.0415086411,
0.0121302931,
-0.0189030021,
-0.0136048058,
0.0497841761,
0.0127762854,
-0.0029546511,
-0.0519503988,
-0.0208223183,
-0.0086396672,
0.0174393188,
-0.0018417705,
-0.0473488905,
-0.0097102514,
0.0265343469,
-0.0602941476,
0.0057616844,
0.0490602702,
0.0005763266,
0.007816419,
-0.0284841526,
0.0121682109,
-0.0404980294,
0.1019366086,
0.014541639,
-0.001939106,
0.0266405717,
-0.0436100662,
0.0264282674,
-0.0045901146,
0.0566554219,
-0.0071067368,
0.002105654,
-0.0579179674,
0.0444775224,
-0.0237152651,
-0.0239996947,
-0.0319309272,
-0.0304277129,
-0.0201451592,
0.0048257816,
-0.0512261577,
0.0454354472,
-0.0105132041,
-0.0003308444,
-0.0097628748,
0.0428836755,
0.0033061861,
-0.0052799741,
-0.0080784895,
0.06011476,
0.0236999542,
0.0146310152,
-0.0329071507,
0.05840021,
-0.0013522769,
0.0527162775,
0.0076516187,
0.01289088,
-0.03392037,
-0.0054225866,
-0.0141943255,
-0.0717005953,
-0.0164237898,
-0.049812559,
0.0058185025,
-0.0716068894,
0.0071208491,
0.0789047554,
0.0541425757,
-0.0263498556,
-0.0012696933,
-0.0000292966,
-0.0105270101,
0.0253973305,
-0.0051850225,
-0.0770601556,
-0.0360520966,
-0.029401781,
-0.0278699547,
-0.0261120182,
-0.0581301823,
0.008988915,
-0.0673415363,
0.0323206037,
-0.0359755307,
0.0247180779,
-0.026558917,
-0.0913140476,
0.0298280269,
-0.0513461865,
-0.0557082817,
-0.0182400495,
0.0082671009,
0.0007288915,
0.0279483609,
-0.0589146949,
-0.0172164198,
0.0175002646,
-0.0503492877,
0.0182492957,
-0.0146666914,
0.0455279462,
0.0117739495,
0.0445737801,
0.016946625,
-0.0398386829,
-0.0030126516,
-0.0207343474,
0.0986584947,
-0.0124052949,
0.0034010815,
-0.0204382315,
0.0343258567,
-0.0420655981,
-0.0458691716,
0.007023748,
0.0525446758,
-0.0287407972,
0.0336769223,
0.0042861304,
-0.0061511793,
0.0068515223,
0.0627787486,
-0.0064041102,
0.0321561582,
-0.0289879646,
-0.0062372559,
0.0491706841,
-0.0700604618,
-0.0073163263,
-0.0025186292,
-0.0496147536,
-0.0218617041,
-0.0711268336,
-0.0854513571,
0.0161559135,
-0.0030008792,
-0.0285649113,
0.0422585756,
0.0530260541,
-0.0000596796,
-0.0444854237,
0.05479699,
-0.0135839134,
-0.011058812,
0.0344270058,
-0.0082342234,
0.031025026,
0.0232103337,
-0.0094161658,
0.0327203311,
0.0122578023,
-0.0193070266,
-0.004881558,
-0.0086094029,
0.0186862424,
0.0447715484,
-0.0192798134,
-0.0205589943,
-0.0639216602,
0.018215837,
-0.0020636411,
-0.035702426,
0.0205255244,
0.0053515383,
-0.0221308265,
0.0437723845,
0.0041295658,
0.0199728236,
-0.0325712338,
0.044305712,
-0.0701555312,
-0.0069700223,
0.0207034759,
-0.0153682539,
0.0984335914,
0.0102022514,
-0.0043341881,
-0.0693924427,
0.0190276261,
-0.0593710579,
-0.0151541764,
-0.0178377517,
0.0474038608,
-0.0156784188,
0.0064085927,
-0.0209097173,
-0.0132446624,
-0.0289670657,
0.0200490281,
-0.0146033512,
0.0218697861,
0.0823468268,
0.0151057309,
-0.0311599579,
-0.0069773197,
-0.0409302451,
0.0190865118,
0.0157885123,
0.0248687658,
-0.0284970868,
-0.0052376539,
0.0282734614,
0.0087553449,
0.0033283967,
-0.0374800302,
-0.0521089584,
0.0358764231,
-0.014881691,
-0.0160904918,
0.0868442357,
-0.0798158273,
0.0768147856,
-0.0216353275,
-0.0023756807,
0.0240848176,
0.0468365625,
0.0100649474,
0.0281098634,
0.0087752352,
0.0192367006,
-0.0234678946,
0.063732408,
0.0876104087,
-0.0188782997,
0.0714059398,
0.0130150234,
-0.0491924062,
-0.0060632741,
-0.047249984,
0.0038347307,
0.0307116918,
-0.0195854213,
0.0008626918,
-0.0464290231,
-0.0055970768,
0.0012599849,
-0.0106021333,
0.0028353466,
-0.0102560893,
0.0263043493,
0.0204946753,
0.0486433841,
-0.0349457562,
-0.0500570722,
0.012681515,
-0.014834567,
-0.0236374326,
-0.054081969,
-5.878961693e-33,
-0.037703786,
-0.024750635,
-0.0062025948,
0.086742349,
0.0113391671,
0.0376420394,
-0.0147797074,
-0.0065889372,
-0.0276104361,
0.0488883406,
-0.0027898075,
0.0096688392,
0.0351141728,
-0.0041344622,
0.0390255712,
-0.0243181307,
0.0036430468,
-0.0024160144,
-0.0023871362,
0.0094957119,
0.0836125612,
0.0142926909,
0.0491224155,
-0.139809534,
0.044631552,
0.0150756482,
0.0113722747,
0.010695667,
0.0277381726,
0.0465817228,
0.0020433066,
0.0440205224,
0.0553807169,
-0.0606927164,
0.032274995,
0.0325413458,
-0.1349018514,
-0.0370910577,
0.0290393103,
0.0051577874,
-0.0282025784,
-0.0325699672,
0.0155897411,
0.0383873098,
0.0377652422,
-0.0334056765,
0.0543583855,
-0.0157532897,
-0.0247773994,
-0.0604253598,
-0.0725495368,
0.066530481,
0.0053338306,
-0.0226840023,
0.0275211409,
0.0165511407,
0.0160436518,
-0.0108846035,
-0.0350895599,
-0.0320817046,
-0.0965390578,
0.0275331978,
-0.034652397,
-0.0255742781,
-0.0479158796,
0.0546505488,
-0.0205577593,
0.0009678525,
-0.0173452776,
0.0339126401,
-0.032121364,
0.0747430474,
0.0045649135,
0.0316458568,
0.0537862666,
0.0225962475,
-0.0963187665,
0.0443086103,
0.0617535301,
0.034152016,
-0.0354913659,
0.0020081217,
-0.0262625143,
-0.011697026,
-0.0180871692,
-0.0155222192,
-0.0141284345,
-0.0178333856,
-0.024095891,
-0.0146645354,
0.0118311327,
0.0714413747,
-0.0048376354,
-0.0048176805,
-0.0197721627,
-0.0030272191,
0.0145641016,
0.0175624434,
-0.0079185069,
-0.0060726856,
-0.0409982391,
-0.0318441316,
0.0152155282,
-0.0166075751,
0.0571419895,
0.0072048698,
0.0688741431,
-0.0371431783,
-0.0133808739,
-0.0049047512,
-0.0094400011,
-0.0184961446,
-0.0303838979,
0.0381388813,
0.0169063583,
0.0341830589,
0.0025235193,
0.0209996048,
0.0137734478,
0.0409299992,
-0.0204734746,
-0.0542440005,
-0.0166537035,
0.0138099575,
0.0248808824,
-0.0134789329,
-0.0107093845,
0.0169522129,
0.0047161239,
-0.0143065564,
-0.0102591701,
0.0205507614,
2.402e-7,
0.0744197741,
0.0397325121,
0.0581077226,
0.0200984627,
-0.0120400572,
0.0060079144,
0.0148332464,
0.0498853698,
0.0184014868,
-0.014580288,
-0.0047210022,
0.009233119,
0.0359749347,
0.0687593073,
-0.0770877153,
-0.1034201905,
-0.0444294363,
-0.0528346449,
-0.0444171131,
-0.0186990891,
0.0922249779,
0.053125523,
0.0514557771,
-0.000381089,
-0.0463552251,
0.0023402369,
0.0258901212,
-0.0173923466,
-0.0224585515,
0.0066938405,
0.0339656621,
0.0098652067,
-0.0331603773,
0.0815593079,
-0.0337400772,
0.0207704417,
0.0115427459,
0.0394490287,
-0.0146216117,
-0.0076737916,
0.0085949637,
-0.0029030661,
0.018339267,
0.00375207,
0.0700910389,
-0.0419352427,
-0.0210333783,
0.0332383886,
-0.0386720896,
0.0544371344,
-0.0240545627,
0.0446810797,
-0.0284534972,
0.0222666189,
0.0076720659,
-0.0089026634,
-0.0184452925,
-0.0775614679,
-0.019043304,
0.0525652021,
-0.0046827947,
0.0014159816,
0.0335222222,
-0.0442288481,
-0.0070970897,
-0.0355147235,
-0.0191570539,
1.631149366e-34,
-0.0272481181,
0.0392840356,
-0.0020188338,
0.0048330394,
0.0590337478,
-0.0284215547,
-0.0560594238,
0.0134920338,
-0.0167711396,
-0.0230958704,
0.0187927075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01597v1
|
Unsupervised Improvement of Factual Knowledge in Language Models
| 2023-04-04T07:37:06 | 2023-04-04T07:37:06 |
Nafis Sadeq, Byungkyu Kang, Prarit Lamba, Julian McAuley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Masked language modeling (MLM) plays a key role in pretraining large language
models. But the MLM objective is often dominated by high-frequency words that
are sub-optimal for learning factual knowledge. In this work, we propose an
approach for influencing MLM pretraining in a way that can improve language
model performance on a variety of knowledge-intensive tasks. We force the
language model to prioritize informative words in a fully unsupervised way.
Experiments demonstrate that the proposed approach can significantly improve
the performance of pretrained language models on tasks such as factual recall,
question answering, sentiment analysis, and natural language inference in a
closed-book setting.
|
[
0.0393077992,
0.0551301129,
-0.0120293228,
0.0439629182,
-0.0234683547,
0.0153698931,
0.0365165323,
-0.0016935944,
0.0397535786,
-0.1230825782,
-0.0247688647,
-0.005433464,
-0.0211969856,
0.0468057096,
0.0189701505,
-0.0275970679,
0.0707599074,
-0.0398104042,
0.0108722365,
-0.0246057399,
-0.0091614248,
0.0165372062,
-0.0171852205,
-0.0152243404,
-0.0131339105,
-0.0287711881,
0.0396457613,
-0.0524385385,
-0.0034916783,
0.0139804371,
0.0369385742,
0.0541817471,
0.0161947422,
0.0308659673,
0.0000019092,
-0.0582317598,
0.0252937861,
-0.0375506952,
-0.053162355,
0.043197114,
0.0459613726,
0.0042506899,
0.012532291,
0.0147503717,
-0.0569782853,
-0.0165402014,
0.0180709921,
0.0471830964,
0.0412064753,
0.0734460726,
0.0085879918,
-0.0118494732,
0.0038043028,
0.0080750026,
-0.019807199,
-0.0193875972,
0.0309079513,
0.0438818857,
-0.0618916601,
0.0256096106,
-0.0117436489,
0.0330304764,
-0.0010568378,
0.0251601636,
0.0781593472,
0.0606022701,
-0.0294423252,
-0.0009053737,
0.0366154537,
0.0762152895,
-0.0370343179,
-0.0474903323,
-0.0078410991,
-0.0111195184,
-0.0252655242,
0.0213863216,
0.0065898206,
-0.0057897647,
0.0069845403,
0.0100191925,
0.0057733119,
0.0050946707,
0.0502246283,
0.0452959426,
-0.0348833017,
0.0760448352,
0.0082450425,
-0.0178227071,
-0.0015521386,
-0.0040598642,
-0.0361586772,
-0.0410312377,
0.0073385495,
0.0156515427,
-0.0003248748,
0.0545468889,
-0.0496044122,
-0.0460517034,
0.0127134183,
-0.0725297108,
0.0012648018,
0.0201410763,
-0.0259285476,
0.0558919497,
-0.0460054912,
-0.0100754155,
0.0172945838,
0.0314570703,
-0.0194675885,
0.005131714,
-0.0076057697,
-0.0237083305,
-0.0244990643,
0.029726414,
-0.0509616844,
-0.0024504096,
0.0092878584,
-0.0032347066,
-0.0030498207,
-0.011206625,
-0.0197629444,
0.0058428207,
-0.0421227291,
-0.027099615,
-0.0501439087,
-0.0253836177,
-0.0229201242,
0.0220731813,
-0.0438008346,
-0.0529377945,
0.0008243286,
0.0085958494,
0.0070375316,
-0.0360861346,
0.0209199507,
0.0094272355,
-0.0271507073,
-0.0327385329,
-0.0403244533,
0.0001973921,
0.0146036362,
-0.0593979321,
-0.0088538146,
-0.0340132862,
0.0046155145,
0.0088732056,
-0.0066243275,
-0.0156174833,
0.0154138189,
0.0308742598,
-0.036916934,
0.1126132235,
-0.0030662764,
-0.0311568454,
0.0394119918,
0.0256604198,
0.0205196645,
0.0607108735,
-0.0031989678,
-0.001814939,
0.0430060551,
-0.0119083468,
0.0242164861,
0.0088000782,
0.0307342429,
0.0012119212,
0.0163419228,
-0.0004773532,
0.0019056919,
0.0000188556,
0.0607050732,
0.0305920355,
-0.0162166916,
-0.0348035917,
0.0650552437,
0.0100934943,
-0.0262999516,
0.0489884503,
0.0124140056,
0.0264671594,
0.023215821,
0.0351317637,
-0.024922071,
0.0021542925,
-0.0729271695,
0.0181158409,
-0.0031808713,
0.0212703384,
-0.0190930609,
-0.0684648901,
-0.0257013254,
-0.0059408206,
0.0423175618,
0.0475881733,
0.0479833074,
0.0397458673,
-0.0238884576,
0.0502926074,
0.038836915,
-0.0231735148,
0.0234670732,
-0.0496544279,
0.0153726814,
0.0318414979,
0.0317292437,
-0.078692019,
-0.0157893598,
0.0040838323,
-0.0078847138,
0.0545638464,
0.0481609665,
-0.0148512917,
0.0068273176,
-0.0485554487,
-0.0010269484,
-0.0125686927,
0.0290195663,
0.0213881601,
0.0233105514,
0.0163656417,
0.0352555513,
-0.0513743423,
-0.0447512046,
0.0502462499,
-0.0433737375,
-0.0976199806,
0.0021012796,
0.0055117183,
0.0097681619,
-0.0150267435,
-0.0144068496,
0.012417648,
0.0130713079,
-0.0305095464,
-0.0513048843,
-0.0237644464,
-0.0522703454,
-0.0428705253,
0.0376631878,
-0.004549203,
-0.0275369324,
0.092291601,
-0.0335356779,
-0.0308228843,
0.0222811271,
-0.0154871559,
0.060652975,
-0.0552843548,
0.0026359914,
0.0162482653,
0.0243553352,
-0.0512038842,
0.0857189149,
0.0008881383,
0.0229151882,
-0.0102452962,
-0.0198728964,
-0.0063972641,
0.0132965231,
0.0037910368,
0.0061403504,
0.030416688,
0.0241724197,
0.0332952328,
-0.0048585711,
-0.0474959984,
0.0096730646,
-0.0847844779,
-0.0249315407,
-0.0296343882,
-0.010007605,
0.0047871242,
0.0068230545,
-0.0182287358,
-0.029049512,
-0.038888298,
-0.0445991047,
-0.0257446356,
0.0160949752,
0.0255081635,
-0.0003711742,
0.0282872301,
-0.0383763015,
0.0102871396,
-0.0122138048,
0.022486547,
0.0018364475,
-0.0210874584,
-0.0394232571,
0.0710747242,
-0.0497904792,
0.0578678995,
-0.0184940156,
0.00138418,
-0.0329769552,
0.0201048646,
0.0452791825,
0.091680564,
0.0264860913,
0.0148886265,
0.0792640969,
0.0271750633,
-0.0573369674,
0.0215000957,
-0.0404184833,
-0.0130894445,
-0.0099874288,
-0.0049440227,
0.0214795545,
0.0418873951,
0.032093782,
-0.0507097431,
-0.0264973473,
0.0181936938,
-0.0407920294,
-0.0382973813,
-0.0719203204,
-0.001382869,
-0.0131352805,
0.0297691356,
-0.0268857181,
-0.0250318833,
0.0698960423,
-0.0344344042,
0.0062658298,
-0.0940633267,
-0.0113862827,
-0.0328922048,
0.0188309383,
0.0267869197,
0.0256383121,
0.0004771107,
-0.0099438,
-0.060404662,
0.0053408784,
0.0382485501,
-0.0376766697,
0.034439031,
-0.0336602144,
0.0181303676,
0.0367885306,
-0.0348654687,
-0.0758947656,
-0.0697847679,
-0.0248314254,
-0.0146036996,
0.0247085467,
0.0131494524,
-0.0317084417,
-0.0131274834,
0.034152545,
0.0597099252,
0.0242928565,
-0.0239187516,
-0.0100596938,
0.0085152127,
0.0797357187,
0.0042206887,
0.0546257198,
-0.0275400057,
0.019530043,
0.0481625497,
0.0372041129,
-0.0321050175,
-0.0097760418,
-0.0100464616,
0.022546947,
-0.0555369183,
0.0020277,
-0.0058327541,
0.0036258968,
-0.0327177458,
-0.0052629942,
0.142222479,
0.0235752687,
-0.0079424167,
0.0038932804,
-0.0037185145,
0.020932138,
0.0294442289,
0.0283420868,
-0.0539338738,
-0.0076672197,
-0.0263824277,
0.0106386952,
-0.0074714925,
-0.0230949316,
-0.0210452694,
-0.1221411824,
-0.0144105926,
0.0012271056,
0.0004998544,
-0.0382090546,
-0.0511673279,
-0.0202384479,
-0.0127373803,
0.0191226266,
-0.030675251,
0.0001983329,
0.013159507,
0.0027321219,
-0.0345258899,
-0.0343753286,
0.0444135964,
-0.0163251385,
0.0320905186,
0.0329616033,
0.025708165,
-0.0192240104,
-0.0245049745,
0.0224746354,
0.0007179148,
-0.0045961472,
-0.0211068094,
0.0818927586,
-0.0575660802,
-0.0158423018,
0.0063155089,
0.0319352113,
-0.0362735242,
-0.0227699466,
-0.0091614006,
0.0198650956,
-0.0075898315,
-0.0249318965,
0.0039443588,
0.0202076063,
0.0046870145,
0.0894856006,
0.0140371481,
-0.0218468402,
0.0156947151,
-0.024013605,
0.0190427639,
-0.0150076142,
-0.0586145036,
0.0158501659,
-0.0039549256,
0.0061111222,
-0.0793308169,
-0.0352247432,
0.0381675586,
0.0480370335,
0.0055308756,
0.0248245504,
0.0462885797,
-0.0197391789,
-0.0441195779,
0.0468958542,
-0.0626315251,
-0.0146844052,
-0.0170721803,
-0.0752719194,
0.0314815007,
-0.0351692289,
-0.0290940683,
-0.010205945,
-0.051604934,
-0.0572253615,
0.0265469272,
0.0374009833,
0.0235816538,
0.0870405659,
-0.0301480591,
-0.0685746148,
0.0517856255,
0.0070582256,
-0.0818668529,
0.0144806094,
0.039107427,
-0.0264026448,
-0.0006697046,
0.0328843556,
-0.0163304992,
0.0252102166,
0.0458717719,
0.0154063823,
-0.0440767445,
-0.0358220711,
0.0207403041,
0.0229925122,
0.0931022018,
-0.0178901423,
0.0135865286,
-0.0516062975,
0.0100474386,
-0.0113683799,
-0.0476226844,
0.0068379478,
0.0118466485,
0.0129400101,
0.0106450887,
-0.0394931361,
0.0339585468,
-0.0311961323,
0.0160753913,
-0.0118502313,
-0.0288026221,
-0.0112629263,
0.0043932633,
0.0020280939,
0.0023762926,
-0.0417441651,
0.0206009075,
0.015873583,
0.04659798,
0.0066055632,
0.0293050036,
0.0185122825,
-0.0088808862,
-0.0518598296,
0.002943201,
-0.0811351538,
-0.0165297892,
-0.0246854629,
0.0264614522,
0.0368973427,
-0.0730667263,
0.0136974864,
-0.0629722998,
-0.0303114615,
-0.0037170819,
0.0035543144,
0.0307867285,
-0.0052528791,
-0.0003105821,
0.0141416024,
-0.0373479612,
0.0365680084,
0.0970768109,
0.0355505906,
0.0480975658,
0.0193386525,
-0.0077404468,
-0.0446202867,
-0.0085386829,
0.0149814971,
0.0603917278,
-0.0009491417,
0.0603850298,
-0.0795415416,
-0.0781928301,
0.0079826349,
-0.0085893515,
-0.0062620682,
-0.0301066283,
0.0526366718,
0.0429632328,
-0.0170769114,
-0.0142761394,
-0.0806460828,
0.0578001738,
0.0429609716,
0.0027324765,
-0.0094150212,
-6.858369627e-33,
-0.0307663716,
-0.036815878,
0.0057754186,
0.0510038249,
0.024293147,
0.0224864911,
-0.0080489116,
0.017355362,
-0.0282989144,
0.0207582694,
-0.0053819022,
0.038306877,
0.0087555656,
0.032568384,
-0.0509565994,
-0.0147488201,
0.0352721922,
-0.0115212305,
-0.0270644613,
-0.0063854111,
0.0163823478,
0.0561286584,
0.0546882525,
-0.0684843585,
0.0017653909,
-0.0027910562,
0.0124665974,
0.0211695787,
-0.013606512,
0.0393742248,
-0.0611930192,
0.0604315735,
0.0196467917,
-0.0386861525,
-0.0158504955,
0.0168764964,
-0.079088524,
-0.0398341604,
0.0406061523,
0.0045212898,
-0.0146131963,
-0.0080328751,
0.0171265416,
-0.0025429539,
-0.0109993797,
0.0020024306,
0.0544879623,
-0.0273535326,
-0.0507670268,
-0.0340155177,
-0.0719581023,
0.0278763585,
0.0072841556,
-0.0155700846,
0.0255699903,
0.0126550915,
0.0133623676,
-0.0046480172,
-0.0683970898,
-0.0040466944,
0.0249916483,
0.028457623,
0.0690078139,
0.0406971797,
0.0106475754,
0.0934243873,
0.0036986342,
0.0087497355,
-0.0497887731,
0.0334406011,
0.0797451213,
0.0078950757,
0.0391343534,
0.0335216708,
0.0177656729,
-0.0121625774,
-0.0471408889,
0.023744924,
-0.0385107659,
-0.0172017515,
0.0186030976,
-0.0072471998,
-0.0457507111,
-0.0266455859,
-0.063935779,
0.0413210914,
-0.049516663,
0.022734886,
0.0146184536,
0.0229259487,
-0.0616453141,
-0.0242237113,
-0.0167699046,
-0.029612191,
-0.0232069306,
-0.0101393182,
0.0167165436,
-0.0034464668,
-0.0070163189,
0.04055297,
-0.0640399605,
-0.0038101184,
0.0036609028,
0.0212907605,
-0.0015992565,
0.0024751804,
0.0435525924,
-0.0021814457,
-0.0597355478,
0.0018896245,
-0.0214555189,
0.0000670694,
0.0424987264,
0.0276146382,
0.0081337476,
0.0298956539,
-0.0139558427,
0.0579304658,
0.035092108,
-0.0222422332,
-0.0311799347,
-0.008094145,
-0.0031578213,
0.0307174791,
-0.0281104725,
-0.0233068988,
0.0052674357,
0.0053848941,
0.0471151881,
-0.0559595115,
-0.0056901327,
0.0057151215,
2.564e-7,
0.0557367876,
0.0559269488,
-0.0176020898,
0.0163788218,
-0.014046941,
0.0675012097,
0.0256682001,
0.0255226959,
0.0091640064,
-0.0486680903,
-0.0153115392,
0.0401136652,
0.0177824795,
0.0062259659,
-0.0622869432,
-0.023563832,
-0.0098592639,
0.0007642288,
-0.0277876742,
-0.0367426984,
0.0200145468,
0.1047636941,
0.0210029781,
-0.0074832928,
0.0011724646,
-0.0575217046,
0.0624183416,
-0.0296788216,
-0.0419606306,
0.014395006,
0.0582748167,
0.0683163106,
0.0112850061,
0.0236133058,
-0.0451687612,
0.002186066,
0.032695286,
0.0632760078,
-0.0022585259,
-0.023116773,
-0.0376579389,
0.0237460267,
-0.0062264856,
-0.0319285803,
0.0853741691,
-0.0220126882,
-0.0025578092,
-0.0290423688,
-0.0159750916,
0.0090207234,
0.0245464109,
-0.0203775596,
-0.0624795444,
0.0436854661,
0.0142626958,
-0.013040266,
-0.006776988,
-0.0898995847,
-0.0340539776,
0.0006658499,
-0.0501316749,
-0.0362209938,
0.0197174735,
-0.0233715065,
0.0336407647,
-0.0278325062,
0.0224791598,
2.521182835e-34,
0.037584845,
0.0079051685,
0.0088883489,
0.0162821822,
0.0363972634,
-0.0017921866,
-0.0109070316,
-0.0074521485,
0.0384356156,
-0.0742576718,
0.0084001329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01563v1
|
Attribute-Consistent Knowledge Graph Representation Learning for Multi-Modal Entity Alignment
| 2023-04-04T06:39:36 | 2023-04-04T06:39:36 |
Qian Li, Shu Guo, Yangyifei Luo, Cheng Ji, Lihong Wang, Jiawei Sheng, Jianxin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The multi-modal entity alignment (MMEA) aims to find all equivalent entity
pairs between multi-modal knowledge graphs (MMKGs). Rich attributes and
neighboring entities are valuable for the alignment task, but existing works
ignore contextual gap problems that the aligned entities have different numbers
of attributes on specific modality when learning entity representations. In
this paper, we propose a novel attribute-consistent knowledge graph
representation learning framework for MMEA (ACK-MMEA) to compensate the
contextual gaps through incorporating consistent alignment knowledge.
Attribute-consistent KGs (ACKGs) are first constructed via multi-modal
attribute uniformization with merge and generate operators so that each entity
has one and only one uniform feature in each modality. The ACKGs are then fed
into a relation-aware graph neural network with random dropouts, to obtain
aggregated relation representations and robust entity representations. In order
to evaluate the ACK-MMEA facilitated for entity alignment, we specially design
a joint alignment loss for both entity and attribute evaluation. Extensive
experiments conducted on two benchmark datasets show that our approach achieves
excellent performance compared to its competitors.
|
[
-0.0170583166,
0.0464990698,
0.0253770687,
0.0207777563,
-0.0070847836,
-0.0038713703,
0.0209638178,
-0.030913474,
0.0079510743,
-0.0088312263,
-0.0015485757,
0.0217849035,
-0.010481162,
0.0011954996,
0.0285335369,
0.0345320106,
0.0559623986,
0.0927087963,
-0.0026985868,
-0.0029741116,
0.0364037193,
0.0500390343,
-0.0373716764,
0.0017534586,
-0.0321948007,
-0.0299877059,
-0.0198786017,
0.0070939185,
0.0540256426,
-0.0305006597,
0.0020431934,
0.0079055326,
0.0072264969,
0.0185109973,
0.0000019503,
-0.0366765149,
-0.036572665,
0.0090598082,
-0.0362557545,
-0.033225216,
0.0121009704,
-0.0095867394,
0.0557235591,
0.0006853573,
-0.0194888134,
-0.059085723,
0.0642320812,
0.0674846843,
0.0324480385,
0.0625242963,
-0.0332716927,
-0.0375721529,
0.028397128,
-0.0242707264,
-0.0123901069,
-0.0641498715,
0.0220274217,
0.0284923147,
-0.040671017,
-0.0037758804,
-0.0135256276,
0.0448338054,
0.0060132015,
0.0031923025,
0.0351414122,
0.0254562683,
0.008638707,
0.0283377804,
0.0168708973,
0.1297098249,
0.0035142566,
0.0148208737,
0.0193748921,
-0.0181337297,
0.0303844102,
-0.0059179976,
-0.0031376588,
-0.0257234294,
-0.0327263661,
0.0000035146,
-0.0591281839,
-0.0040329346,
0.0675974414,
-0.034225978,
0.0173718482,
-0.0005119542,
0.0147161027,
0.0072450456,
-0.0207846388,
0.0117859039,
-0.0340989977,
-0.0239961129,
-0.0209067166,
0.0161188152,
-0.0320802666,
0.0129305227,
-0.0614564084,
-0.0089308592,
0.0071147932,
-0.0044185808,
-0.0133864637,
0.0235984158,
0.0058594942,
0.0672931224,
-0.0485837422,
0.0240461752,
-0.0206190869,
0.0360791981,
-0.0187097378,
-0.0393647999,
-0.078049764,
0.0072009782,
0.0138547197,
0.0285838675,
0.0309372358,
-0.0109343678,
-0.062278457,
0.0165918954,
-0.0490973666,
0.0687516481,
0.0195769276,
0.0421583317,
-0.0063776304,
-0.0263702311,
-0.0251227729,
0.0628039762,
-0.0198798217,
0.0346055329,
-0.0092826085,
0.0276273992,
0.0053503751,
-0.0222982671,
0.0344768055,
-0.0314209275,
-0.0080840839,
0.0646559522,
0.0108063826,
-0.001121821,
-0.0500707105,
-0.0314880311,
0.0109184831,
-0.0511391945,
-0.0027067459,
-0.025748197,
0.099734053,
0.0103004649,
-0.0346188135,
-0.060018383,
0.0054576918,
-0.0494370982,
-0.0198182501,
0.0532266907,
-0.0086914664,
0.0023420863,
0.0032095392,
-0.0180886611,
0.0026493648,
0.0335631631,
0.0139457388,
-0.0418017656,
0.0085859448,
0.0055807242,
-0.0618007742,
-0.0057798522,
0.0638939217,
-0.0243332647,
0.0494003296,
0.0057633086,
0.0038417277,
0.0676438287,
0.0666197911,
0.0195594728,
-0.0143765574,
-0.0514487475,
0.0120895309,
-0.0775971115,
0.0388476513,
0.0280595738,
0.0291372389,
0.017747812,
-0.036887683,
-0.021092657,
-0.0615236349,
0.0208312348,
-0.0114621585,
0.0232982039,
0.0134312613,
0.0489052981,
-0.0193257965,
0.0248761214,
0.0380213633,
-0.0078638885,
0.0196653977,
-0.0053740991,
0.0290560611,
-0.0257201642,
-0.0281909574,
0.057803914,
0.0416294076,
-0.0064088292,
0.009474244,
0.0472101308,
-0.0219778065,
0.0408401787,
0.0150354719,
-0.0171818808,
-0.0688907877,
-0.0192961674,
-0.0371110477,
-0.0043225135,
0.0194051825,
-0.0325630829,
0.0225054175,
-0.0409283191,
-0.0730223954,
-0.0019676932,
-0.018822832,
0.0142837726,
-0.0187584478,
0.0553352349,
0.0483213812,
-0.0853586942,
0.0442891568,
0.0206353199,
0.0013969418,
0.0377750173,
-0.0135262059,
0.0577209145,
0.0120969685,
0.0582924262,
-0.0076526008,
-0.0010392938,
0.0199284442,
-0.0094979508,
-0.0054032626,
0.0071288599,
-0.0491353013,
-0.0544889495,
0.075718157,
-0.0081721023,
-0.0512975752,
-0.0216359496,
-0.0561455302,
-0.057009086,
-0.0074010072,
0.0038041398,
0.0507614873,
-0.0011531494,
0.0114309993,
0.0076708696,
-0.0101179862,
0.0040337462,
0.088879101,
0.0046116621,
0.0236759968,
0.0048960247,
0.014942687,
0.0418398567,
-0.0176018514,
-0.0231985021,
-0.0268511698,
-0.0025017653,
0.0242491234,
0.0083969822,
-0.0394853689,
-0.059738338,
0.0246271882,
-0.1187058017,
0.0232618768,
0.04985274,
0.0015233612,
-0.0037529436,
0.0208717454,
0.0291928425,
-0.0170048513,
-0.0524866655,
0.0267235041,
-0.0001742786,
-0.0183777921,
0.0370357074,
0.0058667958,
-0.0443779081,
-0.0027316576,
-0.0090839053,
-0.0430998318,
0.0406458899,
0.011337176,
0.0086628105,
-0.0167584922,
0.02279412,
-0.0729980841,
0.0301315673,
-0.0016053184,
0.0364202186,
-0.028677335,
0.0352676772,
0.0055053844,
0.0258573145,
-0.0078889932,
-0.0204305872,
-0.003108107,
-0.0194964465,
-0.0625081435,
0.0187176764,
-0.0023034802,
0.0459852256,
-0.0144772725,
-0.005704781,
-0.028613653,
0.0213906672,
0.0247407332,
-0.0166629367,
-0.0508838929,
-0.0023694732,
0.0458876826,
0.0048360187,
-0.0129603297,
0.0291181784,
0.0396462493,
-0.0290059093,
-0.0624284633,
0.035643138,
0.0779482797,
-0.0081200255,
0.0375681669,
0.0241320375,
0.0401862748,
-0.0234069582,
0.0328793898,
0.0017161338,
0.0436977223,
0.0209278502,
-0.0365832709,
-0.0653840229,
0.0254864395,
0.0500441417,
-0.0073790429,
0.0370562375,
0.0199462865,
0.0447984859,
-0.0202963334,
-0.0215071496,
-0.0289482586,
-0.0095421346,
0.013901352,
0.0123250624,
-0.005477366,
0.0010673446,
-0.0665986463,
-0.0264679808,
-0.0149342064,
-0.033815898,
0.0042496393,
0.0037072112,
-0.0128035797,
0.0786304846,
0.05318233,
0.0205105171,
0.010402659,
0.0229083486,
-0.0084780892,
0.0292292964,
0.0193883218,
0.0012139773,
-0.0047465535,
-0.0079035228,
-0.0178948026,
-0.0290857926,
0.0013267823,
-0.0234465431,
0.0557789393,
-0.0023400085,
0.0525058508,
0.0623566471,
0.0027309302,
-0.0050596106,
-0.0236193426,
0.0488470644,
0.0309688374,
0.0170435831,
-0.0003317127,
-0.1314495355,
-0.0299251266,
-0.0316735692,
0.0106684901,
0.0552946888,
-0.0764251873,
0.0256083719,
-0.0788281113,
-0.0439888239,
0.0239142589,
-0.0383043811,
-0.0548003875,
-0.0213983785,
0.0338415168,
-0.0582064502,
0.0410968997,
-0.0096447989,
-0.0115229934,
-0.0289340336,
-0.0047857882,
0.0589124896,
-0.038163472,
0.0160383619,
-0.0803589448,
0.0863966569,
-0.0166944489,
0.0180874318,
-0.0029241212,
0.0020866329,
-0.0399098247,
0.0030915574,
-0.0520507507,
0.0376061462,
0.0170479398,
-0.0668905303,
-0.0282154903,
-0.0195918903,
0.003015453,
-0.023660155,
0.0057388721,
-0.0123402961,
0.0715502426,
0.0159843266,
0.0082009602,
-0.0133393547,
-0.0614976808,
-0.0097990781,
0.0511843897,
-0.0193774085,
-0.0060123024,
0.0016794415,
0.0057944297,
0.0501900055,
-0.0138058523,
0.0228660181,
0.0718610659,
-0.0654935911,
0.0085175717,
-0.0326514952,
-0.0627169833,
0.0149978194,
-0.0024614318,
0.016730424,
-0.002450736,
0.0182515401,
-0.0434162654,
-0.0875527859,
0.0119091552,
-0.0265732203,
0.020463448,
0.0134829683,
0.0180278458,
-0.0018913181,
-0.0271123126,
-0.0404461212,
-0.0066340505,
-0.0722818673,
-0.0763317719,
-0.0297658313,
-0.0133632431,
-0.0020455909,
0.0924377441,
-0.0235847607,
0.0197509229,
0.0278601535,
0.00869074,
-0.0631163716,
-0.0209103748,
-0.0090330495,
-0.0067586014,
-0.0124665322,
0.0232562367,
-0.0833744779,
-0.0002153544,
0.01564092,
0.04209546,
-0.014175293,
-0.0667367801,
0.0105250394,
0.0198699664,
-0.0249293745,
0.0211730376,
0.021695435,
-0.0618257299,
-0.0048218137,
0.0125487139,
-0.0266907718,
-0.0069783046,
0.0063290428,
-0.0124916853,
0.0016493766,
0.0190034378,
0.0011667942,
0.0476246737,
0.0414123461,
-0.0273834057,
-0.0299991611,
0.0083189402,
-0.0119616417,
0.0042922534,
-0.0174458865,
-0.0311548728,
0.0301314108,
0.0348514989,
-0.0091271773,
-0.0544557869,
0.0216586012,
0.0341464207,
0.0145406304,
-0.06417647,
0.018846456,
0.0068237935,
0.031827718,
-0.0450783372,
0.0163536426,
0.0490092114,
0.0022502125,
0.0268926136,
0.0063585299,
-0.008322184,
-0.0163629875,
0.0668685734,
-0.0235200617,
0.0131089408,
0.0514843762,
0.0098705357,
-0.0101356534,
0.0117880311,
0.0406096131,
-0.0027195718,
0.0737383813,
-0.0710096061,
-0.0329492986,
-0.0784543082,
-0.0270012002,
0.04007034,
0.0217431672,
-0.0219561979,
-0.0449334644,
-0.0191194303,
-0.0545410626,
0.0202112757,
-0.0015618185,
-0.049303934,
0.0442624651,
-0.0129740722,
0.0029745593,
0.0195672065,
-0.0326518677,
0.0210741051,
-0.0212968551,
-0.0323755555,
-0.0109645864,
-0.0013362685,
-5.478585746e-33,
-0.0473134443,
0.004606917,
0.0220419485,
-0.0564031377,
-0.0748752132,
0.018669406,
-0.0280293953,
-0.026784759,
-0.075570412,
0.0024121113,
0.0045324666,
0.0014254893,
-0.0050437041,
0.0053087436,
-0.0058810259,
-0.0317220129,
0.0375154801,
0.0248844363,
0.0143494094,
0.0448411554,
0.0040517007,
0.0179343875,
0.0428566858,
-0.1254448593,
0.0385700762,
-0.0093778763,
-0.0268368516,
0.0157790668,
0.0520741716,
0.0510923192,
-0.0073916581,
0.0421305262,
0.0314562209,
0.0095219435,
-0.0072861626,
-0.0371849984,
-0.1178586632,
-0.0084038666,
-0.0058260416,
0.0213649925,
-0.0112054776,
-0.0163030215,
0.052373264,
-0.0230935328,
0.0751133785,
-0.0413134657,
0.071776472,
-0.0060488535,
-0.0329663195,
-0.0287400372,
-0.0148132732,
0.0210892502,
-0.0089938911,
0.01621731,
-0.0167815369,
-0.0167324115,
0.0741145238,
-0.036310982,
-0.0756564215,
-0.0072046197,
-0.041187875,
-0.0329144113,
0.0391689129,
0.0090341568,
0.0102410605,
0.0583893545,
0.0201338604,
-0.0368984491,
-0.0414569937,
0.0176556613,
-0.0159911644,
0.0589389652,
-0.0318297185,
0.0995239839,
-0.0253443029,
-0.0300393142,
-0.0704094991,
0.0265037604,
-0.0052680327,
0.0267356224,
-0.0288599413,
0.0177609287,
-0.044414863,
-0.0188041497,
-0.010646306,
-0.0211525373,
-0.0312965401,
-0.0395761244,
0.0132680265,
-0.0191461183,
-0.0247582272,
0.0766640007,
0.0176369902,
-0.0489060283,
-0.0470288657,
0.0574744493,
0.0142657282,
0.0196394324,
-0.0089693395,
-0.0230416004,
-0.0388470441,
-0.0434327982,
0.0378526188,
-0.0218650941,
0.0099707069,
0.0323039554,
0.0457010008,
-0.027141761,
-0.0224406775,
0.0007061912,
-0.0142884739,
-0.0625783727,
-0.0634873062,
-0.0162232704,
0.0488475561,
0.0316075385,
-0.000808179,
0.0081468755,
0.0798532963,
0.0362444818,
-0.0132553466,
0.0139696999,
0.0460804254,
0.0443730652,
-0.0026723805,
-0.0018108302,
-0.0062481742,
-0.0657911077,
-0.0068552019,
-0.0408866815,
0.0037859173,
-0.0191221554,
2.599e-7,
0.0268538371,
-0.0548964106,
0.0613888614,
-0.0196960326,
-0.019614771,
0.0571018569,
0.005542885,
0.0570919476,
-0.0409188345,
-0.0306120627,
0.0593318492,
-0.0019373603,
-0.0221997127,
0.0437338687,
-0.0318626091,
0.0208941214,
-0.0136918873,
0.0010477208,
-0.0566770248,
0.0315750949,
0.0690667182,
0.0719689876,
0.0417492017,
0.0065332367,
-0.0001971872,
-0.0061136493,
0.0494654737,
0.0192540567,
0.0079355957,
0.028379852,
0.0025618298,
0.0190433506,
-0.0059049195,
0.0550040454,
-0.0066901054,
0.0507223904,
0.0604648031,
0.0379157253,
-0.0086822817,
-0.0108713936,
-0.0252732132,
-0.0334985219,
0.0096031139,
-0.0292971227,
0.0502554029,
-0.0406730883,
0.0025087835,
-0.0016278775,
-0.0535372831,
0.0331220031,
-0.0102758417,
0.0679683834,
0.008475746,
0.019654585,
0.0217536278,
-0.0247778986,
-0.0273374449,
-0.0716209859,
-0.0073060663,
-0.0068058246,
-0.0363819711,
-0.0100844949,
0.0211747363,
-0.0284022447,
0.0563442409,
-0.0660188273,
0.0016907062,
2.093354089e-34,
-0.0323116668,
0.0010376662,
0.0125291478,
0.0128779346,
0.0189021304,
-0.0565597117,
-0.0314056315,
0.0024421415,
-0.001866272,
-0.0444183722,
0.0081585385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06488v1
|
One Small Step for Generative AI, One Giant Leap for AGI: A Complete Survey on ChatGPT in AIGC Era
| 2023-04-04T06:22:09 | 2023-04-04T06:22:09 |
Chaoning Zhang, Chenshuang Zhang, Chenghao Li, Yu Qiao, Sheng Zheng, Sumit Kumar Dam, Mengchun Zhang, Jung Uk Kim, Seong Tae Kim, Jinwoo Choi, Gyeong-Moon Park, Sung-Ho Bae, Lik-Hang Lee, Pan Hui, In So Kweon, Choong Seon Hong
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
OpenAI has recently released GPT-4 (a.k.a. ChatGPT plus), which is
demonstrated to be one small step for generative AI (GAI), but one giant leap
for artificial general intelligence (AGI). Since its official release in
November 2022, ChatGPT has quickly attracted numerous users with extensive
media coverage. Such unprecedented attention has also motivated numerous
researchers to investigate ChatGPT from various aspects. According to Google
scholar, there are more than 500 articles with ChatGPT in their titles or
mentioning it in their abstracts. Considering this, a review is urgently
needed, and our work fills this gap. Overall, this work is the first to survey
ChatGPT with a comprehensive review of its underlying technology, applications,
and challenges. Moreover, we present an outlook on how ChatGPT might evolve to
realize general-purpose AIGC (a.k.a. AI-generated content), which will be a
significant milestone for the development of AGI.
|
[
0.0242559556,
0.0462582558,
-0.0153533658,
0.0014752271,
-0.0504437238,
-0.0000085668,
0.009316246,
0.013316418,
0.0533167012,
-0.0051374487,
-0.0045220624,
-0.0344443098,
-0.0327579677,
0.0632884502,
-0.0047217305,
-0.0569185428,
0.0233150739,
0.0107988426,
0.0246951561,
0.0008399806,
-0.040894229,
0.010732404,
-0.0118636508,
0.0448811091,
-0.0677121505,
-0.0329369344,
-0.0361105502,
-0.0225250162,
0.0303693693,
-0.0137085225,
-0.0331833437,
0.0160069354,
-0.0015326538,
0.0767615139,
0.0000022214,
-0.0456371382,
-0.0089181103,
0.0280360244,
0.0092997253,
0.0073264875,
0.0445313081,
0.0453662612,
-0.0425840653,
0.0017035421,
-0.0667782351,
-0.0116479397,
0.0689386353,
0.0466426127,
0.0305057988,
0.085978061,
-0.0272036102,
-0.02880699,
0.0639103726,
-0.0226261932,
0.04156629,
-0.0463803299,
-0.0040196758,
0.0148386015,
0.0147482846,
-0.0080003478,
-0.0044454057,
0.0109962141,
0.05286818,
0.0038398714,
0.0046856231,
0.0658485293,
-0.044308003,
-0.0077290237,
-0.0073954593,
0.034183111,
0.0077926996,
-0.0298446603,
0.0076431381,
-0.0159279797,
0.0078218048,
-0.0068199658,
-0.0262866784,
0.0520380177,
-0.0132683013,
0.0341020823,
0.025397921,
0.0223460384,
0.0021371956,
-0.0169083346,
-0.0232428815,
0.0225190893,
0.0342705548,
-0.0116542457,
-0.0239668638,
0.0023766842,
-0.0352103636,
-0.044003889,
-0.0306541659,
0.0330267139,
-0.0135749578,
-0.0164273847,
-0.0334657356,
0.0029386033,
-0.0113726417,
-0.0188104324,
0.0091110943,
0.0665921792,
-0.0051345387,
0.0075120581,
-0.0091023501,
0.0448422618,
-0.0283725653,
0.0020292788,
-0.0327276625,
-0.0293132272,
-0.0602984577,
-0.0107592084,
-0.0767272487,
0.0324940272,
-0.0294608306,
-0.0752173737,
-0.0349598266,
0.0537716262,
-0.0263508894,
-0.0068195537,
0.0246460121,
0.0369268619,
-0.0696653649,
0.0060266154,
-0.0007498272,
-0.036519628,
-0.0401318893,
0.0006083648,
0.0335667096,
-0.0427947603,
0.001633845,
0.0174114294,
0.016046267,
0.0134210475,
-0.0174288414,
0.0710391104,
-0.0101258392,
-0.0182010382,
-0.0296549592,
-0.0106105888,
0.0015240236,
-0.0706071407,
0.0338850655,
-0.0349285901,
0.0274378993,
-0.0370631292,
-0.0024223949,
-0.0240994114,
-0.0086787492,
-0.0070732981,
-0.0031312755,
0.0276931133,
-0.0111461896,
0.0062885736,
0.0350464322,
0.0042652329,
-0.0057055028,
0.0629981235,
0.0555082262,
0.0425359048,
0.0157310162,
0.0228351094,
0.0577292815,
0.0333536714,
0.023253262,
0.0090215588,
0.0523608178,
-0.0637352243,
-0.0012244757,
0.0202036649,
0.002649724,
0.0566455908,
-0.0434194319,
-0.0005077493,
0.0433659777,
0.0541543625,
-0.000408492,
0.0829031616,
0.0869487002,
0.0050176131,
0.0073840255,
0.0369453318,
0.0045309765,
0.0358211249,
-0.0411859676,
0.0059499708,
0.00070453,
0.0420479365,
-0.0341439582,
-0.0189525206,
0.0279273838,
-0.0278357174,
0.0334689282,
-0.0610320494,
0.0360778533,
0.0192829967,
-0.0379435234,
-0.0674770325,
0.0054181763,
-0.0669445395,
-0.0145413056,
-0.0979902968,
0.0408180021,
0.0290426034,
0.0679342672,
-0.0050846767,
-0.0547164343,
0.0493745506,
-0.0528948642,
0.0640599728,
0.0370902829,
-0.0111849885,
-0.0250926651,
-0.0353459679,
0.0045600147,
-0.0094639314,
0.0156478696,
0.0438165441,
0.0337046124,
0.0360950753,
-0.0055311243,
0.032392472,
-0.0048384247,
-0.0037556966,
0.0094331102,
-0.0080920281,
0.0248873029,
-0.0114274668,
0.0781617016,
0.0119787008,
-0.0185591746,
-0.0017467891,
0.0179342814,
0.0086066304,
-0.0567727946,
0.0390031189,
-0.0163579676,
-0.0086351465,
0.0068058968,
-0.0732231736,
0.0110356072,
-0.0166871846,
-0.042333141,
-0.0596551672,
0.0332989544,
0.0064337971,
0.056753695,
-0.0627714917,
-0.0132364212,
0.0384866074,
0.0217005834,
0.0211756527,
0.079500556,
0.0366550386,
-0.0809043497,
0.0146056768,
0.0513093434,
0.041105371,
-0.0432663858,
0.0181090124,
0.0447096899,
-0.0041277255,
-0.007405024,
0.0343442857,
0.0305916071,
-0.0380387492,
-0.0276106223,
-0.1186941043,
0.0011249622,
0.0109756971,
-0.001307937,
0.0086469939,
0.014398179,
-0.0150307827,
0.0336336792,
-0.0445249528,
0.055851303,
0.0615599193,
-0.0426990278,
0.0037347749,
0.0098957689,
0.0191993024,
-0.0184708834,
0.0250481386,
-0.014845903,
-0.0005022,
0.0542611629,
-0.0394725166,
-0.0368744247,
0.0324860774,
-0.0578081682,
0.0332312919,
-0.0131359212,
-0.0464287102,
0.0390250869,
-0.0374586321,
0.0510831103,
0.0337429568,
0.0002149733,
0.0531439409,
-0.0054966789,
-0.0273131803,
-0.0277234986,
0.0373386443,
-0.0501831435,
-0.020956561,
0.0274200402,
-0.0058088549,
0.0279319566,
0.0279466584,
0.0272612534,
-0.0126051037,
-0.1058760211,
0.0160980448,
-0.0214095563,
-0.0172237679,
0.0107217273,
0.007889038,
-0.0392723493,
0.000428565,
-0.0185778942,
-0.0398362204,
0.0374493711,
0.0003102812,
0.0122067519,
-0.06402684,
0.0075941849,
-0.026343666,
0.0873143896,
0.0092622619,
0.0304802805,
0.0133711491,
-0.0071576787,
-0.0470563769,
0.0457186289,
0.0093648694,
0.0044685863,
-0.0321429148,
-0.0336738341,
0.0184834842,
0.0017892272,
-0.0344112664,
-0.0349426754,
0.0215408057,
0.0294036623,
0.0093629221,
0.0762190297,
-0.0478338413,
-0.0143080037,
-0.0060323193,
-0.0324907079,
0.0390523672,
-0.0429094583,
-0.0167031419,
-0.0201792475,
0.0303395372,
0.0526177026,
0.0026605704,
-0.0172405131,
0.0389193296,
-0.0107369954,
0.084104903,
0.019843746,
-0.0027748924,
-0.024595296,
0.0002517231,
0.014358134,
-0.0161097199,
-0.0076653641,
0.0241320468,
0.019254595,
-0.0195702631,
-0.0119082704,
0.0719544739,
0.0195739418,
-0.0516848303,
-0.001876952,
0.0271913521,
0.0101367095,
-0.0348417796,
0.0294490699,
-0.1041682586,
0.0182054564,
-0.0082749957,
-0.0121796764,
-0.044537738,
-0.000681971,
-0.0091358973,
-0.0963040963,
0.0998649076,
0.0225711539,
-0.0658772364,
-0.0187509637,
-0.0030628422,
0.0048564533,
-0.0030579756,
-0.0429665782,
-0.0207620896,
0.0200420246,
0.0069834623,
-0.0038152204,
-0.0295447446,
-0.0526761524,
-0.024820419,
-0.00563577,
0.0728307441,
0.0816042423,
0.0603212975,
0.0152815487,
-0.0275837276,
0.0116627906,
0.0301331542,
0.0054659899,
-0.0141682578,
0.0384296738,
-0.0006265964,
0.002853866,
-0.0113309752,
0.0410395972,
0.0127292303,
-0.0206217486,
0.0166792218,
0.0835500509,
-0.0502182618,
-0.040651653,
-0.0397691205,
-0.016350884,
0.0302553382,
0.062923573,
-0.0012784984,
-0.0190011319,
-0.0567012392,
-0.0498354919,
0.0374763235,
-0.0563806519,
-0.0313067697,
-0.0323155485,
0.0211824682,
-0.0772863775,
-0.0790307,
-0.0518457368,
0.0121975858,
0.0302761756,
-0.0053789909,
-0.0485086255,
-0.0097157238,
0.0156424977,
-0.0057719885,
-0.0702134073,
-0.0347389244,
-0.0494427979,
-0.0348278694,
-0.0657154992,
0.0257143788,
-0.0586053506,
-0.0119414609,
0.0460859165,
-0.0418497398,
-0.04573128,
0.0133556528,
0.0540562384,
0.0242535546,
0.0039155129,
-0.0298638642,
0.0336315446,
0.0589794554,
0.0592421331,
0.0080871349,
0.0196070168,
0.0137877045,
0.0298847891,
-0.005622277,
0.0060064713,
-0.0288149696,
0.0433750525,
-0.0174074695,
0.0185774174,
0.0194010586,
-0.0020933677,
0.032406684,
0.0241469815,
0.0032438822,
-0.0314856358,
0.0199497975,
-0.0510842316,
-0.0264612343,
-0.028813526,
0.0279812347,
-0.0611070544,
-0.0035414963,
0.0184870251,
0.0193460491,
-0.004249135,
0.0031045147,
-0.0062854732,
0.0039313775,
-0.0537015162,
-0.0726323053,
0.0155624263,
0.0332636312,
-0.0189110152,
-0.0068760333,
-0.0004308771,
-0.0005711769,
-0.0125673963,
0.0080296788,
-0.0266226828,
0.0695063248,
0.0366613194,
-0.0097505283,
0.0032175435,
0.0500626937,
-0.0740160421,
-0.0540748127,
-0.024887953,
0.1232297793,
0.0735586137,
0.0636993647,
0.0388937071,
-0.0873322934,
-0.0107013825,
0.0151759433,
0.0147000756,
0.0240457114,
-0.0449353792,
-0.058733061,
-0.0188196991,
-0.0228653327,
-0.0288442262,
0.0839134231,
-0.0381182209,
0.0574832596,
-0.0348913111,
-0.0116644818,
-0.0309843719,
-0.0574078783,
-0.0186967086,
-0.0047674105,
0.0203063395,
0.0161186066,
-0.0324307792,
-0.0276788138,
-0.0447263084,
0.0394382812,
0.0181490984,
-0.0078304615,
0.0606414974,
0.0398471318,
-0.0324733593,
-0.0345971622,
-0.0016836029,
-0.039518185,
-0.0663841665,
-0.0024540233,
-0.0028267903,
-6.678275077e-33,
-0.0403407104,
-0.0061958227,
0.0349748433,
0.0519950949,
-0.0475494489,
-0.0230116621,
-0.0275054853,
-0.0042676097,
0.023131093,
0.0109544648,
-0.0201437399,
0.0250231829,
0.0066808322,
0.0315352045,
0.0014384479,
-0.0038226482,
0.0306423288,
-0.0185334403,
-0.0395826772,
0.0680279881,
0.0258910526,
-0.0242117103,
0.0157896448,
-0.0627069622,
-0.005455819,
-0.0177100655,
-0.0504233725,
-0.0382528417,
-0.0456853062,
0.0574858785,
-0.0414194986,
0.0015381792,
0.0226569809,
0.0027137506,
0.0182897206,
-0.0167727023,
-0.0484588034,
-0.0614717752,
-0.0394265801,
-0.0213199165,
-0.0787678808,
-0.0563170277,
-0.0125960056,
-0.0064465669,
-0.0583000779,
0.0027452817,
0.0167343132,
-0.0000217093,
0.0150650954,
-0.046974726,
-0.0645578206,
-0.0034095405,
-0.0060133548,
0.0041845697,
-0.0088493256,
-0.0159460846,
0.002459015,
-0.0055019222,
-0.006809969,
0.0591523387,
0.0031115641,
-0.0267378781,
0.0199101605,
-0.0251481328,
0.0498293936,
0.0163261965,
0.0050665168,
-0.0249812491,
-0.0652090758,
-0.0171623193,
-0.0339570269,
0.0536207557,
-0.001845905,
0.0331184566,
0.0263906196,
-0.0278656501,
-0.0297731906,
0.0717543662,
0.0281550605,
0.0111395149,
-0.0055088415,
0.0042561931,
-0.0392229855,
0.0047678417,
0.0359436683,
-0.0387515798,
-0.0069111083,
-0.0578969717,
0.0161720645,
-0.0073642484,
-0.0060783806,
-0.0152668003,
0.0337130539,
-0.0399231203,
0.0610569082,
0.0252005551,
-0.0437988006,
0.0446944796,
0.0052210335,
-0.0128609911,
-0.0423198752,
-0.0469379984,
0.0444936045,
0.0219902098,
-0.0024177646,
0.0242687725,
-0.0115510225,
0.0733387843,
-0.0057981075,
0.0262896698,
-0.0183457471,
0.0322413072,
0.0339798853,
-0.0327377096,
0.0042803087,
-0.0108643556,
0.014995873,
0.0011848647,
0.0349681415,
0.0822816119,
-0.038282834,
-0.0001231363,
-0.0183389075,
-0.0324950814,
-0.0184526537,
0.056795381,
-0.0340386219,
-0.0072160079,
0.0024732002,
-0.0703513399,
-0.041332569,
0.0141066322,
2.923e-7,
-0.0139173716,
0.0176937636,
0.0394457951,
0.0221233033,
0.0237679742,
-0.0082628885,
0.021459084,
0.0059862486,
0.0155428136,
0.0715149716,
0.0757175311,
0.0447970219,
0.0078093549,
0.0138807306,
-0.0534439161,
0.0178600233,
-0.0364515781,
-0.0357072465,
-0.0478092171,
0.0168391578,
0.0524967276,
0.0542186126,
0.0275438093,
0.0021918609,
0.047456678,
0.0001208335,
0.0605774485,
0.0030937439,
0.0101238592,
0.0400201008,
0.0119651221,
0.0382606424,
-0.0319532715,
-0.0157199036,
0.0129897539,
0.0023998695,
0.0067251627,
0.0237922519,
-0.0071924501,
-0.0090106362,
0.0083332332,
0.0114153381,
0.0388972834,
-0.0454126298,
0.0701874346,
-0.0417887382,
-0.020924475,
-0.0272780638,
0.0078895297,
-0.0004572109,
-0.0264294129,
-0.0217340738,
-0.0081310971,
-0.0200404301,
-0.0143710189,
0.0319615379,
-0.0061370302,
-0.0663888007,
0.0517201461,
-0.0314696692,
-0.0395338871,
-0.0373474136,
-0.0103933625,
0.0056999335,
0.0560277514,
-0.0181030538,
-0.0009691052,
2.563793587e-34,
0.0215053391,
-0.0106370542,
0.0008403751,
-0.0102736726,
0.0239090808,
0.0285804365,
0.0414645262,
0.0049550743,
0.0089090234,
-0.0321599618,
-0.0556530617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01515v1
|
Text-Conditioned Sampling Framework for Text-to-Image Generation with Masked Generative Models
| 2023-04-04T03:52:49 | 2023-04-04T03:52:49 |
Jaewoong Lee, Sangwon Jang, Jaehyeong Jo, Jaehong Yoon, Yunji Kim, Jin-Hwa Kim, Jung-Woo Ha, Sung Ju Hwang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.5.4; I.2.10; I.4.m
|
Token-based masked generative models are gaining popularity for their fast
inference time with parallel decoding. While recent token-based approaches
achieve competitive performance to diffusion-based models, their generation
performance is still suboptimal as they sample multiple tokens simultaneously
without considering the dependence among them. We empirically investigate this
problem and propose a learnable sampling model, Text-Conditioned Token
Selection (TCTS), to select optimal tokens via localized supervision with text
information. TCTS improves not only the image quality but also the semantic
alignment of the generated images with the given texts. To further improve the
image quality, we introduce a cohesive sampling strategy, Frequency Adaptive
Sampling (FAS), to each group of tokens divided according to the self-attention
maps. We validate the efficacy of TCTS combined with FAS with various
generative tasks, demonstrating that it significantly outperforms the baselines
in image-text alignment and image quality. Our text-conditioned sampling
framework further reduces the original inference time by more than 50% without
modifying the original generative model.
|
[
0.003517983,
0.0606417581,
0.0133905094,
0.012278893,
-0.0378059186,
0.0032125225,
0.048180569,
0.0378515311,
-0.0257212631,
0.0018139431,
-0.0123055363,
-0.0179282669,
0.0021447942,
0.0149082514,
0.0245018918,
-0.0783031359,
-0.0397333428,
-0.0384331346,
-0.0308955051,
-0.0131756673,
-0.0072609,
0.0331168845,
-0.0012429495,
0.0003786579,
-0.0807315558,
-0.0382083729,
0.0115658697,
0.0304429382,
0.0330231898,
-0.0437327772,
-0.0425522067,
0.0459721312,
0.0138475792,
0.0068285563,
0.0000022374,
-0.0040467246,
-0.0100411242,
0.0322153941,
0.0372973159,
-0.0056205695,
0.0863560736,
-0.0543702431,
-0.0091272611,
-0.0259514917,
0.0114201829,
0.0072146263,
0.0676749572,
0.0743152574,
0.0543770678,
0.022950368,
-0.0248503853,
-0.0140112657,
-0.0382685922,
-0.0447779074,
-0.0037958985,
-0.0292440057,
-0.0076154782,
0.0049123452,
-0.031953305,
0.0202676728,
-0.0364941396,
0.0609515496,
0.0443441495,
-0.0291677266,
0.0590709187,
0.0800122619,
0.0279923864,
-0.0158956088,
-0.0076800934,
0.0281019974,
-0.0548628606,
-0.0225099325,
-0.0086095594,
-0.0356016681,
-0.0090272846,
0.0150395185,
-0.0369955152,
0.0127492948,
-0.0157916807,
0.0648722425,
-0.038865447,
0.0367696397,
0.0070517426,
-0.0392773263,
-0.0364725031,
0.0009004401,
0.0218319725,
-0.0013592871,
-0.0593883432,
0.0227609891,
-0.0479871742,
-0.0446212851,
0.0807088017,
0.0030514898,
0.0173945446,
0.003330128,
-0.0960033685,
-0.1367246211,
-0.0101551367,
0.0300443619,
0.0045563695,
0.0247416589,
-0.0251740105,
0.0394331738,
-0.0586604737,
0.0136034489,
-0.0035296998,
0.0405163541,
-0.0481030159,
-0.0347283632,
0.021022452,
-0.0056362366,
-0.0694397688,
0.0226287916,
-0.0768690556,
-0.03667932,
-0.0192991123,
-0.0085486481,
0.0078382408,
0.0102400556,
0.0130432379,
0.0218385961,
-0.1042403951,
-0.0141575746,
0.0132281398,
-0.0435365103,
-0.0292048678,
0.0085599301,
0.0211545061,
-0.0155900614,
-0.0413757563,
0.005624041,
0.0529991724,
-0.0327143781,
-0.0249766186,
0.0860617831,
-0.0473779812,
-0.0011731816,
-0.016353203,
0.019215785,
-0.0297761429,
-0.0082135629,
0.0258047525,
-0.0488136075,
0.0525969155,
-0.0046821842,
0.0159810279,
-0.0133326072,
-0.0012367357,
0.0211094785,
0.0151568949,
0.0323683061,
0.0181369856,
-0.0247914735,
0.0444057733,
0.0013820956,
-0.0157287754,
0.0572244264,
0.0235489272,
0.0802325159,
-0.0012975704,
0.0219381507,
0.0026826577,
0.0387643576,
0.0652335063,
0.0181679074,
0.0165264141,
-0.0185041558,
0.0154512823,
0.016684914,
0.0963610858,
0.0696291178,
-0.0402114615,
-0.0144365225,
0.0838127285,
0.0498829372,
-0.0132152997,
0.0229613762,
0.0544149131,
0.0355113447,
-0.0195140634,
0.0242729057,
0.0225786418,
0.0530687161,
0.0711562857,
0.0317374468,
0.0482521392,
0.0530609488,
-0.0313182436,
-0.0362220295,
0.0132055152,
0.0058459952,
-0.0323426463,
-0.015153626,
0.0653024018,
0.05766261,
-0.0718623251,
-0.0057983538,
-0.0166306812,
-0.0394309312,
-0.0018094083,
-0.0199738499,
0.0489700064,
0.0448086783,
0.0313550457,
0.0071228328,
0.0492031723,
0.010779663,
-0.0018036334,
0.0707506463,
-0.0370925926,
0.04412679,
0.0430204906,
-0.0282901954,
-0.0195204224,
-0.0085914675,
-0.0342012234,
0.025292391,
-0.0050354544,
0.0463994853,
-0.0106516648,
-0.0373159721,
-0.0033516863,
0.0640016571,
0.0347761996,
-0.0388808958,
0.0230869595,
0.0221356675,
0.0385363512,
-0.0215336513,
-0.0352370329,
-0.0049286038,
-0.0016777703,
-0.0636857748,
-0.000152541,
0.0077799456,
-0.0561393872,
-0.0917589143,
-0.0459549129,
-0.0916928947,
-0.0409022644,
0.0224966668,
-0.0359974429,
-0.0305971075,
0.0035710284,
-0.0221470762,
0.0236379709,
-0.0497784503,
-0.0178624336,
0.0425565466,
0.0436100326,
0.0126868682,
0.0537490547,
-0.0319915451,
-0.0277848504,
0.0199981164,
0.0390298069,
-0.0203126762,
-0.0388343036,
0.0014536633,
-0.0569454394,
0.0043572043,
-0.0151171293,
-0.0078390865,
0.007506548,
-0.043739941,
-0.0088155344,
-0.0513081364,
-0.0089500649,
-0.0092944559,
-0.0183526408,
0.0052848053,
-0.0028376826,
0.010779297,
-0.0016070682,
-0.0292716883,
-0.0473900586,
-0.0087374188,
-0.0310825408,
0.0408696756,
-0.0243509784,
0.0268605426,
-0.0040076352,
0.0013324135,
0.0458802432,
0.0383725576,
0.0309067145,
-0.0340912119,
-0.0365687013,
-0.0008940085,
0.0236126147,
0.0021984999,
-0.0071131787,
-0.0126619041,
-0.0013541154,
0.0189355072,
0.0618645027,
0.0630801618,
0.034711998,
0.0028266022,
-0.0419209711,
0.0264916904,
-0.0303099025,
0.009230908,
-0.0304488558,
0.036019545,
0.0397668667,
-0.049777437,
0.0317450054,
0.0412359051,
0.0338183232,
0.0139839565,
-0.0640079007,
-0.0000328746,
-0.0088989967,
-0.0440027751,
-0.0470537953,
0.0408808775,
0.0028683946,
-0.0216500796,
-0.0671328157,
-0.0769893229,
0.0643140674,
-0.0511316694,
-0.0121632945,
-0.018840583,
0.0243750028,
0.011124556,
0.0146629494,
0.0420322679,
0.0525826178,
0.0248770602,
-0.0072021266,
-0.0293444041,
0.0111771682,
0.0072176033,
0.0015909232,
-0.0048265178,
-0.0052840505,
0.0233278926,
-0.0222084653,
-0.0303022861,
-0.0268874466,
-0.0373860262,
0.0338205062,
-0.000798082,
0.0519064628,
-0.0005693136,
-0.0055979015,
0.0181850232,
-0.0069266339,
0.0161312111,
0.0068867812,
-0.0320856012,
-0.0193777792,
0.0483130924,
0.0391046964,
-0.0465570353,
-0.0143934079,
-0.0455211215,
0.0172651112,
0.0732067749,
0.0607266538,
0.0125909178,
-0.0239964072,
-0.0025685104,
0.0033913725,
0.0465038493,
0.0206123628,
0.0073933178,
0.0593531244,
-0.0501927622,
-0.0187088009,
0.0582993217,
-0.0030541026,
-0.0036885082,
-0.0181825366,
0.0208231192,
0.0458872579,
-0.0182414539,
-0.0049413261,
-0.0803988352,
-0.0193844717,
-0.022886768,
0.020503886,
-0.0133915683,
0.017090654,
-0.0119432965,
-0.0690490231,
0.069917351,
0.0189953726,
-0.060794536,
-0.0158847664,
-0.016728973,
0.0126099838,
0.0150165968,
0.0168778151,
-0.0119046727,
0.0369152278,
0.0053670467,
0.0340593085,
0.028922148,
0.0068350411,
-0.0394076891,
-0.029254185,
0.0030611004,
0.0293780882,
0.0256224182,
0.032824859,
-0.0704653561,
-0.0120684784,
0.0125355702,
-0.0042729261,
-0.0177109726,
0.0559204817,
-0.0114143239,
-0.019539142,
-0.0014073453,
0.0662642866,
0.0051193759,
-0.0128999464,
0.0015707974,
0.0139758736,
0.0196628254,
-0.0235103369,
-0.0648191124,
0.0050854562,
0.0346251987,
0.0446162298,
0.0319343023,
-0.0532699861,
-0.0456410162,
-0.0261440109,
0.0425274558,
-0.1387577653,
0.012349152,
0.0283959731,
-0.0278729685,
-0.0538761802,
-0.0688530281,
0.0169939417,
0.0318079293,
0.0866825208,
-0.0132111078,
0.0196541771,
-0.0122334622,
-0.0245491527,
-0.0132374661,
0.0286776088,
-0.0579117052,
-0.014750421,
-0.0361396968,
-0.0292571504,
-0.0197040699,
-0.0700415745,
-0.0410209186,
0.063201569,
-0.0999240279,
-0.0087180613,
0.0027041039,
0.0634231195,
0.005491816,
0.0406097434,
-0.0146804536,
-0.0205263831,
0.1089532599,
0.0438610427,
0.0008987894,
0.0078307288,
-0.0125194965,
0.0005140543,
-0.0087182345,
0.025965983,
-0.0466647893,
0.0582122765,
0.0180031974,
0.006932002,
0.0070297862,
0.0404482596,
0.0147425262,
-0.0136118792,
0.0075705242,
-0.0771860033,
0.0412491187,
-0.0095138,
0.0082372185,
-0.0149993049,
-0.0215811115,
-0.0613692738,
-0.0008244647,
-0.0081662545,
0.0098217279,
-0.0150177041,
0.0025474366,
0.0181750208,
0.0301787518,
-0.0152080106,
-0.0423776209,
-0.043837294,
0.0108711673,
0.0057269242,
0.0017954624,
-0.0092439214,
-0.0326864049,
-0.0060851141,
0.0154010048,
0.0166173726,
0.0321275555,
0.0424107425,
0.0054833768,
-0.0093019847,
0.0164865982,
-0.0209835023,
0.011845205,
-0.0601196475,
0.0076380149,
0.0372580923,
-0.0126840826,
0.0314812213,
-0.0288554449,
-0.0047518308,
-0.004501713,
0.0255142543,
0.0338259451,
-0.0466178209,
0.0153684951,
-0.0386618488,
0.0244392175,
-0.0281612203,
0.0695230439,
0.006172624,
-0.0141781587,
-0.0012857993,
-0.0096121924,
-0.0384590141,
0.0016719335,
-0.0069246278,
-0.0179495327,
0.0373007841,
-0.0015267677,
-0.010226327,
-0.0557124205,
0.0214168038,
0.0376633406,
-0.0280755889,
0.0030404613,
0.0636284873,
0.0011078113,
-0.0150443995,
-0.0515020937,
0.0079262797,
0.0583741739,
0.0128463516,
-0.0299794823,
0.0005394954,
-6.499927604e-33,
-0.0618033595,
-0.0395131521,
0.0051526022,
-0.0302175488,
-0.0238309819,
-0.0113384388,
-0.0281880535,
-0.0389358625,
0.0253680032,
0.0246724579,
-0.0115588149,
-0.0081209354,
0.0151272481,
0.0895692185,
-0.0512064099,
0.0343001038,
0.0664418861,
-0.02476486,
-0.0376347303,
0.0260081645,
0.0298895687,
0.0237184819,
0.018042434,
-0.0344725475,
-0.0263110828,
-0.0210583862,
-0.0075275567,
-0.0472778939,
0.0414959341,
0.0264298208,
-0.0054445569,
0.00729647,
-0.0068761376,
-0.0433417335,
-0.0254024044,
0.0294997003,
-0.0875626057,
-0.0041893707,
-0.0104346061,
0.0061291275,
-0.0697491094,
-0.0575754903,
0.0388978161,
-0.0060590692,
0.0063271271,
-0.0305806492,
0.0363604687,
-0.0307859816,
-0.02509881,
-0.0264781211,
-0.0364193022,
0.0096182656,
-0.0423779972,
0.0026823615,
0.0256752986,
0.0113737043,
0.0175944753,
0.0595387705,
-0.0523693822,
-0.0202319473,
0.010532367,
0.0275195576,
0.0644256249,
0.0611085519,
0.0377281234,
0.0311514549,
0.0059715193,
-0.0158082619,
-0.0128745586,
0.0078789974,
-0.0047008437,
0.0429310203,
0.0356995761,
0.0171775743,
0.0459557325,
-0.0166248716,
-0.0733200312,
0.0594465435,
-0.0708085075,
-0.0079320613,
0.0604597479,
0.0261472892,
0.0190814659,
0.0122915031,
-0.0321464166,
-0.0355350561,
-0.0180179905,
-0.000520375,
0.0320026092,
0.0423234254,
-0.0425156392,
-0.001786414,
0.0532423444,
0.0208263732,
-0.0184918866,
-0.0598953031,
-0.0183054004,
0.0376859978,
-0.0099154366,
0.0024912863,
-0.0397032201,
-0.0105963256,
0.061599385,
0.0655361861,
-0.0010139518,
0.0072600306,
0.0543238968,
-0.0336205177,
-0.0556820221,
-0.0026367407,
-0.0663012192,
0.0518970266,
-0.0057872334,
-0.0041594496,
0.0247382894,
-0.0249886923,
-0.0297576431,
-0.0008992432,
-0.0139898499,
-0.0173700638,
-0.0248165932,
0.0285148509,
-0.009898684,
-0.0167536829,
-0.0345713235,
0.02179523,
-0.0249085892,
0.0200684965,
0.0733594596,
-0.0610983595,
-0.0402054563,
0.0542364046,
2.742e-7,
0.0289568678,
-0.014303281,
0.0183485467,
-0.0085345116,
0.0127233434,
0.0312121324,
0.0038899581,
0.0379713774,
0.005091459,
0.0064297146,
-0.0025193316,
0.0378405266,
0.0574227124,
0.0236826688,
-0.0582829714,
0.0181796569,
-0.0320195556,
0.0450069532,
-0.0172676574,
0.0178466104,
0.016905399,
0.0626862571,
-0.0142629463,
-0.0099030128,
0.0762834623,
-0.0105705801,
0.0766764879,
-0.0059368233,
0.0197578203,
-0.0008935434,
-0.0226812996,
0.0016289506,
-0.010912112,
0.0132228341,
-0.0140379695,
-0.0279970728,
0.0695899352,
0.028679451,
-0.0099166306,
-0.0245993324,
-0.0072587715,
0.0190892406,
-0.0047249915,
-0.0410058275,
0.0469254367,
-0.0726063922,
-0.0027993117,
-0.0077547724,
-0.0341395885,
0.0367679372,
-0.0235940665,
-0.0090005444,
-0.0409787335,
0.0453947745,
0.0710506961,
0.0249041095,
-0.0149600329,
-0.0377196744,
-0.030291995,
-0.0614859313,
-0.0488866344,
-0.0341955163,
-0.0831650421,
0.0319684781,
0.0297524072,
-0.0257884581,
-0.0394167379,
2.296240511e-34,
-0.0056639281,
-0.034390375,
-0.0202573352,
0.0170938298,
0.0045729135,
-0.0194711201,
-0.0062215496,
0.0014410734,
-0.0079990439,
-0.0382354744,
-0.0264884252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01492v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01492v5
|
A Unified Contrastive Transfer Framework with Propagation Structure for Boosting Low-Resource Rumor Detection
| 2023-04-04T03:13:03 | 2023-10-17T02:37:46 |
Hongzhan Lin, Jing Ma, Ruichao Yang, Zhiwei Yang, Mingfei Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The truth is significantly hampered by massive rumors that spread along with
breaking news or popular topics. Since there is sufficient corpus gathered from
the same domain for model training, existing rumor detection algorithms show
promising performance on yesterday's news. However, due to a lack of
substantial training data and prior expert knowledge, they are poor at spotting
rumors concerning unforeseen events, especially those propagated in different
languages (i.e., low-resource regimes). In this paper, we propose a unified
contrastive transfer framework to detect rumors by adapting the features
learned from well-resourced rumor data to that of the low-resourced with only
few-shot annotations. More specifically, we first represent rumor circulated on
social media as an undirected topology for enhancing the interaction of user
opinions, and then train a Multi-scale Graph Convolutional Network via a
unified contrastive paradigm to mine effective clues simultaneously from post
semantics and propagation structure. Our model explicitly breaks the barriers
of the domain and/or language issues, via language alignment and a novel
domain-adaptive contrastive learning mechanism. To well-generalize the
representation learning using a small set of annotated target events, we reveal
that rumor-indicative signal is closely correlated with the uniformity of the
distribution of these events. We design a target-wise contrastive training
mechanism with three event-level data augmentation strategies, capable of
unifying the representations by distinguishing target events. Extensive
experiments conducted on four low-resource datasets collected from real-world
microblog platforms demonstrate that our framework achieves much better
performance than state-of-the-art methods and exhibits a superior capacity for
detecting rumors at early stages.
|
[
0.0345125683,
0.0551738665,
0.0343282633,
0.0663359761,
-0.0225855093,
-0.022032205,
0.0020917268,
0.0129034612,
-0.0017162695,
-0.0247259084,
-0.0098022604,
-0.0179287624,
-0.0204658508,
0.0542352088,
-0.0088653006,
-0.0166144725,
0.0435739122,
0.0261670742,
0.0295640919,
-0.0283836853,
0.03327021,
0.051820755,
0.0082923044,
0.014276999,
-0.0393548943,
-0.0097085368,
0.0338923372,
0.0417164043,
0.0137354964,
-0.0500603691,
-0.0087851239,
0.0217258967,
0.0626198351,
0.0203606449,
0.0000018433,
-0.0279029813,
-0.0382256024,
-0.0084865596,
-0.0093672173,
-0.0375156887,
0.0686194673,
-0.0683833435,
0.0058404668,
0.015065481,
-0.0206811875,
-0.0238195397,
0.0313782468,
0.0572008602,
0.035999734,
0.1049385071,
-0.041704949,
-0.0141078159,
0.0129178679,
-0.0309438016,
0.0103588551,
-0.0934654102,
0.0507600829,
-0.0249640271,
-0.0636649653,
0.0299707614,
-0.0087216571,
-0.0284609124,
0.0031611302,
-0.0059168455,
0.0128878076,
0.0353868008,
-0.0097046178,
-0.0040742517,
-0.0112754609,
0.0421761125,
-0.0058836485,
-0.04455081,
-0.0079479776,
-0.0002784918,
0.0177929811,
0.0270793755,
-0.0601039603,
-0.0216737073,
0.0014925532,
0.0501952097,
0.0347485356,
-0.0046288082,
0.0441759452,
0.0179702416,
0.0521170571,
0.0377853252,
-0.0138337472,
-0.0015506268,
-0.0042572389,
0.0267230254,
-0.0263174102,
-0.0605478026,
0.0053710137,
0.0222010557,
-0.0167263262,
-0.0010255139,
-0.0765227526,
-0.0122841951,
-0.0050576362,
-0.1170104891,
-0.0482638553,
-0.0110004367,
-0.0042923274,
0.062390618,
0.0086380616,
-0.0701559111,
-0.0458091125,
0.0024788948,
0.0180216283,
-0.022787679,
0.0044822348,
0.0520034805,
-0.0174630731,
0.0072470075,
-0.015978761,
0.0020999452,
-0.0185517929,
-0.0080958148,
-0.0003940572,
-0.0295712147,
-0.0305349194,
0.0314791165,
-0.0529714078,
-0.029311765,
0.0061442461,
0.0576502867,
0.0102093397,
0.0371992476,
-0.0054067471,
-0.0226859134,
-0.0419473574,
0.0106895883,
0.026034439,
0.0045895264,
0.0066919951,
0.0277344659,
0.015755238,
-0.0098694311,
-0.0553967021,
-0.001175906,
-0.0122110089,
-0.0252931658,
0.0171803143,
-0.0725151822,
-0.0083380044,
-0.0261044018,
-0.0038626494,
-0.0144192949,
0.0050131939,
-0.0133623313,
-0.0576898567,
0.0427059717,
-0.0308465939,
-0.0250714403,
0.0334147699,
0.0309612788,
-0.0342431664,
0.0768651813,
0.0187356416,
0.0868080258,
0.0379892811,
0.0180801153,
-0.0375281721,
-0.0093411589,
0.0773042515,
0.0171383228,
0.0384424068,
-0.0232096165,
-0.0570575073,
-0.0439071991,
0.0259404574,
0.0144884428,
-0.0103528062,
-0.041629985,
0.0509788692,
-0.0399866626,
-0.0622101091,
0.015113431,
0.0338701941,
0.0463233963,
-0.0682163015,
-0.0021297836,
-0.0384649709,
0.0210757628,
-0.054687921,
-0.02844177,
0.0340220183,
0.0438499041,
-0.0341990404,
-0.0055142264,
0.0225092825,
-0.0003428069,
0.0205066912,
-0.0268514901,
0.0385233723,
0.0269360263,
-0.0359422602,
0.062379811,
0.0740496069,
0.0374129005,
-0.0100554097,
-0.0301184356,
-0.0077347318,
0.030258419,
0.007206481,
0.0370097831,
0.0072689014,
-0.01898822,
0.0419765972,
0.0026932247,
0.0249257721,
-0.0114567699,
0.0118208807,
-0.0164651442,
-0.0077533326,
-0.0428944938,
0.0018267719,
0.0104249362,
0.0371051393,
0.049296882,
-0.0189668182,
-0.0281260554,
-0.054242257,
-0.0145393638,
0.0136282248,
-0.0295840483,
0.01660675,
0.0118603157,
0.0226330347,
0.0217749123,
-0.0019229432,
-0.0488098972,
0.0168500524,
0.0123015232,
-0.0548896417,
0.0054346151,
-0.0232278798,
-0.0623793267,
0.0229575988,
-0.0132469935,
-0.0366231613,
0.028830789,
-0.0402992517,
0.0000169376,
0.0802132934,
-0.0129597243,
0.0197849777,
-0.0021171777,
-0.0425415151,
-0.009566105,
0.0269433297,
0.0355749615,
0.0548337474,
-0.0333199985,
-0.0406606048,
-0.0265037846,
0.0026252645,
0.0274171866,
0.0231526308,
0.0020119892,
-0.01255312,
0.0000147431,
0.0211445056,
0.0287259556,
-0.0247268546,
-0.0013005098,
0.0214823522,
-0.0692880973,
0.0079769753,
-0.0183961205,
-0.0150338979,
0.06956622,
0.0335366093,
0.0372199118,
-0.0141412234,
-0.0312898792,
0.0303825811,
-0.0041336864,
0.0198142659,
-0.0005441662,
-0.0108487401,
0.0260809455,
-0.0434792154,
0.0016116691,
-0.0141387591,
0.0588233285,
0.0228907075,
-0.0537730232,
-0.01022211,
0.0077783731,
-0.0447455831,
0.0395449884,
-0.0273784436,
0.01207125,
-0.0182813331,
0.0107050259,
-0.0048668482,
0.0320332721,
0.0116545316,
0.054853119,
-0.0028597917,
0.0225112587,
-0.0070900829,
0.0058648442,
-0.0496708043,
0.0255051795,
-0.058591757,
-0.0283255596,
-0.0011826881,
0.0316672474,
0.0270525422,
0.0124190422,
-0.0263676103,
0.0030562573,
0.008974432,
-0.0096298987,
0.028375132,
-0.025338266,
0.0254747588,
-0.0012788227,
-0.0718906298,
-0.0333626829,
0.076648131,
0.0037431302,
0.0455246195,
-0.0103921592,
-0.0665872321,
-0.0109771378,
0.0110659115,
-0.0354312919,
0.0198488738,
0.0022756702,
-0.0104325991,
-0.0061884942,
-0.0527969152,
0.034252353,
-0.0204151794,
-0.0097703571,
0.0089718252,
0.0385143831,
0.0336122997,
-0.0337389633,
-0.0089482982,
-0.1025737524,
-0.0242297258,
-0.0130036362,
0.0019585423,
-0.026499711,
-0.0520395413,
-0.0030018017,
0.0060397149,
0.0050269845,
-0.0075496491,
-0.0094148163,
0.0379499681,
0.0512397178,
0.0308364015,
-0.0199749582,
0.0345910862,
-0.0083434442,
0.0053222962,
0.0928729847,
-0.0265603755,
-0.0175884478,
-0.0147480061,
-0.0327508338,
-0.0162876938,
0.0385555327,
0.0084596397,
-0.0387306847,
0.0756186843,
-0.0362993479,
-0.0161959827,
0.0742402524,
-0.0111297313,
-0.0258164536,
0.0136080496,
0.0468944386,
0.0234786384,
0.0142174168,
-0.008872224,
-0.082927987,
-0.0216087345,
-0.0368553214,
0.0024888434,
0.0322681777,
-0.0160397943,
-0.0479130596,
-0.0483974665,
0.0167117603,
-0.0099234451,
-0.014892621,
-0.0393061563,
-0.0619212501,
0.0299550258,
-0.0143861715,
0.0166327916,
-0.0354625247,
0.0306350905,
-0.0130150896,
0.0099430783,
-0.0196917895,
-0.0342270657,
0.0200833138,
-0.010195097,
0.0065214313,
0.0006460683,
0.0270546786,
-0.0060395417,
0.0051108571,
0.0051241652,
0.0356318876,
-0.0308807362,
-0.0396010168,
0.1097012758,
-0.0586704053,
-0.0013785255,
-0.0166947488,
0.0280748047,
-0.0161476377,
-0.0212209001,
-0.0292650107,
0.0213965662,
0.0361834951,
-0.0581564382,
-0.0196071491,
0.0335197523,
0.0708820969,
0.043686308,
0.0238615181,
-0.0067495946,
0.0279817041,
-0.0374249369,
-0.0145471161,
-0.0228233412,
-0.0318681486,
0.0095569286,
-0.0302750263,
-0.0712770671,
-0.0423398763,
-0.0153992949,
-0.0221745744,
0.0315010957,
-0.0448863357,
-0.0006333168,
0.0310566574,
-0.0563028976,
-0.0560009666,
0.0013675934,
-0.0094035864,
0.0108891213,
0.0384368338,
0.0025575887,
0.0284554437,
0.0079004206,
-0.014038004,
0.0484354682,
-0.1268073171,
-0.0816519633,
-0.0285355747,
0.0060889293,
0.0077571971,
0.0570212379,
-0.0414249673,
-0.0319142826,
0.0480725691,
0.0242490154,
0.0001662414,
0.0187182594,
0.022534648,
-0.0152411554,
0.055700466,
0.0307224598,
-0.0368005745,
0.0680198669,
0.0370787233,
-0.0190738775,
-0.0750062168,
-0.012165905,
0.0018779781,
0.0063463729,
0.0450264253,
0.0068141827,
-0.0061650821,
-0.0380648635,
-0.0269755442,
-0.019403832,
-0.0100632627,
-0.0169716906,
0.0119638126,
0.0265165307,
0.0059440201,
-0.0263570696,
-0.0225943401,
0.0044113696,
0.0267917328,
-0.0567266606,
-0.0336888731,
0.0271632504,
-0.0004427293,
0.0142038008,
0.0176486783,
0.0039896416,
-0.0022420576,
0.0331452601,
-0.0066743279,
0.0074777347,
-0.0310636759,
0.0198198371,
-0.0325829983,
0.0276231561,
-0.0557628945,
-0.050108254,
-0.0447393656,
-0.0606181175,
-0.0096166804,
0.0242757332,
-0.0017823653,
0.0324214622,
-0.0021700698,
-0.0066661942,
0.0147539685,
-0.006312205,
-0.0455092154,
-0.0235522762,
0.0239270497,
0.0023288764,
-0.0284876693,
0.1005195379,
0.0321830586,
-0.0139399422,
0.0327436067,
0.0334843695,
-0.0609296784,
-0.0353113152,
0.018413892,
-0.0049508852,
0.0989167914,
0.0248147584,
0.0183685385,
-0.0274090879,
-0.0461622402,
0.0230649635,
-0.0198418535,
0.0113983387,
0.043848604,
-0.0054121194,
0.0656228289,
0.0385550074,
0.0069352672,
-0.018902326,
-0.0285097063,
-0.0001596659,
-0.0545994043,
0.0270263012,
-6.65892644e-33,
0.0247543585,
-0.0370458215,
-0.0349039026,
0.0070870584,
-0.0101680188,
0.0515099913,
-0.0292746983,
-0.033921212,
-0.0527813435,
0.0639007688,
0.0535790063,
0.059964586,
-0.012028452,
0.0044494402,
-0.0491081923,
-0.0182074197,
0.0518908203,
0.0181183517,
-0.0025594335,
0.0624655038,
0.0950785354,
0.018690588,
0.076064758,
-0.1112052053,
0.0049934243,
-0.0315743722,
-0.0246459488,
0.02755576,
0.0657308921,
0.0037537515,
0.0055879578,
0.0651211813,
0.0264122337,
-0.0307380836,
-0.0059294719,
0.0157901458,
-0.045064684,
-0.0318648145,
0.0208201464,
-0.0400212146,
0.0038151103,
0.021320764,
0.0375833735,
0.0201986246,
0.0496742912,
-0.031767875,
0.0286398064,
0.0110157412,
0.0218441002,
0.0160122458,
-0.0341284275,
0.0144488877,
-0.0027462882,
-0.0126472823,
-0.0270341951,
0.0110702608,
0.0343214944,
0.0295563266,
-0.0913526267,
0.0123853656,
-0.071026735,
0.0156420339,
-0.0080275144,
-0.0356585793,
-0.0360271372,
0.0482796021,
0.0145527897,
0.0548885055,
0.0083514573,
0.0233636461,
-0.0169596616,
0.0702144206,
0.0003869806,
0.0849524811,
0.0734222755,
-0.0536493771,
-0.1334543526,
0.0106767109,
0.0477179289,
-0.0497624278,
0.0105086267,
0.0303327348,
-0.051805716,
-0.0160114635,
0.0464000367,
-0.0177449379,
-0.0292752925,
-0.0475374833,
-0.0498610698,
0.0223393906,
-0.0010906899,
0.1042918116,
0.0201382712,
-0.0426686704,
-0.0208695401,
0.0480915233,
-0.016811952,
-0.0042818673,
0.0104356054,
0.054359816,
-0.0803387016,
0.0133533794,
0.029776426,
0.0426357239,
-0.00538621,
0.0044216439,
0.0667000711,
0.0170568358,
-0.0510506108,
0.008918426,
-0.0521297827,
0.022838179,
-0.0294420272,
0.0047819517,
0.0112997321,
0.0256378744,
-0.0229195729,
0.013030394,
0.0157676805,
0.0339656621,
0.019285772,
0.0005507761,
-0.0340397209,
0.0184280071,
-0.0080854353,
-0.0203244798,
-0.0043729059,
0.0135955447,
0.0014651645,
-0.0937969983,
-0.0138133066,
-0.0167748258,
2.778e-7,
-0.0062899664,
0.0265843477,
-0.0132637052,
0.0047399215,
0.0254487973,
0.0394933112,
0.0282103028,
0.0459419303,
0.0024648015,
-0.0729483217,
-0.0263166092,
0.0842060149,
-0.0087464461,
0.0617587157,
-0.0489385463,
0.00911674,
-0.0721518025,
-0.0017631609,
-0.0265801568,
-0.0054870984,
0.0406611823,
0.0619995035,
0.0797486678,
-0.0382145643,
0.0341811217,
-0.0156904887,
0.0572917275,
0.0135167018,
-0.0736541897,
-0.0034386679,
0.0232265722,
0.01622409,
-0.0372355245,
0.0032137749,
-0.0321381353,
0.0220673326,
-0.0184957534,
-0.0169374887,
-0.0049481532,
-0.0179566294,
0.0000319326,
-0.0138786789,
0.0114035523,
-0.0033568107,
0.0397010483,
-0.0334083922,
-0.0687896684,
-0.0525943376,
-0.0413791277,
0.0348194912,
0.0169024114,
-0.0035230152,
-0.0082072299,
0.0009472604,
-0.0051519745,
0.0074988576,
-0.0367195494,
-0.046932742,
0.0205658115,
0.0453142375,
-0.0358684212,
-0.0599692315,
0.0336875245,
-0.0612548329,
0.0224986449,
-0.0148225222,
0.0743032619,
1.980719231e-34,
0.0334069096,
0.0123367896,
-0.0231373273,
-0.0027393952,
0.0006780707,
0.009368265,
-0.0297068004,
-0.0717293993,
0.0377832875,
0.002014705,
0.0000819088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01487v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01487v2
|
To ChatGPT, or not to ChatGPT: That is the question!
| 2023-04-04T03:04:28 | 2023-04-05T04:28:41 |
Alessandro Pegoraro, Kavita Kumari, Hossein Fereidooni, Ahmad-Reza Sadeghi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ChatGPT has become a global sensation. As ChatGPT and other Large Language
Models (LLMs) emerge, concerns of misusing them in various ways increase, such
as disseminating fake news, plagiarism, manipulating public opinion, cheating,
and fraud. Hence, distinguishing AI-generated from human-generated becomes
increasingly essential. Researchers have proposed various detection
methodologies, ranging from basic binary classifiers to more complex
deep-learning models. Some detection techniques rely on statistical
characteristics or syntactic patterns, while others incorporate semantic or
contextual information to improve accuracy. The primary objective of this study
is to provide a comprehensive and contemporary assessment of the most recent
techniques in ChatGPT detection. Additionally, we evaluated other AI-generated
text detection tools that do not specifically claim to detect ChatGPT-generated
content to assess their performance in detecting ChatGPT-generated content. For
our evaluation, we have curated a benchmark dataset consisting of prompts from
ChatGPT and humans, including diverse questions from medical, open Q&A, and
finance domains and user-generated responses from popular social networking
platforms. The dataset serves as a reference to assess the performance of
various techniques in detecting ChatGPT-generated content. Our evaluation
results demonstrate that none of the existing methods can effectively detect
ChatGPT-generated content.
|
[
0.0869328454,
0.0292214099,
-0.0073901708,
0.0609727725,
-0.0796280205,
0.0184203442,
0.0019528024,
0.0351403095,
0.0666381642,
-0.0372258648,
-0.0150074977,
-0.0306649376,
-0.0184121281,
0.0585776307,
0.0225281511,
0.015755171,
0.0346958786,
0.0390459038,
0.033253137,
0.0158949886,
0.032782115,
0.0183838494,
0.015555813,
0.0647538081,
-0.0304950476,
-0.033750575,
0.0315709226,
0.0087963417,
0.0027305786,
-0.0190181993,
0.047976546,
0.0540544242,
-0.0357371829,
0.1228057072,
0.0000015244,
-0.0460057892,
-0.0017292226,
-0.0034181736,
-0.0574099682,
0.0141835865,
0.0712548196,
0.002134843,
-0.0215420462,
0.0392337516,
-0.064438425,
0.0056761559,
0.0420133211,
0.0568965748,
0.0643061772,
0.091391556,
-0.0356335118,
0.0283559375,
0.0671687871,
-0.0122178905,
0.0258368179,
-0.0243978668,
0.034582708,
-0.0116752516,
-0.0018708201,
0.0291195512,
0.0096567189,
0.0400090776,
0.0138516016,
-0.0312195066,
-0.029805433,
0.0018541825,
-0.0627364889,
-0.0090364031,
-0.0167977177,
0.0472724065,
-0.043218486,
-0.0652553737,
0.0312652774,
0.0017290193,
0.0318758599,
0.0194280967,
-0.0218274482,
0.033970207,
-0.0248282943,
0.0031564005,
0.0167581588,
-0.0120851723,
0.0360838659,
0.0430616736,
0.0473725908,
0.0092906337,
0.011363009,
-0.0441120043,
0.0029411807,
0.0168001279,
0.000379997,
-0.0619301349,
0.0571879745,
0.011941866,
-0.0035437569,
-0.009937264,
-0.0716019198,
-0.0501634777,
0.0436359681,
-0.0647164062,
-0.0087770447,
0.0060103601,
-0.0166732315,
0.0539053157,
-0.0387260541,
0.0378071405,
-0.0449990518,
0.0431456007,
0.0068280897,
0.0042792722,
-0.0304044429,
-0.032740999,
-0.0344892405,
0.0255543217,
-0.0132502215,
-0.0333613157,
-0.0776900277,
0.0304095335,
0.0108456882,
0.0006789648,
-0.0024286292,
0.0061711003,
-0.0067140628,
0.0143955275,
0.015690228,
0.0017007862,
0.0075133517,
0.0163772739,
0.0224584043,
-0.0908982456,
0.0041324929,
0.0594136976,
0.0083197281,
-0.0062470664,
0.0102738226,
0.0633868501,
0.0089714322,
-0.0427816771,
-0.0203401372,
-0.0822008476,
-0.0391872227,
-0.0170876682,
0.0020232026,
-0.0714869574,
-0.0051234346,
-0.0252010617,
-0.0247171745,
-0.0148818381,
-0.0174791869,
0.0500043929,
-0.0304738469,
0.0267988984,
-0.0069166343,
-0.0047980663,
0.036756251,
0.0257236455,
-0.0189734865,
0.0535525084,
-0.0008113194,
0.0688764602,
0.0645252615,
0.0071755056,
0.0417100973,
0.0648769215,
0.032198824,
0.0046919514,
0.0323956758,
-0.0044411183,
-0.001862381,
0.0053686788,
-0.0031885924,
0.0676645488,
-0.0060858596,
-0.0669232011,
0.0900600776,
0.0639622882,
-0.0057903556,
0.0167130679,
0.0495273061,
0.0414793678,
0.0165760331,
0.0205274746,
-0.0205922462,
-0.0270728413,
-0.0497104861,
-0.0408491567,
0.0032975262,
0.0181828048,
0.0101491185,
-0.0081958985,
0.0057870792,
-0.0193515662,
0.0108866515,
-0.0352721326,
0.0034010671,
0.0073751686,
-0.0293446891,
0.0054114722,
0.0066692047,
-0.0082063694,
0.0038107466,
-0.082396701,
0.0240376275,
0.0332678184,
0.0510073788,
0.0052970164,
0.0150836818,
-0.0489220805,
0.0200155433,
0.0577796027,
0.0306650996,
0.0110567296,
-0.0222036876,
-0.0065570637,
-0.0178368185,
0.0058655785,
0.0018668362,
-0.003296939,
0.053055983,
0.0250793025,
0.0081005255,
0.0044672368,
-0.0260535963,
0.0363694467,
-0.0133073442,
-0.013202928,
0.0133242533,
-0.0106622586,
0.0461125784,
-0.0034818496,
0.00056854,
0.0064772358,
0.0059975386,
-0.0230712183,
-0.0465999693,
-0.0277710184,
-0.0147423344,
-0.0349601209,
0.0262625366,
-0.0416161753,
-0.0405968688,
0.0379241519,
-0.0275010709,
0.0199324228,
-0.008519127,
-0.0431665406,
0.0159413144,
-0.0718499571,
-0.0223773923,
-0.0145349745,
0.0547585748,
0.0008009467,
0.0496111512,
-0.026058089,
-0.0044317315,
0.0089138234,
-0.0061403187,
0.0352362581,
-0.0140225934,
0.0019225042,
-0.005500677,
-0.051777944,
0.0248222072,
0.0312613472,
0.0310122129,
-0.0427583456,
-0.0143442042,
-0.0996557251,
-0.0106824851,
-0.0218834635,
0.0317906924,
0.0603977367,
0.0039880704,
-0.0191341024,
0.0119869197,
-0.0664036199,
-0.0130359577,
0.0301560983,
0.0320231207,
0.0421771668,
-0.0363621302,
0.0279415175,
-0.0365080237,
0.0147554819,
-0.0421265289,
0.0355893858,
0.0329146422,
-0.0301604327,
-0.0099065909,
0.0133575238,
-0.0069063138,
-0.0115039609,
-0.0029342473,
-0.0473788939,
-0.0044913599,
-0.0265361909,
0.0023874757,
0.051425498,
0.0368058607,
0.0277809985,
-0.0244020838,
0.0413277112,
-0.0374473855,
-0.0199548695,
-0.0329137668,
0.0085618794,
-0.0241046529,
-0.0368506238,
0.056208048,
0.0554220229,
0.0232981648,
-0.0014197874,
-0.0374372452,
0.0339359455,
-0.0326142572,
-0.0175325628,
-0.0273812842,
-0.0236209817,
-0.0377155095,
0.0126103582,
-0.0318659469,
-0.0530109294,
0.063693665,
-0.0227351617,
0.0180603582,
-0.0431943834,
-0.0350704789,
-0.0270782728,
0.0160766933,
-0.0024162738,
0.0312319826,
0.0020163655,
-0.0201056544,
-0.0052692369,
0.0137500484,
0.0405612662,
-0.0156177385,
-0.0046119723,
-0.0025580723,
0.0281144343,
0.0137961758,
-0.0233460851,
-0.0645023882,
-0.1034380943,
-0.0040730266,
-0.021423284,
0.03451683,
-0.0365787521,
-0.0081122834,
-0.0135311782,
-0.0258282945,
0.0257010572,
-0.0318127573,
-0.0165387318,
-0.0186552741,
0.0863754004,
0.0456892289,
-0.0253159683,
0.022482276,
-0.0101913214,
-0.0108389789,
0.0930099785,
-0.0106598791,
0.0379497148,
0.0114399828,
-0.0217764843,
-0.0099432347,
-0.0079627344,
-0.0120554501,
-0.0026601786,
0.0256703924,
-0.0501566082,
0.0017790569,
0.0965694562,
0.0269016642,
-0.0364818871,
-0.0080593377,
0.0031901738,
0.0201242026,
-0.016518658,
-0.0217985641,
-0.1068947464,
-0.0269843508,
-0.014548487,
-0.0197701827,
-0.0514177606,
-0.0101228366,
-0.0143357059,
-0.0932177827,
0.0322328396,
-0.0168121327,
-0.0306574665,
-0.0070078243,
-0.0320368856,
-0.0160058271,
0.0088611906,
-0.0012581053,
-0.0580623783,
0.0015898695,
0.0008439462,
-0.0046344334,
-0.0595051572,
-0.031903591,
0.0121230474,
-0.0416902974,
0.0452199094,
0.0669064894,
0.0563854203,
-0.0092769759,
-0.0005481247,
0.0571131557,
0.0050186873,
-0.0402685329,
-0.0037846661,
0.0631691962,
-0.0185768865,
-0.0062110778,
-0.0139234783,
0.0547513254,
-0.0552438982,
0.0197581071,
0.0235188995,
0.0700475127,
-0.0009377716,
-0.0611932352,
-0.0281902011,
0.018813543,
0.0463301763,
0.081659846,
0.0459502004,
-0.035128314,
-0.0480618887,
-0.0325619914,
0.0231177285,
-0.0354451835,
-0.0536468066,
-0.0026657458,
0.0334050842,
-0.0372377038,
-0.0904112086,
-0.0439712666,
-0.0167094562,
-0.0394569822,
-0.0151280044,
0.0056207469,
0.0016772853,
-0.0077206073,
-0.0256996956,
-0.0220153909,
-0.0481853224,
0.0372308567,
-0.0530948639,
0.0092031052,
0.0070790518,
-0.0125396149,
-0.0280677471,
0.0217720624,
-0.1053787544,
-0.0414867885,
0.0082350234,
0.006910197,
0.0193321984,
0.0025412247,
-0.0438994355,
-0.0097660888,
0.0616817139,
0.0734048411,
-0.0432537086,
-0.0121913115,
0.0211701058,
-0.0014203183,
-0.0012977038,
0.0225612577,
-0.0149541609,
0.0237923395,
0.0149954949,
-0.0376569144,
-0.0516747385,
-0.0129154893,
0.0257120617,
0.0298444424,
0.0232657362,
0.0062104282,
0.0053759511,
-0.03443712,
-0.0514632575,
-0.003712252,
-0.0009219644,
-0.017044438,
0.0010999562,
0.050044924,
0.0027790486,
0.0037436604,
0.0145647526,
-0.0486624874,
0.024708271,
-0.0430330485,
-0.000589939,
0.0029404452,
0.0535285808,
0.0237005707,
-0.0063939262,
0.0029593946,
0.0550466888,
0.012227146,
0.0300430339,
-0.0145919016,
0.0361324847,
-0.0010302276,
-0.033718057,
0.0473507568,
0.030352965,
-0.067565538,
-0.0072822133,
-0.0194830149,
0.055757761,
0.0440749601,
-0.0056575034,
0.0209849626,
-0.0502416566,
-0.0228613615,
-0.0210748222,
0.0183382314,
-0.0200305227,
-0.023219306,
-0.020165259,
-0.0165450927,
-0.0382096618,
0.015249976,
0.0923285931,
0.005620914,
0.0463476218,
0.0394425765,
-0.0720881671,
-0.0509942509,
-0.0139813926,
0.0078096548,
0.0198918171,
0.0016204192,
0.0313505493,
-0.0434221961,
-0.0514958091,
-0.0095978761,
-0.017610224,
0.0190087203,
0.0238878187,
0.0023357384,
0.0834348053,
0.0016904627,
0.0342732258,
-0.0431121811,
0.0133200074,
-0.0189404488,
-0.0446906649,
-0.030747639,
-5.509643409e-33,
0.0450604819,
-0.0644020587,
-0.0138733545,
0.0379966684,
0.0049049528,
0.0303250607,
-0.0192689989,
-0.0154310809,
-0.0242294762,
0.0296137743,
0.0006115417,
0.0397049673,
-0.0041285963,
0.0342807658,
-0.0404701717,
-0.0435748175,
0.0310794339,
-0.0342600532,
-0.0216630325,
0.0487020202,
0.0318752527,
0.0224923119,
-0.0004347087,
-0.0856767073,
0.0367909968,
-0.0164302066,
-0.0217001606,
0.0119084474,
-0.0276526995,
0.0845944434,
-0.0394068807,
0.0476993807,
0.0537575744,
0.0047264025,
0.0104494011,
0.0614879392,
-0.0197316427,
-0.0370892473,
-0.0100578424,
-0.0042318385,
-0.0360813625,
-0.0581063777,
0.059421815,
-0.0274458434,
-0.0143218897,
0.0005992944,
0.0342869572,
-0.0080829365,
0.0159471538,
-0.0265453998,
-0.0473377369,
0.020859858,
-0.0076132519,
-0.0005080411,
-0.0147812283,
0.0715202987,
0.0179061294,
0.0325524211,
-0.0617181733,
0.0183715802,
-0.017547084,
0.019073844,
0.0168907437,
-0.0419485793,
-0.0044205436,
0.0568286106,
0.0323517062,
0.013068622,
-0.0211865306,
0.0031310872,
-0.0132234534,
0.0080248592,
0.0828536749,
0.0791533738,
0.019731909,
-0.0343102403,
-0.0765053704,
0.0284356996,
0.0647245869,
-0.0175996497,
0.0124491379,
-0.0236042608,
-0.0509463809,
-0.0055470387,
0.0128454277,
-0.0215462223,
-0.03377226,
-0.0341391377,
0.0372467972,
-0.0024735029,
-0.0262223668,
0.0015714387,
0.0193073135,
-0.0860263556,
0.0039278422,
0.0142907454,
-0.0217648018,
-0.0023881751,
0.0479570776,
0.0590503514,
-0.0417152606,
0.019361645,
0.0258784443,
-0.0232813824,
0.0262389146,
-0.0085991034,
0.0620611832,
0.0229269546,
-0.0590592101,
0.0099312766,
-0.0110855978,
0.040694356,
-0.0301703829,
0.0245487522,
0.0035417441,
-0.0120486487,
-0.0086448407,
0.0004552717,
0.0355768651,
0.0342949331,
-0.0439854711,
-0.0249227639,
-0.0341873877,
0.0003522546,
-0.0254142005,
-0.0123529686,
-0.050348036,
0.0361621566,
0.0246469136,
-0.0823157728,
0.0132671548,
-0.0398751087,
2.248e-7,
0.0436732434,
0.0400830656,
0.0255461447,
-0.0086032329,
0.0325162299,
0.0524752326,
0.0292450376,
0.0434688777,
-0.0184625052,
-0.0092929015,
-0.0112689734,
0.0038369277,
0.0338549986,
0.0047778091,
-0.0875138566,
-0.0013902251,
-0.1033796519,
-0.0256243702,
-0.0519257933,
0.0017852776,
0.06145069,
0.0918726921,
0.0204615556,
-0.0571307205,
0.000429134,
-0.0653920472,
0.0379018299,
-0.0050026393,
-0.0220985655,
0.0247370228,
0.0609834865,
0.0064350213,
0.023739228,
0.0095091648,
-0.0172651131,
-0.0158593003,
0.0057936157,
0.0417587385,
0.0198925193,
0.0123591023,
-0.024059955,
-0.0426281504,
0.0135865035,
-0.0608774871,
0.0713345185,
-0.0217939187,
-0.0184292905,
-0.0596473888,
-0.015667377,
-0.0707484037,
0.0602679625,
-0.0337498598,
-0.0356280617,
0.0139540983,
0.0120890196,
0.0191991683,
0.0025744683,
-0.0436617658,
-0.0082784556,
-0.0470282137,
-0.0457724929,
-0.0039547211,
-0.0364735462,
0.0028253116,
0.0477228835,
-0.0313124172,
0.0434722416,
2.13106955e-34,
0.0272068847,
-0.0183318164,
0.0197319631,
-0.0036671732,
0.0309346765,
0.0330861323,
0.0381275751,
0.0060305903,
0.0034998909,
-0.0192972384,
0.0218579024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01483v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01483v2
|
Blockwise Compression of Transformer-based Models without Retraining
| 2023-04-04T02:55:40 | 2023-09-17T22:47:50 |
Gaochen Dong, Wei Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based models, exemplified by GPT-3, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, have
recently garnered considerable attention in both academia and industry due to
their promising performance in general language tasks. Nevertheless, these
models typically involve computationally encoding processes, and in some cases,
decoding processes as well, both of which are fundamentally large-scale matrix
multiplication. These operations bring the inevitable challenges of massive
computation resources and huge memory footprint, usually requiring at least
10^23 FLOPs and hundreds of gigabytes, respectively. A common method to address
this issue is to reduce the computational and memory requirements by applying
layerwise quantization to the transformer, replacing the usual fp32 data type
with a low-bit equivalent. Unfortunately, this method often leads to decreased
model accuracy and necessitates time-consuming retraining. Such retraining not
only requires fine-tuning skills but also substantial computational resources,
posing challenges for users. To specifically tackle these issues, we propose
BCT, a framework of blockwise compression for transformers without retraining,
aiming to facilitate model deployment. Unlike layerwise compression methods,
BCT achieves finer compression of the entire transformer by operating
blockwise. This method mitigates data distribution deviation caused by
quantization, eliminating the requirement for retraining. BCT effectively
compresses all components of the model, including but not limited to the
embedding, matrix multiplication, GELU, Softmax, layer normalization, and
intermediate results. In a case study, an efficient model is compressed by BCT
achieving up to 7.988x compression. Subsequently, we also evaluate it on
several General Language Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) datasets.
|
[
-0.0222406983,
0.0488995276,
-0.008711556,
0.0488384999,
-0.0190606192,
0.0299021862,
0.0203882251,
-0.0029839617,
-0.0455444157,
-0.0128568644,
-0.0091468347,
-0.0403852612,
0.0309374724,
0.0137443151,
0.0066580926,
-0.0539688431,
0.0389132202,
-0.0012059417,
-0.0487325341,
-0.0064375787,
-0.0031708046,
0.0128672319,
0.0092906244,
0.0534885675,
0.0083706575,
-0.0193509907,
-0.0435790308,
-0.0008412819,
0.0006396172,
0.0231955107,
-0.0146818468,
0.0488497466,
0.0623340644,
0.0539891794,
0.0000022639,
0.0093024764,
-0.0432115644,
0.0170787312,
-0.0525893755,
0.0248210691,
0.026848454,
-0.0444970652,
-0.0394837223,
0.0114260418,
-0.0191035885,
-0.0637254044,
0.0768586695,
0.0278630126,
0.0757521763,
0.0443181433,
-0.0181341041,
-0.0545774139,
0.0132131632,
-0.0069801565,
-0.028896885,
-0.0470478982,
0.0030356601,
0.0283995345,
-0.0302729737,
-0.0008403129,
-0.0549617335,
0.0286772419,
0.0483811423,
0.028357381,
-0.007313956,
0.0328868032,
-0.0335263759,
-0.0444052964,
-0.016664546,
0.0307849888,
-0.058598008,
-0.0569839031,
-0.0189866964,
0.0359023437,
-0.0190481823,
-0.030217072,
-0.0505952463,
0.0424759723,
0.0049640811,
0.0253548715,
-0.0178874508,
-0.0020187721,
0.0431191511,
-0.0114459805,
-0.0538453199,
0.0540203527,
0.0308244247,
-0.0093633346,
-0.0230984427,
0.00806423,
-0.0157957263,
-0.0133172851,
0.0087673534,
0.0154960714,
0.014743574,
0.0012257418,
-0.0636628717,
-0.0308477059,
-0.0192990415,
-0.0341107547,
0.0404606946,
0.0760045052,
0.0065462426,
0.0202678759,
-0.0469543412,
0.0634891689,
-0.0357316174,
0.0297945291,
-0.0259929541,
-0.0027480121,
-0.0407627672,
-0.0257398132,
-0.0917747766,
0.0288168695,
-0.0438934192,
-0.0018430211,
-0.0400311202,
0.0316900015,
0.0058257622,
-0.0142275486,
0.0209015273,
-0.0049969475,
-0.0473975614,
0.0049379482,
0.0393560529,
0.0441748463,
-0.0122523224,
-0.0124237724,
-0.0100993048,
-0.0557256714,
-0.0393426344,
0.0150717683,
0.0036850348,
-0.0251617879,
0.0202986412,
0.0155751724,
-0.0224579964,
-0.0543883182,
-0.0272270013,
0.0099957613,
0.009491371,
-0.0414042696,
0.0093506472,
-0.0596754253,
0.0404607132,
-0.011773197,
0.0225507952,
-0.0106873941,
-0.0095908409,
0.0336485542,
-0.0022143878,
0.0663238466,
-0.0060136858,
-0.0123239588,
-0.0009247351,
0.0244020186,
0.0389032103,
0.0593533702,
0.0357065946,
0.0097102514,
-0.0096461978,
-0.0580568239,
-0.023145156,
0.0413494594,
0.0307425037,
0.0039308183,
-0.0321899317,
-0.0085283471,
0.0125839449,
0.0093801636,
0.0477526002,
0.0663223192,
-0.0534421317,
-0.0223128963,
0.0501350835,
0.024119271,
0.0385508761,
0.0979083851,
0.01500405,
0.0278927572,
0.0076740859,
-0.0004670742,
-0.0227111969,
0.0543395504,
-0.0012859638,
0.0218275823,
-0.0040745968,
0.1013360471,
-0.0424192101,
-0.0077176844,
-0.0137699898,
-0.0113987122,
0.0386418998,
0.0008130621,
0.0364389382,
0.0266451836,
-0.0434562415,
0.1298734397,
-0.0162035208,
-0.0924078971,
-0.0306624733,
-0.0811539888,
-0.0289316587,
0.0015471976,
0.0439778864,
0.0210362021,
-0.0187767912,
-0.0023293772,
-0.0337854624,
0.0087072188,
-0.0036190338,
0.0037654541,
0.0097442782,
-0.0821416453,
-0.01309097,
0.0270107873,
-0.0068022199,
0.029290257,
0.0461120754,
-0.0100872563,
0.009904447,
-0.0411945283,
0.0220304877,
0.0183203798,
0.0130155263,
-0.0027969347,
0.0312381908,
0.006597545,
0.0383591466,
0.0133475959,
-0.0193289761,
-0.0318730585,
0.0608355142,
-0.0281886365,
-0.0227668788,
-0.0173252448,
-0.0709036365,
-0.010385707,
0.0224124454,
-0.0063708564,
0.013688216,
0.0893011615,
-0.0512844808,
-0.0604456104,
0.0044410811,
-0.0639146343,
0.047479257,
-0.0622250028,
0.0057593375,
-0.0205310769,
0.0576387979,
-0.0090181567,
0.0311180353,
-0.0073184674,
-0.0211743657,
0.0201265141,
-0.0102117211,
0.0364448018,
-0.0090424707,
-0.0778164417,
0.0379877612,
-0.0382046662,
0.0239422303,
0.0088923573,
-0.0140467696,
0.000472502,
-0.0145016536,
-0.0779774636,
0.0138950497,
-0.0264530592,
0.0280223582,
0.035587769,
0.0486956313,
0.0208312701,
-0.0037575294,
-0.0275821052,
0.0024561749,
-0.0075145182,
-0.0007969871,
-0.0127228247,
-0.0015552926,
-0.042240981,
0.004108455,
-0.0503532141,
-0.0057198736,
0.0478036962,
-0.0568702631,
-0.0188642014,
-0.0627948493,
0.0117642134,
-0.0006134266,
0.0318303742,
-0.0149459653,
-0.0685214996,
0.0104755946,
0.0073876921,
0.033930447,
0.0730841681,
0.0045202328,
0.0403416529,
0.0814450681,
-0.005689994,
-0.0205899682,
0.0363571085,
-0.0443564244,
-0.0463350452,
-0.0307651721,
-0.0194384959,
-0.0253642388,
0.0777178332,
0.0054786014,
-0.008601523,
-0.0949995294,
-0.0351639837,
-0.02957494,
-0.006756247,
-0.025263425,
-0.0092903534,
-0.0168861691,
0.0156071577,
-0.0080010965,
-0.0374158062,
0.0607882179,
-0.0716253892,
-0.0494145937,
-0.0364348255,
-0.0288034584,
-0.0474808626,
0.0673361644,
-0.0128848907,
0.0401003882,
-0.0270679928,
-0.0106853871,
-0.0419830717,
0.0218857136,
-0.0011598015,
-0.0398801826,
0.0284379553,
-0.0165604688,
0.0034575039,
-0.0452892072,
-0.0184041262,
-0.0011232166,
0.0052560512,
0.0088436743,
0.016429998,
0.0480327904,
-0.0596945062,
-0.0384433493,
0.0694461763,
0.0232314989,
0.0598331094,
-0.0073275929,
-0.0150192035,
-0.0093675004,
0.0083027752,
0.0072542415,
0.0315745771,
0.0332036167,
0.0037412925,
0.0086477501,
0.0525467359,
0.0247615445,
0.0237915665,
-0.0872934312,
0.0072675906,
0.0490297563,
0.0086914161,
-0.0177371614,
0.0289634373,
0.0420678519,
-0.0572681762,
-0.0169173554,
0.0859314278,
0.0266031194,
-0.0580951609,
-0.0038991277,
0.0078685442,
0.0566123985,
0.0101283658,
0.0348170176,
-0.0798310637,
-0.022754794,
0.0267892294,
0.010148,
0.0144634824,
0.0083383331,
-0.0095493533,
-0.0718252957,
0.0331827998,
0.0309582967,
0.0268762894,
-0.0364894755,
-0.0595952496,
-0.037729796,
-0.0260077417,
0.0333710201,
-0.0006518488,
-0.0109611917,
-0.0102092801,
0.0223283768,
-0.011606833,
-0.0621887706,
0.0376724713,
0.0386871547,
0.0528737418,
0.0530834123,
0.0071991384,
-0.0117965043,
-0.0414645225,
-0.0114272702,
-0.000885168,
-0.0195751209,
-0.0126920938,
0.0183172226,
0.0094567128,
-0.0078639034,
-0.0051853494,
0.0015333043,
-0.0238492042,
-0.018807929,
-0.0460730903,
0.089682512,
-0.013325044,
-0.0243387017,
-0.0003513137,
-0.0247352086,
-0.0435751155,
0.0638739616,
0.0176287182,
0.0031921885,
-0.0308685228,
-0.0096541569,
-0.0003869494,
-0.0266866945,
-0.0546178333,
0.0402863771,
0.0171572398,
-0.0421301164,
0.0036713486,
0.0171214659,
0.0260310546,
0.0147212725,
0.0029334449,
-0.051595591,
0.0275589041,
0.0344810374,
-0.1034680828,
0.0024523146,
-0.0063949469,
0.0222871564,
-0.0561680682,
-0.0010708881,
0.008050153,
-0.0034015102,
-0.0321211368,
0.0218189508,
-0.0957918689,
-0.0236945953,
0.0231504887,
0.031586498,
0.0306898486,
0.0317337289,
0.0108902557,
-0.0137182996,
0.0166813023,
0.0464734919,
-0.0366419554,
0.0489771403,
0.0270560309,
-0.0841506869,
0.0131256673,
0.0141754691,
-0.0148466583,
0.0363400392,
-0.0349553265,
0.0247080214,
-0.0278920662,
-0.016659759,
0.0431874506,
-0.0040122364,
0.0443812981,
0.006884967,
0.0226979032,
0.0327456109,
0.037863303,
0.009278507,
0.0353158116,
-0.0506574623,
-0.0224154312,
0.0380763374,
-0.0072308704,
0.0233033318,
0.000370667,
0.0374124646,
-0.0210856292,
0.0260647107,
-0.0019154277,
-0.0308148004,
-0.0414393768,
0.0378084853,
0.0106335683,
-0.026369229,
-0.0405830741,
0.023751298,
0.0310136527,
-0.0446936712,
0.0515835844,
0.0035333743,
0.01809025,
-0.0167958438,
0.065253295,
-0.0498279743,
-0.0382712781,
-0.0450324789,
-0.0246708579,
0.0283564813,
0.0012643024,
0.0324336849,
-0.0394191034,
0.008079173,
-0.0000651815,
0.021963127,
-0.0084025944,
-0.0133816162,
0.0428448059,
0.0081441104,
-0.0068314373,
-0.0228151735,
0.0613677017,
0.0076014637,
0.0239240751,
-0.0167488474,
-0.0008077802,
-0.0358195081,
-0.0350897722,
-0.0302108563,
0.0086977333,
-0.0074117696,
-0.0253391005,
-0.0364929549,
-0.0568837561,
-0.0062929965,
0.0170169175,
0.0302373152,
-0.0488943644,
0.0424723029,
0.0515422709,
-0.0019583185,
-0.0360068046,
0.0007474962,
-0.0199372079,
0.0089573013,
0.0028307319,
0.0001016197,
-6.458355512e-33,
-0.0301419441,
0.0166208129,
0.0293239728,
-0.0217760298,
-0.0314336792,
0.0338102877,
-0.0319834538,
-0.018987285,
-0.0229480751,
-0.0206906125,
-0.0345211104,
0.0232336503,
0.0166267622,
0.0371386148,
-0.0188244563,
0.0081936521,
0.0854424089,
0.002079939,
-0.0174646247,
0.0449818149,
0.0158329941,
0.0140763167,
0.0675661415,
0.0077243941,
-0.0498578586,
0.0140024619,
-0.0068563344,
-0.0038507017,
0.0085574463,
0.0469655804,
-0.0383266136,
0.0201022699,
0.0154555021,
-0.0733590797,
-0.0128165632,
0.0188301373,
-0.1040911973,
0.0190597661,
0.0321745612,
0.050248336,
-0.0061510308,
-0.0163101293,
0.0165879205,
0.0166394226,
-0.013809951,
-0.0665989369,
-0.0163185094,
-0.0120731834,
-0.0273609217,
-0.0301543288,
-0.0266962666,
0.0035024935,
0.0068260841,
-0.0132963164,
0.082592234,
0.0339491926,
-0.0604153499,
0.0079791872,
-0.0852592289,
0.0055268044,
0.0239408668,
0.0799957886,
0.0780864656,
-0.0042977417,
0.0083082337,
-0.0026501825,
0.0088895597,
-0.028740203,
-0.0503114536,
0.0192463174,
0.0618884861,
0.0189935435,
0.0235465802,
0.0295149349,
0.0759201348,
-0.0068007456,
-0.0453403853,
0.0053222682,
0.0150391553,
0.0532149523,
0.0403208807,
0.0122628296,
-0.0108494591,
-0.0209882967,
-0.0333092138,
0.0201002378,
-0.0194787979,
-0.0326530635,
0.0155569222,
0.0058942139,
-0.041667603,
0.0012356393,
0.0475460291,
-0.0435233712,
0.0431694686,
-0.0047806776,
-0.0018453725,
0.0336002037,
0.0175787397,
0.0434575304,
-0.0118951229,
-0.0392111577,
0.0141684562,
-0.0115373963,
0.0209651701,
-0.0046961401,
0.0216871537,
0.091537185,
-0.0620325767,
-0.0060048937,
-0.0417687595,
-0.0037247741,
-0.0139439823,
0.0347775146,
0.0187319517,
0.0597441196,
-0.0004308306,
0.0128699914,
-0.0300209913,
0.0307147484,
-0.0283144917,
0.0079758149,
0.0219860468,
0.047079768,
-0.0204639696,
-0.0182714928,
-0.0827294365,
0.0008080739,
0.046539329,
-0.072072126,
-0.0381280221,
0.046859052,
2.941e-7,
0.0158281643,
0.0430647843,
0.0230694581,
-0.0068109045,
0.018037878,
0.0206868667,
0.01078883,
0.0257002227,
0.0140597951,
-0.0115447277,
0.0255438201,
0.0255189184,
0.0265613366,
0.0129086981,
-0.0807397813,
-0.0065599438,
-0.0523256995,
-0.0166224465,
-0.0412513129,
0.0115119638,
0.0394248702,
0.1576987505,
-0.012409837,
-0.0039947773,
0.0340267494,
0.015208221,
0.0460360087,
0.0054244203,
0.0306690242,
-0.0055025918,
0.0126010077,
0.0177562106,
-0.0242865719,
0.0138828158,
0.007377835,
0.0103011169,
-0.0390811861,
0.0775603727,
-0.021242518,
-0.0162254218,
0.0275126919,
-0.0162696429,
-0.0519353636,
-0.0795268714,
0.0459938906,
-0.0618535839,
-0.0321664996,
-0.0138846952,
-0.0405863486,
-0.0033435661,
-0.0165282711,
-0.0061717164,
0.0344517007,
0.0174495969,
0.0236390885,
-0.0260098949,
0.0110065425,
-0.0647667721,
0.0077327997,
0.0156802908,
-0.046120204,
-0.020241173,
-0.064697884,
-0.0509839766,
0.0610041097,
-0.0072134905,
-0.0157130528,
3.118977962e-34,
0.0156985857,
0.0060127247,
0.0541187935,
0.0228812173,
-0.0056049554,
-0.0264096539,
0.0399557464,
0.0116093727,
-0.0427923873,
-0.0967340469,
-0.0395529382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01481v1
|
The Vector Grounding Problem
| 2023-04-04T02:54:04 | 2023-04-04T02:54:04 |
Dimitri Coelho Mollo, Raphaël Millière
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) on complex
linguistic tasks has sparked a lively debate on the nature of their
capabilities. Unlike humans, these models learn language exclusively from
textual data, without direct interaction with the real world. Nevertheless,
they can generate seemingly meaningful text about a wide range of topics. This
impressive accomplishment has rekindled interest in the classical 'Symbol
Grounding Problem,' which questioned whether the internal representations and
outputs of classical symbolic AI systems could possess intrinsic meaning.
Unlike these systems, modern LLMs are artificial neural networks that compute
over vectors rather than symbols. However, an analogous problem arises for such
systems, which we dub the Vector Grounding Problem. This paper has two primary
objectives. First, we differentiate various ways in which internal
representations can be grounded in biological or artificial systems,
identifying five distinct notions discussed in the literature: referential,
sensorimotor, relational, communicative, and epistemic grounding.
Unfortunately, these notions of grounding are often conflated. We clarify the
differences between them, and argue that referential grounding is the one that
lies at the heart of the Vector Grounding Problem. Second, drawing on theories
of representational content in philosophy and cognitive science, we propose
that certain LLMs, particularly those fine-tuned with Reinforcement Learning
from Human Feedback (RLHF), possess the necessary features to overcome the
Vector Grounding Problem, as they stand in the requisite causal-historical
relations to the world that underpin intrinsic meaning. We also argue that,
perhaps unexpectedly, multimodality and embodiment are neither necessary nor
sufficient conditions for referential grounding in artificial systems.
|
[
0.0399302877,
0.0422164313,
-0.0446893722,
0.0036285191,
-0.0172399413,
0.0194706898,
-0.0308880433,
-0.0012499844,
-0.0180770718,
-0.0463944748,
-0.0415547341,
-0.0049814028,
0.0122265471,
-0.0325442366,
0.0469394773,
-0.016392678,
0.015947666,
0.00008976,
-0.0021517377,
-0.0026765543,
-0.0404641032,
-0.0197113864,
0.0235958565,
0.0360344723,
-0.0302002076,
0.0273481067,
-0.0273446571,
-0.025499681,
-0.0092462134,
-0.0408300124,
-0.053841494,
-0.0072332839,
0.0812316462,
0.0462940671,
0.0000021584,
-0.0400554948,
0.0418457389,
-0.0145314327,
-0.0349151827,
-0.025792947,
-0.0031936057,
-0.0209729709,
-0.0061282502,
-0.0391722769,
-0.0326145329,
0.0007556853,
0.0434951074,
0.0717839599,
0.0281816088,
0.0324848443,
0.0043923487,
-0.0390867554,
0.0455502719,
0.0028907391,
0.0367277972,
0.003644217,
0.0177378356,
0.0552343726,
-0.0110583128,
-0.0046219397,
-0.0813195407,
0.012843322,
0.0677412674,
0.0095288288,
0.0021073832,
0.0419049375,
0.017354697,
-0.0055604479,
0.0203681961,
0.0643627867,
0.0033321858,
-0.0338750929,
-0.0025294342,
0.0421791859,
-0.0094728665,
-0.0277852081,
-0.034105055,
0.0576541647,
0.0296650846,
0.021993285,
0.0697417557,
-0.012919656,
0.0304090288,
0.0066266684,
-0.0311499014,
0.0710265711,
-0.0058869715,
-0.0081716478,
0.0401244052,
0.0147703635,
-0.004112727,
-0.0781603381,
-0.0275422782,
0.0540467463,
0.0003438335,
0.0401471369,
-0.0275272951,
-0.004534137,
-0.0136692589,
-0.1068739519,
0.0493796319,
0.0479273945,
0.0048063481,
0.0214944426,
-0.0398463123,
0.049798429,
-0.0417859294,
0.099463284,
-0.0460436828,
0.0171798319,
-0.0641508847,
-0.0204475857,
-0.0291538779,
0.0789197013,
0.0053106491,
-0.0240373183,
-0.0033789368,
0.049511794,
-0.0101170139,
0.0171428323,
-0.0741471276,
0.0105388016,
-0.0244031046,
0.0195478108,
-0.0602653734,
-0.0106441965,
-0.0612578988,
0.0152728604,
-0.0296213087,
-0.0367488302,
0.0132034216,
-0.0050291303,
-0.0016088536,
-0.0096196346,
0.014814687,
0.0734478682,
0.0405896567,
-0.0506858416,
-0.0416870452,
-0.0198639091,
0.0014817575,
-0.05767975,
0.037199676,
-0.0045612357,
0.0015802681,
0.0334674157,
-0.0076781143,
-0.0714216456,
0.0246113874,
0.0107131461,
-0.007905446,
0.0843213201,
0.0417777114,
-0.0109585449,
0.0272237845,
-0.003888624,
0.0090704858,
0.0126910033,
0.0439810343,
0.0180331077,
-0.017787464,
-0.003339634,
0.004065033,
-0.0333602056,
0.0430756807,
-0.0176166426,
-0.0515268445,
-0.0085602757,
0.0023895819,
0.0642234683,
0.0108224927,
0.0543293282,
-0.0084377164,
-0.0149052553,
0.0592823364,
0.0822358578,
-0.0180866159,
0.022288654,
0.0907798931,
-0.0627476424,
-0.0071827378,
0.0196426008,
-0.0834752396,
0.0256513301,
-0.0383203104,
-0.0125001306,
-0.0366763473,
-0.0360237062,
-0.0240898654,
-0.0424531214,
0.0197632313,
-0.0029464157,
0.0223607104,
-0.010552492,
0.0516920276,
0.005510868,
-0.0080925468,
-0.0005908082,
0.0235386305,
-0.0149665922,
0.0069109276,
-0.0415786393,
0.0641277656,
0.0027647146,
0.0173060596,
0.0009039599,
0.0019501473,
-0.0272233449,
-0.0005173063,
0.0684341639,
0.0141410735,
-0.0150391664,
-0.0347751193,
-0.0108639356,
0.0036730105,
-0.0367696583,
0.0107257292,
0.0491788052,
-0.0754854977,
0.0033237287,
-0.0071755443,
-0.0178720783,
-0.0506964028,
0.065248996,
-0.0352648683,
-0.0376015864,
-0.0300347526,
0.0056371004,
0.0173405521,
0.0004914019,
-0.0203440618,
0.0341328084,
0.0430540964,
-0.0537670963,
-0.0554537214,
0.0586591959,
-0.0496499129,
0.0277777109,
0.0270797107,
-0.0660858154,
0.0361923091,
0.0073155579,
0.0321553163,
-0.0338529721,
0.074557215,
-0.0813780576,
0.0667531416,
-0.0084356386,
0.0148888249,
-0.02296618,
-0.0049369694,
-0.0032178005,
0.0621819757,
0.0005247719,
-0.0013889888,
0.0108370176,
0.0246436894,
0.0337080471,
-0.0303767994,
-0.0077807326,
0.0394721366,
0.0210670792,
-0.0004669266,
0.0110671679,
-0.0158182401,
-0.0316284597,
0.0014241986,
-0.0726425499,
-0.0235121027,
0.0054564564,
-0.0211463273,
-0.0033427828,
-0.0481977947,
0.0323740989,
-0.0140245846,
-0.0316883363,
0.0223695375,
0.0122873876,
0.0227411333,
0.0382440723,
0.0085112145,
-0.0412701741,
-0.0160929486,
0.0060769711,
-0.0508068167,
0.0535538904,
0.02180635,
0.0132785533,
-0.0565462261,
-0.0009687445,
-0.0625944585,
0.0062676966,
-0.0387110487,
-0.0121510858,
0.0312050376,
0.0179269593,
0.0132014323,
0.0617692694,
0.0102734668,
0.095364444,
0.0526546426,
-0.0008493074,
-0.06264323,
-0.0052272673,
-0.031535808,
-0.0132016921,
-0.0259241946,
-0.0086588608,
-0.0215083826,
0.0697446913,
0.0166629497,
0.017318435,
-0.0618989691,
0.1087837964,
-0.0465881489,
-0.04580006,
-0.0681418777,
-0.0394717753,
-0.0195589196,
0.0524063781,
-0.0232338551,
-0.0443741269,
0.0777746961,
0.0183050837,
0.0008413843,
-0.0017378508,
-0.0262647867,
-0.0363276862,
0.0782037452,
0.0183249507,
0.0180883743,
0.0197698642,
-0.0117626693,
-0.046017088,
-0.0112160081,
-0.0091474736,
-0.0077105388,
0.0434782058,
-0.0275112726,
0.0168596879,
0.012090411,
-0.0248252898,
-0.0415589847,
0.0132055581,
-0.0497229695,
0.0059551178,
-0.0324916132,
0.0159057826,
-0.0007516656,
0.0099136289,
0.0807211101,
-0.0254365262,
0.015525273,
-0.0348683931,
-0.0353765972,
-0.0469608046,
0.0144433379,
0.0223068427,
0.0494439565,
-0.0144324135,
0.0179215632,
-0.0225766674,
0.0213735942,
0.0008549573,
-0.0251903441,
0.0384926759,
-0.007963255,
-0.0248505995,
-0.0531241819,
-0.0016129152,
0.0163494851,
-0.032987006,
-0.042945236,
0.077664569,
0.0215599611,
-0.0349641778,
0.0701769814,
-0.0393739603,
-0.0753134266,
0.0354510657,
0.0302094501,
-0.0471454524,
0.0128676342,
0.0098011997,
-0.0283702947,
-0.0197282564,
-0.0710485801,
-0.0150130466,
-0.1053933799,
0.0052655116,
-0.0011914286,
-0.0782668591,
-0.0539495535,
-0.0178894158,
-0.0239975546,
0.0393121429,
0.0008709699,
0.010156095,
0.0150690544,
-0.0112353126,
0.0059629926,
0.0316528454,
-0.0167066399,
0.011776885,
-0.0253947601,
0.047378663,
0.0399072208,
0.0658653378,
-0.0197442044,
-0.0416043028,
-0.0102447988,
-0.0253530927,
0.0079114232,
-0.019509472,
0.0034387931,
0.0054246993,
-0.0222196709,
-0.025641745,
0.0217967406,
-0.0371975824,
-0.0155503107,
-0.0264461115,
0.0788502917,
-0.0584940873,
-0.0143155726,
-0.0029607618,
0.0066652759,
-0.0415650196,
0.0586765744,
0.0404006951,
-0.0735481381,
-0.0084098959,
-0.0426075682,
0.019540865,
0.0315235741,
-0.0832803473,
-0.0137612559,
-0.004761755,
-0.0018616023,
-0.0932734981,
-0.0432418063,
0.0103280582,
0.0344087481,
0.0295707528,
-0.0398179479,
-0.0081079835,
-0.0376063548,
-0.0132146981,
0.0296807867,
-0.027040584,
0.0015701019,
-0.0283992402,
0.0022924836,
0.0179510359,
-0.0904217288,
-0.0169905443,
0.0071109817,
0.0417365246,
-0.0510191061,
-0.0002856369,
0.0481531955,
0.0271750949,
0.0080289189,
0.0093319425,
-0.0032297557,
0.0343501344,
0.0015423249,
-0.0163592398,
0.0502187796,
0.0031020548,
0.0501735024,
-0.0013833087,
0.0446087047,
-0.0421456918,
0.0392990634,
0.0239725634,
0.0128169628,
0.001074668,
0.0131975198,
0.0589111969,
0.0183674283,
0.0040024519,
0.0126858456,
-0.0340141617,
-0.007965452,
-0.012215782,
-0.0246225148,
-0.0288232695,
-0.0250981804,
0.0093670813,
0.0120816911,
0.0490248241,
-0.0196647644,
-0.0700492859,
0.0156150181,
0.0624443814,
0.0402607247,
-0.0356884897,
0.0285757203,
0.0395824872,
-0.0359354205,
0.0596050918,
0.0062329215,
0.0327922665,
-0.0302843489,
0.0462579578,
-0.0255993251,
0.053198345,
0.0492778793,
-0.0004537961,
-0.0252769999,
-0.0134808049,
-0.0804070681,
-0.0408886969,
0.0146834673,
-0.0016516604,
0.0637139156,
0.005935431,
0.0272391625,
-0.055227343,
0.0099294195,
0.0160317253,
0.008841671,
0.0375440717,
-0.0359095223,
0.0348490849,
0.0287965275,
-0.0015835059,
-0.0046925531,
0.020592859,
-0.0386503078,
0.1013333425,
-0.0275202673,
0.0119948285,
-0.0367886126,
0.0155692846,
0.0112952841,
0.009390329,
0.0101595828,
0.0387426615,
-0.0850167498,
-0.0536784008,
0.0230491403,
0.0390679762,
-0.00290999,
-0.0317739025,
0.0469061434,
-0.0035194503,
0.0287015755,
-0.0052713337,
-0.0100486502,
0.0315548554,
-0.0480803996,
0.0044255736,
-0.0251738243,
-6.037686124e-33,
-0.0529244691,
-0.0504130162,
0.0127970604,
0.0151104648,
-0.0439287461,
0.0086519476,
-0.0543320067,
0.0096368566,
-0.0137744052,
0.0329701416,
-0.0050069029,
-0.015331462,
-0.006652087,
-0.036347039,
0.0278384332,
-0.0394006446,
0.0049431343,
-0.0282409396,
-0.0211171731,
0.0130804889,
0.0605686009,
0.0076217069,
0.0611332022,
-0.0798808932,
0.0512772799,
0.0204731654,
0.0200264007,
0.0163246673,
-0.0280217528,
0.0409187078,
-0.0432355143,
0.0379901789,
0.0261862725,
-0.0239078235,
-0.0038439094,
-0.0019248719,
-0.0494088084,
-0.0558415949,
0.0336424112,
0.0107662603,
-0.0370078124,
-0.022387417,
0.0392341465,
-0.0417699255,
-0.0424840823,
0.0601608232,
0.021469824,
-0.0270141996,
0.0020196997,
-0.0350397415,
-0.0773900151,
-0.0319155082,
0.0039128661,
-0.0247730669,
0.0017678436,
-0.0156326722,
-0.0185986869,
0.0127529781,
-0.046540983,
0.0138683664,
-0.065304406,
-0.0376941562,
0.0302889701,
0.0048954221,
0.0412490815,
0.0566480719,
0.0464548692,
0.008459284,
-0.056928385,
0.0023372464,
0.0652946159,
0.0084523428,
0.0503160991,
0.0173386596,
0.0213837959,
0.0251924302,
-0.0500927083,
-0.030194018,
0.0262978841,
0.0429689139,
0.0334863514,
0.0017243149,
-0.0108717745,
-0.0057932287,
-0.0606962182,
-0.0572979413,
-0.0212436505,
-0.0328560099,
0.0129721025,
-0.0017635891,
0.002705174,
-0.0206353683,
0.0178383384,
-0.0776150003,
-0.00018018,
0.026607506,
0.0296048094,
0.0306468438,
0.0238843467,
-0.0498704389,
-0.025433382,
-0.0198006518,
-0.0189110897,
0.0019312192,
0.038329415,
0.0084326956,
-0.0063713654,
0.0316214487,
0.0060051098,
-0.0209265407,
-0.021922389,
-0.0270739775,
0.0264027808,
-0.0383992903,
0.0445367321,
0.0212552324,
-0.0222227909,
0.0218425505,
0.0353604965,
0.0235748868,
0.0068057375,
0.0074648988,
-0.0263325889,
0.0413910858,
-0.044501733,
-0.0079135578,
-0.0256351251,
0.0759564489,
0.0826588571,
-0.063663505,
-0.016306879,
-0.0165393185,
3.059e-7,
0.0239063017,
0.042613484,
0.0429045483,
0.0173447598,
0.0115108965,
0.0367628373,
-0.0224522986,
0.0347596146,
-0.0096579064,
-0.0451503061,
-0.0056025521,
0.0231248867,
-0.0045577642,
0.0138654551,
-0.0355659537,
0.0157870483,
-0.0526078008,
-0.0100527145,
-0.0200119019,
0.0575356893,
0.0158587396,
0.0740253478,
0.0439077429,
-0.021599045,
-0.0113090314,
-0.0082545169,
0.043971248,
-0.0432908498,
0.0233809799,
-0.0304663908,
0.0237324629,
0.006628525,
-0.0165230278,
0.0173826367,
0.0450279638,
0.0444110334,
0.0107425088,
0.0016284297,
-0.0081582423,
0.0019930799,
-0.0256339554,
-0.000272629,
0.0169749577,
-0.0271897353,
0.0442106463,
-0.0904714018,
-0.0548389852,
0.0016983568,
0.031965144,
-0.0118250502,
0.0267970879,
0.0085032322,
-0.0170355644,
-0.0055509317,
0.0112694195,
-0.0043229698,
0.0299527887,
-0.066099368,
0.0059568724,
0.0247756969,
-0.0178749412,
-0.0169144906,
-0.0290731844,
0.0134143401,
0.0536446124,
-0.0833674595,
-0.0202583559,
2.525144618e-34,
0.0014874728,
-0.0326491669,
0.0211403035,
0.0160844252,
0.0245656092,
0.014139859,
-0.0003473128,
-0.0113905277,
0.0661111549,
-0.0327081829,
-0.0390411429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01424v1
|
Polarity based Sarcasm Detection using Semigraph
| 2023-04-04T00:13:55 | 2023-04-04T00:13:55 |
Swapnil Mane, Vaibhav Khatavkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sarcasm is an advanced linguistic expression often found on various online
platforms. Sarcasm detection is challenging in natural language processing
tasks that affect sentiment analysis. This article presents the inventive
method of the semigraph, including semigraph construction and sarcasm detection
processes. A variation of the semigraph is suggested in the pattern-relatedness
of the text document. The proposed method is to obtain the sarcastic and
non-sarcastic polarity scores of a document using a semigraph. The sarcastic
polarity score represents the possibility that a document will become
sarcastic. Sarcasm is detected based on the polarity scoring model. The
performance of the proposed model enhances the existing prior art approach to
sarcasm detection. In the Amazon product review, the model achieved the
accuracy, recall, and f-measure of 0.87, 0.79, and 0.83, respectively.
|
[
0.0641646907,
-0.0473411568,
-0.036108423,
0.0432467796,
-0.046169199,
-0.0031110833,
-0.0069277375,
0.017185837,
0.0233983099,
-0.0649610609,
-0.0204361323,
0.022578463,
-0.0349292085,
0.0452433936,
-0.0392150208,
-0.0211129207,
0.0053223069,
0.0580196977,
0.034106072,
-0.024804974,
0.0119860014,
0.0134771615,
-0.0294771027,
0.0052928682,
0.0058869785,
0.0017012997,
0.0184050929,
0.0768173561,
0.0232762247,
-0.0551531427,
0.0006672618,
-0.0141741307,
-0.0648811162,
-0.0200984851,
0.0000017438,
-0.0449734479,
-0.0221805479,
-0.038955912,
-0.0438263528,
-0.0462494269,
0.155356288,
-0.0295529626,
-0.0179290567,
0.0245245676,
-0.0416451916,
-0.0108355619,
0.0293209683,
0.0134246815,
0.0625079125,
0.0717406943,
-0.0039422642,
0.0153491087,
-0.0367134474,
0.0468153656,
-0.0189857464,
-0.0023477832,
0.0215762444,
0.0259125363,
-0.0637252852,
0.0103935273,
-0.0406068228,
-0.0073652146,
-0.0580385178,
0.012793499,
-0.0323202386,
-0.002413922,
0.0036190022,
0.0137735829,
-0.0088197617,
0.0176340323,
0.0340398662,
0.0033022747,
0.0021393977,
0.0238254555,
-0.0233086906,
-0.0166123956,
-0.0264545679,
-0.019605387,
-0.0127122216,
-0.0062423707,
0.0233139358,
0.0389307663,
-0.0120146722,
0.033296179,
0.0462791584,
0.0548160672,
-0.0136288935,
-0.0576416664,
-0.0358497575,
-0.011232812,
0.0145484516,
0.0145244449,
0.0476031043,
0.0305845141,
0.0665818378,
0.0169243626,
0.0010738045,
-0.0595380738,
0.0395781063,
-0.0489537828,
-0.0125586353,
-0.0066403523,
0.0147683304,
0.0583129935,
0.001580231,
-0.0318390094,
0.038848184,
0.0344490856,
-0.0514193065,
-0.0067511611,
-0.0202788319,
0.0368265063,
-0.0170007572,
0.0143662896,
0.0362564102,
0.014409381,
-0.0867861062,
0.0001764078,
-0.0283698384,
-0.027723629,
0.0413839035,
0.0202031862,
0.0053113829,
-0.0381199233,
0.0032731299,
0.0443489999,
-0.0175719261,
0.0340527296,
-0.0846952572,
0.0490149595,
0.0157715715,
0.0486342907,
0.0584134497,
-0.0316406935,
0.0373509564,
0.0281763989,
0.0745161399,
-0.0662455037,
-0.0823923349,
-0.0015651382,
-0.0616542958,
-0.0062296814,
0.0138348984,
-0.008972873,
-0.0253671538,
-0.0003097886,
-0.0134172887,
0.0458115004,
-0.0087541416,
-0.0197229274,
0.0093970615,
0.0392096117,
-0.0659239963,
-0.0203845315,
0.0201429948,
-0.0266758818,
-0.0634833202,
0.0061251088,
0.0037957896,
0.0060247285,
0.0643613189,
0.0285771824,
-0.0169032421,
-0.0184404831,
0.0191296171,
-0.0288699307,
-0.0406069793,
0.0083878441,
-0.0762057975,
-0.0525604561,
-0.023386512,
0.0128341718,
-0.0037082864,
-0.020545831,
0.0081634847,
0.0067299977,
-0.0434113853,
0.0155463628,
0.0045331907,
0.0141979549,
-0.0136541482,
-0.0031035771,
0.0197508559,
0.0076078535,
-0.1145342216,
-0.0214004777,
-0.0613410585,
0.0023310173,
-0.0125113996,
-0.0426305011,
-0.0420978144,
-0.0494713224,
0.0802898556,
-0.0291906446,
0.0792996809,
0.0228195805,
-0.0433901511,
-0.033028651,
0.004495583,
-0.0672561228,
-0.0273560137,
0.002619239,
0.0188875683,
0.0801969618,
0.0120614972,
-0.0123218503,
-0.0416222401,
-0.0294685457,
-0.0581241064,
-0.011846072,
0.0112034408,
0.0096523901,
-0.0213433094,
-0.0400487669,
0.0104904678,
-0.0043897359,
0.0118594756,
0.0073640668,
-0.025962282,
0.0698018372,
-0.0024038288,
-0.0193510111,
0.0924060643,
-0.0084991353,
-0.0078166379,
-0.0045132786,
-0.0105473213,
0.0346651785,
0.0606539324,
0.0293875039,
-0.0161165707,
-0.0117456391,
0.0441301838,
-0.0246920399,
-0.084657155,
0.0361126289,
-0.0141325295,
-0.08652962,
0.0310237911,
-0.0568708107,
-0.008692788,
0.0302696005,
0.0137701454,
-0.0213111937,
0.0494997464,
-0.0291269273,
0.0110111088,
-0.0406346694,
-0.0085503738,
-0.0320973024,
0.0180843901,
-0.0218608659,
0.0618338101,
0.003238216,
0.0156028634,
-0.0460741296,
0.0004584045,
0.0303681567,
0.046856638,
-0.0301824603,
0.0096298037,
0.0189950969,
-0.0028592937,
0.0246326737,
-0.0110950237,
-0.0189522468,
-0.0177454893,
-0.0754452273,
0.0044838432,
0.017574681,
0.0354132317,
0.0265346505,
-0.0216218289,
-0.0022273771,
0.0518352725,
0.0322835706,
-0.006053641,
-0.0317518748,
-0.0302786566,
0.0223103017,
-0.0169869941,
-0.0087739313,
-0.0163237918,
-0.0212440658,
-0.0338997431,
0.020777544,
0.0371799096,
0.0264061559,
0.0078664552,
0.0635613129,
-0.0062485188,
-0.0179489851,
0.0009113144,
-0.0941192359,
-0.032791473,
-0.0013139476,
-0.0165161006,
0.0698588938,
0.0476831459,
0.0033453896,
-0.001866956,
0.0070794062,
-0.005889527,
0.0094057033,
-0.0184333902,
0.0596886352,
0.0010729547,
-0.0550861359,
-0.0193021931,
0.0094407145,
0.020718839,
-0.0022023071,
-0.0180146396,
-0.0024364833,
-0.016452143,
0.0117725451,
0.0464273915,
-0.028953528,
-0.0230176263,
-0.0295176394,
0.005870875,
0.0036341504,
0.0306135863,
0.0172948502,
-0.0059082168,
-0.0651659295,
-0.0158509947,
-0.0114145009,
0.0613626763,
-0.0077858772,
0.0189791285,
0.0005367832,
-0.0181730092,
0.0224193148,
-0.0610736758,
0.0460545681,
-0.0138165578,
0.0110393623,
0.0362706706,
-0.0262926631,
0.0176438373,
-0.0015264966,
-0.0234216899,
-0.0097458111,
-0.0579613298,
-0.0259323213,
0.0392529815,
0.0048944121,
0.0080525428,
0.0104559083,
-0.0168623365,
-0.0223426018,
-0.0239277985,
-0.0182522777,
0.0226891674,
-0.01302996,
0.0060437052,
-0.0685460567,
0.0295488257,
0.0460634567,
-0.0209337603,
0.0494835004,
-0.033787176,
-0.0009273645,
-0.0099087236,
-0.0384346209,
0.0027264478,
-0.0177885462,
0.0128372861,
-0.0462672785,
-0.012128788,
-0.0096025197,
0.0242762808,
0.1008273512,
0.0516631529,
-0.01065291,
-0.0036950763,
-0.0034304687,
-0.0797444955,
0.0574463867,
-0.0072841905,
-0.0624485947,
-0.0247668773,
-0.0109150922,
0.0244123396,
-0.0312547088,
0.0028034106,
0.0044268481,
-0.0996705145,
-0.0014683566,
0.0051679448,
0.0261923205,
0.0408635736,
0.0206632745,
0.0021542739,
-0.00825343,
-0.0490147918,
-0.0103529524,
-0.0109207183,
-0.0142000085,
-0.0025520921,
-0.0684207231,
0.0347433351,
0.0186880641,
0.0138254501,
0.0063793333,
-0.0114164809,
0.0782586336,
-0.0186068006,
-0.0095295114,
-0.032377921,
-0.0618148744,
0.0201629903,
-0.0234269425,
0.0807086527,
-0.0164270345,
0.0145680327,
-0.0335305221,
-0.0155873811,
-0.0222764481,
0.0375005938,
0.003117596,
0.0192824118,
-0.0059013469,
-0.0288794674,
-0.0581253581,
0.0317874886,
0.0143022519,
0.0401162654,
-0.0317834318,
-0.0239597391,
-0.0221855231,
0.0104198633,
0.0053872275,
-0.0605990328,
-0.0166475065,
0.0062856567,
-0.0286910422,
-0.020361932,
-0.079625532,
-0.0077793705,
-0.0218543522,
0.033591602,
-0.0502550639,
-0.0123138456,
0.0254465695,
0.008051659,
-0.0487127304,
-0.0623784512,
0.0308701564,
0.0191028081,
0.0029420033,
0.0008332604,
0.0562767126,
-0.0413344391,
-0.0119880745,
-0.0062000286,
0.0243964735,
-0.0116525246,
0.0290600155,
0.0439369418,
0.0088218292,
-0.0261082947,
-0.0115039749,
0.0045890263,
-0.0046190806,
0.0698811114,
-0.0065226182,
-0.001390003,
0.0413670503,
0.0726076514,
0.0133455712,
0.0209998153,
-0.0133541934,
0.0606312081,
0.0138410823,
-0.026682606,
-0.0262716319,
-0.0009264321,
-0.0077456795,
0.0163819138,
0.035130363,
0.0158866104,
-0.0334945954,
0.0420029573,
-0.0012283574,
-0.0424595699,
-0.0381321609,
0.0147831934,
-0.0214231201,
-0.0377379693,
0.0018798481,
-0.0703562796,
-0.0140777072,
-0.0437659062,
0.0236276258,
0.0144363781,
0.0674387291,
0.0348543413,
0.0201376304,
-0.0205074418,
0.012256017,
-0.0240517501,
-0.0362779908,
0.0321693718,
-0.0337579995,
0.0319104083,
0.0292602684,
-0.0071314336,
-0.0041660178,
-0.0493922308,
0.0238499977,
0.0105811143,
0.061268881,
0.0265648346,
0.0233344398,
0.0290836263,
0.0007135104,
0.0347791426,
-0.0131003466,
-0.0006418542,
-0.0047791293,
0.0487412289,
-0.0223048031,
-0.0440853648,
0.0420316309,
0.0191622097,
0.0015376479,
-0.0260121711,
-0.0021874215,
-0.0813769996,
0.0357013345,
0.0145558957,
-0.0388377719,
-0.0474049933,
0.0169514492,
0.0369985737,
-0.0249889083,
0.0045978092,
0.0618471801,
-0.0602317341,
-0.055392459,
0.0894968435,
-0.0113001466,
0.0488305837,
-0.0110141272,
0.038743034,
0.0407377481,
-0.0096429856,
-0.0104232859,
-0.0371314511,
0.057811372,
-0.0619852059,
0.0454547331,
0.0000360117,
-5.419576664e-33,
-0.0095083574,
-0.0658563152,
-0.0520289056,
0.0765595213,
0.0262994599,
0.003014863,
-0.0030734539,
0.0223727543,
-0.0080341548,
0.0330499634,
0.0229619779,
0.0241906885,
-0.0040489789,
-0.0328624733,
0.0085211573,
-0.0059132557,
0.0317460746,
-0.0179897789,
0.040551547,
-0.0147054028,
0.0267509297,
0.0194283593,
0.0660956725,
-0.1180739477,
0.0173875336,
-0.0307197347,
-0.0534531549,
-0.0042620297,
0.0199627224,
0.069396928,
0.0356866978,
0.0584900379,
0.0154057592,
0.0365303829,
0.0135016171,
0.0032785942,
0.0130258519,
-0.0137393838,
0.0119163552,
0.0230432227,
-0.0293407179,
0.0021503745,
0.0322769061,
0.0084385909,
-0.0695786923,
0.0332302935,
0.0582397543,
-0.0225240588,
0.008881229,
-0.0648788959,
-0.0498445965,
0.0256020054,
-0.0088374894,
-0.0311485976,
0.0053294613,
0.0354915634,
0.0162327494,
0.0260004457,
-0.0444633067,
0.0262043532,
-0.1197428554,
-0.0433249548,
-0.0432016216,
-0.0383476801,
0.0410814434,
0.0408860929,
0.0123275891,
0.0443073995,
0.0339582823,
-0.005236323,
0.0188322999,
-0.0008434675,
0.0525205061,
0.0879915208,
0.0184723511,
-0.0890183896,
-0.0363068879,
-0.0032749434,
0.1034248173,
0.0000593785,
0.0334691145,
-0.0163424164,
-0.0751085281,
0.0134367496,
0.0515506119,
0.0051156874,
-0.009245377,
-0.0282117743,
-0.0164105333,
0.0374823175,
-0.0073445528,
-0.0077207321,
-0.0065319007,
-0.0646969453,
-0.0007289122,
0.0439899825,
-0.0208931826,
0.0483330525,
0.013842348,
0.0151375216,
0.0061115446,
-0.0131342653,
-0.036281351,
0.0484851226,
-0.0057319254,
-0.0106306672,
0.0678589195,
0.0103060687,
-0.0559239984,
-0.0024479462,
0.0402804986,
0.0026778602,
-0.0246902052,
0.0235219914,
-0.0281095169,
0.0103831515,
0.0088083372,
0.0274970308,
0.0295136087,
0.0347707234,
-0.0266965497,
0.0196113996,
-0.0014503339,
0.0059020375,
-0.0480750725,
-0.0073746275,
0.0182556603,
-0.0779174417,
-0.057240624,
-0.0608479679,
-0.0094312327,
-0.0497713722,
2.552e-7,
0.0687188804,
0.0781978816,
-0.0029342691,
0.0326361209,
0.038793806,
0.0701485276,
-0.0112593761,
0.0062098997,
0.0180231631,
0.0198123008,
0.0212685317,
-0.0420945324,
-0.0547075756,
0.0190878045,
-0.0922675878,
0.0720366612,
-0.0022062473,
0.0201845262,
0.0349171311,
0.0435343124,
0.0898653045,
-0.0065529309,
0.0398634002,
0.0037182937,
-0.0138879213,
-0.038467668,
0.0181584638,
-0.0071278578,
0.0136616677,
-0.0133830737,
0.0029433973,
-0.0266042706,
-0.0147395339,
-0.0017507448,
0.0028822061,
-0.0006814623,
-0.0032372344,
0.0323026814,
-0.0187187027,
-0.0296492595,
0.0433364697,
0.0008160945,
-0.0043357387,
-0.0012146223,
0.0351903327,
0.0116492314,
-0.0318302065,
-0.0676019415,
-0.0460352823,
0.0150247868,
0.0550302453,
0.0166658983,
-0.0292925052,
0.0262838528,
0.0153308921,
-0.0376526415,
-0.0267630424,
-0.0385737456,
0.0111451484,
0.0088842614,
-0.015730124,
-0.0320831239,
0.0543630645,
0.0557714887,
0.0379316136,
-0.0273748487,
0.0277228076,
1.629060798e-34,
0.0521481335,
-0.0152628832,
-0.0228344351,
-0.0490186773,
-0.0011396024,
0.0079692267,
-0.0015219162,
-0.020938959,
0.0337307714,
-0.0049034334,
-0.0286463816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01423v1
|
Thematic context vector association based on event uncertainty for Twitter
| 2023-04-04T00:13:47 | 2023-04-04T00:13:47 |
Vaibhav Khatavkar, Swapnil Mane, Parag Kulkarni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Keyword extraction is a crucial process in text mining. The extraction of
keywords with respective contextual events in Twitter data is a big challenge.
The challenging issues are mainly because of the informality in the language
used. The use of misspelled words, acronyms, and ambiguous terms causes
informality. The extraction of keywords with informal language in current
systems is pattern based or event based. In this paper, contextual keywords are
extracted using thematic events with the help of data association. The thematic
context for events is identified using the uncertainty principle in the
proposed system. The thematic contexts are weighed with the help of vectors
called thematic context vectors which signifies the event as certain or
uncertain. The system is tested on the Twitter COVID-19 dataset and proves to
be effective. The system extracts event-specific thematic context vectors from
the test dataset and ranks them. The extracted thematic context vectors are
used for the clustering of contextual thematic vectors which improves the
silhouette coefficient by 0.5% than state of art methods namely TF and TF-IDF.
The thematic context vector can be used in other applications like
Cyberbullying, sarcasm detection, figurative language detection, etc.
|
[
0.0582315922,
0.001417086,
-0.0201738272,
0.0102901096,
-0.0216670744,
0.0179996956,
0.0000621535,
0.0412111245,
-0.0231616795,
-0.0315707214,
0.0385049582,
-0.0221433509,
-0.0000632179,
0.056051705,
-0.040700648,
-0.0413422436,
0.0502386838,
0.0371274911,
0.0543488674,
0.0164720528,
0.0228355806,
0.0248318724,
-0.0173002798,
0.0250492934,
-0.0125898011,
0.0516888127,
0.0386313982,
0.0154051641,
0.065959841,
-0.0501316972,
0.0110666957,
0.0252107996,
-0.0233280808,
0.014284417,
0.0000017956,
-0.0729210973,
-0.063093774,
-0.0266681369,
0.0343345664,
-0.0501886718,
0.0785591379,
-0.0196187142,
-0.027512081,
0.0452247821,
-0.041165702,
0.0403596088,
0.0628734827,
0.018618457,
0.0030841869,
0.0364285447,
-0.0283118878,
-0.0612451732,
-0.0295929592,
0.0312813632,
-0.037766058,
-0.0161229484,
0.0358936302,
-0.043648798,
-0.0366292037,
0.0258364882,
0.0439559408,
0.0064380402,
-0.0615536124,
0.0301364306,
0.0385182798,
0.0140561117,
-0.0596173257,
-0.0204834864,
0.020785667,
-0.0173167959,
0.0407777056,
-0.0324573182,
0.0610959083,
0.0033597271,
-0.026804667,
0.0242904667,
-0.0401845388,
-0.0230201818,
-0.0270515513,
0.0171009563,
0.0495656542,
0.0614866689,
-0.0269122198,
0.0585092828,
0.0021746859,
0.008808367,
0.0041378024,
-0.0157534294,
-0.0569487177,
-0.0233382694,
-0.0622847453,
-0.0052971495,
0.038725052,
0.0278204624,
-0.0436607152,
0.0445640162,
-0.0349515192,
-0.0192544945,
0.0473179407,
-0.1043394282,
-0.0919598937,
-0.0094185397,
0.0478892699,
0.0137846833,
0.0177528095,
-0.0353121571,
0.0282121822,
-0.0104327817,
-0.0027986146,
-0.0152122239,
-0.0466773249,
0.0257636588,
-0.0116054416,
0.0034401873,
-0.0013164483,
0.023038622,
-0.0599535778,
0.0343180858,
0.0026054613,
-0.0187300779,
-0.0330371894,
0.0145726325,
-0.0267684255,
0.0126611209,
-0.0086703636,
-0.0370547585,
-0.0404011384,
0.0423358567,
-0.0625493303,
-0.0084102536,
0.0475414693,
0.0114602894,
0.0917240679,
-0.0123968627,
-0.0041313292,
-0.007368118,
-0.0003794228,
-0.0353620797,
-0.0694812164,
-0.0242751893,
-0.0154192671,
0.0432055481,
-0.0635139495,
-0.0708322152,
-0.0139172142,
0.0215209499,
-0.0280781258,
0.0377415605,
0.0299952645,
0.0236858018,
-0.0762483254,
0.0421291254,
-0.070729062,
0.0015541607,
0.0628162324,
0.0276905037,
0.0162899159,
0.0182217974,
0.0324481539,
0.0530180596,
0.0579122715,
0.0069844704,
-0.0303126946,
-0.0147683285,
-0.0009993918,
0.0194446314,
-0.0410714447,
0.0017648775,
-0.0468880013,
-0.0239168704,
-0.0394897014,
0.0537370145,
0.0073375902,
0.0431630164,
-0.0010009194,
0.0489372276,
-0.0174024347,
-0.0050405674,
-0.0268334933,
0.0388946123,
0.0067336704,
-0.0161116403,
-0.0061432002,
-0.0395187996,
-0.0825129598,
-0.0239214469,
0.0178141017,
0.0152132846,
0.001077909,
-0.0453040116,
-0.0223567467,
0.0236330293,
0.0475308336,
-0.0699532032,
0.034589991,
-0.015079869,
-0.0085098678,
-0.048921831,
0.0286101997,
-0.0139304837,
0.0301356837,
-0.0182573851,
-0.0004359286,
0.0469800197,
0.0383945704,
-0.0068516941,
-0.0510469861,
-0.0218963288,
-0.0157020297,
0.0129008228,
-0.0358651504,
-0.0082091019,
-0.0429150797,
-0.0352627523,
-0.0014555907,
0.0750702322,
0.0075711724,
-0.0484474041,
0.0187235344,
0.0644884109,
-0.0185556747,
0.0169194862,
-0.0079481918,
0.0186148807,
0.0679625124,
-0.0119493464,
0.0181155838,
0.0040327013,
0.0383398421,
0.0490909629,
-0.0061616502,
-0.0315050781,
0.0463496596,
-0.0009793194,
-0.0261946041,
0.0319971219,
-0.0128395259,
-0.0017676939,
0.0149113983,
0.0031104814,
0.0001479363,
-0.0098235589,
-0.0193640459,
-0.0333091542,
0.0507379957,
-0.0205513611,
0.0484729856,
-0.0327859484,
-0.0060522854,
-0.0578205921,
0.0072545973,
-0.0313982703,
0.1018181741,
-0.0023517141,
0.0139766177,
-0.046069961,
-0.0024126617,
0.0029726841,
0.000085308,
-0.0139347566,
0.0016936641,
-0.0221715868,
0.0390486196,
0.0653364211,
-0.0067713251,
-0.0406796411,
-0.0009711307,
-0.1158039421,
0.0195339881,
-0.0198170673,
0.0106145954,
0.0221705195,
0.0338334888,
-0.032972388,
0.0160609744,
0.0184962284,
-0.0406851582,
-0.0063262247,
0.003494605,
0.0415572077,
0.0201165341,
-0.0193141699,
-0.0159261711,
0.0053654695,
-0.0443926044,
-0.0174645893,
0.0498503372,
-0.0978515223,
0.0095002055,
0.0675670058,
-0.0188521277,
-0.0116281658,
0.0103317378,
-0.0277633928,
-0.0069580697,
-0.0152328229,
0.0028827644,
-0.0547973923,
0.084175311,
0.0324432217,
-0.0105494661,
-0.0415391475,
-0.0090351813,
0.0187500212,
-0.0268165749,
0.0217760354,
-0.0091267517,
-0.0411654562,
0.040598534,
0.0038257097,
0.0319589712,
-0.0083755152,
-0.0418581851,
-0.0277071204,
-0.0124652814,
0.0508500561,
-0.0527523756,
-0.0234942567,
-0.0144654131,
0.0113550443,
0.0243787356,
-0.0283385534,
0.0334784165,
0.0355497897,
0.0482906066,
-0.0904290974,
-0.0665137172,
0.0046363575,
-0.0214514118,
-0.0334714763,
0.0329496227,
0.022932617,
-0.0244158637,
0.0313871652,
-0.0650262311,
0.0312515758,
-0.0450297035,
-0.000866666,
-0.0165591799,
0.0085052503,
0.0252213236,
0.0160851162,
-0.0480558686,
-0.0253586024,
-0.0361229293,
-0.0332966447,
0.0178311896,
-0.0136273289,
-0.0009682731,
0.0141639104,
-0.0387147851,
-0.0121600199,
0.0265706163,
-0.0343396291,
0.0298969131,
0.026143264,
0.0204948746,
-0.0707187429,
0.0187148061,
0.0397578776,
-0.0366255939,
0.0603030547,
0.0250659864,
-0.0463305712,
-0.0151449833,
-0.0393534899,
0.0063318559,
-0.0246836264,
0.0115578622,
0.0198578276,
0.0505568907,
0.0069679534,
0.0211603772,
0.0993628651,
0.0669336244,
-0.0313139744,
0.0054175304,
0.0284107793,
-0.0283184126,
-0.0076054726,
0.0199403372,
0.0001403188,
-0.0078646233,
-0.0056561748,
-0.0040313215,
-0.0640366301,
-0.0741867498,
-0.0003724487,
-0.0161699243,
0.0138387801,
-0.0066806865,
-0.0082966844,
-0.0290501099,
-0.0596896745,
0.0314756073,
-0.0071345232,
-0.0047171153,
-0.0372426547,
0.0048583448,
0.0134714199,
0.0170020629,
-0.0646263734,
-0.0901083499,
0.00629419,
0.0024528506,
0.0399606302,
-0.0109177409,
0.0485594906,
-0.0663122982,
-0.0004993662,
-0.0256215185,
-0.0726849064,
0.0034347859,
-0.0428156033,
-0.0146247195,
0.0072232066,
-0.0001626808,
-0.021598367,
-0.0008680316,
-0.0178899784,
-0.0578929596,
-0.0026157866,
0.0237033498,
-0.0041863373,
0.010260663,
-0.0509043485,
-0.001439439,
0.0249966234,
0.0194548853,
-0.0299788676,
0.0066124229,
0.0615980402,
0.0074956771,
0.025112452,
0.0052300091,
-0.0076788492,
-0.0464720391,
-0.0286724381,
-0.0421306305,
-0.0826334879,
-0.021122802,
-0.0006602285,
0.0425081365,
-0.0591444559,
0.0395005792,
0.0092048487,
-0.0182304643,
-0.0625899285,
-0.0092927068,
0.0350393914,
0.0376580358,
-0.006036385,
0.0208471492,
-0.0154586304,
0.0089299334,
-0.0050543025,
0.0106043657,
-0.044931829,
-0.0308775604,
0.029633645,
-0.039269533,
0.0106436452,
-0.0332792811,
-0.0427309349,
-0.032411132,
0.0877252072,
0.0519434996,
-0.0377260149,
-0.0408787653,
0.005380326,
0.0622571185,
0.0013144966,
-0.0010494036,
-0.0177459754,
0.0277754515,
-0.0383840464,
0.0037741975,
-0.091103524,
0.045009274,
-0.0169667155,
0.0223076176,
0.073384434,
-0.0280780811,
-0.0928761214,
-0.0296483859,
-0.0277947746,
0.0251752082,
-0.0292075761,
0.0349766687,
0.0265796371,
-0.0155833196,
-0.0132367825,
-0.0509822369,
0.0123563018,
-0.0384836681,
-0.0531583466,
0.000353341,
0.0390493348,
0.0317673907,
0.050758142,
0.012029279,
-0.0087428978,
-0.0037207596,
-0.0311021432,
0.0302628614,
0.0095900735,
0.0027393652,
-0.0331670605,
0.0042708595,
-0.0103659248,
0.0145743173,
0.0272874348,
-0.0444968455,
0.0540655814,
-0.0294667259,
-0.0222121794,
-0.0027066723,
-0.0064819641,
-0.0035889107,
0.0114862183,
0.0074495748,
-0.0135496855,
0.0218553133,
-0.0168762635,
0.0191304386,
0.0315565914,
-0.0041265036,
-0.0308209863,
0.0578565374,
0.0060900361,
-0.0585205965,
0.0113912877,
0.025444584,
-0.0615338311,
0.0015490524,
0.0392527841,
0.0440145209,
0.0684281513,
0.0014782439,
0.0165818054,
-0.0269548092,
-0.0024754514,
0.0802697986,
-0.0632925481,
0.0193244237,
0.0000362138,
0.0006202779,
0.0595376231,
0.0133786174,
0.0761440992,
-0.0528411753,
-0.0247986633,
0.0115809198,
-0.0366419777,
-0.0005577608,
-6.472445281e-33,
0.0159983095,
-0.1016434729,
-0.0250304136,
0.0133745391,
0.0236924011,
-0.0048750262,
0.0162430368,
-0.0176974088,
-0.0138216903,
0.0058238022,
-0.0244577788,
0.0232541524,
0.0296786912,
-0.0119842486,
0.0217515528,
0.0177803673,
0.0019713868,
0.0486047417,
0.0226504318,
0.0038872145,
0.0458037592,
0.0286213625,
0.0615822747,
-0.1169070825,
0.0597619265,
-0.0089976573,
-0.0385807902,
0.0346040577,
0.1001028493,
0.0323640518,
-0.0231004301,
0.0554998927,
0.0108065978,
0.0340091102,
0.0020385317,
-0.003036289,
-0.0191973522,
-0.0609586351,
0.0034485525,
0.0242926255,
0.0276304893,
-0.0018080141,
0.0043059899,
0.0016673183,
-0.0408295915,
0.0430739634,
0.0527995117,
-0.0009408502,
-0.0098268501,
-0.0687785149,
-0.0155297276,
0.0872761905,
-0.0110894544,
0.0308152754,
0.0137176774,
-0.0110314898,
0.0034806677,
0.0006227766,
-0.021140825,
0.0218767058,
-0.0346432775,
-0.0140861478,
-0.0110001015,
-0.0152934035,
-0.0167882927,
0.0102297738,
-0.0288748704,
-0.0287680961,
-0.0026264212,
0.0103891445,
-0.0106719853,
0.0148558123,
-0.0307766851,
0.1031567305,
0.0488438345,
-0.0356248878,
-0.0337444842,
0.0723643079,
0.0279924516,
0.0167260449,
-0.0054384363,
0.013668932,
-0.0734239891,
-0.018868139,
0.0203954075,
-0.0243723728,
-0.0213657748,
-0.008762409,
-0.0442798622,
-0.0004407511,
-0.0387234353,
0.071180068,
-0.025074847,
-0.013781786,
-0.0176219251,
0.0131297447,
0.0218876041,
0.0343879871,
0.011404532,
0.0398652628,
-0.0077370545,
-0.03845926,
0.0414577872,
0.045100987,
-0.0088220704,
0.0022488763,
0.0076967608,
-0.0031221923,
-0.0566101186,
0.026583245,
0.0597824045,
-0.0229768548,
-0.0424339399,
-0.0549199171,
0.0034751927,
-0.0059133023,
0.002563132,
0.0349109024,
0.0523751825,
0.0818033889,
0.0052121538,
-0.0151707297,
-0.0685878471,
-0.0006853393,
0.0350207873,
-0.0142036946,
0.0172028299,
0.0251303297,
0.0103412699,
0.0072061736,
-0.0125719607,
-0.0486765467,
2.8e-7,
0.0517419316,
0.0675184429,
-0.0026664394,
-0.017110046,
0.0008515324,
0.0465201959,
0.0506496467,
0.0266378541,
-0.0213840287,
0.0305956341,
0.0369471759,
-0.0102201337,
-0.0358527601,
0.0800040811,
0.0114941839,
-0.0147917755,
-0.0459570624,
0.0246542785,
-0.0313164853,
0.0501856618,
0.0506376661,
0.0505842343,
0.0396069176,
-0.0075213942,
-0.03644678,
-0.0271299668,
-0.0126439044,
-0.0198520478,
-0.0454622246,
0.0440605246,
-0.0114291282,
0.0002149497,
0.0044798478,
0.0168735217,
-0.0230576396,
0.0099322181,
0.0078821871,
0.003125374,
-0.0120968325,
0.0475516506,
-0.0074695391,
-0.0412976891,
0.0257620029,
-0.0232147034,
0.0468677506,
0.0031793453,
-0.0443984121,
0.0257575344,
-0.0026105798,
0.044450704,
0.0245189015,
0.0021063155,
-0.0753186271,
0.0271255784,
-0.0087170396,
0.0260217134,
-0.0427982174,
-0.1069535911,
0.0350364074,
0.0031750423,
0.0001460633,
0.0015653765,
0.0410598926,
-0.0177365653,
0.0488047861,
-0.0135897994,
0.0757661164,
2.277562779e-34,
0.0338068865,
0.0204857271,
-0.0464770943,
0.0017868464,
0.0061891116,
0.005120195,
0.0020682458,
0.0464872718,
0.025050953,
-0.0228384919,
0.0243802555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01412v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01412v2
|
The StatCan Dialogue Dataset: Retrieving Data Tables through Conversations with Genuine Intents
| 2023-04-03T23:18:30 | 2023-04-05T01:20:51 |
Xing Han Lu, Siva Reddy, Harm de Vries
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce the StatCan Dialogue Dataset consisting of 19,379 conversation
turns between agents working at Statistics Canada and online users looking for
published data tables. The conversations stem from genuine intents, are held in
English or French, and lead to agents retrieving one of over 5000 complex data
tables. Based on this dataset, we propose two tasks: (1) automatic retrieval of
relevant tables based on a on-going conversation, and (2) automatic generation
of appropriate agent responses at each turn. We investigate the difficulty of
each task by establishing strong baselines. Our experiments on a temporal data
split reveal that all models struggle to generalize to future conversations, as
we observe a significant drop in performance across both tasks when we move
from the validation to the test set. In addition, we find that response
generation models struggle to decide when to return a table. Considering that
the tasks pose significant challenges to existing models, we encourage the
community to develop models for our task, which can be directly used to help
knowledge workers find relevant tables for live chat users.
|
[
0.0473639257,
0.0937741846,
-0.0260306634,
0.0140252607,
-0.0252103489,
0.0131137976,
0.013602389,
-0.0004848186,
0.0117619988,
-0.0033619129,
-0.0007649563,
-0.0329452381,
0.0005322462,
0.050195083,
-0.0008850452,
-0.0337760411,
0.0168051347,
0.0192943234,
0.0127873998,
0.0139418254,
0.0158470087,
-0.0039629303,
-0.0314034186,
0.049686335,
-0.026413234,
0.0054885824,
-0.0505682901,
-0.010205972,
-0.0285302754,
0.0003027462,
0.0275816265,
0.0765875429,
-0.0007866113,
0.0252439193,
0.0000017648,
-0.0198917184,
-0.014256482,
-0.0066822604,
-0.067444101,
-0.0310163461,
0.0756405964,
-0.0101730051,
0.0263702814,
0.0184316244,
-0.0926243365,
0.0147526423,
0.0399233364,
-0.0067550787,
0.0302738529,
0.0628229901,
-0.0104406849,
0.0180545785,
-0.0318591148,
-0.0286413375,
0.0474517979,
-0.0618191324,
0.0269631352,
0.0396756865,
0.0180138461,
-0.006834283,
0.0308118835,
0.02510323,
0.0073201694,
-0.016090082,
-0.003161106,
0.0304861944,
-0.0549318977,
-0.0070947427,
0.0022907611,
0.1019909158,
0.0570746325,
0.0115811946,
0.0330965258,
-0.0057892096,
0.0364763066,
0.0083805788,
-0.0646925643,
-0.0212289169,
-0.0254663024,
-0.0419879742,
-0.0282460451,
-0.0076405359,
-0.0171898976,
-0.018554382,
-0.0471255183,
0.0208905637,
-0.0430862457,
-0.027378181,
-0.0173152164,
-0.0021494417,
0.0366005115,
-0.0618873835,
0.0111138625,
0.0231682844,
-0.0669573918,
0.0204497091,
0.0210000202,
-0.0138429217,
0.0239404663,
-0.0403684899,
-0.0099830413,
0.0249704197,
-0.0187191609,
0.0305024348,
0.0303193238,
0.0025325895,
0.0174650699,
-0.0027480975,
-0.0057624765,
-0.0296895467,
-0.0710987076,
-0.0090132067,
-0.0370454341,
0.0158711933,
-0.0754935518,
0.0212675426,
-0.0149478409,
0.0403624848,
-0.0195375644,
0.0348032266,
0.0131202368,
0.0321501307,
-0.0587467737,
0.0202446375,
-0.06430424,
0.0210395064,
-0.0515638888,
0.0125440182,
0.0230066553,
-0.1104380712,
0.0020189083,
-0.0168071631,
0.0314612575,
-0.0065030293,
0.0051612174,
0.0662589371,
0.0048032016,
-0.0011434993,
-0.0049786698,
-0.0681614503,
0.0035239051,
-0.0748770386,
-0.0175114404,
-0.020710079,
0.0842620656,
0.0058087767,
-0.0433474034,
-0.0435284972,
-0.0075596292,
0.0372722298,
-0.0207065344,
0.0609213263,
0.0265662707,
0.0231177919,
0.0158122014,
-0.0036401092,
-0.0417113304,
0.0891578719,
-0.0072035179,
0.0041255555,
0.0307703596,
-0.014557492,
0.0342077836,
0.0263881758,
0.0567643382,
0.0159163214,
0.0255973022,
0.0783168823,
-0.0118043674,
0.0224787965,
-0.0203774739,
0.013601766,
-0.0460846089,
0.0061299689,
0.0452150442,
0.0605893508,
-0.0227530021,
0.0511951819,
0.0146898702,
0.0290511437,
-0.0068539553,
0.0070912917,
-0.0183049478,
0.0252066627,
0.018277796,
-0.0033474558,
0.0368708894,
-0.0258384179,
-0.0369748399,
-0.0596116669,
0.0438259691,
0.0295049772,
0.0088051874,
0.0480147265,
0.0394059345,
0.0116650565,
-0.0447740816,
0.0011916058,
-0.018060701,
-0.0560242943,
-0.0436888449,
-0.0373190455,
0.0284220278,
0.0837808996,
0.0655494705,
-0.0321582742,
-0.0496271737,
-0.0209175069,
0.0415566824,
0.0208299626,
0.0551489815,
-0.0441686884,
0.0276833978,
-0.0176982172,
-0.0320035331,
0.0455903187,
0.0036794082,
0.0024323438,
0.0366090834,
-0.0011106522,
0.0046831653,
-0.003937515,
-0.0091563854,
0.0071392376,
-0.0193280857,
0.0053656064,
0.0190450866,
0.0080985753,
0.0472442061,
0.0371566638,
-0.0038299728,
0.0227442272,
0.0255758092,
0.0113750985,
0.0014779225,
0.0275886673,
0.0062306249,
-0.0313562863,
0.0205817465,
-0.0105945468,
-0.0243987534,
-0.0159418061,
-0.0315506272,
-0.0327600017,
0.018938629,
-0.0324433781,
0.0101148076,
-0.0258383024,
-0.0046639168,
0.0320443548,
0.0312800482,
0.001965858,
0.0559414364,
0.0034832724,
0.0265769158,
0.0483398326,
-0.0758973435,
0.0164014939,
-0.1027993336,
0.0556823052,
0.0098883742,
-0.0227612928,
0.032009121,
0.0172463469,
0.0048463685,
-0.0659699365,
0.0012800163,
-0.1187240183,
0.0291605387,
-0.0166025292,
0.0138061717,
0.0080034751,
0.0273964405,
-0.0228371173,
-0.0268613398,
-0.0647303462,
0.0068507632,
0.0434379987,
0.0308667365,
0.059008684,
0.029919615,
-0.0368836708,
-0.0554878116,
-0.0124502499,
0.0013493149,
0.0214192197,
-0.0027604911,
-0.028965041,
-0.0047863116,
-0.0194047503,
-0.0463100374,
0.0257613622,
-0.0177678131,
-0.0197623465,
0.0114756534,
-0.0379556566,
0.0115035754,
0.0644469336,
0.021334039,
0.0478009731,
-0.0379071943,
-0.0483022444,
-0.0885537416,
0.0248775836,
-0.0436565429,
0.0189599358,
0.0099439602,
-0.0569155514,
0.0340134911,
0.0338729471,
-0.0011291752,
0.014888539,
-0.0310847443,
0.0202429835,
0.0315141715,
-0.0174360406,
-0.0594175458,
0.0475811213,
0.0112843867,
0.0358644873,
-0.0052784798,
-0.0096768299,
0.0430035554,
0.0081888102,
-0.0084452592,
-0.0333136804,
-0.0128648775,
-0.0142122908,
0.0804612637,
0.0034990653,
-0.0131697161,
-0.022775799,
-0.0271849148,
-0.0477965325,
-0.0330877267,
0.0566752777,
-0.0539329015,
0.0625806898,
-0.0357321762,
0.0145010334,
-0.0083415853,
-0.0461966582,
-0.0314864665,
-0.0733295158,
-0.0504130796,
-0.021880202,
0.0083925072,
-0.0264519136,
-0.0656413957,
-0.0125902714,
0.0147780422,
0.0375484526,
0.0058474359,
-0.0396831855,
0.0018769072,
-0.0041885367,
0.032057479,
0.0156990346,
-0.0380781367,
-0.0268447939,
0.0588875636,
0.0349380039,
0.0142844822,
-0.0010403662,
0.0080928113,
-0.0298065115,
-0.0045136032,
-0.0076539698,
0.0173317846,
0.0278721638,
0.0034882736,
-0.0287071988,
-0.0256719589,
0.0601396561,
0.0225757807,
0.0268196613,
-0.029201068,
-0.0101900604,
0.021861041,
-0.0044325781,
0.0424308926,
-0.098548457,
-0.0021318148,
0.0103816595,
0.0318609923,
-0.0369566791,
-0.0696686432,
-0.0123928199,
-0.0863508508,
0.0647050142,
-0.0349704213,
-0.0362401158,
-0.0455292128,
-0.030007625,
-0.0074031455,
-0.0444172099,
0.0195931625,
0.0305037126,
0.0186505392,
-0.0012694262,
0.0157447625,
-0.0370649844,
-0.0368776359,
-0.0011456762,
-0.0230114497,
0.0455993712,
0.0601870082,
0.0586175136,
0.0287703406,
0.0148931257,
0.0232353453,
0.0444125086,
-0.0204343032,
0.0091909925,
0.1026290059,
0.0088404724,
0.0090051703,
-0.0290044267,
0.0214851834,
-0.0319509581,
0.0167828016,
0.04117129,
0.0162509214,
-0.0485285372,
-0.0045908969,
0.0023977719,
0.0478020981,
0.0334000401,
0.0751640201,
0.0436317623,
0.0091758976,
-0.0448131301,
-0.0312984549,
-0.0101890434,
-0.0654171407,
0.0183970574,
0.0247606132,
-0.0051680077,
0.0013753201,
-0.0749155432,
-0.0639217421,
0.0408989415,
0.0360427015,
-0.010794431,
0.0110297166,
0.0067726942,
0.0144748231,
-0.0262994282,
0.0004373491,
-0.0566042848,
0.0044264537,
-0.0259853788,
-0.0405728631,
0.0077709462,
-0.0429878198,
-0.0163381714,
0.0253730342,
-0.0857704878,
-0.0346847437,
-0.0219561141,
0.0229006577,
0.0403501354,
0.0324472524,
-0.0095576858,
-0.0077302945,
-0.0163546912,
0.0534307957,
-0.0721299127,
-0.0532255806,
0.0078107161,
0.0338214263,
-0.0048724497,
0.0348010175,
-0.0362434462,
0.007757144,
-0.038474597,
0.0153694367,
-0.0338987745,
-0.0218313802,
0.0175224151,
0.0177405607,
-0.0071108188,
0.0663935915,
-0.0736000985,
-0.0370835289,
0.0329300426,
-0.0313462615,
-0.033943858,
-0.0190731641,
-0.0044496129,
-0.0120772831,
-0.0225395281,
0.0012713106,
0.0129991109,
-0.0264586844,
0.0391886942,
-0.0485121161,
-0.0250427723,
0.0260804575,
0.0064725173,
0.0394522883,
-0.0317303427,
-0.0169053338,
0.0109471008,
0.0321975388,
0.0566404909,
0.0054260041,
0.0396654643,
0.0168753453,
-0.0248426273,
0.0331223197,
0.0022767219,
-0.1043530926,
-0.0690024868,
-0.0161697846,
0.0329082645,
0.0064340951,
0.0256973617,
-0.0149653973,
-0.0307708159,
0.0136788497,
-0.010053983,
0.0381898247,
0.0175940245,
-0.0227969978,
0.0153246233,
0.0081274239,
-0.0325369164,
-0.0326356962,
0.0795428678,
0.0005400499,
0.0271075591,
0.0000229098,
-0.0384002626,
-0.0644332841,
-0.023153929,
-0.011462627,
-0.0165169556,
0.007621096,
-0.0477092527,
-0.024925366,
-0.0363820381,
-0.0013604144,
0.0153143592,
-0.0372173972,
0.0012836573,
0.026861852,
0.0599752069,
0.0290052313,
0.0112249181,
-0.0503107496,
0.0523451045,
-0.030632088,
-0.0297246128,
-0.0319470428,
-5.641552609e-33,
-0.0146719338,
-0.0246305969,
0.0385040566,
-0.0013321801,
-0.0048397118,
-0.0153012462,
-0.0480573662,
-0.0055111782,
-0.0264159236,
0.0054220008,
-0.0402465574,
0.0606994405,
0.0320661925,
0.0143316491,
0.0120095713,
-0.0806398317,
0.0335727856,
-0.0197823737,
-0.0136111267,
0.0283153709,
0.0383988135,
0.0220787432,
-0.0007436147,
-0.0654751509,
0.0513779745,
-0.0027366218,
0.010435544,
0.0104437806,
0.0251058638,
0.0437706523,
-0.0296556484,
0.0357259624,
0.0279135704,
-0.0235230178,
-0.0296872761,
0.0424295664,
-0.0995017588,
-0.0371920653,
-0.0207495149,
0.0161153227,
0.0016644998,
-0.0055132629,
0.0298503991,
-0.0077332743,
-0.0024212347,
0.0045506186,
0.0257336739,
-0.0149693312,
-0.0308215637,
-0.0069204974,
-0.0103213806,
0.0273680147,
-0.0222071279,
-0.0164850131,
0.0152426157,
0.1026918665,
0.0465118885,
-0.038116198,
-0.0079977624,
0.0557333045,
0.0144990878,
0.0046546976,
0.0406511165,
-0.0177215748,
0.0320893936,
0.0091780573,
0.0371818356,
0.0364241004,
-0.0399416909,
-0.0523141064,
-0.037378639,
0.0650489703,
-0.0009714742,
0.0502407476,
-0.0134415636,
-0.0326939747,
-0.0560226925,
0.0646405593,
0.0490394123,
-0.0157854445,
0.0213098507,
-0.0326333009,
-0.0645681471,
-0.0231451076,
-0.0062721879,
0.0093967319,
-0.0275692809,
-0.018430559,
0.0491984673,
0.0271131489,
0.0450896136,
-0.0263526328,
0.0348668993,
-0.0279379878,
-0.0263950806,
0.0369066522,
0.0004494951,
-0.0321931057,
0.0148984715,
-0.0204729289,
-0.0341489613,
-0.0108954208,
0.0319777131,
0.0281097442,
0.0106027788,
0.0492596366,
0.0002348409,
-0.0193208233,
-0.0542586632,
-0.0230191089,
-0.0271813162,
0.0953094289,
-0.042381186,
0.0249655768,
0.0190057773,
0.0325083248,
-0.0074371588,
0.0613931827,
-0.0030444001,
0.0059878961,
-0.039485313,
0.002082794,
0.0063762912,
-0.0161113162,
-0.0072230259,
-0.0142898355,
-0.0328830704,
-0.0315544456,
0.02595759,
-0.0111995451,
0.0121382819,
-0.0254097711,
2.381e-7,
0.0370597914,
0.0013530286,
0.0462441817,
0.0495462678,
-0.0044555785,
0.0031018697,
0.003760746,
0.0075444654,
0.0039168089,
-0.0368773602,
0.0665623248,
-0.0131266369,
0.0654284284,
0.0545399338,
-0.0690044984,
-0.0974796563,
-0.0477743559,
-0.0325189047,
-0.0568525642,
-0.0207391828,
0.0443726853,
0.0707636401,
-0.0255991239,
0.024122946,
-0.0031821595,
-0.0272775218,
0.0392488167,
-0.0664544031,
0.006645829,
0.0326279402,
0.0741541088,
-0.0042557446,
0.0257824231,
0.0666919798,
-0.0321277082,
0.002362808,
-0.0279909037,
0.0568028614,
0.0247196443,
-0.0242031459,
-0.0123566911,
-0.0649971887,
0.0359845944,
-0.0300180316,
0.0493475497,
-0.0804457366,
-0.0070284875,
0.077668719,
-0.0266665593,
-0.0098583465,
0.0095207067,
-0.005445045,
-0.0085317902,
0.0164602324,
0.0276697818,
0.0222584717,
0.0410256498,
-0.0462367497,
0.0068233744,
-0.0000614778,
-0.0503878593,
-0.0586068965,
-0.0067156279,
-0.0222850479,
-0.0293453913,
-0.0040196297,
0.0057159737,
1.874871016e-34,
0.0413085446,
0.0379750989,
-0.0084957099,
0.03428673,
0.0659432113,
-0.0303407442,
0.0186105203,
0.0071225306,
0.0528862216,
-0.0612798557,
-0.0242725462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02020v1
|
A Bibliometric Review of Large Language Models Research from 2017 to 2023
| 2023-04-03T21:46:41 | 2023-04-03T21:46:41 |
Lizhou Fan, Lingyao Li, Zihui Ma, Sanggyu Lee, Huizi Yu, Libby Hemphill
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are a class of language models that have
demonstrated outstanding performance across a range of natural language
processing (NLP) tasks and have become a highly sought-after research area,
because of their ability to generate human-like language and their potential to
revolutionize science and technology. In this study, we conduct bibliometric
and discourse analyses of scholarly literature on LLMs. Synthesizing over 5,000
publications, this paper serves as a roadmap for researchers, practitioners,
and policymakers to navigate the current landscape of LLMs research. We present
the research trends from 2017 to early 2023, identifying patterns in research
paradigms and collaborations. We start with analyzing the core algorithm
developments and NLP tasks that are fundamental in LLMs research. We then
investigate the applications of LLMs in various fields and domains including
medicine, engineering, social science, and humanities. Our review also reveals
the dynamic, fast-paced evolution of LLMs research. Overall, this paper offers
valuable insights into the current state, impact, and potential of LLMs
research and its applications.
|
[
0.0742833838,
0.0837658122,
-0.007056281,
0.0164908189,
-0.0514704771,
0.0002064637,
0.0058149784,
0.0368930213,
0.0141139692,
-0.0761804283,
-0.0074314191,
-0.0481925271,
0.0225703754,
0.0245145522,
0.0458074547,
-0.0179668758,
0.0263211392,
-0.0443916544,
0.0126875313,
-0.0230387524,
-0.0258064158,
0.0216229837,
0.0161815155,
0.0587893389,
0.0235854872,
0.0054309922,
0.0349041596,
-0.0111932866,
-0.0118881399,
-0.0451122373,
-0.022010643,
0.0276599675,
0.016534131,
0.0779272765,
0.000002107,
-0.0734301284,
0.0056680799,
0.0185341816,
0.001751524,
0.024217993,
0.0620700046,
-0.0500720702,
-0.0185843017,
-0.00084918,
-0.0209250934,
-0.0109938802,
0.0563096367,
0.0240433645,
0.002738381,
0.0380954854,
-0.0161999464,
-0.0553400852,
0.0614259765,
-0.0341281518,
-0.0488136932,
-0.0253025722,
0.0714937076,
0.0025814185,
0.0415213816,
0.0271163881,
-0.0106958468,
0.0328052379,
-0.0366082601,
0.004848998,
0.0163138974,
0.0556185208,
0.0036827277,
-0.0178069845,
0.0079881344,
0.0573123991,
-0.0003671534,
-0.0168356933,
0.0454574786,
0.0050768433,
-0.0425166562,
0.0212803949,
-0.0357928351,
0.0449609682,
0.0042093806,
0.0431600437,
0.0413519852,
-0.017466398,
0.0573608428,
0.0467331335,
-0.0384651311,
0.0617698096,
0.0308127552,
-0.0449400917,
0.0117780752,
0.0024001463,
-0.029840745,
-0.0416325666,
0.0156331696,
0.0072826482,
-0.021610409,
0.019577615,
-0.005554121,
-0.0126016606,
0.0544264205,
-0.0350455679,
0.04202649,
-0.0105225677,
0.0212356541,
0.0475266203,
0.0065071541,
0.0384034105,
-0.059003029,
-0.0202919859,
-0.0223582909,
-0.0102333315,
-0.0336253941,
-0.0196006689,
-0.0115611479,
-0.008918291,
-0.0273986962,
-0.0384848006,
-0.0432707295,
0.0075827879,
0.0070067332,
-0.008370324,
0.0053789895,
0.0083308928,
0.0069410624,
-0.0338995494,
-0.0199113954,
0.0253202934,
0.0318160281,
0.0222741999,
-0.0424338132,
-0.034188211,
0.0239072759,
0.0246112719,
-0.0135444412,
-0.0309635606,
0.0011932622,
0.054161232,
0.0296654534,
-0.028584227,
-0.0128721809,
-0.0015991124,
-0.0453165583,
-0.0683382526,
-0.0040579089,
-0.0786353052,
0.0349228941,
-0.0048892805,
0.0276069306,
-0.081040673,
0.0283548795,
0.0079485243,
-0.0793356076,
0.0516995564,
-0.0315830484,
0.0468987375,
0.0306944996,
-0.0311642308,
0.0570028611,
0.0369843617,
0.0558722578,
-0.0363021418,
0.0495179594,
-0.0177896284,
-0.0063209827,
0.062513411,
-0.0172757655,
-0.0059436569,
-0.0237334948,
-0.034901578,
0.0147000765,
0.0661801621,
0.0104645342,
0.0995200276,
-0.0055451156,
-0.0266109072,
0.060109742,
0.0888243169,
-0.0149671184,
0.0214554388,
0.043605309,
0.0262335297,
0.0176500957,
-0.0483405292,
-0.0193393119,
-0.0270806197,
-0.0134394662,
-0.0030917011,
0.0465968251,
0.0511974394,
-0.0079888599,
-0.0041704392,
-0.0370193198,
-0.0176814888,
0.0201913379,
-0.0171021987,
0.08036156,
-0.0290120281,
-0.0151341101,
0.0458362401,
0.0508055761,
-0.0049023801,
0.0180284902,
-0.0657860339,
0.0102494685,
0.0645970777,
0.0725007057,
-0.021429684,
0.0293007214,
-0.0043427423,
-0.0021435164,
0.0552351773,
-0.0073310048,
0.0070052627,
-0.0123645151,
-0.023870023,
0.0159182418,
0.023991771,
0.0023554594,
-0.0100543331,
0.0112022329,
-0.006987452,
-0.0130503457,
-0.0239360929,
-0.0585065745,
0.0546932556,
-0.0609556288,
0.0133027779,
0.0209577326,
-0.0346517414,
0.042583894,
0.0338337086,
-0.0229926389,
0.0256161094,
0.0524520576,
-0.0566890612,
-0.0021230737,
0.0019532889,
-0.0059294859,
0.0009632335,
0.0601379238,
0.0026843625,
0.0091218129,
0.0151975667,
-0.0079040499,
-0.0309240445,
0.0208381563,
-0.0266463235,
0.0374026336,
-0.0368056819,
0.0319326967,
-0.0195554625,
0.0234245677,
-0.0504845232,
0.0544699691,
-0.0189565811,
0.0318209231,
0.0105439983,
-0.0299919974,
0.0012149456,
-0.0157718901,
-0.0483853333,
0.051967863,
0.013040646,
0.0143306376,
0.0299363863,
-0.0088110296,
-0.0132440701,
-0.0622795857,
-0.0656515434,
-0.0162666533,
0.0073760431,
0.0050271004,
-0.0309948083,
0.0007033278,
-0.0138549786,
0.024405105,
-0.010776001,
-0.0298607033,
0.050635837,
0.0072696023,
0.0290943645,
-0.0095539745,
-0.0313805304,
-0.0369289741,
-0.0334361307,
-0.0042451182,
0.0523469746,
0.0028017396,
-0.0196125545,
-0.0542491227,
0.0291491784,
-0.0248987377,
0.0102356076,
-0.014945372,
0.0089779599,
-0.0159532744,
-0.0003781977,
0.0601135418,
0.0547269806,
0.0126643041,
0.0164717007,
0.0577298664,
-0.0007927818,
-0.0199774131,
-0.0217163693,
-0.0364674926,
-0.018813258,
-0.0546525754,
-0.0448850915,
0.0212457143,
0.0536648482,
-0.0257313363,
-0.012493589,
-0.0249582399,
0.012595119,
-0.0465492792,
-0.0346319005,
-0.0082383743,
-0.0153897088,
-0.0307089388,
0.0450671911,
-0.0259421282,
-0.0379049294,
0.0563352033,
-0.0523442514,
0.0214310475,
-0.044780504,
-0.0207612589,
-0.0490996763,
0.0477060936,
0.0235227402,
0.0101589309,
0.0182473753,
-0.0029075453,
0.0030877532,
0.0240257382,
-0.0390581712,
-0.0448554046,
0.0459759496,
-0.0575526021,
0.0411926471,
0.0012391497,
-0.025885921,
-0.0095310751,
-0.0602637492,
-0.0627362356,
0.0354580991,
0.0490605533,
-0.0364414267,
-0.0503369756,
0.0313968547,
0.0102625098,
-0.0131103471,
0.0172341429,
0.0062603494,
-0.0319486931,
0.0369052142,
0.0684288144,
-0.0011064676,
0.0401600227,
-0.0166264251,
0.0090989433,
0.0527580231,
0.0239199884,
0.0514038578,
-0.0206205174,
-0.0062842853,
0.0444111302,
-0.0315925144,
-0.0217166916,
-0.0102107991,
0.0282844063,
-0.0348412693,
0.017869357,
0.1205233186,
0.0327860899,
-0.0523422323,
0.02906036,
0.0038754889,
0.0175433792,
0.010518264,
0.0001457694,
-0.0625030473,
-0.006282283,
0.0071553686,
0.0009758951,
-0.0397194661,
-0.060424991,
-0.0019464213,
-0.1158681214,
0.0268045384,
0.0098738167,
0.0227490701,
-0.0083628921,
-0.0469431207,
0.0023884214,
-0.0172697138,
-0.0133463955,
-0.0010940678,
-0.0218214709,
-0.0184734538,
0.0235093515,
-0.0728541836,
-0.0901885778,
0.01640171,
-0.069803901,
0.0774581805,
0.0532897487,
0.0510702766,
-0.0147214988,
0.0078576067,
0.0027576874,
-0.0124961277,
-0.003690314,
-0.0164981261,
0.0283685252,
-0.0161689203,
-0.0083758822,
-0.0348045118,
0.0355599113,
-0.0455971397,
-0.0142955799,
0.0042772354,
0.076901406,
-0.0100847501,
0.0021193267,
-0.0216867011,
0.0040294533,
-0.0225095171,
0.0696614012,
-0.0026152581,
-0.0606630817,
-0.0278839432,
-0.0062531489,
0.0154120401,
-0.0199865345,
-0.0621586777,
-0.0091026202,
0.0067503937,
0.0028461902,
-0.036635235,
-0.0059397197,
0.0164658353,
-0.0422600619,
0.0280211736,
0.041949328,
0.061344672,
-0.0367723927,
-0.0334726311,
0.0035437262,
-0.0343476199,
0.038347017,
-0.0706946999,
-0.0070936033,
0.0760691166,
0.0006487621,
-0.0186519567,
0.0333064497,
-0.0677346736,
-0.0785928518,
-0.0161713548,
0.0109820729,
0.0153841395,
0.0242787842,
-0.0188565776,
-0.0633527413,
0.0324303806,
0.0379351713,
-0.0455925055,
0.0435400754,
-0.0317640081,
0.0199754015,
-0.0134888394,
0.0350629911,
-0.01312056,
0.0148778139,
-0.0032612123,
0.0490382053,
-0.0145924715,
-0.0672549307,
0.0088625681,
0.0037453002,
0.0205032863,
-0.045596499,
0.0194723271,
-0.0209336411,
-0.0368593149,
-0.0232351273,
-0.0069282432,
-0.0498990603,
-0.013503422,
0.0482052527,
-0.001210348,
-0.0405524485,
0.016325321,
-0.014003682,
0.0538295768,
-0.0332730934,
0.0469907857,
-0.032677684,
0.0128825596,
0.0315220989,
-0.0165745169,
0.0126688806,
0.0295477826,
-0.0490859598,
0.0157707948,
-0.0108372783,
0.0242274906,
0.0011368922,
-0.0261491183,
-0.0410481617,
0.0288474057,
-0.0480059795,
-0.0306748524,
0.0117646838,
0.03393263,
0.0600345805,
0.0170800965,
0.0715272501,
-0.0303417537,
-0.0191627461,
-0.0533030555,
0.0134383915,
-0.0143855019,
-0.0176260583,
0.0005640215,
0.0102217421,
-0.0488884971,
0.0425579362,
0.0942014903,
0.0635982826,
0.0120447529,
0.0085231187,
-0.0188894235,
-0.004728701,
-0.0442964025,
-0.0215838291,
-0.0006617492,
-0.0331705548,
0.0244823676,
-0.0726359487,
-0.0514474399,
0.0364059694,
-0.014601483,
-0.0051204516,
-0.0568125807,
-0.0013653419,
0.0477630086,
-0.0017247472,
0.0030773003,
-0.0543641634,
0.012622701,
-0.0166822746,
-0.0576815195,
-0.0023298992,
-6.821914609e-33,
-0.0018225898,
-0.0305118058,
0.0229322109,
-0.0262719709,
-0.0566811077,
0.0113154333,
-0.0266164225,
0.016622059,
-0.0014309274,
0.005084713,
-0.0259403456,
-0.0232170485,
-0.0023158272,
0.0314481445,
0.0300192107,
0.0411799587,
0.0504706576,
-0.0281380732,
0.0224898756,
0.0171711426,
0.0107983183,
0.0174018815,
0.0139136221,
-0.0783234909,
0.0313693136,
0.00537004,
0.0117172571,
0.0215980858,
-0.0011711882,
0.06260892,
-0.0798203349,
0.0547279418,
0.041952569,
-0.0353053585,
-0.0138307679,
0.0223744512,
-0.073111631,
0.0474446155,
0.0214869846,
-0.0244039781,
-0.0102167111,
-0.0326652937,
0.0384000242,
-0.0028362877,
-0.0577606037,
0.0260336734,
0.0289409757,
-0.0591746531,
-0.0406551883,
-0.0217353869,
-0.0513079502,
0.0387867466,
-0.0003235489,
0.0156049877,
0.0372464545,
0.012078152,
-0.0380032025,
0.0694367513,
-0.0451572314,
0.0456430353,
0.0172892306,
0.0273789428,
0.0278056562,
0.0039374894,
0.03809084,
0.0620649084,
0.0170563962,
-0.02237905,
-0.0269466136,
-0.0201855898,
0.0235084966,
0.0307845064,
0.0155130532,
0.0465544872,
-0.0251993574,
-0.0146251842,
-0.0590175502,
-0.0162689891,
-0.0037442152,
0.0322025716,
0.0548943765,
0.0047877454,
-0.0108311893,
-0.0486075133,
-0.031811852,
-0.0277439263,
0.0018498735,
0.0060766577,
0.0135789001,
0.0138561651,
-0.0219440386,
0.0297236759,
0.0424288213,
-0.0783135518,
-0.0485499837,
0.0187470112,
0.0277121663,
0.0429496355,
-0.0079019209,
0.0256158356,
-0.1209343076,
-0.0433787443,
-0.0091149881,
-0.0076792291,
-0.0114607792,
-0.0328402407,
-0.0303244423,
-0.0100820996,
-0.0333038308,
0.0026222747,
0.011271758,
-0.0057402677,
0.0099624274,
0.023906514,
0.0243806746,
0.0235150252,
0.029569611,
0.0290816948,
0.0333104059,
0.0029493903,
0.0092894966,
-0.0007446986,
-0.0011454123,
0.026305519,
-0.032182049,
0.0215594806,
-0.0371207148,
-0.000486231,
0.0490771346,
-0.0314574018,
-0.0098784752,
-0.0326780304,
2.837e-7,
0.0432441644,
0.0619765557,
0.0146952979,
-0.0323810056,
0.0627761632,
0.0082367603,
0.0123018194,
0.0114121931,
0.0039409031,
0.0075111981,
-0.004212141,
0.034907978,
0.0530560873,
-0.0250413977,
-0.087793611,
0.0155337192,
-0.0825254321,
-0.0007328398,
-0.0829354674,
-0.0063504032,
-0.0053740549,
0.1063569486,
-0.0163121782,
-0.0135453828,
-0.0376041979,
-0.0562289804,
0.0746232346,
-0.0700258464,
-0.0299748909,
0.0460984297,
0.0065458189,
0.0017891946,
0.019472979,
0.0000991612,
0.0195217747,
0.0437225848,
0.0253349282,
0.0422654562,
-0.0231801867,
0.0130384555,
0.0332764126,
0.0054651494,
-0.0202889834,
-0.0585571453,
0.0635323822,
-0.0455112867,
-0.0649294853,
-0.0448840708,
-0.0027841195,
-0.0114868768,
0.0177679937,
-0.0220943615,
-0.0408142731,
0.0111409742,
0.0335594378,
0.008430873,
-0.0038743946,
-0.0539858192,
0.0093348986,
-0.0095474422,
-0.0526309051,
-0.0321471877,
-0.0232374389,
0.0010975479,
0.0157141183,
-0.0559056178,
0.0129922768,
2.748147376e-34,
0.0439768955,
-0.0149450889,
-0.0071405075,
0.0392689966,
0.0264922678,
0.0120131979,
-0.0235059038,
0.0392672271,
-0.0219274741,
-0.129531309,
0.0172287636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01373v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01373v2
|
Pythia: A Suite for Analyzing Large Language Models Across Training and Scaling
| 2023-04-03T20:58:15 | 2023-05-31T17:54:07 |
Stella Biderman, Hailey Schoelkopf, Quentin Anthony, Herbie Bradley, Kyle O'Brien, Eric Hallahan, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Shivanshu Purohit, USVSN Sai Prashanth, Edward Raff, Aviya Skowron, Lintang Sutawika, Oskar van der Wal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How do large language models (LLMs) develop and evolve over the course of
training? How do these patterns change as models scale? To answer these
questions, we introduce \textit{Pythia}, a suite of 16 LLMs all trained on
public data seen in the exact same order and ranging in size from 70M to 12B
parameters. We provide public access to 154 checkpoints for each one of the 16
models, alongside tools to download and reconstruct their exact training
dataloaders for further study. We intend \textit{Pythia} to facilitate research
in many areas, and we present several case studies including novel results in
memorization, term frequency effects on few-shot performance, and reducing
gender bias. We demonstrate that this highly controlled setup can be used to
yield novel insights toward LLMs and their training dynamics. Trained models,
analysis code, training code, and training data can be found at
\url{https://github.com/EleutherAI/pythia}.
|
[
-0.0184422266,
0.0585823692,
-0.0142371384,
0.0330051146,
0.0032638414,
0.0138524352,
0.0297546349,
-0.0025322647,
-0.0456722192,
-0.0449339785,
-0.0582325123,
-0.0737704486,
0.0054460745,
0.0066042156,
0.0323745757,
-0.0539315827,
0.0468869656,
-0.0633978918,
-0.0006838673,
-0.0151298763,
-0.0085814409,
-0.0043609911,
-0.0144572519,
0.0371306166,
0.032081753,
-0.0201596711,
-0.0039053748,
-0.0046448158,
-0.0094075175,
-0.0400562882,
-0.0134085547,
0.0636896119,
0.0204943083,
0.0725446418,
0.00000215,
-0.059916582,
0.0170428082,
-0.0113158282,
-0.040463075,
0.0932239816,
0.0400333814,
0.0094470587,
-0.0168460123,
0.0134929335,
-0.0065697436,
-0.0595759153,
0.0246631671,
-0.0103219915,
0.0248081535,
0.0611763075,
0.0104441028,
-0.0116385836,
-0.003785081,
-0.0564144365,
-0.013753402,
-0.0354440585,
0.0277842134,
-0.0124504482,
-0.0382491611,
0.0054869931,
-0.0409394316,
0.0176638849,
0.0046776854,
0.036836274,
0.0072991806,
0.0840761587,
-0.0129552437,
-0.0453839004,
0.005969407,
0.0285220668,
-0.0016132306,
-0.0302011427,
0.0126149515,
-0.0011845217,
-0.0104751391,
-0.0058270516,
-0.0733331442,
0.0363589972,
0.0192023944,
-0.0050862804,
-0.0066655441,
-0.0480661355,
0.058347743,
0.0214015767,
-0.0328746773,
-0.0020958656,
0.0434652083,
-0.0262800902,
-0.0042022103,
-0.0086977771,
0.0048204279,
-0.0806372538,
-0.0020482377,
0.0246738885,
0.0012600082,
0.0010130724,
-0.0124680456,
-0.0196864158,
0.0415735058,
-0.0412607454,
0.0673489571,
0.0325948969,
-0.0221757926,
0.0329419747,
-0.0417296849,
0.0494453646,
-0.0029896307,
0.0269993767,
-0.0013315444,
0.0147846639,
-0.0499895662,
-0.0049548154,
-0.0196786448,
-0.0028710591,
0.0224432554,
-0.0049322839,
-0.0713657513,
0.0106734792,
0.0149489082,
-0.0103358356,
0.0096367132,
0.0048091621,
-0.0260255709,
0.0148811704,
0.0024951107,
0.044018589,
-0.0540964119,
0.006919052,
-0.0001957053,
-0.0565345995,
-0.0369988456,
-0.0003148956,
0.0119243618,
-0.010186214,
0.020891998,
0.0325655602,
-0.0008263949,
-0.0637197271,
-0.0523253046,
0.0182993095,
-0.0219630711,
-0.0879809111,
-0.0058669383,
-0.072632581,
-0.0049732514,
0.0244769137,
0.0188850779,
-0.0229447652,
-0.004533093,
0.0293948185,
-0.0185791496,
0.0390699059,
0.0481505021,
0.0146079678,
0.0283198878,
0.0004643077,
0.0065128938,
0.0920085087,
0.0432796367,
0.0052425941,
0.0415322073,
-0.0313661098,
0.0116765257,
0.0460038669,
0.0324534774,
0.0261535551,
-0.0347910039,
-0.0050762775,
0.0491722636,
0.041382581,
0.0663761348,
0.0027367715,
-0.0278522242,
-0.0316926688,
0.076286979,
0.0841060951,
0.0170540567,
0.0182462186,
0.026106691,
-0.0276125148,
0.0274414085,
-0.0046357401,
-0.049010817,
0.010300017,
0.0094017945,
0.0108931093,
0.0107378112,
0.0518156812,
-0.0482882783,
-0.026731519,
-0.0411143787,
0.0201556943,
-0.0270975418,
0.0175335221,
0.0670946762,
-0.0050017964,
-0.0145934708,
0.0848833174,
0.0438732021,
-0.0614627078,
0.0095612919,
-0.0315027982,
0.029222345,
0.0358742587,
0.0148623381,
-0.0338897221,
-0.0003833544,
0.0098093431,
0.0343176723,
0.0526213124,
0.0343780518,
0.0012780052,
0.0375977904,
-0.078916356,
-0.0013631111,
-0.008002501,
0.0281717516,
0.0301911347,
0.022348078,
0.0303879231,
0.0201890413,
-0.0154982945,
-0.0166158751,
0.0430706143,
-0.0574865863,
-0.0510856509,
0.0047628544,
-0.0224551149,
0.0068895151,
0.0073421327,
-0.0307750944,
0.0056647393,
0.0451145284,
-0.0109080868,
0.0295206048,
0.0084924325,
-0.0490127541,
-0.0033084655,
0.042841889,
0.040020965,
0.0025624891,
0.0259233601,
-0.0192451365,
-0.0339874476,
0.0544108711,
-0.0061997129,
0.0546717681,
-0.0291562062,
0.041416686,
-0.0170956515,
0.0512517132,
-0.0189568084,
0.0263756663,
-0.0116416169,
-0.0009305474,
0.0158714615,
-0.0176180061,
0.0094096558,
-0.0707476735,
-0.0259274859,
0.0409706905,
-0.007386364,
0.0159217175,
0.000061925,
-0.0289502013,
-0.0397580452,
-0.0073371953,
-0.0822140202,
0.0262832288,
-0.0243115518,
0.0392085761,
0.0165681466,
-0.0158413127,
-0.0438269041,
-0.004310742,
0.0111869276,
0.0041601066,
-0.015358394,
0.0532940589,
0.0102701522,
0.0076763295,
-0.0254584346,
-0.0585829951,
-0.0462880954,
-0.0171372015,
0.0747590065,
-0.0143641727,
-0.0035397108,
-0.0403826609,
0.0292776693,
-0.0088477489,
0.0169545151,
-0.0112763736,
-0.0446035117,
0.0305716731,
-0.0061684288,
0.038158346,
0.08220651,
0.0041005644,
0.0182077251,
0.0849428922,
-0.0367758274,
-0.0535280518,
-0.0028861207,
0.0001716406,
-0.038399592,
-0.0245569982,
-0.0354059711,
-0.0262111407,
0.0931640863,
-0.0009292724,
0.003333692,
-0.0450898334,
-0.0127892299,
-0.0473181158,
-0.0163569525,
-0.0486456715,
0.0215835217,
-0.0375176296,
0.011760015,
-0.0139170419,
-0.0553255491,
0.0198770911,
-0.0361645855,
-0.0075384253,
-0.0116253644,
-0.023410406,
-0.0412781239,
0.0740166306,
0.0164657719,
-0.0037655397,
0.0276265163,
-0.0142859137,
-0.0439238735,
-0.0306473728,
-0.0090422248,
-0.0312959254,
0.0469111502,
-0.0432705395,
0.0082607409,
0.0030308699,
-0.0314594358,
-0.0276758187,
0.0079418272,
-0.0506464131,
-0.004303596,
-0.0320353508,
-0.028573228,
-0.0138515662,
-0.0217826441,
0.0420356058,
0.0406333469,
-0.0209453888,
0.0002226401,
-0.0079679061,
0.0429838449,
0.036783766,
-0.0294761974,
0.0151361562,
-0.0695549622,
0.0102387816,
0.0578403845,
0.0615564585,
0.0313639157,
-0.03302316,
-0.0126838731,
0.0155704971,
-0.0638321564,
0.0116437022,
0.0159372147,
0.0280318037,
-0.0929550678,
-0.0131660625,
0.1028161421,
0.0105027799,
-0.0647727549,
0.0132451588,
-0.0160780903,
0.0671345294,
0.0436229706,
0.0114087909,
-0.051482439,
-0.0220631827,
0.0294470433,
0.0255327411,
0.0168116931,
-0.0069112,
-0.0056780539,
-0.1282677054,
-0.0064881584,
0.0143478988,
-0.0516024977,
0.0257278029,
-0.0571689233,
-0.0077591296,
-0.0508656837,
0.0428212658,
0.0428227894,
-0.0411363915,
0.0232475214,
0.0255797226,
0.0026028769,
-0.0330049098,
0.0580454804,
-0.0740438029,
0.0888427794,
0.0219954532,
0.0117954304,
-0.0259083211,
-0.0200808495,
0.0549573526,
0.0164298508,
0.0008838955,
0.0005710743,
0.0494351313,
-0.0048941034,
-0.0237320196,
-0.014141201,
0.0238652509,
-0.0091856029,
-0.0275177527,
0.0086034201,
0.0396624617,
0.034252964,
-0.0482634418,
-0.0094686104,
-0.0073162029,
-0.0433489457,
0.0813805312,
0.046788983,
-0.0195014346,
-0.040776033,
-0.0022821857,
0.0001721977,
-0.0255525634,
-0.0635439083,
0.0325978994,
0.0130307954,
-0.0381400548,
-0.0478273705,
-0.0238537509,
0.0295145065,
0.0194917079,
-0.0192971323,
0.004484986,
-0.0358440354,
-0.0017896049,
-0.0488605648,
0.0434013493,
-0.0442423262,
0.0117610078,
-0.0884729028,
-0.0067343656,
0.0292193666,
0.0049586659,
-0.0268404223,
0.031172365,
-0.1276485622,
-0.0536978766,
0.0329971276,
0.0456262566,
0.0265031923,
0.0551306233,
0.0451526642,
-0.066470623,
0.0738840178,
0.0277949832,
-0.0166861769,
0.0521243624,
0.0200081747,
-0.0454734452,
-0.0022722089,
0.0343163759,
-0.0189094134,
0.0048800912,
0.0153732002,
0.04388953,
-0.004246159,
0.0109382272,
-0.0144814607,
-0.0119944941,
0.0380472727,
-0.0176899806,
-0.0407723524,
-0.0317268446,
0.0173849426,
-0.0056532356,
0.018326655,
-0.0022992522,
-0.0105579263,
0.0269456878,
-0.0080214133,
-0.0030882815,
-0.0239250213,
-0.0028657794,
0.0321431272,
-0.023313446,
0.0089270771,
-0.0054192925,
0.016076589,
0.0282097906,
0.003519139,
-0.0296000745,
0.0435293652,
-0.0295929331,
0.0370205939,
0.0013850027,
0.0355069824,
-0.0318471156,
-0.0048204772,
-0.0172980819,
0.0044621257,
-0.0620454662,
-0.0360449031,
-0.0209272038,
0.0206559543,
0.0685001463,
-0.0307923667,
0.0573729351,
-0.0214744359,
-0.0049175066,
-0.0266879313,
-0.0189876184,
-0.0308331959,
0.0005814134,
0.0044055632,
0.034740407,
-0.004435834,
0.0192923751,
0.1038702503,
0.0580925308,
0.082696341,
0.0250890367,
0.0108371554,
-0.0136613613,
-0.0266509801,
0.0087586557,
0.0063425843,
-0.06097918,
-0.0303907394,
-0.0501866452,
-0.0692810938,
-0.009285179,
0.005788045,
0.0007572675,
-0.0290975757,
0.0048352685,
0.0439929217,
-0.0316250063,
-0.0097292224,
-0.037318483,
0.0417976752,
0.00894826,
-0.0220740195,
0.0122418776,
-6.905054385e-33,
-0.0088476371,
0.0295366235,
0.0391816571,
-0.015913086,
-0.003248554,
0.0163150653,
-0.0312950537,
0.0134204598,
-0.0089061484,
0.0069387346,
-0.020123018,
0.006281205,
0.0187486,
0.0201893616,
0.0217175018,
0.0011341745,
0.0467326567,
-0.005807722,
-0.0149745867,
0.027669495,
0.0383230485,
0.0494198129,
0.0782910362,
-0.0062153968,
0.0179526694,
0.0112334238,
-0.0032491679,
0.0199655276,
-0.0317861885,
0.0444633886,
-0.0595408492,
0.0307161864,
0.0187712088,
-0.0612434782,
-0.0319328234,
-0.0214372948,
-0.0549186319,
-0.0077092168,
-0.0021135132,
0.0158366505,
-0.0157648101,
-0.0157029983,
0.0587920584,
-0.0101389838,
-0.0372258686,
-0.0389419906,
0.0111160306,
-0.0012820109,
-0.0602068715,
0.0181795135,
-0.0482584611,
0.0329696648,
-0.0083758449,
-0.0215016939,
0.0165132005,
-0.0390063673,
-0.0106972158,
0.0357126817,
-0.0545357466,
0.001016852,
0.0324719474,
0.0547057092,
0.0371022895,
0.0569984317,
0.0319744721,
0.0641944855,
0.0608038157,
0.0100756772,
-0.0027027146,
-0.0377475396,
0.0539539419,
0.0374421999,
0.0420517474,
0.0220227782,
0.041902151,
0.0001032939,
-0.0872109681,
-0.016706245,
0.0410462469,
0.0657691881,
0.0240947921,
0.0327162184,
-0.0353118218,
-0.0163879301,
-0.0497430377,
-0.0407943279,
-0.050227616,
-0.0128275277,
0.0181288924,
0.013635545,
-0.0387797318,
-0.0266876481,
0.0251399577,
-0.0325327441,
-0.0410663821,
0.0122252693,
-0.0179684535,
0.0133251185,
0.0086544435,
0.0366300903,
-0.0734248236,
-0.0170107558,
-0.0102637922,
-0.0028694002,
0.0133619336,
0.0132763498,
0.0057779518,
0.0083910534,
-0.0810394585,
-0.0160816833,
-0.0474218093,
-0.0192469899,
0.0362148359,
0.0174589362,
0.0432284586,
0.0122942086,
-0.0021081937,
0.0628166869,
0.036771562,
-0.0124070058,
-0.0055015688,
0.0022607544,
-0.000267349,
0.0341092534,
0.0012922229,
-0.0090719825,
-0.0469607115,
0.0230764374,
0.0641445816,
-0.0373211578,
-0.0093572708,
-0.0090469811,
2.726e-7,
0.0214137454,
0.06321273,
0.0059327376,
0.022875689,
0.0079958411,
0.0310351681,
-0.0634264648,
0.0503090955,
0.0409287773,
-0.0021005026,
-0.0206112321,
0.0601476841,
0.0406021215,
0.0251601357,
-0.0651218221,
-0.0198011324,
-0.1024025008,
0.0169585701,
-0.0530395694,
-0.0045026666,
-0.0514353402,
0.0961786732,
0.0313953981,
-0.0196034852,
0.0266341101,
-0.0505712852,
0.0706252456,
-0.0218032766,
0.0155043593,
0.0181130245,
-0.0237915497,
0.0106109381,
0.0048887627,
0.000681885,
-0.0144198155,
0.0063672573,
-0.0246958863,
0.0465707667,
-0.0056570075,
0.0148503054,
0.0051320279,
0.0091787474,
-0.0227817632,
-0.0888440534,
0.0670502186,
-0.0268808026,
-0.0281355325,
-0.0724008903,
0.0168804284,
-0.0040491521,
0.0450215451,
-0.017548658,
-0.0339485705,
0.0462404452,
-0.0078623798,
0.0005650829,
-0.0340176784,
-0.0848224834,
-0.0408360399,
-0.0228953008,
-0.049690526,
-0.0388428792,
-0.0681684315,
-0.0061189304,
0.0122779896,
-0.0439976379,
0.0114803649,
2.402534818e-34,
0.0533966832,
0.0006658476,
-0.0051030903,
0.0359558351,
0.0038576298,
-0.0254847873,
0.0131998435,
-0.0001577281,
0.010522237,
-0.0796232298,
-0.0090134833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01352v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01352v2
|
A Simple and Effective Method of Cross-Lingual Plagiarism Detection
| 2023-04-03T20:27:10 | 2023-04-05T09:23:17 |
Karen Avetisyan, Arthur Malajyan, Tsolak Ghukasyan, Arutyun Avetisyan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
We present a simple cross-lingual plagiarism detection method applicable to a
large number of languages. The presented approach leverages open multilingual
thesauri for candidate retrieval task and pre-trained multilingual BERT-based
language models for detailed analysis. The method does not rely on machine
translation and word sense disambiguation when in use, and therefore is
suitable for a large number of languages, including under-resourced languages.
The effectiveness of the proposed approach is demonstrated for several existing
and new benchmarks, achieving state-of-the-art results for French, Russian, and
Armenian languages.
|
[
0.056869138,
0.0042930651,
-0.0163224731,
0.1012399197,
-0.0622829497,
-0.0107033467,
0.0269020367,
0.0485487171,
0.0330113061,
-0.024106808,
-0.024099499,
0.0069595017,
-0.005798046,
-0.0550511852,
0.0481832474,
0.0415453054,
0.0290303249,
0.0139218681,
-0.0176943447,
-0.0053592804,
0.0036525489,
0.0141820274,
0.0670485497,
0.0138470307,
-0.0006104727,
-0.0042893412,
0.0393592045,
0.0069088656,
0.0349213108,
0.013443918,
0.0104152681,
0.017975077,
-0.0099182259,
0.0918349102,
0.0000015231,
-0.040950425,
-0.0704079792,
0.027267009,
0.0696354955,
0.0339441895,
0.0635993257,
0.0172796696,
0.0025919203,
-0.0211535878,
0.0097696269,
0.0013358275,
0.0030938487,
0.0202284083,
0.0737349764,
0.0585745461,
-0.0441761203,
-0.0102891577,
0.0137933241,
0.0041030999,
-0.0191923715,
-0.0061087366,
0.0517343432,
-0.0378681161,
0.0076900888,
0.0203764141,
0.0134113133,
0.0481437556,
-0.0342995152,
-0.0174740255,
-0.0405398086,
-0.0442910679,
-0.050751552,
0.0123443929,
0.048993703,
0.0078889756,
-0.059107922,
-0.0846750736,
0.0382202901,
0.0176448207,
-0.0123178465,
0.0388892516,
-0.0042148791,
0.0215431079,
-0.0294599067,
0.011893074,
0.0476354957,
-0.0249885675,
0.0118525997,
0.0314016081,
0.0266989544,
0.0088511892,
0.0688009113,
-0.061496079,
-0.0090408726,
-0.0176262595,
0.0085340263,
-0.0119460113,
0.0507052206,
-0.0227470398,
0.0198001154,
-0.0387232862,
-0.0449547209,
-0.0872221217,
0.0414885469,
-0.0690102801,
0.0213831365,
0.0652255118,
-0.0263928864,
0.0378210135,
-0.0418003984,
0.0391769633,
-0.0576517992,
0.0193193816,
-0.0446704961,
-0.0654645339,
-0.0442352593,
-0.0155665381,
-0.0565010719,
-0.0000853927,
0.0131260399,
0.0006572005,
-0.0326464586,
0.0141252764,
0.0010994421,
-0.002724906,
-0.018221207,
-0.0628007278,
0.0145071577,
0.010070648,
0.0311530083,
0.0063715461,
0.0165073816,
0.0021140396,
-0.0589493774,
-0.0594740063,
-0.0119953426,
0.0397624113,
-0.000402261,
-0.043536827,
0.0224759188,
0.0189284012,
0.0179006606,
-0.0309957396,
-0.0182919502,
-0.0252017025,
-0.0012831257,
-0.02846976,
0.0005049551,
-0.065367043,
-0.0068307193,
-0.0261556003,
0.0053817597,
-0.0370251797,
-0.0025400799,
0.0290317908,
-0.08251746,
0.0214111507,
-0.0352149047,
0.0128409723,
0.0274146348,
-0.0162167177,
-0.0187275764,
0.0277855638,
-0.0121262837,
0.0159268919,
0.0868595243,
0.0459329933,
0.0014851504,
0.0774302781,
0.0086830165,
0.0278762616,
0.005283406,
0.0066011562,
0.0136231771,
0.0286266673,
0.024242878,
0.0564149395,
-0.0443189964,
-0.0099012014,
0.0439048707,
0.0421283357,
0.009522994,
0.038742926,
0.0320599489,
0.0206099153,
-0.002073304,
-0.00192151,
-0.0017177702,
-0.0244943853,
-0.0057351687,
-0.0127652325,
0.004635456,
0.0243577734,
0.0071768616,
0.0379838087,
0.0010591836,
-0.0000821383,
-0.0302088764,
-0.0051525603,
0.021718882,
0.0094578192,
-0.0367828868,
0.0657932982,
-0.0030166628,
-0.0683060661,
0.0003846064,
-0.0460003018,
0.0526773185,
0.0676001161,
0.1032796204,
-0.02457387,
0.0383995064,
0.004893926,
-0.0311527383,
0.0240322892,
0.0216448847,
-0.0366462991,
0.0040755565,
-0.0436306745,
-0.0599200502,
-0.023123052,
-0.0233623944,
0.0389309898,
-0.0068802289,
0.0472058952,
0.0239936132,
-0.0531277023,
-0.0407555066,
0.0284136012,
-0.0456043854,
0.0098277144,
0.0036806201,
0.0308363568,
0.0006038734,
0.0070900708,
-0.0259058923,
0.0367212929,
-0.0028437229,
-0.0650896728,
0.0334406532,
-0.0168456845,
0.0570265092,
0.007658578,
0.0684998631,
-0.0573588982,
-0.0149767287,
0.0396687761,
0.0062628067,
0.0140046924,
0.026483288,
0.0121575985,
0.0287845228,
-0.1067443192,
0.0425133631,
-0.0522452965,
0.034143541,
-0.0216143336,
0.0542924032,
0.0259547103,
0.0516388677,
0.0975650772,
-0.021699328,
0.0967171341,
-0.0358065888,
-0.0687210038,
0.0144373914,
0.011814869,
0.0086952681,
0.0446010679,
0.0013360087,
0.0038869844,
-0.0385347605,
-0.0832843632,
0.0163162053,
-0.0100378133,
0.0338492803,
0.0084995413,
0.0403710529,
-0.0348740704,
-0.0156584084,
-0.0072630388,
0.000098159,
0.0161556527,
0.0089882948,
0.0251623914,
-0.004718909,
-0.0210848115,
-0.0421467125,
0.0025431779,
0.0118263476,
0.0539075732,
0.0009258864,
-0.0320086256,
-0.0511301793,
0.0265982766,
-0.023091292,
0.0116565824,
0.0116644017,
-0.0103522222,
-0.0243719965,
-0.0476968363,
0.0053158817,
0.0410017483,
-0.008221956,
-0.0553588644,
0.0358313844,
-0.0258549638,
-0.0483578965,
-0.0178027041,
-0.002611381,
-0.0013059938,
-0.0078984145,
-0.012439006,
0.0513409413,
-0.0025230097,
-0.0169696808,
-0.04336657,
0.0108420635,
-0.0202826522,
-0.0013882925,
-0.0204703361,
-0.003866581,
-0.0200408623,
0.0095605049,
0.0028497868,
-0.0110877175,
-0.0201951638,
0.0366687849,
-0.0416779555,
0.0177766196,
-0.0119054085,
0.0115174018,
-0.0357124507,
0.0142815076,
-0.0412208699,
0.0463016555,
-0.0045871339,
-0.0200677514,
-0.0474765636,
-0.0090511823,
0.0913758576,
-0.0111989323,
0.0277086515,
-0.0022124534,
0.0367943943,
-0.0068505267,
-0.0263697524,
-0.0361293629,
-0.0460834466,
0.0091766017,
-0.0026457855,
-0.0145463115,
0.0153813967,
-0.0531680435,
-0.0472947769,
0.0277573615,
0.045616895,
-0.0177113041,
0.0098995855,
0.0102558136,
0.0563717522,
-0.0031184247,
-0.0832662731,
-0.0113609452,
-0.0398862995,
-0.0486511141,
-0.0003707653,
0.0165285151,
0.0103227599,
0.0195395555,
-0.0150471982,
0.0180022698,
-0.0484989882,
-0.0122786043,
-0.0517686643,
-0.0149235642,
-0.042708803,
-0.002963423,
0.0839606896,
-0.0083508166,
-0.0291152634,
-0.0603559129,
-0.0724308789,
-0.018269036,
0.0010197336,
0.0190347861,
-0.0604720227,
-0.0222790595,
-0.0078867972,
0.0167735368,
-0.0066675725,
0.000591375,
0.0098366924,
-0.0775614232,
-0.012954765,
-0.0055512767,
-0.0364366695,
-0.044182118,
-0.0082386667,
-0.02408229,
0.0035942018,
-0.029898759,
-0.0253180508,
0.0067978767,
0.0058038277,
-0.0424479581,
-0.0141061163,
-0.0330424272,
-0.0308234002,
-0.0726792142,
-0.0528623909,
0.0539261401,
0.0669983774,
-0.0166210197,
-0.0349127948,
0.0189020261,
-0.0526994616,
-0.0632318929,
-0.0151734957,
0.0136607401,
-0.0223075338,
-0.012691699,
0.0139245428,
-0.0293729641,
0.0242938343,
0.0059396424,
0.0126188649,
0.056573879,
0.0331608765,
0.0065033277,
-0.0152520603,
-0.0046077408,
0.0502800383,
0.0410909913,
0.0140807452,
0.0213406086,
-0.0089441435,
0.010324996,
-0.0246303622,
-0.0549874902,
-0.0173250325,
0.012528643,
-0.0184240229,
-0.0240318328,
-0.0759315044,
-0.0239719301,
-0.032355167,
-0.0242212471,
0.0511675254,
0.0604758635,
-0.0323976465,
-0.0355848148,
-0.0291575938,
-0.0533226095,
-0.0349361338,
0.0440962873,
-0.0049502417,
0.0184404198,
0.0147368936,
-0.0081243683,
0.0148215555,
0.0065909098,
-0.0546394177,
-0.0236060601,
-0.0481773242,
0.0226200912,
0.0078558484,
0.0358337127,
-0.0205399878,
-0.0103013739,
0.0472371317,
-0.0032819877,
0.0160069149,
-0.0000744087,
0.01362048,
-0.0583362095,
0.004556057,
0.0673707351,
-0.0571029522,
-0.0012815172,
0.035726618,
0.0008182359,
0.0017210089,
-0.0495610461,
0.0217362549,
0.0338238589,
0.0296181682,
-0.0303876642,
0.0422529541,
-0.0691797137,
-0.0101126088,
0.0020962597,
-0.0082274275,
-0.0169947688,
0.0535588712,
0.0390070826,
-0.0186642651,
0.0200471748,
0.0744680762,
-0.0077823983,
0.0383245237,
-0.0155468611,
0.0347112417,
0.0091776308,
0.0600537434,
-0.0217828788,
0.0062262411,
-0.00822639,
-0.0010185874,
-0.00691221,
0.02826057,
-0.0269370619,
0.0273612347,
0.0251993388,
-0.0167134758,
0.0361941233,
0.0428833663,
-0.0463797227,
-0.0152378716,
0.0004821429,
0.0242899712,
0.0811073557,
-0.0423431285,
0.0884642303,
-0.0027880867,
-0.0372534879,
-0.019168837,
0.0193183031,
-0.0481248498,
-0.0160923973,
-0.0468816012,
-0.0145651083,
-0.0072384896,
0.017546881,
0.0596102849,
-0.0018012115,
0.0293736011,
-0.000718385,
-0.0445272028,
0.0012809872,
-0.0163876191,
0.0806818679,
-0.0192810036,
-0.0489205532,
-0.0153975505,
-0.0044611227,
-0.0114792148,
0.0194359161,
0.046831049,
-0.039426282,
0.0235777628,
0.0171783697,
0.0848527253,
0.0116032856,
0.0334196314,
-0.0557853803,
-0.0004189535,
0.0118616177,
-0.0363005437,
0.0092663392,
-4.481500948e-33,
0.0198823959,
0.0239069536,
-0.0363470577,
-0.0048810882,
-0.0276323538,
0.0172784142,
-0.0413024649,
-0.0593668222,
-0.0426675379,
0.0419423915,
-0.0078218738,
0.0213541891,
0.0046996507,
-0.0176360868,
0.0091961026,
0.00270507,
0.0416459292,
0.049847953,
-0.0239040554,
-0.025301436,
0.0419358574,
0.0512015782,
0.0858026966,
-0.020248495,
0.0366752073,
-0.048734948,
-0.0201330539,
-0.0111727063,
0.0563152283,
0.0432225168,
0.0132710105,
0.011775054,
-0.0160289016,
0.0081860311,
-0.023170799,
-0.0409218408,
-0.0060911477,
0.0023893486,
0.0110405302,
0.018285403,
-0.0106193712,
-0.026240278,
0.0319595486,
-0.0275036655,
0.0054411343,
0.0262349322,
0.0756263509,
-0.0507986546,
-0.0262026675,
-0.0142488992,
-0.0652934238,
0.0070998697,
0.0026652098,
0.0289141703,
0.0570979528,
0.0406976901,
0.0183348954,
0.027921699,
-0.0844475552,
0.0357215479,
-0.0754152983,
0.0245155338,
0.0223816819,
-0.0460489579,
0.0419796817,
0.0397865027,
0.0218809061,
-0.052834712,
0.0707831755,
-0.0167400334,
-0.0014776214,
0.0145472055,
0.0222954843,
0.1015122235,
0.0064906403,
-0.0266301725,
-0.026744647,
0.0431441963,
0.0317338817,
-0.0060521732,
0.0294326264,
-0.0104110669,
-0.0247473288,
-0.0157751273,
0.0256315898,
-0.0631094649,
-0.0217875075,
-0.029382607,
0.0454386808,
0.0013933406,
0.0141631076,
0.0413305983,
0.0469057113,
-0.0519309826,
0.0032559072,
0.0179531872,
-0.0338997394,
-0.0054266001,
0.0092689861,
0.0704509094,
-0.0132805258,
-0.0493048653,
-0.0147938468,
-0.0085073086,
-0.0041039893,
0.0245378315,
0.0445323624,
0.0172003955,
-0.0644118562,
0.0263449121,
0.0188326463,
-0.0374341048,
-0.0445095226,
0.0291291364,
-0.0381154418,
-0.0027496468,
0.0523867048,
-0.0091187498,
0.0560646281,
0.009969119,
-0.0387111567,
-0.0161779094,
0.0217411406,
0.0248684734,
0.0017414349,
0.0181340259,
-0.0514471903,
0.0539328381,
0.0010854383,
-0.0400680341,
0.0266196467,
-0.0077210516,
2.333e-7,
0.0148636792,
-0.0173514578,
-0.0112177338,
-0.0506793782,
-0.0254297331,
0.0420096666,
-0.0440236554,
0.0484350249,
-0.011614834,
0.0252959896,
0.0148400664,
-0.0179827362,
0.0226324201,
-0.0129609276,
-0.1147540212,
0.0353126191,
-0.0329183005,
-0.0472636297,
-0.0637661517,
-0.0111741265,
0.0140796704,
0.0915988684,
0.0249048769,
-0.0321112908,
-0.043436259,
-0.0715425611,
0.0835769325,
-0.0078670122,
-0.0619585291,
0.0139774419,
0.0342093185,
-0.0207636803,
-0.0022099109,
-0.0111265089,
-0.0299509894,
0.0497825928,
0.0968401507,
-0.0324732251,
0.0153954756,
0.0145327179,
-0.008001158,
-0.075953275,
-0.0289251618,
-0.0549862683,
0.0224863868,
0.043893788,
0.0429611877,
-0.0439668894,
-0.0188766569,
0.0184804946,
0.0595374294,
-0.0147580691,
-0.0432691723,
0.0175635815,
0.0114025539,
0.0168312006,
-0.0191913638,
-0.0128106773,
0.0307552591,
-0.0546185188,
-0.0314766243,
-0.0265500229,
0.0097758025,
-0.0328178816,
0.0455468968,
-0.0216167253,
0.0777968094,
1.650746717e-34,
0.037265908,
-0.0156327039,
-0.0046074428,
-0.0346005,
0.0200083852,
-0.0254658386,
0.0031572839,
0.0097176731,
-0.0686486736,
0.0251776967,
-0.0023099931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01344v1
|
End-to-End Models for Chemical-Protein Interaction Extraction: Better Tokenization and Span-Based Pipeline Strategies
| 2023-04-03T20:20:22 | 2023-04-03T20:20:22 |
Xuguang Ai, Ramakanth Kavuluru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
End-to-end relation extraction (E2ERE) is an important task in information
extraction, more so for biomedicine as scientific literature continues to grow
exponentially. E2ERE typically involves identifying entities (or named entity
recognition (NER)) and associated relations, while most RE tasks simply assume
that the entities are provided upfront and end up performing relation
classification. E2ERE is inherently more difficult than RE alone given the
potential snowball effect of errors from NER leading to more errors in RE. A
complex dataset in biomedical E2ERE is the ChemProt dataset (BioCreative VI,
2017) that identifies relations between chemical compounds and genes/proteins
in scientific literature. ChemProt is included in all recent biomedical natural
language processing benchmarks including BLUE, BLURB, and BigBio. However, its
treatment in these benchmarks and in other separate efforts is typically not
end-to-end, with few exceptions. In this effort, we employ a span-based
pipeline approach to produce a new state-of-the-art E2ERE performance on the
ChemProt dataset, resulting in $> 4\%$ improvement in F1-score over the prior
best effort. Our results indicate that a straightforward fine-grained
tokenization scheme helps span-based approaches excel in E2ERE, especially with
regards to handling complex named entities. Our error analysis also identifies
a few key failure modes in E2ERE for ChemProt.
|
[
0.0440170392,
0.0478092581,
0.0197406709,
0.0286911465,
-0.0080259237,
0.012469233,
0.0072745141,
0.017774906,
0.0436182208,
-0.0133709582,
-0.0256538037,
-0.0206631459,
-0.0067232451,
0.065011695,
0.0206384882,
-0.0148933269,
0.0226005763,
0.0320189893,
0.0645168722,
0.03229798,
-0.0145752151,
0.0027120155,
-0.0079866257,
0.0001816652,
0.0153450938,
0.001803135,
0.0344011858,
-0.0019907928,
0.0647092387,
-0.0501816534,
0.0038937915,
0.0267474782,
-0.018506553,
0.0033935078,
0.0000016546,
-0.0657366291,
-0.0489519984,
0.0301729422,
-0.0113697946,
-0.021420911,
0.013355121,
-0.0599297956,
0.0030622904,
-0.0013924839,
0.0002626647,
-0.0545779653,
0.0422141962,
0.0809896737,
-0.0094288606,
0.0359139964,
-0.0285317693,
-0.0344030447,
0.0705704391,
-0.0276349634,
0.026448708,
-0.0200536586,
0.0911320597,
-0.0518690273,
0.0229022428,
-0.0170647986,
-0.001801651,
0.0134483939,
-0.0241371095,
-0.0009058462,
0.0657017231,
0.0506664813,
-0.0449738353,
-0.0237432625,
0.0092597706,
0.1070319563,
-0.0261973087,
-0.0046106311,
0.0352591053,
0.0094549879,
-0.0412887633,
0.0024042337,
0.0047261468,
-0.0275106337,
-0.0420615226,
0.0246561952,
0.0172239244,
-0.0121103786,
0.0407725945,
0.0030627528,
-0.0340312645,
0.038283743,
-0.0147100668,
-0.0299556497,
0.0215611216,
0.027521437,
-0.0325703882,
-0.0211744066,
0.0536090098,
-0.0022293532,
-0.0101220924,
0.0168543104,
-0.0019060833,
-0.0119296648,
0.0204153843,
-0.0371270701,
-0.0573252663,
-0.0181465857,
-0.029616449,
0.0447346978,
-0.0237455219,
-0.0003609814,
-0.0095315194,
0.0022153764,
0.0090053352,
0.0010639512,
-0.0367903449,
-0.0098773343,
-0.024472177,
0.0636209995,
-0.0601783618,
-0.032453239,
-0.0466196947,
-0.0148248961,
-0.0111037418,
0.0332419164,
0.0182017088,
0.0224870909,
-0.0109988088,
0.0474216267,
0.0167066604,
0.0244149454,
0.0102970852,
-0.0116108311,
-0.0194413234,
-0.0704386607,
-0.0371339619,
-0.0361820683,
0.0343334526,
-0.0583868623,
0.0234005935,
0.1051878706,
0.0205483474,
-0.0690756738,
0.0395019501,
-0.045190949,
0.0007131653,
-0.0578657314,
-0.0044921665,
-0.0138045894,
0.1139178798,
0.0246620718,
-0.0134765627,
-0.0214035772,
0.0201793574,
-0.0220430084,
-0.0900208354,
0.0810061991,
-0.0085954247,
-0.0526737534,
-0.0091964882,
0.0230698381,
0.0090103066,
0.0023382313,
0.0369188152,
-0.035799969,
0.0317543596,
-0.0106119532,
-0.0178810786,
0.0088718394,
0.0291484147,
-0.0809681639,
0.0406088531,
0.0223042034,
0.0382661,
0.0494534671,
0.0176981073,
0.0463257842,
-0.0216875281,
-0.037347123,
-0.0065981192,
0.0491634235,
0.0259182453,
-0.0008594987,
0.0141789252,
0.011966818,
0.0237771459,
-0.0154584581,
-0.0561609156,
-0.0051106079,
-0.0002204086,
0.0142533695,
0.0129726725,
0.0323261544,
0.0124652619,
0.0158491004,
-0.0046635293,
0.017043937,
-0.0365567207,
-0.0225193575,
0.0681376755,
-0.0207101721,
-0.0553128645,
0.0586661845,
0.0722393915,
-0.0305140968,
0.0423316322,
0.033280354,
0.0017949902,
0.0452663861,
0.0531209894,
-0.0743989795,
-0.0240058377,
-0.0160429403,
-0.031005932,
0.0073839691,
0.0010381065,
-0.0303994622,
0.0604551435,
0.0059773787,
0.0031522908,
0.0013289456,
0.0002065105,
-0.0263532903,
-0.0008147522,
-0.0017197442,
-0.0352577157,
0.0002775094,
-0.0215962175,
0.0444861092,
-0.0230080485,
-0.0180585515,
-0.0081317136,
0.0090783536,
0.0307030939,
0.0410230197,
-0.0135995708,
0.0181923509,
0.0690117627,
-0.0525752306,
-0.0215402544,
-0.0062674228,
0.006510518,
-0.0623901263,
0.031481266,
-0.0234654043,
-0.0092283785,
-0.0267516766,
-0.05906469,
-0.0256492272,
0.0128704933,
0.0197304152,
0.0340705775,
0.028584294,
0.0096197678,
0.0222690292,
0.0356597155,
-0.0314193554,
0.0300104693,
-0.011435627,
0.0241095927,
-0.015845919,
-0.0639797673,
-0.0197994672,
-0.021523349,
-0.0113459509,
0.0337965824,
0.0121546267,
-0.0429105647,
-0.002080746,
-0.0312350187,
-0.0576291122,
-0.0110615185,
-0.0328223109,
-0.007606768,
0.0331227519,
0.0653577,
0.0140447998,
0.0107063325,
0.0059481962,
0.004560763,
-0.0107712587,
-0.034697257,
-0.0336388014,
-0.0079722861,
0.0508973636,
0.0369018055,
-0.0330966301,
-0.0316520855,
-0.0231164992,
-0.0523532145,
0.0725793689,
0.0067478614,
-0.0621115156,
0.0176140033,
-0.0125533808,
-0.0164050944,
0.0180402175,
-0.0159065798,
0.025204828,
-0.022627553,
0.0308247376,
-0.0178166553,
0.0312095992,
-0.0015238284,
0.0463199802,
0.0098673441,
0.0127702421,
-0.0137800621,
0.0157298595,
-0.0554972328,
0.0440057032,
0.0073910095,
-0.0305450372,
0.0262891687,
0.0559334047,
-0.0285570174,
0.0193614773,
-0.0229345895,
0.0122683849,
0.0302139949,
-0.0031167436,
-0.0127013018,
-0.0012268819,
0.0073242295,
-0.0211786572,
-0.0345716886,
-0.0185130034,
0.0979407877,
-0.0484006591,
-0.0073271133,
-0.0479883626,
0.0191178918,
-0.0263426695,
0.0002763885,
0.0046197344,
0.0052461522,
0.0230333582,
-0.0484957248,
0.0323108323,
0.0159994625,
0.0033196586,
-0.0317691751,
0.0332106799,
-0.037895333,
0.0397377647,
-0.0032763712,
-0.0366946645,
-0.0229002219,
0.0462039299,
-0.0464172028,
0.034940131,
0.0114635145,
-0.0435831286,
-0.0165828057,
0.0472027622,
-0.005659855,
0.0080724908,
-0.0265870187,
0.0018512284,
-0.0235173348,
0.0391781293,
0.0542863235,
-0.0535506494,
0.0229125135,
-0.0073075527,
0.0491533019,
0.0795699954,
0.0069883722,
-0.0159590766,
0.031049002,
0.0059342016,
0.0099885128,
-0.0302470345,
0.022418445,
-0.0415553488,
0.0070792576,
-0.0448307954,
-0.034521658,
0.0851180926,
0.007464129,
-0.0380349718,
0.0247190949,
0.0353961848,
-0.0193553902,
-0.0024461271,
0.0335707404,
-0.0789554268,
-0.0067779906,
-0.0131678442,
0.0079041785,
-0.0101577276,
-0.0954177007,
-0.0043287431,
-0.0586938262,
0.0142142884,
-0.0065887268,
-0.0947016329,
-0.0040096436,
-0.0963708758,
-0.0067727133,
-0.0452717692,
0.0195974149,
-0.003065547,
-0.006871325,
-0.0111222044,
0.0146003226,
0.0043938262,
-0.0952536389,
0.0004328925,
-0.0333268233,
0.025117809,
0.0057702451,
0.0111085447,
-0.0103681749,
0.0305232294,
0.0570350327,
-0.0365949199,
-0.0268730279,
-0.0388988443,
0.0874529332,
-0.0375680439,
-0.0211485308,
-0.036396578,
0.0298332162,
-0.0652718619,
-0.0212501269,
-0.0367064141,
0.1110619605,
0.007007184,
-0.024855556,
-0.0187887978,
-0.0134517737,
0.0016648724,
0.070403032,
0.0152856708,
-0.0030093624,
-0.0728551596,
0.0306190439,
0.0132755162,
-0.044758331,
0.0125297057,
-0.0456011221,
-0.0634530559,
-0.0067677265,
-0.0350956544,
-0.0413210765,
0.0730402693,
0.011076293,
-0.0420481861,
0.0213333778,
0.0225332361,
0.0013251631,
-0.0592765808,
0.0496649556,
0.0424087122,
0.0213543046,
-0.0278994869,
-0.0275749378,
0.0326944999,
0.0126971547,
-0.0285483953,
0.0023967572,
-0.0109378519,
-0.0636465997,
-0.0315840282,
0.0098270699,
0.0194049478,
0.0378340036,
0.0086330324,
-0.0235020053,
0.0304235462,
0.0470601395,
-0.0787268877,
-0.0163200051,
-0.0211864952,
0.0198136698,
-0.025913557,
0.0178958923,
-0.0190632381,
0.0057599093,
0.0244665146,
0.0805775598,
0.0090564648,
-0.0268710833,
0.0393989757,
0.0056675808,
0.0781556591,
0.0034613505,
-0.0320697576,
-0.0576769002,
0.0276217535,
-0.0455067903,
0.0248282067,
-0.025272673,
0.0312060732,
0.0055028293,
0.012861833,
-0.0235942081,
-0.006894982,
-0.0593913943,
0.0237752497,
-0.0040376848,
-0.0036058337,
0.0027880406,
0.0144289071,
0.0728775039,
-0.0348865129,
0.0043661757,
-0.0358110815,
0.0158462264,
0.0107482905,
-0.0354736224,
-0.0119104749,
0.0303928573,
0.0346393622,
-0.0212494228,
0.0250124987,
-0.0292909089,
0.0568134263,
-0.027085172,
0.0026493468,
0.0159800258,
0.0020622611,
0.0712756887,
0.003025498,
-0.0188394077,
-0.0141532663,
0.0171651375,
-0.0509203374,
0.0182625148,
0.0649005249,
0.0258757081,
-0.0358984433,
-0.0217953902,
0.0627438352,
0.0070022182,
0.0583170578,
0.0052775727,
-0.0516160131,
-0.0180170666,
-0.0276162904,
-0.0363997556,
0.0272841211,
-0.0591520965,
-0.0007336247,
-0.0600239597,
-0.0360844769,
0.0314874426,
-0.0103194807,
-0.0193932801,
0.0084130066,
-0.0030029835,
0.0233289748,
0.0711165741,
-0.0477772243,
-0.002032035,
0.0431780852,
-0.0130003244,
-0.0654782131,
0.0079105096,
-5.705876762e-33,
0.0025009068,
-0.0382953845,
-0.0063293516,
0.0229880754,
-0.0311334711,
0.043811053,
-0.0622566044,
-0.025859233,
0.0178177711,
0.0424996465,
0.0029265813,
-0.0058643986,
0.0065372046,
0.0022347744,
-0.0059029418,
-0.0278703943,
0.0185509659,
0.0239776187,
-0.0090436265,
0.0073113143,
0.0550450794,
0.1071920767,
0.0326010063,
-0.0736367628,
-0.0051612691,
0.0167170018,
0.0359663218,
0.0122049265,
0.021418605,
0.0466715917,
-0.0583480522,
0.0227180049,
0.0263501499,
-0.0075186603,
0.0201089792,
-0.0110011827,
-0.1531654298,
0.0197328851,
0.001255909,
-0.0078580724,
-0.0461026654,
-0.0113286702,
0.0478915125,
0.0091168974,
-0.0111108199,
-0.0466325507,
0.0379020683,
-0.0145018129,
-0.021025544,
-0.051445026,
-0.0598202609,
0.0198613517,
0.0308517348,
0.0523114279,
0.0459277928,
0.0017307888,
0.014638056,
0.0506575741,
-0.0250614807,
-0.0322864465,
-0.0241292492,
0.0058939233,
0.0117511861,
-0.0066355634,
0.0158451609,
0.0476442836,
0.0394803248,
-0.0336511806,
0.0148257194,
0.0240607858,
-0.0305187181,
0.0408635698,
-0.0214483943,
-0.0091714384,
0.0182780344,
0.0152227599,
-0.1167142838,
0.0149223572,
-0.0031066772,
0.0410373881,
-0.0490794294,
-0.0043429281,
0.0056414385,
-0.0135896746,
0.0050966409,
0.0065573594,
-0.0274495054,
-0.0154830078,
-0.024195686,
-0.0112628452,
-0.0291433427,
0.0442855097,
-0.0101111569,
-0.0208341703,
-0.0601613186,
0.0112932585,
0.0327830128,
0.0055463915,
-0.0063756467,
-0.0092954766,
-0.0628063679,
-0.0414198339,
0.0168997105,
-0.0339978822,
0.0386182182,
-0.0107684219,
0.05711684,
-0.0409302637,
-0.0188042689,
-0.0217030738,
-0.0571674258,
0.025973035,
-0.0098630721,
0.0750488564,
-0.0022728168,
0.0423611067,
0.0072399322,
0.0500012934,
0.0542924814,
0.046148926,
-0.0019325318,
0.0853159726,
0.0448077917,
0.0197823402,
-0.0160096847,
-0.0239141993,
0.0105587859,
0.0268502925,
0.0261404384,
-0.0520661399,
-0.0222658049,
-0.0261230264,
2.563e-7,
0.0671330765,
0.0109815253,
0.0800714493,
-0.0190132465,
0.0159430783,
-0.0016807013,
-0.0149940047,
0.0484761782,
-0.0463704057,
0.0202416405,
0.0083723702,
-0.0332245491,
-0.0017953586,
0.0217196122,
-0.0325541422,
-0.020848481,
-0.063432619,
-0.0894102827,
-0.0560901351,
-0.0126096355,
0.0173663963,
0.046584215,
0.0044259075,
-0.004324839,
-0.026082674,
0.0223539416,
0.0259937439,
-0.0269161332,
0.0222141836,
0.0756176487,
-0.0192910582,
-0.008681641,
-0.0006613844,
0.0669729561,
-0.038068831,
0.0252325628,
-0.0066848602,
0.044794865,
-0.0170787517,
-0.025147805,
0.0511028469,
-0.0270227976,
0.0497202687,
-0.032640066,
0.0329610556,
-0.0450122207,
-0.0336632803,
0.0078627169,
-0.0238175485,
0.003160778,
-0.0001890173,
0.0129155312,
0.0228202324,
0.0659038648,
0.0171743147,
0.0093840342,
-0.0010584773,
-0.1035081372,
0.0165552944,
0.0569294766,
-0.0180608835,
0.0008652622,
0.0267211348,
0.0050147986,
-0.0044864947,
-0.0365696661,
-0.0213476401,
2.404136429e-34,
0.0029595136,
-0.0036012433,
-0.0077684484,
0.03923871,
0.0351500548,
-0.0433706492,
-0.0557123311,
0.0111972503,
-0.0453778952,
-0.077617459,
0.0042121299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01331v1
|
Creating Custom Event Data Without Dictionaries: A Bag-of-Tricks
| 2023-04-03T19:51:00 | 2023-04-03T19:51:00 |
Andrew Halterman, Philip A. Schrodt, Andreas Beger, Benjamin E. Bagozzi, Grace I. Scarborough
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event data, or structured records of ``who did what to whom'' that are
automatically extracted from text, is an important source of data for scholars
of international politics. The high cost of developing new event datasets,
especially using automated systems that rely on hand-built dictionaries, means
that most researchers draw on large, pre-existing datasets such as ICEWS rather
than developing tailor-made event datasets optimized for their specific
research question. This paper describes a ``bag of tricks'' for efficient,
custom event data production, drawing on recent advances in natural language
processing (NLP) that allow researchers to rapidly produce customized event
datasets. The paper introduces techniques for training an event category
classifier with active learning, identifying actors and the recipients of
actions in text using large language models and standard machine learning
classifiers and pretrained ``question-answering'' models from NLP, and
resolving mentions of actors to their Wikipedia article to categorize them. We
describe how these techniques produced the new POLECAT global event dataset
that is intended to replace ICEWS, along with examples of how scholars can
quickly produce smaller, custom event datasets. We publish example code and
models to implement our new techniques.
|
[
0.0749964193,
0.070623599,
-0.0015800786,
0.0311897807,
-0.0283864941,
0.0039068693,
0.0221080333,
-0.012226427,
0.0592743382,
-0.0449145213,
0.0705081224,
-0.0121946055,
-0.034433689,
0.0492146462,
0.0099925892,
-0.0671376735,
0.0719105005,
0.0229145754,
0.029597871,
0.015940316,
-0.0065067094,
0.0498734303,
-0.0363089815,
0.041078683,
-0.005282728,
0.024613725,
-0.0573124588,
-0.0268518422,
0.0141027179,
-0.020724494,
0.0116968341,
0.0417343676,
0.0316321217,
0.0176893845,
0.0000017727,
-0.0506858267,
-0.0258030705,
-0.0494818129,
0.0091081867,
0.0047508297,
-0.0061606863,
-0.0048457147,
0.0047810026,
-0.0256389268,
-0.0534826405,
-0.0317902416,
0.0226237159,
0.0227356199,
0.0447675511,
0.0826033056,
-0.0097245304,
-0.0316589996,
0.0076837442,
0.0056084394,
-0.0164533369,
-0.0187838823,
0.0376548581,
-0.0351580121,
-0.0509606078,
0.0100396564,
0.0252603274,
0.0093170423,
-0.0254565869,
0.0109847737,
0.0139411921,
0.011011296,
-0.0606027283,
-0.0073603913,
0.0079715168,
-0.0095479004,
0.0514112934,
-0.0330132023,
0.0405659601,
-0.005017072,
-0.0086138798,
0.0409260653,
0.0004369202,
0.0236461554,
-0.0287472289,
0.0183973815,
0.082033813,
0.0055395113,
-0.0201808773,
0.0436950922,
-0.0185301024,
0.0428504162,
-0.0147319091,
-0.012423059,
-0.018009562,
-0.0184617806,
0.011949338,
-0.0605844148,
0.0117129339,
0.0443093181,
-0.0269792825,
0.0083202124,
-0.0063897418,
0.0352396071,
-0.0011600349,
-0.0870153233,
-0.0345158167,
0.0133722695,
0.0247392394,
0.0565270782,
0.0479022078,
-0.0084774401,
0.0034755832,
0.0194117408,
0.0004920057,
-0.0279042292,
-0.0506616719,
-0.0029677909,
-0.0284733698,
0.0228935573,
-0.0368825346,
0.0214037281,
-0.0293474663,
0.0050459187,
-0.0007636599,
0.0219950061,
-0.0153956199,
0.0143220397,
-0.0470554382,
0.012653525,
-0.0723113194,
0.0162402149,
-0.0572212152,
0.0261362232,
-0.0487811677,
-0.0019867115,
0.013793759,
0.0058068973,
0.0363143943,
-0.0019622003,
0.0033500053,
0.0458839536,
-0.0104210638,
-0.0117408037,
-0.0544029698,
-0.0323446803,
0.0125269173,
-0.0131179104,
-0.0048936019,
-0.0618877895,
0.047450453,
-0.0088260705,
-0.0154244062,
-0.0677358434,
0.012772386,
-0.0016031874,
-0.0625408143,
0.0618234761,
-0.0230901819,
0.0267520994,
0.0272529647,
-0.0083236005,
0.0205386356,
0.0517107733,
0.0354555473,
0.0266828518,
0.0726390928,
0.0040674629,
0.0213177167,
0.0106370579,
0.0117699169,
0.0336075276,
-0.014903062,
0.0168176945,
-0.039505925,
-0.0085549438,
-0.0103960605,
-0.0139298355,
0.0019365514,
0.0191049948,
0.0402081721,
0.0439682044,
-0.0608262345,
0.0079818489,
0.0075875553,
0.0127240568,
0.0074766069,
-0.0119336387,
0.0217364188,
-0.0152064953,
0.0257883351,
-0.0411606245,
-0.0058053201,
0.003060959,
-0.0136744939,
-0.0179626271,
0.0128739811,
0.0145723689,
0.0047800872,
0.0037903714,
0.0479857475,
-0.0108170193,
-0.0063178982,
0.0476417653,
0.0396489874,
-0.0594439507,
0.0249408875,
-0.0291317198,
-0.0055060727,
0.0325269513,
0.0140193803,
-0.0463872589,
-0.0442172661,
-0.0404615179,
0.0443081409,
0.0428458303,
0.0270658955,
-0.0340890959,
0.0179474521,
0.0085056555,
-0.0232422147,
0.0120229647,
0.0122652929,
0.0209604371,
0.0408341922,
0.0074385097,
-0.0128715755,
0.0171521734,
-0.0220418461,
0.0423525199,
0.0013307985,
-0.0431112312,
-0.0017902581,
0.0186388008,
0.0282308385,
0.0432232879,
0.0055772527,
-0.0245865062,
0.0473074764,
-0.0191530865,
0.0071728844,
-0.0002393126,
0.0609864481,
0.0477939285,
0.0194540229,
-0.0195172261,
-0.0313326865,
0.034411829,
-0.0268918499,
-0.0401917845,
0.041306071,
0.0357766822,
0.0107034389,
-0.0117920199,
0.0038774579,
-0.0137352226,
-0.0087096449,
-0.0551127717,
0.0718961954,
0.0132137099,
0.0324368328,
0.0000183858,
-0.0436251052,
0.0416916236,
0.0219750069,
-0.03148707,
0.0328791626,
-0.0058931084,
0.0110182492,
0.0699831471,
-0.034281522,
-0.0293123927,
-0.0102427742,
-0.0401697196,
0.0328553319,
-0.0281541888,
0.0070772371,
0.0492031239,
0.0267389454,
-0.012294678,
0.0390028208,
-0.0071691172,
-0.088029854,
-0.0374484211,
-0.0245913025,
0.045236934,
0.0117505444,
-0.0211771671,
-0.0234159715,
0.02390166,
-0.0449012965,
0.0439094752,
0.0122039076,
-0.0602673702,
-0.0021454911,
0.0130835231,
-0.0333843715,
0.0454710126,
-0.0463523492,
-0.0326877087,
0.0356322378,
-0.0161154103,
-0.00086527,
0.0400795452,
0.0389396884,
0.0930846706,
0.0104363095,
-0.0458476841,
-0.044425264,
0.0188661776,
-0.0708753765,
-0.0010959437,
-0.0434514917,
-0.0387710296,
0.0130402111,
0.0263804905,
0.0103815589,
0.0137229059,
-0.0042966404,
-0.0174834933,
-0.0163138937,
0.0004617591,
-0.0417221189,
-0.0501051284,
-0.0222374275,
0.0803912058,
0.0089181736,
-0.003896012,
0.0105327563,
0.0047622249,
0.02247639,
-0.0379147977,
-0.0415250435,
-0.0402566865,
0.1309284121,
0.0021933145,
0.0092613874,
-0.0407969989,
-0.0146526312,
-0.0014925983,
-0.0613893904,
0.0288390629,
-0.023230046,
0.0015734186,
-0.0576056577,
0.015688248,
-0.0467385091,
-0.0038268943,
-0.0568929948,
-0.055235859,
-0.0127416346,
-0.0182896368,
0.0140895378,
-0.0155928014,
0.0059355726,
0.050946556,
0.0385291316,
0.0131278224,
0.02219042,
0.0020554489,
-0.0045087496,
0.0284394659,
0.0005585265,
-0.035230495,
-0.037281625,
0.0452100188,
-0.0415816195,
0.0235202704,
0.0157768317,
-0.0043560984,
-0.0084383823,
0.0022620314,
0.0385353267,
-0.0580679029,
0.0035671983,
-0.0134328101,
0.0103716189,
-0.0700370148,
0.0284084324,
0.0883418396,
0.0697527453,
-0.0290906187,
-0.0023197955,
0.034459874,
-0.0495571904,
0.0172299705,
0.0233637504,
-0.0808097869,
0.0355397575,
-0.0110114291,
-0.0106231347,
-0.079531379,
-0.0802557394,
-0.0215865597,
-0.0806813464,
0.0158662423,
-0.0229367781,
-0.0264370181,
-0.0327091366,
-0.0740057975,
-0.0190289989,
-0.0311136618,
-0.08680664,
0.0085462006,
0.0258110464,
0.0048775552,
0.0161704142,
-0.1025924012,
-0.0493699908,
-0.0055858139,
-0.0271923654,
0.0428308696,
-0.0090126703,
0.0639622509,
0.009507156,
0.058204677,
0.0216567703,
-0.0335747637,
-0.033839602,
-0.009740998,
0.0659726337,
-0.0193198491,
-0.041768875,
-0.0065664784,
0.0386584662,
0.0103883911,
-0.0387609415,
0.0147635872,
0.0552288368,
-0.0459626094,
0.0641041845,
0.0220992528,
-0.0095509915,
0.0697094128,
0.0296806227,
-0.0213072114,
0.0085462732,
-0.0055134138,
-0.0160715021,
0.0082900636,
-0.0881559849,
-0.0549231432,
0.0217631385,
-0.0338777862,
-0.0871512741,
-0.0311666019,
-0.0724615753,
0.0557570793,
0.0339810103,
0.0026989072,
0.0570833385,
0.023360312,
0.015013393,
-0.0543465614,
0.0229331329,
-0.0102684498,
0.0000352285,
0.0268848613,
-0.1130580753,
0.0071051372,
0.0567362905,
-0.0254609361,
0.0644827262,
-0.005271039,
-0.0473849215,
0.0473174714,
-0.0358041003,
0.0251004882,
0.0372786745,
0.0006726042,
-0.0185930431,
-0.0183370039,
0.0594532155,
-0.0380814187,
-0.0278264694,
0.000358831,
0.0542066284,
0.0011824988,
0.011248677,
-0.0082787769,
0.0295668133,
0.0072039822,
-0.0264024828,
-0.1158821806,
-0.0331886001,
0.0290166065,
-0.0313413367,
0.0685505942,
-0.0344945565,
-0.062215019,
-0.0473961048,
-0.010323382,
-0.0270677041,
-0.0304393023,
-0.0003153105,
0.0028804992,
-0.021892339,
-0.0186508894,
-0.0446125418,
0.0500552319,
-0.0609102659,
0.0347582065,
-0.0418972336,
0.0448798314,
0.0404606275,
0.060057871,
0.0027921798,
0.0066484953,
-0.0172426496,
0.0202270504,
0.0171946026,
0.0296357721,
-0.0132358763,
-0.0289045647,
0.0214512404,
0.0246511847,
0.0076311342,
-0.0307784099,
-0.1038142294,
-0.0223231819,
-0.0180160962,
0.0136545813,
0.0639512166,
-0.0216108337,
0.002915296,
-0.0171335097,
-0.0213802215,
0.029381007,
0.0352858417,
-0.0183184706,
-0.0188359246,
0.0112792775,
0.0112312324,
-0.0475411415,
0.0412831716,
0.0265605077,
0.0192481298,
0.0392684303,
0.0652787611,
-0.0299152583,
-0.0115702348,
-0.0589907393,
0.049650047,
-0.0037545585,
0.0074106427,
-0.02006872,
-0.0769388825,
-0.0040005855,
0.0044182362,
-0.0130158309,
-0.0172509048,
-0.0063663786,
-0.0010793828,
0.0342441462,
0.031221224,
0.0491629504,
-0.0694534779,
0.0407189615,
-0.0183469374,
-0.0459270328,
-0.0097990436,
-5.88339698e-33,
-0.0245543681,
-0.0268435143,
0.0291506872,
0.0366045758,
-0.007980993,
0.0192026664,
-0.0135250147,
-0.0187650323,
-0.026249107,
-0.0060989824,
-0.0294251628,
0.0042809709,
0.0345108546,
-0.0273268614,
0.0066398061,
-0.024942603,
0.0191294849,
0.0106230127,
-0.0043366835,
0.013431577,
0.1014880612,
0.0048036887,
0.0621569753,
-0.1159303859,
0.0510068461,
0.0002322081,
-0.0191622544,
-0.0074831145,
0.0905039534,
0.0202306565,
-0.0136838472,
0.0045686522,
0.0212359242,
-0.04513162,
0.0263454244,
0.0001551196,
-0.0662655383,
0.0003280753,
0.0158295874,
0.0210907906,
0.039650593,
-0.0210673399,
0.0048751906,
0.0185441561,
0.0053862329,
0.0290969443,
0.0685362816,
-0.0002986145,
-0.0107668741,
-0.0219942927,
-0.0429857858,
0.0327263288,
-0.0469651483,
0.0378873646,
-0.0354857445,
-0.0014564615,
0.0272266995,
0.0030610941,
-0.0532996543,
0.0308578555,
-0.0282546412,
0.0352931097,
0.005735815,
-0.0131565547,
-0.0147169344,
0.0483820774,
0.0201512538,
0.0315754004,
-0.0119419266,
0.0223607924,
-0.0010570359,
0.0470979139,
0.0007980528,
0.1240163967,
0.0226238277,
-0.0610290021,
-0.1004248783,
0.0434219018,
0.0414275937,
0.0029806786,
-0.0109938607,
-0.0157000441,
0.0102538466,
-0.0256516989,
-0.0171039309,
-0.0062460108,
-0.0169385094,
0.0011829913,
0.0033334112,
-0.0074979556,
-0.0436995476,
0.0556046665,
0.0276622996,
-0.0273279957,
-0.0012762432,
0.0163343828,
-0.0198354945,
0.0364234671,
-0.0196984261,
-0.0102410624,
-0.0239085369,
-0.0392594635,
0.0128398351,
0.0008593273,
0.0351364985,
0.0154755767,
-0.0049257348,
0.0120924143,
-0.0316926688,
0.0223499052,
-0.0155824004,
0.0073247482,
-0.054961022,
0.0223890338,
-0.001710133,
0.0078294072,
-0.003156763,
-0.0122852083,
0.0312936679,
0.0017326684,
0.0297172274,
-0.0444686413,
-0.0387392528,
0.0180139765,
0.0138964709,
-0.0037656419,
-0.0154456506,
0.0551638231,
0.0159321502,
-0.0154878311,
-0.0094191432,
-0.0497072414,
2.519e-7,
0.0786665678,
0.0298915412,
0.0102095008,
0.054525733,
-0.0339584723,
0.0063445652,
0.032631889,
0.0442141294,
-0.0125465244,
-0.0135934567,
0.0195159279,
0.0046185753,
0.0268938113,
0.0718969032,
-0.0941934511,
-0.064664796,
-0.0204903167,
0.0037123575,
-0.1032266915,
0.0382024758,
0.0377237275,
0.0388922617,
0.0789499953,
-0.0095781097,
-0.0240609162,
-0.0524542034,
0.0099737002,
-0.0370053165,
-0.0617491677,
0.0526803359,
-0.0027705843,
0.0056463871,
-0.0188565124,
0.0674587563,
-0.0410091132,
0.0075494996,
-0.0439719297,
0.0458554067,
-0.006547696,
-0.0006743008,
-0.0290385,
-0.0667705834,
0.0104600051,
-0.0373129807,
0.0758083612,
-0.0246215016,
-0.0055409451,
0.0381528921,
-0.0327380635,
0.0322480947,
0.0091087464,
0.0022784756,
0.0016223314,
0.0183094963,
-0.0094926488,
-0.0079173036,
0.0127259437,
-0.0595138185,
-0.0181885771,
-0.0181399342,
-0.0106452741,
-0.0421171375,
0.022779854,
-0.0188359246,
0.0300322063,
0.0238642022,
0.0311826244,
2.415912265e-34,
-0.000605414,
0.0562758073,
-0.0286035556,
0.017345937,
0.0488329306,
-0.0064540459,
-0.018321272,
0.0074647381,
0.021239141,
-0.0020005184,
-0.0009846051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01330v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01330v1
|
A Comparison of Document Similarity Algorithms
| 2023-04-03T19:50:55 | 2023-04-03T19:50:55 |
Nicholas Gahman, Vinayak Elangovan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Document similarity is an important part of Natural Language Processing and
is most commonly used for plagiarism-detection and text summarization. Thus,
finding the overall most effective document similarity algorithm could have a
major positive impact on the field of Natural Language Processing. This report
sets out to examine the numerous document similarity algorithms, and determine
which ones are the most useful. It addresses the most effective document
similarity algorithm by categorizing them into 3 types of document similarity
algorithms: statistical algorithms, neural networks, and corpus/knowledge-based
algorithms. The most effective algorithms in each category are also compared in
our work using a series of benchmark datasets and evaluations that test every
possible area that each algorithm could be used in.
|
[
0.0670548752,
-0.0020378102,
0.0057606692,
0.0471307039,
-0.0931639224,
0.0068851858,
0.0106748929,
0.0121060563,
0.0211254694,
-0.0440720059,
0.0128288511,
0.0559801683,
0.0396858826,
-0.0422380045,
0.0086528743,
0.0194356386,
0.0160601456,
0.0456621908,
-0.0107518947,
0.0167120006,
0.0300259702,
0.0084901825,
0.0255484954,
0.0148926452,
0.0028049564,
-0.0155404145,
0.0194372591,
-0.0052618645,
0.0412252098,
0.0238321442,
0.0303547904,
-0.0077599417,
-0.0304014422,
0.0757136941,
0.0000015071,
-0.0511279292,
-0.0400623903,
-0.0037860884,
0.0529418103,
-0.0103836693,
0.0796297491,
0.0033038715,
0.0216256063,
0.003339126,
-0.0150348833,
-0.0099184765,
0.0158981103,
0.0421176441,
0.0584014356,
0.0561258011,
-0.0564100556,
-0.0422236584,
0.0194486976,
0.0264692698,
-0.0083590923,
0.001285822,
0.0167180188,
0.0167732742,
0.0319119841,
-0.0119426697,
0.0210236087,
0.0306696109,
-0.0344122835,
-0.0168746281,
-0.0123517616,
-0.0193857476,
-0.0564348586,
0.0297800936,
0.0188403204,
0.0347893201,
-0.0539214723,
-0.0661189109,
0.0474820137,
0.0090000294,
-0.0059243445,
0.0677327663,
-0.0050253612,
0.0188173428,
-0.0220125541,
0.0339031257,
0.015156731,
0.0376600102,
-0.0479095802,
0.0170353558,
0.0288074557,
0.002846909,
-0.0001573205,
-0.0338293649,
-0.0209424924,
-0.0260429382,
0.0128678735,
-0.0271739457,
0.0446822718,
0.0266457554,
0.0454978347,
-0.0520395413,
-0.0604875907,
-0.099930577,
0.0609812066,
-0.071603179,
0.0392390899,
0.0145516656,
0.0237433966,
0.0750087723,
-0.0584485643,
0.0479074493,
0.0197354425,
0.0213388801,
-0.0412374809,
-0.0331110768,
-0.0755143836,
-0.0008970667,
-0.0170700662,
0.0657452941,
0.0317422375,
-0.0443606637,
-0.0315987505,
0.0288557876,
-0.0018150664,
0.0481849872,
-0.029153537,
-0.0037019956,
0.0490440875,
0.0075871721,
-0.0131152747,
-0.0342725143,
-0.0317481384,
0.0295646694,
-0.0455934145,
0.0099899154,
0.0127658611,
0.0268683415,
0.0557822771,
0.0291975718,
0.0102486126,
-0.0110961786,
0.0090254154,
-0.0417249724,
-0.0386638828,
-0.051481057,
0.0338297375,
-0.0046288064,
-0.0224496182,
-0.0712389797,
0.0374604128,
-0.0417290367,
-0.0357184596,
-0.030249767,
-0.0360902809,
0.0347557925,
-0.0625659674,
0.0167828929,
-0.0070228102,
0.0157562066,
0.0633991063,
0.0022830968,
-0.0253417026,
-0.0248559639,
0.0025100184,
0.0205965396,
0.0707938522,
0.0428048894,
0.0109013505,
0.009295593,
0.008613538,
-0.016211899,
0.0379643366,
-0.0251580048,
-0.0223987941,
0.0067998548,
-0.0048084324,
0.048712451,
-0.0472572744,
-0.02709933,
0.0594550893,
0.0919982567,
0.0103094503,
0.0275328048,
0.0147033837,
0.065164499,
0.0274028908,
0.013112844,
-0.0123072257,
-0.0167147107,
-0.0344678983,
0.0303688049,
0.0041234223,
0.0097916536,
-0.0231325068,
0.0141972741,
0.0047620754,
-0.0321683064,
-0.008038274,
-0.0415834673,
-0.03060879,
0.0299939197,
-0.0329337083,
-0.0041388208,
-0.0263607632,
-0.0271309223,
-0.043336127,
0.0027647372,
0.0282935016,
0.0293470901,
0.0628936365,
-0.0515802577,
0.0122814244,
-0.0060965512,
-0.0228837635,
0.0135654015,
0.0400401913,
-0.0149197718,
-0.0210692789,
-0.0628792942,
-0.0552673787,
-0.0257974733,
-0.0295704044,
0.0263022669,
-0.0214800406,
0.0374310911,
0.0469904579,
-0.0232439768,
-0.0655112341,
0.0574920289,
-0.0093624163,
-0.009686945,
0.0216084793,
-0.0082986206,
0.0234195702,
0.0115945758,
0.00053611,
0.0457149446,
-0.0116675468,
-0.0237365067,
-0.0328245685,
0.0123821935,
0.0096463077,
-0.0279502813,
0.0783013999,
-0.0874002352,
0.0237123538,
0.0522421189,
-0.0405290313,
0.0058490545,
0.0398720391,
-0.0170461759,
0.0299388114,
-0.080432184,
0.0365178958,
-0.0626247451,
0.0261037294,
-0.013884306,
0.0725912601,
0.0198377091,
0.031725999,
0.033382576,
-0.0271737054,
0.0538336635,
0.0036626812,
-0.0191358533,
-0.0468480848,
0.0205274131,
0.0138403354,
0.0108303139,
-0.0023046914,
-0.0075363289,
-0.0209044646,
-0.0702088699,
0.0082903234,
0.0165722985,
0.0219989028,
0.048451826,
0.0143808648,
-0.003451488,
-0.0096514337,
-0.0479094312,
-0.0194352306,
0.0023453205,
-0.0308585297,
0.0391208827,
-0.0123295877,
0.000514768,
-0.0363182425,
-0.0113693569,
0.0068252282,
0.0619831644,
0.0022971577,
-0.0115652224,
-0.0372939631,
0.0453984737,
-0.0281810984,
-0.0095512569,
0.0131269237,
0.032719817,
-0.032668151,
-0.0215893574,
-0.0140704988,
0.0231593419,
0.0349880122,
-0.078215152,
0.0256826412,
0.0505449623,
-0.0813091695,
-0.052532535,
-0.0351173989,
0.0624757335,
0.0252262503,
-0.0255079083,
0.0812962502,
-0.0191536006,
0.0342801251,
-0.0188598782,
0.0369453952,
0.0417102464,
0.0097316802,
0.0001052797,
-0.0052235601,
-0.0666185543,
0.03191109,
-0.0203667469,
-0.0066840299,
-0.001102464,
0.0557911098,
-0.0342498422,
0.0525873862,
-0.0671337396,
0.0000352297,
-0.0489560701,
-0.0101795802,
0.0144011583,
0.0224231295,
0.0168468412,
0.0085067824,
0.0246808641,
-0.0095666936,
0.1168319955,
-0.0125274472,
0.0011876145,
-0.0011735013,
0.0547400042,
0.0059325299,
-0.0009193511,
-0.0224548541,
-0.0430959314,
0.0138907004,
-0.0113369375,
-0.0197803099,
0.0188407842,
-0.0553743355,
0.0116125736,
0.005624644,
0.0801481456,
-0.0333288535,
-0.0291460901,
-0.0060158409,
0.1005357504,
-0.0058933212,
-0.0459800251,
0.0285964254,
0.0191706121,
-0.006840447,
0.0122108161,
0.0185932778,
0.0330140218,
-0.0265913494,
-0.0061420277,
-0.0472968332,
-0.1054204032,
0.0073181586,
-0.00365154,
-0.0304581858,
-0.0071727885,
0.0165254269,
0.0886434913,
0.0339221284,
-0.0381863788,
-0.0444856063,
-0.0237803794,
-0.0278887805,
0.0174221601,
-0.005290119,
-0.0146525903,
-0.0005961219,
-0.0149045009,
0.0327449404,
-0.0439134575,
-0.0394158438,
-0.0066370568,
-0.054085061,
-0.0056382986,
-0.0104824807,
-0.0553421043,
-0.0395338051,
-0.0595603585,
-0.0186718702,
0.0189302024,
-0.0540304892,
-0.0263532475,
-0.020267183,
-0.0284940861,
-0.0445151739,
-0.0377860442,
-0.0066173598,
-0.0513178781,
-0.0498344935,
-0.0246062912,
0.0524992868,
0.0422301553,
-0.0130816204,
-0.0103392154,
0.0120702321,
-0.0019619421,
-0.017406974,
0.0183829423,
0.0198496822,
0.0043352665,
0.0424501933,
-0.0251648687,
0.051224865,
-0.0177296754,
0.023894731,
0.0413581096,
0.0231099818,
-0.0105801551,
-0.0539521687,
-0.0735032558,
0.0221048724,
0.0066897483,
0.0506882742,
0.0480084755,
0.0390827395,
-0.0301401243,
0.029290406,
0.0033183978,
-0.0278749727,
0.0153781502,
0.0182017274,
0.0039935973,
-0.0017917298,
-0.1081468463,
-0.0254262984,
-0.0465844199,
-0.0574993715,
0.0133400327,
0.0238489937,
0.0157736354,
-0.0443489403,
-0.0421310291,
-0.0409673937,
0.0037222495,
0.0051153563,
0.0085510705,
0.0213072225,
0.0480818003,
0.0141135613,
-0.037395183,
-0.0234785285,
-0.0831519142,
-0.0154603887,
-0.0338623337,
-0.0032699395,
0.0071963868,
0.0669647008,
-0.0065207384,
-0.0078433594,
0.0415599234,
0.044618573,
-0.0088374307,
-0.0144709293,
-0.0158852357,
-0.0586888902,
-0.0165163036,
0.0095374743,
-0.0465911217,
0.0461683422,
0.0114252036,
-0.0440600291,
-0.0239139255,
-0.025751302,
0.0228790902,
0.0333268791,
-0.0322200879,
-0.0042787022,
0.011959346,
-0.0320643038,
-0.0241244454,
0.0042687226,
0.000134132,
0.007551325,
0.0352556482,
0.0207691975,
0.0565855913,
0.0105741331,
0.0533245616,
0.0024693243,
0.024169676,
0.006455462,
0.024268819,
0.0109295538,
0.0545050614,
-0.0777412876,
-0.0068774731,
-0.0515782312,
0.0039853053,
0.0037756776,
0.0348141566,
-0.0294911042,
0.0244376827,
0.0640200227,
0.0089861872,
-0.0087602055,
0.0620255545,
-0.0845771134,
-0.0129606035,
-0.040755935,
0.0057630735,
0.0569926314,
-0.0684347451,
0.0216044839,
-0.0352194086,
-0.0106553445,
-0.0020674164,
0.0138460407,
-0.0019948657,
0.0149876904,
-0.0406607538,
0.0128020402,
0.0249058325,
0.0465513654,
0.0695340931,
-0.0314482525,
-0.0030363551,
-0.0160604138,
-0.0922747776,
-0.0269106757,
0.0037372157,
0.0290756132,
0.0489588678,
-0.0313285291,
-0.0447926335,
-0.0301106256,
0.0258857068,
0.0650608465,
0.0317964591,
0.0037861511,
0.0276544839,
0.0730405003,
0.0337943062,
0.0001118008,
0.052087035,
-0.0339904651,
0.000061846,
-0.0207429547,
-0.039314948,
-0.0140698999,
-4.406378778e-33,
0.0373048037,
-0.0224322304,
-0.0422714464,
0.0388780572,
-0.01709418,
0.0022760218,
-0.0249590315,
-0.0807347447,
-0.0301833712,
0.0264882464,
-0.0000264279,
0.0177002084,
0.0014413462,
-0.0227848105,
-0.0038166372,
0.0172362328,
-0.0180633478,
0.0093084173,
-0.0193227939,
0.0033741503,
0.0030657251,
0.0103235608,
0.0224682335,
-0.0769830272,
0.0324803069,
-0.0405879878,
0.0135406023,
-0.0193079021,
0.0329477116,
0.025325017,
-0.0013285363,
0.0035080861,
0.0259627663,
-0.0083654942,
-0.0228785258,
0.0054398272,
-0.0220318642,
-0.0686501712,
-0.0299424585,
-0.0353436321,
-0.0085242214,
-0.0162435547,
0.0521328524,
-0.0208416786,
-0.0259141997,
-0.0072120875,
0.1129802316,
-0.0327032059,
-0.0402183831,
-0.0357103497,
-0.0451951213,
0.0185793843,
-0.039275296,
0.0296458341,
0.0271692537,
0.03561024,
-0.0157610029,
0.0548179038,
-0.079425104,
0.037129391,
-0.0507545955,
0.0144251557,
-0.0112868454,
-0.0445117317,
0.040430434,
0.0560210124,
0.0412125401,
-0.0673809424,
0.0289989226,
0.037188597,
0.0136030624,
-0.0123532312,
0.0491921194,
0.0542316549,
0.0432885773,
-0.0301183239,
-0.0119281197,
0.1142513752,
0.0309042502,
-0.0146527505,
0.0170532521,
-0.0299487486,
-0.0432411656,
-0.0097222151,
0.0089986753,
-0.0224547219,
-0.0179716293,
-0.0118841063,
0.0051330603,
-0.0018482086,
0.0092608416,
-0.0124797253,
-0.0100134974,
-0.063388586,
0.0089632273,
0.0150244348,
-0.0128455944,
0.0087119453,
0.0084740706,
-0.0173658337,
-0.0032956179,
-0.0012066837,
-0.0062923958,
-0.0031623153,
0.0252885241,
-0.0117682964,
0.0725773796,
-0.0179232489,
-0.0305693299,
0.0145783564,
0.0420624726,
-0.045209866,
-0.0261134002,
0.0062333015,
-0.073559247,
0.0024524066,
0.0395046733,
0.0028615554,
0.0199447349,
-0.0117776236,
-0.0168567635,
-0.0087137427,
0.0246885791,
-0.0046988809,
-0.0080898562,
0.0052831555,
-0.0617644191,
0.0623995103,
0.0069704293,
-0.0271703005,
0.0087877894,
0.0117621589,
2.137e-7,
0.0351627171,
-0.0197001919,
0.0656379908,
-0.0502981506,
0.0114804003,
0.0328819193,
-0.0074969847,
0.0392688997,
-0.0154751018,
0.0534577295,
0.038689591,
-0.0180404428,
0.0145096835,
0.0090394802,
-0.1205520481,
-0.00645519,
-0.0653014034,
-0.1016601697,
-0.0732454509,
0.0025262777,
0.0264797006,
0.0216216557,
0.0375368558,
-0.0548446774,
-0.0266198218,
-0.060965348,
0.008356818,
0.0096814968,
0.0107927611,
0.0219370387,
0.0818013847,
-0.0441197604,
-0.0342075862,
0.017581353,
0.0179650672,
0.046986226,
0.0661925226,
-0.0343546122,
0.0069751767,
0.013064228,
-0.0080116047,
-0.0556316078,
0.0055714557,
-0.0368739627,
0.0424718484,
0.0127594974,
0.0329863131,
-0.034769088,
-0.007648387,
0.0109175732,
0.0219794977,
-0.0030080751,
-0.0306146275,
0.0288443193,
0.0324149355,
-0.0009719722,
0.0235403497,
-0.0103652049,
0.0251522604,
-0.0158069935,
0.0103101991,
-0.0020963226,
-0.0278482363,
0.0025593794,
0.0873263478,
-0.0193520412,
0.0380810946,
1.479310853e-34,
0.030129971,
0.0093022054,
0.0123469792,
-0.0150691159,
-0.0159161594,
-0.0055740396,
-0.0226842612,
0.019520035,
-0.0486493707,
-0.0173303969,
0.0098128589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01328v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01328v1
|
Grand Challenge On Detecting Cheapfakes
| 2023-04-03T19:50:26 | 2023-04-03T19:50:26 |
Duc-Tien Dang-Nguyen, Sohail Ahmed Khan, Cise Midoglu, Michael Riegler, Pål Halvorsen, Minh-Son Dao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Cheapfake is a recently coined term that encompasses non-AI ("cheap")
manipulations of multimedia content. Cheapfakes are known to be more prevalent
than deepfakes. Cheapfake media can be created using editing software for
image/video manipulations, or even without using any software, by simply
altering the context of an image/video by sharing the media alongside
misleading claims. This alteration of context is referred to as out-of-context
(OOC) misuse of media. OOC media is much harder to detect than fake media,
since the images and videos are not tampered. In this challenge, we focus on
detecting OOC images, and more specifically the misuse of real photographs with
conflicting image captions in news items. The aim of this challenge is to
develop and benchmark models that can be used to detect whether given samples
(news image and associated captions) are OOC, based on the recently compiled
COSMOS dataset.
|
[
0.0505971387,
0.0383638591,
0.0056860093,
0.0963705778,
-0.0501979515,
0.0121597983,
-0.002284121,
0.0588211119,
-0.0332413241,
-0.0524878576,
-0.0133898119,
0.0019314901,
0.0101077557,
0.048370894,
-0.0401624739,
-0.0284928158,
0.0434850417,
0.0088459635,
0.0095389197,
-0.0099418908,
0.0414295681,
-0.0072826454,
0.0110584563,
0.0005518147,
-0.0640816242,
-0.0302963238,
0.0071668769,
0.0444774553,
0.0219105836,
0.0032545263,
-0.0123019153,
0.0720048174,
0.0091496222,
0.1073258147,
0.0000016627,
-0.0558228306,
-0.0291431937,
-0.018163437,
-0.0325942785,
0.0285327211,
0.1020325646,
-0.0199054405,
-0.0501058176,
-0.0195503086,
-0.0420154259,
0.0171487462,
0.0559071079,
0.0522728935,
0.0648201033,
0.0956841856,
-0.0456952751,
0.0322089717,
-0.0089098308,
-0.0142151462,
0.0235925596,
-0.0258661974,
0.0281180628,
-0.011750374,
-0.0226405617,
0.0096900882,
-0.006759888,
0.0051237964,
-0.0120893233,
-0.0402505733,
-0.0607273728,
-0.0028622567,
-0.0642039776,
-0.013322141,
-0.0049485518,
0.0203662403,
-0.0755639672,
0.0147093544,
0.0014446919,
-0.020166317,
0.0197922513,
0.0473243333,
0.0062435591,
0.0558668189,
-0.0019867849,
0.0157022197,
-0.051490292,
0.0031726619,
0.0042042984,
0.038718652,
0.0248938687,
-0.0227068178,
0.0256657936,
0.0035077916,
-0.0404255837,
-0.0341948234,
-0.0104960678,
-0.0744234994,
0.0099937404,
0.0014408396,
0.0438716076,
-0.0191045813,
-0.0930210128,
-0.0474300683,
0.0126968911,
-0.0523658209,
0.0179491471,
-0.0180033837,
-0.0507941283,
0.079710722,
-0.015413926,
0.0286098961,
0.0092499806,
0.0221353937,
0.0136568602,
0.0182478484,
0.0115648471,
0.0099198204,
-0.0138070071,
0.0178059395,
-0.0331255645,
-0.0401823521,
-0.0605541505,
-0.0260234922,
-0.0482565016,
0.02379434,
-0.0447368622,
0.0190180056,
-0.0332647748,
-0.0046661487,
-0.018625753,
0.0133172171,
0.0563286692,
0.0264143087,
-0.0209434666,
-0.0515720583,
-0.0067959037,
0.0607351996,
0.0128515204,
0.010270494,
0.0257772878,
0.0330813639,
0.0051224269,
-0.0475872532,
-0.0518244244,
-0.0836198106,
-0.0627501383,
-0.0217652041,
-0.025303524,
-0.0627016202,
-0.0418287069,
-0.0477161147,
0.0020582762,
-0.0329521261,
-0.0016058305,
0.0070257778,
-0.0773648396,
0.0397329293,
-0.0165454391,
-0.0045315912,
0.0303874891,
0.0366224833,
-0.0169845391,
0.0610613935,
-0.0196687058,
0.0850864053,
0.0993596539,
0.0211747997,
0.0162949357,
0.0862320289,
-0.0101629002,
0.0320763178,
-0.0037192993,
-0.0014963283,
0.0277190898,
-0.0044934289,
0.0325266719,
-0.0055269157,
-0.0302129127,
-0.0155669628,
0.0743952841,
0.0196827706,
-0.0329872742,
-0.0464263856,
0.0112326462,
0.0005808875,
0.0041455673,
0.0074610687,
-0.0333924517,
0.0266687907,
-0.0408269502,
-0.0193347819,
0.017052453,
0.0299904551,
0.0034484458,
0.0012023902,
-0.0009789269,
-0.0610461459,
-0.0120616537,
-0.0360549018,
0.0445581675,
0.032755997,
-0.042071972,
-0.0044146995,
-0.0392147563,
-0.0060303169,
-0.0269561708,
-0.070070073,
0.0410118252,
0.0341898166,
0.058159817,
0.0043299212,
0.0202866886,
-0.0178918932,
0.0090604667,
0.0119664138,
-0.0095276292,
-0.025783645,
-0.0091697369,
-0.0112124663,
-0.0431562699,
-0.0516164601,
0.0093120523,
-0.0030307653,
0.0430627465,
0.0068008862,
0.0646110848,
0.0137981968,
-0.0173071604,
-0.021220956,
0.0680959225,
-0.0045838063,
-0.0046579265,
0.0467096567,
0.0374028422,
-0.0055391872,
-0.0077831335,
-0.0265760738,
-0.0014683045,
0.0237982292,
-0.0024972598,
-0.0016411915,
0.0318100899,
-0.0053047333,
0.03847133,
-0.0983773544,
-0.0223283302,
0.0736688301,
-0.0353901833,
0.0004323251,
0.0513523296,
-0.0075925547,
-0.0149593009,
-0.0828829557,
0.0165091865,
-0.0241360366,
0.0505717024,
0.0489867032,
0.0712423772,
-0.0209409557,
-0.0256327316,
0.0453408659,
-0.0282732639,
0.0368914343,
-0.0227752998,
0.0047219875,
-0.0579145402,
-0.0420943461,
0.0134951007,
-0.0020161702,
0.0231301598,
-0.0292696916,
0.0065527339,
-0.0308339205,
-0.0300657675,
-0.0232189503,
-0.0177858472,
0.0405724496,
0.0028295771,
0.0065936209,
-0.0080861086,
0.0118475435,
0.0034609009,
0.0294996947,
0.0363931358,
0.0096375346,
-0.0211754665,
-0.0198714063,
0.0141140865,
-0.0067730285,
0.0166837126,
0.0580914877,
0.0213992316,
-0.0277384054,
-0.0347250924,
0.0053961216,
0.0067240093,
0.0063282847,
-0.0010330211,
0.0140075842,
-0.0242832638,
0.0068573207,
-0.0225016233,
0.0739839971,
0.0350123644,
0.0256164838,
-0.0096357968,
0.0356151201,
0.0237438306,
-0.0637555271,
0.0157613885,
-0.0116973193,
0.0171849988,
-0.0621116683,
0.0394645259,
-0.0195907149,
-0.0144931152,
0.0207729209,
0.0144682201,
0.0270370189,
-0.0265549533,
-0.0283733774,
0.0164882299,
-0.0343527906,
-0.0136024356,
0.0240131263,
-0.0154781751,
-0.0532008931,
0.0282589197,
-0.037254896,
0.0306064766,
0.0295425057,
-0.0147196418,
0.0034573202,
-0.0017941023,
0.0005426605,
0.0710975677,
0.0088069569,
-0.0252019763,
-0.0172793921,
-0.0112251239,
0.1118434519,
-0.015777424,
0.0389356241,
-0.0243861377,
0.0101066092,
-0.0042053815,
0.003007005,
-0.0117829926,
-0.0995215774,
0.0135959014,
-0.0169501398,
-0.0415413305,
-0.0398788899,
-0.0186756402,
0.0140346959,
-0.0107506495,
0.051649414,
-0.0126843723,
0.0327247195,
0.0092691584,
0.1063497066,
0.0421873033,
-0.0430671461,
0.0016729119,
-0.0157823619,
-0.0557424687,
0.0659595877,
0.0053691659,
0.0169248302,
-0.0204472747,
0.0303272754,
-0.0027748803,
0.0196501613,
0.0394046456,
0.0157313142,
0.0079099108,
-0.02017623,
-0.0200449768,
0.0421376489,
-0.0197992884,
-0.0424018018,
-0.0177330282,
0.0074016857,
-0.0680997223,
0.0412757285,
-0.0406156369,
-0.0988889635,
-0.0320360623,
-0.0194367412,
-0.0092814537,
-0.0573168211,
-0.0171792563,
0.0030355458,
-0.1046380103,
0.0538562611,
0.0207492486,
-0.029267028,
-0.0404544175,
-0.0187086277,
-0.0101023009,
0.0015226975,
-0.0135825761,
-0.0245753601,
0.0041039884,
-0.0091821551,
-0.0510430075,
0.03870802,
-0.0445892848,
0.0036650696,
-0.0302479956,
0.0324085094,
0.0471845344,
-0.0151929138,
-0.0457377099,
-0.0351876058,
0.011767609,
0.0189058278,
-0.0182405375,
0.019661149,
0.0849543959,
-0.0187490843,
-0.0052611385,
0.0260375813,
0.0606002249,
0.015956793,
-0.0367042981,
-0.0206744075,
0.036938481,
0.0335601941,
-0.0232129395,
-0.0284938533,
-0.0140801268,
0.0642602444,
0.0277880561,
0.0302365366,
0.0225363299,
-0.0423948467,
-0.0019637947,
-0.0225937106,
-0.0231994614,
0.0123162922,
0.0302743539,
0.00109703,
-0.0564659499,
-0.0390238054,
0.0259782933,
-0.0132758301,
0.0149124255,
0.0072387271,
-0.0158587508,
-0.030365603,
0.0214577336,
-0.0962309167,
-0.0109126028,
-0.0276903696,
0.0667807907,
-0.0439454131,
0.0557861999,
0.0122196581,
0.0028671594,
-0.0231542066,
0.0489614531,
-0.059099663,
-0.0276083164,
0.0045581041,
0.0448178239,
0.0275525711,
0.0195757337,
0.0165310502,
-0.0099466667,
0.0514625423,
0.0503674671,
0.0006838986,
0.0202296618,
0.0460392907,
-0.0237474646,
-0.033157248,
0.0377569571,
-0.0186021198,
0.0195142664,
0.0360100381,
-0.0402150601,
-0.0634597242,
0.0002567072,
0.0053591477,
-0.0108301258,
0.0097500868,
-0.0485141315,
0.0147601254,
0.0010725862,
0.0011867542,
0.0020089368,
-0.0119149573,
0.0075131562,
0.0129950568,
0.0337408856,
0.0241402276,
0.0342122167,
0.057384111,
-0.0462735482,
0.0107009001,
0.0283917431,
-0.0419876948,
0.0271771569,
0.0080597671,
0.0140165063,
0.0018176517,
0.0349433161,
0.0489138849,
0.0162257329,
0.0362301059,
-0.0123118544,
0.0464169309,
0.0400414765,
0.0132760825,
0.0061176503,
0.0235838927,
-0.0053290739,
0.0496514849,
-0.0395981334,
0.0400555655,
0.041476883,
-0.0663156584,
0.0099302661,
-0.0319483504,
-0.0141825033,
-0.0250453241,
-0.0054235584,
-0.0425087102,
-0.0830353647,
-0.0125347152,
0.0002679159,
0.0007594927,
0.1024521813,
0.0817591771,
-0.0164121334,
0.0123691373,
0.0184707157,
-0.0341212191,
-0.037807174,
0.0229461063,
0.023520207,
0.000162144,
-0.0389812887,
0.0008074465,
-0.0387674272,
-0.041956313,
0.0017391512,
-0.0076876641,
0.0302840695,
0.0912810266,
-0.0027773136,
0.0793117955,
0.0097817769,
0.0334228985,
0.0165064,
0.0144778844,
-0.0413510315,
-0.0312396288,
0.0222315751,
-5.824283573e-33,
0.0518821254,
-0.0667971373,
-0.0593353845,
-0.015648149,
0.0358978361,
0.0633238927,
-0.0022443978,
-0.0201100819,
-0.0124317659,
-0.0005660071,
-0.0033266293,
0.0453933924,
0.0044461829,
0.0514143258,
-0.0118107321,
0.0264515299,
0.0395629294,
-0.0139190508,
-0.0532121733,
0.0022908687,
0.0476488546,
-0.0193504542,
0.017450165,
-0.0575272106,
-0.0107238144,
-0.0189161412,
-0.0755935833,
0.0292326137,
-0.0116824508,
0.0567542464,
-0.0085096899,
-0.0182932094,
0.0143021913,
-0.0165017657,
0.0044842749,
0.0216092169,
-0.0178970397,
-0.0122422641,
-0.0094474321,
0.015007671,
-0.0118898107,
-0.0363818742,
0.036860317,
-0.0180492736,
-0.0347638726,
-0.0286772288,
0.0398839936,
-0.039231427,
0.0006280799,
0.0227028467,
-0.0393475369,
0.0149005288,
-0.0267614331,
-0.0062901541,
0.0304417945,
-0.0005235909,
0.0235325508,
0.0169565361,
-0.069215931,
0.0472493693,
-0.0200126171,
0.0205685496,
0.0384016074,
-0.041099146,
0.0051823705,
0.0486734472,
0.0163475554,
-0.0115943979,
0.01321874,
-0.0163535494,
-0.0112070572,
0.0634640977,
0.0390746556,
0.1038935781,
0.0943703353,
-0.0267951675,
-0.0439665578,
0.0065284767,
-0.0454398431,
0.0186236706,
-0.0243013632,
-0.0329675674,
-0.0246286392,
0.0386680402,
-0.0179031771,
-0.0523848124,
-0.0441388227,
-0.0477779731,
0.0085859932,
0.036504034,
-0.0446500182,
0.0429403856,
0.0286678281,
-0.0859665424,
-0.0035848331,
-0.057280276,
-0.0016913601,
0.0384303741,
0.0168085676,
0.0473020263,
0.0046667247,
-0.0101417582,
0.0513042957,
-0.0041334606,
0.0244209915,
-0.0119916927,
0.1038677171,
0.0488759689,
-0.0516754538,
0.0098630786,
0.0207227319,
0.0251721051,
-0.0244620666,
0.0035838194,
-0.016232118,
0.0075150752,
-0.0386268497,
-0.0234811865,
0.0140291471,
0.0402429365,
-0.0511211939,
-0.0659903139,
-0.0326558203,
0.0112904608,
-0.0137769654,
-0.0057291701,
-0.0271048248,
-0.0125692571,
0.0397907346,
-0.0615445226,
-0.0055959499,
0.0311480518,
2.46e-7,
-0.0183053706,
0.0142710134,
0.014843232,
-0.0196387246,
-0.0047643138,
0.0514650457,
-0.0039079939,
0.0116629731,
-0.0489984639,
-0.0556930937,
-0.0009366034,
-0.0130273523,
0.0316292718,
-0.0177770592,
-0.0445020497,
0.0464218631,
-0.0214571301,
-0.029860625,
-0.0428262986,
-0.0014504202,
0.0034236468,
0.0538595282,
0.03576589,
-0.0951706991,
0.0246645827,
-0.0677133128,
0.0206580963,
0.032745067,
-0.0057183253,
-0.0423962288,
0.0152681265,
0.025663197,
0.0172271803,
0.0013683605,
-0.0193968322,
0.0022523794,
0.0103314323,
0.020494746,
-0.011811777,
-0.0207914207,
-0.0675406009,
-0.0114667304,
0.0030675298,
-0.034293782,
0.0575794131,
0.0186605435,
-0.0126614105,
-0.0845114067,
-0.0528131761,
-0.00249452,
0.0167760234,
-0.0239346102,
-0.0000886433,
0.0396060646,
0.0319673158,
0.0410083607,
-0.0329253376,
-0.0451509207,
0.0432147458,
-0.0069694021,
-0.0215006433,
0.0081705358,
-0.026689034,
-0.002844057,
0.0829036012,
-0.0123720579,
-0.0171814784,
2.037986698e-34,
0.0368389562,
-0.0382324606,
0.0243075211,
-0.0030927283,
0.0027921256,
0.0094104093,
-0.0454029813,
-0.0150886336,
-0.0364179239,
-0.0099233286,
0.0024839598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01322v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01322v1
|
PALI: A Language Identification Benchmark for Perso-Arabic Scripts
| 2023-04-03T19:40:14 | 2023-04-03T19:40:14 |
Sina Ahmadi, Milind Agarwal, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Perso-Arabic scripts are a family of scripts that are widely adopted and
used by various linguistic communities around the globe. Identifying various
languages using such scripts is crucial to language technologies and
challenging in low-resource setups. As such, this paper sheds light on the
challenges of detecting languages using Perso-Arabic scripts, especially in
bilingual communities where ``unconventional'' writing is practiced. To address
this, we use a set of supervised techniques to classify sentences into their
languages. Building on these, we also propose a hierarchical model that targets
clusters of languages that are more often confused by the classifiers. Our
experiment results indicate the effectiveness of our solutions.
|
[
0.0276662279,
0.0334816687,
-0.0377557315,
0.0411032587,
-0.0694637448,
0.0348112658,
0.0443980396,
0.0298978165,
0.0311090816,
-0.0592833534,
0.0038489595,
-0.048531808,
0.0532512181,
-0.0222942922,
0.0103548272,
-0.0767224953,
0.0332629606,
-0.0434772633,
0.0302838013,
0.0260960236,
0.0395701677,
0.0318018086,
-0.0124946535,
0.0082573593,
-0.0181530602,
-0.032260716,
0.0074462369,
-0.0148262372,
0.0265070777,
0.0104328254,
0.0118613457,
0.0798181221,
-0.013424065,
0.089053899,
0.0000013149,
-0.0618626513,
-0.0230895989,
-0.0579653047,
-0.0129978489,
-0.0031145532,
0.0549130738,
-0.0146083143,
-0.0224597007,
0.0304867849,
0.0094186515,
-0.0519610234,
0.0634168759,
-0.0047182757,
0.0195784457,
0.0264745988,
-0.0037998643,
-0.0584547259,
-0.0123707084,
0.0290379785,
-0.0386473723,
-0.0017347126,
0.0224353597,
-0.0506585091,
0.0076407678,
-0.0346747264,
-0.009612387,
0.011992652,
-0.0222595725,
-0.0163867772,
-0.0287589636,
-0.0250741579,
-0.0558225699,
-0.0174287986,
0.0072522718,
-0.0088532725,
-0.0482460707,
-0.077537179,
0.0169650391,
0.0189176872,
-0.0128428135,
0.0026279113,
0.0196415167,
0.0190495513,
-0.0713332072,
0.0146275116,
0.0784458593,
0.0637455285,
0.0178258196,
0.0012167171,
-0.0228796843,
0.0494660996,
0.0268291943,
0.0127495527,
-0.0091788946,
0.0187292732,
0.0218909066,
-0.0070224451,
0.031523183,
0.0001071905,
-0.0004681635,
-0.0102416696,
-0.0222251117,
-0.0195052233,
-0.0018938148,
-0.0215962883,
0.0735966563,
0.0509498306,
-0.0350546353,
0.0160394982,
-0.0384746455,
0.018835336,
0.0397078283,
-0.012439413,
-0.0060177441,
0.0196386613,
-0.041509375,
-0.0371694267,
-0.0141731407,
0.0047829812,
-0.0202608854,
0.0390589423,
-0.0419044495,
0.0043033138,
0.0148729216,
0.0228444841,
-0.0265138485,
-0.0742952377,
0.0100063803,
0.0048437235,
0.0265864804,
0.0331864208,
0.0126578519,
0.0183136296,
-0.0668673292,
-0.07857012,
0.0432952791,
0.0988149717,
0.0045068027,
0.0239829831,
0.0071184123,
0.05276509,
-0.0555108152,
-0.0598390289,
-0.0778900832,
0.0274785906,
-0.0330196582,
-0.0298511628,
-0.0211184248,
-0.0667041987,
0.0382874385,
0.0129284421,
-0.0111645004,
-0.0159146339,
-0.0009748013,
0.0053870762,
0.0398941189,
0.0354199484,
0.014107313,
0.0067718904,
0.0827607885,
0.0065087825,
0.066312395,
0.0160382502,
0.0129212579,
0.0128731141,
0.0393200032,
-0.0447482355,
0.0441575646,
0.0584192388,
-0.0601597317,
-0.0077498411,
-0.043505121,
-0.0126810241,
0.0458200425,
-0.0103009474,
-0.0466107838,
0.0448081531,
0.0200764257,
0.0498520434,
0.0204817429,
0.046261061,
-0.027521139,
0.0013614926,
0.009675988,
0.0212853495,
0.0221188869,
0.0280727167,
0.0405238234,
-0.0481561571,
0.0060642897,
-0.0301087666,
-0.0039531514,
0.0452859513,
-0.0340021551,
-0.0278479531,
-0.0351593234,
-0.0301645249,
-0.0054338765,
0.0035719567,
0.0901254267,
-0.0131249782,
0.0083903773,
-0.0209500268,
0.0327785015,
-0.0042125969,
0.0366580002,
-0.0388189815,
0.0157766007,
0.0384500138,
-0.0085601555,
-0.0561578162,
0.0606137291,
-0.0090821674,
0.0103220679,
0.0316343158,
-0.0352660753,
-0.037784189,
-0.0008204466,
-0.0237623956,
0.0339977555,
0.0718281493,
0.0344186425,
0.0258188415,
-0.0091061695,
-0.0040183035,
-0.0135644693,
-0.0128682544,
-0.0499781221,
0.0530164503,
-0.0117184948,
0.0187481549,
0.0144888116,
0.0430545509,
0.0151480157,
0.0196651109,
-0.0056389528,
-0.0348995589,
-0.018785309,
-0.0667448714,
-0.0061922814,
0.0260034986,
0.0166649278,
-0.0540350266,
0.0172609538,
-0.0359308422,
-0.0190543178,
-0.0106319273,
-0.0010745679,
-0.0501432456,
0.0497397371,
-0.0410853475,
0.0304991696,
-0.0311111808,
0.034803845,
-0.0529030375,
-0.0163575653,
-0.038556233,
0.0751577765,
0.0024350712,
0.0097195571,
-0.0220880378,
-0.0600283034,
0.0890755579,
-0.0246274918,
-0.0058033462,
0.0099351807,
-0.0301017165,
0.0212948229,
-0.004185494,
0.0074664331,
0.0177572817,
-0.0592321679,
-0.0458414368,
-0.0711552352,
-0.0351853184,
0.0550833717,
-0.0116113201,
-0.0102673313,
-0.0052910293,
-0.0552441701,
-0.0055548372,
-0.0566372573,
0.0412972942,
-0.0148711158,
0.0463181399,
-0.0176366251,
-0.004238761,
-0.0023385601,
-0.0237500276,
-0.0104266377,
0.0675775409,
0.0126571851,
-0.0707787573,
-0.0411379524,
-0.031869527,
0.0094618164,
-0.0047480483,
0.0090102907,
-0.0198442135,
-0.0137786977,
0.0024290909,
-0.0049817408,
0.0434618481,
-0.0336064212,
0.0158048589,
0.044969812,
0.0312875286,
0.0531065203,
-0.0522884466,
0.0109300949,
0.0428511463,
-0.0233084392,
-0.0516217239,
-0.0201144367,
0.0533200949,
0.0169378445,
-0.0002927421,
-0.023941027,
-0.0388217382,
-0.0362268649,
0.0482790098,
-0.0032602311,
-0.0110534942,
-0.0044365092,
0.0869616494,
0.0072996398,
-0.0422328785,
0.0623202622,
-0.0401409045,
-0.0108689554,
-0.0496575236,
-0.0252968278,
-0.0352778919,
-0.0136835044,
0.0149432858,
0.0374998674,
-0.0278665815,
-0.0510000773,
-0.0142578343,
0.0301363412,
0.0136506716,
0.0264049284,
0.0113345701,
-0.0330108069,
0.0066904319,
-0.019225169,
-0.0379296727,
-0.0307995286,
-0.014631303,
-0.0352402665,
0.0070450348,
0.0158065017,
-0.0154858669,
-0.0094703576,
0.0603956021,
-0.0133845732,
0.0359243043,
0.0052292808,
0.0320521854,
-0.0155418217,
0.0475744903,
-0.0258208159,
-0.060762804,
-0.001275409,
-0.0244013816,
0.0006877925,
-0.0099647529,
-0.0214942396,
-0.0082437554,
-0.0208277237,
-0.0112632848,
0.0368398763,
-0.0247574579,
-0.0390177742,
-0.0075883418,
-0.0250457004,
-0.0072396612,
0.0180196986,
0.0722959191,
0.0316790231,
-0.0395229273,
-0.0006659519,
0.0065848199,
0.0195495728,
0.0033966021,
0.0069693457,
-0.048624929,
-0.0100018382,
0.03825799,
0.0186045077,
-0.0121667776,
0.0346335396,
0.0484364666,
-0.0683301687,
-0.0120631643,
0.0165248271,
-0.0874607787,
-0.0181819331,
-0.0205282327,
0.0012434589,
-0.0066807959,
-0.0373223089,
-0.0020262776,
-0.0155356508,
-0.0150990803,
0.0421696901,
-0.0963545665,
-0.0738173351,
-0.0115277627,
-0.0055972785,
-0.0190919414,
0.0014070976,
-0.0191781279,
-0.0567547306,
-0.0039704931,
-0.0015270591,
-0.0583722778,
-0.0383201875,
-0.0112050539,
0.0285189841,
0.0262894053,
-0.0157517865,
-0.0241791923,
0.0189654063,
-0.0629505664,
-0.0068822014,
0.0035648763,
0.0586553551,
-0.0020083992,
-0.0313609652,
0.0677030906,
0.0028540301,
0.0068034893,
-0.0011528125,
0.0029575767,
-0.027522672,
-0.0303472448,
-0.0562267713,
0.0013201879,
-0.0206099264,
-0.0213612877,
0.0219444502,
0.0126072764,
-0.0506981164,
-0.0554174855,
-0.0226233676,
-0.0083482666,
0.0210820623,
0.0566738062,
0.0112452535,
-0.0012722008,
0.0411205962,
-0.0350774303,
-0.0414510407,
-0.0018741047,
-0.0043749833,
-0.091683872,
-0.0260006394,
0.0252851713,
-0.0265006404,
0.0150177479,
-0.0068313661,
-0.0730124563,
-0.0435645916,
0.0504146107,
-0.0158278532,
0.0195632316,
-0.0432763025,
-0.0241412167,
-0.0636095777,
-0.0222666655,
-0.0034036059,
0.0224809796,
0.0081151705,
0.0206735749,
-0.0028557887,
-0.0601577759,
0.0306744203,
0.0134190368,
0.0089817848,
0.0087158289,
-0.0777833834,
-0.0950097293,
-0.0311949234,
0.0163690113,
-0.0051633315,
0.0000075861,
-0.0917310938,
-0.0226691235,
-0.0412278175,
-0.0379407033,
0.026944628,
-0.0018117545,
0.0123657817,
-0.0324754715,
0.0197939351,
0.048380442,
0.0118645439,
0.0249683931,
0.004049914,
0.021526387,
0.011617085,
0.026132036,
0.0461803526,
0.0749686286,
-0.0306715015,
0.0294537824,
-0.0031836601,
0.0415756814,
-0.0158067122,
0.0548623577,
-0.023569433,
0.0192896649,
0.001718284,
0.0117060822,
0.0125399623,
0.0384218358,
0.0282423943,
0.021939598,
0.0024253465,
0.0239340477,
0.0930934027,
-0.0351568311,
0.0171312615,
-0.0119799264,
-0.005384631,
-0.0364478119,
0.0486182421,
0.0350323617,
-0.0345224813,
-0.0196542684,
-0.0010260578,
-0.0402127728,
0.0176977012,
0.0696640685,
0.0301352851,
-0.0209324397,
0.0568354055,
-0.0227526277,
-0.0313968509,
-0.0135863191,
0.0173739195,
0.0184286386,
-0.0300756115,
0.002160521,
-0.0561882369,
-0.04154386,
0.0249282382,
-0.029782854,
0.044138547,
0.0107483575,
0.0057376851,
0.0510538779,
0.026473077,
0.0255045835,
-0.0650252327,
0.0189294796,
0.0174050238,
0.0124276215,
-0.0161000583,
-4.675506005e-33,
-0.0102637755,
-0.0421132557,
-0.0774910599,
0.0331065692,
0.0809401497,
-0.0495385453,
-0.0167225935,
0.0225340016,
-0.0176802967,
-0.0004998948,
-0.0084190276,
-0.0029627474,
0.0404963642,
0.0276968516,
0.0464002118,
-0.0195738021,
0.0290359799,
-0.0036635245,
-0.0158125907,
0.0113385506,
0.1088686734,
0.0021447795,
0.0797842443,
-0.0363359638,
-0.0080684619,
-0.0433090441,
-0.0193887297,
0.0392654128,
-0.0015833863,
0.0429423638,
-0.0246129576,
0.0392679684,
0.0303229224,
0.0564228892,
0.0347603448,
0.0197011884,
0.0105924793,
0.009164325,
-0.0176891964,
0.0729855746,
0.0014407079,
-0.0662500337,
-0.041213531,
-0.0586689971,
-0.0301349387,
0.0349709578,
0.0436312482,
-0.0344700366,
-0.0004941081,
0.0017330685,
-0.0935295671,
0.051497519,
-0.0075202989,
0.0203418173,
0.048541043,
0.0700497255,
-0.0072454778,
-0.0007864089,
-0.0507069714,
0.0212760027,
-0.0004397036,
0.0633160993,
0.0254550725,
0.0865990818,
-0.079894647,
-0.0018478676,
0.0300560892,
-0.0233527441,
0.0580967143,
0.0290373955,
0.0376201235,
-0.0742677599,
0.0460246354,
0.068136096,
0.0100620054,
-0.0278448779,
-0.053167861,
-0.0140717411,
0.036905244,
-0.0304279607,
0.0226513166,
-0.0329738483,
-0.0688809603,
-0.0464948043,
0.0416892953,
-0.0949177295,
0.0069838064,
0.021986708,
0.010672858,
-0.0186205022,
0.0039063022,
0.0015614663,
0.0291799903,
-0.014821779,
0.0231230576,
-0.0238647088,
-0.0298442356,
0.0520416535,
0.0172564406,
0.0356663316,
-0.0336330608,
-0.0691670701,
0.0017395952,
-0.0015940958,
0.0236966759,
-0.014706566,
0.0758289397,
0.0121246297,
-0.0423644744,
0.0501842424,
0.0184729677,
0.0319351703,
0.0168619882,
0.0951448902,
-0.0044697407,
-0.0180500634,
0.0180754066,
0.0134661822,
0.0402068608,
0.0124441413,
-0.0033081726,
0.025203215,
-0.0596495569,
-0.0245831199,
0.000278632,
0.0191035327,
-0.0400520526,
0.0287665799,
-0.0074354997,
-0.0153096132,
0.0298271589,
-0.0211951379,
2.136e-7,
0.0279416256,
0.0236282907,
0.0227801837,
-0.0504827835,
0.0433323346,
0.0053557879,
-0.0154775791,
-0.0047888611,
-0.0373581946,
0.0317752324,
0.0130221825,
-0.013701411,
0.1151464209,
0.0123973545,
-0.0687400177,
0.0147271529,
-0.0319044217,
0.0091441153,
-0.0468297862,
0.0155413756,
0.0099932617,
0.0973996669,
-0.0151458625,
-0.0193084851,
-0.0327462628,
-0.0367168523,
0.0351870097,
0.034530554,
0.0047715022,
0.0320562087,
-0.0094203679,
-0.0280393418,
-0.0237466916,
0.0437315702,
-0.0054437164,
0.0207650829,
0.0278693326,
0.058818724,
-0.0210068505,
0.0301938932,
0.0072848951,
0.012626051,
-0.0305123907,
-0.0601036698,
0.0428788364,
0.045435749,
-0.0067937593,
0.04546744,
0.0251716841,
-0.0289298184,
0.0128787598,
-0.0046435269,
-0.0270616598,
0.0279858001,
0.0257818885,
-0.0617516339,
-0.0110586183,
-0.0057492112,
-0.0245932136,
0.0288250465,
-0.0207389873,
-0.0023900836,
0.0315461233,
-0.003016161,
0.0348606519,
-0.0157112479,
0.0222018156,
2.000715262e-34,
0.0149127329,
0.0153824473,
-0.0480910093,
0.0022136737,
0.0049970234,
-0.0010362791,
-0.0520199426,
0.0264690518,
0.0191189274,
-0.0296873432,
0.0559662357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01319v1
|
Approaches to Corpus Creation for Low-Resource Language Technology: the Case of Southern Kurdish and Laki
| 2023-04-03T19:36:32 | 2023-04-03T19:36:32 |
Sina Ahmadi, Zahra Azin, Sara Belelli, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
One of the major challenges that under-represented and endangered language
communities face in language technology is the lack or paucity of language
data. This is also the case of the Southern varieties of the Kurdish and Laki
languages for which very limited resources are available with insubstantial
progress in tools. To tackle this, we provide a few approaches that rely on the
content of local news websites, a local radio station that broadcasts content
in Southern Kurdish and fieldwork for Laki. In this paper, we describe some of
the challenges of such under-represented languages, particularly in writing and
standardization, and also, in retrieving sources of data and retro-digitizing
handwritten content to create a corpus for Southern Kurdish and Laki. In
addition, we study the task of language identification in light of the other
variants of Kurdish and Zaza-Gorani languages.
|
[
0.0536856651,
0.0240553971,
-0.0316544771,
0.0006969165,
-0.0352794901,
0.0551695712,
0.0419461355,
0.0262542237,
0.0041964012,
-0.00640568,
0.0408989899,
-0.0376812331,
0.0874910206,
-0.0462666489,
-0.0055955043,
-0.0465150848,
-0.0149634425,
-0.0497924127,
0.0294653103,
0.0175244398,
0.0356368609,
0.0381058566,
-0.0299262218,
-0.0123951677,
-0.0654003918,
0.0295927692,
-0.0258789193,
-0.0199964251,
-0.0092785824,
-0.0138812335,
-0.0375631377,
0.0268439762,
-0.0142846182,
0.0711036772,
0.0000014927,
-0.0319685005,
-0.0216062926,
-0.0518069789,
-0.0088391555,
-0.0507415868,
0.0664577931,
-0.0463184305,
-0.0574781261,
-0.0088038491,
0.0042968765,
-0.0246667378,
0.0868157819,
-0.0284557641,
0.0420996249,
0.0329898,
0.0036335706,
-0.0489298515,
-0.0076786228,
0.069106102,
-0.0108766649,
0.0532626435,
-0.0049193245,
-0.0456440076,
0.0367158651,
-0.0328346044,
0.0348931737,
0.0689954981,
-0.0296110194,
-0.0487463996,
-0.0481578,
-0.0205643512,
-0.0714699626,
-0.0792294964,
0.0624875017,
-0.0082331765,
0.0181508809,
-0.0833902657,
0.0253968257,
0.050417006,
-0.0260851234,
0.0223888475,
-0.036014121,
0.0198893826,
-0.0658965185,
-0.0072114714,
0.0463808477,
0.0148200626,
0.0020892099,
-0.019567024,
0.0039595757,
0.0388234481,
0.0652602762,
-0.0147393141,
0.0048535522,
0.0345193073,
0.0252732765,
-0.0123544717,
0.0452981964,
0.0192438513,
-0.0061847176,
0.0065932544,
-0.0119233327,
-0.0844809338,
-0.0227960367,
-0.0050340141,
0.0097990725,
0.0090823332,
-0.0017383378,
0.0071203834,
-0.0352998786,
-0.0276593678,
0.051472418,
-0.0373615287,
-0.0427951403,
0.0087472945,
-0.0351296589,
-0.0149218319,
-0.0620492734,
-0.0014151424,
-0.000268907,
0.0315112919,
-0.0006989986,
0.0182089563,
0.0419153646,
0.0517991483,
-0.0096696168,
-0.0645312592,
-0.0462597869,
0.0096464129,
0.0301823542,
-0.0190017056,
-0.0103120981,
0.0322281905,
-0.0798957571,
-0.0798078328,
0.0425248183,
0.0669343024,
0.0331037268,
0.021562703,
-0.0459898338,
-0.0395520739,
-0.0380790643,
-0.0268595628,
-0.0556687824,
0.0440452583,
-0.0152368182,
-0.0044396296,
-0.0158081632,
-0.0589230917,
0.0350082181,
0.0490244664,
-0.0122498497,
-0.050635837,
-0.0139832702,
-0.0130463094,
0.0393884145,
0.0634135157,
0.0010604522,
0.0390189439,
0.0862126425,
-0.010503429,
0.069393605,
0.0464337021,
0.0272041988,
0.0047698193,
0.0461073183,
-0.0023440465,
0.0040691351,
0.0218503531,
-0.0223352592,
0.045603089,
-0.0237665419,
0.0033234903,
0.0099417502,
0.0329486057,
-0.0113437958,
0.0496620201,
0.0282543302,
0.0408763587,
0.0528443493,
0.0990750939,
0.0044530961,
-0.0126274079,
0.0014299557,
0.0317583829,
0.0084707281,
-0.0115296124,
0.0862365589,
-0.0480060764,
0.0275698118,
0.0007185973,
-0.0085068904,
0.0372847915,
-0.0207082517,
0.0042546638,
-0.0360608287,
-0.0359494053,
0.0314370878,
-0.0460155867,
0.0765449181,
-0.0129086487,
0.0298942067,
0.0227406267,
0.0518850796,
-0.0064692926,
0.0282017794,
-0.0435790047,
0.0143624498,
-0.0198010635,
0.0276901834,
-0.0485306121,
0.0790160447,
0.0070749391,
0.0193680171,
0.0804476887,
-0.0010459938,
-0.0685827807,
-0.0004227764,
-0.0135211749,
0.023922069,
0.0768722817,
0.0079357736,
0.0146181015,
-0.0087176422,
0.0682099611,
0.0371951684,
-0.0365803577,
0.0047828523,
-0.0020719252,
-0.0350619815,
0.0107316878,
-0.0125385411,
0.0275680162,
-0.0167799555,
0.0509092733,
-0.0062302682,
0.0208090488,
0.0116459606,
-0.0229063015,
0.0616181381,
0.0503674187,
0.0374493748,
0.0319019631,
0.0228052028,
-0.0260491725,
0.0091241086,
0.0427970439,
0.0480807647,
-0.0399161503,
0.098016873,
-0.0240267143,
0.0391045734,
0.0112342453,
0.0657515973,
-0.0168586131,
-0.0369039662,
-0.0173006672,
0.0338923857,
0.0267246813,
-0.0210836735,
0.0091941422,
-0.0637851879,
0.0272809304,
-0.0267376211,
0.0017610667,
0.0543792732,
-0.0223205034,
0.0157473721,
-0.0017852918,
-0.040939007,
-0.0112134302,
-0.0355146565,
-0.024721235,
-0.0841591135,
-0.0375407524,
0.0439749956,
-0.0309397951,
0.0370572731,
-0.0140075469,
-0.0158131998,
-0.0042401501,
-0.002444912,
0.0600338839,
-0.0116025303,
-0.0073638968,
-0.0013822225,
0.0301005747,
-0.0110892598,
-0.0055055157,
0.0380027741,
0.0148688219,
0.0254268982,
-0.1150619686,
-0.0567002334,
-0.0236550942,
-0.0431958959,
0.0076890867,
0.0184818376,
-0.0245705396,
0.024157593,
-0.0353631191,
-0.0308047775,
0.006134449,
-0.0580623224,
-0.0054976637,
0.0216315854,
-0.0271431096,
-0.0147301406,
-0.0374136604,
-0.0168769863,
0.0100948308,
-0.0235772766,
-0.0111756399,
-0.0100103756,
0.0089569706,
0.0165454112,
0.0086914478,
-0.015414075,
0.0000635104,
-0.0716115385,
0.0333377607,
0.0067419768,
-0.0068507134,
-0.0042963196,
0.0654705986,
-0.0009606788,
0.0032789104,
0.0224098675,
-0.0109903086,
0.0101938676,
-0.0200528111,
-0.0261173937,
-0.0410435833,
0.018028101,
-0.012445827,
0.0096462034,
-0.0298896562,
-0.0423862711,
-0.0400493778,
0.0357670411,
0.034336254,
0.0000468152,
0.0102103874,
-0.0854485333,
0.0647278056,
-0.0217065606,
-0.0267971791,
-0.0000413381,
0.0052381367,
0.0137589294,
-0.0370456055,
0.0283949394,
0.0372265056,
0.0214963481,
0.0576357357,
0.0214095246,
0.0459800363,
0.0408204757,
0.0543492623,
-0.0137561727,
0.0919748917,
-0.0358833186,
-0.0253528431,
0.0148853688,
0.0434209295,
0.0104905469,
0.0051118713,
0.0316448025,
0.0137515385,
0.0006496241,
0.0038569733,
0.0374961384,
-0.0372901857,
-0.0469647497,
-0.0443149321,
-0.0021718985,
-0.0059601995,
0.0056281481,
0.0464227274,
0.0141601339,
-0.0373371765,
0.0037095342,
-0.006533592,
-0.0253153685,
-0.0022741205,
0.0056573329,
-0.0723037273,
0.0461563505,
0.0284837056,
0.0411881879,
-0.0188547987,
-0.0181324184,
0.0194569118,
-0.0729113892,
-0.0545309335,
0.0299301147,
-0.0107350256,
-0.019451635,
-0.0637316927,
0.013004032,
0.0173158199,
-0.0797290429,
0.0226886012,
0.0033076575,
0.0090994081,
0.0347657837,
-0.0457733646,
-0.0963057354,
-0.0461938493,
0.0182364825,
0.027768936,
-0.0078906314,
0.0212644879,
-0.0571814477,
0.0212606341,
-0.0011517875,
-0.0283627324,
-0.0298803002,
-0.010048585,
-0.0402695276,
0.0291317087,
-0.0388631746,
-0.0420072153,
0.010168694,
-0.0063109943,
-0.0075852317,
-0.0257743075,
0.0035404661,
0.0052346839,
0.0123080024,
0.086597003,
-0.0261789635,
0.0718343109,
-0.0275794342,
-0.0045228233,
0.0058691707,
0.0094636232,
-0.0287312586,
-0.0176507793,
-0.0148486067,
-0.04295782,
0.0247548185,
0.0197302029,
-0.0664129481,
-0.0981590748,
-0.0455302522,
0.0336345062,
0.0261454675,
0.0345283672,
0.0248234496,
0.0255758371,
-0.0213957746,
-0.0598234236,
-0.0160471499,
0.0114154834,
-0.01866428,
-0.050324291,
-0.0381435081,
-0.0142413946,
-0.0443938449,
0.034360785,
-0.0242214575,
-0.0724463314,
-0.0527562909,
0.0868044123,
0.0137960855,
0.0289277099,
-0.0367795825,
-0.0032137039,
-0.0442097858,
0.0253766645,
-0.0043721134,
0.0008221106,
0.0116881421,
-0.0467629172,
-0.0300472789,
-0.0158147439,
0.0567473806,
-0.0020389778,
0.0262621772,
0.0319062024,
-0.0699323118,
-0.0634594485,
-0.0188152641,
-0.0363424048,
0.0104205292,
-0.0157367606,
-0.0458373949,
0.0022605003,
-0.0300678257,
-0.0262716245,
0.0093410946,
0.0092968773,
0.0095704868,
0.0070638931,
0.0184624977,
0.0371115431,
-0.0208307523,
0.0153921396,
0.0082863383,
0.0569996573,
-0.0410280935,
0.0294502079,
0.0098089837,
0.0608505458,
0.0195875037,
0.0247717146,
-0.0158914402,
0.0789692327,
-0.0653490722,
0.0441915728,
-0.0095973304,
-0.0268657021,
-0.018165458,
-0.015530427,
0.0359706655,
0.0413700901,
0.0263589583,
-0.0232462641,
-0.0243140403,
0.007624703,
0.0341053084,
-0.0301215276,
0.0568394735,
-0.0018356548,
-0.0168502573,
-0.0175558254,
0.0446482003,
0.0018042633,
-0.0465591773,
-0.0313131437,
-0.016614072,
-0.0264512394,
0.0440831743,
0.0292087775,
-0.0334699489,
0.000553861,
0.0501323193,
0.0208694581,
0.0023770041,
-0.0256521925,
-0.0144311609,
-0.0267326534,
-0.0512832254,
-0.0066182339,
-0.0528459512,
-0.0527392402,
-0.025307348,
0.0105850138,
-0.0176735613,
-0.0137118008,
0.0005616313,
-0.0051980508,
0.0456862077,
0.07329873,
-0.0310533363,
0.0193569288,
-0.0698542297,
-0.0143066067,
0.034798868,
-4.931016233e-33,
-0.0380142815,
0.0012569599,
-0.005955427,
-0.0292378403,
0.0172188897,
-0.032382708,
-0.0148937544,
0.0312332641,
-0.0241541639,
-0.0329429731,
-0.0426845923,
0.0011456558,
0.0273422468,
-0.0183868743,
0.0474237502,
0.0263700448,
0.0014860176,
-0.0059265238,
-0.0280192699,
-0.0013886673,
0.0926127657,
-0.0434807055,
0.1073075458,
-0.0661634579,
0.0134518296,
-0.0335653983,
-0.0165069643,
0.0038487175,
0.051001288,
0.0171487685,
-0.0252136849,
0.0389870554,
0.007140215,
0.0030631965,
0.0069282413,
0.0365849584,
-0.0161364134,
0.0134552857,
-0.0259610061,
0.0807072222,
0.0236921832,
-0.0279363468,
-0.0441093259,
-0.0303833466,
-0.0385480784,
0.0721517503,
-0.0113695776,
-0.036842797,
0.0025609781,
-0.008851354,
-0.0584677532,
0.0323956683,
0.0084453849,
0.0027509672,
0.0536839552,
0.010039838,
-0.009418264,
-0.0243027676,
-0.0781593695,
0.0231735967,
-0.029048888,
0.0446734428,
0.0550760739,
-0.0240723286,
-0.054809384,
-0.009167552,
-0.0363255776,
-0.0353698321,
0.0401899256,
0.0041039949,
-0.0101027414,
-0.0392991565,
-0.012469966,
0.0607749745,
0.0167290177,
-0.1018856168,
0.0055686892,
-0.0204510894,
0.0243392866,
0.0331072733,
-0.0453496687,
-0.0192160252,
-0.0221587978,
-0.0413809754,
-0.0136248069,
-0.0396165513,
-0.0046619466,
-0.0076284553,
-0.0063894,
-0.0127499178,
-0.0155800814,
0.0339740627,
-0.0038105827,
0.0326047428,
0.0157274082,
-0.0354125611,
-0.0118857762,
0.0539995767,
-0.0298092794,
0.0188134946,
-0.0257183872,
-0.0187726822,
-0.0014283921,
0.0054915664,
0.0326373689,
0.0322135836,
-0.0005675951,
0.0583087504,
-0.0275046155,
0.0313801952,
-0.0043436196,
0.0045493692,
0.0415289439,
0.0616233349,
0.0367305242,
0.0036356212,
0.0487720445,
-0.0218931846,
0.0651191995,
-0.0473595262,
0.0295357388,
-0.0208108108,
-0.0139118005,
-0.0506012253,
-0.0295470953,
0.0304562487,
-0.0352384374,
0.0196919478,
0.0395306386,
0.03089316,
0.0365249813,
-0.0156806782,
2.402e-7,
0.0336431414,
0.0209576804,
0.0546049178,
0.0166618396,
0.0291757304,
-0.0342452154,
0.0050132745,
0.0271125715,
-0.0348782167,
0.0194958579,
0.0009746003,
-0.0050758277,
0.089193888,
0.0074493918,
-0.073788248,
-0.0069090333,
-0.0179022476,
0.0330550075,
-0.0671087652,
0.0189601891,
-0.0099293794,
0.0475112274,
-0.0197964832,
-0.0195723791,
-0.0542387329,
-0.0152041065,
0.0448026545,
-0.0255684778,
-0.0096251518,
0.0128445486,
0.0313495435,
-0.0403805822,
-0.0003007326,
-0.0085952217,
-0.0259031858,
-0.0190734603,
0.0281231869,
0.0390878953,
-0.0106443111,
0.0352702215,
0.0112099098,
-0.0289699137,
-0.0291198622,
-0.0170137919,
0.0503363647,
0.0643071085,
0.0083186366,
-0.0177256931,
0.010493625,
-0.0281789768,
-0.0581045151,
-0.0231342167,
0.0012547214,
0.0346773975,
0.023443494,
-0.0192736462,
0.0020637622,
-0.0000416826,
-0.0303728282,
-0.010440018,
0.0248189829,
-0.0624563806,
0.0090408018,
-0.0063008587,
0.0297508426,
-0.0250050053,
0.0233215112,
1.476709383e-34,
-0.0114280181,
0.0454812124,
-0.0364204198,
0.0049460144,
-0.0228736326,
-0.0207621101,
-0.0375305191,
0.0202841442,
0.0251720008,
-0.0114161354,
0.0058737844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01295v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01295v4
|
Efficiently Aligned Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning for Conversational Tasks using Prompt-Tuning
| 2023-04-03T18:46:01 | 2024-01-27T03:47:55 |
Lifu Tu, Jin Qu, Semih Yavuz, Shafiq Joty, Wenhao Liu, Caiming Xiong, Yingbo Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cross-lingual transfer of language models trained on high-resource languages
like English has been widely studied for many NLP tasks, but focus on
conversational tasks has been rather limited. This is partly due to the high
cost of obtaining non-English conversational data, which results in limited
coverage. In this work, we introduce XSGD for cross-lingual alignment
pretraining, a parallel and large-scale multilingual conversation dataset that
we created by translating the English-only Schema-Guided Dialogue (SGD) dataset
(Rastogi et al., 2020) into 105 other languages. XSGD contains approximately
330k utterances per language. To facilitate aligned cross-lingual
representations, we develop an efficient prompt-tuning-based method for
learning alignment prompts. We also investigate two different classifiers:
NLI-based and vanilla classifiers, and test cross-lingual capability enabled by
the aligned prompts. We evaluate our model's cross-lingual generalization
capabilities on two conversation tasks: slot-filling and intent classification.
Our results demonstrate the strong and efficient modeling ability of NLI-based
classifiers and the large cross-lingual transfer improvements achieved by our
aligned prompts, particularly in few-shot settings. In addition, we highlight
the nice results of our approach compared to LLMs such as text-davinci-003 and
ChatGPT in both zero-shot and few-shot settings. While LLMs exhibit impressive
performance in English, their cross-lingual capabilities in other languages,
particularly low-resource languages, are limited.
|
[
-0.0024255577,
0.0347790644,
0.0073508108,
0.0452702194,
-0.0298192669,
0.0088533266,
0.0141686061,
-0.0394026488,
0.0212896056,
-0.0098772831,
-0.0796644092,
-0.0381527618,
0.0060519949,
-0.0187995303,
-0.0130990176,
-0.0207906198,
0.0723046884,
-0.0129365185,
-0.0075888843,
0.0132722771,
0.002750505,
0.0133679397,
-0.0378759652,
0.0162391495,
-0.0049602725,
-0.0305811893,
-0.029059466,
0.0001984498,
0.0200074837,
-0.0002575367,
0.0124016209,
0.0533592217,
0.0133885099,
0.032974083,
0.0000019079,
-0.0566587597,
-0.0081920484,
-0.0432716943,
-0.0432404093,
-0.0147059103,
-0.0069069234,
-0.0464134179,
-0.0101727461,
0.0031033363,
-0.0282747112,
-0.0231791344,
0.0849052519,
0.038657248,
0.0457198136,
0.1062965393,
-0.0157162324,
-0.0082725342,
0.0247334968,
-0.0410962328,
0.0275025815,
-0.065115802,
-0.008203947,
0.0325449891,
-0.0393952131,
0.0337352194,
-0.0199283343,
0.0425116122,
-0.005549219,
-0.0156207671,
0.0055348068,
-0.0032483509,
-0.0370952748,
-0.0085916026,
-0.037898127,
0.105309397,
0.0095791109,
-0.0046775644,
-0.0285799801,
-0.0205196943,
0.0066635297,
-0.0322697535,
-0.0483047217,
0.0167571604,
0.0270481054,
0.0256472826,
0.0360773727,
0.0165615287,
0.0083775101,
-0.0146604721,
0.0085750725,
0.0390584916,
0.0110263769,
-0.0192502216,
0.0254837945,
0.0088330908,
0.0283128694,
-0.0661671162,
-0.024279315,
0.0207771845,
-0.0854185894,
0.0228719898,
-0.0490775891,
-0.0075723664,
0.0265495405,
-0.0137353716,
0.0264122523,
0.0788333043,
-0.027462054,
0.0682352856,
0.0086081112,
0.0741710216,
-0.020703759,
0.025901597,
-0.0485139154,
-0.0373629667,
-0.0618546642,
0.0056485818,
-0.0284717605,
0.0041251518,
-0.0458445363,
-0.0375301614,
-0.0382450335,
0.0237534512,
0.0101641128,
0.0161587317,
0.0257881787,
-0.0258329231,
-0.0340515785,
0.0118003981,
-0.019149309,
0.0861098468,
-0.0029377749,
-0.0010000599,
-0.0089147706,
-0.0440232381,
-0.0460331663,
0.0387657583,
0.0018959675,
-0.0686142221,
-0.0036971525,
0.0457929783,
-0.0383201912,
-0.0206483025,
-0.0164035521,
0.0227587186,
-0.0292467624,
-0.079870142,
-0.0301013459,
-0.0425145812,
0.0752723217,
0.0042831907,
0.0085019404,
-0.0141866673,
0.0010707643,
0.0056302063,
-0.0122736301,
0.0882610232,
0.0078010908,
0.017659273,
-0.000862342,
-0.0293622538,
-0.0325729847,
0.0849471241,
-0.0009154871,
0.0094150063,
0.0472640917,
-0.0233518276,
-0.0262228828,
0.0474422537,
0.0188100617,
0.0111639863,
0.0330384523,
0.0275826398,
0.0798635483,
0.0301262811,
0.0343535729,
0.0030965661,
-0.0039841682,
-0.001741762,
0.0427590795,
0.0206352044,
0.0029772823,
0.0027870082,
0.0423333645,
0.0408643857,
-0.0348714925,
0.0223883409,
-0.0486075655,
0.0322635435,
-0.0059072562,
-0.003710205,
0.022933498,
0.0108565493,
-0.0406275354,
-0.0217032079,
0.0358266681,
-0.0205444936,
0.0193168446,
0.0021120687,
0.0215432663,
0.0019876712,
-0.0426199436,
0.0968447253,
0.058825884,
-0.056035731,
-0.0083934143,
0.0038440966,
0.0157370809,
0.044524435,
-0.0146162091,
-0.0435130484,
-0.0654953867,
-0.0131460372,
0.0403815247,
0.0314535014,
0.0810180455,
-0.0109593943,
0.0585032627,
-0.0468949229,
-0.0186472628,
-0.0343629383,
-0.0208231062,
0.0427694656,
-0.0058837268,
0.050212808,
0.0069021014,
-0.0063775619,
-0.0138117988,
0.0129891587,
-0.0575707965,
-0.0467155166,
0.0346709117,
0.040065378,
0.021967344,
0.0167063121,
0.0002513433,
-0.0382467993,
-0.0027268801,
-0.0350826979,
0.0171607472,
0.0155075993,
-0.049192965,
-0.0621963181,
0.0321545526,
0.0037894642,
-0.0395575687,
-0.0124609107,
-0.0535007529,
-0.066688329,
-0.0108189471,
-0.0000981558,
0.003584475,
-0.054010693,
0.0189170111,
0.0231332611,
0.0516648069,
-0.0174628738,
0.0385902971,
0.0444991887,
0.0125321141,
0.0519527607,
-0.0078060939,
0.0509125516,
-0.0483956672,
0.0060087838,
0.0330273472,
-0.0340911113,
-0.0035403939,
0.0337131433,
0.0269006118,
-0.0440000556,
-0.0139125278,
-0.1235372722,
0.0588423349,
-0.0096473666,
0.025352167,
0.0178190731,
0.0346530527,
-0.0000599156,
-0.0117935268,
-0.0903868228,
0.0087025575,
0.0347019546,
-0.0021409318,
0.0596681163,
0.0056587295,
0.0028376943,
-0.0394967236,
0.0304672923,
0.0101717394,
0.0073268227,
-0.0464825407,
-0.02714088,
-0.0433083549,
0.0159817245,
-0.0208327901,
0.0174013563,
-0.0046226848,
-0.0412093773,
-0.0111792302,
0.0140070887,
-0.0022783922,
0.0639918745,
-0.003189055,
-0.0321778879,
-0.0104275336,
-0.038024269,
-0.0569597259,
0.045893997,
0.0157471579,
-0.0197646338,
-0.0532907061,
0.002400168,
0.0299972352,
0.0576021113,
-0.0038181366,
0.0108550191,
-0.0756507516,
-0.0266404971,
0.0247717593,
-0.0119477902,
-0.0248170942,
0.0428505838,
-0.0066894069,
0.0314055309,
-0.0321588106,
-0.0298644137,
0.0456415787,
-0.0494198166,
-0.014282479,
-0.0449192934,
-0.0228043217,
-0.0486906655,
0.0472443663,
-0.0371589325,
0.032193929,
0.0293438267,
-0.0469216406,
-0.0397669226,
-0.0215813946,
0.0161389951,
0.0067932135,
0.0241706632,
-0.0161460061,
0.0016290392,
-0.0372500718,
-0.0690748841,
-0.0504629612,
-0.0559201986,
-0.0073865652,
0.0128854383,
-0.0133621534,
-0.021224007,
-0.0506705195,
-0.0124307526,
0.0055904868,
0.0159993116,
-0.0171491764,
0.0299831629,
-0.0266530383,
0.0531043448,
0.0281910952,
0.0342351981,
-0.0392488316,
0.0041293772,
0.0682988241,
0.0199902728,
-0.0069379876,
0.0106554581,
0.0138926757,
0.007757612,
0.0452184081,
-0.0267186221,
-0.0337169282,
-0.0256480426,
0.1022804528,
0.0010708027,
-0.0029844921,
0.0990679711,
0.0113320835,
-0.0210481528,
-0.0338594355,
-0.0004512737,
0.010003238,
0.0144257825,
0.0350121297,
-0.1083062962,
-0.06246626,
0.0015358152,
-0.0267352648,
0.0121952472,
-0.0012659905,
-0.0306306202,
-0.1393046975,
0.020482637,
0.0180835184,
-0.1057794243,
-0.0123733571,
-0.0226926431,
0.0139740659,
-0.0260399971,
0.0451588146,
-0.0232315995,
0.0075399326,
-0.0245089699,
-0.0063265003,
0.0153640267,
-0.0225989204,
0.0267751105,
-0.0401776806,
0.0645226017,
0.0212744046,
0.0531027615,
0.0189191997,
-0.0236248784,
0.0298657566,
-0.0095968423,
-0.0185395516,
0.0030513462,
0.0386167243,
-0.0233757626,
-0.0341747068,
0.0457710475,
0.0293689836,
-0.0230191518,
-0.0202203635,
0.0286254119,
0.0678269342,
0.0149850426,
0.0390095226,
0.0299758036,
0.008455202,
0.0604820997,
0.0919777825,
0.0110903103,
-0.0278494842,
-0.0225947816,
-0.0019045629,
-0.0109695233,
-0.0241867509,
0.0047927825,
0.029496789,
-0.0161698163,
-0.016745992,
-0.0446314104,
-0.0630782992,
0.0259873252,
0.0004288851,
0.0223013572,
-0.0004952331,
-0.032395944,
0.0039295875,
-0.0003527989,
0.0321919881,
-0.0502572209,
0.0210404005,
-0.046767395,
-0.0204044022,
0.0240142792,
-0.0500719808,
0.010614506,
0.006249222,
-0.0678519756,
-0.0579885952,
-0.0672470927,
0.0540630855,
0.0081108175,
0.0821447447,
-0.0256299023,
0.0104499971,
-0.0155550893,
0.0288006254,
-0.0275623221,
-0.0144508416,
0.0467142351,
0.0378598645,
-0.0000280663,
0.0574079826,
-0.0112909805,
0.0077419388,
0.0287559889,
0.0286551956,
-0.0317662694,
-0.0789888054,
0.0121417921,
0.020895429,
0.0213697236,
0.0090613328,
-0.023604583,
-0.0283056628,
0.0417371206,
-0.013746486,
-0.030675089,
-0.0364710614,
-0.0446836725,
0.0360232107,
-0.0574840158,
0.0158166215,
-0.0154976845,
-0.0379512012,
0.0121273324,
-0.0583672188,
-0.003979736,
0.0273169242,
-0.0163322911,
-0.0069942134,
0.0152557325,
-0.0275323894,
0.006486096,
0.0536172017,
0.0456498303,
-0.0294217188,
0.0583981387,
0.006392715,
0.0026399512,
0.0233576782,
0.0141346632,
-0.0338697657,
-0.0502146184,
0.0033717374,
0.0258494988,
0.0565684997,
-0.0432352833,
0.0437181033,
0.0113207567,
-0.0023333475,
-0.0198347177,
0.0698973164,
0.0021527302,
0.0042091343,
0.0408290103,
-0.008006311,
-0.0273117442,
0.012151517,
0.0582399666,
-0.0404265337,
0.0059139393,
0.0234572552,
0.0226410571,
-0.0493373796,
-0.024215376,
0.0424213447,
-0.0022667823,
-0.0221892539,
0.0194064043,
-0.0053849504,
-0.0371060558,
-0.0064179441,
-0.0268394314,
-0.0269798636,
0.0229339451,
-0.0027313677,
0.0721499398,
-0.0246134065,
-0.0028041748,
-0.0256075896,
-0.0107198618,
-0.0091012698,
-0.0123979961,
-0.0419668257,
-5.855509479e-33,
-0.0194723755,
0.0460559763,
0.0262926985,
0.0152116949,
-0.0414725058,
-0.0124840057,
-0.026771741,
-0.0158908814,
-0.0285781231,
-0.0051538413,
-0.0130847506,
-0.0127041265,
0.0272061564,
0.0551796295,
0.0009127829,
-0.0337136798,
0.0182541031,
0.0196954999,
-0.032758411,
0.0344458893,
0.0418684334,
0.0256940033,
0.0886246711,
-0.0429566056,
0.0205265917,
0.0244020987,
-0.0001830161,
0.0447391532,
0.0411984883,
0.0382547602,
-0.0009689622,
0.0241655838,
0.0186604429,
-0.0623619594,
0.0134841725,
0.0736802369,
-0.0726131722,
-0.0364641659,
0.047464814,
0.0320670269,
0.0140755605,
-0.0506011434,
-0.0276176557,
-0.0500663668,
0.0193176921,
-0.0128088929,
0.0076952055,
-0.0281718913,
-0.0042967917,
0.0195093844,
-0.0798368976,
0.005398415,
-0.0348855518,
-0.0549351424,
0.0180403609,
0.0879610702,
0.0155002419,
0.0067760032,
-0.0450436436,
0.0216352865,
-0.0537904613,
0.0255626459,
0.0350886434,
0.0025041455,
-0.0227875914,
0.0444565117,
0.0372377783,
-0.0058887936,
0.0374530591,
0.0136399735,
-0.027208928,
0.0367119983,
-0.0125604803,
0.0578125902,
0.0181300323,
-0.011701596,
-0.069991909,
0.0306449626,
0.0337559618,
0.0093610715,
-0.0167798921,
0.0108212391,
-0.0214435216,
-0.0137889562,
-0.0310394932,
-0.0300809238,
-0.0216174703,
-0.0329861306,
0.017031284,
-0.0135976532,
-0.0091030747,
-0.0252649672,
0.0758590773,
-0.0397398397,
-0.0158953834,
0.0397428833,
-0.0122863753,
-0.0123836184,
-0.0225881953,
-0.0005757103,
-0.0420074575,
-0.0753495842,
0.0063678725,
0.0118826237,
0.0424364731,
0.0268984474,
0.0568156503,
0.001338884,
-0.052044753,
0.006355545,
-0.0461957641,
0.0415492766,
-0.0541961715,
0.0825123563,
0.0243332069,
0.010691789,
-0.0314772204,
0.0690641254,
0.0120206615,
-0.0089474814,
-0.0112865418,
-0.0770345256,
-0.0013056827,
0.0161760636,
-0.0284125544,
0.0222058203,
-0.0117318342,
-0.0084925517,
-0.0080589391,
-0.0473783053,
-0.001637055,
-0.0113543337,
2.679e-7,
0.00713589,
0.0041522747,
0.0004850912,
0.0423055105,
-0.0121461526,
0.0437830389,
-0.0366297252,
0.0368018411,
0.0118981125,
-0.0373696052,
0.0315262899,
0.0323120691,
0.0735617727,
0.0131636402,
-0.1044400409,
0.0057652141,
-0.0538258292,
0.0059627984,
-0.0452185944,
0.0320996679,
0.0312813371,
0.1108300388,
-0.0072351992,
-0.0017476276,
0.0083036898,
-0.0304602534,
0.0514473692,
-0.0552798733,
-0.0448222831,
0.0333327129,
0.0093194135,
0.0024589752,
-0.0140738497,
0.0328103863,
-0.0343942828,
0.045699846,
-0.0035750216,
0.0625550151,
0.0130613213,
-0.04508074,
-0.0255405735,
0.0044661816,
-0.0042660688,
-0.0454606526,
0.0685755387,
-0.0345681682,
-0.025985714,
-0.0416170768,
-0.0215576533,
0.0092446888,
0.0683487505,
-0.0167751107,
-0.0062506911,
0.0355420783,
0.0489184335,
-0.003324535,
-0.0376395546,
-0.0231493097,
-0.0311297979,
0.0050163148,
-0.0075688865,
-0.0254131109,
0.0114113055,
-0.032984823,
0.0007900412,
-0.0348292328,
0.0267271195,
1.998294938e-34,
0.0272798911,
-0.0043805665,
0.0317293517,
0.030985225,
0.0279967263,
-0.0260085482,
-0.0130873993,
-0.0029042359,
0.0218763985,
-0.035553731,
0.0021710873
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.