id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01282v2 | PEACH: Pre-Training Sequence-to-Sequence Multilingual Models for Translation with Semi-Supervised Pseudo-Parallel Document Generation | 2023-04-03T18:19:26 | 2023-04-14T17:54:58 | Alireza Salemi, Amirhossein Abaskohi, Sara Tavakoli, Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh, Azadeh Shakery | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pre-training significantly improves many multilingual NLP tasks,
including machine translation. Most existing methods are based on some variants
of masked language modeling and text-denoising objectives on monolingual data.
Multilingual pre-training on monolingual data ignores the availability of
parallel data in many language pairs. Also, some other works integrate the
available human-generated parallel translation data in their pre-training. This
kind of parallel data is definitely helpful, but it is limited even in
high-resource language pairs. This paper introduces a novel semi-supervised
method, SPDG, that generates high-quality pseudo-parallel data for multilingual
pre-training. First, a denoising model is pre-trained on monolingual data to
reorder, add, remove, and substitute words, enhancing the pre-training
documents' quality. Then, we generate different pseudo-translations for each
pre-training document using dictionaries for word-by-word translation and
applying the pre-trained denoising model. The resulting pseudo-parallel data is
then used to pre-train our multilingual sequence-to-sequence model, PEACH. Our
experiments show that PEACH outperforms existing approaches used in training
mT5 and mBART on various translation tasks, including supervised, zero- and
few-shot scenarios. Moreover, PEACH's ability to transfer knowledge between
similar languages makes it particularly useful for low-resource languages. Our
results demonstrate that with high-quality dictionaries for generating accurate
pseudo-parallel, PEACH can be valuable for low-resource languages. | [
0.0281276386,
0.0632120892,
0.0309060998,
0.0294353813,
-0.0294772163,
0.0114918118,
0.0331781097,
-0.0051958729,
-0.0087921694,
-0.0447478704,
-0.0538261048,
-0.0485703573,
0.0061317096,
-0.0369980671,
0.0394335985,
-0.0588674098,
0.0266176797,
0.0077488422,
-0.0251470599,
-0.0046577062,
-0.0074455147,
0.0492404252,
0.0162289776,
-0.0195110161,
-0.0223712586,
-0.0221939441,
-0.0126988674,
0.0387333184,
0.0418221988,
-0.0290885437,
0.0061625293,
0.0457735397,
0.0138797434,
0.0364925079,
0.0000020507,
-0.0200348608,
-0.0384795703,
0.017563656,
0.0231387615,
0.0224867743,
0.0346440487,
-0.0691480488,
0.0039692018,
0.0334334485,
-0.0161535628,
-0.055364877,
0.0372142382,
0.0072609531,
0.0822354406,
0.0902468041,
-0.0346374027,
-0.0475793369,
-0.013177814,
-0.0607233122,
-0.0185994618,
-0.0209276211,
-0.0052435156,
0.014876226,
-0.0244894587,
0.0114785051,
0.0172704998,
0.0346943215,
0.024064241,
0.0146128694,
-0.0283104032,
-0.014906697,
0.0061740577,
-0.0758090988,
-0.0138457883,
0.0776363388,
-0.0979337022,
-0.0548099391,
0.013869239,
-0.0063652,
-0.0305884574,
-0.0074724909,
-0.019448163,
0.0205710344,
0.0089264354,
0.0095551834,
0.0393812843,
0.0398422666,
0.0461003222,
-0.0068687703,
-0.0282449145,
-0.0367946699,
0.0263847765,
-0.0373464487,
-0.0137345903,
-0.0032584902,
-0.0055008833,
-0.0330489948,
0.0456414595,
0.0013235062,
-0.004210826,
0.0210909415,
-0.0578221753,
-0.119487375,
0.0204919335,
-0.0757505819,
0.0242243949,
0.0601881109,
-0.0015916084,
0.0196674503,
-0.0432436131,
0.0109183351,
0.0034966683,
-0.0060853194,
-0.0984978303,
-0.0344332792,
-0.0120828394,
0.0559297726,
-0.0441113226,
0.0166407991,
-0.0950680226,
-0.0136304265,
-0.0151419668,
0.0097017186,
0.0216810666,
-0.0074671572,
0.0334360711,
-0.0290150195,
-0.071896106,
-0.0172571037,
0.046550978,
0.0004710357,
-0.0079877377,
-0.0169138256,
0.0017057224,
-0.033490371,
-0.041017741,
0.024260357,
0.030333763,
-0.045831766,
0.0106865857,
0.0604615137,
-0.0361937284,
-0.033752773,
-0.0450600535,
-0.0108829476,
0.0016153642,
-0.063182801,
0.0045355479,
-0.0533386879,
0.060242489,
0.0059683253,
0.0254362337,
-0.049087543,
0.0233801585,
0.009996878,
-0.0147313215,
0.0809193924,
-0.0227063615,
-0.0230630189,
0.0104941139,
0.0160841998,
0.0272541884,
0.0909899846,
0.0145537164,
0.0172236282,
0.0450611971,
-0.0018335818,
-0.0459253192,
0.0543859489,
0.0353466608,
0.036151804,
-0.0164916329,
0.0058317557,
0.0306447931,
0.0115777208,
0.0375317596,
0.0662984699,
-0.0329920612,
0.0066808783,
0.0466846302,
0.0065188971,
0.0168832913,
0.0252309069,
0.083439596,
0.0179459993,
-0.0378223993,
0.0353722423,
0.0027811597,
-0.0019518459,
0.0234685168,
0.0384190455,
0.0442222394,
0.0605600737,
-0.0490673594,
-0.0201765541,
-0.0024135236,
-0.0316292308,
0.0157686714,
0.0057433308,
0.0259146653,
0.055161614,
-0.0737413466,
0.0443205684,
0.0220983718,
-0.0635631606,
0.0285660978,
0.0118597914,
-0.0279515348,
0.0402365662,
0.0216927398,
-0.0083240932,
-0.040201962,
-0.0095193321,
-0.0059404331,
0.0627272502,
0.0548418276,
-0.0047148536,
0.036273703,
-0.0698421299,
-0.0001081003,
-0.0151965944,
-0.0076699266,
0.0636178628,
-0.0113574425,
0.0331237502,
0.0698603913,
-0.0144427614,
-0.0398224406,
0.0272471178,
-0.0644516498,
-0.0383315273,
0.0331488214,
0.004020154,
0.0347516686,
0.0341540053,
-0.0049425582,
0.0070010922,
0.0548032597,
-0.0164188314,
0.0032284628,
0.0175161306,
-0.0568574704,
-0.0909002423,
0.0439840592,
-0.0134226484,
-0.0089423563,
0.0531918108,
-0.046914842,
-0.069480367,
-0.023102168,
0.0202975012,
0.032158982,
-0.0481146201,
0.037048351,
0.0588641316,
0.0296774693,
-0.0223771613,
0.0183757991,
-0.0093046362,
0.0215967838,
0.0243935566,
-0.0143570844,
0.027485108,
-0.0124533921,
-0.0129207084,
0.0571505353,
0.0077021811,
0.0318087004,
0.0218527131,
0.0342920944,
-0.0173901208,
-0.0141065102,
-0.0683785155,
0.0274349172,
-0.0232317131,
0.0283639859,
0.0361216217,
0.0597147942,
0.0209738612,
-0.0235258043,
-0.0270029772,
0.003353443,
0.0326650143,
0.0049653095,
-0.0066001392,
0.0176562387,
0.0359120183,
-0.0227796342,
-0.0100908494,
0.0564236827,
0.0327510089,
-0.0126601402,
-0.0156813916,
-0.0238739662,
0.0267725643,
-0.0409735367,
0.021514168,
0.004437889,
-0.0527744964,
-0.0255032163,
-0.0148606561,
0.04558862,
-0.0035210869,
-0.0164411701,
-0.0099889971,
0.0241621658,
-0.0165103767,
-0.037991792,
0.0097077554,
-0.0140743703,
0.0100040827,
-0.0195113849,
-0.0589578636,
0.000193892,
0.0638007447,
-0.0070777372,
-0.0208919551,
-0.0507298931,
-0.0264897905,
0.0020932655,
-0.0527161472,
0.0033778127,
0.0237648729,
0.0185851585,
0.016776327,
-0.0306291636,
-0.016740635,
0.0361718163,
-0.0524215773,
-0.022498671,
-0.0872494131,
-0.023434164,
-0.0112604415,
0.0448855795,
-0.000597637,
0.0461496823,
-0.0318069942,
0.0188705642,
-0.0469219424,
0.0163606331,
0.004319699,
-0.0015509535,
0.0061362856,
-0.0700660497,
-0.0004905707,
-0.0434966199,
-0.0158859827,
-0.0337448902,
-0.0321800075,
0.021223519,
0.0017564463,
0.0489476882,
-0.0103030214,
-0.0346620381,
0.0251354072,
-0.0180398468,
0.1187174469,
0.0150499744,
0.0090334443,
-0.0040155984,
0.0505586118,
0.0074987854,
-0.0353074297,
-0.0205845162,
-0.0525938831,
0.0283865426,
0.0204115063,
0.0197873823,
-0.0559550375,
-0.0075011738,
-0.0231437124,
0.0280217137,
-0.0230442751,
-0.0282902513,
-0.0113391653,
0.0169676077,
-0.0260617957,
-0.0092610754,
0.1053559259,
0.0218228363,
-0.0371262766,
-0.0107612936,
0.006274295,
0.0304407496,
0.0002254041,
-0.0002630501,
-0.0807858631,
-0.0156869274,
-0.0185306035,
0.0005605157,
0.0282631423,
0.0187353417,
-0.049487967,
-0.1020550206,
-0.0001436664,
0.025670955,
-0.0635584593,
-0.0045971689,
-0.0324966833,
-0.041975759,
-0.015816601,
0.0244917534,
-0.0169246495,
0.0085268132,
0.0153222112,
0.0140801035,
0.0496156402,
-0.0753943101,
-0.037968751,
-0.0249000154,
0.0085374741,
0.0193494111,
0.0350708291,
0.0029595878,
-0.0003214582,
0.0291093867,
-0.0246852748,
-0.0045287861,
-0.0334756076,
0.0275053382,
-0.0277260002,
-0.0121600004,
0.0338586345,
0.0009431639,
-0.0386708379,
0.004811374,
0.0194412097,
0.0298460349,
0.0225231759,
0.0030342233,
0.0018095459,
-0.0082659116,
0.0284423493,
0.045883704,
-0.0003951681,
-0.0535295941,
0.0140382145,
0.0028295224,
0.0145381475,
-0.0852515846,
0.0352755934,
-0.0119824419,
-0.0675474033,
-0.0560606569,
-0.1071896106,
-0.0762745515,
-0.0073409849,
0.0554477833,
0.0224481057,
0.0111554703,
0.0090540173,
-0.0211889111,
-0.0303729214,
0.0103904679,
-0.0025762587,
-0.0204942636,
-0.044428736,
-0.0194091499,
0.0274897553,
-0.0264174957,
0.005717996,
0.0217148326,
-0.0864792615,
-0.065929614,
-0.0269970223,
0.0825135186,
0.0146590378,
0.0603941493,
-0.0034873616,
0.0005922471,
0.0180357713,
0.0326724462,
-0.0491691791,
-0.0257825851,
0.0749890581,
-0.0154569643,
-0.0143261664,
0.0325493328,
-0.0207899939,
0.0267792363,
0.0201387219,
0.0361928791,
-0.0359445997,
-0.0581704639,
0.020441521,
0.0209787749,
0.037168283,
-0.0484819189,
0.0260976758,
-0.0227160044,
0.0223630629,
-0.0299043525,
-0.020196557,
-0.0557342619,
0.0202827826,
0.0680640265,
-0.0039794524,
-0.0110126091,
0.0344877392,
-0.0357960686,
-0.0327916816,
-0.0124026928,
-0.0125165777,
-0.0176548734,
-0.0101248212,
0.0147146201,
0.0275116619,
-0.0213252436,
-0.0165707264,
0.0093698213,
0.0061537796,
-0.0380944274,
0.0261983536,
0.0114955297,
0.033234369,
0.0116880517,
0.0404673889,
-0.0209091827,
0.0083054276,
-0.0511423647,
-0.0243186913,
0.0906630903,
-0.0177920908,
0.1079395562,
-0.0019318711,
-0.0141512882,
-0.0151686752,
0.0503535792,
0.0130907241,
-0.0174728222,
-0.0422450863,
-0.0170918833,
-0.0075686718,
0.0433353372,
0.1140090376,
-0.0041815718,
0.0235822964,
0.0297198985,
0.0153795853,
-0.0546811745,
-0.0266806781,
0.0234237406,
0.0384893678,
-0.0330355801,
-0.025129132,
-0.0070264568,
-0.0766670778,
0.015081876,
0.0033427204,
-0.0082420697,
0.0006420884,
0.0444936529,
0.0290808976,
-0.0310837571,
0.0427559875,
-0.0528216437,
0.0123515362,
0.0129750362,
-0.0418078303,
-0.0097600194,
-6.030905358e-33,
-0.0192080736,
-0.0079860371,
-0.0093847746,
-0.0334262811,
0.0076217321,
-0.0004261241,
-0.0249360073,
-0.01858644,
-0.0031966672,
0.009056313,
-0.014270233,
-0.0074264263,
0.0335718319,
0.0363042578,
-0.0049552163,
0.0448926426,
0.0741436407,
0.0085696159,
-0.0041756458,
0.0227774661,
0.0152000599,
0.0405878238,
0.0668156892,
-0.0343806632,
0.0302123558,
-0.0495020971,
-0.0064650229,
-0.0122594498,
0.0220257919,
-0.0005309221,
0.0109801078,
0.0208384003,
-0.0060766875,
-0.0220547933,
-0.0391884036,
-0.0168240629,
-0.0697466657,
-0.0034672974,
0.025940923,
0.0131415613,
-0.0338642672,
-0.0198923275,
-0.0042678197,
-0.0363079533,
0.0375422724,
0.009286385,
0.034887597,
-0.0225641765,
-0.0520822667,
-0.041493956,
-0.0422342718,
0.0164782424,
-0.0090489108,
-0.041274704,
0.0573948845,
0.0883291289,
-0.0085922647,
-0.0034609053,
-0.0832188874,
-0.0074732443,
-0.0377868004,
0.0288139135,
0.0589866601,
0.0247932859,
-0.0025828448,
-0.0144936312,
0.0225154161,
0.0003247187,
0.0629038215,
0.0287287422,
0.0022908389,
0.0196968354,
0.0449161828,
0.0455967486,
0.0450583063,
-0.0136782322,
-0.0727653503,
0.0607168674,
-0.0315155052,
0.0011698279,
0.010929184,
0.0156174339,
0.0347161666,
-0.0049998681,
-0.0405488536,
-0.0426189713,
-0.0145683791,
-0.0204126295,
0.0134944441,
0.0431069769,
-0.0266956445,
0.0404393822,
0.061844606,
0.0026935753,
-0.0119811567,
0.017111795,
-0.0259959921,
-0.0041645067,
-0.0375455134,
0.0452985466,
-0.0800174996,
-0.0577565022,
0.0153161492,
0.0367629305,
-0.0104955724,
-0.0163167175,
0.0346186124,
0.0037791117,
-0.0482418537,
0.0277210455,
-0.0460620038,
0.0399880372,
-0.0058308267,
0.0431391969,
0.0065413998,
-0.0233337302,
-0.0092228204,
0.0472896807,
0.0450098552,
-0.0390868783,
0.0078165419,
0.0068139429,
0.0193585679,
0.0089877695,
-0.0154003492,
0.0209755413,
-0.0288578235,
-0.00648756,
0.0441264994,
-0.0328178145,
-0.0109396754,
0.005407332,
2.667e-7,
0.0297438148,
0.0187957082,
0.0054119336,
0.023678923,
-0.0056050546,
0.0200899467,
-0.037679594,
0.0438893437,
-0.0033396697,
0.0325825848,
0.0288127828,
-0.0084292591,
0.0662925616,
0.0298490636,
-0.0616577528,
-0.0255654193,
-0.0529767908,
0.0295406636,
-0.045293659,
-0.0000398086,
0.0056372206,
0.0894384608,
-0.0145399449,
0.008520606,
-0.0059403107,
-0.0265996046,
0.0757693648,
-0.0080389176,
-0.0490125492,
0.0143624274,
0.0322896875,
0.0155903371,
-0.0570958592,
-0.0184086598,
-0.084340252,
0.0058399132,
0.0530748256,
0.0872490928,
0.0061315508,
0.0068018525,
0.0536564477,
-0.0159104541,
-0.0414823964,
-0.0227032956,
0.0578330718,
-0.0182803292,
0.0027468377,
0.0243550483,
-0.0305520408,
0.0460847914,
0.0334075466,
-0.048980128,
-0.0449796095,
0.0365026295,
0.0675106794,
0.0038839059,
-0.0435771197,
-0.0168021284,
-0.0462413318,
0.0008643057,
-0.0061767483,
-0.0001725245,
-0.0139748603,
-0.0048393086,
0.0176866483,
-0.0043913242,
-0.003684469,
2.353951315e-34,
0.0585645251,
-0.0319420733,
-0.0153014949,
-0.0211433712,
0.0189521424,
-0.0543716587,
-0.0381398983,
0.0172906741,
-0.008091812,
-0.0261232555,
-0.0316869654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01196v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01196v4 | Baize: An Open-Source Chat Model with Parameter-Efficient Tuning on Self-Chat Data | 2023-04-03T17:59:09 | 2023-12-02T21:05:22 | Canwen Xu, Daya Guo, Nan Duan, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chat models, such as ChatGPT, have shown impressive capabilities and have
been rapidly adopted across numerous domains. However, these models are only
accessible through a restricted API, creating barriers for new research and
progress in the field. We propose a pipeline that can automatically generate a
high-quality multi-turn chat corpus by leveraging ChatGPT to engage in a
conversation with itself. Subsequently, we employ parameter-efficient tuning to
enhance LLaMA, an open-source large language model. The resulting model, named
Baize, demonstrates good performance in multi-turn dialogues with guardrails
that minimize potential risks. Furthermore, we propose a new technique called
Self-Distill with Feedback, to further improve the performance of the Baize
models with feedback from ChatGPT. The Baize models and data are released for
research purposes only at https://github.com/project-baize/baize-chatbot. An
online demo is also available at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/project-baize/chat-with-baize. | [
0.03551035,
0.0443215072,
-0.0157780405,
0.024911778,
-0.0342013016,
0.0093701119,
-0.0017033009,
0.0044467882,
0.0737819374,
-0.029183615,
-0.0643128455,
0.0018317745,
-0.0347390398,
0.069607392,
0.0139716035,
-0.0645769462,
0.0446298011,
-0.0430432074,
0.0083556073,
-0.0106055923,
0.0234952588,
-0.0000187605,
-0.0248673018,
0.0483324565,
-0.0147208329,
-0.0355739146,
-0.0583668202,
0.0241513792,
-0.0195848122,
0.0211638995,
0.012893985,
0.0718827471,
0.0206451621,
0.045675464,
0.0000021134,
-0.0257855654,
-0.0207479782,
-0.0214316938,
-0.0455023535,
-0.0074005723,
0.0500288233,
-0.0002677679,
-0.0281451438,
0.0499747358,
-0.0368218832,
-0.0099098422,
0.0248856712,
0.0362703577,
0.1114655808,
0.0975338668,
0.0062141637,
-0.0154034896,
0.0079757404,
-0.018520277,
-0.0075700153,
-0.0659771785,
-0.0012544632,
0.0230452307,
0.0173837133,
0.0267816801,
-0.0418581553,
0.0242772959,
0.020170046,
-0.0771740973,
0.0065571396,
0.0161756054,
-0.0651436821,
-0.0540833473,
-0.0271978844,
0.0944175348,
-0.0144000631,
-0.0020896904,
0.0256060939,
0.015825646,
0.0409789272,
-0.0208253339,
-0.0722208098,
-0.0042220564,
0.0355549455,
-0.0136394957,
-0.0255276561,
0.0080437716,
-0.0166425798,
-0.010992704,
-0.0135463895,
0.0145449424,
-0.0028675741,
-0.0049216659,
-0.0429706015,
-0.011350953,
0.0036126641,
-0.0861395225,
0.0098357229,
0.0309581347,
-0.0355776586,
0.0099365003,
-0.0406132229,
0.0179529283,
0.0066490592,
-0.0188277494,
-0.0315403454,
0.0440142266,
0.0081872381,
0.048432596,
0.0291538499,
0.0240451191,
0.0002850074,
0.011698273,
-0.0210342333,
-0.0184296519,
-0.0426401384,
0.0018250879,
-0.0513134487,
0.0260591414,
-0.0335797295,
-0.0511337481,
-0.0413052738,
0.0614622571,
0.0076268041,
-0.0063483054,
0.0603749789,
-0.0028121294,
-0.0379026607,
0.0043542432,
0.003550272,
0.0139731802,
-0.0200944487,
-0.0358868055,
0.0503005087,
-0.1013363078,
-0.0422628969,
0.0224663243,
0.002373131,
-0.0307271276,
-0.0162342433,
0.0997119918,
0.0119960345,
-0.0436991155,
0.048389826,
-0.0245664418,
-0.0314362086,
-0.0651019067,
-0.0227769446,
-0.0431501158,
0.0627706498,
-0.0215780213,
0.012747,
-0.0167705752,
-0.0007371136,
0.0145096714,
-0.0160602275,
0.0455690697,
0.0046045654,
0.0287638176,
0.0174768679,
0.0272676013,
-0.0368857868,
0.0866490453,
0.0343274847,
0.0289260596,
0.0471182875,
-0.0131441057,
0.0196114108,
0.0445378236,
0.0215663873,
0.010045412,
0.0531024188,
0.0127807194,
-0.0076303282,
0.0360148922,
0.0186344963,
0.0517979153,
-0.0565666854,
-0.0406031981,
0.0654419512,
0.0279566124,
0.0330234095,
0.0418041311,
0.0150400242,
0.0377504826,
0.0264546704,
0.0218470525,
-0.0423251651,
0.0367856659,
0.0023029211,
-0.0255014747,
0.066906102,
0.0419430882,
-0.0558065735,
-0.0313892812,
0.0272259209,
-0.0247086957,
0.0216071568,
-0.015144038,
0.0263034198,
0.0273504425,
-0.0300870892,
0.0356223546,
0.0364104696,
-0.046251636,
-0.0410946161,
-0.0469105355,
0.0085501429,
0.065494433,
0.0794670284,
-0.0102126151,
-0.0239634421,
-0.0406033881,
0.0025060608,
0.0561385602,
0.061013598,
-0.006681812,
0.0308624692,
-0.0293099098,
-0.01430682,
0.0005459128,
-0.0028264723,
-0.0013457933,
0.0328875631,
-0.00096953,
-0.0214378741,
0.0097203366,
0.0187141281,
0.0052230801,
-0.0326557308,
-0.011429647,
-0.0141261024,
-0.0383057594,
0.0463700108,
0.0156407766,
-0.0166171417,
-0.0085118497,
0.013464259,
0.0028125332,
-0.0359736197,
0.045444265,
-0.068893522,
-0.0740057975,
0.0428456552,
0.0015230384,
-0.0232164226,
0.0360270515,
-0.0466087162,
-0.0385416336,
0.0337501653,
-0.0277088117,
0.0380162969,
-0.02284896,
0.0349899083,
0.015771864,
0.0407034233,
0.0019530309,
-0.002498786,
-0.0015298302,
-0.0168835241,
-0.0229978859,
0.0208443329,
-0.0092651434,
-0.0522759221,
-0.0218583997,
0.0173147805,
-0.0140018882,
0.0142311472,
0.015562891,
0.0283565652,
-0.0479221381,
-0.0416306965,
-0.1013481691,
0.0084243575,
-0.0043142117,
-0.0177281927,
0.0221774355,
0.0436485521,
-0.0247687511,
-0.0071356297,
-0.0241685845,
-0.0038705675,
0.0247453153,
0.0199422091,
0.0311180539,
-0.0114361905,
-0.0297107957,
-0.0595125556,
0.0013908597,
0.0135124484,
0.0184688978,
-0.0072357086,
-0.015323719,
-0.0343280174,
-0.0093789399,
-0.0329052061,
0.0563020557,
-0.0081714299,
-0.0660277233,
0.0135825397,
-0.0208674595,
0.0390878096,
0.0456618629,
0.0416373946,
0.011912805,
-0.0028928418,
-0.0209271312,
-0.0662166849,
0.0314292572,
-0.0487319976,
-0.0176648758,
-0.0015722254,
-0.0082178032,
0.0073383539,
0.0477629825,
0.0070843394,
0.0083921105,
-0.0834545493,
0.0229856651,
0.0133682378,
-0.0316194482,
-0.0004573703,
0.019025784,
-0.0284328349,
0.0026454215,
-0.0130378855,
-0.0499351323,
0.0793291926,
-0.0302383509,
-0.0262131207,
-0.0215150509,
-0.0063497061,
-0.0324240029,
0.0334562697,
-0.0159862246,
0.0073850625,
0.0128831426,
-0.0157420523,
-0.0334425643,
0.0167970173,
0.0392922238,
-0.0498629846,
0.0226088539,
-0.0151566323,
0.0139209284,
0.0134532237,
-0.0661806539,
-0.0406178981,
-0.0533975661,
-0.0081009669,
-0.0050721304,
0.0448019765,
-0.0415687412,
-0.0262171309,
0.0369163528,
-0.0112441555,
0.0327398852,
-0.0210052095,
-0.0091960505,
-0.0203701388,
0.0043931631,
0.0393088534,
0.0178891215,
0.0085492581,
-0.0013102574,
0.0774468035,
0.0699755326,
0.0276727658,
-0.0104352944,
-0.0082423035,
-0.0099883676,
0.0085109668,
-0.0234884154,
-0.0117207784,
-0.0290785041,
0.0671723187,
-0.019837955,
-0.034240596,
0.1201462597,
0.0020936057,
-0.0198146142,
0.0044879196,
-0.041227404,
0.0669128373,
-0.0079369629,
0.038059637,
-0.0727661923,
-0.0339412093,
0.0217970964,
0.017190285,
0.0192354061,
-0.0510797538,
-0.0014079249,
-0.1078018174,
0.0564203672,
0.0054398896,
-0.0135229705,
-0.0308690127,
-0.0340549983,
0.0066465633,
-0.0543486886,
0.0149766924,
0.0193216372,
-0.004113622,
-0.0018108014,
-0.0110280747,
-0.0250924118,
0.0030272927,
0.0411910377,
-0.0219837166,
0.0885880217,
0.0268786419,
0.0537090749,
0.0440950543,
0.0324852988,
0.0326528363,
-0.0086762812,
-0.0196641684,
-0.0053971093,
0.0711107105,
-0.0193686578,
-0.0227152295,
-0.0041906699,
0.0260225423,
-0.0114411283,
0.0053546019,
0.0017872188,
0.0199055001,
-0.0256516673,
-0.0082389852,
-0.0261494257,
0.0357132033,
0.0327455439,
0.0911184624,
0.0270203687,
-0.0321655683,
-0.0391314663,
-0.0350136086,
-0.0337516218,
-0.0198823623,
-0.065111354,
-0.0357379802,
-0.0005065943,
-0.0459579639,
-0.098177053,
-0.0354592726,
0.0102915894,
0.0195995737,
-0.0306443907,
0.0050984686,
0.0051738587,
0.0260977652,
0.0211582091,
-0.0013165933,
-0.061689239,
-0.0087480415,
-0.0464677215,
-0.0111269196,
0.0479512438,
-0.0313149914,
0.0012460443,
0.0451055057,
-0.0984849855,
-0.0725167394,
0.0254983809,
0.0647990182,
0.0271346495,
0.0492044836,
-0.0469127037,
-0.019961074,
0.0127140367,
0.030895263,
-0.040209502,
-0.0029206905,
0.0357789434,
0.0598470345,
0.0040943231,
0.0515586585,
-0.0354304165,
0.0224188343,
-0.053205777,
0.0260596704,
-0.0507944152,
-0.0608783141,
0.003294315,
0.0220546182,
0.02371924,
0.0291997958,
-0.0007368312,
-0.0150000211,
0.0159186497,
-0.0517649092,
-0.0099598495,
-0.0658210367,
0.0328755565,
-0.0070396052,
-0.0527660362,
0.0072898711,
0.0083503099,
-0.0636824816,
0.0065933946,
-0.0195552073,
-0.0253840685,
0.0169718079,
-0.0275678989,
0.0179215576,
-0.0214021076,
0.0097744334,
0.0185775645,
0.0009685762,
0.0055463482,
-0.0124729453,
0.0395022146,
0.0090696253,
-0.0169805549,
0.027187353,
0.0464874133,
-0.0892251208,
-0.0376420394,
-0.0198024251,
0.0592755862,
0.0187991019,
0.0408971682,
0.0890013501,
-0.0163494274,
-0.0013259553,
-0.014041123,
0.0464904234,
-0.0027610844,
-0.0132378694,
0.0159169454,
0.018533377,
-0.0257250201,
-0.0097449031,
0.0799164698,
0.002868684,
0.0549514927,
0.0158378687,
0.014777042,
-0.0500407703,
-0.043779172,
-0.0135958511,
-0.0020001086,
0.0065830438,
-0.0201749336,
-0.021667134,
-0.0543749779,
-0.0213819426,
0.0187433567,
-0.008604425,
0.0029225934,
0.0397907495,
0.0366912708,
-0.0067835036,
0.0130765522,
-0.0647402853,
0.0144354021,
-0.0077754152,
-0.0248702634,
0.0392467119,
-6.842227151e-33,
-0.0187638272,
-0.0097076409,
0.0302805044,
0.0214426164,
-0.035613548,
-0.0478540435,
-0.041089654,
0.0114147225,
-0.0400898419,
-0.0020885211,
-0.0295927413,
0.0489511564,
0.0222534388,
0.0078001316,
-0.0014347603,
-0.0110386331,
0.0430717282,
-0.0334137976,
-0.0325691141,
0.0622841045,
0.0357201286,
0.0237710476,
-0.0016859905,
-0.0611696355,
-0.0063854503,
-0.0367727727,
-0.0258945227,
0.0359666087,
-0.0009356881,
0.0587465242,
-0.006454051,
0.0126593122,
0.0050456305,
-0.0094306795,
-0.0338459909,
0.018179955,
-0.0615018494,
-0.0217176024,
-0.0026613995,
0.0001822878,
-0.0094473828,
-0.0065995604,
0.0334658772,
-0.027403662,
0.0186039489,
-0.0122187911,
-0.0013626778,
-0.00496095,
0.0036720259,
0.0111750783,
-0.0265512411,
0.0192101132,
-0.0321003534,
-0.0874211043,
0.0087459013,
0.0603206642,
0.0420094505,
0.0184181686,
-0.038272664,
0.0438227616,
-0.0394190289,
0.0160070267,
0.0387129821,
-0.0162018966,
0.0393152311,
0.0508634038,
0.0061130766,
0.0137254354,
-0.0094208075,
-0.0146540776,
-0.0037133028,
0.0572006926,
0.0197495073,
0.0462174155,
-0.017084023,
-0.0273889061,
-0.0449856147,
0.031832628,
0.0544256531,
0.0400243141,
-0.0113881612,
0.0206858721,
-0.0354776271,
-0.0033203654,
-0.0124543644,
-0.019114498,
-0.014875384,
-0.0210766587,
0.0244950708,
0.038588699,
-0.0282003898,
-0.0533800013,
0.0527919754,
-0.0440449789,
0.0013744448,
0.0167018529,
-0.0446246751,
0.0016022696,
-0.0126682138,
0.0044105891,
-0.0340666883,
-0.0326294601,
0.0500186905,
0.0116377855,
0.0095250597,
0.0279845819,
0.0043934826,
0.0407514758,
-0.0514485538,
-0.0062033068,
-0.0280489177,
0.0718363225,
-0.0236703232,
0.011936265,
0.0112131517,
-0.0096553285,
-0.0261137206,
0.0512906313,
0.0271419212,
0.0343561284,
-0.0526515692,
0.0188984498,
0.012120747,
-0.0093853474,
-0.0187207181,
0.0047946102,
-0.0265840814,
-0.0014570605,
0.0368482769,
-0.0638904348,
-0.0260157585,
-0.0161164347,
2.814e-7,
0.0085430425,
0.0494240485,
0.0402366295,
0.0355247967,
0.046475403,
0.0405391529,
-0.019868331,
0.027981028,
0.015409708,
-0.0024402116,
0.0075160768,
0.0583520122,
0.062591143,
0.0079479404,
-0.1017706692,
-0.0421103425,
-0.0836525187,
-0.0421485342,
-0.0214584507,
-0.0561621152,
0.0180164371,
0.1147212833,
0.0262414441,
0.0057105292,
-0.0048268195,
-0.0044429437,
0.0568004549,
-0.007397471,
-0.046010606,
0.0679871738,
0.0301796123,
0.0224930234,
-0.0033701905,
-0.0336523838,
-0.0030793117,
0.0215095114,
-0.0017192221,
0.0929192007,
0.0232450999,
-0.0322810337,
0.0327837951,
-0.0100960843,
-0.0028341238,
-0.0388991833,
0.0567931645,
-0.0612262599,
-0.0185146295,
-0.0594551228,
-0.0079509784,
-0.0122370757,
0.0590583608,
-0.0219243728,
-0.040358942,
0.0582410805,
0.0046455958,
0.0046355799,
0.0061483849,
-0.0770473406,
-0.0285849776,
-0.0693496317,
-0.0842021406,
-0.0607960373,
-0.0191214029,
-0.0364275873,
-0.0043965359,
-0.0138194086,
0.0032030714,
2.358120876e-34,
0.0366801582,
0.0022580558,
0.0114252148,
0.0261635985,
0.0283680465,
-0.0173147954,
0.0489333719,
0.005141567,
0.0281159021,
-0.0479453392,
-0.0377894379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01179v1 | Hate Speech Targets Detection in Parler using BERT | 2023-04-03T17:49:04 | 2023-04-03T17:49:04 | Nadav Schneider, Shimon Shouei, Saleem Ghantous, Elad Feldman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Online social networks have become a fundamental component of our everyday
life. Unfortunately, these platforms are also a stage for hate speech. Popular
social networks have regularized rules against hate speech. Consequently,
social networks like Parler and Gab advocating and claiming to be free speech
platforms have evolved. These platforms have become a district for hate speech
against diverse targets. We present in our paper a pipeline for detecting hate
speech and its targets and use it for creating Parler hate targets'
distribution. The pipeline consists of two models; one for hate speech
detection and the second for target classification, both based on BERT with
Back-Translation and data pre-processing for improved results. The source code
used in this work, as well as other relevant sources, are available at:
https://github.com/NadavSc/HateRecognition.git | [
0.073268652,
0.0316398181,
-0.0123395231,
0.019661,
-0.0090574687,
0.0339393988,
0.0227968749,
0.0161955599,
-0.0126761245,
-0.056802012,
0.0121643785,
-0.0062897406,
0.0006961726,
0.0066829063,
-0.0166615825,
-0.0706957281,
0.0134505695,
0.0438502021,
0.0412784889,
-0.0357814729,
0.0521434397,
0.0201300327,
-0.004334216,
0.0534292832,
-0.0740014613,
0.0317470059,
0.0481239036,
0.0157275666,
0.0423403978,
-0.0049667843,
0.055497814,
0.0263081901,
0.0060934103,
0.0606046282,
0.0000017022,
-0.0380339436,
-0.0013520747,
0.0004167219,
-0.0066297511,
-0.0612059832,
0.066057615,
-0.0236242991,
-0.0197737105,
0.0455233753,
-0.0171664022,
0.0186990388,
0.045877289,
0.0598846748,
0.072367847,
0.075917311,
-0.0092025818,
-0.0764695033,
0.0344369859,
0.0404943116,
0.0143630793,
0.0259057023,
0.0334902778,
-0.0888091326,
-0.0541709214,
-0.0271734912,
0.0120645538,
0.0049365233,
0.0114530912,
0.0398520567,
0.0261933394,
-0.0140744122,
-0.0324516445,
-0.0547381379,
-0.0018676871,
0.0354064368,
-0.0626665726,
-0.028177334,
0.0064201625,
0.0084273443,
-0.0236582011,
-0.0151074622,
-0.0009948257,
0.0000376726,
-0.028616501,
0.0125526711,
0.0039875559,
0.0124961911,
0.0305456053,
0.0372684933,
-0.0137061235,
0.0317628272,
0.0058307038,
-0.0309436955,
0.0206895322,
-0.0057716575,
-0.0344351381,
0.0004615254,
0.0529950038,
0.0137029644,
-0.0019403195,
-0.0040220455,
-0.0685024336,
-0.0818976089,
-0.0002450805,
-0.0898536742,
0.0321907736,
0.042420499,
-0.0510684587,
-0.0150844678,
0.0033909844,
0.0223132353,
-0.0119102476,
0.0211449154,
-0.0054208902,
-0.0019599518,
-0.0279769059,
0.0305657759,
-0.0419710688,
-0.0136734722,
0.0055823838,
0.0228006057,
-0.0494522117,
0.002880916,
-0.0738232955,
-0.0106691923,
0.0053421464,
0.0256211106,
0.0077687767,
0.0138312941,
-0.0058522164,
0.0290893055,
-0.0457290523,
-0.0194583535,
-0.0791559815,
-0.060606692,
0.0252979919,
0.0399978459,
0.0016833696,
-0.0528226197,
0.0487663224,
0.0559977777,
0.0432290174,
-0.0418642275,
-0.0187838916,
-0.0189870223,
-0.0250935238,
-0.0006151162,
0.0167193338,
-0.0508748181,
-0.0090778908,
-0.0080508562,
-0.0383973978,
-0.0327080637,
-0.0025672736,
0.0152196996,
-0.0579913221,
0.0564317107,
0.0238197837,
-0.0214132667,
0.0731527656,
0.0061976202,
-0.0085938051,
0.0371969566,
-0.0000710975,
0.0320321992,
0.0411010943,
-0.003137202,
-0.0183996838,
0.0704545453,
0.046728503,
-0.0101971468,
-0.0470390879,
0.0220219139,
-0.0542681813,
-0.0496929586,
0.0053059189,
0.0597222373,
-0.0029401509,
-0.0719242245,
0.0088573182,
0.0744781271,
-0.0386915691,
0.025403101,
0.0549859181,
0.035084378,
-0.0219471585,
-0.0083708363,
-0.0471355021,
-0.042155467,
-0.0300038401,
-0.0713685974,
-0.0153502794,
0.0560644716,
-0.0177820846,
-0.0119452812,
-0.0068167769,
-0.0180501211,
0.0366075002,
-0.0533047579,
0.0552940294,
0.0353758447,
-0.0455235913,
0.0686675981,
0.0392763838,
0.0035650369,
0.027760081,
-0.0516751297,
-0.0022620733,
0.0521470532,
0.0182236005,
-0.0129306195,
-0.0191036258,
-0.0620669797,
-0.0479554906,
0.0309946593,
-0.0125117078,
-0.0148459747,
-0.0248625446,
-0.0238108914,
-0.0165135264,
0.0283692218,
0.0195834283,
0.0176917575,
0.0636293367,
0.0158214625,
0.0143845696,
0.0179885961,
-0.0026336832,
0.0306840613,
0.0618047938,
-0.0033116927,
-0.0137614151,
0.0330788679,
0.0373990498,
0.0442903489,
-0.0293195453,
-0.0459302105,
0.0018400048,
-0.0156026874,
-0.026172772,
0.019075159,
-0.0055015376,
-0.0107969726,
0.0320625603,
-0.0705906376,
-0.0285608172,
0.1002047509,
0.0050524897,
0.0220262446,
0.0817082673,
-0.061564967,
0.0245140921,
-0.0123955207,
-0.0140905539,
-0.0790233463,
0.0260137152,
-0.0027289246,
0.0683735162,
-0.0203837752,
-0.0193237979,
-0.0036930055,
-0.0281354655,
0.0366806947,
0.0137230735,
-0.042785354,
-0.0398277789,
-0.0478147417,
0.0057960441,
0.0098013487,
0.0062382366,
-0.014463773,
0.0047287624,
-0.0635000467,
-0.0262836721,
-0.0390906744,
-0.0047737681,
0.0170058049,
0.0245567709,
0.0071464605,
0.0086284503,
0.0069318539,
-0.0262673888,
0.0393207856,
0.0197241437,
0.0008625535,
-0.050434716,
-0.0669314414,
-0.0088820858,
-0.0089134257,
-0.0309385713,
0.0229667109,
0.0316684768,
-0.0594515055,
0.0372805968,
-0.0429061092,
-0.026329007,
0.032442674,
0.0168473069,
-0.0607758351,
0.0368102677,
-0.0013613891,
-0.0039450265,
0.023993602,
0.0691603422,
0.1144204438,
-0.0220669936,
0.0100287441,
-0.0097699482,
-0.0002304696,
-0.0327232108,
0.0390086249,
-0.024387138,
-0.0345417075,
0.0230980683,
0.0779777542,
0.0535421595,
0.0007758595,
-0.0639279336,
-0.0102923084,
-0.0582673252,
-0.021142235,
-0.0183711555,
-0.0585746057,
-0.0208214354,
-0.0604575202,
-0.0189293884,
-0.0390778445,
0.0618273877,
-0.0043814061,
0.0356882848,
-0.0267088022,
-0.0356922708,
0.0157717355,
0.0205526464,
0.0369636267,
0.048704572,
-0.0730324239,
-0.0340487286,
0.0379059836,
-0.0119910883,
0.0037415891,
-0.0118681341,
-0.0299041755,
-0.0048896936,
0.0058220546,
0.0104313679,
-0.0231461134,
-0.06779477,
-0.0566035844,
-0.0573163331,
-0.0300724804,
0.020190144,
-0.0348259062,
-0.0312768184,
0.0289593115,
0.0057432782,
0.001223314,
0.0167832114,
0.0069161542,
0.0136390356,
-0.0068145501,
-0.0238445122,
-0.046321474,
0.008343217,
0.0161326677,
-0.0671496913,
0.0435813479,
0.0357067287,
0.0230876431,
-0.0231590793,
0.0169771872,
0.0510788299,
-0.0126092369,
0.0103189722,
-0.0323660001,
0.0301834513,
0.0085704206,
-0.0158324912,
0.0983931124,
0.0220971294,
0.004847622,
-0.0020531814,
-0.0110567566,
0.0032779076,
-0.0070908307,
-0.0167254396,
-0.06207994,
-0.0012227073,
-0.0207015481,
0.0302253943,
-0.086943388,
-0.0181021504,
0.0190715715,
-0.0456231311,
0.011806692,
-0.0172618423,
-0.0343154706,
-0.039444644,
-0.0043360721,
0.0072246236,
0.0051632812,
0.0344464257,
-0.0420398936,
0.0293391291,
0.007145091,
0.033388216,
-0.075600557,
0.000255765,
0.0184603669,
-0.0408336222,
0.0282681249,
0.0747227818,
0.0593255498,
-0.053522449,
-0.0405289456,
0.0559350699,
-0.013395356,
-0.0296957493,
-0.0611075908,
0.0399206504,
0.0016197693,
-0.0449250303,
-0.0343121067,
0.0157768019,
0.006050006,
-0.0124600409,
-0.0027128726,
0.0362511314,
0.0088905664,
0.0055980748,
-0.0543282591,
0.0535107218,
-0.0119419284,
0.0725269988,
0.0332106836,
-0.0378186591,
0.0288274586,
-0.0772879198,
-0.0034128954,
-0.0591623895,
-0.0714025274,
0.0302209556,
-0.0608919039,
-0.0676088929,
-0.029506743,
-0.0007047852,
0.0343433991,
0.0471441522,
0.0136455977,
-0.0473285578,
0.0113445157,
0.0031236822,
-0.0642696694,
0.0058422117,
0.0363829397,
0.0598906875,
-0.0112625808,
-0.0446916334,
-0.0093494756,
-0.0116265928,
-0.0396511145,
0.0093649169,
-0.0407615639,
-0.0336277969,
0.0827790648,
0.0694851279,
0.0226697568,
-0.0050324546,
-0.0376924761,
-0.0434968509,
0.0686532706,
0.0455407165,
0.0036987967,
-0.0170283318,
0.0509335101,
0.0120033845,
0.0061188517,
-0.0016619869,
0.0078537008,
0.0307957307,
0.0273499358,
-0.04879402,
-0.052540563,
0.0097631896,
-0.0290768724,
0.0092618736,
0.0667163432,
-0.0007535474,
-0.0827272832,
-0.0293100253,
-0.0223892201,
0.0116247181,
-0.0191456713,
0.0029427637,
-0.0095675988,
-0.0039227861,
-0.0052533448,
-0.0441891775,
-0.0375932902,
-0.0641849115,
0.0107726827,
-0.0579867028,
0.0554790646,
0.0385446325,
0.0490033589,
0.0244170949,
-0.0026037965,
-0.0168476235,
0.018775681,
0.0180570371,
-0.0144239264,
0.0073690368,
0.000204222,
0.0068708444,
-0.0038650071,
0.0388220623,
-0.0382879861,
0.0098900264,
-0.0016984425,
-0.0780920982,
-0.0111320335,
-0.017795695,
-0.0021918439,
0.0470307209,
0.0360313915,
-0.0190394185,
0.0135569302,
-0.0014434715,
-0.0287935957,
-0.0503446087,
0.0022516646,
0.0107648391,
-0.0044501121,
-0.0392068401,
0.0091369562,
0.007593248,
0.0660269111,
0.0674822703,
-0.0461625867,
-0.0286228992,
-0.0024395844,
0.0427782834,
0.0142941577,
0.0240323618,
0.030851556,
-0.0162559561,
-0.0456455871,
0.0233745053,
-0.0336635783,
0.0444861203,
0.0143418433,
0.0214007087,
0.0566117577,
-0.0180844199,
0.0119674569,
-0.0015107387,
0.0407263935,
0.010492187,
-0.0585500039,
0.0131951235,
-5.398133811e-33,
-0.0267394483,
-0.0297062378,
-0.021022737,
-0.0101240436,
-0.0101536578,
-0.0437902696,
0.0317445286,
-0.0142360423,
-0.0086620385,
0.0232295971,
0.0220560264,
0.0349847004,
0.0178358275,
0.0140471663,
-0.0357329026,
-0.052626323,
0.048771169,
0.0025362947,
0.0088584628,
0.0020898464,
0.0450944267,
0.018942276,
0.0406643264,
-0.0318282694,
0.0218161345,
0.0102651753,
-0.0276007019,
0.0341626666,
0.0547229536,
0.0489382334,
0.0108283916,
0.0702284575,
0.0297651533,
0.0020374376,
0.0139290951,
0.0699762106,
-0.0555124022,
-0.0068101371,
-0.0014932348,
0.0429139584,
0.0432388373,
0.0151628023,
0.0476284511,
-0.0042876694,
-0.0554172695,
0.0002279948,
0.0418939479,
-0.024078602,
0.0381222628,
-0.0045573306,
-0.0590324365,
0.022009613,
-0.0343357548,
0.000753234,
-0.0151381101,
-0.003185391,
0.0549078509,
-0.0177754797,
-0.0692376792,
0.0151533363,
-0.015256674,
-0.0417854302,
-0.0105748316,
0.0246849526,
0.0019467833,
0.0580956973,
0.0231002942,
-0.0091405185,
-0.0089991838,
0.0331207775,
0.0151235079,
0.0472216681,
0.0192005634,
0.0235948097,
-0.0159145202,
-0.071987994,
-0.0463083051,
0.0432661138,
0.0856835395,
0.0092954449,
0.0027641188,
-0.0370518528,
-0.0376505218,
-0.0226988625,
0.0143831959,
-0.0656759515,
-0.0098753236,
0.0063051046,
-0.0082977479,
-0.0134485532,
-0.0327694453,
0.0224999841,
0.0190668013,
-0.0167730954,
0.0289635248,
0.0421108715,
-0.0340723358,
0.0050300001,
0.0130795464,
0.0372657068,
-0.0163520779,
-0.0500079319,
0.0136625292,
-0.0262433589,
0.0363986343,
0.0136035336,
0.0365659259,
0.0106123015,
-0.053389132,
0.011591916,
-0.0214098953,
0.0507206731,
-0.013365238,
0.0747643486,
0.0096871862,
0.0374625549,
-0.0219809506,
-0.0424274206,
0.0300830752,
-0.0238207038,
-0.002942069,
0.0455954857,
-0.0364858955,
-0.0118429381,
-0.0256297812,
-0.023507623,
-0.0153098116,
0.0233164914,
0.0131266015,
-0.1202220544,
0.0069520837,
-0.0900398791,
2.418e-7,
0.0270457901,
0.0403309874,
0.0039554993,
0.0037911495,
0.0089479852,
0.0375089981,
0.0518209487,
0.0514119565,
-0.0119899567,
0.0026879264,
-0.0353473946,
0.0492906049,
-0.0312226675,
0.0603901446,
-0.0096019749,
-0.0170610957,
-0.0637161955,
-0.0006141358,
-0.0356572643,
0.0458609201,
-0.009812722,
0.0568292066,
0.0676219463,
-0.0612751469,
-0.0115153734,
0.0104147485,
-0.0074506728,
-0.0170753673,
-0.0270725824,
-0.0197947472,
0.0409366116,
-0.0079549411,
0.0225383006,
0.0088289101,
-0.0049890792,
0.0228935573,
0.0066333064,
0.0364904404,
0.0072836736,
0.0167173352,
-0.0017880813,
-0.0457182303,
-0.017055938,
-0.0304805152,
0.0239525568,
0.0000567855,
-0.0209559966,
-0.0259842463,
-0.0267476588,
-0.0103972554,
0.0283564739,
-0.0325829983,
-0.0123705845,
-0.0109432638,
0.0369131826,
-0.033485122,
0.0156325903,
-0.0817862675,
0.0173085537,
0.0088795163,
-0.0277325083,
-0.044618018,
-0.0053225006,
-0.0139161833,
0.0401906595,
0.0357689895,
0.0570744127,
1.856091345e-34,
0.024764007,
0.0121250814,
-0.030214889,
-0.0504472218,
0.0320122875,
0.0212995037,
-0.0011267114,
0.0060972432,
0.0517992452,
-0.0170149039,
-0.0141906096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01246v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01246v3 | Safety Analysis in the Era of Large Language Models: A Case Study of STPA using ChatGPT | 2023-04-03T16:46:49 | 2023-12-20T09:19:15 | Yi Qi, Xingyu Zhao, Siddartha Khastgir, Xiaowei Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.SE | Can safety analysis make use of Large Language Models (LLMs)? A case study
explores Systems Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA) applied to Automatic
Emergency Brake (AEB) and Electricity Demand Side Management (DSM) systems
using ChatGPT. We investigate how collaboration schemes, input semantic
complexity, and prompt guidelines influence STPA results. Comparative results
show that using ChatGPT without human intervention may be inadequate due to
reliability related issues, but with careful design, it may outperform human
experts. No statistically significant differences are found when varying the
input semantic complexity or using common prompt guidelines, which suggests the
necessity for developing domain-specific prompt engineering. We also highlight
future challenges, including concerns about LLM trustworthiness and the
necessity for standardisation and regulation in this domain. | [
-0.0436591431,
0.0080426186,
-0.0166835636,
0.0454826392,
-0.021461105,
-0.0166055653,
0.0155520597,
-0.0363082662,
0.0159592014,
-0.024962211,
0.0553434491,
-0.0151815629,
-0.0062973872,
0.0699750558,
0.0305833854,
-0.0047963816,
0.0387180448,
-0.0728316456,
-0.0129851606,
0.051993981,
0.0257231705,
-0.0256536081,
0.0053819981,
0.0494728051,
-0.026517367,
-0.0349184908,
-0.0275573637,
0.0079483008,
0.0634577125,
-0.02082517,
-0.0259285476,
0.0410545841,
0.0371941663,
0.0421738736,
0.000002182,
-0.0135869067,
-0.0107862018,
0.0560743622,
0.0037149515,
0.0231660232,
-0.0305243488,
0.039366968,
-0.0178581346,
0.0204293095,
0.0169803929,
0.0119438395,
0.0589907244,
0.0199196003,
0.0634851158,
0.0148609076,
-0.012438071,
0.0326069072,
-0.0040887468,
-0.0146701271,
-0.0695157573,
-0.037907064,
0.0543674603,
-0.0228579044,
0.0413599908,
-0.0110130357,
0.016242275,
-0.0002032674,
0.0275043361,
-0.0665254444,
-0.0364410356,
-0.0077412399,
0.0185849443,
0.0115466071,
-0.0187784657,
0.0045112562,
0.0498942919,
0.014370136,
0.0079381317,
-0.0230586734,
-0.0091876239,
0.0242827591,
-0.0114958072,
-0.0128821796,
-0.0145684211,
-0.0117188571,
-0.0516551025,
0.0389944352,
-0.0086357603,
-0.0258631855,
0.0033227943,
0.1117588878,
-0.0028114095,
-0.0256864298,
0.0183273163,
0.0231037866,
-0.0117440168,
-0.0307650156,
-0.0106793819,
0.0070421137,
-0.0631964728,
-0.0030362252,
0.0688834116,
0.0298768021,
0.0336503685,
-0.0551225506,
0.0336187109,
0.0180908907,
0.0193295274,
-0.0256740507,
0.068821393,
0.0395100564,
0.0092893541,
-0.0029415393,
-0.0081815757,
0.0524402261,
-0.0371861272,
-0.0172282346,
-0.0528480485,
-0.021273436,
-0.0272795148,
0.0623431727,
-0.0343601704,
0.0543982349,
-0.0735428035,
0.0246307403,
-0.0255133472,
-0.0265306588,
0.0124447597,
0.0217503998,
-0.0075792251,
0.000362174,
-0.019416552,
0.0357117392,
-0.0303796642,
-0.0390352979,
0.025866311,
0.014840221,
-0.0561666451,
-0.009516947,
-0.0419067368,
0.0743032992,
-0.0149298701,
0.0021531337,
-0.0626792312,
-0.0669318438,
0.0070798164,
-0.0275703464,
-0.0297731441,
-0.0484788492,
-0.0187903214,
-0.0359967314,
-0.0174693558,
-0.0190755576,
-0.0219303109,
-0.0063471873,
0.0095008584,
0.0369748734,
-0.0421996266,
0.0342151113,
-0.0085786004,
0.0464597158,
-0.0414253399,
0.0508182533,
0.0276619196,
-0.0014709044,
0.0203862675,
0.0049397103,
0.0553783365,
0.0484015346,
-0.039075166,
0.0379220359,
-0.0199193563,
-0.0090290755,
0.0045155901,
-0.0441782698,
-0.0306242015,
0.0557284206,
-0.0025046004,
0.0091935173,
0.0092062131,
-0.0091416845,
-0.0241599306,
0.0383660905,
0.0522153676,
0.0486314259,
0.0110470336,
-0.0115546035,
-0.0036104487,
-0.0333286338,
-0.0650486797,
0.0074266512,
-0.0272181761,
0.0171508659,
-0.0184813868,
-0.0251887534,
-0.0140992701,
0.007136866,
0.0098034767,
0.0024665073,
0.0038767732,
-0.0448919684,
-0.0123555362,
0.0268041473,
-0.0067434735,
0.0109746559,
-0.0163340997,
-0.0705191866,
-0.030239448,
0.0777317062,
0.0423375852,
-0.0448408052,
-0.029813759,
-0.0250697192,
0.0226166733,
-0.0243743993,
0.0172401518,
0.0191092677,
-0.0075905779,
0.0039958935,
-0.0556885004,
0.0150106372,
0.0058367914,
0.0100881951,
-0.0646972582,
0.0166510046,
-0.0085882964,
0.0622969121,
-0.0542267859,
0.0190878306,
-0.0337126628,
-0.0184360426,
-0.0507231504,
0.033574637,
-0.0080381073,
0.0174215659,
-0.039892748,
0.0507217646,
0.0299019795,
-0.0211762674,
-0.04224208,
0.0176936127,
-0.0345830359,
0.0633360818,
0.0388799459,
-0.0012581337,
-0.0208065156,
-0.009576153,
-0.0173023418,
-0.0306248143,
-0.002935017,
-0.0493472405,
-0.0205374919,
-0.01234621,
0.0026646925,
-0.028974412,
-0.0516838804,
-0.0314084217,
0.0024367704,
0.0371324904,
0.0100986138,
0.0158256665,
0.0338423066,
0.0495829768,
-0.0020524624,
-0.0472559594,
0.0263414364,
-0.0295976587,
-0.0068863588,
0.0051214527,
0.0246500764,
0.0116244247,
0.0317384712,
-0.0754249319,
-0.0139950039,
0.0129091777,
0.0509295091,
-0.0070832269,
-0.0207837,
-0.0406509377,
0.005016624,
0.0201641228,
0.0318944901,
-0.0556551255,
0.0173919499,
0.0201034676,
0.0355592296,
-0.0596638843,
0.0093317134,
-0.0060842964,
-0.0153971873,
0.0476235934,
0.0545606576,
-0.0252393112,
-0.0658186898,
0.0750665739,
0.0109854415,
0.0004849183,
-0.0038489786,
-0.0439207144,
0.0159707535,
0.0402832925,
0.0857026875,
-0.019190954,
-0.0181189217,
0.0012514328,
0.0214961432,
-0.051137425,
-0.0157620832,
0.0177419651,
0.0119551132,
-0.0601695776,
0.0166185498,
-0.0173840281,
-0.0232685935,
0.0587420687,
-0.0277577136,
-0.0052895742,
0.0111472383,
-0.0278826896,
-0.0273755174,
-0.0182852279,
-0.0343959332,
-0.0977673158,
-0.010157573,
0.0675173923,
0.0244929399,
-0.0008204453,
0.0668387264,
-0.0403812863,
-0.0073487288,
-0.0333408192,
-0.0651569888,
0.0003757565,
0.0607455224,
-0.0453365259,
0.0079647265,
0.0160340331,
0.0366572216,
-0.0230971966,
-0.0255598575,
0.0137587767,
0.0368585773,
0.0142833795,
-0.0509873107,
0.0188700836,
-0.0142408945,
-0.0522287339,
-0.0014540241,
-0.016057739,
-0.026502749,
0.0273596514,
-0.0264938623,
-0.0049391049,
0.0279754493,
0.0315738469,
0.0325933434,
0.0224309471,
-0.0070188222,
-0.0130905556,
-0.0062014977,
-0.0474695861,
0.010485772,
-0.0189273506,
0.0439382121,
-0.0099075856,
0.0889008418,
0.027557971,
0.0378628373,
-0.0128019191,
-0.0546531603,
-0.0441850871,
-0.007787433,
-0.0032595859,
-0.0298531651,
0.0635057688,
-0.0027866727,
-0.0537569337,
-0.0041009355,
0.031832289,
0.0008309853,
-0.0269537009,
0.0242546126,
-0.0468565598,
0.0036684645,
-0.0086053871,
0.0355013274,
-0.022512652,
0.0159950312,
0.043843396,
0.0417161621,
-0.0509754829,
-0.0231857691,
-0.0177331287,
-0.0102251004,
0.0584341921,
-0.017006686,
-0.0325764753,
-0.0201180223,
-0.0646567121,
0.0251226276,
-0.0139830112,
-0.0024301652,
0.0434419923,
-0.0039936332,
-0.0452570878,
0.0288041346,
-0.0702885985,
-0.0432226509,
0.015965635,
-0.0296534672,
0.0453530513,
0.0503616631,
-0.0376307704,
-0.0326828435,
-0.0145560075,
0.1101608723,
0.015967628,
0.013216556,
-0.0309109371,
-0.0289319176,
0.0415737405,
0.0072878795,
-0.030323578,
0.0076667708,
-0.0005041402,
-0.0281621255,
0.029990118,
0.109611623,
-0.0497898348,
-0.0224575475,
-0.0512521155,
0.0239677541,
0.0673823133,
0.0129548945,
-0.0062663057,
-0.0251077339,
-0.0572642609,
-0.0072507733,
-0.0198128223,
0.0377410799,
-0.0461092852,
-0.0150108514,
-0.0068467455,
-0.0640061572,
0.0358478501,
-0.0380414799,
-0.0049039228,
0.0215628557,
-0.0075802365,
-0.0131631317,
0.080252625,
0.0339971408,
-0.0337290503,
0.0374315679,
-0.0117222965,
0.0839608684,
-0.0087590199,
0.0522275493,
0.0119332969,
0.059297923,
-0.0292247366,
-0.0092392191,
0.0122519135,
-0.0580873005,
0.0452798679,
0.0532927364,
0.0376708247,
-0.052208364,
-0.0338595919,
-0.0557645895,
0.0190641601,
0.0131398533,
-0.0343517736,
-0.0214056857,
-0.000384956,
0.0326568484,
0.0118942084,
-0.0040120049,
-0.0222150423,
0.0337466262,
0.0014097565,
0.0346341617,
-0.010657277,
-0.0385478176,
-0.0278215576,
0.0686871409,
0.0098698996,
-0.0127820689,
-0.0002889806,
-0.0359826237,
-0.0097734872,
-0.0010695576,
-0.0055992906,
-0.0584342331,
0.0326830335,
-0.071312122,
-0.0409681872,
0.0312119164,
-0.0275272001,
-0.0165874921,
-0.0101171359,
0.057481885,
0.0515507981,
0.0319179893,
0.0414737351,
0.0327685028,
-0.0103720147,
0.0122045716,
-0.0276811849,
0.0305474624,
-0.0256513208,
0.0268842597,
0.0428949594,
0.0010399943,
-0.0161085669,
-0.0123530012,
0.0340469591,
-0.0076792166,
-0.0810055435,
0.0191278029,
0.037919756,
0.0089786369,
0.0749508291,
-0.020154655,
-0.0596127734,
0.0256253816,
-0.0468788296,
0.0395669155,
0.0283755194,
0.0243557245,
0.0112623749,
0.0340840295,
-0.0470154956,
-0.0462080315,
0.0772554576,
0.0306493081,
-0.005532342,
-0.0436943583,
-0.0737529919,
-0.0374810174,
-0.0402857214,
0.0415872484,
-0.0391508006,
-0.0439939387,
-0.0397165008,
-0.1462193578,
-0.0414419249,
-0.0537829064,
0.0260953307,
0.0025047387,
-0.0000157373,
0.0272636805,
-0.0013842197,
0.0344555341,
0.0469886437,
0.0205452573,
-0.0404649898,
0.0010593727,
0.0010061442,
0.0076615163,
-5.738512893e-33,
0.0027015954,
-0.056014996,
0.0054876287,
-0.0062097465,
-0.0239588041,
-0.0152292978,
-0.0161519088,
0.0415500998,
0.0617633313,
0.0323476009,
-0.0034590545,
-0.0228181332,
0.0184137877,
-0.0523421653,
0.0187385045,
0.0022426159,
0.0245128609,
-0.0108642643,
-0.0113936942,
0.0055308733,
0.0407221057,
-0.0120787239,
0.0083266906,
-0.0522481613,
0.0822682977,
0.0030559471,
-0.0225325637,
0.0630277768,
-0.0094648823,
0.0214599147,
-0.0043149702,
0.0509913787,
0.0087269824,
-0.0408561528,
-0.0073675811,
0.086394012,
0.0219399426,
-0.0589672513,
-0.0095976954,
-0.034073595,
-0.0182168651,
-0.0207440704,
0.0344427302,
-0.0142077822,
-0.0395847,
0.0145141771,
-0.0082501713,
0.0071893428,
0.0544138886,
-0.0389574245,
-0.0249715298,
0.0094488831,
-0.0276778843,
-0.0033032149,
0.0329946503,
0.0472449884,
0.0068568019,
-0.0843410939,
-0.0060130334,
-0.0141393756,
0.0274255108,
-0.0440267958,
0.065292649,
-0.0150209637,
-0.031928461,
0.0098114908,
-0.0645299554,
0.0177769549,
-0.0276063699,
-0.0323913582,
0.0003601836,
0.0974482894,
0.001626722,
0.0117016118,
-0.0735562369,
-0.0305270441,
-0.1177024841,
0.0574776083,
0.0144459996,
0.0752939284,
0.0260327905,
-0.0218085367,
-0.0516586341,
-0.0433705263,
0.0006800424,
0.068760857,
-0.0178439636,
-0.0344767794,
0.0032001974,
-0.0039600856,
-0.0193080511,
-0.0096379574,
0.0124540385,
-0.0110211419,
0.0227479562,
-0.0090937661,
0.0040348615,
-0.0355102457,
0.0259773973,
0.0465432666,
-0.031591326,
-0.007458732,
-0.0233065169,
0.0060990937,
0.0136190262,
-0.0252126027,
-0.0168976653,
0.0465555228,
-0.013147288,
0.0301033612,
-0.0276900772,
0.0200851373,
0.0115400096,
0.0172299147,
0.0170350913,
-0.0201555677,
0.0070652692,
-0.0051132576,
-0.0102735097,
-0.0194305778,
0.0058021178,
0.0434833504,
-0.0366045833,
0.0066723139,
0.0189488716,
-0.0268515702,
-0.0210747886,
-0.0048828595,
0.029752573,
0.0259334277,
-0.0048785075,
-0.0223526638,
2.976e-7,
-0.0146985482,
0.0242555048,
0.0065456433,
0.0845547989,
0.0539639629,
0.0639770925,
-0.016761845,
0.0010779107,
-0.0206073932,
0.0325734653,
0.0241306014,
-0.0405589417,
0.0354365669,
0.0304238256,
-0.0010774914,
-0.0602051765,
-0.0277924798,
0.0628840327,
-0.0584529825,
-0.0266942717,
0.1193602309,
-0.0225585457,
0.0198454056,
-0.0030880678,
-0.0034955277,
-0.0429675616,
0.0163513534,
-0.061001271,
0.001589969,
0.0420521982,
0.071234338,
0.0292314347,
0.0695433021,
0.0451287143,
0.0266728308,
-0.0242637731,
-0.0199650414,
0.0753669739,
0.0345230363,
-0.0153956348,
0.027506439,
-0.0736157373,
0.0384519622,
-0.047168918,
-0.0041661058,
-0.0478394628,
-0.0227909572,
0.023959199,
-0.0374993607,
-0.0577114783,
0.0045536226,
0.0026596584,
0.0198551323,
0.0236860868,
-0.0501353778,
-0.023445677,
0.0267569534,
0.0383278877,
0.0070278221,
-0.0032799882,
0.0105744628,
-0.1026638746,
-0.0245018099,
0.0476347394,
0.0218000058,
-0.0314512104,
0.0355015807,
2.67311548e-34,
0.0052467831,
-0.0368230604,
-0.0252435803,
0.0101121124,
0.0235765856,
0.0398060754,
-0.0077503887,
0.0219961554,
-0.0015185421,
-0.017510511,
-0.0294117779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01106v1 | Crossword: A Semantic Approach to Data Compression via Masking | 2023-04-03T16:04:06 | 2023-04-03T16:04:06 | Mingxiao Li, Rui Jin, Liyao Xiang, Kaiming Shen, Shuguang Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | The traditional methods for data compression are typically based on the
symbol-level statistics, with the information source modeled as a long sequence
of i.i.d. random variables or a stochastic process, thus establishing the
fundamental limit as entropy for lossless compression and as mutual information
for lossy compression. However, the source (including text, music, and speech)
in the real world is often statistically ill-defined because of its close
connection to human perception, and thus the model-driven approach can be quite
suboptimal. This study places careful emphasis on English text and exploits its
semantic aspect to enhance the compression efficiency further. The main idea
stems from the puzzle crossword, observing that the hidden words can still be
precisely reconstructed so long as some key letters are provided. The proposed
masking-based strategy resembles the above game. In a nutshell, the encoder
evaluates the semantic importance of each word according to the semantic loss
and then masks the minor ones, while the decoder aims to recover the masked
words from the semantic context by means of the Transformer. Our experiments
show that the proposed semantic approach can achieve much higher compression
efficiency than the traditional methods such as Huffman code and UTF-8 code,
while preserving the meaning in the target text to a great extent. | [
-0.0312945433,
0.0358550884,
-0.0139197679,
0.0584319979,
-0.054554373,
0.0098101767,
-0.022223115,
0.097468175,
-0.0945952982,
-0.0148462383,
0.0336487293,
0.0630362406,
0.0267355926,
-0.0163482353,
-0.0002974063,
-0.0425164215,
0.0173341352,
-0.0096324505,
-0.0447794572,
-0.0138798552,
-0.0082975402,
-0.0216629077,
0.0453064032,
0.0036555254,
-0.018841492,
0.0275591053,
-0.0131390532,
0.0093001369,
-0.0018450615,
0.005979252,
-0.0552865192,
0.0071825986,
0.0232308432,
0.0602090247,
0.0000023363,
-0.0352324024,
-0.0544338748,
0.0214181598,
-0.0503107458,
-0.0117529798,
0.0451308824,
-0.067907773,
-0.045224499,
-0.001250049,
-0.0021244141,
-0.0041402201,
0.0953203812,
0.0393859632,
0.0461485051,
0.0335803218,
-0.0309305508,
-0.0743235424,
0.019401269,
-0.0258578938,
0.0706970692,
-0.0201876424,
0.0125358663,
-0.0083325375,
-0.0413636789,
0.010967942,
-0.0952717885,
0.0417183228,
0.0015582485,
0.0218822416,
-0.0210801959,
0.0336013921,
0.0352823175,
0.0064454516,
0.0056806239,
-0.0105815111,
-0.0512473881,
-0.0284700505,
-0.0041415105,
0.0058261231,
-0.011592513,
0.0131115709,
-0.0408443473,
0.0270670634,
0.0117937187,
0.0270067211,
0.0032586085,
0.0716523752,
0.0140906265,
-0.0017938894,
-0.0225603003,
0.0624071993,
-0.0046136552,
-0.0339671113,
-0.0086745406,
-0.0388517529,
0.0149417408,
-0.0339344963,
0.0211428907,
-0.0094490601,
0.0499264523,
0.0119262598,
-0.0896157101,
-0.0750355273,
-0.0001888114,
-0.0331309885,
0.0186792593,
0.0406166539,
0.0785551965,
0.0333066247,
-0.0122365532,
0.0356531702,
-0.00331369,
0.0243254956,
-0.019876644,
-0.0256114937,
0.0101218987,
-0.0134356711,
-0.0550722666,
0.0688120127,
-0.0315099321,
-0.0123375794,
-0.0140775871,
-0.0092050899,
0.0432788394,
0.0145780547,
0.0338310115,
-0.0409621559,
-0.0619458854,
-0.0040294053,
0.0238853116,
-0.0410503671,
-0.0172337182,
0.0120593896,
0.0097443843,
-0.0123267034,
-0.0014936539,
0.0285864025,
0.0454677604,
-0.0248754565,
0.0279588718,
0.0624664612,
0.0088934926,
-0.0172057077,
0.0108790528,
-0.0146198673,
0.0108515806,
0.0320508219,
-0.0257588048,
-0.049702391,
0.0095454166,
-0.0327958278,
0.0097705554,
-0.0441518724,
0.0075438265,
0.0388325378,
-0.0294802468,
0.0923835337,
-0.0279885381,
-0.0250512995,
0.0321553238,
0.0221151765,
0.0381471924,
0.0566391461,
0.0569964871,
0.0360545889,
0.0332910828,
-0.051594384,
-0.0197552349,
0.0402875096,
0.0432509296,
-0.0054759472,
-0.0438543782,
-0.0648926124,
0.03542253,
0.0006215773,
0.0303614829,
0.0855232626,
-0.047279153,
-0.0443704203,
0.0165226534,
0.0468484126,
0.0409341715,
0.0464067161,
0.0013563198,
0.0238253381,
-0.0277633388,
0.0287239123,
0.0536855161,
0.0221360028,
-0.0254510082,
-0.007002736,
0.0464427918,
-0.0190987308,
0.0021660223,
-0.0382099524,
-0.0035974931,
-0.0436633527,
0.07176999,
-0.0140293874,
0.021705661,
0.039821092,
-0.073993586,
0.0385286696,
-0.0214405842,
-0.0679756775,
0.0054780873,
-0.0513376556,
-0.009066605,
0.0138267698,
0.0717851296,
-0.0029464918,
0.0800380111,
-0.0088268341,
-0.0326170847,
0.0084528755,
-0.0469943807,
0.00974424,
0.0236872584,
-0.0725677088,
-0.0178109501,
0.0009196643,
-0.0274555832,
0.0187058505,
-0.0264906269,
0.0368321389,
0.0023356415,
-0.0011891864,
0.0219173282,
0.0399544984,
0.0044598118,
-0.0189915691,
0.0296312515,
-0.0077995355,
0.0403371379,
-0.0025320074,
-0.0334948264,
0.0167840067,
0.0427274182,
-0.0760403052,
-0.0166847222,
-0.0659302399,
-0.0088281007,
-0.0484390594,
-0.0042332616,
-0.0888756365,
0.0602285638,
0.1016653404,
0.0101396507,
-0.0251117982,
-0.0035005584,
-0.0897881687,
0.0823735222,
-0.0452687815,
0.001087431,
-0.0175070241,
0.0780353621,
-0.011391582,
0.0333672352,
-0.013125807,
0.0290853567,
-0.0508424416,
-0.0219031684,
0.0272483081,
-0.029128518,
-0.0011727752,
0.0481190123,
-0.0314567238,
-0.0186983421,
0.0368056372,
-0.0008041971,
0.0240912121,
-0.0516659804,
-0.0287801679,
-0.0112932604,
0.0062343231,
0.0168060493,
-0.0155188637,
0.0311550852,
0.0109628765,
0.008294262,
-0.0319046788,
0.0043717069,
-0.0126660494,
-0.0105836326,
0.0178926755,
0.007663154,
-0.0268636718,
0.0353320651,
-0.0455878787,
0.0325996801,
0.0526193455,
-0.0093769887,
-0.0694166347,
-0.0335751362,
0.0762615129,
0.0166912638,
-0.0202961974,
0.0164999012,
-0.0301935319,
-0.0326516926,
0.0009560795,
0.0272763632,
0.0161123667,
0.0126373004,
0.0146292197,
0.0224485043,
-0.0338473171,
-0.0193066616,
0.0045204163,
-0.0290124193,
0.0166721009,
-0.0332988054,
-0.0661507249,
0.0135649061,
0.0372448526,
0.048401136,
0.0285484307,
-0.0640391335,
-0.0094442824,
-0.0133801671,
-0.0570951998,
-0.0854309797,
-0.0469588935,
-0.0044483929,
0.0283695254,
-0.000227731,
0.0048057376,
-0.0016013831,
-0.0506548136,
0.0110876411,
-0.0149608087,
0.0065265913,
-0.0480901711,
0.0495740063,
-0.0270842947,
0.049973812,
0.0053030504,
-0.0315962285,
-0.0204922631,
0.0094478158,
0.0587670319,
-0.0761657655,
-0.0776765719,
0.0064009763,
-0.0180467647,
-0.0104126586,
0.0204447415,
0.01470422,
-0.0340594724,
0.0191481337,
-0.027134629,
0.0648996532,
-0.0089588137,
0.0050481339,
0.0293729007,
0.0232210346,
0.0018119854,
0.0285469051,
-0.0222931542,
0.0089315567,
0.0315522328,
-0.0057780514,
-0.0150177171,
0.0265359059,
-0.0194644667,
0.0121681634,
0.060225293,
0.0183635708,
0.0284478068,
0.0472221449,
0.0119516738,
0.0567368753,
0.0179539304,
-0.0449187122,
0.0358898453,
-0.0262643453,
-0.0210061464,
-0.0053620827,
0.0583843142,
0.0303712003,
0.002054448,
-0.0015275845,
-0.0027527213,
0.0124540376,
-0.0206604004,
-0.0156250931,
-0.0608572848,
-0.0245145112,
0.0428595804,
0.005461121,
-0.0285628475,
-0.0178637672,
-0.0113640781,
-0.0644156784,
0.024189692,
0.0208532438,
-0.0074095349,
-0.0384469479,
-0.0515699536,
-0.0196983367,
0.0095603289,
-0.0219449792,
-0.0166058429,
0.0434086509,
-0.0243810154,
0.0057908203,
-0.0244804043,
0.0060304645,
-0.0239945389,
0.0219104551,
0.0176382009,
0.0688198656,
0.0453601666,
-0.051340647,
-0.114083685,
-0.0085545322,
0.0097536407,
-0.0282083042,
-0.0489346012,
0.0694340691,
-0.0208021477,
0.0111406324,
0.0175290499,
-0.0114488229,
-0.0005666025,
-0.0336189866,
-0.0193192065,
0.0261590928,
0.0213367641,
-0.0137916701,
-0.0139904935,
-0.0225115567,
-0.0101879044,
0.0798820034,
-0.0100568105,
-0.0018989196,
-0.0236525778,
-0.025876753,
0.0357762426,
-0.0246335473,
-0.0648929477,
0.0264094993,
-0.0196436755,
-0.0952003598,
-0.0241232198,
0.0234100912,
-0.0272517651,
0.050945539,
-0.0021930989,
0.0321167782,
-0.0220637638,
0.0227894019,
-0.1006349325,
-0.1197411343,
-0.037710242,
0.0343955867,
-0.0058590258,
0.0093989382,
0.0081399623,
-0.0158723444,
-0.0019471344,
0.0056939446,
-0.0358032212,
0.0118996063,
0.0374337658,
0.0060036723,
0.0212286934,
0.0347094648,
0.0096090389,
-0.0581747368,
0.0668933392,
-0.0015075956,
-0.0444981083,
0.0670476034,
0.0479961373,
-0.0481284894,
0.0282558594,
0.0252597257,
-0.0258563086,
0.0085353954,
0.0027561546,
-0.0033592014,
-0.0210538227,
0.0004992163,
0.050114572,
0.0183018316,
-0.0023013379,
-0.0367568396,
-0.0071987151,
0.0567981526,
0.0211727526,
-0.043320369,
-0.0154974954,
-0.0224713814,
-0.0183122884,
0.0315078236,
-0.0256359447,
0.0165461227,
0.0676906183,
0.0291154552,
-0.0687088966,
0.0077647851,
0.0306999814,
-0.0372670591,
0.0220275912,
0.0056433585,
0.0439376011,
0.0224326067,
-0.0217372589,
0.0426593125,
0.0107247643,
-0.0146424919,
-0.0290618576,
0.0230587572,
0.0157903377,
-0.017677702,
0.0304941386,
-0.0261158086,
0.0362063348,
-0.0378202647,
-0.0106139602,
0.0116351172,
0.0309222136,
-0.031222051,
-0.0330020115,
0.0065189041,
0.0135961808,
-0.0032723385,
-0.0112622399,
-0.0089538693,
0.0119304126,
-0.0193153992,
-0.0082506184,
-0.0217774194,
0.0534853898,
-0.023398323,
0.0068723434,
-0.0296567921,
-0.0244322401,
-0.0335697047,
0.040864598,
0.021771716,
0.0534426793,
0.0152768716,
-0.020021826,
-0.0348038003,
-0.0331330448,
0.0214818865,
0.0339970104,
0.060276743,
0.024179155,
0.0463732928,
0.0304159112,
-0.0002242616,
0.0268415604,
-0.019942604,
-0.0002266799,
-0.0016781745,
-0.0505652837,
0.0461579002,
-6.270701063e-33,
-0.0272550918,
0.0072697713,
-0.0303520542,
0.0550405532,
-0.0193395987,
0.0037876226,
-0.0173476934,
-0.0380295254,
0.0049096253,
-0.0200627521,
-0.0136113409,
0.0250955019,
0.0151406126,
0.0211575124,
-0.020099394,
-0.0052476679,
0.0178515688,
-0.0181168579,
-0.0132410526,
-0.0063062962,
0.0346905999,
0.0009227457,
0.0290209502,
-0.0413931422,
0.0016351399,
0.0004966033,
-0.0257805344,
-0.0300071351,
0.0393562652,
0.0223913752,
-0.0281192288,
0.0187896863,
0.0121902851,
-0.0613516383,
-0.0263247006,
0.0485990345,
-0.0484785289,
-0.0375005864,
-0.0106867794,
0.0224640202,
-0.0355252028,
-0.0858120248,
0.0343197547,
0.000633319,
-0.0472409278,
0.0076046502,
-0.0170706958,
-0.0241868235,
-0.0219572913,
-0.0808407664,
-0.0001325067,
0.0345635675,
-0.0331344083,
-0.0168877188,
0.1003558487,
-0.0295802653,
0.0093017248,
-0.0239357334,
-0.0261785816,
0.0606091954,
0.0188335031,
0.0494953878,
0.0182894301,
-0.0096323844,
0.0083231097,
0.0134185934,
0.0596782826,
-0.0520390235,
0.0277338829,
0.0489182658,
0.0300308745,
-0.02926239,
0.0393706746,
0.0757231563,
0.0971301571,
-0.0758026391,
-0.0390502997,
0.0524826832,
-0.043828994,
0.0111017711,
0.0061541703,
0.0686580464,
-0.0571497232,
-0.0263123401,
-0.0470954627,
0.0183896814,
0.0105599547,
-0.0240601022,
0.0068007731,
-0.0054425285,
-0.037090499,
0.0027819166,
0.0415018238,
-0.0419809259,
0.0193146057,
-0.0057698637,
0.0370419137,
0.035687089,
-0.0133379744,
-0.011967984,
0.015236482,
0.0044928449,
0.0554888248,
-0.0168420915,
0.0046491483,
-0.0338694341,
-0.006231904,
0.0617663786,
-0.0460570902,
-0.0223351996,
0.0241274517,
-0.0322807692,
0.0426465906,
-0.090495564,
-0.0008880357,
0.0087542022,
0.0047377981,
-0.0354160033,
0.0262516793,
-0.0364379101,
-0.0203044526,
0.0009266419,
-0.010382209,
0.0078589069,
0.0061819707,
-0.0005685942,
-0.0354017094,
-0.0162142497,
0.0978821963,
0.0031017005,
-0.0429952294,
0.0414418727,
3.103e-7,
0.0433540866,
0.0214751959,
0.0351051725,
-0.0375068076,
0.022515703,
0.0022851091,
0.014494055,
0.023866158,
-0.044420138,
-0.0123732891,
0.0197548047,
-0.0168449972,
0.0602590516,
0.0001748589,
-0.071474649,
-0.0187238585,
0.0073805093,
-0.0163559988,
-0.0098666744,
0.0408689678,
0.0857775882,
0.1199109182,
0.0031945878,
-0.0158954859,
-0.0267363191,
0.0331216082,
0.0166428294,
-0.0539540425,
0.0304240454,
-0.0263910592,
-0.0730993003,
-0.0356759652,
-0.0035974621,
-0.0044412706,
-0.0319363251,
0.0067681721,
0.0442760475,
0.0216667522,
-0.0068123229,
0.0019484925,
0.0032136866,
-0.0078918766,
-0.0442055091,
-0.0055770087,
0.057801716,
0.0217347313,
-0.04503626,
0.0279458873,
-0.0463378429,
0.0381733663,
0.0169820897,
-0.0095594171,
-0.0395980477,
-0.014244359,
0.0310401265,
0.0522500426,
-0.0045639202,
-0.0408389419,
0.0059475088,
-0.0342424773,
-0.035363894,
-0.0132634565,
-0.0265707467,
0.0040332214,
0.0331849717,
-0.064026013,
-0.0156412181,
3.03020472e-34,
-0.0143252034,
-0.0255958568,
-0.0143945077,
0.0107757058,
-0.0021105038,
-0.0194709469,
0.0137764821,
0.0417784862,
0.0112059228,
-0.0676143616,
-0.0280335173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01097v2 | DoctorGLM: Fine-tuning your Chinese Doctor is not a Herculean Task | 2023-04-03T15:57:51 | 2023-04-17T17:06:29 | Honglin Xiong, Sheng Wang, Yitao Zhu, Zihao Zhao, Yuxiao Liu, Linlin Huang, Qian Wang, Dinggang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent progress of large language models (LLMs), including ChatGPT and
GPT-4, in comprehending and responding to human instructions has been
remarkable. Nevertheless, these models typically perform better in English and
have not been explicitly trained for the medical domain, resulting in
suboptimal precision in diagnoses, drug recommendations, and other medical
advice. Additionally, training and deploying a dialogue model is still believed
to be impossible for hospitals, hindering the promotion of LLMs. To tackle
these challenges, we have collected databases of medical dialogues in Chinese
with ChatGPT's help and adopted several techniques to train an easy-deploy LLM.
Remarkably, we were able to fine-tune the ChatGLM-6B on a single A100 80G in 13
hours, which means having a healthcare-purpose LLM can be very affordable.
DoctorGLM is currently an early-stage engineering attempt and contain various
mistakes. We are sharing it with the broader community to invite feedback and
suggestions to improve its healthcare-focused capabilities:
https://github.com/xionghonglin/DoctorGLM. | [
0.0724527165,
0.0411765836,
0.001760997,
0.006487553,
-0.0056571867,
0.0181688573,
-0.0165378004,
0.0165284481,
0.0414045639,
-0.0112311291,
-0.0565459356,
-0.0747315362,
0.0121434424,
0.0370091945,
0.0154468585,
-0.0656081736,
0.0470566787,
0.0110207926,
0.0377547145,
-0.0021513079,
0.0166623183,
0.0099375211,
-0.0522606932,
0.0580524839,
0.017165862,
-0.0141479895,
0.0077773342,
0.0092815775,
0.0258360561,
-0.0542037077,
-0.0135576837,
0.0273947939,
-0.0252176728,
0.0006711618,
0.0000019284,
-0.0311270747,
0.0022062308,
0.0134846186,
-0.0414287522,
-0.0154775018,
0.0572028421,
-0.0531396866,
-0.0263910796,
0.0368212424,
-0.0470865667,
-0.0337261036,
0.0187148154,
0.0744518414,
0.061059285,
0.095095925,
-0.0024863337,
0.0098137166,
0.0207510851,
-0.0391665697,
0.0022532544,
-0.0634261817,
0.0175074786,
0.0384945534,
0.0486205816,
-0.0061362865,
-0.0085205864,
0.0458332635,
-0.0141235674,
0.012979228,
-0.0380070619,
0.0470580123,
-0.0254682992,
0.0055224779,
-0.0180972405,
0.0748920143,
0.0098549789,
0.0222958941,
0.0197924059,
0.0108218417,
-0.0032815856,
-0.0453896187,
-0.0531246997,
-0.0032634265,
-0.0187843814,
0.0093212575,
0.0008718316,
-0.0418231636,
0.0292771123,
-0.0022474723,
-0.0031818899,
-0.007857969,
0.0023761762,
-0.0165566858,
-0.0019580366,
-0.0111908829,
-0.0051149451,
-0.0120028732,
0.0358198434,
0.0478034802,
-0.0781571791,
0.0355733372,
-0.0167761799,
0.0408153348,
0.069513686,
-0.0646498278,
-0.0079365661,
0.0379218534,
-0.0112096313,
0.0300881267,
0.0129633378,
0.0225515738,
-0.0229356512,
0.0317295194,
-0.0654997528,
0.0028605133,
-0.0540488847,
-0.0188241713,
-0.0392047726,
0.0063213576,
-0.0039863624,
-0.036807552,
-0.0914872885,
0.0026621297,
0.00494806,
0.0176174715,
0.0208218209,
0.0457195491,
-0.0339271799,
-0.0044881138,
-0.022317389,
0.028602846,
0.0182959493,
0.0069169514,
-0.0195291098,
-0.0689249635,
0.0075457823,
0.0221146867,
-0.0136169828,
0.0102727897,
0.0024672288,
0.0764486119,
-0.0159671474,
0.0130949551,
0.0033270509,
-0.0173562244,
-0.0384104885,
-0.0398446918,
0.0134545071,
-0.0398313329,
0.0212927833,
-0.0007463514,
0.0377618931,
-0.0293091666,
0.0332426056,
0.0097741289,
-0.0341504849,
0.0414100476,
-0.0227161814,
0.015037613,
0.0138162402,
0.0483566001,
-0.000554781,
0.0431378596,
0.0157957897,
-0.0542506315,
0.0092600416,
-0.0238354933,
0.0095316051,
0.0184976887,
0.0042614285,
-0.034445487,
0.0163444597,
0.0084276665,
-0.0044182553,
0.0702158138,
-0.0115234507,
0.0792940632,
-0.0135162342,
-0.0182834454,
0.0325496942,
0.0436486267,
-0.0054153642,
-0.0030975067,
-0.0052682054,
-0.0150167821,
0.0017504075,
-0.001301823,
-0.0226701573,
-0.0102838557,
0.0141666643,
-0.0073363218,
-0.014816653,
-0.0055634277,
-0.0419613235,
-0.032956183,
-0.0496280529,
-0.0147749977,
-0.010499482,
-0.0092425672,
0.0109265931,
-0.0258975737,
-0.0246309228,
0.0749440938,
0.0453653112,
-0.036641974,
-0.0355844051,
-0.0584967658,
-0.0341457613,
0.0935285687,
0.0474147275,
-0.0158353951,
-0.0575627647,
-0.0162384268,
0.0101771113,
0.0307976995,
0.061049547,
-0.0150333755,
0.0148252528,
-0.0640675575,
0.0113333333,
0.044545386,
0.0067568868,
-0.0218258314,
0.0109715071,
0.0269133057,
-0.0045573204,
-0.000831133,
-0.0209246855,
0.023606224,
-0.0552845113,
-0.0191697385,
0.0019846314,
-0.0194209293,
0.0581794009,
0.0131694786,
-0.01457744,
0.0197154433,
0.014925641,
-0.0173274912,
-0.0129124969,
0.040960703,
-0.0563164055,
-0.0552609488,
0.0375988074,
0.0021910891,
-0.0123458728,
-0.0197044294,
-0.0504328907,
-0.0494391769,
-0.0347901098,
-0.0623067096,
0.0526367798,
-0.0243945103,
0.0413519368,
0.0531961843,
0.0193280187,
-0.0238378346,
0.0029527538,
-0.0130240628,
-0.0081070578,
0.0278602503,
0.028039217,
0.0048100725,
-0.0639536157,
-0.0250069145,
0.0287119895,
0.0067602047,
0.0273439027,
-0.0405546539,
0.0448836274,
-0.035322912,
-0.0314091258,
-0.1384346336,
-0.0116702393,
0.0035275256,
-0.0133389095,
0.029481139,
0.0247636251,
-0.0165706053,
-0.0271903779,
-0.0558654442,
0.0165519584,
0.0313511305,
-0.0154085066,
0.0078345211,
0.0369550288,
-0.0097248508,
-0.0128159281,
0.027188085,
-0.0353732407,
-0.0150079476,
-0.0057075666,
-0.0307872109,
-0.0176899284,
-0.035808742,
-0.0294855312,
0.002382633,
-0.0182177108,
-0.0632701516,
0.0029603532,
-0.0096831396,
0.0155691225,
0.0217956807,
0.0028931205,
0.0187863279,
0.0096134301,
-0.0104655717,
-0.029853195,
0.0326388218,
-0.0254914183,
-0.0382859632,
0.0003296162,
-0.0330243371,
-0.0223085936,
0.0858934596,
0.0166360196,
0.0463230684,
-0.0390547812,
-0.0403557383,
0.0005628914,
0.0193477124,
-0.0304828156,
0.0407566838,
-0.0586405061,
0.0205700267,
0.0110823885,
-0.0365817547,
0.0832531452,
-0.0279378947,
0.0070086499,
-0.0927032977,
-0.0314275138,
-0.0283386167,
0.0107553517,
-0.0336430967,
0.0245699007,
0.0265945345,
-0.0419943072,
0.0145923644,
0.0409562029,
-0.0269053467,
-0.0607674494,
0.0423045419,
-0.0320651419,
0.0202711597,
-0.001436079,
-0.0425488502,
-0.0492184311,
-0.0098366719,
-0.0562340319,
-0.001599422,
0.020449793,
0.0095336894,
-0.0560028553,
0.0541782975,
-0.0333876312,
0.065222308,
0.0168596711,
0.0025890046,
-0.0008935886,
-0.0030538393,
0.0222677048,
0.0282690283,
-0.0198937301,
-0.0148071712,
0.0675051585,
0.0724993274,
0.0101155071,
0.013299332,
0.0183631424,
-0.0093641989,
0.0068849907,
0.0019662681,
-0.0179219656,
0.0231710896,
0.0271926932,
-0.0633305907,
-0.0115336478,
0.1220845133,
0.0057642749,
-0.0509505942,
0.0241099242,
-0.0269018356,
-0.0119384574,
-0.0237914883,
0.0040280027,
-0.09171433,
-0.0506148003,
-0.0131220054,
0.0405180752,
0.0015006817,
0.0250645149,
0.0130202323,
-0.060589049,
0.037828628,
0.0151278805,
-0.0469884388,
-0.0243472569,
-0.0187994558,
-0.0030978364,
-0.0104185874,
0.0397908762,
0.0001679945,
-0.0222135801,
-0.0297695659,
-0.0047032097,
-0.057906732,
-0.0662736744,
0.042771142,
-0.0033543685,
0.0757135078,
0.0847328752,
0.0319012403,
0.0187835041,
0.0095885703,
0.0300605893,
0.0240844041,
0.019274896,
-0.0161874201,
0.0733575523,
-0.0040341699,
-0.008000426,
-0.0281263702,
0.028387418,
-0.0570162907,
-0.0091071473,
0.0272822808,
0.0530031472,
-0.0530771688,
-0.0166572109,
-0.0299149994,
0.0806758031,
0.0285224523,
0.0681635588,
-0.0030808358,
0.0148051223,
-0.0361876376,
-0.0039391136,
0.0161110312,
-0.0042002951,
-0.0322873294,
0.04280461,
-0.0160554424,
-0.0136510208,
-0.0644393712,
-0.0376668386,
0.0233556703,
-0.0196690634,
0.0098983748,
0.0141142271,
0.0095177218,
0.0442496687,
-0.0230374634,
0.0285033435,
0.0112743098,
0.0189469308,
-0.1014096811,
-0.0679230988,
0.0738653243,
0.0009161478,
0.0025873287,
0.0346690752,
-0.0254542939,
-0.0217473712,
0.0039155874,
0.0568676256,
0.0168158542,
0.0259242356,
-0.0130845914,
0.0158963595,
0.0001946309,
0.0271224566,
-0.0545008294,
-0.0082354061,
0.0170717482,
0.0208772104,
-0.0214614328,
0.0293857157,
0.0043797628,
0.0285685454,
0.0000131325,
0.0590979792,
-0.0330758616,
-0.0513783582,
0.0078412686,
0.0276195332,
0.0227612313,
-0.0023199474,
-0.0211231988,
-0.0223913975,
0.0523107015,
-0.0240106881,
0.0201395433,
-0.0376831889,
-0.0035150801,
0.0160635673,
-0.0365399905,
0.0070487871,
-0.0302651022,
-0.0782104433,
-0.0362156443,
-0.0274572484,
0.0297366548,
0.0114195272,
-0.0258878544,
0.0338830352,
-0.0157934316,
-0.014033515,
0.0364068337,
0.0128533486,
0.0134982709,
0.0002673849,
0.1059620678,
-0.0083105238,
0.0168054197,
0.0231269244,
0.0456317477,
-0.0505784824,
-0.086371623,
-0.0286407229,
0.0346926562,
0.0548252724,
0.0172164813,
0.0393872596,
-0.045313064,
0.0129097691,
-0.0365787558,
0.0214833971,
-0.0332858935,
0.0049530528,
0.0490734503,
0.007106863,
-0.0086275814,
-0.018959986,
0.1036516652,
-0.0094691832,
0.0510642938,
0.0373261124,
-0.0255659055,
-0.0608733222,
-0.0465707183,
0.0377805568,
0.0056661088,
-0.0573813431,
0.0232105739,
-0.0471776426,
-0.0464282148,
-0.0261038225,
-0.0210992992,
-0.0369527675,
-0.0353377536,
0.0565335713,
0.0351808593,
0.0148402005,
-0.0027790235,
-0.0308998656,
0.0506191216,
-0.0391457602,
0.0035145325,
0.0231415834,
-5.832407709e-33,
-0.0210423805,
-0.0009419865,
0.032056123,
-0.0224594958,
0.0022302943,
0.0272396319,
-0.0391012356,
0.0284528453,
-0.0364337675,
0.0195192825,
-0.0228626616,
0.0149018588,
0.0216998104,
0.0445004031,
-0.0113017848,
-0.0259152316,
0.0338792056,
0.0216735378,
-0.0082553988,
0.0551203787,
-0.0062279878,
0.0633238256,
0.0383340903,
-0.0743660331,
-0.0103495177,
-0.0017159289,
0.0099924514,
0.0194738116,
-0.0189197529,
0.0784405246,
-0.0396972075,
0.0314080045,
0.042373836,
-0.0030942634,
-0.0217194706,
-0.0017151763,
-0.0721192881,
0.0044460632,
0.0140168406,
0.0120395906,
-0.0246385355,
-0.0224810783,
0.0039470061,
-0.0345434621,
0.0013656472,
-0.0085204309,
0.0043469267,
-0.0408501774,
-0.0035332222,
0.0120343342,
-0.0264519174,
0.0529848598,
0.0007059082,
-0.0243247785,
-0.043854896,
0.0008616077,
-0.047069788,
0.0212661643,
0.0037172213,
-0.0075054602,
0.041071929,
0.0422878303,
0.0143352738,
-0.006474114,
-0.0122681232,
0.0537121035,
0.0252444837,
-0.0174314287,
-0.0231787264,
0.004401064,
-0.0479178242,
0.0437614657,
0.0317822397,
0.0254257862,
-0.0009019393,
-0.0209024046,
-0.0610993914,
0.026336031,
-0.0053801504,
0.0568932332,
0.0144172804,
0.0042523057,
-0.0480165482,
-0.020637406,
0.0233733412,
0.0164931193,
-0.013913352,
-0.0490979962,
0.0434700921,
0.0067261294,
-0.000884996,
-0.0024163458,
0.0296949036,
-0.0236249007,
0.0274910927,
-0.0055228975,
0.0251463763,
-0.0119920494,
-0.0533005781,
0.0165064,
-0.0627413988,
-0.0384068713,
0.0265961327,
-0.0135984821,
0.0233637784,
0.0256782472,
-0.0010347336,
-0.0266775861,
-0.0373593271,
0.0058866916,
0.0176609289,
-0.0039993008,
-0.02234005,
0.0467673689,
0.0146685326,
0.0019863714,
-0.0125519158,
0.0695073828,
-0.0213954914,
-0.0098274564,
-0.0744668618,
-0.0621033907,
-0.001798989,
-0.0049932636,
-0.0719417408,
0.0267954525,
-0.0452918373,
0.0339504853,
0.0268443897,
-0.0544404425,
-0.0080891615,
-0.0039459262,
2.599e-7,
0.0923599973,
0.0325979628,
0.026889421,
-0.0076350141,
0.0089286165,
0.003482908,
-0.028762944,
0.0266637094,
0.0034040022,
0.0075334581,
0.0376250409,
0.0180101488,
0.0631367713,
0.0334298424,
-0.0764523596,
-0.0138928611,
-0.1002317742,
-0.0413923264,
-0.0117420368,
-0.0233839974,
0.0304068998,
0.1127899289,
-0.0743025765,
-0.0229790471,
0.0302360039,
-0.0217034947,
0.0426419564,
-0.0518830977,
-0.0038502086,
0.0725927353,
0.0232957695,
0.0093552349,
-0.0085881976,
0.0065988009,
-0.0209268928,
-0.0093059698,
0.0005422942,
0.1360224336,
-0.0471926928,
-0.0160850957,
0.0295832232,
0.0103826588,
0.0295935646,
-0.0530545972,
0.0299760196,
-0.0451272056,
-0.0452989489,
0.0010120878,
0.0189035479,
-0.0465703681,
0.054032892,
-0.0300784167,
-0.0460271165,
0.0453088805,
0.033512719,
0.0133297946,
-0.0431908257,
-0.0762730911,
-0.0414449051,
0.0148700783,
-0.0527198799,
-0.0552696548,
0.0542234033,
-0.0338846929,
-0.0203701872,
-0.0623683259,
0.0041722027,
1.935271681e-34,
0.0444314964,
0.0007288813,
0.0010356518,
0.0717840567,
0.0384313017,
-0.0143357441,
0.0382483751,
0.0289504044,
0.0325266868,
-0.0535553433,
-0.0378702134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01089v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01089v4 | RPTQ: Reorder-based Post-training Quantization for Large Language Models | 2023-04-03T15:46:15 | 2023-05-17T10:07:33 | Zhihang Yuan, Lin Niu, Jiawei Liu, Wenyu Liu, Xinggang Wang, Yuzhang Shang, Guangyu Sun, Qiang Wu, Jiaxiang Wu, Bingzhe Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance,
but their deployment presents challenges due to their significant memory usage.
This issue can be alleviated through quantization. In this paper, we identify
that the challenge in quantizing activations in LLMs arises from varying ranges
across channels, rather than solely the presence of outliers. To address this
challenge, we introduce a quantization method called RPTQ, which utilizes a
reorder-based approach. By rearranging the channels and quantizing them in
clusters, RPTQ effectively mitigates the impact of range differences between
channels. To minimize the overhead of the reorder operation, we fuse it into
the layer norm operation and weights in linear layers. In our experiments, RPTQ
achieved a significant breakthrough by utilizing 3-bit activation in LLMs for
the first time, resulting in a substantial reduction in memory usage. For
instance, quantizing OPT-175b can lead to a memory consumption reduction of up
to 80%. | [
-0.0279209819,
0.060144458,
0.0102150748,
0.0382027812,
-0.0012364979,
0.0097989254,
0.0272375196,
0.0075494731,
-0.0256588478,
-0.0497516878,
-0.0193822384,
-0.0469598919,
-0.0182160046,
0.0190873146,
0.0017829979,
-0.0109622562,
0.0325033441,
-0.0294257253,
-0.0111696022,
-0.0157740675,
-0.0212608408,
0.011198693,
0.0140238628,
0.0165869817,
0.0284662768,
0.0013132212,
-0.0080458401,
0.0172969904,
0.0174159687,
-0.0195357725,
-0.0081243394,
0.0598504618,
0.044476524,
0.0504838191,
0.0000020252,
0.0077475607,
-0.0189783592,
-0.001031215,
-0.024896929,
0.0713712052,
0.0209189318,
-0.0123934615,
-0.0649921224,
0.0342835113,
-0.0001515261,
-0.0180106834,
0.0586889088,
-0.0013833061,
0.0574474074,
0.0711621866,
-0.0175321642,
-0.0382466912,
0.0262727272,
-0.019905651,
-0.002618843,
-0.0515329801,
0.023499269,
0.0190749615,
0.0077641262,
0.0118422052,
-0.0116030565,
0.0426284894,
0.0473477542,
0.0086333044,
-0.0100148339,
0.0230234321,
-0.0479648821,
-0.0023628536,
-0.028862536,
0.0302195009,
-0.0861416459,
-0.0473901518,
0.0100690881,
0.005988088,
-0.0402365476,
-0.0964267179,
-0.016155079,
0.0386326984,
0.034405034,
0.0320715159,
-0.0424139649,
-0.0081821671,
0.0516101457,
0.0165215619,
-0.0679012761,
0.0369237475,
0.0393677838,
-0.0090117333,
-0.0352928899,
-0.0185401868,
-0.0386602618,
-0.0284822211,
-0.0018226014,
-0.0194872767,
-0.0067429231,
-0.0084216353,
-0.0642843023,
-0.0222557038,
-0.0264554806,
-0.0594171882,
0.0035122698,
0.0777118728,
-0.004341953,
0.02127303,
-0.0359338075,
0.0576264821,
-0.0177484248,
0.0527549051,
-0.0428624153,
0.0255499389,
-0.0035400775,
-0.0116780158,
-0.0519487746,
0.0134638827,
-0.0337159038,
-0.034181878,
-0.0581160635,
0.0019368888,
-0.0039969166,
-0.0427669697,
0.0021655769,
0.0008120633,
-0.0121598337,
-0.0193020999,
0.0472510979,
0.0224368013,
0.0142956153,
-0.0135145355,
-0.0107254656,
-0.0551405102,
0.0100206323,
0.0188878886,
-0.0198817793,
-0.0283721369,
0.0046312041,
0.0003067387,
-0.0167513359,
-0.042422846,
-0.0036419516,
0.017351551,
0.0070606819,
-0.0412761942,
-0.0284676254,
-0.0510621443,
-0.0222798437,
-0.0082724364,
-0.0055208155,
-0.0133525422,
0.0119438078,
0.0012446737,
-0.0152898245,
0.0498799868,
0.0005035512,
0.0056121401,
0.0111119784,
0.0256848149,
0.0657494962,
0.0803508088,
0.0324362628,
0.0203198008,
0.0054402086,
-0.010150874,
-0.0106677553,
0.0481700525,
0.0188054424,
-0.0087298267,
-0.0706088617,
-0.0412590913,
-0.0174034201,
0.0282951146,
0.0892463475,
0.07165391,
-0.0834977403,
-0.0320584103,
0.0189405493,
0.0380351059,
0.0303246044,
-0.0055722906,
-0.0236355364,
0.0156316645,
-0.0077705402,
-0.0281429216,
-0.0571972542,
0.0287744384,
0.0335763134,
-0.0075381929,
0.0495785549,
0.0639973283,
-0.0270929504,
-0.0072520627,
-0.0303226057,
-0.0022706937,
0.0134042567,
0.0118095009,
0.0295201652,
-0.0150676193,
0.0017147437,
0.1141786799,
0.0009828726,
-0.0683708265,
-0.018140519,
-0.0936778337,
-0.0405452065,
0.0535570122,
0.0198531356,
-0.0314310752,
0.0048286472,
0.0486568771,
0.0114958053,
0.0107793584,
0.0031048055,
0.0190715771,
0.028648952,
-0.0670313612,
-0.0333294496,
0.0080266334,
0.0089071402,
0.017596351,
0.037652038,
0.0018061482,
-0.0114103034,
-0.0010510066,
-0.0105969124,
0.0142239323,
0.0243111514,
-0.0382282957,
0.04190173,
-0.0024118409,
0.0081004547,
0.0132406401,
-0.0283177625,
0.0113786748,
0.0431704782,
-0.0370728895,
0.0095274579,
-0.0365464874,
-0.0244371891,
-0.018682776,
0.0364829041,
0.0370574631,
0.024734037,
0.0444223695,
-0.055023022,
-0.0458901934,
0.0504546389,
0.0019555131,
0.060660895,
-0.0389289074,
0.0313473605,
-0.007042917,
0.0265174136,
-0.0346539542,
0.0144532342,
-0.0128370002,
-0.005586714,
0.0206780583,
0.0122636063,
-0.0083555095,
-0.0130821401,
-0.0225186758,
0.0133301606,
0.0075179823,
0.0540615357,
-0.0086485166,
0.0060473084,
0.0101649128,
-0.0098911058,
-0.0796321779,
-0.0002267777,
-0.0586950481,
0.0103849238,
0.0314688794,
0.0463341773,
0.0187596865,
-0.0324039422,
-0.025076,
-0.0225123912,
0.0010662486,
0.0194854364,
-0.0319027267,
-0.0129800243,
-0.0409406722,
-0.012387068,
-0.0619447231,
0.0216966569,
0.0412303731,
-0.0606262758,
-0.0460167117,
-0.0614550188,
0.0112804128,
-0.0099227866,
0.0590414405,
-0.0041787885,
-0.0658755898,
0.0120963631,
-0.0118168807,
0.0131813735,
0.0585375838,
0.0122477235,
0.024745997,
0.0989222452,
0.0219826438,
-0.0339431874,
0.0151934111,
0.0011942877,
-0.0431263931,
-0.0307317469,
-0.0038621658,
-0.0332076102,
0.0637761727,
-0.0268594027,
-0.0053285412,
-0.0291412007,
-0.0151665583,
-0.0221843831,
-0.0331849828,
-0.0593458042,
-0.0175201837,
-0.0519389808,
0.0527725331,
-0.0070058769,
-0.0496285781,
0.0085273935,
-0.0126683721,
-0.0166221242,
-0.0461622514,
-0.0137218731,
-0.0056093,
0.0491217002,
0.017928984,
0.0594372153,
-0.0522261634,
-0.0299142636,
-0.0524205193,
-0.0330850556,
-0.0337646119,
-0.0363672301,
0.0333311781,
-0.0202931296,
0.0427429117,
-0.03895301,
-0.0438326113,
-0.0043693678,
0.0135546625,
-0.0055461279,
0.0174280256,
0.0219129529,
-0.0504997112,
0.0236462466,
0.0792502686,
0.0077689355,
0.0576548092,
-0.0180387422,
0.0136448843,
0.0014871679,
0.0398338363,
0.0171740986,
0.0133786509,
0.0319840498,
0.0141372792,
-0.0197090711,
0.0333049111,
0.0243736356,
0.0321692154,
-0.0535166338,
-0.0075071696,
0.0572578758,
-0.0031385773,
-0.0091606537,
0.0001133038,
0.0650711134,
-0.0330496095,
-0.0028696056,
0.0770903602,
0.0337002426,
-0.0656158626,
0.0158592351,
0.0275505595,
0.0531794839,
0.0171672218,
0.0209029913,
-0.1111822203,
-0.0111836018,
0.0048181815,
-0.0026579571,
0.0219114926,
0.0460461304,
-0.0238999389,
-0.0806692615,
0.0165944956,
0.0348212644,
-0.0249396209,
-0.0268259421,
0.0118900025,
-0.042779956,
-0.0091956537,
0.0754749924,
0.0396738276,
0.0052594277,
-0.031735599,
0.0286637675,
0.0034578992,
-0.0585921258,
0.0294018276,
-0.0187913291,
0.0535281636,
0.0597982965,
-0.0029909059,
-0.0037410934,
0.0090825967,
0.0247391928,
0.019753512,
-0.0129218008,
0.0234002229,
0.0001488902,
0.0236894358,
-0.013512223,
0.0214728247,
-0.0172161777,
-0.0080716498,
-0.0199843701,
-0.0428352393,
0.0279140398,
-0.0093881832,
-0.0182759464,
0.0096208993,
-0.0188278947,
-0.0354620069,
0.0416409485,
0.0123867625,
0.0001448045,
-0.0575285144,
-0.0255950689,
-0.0002333795,
-0.0435338318,
-0.0404565483,
0.0038274676,
-0.0184570607,
-0.0791303739,
-0.0315457769,
0.0332083181,
0.0070063607,
0.0556333251,
-0.043781288,
-0.0125726955,
0.0240578596,
0.0087471977,
-0.07094796,
-0.0059708464,
-0.0062067597,
0.020266993,
-0.0512839705,
-0.0078477506,
0.0040833093,
-0.000115806,
-0.0201164372,
-0.0261908993,
-0.1283939034,
-0.0784216523,
0.0424907692,
0.0089142509,
0.0245315768,
0.0395395905,
0.0003146067,
-0.0841634572,
0.0667726249,
0.0425722413,
-0.0373258032,
0.0657666475,
0.0307007451,
-0.0398651175,
-0.0166900624,
0.0363759063,
-0.0421287231,
0.0487199649,
-0.0117905224,
0.0207075421,
-0.0681989864,
-0.0222253557,
-0.021159023,
-0.0150450123,
0.0558006056,
-0.0039780308,
0.0076480978,
-0.0071957894,
0.0493858121,
-0.0226274766,
0.0244757477,
-0.0319708996,
0.0181938615,
0.0381246209,
0.0124240909,
-0.0198962949,
-0.0110412296,
0.0691305026,
-0.0418361947,
0.0608478226,
0.0048334794,
-0.0157553852,
0.0086735934,
0.082045801,
-0.0050817048,
-0.0231988337,
0.0507681668,
0.0102693634,
0.0231627543,
-0.0521398447,
0.0026058494,
0.005874455,
-0.0171222445,
-0.0340198688,
0.0782360435,
-0.0487842597,
-0.0633623526,
-0.0255628172,
-0.0135819558,
0.0745599493,
0.0592945367,
0.0589000247,
0.0124207074,
-0.0382184163,
0.004613521,
0.0112638306,
0.0066495887,
-0.0064404542,
0.0241350997,
0.0164430328,
-0.0363066792,
0.0114551634,
0.0304673519,
0.0274486821,
-0.0104456693,
0.0118206562,
0.0058026584,
0.0224849507,
-0.0225413535,
-0.0523832664,
0.0199773461,
-0.0186373703,
-0.0086084893,
-0.0030687151,
-0.0453769751,
0.006986028,
0.0246564895,
-0.002673829,
-0.0328920782,
0.0074520735,
0.0392344594,
0.0095284302,
-0.0142289428,
-0.0372261517,
-0.0625999048,
-0.0108552612,
-0.0294782016,
0.014414249,
-6.606761674e-33,
-0.0026210127,
0.0282889176,
0.0213607419,
-0.051553838,
-0.0290588215,
0.0330296941,
-0.0088167358,
-0.0123267388,
-0.0022486036,
-0.0331848338,
-0.0162669122,
0.034303315,
0.0336167887,
0.0168633573,
-0.0181247424,
0.0265761726,
0.0932565629,
-0.0283483807,
-0.0156630334,
0.0451602265,
0.0054633357,
0.0136828376,
0.0505141653,
0.0392504036,
-0.0722264349,
0.024410177,
0.0003337554,
-0.0011441605,
0.0031173083,
0.041319795,
-0.0327544399,
0.0076750624,
-0.0033429405,
-0.0169974435,
-0.0166822914,
-0.0045710765,
-0.0460743159,
-0.0028585675,
-0.0103735738,
0.0379906222,
-0.0113628106,
0.0077030049,
0.0358866937,
0.024064092,
-0.0419268794,
-0.0131362006,
-0.0336230174,
0.0065589407,
-0.0420252308,
-0.0538267903,
-0.0019536449,
0.0364974812,
0.0411151834,
0.0250678211,
0.0680321157,
-0.0423986204,
-0.0467133932,
-0.0103390627,
-0.0917020589,
0.0006636433,
0.018289132,
0.0939805508,
0.0522815511,
0.0787805319,
0.0220397804,
0.0450915769,
0.0608434938,
-0.0261960309,
-0.0021588299,
0.048170723,
0.0634822845,
0.0037064056,
0.0266678855,
0.0135128191,
0.0992841497,
-0.0220401604,
-0.0674506798,
-0.0372740217,
0.0241504703,
-0.0003455925,
0.0465345681,
0.0611350462,
-0.0144865653,
-0.0449974053,
-0.0101704383,
-0.005061036,
-0.0459274575,
-0.0475096367,
0.022279596,
0.0294860005,
-0.0371740982,
0.0073044025,
0.0408261307,
-0.0289899856,
-0.0155707402,
0.0255238563,
-0.0108370101,
0.0296778884,
-0.005622481,
0.0489332117,
-0.041858796,
-0.0144357579,
0.0124965236,
-0.0041502197,
0.0017415299,
-0.0198768042,
0.0123364013,
0.0581557117,
-0.0811491236,
-0.0127416365,
-0.0185919516,
0.0137970587,
0.0141949449,
0.1040289924,
0.0066410499,
-0.0037133012,
0.0270375293,
0.0524627045,
-0.0348244086,
0.0136311734,
-0.016220659,
0.0125389397,
0.0410988592,
0.0334445164,
-0.0368184149,
0.0264540035,
-0.063839145,
0.0451587513,
0.0624720939,
-0.0670916736,
-0.0537626855,
0.0178733151,
2.808e-7,
0.0335874371,
0.0235762689,
0.0131040169,
0.0105794854,
0.0044185463,
-0.0171716604,
0.0089425426,
0.0129277529,
0.0089116981,
0.020637691,
0.0078751557,
0.0335311703,
0.007980559,
0.0102658179,
-0.0770825371,
0.0276646912,
-0.0604344159,
0.0168057773,
-0.0274945311,
-0.0504554994,
0.0141527299,
0.1372962147,
-0.0150901452,
-0.0077137132,
0.0412553996,
-0.0224827752,
0.0190263223,
0.0134285958,
0.0303128157,
0.0173012,
0.0344545133,
0.0126820616,
-0.0231056735,
-0.0274321306,
0.0078287134,
-0.0039220992,
-0.0503488332,
0.0912249088,
-0.0391518436,
-0.0539775006,
0.0054886001,
0.0096252477,
-0.0280416198,
-0.03002364,
0.0408840403,
-0.0590695329,
-0.0111401547,
-0.0961902887,
0.0002714233,
-0.03529495,
-0.0111039998,
-0.0165096298,
0.0050159395,
0.0257926174,
0.0125330873,
-0.0321229361,
0.0065952279,
-0.1025492847,
-0.0307150912,
0.0233228002,
-0.0068730847,
-0.0328801014,
-0.0442729443,
0.0009955452,
0.0020999459,
-0.0067903455,
0.0069051939,
2.718413568e-34,
0.0447134562,
-0.0066456017,
0.0254715215,
0.0323505066,
-0.0042922632,
-0.0164660234,
-0.0057997419,
0.0199027546,
-0.0392508358,
-0.0682018921,
-0.0171189606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01083v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01083v1 | Can the Inference Logic of Large Language Models be Disentangled into Symbolic Concepts? | 2023-04-03T15:39:35 | 2023-04-03T15:39:35 | Wen Shen, Lei Cheng, Yuxiao Yang, Mingjie Li, Quanshi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | In this paper, we explain the inference logic of large language models (LLMs)
as a set of symbolic concepts. Many recent studies have discovered that
traditional DNNs usually encode sparse symbolic concepts. However, because an
LLM has much more parameters than traditional DNNs, whether the LLM also
encodes sparse symbolic concepts is still an open problem. Therefore, in this
paper, we propose to disentangle the inference score of LLMs for dialogue tasks
into a small number of symbolic concepts. We verify that we can use those
sparse concepts to well estimate all inference scores of the LLM on all
arbitrarily masking states of the input sentence. We also evaluate the
transferability of concepts encoded by an LLM and verify that symbolic concepts
usually exhibit high transferability across similar input sentences. More
crucially, those symbolic concepts can be used to explain the exact reasons
accountable for the LLM's prediction errors. | [
0.0095555661,
0.0534660295,
-0.0491687581,
0.072452493,
-0.0518635884,
0.0165744293,
0.0008322864,
0.0281937812,
-0.006902691,
-0.0674323738,
-0.0269832723,
-0.005351414,
0.0167328604,
0.0460289717,
0.0336932242,
-0.0747508258,
0.0465991013,
-0.0430717953,
0.0102235349,
-0.0198575445,
-0.0172394086,
-0.0193077978,
0.0059058899,
0.0232280474,
-0.0051326901,
0.006199351,
-0.0143986503,
-0.0028058162,
0.008714987,
0.0192468856,
-0.0461557806,
0.0071084476,
0.0314202383,
0.0158415474,
0.0000017162,
-0.0501961485,
0.0479631685,
-0.0387903191,
-0.0542139076,
-0.0140628899,
-0.0151704755,
-0.0236216038,
0.0417067781,
-0.0158500597,
-0.0145578384,
-0.0259404965,
0.0404336527,
0.0673355758,
0.0195623431,
0.0474158637,
-0.0048887455,
-0.0199008547,
0.0103577217,
-0.0282234065,
0.0028737946,
-0.045470126,
0.0435422696,
0.0371459313,
-0.0231236536,
-0.0088007599,
-0.0334638618,
0.0317059234,
0.0287227426,
0.0448615849,
-0.0224634893,
0.0447870269,
-0.0314476676,
-0.0248704348,
-0.0049096602,
0.0701661631,
-0.0226237439,
-0.0086749783,
-0.0095784515,
-0.0016474144,
-0.0061427034,
-0.0071732691,
-0.0449629016,
0.0322478339,
0.0183029138,
0.037317317,
0.0478820242,
0.0246776752,
0.0461517498,
0.0346852653,
-0.0853188634,
0.0673816577,
0.0035040975,
-0.0194703359,
0.0035338567,
-0.0044668904,
-0.0554822572,
-0.0632264093,
-0.0370946862,
0.0317105912,
-0.0100381812,
0.0404261202,
-0.0658990294,
0.0045286585,
-0.0058105555,
-0.029498551,
0.0561534166,
0.0361924358,
0.0079702344,
0.0556658693,
-0.0422208272,
0.0849848017,
-0.0249381717,
0.0309503581,
-0.0302786808,
-0.0359131731,
-0.0473815724,
-0.0007681387,
-0.02779359,
0.0817492753,
-0.0118854977,
-0.0457046926,
0.0035237593,
0.0067923763,
-0.0051360247,
0.0290001035,
-0.0133127328,
0.004026548,
-0.0372779407,
-0.0329063646,
-0.0349137746,
0.0171239413,
-0.0225766972,
0.0444854274,
0.0005624699,
-0.0885072201,
-0.0014541852,
0.0156105431,
0.0326890945,
-0.0331901088,
-0.0096564675,
0.0856936574,
-0.0018318043,
-0.0196108725,
-0.0127740651,
-0.0349030718,
-0.0022211964,
-0.0791508034,
-0.0304635279,
-0.040444728,
0.0283863358,
0.0052614724,
0.0223286971,
-0.0772662908,
0.0276867393,
-0.0074441172,
-0.0197616164,
0.065298982,
0.0021875689,
0.0125109488,
-0.0220140349,
0.0187228136,
-0.0393904522,
0.0607098304,
0.0328147449,
0.0548388138,
0.0123221036,
0.0010912442,
-0.0296181142,
0.0131779034,
0.0342808589,
0.0046780175,
-0.079627797,
0.0054070069,
0.0154503826,
0.0155134769,
-0.0008864141,
0.1117574722,
-0.0272189938,
-0.0379664376,
0.0741765797,
0.0624324083,
0.0164804775,
-0.0110593177,
0.0534291789,
0.0046729441,
0.0241546184,
0.0133339819,
-0.0709720701,
0.0086001726,
-0.0256870296,
-0.0097572431,
-0.0012977328,
0.0122447573,
-0.0431823879,
-0.0443605296,
-0.0139606576,
-0.0072852727,
0.0064626923,
0.0225541312,
0.0541729555,
-0.0042655072,
-0.0244333372,
0.0478135534,
0.022907285,
-0.0145559115,
0.0014996754,
-0.0624236502,
0.0576005355,
0.0138511918,
0.0170264505,
0.0116554359,
-0.0379177853,
-0.0038827988,
-0.0343164802,
0.0283599161,
0.017888654,
-0.0016330997,
0.0490199998,
-0.0379223563,
0.0060994406,
-0.0180574395,
0.0318501778,
0.0315859616,
0.008075933,
-0.0055028088,
0.0168076586,
-0.0230503231,
0.0173226967,
0.0247119777,
0.0030031845,
-0.0235509127,
0.0091352528,
0.0089522218,
0.0827696994,
0.0022581394,
-0.0027724055,
-0.0089726737,
0.0260106903,
-0.0556326509,
-0.0181361809,
-0.0045637693,
-0.0536095649,
-0.0714793578,
0.0040901881,
-0.0140664475,
0.0141802281,
0.0752002969,
-0.0406476073,
-0.0630355254,
0.0433427133,
-0.0234077778,
0.0181953236,
-0.0225749575,
-0.0219619423,
0.0142130936,
0.0533331893,
-0.0012297822,
0.072300069,
0.0015466465,
0.0145573989,
0.0164082665,
0.0330746286,
-0.0076562664,
-0.0428012908,
-0.0241961479,
0.0129827112,
-0.0117486278,
-0.0108980667,
-0.0021079625,
-0.0405786932,
-0.0013014752,
-0.0171153825,
-0.0505588539,
-0.0187461581,
0.0077981437,
-0.0021072931,
0.0229664389,
0.0050590876,
0.0082864715,
-0.0040977597,
-0.0261130966,
0.001529379,
0.0175866671,
0.0128048109,
0.0358847678,
0.029874552,
-0.0485342853,
-0.02633054,
0.0033291571,
-0.0042532897,
0.0615574233,
-0.03626436,
-0.0476598032,
-0.0204761699,
0.0979357436,
-0.0250894725,
0.039796114,
-0.0305205826,
-0.0245340131,
-0.0116929151,
-0.0176289994,
-0.0135088153,
0.0867599174,
-0.0170021746,
0.0527488776,
0.0525286905,
-0.0446443483,
-0.0619404167,
0.0168219656,
-0.0087485276,
-0.0035174584,
-0.044820521,
-0.0333159529,
-0.0044264277,
0.0903828666,
0.0423908569,
-0.0023791024,
-0.0668885335,
0.0086046197,
-0.0034539781,
-0.0302932262,
-0.0387547798,
0.0163782649,
-0.0051447209,
0.0533129983,
-0.0075405748,
-0.0430575088,
0.0640823469,
-0.0173097663,
0.0097287167,
0.018966224,
-0.0550536215,
-0.0373571403,
0.0863604695,
0.0139853461,
-0.0086005256,
0.0387624763,
-0.0274203457,
-0.0716448575,
-0.0331767984,
-0.011217257,
-0.0134241041,
0.0644119978,
-0.0566519685,
0.0022384925,
-0.0235958677,
-0.0154219856,
-0.0522898212,
-0.0091929222,
-0.0478717387,
0.0283462945,
0.0056061312,
0.0011795923,
-0.0081652459,
0.0171315968,
-0.0112608448,
-0.0098411515,
0.0047373404,
0.0123823276,
-0.0531755351,
0.0364812165,
0.0615509152,
0.019909082,
-0.0269952845,
-0.0474906415,
0.0398738496,
0.0290807523,
-0.0135908574,
0.0272264946,
-0.0301117003,
-0.0049594482,
0.0138859218,
0.0135350563,
-0.0485187173,
0.0314593874,
0.0364530794,
-0.0569631681,
-0.0063855392,
0.1161115095,
0.0032447604,
0.010056342,
0.0175204575,
0.0201294478,
0.0031967852,
-0.0029093756,
-0.0053975009,
-0.1155799627,
-0.0533594489,
0.0181772262,
-0.0418173149,
-0.0331850797,
-0.0304795336,
-0.0244689342,
-0.0902229697,
-0.0240404662,
-0.0141973644,
-0.0531007238,
-0.0575874411,
0.0007749737,
0.048972249,
-0.0077321809,
0.0126221823,
-0.0207494814,
0.0355541408,
-0.034022551,
0.0059964894,
-0.0039107492,
-0.05674465,
0.0288723409,
0.0119067784,
0.0499886647,
-0.0039330106,
0.0483240597,
-0.0310641341,
-0.0221409891,
-0.0023913195,
-0.0407757722,
0.0038615512,
-0.0039936015,
0.0282957796,
-0.0169264879,
-0.0211739261,
0.016045101,
0.0372668803,
-0.0317623913,
-0.0259603187,
-0.0007341992,
0.0544393398,
-0.0421562977,
-0.067412816,
0.0064363549,
-0.0067887511,
-0.0203831922,
0.0895210654,
0.0357206985,
-0.0201803651,
-0.0218928456,
0.0018727407,
-0.0433885865,
0.0334127024,
-0.0177821312,
-0.0216352139,
0.0082886284,
0.0136522744,
-0.0648721606,
-0.0009434048,
0.0247904379,
0.0222267415,
0.0116373776,
0.0298132356,
0.0057285433,
-0.0055396496,
0.0046852846,
0.0146227572,
-0.0463459343,
0.0173522551,
0.0185749233,
-0.0166457556,
0.033940386,
-0.0081420327,
-0.0289036464,
0.0024735667,
-0.1132064387,
-0.0526916608,
-0.0115243979,
0.0363163501,
0.0290580578,
0.0270165093,
-0.001447366,
-0.0247866437,
0.047622297,
0.0308247209,
-0.0096288053,
0.0240455661,
0.0294822715,
0.0300348625,
0.0261440743,
0.0829990208,
-0.0434079058,
0.0396318026,
0.0269391313,
0.010410619,
-0.0630890802,
-0.0442830846,
0.0126158223,
0.0078248046,
0.0351013578,
0.0328167304,
-0.0225991905,
-0.021204181,
0.0208994113,
-0.0088013504,
-0.0291739795,
-0.0692782626,
0.0134055298,
0.035003297,
0.0462902002,
-0.0137784053,
-0.0565693304,
0.0287218671,
0.0243955776,
0.0017591605,
-0.0535379238,
0.0443114676,
0.0093175881,
0.0357327424,
0.0105069522,
-0.0376117788,
0.0017030508,
-0.0022443298,
0.0105017293,
-0.0024255207,
0.0450000353,
0.0416002385,
-0.0152339637,
-0.0474740379,
-0.0177851208,
-0.0625862256,
-0.0640601516,
0.0422000773,
0.026985785,
0.0354092941,
0.0285188053,
-0.0096839741,
-0.047379788,
0.0104768677,
-0.0068951868,
0.0737476572,
0.0161638036,
-0.0131319966,
0.0693128929,
0.0296063665,
-0.0003211535,
0.0374554805,
0.066097714,
-0.0139248883,
0.0541899428,
0.0142784538,
0.0218011308,
-0.0400004908,
0.0003615695,
0.0414486341,
0.026573997,
0.019405961,
0.0591287985,
-0.0308651533,
-0.0927415937,
0.0319097005,
0.0053480691,
0.0278679933,
-0.0340628065,
0.0286009833,
0.0168053322,
0.0121696601,
-0.0402635224,
-0.0303976145,
-0.0027638844,
0.0077483142,
0.0082333302,
-0.0417320654,
-6.342404749e-33,
-0.0546717644,
-0.0093692988,
-0.0142250303,
0.023780264,
-0.0166835897,
-0.0006422932,
-0.0314840451,
-0.0293728206,
-0.0306286868,
0.0186794847,
0.0035219491,
0.0317588821,
0.0031718758,
0.0188714433,
-0.0318246707,
-0.0413772911,
0.0406336673,
0.0233774334,
0.005962824,
0.0034885472,
0.0393535085,
0.0062098084,
0.032641124,
-0.0482746176,
0.008768226,
0.0092875855,
0.0146402372,
0.0127642537,
-0.0052037183,
0.0301779769,
-0.0288525,
0.0289798826,
0.0188098624,
-0.0221607778,
-0.0221436322,
0.0445226654,
-0.0461825132,
-0.0449134372,
0.0725618526,
0.0027926189,
-0.0182594582,
-0.0414307453,
0.0335308947,
-0.0104704248,
0.0082761887,
-0.012852354,
0.0068829507,
-0.0150405951,
-0.0030956028,
-0.0456803329,
-0.0289269928,
0.0188087467,
-0.0008971863,
-0.0191842522,
-0.0046866182,
0.0148179037,
-0.0198430456,
-0.0364869721,
0.0020480168,
-0.0114144459,
0.0205973182,
0.0277984142,
0.0450373702,
0.0233150925,
0.013245753,
0.0720807984,
0.0192629807,
-0.0325375423,
-0.0350805372,
0.0097433692,
0.0307008475,
0.0628876686,
0.0317264013,
0.0338850655,
0.0512845777,
0.0236523673,
-0.0663579777,
-0.0271774959,
0.0074232966,
0.1062828377,
0.0538876504,
0.026429655,
-0.0167907849,
-0.0256963931,
-0.0575297996,
-0.0071932236,
-0.0347160399,
-0.0258277245,
0.0339735895,
0.0003306282,
-0.013726633,
-0.0068358183,
0.0481387116,
-0.1004113555,
-0.0104181943,
0.0083803618,
-0.0057032034,
0.0269295219,
0.0019118809,
0.005992725,
-0.0609071888,
-0.0571533665,
0.0262262672,
0.0087369196,
0.0310780667,
0.0142522929,
0.0102481395,
0.0105829807,
-0.0206655767,
-0.0482918397,
-0.0369736254,
-0.0535647273,
-0.0416173413,
0.0062723169,
0.0548456833,
0.0395534299,
-0.0324190743,
0.0264689215,
-0.0315120406,
-0.0321654417,
-0.0047463882,
0.0048090741,
0.0100244563,
0.0105798477,
-0.0387323461,
-0.0376322083,
-0.0586920306,
-0.0336540155,
0.0348308124,
-0.0049301032,
-0.0038124188,
0.0097682131,
2.588e-7,
-0.0039221179,
0.0250793882,
-0.0129278768,
0.0524965376,
0.0207723323,
0.0303828716,
-0.0041315323,
0.0252610315,
0.0121266935,
-0.0510538965,
0.0132458508,
0.0454031825,
0.0445879921,
0.0232504308,
-0.0793311968,
-0.0070862425,
-0.0146338511,
-0.0444770157,
-0.0186504852,
0.0094992789,
0.0751166344,
0.1081791148,
0.0379594006,
0.0074503561,
0.0250359531,
-0.0308757573,
0.0435330197,
-0.0476206541,
-0.0045861271,
-0.0004758986,
0.0461860709,
-0.0053259945,
0.0233484115,
0.072565116,
0.0658865348,
0.037946444,
0.0073935362,
0.0654472336,
0.0014329988,
-0.0029122385,
-0.0640595555,
-0.0239769798,
-0.0218585487,
-0.0268821195,
0.092787005,
-0.0946704671,
-0.0551645905,
-0.0204975884,
0.0018955301,
-0.0182663407,
0.0061028684,
0.0245890003,
-0.0124054952,
-0.0007646775,
0.0166087337,
-0.0197478514,
-0.0171391051,
-0.0753744319,
-0.002219598,
0.0094094025,
-0.0776318312,
-0.0538046993,
-0.0228076037,
-0.0334591605,
0.0180519316,
-0.0543861389,
-0.0041507599,
2.148996757e-34,
0.0070064822,
-0.0129561312,
0.0209003352,
0.0541314334,
0.021827003,
-0.0341045596,
-0.0459252521,
0.0264642816,
0.0496053882,
-0.0910679623,
0.0047635925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01046v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01046v4 | Deep Manifold Learning for Reading Comprehension and Logical Reasoning Tasks with Polytuplet Loss | 2023-04-03T14:48:34 | 2023-12-22T22:18:54 | Jeffrey Lu, Ivan Rodriguez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | The current trend in developing machine learning models for reading
comprehension and logical reasoning tasks is focused on improving the models'
abilities to understand and utilize logical rules. This work focuses on
providing a novel loss function and accompanying model architecture that has
more interpretable components than some other models by representing a common
strategy employed by humans when given reading comprehension and logical
reasoning tasks. Our strategy involves emphasizing relative accuracy over
absolute accuracy and can theoretically produce the correct answer with
incomplete knowledge. We examine the effectiveness of this strategy to solve
reading comprehension and logical reasoning questions. The models were
evaluated on the ReClor dataset, a challenging reading comprehension and
logical reasoning benchmark. We propose the polytuplet loss function, which
forces prioritization of learning the relative correctness of answer choices
over learning the true accuracy of each choice. Our results indicate that
models employing polytuplet loss outperform existing baseline models, though
further research is required to quantify the benefits it may present. | [
-0.0220523719,
0.020142965,
-0.0201726016,
0.0461438335,
-0.0477541052,
0.0280096363,
0.0357632674,
-0.0240653139,
0.0668635592,
0.0249107927,
0.0353518054,
-0.0067341207,
-0.0265677832,
0.0400068983,
0.0315807536,
-0.0509581938,
0.0385041609,
-0.0246229339,
0.0323704258,
-0.0350963026,
-0.0273241159,
0.0110722808,
-0.0373374708,
0.0103561617,
-0.0436614268,
-0.0530568473,
-0.0134983286,
-0.0031508971,
0.0169860702,
-0.0197599158,
0.0320076197,
0.0189975444,
0.0409840234,
0.0495082773,
0.0000020312,
-0.0162790269,
-0.0334173888,
-0.0131422803,
-0.0282946862,
-0.0360221453,
-0.021277938,
-0.0002872296,
0.0454944,
-0.011929146,
-0.0151246386,
-0.0240680873,
0.0340704173,
0.0515103415,
0.0767790377,
0.0413571447,
0.003985601,
-0.0183397029,
0.0374359116,
-0.0060361703,
0.0378063992,
-0.0804341957,
-0.0049561528,
0.0486486927,
0.010495441,
-0.0104699172,
-0.0323402621,
0.0666898862,
0.0483916551,
0.0358662233,
0.009547649,
0.0557113104,
0.0316625573,
-0.0164386947,
0.0218797214,
0.0962696522,
-0.0195538234,
-0.0246517826,
-0.0212053321,
-0.0121850595,
0.0079472177,
0.00262805,
-0.0374104641,
0.0202612747,
-0.0107305283,
-0.0183423273,
-0.0180518553,
-0.0025455011,
0.0295905471,
0.0117140794,
-0.0361680388,
0.0801938921,
0.0007741073,
-0.0290990956,
0.0375496186,
-0.0127758551,
-0.0392358936,
-0.0129107423,
0.0399973691,
-0.0008741574,
-0.0061581121,
0.01312037,
0.0023219632,
-0.0484024622,
-0.0093644308,
-0.0233505797,
0.0375475883,
0.031831108,
-0.0034463045,
0.0866893083,
-0.0244062021,
0.0333801247,
-0.0554258563,
0.0896450654,
-0.0482543595,
-0.0324220285,
0.0036614337,
-0.045032721,
-0.0053880145,
0.0716055036,
-0.005460117,
-0.0071156672,
-0.0251730755,
0.0006197582,
-0.0081677707,
0.0326401405,
-0.016203668,
0.0384203754,
-0.0229300298,
-0.0710385144,
-0.0594200976,
0.0363518745,
-0.0520108119,
0.0390502363,
-0.003438259,
0.027690351,
-0.019224124,
-0.003248726,
0.000494121,
-0.0446549319,
0.0256703962,
0.0500532202,
-0.0232192799,
-0.0168926213,
-0.0178432427,
-0.042857457,
0.0236047879,
-0.0868447274,
0.0333471149,
-0.0592124127,
0.0311673731,
-0.0024293188,
-0.0092751374,
-0.0483285524,
-0.047524035,
0.0224902984,
0.0181998983,
0.0875039175,
0.0457641259,
-0.0126138125,
0.0813968778,
0.0093483673,
-0.0386601053,
0.0433906615,
-0.0134287439,
0.0277125239,
0.0196213219,
-0.0293702092,
-0.0135131991,
0.00384085,
0.0377403274,
-0.0181393791,
-0.0013998902,
0.0307996497,
-0.0167187229,
0.0865535215,
0.0236538202,
0.0315508023,
-0.0666299388,
-0.0615590774,
0.0380561091,
0.0214836914,
0.0572393909,
0.021646997,
0.0153661435,
0.0303455945,
-0.0120681943,
0.0218449906,
-0.0455712974,
0.0318869874,
-0.0055096527,
-0.0129791331,
0.0439510308,
-0.0269551948,
-0.029191386,
-0.0321257822,
0.0474199504,
-0.0015533877,
-0.0035172512,
0.0422726199,
0.0346983559,
-0.045200143,
-0.041829519,
0.0472532213,
-0.026108481,
-0.0202015173,
0.01764117,
0.0021363618,
0.0488463119,
-0.0048498162,
0.0038247216,
-0.0579442009,
-0.0387513787,
0.0113394232,
0.0515952744,
-0.0103400955,
0.0220879186,
-0.0090050735,
0.043588303,
-0.0427311398,
-0.0132617289,
0.0135239335,
0.0028841991,
0.0288451537,
-0.0005193172,
-0.024258798,
0.0040027588,
-0.0634007454,
0.0313373245,
0.0153914671,
-0.03463725,
-0.0563142188,
-0.0068267295,
0.0220994074,
0.0159579255,
-0.0263178814,
0.0240672436,
0.0049439515,
0.0294475164,
-0.0346522294,
-0.0591051318,
-0.0256122537,
-0.072656624,
-0.0395180285,
0.0360337459,
-0.0876870602,
-0.0316944011,
0.0635319948,
-0.0344404317,
-0.0543967113,
0.0046218913,
-0.0346100442,
-0.0486427583,
-0.0111795282,
-0.0550065711,
0.0335250236,
-0.0317024812,
-0.0587485731,
0.0460505076,
-0.0131192328,
0.0397932157,
-0.0193618499,
-0.0069925082,
-0.0026538782,
-0.0369015448,
-0.0205930118,
0.0077349511,
0.0093600908,
0.0167878959,
0.0026514409,
-0.0096322373,
-0.0529789068,
-0.0157290194,
-0.0303751603,
0.0112042008,
0.0003099065,
0.001650569,
-0.0110517805,
-0.0087142605,
0.0071048909,
-0.0244445279,
-0.0181497913,
0.0033784083,
-0.0205955524,
0.0126276575,
0.0318423696,
-0.0084280763,
0.0157688688,
0.0058931164,
-0.0647555068,
-0.0285005383,
0.0246978886,
-0.0202105716,
0.0520960204,
-0.0282352623,
-0.050475888,
-0.0075538624,
0.0417432897,
-0.0025892609,
0.0065774946,
0.013840693,
-0.0387514159,
0.0136931669,
0.091229707,
-0.0237474199,
0.0000445644,
0.0057343547,
-0.0090041189,
-0.0646952614,
0.0526668094,
-0.0771762282,
0.006052976,
-0.0303417128,
-0.0276680365,
-0.031371668,
0.0077891299,
0.0164062474,
-0.0030508498,
-0.0684705973,
0.0383413099,
0.0050002527,
-0.0271788109,
-0.0528901331,
0.0269064698,
-0.0016262131,
0.0646438077,
0.0042143743,
-0.0266427323,
0.0850697905,
0.0362881199,
0.0184097886,
-0.0558315851,
0.0503868498,
-0.0189862661,
0.0534659997,
0.022048993,
-0.0133455582,
-0.0348674618,
-0.0241677985,
-0.0591867976,
0.0379615203,
0.0504260696,
-0.0079617072,
0.0425622538,
-0.0631731972,
0.0050162794,
-0.0100856908,
-0.0259443689,
-0.0256903581,
0.004466977,
-0.0035482082,
-0.0228078086,
-0.062971212,
0.0113142412,
-0.036732614,
-0.059638042,
0.0310901329,
0.0239810087,
-0.0202476848,
-0.0015244004,
-0.0198800191,
0.0354610384,
0.0210061688,
0.0609205961,
0.0176910292,
-0.057894621,
0.0033667653,
0.0654978231,
-0.0045958729,
-0.0152291432,
0.0172834303,
0.0163830016,
0.0352380872,
-0.0108610028,
0.0072723813,
0.0247003194,
0.0424775481,
-0.0809422284,
-0.0072775795,
0.0626881868,
0.0217241514,
-0.0049308366,
-0.0151689285,
0.0045084953,
0.0484695323,
-0.0012808619,
0.0018388865,
-0.0455702581,
-0.0404711664,
-0.0022632454,
0.0248327162,
0.0237537976,
-0.0093894573,
0.033657033,
-0.0409644954,
-0.0071362364,
0.0113143958,
-0.0457748398,
-0.0185124744,
-0.0081939213,
-0.0376232564,
-0.0350169241,
0.0182295889,
-0.0172425993,
0.0359724723,
-0.0199543051,
0.0160908625,
0.001824005,
-0.0005101852,
0.0406813025,
-0.0259000026,
-0.0095879994,
-0.0052356822,
0.0237799529,
-0.0292906575,
-0.0776975751,
0.004526949,
0.0128586534,
-0.0487105399,
-0.0174729209,
0.0624023005,
0.0098021068,
-0.0008537091,
-0.0088235103,
0.0685665533,
-0.0356213711,
0.005842003,
0.0108005619,
0.1097234413,
-0.0049146754,
-0.0026770132,
-0.0523854494,
0.0058246679,
-0.0193827506,
0.0553997271,
-0.0001696145,
-0.0200232789,
-0.076420866,
-0.0091081224,
0.0467904732,
-0.073699683,
-0.0111811506,
0.0267368443,
0.0330647454,
-0.0387719013,
-0.0216547921,
-0.0144842295,
0.0226364098,
0.0399655476,
-0.0049560037,
-0.026396431,
0.0466427989,
0.0025151041,
-0.0614156052,
0.0433912687,
-0.0092341639,
0.0336822197,
-0.0102905538,
0.0309807491,
-0.0202016067,
-0.0331708565,
-0.0414429791,
0.0020567754,
-0.0912018493,
-0.0226394497,
0.0023384651,
0.0391214415,
0.0199751034,
0.0435697064,
-0.0087489281,
-0.0917799771,
-0.0215522833,
-0.0313742906,
-0.0043554925,
0.0185046811,
0.0463115796,
-0.0143608497,
-0.0231861379,
0.0293120444,
0.0036024395,
0.0016408708,
0.0023657542,
0.0063571995,
0.0011583751,
0.0164237358,
0.0209681876,
0.0163797569,
0.0088193947,
0.0292071067,
-0.0043830839,
-0.0372987092,
0.0548120961,
-0.0008340305,
0.004030643,
0.0043715946,
0.0039566974,
0.0365596265,
-0.0284714308,
-0.0231655762,
-0.0438883826,
0.0426298641,
0.0444044545,
-0.0389509164,
0.0151683213,
0.0292457826,
0.023597965,
0.0247322582,
-0.018662326,
-0.033378534,
-0.003985371,
-0.0323537178,
0.0778538063,
0.014764172,
0.0402766205,
0.0550312102,
0.0059680073,
-0.0199042149,
-0.0269827452,
-0.0430985987,
-0.0633493662,
0.0142660532,
0.0198835619,
0.0132094258,
-0.0056615844,
-0.0227032732,
-0.035980586,
-0.0345015973,
-0.0196407102,
0.0211805999,
0.0402572565,
-0.0049716984,
0.0803838968,
0.0152699938,
0.0370078385,
-0.038586989,
0.0462279208,
0.0000432141,
0.0268315729,
0.0069996896,
-0.003240583,
-0.074058786,
-0.0146637773,
-0.0382470042,
0.1032693088,
0.0000821393,
0.0509791784,
-0.0648288578,
-0.0496617593,
0.0261484738,
0.0340635106,
0.0047879508,
-0.0205813982,
0.0127041582,
0.0373277403,
-0.0029663134,
-0.050040625,
-0.0115017034,
0.0472739972,
-0.0358331911,
-0.0192749947,
-0.0133502996,
-6.042401326e-33,
0.0166059807,
-0.0288572274,
0.0389975086,
-0.0221233014,
-0.0412226915,
-0.0000308635,
-0.0027974555,
-0.0005433036,
-0.0423837118,
0.0169649888,
0.0283414144,
0.0221430603,
-0.0024229118,
0.0531286635,
-0.0163525082,
-0.021611046,
0.0017812804,
0.0130500179,
-0.0050327904,
0.0483783446,
0.0422942266,
0.009171892,
0.0455898829,
-0.0406755432,
-0.0225360561,
-0.010529913,
0.0039777313,
0.0520899706,
-0.0657575428,
0.0008313619,
-0.06441807,
0.0341346562,
0.0266142264,
-0.0299753249,
0.0205600001,
-0.0095667299,
-0.075193353,
-0.027104456,
0.0005587405,
0.0199052785,
-0.0745081306,
-0.0201583914,
0.0285555162,
0.0476518609,
0.0502426773,
-0.0940477997,
0.0293337125,
-0.0060401992,
-0.0593882687,
0.0343217216,
-0.0311853942,
0.0413397662,
-0.0395889916,
-0.0397096947,
0.0498674102,
0.0535773151,
0.0219657496,
0.0435180292,
-0.0677875727,
-0.0237899199,
0.0021257743,
0.0036628265,
0.0421487167,
0.0036447714,
-0.0065870406,
0.053763397,
0.0351839513,
-0.0073482813,
-0.0662627071,
0.0152746923,
0.0310218669,
0.0377200432,
0.0709259138,
0.0576458871,
0.0557411648,
-0.0221924707,
-0.0756868124,
0.0091605578,
-0.0421759039,
0.0221525393,
0.0157869831,
0.0144654643,
-0.0411837548,
-0.0037935418,
-0.0687343553,
0.0363671184,
-0.0417054109,
0.0244452357,
0.0293988828,
-0.0292266291,
-0.004514955,
-0.003221151,
0.0155287646,
-0.0226787385,
0.0078412127,
-0.0369242877,
0.0106774494,
0.0093951188,
0.0063312156,
0.047355108,
-0.0265221279,
-0.0016390411,
-0.028489314,
-0.0032629853,
0.0234911982,
0.0140065243,
0.0217196979,
0.0221112855,
-0.0244167633,
-0.0469591692,
-0.0497121625,
-0.0322924852,
0.0119509846,
0.0512747541,
0.0311778057,
0.0542484708,
-0.0253234897,
0.0364443995,
-0.0247162543,
0.0089791538,
-0.0291563775,
-0.0161050893,
-0.0126581863,
0.002577845,
-0.028982522,
-0.0122347642,
-0.0184720661,
-0.0379487164,
0.0198962856,
-0.0918108448,
0.0015992895,
0.0575587004,
2.623e-7,
0.0340029672,
0.0224860702,
0.0447454751,
-0.0034578443,
-0.0149342017,
0.0656502396,
0.0008423247,
0.0151707977,
0.0069107297,
-0.0284464117,
0.014375248,
0.0190505441,
0.0458785594,
0.0372662507,
-0.0820488483,
0.0049212091,
0.0083816908,
0.0412930623,
-0.04033475,
0.0097287074,
0.1193832085,
0.055040963,
0.0218596626,
-0.0412341319,
0.0491718389,
0.0547204465,
0.0406730101,
0.0070498865,
0.0219634026,
-0.0253483728,
0.0502922013,
-0.0193569455,
0.0372797474,
0.0567964874,
-0.0192108117,
0.0018779009,
0.0401215367,
0.0416572168,
0.0264385976,
-0.0576390028,
-0.0389285162,
0.0046027959,
-0.000226081,
-0.0598833486,
0.0774772391,
-0.073437348,
-0.0521492437,
-0.0086271605,
-0.0401165485,
0.0076272218,
0.0680236965,
0.0087872269,
-0.0406008959,
0.0231341813,
0.0106783733,
-0.0472897924,
0.0623103306,
-0.0810848847,
-0.0145145254,
0.0223137103,
-0.0604559034,
-0.0073334319,
-0.061130438,
-0.0025217342,
0.0467261113,
-0.0375493132,
-0.0405423455,
1.922956081e-34,
0.0070405286,
-0.0130560398,
0.0157871153,
-0.0022118315,
0.0118155973,
-0.0355146863,
-0.0043768412,
0.0038380576,
0.0222676564,
-0.0751051456,
-0.0281037781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01019v1 | Simple Yet Effective Neural Ranking and Reranking Baselines for Cross-Lingual Information Retrieval | 2023-04-03T14:17:00 | 2023-04-03T14:17:00 | Jimmy Lin, David Alfonso-Hermelo, Vitor Jeronymo, Ehsan Kamalloo, Carlos Lassance, Rodrigo Nogueira, Odunayo Ogundepo, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Nandan Thakur, Jheng-Hong Yang, Xinyu Zhang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | The advent of multilingual language models has generated a resurgence of
interest in cross-lingual information retrieval (CLIR), which is the task of
searching documents in one language with queries from another. However, the
rapid pace of progress has led to a confusing panoply of methods and
reproducibility has lagged behind the state of the art. In this context, our
work makes two important contributions: First, we provide a conceptual
framework for organizing different approaches to cross-lingual retrieval using
multi-stage architectures for mono-lingual retrieval as a scaffold. Second, we
implement simple yet effective reproducible baselines in the Anserini and
Pyserini IR toolkits for test collections from the TREC 2022 NeuCLIR Track, in
Persian, Russian, and Chinese. Our efforts are built on a collaboration of the
two teams that submitted the most effective runs to the TREC evaluation. These
contributions provide a firm foundation for future advances. | [
0.0262218341,
0.0138859348,
-0.0085833678,
0.0417638011,
0.0007704044,
-0.0089134304,
0.0133148087,
-0.0061029159,
0.0183508005,
0.009175241,
-0.0669817477,
-0.0475711487,
-0.0013378074,
0.0108047435,
0.0277911965,
0.001430596,
0.0392629392,
-0.0140756872,
-0.014584573,
0.0006376414,
-0.0224548671,
0.015275049,
0.0227482133,
0.0165110994,
0.0334058329,
-0.0110169696,
-0.0074691381,
0.0165810473,
0.0019028712,
-0.0386469029,
0.024791237,
-0.0044726823,
0.020002,
0.0939773992,
0.0000017357,
-0.0190688726,
-0.0340381116,
0.0086903293,
0.0503043197,
-0.0160098691,
0.0128041031,
0.0048337667,
0.0096797813,
-0.0072386782,
-0.0343554541,
-0.0428262241,
0.0138452733,
0.0447090641,
0.0491122827,
0.0562646054,
0.0013599255,
-0.0103251748,
0.0185040105,
-0.0644389763,
0.0079184445,
-0.0535584167,
-0.007611841,
-0.0350855999,
0.0018015082,
0.054071907,
0.0081297085,
0.0270479117,
0.0191614144,
-0.031987831,
-0.0023428791,
0.0125890737,
-0.0699588582,
0.0019387365,
0.0307239536,
0.044026088,
-0.039780952,
-0.0085743209,
-0.0140000936,
0.0464245453,
-0.013966742,
-0.0236735027,
-0.0643813163,
-0.0150453905,
-0.0200089402,
0.0180626139,
0.0104485955,
-0.0049714493,
0.0338105671,
0.0143885855,
-0.0227037854,
0.0797212869,
0.0215925276,
-0.037108779,
0.0472651161,
0.0162352752,
0.0459251925,
0.0004993711,
0.0637998208,
-0.0029304437,
-0.0490330234,
-0.0289596431,
0.0410232358,
0.0076730177,
0.0278790854,
-0.0818496272,
-0.0232117716,
0.0457424484,
-0.0268614069,
0.0578489713,
-0.0790430382,
0.0518738143,
0.0007438271,
0.0076870471,
-0.0548562147,
-0.0473737605,
-0.0004423191,
-0.0184844397,
-0.0230668262,
-0.005765174,
-0.0361237451,
0.0048752525,
-0.0432080589,
-0.0031506417,
-0.0032030968,
-0.0110270381,
0.0089522926,
-0.0083332993,
-0.0493923612,
0.02926521,
-0.027975956,
0.047358498,
-0.0287778098,
-0.0435811095,
-0.0314667746,
-0.0353179611,
-0.0081724878,
0.0181427188,
-0.0515020564,
-0.0445142128,
0.0235272925,
0.0129899401,
-0.0154794864,
-0.0196702592,
0.0092946878,
0.0116913831,
0.0334221274,
-0.047446169,
0.0305243079,
-0.0443218686,
0.0416201986,
0.003031743,
0.0242974963,
-0.0229997654,
0.003616476,
0.0309771337,
-0.0443695188,
0.0709784403,
0.0440438055,
-0.0320137478,
-0.0053271051,
0.0216374528,
0.0215374995,
0.0695434958,
-0.003563972,
0.0201622341,
0.0795626342,
0.0208811685,
-0.0518873855,
-0.0006513727,
0.0226226263,
-0.0067537925,
-0.0061410796,
0.0117058111,
-0.0132128587,
0.0240664296,
0.0189512558,
0.0128110731,
-0.0537943542,
-0.0276191961,
-0.0019348435,
0.0169406477,
0.0534692146,
0.0203263666,
0.0182104241,
-0.0423581712,
-0.0171496663,
0.0192877445,
0.0008123682,
0.0586585514,
0.0292538572,
0.0004535313,
0.0408450998,
0.0702880397,
-0.0729590133,
-0.027806839,
0.0104119377,
0.0155658489,
-0.0151994228,
-0.0218849424,
0.0595845766,
-0.0130335093,
0.0155977868,
0.0172949079,
0.0251420569,
-0.0571076013,
0.0640257224,
-0.0342996791,
-0.0142315421,
0.077039279,
0.0337402783,
-0.0501901507,
0.0020029761,
0.0598398671,
-0.0103306761,
0.0298864804,
0.0393173024,
-0.0523121729,
0.0462522656,
-0.0364947468,
-0.0385887735,
-0.0370424017,
-0.0119850915,
0.0428040549,
0.0026112546,
0.0414268896,
0.0333888419,
-0.0433193557,
0.0127609251,
0.012055737,
-0.05501711,
0.0253041741,
0.024492288,
0.0175336134,
-0.0312187504,
0.0098278532,
0.0011816885,
0.0254015177,
0.0494905114,
-0.0139109716,
0.0111467494,
-0.0121329352,
0.0047521,
-0.0373224393,
0.0267351847,
-0.0511702858,
0.0321974047,
0.063657552,
-0.0343606211,
-0.0457707942,
0.0401059873,
0.0260379128,
0.0109325917,
-0.057686653,
0.029590698,
0.0063391901,
0.0256510545,
-0.0303804372,
0.0449358523,
0.0118649593,
0.0547329932,
0.0142048169,
-0.038215477,
0.0194787178,
-0.0491982661,
-0.0755155757,
0.0754299611,
0.0168843772,
0.0132765723,
0.0419548154,
0.0322254039,
-0.0168991107,
-0.0080109676,
-0.08350683,
0.0171106402,
-0.0292375945,
0.0143369511,
-0.0067276922,
0.0195814501,
0.0187929962,
-0.0404303223,
-0.060413368,
-0.0199012309,
0.0196297467,
0.0532947406,
0.0233422294,
-0.0087672239,
0.0320529379,
-0.0459935144,
-0.0891898051,
0.002524805,
0.0563604534,
-0.0361736007,
-0.023524534,
-0.0502571426,
0.0011756284,
-0.0823375508,
0.0396879092,
-0.0299556125,
0.0000212049,
0.0075683724,
-0.0169282407,
-0.0074758776,
0.0579998717,
-0.0206830595,
-0.0230049472,
0.060984455,
-0.0151289962,
-0.0684427544,
0.0324361436,
-0.0156621281,
0.0320878997,
0.0169662312,
-0.0091982456,
-0.0326828137,
0.0092947669,
-0.0533992387,
-0.0368056707,
-0.0403392874,
-0.0093969423,
-0.0248701591,
0.0038987147,
-0.058072187,
0.0117113916,
0.0483772159,
0.0415325873,
-0.0295599606,
-0.0259222463,
0.0658371747,
-0.0187030174,
-0.0062089269,
-0.0568766706,
0.0095382119,
-0.0842421353,
0.0410419255,
-0.0082682716,
0.0174122583,
-0.0487277396,
0.0052378708,
-0.0425234362,
0.0077398964,
0.0035036341,
-0.0336803943,
0.0075303675,
0.0058574472,
0.0073275212,
-0.0321792848,
-0.0735228658,
-0.0019162296,
0.0067615993,
0.0313435905,
0.0252103377,
0.0129295858,
-0.0102882097,
-0.029039396,
0.0285120327,
0.0383573472,
0.0569840781,
-0.0394268036,
-0.005406186,
0.0169475675,
0.0706466511,
0.027359467,
-0.0425257608,
0.0143934088,
0.0055389968,
0.0352293141,
0.0566658787,
0.0648377836,
-0.0132548083,
0.0125625012,
-0.0139789544,
0.0840366185,
-0.0142154666,
-0.0614350736,
-0.0621817969,
-0.0296108201,
-0.024538802,
-0.0516511723,
0.0600411445,
0.0222019274,
-0.075954996,
-0.0190154333,
-0.0529759824,
0.0255897474,
0.041260872,
0.0567123108,
-0.0635113865,
0.0284828488,
0.0031200722,
0.0196803901,
0.0200401079,
0.0079835327,
0.0039932537,
-0.0924584419,
0.0045641847,
-0.0102750482,
-0.0574295409,
0.0104756951,
-0.0582127534,
0.0089565879,
-0.0111384038,
0.0080090845,
0.0138453729,
0.0035675154,
-0.0018832731,
-0.0183176193,
0.017572375,
-0.0391634144,
0.0071252971,
-0.0545838289,
-0.0315471664,
0.0359239168,
0.066925019,
0.0020141201,
-0.0371610001,
0.0126172435,
-0.0358821228,
-0.0267126765,
-0.0496169701,
0.0410290658,
0.001847522,
-0.0223828629,
-0.0046120146,
-0.0528984629,
-0.0241865255,
0.0321804658,
-0.0530212298,
0.041526068,
0.0070537273,
0.0323183946,
-0.0043138647,
0.0010469961,
-0.0114954645,
0.0502552912,
-0.0210380424,
0.0084867151,
-0.0283520278,
-0.0100704143,
0.0256231818,
-0.0508692004,
-0.0403125584,
0.0333639458,
-0.0204581544,
-0.0287791714,
-0.0520088486,
-0.0659615472,
-0.0151859,
0.0099924663,
-0.0230398346,
0.0441057459,
-0.0568827763,
-0.0258019231,
-0.0371264406,
0.0120311873,
0.0112050017,
0.0056809741,
-0.020632619,
0.0204461794,
0.0443394557,
-0.0366535299,
-0.0142246215,
-0.0088897077,
-0.0057521239,
-0.0351399332,
-0.0282052606,
0.052661486,
0.0179355405,
0.0070965718,
-0.0331827775,
-0.0267775971,
0.0596378632,
0.0124972789,
-0.0112934075,
-0.0212591719,
0.0168640707,
-0.0247552078,
-0.0313950107,
0.0519032776,
-0.0654310733,
-0.0115840584,
-0.0109301526,
0.064832814,
0.025353007,
-0.0257964544,
0.0222911835,
0.0130843651,
0.0454241224,
0.0008868064,
0.0391144864,
-0.0482040457,
0.0434129275,
-0.0403310768,
-0.0280372109,
-0.0223771781,
0.0130828433,
0.055620838,
0.0062345383,
0.009810687,
0.0536915623,
0.0241707172,
0.0460039712,
-0.062204089,
-0.0250333529,
0.0205079466,
0.0152713088,
-0.0341414064,
0.0132399946,
-0.0272035711,
0.0005109186,
0.0021434547,
0.0578483827,
-0.0695767552,
-0.0055967863,
0.0057365219,
-0.0244226214,
0.0005366549,
0.0566976443,
-0.0835456625,
-0.0318471305,
-0.0112257535,
-0.0244082138,
0.0846190527,
0.0149696814,
0.0827750489,
0.0255811233,
-0.0315148458,
0.0161382593,
-0.0456573032,
0.0259501506,
-0.0237441845,
-0.0250610542,
0.0193320066,
0.0188368522,
0.0207127519,
0.0726342276,
-0.013247476,
-0.0105772978,
0.0111110015,
-0.0445118994,
0.0115118455,
-0.0394390374,
0.0242366679,
0.006402703,
-0.0370053835,
-0.0548176654,
-0.0201212578,
-0.0393013731,
0.0136685204,
0.0340801105,
-0.0329929627,
-0.0047374256,
0.0313953832,
0.0900159702,
0.0358429439,
-0.015776908,
-0.0450538136,
-0.0249510705,
-0.0310076326,
-0.0364495926,
0.0053592715,
-6.005526068e-33,
-0.028744882,
0.0461581424,
0.011604839,
-0.0287496224,
-0.0193491094,
0.021724198,
-0.0044120271,
-0.0225593206,
-0.0360293277,
0.0047175977,
-0.0409529619,
0.0196373388,
0.0190826766,
-0.0027494079,
0.0144821927,
0.004833471,
0.0312030278,
0.0102390321,
-0.0194748398,
0.046676483,
0.0806894228,
0.0465845913,
0.0841029286,
-0.0390348174,
0.0378797762,
0.0074621523,
0.0217228122,
0.0441606194,
0.00668725,
0.0811336488,
0.0012761697,
0.0055522583,
0.0425617807,
-0.0453036055,
0.0347373225,
-0.0294588059,
-0.0936491638,
-0.0278365463,
-0.0052973242,
0.0211196337,
-0.045101162,
0.0239895433,
0.013603895,
-0.0358586013,
0.0120756868,
0.0194988158,
0.0269577075,
0.0045941174,
-0.0364559144,
-0.0329331048,
-0.0256141368,
0.0020032739,
0.0271835905,
-0.0055940375,
0.0239159577,
0.1087446138,
0.0023007069,
0.0545670949,
-0.0722381175,
0.0310156737,
-0.1026035175,
0.0666618496,
0.0364155844,
-0.0038392271,
-0.0298931282,
0.0486761108,
0.047720287,
0.0066844551,
0.0534506515,
-0.0514456518,
0.0078530796,
-0.0090556974,
0.0311736278,
0.0400851034,
0.0185069758,
-0.0112098223,
-0.1064793766,
0.0548081808,
0.0285355859,
0.0714643076,
0.0078078709,
0.0058746515,
-0.0396449938,
-0.0250551738,
-0.0116897346,
-0.0774944872,
-0.0466303453,
-0.0384347923,
0.0062845559,
0.0233632568,
-0.0114473477,
0.0064715347,
0.0270250794,
-0.0144319683,
-0.0101546505,
0.0598146506,
-0.0025202751,
-0.0097572943,
0.0105378069,
0.0590102896,
-0.0145478537,
-0.0280618668,
-0.0299273953,
-0.0026548274,
-0.0031227856,
-0.0017223933,
0.0368860699,
0.0219762698,
-0.0317593031,
-0.0004072695,
-0.0332093909,
-0.0097314166,
-0.0365937203,
0.0553524345,
-0.0218616985,
0.0089222314,
0.0027039447,
0.0405970104,
0.0814480409,
0.0161240026,
-0.0337829106,
-0.0542749241,
0.0390879549,
0.0036882712,
0.0438547097,
0.0276846383,
-0.0546902008,
0.0438899733,
0.0236282013,
-0.0691119358,
-0.003356253,
0.0407573581,
2.605e-7,
0.0164418891,
0.0034836847,
-0.0064273253,
0.0208033007,
0.015020608,
-0.0227638837,
-0.0513737686,
0.0541733243,
0.0286900476,
0.0436851047,
-0.0057025305,
0.0254699886,
0.0225740764,
0.0530019514,
-0.0580048747,
-0.0259993337,
-0.0502256081,
-0.0456759408,
-0.0326692089,
-0.0483373329,
-0.008205832,
0.0812061056,
-0.0273505636,
0.0028928006,
-0.0319194682,
-0.0586020015,
0.0825851932,
-0.0018699768,
-0.0283876602,
0.0108476914,
0.0276060104,
0.009078077,
-0.0164310951,
-0.0146226129,
-0.0083492389,
0.061807353,
0.0729375184,
0.0335642807,
0.0053486149,
-0.0397206694,
0.0288577825,
-0.0029422089,
0.0044567334,
-0.0658602864,
0.0556497686,
-0.0075796149,
0.0105937477,
0.0252935775,
-0.01128159,
0.0254943222,
0.0688750371,
-0.0481637157,
-0.0615702197,
0.0196702182,
0.0110584581,
0.0089977439,
0.0024893712,
-0.0461968668,
-0.025071932,
0.0007975802,
-0.023198545,
-0.0426698588,
-0.0087445173,
-0.0366165787,
-0.0310059786,
-0.0031233772,
-0.008847178,
1.998740799e-34,
0.0447659381,
-0.0042970688,
-0.0165749975,
-0.0188262034,
0.0163086466,
-0.0344940461,
-0.0172637627,
-0.0092400759,
0.0024387364,
-0.0658993796,
-0.0452228673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01002v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01002v3 | Does Human Collaboration Enhance the Accuracy of Identifying LLM-Generated Deepfake Texts? | 2023-04-03T14:06:47 | 2023-10-09T21:57:47 | Adaku Uchendu, Jooyoung Lee, Hua Shen, Thai Le, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Advances in Large Language Models (e.g., GPT-4, LLaMA) have improved the
generation of coherent sentences resembling human writing on a large scale,
resulting in the creation of so-called deepfake texts. However, this progress
poses security and privacy concerns, necessitating effective solutions for
distinguishing deepfake texts from human-written ones. Although prior works
studied humans' ability to detect deepfake texts, none has examined whether
"collaboration" among humans improves the detection of deepfake texts. In this
study, to address this gap of understanding on deepfake texts, we conducted
experiments with two groups: (1) nonexpert individuals from the AMT platform
and (2) writing experts from the Upwork platform. The results demonstrate that
collaboration among humans can potentially improve the detection of deepfake
texts for both groups, increasing detection accuracies by 6.36% for non-experts
and 12.76% for experts, respectively, compared to individuals' detection
accuracies. We further analyze the explanations that humans used for detecting
a piece of text as deepfake text, and find that the strongest indicator of
deepfake texts is their lack of coherence and consistency. Our study provides
useful insights for future tools and framework designs to facilitate the
collaborative human detection of deepfake texts. The experiment datasets and
AMT implementations are available at:
https://github.com/huashen218/llm-deepfake-human-study.git | [
0.0485407263,
0.0676228404,
-0.0240562726,
0.0562283993,
-0.0661440343,
0.0012058914,
0.0657899603,
0.0290435683,
0.0066927671,
-0.0320785195,
-0.0506030992,
-0.0600863546,
0.0122574801,
0.0351961628,
0.0127273537,
-0.0376664922,
-0.0034585081,
-0.0424115434,
0.012876085,
0.013110525,
0.0314826407,
0.0224174671,
-0.0159672312,
0.0464578979,
-0.0315895379,
-0.0269132573,
-0.0321198106,
0.0208716989,
0.0382385142,
0.0198810361,
0.00573547,
0.0744623989,
-0.0102122538,
0.0961140916,
0.000001919,
-0.0312022641,
-0.0173890255,
-0.0258421395,
-0.0254089832,
0.0175420474,
0.0200942773,
-0.0043503754,
-0.049429886,
0.013227867,
-0.0418354459,
0.0512121655,
0.0386053547,
0.04025032,
0.032818228,
0.065767087,
-0.0184504427,
0.007096942,
0.0537357219,
-0.0076166331,
-0.0094445683,
-0.0160874426,
-0.0070398534,
-0.0538044944,
-0.009892975,
0.0046216347,
0.0094739012,
0.0233634282,
0.0452054515,
-0.0526036024,
0.0069647045,
0.0249281619,
-0.0358614661,
-0.0599053651,
-0.0121780802,
0.0582362413,
-0.0091834366,
-0.0154694887,
0.0314156339,
-0.0293219853,
0.0209429543,
0.0586846918,
-0.0068269465,
0.0546468049,
-0.0378429703,
0.0094667589,
-0.0085042221,
-0.0147160282,
0.0181590449,
0.0143227782,
0.0411214791,
0.0689738095,
-0.0060296236,
0.0098789381,
-0.0322254561,
0.0206733588,
-0.0007779971,
-0.0673187375,
0.0878422484,
0.0128912563,
0.0161338802,
-0.0261145961,
-0.0752843842,
-0.0752285719,
0.0234663449,
0.0065965471,
0.0476755239,
0.0142999729,
-0.0709170848,
0.0152121214,
-0.0291422941,
0.0454807505,
-0.0278296974,
0.0420464315,
0.0014681101,
0.0161317289,
-0.0196882058,
-0.0196131077,
-0.0130147403,
0.0032146019,
-0.0270289928,
-0.0212903824,
-0.0307775307,
0.0044947239,
0.0066304607,
0.0031468978,
-0.0266934242,
0.0044070166,
-0.0309417471,
-0.007543182,
0.0105052982,
-0.0121880602,
-0.0200399309,
0.0179024898,
0.0096920384,
-0.0881304145,
0.007754528,
0.0497992374,
0.0226853136,
-0.0301914252,
-0.0048428117,
0.041327782,
-0.0103938179,
-0.0436620452,
0.0040282258,
-0.0736919492,
-0.0320649333,
-0.0422840342,
-0.0072608041,
-0.0754707009,
-0.0055179535,
-0.0200337432,
0.0044179661,
-0.0281079374,
-0.0142906178,
0.0137692122,
0.0161524285,
0.0605743751,
-0.0405755639,
0.0114824064,
0.0625527725,
0.0348163843,
0.0070229638,
0.0032166857,
0.0332602449,
0.0869697332,
0.0392656475,
-0.0005818127,
0.0451052748,
0.0493093617,
-0.0247106589,
0.0134113599,
0.0092526004,
-0.0366867557,
-0.0428556316,
0.0214288067,
0.0379027575,
0.0433445759,
0.0054395888,
-0.0182225034,
0.110093005,
0.1032657772,
0.0372113697,
0.0177553669,
-0.0205650292,
0.0475194752,
0.0085776439,
0.0375979207,
-0.0313703269,
0.0285396948,
-0.0173331071,
0.0032044291,
0.026703693,
0.0258219838,
0.0007785188,
-0.0234351419,
-0.001045046,
-0.0397560522,
0.0000435355,
-0.0159062091,
0.0196101088,
-0.0020052141,
-0.0314203911,
-0.0004619334,
-0.0392084159,
-0.0744559094,
0.012290352,
-0.0593580902,
0.0566854365,
0.0628493801,
0.0412569381,
0.0108445501,
0.0520742871,
-0.0172913931,
0.0215588659,
0.0542407334,
-0.0210964251,
0.0305483826,
0.0125335976,
-0.0401133411,
-0.0379339531,
-0.0110130031,
0.0002943229,
0.0072432002,
0.023259636,
0.0098929694,
0.043593362,
0.0127277412,
-0.0105068786,
0.03073892,
-0.0226265267,
0.0033011481,
-0.0415188447,
0.0236205421,
0.0025430869,
0.0515891165,
-0.0161158852,
0.011445595,
0.0115567204,
-0.0378511995,
-0.0256479904,
0.0128383841,
-0.0230358578,
0.0046468256,
0.0018393192,
-0.088585645,
-0.0146735031,
0.0544438213,
0.0012441839,
-0.0347084887,
-0.010923434,
-0.0386409983,
-0.0105767818,
-0.0526725575,
-0.006497764,
-0.0089154644,
0.0125059681,
-0.0098830294,
0.0380744562,
-0.0144636706,
-0.0341172554,
-0.0142315906,
0.0116600515,
0.0090244012,
-0.0464645214,
0.0065891873,
0.0139787728,
0.0013558059,
0.0268438645,
0.0048308265,
0.0042255884,
-0.0652220547,
-0.0241915472,
-0.0611825623,
0.0035232808,
-0.0229384489,
0.0405104868,
0.0422577187,
-0.0258636866,
-0.0203849208,
-0.0052893916,
-0.0456546657,
-0.0055037001,
0.0054514264,
0.0067931288,
0.0436290689,
-0.0324382968,
0.0042335177,
-0.031172771,
-0.007852003,
-0.0012350152,
-0.0124720652,
0.0585344732,
-0.0584390834,
-0.0622593239,
0.0268118642,
0.0075900448,
-0.0462398902,
0.0140305348,
-0.0610139146,
0.0267922338,
0.0042831744,
0.0239506699,
0.0740703046,
0.0045728716,
0.0211914796,
0.0323543996,
0.0274657924,
0.0050727688,
-0.023788482,
0.0206235554,
0.0248735193,
0.0057832105,
-0.0416748077,
0.0144192809,
0.0493832864,
0.0151596637,
0.009977527,
-0.0296700709,
0.0346728973,
-0.0173558723,
-0.0294132791,
-0.0004837299,
-0.073901318,
-0.0443415567,
0.0524821356,
-0.0357189327,
-0.0890838727,
0.0625369549,
-0.0410723574,
-0.0267017521,
0.0189303998,
-0.0433721989,
-0.0248811711,
0.0768061355,
-0.0005965149,
0.0274816267,
-0.0038485311,
-0.0531779639,
-0.0239156745,
0.0224890392,
0.0367671885,
-0.0197070781,
0.0497771092,
-0.0288944822,
-0.0168339331,
-0.0319334045,
-0.0110776201,
-0.017443506,
-0.0451652482,
-0.062881954,
0.0065031662,
0.0196845736,
-0.0447244607,
0.0014875621,
-0.0001822718,
0.0332081616,
0.0232910607,
-0.0028419439,
0.0085074408,
-0.0389457121,
0.0642126426,
-0.0046018916,
-0.0026119533,
0.0024309119,
-0.0759857446,
-0.0078426888,
0.0775354579,
0.0375075862,
0.0275371503,
0.0009953141,
-0.0285365265,
-0.0021634363,
0.0347482637,
-0.0528960675,
0.0018568916,
0.0743647218,
-0.0567842238,
0.0218344759,
0.0710493922,
-0.0082370471,
-0.0454250313,
-0.0112244617,
0.0082434574,
0.0157624166,
-0.0211832952,
-0.0317687914,
-0.089056626,
-0.0488038287,
0.0410051234,
0.0371011384,
-0.0088810446,
-0.0066342675,
-0.0101060402,
-0.0566796996,
0.0281306691,
0.0159533285,
-0.0050743581,
0.0127527714,
-0.0251679271,
0.0068196291,
0.0119456304,
0.006595816,
-0.0188497528,
0.0166491382,
-0.0007167755,
0.0123328064,
-0.0217082538,
-0.0202961899,
-0.0190565381,
-0.0531347506,
0.048251044,
0.0771142021,
0.0369388461,
-0.0264547318,
-0.0538041256,
0.0194879118,
-0.026091665,
0.031317696,
0.0060750465,
0.0745795444,
-0.0193168931,
-0.0017911716,
-0.0471372902,
0.0747429654,
-0.0376426131,
-0.007951837,
-0.008058737,
0.0210293252,
-0.0448761955,
-0.0506102592,
-0.0034153063,
-0.0042504617,
0.0008234418,
0.0612061918,
0.050542295,
-0.0274342801,
-0.0317222625,
-0.036213126,
0.0576979481,
-0.0705319345,
-0.0548910499,
-0.0025502483,
0.0173750091,
-0.0224966947,
-0.0724253654,
-0.033602532,
0.0004640991,
0.0173015706,
0.0119414218,
0.0246100649,
-0.0045200237,
-0.0030693216,
-0.0368735604,
0.0330751054,
-0.0217791628,
0.0605822578,
-0.075922884,
-0.0091472743,
-0.0325973704,
-0.0428035408,
0.0099431509,
0.0447437987,
-0.0933943018,
-0.0649970248,
0.0341674164,
-0.0007157022,
0.0276159756,
-0.0223606005,
-0.006174745,
-0.1114237159,
0.0575100183,
0.0532629788,
-0.0310347229,
0.022317484,
0.0248083305,
-0.0201603435,
-0.0152396848,
0.031928923,
0.0063080387,
-0.0181612317,
0.0166941173,
-0.0067717992,
-0.0395733826,
-0.0848023146,
-0.0132556604,
0.0251999069,
0.0380700491,
-0.033957988,
0.0453771763,
-0.042239178,
-0.0105222929,
0.0166819412,
0.008995668,
-0.0469029844,
-0.0017023176,
0.0194627009,
-0.0345046036,
0.0345360599,
0.0304418691,
-0.0131426807,
0.0419436991,
-0.0252678189,
0.0686159134,
0.0277346,
0.0679298937,
0.0086946301,
0.0136252558,
0.0058673359,
0.0681795627,
-0.034449134,
0.0410570353,
0.0411468893,
0.014500252,
0.0040032505,
-0.0312122367,
0.0146617368,
0.042549178,
-0.0690694526,
-0.0380530879,
0.0057241162,
0.0216718968,
0.0540646873,
-0.0000403936,
0.0550289638,
-0.0549531654,
0.0023415075,
-0.0280093066,
0.0397920087,
0.0105050541,
-0.0171946194,
-0.0157021601,
-0.0005278949,
-0.0135599235,
-0.001135239,
0.081135653,
0.0189000908,
0.0215932541,
-0.0003855883,
-0.0031811094,
-0.0279569253,
-0.0117243435,
0.026294725,
0.0281296875,
-0.0381770171,
-0.0217308756,
-0.0179121215,
-0.0390611887,
0.0156350229,
-0.0089434916,
0.0149127571,
-0.0244526546,
0.0138631528,
0.0177641734,
-0.0123563474,
-0.0316455141,
-0.0308226552,
0.034654431,
0.0115469005,
-0.0064081927,
0.0096501447,
-6.004899015e-33,
0.0104901036,
-0.1231810004,
-0.0467240177,
0.0017051669,
0.0036575261,
0.0351206549,
-0.0340524465,
0.017312672,
0.0245753881,
0.0062305615,
-0.0224252027,
0.0379637219,
0.0257292017,
-0.0026098683,
-0.0034703896,
-0.0144999493,
0.0418493897,
-0.0174263436,
-0.0177698359,
0.0263387598,
0.0262022279,
0.0417835675,
0.0561774746,
-0.0652727634,
0.05595164,
-0.0528593808,
-0.0437036417,
-0.0048640417,
-0.0338747688,
0.0703007057,
-0.0225274209,
0.0158236865,
0.021965364,
0.0163930021,
-0.0210543443,
0.0829185769,
-0.023272939,
0.0132875489,
-0.0346034989,
0.0068147243,
-0.0526518337,
-0.0638760701,
0.0583940521,
-0.0277673751,
-0.0206252169,
0.0067982152,
0.0545283742,
-0.0234459899,
0.012949992,
-0.0128979292,
-0.0187846534,
0.0327807702,
-0.0058907513,
-0.0082552116,
0.0779750571,
0.0261471607,
0.0166712031,
-0.0364739671,
-0.0860817805,
0.053231746,
0.0166855063,
0.0123097012,
0.0615983643,
0.0123771708,
-0.0295833368,
0.0542668216,
0.0467249118,
-0.006148966,
-0.0272780862,
-0.0289589074,
0.0068908576,
0.0577877201,
0.0708586127,
0.1138460711,
0.0175623447,
-0.0147975925,
-0.0166304447,
0.0375615694,
-0.0093628289,
-0.0321222879,
0.0242104419,
0.0282158442,
-0.0571381897,
-0.0081268633,
0.0009596843,
-0.0275790803,
-0.0311908592,
-0.0151142795,
0.0077126925,
-0.0085178502,
-0.0359925739,
-0.0302205384,
0.0114526683,
-0.0360753536,
0.0088856434,
-0.0242173281,
-0.0218233131,
0.0342093855,
0.0007830689,
0.0047218883,
-0.0528608002,
-0.0158230085,
0.0071031637,
0.037373554,
0.0418174043,
0.0162193682,
0.0344077311,
0.02621153,
-0.0512071885,
0.0144188283,
-0.0215112679,
0.01716296,
0.0358368307,
-0.0246141888,
0.0197606888,
-0.0581872016,
-0.0060469285,
0.0255469345,
0.032680776,
0.0121541582,
-0.0400279537,
-0.010090244,
-0.0506848693,
-0.0088056866,
-0.0319990292,
0.0050815181,
-0.0138711724,
-0.0141138695,
0.0762033015,
-0.0277235676,
-0.0008808344,
-0.0412308238,
2.486e-7,
0.0115038157,
0.0288366564,
0.057040602,
-0.0170190763,
0.0247994717,
0.0666225851,
-0.0093907863,
0.0311565809,
-0.0357503034,
-0.0107817845,
0.0023919861,
0.0250714291,
0.1007865071,
0.0331205651,
-0.045936957,
0.0201285798,
-0.0656405091,
0.0297098253,
-0.0753983557,
0.0246768314,
0.055884432,
0.0065594073,
0.0249630287,
-0.0555969216,
0.0223654807,
-0.0638803095,
0.0327230059,
-0.0291524082,
0.0065956451,
-0.0082963053,
0.0636067986,
0.0036559589,
-0.0072364039,
0.0278167278,
-0.0042609312,
-0.056645155,
0.026920205,
0.0582359508,
0.0155292172,
-0.002770043,
-0.0007203866,
-0.0259959064,
0.0171427988,
-0.0724736229,
0.0390500277,
0.0261056814,
-0.0230242796,
0.0041338406,
0.0223874711,
-0.0828529149,
0.0173602384,
-0.0186791997,
0.0049375794,
0.0164090469,
0.0098757884,
-0.0153042227,
-0.0293437466,
-0.0331863426,
-0.0631202906,
-0.0508390404,
-0.033051163,
-0.0049588401,
-0.0927928686,
0.0005318103,
-0.0044297609,
-0.0638670847,
-0.0043330663,
2.132402542e-34,
-0.0132044153,
-0.0009420661,
-0.0043071127,
0.0204305183,
0.0266280454,
0.0226891879,
0.0138292396,
-0.0127029307,
0.0092387144,
-0.0190228652,
-0.0133588389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00964v1 | Robust Text-driven Image Editing Method that Adaptively Explores Directions in Latent Spaces of StyleGAN and CLIP | 2023-04-03T13:30:48 | 2023-04-03T13:30:48 | Tsuyoshi Baba, Kosuke Nishida, Kyosuke Nishida | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Automatic image editing has great demands because of its numerous
applications, and the use of natural language instructions is essential to
achieving flexible and intuitive editing as the user imagines. A pioneering
work in text-driven image editing, StyleCLIP, finds an edit direction in the
CLIP space and then edits the image by mapping the direction to the StyleGAN
space. At the same time, it is difficult to tune appropriate inputs other than
the original image and text instructions for image editing. In this study, we
propose a method to construct the edit direction adaptively in the StyleGAN and
CLIP spaces with SVM. Our model represents the edit direction as a normal
vector in the CLIP space obtained by training a SVM to classify positive and
negative images. The images are retrieved from a large-scale image corpus,
originally used for pre-training StyleGAN, according to the CLIP similarity
between the images and the text instruction. We confirmed that our model
performed as well as the StyleCLIP baseline, whereas it allows simple inputs
without increasing the computational time. | [
0.06391415,
-0.0038087999,
0.0021680777,
0.0189696196,
-0.0217483863,
-0.0085814204,
-0.0090072518,
0.0250320509,
-0.0618476868,
-0.0546577573,
-0.0650663078,
-0.002290101,
0.0067630848,
0.0467971936,
0.003892648,
-0.0983382612,
-0.0060230279,
-0.0138453571,
-0.0067264177,
0.0119861001,
0.041813843,
-0.0198948961,
-0.013612912,
0.0122556025,
-0.0130596897,
0.0002627592,
-0.0449752919,
0.0651140735,
0.0296594761,
0.0135730691,
-0.0200013779,
0.0429082178,
0.0244757384,
0.0027659468,
0.0000019323,
0.0182768069,
-0.0035097711,
0.0099538881,
0.0731720179,
0.0126406224,
0.0863318816,
-0.0202659182,
-0.0733970106,
-0.0468269661,
-0.0243876502,
0.0463014096,
0.0927067697,
0.0994346589,
0.1127605736,
0.0617366731,
-0.0278075915,
-0.0591144934,
-0.0332681723,
-0.0265443679,
0.0377668701,
0.0040943855,
0.0028859698,
-0.0095011881,
-0.0200521294,
0.0442432463,
-0.041364342,
0.0622747205,
-0.0313921869,
-0.0464490168,
0.0090078777,
0.0418042429,
-0.0664669126,
0.0188753176,
-0.0097508328,
0.0392979011,
-0.0594152808,
0.0188529007,
-0.0119498083,
-0.0388599634,
-0.0045481301,
0.0492007621,
-0.0565250292,
-0.0232605524,
0.0114799272,
0.0163760651,
-0.0494856648,
-0.0379909799,
0.0085932557,
-0.0319223814,
0.0260240119,
0.0027356639,
0.0329308547,
-0.0264590774,
-0.0425917208,
-0.0018624624,
-0.0477525666,
-0.0218721647,
0.0713394433,
0.0049293069,
0.0150575778,
-0.0135618951,
-0.038817022,
-0.0517986156,
-0.003226494,
-0.0702982247,
0.0354132503,
0.0099271359,
-0.0269262306,
0.0587390102,
-0.0143444706,
0.0238775741,
0.0000237516,
0.0057123736,
-0.0174483526,
-0.0048041139,
-0.0170910694,
-0.0300193746,
-0.0478604063,
-0.0356942378,
-0.0579361767,
-0.0295545291,
-0.0343709998,
0.0106857838,
-0.0349548087,
0.021543188,
0.021926038,
0.0238463227,
-0.0472108945,
0.0060651992,
0.000123367,
-0.0255877022,
0.010396136,
0.0272485893,
-0.0457951464,
0.0419571288,
0.0317171067,
0.0410778299,
0.0523300059,
-0.0095985848,
-0.0073655192,
0.0335769281,
-0.048899211,
0.0327657312,
-0.0526308194,
-0.0030965304,
-0.0342018157,
0.0054429453,
0.0215018615,
-0.0373623185,
0.0008230039,
-0.0203519985,
-0.0326142423,
-0.0496816747,
0.0167761147,
0.0379120447,
-0.0459444523,
0.0637581274,
-0.0176964607,
0.0023116476,
0.0897309482,
0.0017570334,
-0.0402857028,
0.0109750703,
0.0316559039,
0.0408296026,
0.0791697428,
0.0035325917,
0.0127133457,
0.0720031485,
-0.0153990211,
-0.0500195771,
-0.0477649234,
-0.038326364,
-0.0114287436,
0.0137658743,
0.0201683808,
0.0551195368,
-0.0448298119,
-0.0341517441,
0.0641352683,
0.0512125678,
0.0182707217,
0.0438992195,
0.026508702,
0.0345263593,
-0.0172080919,
0.0088960901,
-0.03864979,
0.0517618619,
-0.0226111673,
0.0169814024,
-0.0066023842,
-0.0364951231,
-0.0313986912,
-0.0181029905,
0.010052518,
0.0171573367,
0.0152909728,
-0.068723768,
0.0612480342,
0.00023444,
-0.0646156669,
-0.0432594121,
-0.0370358787,
-0.048871085,
-0.0242095068,
0.0063641258,
-0.0043342337,
0.0525569282,
0.0357180387,
-0.021937497,
-0.0125880335,
-0.0028083082,
-0.0266714059,
0.0326130241,
0.0023274659,
-0.028504448,
-0.0077087572,
-0.0360124148,
-0.0221970063,
-0.038913358,
0.0010017924,
0.0017539851,
-0.0085222162,
0.0022687078,
0.0092195943,
0.0170412678,
-0.0491934903,
0.0544254072,
0.039591413,
-0.0345298462,
0.0005460084,
0.0418414176,
-0.0160867814,
-0.0029414096,
-0.0564397797,
0.0124028353,
0.0136102531,
-0.0425552726,
-0.0529517271,
0.0343984254,
0.0121226236,
-0.0515722334,
0.0193925444,
-0.0878534466,
-0.0262261853,
0.0001649644,
-0.03156811,
-0.0409741402,
-0.0062449062,
0.0062069963,
-0.019900322,
-0.0713430271,
0.0158242621,
0.0258444287,
-0.0240412802,
-0.0166481342,
0.032800056,
0.0063691689,
-0.0096947541,
0.0366673023,
0.0458111167,
0.0051435451,
-0.0179681908,
-0.0559344068,
-0.0385990813,
0.0088748606,
-0.0325024538,
0.0025116312,
0.050462164,
-0.0200067759,
-0.0197522994,
-0.0230821017,
-0.0237190127,
-0.0347300395,
0.0209674928,
0.0276829731,
-0.014831325,
-0.0068225316,
-0.0497528799,
-0.0478695743,
0.0133494614,
-0.0229122341,
-0.0211091414,
0.0592021309,
0.0370846875,
0.0339833386,
-0.0516968034,
0.0093521057,
0.022487184,
-0.0056612082,
0.057074938,
-0.0317820534,
-0.0453791097,
0.029614618,
0.0133215981,
0.0389110632,
0.0013091647,
-0.0378142633,
-0.0398320816,
-0.0099585671,
0.037985906,
0.0710826814,
0.0337272882,
-0.0095104398,
0.0359444246,
0.011701175,
0.0215115566,
0.0048892293,
-0.0185918156,
0.0261098705,
0.0594186746,
-0.0223996062,
0.0203299858,
0.0229022261,
0.0089674508,
0.042376738,
-0.0350557715,
0.0095095029,
0.0099698436,
0.036503952,
-0.0133631462,
0.004781228,
-0.0405628532,
0.0000976558,
-0.0442675278,
-0.0498686582,
0.0471525341,
-0.0276293382,
-0.0393785015,
0.0167763457,
-0.0061287694,
0.0131750964,
0.0684353486,
-0.0028762461,
0.0356471539,
-0.0435202345,
0.0014294062,
-0.0719017163,
0.0172430146,
0.0897367671,
0.0164965242,
0.0329864174,
-0.0493723564,
0.0131128142,
-0.0365912914,
-0.0171807539,
-0.0241753887,
-0.026039172,
0.0244217571,
0.0042775203,
0.0514030345,
-0.0269228164,
-0.0045819818,
0.0735877231,
-0.0176733248,
0.0804238841,
-0.0364250392,
-0.0170755126,
0.0040036468,
0.0457070507,
0.0367033072,
-0.0366929658,
-0.0900981128,
0.0124082202,
-0.0102671012,
0.068390362,
-0.028371226,
-0.0348052159,
-0.0063506695,
0.0318385847,
0.0125344591,
-0.0371117592,
-0.0151044726,
-0.0158549882,
0.0636651143,
-0.0128911184,
-0.0253915712,
0.0832126588,
0.0464688763,
-0.0327685438,
-0.0364561081,
-0.0331358463,
-0.0140066603,
0.0616759136,
0.0440215357,
-0.0627717227,
-0.0247944519,
-0.0129652983,
0.0349480845,
0.0111362329,
0.0189227927,
-0.0270347204,
-0.0454081856,
0.0465999544,
0.0106126256,
-0.0630207136,
-0.0476937704,
0.0131050497,
0.0447196923,
0.0115650957,
-0.069363974,
0.0175731424,
-0.0117431032,
-0.0105981268,
-0.0120390542,
-0.011352906,
-0.0241309013,
-0.0494885519,
-0.0422327109,
0.0014353085,
0.0664579347,
0.0249307491,
0.0145825585,
-0.0421757698,
0.0069974074,
0.0329073593,
0.0249329861,
-0.0258377045,
0.0533837527,
-0.0188099444,
0.0117656132,
-0.0056982683,
0.0498684682,
0.0367396958,
-0.0326731317,
0.0193416364,
0.0352655724,
-0.0544402003,
0.0010825103,
-0.0441980399,
0.0053300899,
0.0226134863,
0.0233682562,
0.0234104414,
-0.0447768681,
-0.0261228923,
-0.0486974679,
-0.0039337077,
-0.020029027,
-0.0426691808,
-0.0490450896,
-0.0439984575,
-0.0227320362,
-0.0960460901,
0.0076632937,
0.0461527742,
0.0375077799,
0.0254287012,
-0.0156313516,
0.0133516472,
-0.0075402367,
-0.071106948,
-0.0237828959,
0.026282046,
0.020830946,
0.001825189,
-0.0281251837,
0.0577544309,
-0.019975163,
-0.0223064255,
-0.0047188969,
-0.0182347354,
-0.0417105332,
-0.0168700498,
0.0571036637,
0.0063200891,
0.0243798029,
-0.0089886319,
-0.0518389009,
-0.001736816,
0.0355854034,
0.0392542072,
-0.005336131,
0.0203008242,
0.0020655505,
-0.007864818,
0.0148241194,
-0.050020244,
-0.0015511372,
0.0147880716,
0.0143502634,
-0.0228627399,
-0.00972478,
-0.0207831655,
-0.042535428,
0.0565049648,
-0.0157579724,
0.0193199161,
-0.0523653589,
0.0133935027,
-0.0280997399,
-0.0134096919,
-0.0387719683,
0.0320208818,
-0.0369166285,
-0.0107248435,
-0.0365838669,
0.0198776647,
-0.062499769,
0.0057720426,
-0.0602374114,
-0.0101118358,
0.0528626181,
0.0339697152,
-0.0043258718,
0.0346009023,
0.0131538734,
0.0272305403,
0.0260279067,
-0.0104606673,
-0.0207465235,
0.0897463933,
0.028814273,
0.0134766605,
-0.0414119288,
0.0330042429,
-0.042390462,
0.0137645416,
-0.0459802523,
0.0153598776,
0.0632598773,
-0.0277626254,
0.027088169,
-0.0273015033,
-0.033433564,
-0.0087792445,
0.0364891663,
0.0429511964,
-0.0474830531,
0.0523773767,
-0.0293954201,
0.0196314622,
0.0078813583,
0.057928998,
-0.0558544174,
0.027146019,
-0.0152736325,
-0.0539539382,
-0.0220024604,
0.0030590373,
0.0354263224,
0.0133678988,
-0.0357819721,
0.0060308482,
-0.0111312848,
-0.0214048456,
-0.0097682122,
0.037541844,
0.0001283062,
0.0346118249,
0.0504363216,
0.0301713441,
-0.0026526898,
0.0175031386,
-0.0024799432,
0.024070438,
-0.0322118998,
0.0129342396,
-0.0611584224,
-5.281394365e-33,
-0.0131382607,
-0.0508588441,
0.0032540064,
0.0529706217,
-0.0194979887,
-0.0546978526,
-0.0195731912,
0.0474000126,
0.0363586806,
0.0149118174,
-0.0006398399,
-0.0102936812,
0.0119050872,
-0.0007046327,
0.0098971175,
0.0616081767,
0.0736368075,
-0.0279904511,
-0.0202225503,
0.0000569712,
0.0183644034,
0.0293834899,
0.0645218641,
-0.0824198723,
-0.0132067101,
-0.0259328857,
-0.0158863142,
-0.0019762283,
0.037212681,
0.0222340524,
0.0169547014,
-0.0151917199,
-0.0189692564,
-0.050808683,
0.0109618623,
-0.0013936152,
-0.0252168309,
-0.0400079004,
-0.0333213173,
0.0637791455,
-0.0197346769,
-0.0319494791,
0.0439381003,
-0.0446543582,
-0.005776688,
0.0530820116,
0.0627066195,
-0.0176285785,
0.0346126184,
-0.067485027,
-0.0303223934,
0.0172713231,
-0.0155923516,
-0.0566929244,
0.0000474051,
-0.0075812731,
0.0468000658,
-0.0300424546,
-0.0878147557,
0.0202046242,
0.0298692733,
0.009602787,
0.0762193426,
0.0215904322,
0.0308508445,
0.0336140022,
0.0045906929,
-0.0222515985,
-0.0010862778,
-0.0300200284,
0.0132320523,
0.0245314557,
0.0130169978,
0.0139154708,
0.0653005168,
0.005142977,
-0.0153819639,
0.0516717173,
-0.0214499105,
0.0510337986,
-0.0059682918,
0.0494052097,
0.0509553514,
0.0091745043,
-0.005992915,
-0.0662710071,
-0.0274016857,
-0.0245783683,
0.0320659094,
0.0289295632,
0.0094928881,
0.0470735691,
0.0386050977,
0.0335471854,
0.0024016022,
-0.0139210438,
-0.0574158765,
0.0574588105,
-0.026513055,
-0.0625159815,
0.0035826575,
-0.0094273444,
0.0695787817,
-0.012814736,
0.0130933085,
0.0107217599,
0.0486697145,
0.0361231714,
-0.0486771837,
-0.0053356038,
0.0241347235,
-0.0288617387,
-0.0077393265,
0.0441467725,
-0.0141534377,
-0.0364022367,
-0.0340560041,
0.0185838081,
0.0223534182,
0.0370102413,
-0.0431295149,
-0.024817219,
0.0093047619,
-0.0280954149,
-0.0559788942,
0.0383127108,
0.0318226069,
0.0116754603,
0.0005497525,
-0.0509849675,
-0.0260684397,
0.0121610574,
2.475e-7,
0.0427206121,
0.030468652,
0.0262033902,
0.0128561715,
0.0263483245,
0.0329440646,
-0.0688799322,
-0.0136929024,
-0.0018973235,
0.0579443164,
0.0521667264,
-0.0221848041,
0.0046484279,
-0.0046876906,
-0.0229211431,
0.0068268478,
-0.0137849227,
0.0257725138,
-0.0055322275,
0.0236167889,
0.0896381289,
0.056710612,
-0.002550615,
-0.0163375717,
0.0300163403,
-0.0028361112,
0.1014864817,
-0.0149056418,
0.0640653595,
-0.0450355038,
0.0106762545,
0.0086123087,
-0.0404340103,
-0.0161945522,
-0.0327614844,
-0.023823576,
0.0223085638,
0.0777281076,
-0.0633974299,
0.0305255093,
0.0008781808,
0.0450671799,
-0.0012007678,
-0.0182021968,
0.0644477531,
-0.0720395818,
-0.015223016,
-0.0518370643,
-0.0375759229,
0.0583376698,
0.016033927,
-0.0405035764,
-0.0418282114,
0.017941758,
0.0369531102,
0.0367662795,
-0.0512613729,
-0.0678238124,
-0.0159822684,
-0.0014909033,
0.0185081679,
0.0099862712,
-0.0433700904,
0.0253666751,
0.007514779,
0.0212895274,
-0.0230912529,
2.054207143e-34,
0.0166767873,
0.020287266,
-0.0191881284,
0.0432970226,
0.0057546059,
0.0332341678,
0.0212232228,
-0.0059499228,
-0.0070259818,
-0.042462334,
-0.0702616125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00958v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00958v2 | DrBERT: A Robust Pre-trained Model in French for Biomedical and Clinical domains | 2023-04-03T13:25:53 | 2023-05-04T19:59:38 | Yanis Labrak, Adrien Bazoge, Richard Dufour, Mickael Rouvier, Emmanuel Morin, Béatrice Daille, Pierre-Antoine Gourraud | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, pre-trained language models (PLMs) achieve the best
performance on a wide range of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. While
the first models were trained on general domain data, specialized ones have
emerged to more effectively treat specific domains. In this paper, we propose
an original study of PLMs in the medical domain on French language. We compare,
for the first time, the performance of PLMs trained on both public data from
the web and private data from healthcare establishments. We also evaluate
different learning strategies on a set of biomedical tasks. In particular, we
show that we can take advantage of already existing biomedical PLMs in a
foreign language by further pre-train it on our targeted data. Finally, we
release the first specialized PLMs for the biomedical field in French, called
DrBERT, as well as the largest corpus of medical data under free license on
which these models are trained. | [
0.0330969915,
0.08247675,
0.0162906311,
-0.003830885,
-0.0263737179,
-0.0010257302,
0.0156432204,
-0.0087647997,
0.0154429711,
-0.0612756908,
-0.0484295338,
-0.0579011887,
-0.0185008869,
0.0413425155,
0.0148514193,
-0.0270726178,
0.0517479703,
0.0143094268,
0.0121033322,
0.0021776471,
0.0082629593,
0.0048412844,
-0.0336681232,
0.0363670774,
0.0350948982,
0.0306086279,
0.0425450988,
-0.0116229318,
0.0032919534,
-0.0586250722,
0.017737722,
0.0658915117,
-0.0066021364,
0.002864796,
0.000001845,
-0.0502804406,
-0.0296349898,
0.0192029588,
-0.0036408941,
-0.0174129326,
0.0426528789,
-0.0608818345,
0.0115206065,
0.0179113653,
-0.0476587825,
-0.0542818829,
0.0176612791,
0.0368446819,
0.0421472639,
0.0824524909,
-0.0139217395,
-0.0072375508,
-0.0196137745,
-0.0309556425,
-0.0345152467,
-0.0517185628,
0.041982092,
-0.0505399927,
0.0241275933,
-0.0090427566,
-0.0187916588,
0.0296457931,
-0.047506392,
0.0419174396,
0.0094314385,
0.0196841657,
-0.0228282493,
-0.0529571436,
-0.015844088,
0.0950210541,
-0.0298751071,
-0.0272002202,
0.010531961,
-0.0060100127,
-0.0273324307,
0.0139821982,
-0.0156028559,
0.0086749196,
0.0241041239,
0.0109784491,
0.023163354,
0.0150195593,
0.0357254073,
-0.0120697115,
-0.0484550558,
-0.0020239989,
0.0086184219,
-0.0278998669,
0.0490797088,
0.0216240678,
-0.0308933854,
-0.0037280244,
0.031053517,
0.0131974472,
-0.011627092,
0.021885559,
-0.0187542643,
-0.024258865,
0.0703532994,
-0.0592220128,
0.0071002529,
-0.0109850056,
-0.033996582,
0.043416407,
-0.0180458575,
0.0010442446,
-0.0382840447,
0.0459663942,
-0.0283256881,
0.0156338699,
-0.0476944968,
0.016591128,
-0.0252632461,
0.0176956784,
-0.0121316994,
-0.0084094992,
-0.066814214,
-0.0170358103,
0.0229820404,
-0.0215654224,
0.043657776,
0.0105189085,
-0.006389292,
-0.0210480187,
-0.0213828851,
0.0091834338,
-0.0038400351,
0.0375933833,
-0.0668960959,
-0.0711336061,
0.0094000194,
-0.0118936067,
0.0170662683,
-0.0275452062,
0.0283681247,
0.0859828517,
0.0185474101,
-0.0408275947,
-0.0130943758,
-0.0443298072,
0.0159610882,
-0.0447857641,
-0.0260821804,
-0.0657460913,
0.0286157206,
-0.0054807556,
0.0420130529,
-0.0735963061,
0.0300622154,
0.0037632943,
-0.0810436904,
0.0985292941,
-0.0685934797,
0.00587219,
-0.0024364968,
0.0221108198,
-0.0035139124,
0.0407016613,
-0.0067405086,
-0.0743366629,
0.0305059627,
-0.0170538276,
0.0432957783,
0.0460302942,
0.0378240421,
-0.0714512542,
0.0049088486,
0.0190762524,
0.0096953902,
0.0255409554,
0.0033558626,
0.0598397218,
0.0132752666,
-0.0092555014,
0.0273388308,
0.0680121556,
0.0209968351,
0.0112116961,
0.0070384396,
-0.0188500565,
0.0342677273,
-0.0271363705,
-0.0271501429,
-0.0655893087,
-0.0271232296,
-0.0134813981,
-0.0459457412,
-0.0061435108,
-0.0257282723,
-0.0188613012,
-0.0223467182,
-0.0336318128,
0.0092557007,
-0.0071198693,
0.0626695603,
0.01055279,
-0.0452679917,
0.0440428592,
0.059220016,
-0.0277634896,
0.0178092513,
-0.0237318687,
-0.0280450378,
0.0617819689,
0.040009331,
-0.0645536557,
-0.0143634044,
-0.033651527,
0.006672136,
-0.0060967882,
0.0204334278,
-0.0037737102,
0.0471356101,
-0.0323449597,
-0.0259747691,
0.0321343578,
0.0249460731,
-0.0204038415,
0.0118458429,
0.0524257757,
-0.0188080259,
-0.0249068402,
-0.0219575893,
0.059144441,
-0.0687874258,
-0.0224832967,
-0.0125820022,
-0.010958937,
0.0130908107,
0.0089898743,
-0.0283175576,
0.0313987806,
0.0317992792,
-0.0379477553,
0.0087426715,
0.0078923218,
-0.012793798,
-0.0367157273,
0.0245666988,
-0.0217727758,
0.0010585528,
0.0219729431,
-0.0219091289,
0.0137628075,
-0.0142113687,
0.0197052918,
0.0295463093,
-0.0060679652,
0.0558962785,
0.023210397,
0.0077761132,
-0.0398222432,
0.02916448,
-0.0181441326,
0.0521065779,
-0.0019507617,
-0.0301348306,
0.0122718643,
-0.0086072888,
-0.0406753309,
0.0000520711,
-0.0051582116,
0.0221189391,
0.0113081113,
0.0183708668,
-0.0085456939,
0.0070939786,
-0.0584120713,
-0.0012998946,
-0.0197601691,
0.0017183183,
0.0236481726,
0.0266385619,
-0.0206241757,
-0.0596022494,
-0.0317153148,
-0.0189792607,
0.0315442868,
0.012117926,
0.0358714834,
0.0441653319,
0.0065450761,
-0.0313266702,
0.0051638447,
-0.004210182,
0.0246446077,
0.0019416162,
-0.027523974,
0.0235827956,
0.0406263508,
-0.0275259465,
0.0485537685,
0.002977828,
-0.0337304957,
-0.0157858357,
-0.0357519463,
-0.0177676305,
0.0152799347,
0.0074004568,
0.0318449922,
0.0228243433,
0.018399626,
-0.0041492493,
-0.0197998602,
-0.0612027869,
-0.0361008346,
-0.0532834455,
-0.0170654263,
0.0328265615,
0.0819590017,
0.0024137343,
-0.0177694056,
-0.0049187383,
-0.0028329545,
-0.0105318697,
0.0025459623,
-0.0365508646,
0.0583525635,
-0.0183823854,
0.0716182739,
0.0155831911,
-0.0278411284,
0.0834393203,
-0.0151807489,
0.0462014824,
-0.0674315989,
-0.0416330844,
-0.0184971858,
0.0208008327,
0.0107044373,
0.0120684644,
0.0260020085,
-0.0522096194,
-0.010251713,
0.0249192324,
0.0112117548,
-0.0589405857,
0.0460986421,
-0.0131050069,
0.0121112494,
0.0117229214,
-0.0357318856,
-0.0611367151,
-0.0564380847,
-0.053761933,
-0.0124200014,
0.0174817406,
0.032972116,
-0.0606394857,
0.0079115164,
-0.0389450043,
0.1043419093,
0.0480738245,
-0.0049217618,
0.0033363397,
0.0047338437,
0.0079069594,
-0.003482579,
-0.0105200196,
-0.0277212411,
0.0030942298,
0.0486026667,
-0.0269623697,
-0.0172236636,
0.0002965676,
0.0014025627,
0.0329413898,
-0.0506915599,
-0.0200427677,
0.0251529198,
0.0237891655,
-0.0391182899,
-0.0206583608,
0.1295385212,
0.0249608643,
-0.0289631747,
0.0103038372,
0.0405320041,
-0.0413349532,
0.0026514234,
-0.0130280191,
-0.0630421564,
-0.0324845538,
-0.0083152307,
0.0120597137,
0.0092588533,
-0.0085585415,
0.0113849929,
-0.0606620833,
-0.0046423655,
-0.0135413399,
-0.0261374973,
-0.0031925272,
-0.0428490341,
-0.0194876622,
-0.0649364367,
-0.0039877254,
-0.0304421112,
-0.0388661735,
-0.0064309076,
0.0049834973,
-0.0686722845,
-0.1394717693,
-0.0112536391,
-0.0619746298,
0.0419954509,
0.0626740679,
-0.0028489919,
-0.0248327069,
0.0152155673,
0.049875021,
0.0119982492,
-0.0010438721,
-0.0216370858,
0.0516534857,
0.010309129,
-0.0170608722,
-0.00988896,
-0.0048183328,
-0.0411528535,
-0.027898863,
0.0060357023,
0.0646191761,
-0.032801386,
0.0172407441,
-0.0235709026,
0.0226927232,
-0.0011351428,
0.0577639975,
-0.0116290143,
-0.0098145725,
-0.0255263075,
-0.0050564515,
0.0052305944,
-0.0153910965,
-0.0719936341,
0.0360347256,
-0.0419850759,
-0.0313071758,
-0.0589519292,
-0.0136976046,
0.0530952178,
0.000066017,
0.025513228,
0.0381281339,
0.0466068834,
0.0141706765,
-0.0625313371,
0.0600918867,
0.0257292204,
-0.0259887315,
-0.108068198,
-0.0634032711,
0.0610074103,
-0.012744884,
-0.0334074274,
-0.0091670128,
-0.0128838848,
-0.0437160805,
-0.0082175555,
0.0555961728,
0.0180496965,
0.0220481493,
-0.009621283,
-0.0272035953,
0.0524861924,
0.0424992479,
-0.0658587068,
-0.0428307615,
0.0317834578,
-0.0412436202,
-0.022400571,
0.0113723474,
0.0018127237,
0.046003785,
0.0261879805,
0.0399817936,
-0.0039502056,
-0.036619693,
0.0311184917,
0.0152459294,
0.1103694737,
-0.0190630089,
-0.0035317212,
-0.0679604635,
-0.0003751632,
-0.0170954969,
0.0364486687,
-0.0220909733,
0.0164680555,
0.0647635162,
0.0030577129,
-0.0347246081,
-0.0045333663,
-0.0647292808,
0.0005242195,
-0.0423287116,
0.0338865295,
0.0343664326,
-0.0226415638,
0.0587273389,
0.0192814153,
0.0309142973,
0.0413718969,
0.0047300607,
0.0114650438,
-0.0388194397,
0.0405786112,
0.0046110093,
0.0567543469,
0.0002095866,
0.0323016457,
-0.0467032008,
-0.0288166087,
-0.0239883736,
0.0249562953,
0.0588691607,
-0.0297149979,
0.0310074724,
-0.0058302693,
-0.0077770734,
-0.0489769094,
0.0562378652,
-0.0225711782,
0.0035206804,
0.0315335616,
-0.011502279,
-0.0304701179,
-0.0139500992,
0.0975797176,
0.0367964096,
0.0277468711,
0.0223919749,
-0.0266018044,
-0.0377617441,
-0.0103969602,
0.0330844,
0.0053116581,
-0.0802686065,
0.0271540731,
-0.0275033321,
-0.0634897426,
0.0302433614,
-0.0397413485,
-0.0409092456,
-0.0033931138,
0.0478295423,
0.0344338194,
0.031869594,
0.0256836191,
-0.0467700623,
0.045436874,
-0.0049767559,
-0.0198761765,
0.0224165078,
-5.810417148e-33,
0.0176664069,
0.0030934021,
-0.0014593699,
-0.023328213,
0.0361604951,
0.0237434246,
-0.0069833016,
0.0128069734,
-0.0042492505,
0.0109348269,
-0.000570302,
-0.0074873473,
0.0197309926,
0.0445774086,
-0.0073618731,
-0.0490493067,
0.035484273,
0.0147660626,
-0.0244104844,
-0.0137927672,
-0.0274675619,
0.1121415123,
0.0679599792,
-0.0789144486,
0.0000613701,
-0.0323519781,
0.020692436,
0.0001804143,
0.0148185333,
0.0662894994,
-0.0392527692,
0.0206638798,
0.0305681564,
-0.0066569829,
-0.0215577725,
-0.0015940395,
-0.1081955358,
-0.0041590724,
0.0136162462,
0.0404804572,
-0.0240467768,
0.0115587059,
0.036046464,
-0.0352096483,
-0.0237890854,
0.0229990315,
0.040569596,
-0.04302397,
-0.0026532451,
-0.0400036983,
-0.0435229056,
0.0294049084,
0.0283370297,
0.0175648183,
0.0479799099,
0.0128097925,
-0.0318087637,
0.0529540144,
-0.0315585695,
0.0108706914,
0.023475429,
0.0327338576,
-0.0034193068,
-0.0475345887,
-0.0074497601,
0.0490038171,
0.0081826132,
-0.0322889015,
-0.0115004862,
0.0405120775,
0.0167410802,
0.018463783,
0.026063405,
0.0404280722,
0.027751483,
-0.0221418049,
-0.1015352532,
0.0198873617,
-0.0429979973,
-0.0077573811,
-0.0042686742,
-0.0253394898,
-0.0104342801,
0.0032588062,
-0.0308861136,
0.0136224395,
-0.0108426567,
-0.0108366311,
0.0310903043,
0.0347098149,
0.0211235024,
0.0280693937,
0.0179550387,
-0.0224655848,
-0.0347967148,
-0.012102887,
0.0438866168,
-0.0149199897,
-0.0348543562,
0.0357476622,
-0.0624694154,
-0.0315540805,
0.0016219197,
-0.0175182503,
0.0333667547,
-0.0167271011,
0.0287415721,
-0.0150328996,
-0.0588504784,
-0.0059176525,
0.0079188058,
0.0066844309,
0.0304468386,
0.0900931284,
0.0428112745,
-0.005544791,
0.0129569788,
0.0752064362,
-0.003796688,
-0.0212517697,
-0.03233473,
-0.0108664781,
0.0300972257,
0.0243974607,
-0.041357819,
-0.0198164042,
-0.0380789377,
0.0391866602,
0.0329732299,
-0.05913122,
-0.01597015,
-0.0532867908,
2.489e-7,
0.1167364195,
0.0182798039,
0.0005958562,
-0.0004071116,
-0.0120181963,
-0.0066957031,
-0.0373674631,
0.0303572603,
-0.0349532105,
0.0016053326,
0.0144781936,
-0.011262848,
0.0183101222,
0.0157305058,
-0.0534141064,
-0.0386119187,
-0.0359465219,
-0.0009400701,
-0.0159074292,
-0.035491392,
0.0370839164,
0.1142217144,
-0.0374482498,
-0.0095017767,
-0.030272739,
-0.0358562693,
0.0709053874,
-0.0422367379,
-0.0018791165,
0.044659473,
0.0048503769,
0.0765594468,
-0.0152308792,
0.0129469251,
-0.0471273847,
-0.0016159519,
0.0266457237,
0.0978889391,
-0.0223747063,
0.0156349801,
0.0393869989,
-0.0253964961,
-0.0031552403,
-0.0029821014,
0.0440487936,
-0.0580858663,
-0.0265217368,
-0.0035354751,
-0.0127895111,
-0.0362243243,
0.0794884115,
-0.0289524961,
-0.0031508945,
0.0475684479,
0.0465228446,
0.0278696846,
-0.0379611924,
-0.0998836681,
-0.0287844054,
0.0030886093,
-0.0024002739,
0.0105630998,
0.0635870844,
-0.0068524349,
0.0148936464,
-0.0435395241,
0.0359172821,
2.106399781e-34,
0.0403475538,
0.0020411988,
-0.0162648689,
0.0368829072,
0.0190583318,
-0.0383287445,
0.029322315,
0.0070932745,
-0.02165794,
-0.0150302052,
0.0031844119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01242v1 | Enhancing Clinical Evidence Recommendation with Multi-Channel Heterogeneous Learning on Evidence Graphs | 2023-04-03T12:15:53 | 2023-04-03T12:15:53 | Maolin Luo, Xiang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clinical evidence encompasses the associations and impacts between patients,
interventions (such as drugs or physiotherapy), problems, and outcomes. The
goal of recommending clinical evidence is to provide medical practitioners with
relevant information to support their decision-making processes and to generate
new evidence. Our specific task focuses on recommending evidence based on
clinical problems. However, the direct connections between certain clinical
problems and related evidence are often sparse, creating a challenge of link
sparsity. Additionally, to recommend appropriate evidence, it is essential to
jointly exploit both topological relationships among evidence and textual
information describing them. To address these challenges, we define two
knowledge graphs: an Evidence Co-reference Graph and an Evidence Text Graph, to
represent the topological and linguistic relations among evidential elements,
respectively. We also introduce a multi-channel heterogeneous learning model
and a fusional attention mechanism to handle the co-reference-text
heterogeneity in evidence recommendation. Our experiments demonstrate that our
model outperforms state-of-the-art methods on open data. | [
0.0250285007,
0.0029254651,
0.0130030308,
0.0082332902,
-0.0254135635,
-0.0302917957,
-0.017035421,
0.0248044915,
0.0411572419,
-0.0155256018,
-0.0405542552,
0.0213108715,
0.0020755846,
0.0475536846,
0.0050263801,
-0.0389413759,
0.0063826251,
0.0386110432,
0.0807917938,
-0.0083446484,
-0.003838642,
0.0036377821,
-0.0090107759,
0.0329359211,
-0.0087667918,
-0.025760306,
0.0332396775,
0.0033481007,
0.0261352696,
-0.0451342613,
-0.0196551979,
0.0009940999,
-0.0313263498,
0.011332362,
0.0000018226,
0.0040760939,
-0.0253382269,
0.0052295416,
0.0182409286,
-0.064045988,
0.0026257138,
-0.0181314778,
0.0506312624,
-0.035970699,
-0.017678462,
0.0026543338,
0.0346411169,
0.0796946213,
0.037700858,
0.0423301756,
-0.017563533,
0.0135215353,
0.0319845378,
-0.0139027173,
0.0481310263,
-0.0021902591,
0.0350134037,
0.0199309979,
0.0508815609,
0.0080833221,
-0.0236335415,
0.0075917216,
-0.0172333959,
0.0080470955,
0.0618282072,
0.0602318235,
-0.0195781589,
-0.0020179157,
0.0201961417,
0.1278530359,
-0.0291368142,
-0.019908309,
-0.0062271738,
-0.0238298047,
0.0086988537,
0.0552565716,
-0.0192770902,
-0.0133675607,
-0.0635567755,
0.0085697705,
0.0194972549,
-0.0144507792,
0.0413169377,
-0.0232509095,
0.0091124484,
0.0521667972,
-0.0256390981,
-0.0128449118,
0.0395765863,
-0.0164530464,
0.0072136866,
-0.0354345441,
0.0432760194,
-0.0070035802,
-0.0519386679,
0.0002921457,
0.0038355668,
-0.0051375162,
0.074615553,
-0.0502040759,
-0.0006326031,
-0.0198951066,
-0.0262880009,
0.0610505566,
-0.0129806371,
-0.1080694348,
-0.0382892638,
0.0520754978,
-0.0241370611,
0.008847205,
-0.0602753013,
0.0242973119,
-0.0061133443,
0.0196763575,
0.0263654068,
-0.053863667,
-0.0007430337,
-0.0013308558,
-0.0465475731,
0.0037699733,
0.0122068208,
0.0200730339,
0.0059442264,
-0.0201881975,
-0.0201607961,
0.0212868415,
-0.0090240957,
0.0554024763,
-0.0146727962,
0.0261728466,
0.018673813,
0.0484252721,
0.0285159536,
-0.0204453319,
0.0119908219,
0.0106256166,
0.0340591297,
-0.005075491,
-0.0302799474,
-0.0639959946,
-0.0478483811,
-0.0194445495,
0.0012677525,
-0.0815640166,
-0.0027758041,
0.0107074501,
0.0206969418,
-0.0305516738,
0.0170271862,
-0.0029869957,
-0.1029519737,
0.0281257015,
-0.0318356976,
-0.0372030064,
-0.0164257977,
-0.0031183925,
-0.033544533,
-0.0040422315,
-0.0034102562,
0.0274901595,
0.0081378166,
0.0334732942,
-0.0320634507,
-0.0641849637,
0.0699978843,
0.0236839317,
0.0343258716,
0.0363574177,
-0.0116171548,
0.0734400749,
-0.0175231304,
0.0429644957,
-0.0387840867,
-0.0536614172,
0.0329674296,
0.0118960375,
0.0669614226,
0.0165230017,
0.0155676836,
-0.0213462524,
-0.0407340229,
-0.0164050981,
-0.0186163094,
0.0211450513,
-0.0142188398,
0.0215610918,
0.0207299683,
0.0196848232,
-0.0324702412,
-0.0190922283,
-0.0220051426,
-0.0247729123,
-0.0135535449,
0.0025997483,
0.0360207632,
-0.0172438696,
-0.0210073125,
0.0056648003,
0.0621663779,
0.0360720605,
-0.0315145478,
0.0168973692,
0.0139006851,
0.0546280295,
0.0003399065,
-0.0589533746,
-0.0263460279,
-0.039698977,
0.0111812213,
-0.056309741,
0.0014254305,
0.0096931634,
-0.0101021593,
-0.0058200001,
-0.0465474017,
-0.0133697735,
-0.0027617302,
0.013161133,
-0.0560853183,
0.0250802357,
-0.0469503701,
-0.060287524,
-0.0200325008,
-0.0015072568,
0.0300961509,
0.0485386774,
0.0266690403,
-0.0142694479,
0.0351980999,
0.0512905456,
0.0035650248,
0.0501240902,
0.0374433175,
-0.0239992775,
-0.070274733,
-0.0262787063,
-0.0249778405,
-0.0229564328,
0.0434747413,
-0.1076042354,
0.003214183,
-0.0713917464,
-0.0211676918,
-0.0412810594,
0.0275048446,
-0.0625794232,
0.0501556806,
0.0416621305,
-0.0403234102,
0.0628240407,
-0.0078091174,
-0.0316034108,
0.0550145023,
-0.0081772394,
0.009950337,
0.0050851246,
-0.0416241251,
0.0193330385,
-0.0183335934,
0.0056261783,
-0.0097284894,
-0.0028860772,
0.0271738246,
0.0102530401,
-0.014706607,
-0.0256460067,
-0.0014513407,
-0.0375384204,
0.0104746977,
0.018672524,
0.002611147,
-0.0355760083,
-0.0098814052,
0.0141469184,
-0.0361598544,
-0.0684837401,
0.0263267849,
-0.0142367994,
0.0088220593,
0.0278290436,
0.0389145538,
0.0320813246,
-0.011599022,
-0.0575614348,
-0.0104611469,
0.0555723161,
0.0131202284,
-0.0202071778,
-0.0031214724,
-0.0379860066,
-0.0557322726,
0.003049968,
0.0115718301,
0.0692113265,
-0.0088081565,
0.0117591498,
0.0008552591,
0.0124864131,
-0.0531501584,
-0.028270334,
0.0640605614,
0.0309882481,
-0.050102476,
-0.0003312727,
-0.0487120859,
0.046694126,
0.0042234557,
0.0176817961,
0.0029908149,
-0.0028465313,
0.0365444385,
-0.0450969152,
-0.0442620777,
-0.029350901,
0.0275306366,
0.0335336588,
-0.0540130995,
-0.0102104405,
0.0318575427,
-0.0060254489,
-0.0414421484,
-0.0444767736,
0.1132861748,
0.018102495,
0.0494140275,
-0.0290083829,
-0.0243560467,
-0.0611876361,
-0.0389268845,
0.0259943083,
0.0370517112,
0.0368367881,
0.0029184308,
0.0166465547,
0.0185158402,
0.0476165935,
-0.0089225993,
0.0568189211,
0.024368545,
0.0428641811,
0.0240345597,
-0.0215536039,
-0.0107940501,
-0.026770426,
0.0022604917,
0.0158711262,
0.0033549813,
0.023536643,
-0.0750227198,
-0.0290184822,
0.0247768834,
0.0632816777,
0.0386507958,
-0.0312357731,
0.0097804768,
-0.0036018267,
0.0095292432,
-0.0125964219,
-0.0001069189,
-0.0007130287,
-0.0208973996,
0.0637588724,
-0.0482489914,
-0.0427984558,
-0.0251479894,
-0.0146970963,
-0.0369738676,
-0.0267839823,
-0.0167975072,
-0.0015557706,
-0.0177027825,
-0.0105615007,
0.0429284498,
0.0133414585,
0.0228520073,
-0.1081935912,
0.0305567216,
-0.0237269904,
-0.0074804486,
-0.0003803322,
-0.0291366652,
-0.0982902572,
-0.0306969546,
-0.045557715,
0.0048182937,
0.0258731488,
-0.0295428839,
0.0276148524,
-0.0112682413,
-0.0095233722,
-0.0033743088,
0.0239782259,
-0.0516699627,
-0.0795714557,
0.0250633322,
-0.0315252393,
-0.040920306,
-0.043740429,
-0.0101939244,
0.0073972843,
-0.0118218567,
-0.0142743904,
-0.0484840646,
0.0219839662,
-0.0195325762,
0.0341870412,
-0.0301017221,
0.0223484375,
0.0151514485,
-0.0496471524,
-0.0452936403,
0.024855746,
0.005149303,
-0.017081365,
0.0634597018,
-0.0223475732,
0.0485816561,
-0.0364563391,
0.0414620228,
-0.0671379492,
-0.0433225557,
0.0061313198,
0.1228243336,
-0.0191350151,
-0.0199441481,
-0.0323702767,
0.0140689956,
0.0437296294,
0.0230417326,
0.0174246412,
0.0384117886,
0.0061931154,
0.008335053,
0.0312228613,
0.0329605304,
-0.0248863548,
0.0517234392,
-0.05222914,
0.0182289947,
-0.0359521024,
-0.0154177025,
0.0424339771,
-0.0059796148,
-0.0217489302,
0.0222956706,
0.0205000024,
-0.0517555848,
-0.0346709155,
0.0885451511,
0.0226517282,
0.0431102775,
-0.0155990813,
-0.0175987706,
0.0089162821,
-0.0481412634,
0.003581014,
0.0272140875,
0.0142602632,
-0.0148287117,
-0.0434135497,
0.0333956443,
0.008224288,
0.0248419642,
-0.0253598001,
-0.0049944059,
0.0063605485,
0.0137993451,
-0.0312069021,
-0.0679550022,
0.0398343876,
-0.0281755552,
0.0051392308,
0.0240439251,
-0.0320774391,
0.0391379707,
0.0107998243,
0.0071360073,
-0.0517243668,
-0.0118323639,
0.0423388779,
-0.0096027907,
0.0694380552,
-0.0023515648,
0.0027395969,
-0.0336394757,
0.0161707457,
0.0178652778,
0.0069356915,
-0.0064264,
0.0181804616,
0.0039076176,
-0.066282481,
0.0200653262,
-0.0063637276,
-0.0481350534,
-0.0005472669,
-0.0625729561,
0.0321615227,
0.0341364667,
-0.0386237428,
0.0333597586,
-0.0201554168,
-0.0074878591,
-0.0056157559,
-0.0045492733,
0.0053375671,
-0.0005879556,
0.0131965997,
0.0149269244,
-0.0057591838,
-0.0230774917,
0.0064297686,
-0.0439252518,
-0.0115845585,
0.0005724498,
-0.0078417147,
0.035435956,
0.0102023492,
0.0389572941,
-0.0151274791,
-0.0035708861,
-0.0230450314,
0.0307377577,
-0.0177148283,
-0.0150780976,
0.0213545617,
0.010743293,
-0.0054330193,
0.0311003253,
0.1026649103,
-0.0383792296,
0.0186491627,
-0.0277879927,
-0.0658425391,
-0.040269427,
-0.0304593779,
-0.0158775356,
0.0959448442,
-0.0643241107,
0.0276018064,
-0.0587252639,
-0.0266657155,
-0.0008227997,
-0.0255720261,
-0.0066211042,
0.0055018128,
0.031209128,
0.0108005237,
0.0362342559,
-0.0078855362,
-0.0329786651,
0.0257721841,
-0.000946449,
-0.0124026528,
-0.0097195609,
-5.80211926e-33,
0.0569827743,
-0.0352047049,
-0.0056972713,
-0.0112763299,
0.0192838237,
0.0568822846,
-0.0164116025,
-0.0017893359,
-0.019133063,
0.0558419116,
0.0013915985,
0.0223648157,
-0.0073442622,
0.020445589,
0.0128792636,
0.0043271808,
0.0051898062,
0.0524392687,
-0.0023482651,
0.0565888099,
0.0383052975,
0.0076405904,
0.0272501502,
-0.0776857287,
0.0475496463,
0.0047491947,
0.035945233,
-0.0026823571,
-0.0113063399,
0.0834741071,
-0.012919643,
0.0795758739,
0.0420530625,
-0.0342627093,
-0.0240267664,
-0.01444118,
-0.0603641197,
-0.04285153,
0.0019415305,
-0.0824981704,
-0.0385261886,
-0.0218252297,
0.028387934,
0.0313640162,
0.0613197684,
-0.0572469905,
0.0522807799,
-0.023474548,
-0.0908028781,
-0.015284488,
-0.0165416412,
0.0679652244,
-0.0294347554,
0.0201876778,
-0.0438164026,
0.0202306565,
-0.0060365181,
0.0219216272,
-0.0688965693,
0.0169916209,
-0.0379465334,
0.0037875255,
-0.0164812859,
-0.0606517009,
-0.0754342303,
0.046111811,
-0.0467325523,
0.0258027222,
-0.0139931105,
0.0102961473,
-0.0618968494,
0.0670315698,
0.0171366483,
0.0070628147,
0.0065827458,
0.0221183039,
-0.0869754553,
0.0027220401,
-0.0085450364,
0.0403533652,
0.0247766506,
0.027531242,
-0.0108489851,
0.000192105,
-0.0027005954,
-0.0046807942,
-0.030163018,
0.0090651205,
-0.0427307971,
0.0335011855,
0.0195446908,
0.0797756687,
-0.0012795199,
0.0024235912,
0.0072049685,
0.0405542701,
0.0243880861,
0.02686649,
0.0086398385,
0.0185912382,
-0.0792083293,
-0.0020385187,
0.0114051858,
-0.0156389475,
0.0241490602,
0.0387693234,
0.0859240144,
-0.0410440937,
-0.0197672099,
-0.0213407148,
0.0176689997,
-0.0390862264,
-0.0162485559,
-0.0380880237,
0.0375603847,
0.0581564531,
-0.0006687991,
0.1183500737,
0.0294061322,
0.0437333398,
-0.0077726399,
-0.0524498299,
-0.0138709163,
-0.0076668165,
-0.029723946,
-0.0257508438,
-0.0241651908,
0.0060315174,
0.0497067422,
-0.0507833883,
-0.0215859022,
0.0183389951,
2.658e-7,
0.0756780282,
0.0160632543,
-0.0087380549,
-0.0313447043,
0.0260189641,
0.0052381465,
0.0201057456,
0.0511335209,
0.0036849447,
-0.0374203883,
0.0319273025,
0.0079866434,
-0.0259300135,
0.0411885567,
-0.0204230361,
-0.0597191751,
-0.0701894835,
-0.0473795682,
-0.0462568104,
-0.0399906673,
0.0544978566,
0.0728398114,
-0.0133205317,
0.0022445852,
0.0211579762,
-0.0062192921,
0.049408406,
-0.0127120567,
0.0219897311,
-0.0026779543,
0.1028470322,
-0.0573670268,
-0.0219625104,
0.0608155467,
-0.013172769,
0.0185002517,
-0.0067115459,
0.0303858351,
-0.0443603173,
-0.0082915416,
0.0222887229,
-0.033183191,
0.0268590339,
-0.0037978911,
0.0614741817,
-0.0587903224,
-0.0524644628,
0.0238481592,
-0.0198924467,
0.0110308686,
0.0727107897,
-0.0004100568,
-0.0167115945,
0.016900437,
0.0137481876,
0.028221203,
-0.0047118952,
-0.0455070101,
-0.0025259892,
0.0708050057,
-0.0317989774,
-0.0009317625,
0.0356593691,
-0.0430868864,
0.0427273847,
-0.0683327839,
0.0169056654,
2.009416905e-34,
0.0418888852,
0.0089643663,
-0.0071136681,
-0.0568155274,
0.0027568464,
-0.0452422649,
-0.005605788,
-0.0138612408,
0.0629306883,
-0.0796096921,
-0.0340123214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01241v1 | Detection of Homophobia & Transphobia in Dravidian Languages: Exploring Deep Learning Methods | 2023-04-03T12:15:27 | 2023-04-03T12:15:27 | Deepawali Sharma, Vedika Gupta, Vivek Kumar Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The increase in abusive content on online social media platforms is impacting
the social life of online users. Use of offensive and hate speech has been
making so-cial media toxic. Homophobia and transphobia constitute offensive
comments against LGBT+ community. It becomes imperative to detect and handle
these comments, to timely flag or issue a warning to users indulging in such
behaviour. However, automated detection of such content is a challenging task,
more so in Dravidian languages which are identified as low resource languages.
Motivated by this, the paper attempts to explore applicability of different
deep learning mod-els for classification of the social media comments in
Malayalam and Tamil lan-guages as homophobic, transphobic and
non-anti-LGBT+content. The popularly used deep learning models- Convolutional
Neural Network (CNN), Long Short Term Memory (LSTM) using GloVe embedding and
transformer-based learning models (Multilingual BERT and IndicBERT) are applied
to the classification problem. Results obtained show that IndicBERT outperforms
the other imple-mented models, with obtained weighted average F1-score of 0.86
and 0.77 for Malayalam and Tamil, respectively. Therefore, the present work
confirms higher performance of IndicBERT on the given task in selected
Dravidian languages. | [
0.0784207061,
0.0053900052,
-0.0109499348,
0.0495607853,
-0.0096884388,
0.0345890597,
0.0260177292,
0.0108103575,
0.0449074097,
-0.0359611735,
-0.0097512035,
-0.0948680341,
-0.0202887449,
0.0176540986,
-0.0209997371,
-0.0242902972,
0.0003314444,
0.0699187666,
0.0188494995,
-0.0155262891,
0.0162591562,
0.0133171994,
0.0017847861,
0.0263874177,
-0.009984591,
0.0059973118,
0.021289574,
0.0116119664,
0.0206459872,
-0.0151708731,
0.0345444493,
0.0271046311,
0.0076651047,
0.0894902721,
0.000001762,
-0.0467018001,
0.0242121667,
-0.0024056991,
0.0178124122,
-0.0155744078,
0.0517663471,
-0.0470341109,
-0.007243129,
0.0474601202,
-0.0358818211,
0.0047905096,
0.0611455403,
0.049058985,
0.0611720793,
0.0982182249,
-0.0084657054,
-0.0277224649,
0.0042223684,
0.011194516,
-0.024577193,
0.0215267912,
0.0381286032,
-0.0599447824,
-0.0262294561,
-0.0179144945,
-0.0418380946,
0.0168013219,
0.036820069,
-0.0028715364,
0.0111344345,
-0.0515566505,
-0.0059835482,
-0.0518357754,
0.0566660389,
0.0493098125,
-0.0598363243,
0.0033147605,
0.0037062925,
0.0109238569,
-0.0477652773,
-0.0177927781,
-0.0237079337,
0.0205182116,
-0.0309738982,
0.0457007959,
0.0101324245,
-0.0142220585,
0.0624779612,
0.0950584635,
0.0088728322,
-0.0014691821,
-0.0068210326,
-0.0227542445,
-0.0033806607,
-0.0286406241,
0.0131491255,
-0.0026136823,
0.0647393018,
0.0319915824,
-0.0032501956,
0.0179880783,
0.0157117657,
-0.07686349,
0.0118117379,
-0.0721065328,
0.0005479159,
0.0684965476,
-0.0503031239,
-0.0255216323,
-0.0382313989,
0.0581444167,
-0.0395850688,
0.025018407,
0.0450503789,
-0.0307746083,
0.005668283,
0.0065962966,
0.0274460297,
-0.0009399135,
0.0008721146,
0.0429446511,
-0.0681894198,
0.0334795676,
-0.045479808,
-0.0267201867,
-0.0111988662,
0.019492479,
-0.0163395088,
0.0005819108,
-0.0001210654,
0.0220128167,
-0.0257011373,
0.0141858151,
-0.0411194675,
-0.0590452254,
0.0474958159,
0.0415552743,
0.0132332025,
-0.0334879756,
0.0250533018,
0.037017934,
0.0087777767,
-0.0379324667,
-0.0366546698,
-0.0047346866,
-0.025083527,
-0.0405578576,
0.0160519686,
-0.0684265122,
0.0237869639,
-0.0067959437,
-0.0402005687,
-0.0481183343,
0.0001331853,
0.0136425747,
-0.0365163125,
0.0841231495,
0.0327629,
-0.0265364368,
0.0957627222,
0.0426457822,
0.0415786318,
0.0565922,
0.016476823,
0.0615577251,
0.0286589842,
-0.0163662545,
0.0120360553,
0.0268955398,
0.0123564275,
0.0324423946,
-0.0404394343,
0.0149813555,
-0.0730411559,
0.0069567082,
-0.0225110259,
0.028156057,
0.0191303492,
-0.0213063825,
0.0090553649,
0.0460097417,
0.0016175762,
0.0782218575,
0.0530230738,
0.025256142,
-0.0290833618,
-0.004184851,
-0.0401815735,
-0.0166050568,
0.0217195228,
-0.0459741466,
0.0168423261,
0.0351095051,
-0.0354118943,
-0.0204120893,
-0.0055270898,
-0.0371456668,
0.0629951879,
-0.0534413457,
0.0614021085,
-0.0132221412,
-0.0269509759,
0.0280690137,
0.0426267758,
-0.040541999,
0.0368624926,
-0.0435505956,
0.0488725044,
0.0388314798,
-0.0197431706,
-0.0146119287,
0.0136389285,
-0.0693792477,
-0.0054638106,
0.0533540659,
0.0022346354,
0.0219207201,
0.0034698676,
-0.0511858277,
-0.0203116927,
0.0562615991,
-0.0164592825,
0.0018433051,
0.0141723584,
0.0801807418,
0.0462335721,
0.0575662032,
-0.0062983548,
0.0133932391,
0.0430557989,
-0.029879855,
-0.0023051528,
0.0399048813,
0.0550033078,
0.0260290876,
-0.0069581945,
-0.0703951493,
0.0077935467,
-0.0157682542,
-0.0785729066,
-0.0087714624,
-0.0459935889,
-0.0131207863,
0.0140336938,
-0.0875704139,
0.0089442246,
0.1006338894,
-0.0114737423,
0.0059310258,
0.0727077425,
-0.0080892723,
0.0142091922,
-0.0309699345,
-0.002343707,
-0.0653617978,
0.0249514449,
-0.0015215977,
0.0304974001,
-0.0251448248,
0.0028664009,
0.0031039044,
-0.0216114838,
0.0613668375,
0.002415495,
-0.0440250263,
-0.0092592156,
-0.0339745954,
0.0290493071,
0.015164041,
0.0366121642,
0.0186620243,
-0.0221249666,
-0.1115525365,
-0.02742045,
-0.0148697468,
-0.0277757514,
-0.0288700946,
0.0370674171,
0.0001391987,
0.0291555449,
-0.0177661292,
-0.0319614485,
0.0530126542,
0.0315367244,
0.0157393739,
-0.0477794148,
0.0132260919,
-0.0053425664,
-0.0291720163,
-0.0402810127,
0.0333739184,
0.016370764,
-0.0682502389,
0.0178668499,
-0.0449269153,
-0.0385639854,
0.0199668147,
0.0170412976,
-0.0977951363,
0.0166519098,
0.0205025375,
-0.0074269152,
0.0442055725,
0.057406418,
0.0694666356,
0.005052309,
0.0577680208,
-0.0257411674,
0.0047649061,
-0.0038633624,
0.0209724307,
-0.0017982861,
-0.0070324838,
-0.017571941,
0.0264028516,
0.0163201131,
0.0068973871,
-0.0581087135,
-0.007468468,
-0.0648972094,
-0.0210759509,
0.0058600656,
-0.0233117193,
-0.0205704346,
0.0070417556,
-0.0106974961,
-0.0364972763,
0.0499439947,
0.0170209855,
0.0116303461,
-0.0554360561,
-0.020322362,
-0.0161041878,
0.0114001213,
-0.0146266352,
0.0470276661,
-0.0801911801,
-0.0432776883,
-0.0131300753,
-0.011570584,
-0.0121024456,
-0.0228372756,
0.0389119312,
0.0079093715,
-0.0036647851,
-0.0209591724,
-0.0389914103,
-0.0678808838,
-0.0638191178,
-0.0256099701,
-0.0340743475,
0.0062090894,
-0.0363968797,
0.0201164298,
0.0512628034,
-0.0218957625,
-0.0249077324,
-0.0029561336,
0.0117030088,
0.0190648045,
-0.0132539291,
-0.0055702939,
-0.0361031704,
0.0238646436,
0.0588476025,
-0.0118328612,
0.0062410082,
-0.0154333999,
0.0119714197,
-0.0514780059,
0.0117006674,
-0.002961481,
0.0042193271,
0.0069096973,
-0.0394241624,
0.0148814097,
-0.0100381188,
0.0153639708,
0.0717314258,
0.008531237,
-0.0470750816,
-0.0010051084,
-0.0208189692,
-0.0398229174,
-0.0196413025,
-0.0126772812,
-0.0989773571,
-0.0061944979,
-0.0264543183,
-0.0253282636,
-0.0341534317,
-0.0411073267,
0.0120073436,
-0.0215436108,
-0.0167251024,
-0.0267203357,
-0.011370616,
-0.07751064,
-0.0160310119,
-0.0044435742,
0.0002296504,
0.0394098088,
-0.0159729719,
-0.0035341515,
-0.0124977482,
0.0231145229,
-0.0808810741,
-0.0253231991,
0.0065040486,
-0.0402521305,
-0.0257936046,
0.0230317004,
0.0744693801,
-0.0761276782,
-0.0185481105,
0.0272759404,
0.0018817086,
-0.0312994234,
-0.056005884,
0.0047363532,
-0.0051102382,
-0.0668524355,
-0.0015339728,
0.0254247226,
-0.0260224137,
0.0262040794,
-0.0127487034,
0.0783603415,
0.016424384,
-0.0268857162,
-0.023372151,
0.0081451554,
0.0000550102,
0.0474749468,
0.0273909755,
-0.0603473485,
0.005440407,
-0.0610858649,
-0.0288705453,
-0.0091227237,
-0.0313029177,
-0.0195424873,
-0.0087702125,
-0.0440081842,
-0.026007656,
-0.0534207635,
0.0156213017,
-0.0227398202,
0.0269471575,
-0.0145502668,
-0.0096681332,
-0.0051537105,
-0.0700653195,
-0.0013249159,
0.0061697275,
0.0361254066,
-0.0205626432,
0.038897153,
-0.0054313671,
-0.0106853014,
-0.0079675419,
-0.0172480717,
-0.0135508645,
-0.0443713441,
0.0341093987,
0.0219809525,
0.0163472258,
-0.0130510842,
-0.0366093442,
-0.0739257708,
0.0503996201,
0.0385279879,
-0.0063348059,
-0.0394470729,
0.0496089906,
0.0103680352,
-0.0039947252,
0.0400590301,
-0.0074553033,
0.0048780181,
0.0021826781,
-0.0661391541,
-0.0293618757,
-0.0618505254,
-0.0468614437,
-0.0117988326,
0.0146854166,
-0.0102715241,
-0.0511737019,
-0.0201311689,
-0.0226502549,
0.0608387738,
0.0049808985,
-0.0027790382,
-0.0137434201,
0.0400713384,
0.0043062135,
-0.0431493297,
0.0024474659,
0.0061423988,
-0.0206500031,
-0.0099193864,
0.0763117149,
0.0258842222,
0.0742190704,
0.0118455067,
0.0204361919,
-0.0485016033,
0.0167161934,
-0.0093222316,
-0.0232555009,
-0.0009190108,
0.0288015995,
-0.0016103954,
0.0392151959,
0.0446831286,
-0.009145638,
0.0531733669,
-0.0331061482,
-0.0380564518,
-0.0592598692,
0.0421001837,
-0.0338421576,
0.0187963806,
0.0029306812,
-0.003865201,
-0.0342608057,
0.0441625938,
-0.0542324185,
-0.0108516421,
0.0549319275,
0.002392198,
-0.0169703383,
0.0001488201,
0.0144156171,
0.0113282027,
0.0218179896,
0.0789617971,
-0.0350682251,
-0.0386815369,
0.0037686161,
0.0201487504,
0.0228856541,
0.0176603738,
0.026002394,
0.0019062218,
-0.0447451584,
0.0183644742,
-0.0925164297,
0.0153766917,
-0.0276511889,
0.0329455025,
0.053242974,
0.0364853032,
0.028776098,
-0.0158233065,
-0.0081368051,
0.0252459999,
-0.0440641902,
-0.0378444605,
-5.491846057e-33,
0.0023678988,
0.0104597621,
-0.0174523778,
0.0071998187,
-0.0020915878,
-0.0367980003,
0.0064676479,
-0.002622084,
-0.0356481671,
0.0079576131,
0.0010980713,
0.0400398225,
0.0124201784,
0.0130036576,
-0.0043716398,
-0.0377562456,
0.0411631465,
0.0215721559,
-0.0008573997,
0.0192794148,
0.0491549931,
0.0263241623,
0.0501051806,
-0.0901113749,
0.0223125257,
-0.0186738744,
0.010243088,
-0.005843685,
0.0001077129,
0.0337345488,
-0.0386880934,
0.0709211305,
0.0438428521,
-0.0062860344,
0.0489807464,
0.0985227153,
-0.0237836279,
-0.0035056346,
0.0018389153,
0.055749692,
0.0142546566,
-0.0249063112,
0.0683091953,
0.0127650537,
-0.015155944,
-0.0179894697,
0.0497248806,
-0.0029243832,
0.0030523178,
-0.061090719,
-0.0579103008,
0.0234370492,
-0.0173858441,
-0.011341501,
0.0068907328,
0.0448061973,
0.0192361791,
0.0061067562,
-0.0909909606,
-0.0183304176,
-0.0105581544,
-0.0193628594,
0.0117372628,
0.0067311563,
-0.0234946664,
0.0129807917,
-0.0042424696,
-0.0210147295,
-0.0173175186,
-0.0050523626,
0.0446728021,
0.0351175368,
0.0228537973,
0.026902983,
0.0205443501,
-0.0731452107,
-0.0644535795,
0.0112516936,
0.0804664046,
0.0286756419,
0.0085328324,
-0.0152977509,
-0.0323009863,
-0.0366427712,
0.0087634316,
-0.0185740404,
-0.0172848478,
-0.0478260852,
0.0101360669,
-0.052943781,
-0.0153950816,
0.0491283238,
0.0228930227,
-0.0318339095,
-0.0121242302,
0.0341606848,
-0.0121700512,
-0.0113749038,
0.0415286385,
0.0307026729,
-0.0313728452,
-0.0068375464,
-0.0349408761,
-0.0009556433,
0.0241355225,
0.0097368853,
0.0407565124,
0.0300626364,
-0.0622860827,
-0.0115562417,
-0.000793521,
0.0218574684,
0.0026470819,
0.1466785073,
-0.0292582233,
0.0065911813,
-0.0039573954,
0.0292633176,
0.0318392701,
0.0086007603,
-0.012671994,
-0.0107709467,
0.0192841832,
0.008194319,
-0.035704907,
-0.0350077674,
-0.0559915081,
0.0576488487,
0.0223109834,
-0.1068062186,
0.0239195097,
-0.0297417529,
2.509e-7,
-0.0156291258,
0.016123509,
0.0010992512,
-0.0500787124,
-0.0026045244,
0.0419389792,
0.036556527,
0.0307032634,
-0.0136360666,
0.0338197351,
-0.0204987768,
0.0280436911,
0.0103504499,
0.0248543508,
-0.0323155373,
-0.0318379998,
-0.0929723755,
0.01628731,
-0.0428219736,
0.0256513022,
-0.038024392,
0.0950858742,
0.0874069631,
-0.0593137182,
0.0084308898,
-0.027799597,
0.0225803107,
-0.0044174464,
0.0360108949,
-0.0053485832,
0.0429034941,
0.0576538742,
0.0319084823,
-0.0248613115,
-0.0010243601,
0.0192086846,
0.0143027939,
0.0279885195,
-0.028885629,
0.0457962565,
0.0320164971,
-0.035210073,
-0.0263522062,
-0.0496639535,
0.0410915837,
-0.011492935,
-0.0301714372,
-0.0142283756,
0.0107516367,
-0.0148619581,
0.062303368,
-0.0273661744,
0.0018234574,
-0.0112790633,
0.0142737981,
-0.0608865097,
-0.0008036876,
-0.0833738074,
0.0250936057,
-0.0125727383,
-0.0165655334,
-0.0002561983,
-0.0236642938,
0.0007010192,
0.0583601743,
0.0050811875,
0.0628725141,
1.753295168e-34,
0.0391522348,
0.0022671772,
-0.0049829204,
-0.0157805216,
0.0150725674,
0.0362957269,
0.0240176804,
0.0016415224,
0.0461319834,
0.0024974104,
-0.0074471892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00913v1 | LAHM : Large Annotated Dataset for Multi-Domain and Multilingual Hate Speech Identification | 2023-04-03T12:03:45 | 2023-04-03T12:03:45 | Ankit Yadav, Shubham Chandel, Sushant Chatufale, Anil Bandhakavi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current research on hate speech analysis is typically oriented towards
monolingual and single classification tasks. In this paper, we present a new
multilingual hate speech analysis dataset for English, Hindi, Arabic, French,
German and Spanish languages for multiple domains across hate speech - Abuse,
Racism, Sexism, Religious Hate and Extremism. To the best of our knowledge,
this paper is the first to address the problem of identifying various types of
hate speech in these five wide domains in these six languages. In this work, we
describe how we created the dataset, created annotations at high level and low
level for different domains and how we use it to test the current
state-of-the-art multilingual and multitask learning approaches. We evaluate
our dataset in various monolingual, cross-lingual and machine translation
classification settings and compare it against open source English datasets
that we aggregated and merged for this task. Then we discuss how this approach
can be used to create large scale hate-speech datasets and how to leverage our
annotations in order to improve hate speech detection and classification in
general. | [
0.0319499038,
0.0383213237,
-0.0182729289,
0.0534563474,
-0.0111453924,
0.059835691,
0.0535508767,
0.0014853734,
0.0115755294,
-0.0537058935,
-0.0646586716,
-0.0424175672,
0.0026700494,
-0.0237232931,
-0.0050969832,
-0.0415236056,
0.0353680551,
0.023822872,
0.0139570897,
-0.0062193554,
0.0477794409,
0.0251279529,
-0.0214211047,
0.0442081951,
-0.065064095,
0.006449183,
0.0397586934,
-0.0280023385,
0.0502166115,
-0.014031589,
0.0553480461,
0.0394978896,
0.0195003394,
0.0872975066,
0.0000017897,
-0.0356931388,
0.0151020344,
0.0045491257,
0.0189973637,
-0.0740405768,
0.076710023,
-0.034680564,
-0.0045667356,
0.0157680139,
-0.0188370142,
0.0016967872,
0.0741450191,
0.0522719547,
0.0577643439,
0.0615604632,
-0.0029679567,
-0.074757427,
0.0038887421,
0.0025269396,
-0.0121133961,
0.0371343009,
0.0355571173,
-0.0332165398,
-0.060763754,
-0.0134162139,
-0.0129288845,
-0.0054409164,
0.0097389072,
0.0191792585,
-0.0330274031,
-0.0563822947,
-0.0390586779,
-0.0563132353,
0.0362583175,
0.0413006097,
-0.0547254831,
-0.014578104,
0.0060235732,
0.0105918385,
-0.0503825545,
-0.0283141807,
0.0146558145,
0.0220803656,
-0.0284196455,
0.0135219889,
0.0373439305,
0.0315814093,
0.0443284102,
0.0525715165,
0.0202930681,
0.0110527445,
-0.0314268842,
-0.022263214,
0.0276314598,
-0.0190490074,
-0.0167361163,
0.013550045,
-0.0080650644,
-0.0200351104,
-0.0121186692,
0.0055964892,
-0.0569123477,
-0.0856994241,
0.0197299458,
-0.0962738544,
0.0278378855,
0.0498811416,
-0.0529469624,
-0.008575636,
0.0184508972,
0.0126696369,
0.002681535,
0.0106759043,
-0.0076387036,
-0.0104223369,
-0.0255590826,
0.0262215324,
0.0337949395,
-0.0170267373,
0.0024920811,
0.0629453436,
-0.0806959644,
-0.0250746328,
-0.0684885308,
-0.0119631095,
-0.010878535,
-0.0260604303,
-0.0003895233,
0.0003639187,
0.0026893986,
0.0141952047,
-0.0411873832,
0.0288392641,
-0.0503454283,
-0.0827673823,
0.0237963386,
0.062307179,
-0.0614628568,
-0.0343242139,
0.0350425392,
0.0805536434,
0.0193657707,
0.0000556272,
-0.0215531215,
-0.0404464155,
-0.0195211768,
-0.0666243136,
0.0279757995,
-0.060510844,
0.0408724435,
-0.0258991495,
-0.0334877372,
-0.0777302682,
-0.0012521531,
0.0134961754,
-0.0286060162,
0.104992494,
0.007618119,
-0.0307782106,
0.0561381094,
0.0197554696,
-0.0093594044,
0.065554224,
-0.0024381075,
0.0088109067,
0.0505080149,
0.0047280388,
0.0057272627,
0.0715424046,
0.0366348997,
0.0069995997,
-0.0163155273,
0.0136119919,
-0.0237153359,
-0.0331355669,
0.0091822464,
-0.0087196566,
0.0057698144,
-0.0387500823,
-0.0037967605,
0.0531964041,
-0.0378327556,
0.0052575273,
0.0471994951,
0.026737798,
-0.0161416661,
-0.0359991379,
-0.0439509042,
-0.0351787023,
0.0009461577,
-0.0435418449,
0.038277071,
0.0559048317,
-0.0144428667,
-0.0389703512,
-0.0405322462,
-0.0081957933,
0.0492569953,
-0.0429052077,
0.0455925055,
0.0257062651,
0.0137489904,
0.007492797,
0.0580677576,
-0.011971659,
-0.0045158081,
-0.0393182747,
-0.0041759601,
0.0298519116,
-0.0147206169,
-0.038080845,
-0.0037714206,
-0.0798578784,
0.016767744,
0.0356034189,
-0.0143639557,
-0.0152935144,
0.0098148594,
-0.0416861363,
-0.0221569967,
0.0470544696,
0.0037050501,
0.0331681371,
0.0524100512,
0.0081697833,
0.0063235951,
0.0378841162,
-0.0473175012,
0.0090168994,
0.0161606185,
-0.0275483672,
0.0110340342,
0.0284473356,
0.0682879239,
0.0408734418,
-0.0339668579,
-0.086038895,
0.0168074127,
-0.0153104318,
-0.0283192061,
0.0424193889,
-0.0032618276,
-0.0022790013,
0.0264604501,
-0.0448436625,
-0.0207360797,
0.063109763,
-0.0071093179,
0.0175818838,
0.0446464606,
0.0079564378,
-0.0247391332,
-0.0391451605,
-0.0242948774,
-0.0679820105,
0.0453912765,
-0.0049119452,
0.0754845738,
-0.012559155,
0.0083755497,
0.030172376,
-0.0657548308,
0.0661789924,
0.0478717834,
-0.0460886024,
-0.0412711911,
-0.0279406123,
0.0387808122,
-0.0028633687,
0.0196175128,
-0.0003668009,
0.0335126668,
-0.0531005748,
0.0024157772,
-0.0327223688,
0.0068159099,
-0.0052763945,
0.0202970728,
-0.0166489743,
0.012316769,
-0.0065087257,
-0.042684447,
0.0463868603,
0.0221235268,
0.0054941759,
-0.0601000376,
0.0066562975,
-0.0047933259,
0.0041514905,
-0.0127520682,
0.0141548477,
0.0009819438,
-0.073411651,
0.0403291211,
-0.0403109342,
-0.0339749642,
0.0106028877,
-0.0073585645,
-0.0447782576,
0.0142531097,
0.0318945274,
-0.0322691612,
0.0287426189,
0.024221763,
0.0681478679,
0.0273430515,
0.0182543993,
-0.0177612752,
0.0027587612,
0.0032462971,
0.0357691087,
-0.0154859647,
-0.0183275435,
-0.0305478387,
0.0725226551,
0.0378498845,
-0.0214093328,
-0.0358351432,
-0.0057510515,
-0.0615751818,
-0.0443034954,
-0.0199217275,
-0.0274486542,
-0.0273762718,
-0.0321541987,
0.0010643568,
-0.0577093922,
0.0549109988,
0.0170470905,
0.0260317884,
-0.0223073345,
-0.0216035359,
-0.0128083099,
0.0370997861,
-0.0192696005,
0.0500492267,
-0.0378448181,
-0.0025133041,
0.0286887828,
-0.0080499714,
0.0155748138,
-0.0111426394,
-0.0143130645,
-0.0196234547,
0.013080365,
-0.0228129402,
-0.0398818478,
-0.061486125,
-0.0164843276,
-0.0591260567,
-0.0437365621,
0.0057562413,
-0.0136373984,
-0.0397212282,
0.0118104601,
0.0249417499,
-0.0137616144,
0.0216596127,
0.0346725471,
0.0390367135,
-0.0267186761,
-0.0189835802,
-0.0045142458,
-0.0017417819,
-0.0042138686,
-0.0495191924,
0.0244602188,
-0.0317850336,
0.0035228932,
-0.0023877353,
0.0018760827,
0.0304516237,
0.0148310028,
-0.0107338522,
-0.0397045501,
-0.0033798148,
-0.006916204,
0.0281072743,
0.084255591,
0.0058880565,
-0.0265910048,
-0.0153339375,
-0.0250703432,
-0.0019884584,
0.0192575827,
-0.012589925,
-0.1078799218,
-0.0238189138,
-0.0146878269,
0.0205750447,
-0.0714284182,
-0.0356520228,
-0.0041354652,
-0.0277145654,
0.0021659473,
-0.0224536248,
-0.0702943951,
-0.0265712347,
0.010961419,
0.0004660024,
-0.0210606176,
0.0283095576,
-0.0693055987,
0.0343491808,
-0.0180024412,
0.0378019921,
-0.0710001662,
-0.0286542475,
0.0403712951,
0.0001648503,
0.0376691259,
0.0248870943,
0.0385684408,
-0.0477771908,
-0.0074486556,
0.0446257368,
0.0110952454,
-0.046460595,
-0.0697397068,
0.0352493376,
-0.009205522,
-0.055836726,
0.0152746942,
0.051452525,
-0.0028649298,
-0.0001702066,
0.0415926054,
0.0578101948,
0.0299823396,
0.0421082899,
-0.0423194319,
0.0121418862,
0.0149717974,
0.0681475922,
-0.0152419498,
-0.0528704673,
0.051684279,
-0.0595295131,
-0.0338861272,
-0.0341870971,
-0.0868974328,
0.013534097,
-0.0566694625,
-0.0235480759,
0.0086081829,
-0.0293694567,
0.0344232842,
-0.00574901,
0.0495299473,
0.0180541649,
-0.0134917274,
-0.0092171682,
-0.086267069,
-0.0065267468,
0.0140921362,
0.0746783763,
0.0046903556,
0.0020016734,
0.0098141907,
-0.0169309974,
-0.0433256887,
0.03327775,
-0.0610971302,
-0.036170546,
0.0462119877,
0.0447400026,
0.0102570849,
0.03949669,
-0.0091773011,
-0.0320286527,
0.0413332842,
0.0408193879,
-0.0103437472,
-0.0222924668,
0.0618530996,
-0.0035046104,
-0.0022575343,
0.0183115769,
0.0005866457,
0.0417298339,
0.0416327678,
-0.0733822659,
-0.0646282062,
0.01974006,
-0.0279347841,
-0.0120908553,
0.0387734771,
-0.0251851473,
-0.0702650696,
-0.0550726466,
-0.0063605946,
0.0200554747,
-0.0488439575,
-0.0134899588,
-0.0031731753,
0.0143470857,
-0.0241313279,
-0.0257203337,
-0.0040937415,
-0.0134680634,
-0.0093923323,
-0.0287955049,
0.0504401885,
0.0579307228,
0.0476564504,
0.0037978687,
0.0184735041,
-0.0031068402,
0.0374959968,
0.0036271208,
-0.0108519066,
-0.0108933169,
-0.0043145781,
0.0060558743,
0.0252022259,
0.0567161627,
-0.0001781935,
0.0605648644,
0.0028496166,
-0.0590956472,
-0.0398322344,
-0.0037154679,
-0.0277567264,
0.0468767248,
0.0157994702,
-0.0129606873,
-0.0248067267,
0.0257837996,
-0.0364382118,
-0.0485738181,
0.0094564557,
0.0158688277,
-0.0418974832,
0.0196381621,
0.041432783,
-0.0032362395,
0.0258757323,
0.0771949738,
-0.0471890569,
-0.03171492,
-0.0077340342,
0.0421664454,
0.0165238362,
0.0078749722,
0.0005291266,
-0.0471032709,
-0.0244644303,
0.0022253359,
-0.0586042963,
0.0135243535,
0.0131108407,
0.0289915055,
0.0708982274,
-0.0101250978,
0.0159064177,
-0.0230292678,
0.0047165933,
-0.0072239893,
-0.0522740707,
0.0254732817,
-4.876706557e-33,
-0.0045623421,
-0.0142143266,
0.0061832457,
-0.0114662815,
0.0128283156,
-0.0100091752,
0.0601312928,
0.0003171729,
-0.0217060838,
0.0328554884,
0.0213237666,
0.0156228133,
0.0119201336,
0.0002515565,
0.0272288788,
-0.0274962354,
0.0258252099,
-0.0031039047,
-0.0089258086,
-0.0132714501,
0.0693480447,
-0.0165890958,
0.0797988847,
-0.0753713399,
0.0717849582,
-0.0027038094,
-0.037747886,
0.0147392927,
0.0254142229,
0.0835027918,
-0.0337671302,
0.0892394558,
0.0294035189,
-0.047250919,
0.0036923746,
0.0303683653,
-0.033254005,
0.0063731857,
0.0279539116,
0.0515968576,
0.0031107659,
-0.0323502347,
0.0126518495,
0.0029153016,
-0.0604971983,
-0.0116304727,
0.0431342721,
-0.0442752801,
0.030468937,
-0.0216330327,
-0.0868942067,
0.0294470172,
-0.0443236344,
-0.0141492318,
0.0074419533,
0.0459169187,
0.0491363332,
-0.0188584402,
-0.0903257057,
0.0318722539,
-0.0367653742,
-0.0266660191,
0.0066409409,
0.0056982217,
0.0130720939,
0.0579726137,
-0.0129381008,
-0.0036801388,
0.0059121274,
0.0572722033,
0.0195186082,
0.0476474315,
0.0064373473,
0.0731799975,
-0.0020317098,
-0.0568800904,
-0.0674235374,
0.022673117,
0.0472828038,
-0.0033162099,
-0.0047719679,
-0.0465341099,
-0.0476242304,
-0.0208017603,
-0.0081017893,
-0.0466895588,
-0.0153285423,
-0.0235223901,
0.0248885602,
-0.0332290195,
-0.0172044523,
0.0183456633,
0.0233749039,
-0.0304086581,
0.0161675476,
0.0498540439,
-0.0401290953,
-0.0091461977,
0.0319618024,
0.0552826375,
-0.0362380445,
-0.022294376,
-0.0136437397,
-0.01086595,
0.0576986745,
-0.00880701,
0.0983881578,
0.0154775484,
-0.0674079806,
0.0108897407,
0.0155797619,
0.0478461497,
-0.0323692597,
0.0920934528,
0.0098255053,
0.0539881364,
-0.003531171,
-0.0216642395,
0.041969154,
-0.0314284563,
0.0022878365,
0.0038801483,
-0.0236519445,
-0.0010965083,
0.0086510861,
-0.0123122316,
-0.0152283628,
-0.0307147726,
0.0142146172,
-0.0874173865,
0.0195991881,
-0.0582167618,
2.393e-7,
0.0040872688,
0.0379213057,
-0.0067937984,
0.0144854719,
0.0063743484,
0.0459467955,
0.0305999778,
0.0274909325,
-0.0345963798,
0.013357209,
-0.0350681543,
0.0370326564,
0.0440214276,
0.0585772581,
-0.0358444937,
-0.0342464708,
-0.0307108238,
0.0171367507,
-0.0644803047,
0.033192005,
-0.0261863843,
0.101723738,
0.0605788119,
-0.0422839113,
-0.0254840348,
0.0060690031,
0.0060220324,
-0.0212008171,
-0.0425519682,
-0.0222400092,
0.0263407901,
0.0417192057,
0.0181457549,
-0.0102694435,
-0.0172128584,
0.0103070727,
0.0308372322,
0.0325669125,
0.0244299062,
0.0361528024,
0.0053864247,
-0.0327869579,
-0.0056959651,
-0.0141116641,
0.0306280889,
0.0323670655,
-0.0152017251,
-0.0423072353,
0.0134619661,
0.0018924921,
0.0692857578,
-0.0093555097,
0.012437324,
-0.0211216547,
0.0527912639,
-0.0307280738,
-0.0072130687,
-0.0461479239,
-0.0041517084,
-0.0039033147,
-0.0193763319,
-0.0055531589,
-0.0040029101,
-0.0065657948,
0.0396702141,
0.0268756952,
0.0452476889,
1.680685663e-34,
0.029928213,
-0.033401452,
-0.0058078859,
-0.0258650556,
0.0223197974,
0.0086807534,
-0.0281435456,
-0.0142085757,
0.038762629,
-0.0030895316,
0.0094101857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01240v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01240v2 | Identifying Mentions of Pain in Mental Health Records Text: A Natural Language Processing Approach | 2023-04-03T11:56:11 | 2023-04-05T14:02:53 | Jaya Chaturvedi, Sumithra Velupillai, Robert Stewart, Angus Roberts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pain is a common reason for accessing healthcare resources and is a growing
area of research, especially in its overlap with mental health. Mental health
electronic health records are a good data source to study this overlap.
However, much information on pain is held in the free text of these records,
where mentions of pain present a unique natural language processing problem due
to its ambiguous nature. This project uses data from an anonymised mental
health electronic health records database. The data are used to train a machine
learning based classification algorithm to classify sentences as discussing
patient pain or not. This will facilitate the extraction of relevant pain
information from large databases, and the use of such outputs for further
studies on pain and mental health. 1,985 documents were manually
triple-annotated for creation of gold standard training data, which was used to
train three commonly used classification algorithms. The best performing model
achieved an F1-score of 0.98 (95% CI 0.98-0.99). | [
0.0665153265,
0.0312231313,
-0.0086135836,
-0.0126913814,
-0.0314351358,
0.0307171606,
0.0255699828,
0.0177148413,
0.0844012573,
-0.0708289519,
0.0305650756,
0.0239238422,
0.0080572469,
-0.0154157961,
-0.0236334745,
-0.0229876991,
0.0263550114,
0.0761036351,
0.0543037429,
0.0321045443,
-0.0322971269,
0.0261164028,
-0.0451829955,
0.0276787523,
-0.0341118649,
-0.0257283337,
0.0299653616,
-0.0190848932,
0.0174675975,
-0.0821980461,
0.0004681127,
0.054260917,
-0.0471646003,
-0.045998212,
0.000001931,
-0.0611155629,
-0.0342493318,
0.0005861362,
0.0020679019,
-0.0419254117,
0.0260558464,
-0.0844758749,
0.0279389378,
0.0217381604,
-0.0541131645,
-0.044618953,
0.0427373126,
0.0793012977,
0.034211088,
0.0421560444,
-0.0495703332,
-0.0000886911,
-0.0353397354,
0.032906387,
0.0074079963,
0.0099309878,
0.0429746024,
-0.0292124543,
0.0340037607,
-0.0547003411,
-0.0110651627,
0.0372118875,
-0.0573222712,
0.0411720462,
0.0084577911,
0.0424243398,
-0.0923529789,
0.0024581719,
0.0320693851,
0.0269135162,
0.0303680226,
0.0176361557,
0.0314459279,
-0.0100633027,
-0.0138144102,
-0.0158083718,
0.0273929108,
-0.0021861442,
-0.051289428,
0.0052284896,
0.0212842487,
0.0257706009,
0.0112164384,
0.011936578,
0.0265856553,
-0.0109705292,
-0.0170791075,
-0.0166262873,
0.0551045984,
-0.04187705,
-0.0315384902,
-0.0414192453,
0.0353757478,
0.013213492,
-0.007318228,
0.0192407202,
-0.0390587896,
-0.0447465479,
0.0745748356,
-0.0885163248,
0.0145143596,
0.0108639067,
-0.0061343745,
-0.0131252185,
0.0197839905,
-0.0482425652,
0.0205038693,
0.0358893089,
-0.0247076657,
0.0279709976,
-0.0570727438,
0.0004219868,
-0.054928422,
0.0252180062,
0.007526732,
0.0120919989,
-0.0773559734,
0.0020327831,
-0.0166385565,
-0.0034543811,
-0.0302988291,
0.0153616527,
-0.0018892323,
0.043596074,
0.0224685967,
-0.0281338356,
-0.0208729375,
0.0239032246,
-0.0345896184,
-0.0148934014,
0.0614549667,
-0.0230072904,
0.016050227,
-0.0057316008,
0.0437074192,
0.0495961905,
0.0303650871,
-0.0272582434,
-0.0486283973,
-0.0224228185,
-0.0175518263,
0.0195615739,
-0.0031454603,
0.010440262,
0.0111844037,
0.0247518681,
-0.017937934,
-0.0486256257,
0.0043177856,
-0.0076176482,
-0.0697474629,
0.0661325678,
-0.0449466221,
0.0081307692,
0.0340942405,
0.0029730415,
0.0530295335,
-0.0090558538,
0.0517138839,
-0.0004151836,
0.0532573946,
-0.0219975226,
0.0222212467,
-0.0254044533,
-0.0186171643,
-0.0937439203,
0.0415082611,
0.0159332827,
-0.020257242,
0.0388114825,
-0.0845857114,
0.0710403845,
0.0202545002,
-0.0065920637,
-0.0220703855,
0.0659824759,
0.0241192617,
0.0333811529,
-0.0231893789,
0.0121222315,
0.0140380189,
-0.034243267,
0.0049971873,
-0.0333344638,
0.0038627195,
-0.0041746269,
-0.0165702719,
-0.0264339354,
-0.0186076295,
-0.0534326956,
-0.0985100865,
-0.0405810215,
0.000546821,
-0.0158517584,
0.0533531941,
-0.0105516044,
-0.0436327308,
0.0193217658,
0.035735894,
-0.0148228267,
-0.0433139913,
-0.0122423489,
-0.0278950576,
0.0424930379,
0.0054594646,
-0.0521351881,
-0.0137580205,
-0.0522998609,
0.0086034499,
0.010054891,
-0.000590424,
-0.0020281854,
0.017278906,
-0.0186068621,
-0.0021787437,
0.0416710488,
0.0143175665,
-0.0324521959,
-0.0634617731,
0.0105553046,
-0.012416767,
0.0137019912,
-0.0107230581,
0.0767665505,
-0.0054726494,
-0.0741641074,
0.0216829162,
-0.0108099012,
0.065542832,
0.0307262931,
-0.00194529,
0.0176719185,
0.0362491161,
-0.0515866689,
-0.0292923786,
0.0306125246,
0.0148750348,
0.0146469912,
-0.0226777941,
-0.0211795643,
0.0216296222,
-0.0207056403,
-0.0352510698,
-0.0142780403,
0.0092718732,
-0.0454487614,
0.0480199233,
-0.027794281,
-0.0274449252,
0.0088163586,
-0.0074940231,
-0.0493938141,
0.0279231388,
-0.0163724218,
0.0479288809,
-0.0683269277,
-0.0865956172,
0.0111810444,
-0.0007192945,
-0.0114234369,
-0.0152812768,
-0.0391843319,
0.0090379883,
-0.0315978862,
0.0109529989,
0.0106890956,
-0.0231783967,
-0.126174897,
0.005488018,
-0.0025058561,
0.0049414919,
-0.0142968372,
0.0039808778,
-0.0250704866,
-0.0285966545,
0.0151594859,
-0.027563747,
0.0359159634,
-0.0119458558,
0.0106593734,
0.0258530118,
0.0408979915,
-0.041535832,
0.0019998471,
-0.068476744,
0.0122078415,
0.0271263774,
-0.0436306112,
-0.0166834816,
-0.0176805966,
-0.0121316947,
0.0135693112,
0.020643061,
-0.0266255215,
-0.0074531031,
0.0361711606,
-0.0251326337,
-0.0161020439,
0.0032878406,
0.0158127919,
0.0636760145,
0.0081084324,
0.0298459325,
0.0400170833,
-0.0247224029,
0.0203663465,
-0.0262075644,
-0.0568009838,
0.0611454286,
0.0642068237,
0.0599334203,
-0.0334672444,
-0.0042440528,
-0.0168047156,
0.0040737647,
0.0543446243,
-0.0236471444,
-0.0248275548,
-0.018356923,
0.0173390154,
-0.0004763415,
-0.0328772552,
0.0479462072,
-0.005966479,
0.0211599562,
-0.1010311544,
-0.0255045388,
-0.0194837023,
0.0102659352,
0.0225147624,
0.023781972,
0.052844096,
-0.0018140954,
0.0701205134,
-0.013026054,
0.0140555156,
-0.0311963242,
0.0166544393,
-0.0003392083,
0.0341673605,
0.0205075331,
-0.0105708027,
-0.076334402,
-0.0394602455,
-0.0337421522,
0.003914814,
0.0279843956,
0.0418730527,
-0.0073355664,
0.0115645826,
-0.0384005979,
0.0776871368,
0.0204705019,
-0.0175498743,
-0.0013042993,
-0.0101516759,
0.0079822913,
-0.0266907271,
-0.0203207582,
0.0748669952,
-0.0492428504,
0.0582993776,
-0.0067747007,
0.0584967658,
0.0288052838,
-0.0086925989,
-0.0098269982,
-0.076645121,
0.0090704374,
0.0134287318,
-0.0598440431,
-0.0270560551,
-0.0302541442,
0.0857392028,
0.0724864975,
-0.0197649058,
0.0475046188,
-0.0227096304,
-0.0719152465,
0.0110566048,
0.0164323021,
-0.0274002943,
-0.0030376031,
-0.0357531756,
0.0264311284,
-0.0373338759,
0.0067468574,
-0.0006931815,
-0.0051948619,
0.015870655,
-0.0443305261,
-0.0325951017,
-0.029107023,
-0.0477420539,
0.0045766155,
0.0156967491,
-0.0417093672,
-0.0290678963,
-0.0334966071,
0.0030130688,
0.0283482205,
-0.077700533,
-0.0513723418,
0.0109527186,
0.0068526594,
0.0566317588,
0.0366401412,
0.0775732622,
-0.0408405922,
-0.0535570048,
-0.0000824162,
0.0001339748,
-0.0213040318,
-0.0368988514,
0.096687533,
0.0074406271,
0.0355770327,
-0.0496453643,
0.0233522765,
-0.0692938715,
0.0151699744,
0.033932507,
0.0651367456,
-0.0673819482,
-0.0073296796,
-0.0091191027,
0.0375667512,
0.0575983897,
0.0320448689,
-0.0231765099,
0.0298177823,
-0.0207387712,
0.0107866423,
0.0597394444,
0.0230889618,
0.0098277656,
0.0341068506,
-0.0634411126,
-0.0071645477,
-0.0575246625,
-0.0433667675,
0.0251159538,
-0.0250500701,
0.025304934,
0.0254998095,
0.0419725329,
0.0006953661,
-0.0984589979,
-0.0020696998,
0.0628249422,
0.0020539118,
0.0196555182,
-0.0208344553,
0.0316780657,
0.0494326167,
-0.0322583653,
-0.0214152467,
0.0246364214,
-0.0062228451,
0.0491899699,
-0.0356269069,
0.0072438321,
-0.0355264246,
-0.0126353046,
-0.0004394565,
-0.0060083186,
0.0309294984,
-0.0405836701,
-0.0523505323,
0.0308582261,
0.0269790776,
0.0055626202,
-0.0010361043,
0.0104856174,
0.0282392483,
0.029214425,
-0.011559491,
-0.0214349627,
0.0209961664,
-0.0076515037,
0.0198411793,
0.0316954628,
0.01439045,
-0.0333021842,
-0.0244445466,
-0.0189977754,
-0.0088668885,
-0.0018079799,
-0.0212211385,
-0.0295491125,
-0.0004047226,
0.003155774,
-0.0449899696,
-0.0178791452,
-0.0849204287,
0.0017881033,
-0.0159688499,
0.0621208958,
0.060202986,
-0.0077211531,
-0.0391676389,
-0.0054208995,
0.0008219823,
0.0189401302,
0.0390708074,
0.0336648785,
-0.01393581,
0.0255270544,
0.0098451087,
0.0287072379,
-0.0200909246,
0.0267088953,
-0.0050485884,
-0.00658374,
0.004744886,
-0.0206723735,
0.0407419801,
-0.0424443558,
0.0117855007,
-0.0401180089,
0.0078734253,
-0.0081471559,
0.0195122622,
-0.0404402092,
0.0044370708,
0.0059234332,
-0.0002432334,
-0.0545901172,
0.0072486699,
0.0552377217,
-0.0128728002,
-0.0015491463,
0.0297501553,
-0.0769554004,
-0.0481389575,
0.027281113,
0.0130106658,
0.0204718579,
-0.0476270691,
0.023738632,
-0.026253067,
0.0009365641,
0.0394136608,
-0.0487417057,
0.0038618229,
-0.0013808858,
0.0451452993,
0.0176243167,
0.0340963006,
-0.0407265164,
-0.053748399,
0.0384826027,
-0.0114572095,
-0.0284120739,
-0.0171843357,
-4.79026107e-33,
0.0233105198,
-0.0352912918,
-0.0133655574,
-0.0034231967,
0.0089209601,
0.0387931243,
0.0032193135,
-0.0079218568,
-0.0102060959,
0.0046337554,
-0.0032885035,
0.0318004787,
0.0244107228,
0.0344874226,
0.035736423,
-0.0195608996,
0.0321684144,
-0.005565119,
0.0041410089,
0.0231230874,
0.013507084,
0.0555670224,
0.0843891278,
-0.1271108687,
0.0499582589,
0.0161572993,
-0.0041293288,
-0.0090752942,
0.014069519,
0.0150904348,
-0.0566196628,
0.0399857052,
0.0384306498,
0.0324932449,
0.0228527505,
0.0014830714,
-0.0431481749,
-0.0278481226,
-0.0289967339,
-0.0039820438,
0.0031227167,
0.0055424287,
0.0492254533,
-0.0121160047,
-0.0160622504,
-0.0139942728,
0.0643017218,
-0.0378765054,
0.0157761592,
-0.0730337352,
-0.0305017028,
0.0183021706,
-0.0064332439,
0.0277097281,
-0.0060355696,
0.0219031386,
-0.0482156985,
0.0306194574,
-0.049383007,
-0.0475316271,
0.0180680044,
0.0005195994,
-0.0126304068,
-0.0924386978,
0.008436298,
0.02843187,
-0.0071689524,
-0.0108941486,
-0.0241398383,
0.0614860617,
0.0042530005,
0.0464631766,
0.0209640563,
0.0170963928,
0.0484342799,
-0.0199262165,
-0.0551272668,
-0.0059458036,
-0.0181536991,
0.0348937325,
0.051646091,
-0.0260278415,
-0.0643473715,
-0.0088413833,
0.0148459291,
-0.027362233,
-0.0048630377,
-0.0137932096,
-0.0116314879,
-0.0165113453,
-0.0031156507,
-0.0172537137,
-0.0450628102,
-0.0136803836,
-0.026795717,
-0.0022382787,
0.0477046371,
0.0422895253,
-0.0113776885,
-0.0026061544,
-0.0313295871,
-0.0142433699,
-0.023458194,
-0.0286480878,
0.0823979527,
-0.0194614436,
0.0381257199,
-0.0564698949,
-0.0613766946,
-0.0040966324,
0.0575195141,
0.0041242992,
0.029022567,
0.0700207353,
-0.0060973279,
0.0161957983,
0.0076036239,
0.0248546861,
0.0160182919,
0.0225745216,
-0.0440154634,
-0.0737937316,
-0.0376836769,
-0.0105029251,
-0.0084611755,
-0.0244581196,
-0.011916141,
0.0457092859,
0.059612453,
-0.0496741198,
0.0367096178,
-0.0496571176,
2.556e-7,
0.0625274256,
0.0697302893,
-0.026630519,
-0.0409763195,
0.0089814626,
0.018574195,
0.0411853567,
0.037549939,
0.0303942263,
0.0133910114,
0.0163775235,
-0.0143235419,
0.0136401942,
0.0695176721,
-0.0366048254,
-0.0261473116,
-0.0001651046,
-0.0423742644,
-0.017577026,
0.0023967018,
0.0685576126,
0.0528743491,
0.01775584,
-0.0254957676,
-0.0218975935,
-0.0119709149,
-0.0140811196,
-0.0703045428,
0.0079298252,
0.0614889972,
0.0958018601,
-0.0151544344,
0.0198358223,
0.044422932,
-0.0198256951,
-0.0100550102,
-0.0238911174,
0.0307543036,
-0.0359621532,
0.0100292508,
0.0279753897,
-0.0108900955,
-0.0019589046,
0.0185017996,
0.0479663983,
-0.0588841029,
-0.0165133681,
-0.0187910926,
0.033056289,
-0.0206595082,
0.0897369683,
0.0021152201,
-0.0248580202,
0.0361722521,
0.0395730659,
-0.0166666601,
0.0018119384,
-0.0520124026,
-0.0085824365,
0.0767829865,
-0.0210858174,
0.0339881815,
0.0846164301,
-0.0000935552,
0.0373166278,
-0.07250949,
0.0296667125,
2.191737686e-34,
-0.0017243756,
0.0365443341,
0.0076738554,
0.0405661203,
-0.0022910808,
0.0015737761,
-0.0127526522,
-0.0005828854,
-0.0140536502,
-0.0719935,
0.0182553008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00906v1 | ScandEval: A Benchmark for Scandinavian Natural Language Processing | 2023-04-03T11:51:46 | 2023-04-03T11:51:46 | Dan Saattrup Nielsen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces a Scandinavian benchmarking platform, ScandEval, which
can benchmark any pretrained model on four different tasks in the Scandinavian
languages. The datasets used in two of the tasks, linguistic acceptability and
question answering, are new. We develop and release a Python package and
command-line interface, scandeval, which can benchmark any model that has been
uploaded to the Hugging Face Hub, with reproducible results. Using this
package, we benchmark more than 100 Scandinavian or multilingual models and
present the results of these in an interactive online leaderboard, as well as
provide an analysis of the results. The analysis shows that there is
substantial cross-lingual transfer among the Mainland Scandinavian languages
(Danish, Swedish and Norwegian), with limited cross-lingual transfer between
the group of Mainland Scandinavian languages and the group of Insular
Scandinavian languages (Icelandic and Faroese). The benchmarking results also
show that the investment in language technology in Norway, Sweden and Denmark
has led to language models that outperform massively multilingual models such
as XLM-RoBERTa and mDeBERTaV3. We release the source code for both the package
and leaderboard. | [
0.0585624613,
0.0165509824,
-0.0017271114,
0.059238527,
-0.0264093317,
0.0165348314,
-0.0148801077,
-0.0523060746,
-0.0072883354,
-0.0220431108,
-0.0328602567,
-0.0286144391,
0.0026064145,
0.0415340215,
0.0325496271,
-0.0795244724,
0.0853403732,
-0.0419918559,
-0.0104912156,
-0.0265520737,
-0.0008827308,
0.0223772451,
-0.0364526398,
0.0065279398,
0.0174597073,
0.0096432744,
-0.0084103607,
-0.0139504708,
0.0159403998,
-0.0011885816,
0.0262718033,
0.0371944197,
-0.0265983474,
0.0401130468,
0.0000020482,
-0.036766842,
0.0343316384,
-0.0415279232,
-0.0088451365,
0.0670808405,
0.0792412087,
0.0073989476,
0.0218234695,
-0.0270420648,
-0.0144485561,
-0.0431229658,
0.0017596568,
0.0277239457,
0.0536471568,
0.051007174,
0.0015320526,
-0.0179438014,
0.0125144906,
-0.0196243636,
-0.0902487189,
-0.0114656072,
0.0172986761,
0.0689227581,
0.0526277721,
0.0131659219,
-0.0415834486,
0.0746113211,
0.0258927066,
0.0367421769,
-0.0008949913,
0.0236321352,
-0.0518961847,
-0.0127998386,
-0.0429055057,
0.1092704386,
-0.0208316669,
-0.0299634114,
-0.0132371709,
-0.0178120472,
-0.0363700129,
-0.0304954927,
-0.025555864,
-0.0277496055,
0.0150393052,
0.0039799465,
0.0342488661,
-0.0182637386,
0.0030087519,
0.0208306052,
-0.00148516,
0.0608665012,
-0.0068706763,
-0.0236020945,
0.0866221115,
0.023974387,
0.0026799755,
-0.0492322072,
-0.014067159,
0.0160752684,
-0.0351495482,
-0.0315631889,
-0.0259224158,
-0.0469128005,
0.0593251362,
-0.0210068151,
0.0074629257,
-0.0097304471,
-0.0768117309,
0.05801351,
0.0014604976,
0.0395443439,
-0.0261193365,
-0.007263816,
-0.050130561,
-0.0285466202,
-0.0049445517,
0.0042030308,
-0.0387538671,
-0.0102604004,
-0.0456117727,
-0.0193378758,
-0.030399641,
-0.024113534,
0.0109530054,
-0.0240265224,
-0.0043105562,
-0.0097839767,
-0.0232405607,
0.0413717777,
-0.0447563417,
0.0518077053,
-0.0596002936,
0.0297896285,
-0.0615458526,
-0.042945113,
0.0411927067,
0.007933707,
0.0283164233,
-0.0450102463,
0.0660795867,
-0.0099600386,
-0.0200810842,
-0.0183277819,
0.0251746718,
0.0255598444,
0.0170073286,
-0.0786631852,
-0.0018979518,
-0.0825833902,
0.0308183413,
0.0045663822,
-0.0275516752,
-0.0272164512,
-0.0168977417,
0.0036898721,
-0.0305954702,
0.0360445157,
-0.0074673486,
0.0021053022,
-0.0082483226,
-0.0166641586,
-0.0483799465,
0.0341595113,
-0.0287664849,
-0.0280011091,
0.0614726022,
-0.0359226763,
-0.008261852,
0.0568276383,
0.0274911989,
0.0007014236,
0.010658117,
0.0752555132,
-0.0203109458,
-0.0134689091,
0.0563375652,
0.0387948975,
0.0024748058,
-0.0489423908,
0.031756945,
0.0766685233,
-0.0068261675,
0.0070673358,
0.0169234723,
0.0070705554,
-0.0078225825,
-0.0097552035,
-0.0445586182,
-0.0003754614,
0.0034914976,
0.0139543833,
-0.0078263534,
0.0313989483,
0.003901748,
-0.0167056359,
0.0182054415,
0.0070493766,
0.0584560558,
0.0273672789,
0.0013948426,
-0.0092103863,
0.004253963,
0.034508206,
0.007014764,
-0.0624763705,
0.0329897851,
-0.0183445942,
0.043428421,
0.0045623784,
-0.0036994377,
0.0044862847,
-0.0515105762,
-0.0532714874,
0.0510766804,
0.0125607476,
0.0867252946,
-0.0014206708,
0.0479020625,
-0.0177536551,
0.0281244107,
-0.0217854939,
-0.0269600283,
0.06301862,
0.0304802731,
0.0615109988,
-0.0521291867,
-0.0335077532,
0.003357345,
0.014391386,
-0.0149255646,
-0.0014720918,
-0.0222582538,
-0.0085455915,
0.0237817913,
0.0449924506,
-0.0352600366,
0.0121763134,
0.0370470025,
-0.0517455861,
-0.0302561037,
0.0365543738,
0.0118508646,
-0.04304244,
0.0140304137,
-0.0432105847,
-0.0599419773,
0.0405804329,
-0.0274618659,
-0.0392797664,
0.0476236753,
-0.0253698491,
-0.0278040692,
0.0018629822,
-0.0210519582,
0.0130950799,
0.0520245396,
-0.0107570253,
0.0620882325,
0.0018814115,
0.0739032924,
0.0131289074,
-0.0132517563,
0.0162606761,
-0.0717890412,
-0.0424603187,
0.0641861483,
-0.0382166617,
0.0235891137,
0.0356684141,
-0.0151684908,
-0.0430777445,
0.0114294365,
-0.0461462736,
0.0376811139,
-0.0354190841,
0.0489904098,
0.0164823644,
0.0191201232,
-0.0207791105,
-0.0473681726,
-0.0662518963,
-0.0109878173,
0.0777147189,
0.0279893372,
0.0033318347,
-0.0001672041,
-0.0177350361,
-0.0509378426,
-0.0388495736,
0.0207693093,
0.0261386074,
-0.0432323627,
-0.034352731,
-0.0128650805,
0.0213503111,
-0.0535676926,
0.049588073,
-0.0100961104,
-0.052442532,
-0.0230477024,
0.008204381,
0.0338585488,
0.0611834042,
-0.0358549356,
-0.0650371462,
-0.0071290438,
-0.0292691886,
-0.0594530851,
0.0118881604,
-0.0427548327,
0.027904151,
-0.0458949767,
-0.0430038609,
0.0078015309,
0.048920583,
0.0170385428,
-0.0066528865,
-0.0085965376,
0.0109728044,
-0.026254775,
-0.0198313128,
-0.0598764904,
-0.0027055251,
0.0131519595,
0.0722088069,
-0.0381825939,
-0.0244134478,
0.0512407944,
-0.01397321,
-0.0325706154,
-0.0649318546,
-0.0347531363,
-0.023201922,
0.075951241,
0.0154276788,
0.0271526594,
-0.0414624587,
-0.0104127591,
-0.0018145173,
-0.061640989,
0.0431200452,
-0.0199658759,
0.0427098908,
-0.0289932769,
0.0045219106,
-0.0001160613,
-0.024524156,
-0.0138259605,
-0.0494699031,
-0.0678752363,
0.0249831751,
-0.0388406403,
-0.013743191,
-0.0260236338,
-0.0353446119,
0.0282809529,
0.0078642601,
0.0003761023,
0.0381447673,
-0.0279004872,
0.0198780969,
0.0193296336,
0.0416679457,
0.0104799727,
0.0305229276,
0.0085632149,
0.0231089834,
0.0171371847,
0.0128732054,
-0.0114651192,
0.0193884913,
0.038388446,
-0.0362703688,
-0.046053838,
-0.0199962836,
0.0641055554,
-0.0468089432,
0.0401797108,
0.0256736726,
-0.0009462282,
0.0730181187,
0.0146176731,
-0.0125031732,
0.0243107677,
0.0552233681,
0.0526884608,
-0.0719683319,
-0.0274900459,
-0.0228814762,
0.0251577329,
-0.001392234,
-0.0135113504,
-0.0064348695,
-0.0705476254,
0.0300156847,
-0.0107928738,
-0.1085706353,
-0.022514794,
-0.0449310988,
-0.0337672122,
-0.0611436665,
0.0058721313,
-0.0085449675,
-0.0066506756,
0.0174742192,
0.0009077619,
-0.0213318113,
-0.0136300931,
0.064597562,
-0.0351646394,
0.0353443287,
0.0360405706,
0.0433958843,
-0.0402664319,
-0.0781792402,
0.0258642603,
-0.0181990061,
-0.0229742918,
-0.0216115993,
0.0556060784,
0.0291507617,
-0.0021050717,
-0.0513539426,
0.039034985,
-0.0263886638,
-0.0140122697,
0.0060769301,
0.073761344,
0.0424625091,
-0.0258682799,
0.0272051804,
0.0190721788,
0.0143814087,
0.0614943244,
0.0381224118,
-0.0033709318,
-0.0585592836,
-0.0010865086,
-0.0271363165,
-0.0244183391,
-0.0076013161,
0.0481886193,
-0.0146501437,
-0.0049745007,
-0.0483740233,
-0.0519178696,
0.0215165559,
0.0199837554,
0.0021654358,
0.0182880852,
0.001353844,
-0.0217223987,
-0.0645046756,
0.0689212456,
0.0104065612,
0.0458163917,
-0.0188463051,
0.0155636165,
0.027697999,
0.0123227192,
-0.0293563344,
-0.00741925,
-0.010170076,
-0.076812394,
0.0152749037,
0.0563728437,
0.01540008,
0.0472127125,
-0.0062804986,
-0.0593656339,
-0.0286160614,
-0.014676813,
-0.0171357132,
0.0493520498,
0.0451792143,
0.0101719759,
0.006756342,
0.0164960101,
0.0012105019,
0.0291597042,
0.0124787772,
-0.0218763426,
0.0218735225,
-0.0295749754,
-0.0238686223,
0.0616528057,
-0.0073989453,
-0.005560481,
-0.0297671128,
-0.0558189712,
0.0041190353,
0.0303317569,
0.0023331728,
-0.0204288736,
-0.0198255982,
0.0355970301,
-0.0064399545,
-0.0274272449,
0.0475851037,
-0.0535977148,
0.0362802967,
-0.0529994257,
0.0638697669,
0.0812956169,
0.0208953898,
0.0186344236,
0.0368643999,
-0.0307421517,
0.0257588495,
0.0119730514,
0.0974559784,
-0.0269856546,
0.0474857055,
0.0015588426,
-0.0377407037,
0.0231025014,
0.0022594796,
-0.0883389637,
-0.0304807294,
0.0332003981,
-0.0494357608,
0.0545083135,
-0.0056029088,
0.0933129862,
0.0051555885,
-0.0092346212,
0.0002334423,
0.0330431908,
-0.0087477732,
-0.0384715758,
0.0418286547,
0.0007003329,
-0.0273956582,
0.0236276872,
0.0193076562,
-0.0415999442,
0.0567821674,
0.0414240025,
0.0159255676,
-0.0422985516,
-0.0189476293,
0.0039891386,
-0.0091581801,
-0.0304324161,
0.0375822671,
-0.0361475609,
-0.0679340437,
-0.0244039912,
0.0153547432,
-0.0146692973,
-0.010911609,
0.0382825211,
0.0464127958,
0.0441549756,
-0.0278771464,
-0.0656131953,
0.0401870832,
-0.0450512953,
-0.037573088,
-0.0173218343,
-6.362630599e-33,
-0.0100645348,
0.0264562536,
0.0026779086,
-0.0263363663,
0.0030585555,
0.0033302661,
-0.0058589783,
0.018484557,
-0.0406803228,
0.0316738673,
-0.0141629558,
-0.0130182076,
0.0055204271,
0.00180043,
-0.0453150645,
-0.0479227267,
0.0148726031,
-0.0003657397,
-0.0112269465,
0.0002831008,
0.0052898792,
0.0258760285,
0.1052263901,
-0.0260891188,
0.0338917151,
0.0302533284,
0.0127102425,
0.0351942815,
0.039245747,
0.0376448072,
-0.0113809677,
0.0479395837,
0.0271749031,
0.0011567201,
-0.0120423632,
0.0364467166,
-0.0948533118,
-0.0487419367,
0.0324306563,
0.0426249765,
-0.0287365373,
-0.0008590815,
0.00814135,
-0.0348168612,
-0.0081611825,
0.0306453351,
0.0195536464,
0.0047795516,
-0.0064606098,
0.0322057381,
-0.0422160737,
0.0101743322,
-0.0396984331,
-0.0160677414,
0.0058857477,
0.0668491945,
-0.0178280473,
-0.0210709814,
-0.0661908984,
0.0060149385,
-0.0161987226,
-0.0050249114,
0.0500186495,
-0.0470599867,
-0.0064180954,
0.0703712851,
0.0418162867,
0.0002022967,
-0.0128102237,
-0.0172739718,
0.0557889529,
0.0238266513,
0.0687385947,
0.0590428747,
0.0204508658,
0.0160486586,
-0.0665782019,
0.006902779,
0.056289278,
0.0267557483,
-0.0143585531,
-0.0463786721,
-0.0460075326,
-0.0134848943,
-0.0680756345,
-0.0450125895,
-0.0334674083,
-0.0281430893,
0.0800508037,
-0.019312365,
-0.0052287504,
-0.006031584,
0.0431089215,
-0.0425740965,
-0.022872787,
0.0086325351,
0.0023061621,
0.0045973076,
0.0173278432,
0.0597208105,
-0.0435378253,
0.0041670883,
-0.0193129424,
0.0222319532,
0.0232708417,
0.0106500871,
0.0246356279,
-0.0067988094,
-0.066814594,
0.0340942815,
-0.0273309089,
0.05875808,
-0.0413998961,
0.0350711755,
0.0379859209,
0.0247198548,
-0.0271275174,
0.0335725956,
0.0063206106,
-0.0034506975,
-0.0597971901,
-0.0586722605,
-0.0010795534,
0.0679078922,
-0.0364775471,
-0.0064045419,
-0.051903896,
-0.0042329482,
0.0142786307,
-0.0349796861,
0.0087713059,
0.0246256813,
2.625e-7,
0.0645532161,
0.0362962112,
0.0211715102,
-0.0173130147,
0.0001343067,
0.0080500813,
-0.0104480702,
0.0311255958,
0.0013933203,
0.0247093569,
-0.0456487983,
0.0246869102,
0.0320254229,
0.0675195754,
-0.0625607967,
-0.0169381816,
-0.036898829,
0.0168532636,
-0.0546894297,
-0.0207758769,
0.027754264,
0.0784233287,
-0.0225768294,
-0.0001725472,
-0.0313248746,
-0.0472587422,
0.0264450014,
-0.0248599537,
0.0153515069,
-0.0117284367,
0.0248798244,
0.0021449218,
0.029464962,
0.010277031,
-0.0195387732,
0.0293267407,
0.0220813435,
0.0465062745,
-0.0012583166,
-0.0409295373,
0.0021009496,
-0.0257581323,
-0.0266539995,
-0.0787922889,
0.0724167898,
-0.0494244806,
-0.0576944984,
-0.0265113376,
-0.0502516441,
0.0297581367,
0.0514021143,
-0.0249838717,
0.0062367953,
0.0297258887,
0.0581422485,
-0.0446883999,
-0.0322049893,
-0.0115109403,
-0.0423013233,
0.0190299153,
0.0164835174,
-0.0412503444,
-0.0207193159,
0.0259638485,
-0.0166188609,
-0.0144929811,
-0.0030504949,
1.960365271e-34,
0.0442707315,
0.002652955,
0.0216418598,
-0.0067246766,
0.0274057649,
-0.0139665669,
0.0228560418,
-0.0157341529,
0.01414782,
-0.0456307717,
-0.0057816603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00884v1 | Dialog-to-Actions: Building Task-Oriented Dialogue System via Action-Level Generation | 2023-04-03T11:09:20 | 2023-04-03T11:09:20 | Yuncheng Hua, Xiangyu Xi, Zheng Jiang, Guanwei Zhang, Chaobo Sun, Guanglu Wan, Wei Ye | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end generation-based approaches have been investigated and applied in
task-oriented dialogue systems. However, in industrial scenarios, existing
methods face the bottlenecks of controllability (e.g., domain-inconsistent
responses, repetition problem, etc) and efficiency (e.g., long computation
time, etc). In this paper, we propose a task-oriented dialogue system via
action-level generation. Specifically, we first construct dialogue actions from
large-scale dialogues and represent each natural language (NL) response as a
sequence of dialogue actions. Further, we train a Sequence-to-Sequence model
which takes the dialogue history as input and outputs sequence of dialogue
actions. The generated dialogue actions are transformed into verbal responses.
Experimental results show that our light-weighted method achieves competitive
performance, and has the advantage of controllability and efficiency. | [
0.0435368568,
0.0276751202,
0.0007285176,
0.0319963247,
-0.0183607042,
0.0058610183,
0.0053280597,
-0.0344363451,
0.0304278769,
-0.0733785927,
-0.016844999,
-0.0388983935,
-0.0476849936,
0.0717063621,
0.0195441209,
-0.0554812886,
0.0342741199,
-0.0103138471,
0.0105509628,
0.0126397246,
-0.0005777491,
0.0031970113,
-0.0354050994,
0.0598637834,
-0.0080916993,
-0.0180328023,
-0.0583786704,
-0.0217646249,
0.0175723098,
-0.0009391057,
0.0275267512,
0.0129022785,
0.0475541539,
0.0210545417,
0.0000017101,
-0.053640224,
0.0242318921,
-0.016063761,
-0.0358478725,
-0.0119982585,
0.0059874658,
0.0282752402,
-0.0038939405,
0.035900943,
-0.0369188264,
-0.0134044141,
0.0242818315,
0.0972061083,
0.0919664353,
0.1069188714,
-0.0136715425,
-0.0418998823,
0.0087754084,
-0.0193205699,
0.0036150671,
-0.0483414568,
-0.0266471691,
0.0381219536,
0.0504995771,
0.0476353467,
-0.0093729217,
0.0146479663,
0.0307607949,
-0.0532850847,
-0.021117961,
0.0155951288,
0.0140847694,
0.0075458842,
-0.0462062955,
0.096750237,
0.0053455797,
0.0177851934,
0.0206196643,
-0.0163623486,
0.0128264902,
-0.0560113452,
-0.0383639038,
0.0040261038,
-0.0111480597,
-0.0025611997,
-0.0183950178,
0.0208518151,
-0.028865125,
-0.0333055444,
-0.0165779181,
0.0106848711,
-0.0161620397,
-0.0260969158,
-0.0292238481,
-0.0240903161,
0.0218214244,
-0.0781772956,
0.0113304937,
0.0479654856,
-0.0891111493,
-0.0051093688,
-0.0294153485,
0.0109936241,
-0.0099607175,
-0.0555199422,
0.0267813206,
0.0272453595,
0.0153082097,
0.0132733351,
-0.0034529683,
0.0861224085,
-0.0305009764,
-0.0312693529,
-0.0417485014,
0.0025875859,
-0.0649018362,
0.0172728375,
-0.067562297,
0.029831117,
-0.0812517405,
-0.0408764966,
-0.0305124074,
0.0469962247,
-0.0303773303,
-0.0068142577,
0.0236141086,
0.0427593924,
-0.0299586225,
0.0014259769,
-0.0391077548,
0.0274030939,
0.0037908307,
0.0248679053,
0.0171264615,
0.0096308654,
0.0058893324,
0.0323904604,
0.0235329606,
0.0112653831,
-0.0179196391,
0.0779875144,
-0.0473500974,
0.0057160333,
-0.0152256126,
-0.0240041018,
-0.0250498783,
-0.0603931807,
-0.01816006,
-0.0206859987,
0.0387672856,
-0.0255205631,
-0.0541419685,
-0.0158848912,
0.0243386421,
0.0061635026,
-0.0250835922,
0.0367554091,
0.0384746753,
0.0017725646,
0.0117167309,
-0.006189201,
-0.0185032524,
0.0410952047,
0.0479457155,
0.0282951389,
0.0046458771,
0.0100848079,
0.0228192583,
0.0244118199,
0.0009474509,
-0.0019856482,
0.0465745442,
0.0499489717,
-0.0203754622,
0.0294324029,
0.0355930179,
0.0424639098,
-0.0409148484,
0.0097657731,
0.0340766348,
0.0096830605,
-0.0060107363,
0.010142995,
0.0619258545,
0.0671878308,
-0.0113222999,
-0.0197966602,
-0.0129976654,
0.0144823398,
0.0108976783,
0.0140231615,
0.048198346,
-0.0175292753,
-0.0464623719,
-0.0396387912,
0.0221970621,
0.0048232563,
0.0131845037,
0.0171513408,
0.0130149322,
0.0308829304,
-0.1075705737,
0.0123428917,
-0.0368408747,
-0.0636740327,
-0.0006899383,
-0.0351481959,
-0.0047522215,
0.0436877161,
0.017471781,
-0.0057078116,
-0.0446365997,
-0.042486012,
0.0044370596,
0.0728550404,
0.0250417702,
-0.0408608988,
0.0234389845,
-0.0456619635,
-0.0248403456,
-0.0178825129,
-0.0221692789,
0.0236752145,
-0.0491189435,
-0.0170444306,
0.0181123316,
0.0433435291,
-0.0254703667,
-0.0112243555,
0.0001736047,
-0.0230840482,
0.049592562,
0.0066420073,
0.0656191483,
0.0478150882,
-0.0059061572,
-0.0002191329,
0.0129917497,
-0.0174652711,
-0.0408665687,
0.032129772,
-0.0346531086,
-0.0759248063,
0.0042021694,
0.0118717309,
-0.0321197733,
0.0062691174,
-0.0469551571,
-0.0837885067,
0.0270496327,
-0.0451617315,
0.0001051305,
-0.0350352116,
0.005101196,
0.0480580591,
0.0054819039,
-0.03599016,
0.0347495414,
0.015978951,
-0.0272529926,
0.067045711,
0.041353479,
0.0191378184,
-0.0866049007,
0.0202001035,
0.0149030695,
-0.0152914422,
0.0174226183,
0.042086333,
0.0184918866,
-0.0103136487,
-0.0085896403,
-0.0966606438,
-0.0013677226,
-0.0154764354,
0.0026755054,
0.0107544437,
0.0043465514,
0.0090872524,
-0.0316312723,
-0.0651810244,
0.0279217232,
0.1004770696,
-0.0137777524,
0.0311289765,
0.0188287385,
-0.0362123773,
-0.03393225,
0.030246634,
0.0117582493,
0.0293473918,
0.0042459308,
0.0161846001,
-0.0713232085,
0.0306959432,
-0.0138021382,
0.0577097982,
-0.0093980869,
-0.0241001155,
0.0344022624,
-0.0051534693,
0.0398653895,
0.0389901325,
0.0189174917,
0.0370774344,
-0.0320858061,
-0.0316213854,
-0.0682206228,
0.0711709261,
-0.0299603082,
-0.0017574367,
-0.0364050232,
-0.0101488875,
0.064608939,
0.0603378452,
0.0345732979,
0.0186212156,
-0.0301067512,
-0.0014616699,
0.0483299531,
-0.0257516857,
0.0098268213,
-0.0233589169,
-0.0563830025,
0.0106937187,
0.0014674824,
-0.0091308542,
0.0125659965,
-0.0047618812,
-0.0217742119,
-0.0798424035,
-0.007897377,
-0.0093409456,
0.079563424,
0.0140100466,
0.0265913308,
0.0483064204,
-0.0371972173,
-0.0369289629,
0.0065240893,
0.013706998,
-0.0131882327,
0.0454943664,
-0.039217338,
0.0204466525,
-0.0320219733,
-0.0395368077,
-0.0652369261,
0.0085085994,
-0.0058114766,
0.0206686221,
0.0172509737,
-0.0251848251,
-0.0223919582,
0.0174926445,
0.007571192,
0.019589236,
0.0160453264,
0.0046074456,
-0.0266427677,
0.0655790269,
0.037294887,
0.0340956822,
-0.0166250821,
0.0232943241,
0.0358036943,
0.0321845785,
0.0465886481,
-0.0096180607,
-0.034441255,
-0.0242114477,
0.0201642513,
-0.0101860017,
0.0096991137,
0.0171999931,
0.0499601997,
-0.0267597958,
-0.0178400055,
0.0942991972,
0.0106772939,
0.0160828978,
0.0001139948,
0.0310069863,
-0.0010816534,
-0.0065122498,
0.0434623174,
-0.0473318808,
-0.0446161553,
-0.0108813709,
-0.0036253736,
0.002716559,
-0.0207334664,
-0.0128581775,
-0.0934473202,
0.0602331907,
-0.0313287079,
-0.0168799367,
-0.0390305407,
-0.0045795147,
0.0009303108,
0.0164271537,
0.0223681536,
0.0282492116,
0.0146000488,
-0.018529376,
0.0228443053,
0.0074624959,
-0.0132058905,
0.0119369989,
-0.0039578974,
0.059853524,
0.0530923419,
0.0577213094,
0.0590421744,
0.0503047518,
0.017063288,
0.0278345887,
-0.0085250298,
0.0288470332,
0.0204667896,
0.004471797,
-0.0272566639,
0.0027411575,
0.0300378613,
-0.029462032,
0.0060708951,
0.0275974739,
0.0343989842,
-0.0655847937,
0.0052993572,
-0.0287660006,
0.0276765041,
0.0573537871,
0.0546021722,
0.0015715379,
-0.0511870012,
-0.0779422149,
-0.0328447744,
-0.044900205,
-0.0902479291,
-0.0073507349,
-0.0360068865,
0.0038160335,
0.0289945845,
-0.0844956264,
-0.0472697131,
-0.0099767009,
0.0353875086,
-0.0227419417,
-0.0454466231,
0.0334738977,
0.0071396432,
-0.0189803131,
-0.0178359952,
-0.0008363499,
0.0300264414,
-0.0671978891,
-0.0368956998,
0.0591697134,
-0.0058239852,
-0.0121613834,
0.0579984821,
-0.0729274675,
-0.0636234134,
-0.0641244128,
0.0752825886,
0.0114778941,
0.0259167999,
0.0242354684,
0.0270195976,
0.0217748675,
0.0011507078,
-0.0316331014,
-0.021841025,
0.0498997793,
0.0606491715,
-0.03434816,
0.0281810481,
-0.0445041172,
0.0318099596,
-0.0051145446,
0.0737566724,
-0.0280951951,
-0.0926977322,
-0.0151734641,
-0.0247984007,
-0.0086529087,
0.0074962527,
-0.0126985516,
-0.020232914,
0.0247761514,
-0.0354903489,
-0.013433421,
-0.08347404,
0.0189882033,
-0.0414696932,
-0.0178905725,
0.0381361246,
0.0116728367,
-0.0561538786,
0.0442991257,
-0.0062467414,
0.0029210893,
0.0119247148,
-0.011710979,
0.0262359846,
-0.0095217181,
-0.0253671035,
-0.0117084337,
0.0471990183,
0.020030316,
0.0145703033,
0.0839686841,
0.0220248848,
-0.0237195883,
-0.0077359793,
0.0351776369,
-0.0734563023,
-0.0139839519,
-0.0136305243,
0.0070205699,
0.0369985476,
0.0380974598,
0.0488996208,
-0.0531112663,
0.0256479811,
-0.036275249,
0.0835404024,
-0.0111023728,
-0.0400484353,
0.0295074899,
0.0136088058,
0.0034132488,
0.0160509944,
0.0673632696,
-0.0051249368,
-0.0137202917,
0.002226237,
0.0030512169,
-0.0689326376,
-0.064351581,
0.0037323956,
-0.0001812203,
-0.0136773977,
0.0109367892,
-0.0386674739,
-0.0188870989,
-0.0001692286,
0.0136917653,
0.0157355275,
-0.0240931604,
0.0619309619,
0.016212834,
0.0342609659,
0.0018668136,
-0.0363945886,
0.0269316956,
-0.0479609966,
-0.0316850469,
-0.0738720149,
-4.802624699e-33,
-0.0102589475,
-0.0288801752,
0.0414122418,
0.0018364659,
-0.0402014405,
-0.0244574659,
-0.0452389047,
0.0049079806,
0.0028503865,
0.0077834208,
-0.018448649,
-0.0075398702,
-0.0056431093,
0.051430814,
-0.0075642704,
0.0000015924,
0.0706487447,
-0.0264919847,
-0.0132544097,
0.068529591,
0.0559092872,
-0.008783808,
0.0027502868,
-0.0562744439,
0.0025104869,
-0.0163165051,
-0.0100644026,
0.036448583,
0.0337940119,
0.0487057418,
-0.0088556288,
0.0511951558,
0.0093955854,
-0.0782672837,
-0.0182512682,
0.0428620838,
-0.0463301316,
-0.0185467806,
-0.0009465514,
-0.0084167151,
-0.0146719916,
-0.0017107847,
-0.035243731,
-0.0093129734,
-0.0002652073,
-0.0009715076,
0.0032152447,
-0.002117187,
-0.0118929017,
-0.0246470273,
-0.0709188432,
-0.0129661523,
-0.0185796302,
-0.0689086914,
-0.0244071726,
0.0838498771,
0.0017143508,
-0.079181321,
-0.0126826493,
-0.0007252116,
0.0148001248,
0.003088698,
0.0354333296,
0.0589924492,
0.0037537222,
0.0214671213,
0.0200825687,
0.0199405737,
-0.0322472639,
0.0236222949,
-0.0614730902,
0.0455702171,
0.0008321196,
0.0337433703,
-0.0249079317,
0.0334748477,
-0.0456484482,
0.0281722695,
0.0234065633,
0.0569241904,
0.009243085,
0.0094484584,
-0.0023868531,
-0.0163032431,
-0.0040128198,
0.0301533863,
0.0075049344,
-0.03369857,
0.0464787558,
0.0397000462,
0.0123059433,
-0.0339217559,
0.0777060986,
-0.0182815064,
-0.0050444705,
0.0410663337,
-0.0208230261,
-0.0051227938,
-0.0114402007,
-0.0114579797,
-0.0429385453,
-0.0195732918,
0.0483465418,
0.028989343,
-0.0119633395,
0.0097149992,
-0.0160571039,
0.0096815806,
-0.0340433903,
0.0293084849,
-0.0392415076,
0.0595043711,
-0.0654193312,
0.0626555309,
-0.0099540902,
-0.0077295057,
-0.0299453232,
0.0864973441,
-0.0639667511,
-0.0512126572,
-0.0288433786,
0.0013317442,
0.0339212529,
0.0157057215,
-0.0525776483,
0.0314466059,
-0.0259508118,
0.0532922857,
0.0002930803,
-0.0328902788,
0.0043206117,
0.0123247476,
2.269e-7,
-0.0570529774,
-0.022329798,
0.0489289686,
0.0472741723,
0.03633634,
0.0676197708,
0.0257250108,
0.0382286683,
0.0252921134,
0.0252686031,
0.007223506,
-0.0111266635,
0.0396421365,
-0.0046327421,
-0.1109079942,
-0.0319037102,
-0.0242809802,
-0.0304725431,
-0.0362398066,
-0.0055741468,
0.0766527057,
0.0473269597,
-0.0232050437,
0.0216737073,
0.0045130877,
-0.0280623287,
0.0513408892,
0.0137156891,
-0.0018893017,
0.0086449785,
0.024728423,
-0.0217501428,
-0.0225721393,
-0.0116304401,
-0.0186791476,
0.0152375838,
-0.0146094086,
0.0709166229,
0.0062173372,
-0.0587114468,
-0.031649638,
-0.0154499942,
0.0243934467,
0.0028558422,
0.0224008225,
-0.0890933275,
-0.0027312071,
-0.0132841133,
-0.0166467857,
0.0046294751,
-0.0509171188,
-0.0094340295,
-0.0249134153,
0.0080929026,
0.02504321,
-0.0183132626,
0.0481371544,
-0.0690928176,
0.0085349856,
-0.0193436537,
-0.0487085283,
-0.031264782,
-0.0055961069,
-0.0041632927,
0.0254655425,
0.007034902,
-0.0286241565,
1.622732069e-34,
0.0229988694,
-0.0068441355,
0.0117562292,
0.040370252,
0.0073276968,
-0.0119539602,
-0.0157496538,
0.0015201595,
0.0788657814,
-0.0604699925,
-0.045635771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00869v1 | GreekBART: The First Pretrained Greek Sequence-to-Sequence Model | 2023-04-03T10:48:51 | 2023-04-03T10:48:51 | Iakovos Evdaimon, Hadi Abdine, Christos Xypolopoulos, Stamatis Outsios, Michalis Vazirgiannis, Giorgos Stamou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The era of transfer learning has revolutionized the fields of Computer Vision
and Natural Language Processing, bringing powerful pretrained models with
exceptional performance across a variety of tasks. Specifically, Natural
Language Processing tasks have been dominated by transformer-based language
models. In Natural Language Inference and Natural Language Generation tasks,
the BERT model and its variants, as well as the GPT model and its successors,
demonstrated exemplary performance. However, the majority of these models are
pretrained and assessed primarily for the English language or on a multilingual
corpus. In this paper, we introduce GreekBART, the first Seq2Seq model based on
BART-base architecture and pretrained on a large-scale Greek corpus. We
evaluate and compare GreekBART against BART-random, Greek-BERT, and XLM-R on a
variety of discriminative tasks. In addition, we examine its performance on two
NLG tasks from GreekSUM, a newly introduced summarization dataset for the Greek
language. The model, the code, and the new summarization dataset will be
publicly available. | [
-0.0016964186,
0.0516784601,
-0.002590406,
0.0295440704,
-0.0113494517,
0.0199459549,
-0.0058855633,
-0.0030562331,
0.0100532416,
-0.0475011319,
-0.0193605572,
-0.0422532186,
0.0092876898,
0.0349125825,
0.0188252237,
-0.0593779832,
0.036613401,
-0.006484211,
-0.0306095574,
0.0086429678,
-0.0031436887,
0.013331498,
0.0140113793,
-0.0096968748,
0.0244089309,
0.0338099785,
0.0031890965,
-0.0059290961,
0.0309820287,
-0.0092167594,
-0.0309991203,
0.0343771353,
0.0322516039,
0.034498971,
0.0000017826,
-0.0400434583,
-0.0030649032,
-0.0064923912,
-0.0079972278,
0.0220368747,
0.003285551,
-0.0209072195,
-0.0000323684,
0.0026231986,
-0.0453442931,
-0.0488092788,
0.0330478847,
0.0085339081,
0.0531558022,
0.1053500846,
-0.0297619645,
-0.065825887,
0.0197125357,
-0.0395355336,
0.0175924227,
-0.0343558602,
0.0190031826,
-0.0289766155,
-0.0146542909,
0.0017791102,
-0.0066394508,
0.0280381255,
0.0038644162,
0.0435497314,
-0.0604966246,
0.029840555,
-0.0552947298,
-0.0240039136,
0.0077651865,
0.0423779376,
-0.008328395,
0.0000777003,
0.0394672565,
0.0216058102,
0.0010675031,
-0.003152183,
-0.0274690725,
0.0448566787,
-0.014799892,
0.034238182,
0.00254875,
0.0038559679,
-0.0086789289,
0.0162771679,
-0.0682917386,
0.0234980434,
0.0503863096,
0.0155202039,
-0.0143410945,
0.0557179973,
-0.0986731425,
-0.0479139984,
0.0091212373,
0.0684365779,
-0.0073959553,
-0.0143531533,
-0.0708102658,
-0.0677737296,
-0.0186295547,
0.0102267489,
0.02326837,
0.0353508256,
-0.0015401695,
0.0326276645,
-0.0666818246,
0.0743076429,
0.0340024345,
0.027503822,
-0.0341402851,
-0.0148798069,
-0.0050726542,
0.0300776362,
-0.0603473559,
0.0113964351,
-0.0502908602,
-0.0265088305,
-0.0564142019,
0.0268103573,
0.0588680282,
-0.0450683944,
0.0164736211,
-0.0304787923,
-0.0493794568,
-0.0051759453,
0.0289607979,
0.0226514731,
0.0028420889,
0.009375005,
0.0087280851,
-0.0223336183,
-0.003398329,
0.0265960731,
0.0387020558,
-0.0397529416,
0.0312340669,
0.0607238188,
-0.0225478113,
-0.1037197113,
-0.0380642228,
-0.0037950408,
-0.0363416336,
-0.0884447768,
-0.0027414025,
-0.0338782631,
0.0334388688,
-0.0107889436,
-0.0030028427,
0.0004630536,
-0.0022462527,
0.0339289829,
-0.0355805419,
0.0650326908,
-0.0326165967,
0.0020034646,
-0.0057108914,
-0.0143571272,
0.000935508,
0.0263877902,
0.0358806252,
0.0250020549,
0.0481105447,
0.0104778223,
-0.0171674509,
0.0586092658,
0.004378397,
0.0177457277,
0.0025188713,
-0.0251907613,
0.0067630839,
-0.0011053088,
0.0193803702,
0.0507532433,
-0.0328094028,
0.0272860806,
0.0719563365,
0.0596189946,
-0.0238390882,
0.0419103168,
0.0312197078,
-0.0075976341,
0.037121661,
0.0260993633,
-0.0470093824,
0.016814556,
0.0141455922,
0.0694074184,
0.0080465134,
0.0489799939,
-0.0202824306,
-0.0162023176,
0.0111306934,
-0.034114182,
0.0027360083,
0.0005131415,
0.0593012795,
0.0446534567,
-0.0612897761,
0.0842397436,
0.0006693818,
-0.1048359051,
0.011668711,
-0.0245561227,
0.0532146953,
0.015483629,
0.030210726,
-0.0338478386,
-0.0218078401,
0.0106976498,
0.0205078404,
0.0629569441,
-0.0001439769,
0.0221907441,
0.0108918222,
-0.0594889149,
-0.0334784761,
0.009623385,
0.0332856216,
0.0202327687,
-0.0032007396,
0.028674664,
0.0418566093,
0.0133390147,
-0.0437980965,
0.045712661,
-0.0282809362,
-0.0239530876,
0.0027145923,
-0.0239339545,
-0.026008239,
-0.0296846256,
-0.0020796314,
0.0192956645,
0.0329818167,
-0.0764319971,
0.0165854599,
0.0053630443,
-0.0609478839,
-0.0581497215,
0.0709155574,
-0.0276151281,
0.0115478653,
0.0465075932,
-0.0572068244,
-0.0531747229,
0.0353596732,
-0.0556233004,
0.0036077539,
-0.009974503,
0.0134953866,
0.040595714,
0.0402538516,
0.0082074367,
0.0530057028,
0.0121477982,
0.0097850831,
0.0349143744,
0.0000285882,
-0.0041572843,
-0.0109387944,
-0.0352821574,
-0.022958301,
-0.0043365522,
-0.0135698346,
0.03236413,
0.0072952895,
0.0142084341,
-0.0207269285,
-0.0868595243,
0.014046859,
-0.0583929457,
0.06872347,
0.0146323545,
0.0243396834,
-0.0130239716,
-0.0230432432,
-0.0440719947,
0.021635646,
0.0338406004,
-0.0024374446,
0.0581166036,
0.0108040869,
0.0221517719,
-0.0389539599,
-0.0174219012,
0.0176323932,
0.0606854893,
0.0339041874,
0.0015145415,
-0.0477841422,
0.0124097206,
-0.0260839108,
0.0038089599,
0.0107574286,
0.0043126564,
-0.0196594279,
-0.0028610241,
0.1215327531,
0.0174893793,
0.0344783328,
-0.0316527039,
-0.005194765,
0.0007414826,
0.0160823204,
-0.0163322221,
-0.0459952243,
-0.0259903781,
-0.0511959754,
-0.0379384868,
0.0079325708,
0.0669849962,
-0.0729560852,
0.0024821088,
-0.0596275106,
0.0229196772,
-0.022366995,
0.0544170812,
-0.0126017584,
0.023850197,
-0.0216554012,
0.0280924682,
-0.0196893718,
-0.0228389595,
0.0064201211,
-0.0362074077,
0.0117689278,
-0.0596687905,
0.0069868877,
-0.0619452856,
0.0555201247,
0.0465350933,
0.0200648271,
-0.0017619216,
-0.0071051009,
-0.0461975001,
0.0059615462,
0.0338946059,
-0.0379616432,
0.0735669136,
-0.0180787928,
0.0195972659,
-0.0467249714,
0.0071203685,
0.0222865548,
0.0167009346,
-0.0265097227,
0.034992367,
0.0272263438,
-0.0077379001,
-0.0641930923,
0.0049494477,
-0.0151688755,
0.0956660062,
-0.0278323721,
0.0000140347,
-0.0238877181,
0.0860520676,
0.0545765497,
0.0040829456,
0.0131233968,
-0.0270004217,
-0.019087594,
0.0306215528,
0.0167275649,
0.003678641,
-0.0340402834,
-0.0150816469,
0.0058563817,
-0.0619512275,
-0.0146147413,
0.0074787806,
0.0038745687,
-0.0261596367,
-0.0192461014,
0.0925596207,
-0.0133393612,
-0.0488704816,
-0.0116095124,
0.0385042951,
0.0071960008,
0.0358992703,
0.0263771955,
-0.0646255314,
-0.052886866,
0.0011172331,
0.0042691901,
0.0522701517,
-0.0110919885,
-0.0345637389,
-0.068200849,
-0.0001113184,
-0.0098956395,
-0.1023945287,
-0.0526515283,
-0.0174494553,
-0.0205976758,
-0.0524416976,
-0.0081526497,
0.0065550245,
-0.0521148182,
0.0363412872,
0.0314029232,
-0.0110430662,
-0.0216088034,
-0.044432696,
-0.0479670055,
-0.0245722923,
0.0477577411,
0.0454992093,
-0.0389237776,
-0.0125484187,
0.0275425836,
-0.0144058354,
-0.0145405857,
0.0249099527,
0.0798595622,
-0.0266289655,
-0.0344103873,
-0.0131177818,
0.0201016366,
-0.0311658401,
-0.0270481333,
-0.0183795076,
0.0468477197,
0.0504001565,
-0.0289172512,
0.0038508787,
0.0035833449,
-0.0287762098,
0.0492641777,
0.0070383567,
-0.0123292077,
-0.0379493497,
0.0074070203,
-0.0047124424,
-0.0494831316,
-0.0366985984,
-0.0052571897,
-0.0012911977,
-0.0750208199,
-0.1002125069,
-0.0226644557,
0.0093453303,
0.023426773,
-0.0281423926,
-0.0425077938,
-0.0470353067,
-0.0134338131,
-0.0295532998,
0.0369476825,
-0.018123256,
0.0304967556,
-0.0450610109,
0.022032978,
0.02106346,
-0.0156885721,
-0.0282160696,
0.0174785648,
-0.0496445,
-0.0637862608,
0.002608771,
0.0880817249,
0.0150901135,
0.0200730413,
0.0177442711,
0.0203577988,
0.0012830733,
0.0318696871,
-0.0076931445,
0.0208529718,
0.0361405835,
-0.027574338,
-0.0484158471,
0.0461541228,
0.0040318849,
0.0253116805,
0.038368497,
0.0411699377,
-0.0233793706,
-0.0656037107,
0.0087214345,
0.0095863789,
0.0438000597,
-0.0258572698,
0.0216091108,
-0.014931811,
-0.0131849004,
0.0144961849,
0.0438027903,
-0.0401165709,
0.014399616,
0.0024107336,
-0.000708329,
-0.0023930327,
0.019651562,
-0.0095604416,
-0.0042859633,
-0.0373167843,
0.0151924687,
0.0303783882,
-0.0254393052,
-0.0190476198,
-0.012592108,
-0.0189419463,
-0.0222857054,
-0.0046504536,
0.0294725839,
-0.0535246804,
0.0544452854,
0.018220799,
0.0026486767,
0.0431540981,
0.0377234183,
-0.0597978272,
-0.0350597501,
-0.04559521,
0.0286765844,
0.0632306933,
-0.0125922523,
0.0841309279,
-0.0154169928,
-0.0238400791,
-0.0398497842,
0.0444233567,
-0.0118782828,
0.0243368987,
-0.0481171981,
-0.0069561591,
-0.0051645464,
0.0126071554,
0.0839675888,
0.0131672258,
0.0263086483,
0.0516393967,
-0.0335215479,
-0.0173261538,
-0.0274520889,
-0.0003254204,
-0.0397414863,
-0.0443462767,
-0.0213576555,
-0.0333078653,
-0.0760726035,
0.0257061366,
0.0146063184,
0.013151871,
0.0136636961,
0.0583411828,
0.0285218973,
-0.019958239,
0.0064831157,
-0.0210930612,
0.0265477505,
-0.0393262506,
0.0144870272,
-0.0137792919,
-5.413353156e-33,
-0.0366159081,
0.0381261557,
0.0261807758,
-0.0147729265,
-0.0297800228,
0.0048808944,
-0.047429014,
0.0129988436,
0.019758109,
0.0211326461,
0.0037714411,
-0.0097401058,
0.010719331,
0.0532443933,
-0.0169533473,
-0.0082695996,
0.0453582704,
0.0275586192,
-0.0337674208,
0.0286293086,
0.0372285843,
0.0605572313,
0.1032176614,
0.0378167965,
-0.0293645225,
-0.009045653,
0.0406892411,
-0.0333613977,
0.0285749212,
0.0325531252,
0.0034953018,
0.0160612818,
0.0011539008,
-0.0473315641,
-0.0379481092,
0.0430528969,
-0.0537126176,
-0.0238656644,
-0.0295997243,
0.025158925,
-0.0423813835,
-0.0056781298,
-0.0166908018,
-0.0271918084,
0.0084050689,
-0.0362818986,
0.0461328365,
-0.0307614077,
-0.0522939526,
-0.0628892034,
-0.0329585336,
0.0470473729,
0.0092093619,
-0.0230403133,
0.0413990729,
0.0694676191,
-0.0088897282,
0.0022081363,
0.0239940006,
0.0006783077,
0.0037461158,
0.054745134,
0.0133911343,
0.0163548365,
-0.0121876337,
0.0019145702,
-0.0005505414,
-0.0688771829,
0.0037801999,
0.0200155452,
-0.0042719278,
0.0259980168,
0.0971871316,
-0.0097268289,
0.0013754953,
0.0091765597,
-0.0595131405,
0.021795122,
0.002634268,
0.0262017492,
0.0007497445,
-0.0262501985,
0.0267943535,
0.0125830099,
-0.0240428355,
-0.0677047595,
0.0021136627,
-0.0124240061,
0.0205032974,
0.0201757886,
-0.0251831543,
0.0439673588,
0.029579483,
-0.0425226241,
-0.0165567603,
-0.0090162307,
-0.0299313888,
-0.0250105727,
-0.0365540721,
0.0074928515,
-0.0617375821,
-0.0296680164,
0.0256849881,
-0.0195962824,
-0.0323806405,
-0.0108961109,
0.0398294777,
0.0011539288,
-0.0543995909,
0.0075143245,
-0.0239887014,
0.0271709599,
-0.0182610862,
0.1046240181,
0.01682299,
-0.0000475804,
0.0010995262,
0.0463676192,
-0.0117325457,
-0.0202348921,
-0.0291964151,
-0.0004878447,
0.0256012101,
0.0543553457,
0.0111977169,
0.0114388876,
-0.0364692956,
0.0832618698,
0.0147789847,
-0.0372003019,
-0.0129819801,
0.0448802412,
2.527e-7,
0.0622756816,
-0.0036403718,
0.0244908426,
-0.008685126,
-0.027458461,
0.0243340936,
-0.0272755399,
0.0533404537,
0.0068462351,
0.0155650666,
0.0111801568,
0.0348276347,
0.0339319371,
-0.0010108482,
-0.0652148053,
-0.0510522276,
-0.0973675847,
0.0033770013,
-0.0488821082,
-0.0346772783,
0.0365518257,
0.1079413369,
-0.0098127611,
-0.0361271948,
0.0010871885,
-0.0250601489,
0.062512517,
-0.0341257937,
-0.0085141603,
0.0219333656,
0.0146170259,
0.0032568977,
-0.0219786149,
0.0303509869,
-0.0372724384,
0.0085199904,
0.0610789061,
0.0530386604,
0.000270195,
0.0226124693,
0.0050229025,
0.0208189897,
-0.0178896748,
-0.0039251684,
0.0687774196,
-0.1034011245,
-0.0023734146,
-0.0211371593,
-0.0987210274,
0.0178164411,
0.0134590566,
0.0200150423,
-0.034804292,
0.0436616279,
0.0823129416,
0.0017114801,
-0.0152169084,
-0.0856618807,
0.0315815173,
-0.0236731954,
-0.011750944,
0.0006676631,
-0.0669521689,
0.0069623184,
0.0198049136,
-0.0299192015,
-0.0227610637,
2.11242396e-34,
0.0257683489,
-0.0157240629,
-0.0070156357,
0.0318784975,
-0.0252722912,
-0.0455662161,
0.0216865782,
-0.007195543,
-0.0105327563,
-0.0627534315,
-0.010959425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01238v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01238v3 | Spam-T5: Benchmarking Large Language Models for Few-Shot Email Spam Detection | 2023-04-03T10:27:53 | 2023-05-07T10:57:51 | Maxime Labonne, Sean Moran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) in
email spam detection by comparing prominent models from three distinct
families: BERT-like, Sentence Transformers, and Seq2Seq. Additionally, we
examine well-established machine learning techniques for spam detection, such
as Na\"ive Bayes and LightGBM, as baseline methods. We assess the performance
of these models across four public datasets, utilizing different numbers of
training samples (full training set and few-shot settings). Our findings reveal
that, in the majority of cases, LLMs surpass the performance of the popular
baseline techniques, particularly in few-shot scenarios. This adaptability
renders LLMs uniquely suited to spam detection tasks, where labeled samples are
limited in number and models require frequent updates. Additionally, we
introduce Spam-T5, a Flan-T5 model that has been specifically adapted and
fine-tuned for the purpose of detecting email spam. Our results demonstrate
that Spam-T5 surpasses baseline models and other LLMs in the majority of
scenarios, particularly when there are a limited number of training samples
available. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/jpmorganchase/emailspamdetection. | [
0.0748340264,
0.0472101793,
-0.0083645144,
0.0632336736,
-0.063533932,
0.007734573,
0.0428663865,
0.0284248702,
0.0203190502,
-0.0915934518,
-0.0201950055,
-0.0253553595,
-0.0152956937,
0.0298683029,
-0.00155718,
-0.0311948676,
-0.0175432432,
-0.0137300175,
0.0226270352,
0.0215542838,
0.002836691,
-0.0025147283,
0.0063041528,
0.0440711454,
-0.0158852153,
0.0111646149,
0.0192748159,
0.0440723449,
0.0196862034,
-0.0193509664,
0.0497138724,
0.031448938,
-0.0030721198,
0.047007557,
0.0000018447,
-0.061145138,
-0.0000030457,
0.0265107844,
-0.0293873288,
0.0602002591,
0.0605778843,
-0.0503902212,
-0.0060614282,
0.0381827168,
-0.0192552339,
-0.0009513609,
0.0362641066,
0.075595364,
0.0622604266,
0.089868933,
-0.023730753,
-0.0321300253,
0.0526455864,
-0.0239248518,
0.0088461637,
-0.0216204002,
0.0900897086,
-0.0754106939,
-0.0004760026,
0.0712257847,
-0.0045376811,
0.0089301355,
-0.0353498124,
-0.0272761714,
-0.009742612,
0.0107714674,
-0.0333632082,
0.0075819385,
-0.0188852288,
0.0052359807,
-0.0558097102,
-0.0273741707,
0.0080590639,
0.0198902767,
0.0001812339,
0.0034092255,
-0.0378789194,
0.0586440526,
0.0066091148,
0.0167735741,
0.0060136388,
-0.0310275164,
0.02817294,
0.0431817621,
-0.0173958018,
0.0103988107,
0.0326196402,
-0.0357299037,
-0.0263128057,
-0.0048000948,
0.0084919902,
-0.0524813831,
0.0223667137,
0.0142370155,
0.03029605,
-0.0090447599,
-0.053879872,
-0.0550387129,
0.034511935,
-0.0689498484,
0.0341683216,
0.0009323317,
-0.0076080784,
0.0440810062,
-0.0185284279,
-0.0075741713,
-0.0085492143,
0.0294191688,
-0.0166684054,
-0.0066442122,
-0.0673455968,
-0.0300844256,
-0.0540177673,
0.0343347378,
0.0195250083,
-0.0149144456,
-0.0883325934,
0.007409018,
0.0079839798,
0.0285703987,
-0.0006235194,
-0.0423081368,
0.0072160461,
0.0165666267,
0.0144093484,
0.0180379245,
-0.0057954313,
0.0318652689,
-0.0147138247,
-0.040039327,
-0.0172820874,
0.0306475423,
-0.0265830643,
-0.0790472925,
0.0229969826,
-0.0020942569,
0.0358870439,
-0.0796782672,
-0.0232488252,
0.0173758306,
-0.0773271322,
-0.0201559663,
-0.0411205925,
-0.0400233045,
-0.0529265925,
0.0171111356,
0.0164436679,
0.0144733833,
-0.0231806524,
0.0239867084,
-0.0745974481,
0.0228156876,
0.0322012939,
0.0013843672,
0.0377521142,
-0.0226552431,
0.0204818137,
0.0281786881,
-0.0203042831,
0.0631293431,
0.0387736298,
-0.0072446889,
0.0628782064,
0.0644093305,
0.0069659338,
0.0123163871,
-0.021877069,
-0.022037996,
0.0046008667,
-0.0387748219,
-0.0176677834,
0.0520282723,
-0.0170553345,
-0.0255031437,
0.1004397422,
0.0188574754,
-0.0151305692,
-0.0029717616,
0.0185970441,
0.0356762372,
0.0017461368,
-0.0465575755,
-0.0596510135,
-0.0215140078,
-0.0442204587,
-0.0274174456,
-0.0090089496,
0.0158132259,
-0.0163034145,
-0.0138880024,
-0.0258382391,
-0.0032817076,
-0.0454127118,
-0.0006615552,
0.0925988629,
0.0119287204,
-0.0347167626,
0.0868793204,
-0.0074374862,
0.0309099369,
-0.0465034917,
-0.0309969205,
0.0129614146,
0.0217902157,
0.0542354211,
-0.0070857503,
-0.0080465823,
-0.0626996085,
-0.0233778153,
0.0271207895,
0.0028026605,
0.0368630141,
0.024465099,
-0.0037614659,
-0.0014984413,
-0.0296508074,
0.0151537228,
-0.0405782573,
0.0195955783,
0.013734838,
0.0232103746,
-0.0193912573,
-0.0256365687,
0.0403866135,
0.022096077,
-0.0238571875,
0.0527231544,
-0.0044457424,
0.042703446,
0.0064738379,
-0.0363130011,
-0.0191509333,
0.0448475294,
-0.0536527075,
-0.0071911095,
-0.0510037132,
0.0329296775,
-0.0269624013,
0.0484603904,
-0.0007066776,
-0.0262581278,
0.0668327957,
-0.0546711721,
0.0417394973,
0.0110271582,
-0.0159970373,
-0.0055767363,
-0.0642085299,
0.0051047518,
-0.0267788842,
0.0468377173,
0.0039897761,
0.0513077304,
-0.003172216,
-0.0208683982,
-0.0012660396,
-0.0098567633,
0.0180756468,
0.0039850934,
-0.0452411175,
-0.0225210413,
-0.0434223488,
-0.0149811385,
0.0058193323,
0.0431895591,
0.006486556,
-0.0456993729,
-0.1019984484,
0.0008709067,
-0.0392677188,
0.0049695116,
-0.0023915351,
0.0206725989,
0.0062264004,
0.0163098574,
-0.0321899205,
-0.012948093,
0.0083623892,
0.0027862869,
0.0339194499,
-0.0191571042,
-0.0486035533,
-0.0067495937,
0.0027179993,
-0.0116577717,
0.044200398,
0.0141122872,
-0.0177770928,
-0.0252199098,
0.0021464722,
0.0056888447,
0.0026812605,
0.0100219566,
-0.0686410666,
-0.0287187435,
-0.0200856123,
-0.0118277352,
0.0211311877,
0.0588756688,
0.0270091109,
0.0239456985,
0.043142762,
-0.0196420457,
0.0146387843,
-0.0282633603,
-0.0032678114,
-0.0483810641,
-0.054295551,
0.0698630586,
0.0526699312,
-0.0016409532,
-0.0049313358,
0.0061666644,
0.0453422368,
0.023877006,
0.0118167549,
-0.024435157,
-0.0280337948,
-0.0130554792,
-0.0209776796,
-0.0109894853,
-0.063329272,
0.0607725903,
-0.0428386517,
-0.0005425501,
-0.0428600088,
-0.0394282006,
-0.0304980222,
0.0085913483,
0.0273686312,
0.0146720465,
0.0082174912,
-0.0088667953,
0.0272025224,
-0.0019123404,
0.0259335283,
0.0374012589,
0.0142328786,
0.0166821443,
0.0595082343,
0.0088840518,
-0.0382273123,
-0.0609451272,
-0.0910430104,
-0.0442789011,
-0.0022822141,
-0.0040254602,
-0.013804703,
-0.0792664737,
0.0202569403,
-0.0053080879,
0.019717969,
-0.015320343,
-0.0228062104,
0.0036353345,
0.0426664241,
0.0245416369,
-0.0836418718,
-0.0119390497,
-0.0459903628,
-0.0078021092,
0.0479830652,
0.0157029647,
0.0303151663,
-0.0157589708,
-0.0172736812,
0.0155384708,
-0.0446728542,
-0.0039264299,
-0.0042760959,
-0.0084758596,
-0.0181567241,
-0.044501435,
0.1125173569,
0.0203342959,
-0.0113911992,
0.0011948129,
0.005887094,
0.023275936,
-0.005947141,
0.0068783206,
-0.0715006664,
-0.0412208214,
0.0232072808,
-0.0062404214,
-0.0210852996,
-0.0084806588,
0.0053656967,
-0.1237111464,
0.0445098728,
-0.0010988557,
-0.0327684879,
-0.020998776,
-0.041565638,
-0.0153599754,
-0.0005390015,
0.0050044232,
-0.0306086317,
-0.0181902051,
-0.0124751013,
-0.0233323816,
-0.0240085386,
-0.0393170454,
-0.009154045,
-0.0659566298,
0.034552291,
0.0603294335,
0.0273514744,
-0.0786402896,
0.0016572584,
0.0352419689,
-0.025225535,
-0.0319082141,
-0.0040813587,
0.072988376,
-0.0361175239,
0.0019186533,
-0.0045691468,
-0.0021752864,
-0.0273126643,
0.0203832574,
0.0248370077,
0.0492337942,
-0.0027288841,
-0.0427059047,
-0.0024634022,
-0.0027281023,
-0.0051370105,
0.102981247,
0.0143749956,
-0.0618153326,
-0.0351119898,
-0.0268034935,
-0.0131319538,
0.0251816344,
0.0232074577,
0.052231662,
-0.0288787,
-0.0661062375,
-0.0593852997,
0.0135112731,
0.0286791474,
-0.002924443,
0.0155401742,
0.0233828966,
-0.04709116,
0.0015190088,
-0.0193250738,
0.0109386314,
-0.0015095115,
0.0504411012,
-0.0758378878,
0.0113004576,
0.0108525697,
-0.0179506801,
0.0034148803,
-0.0058385995,
-0.1122342572,
-0.0466410518,
-0.0130357677,
0.0593514219,
0.0208131503,
0.0051918337,
-0.0311462693,
-0.0664769486,
0.0495018959,
0.0446325094,
0.0000476547,
0.0012431395,
0.020164866,
-0.0421987623,
0.0175637901,
0.0264289621,
-0.0377778895,
0.045544114,
0.0667930096,
-0.0197620019,
-0.0358868949,
-0.0113881845,
0.0101852901,
0.007142995,
0.0536460467,
0.0137858056,
-0.0048742634,
0.0122955805,
-0.0048904065,
-0.0194352381,
-0.033319056,
-0.0334947556,
-0.018076973,
0.0406736359,
0.0152227851,
-0.0097030932,
0.0326452628,
-0.0318511054,
0.0305557139,
-0.0075456705,
-0.000181217,
-0.0035886981,
0.0096396152,
0.0605851635,
0.0053515779,
-0.0005047497,
0.0089405384,
0.0265799109,
-0.0014378245,
0.0007339309,
0.013470443,
0.0067120031,
-0.0143101895,
-0.0150911417,
-0.004622296,
-0.0320132747,
0.0043799551,
-0.017577786,
0.023637699,
0.0465429276,
-0.0178299844,
0.0440186486,
-0.0548192486,
0.0009769965,
-0.0401399098,
0.0074541699,
-0.0013133194,
0.0026264042,
-0.0159885939,
-0.0195850376,
-0.0455621108,
0.0222181343,
0.0748361051,
0.016274428,
0.0328777209,
0.0268565454,
-0.0785471126,
-0.032241758,
0.0218045749,
0.0621453598,
-0.0056439219,
-0.0188528616,
0.003846145,
-0.0263772048,
-0.0293476377,
0.0309768505,
-0.050564561,
0.0174062327,
0.0161739327,
0.0089606512,
0.0797969177,
0.0148712192,
0.0058342302,
-0.0368728191,
0.0000132694,
0.0270744916,
-0.0716199502,
-0.0039454289,
-5.651948387e-33,
0.0577083528,
-0.0301612113,
-0.040332064,
-0.0231950004,
0.0202836636,
0.0092747044,
0.006780365,
-0.0398659743,
0.0081924107,
0.0452009812,
-0.0030440306,
-0.0033930778,
-0.0069195512,
0.0655713454,
-0.0097589456,
0.0055967849,
0.0799938291,
0.0136890635,
-0.0252025928,
-0.0134230182,
0.0389744304,
0.0520885922,
0.0067603043,
-0.0001080577,
-0.001340152,
0.0090893032,
-0.0683158711,
0.0358020887,
0.0223246869,
0.0690561607,
-0.0277327057,
0.0402624942,
0.0430904478,
-0.0108463541,
0.0178330056,
0.022287054,
-0.0040460187,
0.003252421,
-0.017563697,
0.0160949826,
0.0469701029,
-0.031640701,
0.0661022812,
0.0159196295,
-0.0262996983,
0.0205186848,
0.0211282913,
-0.0387359671,
0.008857212,
-0.0554660968,
-0.0140303783,
0.0020837595,
-0.0015137314,
0.0089598885,
0.0260553528,
0.0665181205,
0.0032420417,
0.0627788752,
-0.040793404,
0.0027820615,
0.0409632102,
-0.0099777812,
0.0135047296,
0.0032009017,
-0.0210332498,
0.0391776338,
0.0305400435,
0.009739751,
-0.0112226475,
-0.0162750576,
0.0082905637,
0.0484833941,
0.0469252542,
0.0606333613,
0.038734559,
-0.0041706543,
-0.0991307274,
0.0324882045,
0.0181753952,
0.024050666,
0.0683552176,
-0.0190433972,
-0.0198308397,
-0.0076120277,
0.0057639023,
0.0050443099,
-0.0312802568,
-0.0058854129,
0.0401875637,
0.029979689,
0.0008582365,
-0.0193297993,
0.029953137,
-0.0615760274,
-0.0531473421,
0.0318835378,
-0.0190669894,
0.0139610386,
0.004697884,
0.0059623765,
-0.0109953852,
-0.012913486,
0.0100946901,
-0.0398481674,
-0.0161566045,
-0.0293019563,
0.074592866,
0.0113547519,
-0.0942976177,
0.0107872616,
0.0364937969,
0.0266351793,
0.0045320727,
0.0532979891,
-0.018502105,
-0.0006631883,
0.0165703017,
0.0388908051,
0.0163291134,
-0.0049778256,
0.0051839533,
0.0116603347,
-0.0003800787,
0.0064240689,
-0.0226612166,
-0.0183518939,
-0.0344340242,
0.008413977,
0.035167478,
-0.0812163875,
-0.0018119649,
-0.0192821622,
2.593e-7,
0.0287453923,
0.0768944025,
-0.0355544165,
-0.0189827234,
0.0278539043,
0.080856055,
-0.0161437374,
0.0543306172,
-0.0311852172,
0.0261746105,
-0.0086855609,
-0.0045724805,
0.0311573204,
-0.0066016512,
-0.0956605747,
-0.01094543,
-0.0775372833,
-0.0091115758,
-0.0875877067,
0.0426178128,
0.0372291058,
0.1276923865,
0.0549722575,
-0.0403621383,
0.0048653041,
-0.0733801872,
0.0421155803,
-0.028930787,
-0.046925012,
0.0259653032,
0.0686619282,
-0.0233626943,
0.0408104546,
0.0182230622,
-0.0403278358,
0.0180995949,
-0.0422040895,
0.0630142465,
0.0056975828,
0.0396269225,
-0.0153751224,
-0.0024252643,
0.0089568375,
-0.0934409946,
0.0666566417,
-0.0430886708,
-0.0110878376,
-0.0158240888,
-0.0268511251,
-0.0580918118,
0.0373870507,
-0.0535446778,
-0.03710372,
0.019959908,
0.0426017605,
-0.0176015571,
0.0145506794,
-0.0642133579,
0.0239934009,
0.0095578004,
-0.0212854426,
0.0000564226,
-0.0306133442,
-0.0265073702,
0.0525450408,
-0.0347708948,
0.0334515758,
2.515203885e-34,
0.0389107727,
-0.0427698307,
-0.0257968549,
0.0550226383,
0.0038271351,
0.0012611629,
0.0024048951,
0.0187104903,
-0.0173055641,
-0.0842250958,
0.0321760327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00830v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00830v2 | AUDIT: Audio Editing by Following Instructions with Latent Diffusion Models | 2023-04-03T09:15:51 | 2023-04-05T12:13:48 | Yuancheng Wang, Zeqian Ju, Xu Tan, Lei He, Zhizheng Wu, Jiang Bian, Sheng Zhao | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Audio editing is applicable for various purposes, such as adding background
sound effects, replacing a musical instrument, and repairing damaged audio.
Recently, some diffusion-based methods achieved zero-shot audio editing by
using a diffusion and denoising process conditioned on the text description of
the output audio. However, these methods still have some problems: 1) they have
not been trained on editing tasks and cannot ensure good editing effects; 2)
they can erroneously modify audio segments that do not require editing; 3) they
need a complete description of the output audio, which is not always available
or necessary in practical scenarios. In this work, we propose AUDIT, an
instruction-guided audio editing model based on latent diffusion models.
Specifically, AUDIT has three main design features: 1) we construct triplet
training data (instruction, input audio, output audio) for different audio
editing tasks and train a diffusion model using instruction and input (to be
edited) audio as conditions and generating output (edited) audio; 2) it can
automatically learn to only modify segments that need to be edited by comparing
the difference between the input and output audio; 3) it only needs edit
instructions instead of full target audio descriptions as text input. AUDIT
achieves state-of-the-art results in both objective and subjective metrics for
several audio editing tasks (e.g., adding, dropping, replacement, inpainting,
super-resolution). Demo samples are available at https://audit-demo.github.io/. | [
0.00680725,
0.0114460606,
0.0160412006,
0.0041487492,
-0.002479627,
-0.0329700634,
0.0042895828,
-0.0195009727,
-0.1062928438,
-0.02887756,
-0.0445471443,
-0.0029666335,
0.0006922924,
-0.0050252695,
0.003127085,
-0.0723608434,
-0.0010375549,
-0.0218526721,
-0.0302527733,
0.0188192185,
-0.0185874756,
-0.0168216843,
-0.0393348038,
-0.0094067976,
-0.0313228965,
-0.017425213,
-0.0559686422,
0.0663593411,
0.0381984338,
0.0444245115,
-0.0328934863,
0.0721028149,
0.0313013643,
0.0225004908,
0.0000018348,
0.0029082464,
-0.0076669413,
0.0360171311,
0.0466481037,
0.0539487563,
0.0280611198,
0.0015970512,
-0.0729059353,
-0.0160157606,
0.0159898475,
0.0159657337,
0.0532850325,
0.0453507677,
0.1085565984,
0.0572275631,
-0.0265548881,
-0.0947655812,
-0.0247729141,
-0.0181044545,
0.0765920356,
0.0222920999,
0.0148199471,
0.0120070633,
0.0294417683,
-0.0136204734,
-0.0359464251,
0.0491946079,
0.01738354,
-0.030716572,
0.0679336786,
0.0264024585,
-0.0056525585,
-0.0221949443,
-0.0023066211,
0.0437997952,
-0.0281396471,
0.0222835466,
0.011431627,
0.0047531882,
-0.0032579105,
-0.0093091223,
-0.0503721163,
-0.0271445252,
0.0073487349,
-0.0017738328,
-0.0918355063,
-0.028359687,
0.0472632013,
-0.0638944209,
0.044475276,
-0.0154484445,
0.057593815,
-0.0499191247,
-0.0266267434,
-0.0283747744,
-0.0088294838,
-0.0497218594,
0.0448366888,
-0.0002547437,
-0.0216145236,
-0.0441100672,
-0.0564687774,
-0.0237909835,
-0.0417121239,
0.0064489054,
0.0300947651,
0.0305078477,
-0.0009755608,
0.0962091386,
-0.0094964467,
-0.0114088207,
0.0083267493,
-0.0239330046,
-0.0075498284,
0.0024259412,
-0.0490808152,
0.0233773496,
-0.0327709131,
0.0272725783,
-0.0268745683,
0.004868702,
-0.0517192036,
-0.030237142,
-0.0497140549,
0.0480207764,
0.0349481069,
0.0303500239,
-0.0449597277,
-0.0262266938,
0.0093337158,
-0.0081806313,
0.0020748305,
0.0675812066,
0.00470941,
0.0853236765,
-0.0239404999,
-0.0125792352,
0.0463320427,
-0.0088962624,
0.0363159142,
0.0559696741,
-0.0219405591,
0.0200085118,
-0.0339316279,
-0.0022023534,
0.0278492849,
-0.0159332193,
-0.0211374275,
-0.0496101081,
0.010930459,
-0.0571048968,
-0.02329956,
-0.0065348996,
-0.0027272885,
0.0222663209,
-0.0194673575,
0.0572498553,
-0.0122223571,
0.0565781854,
0.0544062667,
0.0258359108,
-0.0246400014,
0.006155632,
0.0624618419,
0.0004759193,
0.0421012044,
-0.0163749978,
0.0080969101,
0.0302342661,
0.0189286098,
0.0260206666,
-0.0279113036,
-0.0395621844,
-0.0371831954,
0.0247611441,
0.0544699356,
0.0453879498,
-0.0331497192,
-0.0443553105,
0.0756161138,
-0.0039246585,
0.0269858893,
-0.0159829129,
0.059041284,
0.0021168697,
-0.0351573229,
0.0398590975,
0.0406861603,
0.0533582345,
0.0382463932,
0.0426807217,
0.0753095224,
-0.0448454022,
-0.0232252739,
-0.0404682793,
0.013398055,
-0.0135752652,
0.0298273098,
-0.0408398174,
0.0146426922,
0.0254242457,
-0.0744762346,
-0.0031147744,
-0.0241020769,
-0.0553884506,
-0.0322004966,
-0.0450944863,
0.0223950539,
0.0592965521,
0.0348181464,
-0.0438201539,
0.0325455479,
-0.0666611269,
0.0124953464,
0.0409730636,
-0.0068792528,
-0.0435981117,
0.0361084901,
-0.0522734821,
-0.0336103812,
-0.0354580954,
0.0141618913,
0.0158918854,
-0.011099292,
0.0188691951,
0.0088755321,
-0.010025843,
0.0251103491,
-0.0205575079,
-0.0160611868,
-0.0521885082,
0.0240606926,
0.0064237579,
0.002345728,
0.021663459,
-0.0519868322,
-0.0104531813,
-0.0180068221,
0.004625503,
-0.0098189637,
0.0072396058,
-0.0115611563,
0.00050948,
0.0174746327,
-0.0502762645,
0.0108922748,
0.0253334474,
-0.0104362946,
-0.030742811,
0.0379780233,
0.0166401155,
0.0134313554,
-0.0183057748,
0.0304040499,
-0.0051388685,
-0.0330777764,
0.0065860068,
0.007105662,
-0.0069559226,
-0.009935868,
0.0090538757,
0.0722767562,
-0.0118539231,
-0.0150276786,
-0.0335364789,
-0.017608311,
0.0025812965,
-0.0303241126,
-0.0206564739,
0.0001676858,
-0.0662180334,
-0.024130011,
-0.042116899,
0.0116041759,
-0.0336582139,
-0.0093540838,
0.0105528943,
0.0214097183,
0.0075468402,
-0.0270625446,
0.0340156108,
-0.0138670532,
-0.0390100144,
-0.0165324435,
-0.0282570887,
0.0292596426,
-0.0195348226,
-0.0601671822,
0.0073124701,
0.0386090614,
-0.0436208285,
-0.0154494494,
-0.0413119085,
-0.006760912,
0.0272300206,
0.0258130413,
0.0075898203,
0.0177125894,
0.0004606213,
-0.0265687574,
0.0297912844,
0.0641360581,
0.0514010973,
-0.0260505732,
0.0161826424,
0.0288001057,
-0.0494147278,
0.0121190073,
0.0319051035,
0.0162550285,
0.036759533,
0.0194709171,
0.0131669529,
-0.0275035556,
0.0209864285,
0.0685231462,
0.01064297,
-0.0392611772,
0.0036378221,
-0.0236237179,
-0.0084102508,
0.0080616316,
-0.041649621,
-0.0245178323,
-0.0174781419,
-0.0454048663,
-0.0358112343,
0.0652696863,
-0.0159843862,
-0.0419354439,
-0.0320346504,
-0.0742165074,
0.007357263,
-0.0248299614,
-0.0263696201,
-0.0050741388,
-0.023068456,
-0.0156555269,
-0.0635880828,
0.0133641856,
0.0756900609,
-0.0425349362,
-0.0139985047,
-0.0510950349,
-0.020679526,
-0.021853039,
0.0454979576,
0.0087501341,
-0.0345773324,
0.0420647599,
0.0433286056,
-0.0449350253,
-0.0057448768,
-0.0396566577,
0.042059768,
0.0274764001,
0.078112945,
-0.0015762,
-0.0037536058,
-0.0329769105,
0.0296101868,
0.0334560238,
-0.0355301835,
-0.0760191977,
-0.0732784048,
0.048767522,
-0.0002939319,
0.0466086753,
-0.031523034,
-0.0377393849,
0.0130550452,
-0.0314903185,
-0.0208697226,
-0.0111672496,
0.0102311401,
0.0764890686,
-0.0333521329,
0.0318714865,
0.0891101286,
0.0395642929,
-0.0251360405,
-0.0017890334,
0.0204677973,
0.001657569,
0.0548835248,
-0.0223025735,
-0.0677700266,
-0.0080380794,
0.0421639346,
0.0450987294,
0.0207455587,
0.0220026672,
-0.0065251668,
-0.0370096378,
0.1035067365,
0.0310564097,
-0.0075546969,
-0.0188083798,
-0.020138137,
0.0373090468,
0.0025401439,
-0.0064764163,
-0.0001569226,
-0.0004354554,
0.017200416,
0.024349967,
0.0451968275,
-0.0687949657,
-0.0328880884,
-0.043224711,
0.0336578153,
0.0713297352,
0.018651003,
-0.0171362907,
-0.029029049,
0.0431122743,
0.0417582355,
-0.0173290297,
0.0078714797,
0.0505135171,
0.0299824253,
0.0216831509,
0.0398514569,
0.0411665589,
0.0341852568,
-0.0263342783,
0.0319786258,
0.0281394031,
-0.0024867011,
0.0219055898,
-0.0212566424,
0.0033968543,
0.0379998386,
0.0182336792,
0.061236944,
-0.0230660923,
0.0033658813,
-0.0243621822,
-0.0052277353,
-0.0569087677,
-0.0164918099,
-0.0288078617,
-0.0452147685,
-0.0574306324,
-0.0387779325,
-0.0136997709,
0.0059613995,
0.0346465558,
0.0401468575,
0.0127371019,
-0.0178510062,
-0.0326262861,
-0.0918996483,
-0.0196193196,
0.0316005871,
0.0424858518,
-0.0300317816,
-0.0449959524,
0.025097793,
-0.0043023038,
-0.0202635732,
-0.0151703684,
-0.0563513637,
-0.0476421714,
-0.0476827249,
0.0321468711,
0.0169766042,
0.0649010837,
-0.0121952333,
-0.0456068404,
0.0227745101,
-0.0360991582,
0.0315580331,
0.0688524693,
0.0469983928,
-0.0403349139,
0.0168552585,
0.0182110686,
-0.0790702775,
0.0327958465,
0.0143879456,
0.0190890264,
-0.0053583151,
0.0321809351,
-0.0006741917,
-0.0735511556,
0.0066354969,
0.0227558613,
0.0696104169,
-0.0673905537,
0.0216015447,
-0.0181508083,
-0.0059218993,
-0.049918443,
0.0012150736,
0.0113965301,
0.0173304528,
-0.0392797738,
0.0127897719,
-0.0246926285,
-0.0018511172,
-0.046637509,
0.0252054483,
-0.000141608,
-0.0483333096,
0.0101127606,
0.0044692797,
0.0674872175,
-0.0070789442,
0.0445624851,
0.023747867,
0.0613968335,
0.0446119197,
-0.002318375,
0.0147408806,
-0.0076300018,
0.0273946021,
-0.0281648226,
0.046669893,
-0.0514895171,
0.0286442097,
0.0722888634,
-0.0382600687,
0.0360289514,
0.0338558592,
-0.0151699865,
-0.0233116988,
0.0664877445,
-0.0086642196,
-0.0050169434,
-0.0187901594,
-0.0007986508,
0.0423538163,
0.0441385284,
0.0407779627,
-0.0718359724,
0.0247139949,
-0.0415703282,
-0.0167032313,
-0.0169983488,
0.0152400639,
-0.048063945,
0.0270286985,
-0.001869116,
0.0120287761,
0.0049943845,
-0.0585552342,
-0.0477218479,
0.0026514232,
0.0046950383,
0.0090330718,
0.034181606,
0.0162463412,
-0.0236076284,
0.0509380028,
0.006120523,
-0.0582028404,
-0.0041905441,
-0.0275676157,
-0.0044009169,
-4.706509669e-33,
-0.0373921692,
0.0155877946,
0.0005011447,
-0.0007544731,
-0.035873279,
-0.0365606137,
-0.0468597226,
0.0149660464,
0.0390610434,
0.0190398805,
0.0111282058,
0.0458028503,
-0.0021413513,
-0.0050918167,
0.0358770005,
0.0423562787,
0.1080741063,
-0.0227403957,
-0.0140556963,
0.0043248609,
-0.0137143712,
0.0301102716,
0.0217042975,
-0.0522026792,
-0.0295670312,
0.0052267076,
-0.021182796,
-0.0196945276,
0.0011061296,
0.0402260609,
0.0397141688,
-0.006176102,
-0.0588396639,
-0.0318311043,
0.0011735114,
-0.0252803508,
-0.0104277655,
-0.025543198,
-0.0259316675,
0.0173719954,
-0.0388332717,
-0.0394259803,
0.0564221442,
0.0366095267,
-0.0307220519,
-0.0095345182,
0.0599923544,
-0.0127690723,
0.0229762103,
-0.0354240462,
-0.032543771,
0.0292690713,
-0.0337135382,
-0.0702780262,
0.0352534167,
0.0095217396,
0.0125677865,
-0.0199922677,
-0.100704506,
0.0214319769,
0.0213914718,
0.0239055958,
0.0244494881,
-0.0112768719,
-0.0083098635,
0.0113791246,
0.0252999682,
-0.0260326713,
0.0244913846,
0.0097539667,
-0.0283341035,
0.0354986601,
-0.0071964338,
-0.0326876566,
0.0422331765,
0.0067703631,
-0.0069914227,
0.0436561666,
-0.0877448097,
0.0186793618,
0.0061619715,
0.1127264574,
0.006713653,
0.0195956491,
-0.0506238453,
-0.0022956873,
-0.0430053063,
-0.0583692342,
0.0349115059,
0.0150524713,
0.0330782123,
-0.0382219441,
0.0197619013,
0.0021025457,
0.0406169072,
-0.0540741235,
-0.0765400678,
0.0562750064,
-0.0072954032,
-0.0471212603,
0.0021797167,
0.0165901575,
0.0849209726,
0.0331276581,
0.0127793308,
-0.0140090706,
-0.0201419648,
0.0673352107,
-0.016679829,
0.0005121607,
0.0222945362,
0.010004607,
-0.0052566123,
0.0533578172,
-0.0392718688,
0.0094808564,
-0.0350758806,
0.0230295602,
-0.0258199554,
0.0296167992,
-0.0176744666,
0.0117587605,
-0.0444594808,
-0.0093098329,
-0.0451925322,
0.049111221,
0.0224543195,
-0.0095253885,
0.0336058401,
-0.0090053724,
-0.0467089489,
0.0311406534,
2.564e-7,
-0.0369993374,
0.0150825819,
-0.0234910958,
0.000274108,
0.0127124088,
0.0218766537,
-0.0880359635,
-0.0230317563,
0.0021048458,
-0.0533679724,
0.0538798608,
0.0043964842,
0.0370253772,
0.0058021299,
-0.0924275145,
-0.0133573906,
-0.0363790095,
0.0284573324,
-0.0098891957,
-0.0075621991,
0.0130846761,
0.0530257672,
0.0509959273,
-0.000155814,
0.0232083891,
0.0349820741,
0.0413181521,
0.016660355,
-0.0108316597,
-0.0582578927,
0.0249064453,
-0.0052913795,
-0.0005896674,
0.0103774257,
-0.055429697,
-0.0034676911,
0.0528223179,
0.0579170696,
-0.0572869107,
-0.0407789089,
-0.0080124708,
0.0626165345,
-0.0050893975,
0.0154047916,
0.0542847775,
0.0080939503,
-0.0103209028,
-0.0268163607,
-0.0876902863,
0.0451666005,
-0.014301396,
-0.0244384054,
-0.0081847832,
-0.0526197627,
0.022480024,
0.0773933977,
-0.0296509713,
-0.0143083762,
0.023375148,
0.0190409068,
-0.0077541005,
-0.0486294478,
-0.0170541387,
-0.0149481269,
-0.0066234162,
-0.0074942168,
-0.0252594389,
1.779454394e-34,
0.0441373922,
-0.0268432628,
0.0183138326,
-0.0190516748,
0.0057684341,
0.0491508804,
-0.0597947389,
-0.0223442595,
0.0118452013,
-0.0344511159,
-0.0784984753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00824v1 | Towards Integration of Discriminability and Robustness for Document-Level Relation Extraction | 2023-04-03T09:11:18 | 2023-04-03T09:11:18 | Jia Guo, Stanley Kok, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level relation extraction (DocRE) predicts relations for entity
pairs that rely on long-range context-dependent reasoning in a document. As a
typical multi-label classification problem, DocRE faces the challenge of
effectively distinguishing a small set of positive relations from the majority
of negative ones. This challenge becomes even more difficult to overcome when
there exists a significant number of annotation errors in the dataset. In this
work, we aim to achieve better integration of both the discriminability and
robustness for the DocRE problem. Specifically, we first design an effective
loss function to endow high discriminability to both probabilistic outputs and
internal representations. We innovatively customize entropy minimization and
supervised contrastive learning for the challenging multi-label and long-tailed
learning problems. To ameliorate the impact of label errors, we equipped our
method with a novel negative label sampling strategy to strengthen the model
robustness. In addition, we introduce two new data regimes to mimic more
realistic scenarios with annotation errors and evaluate our sampling strategy.
Experimental results verify the effectiveness of each component and show that
our method achieves new state-of-the-art results on the DocRED dataset, its
recently cleaned version, Re-DocRED, and the proposed data regimes. | [
0.0227666628,
0.0378968567,
0.0200518072,
0.0718027651,
-0.0101670865,
0.0260523241,
-0.0272878725,
-0.0019923772,
0.0325502641,
-0.0448358543,
-0.0387201905,
-0.0211194586,
-0.0227839984,
-0.0335777886,
-0.0032753272,
-0.0726830065,
0.0079200771,
-0.0019154017,
0.0386422388,
0.0131185977,
0.010530063,
-0.0077454266,
-0.0027782037,
-0.039388746,
-0.0365050063,
-0.0395232886,
0.0240720641,
0.0121402452,
0.0435704887,
-0.045619078,
0.0158624034,
0.038276162,
-0.0200259164,
-0.0061889119,
0.0000019083,
-0.0731292516,
-0.0677913129,
0.0306149088,
-0.0176692735,
-0.0532774404,
0.0236785896,
-0.0587147065,
0.0127089033,
-0.0217152853,
-0.0169544928,
-0.0341572724,
-0.0018334071,
0.1006652415,
0.0331464112,
0.0499477834,
-0.023387501,
-0.0438045077,
0.0477122106,
-0.0198214483,
0.0304154549,
-0.0373968817,
0.0260637756,
-0.0040521873,
0.0088260025,
-0.0285994299,
-0.0184031688,
0.0079389792,
0.0192814674,
0.0008657686,
0.021151958,
0.047995653,
-0.0052822684,
-0.0021000286,
0.0098940171,
0.1079175472,
0.0446883217,
0.0252913162,
0.0175152775,
-0.000681094,
-0.0090257479,
-0.0124757001,
0.0025671923,
-0.0261451025,
-0.054892689,
0.033831995,
0.0223213546,
0.0135007892,
0.0388180725,
0.002735483,
-0.0113616362,
0.0129470835,
-0.0052558263,
-0.0711456761,
0.0420018099,
0.0199262425,
-0.0386689752,
-0.00413618,
0.0331654474,
0.0062784068,
0.0210915506,
0.0435317941,
-0.0390214473,
-0.0776516125,
0.0083740475,
-0.0600050613,
-0.0528439097,
-0.0219701212,
-0.0282568913,
0.0888700485,
-0.0377679057,
0.0111291232,
-0.0098861232,
0.0023937661,
0.016855197,
-0.0214125961,
-0.0153851407,
0.0270413775,
-0.0090321181,
0.0577799231,
-0.0165635701,
0.0220744815,
-0.0228345077,
-0.0185152572,
-0.0434009843,
0.0403495654,
0.0184948277,
-0.0185467321,
-0.025719041,
-0.0325715393,
0.0019633062,
0.0039915387,
-0.0296881758,
0.0077688778,
-0.0272204503,
0.0091941729,
0.0057106828,
-0.0058996878,
0.0326161161,
-0.0365451388,
-0.0166771282,
0.1021453142,
0.0043291589,
-0.0445476696,
-0.0554240607,
-0.0409254953,
-0.0105022741,
-0.0539425276,
0.0222507324,
-0.003440791,
0.0145617398,
0.0122665465,
-0.018426856,
-0.0507268384,
0.0449607633,
-0.0292002186,
-0.0363500789,
0.1023874208,
-0.0088630421,
-0.0731190667,
0.0199960954,
0.0301010888,
-0.0094331633,
0.0926443338,
0.061267484,
-0.0334280357,
0.0635895133,
0.048159495,
-0.0064498689,
0.0110860215,
0.0260099676,
-0.0259662829,
0.0142741557,
0.0075117997,
0.0211894847,
-0.0056294571,
0.0594481602,
0.0359283648,
-0.0219836403,
-0.070596382,
0.0079485336,
-0.0231364761,
0.0060501415,
-0.0159042999,
-0.0056088376,
-0.0149595775,
-0.0107861944,
0.0127090067,
-0.0359308645,
-0.0186261572,
-0.007105663,
0.0176736917,
-0.0025950079,
-0.0209009331,
0.0077972068,
-0.0049010222,
-0.0207311753,
-0.0481036492,
0.0037682496,
-0.0133907711,
0.1285689175,
0.0093850931,
-0.0406904742,
0.0364626013,
0.0446233861,
-0.0396104082,
0.0046197544,
0.0336559005,
0.0306372084,
0.0101188207,
0.0285592005,
-0.0804401487,
0.0032661795,
-0.0395738855,
-0.0114787398,
0.0341557972,
0.0225949213,
-0.0155567117,
0.0566361323,
-0.0280649476,
-0.045407638,
0.0361590311,
0.0119043654,
-0.0060926429,
0.0282038711,
0.0043275971,
0.0220351517,
-0.0608278848,
0.0094667068,
0.0503124483,
-0.0387025364,
-0.0505967699,
0.0147574013,
0.0243798923,
0.0490183048,
0.0246790834,
-0.0080207726,
-0.0029456799,
0.0483360179,
-0.0345105529,
0.00546881,
-0.0242402963,
-0.037685018,
-0.0604713671,
0.0265327916,
-0.0120517472,
-0.0233237036,
-0.0220806301,
-0.0331982039,
-0.0247394163,
0.000480131,
0.0088900104,
0.0207550619,
-0.0097556524,
0.0000617255,
0.0417029597,
-0.002910295,
-0.0260007512,
0.0808393583,
-0.0254282076,
0.0102472669,
-0.0212416556,
-0.0297599025,
-0.0179212876,
-0.0211298894,
-0.0093394294,
0.0144107919,
0.0003081562,
-0.0151530812,
0.0093659889,
-0.003845942,
-0.0805313736,
-0.0183964428,
-0.0187988263,
0.0162775014,
0.0120625459,
0.0475336164,
-0.0078840852,
-0.0117232595,
0.0072432645,
-0.0201447885,
-0.0007070235,
0.0029941134,
-0.0539247543,
-0.0046594208,
0.0478213876,
0.0153841972,
-0.0061177206,
-0.0036903813,
-0.014402546,
-0.0291860159,
0.0387199745,
-0.0052846484,
-0.0161479432,
-0.0091021983,
0.0653215051,
-0.0049180947,
0.057144884,
-0.0107645504,
0.024620736,
-0.0307382047,
-0.0107279345,
0.0100448309,
0.0478710979,
-0.0128240297,
0.0426840596,
-0.0037701791,
0.004020486,
0.0017966818,
0.0247659199,
-0.0191036854,
0.0511587113,
-0.0068836454,
-0.0127016809,
-0.0481433757,
0.0621988885,
-0.0115900021,
0.0136713516,
-0.0096779661,
-0.0067813969,
-0.0154227875,
-0.0198989175,
-0.0023255926,
0.0346171409,
0.0106540881,
0.0044598952,
-0.0661277696,
0.0043778345,
0.0738654733,
-0.0164198615,
-0.0149712572,
-0.0204645526,
0.0156348944,
-0.016720159,
0.0586931705,
0.0057433126,
-0.009638859,
0.0300339274,
-0.0093872342,
-0.0288331918,
-0.0390851386,
0.0569860972,
-0.0137490714,
0.0239014942,
-0.0469147563,
0.0249411631,
-0.0288097337,
-0.059542831,
-0.0290821306,
-0.0129196858,
-0.0016575797,
0.0228169542,
0.0024249235,
0.0151956799,
-0.0092725679,
0.0175554901,
0.008328489,
0.0497857966,
-0.0225764681,
-0.0346598215,
-0.0067876983,
0.0912699178,
0.0458260477,
-0.025353685,
0.0382842049,
-0.0087884422,
0.0264083408,
0.0506792367,
0.0164266992,
-0.0477921441,
0.0131918928,
0.0020931796,
-0.0094233667,
-0.0327855125,
-0.0024543577,
-0.0208832789,
0.0287843291,
-0.086671479,
-0.0491093174,
0.0874437764,
0.0095302137,
-0.0227636136,
-0.0235459786,
-0.0038120504,
0.0095732734,
0.0122037372,
-0.0135946786,
-0.0635516569,
-0.0375510864,
-0.0033335348,
0.0420418382,
0.008399887,
-0.0714582875,
0.0107660731,
-0.0933227912,
0.0053908746,
-0.0075952923,
-0.0493520461,
-0.0092605622,
-0.0665481463,
0.0230446476,
-0.0243985709,
-0.0067248209,
0.0120623447,
-0.0027272343,
-0.0093030836,
0.0107630165,
-0.0073971944,
-0.0165970791,
0.0030723845,
-0.0292459745,
0.0097403387,
0.0258694757,
0.041539114,
0.0087569831,
-0.001767208,
0.0384902284,
-0.0492436476,
-0.0559404977,
-0.0265227426,
0.0792056248,
-0.026219869,
0.0078081754,
-0.0008013692,
0.0491458327,
-0.0661516041,
0.0027081452,
-0.0096035209,
0.0771338642,
0.0043182587,
-0.0095710075,
-0.0042912452,
-0.0216824766,
0.0336958617,
0.0689134523,
-0.0045849569,
-0.015175553,
-0.0619513951,
0.0171345547,
0.0484565049,
-0.0208396129,
0.0664163828,
-0.0353045091,
-0.0660292879,
-0.0086808158,
-0.0519571677,
-0.0991214067,
0.0005993047,
0.0274975821,
-0.0292595439,
0.0050627748,
0.0023879379,
0.0178416166,
-0.0484806076,
-0.0127103878,
-0.0118651558,
-0.0139739541,
-0.017432604,
0.0180203859,
0.032228034,
-0.0116736162,
-0.0536542311,
0.0078347707,
-0.0367612019,
-0.0276624411,
-0.0033459989,
0.0051028496,
0.01263877,
0.0778225586,
-0.0206010286,
-0.0098306537,
0.0010069635,
0.0673455372,
-0.055106651,
-0.0139438761,
0.0555302463,
0.0086815413,
0.0004574675,
0.0470020808,
-0.0561649576,
0.0166926943,
0.038786076,
0.0151991611,
-0.0469867438,
-0.0436032452,
-0.0065265088,
0.008428812,
0.075822942,
0.0070925504,
-0.0189208146,
-0.0424783826,
0.039525006,
-0.0469150655,
-0.0159730688,
-0.0289864838,
0.0231115986,
0.0068608751,
-0.0196954813,
-0.0324630961,
0.0065233428,
0.0214618538,
0.0298743974,
0.0189291742,
0.0028135118,
0.0654509291,
0.0084580984,
-0.0066713225,
-0.0385699421,
-0.0162830185,
0.0149565451,
0.0407829732,
0.0445185192,
-0.0039531356,
0.0477897115,
0.0219514146,
-0.0151007166,
0.0154067194,
-0.0448841192,
-0.0417465717,
0.0513021015,
-0.0390231162,
0.0221217144,
0.0305755008,
0.0065785041,
0.0514420047,
-0.0137792276,
-0.0130091244,
0.0019375475,
0.0374284908,
-0.0054004486,
0.014047537,
0.0390233807,
0.0238883644,
0.0095760962,
0.0293626767,
0.0728161037,
0.0070403302,
0.0544030778,
0.0085894866,
-0.020155292,
-0.0708778948,
-0.0061647855,
-0.0063508651,
0.008880958,
-0.0005975494,
0.0137107493,
-0.0607339554,
-0.0577201247,
0.0408290513,
-0.0322330557,
-0.0246622898,
0.0320472009,
0.0011531614,
0.0307417065,
0.0011673605,
-0.0678009167,
-0.0449695252,
0.0242498182,
-0.0275588427,
-0.0184509065,
-0.0387990363,
-5.982406298e-33,
-0.0514128804,
-0.0385234244,
-0.0012805195,
-0.011564061,
-0.0097740004,
0.0274398308,
-0.0280743781,
-0.029258484,
0.0014421224,
0.0520271398,
-0.0076790643,
0.0147672193,
0.0038873251,
0.0306922887,
-0.033226721,
-0.043042995,
0.036505267,
-0.0069999304,
0.0188112985,
0.0104223769,
0.0840278566,
0.048389636,
0.0603087842,
-0.1458900422,
0.0481155775,
-0.000173655,
-0.00597791,
0.0297733396,
0.0466516539,
0.0349799283,
-0.0245013051,
0.0095312577,
0.0208802652,
-0.0284258556,
0.0071486556,
-0.0036307641,
-0.1667177379,
-0.0182745364,
-0.0493851826,
0.0069673792,
-0.0309240669,
-0.0225624274,
0.0500693507,
0.0130704287,
0.043903444,
-0.0590557158,
0.0350604169,
-0.0578292161,
-0.0190969985,
-0.0967256874,
-0.048465699,
0.0609328337,
0.025639927,
0.0101884799,
0.0351870768,
-0.0054602446,
0.016546566,
0.0373900309,
-0.0822616518,
-0.0666607842,
0.0171962529,
-0.0054007112,
0.0078225425,
0.015030453,
-0.0088234339,
0.0422400013,
0.0039816303,
-0.0154604437,
0.0358131342,
-0.0535816103,
0.0036904833,
0.0210562125,
0.0025139807,
0.0691711903,
0.0527770445,
0.0211885199,
-0.1027052552,
0.0115142781,
0.0153766768,
0.0445136465,
-0.0291070286,
0.0141180744,
-0.0655820146,
-0.0057199928,
0.0047006248,
-0.0356123932,
-0.007647885,
0.0042906236,
-0.0073881261,
0.0075805262,
-0.0314844251,
0.0378064364,
0.0005294995,
-0.0085230377,
-0.0500538945,
0.0492536537,
0.0079590939,
-0.0005141039,
0.01000538,
-0.0258963984,
-0.0325205065,
-0.0146314362,
0.0039102654,
0.0038352807,
0.0020499497,
0.0114849387,
0.0876948014,
-0.0606451146,
-0.0733263567,
-0.0231537111,
-0.0200979933,
0.0340337195,
0.0105939079,
0.0299821291,
0.0191743467,
-0.0031403918,
0.0092805121,
0.0704670474,
0.0736957043,
0.0299079008,
-0.008695812,
0.0395615771,
-0.0004701315,
0.0137842186,
0.0193059389,
-0.0315966122,
0.0350529589,
0.0061633345,
0.0343334265,
-0.0678395778,
0.0132685816,
-0.0069375299,
2.626e-7,
0.045896709,
0.0226376709,
0.0473816618,
-0.0063769366,
0.0390874073,
0.0578329898,
0.0300327111,
-0.0034259779,
-0.0128227873,
-0.0207613837,
0.0114922849,
-0.0297437012,
0.0224516671,
0.0641841888,
-0.0456005335,
-0.0421524495,
-0.0341530405,
-0.0441933386,
-0.0261482485,
-0.0187465474,
0.1019844189,
0.0776175633,
0.0391629711,
-0.0097042248,
-0.034408465,
-0.0445527881,
0.0581522211,
-0.0506173857,
0.0569715314,
0.0163689442,
0.0350285433,
-0.018377237,
0.0008090578,
0.0614625737,
-0.0192429125,
0.0264818612,
0.0017130319,
0.064116396,
-0.0051193531,
-0.0088805947,
0.0236602314,
-0.012659193,
0.0231329817,
-0.0155994231,
0.0668082461,
-0.0688348934,
-0.0288900416,
-0.0019341252,
-0.0411859304,
-0.0281186048,
0.007059529,
0.0221143831,
0.0055645257,
0.0187530313,
-0.0011440774,
-0.010338217,
-0.0071343118,
-0.066206947,
0.0212677941,
0.0562281907,
0.0108958222,
-0.0103503605,
0.0184706133,
0.0261777714,
0.0153781641,
-0.0671711341,
0.0052517853,
2.511938903e-34,
0.0026696192,
-0.0035905731,
-0.0517913662,
0.0477575101,
0.0255789142,
-0.0418666787,
-0.0435679257,
-0.0088260649,
0.0217450783,
-0.0450561643,
0.0431408212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00815v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00815v1 | Design Choices for Crowdsourcing Implicit Discourse Relations: Revealing the Biases Introduced by Task Design | 2023-04-03T09:04:18 | 2023-04-03T09:04:18 | Valentina Pyatkin, Frances Yung, Merel C. J. Scholman, Reut Tsarfaty, Ido Dagan, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Disagreement in natural language annotation has mostly been studied from a
perspective of biases introduced by the annotators and the annotation
frameworks. Here, we propose to analyze another source of bias: task design
bias, which has a particularly strong impact on crowdsourced linguistic
annotations where natural language is used to elicit the interpretation of
laymen annotators. For this purpose we look at implicit discourse relation
annotation, a task that has repeatedly been shown to be difficult due to the
relations' ambiguity. We compare the annotations of 1,200 discourse relations
obtained using two distinct annotation tasks and quantify the biases of both
methods across four different domains. Both methods are natural language
annotation tasks designed for crowdsourcing. We show that the task design can
push annotators towards certain relations and that some discourse relations
senses can be better elicited with one or the other annotation approach. We
also conclude that this type of bias should be taken into account when training
and testing models. | [
0.0664072931,
0.0249257181,
-0.0068793637,
0.0622469895,
-0.0144771105,
-0.0075190798,
0.0013942077,
-0.0281430352,
0.0112031037,
-0.0905542523,
-0.0303610433,
0.0239087101,
0.0131487874,
-0.0543903597,
-0.0285473354,
-0.0626327842,
-0.0053644753,
-0.0161216483,
0.0632153675,
-0.010308112,
0.0319840424,
0.0151539259,
-0.0405246094,
0.0537435003,
-0.0491207615,
-0.0131912418,
-0.0085394373,
0.0134831807,
0.0164235309,
-0.0555402301,
0.0228519961,
0.0635970384,
-0.0055824537,
0.04614361,
0.0000017532,
-0.0456526168,
0.0209319405,
0.0239376333,
-0.055172924,
0.0058420082,
-0.0073783724,
0.0150595661,
0.0369156972,
-0.01463007,
-0.0400512703,
-0.0223716348,
0.0403410904,
0.0671865642,
0.065189153,
0.0011204273,
-0.0075152209,
-0.0110078147,
-0.0665949285,
0.019249117,
-0.0358247794,
-0.0435192958,
0.0043978952,
0.0223952346,
-0.0095001953,
0.0575606376,
0.0250355899,
0.0243296362,
-0.0048553837,
-0.0227896702,
0.0503347255,
-0.0170000233,
-0.0689513236,
-0.0165794231,
-0.0263402183,
0.0582553335,
0.1222975552,
0.0266616736,
-0.0123126227,
-0.0058651222,
0.0076634246,
0.0381294116,
0.0085732574,
0.0116492715,
-0.043386519,
0.0180339068,
-0.0095522255,
0.033437971,
-0.0051020095,
0.00095319,
0.073566772,
0.0533408858,
-0.031928435,
0.0217911061,
-0.0014800193,
0.058259204,
-0.0360606946,
-0.0613904223,
0.0146917673,
-0.0191753376,
-0.0354247987,
0.0017011428,
-0.0053982292,
-0.0425718687,
0.0296707135,
-0.0856207311,
0.0462967902,
0.0028376151,
-0.0428580828,
0.0391851403,
-0.0052291946,
-0.0089612007,
-0.0140435984,
-0.0331150368,
0.0006790417,
0.0042478205,
-0.0348059013,
-0.0037741102,
-0.0402466543,
0.0370152481,
-0.0586100034,
0.0185936838,
-0.0257239975,
-0.0204440374,
-0.0325437412,
-0.005055286,
0.0092011476,
0.0107736103,
-0.0481375493,
0.0167186223,
-0.0607143603,
0.0135386391,
-0.0618078411,
0.040827807,
-0.0382815786,
-0.0622340441,
0.0142128365,
0.0283729415,
0.0046584792,
-0.0223921314,
-0.0509113632,
0.0645420179,
-0.0031042963,
0.0140021965,
-0.0425165705,
-0.0618400127,
-0.0144216651,
0.00935682,
0.0127617503,
-0.0367887579,
-0.0038732185,
0.0016011588,
-0.006994715,
-0.01755495,
0.0466946028,
0.0005666334,
-0.0434232131,
0.0946134999,
-0.0304689165,
-0.0083279023,
0.0532581247,
-0.0105190594,
-0.0476481132,
0.0781300366,
0.0429381654,
-0.0148305697,
0.0300956536,
0.0290962067,
-0.0078102872,
0.0005686034,
-0.0063826242,
-0.0232824069,
0.0626934692,
0.0255916324,
-0.0397676788,
0.0218042247,
0.0330953822,
0.0755335614,
-0.0125635946,
-0.005201675,
0.040404126,
0.0523952842,
-0.0669571832,
-0.0072813355,
0.028825704,
0.0426885039,
0.021953728,
0.0313660614,
-0.0000370486,
0.0067013288,
-0.0137697309,
-0.0374513119,
0.0226909369,
-0.0284786969,
0.0005746272,
-0.0632648319,
-0.0354381204,
-0.0026667835,
0.0442459211,
-0.0062831854,
0.0208104011,
0.044310946,
-0.0127059277,
0.0292666443,
0.0201255381,
-0.0391732603,
-0.0092896931,
0.0001594016,
-0.0061550164,
0.0202581957,
-0.0167744309,
-0.0083731944,
-0.0363962837,
-0.0348386317,
0.0421632081,
0.0926892459,
0.0304167587,
-0.0369884223,
-0.0346404798,
-0.0168647021,
-0.0570676289,
0.0036289955,
0.0276413821,
0.0183463916,
0.0320722722,
-0.0463615693,
0.0124500832,
-0.019804934,
-0.0438249856,
0.0233780034,
0.0037298782,
-0.0219455287,
-0.0146530429,
0.014029867,
0.0411175825,
0.0346557945,
-0.0024577293,
0.003899565,
0.0144384243,
-0.0378236473,
-0.0337128267,
0.0579597242,
-0.0306557976,
0.0046092072,
0.0059105358,
-0.0879507363,
-0.058203835,
-0.0170256346,
-0.0197887309,
-0.0149412006,
0.0187894665,
-0.0518638641,
0.0106822858,
-0.0236015432,
-0.0611036122,
0.0088192234,
-0.0465191193,
-0.0061011077,
0.031592641,
0.0054826057,
-0.0029138853,
0.0344391614,
-0.0706099048,
0.0314645357,
-0.0158699136,
-0.03335182,
-0.0295444578,
0.0377133898,
0.0162469894,
0.0413174704,
-0.0185239799,
-0.0347381681,
0.0174705572,
-0.1154012382,
-0.0201890655,
-0.01762853,
0.0272061527,
0.0039636674,
-0.0268423352,
0.019398069,
-0.0507126004,
0.0183952656,
-0.0379996113,
-0.0804969072,
0.0386838056,
0.0804195851,
0.0290020667,
0.0567288473,
-0.037774276,
0.0239212997,
-0.0288714226,
0.0171366259,
0.0852297097,
-0.0352036394,
-0.0301981289,
0.0055836421,
-0.0241689589,
0.0104271611,
0.0174120571,
-0.0409018174,
0.0555148944,
0.064579241,
0.0204455554,
0.005278544,
0.0000990232,
0.0540482476,
-0.0036948605,
-0.027764339,
-0.0425261632,
0.0214093272,
0.0046399697,
-0.0127790198,
-0.0266169999,
-0.0169132352,
-0.0265193861,
0.0633970723,
-0.0020009975,
0.0072180023,
-0.0688983425,
0.0387666114,
-0.0830863416,
-0.015116551,
-0.0080209859,
-0.0536996275,
-0.0025645145,
0.0597142614,
-0.0199716296,
0.0258244071,
0.0579052046,
-0.010654686,
0.0038052571,
-0.0243063197,
0.0234374646,
-0.0244998969,
0.064053975,
-0.0399787985,
0.0115754372,
0.04211336,
-0.0173595324,
-0.0295499824,
-0.0052572968,
0.0990913436,
-0.027024813,
0.0277373753,
-0.0545269474,
0.0161777772,
-0.0175001752,
-0.053277038,
-0.0303298403,
-0.0629864857,
-0.0572126694,
0.011385709,
0.0397057459,
0.0013625046,
0.0469663627,
0.0270488914,
-0.0177985895,
-0.0016699436,
0.0377979986,
-0.0103755333,
-0.0219608583,
0.0162461232,
0.0122292228,
0.063003771,
0.013051522,
0.0317258909,
-0.0395836793,
0.0346688367,
-0.0197020825,
-0.010042211,
-0.0357317552,
-0.0244137999,
-0.0072516864,
-0.0421849228,
-0.0316083767,
-0.035965763,
0.0947030112,
-0.056927558,
0.0324091539,
0.0793046206,
0.0059451079,
-0.0049793744,
-0.000046911,
-0.0287506711,
0.0006502748,
0.0237402152,
-0.0184751786,
-0.0959767774,
-0.0146127352,
-0.0093172695,
0.023157021,
-0.0224620104,
-0.0723670423,
0.0265146028,
-0.1054721773,
0.0010749276,
-0.0279332642,
0.0045195031,
0.0629297644,
-0.0428381786,
0.0415171534,
-0.018603513,
0.0001935893,
-0.0167111512,
0.0071696918,
0.0261100773,
0.0512059815,
-0.0226666275,
-0.0009554042,
0.0139712952,
-0.0252491646,
0.0715618804,
0.0359488428,
0.0551307648,
-0.0065644439,
-0.0036131337,
0.0335911028,
0.0084262788,
0.0132065602,
-0.0134213995,
0.0455683991,
-0.0024567225,
-0.0213388167,
-0.0392467193,
0.022121286,
-0.02226099,
0.006830771,
0.0006182368,
0.0199433025,
0.0116255293,
0.0191434193,
-0.0075029642,
0.0217557233,
0.0378702395,
0.0838631317,
0.0093297632,
-0.0218445659,
-0.0224557742,
-0.0527914055,
0.0345056392,
-0.0343527794,
-0.0400773622,
0.0109117981,
0.009773382,
-0.022936957,
-0.0695310533,
-0.0851132125,
0.0348438509,
-0.0005543535,
0.0276979227,
0.0073513859,
0.0531495288,
0.0160170794,
-0.0003402815,
0.0387666933,
-0.0276078247,
-0.0077039083,
0.0200577565,
-0.0320084281,
0.0102030532,
-0.0048949746,
-0.0275559761,
0.0468894616,
-0.0508172624,
-0.0293853749,
0.0047040898,
0.0344782099,
0.018612165,
0.0544061922,
-0.0108043337,
-0.0224564634,
-0.0277946629,
0.0500485562,
-0.0268331598,
0.0179412048,
0.0449413322,
0.0651337355,
-0.0126056392,
0.0303931069,
-0.0346625261,
0.0046651107,
-0.0164592322,
0.0392898507,
-0.0558480807,
-0.0358444937,
0.0154035846,
0.0240716301,
0.081487529,
-0.021327924,
0.0231324062,
-0.0333510451,
-0.0046370821,
-0.0240585115,
-0.0540261045,
-0.0498613194,
-0.0065189414,
-0.0421288833,
-0.0322598629,
-0.0175242778,
-0.0069946791,
-0.0161822978,
0.0680534393,
-0.0171251632,
0.0419350527,
0.1021376848,
0.0177144893,
-0.0324245878,
-0.0042631715,
-0.0046339855,
0.0281250663,
0.0054282169,
0.04038563,
0.0231444519,
0.0220372956,
0.0293621682,
-0.0125087071,
0.0449821912,
-0.0230443534,
-0.0008410868,
-0.0027134928,
-0.0007386229,
0.0292554386,
0.0262858234,
-0.0218479242,
0.0732359439,
0.0035769884,
0.004578724,
0.0158035308,
0.038726531,
0.0033561143,
-0.0008988312,
0.0341483802,
-0.0091782156,
-0.0308050364,
0.0168975331,
0.058153633,
-0.0640059263,
0.0375513919,
0.006065432,
-0.0197933391,
-0.0597515069,
-0.0325681493,
-0.0452130102,
-0.0106485728,
0.0166076906,
0.0101230806,
-0.0614011548,
-0.0278153438,
0.0285356697,
-0.0122459065,
-0.0132914307,
-0.0137086557,
0.0254480094,
0.0015710827,
-0.0059001376,
-0.0561601557,
-0.0555595793,
-0.006855451,
-0.0536824279,
0.0106755951,
-0.0770118013,
-6.067971267e-33,
-0.0816366822,
-0.0789138153,
-0.0121419262,
0.0299564339,
-0.0137149869,
0.0364631973,
-0.0433000773,
0.0287072603,
-0.0071858605,
0.0634492561,
0.0226753429,
-0.0032048766,
0.0242989287,
-0.0176978391,
0.0636380911,
-0.0655997247,
0.0685047209,
-0.014704925,
-0.0073931748,
-0.0189822279,
0.0379338413,
-0.0419923216,
0.0250962861,
-0.103198424,
0.0872143283,
-0.0227308478,
-0.0244799387,
0.0459383503,
0.0229902752,
0.045609504,
-0.0114549361,
0.0364643596,
0.0166485123,
0.0188660193,
0.0096221613,
0.002577892,
-0.0585762411,
-0.0369416215,
0.0530654788,
0.0411092341,
-0.0578398183,
-0.0326094627,
0.0166102163,
0.0158411488,
-0.0125258667,
0.0120532867,
0.0622230843,
-0.0078763161,
0.0358316824,
0.0163669754,
-0.0304840207,
0.0191865005,
-0.0183089674,
-0.0112012131,
0.0173308942,
0.0489446297,
0.0283129066,
-0.0430356637,
-0.0677853897,
-0.013550329,
-0.0469020158,
-0.013396306,
0.0184177179,
-0.0049895206,
0.0125093637,
0.0420019217,
-0.0364625305,
0.0511354506,
-0.036820244,
-0.0277464837,
-0.028305918,
0.0047166296,
0.0183107182,
0.065544188,
-0.0165654663,
0.0338185802,
-0.0123867393,
-0.0199214853,
-0.0046615233,
0.0268408228,
-0.00033409,
0.0045863283,
-0.0436326228,
-0.0109740775,
-0.0589910261,
-0.0597131923,
-0.0146527337,
-0.0157846082,
0.0019602007,
-0.032117743,
-0.0199224241,
0.0380092449,
0.0047305436,
-0.0259006079,
-0.0259912107,
-0.0328238197,
0.0026013099,
0.0281299111,
0.0030520298,
0.0000990902,
-0.0215017106,
0.0413490273,
-0.0027165322,
0.0440079048,
0.0560341142,
0.025604656,
0.036075417,
-0.0208426304,
-0.0253934972,
-0.0207530558,
-0.0164190028,
0.014919661,
-0.0623593777,
-0.0090813469,
0.0412309766,
0.0455775298,
-0.0158808976,
0.0024290807,
0.021405967,
0.0398431793,
-0.006493147,
0.0252472982,
-0.0287906993,
-0.0307465103,
-0.0124889361,
0.0008697007,
0.0440413095,
0.0150483064,
-0.0147282584,
-0.0016157731,
-0.0103377951,
-0.0030572645,
2.276e-7,
0.061001163,
0.0575428084,
0.0494902283,
-0.0061623221,
-0.002077132,
0.0267514531,
0.042303782,
0.0130090714,
0.0072295256,
-0.051938843,
-0.0194072016,
-0.0011565237,
0.039502874,
0.0690038949,
-0.1040016115,
-0.0560634695,
-0.064529188,
0.0320371427,
-0.0181686115,
0.0147301136,
0.0816825628,
-0.0320588313,
0.0112377014,
0.0370797701,
-0.0676224157,
0.0012689239,
0.0376448818,
-0.0383322947,
0.0098931799,
0.029876221,
0.0088362396,
-0.0012049035,
0.0091259768,
0.0552892648,
0.0048962152,
-0.0316234455,
0.0413992479,
0.0300035607,
0.0001172793,
-0.0430244319,
-0.0526170917,
-0.000040056,
0.0326123759,
0.0159141514,
0.0007791749,
-0.0562212542,
-0.0400131047,
-0.022811044,
-0.0320440121,
-0.0071557052,
0.0124881715,
0.0280016121,
-0.0029821035,
0.0115067223,
0.0126143852,
-0.0167285856,
-0.0229657125,
-0.0165757034,
-0.018157538,
0.006280161,
-0.0042354097,
-0.0299633052,
0.0017613005,
0.0057236501,
-0.0210234877,
-0.0176392607,
0.0164737031,
1.121595295e-34,
0.0056798882,
-0.0075642066,
0.0315561481,
0.0351211429,
0.063433826,
0.0269494001,
-0.0159635898,
-0.010263701,
0.0410392806,
-0.0083613768,
0.0129611399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08174v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08174v1 | Benchmarking Faithfulness: Towards Accurate Natural Language Explanations in Vision-Language Tasks | 2023-04-03T08:24:10 | 2023-04-03T08:24:10 | Jakob Ambsdorf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | With deep neural models increasingly permeating our daily lives comes a need
for transparent and comprehensible explanations of their decision-making.
However, most explanation methods that have been developed so far are not
intuitively understandable for lay users. In contrast, natural language
explanations (NLEs) promise to enable the communication of a model's
decision-making in an easily intelligible way. While current models
successfully generate convincing explanations, it is an open question how well
the NLEs actually represent the reasoning process of the models - a property
called faithfulness. Although the development of metrics to measure
faithfulness is crucial to designing more faithful models, current metrics are
either not applicable to NLEs or are not designed to compare different model
architectures across multiple modalities.
Building on prior research on faithfulness measures and based on a detailed
rationale, we address this issue by proposing three faithfulness metrics:
Attribution-Similarity, NLE-Sufficiency, and NLE-Comprehensiveness. The
efficacy of the metrics is evaluated on the VQA-X and e-SNLI-VE datasets of the
e-ViL benchmark for vision-language NLE generation by systematically applying
modifications to the performant e-UG model for which we expect changes in the
measured explanation faithfulness. We show on the e-SNLI-VE dataset that the
removal of redundant inputs to the explanation-generation module of e-UG
successively increases the model's faithfulness on the linguistic modality as
measured by Attribution-Similarity. Further, our analysis demonstrates that
NLE-Sufficiency and -Comprehensiveness are not necessarily correlated to
Attribution-Similarity, and we discuss how the two metrics can be utilized to
gain further insights into the explanation generation process. | [
0.0210819114,
0.0580309592,
0.0004243868,
0.024693884,
-0.0248764772,
0.0258535221,
0.0178144872,
-0.0264618266,
-0.0474282391,
-0.030171793,
0.0025749884,
-0.0111663938,
0.0343573205,
0.0434966087,
0.0266997293,
-0.0561410673,
0.0298965015,
-0.0227346327,
-0.0204233527,
0.0133223822,
0.0143225612,
0.0040097395,
-0.0077782697,
0.0863634646,
-0.0025299373,
0.0068915742,
-0.0208400693,
0.0255959071,
0.0062590376,
0.0030353656,
-0.0271197725,
-0.0004934705,
0.0388849564,
-0.0052363547,
0.0000022628,
-0.0360421315,
0.0253739804,
0.009826012,
-0.0597068816,
0.0241704974,
-0.0129059078,
-0.0286706258,
0.0299425349,
-0.0011390069,
0.0225682724,
0.036747545,
0.0948523358,
0.0404121913,
0.0373090506,
0.0284332465,
0.0062970845,
-0.0298148822,
0.0085280174,
-0.0173021108,
0.0125491414,
-0.0129177244,
-0.0223403517,
0.0116322814,
-0.0223543327,
0.0064085247,
-0.0217994638,
0.0199525859,
0.0621376634,
-0.0281724725,
0.0050115855,
0.0162931867,
-0.0134830875,
-0.0541960709,
-0.009999915,
0.0599183179,
-0.0040601483,
-0.0240818467,
0.0065674088,
-0.0220167413,
-0.0131547665,
0.0450655259,
-0.0418208539,
0.0183094088,
0.0084805451,
0.0219292454,
-0.0336304195,
0.0050016288,
0.0643207803,
0.0286460984,
0.0028722836,
0.026580587,
0.0017488912,
0.0297331382,
-0.0286254045,
0.000010205,
-0.0460369177,
-0.0786934122,
-0.0007931466,
0.0408826508,
-0.0348562151,
0.0014127236,
-0.0369870849,
0.0037364531,
-0.0068990681,
-0.0122689232,
0.0679510832,
0.0536204278,
-0.0331588723,
0.0267415754,
-0.0163100772,
0.1040066481,
-0.0158978738,
0.0294668172,
-0.036535956,
-0.0458534174,
-0.051223319,
-0.020442944,
-0.0171815623,
-0.0155798066,
-0.0342651531,
-0.0487621091,
-0.0434702747,
0.0081910649,
-0.043262098,
-0.0031022781,
0.0231718048,
0.048021771,
-0.0413750745,
-0.0182623956,
-0.0418661088,
0.0079402756,
-0.0576128922,
0.0258056801,
0.0509217158,
-0.0787206143,
-0.0001034241,
0.0496228337,
-0.0187408235,
-0.0091098184,
-0.0114935664,
0.0508805327,
0.0053179292,
0.0057124561,
-0.02029128,
-0.0429306813,
-0.0318201296,
-0.0492304862,
-0.00268624,
-0.0431644134,
0.0282196123,
-0.0029657611,
-0.0136509854,
-0.050017938,
-0.0104312617,
-0.0103095388,
-0.0246412363,
0.0776113793,
-0.0247861929,
0.0258318186,
-0.0014251327,
0.0166805666,
-0.0096763885,
0.0017497172,
0.03260554,
0.0129328677,
0.0144222816,
-0.041399464,
0.0355069526,
-0.0032565657,
-0.0023495739,
-0.0203086082,
-0.0551581755,
-0.0330419429,
-0.0835051611,
0.0475827195,
0.0642171651,
0.0417472906,
-0.028233951,
-0.0290275551,
0.063545458,
0.0305779409,
0.0512640812,
0.0153763201,
0.078277126,
0.0116965054,
-0.0231929328,
0.0256165043,
-0.0918385088,
0.0648859441,
0.006406466,
0.012800429,
0.0010193894,
-0.0099737765,
-0.0385487638,
-0.0667619556,
-0.0085935425,
-0.0076715131,
0.0122502269,
0.0209421199,
0.0389711075,
-0.0108536454,
-0.0223902613,
0.0558619313,
0.0309490357,
-0.0263263304,
0.005173177,
-0.0826995149,
0.0445700362,
0.0805546343,
0.008028687,
0.0363296643,
-0.0098303454,
0.0117691429,
0.0188556965,
0.0295756105,
0.0239879675,
0.0094183506,
0.0484061204,
-0.0451496392,
-0.0660049096,
-0.0449100472,
0.0264553688,
0.0220167972,
-0.002405568,
-0.0251312573,
0.0329366662,
-0.0667489618,
-0.0365472622,
0.0355310738,
0.0142177688,
0.0002047133,
-0.0025503496,
0.0051422711,
0.008697235,
0.0133864507,
-0.015575164,
0.0262375735,
-0.0062838853,
-0.0126384431,
0.0065463651,
0.0412145965,
-0.0602284856,
0.019198034,
0.020179905,
-0.0579473637,
0.0123939607,
0.0545678325,
-0.028783733,
-0.0449939333,
0.0157069601,
-0.0532586128,
-0.0077079516,
-0.0455472618,
0.0102060949,
-0.005641914,
0.0016361825,
-0.009639591,
0.0404865965,
-0.0018543085,
-0.0047959913,
0.0333029069,
0.0025089951,
0.0332180187,
-0.0341641009,
0.0298073087,
-0.0093414411,
-0.0276127011,
0.0027373806,
0.0160870478,
0.0001728834,
-0.0287172142,
0.012173011,
-0.0668646768,
-0.0217834748,
-0.0441552848,
-0.0044357996,
0.0410428531,
-0.0064412551,
0.0238145571,
-0.0245216079,
-0.0151936458,
0.0264818165,
0.011083832,
0.0007135908,
0.0310829412,
-0.0063076406,
-0.0545665398,
-0.0402232595,
-0.0111563783,
0.0031521814,
0.0549884774,
0.0215539094,
-0.0103209158,
-0.0751398578,
-0.0056731249,
-0.0250938442,
-0.0076996344,
-0.0137807587,
-0.0419542678,
0.042867478,
0.0497502945,
-0.0240304098,
0.040708825,
0.0062836953,
0.043888133,
0.0274870116,
0.0379632674,
-0.0638371781,
-0.0177316722,
-0.0367284082,
-0.0321942009,
-0.0166044403,
-0.0578688234,
-0.0001703896,
0.0597878955,
-0.0069161905,
0.0144868633,
-0.0729479939,
0.0347460359,
0.0169969965,
-0.0574782714,
-0.0371180959,
-0.0422688834,
0.0017705014,
0.0555472448,
-0.0403408632,
-0.0991720557,
0.0521206297,
-0.047231175,
0.0155382808,
0.0159368049,
-0.0109079396,
0.0038367505,
0.0584015772,
0.0053672525,
0.0318439975,
0.0172491129,
-0.0016002104,
-0.0313985087,
-0.0310906991,
0.0451927446,
0.0316591337,
0.0755428448,
-0.0701589212,
-0.0124046598,
0.0156352483,
0.010233473,
-0.0436402,
-0.001293239,
-0.0277662314,
0.0515219234,
-0.0139748696,
-0.0208111089,
-0.0442400612,
0.0100908121,
0.0356846116,
0.0076166089,
0.0042910976,
-0.0186443217,
-0.0119024618,
0.001709936,
0.0464947782,
0.0779547766,
0.0411700271,
-0.0220240802,
0.0110709975,
0.0225664061,
0.0088248001,
0.0603247434,
-0.0739419535,
0.0323184915,
-0.0155582754,
0.0025452485,
-0.0281782206,
0.0570207499,
0.081211552,
-0.0787475631,
0.0002089716,
0.1151183993,
-0.0028085848,
-0.0119196856,
0.0275827628,
-0.0189154316,
0.0423374176,
0.0168115981,
-0.0091075655,
-0.0471588969,
-0.0527626537,
0.0010840927,
0.0234775636,
0.0245487187,
0.0129259806,
-0.0085638994,
-0.0533077829,
0.0510140769,
0.0041965996,
-0.0125183435,
-0.0486659035,
-0.026295431,
-0.0121576609,
-0.0083064036,
0.0234806817,
-0.0100546619,
0.0376861393,
0.0155370682,
0.0359043255,
-0.0352412947,
-0.0583313778,
0.0217011906,
-0.0742787644,
0.0313803814,
0.0670734867,
0.0021499675,
-0.005970519,
-0.0590324625,
0.0123980632,
-0.0038416807,
0.0438870043,
0.0086974185,
0.049493432,
0.0105673159,
-0.0428082198,
-0.030945465,
0.0341979004,
-0.0314316377,
-0.02668548,
-0.0328166671,
0.0337907821,
-0.0354104787,
-0.0154222921,
-0.039506238,
-0.016313944,
-0.012521957,
0.0924709365,
0.0704929456,
-0.0211480875,
-0.0552703589,
-0.0082095033,
-0.0068308786,
-0.0484684184,
-0.0363367535,
0.0410323963,
0.0388952196,
-0.0354466923,
-0.0303986464,
-0.0397196263,
0.0010702548,
0.0188398957,
-0.0111613432,
-0.030087091,
0.0007697207,
-0.0195568614,
-0.0372195579,
0.0661565363,
0.0019401391,
0.0285624508,
-0.0141723389,
-0.0197088234,
-0.0153752379,
-0.0280362479,
-0.0164416507,
0.009391793,
-0.0151624195,
-0.018836312,
-0.0128966933,
0.0366690904,
0.0283089317,
0.0601465106,
0.0026133528,
-0.0650226995,
-0.0021379115,
0.0025705539,
0.0043189023,
0.0048238263,
0.0283288825,
-0.0195176583,
-0.0041082995,
0.063085258,
-0.0393268391,
-0.0008897186,
0.0050077122,
0.0557316765,
0.0191763658,
-0.0285040643,
0.0455491319,
-0.004139442,
0.0349407382,
-0.0371263362,
0.0141795892,
-0.007321883,
-0.0162357092,
0.0169836078,
-0.0016490557,
-0.0714693666,
0.0247271284,
0.0287512094,
0.0234748106,
0.0179114752,
-0.0154931964,
-0.0227845535,
0.0072763562,
-0.0332075357,
-0.0126556428,
-0.0037408916,
0.0044533568,
-0.0321905464,
0.040536698,
-0.0174440183,
0.020120563,
-0.0465384573,
0.0305900816,
-0.0047846222,
0.0730533749,
0.0251844786,
0.0161349941,
-0.0196851306,
0.0200671777,
-0.0347053334,
-0.0664759949,
-0.0025861713,
-0.0032221209,
0.0309123825,
-0.0149591444,
0.0436466411,
-0.005408478,
0.0053462526,
-0.0306341257,
0.0783104822,
0.0326803699,
-0.0044487892,
0.04537981,
0.0232107434,
-0.0235813819,
-0.025964465,
0.0561796091,
0.0092679812,
0.0192058738,
-0.0299350657,
-0.0171563476,
-0.0007587348,
-0.0526651032,
0.0134516535,
0.0272399485,
-0.0191447511,
-0.016776111,
-0.0260964409,
-0.0687755048,
-0.0327184796,
0.0243634377,
0.0021278684,
-0.0149814626,
0.0509526804,
0.0777213797,
-0.0282970369,
-0.0246795863,
0.0067345584,
-0.0259004403,
-0.0306218062,
0.0463245846,
-0.0102880681,
-6.543649382e-33,
0.0042593977,
-0.0363087133,
0.0189087521,
-0.048556149,
-0.0098609235,
0.0159623772,
-0.0535871275,
-0.0022159771,
-0.0408064574,
0.0578508154,
0.0520884953,
0.0223094337,
0.0101476302,
0.0282163415,
0.0045719133,
-0.0428231768,
0.0257622655,
0.0207093749,
-0.0319332853,
0.0153518617,
0.0161905847,
-0.0268104542,
0.0644351989,
-0.0865812898,
0.038365148,
0.0441301614,
-0.0111006806,
0.0122453459,
-0.007447008,
0.0996238291,
-0.0234478675,
0.0403458551,
0.0243397504,
-0.0333337151,
-0.0103812329,
0.0163650345,
-0.0442136191,
-0.0136758955,
0.0494945198,
0.0211276505,
-0.1070352271,
-0.0136400759,
0.0786121935,
-0.0018667638,
-0.0231440943,
-0.0313798971,
0.0394780859,
-0.01074694,
-0.0134957721,
0.004110564,
-0.0345912538,
0.0060577099,
-0.0284433234,
-0.050769791,
0.0000715761,
0.0480728447,
-0.0338270776,
0.0282789636,
-0.0243462231,
-0.0355061591,
0.0099777495,
0.0026702282,
0.1249949783,
0.0075763888,
0.0007132645,
0.0862653181,
0.0542204864,
-0.049631577,
-0.0737236366,
-0.0269832686,
0.0091849174,
0.074698925,
0.1013706028,
0.0468344614,
0.0416811481,
0.0312643312,
-0.0668985844,
0.0273756161,
-0.0474266037,
0.0623138994,
0.0352598168,
0.0189661384,
-0.0429871157,
-0.0193597395,
-0.061448466,
-0.0254788324,
-0.0573328733,
-0.0436633229,
0.0714942142,
-0.0138414418,
-0.0440749153,
-0.0004598233,
0.0244732313,
-0.0451086648,
0.0151693979,
0.0150263514,
-0.0295539033,
0.0140000423,
0.015344739,
-0.0013787965,
-0.0216561984,
-0.0061737141,
0.0095873121,
0.0312203132,
0.0378737263,
-0.0006674638,
0.0252299309,
0.028451873,
0.0053336811,
-0.0024164091,
-0.0673590004,
-0.0478962399,
-0.0322725177,
-0.0146982418,
0.0428028777,
0.0143654188,
-0.0673528984,
0.0218764916,
-0.0196319446,
-0.0242279135,
-0.0025749984,
-0.00280866,
-0.0044058883,
0.0346225277,
-0.0161803551,
-0.0245089345,
-0.0568955317,
-0.0479951203,
0.0409681536,
-0.0282041188,
-0.0332378633,
0.0292321499,
2.773e-7,
0.032364212,
-0.0076878504,
0.0318345986,
-0.0102320565,
0.016495537,
0.0432446599,
0.0123163294,
-0.0108407382,
-0.0303839892,
-0.0661572814,
0.0024745506,
0.0564577356,
0.0374239348,
-0.0222433489,
0.0412436724,
0.0165207386,
-0.0684713125,
0.0008802883,
-0.0194881521,
0.0294039622,
0.0661202744,
0.0425845869,
-0.0075703217,
-0.0172947515,
0.0469450355,
-0.0436706394,
0.0442119762,
-0.070289813,
0.0293868594,
-0.0026899555,
0.0496749133,
0.0223417953,
0.0165696088,
0.0134483567,
0.0065239677,
-0.0231535658,
0.0210779831,
0.0494350791,
-0.0363510177,
-0.025535617,
-0.0670631826,
-0.0364233553,
0.0376114994,
-0.0977857411,
0.0582989305,
-0.0546904691,
-0.0239000861,
-0.0192643702,
-0.0271262117,
-0.0089853182,
0.0073893298,
0.0010271543,
-0.0102444682,
0.0017368604,
0.0254844557,
-0.0086633423,
-0.0382379107,
-0.0689387098,
-0.0475448295,
-0.0147076724,
-0.0341396369,
0.0148803573,
-0.0692351907,
-0.0155571224,
0.0772501305,
-0.0107912933,
-0.0393139534,
2.330698567e-34,
0.0033744592,
0.0245178472,
0.0500263982,
-0.0006755399,
0.0208024401,
0.0006366583,
-0.0163742229,
-0.0123606287,
0.0159032773,
-0.0467043519,
-0.0311859623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01233v1 | Multi-Modal Perceiver Language Model for Outcome Prediction in Emergency Department | 2023-04-03T06:32:00 | 2023-04-03T06:32:00 | Sabri Boughorbel, Fethi Jarray, Abdulaziz Al Homaid, Rashid Niaz, Khalid Alyafei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language modeling have shown impressive progress in generating compelling
text with good accuracy and high semantic coherence. An interesting research
direction is to augment these powerful models for specific applications using
contextual information. In this work, we explore multi-modal language modeling
for healthcare applications. We are interested in outcome prediction and
patient triage in hospital emergency department based on text information in
chief complaints and vital signs recorded at triage. We adapt Perceiver - a
modality-agnostic transformer-based model that has shown promising results in
several applications. Since vital-sign modality is represented in tabular
format, we modified Perceiver position encoding to ensure permutation
invariance. We evaluated the multi-modal language model for the task of
diagnosis code prediction using MIMIC-IV ED dataset on 120K visits. In the
experimental analysis, we show that mutli-modality improves the prediction
performance compared with models trained solely on text or vital signs. We
identified disease categories for which multi-modality leads to performance
improvement and show that for these categories, vital signs have added
predictive power. By analyzing the cross-attention layer, we show how
multi-modality contributes to model predictions. This work gives interesting
insights on the development of multi-modal language models for healthcare
applications. | [
0.0151586924,
0.0525801368,
0.0027447508,
-0.0020479576,
0.0007337249,
0.0048876163,
0.007736302,
0.0228534006,
-0.0339563675,
-0.0498373173,
-0.0554837026,
-0.0880279541,
0.0065797595,
0.0531380177,
0.0278781243,
-0.0271763224,
0.0475103743,
-0.0049512768,
0.0000705099,
0.0300863758,
-0.0059565785,
0.0097642951,
-0.0007108718,
0.071750395,
-0.0071982029,
-0.0011008227,
-0.0174581315,
0.0136761609,
0.0093592284,
-0.0538601018,
0.0067669442,
0.0638852492,
0.026213171,
-0.0077291992,
0.0000020195,
0.0088607147,
-0.027754318,
0.0040805866,
-0.0046684905,
-0.1000707671,
0.0371712074,
-0.1119329855,
0.0044010584,
0.0105989547,
-0.0088672088,
-0.0689711794,
0.0294476803,
0.0788161457,
0.0367918052,
0.0641474724,
-0.0186394509,
-0.0062996186,
0.0304360427,
-0.0232906323,
0.0332001895,
-0.0279064756,
0.0080179237,
0.0088048214,
0.0105220508,
0.0010273301,
-0.0451632179,
0.0433594994,
0.023626389,
0.0325578004,
-0.0132110547,
0.0441483036,
0.0290482529,
-0.0037788651,
-0.0226554554,
0.0596923716,
-0.0656362921,
-0.0130542712,
0.0101196831,
0.0105663817,
0.001897733,
-0.015561508,
-0.0357213952,
-0.014321181,
-0.0149342474,
-0.0022303483,
0.0144126387,
0.0528694689,
0.0245522037,
-0.0206227154,
0.0006151914,
-0.0193644278,
0.0040606973,
-0.0378887765,
-0.0293369908,
0.0026756979,
0.0075039165,
-0.0220781472,
0.0263881367,
0.0087718321,
-0.0534294732,
0.0203681458,
-0.0537580177,
-0.0288888812,
0.0304610878,
-0.0731061101,
0.0276500396,
0.0458642691,
-0.0114474418,
0.00883919,
-0.0148346275,
0.0069436091,
-0.0414068773,
0.0546613596,
-0.0550212525,
-0.0308168121,
-0.026497161,
0.0103161065,
-0.0193785205,
-0.0186409373,
0.0363443196,
0.0029185414,
-0.0669254884,
0.0034400295,
0.0029938626,
-0.0019432231,
0.0577372909,
0.0262880996,
-0.0573300533,
-0.0200768355,
0.004573944,
0.0470476262,
0.0481764935,
0.0131681599,
-0.0224979222,
-0.0355105735,
0.0085121207,
0.0405578725,
0.0103362557,
-0.0043423013,
-0.014717631,
0.0607517697,
-0.0184930731,
-0.0194507316,
0.0087360721,
-0.0290944632,
-0.0441226102,
-0.0049075037,
0.0075335372,
-0.0450617336,
0.0226529445,
0.027338732,
0.0247008279,
-0.0681550577,
0.0181914028,
-0.000634549,
-0.0347122438,
0.043862313,
-0.0145815462,
-0.0021330512,
-0.0010704419,
0.0297040232,
0.0233536027,
0.0481288098,
0.0329860151,
-0.014278545,
-0.0034549409,
-0.033985462,
0.0285364725,
0.0180414692,
0.0025655944,
-0.0448297933,
-0.0020406565,
0.000107424,
0.0014443061,
0.0578689277,
0.0012957008,
0.0132772774,
0.0216167364,
-0.0586235859,
0.0379666053,
0.0254372302,
0.0701503903,
0.0267722588,
0.0448592789,
-0.0180075523,
-0.0565586165,
-0.0275481343,
-0.0183039214,
0.0195275582,
0.0163790286,
0.0010909464,
0.0098779416,
0.0247130562,
-0.0307397861,
-0.0390955806,
-0.0438059345,
-0.0335524678,
-0.0404500403,
-0.0059021013,
0.0450844839,
-0.0144996978,
-0.0486411899,
0.0826002583,
0.0284499787,
-0.0218734462,
-0.0114897536,
-0.0419331267,
-0.0312888734,
0.0878713876,
0.0142527828,
-0.0226121601,
-0.0430922918,
-0.0417264551,
0.0223255996,
0.0126367491,
0.0168069117,
0.0067183953,
0.0313000791,
-0.0458597131,
-0.0160094909,
0.0629143044,
0.0133398594,
-0.0111623621,
-0.044804953,
0.0309545081,
0.0079946155,
-0.0355627015,
-0.0069299098,
0.0212341528,
-0.0248206705,
0.0072269072,
-0.001091469,
0.003420765,
0.026791336,
-0.000750995,
0.0103409924,
0.026654873,
0.0320771672,
-0.0412577651,
-0.0297296643,
0.0464082621,
-0.0792027488,
-0.0295858067,
0.0067185843,
-0.0091143195,
0.011942138,
0.0086527234,
-0.0173760336,
-0.0257945377,
-0.0065896064,
-0.0642587617,
0.0082024429,
-0.0060476293,
0.0008854693,
0.0398097448,
0.024902029,
-0.0037142602,
0.0347761065,
-0.0478494875,
0.0293665975,
-0.0015188612,
0.0102608595,
0.0128641613,
0.0054587619,
-0.0219227057,
-0.0013762935,
-0.0114929536,
0.0471534431,
0.0031221157,
0.0019717251,
0.0024285447,
-0.0438399576,
-0.1505954117,
-0.0151711637,
-0.0156220123,
-0.0238434393,
0.0471647717,
0.0389217362,
0.0054127756,
-0.0320061743,
-0.0608053058,
0.0011493929,
0.0344045237,
0.0014071409,
0.0011656455,
0.0187821817,
0.0053757615,
-0.0140071157,
-0.0151045658,
-0.059326075,
0.0580567159,
-0.0010246591,
-0.0238026604,
-0.037840765,
-0.014894207,
0.0015835019,
0.0150755057,
0.0023370041,
-0.015923325,
-0.0096018268,
-0.0269843638,
0.0318327136,
0.0122419391,
0.0214114822,
0.0541008972,
0.0356658995,
0.0106692696,
-0.0366787277,
0.0132514285,
-0.0270775314,
-0.0109021654,
0.000397175,
-0.0653823465,
-0.0063035847,
0.1117223352,
0.0320560709,
0.0061817826,
-0.0556119941,
-0.0270403586,
-0.0042758738,
-0.0104063926,
-0.0382166207,
0.0485689305,
-0.0387208611,
0.0427425057,
0.0152699929,
-0.0176605992,
0.070923239,
-0.0169899967,
-0.0006699886,
-0.065863356,
-0.0193464272,
-0.0511573888,
0.0125983022,
-0.0267079417,
0.0265244618,
0.0094270268,
-0.0151061788,
-0.0317847915,
0.0449215062,
-0.0455631875,
-0.063082844,
0.0607999489,
0.0043362277,
-0.007547474,
0.0103003317,
-0.0533894412,
-0.0442304648,
-0.0634273663,
-0.0135997199,
0.014297612,
-0.0321683064,
0.0220717676,
-0.0962190405,
0.0513095185,
0.002409888,
0.0702704713,
0.0219754782,
-0.0318580195,
-0.0099987891,
0.0476465933,
0.0200827047,
0.0521461032,
-0.0242746752,
-0.0328249186,
-0.0023646164,
0.0674007386,
-0.0212254077,
0.0324329473,
-0.0059173936,
0.010138738,
0.0235142559,
0.0148969823,
-0.0338408053,
0.0438792929,
0.0072203069,
-0.0584389269,
0.0027505017,
0.1098188385,
0.0208290964,
-0.0790738985,
0.0257854331,
-0.0410193764,
-0.0214535911,
-0.0077356435,
0.0267873257,
-0.0297578331,
-0.0583267063,
-0.018777417,
-0.0033312987,
0.021275796,
-0.0178862903,
0.0256981459,
0.0150170075,
0.0212598145,
-0.0195269845,
-0.0223101526,
-0.0801080763,
-0.0230033435,
0.019933695,
0.0042809951,
0.0081065074,
-0.0285174884,
-0.0144162076,
-0.0219759494,
0.0099790273,
-0.0204826761,
-0.0939255133,
0.0013980895,
-0.0127854217,
0.0306500513,
0.0503742918,
0.0226100609,
-0.0461241081,
-0.0468548648,
-0.016349569,
0.0115449242,
0.0407173559,
0.0086922916,
0.0281511769,
-0.0217453744,
-0.0014195933,
-0.0357583798,
-0.0031850953,
-0.0587193333,
-0.0493886732,
-0.0204046499,
0.0801552758,
-0.0386813171,
-0.0365501903,
-0.0517237335,
0.0262904819,
0.0259690247,
0.0485126339,
-0.0004760737,
-0.0546170101,
0.004291066,
-0.0179326944,
0.0524043329,
0.0248521976,
-0.0540713333,
0.0150520215,
-0.0101739066,
-0.0812675804,
-0.0299112573,
-0.03338027,
0.0028611876,
0.0001481443,
0.0059089991,
0.0063074864,
0.0347319134,
-0.0066221347,
-0.0553607754,
0.0400581732,
0.016634265,
0.0193079077,
-0.0540082343,
-0.0079651866,
0.0604074635,
-0.0018955681,
-0.0133554433,
0.0039790221,
-0.058737807,
0.0160965137,
0.0046565663,
0.0526761897,
0.0133653702,
0.0138917966,
-0.0060685081,
-0.0236027725,
0.0246527102,
0.0120636541,
-0.0504289754,
0.0110038444,
0.0027616024,
-0.0305551961,
0.0014478352,
0.0327592678,
-0.0197513159,
0.0351458602,
0.0046259128,
0.0121328486,
-0.0327161886,
-0.0362688079,
-0.0069368128,
-0.036121957,
0.0392392278,
-0.0141977426,
-0.0330702849,
-0.0034026776,
0.0204262417,
-0.0174883362,
0.0162867475,
-0.0120976614,
0.0001972191,
0.035359282,
-0.0046675312,
-0.0021816213,
0.0411709361,
-0.0300428327,
-0.0615065061,
-0.0416326635,
0.0660109669,
0.0107984962,
-0.006074091,
0.0353127234,
0.0183758624,
-0.0070073432,
0.0094522936,
0.0160852317,
0.0200599506,
-0.0187502056,
0.0708508193,
-0.0239068903,
0.0034429228,
-0.0198490229,
0.0868821591,
-0.0476008058,
-0.014354242,
-0.0364053957,
0.0158711411,
-0.0011081033,
0.0056806821,
0.0029478327,
-0.016095465,
0.032274399,
-0.0212244894,
0.0389861129,
0.005048465,
0.0211448669,
0.062423896,
0.0052506807,
-0.0041872878,
-0.0264304914,
0.1114271581,
0.0005883375,
0.0169327762,
-0.0135907363,
-0.0471661463,
-0.0476877578,
0.0273488481,
0.0411435254,
0.0320597775,
-0.0554385632,
0.0122052096,
-0.069942072,
-0.0368793495,
0.0784576237,
-0.0230692718,
-0.0176578257,
-0.0266656466,
0.0444104597,
0.0560423955,
0.0189135,
0.0021673595,
-0.0290654879,
0.0123878838,
0.0185648967,
-0.016507918,
-0.0075979186,
-5.936078964e-33,
-0.0209150184,
-0.02644822,
0.004780164,
-0.0427129455,
0.0422228724,
0.0549130626,
-0.0316572338,
0.0138271889,
0.0115071964,
0.001162266,
-0.0121920211,
0.0073960689,
0.0141945351,
0.0422792956,
0.0230289772,
-0.0469906777,
0.0352625623,
0.0053211455,
-0.023595456,
0.0238440521,
-0.0021853987,
0.0521427095,
0.0755020604,
-0.112720862,
0.0060650073,
-0.0008256726,
0.0227303524,
-0.0060653379,
0.0004403373,
0.0652490482,
-0.0432957448,
0.0576750226,
0.0623881519,
-0.0428094417,
-0.0216499157,
0.0391844735,
-0.0271246172,
-0.0131137017,
0.0160675887,
0.0140798101,
-0.0428249128,
-0.0223212149,
0.0553462468,
-0.0090203146,
-0.0141685363,
-0.0299376529,
0.0419837758,
-0.0214843713,
-0.0040859864,
-0.02975953,
-0.0348377302,
0.0415609218,
0.0049660453,
-0.0218497496,
0.0272203367,
0.0467436053,
-0.0050658239,
0.0169486683,
-0.0494442955,
-0.0079597905,
-0.0282145161,
0.0412666053,
0.0467610136,
-0.0015927203,
-0.0581899323,
0.0738905668,
0.0325233564,
-0.0195111595,
-0.06628526,
-0.011332971,
-0.0130200041,
0.0423721932,
0.0471867658,
0.0755145922,
0.0063752164,
-0.0173306223,
-0.0481624939,
0.0665062368,
-0.0423570424,
0.0201438982,
0.0721895993,
-0.0158148874,
-0.0570185557,
-0.0045927684,
-0.0021525526,
-0.0021425565,
-0.0262345839,
-0.0332168154,
0.0318957008,
0.0052691954,
0.0387388058,
0.0552145392,
0.062016625,
-0.0196325053,
-0.0047812792,
0.0150164934,
0.0276403185,
0.0402548909,
-0.0147486413,
0.0138349114,
-0.0230929982,
-0.0025927557,
0.050093215,
-0.0113846716,
0.0410664938,
0.0052690138,
0.0354022346,
0.0089994129,
-0.0563705973,
-0.0242073201,
0.0178848561,
-0.0425948687,
0.0106998375,
0.0355140157,
0.045813635,
0.0154615724,
-0.0273467936,
0.0395737328,
-0.0027135552,
0.0051421891,
-0.0172004178,
-0.0577876568,
0.0136471987,
0.0284659974,
-0.0433527417,
-0.0281268917,
-0.0684105754,
-0.0227786284,
0.029866064,
-0.0429975763,
-0.0104567204,
0.0286407247,
2.702e-7,
0.1135238856,
0.0356043838,
-0.0023526265,
-0.0714086294,
0.0354084261,
0.033339873,
0.0104158428,
0.0505438335,
0.0152876228,
-0.0147147132,
0.0199475978,
-0.0138773248,
0.0322884023,
0.0416865759,
-0.066787906,
-0.0157221109,
-0.0587762296,
0.026225999,
-0.0112081813,
-0.0076488703,
0.0767366216,
0.1384152323,
-0.0634742156,
-0.01855422,
0.0212363824,
0.0169514231,
0.0610867441,
-0.0645786971,
-0.0030621961,
0.0153810335,
0.0234628003,
0.0104255574,
0.004304071,
0.018962441,
-0.0168078169,
-0.0122757899,
0.0452573448,
0.0771156996,
-0.0609663017,
0.0153034832,
0.008497064,
0.0119165136,
-0.0099748783,
-0.0665808618,
0.0649902299,
-0.0504712313,
-0.0295819473,
-0.0164342504,
-0.0081411954,
0.0499973781,
0.0285374504,
-0.0160022434,
-0.0685104802,
0.04874615,
0.0241815262,
-0.0161719155,
-0.0336905234,
-0.056385152,
-0.0611176454,
0.0211270638,
-0.0284458101,
-0.0131955855,
-0.0081726378,
-0.0671819523,
0.058308851,
-0.0802873746,
-0.0052562905,
2.559554001e-34,
0.0226530731,
0.0295516439,
-0.0028054386,
0.0200077351,
0.0080443406,
-0.0495628528,
0.0238869209,
0.0163311828,
0.0092318961,
-0.0683168247,
-0.0339935683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00740v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00740v2 | Inspecting and Editing Knowledge Representations in Language Models | 2023-04-03T06:24:10 | 2023-05-22T14:53:20 | Evan Hernandez, Belinda Z. Li, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural language models (LMs) represent facts about the world described by
text. Sometimes these facts derive from training data (in most LMs, a
representation of the word "banana" encodes the fact that bananas are fruits).
Sometimes facts derive from input text itself (a representation of the sentence
"I poured out the bottle" encodes the fact that the bottle became empty). We
describe REMEDI, a method for learning to map statements in natural language to
fact encodings in an LM's internal representation system. REMEDI encodings can
be used as knowledge editors: when added to LM hidden representations, they
modify downstream generation to be consistent with new facts. REMEDI encodings
may also be used as probes: when compared to LM representations, they reveal
which properties LMs already attribute to mentioned entities, in some cases
making it possible to predict when LMs will generate outputs that conflict with
background knowledge or input text. REMEDI thus links work on probing,
prompting, and LM editing, and offers steps toward general tools for
fine-grained inspection and control of knowledge in LMs. | [
0.0423352569,
0.0165002178,
-0.04388199,
0.0546670929,
-0.0516481958,
-0.0008214657,
-0.0404614881,
-0.029747691,
0.031044241,
-0.0539081246,
-0.0263972413,
0.0008792579,
-0.0002966725,
0.0483783185,
0.0407478139,
-0.0243952591,
0.0811412558,
-0.0148284389,
0.0465414263,
0.0304304324,
-0.01140563,
0.0061559444,
0.0077260737,
0.0102324961,
-0.0250137504,
-0.0383580402,
-0.0415360965,
-0.0258389041,
-0.0042419708,
-0.0088470094,
-0.0090916567,
0.0384455137,
0.0101498831,
0.0097011076,
0.0000021568,
-0.0505454578,
-0.0140154082,
-0.0156275667,
-0.0528256632,
0.0178905614,
-0.0103326617,
-0.0425141975,
-0.0095940186,
-0.0105247721,
-0.0560452193,
-0.0156959444,
0.0349794701,
0.0524260737,
0.0553277917,
0.0796223134,
0.0069591301,
0.0225129817,
0.0061864899,
-0.0208486114,
0.0471981764,
0.007481046,
0.0536631979,
-0.0203998554,
-0.0318731777,
0.0475627668,
-0.0322561376,
0.0348339193,
0.0276253894,
-0.0371399671,
0.0066031669,
0.0242680721,
0.023865357,
-0.0102538001,
-0.009543607,
0.0262354035,
-0.0068351515,
-0.0151585126,
0.0001325591,
0.0135886213,
0.046185635,
-0.0044589187,
-0.0159669779,
0.016067367,
0.0146227367,
0.0016855672,
0.0342359915,
-0.0344303735,
0.0319622122,
0.0186155178,
-0.0127651431,
0.0649075583,
0.0057677664,
-0.0248188507,
-0.0375203602,
0.0076529183,
0.0178249273,
-0.0887645856,
-0.0066818935,
0.0720601156,
0.0088111935,
0.0362727791,
-0.0380478427,
0.0124173462,
0.024774069,
-0.0483500846,
0.0130218957,
0.0332553349,
-0.0475301407,
0.0557156168,
-0.0430144034,
0.0642407462,
-0.0036359157,
0.0782164037,
-0.011360188,
0.0059855413,
-0.0376704484,
-0.0423419327,
-0.0295672305,
0.0284255985,
-0.0059937607,
0.003903189,
0.0054430133,
0.0529428646,
-0.0297413357,
0.0355920345,
-0.0267312564,
0.0180953611,
0.005329099,
0.0070554977,
-0.0973646715,
0.0225346256,
-0.0244351141,
0.0163841788,
-0.0070195827,
-0.0409880318,
-0.0359571427,
-0.0165498964,
0.0016760171,
-0.0133692939,
-0.0143882008,
0.0867017135,
0.0035627913,
-0.0137260295,
-0.0755957365,
-0.0698240772,
-0.0057494836,
-0.0341030285,
0.0278246924,
-0.0361413136,
0.0402881093,
-0.0307193622,
-0.0252956245,
-0.0759190917,
0.0090461988,
0.0133103533,
-0.0412332974,
0.0733708888,
0.0047090561,
0.0113332458,
0.0202788133,
0.0281421132,
-0.0102988919,
0.0460846424,
0.0234156828,
0.0222628415,
0.00596378,
0.0023977498,
0.0228738785,
0.0004389917,
0.051942151,
-0.0147464722,
-0.0279490743,
0.0068233791,
0.0357506089,
0.0251557175,
0.0134669226,
0.057979919,
-0.0271139201,
-0.0233093146,
0.0738603249,
0.0219691377,
0.0305277184,
0.0076742843,
0.0505443141,
-0.0592878722,
0.0099427514,
0.035637442,
-0.0785190389,
0.0456902944,
-0.037303526,
-0.0117594386,
-0.0271452032,
0.0294721592,
-0.0108571239,
-0.049178198,
-0.0106836976,
0.0112148644,
0.0107891439,
-0.0103954766,
0.0262207687,
0.0500579886,
0.0071754651,
0.0519375242,
0.0172196347,
0.0101067796,
0.0355503336,
-0.0787919089,
0.03797438,
0.0766584799,
0.0522772595,
-0.0452213697,
-0.038659256,
0.0076019778,
-0.0563902892,
0.0537437387,
0.0529963449,
-0.0376308113,
0.0017346506,
-0.0121253757,
-0.0001801496,
-0.060803514,
0.0586382151,
-0.0020815122,
-0.016733015,
0.0058175437,
0.0152782239,
-0.032551825,
-0.0044859331,
0.052435331,
-0.0027258946,
-0.0344510339,
-0.0101124113,
0.0380473286,
-0.0245594662,
0.0023148472,
0.0177735295,
0.0260374751,
0.0304765459,
-0.0097253993,
-0.0210770015,
0.0074482067,
0.0173212178,
-0.0665393174,
0.0404717885,
-0.0219766796,
-0.0139581682,
0.0037585043,
-0.0368973278,
-0.0335332789,
0.0318747908,
-0.0291646551,
0.0450369939,
-0.0451447889,
0.0091280341,
-0.0161987413,
-0.0280434284,
0.0016067773,
0.0793736279,
-0.0156685933,
-0.0303064752,
0.0070615113,
-0.0410297588,
-0.0233798381,
-0.0077363402,
-0.0011532344,
-0.0051643215,
0.0058617932,
-0.0049329088,
-0.0151256211,
0.0087765893,
-0.0340093896,
-0.0106571373,
-0.0476037487,
0.003870385,
0.0165334679,
-0.0028863312,
0.0496703945,
0.0042039002,
0.0243704617,
-0.0195017532,
-0.0267009791,
-0.0031481348,
-0.0027944827,
0.0192649085,
0.0797693804,
0.0205023531,
0.0133458413,
-0.031939894,
0.0211974662,
-0.0423010886,
0.0598912723,
0.0032424945,
0.002059829,
-0.074339129,
-0.0073886677,
-0.0700957254,
0.0183937456,
0.0147000607,
-0.0426634401,
0.0127665149,
-0.0043730522,
0.0124189947,
0.0613871217,
-0.0072344784,
0.051028531,
0.1082093269,
-0.0154108349,
-0.055656448,
0.0160250608,
-0.000026157,
0.0251482893,
0.0131715275,
-0.0091632549,
0.0226882827,
0.0857167169,
0.0132851927,
-0.0360331945,
-0.0324196182,
0.0773412511,
0.0097249486,
-0.0329854228,
-0.0323092826,
-0.0369424894,
0.0026507257,
0.0411320962,
-0.0673507005,
-0.0529027171,
0.1129773036,
-0.0371310264,
0.035588827,
-0.0405310206,
-0.0182924289,
-0.0214384384,
0.0677527115,
-0.0134233478,
0.0089319916,
-0.001360359,
-0.0261997376,
-0.0531166904,
0.0216567367,
-0.0040029073,
-0.0371863507,
0.0274395328,
-0.0750902593,
-0.0179127306,
0.0193088669,
0.0124798687,
-0.0780794695,
-0.0146961706,
-0.0164586734,
0.0112537695,
-0.0069340188,
0.0108221387,
-0.021533804,
-0.0151978079,
0.0174248684,
0.042926129,
-0.0094972551,
-0.0097470703,
-0.028065538,
-0.0222167838,
0.0467966944,
0.0303193666,
0.0063613094,
0.009566959,
0.0070053344,
0.0390488394,
-0.0449688286,
-0.022376094,
-0.0225346051,
0.0185551476,
-0.0148733631,
-0.0522211976,
0.0209436826,
-0.0228728596,
0.0108694937,
-0.0771174282,
-0.0453263819,
0.1054637656,
0.0466154031,
-0.0368790701,
0.0252303649,
-0.0411677919,
-0.0181051474,
0.0298119038,
0.0516297519,
-0.0980970487,
-0.0024476212,
0.0055416944,
-0.0267165508,
-0.0355692245,
-0.024668891,
-0.0484841205,
-0.1186073944,
0.0102507398,
0.0065525924,
-0.0224604849,
-0.0650205836,
0.0082738549,
0.0244098082,
0.0285691209,
0.0153080784,
0.0060095661,
0.0208498407,
0.0110402815,
-0.013146461,
0.0239653848,
-0.0596405379,
-0.0130408294,
-0.0469853841,
0.0608317107,
0.0596514866,
-0.0040349336,
0.0309651308,
-0.0217787623,
0.0016502859,
0.0418223478,
0.0479973219,
-0.0170267578,
0.0516134575,
-0.0288652387,
-0.0251723714,
-0.0297657028,
0.0237560067,
-0.0109813502,
-0.0330828242,
0.0209540464,
0.1141833588,
-0.0441624187,
-0.0177485999,
-0.0084356423,
-0.0015903421,
0.0193100721,
0.0867556185,
0.0614713766,
-0.0042820387,
0.0133474562,
-0.0491570681,
-0.0170757901,
-0.0020607535,
-0.0417913571,
0.0281675514,
0.0118478741,
-0.0022107414,
-0.1218949035,
-0.0321143791,
0.0596390702,
0.0099225957,
0.0539747365,
-0.0247697923,
0.0485327095,
-0.059859775,
-0.0555191487,
-0.0099699302,
-0.0363399759,
-0.0203130487,
0.0198942926,
-0.0212988388,
0.0349526815,
-0.0391233303,
-0.0101528019,
-0.0212685689,
-0.0509647466,
-0.0794632733,
0.0086959852,
0.0804308206,
0.0320897214,
0.0551581532,
-0.0544376411,
-0.0327812508,
0.0349792838,
0.0364958942,
-0.062277481,
0.023607634,
-0.009685589,
-0.019757878,
-0.0010985698,
0.0479655564,
-0.0473888852,
-0.0068074847,
0.0238370094,
0.0056765852,
-0.0194874834,
-0.0367474742,
0.0549457408,
-0.0168062355,
0.035000708,
0.0532970652,
0.0030055167,
-0.0604477338,
-0.000568453,
-0.0319055989,
-0.0371428244,
-0.0183089618,
0.0197332948,
0.0141195636,
0.0154444426,
-0.0191990118,
-0.0317543074,
-0.0065319058,
0.0346474499,
-0.0094931349,
-0.0404007435,
0.047075849,
0.0240212064,
-0.0342872292,
0.021161953,
-0.0088524204,
0.0582038872,
-0.050546106,
0.0253556222,
-0.0274371263,
0.0152799524,
0.0238991659,
-0.0059433249,
-0.060354393,
-0.0058908002,
-0.0476575568,
-0.0454273261,
-0.0001104566,
0.042012509,
0.0275936034,
-0.0073564644,
0.0033673397,
-0.0434649177,
0.0036065951,
0.0266397428,
0.0318584852,
0.0020013577,
-0.0265778732,
0.0282928329,
0.018312877,
-0.016652517,
-0.0386290476,
0.0635467917,
-0.035589844,
0.1086696535,
-0.0164275914,
-0.0236053485,
-0.0404016227,
-0.0175650138,
-0.0145750223,
0.0023354695,
-0.041148141,
0.0133373933,
-0.0484728627,
-0.0613033511,
-0.0015424401,
0.0611027442,
0.0064167138,
-0.0045228931,
-0.0092560425,
0.0149986809,
0.0421771966,
-0.0365924947,
0.0005550268,
0.0314924195,
-0.0329540409,
-0.0087513784,
-0.0181112383,
-6.628560482e-33,
-0.0644221753,
-0.0363623537,
0.0242662597,
-0.0176277123,
-0.026165437,
-0.0040130215,
-0.0336246043,
-0.0187784042,
-0.0181580763,
0.0298685525,
0.0127657661,
0.0364810564,
-0.0004414686,
-0.0147531424,
0.0302244723,
-0.0417699926,
0.0608327761,
0.0024805092,
-0.0350742675,
-0.0120303407,
0.0379849784,
0.0297484677,
0.0675462708,
-0.032376118,
0.0331788398,
0.0139493532,
-0.01412741,
0.0662468672,
-0.0687835589,
0.0504919626,
-0.0272488724,
-0.009510546,
0.0309709497,
-0.034021765,
-0.0206499733,
0.0130413752,
-0.0703620687,
-0.0752597675,
0.0471931584,
0.0211170539,
-0.0519424267,
-0.0579418875,
0.0474438444,
-0.0153103778,
0.027655527,
0.016449105,
0.0165011045,
-0.0257964656,
0.0086674104,
0.0124029983,
-0.0615254976,
-0.0161585938,
-0.0003428283,
-0.0407419503,
-0.0084911669,
0.0008257792,
0.0145120397,
-0.0388650931,
-0.0754797757,
0.0102389334,
0.0251294412,
0.0197662245,
0.0502403639,
0.0142203374,
-0.0038055482,
0.0763069391,
-0.0018126571,
0.0089967772,
-0.055737514,
0.0190330818,
0.0522739403,
0.0281539354,
0.00611838,
0.0403325446,
0.0390313007,
0.0020829316,
-0.0433678403,
0.0035068202,
-0.0145068532,
0.0340460055,
-0.0002705354,
0.0033432825,
0.0228874013,
-0.0114506809,
-0.0524674132,
-0.0057406109,
-0.0513140447,
-0.0319256894,
0.0194994155,
0.0185855702,
-0.0360401087,
-0.0261796732,
-0.0140454136,
-0.0228396561,
0.0293516889,
0.032692451,
-0.0099097183,
0.0186518244,
0.0012356633,
-0.0049255136,
-0.0246891901,
-0.0108023481,
0.0444881208,
0.0055813449,
0.0213693511,
0.0526709892,
0.0402617157,
0.0309140962,
-0.0176759288,
0.005252935,
-0.0491767377,
0.0153109897,
-0.0126230763,
-0.0121679967,
0.0243212134,
0.0273677427,
-0.0300041698,
-0.0201763399,
0.0394595638,
0.0200755689,
-0.0383157581,
0.0541183837,
0.0113345496,
0.0160537101,
-0.0368205942,
-0.0238663293,
-0.0262154322,
0.0048876731,
0.0151506495,
-0.0352188721,
0.0221622232,
0.0199323222,
2.961e-7,
0.0355735868,
0.0388927944,
0.0420620628,
0.0529596843,
0.0198964812,
0.0167587474,
-0.0210760478,
0.036394868,
0.009977987,
-0.0752246901,
0.0107642412,
0.0279588401,
0.0044695116,
0.0255070832,
-0.0517968386,
-0.0001549152,
-0.0244846102,
-0.0218768585,
-0.0292307194,
-0.0253577866,
0.0413947552,
0.054712113,
0.0615286455,
0.0037325092,
-0.0173342414,
-0.0410811342,
0.0641262382,
-0.0032708705,
0.0081070792,
-0.0193275269,
0.053767316,
0.0536517538,
0.0020186703,
0.0251227655,
-0.0127904555,
0.0195346717,
-0.0563048162,
0.0518260561,
-0.0128152305,
-0.0242022015,
-0.0480672047,
0.0202423353,
0.0047154264,
-0.0419953987,
0.0570065305,
-0.0531161726,
-0.0136122713,
-0.0343108736,
0.0522277877,
-0.0133852512,
-0.0036167491,
-0.0234796368,
-0.03081562,
0.0171017554,
0.003151387,
0.0255446211,
-0.0146787995,
-0.0650718883,
-0.0431556478,
0.0028459977,
-0.0246133972,
-0.0224448498,
-0.0352393351,
-0.0235538706,
0.0376375541,
-0.0853603333,
0.0047111968,
2.625913871e-34,
-0.0066615255,
-0.0108407233,
0.0140295029,
0.0597248375,
0.0476777181,
0.0014096387,
-0.0185469761,
0.0264604576,
0.0357115082,
-0.0771822855,
-0.0355641507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00723v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00723v3 | Exploring the Use of Large Language Models for Reference-Free Text Quality Evaluation: An Empirical Study | 2023-04-03T05:29:58 | 2023-09-18T03:52:18 | Yi Chen, Rui Wang, Haiyun Jiang, Shuming Shi, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating the quality of generated text is a challenging task in NLP, due to
the inherent complexity and diversity of text. Recently, large language models
(LLMs) have garnered significant attention due to their impressive performance
in various tasks. Therefore, we present this paper to investigate the
effectiveness of LLMs, especially ChatGPT, and explore ways to optimize their
use in assessing text quality. We compared three kinds of reference-free
evaluation methods. The experimental results prove that ChatGPT is capable of
evaluating text quality effectively from various perspectives without reference
and demonstrates superior performance than most existing automatic metrics. In
particular, the Explicit Score, which utilizes ChatGPT to generate a numeric
score measuring text quality, is the most effective and reliable method among
the three exploited approaches. However, directly comparing the quality of two
texts may lead to suboptimal results. We believe this paper will provide
valuable insights for evaluating text quality with LLMs and have released the
used data. | [
0.0458515249,
0.0484331287,
0.0144598689,
0.0205004364,
-0.0684206858,
-0.0064507113,
0.0209577959,
0.0613332652,
0.0035853682,
-0.0505891554,
-0.0073446967,
-0.0612409264,
0.0400582254,
0.0043999855,
0.0110420808,
-0.0201590993,
0.0062312772,
0.0124586225,
0.0372693613,
0.0241596829,
0.0569718666,
-0.0115337735,
0.0471346453,
0.0348402448,
-0.0294748954,
-0.0383837521,
0.0483861491,
0.0276005603,
0.0034290568,
-0.0027875907,
0.0079152901,
0.03457449,
-0.0728452504,
0.0236024708,
0.0000017957,
-0.0163049959,
-0.0339792743,
0.0345461555,
0.0466981791,
0.0529014394,
0.0895001441,
0.0227243379,
-0.0479351357,
0.0387321673,
-0.0178409107,
0.0074113728,
0.014551159,
0.0786762983,
0.0957713351,
0.0675260201,
-0.0167901479,
0.0066823605,
0.0212508515,
0.0079666143,
-0.0230831262,
-0.0072280057,
0.0235888846,
0.0608778745,
-0.0220724083,
0.0377759039,
0.0332379267,
0.0377509482,
-0.0059153549,
-0.0668267533,
0.0313269496,
-0.0010937231,
-0.0494356379,
-0.0273412708,
0.0345068946,
0.0294631459,
-0.0346169658,
-0.0309083238,
0.0281796772,
-0.0093285572,
-0.0021756582,
0.0087940106,
-0.0212057121,
0.0204396527,
0.0035461024,
0.0297641698,
0.0060895174,
0.0132345473,
0.0178966634,
0.0182334445,
0.0323085673,
0.0151234753,
0.0180655662,
-0.0500486009,
-0.0124276131,
-0.0005968141,
-0.0195368975,
-0.0426946878,
0.0149983848,
-0.0038462661,
-0.0065353611,
0.0003412176,
-0.0443134084,
-0.0157951154,
0.036604736,
-0.0808123648,
0.0272349715,
0.0087887971,
0.0103297029,
0.021979969,
-0.0440759808,
0.0401752777,
0.0288731344,
-0.004316044,
-0.0302729234,
-0.0150511246,
-0.0436243676,
0.014334539,
-0.0196709242,
0.0327244997,
-0.0326498635,
-0.0390544273,
-0.0386212878,
-0.0012537251,
0.0114842933,
-0.0007267272,
0.0361564644,
-0.0101799294,
0.0093463762,
-0.006951293,
-0.0145594291,
-0.0012580703,
0.0004659889,
-0.0029739558,
-0.0108902501,
-0.0216371939,
0.0209158063,
0.0515355021,
0.0067610941,
0.0067667947,
-0.009811894,
0.0519217961,
0.0241761114,
-0.0160823166,
-0.0273015667,
-0.0212524943,
-0.0394263603,
-0.0301993825,
-0.0202516541,
-0.0719190836,
-0.0233098976,
0.005385811,
0.0209404621,
-0.0290826503,
0.0018834647,
0.0352310501,
-0.0301944483,
-0.0152371144,
-0.0405209213,
0.0475651473,
0.0044964915,
-0.0169548187,
0.0038561318,
0.0245198496,
0.0570881814,
0.0147867687,
0.0504624546,
0.0158184879,
0.0293110479,
0.0358183868,
-0.0104862629,
0.0417968966,
0.0013980292,
-0.0203569122,
0.0057778531,
0.0148899052,
-0.0018491028,
0.1223243102,
-0.0277419183,
0.0112356739,
0.0970373675,
0.0015287107,
0.0632932559,
0.021780191,
0.0413832925,
0.0358118638,
0.0344744064,
0.0082083009,
0.0041738902,
-0.0088624479,
-0.0097030727,
0.0158837903,
0.118849352,
0.0295532234,
0.029619582,
-0.0836348757,
-0.0452093668,
0.0048364983,
0.0096972268,
-0.0756440237,
-0.003282588,
-0.0075819055,
-0.0584214777,
-0.0141042685,
0.014847694,
-0.0609369501,
0.037345577,
-0.0369057097,
0.0500133336,
0.0690986887,
0.0613606311,
0.0135555277,
0.0344248004,
-0.0225762483,
-0.002286633,
0.0518305898,
0.0120307105,
-0.0064395331,
-0.0210555978,
-0.0635462403,
-0.0149205802,
0.0172009952,
0.0246339478,
-0.0336731672,
-0.0094533572,
-0.0069930865,
0.0470423773,
-0.0259942021,
-0.114006348,
0.0318482965,
0.0125032002,
0.0088589862,
0.0381316356,
-0.0128516955,
0.0327326767,
0.0306403954,
-0.0557053797,
0.0278118644,
-0.0101482514,
-0.0296625867,
-0.0404805988,
-0.0285899453,
-0.0206769295,
-0.0120454496,
0.0354005173,
-0.0531837866,
0.0125723789,
0.0044353558,
-0.0014434024,
-0.0340063088,
-0.0255598947,
-0.0836063921,
0.0094382642,
-0.061213512,
0.0299829617,
-0.003725487,
-0.0226036403,
-0.0346017443,
0.043642167,
0.0249117743,
0.0418112427,
0.0112687591,
-0.0064060744,
0.0657601953,
0.0026193899,
-0.0407740399,
-0.0094078109,
-0.0131176757,
0.0564591698,
0.0754529908,
0.045237951,
-0.0327778421,
-0.0707438067,
-0.0584373251,
0.0307473652,
-0.0148447622,
0.0093003623,
0.0176081993,
-0.0188177023,
-0.0003417414,
0.0444553681,
-0.0462546907,
-0.04729468,
0.024201775,
0.0063653896,
0.0482516475,
-0.0205317494,
0.0264272131,
-0.031776309,
-0.0038508235,
0.0223266874,
0.0628263578,
0.0252065342,
-0.0035300129,
-0.0617481954,
0.0681641251,
-0.0375471748,
-0.0472913794,
0.0585735515,
-0.0734740496,
-0.0215600412,
-0.0183534138,
0.0579161718,
0.0288894381,
0.0146753304,
-0.0349143967,
0.0300329998,
-0.0119587798,
-0.0383758396,
-0.0288424734,
-0.0443793423,
0.0187135898,
0.0206141826,
-0.0469506532,
0.0325518996,
0.0157214981,
0.0109585291,
-0.0133593231,
-0.0764565244,
0.0593046695,
-0.063370049,
0.0314567648,
0.0100702383,
0.0073751286,
-0.0100928061,
0.0178052634,
-0.006817942,
-0.050347399,
0.0273568574,
-0.0496898144,
0.0310282297,
-0.0441290587,
0.0085359048,
-0.0510132499,
-0.0206626095,
-0.0235551875,
0.0404570773,
0.0151618812,
-0.0036687965,
-0.0191684924,
0.0039272071,
0.0594664514,
-0.0325585902,
0.0202266518,
-0.0290739611,
0.0117727695,
0.0106713977,
0.016818082,
-0.0006514072,
-0.0182272121,
0.0134024126,
-0.0036281156,
0.0488157123,
0.0028112764,
0.0046642227,
0.0368275382,
0.0086795641,
-0.006491411,
-0.0407377072,
-0.0110785933,
0.0147986906,
0.0470655262,
0.0097470926,
-0.0383311883,
0.0408359841,
-0.0204918124,
-0.0019729282,
0.0401023924,
-0.0273210984,
0.0480220281,
-0.0019647349,
-0.0404881127,
-0.0032021008,
-0.0035390644,
-0.07191661,
-0.0033904887,
0.0545217842,
-0.0490548015,
-0.0323339477,
0.1080313101,
0.0333508216,
-0.0035262732,
-0.0220580548,
-0.0040092664,
0.0237596296,
-0.0205969121,
-0.0082146171,
-0.0278007481,
-0.0124364756,
0.0187222362,
0.0053930013,
-0.0336613022,
-0.0038695519,
0.0011018231,
-0.1003341973,
0.0032516115,
0.0407760516,
-0.0174609758,
-0.0216180198,
-0.042024862,
0.0123633435,
-0.029439494,
0.0008596656,
-0.0011729161,
-0.0034735834,
0.027967317,
0.0146473795,
-0.0792053938,
-0.0562386066,
-0.0272401012,
-0.0386463031,
0.0702881664,
0.0670547411,
0.0628081784,
0.0042326376,
-0.0256445147,
0.0309021808,
-0.0581467636,
-0.0423930176,
-0.0102628954,
0.034672875,
0.002316063,
0.0096168052,
-0.0179975312,
-0.0220463555,
0.0247514863,
0.0023881334,
-0.0111630764,
0.0291418787,
0.0116306525,
-0.0162621047,
-0.0207189247,
0.0218784995,
-0.0025881052,
0.0841291249,
0.0268734209,
-0.0450751781,
-0.0311894771,
-0.038574975,
-0.0265347436,
-0.0413797759,
-0.0329782628,
0.0341367945,
-0.0444545709,
-0.034676142,
-0.1192292795,
-0.037501663,
-0.0106110843,
-0.0206437688,
0.0096402112,
-0.002330767,
-0.0092226686,
-0.0165876932,
0.0345193371,
-0.0228755493,
-0.0270138234,
0.0122118397,
-0.0755848885,
0.0254784357,
0.0082401754,
-0.002689919,
-0.0065465118,
-0.0150287859,
-0.0382888354,
-0.0462606996,
-0.0250908844,
0.0262594186,
0.011523176,
-0.0237219483,
-0.0415538922,
-0.0492950641,
0.0297859218,
0.0459588543,
-0.0328163654,
0.0119590443,
0.0209844746,
0.0098927394,
0.0207207762,
0.026330309,
-0.0533293188,
0.0273711607,
-0.0064053573,
0.0411234796,
0.0161377657,
-0.0221266374,
0.0124527961,
0.0534832925,
-0.0034343412,
-0.0099483486,
0.0081432229,
-0.0091476366,
-0.0400762297,
-0.0363947637,
-0.0314828046,
-0.0420411602,
0.0485801212,
0.0190775841,
0.0265538245,
-0.062050391,
0.0349751227,
-0.0441949666,
0.0428446904,
0.0104569225,
0.0124648707,
-0.0242683105,
-0.0191435851,
-0.0174131691,
-0.0191608537,
-0.0185246356,
-0.0343200266,
-0.0218580049,
-0.0199202541,
-0.0107608549,
-0.0035579174,
0.0392563678,
0.00725275,
0.0363028161,
0.0602717586,
-0.0424314514,
0.0077470662,
-0.0686644465,
0.011622862,
0.0505546555,
0.0030224745,
0.0938984528,
-0.0204534046,
-0.0215067808,
-0.0439850911,
0.0494881235,
0.0738152266,
-0.0013577662,
-0.0317155905,
-0.0108441617,
-0.0466179587,
-0.0124856671,
0.060270194,
-0.0044075912,
-0.0192916393,
0.0067986706,
-0.0361198522,
-0.0416696183,
0.0237304308,
-0.0108465645,
-0.0155345025,
-0.0089711901,
-0.0066923141,
-0.0583581477,
-0.0206439029,
0.0264981966,
0.0363939442,
0.0364509746,
-0.0014175915,
-0.0111552458,
0.0414980799,
0.0048931511,
0.0502720401,
-0.0707021207,
-0.0698920637,
-0.0069359001,
-0.0091740433,
-0.0189739745,
-5.617857949e-33,
-0.0066427561,
-0.0496086515,
-0.0503333099,
-0.0175914839,
-0.0321206897,
0.0137871876,
-0.0360542089,
-0.0300888643,
0.0149545316,
0.0249102805,
0.0099364379,
-0.0000051706,
0.0025577124,
0.0014083127,
-0.0148228295,
0.0122619839,
0.0348670594,
0.0143387886,
-0.0546672419,
0.0092386724,
0.0193532035,
-0.016838558,
0.0095735341,
-0.0545206852,
0.0225919634,
-0.0147045553,
-0.0487368777,
-0.0157290176,
0.0427845418,
0.077082552,
-0.0019635439,
0.0472116098,
0.0296866708,
-0.0325368904,
-0.0161782689,
-0.0056363628,
-0.0223479532,
-0.0055047395,
0.0018000308,
-0.0509688295,
-0.0138067976,
-0.0393103734,
0.0317546353,
0.0006650214,
-0.0284140389,
-0.0174552836,
0.0568951443,
-0.0553844348,
-0.0336673185,
-0.0617358014,
-0.0291425958,
0.0582202636,
-0.0001061615,
-0.0155284628,
0.0093160393,
-0.0007006976,
-0.0334250256,
0.0329162031,
-0.0064179557,
0.0331957042,
0.0106444918,
0.0532498546,
-0.0142814768,
-0.032282766,
-0.0133384541,
0.0277059413,
-0.0369372703,
0.0092966538,
0.0174782928,
-0.0352593735,
0.0071708746,
-0.0039271102,
0.084906362,
0.0855400488,
0.0262578689,
-0.036305245,
-0.0558423363,
0.0679182187,
-0.028622441,
0.0187959839,
0.0050796107,
-0.0056329528,
-0.0023860065,
-0.0032139758,
-0.0584715381,
-0.021925956,
-0.0227755811,
-0.0343207344,
0.0227571558,
0.0076205954,
-0.0371328592,
-0.0245512407,
0.015985094,
-0.0458318964,
-0.0117976703,
0.0133924624,
-0.0642669722,
0.0171851665,
-0.0217398908,
0.0143829305,
-0.0413631164,
0.0047227377,
0.0147403553,
0.0314979851,
-0.001660266,
-0.034637522,
0.0485287458,
-0.0016503081,
-0.0969301909,
0.0389802977,
-0.0062537864,
0.0143426219,
-0.0038339396,
-0.0095425602,
-0.0074279648,
-0.0465187952,
-0.0106538618,
0.0538858809,
0.0126295788,
0.0354112387,
-0.0019674727,
-0.0283737704,
0.0314196385,
-0.0134218466,
-0.0359185673,
0.0165534206,
-0.0289670862,
0.017462844,
0.0320713408,
-0.0248049889,
-0.0229772571,
-0.0360392965,
2.462e-7,
0.0375626609,
0.0865262896,
0.0143474815,
0.0193767697,
-0.0133007187,
0.0326220281,
-0.0187593531,
0.0190884583,
-0.0228618085,
0.0412923247,
-0.0144320354,
-0.0390244834,
0.0781719014,
0.0135987587,
-0.07994847,
0.0120522697,
-0.0891866684,
-0.0296707358,
-0.0157592166,
0.0035148177,
0.0772006735,
0.0825846419,
-0.0080984067,
0.0247189477,
0.0072327792,
-0.0530076995,
0.0765661523,
-0.0187426303,
-0.0567424223,
0.034492176,
0.1058750972,
-0.0211213697,
0.0134554915,
-0.0207788814,
-0.0333565474,
-0.01984144,
0.0580048822,
0.0801511481,
0.0201481767,
0.0086943954,
0.0154085774,
-0.0353445485,
0.0156298894,
-0.0319694243,
0.0805797949,
0.0026479512,
-0.0142962513,
-0.011614034,
-0.0583565049,
-0.0149453068,
0.0461143851,
-0.0158164632,
-0.0564814955,
0.0164211523,
-0.0058494196,
0.0385226756,
-0.0003831069,
-0.0256252717,
-0.040651653,
-0.0337157249,
0.0318254344,
-0.0506595373,
0.0185101088,
0.0144059854,
0.0338174105,
-0.0800169408,
0.020173464,
2.270644811e-34,
0.0888527259,
-0.073405467,
0.0290146992,
-0.002048519,
0.0358249322,
0.009191433,
0.020459801,
-0.0058428701,
-0.0192369577,
-0.0384902731,
0.0491727442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00717v1 | MiniRBT: A Two-stage Distilled Small Chinese Pre-trained Model | 2023-04-03T04:45:57 | 2023-04-03T04:45:57 | Xin Yao, Ziqing Yang, Yiming Cui, Shijin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In natural language processing, pre-trained language models have become
essential infrastructures. However, these models often suffer from issues such
as large size, long inference time, and challenging deployment. Moreover, most
mainstream pre-trained models focus on English, and there are insufficient
studies on small Chinese pre-trained models. In this paper, we introduce
MiniRBT, a small Chinese pre-trained model that aims to advance research in
Chinese natural language processing. MiniRBT employs a narrow and deep student
model and incorporates whole word masking and two-stage distillation during
pre-training to make it well-suited for most downstream tasks. Our experiments
on machine reading comprehension and text classification tasks reveal that
MiniRBT achieves 94% performance relative to RoBERTa, while providing a 6.8x
speedup, demonstrating its effectiveness and efficiency. | [
0.0428218879,
0.0473801419,
0.0076096868,
0.0471961685,
0.0008399505,
0.0054107062,
0.0483785868,
0.0091664921,
0.0099165263,
-0.0248100124,
-0.0436451957,
-0.0602016561,
-0.0366591476,
0.0426732488,
-0.013853183,
-0.0523526184,
0.0616085008,
0.0080064889,
-0.0104877483,
0.0015811812,
0.0320633501,
-0.0100736218,
0.0304606315,
0.0122543667,
0.0390066877,
-0.026285531,
-0.019823391,
0.0091680894,
0.0155613255,
-0.0344277136,
0.0596216246,
0.0427982323,
0.0062341653,
0.0352792367,
0.0000021928,
-0.0196605101,
-0.0341435857,
-0.0002502407,
-0.056239944,
0.0722704753,
0.0449078418,
0.0239805542,
-0.0107274149,
0.0156441294,
-0.0436572209,
-0.0655608252,
0.033331167,
0.079888083,
0.0634290949,
0.0704738796,
-0.0173729304,
-0.0388183892,
-0.0048484579,
-0.0484784134,
-0.0067488528,
-0.0487680398,
0.0104624238,
0.0072033256,
-0.0257660989,
-0.003426546,
-0.0261864047,
0.0021248343,
0.0343160704,
0.0556856468,
-0.0210640822,
0.035963878,
-0.0106713185,
-0.0226263553,
-0.0070827492,
0.1011462361,
-0.082862325,
-0.0273747258,
-0.0183410849,
-0.0249820445,
-0.0254386123,
-0.0331360102,
-0.0006127576,
-0.0102805868,
0.0118824979,
0.0216830261,
-0.0028240618,
-0.0010025994,
0.0420804583,
0.0462243445,
-0.0543746278,
0.0223496854,
-0.0096886568,
-0.0295012332,
-0.0196507387,
-0.0100064036,
-0.0039454871,
-0.0511787795,
0.03253223,
0.01967589,
0.0311779641,
0.0022385637,
-0.0515921675,
-0.0305488463,
-0.0130002536,
-0.006393061,
0.0053275838,
0.0346496515,
-0.0455281436,
0.045783069,
-0.0490900651,
-0.0005165868,
-0.016939342,
0.0338175595,
-0.0361627601,
-0.0055975635,
0.0175987091,
-0.0177061241,
-0.0734471455,
0.0396641567,
-0.0693900511,
-0.0518967323,
-0.0116074244,
-0.0183005482,
-0.0037958664,
-0.0449184105,
0.0130318468,
0.0078004301,
-0.0445124432,
-0.01832987,
-0.0162884966,
0.0202430133,
-0.0319601744,
0.0435289852,
-0.0253153499,
-0.0503254756,
-0.0321827568,
0.0023234796,
0.0371486843,
-0.0382956937,
0.0411768705,
0.012666625,
-0.0145499678,
-0.0610793009,
-0.0436223522,
0.0132219009,
-0.000309518,
-0.0554822125,
0.0178135931,
-0.0357855633,
-0.0036111835,
-0.0243864339,
0.061797902,
-0.0305553842,
0.0097486768,
0.0054281685,
0.0121871298,
0.0928910002,
-0.0175104048,
-0.0347424895,
-0.051297918,
0.0346491225,
0.0212470554,
0.0495224074,
0.0315094702,
0.044750534,
0.0419386998,
-0.0172847193,
-0.0401020832,
0.0230371151,
0.0292969942,
-0.0291184299,
-0.0017646922,
-0.0001626925,
-0.0207316875,
-0.0291554537,
0.0312919803,
0.0161508378,
-0.0356120355,
0.0002087633,
0.0585094281,
0.0253567137,
0.0115800938,
0.0520544164,
0.0251633078,
0.0380528197,
-0.0038943386,
0.0081752064,
-0.0200895816,
0.0064020236,
-0.0364583582,
-0.0028422929,
0.0184198152,
0.034238901,
-0.0533178821,
-0.0582615361,
0.0090155452,
0.0106761791,
0.0178895183,
0.0280183814,
0.0106981844,
0.0127029419,
-0.0367813036,
0.0200596862,
0.0253723152,
-0.0391856246,
0.0149007784,
-0.0406080075,
0.0193581879,
0.0438952111,
0.0275797453,
-0.0430364721,
0.0282979831,
0.0142098553,
0.0023238678,
0.0191272609,
0.070242852,
0.0038556342,
0.0154847382,
-0.050724104,
-0.0101472326,
-0.0049192025,
0.005507004,
0.005769413,
0.0289670583,
0.0321960188,
0.0252265204,
-0.0205349084,
-0.0338918678,
0.0337363668,
-0.0550888218,
-0.060645815,
0.0074155419,
0.0240235459,
0.0268767122,
-0.0163714867,
-0.059674155,
0.0020526638,
0.0168828852,
-0.0222019143,
-0.0116415787,
-0.0175286476,
-0.0291012414,
-0.0901352912,
0.0354291759,
-0.0132119497,
0.0238398891,
0.0995481685,
-0.0598156117,
-0.0424429402,
-0.0192581937,
0.0390467532,
0.0122996522,
-0.0736885071,
0.0294336528,
0.0168682411,
0.0572370626,
-0.0112699922,
0.0224049706,
-0.0007509267,
0.0228251126,
0.000120096,
-0.0113635547,
0.0149615696,
0.0290737916,
-0.0789291784,
-0.021551244,
0.0027945747,
0.0150714768,
0.0060179345,
0.0226268619,
-0.0144969933,
0.0107562216,
-0.0375904366,
0.0504479781,
-0.0446483828,
-0.0203970149,
0.0194428042,
0.0278812665,
-0.013007232,
-0.0298318639,
-0.0210321732,
0.0038038904,
-0.0402609222,
-0.001809934,
0.0059954757,
-0.0296486523,
0.0213317461,
-0.0244437773,
-0.023624137,
0.0165472608,
0.003260996,
-0.0175237376,
-0.0423124023,
-0.0139279971,
0.0315198898,
0.0280515496,
0.0527290143,
-0.0097052772,
-0.0649935976,
-0.0371481292,
-0.0208444875,
0.0443864428,
0.0549037233,
-0.0272632018,
0.0233153645,
0.0391334556,
0.0344871469,
-0.0084106196,
0.041426409,
-0.0068051089,
0.007619244,
-0.0228489842,
-0.0274391733,
-0.0390489027,
0.0791764259,
-0.0036112692,
-0.031141201,
-0.028850738,
-0.0054875757,
-0.0239299871,
-0.0132253263,
-0.0419537574,
0.0214590114,
-0.0311855283,
0.0086464621,
-0.0571133941,
-0.0035930055,
0.0410950333,
-0.0316787213,
-0.005574442,
-0.0699021891,
-0.0111843068,
-0.016115848,
0.043305818,
0.0336469375,
0.0107993949,
-0.0140093602,
-0.0085798912,
-0.0558061227,
0.0249487367,
-0.0096149659,
-0.0201181825,
-0.0094238203,
0.0126669556,
0.0071343505,
-0.0486802571,
-0.0017559291,
-0.0383750908,
-0.0759315863,
-0.0470296331,
0.0328531638,
0.0640378892,
-0.0005088181,
-0.0001457618,
0.0522937514,
0.004128187,
0.1014285907,
-0.006716039,
0.0356502086,
-0.034719307,
0.0265334193,
0.0297519397,
0.005264136,
0.0409739688,
-0.0360495374,
0.0764632374,
0.0624557473,
0.0387801118,
-0.0116392896,
0.0007026134,
-0.0001563792,
0.0280563403,
-0.0235115476,
-0.0017612735,
0.0040403213,
0.0687280521,
-0.0791190192,
-0.0118840542,
0.1014635563,
0.0136324046,
-0.0052359127,
-0.0018494622,
0.0375547186,
0.0170289986,
0.0169521552,
-0.0357432477,
-0.094815731,
-0.0509620905,
0.0150645385,
-0.008886775,
0.0250250734,
0.0009374499,
-0.0225097276,
-0.0978246257,
0.0354851708,
0.0022597059,
-0.0340576209,
-0.0052866419,
-0.0137754232,
-0.0110527268,
0.0023673705,
0.0180661641,
-0.0010745887,
-0.011659326,
-0.0179680865,
0.0097137345,
-0.0437363572,
-0.0369666405,
0.027579274,
-0.0327948704,
-0.0100337612,
0.0191275384,
0.0057243435,
-0.0050524711,
-0.0104282759,
0.0393382199,
-0.0422997437,
0.0014887888,
-0.0017778543,
0.0799794048,
-0.016400313,
-0.0289628636,
0.0027308671,
0.0231473781,
-0.0143855177,
-0.0094893882,
-0.0066263163,
0.015911771,
0.0159646589,
-0.0251410399,
-0.0226481054,
0.0107309166,
-0.0130890142,
0.0991861746,
0.0309692975,
-0.0521233231,
-0.0602811649,
0.0251497291,
-0.0270582736,
-0.096444793,
-0.0402685776,
0.0479150303,
-0.0450632572,
-0.0244433228,
-0.0461161658,
-0.0561887287,
0.0324518569,
0.0077694883,
-0.0207492355,
0.0034277462,
0.0345893577,
0.0239919648,
-0.0732987523,
0.0393730737,
-0.010784924,
0.0209745299,
-0.0459429286,
-0.0116728228,
0.0227377005,
-0.0362322442,
-0.0147689963,
0.0036928277,
-0.0952670202,
-0.0311750639,
0.0185855981,
0.0342316628,
0.0065938886,
0.0215603244,
-0.0195593219,
-0.0354800895,
0.0580164604,
-0.0207367558,
-0.0149784619,
-0.0205959678,
0.049910605,
-0.0774933249,
-0.000108941,
0.0012882403,
-0.0080725821,
0.0584022067,
0.0457003079,
0.0274841003,
-0.0319133736,
0.0290525015,
0.0289191119,
0.0142053412,
0.06259951,
0.0158488564,
0.0227424111,
-0.0662038475,
0.062933594,
-0.0108925784,
-0.0209292453,
-0.0317392498,
-0.0277540311,
0.0605875626,
0.008628062,
-0.0383221433,
0.0484454222,
0.0001420484,
-0.0062040351,
-0.0137964357,
-0.0084073739,
-0.0025867887,
0.0241875648,
0.0260675214,
-0.0002611146,
-0.0217645094,
0.0036118878,
0.0133472383,
0.0031779206,
0.0030489734,
0.0304522142,
0.0161803439,
0.0209454689,
-0.0354170017,
0.0298686512,
-0.0575791076,
-0.0410690866,
-0.0299133137,
0.0169749111,
0.050728824,
-0.0266871992,
0.0081124473,
-0.0189224761,
-0.0255561303,
-0.0285246763,
0.0015928159,
-0.0147476327,
-0.0134142032,
-0.0020273498,
0.0073057553,
-0.021142887,
-0.0211020671,
0.0934865624,
0.0366621763,
0.0600149222,
0.0381478667,
0.0147657013,
-0.0380573273,
0.0049001407,
0.0283179265,
0.0742265806,
-0.0225513186,
0.0459452868,
-0.0421505943,
-0.0750474855,
-0.0286733396,
-0.0125760809,
-0.0221121106,
-0.0063255252,
-0.0010505045,
0.0316219293,
0.001469645,
-0.0331604928,
-0.0402109623,
0.013503748,
0.0282129571,
-0.004739352,
0.0304368418,
-7.16678555e-33,
-0.0119206598,
0.0105848201,
0.013140453,
-0.0242283661,
0.0062357159,
0.0245365575,
-0.0131883435,
-0.0193683617,
-0.066829659,
0.0114233587,
-0.0383725129,
0.0404858254,
0.034920305,
0.0509130582,
-0.0575767942,
0.0201392882,
0.0909243524,
0.0073253922,
0.0241543185,
0.0039651226,
0.0156345051,
0.0705706924,
0.0423128195,
-0.0298334751,
-0.0170891471,
-0.0146988714,
-0.0152234705,
0.0011369993,
-0.0047117705,
0.0201645792,
-0.0417977087,
0.0471756831,
0.0349338949,
-0.0087474631,
-0.036928691,
0.0253862627,
-0.1367070824,
-0.028282335,
-0.0048283902,
0.0440062284,
-0.0376040414,
0.0282853227,
0.0148589807,
0.0043062139,
0.0649689808,
0.0013308414,
0.0238157287,
-0.0227337275,
0.0059897341,
-0.0188548993,
-0.0282372832,
0.0307650343,
0.0051143495,
-0.031625215,
0.0453541987,
0.0157469474,
-0.008549571,
0.0151986415,
-0.0957777053,
-0.0391273238,
0.0659312978,
0.0521579348,
-0.0085157547,
0.023045836,
0.0203215703,
0.0330895297,
0.0349738821,
0.0130490949,
-0.0019425119,
-0.0121088736,
0.0603253096,
0.0493248142,
0.0318906754,
0.0204536691,
0.090961501,
-0.0174733922,
-0.0989708304,
0.0098564783,
0.0104781343,
0.0243588388,
0.0026433733,
-0.0078697884,
-0.0226888768,
-0.0005946949,
-0.004956434,
-0.0304912161,
-0.0361318327,
-0.0055404007,
0.0396063104,
0.0464397818,
-0.0579311103,
-0.0075848573,
0.0450614057,
-0.0772665143,
-0.0034388956,
0.0258474723,
0.0045903428,
-0.0329042114,
-0.0248645507,
0.0512823872,
-0.0884035453,
-0.0333309397,
0.0029708452,
-0.0232699849,
-0.0294528473,
0.0147571759,
0.0488251746,
0.008472695,
-0.0746776089,
-0.0084848637,
-0.0150979823,
0.0078934887,
0.0641760081,
0.075686343,
0.020928178,
0.0245527532,
-0.0085748741,
0.0356041417,
0.0436744951,
-0.0208004564,
-0.0382333361,
-0.0142542357,
-0.0009108436,
0.0401416272,
-0.0065197097,
-0.0003081324,
-0.0365606137,
0.0337843262,
0.05527642,
-0.0736000836,
-0.0192204081,
-0.0030597351,
2.738e-7,
0.0389152952,
-0.023216024,
0.0178978145,
0.032009732,
-0.0043142829,
0.0107974503,
0.0010356953,
0.0531842597,
-0.0234237593,
0.0105281668,
0.0508873798,
0.0414070189,
0.0498863347,
0.0070071518,
-0.0490940996,
-0.0175227951,
-0.0211246423,
0.0047107087,
-0.0006563449,
-0.0216665436,
0.0243103839,
0.1223821789,
-0.0018564808,
-0.0004102112,
0.0234825574,
-0.0664417297,
0.0254628733,
0.0149458786,
0.0259946343,
0.0664799288,
0.0322328657,
0.0389313661,
-0.0312069748,
0.0074282046,
-0.0285012182,
0.0418393947,
0.0297249984,
0.0812440813,
-0.0239139665,
0.0004883615,
-0.0225037187,
0.0173823275,
-0.0071821036,
-0.0581853576,
0.1013336927,
-0.0541102625,
0.0071704034,
-0.008482419,
-0.0427319929,
-0.0201898888,
0.0272831544,
-0.0038871281,
-0.0055007366,
0.0349658281,
0.0143247563,
-0.0106623583,
-0.043725729,
-0.0928145424,
-0.0356970057,
-0.005620569,
-0.03563793,
-0.031874001,
-0.0118670743,
-0.0789821297,
0.0243202969,
-0.0249573942,
0.0058814622,
2.34899105e-34,
0.0272599943,
-0.0261294246,
-0.0065589608,
0.0548223481,
0.0151237249,
-0.0252760872,
-0.0040098592,
-0.0316898674,
-0.0077300053,
-0.0611136705,
-0.05140334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01905v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01905v2 | Dual-Attention Neural Transducers for Efficient Wake Word Spotting in Speech Recognition | 2023-04-03T01:19:39 | 2023-04-05T01:22:38 | Saumya Y. Sahai, Jing Liu, Thejaswi Muniyappa, Kanthashree M. Sathyendra, Anastasios Alexandridis, Grant P. Strimel, Ross McGowan, Ariya Rastrow, Feng-Ju Chang, Athanasios Mouchtaris, Siegfried Kunzmann | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | We present dual-attention neural biasing, an architecture designed to boost
Wake Words (WW) recognition and improve inference time latency on speech
recognition tasks. This architecture enables a dynamic switch for its runtime
compute paths by exploiting WW spotting to select which branch of its attention
networks to execute for an input audio frame. With this approach, we
effectively improve WW spotting accuracy while saving runtime compute cost as
defined by floating point operations (FLOPs). Using an in-house de-identified
dataset, we demonstrate that the proposed dual-attention network can reduce the
compute cost by $90\%$ for WW audio frames, with only $1\%$ increase in the
number of parameters. This architecture improves WW F1 score by $16\%$ relative
and improves generic rare word error rate by $3\%$ relative compared to the
baselines. | [
-0.0359442495,
0.0461503603,
-0.0026546295,
0.0462283939,
-0.0335566774,
-0.031060474,
0.0287013724,
-0.0292541124,
-0.0078096935,
-0.0480776913,
-0.0474088937,
-0.0748920068,
0.0270272791,
0.0557925403,
0.0154549358,
0.0053087808,
0.0852636322,
-0.0078638857,
0.0330409333,
-0.0015714335,
-0.0126174977,
0.0026910619,
-0.0471504591,
0.0157918185,
-0.0236377455,
0.0194377899,
-0.0160127934,
-0.0062556285,
0.0055885995,
-0.0012628536,
-0.0322527476,
0.0174182523,
0.0153598553,
0.0589567497,
0.0000020353,
-0.0035801455,
0.0271107815,
0.0210126005,
-0.0379508063,
-0.0205690954,
0.0406327732,
0.0815713704,
-0.0189892054,
0.0084591629,
0.019115245,
-0.0526989661,
0.0689646527,
0.0025216101,
-0.0227949768,
0.0352363251,
0.0023025258,
-0.0049622296,
0.0208773278,
-0.0389127694,
0.0068875886,
-0.0575414449,
-0.0097424919,
-0.0742269605,
-0.0573355481,
-0.0520644076,
0.0002059597,
0.0547634773,
-0.0019538209,
0.0114830807,
0.0270934254,
0.0008047378,
-0.0765849575,
-0.0329381786,
-0.0235726237,
0.0642498657,
-0.0458921194,
0.0213015359,
0.0003036786,
-0.0094062751,
0.0022864339,
-0.0428873226,
0.0027615589,
0.0110702217,
-0.0089968974,
0.0185240787,
0.0345811397,
0.0273329038,
0.0471638963,
-0.0021572127,
-0.0429133512,
0.0171195213,
-0.0010401229,
0.0146693634,
0.0384476706,
0.0346329398,
0.0105116777,
-0.0065019834,
0.0568645075,
0.0037589155,
-0.0369590856,
-0.0132155009,
-0.0847830102,
-0.0651892424,
-0.0305126123,
-0.048879005,
0.0493471511,
0.0522451289,
-0.107330665,
0.0225703344,
-0.0565186329,
0.0294057541,
-0.0143913385,
-0.0098313419,
-0.0068910071,
-0.0132161668,
0.0596651062,
0.0162353925,
-0.0181706436,
0.0208227318,
-0.0422149524,
-0.0481979363,
-0.0274626259,
-0.0061794003,
-0.0259091388,
-0.0375195183,
0.0252685696,
-0.0087958258,
-0.0512356237,
-0.0205763038,
0.0468977429,
0.0528556369,
0.0266232621,
0.0396187864,
0.0183638874,
-0.0902154669,
-0.0496839248,
0.0394807458,
0.0563879199,
0.0119852163,
0.0273429807,
0.0758553073,
0.0090131611,
-0.0493655242,
-0.0094337799,
0.0483499542,
-0.0157721005,
-0.0033987311,
0.0126649672,
-0.0743959248,
0.0445780382,
-0.0363667719,
-0.0174478441,
-0.000519173,
0.0224085059,
0.0373803191,
-0.0191819947,
0.0231506601,
-0.0363591798,
-0.0278864,
0.00774477,
-0.0161602292,
0.0154702319,
0.0466398261,
0.0655615628,
-0.0120754568,
0.0265970528,
-0.0245060977,
0.0068041207,
0.0491215102,
0.0240298081,
-0.0126658399,
-0.0195902083,
-0.0004625964,
-0.0198836811,
0.013064703,
0.0879680961,
0.0273954589,
-0.0099229394,
-0.045848839,
0.053806521,
0.0178327598,
-0.0025383837,
0.0334227346,
0.0328103155,
0.0012431933,
-0.0544746183,
-0.0441148244,
-0.0282319617,
0.060137257,
-0.0189670436,
0.0031355666,
0.0633099303,
0.0181994941,
-0.0196819734,
-0.0304152388,
0.0253539886,
-0.022396205,
-0.0432271138,
0.0689402148,
0.0213755816,
-0.001289916,
-0.0610789172,
0.0890355781,
0.0088830227,
-0.03185004,
-0.0268585123,
-0.0798216611,
-0.0115716113,
0.0230327696,
-0.0197974201,
-0.0554998331,
-0.0104841879,
-0.0247797705,
0.0074632224,
0.0455519371,
0.0183956027,
0.0360331833,
0.0475778505,
-0.0500482582,
0.0010985503,
0.0097698728,
0.0153878219,
0.0673546121,
0.003098608,
0.0489033647,
-0.0168758202,
-0.0204352085,
-0.0477029905,
-0.0146198124,
0.0675613806,
-0.0066266176,
0.038617406,
0.0103818942,
0.0617749728,
0.0291826334,
-0.0298907515,
0.0186439995,
0.0147462999,
-0.0521831214,
0.0238244943,
0.0372773036,
-0.0931345373,
0.0228399895,
0.0350520276,
-0.022757791,
0.0298939366,
0.0681511685,
0.0092379395,
-0.0302206222,
0.0336575881,
-0.0406549945,
-0.0003364398,
-0.023802625,
0.0033257825,
0.004552104,
0.0471784584,
0.0045450125,
0.0173818693,
-0.0338917561,
0.0104553625,
-0.0242791921,
-0.0106486073,
-0.0038331079,
-0.033972647,
-0.0121947369,
0.0062379506,
-0.0346807428,
-0.0109898522,
-0.0371678434,
-0.0368621722,
-0.0056119519,
0.0068973522,
-0.0673269331,
0.0134862699,
-0.0232397132,
0.0270142648,
-0.0019677279,
0.0330283195,
0.0088711614,
-0.0099561512,
-0.0264088251,
0.017124651,
-0.0272459798,
0.0012919442,
-0.0411019064,
-0.0413047709,
0.0085569611,
-0.0303702131,
-0.0314533412,
0.0409174487,
-0.0017542493,
-0.027440263,
-0.0541664548,
-0.0367734544,
0.0076708817,
0.0633223951,
0.0387072861,
0.0065222615,
-0.0219400153,
-0.0260862596,
-0.0181999821,
0.0239268076,
0.077786915,
0.0084011666,
-0.0329667479,
0.0377389304,
-0.0273991581,
0.0030264372,
0.0542220697,
0.0410533883,
0.0362145938,
0.0063392352,
-0.0031967254,
-0.0562936813,
0.0684101507,
0.0014799836,
0.0065366952,
-0.0015114526,
-0.0429870486,
0.0001459019,
-0.0291117597,
0.0142450416,
-0.0244201776,
-0.0387450866,
-0.0065804305,
0.0004985085,
-0.0389898084,
0.0195932612,
-0.0273503698,
-0.0517424718,
-0.053883981,
0.0028570823,
0.0232605208,
-0.0123155573,
-0.0136000719,
-0.0067636226,
-0.0682643875,
-0.0490775071,
-0.0024297857,
0.0025079206,
0.0051078578,
-0.0695806518,
0.0760240853,
-0.0068444884,
-0.0204438642,
-0.0489728302,
-0.025162207,
-0.0124151958,
-0.0300383996,
-0.0665997639,
-0.0032334842,
0.0170897394,
-0.0321286693,
-0.0591377579,
0.0181726925,
0.0385225452,
0.085731864,
0.0192234069,
0.0093770875,
-0.012724285,
0.0416096635,
0.0051514935,
0.0720367357,
0.0316337459,
0.0384493805,
-0.0147386277,
0.0206449702,
0.0768322945,
0.016384216,
-0.0598342046,
-0.003032408,
0.0628057197,
0.0005743302,
-0.0227138493,
0.0306250807,
0.0586383268,
-0.0621475764,
0.0131290443,
0.0667519569,
0.0061414526,
-0.0573992655,
-0.0134155564,
0.020962147,
-0.005719013,
0.0284322593,
-0.0080446554,
-0.0282349885,
-0.0484237485,
0.0373553783,
0.0539010838,
-0.0089918738,
-0.0034417438,
-0.021971155,
-0.0623753816,
0.0363779031,
0.0189974848,
-0.0055557871,
-0.0464621559,
-0.00641783,
0.0190289952,
-0.0076162787,
0.033516895,
-0.0161316786,
0.0180831179,
-0.0329768844,
-0.0041493913,
-0.0274415407,
0.0036360607,
0.0502342768,
-0.0463743135,
0.0305007976,
0.0790657252,
0.0011521276,
-0.0383781232,
-0.0388971083,
0.0246849172,
-0.0211924296,
0.0013607673,
-0.0004295799,
0.0040738392,
-0.0136105865,
-0.0445326455,
-0.0205483381,
0.0184855219,
-0.0294160303,
0.0190793071,
-0.0201191492,
0.0755720362,
0.0186228659,
-0.0227160472,
-0.0306339655,
0.0298165046,
0.0242494792,
0.0429993682,
0.0399249271,
-0.0641688779,
0.0197548661,
0.0394024141,
0.0067094364,
-0.0812223703,
-0.0442813262,
-0.0025400864,
0.0160984844,
-0.0573851764,
0.0017223797,
-0.0237601362,
-0.0108638657,
0.053926751,
0.0010892272,
0.0204825755,
-0.0074124872,
0.0027543944,
-0.0786582306,
0.0348206572,
-0.0179252513,
0.0376179628,
-0.0390901379,
-0.0328592695,
0.0196961593,
-0.0183127988,
-0.0135938311,
0.0599368364,
-0.0661732927,
0.0054438673,
0.0271962304,
0.0079789683,
0.0084634898,
0.0581660829,
-0.0417105965,
-0.0089171231,
0.0026547727,
0.059810292,
-0.0456288271,
0.0219431948,
0.0743402168,
-0.0458171517,
-0.0066748825,
0.0089994743,
-0.0566043817,
-0.004896563,
0.01987876,
-0.012976706,
0.0273513086,
-0.0171337482,
-0.0318995342,
0.0002555332,
0.0745575875,
-0.0190801211,
0.0737236068,
-0.040255364,
0.0417916812,
0.0363166817,
0.0265910737,
-0.0601664707,
0.0132046929,
0.0131204426,
-0.0171583835,
-0.0221907496,
0.0264027268,
0.0264318399,
-0.109124504,
-0.0327199288,
0.0558829159,
0.001982138,
0.0280301422,
-0.0184900649,
-0.0374105647,
-0.0639596879,
0.0141028967,
0.0229395907,
0.0430326536,
-0.0153018571,
0.0194677711,
0.007627333,
-0.0422868319,
-0.0152199194,
0.0215204433,
-0.0018048347,
-0.0213398095,
-0.0070846104,
0.0452295393,
0.068316102,
-0.0560426526,
0.000799109,
0.0295536872,
-0.0136443609,
-0.0102474466,
0.0080353422,
0.0122549599,
0.0082633058,
-0.0095065478,
0.0335654169,
0.0082166009,
0.0225532018,
0.0426824503,
-0.0097657051,
0.0066627781,
0.0133642145,
0.0061974907,
-0.0192951132,
-0.0397333167,
-0.0427630879,
0.0172928907,
-0.0133741703,
0.0018449839,
-0.0108690243,
-0.057150878,
0.0479512997,
-0.0178242587,
0.0620117635,
0.0128724715,
0.0054859659,
0.0386592261,
0.0050810063,
-0.0501473173,
0.0148740681,
-0.004109004,
0.0166044682,
-0.015841011,
0.0220305175,
-6.006864295e-33,
-0.0373788588,
0.0121970046,
-0.0252278727,
-0.0262276586,
-0.032115452,
0.0307177249,
0.0075468486,
0.0089263255,
-0.0433068536,
0.0014916249,
-0.0289928187,
0.0411379077,
0.049285423,
0.0035967799,
-0.0095737539,
-0.0127111105,
0.0643230155,
-0.018369263,
0.0130159017,
0.0228023659,
0.0081425617,
0.0126042766,
0.0709798634,
-0.0262419321,
-0.0252943058,
0.0026187964,
0.0461262576,
-0.0448257737,
0.0032489419,
0.0124120563,
-0.0215472523,
0.0441988371,
0.0000383414,
0.0266533569,
-0.0339141302,
0.0271381009,
-0.0831893682,
-0.0220192764,
0.0009281417,
0.0489767715,
-0.0140196802,
-0.0236522909,
0.05662442,
0.0526359938,
0.0200149342,
-0.0490791462,
-0.0221264195,
-0.0204855613,
-0.0554862432,
-0.0139921848,
-0.013285974,
0.028512923,
0.0120228259,
0.0144614559,
0.0458543487,
-0.0080480929,
-0.0386996828,
-0.0560536571,
-0.0943554714,
-0.0185620505,
0.0158260167,
0.0455254279,
0.0221631322,
0.0494340062,
-0.0366025306,
0.0465169959,
0.0755186304,
-0.041707132,
0.005584293,
0.0160176717,
0.0422140658,
0.0046350537,
0.0451374874,
0.0100774067,
0.0805071145,
-0.0329947732,
-0.0575693101,
-0.0472778715,
-0.0010364769,
0.0021636903,
0.1151635051,
-0.0024604241,
-0.0383660085,
0.0040610833,
-0.0347279571,
0.0074330466,
-0.0634672493,
0.0310804024,
0.0241692998,
0.0364826508,
0.0152085479,
0.0139535787,
0.0581683889,
0.0019162495,
0.0856226906,
-0.0329209976,
0.0334748663,
0.0032395739,
-0.0020142717,
0.0154922782,
-0.0221380871,
0.0169361439,
0.0210944898,
0.05697814,
0.0008367181,
0.006128557,
-0.0054937103,
0.0391166657,
-0.0360211618,
-0.018535208,
-0.0061854129,
-0.004271477,
0.0185061619,
0.0399280414,
0.0671704113,
-0.0273612067,
0.002878336,
0.0351366512,
-0.056164477,
-0.0056208158,
0.0021912619,
0.0304382481,
-0.0120990667,
0.0526332669,
-0.0198954064,
0.0264710169,
-0.010740052,
0.0116478298,
-0.0153680081,
-0.048859261,
-0.0317608006,
0.0290497076,
2.899e-7,
-0.0451430976,
-0.0079681361,
-0.0149276583,
-0.0283410028,
0.0203607958,
-0.0150932316,
0.0421175286,
0.0090942327,
-0.0078335693,
0.0307862014,
0.0146899726,
0.0036219752,
0.0548552088,
0.0042862273,
-0.0925610289,
-0.0815173388,
-0.013806452,
0.0829815716,
-0.0166968182,
-0.0447810069,
-0.0210517012,
0.0635784268,
-0.0170531366,
-0.0342134945,
0.0507864989,
-0.029732123,
-0.0117127504,
0.0174889844,
0.0515211113,
-0.0469653644,
0.009221822,
0.0516877919,
-0.0328058489,
0.030579498,
-0.0275376644,
0.0419798829,
0.0311875623,
0.041697327,
-0.0238035843,
-0.0602778904,
-0.0254441109,
0.0072323326,
-0.0133420611,
0.0038142987,
0.0540751033,
-0.0269534867,
-0.0342696644,
-0.0580523387,
-0.0455751792,
-0.0013249201,
-0.016551327,
0.0121156946,
0.0486572534,
-0.0111247851,
0.0094394125,
-0.0252347309,
-0.0543002859,
-0.0776912346,
0.0043679434,
0.022399595,
-0.0479770936,
-0.0278855804,
-0.0787947252,
-0.0441650525,
0.0439054556,
-0.0065284092,
-0.025949182,
2.250914643e-34,
0.0394841582,
-0.037154723,
0.0140680335,
0.0318894126,
-0.0107885506,
-0.0219293162,
0.0252490453,
-0.0309624132,
-0.0061718021,
-0.020407835,
-0.0400396958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00649v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00649v1 | Multilingual Word Error Rate Estimation: e-WER3 | 2023-04-02T23:08:11 | 2023-04-02T23:08:11 | Shammur Absar Chowdhury, Ahmed Ali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | The success of the multilingual automatic speech recognition systems
empowered many voice-driven applications. However, measuring the performance of
such systems remains a major challenge, due to its dependency on manually
transcribed speech data in both mono- and multilingual scenarios. In this
paper, we propose a novel multilingual framework -- eWER3 -- jointly trained on
acoustic and lexical representation to estimate word error rate. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of eWER3 to (i) predict WER without using any internal states
from the ASR and (ii) use the multilingual shared latent space to push the
performance of the close-related languages. We show our proposed multilingual
model outperforms the previous monolingual word error rate estimation method
(eWER2) by an absolute 9\% increase in Pearson correlation coefficient (PCC),
with better overall estimation between the predicted and reference WER. | [
-0.0077794767,
0.078536965,
0.020603979,
0.0366791487,
-0.0218832605,
-0.0051626982,
0.0176964067,
-0.0170998219,
-0.0132647865,
-0.0125489011,
-0.1158904135,
-0.0670645833,
0.0702391043,
-0.0148675693,
0.033765927,
-0.0029163747,
0.0341401994,
-0.0536292382,
0.0066002337,
-0.0274287909,
0.025034938,
0.0118014514,
-0.026480725,
0.0498164743,
-0.0284647513,
0.0318691991,
0.0290735215,
0.0324026644,
-0.0026020398,
-0.0463742428,
0.0142087908,
0.025244398,
0.0064990702,
0.0440617129,
0.0000020587,
-0.052325137,
-0.0306641143,
0.0131765669,
0.0196246859,
-0.0044558421,
-0.0011290353,
-0.0248986632,
-0.0135184396,
0.0515762568,
0.0262487456,
-0.0108463904,
0.0700626522,
0.0130468188,
-0.0200526454,
0.0275365766,
-0.0144637572,
-0.0115692867,
-0.0076045231,
-0.0194302797,
-0.0494479351,
-0.0237695649,
-0.0229463596,
0.0036963243,
-0.0691951662,
-0.0613556691,
-0.0744929388,
0.047969345,
-0.0227614865,
0.0031028781,
-0.0759044215,
-0.0194701701,
-0.0227375496,
-0.0542730168,
-0.0368791744,
0.0427816808,
-0.0109978737,
-0.0194571279,
-0.015155849,
0.0021739777,
-0.0544821471,
-0.0046136775,
0.0216750652,
0.0101876967,
-0.0247091018,
0.0014679214,
0.0363937914,
0.0395176932,
0.0296087973,
-0.0371663719,
-0.0030456646,
0.0375992432,
0.0402188264,
-0.0530974381,
0.0201868862,
-0.00311818,
0.0185014401,
0.0265041161,
0.0695606098,
-0.0254425015,
-0.0302886702,
0.0088601597,
-0.0395663865,
-0.085027352,
0.0083967922,
-0.0459899753,
0.0221626256,
0.0509706624,
-0.0423490517,
0.016860811,
-0.0093666753,
0.0860125422,
0.043592453,
-0.0125135044,
-0.0148113267,
-0.0346249677,
0.0136387907,
0.0314604305,
-0.0131177111,
-0.007279302,
-0.0016699209,
-0.0194569416,
-0.0620075315,
-0.026735127,
-0.0059524621,
0.0117478063,
0.0393535122,
-0.0225487091,
-0.0470221639,
-0.0176383778,
0.0263740811,
0.0505287088,
0.0156363137,
0.0205496009,
-0.0345281065,
-0.0583862588,
0.0114909271,
0.024668796,
0.0296932552,
0.0013905591,
0.0295313876,
0.0531667806,
0.0104742255,
-0.0559174009,
0.0005657371,
0.0000508485,
-0.0414693467,
-0.0489895269,
-0.0368323214,
-0.0658342987,
0.0749917775,
0.0124527737,
0.0309317801,
-0.0258002132,
0.0174666252,
-0.0401979089,
0.0141261965,
0.076229237,
-0.0323583595,
0.0146095678,
0.0398014262,
-0.0144888712,
0.0395710841,
0.0624429993,
0.0521030426,
-0.0450032838,
0.060853757,
-0.0059706005,
-0.0202689376,
0.0711314604,
-0.0103048766,
-0.0105748987,
0.0222839322,
-0.0636139512,
-0.0041215937,
-0.0087222336,
0.0469480939,
0.061597649,
-0.0158861503,
0.0166634377,
0.0237583555,
0.0750942305,
0.0380442142,
0.006960318,
0.0314223468,
-0.0171448719,
-0.0022540702,
-0.0077929189,
0.0205760617,
-0.0087538557,
-0.0063222032,
0.018792497,
0.0912386179,
0.0548490658,
-0.0306202695,
-0.0225612167,
-0.0148794223,
-0.0595870316,
-0.0043646279,
0.0096126478,
0.0711382404,
-0.0359185636,
-0.0430262908,
0.0484107509,
0.0339982286,
-0.0638846979,
0.0401986651,
-0.0176004861,
-0.0001109139,
0.0434706211,
0.0350873433,
-0.0077194837,
-0.0044013886,
-0.0038475452,
-0.0638424829,
0.0527069755,
0.0316254497,
0.0023343961,
0.0714956746,
-0.081143789,
-0.0198643934,
0.0336901918,
-0.0117500927,
0.0516689532,
-0.011073878,
0.0455856174,
0.0112109706,
-0.040951658,
-0.0130216554,
-0.0129872337,
-0.0394682512,
0.0156683438,
0.0050442857,
0.0083558708,
0.0489222519,
0.0413059294,
-0.048336152,
0.0003115317,
0.0048507452,
-0.012967268,
0.0008790576,
0.0490890443,
-0.0450136513,
-0.0359987468,
0.0499735326,
-0.0192248709,
0.0294579901,
0.0183847062,
0.022722736,
-0.0854775161,
0.0242601708,
-0.0128356209,
0.0200018194,
-0.0726017356,
0.0217916872,
0.0178949591,
0.0306516383,
0.014498882,
-0.0233402643,
-0.0215260871,
0.038772177,
0.028082734,
-0.0034411983,
0.0145653477,
-0.0140673229,
-0.071628049,
0.041548077,
0.0037800281,
0.0357361957,
0.0518725999,
0.0098804208,
0.0079618143,
-0.0101187518,
-0.0721372738,
-0.0033618165,
-0.0465871207,
0.0373997129,
-0.0047745411,
0.0228200331,
-0.0013948339,
-0.0389454179,
-0.0123242997,
-0.0034652178,
0.0306445397,
-0.0079480484,
-0.0469335392,
-0.0266968962,
-0.0245525744,
-0.0515746027,
0.0131582757,
0.0224804785,
-0.0063684904,
0.0135091562,
-0.0561640486,
-0.0802471489,
0.0103864484,
-0.028543504,
0.0215340797,
0.0279183984,
-0.0282172188,
-0.0271520801,
0.0218005013,
0.025461575,
-0.0284871627,
-0.0452878401,
0.0069555053,
0.0287273303,
-0.0281939022,
-0.0398847684,
-0.0123142088,
0.0100938343,
-0.0004386018,
-0.0040820488,
-0.0213164072,
-0.0151134199,
0.0343832038,
0.031985227,
0.0065470426,
-0.043667879,
-0.062508516,
-0.0308970548,
-0.0389089659,
-0.0057195211,
-0.0297398567,
0.0057497863,
0.0083960509,
-0.008792405,
-0.0471076034,
0.0431000888,
-0.0759898275,
-0.0211376157,
-0.0366913974,
-0.0125573762,
-0.0143841244,
-0.008184108,
-0.0147268102,
0.0148741677,
-0.0599724241,
-0.0759617686,
-0.003603444,
-0.0007315268,
0.0272695143,
-0.0640886948,
0.0334954411,
-0.0525713004,
0.0007663317,
-0.0076058009,
-0.0530240275,
0.0180850066,
0.0311685596,
-0.0241702311,
0.0279624946,
0.0005206657,
-0.0349483751,
0.0076249228,
0.0193563756,
0.0416523665,
0.0550952256,
0.010636121,
0.0087891538,
-0.0034301726,
0.0356168076,
0.0161587335,
0.0144991698,
-0.013410232,
-0.0817110017,
0.0499362722,
-0.0064265709,
0.0443304777,
0.0093388567,
-0.0047971667,
-0.0064325226,
0.0602560192,
0.0396402515,
-0.0089112353,
-0.0105660148,
0.0472751707,
0.0003923262,
0.0135883633,
0.1058251858,
0.006088207,
-0.0540968701,
-0.0360112824,
-0.0729630068,
0.0015664544,
0.0225298982,
0.0058624917,
-0.0299683642,
-0.0169605874,
0.0313981064,
0.0523958318,
0.0223126113,
0.0009904851,
0.0075568003,
-0.0929394662,
0.0059480793,
0.0000793232,
-0.0440848581,
-0.0489972718,
-0.0378884636,
-0.0218931623,
-0.0115435934,
0.0236218516,
-0.0041181128,
0.0308013353,
-0.0269210562,
0.0544071868,
-0.0866672471,
-0.0560660586,
0.0102567906,
-0.0399605967,
0.0492875427,
0.0467898212,
0.0469134301,
-0.0542239584,
-0.0271302387,
0.0076347357,
-0.0030443717,
-0.0142873935,
-0.0186684094,
0.0034762593,
0.0035336316,
-0.0205321517,
0.0224052891,
0.0238208286,
-0.0038534703,
0.0120642204,
0.0155521864,
0.0279053766,
-0.0245840661,
0.0343722403,
0.0364030488,
-0.0154010039,
0.0226446707,
0.024551427,
0.0004634136,
-0.0494857766,
-0.0076711741,
0.0186049361,
0.0328462869,
-0.0273099523,
0.0119772647,
-0.0039189709,
-0.0230664164,
-0.0393157899,
-0.0538972989,
-0.0730893537,
0.0079825297,
0.0061692465,
0.0349066928,
0.0210069139,
-0.0219050869,
0.0167371836,
-0.0110306488,
-0.039304249,
0.0065964442,
0.0191526059,
-0.0713664517,
0.0355314948,
-0.0020727543,
-0.0092625879,
-0.0060292971,
0.0265228506,
-0.0301659741,
-0.0558075272,
0.0068266573,
0.0524445549,
0.0077695618,
0.0151243657,
-0.0272737481,
-0.0502818227,
0.0388518982,
0.0081819417,
-0.0108685568,
0.0202138629,
0.0323726386,
0.0252827685,
-0.0378881507,
0.0269958787,
-0.0445364676,
-0.0125930458,
-0.0222311374,
0.0656629875,
0.0058608656,
-0.099652268,
-0.0161722191,
0.0310095828,
0.0541883446,
-0.0594995841,
0.0092846155,
-0.0850825906,
0.0075110188,
0.0034290573,
0.0384683087,
-0.0404854305,
0.0308601875,
0.0116432402,
-0.0451420806,
-0.019222511,
0.0179871451,
0.0037970939,
-0.0730743036,
0.0034616487,
0.0498766415,
0.0523359329,
0.0370572358,
0.0050874734,
0.010578909,
-0.0165325981,
0.0322927609,
0.0373330414,
0.0097013405,
-0.0203406122,
0.0368314423,
-0.0285601448,
-0.0068761948,
0.0562343486,
0.0085961614,
0.0036316833,
-0.0131925577,
-0.0336243585,
0.0187412035,
0.0706999972,
0.0074930745,
0.1001682207,
-0.0209047403,
0.0287269019,
-0.057196524,
0.0669204891,
-0.0196801331,
-0.0017065629,
0.0327310562,
-0.0336570516,
-0.0095648533,
0.0390225537,
0.0799653307,
-0.0026287532,
0.0088667516,
-0.0372360982,
-0.0022849694,
-0.0094784461,
-0.028770674,
0.0277256574,
-0.0270398837,
-0.0710227787,
-0.0133850845,
-0.0082507068,
-0.0834757537,
0.0489908345,
0.0537021868,
0.0064939596,
0.0134870159,
-0.0292780101,
0.0618182644,
-0.0453666672,
0.0383268893,
-0.0462882258,
-0.0650404543,
-0.0077624903,
0.006009914,
0.0332371891,
-5.91737244e-33,
-0.0335561447,
-0.0244292188,
-0.0149900094,
-0.0112592569,
-0.0033438529,
0.036703337,
-0.0091907848,
0.0320701897,
0.022835372,
-0.0043251012,
0.0041122008,
-0.0086128842,
0.0300752185,
-0.0090825213,
0.0272879768,
0.027460251,
0.0408193618,
-0.0093221618,
-0.0081018768,
-0.0281356778,
0.0692519769,
0.0663905665,
0.1012564227,
-0.0584470816,
0.0330965072,
0.0220471621,
-0.0032945471,
-0.0314601399,
0.043633759,
0.0334516987,
-0.0002152563,
0.0453709997,
-0.0254870076,
-0.0051275818,
-0.029532332,
-0.0264599379,
-0.0561832748,
-0.0211257525,
0.0012997079,
0.0474508554,
-0.0220363084,
0.0433995947,
0.0078487042,
0.0075028902,
-0.026188273,
-0.0002865718,
0.0244381502,
-0.0131391352,
-0.0261923522,
-0.0566599816,
-0.0468552411,
0.0519799106,
-0.0087481234,
0.0105914837,
0.0723642781,
0.0809613094,
-0.0109185176,
-0.040790841,
-0.1070053503,
-0.0012563516,
-0.0717458725,
0.0218978468,
0.0447457358,
0.0052032359,
-0.0381976739,
0.0291319825,
0.0269644447,
-0.0506296307,
0.0483231023,
-0.0532042123,
0.0623327903,
-0.0127397655,
0.0207823515,
0.0582107753,
0.0149180964,
-0.0276717227,
-0.0495246015,
0.0069255768,
0.016933402,
0.0213182755,
0.0419937186,
-0.0000760984,
-0.0591328181,
-0.0033689891,
-0.0510471947,
-0.0077899513,
-0.037330959,
-0.0218766369,
0.0435081124,
0.009644893,
0.0141626094,
-0.0071527367,
0.0705392957,
-0.0036335655,
-0.0031520971,
0.0027727475,
0.0269539617,
-0.0002763335,
-0.0425290987,
0.0576679409,
-0.0382966325,
-0.0348159,
-0.0266347695,
0.0479466505,
0.0282468591,
-0.0405074693,
0.0127643989,
0.0546521805,
-0.0729818642,
0.0179589484,
-0.0081199547,
-0.0123362755,
0.0093974434,
-0.0017075202,
0.0477842838,
-0.0283189025,
-0.0126122981,
0.0197841451,
0.020036459,
0.0212015323,
0.004931144,
-0.0260407645,
0.0012404047,
0.0468580946,
-0.0257818624,
0.0055396738,
0.0015142178,
-0.0377393551,
0.0007689393,
-0.0010993232,
-0.0081815878,
0.0032030125,
2.813e-7,
0.0067969207,
0.0190616809,
0.0166306458,
-0.0185289476,
-0.0118449414,
-0.001416779,
-0.0446528867,
0.0144664478,
-0.0082782684,
0.0475692861,
0.0179017168,
-0.0303815845,
0.1085534692,
0.0541604385,
-0.0429547466,
-0.0189600717,
-0.0827881023,
0.0424614698,
0.0107892593,
0.0138153592,
0.0234952047,
0.0643908381,
-0.020648215,
-0.0213357285,
-0.0532243252,
-0.002645798,
0.0652579591,
-0.0230481029,
-0.0237491764,
-0.0053458293,
0.0389941595,
0.0120322369,
0.0082177045,
0.0114071276,
-0.0618007816,
0.0500998311,
0.0641747639,
0.0152829569,
-0.013012236,
-0.0388300158,
0.0454302281,
0.0363830887,
-0.0579007044,
-0.0259846393,
0.020320721,
0.059252128,
-0.0123611623,
-0.0129867271,
0.0060076821,
0.0388271585,
0.0692779571,
-0.040062435,
-0.0050592236,
0.0070504197,
0.0363735855,
-0.0103015369,
-0.0320098586,
-0.0268346164,
-0.0034045989,
0.0060396176,
0.0049664611,
0.0012526183,
0.0021826448,
-0.0273375865,
-0.0021050673,
-0.0184424557,
0.0228981841,
2.053735568e-34,
0.0601265915,
-0.0297918562,
0.0256190263,
0.0028021696,
0.0416597463,
-0.0548710823,
0.0060244696,
0.0074536693,
-0.0284921099,
-0.0349725373,
-0.0401564687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00636v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00636v1 | Classifying COVID-19 Related Tweets for Fake News Detection and Sentiment Analysis with BERT-based Models | 2023-04-02T22:00:27 | 2023-04-02T22:00:27 | Rabia Bounaama, Mohammed El Amine Abderrahim | cs.CL | cs.CL | The present paper is about the participation of our team "techno" on
CERIST'22 shared tasks. We used an available dataset "task1.c" related to
covid-19 pandemic. It comprises 4128 tweets for sentiment analysis task and
8661 tweets for fake news detection task. We used natural language processing
tools with the combination of the most renowned pre-trained language models
BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers). The results
shows the efficacy of pre-trained language models as we attained an accuracy of
0.93 for the sentiment analysis task and 0.90 for the fake news detection task. | [
0.0420551859,
0.0395011827,
-0.0070109447,
0.0429091305,
-0.0294622723,
0.0129980072,
0.0090794768,
-0.0066626635,
0.016532002,
-0.0750660598,
-0.0028381518,
-0.0252308957,
-0.0283233579,
0.0615582317,
0.0151366871,
-0.0500392094,
0.0513381362,
0.046651192,
0.0557051823,
-0.0371438637,
0.0090731336,
0.0258976035,
-0.0171107259,
0.0484541655,
-0.0045772921,
0.0206949692,
0.0333568379,
0.0119357957,
0.0508035235,
-0.0330032408,
0.055860091,
0.0358032584,
0.0365076959,
0.0558002368,
0.0000017794,
-0.0257962327,
-0.0300285276,
0.0016946057,
-0.0027036334,
-0.0257629845,
0.036403764,
-0.0522411466,
0.0038573993,
0.0658055618,
-0.0543362051,
-0.0427202135,
0.0336125232,
0.052368205,
0.1003529206,
0.121549502,
-0.0222665574,
-0.0235694591,
0.0168773327,
0.0075739999,
-0.018776739,
0.0081929779,
0.0514476337,
-0.0154962577,
-0.0171758644,
0.0322201066,
0.0395852663,
0.0115135796,
0.0016147578,
0.0076289917,
-0.0122330552,
0.0441837236,
-0.0614766181,
-0.0370111577,
0.0011379842,
0.0107272221,
-0.0405403301,
-0.0737889037,
0.0312509723,
0.0110473363,
-0.0217758752,
0.0413389914,
0.0167737566,
-0.0140064508,
-0.005969415,
0.039147269,
0.0109403636,
0.0084549198,
0.0254923124,
0.0404143482,
-0.0101421699,
0.0150738861,
-0.0028582481,
-0.0689342171,
-0.0199733321,
0.0037085484,
-0.0319081172,
-0.0698433816,
0.0513741225,
0.018075766,
-0.0118333967,
0.0062535848,
-0.0511363,
-0.0784158483,
0.0230394024,
-0.1484889984,
-0.0248086285,
0.0205829721,
0.0082530184,
-0.005543286,
-0.0282409824,
0.0076119485,
-0.0219226815,
0.0558149032,
0.000898855,
-0.0031124786,
-0.0290111415,
0.0063809548,
-0.0371294804,
0.0310756136,
-0.0072213551,
0.0208549127,
-0.0564124286,
-0.0082743363,
0.0057766396,
0.0029998438,
0.0008092194,
-0.000603142,
-0.0175828598,
0.0162838176,
0.0048758965,
0.0341803506,
0.0113024684,
0.0168063603,
-0.0617026351,
-0.0094594723,
0.0041105575,
0.0087048709,
0.0220363624,
-0.0105900252,
0.0027738733,
-0.0082948245,
0.0164138749,
-0.0275125504,
-0.0032774142,
-0.0107352948,
-0.019279737,
-0.0313229337,
-0.0066336761,
-0.0548108891,
-0.0206578411,
0.0277796984,
-0.0121862758,
0.013774774,
0.0025760725,
0.0132943634,
-0.0455446541,
0.0394835696,
-0.0353281461,
-0.0131480461,
0.0506830178,
-0.0021647939,
0.0267787967,
0.0627087802,
0.020517204,
0.0862974077,
0.0204443298,
-0.0062075569,
0.0163909774,
0.0145478416,
0.0488853119,
-0.0014829978,
0.013120614,
0.012875204,
-0.0222160369,
0.0083827414,
-0.0079446137,
0.0347745009,
0.0108628748,
0.0013740102,
0.0384665839,
-0.0026910082,
-0.0059429356,
0.0023831872,
0.0225271098,
0.0497998148,
0.0197929144,
-0.0160769485,
-0.0146789085,
-0.0117475586,
-0.0243503116,
-0.0192631967,
-0.0125169223,
0.0318488069,
-0.0189200938,
-0.0088974284,
-0.0170216225,
-0.0196598079,
0.002582286,
-0.0266513601,
0.0301187355,
-0.0329570323,
-0.0812978745,
0.0256022103,
0.0180218425,
-0.0343771093,
0.0053583025,
-0.0824900344,
0.0178982113,
0.0543719046,
0.0224339422,
0.0000360771,
-0.0710157305,
-0.0474049151,
-0.0152954301,
0.0652801245,
0.0297833309,
-0.0008833094,
-0.0458412431,
-0.0089609101,
-0.0123078823,
-0.0251736958,
0.029630525,
-0.0074498211,
-0.0138871009,
0.0511614271,
0.0013748212,
-0.0069007082,
-0.0158150271,
0.0197123233,
0.0018410611,
0.0042989398,
-0.0253378395,
0.0297624785,
0.0296611898,
0.0378028713,
-0.0144144343,
0.0022232758,
0.0499977246,
-0.0215556305,
-0.0390789658,
0.0083448589,
-0.0121444557,
-0.0571819991,
0.0033665488,
-0.0396053083,
-0.0017593049,
0.0938931331,
-0.0225204211,
0.0140392473,
0.023170175,
-0.0427851342,
0.0539501533,
-0.0523334183,
-0.0018229405,
-0.066846706,
0.0240417998,
0.0554005019,
0.0593083389,
-0.0418981127,
0.0238171164,
-0.0305261277,
-0.0344687849,
0.0190221388,
-0.000398426,
-0.0123518649,
-0.0016625976,
-0.0002074407,
0.0140768588,
0.036848668,
-0.0172835551,
0.0184832774,
-0.0148853092,
-0.1052191034,
-0.0229589287,
-0.0543358028,
0.0462740809,
0.0424386635,
-0.0039918614,
-0.0140948594,
0.0278988872,
-0.0026171561,
-0.0279423781,
0.0140567496,
-0.0142268017,
0.0135187088,
-0.0388274789,
-0.0005504531,
0.0080217076,
0.012138403,
-0.0549403206,
0.0310720894,
0.016397994,
-0.0474232249,
-0.0263231397,
-0.032743223,
-0.0110739889,
0.0170775987,
0.0040799072,
-0.0858979002,
0.0112704942,
0.0199980047,
0.0360741764,
-0.0072439401,
0.0461488999,
0.062827386,
-0.0015486856,
0.0453043915,
-0.0150914807,
0.0103260027,
-0.0347731411,
0.0336151049,
-0.0328954533,
-0.0523080416,
0.0321808718,
0.0599544793,
0.0086093051,
-0.0177877601,
-0.0404245704,
0.0025990924,
-0.0009422887,
-0.0120675834,
0.0283075999,
-0.0581254326,
-0.0173396245,
-0.0387724712,
-0.0053524035,
-0.0079029445,
0.0672434494,
-0.0108909765,
0.0459393896,
-0.1007895172,
-0.014356114,
-0.0099595776,
-0.02286762,
0.0195118207,
0.0110209668,
-0.0055137561,
0.0060727093,
0.0488254763,
-0.0336608402,
-0.0067382827,
-0.0362559222,
-0.0191369299,
0.0144741181,
0.0281079374,
0.0139580425,
-0.0112902801,
-0.0763894096,
-0.0938895643,
-0.0439083353,
0.0098311352,
0.0268276073,
-0.0251410455,
-0.0685765222,
-0.0020904618,
-0.0056376443,
0.0537522435,
0.0136415046,
0.0272308663,
0.0143517712,
0.0283075944,
-0.0012144384,
-0.0290464256,
0.0109653529,
-0.0083154738,
-0.015074499,
0.0268199407,
0.0138064893,
0.0201278981,
-0.0523974225,
-0.0389388874,
0.008447079,
-0.067365773,
-0.0122849522,
-0.0098276157,
0.0363438986,
-0.0313619599,
-0.0010649371,
0.135774821,
0.032422971,
-0.0064098798,
-0.0006325455,
0.0093795601,
-0.047672864,
-0.0041803122,
0.0068840021,
-0.0296807401,
-0.0162986312,
-0.0042092921,
-0.0017829888,
-0.0451099537,
-0.0262578782,
-0.0017958707,
-0.0717521533,
-0.0004444053,
-0.0210991874,
0.0099085728,
-0.0431325361,
-0.0972846001,
-0.004448432,
0.0056459713,
0.0180721749,
-0.0432847142,
0.0025582367,
0.0273221023,
0.015048679,
-0.0336320028,
-0.0595004074,
0.0088674389,
-0.0257176384,
0.0351730585,
0.0625619516,
0.0602862388,
-0.0476064906,
-0.0518174618,
0.0270549823,
0.0006465607,
-0.0319028087,
-0.0173166152,
0.0600835867,
-0.0474479645,
-0.0101731783,
-0.0152545581,
0.006857221,
-0.0315829553,
-0.0119176814,
-0.0375619791,
0.0585138202,
-0.0259726644,
-0.0862677321,
-0.034774974,
0.0334932879,
0.0351638235,
0.0516008511,
0.01371036,
-0.0166088846,
-0.0037104557,
0.0089843618,
0.0381680876,
-0.0575504042,
-0.0349670611,
0.0187280402,
-0.0164079834,
-0.0895250663,
-0.0668086186,
-0.025224179,
0.0321729295,
-0.0116143711,
-0.043524269,
-0.0543591231,
0.0644723848,
-0.0068942327,
-0.0512165949,
-0.0015161107,
0.0312564634,
0.0553299114,
-0.0507672243,
-0.0437195636,
0.0373256281,
0.0182044841,
-0.0249954611,
-0.016568318,
-0.0452779457,
-0.0366692878,
0.0251363665,
0.0252682939,
0.0165856462,
-0.007288177,
-0.0050265114,
-0.0111401491,
0.0790352672,
0.0683800876,
-0.0516195856,
-0.0297868922,
0.0414948091,
0.0210793037,
0.0134002967,
0.0169829484,
0.0032639219,
0.0273965504,
-0.0023255353,
-0.0000795943,
-0.0280057397,
0.0086953444,
0.0192864165,
0.0079500554,
0.0757224187,
0.0095485682,
-0.0198839139,
-0.0387370512,
-0.0144492425,
-0.0053395606,
0.0190191176,
0.001659989,
0.0097956825,
-0.0010942626,
0.017148966,
-0.0441099815,
0.0465556122,
-0.0845682919,
-0.0372818373,
-0.0529142171,
0.0609423332,
-0.0072718989,
0.0725035518,
0.0275239758,
-0.0160825122,
-0.034567941,
-0.0033388906,
0.0330471583,
-0.0313136131,
-0.0038449515,
-0.0171785578,
0.0006392134,
0.0035100186,
0.0124211712,
0.0217666514,
-0.0364860557,
0.0051034656,
-0.0716277435,
0.027623063,
0.0170984212,
0.0111994352,
0.0436628126,
-0.0282789096,
-0.0057441108,
-0.0076185539,
0.0209273677,
-0.0302973818,
-0.0053665377,
0.0098924506,
-0.0187771786,
-0.0455616191,
-0.0053633135,
0.0541720092,
-0.0174307991,
0.0539749786,
0.0776552036,
-0.0298277456,
-0.0298410896,
0.0037932417,
0.0528451763,
-0.0152945817,
-0.026980022,
0.0444377959,
-0.0131012378,
-0.0403744765,
0.0838422254,
-0.0516541228,
0.003703688,
0.0076092803,
-0.0067634801,
0.0591504388,
0.0100792209,
0.041154854,
-0.0245101489,
0.0278892908,
0.0141350646,
-0.0411429107,
-0.0109115178,
-6.280512767e-33,
0.0584313683,
-0.0253229663,
-0.0227877013,
-0.0368444398,
0.008233197,
0.0392770953,
-0.0080517419,
-0.0272957515,
-0.02860686,
0.0369443186,
0.0262256674,
0.0202585943,
-0.0021722133,
0.0328124277,
-0.0513346866,
-0.0237474423,
0.0731415749,
0.0052360296,
-0.003262169,
0.0194985177,
0.0368409604,
0.0484783836,
0.087615937,
-0.0646585897,
0.0293401144,
-0.0350792073,
-0.0069397585,
0.0261458624,
0.0259505492,
0.0209359713,
-0.0260082949,
0.063235417,
0.0477960743,
-0.0179752205,
0.0001267935,
0.0542360246,
-0.0179132465,
-0.0468500666,
0.0032909089,
0.0088026132,
-0.0217056796,
-0.0182154309,
0.0581198297,
0.0225679241,
-0.03461238,
0.0504191704,
0.0293157734,
0.0003305734,
0.0382150076,
-0.0358432941,
-0.0352804251,
0.0177827869,
-0.0179188345,
-0.0197497606,
-0.0116987154,
0.0641920418,
0.0075169397,
0.0342805348,
-0.0735823065,
-0.0044302484,
-0.0167337321,
0.0041716537,
0.0084840562,
-0.0656363517,
-0.0081820758,
0.0341571271,
-0.0014014333,
0.0052573625,
-0.0612467267,
0.0173934605,
0.0014576337,
0.0216763802,
0.0245350953,
0.0531370752,
0.0296926033,
-0.0710163042,
-0.0759189278,
0.0576842465,
0.032728333,
0.0294688512,
0.0194943473,
-0.0313638374,
-0.0088196089,
0.010232606,
0.0245051365,
-0.02440851,
-0.0058746482,
-0.0035254189,
-0.0343535095,
-0.004368206,
-0.0200163648,
0.0367984883,
0.0037094839,
-0.035094481,
0.0076672416,
0.0205073729,
-0.0057686223,
-0.0107777053,
-0.0018336249,
0.094244048,
-0.0514706075,
-0.0231707059,
0.0295817517,
0.0319448411,
-0.0115631884,
-0.0081514353,
0.0258628335,
0.0367658548,
-0.0506300107,
0.0224571098,
-0.0040783011,
0.035136506,
-0.0175242219,
0.0519639626,
0.0072983331,
0.0151250325,
0.0118093863,
-0.002174098,
-0.0132816695,
0.0287492555,
0.0043893592,
0.01916367,
-0.0307286736,
0.0271790661,
-0.0080403788,
0.0051169833,
-0.0567580126,
0.0498146638,
-0.0377005115,
-0.1159235016,
-0.0056735128,
-0.0376908071,
2.688e-7,
0.0582862981,
0.089055188,
-0.0208361764,
0.0007844042,
-0.0087322043,
0.0496349148,
-0.0005966395,
0.0660090819,
-0.0002897264,
-0.0413252786,
-0.0210803878,
0.0080362931,
-0.0227921829,
0.0315798,
-0.0542450696,
0.0041365097,
-0.0866210312,
0.0237947982,
-0.0296265502,
0.0312240385,
0.0522417389,
0.0798334628,
0.0245686118,
-0.0020700861,
-0.0142732346,
0.0047099385,
0.0458944961,
-0.0062564369,
-0.0486329831,
0.0282314178,
0.0309755169,
-0.0097826635,
0.0248755924,
0.0233114641,
-0.039852269,
0.0234437939,
-0.0117999725,
0.0155174835,
-0.0094946092,
-0.0021895217,
0.0017793576,
-0.0718132183,
0.0023975642,
-0.022146035,
0.067380704,
-0.0754116774,
-0.0649968088,
-0.0027383142,
-0.0526680015,
0.0451144204,
0.0361351408,
-0.0171987657,
-0.0456547625,
0.0418117493,
0.0112504661,
-0.0043001231,
-0.0113286814,
-0.0720181689,
0.0220131837,
-0.0173272304,
-0.0756595209,
-0.0246851761,
0.0076193106,
-0.0175188053,
0.0937851444,
-0.0168820489,
0.0871958584,
2.204415117e-34,
0.0584997684,
-0.001625365,
-0.04610838,
0.006573868,
0.0006862404,
-0.0219374448,
0.0185622498,
-0.0070267553,
0.0096095391,
-0.0195553377,
-0.0151149798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00634v1 | MMT: A Multilingual and Multi-Topic Indian Social Media Dataset | 2023-04-02T21:39:00 | 2023-04-02T21:39:00 | Dwip Dalal, Vivek Srivastava, Mayank Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Social media plays a significant role in cross-cultural communication. A vast
amount of this occurs in code-mixed and multilingual form, posing a significant
challenge to Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools for processing such
information, like language identification, topic modeling, and named-entity
recognition. To address this, we introduce a large-scale multilingual, and
multi-topic dataset (MMT) collected from Twitter (1.7 million Tweets),
encompassing 13 coarse-grained and 63 fine-grained topics in the Indian
context. We further annotate a subset of 5,346 tweets from the MMT dataset with
various Indian languages and their code-mixed counterparts. Also, we
demonstrate that the currently existing tools fail to capture the linguistic
diversity in MMT on two downstream tasks, i.e., topic modeling and language
identification. To facilitate future research, we will make the anonymized and
annotated dataset available in the public domain. | [
0.0414424278,
0.039415013,
-0.02697495,
0.0514541864,
-0.0281800199,
0.0481788479,
-0.0064638979,
0.00060746,
0.0069888928,
0.0078257164,
-0.0064999959,
-0.0309318397,
-0.0096771717,
0.0407395996,
0.0291604735,
-0.0157059841,
0.0178299975,
0.0063985954,
0.056044694,
0.000359818,
0.0383917056,
0.0643690899,
0.0165209677,
0.0308387484,
-0.0233492069,
-0.0093562482,
0.0389145538,
-0.0078069186,
0.0077917837,
-0.0320014432,
0.0463093072,
0.0857261345,
-0.006769361,
0.0450551584,
0.0000015827,
-0.0253160633,
-0.0357143804,
-0.0432657972,
0.0273695681,
-0.0315166265,
0.0778023005,
-0.0486159846,
0.0262104664,
0.002251352,
-0.0278136507,
-0.0100463768,
0.0772436112,
0.0263358559,
0.0372325256,
0.0826376453,
-0.0268917345,
-0.0346514732,
-0.0060398057,
0.0008485392,
-0.0180159546,
-0.0057777851,
0.0060679321,
-0.0133571718,
-0.0011014441,
0.0178528186,
0.0283196252,
0.0134771392,
-0.013224029,
-0.0122325569,
-0.0079967799,
-0.0140180178,
-0.0443576276,
-0.0171154402,
0.0283857845,
0.0455440022,
-0.0269475859,
-0.067199178,
0.086281769,
-0.0021727209,
-0.0814808235,
-0.0392518565,
-0.0259964652,
0.0302554537,
-0.0539837405,
0.0489715748,
0.0822454914,
0.0031081934,
0.0043201777,
0.0296102706,
0.0643147975,
0.0295440294,
0.0086812079,
0.0016986961,
-0.0661913529,
0.019707432,
-0.0012652745,
-0.046744518,
0.0265018735,
-0.0253771674,
-0.0251801684,
0.037180908,
-0.0040267091,
-0.0743006393,
0.0204535965,
-0.0487066284,
-0.0534224622,
0.0053180703,
-0.016346788,
0.0293921977,
0.0416772477,
-0.0456254743,
-0.0194906723,
-0.0077751735,
0.0382044241,
-0.0434419028,
-0.0252406467,
-0.0190534536,
0.0357846655,
0.0014058729,
-0.0054268166,
0.0469701104,
-0.0441333205,
0.0168008152,
-0.0277253687,
-0.0158356559,
-0.0026119801,
-0.0354134291,
-0.0233250614,
-0.0237273816,
0.0293766838,
0.0550502576,
-0.0355456136,
0.0188082121,
-0.0223355629,
-0.0528213643,
0.0029389982,
0.0249931794,
0.020653069,
-0.0136177465,
-0.0302598123,
0.0225675739,
-0.003525048,
-0.0674500912,
-0.0784067959,
0.0068092612,
0.0174820237,
-0.0159290172,
0.0044939662,
-0.1014588773,
0.070962362,
0.0538158901,
0.0082096206,
-0.0275966302,
0.0112706972,
0.026340628,
-0.0390618518,
0.0520398952,
-0.0483221114,
0.011330069,
0.0861616284,
0.0362267941,
0.0732685253,
0.0867470652,
-0.000087989,
0.0060639088,
0.0945491344,
-0.0091551486,
0.0009201365,
0.0263747312,
-0.0170407109,
0.0136467172,
0.0115467897,
-0.0005956463,
-0.0314161777,
-0.0329978466,
-0.0245929472,
0.0141427815,
0.0031177034,
0.0451125167,
0.0034935065,
0.0693460479,
-0.007040197,
0.0212497152,
-0.0055644,
0.0406206883,
0.0082078595,
-0.012665011,
0.0237181373,
-0.0040601552,
-0.0231555384,
-0.0264148824,
0.0606976971,
0.0063998345,
-0.0344000682,
0.0249176845,
-0.0024635377,
-0.043146614,
0.0089172348,
-0.0410536416,
0.0539782718,
-0.0350816809,
0.0086649228,
0.021160638,
0.0789590925,
-0.0622525699,
0.0214453526,
-0.0023935479,
0.0409414023,
0.0214368738,
-0.0185509641,
-0.0528757013,
0.0038784379,
-0.0159735978,
0.0530508794,
0.0597355999,
-0.009415417,
-0.015440207,
0.0005138485,
-0.0055709281,
0.0302280542,
0.0193959475,
-0.0034152381,
-0.0164943989,
0.027128838,
0.0325558633,
-0.0204425901,
0.0133642228,
-0.002065887,
0.0094782338,
-0.0170529727,
0.0087257093,
0.0289749466,
-0.0149308583,
0.025401853,
0.0571328588,
-0.0026382066,
-0.0605111867,
-0.000599672,
0.0019551336,
-0.0234237108,
0.0114508374,
0.0114156641,
-0.0239783768,
-0.0008776337,
-0.065495193,
-0.0373838991,
0.0012533284,
-0.0328908227,
-0.0645969138,
0.0702721998,
0.0018193165,
0.0095314961,
-0.0165193416,
0.001518275,
-0.0409112386,
0.0104513364,
-0.0039081695,
0.0451662093,
-0.0131404297,
0.0238239262,
-0.0077251224,
-0.0509382039,
0.0496717542,
-0.0228031576,
-0.0120165795,
0.0502941422,
0.0062730806,
0.0231867805,
0.033595711,
0.0251931921,
-0.0563486218,
-0.0110676615,
-0.0907138214,
0.0062528239,
-0.045670934,
0.0176223535,
0.0123636452,
0.061456155,
-0.0338438563,
-0.0139234746,
0.0140240723,
-0.0146137653,
0.0528936759,
0.0176077373,
0.0319863521,
-0.0370495245,
0.0542343706,
-0.0172242783,
-0.0296302643,
-0.0441720486,
0.0452161506,
-0.0183154531,
-0.0759634227,
-0.0161050465,
0.0138818054,
-0.0157249644,
-0.0180624258,
-0.0178977363,
-0.0188504141,
-0.0238893051,
-0.0247396808,
0.0381685495,
-0.009439623,
0.0013703887,
0.0062192888,
0.007040597,
-0.0273484066,
-0.0033290812,
-0.0116619561,
-0.0042626713,
0.0015005871,
0.0184446126,
-0.0409361273,
0.0347309895,
0.0536548346,
-0.0344798826,
0.0213933382,
-0.0339799263,
-0.0338339806,
-0.0470739082,
0.0190093741,
-0.0129788322,
0.0306343734,
-0.0146420347,
0.0504241101,
-0.0094355289,
-0.0402019843,
0.0510698892,
0.0049314983,
0.0255780648,
-0.0447527468,
-0.0320002772,
-0.0394167192,
0.0064001819,
-0.0195579007,
-0.0062036044,
-0.002815838,
-0.045899082,
0.0223301742,
0.0254529137,
-0.0197513457,
-0.0232602395,
0.0337391272,
-0.0250576697,
0.0309212357,
-0.0199944936,
-0.0097228,
-0.0089476248,
-0.0550395176,
-0.0247190669,
-0.0247677453,
0.0236986075,
-0.0177253876,
0.0501247868,
0.0280848555,
0.0118418653,
-0.0308295134,
-0.0045835762,
0.0195945036,
0.0104031172,
0.0327575915,
0.0457909442,
-0.0195388608,
-0.0223632772,
0.0309206638,
0.0000792002,
-0.0260100756,
0.0447906964,
-0.0325708091,
0.0095324777,
-0.0112667959,
0.0256680157,
-0.0244350042,
-0.0087019261,
-0.0173187908,
0.0769819096,
0.0414386503,
0.0128377071,
0.0921643674,
0.0428330638,
-0.0542878509,
-0.0267756395,
-0.0372707248,
-0.0063120401,
0.0039240206,
0.0324100554,
-0.1047738791,
-0.0145550137,
-0.0044710753,
-0.0113502806,
0.0032936209,
-0.0405459814,
-0.0161686242,
-0.0669516623,
-0.0224047545,
-0.0106666395,
-0.025613958,
-0.0420976467,
-0.0422054529,
-0.0384362936,
-0.033767499,
-0.0134102926,
-0.0451192372,
-0.0172099173,
-0.0221679416,
0.0232344232,
-0.0215148162,
-0.0503669903,
0.0070134243,
-0.0361128151,
0.0292122476,
-0.0092346994,
-0.0043403716,
-0.0242228489,
0.0229823459,
-0.0182037242,
-0.0256170798,
-0.0641530752,
-0.0267788768,
0.0114552407,
-0.0285862442,
-0.0298882499,
-0.0012007119,
0.0181199163,
-0.0617705807,
-0.0277755391,
-0.0066277687,
0.0303220544,
0.0211413894,
0.0037132879,
0.0091905436,
-0.0227621626,
0.0485425591,
0.0050722254,
0.0178758204,
-0.0358355381,
-0.000067087,
-0.0600005016,
0.0236652549,
0.0107524367,
-0.0362161398,
-0.000642021,
-0.0568734966,
-0.0795419142,
0.0089459457,
-0.049982924,
0.0353205837,
-0.0050848839,
0.0021084317,
0.0277879126,
0.0560796671,
-0.0119540272,
-0.0286037792,
0.0216809325,
-0.059549991,
0.0238156989,
-0.0575650223,
-0.0167323146,
0.0120849349,
0.0069127316,
0.0086736642,
-0.0040279697,
-0.1058023721,
-0.0507071428,
-0.0065211793,
-0.0392959043,
0.0098364847,
0.0067502395,
-0.0370355621,
-0.0979822129,
-0.0220207032,
0.0302225463,
-0.0517911911,
-0.025198834,
0.0134301865,
0.036584802,
-0.0031574715,
0.0555611514,
-0.0496010669,
0.0057221903,
0.0106453383,
0.0008805303,
-0.0508594774,
0.0306069367,
-0.0088467347,
0.0199292172,
0.0673357248,
-0.0215423908,
-0.0604788437,
-0.0766894966,
-0.048689723,
0.0015181857,
-0.0361233875,
-0.0018326361,
-0.0160792209,
0.0205849744,
0.0033977639,
-0.0458547026,
0.0113937771,
-0.0089504244,
0.0320066772,
-0.0306971353,
0.0692113414,
0.0158715472,
0.0651679188,
-0.0227341205,
-0.0107444068,
0.0364724174,
0.0374970548,
0.0100774057,
0.0001164092,
-0.0306028537,
0.0333844312,
-0.0363967866,
0.005676596,
0.0567638688,
0.0303966161,
0.0432773568,
0.0113239931,
0.0080725178,
0.0354523137,
0.0751201138,
-0.03187038,
0.0877091587,
0.0114557026,
0.0002321911,
-0.0400691703,
0.0476554148,
-0.027177209,
-0.0225190986,
0.0356840566,
-0.0116700279,
-0.056655094,
0.032437779,
0.076011546,
-0.0164301526,
-0.024125699,
0.0522120036,
-0.0152813122,
-0.0002858341,
0.0178387519,
0.0280455388,
0.0355095118,
0.017838113,
0.0268568248,
-0.0151437148,
-0.0453217179,
0.0077128634,
-0.0889096409,
0.0239662807,
0.0047144955,
-0.0058137872,
0.0870308727,
0.024771288,
0.0277068,
-0.0536101535,
-0.009956196,
0.0139813758,
-0.0595573671,
-0.0029951131,
-5.964155279e-33,
0.0167473387,
-0.0191905275,
-0.020083392,
-0.0003713237,
0.0457939282,
0.0228445828,
-0.0338243619,
0.0302729215,
0.0082701063,
-0.0196235403,
-0.0286854133,
0.0511424653,
0.0173255261,
0.0064357808,
0.0483430289,
-0.0366184711,
-0.0077825207,
0.0340529457,
0.0082730381,
0.0578063987,
0.0509623736,
-0.0082752043,
0.0927094147,
-0.090733923,
0.0517041646,
-0.0358868092,
0.0124120936,
0.0083831549,
0.089494437,
0.0331422016,
-0.0660798028,
0.0632037818,
0.0545415767,
-0.0261017401,
-0.0012254681,
0.0406877361,
-0.0399649143,
-0.0230904222,
-0.0045671472,
0.0185072571,
0.0037581625,
-0.0686411411,
0.0209275745,
-0.0099641485,
-0.0269895867,
0.0511657931,
0.0393323973,
0.0542945229,
0.0544801913,
-0.0087928427,
-0.0621279739,
0.0905872658,
-0.0178129431,
0.0176550541,
0.0212740041,
-0.0083650388,
0.0307695419,
0.0410112888,
-0.049168162,
0.0293383989,
-0.0164264999,
0.0146447243,
0.0565755889,
-0.0075412481,
-0.0635414124,
0.0002390371,
0.0196830779,
0.013391532,
0.025945425,
0.0168803241,
-0.0201124549,
0.0024773693,
-0.0131516606,
0.0494078137,
0.0147168301,
-0.0860799178,
-0.0474597178,
0.0103115495,
0.0275592133,
-0.0018983273,
0.0000160682,
-0.0097169708,
-0.0238907468,
-0.0299680363,
0.0352762714,
-0.0612475537,
-0.0340186357,
-0.0054332674,
-0.0183502957,
-0.0287807398,
-0.0161261447,
0.0751556084,
0.0586726516,
-0.027721649,
-0.0174234658,
0.0082504591,
-0.0270328298,
0.0243757963,
0.0294550229,
0.0786677748,
-0.0782301575,
-0.0553459823,
0.0011808642,
-0.0031449418,
0.0218368378,
-0.0130422609,
0.0301532242,
-0.0124694081,
-0.0588566996,
-0.0007712119,
-0.0004487222,
0.0301425848,
-0.046442464,
0.0234035105,
0.0080812629,
0.0159330275,
0.0044723577,
0.0111723254,
0.0921454877,
0.0184758082,
-0.0055851811,
-0.048107475,
-0.0507799722,
0.0001425301,
0.0010764803,
0.026853187,
-0.0374024361,
-0.0006646612,
0.0149171948,
-0.0203305166,
-0.0014214203,
-0.0265649278,
2.466e-7,
0.0059843636,
0.0648948029,
-0.0066821892,
-0.0226266868,
-0.0025566351,
0.0164180323,
-0.0122133577,
0.0397578254,
-0.0427835621,
-0.0151157388,
-0.0461153425,
0.0052249744,
0.0691355169,
0.0235461574,
-0.0735153183,
0.014521311,
-0.0691371411,
0.0264912508,
-0.0859201252,
0.0276197772,
-0.0376806706,
0.0857637674,
0.0418652669,
0.0147684561,
-0.0565517619,
-0.0235329047,
0.0314620882,
-0.0231076367,
-0.0324713923,
0.0454400629,
0.0200888049,
0.0177746229,
-0.0111887334,
-0.0311055183,
-0.0300343577,
0.0034045062,
0.0452813283,
0.0462515615,
0.0270497836,
0.0528103225,
0.0118890945,
-0.0214662775,
0.004580827,
-0.0255794413,
0.0667341053,
0.0357290022,
-0.0778584927,
-0.0476196259,
0.0521978401,
0.0050052176,
0.0406436436,
-0.0014784069,
-0.0606492683,
0.0037783815,
0.0085076643,
-0.0487239957,
-0.0298510548,
-0.0563053861,
0.018861752,
0.0226880666,
0.005988827,
-0.0099492725,
0.0020292928,
-0.0057845614,
0.0441677012,
-0.017268952,
0.0714241266,
1.924369659e-34,
0.0240906738,
0.0025752885,
-0.0164219476,
-0.0074522262,
0.0304519739,
-0.0095139379,
-0.052891165,
0.0112319943,
-0.0044720341,
-0.018502079,
0.022829039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00612v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00612v1 | Eight Things to Know about Large Language Models | 2023-04-02T20:03:27 | 2023-04-02T20:03:27 | Samuel R. Bowman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The widespread public deployment of large language models (LLMs) in recent
months has prompted a wave of new attention and engagement from advocates,
policymakers, and scholars from many fields. This attention is a timely
response to the many urgent questions that this technology raises, but it can
sometimes miss important considerations. This paper surveys the evidence for
eight potentially surprising such points:
1. LLMs predictably get more capable with increasing investment, even without
targeted innovation.
2. Many important LLM behaviors emerge unpredictably as a byproduct of
increasing investment.
3. LLMs often appear to learn and use representations of the outside world.
4. There are no reliable techniques for steering the behavior of LLMs.
5. Experts are not yet able to interpret the inner workings of LLMs.
6. Human performance on a task isn't an upper bound on LLM performance.
7. LLMs need not express the values of their creators nor the values encoded
in web text.
8. Brief interactions with LLMs are often misleading. | [
0.0299681127,
0.0702990144,
-0.0481287353,
0.0260987245,
-0.0322216786,
-0.0004045602,
0.0336366892,
0.0151923103,
0.0220690463,
-0.0368383154,
-0.0085290028,
-0.0369617678,
0.0159406438,
0.0288946331,
0.0488825329,
-0.0336429514,
0.0094481101,
-0.0575903207,
-0.0030500116,
-0.0285502207,
0.0025108003,
-0.0063360813,
0.0340796486,
0.0584734604,
0.0152376071,
0.0175245646,
0.0077496381,
-0.0331306495,
-0.042694103,
-0.0148826297,
-0.0325648747,
0.0300844219,
0.0265050996,
0.0547777154,
0.0000020249,
-0.0693921074,
0.0294785816,
-0.0212837458,
-0.023523856,
0.0438641533,
0.034633074,
0.0041712658,
-0.0355130732,
0.0245578513,
-0.0395959578,
0.0056639025,
0.0159590598,
-0.0279549863,
-0.0148917446,
0.0423916951,
0.0138792517,
-0.0121973101,
0.0314791985,
-0.0330772027,
-0.0323204212,
-0.0038259979,
0.0430162922,
0.0050807362,
0.0056847082,
0.0106149986,
-0.0380768888,
0.0439119935,
0.0090182908,
-0.0237798244,
-0.021745095,
0.0459826924,
-0.0022738136,
-0.0387143008,
0.0056983186,
0.0317497142,
0.0260546058,
-0.0133312978,
0.0338161513,
0.001446393,
-0.0033669875,
0.0309716798,
-0.0577352419,
0.0690685958,
0.006105877,
0.0369996987,
0.0311047435,
-0.0276137777,
0.0533487275,
0.0242102128,
-0.04018097,
0.0622104108,
-0.0065126424,
-0.0297383349,
-0.0175308511,
0.0274267495,
0.0069068912,
-0.0635832623,
0.00735255,
0.0086540431,
-0.011878998,
0.0361804776,
-0.0240027308,
-0.0029764541,
0.0175090227,
-0.0600929782,
0.0472495407,
0.01708382,
-0.0162961166,
0.0356048048,
-0.0249465499,
0.0584397316,
-0.0518128462,
-0.0113218976,
-0.0208826233,
0.0051875859,
-0.0370943025,
-0.0267239995,
0.0104311677,
0.024735393,
-0.0085605541,
-0.0148382569,
-0.0329013094,
0.0462334454,
-0.0055757421,
0.0286477059,
-0.0357091986,
-0.032088533,
0.0075435177,
-0.0210779421,
-0.0518982708,
0.0531038046,
0.0023564559,
0.0310765039,
-0.0230314936,
-0.045138035,
0.0464414656,
0.0253180321,
-0.0114829252,
0.0011441928,
0.0054104654,
0.0799804702,
0.0108188502,
-0.008452611,
-0.0216687471,
-0.0306608118,
-0.0202843249,
-0.0608900599,
0.0008321063,
-0.0596076064,
-0.0077021392,
0.0540324375,
-0.0097886678,
-0.0540058166,
-0.0054603536,
-0.004757558,
-0.0448595397,
0.0244174134,
-0.0263205897,
0.0371783189,
0.0209822115,
-0.0124247102,
0.0133317029,
0.0739450753,
0.0253012236,
0.0147931455,
0.0175412223,
-0.0414758734,
0.0081788376,
0.0684320405,
-0.01375903,
0.0424509719,
-0.0404863842,
0.0022097917,
0.0126371076,
0.0369348563,
0.0391036943,
0.0495425612,
0.0063558104,
0.0270600151,
0.0994791463,
0.0808036849,
-0.0016388948,
0.0169069711,
0.0209827572,
0.0214770753,
0.0004946541,
0.0070111528,
-0.0217526965,
-0.0121033024,
-0.0169630032,
0.0102517568,
0.0167578384,
0.0397412814,
-0.0308258738,
-0.028457405,
-0.007110876,
-0.0190606583,
0.0118399197,
0.0368506014,
0.088932924,
-0.0599868856,
-0.0108970432,
0.0424962007,
0.035217233,
0.0041554398,
0.0254505053,
-0.0877974182,
0.0308811441,
0.0602825955,
0.0306547396,
0.0048962617,
0.0227643382,
-0.0125072971,
0.0140352072,
0.0694176108,
0.0471614487,
-0.0028861715,
-0.0454854853,
-0.0155735351,
0.0088468138,
-0.0006814167,
0.0095829498,
0.0193405915,
-0.0094020711,
0.0164371692,
-0.0063120387,
-0.0081414962,
-0.03538711,
0.0151334256,
-0.0610078759,
0.0067360941,
-0.057496883,
-0.0050908793,
-0.0003418995,
0.0237775501,
-0.012329597,
0.0064238016,
0.0114394082,
-0.0276981965,
-0.0073841624,
-0.0065117497,
-0.0196207352,
0.0648687556,
0.0559429526,
0.0045869183,
0.0142363543,
-0.0112426355,
0.0103029301,
-0.030271979,
0.0657850802,
-0.0313592069,
0.0845547169,
-0.0202839505,
0.0492416769,
-0.0660860911,
-0.000630873,
-0.035791982,
0.025383953,
-0.0174742136,
0.0330802239,
0.0225920472,
0.0049455762,
0.0041585355,
-0.0344802141,
-0.0153407548,
0.0300778653,
0.0083776377,
0.0445749313,
0.030695729,
-0.0053627104,
-0.0079021808,
-0.0326892734,
-0.051082015,
-0.0235169493,
-0.0028987306,
0.0116677433,
0.0202472992,
-0.0386838987,
-0.0242558345,
0.020428516,
-0.0201005619,
0.0092820739,
0.022008149,
0.0238892566,
0.011324659,
-0.0109118605,
-0.0418800898,
-0.0391521268,
-0.0192609653,
-0.0062242672,
0.025473047,
0.0104441699,
-0.026768662,
-0.0914265439,
0.0399290919,
-0.0206013881,
0.0203058776,
-0.0303880945,
-0.0311019514,
0.0427699313,
-0.0177643858,
0.0349891149,
0.0304961298,
-0.0235258583,
0.0546228923,
0.0647058859,
-0.0049736868,
-0.0675069392,
-0.0298980698,
-0.0026143177,
-0.0398626328,
-0.0853471085,
-0.0297053102,
-0.0196782108,
0.0831095949,
0.0048086327,
0.0075526698,
-0.0137728984,
0.024243148,
-0.0699905232,
-0.0260646567,
-0.0294809993,
-0.0058325538,
-0.042195607,
0.0642309114,
-0.0062007369,
-0.0773515031,
0.039288599,
-0.0278067961,
0.0099337874,
-0.000485747,
-0.0345404856,
-0.0229402259,
0.0527468957,
-0.0028394903,
0.0161735862,
-0.0131296376,
-0.0314520784,
-0.0480591282,
0.0120765977,
-0.0157725532,
-0.0306601785,
0.0644044727,
-0.05081762,
0.0244953241,
0.0024424149,
-0.0341275334,
-0.0163568705,
-0.0406031907,
-0.0720248893,
0.0093256533,
0.0517662987,
-0.0399310812,
-0.0137738353,
0.0040867743,
0.0573315546,
0.0031326925,
0.0024792918,
-0.0036978887,
-0.0214783959,
-0.023250673,
0.0149441911,
0.0148566514,
0.0256802812,
-0.0560903624,
0.0276906192,
0.0276293494,
0.0113251647,
-0.002568474,
-0.0236453619,
-0.0127303507,
0.0485879891,
-0.0248903912,
-0.0489565544,
0.0462168679,
0.0381153375,
-0.0677419454,
0.0121004004,
0.1065159887,
0.007437353,
-0.017584417,
0.0171903092,
-0.0201132353,
0.0114255464,
0.0492179841,
0.0207158141,
-0.068641454,
0.014461589,
0.0091555808,
0.0149965966,
-0.0160255041,
-0.0160570648,
-0.005107434,
-0.1304564476,
0.0352999978,
-0.0005414351,
-0.026261162,
0.0189181287,
-0.0344539098,
-0.0012667959,
0.020093618,
0.0215707161,
0.0158018954,
-0.0328508951,
-0.0187713727,
0.0289503392,
-0.0690848306,
-0.0488964655,
0.0127041414,
-0.0509355962,
0.0612256005,
0.0486802496,
0.0237870328,
-0.0413855836,
-0.0084988149,
0.0179463513,
0.0187987592,
0.0235756747,
0.0010310804,
0.0215793084,
0.0419540778,
-0.0299388636,
-0.0412017144,
-0.0019397868,
-0.0257297922,
0.0074878694,
0.0276606884,
0.077874966,
-0.0308720227,
-0.0422766693,
0.0156337358,
-0.022578178,
-0.0394285172,
0.0594486408,
0.0114200562,
-0.085839957,
-0.0170125477,
-0.0401672535,
-0.0256602112,
-0.0002751251,
-0.0651347265,
0.0260205381,
0.0085751005,
-0.004438241,
-0.035171207,
-0.0309785716,
0.0274859592,
0.0129623497,
0.0332267322,
0.0233406741,
0.0593881942,
-0.0388410576,
-0.0035721951,
0.0122777186,
-0.0404100604,
-0.0093267895,
-0.0807210431,
-0.0198879465,
0.0279890187,
-0.0336976238,
0.0026444797,
-0.0362354591,
-0.0590509959,
-0.0868792534,
0.0194136556,
0.0103750182,
0.0350854695,
-0.0204583257,
0.0185473897,
-0.0796701908,
0.0596607998,
-0.0038308918,
-0.0361303613,
0.0288991891,
-0.0049508885,
0.0135296267,
-0.0103356587,
0.0344769731,
-0.0148916729,
-0.0101905158,
0.0108847748,
-0.0090010557,
-0.0483397879,
-0.022701744,
0.0032099257,
0.0288339593,
0.042263303,
-0.0373380966,
0.0111644166,
-0.0318621807,
-0.0224728938,
-0.0166787282,
0.0165053327,
-0.0143704293,
-0.0479109585,
0.0351182595,
0.0216865316,
-0.0011588513,
0.0155165121,
-0.0107494295,
0.0337939002,
-0.0508692451,
0.0459978357,
-0.0237712692,
0.0217798501,
0.0707742944,
0.0148468716,
0.0103840679,
0.0452855527,
-0.0254281852,
0.0387638398,
0.0206557289,
0.0498721823,
-0.022258766,
-0.0106495088,
-0.0016425169,
0.0094106551,
-0.039896559,
-0.1452032924,
0.0238592345,
0.0494740866,
0.0755382776,
0.0051356154,
0.0576034784,
-0.0432771854,
0.011577718,
-0.0321454406,
0.0050504445,
-0.0175193343,
-0.0460898802,
0.0225124042,
0.0035047415,
-0.065996483,
0.0209817234,
0.0818883628,
0.0325926244,
0.03788222,
-0.0209946372,
0.0062218532,
-0.0145767359,
-0.0463877358,
0.0206782855,
0.0034274796,
-0.0385892615,
-0.0040712482,
-0.0653582588,
-0.0619523712,
-0.0293320324,
-0.0062723025,
-0.0263910033,
-0.0667565688,
-0.0154633783,
0.0434399247,
-0.0011836106,
0.0163238868,
-0.0514166541,
0.0177669898,
-0.0266474113,
-0.0195510834,
0.0108077331,
-6.473030824e-33,
0.0051798462,
-0.0152692981,
0.0420841873,
-0.0383875147,
0.0011327018,
0.0138444137,
-0.0295535102,
0.0560282171,
-0.0374761485,
-0.0175876636,
-0.0127903596,
-0.0174599923,
0.0167366825,
0.004712048,
0.0667566657,
0.0030802765,
0.0275147147,
-0.0068519982,
0.0245203283,
-0.0055046054,
0.044744283,
-0.0019681987,
0.0617146008,
-0.0703331456,
0.0446194485,
-0.0103224367,
-0.0029617934,
0.0049401224,
0.0294823702,
0.0507445298,
-0.0303514693,
0.0617139302,
0.0263462886,
-0.0788916498,
-0.045234818,
0.0040574148,
-0.0064064637,
0.0145570012,
0.0362530537,
0.0247876961,
0.0220679138,
-0.0222822502,
0.0481234193,
0.0049779029,
-0.0639602095,
0.0267801508,
0.0230756011,
-0.0195725579,
-0.0199950617,
0.0232964568,
-0.0523406193,
0.0183980167,
-0.000989318,
0.0396077223,
0.0075369421,
0.000994276,
-0.0236419775,
0.0255763363,
-0.0604074933,
0.0456160158,
0.0049196957,
0.0471379161,
0.0852065235,
0.018286055,
0.0237698406,
0.0692326054,
0.052594237,
0.0214396864,
-0.0026616929,
-0.0315925106,
0.0769902319,
0.02945734,
0.0182308778,
0.0342894606,
-0.0172856282,
-0.0322797224,
-0.0552256815,
-0.0264827274,
0.0412641577,
0.0161452107,
0.0371779799,
0.0057800245,
-0.0524136052,
-0.0829028487,
-0.0289131217,
-0.0121643711,
-0.010058403,
-0.0182996001,
0.0304391515,
-0.0154927867,
0.0203129034,
-0.0044867839,
0.0464144945,
-0.0742237046,
-0.0541595593,
-0.009461428,
-0.0378502719,
0.0488651805,
-0.0006926797,
0.0287853889,
-0.1120489538,
-0.0493151098,
-0.0592313036,
0.0073594102,
0.0134353004,
0.0367500223,
-0.0289465543,
0.0055728666,
-0.0579934381,
0.0025744475,
-0.0289161876,
0.0011363901,
0.048068691,
-0.0364880264,
0.068913877,
-0.0317245945,
0.0123260394,
0.0133554386,
0.0306346975,
-0.0330071524,
-0.005054201,
-0.0002958039,
-0.0171056446,
0.0123360734,
-0.0444994047,
0.0016106523,
-0.0663661435,
0.0492804758,
0.0538858622,
-0.0465393141,
-0.0204919018,
-0.0193612836,
2.653e-7,
0.0401627645,
0.0879612863,
-0.0150489463,
0.0127569307,
0.0211081877,
0.0431515612,
-0.0365307592,
-0.0002231968,
0.0167437866,
-0.0028162571,
-0.020860428,
0.0239267629,
0.0485930331,
0.0176547822,
-0.0630605742,
-0.0163265858,
-0.0671207011,
0.0376432166,
-0.0857293531,
0.0262364913,
0.0033493009,
0.0577666461,
0.0211692322,
-0.0156196402,
-0.0260944664,
-0.0780745596,
0.0716216564,
-0.052658949,
-0.0069785067,
0.0068831434,
-0.0051664398,
0.0412648767,
-0.0243293159,
0.0121783186,
-0.0003118647,
0.0275554229,
-0.0287015885,
0.0599174015,
0.0367101319,
0.024905948,
0.0191110149,
-0.0526532419,
-0.0087132649,
-0.0649110451,
0.0636441484,
-0.0284009613,
-0.0544517823,
-0.0312442575,
0.0226324033,
-0.0304051656,
-0.025406599,
-0.025410071,
0.0008413997,
0.0226930156,
0.0119690523,
-0.0292641111,
0.0138971014,
-0.0367394015,
-0.0234299339,
0.0076519242,
-0.057318069,
-0.0877252817,
-0.0377642736,
0.0389840454,
0.0309081543,
-0.0067204805,
0.0380750075,
2.340949704e-34,
0.0317855999,
0.0230139662,
0.0400450826,
0.0076828916,
0.0168611053,
0.0262612496,
-0.0060033309,
0.0245664399,
0.0167374425,
-0.0659758374,
-0.0037048596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00592v1 | PK-Chat: Pointer Network Guided Knowledge Driven Generative Dialogue Model | 2023-04-02T18:23:13 | 2023-04-02T18:23:13 | Cheng Deng, Bo Tong, Luoyi Fu, Jiaxin Ding, Dexing Cao, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; F.4.1 | In the research of end-to-end dialogue systems, using real-world knowledge to
generate natural, fluent, and human-like utterances with correct answers is
crucial. However, domain-specific conversational dialogue systems may be
incoherent and introduce erroneous external information to answer questions due
to the out-of-vocabulary issue or the wrong knowledge from the parameters of
the neural network. In this work, we propose PK-Chat, a Pointer network guided
Knowledge-driven generative dialogue model, incorporating a unified pretrained
language model and a pointer network over knowledge graphs. The words generated
by PK-Chat in the dialogue are derived from the prediction of word lists and
the direct prediction of the external knowledge graph knowledge. Moreover,
based on the PK-Chat, a dialogue system is built for academic scenarios in the
case of geosciences. Finally, an academic dialogue benchmark is constructed to
evaluate the quality of dialogue systems in academic scenarios and the source
code is available online. | [
0.0848885402,
0.0138152158,
-0.0065463283,
0.0437806025,
-0.0177451801,
-0.0149199236,
-0.0077850707,
-0.0122850724,
0.0479637049,
-0.0374476016,
-0.0125679187,
0.0095597953,
-0.0301913507,
0.058718197,
0.0291067325,
-0.0663328916,
0.0620212108,
-0.0216557663,
0.0387798436,
-0.0191621874,
-0.0036425493,
0.0082609486,
-0.0618524402,
0.0195586607,
0.0016177418,
-0.0189970043,
-0.0342200994,
0.0003109685,
-0.0043978151,
-0.0092896018,
0.0518760234,
0.0387115963,
0.0069533442,
0.0243508294,
0.0000019705,
-0.0321562067,
0.0339119136,
0.000451755,
-0.0218625199,
0.0030744872,
0.0074945684,
0.0562346354,
0.0050471234,
0.0131278578,
-0.0535520278,
-0.0244478639,
0.0506630801,
0.0641437843,
0.0669277832,
0.078804791,
-0.0003141713,
-0.0480489023,
0.0312148053,
-0.0159438364,
-0.011040221,
-0.0438864157,
0.0216813907,
0.0475551523,
-0.0009403407,
0.0498020947,
0.0016926605,
0.0230276175,
-0.005434576,
-0.0488615073,
0.04990701,
0.010566052,
-0.0139678903,
0.0088890065,
-0.0152780265,
0.1170353219,
0.0112073263,
-0.0139626088,
0.0280566253,
-0.0214168467,
0.0074502504,
-0.0125839533,
-0.0387749486,
-0.0079188673,
-0.0025410515,
-0.0267269742,
-0.0322219469,
0.0280091241,
-0.0088470271,
0.0077404291,
-0.0053462158,
0.0463311486,
0.003370496,
-0.0229761079,
-0.021248268,
-0.0252195112,
0.0300770886,
-0.0752486587,
-0.0028924949,
0.0431902669,
-0.0225233957,
0.0301539022,
-0.0202678367,
0.0015745581,
0.0208973847,
-0.081537962,
-0.0213272255,
0.0323988125,
-0.002973062,
0.0341472179,
0.0053797611,
0.047274325,
0.005085811,
0.0166397057,
0.0034964182,
-0.0136199556,
-0.0511084162,
-0.0107254786,
-0.0504403263,
-0.0079738982,
-0.0338459574,
-0.0451868176,
-0.0291850884,
0.0366391875,
0.0226011127,
0.0292434376,
0.0145454751,
0.0543164201,
-0.0201797113,
-0.0096817203,
-0.0533789583,
0.0464424752,
-0.0308602657,
0.0077816234,
0.0243151207,
-0.0327500068,
-0.0032965236,
0.0326019153,
0.018397294,
0.008602703,
-0.0241071302,
0.1067532673,
0.0082552023,
0.0117376838,
-0.0274873134,
-0.0427595042,
-0.0163571853,
-0.0489744991,
0.0052461624,
-0.0246137828,
0.0518028736,
-0.0003832307,
-0.0551794432,
-0.0537452772,
0.0302922223,
-0.0007365229,
-0.0298209973,
0.0493488945,
-0.064365156,
-0.0092755435,
0.0857921019,
0.0244363919,
-0.0035682882,
0.0216285456,
0.0331691615,
0.0105775679,
0.035194736,
-0.0056214817,
-0.0190814994,
-0.0087100491,
0.0352561697,
-0.0240039863,
0.0313728228,
0.0138438791,
-0.0220345836,
0.0640670061,
-0.0068768547,
0.0593928397,
-0.0662097111,
-0.0213927384,
0.0171131883,
0.0296296626,
-0.009138207,
0.0639776289,
0.054287117,
0.0532626994,
0.0182791501,
-0.0130727692,
0.0021620071,
0.0154627683,
-0.0216293819,
0.0039693671,
0.0441130474,
-0.0024625373,
-0.0284499954,
-0.051967714,
0.0095828641,
0.0065191281,
0.0072288946,
-0.0003784921,
0.0713063851,
0.0246354863,
-0.0857400298,
0.0390458517,
0.026300516,
-0.0514719263,
-0.0118697686,
-0.0144762592,
0.0250878241,
0.0533437543,
0.0481312051,
0.0035668346,
-0.0756736919,
-0.0203934927,
-0.035909757,
0.0588390864,
0.0546473116,
-0.0322567709,
-0.0192417353,
-0.07049077,
-0.0178356841,
-0.0350227877,
-0.0064648255,
0.0232736673,
0.0202366151,
0.0118784513,
0.057966888,
-0.0055253562,
-0.0136844497,
0.0003642886,
-0.018644657,
0.0160588156,
-0.005218375,
-0.030182343,
0.0095746955,
0.0334548168,
-0.0220482033,
0.0226225071,
0.0319509134,
0.0241946876,
-0.0179716181,
-0.0007469715,
-0.094770126,
-0.0823533013,
0.0274304468,
-0.0411182567,
0.030927062,
-0.0374589786,
-0.0430608429,
-0.0746502951,
0.0532307774,
-0.0443440638,
0.0724922866,
-0.0420834981,
-0.0157266948,
0.0292310063,
0.0127511891,
-0.0300043635,
0.0457545146,
0.0214643124,
0.0229812805,
0.0243952349,
0.0449140854,
0.0416107811,
-0.0834718049,
-0.0014739563,
-0.011066067,
0.0081048533,
-0.0125238048,
0.0124612218,
-0.0151313813,
-0.0685191751,
0.0021688815,
-0.1273761094,
-0.0122914566,
0.0121550057,
0.0025266239,
0.0102550806,
0.0182519369,
-0.001226175,
-0.0387498625,
-0.0662723929,
0.0514426492,
0.0426899083,
-0.0324155092,
0.0582860224,
0.004717363,
0.0090351906,
-0.0479908064,
-0.0003962372,
-0.0011754748,
0.0376470126,
0.0354877375,
-0.0436344817,
-0.038872391,
0.0533707216,
-0.0459756702,
0.0358062834,
-0.0216659661,
-0.0394708142,
-0.0196224079,
0.0036332547,
0.0316279605,
0.0196177494,
0.042065531,
-0.0001204323,
-0.0303879082,
-0.0511218905,
-0.0810912251,
0.0489228964,
-0.0292767137,
0.0083832582,
-0.0145133976,
0.0405618772,
0.019008141,
0.0012857878,
0.0400733799,
-0.0022489119,
-0.0126404837,
0.0338804387,
0.0335743651,
-0.0168689378,
0.0021207831,
-0.0210658275,
0.0082927058,
0.0089681661,
-0.0120341731,
0.0062618428,
0.0625359714,
-0.0266114138,
-0.0094305314,
-0.0207559504,
-0.0079923598,
-0.0261793192,
0.0159826446,
0.0058606626,
0.00359807,
0.0205367077,
-0.0099542541,
-0.0134394215,
-0.0168897677,
0.019465534,
-0.0277623702,
0.0070926715,
-0.0519022681,
0.0241803005,
0.0133162728,
-0.0091409776,
-0.0570235588,
0.0185382888,
-0.0055858921,
0.0186272115,
0.024785459,
-0.0422207303,
0.0282196887,
0.0387078971,
0.0111285476,
0.0282902624,
0.0034683479,
0.013045379,
-0.0136494944,
0.0467542894,
0.0256935805,
0.0198656358,
-0.0065205228,
0.0232246239,
0.0198207945,
0.0264575295,
-0.0165777039,
0.0016131345,
-0.0347633734,
-0.0360265449,
0.0003369156,
-0.0230258573,
-0.0225523207,
-0.0099680154,
0.0290755872,
-0.0485651977,
-0.0346677452,
0.1068674773,
0.0228338577,
-0.0317208171,
-0.024073014,
-0.0149059193,
0.0001505028,
-0.0075933617,
0.0585198365,
-0.0776243284,
-0.0061142216,
-0.0471901409,
-0.0104663074,
0.0033379139,
-0.0409305803,
-0.0026456597,
-0.0973021165,
0.0321470201,
0.004446751,
-0.0077837184,
-0.0295569971,
-0.0012148048,
-0.0105298739,
0.0181828793,
-0.0199095458,
-0.0069840481,
0.0434299037,
-0.0159481205,
0.0146699101,
-0.0096816728,
-0.0095501756,
0.0118630938,
0.0017239209,
0.086442098,
0.0801141858,
0.0693411604,
0.026643388,
-0.0218283907,
0.0031138319,
0.0132989613,
-0.0056728986,
0.0091745788,
0.0182105098,
0.0074600531,
-0.0136123206,
0.0028123653,
0.0153065939,
-0.047107093,
0.0004537189,
0.0254473407,
0.0355342552,
-0.0517295934,
0.0126383174,
-0.0275859646,
0.0532880686,
0.0567007922,
0.051598873,
0.0029273913,
0.0078461329,
-0.066879116,
-0.0384844206,
0.0026228677,
-0.0674090311,
0.0056014541,
-0.0138171231,
0.0090938397,
0.0090942215,
-0.0852890089,
-0.0256741773,
0.022797903,
-0.0016036989,
-0.0206379108,
-0.0147715295,
0.031095488,
0.0159453638,
-0.0156736448,
-0.0059003485,
-0.0152557427,
-0.0006811505,
-0.0479520708,
-0.0530930683,
0.0770264491,
-0.0149680041,
-0.0246577244,
0.055427812,
-0.0538034178,
-0.0705829784,
-0.0297000613,
0.0836690813,
0.0117817987,
0.0222476367,
-0.0389131606,
-0.0022186658,
0.0232695062,
0.0219327472,
-0.0474893786,
-0.0213987064,
0.0194432903,
0.0575009771,
-0.0080474457,
0.0152637279,
-0.0398905352,
0.024567984,
-0.0357430093,
0.0313874036,
-0.0417772196,
-0.1263470054,
-0.0399710797,
0.0018882297,
0.0346381254,
0.0281324722,
-0.0192110389,
-0.0320584849,
0.0131179877,
-0.0228411388,
-0.0173460264,
-0.0538516454,
0.0423482656,
-0.0158803184,
0.0023081724,
0.0064546466,
-0.0396346152,
-0.0298436284,
0.0221770685,
0.0076049566,
-0.0212248322,
0.0678838864,
-0.0289313719,
0.0242630001,
-0.0295960493,
-0.0449590459,
0.044801116,
0.0110549135,
0.0172127057,
-0.0225856788,
0.077935122,
0.0366858989,
-0.0111950962,
0.0287201572,
0.0050594937,
-0.0631831214,
-0.0483959094,
-0.0497239418,
0.0678412616,
0.0413476415,
0.061274875,
-0.0011890017,
-0.0357374288,
0.0149828279,
-0.0120761199,
0.0722869486,
-0.0061781341,
-0.062309619,
0.0592441559,
0.0092250993,
-0.0160945114,
-0.0085574565,
0.0472252034,
0.0295335427,
0.0272915717,
0.0085939318,
-0.0108981766,
-0.0433111899,
-0.0404039808,
-0.0093400488,
0.0356631391,
0.0142793022,
0.037151169,
-0.0069863219,
-0.0449376777,
0.0072978027,
0.0358631909,
0.0104670832,
-0.0068317559,
0.061656937,
0.0506990962,
0.006224636,
-0.0255597625,
-0.0430750996,
0.049293343,
-0.0408879966,
-0.0251220819,
-0.0510424972,
-5.897986335e-33,
-0.0617613792,
-0.04906369,
0.021523159,
0.0310521238,
-0.057270579,
-0.065657489,
-0.0434472822,
-0.0227315929,
-0.0271481387,
0.0070248651,
-0.015044095,
0.0268869102,
-0.0009816601,
0.0534977242,
-0.0016215802,
0.0116684698,
0.0368180871,
0.008184799,
0.0394170471,
0.0863474384,
0.0418400541,
0.0303613413,
0.0350672677,
-0.0424018055,
0.0165083278,
-0.0466045924,
0.0318503603,
0.0161051136,
-0.0178228579,
0.0304836016,
-0.0385032669,
0.0570516139,
-0.0057318029,
-0.0124362474,
-0.02413732,
-0.0053704488,
-0.075542219,
-0.0543269925,
0.0161555018,
-0.0072591482,
-0.026921669,
-0.0083744926,
0.0187674388,
-0.0321450196,
0.04043689,
0.0089383554,
0.0440525562,
0.0034539117,
-0.0411257446,
-0.0469741784,
-0.0526300259,
0.0251455735,
-0.0140122967,
-0.0268383957,
-0.053970933,
0.0436293222,
0.0139008546,
-0.0759682581,
-0.0266488958,
0.0376274064,
0.0418177806,
-0.0055573485,
0.0194668099,
0.0529288314,
0.0160927437,
0.0367862694,
-0.0063506481,
0.0071368027,
-0.0379449576,
-0.0111048613,
-0.0318034366,
0.0457133763,
0.0150820827,
0.0563581102,
-0.026743535,
-0.0273106787,
-0.061152678,
-0.0150782885,
0.0234369002,
0.0207958724,
-0.018442113,
-0.0063168681,
0.0061427858,
-0.033239428,
-0.0320490897,
-0.0002490645,
0.0073161288,
-0.0507070757,
0.0247472636,
-0.0143994344,
0.0076782829,
-0.0121840639,
0.0054333718,
-0.0735026598,
0.0098815486,
0.0686444491,
-0.0195785314,
-0.0110384896,
-0.0208053011,
0.0119765289,
-0.0972302556,
-0.0216100756,
0.0225068647,
0.0266113486,
-0.0061632646,
0.0453604832,
-0.0205227043,
-0.0359965302,
-0.0003720662,
-0.0063355062,
-0.0466849767,
0.0222074855,
-0.0247639585,
0.0148915052,
-0.0278857239,
0.0226098672,
-0.046943523,
0.0414742231,
-0.0151082426,
0.0220154356,
-0.0006102108,
-0.0378927588,
0.0275233202,
0.0229300596,
-0.0539889485,
0.0031294769,
-0.0028360991,
0.0173288267,
-0.0245699156,
-0.0323838145,
0.0091357315,
0.0204243809,
2.707e-7,
0.008184758,
0.0279363357,
0.0790374726,
0.0259129647,
0.0086545534,
0.0019616501,
0.0322715566,
0.0318474136,
0.0187286977,
-0.0076278518,
0.0103793321,
0.0245760605,
0.0115721747,
0.0107905064,
-0.1428038776,
-0.0218857788,
-0.0457991064,
-0.0499631874,
-0.0387286134,
-0.0139807221,
0.0922540426,
-0.0050863321,
0.0202269461,
0.0220519789,
-0.0145991901,
-0.0200323984,
0.0553916954,
-0.0038264079,
-0.0231417716,
0.0573678203,
0.0993405581,
0.0050729373,
-0.0264692027,
0.0430017598,
0.0065999236,
0.0259768236,
0.0238780864,
0.032640066,
0.0000914442,
-0.049631726,
-0.0038128213,
-0.0320783295,
0.0268004313,
-0.0275685173,
0.0103738392,
-0.0636002868,
0.0245634746,
-0.0068021864,
-0.0142764207,
-0.008798019,
0.01153332,
-0.0425834507,
-0.0048129987,
-0.0152812842,
0.0214266721,
-0.0225496236,
0.0257852599,
-0.081284672,
0.0239985771,
0.0064885621,
-0.0506684184,
-0.04209131,
-0.0232487042,
-0.0560257696,
0.0216826033,
0.0093300017,
0.0092620905,
1.843685173e-34,
0.0440943129,
0.0076142875,
-0.0209189728,
-0.0020931803,
0.0396953896,
0.0050793123,
0.0741657615,
0.0160527695,
0.0441013314,
-0.0784064457,
-0.0281703975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00557v1 | Semi-supervised Neural Machine Translation with Consistency Regularization for Low-Resource Languages | 2023-04-02T15:24:08 | 2023-04-02T15:24:08 | Viet H. Pham, Thang M. Pham, Giang Nguyen, Long Nguyen, Dien Dinh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The advent of deep learning has led to a significant gain in machine
translation. However, most of the studies required a large parallel dataset
which is scarce and expensive to construct and even unavailable for some
languages. This paper presents a simple yet effective method to tackle this
problem for low-resource languages by augmenting high-quality sentence pairs
and training NMT models in a semi-supervised manner. Specifically, our approach
combines the cross-entropy loss for supervised learning with KL Divergence for
unsupervised fashion given pseudo and augmented target sentences derived from
the model. We also introduce a SentenceBERT-based filter to enhance the quality
of augmenting data by retaining semantically similar sentence pairs.
Experimental results show that our approach significantly improves NMT
baselines, especially on low-resource datasets with 0.46--2.03 BLEU scores. We
also demonstrate that using unsupervised training for augmented data is more
efficient than reusing the ground-truth target sentences for supervised
learning. | [
0.0219143704,
0.0840462297,
0.0198143981,
0.024532415,
-0.0325122513,
0.0020056039,
-0.0124859205,
-0.0160710718,
-0.0388977863,
-0.0053359494,
-0.0226585008,
-0.0184596796,
-0.0022288249,
-0.037343964,
0.0605458394,
-0.0608935319,
0.0094566196,
0.0309086721,
-0.0556134731,
-0.0249035619,
0.0210725572,
0.0185075048,
0.0140050398,
-0.0191747304,
-0.0187281854,
0.0083297687,
-0.0270872768,
0.0392835923,
0.056831833,
-0.0024737462,
-0.0133986576,
0.0267546792,
0.009043688,
0.0329261348,
0.000002093,
-0.0512075722,
-0.038990628,
-0.0076374533,
0.0044692946,
0.0095068188,
0.0028413918,
-0.0874304697,
-0.0203245301,
0.0198298525,
0.006240759,
-0.0265083332,
0.0651798397,
0.0353268348,
0.0902768821,
0.0895056948,
-0.0126717696,
-0.0001712794,
0.015933957,
-0.0592090078,
0.0129248574,
-0.0474982113,
-0.0135765402,
0.0258966405,
-0.03110772,
-0.0043187835,
0.024642745,
0.0585516691,
0.0543364771,
-0.0163129773,
-0.0108337067,
0.0068032816,
-0.0393768698,
-0.0034725436,
-0.0062699951,
0.0630630255,
-0.0341916122,
-0.0263638403,
0.0022593681,
-0.0293706823,
-0.0306869112,
-0.0343808345,
-0.0300431605,
-0.0140228821,
0.0287085045,
0.0004196418,
0.0140164765,
0.0104477387,
0.0577283204,
-0.0041920529,
-0.0332395621,
-0.0131179262,
0.038617745,
-0.067279622,
-0.0159756672,
0.0204202421,
-0.0351089165,
0.0081687458,
0.0155711854,
-0.0148009164,
0.0237993356,
0.0207585897,
-0.0408692025,
-0.0839225054,
-0.0154718058,
-0.0337020271,
0.0176311024,
0.0437996387,
-0.0195442755,
0.0442493632,
-0.0144278603,
0.0174297653,
-0.0219147,
0.0310621336,
-0.0666517317,
-0.0249228403,
-0.0312442817,
0.0111452127,
-0.0439007469,
0.0130177885,
0.0051093437,
0.035610456,
-0.0219771899,
0.013327715,
-0.0089784395,
0.0120552499,
0.0519728661,
-0.0299643818,
-0.0802328736,
-0.0368304439,
0.0273462199,
0.0595468096,
-0.0011483863,
-0.0173690394,
0.022822015,
-0.0562511533,
-0.02935284,
0.0031470503,
0.0377293117,
-0.0614068545,
0.0009602337,
0.0600631721,
-0.0144916279,
-0.0480382144,
-0.0647559166,
0.0126114879,
-0.032920856,
-0.0859170258,
-0.0192696396,
-0.0474466309,
0.0693927407,
-0.0297859125,
0.0271960907,
-0.0132419793,
-0.0099318428,
-0.0038133108,
0.0094863875,
0.0689078569,
-0.0327858515,
-0.0401471891,
0.0087616537,
-0.0160600469,
0.0497716703,
0.0696132556,
0.0411567427,
-0.0240610857,
-0.0139238238,
0.0019963586,
-0.0765191838,
0.0535359457,
0.0398864597,
0.0394701697,
-0.0571365692,
-0.0111370599,
-0.017148912,
0.0347953923,
0.0287189148,
0.0680754185,
-0.0329612456,
0.0434053428,
0.0655854791,
-0.0207199156,
0.0311374273,
0.0470638946,
0.0552708209,
0.0151369749,
-0.0365965404,
0.0294997413,
-0.0168648567,
0.0119841574,
0.0046426733,
0.0115362564,
0.0662617236,
0.0306250229,
-0.0439664386,
-0.0481518358,
0.0145958243,
-0.0390845612,
-0.006562029,
-0.0078048529,
0.0468343794,
0.0272075199,
-0.0216735713,
0.0182143282,
0.0119537078,
-0.0651741922,
0.0405498259,
0.0158105548,
-0.0223236289,
0.0735598207,
0.0369810015,
0.0021907981,
-0.0296999887,
-0.0320857055,
-0.0227456056,
0.049697727,
0.0467696264,
0.036661543,
0.0532952361,
-0.0593411624,
-0.0164472833,
-0.0122922547,
0.0150071923,
0.0395427272,
-0.027101472,
0.0476060808,
0.0704715475,
-0.0654096752,
-0.0092237843,
0.0232187267,
-0.0266579129,
-0.0180715863,
0.0236098208,
0.0490713082,
0.0333697684,
0.0468169041,
-0.0299401339,
-0.0018440798,
0.0206246376,
-0.0502278358,
-0.0464240648,
0.0076895682,
-0.0601682588,
-0.080399245,
0.0322349593,
-0.0317396671,
-0.0206764489,
0.0607909039,
-0.0116931414,
-0.0761401057,
-0.0210398305,
-0.0366829783,
0.0545404479,
-0.0802441463,
0.0183447488,
0.0392637774,
-0.0118981414,
-0.0436737314,
0.0279501565,
-0.0082565947,
0.0121395607,
-0.0481051765,
-0.0586557612,
0.0240562577,
-0.0398507491,
-0.0219784155,
0.019941004,
0.0123826098,
0.0722131282,
0.070648469,
0.0421280973,
-0.0046129585,
0.0004872055,
-0.046418976,
0.0009434439,
-0.0480441153,
0.0112354746,
0.0200149361,
0.1048441231,
0.0089801634,
-0.0020262171,
0.0010469524,
-0.0037012254,
0.0088975886,
-0.0020484673,
-0.0039710687,
0.0322048217,
0.0239180513,
-0.007055026,
-0.0113401646,
0.0137818856,
0.0113098491,
-0.0153060174,
-0.0159799252,
-0.0594090745,
0.0501250513,
-0.045564279,
0.0148487734,
0.0139714219,
-0.0484687202,
-0.0082743447,
-0.0360325761,
0.0292931981,
-0.0019227735,
-0.0125450538,
-0.0293093324,
0.0341029018,
0.0402126722,
-0.0706535727,
0.035910327,
-0.0128826788,
-0.0361532569,
-0.0156684406,
-0.0217570085,
-0.0101678856,
0.0503239147,
-0.0257809423,
-0.0102255642,
-0.0700410232,
-0.0289557241,
0.0199879929,
-0.0509428568,
-0.0128140207,
0.0423824079,
0.0085521322,
0.0175580643,
-0.0107457507,
-0.0335446484,
0.0693710819,
-0.0456017256,
-0.0043016663,
-0.068091318,
-0.0449534245,
-0.0135336453,
0.0287070591,
0.011587088,
0.0247697197,
-0.0219258517,
-0.002420764,
-0.0296122245,
0.0019586724,
0.0264071599,
0.0546893887,
0.0335961096,
-0.0229766984,
0.0038355032,
-0.0190022253,
-0.0208875649,
-0.0272311568,
-0.0346071906,
-0.0252410714,
-0.035104569,
-0.0077944119,
-0.0025088049,
-0.014461942,
0.0061647794,
0.000150314,
0.0855616927,
0.0172017626,
0.0092204716,
-0.0439088047,
0.0194969885,
0.0484790839,
-0.0023662094,
-0.0246238858,
-0.0436705016,
0.0265624393,
0.0078391302,
0.0329936072,
-0.0264198277,
-0.0463962667,
-0.0348315202,
-0.0024296062,
0.0145372935,
0.0071336143,
0.0125496257,
0.0305588432,
-0.0336478688,
-0.0143156257,
0.0855799019,
0.008875113,
-0.0276992749,
-0.0105109448,
-0.0105145993,
0.0795357525,
-0.000805189,
0.008601849,
-0.0671286583,
-0.0439639091,
-0.0051253862,
0.0445476063,
0.0203322247,
0.0224639047,
-0.0452813096,
-0.0975019932,
-0.0141414348,
0.0437034629,
-0.0754888505,
-0.0257313997,
-0.0264208671,
-0.0258451253,
-0.0394250825,
0.0428685695,
-0.0227324087,
0.0289493985,
-0.0206175726,
0.0139242318,
0.028463522,
-0.080527097,
-0.0422681235,
-0.0586049967,
0.0096123582,
0.055023957,
0.007167425,
-0.0139771663,
-0.0037785103,
0.0565756783,
-0.03801772,
-0.0096072415,
0.0100630047,
0.0227504447,
-0.031564448,
-0.036004819,
0.0344329365,
0.0232131705,
0.0008133237,
0.0259356629,
0.021909602,
0.0644656494,
-0.0151125286,
0.0053539313,
0.024321042,
-0.046902284,
-0.020660622,
0.0598988011,
0.0126199471,
-0.0577060319,
0.003922401,
0.024648834,
0.0122479163,
-0.0569565371,
0.0291382484,
-0.005774328,
-0.0428641774,
-0.0418415815,
-0.0625454411,
-0.0854238346,
-0.0109600741,
0.0329863578,
-0.015278874,
0.0283824373,
0.0386140682,
-0.0191878397,
-0.0566978641,
0.0478446782,
-0.058499638,
-0.0048114266,
-0.0163360834,
-0.004070078,
0.0006251476,
-0.0263518412,
0.013493686,
-0.0019200982,
-0.1046497449,
-0.0696586147,
-0.0357955731,
0.0522007272,
0.0109472647,
0.086857304,
-0.0168318693,
-0.0080475369,
0.0046265665,
0.064408876,
-0.0297539942,
-0.0126553606,
0.0194667596,
-0.0332996584,
0.0031723166,
0.0378115736,
-0.0368721895,
-0.0142685147,
-0.0033523708,
0.062810488,
-0.0137300761,
-0.0355651528,
0.0539061055,
0.0079804268,
0.0688742623,
-0.0269391201,
0.0034678115,
-0.0223501939,
0.0311705731,
-0.0040513645,
-0.0028818415,
-0.0498101264,
-0.0238063335,
0.0352958068,
0.0243215784,
-0.0039969468,
0.0149165411,
-0.0265223309,
0.0339899622,
-0.0202190056,
-0.0183533262,
-0.0381935239,
0.0168496519,
0.0068081548,
0.0017512124,
0.0055847135,
0.0237206854,
0.0029066443,
0.0095595103,
-0.0373355858,
-0.007907276,
0.0239955075,
0.0083450731,
0.0151396645,
0.0441847034,
-0.0512345806,
-0.0025774334,
-0.0373435207,
0.0188028701,
0.0924329013,
-0.0224233661,
0.0962212384,
-0.0231761578,
0.0030992567,
-0.0283560958,
0.0318982564,
0.0116798608,
-0.0241071433,
0.0043432796,
0.0168925077,
0.0020798945,
0.0514593869,
0.044156611,
0.00405424,
0.0253056306,
-0.0040470306,
0.0205134638,
-0.0463133119,
-0.012084242,
0.0153631214,
0.0299472213,
-0.0144785726,
-0.0005240269,
0.025869472,
-0.0837342441,
-0.0009900292,
0.0032482748,
-0.0213374849,
-0.0006313805,
0.0541119911,
0.0457537882,
-0.0748197138,
0.0144922202,
-0.0074005709,
0.0050151544,
0.0156963263,
-0.0351751409,
0.0076234043,
-6.717087696e-33,
-0.0069751889,
0.0424274504,
0.0206754189,
-0.0562807582,
-0.0353893116,
0.0046079764,
-0.016898144,
-0.0180982687,
-0.002775633,
0.0117070386,
0.0130670751,
0.0201552697,
0.0235206652,
0.0372374542,
-0.0140756164,
0.0077127079,
0.0659973696,
0.043175187,
0.0213629082,
0.0049160975,
-0.0077631087,
0.0349825025,
0.0904931277,
-0.052637253,
0.0181707609,
-0.022579493,
-0.0026176739,
0.0017462383,
0.0163050257,
0.0096115759,
-0.0071937279,
0.0318270139,
0.0131406235,
-0.0432673767,
-0.0192476176,
-0.0431075394,
-0.073926717,
-0.0048738578,
0.0059502139,
0.0281803459,
-0.0713898316,
-0.0297303107,
0.0296410918,
-0.0427783802,
0.0185685437,
0.007508025,
0.0180902407,
-0.0189249273,
-0.0231488757,
-0.0056873956,
-0.0209795125,
0.0318973884,
-0.025499396,
0.0004597637,
0.0103167165,
0.0632513538,
-0.0112332469,
-0.0160296783,
-0.0618554205,
0.0064625065,
-0.0063950014,
0.061004255,
0.068048358,
-0.0000726412,
-0.0333644859,
0.015105621,
0.0136517743,
-0.0169009622,
0.0441470332,
0.0245183166,
0.0298996735,
-0.0081991926,
0.0458846614,
0.0567172803,
0.0547719933,
-0.0009367212,
-0.06572593,
0.0484352708,
-0.0175092537,
0.02674013,
-0.0031256734,
0.0477344133,
-0.0204486903,
-0.0029462217,
-0.0333530009,
-0.0465239063,
-0.0226623658,
-0.015776068,
0.0144454911,
0.0224373005,
-0.023126198,
0.0045918012,
0.0650880113,
-0.0136055117,
0.0075991242,
0.010907962,
-0.0246586315,
-0.0130946953,
-0.012621616,
0.052037444,
-0.0149298953,
-0.0359194502,
0.0115661751,
0.0410809219,
0.0009909144,
0.0014143263,
0.0758084878,
0.010413548,
-0.0277736522,
0.002599587,
-0.0457586385,
-0.0218773559,
-0.0577946901,
0.0050852615,
0.0350821726,
0.0024481893,
-0.0058846842,
0.0585837066,
0.0546593256,
-0.0216276962,
-0.0019143776,
0.0289205909,
0.0261198226,
0.0341178253,
-0.0029853936,
0.0063738707,
-0.0218024068,
-0.0422823578,
0.0119047826,
-0.067347236,
0.0016922336,
-0.0176606979,
2.854e-7,
-0.008675429,
0.0136821605,
0.0388387479,
-0.0227780826,
0.0030275348,
0.0299139414,
-0.0402113944,
0.0375709049,
-0.0417662151,
0.0008903077,
0.0460352041,
0.0160518698,
0.0639852583,
-0.0034961053,
-0.100969024,
0.0017467468,
-0.0456051901,
0.0074085719,
-0.0573472567,
0.0112775676,
0.0700065643,
0.1161127314,
0.0006636465,
-0.0021780594,
0.0322588719,
-0.0451160334,
0.0579961948,
0.0027735515,
-0.0370690934,
-0.0049086818,
0.0625388995,
0.0465245545,
-0.0245692562,
-0.0118376594,
-0.0408166312,
0.0162570234,
0.0418112874,
0.0440828875,
-0.0029787759,
-0.0069386843,
0.0330629051,
0.0304233711,
-0.0349533781,
-0.0076604756,
0.0474218242,
-0.0234668385,
-0.0096878493,
0.0409859978,
-0.0381722189,
0.0177859385,
0.0641732365,
-0.0061156768,
-0.0404547043,
-0.0015457305,
0.0707195252,
-0.0103206355,
-0.0571886525,
-0.0406318828,
-0.0318762176,
0.023675289,
-0.0274222288,
-0.0288893525,
-0.041810412,
0.021169465,
0.0632517338,
-0.0192040093,
-0.0199979842,
2.536234443e-34,
0.0524174422,
-0.0057656732,
0.0228144675,
-0.0484062433,
0.0013414321,
-0.0314950421,
-0.040095441,
0.0130972266,
-0.0182127599,
-0.042792391,
-0.0171454865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01228v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01228v2 | Better Language Models of Code through Self-Improvement | 2023-04-02T10:59:19 | 2023-05-10T02:36:40 | Hung Quoc To, Nghi D. Q. Bui, Jin Guo, Tien N. Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models for code (PLMCs) have gained attention in recent
research. These models are pre-trained on large-scale datasets using
multi-modal objectives. However, fine-tuning them requires extensive
supervision and is limited by the size of the dataset provided. We aim to
improve this issue by proposing a simple data augmentation framework. Our
framework utilizes knowledge gained during the pre-training and fine-tuning
stage to generate pseudo data, which is then used as training data for the next
step. We incorporate this framework into the state-of-the-art language models,
such as CodeT5, CodeBERT, and UnixCoder. The results show that our framework
significantly improves PLMCs' performance in code-related sequence generation
tasks, such as code summarization and code generation in the CodeXGLUE
benchmark. | [
0.017309729,
0.1035936326,
-0.0105990348,
-0.0096009346,
0.0164263714,
0.0042548911,
-0.0297225751,
-0.0316187739,
-0.0197161585,
-0.0112178233,
-0.0154097192,
0.0247833971,
-0.002000157,
0.0451124944,
0.0838621557,
-0.0227120388,
0.0393757671,
-0.0469123758,
-0.0336632691,
0.0047184634,
0.0099560926,
0.0199568551,
0.024303982,
0.0369260572,
0.0394778512,
-0.0136273326,
-0.0266391579,
0.0012490168,
-0.0124039026,
-0.0326685905,
0.0236578342,
0.0664008185,
0.0155302854,
0.015009989,
0.0000021332,
-0.0183126982,
-0.0270410832,
-0.0146037294,
0.0220230408,
0.0527975224,
0.0101439217,
-0.045408491,
0.0094307344,
0.0281013548,
-0.0527628958,
-0.0546678044,
0.0366221815,
-0.046792116,
0.0927391574,
0.0886314511,
0.001398314,
-0.0177300293,
0.0198267661,
-0.028716024,
0.0164489672,
0.0024781339,
-0.0019363916,
0.0688521639,
0.012667764,
0.0176173914,
0.0083032586,
0.0140164662,
0.0300458036,
-0.0116202515,
0.0192145426,
0.0408965759,
-0.0368564427,
0.0096670641,
0.000823518,
0.0297622662,
-0.0538259037,
-0.0660402849,
0.0051729139,
-0.0268389452,
-0.0149749024,
-0.0733759925,
-0.0231840909,
0.0259419829,
0.0196831878,
0.0142946374,
0.0094626518,
-0.0240023714,
0.019550126,
0.0016909296,
-0.0415449478,
0.0160851572,
0.0189428944,
-0.0098347329,
-0.0401992984,
-0.0153096626,
0.0001609014,
-0.0766834468,
-0.0178130511,
0.0704507753,
-0.0035565009,
-0.011723143,
-0.0713788718,
-0.0273726024,
0.0300000589,
-0.0180690419,
0.0462886654,
0.0449262485,
-0.0292726271,
-0.004680261,
-0.0587138459,
0.0382781141,
0.0127717461,
0.0204184484,
-0.0491414033,
0.0239618327,
-0.0517239086,
0.0105395708,
-0.0489634424,
0.0448438115,
-0.0091075376,
0.0373462066,
-0.0338770598,
0.0562633201,
0.0291342605,
0.0257544909,
0.0009519481,
-0.0321644545,
-0.0428085476,
0.0039292364,
0.0442566946,
-0.0198402535,
-0.0179057047,
-0.0357042812,
-0.0069807423,
-0.0578231923,
-0.0189275686,
0.0226404052,
-0.0139676929,
-0.0155617706,
0.0165626407,
0.0435455069,
-0.0006357965,
-0.0005717227,
-0.0420489684,
-0.0241437051,
0.0001823995,
-0.0200150535,
-0.0335176103,
-0.0948274136,
-0.0484492593,
0.007785744,
-0.0110653341,
-0.0564866811,
-0.0055763074,
-0.0154726962,
0.0364342369,
0.0288398918,
-0.1003714353,
0.0008809241,
0.0015275363,
-0.0065417052,
0.0071003139,
0.0295316689,
0.0544467419,
0.0086626317,
-0.017976474,
-0.0580804944,
0.0314488932,
0.0498277582,
0.0191410463,
0.0028386144,
-0.0059269741,
0.0371066481,
-0.0000235905,
-0.0316957831,
0.0601084158,
0.0257577393,
-0.012631801,
0.0395487882,
0.0067085307,
-0.0073949187,
0.0495546535,
0.0347711407,
0.0739648789,
0.0273019373,
0.0237640031,
-0.0061434018,
-0.0145146027,
0.0439664833,
-0.0209986847,
0.0625496879,
0.0276714638,
0.0293764602,
-0.0119275358,
-0.079652518,
0.0068202368,
-0.0220776293,
0.0177696869,
-0.009277733,
0.019088082,
0.0135705853,
-0.0470492467,
-0.0162268505,
0.0183131155,
-0.0907988995,
-0.0054976111,
-0.0301162209,
0.0042386283,
0.0428077988,
0.066141516,
-0.0563674681,
-0.0374363065,
-0.046873346,
0.0062306048,
-0.0263566207,
0.035434559,
-0.0032380158,
0.0197451208,
-0.0560263805,
-0.0258957725,
-0.0626880154,
-0.0035311857,
0.0454306938,
0.0211949963,
-0.0431893319,
0.0583232082,
0.0053093564,
-0.0739807561,
0.048293069,
-0.022824958,
-0.0016764862,
-0.001986342,
-0.0242586248,
0.0183559321,
-0.0227167569,
-0.0592993051,
0.0305059478,
0.0315499343,
-0.0002700392,
0.001478086,
-0.0222832598,
-0.0369579233,
-0.0461431444,
0.061089322,
-0.0310778785,
-0.0115267718,
0.0132311573,
-0.0251070671,
-0.0414622724,
0.0454387851,
-0.0406734534,
0.036013443,
-0.0430677012,
0.0123617155,
-0.0087119853,
-0.0098694945,
-0.0021262784,
0.0446446463,
-0.0007060833,
0.0289610904,
0.0089832675,
0.0970183909,
0.0217150673,
0.0122543816,
-0.0012627636,
-0.0192114376,
-0.027774591,
0.0412151814,
0.0243739206,
0.0681924224,
-0.0308443941,
-0.0350183845,
-0.1103583351,
0.0146711264,
-0.0244832113,
0.0096499519,
0.0155866565,
0.0320107974,
-0.0019217365,
-0.0100198593,
-0.0323485099,
-0.0308253318,
-0.0087834829,
-0.0166219771,
0.0239423066,
-0.0027361375,
-0.0461363047,
-0.0651434585,
-0.0011175696,
-0.0172715541,
0.0204825345,
-0.0240528472,
0.0041419771,
-0.0394159444,
0.0814852268,
-0.0179419499,
0.0274488255,
-0.0127655528,
-0.0757194906,
0.0072266646,
-0.0637267753,
0.0813325271,
0.005176269,
0.0214949045,
-0.0224941298,
0.0592186525,
0.0065578874,
-0.0378182158,
0.0071486174,
0.0235937275,
-0.0488232709,
-0.0094970204,
-0.0291255899,
0.0425204709,
0.0724754557,
-0.0107829357,
-0.0020103126,
-0.0517005399,
0.0150125707,
0.024231961,
-0.0109598087,
0.0151620172,
-0.0276691113,
-0.0062057828,
0.0458553247,
-0.0344350412,
-0.0820315033,
0.0596738756,
-0.0588260405,
-0.0284532383,
-0.0213823877,
-0.0310278349,
-0.067554906,
0.0403577276,
0.042584911,
0.0284004193,
0.0199300926,
-0.0189209916,
-0.0247226413,
0.0084814234,
-0.0063461806,
-0.0227379408,
0.0419632383,
-0.0491173714,
0.0372072011,
-0.0023764384,
-0.0049152034,
-0.0378737785,
-0.020425057,
-0.0059018694,
-0.0229315553,
0.0351630151,
0.0090632774,
0.0516605042,
0.0127723403,
0.0043524154,
0.0887553841,
0.0161155183,
-0.0319757909,
-0.0194793977,
-0.021158373,
-0.0190895572,
-0.0422516912,
-0.0235491581,
-0.0288262181,
-0.0238397662,
-0.0177408755,
0.0472930372,
0.0492567532,
-0.0827971548,
0.0210248288,
0.019809939,
-0.002866179,
-0.0195047446,
0.0468578711,
0.066124998,
-0.0090525514,
-0.0356212296,
0.1308722943,
0.0232978985,
-0.0386943407,
0.0132371932,
0.013951649,
0.0615026914,
0.060130585,
0.026392743,
-0.0421535373,
-0.0248886421,
-0.0179534629,
0.032573618,
-0.0188692082,
0.0031430877,
-0.041422274,
-0.0881527141,
0.0002732014,
0.041070994,
-0.0578174554,
-0.0190125071,
-0.0176721364,
-0.0387752615,
-0.0005277153,
-0.0347090177,
0.0245898366,
-0.027369665,
0.0347531065,
0.0361190662,
-0.0419204757,
-0.0289709233,
-0.0258266181,
-0.0290934108,
0.0561996512,
0.1107600704,
-0.0111704068,
0.0113833966,
0.0237308443,
0.0417015515,
-0.0070849201,
0.0205805656,
-0.0243147388,
0.0413311794,
-0.0078127757,
-0.0122640952,
0.0422435962,
0.0299324654,
-0.053755451,
0.0009758009,
0.0276949387,
0.0099325264,
-0.0040519712,
-0.0009385715,
-0.006942675,
0.0006311479,
-0.0272567403,
0.0213359687,
0.0631871596,
-0.0121954922,
0.0011789545,
-0.0657780617,
0.0092822369,
-0.0659835264,
0.0097859558,
-0.0151848141,
0.0145424698,
-0.0123765999,
-0.0413384065,
-0.0391719788,
0.026228644,
0.0423258804,
0.0122750178,
-0.0106174853,
-0.0099425288,
-0.0169786941,
-0.0844539106,
0.0076989913,
-0.0319657028,
-0.0124635147,
-0.0504233427,
-0.0614276454,
0.0281572174,
-0.0268358644,
-0.0071946946,
-0.0005216451,
-0.1140846387,
-0.0634267777,
-0.0279610995,
0.1121349707,
0.0207062606,
0.0492637642,
-0.0246613845,
-0.0525411703,
-0.028187491,
0.0341709033,
-0.0665421486,
0.0123131601,
0.0547958836,
-0.0358759649,
0.0123236012,
-0.0072428542,
-0.0384823121,
0.0174924079,
0.0062653264,
-0.0076188571,
-0.0171331428,
-0.0166429263,
0.0622641258,
0.0236604363,
-0.004447612,
0.0110583045,
-0.0143872052,
-0.0005098013,
-0.0139677823,
-0.0147690978,
-0.0141156241,
-0.0475950204,
0.0301003866,
0.0171736199,
0.0006751629,
0.0296835285,
0.0167334769,
-0.0608539321,
0.020494245,
-0.0199361797,
0.0415430777,
-0.0035345186,
0.0492945984,
0.0483204201,
-0.0030396155,
-0.01584512,
0.0267387833,
0.0004416614,
-0.0066876402,
-0.0206864364,
0.027901968,
0.0169788338,
0.0462292545,
0.0219133254,
0.0308271199,
-0.0769233555,
-0.0338805616,
-0.0471662357,
0.0012727696,
0.0442213751,
0.0376712494,
0.0697997957,
-0.00011253,
0.0319425724,
-0.0226123892,
0.0752764121,
-0.0036382396,
-0.038748242,
-0.0121277217,
0.0358714871,
-0.0227251612,
-0.0319940113,
0.1082200706,
0.0062758424,
0.0110467542,
-0.0025453703,
0.0162398759,
-0.0553628989,
0.01935721,
0.0389436446,
0.0176996775,
-0.0332832374,
-0.0118628647,
0.0006134662,
-0.0512939468,
-0.0139920153,
0.0545887724,
0.0301730819,
-0.0009978823,
0.0485537723,
0.0639173016,
-0.028379783,
0.0063489373,
-0.0277009681,
0.0224516001,
0.0408531688,
-0.0524799377,
0.0015365221,
-5.863222926e-33,
-0.0294020344,
0.0054001743,
0.0139272381,
0.0134446016,
-0.0021266511,
0.0092668645,
-0.066082865,
0.0054746354,
0.0212319158,
-0.0541265272,
0.0275228024,
0.0301018693,
-0.0192879122,
-0.0103087388,
0.0380543135,
0.0422898158,
0.0697111338,
0.0426918939,
-0.0577612706,
0.0353337638,
-0.0755472109,
0.0334659293,
0.014775916,
-0.0205953289,
-0.0071134176,
-0.0272637419,
-0.001871995,
-0.0309611782,
0.050398428,
0.0414894223,
0.0102083394,
-0.00125393,
-0.0097189089,
-0.0079777911,
-0.0601132996,
-0.0519459434,
-0.0252776481,
-0.0182342827,
0.0145928003,
0.0010260199,
-0.009300895,
-0.0731677264,
0.0490643643,
-0.029886255,
-0.0212595835,
0.0148039926,
0.0247040577,
-0.0082449224,
-0.0103822947,
-0.0315877981,
-0.0487965755,
0.0445333123,
-0.0679647997,
-0.0165129509,
0.0260860343,
0.0109811593,
-0.000440823,
0.0497987419,
0.022556657,
0.0214226004,
0.0542435795,
0.070673652,
0.0657886341,
-0.0021237086,
0.0109793302,
0.017726101,
0.0553587526,
0.0164987501,
-0.0019853802,
0.0495281294,
0.0625829622,
0.0141503764,
0.0187904686,
0.0194003284,
0.0166471992,
-0.0005489284,
-0.0219275095,
0.0453206114,
-0.0181599073,
-0.0145312762,
-0.0084721297,
0.0448042974,
-0.0077016358,
0.0040383427,
-0.0516028851,
-0.0311834477,
-0.008544853,
-0.054429464,
0.0309529994,
0.0191771258,
-0.0421298668,
-0.0103672314,
0.0194511022,
-0.0184374992,
0.0048143924,
0.0272418782,
-0.0553129092,
0.0386533774,
-0.0171812419,
0.0442164317,
-0.01723364,
-0.0200518928,
0.0616559014,
-0.0129689919,
0.0629525632,
0.0059561441,
0.0244610887,
0.020505216,
-0.0594535731,
-0.0060209422,
-0.0363648385,
-0.0087338332,
-0.0232222192,
0.0176672712,
-0.0004585214,
-0.0056405119,
0.0100151915,
0.0311524961,
0.0004665356,
-0.0492186993,
-0.073116146,
-0.0126906252,
0.0279113892,
0.0414709523,
-0.008004006,
-0.0279253852,
-0.041834563,
0.0281231999,
0.030950794,
-0.0353438519,
-0.0615076609,
0.0098197199,
2.731e-7,
0.024839513,
0.0333808213,
0.0413721949,
0.0300026927,
-0.0099419439,
0.0295550581,
-0.0471946895,
0.0125514138,
0.0170872677,
-0.0105728637,
-0.0064799068,
0.0274052918,
0.0225253589,
0.0185661931,
-0.0004379815,
0.0117509011,
-0.0019919162,
0.0126113426,
-0.0584430806,
-0.0142968893,
0.0330347084,
0.0834338591,
-0.0186937675,
0.0073798164,
0.0149185024,
-0.0221777465,
0.0193584766,
-0.0083911726,
-0.0280852374,
0.0431809947,
-0.0395984724,
0.0525557473,
-0.0389942564,
-0.0396077856,
-0.0289029703,
-0.0295436345,
0.0149616655,
0.046758838,
-0.011364785,
0.064106226,
0.0505887046,
0.0041125342,
-0.0110079134,
-0.061349716,
0.0470160656,
-0.0257578846,
0.0198159106,
0.0011621454,
-0.0444486216,
0.0352018289,
-0.0107912952,
-0.0325281657,
-0.0033615476,
0.0288562104,
0.0128000807,
-0.0175849069,
-0.0269676372,
-0.0368322134,
-0.0542914458,
0.0100799231,
0.0211382117,
-0.0192886088,
-0.0763713121,
0.0289310999,
0.0169471707,
-0.0385820679,
0.0187194198,
2.60810077e-34,
0.0440843366,
-0.0419425331,
0.0277304035,
-0.0109110512,
0.0325832218,
-0.0293229446,
-0.0134811131,
0.0276034754,
-0.0081867995,
-0.0205351319,
-0.0457498692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00483v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00483v2 | A Data-centric Framework for Improving Domain-specific Machine Reading Comprehension Datasets | 2023-04-02T08:26:38 | 2023-05-26T05:43:19 | Iva Bojic, Josef Halim, Verena Suharman, Sreeja Tar, Qi Chwen Ong, Duy Phung, Mathieu Ravaut, Shafiq Joty, Josip Car | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low-quality data can cause downstream problems in high-stakes applications.
Data-centric approach emphasizes on improving dataset quality to enhance model
performance. High-quality datasets are needed for general-purpose Large
Language Models (LLMs) training, as well as for domain-specific models, which
are usually small in size as it is costly to engage a large number of domain
experts for their creation. Thus, it is vital to ensure high-quality
domain-specific training data. In this paper, we propose a framework for
enhancing the data quality of original datasets. We applied the proposed
framework to four biomedical datasets and showed relative improvement of up to
33%/40% for fine-tuning of retrieval/reader models on the BioASQ dataset when
using back translation to enhance the original dataset quality. | [
0.0534219593,
0.0337784849,
-0.016695613,
0.0268664304,
-0.0314578563,
0.0339937992,
0.0190313533,
-0.0293140542,
0.001061311,
-0.0093216766,
-0.0518300757,
-0.0439861566,
0.0141115179,
0.0134097673,
0.0156875867,
-0.0241021439,
0.0518436395,
-0.0062578293,
-0.0066136895,
0.0054586516,
-0.0260392912,
0.0142494263,
-0.0002617556,
-0.0036226953,
0.0844687,
-0.0251080673,
0.016303191,
0.0249958038,
0.0449093468,
-0.0363681465,
0.0160382837,
0.0292938463,
-0.000726765,
0.0305737071,
0.0000017508,
-0.0383561254,
-0.0387589447,
0.023338588,
-0.0352068841,
0.0082757575,
0.0514168255,
-0.0540086739,
0.018233614,
-0.00264548,
-0.0036931762,
-0.0394356474,
0.0207027923,
0.0416261554,
0.0762451738,
0.0641451851,
-0.0043753181,
-0.0245734416,
0.0469785705,
-0.0187175628,
0.0017246986,
-0.0465126708,
0.0416255221,
0.0809452981,
0.019852113,
0.0437065512,
-0.0011376165,
0.0693376288,
0.0115343919,
0.0332958959,
0.0019301064,
0.0166013092,
-0.0037679917,
-0.0183503758,
0.0120201893,
0.112061657,
0.0495148711,
-0.0129423328,
-0.0306491572,
-0.0013314807,
-0.0089303423,
0.0342095084,
-0.022428114,
0.0132430783,
-0.0235209297,
0.0091180103,
0.0102662863,
-0.0133402403,
0.0521749668,
0.0311612263,
-0.0380958766,
0.0096369339,
0.00482562,
-0.0488027111,
0.0069038928,
0.0099195754,
-0.0172967166,
0.0434559956,
0.0478235073,
0.0225389637,
-0.0105179325,
0.0357197151,
-0.0441116877,
-0.0565561987,
0.0338360034,
-0.0187898483,
0.0273677502,
0.0379355028,
-0.0558485724,
0.0384336747,
-0.0060022795,
0.0067200516,
-0.0141086271,
0.0325152576,
-0.0556335114,
-0.0279588308,
0.008164838,
-0.0004258145,
-0.0030324268,
0.0115654226,
-0.071067512,
-0.009356753,
-0.0464525819,
0.0342580192,
0.0489706434,
-0.0262922626,
0.0233610813,
0.0041561131,
-0.0836763978,
-0.0110843247,
-0.0168346222,
0.0262986664,
-0.0097495969,
0.0319363996,
-0.0170965083,
-0.0707381591,
-0.0047536837,
-0.0105471769,
0.0038114758,
-0.0673668757,
0.005618582,
0.0735323206,
-0.0038893186,
-0.0538682602,
-0.0446403921,
-0.0181009509,
-0.0002497706,
-0.0541938059,
0.0099650174,
-0.0225788876,
0.0279770494,
0.0219649356,
0.0023922699,
-0.0437080897,
-0.0180708319,
0.0309343114,
-0.0327924415,
0.1011075079,
-0.0354974642,
-0.0013910494,
0.0237086155,
0.0301847514,
-0.0125891892,
0.0736743957,
0.0076735839,
-0.0474793874,
0.0412534028,
-0.0013719181,
-0.0310825706,
0.0053557199,
0.0240102336,
0.0059102029,
-0.0134808756,
0.0439678729,
-0.0240925979,
0.0404311605,
0.0185151678,
0.0316589922,
-0.0318974406,
-0.0187220331,
0.0636342764,
0.0310424138,
0.0482448079,
-0.0027126421,
0.0065276674,
0.0245960504,
0.0131301684,
0.025853375,
-0.0136932191,
-0.0299223252,
0.012636628,
0.0472219549,
0.0000995631,
0.000029104,
-0.0133484453,
-0.0415412523,
0.0116522647,
0.0151558407,
0.0028258529,
0.0601657033,
0.0723156333,
-0.0003388454,
-0.0456842966,
-0.0000960389,
0.0213575307,
-0.0406546034,
0.0122944694,
-0.036458306,
0.0032658749,
0.0333026163,
0.0677802861,
-0.011402823,
-0.0571105331,
0.0135010891,
0.0365357324,
0.0135092419,
-0.0028156969,
-0.0136481524,
0.039465256,
-0.073334612,
-0.0334578678,
0.060497243,
-0.0026741219,
-0.01822046,
-0.0095213847,
0.0301027261,
0.0338647477,
-0.0411794372,
-0.0589095801,
0.0660159513,
-0.0905567184,
-0.0104254689,
-0.0129104434,
0.0277136546,
0.0350105427,
0.0365339555,
0.0021092517,
-0.02141333,
0.0429996252,
-0.0286682397,
0.030867625,
-0.0142525695,
-0.0378736332,
-0.0233546495,
0.0330145694,
-0.0383891985,
-0.0216890424,
0.0391396917,
-0.0178072043,
-0.0332845263,
-0.0347623676,
-0.0316640362,
-0.0412536673,
-0.0677030087,
0.0119159939,
-0.022954233,
0.0022659572,
-0.0754955113,
0.0205525663,
-0.0013666408,
0.0471205041,
0.0208752509,
0.014275562,
0.0136196474,
-0.0522194803,
-0.0155711612,
0.0043832967,
-0.0000132912,
0.0182869174,
-0.0047697499,
0.0098385233,
-0.0739496723,
0.0396712124,
-0.0381488726,
0.0063307923,
0.0002060353,
0.0031716661,
0.0271515362,
0.028231686,
-0.0126049137,
-0.0118275331,
0.0153590804,
-0.0411746278,
0.0255487338,
0.014368359,
0.0228597764,
0.0183919948,
0.0100562107,
-0.0132094556,
-0.024738254,
-0.0135430191,
0.0324360467,
0.0001363002,
0.0010881979,
-0.0776408762,
0.0445563123,
-0.0021002318,
0.0126867173,
-0.0178154353,
-0.0340632759,
-0.0005370827,
0.010008771,
0.0038122879,
0.0810845122,
-0.0317952484,
-0.0122158835,
0.0240270291,
0.0125196148,
-0.0482902266,
0.0142004211,
-0.0247485414,
0.003074955,
-0.0273309164,
-0.0315208025,
0.0017430445,
0.0304954592,
0.0141514093,
-0.0273425244,
-0.0166276749,
0.0216995776,
-0.0200851411,
-0.0001385187,
-0.0474773012,
0.0312068127,
-0.0289627872,
0.0655954927,
-0.0437017791,
-0.035812825,
0.1140680015,
-0.0291771423,
0.0052600983,
-0.089452073,
0.0093228705,
-0.0358721614,
0.0150617873,
-0.0263766199,
0.0143426992,
-0.0122704217,
-0.0201614145,
-0.0533157326,
0.0321898386,
0.002312863,
-0.0376703776,
0.0705790296,
-0.0482842885,
0.0096485876,
-0.0125247948,
-0.006133589,
-0.0678457469,
0.0495175645,
-0.0290759671,
-0.031707868,
0.0009408962,
0.004753137,
-0.08097139,
-0.0036675632,
0.0055441782,
0.0574095212,
-0.0328849331,
-0.0116731124,
-0.0081240935,
0.0331628285,
0.0195527673,
-0.0075599691,
0.0059787757,
-0.0464457534,
0.0209578071,
0.041045174,
-0.034453921,
-0.0426262207,
0.0217761192,
-0.0014902891,
0.0533989593,
-0.0098546585,
0.0314272717,
-0.022013545,
0.0456203148,
-0.0645703599,
-0.0335320719,
0.0923789591,
-0.004775987,
-0.0584461875,
-0.0264378283,
-0.01548314,
0.0102580078,
-0.0048979665,
0.0144976238,
-0.0685606897,
-0.0466967672,
-0.0047668139,
0.0721311569,
0.009279307,
-0.009820302,
-0.005124622,
-0.0679680035,
0.0274505448,
0.0193262808,
-0.0793808252,
-0.0883770138,
-0.0560252704,
-0.0025156909,
-0.0497093052,
0.072604917,
0.0334029794,
0.0066836984,
-0.0056721,
-0.0006208853,
0.035758175,
-0.1117187589,
-0.0167775843,
-0.0119635351,
0.0131396884,
0.0746034086,
0.0177799985,
0.0162156727,
-0.0019369414,
0.0166562274,
-0.0500680879,
-0.020225659,
-0.0015277459,
0.0772588104,
-0.0278418008,
-0.0038248715,
-0.0426981188,
0.0645450503,
-0.0443995558,
0.0066732541,
0.0046998411,
0.0444861948,
-0.0148175377,
0.0128025664,
-0.0649593547,
-0.0157029461,
0.002842705,
0.0969263017,
0.0298066512,
-0.0324619561,
0.0063138851,
0.0235256478,
0.0258321483,
-0.0636406615,
-0.0286054406,
0.0540450178,
-0.0589077286,
-0.0140182329,
-0.0451650433,
-0.0871718302,
0.026600223,
0.000126731,
0.0275794528,
0.0604564585,
0.016988324,
0.0026941956,
-0.0705281198,
0.0722786412,
-0.0334877372,
-0.0059654317,
-0.0752310678,
-0.0307055917,
0.0424021035,
-0.0261819996,
-0.011330503,
0.050645791,
-0.0350467265,
-0.0394671299,
0.0190857314,
0.0105473781,
0.0224995986,
0.0502180271,
0.0018874737,
-0.0345521271,
0.0329546854,
0.0005838948,
-0.0623296238,
-0.0229009539,
-0.000547107,
-0.0332926363,
-0.0231218934,
0.0158974957,
-0.0098237842,
0.0349041484,
0.0238822848,
0.0342042111,
-0.0048519266,
-0.0210848935,
0.0172572061,
0.0444388948,
0.0714371055,
-0.0085245157,
-0.0249821097,
-0.038684994,
0.0256916024,
-0.0299334805,
0.0046396665,
-0.0165676698,
0.0059475624,
0.0472271256,
-0.0286568981,
-0.0353090949,
-0.0069844038,
-0.0631914958,
0.0132322963,
-0.0752544701,
0.0680514351,
-0.0155909183,
0.0218536407,
0.0497786887,
-0.0079606865,
-0.0218476448,
0.0090563968,
-0.010795299,
0.0346962139,
0.0233895369,
0.0335860625,
0.0189323276,
0.0060028322,
0.006318972,
0.041308105,
-0.0544401556,
0.0063427878,
-0.0150744794,
-0.0017571221,
0.007835337,
-0.0049558808,
0.0342418738,
0.0149885453,
-0.021525247,
-0.045045808,
0.0296990573,
0.0071428283,
0.0200058427,
0.032468196,
0.0172495227,
-0.0011512585,
-0.0147009045,
0.0664553568,
0.0221356805,
0.0414279737,
-0.0270502754,
-0.0297855083,
-0.0346496105,
-0.030277539,
0.0025418347,
0.0147776818,
-0.050251957,
0.0058262134,
-0.0420553051,
-0.0987415165,
0.0083324229,
-0.0009688593,
-0.0055849901,
0.0046353121,
0.0027578983,
0.0500661023,
-0.0043205894,
-0.0247491542,
-0.0357462987,
0.0473557673,
-0.0306710266,
-0.0418579578,
-0.0166829769,
-5.51901467e-33,
0.0050093937,
-0.0044083013,
0.0115798796,
-0.0392914042,
-0.0075928941,
0.0225538388,
-0.0210945476,
-0.0346609652,
-0.0336136743,
0.0017583555,
-0.0170581341,
0.0379992761,
0.0146746775,
0.0306899715,
-0.0530319586,
0.0048222174,
0.0443254262,
-0.0049932231,
-0.028343793,
0.0061322171,
-0.0002688189,
0.0869666412,
0.0539756194,
-0.0559206828,
0.039968133,
-0.0423061214,
0.012271652,
0.0303333625,
0.0276794843,
0.0510197505,
-0.0187105034,
0.0532581694,
0.0414169841,
-0.0363712199,
-0.0071917982,
0.0148424273,
-0.1311618835,
0.0100572165,
0.0275532585,
0.0372155569,
-0.0114706298,
-0.0340280384,
0.0454131514,
-0.0298008341,
0.0104526281,
-0.0335076302,
0.0266652778,
-0.0630304143,
-0.0654456019,
-0.0060858745,
-0.042203296,
0.0377146825,
-0.0042464528,
-0.0058729737,
0.0383190326,
0.0440757088,
-0.0207575299,
0.0746843964,
-0.0595284663,
0.0147199407,
0.0511063114,
0.0121786194,
0.0398830362,
0.0389023609,
0.0117156571,
0.0065882197,
0.0235909168,
-0.0201836526,
0.0153451758,
-0.0104672182,
0.0347242393,
0.0272546522,
-0.007501977,
0.0836455375,
0.0354912356,
-0.0092865918,
-0.0834005848,
0.0681079477,
-0.0677951649,
0.0165561326,
0.0128370356,
-0.0227624383,
-0.0519044027,
0.0069321468,
-0.0455277264,
0.033903107,
-0.024260981,
-0.0056603854,
0.0298361629,
-0.0171824619,
-0.073588863,
-0.0056384699,
0.0418269336,
-0.0465871394,
-0.0059599141,
0.0223761499,
-0.0022655306,
-0.0092552919,
-0.0116327433,
0.0178629532,
-0.0269813128,
-0.030536063,
0.0040107667,
0.0202812441,
0.0178552363,
-0.0403555557,
0.043730814,
-0.0175214335,
-0.0197091382,
-0.0111627253,
-0.0095214415,
-0.0012335753,
-0.0126024261,
0.0712522715,
0.0109258182,
0.0050144787,
-0.0105104018,
0.08274021,
0.0297627021,
0.0093507366,
-0.0449068211,
-0.0107517596,
0.009623873,
0.024778707,
-0.0355293415,
-0.0231803842,
0.007954252,
0.0048375018,
0.0225106906,
-0.0613966472,
-0.0013421153,
0.0147513347,
2.359e-7,
0.063342981,
0.0376800597,
0.0142790526,
0.0441964269,
-0.0291392598,
0.0185208861,
0.0008502902,
0.0048027355,
0.0307785347,
-0.0029648789,
0.0464467816,
0.0198275391,
0.0432806909,
-0.0093635842,
-0.09777309,
-0.0494201183,
-0.0045875576,
0.0196394306,
-0.013489238,
0.0103913322,
0.0404124334,
0.0792193338,
-0.037981309,
-0.0480236448,
0.0410575829,
-0.0104855495,
0.0301445145,
-0.038250763,
-0.0086609321,
0.0535987541,
0.0439809896,
0.0505302511,
0.0151852323,
0.011639202,
-0.0182057377,
0.0055740289,
-0.0013519265,
0.0521957725,
0.0136123728,
-0.0378488638,
0.021840116,
0.0120340558,
0.0118219675,
-0.0233659483,
0.0666504428,
-0.0681193471,
-0.0471879728,
0.0187404454,
-0.0567710623,
-0.0140024107,
0.0166018624,
-0.032133054,
-0.0208719894,
0.0360435285,
0.0263959728,
-0.0286390316,
0.012075251,
-0.0572810918,
-0.0064192917,
-0.0059532556,
-0.0376353413,
-0.0420888849,
-0.0039733849,
-0.0424111411,
0.0136054615,
-0.0559357591,
0.0086959507,
1.884132396e-34,
0.0298413262,
-0.0193890315,
0.0117184948,
0.0328023359,
0.007246566,
-0.0362485498,
0.0494957194,
-0.0010731748,
-0.0155302864,
-0.0864819065,
-0.0115468111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00468v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00468v2 | Words that Matter: The Impact of Negative Words on News Sentiment and Stock Market Index | 2023-04-02T06:45:18 | 2024-02-23T02:05:44 | Wonseong Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study investigates the impact of negative words on sentiment analysis
and its effect on the South Korean stock market index, KOSPI200. The research
analyzes a dataset of 45,723 South Korean daily economic news articles using
Word2Vec, cosine similarity, and an expanded lexicon. The findings suggest that
incorporating negative words significantly increases sentiment scores'
negativity in news titles, which can affect the stock market index. The study
reveals that an augmented sentiment lexicon (Sent1000), including the top 1,000
negative words with high cosine similarity to 'Crisis,' more effectively
captures the impact of news sentiment on the stock market index than the
original sentiment lexicon (Sent0). The results underscore the importance of
considering negative nuances and context when analyzing news content and its
potential impact on market dynamics and public opinion. | [
0.0289678518,
0.0266359542,
-0.0266009085,
-0.0045149243,
-0.006630409,
0.0069577396,
-0.0186701845,
0.0516659021,
0.0148673691,
-0.0358041301,
0.0176685955,
0.0270986035,
-0.009717186,
0.0417871885,
-0.0071252463,
-0.0420655534,
0.0477040261,
0.0641667619,
0.0468906984,
-0.0127488086,
0.0066346638,
-0.0193391163,
0.0317358412,
0.0132918339,
-0.0110631203,
0.0173183009,
0.0213316809,
0.0310804863,
0.0294220056,
-0.0635853484,
-0.0044228425,
0.0121228416,
-0.0158975571,
0.0182662159,
0.0000018228,
-0.042725917,
0.0106420834,
-0.0202858765,
0.0421902351,
-0.0061801933,
0.111719884,
-0.062364731,
0.0074935183,
0.0006088646,
-0.0309969038,
-0.027910104,
0.0447076,
0.0426000282,
0.083686471,
0.0336661451,
-0.0086167399,
-0.0058266218,
-0.041809205,
-0.0155872284,
-0.0229399949,
-0.0278863329,
0.0377793312,
-0.0135552781,
-0.0395851843,
-0.0404382274,
-0.0341577642,
0.0091188569,
-0.0402886644,
0.0567253716,
-0.0096891625,
0.0014538565,
-0.0466530994,
-0.0337723084,
0.0111412937,
0.0032642353,
0.0486014634,
-0.0014452374,
-0.0349966362,
-0.0131675526,
0.0094076777,
0.062688373,
-0.0175243653,
-0.0216569472,
0.0050677676,
0.0185809489,
0.0124086058,
0.0306435898,
-0.0137770846,
0.0396413133,
0.0153992577,
0.0476057865,
0.001252306,
-0.0722485632,
0.0363528393,
-0.0072693289,
-0.0059989979,
6.39e-7,
0.0091104805,
-0.0431009084,
0.0265270919,
0.045140177,
0.0198313594,
-0.0283918045,
0.0042194589,
-0.1732269675,
-0.0857805833,
0.0251205601,
0.0129371407,
-0.0034183182,
0.0002291465,
-0.022464335,
0.067119807,
-0.0298177619,
0.0175367035,
0.0334915295,
-0.0331211798,
0.0149375843,
-0.007683916,
0.0339473337,
0.0081608072,
-0.0074402378,
-0.0488978177,
-0.0232522525,
-0.071197547,
-0.0127098467,
-0.0189125352,
-0.0141245676,
-0.0006140947,
-0.0075978157,
-0.0385559611,
0.0026915721,
-0.0966683999,
0.0376979597,
-0.0382271595,
0.0079148933,
0.0292738285,
-0.002777983,
0.0240704995,
0.0309678651,
0.0153276687,
0.0130121885,
0.0664602593,
-0.0241921302,
-0.0261612721,
-0.0339179449,
-0.0242798161,
-0.004846219,
-0.0823756009,
-0.0047062314,
-0.0186098386,
-0.0041316818,
0.0090937782,
0.0096178576,
0.0065449905,
0.0040888633,
-0.0669883341,
0.0456656143,
-0.0094771273,
-0.015825104,
0.0021940237,
0.0083150845,
0.0694795921,
0.0432109684,
-0.0349292904,
-0.0207733065,
0.0581964739,
0.0195357669,
-0.0244697668,
0.018325055,
0.0088222669,
-0.0115436111,
-0.0830220208,
0.0104077924,
-0.0242956933,
-0.049411878,
-0.0063398895,
-0.012012613,
-0.0039928951,
0.0085254386,
0.0362570435,
0.0217428915,
-0.06271936,
0.0482216887,
-0.0515324213,
-0.0089429151,
-0.0382795855,
-0.0534799621,
0.0131005216,
-0.0248284545,
-0.0565160699,
0.0398632959,
-0.0135230077,
-0.032921005,
-0.0291620065,
-0.0127676558,
-0.0149940234,
0.0162418801,
0.0721780062,
-0.0385113992,
0.0125696808,
-0.035286773,
-0.0380560681,
0.0306098927,
0.0374343768,
-0.0364617594,
-0.0009199157,
0.0253290851,
0.030092638,
0.0471602865,
0.0132688833,
0.0542139448,
-0.0049705408,
-0.0156199727,
-0.0194712095,
0.0302711017,
0.0083613172,
0.0338789113,
-0.0854208991,
0.0006331891,
-0.01273394,
0.0672508478,
0.0484110415,
0.0120295985,
0.0067340434,
0.0515726805,
-0.0000951375,
0.0386455692,
-0.0165696181,
0.0132236741,
0.0585274436,
0.0009067461,
-0.0179097001,
-0.0225524772,
0.0426348113,
0.034284357,
0.0014379555,
-0.0004061707,
0.022632055,
-0.0040846877,
-0.0890922099,
0.0463610739,
-0.0162997544,
0.0028861037,
-0.0390107259,
-0.085548602,
0.0388910919,
0.0523186512,
0.0117750838,
-0.0123652099,
0.0526768826,
0.0110195829,
0.0181846134,
-0.0266943593,
-0.0260557681,
-0.066320315,
0.0264100153,
0.0084259678,
0.0279994048,
-0.0450785756,
0.0179104544,
-0.0476264581,
-0.0095872069,
-0.0001317044,
0.0314989164,
-0.0391395465,
-0.0042151702,
0.0225478113,
0.0127971778,
0.039063517,
-0.0133237103,
-0.0144027052,
-0.0264649875,
-0.0562500283,
-0.0279141646,
0.0117839556,
-0.0044237156,
0.0352626219,
-0.0163654052,
-0.0397007987,
0.0241554547,
0.0182779506,
-0.0051180408,
0.0187610295,
0.0374676622,
0.0082722111,
0.0078129005,
0.0078458469,
-0.0375970602,
-0.0191227626,
-0.0080241794,
-0.040401347,
0.0481592752,
-0.0541999713,
0.0221106857,
0.0735320821,
-0.0680272654,
-0.0489192531,
0.009857947,
-0.0392102674,
-0.0041255681,
0.0139697241,
-0.0295664351,
0.0079565812,
0.0333964415,
0.0725151524,
-0.0261849985,
-0.0230540056,
0.0110764084,
-0.0149049433,
-0.0572497174,
0.0217648819,
-0.0007482457,
-0.0120604057,
-0.0101726865,
0.0572661236,
0.0261815879,
-0.0086778272,
-0.0589815453,
0.0112803597,
-0.0706752315,
0.0147690177,
-0.0317114629,
-0.0425951779,
-0.0179148484,
0.0244241096,
0.0120081613,
-0.0130449468,
0.0072726812,
0.052171994,
0.004650976,
-0.0332001336,
0.0070150224,
-0.0209928453,
0.0055547445,
-0.0646752343,
-0.0199193358,
-0.0309641697,
0.0140124969,
-0.016928846,
-0.063409999,
0.0284101609,
-0.032238137,
-0.0033754066,
-0.00858464,
0.0262862667,
-0.0035143129,
-0.0158742443,
0.0017818188,
-0.0626064017,
-0.0318285488,
-0.010096129,
0.0812018514,
0.012358983,
-0.0098066851,
0.0549486727,
-0.0277078729,
-0.0930274874,
0.008822659,
-0.0367981717,
0.0336567909,
-0.0323445089,
0.0322027951,
-0.0047217426,
0.0268453397,
0.0256342236,
0.0297358856,
-0.0054582879,
0.0084356749,
0.0070811682,
0.0187759716,
0.0129067712,
-0.0058588814,
0.0174738783,
0.0055184583,
-0.0247022957,
-0.0109082367,
-0.0190322138,
-0.0020048001,
0.0581628345,
-0.0033009681,
0.0179066788,
-0.0015737258,
0.0086320825,
0.0010199969,
0.0390140787,
-0.0230404362,
0.0151520725,
0.0052325618,
-0.0171527024,
0.0216484498,
-0.0250013862,
-0.033606492,
-0.0295098294,
-0.1176889688,
0.0059777461,
-0.003763193,
-0.0218133479,
-0.0087998603,
-0.0260964725,
-0.0017553836,
-0.0385126695,
-0.0175166558,
0.0063844668,
0.0042608217,
0.0441117063,
-0.0241966788,
-0.082393907,
0.0189423915,
0.0034310238,
0.00253861,
-0.0113160405,
-0.0050670267,
0.0680230707,
-0.0587861426,
0.0094709294,
-0.0322860777,
-0.0324946046,
-0.0115600871,
-0.0327627547,
0.0572212152,
-0.0261066146,
-0.0372000076,
-0.0344976373,
0.0215668622,
-0.0379392169,
0.0730798244,
-0.0247596595,
-0.0221806038,
0.0186809972,
-0.0475722179,
-0.0216439739,
0.0625877306,
0.0188806225,
0.0436904207,
-0.0061861398,
-0.0153342821,
0.0512547642,
0.0033714049,
0.0498619974,
-0.0034850514,
-0.0290759876,
-0.0343022719,
-0.0370738544,
-0.0261974111,
-0.0423202217,
-0.0937558413,
-0.0071903914,
0.0496457554,
0.0148209352,
0.0183824357,
0.0221992061,
0.0062686871,
-0.0394314528,
-0.0288359281,
0.0399421751,
0.0037317178,
0.0268147923,
-0.0042038341,
0.0191442426,
0.0673893094,
-0.028879527,
0.0007714742,
-0.0375265777,
-0.017077161,
0.0508585498,
0.0098704025,
0.0161300786,
-0.0174960289,
0.0094393324,
0.061174266,
0.0403378792,
0.0685657561,
-0.0332846232,
0.0035295542,
0.0283089262,
0.0338589065,
0.0036965008,
0.0230119843,
0.0149209565,
0.0239032656,
-0.0112962797,
0.011631825,
-0.0519749112,
-0.0281476099,
-0.0131060723,
-0.021077875,
0.0755013153,
-0.0124632753,
-0.0477112606,
-0.0287443828,
-0.0435977429,
-0.0057985308,
-0.0085453158,
0.0142358122,
-0.0411410816,
0.0036054652,
-0.0192399789,
-0.0709899589,
0.0681066737,
-0.0584003404,
-0.037195906,
-0.0062184199,
0.0406719446,
0.0396797173,
0.075439997,
0.0166876484,
-0.0105349422,
-0.0052427026,
-0.027776679,
0.0106124971,
-0.0532970168,
-0.0309716985,
0.0091174496,
0.0191893931,
0.0101730861,
0.0255313646,
-0.0291347131,
-0.0020247356,
0.0155966189,
-0.0054528373,
0.0322299972,
-0.0529119484,
-0.0221593939,
-0.0076694628,
-0.0245096963,
-0.0034368695,
0.0079332674,
-0.0111167906,
-0.0445910469,
-0.0381737351,
0.045179788,
-0.0083880825,
-0.0718116462,
0.0069479402,
0.0093881031,
-0.0407317765,
0.0288525969,
0.0022897604,
-0.0335518569,
0.0003776646,
-0.0012569854,
0.1040231735,
0.0149614876,
0.0281614661,
0.0192720722,
-0.1038155034,
-0.032916721,
0.0380148217,
-0.0211987216,
0.0215482283,
0.0224013962,
0.0324691236,
0.02978204,
0.0169425905,
0.0629938468,
0.0035975634,
0.0093149357,
-0.0963580608,
-0.0117386719,
-0.0254384317,
-6.025656409e-33,
-0.0179758966,
-0.0249723177,
-0.0212414619,
0.0164685212,
-0.0099052293,
0.0081391251,
-0.0239798017,
0.0594297983,
-0.0024889389,
0.0366961062,
0.0256539118,
0.0573959164,
0.0132697467,
-0.0060464651,
0.0825443864,
-0.0327084288,
0.0307201743,
0.007064891,
0.0284619369,
-0.04406875,
0.0869141743,
0.0529165827,
0.047799211,
-0.0378068648,
0.0744219124,
-0.0299405549,
-0.0301741045,
-0.0858147517,
0.1381418407,
0.0021166836,
0.0103582721,
0.0466301329,
0.0400901623,
-0.0504206009,
0.010838314,
-0.0068630776,
0.0166479032,
-0.0651325807,
0.0156521872,
0.0172228031,
0.0402112193,
0.0523911491,
0.0405205488,
0.0196593478,
-0.0568160526,
0.0745460093,
0.0192558616,
-0.0083391489,
-0.0287413225,
-0.0086732358,
-0.0708269104,
0.0299911629,
-0.0059991516,
0.0506897829,
-0.0003232154,
0.0556621477,
0.0049448675,
0.0414860323,
-0.0182031877,
-0.0045458814,
-0.0208625142,
-0.0021483316,
-0.0043764124,
-0.000531486,
0.0108087752,
0.0371112861,
0.0148061998,
0.0127398325,
0.0201012995,
0.0680204257,
0.0449776202,
0.0013843083,
-0.0016640027,
0.1266191453,
0.0423626266,
-0.113105759,
0.0072506447,
0.0287188031,
-0.011306568,
0.0395310037,
0.0346684679,
0.0102015492,
-0.0496095754,
-0.0331212319,
-0.0029294367,
-0.0191447865,
-0.0199725702,
-0.0145803681,
0.0291769393,
-0.0175869726,
-0.0287625622,
0.0283278879,
0.0123064071,
-0.0229025465,
-0.0583982877,
0.0019786186,
-0.0129613159,
-0.0269376095,
-0.0055727526,
-0.0329797827,
-0.0121856183,
-0.0007778255,
-0.0364802182,
0.0478517562,
-0.0021641804,
-0.0355896242,
0.0108911851,
0.0128432903,
-0.0446099974,
-0.0298218392,
0.0458222739,
-0.0260019396,
0.0224192888,
-0.0235333368,
0.010623361,
0.0091694444,
0.0131468112,
-0.0220900942,
0.0499468111,
0.0445492156,
-0.0065888911,
-0.0381930806,
-0.0141020166,
0.0181842484,
0.0064597926,
-0.0163341369,
0.0254339427,
0.0132465623,
0.0196192674,
-0.0475222021,
-0.0017311836,
-0.0114834094,
2.64e-7,
0.0319003798,
0.0760834441,
-0.0232581273,
0.0074297776,
-0.0004739766,
0.066664122,
-0.0208213199,
0.0027019994,
-0.0154892467,
0.0076173916,
0.0408946015,
-0.0086525138,
-0.0039248033,
0.0480912402,
-0.0428321436,
0.0239513014,
-0.0364564732,
0.0163504351,
-0.0523821004,
0.0453535318,
0.0648342296,
0.0453108586,
0.046680022,
-0.0186425,
-0.0457952023,
-0.0015435361,
0.0152393775,
-0.0811830461,
-0.0184816681,
-0.0208784994,
0.0168365315,
0.0170752071,
0.0004485688,
0.0162423849,
-0.0227486566,
0.000964162,
0.0278696548,
-0.0269847717,
0.0006722964,
0.0129913855,
0.0170304812,
-0.0296729766,
-0.0316366479,
-0.0453047454,
0.0507399514,
-0.0597755425,
-0.0322801247,
-0.1000395417,
-0.0330372155,
0.0712162703,
0.0769423991,
-0.026501216,
-0.0335526839,
0.0146398591,
-0.0108386325,
0.0193868503,
0.0107026529,
-0.0049969326,
0.015184463,
0.0036834187,
-0.0088040559,
0.0007176258,
-0.0005400851,
0.0705731586,
0.0360459201,
0.0334123112,
0.0295711756,
1.741047068e-34,
0.0454465412,
-0.0164600182,
-0.0625650585,
-0.0146093648,
0.041270256,
0.0059114047,
-0.0873741955,
0.0329279266,
-0.0247022193,
-0.0224524252,
0.0118331248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00457v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00457v3 | LLMMaps -- A Visual Metaphor for Stratified Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2023-04-02T05:47:09 | 2023-10-12T11:35:35 | Patrik Puchert, Poonam Poonam, Christian van Onzenoodt, Timo Ropinski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.GR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
and demonstrated impressive capabilities in various tasks. Unfortunately, they
are prone to hallucinations, where the model exposes incorrect or false
information in its responses, which renders diligent evaluation approaches
mandatory. While LLM performance in specific knowledge fields is often
evaluated based on question and answer (Q&A) datasets, such evaluations usually
report only a single accuracy number for the dataset, which often covers an
entire field. This field-based evaluation, is problematic with respect to
transparency and model improvement. A stratified evaluation could instead
reveal subfields, where hallucinations are more likely to occur and thus help
to better assess LLMs' risks and guide their further development. To support
such stratified evaluations, we propose LLMMaps as a novel visualization
technique that enables users to evaluate LLMs' performance with respect to Q&A
datasets. LLMMaps provide detailed insights into LLMs' knowledge capabilities
in different subfields, by transforming Q&A datasets as well as LLM responses
into an internal knowledge structure. An extension for comparative
visualization furthermore, allows for the detailed comparison of multiple LLMs.
To assess LLMMaps we use them to conduct a comparative analysis of several
state-of-the-art LLMs, such as BLOOM, GPT-2, GPT-3, ChatGPT and LLaMa-13B, as
well as two qualitative user evaluations. All necessary source code and data
for generating LLMMaps to be used in scientific publications and elsewhere is
available on GitHub: https://github.com/viscom-ulm/LLMMaps | [
0.0163328517,
0.0506518073,
-0.0326595716,
0.0423935577,
-0.0528155155,
0.0054551479,
-0.0169966482,
0.0273611378,
0.0225033704,
-0.03165273,
-0.0466446057,
-0.0113100195,
0.0125464275,
0.0423279554,
0.0232124161,
-0.0609802864,
0.0420521423,
-0.0364968814,
-0.0031890448,
0.0335702784,
0.0241072476,
-0.0016281126,
-0.0105594946,
0.0624216869,
0.0100675384,
-0.0512586907,
0.0046250708,
-0.01741351,
0.0051501226,
-0.0485122912,
-0.0619910546,
0.0519760437,
-0.0095200613,
0.0857037678,
0.0000023398,
-0.0474687591,
0.00101906,
0.015665466,
-0.014965211,
0.055758357,
0.0360613018,
0.0087289717,
0.0289525017,
0.019601943,
-0.0517063737,
-0.0098775029,
0.0430724435,
0.0484451465,
0.0629402846,
0.0033113305,
-0.0018667202,
-0.0230084397,
0.0128291417,
0.0055228877,
0.0043653841,
0.0048707169,
0.0070686615,
-0.0047268514,
0.0175660979,
0.0150454855,
-0.019094063,
0.0485625118,
-0.0084979422,
-0.0497311987,
0.0419842862,
0.0369123407,
-0.0455420054,
-0.0547796078,
-0.0090507763,
0.0651905015,
-0.0291015115,
0.0075208405,
-0.029762961,
-0.0264460035,
-0.0036135516,
0.0229571704,
-0.0791123286,
-0.0029639176,
-0.0051965583,
0.0160288587,
0.0039255158,
0.0128036542,
0.031306278,
0.00085974,
-0.0224444643,
0.0672438964,
0.022611158,
-0.0169962067,
0.011355483,
0.0071167098,
-0.0041860235,
-0.0526243672,
0.0239161663,
0.040690735,
-0.0415107869,
0.0199169256,
0.0235305447,
-0.03412636,
0.0631424263,
-0.0595927946,
0.0444551259,
-0.0051379264,
-0.037683215,
0.0619078465,
-0.0069274153,
0.0526344515,
-0.0070483298,
0.0424100347,
-0.0045381938,
-0.0213985518,
-0.031571947,
-0.0330682322,
-0.0168359987,
-0.011785659,
-0.0209180862,
0.0042560128,
-0.0423210524,
-0.0012681431,
-0.0296194199,
0.0008442628,
0.0231635403,
0.0036376419,
0.0278329905,
0.0095488494,
-0.0887252241,
0.0101193767,
-0.0505506583,
0.0116211446,
-0.0021306239,
-0.0711526573,
-0.0125768865,
0.0152368117,
-0.0149337612,
-0.0103844628,
-0.0090326993,
0.0690578148,
0.0377980694,
-0.0021777584,
-0.0046528601,
-0.0184779949,
-0.0203766897,
-0.0244715549,
-0.0041364832,
-0.053801544,
0.0234382208,
0.0122332228,
0.0115121203,
-0.0009760936,
0.0044148676,
0.0277461242,
-0.0262447987,
0.0806699321,
-0.0675856099,
0.0103657842,
0.0054930081,
0.0223598666,
-0.0028344798,
0.0700791925,
0.0289373975,
-0.0028342158,
0.0319775753,
-0.0423148423,
0.0352557413,
0.0194681361,
-0.0124652302,
0.0172382519,
-0.0389314406,
0.0147348689,
-0.0255482998,
0.0367088728,
-0.0060103196,
0.0416913815,
-0.0283734053,
-0.011824674,
0.0309250914,
0.0610636696,
0.0631579384,
0.0167210102,
0.0055366927,
0.0063575422,
0.0275008939,
-0.0099059306,
0.0008075874,
0.0250507612,
-0.0377737805,
-0.0024932851,
0.0238397121,
0.0224589501,
0.0098465104,
-0.0445069857,
-0.0549997911,
0.0383389257,
0.011509724,
0.0008071529,
0.0410671346,
0.0077629969,
0.0029544637,
0.0186781902,
0.0162061788,
-0.0409162119,
-0.0031100824,
-0.0631315708,
0.0139385499,
0.0751053989,
0.0535591617,
-0.0592176467,
0.008616576,
0.007144908,
-0.0171638597,
0.058894489,
0.033904139,
0.0181124005,
-0.0017971445,
-0.0117846094,
-0.0270489883,
-0.0243047364,
0.0131645063,
0.0006252512,
-0.0075103282,
0.0078219995,
-0.0233999453,
-0.0625644028,
-0.0335487388,
0.0390165895,
0.0269709285,
0.0132353967,
-0.0111360606,
-0.026512282,
0.0216484871,
0.0446139127,
0.000277982,
0.0639199317,
0.0517950915,
-0.0159302987,
-0.0078232437,
-0.0045442465,
0.01619903,
0.0012547802,
0.0378844738,
-0.0504218712,
-0.0168456677,
-0.0015480442,
-0.0312624425,
-0.031894736,
-0.0131086828,
-0.0677304491,
0.0415738784,
-0.0123999659,
0.0076696156,
-0.036536146,
0.0146003105,
-0.0468012914,
0.0726566836,
-0.0145368073,
0.0433748998,
0.0030828852,
-0.0067578522,
0.0105965156,
0.0057908478,
-0.021669887,
0.0265887864,
0.0153488452,
0.0102505665,
0.0047322796,
-0.0009990798,
-0.0902165771,
0.0075208438,
-0.0959472135,
-0.0126322787,
0.006459008,
0.0168952718,
0.0170608684,
-0.0323126391,
-0.0311697852,
-0.0086464938,
-0.0171751231,
-0.0092379423,
0.0399001949,
0.0344053321,
0.0627695024,
-0.0090380032,
-0.0054950961,
-0.0403977185,
-0.0217614081,
-0.0179870222,
0.0574269257,
0.0444945879,
-0.0251350906,
-0.0579199195,
-0.0070425123,
-0.0411507338,
-0.0086544305,
0.0123589393,
-0.0000191058,
0.0519345812,
-0.0175625384,
0.0207519569,
-0.0040824916,
0.0006908904,
0.0597318672,
0.0786899328,
-0.0317359902,
-0.0458549187,
-0.0171362944,
-0.0022504693,
0.0146486741,
0.0013598469,
-0.0406444632,
0.0171063375,
0.0438118875,
0.0048739328,
0.0036196539,
-0.0420914665,
0.0347675271,
-0.0401954614,
-0.0291307978,
-0.063932538,
-0.0438519046,
0.000169861,
0.0641503111,
-0.0119892946,
-0.0665838122,
0.0636248216,
-0.05430815,
0.0208260659,
-0.0349338949,
-0.0324068181,
-0.0561823174,
0.0893484801,
-0.0222230982,
-0.0111962333,
-0.0194565076,
-0.0246384703,
-0.0143591091,
-0.0042127166,
-0.0083929133,
-0.0642987192,
0.0541203916,
-0.063457936,
-0.0150605123,
-0.0010276155,
0.0265054852,
-0.0281156115,
-0.0170047656,
-0.0455590673,
-0.0030609369,
0.0150431842,
-0.0069116522,
-0.033934515,
0.0330656506,
0.0460828282,
-0.0140281972,
0.0018764799,
-0.0179964416,
0.0106513202,
0.0043189269,
0.0322531275,
0.0277079903,
0.0665613487,
-0.0252149515,
0.0267727412,
0.0580188707,
0.0175118539,
0.0234626066,
-0.0253967885,
-0.0114211598,
0.0175524373,
-0.0125326384,
-0.0261775479,
-0.0208804533,
0.0581935383,
-0.0432990566,
-0.0093679624,
0.106037423,
0.054117281,
-0.0509558097,
0.0228814352,
-0.0417982228,
0.0456456915,
0.0372264199,
0.0088827237,
-0.0909773931,
0.0022331513,
-0.0213945843,
-0.0083431844,
-0.0172250718,
-0.0460095964,
-0.0024619154,
-0.1232641563,
0.0490789823,
-0.0078094224,
-0.0353254043,
-0.0294775013,
-0.0725230649,
-0.0007846148,
0.0051154504,
0.0177525803,
-0.0237621777,
-0.0032503558,
0.0050913482,
0.0159383211,
-0.0391621701,
-0.0369626172,
0.0301792528,
-0.0298400559,
0.0347514413,
0.0208933763,
0.0371487439,
-0.0255286917,
-0.052354183,
0.0151137039,
-0.0158645734,
0.0246386211,
-0.018765498,
0.0466313474,
0.0293613616,
-0.0036970589,
-0.05500184,
-0.0393521972,
0.0120700616,
-0.0144609408,
0.009338038,
0.0741057098,
-0.0495293476,
-0.0061974637,
-0.0645366013,
0.0211568698,
-0.0303831995,
0.0654648319,
0.0662716925,
-0.0192777757,
-0.025421666,
-0.0452335477,
0.0234046597,
-0.0203872211,
-0.0723006725,
0.0397146083,
0.0147095509,
0.0005430009,
-0.0457661562,
-0.0079269269,
0.0522777475,
-0.0221326277,
0.003646784,
0.0412022248,
-0.0228436235,
-0.0068878694,
-0.0160443913,
0.0470313467,
-0.0155796232,
0.0341155566,
0.0058145174,
0.0097107943,
0.0376053192,
0.0242162868,
-0.0181778669,
0.0469185337,
-0.071757257,
-0.0504775047,
0.0101796594,
0.0146911368,
0.0259458274,
-0.0080178315,
-0.0273672808,
-0.087761797,
0.0692259967,
0.0438907556,
-0.0191964544,
-0.0322492979,
-0.0541993082,
0.009904529,
0.0082697487,
-0.0039652498,
-0.0163355954,
-0.0055640182,
-0.0384713821,
0.026780393,
-0.0278279986,
-0.0101296883,
0.0133867888,
0.0165646207,
0.0625742897,
0.002788042,
-0.0361536667,
-0.0084620751,
-0.0104785999,
-0.0617068708,
-0.021368729,
-0.0140172802,
-0.0130162966,
0.0304744784,
-0.067311734,
0.0054390533,
0.0067059835,
-0.0477979518,
0.0155697474,
-0.0562274083,
0.0550587662,
0.0369751155,
-0.0301708281,
0.0039129658,
0.0005482512,
-0.0101784235,
-0.0170746036,
-0.0471091382,
0.020965321,
0.0287233237,
0.0435176007,
-0.0129820034,
-0.0298486929,
0.0119727524,
0.0500081219,
-0.0767500997,
-0.0807951689,
0.0131953089,
0.0588197783,
0.0376703702,
0.0201389641,
0.0630014911,
-0.0202666558,
-0.0114044389,
-0.0029658,
0.0146986553,
0.0119020315,
-0.0042151879,
0.067164056,
0.0279290359,
-0.0414706357,
-0.0428859368,
0.0594150722,
0.01211935,
0.0236308519,
-0.0204180311,
-0.0430259556,
-0.0254317857,
-0.0349046737,
-0.0196297541,
0.0152055761,
-0.0340607837,
-0.0144423181,
-0.103891708,
-0.0726534426,
-0.002850425,
0.0093051177,
-0.001887325,
-0.0152373463,
0.0316133685,
0.0572350249,
0.0216256827,
-0.0122016212,
-0.0325866379,
0.0392748043,
-0.0078124977,
-0.0426506698,
0.0016079446,
-6.985915172e-33,
-0.0195309948,
-0.0702835694,
0.0082438327,
-0.0515694208,
-0.0298202299,
-0.0068270075,
-0.0190263744,
0.0288969651,
-0.0305949934,
0.0196954608,
-0.0134521965,
0.0241517965,
0.0020832808,
0.0069960291,
0.0138954539,
-0.0248543583,
0.0182009544,
0.0021172606,
-0.0173949264,
0.0183769595,
0.0059394101,
0.008569235,
0.0523764491,
-0.0705205724,
0.0629359931,
0.0173549037,
-0.0179501455,
0.0174543392,
-0.0412305705,
0.0748026893,
-0.0426923968,
0.0782178193,
0.0308662411,
-0.0230826624,
-0.0370779745,
0.0044250521,
-0.0130751012,
-0.0402457863,
0.0357912444,
0.0009066532,
-0.0496834107,
-0.0052591092,
0.0604816452,
0.0148492735,
0.0018087318,
-0.0204238445,
0.0431596451,
-0.0260568894,
-0.0375080295,
0.0182472561,
-0.0053139734,
0.0410884246,
-0.0185445882,
0.0258117486,
0.0042667678,
0.0409829617,
-0.0000794854,
0.0491126142,
-0.0604007728,
0.0432248525,
0.0725583881,
-0.0109345233,
0.0732661635,
-0.0001749702,
0.0260875076,
0.070663631,
0.0126029551,
-0.0044298689,
-0.0217383355,
-0.0244492739,
0.0136580467,
0.0606695935,
0.0871384218,
0.0197380558,
0.007030732,
-0.0008474616,
-0.0600703321,
0.0229801722,
-0.0267176051,
0.0474583209,
0.0092233596,
0.0317583568,
-0.0314245969,
-0.0074847303,
-0.0329596996,
-0.0067360564,
-0.0510602146,
-0.0066034654,
0.0286275186,
-0.0578654595,
-0.0231003594,
0.0136404214,
-0.0048787524,
-0.0184204821,
-0.0424445122,
-0.0159190055,
0.0069217724,
0.0478496514,
0.0203945581,
0.0234568398,
-0.0107831033,
0.0128811076,
0.0036910838,
0.010103384,
0.0203134269,
0.0051206006,
0.0089943968,
-0.0312527083,
-0.0681323558,
0.0181885026,
-0.0333385244,
-0.0195852928,
-0.0022648971,
-0.0164652728,
0.0340324827,
-0.0078652296,
-0.0266827866,
0.0403778329,
0.0344413556,
0.0426884741,
0.0125342077,
0.0091674691,
-0.0242747106,
0.0036108142,
-0.0147472918,
-0.0272074714,
-0.0410197526,
-0.0234835334,
0.0687785223,
-0.0492307618,
-0.0273060128,
-0.0075875958,
2.952e-7,
0.1056784913,
0.0680903122,
0.0235097539,
0.0434429273,
0.037464682,
0.0108531527,
-0.0109526422,
0.0209416971,
0.0155697204,
-0.0132882819,
-0.0335211009,
0.0065564285,
0.0494974181,
0.080915384,
-0.0323803909,
-0.0234059803,
-0.0705028623,
-0.0315497108,
-0.086418733,
0.0016614071,
0.0873653069,
0.0748906955,
-0.01036877,
0.007964029,
-0.0317721404,
-0.0571197681,
0.0542524047,
-0.0432793908,
-0.0070348685,
0.000580947,
0.0421359055,
0.0399410874,
0.0283649918,
0.0317961462,
-0.0056295767,
-0.0360228196,
0.0163447727,
0.0302367806,
-0.0087298313,
-0.0209915806,
0.0036520807,
-0.0153476913,
0.0323450714,
-0.1146763712,
0.083448261,
-0.0160770863,
-0.0294450987,
-0.0221817885,
0.0117401741,
-0.033385355,
0.0998127759,
-0.0544594936,
-0.0336027369,
0.0370922312,
0.0022047993,
-0.0118068429,
-0.0373389013,
-0.0262867194,
-0.0387434922,
-0.0200366061,
-0.0303379055,
-0.0297932345,
-0.0567607544,
-0.0006745749,
-0.0160673652,
-0.0769162178,
0.0103816688,
2.892003778e-34,
0.0496414304,
0.0107196039,
0.031002583,
0.0242017321,
0.0627539381,
0.0027814379,
0.0258601811,
0.0284713749,
-0.0043807677,
-0.0838909671,
-0.000881259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00416v1 | Towards Healthy AI: Large Language Models Need Therapists Too | 2023-04-02T00:39:12 | 2023-04-02T00:39:12 | Baihan Lin, Djallel Bouneffouf, Guillermo Cecchi, Kush R. Varshney | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have led to the development
of powerful AI chatbots capable of engaging in natural and human-like
conversations. However, these chatbots can be potentially harmful, exhibiting
manipulative, gaslighting, and narcissistic behaviors. We define Healthy AI to
be safe, trustworthy and ethical. To create healthy AI systems, we present the
SafeguardGPT framework that uses psychotherapy to correct for these harmful
behaviors in AI chatbots. The framework involves four types of AI agents: a
Chatbot, a "User," a "Therapist," and a "Critic." We demonstrate the
effectiveness of SafeguardGPT through a working example of simulating a social
conversation. Our results show that the framework can improve the quality of
conversations between AI chatbots and humans. Although there are still several
challenges and directions to be addressed in the future, SafeguardGPT provides
a promising approach to improving the alignment between AI chatbots and human
values. By incorporating psychotherapy and reinforcement learning techniques,
the framework enables AI chatbots to learn and adapt to human preferences and
values in a safe and ethical way, contributing to the development of a more
human-centric and responsible AI. | [
0.0958089232,
0.0481862016,
-0.0466363989,
-0.0190635789,
-0.0415655226,
-0.0066532856,
-0.0080026081,
0.0022653304,
0.0709629357,
0.0116731171,
-0.0371964686,
-0.011862373,
-0.0185079612,
0.0438601971,
-0.0188492276,
-0.0876715034,
0.0491605699,
-0.0016639058,
0.0679190531,
-0.0036363497,
0.0355866477,
0.0254651178,
-0.0069580851,
0.0518478863,
-0.0272909254,
-0.0153686972,
-0.0016288015,
-0.0056503359,
0.0379417725,
-0.0222140644,
0.0302791391,
0.0123191988,
0.0096255867,
0.0211185273,
0.00000195,
-0.0381516814,
0.0031509798,
0.0011868848,
0.027987631,
-0.0485520214,
0.093491964,
-0.0141122686,
-0.0236338582,
0.0466264263,
-0.0578887947,
0.024738973,
0.0288149901,
0.0751363784,
0.0979214609,
0.0853440166,
-0.0112794871,
0.0271567628,
0.0279090516,
0.0173354689,
-0.0004729232,
-0.0525549613,
0.0189759638,
0.010496309,
0.0253673233,
0.0281125475,
-0.0130727654,
0.0071656429,
0.0123980474,
-0.0217387676,
0.0003946053,
0.0153763443,
-0.0194130149,
-0.0746279061,
-0.0222581197,
0.0680946261,
0.0301446747,
-0.0003661271,
0.0278570335,
0.0143127507,
0.0314685218,
-0.0478705503,
-0.0132067204,
0.0331872329,
-0.0152937444,
0.0022765128,
0.0276757516,
-0.0216287505,
0.0121815307,
0.0334502645,
0.050848946,
-0.0031098102,
-0.0140382349,
-0.0228007343,
0.0073539657,
0.014136414,
-0.0123424623,
-0.0500086397,
0.0165692605,
0.0523611531,
-0.0715766624,
0.0253897868,
-0.0532695726,
0.0161100123,
0.0069999895,
-0.0276500918,
-0.022166105,
0.0473394617,
-0.0004585299,
0.0257382207,
0.0476616696,
0.0412367173,
0.0090889959,
0.0508654714,
-0.0133370832,
0.0007040313,
-0.0324920863,
-0.0207068361,
-0.029311398,
0.0178506821,
0.0262956675,
0.0096333763,
-0.0291742627,
0.0459768809,
-0.0769121125,
0.0349325761,
-0.0224181581,
0.0105097815,
-0.013833534,
-0.01010748,
-0.0580978021,
0.0071365214,
-0.0556450896,
-0.0204373971,
0.0191761535,
-0.0732217506,
0.0018763543,
0.0028923131,
-0.0344319865,
-0.0009071663,
0.0234712474,
0.0980693549,
0.0042326101,
-0.037048243,
0.0006818893,
-0.0236631725,
-0.0185274389,
-0.0586755201,
0.0223686974,
-0.0125585468,
0.0351126082,
-0.025029188,
-0.0207384154,
-0.0694195926,
0.0315264501,
0.0267003402,
-0.060712833,
0.0455237925,
-0.0132292546,
0.0002756261,
0.0187823288,
0.0508312881,
-0.0403456762,
0.0301748049,
0.0200754777,
0.0239840932,
0.0298918076,
-0.0173184332,
0.0369019732,
-0.0027154598,
-0.0150234392,
-0.0113275386,
-0.0172955636,
-0.0018093134,
-0.0069013704,
0.0360463038,
-0.0151860323,
0.0587094389,
-0.0448224135,
0.0021905282,
0.0855421647,
0.0426173359,
-0.0604329742,
0.0611329004,
0.013183157,
0.0289266352,
0.0119999237,
-0.0141397975,
-0.070051156,
0.0304925647,
-0.03660978,
-0.0569861494,
-0.0311223641,
-0.005681315,
-0.0191881042,
-0.0532450154,
0.027219722,
-0.0301651936,
0.0582648888,
0.022953786,
0.0023690353,
-0.0004490004,
-0.0220485628,
-0.054885231,
0.0465833321,
-0.0272526871,
-0.0351892449,
-0.0790620819,
0.0412006527,
0.1125833839,
0.078060098,
-0.0386795849,
-0.0376012474,
-0.0436486565,
-0.0349754281,
0.0386237651,
0.0501420833,
-0.0112037323,
-0.0072634621,
-0.0185413323,
-0.0089057749,
0.0259959474,
-0.0151698468,
-0.000224469,
0.0198700652,
0.0153444353,
-0.0324420743,
0.037084803,
-0.0299419463,
0.036510203,
-0.0106558483,
-0.006710066,
-0.0180092975,
-0.004388344,
0.0332705602,
0.0045423163,
-0.0047798394,
-0.0187946819,
0.0038462307,
0.027183013,
-0.023837246,
0.0281486288,
-0.046886865,
0.0280848444,
0.0268155914,
-0.0250049494,
-0.036188744,
0.0771318153,
0.0004971283,
0.0195412058,
0.0171422679,
-0.042366568,
0.0148937702,
-0.0235549975,
0.0090084253,
-0.061180234,
0.0115921851,
-0.0245600399,
0.0144623145,
-0.0094685545,
-0.0556403287,
-0.0211604238,
-0.0045101917,
-0.0306798574,
-0.019029025,
-0.017769767,
0.0072536105,
0.0115516484,
0.0404230803,
0.0757302195,
0.0405628309,
-0.0479304306,
-0.0194464102,
-0.0926034302,
-0.0134385889,
0.0036374044,
-0.0198219903,
0.0015620209,
-0.0161999762,
-0.0109230997,
-0.0033006021,
-0.0421012305,
0.0364651196,
0.0268969629,
0.026863724,
0.0350431055,
-0.0133026699,
-0.0341520831,
-0.0470940098,
0.0315626189,
-0.0269240141,
-0.026345253,
-0.0068149078,
0.0140263168,
-0.038250085,
0.0113828247,
-0.039147459,
0.0320149772,
-0.0095066633,
-0.0755918249,
0.0252106823,
0.010595358,
0.0196092669,
0.0934448615,
0.0549648218,
0.0820583329,
0.0321891382,
0.0450729281,
-0.0589353815,
0.0314961411,
0.0142195811,
-0.0293834824,
-0.0306459293,
-0.0400618166,
-0.0044667027,
0.0566729046,
-0.0112915616,
0.0243100263,
-0.0780358091,
0.0497878939,
-0.0065094815,
-0.0568961166,
0.0221981686,
-0.0346506573,
-0.0151652787,
-0.0027228829,
-0.0137519957,
-0.0412994251,
0.0996585116,
0.0337341279,
0.0201039892,
-0.030467432,
-0.0427711606,
0.0192207843,
0.0341775976,
-0.0007891367,
0.0285037607,
0.0321334898,
-0.0033480583,
-0.0403419659,
-0.0549882427,
0.0229382217,
-0.0557026416,
-0.0113149807,
-0.0408455506,
-0.0279576629,
0.0498244949,
-0.0380514972,
-0.0737375841,
-0.0299060009,
-0.0464535058,
-0.0157903954,
0.0163268838,
-0.0136939362,
-0.0473213568,
-0.0490015931,
0.038681142,
-0.0009055347,
-0.0205800943,
-0.0246682353,
-0.0074815969,
-0.0648710951,
0.057228487,
-0.0336656049,
0.0421669185,
-0.0086270375,
0.0683477521,
0.0531352535,
-0.0114488145,
0.0028339864,
-0.0110000409,
-0.020885054,
-0.0130990697,
0.0106848469,
0.0122915637,
0.0166215431,
0.0396093726,
-0.020393718,
-0.0456586331,
0.0926868841,
0.0149540734,
-0.0435764007,
0.0381857678,
-0.0194737576,
0.0067824898,
-0.0038120812,
0.0267689452,
-0.0520011261,
-0.0194357578,
0.0021493016,
0.0355471186,
-0.0498764701,
-0.0578598343,
0.0200913008,
-0.0633815676,
0.0031929065,
-0.0044213547,
-0.0011198723,
-0.0549362004,
-0.0149308834,
-0.0213360768,
-0.0164130088,
0.0424587801,
-0.0094459932,
0.0146970553,
-0.032397218,
-0.0206552316,
-0.0251303017,
0.007256099,
0.0420849994,
-0.0509217568,
0.09971793,
0.098531276,
0.0660718232,
-0.0159665458,
0.0005288167,
-0.021373678,
0.0893432945,
0.004721649,
0.0312549733,
0.0300797168,
-0.0130088413,
0.0050223093,
-0.0358734392,
0.0273716021,
0.0010500996,
-0.0237414241,
0.0308445618,
0.0524222292,
-0.0241945907,
-0.0328745991,
-0.0223998185,
0.0454266556,
0.0438978747,
0.0487006009,
-0.02079615,
-0.0690890849,
-0.0330065079,
-0.0211105105,
-0.0149375601,
0.0047920668,
-0.0476269759,
-0.00127882,
-0.0302382372,
-0.0177629348,
-0.0854691789,
-0.0690208897,
-0.0015226619,
-0.012625074,
0.0061387494,
-0.0807968304,
0.0191358831,
0.0473703891,
0.0191010274,
0.0083663231,
-0.0431893505,
0.0063715358,
-0.009434768,
0.0125041241,
0.0144559126,
-0.053264644,
0.0260918774,
0.0218420252,
0.011065024,
-0.0333132409,
0.025881974,
0.0716829821,
0.0182637721,
0.043825902,
-0.0114859911,
-0.0260914657,
-0.0108003262,
0.0240553245,
-0.0469986647,
-0.018175697,
0.0264120419,
0.0261188261,
0.0080702603,
0.0129563799,
-0.0374442041,
0.0160671696,
0.0082756775,
0.0020990828,
-0.0026705069,
-0.0112060728,
0.0515274145,
0.0325826034,
-0.0073368819,
-0.0008033833,
0.0209740568,
0.0111984899,
-0.0304166153,
-0.0414438508,
-0.019721359,
0.0006826405,
-0.0035257856,
0.0060273246,
0.0060804617,
-0.0016285501,
-0.0343403779,
-0.0483684689,
0.0235960409,
-0.000849652,
-0.0212160703,
-0.007885145,
0.0266578626,
-0.0066470141,
-0.0073200502,
-0.0082648713,
0.0283311326,
-0.0031038991,
0.0265364945,
-0.0055610081,
0.0825514272,
0.0232579987,
-0.0103416936,
0.0095280316,
0.0393763259,
-0.0554859042,
-0.0784760267,
0.0125875538,
0.0277870428,
0.0097997617,
0.0537979454,
0.0186008886,
-0.0708156154,
0.0033896931,
-0.0059225578,
0.0351864547,
-0.0163854286,
-0.0273961257,
-0.0370559618,
0.0274052788,
-0.013663264,
-0.0080738291,
0.0244051572,
-0.0380543433,
0.0551598743,
-0.0046948297,
-0.0248774346,
-0.0270974971,
-0.006914068,
0.0117551135,
-0.0034653458,
-0.010819952,
-0.0094738407,
-0.0329204015,
-0.0549138635,
-0.0259440057,
0.0180726238,
-0.0021907333,
-0.0399655476,
0.0229879823,
0.0133870598,
-0.0152962813,
-0.0057756952,
-0.0407878906,
0.0084670577,
-0.0210348032,
0.0056551094,
-0.0218751635,
-5.416989107e-33,
0.0173821934,
-0.0137605015,
0.0165885333,
0.0229462795,
-0.0520213172,
-0.0567789264,
-0.0156416669,
0.0043682409,
-0.0264268722,
0.0391634591,
-0.0207227282,
0.0488540977,
-0.0085545089,
-0.0290758051,
0.0233740173,
-0.0308676679,
0.028554922,
-0.0246981867,
-0.0300776213,
0.0431817435,
-0.0139557356,
0.0156220905,
0.0441300347,
-0.0702790171,
0.0203867387,
0.0204593949,
-0.0450373925,
0.0293091964,
-0.0183645301,
0.0269412007,
0.0269890763,
0.0634725317,
0.0063048447,
-0.0033172136,
0.0116344215,
0.0602361746,
-0.0098204026,
-0.0399500392,
0.0039458033,
-0.004055466,
-0.0666573942,
-0.0462580882,
-0.0024753867,
-0.0509132296,
-0.0222070888,
0.0122988401,
0.0001405062,
-0.0145112853,
0.0155793456,
0.0189380907,
-0.0597033761,
-0.0349486023,
-0.0549982339,
-0.0620534942,
-0.0290667396,
0.0521634966,
-0.0169818383,
0.0128301345,
-0.0221707728,
0.031556163,
-0.0003790232,
-0.0423634835,
0.009676205,
-0.0089995535,
0.0161773097,
0.0435883813,
0.0467288569,
0.0609146431,
-0.0254350808,
-0.0216524862,
0.036711175,
0.0203553904,
0.0328788422,
0.0276983045,
-0.050028611,
-0.0748651996,
-0.0355144553,
0.0096024498,
0.045456063,
0.0454546735,
0.0149989352,
0.0000515108,
-0.0564371943,
-0.0049868715,
-0.0340806246,
-0.0212039482,
-0.0109477127,
-0.0564926378,
0.0090613998,
0.0016976452,
-0.0260771979,
-0.035459172,
0.0003136666,
-0.0813936591,
0.0468275808,
0.0200982578,
-0.0327237397,
-0.0163677074,
-0.0041430979,
0.0003362791,
-0.0172134116,
-0.0433833078,
0.0172258839,
-0.0348549932,
0.0542517118,
0.0047861533,
0.0278590173,
0.0326091088,
-0.0140052587,
-0.0159233641,
-0.0276871361,
0.0914703831,
0.0079003451,
-0.004760474,
-0.0190101042,
0.0227921307,
-0.019616127,
0.0401405282,
0.040079508,
0.0229716357,
-0.0664793849,
0.0402600467,
-0.0156082371,
-0.023453081,
-0.0356948487,
-0.0215872526,
-0.0598479435,
0.0252087452,
0.0233457703,
-0.0683838502,
-0.0248244721,
-0.042853523,
2.632e-7,
-0.0450401604,
0.0673902407,
0.0123341,
0.0489290245,
0.0174898971,
0.0979417115,
0.0228697415,
0.0894593447,
-0.0119079966,
-0.0382241234,
0.039004907,
0.0272202268,
0.064955242,
0.0296427924,
-0.0287608784,
0.0005942205,
-0.0697419047,
-0.0447713286,
-0.0376342647,
0.0073890504,
0.0688194558,
0.0433130227,
0.0247593336,
-0.0205386709,
0.019470375,
0.0382930152,
0.0347411893,
-0.0512554273,
-0.0255438183,
0.0229020752,
0.0063547366,
0.0254071224,
0.0186326765,
0.0168034025,
0.0193113498,
0.0136889173,
-0.0187955201,
0.0958522931,
-0.0596926063,
-0.0407052375,
0.0126343071,
0.0393579267,
-0.0006934797,
-0.0252609085,
0.0344440751,
-0.0721278414,
-0.0365542471,
-0.037193682,
-0.0271890908,
-0.0291171037,
0.0358590931,
-0.0261850972,
-0.0458394289,
0.0268880539,
-0.0049201488,
0.0351599418,
0.015985921,
-0.0276200939,
0.0410857275,
-0.0101465471,
-0.0137667619,
-0.0521612093,
0.0111140497,
0.0377348326,
-0.013154312,
-0.0361131765,
0.0473393649,
1.717476684e-34,
-0.0098487558,
-0.018686967,
0.0204836018,
0.0237529799,
0.0513449535,
0.0605541356,
0.0049720574,
0.0406160876,
0.0272903517,
-0.0107895248,
-0.0179476459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00363v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00363v1 | Automatic Authorship Attribution in the Work of Tirso de Molina | 2023-04-01T18:05:14 | 2023-04-01T18:05:14 | Miguel Cavadas, Pablo Gamallo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic Authorship Attribution (AAA) is the result of applying tools and
techniques from Digital Humanities to authorship attribution studies. Through a
quantitative and statistical approach this discipline can draw further
conclusions about renowned authorship issues which traditional critics have
been dealing with for centuries, opening a new door to style comparison. The
aim of this paper is to prove the potential of these tools and techniques by
testing the authorship of five comedies traditionally attributed to Spanish
playwright Tirso de Molina (1579-1648): La ninfa del cielo, El burlador de
Sevilla, Tan largo me lo fiais, La mujer por fuerza and El condenado por
desconfiado. To accomplish this purpose some experiments concerning clustering
analysis by Stylo package from R and four distance measures are carried out on
a corpus built with plays by Tirso, Andres de Claramonte (c. 1560-1626),
Antonio Mira de Amescua (1577-1644) and Luis Velez de Guevara (1579-1644). The
results obtained point to the denial of all the attributions to Tirso except
for the case of La mujer por fuerza. | [
0.0130149145,
0.0185390469,
-0.0389418416,
0.0329863131,
-0.0375945829,
-0.0004202308,
0.0691768155,
0.0205000304,
-0.0066111274,
-0.0202069543,
0.0251125339,
0.0119109256,
0.0616966821,
-0.0658260807,
0.0141087547,
0.0141174346,
-0.055813998,
0.0279496983,
0.0319431573,
0.0084282039,
-0.0030632885,
0.0076396782,
0.0230441131,
0.0360347368,
0.038681563,
-0.0083665214,
0.0677912682,
-0.0087704081,
0.0450847,
0.0161149316,
-0.0232734513,
0.0641633943,
-0.0466779359,
0.0927485898,
0.0000015873,
-0.0417072438,
-0.0229764488,
-0.0253195893,
0.0767079219,
-0.0419189371,
0.069444336,
0.0836504921,
-0.0306054931,
-0.0325297825,
-0.005417781,
0.0155954771,
0.0228543431,
-0.0117631732,
-0.0341503955,
0.0608888529,
-0.0234945919,
-0.0971115381,
0.0420017913,
0.0123562794,
0.0193275586,
0.0432053395,
0.0179930273,
-0.0271315724,
0.0207607523,
0.0354085453,
0.0046594935,
0.0159844458,
-0.0402326025,
-0.0291399788,
-0.0145893944,
-0.0218122136,
-0.0594337061,
0.0201795697,
0.0524854586,
-0.0160832033,
0.0308332704,
-0.0368071049,
0.0512171835,
0.0488114692,
-0.0099339532,
0.0819884539,
0.0076744617,
0.0128026009,
-0.049290482,
-0.0447961763,
0.0170415156,
0.0246662814,
0.0002577571,
0.0223247912,
0.0375158079,
-0.0004415826,
-0.0067463168,
-0.0092686098,
0.0273363646,
-0.0354622453,
-0.0194295123,
-0.0752990246,
0.0186136253,
0.0353058241,
0.0587771572,
-0.0230579935,
0.0307328813,
-0.0665861219,
0.0225743316,
-0.0290804133,
0.0135875801,
0.0093996972,
0.004949321,
0.014099801,
0.0141802318,
0.0072281165,
0.0008029336,
0.005030686,
-0.0105389711,
0.0018282625,
-0.0541333035,
-0.0080233673,
-0.0614103898,
-0.0516102798,
0.0423543602,
0.0452591777,
-0.0348015539,
-0.0435418859,
0.0016851474,
0.0002696819,
-0.0256047901,
-0.0016159149,
-0.0013628395,
0.0172397513,
-0.0400019921,
0.013910762,
-0.0539730862,
0.0124302097,
-0.060819,
-0.0262607187,
0.0001297918,
0.0625028014,
0.0274449103,
-0.0579071008,
0.0369633511,
-0.0322671346,
0.0119225485,
-0.0775794163,
0.032611642,
-0.0441078395,
-0.0379934832,
-0.0378899537,
-0.0040505305,
-0.0620643646,
0.0123473071,
-0.0294374432,
0.0120896427,
-0.0060244817,
-0.0276498795,
0.0398646817,
-0.0256672408,
-0.0255724285,
-0.0180597194,
0.0050727325,
0.0400416739,
-0.0157111231,
-0.0548695326,
-0.038744811,
0.0678478479,
0.0280730333,
0.0176569484,
0.0179088805,
0.0616025031,
-0.0105320718,
-0.0362992473,
-0.0005418949,
0.0160874929,
-0.0001115179,
0.0166673213,
0.039141871,
0.0047548311,
0.0074976124,
-0.0048433607,
0.0002846757,
0.0272293091,
0.0563513078,
0.0554803982,
0.03051994,
0.0431991294,
-0.0080597,
0.0799937546,
-0.0216346681,
0.0147380205,
0.0149620455,
0.0317818336,
0.004918979,
-0.0374550782,
0.0536184572,
0.0227871761,
0.0099900244,
0.0126054147,
0.0387737639,
-0.0058740429,
-0.0430469364,
-0.0093566645,
-0.0073918942,
0.0119345188,
-0.0782478005,
-0.014683011,
-0.0233711116,
-0.0006292283,
-0.0105770035,
0.0359268412,
0.0168200303,
0.0684438199,
-0.0418252274,
0.0497350097,
-0.0053496305,
-0.003868978,
-0.0221966654,
-0.0880563706,
-0.0266718231,
0.0084006935,
-0.0239866152,
0.0132532129,
0.0077088969,
-0.0045785871,
0.0339226276,
-0.0445687957,
0.0552915409,
-0.0063089496,
-0.0085155014,
-0.0017686844,
0.0273365006,
0.008200109,
-0.0708103776,
-0.0010664734,
0.0028657613,
0.0335630588,
0.0158124007,
-0.0399928726,
-0.0431446098,
0.0297508594,
-0.0092287818,
-0.0065628551,
0.072568804,
-0.0021501156,
0.0175072476,
0.0318836607,
-0.0662417263,
0.0249467436,
-0.0397282243,
0.0012101338,
-0.0291391741,
0.0521411672,
-0.0374337286,
-0.0070457258,
-0.0002997731,
0.0380959846,
-0.059770491,
-0.0106073087,
-0.0423804186,
0.0547844134,
0.0458631441,
0.0961802378,
-0.0248062797,
-0.0346110314,
0.0302749928,
-0.0204278957,
-0.0118941022,
-0.0461019203,
0.0176493749,
0.0486271046,
0.0437738225,
-0.0274480209,
0.0101221027,
-0.0825872123,
-0.0203453414,
-0.0124058221,
-0.0023816554,
-0.015386261,
-0.0059418306,
-0.018072987,
-0.0177702401,
-0.0082874224,
0.0076520955,
-0.0418153703,
-0.0307002813,
-0.0343374386,
0.0509507395,
0.0180284083,
-0.0173406173,
-0.0107717281,
0.0144522227,
-0.0303750597,
0.0146260029,
0.0785958096,
-0.0071925553,
-0.0045034564,
-0.0174402334,
-0.0419098698,
-0.0071050548,
-0.0149452845,
-0.0081096012,
-0.0062157256,
0.0141453966,
-0.0047969092,
0.05039341,
-0.0297068227,
-0.0262701157,
0.0373513401,
-0.0432560816,
0.0241926741,
-0.0179826096,
0.020424189,
0.0221077073,
-0.0190801229,
-0.0757424086,
0.0520093031,
0.0059220782,
-0.0012111703,
-0.0459237881,
-0.0028711699,
0.0070513911,
0.0128189279,
0.0358260609,
0.0823506042,
-0.0295791682,
0.0126549071,
0.0290433597,
-0.0127985124,
0.004703003,
0.0048534493,
-0.0472574979,
-0.0081854975,
-0.0631464496,
-0.0187362786,
-0.0329166949,
0.0395179689,
0.0483400933,
0.0276790205,
-0.0005025177,
-0.0085660107,
-0.0302956607,
0.0171554722,
0.0959415808,
0.000448185,
0.003066465,
0.0551496893,
-0.0124111939,
-0.0039872304,
0.0302616004,
0.0113443453,
-0.032223098,
-0.0145611987,
-0.0215136744,
0.017601084,
-0.0584872216,
-0.0414150879,
-0.0522637591,
0.0207233634,
0.0371945277,
0.0194545053,
-0.016036585,
-0.0286229067,
0.0454209708,
-0.0270967968,
-0.0326552354,
-0.058133699,
-0.0137330312,
-0.03409281,
-0.0216032304,
-0.0630960613,
0.0096265245,
-0.0150290094,
-0.0247000903,
-0.0161055401,
-0.0253788549,
-0.0621842444,
-0.0332343914,
0.0228973459,
-0.0009321677,
0.0252174791,
0.0781492144,
0.0090598548,
-0.0386994667,
-0.025704721,
-0.0196868796,
-0.0418681316,
0.0130108129,
0.0212481767,
-0.009751617,
0.0634538457,
-0.0162148941,
0.0147911552,
-0.0275927745,
-0.0442006625,
-0.0006062479,
-0.0438010767,
0.0206294768,
-0.0209957473,
-0.0250594225,
0.0147470022,
-0.0406361558,
-0.0097963633,
-0.0105572166,
-0.0759770572,
-0.0036228946,
0.0259876326,
0.0234632548,
0.0080230813,
-0.0025445509,
0.0085691651,
-0.0191222932,
-0.0685027316,
-0.0306936931,
-0.0056935227,
0.0933486149,
-0.0521494336,
-0.0459373444,
-0.0909261554,
-0.0183270406,
-0.0252311211,
-0.0144218449,
0.0894037709,
0.0136545682,
0.0242142621,
-0.0346062221,
-0.0343273357,
0.0544143952,
-0.0189819969,
0.059682712,
0.0477930754,
0.031626977,
-0.0138033163,
0.0169019606,
0.015852198,
-0.0332206413,
-0.0105590252,
-0.0078214658,
0.0185739677,
0.000956026,
-0.0140753668,
0.0380202942,
0.0187402461,
-0.0315904655,
-0.0190296471,
-0.0197209679,
-0.0948335007,
-0.056787435,
0.0077540041,
-0.0645192936,
0.0674208179,
0.0748822093,
0.0161713846,
-0.0051492592,
-0.0243175905,
-0.0378297791,
0.0032490776,
0.0185742062,
0.0105771143,
-0.0103163188,
-0.0027431543,
-0.0136297159,
0.0037508551,
0.0283202063,
-0.0280349944,
-0.0764434859,
-0.0117115919,
-0.0221953318,
0.0125359464,
0.0240206383,
0.0146388831,
-0.0598873608,
-0.0807575732,
0.0380279683,
0.0127537986,
0.000453204,
0.0506274961,
-0.0493118688,
-0.0474133231,
-0.0304045361,
-0.0006007135,
0.0193432961,
0.0148286428,
0.0178451855,
-0.0455799922,
-0.0151776187,
-0.0187211689,
-0.0392183624,
-0.0067987856,
0.0430785492,
-0.0711043626,
0.0495383665,
0.030405499,
-0.0347372368,
-0.0036253596,
0.0189088956,
0.0537074469,
0.0001344858,
0.0058147614,
-0.0435449034,
-0.0100551844,
-0.0035259444,
-0.0312714316,
0.0197550878,
0.0175504163,
0.0368554629,
0.0620667785,
0.0732380003,
-0.0128409779,
0.0363333933,
0.026348941,
-0.0162750818,
0.0249371771,
0.084558934,
0.0096553294,
-0.0471950434,
0.0269011091,
0.0129252281,
-0.0188602787,
0.0529429354,
-0.0304504838,
0.0153852515,
0.001657995,
-0.0579211265,
-0.0118046785,
-0.0306269117,
0.0291351918,
0.0342537723,
-0.0001380601,
0.0022623558,
0.0104285683,
0.0211230163,
0.0335310064,
-0.0629233867,
-0.014810089,
-0.0263735261,
0.0426557697,
0.0343132801,
-0.0391487479,
-0.0363874286,
0.0221609361,
-0.0839749426,
0.0240340345,
-0.0300860964,
-0.0269329492,
-0.049617283,
0.0172947515,
-0.0593082272,
-0.0441097841,
-0.0116129629,
0.0580943562,
-0.0369418971,
0.0559318736,
-0.0147712622,
0.0232003499,
0.03848809,
-0.0150938751,
0.0119861392,
-0.0658146739,
0.0576059036,
-0.0025327646,
0.0000814539,
-0.0147284977,
-5.184232777e-33,
-0.0046004909,
-0.0432703048,
0.0085671376,
0.034434475,
-0.0135677122,
-0.0494789034,
-0.0263283066,
-0.0445296094,
0.0406452902,
0.017755257,
-0.0348896831,
0.0119624482,
-0.0032748827,
-0.0437014662,
0.0228342917,
0.0552782863,
0.0090336436,
0.004631483,
-0.048843056,
-0.0176074691,
0.025551416,
-0.0117040733,
0.0043045683,
-0.0649957508,
0.0445082858,
-0.0564376079,
-0.0259590913,
-0.008785205,
0.0289915111,
0.0027920986,
0.0317555107,
-0.0410160944,
0.0001042292,
0.0182140451,
0.0074947337,
0.0246334895,
-0.0087948814,
-0.0766838938,
0.0219920743,
0.0374561958,
0.0857420638,
-0.0685082749,
0.0040711546,
-0.0147808427,
-0.0336241946,
0.0036642591,
0.0769018531,
0.0060584159,
-0.032832358,
-0.0724464506,
-0.0133450376,
0.0018831913,
-0.006375771,
-0.0006011302,
0.0397391617,
0.0022585623,
0.018063711,
-0.0098807951,
-0.0308927298,
0.0221994203,
-0.0660068616,
0.0055829934,
-0.0553452969,
0.0302504972,
0.033385776,
0.0212063957,
0.0130942082,
0.0274577718,
0.0003192344,
0.0874722376,
0.0135918017,
0.0067567937,
0.0126910675,
0.0664917678,
0.0204634443,
0.0210764073,
-0.0055917818,
0.0082469229,
-0.026736455,
0.0028325645,
0.0257747583,
-0.0084254164,
-0.0071138623,
-0.0396767631,
0.0184699576,
-0.0486492589,
0.0358664729,
0.0046047433,
-0.0665534884,
-0.0140708201,
0.0056749349,
-0.0264661424,
-0.0206359215,
-0.055751767,
-0.0066592013,
-0.0424926057,
-0.0622837394,
0.1145193577,
0.0123161972,
0.0386487618,
0.0211812295,
-0.0071519827,
0.0227341969,
0.0767793804,
0.0211028326,
-0.0165697671,
0.0642493144,
-0.0018702055,
-0.038397599,
-0.008909585,
0.0341413468,
-0.0057560285,
0.0086169699,
0.0174850766,
-0.0182757992,
0.0497914329,
0.0493856519,
0.0107062589,
0.0538240522,
0.0280418061,
0.0085577462,
0.0261786617,
0.0273291711,
-0.0344630778,
-0.0059978608,
-0.0066121183,
0.0199840721,
-0.0123565206,
0.0105680237,
-0.0049859323,
-0.0077045583,
-0.0988944471,
2.664e-7,
0.0545240901,
0.0041402299,
0.0330852307,
0.0020628229,
0.0045961994,
0.0197388865,
-0.0065653804,
0.010046578,
-0.0235129446,
0.0489455052,
0.0437946208,
-0.0079024108,
0.0114024198,
0.0709141791,
-0.03361132,
-0.055769302,
-0.0296858829,
-0.030755654,
-0.0231977887,
0.0221005566,
-0.0233130828,
0.0175618809,
0.0583994612,
-0.0002200662,
-0.011457203,
-0.0569679141,
0.010057332,
0.0252381377,
0.0227069538,
0.0269647557,
0.0477686152,
-0.058232192,
-0.0167206526,
0.051167056,
0.0331849121,
0.0166695956,
-0.0378425866,
-0.0313163474,
0.0019027735,
0.0804177448,
0.0589046665,
-0.0800430104,
0.0268148314,
-0.0149077056,
-0.0131420912,
0.0879760459,
-0.0118677719,
0.0461125672,
-0.021063691,
-0.0356950127,
0.0305193346,
0.0170360375,
-0.0348170288,
0.0397723019,
0.0122394161,
0.0142828152,
0.0241070334,
-0.0480863228,
0.0064626201,
0.0280473903,
-0.0152082592,
-0.0585002638,
0.0551679246,
0.0146448677,
0.0636917502,
-0.0630039722,
0.0747795328,
2.31911329e-34,
0.0208128877,
-0.0019512745,
-0.042904824,
-0.0274610985,
0.0051918766,
-0.0047942903,
-0.0328471214,
0.0171762202,
0.0170496665,
-0.0023486712,
-0.0191920251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00350v1 | When Crowd Meets Persona: Creating a Large-Scale Open-Domain Persona Dialogue Corpus | 2023-04-01T16:10:36 | 2023-04-01T16:10:36 | Won Ik Cho, Yoon Kyung Lee, Seoyeon Bae, Jihwan Kim, Sangah Park, Moosung Kim, Sowon Hahn, Nam Soo Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Building a natural language dataset requires caution since word semantics is
vulnerable to subtle text change or the definition of the annotated concept.
Such a tendency can be seen in generative tasks like question-answering and
dialogue generation and also in tasks that create a categorization-based
corpus, like topic classification or sentiment analysis. Open-domain
conversations involve two or more crowdworkers freely conversing about any
topic, and collecting such data is particularly difficult for two reasons: 1)
the dataset should be ``crafted" rather than ``obtained" due to privacy
concerns, and 2) paid creation of such dialogues may differ from how
crowdworkers behave in real-world settings. In this study, we tackle these
issues when creating a large-scale open-domain persona dialogue corpus, where
persona implies that the conversation is performed by several actors with a
fixed persona and user-side workers from an unspecified crowd. | [
0.0522572212,
0.0937797278,
-0.0192372575,
0.0576628409,
-0.0238985214,
-0.0104053179,
0.0024059853,
-0.035981819,
-0.0285569467,
-0.0174996965,
-0.0154134957,
-0.0105093708,
0.0124652917,
0.0245266762,
0.0242747292,
-0.0408099331,
0.0271574482,
-0.0018065668,
0.0208591837,
0.0138376458,
0.0402593166,
0.0440281294,
-0.0302298069,
0.0501938015,
-0.0164034888,
-0.0022525352,
-0.0093489438,
-0.0032976978,
0.0560707673,
0.0081330892,
0.0268355254,
0.0650663972,
0.0273041148,
0.0187770519,
0.0000014354,
-0.046249941,
0.0029355439,
0.0090872645,
-0.0127259223,
-0.0694522113,
0.0277997404,
0.0350728817,
0.0109517546,
0.0451504588,
-0.0619025752,
-0.0338794477,
0.0395981371,
0.0496238172,
0.0972174555,
0.0637091845,
-0.0287281629,
-0.0409285575,
-0.0375172421,
-0.0230794549,
-0.0282963198,
-0.0603409633,
-0.0063749333,
-0.0874435604,
-0.015175242,
0.0071974779,
0.0499793775,
-0.0354188904,
-0.0385975987,
-0.0289344452,
0.0222461428,
-0.002851157,
-0.0731590912,
-0.0366910696,
0.014418113,
0.0998015553,
0.0933268368,
0.0071704406,
0.0140824625,
0.0155404378,
0.0410188362,
0.0238332693,
-0.0098936139,
0.0313416347,
-0.0244672131,
0.0035228599,
-0.020360671,
0.0480359308,
-0.0122648254,
0.004666463,
0.0217890758,
0.0096429801,
-0.0085996864,
0.0074977991,
-0.0387991033,
0.0126520488,
0.0004501278,
-0.0515688695,
0.011712404,
-0.0091152638,
-0.0212317277,
0.023796767,
-0.0537552387,
-0.02711864,
0.0155113405,
-0.0352981165,
-0.0065029394,
-0.0130991815,
0.0057564648,
0.0587341934,
0.0466782898,
-0.0284156371,
-0.0054582749,
-0.0194086079,
0.0164299868,
-0.0362061337,
-0.0491655134,
0.0124413539,
-0.0704342499,
0.0005891072,
-0.0381234773,
0.0170907602,
-0.0006705324,
0.0061263014,
-0.0389635004,
0.0027965428,
-0.0058464007,
0.0198522843,
-0.0405025706,
0.0070690429,
-0.0466663502,
0.0342945345,
-0.0614585355,
0.0194745734,
-0.0055092205,
-0.0571411327,
0.0032255054,
0.0039047129,
0.0306657478,
0.0004363928,
-0.0347005911,
-0.0030526933,
0.0131593673,
-0.0148238521,
-0.0100455526,
-0.0720711723,
-0.0043612048,
-0.0418273099,
-0.0437639542,
-0.0453740917,
0.0790792406,
-0.0131305568,
-0.0243953988,
-0.0324943401,
0.0219226032,
0.0546863563,
0.0028673105,
0.099749513,
-0.0221172869,
0.0114293089,
0.0317544863,
0.0166713111,
-0.0122657716,
0.0502971746,
0.0392340012,
-0.0181227122,
0.0672812536,
0.0092444839,
0.0161462091,
0.0208824854,
0.0095499847,
-0.0040949606,
0.0591372699,
0.0481489748,
0.0160709098,
0.0309415981,
0.0227466989,
0.0518691838,
-0.0385414958,
-0.0412911475,
0.0303451903,
0.0626995862,
-0.048703108,
0.0139238061,
-0.0021693655,
0.0607250333,
0.0084432177,
-0.0225136559,
-0.0026292324,
-0.0030708739,
0.0025029045,
-0.0794084594,
0.008074224,
-0.0037351083,
-0.0168681312,
-0.0193217192,
0.0137917483,
-0.0081731733,
-0.0038013502,
0.0014985832,
0.0050398428,
0.0342824422,
-0.0241138767,
0.0380919836,
0.009245039,
-0.1007662788,
0.0007036445,
-0.0310547333,
0.0143540315,
0.0380825028,
0.0355329439,
0.006994342,
-0.0069673974,
-0.0305711795,
-0.0162022803,
0.0496846028,
0.0391285457,
-0.0527244136,
0.0006843131,
-0.0310239941,
-0.007152196,
-0.000537169,
-0.0180672873,
0.0180964246,
0.0457397476,
-0.0193661321,
0.008572327,
0.029318532,
0.0069322824,
-0.0087662349,
-0.0298913326,
0.0080967015,
0.0240170658,
0.0076100989,
0.0377402268,
0.0628670901,
-0.0057819285,
-0.0205558501,
0.0215177294,
-0.0114714475,
-0.0434999205,
0.0601951554,
-0.0047345255,
-0.0076572392,
0.0143459383,
-0.0496547781,
-0.0308739748,
0.0417609923,
-0.0025827291,
-0.0156722851,
0.0106684817,
-0.0461549871,
0.0056742975,
-0.0316592455,
-0.0262691192,
0.0165441036,
0.0333051793,
-0.0247848313,
0.0399692915,
0.0131543698,
-0.0028181619,
-0.0225168206,
0.0193763226,
0.0246880557,
-0.0653330833,
-0.005648524,
-0.0038237111,
0.0405391417,
0.0396495089,
0.027953336,
-0.0548149385,
-0.0656383485,
-0.0203132369,
-0.1231297255,
-0.0045642015,
-0.0068695317,
0.012908265,
0.0064453338,
0.0173603632,
-0.0078205578,
-0.0179342479,
-0.0661061853,
0.0070723393,
-0.0037462264,
0.0024143129,
0.0711959079,
0.0110687269,
0.0169479009,
0.0010379883,
0.0226898678,
0.0086146845,
0.0238444116,
0.0450902618,
-0.02007748,
-0.0340231061,
0.0041045994,
-0.057912793,
0.0186504386,
-0.0292249434,
-0.0182036478,
0.0274784844,
0.0158066936,
0.0558406264,
0.0090527954,
0.041031234,
0.0249281265,
-0.0383546874,
0.0209521521,
0.0037888563,
0.0034233693,
-0.0128995925,
-0.0133586368,
-0.0181715973,
-0.0092884135,
0.0534343347,
0.0283871535,
0.0128115285,
-0.01392671,
-0.058807157,
0.040095523,
-0.0115795499,
-0.0279369336,
0.0077137901,
-0.0005941613,
-0.0287660472,
0.0497426316,
-0.0104183583,
-0.0124753304,
0.0481891409,
-0.0016263017,
0.0082925763,
-0.0400154218,
-0.0063806213,
-0.0498248637,
0.0515257604,
-0.0133257424,
0.0297993645,
0.0075259004,
-0.0249961931,
-0.013028305,
0.0158230197,
0.06526573,
-0.0487235151,
0.0106848124,
-0.032272812,
0.0190536119,
-0.0089505529,
-0.070357807,
-0.0371440686,
-0.0675857887,
-0.0368301533,
-0.027211586,
0.0339299776,
-0.0338919349,
0.0035481597,
-0.0124190534,
-0.0349248126,
0.0015229034,
0.0133093847,
-0.0010919911,
-0.0147889862,
0.0327111818,
0.0030517096,
0.0729937851,
-0.0188534427,
-0.0126098329,
-0.0064562024,
0.0632655993,
0.0260430817,
-0.0261615198,
0.0054233577,
-0.0229499638,
0.0257336367,
-0.0032278833,
-0.0248379186,
-0.0200841296,
0.0659722611,
-0.0264205188,
0.0050024418,
0.0654330179,
0.0259016957,
-0.0637816638,
-0.0115702432,
-0.0182745438,
0.0002571678,
0.0183895379,
-0.0017001507,
-0.0902379826,
-0.0128495088,
-0.0146947512,
0.0746076331,
-0.044333078,
-0.0759366825,
-0.0289597586,
-0.1374633163,
0.0613514148,
-0.0192068592,
-0.0141597623,
0.0401350409,
-0.0497435741,
0.0198555999,
-0.0311471019,
-0.0184212793,
-0.0361922123,
0.0353663899,
0.0198646691,
0.0081248647,
-0.0040609757,
-0.0300888829,
0.0273047779,
-0.0538680069,
0.0836206749,
0.0271157231,
0.0660519004,
0.0190101042,
-0.0416979939,
-0.0366633795,
0.0152116697,
-0.013849631,
-0.0010768506,
0.093087554,
-0.0174448807,
-0.0279707517,
-0.0503991991,
0.0460376218,
-0.0621197857,
0.0014431755,
0.0037943146,
0.0210404806,
-0.0057434668,
0.0083613675,
0.004561489,
0.0151387127,
0.0362189487,
0.0699501932,
-0.0058036051,
-0.0449823402,
-0.0056252354,
-0.0001958842,
0.0042488785,
-0.0595033467,
-0.0524410494,
-0.0253079049,
0.0090054851,
-0.0589190237,
-0.0701784417,
-0.0363212936,
0.0389588512,
0.0383052118,
-0.0219079982,
-0.0312411785,
0.0440709777,
0.0400429256,
-0.0551562347,
0.0579065606,
-0.0368731655,
0.0336974561,
-0.0678464174,
-0.0866158679,
0.0574751832,
0.0020600515,
-0.0226666182,
0.0443162583,
-0.109426491,
-0.0473397411,
0.0099847289,
0.01516366,
0.0175381303,
0.0513575003,
-0.0147630842,
-0.034504395,
-0.029615825,
0.0472956486,
-0.0697927028,
0.0157373119,
0.0108129317,
0.0805364847,
-0.0330086872,
0.0346863791,
-0.00318441,
-0.0074108639,
-0.0286647398,
-0.0057857702,
-0.0524975546,
-0.0914526731,
0.0015956968,
0.0241402332,
0.0345149636,
0.0090740956,
-0.0017507704,
-0.0599378347,
-0.0374576002,
-0.0178015064,
-0.0430227332,
-0.061380811,
-0.033398103,
0.0081745759,
-0.0224780384,
0.00509491,
0.0443381406,
-0.0599098206,
0.0295284241,
-0.0287548471,
-0.0051361253,
0.0882859305,
0.0324446075,
0.0118931914,
0.0011099974,
0.0064431801,
-0.0013372339,
-0.0242734868,
0.0382070392,
0.0093165664,
0.0187109206,
0.0163605679,
0.0079244031,
0.0370453447,
0.0436925925,
-0.0389853455,
-0.046077773,
0.0125133535,
0.0338404402,
-0.0245212484,
0.0284520127,
0.0460864156,
0.0041830181,
-0.0157566909,
0.0040208255,
0.0437461324,
-0.0204642005,
-0.0104019158,
0.0285897776,
0.004636127,
-0.0442465283,
0.0150987105,
0.070146732,
-0.020162696,
0.0133434199,
-0.024048727,
-0.006771002,
-0.0421661101,
-0.0237235446,
0.0012278133,
-0.01959805,
0.026059119,
0.0141600501,
-0.0722818598,
-0.0146953296,
-0.0114174709,
-0.0086983778,
-0.0025071013,
0.0184293743,
0.0378479846,
0.0287996419,
-0.0092092948,
0.0064367773,
-0.0671971366,
0.0172489453,
-0.0267789047,
0.0115141021,
0.0021729439,
-5.175125634e-33,
-0.0410533734,
-0.0647354499,
0.0105100088,
0.019763045,
-0.0448807627,
-0.0265647862,
-0.0168070141,
0.0242516082,
0.0127541572,
-0.003206166,
0.0011243733,
0.0506436415,
0.0106644034,
0.0204185136,
-0.0083595505,
-0.0404834077,
0.0627734885,
-0.0519622229,
-0.0153444037,
0.0737266093,
0.0641707405,
-0.0230864752,
-0.0011832871,
-0.0990874544,
0.0667234361,
-0.0088247424,
-0.0327660367,
0.0539863408,
0.0565390885,
0.0264053661,
0.0001769209,
0.0528834797,
0.0179685634,
0.0115097146,
-0.0050805919,
0.04629362,
-0.0676076934,
-0.0124251423,
0.0022893767,
0.0367047526,
-0.0468427055,
-0.0203242879,
0.0212030988,
0.0044465922,
0.0293134097,
0.0133680021,
0.046976842,
0.0001264505,
0.034930829,
0.0087063089,
-0.0100520132,
0.0163074061,
-0.0179332066,
-0.0288514197,
-0.0104579497,
0.005405359,
0.0118545592,
-0.0112939253,
-0.0789865628,
0.049963586,
-0.0585974865,
-0.0500045717,
-0.0179582667,
0.0402343757,
0.0248448197,
0.0272267349,
0.0311533138,
0.0429118276,
-0.0348961204,
0.0000792492,
-0.0322259888,
0.0480971448,
0.0359461047,
0.1209969223,
0.0206341147,
-0.0084686317,
-0.0064438027,
0.0355272293,
-0.0030514104,
-0.023107864,
-0.006534589,
-0.0226699412,
-0.021822121,
-0.0064772861,
-0.0311244987,
-0.0233570468,
-0.0032503773,
0.0377330445,
-0.0119965253,
-0.0030595001,
-0.0431281179,
-0.0114880623,
0.0013131343,
-0.0509270132,
0.0229864828,
0.0120927291,
-0.0085328324,
0.0070400322,
-0.0013927695,
-0.0281430744,
-0.033551842,
0.0125299068,
0.0121472189,
0.0351492465,
0.0535921529,
0.0171686262,
0.0039197379,
0.0027350008,
-0.0470829494,
-0.0179838333,
-0.0225896854,
0.0777583793,
-0.0580198392,
0.0509221107,
0.0144908838,
0.0186928771,
-0.0283450074,
0.0369345918,
0.0187729411,
0.0328387693,
-0.0212156102,
0.0165494513,
-0.0034973114,
-0.0305970944,
-0.006403923,
-0.002093089,
0.0053670048,
-0.0097924983,
0.0560944788,
-0.024728151,
-0.0187648665,
-0.0564284697,
2.216e-7,
0.0047897263,
0.0040097213,
0.0284273159,
0.052987013,
0.0158039238,
0.0636704117,
0.0252772886,
0.0666843727,
-0.0193848703,
-0.0235986821,
0.0072389604,
0.0221707895,
0.0538814217,
0.0654355958,
-0.1136918291,
-0.0044137486,
0.0088150082,
0.0137985144,
-0.0259294081,
0.014952831,
0.0815652013,
0.0393678322,
0.0647519901,
-0.0080988202,
-0.0083980346,
-0.0121191153,
0.0705881789,
0.0075550126,
-0.0459374823,
0.0087606777,
0.027499048,
0.0103905946,
-0.0057207458,
0.0152953425,
-0.0311612412,
0.039428737,
0.0171295404,
0.0263813511,
-0.0081118913,
-0.0300398506,
-0.0110508911,
-0.0403593406,
-0.010273004,
0.0060389647,
0.0374889448,
-0.0406542644,
-0.0590555184,
-0.0255151764,
-0.0026106879,
-0.0445804745,
0.0076431665,
-0.0042901384,
-0.0397707634,
0.0183523186,
0.0294883996,
-0.0254289005,
0.001564104,
-0.080055967,
0.0212184098,
-0.0270399544,
-0.0668135583,
-0.0582760051,
0.0376066826,
0.0084967995,
0.00517081,
0.0057929959,
0.0402829051,
1.321251633e-34,
-0.0044716601,
0.035834264,
-0.0287677236,
-0.0080644237,
0.0718925074,
-0.0134913083,
0.0035361929,
-0.0334848315,
0.0524519905,
-0.0231161844,
0.0052595232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01938v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models on a Highly-specialized Topic, Radiation Oncology Physics | 2023-04-01T06:04:58 | 2023-04-01T06:04:58 | Jason Holmes, Zhengliang Liu, Lian Zhang, Yuzhen Ding, Terence T. Sio, Lisa A. McGee, Jonathan B. Ashman, Xiang Li, Tianming Liu, Jiajian Shen, Wei Liu | physics.med-ph | physics.med-ph, cs.CL, physics.ed-ph | We present the first study to investigate Large Language Models (LLMs) in
answering radiation oncology physics questions. Because popular exams like AP
Physics, LSAT, and GRE have large test-taker populations and ample test
preparation resources in circulation, they may not allow for accurately
assessing the true potential of LLMs. This paper proposes evaluating LLMs on a
highly-specialized topic, radiation oncology physics, which may be more
pertinent to scientific and medical communities in addition to being a valuable
benchmark of LLMs. We developed an exam consisting of 100 radiation oncology
physics questions based on our expertise at Mayo Clinic. Four LLMs, ChatGPT
(GPT-3.5), ChatGPT (GPT-4), Bard (LaMDA), and BLOOMZ, were evaluated against
medical physicists and non-experts. ChatGPT (GPT-4) outperformed all other LLMs
as well as medical physicists, on average. The performance of ChatGPT (GPT-4)
was further improved when prompted to explain first, then answer. ChatGPT
(GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) showed a high level of consistency in its answer choices
across a number of trials, whether correct or incorrect, a characteristic that
was not observed in the human test groups. In evaluating ChatGPTs (GPT-4)
deductive reasoning ability using a novel approach (substituting the correct
answer with "None of the above choices is the correct answer."), ChatGPT
(GPT-4) demonstrated surprising accuracy, suggesting the potential presence of
an emergent ability. Finally, although ChatGPT (GPT-4) performed well overall,
its intrinsic properties did not allow for further improvement when scoring
based on a majority vote across trials. In contrast, a team of medical
physicists were able to greatly outperform ChatGPT (GPT-4) using a majority
vote. This study suggests a great potential for LLMs to work alongside
radiation oncology experts as highly knowledgeable assistants. | [
0.0558015481,
0.0264741629,
-0.0054914933,
-0.0036712214,
-0.0318641625,
0.0127074383,
0.0430133939,
0.034695942,
0.0274004992,
-0.0161094163,
0.0198549107,
-0.0386388153,
-0.0286623854,
-0.0211590026,
0.0171836335,
-0.0442572646,
0.0145123033,
-0.0468284301,
0.0520056561,
-0.0276144426,
-0.0139324758,
-0.0174627546,
-0.041499503,
-0.0026395924,
0.0564697683,
-0.0160981864,
0.0606111139,
-0.0248972736,
-0.0040156422,
-0.0587729961,
-0.0138482535,
0.0526976585,
-0.0190822631,
0.0393224098,
0.000002218,
-0.0859828144,
-0.0108935656,
0.0219541602,
-0.0394123197,
0.0222366434,
0.0235583037,
0.0258595943,
0.0094075529,
0.0291425567,
-0.0317664407,
-0.0047400258,
0.0266579892,
0.0106663285,
0.0201591756,
0.0471535623,
-0.0000849114,
-0.0250173993,
0.0539763123,
0.0009014139,
0.0450446159,
-0.0227375645,
0.0301800687,
0.0761789382,
0.0133553352,
0.026209062,
-0.0098280637,
0.0574905537,
0.0271488279,
0.0150959287,
0.0031618669,
0.0675193146,
-0.0218925662,
0.0407204181,
0.0216112398,
0.0338682495,
0.0181145091,
-0.0132487435,
0.0066774851,
0.008935648,
-0.0036427325,
0.0635442138,
-0.1014759243,
0.0098158605,
-0.0098774675,
-0.043579895,
0.0106375143,
-0.0031079049,
0.0006388566,
-0.0040881238,
-0.0109592108,
0.0728544891,
0.0300967805,
-0.0308722407,
0.0142687457,
0.005637317,
-0.0281338431,
-0.0582167245,
0.0143514471,
0.0462412871,
-0.0280459803,
0.0328511745,
0.0201479774,
0.0132026942,
0.0792161226,
-0.0562561452,
-0.0059453472,
0.0366650708,
0.0317805,
0.0426912047,
-0.0321019404,
0.0585053563,
-0.0186993759,
0.0255689062,
-0.0557896756,
0.0217580777,
-0.0735265464,
-0.0279767346,
-0.0007684078,
0.0169337634,
0.0378941409,
0.0037065765,
-0.0666598603,
-0.051153414,
0.0107306698,
-0.0008931602,
-0.0055058878,
0.0072405348,
-0.0246112887,
-0.0126736164,
-0.0531633012,
0.0583949611,
-0.0250019636,
0.0143775437,
-0.0002763197,
-0.0406472832,
0.0057975841,
-0.001858364,
-0.0283730626,
-0.0252345875,
0.0006592235,
0.0553922318,
-0.0145136192,
0.0176154803,
0.0351493806,
-0.0449756756,
-0.0334110297,
-0.0730855316,
0.0345878638,
-0.078619808,
-0.0121575007,
0.0658718124,
0.0038709298,
-0.0393891931,
0.0237218235,
0.0258554351,
-0.0270143487,
0.031697955,
0.0226922948,
0.028144829,
0.0663796961,
0.0377254598,
-0.0024833768,
0.0165347066,
0.0180231407,
-0.0313903876,
-0.0033365958,
-0.0528987907,
0.0032071634,
-0.0274834987,
0.0151658691,
-0.0045615388,
-0.008860657,
0.0334356651,
0.0022873424,
0.0596411005,
-0.0270154513,
0.0547043756,
-0.0290528033,
0.0107206674,
0.0317983031,
0.0758512542,
0.0120136924,
0.0604605712,
-0.0264965929,
-0.0252233539,
0.0242779274,
0.0236584675,
-0.0123511655,
0.0410251692,
-0.055185508,
-0.0025741151,
0.0208259784,
0.008127911,
-0.0169202387,
-0.0396356396,
-0.0339661576,
0.0345897824,
0.032227587,
0.0252363104,
0.0397271402,
-0.0448295139,
-0.0042475234,
0.033485882,
0.0408257619,
-0.0334382877,
-0.0104327668,
-0.0383321978,
-0.0039090915,
0.0386826284,
0.0309589412,
-0.0117056081,
-0.065966256,
-0.0195166562,
0.0401515402,
0.044163201,
0.0381714329,
0.009135508,
-0.0409472212,
-0.0187229682,
-0.0021578255,
-0.0110481689,
0.0056199566,
-0.0220204629,
-0.0296117458,
0.0322132744,
-0.0168672148,
-0.0012426435,
-0.0123563921,
0.0139320707,
-0.0871891528,
-0.0483429693,
-0.0448001958,
-0.0356164128,
0.0294906385,
-0.0256184563,
-0.0069472077,
0.044315774,
0.0030698138,
-0.0321916342,
-0.0403347351,
-0.0147700449,
-0.0340253264,
0.0030102874,
0.0236945767,
-0.052418936,
-0.0176359564,
-0.0173187125,
0.0002100912,
-0.0111711277,
-0.0070506437,
-0.0308687314,
-0.0034302906,
0.0087832892,
-0.0022530106,
-0.0316234343,
-0.0191075075,
-0.0539765432,
0.0677511394,
0.0096876519,
0.070529148,
0.0099335806,
-0.0362589583,
0.0338673815,
-0.0651023164,
-0.0421145074,
0.0111895334,
0.010632203,
0.0085416576,
0.0182464737,
-0.0118328566,
-0.0578188412,
-0.020424908,
-0.0690554827,
-0.0082539665,
0.0154910721,
0.0135052195,
0.0195655636,
-0.045573689,
-0.0184100214,
0.0151968477,
-0.0335796773,
-0.025622623,
0.0490675718,
0.0176668093,
0.0171516798,
0.0026215552,
0.0035102644,
-0.0377139039,
-0.039510455,
-0.0782001615,
0.0190661568,
0.0464244075,
0.0530811064,
-0.0079888841,
0.070543915,
-0.0308366623,
-0.0233114362,
0.005579053,
-0.0750010759,
0.0611698143,
-0.0185613446,
-0.0094152745,
0.0615358129,
0.0183063559,
-0.0110190362,
0.0335668549,
-0.0412473492,
-0.0395354442,
-0.0025699348,
-0.0319658145,
-0.0161350854,
-0.0159351993,
-0.0491941944,
-0.0290332232,
0.0579351597,
0.0236271396,
0.0040415591,
-0.0272065345,
0.0332299247,
-0.0748907402,
0.0030080124,
-0.0319239534,
0.0149873951,
-0.002041264,
0.0320935212,
0.0284270514,
0.002412532,
0.0979019776,
0.0032258476,
0.0125492485,
-0.1011069566,
0.026035279,
0.0004548285,
0.0563252009,
-0.0307068173,
0.0100865858,
0.016868161,
0.0158087257,
-0.0466324054,
-0.0334506407,
0.0125036165,
-0.0359924734,
0.027010303,
-0.0417413823,
-0.0056665018,
0.0158880837,
-0.019848058,
-0.0350889564,
-0.0192486849,
-0.0077364598,
0.0138421794,
-0.0292182155,
-0.0295854434,
-0.0568614863,
-0.009889924,
0.0365298204,
-0.0056594014,
-0.0306664538,
-0.0204380378,
-0.009048095,
0.0355111845,
0.0491551496,
0.0086033661,
0.0308169667,
-0.0471338555,
0.0497529209,
0.0694732517,
0.0090519693,
0.0159027074,
-0.007945599,
-0.0283451062,
0.0205435269,
-0.0188137908,
0.0018029888,
0.0377299562,
0.0441287011,
-0.0526485592,
-0.0043168208,
0.1115202978,
0.0130845197,
0.0106402775,
0.0068733599,
-0.0272570215,
-0.0057017109,
0.0016297819,
0.0306604672,
-0.0594779365,
-0.009264457,
-0.0367498323,
-0.0166001525,
-0.0233913846,
-0.0206495076,
0.0161570404,
-0.0539516881,
0.0161552913,
0.0157771148,
-0.0197641645,
0.0137039134,
-0.0403276235,
0.0100620287,
0.0081405547,
-0.0101304799,
0.0284408182,
0.0212239213,
-0.0158037506,
0.0143101951,
-0.0599422827,
-0.0550079234,
0.0785179287,
-0.0193373356,
0.0526688583,
0.0033269061,
0.0349517725,
-0.0613800511,
-0.0560468808,
-0.002635777,
-0.0076226844,
-0.0107803959,
-0.0006000616,
0.0128226522,
0.0433109663,
0.0348727666,
-0.0719177052,
0.0543430746,
-0.0443643257,
-0.0144571336,
0.0389136001,
0.1045254618,
-0.0153991785,
-0.0447675958,
-0.0415100157,
0.0055396785,
-0.0189539958,
0.0809599683,
0.0060689584,
-0.0240272228,
-0.0232414789,
-0.0325238369,
0.0220676903,
0.0507765338,
-0.0384078324,
0.0243838057,
0.030391138,
-0.0105834026,
-0.0497979522,
0.0093880519,
0.0386602432,
-0.0092101712,
-0.0118111297,
0.0580227301,
-0.0100162132,
0.005642408,
-0.0009097581,
0.0654089153,
0.0072632199,
-0.0037763549,
-0.0441694073,
-0.0245918017,
0.0257716384,
-0.0259281043,
-0.0468393527,
0.0113484524,
-0.0116989166,
-0.0315373316,
-0.0034177266,
0.026113471,
0.0338398963,
-0.0550884381,
-0.000855131,
-0.0646499991,
0.031005675,
0.0031286732,
-0.0456115715,
-0.0003562979,
-0.0455911718,
-0.0190236289,
0.0293202028,
-0.0324707255,
0.0074885418,
0.0239655543,
-0.0086915148,
0.0421631746,
-0.0462315455,
-0.0505043678,
0.0531106889,
0.0741434395,
0.048013296,
0.0247234087,
-0.0225371998,
0.0032223447,
0.0295060631,
-0.0567941889,
0.0114840567,
-0.0082823858,
-0.036510475,
0.0713641196,
-0.001284676,
-0.001262064,
-0.0643955544,
-0.0617580786,
0.0138049554,
-0.0595213547,
0.0832673907,
0.0403468311,
0.0186678357,
0.0682385862,
-0.0274585113,
-0.0171608794,
-0.0454868563,
-0.0235743653,
0.0436142422,
-0.0037534679,
0.0532262437,
0.0289152022,
-0.0139333829,
-0.0008227791,
-0.0115059353,
-0.0909985974,
-0.070299685,
0.0089680543,
0.0292911865,
0.013129863,
0.0499487929,
0.0111902989,
-0.0592466146,
0.0027824314,
-0.0218300149,
-0.0045193308,
0.0211759713,
0.0187579747,
0.0835062861,
0.0364127532,
0.0186515301,
-0.0206692275,
0.0657412782,
0.0158602539,
0.0137187839,
-0.0163151324,
-0.0361435525,
-0.041679848,
-0.0338080637,
-0.0331577733,
0.0118717793,
-0.0174272284,
0.0316414759,
-0.0860450715,
-0.030146718,
-0.003215105,
0.0463078469,
-0.0207227245,
-0.0411825702,
0.0177937355,
0.0515721589,
-0.0195277445,
-0.064418301,
-0.0114790229,
0.0684419647,
-0.0341768004,
-0.0273878872,
-0.0003625996,
-6.400211888e-33,
0.011947385,
-0.0187644921,
0.0447558537,
0.0126497336,
0.0101720877,
0.0197435785,
-0.0556778759,
0.0188956894,
-0.0107843373,
0.0036418163,
-0.014714363,
0.006428977,
0.0047353427,
0.0003315098,
-0.0054662493,
-0.0227161087,
0.0137359994,
0.0161268152,
-0.0226997454,
0.0211586654,
0.002042864,
-0.0019655288,
0.0204174351,
-0.038161885,
0.0303604752,
-0.0228924491,
0.0195493344,
-0.0132071972,
-0.0779525116,
0.0584280901,
-0.0321082398,
0.0367008671,
0.0193100888,
-0.0512303263,
0.0147308428,
-0.0132263359,
-0.0366248377,
-0.0269219577,
0.0170879867,
-0.0372877344,
-0.0377781354,
-0.0294515733,
0.0501261726,
0.0051035462,
-0.0506581552,
-0.0458945595,
0.0314892679,
-0.024444297,
-0.0075211953,
0.0221527759,
-0.036293909,
0.023872409,
-0.0212381054,
0.0174783468,
-0.0382014923,
-0.0188323818,
-0.0556864142,
0.0324023254,
-0.0099164583,
0.0189646203,
0.0447533764,
0.0322692655,
0.0354646705,
-0.0572728999,
0.0449031144,
0.0662973449,
0.0245776046,
0.0194280427,
-0.002916273,
-0.0492395274,
0.015779037,
0.0182692856,
0.0762997419,
0.0392790325,
0.0422685556,
-0.0247316528,
-0.1371889859,
-0.0011730924,
0.0265947469,
0.0707604513,
0.0425123647,
0.0057194857,
-0.0329126231,
-0.0222703833,
-0.040245425,
0.0454006493,
-0.0115431277,
-0.0584673621,
0.015592563,
-0.0579634868,
-0.0058419961,
-0.018141631,
0.0507166795,
-0.0122014815,
0.0082013356,
0.0163490493,
0.016712483,
0.0341393426,
-0.0153503735,
0.0527331606,
-0.0599944778,
0.0195406806,
-0.0002216647,
-0.0394681841,
0.0405815132,
0.0225616675,
-0.0100842845,
-0.0096460516,
-0.0110593941,
-0.0215197466,
-0.0310146399,
-0.0487011261,
0.021930743,
0.012522812,
0.0213166457,
0.0521778949,
0.0139568625,
0.0290509928,
-0.0127282869,
-0.0054809498,
-0.0098604849,
-0.0145604135,
-0.0146510499,
0.0020994258,
-0.0323309861,
-0.0124751823,
-0.0104585486,
-0.0067724902,
0.012623895,
-0.047868263,
-0.0099597527,
0.0350240953,
2.934e-7,
0.0616903901,
0.0938713402,
-0.0200988408,
-0.0211292394,
0.0336058177,
-0.0028657159,
-0.0530314408,
-0.035189867,
0.0826883912,
-0.0027019898,
0.0084143346,
0.0147230802,
0.0402432978,
0.0524207875,
-0.0398810431,
-0.0365021862,
-0.050413508,
-0.0061452151,
-0.0309277195,
0.0224693269,
0.0762223527,
0.0079273032,
-0.0078900605,
-0.0121999271,
-0.0069255419,
-0.0125311175,
0.0436144397,
-0.0380104892,
-0.0007427682,
0.0373525061,
0.0173922107,
-0.0062956135,
0.0302769728,
0.0973101407,
0.0126342904,
-0.0327977426,
0.0265243724,
0.0758952573,
-0.0033616088,
0.0106728962,
0.0233457927,
-0.0173630957,
0.0145540228,
-0.0849954933,
0.0428714789,
-0.0667000189,
-0.0649990216,
0.0052979328,
-0.0274653323,
-0.0498020351,
0.0655358285,
-0.0086432444,
-0.03264153,
-0.0118869841,
0.0031383669,
0.0163444411,
-0.0145060662,
-0.0082300697,
-0.0118299723,
0.0423676558,
-0.0517762005,
-0.0658661723,
-0.0191883277,
-0.0489954837,
0.0317856334,
-0.0497146733,
-0.0013825134,
2.787086086e-34,
0.0163220819,
0.0200314969,
0.0112435445,
-0.0129258409,
0.0348589085,
0.0025355218,
0.0308453813,
0.023431411,
0.0207925644,
-0.104062885,
-0.0127670476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00235v1 | What Does the Indian Parliament Discuss? An Exploratory Analysis of the Question Hour in the Lok Sabha | 2023-04-01T05:43:22 | 2023-04-01T05:43:22 | Suman Adhya, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | The TCPD-IPD dataset is a collection of questions and answers discussed in
the Lower House of the Parliament of India during the Question Hour between
1999 and 2019. Although it is difficult to analyze such a huge collection
manually, modern text analysis tools can provide a powerful means to navigate
it. In this paper, we perform an exploratory analysis of the dataset. In
particular, we present insightful corpus-level statistics and a detailed
analysis of three subsets of the dataset. In the latter analysis, the focus is
on understanding the temporal evolution of topics using a dynamic topic model.
We observe that the parliamentary conversation indeed mirrors the political and
socio-economic tensions of each period. | [
0.0284354705,
0.0545007251,
-0.0402941741,
0.0286505967,
-0.0691440329,
0.0321402587,
-0.0214224961,
0.015018845,
-0.0457381494,
0.0000609209,
0.0561477654,
-0.0383822173,
0.0078974897,
0.0344786942,
-0.0076612756,
-0.0669663474,
0.0426536165,
0.0278139059,
0.0143743679,
0.0113584045,
0.0146106305,
-0.0066500618,
-0.0360770114,
0.0149264066,
0.0193536617,
0.0134831006,
-0.0492135063,
-0.0317804255,
0.0373450667,
-0.0123399664,
-0.0039989254,
0.035022188,
0.036897216,
-0.022675965,
0.000001319,
-0.0464717969,
-0.0134395612,
-0.0277925022,
0.0019633449,
0.0143562621,
0.0828574449,
0.0214097593,
0.0083377771,
0.0293310955,
-0.0526573211,
0.0545801818,
0.0127842836,
0.0076989154,
0.0323257074,
0.081240803,
-0.0226841997,
0.0427192673,
-0.0115553532,
-0.0094137238,
0.0006818042,
-0.0280491095,
0.0308292415,
-0.0260496102,
-0.0064867688,
0.0178241413,
0.0079720123,
-0.0222074185,
-0.0397038832,
-0.0436206236,
-0.004030691,
-0.0018696733,
-0.0320617855,
-0.0153968018,
0.0144438297,
0.0327864923,
0.0682335049,
-0.0229180604,
0.0843212008,
0.0054698731,
-0.0609834157,
0.0350364484,
-0.0626450479,
0.0028062023,
-0.0291249175,
0.0221329387,
0.0961377248,
0.0196017157,
-0.0454079881,
0.005197112,
0.0365833119,
0.0098014334,
0.008346959,
-0.0232917406,
-0.082844831,
-0.0401410051,
0.0450822525,
-0.05066384,
0.0090567144,
-0.0040103826,
0.0357798897,
0.0646913573,
0.0213307254,
-0.0513210297,
0.0132867908,
-0.0498376824,
-0.0718595833,
-0.0077150376,
-0.0070911138,
0.065882422,
0.0810373574,
-0.0189755838,
0.0120234415,
-0.0257344563,
0.0088185659,
-0.0063135521,
0.0006305047,
0.0062581701,
0.0333196595,
0.0179528594,
-0.0194544662,
0.0011166375,
0.0051095784,
0.031235503,
0.0447262526,
-0.0246409979,
-0.0239988845,
-0.0191650074,
-0.0325143337,
0.0117715616,
-0.0197576862,
0.0354464985,
-0.0547346622,
0.039987985,
-0.0194420759,
0.0116775585,
-0.0089384848,
0.0530339368,
0.0194955505,
0.0056471857,
-0.0589829609,
0.0169755947,
-0.0420629717,
-0.0105384123,
-0.008368223,
0.0217492171,
-0.0287671871,
0.0142682847,
0.0015889407,
-0.0527643636,
0.0464113131,
0.0032790515,
-0.0172239691,
0.0225154981,
0.002686044,
0.0335179456,
-0.0143997306,
0.0382545441,
0.0144215897,
0.0308341403,
0.0721995234,
0.0181192085,
0.0524492189,
0.0168792363,
0.0273832809,
-0.0437721275,
0.0722541437,
0.0112068634,
0.0159535669,
0.0334552526,
-0.0295600612,
0.0441653989,
-0.0459519736,
0.0522896796,
-0.0124175837,
-0.0536404662,
-0.0225930307,
-0.0080563538,
-0.0160865355,
0.0017781715,
0.0034203576,
0.0687196925,
-0.0289710313,
0.0341438875,
-0.0660712942,
0.0159141645,
0.0354857333,
0.0397456922,
0.0641655922,
-0.0065628728,
0.041458562,
-0.0250544008,
0.0597765818,
-0.0343721211,
-0.0046344534,
-0.0220474433,
0.0070261718,
0.0111365486,
-0.0060955281,
-0.0391390324,
0.0716930255,
-0.0310107619,
0.0041270857,
0.0113728456,
0.0729306862,
-0.0297249723,
-0.0135525903,
-0.0419102088,
0.0614574365,
-0.0272711311,
0.0490222275,
-0.0640074536,
-0.0347048268,
-0.0266902931,
0.0710068867,
0.0362910591,
0.0184744522,
-0.0360101685,
-0.0379759148,
0.0144613395,
-0.0014483669,
0.0334713422,
0.019985294,
-0.0140628964,
-0.0258811824,
0.0171517786,
-0.044588618,
-0.0097739482,
0.0475414731,
0.0391880982,
-0.0153273549,
0.0377503745,
0.0185441617,
-0.02589407,
0.0479817502,
0.0099675003,
-0.0220460203,
-0.0356434099,
0.0592289269,
-0.0085842181,
0.0236676652,
0.0252360273,
-0.0053447224,
0.0056661428,
0.0158202369,
-0.058377251,
0.010039187,
0.0055780341,
-0.0077808094,
-0.0440250188,
0.0697308928,
-0.0001700585,
0.0032090396,
-0.003702682,
0.0019666571,
-0.0237901025,
-0.0464111865,
-0.0601071939,
0.0582259409,
0.0042699995,
0.0199426692,
0.0173525903,
-0.0123318359,
0.1020648181,
-0.0354839079,
0.0430488996,
0.0128493952,
0.0045138923,
0.0111799212,
0.028036803,
-0.0232735481,
-0.0200763382,
-0.0437742919,
-0.0638022125,
-0.0035758743,
-0.0336335376,
0.0371118188,
0.0519771352,
-0.0078720497,
-0.0109880827,
0.0121823838,
-0.0212907195,
-0.0039964016,
0.0129660321,
-0.0364708416,
0.0762612969,
-0.0036961215,
0.0220919736,
-0.036403656,
-0.0012684887,
-0.05248487,
0.0414670631,
0.0074635851,
-0.0754625723,
0.0233513005,
0.0108036259,
-0.0213973522,
-0.0060417322,
-0.0851384625,
-0.0300904997,
0.011972975,
-0.0209618583,
0.0636591986,
0.0442498922,
0.0871557668,
0.0213802122,
-0.0170146171,
-0.0215097703,
-0.0402531885,
-0.0114388512,
-0.0297079142,
0.0850179642,
-0.0056780875,
-0.0422693156,
0.0598546378,
0.0481343791,
0.0086923847,
0.0254982039,
0.0194721278,
0.0160293598,
-0.0399524868,
0.0423839465,
-0.0573930778,
0.0266062059,
-0.0535874739,
0.0653807893,
0.0191545077,
-0.0374103375,
0.005979869,
0.0106220776,
0.0602120049,
-0.0980984569,
-0.0305202547,
-0.0582383126,
0.0715250298,
-0.0396730751,
-0.0051204446,
0.0033902305,
-0.0415962338,
-0.0464114957,
-0.0171128865,
0.037832018,
-0.0485585369,
0.0546644852,
-0.0638749376,
0.0560461544,
-0.0329767652,
-0.0108103184,
-0.0146054132,
-0.1125127599,
0.032233201,
-0.0322162993,
-0.0251553897,
-0.0378296264,
-0.0244780779,
0.0512910932,
-0.0118393917,
-0.0159086566,
0.0088884849,
0.0082978522,
0.031118419,
0.0780871958,
0.0578104258,
-0.004488559,
-0.0215302054,
0.0336273536,
0.0011001928,
0.000312781,
0.0621010587,
0.0409986079,
-0.0039955433,
-0.0265824255,
-0.0056304312,
-0.0289542843,
-0.0022813191,
-0.0019530788,
0.0016893244,
-0.0156887267,
-0.0325014032,
0.0562546365,
0.0559602417,
-0.0343138799,
-0.0129973022,
-0.0380513407,
-0.0340114571,
0.0067214584,
0.0146649852,
-0.1028863415,
0.0416400172,
0.0223029647,
-0.0020403368,
-0.0625065044,
-0.0501024388,
-0.0200776011,
-0.0584709831,
-0.0077891736,
-0.0390598252,
0.0230857432,
0.0209227204,
-0.0512774102,
0.0273787938,
-0.0072104139,
-0.0428622104,
0.0305982642,
0.0135647282,
0.0218931548,
0.0370728001,
-0.0738766715,
-0.0113465507,
0.0130827362,
0.0362719446,
0.04017248,
-0.0045882412,
0.0506924279,
-0.0138389934,
0.0197884422,
0.0409818031,
-0.0640664399,
-0.0554276481,
0.028160315,
0.0222779661,
-0.0072264411,
-0.0283476543,
-0.0276517645,
0.0593384393,
0.0254021026,
0.0024896155,
0.0461451486,
0.0225423817,
-0.0451168418,
0.0074199145,
-0.0189880617,
0.0136632379,
0.0375320576,
0.0255048424,
0.0084891394,
0.0052163661,
0.0327002816,
-0.0240967125,
0.003213082,
0.0026237315,
-0.0176544078,
-0.0262598172,
-0.0329603478,
-0.0197724383,
-0.0364679359,
-0.0218304358,
0.0096833538,
0.0371873789,
0.0020229006,
0.052694384,
0.0246918034,
-0.0181841683,
-0.0220380519,
-0.0278797261,
-0.0275321566,
-0.0086325649,
-0.0250907429,
-0.0505051464,
0.0196266267,
0.056392286,
-0.0518639274,
-0.0478879251,
-0.0897298679,
-0.0464144722,
0.0045768972,
-0.0313027315,
0.0245048292,
-0.0137239052,
-0.0129257273,
-0.0046699997,
0.0194819327,
0.0188548621,
-0.0333275497,
-0.0288557075,
-0.0268494803,
0.0295984242,
0.0003569431,
0.0221712738,
-0.0245006997,
0.0081754178,
-0.0266627409,
-0.0352157652,
-0.071570158,
0.0010662666,
-0.015931813,
-0.0137684597,
0.0219953079,
0.0130361672,
-0.0724047944,
-0.0523817129,
-0.0057386085,
-0.0193460528,
-0.0275550112,
-0.0059791743,
-0.0096148765,
-0.0084984144,
-0.0211658143,
-0.0473046005,
0.0325503685,
-0.0553455353,
0.068967469,
-0.0341053046,
0.0668790713,
0.0276915729,
0.038252987,
0.0033788926,
-0.0295830593,
0.0356084928,
0.0005631498,
-0.0359350927,
0.0341016911,
0.0093881488,
0.0426796451,
-0.0126482444,
-0.0108297868,
0.0512688123,
-0.0070553217,
-0.0220153108,
-0.0026272018,
0.0053109052,
0.0385715924,
-0.0027185581,
0.0054307673,
0.0118418261,
0.0070440881,
0.0050676255,
-0.0217311345,
0.0240527652,
-0.0264513809,
0.0124149323,
0.0369477086,
-0.0032138897,
-0.0549383909,
0.0394354798,
0.0792096257,
-0.0333001576,
-0.0178091526,
0.0877028927,
-0.0240269229,
-0.0352711864,
0.0022418548,
0.0192983989,
-0.0057304045,
0.0148674389,
0.0013283294,
-0.0248897206,
0.042542588,
0.0105522135,
-0.0444042608,
0.0273189787,
-0.0199136995,
0.00098886,
0.0528683215,
0.0058386121,
0.0901005045,
-0.0507238433,
0.0375986695,
-0.0644790828,
-0.0214354917,
-0.0148727531,
-5.192014917e-33,
-0.0295119695,
-0.0246836245,
0.0225858893,
-0.0040179603,
0.0140986228,
0.0107368091,
-0.0308640152,
0.0059357206,
-0.0021048996,
-0.0191378016,
-0.0120556429,
0.0723619238,
0.0283179116,
-0.0197232757,
0.0353686064,
-0.0446380153,
0.0008255752,
0.008467868,
0.0162035804,
0.0205322001,
0.0476200543,
-0.0076418291,
0.0317630321,
-0.0345600434,
0.044634562,
-0.003724352,
0.0251722056,
-0.0134593779,
0.0498990864,
0.0026208051,
-0.0307896454,
-0.0027021929,
0.0423326604,
-0.0220291056,
-0.0023890478,
0.0748633817,
-0.0670755506,
-0.0306525454,
-0.0338113233,
0.0042750393,
0.0243054945,
0.0018365447,
0.0170229245,
0.0304498058,
-0.0151477344,
0.0275870152,
0.0442689173,
0.011769468,
-0.0002890328,
-0.0564297251,
-0.0106579876,
0.0794029087,
-0.0440248847,
0.0104902461,
-0.0569276772,
0.0494874083,
0.0580610037,
0.001556073,
-0.0453582965,
0.0271932483,
0.0378100462,
0.0394844487,
-0.0032072116,
-0.0539282598,
0.0299173929,
0.0193980001,
-0.009488631,
0.0186419282,
0.0200577881,
0.0309210643,
-0.0106415851,
0.0069975001,
-0.0007666809,
0.0167266559,
0.0357760265,
-0.0512140915,
-0.0667601451,
0.0292529333,
0.0836410895,
0.0591873489,
0.0154461516,
-0.0067184251,
-0.0056490949,
-0.0145660816,
0.0028991243,
0.0079183746,
0.0147067998,
-0.0051180646,
0.0156222079,
-0.0386384279,
-0.005912568,
0.000301872,
0.0433630459,
-0.0257513784,
0.0011875799,
-0.0041017523,
-0.0539771691,
0.0116962204,
-0.0044664429,
0.0039961813,
-0.0727476999,
-0.0409152582,
0.0018471438,
0.0441657826,
0.041587621,
-0.0241559632,
-0.0415378287,
-0.0294376742,
-0.0729574114,
-0.0433847755,
0.0234024674,
0.0121965203,
-0.0259049963,
0.0813221037,
0.0126907397,
0.0044012307,
0.0084267957,
0.0064017186,
0.0211534631,
0.0112157539,
0.0129768206,
-0.0106116468,
-0.0411983542,
-0.0180453677,
0.003550654,
0.0051067891,
-0.0360716879,
0.0176062435,
0.0370828658,
-0.0081151659,
0.0036019695,
-0.0194451604,
2.221e-7,
0.0246702712,
0.0791026875,
0.0307810586,
-0.0227809642,
0.0187438838,
0.0052832118,
-0.0309515968,
0.0494683012,
-0.063608326,
-0.0454727374,
0.0157000255,
-0.0365721136,
0.01739222,
0.0462436937,
-0.0900247097,
-0.0367058255,
-0.1065987274,
-0.0147466185,
-0.0791907907,
0.0354657434,
-0.0529282615,
0.0383808725,
0.0146852843,
0.0095175123,
-0.0486145578,
-0.0324264765,
0.0344005972,
-0.0218611341,
-0.0918718502,
0.0333371051,
0.0288820378,
-0.0233662464,
-0.0127126817,
0.0141821289,
-0.0115277534,
0.032099545,
-0.0089631062,
0.0501456633,
0.0147322584,
-0.0040830844,
-0.0198131483,
-0.0241820216,
-0.0095540611,
0.0083320588,
0.0764017478,
-0.0094461087,
-0.0343144499,
-0.0408941358,
-0.0062636873,
0.0076897126,
0.027988648,
0.0323435105,
-0.0007892948,
0.0019765378,
-0.0077449344,
-0.0517259762,
0.0255622882,
-0.063200824,
-0.0182250664,
0.0100505063,
-0.0560245961,
-0.0560450964,
-0.0059933686,
0.0067507024,
0.0029758336,
-0.0146850478,
0.0034802824,
1.491594424e-34,
0.044738695,
0.0023995028,
-0.0778960511,
0.0172028188,
0.0428652056,
-0.0217698719,
-0.0217101909,
-0.0082408991,
0.0209906753,
-0.0823292434,
0.0188004337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00228v1 | Large language models can rate news outlet credibility | 2023-04-01T05:04:06 | 2023-04-01T05:04:06 | Kai-Cheng Yang, Filippo Menczer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance in
various natural language processing tasks, they are prone to hallucinations.
State-of-the-art chatbots, such as the new Bing, attempt to mitigate this issue
by gathering information directly from the internet to ground their answers. In
this setting, the capacity to distinguish trustworthy sources is critical for
providing appropriate accuracy contexts to users. Here we assess whether
ChatGPT, a prominent LLM, can evaluate the credibility of news outlets. With
appropriate instructions, ChatGPT can provide ratings for a diverse set of news
outlets, including those in non-English languages and satirical sources, along
with contextual explanations. Our results show that these ratings correlate
with those from human experts (Spearmam's $\rho=0.54, p<0.001$). These findings
suggest that LLMs could be an affordable reference for credibility ratings in
fact-checking applications. Future LLMs should enhance their alignment with
human expert judgments of source credibility to improve information accuracy. | [
0.0625250638,
0.0323302001,
0.007015435,
0.0183496717,
-0.0536661148,
-0.0023132758,
0.0293409508,
-0.0251466837,
0.0488271639,
-0.0409111492,
-0.0466093644,
-0.0200914945,
0.0178378969,
0.0483236685,
-0.008091636,
0.0078036659,
0.0313302614,
0.0010441556,
0.0762278065,
-0.028054256,
0.0037626775,
0.0412282422,
-0.0311791897,
0.0487108678,
-0.0143311527,
-0.0117606502,
0.0232202485,
0.0019813646,
0.0008090275,
-0.0224482082,
-0.0269640312,
0.0410678089,
0.0002101155,
0.0646913499,
0.000001571,
-0.0285752974,
0.002459076,
-0.0011168534,
-0.0524164401,
0.0138430009,
0.0391187631,
-0.0207026191,
-0.024936052,
0.0207649283,
-0.0241971221,
0.0004142514,
0.0350755155,
0.0282330476,
0.0840088502,
0.1040754616,
-0.0083746696,
0.0132441958,
0.0161162559,
0.0023709082,
0.007212922,
-0.0422144309,
0.0460110717,
0.0651531443,
-0.025327377,
0.0266200323,
0.0296728387,
0.0087955836,
0.0315727703,
-0.0471293405,
-0.0470826216,
0.0343128145,
-0.047643207,
-0.0283450317,
0.017708946,
0.0326166451,
0.0121163493,
-0.0492634811,
-0.0009853051,
0.0228891261,
-0.0010841571,
0.0367798917,
-0.0311810244,
0.0524929464,
-0.0283156075,
-0.0109456144,
0.0172385126,
-0.0227545854,
0.0350993276,
0.0630819276,
0.0260620993,
0.0836910605,
0.0105118677,
-0.015547771,
0.0229719914,
0.0196987242,
-0.0101787774,
-0.0716934875,
0.0129191168,
0.0055187028,
-0.0399342142,
0.0302107707,
-0.025990501,
0.0558250323,
0.0393179245,
-0.0898597315,
-0.0481470823,
0.0276983157,
-0.0391849726,
0.087242268,
-0.0124783264,
0.0026980047,
-0.0140852621,
0.0201192014,
0.0211288501,
-0.0295570418,
-0.0146138081,
0.0402659662,
0.0231067315,
0.0010610587,
-0.0177446213,
0.0036108121,
-0.0548520796,
0.0149076851,
-0.0078425249,
0.0286536571,
0.0176110864,
0.0173930544,
0.0032006509,
-0.03404608,
-0.0656442866,
0.0379195847,
-0.0423027836,
0.03683988,
-0.0104770996,
-0.0663161725,
0.0100141689,
0.0146457544,
-0.0290250573,
-0.0203585513,
0.0081273364,
0.0075158365,
0.0126440506,
-0.0122895818,
-0.0127708791,
-0.0123296045,
-0.0207784846,
-0.0843278542,
0.0051010614,
-0.0635791197,
0.0059938449,
0.0142893428,
-0.0000834358,
-0.0102226511,
-0.0025957753,
0.0366540924,
-0.0373922624,
0.0294942316,
-0.011630645,
0.0154292732,
0.0318881944,
0.0090436228,
-0.0465663522,
0.0548184104,
0.0117696449,
0.069276467,
0.0451536663,
0.0306997597,
0.0012778615,
-0.013414491,
-0.0024846743,
0.0188804325,
0.0072698868,
0.0098841107,
-0.037898656,
0.0050047394,
-0.0113044269,
0.0429400317,
-0.039120771,
-0.0309739839,
0.1152957454,
0.0049179769,
-0.0171661433,
0.0221901368,
0.0465046205,
-0.0073645185,
0.0485515036,
0.0023266482,
-0.0793582499,
0.0312383715,
-0.0279048942,
-0.0317144655,
0.0323243327,
0.0682008788,
-0.0016016298,
-0.0276621263,
-0.009833795,
-0.0045357328,
0.0145454202,
-0.0051345672,
-0.0032816653,
-0.0518450513,
-0.033976946,
-0.0002814767,
0.0298048407,
0.004774279,
-0.0071210181,
-0.0524534136,
0.0394088961,
0.0485262647,
0.0279924497,
0.0221774299,
0.0268375929,
-0.0252614766,
0.0170085616,
0.0495395847,
0.0482428186,
-0.0059209648,
-0.0268245228,
0.014010109,
0.0054595675,
-0.0276206397,
0.0312776379,
0.0278865788,
0.0629091039,
0.045255769,
-0.0164200179,
-0.0184481684,
-0.0322681516,
0.0068927528,
-0.0253806543,
0.0068241968,
-0.0103799077,
-0.0078269197,
0.0164767932,
0.0196970664,
-0.0139942104,
-0.0073698387,
0.015639374,
0.0196819231,
-0.0421374738,
0.0016631379,
-0.0118791312,
0.0022829839,
0.0279496703,
-0.0254663788,
-0.0181520693,
0.0323132612,
0.0017878012,
-0.0087613054,
-0.0064960001,
-0.0275546927,
0.0302787758,
-0.0626991168,
-0.0086774817,
-0.0278024357,
0.016634291,
0.0213253908,
0.0910018235,
-0.0114598051,
0.0116537753,
0.0159070939,
0.0065950528,
-0.0250844378,
0.0051092203,
-0.0209334325,
0.0306801498,
0.0219176412,
0.0276594833,
0.0340872183,
-0.0432677008,
-0.033055786,
-0.0135136517,
-0.0895914808,
0.0079289414,
-0.010392677,
-0.0044466336,
0.03475127,
-0.0399314836,
-0.0025786415,
0.0318679139,
-0.0341496207,
-0.015647836,
0.0125359921,
0.0287314299,
0.0028392598,
-0.0114553319,
-0.0177221075,
-0.0159286987,
0.0161559917,
-0.0205146819,
0.0304211173,
0.0517848469,
-0.0234085191,
-0.0500819311,
0.0011461294,
-0.0782574266,
0.0081559764,
-0.0160724483,
-0.0396845452,
0.0236928649,
0.0296850037,
-0.0316272117,
0.0800252631,
0.0527549274,
0.01552324,
0.0561642423,
0.0393007174,
-0.0344680063,
-0.0361770876,
-0.0245020352,
-0.0049646338,
-0.0330532491,
-0.0558199212,
0.015652461,
0.0069878888,
0.0267133322,
0.0323049128,
-0.0161416419,
0.0466956608,
0.0102818906,
-0.0111165391,
0.0367300399,
-0.0338612646,
-0.0108866245,
0.0541127734,
-0.0172522627,
-0.0340741798,
0.0904418826,
-0.0397449695,
0.0590466075,
-0.0129332114,
-0.0210895538,
-0.0099843415,
-0.0034853199,
-0.0310393274,
0.0337508507,
-0.0164148845,
0.0093458649,
0.0093766721,
-0.0208736639,
0.05487727,
-0.0410661511,
0.0138025703,
-0.0276078135,
0.0189297032,
0.0441777706,
-0.0164052527,
-0.0528567247,
-0.0868553594,
-0.0393873826,
-0.018840272,
0.0121671651,
-0.047261145,
-0.0816366971,
-0.0089023681,
0.0629064664,
0.0004588223,
-0.027052477,
0.0136564337,
0.0316217616,
0.0026915155,
0.0202012453,
0.0348677188,
0.0805747136,
0.0286473334,
0.0096979896,
0.0536173172,
-0.0222347137,
0.0315474458,
-0.0302971881,
-0.0568833537,
-0.020288093,
-0.0071222065,
-0.0095195938,
-0.0198066998,
0.0153650213,
-0.0133088762,
0.0058466359,
0.1111437157,
0.0210124683,
-0.0412273109,
-0.0197342187,
0.0183646362,
-0.0241108797,
0.0426525176,
-0.0060495553,
-0.0941540971,
0.0044855061,
-0.010674498,
-0.0159112699,
-0.0379226059,
-0.0348029211,
-0.0376154892,
-0.1035809666,
0.0134746954,
-0.0232916307,
-0.0178753622,
-0.0136852162,
-0.1051672772,
0.0142236557,
-0.0088157179,
0.0118275853,
0.0063666464,
0.0360886119,
-0.0270840023,
-0.0152547453,
0.0151483677,
-0.0645382851,
0.0855399892,
-0.0253875479,
0.0681076348,
0.0380520597,
0.0425363705,
-0.0225387476,
-0.0386477299,
0.0075989952,
0.0297729447,
-0.0531519018,
0.0102146342,
0.0575863011,
-0.0460566804,
0.0126402676,
-0.026968427,
0.0108004147,
0.0214213859,
0.0058552516,
-0.0059728106,
0.0195736699,
0.000789391,
-0.0276417602,
0.0002879229,
0.0282863807,
0.0132538518,
0.0895175934,
0.0118899876,
-0.0135732237,
0.01655473,
-0.022068033,
-0.0468889028,
0.0278274287,
-0.0640601665,
0.0730178207,
-0.0112188272,
-0.0720186532,
-0.0837181062,
0.0036885859,
-0.0000898725,
0.0174260419,
-0.0224187188,
-0.0127784181,
0.0317786336,
0.0128602292,
0.0276540462,
0.0225658733,
-0.0440483168,
0.0040323157,
-0.029949991,
0.0448855646,
0.0361638069,
-0.0248471126,
-0.0018129731,
0.0249114558,
-0.0507678986,
-0.0333515443,
0.0093082013,
0.0040158378,
0.0244971924,
0.0270784851,
-0.0541959666,
-0.0129062403,
-0.0035840655,
0.0334905423,
-0.0626008064,
0.0072608041,
0.0062896525,
0.0192620195,
0.0309276842,
0.0105058299,
-0.034628436,
0.0410055555,
0.007102699,
-0.0142350113,
-0.0323393345,
-0.0295835808,
0.0578764416,
0.0491532832,
0.0247662514,
-0.0030621763,
0.0259314682,
-0.0137191564,
-0.0215661284,
-0.046910584,
-0.0225340407,
0.0243185069,
0.0094953477,
0.008709956,
-0.0245285146,
-0.0162132215,
-0.037716601,
-0.0484473892,
0.0376293324,
-0.0240237974,
-0.0246714838,
0.0011545327,
0.0149933295,
-0.0319037922,
-0.0266198609,
-0.0580866262,
0.0153227113,
-0.0156391542,
0.0226924028,
-0.0246527381,
0.0268637221,
0.0121173384,
-0.0464186035,
0.0380738042,
-0.0174073931,
-0.0971836597,
-0.0357894078,
-0.0266743489,
0.0342991017,
0.0349797793,
0.0095401192,
0.0376850292,
-0.0331954882,
-0.0209256988,
-0.0133136893,
-0.0273138024,
0.0330917276,
-0.0136712808,
0.0182978362,
0.0052359393,
-0.0477009453,
0.0288760923,
0.0384446159,
-0.0033631104,
0.0180959366,
0.029709667,
-0.0912150741,
-0.023455441,
-0.0556720123,
-0.0619761162,
0.0180728417,
-0.0172278192,
-0.0246238466,
-0.053490486,
-0.0463387072,
-0.0115525639,
0.028145032,
0.0227453411,
-0.0118085733,
-0.0337850712,
0.0982884616,
0.0212811735,
0.0288020149,
-0.0562900342,
0.0097894706,
-0.018866336,
-0.0109507823,
-0.0004232635,
-6.113173432e-33,
0.0152395386,
-0.0599800386,
-0.0120323701,
-0.022765344,
0.0172752105,
0.0367517732,
-0.0291498564,
0.0062803077,
-0.0715813488,
0.0293196309,
0.0109732905,
0.0388983712,
0.0175654609,
-0.0445200615,
-0.0313001797,
-0.0181050487,
0.0423313677,
0.0061293854,
-0.0401442572,
0.0043416773,
0.041362036,
-0.0487869345,
0.0485637672,
-0.0907189623,
0.0896574855,
0.0002039734,
-0.0488710329,
0.0001382213,
-0.0045573809,
0.0540563166,
-0.0060100309,
0.0403466821,
0.0379997678,
-0.0616589412,
0.0351383165,
0.0141141312,
-0.0535646789,
0.0106602032,
0.0641986951,
-0.0245693605,
-0.0074529396,
0.0118803149,
0.0198914241,
-0.015331286,
-0.0068028737,
0.0056432537,
0.0079044728,
-0.0508154221,
0.0095388722,
0.0098080542,
-0.0260856058,
0.0084069269,
0.0108818887,
-0.0028330858,
-0.0552597456,
0.0409665853,
-0.0011990889,
0.0368597321,
-0.054927595,
0.030820407,
-0.0522511862,
-0.0053969678,
0.0454100557,
-0.0541138873,
-0.020884933,
0.0744427592,
-0.001173932,
0.0270049982,
-0.059132427,
-0.0114518972,
0.0140668051,
0.0352004133,
0.0436732396,
0.1105141863,
0.0162267108,
-0.0520004854,
-0.0875822306,
0.0336995758,
0.0799629167,
0.0031555684,
0.044595398,
-0.0296341088,
-0.0177194048,
0.0254650488,
-0.0174876247,
-0.0054914323,
-0.0535850301,
-0.0449515544,
-0.0111857243,
0.0192312654,
-0.0255596638,
0.0211720485,
0.0191667154,
-0.0387362279,
0.0105942385,
0.0496682636,
-0.0527606942,
-0.0170023721,
-0.0078975614,
0.0392469466,
-0.057961043,
0.0424635075,
-0.0051905848,
0.0268793516,
0.0026380119,
0.0035301866,
0.0469496101,
-0.0116211064,
-0.0507019088,
0.0274205413,
-0.0379575901,
0.0227347501,
-0.0034020271,
-0.0080283191,
0.0389576182,
-0.0032370875,
-0.0298879128,
0.006366733,
-0.0040610651,
0.0124372272,
-0.0065782494,
-0.0112687536,
-0.0061260886,
0.0176336411,
-0.0377074443,
-0.0203081127,
-0.0197336972,
-0.0131213982,
-0.0163372923,
-0.0725443512,
-0.0018174957,
-0.010061278,
2.488e-7,
0.0058163353,
0.0648795217,
-0.0228037685,
0.0489573888,
0.021901777,
0.0224387664,
0.0177804828,
0.0063862177,
0.0013984318,
-0.1149906665,
-0.0360509977,
0.0384665839,
0.0215473045,
0.0720631257,
-0.0515982471,
-0.0153688043,
-0.0713548362,
-0.0149979088,
-0.0593525358,
-0.0010678518,
0.0216205604,
0.0601725802,
0.047420755,
-0.0092405686,
-0.0086516989,
-0.0642882511,
0.0616798922,
0.021704413,
-0.0635045692,
0.0075217467,
0.0684901699,
0.0091672139,
0.0127355531,
0.0232061129,
0.0034868282,
-0.0022393072,
0.0132406419,
0.0670132115,
0.0197800677,
-0.0101506757,
-0.0079995068,
-0.0508867428,
0.0265419893,
-0.0612052009,
0.0773507506,
-0.0130724404,
-0.0410406291,
-0.0693327263,
-0.0341796018,
-0.0199019983,
0.0585956462,
-0.0446306244,
-0.0125373406,
0.028160492,
-0.0229592361,
0.0150605096,
0.0161927249,
-0.0123168714,
-0.012513835,
-0.0153867835,
-0.0498380847,
-0.0616691373,
0.0255325604,
-0.0320144147,
0.0162570216,
-0.0533837043,
0.0535324067,
1.908361355e-34,
0.0456652083,
-0.0040127132,
0.0050546811,
0.0008667742,
0.077923812,
0.0558762327,
-0.0054944162,
-0.030554669,
0.0122899031,
-0.0359919816,
0.0053143185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00215v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00215v3 | Inductive Relation Prediction from Relational Paths and Context with Hierarchical Transformers | 2023-04-01T03:49:47 | 2023-07-10T10:27:06 | Jiaang Li, Quan Wang, Zhendong Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Relation prediction on knowledge graphs (KGs) is a key research topic.
Dominant embedding-based methods mainly focus on the transductive setting and
lack the inductive ability to generalize to new entities for inference.
Existing methods for inductive reasoning mostly mine the connections between
entities, i.e., relational paths, without considering the nature of head and
tail entities contained in the relational context. This paper proposes a novel
method that captures both connections between entities and the intrinsic nature
of entities, by simultaneously aggregating RElational Paths and cOntext with a
unified hieRarchical Transformer framework, namely REPORT. REPORT relies solely
on relation semantics and can naturally generalize to the fully-inductive
setting, where KGs for training and inference have no common entities. In the
experiments, REPORT performs consistently better than all baselines on almost
all the eight version subsets of two fully-inductive datasets. Moreover. REPORT
is interpretable by providing each element's contribution to the prediction
results. | [
0.0342960395,
0.0044350042,
0.0054607019,
0.0561875366,
-0.0015902953,
0.0121502932,
-0.0663143769,
-0.0048093605,
0.0264348388,
-0.0092366599,
0.0101144845,
0.0253251996,
-0.0064214072,
-0.0324226618,
0.0226405114,
-0.0426238701,
0.0053356974,
0.0250046104,
-0.0490664504,
-0.0050195237,
-0.025627695,
0.0223174449,
0.0027684595,
0.0380440094,
-0.0403202772,
-0.0059562679,
-0.0164277609,
-0.0059028803,
0.034161564,
-0.044604443,
0.012468257,
0.0292881634,
0.0295308717,
-0.0263984166,
0.0000019077,
-0.0341887213,
-0.0046009566,
0.0125010507,
-0.0366200507,
-0.0913591385,
-0.0445300192,
-0.0710331053,
0.0445610583,
0.0159044135,
-0.0344717763,
-0.0358870327,
0.0329441689,
0.0807186067,
0.0031803325,
0.0281261522,
-0.0366547294,
-0.0715011358,
0.050669387,
-0.0030363982,
0.0366533287,
0.0052288952,
0.0105418051,
0.0230590515,
-0.0586149767,
-0.0175884701,
-0.0035180834,
-0.0231570061,
0.0457663797,
-0.0075231418,
0.071821548,
0.0400686562,
-0.0248465873,
-0.0023695782,
-0.0008551296,
0.0937917307,
0.0021357022,
-0.0018597587,
-0.0360535346,
0.0199397504,
-0.0042454009,
0.0350768492,
0.0010016032,
-0.0126384562,
-0.0325275138,
-0.0024535358,
0.005194841,
0.0219759643,
0.0417994298,
-0.0148615316,
-0.0363346003,
0.0699714646,
-0.0009615092,
-0.0414335839,
0.0470308997,
0.0416941121,
0.0100464122,
0.0078417053,
-0.025264116,
0.031796325,
-0.0249679498,
0.0246505421,
0.0340627246,
0.0443560444,
-0.0008189966,
-0.0342588872,
-0.0347246043,
0.0193956066,
0.0309130009,
0.0501538962,
-0.0427237898,
0.0102883689,
-0.017533591,
0.0015177202,
-0.0296776649,
-0.0279862173,
-0.0591949001,
0.0209233128,
-0.0177669935,
0.041155301,
0.0215320755,
0.0087129222,
-0.0384825841,
0.0343899392,
-0.0150545258,
0.0237225592,
0.0421872288,
0.020884335,
-0.0264584515,
0.0080520054,
-0.035183154,
0.0273851976,
-0.0396221355,
0.0003136373,
-0.0405944325,
0.0180971585,
-0.0016642485,
-0.0273037218,
0.0250116475,
-0.0245122872,
-0.0094607668,
0.0786001906,
0.047769133,
-0.0368901305,
-0.0441182926,
-0.0506143272,
0.0486227162,
-0.0400048383,
0.0800128058,
-0.0333677195,
0.0491821021,
0.0417711362,
-0.0094719324,
-0.0020381946,
0.0247163959,
-0.0129190506,
-0.0621882267,
0.0625587851,
-0.0054321019,
-0.0228983574,
-0.0340800099,
0.0009709561,
-0.032318633,
0.0358517319,
0.0173400249,
0.0251075216,
0.0012051876,
0.0086137429,
-0.0379232503,
0.0069232108,
0.0325785428,
-0.0049961852,
0.0421653874,
0.0376809947,
-0.0308660269,
0.0155259324,
0.005904607,
0.0208043624,
-0.0106716789,
-0.0109243775,
-0.004348075,
0.0212672167,
0.0028215083,
0.050077904,
0.0517503805,
-0.008192027,
-0.0225526709,
0.0174927749,
-0.0785780922,
0.0305729806,
-0.0205926728,
0.0102388449,
-0.0304635148,
0.004821552,
-0.0031587218,
-0.0135700153,
0.0188674126,
-0.0341081619,
0.0374547914,
0.0026108099,
0.0759379119,
0.0532407761,
-0.0478401966,
0.0670741349,
0.082522817,
-0.0296525527,
-0.0250255838,
0.0457214005,
-0.0051482986,
0.0272542723,
0.0491777398,
-0.0324556492,
-0.0275525041,
-0.01146599,
-0.0335850157,
-0.0035748065,
0.0096336249,
-0.0416328907,
-0.0035383299,
-0.0237064473,
-0.0845333114,
0.0391022004,
-0.0209801681,
-0.0086162109,
0.0457157195,
-0.0097817359,
0.025084842,
-0.0460811406,
0.0454071015,
0.0374554656,
-0.0398658365,
0.0415012538,
-0.002909614,
0.0484737009,
0.0176776703,
0.0217539687,
0.0306469947,
-0.0065446082,
0.0545423254,
-0.0264727063,
-0.0779352486,
0.009202213,
-0.0125257978,
-0.0654945523,
0.0393914506,
-0.0740973502,
-0.0122711025,
-0.0255392473,
-0.0276444014,
0.0116505604,
0.0065386761,
-0.005985016,
0.1043293774,
-0.0153252967,
-0.0446166359,
0.0087317564,
-0.0268323366,
0.0075538144,
0.0955233797,
-0.0249563549,
-0.0047800485,
-0.0207665209,
-0.0561053418,
-0.0040470702,
0.0210066903,
-0.0114332438,
-0.0067195934,
-0.0120090907,
-0.0299041625,
0.0100810286,
-0.0355474278,
-0.0680602342,
0.0042845188,
-0.0513190553,
-0.0130450753,
0.0102515453,
0.0036777265,
-0.0115836635,
0.000186061,
0.0633747578,
0.0081931427,
-0.0109990612,
0.0009430609,
-0.0402373746,
0.0142120076,
0.0210658666,
-0.0121671846,
0.0038991361,
0.0171701312,
-0.040777348,
-0.0687725246,
0.0919409916,
0.0118773412,
0.0011486504,
0.0030472465,
0.0301777367,
-0.0503167361,
0.0181402657,
-0.0371608883,
0.0086775497,
-0.0211101919,
0.0053627314,
0.0406911261,
0.0079173362,
-0.0175239369,
0.0406908914,
0.0042517851,
0.0278097242,
-0.015841594,
0.0008318322,
-0.0560703725,
0.0290069822,
-0.038669508,
-0.0194354095,
-0.0667383373,
0.0193754118,
0.011288981,
-0.00871264,
-0.0650055185,
-0.0166828111,
-0.0025142974,
0.0436756201,
-0.0057291687,
0.0060259295,
0.0513443127,
-0.0155572537,
-0.0148176057,
0.0099093337,
0.0843210816,
0.0082583055,
0.0200436208,
0.0259176698,
0.013555632,
-0.0457942858,
0.0620349087,
0.0096567152,
0.0016981676,
0.0239463076,
-0.0047550849,
-0.0546250492,
0.0325466804,
0.0441361815,
-0.0262197815,
0.0401769169,
0.0444883406,
-0.0011045823,
0.0030364518,
-0.0217322446,
-0.0551560186,
0.0017102004,
-0.0142859686,
0.0295010861,
0.014223258,
-0.0107072135,
0.0079471711,
0.0057431413,
-0.0086447019,
-0.036064472,
0.0310270302,
-0.0512478314,
-0.014789151,
0.0097782612,
0.0309760999,
-0.0058080843,
0.0326565914,
0.0096197296,
0.0353147462,
0.0455311835,
0.0079174656,
-0.0325491168,
-0.0471243262,
0.0167420525,
-0.0381960794,
-0.0164765306,
-0.0131686125,
-0.0061788796,
-0.0268443376,
-0.0365596004,
0.0229912996,
0.0829336792,
0.0265563335,
-0.0231843535,
0.0199725647,
0.0188914612,
0.0169461612,
0.058896549,
0.0261974409,
-0.1167449579,
-0.002861087,
-0.0002943877,
0.0020464892,
0.0516310073,
-0.0872545242,
0.0402238667,
-0.0995758846,
0.0254322272,
0.0088033602,
-0.0082007051,
-0.0621416606,
-0.0707561821,
-0.0183645301,
-0.0236701556,
-0.0478193052,
-0.0179030113,
-0.037705835,
-0.0067060324,
-0.0047767251,
-0.0443861932,
-0.0245278403,
0.0239688214,
-0.0304249991,
-0.0154722864,
0.0027739245,
0.0127932103,
0.0105150091,
0.0099136094,
-0.0595584512,
0.0108892955,
-0.0130175734,
-0.0095731458,
0.0659724846,
-0.0204825066,
0.0212613605,
-0.0249293111,
0.0251152627,
-0.0623201579,
0.0032801372,
0.0025924072,
0.1239006147,
-0.0206834152,
-0.0376266018,
-0.0092769433,
-0.0173774604,
-0.0020210026,
0.0552056134,
-0.0192776881,
0.0286265332,
0.0056301076,
-0.0104553252,
0.0493670627,
0.0339480937,
-0.0045648855,
0.0416167565,
-0.0441292748,
0.0068890583,
-0.0504051559,
-0.0565944351,
0.0258094184,
-0.0038040243,
0.0071978597,
-0.0008597549,
0.0676632896,
-0.0138437431,
-0.0783822984,
0.0154162571,
-0.0115463547,
0.0093805753,
0.0499155559,
0.0216957778,
0.0086377701,
-0.0149891945,
-0.0441549607,
-0.0427013785,
-0.0321703963,
-0.0398359336,
-0.0548659563,
0.0406320728,
0.0033434825,
0.0795778781,
-0.0103532895,
0.0203327201,
0.0460383743,
0.0040873028,
-0.0277372748,
-0.0370302424,
0.0344931111,
-0.0063482895,
0.0089652287,
0.0600773133,
-0.0641363189,
-0.0089468062,
0.0015950513,
0.0415221006,
-0.0269071106,
-0.0191034805,
0.0220179353,
-0.0108637009,
0.0648142844,
0.0213951115,
0.0098198568,
-0.0210500509,
0.0388414152,
-0.0106161823,
-0.0335895605,
-0.054204192,
0.0349688567,
0.0031842075,
0.0315677151,
0.013593467,
-0.0433638431,
0.0287913475,
0.0213764887,
-0.0054333252,
-0.008338118,
0.0348543711,
-0.0227703247,
0.0400286168,
0.0131507954,
-0.0134620778,
-0.0311933216,
0.0328954645,
0.0035477411,
-0.0263177603,
0.0188135169,
0.0301519334,
0.0194253363,
-0.0533413142,
-0.0232463274,
-0.0141404178,
0.0280944258,
-0.0202233903,
0.0097138686,
0.0425621718,
-0.004038333,
-0.0027543888,
-0.0325780995,
0.0158348382,
0.031540826,
0.0566315167,
-0.0315211602,
-0.0389127359,
0.0503167771,
0.0098743616,
-0.0159907527,
0.0268697236,
0.0654798821,
-0.0267353859,
0.0667706281,
-0.0216063783,
-0.0537988544,
-0.0675893351,
-0.0264398027,
0.0179901272,
0.0146729704,
-0.0067329668,
0.0308993924,
-0.050961975,
-0.0892959461,
0.0144346775,
-0.0349145383,
-0.0488048606,
0.006749209,
-0.001647467,
0.0094452593,
0.0357000269,
-0.0759579167,
0.0084589357,
-0.0234977119,
-0.0751375481,
-0.0252296776,
-0.0327817053,
-5.45514896e-33,
-0.0054350151,
-0.0127103692,
0.0218668468,
0.0304229315,
-0.0459258743,
0.0219596699,
-0.0053189509,
-0.050663244,
-0.0323318355,
0.0595267937,
-0.0510384776,
-0.0050445073,
-0.0115189534,
-0.0036586141,
-0.0015535521,
-0.0274682604,
0.0120031051,
0.0171436798,
0.0157760326,
-0.0022128357,
0.0022227722,
0.0315898396,
0.0754159167,
-0.0869914666,
-0.0106995422,
-0.0496968329,
0.021233784,
0.0492023341,
-0.0096365893,
0.0147712147,
-0.0139127178,
0.0310016144,
0.0381402001,
-0.0224888772,
0.0224408433,
0.0047345008,
-0.1489293128,
-0.030384656,
-0.033618927,
0.0019226678,
-0.0454954579,
0.0093037616,
0.0370172225,
0.0083641885,
0.0702843666,
-0.1042796299,
0.0400520787,
-0.0258675739,
-0.0443816893,
-0.0598346107,
-0.0370881781,
-0.0043720421,
-0.0060301162,
0.005757716,
-0.0079710102,
0.0202037878,
0.0495315827,
-0.0425444953,
-0.0559322201,
-0.0009582566,
-0.0318449438,
-0.01949328,
-0.0030704786,
-0.0221992433,
0.0248940457,
0.0356536806,
0.0012249171,
-0.0023318802,
-0.0239280071,
-0.000690305,
-0.0292497594,
0.0570599101,
-0.0204875246,
-0.0049958942,
-0.0173816178,
0.0009562604,
-0.102428779,
0.0239268877,
0.0482564233,
0.0614316203,
-0.0326022469,
0.0081367753,
-0.0456065275,
-0.0242806356,
-0.0232798178,
0.0097671207,
0.0042022285,
-0.0633993223,
-0.0100946585,
0.0010959113,
-0.0044138487,
0.0556173213,
0.0066858828,
-0.0701435059,
-0.0211674608,
0.0704614669,
0.0223186109,
-0.011820348,
-0.0131052481,
0.0013775694,
-0.0237502828,
-0.0139837973,
0.0165157467,
-0.0258509573,
0.0353288241,
0.0332878157,
0.0787351206,
0.017079426,
-0.0132707972,
-0.0185838155,
-0.0438909791,
-0.0545387529,
0.0002047996,
0.0038339635,
0.0250009932,
0.0740118027,
0.0039626905,
0.018994458,
0.0540521815,
0.0659349263,
-0.0107468432,
0.0445882902,
0.0316944867,
0.01032821,
0.0115636196,
-0.0463815555,
-0.0299476124,
0.0008968462,
0.029309772,
-0.0489127226,
-0.0340512842,
-0.0052721179,
2.642e-7,
0.0412097163,
0.0306942202,
0.0427228808,
0.0585696585,
-0.0018781177,
0.0104052583,
0.0361858942,
0.0337164365,
0.0206410829,
-0.0107958997,
0.0506775081,
-0.01107716,
-0.0123810815,
0.0521901026,
-0.0750282928,
-0.0643525422,
-0.0671349913,
-0.0686905608,
-0.0134356348,
-0.0150637124,
0.0516834147,
0.0793897063,
0.0632370189,
0.0169927757,
-0.0073241219,
-0.0042816158,
0.0410359986,
0.007628737,
0.023121031,
-0.0058683776,
-0.0120149786,
0.0203492325,
-0.0071153501,
0.0670711398,
-0.0120903635,
0.0216409266,
0.0102088228,
-0.0128218392,
-0.0267779976,
-0.0243447144,
0.0198530722,
-0.0226129536,
0.014126135,
-0.0201623738,
0.0506224297,
-0.0851887167,
-0.009703937,
0.0604730919,
-0.0426587127,
-0.0034079319,
-0.0196997207,
0.0542093478,
0.0304197762,
-0.0051409518,
0.0245662183,
-0.0066326587,
0.0029659041,
-0.0733705312,
0.0049000364,
0.0335374065,
-0.0134504335,
-0.01616068,
0.0337509327,
-0.0427900665,
0.0148309497,
-0.0136234527,
0.0315351449,
2.445593038e-34,
-0.0205705576,
0.0099191796,
0.029195061,
-0.0061890767,
0.0617298372,
-0.0758474395,
0.0170334745,
-0.0044620293,
0.0387566872,
-0.07302358,
0.0126872603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00180v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00180v1 | FCC: Fusing Conversation History and Candidate Provenance for Contextual Response Ranking in Dialogue Systems | 2023-03-31T23:58:28 | 2023-03-31T23:58:28 | Zihao Wang, Eugene Agichtein, Jinho Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Response ranking in dialogues plays a crucial role in retrieval-based
conversational systems. In a multi-turn dialogue, to capture the gist of a
conversation, contextual information serves as essential knowledge to achieve
this goal. In this paper, we present a flexible neural framework that can
integrate contextual information from multiple channels. Specifically for the
current task, our approach is to provide two information channels in parallel,
Fusing Conversation history and domain knowledge extracted from Candidate
provenance (FCC), where candidate responses are curated, as contextual
information to improve the performance of multi-turn dialogue response ranking.
The proposed approach can be generalized as a module to incorporate
miscellaneous contextual features for other context-oriented tasks. We evaluate
our model on the MSDialog dataset widely used for evaluating conversational
response ranking tasks. Our experimental results show that our framework
significantly outperforms the previous state-of-the-art models, improving
Recall@1 by 7% and MAP by 4%. Furthermore, we conduct ablation studies to
evaluate the contributions of each information channel, and of the framework
components, to the overall ranking performance, providing additional insights
and directions for further improvements. | [
0.0540657714,
0.0606575496,
-0.0039822473,
0.0362832248,
-0.0109143183,
-0.0070054941,
0.0010751818,
-0.0134368772,
0.0078704553,
-0.0515029766,
-0.0448785834,
-0.0431555174,
-0.0020570143,
0.0459479429,
-0.0213504061,
-0.0205944721,
0.0350263044,
0.0175089501,
0.0431594364,
0.0290857758,
-0.0124597633,
0.0181698874,
-0.033179082,
0.0478342138,
-0.0180096515,
-0.0301544331,
-0.0232349075,
0.0172229763,
0.0448840521,
-0.0273320843,
0.0244497135,
0.0480352268,
0.0249303784,
0.0651017949,
0.0000015204,
-0.0331415161,
-0.0189626683,
-0.0095512057,
-0.0608152784,
0.0170719698,
-0.0069391946,
0.0671173707,
0.0065210257,
0.0035617976,
-0.0678768009,
0.0181225277,
0.0165414121,
0.0343189426,
0.0676494613,
0.0441949405,
-0.0086066499,
-0.0132566663,
0.0272134133,
-0.0486882366,
0.0222860873,
-0.0581089258,
0.002691637,
0.026394004,
-0.0000544995,
0.0704380497,
-0.0030132558,
0.0272951107,
0.0005471455,
-0.0563201867,
-0.0232730582,
0.0346259363,
-0.0105411522,
0.0160217341,
-0.0111250943,
0.1237184033,
0.0562009178,
0.038921088,
-0.0258762147,
0.017170202,
0.0120458752,
-0.0561871901,
-0.0721293837,
0.0002270249,
-0.0181078315,
-0.0017296792,
-0.0451123677,
0.0413800031,
-0.0040710061,
0.0267651752,
-0.0044844025,
0.0546603911,
-0.0220308732,
-0.0148157803,
-0.0390792675,
-0.0089003462,
0.0220075604,
-0.018952297,
0.0371468775,
0.0176472031,
-0.0470607169,
0.0216848608,
0.0343163945,
0.0311646145,
0.0365158431,
-0.0408890471,
-0.0411737785,
0.0168985892,
-0.0194051508,
0.0643417463,
0.0022099824,
0.044888448,
-0.021771796,
-0.0217938833,
-0.0234829765,
-0.0408455618,
-0.0522195175,
-0.0253250003,
-0.0146707762,
0.0205787607,
-0.080383867,
-0.0214071739,
-0.0258119665,
0.0264367983,
-0.010785941,
-0.0193514302,
0.0113319457,
0.0756265074,
-0.0265485905,
0.0286259986,
-0.0480804257,
0.0248526894,
-0.0272300448,
0.0058576674,
0.0526733287,
-0.0723275542,
-0.0188205577,
0.0103510972,
-0.0001514768,
-0.0271456037,
-0.0212189127,
0.0217472389,
-0.0047471048,
-0.0197814479,
0.0454852842,
0.006963646,
-0.0366296954,
-0.0379664078,
-0.0039425129,
-0.0146483518,
0.0525691621,
-0.0135875624,
-0.0363520496,
0.0094737308,
0.0009786265,
0.0330070741,
-0.0242203828,
0.0382470265,
0.0329459161,
-0.0423726365,
0.0321930237,
0.0160241555,
-0.0199975315,
0.0265571717,
0.0128792934,
0.0331219248,
0.0390208364,
0.0231429171,
0.0132743139,
-0.0404879935,
0.0325420834,
-0.0118385963,
0.0217414163,
0.0517212637,
-0.0316652805,
0.0260432623,
0.0133621218,
0.0287932791,
-0.066130504,
-0.0437425561,
0.0382528156,
0.0396531969,
0.0083669741,
0.0031385385,
0.0036739316,
0.0182367172,
0.0011892387,
-0.007439238,
-0.0569151007,
0.0332559943,
0.0225581676,
-0.0055335565,
0.0505121686,
0.028348783,
-0.0313500538,
-0.0486795045,
0.0432204418,
0.0083865505,
-0.0046865814,
0.0296568908,
0.0035570303,
0.0063412515,
-0.051079765,
0.0618053302,
-0.0096738795,
-0.027549075,
-0.0369525477,
-0.04230408,
-0.0000504394,
0.0396965295,
0.0504021309,
-0.027443096,
-0.0565173961,
-0.0244112574,
-0.0117169823,
0.0314508304,
0.0293757468,
-0.0221851114,
0.0819188282,
-0.033012446,
-0.0298901163,
0.0025386554,
-0.0017435045,
0.0454633236,
0.0107422052,
-0.0275698919,
0.0204151347,
-0.0000099056,
0.0491831377,
-0.0104169678,
0.0153450901,
-0.0079170549,
0.0330930538,
-0.0093195494,
0.0431842469,
0.0398149788,
0.0006992352,
0.0249539446,
0.0635581762,
-0.0021678226,
-0.0206860341,
0.0086977435,
-0.0874480382,
-0.0652308837,
0.0189818088,
0.0147397714,
-0.0107999044,
0.007246126,
-0.0486675315,
-0.0510814339,
0.0304400548,
0.0069780136,
0.0358791687,
-0.0693247467,
-0.0001383641,
0.0442344248,
0.0050600255,
-0.0639183521,
0.0832257718,
-0.0124113047,
0.0104490696,
0.0249272659,
0.0220733825,
0.0167923216,
-0.0599109866,
0.000994716,
0.0173938125,
-0.048831448,
0.0103812078,
0.0097473618,
-0.0038173539,
-0.0646771938,
-0.0021952169,
-0.1011342928,
0.0204096083,
-0.0010706283,
-0.0016569699,
0.0093254633,
0.029635882,
0.0206126589,
-0.0393284746,
-0.0348203219,
-0.0314884856,
0.0399430729,
0.028482141,
0.0374235027,
0.0621990375,
0.0061366069,
-0.0694127455,
-0.0239371303,
0.0188505519,
0.0625699982,
-0.0296909921,
0.0170869734,
-0.0102684014,
-0.0276820064,
-0.066626519,
0.0570645221,
-0.0371425375,
-0.0123273125,
0.0313193649,
-0.0294083953,
-0.0127325067,
0.0402258933,
0.0321085006,
0.0117357653,
-0.0234966613,
-0.0256902426,
-0.0766511038,
0.0460828915,
-0.0314863995,
0.0108411247,
0.0041082725,
0.0244905818,
-0.0126555115,
-0.0021436368,
-0.0035149909,
0.006583882,
-0.0103169261,
-0.0158767886,
0.0536693297,
-0.0056670816,
-0.0497970842,
-0.0237839762,
-0.0126695,
0.031661056,
-0.0453917719,
-0.0390642583,
0.0668108836,
-0.0180330537,
-0.0255779251,
-0.010550811,
-0.0055180173,
-0.0527095348,
0.0535867438,
-0.0197255332,
0.0072085666,
-0.0417979695,
-0.0542086959,
-0.0059814635,
-0.0324197784,
0.0072695995,
-0.0563387945,
0.0366573967,
-0.0092736362,
0.0170325097,
0.0023622687,
-0.0560838841,
-0.07415732,
-0.0082679065,
0.0050717695,
0.0258412175,
0.0163318198,
-0.0210935641,
-0.051225815,
0.0077953446,
0.0052572913,
0.041747801,
-0.0006577008,
0.0045291684,
0.0067964327,
0.0728931725,
0.0039899005,
0.0405463651,
0.0293012932,
0.023260301,
0.0478258617,
0.0515103675,
0.054452911,
-0.0276015271,
-0.0128922388,
-0.047975935,
-0.0015907744,
0.0040002749,
0.0027851444,
-0.0197514612,
0.0024891237,
-0.0027681612,
-0.0316801406,
0.0898999572,
0.0420248881,
-0.0500621907,
-0.024632968,
-0.0280679706,
0.047375869,
0.0067558307,
0.0351951197,
-0.0536896586,
-0.0035942555,
-0.0235015694,
-0.0008853413,
0.0237189941,
-0.0325590707,
-0.0186688174,
-0.1016446054,
0.0278741103,
-0.0334442966,
-0.0499223843,
-0.0287760105,
-0.0302934274,
0.0102258101,
-0.001091547,
0.017981872,
0.0204903781,
0.0175944008,
-0.031768918,
-0.0024276667,
0.0348096006,
-0.0350300334,
0.0351764485,
0.0003065048,
0.0342634618,
0.0493647978,
0.0553477779,
0.0491683297,
0.0041962047,
0.01280881,
-0.0377488658,
0.0255096722,
-0.0196525566,
0.0673256144,
-0.0203160867,
0.0212808736,
-0.0399707966,
-0.0314705968,
0.0027670602,
-0.0274862293,
-0.0341668092,
0.0210900102,
-0.0536980405,
0.0561502576,
-0.030027695,
0.0301393159,
0.0329483971,
0.0660238042,
0.0341353454,
0.0068773902,
-0.0376077257,
-0.0427560546,
0.0236279145,
-0.0325550176,
0.0033024347,
-0.0131584257,
0.0353304483,
0.0410376154,
-0.0899651945,
-0.0538611412,
-0.0416532718,
0.0263655782,
-0.0472814888,
0.0181065425,
-0.0265128296,
0.0109175639,
-0.0282798335,
0.0187350884,
0.0037599059,
-0.0059622391,
-0.0426996052,
0.0276704375,
0.0743653923,
-0.023843525,
-0.0317297578,
0.0276890397,
-0.0401484035,
-0.0254179016,
-0.0287422054,
0.055842489,
0.0240450259,
0.0650440156,
-0.0221339203,
0.0133193433,
0.004055819,
0.0102932369,
-0.008991925,
-0.045282919,
0.0386978798,
0.0604365356,
-0.040044792,
0.0270353034,
-0.0501713417,
0.0353682525,
-0.023439398,
0.0585289784,
-0.0389596969,
-0.0790149495,
-0.0095532229,
-0.0458906554,
0.0731903166,
0.0309822243,
-0.0214813016,
-0.0074408324,
0.0575647205,
-0.0404043868,
-0.0103723444,
-0.0347570777,
0.0296846498,
-0.0223753881,
-0.0495186001,
0.0128295021,
-0.0299067385,
-0.0103379134,
0.0686313957,
-0.0368961506,
-0.014160566,
0.0223131422,
-0.0273754951,
-0.0128785037,
0.0122590894,
-0.0329602994,
0.0489053242,
0.0158146508,
0.0622392185,
-0.0181554593,
0.0543080568,
0.0093159154,
-0.0496669002,
0.0231286511,
0.0476713441,
-0.133535549,
-0.0104143647,
-0.0254250877,
0.0016210211,
0.0410206132,
-0.0087472918,
0.043707706,
0.0287206583,
0.0195041914,
-0.0219919961,
0.0025820734,
0.0206261948,
-0.0393318124,
0.0100824432,
0.0462835059,
0.0111988373,
0.0803541616,
0.0396523736,
-0.0291857477,
0.0057061631,
-0.0093180956,
-0.0383809246,
-0.0472092815,
-0.0404226407,
-0.0221082773,
0.0458750091,
-0.0067853783,
0.0121792685,
-0.039402388,
-0.0266265143,
0.0177659616,
-0.013975312,
0.0008248102,
0.0053410451,
0.0367726162,
0.0371204391,
0.0259839408,
-0.0382652394,
-0.0613175482,
0.0155202299,
-0.0250800606,
-0.0288545135,
-0.0687494501,
-5.451726435e-33,
-0.0315512381,
-0.0333692878,
0.007612681,
-0.0072198808,
-0.0223465078,
0.0050182045,
-0.0298006032,
-0.0316204354,
-0.0619123839,
-0.0119637856,
-0.0280841179,
0.0159244779,
0.014154898,
0.0441834442,
-0.0390542746,
-0.0318594426,
0.0350865088,
0.0116563579,
0.0018207215,
0.0479955897,
0.0561204329,
0.040907383,
0.0302585606,
-0.1059298664,
0.0162989162,
-0.01033621,
0.0041475436,
0.0625761524,
-0.0160621107,
0.0936442092,
-0.028161006,
0.0285586268,
0.0326967351,
-0.0569112152,
0.0165427625,
0.0267139468,
-0.0810774192,
-0.0104958257,
-0.012058231,
-0.0395845883,
0.014659469,
0.0025788769,
-0.0064823814,
-0.0149371745,
0.0397586077,
-0.0083987992,
0.0108374385,
-0.0118952179,
-0.0600511208,
-0.0118308067,
-0.0231866091,
0.0308770016,
-0.0128405588,
-0.0318232477,
-0.0181438122,
0.1041867957,
0.0231613368,
0.0467845276,
-0.0776175633,
0.0113870744,
-0.033410348,
-0.0007413612,
0.0034832899,
0.0219396241,
-0.0251982454,
0.0553882979,
0.0149585642,
-0.0023483541,
-0.0339191556,
-0.0519167595,
-0.0370519422,
0.0529303662,
0.0215094145,
0.0410289206,
-0.0286582671,
0.0206182618,
-0.0573673658,
0.0334685519,
0.0214656983,
0.0202760175,
-0.0068732677,
0.0276502538,
-0.0233805329,
-0.0013596211,
-0.0317980275,
0.0103013832,
-0.0420149788,
0.0080862818,
0.0228332654,
0.0293620955,
-0.0059119123,
0.0101697743,
0.0442983992,
-0.0297836848,
-0.0175673552,
0.0819967389,
0.0051593333,
0.0012317838,
0.0188584868,
0.0226180591,
-0.0221106317,
0.0205659624,
0.0565916523,
-0.0022664722,
-0.0241822451,
0.0146413129,
0.0135770226,
-0.0334702209,
-0.0329809152,
0.0049424442,
0.0079014786,
0.0216296781,
-0.0672200769,
0.0454978198,
-0.0085550854,
-0.0001932567,
-0.0116108349,
0.079737097,
0.0052827541,
0.0449284725,
-0.0150746256,
-0.043560449,
0.0404084139,
0.0065991785,
-0.019463921,
0.0034672415,
0.0298399124,
0.0209425148,
0.0222739708,
-0.0139280856,
-0.0102256611,
0.0254515447,
2.212e-7,
0.0165403429,
0.0155442068,
0.0322839729,
-0.0079177823,
0.0329600945,
0.0383666083,
0.0021303482,
0.0165312514,
0.0507830568,
-0.0174548067,
0.0161458608,
0.0172723923,
0.0483947657,
0.012992519,
-0.0718677938,
-0.0862456411,
-0.0632705018,
-0.0749773458,
-0.0151994405,
-0.0276009627,
0.0488977544,
0.0892341211,
-0.020179946,
-0.0088157477,
-0.0250065997,
0.0013563184,
0.0333434865,
-0.0215976685,
-0.0066823619,
-0.0188586451,
0.027707018,
-0.0211236142,
-0.0134503609,
0.0056783571,
0.0005332661,
0.0187135339,
0.0094942059,
0.065570496,
-0.0016566537,
-0.1182412878,
-0.0153426267,
0.0265367143,
0.0291334502,
-0.036421001,
0.033143457,
-0.019404849,
-0.0023342678,
-0.0173785407,
-0.0530953482,
0.0380468518,
0.035969656,
0.0036644093,
-0.0348538607,
0.0079565085,
-0.0214398261,
0.0077537308,
0.0227904357,
-0.1146189123,
-0.0197148956,
-0.0209912471,
-0.0628171638,
-0.0388835371,
0.0148529755,
-0.0418491736,
0.0297991876,
-0.0104467003,
0.0281851199,
1.932747123e-34,
0.0447608232,
-0.00374667,
0.0090508079,
0.0407968685,
0.0343110636,
0.0096175447,
0.0101117725,
-0.0187989231,
0.0502854362,
-0.0886644498,
-0.0085750744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00173v1 | Lego-Features: Exporting modular encoder features for streaming and deliberation ASR | 2023-03-31T23:33:21 | 2023-03-31T23:33:21 | Rami Botros, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Johan Schalkwyk, Ciprian Chelba, Tara N. Sainath, Françoise Beaufays | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | In end-to-end (E2E) speech recognition models, a representational
tight-coupling inevitably emerges between the encoder and the decoder. We build
upon recent work that has begun to explore building encoders with modular
encoded representations, such that encoders and decoders from different models
can be stitched together in a zero-shot manner without further fine-tuning.
While previous research only addresses full-context speech models, we explore
the problem in a streaming setting as well. Our framework builds on top of
existing encoded representations, converting them to modular features, dubbed
as Lego-Features, without modifying the pre-trained model. The features remain
interchangeable when the model is retrained with distinct initializations.
Though sparse, we show that the Lego-Features are powerful when tested with
RNN-T or LAS decoders, maintaining high-quality downstream performance. They
are also rich enough to represent the first-pass prediction during two-pass
deliberation. In this scenario, they outperform the N-best hypotheses, since
they do not need to be supplemented with acoustic features to deliver the best
results. Moreover, generating the Lego-Features does not require beam search or
auto-regressive computation. Overall, they present a modular, powerful and
cheap alternative to the standard encoder output, as well as the N-best
hypotheses. | [
-0.0489471257,
0.0834725946,
0.0132102603,
0.0037772718,
-0.0003867837,
0.0032929562,
0.0424664989,
-0.0384629257,
-0.0626414642,
-0.0126815708,
-0.0367684551,
-0.039674338,
0.0145494714,
0.0937419534,
-0.0076448033,
-0.0557265617,
-0.0049955091,
-0.033828944,
-0.0093328608,
-0.0302602313,
0.0282375272,
0.0181096364,
-0.0181881879,
0.0727262199,
0.0183749739,
0.0375478119,
-0.0442161709,
0.0029674158,
0.0100138644,
-0.0018405401,
-0.0329615958,
0.0111631677,
0.0761553869,
0.0143665262,
0.0000020337,
0.0190829821,
-0.0287220255,
-0.0076534408,
-0.0911532044,
0.0003353211,
0.0051020416,
-0.0341707319,
-0.0133574363,
0.038239982,
-0.0058551901,
-0.063153103,
0.0600421131,
0.0129840253,
0.0270936061,
0.0507208966,
0.0071915635,
-0.0597955249,
0.0277866274,
-0.0380941778,
0.0004672592,
-0.0098819956,
-0.0356222279,
-0.0461618006,
-0.0220042672,
-0.016368255,
-0.0347144231,
0.0157439187,
0.0351392627,
0.0107716937,
0.0423793234,
0.0046542524,
-0.0274099186,
-0.0196462329,
-0.0032042582,
0.0502026863,
0.0126304757,
-0.0274976958,
0.0171149522,
0.0003308157,
-0.0279448051,
-0.0209381953,
-0.013215499,
0.0304412358,
0.0308837052,
-0.000565984,
-0.0243745428,
0.027390331,
0.0184978768,
-0.0415143631,
-0.0254069194,
0.0095310863,
0.021708345,
0.0093871458,
-0.026898304,
-0.0107992645,
-0.0090880841,
-0.0289658476,
0.0015802373,
-0.0112214964,
0.0053453604,
-0.0234719552,
-0.0601424836,
-0.0043888544,
-0.0636567101,
0.0179302972,
0.0498159751,
0.0578017421,
-0.0148630692,
0.0105363289,
-0.0220966171,
0.0331143253,
0.0024179013,
0.0059760609,
-0.0295331385,
-0.0411311015,
-0.0347720571,
-0.0111969775,
-0.0227416493,
0.0308876392,
-0.0289025437,
-0.0469042435,
-0.0199717879,
0.0185549222,
-0.0249342695,
0.0083564334,
0.01040674,
0.0205504354,
-0.0232601035,
-0.0420173854,
0.0324458964,
0.0778818205,
-0.0166013464,
0.0129660927,
0.0159784816,
-0.0780620426,
-0.0249001868,
0.0109993508,
0.0325051136,
0.00747274,
0.0147085469,
0.0514418967,
-0.0056051402,
-0.0115616769,
0.0346135907,
-0.000821287,
-0.0223375876,
-0.0413224399,
0.0393666923,
-0.0587905385,
0.0499256514,
0.0109294523,
0.0144488038,
-0.0381484665,
-0.0026554281,
-0.0382779241,
0.0533121601,
0.0446902402,
-0.0070995581,
0.0065402328,
0.0060544224,
-0.009366937,
-0.0016692551,
0.0440151989,
0.0592665374,
0.0259372741,
-0.0142807746,
-0.0659720004,
-0.0157418177,
0.0304430835,
0.0137116937,
0.0001667961,
-0.0264167301,
-0.031887576,
0.0375905819,
-0.003981201,
0.0400132649,
-0.022856364,
-0.0619709529,
0.0105513241,
0.0446140505,
-0.0048637432,
0.0479632579,
0.0059572444,
0.0259725153,
0.0188832525,
-0.0118523892,
-0.006248856,
0.0033554309,
0.0625541806,
0.0155951092,
0.0025171305,
0.0206751022,
0.0808371529,
-0.0427143946,
-0.0064453767,
0.0004447562,
-0.0083526121,
0.0224353764,
0.0368330851,
0.0519411713,
-0.0096992645,
-0.0273619052,
0.062995486,
-0.0288839974,
-0.0457585603,
0.0257486776,
-0.0290767942,
-0.0054918309,
0.0620145872,
0.0286225919,
0.0052690837,
-0.0476339459,
-0.0255592,
-0.018496789,
0.0055012917,
-0.0053795846,
-0.0071799066,
0.0814201087,
-0.0863912255,
-0.0464638397,
-0.0041628997,
0.0169572383,
0.0892506093,
-0.0418544188,
0.0210869238,
0.0095922528,
-0.0079849316,
0.0415222757,
-0.0313538462,
-0.0049246126,
-0.0117177609,
0.05327994,
0.0150176743,
0.0606929995,
0.0120113529,
-0.0236737002,
-0.0005768402,
0.0454201996,
-0.0584327132,
0.0088800248,
0.0553159155,
-0.0658561066,
-0.0382966064,
0.0028875177,
-0.0318097323,
0.0540201254,
0.0618455,
-0.0304151922,
-0.0766984671,
0.0455245636,
-0.0067057349,
0.033892706,
-0.0305312369,
0.0281869676,
0.0147481216,
0.0171662942,
0.0464961752,
-0.0071603917,
-0.0005065412,
-0.018717831,
-0.0088807819,
-0.0420614444,
-0.0039504347,
-0.0663052574,
-0.0242373273,
0.0413418226,
0.0067237508,
-0.0034557492,
-0.0080868276,
-0.0216871314,
0.0424562432,
0.0075812754,
-0.0926974118,
-0.0132584609,
-0.0468785204,
-0.004591499,
0.0048542544,
0.0113232862,
0.0253082123,
-0.0082283933,
-0.0149090569,
-0.0183190368,
-0.0100062536,
0.0187984984,
-0.0527460687,
-0.0031954139,
-0.0355368555,
0.0166832842,
-0.0455646664,
0.0417112559,
0.0099167256,
-0.0654048696,
-0.0162616316,
-0.0426615141,
-0.0508411825,
0.0247341264,
-0.0151986638,
-0.0133240074,
-0.0135273961,
0.000262691,
-0.0129062217,
-0.0278578289,
0.0318563022,
-0.0062499223,
0.0221240465,
0.0289107375,
-0.0158933774,
-0.0463220775,
0.0221816078,
0.0077411975,
0.0835807323,
-0.010550959,
0.0248339623,
-0.0148457745,
0.0050481646,
0.0064550932,
0.039003469,
-0.0742972046,
-0.0041922149,
0.0397797786,
-0.0676136687,
-0.0274108946,
-0.0702363104,
-0.002011399,
-0.0033956252,
-0.0012866594,
-0.0303302761,
0.0258495454,
-0.0498941988,
-0.0453136005,
-0.0134208919,
-0.029014349,
-0.0387917161,
0.0318483748,
0.0105819432,
-0.0093058189,
-0.0252683591,
-0.0402338505,
-0.0080002313,
0.0507786572,
0.0343570225,
-0.0248199403,
0.0480455905,
-0.0082495259,
-0.0310110431,
-0.0361157879,
-0.0398870111,
-0.0078607555,
0.0049713934,
-0.0039886259,
0.038605947,
0.0060726455,
-0.0281700101,
-0.0429494753,
0.0224663001,
-0.0076589594,
0.0411037095,
0.006377066,
0.0644175634,
-0.0367792621,
0.0501658283,
0.0298473798,
0.0423336662,
0.018079374,
-0.0208214391,
0.0413549393,
0.0141942007,
0.0644476041,
0.0014589228,
-0.0543686822,
-0.005061056,
0.0500939675,
0.0202660412,
-0.0229484178,
0.017840052,
0.0783683658,
-0.0736786872,
0.0149321072,
0.0910802931,
-0.0167356282,
-0.0221950505,
-0.0231494624,
0.0245557092,
0.0886173174,
-0.0052171708,
-0.0256373305,
-0.0444672294,
-0.0558997355,
0.0600587465,
0.0082643507,
0.02644304,
0.0160922706,
-0.0064695072,
-0.1026430875,
0.062722221,
0.0491099618,
-0.0073693697,
-0.0334345177,
-0.0096748611,
-0.0427282453,
-0.039891459,
0.0292580891,
-0.0139450533,
-0.0040417467,
0.0067573916,
0.0353247002,
-0.0642743036,
-0.0555851758,
0.0168840531,
-0.0251921695,
0.0706177503,
0.0655755773,
-0.0043905806,
0.0046082083,
-0.0108459266,
0.0099095553,
-0.0363690965,
0.0046601426,
0.0176935699,
0.0216496568,
-0.0046913759,
-0.0066269841,
0.0444854051,
0.0318855718,
-0.006436571,
-0.0007733632,
-0.0313911214,
0.0517808534,
-0.0653520748,
0.0164210852,
-0.0124292858,
-0.0090607367,
0.0011079642,
0.0659767613,
0.0187153071,
-0.0105810901,
-0.0290288683,
0.0101368958,
-0.0028638944,
0.0057772803,
-0.0056709731,
-0.0146342842,
0.0247204956,
-0.05780093,
-0.0245893765,
-0.0074983845,
0.0406222865,
0.034448415,
-0.0103145866,
-0.0222441461,
-0.0517285913,
0.0097238682,
-0.0395430177,
0.0036076014,
-0.0102746775,
0.0018869785,
-0.0363164507,
0.0111706788,
0.0446046479,
-0.032070592,
-0.0170001108,
0.016737543,
-0.0810329244,
-0.0373059288,
0.012595485,
0.0013621481,
0.0210195985,
0.0641168952,
-0.0267307106,
-0.0128442887,
0.0473312363,
0.0023124046,
-0.0283459779,
0.020527035,
0.0719268247,
-0.0136683388,
-0.0258511454,
0.0397943407,
-0.0485160239,
0.0282512885,
-0.0367603824,
0.0139312381,
-0.0002480616,
-0.0226278715,
-0.0029162699,
-0.0171742514,
0.0364443064,
0.0124090416,
-0.0073656486,
-0.0221474525,
0.0574868321,
-0.0156679936,
0.0559649132,
-0.0650332496,
-0.0029916863,
0.0405209549,
0.0126491077,
0.0007010415,
0.0613380447,
0.0426093526,
-0.0159943514,
-0.0303182863,
0.0539527535,
0.0177515503,
-0.020428583,
-0.0143339681,
0.0006116673,
0.0058026342,
0.0408377498,
0.0366047956,
-0.0006604253,
-0.0343976244,
0.0094537642,
-0.0090676751,
0.0162468944,
-0.0199373513,
0.0597412288,
-0.0679926127,
-0.0730379522,
-0.0549518317,
0.0224012863,
-0.0056259786,
0.0203825776,
0.0500282384,
0.0121451057,
0.0010521531,
-0.0450059548,
0.0237921253,
-0.0155338896,
-0.0164346527,
0.0384727828,
0.012435995,
-0.0263146218,
-0.0044924603,
0.0171961654,
0.0032717725,
0.0351520851,
-0.0292827282,
0.0525302477,
-0.0248191003,
-0.0431566797,
-0.018732449,
-0.0015126077,
-0.0012118379,
-0.0238434151,
-0.0145385507,
-0.0291278679,
0.0321483128,
-0.057841219,
0.0034473054,
-0.0393424742,
0.0407897495,
-0.0063407621,
-0.0414630026,
0.0191546232,
0.0216564313,
-0.0516656935,
-0.0104852803,
-0.0018198144,
0.0084977718,
-6.324676825e-33,
-0.0314185061,
0.0499143973,
0.0016478652,
-0.0300675537,
-0.0262162723,
-0.0179781467,
-0.0066154529,
-0.0102607356,
-0.015614599,
-0.0213164203,
-0.0075825821,
0.0358353555,
0.0301359687,
0.0044959653,
0.027427122,
-0.0558466315,
0.1077025011,
-0.0300050154,
-0.0270330049,
0.0264753588,
0.0562789515,
0.0228771679,
0.0239302851,
-0.0320516489,
-0.0634474829,
0.0216128826,
-0.0326887034,
-0.0298018213,
0.00916092,
0.0455810986,
0.0144897969,
0.0052641826,
-0.0090561248,
-0.0639409348,
-0.0454950817,
0.004681956,
-0.0693607777,
0.0074480916,
-0.0320251472,
0.0256346595,
-0.0084924232,
-0.0492639169,
0.0166471712,
0.0255684368,
-0.0341444686,
-0.0381988399,
0.002975008,
-0.0140136359,
-0.0312891714,
-0.0244400818,
-0.0018720513,
0.0181919821,
-0.034836404,
-0.0105893407,
0.0693219751,
0.065211527,
0.0052694613,
-0.0177385285,
-0.089886114,
0.0448905267,
0.015107546,
0.0651762635,
0.0432040878,
-0.0211624634,
0.03373871,
0.0592782982,
0.0809147954,
-0.0768598467,
-0.0087828953,
0.022135172,
0.0348134339,
0.0767119005,
0.0378098413,
0.0204529073,
0.0916811451,
-0.0062050815,
-0.0170804393,
0.001041343,
0.0004297676,
0.0565901287,
0.0172036663,
0.0400497206,
-0.0223498754,
-0.0008447376,
-0.056120608,
-0.0622845218,
-0.0106545519,
-0.0349665619,
0.0575237945,
0.0474260375,
-0.0142258471,
-0.0030486989,
0.0919700637,
-0.0299577042,
0.0440324023,
0.058722496,
-0.0245216731,
0.0316451155,
0.0329088308,
0.011372488,
-0.0236520618,
-0.0172588229,
0.076669842,
-0.0011136902,
-0.0056370432,
-0.0234094784,
-0.0100602927,
0.103283301,
-0.0507458299,
-0.0131745683,
-0.0208727084,
0.0146590918,
-0.0260462891,
0.0380257964,
0.0633529499,
-0.006401117,
-0.00001115,
0.02857765,
-0.055141937,
0.0412804484,
-0.0167960767,
-0.0013102018,
0.0421289019,
0.008431538,
-0.0024343687,
0.0220337771,
-0.0150127476,
-0.0907221809,
0.0437825993,
-0.0005765122,
-0.0104318932,
0.0246704649,
2.788e-7,
-0.0616920181,
-0.0198388323,
0.0411984473,
-0.0515569374,
0.0510006398,
0.0360377878,
-0.0053035738,
0.0046015107,
0.0239733402,
-0.0208105724,
0.0156353097,
0.0262330882,
0.0977673754,
0.01452873,
-0.0778768733,
0.0066686342,
-0.016705852,
-0.0039626132,
0.0029346645,
-0.0469904803,
0.0011104554,
0.1056438237,
-0.0207683332,
-0.0177272819,
0.0237746686,
0.0240357667,
0.0407914259,
0.0011604608,
-0.0129053416,
-0.0090613272,
-0.0216132421,
-0.0110935466,
-0.0449531488,
-0.0141981645,
-0.0327882245,
0.0335580222,
0.0106802452,
0.0555185713,
0.0113704959,
-0.1190540642,
-0.0180051979,
0.0511355586,
-0.0262169261,
0.039412003,
0.0775066465,
0.0219502542,
-0.0412530154,
-0.0305060726,
-0.0643007681,
0.0045411638,
0.0017437357,
0.0073044566,
0.0150690991,
0.0030953335,
0.0042393552,
-0.0089850677,
-0.016477108,
-0.0662419274,
0.0206721295,
-0.0256478377,
-0.0928490683,
-0.0086782053,
-0.0340528823,
-0.0001825466,
0.0737696141,
-0.0506617092,
-0.0395442918,
2.533343921e-34,
0.0382098258,
-0.0039888197,
0.0280067176,
0.0446771346,
-0.0186278578,
-0.0392762572,
-0.014073642,
-0.0017005787,
0.0054219253,
-0.0633869022,
-0.0385638066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00171v1 | Practical Conformer: Optimizing size, speed and flops of Conformer for on-Device and cloud ASR | 2023-03-31T23:30:48 | 2023-03-31T23:30:48 | Rami Botros, Anmol Gulati, Tara N. Sainath, Krzysztof Choromanski, Ruoming Pang, Trevor Strohman, Weiran Wang, Jiahui Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Conformer models maintain a large number of internal states, the vast
majority of which are associated with self-attention layers. With limited
memory bandwidth, reading these from memory at each inference step can slow
down inference. In this paper, we design an optimized conformer that is small
enough to meet on-device restrictions and has fast inference on TPUs. We
explore various ideas to improve the execution speed, including replacing lower
conformer blocks with convolution-only blocks, strategically downsizing the
architecture, and utilizing an RNNAttention-Performer. Our optimized conformer
can be readily incorporated into a cascaded-encoder setting, allowing a
second-pass decoder to operate on its output and improve the accuracy whenever
more resources are available. Altogether, we find that these optimizations can
reduce latency by a factor of 6.8x, and come at a reasonable trade-off in
quality. With the cascaded second-pass, we show that the recognition accuracy
is completely recoverable. Thus, our proposed encoder can double as a strong
standalone encoder in on device, and as the first part of a high-performance
ASR pipeline. | [
-0.0337242484,
0.0348224528,
0.0127405208,
0.047490783,
-0.0189904571,
-0.0052450034,
0.0671892539,
-0.007601745,
-0.0146923065,
-0.024973223,
0.0215236023,
-0.0188051071,
0.0033447219,
0.0225291681,
-0.0167953987,
-0.0012762448,
-0.0027570252,
-0.0040060044,
-0.0170953982,
-0.0469170883,
-0.0119394176,
0.0034673873,
-0.0095291007,
0.0428144112,
0.0235496517,
0.0061474573,
-0.0304228645,
0.0171161741,
0.0271649379,
-0.0183669794,
-0.0315053798,
0.019767778,
0.0547874272,
0.0191441793,
0.0000022176,
0.0362207219,
-0.0127545316,
0.0113936123,
-0.0454809107,
0.0012678829,
0.0217210744,
-0.0436225086,
-0.0386951938,
0.0252605695,
0.0014176988,
-0.0220495965,
0.0735564753,
0.0302501991,
0.0102511998,
0.0320023224,
0.0170772132,
-0.0389952473,
0.012608449,
-0.019813817,
-0.0466674305,
-0.0511600263,
-0.0283131618,
-0.051107537,
-0.0283591338,
-0.0237020738,
-0.0457087681,
0.0203257035,
0.0805444196,
0.0094231432,
0.0505419038,
0.0123650692,
0.025048187,
-0.0363991931,
-0.0325106606,
0.0048387358,
-0.0193336904,
-0.0575400181,
-0.0044175456,
-0.0089351339,
-0.0552087314,
-0.0244635791,
0.0099309906,
0.0049781697,
-0.0369507521,
0.0087648639,
-0.041470997,
0.0125992419,
0.026861418,
-0.029959213,
-0.0439383164,
-0.0071770805,
0.0231988635,
0.0170912053,
-0.0206721872,
0.0174303968,
0.0512591451,
-0.0509455353,
0.0370726287,
-0.0031005398,
0.0000250577,
-0.0549541563,
-0.0735616609,
-0.0199300423,
-0.0507671237,
-0.0434742421,
0.0482869968,
0.0526428074,
0.0112857241,
0.0159660466,
-0.0253023244,
0.0646695718,
-0.0535728224,
0.0367771573,
-0.0089182947,
0.0122443289,
0.0074453135,
0.0012157651,
-0.018160712,
0.0104699237,
-0.0297978371,
-0.0845758021,
-0.0108105456,
-0.0193622373,
0.0193279404,
-0.0147657609,
0.0317575932,
0.013760074,
-0.0342290215,
-0.0469560027,
0.0302669927,
0.0812982321,
0.029792998,
-0.0131462133,
0.0028095043,
-0.0972750261,
-0.0163434837,
0.0264485627,
0.0352438539,
0.0043066465,
0.0065770666,
0.0223449189,
-0.0083606131,
-0.0635842234,
0.0225904752,
0.0266067293,
0.0135237891,
-0.0011365839,
0.0545358472,
-0.0281538125,
0.0628262386,
-0.0043180371,
0.0022631907,
-0.0747092962,
0.0397399142,
0.0189341772,
0.0387661867,
0.0462273285,
0.0097827744,
-0.0564312153,
-0.0075566242,
0.0009917276,
0.0065907417,
0.0276889373,
0.0556186065,
0.0021004784,
-0.0202905666,
-0.0663006082,
-0.011033698,
0.0052123875,
0.0036200602,
-0.046464894,
-0.0406300984,
-0.0070291227,
0.0379788652,
0.0257922094,
0.0648388937,
0.0160635971,
0.001790993,
-0.0316719562,
0.0188330878,
-0.005361943,
0.0357456692,
-0.0159392282,
-0.0234927461,
0.0223809462,
-0.0376605764,
-0.0301215462,
-0.0387150757,
0.0870175064,
0.0354641825,
-0.0181887131,
0.0711295456,
0.0728394613,
-0.0230336804,
-0.0123985903,
-0.0418939777,
-0.0054878714,
-0.014472858,
0.0514347255,
0.0300611425,
-0.0054621948,
-0.0089765247,
0.0168067832,
-0.0161350686,
-0.0309969038,
-0.0019652953,
-0.0589667298,
0.0128036728,
0.0345101468,
0.0588058122,
0.0228128601,
-0.0124872234,
0.0297098253,
0.013196243,
0.0012803613,
-0.0009324951,
0.0324521512,
0.0680156946,
-0.0541100092,
-0.0243521854,
0.0178380497,
-0.000385494,
0.0656957999,
0.0223564766,
0.0015400399,
0.0019880175,
0.0212275758,
0.0145192463,
-0.0107688652,
0.0251333527,
-0.0156105086,
0.0553250015,
0.0335507318,
0.0482190289,
0.0024214641,
-0.0239810608,
-0.0204784311,
0.0615649745,
-0.0774760023,
0.0036653839,
-0.0173334889,
-0.0626198575,
-0.0019469439,
-0.0120787015,
-0.0081893271,
0.0289891418,
0.0424928144,
-0.0000215484,
-0.0536673702,
0.0302685779,
-0.0385157168,
0.0788359642,
-0.007165439,
0.0327662192,
0.0633257106,
0.0389490947,
0.0402138345,
-0.0006729517,
0.0102791172,
0.0066547194,
-0.0490314849,
-0.0217311326,
-0.0336024724,
-0.0319056213,
0.0039732722,
-0.004128369,
-0.0114231082,
-0.0161780603,
0.0119710332,
-0.0478913151,
0.0511895977,
-0.0089544794,
0.0313919671,
-0.0013315838,
-0.06013228,
0.0133141149,
-0.0145764221,
0.0534539595,
0.0429737195,
-0.0437824056,
0.0295687467,
-0.0120805446,
-0.0354904085,
0.0224810429,
-0.0578801334,
-0.0243880264,
-0.0647804961,
0.0491046347,
-0.0256758016,
0.0520380177,
0.0010036139,
-0.0097072041,
-0.0015277797,
-0.04415695,
-0.0741938725,
0.0551792048,
0.0267564654,
-0.0054640742,
-0.0173404627,
0.0367422141,
0.0176532026,
-0.0201918762,
0.1106415987,
-0.0061646872,
0.0209612772,
0.01612835,
0.0353602283,
0.0053000618,
0.0066388883,
0.0233424176,
0.0096557382,
-0.0103128748,
0.0123690376,
-0.0604327284,
0.060469307,
-0.0198726654,
0.0131575409,
-0.0586140677,
-0.0246867836,
0.0382073782,
-0.0291526821,
-0.0128737791,
-0.0077444483,
-0.0216109324,
0.0132308127,
-0.0142691303,
-0.0293171536,
0.0152378865,
-0.0481911674,
-0.0339205675,
0.0151141165,
-0.0096048489,
-0.0014370481,
0.0528268516,
0.0626333356,
0.0240319613,
-0.0150542818,
-0.0388214588,
0.0452286676,
0.0443891995,
-0.0052026487,
-0.0175548531,
0.0237852447,
-0.0229637958,
-0.0006531484,
-0.0257255342,
-0.0421966314,
0.0124390582,
0.0494717509,
-0.0371484123,
0.0071532018,
0.0019222909,
-0.0435733572,
-0.0209676083,
0.0289630145,
0.0110436231,
0.0809732974,
0.0254501607,
0.0177805908,
-0.0574892983,
0.0089044413,
-0.0108944876,
0.043526154,
0.0069950977,
0.0085852537,
0.0188645292,
0.0699477643,
0.0316700488,
0.0047267415,
-0.0712014586,
-0.011067329,
0.0466654859,
0.0058141015,
0.0317205191,
0.0702601522,
0.0669213608,
-0.0833025798,
-0.0307392534,
0.051363945,
-0.0209790152,
-0.0434088036,
-0.007507822,
0.037676882,
-0.0025352049,
0.0140894121,
-0.0209860876,
-0.0390288159,
-0.0611967482,
0.0394782908,
0.0112700975,
0.0230823439,
0.0315507576,
-0.0049671535,
-0.0451454781,
0.0331785604,
0.0059024361,
-0.0099704079,
-0.07376232,
-0.0323951282,
-0.0375569128,
-0.0228470601,
0.0333022736,
0.0047850362,
-0.0028574392,
-0.0005672671,
-0.0253491867,
-0.0211139023,
-0.0471167117,
0.0158897843,
-0.0265315212,
0.0096943779,
0.0662052855,
-0.0371351354,
0.0278191902,
-0.0575110242,
0.0001405461,
-0.0377444103,
0.0106211491,
-0.0071980027,
-0.0094690342,
0.0054165339,
-0.0107135922,
-0.003836568,
0.0138466069,
-0.0380422547,
-0.0031632464,
-0.0414317772,
0.0245595966,
-0.0176149942,
-0.02822062,
0.0159716737,
-0.0119225588,
-0.0237485338,
0.027550064,
0.0040815491,
0.0160759687,
-0.0478747711,
0.0100264847,
0.0376577228,
-0.0614015013,
0.0019109517,
-0.0385043547,
0.0555986091,
-0.0870737061,
0.032575205,
0.0334363207,
0.0053378604,
0.0357033163,
0.0001788449,
-0.0441737846,
0.0348199792,
0.0161210205,
-0.063168399,
-0.0321706384,
-0.0452750735,
-0.0039453167,
-0.0672800764,
-0.023957625,
0.0223869123,
0.0011618048,
-0.0103996098,
0.0621294118,
-0.0860144719,
-0.0221261159,
0.0428338014,
0.0204958748,
0.0169035736,
0.0444217175,
-0.0101178586,
0.0023173592,
0.0190107245,
-0.0074497527,
-0.053059116,
0.0461535119,
0.0159420669,
-0.0496654101,
-0.0024873682,
0.0314866602,
-0.0179528017,
0.0240556635,
-0.0167511459,
0.0007579179,
-0.012144383,
-0.0663201213,
0.0193360969,
-0.0170630626,
0.0399813317,
0.0008839007,
0.038708359,
0.022436494,
0.0977778062,
-0.0088324882,
0.059837684,
-0.0390939116,
-0.0234028492,
-0.0159480888,
-0.0028866888,
0.0186598431,
0.0719776303,
0.0573739409,
-0.0454775952,
0.011192427,
0.0266411118,
0.0010753594,
0.0199957713,
0.0100681484,
-0.0403782614,
-0.0061310353,
0.0236812457,
0.0624390729,
0.0465545505,
-0.0496133007,
-0.0139916874,
0.0107599637,
0.0175191015,
-0.0366975069,
0.0295379627,
-0.031175999,
-0.0330593064,
-0.0447643586,
0.0068394328,
0.0127919326,
0.0215682015,
0.0042985841,
0.0025590546,
-0.0102025941,
-0.034003254,
0.0634586513,
-0.0194289777,
-0.0382816829,
0.0526879318,
0.0236250348,
0.0117404936,
0.0161284506,
-0.0050723143,
-0.0283428524,
0.0270491447,
-0.0045232712,
0.0483332761,
-0.0316004083,
-0.0416655913,
-0.0481416956,
0.0083467541,
-0.013402625,
0.0120589323,
0.0331819095,
-0.0341630764,
0.0511466004,
-0.038280528,
0.0289517511,
-0.052180849,
-0.0049934476,
-0.0186848342,
-0.0041063344,
-0.0548417307,
0.0378729552,
-0.0229975116,
-0.030038191,
-0.0066986242,
0.0023549397,
-6.997802359e-33,
-0.026260417,
0.0306802373,
0.0131311351,
-0.0303653199,
-0.0053284247,
0.0102555873,
-0.0063941972,
-0.0138546657,
-0.0055235988,
-0.0253709666,
-0.0148091568,
0.0200119093,
0.0454415157,
0.0499707051,
0.0155719398,
-0.0182842165,
0.0885112733,
-0.034956526,
-0.0377584845,
0.0166943371,
0.0432312377,
-0.0033961507,
0.0252482668,
-0.006411517,
-0.0858046934,
0.0433564298,
0.0007405633,
-0.0702199191,
-0.0243406817,
0.0078322524,
-0.0006945301,
-0.0212258063,
-0.0016387996,
-0.0396032333,
0.0126497447,
0.0149019165,
-0.0747995973,
0.030940298,
-0.0665293112,
0.0330439173,
-0.0070371754,
-0.0693082884,
0.0274542291,
0.0351646915,
-0.0765119493,
-0.0544395894,
-0.0187315401,
0.0205855705,
-0.0494468436,
-0.01942694,
0.0111152865,
0.0151012233,
0.0084635131,
-0.0123651261,
0.0462399721,
-0.0006726503,
-0.0518232137,
0.0007434047,
-0.1223077476,
-0.0052943812,
-0.0021529708,
0.0553141274,
0.0332417749,
-0.0185371935,
-0.0037626857,
0.0135856634,
0.0402721241,
-0.0642518401,
-0.0393095836,
0.0004315311,
-0.0196992271,
0.0057825893,
0.0113184759,
-0.0041099177,
0.0997675061,
-0.0313543007,
-0.014261202,
-0.0051304684,
-0.0166502763,
0.0572148114,
0.0363725238,
0.0141151398,
-0.0719869211,
-0.0030036797,
0.0228618402,
-0.0276722852,
-0.0158048794,
0.0034848049,
0.0435166396,
0.0628388226,
-0.0368301459,
0.0179312583,
0.0496325009,
-0.0270475317,
0.0790243,
-0.0166795272,
0.0857814327,
0.0478591211,
0.0280820001,
0.0008162567,
-0.022968987,
0.0048161619,
0.0410645455,
-0.0135806948,
0.0081418017,
-0.0167474989,
0.0014487382,
0.0816811919,
-0.0861318558,
-0.0387511849,
-0.031378407,
0.0324403904,
0.017490821,
0.0010691492,
0.0638724416,
-0.0008117675,
0.0048768362,
0.0508198813,
-0.0886675864,
0.0074455063,
-0.0187988505,
0.009135019,
0.0637395903,
0.0009889265,
-0.014975002,
0.0266373772,
-0.0567374341,
-0.0219465811,
0.0007193576,
-0.0253054369,
-0.0365203954,
0.053778369,
3.063e-7,
-0.0495585464,
-0.0003144422,
0.0407382511,
-0.0475926921,
0.0247487575,
-0.0235761367,
0.044389274,
0.0335801877,
-0.0089595914,
-0.0012922029,
-0.0310354531,
0.0272024386,
0.068158567,
-0.0134220738,
-0.0598933734,
0.0177178159,
-0.0232101809,
0.064840138,
0.0360108241,
-0.0302527212,
0.0025294914,
0.0939074382,
-0.0263166912,
-0.0105023831,
0.0660602376,
0.0312979408,
0.0180149563,
0.0456431247,
0.0824263841,
-0.0495754406,
-0.0253162812,
-0.0157694239,
-0.0585905313,
0.0230606217,
-0.0079241274,
0.0128742792,
-0.061336711,
0.0540559851,
-0.0269623268,
-0.0648962557,
-0.0418947712,
0.0169159994,
-0.0163979083,
-0.0045131091,
0.0526058376,
-0.013043737,
-0.0591242462,
-0.0424193256,
-0.0490431339,
-0.0009404988,
-0.0326014608,
0.0372384451,
0.0378620848,
-0.0088441912,
0.014536771,
-0.0228341501,
-0.0108499238,
-0.0429766364,
0.0218551587,
-0.0209031291,
-0.0634317473,
0.0222634971,
-0.0698633716,
-0.0158416964,
0.0525119752,
-0.0067313965,
-0.0595246851,
2.559343468e-34,
0.0153311612,
-0.0066648754,
0.0240531005,
0.0409863517,
0.0119159864,
-0.0431016721,
0.048271887,
0.0187516864,
-0.0355421118,
-0.073771283,
-0.0430215299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00121v1 | Decoding the End-to-end Writing Trajectory in Scholarly Manuscripts | 2023-03-31T20:33:03 | 2023-03-31T20:33:03 | Ryan Koo, Anna Martin, Linghe Wang, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Scholarly writing presents a complex space that generally follows a
methodical procedure to plan and produce both rationally sound and creative
compositions. Recent works involving large language models (LLM) demonstrate
considerable success in text generation and revision tasks; however, LLMs still
struggle to provide structural and creative feedback on the document level that
is crucial to academic writing. In this paper, we introduce a novel taxonomy
that categorizes scholarly writing behaviors according to intention, writer
actions, and the information types of the written data. We also provide
ManuScript, an original dataset annotated with a simplified version of our
taxonomy to show writer actions and the intentions behind them. Motivated by
cognitive writing theory, our taxonomy for scientific papers includes three
levels of categorization in order to trace the general writing flow and
identify the distinct writer activities embedded within each higher-level
process. ManuScript intends to provide a complete picture of the scholarly
writing process by capturing the linearity and non-linearity of writing
trajectory, such that writing assistants can provide stronger feedback and
suggestions on an end-to-end level. The collected writing trajectories are
viewed at https://minnesotanlp.github.io/REWARD_demo/ | [
0.0728195682,
0.0510020517,
0.0133570991,
-0.0316303745,
-0.0622100681,
0.0065516019,
0.0072410377,
0.0061211693,
-0.0332458057,
-0.079343006,
-0.0124990791,
-0.0103280898,
0.0243983399,
0.0224424321,
0.0269837994,
-0.0182855409,
0.0075884201,
-0.0253507346,
0.0777975917,
0.0254056305,
0.0230605304,
0.031245267,
0.0131142307,
0.0528871045,
0.0095901713,
-0.0762271509,
-0.0228864122,
0.0025897503,
-0.0253032129,
-0.0186362732,
0.0054857493,
0.0767962262,
0.0272516999,
0.0864547044,
0.0000017942,
-0.0409607179,
-0.0052692555,
0.0040643653,
0.0293174144,
0.0237323735,
0.060386505,
-0.0342747606,
-0.0124831665,
-0.0072333859,
-0.0105247274,
0.0016596135,
0.026859656,
0.0451388769,
0.0190559048,
0.068849355,
-0.008217115,
-0.0496289656,
0.0666084439,
0.0010918094,
0.0233595874,
0.0385524631,
0.0377170481,
0.0168274753,
-0.0036328919,
0.0391031057,
0.0079321703,
-0.0115772039,
-0.0295310467,
-0.1003562734,
0.0291538034,
0.0125712641,
0.0119460281,
0.0033533568,
0.0326751731,
-0.0247144494,
0.0675231963,
-0.0156878959,
0.0581408031,
0.0025539466,
-0.0293496959,
0.035132248,
-0.0650784373,
0.0252205823,
-0.0219957661,
-0.0400362387,
0.0586529411,
-0.0130561311,
0.0117713045,
0.0454426706,
0.0138975708,
0.0123266988,
0.0023451312,
-0.0313602462,
-0.0258547831,
0.0061506322,
0.0235128477,
-0.0987121686,
-0.0100158472,
0.0611606613,
-0.0029828851,
-0.008887169,
-0.0277534984,
-0.0650152713,
0.0311363079,
0.0010071726,
0.0875386372,
-0.0018183317,
0.0558575764,
0.0344353877,
0.0293922294,
0.0159188882,
-0.0123942941,
-0.0107167419,
-0.0229907837,
0.0362220779,
-0.038348265,
-0.0248117112,
-0.0071952506,
0.0068380227,
0.0105047794,
-0.0444352813,
-0.0418808423,
-0.0009340338,
0.0209933985,
0.0206286311,
-0.0134869311,
0.0013231202,
-0.0666297004,
0.002247334,
0.0240526758,
-0.0014328597,
0.0188548975,
0.0321526416,
0.0081132092,
0.074104093,
0.0128199933,
0.039884191,
0.0069095003,
-0.0270676743,
-0.0185849648,
0.013283941,
-0.0023830468,
0.0053315447,
-0.0261601992,
-0.058824826,
0.0274165384,
-0.0491468385,
0.0144333588,
-0.0706828162,
0.0184372533,
0.0383993722,
-0.0082057202,
-0.0466345027,
-0.0256445128,
0.0116832834,
-0.0207430795,
-0.0099485843,
-0.0217481963,
0.0237972438,
0.089523837,
-0.01737261,
-0.0058430065,
-0.0240460858,
0.0677117035,
0.0061363401,
0.0302144587,
-0.0049710744,
0.051940877,
0.0159352403,
-0.0185590386,
0.0140999826,
-0.0216715168,
-0.0091260187,
0.0102731613,
0.0668340325,
0.0147209056,
0.0386382006,
-0.0314618535,
0.0531471595,
0.0818262324,
0.0687241331,
0.0231367182,
0.0264938511,
0.0499220341,
-0.0006588547,
0.0228973906,
0.0312819742,
0.020248659,
0.0252594799,
0.0231993757,
0.0198144056,
-0.0028080086,
-0.013983936,
-0.0049646543,
-0.0121719856,
-0.0209110025,
0.0284928977,
-0.0356669202,
-0.070006147,
0.0220423304,
-0.0047751726,
-0.0347070023,
-0.0299494825,
-0.0132644018,
-0.0420300066,
0.0478314757,
0.0175322313,
0.0650685281,
0.0755575597,
0.0876775831,
-0.0329859741,
-0.002759143,
-0.0415966325,
0.0219486132,
0.045111198,
-0.0067784176,
-0.0166587457,
-0.0566443019,
-0.0275178663,
-0.0242458694,
-0.0299068652,
0.0131698372,
-0.0385482162,
-0.0207111724,
0.0016097459,
-0.0101994714,
-0.0046123667,
-0.0704666153,
0.0676445365,
-0.0603022613,
0.0030992075,
0.0009052405,
-0.0242328886,
0.0152287344,
0.0121286903,
-0.0397928059,
0.0287179928,
0.015602245,
-0.0210509263,
0.0141680548,
0.0298423413,
0.0379977599,
0.0277607422,
0.0149242282,
-0.0140069891,
0.0339433551,
0.0052630231,
0.0190247484,
-0.0478739776,
0.0144197913,
-0.0198493358,
-0.0010307019,
-0.0111791622,
0.0132291829,
-0.0110077821,
-0.0483568683,
-0.0241443999,
0.0112174945,
-0.0092151491,
0.0519459397,
0.0316736177,
-0.0396152139,
0.0129887993,
0.0318622068,
0.0022399651,
0.0159858949,
0.0296044108,
-0.0007234736,
0.0456699803,
-0.0159911364,
-0.013389769,
-0.084141545,
-0.0546049699,
0.0192917343,
-0.0290843025,
0.005352553,
0.0229372885,
-0.0427599698,
-0.0004013691,
0.039304316,
0.0176797025,
-0.0102238571,
-0.0006075977,
-0.01837424,
0.052338317,
-0.0153675657,
0.0163639113,
-0.0301915985,
-0.0131916245,
-0.0115736844,
0.0416636094,
0.0710868537,
-0.0206097085,
-0.0628431812,
0.0455991514,
0.0029430976,
-0.0564217009,
-0.0137933148,
-0.0153315039,
0.0135280108,
-0.0304059107,
0.0360216983,
0.0746934265,
0.0247926805,
0.02210683,
0.0598633029,
-0.0085699661,
-0.0188777354,
-0.0360028222,
-0.0143436082,
0.0416494273,
-0.0092653045,
-0.0488687456,
0.0369023196,
0.0246718433,
0.0180846285,
-0.0075233341,
-0.0146452067,
0.0137817627,
-0.0489002354,
0.0128327012,
-0.0146692507,
-0.023010077,
-0.0167498719,
0.0599949807,
0.0029030005,
-0.0490344428,
0.0087678162,
-0.0223586913,
0.0148359854,
-0.0273855422,
0.0187667925,
-0.0625183731,
0.0673115477,
-0.0053569623,
-0.0051501673,
0.006402385,
-0.0047337194,
-0.0440061018,
-0.0152910789,
0.02981757,
0.0132896472,
0.0197126251,
-0.0467918813,
0.0206730068,
-0.0299805496,
0.0121586109,
0.0199844074,
-0.031113537,
0.0102429502,
0.0429726727,
0.0448553935,
-0.0712112337,
-0.0656977221,
0.0145408753,
0.0476351939,
0.0926497504,
-0.0385247916,
-0.0254778769,
-0.0434365533,
0.0234355237,
0.0721651986,
-0.0447104163,
-0.041743584,
-0.0599736758,
0.0096325679,
0.0388698243,
-0.0425798036,
0.0471565053,
-0.0248438139,
-0.0452560596,
0.019403642,
-0.0666263923,
-0.054582648,
0.0072992709,
0.0171332378,
-0.0416258015,
-0.0301796626,
0.1398572028,
0.0198924132,
-0.0899786502,
-0.0321326144,
-0.0391982757,
0.0147918398,
0.0212301146,
0.0441034622,
-0.0378806964,
0.0340574943,
0.0037171568,
0.0231246259,
-0.0235833563,
-0.0414098427,
-0.005593271,
-0.038463112,
0.0728918612,
0.0042390861,
-0.015527186,
0.0230423231,
-0.0418487415,
0.0061867503,
0.0128226895,
-0.0694902465,
0.0033183433,
-0.0105778193,
0.0013785252,
0.0202252995,
-0.056295421,
-0.0316875987,
-0.0449469015,
-0.042097494,
0.0423658416,
0.0035430703,
0.0567712821,
-0.0200576968,
-0.001557785,
-0.0098234601,
0.0059029385,
-0.0008142798,
-0.0211394373,
0.022307191,
-0.0015594742,
0.0553557351,
-0.0343364887,
0.0392802693,
-0.0410053283,
-0.0419425927,
0.0542541258,
0.0679188445,
-0.0402874164,
-0.0072818748,
-0.0677336156,
0.0204999577,
0.0255954657,
0.0485092103,
0.0132568162,
-0.0589692853,
-0.0370153934,
-0.0239349529,
0.0449747145,
-0.0254746079,
-0.0141107887,
-0.0654890686,
-0.0425319858,
0.0166775882,
-0.0713206381,
-0.0448758937,
0.0061993632,
0.0383771695,
0.0629056916,
0.0607679561,
-0.0109934779,
-0.0628851727,
-0.067335546,
-0.0053441245,
0.01854375,
0.0273897871,
-0.036097575,
-0.0412115529,
0.0052323346,
-0.0077118515,
-0.0063648187,
-0.0210035481,
-0.0185013823,
-0.0376636088,
0.0117077501,
-0.0124810822,
0.0211294461,
-0.0024362863,
0.0211225376,
-0.0677050725,
-0.0255013164,
-0.0258648749,
0.0142308455,
0.0390350893,
-0.0080369301,
0.0013704204,
-0.04079362,
-0.0041348431,
-0.022905115,
0.0197609365,
0.0134549262,
0.0016263553,
-0.0334566794,
-0.0282955859,
-0.0149942078,
-0.0229282808,
0.0099618575,
-0.0482985862,
0.0060512871,
-0.0670471936,
-0.0199137181,
-0.029169485,
-0.0328355879,
-0.0219628327,
0.0127550904,
0.0252495296,
0.0027757988,
-0.0250415392,
0.0667157099,
-0.0348934866,
0.003932701,
-0.053984914,
0.0288179759,
-0.0306528155,
0.063683264,
0.0096163508,
-0.0065146573,
-0.0248812847,
0.0075164679,
-0.0657005087,
0.0137416217,
0.0340982899,
0.0527376942,
0.0422789901,
0.0259076748,
0.018827701,
-0.0105018513,
-0.0887755379,
0.0011826408,
-0.0045800246,
0.0090454333,
0.040824011,
0.0025540171,
0.0610673651,
-0.0473351255,
-0.00582011,
-0.0403567031,
0.0805994049,
0.0371300131,
-0.0019489977,
-0.0197026879,
0.0030209625,
0.0058288211,
-0.0225275438,
0.0686484277,
0.0131316232,
0.027448656,
0.0014159057,
-0.0429920889,
-0.0193897393,
-0.0282781962,
0.0245858897,
0.006868199,
0.0312883705,
-0.0044547552,
-0.0663207173,
0.0263071619,
0.0695416331,
-0.0095982971,
-0.0147902239,
-0.0679970682,
-0.0003608725,
0.0449923351,
-0.0350155272,
0.0078261709,
-0.0805708021,
0.051165387,
-0.0581925809,
-0.0533218645,
-0.0480118766,
-5.165739679e-33,
0.007727033,
-0.0918129086,
0.0294786654,
0.0539277643,
-0.0472774804,
0.018513767,
-0.039686732,
-0.0210182164,
0.0359249823,
0.0251990631,
-0.0577933639,
0.0144382566,
-0.0215349738,
0.0099868672,
0.0631931648,
0.0580406524,
0.070769459,
-0.019690441,
-0.0676416233,
0.0322945528,
0.0348615833,
0.0030459857,
0.0017968687,
-0.0565320738,
0.0634123906,
-0.0648563355,
-0.0183574744,
-0.024380343,
-0.0014066828,
0.0358797796,
-0.0351807587,
-0.0245479923,
0.0256948173,
-0.0078287954,
-0.010877992,
0.0255533457,
-0.0091856904,
-0.0019110279,
0.0171079878,
0.0022406667,
-0.0010462065,
-0.0828086361,
0.0185074247,
-0.0103317918,
-0.0579622835,
-0.0117040668,
0.0703579858,
0.0029099537,
-0.0357362069,
-0.0532002263,
-0.0930524096,
0.0284629073,
-0.0061627221,
-0.0142959189,
-0.0104150232,
0.0063220505,
0.0081474874,
0.0220964514,
-0.06171358,
0.0311694536,
-0.002679927,
0.0478911847,
-0.0208985675,
0.0215240456,
-0.0079206508,
0.0652914122,
-0.0243177414,
0.0496313758,
-0.0014810485,
0.0071837171,
-0.0015961236,
0.0203291941,
0.0521421023,
0.0441908091,
0.0244791452,
-0.0069922823,
-0.017787816,
0.0266982652,
-0.0038793399,
-0.001216662,
0.0433911979,
-0.0252280515,
0.0185089484,
-0.0440226272,
-0.0176491793,
-0.0354389623,
0.0059052464,
0.0202211607,
0.0097160097,
0.0096544065,
-0.0047311438,
-0.0344396271,
0.0050962991,
0.0043268376,
-0.0281070974,
0.0475062281,
-0.0638310686,
0.1084455624,
-0.0151323201,
-0.0152171254,
-0.0819040462,
-0.0195801891,
-0.0025447879,
0.0369760692,
0.0084448392,
0.018374119,
0.0461489633,
0.0359362252,
-0.0198851712,
-0.0171018168,
0.0053916327,
0.0319043249,
0.0006278837,
-0.0168801751,
0.0061662081,
-0.0172165241,
0.040431723,
0.003814935,
0.0377717726,
0.0010444104,
0.0048075216,
0.0097669018,
0.02138827,
0.0141373705,
0.0044799885,
0.0025135011,
0.0000823125,
0.0232167616,
0.0240944903,
-0.0064339237,
0.008709304,
-0.0197905842,
2.524e-7,
0.0718408152,
0.0513561964,
-0.0141327912,
0.0191718563,
0.0410410389,
0.0143973418,
-0.0328241065,
0.0127012236,
-0.0035928646,
0.0367168486,
0.0298281889,
-0.0296154246,
0.0408650711,
0.0049694171,
-0.0902267471,
-0.0126442136,
-0.0725929886,
-0.0177292675,
-0.0778076872,
-0.0071158889,
0.0136125414,
-0.0296989642,
-0.0177585874,
-0.021649396,
-0.0413026139,
-0.0344474241,
0.0776679739,
-0.0167250633,
0.0157044604,
0.0231710598,
0.0236646924,
-0.030994704,
0.0094111478,
-0.0036523745,
-0.0216914658,
0.0001711248,
-0.0127287321,
0.0786778331,
-0.0034526878,
0.0443157442,
0.0395768397,
0.0223807544,
0.0043541905,
-0.0299604107,
0.0116265286,
0.002914028,
-0.0277564228,
-0.0721621141,
-0.0062631546,
0.0007954674,
0.0230183117,
-0.0207576808,
0.0022854479,
0.0161107276,
-0.0039543319,
0.0012991275,
0.0250917431,
-0.0264537651,
-0.0077067027,
-0.0005679953,
-0.0231418535,
-0.0212209262,
-0.0311421733,
-0.0317435637,
-0.0119547611,
-0.0921769515,
0.0078105573,
2.446183081e-34,
0.066730231,
-0.0324561521,
-0.0208762363,
0.0174837038,
0.0096672876,
0.0004267967,
0.0194090623,
0.0482970551,
0.0120373098,
-0.0499372557,
-0.0194697008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00116v1 | Enhancing Large Language Models with Climate Resources | 2023-03-31T20:24:14 | 2023-03-31T20:24:14 | Mathias Kraus, Julia Anna Bingler, Markus Leippold, Tobias Schimanski, Chiara Colesanti Senni, Dominik Stammbach, Saeid Ashraf Vaghefi, Nicolas Webersinke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly transformed the landscape of
artificial intelligence by demonstrating their ability in generating human-like
text across diverse topics. However, despite their impressive capabilities,
LLMs lack recent information and often employ imprecise language, which can be
detrimental in domains where accuracy is crucial, such as climate change. In
this study, we make use of recent ideas to harness the potential of LLMs by
viewing them as agents that access multiple sources, including databases
containing recent and precise information about organizations, institutions,
and companies. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method through a
prototype agent that retrieves emission data from ClimateWatch
(https://www.climatewatchdata.org/) and leverages general Google search. By
integrating these resources with LLMs, our approach overcomes the limitations
associated with imprecise language and delivers more reliable and accurate
information in the critical domain of climate change. This work paves the way
for future advancements in LLMs and their application in domains where
precision is of paramount importance. | [
0.0412629955,
0.1213696152,
-0.0146184023,
0.0447726473,
-0.0178762786,
-0.0116839046,
-0.0122140385,
0.0192256905,
0.0396320857,
-0.0470299348,
0.0101441592,
-0.0065956847,
-0.0233270451,
0.0518092811,
-0.0078304317,
-0.0671302602,
0.0316373222,
-0.0359613933,
0.027125543,
-0.0225160122,
0.0123798028,
-0.0070011173,
0.0294483062,
0.0002797519,
0.0022016766,
-0.0005530861,
-0.019466592,
0.0075798579,
0.0166090168,
-0.0165727604,
-0.0103890151,
0.0268975534,
0.0334546231,
0.0561647974,
0.0000019275,
-0.0359916836,
-0.0363716893,
-0.015539553,
0.0002371938,
0.0075194477,
0.1023351774,
-0.032066375,
-0.0026572777,
-0.0020701718,
-0.090795882,
0.0224121716,
0.0788796023,
-0.0129886186,
0.0622998178,
0.0693490654,
0.0028925082,
0.001644776,
0.0118045397,
0.0090806819,
-0.0176825095,
-0.0097471718,
0.0507137813,
-0.0048681502,
0.0460830778,
0.0414927155,
0.0076547982,
0.0805289969,
0.0061010453,
-0.018364219,
-0.001334306,
0.0494980514,
-0.0401586555,
-0.0036709697,
-0.0249503851,
0.0460025407,
0.0403823443,
-0.0074788476,
0.0037376669,
-0.0024083629,
-0.0029207619,
0.0059840493,
-0.0347627886,
0.0306965299,
0.0175770652,
0.0129151028,
0.0205331556,
-0.0072854017,
0.0156662501,
0.0822723955,
-0.0522810295,
0.1241169572,
-0.0153370993,
-0.0442897268,
-0.0249455664,
-0.0181582849,
0.0313659869,
-0.0437836386,
0.0036202711,
0.0291932337,
-0.0483022556,
0.028383635,
-0.0410372987,
0.0009484832,
0.0028486021,
-0.0526278615,
0.0306948125,
0.0076139621,
0.0192954689,
0.0520463921,
0.0657729879,
0.0331137441,
-0.0096986135,
-0.0043826229,
-0.0108782733,
-0.0556407906,
-0.0402689129,
-0.0447469316,
-0.0252468977,
-0.0119765103,
-0.0353950672,
-0.0013453421,
-0.0023937926,
0.0173067264,
-0.0313665904,
0.0088564735,
-0.0134677505,
0.002741328,
-0.0058892276,
-0.0245493222,
-0.0470145047,
-0.0011531388,
-0.0376469567,
0.0338706337,
0.0301954187,
-0.0591571145,
0.0116491187,
0.0138209788,
0.0212310702,
-0.000463012,
-0.0006711444,
0.091792047,
0.0481319651,
-0.0094410386,
-0.01500112,
-0.0248440839,
0.0108220298,
-0.0377994925,
-0.0356955864,
-0.0494796298,
0.0193812232,
-0.0108407745,
-0.0133917592,
-0.0667911321,
-0.0046016998,
-0.0214859396,
-0.0767695531,
0.0688573793,
-0.0817309618,
-0.0046479315,
0.0287171174,
-0.0109719485,
-0.000448441,
0.0875445828,
0.0522365421,
0.0466944054,
0.0454375036,
0.0199246481,
0.0143824387,
0.0309599116,
0.0034014327,
0.0357358307,
-0.0208905637,
0.0053933882,
-0.0482666381,
0.0229080971,
0.0068567465,
0.0397127047,
0.0021275938,
0.027152421,
0.0976060629,
0.0254738536,
-0.0225800052,
0.0328051858,
0.0369105078,
0.0440693088,
-0.0116242589,
-0.0354561247,
-0.0333664119,
0.0267957449,
-0.0291642677,
0.0034195599,
0.0130700981,
0.0364032574,
0.0006452205,
-0.0541869253,
-0.0271566603,
0.0061823828,
-0.0134915784,
-0.0145613272,
0.0335767828,
-0.0297629032,
-0.0059582191,
0.0068319635,
0.0284053218,
-0.026835721,
0.0357851796,
-0.0126597201,
-0.015778834,
0.1092177927,
0.0124041736,
-0.0199605506,
-0.0032122736,
-0.0032624083,
0.0031671075,
0.0523834974,
0.048312895,
0.0118024983,
-0.0537286624,
-0.037278071,
-0.0201175511,
0.0031174587,
0.017330993,
-0.004106869,
0.0115038622,
0.0204103235,
0.0086958725,
-0.0075595719,
-0.0032816157,
0.0250863004,
-0.0454094857,
-0.0133342184,
-0.0352269262,
0.0115905628,
0.0274380781,
0.0065166722,
-0.0082847159,
0.0123944655,
0.030770449,
-0.0193979535,
-0.104941912,
0.0490352698,
0.0207069367,
0.0564522222,
0.0342414863,
-0.0002349752,
-0.0012966297,
0.0351477563,
-0.0283722524,
-0.0264022741,
0.0292692184,
-0.0181659721,
0.0665872097,
-0.0234770887,
-0.0235553645,
-0.0256653503,
0.0331156664,
-0.0268363878,
0.0733397081,
-0.0088020228,
-0.0041836845,
0.0314603411,
-0.0165231321,
-0.0330197178,
-0.0458889231,
0.0144187324,
-0.012475525,
0.0123967929,
0.0250228141,
0.0433454737,
-0.0253991671,
-0.0365202278,
-0.0175994169,
-0.0511846431,
0.0011905677,
-0.0106464708,
0.0168773774,
0.0231836382,
-0.0032542604,
-0.0250768997,
0.0251594521,
0.0176235791,
-0.0122901257,
-0.0122837154,
0.0152996723,
0.0531824082,
0.0144111915,
-0.0155134201,
-0.0502347313,
-0.0077067511,
-0.034349598,
0.0572645441,
0.0393350311,
-0.0569415204,
-0.0592674017,
0.0494070724,
-0.0419673957,
0.0075274287,
0.0003719274,
-0.0318561383,
-0.0041670818,
-0.0554757267,
0.0021285599,
0.0291033089,
0.0290476624,
0.0452473909,
0.0291205458,
-0.0336704329,
-0.0674850568,
0.0124914097,
-0.013356939,
0.0189561043,
-0.0104202284,
-0.0161323901,
0.011606236,
0.0025984729,
-0.0174037851,
0.0101808039,
0.0241300464,
0.1031041369,
-0.0371454954,
-0.0370969512,
-0.0272523705,
0.0037688385,
-0.0083513968,
0.057437472,
-0.0096632019,
-0.0713321641,
0.060278248,
-0.0144684874,
0.0249734391,
-0.0302581098,
-0.03886576,
-0.0183617249,
0.0573366657,
-0.0100019136,
0.0190554988,
-0.0151251731,
0.0115075363,
-0.0127011212,
-0.0331572294,
0.0162773766,
-0.0028880748,
0.030133551,
-0.0603052825,
0.0222003441,
0.0106718224,
-0.0374474823,
-0.0279360749,
-0.0416003577,
-0.0600421578,
0.0345843509,
0.0322999805,
-0.0734233037,
-0.1071947664,
0.0010367226,
0.0385629646,
0.0213869084,
-0.0070276102,
-0.0197377764,
-0.014985309,
-0.01242813,
0.0532047376,
0.0309608746,
0.0362849832,
0.0079738609,
0.0230414812,
0.0235427693,
0.0236644819,
-0.010779907,
-0.0546264425,
-0.0178438332,
-0.0061714393,
-0.0222001206,
0.0128788212,
-0.0103299217,
-0.0070940321,
-0.0824502781,
-0.0052548363,
0.1063020453,
0.0142571609,
-0.0223719534,
0.0068986285,
-0.019538464,
-0.0003118699,
0.0168705732,
0.0340154469,
-0.0710216165,
-0.0001887456,
0.014546901,
-0.0038503022,
-0.0191783886,
-0.0552525707,
-0.0245742593,
-0.0789954066,
0.0575651526,
0.0193542615,
0.0020731178,
-0.0066797128,
-0.0967065543,
-0.0071979677,
-0.0213183481,
-0.0447435826,
-0.0101636648,
-0.0120010162,
-0.0070916647,
0.0097524701,
-0.0223072805,
-0.0663834661,
0.0004443427,
-0.0364445895,
0.0413559191,
0.0958360508,
0.050005272,
-0.0434163399,
0.0053451485,
0.0028016435,
0.0228899885,
0.0081011569,
-0.014674007,
-0.0058120838,
0.0256406497,
-0.015590406,
0.0008780332,
0.0282119587,
-0.0408250205,
0.0109537784,
0.0205078591,
0.1050896123,
-0.0186961219,
0.0016016681,
-0.0133130047,
-0.0082643405,
0.0371651128,
0.0575408041,
0.0005585235,
-0.0192506723,
-0.052646365,
-0.071497269,
-0.0255800989,
-0.0337579735,
-0.0286290944,
0.0295522846,
-0.0466959514,
-0.0310656354,
-0.04264047,
-0.0515232421,
0.0402399525,
0.0012739594,
0.0043705031,
0.0058129258,
0.0965417102,
-0.0138040381,
-0.0322091728,
0.0140967248,
-0.0547522195,
0.0334761068,
-0.0233094227,
-0.0507459864,
0.0388754383,
0.0169539414,
-0.0171263237,
0.0471808687,
-0.0622492619,
-0.076403968,
0.0220929217,
0.0254153945,
0.0322697535,
0.0079918504,
-0.0024796866,
-0.0261115432,
0.0464169532,
0.0919768214,
-0.041602172,
0.000247022,
-0.0078997919,
-0.0026860912,
0.0063233683,
0.0326010808,
-0.0433663353,
0.0299663674,
-0.0262150187,
0.0444839485,
-0.0554738939,
-0.0119925374,
0.0281666014,
0.0203453135,
0.0146752363,
0.0119437184,
-0.0219099727,
-0.0155946165,
-0.0125286654,
-0.0077555724,
-0.0271730851,
-0.0215309393,
0.0128035992,
-0.0194917936,
0.0173785053,
-0.0224150978,
0.0519371219,
-0.0210179798,
0.0076340581,
-0.0489690155,
0.0379182845,
-0.0065961191,
0.0544119738,
0.0246097986,
-0.0092276111,
0.0036328922,
0.0035527973,
-0.0125367101,
0.0052033602,
-0.0138116889,
-0.0333269015,
0.019666383,
-0.0079738488,
-0.0379089341,
0.0244457554,
-0.0906180665,
-0.050825201,
-0.0131143145,
0.0274548866,
0.0449422337,
0.052978199,
0.000288804,
-0.0588633753,
-0.0229580943,
-0.0115321344,
0.0084777586,
0.0436418205,
-0.0494157337,
0.0455876179,
0.0118225859,
-0.0584146827,
0.0055212597,
0.0390137061,
-0.0004232784,
0.0683211684,
0.0052028382,
-0.0315232202,
-0.0323501341,
-0.0478709489,
-0.040173281,
-0.0441798009,
-0.0095490776,
-0.0011777458,
-0.0492392667,
-0.0362889618,
0.0453846902,
0.0115361735,
-0.0215110499,
-0.0133743808,
0.0039042283,
0.0498227105,
-0.0036374808,
-0.0240344144,
-0.0253567491,
0.0329390205,
-0.0693290457,
-0.0383606218,
-0.0202964265,
-6.200090587e-33,
-0.0253552981,
-0.0411671102,
0.0452141277,
0.0077847112,
-0.024605047,
0.0388980843,
-0.0203337967,
-0.0069261384,
-0.0320581459,
0.0222883001,
-0.016212238,
0.0020801479,
0.0266398247,
-0.0118058687,
0.0466951281,
0.0069311033,
0.041855365,
-0.0037107787,
0.007252418,
-0.0146769769,
0.0677178502,
0.0276520159,
0.0375771746,
-0.0835576355,
0.0227789376,
-0.0149003435,
-0.0543715283,
0.0125389537,
0.0074850465,
0.0579238385,
-0.003521662,
0.0612661429,
0.0107283592,
-0.0313353054,
-0.055096902,
0.0186420791,
-0.0599532388,
-0.0105561037,
-0.0039717434,
-0.0116197346,
0.010825214,
-0.0282801222,
0.0123235472,
0.006034648,
-0.0008674718,
0.0390181839,
0.0486775301,
-0.0476233661,
-0.0099316686,
-0.0354527906,
-0.0602934882,
0.0386120342,
0.0013261373,
0.057648886,
-0.0138657214,
0.0065143891,
-0.0050210087,
0.074002102,
-0.0583309829,
0.0481356494,
0.0616736673,
0.0342218876,
0.0570412725,
0.0208456069,
0.01126072,
0.0716653615,
-0.0122603057,
0.0195713397,
-0.0476500541,
-0.0352521949,
0.0430199876,
0.0215518773,
-0.0115490388,
0.0927160084,
0.0107359057,
-0.0424767509,
-0.0387414172,
0.0300017241,
0.0331475176,
0.0244133957,
0.0216175877,
0.0048360685,
0.0086219907,
0.0092523983,
-0.0320255272,
0.0335355103,
-0.0473395698,
-0.0124415159,
0.010205905,
0.0076058954,
-0.0015011018,
0.0160217173,
0.0063087018,
-0.0718031675,
-0.0318855867,
0.0458047949,
-0.0234270077,
0.0163863953,
0.008910018,
0.0184444301,
-0.0582188368,
-0.0532712303,
-0.0355732031,
0.0459975675,
-0.0013269719,
0.0169002302,
0.0085733272,
0.0360417105,
-0.03260573,
-0.0058913706,
-0.0301276874,
-0.0024317983,
0.0116727706,
-0.0790060386,
-0.0134328222,
0.0126547143,
0.0182666089,
0.0290682036,
0.0213720351,
0.0182542205,
0.0236703102,
0.0136508998,
-0.020097781,
0.0182632376,
-0.0215346813,
-0.0192103032,
-0.0497286692,
-0.0126964403,
-0.0032857172,
-0.0644511431,
-0.0007180932,
0.0041293781,
2.633e-7,
0.0674519241,
0.0706152618,
-0.007533181,
0.0442706719,
-0.0127262734,
0.0274701715,
-0.0086046988,
-0.0019287807,
-0.0509744473,
0.018512914,
-0.0072523598,
-0.006818424,
0.0406919196,
0.0364973955,
-0.0769936889,
-0.0313772857,
-0.0555455796,
-0.0522480831,
-0.1036409363,
-0.0289054364,
0.0385609455,
0.0853844881,
0.0558832735,
0.0115038948,
-0.0034855404,
-0.0578756705,
0.072794944,
-0.0595848858,
-0.0263284426,
0.0204003267,
-0.0023275374,
-0.0130833806,
-0.0076756268,
0.0027238354,
-0.0154684642,
0.0036000772,
-0.0300129093,
0.0481176861,
0.0212091561,
-0.0121001545,
0.0131342933,
-0.0505711585,
-0.0049217264,
-0.0401590951,
0.0152533036,
-0.0139021333,
-0.0109265419,
-0.0264747255,
-0.0329601057,
0.0220665075,
-0.0126915714,
-0.0579876341,
-0.0147444969,
0.0061192526,
-0.0209516939,
-0.0218632724,
-0.0014824906,
-0.0408442318,
0.0086209131,
-0.0300803017,
-0.0362497605,
-0.0441529565,
-0.0390506573,
-0.0029437689,
0.0588996746,
0.0005251484,
0.0539056808,
2.092017653e-34,
0.0469347499,
0.0121042151,
-0.0477727242,
0.0175963957,
0.0468971096,
0.029460283,
0.0219318755,
0.0372964889,
-0.0004317847,
-0.0830066428,
-0.0124021564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00115v1 | Extracting Thyroid Nodules Characteristics from Ultrasound Reports Using Transformer-based Natural Language Processing Methods | 2023-03-31T20:23:58 | 2023-03-31T20:23:58 | Aman Pathak, Zehao Yu, Daniel Paredes, Elio Paul Monsour, Andrea Ortiz Rocha, Juan P. Brito, Naykky Singh Ospina, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The ultrasound characteristics of thyroid nodules guide the evaluation of
thyroid cancer in patients with thyroid nodules. However, the characteristics
of thyroid nodules are often documented in clinical narratives such as
ultrasound reports. Previous studies have examined natural language processing
(NLP) methods in extracting a limited number of characteristics (<9) using
rule-based NLP systems. In this study, a multidisciplinary team of NLP experts
and thyroid specialists, identified thyroid nodule characteristics that are
important for clinical care, composed annotation guidelines, developed a
corpus, and compared 5 state-of-the-art transformer-based NLP methods,
including BERT, RoBERTa, LongFormer, DeBERTa, and GatorTron, for extraction of
thyroid nodule characteristics from ultrasound reports. Our GatorTron model, a
transformer-based large language model trained using over 90 billion words of
text, achieved the best strict and lenient F1-score of 0.8851 and 0.9495 for
the extraction of a total number of 16 thyroid nodule characteristics, and
0.9321 for linking characteristics to nodules, outperforming other clinical
transformer models. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to
systematically categorize and apply transformer-based NLP models to extract a
large number of clinical relevant thyroid nodule characteristics from
ultrasound reports. This study lays ground for assessing the documentation
quality of thyroid ultrasound reports and examining outcomes of patients with
thyroid nodules using electronic health records. | [
0.0626190454,
0.0651536956,
0.0199886095,
-0.0112339323,
-0.0121735837,
0.0098434137,
-0.0226238109,
0.0322298557,
0.0218327306,
-0.0465169251,
0.0355501994,
-0.0111698797,
-0.009513638,
0.0107264426,
-0.0212973226,
-0.0605064929,
-0.021359425,
0.0234347917,
0.0171447136,
0.0542492196,
0.0271886494,
0.0159539357,
0.0047015548,
0.045181267,
-0.0399786346,
0.0317348056,
0.0530377515,
-0.0218899101,
0.0223791767,
-0.0881403014,
-0.0364912935,
0.0146205667,
-0.0635023788,
-0.003024807,
0.0000015169,
-0.0665217936,
-0.0225708149,
0.0441607721,
0.0088220024,
-0.0225623325,
0.0460983627,
-0.0735805705,
-0.0210624449,
0.0152736437,
-0.0001813632,
-0.0422594734,
0.0567737147,
0.0597897023,
0.0711530894,
0.0758898184,
-0.0467933789,
-0.0561760366,
0.0393069424,
0.0392050222,
0.0195674617,
-0.0181547385,
0.035225492,
-0.0079388665,
-0.0015476081,
-0.0033275189,
0.0458933376,
0.0187853966,
-0.0395688266,
0.0112610944,
-0.0169142131,
0.0527540073,
-0.0561969131,
-0.0258602817,
0.0175760984,
0.0436648875,
0.0103648966,
0.005205242,
0.0257363077,
0.0156855416,
-0.0176935885,
0.0018175145,
-0.011868584,
-0.0004243962,
-0.0630672574,
0.0214146078,
0.0293307304,
0.0055874409,
-0.0160446875,
-0.0077581662,
-0.0223004296,
-0.0222896598,
0.00978,
-0.0159982126,
-0.0109031703,
0.0295713749,
0.0091028158,
-0.0368501022,
0.083327502,
0.0150618292,
0.0168268457,
0.0204455797,
-0.0080896914,
-0.0597437061,
0.0761129484,
-0.034868516,
-0.0012783589,
-0.0068815732,
-0.0380886681,
0.0421053246,
-0.0277531948,
-0.01157533,
-0.0003822968,
-0.0201382805,
-0.0251236185,
0.0003966714,
-0.0732360482,
-0.0208626669,
-0.0370275266,
0.0186472218,
-0.00052506,
0.0003639719,
-0.0478036292,
-0.0287301429,
0.008786153,
0.0028839111,
0.0415332839,
0.019145079,
-0.010904355,
0.0236867927,
-0.0044027651,
0.0502741374,
0.0080631282,
-0.0109166997,
-0.0379275307,
-0.0149338748,
0.0532751866,
0.0054724896,
0.0535821393,
0.0059093023,
0.0336363465,
0.0318052024,
0.0312387999,
-0.0277799182,
0.0061841984,
-0.0134116141,
-0.0218179431,
-0.0093356548,
-0.0270675793,
-0.0549928844,
0.0162105896,
0.0188971441,
0.0134393908,
-0.0025306731,
0.0284241457,
0.0359309725,
-0.0234380681,
0.0780028179,
-0.0511013754,
-0.0169261992,
0.0119270897,
-0.0119488509,
0.0368062146,
-0.0114080114,
0.0464954823,
-0.0484861061,
0.0015429684,
0.0022610901,
0.0177032035,
0.0014844477,
-0.0465833582,
-0.079801634,
0.0356461965,
0.0115641588,
-0.055087328,
0.0528781004,
-0.0161638856,
0.0908876806,
0.0064192759,
-0.0081494162,
0.0111253597,
0.104182303,
0.0339645892,
0.0047758948,
0.0121355979,
-0.0043362235,
-0.0122996522,
-0.0235145297,
-0.0036274404,
-0.0458599217,
-0.0051482012,
0.0502766967,
-0.0646148697,
0.0126285618,
0.0098781716,
-0.0594576299,
-0.0849438757,
-0.0059672296,
0.0059910193,
-0.0443899706,
0.0339028686,
-0.0075098211,
-0.0466273092,
0.0267360341,
0.0398289226,
-0.0181097835,
-0.0006885997,
-0.0229145605,
-0.0245171264,
0.050301604,
0.0277852472,
-0.0707367808,
-0.029655233,
-0.0282940175,
-0.0229304619,
0.0415506996,
-0.0191001743,
-0.0201442782,
-0.008866339,
-0.0207058061,
0.0191369206,
0.0752349049,
0.0328307562,
-0.037446782,
-0.0175040625,
0.0312302094,
-0.0196755361,
-0.023506429,
-0.0455063693,
0.0611768365,
0.0068930457,
-0.0376035199,
-0.0269545075,
-0.0098208068,
-0.014810577,
0.0108457133,
-0.0152439643,
0.0227807239,
0.0115046697,
-0.0182775296,
-0.0410497673,
0.0243000519,
0.0128593529,
-0.0091124754,
0.0321592093,
-0.0648362339,
-0.0244035479,
-0.0120515265,
-0.0030510558,
0.0001157526,
-0.0346817039,
-0.0506409667,
0.010506344,
0.0013737284,
0.0127371335,
0.0548251979,
0.0031759134,
-0.052753903,
0.0131098898,
-0.0048254351,
0.0026044231,
0.0236140098,
-0.095372878,
0.0150700072,
-0.0009832352,
-0.0182382595,
0.0622336566,
0.021430498,
0.018455198,
0.0139036253,
0.016028069,
-0.0294552557,
-0.0479318947,
-0.0766735896,
0.0014627925,
0.0204635374,
0.0307095535,
0.0316107571,
0.034392558,
0.0052507124,
-0.0294569507,
-0.0302790571,
-0.0442360379,
0.0312252715,
0.0086781029,
0.0665163621,
0.040778771,
-0.0046187462,
-0.0408494063,
0.0013067161,
-0.0564408451,
0.004545175,
0.0561228804,
-0.0324359909,
-0.0246283971,
0.0120897191,
0.0007225754,
0.0302944835,
0.0425573401,
-0.0335250273,
0.0050542201,
-0.010922052,
-0.0246406011,
0.0247054677,
-0.0118516469,
0.0380194783,
0.0229008999,
-0.0235211123,
0.0041550593,
-0.0144816041,
-0.0485326312,
0.0046835397,
-0.0078201881,
-0.0537988953,
0.0455054604,
0.0670735836,
0.0226956159,
-0.0074034911,
0.0017092339,
-0.0142889265,
-0.041457817,
0.0520036817,
-0.0218660664,
-0.008420133,
-0.024313271,
0.0249577593,
0.0308614727,
0.0065416829,
0.1300154775,
-0.0199126862,
0.0143175749,
-0.1382031441,
-0.0048860079,
-0.0439964384,
0.0266259443,
0.0073083811,
0.0158759095,
0.0876122713,
-0.0658369064,
0.0381874591,
0.0029335087,
0.0412419885,
-0.0502689369,
0.0394941755,
-0.0032902346,
0.0312727466,
0.0057599242,
-0.0163973682,
-0.011782974,
-0.0269604027,
0.0086411517,
0.0114791039,
0.0419430807,
0.0085904356,
-0.0553510822,
0.0587471649,
-0.0186413694,
0.0639469102,
0.0431258455,
-0.0359762646,
-0.0133284302,
0.0634114817,
0.019453017,
0.0091743432,
-0.0403272994,
0.0461471416,
0.0043521863,
0.0504883491,
0.0259383451,
0.0269540381,
-0.0149091939,
-0.0044934386,
0.0045745242,
-0.0697750822,
-0.0118764061,
-0.0100766243,
0.01595819,
-0.0529196933,
-0.0235612709,
0.1097647697,
0.0383733623,
0.0308690276,
-0.000212258,
0.0336067714,
-0.0546475127,
-0.0267504063,
0.0418750718,
-0.0231764633,
-0.0194220804,
-0.0068504126,
-0.0011657714,
-0.01339876,
-0.0466122217,
0.033917211,
-0.0147540579,
0.0056875767,
-0.0109279118,
-0.0382537059,
-0.0358721539,
-0.0605795793,
-0.0306209885,
-0.0379463322,
-0.0318317749,
-0.0285107363,
-0.0339586101,
-0.0026935288,
0.0049940548,
-0.1296408027,
-0.0546937063,
0.0088247033,
-0.0273042507,
-0.0279132575,
0.0556234047,
0.0666821226,
-0.0453369655,
-0.0054732352,
-0.0181553327,
-0.0216815472,
-0.0205672979,
-0.001499378,
0.06769602,
0.0097220596,
-0.0101718437,
-0.0461524241,
0.0062280525,
-0.0309926961,
-0.0085501987,
-0.0211529527,
0.0798615292,
0.0092559652,
-0.0241723843,
-0.024682451,
0.0187107902,
0.0192401279,
0.0266853198,
-0.0321160406,
0.0007905372,
-0.0475467741,
-0.0010871945,
0.048719041,
0.0179832596,
0.0030535958,
0.0478341021,
-0.0248510297,
-0.054672461,
-0.0836387277,
-0.0538225882,
0.0230842791,
-0.0024139592,
0.0569326989,
0.0473353192,
0.0568699911,
-0.0119809052,
-0.0330105908,
0.0731517076,
0.051515054,
-0.0052629095,
-0.0183981638,
0.0014353392,
0.0767968446,
0.0343270637,
-0.0169477854,
0.0697508678,
0.0253727585,
-0.0159907006,
-0.0190249309,
-0.013909135,
0.0322164707,
-0.0097461073,
-0.0217745937,
-0.0179777537,
-0.0038823071,
0.04923537,
-0.0283515342,
-0.0309094265,
-0.0011555534,
-0.0117099676,
0.0296334121,
-0.0260961112,
0.0035226073,
0.0009131586,
-0.0376765318,
0.0310009699,
-0.0620203353,
-0.0183267593,
0.042059727,
0.0440666117,
0.0527328365,
-0.0110607352,
0.0378495976,
-0.0603058189,
-0.0246829949,
-0.0177797433,
0.009547676,
-0.0401705205,
-0.0057194047,
0.0300887693,
0.0031176242,
-0.0461138524,
0.0068841917,
-0.0852412134,
-0.0222714934,
-0.0289036259,
0.0763054192,
0.0246421136,
-0.0274561457,
0.023870185,
-0.0524352677,
-0.0004424969,
-0.0469819456,
0.0133969132,
0.0059859776,
-0.0195107032,
0.0140448809,
0.0130099263,
0.0074794823,
-0.0100197466,
0.03251037,
-0.0158145707,
0.0357907973,
-0.0464465767,
-0.0656841621,
0.0225650091,
-0.026575258,
0.0396960713,
-0.0461429693,
-0.007363413,
-0.0074707218,
0.048847992,
-0.0134393396,
0.0336188264,
0.0677952021,
0.0201898105,
-0.0216793437,
-0.0639023781,
0.0525846891,
0.0233458653,
0.0129108364,
-0.017635813,
-0.0823627636,
-0.0553916469,
0.0127229616,
-0.0098581621,
0.0267402679,
-0.0475908332,
0.0002999685,
-0.0616166592,
-0.0128910812,
0.0397993848,
-0.0133063169,
-0.0112573868,
-0.0242767092,
0.0215409175,
0.0209505334,
0.0481165238,
-0.0067702024,
-0.0297784097,
0.0071270131,
0.0210935175,
-0.007296762,
0.0049497304,
-5.101660176e-33,
-0.0064799045,
-0.0331232063,
0.0272044893,
0.0238377638,
0.0196241885,
0.0512131378,
-0.0115613956,
-0.0048533748,
-0.0064845067,
0.0131004397,
-0.0170982424,
-0.0301079769,
0.025071675,
0.0441402346,
0.0012936958,
-0.0315323956,
0.0423386656,
0.0269604549,
-0.0198626835,
-0.0378806069,
-0.0172033496,
0.0568639301,
0.0915509388,
-0.0894985199,
0.0018881876,
0.0385165624,
0.0286397487,
-0.0210889336,
0.0556725971,
0.0414044447,
-0.0421502031,
0.0591105819,
0.0153956534,
-0.0334014781,
-0.0104682799,
-0.0094302064,
-0.0864636973,
-0.0382498167,
0.0087498976,
0.0139037911,
-0.0164526571,
0.0124446219,
0.0740997046,
-0.0438782163,
0.0013492765,
0.0206881408,
0.0574446395,
-0.0302071609,
-0.0154685359,
0.0068999245,
-0.0645391792,
0.062419679,
0.0190712027,
0.0101297721,
0.0048705949,
-0.0194990784,
-0.0401815251,
0.0168116689,
-0.0646018982,
-0.0351200774,
0.0138379531,
0.0263673719,
-0.0127787814,
-0.0552590862,
-0.0196204856,
0.0413954742,
0.0525104888,
-0.0349991322,
-0.0389965996,
0.0056991992,
-0.0368358083,
0.0324243568,
0.0391986631,
-0.0275748186,
0.0490363613,
-0.0242288169,
-0.0546309687,
0.0379181914,
-0.0350812152,
0.0806162283,
-0.0053603621,
-0.0298102666,
-0.0588931814,
0.0021879561,
-0.0132459598,
-0.0237260945,
0.0022504656,
-0.0083615789,
0.0112334825,
0.0247251038,
0.0194572452,
0.0665316209,
-0.0096465684,
0.0059882645,
-0.0201447047,
0.0141801452,
0.0464593396,
0.0268177353,
-0.0760796964,
-0.0382469334,
-0.0167195033,
-0.0394752808,
-0.0003030161,
-0.0229550637,
0.033218164,
-0.017816022,
0.0079194661,
-0.0160366651,
-0.0796487778,
-0.0030481417,
0.0137040131,
0.018589925,
-0.0105122877,
0.0250733737,
0.0250089131,
0.0117093632,
0.0137431752,
0.0566784889,
0.0243915729,
-0.0142068323,
-0.019364275,
-0.0213315878,
0.0356872231,
-0.0176049229,
-0.0214317571,
-0.0244656634,
0.0062935343,
0.0470017418,
0.0383698456,
-0.017619824,
-0.0006364085,
0.0050651738,
2.379e-7,
0.1019437239,
0.0764072016,
0.0300682187,
-0.013855922,
0.0153587321,
0.0076475339,
0.0079106167,
-0.0091019785,
-0.0023893935,
0.0043694736,
-0.0061311461,
-0.0303659346,
-0.019745566,
0.0540361814,
-0.0675043315,
-0.0666878447,
-0.0315608457,
-0.0444373004,
-0.0286398418,
0.009442172,
0.0926971883,
0.048037082,
-0.0175270718,
-0.0461599231,
-0.0167979244,
-0.0305535719,
0.0036139144,
-0.0373885259,
0.0168392304,
0.0405598879,
0.0431421585,
0.0001982465,
0.0382165834,
0.0296821855,
-0.0173390601,
0.0117334481,
0.0239249691,
0.068666026,
-0.0511353202,
0.0372510925,
0.0386222117,
-0.0324956551,
-0.003613764,
-0.0143632926,
0.0261510815,
-0.0423768982,
-0.0448601209,
-0.0105171353,
-0.0087736705,
-0.0224313755,
0.0241659824,
-0.0322073735,
-0.0512167104,
0.0489087701,
0.0012913209,
0.0164159164,
-0.0372962281,
-0.0454951413,
-0.0159038212,
0.022675056,
0.0072367401,
-0.0046837968,
0.0359931216,
-0.012219375,
0.0025697476,
-0.0319163874,
0.009856429,
2.344609349e-34,
0.0114246029,
0.0013404182,
0.0034638555,
0.0589550212,
0.0208940189,
0.017515339,
0.0384393595,
0.023559561,
-0.0173275471,
-0.0597538017,
0.0180856083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00114v1 | Dense Sparse Retrieval: Using Sparse Language Models for Inference Efficient Dense Retrieval | 2023-03-31T20:21:32 | 2023-03-31T20:21:32 | Daniel Campos, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Vector-based retrieval systems have become a common staple for academic and
industrial search applications because they provide a simple and scalable way
of extending the search to leverage contextual representations for documents
and queries. As these vector-based systems rely on contextual language models,
their usage commonly requires GPUs, which can be expensive and difficult to
manage. Given recent advances in introducing sparsity into language models for
improved inference efficiency, in this paper, we study how sparse language
models can be used for dense retrieval to improve inference efficiency. Using
the popular retrieval library Tevatron and the MSMARCO, NQ, and TriviaQA
datasets, we find that sparse language models can be used as direct
replacements with little to no drop in accuracy and up to 4.3x improved
inference speeds | [
0.0320994258,
0.0597222708,
0.0003834257,
0.0552444533,
-0.0231656488,
-0.0163334422,
0.0244772267,
0.0642881766,
-0.0255801976,
-0.0436982699,
-0.021669304,
-0.0467011817,
0.003096048,
0.0101930061,
-0.0014189298,
-0.03499908,
0.0453420356,
-0.0064183758,
0.009888446,
-0.0082346089,
0.008452801,
0.0179758202,
0.0326242298,
0.006743371,
0.0188229531,
0.0247663558,
-0.0059303669,
0.0422274061,
-0.0233307686,
-0.0098899659,
0.0369766392,
0.0653382465,
0.0598367564,
0.0564028881,
0.0000016426,
-0.0113625908,
-0.0315817147,
-0.0030140944,
-0.005834111,
0.019695079,
0.0355345719,
-0.0185866263,
0.0475814342,
-0.0142637044,
-0.0133422026,
-0.058311116,
0.0407933071,
0.0100460202,
-0.0146210724,
0.043286968,
-0.015391672,
-0.013669231,
0.0014809784,
-0.0279781576,
0.0294436365,
-0.0815916955,
0.027627198,
-0.0180251338,
0.0352768302,
0.0621045269,
0.0061511518,
0.0351020731,
-0.0357649438,
0.022850072,
-0.0012339915,
0.0264280792,
-0.0405671895,
0.0156609863,
0.0213090889,
0.0063142474,
-0.0088165374,
-0.0430773944,
0.0022989246,
0.0413711779,
-0.0484617688,
0.0290227793,
-0.0534503944,
0.0019796523,
-0.0166733526,
0.0027993005,
0.018405078,
0.0090923049,
0.0222451575,
0.0520215072,
-0.0210906789,
0.0324214883,
0.0463179313,
-0.0236080252,
-0.0181097928,
0.0013540869,
-0.0376636013,
-0.0105963992,
0.0113379229,
0.0117033171,
-0.0247162394,
0.003705194,
-0.0197675582,
-0.0424683504,
0.0485997386,
-0.0314445719,
0.0277026072,
0.0496762171,
-0.0160619617,
0.078201063,
-0.0271836426,
0.0164313596,
0.0040494869,
-0.035275694,
-0.0412019193,
-0.0319551304,
0.0077688154,
-0.0388283432,
-0.0342116095,
0.0500340872,
-0.0556557365,
-0.0318458676,
-0.0233905744,
0.0280908532,
0.0047578732,
-0.0558473878,
-0.0367541499,
0.0115028424,
-0.0645813048,
0.0024934262,
-0.0201780368,
0.0390866958,
-0.0104511874,
0.031600114,
-0.0143303629,
-0.0569710806,
-0.0166773405,
0.0121460157,
0.0462084189,
-0.0782722235,
0.0231419969,
-0.0087169958,
0.0045622932,
-0.0588376634,
-0.0059269229,
-0.0051373169,
0.0200905558,
-0.040722236,
-0.0543326475,
-0.0930244327,
-0.0040509608,
0.0240725633,
0.0022769899,
-0.050861042,
0.0062566786,
0.0472466648,
-0.0734528154,
0.0377003588,
-0.0327999704,
-0.0066550532,
0.0433257334,
0.0086549371,
0.0511316769,
0.0731707141,
-0.0448465385,
0.0430389978,
0.0442460515,
0.0097394334,
-0.0018840322,
0.0058111986,
0.0171144865,
0.0437379777,
-0.0395409726,
0.0203716792,
-0.008698388,
0.0146294907,
0.0344142132,
0.0833196715,
-0.0428459309,
-0.0226745047,
0.0082211494,
0.0891992897,
0.0323182531,
-0.0177682117,
0.0342081897,
0.0004699638,
-0.0268813558,
-0.0349933691,
-0.0006978855,
0.0133078853,
-0.0566801988,
-0.0009564115,
0.0796383768,
-0.0018345822,
-0.0208563488,
-0.0096682012,
-0.0337440744,
0.0316680223,
-0.009155334,
0.0115778558,
0.0660140589,
-0.0490603112,
-0.0121636475,
0.0154572306,
0.0491657518,
-0.0452311411,
-0.0278017819,
-0.0396780409,
0.0308991112,
0.0344772823,
0.0375345647,
-0.041878026,
-0.0225000065,
0.036682833,
-0.0065369266,
0.01547004,
0.0457986817,
-0.0202883314,
0.0019317358,
-0.051858712,
-0.0108068632,
0.0352561325,
0.0275656972,
0.0062473342,
0.0464133844,
0.033374764,
0.0414553471,
-0.0292490888,
-0.0182503723,
0.0133096445,
0.0020662583,
-0.0288154725,
0.0115121212,
-0.003644987,
-0.0124114444,
0.0105280653,
0.0067549292,
0.0002970617,
0.0671238527,
-0.0296259299,
-0.0070911818,
-0.040933311,
-0.0138259185,
-0.0278141368,
0.0192061719,
0.0281493273,
0.0545613058,
0.021856267,
-0.0035541188,
-0.0152592966,
-0.0042410977,
-0.0291416384,
0.0271147881,
-0.054096777,
-0.0111094471,
-0.0178470071,
-0.0037063493,
-0.0450810269,
0.0941510051,
-0.0159593672,
0.0881712064,
0.0436954722,
0.0128702382,
0.0331747383,
-0.0728548914,
-0.0550243631,
-0.0021435081,
-0.0060562738,
0.0241493341,
0.0620914996,
-0.0324742831,
0.0208643191,
0.0384331085,
-0.0996193737,
0.0251018927,
-0.0362257101,
-0.0208609607,
-0.02414722,
0.0524894036,
0.0022446101,
-0.0230986793,
-0.01150457,
-0.0063558584,
0.0218369998,
0.0523985885,
0.0042300699,
0.0392828621,
-0.0172469076,
-0.0669865534,
-0.0695437044,
0.004443875,
0.0528337136,
-0.0328737125,
-0.0388582535,
-0.0080725551,
0.0715204105,
-0.0239023846,
0.0337456875,
-0.0208443142,
0.0436113775,
0.0116206948,
-0.1001620889,
0.0008601554,
0.0442879759,
0.0058978349,
0.0454549268,
0.0239375439,
-0.0076568737,
-0.0806907043,
0.0132735465,
-0.0300890487,
-0.0225072522,
-0.0027272436,
-0.0196282901,
-0.0140779763,
0.0067910743,
-0.0192950014,
-0.02536094,
-0.0366255753,
-0.0048888461,
0.0148570724,
0.0064105336,
-0.0659445897,
0.034445703,
0.0321321897,
0.0685091242,
-0.0224075727,
-0.070566766,
0.0387042649,
-0.0231389608,
0.0141516356,
-0.0188253243,
-0.0262702014,
-0.0487290248,
0.0513407141,
-0.015082946,
0.0284617636,
-0.0700667799,
-0.0003583069,
-0.0012516319,
0.0294312946,
0.0024082179,
-0.0476384014,
0.0740280226,
-0.009287226,
0.0773997456,
-0.0032481414,
-0.0338213891,
-0.0176124927,
-0.0267594401,
-0.0182361603,
0.0304838177,
0.0243312083,
-0.01526218,
-0.0523504652,
0.0601163693,
-0.0162179116,
0.047226917,
-0.0213587545,
-0.0192544572,
0.0182181932,
0.0332649313,
0.0524792336,
0.0003529684,
-0.0248444807,
0.0099542048,
-0.0398040265,
0.049434334,
0.0320895799,
-0.0369573124,
-0.0390317813,
0.0023534538,
0.0694664568,
-0.0142056532,
-0.0084776049,
-0.0013695743,
-0.0102634439,
-0.0385020263,
-0.0374926776,
0.077240251,
0.0130075309,
-0.0682096928,
-0.0243886672,
-0.0098298537,
0.0429612212,
0.0495080203,
0.0396633334,
-0.0752927065,
-0.0162392408,
-0.0007699942,
0.038001392,
0.0101010464,
-0.0153562538,
0.0290634464,
-0.0728094354,
0.0375947878,
-0.0206769034,
0.0218660943,
-0.0589498207,
-0.0721625909,
0.0229920968,
-0.0127230054,
-0.0357640348,
0.0182694271,
-0.0168499332,
-0.0116236825,
0.0163429305,
0.0486417711,
-0.0409449637,
-0.0091928253,
-0.0205043349,
-0.0034171394,
0.002069487,
0.0205041543,
-0.0110938847,
-0.0403012745,
-0.0141543364,
-0.0428094417,
-0.0067189904,
-0.0675742552,
0.0127286362,
-0.0321035646,
0.0169124138,
0.0065110368,
-0.018136112,
-0.0066467244,
-0.01424844,
-0.0293153543,
0.0443774424,
-0.0218725447,
0.0204186197,
-0.0426219627,
-0.0344285257,
-0.0030031407,
0.0759284943,
-0.0246276818,
0.0282466263,
-0.0174361095,
-0.0315907598,
-0.0091688391,
0.0287433621,
-0.051163137,
-0.0324860141,
-0.0071068001,
-0.0018934413,
-0.0132604511,
-0.0021888039,
0.0218748711,
0.0413350537,
-0.033797536,
0.086305894,
-0.04852302,
-0.0202337019,
-0.0624238029,
0.0358119272,
-0.0194322523,
0.018100623,
-0.0276758559,
0.0103575736,
0.0027471355,
-0.0171985906,
-0.029870918,
-0.0015033074,
-0.0780819133,
-0.044264704,
-0.033336781,
0.0198576543,
0.0213909373,
0.0129691167,
-0.0087968493,
-0.0526872426,
0.0405353494,
0.0657695979,
-0.032904733,
0.0151112592,
-0.0230951384,
-0.0288959015,
-0.0280115698,
0.0313155763,
-0.0518726148,
0.0205537565,
-0.0078760833,
0.0551178642,
-0.0438583195,
-0.0601733699,
0.0282867458,
0.0032840907,
0.0580819175,
0.0002476709,
0.0137374839,
-0.0253727138,
0.008449275,
-0.0183455385,
-0.0175738055,
-0.0079136826,
-0.0023817082,
0.0276680868,
0.0013147795,
-0.0189417135,
-0.0153088337,
0.003121038,
0.0661627278,
-0.0828687027,
0.0071179089,
0.0190816782,
-0.0405017696,
0.0364563689,
-0.0159548465,
-0.0297650993,
-0.013512182,
-0.0290781613,
0.066243872,
-0.0569579974,
-0.0025339001,
0.0257430729,
-0.0220807102,
-0.022476729,
0.0024283191,
-0.0727402493,
-0.0421664864,
-0.0029720305,
-0.0293431431,
0.0535903499,
-0.0452264734,
-0.0049993135,
-0.0282603595,
-0.0120497849,
-0.0446424596,
-0.0260547027,
0.0570242666,
-0.002206706,
0.0378807746,
0.0476160683,
0.0066294773,
0.0717657954,
0.0796358436,
0.0289722644,
0.0329532064,
0.0099186115,
-0.0554874837,
-0.0026889325,
0.0026412015,
0.0393848382,
0.0829962119,
-0.0245333668,
0.0103064962,
-0.0094169145,
-0.0400002748,
0.0516902842,
-0.029641401,
-0.0225952454,
-0.0258821826,
0.0190547947,
0.0983153284,
0.0360968076,
0.0009570586,
-0.0473336428,
0.0430065915,
-0.0620660633,
-0.0194756258,
-0.0443544202,
-6.342457646e-33,
-0.0029419709,
-0.0044987076,
0.018767057,
-0.0053466167,
0.0122988215,
0.0247454792,
-0.0074896701,
-0.0194026586,
-0.0315422006,
-0.0048181266,
-0.0200756155,
0.019116072,
-0.003094061,
0.0123929773,
-0.0201787185,
0.0192342084,
0.0327398106,
0.0444711149,
0.0106379418,
0.0112736616,
0.0385606885,
0.0569333769,
0.0175163299,
-0.0838509575,
0.0079706572,
-0.0377015881,
0.0527665578,
0.0419382863,
0.0164062884,
0.058139462,
-0.0185945388,
0.0389897376,
0.0207372401,
-0.0193408914,
0.0246028844,
-0.0098440591,
-0.0746357888,
-0.0073866574,
0.0378944166,
-0.0363617055,
0.0162383839,
-0.0267720968,
-0.0046148049,
0.0021720296,
0.0018682219,
-0.0037543729,
0.0137805361,
-0.0049254675,
-0.0904252976,
-0.0598657951,
-0.0499325246,
0.0441841595,
0.0267169382,
0.0435861498,
0.0551871471,
0.0037482036,
-0.008837088,
0.0416765958,
-0.0335801095,
0.0082014427,
-0.0654147044,
0.0951197222,
0.0206691697,
0.0252308194,
-0.0307358727,
0.0268932097,
-0.0089447275,
-0.0067005474,
-0.003738397,
0.016757885,
0.0474473648,
0.0191960819,
0.0007332056,
0.0240460895,
0.0519870855,
-0.018219173,
-0.0687685162,
0.0458509438,
-0.0188860875,
0.0576271266,
0.0908723325,
0.0607742891,
-0.0631691664,
-0.0450802222,
-0.016814582,
-0.0052100313,
-0.0536688343,
-0.0086318795,
0.002490337,
0.0472491533,
-0.0137063423,
0.0356305391,
0.0593508333,
-0.0214198679,
-0.0435373299,
0.0303164739,
0.006959551,
-0.0211216919,
-0.017949909,
0.0510749519,
-0.0161560811,
-0.0490070209,
0.0105895763,
0.0007078561,
-0.0217213985,
-0.0029096375,
0.0115692997,
0.0100232968,
-0.0525134727,
-0.0301245209,
-0.0203499068,
-0.0264692567,
-0.0542161055,
0.0376177914,
0.0175407007,
0.0455553755,
0.044140514,
0.0343758389,
0.0252979212,
0.0033451444,
-0.022607347,
-0.0727855116,
0.0055543841,
-0.0257268287,
-0.0010269945,
0.0206383877,
-0.0379920006,
0.0298936032,
0.0209722482,
-0.0422500335,
-0.0030057007,
0.0497682542,
2.438e-7,
0.0468314439,
0.0269651003,
-0.0185522754,
0.0097656697,
-0.0338630229,
-0.0088033201,
0.0235191919,
0.0134147033,
0.0312368833,
-0.0047814543,
0.0013722816,
0.03058373,
0.0135134626,
0.0038878634,
-0.0767320916,
0.0013571233,
-0.0391727276,
-0.0350842178,
-0.0581989177,
-0.0229069795,
0.028787341,
0.0927320346,
-0.0159184709,
-0.0176136792,
0.0206608865,
-0.0428666212,
0.0436722375,
-0.0094443569,
0.0042063138,
0.0057108714,
0.0820196122,
0.0267713014,
0.0243476797,
-0.0127054788,
0.0048993793,
0.0356765054,
0.0220379569,
0.0561753735,
-0.0305984244,
0.0056376252,
0.007597493,
-0.0393548869,
-0.0012660515,
-0.0331456363,
0.0691584945,
0.0380615667,
0.0262010228,
-0.0011328078,
-0.0102415662,
0.032094948,
-0.0166917201,
-0.008563376,
-0.0228851121,
0.0012448302,
0.0222459529,
-0.0002243706,
-0.0152899493,
-0.0672001168,
0.0099145239,
0.0272823647,
-0.0609558709,
-0.037274342,
-0.0422322713,
0.0191784166,
-0.0070608198,
-0.0203491002,
0.0229876228,
2.42570675e-34,
0.0351260565,
0.0532719046,
-0.0269374754,
0.0424110554,
0.0122023281,
-0.0271796305,
-0.007675258,
0.0360519774,
-0.0001366021,
-0.1410642266,
-0.0077984296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00111v1 | Identifying Symptoms of Delirium from Clinical Narratives Using Natural Language Processing | 2023-03-31T20:16:44 | 2023-03-31T20:16:44 | Aokun Chen, Daniel Paredes, Zehao Yu, Xiwei Lou, Roberta Brunson, Jamie N. Thomas, Kimberly A. Martinez, Robert J. Lucero, Tanja Magoc, Laurence M. Solberg, Urszula A. Snigurska, Sarah E. Ser, Mattia Prosperi, Jiang Bian, Ragnhildur I. Bjarnadottir, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Delirium is an acute decline or fluctuation in attention, awareness, or other
cognitive function that can lead to serious adverse outcomes. Despite the
severe outcomes, delirium is frequently unrecognized and uncoded in patients'
electronic health records (EHRs) due to its transient and diverse nature.
Natural language processing (NLP), a key technology that extracts medical
concepts from clinical narratives, has shown great potential in studies of
delirium outcomes and symptoms. To assist in the diagnosis and phenotyping of
delirium, we formed an expert panel to categorize diverse delirium symptoms,
composed annotation guidelines, created a delirium corpus with diverse delirium
symptoms, and developed NLP methods to extract delirium symptoms from clinical
notes. We compared 5 state-of-the-art transformer models including 2 models
(BERT and RoBERTa) from the general domain and 3 models (BERT_MIMIC,
RoBERTa_MIMIC, and GatorTron) from the clinical domain. GatorTron achieved the
best strict and lenient F1 scores of 0.8055 and 0.8759, respectively. We
conducted an error analysis to identify challenges in annotating delirium
symptoms and developing NLP systems. To the best of our knowledge, this is the
first large language model-based delirium symptom extraction system. Our study
lays the foundation for the future development of computable phenotypes and
diagnosis methods for delirium. | [
0.0464487001,
0.0257528834,
0.0061803022,
-0.0077346447,
-0.0217065401,
0.0379492231,
-0.0300601106,
0.0180241242,
0.0360632725,
-0.0846383348,
0.0374754407,
-0.0034779413,
0.0165181849,
0.0568752997,
0.0130023062,
-0.0625003502,
0.032295242,
0.0144584589,
0.0698864982,
0.0439811461,
-0.0049617784,
0.0141524198,
-0.0558004826,
0.0519608781,
0.0036386133,
-0.0209692456,
0.0181211699,
-0.0137133962,
0.0375136733,
-0.0517398156,
-0.0159978066,
0.0354944468,
-0.0136279464,
-0.0353689082,
0.0000018985,
-0.0537272021,
-0.0177481323,
0.0270464718,
0.0099260397,
-0.0647657663,
0.0786806643,
-0.0153513672,
0.0156638809,
0.0171909612,
-0.0505747497,
-0.0051193214,
0.055712346,
0.1039079428,
0.0449004285,
0.0610358343,
-0.0317801349,
-0.0652166232,
-0.0145123499,
0.0045253611,
0.0451994203,
0.0195144489,
0.0531685427,
0.0082431678,
0.0145780863,
-0.0785534978,
0.0244631376,
0.0058398969,
-0.0210695174,
0.0662941635,
-0.0336158909,
0.029694492,
-0.0359431952,
-0.0427136309,
-0.0062111872,
0.0347149409,
-0.0096002007,
0.0278063118,
0.0507980809,
0.037709251,
-0.0139221372,
0.0000196073,
-0.0139451632,
0.0008873788,
-0.0416432023,
0.0145100737,
0.0632295981,
0.0223487522,
0.0111772818,
-0.0299104787,
-0.035267856,
-0.0031695548,
0.0140464893,
-0.0373312496,
0.0127426907,
-0.017648438,
-0.0387770198,
-0.0328389481,
0.0382441208,
-0.0364400223,
-0.0467714965,
-0.0027091752,
-0.0319317244,
-0.0082662711,
0.0506178588,
-0.0685449913,
-0.0003558326,
0.0106563875,
-0.0414909348,
0.0317202024,
-0.0365666412,
0.0023476332,
0.0157439858,
0.0238383841,
-0.0201935321,
-0.0199729968,
-0.0892917663,
0.0274954103,
-0.0763067976,
0.0074218065,
-0.0100957267,
-0.0201255735,
-0.0513754301,
-0.0321169272,
-0.015440668,
0.0155688021,
0.0231427513,
0.0421402045,
0.0087389769,
0.0239548478,
0.0012378858,
0.0291735157,
0.0146176293,
-0.0189973377,
0.0100328736,
-0.0598787852,
0.0392329544,
0.0234830659,
-0.0076199248,
-0.0169176236,
0.0225867629,
0.0556473546,
0.038913358,
-0.0121083893,
-0.0639541224,
-0.0272192545,
-0.0051124636,
-0.0130969016,
0.0039255819,
-0.0313966647,
0.0220362097,
0.0053820452,
-0.0007249838,
-0.0418614335,
0.0305177085,
0.025126623,
0.0104864119,
0.0690494403,
-0.0766327381,
-0.004774956,
-0.0028646349,
0.0022824944,
-0.0067582624,
0.0311082304,
0.053425815,
-0.0308914203,
0.0120454747,
-0.0510796718,
0.0554255322,
0.0094342604,
-0.0437713228,
-0.04554189,
-0.016659867,
0.0043190429,
-0.0396268182,
0.0283020083,
-0.005190121,
0.0537650064,
0.0306372214,
-0.0175632387,
0.0174384639,
0.0449254252,
0.0068231011,
0.0256681163,
0.0282203872,
0.004413025,
-0.0128414184,
-0.0155940996,
-0.0118074827,
-0.0009673777,
0.0325930752,
-0.0065546203,
0.0175641701,
0.0400882401,
0.006856618,
-0.0399122946,
-0.0664299354,
0.001654875,
0.0400013775,
0.0042747767,
-0.0117927128,
-0.0218353551,
-0.0484047346,
0.057192225,
0.040236868,
-0.0357020646,
-0.0296485387,
-0.0071693417,
-0.0435821265,
0.0935897529,
0.0264916196,
-0.0364078395,
-0.0046359212,
-0.0481689312,
0.0037770262,
0.0254150946,
0.0235862732,
-0.0300697647,
0.0140355183,
-0.0212462284,
0.0292156227,
0.0465698279,
0.0264848024,
-0.035728164,
-0.0681726262,
0.0157727506,
-0.0170104448,
-0.0416021049,
-0.0511853434,
0.0372333191,
-0.0261463244,
-0.0262001604,
-0.0257609412,
0.0022047244,
0.0100455722,
0.021089863,
-0.0066503561,
0.0088486858,
0.0143002048,
-0.066094093,
-0.0393872596,
0.0197373535,
0.0085085956,
-0.0193550717,
0.0088404696,
-0.0146315517,
0.00454586,
0.0213956665,
-0.0430955961,
-0.0379689001,
0.0100584235,
-0.0898898914,
0.0216065366,
-0.0250692721,
-0.0195952915,
0.0329677723,
0.0442979261,
-0.0338103101,
0.0537677184,
-0.0132375956,
0.0217986852,
-0.0333601348,
-0.0942257643,
0.0074732564,
-0.0260510966,
-0.0191365127,
0.0010109795,
-0.0286387205,
0.0231497679,
-0.0237387717,
-0.0448073968,
-0.0162458494,
0.0253016986,
-0.1082645133,
-0.0015273662,
0.0110624116,
-0.008068488,
0.0149295656,
0.0152219879,
-0.0313670523,
-0.0072397422,
-0.0361004733,
0.0097275106,
0.0266569387,
0.0178454276,
0.0299809985,
0.0439626984,
-0.0508372858,
-0.0306214169,
0.0214583091,
-0.0575186871,
0.0252508689,
0.0023715217,
-0.0734924525,
-0.0538230166,
-0.0315059051,
-0.0386908427,
0.0306298714,
0.0283896178,
-0.0177611019,
0.0008399319,
-0.0101609379,
0.0186616722,
0.010733949,
0.007135883,
0.0495451093,
0.0055119917,
-0.0231303275,
0.0094986251,
0.0044776178,
-0.0393811651,
0.0368208662,
0.010331966,
-0.0662829354,
0.0358713306,
0.0940674469,
0.0537469573,
0.007188431,
-0.0172850862,
-0.0124986842,
-0.0068877907,
0.0413514934,
0.0177509878,
0.0040760981,
-0.0386505388,
0.024415018,
0.0082088858,
-0.0110492269,
0.0809429586,
-0.0304625593,
-0.0023350823,
-0.0924798399,
-0.0175367165,
-0.0297920723,
-0.0209470503,
0.0083092023,
0.0201189388,
0.038620811,
-0.0471418574,
0.0230220743,
0.0284055658,
-0.0189094506,
-0.0255215075,
0.0808399022,
-0.004086019,
0.0109479018,
0.0150679024,
0.0090368204,
-0.0414714962,
-0.0039996412,
-0.0505983457,
0.0101281954,
0.0239527598,
-0.0007580296,
-0.0787727088,
0.021153545,
-0.0105561605,
0.0465983711,
0.0304649379,
-0.0345177129,
0.0028525919,
-0.0077738701,
0.0413258374,
0.0014740258,
0.0299850516,
0.0255332012,
0.0005027587,
0.0865537301,
-0.0164017528,
0.0523798466,
-0.0417697616,
-0.0188425966,
-0.0088812802,
-0.0700344369,
0.012292848,
0.0049400791,
-0.0113291228,
-0.0265766941,
0.000719248,
0.1117949188,
0.0253701359,
-0.0433573835,
0.0201704241,
-0.0485504977,
-0.0170737281,
-0.0015241598,
-0.0197212677,
-0.0917790756,
-0.0518586002,
-0.0308004674,
0.0556582995,
-0.0104511501,
-0.0362535082,
0.0179085936,
0.0118499855,
0.0374417417,
-0.0272931475,
-0.0005226863,
-0.0174152609,
-0.0287304558,
0.0175566114,
-0.0454830006,
0.0139061706,
-0.025845468,
-0.0182971861,
0.0057419688,
0.0115415854,
-0.0613333508,
-0.0844393224,
0.0528817922,
-0.0240128003,
0.0439145789,
0.0628571138,
0.0597706698,
0.0050688568,
-0.0871187374,
0.0040266612,
-0.0377488285,
0.0244687684,
0.0128265424,
0.050119523,
0.0002452044,
-0.0179596487,
-0.0388359912,
0.0204289034,
-0.0775004551,
-0.0241253115,
-0.0299422443,
0.0570114516,
-0.0709107444,
-0.0284349229,
-0.0420225672,
0.0278020073,
0.0549983941,
0.0683206469,
0.0189461466,
-0.0012899789,
-0.0620120764,
0.0239256937,
-0.0074015502,
-0.019862324,
-0.0122531336,
0.0129578756,
0.0327343978,
-0.0317992903,
-0.0922045261,
-0.010989272,
0.0401135087,
-0.0072221835,
0.0063038208,
0.0054898881,
0.0378349125,
0.0142829176,
-0.055351086,
0.0400026366,
0.0407876372,
-0.0031148009,
-0.0270226486,
-0.027161492,
-0.0219747499,
0.0404536724,
-0.0154629257,
0.0202620253,
-0.0263162144,
0.0057474091,
0.0971079022,
0.0291386042,
0.0220714267,
-0.0297968052,
-0.0035670586,
-0.0194989871,
0.0069953976,
0.011626469,
0.0206318237,
-0.0247188173,
-0.0182230379,
0.0356456339,
0.0126436008,
-0.0094852876,
-0.0033336219,
0.0127818407,
-0.0461833812,
-0.0074803964,
0.0119123887,
0.0337569118,
0.0128435791,
0.0161347743,
0.0385235213,
-0.0308348015,
-0.0121690594,
-0.0269155968,
-0.0477182604,
-0.0396700166,
0.023315616,
-0.0150478696,
0.0024278418,
0.0101905754,
0.0006712897,
0.0080907457,
0.0036953194,
-0.1048221663,
-0.0860102177,
-0.0579976477,
0.0596556999,
0.0407668427,
-0.0090272445,
0.0270179827,
-0.0342805237,
0.0087983795,
-0.0163825639,
-0.0254388377,
0.0192081239,
-0.0018972468,
0.0949940532,
0.0054121353,
-0.0096950326,
-0.0003850752,
0.073770687,
0.0117966589,
-0.0256250538,
-0.0090052141,
-0.0011747183,
0.0282534435,
0.0022398669,
0.0596104376,
-0.0130962813,
0.0322308131,
0.0105264867,
-0.0038072092,
0.0019536202,
-0.002418976,
0.0242330506,
0.002801141,
-0.0372958109,
-0.0182612743,
0.080153428,
-0.0217516832,
-0.0114498176,
0.006967396,
-0.0236690678,
-0.0227865633,
0.0001593029,
-0.0216702074,
0.010473148,
-0.0724456608,
-0.029429948,
-0.0402599387,
-0.0102907028,
0.0720113888,
-0.0062734224,
-0.0147764273,
0.0063855005,
0.0437318683,
0.0370364226,
0.0032813041,
-0.0359997787,
-0.0345515162,
0.0030497531,
-0.0095532266,
-0.0302351918,
-0.0018697563,
-5.771431511e-33,
0.0021771486,
0.0119601768,
0.0121532911,
0.0036346794,
0.0103178136,
-0.0184555463,
-0.0292147957,
0.0130231194,
0.0120089371,
0.0290314164,
-0.0011968194,
0.0050327894,
0.0126724737,
0.0289929565,
0.0498207808,
-0.0655048639,
0.0249228384,
0.0157687906,
-0.0182812847,
0.0168668199,
0.0171833243,
0.0244724918,
0.0793006644,
-0.091279164,
0.0451226309,
0.0075104199,
-0.0079278098,
0.0135627184,
0.0707198754,
0.0130789122,
-0.0502341911,
0.0573464371,
0.0350842923,
-0.0357171446,
-0.022558311,
-0.0024525339,
-0.0193047244,
-0.0184501372,
0.0446298867,
-0.0075075384,
-0.0232239999,
-0.0148963463,
0.0630267039,
0.0082035009,
0.0430770703,
0.0305435602,
0.0390008762,
-0.0474807248,
0.0467460789,
0.03333712,
-0.0606632568,
0.0239727963,
0.0199906752,
0.0045931954,
0.0083799968,
0.0404522009,
-0.0254683942,
-0.0006161107,
-0.0768841878,
-0.0420440137,
-0.0323540159,
0.0115781259,
0.0130705694,
-0.0681631193,
-0.0207853224,
0.0756955147,
0.0619927235,
-0.0057716132,
-0.0680960193,
0.0562763177,
-0.0458552167,
0.0660240948,
0.0795406848,
0.0114752743,
0.0470451713,
-0.0046250722,
-0.0300184824,
0.0480675548,
-0.0934638456,
0.0400524288,
0.037734542,
-0.0325909369,
-0.0562191308,
-0.0074970839,
0.0353141651,
0.0085107032,
-0.0344047248,
0.0019604932,
0.0283200908,
-0.0025850195,
0.0448774584,
0.0657157078,
0.0256517902,
-0.0251741521,
0.0130722653,
-0.0249417592,
0.0130512128,
0.0402327776,
-0.0177716147,
-0.0366133898,
-0.0037422322,
-0.0213800669,
0.0461116321,
-0.0155483373,
0.0686279759,
0.016063923,
0.0061595701,
-0.0063761394,
-0.032372158,
0.002138014,
0.0267458763,
0.009087489,
-0.0109829837,
0.0764411241,
0.0156090297,
0.0262759477,
-0.0026508099,
-0.0253928509,
0.0201122221,
-0.0200304985,
-0.0063543012,
0.0093585467,
0.0076479716,
-0.0023187646,
-0.0021055448,
0.0025506811,
-0.0439791977,
-0.0107643986,
-0.0215616692,
-0.0401211306,
0.0081984727,
-0.0334858447,
2.683e-7,
0.0626845956,
0.047000479,
0.0231518596,
-0.0589573979,
-0.0046227369,
0.0137142427,
0.0554192998,
0.0505563766,
0.0192054268,
-0.0552397966,
-0.0010172554,
-0.0197893921,
0.0230433326,
0.0642288402,
-0.0491552055,
-0.0614558198,
0.0112041486,
-0.0111962315,
-0.0359131135,
-0.0129307099,
0.0940996036,
0.0290306509,
-0.0444105417,
-0.0391901508,
0.0259367116,
-0.0532239489,
0.0090836678,
-0.0071897786,
0.0070813559,
0.047287073,
0.0568516478,
0.0129549289,
0.0211338066,
0.0343867429,
-0.0452852882,
-0.0070083048,
0.0208367165,
0.0360476859,
-0.0715066716,
0.0153474826,
0.0263105072,
-0.0186744947,
0.0064329626,
-0.0257697385,
0.0508229919,
-0.0603097714,
-0.0331585556,
-0.0099917175,
-0.04607182,
0.0153693333,
0.0413232893,
-0.0168864429,
-0.0336988829,
0.0343474187,
0.0187776107,
0.0380013213,
-0.038103994,
-0.0506701581,
-0.0200083014,
0.0209553298,
-0.0317042321,
0.0360350385,
0.0373841636,
-0.0536676385,
-0.0022791254,
-0.0584169067,
-0.0130092856,
2.400489871e-34,
0.0188335907,
0.016250968,
0.0087737916,
0.026424177,
0.0189418979,
-0.000597114,
-0.0056177308,
-0.0027460274,
-0.0390914343,
-0.0737846196,
-0.0246179178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12191v1 | "Genlangs" and Zipf's Law: Do languages generated by ChatGPT statistically look human? | 2023-03-31T20:10:59 | 2023-03-31T20:10:59 | Justin Diamond | cs.CL | cs.CL | OpenAI's GPT-4 is a Large Language Model (LLM) that can generate coherent
constructed languages, or "conlangs," which we propose be called "genlangs"
when generated by Artificial Intelligence (AI). The genlangs created by ChatGPT
for this research (Voxphera, Vivenzia, and Lumivoxa) each have unique features,
appear facially coherent, and plausibly "translate" into English. This study
investigates whether genlangs created by ChatGPT follow Zipf's law. Zipf's law
approximately holds across all natural and artificially constructed human
languages. According to Zipf's law, the word frequencies in a text corpus are
inversely proportional to their rank in the frequency table. This means that
the most frequent word appears about twice as often as the second most frequent
word, three times as often as the third most frequent word, and so on. We
hypothesize that Zipf's law will hold for genlangs because (1) genlangs created
by ChatGPT fundamentally operate in the same way as human language with respect
to the semantic usefulness of certain tokens, and (2) ChatGPT has been trained
on a corpora of text that includes many different languages, all of which
exhibit Zipf's law to varying degrees. Through statistical linguistics, we aim
to understand if LLM-based languages statistically look human. Our findings
indicate that genlangs adhere closely to Zipf's law, supporting the hypothesis
that genlangs created by ChatGPT exhibit similar statistical properties to
natural and artificial human languages. We also conclude that with human
assistance, AI is already capable of creating the world's first
fully-functional genlang, and we call for its development. | [
0.0203001276,
0.0545234978,
-0.0555638596,
0.0171141922,
-0.0523222871,
0.0158890896,
-0.0378470831,
0.0410183817,
-0.029123541,
-0.0128313443,
-0.0025596444,
-0.0226654951,
0.0563222989,
0.0400154367,
0.0422864035,
-0.0600609295,
0.0139738638,
-0.0196294468,
0.0202861484,
-0.013338835,
0.0101982504,
0.0063790926,
0.0121071152,
0.0427589007,
-0.0277486574,
-0.0122215953,
-0.0097648315,
0.0080500729,
0.0039521363,
0.0229038764,
-0.0466685928,
0.0332087241,
-0.0382897407,
0.0445905514,
0.0000016898,
-0.0519973449,
0.0493021458,
0.0056414623,
0.0059450613,
-0.0030625672,
0.0785129666,
0.0077862157,
-0.0637209192,
-0.0127130086,
-0.0527092367,
0.0029920822,
0.0714382008,
-0.0122197131,
0.011189932,
0.0363726765,
-0.0302814767,
-0.0438998267,
0.0627304837,
0.006152878,
0.0232736673,
-0.002121052,
-0.0176354013,
0.0102357967,
0.0109327445,
-0.0391480811,
-0.0074302941,
0.0394032449,
0.0273339618,
0.0175173413,
-0.0215869732,
0.0242159478,
-0.0730222389,
-0.0673279911,
0.0070571075,
0.0668775588,
-0.008118229,
-0.064978227,
-0.0141474213,
0.0216844305,
0.0226693321,
0.0141511383,
-0.0284903925,
0.0552537814,
-0.0170930922,
0.0500711724,
0.0531187281,
-0.0087515861,
0.0036559519,
-0.0152815077,
-0.0234825891,
0.0783255845,
0.0319893546,
-0.0308750365,
-0.0087834075,
-0.0068121646,
-0.0116018001,
-0.0514397845,
-0.0120973,
0.0013346907,
-0.0001411063,
0.0252894182,
-0.0296474453,
-0.0162195507,
0.0355578214,
-0.0506765023,
-0.0112339938,
0.0324619599,
-0.0378146954,
0.0130240424,
-0.0181280095,
0.0587059036,
0.0170674697,
0.0217188094,
-0.0566010252,
-0.0034615549,
-0.0427303649,
-0.0165478252,
-0.0240976159,
0.0020083373,
-0.031057708,
-0.004215688,
-0.0455341004,
0.0222801361,
-0.0055351607,
-0.0154329315,
-0.0214268938,
0.0015567325,
-0.0355805345,
0.0029510008,
-0.0312235113,
-0.0132958209,
-0.0356984511,
-0.0121299205,
-0.0412209556,
-0.1119862944,
0.0538575202,
0.0360237472,
-0.0134751666,
0.0024114989,
-0.0064282906,
0.047070615,
0.0153192263,
-0.0229788292,
-0.0153901335,
-0.0036204683,
-0.01483016,
-0.044337824,
0.0052428367,
-0.0611503981,
-0.0119210845,
0.0074326759,
0.0154048493,
-0.0279313587,
-0.024465818,
0.027208738,
-0.0467797667,
0.0273442771,
-0.0230224412,
0.0445532501,
0.0117123593,
-0.0251238327,
0.0344676785,
0.0467419401,
0.0411643349,
0.0098140268,
0.0413596667,
-0.021487223,
0.0320754573,
0.0553202592,
-0.0304129459,
0.0309664942,
-0.022899352,
-0.0539118089,
-0.0135649694,
0.014692815,
0.0626991615,
0.101706259,
0.0121316025,
-0.016658796,
0.0557227992,
0.1085961238,
0.0041620173,
0.0522996709,
0.0491927415,
0.0208210405,
0.0465528741,
0.0638237894,
-0.0123241944,
-0.0088024354,
-0.0397480838,
0.0046029096,
-0.0106792897,
0.0456214733,
-0.0134626981,
-0.0116923079,
-0.0077616414,
-0.010576576,
0.0444164351,
-0.0421323478,
0.0356365331,
0.0039495318,
0.0032587822,
-0.0640863478,
0.0461918563,
-0.0369091183,
-0.0325256251,
-0.0954489484,
0.0210254788,
0.0478927568,
0.0192782227,
0.0170006156,
0.0416481607,
0.0325975753,
-0.0352082029,
0.0859553963,
0.0323226638,
-0.0098137148,
-0.0002137479,
-0.009260322,
0.0423372351,
0.0155523159,
0.0040547228,
0.0612425953,
-0.040129479,
0.0355656296,
0.0064580706,
-0.0115735913,
-0.0118045192,
0.0355638638,
-0.0629742891,
0.0216382779,
-0.0277965367,
-0.0117211351,
0.0315512531,
0.0055494746,
-0.0664984584,
0.039537929,
-0.0166044179,
-0.0150049133,
0.0117491512,
0.0546867512,
0.0221051648,
-0.0069546294,
0.0521420911,
-0.0658366159,
0.0021858546,
-0.0012390161,
0.0242472161,
-0.0184634943,
0.0583047457,
-0.0672259405,
0.0743717551,
-0.0615485087,
0.0333235003,
-0.0262695905,
0.022006657,
-0.009121161,
0.0424218029,
0.0243902616,
0.0018722177,
0.0408538394,
-0.0221932437,
0.0482278317,
-0.0555685982,
0.0189387314,
0.0350912437,
-0.0069977827,
0.0073342673,
0.0168865174,
0.0340496711,
-0.0488430299,
-0.0079184473,
-0.1019049361,
-0.0310910959,
-0.0023011416,
0.0176183581,
-0.0012913424,
-0.0289262999,
-0.0364286415,
0.0126329204,
-0.0728577524,
0.0278602578,
0.0374388397,
0.0018583304,
0.0199899338,
-0.0551098734,
-0.0423186161,
-0.0294155069,
-0.0065609966,
-0.0159581359,
0.00855924,
0.0424602292,
-0.0181945916,
-0.0373026505,
0.0292920787,
-0.0567216612,
-0.0053127301,
0.0012128835,
-0.0608413033,
0.016433686,
-0.0244560484,
0.0859061927,
0.055193916,
0.0243349131,
0.0316880532,
0.0218668915,
0.0089727342,
-0.0149390846,
-0.0367935039,
-0.0231013689,
0.0042717489,
-0.0242574196,
-0.0799396038,
0.0219250172,
0.0378091,
0.0110821929,
-0.0015464209,
-0.0733955652,
0.0557062477,
-0.0208358988,
-0.0764942914,
-0.0052122111,
0.0065359017,
-0.0337738916,
0.070553638,
-0.0248596556,
-0.0832425728,
0.0322350077,
-0.0369449593,
-0.0071647475,
-0.0215340834,
-0.0091531845,
-0.0042733671,
0.0420694686,
0.0553104393,
0.0368563235,
0.0357803665,
-0.0178292077,
-0.0588274784,
0.0163768623,
0.0012403298,
-0.0571726635,
-0.0061317082,
-0.0817286968,
-0.0022047816,
0.0056946743,
-0.0129074818,
-0.0133267231,
-0.0230110288,
-0.0112835672,
0.0149796102,
0.0513663664,
-0.0476543494,
0.0424078628,
0.0097176172,
0.0391691215,
0.0052857837,
-0.0095714917,
0.0056628599,
0.0043829926,
0.0351730362,
0.0539008193,
0.0187271703,
0.0339807011,
-0.0226694271,
-0.0166669358,
0.033171922,
-0.0115929479,
0.0561748147,
-0.0113866329,
0.0063870377,
0.0219421517,
0.0195095334,
-0.0590537116,
0.0214236863,
0.0161204673,
0.0153623288,
0.0409237631,
0.0750121698,
0.0213256869,
-0.0242365692,
0.0239117946,
-0.0095743872,
0.0119171087,
-0.0007232064,
0.0315296166,
-0.0773524866,
0.0103951115,
0.0331173316,
0.0076478305,
-0.0444308072,
-0.0030475946,
-0.0244916193,
-0.1154117212,
0.0491395816,
0.0057151481,
-0.062298283,
-0.0038667126,
-0.0292879492,
-0.0197452102,
0.0042923228,
0.0147783281,
0.0006757829,
-0.02456991,
0.0282445606,
0.0177403782,
-0.0387118831,
-0.037753623,
-0.0073031699,
-0.0362353586,
0.0730954483,
0.0584820062,
0.0835335776,
-0.0650186166,
-0.0519234464,
-0.0046494496,
0.028843075,
0.0021041946,
0.0172738787,
0.0275661089,
0.0314500444,
-0.0205154698,
-0.0732396469,
0.0037776972,
-0.0321896151,
0.0016925845,
-0.0148399137,
0.0086592259,
-0.0066856919,
-0.0677147508,
-0.0206016768,
-0.0082157245,
-0.0405190103,
0.0520600975,
0.0347260125,
-0.0302529149,
-0.0308410805,
-0.0463138074,
0.0504240878,
-0.0216521341,
-0.0954616293,
0.0195607003,
-0.0108188819,
-0.0987424254,
-0.1064256951,
-0.0564888194,
-0.0142614404,
0.042627994,
0.0414529257,
-0.0505174734,
0.0123684295,
0.0075162086,
-0.0073506231,
-0.0321192704,
-0.0222684424,
0.0085458802,
-0.0572586916,
-0.0382382609,
0.0117305396,
-0.0472367145,
-0.0013300297,
0.0205166545,
-0.0340414569,
-0.0510289967,
0.0434333757,
0.0297477506,
0.0355268791,
-0.0293704271,
-0.002364438,
-0.0306088813,
0.0283771101,
0.0511868149,
-0.0078644967,
0.0512112565,
-0.0036678775,
-0.0379084088,
0.0180670805,
0.0211118869,
0.0021213521,
0.0205000136,
-0.0237207059,
0.0196594764,
-0.0037393621,
-0.0473490842,
0.0372897275,
0.0735628232,
-0.01352935,
-0.0601134598,
-0.0091127874,
-0.0217291322,
-0.0391175598,
-0.0122558363,
0.0199831724,
-0.0256045628,
-0.0377289839,
0.0301197544,
0.0444296934,
-0.0020521146,
0.0169299487,
-0.0430824347,
0.0074030929,
0.0318508111,
-0.0077947821,
0.0029792404,
0.0665975362,
0.0015965,
0.0290835146,
0.0291755237,
0.0350732617,
-0.043443311,
0.0599986389,
0.0001476789,
0.0151070487,
-0.0121668084,
-0.0393279828,
0.0095035322,
0.0327806994,
-0.03477313,
-0.0550347902,
0.0134918178,
0.0462711565,
0.0697802082,
0.0213740338,
0.0897663757,
-0.0524725653,
0.0040276684,
-0.0280327294,
0.0128702074,
0.0085112769,
-0.0078448141,
-0.0483620688,
-0.0061976374,
-0.0463928171,
-0.0232154373,
0.0815664455,
0.0370587297,
-0.0133843273,
-0.0300969984,
-0.0282264221,
-0.0007793088,
-0.0001598597,
-0.0200016405,
-0.0206716359,
-0.0052174008,
-0.0072517628,
-0.0814104378,
-0.0856904611,
-0.0442419723,
0.0307982508,
0.0469681248,
-0.0059140511,
0.0110659245,
0.0352863222,
-0.0277569406,
-0.003726563,
-0.0576510467,
0.0247201119,
-0.0567812845,
0.0068688598,
0.0152485045,
-5.509984302e-33,
-0.0069886851,
-0.0003020755,
-0.0089843869,
0.0386459641,
-0.0008873334,
-0.0291788653,
-0.0542814396,
0.0318237096,
-0.0376883149,
0.028561078,
-0.0149944108,
-0.0118684107,
0.0239450913,
-0.0198531821,
0.0108152712,
0.0204985552,
0.0043076444,
-0.0385538749,
0.0109895822,
-0.0106155733,
0.0187022723,
-0.0141413789,
0.0598563254,
-0.0168381128,
0.0280264542,
-0.0247488432,
-0.0009497383,
-0.0075458032,
-0.0001114006,
0.028091155,
-0.0468673967,
0.0344548933,
0.0398806147,
-0.0173801016,
-0.0054676598,
0.0204167943,
0.0024580501,
-0.0203739647,
0.0135747483,
0.0217688028,
-0.0361945182,
-0.0201871749,
0.0059891557,
-0.024861889,
-0.0568308868,
0.0330147259,
0.0537034534,
-0.0300864354,
-0.0041366788,
-0.004941735,
-0.0738815963,
0.012562111,
-0.014894397,
-0.0030046902,
0.0369492918,
-0.016448684,
-0.0454595648,
0.0011716352,
0.0104786484,
0.07966692,
0.0187907889,
-0.0076241712,
0.0728378892,
0.0002905521,
0.0373089015,
0.0525403544,
0.115959622,
0.0078281229,
-0.0302789882,
-0.0031614336,
0.0609474145,
0.000972936,
0.0148346825,
0.0777211264,
0.0608872958,
-0.0258212667,
-0.0078269253,
0.0185704008,
0.0508766063,
0.0043001175,
-0.0404510833,
0.0180820134,
-0.0579440333,
-0.010581065,
0.0037109766,
-0.0484853536,
-0.0162525903,
-0.0474766679,
0.0061915088,
-0.0523725972,
0.0000601154,
-0.0374336801,
0.031450402,
-0.0550783835,
0.0001226283,
-0.0152255371,
-0.0548812747,
0.0427713729,
-0.0025230194,
0.0352216884,
-0.0177286323,
-0.0441386327,
0.0060692285,
0.0518580228,
0.049058333,
0.0119179348,
-0.0051047392,
0.0217674188,
-0.0400520489,
0.0162020084,
-0.0102537153,
-0.0340371169,
0.0467618704,
-0.0182511117,
0.0121517684,
0.0079176323,
-0.0004369287,
-0.0339399166,
0.0327626131,
0.0323757157,
-0.0754023939,
-0.0167528912,
-0.036838565,
-0.0247137658,
-0.0481389426,
-0.0225187503,
-0.0638422295,
0.0398662351,
0.0499725156,
-0.0218940824,
-0.0178302433,
-0.0080464138,
2.596e-7,
0.0240338072,
0.0359516069,
0.045134116,
0.0178836454,
0.0523448773,
0.0082283244,
-0.0225615464,
0.0156908594,
0.0191852227,
-0.0293466728,
-0.0051257298,
0.0317811482,
0.0404150747,
0.0409455895,
-0.0657909513,
0.0494911037,
-0.0355881825,
-0.0171734001,
-0.0159932412,
0.0476426296,
0.0355327837,
0.0847061351,
0.0002432227,
-0.0406920165,
0.0222031381,
-0.0249909926,
0.0279551353,
-0.0265360232,
-0.0065916958,
0.0154473977,
-0.0297521967,
0.0215236899,
0.0176307317,
0.0174450818,
-0.009203623,
-0.011404329,
0.0364252552,
0.0429574586,
-0.0144633893,
0.0346063003,
0.0187457055,
-0.0058773565,
-0.0022345015,
-0.0451395288,
0.0448806472,
0.0145979831,
-0.0356137194,
-0.0152107477,
-0.0190387759,
0.0007321635,
0.0050572008,
-0.0414679982,
-0.0185583588,
0.0306240898,
0.0205373541,
-0.0174951274,
-0.013588706,
-0.0306985565,
-0.0143820811,
0.0025650116,
-0.0270621479,
-0.0703021586,
-0.0387720317,
0.0192266516,
0.043565996,
-0.0056885881,
0.0201063138,
1.996285577e-34,
0.0222062487,
0.0128547708,
0.0421044566,
-0.025208788,
0.0185632799,
0.0137085551,
0.035976667,
0.0441102237,
0.0242824238,
-0.0447032042,
-0.0185876284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18223v13 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18223v13 | A Survey of Large Language Models | 2023-03-31T17:28:46 | 2023-11-24T13:57:45 | Wayne Xin Zhao, Kun Zhou, Junyi Li, Tianyi Tang, Xiaolei Wang, Yupeng Hou, Yingqian Min, Beichen Zhang, Junjie Zhang, Zican Dong, Yifan Du, Chen Yang, Yushuo Chen, Zhipeng Chen, Jinhao Jiang, Ruiyang Ren, Yifan Li, Xinyu Tang, Zikang Liu, Peiyu Liu, Jian-Yun Nie, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language is essentially a complex, intricate system of human expressions
governed by grammatical rules. It poses a significant challenge to develop
capable AI algorithms for comprehending and grasping a language. As a major
approach, language modeling has been widely studied for language understanding
and generation in the past two decades, evolving from statistical language
models to neural language models. Recently, pre-trained language models (PLMs)
have been proposed by pre-training Transformer models over large-scale corpora,
showing strong capabilities in solving various NLP tasks. Since researchers
have found that model scaling can lead to performance improvement, they further
study the scaling effect by increasing the model size to an even larger size.
Interestingly, when the parameter scale exceeds a certain level, these enlarged
language models not only achieve a significant performance improvement but also
show some special abilities that are not present in small-scale language
models. To discriminate the difference in parameter scale, the research
community has coined the term large language models (LLM) for the PLMs of
significant size. Recently, the research on LLMs has been largely advanced by
both academia and industry, and a remarkable progress is the launch of ChatGPT,
which has attracted widespread attention from society. The technical evolution
of LLMs has been making an important impact on the entire AI community, which
would revolutionize the way how we develop and use AI algorithms. In this
survey, we review the recent advances of LLMs by introducing the background,
key findings, and mainstream techniques. In particular, we focus on four major
aspects of LLMs, namely pre-training, adaptation tuning, utilization, and
capacity evaluation. Besides, we also summarize the available resources for
developing LLMs and discuss the remaining issues for future directions. | [
0.052246049,
0.0674050823,
-0.010832631,
0.030915359,
-0.0182811506,
0.0218199566,
0.0162047334,
0.0148543231,
-0.0163061805,
-0.0642635971,
-0.0483447835,
-0.0614767559,
-0.0309641007,
0.0454160348,
0.0048630321,
-0.0299027041,
0.0333764367,
-0.0482289866,
-0.0290152784,
0.0033083323,
-0.0018526696,
0.0122222248,
0.0161253884,
0.0563567169,
-0.0248776432,
0.0052737468,
-0.0090585025,
-0.0070413826,
-0.0200692229,
-0.0123247197,
-0.0065028127,
0.0421748944,
0.0433278494,
0.0610420555,
0.0000021468,
-0.0492009372,
-0.0166338496,
-0.0224439837,
-0.0220989455,
0.050564006,
0.0415281542,
-0.0284641664,
0.0049359379,
0.0213556141,
-0.0527454428,
-0.0406898484,
0.0578274578,
0.0296168141,
0.045583237,
0.0841917396,
-0.0079982867,
-0.0472349226,
0.0394977443,
-0.0319079719,
-0.0384114161,
-0.0606113784,
0.0396151245,
0.0172686167,
0.0090240566,
0.0064337007,
-0.0133599704,
0.0352988355,
0.0309914239,
0.0003955448,
-0.0054597771,
0.0415912159,
-0.027374899,
-0.035956461,
-0.021004241,
0.0690623447,
-0.0538318865,
-0.048067227,
0.0015857409,
-0.0103535,
-0.0136581594,
0.0206882618,
-0.0434154086,
0.0422736555,
0.0364938341,
0.0455070809,
0.0326372162,
-0.0039374949,
0.0211073328,
0.0208557509,
-0.0747157559,
0.0455953889,
0.0222913083,
-0.0095991464,
-0.0099998647,
-0.0108409226,
-0.0558345765,
-0.0439751707,
0.0211537089,
0.0511228554,
-0.026812844,
0.0281907842,
-0.039787624,
-0.0149793001,
0.0042165224,
-0.0420828946,
0.0573257059,
0.0236305017,
-0.0075371317,
0.0516152568,
-0.0315497518,
0.0645484626,
-0.0228005312,
0.0199711453,
-0.0645414516,
-0.0173526816,
-0.0327269956,
-0.0181071125,
-0.081223771,
0.0266801044,
-0.038565021,
-0.0392823741,
-0.020916447,
0.01054761,
0.0437362008,
-0.0263418518,
0.0337970145,
-0.0141227385,
-0.0311184339,
-0.0346908905,
0.0002044913,
0.0397630073,
-0.0128078368,
0.0086045265,
-0.004326371,
-0.0765618086,
-0.0207629912,
0.0226167347,
0.0033049823,
-0.0241581555,
0.0208505969,
0.0531737097,
0.0037148795,
-0.0608948767,
-0.0350036435,
0.0105842222,
-0.021241542,
-0.0670119822,
-0.0052372837,
-0.0354589596,
0.0436681733,
0.0030106879,
-0.0028851496,
-0.0396063663,
0.010714964,
0.0100054815,
-0.0498338118,
0.049815964,
-0.0070200902,
0.0486457199,
0.009384173,
-0.0138508631,
0.0223312657,
0.057416454,
0.0498817936,
0.0364772826,
0.0234657805,
-0.0301344022,
0.003939637,
0.062959455,
0.0045700776,
-0.0124565661,
0.0033948743,
-0.0046522743,
0.0099596176,
0.012984952,
0.0159853213,
0.0871573761,
-0.0221640263,
-0.0131663196,
0.055737216,
0.0507622026,
0.0190329086,
0.0464140661,
0.0809237063,
0.0292900726,
0.0153640825,
-0.041787561,
-0.0390645526,
-0.0162289944,
-0.0400417894,
-0.0110800862,
-0.0014897629,
0.0671904013,
-0.0388298035,
-0.0470145121,
-0.0260688029,
-0.0065632351,
-0.0015389392,
-0.0019081256,
0.0692271516,
0.0135959452,
-0.0345339514,
0.0601975471,
0.0630334839,
-0.0379658453,
0.018197896,
-0.0775014982,
-0.0012282121,
0.029457204,
0.0339582488,
-0.0267915651,
-0.0212234613,
0.0193691049,
0.0066757225,
0.0411192663,
0.0416536182,
0.0167015828,
0.0053251414,
-0.0536675788,
0.0154357944,
0.0009586756,
0.0077798655,
0.0477944426,
0.0188766811,
-0.0006387273,
0.0253614206,
-0.0204537697,
-0.0449435003,
0.0587608144,
-0.0521683097,
-0.0148104606,
0.0194293242,
-0.010748568,
0.0526264943,
0.0005808669,
-0.0310584456,
-0.003032302,
0.0228941515,
-0.0407323986,
-0.0116420947,
0.0210128576,
-0.0798765942,
-0.0417067036,
0.0260239765,
0.0059917672,
0.029030323,
0.0170879643,
-0.0167669449,
-0.0383196287,
0.0279333293,
-0.0245325565,
0.0661036819,
-0.0566867366,
0.0453142487,
-0.0045195385,
0.0473453104,
-0.0432735384,
0.0405083671,
-0.0018402429,
-0.0227966849,
-0.003659985,
0.0191078689,
0.0244291462,
-0.023988504,
-0.047149159,
0.0052804719,
-0.0152846575,
0.0087363403,
0.0229810644,
0.0316061527,
-0.0246728454,
-0.0525990203,
-0.0848820359,
0.0200661849,
-0.0384045094,
0.0105543686,
0.0231267717,
0.0191236567,
-0.0188629813,
-0.0048504448,
-0.0188886989,
0.0281162132,
0.0462812036,
-0.0066263694,
0.0267080329,
0.0135101341,
-0.0468335561,
-0.0463548638,
-0.008391737,
-0.0078251306,
0.0623230189,
0.0326271318,
-0.0078180125,
-0.0584582873,
0.0704657584,
-0.0057880278,
0.0222406574,
0.0018907191,
-0.0624958724,
-0.0161914416,
-0.0395055264,
0.0667663142,
0.0511942208,
0.006291294,
0.0598323047,
0.0490733311,
-0.0259266049,
-0.0362490229,
-0.0006468905,
-0.0386083424,
-0.0455497243,
-0.0403040759,
-0.0152335893,
0.0273376182,
0.1032699421,
-0.0198442582,
-0.0212094858,
-0.0652222857,
0.011354398,
-0.0288424678,
-0.0169999152,
-0.002612828,
0.0075366832,
-0.0216063783,
0.0328623988,
-0.0221103169,
-0.0441764146,
0.0258032195,
-0.0594800599,
-0.0103721563,
-0.0462090299,
-0.0187370963,
-0.0634096414,
0.0767069086,
0.046015691,
0.0281735342,
0.0031054551,
-0.002710432,
-0.0249237008,
0.0367436111,
-0.032384865,
-0.018963363,
0.004006186,
-0.0631320104,
0.0391147695,
0.0094892327,
-0.026517868,
-0.0436082967,
-0.0601467416,
-0.0172759257,
0.0009185043,
0.0422635935,
-0.0222945604,
-0.0242181476,
0.0501424819,
-0.0029247424,
0.0130676255,
0.0096564665,
-0.0004306948,
-0.024711974,
0.0212658327,
0.052566085,
0.0176090039,
0.0240255985,
-0.0294706374,
0.0158219319,
0.0285795592,
0.0198920146,
0.0082286382,
-0.0529060885,
0.0130152563,
0.0287496448,
-0.0370824896,
-0.0176086482,
0.0235904399,
0.0459482223,
-0.0397295766,
-0.0196011756,
0.143534407,
0.0348203368,
-0.031412594,
0.0206402261,
0.027957581,
0.0353224427,
-0.0054025794,
0.0368920304,
-0.0670523569,
-0.0156980194,
-0.0184359774,
-0.0336064771,
0.0027578287,
-0.0436382741,
-0.0307834204,
-0.11047896,
0.0191472024,
0.0170943551,
-0.0232279338,
-0.0105987368,
-0.0233792737,
-0.0054306672,
-0.0198016465,
0.0182026047,
0.0091807153,
-0.0350866206,
-0.004899709,
0.0176749714,
-0.0175046623,
-0.0534381419,
0.0238182452,
-0.0571102835,
0.0611022972,
0.035175465,
0.0119641963,
-0.0089839259,
-0.0000337323,
0.0474347323,
0.0040999656,
0.0121067669,
-0.0122582698,
0.0104392925,
-0.011786839,
-0.0198305491,
0.0050179642,
0.0208777953,
-0.0643568262,
-0.0072109285,
0.0072077746,
0.0478146635,
-0.0089637665,
-0.0343161188,
0.0228637122,
0.0102058742,
-0.037423078,
0.0909225047,
0.0441951752,
-0.0548499674,
-0.0481822267,
0.0055221007,
-0.0083471714,
-0.0109235523,
-0.0391294844,
0.0289532579,
0.0133573869,
0.005554439,
-0.0611389577,
-0.0228476916,
0.0235048458,
0.018791955,
0.0092226453,
-0.0222197417,
0.0465890467,
0.0015307136,
-0.0101507306,
0.044586625,
-0.0515153967,
-0.0254619271,
-0.0756956935,
-0.0204703622,
0.0377928093,
-0.040019799,
-0.0304422192,
0.0019422561,
-0.0932076946,
-0.0579423793,
0.025984738,
0.0377523899,
0.0225074496,
0.0364140682,
-0.0183929875,
-0.0582656562,
0.0464618914,
0.0267261378,
-0.0372182466,
0.0195133071,
-0.0063748229,
0.0003948251,
-0.004285784,
0.0403430164,
-0.0191038381,
0.061637979,
0.0257254969,
0.0536031649,
-0.024600951,
-0.0565756373,
0.0360772125,
0.0319501683,
0.0105251912,
-0.0198180601,
0.0004354507,
-0.0375079177,
-0.0227098539,
-0.036991924,
0.0112057952,
-0.0576728992,
-0.0152827371,
0.0328631513,
0.0085106138,
-0.0234165024,
-0.013369808,
-0.0148855662,
0.0337194577,
-0.0023647228,
0.0072099511,
-0.0252494104,
-0.0019572193,
0.029823225,
-0.0033977521,
-0.0013493906,
0.025143059,
0.0014458351,
0.0256508198,
-0.026374625,
0.0720110312,
0.0058540949,
-0.0196847599,
-0.0367382169,
0.0469626375,
-0.062587522,
-0.0610200763,
-0.0188836847,
0.0363998935,
0.0736412108,
-0.0115294792,
0.0422974043,
-0.0396352001,
0.0109089147,
-0.0194731876,
0.0265786424,
0.0165701788,
-0.0161704514,
0.0113471895,
-0.0009204379,
-0.0367616378,
0.013640129,
0.0770144314,
0.032738205,
0.0350646116,
0.0287930276,
0.0116396369,
-0.0467041396,
-0.0216461085,
-0.0153079685,
-0.0150268748,
-0.0238991119,
0.057936281,
-0.0564523488,
-0.0514835641,
-0.0248206947,
-0.0055793384,
0.0175545644,
-0.0081274407,
0.0436136872,
0.0636225492,
-0.0160690676,
0.0158534572,
-0.0308776051,
0.000415315,
-0.0074085467,
-0.0141981784,
0.0041924263,
-6.836968283e-33,
-0.0353996977,
0.0068219253,
0.0324022248,
0.0072887344,
-0.0201669615,
-0.0091953129,
-0.0223166533,
0.0002001652,
-0.0157403108,
-0.0003496982,
-0.0255534705,
-0.0117557328,
0.0058049271,
0.0426345095,
-0.0259773005,
0.0087216506,
0.0532150827,
-0.0243497286,
0.0061542192,
0.0332545564,
0.0089752153,
0.041109927,
0.0376220904,
-0.0324954093,
-0.0471652076,
0.0035117951,
-0.0041894978,
0.0329751223,
0.0073911087,
0.0492084734,
-0.0553337932,
0.0162743144,
0.0390866362,
-0.0283932853,
-0.0124090211,
0.0129515082,
-0.0639558136,
0.0022503496,
0.0041414583,
0.0215108935,
0.0069545517,
-0.0216244459,
0.0529872254,
-0.0335244648,
-0.0393823422,
0.023504924,
0.0070639364,
-0.0164503809,
0.0154901892,
-0.0199971404,
-0.0613174587,
0.027085593,
-0.0071683754,
-0.0246410873,
0.0092114825,
0.0028815554,
-0.0381587781,
0.0398817658,
-0.0141943498,
0.0156590473,
0.0417582728,
0.028669022,
0.0387282968,
0.0213029608,
0.0046389033,
0.0505906343,
0.0133815249,
-0.0138761802,
-0.036992792,
-0.0066647925,
0.0530341566,
0.0381311178,
-0.001933489,
0.0200845879,
0.0356718227,
-0.0069585401,
-0.0703958422,
0.0028885358,
0.0161391068,
0.0365499705,
0.0368043408,
-0.009881665,
-0.0223321989,
-0.014258123,
-0.0371244103,
-0.0165761895,
-0.0204095468,
-0.0380714014,
0.0460554399,
0.0169912744,
-0.0105759501,
-0.0268559977,
0.0619347841,
-0.0746376812,
0.0006178167,
0.0173865762,
-0.0138212852,
0.004300477,
-0.0236251801,
0.0553532727,
-0.0765153021,
-0.0712960884,
0.0140324319,
-0.0175711252,
-0.0119791487,
-0.0055465722,
-0.0065712854,
0.0163683929,
-0.0454567075,
0.0004682084,
-0.0237243325,
-0.0057976632,
0.0154230529,
0.0256168973,
0.0393910557,
0.018775031,
-0.0161408056,
0.0439709537,
0.023658609,
-0.0076234839,
-0.0148067903,
-0.012122578,
0.0196850598,
0.0333935469,
-0.042748522,
0.0122773405,
-0.0432093926,
-0.0062328475,
0.0436361656,
-0.0646528006,
-0.0236993376,
-0.0105429133,
2.852e-7,
0.0576295555,
0.0609426498,
0.0219332036,
0.0029630428,
0.0213798955,
-0.0048691067,
0.0034174602,
0.0112882992,
-0.0099028032,
0.0250515752,
0.0270205997,
0.0638479739,
0.0363784283,
-0.0160208605,
-0.0665638372,
-0.0139803346,
-0.0756200179,
-0.0042481893,
-0.0525738187,
-0.0002393122,
0.0426528119,
0.1424327344,
-0.0129909925,
-0.0193975624,
-0.0076767667,
-0.0662626773,
0.0878906474,
-0.0550963357,
-0.0298078507,
0.0538573936,
0.0328312777,
0.027275661,
-0.0109614572,
0.0105860652,
0.0269147903,
0.0568189733,
0.0074374941,
0.0782775804,
0.0081263622,
0.0384300649,
0.0380638465,
0.0006607333,
-0.0122894542,
-0.0853775889,
0.0814624429,
-0.1081807315,
-0.027023958,
-0.0150627997,
-0.0160499513,
-0.0342263803,
-0.0248417929,
-0.0430598706,
-0.0019321785,
0.0305116158,
0.0299512222,
-0.0142591028,
0.0002570503,
-0.0768675134,
-0.0034428551,
0.0046335487,
-0.0489445254,
-0.0181424618,
-0.0502426252,
-0.044526767,
0.0432631969,
-0.0407583639,
0.0129845832,
2.961575824e-34,
0.0499161035,
-0.0258589052,
0.0066232583,
0.026259996,
0.0474291109,
0.0041780891,
0.0048765279,
0.026540447,
-0.0072000809,
-0.1368722469,
-0.0026852165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18190v1 | Assessing Language Model Deployment with Risk Cards | 2023-03-31T16:45:42 | 2023-03-31T16:45:42 | Leon Derczynski, Hannah Rose Kirk, Vidhisha Balachandran, Sachin Kumar, Yulia Tsvetkov, M. R. Leiser, Saif Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces RiskCards, a framework for structured assessment and
documentation of risks associated with an application of language models. As
with all language, text generated by language models can be harmful, or used to
bring about harm. Automating language generation adds both an element of scale
and also more subtle or emergent undesirable tendencies to the generated text.
Prior work establishes a wide variety of language model harms to many different
actors: existing taxonomies identify categories of harms posed by language
models; benchmarks establish automated tests of these harms; and documentation
standards for models, tasks and datasets encourage transparent reporting.
However, there is no risk-centric framework for documenting the complexity of a
landscape in which some risks are shared across models and contexts, while
others are specific, and where certain conditions may be required for risks to
manifest as harms. RiskCards address this methodological gap by providing a
generic framework for assessing the use of a given language model in a given
scenario. Each RiskCard makes clear the routes for the risk to manifest harm,
their placement in harm taxonomies, and example prompt-output pairs. While
RiskCards are designed to be open-source, dynamic and participatory, we present
a "starter set" of RiskCards taken from a broad literature survey, each of
which details a concrete risk presentation. Language model RiskCards initiate a
community knowledge base which permits the mapping of risks and harms to a
specific model or its application scenario, ultimately contributing to a
better, safer and shared understanding of the risk landscape. | [
0.0363147072,
0.0345513336,
-0.0292875357,
-0.0049322271,
-0.0203527026,
0.007498268,
0.0102610355,
0.0077524781,
0.0225188266,
-0.0625133961,
0.0300221555,
0.0032414554,
-0.0036997225,
0.0537941009,
0.0434488021,
-0.0597106777,
0.0540372543,
-0.0301287062,
0.0119712139,
0.0171600915,
0.0350770913,
0.0512008555,
0.0167303234,
0.0777416825,
-0.035379719,
-0.0272682998,
0.014479517,
0.0109631978,
0.0336783677,
-0.0402286872,
0.004769519,
0.0230776705,
-0.0113963205,
0.0153737245,
0.0000021975,
-0.0426725969,
0.0249040071,
0.0214804579,
-0.0172540955,
0.0074923062,
0.0419045687,
0.0154482769,
-0.0318606012,
0.0204417855,
0.0064258808,
0.0022065721,
0.0697962344,
-0.0319979042,
0.0550683625,
-0.0012291922,
-0.0236282665,
0.0159127992,
0.0192118697,
0.0064190724,
-0.0008781228,
0.0269586723,
0.0355613045,
0.0133787794,
0.0195468236,
0.0154130384,
0.035983175,
0.0555597208,
0.0066935793,
-0.0433129668,
-0.0373027883,
-0.0130346157,
-0.0081196772,
-0.0601396784,
0.0015227805,
0.0401461422,
-0.0064336755,
-0.0198354758,
0.0009393247,
-0.0310887694,
0.0108972453,
0.0121238036,
-0.0108316131,
0.0661546662,
0.0063521406,
-0.012594833,
0.0031610206,
0.0062275706,
0.0420534126,
0.0341020823,
0.0632639453,
0.0695681795,
0.0118782064,
0.0050518541,
-0.0098295081,
-0.031159794,
0.0162981022,
-0.0732411295,
0.0058135907,
0.0103122704,
-0.0061664036,
0.0670925453,
-0.0395182297,
-0.0459703356,
0.1015438288,
-0.0888566375,
0.029923724,
0.0234010704,
-0.009319324,
0.0110676,
0.0329100452,
-0.0079246862,
-0.0072414987,
0.0129919481,
0.0009133718,
0.0488327257,
0.0261670183,
-0.0560062006,
-0.0168009102,
-0.0309960172,
0.0113506541,
0.0339150541,
-0.0028825093,
0.0510959662,
-0.0526140817,
0.0245864633,
0.0086411443,
-0.0038642671,
-0.022353502,
-0.0200612675,
0.027422905,
-0.010770726,
-0.0264760852,
0.0470898375,
0.0231707655,
-0.0680291876,
0.0254343562,
-0.000228661,
-0.0584536307,
0.0002820981,
-0.022229353,
0.0950961858,
0.0408833846,
0.0265790541,
-0.0296112671,
-0.0483971015,
-0.0567669123,
0.0123362886,
-0.0428288765,
-0.0924490094,
-0.0314554349,
0.0275698099,
-0.016072724,
-0.0529223606,
0.0246553961,
0.0298985951,
-0.0467662588,
0.0278347805,
-0.0494703539,
0.0094681242,
0.0431785882,
0.0661518276,
0.0024839484,
0.0473530143,
0.0368133523,
0.0252903569,
0.0130182654,
-0.0388470329,
0.0209757891,
0.0564722754,
-0.0229378343,
0.0592336915,
-0.0287046637,
0.0001763469,
0.0230250936,
-0.0407798365,
-0.0304310061,
0.0681465566,
-0.0005349112,
0.0355997272,
0.0588169508,
0.0128310909,
-0.0517394245,
0.0079957284,
0.0268273838,
0.004550403,
-0.03513344,
-0.0701190531,
-0.0189565122,
-0.016393723,
-0.0411499552,
-0.0202644877,
-0.0255028978,
0.0234809518,
-0.00185351,
-0.01176167,
-0.03580698,
-0.0190974101,
0.0762833729,
0.0060681356,
-0.0120427841,
0.0359687246,
0.022927627,
0.0555749424,
0.0275621563,
-0.0599670671,
0.0085294209,
-0.0466114692,
-0.0052720685,
0.0885916129,
0.0518138595,
-0.0276716501,
-0.0203982834,
-0.0523875654,
-0.0072969799,
0.0147325406,
0.0228000749,
-0.0063557513,
-0.0217108577,
0.0002776491,
-0.0137455733,
0.0238921177,
0.009323244,
0.0043277466,
0.002692343,
0.0297161452,
0.0051200562,
-0.0150138894,
-0.0957891941,
0.022081567,
-0.027865313,
-0.0370290056,
-0.0661298186,
0.0128672486,
0.0036823745,
0.011505709,
-0.0196828041,
0.0170430318,
0.0220321007,
0.0152636673,
0.0021431055,
-0.002125696,
-0.0204855409,
0.096456252,
0.0619499646,
-0.0351572633,
0.005205085,
0.0198295824,
0.0034372956,
0.0096874749,
0.0363087766,
-0.0480383784,
-0.0208943672,
0.0057679606,
0.0080693783,
-0.0168474764,
-0.0324044451,
-0.0178743843,
0.0053671654,
-0.0180885587,
-0.0236081835,
0.0045237453,
-0.0351237655,
0.0116984546,
0.0042730751,
-0.0785308331,
0.01814734,
-0.0305919703,
0.0536573455,
0.0375965536,
0.032626912,
-0.0007187884,
0.0028002637,
-0.0462400503,
-0.0501750782,
-0.0098998509,
0.0144594954,
0.0313966423,
0.0100812968,
-0.0422219373,
0.0118983071,
-0.0099805687,
-0.0492247045,
0.0040370328,
0.0512506515,
0.0054370151,
0.0046685389,
-0.0291537065,
-0.0051705036,
-0.0099967001,
-0.019413732,
0.0405836031,
-0.0023495839,
-0.0454019904,
-0.0528574586,
0.0296072196,
-0.0457529463,
-0.0355984382,
0.0150264865,
-0.0464130491,
0.04081285,
0.009810593,
0.0249290653,
-0.0167305619,
0.0180004202,
0.0496268682,
0.0731988624,
-0.0050887773,
-0.0505873971,
-0.0363083109,
0.0280299671,
-0.0359836556,
0.0173475053,
-0.1041136086,
-0.0050318749,
0.0320341848,
0.0055994168,
0.0008307011,
-0.0387638174,
0.0207484979,
-0.0750857219,
-0.0454281345,
-0.016211547,
-0.1385441422,
-0.0444677584,
0.0321811065,
-0.0032756175,
-0.0669036359,
0.040569257,
-0.0253678076,
0.0187675189,
-0.0273721311,
-0.0367070213,
0.0240541305,
0.0637694448,
-0.0263261609,
0.0418196879,
0.0697984323,
-0.0233393852,
-0.0159837343,
-0.0288033616,
0.0275569223,
-0.0151550937,
0.0107699372,
-0.0633451864,
-0.0103877643,
-0.0052621476,
-0.0015236251,
-0.0130287632,
-0.0249968488,
-0.0062967311,
0.015917182,
0.0450354964,
0.0217386335,
0.036584124,
0.0241458025,
0.0612110049,
-0.0018105467,
0.0254253931,
0.0020384509,
0.0021293941,
-0.0344230793,
0.0158597846,
-0.0823194906,
0.0404321179,
0.0036515053,
0.0042580226,
0.0562685877,
-0.0217826366,
-0.0138051203,
-0.0201511011,
0.0003872267,
0.0417354032,
-0.0064932867,
-0.0362992547,
0.0534436852,
0.0275184102,
-0.0553623475,
-0.0057132221,
0.0121502653,
0.0213840939,
-0.019228423,
0.034791898,
-0.0312271342,
0.0242721271,
0.0109572737,
-0.0001956287,
-0.0772832632,
0.0310234688,
0.0186593812,
0.0170914959,
-0.0469434001,
-0.0206604302,
0.0153505662,
-0.0251644365,
0.0463286825,
0.0227441527,
-0.0530011728,
0.016354613,
-0.0142796198,
-0.0214545783,
0.022099413,
0.0343002379,
-0.005035812,
-0.0090122437,
-0.0316051617,
0.0367316268,
-0.0870558023,
-0.0264780279,
-0.0047700759,
0.0037662091,
0.0485450588,
0.0589363649,
-0.0262286644,
-0.0564639941,
-0.0049681412,
0.057178732,
0.0068304716,
-0.0344024189,
0.0080315294,
0.0033043094,
0.0203606635,
-0.0133340228,
-0.0275847372,
-0.0088691832,
-0.0049020564,
-0.0818501562,
0.0054473956,
0.0690125525,
-0.0078489846,
0.0031865919,
-0.0437351018,
0.0019806675,
0.0702698901,
0.043985974,
0.0344815515,
-0.0469896197,
0.0166785717,
-0.0622349828,
0.0253606495,
-0.0015832935,
-0.0562795699,
-0.0197669808,
0.000974722,
-0.0564994924,
-0.0311444867,
-0.0472016484,
-0.0018914811,
-0.0041234395,
0.0666033849,
-0.0249675941,
-0.0050736242,
-0.0069994628,
-0.0069201961,
0.0309062563,
-0.0079042027,
0.0230576601,
-0.0326433666,
0.0309569761,
-0.0338347442,
0.0408290625,
0.0128633939,
0.0623348355,
-0.0332477614,
-0.0820015594,
0.0507787056,
0.0825567469,
0.0286014192,
-0.0452334695,
0.0001288792,
-0.0757951215,
0.0520181805,
0.0152615597,
-0.0182785541,
-0.0158303939,
0.0347075053,
-0.0245352518,
0.0203674547,
-0.0025296048,
-0.0346689299,
-0.0125658726,
0.0043864981,
0.0089073768,
-0.0936678573,
-0.0181614272,
0.0047985893,
0.0420507714,
-0.023798449,
-0.0773609132,
0.017524112,
-0.0240036417,
-0.0295594856,
-0.0339826196,
-0.0501191467,
-0.0035619936,
0.0389170498,
-0.0039798371,
-0.0119646937,
0.0269383453,
0.0086284103,
-0.0524373725,
0.0256816838,
0.0186804105,
0.0704469606,
0.0291989408,
0.0648446009,
0.0574961938,
0.0057081641,
-0.0325866751,
0.0109964684,
-0.073095724,
0.0032172457,
0.0032166662,
0.0171385519,
-0.0103492206,
0.0011690762,
0.0342815518,
0.0339907221,
0.0275008902,
-0.0768945813,
-0.0151856374,
0.0042289053,
-0.0247785114,
0.0234465133,
0.0497266799,
-0.0572301336,
-0.0130775748,
-0.0361174308,
-0.0121138934,
-0.0029474844,
-0.08805383,
0.0264010672,
0.0097087976,
-0.0473006964,
-0.0363168381,
0.0360422134,
-0.0082735363,
0.0416266695,
0.0162614807,
-0.0164022911,
-0.0051686172,
-0.029112054,
0.0394602865,
0.0207609683,
-0.053570088,
-0.0371475331,
-0.0970622525,
-0.0795054212,
-0.0252517853,
0.0053910483,
-0.0051856283,
-0.005820985,
0.0153840482,
0.0176021177,
0.0518778674,
-0.0079238843,
-0.0313234478,
0.033512067,
-0.0260119978,
-0.0048108064,
-0.0033257818,
-5.982520541e-33,
-0.0008863742,
-0.0244694725,
-0.0095139965,
-0.0084606726,
0.0187822096,
0.0120106563,
-0.0188674238,
0.0594219156,
-0.0108905295,
0.0253128987,
0.0207442492,
-0.0240636859,
0.0001913749,
-0.0057738489,
0.0144264502,
-0.0029634868,
-0.0036017362,
0.005627173,
-0.0171483643,
0.0064132949,
0.0570022613,
-0.030321816,
0.0486619323,
-0.101805605,
0.0788003132,
-0.0096318284,
-0.0590086468,
-0.0129769845,
-0.0220296271,
0.0308410916,
0.0130923335,
0.0509090684,
-0.0114232199,
-0.0276921224,
-0.0073818848,
0.056203872,
0.0205404963,
-0.0112483967,
0.0457847565,
-0.0129986294,
0.0076618595,
-0.0643390343,
0.0280670542,
-0.015182592,
-0.0208827034,
0.0287984479,
0.001859401,
-0.0343800597,
-0.0338177159,
-0.0020057808,
-0.0405191742,
0.0008985053,
-0.0295887962,
0.015889436,
-0.0186662115,
0.0569514781,
0.0070380806,
-0.0085996827,
-0.0582236052,
0.0306034051,
0.0448280796,
-0.0248135366,
0.0961269885,
-0.0076146522,
-0.0271555856,
0.0494936034,
-0.0512425564,
0.0374450497,
0.0019242995,
0.0012946043,
0.0205105506,
0.0240113102,
0.0359093025,
0.0463973098,
-0.0427797213,
-0.0369577035,
-0.0404481553,
0.0204853602,
-0.0102765029,
0.0409924611,
0.0139945131,
-0.0159660429,
-0.0692663193,
-0.0602842569,
-0.0219615269,
-0.023054244,
-0.0114074433,
-0.0430845954,
0.0314245149,
-0.053647846,
-0.0344390534,
0.0042649121,
-0.0160093699,
-0.0081770858,
-0.0081063155,
0.0073142215,
0.0137953619,
-0.0247340314,
0.00500509,
0.0688132495,
-0.0209196191,
0.0242863856,
0.0019079878,
-0.0087166848,
0.0349184349,
0.0378694013,
0.0350691192,
0.0261921417,
-0.0542022176,
0.0281057805,
0.0080200639,
0.0660235062,
0.0186949726,
0.0279851966,
0.0278730113,
-0.0204175711,
0.021727819,
-0.0100999568,
0.0814872086,
-0.0193777867,
0.0007612093,
0.013889865,
-0.0513511635,
0.0099656191,
-0.0153850578,
0.0013411624,
-0.0480386429,
0.0648186579,
0.1141431406,
-0.0247599315,
-0.0073382561,
-0.0212478694,
2.807e-7,
0.0739086345,
0.01949865,
0.0104508307,
0.0138101028,
0.0182320662,
0.0408455767,
0.0311207436,
0.0427046083,
0.0184682868,
0.0168135259,
-0.0017918289,
-0.0103562046,
0.0380223766,
0.0756865963,
-0.0199418925,
0.0158126485,
-0.0806011707,
0.0354906768,
-0.0606495515,
0.0042168456,
0.0443342105,
0.0223287046,
-0.0099884188,
-0.0162991527,
-0.054815203,
-0.0338110924,
-0.020701427,
-0.070764035,
0.0307079628,
-0.0028697297,
0.0281958114,
0.0434331484,
0.0412154756,
0.0053012804,
-0.0039650467,
-0.0564006679,
-0.0296103843,
0.0246287212,
-0.0042745876,
0.0023030757,
-0.0073309471,
-0.0780034214,
0.0179299116,
-0.108021155,
0.0278188493,
0.0138234682,
0.0157016609,
-0.0081165116,
-0.0527413487,
0.0000701034,
0.0343058892,
-0.0574981906,
-0.0225725546,
-0.0000030751,
0.0014130542,
0.005416499,
-0.0009937716,
-0.0331178941,
-0.0378962345,
-0.0016392816,
0.0167610962,
-0.0546314307,
-0.0188873895,
0.0303709563,
-0.0514395088,
-0.0526108667,
0.0483990088,
2.658590318e-34,
-0.0128574539,
-0.0266827885,
0.0067757568,
-0.0271178577,
0.0185291953,
0.0406751446,
-0.0077246432,
0.0081531182,
-0.0146739194,
0.000789707,
-0.0314691104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00025v1 | Demo Alleviate: Demonstrating Artificial Intelligence Enabled Virtual Assistance for Telehealth: The Mental Health Case | 2023-03-31T16:41:15 | 2023-03-31T16:41:15 | Kaushik Roy, Vedant Khandelwal, Raxit Goswami, Nathan Dolbir, Jinendra Malekar, Amit Sheth | cs.CL | cs.CL | After the pandemic, artificial intelligence (AI) powered support for mental
health care has become increasingly important. The breadth and complexity of
significant challenges required to provide adequate care involve: (a)
Personalized patient understanding, (b) Safety-constrained and medically
validated chatbot patient interactions, and (c) Support for continued
feedback-based refinements in design using chatbot-patient interactions. We
propose Alleviate, a chatbot designed to assist patients suffering from mental
health challenges with personalized care and assist clinicians with
understanding their patients better. Alleviate draws from an array of publicly
available clinically valid mental-health texts and databases, allowing
Alleviate to make medically sound and informed decisions. In addition,
Alleviate's modular design and explainable decision-making lends itself to
robust and continued feedback-based refinements to its design. In this paper,
we explain the different modules of Alleviate and submit a short video
demonstrating Alleviate's capabilities to help patients and clinicians
understand each other better to facilitate optimal care strategies. | [
0.0645861104,
-0.0161739625,
-0.0345197134,
-0.031412404,
-0.014492264,
0.0169810001,
0.0026670918,
0.0196687691,
0.0830062628,
0.0156603251,
0.0321812332,
0.0122827403,
-0.0071299584,
0.0563961789,
-0.0105983689,
-0.0944928378,
0.0075574387,
0.0317008384,
0.0606663004,
0.0352611765,
0.0355131961,
0.0127504738,
-0.0901846215,
0.0776103288,
-0.0115283094,
-0.0102749905,
-0.0034733817,
0.0184535552,
0.0312928893,
-0.0634351075,
-0.0202342682,
0.0104730651,
-0.0070048701,
-0.0180929713,
0.0000021645,
-0.0062713404,
-0.0116432123,
0.0133182164,
-0.0637138337,
-0.1041039377,
0.0274003297,
-0.0502002202,
-0.0008595413,
0.0418065339,
-0.016587548,
0.0023873223,
0.0570059493,
0.069324635,
0.0685265884,
0.0372059532,
-0.0253997035,
0.0610826686,
0.0014866336,
0.0257416852,
0.0040717102,
-0.0211532898,
0.017140476,
0.0027414332,
0.0773438066,
-0.0357155055,
-0.0031284571,
0.0272809081,
-0.01443897,
0.0134054208,
-0.0094705252,
0.0226361267,
-0.0330471881,
-0.0806311145,
-0.0348530561,
0.0568586327,
0.0499468073,
0.0355005898,
0.0245686006,
0.0057571358,
0.020343205,
0.0076747667,
-0.0225960668,
-0.0369547382,
-0.0408651195,
-0.0082657412,
-0.0226694476,
0.0031706088,
0.0137327863,
-0.0003909506,
0.0365599245,
0.0163122136,
0.0028388088,
-0.0128941396,
-0.0079877013,
-0.021879049,
-0.0134923374,
-0.0559381172,
0.0263722874,
0.0707339346,
-0.0869441181,
-0.0058030337,
0.000177832,
-0.0498079881,
-0.0136190131,
0.0007185502,
0.0085653383,
0.0518737324,
-0.0043681897,
-0.0197451822,
0.0932477489,
0.00496834,
0.0213933066,
0.0081768353,
-0.0130641637,
0.0141732525,
-0.0633934513,
0.0046878969,
-0.0410342254,
0.0248212162,
0.0236913599,
-0.0105684279,
-0.0529341176,
0.0381026044,
-0.0288583748,
0.0262861867,
0.0031807518,
0.0194949973,
-0.0008594613,
0.0193568431,
-0.0197540578,
-0.0097446805,
-0.0689565465,
0.0076660211,
0.0244792812,
-0.0761256143,
0.0142507749,
-0.0075856065,
0.0048352098,
-0.0125354603,
0.0006401914,
0.0413978398,
0.0124424398,
-0.0336230733,
0.0078448039,
-0.0210829005,
-0.0132675227,
-0.0019006974,
0.0288168639,
-0.0095877238,
0.0560573637,
-0.0118175,
-0.0014351618,
-0.0144145181,
0.0298417918,
-0.0198196303,
-0.0534127839,
0.0658751875,
-0.0867025033,
0.0097716348,
0.0436428785,
0.0475462526,
-0.0273988862,
-0.0017317191,
-0.0219582431,
0.0047175162,
0.0454070754,
-0.0334444717,
0.0455900617,
-0.0195265952,
-0.0052991454,
-0.0701175258,
0.0388621166,
-0.0135955838,
-0.0550335348,
0.0729597434,
-0.0728861988,
0.016958328,
-0.0303080324,
0.0453236774,
0.035195291,
0.0669151545,
0.0216176622,
0.0337617919,
0.0044892179,
0.0411109813,
0.0063736239,
-0.0185604449,
-0.0308878683,
0.0215719994,
-0.0207427703,
-0.037924055,
-0.0080330381,
-0.0282154549,
-0.04641743,
-0.0774322674,
-0.0226061102,
-0.0450420268,
-0.0097300988,
0.0302962717,
-0.005278246,
-0.033528991,
0.0269792993,
0.0255256481,
0.036221765,
-0.0026299362,
-0.0580298193,
-0.0582582355,
0.0241211802,
0.1248248592,
0.0347043015,
-0.0510777682,
-0.0593758933,
-0.0122100189,
-0.0209217649,
0.0242293347,
0.0262716319,
0.0011874788,
0.0197941661,
-0.0100457873,
-0.0151629653,
0.0551292636,
0.0060947444,
-0.0083936676,
-0.0223753881,
0.0182249881,
-0.0654484332,
0.0477377512,
0.013934711,
0.0364450589,
-0.0078499122,
-0.0069255396,
-0.0291650835,
-0.0019267157,
0.0653987154,
0.0554270111,
0.0175282564,
0.010643064,
0.0387127772,
-0.0219849423,
-0.0523513108,
0.0355516672,
-0.002333632,
0.0222085863,
0.0249860231,
-0.0396927185,
0.0102974046,
0.0558058806,
-0.0175456051,
-0.0190409087,
0.0062843929,
-0.0779857785,
0.0376349501,
-0.0053390367,
0.0058317618,
0.0096722161,
0.0123190209,
0.0004738216,
-0.0157711599,
-0.0230312906,
-0.0054803323,
-0.0206109192,
-0.0272961948,
-0.0367152728,
-0.0307620075,
0.0240574628,
-0.0093261683,
-0.0309442673,
-0.0029604333,
-0.0144156637,
0.0175398234,
-0.0300728921,
0.0287905671,
-0.1605197489,
-0.0071201534,
0.0115492903,
-0.0516522452,
0.0181153435,
0.0035132661,
-0.0109472563,
-0.056453716,
-0.0199505314,
0.0373298675,
0.0337945782,
0.0001602551,
0.03762725,
0.0413024351,
-0.034125302,
-0.0309579093,
0.0029037967,
-0.0285792444,
0.0010478746,
0.0043048891,
-0.0418349281,
-0.0340070352,
-0.0443007722,
-0.0679965094,
0.016107453,
-0.0080280583,
-0.0519909821,
0.0215113405,
-0.0149404546,
-0.0039722077,
0.0109678069,
0.0312988348,
0.034505289,
0.0473779812,
0.0286366325,
-0.0149237094,
0.0102378707,
-0.0166589487,
-0.0042069061,
-0.0221016556,
-0.0504218154,
0.0078623528,
0.0211609378,
0.0086398693,
0.0404154062,
-0.0573155358,
0.0253584255,
0.0183943883,
0.0064034848,
-0.0039497772,
0.0042385305,
-0.0057612713,
0.0237710457,
-0.0094309412,
-0.0260858908,
0.0736068264,
0.0096119856,
-0.0047430745,
-0.0509674698,
-0.0560802929,
-0.0236879531,
-0.007093647,
-0.0373688824,
0.0376835242,
0.0211757794,
-0.0040118522,
0.0305663161,
-0.0441782288,
-0.0364312753,
-0.0432856306,
-0.0282874536,
-0.0475349762,
-0.009185724,
0.0308255684,
-0.0268743392,
-0.0574053749,
-0.0183641855,
-0.0700242668,
-0.0252017137,
0.0381335206,
0.0003762819,
-0.0206916183,
-0.0365151055,
0.0484906286,
0.034161713,
0.0360148773,
-0.0361296907,
0.0105668278,
-0.066276215,
0.0215056129,
0.0292025059,
0.0198781155,
0.0304480325,
0.0517439246,
0.0378500558,
-0.0122606568,
0.0020115243,
0.0092944745,
0.0061611133,
-0.0143979173,
-0.0182479005,
0.010838178,
0.0312795229,
0.0398541316,
-0.0089530116,
-0.0182723105,
0.0874735489,
0.0143915471,
-0.0562131405,
0.0425006188,
-0.0773056671,
-0.0575772412,
-0.0291374046,
0.027693091,
-0.0239302609,
-0.0227630548,
-0.0281234086,
0.0567400269,
-0.0368903875,
-0.0310123209,
-0.000751025,
-0.0148925986,
0.0235319547,
-0.0140861943,
-0.0195646547,
-0.0227582697,
0.0032910286,
0.0226476695,
-0.0090402644,
-0.0016273789,
-0.0172294807,
-0.0011109284,
-0.02124165,
-0.0080651436,
-0.055486843,
-0.0240380205,
0.0483881533,
-0.0082143834,
0.0905177519,
0.0129700145,
0.0714140385,
0.0094933687,
-0.0237491373,
-0.0466355197,
0.0716992617,
0.0337528698,
-0.0153947612,
0.0741277114,
0.0121203335,
0.0194216277,
-0.0610853359,
0.0389450751,
-0.0258097555,
-0.0103822434,
0.0233484209,
0.0524223931,
-0.0643087253,
-0.0074820062,
-0.0492275916,
0.0622365326,
0.0488733202,
0.0240887068,
0.0073206406,
-0.0393487178,
-0.0368108973,
0.0089432728,
0.0138041936,
0.0242096074,
-0.0242489185,
-0.0020512864,
-0.0273032468,
-0.053987395,
-0.0859534889,
-0.0377429686,
0.0184586011,
0.0001716694,
0.0039233896,
-0.0356012322,
0.0447988771,
0.0640864,
-0.0212080739,
0.0171789639,
0.0256773457,
-0.0064421063,
-0.0511222221,
0.0045362036,
-0.0174862165,
-0.0531912334,
0.0251339041,
0.0136874821,
0.0273692738,
0.0140672987,
0.0580191314,
0.0613863878,
0.0210383367,
-0.0004532966,
-0.0117047634,
-0.0153178284,
-0.0103104571,
0.0169743542,
-0.0633075014,
-0.0318421125,
0.0332199372,
0.0605483428,
-0.0075042569,
0.0258622076,
-0.0265999008,
0.0592187867,
-0.0280977525,
-0.0110808713,
-0.0128708091,
0.0105432579,
0.0116151115,
0.0559164993,
-0.00540224,
-0.0005055194,
-0.0383746773,
0.0304060634,
-0.0030005372,
-0.0351873972,
0.020567568,
-0.0328328125,
0.0020234019,
-0.0286773834,
-0.0308172014,
0.0314248465,
0.006767822,
-0.0797440335,
-0.0620101094,
-0.01053809,
0.0013528902,
-0.0118103912,
0.019270584,
-0.0135156503,
-0.0066205086,
0.0213938076,
0.0658285171,
-0.016478952,
0.0367305912,
-0.0016453541,
0.0903744698,
-0.0180806257,
-0.0045934068,
0.0044490364,
0.0811667815,
-0.0632590204,
-0.1401993632,
0.0260373,
0.0179729667,
0.0356037132,
0.0558525398,
0.0179590844,
-0.017934544,
0.0072065899,
-0.0148676699,
0.0329929926,
-0.0061952253,
-0.0012122145,
-0.0307037607,
0.0116228675,
-0.0187801346,
-0.0261636358,
0.0297975186,
-0.0683288053,
0.013385647,
-0.004778232,
-0.0341385193,
-0.0357824154,
-0.0031158177,
0.0045210728,
0.0295262318,
-0.0313955285,
-0.0211867411,
-0.0262866504,
-0.032274615,
0.0272602662,
-0.0054030987,
-0.0406885035,
-0.0392428897,
0.0651647747,
-0.005869458,
0.0078886747,
-0.025766762,
-0.0219959412,
0.0266333036,
-0.0518276729,
0.0239059757,
-0.0146879256,
-5.575682314e-33,
0.0123596266,
-0.0228797719,
0.0120455828,
-0.0039600199,
0.0125807663,
-0.0012835579,
-0.029498022,
0.0312298741,
-0.0217582081,
0.0138376011,
0.0134914927,
0.0805765763,
-0.0025182725,
0.0042535518,
0.0202872828,
-0.0196888596,
0.0167859085,
0.0100251185,
-0.0153591735,
0.0347605832,
-0.0195406955,
0.0574191883,
0.0100839557,
-0.093741104,
0.0154400766,
0.002512608,
-0.0011502994,
0.02344485,
0.0117643094,
0.0197944473,
-0.0197587237,
0.0291959848,
0.0405309871,
0.0371810198,
0.0106891226,
0.0384104103,
-0.0316972919,
-0.0572863929,
-0.0111443782,
-0.0341712981,
-0.1058637202,
-0.0153879505,
0.0121017927,
-0.0196999777,
-0.0219546631,
-0.0069406233,
0.0331514366,
-0.0316585302,
0.0225791875,
0.0184213296,
0.003821603,
-0.0005691681,
-0.02875093,
-0.0325930268,
-0.0116407759,
0.0555336066,
-0.0482474715,
0.0131332818,
-0.0015813706,
0.012950385,
-0.0179546922,
-0.0466068499,
0.0003335624,
-0.0661204979,
-0.0214808527,
0.0103913927,
-0.0075942688,
-0.0233929288,
-0.0729688928,
0.0120109683,
-0.0319209248,
0.0635014549,
0.076890707,
0.0107674543,
-0.0122156357,
-0.0229217745,
-0.0375897102,
0.0339890607,
-0.0010676548,
0.0477308743,
0.0110878358,
0.0196282435,
-0.0729535967,
0.0201671235,
-0.000885025,
-0.0176372454,
-0.0173608977,
-0.0383171774,
0.0165509637,
-0.0104820114,
-0.0217916872,
-0.0440902337,
-0.0469061024,
-0.0336234048,
0.0631417632,
-0.027817741,
0.0485637523,
-0.0058025355,
0.0118692238,
-0.0348932482,
0.0068337191,
-0.0119505208,
0.0285587627,
0.0149292676,
0.0752245113,
0.0068097292,
0.0128459977,
-0.006474155,
0.031612996,
-0.025135288,
0.0204555448,
0.0558636747,
0.0212085042,
0.0119237471,
-0.0113622397,
0.0301917251,
-0.0318871289,
0.0398945883,
0.0177956149,
0.039201308,
-0.0679069012,
-0.0173592735,
-0.0167539846,
-0.0152700916,
-0.0191583838,
-0.0345837027,
-0.0670216829,
0.0410330296,
0.0342352092,
-0.0525839441,
-0.0201493464,
-0.0217937063,
2.918e-7,
0.0206716917,
0.0514720455,
0.0267221034,
0.0135508617,
0.0258819535,
0.0212223362,
0.0133501207,
0.0304763298,
-0.0191347729,
-0.0213486049,
0.0523331128,
0.0366027281,
0.0486845076,
0.0320918337,
0.0274358653,
-0.0959989801,
-0.0179479793,
-0.0302123092,
-0.0523517728,
0.020927608,
0.1047857329,
0.0198366307,
0.0182293076,
-0.0229198243,
0.0235158242,
0.0284113195,
-0.008564801,
-0.0534379669,
0.0348711163,
0.0214083921,
0.0130291507,
0.0157157108,
0.0262820497,
0.0019657493,
-0.0077817282,
-0.0332278684,
-0.0231148247,
0.0822906643,
-0.0778449327,
-0.0141959423,
0.0103300167,
0.034027297,
0.0250739977,
-0.0145551739,
0.0279173199,
-0.0676128268,
-0.0684551448,
0.0083941706,
-0.0004420627,
-0.02299124,
0.0341647528,
-0.0267412346,
-0.0259454865,
0.0478118062,
0.0019010192,
0.0165585913,
0.0190518554,
-0.0494363829,
0.0245704781,
0.0281946473,
-0.0609306023,
-0.0053545428,
0.0067302892,
-0.0445820168,
-0.008326727,
-0.0667287111,
0.016559042,
2.019506871e-34,
-0.0211403482,
0.0537349358,
0.0035389289,
0.0280595534,
0.0503356457,
0.0290229693,
0.0378010273,
0.0394900404,
0.0336955041,
-0.0198513027,
-0.0170668568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01008v2 | Self-Supervised Multimodal Learning: A Survey | 2023-03-31T16:11:56 | 2023-08-04T21:17:28 | Yongshuo Zong, Oisin Mac Aodha, Timothy Hospedales | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multimodal learning, which aims to understand and analyze information from
multiple modalities, has achieved substantial progress in the supervised regime
in recent years. However, the heavy dependence on data paired with expensive
human annotations impedes scaling up models. Meanwhile, given the availability
of large-scale unannotated data in the wild, self-supervised learning has
become an attractive strategy to alleviate the annotation bottleneck. Building
on these two directions, self-supervised multimodal learning (SSML) provides
ways to learn from raw multimodal data. In this survey, we provide a
comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art in SSML, in which we elucidate
three major challenges intrinsic to self-supervised learning with multimodal
data: (1) learning representations from multimodal data without labels, (2)
fusion of different modalities, and (3) learning with unaligned data. We then
detail existing solutions to these challenges. Specifically, we consider (1)
objectives for learning from multimodal unlabeled data via self-supervision,
(2) model architectures from the perspective of different multimodal fusion
strategies, and (3) pair-free learning strategies for coarse-grained and
fine-grained alignment. We also review real-world applications of SSML
algorithms in diverse fields such as healthcare, remote sensing, and machine
translation. Finally, we discuss challenges and future directions for SSML. A
collection of related resources can be found at:
https://github.com/ys-zong/awesome-self-supervised-multimodal-learning. | [
-0.024868438,
0.0647715181,
0.0375749283,
0.030871775,
-0.0072671999,
-0.0000120479,
0.0277631655,
-0.045559261,
-0.0003504039,
-0.0553592145,
-0.0795883164,
0.0252770204,
0.0094940234,
0.0150498096,
0.0510709099,
-0.0469689369,
0.0238321144,
0.0163173694,
-0.0192101449,
-0.0135437576,
0.0234001596,
0.0042533525,
-0.0499249063,
0.0142105268,
-0.0861541778,
0.0049747364,
-0.0194996409,
0.0457668416,
0.0343940742,
-0.0514655747,
0.003540905,
0.040082071,
0.0390456729,
0.0438848622,
0.0000021399,
-0.0209703092,
-0.0223692413,
-0.0005569452,
0.0301842857,
-0.0328459181,
0.0360174067,
-0.0431467295,
0.0090474449,
-0.0148308445,
-0.0380325131,
-0.045607727,
0.0965443626,
0.037973661,
0.0705054849,
0.0392256118,
-0.0313442759,
-0.0266444385,
0.0020919854,
-0.0248407386,
0.0213912502,
-0.0211364292,
-0.0126227019,
-0.0024393871,
-0.0428838097,
0.0075669507,
-0.0417038985,
0.0407541245,
-0.0242790878,
0.0051620305,
0.0432573035,
0.043102473,
-0.0146288304,
-0.049185209,
-0.0314137973,
0.0862202346,
-0.0168758221,
0.0039193812,
0.0136874188,
-0.008663604,
0.0098831486,
0.028960688,
-0.0225038063,
-0.0082557471,
0.0024476999,
0.0128796827,
-0.0759102106,
0.0264188573,
0.0315764286,
-0.0195821226,
-0.0192058962,
0.0032444748,
-0.0171253514,
0.049386926,
-0.0074326084,
-0.0009440912,
-0.002235496,
0.0002266042,
-0.0316980481,
0.0123062367,
0.0049080998,
-0.0270551145,
-0.0330863483,
-0.0108123384,
0.0205088537,
-0.0036680072,
0.0314483419,
0.0215394255,
-0.0540490523,
0.0709467456,
-0.0067778104,
-0.0621955991,
-0.0537100323,
0.083598882,
-0.0208825748,
-0.0037022436,
-0.0528923571,
0.0310509093,
-0.0052434718,
-0.0013404805,
0.0051043006,
-0.0065232846,
-0.0391699485,
-0.0034925519,
0.0032726754,
0.0046472694,
-0.0455152765,
0.0392991938,
-0.0551319122,
-0.0065810271,
-0.0149418656,
0.0642328262,
-0.0032037825,
0.0312658027,
0.0082569448,
-0.0123375636,
0.0188161004,
0.0305076689,
0.0038412877,
-0.0327380449,
0.0025509922,
0.0676776022,
-0.0307525638,
-0.0154187754,
-0.0167343356,
-0.0240517557,
-0.0439237952,
-0.0421599522,
0.0483613051,
-0.0386994742,
0.0469318256,
-0.008546575,
0.0169065967,
-0.0304447748,
0.0131054251,
-0.0329360813,
0.0215312988,
0.1479486078,
-0.0289487485,
-0.0095063541,
0.0552992374,
-0.0101067405,
-0.0040000821,
0.0514943078,
0.0266396515,
0.0320581347,
0.0090786824,
-0.0322296843,
0.0042739664,
-0.000940874,
0.0257567521,
0.0221737791,
-0.0173315573,
-0.0342716798,
0.0434063524,
0.0471675359,
0.0411002934,
-0.0094929896,
0.0141561739,
-0.0273558721,
0.0378210172,
0.005004189,
0.0160578545,
0.0014830481,
0.0023071924,
-0.0184399672,
0.0196271576,
0.0000107675,
-0.0484507345,
0.0854643285,
-0.0106181959,
-0.0160345975,
0.063377589,
0.0598244481,
-0.0333299935,
-0.0566058569,
0.0120734842,
-0.0323148333,
-0.0064278236,
-0.0088914447,
0.0532022417,
-0.0155013883,
0.009818011,
-0.0167673044,
0.0456706844,
-0.0324352831,
-0.0053426316,
0.0190281104,
-0.0202699415,
-0.0023855481,
0.0078488439,
-0.0433579721,
-0.0480500571,
-0.0100632384,
0.0221679676,
0.0071322252,
0.0055654789,
0.0191147421,
0.0787353292,
-0.0469592847,
-0.0897948816,
-0.0125498986,
-0.003941712,
-0.0078222919,
-0.0115738129,
-0.0352750085,
-0.0087380363,
-0.0461621545,
0.0376585349,
0.0428069681,
0.00492239,
-0.0136308996,
0.0130085321,
0.0487781279,
0.053072609,
0.0057407962,
0.0070608691,
-0.0048094322,
0.0307113528,
-0.0519704707,
-0.0112432456,
0.0031653151,
-0.0569451116,
-0.0284480285,
0.0274788924,
-0.0542120859,
-0.0163898878,
0.0063087153,
-0.0452328175,
-0.06193804,
0.000795783,
-0.0107488818,
-0.0375609286,
-0.0170785598,
-0.0239699967,
0.0493762046,
0.0156847127,
-0.0214843228,
0.015649803,
-0.0316504352,
-0.0308320355,
-0.0463710539,
-0.000643665,
0.0311002769,
0.0310859345,
-0.0484655909,
-0.0054162755,
0.0002234674,
0.0291556325,
0.0358015262,
-0.0416642465,
-0.0219606496,
0.0251625627,
-0.0953067541,
0.0008684856,
0.0204049814,
-0.0172427855,
0.0045478144,
0.0175275914,
0.009807393,
-0.0582576096,
-0.034349367,
0.0251840036,
-0.0092756404,
0.0083249174,
0.0317654982,
0.0319216251,
0.0583030991,
-0.0321407765,
0.0067448523,
-0.0299649406,
0.0002250647,
0.0020528492,
-0.0251023192,
0.0047980109,
-0.0644509867,
-0.0738398731,
0.0467498526,
-0.0041593378,
-0.0328157246,
0.0271759909,
-0.0470510162,
0.0296988767,
0.0366379023,
0.0081400611,
-0.0024542455,
0.037088152,
-0.0265020709,
-0.0154645983,
0.0158921573,
-0.0119816698,
0.0117171369,
0.0236316361,
0.0208291635,
-0.0442340672,
0.0441485383,
0.0098883482,
0.0017465997,
-0.0170798656,
0.0134742726,
0.0443018228,
-0.0480829999,
-0.0375254713,
0.0783186778,
-0.0057804422,
-0.0001484783,
-0.0366489552,
-0.072683908,
0.0340773277,
-0.0100485114,
-0.0104841385,
0.010284734,
0.0206314195,
-0.0041154106,
0.030750839,
-0.0016635848,
0.0627453029,
0.0017845422,
0.0042367731,
-0.0210282821,
-0.0318128765,
0.0475485139,
-0.0084787095,
0.0328164361,
-0.0283326115,
0.0122248204,
-0.0145495841,
-0.0393097959,
-0.0211997684,
-0.0516938791,
-0.0158996154,
-0.0378547907,
-0.0641140118,
0.0059162164,
-0.0457591191,
-0.0208624639,
0.0246264543,
0.0471511036,
0.0016622022,
-0.0252453387,
-0.0217010882,
0.070128873,
-0.0122322375,
0.0491212904,
-0.0481376611,
-0.0310905334,
-0.0093007516,
0.032083001,
0.0323370285,
0.0036852979,
-0.0799483135,
0.0106812343,
-0.0048860391,
0.044366166,
0.0176257491,
0.0104712918,
0.0672640651,
-0.0098366905,
0.0388882048,
0.03207279,
-0.0099930679,
-0.0376656204,
-0.0209879465,
0.0219878405,
-0.008934089,
0.0315170921,
-0.0149698462,
-0.0399982333,
-0.0920206904,
-0.0136097893,
-0.0076404512,
0.0516356528,
-0.0005036838,
0.0048792879,
-0.0359526724,
0.0210153572,
0.0414935313,
-0.0779668018,
-0.0339404829,
-0.0169003457,
0.0208822265,
-0.0561430529,
-0.0447991975,
-0.0253187343,
-0.0195237435,
-0.0216453411,
0.0172760542,
0.0034859029,
-0.0540171824,
-0.0264820009,
-0.0545949861,
0.0383902043,
0.0363872759,
0.0236611422,
-0.026138667,
-0.050844796,
0.0447656699,
0.0034589781,
-0.0047124363,
-0.0183537342,
0.0674244091,
-0.0375822335,
-0.0304193012,
0.0204785913,
0.0668937042,
-0.0067434129,
0.0250091683,
-0.0355309844,
0.0535759926,
-0.0439350642,
0.0570376739,
-0.0500864871,
-0.0038878266,
0.0214879252,
-0.0110147847,
-0.052922029,
-0.0274567846,
-0.0122139892,
0.025975829,
0.0447551459,
0.040246509,
-0.0043878229,
0.02442367,
-0.0212960616,
-0.0381276496,
-0.052793406,
0.0025050535,
0.0239625536,
0.0461508222,
0.0007107297,
-0.0082377251,
-0.0308588557,
0.0269298796,
-0.0508726425,
0.0787030309,
-0.0244581364,
-0.0093327044,
-0.0216288548,
-0.0137555227,
0.0471136458,
-0.044272054,
0.0510502905,
0.0247734785,
-0.0714147687,
-0.0396108553,
-0.0288185831,
0.072096169,
0.000766373,
0.0460730344,
0.0165070966,
0.0107896496,
0.035377346,
0.0964160934,
-0.0474323891,
0.0046959524,
0.0279011969,
0.0160018262,
-0.0233744159,
-0.0025203875,
-0.0058638989,
0.0167525094,
-0.0212636255,
-0.026629271,
-0.0314681269,
-0.0228165202,
0.0366024226,
-0.0240476262,
0.0998236015,
-0.054060474,
0.0397812389,
-0.0475804694,
-0.0358303711,
0.0248478763,
-0.0247024447,
-0.0445211716,
0.0001226,
-0.0073021315,
0.0048542954,
0.0276088808,
0.0323299468,
0.038966015,
0.0256390627,
-0.037647143,
0.0163375679,
-0.0036244169,
-0.0258347373,
-0.0667061433,
0.0248442888,
0.0193066467,
0.0686047748,
0.0039916588,
0.0002137443,
0.0101523809,
0.0570775531,
0.0371393338,
0.0361750685,
-0.0443845615,
0.0706607997,
0.0166677777,
0.0432504416,
-0.0370533951,
0.0218958408,
0.0631210729,
0.0015085298,
0.0335880443,
0.0166010167,
-0.022314705,
-0.0449496508,
0.0617545359,
-0.0130215036,
0.0232849922,
0.0523292944,
-0.0133668631,
0.0107555613,
0.0106230341,
0.0579192638,
-0.0154002449,
0.010777358,
0.0014857101,
0.0120410277,
-0.071378842,
0.0302764084,
0.0582909063,
0.0210591424,
-0.0121289203,
0.0048255282,
0.0010576451,
-0.0212747473,
0.0055197254,
0.0236666258,
-0.0685642585,
0.0210978482,
0.0483791381,
0.0297160279,
-0.0138633521,
-0.0250296965,
-0.0370083787,
-0.0244306307,
0.0173179638,
0.0155210337,
0.0584744588,
-6.583889492e-33,
-0.0174225587,
-0.0256630145,
0.0066422066,
-0.031404715,
0.0076842508,
0.0070001525,
-0.0141744474,
0.0394377224,
0.0090543581,
0.0037939197,
0.0213839412,
-0.039064303,
-0.0032701087,
0.0006427513,
0.0387042128,
0.026506545,
0.0303843431,
-0.0199294854,
-0.0097053666,
0.0162425693,
0.03367633,
0.0080449702,
0.0380840413,
-0.1162308231,
-0.0102759684,
0.0229847841,
-0.0625893623,
0.0006372255,
-0.0064779199,
0.0244909842,
-0.0222154222,
-0.0044130264,
0.0117209442,
0.0147926155,
-0.0450277701,
0.0049627624,
-0.0811378881,
0.0012822142,
-0.0494056977,
0.0144692631,
-0.0987989083,
-0.0288921017,
0.0740295872,
-0.0394503511,
0.0023185669,
-0.0290665012,
0.0504402258,
-0.0302639101,
0.0163689423,
0.0095160957,
-0.0104554016,
0.0431937724,
-0.0352847576,
-0.0676347613,
0.0388275832,
0.0245839655,
0.0514941365,
0.0272081103,
-0.041979298,
0.0209144875,
-0.0633764341,
0.0149377687,
0.0801133439,
0.0434293337,
0.0007064625,
0.0438620187,
0.0481853522,
-0.0498328134,
0.0075209709,
0.0128059741,
0.0092371311,
0.0535798445,
0.022186162,
0.069770284,
0.0329987779,
0.0282954052,
-0.0341946781,
0.0765570924,
-0.034260951,
0.0004532671,
-0.0274555776,
0.0391150303,
0.0092476029,
0.0138650937,
-0.0145379575,
-0.0362304486,
-0.0130968764,
0.0203837939,
0.0017489806,
0.013026108,
-0.0317509808,
0.0650168359,
0.0698560849,
-0.0182098169,
0.0059472248,
-0.0220015794,
0.0190143269,
0.0464440249,
0.0104826167,
-0.02951671,
-0.0453926809,
-0.0325068794,
0.0430535525,
-0.008243124,
0.0093414104,
-0.0057434761,
0.0121978978,
0.0602761582,
-0.0192103423,
-0.0105058746,
-0.0294590238,
-0.0220572501,
-0.0167769864,
-0.0233105216,
0.0519438423,
-0.0105844596,
-0.0290542971,
0.0410277098,
-0.0112391785,
0.0137125906,
-0.0336953849,
-0.0403232388,
-0.0212844666,
0.0075027538,
0.0270477179,
0.0166703872,
-0.0391000174,
-0.1089868695,
0.0210565813,
-0.0588569045,
-0.0126449633,
0.0269343983,
2.85e-7,
0.037396118,
0.0173005648,
0.0236545205,
-0.0755465031,
0.0007066291,
0.0928051472,
-0.0457734205,
0.0492968224,
-0.0476847664,
-0.0727691799,
0.0080749877,
0.0587053485,
0.0171533525,
0.0323448405,
-0.0017159412,
0.032507997,
-0.0077243531,
0.0350417718,
-0.0435161889,
0.0189707577,
0.0192057565,
0.0693906322,
-0.019936353,
-0.0430933498,
0.0320338383,
0.0072441027,
0.0707649291,
0.0080472426,
-0.0164887514,
-0.0174229704,
0.0018975006,
0.0087994458,
-0.0401888713,
0.0043513388,
-0.0074102096,
0.0007072642,
0.04095551,
0.0155503461,
-0.0316092893,
-0.0445040092,
0.0274270568,
0.0593169294,
-0.0208930671,
0.0098107904,
0.0772831514,
-0.0680632293,
-0.0521730147,
-0.0270153098,
-0.0192565341,
0.0487316288,
0.0586293265,
0.0203714706,
-0.0680248141,
0.0325155072,
0.0189166423,
0.0050205155,
-0.0440400094,
-0.0734349787,
-0.0395062417,
0.0155558391,
-0.0453489199,
0.0013691342,
0.0117375124,
-0.014051049,
0.026527334,
-0.064586021,
-0.0554077178,
1.747813737e-34,
-0.0205282904,
-0.0360450968,
0.017413469,
-0.0602982491,
-0.0203973129,
-0.0273768324,
-0.0765074417,
-0.0157838389,
0.0172691084,
0.0034978851,
-0.0089743482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18162v1 | A Multiple Choices Reading Comprehension Corpus for Vietnamese Language Education | 2023-03-31T15:54:54 | 2023-03-31T15:54:54 | Son T. Luu, Khoi Trong Hoang, Tuong Quang Pham, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine reading comprehension has been an interesting and challenging task in
recent years, with the purpose of extracting useful information from texts. To
attain the computer ability to understand the reading text and answer relevant
information, we introduce ViMMRC 2.0 - an extension of the previous ViMMRC for
the task of multiple-choice reading comprehension in Vietnamese Textbooks which
contain the reading articles for students from Grade 1 to Grade 12. This
dataset has 699 reading passages which are prose and poems, and 5,273
questions. The questions in the new dataset are not fixed with four options as
in the previous version. Moreover, the difficulty of questions is increased,
which challenges the models to find the correct choice. The computer must
understand the whole context of the reading passage, the question, and the
content of each choice to extract the right answers. Hence, we propose the
multi-stage approach that combines the multi-step attention network (MAN) with
the natural language inference (NLI) task to enhance the performance of the
reading comprehension model. Then, we compare the proposed methodology with the
baseline BERTology models on the new dataset and the ViMMRC 1.0. Our
multi-stage models achieved 58.81% by Accuracy on the test set, which is 5.34%
better than the highest BERTology models. From the results of the error
analysis, we found the challenge of the reading comprehension models is
understanding the implicit context in texts and linking them together in order
to find the correct answers. Finally, we hope our new dataset will motivate
further research in enhancing the language understanding ability of computers
in the Vietnamese language. | [
0.0370280109,
-0.0207110662,
-0.0147995222,
0.0350910723,
-0.0511259511,
0.0233908445,
0.024623353,
-0.0504946522,
0.0414918326,
-0.0271349568,
0.0024488389,
-0.0169758406,
0.0098304376,
-0.0266439263,
0.0287739802,
-0.0515585802,
0.0323325843,
-0.0113231866,
-0.0020698365,
0.0200966392,
-0.0112604788,
0.0066694953,
-0.0008498576,
0.0175628476,
0.0867905244,
-0.0439611524,
-0.0395177193,
0.0253319666,
0.047922276,
-0.0579562224,
0.0056192107,
0.0362628289,
-0.019141024,
0.0112297963,
0.0000021721,
-0.0399994738,
-0.0402087793,
-0.0242546163,
-0.0021892856,
0.0336772688,
0.0339444801,
0.0153339179,
0.0450401232,
0.0174654704,
0.0020403373,
0.0158892851,
0.0131013105,
0.0298413262,
0.0640466437,
0.0474562645,
0.0048312866,
-0.0219091196,
0.0126375612,
0.0053499904,
0.0270968992,
-0.0365167223,
0.0451264381,
0.0226508919,
0.0362318903,
-0.0001567913,
-0.0522010997,
0.0583934262,
0.0231688879,
0.0226239599,
-0.0087605454,
0.0274933781,
0.0003662834,
-0.0037654843,
-0.0221971944,
0.0793073475,
-0.0002029049,
-0.0253933892,
-0.0359330997,
0.0150137935,
-0.0034837585,
0.0528059602,
-0.0420562066,
0.0000909915,
-0.0563217886,
0.0089577818,
0.0733563527,
-0.0301933046,
-0.0063207052,
0.0422454402,
-0.0160478931,
-0.0125171319,
-0.0010793037,
-0.0404800884,
0.0151509391,
-0.00008065,
-0.0669947341,
-0.0081781205,
0.0611147881,
0.0571352765,
0.0176143106,
0.0276037473,
-0.0150978519,
-0.056807138,
0.0160357486,
-0.0928723365,
-0.0009286538,
0.0719456375,
-0.0514299795,
0.0370295532,
-0.0234966762,
0.027620798,
-0.0185727533,
0.0392482169,
-0.0816532522,
-0.0130576976,
0.0103856996,
-0.0001776929,
-0.0595474206,
0.0507678203,
-0.0399305448,
-0.0217072442,
-0.0271674749,
0.0092539554,
0.0530726537,
-0.0225681886,
0.0108069424,
-0.0060831341,
-0.0613749661,
0.0043853302,
-0.014622556,
0.031713862,
-0.0575786233,
0.0307901427,
-0.0089389412,
-0.0146738887,
-0.0109931603,
0.0162324868,
0.0097558433,
-0.0521908514,
0.0015788167,
0.0374412574,
-0.0258332565,
-0.0139531856,
-0.045562949,
0.0126726646,
0.0223235264,
-0.0275628362,
0.0137053477,
-0.0475267321,
-0.0035520601,
0.0237623397,
0.0279029775,
0.0472868383,
0.0099289697,
0.0216687657,
-0.0204645749,
0.0648178607,
0.012975432,
-0.0234868433,
0.037233036,
0.0195897762,
-0.0226985123,
0.0452339463,
0.0398703702,
0.0024490347,
0.0465308949,
-0.0150055429,
-0.0244218428,
0.0090983659,
-0.0197168458,
-0.0086211218,
0.0077360412,
0.0353355929,
-0.0649426281,
0.0327508971,
-0.0096111149,
0.0424195863,
-0.0184077695,
-0.0316818766,
0.0398963243,
0.0301586017,
0.0198641848,
0.0294028744,
0.0332829952,
0.021459084,
0.0755854845,
0.0551646613,
-0.0187160559,
0.0049136137,
-0.0541777462,
0.04015081,
0.0121118417,
-0.0050461632,
-0.005886436,
-0.0725680515,
0.0027645291,
0.0178803857,
0.0148154255,
0.0282073133,
0.0780333951,
0.0094824322,
-0.0564786196,
-0.0022065425,
0.0204859413,
-0.00273294,
0.0027462833,
-0.020425966,
0.0588663854,
0.0294606704,
0.0646796003,
-0.0580236726,
-0.0468344688,
0.0002139103,
0.012317122,
0.03276233,
0.0117531018,
-0.008593889,
0.0101428209,
-0.0585741624,
0.0093086064,
0.0271347556,
-0.0041075568,
0.0319775641,
-0.0212033056,
0.0260657314,
-0.0234950595,
-0.0384385176,
-0.0304601714,
0.0474244617,
-0.0118914433,
-0.0329379067,
-0.0302665718,
0.031122962,
0.0385701731,
0.0388772637,
0.0073280572,
-0.0080078952,
0.0302590728,
-0.0362665877,
0.0355627835,
-0.0023068283,
-0.0426350534,
-0.077132158,
0.0279877204,
-0.0767279938,
-0.0118935257,
0.0662980229,
-0.0021968591,
-0.0211353377,
0.0046960553,
-0.0175784864,
0.0043495893,
-0.0469128489,
0.0260879099,
-0.0174435508,
0.0261824355,
-0.0407040641,
0.0703408271,
-0.0224353522,
0.0520464033,
0.0639750361,
0.0325002931,
0.0027042427,
0.0046733841,
-0.0291533414,
-0.0081695011,
0.0096148476,
0.0019386361,
-0.0020541698,
0.0159131214,
-0.0634191781,
-0.0205479059,
-0.092399016,
0.0502251126,
-0.0081270421,
0.0102617312,
0.0224857647,
-0.0004418204,
-0.0252761152,
-0.0234345831,
0.0230382681,
0.0140512837,
-0.0368392579,
-0.0132071748,
0.0154865766,
-0.0078772493,
0.0191492457,
-0.038121812,
-0.045756571,
-0.0231785476,
0.0398440361,
0.0259986576,
-0.0515593998,
-0.0258971713,
-0.0121200997,
-0.0144831212,
-0.027910497,
-0.0059466544,
-0.0577515326,
-0.0017166053,
-0.0434856638,
0.0163917802,
0.0896193683,
0.0137746409,
0.0188066959,
0.0287970901,
-0.0070601623,
-0.0386276394,
0.0393345989,
-0.0048610191,
0.0059175296,
0.0010405479,
-0.0271114428,
-0.0421205871,
0.0645783022,
0.0413689464,
-0.0327239782,
-0.0057013044,
-0.0169767849,
-0.0206282586,
0.0208636671,
-0.0389003642,
0.0237668008,
-0.0325769596,
0.0161207672,
-0.0342014842,
-0.0021486203,
0.1107046381,
-0.0171352178,
-0.0167538393,
-0.1292398572,
0.0403251611,
-0.0387416855,
0.0272852667,
0.0068562678,
-0.0167503823,
-0.017057389,
-0.0635619164,
-0.0401044413,
0.0215707943,
0.0335349888,
-0.035799142,
0.0780032426,
-0.0340547189,
-0.0269532111,
-0.0195159838,
0.0332568288,
-0.044714991,
0.0153266517,
-0.0286471359,
-0.0310792346,
-0.0084227817,
0.032270778,
-0.0314753912,
0.0205106288,
0.022572929,
0.0398745947,
-0.0445631891,
-0.0172123369,
-0.034163028,
0.1122308299,
0.013492113,
0.0147969751,
0.0106214853,
-0.0387837254,
0.0730289444,
0.0290802419,
-0.0073326263,
0.0118435333,
0.0014261066,
0.0320398919,
0.0266507659,
-0.053431157,
0.042277921,
-0.0093398904,
0.0333751552,
-0.1025468856,
-0.0083799865,
0.0823229924,
0.0292125028,
-0.0263841581,
-0.0364168845,
-0.0436787419,
-0.0247434322,
0.0035154363,
0.028124636,
-0.0457540192,
-0.0355857424,
-0.0053913225,
0.0265148133,
0.0305516738,
-0.0170544647,
-0.0056317826,
-0.0718267262,
0.000995908,
0.0040665963,
-0.0381297022,
-0.0307863131,
-0.0299247969,
0.0094688796,
0.01123254,
0.0414553471,
0.0190379042,
0.023797024,
-0.0130557185,
0.0056194849,
0.0336776562,
0.0058047925,
0.007092271,
-0.0211727936,
-0.0224686004,
0.0274233073,
0.0429905429,
-0.0315125026,
0.0001718086,
0.0424274839,
-0.0424550772,
-0.0254901964,
-0.0035000243,
0.0415134877,
-0.0058990093,
0.0039341878,
-0.0562106073,
0.0524849594,
-0.0170654133,
-0.0014511483,
0.0494594797,
0.0538413003,
0.0217187796,
-0.0393510759,
-0.0483264327,
0.0482579581,
-0.0142800631,
0.0714664236,
0.0490135327,
-0.0775620267,
-0.0200699382,
-0.0349156149,
-0.0099049248,
-0.0829529539,
0.0250295065,
0.0569218993,
-0.0244186129,
-0.0194490887,
-0.0430818014,
-0.0720393881,
0.0368422084,
0.0245373435,
0.0401920751,
0.0439813174,
0.0524356812,
0.0017387517,
-0.0333297476,
0.0346422307,
0.0145333242,
-0.0109047014,
-0.0190931056,
-0.0195488892,
-0.0138580641,
-0.0597476289,
-0.0074453908,
0.0327133313,
-0.0386141278,
-0.0096052885,
-0.0073043886,
0.0114245405,
0.0134818507,
0.0470770076,
-0.0185129307,
-0.0224635527,
0.008338524,
-0.0236980058,
0.0163970087,
-0.0211891625,
-0.0149318846,
0.030885715,
-0.0174789485,
0.0111571895,
0.0051007573,
0.0055352026,
-0.0051740515,
0.0377040692,
-0.0054781828,
-0.0330279246,
0.0151280966,
0.0089507569,
0.0328674316,
-0.0200735945,
0.0108057633,
-0.0663985461,
0.0197435059,
-0.009444816,
-0.0100681763,
0.0034004108,
0.008312745,
0.0273500439,
-0.0591410398,
-0.036212761,
-0.0212110188,
-0.000528938,
-0.0149815958,
-0.015379509,
0.0601129383,
0.0339216776,
0.07528615,
-0.0111957127,
-0.0142358234,
-0.0441766493,
-0.0473121256,
-0.0197793692,
0.0698882267,
0.0199930482,
0.092044048,
0.0188393593,
-0.0175050274,
0.0303857867,
0.0009061004,
-0.0343413688,
0.0246341806,
-0.0413108356,
0.024778625,
0.0236264281,
-0.0163574815,
0.0073990435,
-0.0118425982,
-0.007416958,
-0.0288757533,
0.0438313261,
-0.0056302999,
-0.0146232378,
0.0043211137,
0.0080491006,
0.0468344688,
0.0140204336,
0.0541717969,
-0.0149068125,
0.0061989874,
0.0399205759,
-0.0344851725,
-0.0607148819,
0.0008191536,
-0.0114780143,
0.0739774555,
-0.0209254939,
0.0083859535,
-0.0327771604,
-0.0519620925,
0.0381046757,
0.0240078829,
0.0264645237,
-0.0002262762,
-0.0112686288,
0.0524155237,
-0.0005930347,
-0.0321291126,
-0.0552063808,
0.0617832802,
-0.0870177075,
-0.0157609712,
0.0013499872,
-6.21637853e-33,
-0.0597568452,
-0.0289019514,
-0.0130567979,
-0.0418577828,
-0.0115799801,
0.0187541619,
-0.0612696484,
-0.0101434998,
-0.031499397,
0.0045367335,
-0.0191109311,
0.0099563142,
-0.0001210277,
0.0410529375,
-0.0059513794,
-0.0135258306,
-0.0224379096,
0.005831168,
-0.0120518217,
-0.0066214609,
0.0314244889,
0.0488711298,
0.0622139573,
-0.0054640318,
0.0291604362,
-0.0406386554,
0.0133958757,
0.0068094218,
-0.006630776,
0.0553872734,
-0.0288565196,
0.0360443294,
0.0438473783,
-0.0048276139,
0.0028773644,
0.0463377759,
-0.1362500936,
-0.0733735189,
0.0296734348,
0.0413836651,
-0.0784220621,
-0.0279478356,
0.0299326275,
0.0165280551,
0.0760598332,
-0.0245026723,
0.0612405501,
-0.050801903,
-0.0244602114,
0.014840845,
-0.0552643649,
0.0035402535,
-0.0499730222,
-0.032051906,
-0.0074244644,
0.0909125656,
-0.0096947579,
0.0413991362,
-0.0820203125,
-0.0131578315,
0.0320929512,
-0.0154859442,
-0.0090642041,
0.0371100418,
0.0040925639,
0.0171164274,
-0.0125926165,
-0.0684830546,
-0.0227844659,
0.0127090942,
0.0330834985,
0.0026706257,
0.0438499711,
0.0099996598,
0.0500719249,
0.0091147339,
-0.0847624391,
0.0253401492,
0.0345354788,
0.0034087284,
0.0389278829,
-0.0594773442,
-0.0575819053,
0.0081589706,
-0.0249047019,
-0.066049695,
-0.041425541,
-0.0115340715,
0.0171912368,
-0.0447125174,
-0.0574066937,
-0.0132492473,
0.0515343174,
-0.0582815222,
0.0273636077,
0.0173589811,
-0.0104804952,
0.0278518088,
-0.0286368374,
0.0630816072,
-0.0336913913,
0.0080987215,
-0.0295472201,
-0.011802773,
-0.0105878366,
0.0114104301,
0.0173390284,
-0.0300931539,
-0.0061586462,
-0.0132583622,
-0.0440668985,
-0.0152044035,
-0.0111774961,
0.0929923952,
0.0206693616,
0.0285152551,
0.0052091251,
0.0589323565,
0.0054477192,
0.0216943771,
-0.0505981296,
0.0098610613,
-0.0051761116,
-0.0004867457,
-0.0200567488,
-0.0001780138,
-0.0311057698,
0.0503124036,
-0.0061302921,
-0.0535322502,
0.0220475048,
0.0693943352,
2.802e-7,
0.0527302511,
0.0159724727,
0.0559436306,
0.0315554366,
-0.0103644347,
0.0106599415,
-0.0090086907,
0.0097787017,
0.0472607464,
-0.0129428124,
0.0351048186,
0.0199546255,
0.0464628413,
0.0024488496,
-0.1089751869,
-0.0877423137,
-0.0036308258,
0.0228894483,
-0.0288066529,
-0.0106384344,
0.0624552742,
0.0599662736,
-0.0018700203,
0.0045918864,
-0.0082694171,
-0.0175770912,
0.013526177,
0.0144819263,
-0.0082071554,
0.0490675047,
0.0515638851,
0.0227848012,
-0.0341028571,
0.0049950224,
-0.0107068587,
0.0150586013,
0.0468526185,
0.0369024612,
0.0248526186,
-0.0458092615,
-0.0000220814,
-0.0101417331,
0.0170647688,
-0.0505242348,
0.0582173616,
-0.0304189399,
-0.0121723274,
0.0303027947,
-0.0143254446,
0.0164918248,
0.006888316,
-0.005492426,
-0.036169298,
0.0223372281,
0.0033248069,
-0.0661311299,
0.0013694904,
-0.0534473136,
-0.0239514355,
-0.0198640339,
-0.0398521945,
-0.0119247427,
-0.0217589997,
-0.0374647528,
0.0431177728,
-0.0851479247,
0.0008910043,
2.009417135e-34,
0.0240287408,
-0.0566898957,
0.0001510192,
0.0012000081,
0.023865873,
-0.048620142,
0.0206491984,
-0.0153472954,
0.0191719308,
-0.0708944201,
-0.032624349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01016v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01016v3 | Quick Dense Retrievers Consume KALE: Post Training Kullback Leibler Alignment of Embeddings for Asymmetrical dual encoders | 2023-03-31T15:44:13 | 2023-06-01T22:08:03 | Daniel Campos, Alessandro Magnani, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | In this paper, we consider the problem of improving the inference latency of
language model-based dense retrieval systems by introducing structural
compression and model size asymmetry between the context and query encoders.
First, we investigate the impact of pre and post-training compression on the
MSMARCO, Natural Questions, TriviaQA, SQUAD, and SCIFACT, finding that
asymmetry in the dual encoders in dense retrieval can lead to improved
inference efficiency. Knowing this, we introduce Kullback Leibler Alignment of
Embeddings (KALE), an efficient and accurate method for increasing the
inference efficiency of dense retrieval methods by pruning and aligning the
query encoder after training. Specifically, KALE extends traditional Knowledge
Distillation after bi-encoder training, allowing for effective query encoder
compression without full retraining or index generation. Using KALE and
asymmetric training, we can generate models which exceed the performance of
DistilBERT despite having 3x faster inference. | [
0.010173467,
0.027294904,
-0.0030695533,
0.0520333648,
-0.0050720931,
0.02484072,
-0.0255923457,
0.0291203167,
-0.0376850255,
-0.0085619846,
-0.0095107574,
0.0142050115,
-0.0249381214,
0.0263539329,
0.0113495812,
0.0076486003,
0.0434439927,
-0.0049932855,
0.0045137662,
-0.0385408811,
-0.011173944,
0.0065507763,
0.0045550065,
-0.0119596012,
0.0538248196,
0.0221196245,
-0.0466997288,
0.0377917439,
-0.028420493,
-0.0294447709,
0.0025652468,
0.0344100781,
0.0406429581,
0.0048127794,
0.0000019802,
-0.0327599049,
-0.0280250367,
0.0148322498,
-0.0854939595,
0.012748667,
-0.0000053779,
-0.0194488503,
0.0760750398,
0.0030967081,
-0.0204148274,
-0.0025364391,
0.0381387919,
-0.0189279281,
0.009036296,
0.0303897988,
-0.0041065416,
-0.059852995,
0.0088610705,
-0.0249480754,
-0.0147025697,
-0.0381392911,
-0.0064420979,
-0.0130950902,
-0.0235761032,
0.0564752668,
-0.0149617177,
0.0494831838,
0.0461890399,
0.0307903867,
0.0516826473,
0.0265837405,
-0.0493961126,
-0.0208383854,
0.0218170006,
0.0548827313,
-0.0016750854,
-0.0235002209,
-0.0283230618,
0.0231824368,
0.0012277151,
0.0404777899,
-0.0539152026,
-0.0029136362,
-0.004023009,
-0.0050781858,
0.0142889852,
-0.0038536508,
0.0303803589,
-0.002964311,
-0.036874529,
0.0248305444,
0.0573733896,
-0.0384687707,
-0.0001751871,
0.0168530885,
-0.0177423209,
-0.0310379285,
0.011137397,
0.0090973433,
0.0008609199,
-0.0089365579,
0.0051724943,
-0.0441511273,
0.0056386185,
-0.0483245738,
0.0229388848,
0.0486787707,
-0.0151036214,
0.0491620079,
-0.0318783037,
0.0781204253,
0.0288412813,
0.0427434742,
-0.0549574904,
-0.0338798948,
-0.0173270609,
-0.0253123678,
-0.04920955,
0.0569574051,
-0.0777606517,
-0.0199248381,
-0.0246610958,
0.0387256071,
0.0134228393,
-0.0108872242,
0.0256554689,
0.0172410607,
-0.0297598857,
0.0031417715,
-0.0277403984,
0.0753924698,
-0.0477860533,
-0.010533344,
0.0041922629,
-0.0340666324,
-0.0442830957,
0.0020361892,
0.0274658874,
-0.0672475845,
0.0072293761,
-0.0128223952,
-0.0261649434,
-0.0380563587,
0.006983764,
-0.0163571294,
0.0099764625,
-0.0335916691,
0.0158757214,
-0.0603639483,
0.0736632049,
0.011706885,
-0.01345124,
-0.066966258,
-0.0149940383,
0.0019765208,
-0.009637136,
0.0642052814,
0.0084394701,
0.0037311553,
0.009289084,
0.004911371,
0.0212090276,
0.1071162447,
-0.0389821529,
0.0069621783,
0.0398704335,
-0.0385206826,
-0.0410704464,
-0.0078935251,
0.0742128938,
0.0214938112,
-0.053156659,
0.0429835059,
-0.0044745179,
0.0244155452,
0.0277555622,
0.0478471704,
-0.0614636205,
-0.0191236511,
0.0167388022,
0.0237052571,
0.0512708314,
-0.0261644628,
-0.0101012206,
-0.019925477,
-0.0331617557,
0.0135054011,
-0.0357085131,
0.0432412364,
-0.0475983657,
-0.0011351632,
0.0602741502,
0.0425898731,
-0.0500498302,
-0.0309135616,
-0.026440423,
0.0089741098,
-0.0049803676,
0.0283034686,
0.036910478,
-0.0102537284,
-0.0078172982,
0.072819531,
0.0226469506,
-0.0516022369,
-0.0083643133,
-0.0174263678,
-0.0256858841,
0.0077361674,
0.0507695563,
-0.0091567906,
-0.0464040264,
0.0463301092,
-0.0441270955,
-0.0217592642,
0.0294612385,
-0.0320052877,
0.0388012752,
-0.067865178,
-0.0611348189,
-0.0242906678,
0.0224826355,
-0.0037265113,
0.0344733372,
0.0451045148,
0.0484585799,
-0.0840791389,
0.0496166758,
0.0110956291,
-0.056246724,
-0.0421515889,
-0.0029371118,
0.0355561189,
0.0175010748,
0.0068738861,
0.0077937841,
0.0008311854,
0.0753877908,
-0.0403788388,
-0.0321824476,
-0.0115542589,
-0.0263445564,
-0.1036646217,
0.0448795371,
0.005613232,
0.0346303396,
0.0598116629,
-0.0158347245,
-0.0272929259,
-0.0159125663,
-0.0066118892,
0.0472429805,
-0.0409429744,
0.0039926758,
0.0038805178,
-0.0133656301,
-0.0247473493,
0.0597153939,
-0.0370241441,
0.0331748798,
-0.0119223045,
-0.035906855,
0.0141042145,
-0.0180279054,
-0.0304208528,
0.0404737554,
0.0014890675,
-0.0216254331,
0.0286252405,
-0.0389478356,
-0.0096094431,
-0.003941997,
-0.0794209689,
0.0154398689,
-0.0485890917,
-0.0074533909,
0.0114645781,
0.0458676443,
0.0267428122,
-0.021528434,
-0.041873686,
0.0006154214,
0.0066815363,
0.0522464216,
0.0051708804,
0.0369919911,
-0.0103920475,
0.0148941083,
-0.0563270673,
0.0249158591,
0.0664939061,
-0.0509971827,
0.0056773792,
-0.0100731654,
0.0148101114,
-0.0450686403,
-0.0039474955,
-0.0211706813,
-0.0131191807,
-0.0104725808,
-0.0468909331,
0.0048597213,
0.0722240284,
0.0046229321,
0.0386968665,
0.0311477035,
0.0185320359,
-0.0703596398,
0.0265693553,
-0.0386808254,
-0.0318196863,
-0.0236014463,
-0.0198649764,
-0.0169765186,
0.006681147,
-0.0485158414,
-0.0129837953,
-0.0505092144,
-0.0023963603,
0.0332312658,
-0.0437195338,
-0.0888474211,
0.0084064882,
0.029621901,
0.0509946719,
-0.0248503834,
-0.0375157036,
0.0597673543,
0.0031805534,
-0.0165631864,
-0.0226178374,
-0.0177064538,
-0.0327472426,
0.0781965256,
-0.0185526684,
0.0218629651,
-0.0218410157,
-0.028405156,
-0.0531671271,
0.0218584649,
0.0384935215,
-0.0529092588,
0.036006324,
-0.0154850464,
0.0180163942,
-0.0108445464,
-0.0677477345,
-0.0391526297,
-0.0151290512,
-0.0055552064,
0.0294163208,
0.006774982,
-0.0193604659,
-0.0222635288,
0.0205651186,
-0.0131659489,
0.0059844106,
-0.0218179189,
0.0146206217,
0.0042360867,
0.0145451007,
0.0714117885,
0.0281758998,
-0.0129542518,
-0.0136161847,
0.0120932674,
0.0619792938,
0.0080334153,
-0.0392975993,
0.0206972957,
0.0027150265,
0.0442182273,
0.0022897292,
-0.0271042865,
0.000411698,
0.050928127,
-0.0133315194,
-0.0383499041,
0.0988161713,
0.0194901228,
-0.0412332378,
-0.0175616629,
-0.0123336166,
0.0665962473,
0.0513467826,
0.0082785301,
-0.0763827413,
-0.0320030972,
0.0209709387,
0.0606614016,
0.0413780957,
-0.0153944772,
0.0148075623,
-0.1364587545,
-0.0038040865,
0.0113923801,
-0.0212368835,
-0.0914550498,
-0.0563710928,
-0.0259021334,
-0.025223894,
0.0162066687,
0.0447273254,
-0.0104623623,
0.0252170525,
0.0054408461,
0.0425882414,
-0.0373154357,
-0.0032886423,
-0.0267587062,
0.002904901,
0.0139423106,
0.000569846,
0.0267826803,
-0.0433783568,
-0.0067198249,
-0.0373791344,
-0.0211312547,
-0.0106938174,
0.0403122902,
-0.0215467568,
0.010873463,
0.0179711133,
0.003697518,
-0.0267485939,
0.0182651747,
-0.0232931189,
0.0477798432,
-0.0002896967,
-0.0134730833,
-0.0367781036,
-0.037048012,
-0.0047893701,
0.0923964605,
0.0014593916,
0.0475242101,
-0.0088539822,
-0.00216088,
0.0133940792,
0.0066059465,
-0.0060240887,
0.0363778099,
-0.0119149005,
-0.0085767815,
-0.0444205329,
-0.0286041182,
0.0086724069,
0.068707034,
-0.0318782292,
0.0412778333,
-0.0278074332,
-0.0132252434,
-0.0753733739,
0.0022173114,
-0.0120824277,
-0.0291376021,
-0.0088914055,
0.0137969432,
0.0140789263,
0.0145104565,
-0.0355703756,
-0.0388744734,
-0.07091593,
-0.0637222156,
-0.0285805706,
0.0315561108,
0.0173382424,
0.0546039119,
0.0070104692,
-0.0225188434,
0.0400153808,
0.0662269294,
-0.0437044203,
0.0383047275,
0.0135647431,
-0.0607118122,
-0.0084476098,
0.045924712,
-0.0566943139,
-0.0051516681,
-0.0201559421,
0.0608069673,
-0.0448217317,
-0.0461963452,
0.0326004736,
0.0809801221,
0.054021202,
0.0242767148,
0.0020697291,
-0.0039126114,
0.0373682454,
-0.0317363665,
-0.0160414763,
-0.0336424559,
0.0059282091,
0.0279282611,
0.0182952546,
0.0091426978,
0.0475718603,
0.0545150861,
0.0402986184,
-0.0562682152,
-0.0137032522,
0.0258966908,
-0.01499297,
0.0327301472,
0.01881231,
-0.0229611043,
0.0195200276,
0.0333408415,
0.0632389039,
-0.0487725362,
-0.0042042942,
0.0414446481,
0.0379581042,
-0.0371643454,
0.017137887,
-0.0747228041,
-0.0383010507,
0.0167426467,
-0.0142493062,
0.030997375,
-0.0295135882,
0.0095413337,
0.0123739829,
-0.02193713,
-0.0263587367,
0.0095944181,
0.020431336,
-0.0150966123,
0.058112815,
0.0397973582,
-0.0026571075,
0.0039476766,
0.0757432505,
0.0049394961,
0.0683370605,
-0.0249985736,
-0.013580909,
-0.0096574025,
-0.0227505732,
0.0391027816,
0.0514776669,
0.014549016,
0.0135487393,
-0.0057255989,
-0.0654935613,
0.0161157139,
-0.0237149689,
-0.0054842276,
-0.0091941748,
0.0698456168,
0.0931190103,
0.0099886311,
-0.0652719513,
-0.0005421188,
0.0195935871,
-0.0664789826,
-0.0161923617,
0.0128152883,
-7.051255761e-33,
-0.0235290155,
0.0260494929,
0.0286692977,
-0.0918025747,
-0.0400413275,
-0.0009439715,
0.0052088923,
-0.0180266667,
-0.0807517022,
0.0044430587,
-0.0281851012,
0.047402747,
-0.0002009887,
0.0049333931,
0.0032379297,
-0.0235298201,
0.0311630983,
0.016903257,
-0.0198351499,
-0.0074946997,
0.0412546955,
0.0426219255,
0.027696928,
-0.0288177505,
-0.044508189,
0.0137287108,
0.0581644997,
0.0448490568,
0.0110277394,
0.0190621633,
0.0115016382,
0.0209747814,
0.0003902443,
-0.0085909413,
-0.0067258682,
-0.0331191942,
-0.0798632056,
-0.0411019474,
0.009073073,
0.0034418278,
-0.0158467498,
-0.0291085206,
0.0458738692,
-0.0218200535,
0.0114203831,
-0.0478845462,
-0.0064050909,
-0.0094414176,
-0.0579832196,
-0.0315070674,
0.008298832,
0.0059309951,
-0.0139681986,
-0.0015844724,
0.0402712561,
0.0328933038,
0.0348038301,
0.0318754986,
-0.023253832,
0.0038847709,
-0.0286332984,
0.0732746273,
0.0273109078,
0.0115610072,
0.004794349,
0.0364880897,
-0.001681537,
-0.0054112468,
-0.0566975027,
0.0215005726,
0.0280839019,
0.060582459,
0.0261375252,
0.0611832142,
0.1020078659,
-0.0208614618,
-0.099560298,
0.0329821445,
-0.0321628153,
0.02986251,
-0.0056755715,
0.0570591167,
-0.0608421341,
-0.0401164331,
-0.0522235744,
0.0110418955,
-0.0400996059,
-0.0212667808,
0.0265718717,
0.0302458908,
-0.0266230386,
0.0040178397,
0.0439499803,
-0.0373397171,
0.0247416999,
0.0623151436,
0.0076951492,
-0.0100872293,
-0.0066914945,
0.0534959137,
-0.0207088739,
-0.0092343427,
0.0159597863,
0.0249177292,
-0.0177821573,
0.0216613133,
0.0209173672,
0.0109386621,
-0.0404068418,
-0.0274247229,
-0.0292636435,
-0.034591496,
-0.0006066608,
-0.009539214,
0.0478284508,
0.048459623,
0.0212431792,
0.0333928987,
0.0468553267,
0.0268200673,
-0.0627625808,
-0.0468184464,
0.04165975,
0.0000948612,
0.0200587809,
0.0194066111,
-0.049409043,
-0.0206309091,
-0.0038216165,
-0.0514548011,
-0.023204213,
0.0235143285,
2.856e-7,
0.0627233461,
0.0021400102,
0.0330001861,
0.0363706611,
-0.0332819484,
0.002784834,
0.0233175382,
0.0265108012,
0.0389635712,
-0.0490651391,
0.0196539667,
0.0495954677,
0.0081479149,
0.0190550499,
-0.0838109031,
-0.0325810462,
-0.0664303005,
-0.0222685654,
-0.0181777421,
-0.0274628457,
0.0596508197,
0.0826175511,
0.0049890322,
-0.0058179288,
0.0158248637,
-0.0432357527,
0.0477359481,
0.0181419626,
0.022123469,
-0.0077111511,
-0.0064357664,
-0.0095439255,
0.022624949,
0.0119110476,
-0.0206531361,
0.0334238112,
0.0111804567,
0.0400037356,
-0.0293448642,
-0.0561918169,
-0.0029330875,
-0.0097152693,
-0.0278218091,
-0.0425181389,
0.1135788634,
0.0096654268,
-0.0063628615,
0.004794423,
-0.0819954127,
0.0078903763,
0.0238764472,
0.0207418725,
0.0032412985,
0.0262717102,
0.0304915719,
0.0043013925,
0.0097975237,
-0.0864371732,
-0.0039349571,
0.004035682,
-0.034830898,
-0.0405258723,
-0.0303099807,
-0.0194812659,
-0.0022173321,
0.0080632903,
-0.0130596394,
2.709859551e-34,
0.0352557525,
0.0416631028,
0.0348008387,
0.0305613205,
0.016320629,
-0.0724826604,
-0.0251192693,
-0.0007155886,
0.0174036697,
-0.1143753082,
-0.0158312656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.06147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.06147v1 | CQSumDP: A ChatGPT-Annotated Resource for Query-Focused Abstractive Summarization Based on Debatepedia | 2023-03-31T15:39:54 | 2023-03-31T15:39:54 | Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Mizanur Rahman, Israt Jahan, Enamul Hoque, Jimmy Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Debatepedia is a publicly available dataset consisting of arguments and
counter-arguments on controversial topics that has been widely used for the
single-document query-focused abstractive summarization task in recent years.
However, it has been recently found that this dataset is limited by noise and
even most queries in this dataset do not have any relevance to the respective
document. In this paper, we present a methodology for cleaning the Debatepedia
dataset by leveraging the generative power of large language models to make it
suitable for query-focused abstractive summarization. More specifically, we
harness the language generation capabilities of ChatGPT to regenerate its
queries. We evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed ChatGPT annotated
version of the Debatepedia dataset using several benchmark summarization models
and demonstrate that the newly annotated version of Debatepedia outperforms the
original dataset in terms of both query relevance as well as summary generation
quality. We will make this annotated and cleaned version of the dataset
publicly available. | [
0.0405956097,
0.0469480194,
0.0356195457,
0.0063039032,
-0.0286909603,
0.0160416048,
-0.0074714511,
-0.0335249342,
-0.0188198183,
-0.0421680324,
0.0201534498,
-0.0337902978,
-0.0089502884,
0.0129364599,
-0.0038697189,
-0.0807104111,
0.0205829758,
0.0114332661,
0.0424860157,
-0.0014356264,
0.0439402759,
0.0208150297,
-0.001495305,
0.0447159149,
0.0131552601,
-0.0292353984,
-0.0081527606,
-0.0013896789,
0.0396978818,
-0.0024000362,
0.0086150737,
0.0444627926,
0.0274968818,
0.0449072272,
0.0000016908,
-0.0364781246,
-0.0306805484,
-0.0177178998,
0.0201725997,
0.0437102132,
0.0999035537,
0.0510252081,
0.0155753577,
0.0374920368,
-0.0126130031,
-0.002513658,
0.0214489009,
0.0474227369,
0.106978938,
0.0575591847,
-0.0073747467,
-0.0248041637,
0.0191411562,
-0.0307891555,
-0.0339754634,
-0.0110113574,
0.0061573135,
0.0436879024,
-0.037091393,
0.0315058753,
0.0243442245,
0.0152718816,
0.0056185336,
-0.0313258655,
-0.0072257593,
0.0010182111,
-0.1261541396,
-0.0089879902,
0.0333353393,
0.0648492724,
0.02196569,
-0.0287639573,
0.0466097482,
0.0020669582,
0.0093141021,
0.0200011637,
-0.0777186975,
0.0354991518,
-0.0182087831,
0.0316090472,
0.0473341867,
0.0051065991,
0.0004314603,
0.0374163762,
-0.0038467369,
0.0025450722,
0.0101708956,
0.0227955561,
-0.0096653979,
-0.0154663371,
-0.0267570652,
-0.0651325434,
-0.008753553,
0.0038902443,
-0.0126607055,
0.0036789966,
-0.0314578228,
-0.0628980696,
0.0277357399,
-0.060043592,
-0.0339432471,
-0.0116400253,
0.0350020751,
0.0534423366,
0.0189579669,
-0.0276040472,
0.000588127,
0.00471598,
-0.0489865765,
-0.0374181904,
-0.0147462953,
0.0013509756,
-0.0762078017,
0.0303146448,
-0.0669262856,
-0.0026675856,
-0.0173548348,
0.0134740192,
-0.0116555011,
-0.0212745462,
0.0057063005,
0.0147373909,
-0.0240610018,
-0.0241906699,
-0.0154408338,
0.0083911708,
-0.0333185196,
-0.0408003442,
0.0582259968,
-0.0226557218,
-0.0013608605,
0.0163577963,
0.0139803458,
0.0085923038,
-0.0175948162,
0.0116289472,
-0.0353423059,
0.0073660184,
-0.0036128168,
-0.0300154146,
0.0018974821,
-0.0218011755,
0.0102373278,
-0.073925145,
0.018227255,
-0.0109440358,
-0.0222493745,
-0.0109643312,
0.0048198705,
0.0511608347,
-0.0338014625,
0.0261776373,
-0.0237651095,
-0.0196146257,
0.085917674,
0.0209614355,
-0.0088660615,
0.0731955841,
0.0284051374,
0.0118565578,
0.060125906,
0.0433869436,
-0.0035379753,
-0.0033305043,
0.0255274344,
0.0297495704,
0.0465795472,
0.0161162391,
-0.050043337,
-0.0179923456,
-0.01397199,
0.0754331127,
-0.049098473,
-0.0146001121,
0.0025972079,
0.0519815423,
0.0002241898,
0.0225996524,
-0.0209843386,
0.0445776917,
0.0343274064,
0.0408790931,
0.0173437893,
0.0189335626,
-0.0042819139,
0.0313181095,
0.0739324167,
0.0177724436,
-0.01815762,
-0.0693247542,
0.001134287,
0.0372329913,
0.0112246498,
0.0004825039,
0.0125956973,
0.012775409,
-0.0487623811,
0.0545292124,
0.0247135162,
-0.060765896,
0.0086499434,
-0.0298699103,
0.0231358502,
-0.0164259393,
0.0454453863,
-0.0483437032,
-0.0664961934,
-0.0047466792,
0.0352031924,
0.0552426353,
0.0697145015,
-0.0278462395,
-0.0441130921,
-0.0387847759,
-0.0307634845,
-0.0279996414,
0.0174225811,
-0.0048588556,
0.0148862917,
-0.0305687021,
0.0443833396,
-0.0226880386,
-0.0645298064,
0.0051515312,
-0.0044064964,
0.0074597639,
0.004803203,
-0.0265635531,
0.0358238555,
0.0507089198,
-0.0279391985,
0.0062583173,
0.0192951579,
-0.0258989688,
-0.0126484837,
0.0258843321,
-0.0317898616,
-0.0432614721,
0.0395832844,
-0.0734212399,
-0.010183258,
0.0178175643,
-0.0433180258,
-0.0359034613,
0.0189999361,
-0.0371272787,
0.0111228283,
-0.041285079,
-0.0164554827,
0.0093029374,
-0.0340757929,
-0.0478586815,
0.0781996623,
0.0068494887,
-0.0048786798,
0.050781846,
0.0127427084,
0.0320785791,
-0.0504849255,
-0.0046221879,
0.009660122,
0.0127332071,
-0.0039483113,
0.0755429789,
-0.0129356384,
-0.0429739244,
0.0047346605,
-0.0862594396,
0.0072860657,
-0.0248318501,
0.0075081596,
0.0656310022,
-0.0053150207,
0.0100314012,
0.0397760645,
-0.072280921,
-0.0148380548,
0.0100831613,
0.0009176008,
0.0295743253,
0.0108881826,
0.0366354249,
-0.0578486621,
-0.0137177892,
-0.0004137724,
0.0342840292,
0.0138154943,
-0.0181095768,
0.0059254551,
0.0506107584,
-0.0334135666,
-0.0124214683,
-0.0270724744,
0.0149083259,
0.0188413821,
-0.0033263266,
0.0483810604,
-0.0058124047,
0.0602407046,
0.0052864901,
0.0272236168,
-0.0093576619,
-0.0516798198,
-0.0134451073,
-0.0224198513,
0.0306890234,
0.0416091345,
-0.0313086435,
0.0480727851,
0.0338702127,
0.0044865189,
-0.0053201318,
-0.0475828275,
0.0605122223,
-0.0304221027,
0.0259030573,
-0.0560565926,
-0.0070589576,
-0.0021932544,
0.0328216106,
-0.0324354209,
0.001929104,
0.0537815057,
-0.0190045852,
0.0278456993,
-0.0882957578,
0.0069544902,
-0.0469367541,
0.0297406614,
-0.0186381713,
0.0456422828,
-0.0220997818,
-0.0221730992,
-0.0443724245,
-0.0471252985,
0.0363403969,
-0.0446166545,
0.0580622517,
-0.0502868742,
0.0309917647,
-0.0292540248,
0.0057937722,
-0.0104792854,
-0.0160454866,
-0.0032306865,
0.0214084163,
0.0636701435,
0.0067899236,
-0.0183963068,
0.0201895703,
0.0129287699,
0.0381771997,
-0.0004654672,
-0.0111277048,
0.0267318878,
0.0470044203,
0.0781792402,
-0.0019936771,
0.0244384054,
-0.0084111523,
0.0397379473,
0.0857972801,
0.0262224264,
-0.0541385524,
0.0023174635,
-0.0455160663,
-0.0340796411,
-0.0634942949,
0.011325758,
-0.0679344237,
0.0530877002,
-0.0219113808,
-0.009308829,
0.0881113932,
0.0376652181,
-0.0357374735,
-0.0362173878,
0.0066332053,
0.0559835881,
-0.0100961309,
-0.0110417865,
-0.0973706469,
0.0130832242,
-0.0198835619,
0.0316071175,
0.0017070657,
-0.0319897532,
-0.0111141419,
-0.0913326666,
0.0225683972,
0.0135996351,
-0.0707528442,
-0.0164557733,
-0.0241468996,
0.0114907343,
-0.0512736104,
-0.0113541307,
0.047408361,
-0.0106164534,
0.0313932113,
0.0126619888,
-0.05403037,
0.042765405,
-0.0110173216,
-0.0164384656,
0.0095173186,
0.0017175744,
0.0481725149,
0.0148884477,
0.0340712741,
0.0653066263,
-0.0346611775,
-0.0455950573,
-0.0017357168,
0.0546494126,
0.0019534202,
-0.0022242703,
-0.0301948991,
0.0525816157,
0.0046171993,
-0.0375694484,
0.0062102941,
0.0153679932,
-0.0095139779,
0.0098555628,
-0.0425131619,
0.0474794656,
-0.0358841084,
0.0936769173,
0.0395842865,
0.0184121169,
-0.0398459285,
-0.0480258651,
0.018032914,
-0.0680241212,
-0.0105255926,
-0.0405602641,
-0.0372704603,
0.0155038154,
-0.0951520354,
-0.0552946404,
-0.00361575,
-0.000035904,
-0.0291584786,
-0.0017869705,
0.0215953887,
0.0225297008,
-0.021288136,
0.0023139089,
-0.0144322235,
-0.0345274396,
0.0031264892,
-0.0516101047,
0.0412989743,
-0.0073492588,
-0.0483227074,
0.0703976825,
-0.0398557261,
-0.0689218938,
-0.006842644,
-0.0104450099,
0.0227130875,
0.04790131,
-0.0099547617,
0.0199845526,
0.0349686407,
0.0354295969,
0.0172449462,
-0.0226405039,
0.0170377586,
0.0656919628,
-0.0104753869,
0.0288176425,
-0.0297481958,
0.0136042302,
-0.042742461,
0.0587447807,
-0.0489609912,
-0.0442992561,
0.0196685698,
0.0600453019,
0.017335318,
0.0058773663,
-0.0027597668,
-0.0585440062,
-0.0081690736,
-0.0382121205,
-0.0337808765,
-0.0346738175,
0.0583475158,
-0.0402524285,
-0.0634124652,
-0.0220260918,
0.027008025,
-0.0229818169,
0.0589229167,
-0.019560596,
-0.0021484655,
-0.0196766574,
-0.0257824678,
-0.0243190266,
-0.0253107063,
-0.0425548777,
-0.0043631,
-0.0391764343,
0.0214820057,
-0.0158226807,
0.0053325603,
0.021703288,
-0.0025251352,
0.0152634429,
0.0017908827,
-0.0852866396,
-0.0451347269,
-0.0573505908,
0.0332983583,
0.0143132899,
-0.0290390085,
0.0587498248,
-0.00982075,
-0.0528906099,
-0.0133820055,
0.0235063061,
0.0599018335,
0.0111286445,
-0.01203385,
0.0144128036,
-0.0102461493,
0.0090186242,
0.0688738823,
-0.0617961735,
0.0261417907,
0.0364502706,
-0.0363883451,
-0.0396690182,
-0.0463083908,
-0.0341580473,
0.0270181037,
0.0145905204,
-0.0253420454,
-0.0347026959,
-0.0246955045,
-0.0203045756,
0.0272696633,
0.0291601643,
0.0226131883,
0.0473989286,
0.0660480782,
0.0050532203,
-0.0025545617,
-0.0542884283,
0.039525073,
-0.0228527542,
-0.005791211,
0.0015374859,
-5.744651913e-33,
-0.0256124754,
0.0133836064,
-0.0094739636,
0.0382700898,
-0.034868557,
-0.0229903739,
-0.0623625107,
-0.0055830856,
-0.0120740188,
0.0104207601,
-0.0093850009,
0.0488841943,
0.0052114446,
0.0341906212,
-0.0336457193,
-0.0004685699,
0.0307582263,
-0.0032242937,
-0.0322079547,
0.0690873936,
0.06056365,
-0.0175199043,
0.0315661617,
-0.0424002744,
0.030779466,
-0.0266484767,
-0.0153134111,
0.010859916,
0.0300630294,
0.0363415144,
-0.005945371,
0.0242422167,
0.0365322493,
-0.0573546737,
-0.0149220712,
-0.0149689047,
-0.0682967454,
-0.0128207402,
0.0207631346,
-0.0594760999,
-0.0275614746,
-0.0461088084,
0.052311603,
-0.0187286455,
0.0051456983,
-0.0446194746,
0.0291389916,
-0.0433862619,
-0.0099527771,
-0.0896895453,
-0.0018966565,
0.0533112623,
-0.0277892575,
0.0041852444,
-0.0287854467,
0.0254857056,
0.0160627384,
0.0553111061,
-0.0387682877,
0.0488835871,
0.0393791795,
0.0341316685,
0.0159423575,
-0.0282941703,
0.0265556797,
0.0616986826,
-0.0178956874,
-0.0061837351,
-0.0106248558,
0.0298197791,
-0.0333347879,
0.00605541,
0.0273791924,
0.0396601073,
0.023603294,
0.0264392514,
-0.0783378035,
0.0883230865,
-0.0045746989,
0.0144716911,
0.0133473072,
-0.006833666,
0.0247427933,
-0.0092339525,
-0.0349414274,
-0.0035430978,
-0.0115438914,
-0.0136920847,
-0.024760006,
-0.0016525629,
-0.074124679,
-0.0130124688,
0.0118550099,
-0.0367624201,
0.0167589411,
0.0395847633,
-0.0179913584,
-0.0099100918,
0.0149316536,
0.0079791015,
-0.0293231923,
0.0487214699,
0.0231462549,
0.02550794,
-0.0212269537,
-0.0204602759,
0.0181450099,
-0.0248865802,
-0.0524955653,
0.015165614,
-0.0073872642,
0.035486985,
-0.0634024441,
0.0499520488,
-0.0146246729,
0.0144498665,
0.0237091072,
0.0319878086,
0.0238329377,
0.0383286998,
-0.0154070472,
-0.0060951822,
-0.0080440454,
0.0106218271,
-0.0005783477,
0.0339151323,
0.0172366276,
0.0309934132,
0.0350074694,
-0.0326451212,
-0.011746007,
-0.0225449931,
2.362e-7,
0.0660865828,
0.0270727668,
0.0352764726,
0.0177107695,
-0.0242276397,
0.005215453,
0.0054222662,
0.0450536832,
0.0317652076,
-0.0383511446,
0.0090775825,
0.0274574123,
0.0337551683,
0.0519077964,
-0.0773375183,
-0.0577220805,
-0.0700060502,
-0.0641909242,
-0.0171491019,
-0.0112930015,
0.0525866151,
0.0720536485,
-0.0263047908,
-0.0045449175,
-0.0267945975,
0.0015058783,
0.0381526276,
-0.0274421144,
-0.0940143764,
0.054459922,
0.0867612064,
-0.0143942749,
0.0195392277,
-0.046824038,
-0.0211247467,
-0.0146563714,
0.0391484797,
0.0457761064,
0.0606062524,
-0.0305562913,
0.0193471331,
-0.0365691632,
0.0408464931,
-0.0276150126,
0.0471345633,
-0.0556441769,
0.0155788511,
-0.0345936492,
-0.0790849775,
0.0171619933,
0.0162043087,
-0.015160379,
-0.0537517257,
0.0293654911,
-0.0434732884,
0.0011128305,
0.0388834365,
-0.0499404818,
-0.0262136403,
0.0216912385,
-0.0192425493,
-0.044263877,
0.01218725,
0.0110562565,
-0.0225168262,
-0.0487711318,
0.0189077444,
2.062657386e-34,
0.1050554141,
-0.0016484243,
-0.0467834659,
-0.0322342366,
0.038768515,
-0.0048663309,
0.0257265195,
-0.0186505448,
0.0030780132,
-0.0566845424,
0.0017589878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18149v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18149v2 | Can AI Chatbots Pass the Fundamentals of Engineering (FE) and Principles and Practice of Engineering (PE) Structural Exams? | 2023-03-31T15:37:17 | 2023-04-03T02:50:06 | M. Z. Naser, Brandon Ross, Jennier Ogle, Venkatesh Kodur, Rami Hawileh, Jamal Abdalla, Huu-Tai Thai | cs.CL | cs.CL | The engineering community has recently witnessed the emergence of chatbot
technology with the release of OpenAI ChatGPT-4 and Google Bard. While these
chatbots have been reported to perform well and even pass various standardized
tests, including medical and law exams, this forum paper explores whether these
chatbots can also pass the Fundamentals of Engineering (FE) and Principles and
Practice of Engineering (PE) exams. A diverse range of civil and environmental
engineering questions and scenarios are used to evaluate the chatbots'
performance, as commonly present in the FE and PE exams. The chatbots'
responses were analyzed based on their relevance, accuracy, and clarity and
then compared against the recommendations of the National Council of Examiners
for Engineering and Surveying (NCEES). Our report shows that ChatGPT-4 and
Bard, respectively scored 70.9% and 39.2% in the FE exam and 46.2% and 41% in
the PE exam. It is evident that the current version of ChatGPT-4 could
potentially pass the FE exam. While future editions are much more likely to
pass both exams, this study also highlights the potential of using chatbots as
teaching assistants and guiding engineers. | [
-0.0076670796,
0.0409410782,
-0.0407068618,
-0.0093735093,
-0.0261896458,
-0.0313106328,
0.0290774126,
0.0030095316,
0.0718297362,
-0.0030672993,
0.0119300205,
-0.0148968846,
-0.0111442897,
0.0361627378,
0.0101292711,
-0.065908961,
-0.0209200382,
-0.0158332046,
0.0178257488,
0.0043454808,
-0.003086491,
-0.0148126315,
-0.0905636698,
0.0392205939,
-0.042360153,
0.0117002074,
-0.0740710571,
-0.0386226475,
0.0160048641,
-0.0257073194,
0.0316981897,
0.037005391,
-0.0104368757,
0.0407548733,
0.0000021365,
0.0035433951,
-0.0102833807,
0.0172643308,
-0.0256319214,
-0.033868961,
0.0274733473,
0.0368399769,
-0.0383306146,
0.0220565405,
-0.0440663472,
0.0330935046,
0.0557533205,
0.0182901453,
0.0477632582,
0.0613339245,
0.0086271204,
0.0157495588,
0.0109246718,
0.0124640185,
0.0102036158,
-0.0503536761,
-0.0122461049,
0.0710915476,
0.0558331721,
0.02521253,
-0.0345045067,
-0.0212121215,
0.0539307855,
-0.0108592287,
0.0100255739,
0.0238189138,
-0.0342926532,
-0.0045708283,
-0.025094226,
0.0565787256,
0.0539391972,
-0.0137890158,
-0.0091344304,
-0.0143657839,
0.0178479478,
0.0241986271,
-0.038379807,
0.000742174,
-0.0239973776,
-0.0333732143,
-0.0397496931,
-0.0635088384,
-0.0418139175,
-0.0114823701,
0.0054499931,
0.0091690589,
-0.012546272,
0.0105409091,
-0.0144553417,
0.0265152827,
0.0517849401,
-0.0282475874,
-0.0020203379,
0.0668817386,
-0.0192747973,
-0.0192094687,
0.0152096776,
-0.0036173363,
0.012128151,
-0.0214027204,
-0.0406079143,
0.0588895902,
0.0027588799,
0.0431221686,
-0.0208593346,
0.1027531326,
0.0536382757,
0.069195956,
-0.0392681658,
0.0100403391,
-0.068345733,
-0.0002620837,
-0.0109150764,
0.0219162498,
-0.0156900696,
0.036404822,
-0.0189686138,
0.0188966356,
-0.0331288688,
-0.0107336752,
-0.0493900664,
0.0584142804,
-0.0007623326,
-0.004941354,
-0.0276699122,
-0.0127701368,
-0.0165930744,
0.0428677127,
0.0257421937,
-0.0534816869,
0.0078606745,
0.0345800221,
-0.0106797172,
0.0164687745,
0.0054558748,
0.0498587564,
-0.0327420123,
-0.0103511019,
0.0098377131,
-0.0446815938,
0.0432399884,
-0.0371992141,
0.0519212782,
-0.0279794801,
0.0017923041,
-0.0377229564,
-0.0334259495,
-0.0088968566,
0.0291753784,
-0.0125114517,
0.0311110187,
0.0393951833,
-0.0065520997,
-0.0197529364,
0.0515621267,
0.0511269979,
-0.0720407367,
0.034404397,
0.0045978869,
0.0211850591,
-0.0103342682,
-0.025223162,
0.0106859105,
0.0189248975,
-0.0198512021,
-0.0092315217,
0.0422831066,
-0.0166545752,
0.032610558,
0.0446063392,
-0.0286730565,
0.0034445729,
0.009143658,
0.0490771756,
0.0353683345,
0.0321622603,
-0.0328140669,
0.0317530595,
0.0004563056,
0.0659006611,
0.0743953437,
-0.0033242297,
-0.0343910158,
-0.0012740192,
-0.04123649,
-0.0308839921,
-0.0360003822,
0.0178824943,
-0.0160535425,
-0.0618212037,
0.006589374,
-0.0171948634,
0.0134558734,
0.0116630457,
0.0493119732,
-0.0118675809,
-0.0037110269,
-0.0136714894,
0.0003196048,
-0.0144592244,
-0.0362073891,
-0.0607809499,
0.0005161131,
0.0148083903,
0.0386853702,
-0.053622134,
-0.0852080956,
0.0169410948,
0.0036400685,
0.008532417,
0.0734612197,
-0.0054471442,
-0.0161829144,
-0.002065107,
-0.0397755392,
-0.0126300389,
0.0089323819,
-0.008947257,
0.004217267,
0.0303904004,
-0.0153738298,
0.0141916052,
-0.0677882358,
0.0359357372,
-0.0028611468,
-0.0285383202,
-0.0367348753,
0.0172671136,
0.0028166592,
0.0495934859,
-0.0031015063,
0.0023032608,
0.0393576697,
0.0222052317,
-0.0530949496,
0.0094078677,
-0.0251922179,
0.0395694226,
0.0581639223,
-0.0851585791,
-0.0176949184,
0.0548980348,
-0.0476286672,
-0.0226602294,
-0.008606879,
-0.03926377,
0.03342399,
0.0262176935,
0.0419202484,
-0.0266938973,
-0.0290901493,
-0.0277326126,
-0.0203212686,
0.050035771,
0.0004602455,
0.0285379067,
0.0445213839,
0.0454056896,
-0.0125972573,
-0.0413163453,
0.0216426682,
-0.0196200721,
0.0074279634,
0.0133236703,
0.0488119647,
-0.061906971,
0.0351170823,
-0.097168982,
-0.0457036719,
0.0186860412,
-0.0071918429,
0.0349146388,
-0.0596018583,
-0.0044673346,
-0.0138108348,
-0.0326768123,
0.0328569822,
-0.0113069797,
-0.0371445976,
0.0285289306,
-0.040536534,
-0.0387574583,
-0.0387043916,
0.0033012126,
-0.0522469282,
-0.0183435716,
0.144312188,
-0.0015370923,
-0.008737145,
0.0417816266,
-0.0014978353,
0.0026177051,
0.0062478432,
-0.0772769228,
0.0278346483,
-0.0163529366,
-0.0017487239,
0.0618075728,
-0.0112176901,
0.0322285965,
0.0349588208,
0.0031453702,
-0.0544896163,
0.0181613211,
0.0136467097,
0.0232919734,
0.0033289301,
-0.0246362276,
-0.0302622076,
-0.0360727571,
-0.0215396285,
0.025216097,
0.0077437838,
0.0474610366,
-0.0164059307,
-0.041257523,
0.0052624629,
0.017266443,
0.0012240218,
0.016616255,
0.0277722571,
-0.0186257847,
0.0447160564,
0.0018452185,
0.0002762155,
-0.041914165,
-0.0035730291,
-0.01741587,
0.0645517111,
-0.0286397301,
0.006225389,
0.0413400307,
0.0021472406,
-0.0384024121,
0.0071768477,
-0.0076503064,
-0.0432737581,
-0.0703136995,
-0.0640875548,
0.0007656322,
-0.0095001953,
-0.0667610466,
-0.0536529347,
0.0233102348,
-0.0130512686,
0.027495956,
0.0029343665,
-0.0564228185,
-0.022452848,
-0.006680178,
-0.0063445973,
-0.0339027159,
-0.0094783539,
0.0167423561,
0.0020817353,
0.0248898249,
0.0084685618,
0.0872101635,
0.0216340143,
0.0128821051,
0.0230578911,
0.0595163219,
0.0536268912,
0.005552466,
-0.0466064066,
-0.0477631241,
0.0127264904,
0.007173806,
0.0089948969,
0.0091454368,
0.0122100087,
-0.063744694,
-0.0029523938,
0.0328996666,
0.0054377406,
0.0029352929,
-0.0141117238,
-0.0186728928,
-0.0184367895,
-0.0422375649,
-0.0116449036,
-0.0813296214,
-0.0055264453,
0.0207216647,
0.016161235,
-0.0296717715,
-0.0028178561,
0.016818203,
-0.0790846199,
0.057331536,
0.0034521869,
-0.0442276634,
-0.0435381383,
-0.0273104925,
0.0018273913,
-0.0170591548,
-0.0272002518,
0.0030888959,
0.0385429077,
0.0142232142,
0.0532842167,
-0.0846105292,
-0.0183623154,
0.045403108,
-0.0526692495,
0.0860718489,
0.0359392725,
0.0323618948,
-0.00984836,
-0.0308730509,
0.0510707051,
0.0447118282,
0.0325836502,
-0.0165500399,
0.0079232194,
0.0243966933,
0.01106048,
-0.037248835,
0.0061022765,
-0.0305583756,
-0.0057684937,
0.0642478988,
0.0683794543,
-0.0633589327,
0.0149858342,
-0.0715359524,
0.0118414788,
0.0315935425,
-0.0056395,
-0.0166747421,
-0.0128413765,
-0.0491716415,
-0.0488302261,
-0.0154266087,
0.0119155152,
-0.0413739085,
-0.0174012594,
0.001947792,
-0.0087750312,
-0.0488450453,
-0.0672017783,
0.0745612234,
0.0147817256,
0.0340372063,
-0.0409275182,
0.0368384458,
0.0498795211,
-0.0175707377,
0.0071891821,
-0.0048909443,
0.027410768,
-0.0151185635,
-0.0144708445,
0.0240738243,
-0.060290236,
-0.0173813496,
-0.0214066673,
0.0208832007,
-0.01930435,
0.0591946617,
0.0509310775,
0.0184203424,
-0.019824313,
-0.0603494197,
0.0128213586,
0.0220379718,
-0.0072752452,
-0.0611310825,
-0.0139599312,
0.0206811633,
0.0173125565,
-0.0108768512,
-0.0283099059,
-0.0186608341,
0.0143823316,
-0.0253147427,
-0.0108493837,
0.0257671718,
-0.0519202873,
0.0479901396,
0.1179044768,
-0.0004453212,
0.0537887476,
0.0122049162,
0.0049360218,
0.0504003689,
0.0148527119,
0.0051021804,
-0.0050832392,
0.0169467386,
-0.0246289689,
-0.0172615293,
0.0403616577,
0.0334112346,
0.0024709518,
0.0266517382,
-0.0141449533,
0.0547581166,
0.0164328404,
0.0469065309,
-0.0030054792,
-0.0119384453,
0.0076558096,
0.0059853108,
0.0217094012,
0.051528547,
0.0309402589,
0.0504707657,
-0.0017877502,
-0.0233117417,
-0.0036110983,
0.0190532077,
-0.0516356379,
-0.1029351279,
-0.0268127397,
0.062826097,
0.0421563797,
0.1076687872,
-0.0323632434,
-0.0473244116,
0.0322603658,
-0.0057106172,
-0.0162696745,
0.0276057459,
-0.011007892,
0.0199881569,
0.001091344,
0.0081258733,
-0.0184155609,
0.0123613728,
-0.0286793932,
0.0352910161,
-0.0167705901,
0.0094866659,
-0.0243181083,
-0.033233121,
0.0740340948,
0.0219290592,
-0.0156908855,
-0.0299236141,
-0.0246462338,
-0.0321083255,
-0.0206840597,
0.040700037,
-0.0051317746,
-0.0538064539,
0.0607945509,
0.0375632755,
0.0169025008,
-0.0224955697,
0.015926946,
-0.0220269021,
-0.0218331907,
0.0453281999,
-0.0023406409,
-5.530362966e-33,
0.0030272061,
-0.0634717643,
0.0391177461,
0.0449635759,
-0.0226008482,
-0.0165452752,
-0.0119250678,
0.0176834818,
-0.0429665335,
-0.0079067312,
-0.0396566093,
0.0368894339,
-0.0023730379,
-0.0090202475,
0.0837340057,
-0.017896343,
0.0411597937,
-0.0125164362,
-0.0254324134,
0.0153880343,
-0.0450753011,
0.0002172278,
0.0312518105,
-0.0771410316,
0.0499600582,
0.0067861504,
-0.0068058642,
-0.0387705117,
-0.0375481062,
-0.0000512719,
0.0115412204,
0.0438827612,
0.0129793836,
0.0058643473,
-0.0052368673,
0.003897856,
-0.0525493324,
-0.0590711124,
-0.0445482619,
0.0455922857,
-0.0451606698,
-0.0428265929,
0.0157544855,
-0.0177771393,
-0.052442994,
-0.0415837429,
0.0506805442,
0.001280912,
0.0499094762,
0.0319785327,
-0.0534988418,
0.0099364836,
-0.0557491891,
-0.044256255,
-0.0200383086,
0.0733453035,
0.0087311985,
-0.0420975536,
-0.0240069218,
0.0429590978,
-0.0018753615,
-0.0320964418,
0.0523982793,
-0.0643020123,
-0.0234289579,
0.043028295,
0.0495064668,
-0.0147602381,
-0.0047237887,
-0.0901922956,
0.0080617191,
0.0757399201,
0.0714270771,
0.0309343841,
0.0185042378,
-0.0147613334,
-0.0867469832,
0.0615537055,
0.0844138637,
0.0520672053,
-0.0176272057,
-0.032860823,
-0.0941550657,
0.0108089335,
-0.0089482078,
0.0023298378,
0.0093430374,
-0.030333953,
-0.0100893984,
0.013263423,
0.0125114564,
-0.0835602134,
-0.0214407407,
-0.0618989989,
0.0830562264,
-0.0172499102,
-0.0109797316,
0.0017645459,
-0.0338000916,
0.0257833041,
-0.0582413338,
-0.0034422425,
0.0209198222,
0.020059213,
0.0547005087,
-0.0052056131,
-0.0541788228,
0.0583718531,
0.006960663,
-0.0156739615,
-0.0434864238,
-0.0403103866,
0.02920275,
-0.030870378,
0.0386386625,
0.0317739099,
-0.0038571313,
-0.0049582939,
-0.0040756352,
0.0522499047,
-0.0351671576,
-0.0110238399,
-0.0322384574,
-0.0396101885,
-0.0169812068,
-0.0303001385,
-0.0457791835,
-0.0333460569,
-0.0378321745,
-0.0605674163,
-0.0192865394,
0.0233241804,
2.813e-7,
-0.0345144309,
0.0397625081,
0.0388052613,
0.0369774625,
0.0004390633,
0.0366522707,
-0.0339294001,
0.0200374033,
0.0310015883,
0.0831556618,
0.0278016776,
0.0050608851,
0.0187166911,
0.0190659463,
-0.0823949352,
-0.0375462957,
-0.0062794089,
-0.0542754158,
-0.0381534547,
0.0315058827,
0.0852383971,
0.0223848075,
-0.0246876497,
-0.009264417,
0.0125394827,
-0.0211532898,
-0.0248401053,
0.0162897427,
0.0019526812,
0.0214219671,
-0.0043537216,
0.003760786,
-0.0227789804,
0.0584306382,
0.0050711865,
-0.0329658985,
0.0245342869,
0.016646564,
0.0301674027,
-0.0149872713,
0.0230000727,
-0.0064942082,
0.0315528698,
0.0005858801,
0.0495092869,
-0.0227124281,
-0.0475309677,
-0.0182130039,
-0.057662122,
-0.0396948047,
0.0186759233,
0.0227892213,
0.0150969652,
-0.0507540852,
-0.0353632197,
-0.0043956675,
-0.0100727826,
0.0009124235,
0.0549559519,
0.0005226031,
-0.0143157775,
-0.0768477917,
0.0032525708,
-0.0246757027,
0.0037476646,
-0.0317381993,
-0.0077512679,
2.015871333e-34,
-0.0274322964,
-0.0218769964,
0.0164805502,
0.0633302703,
0.0373767503,
0.0420666039,
0.0508515202,
-0.0080591785,
0.0085324645,
-0.0179515686,
-0.0143167712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18121v1 | BERTino: an Italian DistilBERT model | 2023-03-31T15:07:40 | 2023-03-31T15:07:40 | Matteo Muffo, Enrico Bertino | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | The recent introduction of Transformers language representation models
allowed great improvements in many natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
However, if on one hand the performances achieved by this kind of architectures
are surprising, on the other their usability is limited by the high number of
parameters which constitute their network, resulting in high computational and
memory demands. In this work we present BERTino, a DistilBERT model which
proposes to be the first lightweight alternative to the BERT architecture
specific for the Italian language. We evaluated BERTino on the Italian ISDT,
Italian ParTUT, Italian WikiNER and multiclass classification tasks, obtaining
F1 scores comparable to those obtained by a BERTBASE with a remarkable
improvement in training and inference speed. | [
0.0208707005,
0.0547879599,
-0.0231622029,
0.0386975259,
-0.0321594961,
0.0096129691,
0.0191198755,
0.0053429198,
0.0171509646,
-0.0435137264,
-0.0443672612,
-0.0335993208,
-0.0064741797,
0.0045036431,
-0.0107729733,
-0.0480388887,
0.0568045005,
-0.012368408,
0.0173750576,
-0.0064246641,
0.0066080824,
-0.019337628,
-0.0223450847,
0.0385775007,
0.002982928,
0.0243272316,
-0.0062980368,
-0.0264444984,
-0.0285113119,
-0.004389869,
0.0505469553,
0.0463083051,
0.0246841963,
0.0420394354,
0.0000020218,
-0.0019864244,
0.0178373717,
-0.005020984,
-0.0105928322,
0.0100359805,
0.0091079399,
0.0323627442,
-0.016287338,
0.0237728991,
-0.0295394994,
-0.0035757194,
0.0554552041,
0.0555483848,
0.0199248735,
0.080746077,
-0.0153681245,
-0.074453935,
0.0381931476,
-0.0333828516,
-0.035159599,
0.0224752799,
-0.0045442842,
-0.0677727088,
-0.0225771014,
0.0190673117,
-0.0038340816,
0.0222893767,
-0.0124141537,
0.0417651199,
-0.0557401143,
0.0386069119,
-0.0833634734,
-0.0348331928,
-0.0017971852,
0.0342573784,
-0.0013738228,
-0.0335794576,
-0.0081222486,
0.0680172294,
0.0245797373,
0.0085334182,
-0.029852394,
-0.0028826138,
-0.0053530941,
0.0169822611,
0.0211360566,
0.0051315054,
0.0192146525,
0.0170206875,
-0.0325132385,
0.0524296276,
0.038885314,
-0.0088575231,
0.0019537299,
-0.018657051,
-0.026076179,
-0.0186635237,
0.0135266306,
0.0313708447,
0.0251459442,
-0.0310572535,
-0.0100294938,
-0.0308046713,
0.0248406995,
-0.0814116225,
-0.0143957082,
0.0220507681,
-0.0287621785,
-0.0007429458,
-0.0557115376,
0.0718320534,
-0.0576442257,
0.0319283679,
-0.0286391545,
-0.0290015321,
-0.0857492462,
-0.0134234512,
-0.0902037695,
0.0480835885,
-0.0458460189,
-0.0448106714,
-0.0281053782,
0.0269332863,
0.0043399646,
-0.0306246113,
0.0499281362,
0.0060184337,
-0.0031379177,
0.0563040636,
-0.0392842963,
0.0973790884,
-0.0323997363,
-0.0281598624,
-0.0236055031,
-0.0419674665,
0.0040350086,
0.0007224448,
-0.0109962532,
-0.0320601352,
0.0369101651,
0.0412123762,
-0.0062343199,
-0.082388185,
-0.043346338,
0.0372649357,
-0.0333695859,
-0.0804561451,
0.0060177422,
-0.0575292334,
0.0070796632,
0.0120421909,
0.0192369241,
-0.0215942021,
0.0294112414,
0.0066544968,
-0.0008469919,
0.0478951372,
-0.0294361282,
-0.0205174107,
0.0172821302,
0.0011514528,
0.0052255914,
0.032578826,
0.0351316035,
0.0197049789,
0.0081579471,
0.0024248299,
-0.0088501917,
0.0471807197,
0.0214307327,
0.0126227858,
-0.027728118,
-0.0129982801,
-0.0450774468,
-0.0049269809,
0.0516775958,
0.0711510405,
-0.0043668156,
0.0143967932,
0.0863250941,
0.0308274683,
0.0491214953,
0.0591257028,
0.0101753836,
0.0370677523,
-0.0002889848,
-0.0272618681,
-0.0240048338,
0.0155460229,
0.0054799016,
-0.0196149796,
-0.0461565889,
0.0220263023,
-0.0309814457,
0.001589322,
0.0123627279,
-0.0492778011,
0.0358876288,
0.0015614526,
0.0821387991,
0.0060955822,
-0.025924867,
0.1104559824,
0.0390950888,
-0.0452172272,
-0.0389676914,
-0.0810670108,
0.0115139103,
0.0657537207,
0.0313442983,
-0.0075546578,
-0.0271935984,
-0.0194369406,
-0.036207974,
0.0369984992,
0.0518254302,
-0.0017267319,
-0.0019420381,
-0.0394625552,
-0.0124194939,
0.0117242746,
0.0307348613,
0.0555996299,
-0.0132330386,
0.0028905009,
-0.0040444499,
-0.0457729846,
-0.0195746198,
0.0145740714,
0.034530323,
-0.0223482475,
-0.0269161016,
0.0277210306,
-0.023194734,
-0.0074512195,
-0.0324714482,
-0.0061847498,
0.0364806801,
-0.0733484551,
0.0014571163,
0.0038977342,
0.0017118476,
-0.0509473644,
0.0167382136,
-0.0341864601,
0.0316636898,
0.0589200035,
-0.0136622163,
-0.0561780594,
0.0105837407,
-0.0669765174,
0.0343470648,
-0.0229949616,
0.0092631849,
-0.0382050425,
0.0394376032,
-0.0070368913,
0.0874390453,
-0.0420710072,
0.0228390489,
0.0151518332,
0.0158256572,
0.0437224172,
-0.0074857655,
-0.104470402,
0.0230223704,
-0.0094738398,
-0.0002265362,
0.0536740161,
-0.0325770862,
0.035486564,
-0.0456628278,
-0.0933774859,
0.0106609194,
-0.0322441608,
0.0190234873,
0.0086318683,
0.0321263969,
0.0072085783,
-0.00727659,
-0.0224177744,
-0.0339387693,
-0.041362498,
0.0047992696,
0.0294869132,
-0.0050365012,
-0.0539336056,
0.0010332604,
-0.0074527995,
0.0148105668,
0.0364492424,
-0.0278498493,
-0.021152148,
-0.0258151125,
-0.0325782299,
-0.0042261356,
0.064603202,
-0.0191338826,
-0.0642097816,
-0.0193728004,
0.001150722,
0.0726758242,
0.0141351428,
0.0020157578,
-0.0138551975,
0.0181944892,
0.0183301251,
-0.0291768648,
0.019027723,
-0.0141300121,
0.0170762204,
-0.0745189264,
-0.0704654083,
-0.0023187697,
0.0811943859,
-0.0142032122,
0.0066877166,
-0.038602978,
-0.0523923635,
0.0076354006,
0.0292687733,
0.0033104473,
-0.0115527613,
-0.0230874922,
0.0163650066,
-0.0130633721,
-0.0211561695,
0.0245744493,
-0.0436480008,
0.0154664004,
-0.0569783114,
-0.0203022454,
-0.0010577539,
0.0495711453,
0.0356093869,
0.0480396226,
-0.0591276065,
-0.0271813199,
-0.0192999262,
-0.0041419896,
0.0285882764,
-0.0487958081,
0.0574652143,
-0.0113050444,
0.0090500079,
-0.0150240269,
-0.0426518917,
-0.0074237417,
0.0041280664,
-0.0327263698,
0.0535912886,
0.0527208075,
-0.0317279138,
-0.0657398924,
0.0322750844,
0.0107053416,
0.0909477025,
-0.0197533853,
0.0283764582,
-0.004474435,
0.0447161049,
0.000626481,
-0.016805172,
0.0001921337,
-0.0010404279,
0.0155092617,
0.0088165216,
0.0641980991,
0.0326170623,
-0.0721668452,
-0.016291637,
0.0168434419,
-0.0386226512,
-0.072318919,
-0.0214453135,
0.0151374387,
-0.0233732034,
-0.0431710072,
0.1055236831,
0.0127327964,
-0.0462149493,
-0.0100667011,
0.018824704,
0.0548172444,
0.0354085788,
0.027496472,
-0.0566668063,
-0.0130134905,
0.0117441053,
0.012195237,
-0.0075535872,
-0.0053448062,
0.0173282661,
-0.0604752898,
0.0270973835,
-0.0271714348,
0.0266169738,
-0.0333074667,
-0.0687989146,
-0.0593843609,
-0.0045393696,
0.0059361728,
-0.0034016892,
0.0198580716,
-0.021640107,
0.0499931313,
-0.026395401,
-0.0454949364,
0.0175518207,
-0.0143490378,
0.0143765286,
0.0559891611,
0.0328213312,
-0.0523973629,
-0.0562105291,
0.0189237855,
0.0136091784,
0.0029634091,
-0.006634139,
0.0642009452,
0.0227726456,
-0.0236559622,
-0.0561090074,
-0.0262520369,
-0.0022081572,
-0.0290787462,
-0.0465187207,
0.057680022,
-0.0272142217,
0.0370123684,
-0.0302067194,
-0.0578852072,
-0.0033068012,
0.0360955745,
0.0423173197,
-0.0571718179,
-0.057364773,
0.0290511828,
-0.0258463882,
-0.0546045899,
0.0203710813,
0.0386377871,
-0.0336159952,
-0.0713641122,
-0.0698166266,
0.0048254766,
-0.0000435175,
0.0104264067,
0.0111294705,
-0.0125785256,
0.0158240367,
0.0062040528,
-0.0580934063,
0.0593596846,
0.040680822,
0.0113097252,
-0.0848501772,
-0.0139444787,
0.0670121387,
0.0078180386,
-0.0449185707,
-0.0135993799,
-0.062529631,
-0.0262527689,
0.0140315145,
0.0750677437,
0.0219653174,
-0.0332825035,
-0.0147762811,
-0.0546762422,
0.0238931272,
0.0001386855,
0.0149951475,
-0.0289567877,
0.0182226785,
-0.0089031868,
-0.0006858847,
0.0242203418,
-0.0138396882,
0.0553955361,
-0.0316500217,
0.0349846929,
-0.0211556368,
0.0060267434,
0.0427747108,
0.0008204193,
0.0733600408,
-0.0329657607,
0.0235613715,
-0.0317335688,
0.0113839023,
0.0304558966,
0.0131386211,
-0.0257954076,
0.0537782274,
0.0714277476,
-0.0070778276,
0.0092697246,
0.0189250242,
-0.010429645,
0.0103770196,
-0.0194319356,
0.0346664786,
0.0310312826,
-0.001950855,
-0.0024211032,
0.0370031148,
-0.0273890402,
0.0177328605,
0.0369474813,
0.0241538621,
-0.0604197979,
0.0684044585,
0.011477218,
0.0010752248,
-0.0370874442,
0.0317359827,
-0.042425856,
0.0055989716,
-0.0061541996,
0.0586181954,
0.0370590389,
0.0120742414,
0.0462076552,
-0.0247417651,
-0.0149556361,
-0.0188436843,
0.0054679406,
-0.0188961998,
0.0050098477,
0.0412998945,
0.0031039596,
0.0023218438,
-0.0300286505,
0.0398019552,
-0.0034916895,
0.0219123997,
0.0040272004,
-0.0004847595,
-0.0420421325,
-0.0266622286,
0.0317217819,
0.0151662799,
-0.0415301844,
-0.0039327461,
-0.0351902321,
-0.0273800101,
0.0156371109,
-0.022774836,
0.0240485296,
-0.0688234195,
0.0333752967,
0.0260959882,
0.0182871874,
-0.038014438,
-0.0236013904,
-0.0009643704,
0.0096716397,
0.0319268033,
-0.0392919965,
-5.802348849e-33,
-0.0230534002,
0.0170013774,
0.0178124886,
-0.0080444403,
-0.0268945787,
0.0014969088,
0.0038629805,
-0.0043726321,
-0.0493920594,
0.0085452134,
-0.0032029827,
-0.0076987143,
0.0064009684,
0.0442618392,
-0.0034283646,
-0.0087187327,
0.0464597084,
-0.0009364701,
-0.0273281038,
0.0145085296,
0.0434986167,
0.0398207754,
0.0760999098,
-0.0209353063,
-0.0232247282,
-0.0548020937,
-0.0027555812,
0.0004036752,
0.0357720889,
0.0409573838,
0.0010988994,
0.043910969,
0.0263897702,
0.0047346605,
0.0140160825,
0.052852679,
-0.0805000365,
-0.0208687838,
0.0095225908,
0.0565831102,
0.0586549379,
-0.0052013122,
0.0341618173,
0.0179319773,
0.001902364,
0.0425101332,
0.0203580521,
-0.0146256452,
-0.0568976253,
-0.0388309248,
-0.0336711109,
0.0106791938,
0.0258359667,
-0.0472944602,
0.0312585048,
0.0732195228,
-0.0041317591,
-0.0251232553,
-0.0696928427,
-0.017213745,
0.0160797369,
0.0338844247,
0.0290139578,
0.0453205518,
-0.0071387622,
0.0349767655,
0.0819200277,
-0.0311573744,
0.0055624689,
-0.0479900315,
0.0683530644,
0.0594321378,
0.050573945,
0.0022077214,
0.0198058374,
-0.0479163639,
-0.063271746,
0.0026562156,
0.0554841273,
0.0255134385,
0.0182889979,
-0.01937766,
-0.0258356743,
-0.0228000619,
-0.0396179222,
-0.0268327259,
-0.0068358751,
-0.0040069069,
0.0179919992,
-0.0218775626,
0.0288685355,
0.0009540967,
0.0242324714,
-0.0373848453,
-0.004084107,
0.0076360381,
0.011922624,
0.0361970104,
-0.0176840518,
0.0375262983,
-0.0414967984,
-0.0725186318,
-0.0423885286,
0.0244702809,
-0.0168771725,
0.0136375204,
0.0608686917,
0.012095836,
-0.0615259074,
0.0013553449,
-0.0510125943,
-0.0112097384,
0.0010155893,
0.1079507694,
0.005361184,
0.0141779203,
-0.0055736047,
0.0068006516,
0.0135639291,
0.0356654152,
-0.0009328579,
0.0027071186,
0.037824437,
0.0393389761,
-0.0045077377,
-0.0003234156,
-0.0452682599,
0.0721391365,
-0.0203153044,
-0.088973999,
-0.0221021585,
0.0059523126,
2.705e-7,
0.0646180585,
0.0455442667,
0.0018020921,
-0.0188519098,
-0.0110674892,
0.0027353081,
-0.0130806854,
0.0527475029,
-0.0231788922,
0.0445371009,
0.0174144134,
0.0153004872,
0.0006156965,
0.029206017,
-0.0590738319,
-0.0078840917,
-0.0632471219,
-0.0262185074,
-0.0416381583,
0.0282458924,
0.0341464765,
0.1073431522,
0.0237339679,
-0.0279963464,
0.014965022,
-0.0309515111,
0.0746798664,
-0.0068279263,
0.0124675669,
0.0189942233,
0.0098130554,
0.0677274466,
-0.0295457318,
0.0129587157,
-0.0139851002,
0.0725107938,
-0.0240574442,
0.053367205,
-0.0376106389,
-0.0168003608,
0.046497412,
-0.081129849,
-0.0485020652,
-0.0422876701,
0.0224111043,
-0.074797824,
-0.0119241634,
-0.0249498002,
-0.0497227162,
0.0169695765,
0.0219845232,
-0.0250084437,
0.0012149378,
0.0104648974,
0.0141902994,
-0.0626542047,
-0.0083647901,
-0.0555866212,
-0.0021988184,
0.001162676,
-0.0308791269,
-0.0407784991,
-0.0416550003,
-0.0351502858,
0.029188497,
-0.00833485,
0.0219448283,
2.319747184e-34,
0.0297742095,
-0.0073004481,
-0.0489864275,
0.0568114109,
-0.0034194689,
-0.0329428539,
0.0102996612,
-0.0060072201,
0.0043967906,
-0.0546528809,
-0.0195689835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18120v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18120v2 | UKP-SQuARE v3: A Platform for Multi-Agent QA Research | 2023-03-31T15:07:36 | 2023-05-17T13:08:47 | Haritz Puerto, Tim Baumgärtner, Rachneet Sachdeva, Haishuo Fang, Hao Zhang, Sewin Tariverdian, Kexin Wang, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | The continuous development of Question Answering (QA) datasets has drawn the
research community's attention toward multi-domain models. A popular approach
is to use multi-dataset models, which are models trained on multiple datasets
to learn their regularities and prevent overfitting to a single dataset.
However, with the proliferation of QA models in online repositories such as
GitHub or Hugging Face, an alternative is becoming viable. Recent works have
demonstrated that combining expert agents can yield large performance gains
over multi-dataset models. To ease research in multi-agent models, we extend
UKP-SQuARE, an online platform for QA research, to support three families of
multi-agent systems: i) agent selection, ii) early-fusion of agents, and iii)
late-fusion of agents. We conduct experiments to evaluate their inference speed
and discuss the performance vs. speed trade-off compared to multi-dataset
models. UKP-SQuARE is open-source and publicly available at
http://square.ukp-lab.de. | [
0.0445755571,
0.0532014035,
-0.0240786411,
0.0282925032,
-0.0141449999,
0.0246057268,
0.0523961969,
-0.0512895063,
0.0197910983,
-0.0213478468,
-0.0295465421,
-0.0027949065,
-0.0296696052,
0.0089392466,
0.0062105274,
-0.0398322642,
0.0399027169,
-0.013348029,
0.0035583223,
-0.0346675441,
0.0277768299,
0.0081626046,
-0.0220453925,
0.049142126,
-0.0050872047,
-0.0342233591,
-0.0163129568,
-0.0296424888,
0.020918835,
0.0006577275,
0.0180460792,
0.0563168377,
0.0366628356,
0.00032119,
0.000001918,
-0.0571267195,
-0.0263832398,
-0.0001258073,
-0.0577915944,
-0.0047085229,
-0.0161859393,
0.0228242986,
0.0487672314,
0.0242395923,
-0.0876220763,
-0.004506743,
0.0452013053,
0.003295924,
0.0844409838,
0.0292861685,
0.0072729122,
-0.0247461256,
0.0018369609,
-0.0203721151,
-0.0140054049,
-0.0903931558,
0.0654394999,
0.0050187674,
0.0291319769,
-0.0164682474,
0.0038906464,
0.0057834694,
0.0168580338,
0.0199591238,
-0.015312179,
0.0175156593,
-0.0221311934,
-0.0142246662,
-0.041889824,
0.1086801142,
0.0499600731,
0.0254280455,
-0.0143657345,
0.0213513263,
0.0192087963,
0.0601364635,
-0.050413277,
-0.0086611155,
-0.022597041,
-0.039339859,
-0.0150839454,
-0.0037228179,
-0.0132391732,
0.0337512717,
-0.0308775902,
0.0648688525,
-0.0167408586,
-0.0219296012,
0.0119689545,
0.0235980712,
-0.0603485033,
-0.052231811,
-0.0153592983,
0.0581350848,
-0.0265022218,
0.0271099284,
-0.0342569351,
-0.0293490421,
0.0304895584,
-0.0050798063,
0.0032236157,
0.0091711953,
0.0254127663,
0.0897745565,
0.0204109736,
0.0498387255,
-0.0233493447,
0.0349082835,
-0.0383256301,
-0.034599714,
-0.074588187,
-0.02120273,
-0.0353642032,
0.0822136104,
-0.0003981439,
0.0046723629,
-0.0188017581,
0.0193728358,
-0.0150781553,
-0.0339846872,
-0.0118208658,
0.05586024,
0.0067829303,
0.0151304984,
-0.0761861056,
0.0380594842,
-0.1070290655,
0.0673984289,
0.004955221,
-0.0741217434,
-0.0281815901,
-0.008206564,
0.0201955233,
-0.0380146503,
0.0015617515,
0.043730773,
-0.0021976726,
-0.0277311075,
0.023496544,
-0.0493239537,
0.0366436765,
-0.0507583842,
-0.0389136262,
-0.0558932647,
0.1046464443,
0.0075674914,
-0.0132133905,
-0.0394318812,
-0.0210562553,
0.0353001766,
0.0068575363,
0.0821499228,
-0.0589575991,
0.0185782537,
0.0340665728,
0.017382754,
-0.062271744,
0.0833632499,
-0.001408759,
-0.0399706699,
0.0586573891,
0.0157202333,
0.0299111269,
0.0043794336,
0.0127165113,
0.0347715281,
0.0719792247,
0.0889828056,
-0.0099110575,
0.0220540352,
-0.0146957533,
0.0036334521,
-0.037396282,
-0.0546330176,
0.0102402326,
0.0559545234,
-0.0067191916,
-0.0041518016,
0.0024367296,
0.0224451367,
0.0421668403,
-0.0172232818,
0.0167647582,
0.0494071655,
-0.0048422427,
-0.0198677499,
0.0150453644,
0.0757929012,
-0.0612266362,
-0.0391932763,
-0.0005724944,
-0.0052451403,
0.0080079855,
0.0456311144,
0.0155392764,
-0.0135862706,
-0.0196458586,
0.0077700033,
0.0208451673,
-0.0337986834,
-0.0192918833,
-0.0601131059,
0.0747224689,
0.0275203381,
0.0459183529,
-0.0600805804,
-0.0605202504,
-0.0084876027,
0.0420403145,
0.0034853099,
0.0196293462,
-0.0524862781,
0.0290154591,
-0.0278045479,
-0.0675989762,
-0.0187918022,
-0.023831103,
0.0494825877,
0.0248441044,
0.0240474343,
-0.023454044,
0.0018416081,
0.0394279696,
0.0194915868,
-0.0334704556,
-0.0020278692,
-0.0039856057,
0.0116453925,
0.0407053418,
0.0240066387,
-0.0200916082,
0.0163727906,
0.0454322658,
0.005111746,
-0.0516558588,
0.0007170164,
0.017077513,
-0.0398002155,
0.036065992,
-0.0263529364,
-0.0117624179,
0.0484348089,
-0.0319034643,
-0.0479361266,
-0.0035088423,
-0.0033051977,
-0.0201596525,
0.0004609453,
-0.0411753468,
0.0143635254,
0.0302633308,
-0.0344915427,
0.0725818351,
0.0202097073,
-0.0073935296,
0.0437701717,
0.0126363626,
0.016190242,
-0.0229570232,
0.0276761912,
-0.0002304536,
0.0139257582,
0.0386697501,
0.0231345054,
-0.0152212242,
-0.0486218482,
-0.0130030736,
-0.0534539074,
0.0120870434,
-0.0028280504,
0.0136235813,
0.0102118878,
0.0002653504,
-0.0011551719,
-0.0084588453,
-0.056548588,
0.0144846393,
-0.0007111385,
0.0512507036,
0.0286451876,
0.0394895896,
0.0141592473,
-0.0494553819,
-0.004986648,
-0.0210276414,
0.0250349138,
0.0247047655,
-0.01934704,
-0.02462993,
-0.0304593984,
-0.0853104517,
0.035456311,
-0.0152551457,
-0.031247193,
0.0186448507,
-0.0289989579,
0.0014991184,
0.0545578077,
-0.0180080086,
-0.0095477067,
0.0212027766,
0.0083603635,
-0.0344832726,
0.0599788763,
-0.0304958802,
0.0147966491,
-0.0427469425,
0.0098305671,
-0.0041534719,
0.0363675728,
-0.0046901251,
-0.0448850729,
-0.0308958404,
0.0783036277,
0.0217535496,
-0.0317532532,
-0.0237056017,
0.0108597763,
0.0188132282,
0.0711207911,
-0.0186335575,
0.0061255093,
0.0970068946,
0.0315455012,
-0.0294227768,
-0.0549036786,
-0.0070668613,
-0.1013670862,
0.0383957028,
-0.0362925828,
-0.0084955338,
-0.0225158315,
0.0242052153,
-0.0366486199,
-0.0267470051,
0.030772185,
-0.0062137884,
0.0376806594,
-0.0337011889,
0.0349862166,
-0.0254911967,
-0.0621488467,
-0.0128571205,
-0.0649807528,
-0.0597052984,
-0.0154810846,
-0.0447377041,
-0.0111245438,
-0.0451074429,
-0.0130569963,
0.0405327529,
-0.012432212,
-0.0215798654,
-0.0107813831,
-0.0215118341,
0.0688646957,
0.0777271837,
0.0670167878,
0.0137425996,
-0.0247866586,
0.055440668,
0.0634929761,
0.0533105768,
-0.0122051034,
0.0339688845,
-0.0404814966,
0.0249153245,
-0.0277288407,
0.0056918007,
0.0026371754,
0.0401677825,
-0.0292084925,
0.0135853924,
0.0772249922,
0.0398958549,
-0.00307472,
-0.0262184441,
-0.0126817161,
0.0317250788,
0.0319137163,
0.0325019471,
-0.0499382801,
-0.0568110719,
-0.027045371,
0.0136830891,
-0.0102377795,
-0.046862483,
0.0083381953,
-0.0893489569,
0.0015872195,
-0.044886414,
-0.0297652259,
0.0090477094,
-0.0538392328,
0.0258091167,
-0.0370572954,
-0.0205680225,
-0.010471168,
0.0122583918,
-0.0033258649,
0.0193953309,
0.0125245946,
0.026472304,
0.0638029426,
-0.0242122486,
0.0138950599,
0.0784118399,
0.0377744436,
-0.0017796567,
-0.0602046847,
-0.0213500932,
-0.0434734263,
-0.0041914238,
-0.0007506186,
0.0690754429,
-0.0267290939,
-0.0109627405,
-0.0091768634,
0.0383968353,
-0.050132174,
0.0205628518,
0.0636806265,
0.0605182797,
0.0122761726,
0.0042313351,
-0.0409560651,
0.003523496,
-0.0131808175,
0.037924435,
-0.0115473391,
-0.0356217697,
-0.0588342249,
-0.0201220717,
-0.039845489,
-0.0585057959,
-0.0194464624,
0.0327792093,
-0.009122449,
0.0061364817,
-0.0673501864,
-0.0825100839,
0.0707431212,
0.0290698782,
-0.0107210036,
0.0522549488,
0.0070941984,
0.0594062693,
0.0074685127,
0.0171944704,
-0.020347815,
0.0246878061,
-0.0152498689,
-0.0183049459,
0.0530877821,
-0.0231483318,
-0.0313808732,
-0.0052991933,
-0.0696677566,
-0.0500631556,
-0.0230504069,
0.0475227684,
0.0227635875,
-0.0012449482,
-0.0185543634,
-0.0387930386,
0.0191463865,
-0.0102678742,
-0.049537655,
-0.0020372572,
0.0192000177,
-0.0030241683,
-0.0236585941,
0.0363856032,
-0.0608457774,
0.0020464142,
-0.0258126091,
0.0027360714,
-0.085828878,
-0.0400312506,
0.0173135605,
-0.0326085091,
-0.0148204621,
0.0628332496,
-0.0090378867,
-0.0100481389,
0.0328300968,
0.0135782352,
-0.0163605399,
-0.0376139916,
0.0088737905,
-0.0025285401,
-0.0575684719,
0.0403463729,
0.0011074672,
0.0009564764,
-0.0077389334,
-0.0263076015,
0.0123094367,
0.0778114125,
0.0167394578,
-0.0032622623,
-0.0109629892,
-0.0188729204,
-0.0031231986,
-0.0085500246,
0.0264788419,
0.0183260255,
0.0397596061,
0.0280737709,
-0.0057770675,
0.0248182192,
0.0115595004,
-0.1027776375,
-0.0662141442,
0.0278500188,
0.0085368361,
0.0224145651,
0.0616779886,
0.0422357321,
0.0122009832,
-0.0168938804,
-0.0065846681,
-0.0074441079,
0.0060843602,
-0.0095890127,
0.0757326558,
0.0361183658,
-0.0143692037,
-0.0031759625,
0.1021946892,
0.003705706,
0.0544933453,
-0.0199921671,
-0.0169198904,
-0.0160538256,
-0.0337618589,
-0.0046936348,
0.0073042908,
0.0030847387,
0.0286675319,
-0.0418125317,
-0.0166489575,
0.0097898552,
-0.007294219,
-0.031796474,
0.0013495532,
0.0365652964,
0.048537042,
0.0116952611,
-0.0421964824,
-0.045957271,
-0.0014961776,
-0.0691155344,
-0.0137176039,
0.0318274386,
-6.27409016e-33,
-0.0122873001,
-0.0246864259,
0.0247342847,
-0.0213662386,
0.0056166728,
0.0094550755,
-0.0049128602,
-0.0110642957,
-0.0655046105,
0.0002170018,
-0.0189336333,
0.021157762,
0.0050848541,
-0.0018492345,
0.0067778178,
-0.0505333804,
-0.0017741268,
0.0063711489,
0.015591383,
0.0103283422,
0.0091460831,
0.0107962461,
0.021772176,
-0.0204555374,
0.0029446804,
-0.0143358391,
-0.0017198052,
0.0364578553,
-0.0577127747,
0.0909994394,
0.003132985,
0.0312350336,
0.0338681415,
-0.0307574011,
0.0089642936,
0.0262657441,
-0.06122889,
-0.0462953523,
-0.0043610786,
-0.0089908065,
-0.0553320833,
-0.0351969376,
-0.0115568675,
0.0173939262,
0.0486888178,
-0.0323895402,
0.0567660853,
-0.0134479161,
-0.0063215555,
-0.0147822304,
-0.0160133298,
0.0185267776,
-0.0212182757,
-0.017974373,
-0.0276631005,
0.0649950728,
0.0167094879,
-0.0060200053,
-0.047403574,
0.0098023061,
0.0271705333,
-0.0080818925,
-0.0020006327,
-0.0026156537,
0.0086329365,
0.0146479271,
0.0249533206,
-0.0009923081,
-0.0023438276,
-0.0016696859,
-0.0452685803,
0.057894215,
0.0646865889,
0.0825672895,
-0.012019108,
0.0168185569,
-0.0728623495,
0.0537254736,
0.0571539663,
0.0254246816,
0.0047160275,
-0.0137602007,
-0.0208219215,
0.0039222254,
-0.049027551,
0.0560687855,
-0.0397662111,
-0.025965644,
0.0350519828,
0.0158426035,
-0.0244656876,
-0.00230235,
0.0054999809,
-0.047134541,
-0.0113867419,
0.0232173912,
-0.0341803357,
0.0408291928,
0.0129061658,
0.0106610674,
-0.0438787788,
0.011294093,
0.0189168453,
-0.0117181195,
0.0184724145,
0.0089340182,
-0.0052027935,
-0.0140424697,
-0.0510619357,
-0.0266823974,
-0.016137857,
0.0103756655,
0.0004188059,
-0.0177325755,
0.0189624578,
0.0501211025,
-0.0081135789,
0.0373101346,
-0.0029065462,
-0.0099232271,
-0.0425391495,
0.0003903235,
-0.0034473855,
-0.0121343909,
-0.0191391315,
-0.009802293,
-0.0593336672,
-0.004543514,
-0.0151150897,
-0.0324392132,
-0.0205357615,
0.0135675594,
2.554e-7,
0.0168754831,
-0.00895207,
0.020399794,
0.0316172317,
0.0211804584,
0.0381409116,
-0.0188648626,
0.0437243581,
0.0096391458,
-0.0100302519,
0.0130822146,
0.050319545,
0.0247822814,
0.041260507,
-0.0800487176,
-0.0672651902,
-0.0075189099,
0.0085317064,
-0.0609252825,
-0.0236926358,
0.0554630682,
0.0847703293,
0.0276557244,
-0.0032730903,
-0.0310893897,
-0.0643709078,
0.0564746894,
0.0351422243,
0.0089115612,
0.0426742174,
-0.0056151934,
0.0046229311,
-0.0043280469,
0.033874128,
0.0208090357,
0.01317784,
0.0150171211,
0.048028376,
-0.0049435371,
-0.072489433,
0.0073603918,
-0.0082582282,
0.0195983015,
-0.0169339031,
0.1196094528,
-0.0454163514,
-0.052579321,
0.0113868592,
-0.0092121605,
-0.0086055836,
0.026365418,
-0.006921987,
-0.0042280275,
-0.0065907137,
-0.0019625302,
-0.0300116912,
0.0147256451,
-0.0735368803,
0.0468428023,
-0.0141149173,
-0.041956421,
-0.0502417907,
-0.0176913776,
-0.0329830684,
0.0218194965,
-0.0576033853,
0.0013512698,
1.906088311e-34,
0.0026208791,
-0.0189453457,
0.0222167149,
0.0714572594,
0.0232470166,
-0.0441997685,
-0.0378262848,
-0.0525193177,
0.057263311,
-0.0811319351,
-0.010040774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18116v1 | Pair Programming with Large Language Models for Sampling and Estimation of Copulas | 2023-03-31T15:02:48 | 2023-03-31T15:02:48 | Jan Górecki | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.CO, 65C60, 68N19, 68T50 | Without writing a single line of code by a human, an example Monte Carlo
simulation based application for stochastic dependence modeling with copulas is
developed using a state-of-the-art large language model (LLM) fine-tuned for
conversations. This includes interaction with ChatGPT in natural language and
using mathematical formalism, which, under careful supervision by a
human-expert, led to producing a working code in MATLAB, Python and R for
sampling from a given copula model, evaluation of the model's density,
performing maximum likelihood estimation, optimizing the code for parallel
computing for CPUs as well as for GPUs, and visualization of the computed
results. In contrast to other emerging studies that assess the accuracy of LLMs
like ChatGPT on tasks from a selected area, this work rather investigates ways
how to achieve a successful solution of a standard statistical task in a
collaboration of a human-expert and artificial intelligence (AI). Particularly,
through careful prompt engineering, we separate successful solutions generated
by ChatGPT from unsuccessful ones, resulting in a comprehensive list of related
pros and cons. It is demonstrated that if the typical pitfalls are avoided, we
can substantially benefit from collaborating with an AI partner. For example,
we show that if ChatGPT is not able to provide a correct solution due to a lack
of or incorrect knowledge, the human-expert can feed it with the correct
knowledge, e.g., in the form of mathematical theorems and formulas, and make it
to apply the gained knowledge in order to provide a solution that is correct.
Such ability presents an attractive opportunity to achieve a programmed
solution even for users with rather limited knowledge of programming
techniques. | [
-0.003564507,
0.0672725216,
-0.0332412757,
0.0118376883,
-0.0686055496,
-0.0146271819,
0.0348180309,
-0.0194707233,
0.0042455317,
-0.0295592379,
-0.0027974646,
0.0069987117,
0.0241528116,
0.0444714427,
0.0044431412,
-0.0468042083,
0.0081970328,
-0.06139002,
0.0135858152,
-0.0252895635,
-0.0067737703,
-0.0241472535,
-0.0103614181,
0.0397382416,
-0.0122004841,
-0.0195792615,
-0.0061309971,
-0.0147494599,
-0.0380323566,
0.0002193215,
-0.0079418337,
0.0654458031,
0.0378653742,
0.0278154034,
0.0000025575,
-0.053538546,
-0.0292615816,
0.062007267,
-0.0147927515,
0.0153257512,
0.0206799153,
0.0224920176,
-0.0019777638,
0.0018304231,
-0.0292549469,
0.0592596941,
0.0393360816,
-0.0502318814,
0.0310605653,
0.001589591,
0.0061534471,
0.0570922717,
0.0321195126,
-0.0249849521,
-0.012237058,
-0.0322854817,
0.0158206597,
0.0883337334,
0.0545626804,
-0.0042805606,
-0.0447516367,
0.0563285276,
0.0448760539,
-0.0079213651,
0.002982381,
0.0463249162,
-0.0138795385,
-0.0109641133,
-0.0148363309,
0.0292525794,
0.0088300128,
0.0054731546,
0.0152155822,
-0.0169805065,
-0.0018821956,
0.0758111328,
-0.0741964579,
0.0247512106,
-0.0431484692,
-0.0226533171,
0.0196061991,
-0.031935934,
0.0001622716,
-0.0088836439,
-0.008792242,
0.0741667449,
-0.0072158664,
-0.0229740292,
-0.0067423745,
0.0149902105,
-0.0317939557,
-0.0464518517,
0.0206111223,
-0.0060192896,
-0.0442440771,
0.0037168365,
0.0035669478,
-0.0046355268,
0.0107687553,
-0.0194257982,
0.0320173278,
0.0102485782,
0.006443643,
0.0358446464,
0.0413240492,
-0.0271393992,
-0.0252109654,
-0.0109943021,
0.0237060674,
0.0296114199,
-0.0564122833,
-0.0224034972,
-0.0274805874,
0.0074796006,
-0.0296418797,
-0.0081838723,
-0.0434438549,
-0.0077392706,
-0.0103713386,
-0.0181921944,
0.0245970488,
0.0010174928,
-0.0299883857,
0.0090049654,
-0.0269885343,
0.0030432006,
-0.0448333025,
0.0158892423,
0.0046839565,
-0.0649975538,
0.0148473661,
0.033086773,
-0.0152038205,
-0.0445568264,
0.030297501,
0.0689530596,
0.028004488,
-0.0039821793,
0.0265709218,
-0.0024229356,
-0.029630065,
-0.0439613648,
-0.0304865781,
-0.0886228457,
0.0266116578,
0.0124672912,
0.0049142679,
-0.0183841269,
0.013294653,
0.0090269577,
-0.0296328608,
0.0631874129,
-0.0106595764,
-0.0167881604,
0.0586709343,
-0.0098548997,
-0.017314842,
0.0397057161,
0.0268296991,
0.0097294291,
-0.0059209578,
-0.0148966433,
0.076413855,
-0.0060271304,
-0.0047726422,
0.0385750271,
-0.0071186493,
-0.0280657634,
0.0340475254,
0.0068737511,
0.0405950397,
0.0342847295,
-0.0214725174,
0.0017933035,
0.060579583,
-0.0031243586,
-0.0185011346,
0.0385798477,
0.0799519867,
0.0304423589,
0.0358277857,
0.0024084621,
-0.0281705987,
0.0409868434,
-0.0387355424,
-0.0034276808,
0.0310142413,
0.0338112712,
0.009559188,
-0.0415985845,
0.0571449734,
-0.0229130816,
-0.0051060743,
-0.0495219454,
0.1152961925,
-0.0479362831,
-0.0154889477,
-0.0448264368,
0.0265929308,
0.0012858432,
-0.0258588698,
-0.0509224981,
0.0365534984,
0.0156571418,
0.0352465473,
-0.0280940589,
0.037280757,
-0.0178365875,
-0.0351870321,
0.0118006459,
0.0061728549,
0.0262840055,
-0.0172382221,
-0.0048197606,
-0.0016904841,
0.0056259325,
0.021448886,
0.0384098813,
0.0155500295,
0.0024378798,
0.0154233724,
0.0678083152,
0.0128292767,
-0.0031601388,
-0.054587204,
0.01570067,
-0.0161688775,
-0.0456811301,
0.0469408333,
-0.0225734673,
-0.0542152487,
0.0376868583,
-0.0018431877,
-0.029708419,
-0.0586899891,
0.0261762496,
-0.0013040184,
0.0194526855,
0.0207907464,
-0.020198606,
-0.0121580614,
-0.0688875616,
-0.0003615226,
0.0004890587,
0.0643401816,
-0.0215142295,
0.0084037771,
-0.0425083749,
-0.0045148362,
0.0212638099,
0.0163093898,
-0.014424935,
0.0385573767,
0.0196557418,
0.0066597755,
0.0284432042,
0.000903886,
0.0356398784,
-0.079056792,
0.0227656532,
-0.019427672,
0.0157219153,
0.0098079657,
0.0320824534,
0.0100337323,
-0.0049240063,
-0.014238351,
-0.0900043994,
0.0038093997,
-0.0101435604,
0.0273209065,
-0.0414041691,
-0.0372438207,
-0.0365603492,
0.0084577901,
-0.0085819168,
0.0213436969,
-0.0417772718,
-0.0131574115,
0.0250292085,
0.0029407085,
-0.0615290217,
-0.0585075691,
-0.0099918079,
-0.0196750537,
-0.002270129,
0.0618118644,
-0.0249535516,
-0.0194303878,
0.0302107986,
0.0054548248,
0.0352383368,
-0.0098440219,
-0.0178067666,
0.0172583945,
-0.0444779433,
0.0750506073,
0.0409366712,
-0.0279008616,
0.0458278768,
0.0156736914,
-0.0541273803,
-0.0267196801,
0.0372351818,
-0.0106291398,
-0.0135031091,
0.0195690691,
-0.032133881,
-0.0277737398,
0.0636727661,
-0.0024043145,
-0.0102401562,
0.0027297384,
0.0418189764,
-0.0319600329,
-0.0259377509,
-0.029511841,
0.005796364,
-0.01081031,
0.0168031044,
0.0189998951,
-0.0836093277,
0.0419444852,
-0.0420172811,
0.0086144861,
-0.04513539,
-0.0486230925,
-0.0008819742,
0.0285829101,
0.0093313353,
-0.0243656207,
-0.0281659625,
0.0258536525,
-0.0213844217,
0.0109007554,
0.0125321075,
-0.0260337014,
-0.0367696173,
-0.0946655795,
0.0332534276,
0.0394641384,
-0.0295273997,
0.0151517559,
-0.0215308107,
-0.0723334849,
-0.00021737,
0.0209757537,
-0.0576208793,
0.0131556541,
-0.0068076584,
0.0591059849,
0.0334556736,
-0.0102746999,
-0.0182620119,
-0.0115907425,
-0.0022716837,
0.0264712665,
-0.0079796575,
-0.0289838966,
-0.0546000972,
0.0058000642,
-0.0006369756,
0.0274324566,
0.0914264247,
-0.0420532376,
-0.030466415,
-0.0116457138,
0.0196895488,
-0.0472504757,
0.0391815193,
-0.0036426112,
-0.0143372584,
0.004702983,
0.0734211504,
0.0168689862,
-0.0160953272,
0.0071620713,
-0.0280218609,
0.002778074,
0.0086791096,
0.0274947863,
-0.0574571863,
0.0058342689,
0.0113623636,
-0.0008970015,
-0.0367432982,
-0.0382114761,
0.0047681038,
-0.0973642692,
0.0458913296,
-0.0098203812,
-0.0376864411,
-0.0336158164,
-0.1014242917,
0.0002041032,
-0.0375410058,
0.0015056065,
-0.0095541552,
0.0199262891,
0.0348763578,
0.0183955096,
-0.0650755167,
-0.0522411019,
0.0389977321,
-0.0315876119,
0.0742211118,
0.0338432975,
0.0368132219,
-0.0725440755,
0.0323464461,
0.0287509225,
0.0511908792,
0.0201240666,
0.0008972222,
0.012743053,
0.0364575982,
0.0105215497,
-0.0329059586,
0.0188905168,
-0.0063425847,
-0.023790231,
0.0412009694,
0.0591561645,
-0.0474858321,
-0.0368913636,
-0.009642574,
0.024143273,
0.057666216,
0.0563555174,
0.0340336412,
-0.0623155423,
-0.0230721701,
-0.0354843549,
-0.0449455902,
0.003954269,
0.0046368744,
0.0050455825,
0.0313238464,
-0.0500490777,
-0.0413404107,
-0.0082155913,
0.0522545427,
0.0314727835,
-0.0147057222,
0.029232746,
0.0551848523,
0.0177886616,
-0.0048056678,
0.0149236973,
-0.0424464308,
0.0369083397,
-0.040257562,
0.0158442371,
0.0131922923,
-0.0440902747,
-0.0419367999,
0.0655168518,
-0.0876374021,
-0.0475758687,
0.0127506768,
0.0795413181,
0.0333456397,
-0.0283937957,
-0.0130439634,
0.0027313265,
-0.058486592,
0.0961528793,
-0.0475559644,
0.0277563632,
-0.0395850278,
0.023254307,
0.0203933567,
-0.0242421702,
0.0291288719,
-0.0027697054,
-0.022841638,
0.0141022271,
-0.0424355157,
-0.065736793,
0.0057244077,
0.0498627648,
0.0228106845,
-0.0001614135,
0.0289496891,
-0.029629387,
-0.0059909923,
-0.0273430087,
0.0052272025,
-0.04891726,
-0.0421378575,
0.0119653968,
-0.016049128,
-0.0025602272,
-0.0260985848,
0.0001911294,
-0.002003185,
-0.0176289231,
0.0311675221,
0.0187998321,
0.0212124195,
0.0554842427,
-0.0453566723,
0.0348061025,
-0.0237430558,
0.01129195,
0.0809475332,
0.0459422171,
0.0509958751,
-0.011234466,
-0.0476726964,
0.02279648,
-0.0115104159,
-0.0159065891,
-0.0733508989,
-0.0127712451,
0.0830488876,
0.0518698059,
0.0095558017,
0.0067919423,
-0.0818303078,
0.0074697752,
-0.066701971,
0.0491942763,
0.0363145061,
0.0357608646,
0.0035016339,
-0.0061168824,
-0.0637287796,
-0.0073739085,
0.077693373,
0.0173217226,
-0.0104605742,
-0.0262578577,
-0.0378084704,
-0.0255894121,
-0.0047532064,
-0.0101782829,
-0.0102706281,
-0.0067038401,
0.0519790053,
-0.0791413188,
-0.0772391111,
-0.0467355624,
0.0287524816,
0.0098870592,
-0.0149509367,
-0.0033966193,
0.0581138693,
-0.0659414604,
0.0463066585,
-0.0324000157,
0.0816210657,
-0.026176475,
-0.0201964527,
-0.0066124075,
-6.878323644e-33,
-0.024578182,
-0.0271520838,
0.0084621748,
0.0472396277,
0.0395539291,
-0.0165590644,
-0.0210853387,
0.0111112678,
0.0177797396,
0.0199676566,
0.0088021336,
-0.0124245621,
0.0166018959,
-0.0153645948,
0.0350708328,
0.0150308665,
-0.0095843356,
0.013036496,
-0.0014003954,
-0.0159928259,
0.0213703904,
0.0087019596,
0.0002354091,
-0.1467552334,
0.0286919679,
0.01834061,
-0.0331966728,
-0.0309128147,
-0.0464954153,
0.0461965203,
0.0084993737,
0.0377329104,
-0.0035000991,
-0.0403662324,
-0.0108983358,
0.0268971957,
-0.0029716683,
-0.0300898328,
0.0204549804,
-0.0367145129,
-0.0406551249,
-0.0303815715,
0.0046836673,
0.0384737998,
-0.0210045408,
0.03695428,
0.0343646333,
-0.0411100313,
-0.0020179765,
0.0071276627,
-0.0239249635,
0.0364091434,
-0.0237273294,
0.0214503426,
-0.0007306912,
-0.0090542715,
-0.0676311702,
0.0148647791,
0.0372439176,
0.0132180685,
0.0679597184,
0.0297485292,
0.0656381547,
-0.0152684115,
0.0400559343,
0.0330545679,
-0.0011859849,
-0.0067748991,
-0.0228095334,
-0.0545380674,
0.0135902334,
0.0313190073,
0.014360534,
0.0706208274,
0.0116390716,
0.0332396999,
-0.1049296856,
0.0356263965,
0.0753649548,
-0.0435828269,
0.0267159753,
0.0080729723,
-0.049977798,
-0.0367366895,
-0.0480435155,
0.0066024247,
-0.0204855446,
-0.0254709981,
-0.005372725,
-0.0175356138,
-0.0187216327,
0.0124931913,
0.0230379291,
-0.0142675499,
-0.0320007242,
-0.056662377,
-0.0139846783,
0.0153864007,
0.0079553397,
0.0180031117,
-0.0680540577,
-0.0295762103,
-0.0408568718,
0.0422039703,
0.0465799011,
0.0257747173,
0.0187864657,
0.0240672361,
-0.0437360406,
-0.024731338,
-0.0317543335,
0.0198551733,
0.0455674641,
-0.0028459614,
0.0282141715,
0.0062627168,
-0.0159724616,
0.0089105153,
0.0113032423,
-0.0450775474,
-0.0181373134,
-0.0136890411,
-0.0361215025,
-0.0144884642,
0.0200154688,
-0.0430958942,
-0.0193795133,
-0.0389103629,
0.0209432878,
-0.0294844527,
-0.0127296085,
-0.0203301907,
3.225e-7,
0.0582894646,
0.0699286014,
-0.0069483318,
0.0290912203,
0.0430960581,
0.009429764,
-0.0387478769,
0.0261184741,
0.0278088842,
-0.0684017763,
0.0278613865,
0.047627639,
0.0510749482,
-0.0048929974,
-0.0559193268,
-0.0123768235,
-0.0578007437,
0.0040309285,
-0.060759332,
-0.0253920238,
0.035689313,
0.0546076111,
0.0439904146,
0.0071122623,
0.0118680866,
0.0010950316,
0.0439360216,
-0.055100061,
-0.0035910825,
0.0294503029,
-0.0671050772,
0.008584368,
0.0184772871,
0.1102937236,
0.0029899343,
-0.0422210917,
0.0534432232,
0.0992864072,
0.0212359894,
0.067493014,
0.0576011166,
-0.0299606957,
0.0103136841,
-0.0505462699,
0.0357976779,
-0.0417847335,
-0.0274413023,
0.0050832811,
-0.0096947709,
-0.0098293452,
0.050035052,
-0.0180877745,
0.0352213047,
-0.0150043964,
-0.0413696282,
0.0363956317,
0.0296153128,
0.0573052242,
-0.0225858167,
-0.0200522169,
-0.0563516021,
-0.1031157374,
-0.0336046964,
-0.0424881317,
0.0365905091,
-0.0395165049,
0.0370100215,
3.03297907e-34,
0.0604843087,
0.0407793596,
0.007438628,
-0.0088577503,
0.0371683016,
0.0278606564,
-0.0437011272,
0.0242435187,
0.0133037856,
-0.0297110472,
-0.0234213788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18110v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18110v1 | The Edinburgh International Accents of English Corpus: Towards the Democratization of English ASR | 2023-03-31T14:56:54 | 2023-03-31T14:56:54 | Ramon Sanabria, Nikolay Bogoychev, Nina Markl, Andrea Carmantini, Ondrej Klejch, Peter Bell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | English is the most widely spoken language in the world, used daily by
millions of people as a first or second language in many different contexts. As
a result, there are many varieties of English. Although the great many advances
in English automatic speech recognition (ASR) over the past decades, results
are usually reported based on test datasets which fail to represent the
diversity of English as spoken today around the globe. We present the first
release of The Edinburgh International Accents of English Corpus (EdAcc). This
dataset attempts to better represent the wide diversity of English,
encompassing almost 40 hours of dyadic video call conversations between
friends. Unlike other datasets, EdAcc includes a wide range of first and
second-language varieties of English and a linguistic background profile of
each speaker. Results on latest public, and commercial models show that EdAcc
highlights shortcomings of current English ASR models. The best performing
model, trained on 680 thousand hours of transcribed data, obtains an average of
19.7% word error rate (WER) -- in contrast to the 2.7% WER obtained when
evaluated on US English clean read speech. Across all models, we observe a drop
in performance on Indian, Jamaican, and Nigerian English speakers. Recordings,
linguistic backgrounds, data statement, and evaluation scripts are released on
our website (https://groups.inf.ed.ac.uk/edacc/) under CC-BY-SA license. | [
-0.0080047091,
0.0726559013,
0.0042884955,
0.0185852572,
-0.0294788349,
-0.0112886429,
0.0198589787,
-0.0202678796,
-0.0034927726,
0.0204878617,
-0.0654658452,
-0.0650880858,
0.0768197104,
0.0167394318,
0.0133506609,
-0.0359244607,
0.0060670283,
-0.0463186279,
0.0014556331,
-0.0426964238,
0.0384707376,
0.0273203254,
-0.0152672632,
0.0378553905,
-0.0365850665,
0.0254803449,
-0.0096026808,
0.0161196347,
0.0383174568,
0.0201891903,
-0.0139218457,
0.0270622429,
-0.0223271083,
-0.0012427414,
0.0000019612,
-0.0189217087,
0.0153241968,
-0.0295389183,
-0.0590186939,
0.0367997624,
0.0210335273,
0.053961385,
-0.005123158,
0.0477827191,
-0.0210187864,
0.0044034859,
0.083401069,
-0.0229210947,
0.0034054902,
0.0358697511,
0.0003318264,
-0.0271094758,
0.0144531587,
-0.0167424455,
-0.0462945029,
-0.0018338842,
-0.0039210673,
-0.0380709507,
-0.0093683936,
-0.0269585103,
0.0011793654,
0.0172837097,
-0.0104196398,
-0.0259745046,
0.0055500139,
-0.0040963315,
-0.0370356701,
-0.0437445231,
-0.0016194776,
0.0576321483,
-0.0263830405,
-0.0282144081,
0.0205637999,
0.0162426215,
-0.0429645628,
-0.0122134248,
0.0182240214,
0.0128142117,
-0.0190980025,
-0.0066889543,
0.0220207609,
0.0507110283,
0.010061671,
-0.0008763112,
0.0046718935,
0.0215977244,
0.0251425151,
-0.0206936896,
0.0282931086,
-0.0085884454,
0.0236568153,
0.0332062319,
0.0660066232,
-0.0334043019,
0.0246597771,
-0.0127565255,
0.0386991501,
-0.0075632483,
0.0066115861,
-0.0212565381,
0.035639748,
0.0268192478,
-0.0487631187,
-0.0146421734,
0.0276509356,
0.0430301018,
0.0024381224,
0.0095139733,
-0.0030796577,
0.0066682626,
-0.0328856446,
0.0001410033,
-0.0002794954,
-0.0036983518,
-0.0338120423,
0.00085596,
-0.0304479115,
-0.0310513712,
-0.030599311,
-0.0058959452,
0.040403273,
-0.0112140803,
-0.0178891215,
-0.0413415059,
0.0547144637,
0.0353426002,
-0.0010571296,
0.0677864105,
-0.0153049277,
-0.1261882931,
0.0108924638,
-0.004993076,
0.0228611268,
0.0160518177,
0.0163641069,
-0.0207796786,
0.0206246562,
-0.0506927595,
-0.0241803695,
0.0132610435,
-0.0709226504,
-0.040427044,
-0.0312640928,
-0.045387689,
0.0641486943,
-0.0186015218,
0.0196608733,
-0.0216551144,
-0.0169469342,
-0.0253536999,
0.0353137329,
0.058195781,
0.0016703581,
0.0413360223,
0.0817873701,
0.0108927367,
0.0406711213,
0.0272431541,
-0.0014800491,
-0.0227366164,
0.003071225,
-0.0217313711,
0.0126666846,
0.0630283356,
-0.0046911263,
0.0089993533,
0.0013524345,
-0.035678111,
-0.0487835929,
0.0188748837,
0.0415559337,
0.0286739785,
-0.0258169528,
-0.0204499494,
0.0352524333,
0.0205745343,
-0.0102344882,
0.0073967385,
0.0127694299,
0.0505874939,
0.0261498876,
-0.0288850311,
0.0063783494,
-0.0359044932,
0.0204751864,
-0.0028947953,
-0.0121182157,
0.0645306781,
-0.0517952256,
0.0136666605,
-0.0023446379,
-0.0445083417,
-0.0071531325,
0.0412526801,
0.0232073963,
-0.0291490331,
0.0096268458,
0.002085692,
0.0016654992,
-0.049132634,
0.0264603496,
-0.0647694096,
0.009460384,
0.0173750725,
-0.0064656567,
0.0009532509,
-0.0107661253,
-0.0321898162,
-0.0089569539,
0.0055345492,
0.0007737202,
-0.0287905633,
0.0954426602,
-0.0757368878,
0.0393618308,
0.0660232157,
-0.0190172475,
0.0245595761,
-0.0304997414,
0.033006914,
0.0074004433,
-0.030809341,
-0.0000296416,
-0.0260233115,
-0.015508919,
0.0070719826,
0.0494247377,
0.0027408197,
0.0685809851,
0.0700264722,
-0.0580754504,
-0.0199313909,
0.0208668299,
-0.0290618222,
0.0597130321,
0.0527485833,
-0.0514440238,
-0.0177265387,
0.0616680719,
-0.077883333,
0.0340792686,
0.0524461679,
0.0145199737,
-0.1133281291,
0.0411991961,
-0.0262094662,
0.0264577921,
-0.0425840728,
0.084837988,
0.0049676108,
0.017750198,
0.0391326733,
-0.0337848999,
0.0004137359,
-0.0349941999,
-0.0088517331,
0.0189854633,
-0.0050804676,
-0.087133497,
-0.0037196171,
0.0320641249,
0.0042091785,
0.0263352692,
0.0167842899,
-0.0125770122,
-0.0424604416,
-0.008253633,
-0.0958513096,
-0.0160760637,
0.0038054679,
0.0163413137,
-0.026523279,
0.0366450362,
-0.0146625424,
-0.0263552032,
-0.0300937481,
-0.0301921256,
-0.0150265303,
0.0026523711,
-0.0799669102,
-0.0128183663,
-0.011697161,
-0.0300519001,
-0.0337751731,
0.0191645343,
-0.0168128219,
-0.0420995206,
-0.0246307459,
-0.0201814417,
-0.0642721877,
0.0476676449,
-0.00341888,
0.0091503356,
-0.0613271035,
-0.0502600335,
0.0084592188,
0.0119408937,
0.0028614858,
0.0050590667,
-0.0255857632,
-0.0164620802,
-0.0249999557,
-0.0375161618,
-0.0213891193,
0.0145375831,
0.0443471484,
0.0174698737,
-0.0445965789,
-0.0435177349,
0.036888063,
0.0234397743,
0.0364999771,
-0.0475829504,
-0.0237623882,
0.0058890306,
-0.0453968346,
-0.0362630449,
-0.0395014882,
-0.0591400079,
0.0047518336,
-0.0330220275,
-0.0227444954,
0.0092807915,
-0.0871622935,
-0.0363305993,
-0.0488742404,
-0.0245266818,
-0.0036850586,
-0.0206574406,
-0.0084809111,
0.0066054291,
0.0044149188,
-0.0601919964,
0.0325244889,
0.0295196753,
0.0133769829,
-0.0408580676,
0.0421314202,
-0.0514079891,
-0.0088969199,
0.0111235781,
-0.0440742895,
0.0379196256,
-0.0412066467,
-0.0698488206,
0.0099627692,
0.0099816266,
-0.0407070331,
0.0636638403,
0.0095158797,
-0.0131420866,
0.0385405086,
-0.0139667857,
0.0435674936,
0.0070580719,
0.0248760264,
0.0429175682,
0.0410842001,
-0.0472790226,
-0.0047499044,
0.0644793436,
-0.0479358286,
0.0313344449,
0.0140104434,
-0.0346744694,
0.0023042327,
0.0445072576,
0.0067520821,
-0.0321312174,
-0.0018223596,
0.0546812899,
0.0146089345,
-0.0061375774,
0.0625622496,
-0.005110587,
-0.0241476614,
-0.0059870821,
-0.039337974,
0.0244525447,
0.0032241913,
-0.0280068535,
-0.0665945336,
-0.0226274896,
0.064492695,
0.0299687218,
-0.0046468992,
0.0081560602,
0.0007956217,
-0.0992751122,
0.0335794576,
0.0155007914,
-0.0335542671,
-0.0122803915,
-0.0256310552,
-0.0478619747,
-0.0501230657,
0.0202912688,
0.0169864129,
0.0146458661,
-0.0433720089,
0.0652801022,
-0.077369839,
-0.0788768008,
0.0644840598,
-0.0126987947,
0.1015608609,
0.0329263806,
-0.0004671189,
-0.0366612002,
-0.067017749,
-0.0170005076,
-0.0524468571,
-0.005990997,
-0.0322490036,
0.0349344164,
0.0511739776,
-0.0141304405,
-0.0121281501,
0.0469908044,
-0.0008832245,
0.011452619,
0.0227304138,
0.0360309035,
-0.0394325629,
0.0054165353,
0.0242854133,
0.0034513585,
0.0411985442,
0.0363825932,
0.0312079862,
-0.055596035,
-0.0048846845,
0.045014888,
0.0509151705,
-0.038534075,
-0.0416740105,
0.0603400879,
0.0204488672,
-0.0638594255,
-0.000830936,
-0.0241316427,
0.0099324193,
0.0214735363,
0.0307875313,
-0.0248919465,
-0.0073444853,
0.0030677191,
0.0156894624,
0.0096165035,
0.0000070693,
0.0588114224,
-0.0714266226,
0.0213600975,
0.0278139599,
-0.0355771743,
0.0031245321,
-0.0254826322,
-0.017604325,
-0.0702573955,
0.0961202532,
0.0194699764,
0.0224799868,
0.0491258428,
-0.0266760606,
-0.0794414654,
0.0197160952,
-0.0376681313,
0.0190438535,
-0.0186949894,
0.0309917647,
0.0031890972,
-0.0342585519,
0.0263309907,
-0.0036517559,
0.0610649884,
-0.0120660095,
-0.02699917,
-0.0807708129,
-0.0533080474,
-0.021428667,
0.0227609035,
0.0600189865,
-0.044505775,
-0.0270904694,
-0.0545476936,
0.004077517,
0.0181965418,
0.0804461166,
-0.0199744571,
-0.0345518701,
0.0503489003,
0.0135137895,
-0.022340985,
-0.0012884168,
-0.035945069,
-0.019123802,
0.0108503448,
0.0894440934,
0.0346724875,
0.0554243103,
0.0186215919,
0.0109652085,
-0.0275126528,
0.058807198,
0.0071279909,
0.0420194566,
0.0337780677,
0.0197741166,
-0.02462155,
-0.0179426558,
0.0411042422,
0.0336630754,
0.0021550199,
0.0061659361,
-0.003156235,
0.0316202119,
0.0498196445,
-0.0273073595,
0.0756296441,
0.0215426981,
0.0367150865,
-0.0466929115,
0.0249733422,
-0.016283676,
-0.0020675256,
0.0605761446,
-0.0179158151,
-0.0305020958,
0.0431910753,
0.0456511453,
-0.0183877293,
0.0020957703,
0.0101347473,
0.0388039947,
-0.0288174078,
-0.0299437642,
-0.0113754617,
-0.0222747549,
-0.0497370772,
-0.0182961412,
-0.0142339291,
-0.0748351887,
0.0324182883,
0.0031925526,
0.0408839025,
-0.0050496818,
0.0179495234,
-0.015853554,
-0.0372608565,
-0.0025813447,
-0.0175111741,
-0.04637466,
-0.0244506821,
-0.0358435363,
0.0164665505,
-6.001311553e-33,
0.0319877528,
0.0612215549,
-0.0257997196,
0.0062489971,
-0.0250148345,
0.0321377963,
-0.0056777564,
0.0248646364,
-0.0425677337,
-0.0019187052,
-0.0530283898,
0.0087361531,
0.0362022296,
0.0284277424,
0.0441008359,
0.0234849304,
0.0389487185,
0.0016450866,
0.0232860781,
-0.0072813947,
0.0391401798,
0.0394424163,
0.0518537648,
-0.0584090985,
-0.0243874844,
0.0172561742,
-0.0305849034,
-0.0004072288,
0.030501537,
0.0285287909,
-0.0123250717,
0.0700227991,
0.0006153415,
-0.0283318479,
-0.0145642264,
0.0369624719,
-0.0744193271,
0.0122387223,
-0.0102364169,
0.0749506131,
-0.0013455974,
-0.0341556035,
0.0061822939,
0.000211459,
-0.0727383643,
0.0009915316,
-0.0227159094,
-0.0191108342,
0.009384796,
0.0024721108,
0.0041180295,
0.061310593,
-0.0249538906,
0.0093587078,
0.0609221682,
0.0392307676,
-0.0273749046,
-0.0717879012,
-0.0867569968,
0.0267167445,
0.0125622572,
0.0287122205,
0.0571862794,
0.0133141084,
-0.0272137187,
0.0072172331,
0.0688994005,
-0.0830776989,
0.0296929274,
-0.0140745537,
0.0342164822,
0.0310418289,
-0.009325427,
0.0545388013,
0.0463253036,
-0.0734465867,
0.0139704114,
0.002427262,
0.0638921037,
0.0235107914,
-0.0324610025,
-0.002360598,
-0.0483245552,
-0.0252349135,
-0.021072479,
0.0100402562,
-0.0208701994,
-0.0186212379,
0.0571384393,
-0.0348898321,
0.0215950813,
0.029126605,
0.0747626722,
-0.0153203234,
0.0003162436,
-0.0197030306,
0.0035794086,
0.0133808414,
-0.0018671621,
0.0613325015,
-0.0642188489,
-0.0143991858,
-0.0035033752,
0.0709600747,
0.0336450152,
-0.0041400231,
0.0068376716,
0.055057276,
-0.088071838,
-0.0066208201,
0.0040535866,
0.0297362469,
0.0059590572,
0.0171270277,
0.035380993,
-0.006621473,
-0.0084130429,
0.0235833712,
0.0108393328,
0.0416960083,
0.0346419178,
-0.0702822655,
0.0028765809,
0.0229980871,
-0.029964583,
0.0257597733,
0.004539737,
-0.0558874421,
-0.0101517932,
0.0080248546,
0.0069297468,
0.0091457153,
2.608e-7,
-0.0346581601,
-0.0037996343,
0.0403029732,
-0.0172426999,
-0.0042139767,
-0.0014824895,
0.003809144,
-0.0235412326,
-0.0152572868,
0.0271495953,
0.0093541229,
-0.0409698412,
0.1188414171,
0.0086531928,
-0.0798085108,
-0.0266216472,
-0.0814178735,
0.0334609747,
-0.0107683493,
0.0049242522,
-0.0041934117,
0.0856833383,
-0.0052205035,
-0.0604474209,
-0.0326252989,
-0.0211453494,
-0.000643658,
-0.0330815539,
0.0143248802,
0.0093341842,
0.0481300615,
-0.0290445704,
-0.0079800095,
0.0356507637,
-0.0461669043,
0.0587017126,
-0.0156059284,
0.0393326804,
-0.0590224043,
-0.0083965007,
0.0104253571,
0.0229888707,
-0.0505519137,
-0.0271244962,
0.0552647598,
0.0639385059,
-0.0442165434,
-0.0198541153,
-0.0493752509,
0.0019588952,
0.0267558079,
-0.0077643362,
0.0356917866,
0.0065532248,
0.0012440979,
-0.0645437464,
-0.024250919,
-0.0247946549,
0.0159305688,
0.0350785069,
-0.0214395951,
0.027224252,
0.0074933944,
0.031947419,
-0.0134590045,
-0.0328216553,
-0.0007630723,
1.626319393e-34,
0.0177155137,
-0.0100643104,
0.0525622219,
0.0421633497,
0.0057585016,
-0.0268924087,
0.039337676,
0.02931091,
-0.0023866515,
-0.0232054945,
-0.0305365846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18103v1 | Dataset and Baseline System for Multi-lingual Extraction and Normalization of Temporal and Numerical Expressions | 2023-03-31T14:49:05 | 2023-03-31T14:49:05 | Sanxing Chen, Yongqiang Chen, Börje F. Karlsson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Temporal and numerical expression understanding is of great importance in
many downstream Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Information Retrieval
(IR) tasks. However, much previous work covers only a few sub-types and focuses
only on entity extraction, which severely limits the usability of identified
mentions. In order for such entities to be useful in downstream scenarios,
coverage and granularity of sub-types are important; and, even more so,
providing resolution into concrete values that can be manipulated. Furthermore,
most previous work addresses only a handful of languages. Here we describe a
multi-lingual evaluation dataset - NTX - covering diverse temporal and
numerical expressions across 14 languages and covering extraction,
normalization, and resolution. Along with the dataset we provide a robust
rule-based system as a strong baseline for comparisons against other models to
be evaluated in this dataset. Data and code are available at
\url{https://aka.ms/NTX}. | [
0.022073634,
0.0668960065,
0.004321726,
0.0430288799,
-0.029759381,
0.0049252925,
0.0260420684,
0.0142971845,
-0.0277240332,
-0.0165165253,
-0.0163489413,
-0.0327367596,
-0.0026382613,
0.0356740132,
0.0110730501,
-0.0397876874,
0.0468575172,
0.0003674577,
0.0204929244,
0.0477275252,
0.0242574923,
0.0210386831,
-0.022162281,
0.0559720211,
-0.023677513,
0.0031800927,
0.0413981192,
-0.0431025885,
0.0483415537,
-0.0134237092,
0.0147586549,
0.0304401889,
0.0038345491,
0.0064590476,
0.0000017196,
-0.0357653648,
-0.0293150134,
-0.0079641333,
-0.0014645822,
0.0247456431,
0.0498936512,
-0.0309857465,
-0.0129153477,
-0.0123016071,
-0.0655675679,
-0.0649211109,
0.0355333015,
0.020294778,
0.0200039688,
0.0688112527,
-0.0314426199,
-0.0108818626,
-0.0065017683,
0.0063329893,
-0.0075257202,
-0.0560167246,
0.0035247859,
0.0127795702,
0.0100674946,
-0.00960497,
0.0532908998,
0.0374788456,
-0.0018850435,
-0.0234739501,
-0.0096350117,
0.0158600304,
-0.041948963,
0.004149063,
-0.0168180764,
0.0442835055,
0.0161945298,
0.0032004414,
-0.0024055822,
0.0250425655,
-0.0292311739,
-0.0359860547,
-0.0367139988,
-0.020738028,
-0.0061514345,
0.0083086062,
0.0262541659,
0.0490876883,
-0.0035441713,
0.0353242494,
0.0076798424,
0.0491732769,
0.0219862349,
0.0065308437,
0.0033742101,
-0.0025083749,
0.0364657603,
-0.0018076585,
0.0669924989,
0.0116788922,
0.0254811998,
0.0135697983,
-0.00474098,
-0.012138458,
0.0109693939,
-0.0842837095,
-0.0113947773,
0.0350720137,
-0.0392288119,
0.0605659112,
-0.0454349071,
0.0405772179,
-0.02538714,
-0.0392421819,
-0.0160043649,
-0.0236087851,
-0.0564134382,
0.0068535381,
-0.0105010727,
0.0291127972,
-0.0431572311,
0.025373999,
-0.056645412,
0.0051608053,
-0.0206942987,
0.011869845,
0.0107149445,
-0.0163921826,
0.0004496251,
0.0093678012,
-0.0464658514,
0.0508530736,
-0.0460349284,
-0.0131507581,
-0.0550916791,
-0.0900063291,
-0.0298794433,
0.0003263639,
0.0338528976,
-0.0544289984,
-0.0047305808,
0.0522960685,
-0.025900444,
-0.0211394969,
-0.0283417031,
-0.0396008529,
-0.0161630232,
-0.0457508117,
-0.0184621681,
-0.078803651,
0.0628174841,
-0.0029688117,
-0.0204421803,
-0.064880237,
0.0222146586,
0.0027875009,
-0.0004318179,
0.0771698803,
0.0042348653,
0.0034040329,
-0.0237670299,
-0.0188867338,
0.0566963293,
0.0651592091,
0.0365117975,
-0.0321342051,
0.0631308258,
0.0010638054,
-0.0317498781,
0.0762480795,
-0.0055105444,
-0.0271669626,
-0.0433762223,
0.0111172656,
0.0122485552,
0.0030352462,
0.0355783142,
0.035414163,
-0.0193713252,
-0.0209702514,
-0.0013384252,
0.0095181912,
-0.048746407,
-0.0085130651,
0.0827716738,
-0.0175800342,
0.0431613438,
-0.0341154598,
0.0096880123,
3.874e-7,
0.0102314865,
0.0294805001,
-0.032323774,
0.0576550849,
-0.0288651437,
-0.0323941596,
-0.0033211408,
-0.0060942867,
0.0172525346,
-0.0034520396,
0.0680017546,
-0.0206099227,
-0.015043146,
0.0743124634,
0.0297410842,
-0.0266295485,
0.0207336061,
0.0102683594,
-0.0278963111,
0.0619127788,
0.0246428642,
-0.0555424318,
-0.0409887508,
0.0003563942,
0.0006151291,
0.0346281528,
0.033765357,
-0.0345956087,
0.046442721,
-0.0456980132,
-0.0167241842,
0.0256661158,
0.0019554349,
0.006119031,
0.0178352576,
0.0185988825,
0.0206360463,
-0.0300340038,
-0.040380843,
0.0324052498,
-0.0238268003,
-0.0422878712,
-0.0024765083,
0.0075084032,
0.0281621162,
0.0834507719,
0.0012145531,
0.0002151034,
0.0499554165,
-0.0480026156,
0.048212193,
0.0730216429,
0.0116212079,
-0.0466926843,
0.0687322766,
-0.0185422469,
-0.0476571321,
0.0005598209,
-0.0206441395,
-0.0389076062,
0.0070743822,
0.0289890952,
0.0320166871,
-0.0552906692,
0.0057260375,
0.0151173165,
0.0337134786,
-0.0261940714,
0.0508369319,
0.0042478042,
0.038907215,
0.004104353,
-0.0519101769,
0.027435286,
-0.0178983938,
-0.0246610977,
0.0134879341,
-0.0185872931,
-0.0360822715,
0.0274739601,
0.0162034035,
-0.0465148874,
-0.0023192128,
-0.0861253589,
-0.0127334557,
-0.0258934554,
0.0827969611,
0.0047986601,
0.0391541161,
-0.0142137101,
-0.0110039189,
-0.0164467786,
-0.0527664833,
-0.0049956008,
0.0121274451,
0.0671972185,
0.0391637832,
-0.0135227013,
-0.0290192924,
0.006396967,
-0.0541576259,
0.0532997884,
-0.0033464159,
-0.0786125436,
-0.0234456975,
0.0081142979,
-0.0411645807,
0.01958156,
0.0124520669,
-0.0061740526,
-0.0087339785,
0.0026486074,
0.0522308163,
0.0162701067,
-0.0307285469,
0.0378065705,
-0.0044194367,
-0.0559178405,
-0.0641131029,
0.0253633633,
-0.0148131112,
0.0095831947,
-0.0342217833,
-0.0169711523,
-0.0134377684,
0.0486781821,
-0.0174807552,
0.0074268826,
-0.0168789402,
0.0046916376,
-0.0423177332,
-0.013142731,
0.0104772039,
0.0463379323,
-0.0286460035,
0.038003929,
-0.0280068535,
0.0049712397,
0.0738544837,
-0.0149872471,
-0.049288176,
-0.0088401055,
-0.0229486134,
-0.0765590146,
0.0796980709,
-0.0226602945,
-0.0012113431,
0.0169550609,
-0.0708329901,
0.0056813546,
0.0022806178,
0.0126143405,
-0.0192739069,
0.0556640513,
-0.0328062885,
0.0276925005,
-0.0169847813,
-0.023917336,
0.0041910787,
-0.0451653264,
-0.0250296071,
0.0215438884,
-0.0112458412,
0.0149397645,
-0.0396439098,
0.0229723416,
-0.0157936346,
0.025872536,
-0.0284100231,
0.0003005083,
-0.0132043697,
0.047319863,
0.0277936477,
0.000452919,
-0.0285771694,
0.0250465907,
-0.0236242004,
-0.0024430195,
0.0307410955,
-0.0433769897,
-0.0390714779,
0.0036771176,
0.0175410565,
-0.0515695885,
0.0181001034,
-0.0251897238,
0.0297484063,
-0.0744774565,
0.0131988777,
0.0823813006,
0.0126921711,
-0.0335002504,
-0.0083762622,
-0.0135470424,
-0.0022800413,
0.0135138687,
0.0060395114,
-0.0822549984,
-0.0059655709,
-0.0204719882,
-0.0254190043,
0.0124016479,
-0.0468669683,
0.0150885675,
-0.0978471413,
0.0058987266,
0.0071306322,
-0.0655797645,
-0.0346307904,
-0.0536141582,
0.0006996166,
-0.0730505735,
-0.0030544419,
0.0069638551,
-0.0067955307,
0.0075971428,
0.0118287513,
-0.0364470519,
-0.0853752717,
0.0634181648,
-0.0233980417,
0.0344616733,
0.0032868281,
0.0653369874,
-0.0119859893,
-0.015411308,
-0.0033502157,
-0.0161220971,
-0.0217589382,
-0.02596136,
0.026391644,
0.0111441659,
-0.0383565351,
-0.0061842003,
0.0138576254,
-0.0099928435,
0.0047634887,
0.0036097863,
0.0786634982,
0.0054107029,
0.056530308,
-0.0065675029,
-0.0225680489,
0.0246859323,
0.0512845181,
-0.0178270899,
-0.0025676975,
-0.0328736566,
-0.0071018515,
-0.0036385532,
-0.0930593759,
-0.041688554,
-0.0305387601,
-0.0622285977,
-0.0289156903,
-0.0614939854,
-0.069754608,
0.0259074159,
0.0290342439,
-0.0006616376,
0.0020441294,
0.0094258012,
0.0392957218,
-0.0580488741,
0.0590803809,
0.0024054078,
0.0172080807,
-0.0137349078,
0.0166332275,
-0.0028226685,
0.0190678164,
-0.0200095847,
0.0498969331,
-0.0351534411,
-0.0570130758,
-0.0130980201,
0.0067802565,
0.014213942,
0.0436078347,
-0.0173938219,
-0.0070963581,
-0.0062134941,
0.0066233892,
-0.0236238055,
-0.0529451892,
0.0311403815,
0.0361174382,
-0.0118380832,
0.0190403294,
-0.0363600701,
0.0124092568,
-0.0491112806,
0.0745808855,
-0.0293803979,
-0.0171720982,
0.020351449,
0.0291607957,
0.0393265337,
0.0049388944,
-0.0162204094,
-0.0333538689,
-0.0105840564,
-0.0527759753,
-0.0015105892,
-0.008452164,
0.0460857004,
-0.0053783092,
0.0013585259,
-0.0314236768,
0.0113981599,
-0.0056503601,
0.0068293619,
-0.0203246996,
0.0272504985,
0.0232014917,
0.0296985656,
-0.0261959117,
0.008472329,
-0.0137504674,
0.0250586402,
-0.0133583928,
0.0050971108,
-0.042066548,
-0.0409480929,
-0.0131103685,
0.0320060216,
-0.0043208594,
-0.0094821565,
-0.0150269447,
0.0630538464,
-0.0139888274,
-0.034134306,
0.0747042969,
-0.0254059769,
0.1092565283,
0.0053497013,
-0.0258592311,
0.0197040793,
0.0250895135,
-0.0050158137,
0.0125133684,
-0.00948493,
0.0107955923,
-0.0269480702,
-0.0242253244,
0.068849802,
0.0005376179,
0.048313275,
0.0315107405,
-0.0400195643,
-0.0311602764,
-0.0259516425,
-0.0340669006,
-0.0259313472,
-0.0285452791,
-0.0379701704,
-0.0670774579,
-0.032557331,
0.0366915911,
0.0186329298,
-0.0391629636,
0.0126772765,
0.006069371,
0.0560929589,
0.0549255423,
-0.0265524033,
-0.0379404984,
0.0175442565,
0.0278906096,
-0.0309772324,
-0.0754506811,
-5.614737012e-33,
-0.0198150221,
0.0087347627,
0.0198496021,
0.0113158077,
-0.0243645757,
0.0381491482,
-0.0149740716,
-0.0206219889,
-0.017559085,
0.01616049,
-0.0207740944,
-0.0121901575,
0.0549253263,
-0.0128481649,
0.0430472679,
-0.0088551939,
0.0061987382,
-0.0085922973,
0.0042250757,
0.0024302478,
0.0842692256,
0.0507456735,
0.1473949701,
-0.0753830299,
0.0754193813,
0.0587533079,
-0.0141410595,
0.0424032807,
0.0847397298,
0.0758539662,
-0.0025673928,
0.0473335907,
0.00338743,
-0.0245861225,
-0.0298003945,
-0.0172701683,
-0.152973175,
-0.0445425101,
0.0388921164,
0.0430976041,
0.0081481123,
-0.0301194154,
0.0035785297,
-0.0370830484,
-0.0280067362,
0.0278227739,
0.0331155434,
-0.0397002809,
0.0074056103,
-0.0705814287,
-0.0726237223,
0.0641058013,
-0.0176826715,
0.0436821915,
0.0994732007,
0.0398586579,
0.0101860026,
-0.018816784,
-0.076297611,
0.0281162038,
-0.046909377,
0.0340437219,
0.0365061946,
-0.0249583665,
0.0265568234,
0.0245647803,
0.0087906457,
0.0043677362,
-0.0049251756,
0.0026214835,
0.0458103865,
0.0195607506,
-0.0020119748,
0.0242696796,
0.0147047667,
-0.0052237357,
-0.0559708253,
0.0384630784,
0.0792968348,
0.0608006679,
-0.0330173448,
-0.0183048751,
-0.0412676781,
0.0226609632,
0.0224802643,
-0.0130882841,
-0.017617885,
-0.0374355502,
0.0066482183,
-0.0081259329,
0.0180618055,
0.0727537423,
0.0402960368,
0.0029371239,
-0.0455216207,
0.0397663452,
0.0199831501,
0.0273115635,
0.0100070545,
-0.0088894656,
-0.0470373258,
-0.0598541349,
-0.0086696995,
0.0001853283,
0.041402813,
-0.0242990665,
0.0042429985,
0.0244914386,
-0.053512007,
-0.0113223381,
-0.0172255374,
0.0037939141,
-0.0314398482,
0.0183092542,
0.0251856707,
-0.0178978555,
-0.0070745298,
0.0188938603,
0.0665047616,
0.0334516317,
-0.0142438747,
0.005913612,
0.0521206856,
0.0403294377,
-0.0020769411,
-0.0018836624,
-0.0348167717,
0.0256354231,
0.0224061701,
0.0171360858,
0.0064156121,
0.031744808,
2.379e-7,
0.0506443828,
0.0219446048,
0.0398859866,
0.0626327097,
-0.0201552603,
-0.0338386334,
0.0062185279,
0.0013621267,
-0.0334317945,
0.0418560766,
0.0297425762,
-0.0281593855,
0.0271046609,
0.0534553565,
-0.0720640495,
-0.0545567572,
-0.0392454974,
-0.0542024821,
-0.0549903922,
-0.0106697399,
0.0109525174,
0.0816228539,
0.0169061031,
0.0239987206,
-0.0536349341,
-0.0538361184,
0.05280184,
-0.0122807492,
-0.0535673872,
0.0401480012,
0.0728072077,
-0.0076050973,
-0.0133726308,
0.0012246692,
-0.0166009292,
0.0399681143,
0.0382599458,
0.0734028444,
-0.0159830637,
0.0083472533,
-0.0120493677,
-0.0765918046,
-0.0131079508,
-0.0202918332,
0.0550520681,
-0.0037431868,
-0.0209031608,
-0.0116592543,
-0.0169292968,
0.0452353433,
0.0262489878,
-0.0003983987,
-0.0260670241,
0.0392167754,
0.0284830742,
-0.0220518839,
-0.0498599894,
-0.0670605153,
-0.0534360483,
0.060124103,
0.0068563223,
0.0098546539,
0.0119514419,
-0.0349096693,
-0.0025310013,
-0.0288220346,
-0.0003740724,
2.433491875e-34,
0.0304513555,
0.0092863217,
-0.0198663846,
0.0671285838,
0.0328107849,
-0.0275139548,
-0.0270031057,
0.0314356908,
-0.018777879,
-0.0331284739,
0.0073789735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18049v1 | No Place to Hide: Dual Deep Interaction Channel Network for Fake News Detection based on Data Augmentation | 2023-03-31T13:33:53 | 2023-03-31T13:33:53 | Biwei Cao, Lulu Hua, Jiuxin Cao, Jie Gui, Bo Liu, James Tin-Yau Kwok | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online Social Network (OSN) has become a hotbed of fake news due to the low
cost of information dissemination. Although the existing methods have made many
attempts in news content and propagation structure, the detection of fake news
is still facing two challenges: one is how to mine the unique key features and
evolution patterns, and the other is how to tackle the problem of small samples
to build the high-performance model. Different from popular methods which take
full advantage of the propagation topology structure, in this paper, we propose
a novel framework for fake news detection from perspectives of semantic,
emotion and data enhancement, which excavates the emotional evolution patterns
of news participants during the propagation process, and a dual deep
interaction channel network of semantic and emotion is designed to obtain a
more comprehensive and fine-grained news representation with the consideration
of comments. Meanwhile, the framework introduces a data enhancement module to
obtain more labeled data with high quality based on confidence which further
improves the performance of the classification model. Experiments show that the
proposed approach outperforms the state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0628618076,
0.0523040742,
-0.0216338299,
0.0647140518,
-0.0087193828,
0.0121707227,
-0.0338041298,
-0.0003691802,
-0.017115863,
-0.007696629,
-0.0199269522,
-0.0228676815,
-0.0113533102,
0.0559381656,
-0.0108011626,
-0.0294736475,
0.0508809127,
0.0612871237,
0.0272572581,
0.0003071737,
0.0522954203,
0.0355121866,
0.0047023846,
-0.0103150439,
-0.0358628482,
0.0119030764,
-0.0116081079,
0.0354460888,
0.0532362647,
-0.0203130767,
0.004894672,
0.0185178686,
0.0418045782,
0.0996409357,
0.0000020513,
-0.0041671824,
-0.0005334385,
-0.0183547437,
-0.0419569947,
-0.0015621668,
0.0561587811,
-0.0653355643,
-0.0361427478,
0.018083822,
-0.0420250893,
-0.0717477649,
0.0260510948,
0.0766982362,
0.0809212998,
0.1061600894,
-0.0344708152,
0.006262457,
0.018808201,
-0.0068970518,
0.0347271971,
-0.0178963039,
0.0656575263,
0.0245543327,
-0.0248320941,
0.0157236792,
0.0053434232,
-0.0027706553,
0.0424980372,
-0.0277210437,
-0.0060880934,
-0.0049529336,
-0.0014883287,
-0.0252741184,
0.0332012884,
0.0397659019,
-0.0592546798,
-0.0293398388,
0.0119868191,
-0.0186019223,
0.0176817365,
0.0132062435,
-0.0160265509,
-0.0066098529,
-0.002758038,
0.0260055494,
0.0103267832,
0.0059563154,
0.0402885415,
0.0528458729,
0.003622747,
0.0036090973,
-0.0425874442,
0.0219764374,
-0.01227252,
-0.0038850731,
-0.0126652336,
-0.0102670509,
0.0463239737,
-0.0214327611,
0.0087623773,
-0.0061803604,
-0.082139343,
-0.0463928171,
-0.0199962165,
-0.1032670215,
-0.0661548451,
-0.0154699115,
0.0097033903,
0.0322673172,
-0.023927357,
-0.0484552272,
-0.0416707247,
0.0104440246,
-0.0255590137,
-0.012673486,
-0.0114594353,
0.0156591199,
0.0030467247,
0.0398998037,
-0.019444732,
-0.0485203117,
-0.0727810189,
0.0137732839,
-0.0347068794,
-0.0205001887,
-0.0404752195,
0.0395319946,
0.0016145279,
0.003895839,
0.0136512695,
-0.0053779529,
0.012801528,
0.0508665703,
0.0068953885,
-0.034025725,
0.0031841113,
0.0198158231,
0.0283623803,
0.0323498212,
0.0006844389,
0.0047321194,
0.0119578624,
-0.0209046565,
-0.0534114465,
-0.0327386595,
0.0058368398,
0.0077052852,
0.0132226329,
-0.0708797127,
0.0199207179,
-0.0718695074,
-0.043725796,
0.0023317183,
-0.0128511982,
0.0013846216,
-0.0356537215,
0.0397363678,
-0.0533314832,
-0.0182362143,
0.0530132949,
0.0424610563,
0.0299580358,
0.0541394427,
0.0183309261,
0.1009339243,
0.0571391582,
0.0313924104,
0.0114437276,
0.0179231241,
0.0658974573,
0.0049398472,
0.0305697862,
-0.0488146283,
-0.0615376793,
0.0029219745,
0.0200468004,
-0.0231832545,
-0.0518371947,
-0.0494087934,
0.0282948185,
-0.0249414891,
0.0071749045,
0.0385417007,
0.0157461986,
0.0443024859,
-0.0144599592,
-0.0128797926,
-0.0174888354,
0.0312233567,
-0.0305302031,
-0.0199888218,
-0.006151523,
0.0165310409,
-0.0206638947,
-0.0209486317,
0.0264788773,
-0.0168803874,
0.0660192817,
-0.0177043024,
-0.017820105,
0.0342777967,
-0.0112765618,
-0.002044217,
0.0341710746,
0.0258097015,
-0.0060136449,
-0.0442141108,
0.0072837002,
0.0313848071,
0.0107770069,
0.0327107385,
0.0034552582,
-0.0303611457,
0.0020637133,
0.0062605571,
0.0329048932,
-0.0225930326,
-0.0289095026,
-0.0178657193,
-0.0128769595,
-0.0102805309,
0.0155377453,
0.0187345967,
0.023852367,
0.0262600854,
0.0312111434,
0.0156474058,
-0.0455623306,
0.0039704819,
-0.0091633769,
0.034865886,
0.0218787789,
0.0366753228,
0.0537240431,
0.0373761915,
0.016960429,
-0.0384564213,
0.0409648381,
0.0266849715,
-0.0618895628,
-0.049350109,
-0.0031812605,
-0.0454535931,
0.0078177657,
-0.0386982933,
-0.0135609712,
0.0731839612,
-0.0272016227,
0.0041555837,
0.0473022275,
-0.0355636626,
0.0448762774,
-0.0343252905,
-0.0409408212,
-0.0306477882,
0.0515885875,
0.0439102352,
0.052183941,
-0.0424957126,
-0.0222851578,
-0.0137388399,
0.0289350394,
-0.012711986,
0.0099467812,
0.0126899993,
-0.0520012528,
-0.0223609898,
-0.0002360659,
0.0177224353,
-0.021436153,
-0.018027138,
-0.0168563854,
-0.0446845666,
-0.0070892246,
-0.0156929065,
-0.0123303384,
0.0549616367,
0.02362049,
0.0082268221,
0.036438603,
-0.0445480831,
0.0317241289,
0.0058891862,
0.0110753616,
-0.0173385087,
-0.009167931,
0.0046608886,
-0.0244321972,
0.0146327931,
0.0091077499,
0.0246866271,
0.0079878801,
-0.0808887705,
-0.0072427499,
-0.0402827561,
-0.0652013198,
0.0164051652,
-0.0400279984,
-0.0320676267,
-0.0176794361,
0.0000516795,
-0.0389562733,
0.0311032869,
0.0548517741,
0.0809198543,
-0.0281092953,
0.0464038029,
-0.029117493,
-0.0360091701,
-0.0581545644,
0.0945400745,
-0.026185032,
-0.0333273225,
-0.0051954864,
-0.0146917431,
0.0114500411,
0.0084372927,
0.0059432168,
0.0264181308,
0.0382062979,
-0.0268661585,
0.0444119573,
-0.069307074,
-0.004973622,
-0.0310289208,
-0.0473207757,
-0.0062397076,
0.0943494588,
0.0260365922,
0.0377364978,
-0.0293829329,
-0.0561846308,
0.0027011593,
-0.003168059,
-0.0035710735,
0.0111232819,
-0.0314164571,
-0.007500649,
0.0300020128,
0.0093399268,
0.0414601043,
-0.0271772966,
-0.0132843098,
0.0135789271,
0.0212081298,
0.0419183224,
0.0020222091,
-0.0486555882,
-0.0864729807,
-0.0010403339,
-0.0267306585,
0.0055562537,
-0.0370770432,
-0.0163777638,
-0.0216060206,
0.0267401524,
0.0343991369,
-0.0032693993,
0.0022439738,
-0.0013089271,
0.0339141749,
0.026856903,
-0.0037370382,
0.0478749573,
-0.0181572493,
-0.0166894663,
0.0490339473,
-0.0058024721,
0.0177088343,
-0.0374676622,
-0.0202487465,
-0.0080334125,
0.0361249559,
0.0005889848,
-0.0445055403,
-0.0071439552,
-0.047778368,
0.030909732,
0.0672203451,
0.0105596641,
-0.04082077,
0.0263602566,
0.0292416979,
-0.0257201679,
0.0038250773,
-0.0136789391,
-0.0656034425,
-0.003729562,
-0.0340756215,
-0.0086573828,
-0.040058434,
-0.0248197149,
0.0098197451,
-0.0502357073,
0.0043746792,
0.0006191467,
-0.0388626494,
-0.0285921637,
-0.07884904,
0.0197042394,
-0.0002857758,
0.0163723603,
-0.0376000628,
0.0678768903,
-0.0271999817,
-0.0234810747,
0.0168485958,
-0.0739143789,
-0.0075052707,
-0.0126543762,
0.0844397247,
0.0047113383,
0.0322600901,
-0.0375325121,
-0.0319094732,
0.0661077872,
0.0204193462,
-0.0400610641,
-0.0054247472,
0.0803567618,
-0.0238680001,
-0.0017194024,
-0.0630683303,
0.0666821525,
0.0022712185,
0.0042472156,
-0.0425904803,
0.0170503482,
0.0093236994,
-0.0782928392,
-0.0354069024,
0.0055075986,
0.0449713282,
0.0357842967,
0.027162727,
-0.0271964725,
0.0487368219,
0.0042730006,
-0.0193686988,
-0.0048856898,
-0.0706873462,
0.0208827015,
0.0029248181,
-0.0740967318,
-0.0375844799,
-0.0175765455,
-0.0239280164,
0.0223244894,
-0.0544941127,
-0.01456099,
0.0432316363,
-0.0565835387,
-0.0291716382,
0.0112943752,
0.0215921793,
0.0301684681,
0.0423905961,
0.0193773415,
0.0170612708,
-0.0322409794,
-0.01939236,
0.019919496,
-0.0779190361,
-0.0381934494,
0.0150542427,
0.0194339827,
0.0117259528,
0.0752157941,
-0.0203050561,
-0.0173195787,
0.0453756228,
0.0256808735,
-0.019489469,
-0.0014832231,
0.0238007121,
-0.0080107367,
0.0193477254,
0.020360915,
-0.0159899835,
0.0581753813,
0.0084630605,
-0.0461118929,
-0.0833850875,
0.0103008337,
-0.0063961004,
0.0063196016,
0.0419729985,
0.0383555405,
-0.0296828877,
-0.0574175864,
-0.0390215069,
-0.0227279235,
-0.0099148806,
0.0017289341,
0.0127809588,
0.0080787186,
-0.0002808181,
-0.0062292148,
-0.0251742341,
0.0269416459,
0.0121162515,
-0.0222816467,
-0.0381171815,
0.0115249176,
0.0340997539,
-0.0020643426,
0.0259257071,
-0.0277444273,
0.0361649208,
0.0175940692,
0.023473192,
-0.0335965306,
-0.0274281949,
0.0293405969,
-0.0611552224,
0.0317186937,
-0.0008051341,
-0.0374651924,
0.0303329248,
-0.0545343757,
0.0530254804,
0.0146412598,
-0.0109660514,
0.0460286774,
-0.0091414545,
-0.0029725898,
0.0094882492,
-0.0334128588,
-0.0369493328,
-0.0812631547,
-0.0257960893,
0.0257348921,
-0.0210959148,
0.0502302535,
0.029091917,
-0.0176391322,
0.0179162584,
-0.0089659784,
-0.0700015873,
-0.0309539475,
0.0348394737,
0.0257511269,
0.0989650041,
-0.0285190046,
0.0364073366,
-0.02911832,
-0.0404287986,
-0.0298991185,
-0.0054877987,
0.0053724591,
0.0279891156,
0.0066463151,
0.070462808,
-0.0108479317,
0.0430473089,
-0.0212836303,
-0.0174130313,
-0.0187577158,
-0.0582104996,
0.0344299823,
-6.562081868e-33,
0.0631786734,
-0.0190284643,
-0.0609967262,
0.0056424183,
-0.0407190919,
0.0682922006,
-0.0181450676,
-0.0150484033,
-0.0436225571,
0.0316305198,
0.0458140783,
0.0586477518,
-0.0213548411,
0.0196751114,
-0.0978011414,
0.0050199833,
0.0377397314,
0.0146814417,
-0.0036612828,
0.0377172865,
0.0479497127,
-0.0056207962,
0.0306364093,
-0.0950463861,
0.0091631403,
-0.0413824134,
-0.0059874412,
0.0193330571,
0.0197847076,
0.0525009446,
0.0129855946,
0.0590548776,
0.023406582,
-0.0255047176,
0.0026248302,
0.0009654551,
-0.036247693,
-0.0154078966,
-0.0034201182,
0.0024079659,
-0.0609811582,
0.0174728502,
0.0723303705,
0.0141551439,
-0.00149873,
0.0215066336,
0.026766384,
-0.0204998441,
0.0097501026,
0.0086788842,
-0.0069417665,
0.0140487486,
-0.0067359004,
0.0084495973,
-0.0148883173,
0.0300262794,
0.024331281,
-0.0227615871,
-0.1528638154,
0.0083609736,
-0.0483501069,
-0.0024069059,
-0.0166789256,
-0.0330760442,
0.0049167834,
0.0500161052,
0.0119605195,
0.0720359012,
-0.0257527642,
0.0217166487,
0.0318912715,
0.0300640874,
0.0284157488,
0.0875547305,
0.0093072196,
-0.079229258,
-0.0861041546,
0.0206209067,
0.0835226476,
-0.0367975459,
0.0065692645,
0.0011044499,
-0.0203969181,
0.0038359549,
0.0052176449,
0.0005268603,
-0.0264336951,
-0.0295285359,
-0.0437564738,
0.050692793,
-0.0634379387,
0.0407912321,
-0.0039614383,
-0.0595260225,
-0.0103569841,
0.034315858,
-0.0207368173,
0.0233753771,
0.0289647114,
0.036485903,
-0.0264613908,
-0.0195272528,
0.0301544033,
-0.0052114199,
-0.0037840693,
-0.00710017,
0.0469024368,
0.0061069541,
-0.0126435608,
0.0095247533,
0.0033187694,
0.0283598136,
-0.0499062091,
-0.0202674754,
0.0006365381,
0.0078428984,
-0.0223606117,
0.0056401864,
0.0225166678,
0.068859756,
0.0143612837,
-0.003148318,
-0.036404293,
0.0237570535,
-0.0134092448,
-0.0083854953,
-0.0300553944,
-0.0139022181,
0.0070608021,
-0.1195024103,
0.0084576746,
-0.0096080443,
2.975e-7,
-0.0411185026,
0.0468963049,
0.0076680765,
-0.0336010754,
0.03756864,
0.050396312,
0.0544721596,
0.0195152368,
-0.0111621479,
-0.120078817,
-0.0000912234,
0.0502667278,
-0.0308705736,
0.0108569479,
-0.0582752004,
-0.0139074009,
-0.0522371009,
-0.009897681,
-0.0263171233,
-0.0070635285,
0.019596722,
0.0877394825,
0.0778460652,
-0.0498749502,
0.0331631452,
0.0388978831,
0.0109486599,
0.056251172,
-0.0330120809,
0.0131251058,
0.0137913758,
0.0173202157,
-0.0016820675,
0.0080459248,
-0.0179782938,
0.0114063695,
-0.0083815027,
-0.0029987565,
0.0208952632,
-0.0076901298,
0.0215874985,
-0.0237662084,
0.0280472897,
-0.036956083,
0.0627117828,
-0.0594949648,
-0.0467987806,
-0.0376798138,
-0.0408264063,
0.0200549122,
0.0206966791,
-0.0142941121,
-0.0178177133,
0.0434895419,
0.0074677397,
-0.0073444042,
0.0002534483,
-0.0663269609,
0.0442835465,
-0.0226851273,
-0.0581219345,
-0.0071100229,
-0.0207917877,
-0.0197764747,
0.1129914746,
-0.0024421574,
0.0373393781,
2.248129502e-34,
0.0336421505,
-0.0089902673,
-0.0009327595,
-0.0402451009,
-0.0006443805,
0.0348103829,
-0.025288133,
-0.021022547,
0.042053815,
-0.0147790564,
-0.0056438255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18027v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18027v2 | Evaluating GPT-4 and ChatGPT on Japanese Medical Licensing Examinations | 2023-03-31T13:04:47 | 2023-04-05T07:53:37 | Jungo Kasai, Yuhei Kasai, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Yutaro Yamada, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) gain popularity among speakers of diverse
languages, we believe that it is crucial to benchmark them to better understand
model behaviors, failures, and limitations in languages beyond English. In this
work, we evaluate LLM APIs (ChatGPT, GPT-3, and GPT-4) on the Japanese national
medical licensing examinations from the past five years, including the current
year. Our team comprises native Japanese-speaking NLP researchers and a
practicing cardiologist based in Japan. Our experiments show that GPT-4
outperforms ChatGPT and GPT-3 and passes all six years of the exams,
highlighting LLMs' potential in a language that is typologically distant from
English. However, our evaluation also exposes critical limitations of the
current LLM APIs. First, LLMs sometimes select prohibited choices that should
be strictly avoided in medical practice in Japan, such as suggesting
euthanasia. Further, our analysis shows that the API costs are generally higher
and the maximum context size is smaller for Japanese because of the way
non-Latin scripts are currently tokenized in the pipeline. We release our
benchmark as Igaku QA as well as all model outputs and exam metadata. We hope
that our results and benchmark will spur progress on more diverse applications
of LLMs. Our benchmark is available at https://github.com/jungokasai/IgakuQA. | [
0.050384745,
0.078172721,
-0.0003529864,
0.0010888202,
-0.0306838416,
0.0111289127,
0.005301307,
0.0629563555,
0.0248156581,
-0.004940819,
-0.0094035445,
-0.0438846759,
0.0169269554,
0.0186961647,
0.0116124405,
-0.0759010315,
0.0260161944,
0.0097400164,
0.0386648066,
-0.0124154249,
0.0169659127,
0.0185254756,
-0.0244334713,
0.0720108896,
0.0110613918,
-0.0010569124,
0.0280249305,
-0.0305482969,
0.0083658155,
-0.0669459701,
-0.0300753638,
0.0449425206,
-0.0497908294,
0.0181145221,
0.0000019027,
-0.0419261977,
-0.0057389438,
0.0194054972,
-0.0146033755,
0.0201694518,
0.0583876744,
-0.0271307137,
-0.0386668071,
0.0191009026,
-0.038764894,
-0.0416567586,
0.0529982634,
0.0021829046,
0.0358566083,
0.0602597184,
-0.0330109559,
-0.0043861717,
0.019569084,
-0.0468936674,
-0.0404388383,
-0.0212690625,
0.0198241789,
-0.0282275323,
0.0338833369,
-0.026004333,
-0.0035439841,
0.0233191382,
0.0130295567,
0.0247562379,
-0.0570647493,
0.0162580572,
-0.0400382467,
-0.0141414199,
0.0183503181,
0.0384470262,
0.0181474462,
-0.0149211017,
0.0144193638,
-0.0095964596,
0.0020068551,
-0.002608669,
-0.0516593307,
0.0198380332,
-0.0169254597,
0.0131098833,
0.0762091577,
0.0039745644,
0.0261144582,
0.0090121813,
-0.0124858031,
0.0492427684,
0.0583635978,
-0.0296794325,
0.0273060612,
-0.0050452156,
-0.0240659881,
-0.0487142652,
0.0196880233,
0.0193549618,
-0.0490050465,
0.0379363149,
-0.0132437162,
0.006321263,
0.0916573554,
-0.051181756,
0.0101012541,
0.0213285871,
-0.0110843936,
0.0128768235,
-0.0006695487,
0.0378909595,
-0.0110752229,
0.0351470932,
-0.0391312651,
0.005748413,
-0.0169425253,
-0.015964482,
-0.0246848539,
0.0145168705,
-0.0261171944,
0.0214292184,
-0.1114579141,
-0.0082696928,
-0.0347037315,
0.0370158665,
0.0154631389,
-0.0283581,
-0.029850876,
0.0161966328,
-0.032911662,
0.0161747187,
-0.0148278382,
-0.0115849646,
-0.0215878151,
-0.0351515338,
0.0383026749,
0.0239538904,
-0.0069306968,
-0.0088284221,
0.018989658,
0.0790107697,
0.0321661234,
0.0014809188,
0.0094169797,
-0.0298441332,
-0.048412241,
-0.0398757234,
0.0101729538,
-0.0680479556,
0.0068058535,
0.0180311464,
0.026892988,
-0.0669106543,
0.0258025192,
0.0279759038,
-0.0138065284,
0.0582994893,
-0.0106738703,
0.0123456921,
-0.0190461092,
0.0329762436,
0.0043545035,
0.0440774001,
0.0145760821,
-0.0443410128,
0.0464582406,
-0.0257321112,
0.0163099878,
0.0704066157,
0.0100242011,
-0.0088725863,
-0.0075602825,
0.0115660336,
0.0437910371,
0.0608253628,
-0.0118501829,
0.0743435994,
0.0007961009,
0.0022077851,
0.0145669682,
0.0925747678,
0.0102925552,
0.0010231313,
0.0230098311,
-0.0326630399,
0.0052612643,
-0.0013937902,
-0.0296441335,
-0.025586905,
-0.0208841078,
0.0375603102,
-0.0349046253,
0.0157156847,
-0.0110763675,
-0.0430127531,
-0.0618308075,
-0.0135175046,
-0.0209905654,
-0.0194490943,
0.0317132957,
-0.0074797049,
-0.0254819989,
0.0920875594,
0.0580443889,
-0.0599153228,
-0.0205828492,
-0.0391644761,
-0.0154781593,
0.0615411252,
0.0797290057,
-0.0275985412,
-0.0256501995,
0.0194364693,
-0.0009707219,
0.065042451,
0.0524144657,
-0.0225333925,
0.0003434164,
-0.0296915974,
0.0073318761,
0.0510233752,
0.0100451093,
-0.0036998889,
0.0363994464,
0.0771414638,
0.0013882093,
-0.040480461,
-0.0039768466,
0.0296595581,
-0.090714097,
-0.008329602,
-0.0373932049,
0.0027252806,
0.0536292903,
0.0312289819,
0.0025250015,
0.0334969535,
0.0241023507,
-0.0454540588,
0.0101158051,
0.0373268053,
-0.0415715985,
-0.0185648967,
0.0681945533,
-0.0082568079,
-0.0049192444,
0.0009475083,
-0.0147289112,
-0.0164555013,
-0.0513601303,
0.0005260783,
0.0465936959,
-0.0538803376,
0.0350311212,
0.0098285312,
-0.0071833902,
-0.0211122055,
0.0138013409,
-0.0123655302,
0.0478769653,
0.0382121988,
-0.0403125808,
0.0318048224,
-0.0192856994,
-0.0589093827,
0.0711836666,
0.009906766,
0.0205153693,
-0.0236153435,
0.0537040569,
-0.021016743,
-0.0346836932,
-0.1191953644,
-0.0003281207,
-0.0052025192,
0.0198324323,
0.007850742,
0.0252011307,
-0.0329680853,
0.0090997526,
-0.054247506,
-0.045767121,
0.0318233185,
0.0215242412,
0.0092018303,
-0.0051987125,
0.0092274025,
-0.0193786304,
0.0045463825,
-0.0215567444,
0.0078684455,
-0.0099087711,
-0.0239882357,
0.0081832083,
0.0073523694,
-0.0209658761,
-0.0016218232,
0.0070272842,
-0.0536210462,
0.0233579818,
-0.0329842493,
0.00245573,
-0.0136174876,
-0.0306341238,
-0.0026364021,
0.0386106037,
-0.0139456801,
-0.0174162667,
-0.0053383517,
0.0054531642,
-0.0330836847,
-0.0143670077,
-0.0575988255,
-0.0049178717,
0.068725422,
-0.0048564258,
-0.0057367249,
-0.0558894686,
-0.0254913792,
-0.0819652751,
0.0202842727,
-0.0220337212,
0.0362046771,
-0.0451299995,
0.0445673652,
0.0311911218,
-0.0191263258,
0.07597664,
-0.0271636527,
0.0139717413,
-0.0865537003,
0.0181047469,
-0.0480780005,
0.0610933006,
-0.0349304713,
0.0138812922,
0.0243645702,
-0.0456762314,
-0.0035436649,
0.0249824598,
-0.0065606008,
-0.0761505291,
0.0805841088,
-0.0484607928,
0.0043886835,
-0.0187314507,
-0.0433834903,
-0.0218410324,
-0.0270190537,
-0.0348580554,
0.0126848668,
0.0163082071,
0.0231240056,
0.0232491456,
0.0559632443,
-0.0480850637,
0.0545281544,
0.0172352251,
0.0103658466,
0.0092674354,
0.005884775,
0.0300538968,
-0.0164039116,
-0.0229393877,
0.000739278,
0.0492630899,
0.0602690428,
0.0255898852,
0.0147613576,
0.0072294241,
0.0121937897,
0.0436675102,
-0.0650675967,
-0.0170039553,
0.0210212059,
0.0437090695,
-0.0416635834,
0.0132938083,
0.128421858,
0.0315352231,
-0.04089237,
0.0161655433,
-0.0309199076,
0.0143613424,
-0.0052709542,
0.0154306972,
-0.1094075814,
-0.0060141082,
0.0130905798,
0.033703804,
-0.0230476297,
0.0085147563,
0.0325699449,
-0.1190105304,
0.0572142974,
0.0135536278,
-0.0420753658,
-0.002826317,
-0.0362744629,
0.0056424513,
-0.0329802223,
0.0385105684,
0.0038589267,
-0.0386823379,
0.0007962312,
-0.0244110823,
-0.1029586643,
-0.0690776929,
0.0406777412,
-0.0274602976,
0.033975888,
0.0213044267,
0.0230540968,
-0.0301942267,
-0.0126172528,
0.0364632159,
-0.000302087,
-0.0208409782,
-0.0332314372,
0.0399736017,
0.0500424765,
-0.0305478331,
-0.0491318591,
0.014056243,
-0.0430400111,
-0.0387185477,
0.0245851241,
0.0600683652,
-0.0033151372,
-0.0065973625,
-0.0257313829,
0.0337914936,
-0.0111889113,
0.0724600479,
0.0367731825,
-0.0450389162,
-0.002067901,
-0.0329803601,
0.0138293682,
-0.0022984557,
-0.0205768514,
-0.0054934025,
-0.034028586,
-0.0247659739,
-0.0785718262,
-0.0634000227,
0.0332520343,
-0.0051811137,
0.0296797212,
0.0411702506,
0.0030269187,
-0.0120217241,
-0.0154140871,
0.0182535816,
-0.0076030754,
0.0226194169,
-0.0631946772,
-0.0353248939,
0.045289766,
0.0427862443,
-0.0105850874,
0.0194544308,
0.0042449683,
-0.0387675688,
0.0076935189,
0.0410400964,
0.0267525893,
-0.0024820464,
-0.0115196221,
0.0095582418,
-0.0025354244,
0.0350818932,
0.0005142441,
-0.0091548981,
0.0098745814,
0.0013758705,
0.0100737512,
0.0069182743,
0.0008402505,
-0.0225701481,
0.0018540646,
0.0572894514,
-0.0180650335,
-0.0056921882,
0.0197327454,
0.0732248798,
-0.0054641175,
-0.0553915128,
0.0121766441,
-0.0160759259,
-0.0092836972,
-0.0469136946,
-0.0072799954,
-0.0315441787,
-0.0292641521,
0.0422670692,
-0.0087739797,
-0.0331108123,
-0.0181390177,
-0.0639486536,
-0.0015938266,
-0.0630639642,
0.05398684,
0.0275686961,
0.0179644637,
0.0340166651,
-0.02465,
-0.003380388,
-0.0292626284,
-0.0086420877,
0.0224113408,
-0.0399131514,
0.0848792791,
-0.021022154,
-0.0086818347,
0.0515886731,
0.0482324138,
0.0124355173,
-0.0295242853,
0.0019080804,
0.041491814,
0.0782167017,
-0.0165514685,
0.0420999043,
-0.0503134094,
-0.008423089,
-0.0192663372,
0.018383123,
-0.0117923059,
-0.0053339531,
0.0258064326,
0.0068418942,
-0.0148009695,
-0.0425511338,
0.105219543,
0.0240153633,
0.045919016,
0.0337637216,
0.0017708598,
-0.0480668284,
-0.0353254117,
0.0310113933,
-0.0094329277,
-0.0563201532,
-0.0279353317,
-0.0973372087,
-0.0688979179,
-0.0077417693,
-0.0103143053,
-0.036043901,
-0.0144560998,
0.0114059495,
0.0353940278,
0.0259978753,
-0.0095670009,
-0.0341569036,
0.038557332,
-0.0092548737,
-0.0081625674,
0.0350398757,
-5.921630301e-33,
-0.0350408368,
-0.0132060703,
0.0278179031,
-0.0035578744,
0.0065273019,
-0.0033770292,
-0.0268904716,
0.0045026112,
0.0002570517,
0.0143285049,
-0.0456422567,
-0.006910848,
0.0250043347,
0.0237024128,
0.020206118,
-0.0352564342,
-0.015653763,
0.0243659765,
-0.0134090548,
0.0156878512,
-0.0252495334,
0.0018623818,
0.0640725717,
-0.0430978164,
0.0406208672,
0.0256997813,
0.0075966404,
-0.0213872436,
-0.0380508266,
0.0850201473,
-0.0152814807,
0.0684867278,
0.0272867307,
-0.0321654417,
-0.0014629447,
-0.0163546167,
-0.0616754442,
-0.0257944688,
0.0408301502,
0.0153274518,
0.0045806733,
-0.0602177791,
0.0246919673,
-0.0181769934,
-0.0426252261,
-0.0010505917,
0.002144573,
-0.0565213561,
-0.0448642224,
-0.0026456807,
-0.0361115187,
0.0337699242,
0.0238762051,
0.042315755,
0.0127084618,
-0.0242650248,
-0.0224619731,
0.0235435255,
-0.0202801861,
-0.0083534028,
0.0572306812,
0.0354312211,
0.0199225135,
-0.0650473833,
-0.018893756,
0.0205663685,
0.0001531533,
-0.0144800283,
0.0099667674,
0.0195218604,
0.0009752683,
0.0382562391,
0.0620297939,
0.034958709,
0.011410662,
-0.0410689376,
-0.0617836565,
0.0480383225,
-0.0395983607,
0.0373468623,
0.0172892548,
-0.0326065496,
-0.0550924502,
-0.0464313328,
-0.0267181117,
-0.0277352184,
-0.0165475365,
-0.0382153876,
0.0432535373,
-0.0326926,
0.0199058615,
0.011193593,
-0.0027880135,
-0.04612156,
-0.0195138995,
0.0069387439,
0.0118853981,
0.0276926402,
-0.0476788767,
0.0355671309,
-0.0457013622,
0.0003578397,
-0.0327477604,
-0.0099276053,
0.033282917,
0.0058539193,
-0.0016103825,
-0.0070551801,
-0.0806640536,
0.0133545091,
-0.0011522344,
0.0101423701,
0.0078644417,
0.0232641194,
0.0426317453,
-0.0060307733,
0.0351468809,
-0.0015052963,
0.057352677,
-0.0002015933,
-0.0655436963,
-0.0257369298,
-0.0001887765,
-0.0200138297,
-0.0315391272,
0.0160568543,
-0.0221071206,
0.0541149005,
0.055667758,
0.0036900954,
-0.0092748785,
-0.0152353402,
2.637e-7,
0.0909270421,
0.0441524312,
-0.0083464552,
0.0123830801,
-0.0029235019,
0.0043538101,
-0.0356092118,
-0.0189420506,
0.0222995579,
0.0195562262,
0.011350737,
-0.0211885162,
0.0770914927,
0.0382176712,
-0.1227369159,
0.0278037749,
-0.046786081,
-0.0076913685,
-0.0603736527,
0.0249415785,
0.0182032585,
0.0750465915,
-0.0233578812,
-0.034083724,
-0.0192115195,
-0.0233110674,
0.0476485007,
-0.0648445934,
-0.037735004,
0.0361154266,
0.0383403897,
0.0013218436,
0.04727,
0.0076739322,
-0.0192508958,
-0.0194475837,
0.0350465737,
0.1194078699,
-0.0218088198,
0.0039490536,
0.0398132093,
-0.0181576144,
-0.0103481896,
-0.0784324482,
0.0681950897,
-0.0031733699,
-0.0351125337,
-0.0481107533,
-0.0389305726,
-0.0426921286,
0.0438769758,
-0.0051405909,
-0.0426039845,
0.044932358,
0.0354747549,
-0.0067754672,
-0.0364916138,
-0.0154314814,
-0.0458401144,
0.0010784245,
0.0038518738,
-0.0523821861,
-0.0065223044,
-0.0146090724,
-0.0243267715,
-0.0886702463,
-0.0087587805,
2.705513206e-34,
0.0280528273,
-0.0077286875,
0.0313181654,
0.0415772498,
0.0164661128,
0.0156455133,
0.0375273898,
0.045726303,
-0.0330692977,
-0.0331818983,
-0.0057142596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18011v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18011v1 | Exploiting Multilingualism in Low-resource Neural Machine Translation via Adversarial Learning | 2023-03-31T12:34:14 | 2023-03-31T12:34:14 | Amit Kumar, Ajay Pratap, Anil Kumar Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) offer a promising approach for Neural
Machine Translation (NMT). However, feeding multiple morphologically languages
into a single model during training reduces the NMT's performance. In GAN,
similar to bilingual models, multilingual NMT only considers one reference
translation for each sentence during model training. This single reference
translation limits the GAN model from learning sufficient information about the
source sentence representation. Thus, in this article, we propose Denoising
Adversarial Auto-encoder-based Sentence Interpolation (DAASI) approach to
perform sentence interpolation by learning the intermediate latent
representation of the source and target sentences of multilingual language
pairs. Apart from latent representation, we also use the Wasserstein-GAN
approach for the multilingual NMT model by incorporating the model generated
sentences of multiple languages for reward computation. This computed reward
optimizes the performance of the GAN-based multilingual model in an effective
manner. We demonstrate the experiments on low-resource language pairs and find
that our approach outperforms the existing state-of-the-art approaches for
multilingual NMT with a performance gain of up to 4 BLEU points. Moreover, we
use our trained model on zero-shot language pairs under an unsupervised
scenario and show the robustness of the proposed approach. | [
0.0141752381,
0.0797116682,
-0.0165877361,
0.0419845171,
-0.0502132475,
-0.0001987239,
0.0329778045,
0.0179650262,
-0.0413939282,
-0.003760145,
-0.0470318981,
-0.0426126868,
0.0050759912,
-0.0474652015,
0.0464729927,
-0.0779739097,
0.0189006403,
-0.002101691,
-0.0013493326,
-0.0331203528,
0.0005650173,
0.0344621576,
0.0311391782,
0.0464717224,
-0.0348973535,
-0.0209378563,
0.007284767,
0.0206645615,
0.0458424874,
-0.0156329703,
0.0250541475,
0.0113857565,
0.003324535,
0.0575975291,
0.0000022001,
0.011427287,
0.0065788948,
-0.0111662596,
0.0059906882,
0.0296304505,
0.059213493,
-0.0371048301,
-0.0032963704,
0.0178320613,
-0.0195912514,
-0.0651648417,
0.0455120988,
0.022752475,
0.0615916736,
0.0830853805,
-0.0311645176,
-0.0591516756,
0.0123239271,
-0.0771746188,
-0.0080849165,
-0.0440194383,
-0.0189422797,
0.0274900477,
-0.0508845784,
-0.0134135159,
-0.0111616002,
0.0596429817,
0.0283729415,
-0.0146777676,
-0.0326918289,
0.0280067176,
0.017223157,
-0.0185408257,
-0.0223529693,
0.0709729269,
-0.1190290451,
0.0134366499,
-0.0432682857,
-0.0243052188,
0.0034814039,
-0.0478850864,
-0.0554578193,
0.0053987037,
0.0205641091,
0.0231592804,
0.0306526199,
0.0587887093,
0.055799894,
-0.016768977,
-0.0279874709,
-0.0120591018,
0.0453168303,
0.0094327042,
-0.0230268445,
0.014974732,
-0.0390852578,
-0.0041328603,
0.0396732651,
-0.0132680163,
-0.0149895651,
-0.002231264,
-0.0574284568,
-0.0561752729,
-0.0003515017,
-0.0078071365,
0.0539422035,
0.0257382095,
0.0160138719,
0.0351119041,
-0.0570765845,
0.0272447523,
-0.0291275643,
0.017824363,
-0.051576037,
-0.0363295786,
0.0178330801,
0.000894498,
-0.0140107814,
-0.002361451,
-0.0510956272,
0.0027438551,
-0.0252052471,
-0.0096300393,
-0.0088401958,
0.027722666,
0.0163570102,
0.0155369891,
-0.1016520113,
-0.0242472161,
0.0359754227,
0.0614612512,
-0.048059877,
0.0091575971,
0.0234662183,
-0.0597322546,
-0.0423395932,
0.0187580008,
0.0020287144,
-0.032326676,
0.0183167811,
0.1305847913,
-0.0278040674,
-0.0030281274,
-0.0354129374,
-0.0074125058,
-0.013962958,
-0.0590387806,
0.0112082586,
-0.0549237616,
0.06272313,
-0.0095871044,
0.003359687,
-0.0579210632,
-0.0037283972,
-0.0189214963,
-0.0076697688,
0.062783435,
0.0393941887,
-0.0485477187,
0.0303188916,
-0.0023058977,
0.0576914102,
0.0669135973,
0.0525490828,
0.0435674191,
-0.0115194814,
0.0412464254,
-0.0154706473,
0.0640506446,
0.0336217955,
0.0492620207,
-0.0464605689,
-0.0223700311,
0.0332917534,
0.0404019393,
0.0569659881,
0.053389512,
-0.0349002145,
0.000429356,
0.0572916307,
0.0297477301,
-0.0023283053,
0.0226325374,
0.0408691876,
-0.0022321115,
-0.0408519357,
0.0090590604,
0.0118493205,
0.0677070618,
0.0051259822,
0.0077172602,
0.0230984204,
0.0610574223,
-0.019280754,
-0.0477568805,
0.0405720472,
-0.0289090481,
0.0009336841,
-0.0226204414,
0.0102212196,
0.0358321108,
-0.0397821777,
0.0158809386,
0.0069676861,
-0.0170757268,
0.0396510623,
-0.0046277437,
-0.0328924246,
0.0401317105,
0.0569953583,
0.0020056709,
-0.003658338,
-0.0491803512,
-0.0514268018,
0.0641679019,
-0.0103302067,
0.0102936123,
0.0349195823,
-0.0725701004,
-0.0057598348,
-0.0513263941,
-0.0037077074,
0.0852811113,
-0.0163614135,
0.049323,
0.0124042816,
-0.0091221156,
-0.044721704,
0.0189123731,
-0.0134971514,
-0.0079231709,
0.0550205857,
0.0194135308,
0.0086793276,
-0.0076304497,
-0.0255650748,
-0.0078405328,
-0.0020270892,
-0.061149545,
-0.0297749564,
0.0250433274,
-0.0650334731,
-0.1112007648,
0.0071229693,
-0.0554448068,
-0.0124574853,
-0.0154808285,
-0.0422040261,
-0.0475704148,
0.0295894071,
-0.0256712288,
-0.0348746032,
-0.0275866389,
0.0142477695,
0.0185996145,
0.0285245758,
-0.0422759615,
0.022171583,
-0.0115095899,
-0.011661822,
0.0037268666,
0.0072714756,
0.0370785035,
-0.0159085635,
-0.0074433293,
0.0616909899,
0.0347025804,
0.0101215681,
0.0418396443,
0.0301220547,
0.0390724503,
-0.0298139956,
-0.0156981032,
-0.0023129694,
-0.0204441547,
0.0113723166,
0.0290534236,
0.0772683024,
0.0246958453,
-0.0194410216,
-0.0625785589,
0.0268998146,
0.0061122398,
-0.0223957077,
0.0235829242,
-0.00218631,
0.0507740229,
-0.0254032779,
-0.0110619301,
0.0384162962,
0.061782077,
0.014925627,
0.0112355407,
-0.0552817732,
-0.0060451245,
-0.0202379636,
0.0234875623,
-0.0148300147,
-0.0804686695,
-0.0080360146,
-0.008381445,
0.0376136675,
0.0695733353,
-0.0151608456,
-0.0064018979,
0.0420078039,
0.0197986476,
-0.051368922,
0.0198277198,
-0.0065931357,
0.0092692999,
-0.0477841683,
-0.0103298547,
-0.0340174139,
0.0417237505,
0.044580251,
0.0242089313,
-0.0419505462,
0.0162469,
-0.0002809323,
-0.0693189055,
-0.0341347903,
0.0560286678,
0.0015441037,
-0.0133931274,
-0.0494476222,
-0.0287305936,
0.0842354447,
-0.020663254,
-0.0281577017,
-0.0459574163,
-0.0057499683,
0.0011095169,
0.0395093486,
0.0081900451,
0.0617962256,
-0.0318466835,
-0.0307342,
-0.0478512943,
0.0183189828,
0.0187497456,
-0.0067484858,
0.0245155599,
-0.0111977439,
-0.0300313532,
-0.0323241018,
-0.0371545181,
-0.0251694899,
-0.0031703401,
0.0121234627,
0.0164692756,
0.0601385497,
-0.0295346156,
-0.0331051014,
-0.0233488977,
0.0207680278,
0.0599050596,
-0.0202181656,
0.0182056967,
-0.0310861468,
0.0743651912,
0.0397508033,
-0.024546111,
-0.0314442702,
-0.0189716592,
0.0160125103,
0.0091287047,
-0.0439967513,
0.027539162,
-0.0257246643,
-0.0015293653,
0.0237499569,
0.0184495281,
-0.0193439014,
-0.0290228482,
0.0335647315,
-0.036232993,
-0.0058407807,
0.0702640861,
0.0008887397,
-0.05294431,
0.0047657704,
0.0204732697,
0.0478173085,
0.0149666118,
0.0149714816,
-0.1026518419,
-0.0247908849,
-0.0160905793,
-0.0009763877,
0.0218519699,
0.0347149894,
-0.009349633,
-0.0965376198,
-0.0108117554,
0.0442792512,
-0.0341569372,
0.0049738362,
0.0211563837,
-0.027253015,
-0.0068203099,
0.0406938232,
-0.0528472401,
0.0507020578,
-0.0071829357,
0.0128073199,
0.0477833599,
-0.0803223923,
-0.0301688965,
-0.0270262696,
0.0262367725,
0.0817988738,
0.066973716,
-0.0251864698,
-0.0459803492,
0.001113278,
0.0189033262,
-0.0172040816,
-0.0025809354,
0.0378227793,
0.0031456107,
-0.0254893266,
0.0411672853,
0.0186219029,
-0.0028556127,
0.0317310616,
0.0296316892,
0.0326394178,
-0.0150943594,
0.0187969171,
0.0064495485,
-0.0349769369,
0.0222235341,
0.042488303,
0.018898461,
-0.049890779,
-0.033399567,
-0.0594498217,
-0.0193804484,
-0.1210338622,
-0.0197293907,
-0.0001398543,
0.0079767555,
-0.0001922444,
-0.0839302763,
-0.0840452388,
0.01063722,
0.00841616,
0.0116687911,
-0.0253113694,
-0.0460116155,
0.0081779864,
-0.0130100828,
-0.0262373891,
-0.0046213591,
0.0311274193,
-0.0136523871,
0.0139157502,
0.0095006367,
-0.0323301852,
0.0081113931,
0.0114570046,
-0.049091965,
-0.0661033541,
-0.0435045958,
0.0741951168,
-0.0024034246,
0.0466787741,
-0.0558228754,
-0.0053398535,
0.0702176318,
0.0501430556,
0.0043199039,
-0.0319072455,
0.0555173755,
0.0157407746,
-0.0018022819,
0.0483141206,
0.0047338405,
0.0330830738,
0.0259113573,
0.0443852954,
0.0173552185,
-0.0140021974,
0.0212660674,
-0.010277749,
0.0060500414,
-0.0548325926,
0.0109819155,
-0.0378361866,
-0.0065318416,
-0.0367020294,
-0.0211096145,
-0.0467025861,
-0.0138362925,
0.049309317,
0.0095585249,
0.0013072382,
0.0215258077,
0.0326258391,
-0.0341548212,
-0.0078689093,
-0.0286782738,
-0.0120847728,
0.0221189875,
-0.0259236265,
0.041987516,
-0.004482876,
0.0008241519,
-0.0029247338,
-0.0088063926,
-0.0431295522,
0.0278670993,
0.0230828524,
-0.0175021719,
-0.0235164315,
0.0197926406,
-0.010815382,
0.0555875823,
-0.0234901048,
0.0076083941,
0.1073856056,
0.0092991553,
0.0934033021,
-0.0015416979,
-0.0193625912,
0.0049569928,
0.0200759489,
-0.0018094402,
-0.0424546152,
-0.002103531,
-0.0219144318,
0.0021952719,
-0.0142920082,
0.093075335,
-0.009641096,
0.0351437479,
-0.0404235832,
0.0146194473,
-0.037177328,
-0.0348810442,
-0.0005981452,
-0.0130846547,
0.00344885,
0.0318232179,
0.0150102079,
-0.036882326,
-0.0554803535,
0.0225023124,
0.0138800787,
0.0101763234,
0.0372707695,
0.0435769856,
-0.0300665107,
-0.0113397641,
-0.038855169,
0.0192660503,
0.0091074537,
-0.0467797294,
-0.0305911563,
-6.45760393e-33,
-0.0292549673,
0.0035894318,
-0.0263638496,
-0.0408247411,
-0.0197425522,
-0.0177182052,
-0.0441548005,
-0.0142580392,
-0.0114676123,
0.0200611129,
0.0106829805,
0.0043939115,
0.0030648955,
0.022593895,
0.0225299075,
0.0306662209,
0.0942032933,
0.0046263537,
-0.0180414636,
0.0450832658,
0.0361655839,
0.0379811972,
0.0924922824,
-0.0334681906,
0.0292091444,
-0.0096473545,
-0.0319244005,
-0.0153043307,
0.0010934179,
-0.0134227788,
-0.0062541906,
0.0273036659,
-0.0073158131,
-0.0261614136,
-0.0152197611,
-0.0443864204,
-0.0841579512,
-0.0191317722,
-0.0049284738,
0.0247606374,
-0.0858468786,
-0.069711715,
0.0457595475,
-0.0338977315,
0.0194110386,
-0.0108104171,
0.0227825288,
-0.037025746,
-0.0176833998,
-0.012079102,
-0.0539191701,
-0.0089678625,
-0.0076165558,
0.0191999227,
0.0271590315,
0.0532332584,
-0.0017166744,
-0.0051078517,
-0.0710414499,
0.0039803907,
-0.0314557999,
0.0792226493,
0.0458651148,
0.0523733385,
-0.0016769167,
0.0078631081,
0.0029110024,
-0.0465636142,
0.0317979231,
0.0312473364,
0.0360531062,
-0.0372893363,
0.073358655,
0.0576585606,
0.0159030594,
-0.0086912168,
-0.0723397136,
0.0327804983,
0.0154107567,
0.0270417351,
0.0114231315,
0.0286188927,
0.0164995603,
-0.0081850234,
-0.0233759936,
-0.0814944506,
-0.0002002884,
-0.0504961945,
0.0014206672,
0.0079106223,
-0.0217184108,
-0.0196511149,
0.0501756296,
-0.0199340116,
-0.0185986832,
0.0290724449,
-0.0267824586,
0.0009326582,
0.0012836362,
0.0445402339,
-0.0048436644,
-0.0063572479,
0.0091373567,
0.0295972209,
0.0138683207,
-0.0078658033,
0.07392364,
0.0159915611,
-0.0231457446,
-0.0017092606,
-0.0468585491,
0.0041975337,
0.0009798382,
0.0214546211,
0.0043798289,
-0.0125501137,
-0.0353552289,
-0.0131355105,
0.0265390072,
0.0056335949,
-0.0087785898,
-0.0388310552,
0.0086939652,
0.0384219363,
-0.0877497271,
0.0122268628,
-0.0409990214,
-0.0009452245,
0.039036002,
-0.0833274275,
-0.0325687565,
-0.0272870846,
2.903e-7,
0.0130805066,
0.0214871019,
-0.0077069658,
0.0112100961,
0.013437218,
0.0138703315,
-0.0373731256,
0.046389401,
-0.0418410636,
0.0256043728,
0.0078046997,
0.0215387903,
0.0688111559,
0.0255060922,
-0.0695758387,
0.0322416387,
-0.0578060746,
0.0193807036,
-0.0574444719,
-0.0196036659,
-0.0083011054,
0.0845108777,
0.0100121126,
0.0194141455,
0.0255354494,
0.0047802855,
0.0587127879,
0.0417752936,
-0.0291757323,
-0.0074684294,
0.0660350844,
0.0406381041,
-0.0170111842,
-0.0187884886,
-0.0248830449,
0.0048167319,
0.0508819744,
0.0431810766,
-0.0163052417,
-0.0021333802,
-0.0184888784,
-0.0030849481,
-0.0134074194,
-0.0345905125,
0.0451646745,
-0.0296445303,
-0.0180311222,
0.0239574574,
-0.0156002389,
0.0144456085,
0.0797132105,
-0.0354123861,
-0.0441930778,
-0.0118040061,
0.0455620289,
0.0209974553,
-0.0184040312,
-0.0296365879,
-0.0241963454,
0.0155019574,
-0.0155839296,
-0.0019470074,
-0.0215216167,
0.0041300617,
-0.0061258906,
-0.0121079208,
-0.0171330255,
2.353983687e-34,
0.0217604097,
-0.0085040499,
0.0146950167,
-0.035970252,
0.0127017172,
-0.0254754983,
-0.0229774453,
0.0024646558,
0.0067359358,
-0.0106027471,
-0.0654628202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00020v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00020v2 | SemiMemes: A Semi-supervised Learning Approach for Multimodal Memes Analysis | 2023-03-31T11:22:03 | 2023-05-16T07:19:23 | Pham Thai Hoang Tung, Nguyen Tan Viet, Ngo Tien Anh, Phan Duy Hung | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The prevalence of memes on social media has created the need to sentiment
analyze their underlying meanings for censoring harmful content. Meme censoring
systems by machine learning raise the need for a semi-supervised learning
solution to take advantage of the large number of unlabeled memes available on
the internet and make the annotation process less challenging. Moreover, the
approach needs to utilize multimodal data as memes' meanings usually come from
both images and texts. This research proposes a multimodal semi-supervised
learning approach that outperforms other multimodal semi-supervised learning
and supervised learning state-of-the-art models on two datasets, the Multimedia
Automatic Misogyny Identification and Hateful Memes dataset. Building on the
insights gained from Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training, which is an
effective multimodal learning technique, this research introduces SemiMemes, a
novel training method that combines auto-encoder and classification task to
make use of the resourceful unlabeled data. | [
0.0210638773,
0.0457659923,
-0.0127415573,
0.0330066606,
0.0044454709,
0.0473157912,
0.0277194697,
0.0092260279,
0.047405351,
-0.0873058587,
-0.0360579789,
-0.0292267594,
-0.057066869,
0.0256980024,
0.0403054468,
-0.0689727217,
0.0296322219,
0.0569237582,
0.013004641,
-0.031824939,
0.0414415896,
0.0160475988,
-0.0265008751,
0.0187720489,
-0.0742715076,
-0.0260280538,
0.0346024595,
0.015747495,
0.0218313914,
-0.0282317139,
0.0365698002,
0.0151145142,
0.0328677148,
0.0079063354,
0.000001983,
-0.041582983,
0.0037608035,
-0.0344374478,
0.0146093694,
-0.0482880026,
0.0568763278,
-0.0604449064,
0.0009272596,
0.0024146016,
0.0089235399,
-0.0023308326,
0.0898783132,
0.0246491916,
0.1034620106,
0.0606391951,
-0.0429474413,
-0.0279200468,
-0.0074216351,
0.008815391,
0.0003104157,
0.002664591,
0.0185183864,
-0.0146082044,
-0.0453041568,
0.0157566778,
-0.0685654581,
0.0534035973,
0.0036969078,
0.0105820131,
0.0247713346,
-0.0292634647,
-0.0173270497,
-0.0583180599,
0.012137901,
0.0657546222,
-0.0264256783,
0.0004610388,
0.0111841541,
-0.0076745194,
-0.0184787512,
-0.0096995514,
-0.0381904133,
0.0237909388,
0.0209230613,
0.0410893969,
-0.0119879982,
0.0358783677,
0.0266890153,
0.0228764676,
0.0089841383,
-0.0122210775,
-0.0097197583,
-0.0106665911,
-0.0064762812,
0.0016040354,
-0.0032397464,
0.0086696716,
0.0164957643,
0.0093166418,
0.0301919598,
-0.0004508941,
-0.0312169474,
-0.0849493891,
0.0190005396,
-0.0834283605,
-0.0186076108,
-0.0053344634,
-0.0381460935,
0.0407665893,
0.0031673932,
-0.0225210469,
0.0074658762,
0.0578484349,
-0.0093188165,
-0.0301632807,
-0.0213252436,
-0.0018305125,
0.0129284514,
0.0365895815,
0.0180626027,
-0.0084667671,
-0.0898402855,
-0.0140692387,
-0.0600195192,
-0.0278264768,
-0.0123166246,
0.0076048672,
0.010551827,
0.0246348307,
-0.0002372539,
0.0190173313,
0.0045927987,
0.0360885449,
-0.0654796436,
-0.0267193057,
0.0151871257,
0.034767203,
0.0333439857,
-0.0289962627,
0.0440944955,
0.116142258,
-0.0091796955,
-0.0522719696,
-0.0354519337,
-0.0217510965,
-0.0288299005,
-0.0244317334,
0.0491721146,
-0.0463702939,
0.0046742042,
-0.0036976312,
0.0190613233,
-0.0188877545,
-0.0024933631,
-0.0102725569,
-0.0194139481,
0.0954316854,
0.0053751669,
-0.0197017305,
0.0411665738,
0.0376494601,
0.0007964951,
0.0659215897,
0.0099069215,
0.0360726453,
0.0670968145,
-0.0183560885,
-0.0099225733,
0.0437291674,
0.0461325422,
-0.0210238919,
-0.0590003841,
-0.0016672148,
-0.0070776273,
-0.0110617699,
0.0162457637,
0.0228294395,
0.0092576193,
-0.0680248067,
0.035279341,
0.0192530397,
-0.0106364246,
0.0248253122,
0.0274546035,
0.0186437704,
0.0081049651,
-0.0197639912,
-0.0041819089,
0.0226370823,
-0.0244265813,
-0.0169610605,
0.0777185336,
0.0322717987,
-0.0503928475,
-0.015344278,
0.0041777263,
-0.0690411478,
0.0570347235,
-0.028862996,
0.0559494868,
0.0151042184,
-0.0308447443,
0.0012054478,
0.0242223497,
-0.0178000685,
-0.0090915011,
-0.0320990942,
0.0267407186,
0.0349988081,
0.0166569371,
-0.0571627729,
-0.0020683557,
-0.06612923,
0.055975385,
0.0264552329,
-0.0367733687,
0.0344683044,
0.0271455701,
-0.0441159271,
-0.0362085216,
-0.0210431013,
0.0002260246,
-0.0014687526,
0.0011571359,
0.0498406403,
-0.0066815973,
0.0485519022,
0.0026245301,
-0.0084531261,
0.0416492857,
-0.0236310046,
-0.0097779576,
0.0559097007,
0.0263278875,
0.0289704539,
-0.0609127469,
-0.0694174021,
0.002851398,
-0.0461857133,
-0.0550426431,
-0.015580764,
-0.0562251173,
-0.0567359552,
0.0251522437,
-0.0576942898,
-0.0396748707,
0.0607820787,
-0.0101002492,
0.0197653994,
0.0756167024,
-0.0313313417,
0.0133563196,
-0.0483195521,
-0.0483394526,
-0.0027137885,
0.049353376,
0.0214886628,
0.0326480307,
-0.0285498276,
-0.019574767,
-0.0271394476,
-0.0433366559,
0.03035748,
0.0594502948,
-0.0503158681,
-0.0054963748,
-0.0285372399,
0.0118934223,
-0.0014108423,
0.0160434246,
-0.0324650742,
0.0226538684,
-0.0637696385,
-0.0217121858,
-0.0210473426,
-0.0367275737,
-0.0292921681,
0.01086633,
-0.0112809408,
-0.0426736064,
-0.012135921,
-0.0045259893,
0.0261024069,
0.0235987492,
0.0132624656,
-0.0166497864,
0.0445007868,
-0.0436978601,
-0.0171001125,
-0.0069431765,
0.0738886148,
0.0031391433,
-0.0304840039,
0.0567991696,
0.0191274192,
-0.0371618159,
0.0064188624,
0.009934363,
-0.064431414,
0.0110841282,
0.0281355213,
0.0043431884,
0.0033103102,
0.0434560068,
0.0903964639,
-0.0003973717,
0.0084503861,
-0.0230273921,
-0.0013789872,
0.0001735214,
0.0191421006,
0.0480473265,
-0.0223742481,
-0.0235945713,
0.0410667025,
0.0119119212,
-0.0084363464,
-0.0433139615,
0.0379864275,
-0.0071468041,
-0.042744346,
-0.0326778702,
-0.0282063838,
0.024280332,
-0.0156931616,
-0.016170295,
-0.0527540557,
0.0500801578,
0.0216471497,
-0.0267371554,
0.0231788885,
-0.0340580083,
-0.0121700699,
0.0675955638,
0.005534417,
0.0614641942,
0.0066819023,
-0.0037311753,
0.0413027555,
-0.0628399774,
0.0097671598,
0.0017487345,
-0.0193928536,
0.0282797515,
0.0027803672,
0.0027332336,
-0.0468524061,
-0.0402548276,
-0.0668664202,
-0.0070121796,
-0.0398894064,
-0.0146991042,
0.0248913951,
0.0103857722,
0.0071084825,
-0.0154896574,
-0.0252928007,
0.0367582291,
-0.0194990188,
0.0260355026,
0.0135905696,
0.0370644666,
-0.0282831341,
-0.0398638099,
-0.0289527997,
0.000781058,
0.0391417593,
-0.0487790778,
-0.0343175679,
-0.0354104452,
0.0150680924,
0.0139904693,
0.0106756724,
0.0129957423,
-0.0468900837,
0.0217604712,
-0.0069873892,
0.0372427106,
0.0893986076,
0.0094711883,
-0.0502270497,
0.010821199,
0.0255634412,
-0.0532552637,
0.0247067716,
-0.0158396848,
-0.0708647221,
-0.0475534908,
-0.063126944,
0.0070674513,
-0.0313113965,
-0.014804231,
0.016140895,
-0.0570661761,
0.004676675,
-0.0067530242,
-0.0225908291,
-0.0259806551,
-0.0045497976,
-0.008178548,
-0.0241896808,
-0.0511961319,
-0.0695858672,
0.0217293482,
-0.0072567491,
-0.0161804296,
-0.0245801806,
-0.0544921085,
-0.004972415,
-0.0283257458,
0.0314112976,
-0.0080491472,
0.0303238332,
-0.0403729677,
-0.0316635631,
0.0385053121,
0.0127900047,
-0.0127018085,
-0.0658615679,
0.0808040649,
-0.0412946753,
-0.0484974906,
-0.0128274364,
0.0016153124,
0.0193280634,
-0.0079672886,
-0.031895332,
0.048716303,
-0.0005784121,
0.0123648429,
-0.0885602757,
0.0138512729,
0.0302093215,
0.0330930613,
0.0313087441,
-0.051159028,
0.0047570281,
-0.0435575582,
0.0251699779,
-0.0204186551,
-0.0303195156,
-0.0589894652,
-0.0324193537,
-0.0019619663,
-0.0151165286,
-0.0020224063,
0.0006884612,
0.0089203576,
-0.0056471503,
-0.0284549352,
0.0154612912,
-0.0214700084,
-0.0742673352,
-0.0001985626,
0.0043783356,
0.0227161534,
0.0286892038,
-0.0525380336,
0.0301603079,
-0.0123968581,
-0.0035617766,
0.0030753114,
-0.0132706491,
-0.0386599042,
-0.0259349123,
0.0920458883,
0.0067144223,
0.0282735266,
0.0306987111,
-0.0188310258,
0.0737146884,
0.0831465572,
-0.0213552415,
-0.0279365722,
0.0423006304,
-0.0033944144,
0.0171824396,
0.0072200149,
-0.0096611874,
0.0535629503,
0.0038166719,
-0.0435448326,
-0.0423875637,
-0.0078833615,
-0.033177238,
-0.039293658,
0.0398623906,
-0.0093284631,
0.0015962924,
-0.0339325927,
-0.0415265933,
-0.0160021186,
-0.0007816452,
-0.0228064246,
0.027836144,
0.0195882525,
0.0101375133,
-0.0546718463,
-0.0088502243,
-0.0175314452,
0.0414368287,
-0.0131656816,
0.0530303083,
0.0333378054,
-0.0151258092,
-0.0425741673,
0.0064878073,
0.0138175488,
0.029416468,
0.0386309214,
-0.0268314518,
0.0128558679,
0.0219270214,
0.0015805963,
0.029770229,
-0.022086462,
0.0282230135,
0.0621104352,
0.0147869186,
-0.0243434403,
0.0103087723,
0.0654985383,
-0.0462798066,
0.0022193971,
0.0364600867,
-0.0312508643,
-0.0049183518,
0.0305569153,
-0.0345932133,
-0.0330882296,
0.0285393037,
-0.0094893305,
-0.0004858097,
0.0130303055,
0.0389722697,
-0.0288380571,
0.0380366333,
0.0405289754,
-0.056871146,
-0.0475763418,
0.0053987438,
0.0619495213,
0.0366682708,
0.0171302706,
0.0642958358,
-0.0082270298,
-0.090040721,
0.0155639555,
-0.022184154,
0.0177719984,
0.0523539707,
0.0300385952,
0.0382663198,
0.0485855862,
0.0278257225,
-0.0296851024,
0.0008973769,
-0.0022129994,
-0.0302454028,
0.0374099165,
-6.119204821e-33,
-0.0090995422,
-0.0129309511,
-0.0224888492,
-0.0074918699,
-0.0045117796,
-0.0028355583,
0.0008670507,
0.0179203525,
0.0351724848,
-0.0007613759,
0.0440399684,
-0.0078499373,
-0.0257180445,
0.0107947197,
0.0210570972,
-0.0078811478,
0.0170243718,
-0.0000609826,
0.006322185,
-0.0166913755,
0.0189197268,
0.053982839,
0.0194560681,
-0.1186463982,
0.0140767908,
0.0040050312,
-0.0216417164,
-0.021504296,
0.0510618836,
0.0701096728,
-0.0282898936,
0.0798904002,
0.0395680964,
-0.0106510539,
-0.0013426053,
0.0384440497,
-0.0301660988,
-0.0255990997,
-0.020653408,
0.016364947,
-0.0373040996,
-0.0329846814,
0.0493451282,
-0.00263039,
-0.0351053253,
0.0013157168,
0.0756161362,
-0.0060745985,
0.049740199,
-0.0566992946,
-0.0569211468,
0.0067560873,
-0.0582975447,
-0.0461548455,
0.0170162208,
0.0482779071,
0.0523376763,
0.038019605,
-0.0696624294,
0.0284499377,
-0.0590980016,
-0.0657548308,
0.0384441465,
-0.0040118052,
0.0081608398,
0.0764420852,
-0.0069995672,
0.0203845296,
-0.0137589583,
0.048793681,
0.0227281377,
0.0201091859,
0.0173320547,
0.0680192485,
0.0545705631,
-0.0740562305,
-0.095281288,
0.0128200231,
-0.0117532993,
-0.0116275158,
-0.0055471966,
0.026105728,
-0.0125285704,
0.0144658377,
0.0133301811,
-0.0428671092,
-0.0197693091,
-0.0499865562,
-0.0118082026,
-0.0288035236,
-0.0245363768,
0.0403476134,
0.0505222939,
-0.0485344566,
-0.0326049142,
0.0122724837,
-0.0058883922,
0.0247765929,
0.0374588743,
0.019090699,
-0.0167928264,
-0.0011601542,
0.0404266156,
-0.0225547943,
0.0345073529,
0.0035029394,
0.0758927017,
0.0709074587,
-0.0415444486,
-0.0080007641,
-0.0005915657,
0.0082833068,
-0.0349326879,
0.0426432714,
-0.0046111071,
0.0372493714,
-0.0307595674,
0.011542947,
0.0050083646,
0.0084749227,
-0.0095851514,
-0.0484157763,
-0.0207125675,
0.0237306599,
0.0080377469,
-0.0241314843,
-0.027091438,
-0.0142547144,
-0.0235417765,
-0.1250125617,
0.018355703,
-0.0171004236,
2.661e-7,
0.0378865786,
0.0289493576,
0.006055756,
0.0183089022,
0.0295728184,
0.0658638701,
-0.0109236753,
0.0537099205,
-0.0077741751,
-0.015177886,
0.0021535095,
0.0672463626,
-0.0023500021,
0.0046206862,
-0.0102122789,
0.0063579236,
-0.0241623037,
0.0386360288,
-0.0459679477,
0.0581720136,
0.0733292177,
0.0846424326,
0.0475054532,
-0.0533781573,
-0.0135881808,
-0.0182734244,
0.0783009678,
-0.0332227647,
-0.0157198384,
-0.0536000095,
0.0283499695,
0.0415568687,
0.0068410896,
-0.0077550444,
-0.0025129216,
-0.0247716624,
0.059933126,
0.0116125401,
0.0169305671,
-0.03071649,
0.0293082427,
0.0481031016,
-0.0147016514,
0.0075764754,
0.0640506446,
-0.0221180543,
-0.0383837447,
-0.0524539053,
-0.0189311858,
0.0069772638,
0.1181812808,
-0.0329816788,
-0.044223398,
-0.0086932722,
0.0584118739,
-0.0396631397,
-0.0210217256,
-0.0882056281,
0.0088872025,
0.0305256657,
-0.0429639146,
0.0300100874,
-0.0150620565,
0.0212589093,
0.0599202551,
0.0158382989,
0.0106528364,
1.729440898e-34,
0.0367503911,
-0.0665541515,
-0.0085721826,
-0.0296984613,
-0.022896722,
0.0077795121,
-0.0323081166,
-0.0347425751,
-0.001134336,
0.0031547365,
-0.008710457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17972v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17972v2 | $\varepsilon$ KÚ <MASK>: Integrating Yorùbá cultural greetings into machine translation | 2023-03-31T11:16:20 | 2023-04-24T16:29:38 | Idris Akinade, Jesujoba Alabi, David Adelani, Clement Odoje, Dietrich Klakow | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the performance of massively multilingual neural
machine translation (NMT) systems in translating Yor\`ub\'a greetings
($\varepsilon$ k\'u [MASK]), which are a big part of Yor\`ub\'a language and
culture, into English. To evaluate these models, we present IkiniYor\`ub\'a, a
Yor\`ub\'a-English translation dataset containing some Yor\`ub\'a greetings,
and sample use cases. We analysed the performance of different multilingual NMT
systems including Google and NLLB and show that these models struggle to
accurately translate Yor\`ub\'a greetings into English. In addition, we trained
a Yor\`ub\'a-English model by finetuning an existing NMT model on the training
split of IkiniYor\`ub\'a and this achieved better performance when compared to
the pre-trained multilingual NMT models, although they were trained on a large
volume of data. | [
0.0346036553,
0.0280859191,
-0.0214532577,
0.0501845032,
-0.0251340847,
0.0525530316,
0.0147955567,
0.0004694845,
-0.0098672248,
0.0007332644,
-0.0469710231,
-0.1010215208,
0.0500214323,
-0.0054277834,
0.0319071151,
-0.0562816001,
0.0152086876,
-0.0192234982,
-0.0387873426,
0.0007840825,
-0.0365691073,
0.0334266312,
0.0353070945,
0.0445692837,
-0.0560326837,
-0.0052702436,
-0.0008815274,
0.0404119566,
0.0170135573,
-0.0197943915,
-0.0278592445,
-0.0239749011,
-0.0011397937,
0.063478291,
0.0000023328,
-0.0074438886,
0.02302479,
0.0079838149,
0.0040586879,
0.0015315179,
0.0492670499,
-0.0753749162,
-0.0335195325,
0.0260020103,
-0.0209881943,
0.0195072088,
0.078275159,
0.0297373496,
0.0665660724,
0.1112358123,
-0.0063807247,
-0.0697868839,
0.0511725396,
-0.0482103713,
0.0003366002,
-0.0101536298,
-0.0043006069,
0.0026389344,
-0.0379516482,
-0.0330262296,
-0.0273136124,
0.0539763905,
0.0226444788,
-0.0103277825,
-0.0895273387,
-0.0055622547,
-0.0068429015,
-0.0568089932,
-0.0260182619,
0.0463151745,
-0.0623678602,
0.0255355183,
0.0019888247,
0.0276579224,
-0.0386516899,
-0.033709392,
-0.0346286483,
0.0089924159,
-0.001570355,
0.0067187645,
0.0025977804,
0.0269151405,
0.0532414764,
-0.0174122062,
-0.0672598258,
0.0287660565,
0.0283453669,
-0.0200317632,
-0.0288638193,
-0.0106840329,
0.010582272,
0.0064197443,
0.0556576699,
0.0097907642,
0.0318393894,
0.0155659048,
-0.0134924641,
-0.0554631129,
0.0035988751,
-0.0616006181,
0.0398348533,
0.0451997332,
-0.0281746704,
0.0573101826,
-0.0013888432,
0.0319229476,
-0.0559487753,
-0.0309878848,
-0.0392189771,
-0.0283691939,
-0.0605316013,
-0.0090954825,
-0.0110065239,
-0.0021077334,
-0.0428837873,
-0.0069227116,
-0.0316126905,
-0.0011469442,
0.0221852027,
-0.0094674984,
0.0204583034,
-0.0542989634,
-0.0209147874,
-0.0285669994,
0.0071248896,
0.0191207547,
-0.0283219554,
-0.0627098829,
-0.0205187555,
-0.0797355324,
0.0270769056,
0.0008819752,
-0.0101265861,
-0.0205986202,
0.0062217549,
0.0633720905,
-0.0161430687,
-0.0476786643,
-0.04572713,
0.0086017177,
-0.0292324275,
-0.0298420694,
0.0043150894,
-0.0366397798,
0.0884237364,
-0.0085622221,
0.0392918624,
-0.0246614125,
-0.0139673138,
0.0146654835,
-0.0121460743,
0.033950258,
0.0316732265,
0.0046132253,
0.0703803226,
0.0059854807,
0.0126197394,
0.0319415666,
0.0409516245,
0.0396043956,
0.0236873571,
-0.0005380644,
-0.0411210097,
0.0545388199,
0.0034371379,
0.0091198105,
-0.0120621454,
-0.001162593,
0.0123823462,
0.0191625208,
-0.0014668086,
0.0761347413,
0.0039493679,
0.0127011184,
0.0644405559,
0.0342476405,
-0.0054114005,
0.0721751153,
0.0548239052,
0.0032784226,
-0.0201145094,
-0.0007106112,
-0.0375127941,
0.0362887904,
-0.0193700455,
-0.0417722054,
0.0413286202,
0.0997048393,
-0.0196966957,
-0.0283867884,
0.0132140601,
-0.0239427295,
-0.0176300965,
-0.0214390792,
0.0405715778,
-0.0186282471,
-0.0375793092,
-0.0236252435,
0.0187528841,
-0.0197058599,
0.0294047855,
-0.0266777948,
-0.0006384141,
0.0280556232,
0.0302852429,
0.0378972255,
0.0347645953,
-0.0293100346,
0.0086947596,
0.033655975,
0.0595009401,
0.0107788667,
0.0604534112,
-0.0525930151,
0.0346338488,
0.0356221758,
-0.0063234484,
0.0649914294,
-0.0051673423,
0.108398214,
0.0436039194,
0.0471446849,
-0.0425661653,
0.0258708876,
-0.0215148274,
-0.0097906077,
0.0323098861,
0.0064821802,
0.0444245487,
0.070670113,
-0.0253100265,
-0.0262102261,
-0.0117839854,
-0.0609120578,
-0.0234934688,
0.0361493677,
-0.0635157079,
-0.0356807075,
0.0090801083,
-0.027316099,
0.0083730388,
0.0089213187,
-0.0209719092,
-0.0576537475,
0.0300747082,
-0.0464485995,
-0.0010518547,
-0.0291370656,
0.0349965729,
0.0229467917,
0.0018365318,
-0.0282675754,
0.0164073166,
0.019243829,
-0.0282147713,
-0.0128349196,
-0.0405929759,
0.0591181256,
-0.02620757,
-0.0476775505,
0.0881138444,
0.0080012614,
0.0147763304,
0.0127643486,
0.0040297634,
-0.0056689647,
-0.0440968089,
-0.0945774019,
0.0043637804,
-0.0225219354,
0.025974011,
0.0019450779,
0.0755255222,
0.0002876855,
0.0123796919,
-0.0410110615,
-0.0013117344,
-0.0186146982,
0.0171857309,
-0.01640906,
0.004378261,
0.0308941063,
-0.0289033558,
-0.0365633518,
0.0365216173,
0.0398510732,
0.0242591631,
-0.0458567701,
-0.0525771827,
-0.0981091037,
-0.041543413,
-0.0089613814,
-0.0164407305,
-0.0678599179,
0.0068009547,
-0.0340648554,
0.0556205288,
0.0248354264,
0.0031163474,
-0.0177659187,
0.0102083096,
0.0032360556,
-0.0497143082,
0.0150571326,
-0.0028844872,
-0.0034695913,
-0.0047722938,
-0.0457009561,
0.0273401272,
0.0342904888,
0.0434457287,
-0.0036692293,
-0.065380238,
0.0247691739,
-0.0245371219,
-0.0547750667,
-0.0234942939,
0.0375180729,
0.00578997,
0.0383673087,
-0.0169063546,
-0.0312613696,
0.0593915321,
-0.0000980791,
-0.0381207354,
0.0079606092,
0.0212429427,
-0.0387914665,
0.0354254693,
-0.0225271322,
0.0541691482,
-0.0209682956,
-0.0504424088,
-0.0049356776,
0.0424071774,
-0.0109220622,
-0.0196656045,
0.010536164,
-0.0242857337,
-0.0286999438,
-0.0136397025,
-0.028212158,
-0.0022094797,
0.0082407426,
-0.01027078,
-0.0325886048,
0.0134628695,
0.0019573914,
-0.0062412103,
0.0392800197,
-0.0005780727,
0.0191521924,
-0.011712241,
0.0114300624,
0.0005895183,
0.0189908501,
-0.0092013124,
-0.0140278768,
0.0088716336,
-0.0061555924,
0.0091259992,
-0.049733486,
-0.0100703491,
-0.0216916464,
-0.0261302143,
-0.0123674078,
0.0275101587,
-0.0196393318,
-0.0412561744,
-0.0171487983,
0.0169406962,
-0.0282346867,
0.0228590779,
0.0888099074,
0.0356358811,
-0.0439695418,
-0.0050802575,
-0.0399430916,
0.0163583029,
-0.0218758043,
0.0310946666,
-0.0694539472,
-0.0007429356,
-0.0061458414,
0.0145293558,
0.0488259718,
0.0059162234,
-0.0090435809,
-0.0745761916,
-0.0025457609,
0.045303259,
-0.0513768457,
-0.0721027702,
0.0114466092,
-0.0669152215,
-0.0328432955,
-0.0114217624,
-0.0055728271,
0.0235491823,
-0.0402459353,
-0.0105858501,
0.0572100617,
-0.0664321557,
-0.0212063249,
-0.0585973449,
0.0472435057,
0.0690972134,
0.0595690981,
-0.0156220421,
-0.0189622045,
0.0025760939,
-0.0003965644,
0.0221599881,
-0.0224027149,
0.0140856309,
0.0302478392,
-0.0413161963,
-0.0036683253,
-0.0341954529,
-0.0223328099,
0.0523616076,
0.0331393108,
0.0219710488,
-0.0043909857,
-0.012514174,
-0.0183205102,
-0.0245280452,
0.0109593524,
0.0282093212,
0.0028087818,
-0.0377934799,
-0.0033639346,
-0.013450982,
-0.0150823342,
-0.037450619,
-0.0147135425,
0.0301641691,
-0.0662818626,
-0.0441217646,
-0.1174928993,
-0.0804807097,
-0.0146147693,
0.0454093143,
0.0630112961,
-0.0207195543,
0.0073039629,
0.0295073129,
-0.0080009764,
0.0284158271,
-0.0512107797,
0.028811058,
-0.0718371868,
0.0204406921,
0.0261296947,
-0.0210005715,
0.0460866392,
0.0123860948,
-0.0533755608,
-0.0617856607,
-0.0092859557,
0.0817689449,
0.021964455,
0.032889083,
-0.0025359823,
-0.0524147153,
0.014694361,
-0.0283591617,
0.031296581,
-0.0344103537,
0.0185482856,
-0.0016627107,
-0.0123139927,
0.0224643555,
0.0134987161,
0.0111259473,
0.0009982892,
0.0081763053,
-0.0139362756,
-0.0000324174,
-0.0165793505,
-0.0176259838,
-0.0171984285,
-0.0535215661,
-0.0312508568,
-0.0155892447,
0.0069024418,
0.013523452,
0.0107437782,
-0.0340648144,
-0.0537127554,
0.0664866567,
0.0262459721,
-0.0285387468,
-0.0232248306,
0.03249944,
-0.0203654114,
0.0034273956,
0.0039043755,
0.0100907823,
0.050366953,
0.0260920394,
0.0424835607,
-0.0406446755,
0.0570416078,
-0.009220805,
0.009280419,
-0.0397218801,
0.0682053342,
-0.0277456343,
0.0108880838,
0.0583129376,
0.0540410392,
0.0165003538,
-0.0348888747,
-0.0058485088,
-0.0042894888,
0.0910224915,
0.0074100206,
0.1069955453,
0.0254992396,
-0.0065923636,
-0.0056019751,
0.0334564745,
0.0053232354,
-0.0201087426,
0.0103786411,
-0.0070617367,
0.0212299507,
-0.0042493865,
0.0372564308,
-0.0571585745,
0.0015726156,
0.0364534445,
0.0167036671,
0.0020246033,
0.0054312269,
0.0556309596,
-0.0181728303,
-0.0286016297,
-0.0036635103,
-0.021532841,
-0.0732804388,
-0.0012541603,
0.0138870869,
0.0527332947,
0.0177882519,
0.0002877875,
0.0305606835,
-0.0026552703,
0.0251783039,
-0.0480902717,
0.0072798319,
-0.026536515,
-0.021459274,
-0.0033134983,
-6.687014142e-33,
-0.0202141423,
0.0231691524,
0.019674927,
-0.0163497292,
-0.0225198809,
-0.045795396,
-0.0256060567,
-0.0151889827,
-0.0133446334,
-0.0281619802,
-0.0522882491,
0.0017297113,
0.0202857554,
0.0197396502,
0.0451889336,
0.0172634199,
0.0472258404,
0.0241566375,
-0.0117362654,
0.0022646631,
0.0296167433,
0.0426297337,
0.0553763546,
-0.066853635,
0.0489355326,
-0.0244898833,
-0.0172071904,
-0.014548501,
0.0221253131,
0.0060330648,
-0.0317449421,
-0.0025319231,
0.0231663603,
0.0322041884,
0.0075718779,
-0.0138513474,
-0.084995009,
0.0064037615,
0.0383085869,
0.0483013429,
0.0284345169,
-0.0621293224,
0.0333372205,
-0.0539531708,
0.0047889971,
0.0226495471,
-0.0121648889,
-0.0329270251,
-0.0120483153,
-0.030844925,
-0.0870708972,
0.0363833122,
0.0237760246,
0.0008284102,
0.0427507237,
0.0516652986,
-0.0129424613,
-0.0221073907,
-0.0891783014,
-0.0159904882,
0.0144691346,
0.0189645719,
0.0649071112,
0.0572714806,
-0.0371967256,
-0.0304709338,
0.0191493891,
0.0028802119,
0.0539454259,
0.0482492149,
0.0453755073,
-0.0430624112,
0.0625513569,
0.0596947744,
0.0718716905,
-0.0404279642,
-0.0135493856,
0.0428335331,
0.0280993525,
-0.0267339591,
0.0107410932,
0.0082018208,
-0.0166074596,
0.0029513007,
-0.0063347761,
-0.0322837234,
-0.0279828347,
-0.0527758375,
0.0252381954,
-0.0038675417,
-0.0144233862,
0.0235450026,
0.0514996536,
-0.0166600477,
0.0079344567,
-0.0083426433,
0.0067640292,
-0.0052560801,
-0.0224533789,
0.0353126712,
-0.0322804116,
-0.0355021805,
-0.0276878662,
0.0064783874,
0.0143940048,
-0.002396625,
0.0437511094,
0.0452942103,
-0.0571187921,
0.0051693362,
-0.0184584986,
-0.0015228394,
0.0223910436,
0.0111789051,
0.0060223672,
-0.0344197974,
-0.0082802912,
-0.003317527,
0.0711570755,
-0.0078489091,
0.0082504591,
-0.026453156,
0.0339733921,
-0.00251037,
-0.0667722374,
0.004503346,
-0.0267709792,
0.0027195374,
0.042557057,
-0.0506090596,
-0.0144164879,
0.0097036092,
3.14e-7,
0.0101485709,
0.021079991,
-0.0098771062,
0.0284625068,
0.0149926078,
-0.0016511377,
-0.041062627,
0.0171595234,
0.0219640769,
0.0745166615,
0.0413305052,
-0.0326231942,
0.0901402533,
0.0131775644,
-0.133298412,
-0.0556807928,
-0.0104674445,
-0.0032985329,
-0.0748713389,
0.0087903878,
0.048260998,
0.1312692761,
-0.0003610039,
-0.027870927,
-0.0474272631,
-0.0268070195,
0.0634534135,
-0.0219692793,
-0.0026014703,
-0.0347023904,
0.0340184197,
0.0073878756,
-0.0482432917,
-0.0365700535,
-0.0213338826,
0.0017948058,
0.0698233247,
0.0772340298,
-0.0126559129,
0.0579834953,
0.0236852672,
-0.0034588401,
-0.043169219,
-0.0703989193,
0.049352847,
-0.0191537682,
-0.0288319737,
0.0163805485,
-0.0007050486,
-0.008612616,
0.0335593931,
-0.0666890144,
-0.0041307681,
0.0215383675,
0.043857906,
-0.048798766,
0.0125842923,
-0.0332330279,
0.0019727689,
-0.013519844,
-0.0089321258,
-0.0104774479,
-0.0144411735,
0.0216916949,
-0.0110411542,
-0.0048043965,
-0.0127296736,
2.34373783e-34,
0.0394043401,
-0.0272789039,
0.0315143317,
0.0122250076,
0.0411934815,
-0.0128469989,
-0.0206977893,
-0.0006138512,
-0.0113125117,
-0.0379156545,
-0.0238062888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17932v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17932v1 | Trimming Phonetic Alignments Improves the Inference of Sound Correspondence Patterns from Multilingual Wordlists | 2023-03-31T09:55:48 | 2023-03-31T09:55:48 | Frederic Blum, Johann-Mattis List | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sound correspondence patterns form the basis of cognate detection and
phonological reconstruction in historical language comparison. Methods for the
automatic inference of correspondence patterns from phonetically aligned
cognate sets have been proposed, but their application to multilingual
wordlists requires extremely well annotated datasets. Since annotation is
tedious and time consuming, it would be desirable to find ways to improve
aligned cognate data automatically. Taking inspiration from trimming techniques
in evolutionary biology, which improve alignments by excluding problematic
sites, we propose a workflow that trims phonetic alignments in comparative
linguistics prior to the inference of correspondence patterns. Testing these
techniques on a large standardized collection of ten datasets with expert
annotations from different language families, we find that the best trimming
technique substantially improves the overall consistency of the alignments. The
results show a clear increase in the proportion of frequent correspondence
patterns and words exhibiting regular cognate relations. | [
-0.0235144999,
0.0955567881,
-0.0294317473,
0.026317725,
-0.0779745653,
0.0050744861,
-0.0194275267,
-0.0263026915,
-0.0692187846,
0.0123106977,
-0.0419409908,
-0.0017301474,
0.0986802503,
-0.0747073591,
0.0252268761,
0.0154084172,
0.030267125,
-0.0210511424,
0.0036656414,
0.0071392884,
-0.0073464499,
0.0263047814,
-0.0302061103,
0.0100107333,
-0.0017302864,
-0.0036529875,
0.0099285338,
0.0146640828,
0.0344076976,
-0.0256505925,
-0.0312706567,
0.0367019735,
-0.0552625991,
0.0662637651,
0.0000015574,
-0.0731136873,
0.0055393456,
0.0161452852,
-0.0283018164,
0.0115060201,
-0.0082353801,
0.0426613539,
-0.0255813301,
-0.0242601559,
0.003091455,
0.0321457125,
0.0976470634,
-0.0796695054,
-0.0325856209,
0.0254205652,
-0.0071748737,
-0.0458057858,
-0.0231840946,
-0.025973931,
0.0078208214,
-0.0068317587,
0.0255674738,
0.0048166872,
0.0205233768,
-0.0539956465,
-0.0177394468,
0.0348583721,
-0.0977346599,
0.0059192991,
-0.0420340374,
-0.0184249859,
-0.0337997861,
-0.0357288457,
0.0361334495,
-0.0031132177,
0.0300605372,
-0.0623430274,
0.0137625914,
0.0126769394,
-0.0097209569,
0.0182685871,
0.0077572078,
-0.0223193411,
-0.0645979345,
0.0262293071,
0.069490023,
-0.0239115581,
-0.0108017307,
-0.0272410326,
0.0032703711,
0.0697041005,
0.0663066506,
-0.0511590354,
-0.0176206958,
0.0053761029,
0.0516505018,
-0.0340236835,
0.0086867409,
-0.0022696201,
-0.0372043625,
-0.0128644742,
0.0090432186,
-0.0108232303,
0.0430752672,
0.0011440058,
0.0315601006,
0.006366204,
-0.042098403,
0.0212655813,
-0.020336736,
0.0096963588,
0.0226571839,
-0.0707086548,
-0.0142528377,
-0.024033498,
-0.035615366,
0.0158186648,
-0.0149223665,
-0.0471308939,
0.0120186564,
0.0533728823,
-0.0362132899,
-0.0480097532,
-0.0284555946,
0.031922061,
0.0037088695,
-0.0394692123,
-0.0136342589,
0.0318068452,
-0.0241002515,
0.0081351809,
-0.0240181088,
0.0346380062,
-0.0899616331,
-0.0586777367,
0.0137766432,
0.0270385481,
0.0469436757,
-0.0272963531,
0.0392736234,
0.0347854346,
0.0214678403,
0.0202607904,
0.025463853,
-0.0003984965,
-0.0534609854,
0.0051989374,
-0.0465948768,
-0.0865048543,
0.0750435144,
-0.0296472423,
-0.0370591208,
-0.0388822146,
-0.0395890549,
-0.0044983826,
-0.0718958378,
0.0234352052,
-0.0209558085,
0.0442376137,
-0.0122691523,
-0.0477459729,
-0.0106849233,
-0.026723206,
0.0174004454,
-0.0907278061,
0.0568809547,
-0.0324762538,
-0.0607045405,
0.0189670399,
-0.0157441162,
-0.0360458605,
-0.0187384076,
-0.0091520511,
0.0251819193,
0.0441543832,
0.0654804707,
0.0254696421,
0.0017941482,
-0.068160966,
0.0245378613,
0.0607403256,
0.0624303184,
0.016073402,
0.0150209507,
-0.0159369893,
0.0090079904,
0.0380298682,
-0.0100056333,
-0.0536589287,
0.0041298596,
-0.0017170653,
0.0165940579,
0.0580137484,
0.0096198944,
0.0451131836,
-0.0432758369,
-0.0180118028,
-0.0127902254,
0.0206283014,
0.0121319536,
-0.0227321256,
-0.0217401683,
-0.0177227613,
0.0367617123,
-0.0225668587,
-0.0304133277,
0.0059003523,
0.0516954735,
0.0329469852,
0.0164924394,
-0.0507314317,
0.0029160993,
0.066919826,
-0.0474823564,
0.0452164486,
-0.0065393215,
-0.0251290631,
0.03042222,
-0.0082533509,
-0.0021911517,
0.0452632308,
0.0047425334,
0.049544394,
-0.0164714959,
0.0491377749,
-0.0027361335,
-0.027508527,
0.0013168949,
0.0251766182,
-0.0368265621,
-0.0194627717,
-0.019733388,
0.0116202533,
0.052017618,
0.0467026234,
-0.0043437048,
0.0527356118,
0.0027970304,
-0.0238194633,
0.078511551,
0.0628030077,
0.0096249245,
0.0090532191,
0.0664388761,
-0.060681548,
-0.0019814975,
-0.0324939713,
0.006023163,
-0.0165286735,
0.0101722497,
-0.0414827019,
0.0580958836,
-0.0088795945,
0.0401414558,
-0.0329407677,
-0.0000058188,
-0.0253349282,
0.0433422811,
0.0907967687,
0.0461202003,
0.0156766009,
-0.0474542752,
0.015008457,
-0.0345751084,
-0.0099972766,
0.0093579022,
-0.0156194894,
-0.0502111688,
0.015636934,
-0.0375150666,
-0.0164874233,
0.009652691,
-0.0389639996,
0.0053177257,
0.0155582791,
0.0808190107,
0.0046501486,
-0.0024754454,
-0.0100768004,
0.0035363021,
0.0187343135,
0.0064093531,
-0.0187890232,
0.0297440737,
0.0353971645,
-0.049442865,
-0.0308547243,
-0.0698632374,
0.0018646345,
-0.0051469672,
0.0217689723,
0.0091575077,
-0.0504107252,
-0.0482116155,
-0.0345657356,
-0.0932271332,
0.0115823084,
0.0036946186,
0.004479547,
0.0220766906,
0.0258841719,
0.0263066757,
-0.0181705076,
-0.0191685241,
-0.0706908405,
0.0440776534,
-0.0415510572,
-0.0269648768,
-0.0313345008,
0.0037626191,
0.0462576337,
-0.0045522298,
-0.0340902656,
-0.034542378,
0.0614536144,
-0.0045802523,
-0.0126435366,
-0.0026463948,
-0.002200431,
0.01686229,
0.02231526,
0.0012366398,
-0.0609135255,
-0.0302167535,
0.0341302082,
-0.036261823,
-0.0279873665,
0.0217289403,
-0.0590687469,
0.0267364122,
-0.0361065678,
-0.0194922704,
-0.0496541895,
0.0703460351,
0.004524318,
-0.0131591773,
0.0107338019,
-0.0342111029,
-0.0274688881,
0.0157551356,
0.1194990203,
-0.0226763319,
-0.0006548015,
-0.0509467646,
0.0231395625,
-0.024374662,
-0.0068489043,
-0.0125292223,
0.0082538547,
-0.0594951957,
0.0031900157,
0.0092433849,
-0.0394805111,
0.0238976609,
0.0279090591,
-0.0007549858,
0.0160119813,
0.0429876894,
0.048133336,
-0.0087021627,
0.034824539,
-0.0042329277,
0.0355448164,
-0.0326382741,
0.0457172468,
-0.0038178985,
0.0057110861,
-0.0091290716,
0.0455875881,
0.001919191,
-0.0324324705,
0.0340789594,
-0.0338331461,
-0.0294919703,
-0.0208159517,
0.0037487431,
0.0323215164,
0.0211212989,
0.0683981329,
0.0371500701,
0.0393906794,
0.0194031782,
-0.0425425842,
0.029280344,
0.0191686004,
-0.0106951734,
-0.053178709,
-0.0106710279,
0.0479577407,
-0.0075227465,
0.015716631,
-0.033049725,
-0.0002648127,
-0.118117176,
-0.0176673811,
-0.0075520957,
-0.0441240147,
0.0003843622,
-0.0435840674,
0.0299338717,
-0.0347348116,
-0.0743225738,
0.0446240678,
0.0001777487,
-0.0043110834,
0.0208704527,
-0.0595172755,
-0.0187748782,
0.0053068926,
-0.0884289518,
0.0307605509,
0.01550401,
0.0888863802,
-0.0264493916,
-0.045598112,
0.0082671344,
-0.0019784831,
-0.015863223,
0.0161035322,
0.0230312068,
0.0585750118,
0.0115214679,
0.0052781315,
0.0122041218,
0.01429593,
-0.0421831124,
0.0494971238,
0.020271536,
0.0073464639,
-0.0149357449,
0.0249287318,
0.0696132407,
-0.0223042145,
0.0665911138,
0.0265920013,
-0.0177605692,
0.0149019891,
0.0462883003,
0.0327123553,
0.0021217559,
-0.0029679139,
0.0423729345,
-0.0115803061,
-0.0513956845,
-0.1173840389,
0.0072425269,
-0.0250513554,
0.037207853,
0.0566673912,
0.0157419126,
-0.0257009696,
-0.007583071,
-0.0372712091,
0.0234976355,
-0.0136003448,
0.0398721136,
-0.0392052531,
-0.0052749706,
0.0169418864,
-0.0234452821,
-0.0093742479,
0.0097108744,
-0.0412236564,
-0.0619032234,
0.0181996562,
-0.0188565906,
0.0221638288,
0.063837491,
-0.0020572317,
0.0098578371,
-0.033129368,
0.0090126516,
0.0376174785,
0.01699977,
-0.007717642,
-0.0516815484,
0.0128102638,
0.018128125,
-0.0288413856,
-0.0016526551,
-0.0027436179,
0.0165621135,
0.0365926214,
-0.0735567063,
0.024477452,
0.0086181061,
0.0265964307,
-0.0733924583,
-0.0353829525,
-0.0102371015,
-0.0244556554,
0.0126432041,
0.0033842816,
0.0244785268,
-0.0102277342,
-0.0151343439,
0.0052295844,
0.0127419475,
-0.0036903312,
-0.0510139279,
0.0118395258,
-0.0376348384,
0.0493040569,
0.0416466817,
0.0443169437,
-0.0202666856,
0.0007175094,
0.0041579306,
0.0331079625,
-0.0437145233,
0.0824430957,
-0.0175583549,
-0.0682635084,
-0.0217235927,
0.0371391736,
0.0007624136,
0.0090994444,
0.0102392994,
0.018345017,
-0.0070278379,
-0.0038737175,
0.0851519257,
-0.0439170785,
0.0616434887,
-0.0079598604,
-0.0190500747,
0.0116619701,
0.020818593,
-0.0354206599,
0.0012032323,
-0.0265119597,
0.0183052234,
-0.0248863827,
0.020810537,
0.0287922025,
-0.0530704223,
0.0227141026,
-0.025918778,
-0.04018512,
0.0266537517,
-0.0392816849,
-0.0138894087,
-0.0328865275,
-0.0512894094,
-0.0729749128,
-0.0442322269,
-0.0568658151,
0.0099027269,
0.0377277993,
-0.0008975521,
0.0406433567,
0.015248999,
0.0174905788,
0.0047053592,
0.0543494746,
0.008178425,
0.0046844706,
0.0061627771,
-0.0235796962,
-0.0297019556,
-5.100473662e-33,
-0.0072094277,
0.0074458178,
0.0037532565,
-0.0025422596,
-0.016260799,
-0.0148403635,
-0.0177981146,
0.0086669754,
-0.0471262448,
-0.0240408238,
0.0313365795,
-0.0313731246,
0.006705049,
-0.0512427054,
0.0385482423,
0.023767747,
0.0147661939,
0.0404569656,
-0.020178318,
-0.0646533668,
0.0478520133,
-0.023953123,
0.0655125976,
-0.0388845801,
0.004399946,
0.0167136397,
-0.00771017,
0.0347604118,
-0.01501536,
0.021270914,
0.0142673198,
-0.0119755296,
0.0034773222,
0.0451468006,
0.0169579759,
-0.0083496179,
-0.0637942031,
-0.0270842277,
0.0485017486,
-0.001205132,
0.067068167,
0.0209369287,
-0.0244982745,
0.0177228972,
-0.0300342366,
0.0150951752,
0.0485258549,
-0.0195398387,
-0.0101827374,
0.0235916283,
-0.0824775174,
0.0430339389,
-0.019548744,
-0.012182693,
0.0159084275,
0.0759091154,
0.0246127807,
0.0040399805,
-0.0448651947,
0.0461926572,
0.001995669,
0.0245702658,
0.0512653589,
-0.0131306052,
-0.0494740047,
0.0392750502,
0.0442735925,
-0.0660560355,
0.0629550144,
0.0302721821,
0.0096773477,
0.0249422546,
-0.021102095,
0.0369040221,
0.0778800994,
-0.0109336032,
0.028618997,
0.0042999885,
-0.0002593493,
-0.0032452394,
-0.0211824887,
0.0264252145,
-0.0056415759,
-0.0014874229,
-0.0087250769,
-0.0263652913,
-0.0151516488,
0.0371726826,
-0.0017809301,
-0.0469727665,
0.0016391812,
0.0580060482,
0.0136173014,
0.0150516527,
-0.0235557761,
-0.0331893973,
-0.0123818507,
-0.0119913714,
-0.0324704051,
0.0118453791,
0.0182153024,
-0.0424280651,
0.0262919236,
0.0240860246,
0.0646071956,
-0.0022930533,
0.0339547209,
-0.0012841841,
-0.0510678627,
0.006018294,
-0.0176167134,
-0.0431775749,
-0.0490098931,
-0.0221764352,
0.0454906337,
0.0251279231,
0.0435524322,
-0.0454280935,
0.0832802206,
-0.0351193957,
-0.0216736831,
-0.0072117993,
-0.0121633923,
-0.0361886285,
0.0148160132,
0.0257654861,
0.0551935285,
0.0175605975,
0.0022469517,
0.0139031466,
-0.0042125611,
0.0211579986,
2.501e-7,
0.0320663899,
0.0026578482,
0.0808021575,
-0.004784348,
0.0172291212,
-0.0347754322,
-0.0330224335,
-0.0084169228,
0.0015525458,
0.0267806221,
0.0499410294,
-0.0470895134,
0.1087433845,
0.0875870958,
-0.0435398668,
-0.0262621809,
-0.0819896311,
-0.0344217718,
-0.0636291355,
-0.0166733917,
-0.0065368451,
0.0438747741,
-0.0148285022,
-0.0474803299,
-0.0197318383,
0.0150594767,
-0.0054457132,
-0.0390229933,
0.0270231385,
-0.0091335634,
-0.0133909881,
-0.1025059298,
0.0303415414,
0.031299185,
-0.0569300093,
0.0450581983,
0.0368598141,
-0.0341426767,
-0.0169011243,
0.0307936054,
-0.0199723281,
0.0164683908,
-0.0124682849,
-0.0071044262,
0.0265361127,
0.065647833,
-0.0061626285,
-0.0339646675,
-0.0303947013,
0.0666382983,
0.0152850561,
0.0195572544,
0.0149836224,
0.0219259579,
0.0578088239,
0.0026179291,
-0.0700278431,
0.0179715622,
-0.0239295997,
0.0356545299,
-0.0514611751,
-0.0182577912,
0.0589212067,
-0.0377071574,
-0.0080100968,
-0.0170040689,
0.0039987559,
1.673062283e-34,
-0.0196198244,
-0.014982448,
0.0314774103,
-0.0089731123,
0.0125878658,
-0.0101128966,
0.0126657551,
0.0721356571,
-0.0026805496,
0.0188394897,
-0.0100153573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17930v1 | JobHam-place with smart recommend job options and candidate filtering options | 2023-03-31T09:54:47 | 2023-03-31T09:54:47 | Shiyao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the increasing number of graduates, many applicants experience the
situation about finding a job, and employers experience difficulty filtering
job applicants, which might negatively impact their effectiveness. However,
most job-hunting websites lack job recommendation and CV filtering or ranking
functionality, which are not integrated into the system. Thus, a smart job
hunter combined with the above functionality will be conducted in this project,
which contains job recommendations, CV ranking and even a job dashboard for
skills and job applicant functionality. Job recommendation and CV ranking
starts from the automatic keyword extraction and end with the Job/CV ranking
algorithm. Automatic keyword extraction is implemented by Job2Skill and the
CV2Skill model based on Bert. Job2Skill consists of two components, text
encoder and Gru-based layers, while CV2Skill is mainly based on Bert and
fine-tunes the pre-trained model by the Resume- Entity dataset. Besides, to
match skills from CV and job description and rank lists of jobs and candidates,
job/CV ranking algorithms have been provided to compute the occurrence ratio of
skill words based on TFIDF score and match ratio of the total skill numbers.
Besides, some advanced features have been integrated into the website to
improve user experiences, such as the calendar and sweetalert2 plugin. And some
basic features to go through job application processes, such as job application
tracking and interview arrangement. | [
0.0661389232,
-0.0429525338,
-0.0160315242,
-0.030951187,
0.0090563735,
-0.0240613073,
-0.0244042408,
0.0414554626,
0.0469904803,
-0.0630655438,
-0.0143335313,
0.0257581547,
0.0083512953,
0.0159248654,
0.0174541827,
-0.0108183548,
0.008283955,
0.0336608887,
-0.0307803676,
0.0106213698,
0.0123752626,
0.0031660609,
-0.0053431708,
0.0418668129,
0.0363989696,
0.0121608321,
0.0305882394,
-0.009404772,
0.0476148799,
-0.0155541748,
0.0263504237,
-0.0152552379,
-0.0075357207,
-0.0040208795,
0.0000021894,
-0.0246073771,
-0.0321409591,
0.0174179506,
0.0083860196,
-0.0378196798,
-0.0184649862,
0.0266664177,
-0.0118405875,
0.0420023501,
-0.0200651716,
0.0659121796,
0.0305932965,
0.0056500691,
0.0279629603,
0.0377384908,
0.0127638336,
-0.0545602553,
-0.0499291196,
-0.0121586658,
0.0005531329,
-0.0235463269,
0.0420893468,
-0.0831371769,
0.0421276167,
0.0066624191,
0.0006415712,
-0.0309283044,
-0.0710548162,
-0.0449429117,
0.0643919855,
0.0320712104,
-0.0371732339,
-0.0632789284,
0.0402267762,
0.0200864915,
-0.0402204134,
-0.0010391186,
0.0230545849,
-0.0068520191,
0.0002402961,
0.0524154976,
-0.0182482712,
0.0111371381,
-0.0448033698,
-0.015114109,
-0.0112569919,
0.0254354514,
-0.028605463,
-0.0172594395,
0.0384051166,
0.0998153314,
-0.0141429715,
-0.0478385091,
-0.003068137,
-0.0264916942,
0.0758020952,
-0.018438058,
0.0803560764,
0.0329869948,
-0.0207943786,
-0.0119345356,
0.0077668438,
-0.0196502171,
0.0395780392,
-0.0992570892,
-0.0281409491,
0.0099578528,
0.0105857309,
0.0200247411,
0.0128964279,
-0.0022565587,
0.0230465289,
-0.0094654495,
-0.0121300761,
-0.0263419542,
-0.065874435,
-0.0246347617,
-0.036537312,
0.0195466317,
0.0054052663,
0.0185748599,
-0.0596611314,
0.0028434831,
-0.0156326257,
0.0200758204,
0.0584046282,
0.0384586751,
-0.010995443,
0.0235150252,
-0.0528482758,
-0.0381257683,
-0.0208608769,
-0.0114296451,
-0.0360778123,
0.0161682498,
0.0541346632,
0.0246930793,
0.0771112368,
-0.0371509492,
0.0094771553,
0.0110157868,
0.0476101376,
0.0110605545,
-0.0058400291,
0.0091577219,
0.0088368729,
0.0166074447,
-0.0291619208,
-0.0391396731,
0.0062701828,
-0.0041646119,
-0.0297412444,
0.022058174,
0.031193763,
0.0473117381,
-0.0179322176,
0.0403871201,
-0.0105308741,
0.0023456127,
0.0866576955,
-0.0140109221,
-0.0003486483,
-0.0168804415,
-0.0084423963,
0.100669086,
0.0280379355,
-0.0425060391,
0.0566108562,
0.0194693711,
-0.0415156111,
-0.0489988923,
0.012929487,
0.0560377464,
-0.0321600437,
0.0199037921,
-0.0117951399,
-0.0209524855,
-0.0371293612,
0.0761764571,
0.0059756381,
0.0173446462,
0.0561343804,
-0.010819748,
0.0357038528,
0.0875643492,
-0.0051802229,
-0.0647220686,
0.0263733584,
0.0562133268,
-0.0251166131,
-0.0390363187,
-0.053423211,
0.0538700297,
-0.0176741984,
0.0144621776,
0.0057667904,
0.0006653806,
-0.0081365239,
0.0283987001,
0.0418161303,
-0.0262355618,
-0.0536136888,
0.0195521191,
0.0127031729,
-0.0084240437,
-0.0034231427,
-0.0359495506,
-0.0172302946,
0.1050044447,
0.0384554975,
-0.0352724791,
-0.0382825732,
-0.0211691894,
-0.0568575896,
-0.0124967163,
0.0612866022,
-0.0377361625,
-0.026372334,
-0.0402344912,
-0.0480096042,
0.0323160812,
-0.0146962684,
-0.0007876856,
0.011831292,
0.0529177971,
0.0133284768,
-0.0070713595,
0.0045666252,
0.0044810283,
0.0662267953,
-0.0115986103,
0.0011911027,
0.0303733051,
-0.0137007758,
0.0006653096,
0.014031712,
0.0060389335,
0.0183240995,
-0.0042589982,
0.0106886989,
-0.002760828,
0.0459267236,
0.0142202443,
-0.0061519323,
0.0144691421,
0.0179360956,
0.0294424985,
-0.0109545989,
-0.0001687544,
-0.0406743884,
0.0039235856,
-0.0084023923,
-0.0064652185,
0.0307831112,
-0.0461116508,
0.0228623059,
-0.0494241044,
0.1072857082,
0.073918514,
-0.0069380677,
0.0031678686,
-0.005526647,
-0.0030573022,
-0.1019604504,
-0.0074525578,
-0.003166544,
-0.0079002446,
0.050829839,
0.0252216812,
0.0046082749,
-0.0376232564,
-0.0280776899,
-0.0548924804,
0.0299218204,
0.0382948443,
0.0123409331,
0.0085276505,
-0.001778066,
-0.0012409005,
-0.0413566679,
-0.0235376395,
0.0143011911,
-0.0457772687,
-0.046632573,
0.0331258886,
-0.0105954986,
-0.0084960284,
-0.046631258,
-0.0094305361,
-0.0060499315,
-0.0205045044,
0.0318345353,
-0.0292166583,
-0.0321824253,
0.011848459,
0.0048939106,
0.0137253534,
0.0428050235,
-0.0286849961,
-0.0513592325,
0.0151814809,
-0.0277410671,
0.0598324537,
0.0102791926,
0.0392434038,
0.0009174178,
-0.0058048703,
0.0044112643,
-0.0068785795,
-0.0185139589,
0.0904136449,
0.0001682538,
0.0016163241,
-0.0000527143,
-0.07969255,
0.0173645485,
-0.0025054717,
-0.0115455603,
0.0157723073,
0.0105724502,
0.0310776234,
-0.0577967279,
0.0355800875,
-0.0348739102,
0.0132123055,
0.017903896,
0.0092863133,
-0.0083896704,
0.0054835519,
0.039708823,
-0.0399617068,
-0.0677142516,
-0.0238767583,
-0.0152548412,
-0.0227246378,
0.0306556039,
-0.0691267848,
-0.0467295945,
-0.013510081,
-0.0055071707,
0.0168724917,
-0.0657270029,
-0.1180235967,
0.0562356524,
-0.0398418158,
0.0004829865,
-0.024703294,
-0.0642754361,
-0.0103827836,
-0.0201330855,
0.0135931158,
0.022959413,
0.0026127682,
-0.0546133555,
0.0118543776,
-0.0011266422,
0.0293082763,
0.0042183069,
-0.0087851891,
-0.001211051,
0.0351681188,
0.0581418388,
0.0233561955,
-0.0316813439,
0.0485904142,
-0.0017935282,
0.0099177007,
-0.0079107024,
0.0048896661,
-0.0000262451,
0.00241422,
0.0350850858,
-0.0946663767,
-0.0350143835,
0.0006604629,
-0.0530647077,
-0.0174070504,
0.0256072246,
0.048733715,
0.0209048688,
-0.0306136739,
-0.0091025075,
0.0052621984,
-0.0998843536,
0.0391061045,
0.0763889626,
-0.0035461078,
0.0196133833,
0.0245983079,
0.0607356243,
-0.0032282076,
0.007148271,
0.0144515857,
-0.0700886324,
0.0566965975,
-0.0252998155,
0.0213980824,
-0.0094103012,
-0.039910879,
-0.0120086242,
-0.0033224432,
-0.0664409101,
-0.007227309,
-0.0320360847,
0.006894303,
0.0178533848,
0.0043421821,
-0.0536991581,
0.0601620413,
-0.0569408871,
-0.0122201154,
0.1165984273,
0.0927605405,
-0.0122972764,
-0.0338349082,
-0.0489553735,
-0.0069749188,
-0.0166455135,
0.0014638924,
-0.0117503079,
-0.0657804832,
-0.0040067257,
-0.0187928788,
-0.0141580235,
0.0151245017,
0.042257145,
0.0365828983,
0.0332168825,
-0.018644115,
0.0339832678,
-0.0670096576,
0.0078151179,
-0.011411543,
0.0424481556,
-0.0297399648,
-0.0714200586,
0.0237353891,
0.0084955683,
-0.007478585,
0.0290799383,
-0.0222201645,
0.0235551242,
-0.0452082269,
-0.0105458386,
-0.0634033084,
-0.0383059122,
0.0335520171,
0.0442185998,
0.0266003367,
0.0210699905,
0.0231253598,
0.0052567101,
-0.0448849313,
-0.0380633026,
0.0494500808,
0.0598189458,
-0.0504535101,
-0.0027228196,
-0.0054542436,
-0.0693833455,
-0.0431874134,
-0.0617478117,
0.0013746347,
0.0375446379,
-0.0337738059,
0.0159695446,
0.0243567508,
0.0083851507,
-0.0438393727,
-0.0488982722,
0.0120019019,
0.042053286,
-0.047640603,
-0.0245812964,
-0.0240854081,
0.0087395478,
0.0004725675,
-0.0038660837,
-0.044539202,
0.0237702895,
-0.0121601205,
-0.0218911804,
0.0738030151,
0.0018559714,
-0.0020344446,
0.0322164595,
0.0059910975,
0.0253236908,
-0.0119200349,
-0.0380344614,
0.0212785322,
0.0017944663,
-0.0341185294,
-0.0159112308,
0.0314602591,
0.0501410961,
-0.0111591043,
0.0261624865,
-0.0055782683,
0.0419451669,
-0.0325054973,
-0.0740216002,
0.0599325188,
-0.0626470968,
0.0178484377,
-0.0185674299,
-0.0015893033,
0.0220933855,
-0.0138366641,
0.035450317,
0.0407466888,
-0.0313670263,
0.0127751203,
-0.0447615422,
-0.012471701,
0.0000976859,
0.0508380197,
-0.0220961943,
-0.0400189459,
-0.0279701892,
0.061542403,
0.0254491773,
-0.0426505916,
0.0281639546,
0.0071606906,
-0.0077009341,
-0.0063684215,
-0.0236106385,
0.029781295,
-0.004495332,
0.0055784974,
0.0023137231,
-0.0166052766,
-0.0078464877,
0.034149874,
0.0151883885,
-0.0414298996,
-0.0243434049,
-0.0648829788,
-0.0247125309,
0.070827432,
0.0780284554,
0.0601568371,
-0.0357398987,
-0.0014501938,
-0.0184145905,
-0.0176439043,
0.0151151558,
-0.027798295,
-0.0104130711,
-0.0234952252,
0.0443743356,
0.0365021713,
-0.0060952613,
0.0018276711,
-0.0441484936,
0.0022071719,
0.0021497537,
0.036056798,
-0.0226298608,
-6.5125267e-33,
-0.0356694572,
-0.049603492,
0.0169809144,
0.0203067884,
0.0536105558,
-0.0122254631,
0.0584077947,
-0.0477812812,
-0.0109134903,
-0.0182573143,
-0.0023685866,
0.0326774605,
0.0256078653,
-0.0056087589,
0.0234455038,
0.0232331343,
0.011980718,
0.0225434676,
-0.0037538274,
-0.0031645538,
-0.011296819,
0.0636486411,
0.0831278786,
-0.0258551445,
-0.0169977844,
-0.0114820907,
-0.0266866442,
0.0236823969,
0.0392846204,
0.0545021705,
-0.0216040872,
0.0136352014,
-0.0088113528,
-0.0418571271,
0.031926237,
0.0076238899,
-0.078848809,
-0.0020411531,
0.0064623831,
0.0613836162,
0.0335796326,
0.0087186815,
0.0124398591,
-0.0204807576,
-0.0107836556,
0.055343762,
0.0689453259,
-0.0230089575,
-0.0240442976,
-0.0294138268,
-0.0388718545,
0.0364386253,
0.0033489538,
-0.0186514799,
0.0134201963,
0.0125019699,
0.0217546709,
0.0177893676,
-0.1300657541,
-0.0295777023,
-0.0413150452,
0.0213292539,
-0.0008308234,
-0.0195137262,
-0.0036793933,
0.0371131338,
0.0445123091,
-0.0155207673,
0.0521073453,
0.0117769931,
-0.0266150199,
0.0597437099,
-0.0096953847,
-0.0425564945,
0.0536861084,
-0.0922400728,
-0.0017391266,
0.0475933403,
0.035354998,
-0.0152130201,
0.0271044765,
-0.0003685665,
-0.0338802487,
-0.009625352,
0.0585298166,
0.0048061623,
-0.0383891799,
-0.0122839753,
0.0391475596,
0.0390795544,
-0.0186427739,
0.043794632,
-0.0801931918,
-0.0192622822,
0.0348565467,
0.0117436377,
-0.0256832112,
-0.0213287156,
-0.0180836543,
-0.0071197902,
-0.0181578416,
-0.0389600024,
-0.0439426601,
-0.0037586137,
-0.014244684,
0.0723904967,
-0.0234047789,
0.0127848126,
-0.0348914489,
0.0020028134,
0.0214672592,
-0.0405501723,
-0.0244967043,
0.0246279724,
0.0098571321,
-0.0057009961,
0.0001423532,
0.0263675209,
0.057308808,
0.0250922982,
0.0098365508,
-0.066608265,
0.0714636296,
0.0182489268,
0.0104136504,
-0.0078727901,
-0.0526504628,
-0.005600119,
-0.0252008513,
-0.0422099493,
-0.01015939,
0.0000438629,
2.944e-7,
0.0414950438,
0.0339281298,
-0.0685367212,
-0.0338042229,
0.0014721602,
0.0096646799,
0.0171709359,
0.0391071104,
0.0028381574,
0.0880988538,
-0.0218616873,
-0.0466465279,
0.0051813722,
-0.0010445807,
-0.072305344,
-0.0528911613,
-0.0520395935,
-0.0441547148,
-0.0479485728,
0.0561051033,
0.0653003231,
0.0737919211,
0.05845825,
-0.0071214582,
-0.0015408521,
-0.0045874636,
-0.0118804481,
0.0342956744,
0.0211153589,
0.0177479405,
0.011783937,
0.0377236754,
-0.0293418299,
0.0002355071,
-0.0356192291,
0.0402732007,
0.0786099583,
0.0186943244,
-0.0413355306,
0.0678388998,
0.0513864607,
-0.0717590079,
0.0016549772,
-0.059068393,
0.0500042439,
0.0007570632,
-0.0312535837,
0.0075606368,
-0.0485684238,
-0.0037493773,
-0.0071582333,
-0.0042997319,
-0.0327879265,
-0.0418699086,
0.0130076762,
-0.0323958136,
-0.0748827085,
-0.0452018864,
0.0002593308,
-0.0250740349,
-0.0047894553,
-0.0641436577,
-0.005506828,
-0.0073033846,
0.0440408997,
-0.0006373441,
-0.0001041549,
2.863844719e-34,
0.0388828442,
0.044417318,
-0.02764103,
-0.0033337327,
0.0286041033,
-0.002542794,
0.0057438719,
-0.0174932871,
0.0030792954,
0.0034882959,
-0.0422799736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17927v1 | Cross-Cultural Transfer Learning for Chinese Offensive Language Detection | 2023-03-31T09:50:07 | 2023-03-31T09:50:07 | Li Zhou, Laura Cabello, Yong Cao, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting offensive language is a challenging task. Generalizing across
different cultures and languages becomes even more challenging: besides
lexical, syntactic and semantic differences, pragmatic aspects such as cultural
norms and sensitivities, which are particularly relevant in this context, vary
greatly. In this paper, we target Chinese offensive language detection and aim
to investigate the impact of transfer learning using offensive language
detection data from different cultural backgrounds, specifically Korean and
English. We find that culture-specific biases in what is considered offensive
negatively impact the transferability of language models (LMs) and that LMs
trained on diverse cultural data are sensitive to different features in Chinese
offensive language detection. In a few-shot learning scenario, however, our
study shows promising prospects for non-English offensive language detection
with limited resources. Our findings highlight the importance of cross-cultural
transfer learning in improving offensive language detection and promoting
inclusive digital spaces. | [
0.0574813671,
0.0468004793,
-0.034891706,
0.0320947133,
-0.0005489939,
0.0515709892,
0.0673939735,
0.0179554075,
0.0213302635,
-0.0499116965,
-0.0702792406,
-0.0350817479,
-0.0112392781,
0.0101423794,
-0.0125687681,
-0.0404661745,
0.027290402,
0.0546760596,
0.0450329036,
-0.0231086705,
0.0396749303,
0.0183460396,
0.0312173497,
0.0280993469,
-0.0281810984,
0.006459842,
0.0490157716,
0.0171530079,
0.0326557755,
0.0046244604,
0.064224124,
0.0237712096,
-0.0027219108,
0.0329357721,
0.0000017276,
-0.0339717567,
-0.0111696525,
-0.0203552246,
0.0359841213,
-0.016081173,
0.1113213748,
-0.0334310643,
-0.0579613708,
0.0112515008,
-0.0197559949,
-0.0026765044,
0.085048236,
0.063593924,
0.0518160723,
0.0558099113,
-0.0068875127,
0.0050101061,
-0.0613646992,
0.0122847939,
-0.0082502542,
-0.0226668287,
0.0458906405,
0.0027803574,
-0.064911522,
-0.0173896085,
-0.0660059825,
-0.0165435113,
-0.0199523829,
0.017763447,
-0.0367018469,
-0.0275794193,
-0.0304902382,
0.0001763327,
0.0237868596,
0.0842093676,
-0.0463749282,
0.0025913229,
-0.024129916,
-0.0168997347,
-0.0139240241,
-0.0438922755,
-0.0306780152,
0.0032649497,
-0.0058726761,
0.053797435,
-0.0267866347,
-0.017493261,
0.0307512153,
0.074070707,
0.0313704573,
0.0134457098,
-0.0131807737,
-0.0256191101,
0.0005962279,
0.0050506266,
0.0215933565,
0.0096953623,
0.0478420258,
-0.0032860362,
-0.0106939422,
0.0194370169,
-0.0315092616,
-0.0288073756,
0.0068950006,
-0.044637125,
0.0237160362,
0.0432181284,
-0.0685295612,
0.0127116134,
-0.016226029,
0.0468480028,
-0.0038397142,
0.049340371,
-0.0380910672,
-0.0356707945,
-0.0335003212,
0.0203370173,
0.0280036014,
-0.0157207996,
0.0338902548,
0.0178610571,
-0.0473343208,
-0.022297062,
-0.0564149171,
-0.0513495877,
-0.020204084,
-0.0143792136,
-0.0428492762,
-0.0073272469,
0.0033311085,
0.0183265489,
-0.0302361455,
0.0313967355,
-0.0488388389,
-0.073015593,
0.011169116,
0.0061493139,
-0.0198462736,
-0.0270490553,
0.0339141935,
0.0200978834,
-0.0072452622,
0.0059529273,
-0.0407595299,
0.0342911072,
-0.0287543815,
-0.0261676125,
0.0299797654,
-0.0544976853,
0.0018844538,
-0.0211670622,
0.0083434246,
-0.0892577618,
0.0008334172,
0.0133494558,
-0.0785915405,
0.0459910519,
0.0016116267,
-0.0057774857,
0.0309390742,
0.0153874578,
-0.0400382206,
0.0653389096,
0.0210072435,
0.0136037255,
0.0765274912,
-0.0167319123,
-0.0253229979,
0.0418168306,
0.0167027097,
0.0252828449,
-0.0883951187,
-0.0137414886,
-0.0138690118,
-0.0559825711,
0.0469465405,
0.0244473796,
0.0236304086,
-0.025652308,
0.0192739554,
0.047054939,
-0.0306054391,
0.0314981118,
0.0261323527,
0.0408273973,
-0.0647825226,
-0.006490902,
-0.0563270748,
-0.0000328024,
0.0048750388,
-0.0532390475,
-0.0041090772,
0.0871219262,
-0.0350396596,
-0.0318323188,
-0.0102980873,
-0.0229193382,
0.068382591,
-0.0225238521,
0.0506080464,
0.0287003275,
0.0095773777,
0.0044030417,
0.0685960352,
-0.0457870327,
0.0073537375,
-0.0399803855,
0.0347444229,
0.0685361996,
-0.0225505251,
0.0011552688,
0.0143926954,
-0.0501633659,
0.0392190404,
0.0353347547,
0.032858748,
-0.0083945571,
0.0237783585,
-0.0384025797,
-0.0446104482,
0.0446124785,
0.0162584055,
0.0328944363,
0.0514649823,
0.0479229875,
0.0242949966,
0.0314635187,
-0.045883961,
0.0164894816,
-0.0185889043,
-0.0284369774,
0.0151872346,
0.0110956598,
0.0238052718,
-0.0005989473,
-0.0337270238,
-0.0626873374,
-0.0281284451,
-0.0195357073,
-0.0296296775,
0.0335651934,
-0.0379373245,
-0.0169603676,
0.0185296126,
-0.0188272875,
-0.0004736695,
0.047168728,
-0.041293826,
0.0138527229,
0.0498326384,
0.02960122,
-0.0292198155,
-0.045808509,
-0.0254799332,
-0.0659030899,
0.0733449534,
0.0287242197,
0.028488135,
-0.005286206,
-0.0051465351,
0.0050324011,
-0.0289830994,
0.0255236216,
0.0091918083,
-0.0551683046,
0.0140536753,
-0.0445725694,
0.0116607016,
0.0120454105,
0.0456608497,
-0.017683601,
0.0307543371,
-0.0298031513,
-0.0060841613,
-0.0236852858,
-0.0300804414,
-0.0053445864,
-0.0085873073,
-0.0323134772,
-0.0245360658,
-0.0401768275,
-0.0150856012,
0.0269764662,
0.0533187017,
0.0009587094,
-0.0787575543,
-0.0066386051,
-0.0005474662,
-0.027253639,
0.0113345832,
0.0023294273,
-0.0342376195,
-0.0517116711,
0.0227122232,
-0.0377472714,
-0.0191020425,
-0.0022823594,
-0.0007098169,
-0.0819467083,
-0.0004968485,
0.0253044944,
-0.0313920639,
0.0905867293,
0.0323100612,
0.048750639,
0.0426902957,
-0.028161861,
-0.02540523,
0.0102218064,
0.0109111201,
0.0131266387,
0.0010109665,
-0.0743301958,
-0.0315484814,
0.0535868742,
0.022996692,
-0.0055262437,
-0.0657705292,
0.0026547189,
-0.0506665632,
-0.0511977412,
-0.0403328203,
-0.0273999125,
-0.0356195495,
0.0032860532,
-0.0079021687,
-0.0663722605,
0.0583539009,
0.0236721262,
0.0210920777,
-0.008296892,
-0.0068955882,
-0.0035270692,
0.0338314846,
-0.0109785777,
0.0587842688,
-0.0134607777,
-0.0238536112,
-0.0003951087,
-0.0196733512,
0.0360860229,
-0.038646508,
-0.0127353752,
-0.016013857,
-0.0347731225,
-0.0031552385,
-0.0234296229,
-0.0426043011,
-0.0080625555,
-0.0198591687,
0.0001616212,
-0.0181571431,
0.0079463748,
0.0116327358,
0.0425675996,
0.0199672673,
-0.0433783717,
0.0084472224,
0.0277895536,
0.03902971,
-0.0633430183,
0.0399601832,
0.0103803361,
-0.0119959423,
0.022476064,
0.0075257579,
0.0541006848,
0.0176642649,
0.0078813825,
0.0377994962,
0.0487129167,
0.03862435,
0.0399883091,
-0.0182994399,
-0.0159019325,
0.0518914945,
0.0027943775,
0.0018331815,
0.0474959016,
-0.0023819022,
-0.0033870707,
-0.0000957354,
-0.0123850573,
-0.034284547,
0.0163141973,
0.0120464601,
-0.0634286255,
-0.0237397552,
-0.0044218036,
0.0065632397,
-0.0696691275,
-0.0284140632,
-0.0306965541,
-0.0910164565,
0.0020914769,
0.0197871253,
-0.0712521225,
-0.0471190698,
0.0044707446,
0.0443491936,
-0.0176702347,
0.04787191,
-0.0512891971,
0.0162813514,
-0.0435471795,
0.004407627,
-0.0325222351,
-0.0353274643,
0.0468325838,
-0.012909689,
0.0403850339,
0.0251522083,
0.0562060699,
-0.0276429541,
-0.0090698395,
0.0310740899,
-0.0123155629,
-0.0218343977,
-0.0449996181,
0.0363940001,
0.0046425327,
-0.037708886,
0.0134156961,
0.0196337514,
-0.0019174999,
-0.0103263883,
0.0145063354,
0.0412915275,
0.0732183903,
-0.021271877,
-0.0385572314,
0.0338629,
0.0226654522,
0.0886545554,
-0.0005005291,
-0.0820147321,
0.0121020125,
-0.0349348336,
-0.0661325306,
0.0072663585,
-0.0480232984,
0.0168855693,
-0.0777847022,
-0.0549983606,
-0.0599908121,
-0.0095102768,
-0.012972706,
0.0178020727,
0.0277069397,
-0.037634857,
-0.0437823497,
0.0088500082,
0.0081931204,
-0.0196769554,
-0.0213880371,
0.0363330059,
-0.0071397875,
0.0098764962,
-0.0230689626,
-0.0306968205,
-0.0135870157,
-0.0192268863,
-0.0145156933,
-0.0446901917,
0.0552772768,
0.0617616437,
0.0042260853,
0.0196479633,
-0.0148864612,
-0.0043905112,
0.0312030688,
0.0536772646,
-0.0065583247,
-0.0276759975,
0.0880403072,
-0.0305490717,
-0.0072227702,
0.0280358177,
-0.0403693281,
0.0648257509,
0.0724362135,
-0.0242535528,
-0.0483156554,
-0.0417289846,
-0.0154880211,
0.0056140511,
0.0092921536,
0.0023765948,
-0.0861712322,
-0.0325882658,
-0.015856551,
0.0231964067,
-0.0233705807,
-0.0281999204,
-0.0195430908,
0.05032368,
-0.0154551025,
-0.0468915254,
-0.0039499355,
-0.0200882144,
0.0088106263,
-0.0358489566,
0.0025149968,
0.0322478004,
0.0657740086,
-0.0047231242,
0.0337027572,
-0.0484128855,
0.0124950465,
0.0315077826,
-0.0179836005,
-0.0159580819,
0.0689451918,
0.0130358692,
0.0304349922,
0.0250590052,
-0.016934365,
0.024402352,
0.0129511924,
-0.0316850021,
-0.0227282085,
0.0149017656,
-0.0615323,
0.0634237006,
-0.013392576,
-0.005701148,
-0.039945703,
0.0084908959,
-0.0091604879,
-0.0938576907,
0.0436229371,
0.0004797476,
-0.0184174329,
0.0177991632,
0.0605939478,
-0.0575119965,
0.0295558143,
0.0333491899,
-0.0467895009,
-0.0051496997,
0.0207794141,
0.0775803253,
0.012899654,
0.0054808548,
0.0661955997,
-0.0359193534,
-0.050568305,
-0.023485668,
-0.0824428499,
0.036079485,
-0.0062165922,
0.0113766538,
0.0844669417,
-0.0154634668,
-0.0004325421,
-0.0173876099,
-0.015454446,
-0.0079123797,
-0.0070891716,
0.0053646239,
-5.626973541e-33,
-0.0147902966,
-0.0120330155,
-0.0186385103,
0.0339841172,
0.0083935047,
-0.059194494,
0.0019244635,
0.0059095919,
-0.0481904298,
0.015072871,
0.0034713463,
0.0150341243,
0.0118722608,
0.0096898545,
0.0036350901,
-0.0316021256,
0.0206374992,
0.0130803389,
-0.0239667147,
0.0168622714,
0.0723056793,
0.0310903694,
0.0616604351,
-0.0618573986,
0.0268131737,
0.0172998831,
-0.0182547513,
0.0191732161,
0.0425439291,
0.0555260703,
-0.0172887351,
0.0925618708,
0.0524634868,
-0.0171927176,
-0.0066902335,
0.0390834883,
-0.0619012229,
-0.013605644,
-0.0058623482,
0.0423892252,
0.0746561885,
-0.0407814942,
0.0210595485,
-0.0322667658,
-0.0101125119,
-0.0324435495,
0.0447744466,
-0.0680739209,
0.0123857623,
-0.0121233873,
-0.0888723508,
0.0314401612,
-0.0088420538,
-0.002846827,
-0.0148899909,
0.0368724987,
0.0043654051,
0.0191340428,
-0.0403946489,
0.0128260367,
-0.0098317973,
-0.0156918988,
0.0252131373,
-0.0023709829,
0.013759085,
0.0512574352,
0.0193141773,
0.0121438662,
0.0245659705,
-0.0058040698,
0.0540230609,
0.0435864814,
-0.0070211641,
0.0825517625,
0.0570645742,
-0.0908709243,
-0.0368136242,
-0.0098100267,
0.0546705239,
0.0252993908,
0.0137547096,
-0.002514753,
-0.0336340405,
-0.0408558026,
0.0296161026,
-0.0334903337,
-0.0014852753,
-0.0655506849,
0.033235319,
-0.0157371853,
-0.0357124135,
-0.0386183374,
0.0372521169,
-0.0411259085,
-0.0220112149,
0.0342447758,
-0.0218045525,
-0.0467263982,
0.0208538976,
0.0361225307,
-0.0792414993,
-0.0326043777,
-0.0170708038,
-0.0498147346,
0.0088263517,
0.0252104551,
0.0875574872,
0.0453661643,
-0.0726393834,
0.0130158551,
-0.0072470922,
0.0135781839,
0.0093641169,
0.0589196011,
0.0100618275,
0.0336676575,
-0.021332955,
0.0030066022,
0.0371564701,
-0.0105972085,
-0.0217216965,
-0.0497223996,
-0.0588167943,
0.0078327553,
-0.0530966669,
-0.0135891708,
-0.0135435434,
0.0038622443,
0.0211583432,
-0.0552412942,
-0.0192121901,
-0.001073989,
2.454e-7,
0.0047899298,
-0.015063026,
-0.0095775519,
0.01463723,
0.0039251191,
0.0302046072,
-0.0180201288,
0.0468350165,
0.0441467054,
0.0491512902,
-0.0127466638,
0.0383903384,
0.0572807826,
0.0655841529,
-0.0314144418,
0.0188507307,
-0.0585378073,
0.0495995656,
-0.0069327885,
0.0167469718,
-0.0015875957,
0.0577626601,
0.0420270897,
-0.0452316888,
-0.0213739518,
-0.0574497059,
0.0189084932,
-0.0758982003,
0.0446114019,
-0.0265195835,
0.0437559746,
0.002458646,
0.0026709558,
-0.0019297984,
0.0012288091,
0.0161740649,
0.0417690761,
0.0581800565,
0.0379244164,
0.0325029492,
-0.0089440122,
-0.0115542728,
0.0023015358,
-0.0358328074,
0.0632773414,
-0.0007485798,
-0.0120711373,
-0.0200546384,
0.0177942812,
-0.0270798989,
0.0555474833,
-0.0415681973,
-0.0055238293,
-0.0099810921,
0.0656546727,
0.0155566912,
-0.025884144,
-0.0379345194,
-0.002210408,
-0.0011267436,
-0.0208572093,
-0.038659811,
0.0248522926,
-0.0109134465,
0.001221532,
0.029755393,
0.0661032349,
1.426011253e-34,
0.0015748424,
-0.040258307,
-0.0005794184,
-0.0204449873,
0.0059943749,
0.0124540059,
0.0271468535,
0.0024730675,
0.0236437488,
-0.0064827451,
0.0036019222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17910v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17910v2 | Selective Knowledge Distillation for Non-Autoregressive Neural Machine Translation | 2023-03-31T09:16:13 | 2023-08-04T16:19:24 | Min Liu, Yu Bao, Chengqi Zhao, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Benefiting from the sequence-level knowledge distillation, the
Non-Autoregressive Transformer (NAT) achieves great success in neural machine
translation tasks. However, existing knowledge distillation has side effects,
such as propagating errors from the teacher to NAT students, which may limit
further improvements of NAT models and are rarely discussed in existing
research. In this paper, we introduce selective knowledge distillation by
introducing an NAT evaluator to select NAT-friendly targets that are of high
quality and easy to learn. In addition, we introduce a simple yet effective
progressive distillation method to boost NAT performance. Experiment results on
multiple WMT language directions and several representative NAT models show
that our approach can realize a flexible trade-off between the quality and
complexity of training data for NAT models, achieving strong performances.
Further analysis shows that distilling only 5% of the raw translations can help
an NAT outperform its counterpart trained on raw data by about 2.4 BLEU. | [
-0.0168774035,
0.0681149065,
0.0030895527,
0.0159699619,
-0.01863092,
0.015018574,
0.0093376962,
-0.0074376068,
-0.0602460764,
0.0103974054,
-0.0318330191,
-0.0320144892,
0.040112026,
0.0258417092,
0.0289110616,
-0.0112087978,
-0.0005182319,
-0.0334735289,
-0.036501918,
0.0015723587,
-0.0288574956,
-0.0157371722,
-0.0036270947,
0.0288359374,
0.0000794635,
-0.0182931516,
0.0035098693,
0.0120222671,
0.0236963537,
-0.0196319725,
0.0328875892,
0.0503126681,
0.0056643956,
0.0294210371,
0.0000023319,
0.0117570665,
-0.0110789826,
-0.0088411486,
-0.0175697245,
-0.0060237991,
-0.0310505666,
-0.0406153873,
0.0062392186,
0.0371877551,
-0.0364193693,
-0.0275432095,
0.0239533,
0.0145709626,
0.0983877629,
0.0844912753,
0.0069533652,
-0.0523090027,
0.0061005359,
-0.0631202087,
-0.0039939196,
-0.0156701859,
-0.026962094,
-0.0325013511,
-0.0769166797,
0.0124074835,
-0.0445193164,
0.0815978199,
0.0199455265,
-0.0111408457,
-0.0024680591,
0.0128909452,
-0.0378071293,
-0.0430850536,
-0.0124727981,
0.074952729,
-0.0522258095,
0.0184010211,
0.0159577969,
-0.0127831455,
-0.0055774916,
-0.0440410748,
-0.040065553,
0.0269680545,
0.0214147158,
0.0290715117,
-0.0220403299,
0.0584484525,
0.0279386081,
-0.036152903,
-0.0576128215,
-0.0177550819,
0.0042467145,
-0.018440444,
-0.0126882847,
0.0164690632,
0.0055879676,
0.0008633419,
0.0334941931,
0.0073801149,
0.0349111222,
0.0256441105,
-0.0215761475,
-0.0029627152,
-0.0291809253,
-0.0006852036,
0.0340327844,
0.0674516931,
0.0005645106,
0.0044704229,
-0.023468785,
0.079681769,
0.0024040162,
-0.0046489039,
-0.0397354439,
-0.0125746876,
-0.0602824502,
0.0187354833,
0.0046954267,
0.0175926834,
-0.0361626707,
0.0042361934,
-0.0212999266,
-0.0256157666,
-0.0163075533,
-0.0167562682,
0.0616284721,
-0.0152711123,
-0.0713722855,
0.0006181175,
-0.0152348997,
0.1253886074,
0.0090949219,
-0.0529421382,
0.0193777699,
-0.0668139011,
-0.0451904833,
0.0098430328,
0.0006670366,
-0.0107216258,
-0.0130871292,
0.0689124838,
-0.0421198346,
-0.0357611664,
-0.0135806855,
-0.0098775392,
-0.0342537463,
-0.0559904501,
0.054687269,
-0.0504881814,
0.0443678163,
0.0077051353,
0.0045558973,
-0.047497306,
0.008668079,
-0.0093237869,
0.0006479576,
0.0162178632,
0.0307862926,
-0.0235623196,
0.0271076486,
0.0241349991,
-0.0276184473,
0.0505439565,
0.0299925935,
0.0092811882,
-0.0414612889,
-0.0070980298,
-0.0142644066,
0.0225034133,
0.047128357,
0.0102914833,
-0.0103859212,
-0.0374646075,
0.0056506726,
0.0124477437,
0.0427682623,
0.0625378639,
-0.0299878884,
0.0137901008,
0.0786277801,
-0.0030479664,
0.0672681183,
0.0524853095,
0.0208626203,
0.0181008764,
-0.017706288,
0.0169067364,
-0.0186587442,
0.0542663522,
-0.0126383044,
-0.0050749229,
0.0147821531,
0.0768856108,
-0.0273405612,
-0.0763794705,
0.031381119,
-0.0182048064,
0.0247997791,
-0.0291740876,
0.0250499547,
0.043121513,
-0.0242715441,
0.0767020807,
-0.0021748436,
-0.0437193923,
0.0400491841,
-0.0430643111,
-0.0492538251,
0.0095466441,
0.0333300643,
0.0050632101,
-0.0385673791,
-0.0421475284,
-0.0386050828,
0.0405876599,
0.0226179082,
0.0398512073,
0.0297063552,
-0.0554830059,
-0.0440174229,
-0.0047933059,
0.0181619413,
0.003857726,
-0.0189953465,
0.0576134734,
0.0731868669,
-0.0210331902,
-0.0527498983,
0.0310351569,
-0.0250612311,
-0.0582815818,
0.0217576958,
0.0195669681,
0.0163385626,
0.0156149715,
0.0020333116,
-0.003929385,
-0.0052183596,
-0.0575589538,
-0.033811897,
0.000468759,
-0.1145538464,
-0.1034319848,
0.0197740123,
-0.0603142343,
0.0094315493,
0.036063239,
-0.0416752063,
-0.0904694647,
-0.0037496584,
-0.0278390646,
0.0033216346,
-0.0494347066,
0.0298920497,
0.0516530536,
0.0107308179,
-0.0072094789,
0.0240582842,
-0.0404187329,
-0.0247215219,
-0.0057616825,
-0.0589480698,
-0.0095919035,
0.0327862352,
-0.0464253873,
0.0190579258,
0.0183370803,
0.0417956933,
0.0228429213,
0.016783366,
-0.0069161421,
-0.0556073561,
0.009742639,
0.0215126108,
-0.0552936494,
0.0266315416,
0.0142108891,
0.0621998981,
0.0275853164,
-0.0090357363,
-0.0540477261,
0.0028797379,
-0.0104349591,
-0.0256657023,
0.0047823046,
0.0166959055,
0.0367536545,
0.0118382405,
-0.022542676,
0.0175911002,
0.0513621345,
-0.041488491,
0.0204458237,
-0.0607674457,
-0.0009543867,
-0.020968141,
0.0066172821,
-0.0127877705,
-0.0382530913,
0.0151559683,
-0.0184501503,
0.0313224122,
-0.0074270121,
-0.0053547309,
-0.0104345856,
0.0278517939,
-0.0039360584,
-0.0809570253,
0.0291364733,
-0.0266610291,
0.0009617407,
0.019178139,
-0.0281235017,
0.0024691047,
0.0948503092,
-0.0048580277,
-0.0237745326,
-0.059634205,
-0.0101313572,
0.0106942207,
-0.0034444409,
-0.0183763541,
0.0202117916,
-0.0061862674,
-0.0294193141,
-0.0055775363,
-0.0285277124,
0.0756467283,
-0.0538778193,
-0.0079574371,
-0.0473072492,
-0.0114814062,
-0.0028156838,
0.0121518178,
-0.0277371537,
0.0029955541,
0.0028355098,
-0.0200653579,
-0.0235572271,
0.0130907642,
-0.005398497,
-0.0120527372,
0.0896262228,
-0.0509497561,
-0.0213342737,
-0.0168607477,
0.0023132036,
-0.0331062004,
-0.0063711903,
0.0326069519,
0.001715562,
0.033710897,
-0.0065207356,
-0.0183231346,
0.0254590511,
0.0145957107,
0.097415328,
-0.0139096184,
-0.0005284623,
-0.027231887,
0.0229419675,
0.0003580398,
0.025252426,
-0.0107234586,
-0.0307382196,
0.0161016174,
0.0094505493,
0.0062163966,
-0.0338368751,
-0.0398970991,
0.0067678685,
0.0131120747,
0.0009385394,
-0.02403198,
0.0055049281,
0.0303320214,
-0.07148619,
0.0016771927,
0.0822153762,
0.0002177324,
-0.0134309353,
0.0032080039,
0.0279408097,
0.0433654673,
0.0001389818,
0.0190685205,
-0.0531184748,
-0.0272404514,
-0.0199417546,
0.0485807955,
0.0645443574,
-0.0103132902,
-0.012382661,
-0.0589862503,
-0.0018734941,
0.0518787242,
-0.0274420902,
-0.0655498654,
0.0061878185,
-0.0530195795,
-0.0386606343,
0.0355405137,
0.0027182817,
-0.0116196731,
0.0020105124,
0.0118940333,
-0.030444568,
-0.0838519335,
-0.0101313107,
-0.0374319591,
0.0176971238,
0.0626293421,
0.009656148,
0.010253164,
-0.0662703961,
-0.0075119669,
-0.039812427,
0.0429399572,
-0.0000209734,
0.0059556975,
0.0218078364,
-0.0412949324,
0.0208418146,
0.0054902965,
-0.0177012607,
0.04238341,
0.0052057225,
0.0711376667,
-0.0367528163,
-0.0473948717,
0.0184801295,
-0.0467345119,
0.0149456412,
0.0436430983,
0.0353773162,
-0.0215327628,
-0.0074819503,
-0.0084650563,
0.0105144996,
-0.0266143624,
-0.0338408537,
0.0218556654,
-0.0033015998,
-0.0569975972,
-0.0909843221,
-0.0414647684,
0.0058889012,
0.0550000109,
-0.0090104183,
-0.0283023063,
0.0651424006,
0.0048563816,
-0.0226913244,
0.0363897644,
-0.0269331429,
-0.0236756522,
-0.0154660121,
-0.0045245239,
0.0231114794,
0.0064051999,
-0.004072526,
0.0344851725,
-0.1052030846,
-0.0702292994,
-0.0001787347,
0.0739916563,
0.019900281,
0.0675782636,
-0.0036476045,
0.0102328677,
0.0941028818,
0.0261195209,
-0.0184428934,
-0.0257616602,
0.0376920179,
-0.0180860721,
-0.0152575728,
0.0118013732,
-0.0167696755,
0.0000234606,
0.0042220103,
0.0836920738,
-0.0188898072,
0.0150351068,
0.0154085895,
-0.0032864928,
0.0630875602,
-0.0055824621,
0.0043346882,
-0.018376166,
0.0228138436,
0.0290892627,
0.0190739781,
-0.0724844038,
0.0085895797,
0.0417926237,
0.009163321,
0.004197143,
0.0519856736,
0.0035927624,
-0.0303451288,
-0.0270601138,
0.0073066927,
-0.015148961,
-0.003878271,
0.0224977843,
0.0037732827,
-0.0229684841,
0.0117928786,
0.0476962514,
0.0020408903,
-0.0317447558,
0.0397252887,
0.0014447959,
0.0726997554,
-0.0060386341,
0.0340421088,
-0.0449902527,
-0.0186430495,
-0.0168350153,
-0.0008314283,
0.0475903563,
0.0292564332,
0.0758606493,
-0.0093326205,
0.0227043107,
0.0107269194,
0.0131187569,
-0.0141102867,
0.022329377,
0.0071350452,
0.0109349098,
0.0185440835,
-0.0079575181,
0.084602274,
-0.0425356813,
0.0084401108,
-0.0070269629,
0.0569964647,
-0.0535641313,
-0.0427370965,
0.0070061847,
-0.0438102856,
-0.0059674033,
-0.0194594003,
-0.0001622424,
-0.0465250798,
-0.0063861744,
-0.0139359161,
-0.0056371395,
-0.0386771746,
0.0333066732,
0.0348998085,
-0.0478710346,
-0.0166948289,
-0.0297235716,
-0.017553689,
0.0395434909,
-0.0118609369,
0.0027190773,
-7.325850506e-33,
-0.0126863895,
0.0274746493,
0.0221190322,
-0.02498243,
-0.0402742662,
0.0002865926,
-0.0075763655,
-0.0333543606,
0.0106642153,
-0.006566958,
-0.0128205139,
0.039752271,
0.0289403163,
0.0199523959,
0.0133954473,
0.0019109616,
0.1123385504,
0.0055785896,
-0.0386263877,
0.0534597561,
0.0127203409,
0.0636883155,
0.0730952471,
-0.049818445,
0.0148397582,
-0.0095657716,
0.0200320855,
-0.0014613528,
0.0135159567,
-0.0250260625,
0.0000080573,
0.0267942566,
0.0049826591,
-0.0827655196,
-0.0688556135,
-0.0437672734,
-0.0919461474,
-0.0389395319,
-0.0225177519,
0.0210929252,
-0.015163091,
-0.0257718768,
0.1156974211,
-0.0160195008,
-0.000858264,
-0.0244983174,
-0.0040649851,
-0.0012005081,
-0.0383884571,
-0.0283381417,
-0.0299299564,
0.0074919378,
-0.010837811,
-0.0443016179,
0.0118903117,
0.0234592706,
-0.0295185745,
-0.0357274674,
-0.1403832734,
0.0128210699,
0.0518497825,
0.0867853463,
0.079974696,
0.0273187663,
-0.0126691135,
-0.0016052574,
0.0168219041,
0.0202427097,
0.0253300518,
-0.0023278322,
0.0659613386,
0.0148418965,
0.0498965085,
-0.0188551713,
0.0837147757,
-0.0211571697,
-0.026097957,
0.0367654301,
-0.0266264547,
0.0434919633,
-0.0168688297,
-0.0141483098,
0.0086922254,
-0.0284986049,
-0.036665123,
-0.0337482765,
-0.0193800926,
0.0029357739,
0.0062493104,
0.0550742373,
-0.0226103812,
-0.0129873771,
0.0616725162,
-0.0220407173,
0.0387753285,
0.0424235351,
-0.0129222153,
-0.0110201119,
-0.0147455717,
0.0074530109,
-0.0178755783,
-0.0191621892,
0.0229565892,
0.0262056142,
0.0284097176,
-0.0032593431,
0.018761212,
0.0826822668,
-0.0368690602,
-0.0163761098,
-0.0558480099,
0.0325642638,
0.0128360912,
0.0038791664,
0.02525617,
-0.0305516589,
-0.0193586834,
0.020734828,
0.0100798141,
0.0029294172,
-0.0023306145,
0.0516327098,
0.0563193671,
0.049641151,
-0.0296530239,
0.006700784,
0.0036032267,
0.0242706519,
0.0364807434,
-0.0509524085,
-0.0232362431,
0.0310285725,
3.001e-7,
0.0334751345,
0.0444629267,
-0.0008877824,
0.0000440797,
-0.0041458923,
0.0233117789,
-0.0591156334,
0.0009141474,
0.0040825796,
0.0018594869,
0.0405655652,
0.0106774839,
0.0914389491,
0.0466724299,
-0.1036924422,
-0.0215853024,
-0.0529814735,
0.0007550109,
-0.0241763089,
-0.0453006998,
0.0516472161,
0.0590641648,
-0.0402737111,
0.0051490464,
0.0134301726,
0.0037101344,
0.0394707397,
0.0373098142,
0.0295478329,
-0.0047222017,
0.0783971623,
0.0002601875,
-0.0253286399,
-0.021447368,
-0.0369782634,
0.0293927584,
-0.0023591975,
0.0740843266,
0.0138498265,
-0.0542191081,
0.0303722322,
0.0323005617,
-0.0092594754,
-0.0255057272,
0.0276333969,
-0.0904396847,
0.025506733,
0.0597180799,
-0.0381450541,
-0.006975967,
0.0273597371,
-0.0224352498,
-0.005864731,
0.029003188,
0.0242589097,
-0.010750128,
-0.0037408289,
-0.0555845425,
-0.0215174928,
-0.007829437,
-0.0320655294,
-0.0347051658,
-0.0436010174,
-0.0391729511,
0.0131382253,
0.0286446046,
-0.0080430759,
2.582666929e-34,
0.0186531805,
-0.0233288966,
0.0328766964,
-0.0106717329,
-0.0059738522,
0.0007272487,
-0.0598883964,
-0.0036424408,
-0.0291407146,
-0.0541482717,
-0.0532504357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17876v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17876v3 | WebQAmGaze: A Multilingual Webcam Eye-Tracking-While-Reading Dataset | 2023-03-31T08:18:30 | 2024-03-15T12:01:25 | Tiago Ribeiro, Stephanie Brandl, Anders Søgaard, Nora Hollenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present WebQAmGaze, a multilingual low-cost eye-tracking-while-reading
dataset, designed as the first webcam-based eye-tracking corpus of reading to
support the development of explainable computational language processing
models. WebQAmGaze includes webcam eye-tracking data from 600 participants of a
wide age range naturally reading English, German, Spanish, and Turkish texts.
Each participant performs two reading tasks composed of five texts each, a
normal reading and an information-seeking task, followed by a comprehension
question. We compare the collected webcam data to high-quality eye-tracking
recordings. The results show a moderate to strong correlation between the eye
movement measures obtained with the webcam compared to those obtained with a
commercial eye-tracking device. When validating the data, we find that higher
fixation duration on relevant text spans accurately indicates correctness when
answering the corresponding questions. This dataset advances webcam-based
reading studies and opens avenues to low-cost and diverse data collection.
WebQAmGaze is beneficial to learn about the cognitive processes behind
question-answering and to apply these insights to computational models of
language understanding. | [
0.0204789881,
0.022364568,
-0.0406176113,
0.0122079831,
0.0068722414,
0.0199978538,
0.0571550913,
0.0151461689,
0.0412771553,
-0.0180899147,
-0.0229716152,
-0.0381558165,
0.0683867633,
0.03898656,
0.0443860851,
-0.0371397287,
0.0136788562,
-0.0418526009,
0.0052277213,
0.0384775549,
0.0701434463,
0.0220675599,
-0.0232007764,
0.0295019578,
0.0043821945,
-0.0451813564,
-0.0150081841,
-0.0393128581,
0.0233527981,
0.021300124,
0.0217616446,
0.0488631092,
-0.0140482532,
-0.0241396334,
0.0000019644,
-0.0224989895,
-0.017055802,
-0.035255909,
-0.000379695,
0.0366483219,
0.0387345068,
-0.0369404927,
0.008424459,
0.0197216123,
-0.0194592383,
-0.0013574361,
0.0526536107,
-0.0321868435,
0.0064233295,
0.0081772534,
-0.0158273447,
0.0196720045,
0.0457524247,
0.0265026484,
0.0320882648,
-0.0468787439,
-0.019449681,
0.0133225201,
-0.0193047635,
0.008635154,
-0.053409297,
0.0474050827,
-0.0245895032,
-0.0077774273,
0.0316303298,
0.0310250036,
-0.034078978,
-0.093520537,
-0.0137330946,
0.0676613674,
0.0394015573,
-0.0677535385,
0.0087158456,
0.0315901525,
-0.0161513891,
0.0652384087,
-0.0711685866,
0.0533058532,
-0.032219138,
-0.0016372437,
0.004894204,
-0.0123224482,
-0.0005725772,
-0.0078319926,
0.0185468327,
-0.0158830192,
0.0074663344,
-0.0090622725,
-0.0359134004,
0.0216107126,
-0.007322289,
-0.0127358064,
0.069974497,
0.0289042201,
0.0638513491,
0.027139904,
-0.0260280482,
-0.0742531791,
-0.0196954794,
0.0006275974,
0.0134495022,
0.0453192145,
0.0079753269,
0.0500594899,
-0.0180503018,
0.060590189,
-0.0134075666,
-0.0405506901,
-0.0194023214,
-0.0055920337,
0.0087531442,
-0.0348376371,
0.0043489961,
-0.0444765091,
-0.0179235302,
-0.0483684056,
-0.0010490331,
0.033980459,
0.0376094878,
-0.021872865,
-0.0455822647,
0.0374882706,
-0.0165067501,
0.0047468841,
-0.0248026177,
0.0509566106,
-0.0415498987,
0.0454162285,
-0.0139404777,
-0.070620209,
0.0144723346,
0.0171495341,
0.0306085497,
0.0139548117,
0.0032599254,
0.0135851875,
-0.0319281891,
-0.0532507859,
-0.0026787107,
0.0074317642,
-0.0154050225,
-0.0083506117,
0.0125448257,
-0.0429900549,
0.0408125632,
0.0375183336,
0.0006270914,
-0.0134719042,
-0.0150483092,
0.0584877059,
-0.026285572,
0.0557898469,
-0.0496074334,
0.0217014756,
0.0065016281,
0.0087180911,
0.0110762333,
0.0452168137,
0.0398888998,
-0.0373608656,
0.0538609549,
-0.0230146218,
0.0280620717,
0.0419324264,
-0.0274449587,
-0.0155039234,
-0.0121191991,
-0.0129048601,
0.0191070233,
0.0092841964,
0.0111506758,
-0.0038449657,
-0.0152051244,
-0.0068848105,
0.0935617089,
0.1005271226,
-0.0138002466,
-0.0233735479,
-0.063402541,
-0.0186864994,
0.028038688,
-0.0066980477,
-0.0050925175,
0.0403360203,
-0.0123058902,
0.0210855026,
-0.0298375431,
-0.0144771449,
-0.0063460558,
-0.0465395935,
-0.0265420154,
0.0188333951,
-0.0022942745,
0.035851907,
0.054030221,
-0.0335362963,
-0.0256583802,
0.0191210918,
-0.0131701948,
-0.0883251876,
-0.0020757096,
-0.023899816,
0.0761127621,
0.0580608882,
0.0197694208,
-0.0181271993,
-0.0616906919,
0.0037774325,
0.0552507006,
0.0364868194,
-0.0390721858,
0.0045560854,
0.0428343527,
-0.0593838319,
0.0305265468,
0.0279679261,
-0.0027229863,
-0.0404325686,
-0.0305104479,
0.0223309342,
-0.0106785148,
-0.027229473,
-0.0195065532,
0.0306283329,
-0.0309506599,
-0.0005630628,
-0.0620601252,
0.0046590921,
-0.0197553877,
0.0113407159,
-0.0044325129,
-0.0099940635,
0.0251917411,
-0.0044674086,
0.1140185148,
0.0258717556,
0.0126903001,
-0.0087278234,
0.0349963158,
-0.1123353988,
-0.0153936008,
0.0229574703,
0.0481674634,
-0.0450896062,
-0.0076423129,
-0.0732239783,
0.0093582384,
-0.0187976249,
0.0377149917,
-0.0046998993,
0.0154353045,
-0.011517074,
0.0301192794,
-0.0257033352,
0.0143190287,
0.0269918088,
0.0044096373,
-0.0164154023,
0.0056483368,
0.032780163,
0.0085124793,
0.0038889104,
-0.012372572,
0.0208379086,
-0.0028287903,
-0.0712022185,
-0.0013158353,
-0.0758674964,
-0.0060590352,
0.0002046627,
0.0076265163,
0.0453963093,
-0.0092572197,
-0.0144332964,
-0.0182711743,
-0.0422788635,
0.0357909352,
-0.0310280398,
-0.0111657027,
0.0081047807,
-0.0425590314,
-0.0030972264,
-0.065111056,
-0.0384418704,
-0.0399687067,
0.0602515563,
0.0478795506,
-0.0009297284,
-0.0486141406,
-0.0084102731,
-0.0046085152,
-0.0010116845,
-0.0348239318,
-0.039186053,
0.0521807745,
-0.0032253512,
0.0187919792,
0.1136395782,
0.0073305541,
0.0102474904,
0.0104626864,
-0.0300688464,
-0.0262470562,
-0.0164924338,
0.0283545982,
0.0187641568,
-0.0135220857,
-0.0859065354,
-0.0161452405,
0.0437813066,
-0.0069076284,
0.0031784,
-0.0618286878,
0.0319254622,
-0.0031331587,
-0.0361709781,
-0.0476819277,
0.0038776402,
-0.0355866849,
0.0937559828,
-0.0316854157,
-0.0659285709,
0.031987384,
-0.0292328782,
-0.0241931099,
-0.0381602868,
0.0296137407,
0.014923064,
0.0547458865,
0.0016701083,
-0.0097188558,
-0.001228651,
-0.0122405961,
-0.0515895635,
0.0251418352,
0.0440655053,
-0.0090646632,
0.0978076383,
-0.0463703498,
-0.011315465,
0.0072315978,
0.0429177769,
-0.0302358493,
0.012183629,
-0.0618004203,
-0.0729054213,
-0.0037359542,
0.0065941038,
-0.0136939529,
0.0256768931,
0.0711597055,
0.0365521125,
0.0037646887,
0.0051028025,
-0.0205428693,
0.022935044,
0.0574439391,
-0.0137600023,
-0.0094586518,
-0.0495188907,
0.0155725032,
0.0724420324,
0.0481601059,
0.0026044876,
0.000625808,
0.0219941232,
0.0436859988,
-0.0083958274,
-0.003113773,
-0.0103814816,
0.0372319743,
-0.0701253936,
0.0155311134,
0.0799789727,
0.048000697,
-0.0463307723,
-0.0206260514,
-0.0141202891,
0.0106775519,
0.021414889,
0.0036702428,
-0.0456911735,
-0.0506112576,
0.0170411263,
0.041775614,
0.0017570064,
-0.0044257664,
-0.0115829762,
-0.0588345602,
-0.0066191182,
0.0079458002,
-0.0295173675,
-0.028069118,
-0.0486249886,
0.0187114105,
-0.0006662182,
-0.0415527895,
0.0309495293,
-0.0159774367,
0.0231315009,
0.0037647078,
-0.034828864,
0.0337261185,
0.0048976387,
-0.0160082337,
0.0014633567,
0.0141447755,
0.0348390378,
0.0162908211,
-0.0548068509,
0.0014881891,
-0.0889901519,
0.0001160317,
-0.0000724885,
0.0538860336,
-0.0175359193,
-0.026285328,
-0.0724945739,
0.0617712066,
-0.0424636193,
-0.0305210073,
0.0214809813,
0.057733424,
0.0236957371,
0.0037530749,
-0.0153171923,
-0.0015810962,
-0.0531943515,
0.0124146361,
0.0148906773,
-0.0567976385,
-0.0292246193,
0.0084852334,
0.0069368244,
-0.0276514385,
-0.019702781,
0.007374899,
0.0378289409,
-0.0466991439,
-0.0705259219,
-0.0568504035,
0.0755234882,
0.0112702493,
0.0220968798,
0.0381828919,
0.0707836822,
0.0193021614,
-0.0570209287,
0.0703607276,
0.0341003537,
0.0130194994,
-0.0473549701,
-0.0124696316,
-0.0091546103,
-0.0441446267,
0.0111394133,
0.0537244119,
-0.056944184,
-0.0483910292,
-0.0330895893,
0.0355697945,
0.0259540584,
0.0060657472,
-0.000231742,
-0.0375265516,
-0.0565509237,
-0.0373612307,
-0.0461588204,
0.0282295737,
-0.0137197152,
-0.0204376485,
-0.0050069951,
-0.0003705714,
0.0244798437,
-0.0347100608,
-0.0329124928,
-0.0230054911,
-0.0556460246,
-0.0417073667,
0.0173677877,
-0.006163334,
0.0110047264,
0.0051871482,
0.0123288296,
-0.0701226071,
-0.004889736,
-0.0001953283,
0.0340762176,
-0.0321166478,
-0.0031674842,
0.0114247883,
-0.0169816092,
-0.0091970302,
-0.0118860882,
-0.0367706716,
-0.058945071,
-0.0188086983,
0.0504322574,
-0.0139199663,
0.0097737815,
-0.0258780345,
0.0125809787,
0.001337546,
0.0162966717,
-0.0595846213,
0.0465802327,
0.0402978025,
0.0800876841,
0.0000637645,
-0.0441706628,
0.0248883665,
0.0047770455,
-0.0172963981,
0.0213437937,
0.0523078889,
0.0202513617,
0.0145786554,
-0.0449318178,
0.0687428787,
0.0026808437,
-0.0006148296,
-0.0433686189,
0.0602112487,
-0.0138125615,
-0.0108140716,
0.0125439949,
0.0183994938,
0.0038794247,
-0.006974516,
0.0750807896,
0.0079353889,
-0.0209431909,
0.0366170593,
-0.03464102,
-0.0266120005,
0.0352857374,
0.0211098865,
0.014198347,
-0.0318367332,
0.0498136207,
-0.0274422523,
-0.0696151555,
0.0010345603,
-0.005476384,
0.0252610892,
-0.0158542451,
0.042428609,
0.0389315486,
-0.029640466,
-0.0075770235,
-0.0584189482,
0.0147050163,
-0.0639875084,
0.0130989254,
-0.0008123395,
-5.683733387e-33,
0.0255995933,
-0.0614487454,
-0.0121766757,
-0.0085382052,
-0.0034152914,
0.0215825196,
-0.0048925858,
0.0242229197,
-0.0000072524,
-0.0150357652,
-0.001574018,
0.039093364,
-0.0022710019,
0.0571753383,
-0.0286768693,
-0.0190025792,
-0.0065196571,
-0.0144136129,
-0.018240789,
0.0025223361,
0.0399225876,
0.0146797206,
0.0668188483,
0.0009793728,
0.0476002321,
-0.0136974361,
0.0027560473,
-0.0327005461,
0.0376677103,
0.0762661025,
-0.0346468687,
0.0456842706,
0.0281717461,
0.0023518566,
0.024761375,
0.080129981,
-0.0657266527,
-0.0038022292,
0.0451725423,
0.0867375284,
-0.0788012147,
-0.0046698446,
0.0359199755,
-0.013188567,
0.0123463562,
-0.0269378461,
0.0544971637,
-0.049689915,
-0.0384051427,
0.0335929915,
-0.026772825,
0.0138891079,
-0.0359965004,
-0.0440859199,
0.0177119952,
0.1247039288,
-0.0074495873,
0.002659596,
-0.0630200207,
0.0227568373,
-0.0004065392,
0.0145501317,
0.1000821739,
0.0170131307,
0.0513706096,
0.0379898958,
0.0168435462,
-0.0270349514,
-0.0447863564,
-0.0339848101,
0.0407058038,
0.0097851371,
0.0640278012,
0.0071198116,
-0.013823404,
-0.0230710171,
-0.0771408379,
-0.0048725009,
0.0006982966,
0.0413614064,
0.0285086334,
-0.0169808697,
-0.0458049327,
-0.0031174957,
-0.0262034796,
0.0202685222,
-0.0502255149,
0.018671019,
0.0497344546,
-0.0186992995,
-0.0512962453,
-0.0407891646,
0.0239080135,
-0.0421440229,
0.0487182476,
0.0172812697,
-0.0293572526,
0.0608131625,
0.0269764774,
0.0432189777,
-0.0321274735,
0.0230527148,
-0.0180475228,
0.0299375765,
0.0276538339,
0.0283009019,
-0.0276537184,
-0.0413939171,
-0.0171076804,
-0.0310847387,
-0.0239027627,
0.0033974312,
-0.0045903199,
0.0368624255,
0.0525074042,
0.012950235,
-0.0644855648,
0.0281105042,
-0.0059362827,
0.0058265193,
-0.0374617688,
-0.0551088005,
-0.0548999831,
-0.0018705175,
-0.0395280011,
-0.0015069941,
-0.0447745994,
0.0242204405,
0.0028857272,
-0.0601071082,
-0.0108688353,
0.0441775806,
2.631e-7,
0.021654563,
0.0584783703,
0.0118825799,
0.0050652553,
0.0364002101,
0.0274224095,
0.0306308419,
0.0336115099,
0.0183354691,
-0.0632111803,
-0.0407341681,
-0.0029877103,
0.0476331934,
-0.026186591,
-0.015973784,
-0.0356057175,
0.0135167381,
0.0568688139,
-0.0308310501,
0.0486268699,
0.0335793942,
0.0299173221,
-0.0334141888,
-0.0165434219,
0.0084530963,
-0.0261388049,
0.0432136729,
-0.022604879,
-0.0111505128,
-0.0144281508,
0.0475365818,
0.0095636481,
-0.0232025553,
0.0562486574,
-0.0283514522,
-0.0250490438,
0.0559230782,
0.016544221,
-0.0460206382,
0.0060869632,
-0.0031140603,
-0.0308304895,
-0.0249817893,
-0.0894868001,
0.0979564115,
0.0329195112,
-0.0327702314,
0.0278676432,
0.0007602599,
-0.0253674705,
-0.0009544298,
-0.003445891,
-0.0069380431,
0.0295621306,
0.006969458,
-0.0556811094,
-0.0284288023,
-0.0418189913,
-0.0365650542,
-0.0044077924,
-0.0037503166,
0.0014716535,
-0.0621007755,
-0.0291684195,
0.0451886915,
-0.0086984206,
-0.0192446411,
1.454579783e-34,
-0.0317511857,
-0.0070638531,
0.0225594006,
0.0316761397,
0.0212643687,
-0.0537189543,
0.0113348523,
0.0056376848,
0.0811215639,
-0.0661556125,
-0.0173719358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17853v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17853v2 | Can AI Put Gamma-Ray Astrophysicists Out of a Job? | 2023-03-31T07:29:47 | 2023-04-04T09:30:55 | Samuel T. Spencer, Vikas Joshi, Alison M. W. Mitchell | physics.pop-ph | physics.pop-ph, astro-ph.HE, cs.CL | In what will likely be a litany of generative-model-themed arXiv submissions
celebrating April the 1st, we evaluate the capacity of state-of-the-art
transformer models to create a paper detailing the detection of a Pulsar Wind
Nebula with a non-existent Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescope (IACT)
Array. We do this to evaluate the ability of such models to interpret
astronomical observations and sources based on language information alone, and
to assess potential means by which fraudulently generated scientific papers
could be identified during peer review (given that reliable generative model
watermarking has yet to be deployed for these tools). We conclude that our jobs
as astronomers are safe for the time being. From this point on, prompts given
to ChatGPT and Stable Diffusion are shown in orange, text generated by ChatGPT
is shown in black, whereas analysis by the (human) authors is in blue. | [
0.0366849676,
0.0867215544,
0.0241301693,
0.025637703,
-0.0603740178,
-0.0045561935,
0.0431042388,
0.0163506959,
0.0154719977,
-0.000843543,
0.0040204362,
0.0071198433,
-0.0194722731,
0.0425035208,
0.0033861422,
-0.0226198584,
0.0094287628,
-0.0194433797,
0.0410209522,
-0.0317990929,
-0.0376200974,
-0.0232496615,
0.0354676954,
0.0161799658,
-0.0037840651,
-0.0454588458,
0.06176861,
-0.0108219059,
0.0058957827,
0.0156870633,
-0.0351597778,
0.0663500503,
-0.0421924405,
0.1136328056,
0.0000021037,
-0.0312608518,
-0.0278356075,
0.0594355538,
-0.056003917,
0.0304809306,
0.0560926013,
-0.0195268448,
-0.0092523992,
0.0099397032,
-0.0652614534,
0.0075984327,
0.0285088718,
-0.0059483922,
0.0351209007,
0.0415166058,
-0.0065140324,
0.0150810899,
0.0550108775,
-0.0010461924,
0.0277251005,
-0.0159951337,
0.001199621,
0.0159184504,
-0.0199056286,
0.0546990484,
0.0060263951,
0.0929962695,
0.0145460777,
-0.0691436306,
0.0126150688,
0.0360673554,
-0.0374420397,
-0.0171278827,
-0.0002623471,
-0.0395433046,
0.010252866,
-0.0546140969,
0.0029032577,
0.0022031015,
-0.006440185,
0.0475913957,
-0.0479458272,
0.0373299308,
-0.0267452803,
-0.0466975383,
0.0298134089,
-0.0231735893,
-0.0223466735,
0.0000270609,
0.0329853594,
0.0449889638,
0.030013768,
-0.0462772399,
0.0040907976,
0.0381470136,
0.0273755658,
-0.1017973423,
0.0226765256,
0.0000477262,
0.0235842187,
0.0214629751,
-0.0252869073,
-0.0286807697,
0.00093804,
-0.0203674566,
0.0073893736,
0.0260489006,
0.0307164937,
0.0847970471,
0.0326212496,
0.0165514089,
-0.0314672738,
0.0492263548,
0.0278868768,
0.0149684986,
-0.0128755132,
-0.0441654138,
-0.0094190482,
-0.0479685031,
0.0306493361,
-0.006849959,
0.0032132647,
0.0002020559,
0.0041788435,
0.0265212562,
0.061462231,
0.0604579523,
-0.0931075439,
0.0015156694,
0.010265938,
-0.0204784498,
0.0567337275,
-0.0236291289,
0.0228459816,
-0.0428505316,
-0.0142169632,
0.029604217,
-0.0036667373,
-0.0095022628,
0.0077551878,
0.0572990216,
0.0329359286,
-0.0315125994,
0.0695351809,
-0.05173406,
-0.0328441747,
-0.0522437431,
0.0407544933,
-0.0103584193,
-0.0082117673,
0.0038770172,
0.0065342393,
-0.0355416127,
-0.0236986298,
-0.0044184169,
-0.0075431098,
0.0481282286,
-0.0434470512,
-0.0075776549,
0.0016052689,
0.0369510166,
-0.0668518692,
-0.0494698137,
-0.0090674153,
0.0216455441,
0.0431369692,
-0.0440945514,
0.0847064555,
0.0015109779,
-0.0128224865,
0.0360159911,
0.0163619164,
0.0130419508,
-0.0559377261,
-0.0021908213,
0.0180217642,
0.0591780953,
-0.0509807132,
-0.0233602598,
0.0167152565,
0.0184718668,
-0.0298966412,
0.0637940392,
0.0392727889,
-0.0181118902,
0.0040408592,
0.0018287672,
-0.0219219029,
0.0536510721,
-0.0522890911,
-0.0108149108,
-0.0465919264,
-0.0137352413,
-0.0062792157,
-0.0159347951,
0.0018244678,
-0.0027451031,
-0.0301778186,
-0.0315393321,
0.0220283773,
0.0461530536,
-0.024094766,
-0.0740332231,
0.0172096118,
-0.0292220414,
-0.0091269445,
-0.071738869,
0.0196340829,
0.0120094949,
0.0691194236,
-0.0166767277,
0.0127847688,
-0.0309697166,
-0.0217809174,
0.1001798511,
0.0272275526,
-0.0057515465,
-0.037008021,
-0.009299241,
-0.0251680203,
-0.0318786427,
-0.0004610578,
0.0463112406,
-0.0098286942,
-0.0072663384,
-0.0045391344,
0.0265512466,
-0.0415483527,
-0.0044435514,
-0.0574139319,
-0.0862158537,
0.0190222971,
-0.0109939054,
0.033782877,
-0.0052841208,
-0.0408626609,
0.0284629241,
0.0365366302,
0.0047494732,
-0.0216492061,
0.0384029038,
0.0328456983,
0.0362156779,
0.0025989716,
-0.075130783,
-0.0300548691,
0.0067572813,
0.0123003069,
0.01721536,
0.0386610068,
-0.0377451442,
-0.0223648753,
-0.0160904787,
0.0028228324,
-0.0170945395,
0.0145107247,
0.0043567331,
0.0130924834,
-0.000131613,
0.030583011,
0.0163597558,
-0.0334418602,
0.0285848584,
-0.0402995534,
-0.0152477548,
-0.0318057574,
0.0130928485,
-0.0280638095,
0.040981032,
-0.0058623264,
0.0325624123,
-0.0156321917,
0.0101225181,
-0.0494598821,
0.0103370454,
-0.0304803755,
0.0557203591,
-0.0464293398,
-0.0321474001,
0.0244999137,
0.0484572463,
-0.028353028,
0.0472692549,
-0.0304276068,
0.0246489719,
-0.0227956474,
-0.0095127588,
-0.0421772338,
-0.0165257081,
-0.0442115963,
0.0330006294,
0.1125501618,
-0.027033668,
-0.1089604422,
0.0435365289,
0.0096121533,
-0.0080623366,
-0.0105880303,
-0.020174114,
0.011599551,
-0.030017823,
-0.04219326,
0.0722674802,
0.004310437,
0.0114588449,
0.0136953741,
0.0107520223,
0.0072427671,
-0.0386730209,
-0.0253025349,
-0.0082467133,
0.0501601659,
-0.0136425719,
0.0341680944,
0.0140553713,
0.0054899724,
-0.0188321453,
0.0070151407,
0.0432081558,
-0.0423718616,
-0.0206245799,
0.0395587571,
-0.0598710589,
-0.0411824286,
-0.011181334,
0.0189098883,
-0.0415505394,
0.0261312407,
-0.0706264079,
-0.0147702424,
-0.0612160265,
-0.0360597968,
0.0115518216,
0.0010720108,
-0.0046203244,
0.0334293209,
0.050638821,
0.0408790559,
-0.0317787491,
0.008595489,
-0.0077809691,
0.0015264925,
-0.0632861406,
-0.011969544,
-0.0172460116,
0.0078028175,
0.0034577502,
-0.0089013511,
-0.0336364768,
0.0406328142,
0.0232479461,
0.0489517823,
-0.0314119831,
-0.0639238507,
-0.0180432349,
0.0471710637,
0.0098793609,
-0.0166199002,
-0.0426063165,
-0.0196181592,
0.039160911,
0.0418604277,
-0.0416111127,
0.0280362219,
-0.0297909994,
-0.035634771,
0.0333723053,
0.0002638477,
0.0402409472,
-0.0106047029,
-0.0431025438,
0.0270560496,
-0.006483919,
-0.0121640814,
-0.0148044927,
0.0409463681,
-0.0089908112,
-0.0409693606,
0.0495493524,
-0.0108489292,
-0.0234231912,
0.00867905,
0.0535898656,
-0.0170188285,
-0.0077322936,
0.0084122922,
-0.0558777563,
0.0578006171,
-0.0105007784,
0.0366390385,
-0.0706515238,
-0.0315199755,
-0.0035980958,
-0.0218096823,
0.0978017971,
-0.0175079145,
0.0029842062,
0.0082859378,
-0.061964348,
-0.0198479723,
-0.0025054174,
-0.0223088488,
-0.016144352,
0.0286133736,
0.0126991766,
0.0239465479,
0.0212903414,
-0.040655449,
-0.0039657182,
-0.0188134983,
0.0176234208,
0.0184937883,
0.0338256843,
-0.038922634,
-0.0652366877,
-0.0324008204,
0.0388933979,
0.0038036075,
0.032329265,
0.0484997854,
0.0243935641,
-0.0009075305,
-0.0076792389,
0.0642571822,
-0.0304275788,
0.0263688881,
-0.0327279754,
0.0664741099,
-0.0410065912,
-0.072488822,
-0.0245043542,
-0.0364173315,
0.0557044186,
0.0681637377,
-0.0037042794,
-0.0064182049,
-0.0410855152,
-0.0715976134,
0.0806901827,
-0.0186224077,
-0.0401457176,
-0.028612515,
0.0424419828,
-0.1313743591,
-0.0473227836,
-0.0397682711,
-0.0364663936,
0.0541227795,
0.0220117569,
-0.0388578922,
-0.0031423126,
-0.0125858728,
-0.0106603131,
0.0256822221,
-0.0619794577,
0.014330769,
-0.0428422503,
-0.0358851179,
-0.0059070652,
0.0169852525,
-0.0621354096,
0.0400889553,
-0.0277604535,
-0.0473098345,
0.0482051,
0.0758144334,
0.0469345897,
-0.0346794948,
-0.0078239664,
-0.0075824284,
0.0100454353,
0.0395918228,
0.0176379085,
0.0207892172,
-0.0428338423,
-0.03869012,
-0.0313416272,
-0.0638479069,
0.0000092723,
0.0220810547,
0.0338614024,
-0.009514696,
-0.0501779467,
-0.0106340181,
0.0344421603,
0.0477712713,
0.0043489798,
-0.0573083013,
0.02478173,
0.0074143121,
-0.0432999171,
-0.0203135274,
0.0195932891,
-0.0284874737,
-0.0026351551,
0.0431612544,
-0.0205355063,
0.0277929865,
0.0472601354,
-0.0398910269,
-0.0155879399,
-0.0550253019,
0.0292680636,
0.0201172456,
0.0588243343,
0.0105002951,
-0.0145568084,
0.0234984998,
-0.0083729103,
-0.0089505985,
0.0005877852,
0.0284679364,
0.0011426087,
0.0330100432,
0.0083338171,
0.0090392008,
0.0280839447,
-0.1342248321,
-0.0522533283,
-0.0161278825,
0.0774133205,
0.0251243934,
0.0723244697,
-0.0283191483,
-0.0847084448,
-0.0117846932,
-0.017808469,
-0.0072360118,
0.0546345674,
0.0200800616,
0.0249259491,
-0.016906321,
-0.0226213336,
-0.0023397047,
0.0572777949,
0.007403757,
0.0494126268,
-0.0450037904,
0.0063200546,
-0.0271533933,
-0.0750536621,
-0.0820434391,
-0.0558003932,
0.0340746753,
-0.0148332445,
-0.0364110842,
-0.0195621792,
-0.0286734458,
0.0448446311,
0.0101967985,
-0.058534462,
0.0008316414,
0.008123748,
-0.0432263687,
-0.0101331538,
0.0139612705,
0.036703866,
-0.0205154344,
-0.0359838977,
-0.0380748995,
-6.559711778e-33,
0.0222666897,
-0.035770122,
0.0157267451,
0.0574624725,
0.0283311233,
0.0163704306,
-0.0517898612,
-0.0533393621,
-0.0068283081,
-0.0157238673,
-0.0210439488,
-0.0048584207,
0.0129666496,
-0.0213737004,
0.0201264098,
0.0276854262,
0.0717146918,
-0.0113069434,
-0.0280499365,
0.0372420624,
0.0131353876,
-0.0098912586,
-0.0102696111,
-0.1125868261,
0.0410560966,
0.0085239289,
-0.0382554047,
0.0080606714,
-0.006950296,
0.0373732708,
-0.0246096943,
-0.0042769276,
-0.0220811982,
-0.0068278508,
-0.0039940965,
0.0084394598,
-0.0187681168,
0.0243339371,
-0.0119233951,
-0.0099961692,
0.0129692284,
-0.0496690534,
0.0266540758,
0.0093117794,
-0.0493986718,
-0.0083613321,
0.0330181345,
0.0294244401,
-0.0413302332,
-0.0336181372,
-0.0161466245,
0.010166551,
-0.0301566739,
0.0324325785,
0.012338479,
-0.0230380204,
-0.0119195431,
0.0707726628,
-0.0784713775,
0.0506749004,
0.0340691321,
-0.0088649206,
0.0497246571,
-0.0358395576,
0.0524584875,
0.0394534431,
0.0390919745,
0.0307533238,
0.0467520244,
-0.013045067,
-0.0064311814,
0.0500826463,
0.0841355845,
0.0307913907,
0.0561724193,
-0.0460771322,
-0.0038914087,
0.0376263857,
-0.0074905045,
0.0195571035,
0.0030217532,
0.0051685753,
-0.0186455008,
-0.0049383002,
0.0634438992,
-0.0798144713,
0.0005876368,
0.002166461,
-0.0027895183,
-0.0058571827,
-0.0435965545,
0.0296580363,
-0.0191864632,
-0.0552754775,
0.0339664333,
0.0317726023,
-0.0056321677,
0.0695289895,
0.0039332127,
-0.0081593487,
-0.0478376336,
-0.0011438519,
0.0459810309,
0.0529462323,
0.0569160506,
0.0314504951,
0.0331961028,
0.0515199974,
-0.0515044741,
0.0184604768,
-0.0076946625,
0.0236217324,
0.0608721599,
-0.0244218316,
0.0145552251,
0.0060516926,
0.0242094137,
-0.029861493,
0.0043379674,
0.07478901,
0.0195153672,
0.0283389743,
-0.0240667313,
-0.0000684301,
-0.012813312,
-0.0337726027,
0.0285276193,
-0.0327024385,
0.0550373234,
-0.0669182241,
-0.0001106675,
-0.0254680328,
2.91e-7,
0.0120496424,
0.0561813675,
0.0364308245,
0.0092848968,
0.0421046503,
0.016191572,
-0.0300693233,
0.0036949827,
0.0430748723,
0.0254954733,
-0.0095056212,
-0.0653791353,
0.0101915915,
0.0359078497,
-0.0217948053,
-0.0137210218,
-0.0292578191,
-0.0023949405,
-0.0543810688,
0.0110482546,
0.0370089822,
0.0087214392,
0.031880036,
-0.0275942255,
0.0154941259,
-0.0798742846,
0.0140399346,
0.0341851488,
0.0525478236,
0.0194375757,
0.0366629139,
0.0136890626,
0.0043309396,
0.0426652841,
-0.0454417467,
-0.006934002,
0.0058170711,
0.0384063274,
-0.0146618402,
0.0220614579,
0.0035846063,
-0.0328280404,
0.0380141139,
-0.022423977,
0.0267761517,
0.0112133399,
-0.0322147496,
-0.0017070211,
-0.0546791591,
-0.0545220748,
0.011433295,
-0.0254051592,
0.0080337441,
-0.0232048761,
-0.0227520391,
0.0427983627,
0.0092748115,
-0.011559464,
0.0267058518,
0.0225265007,
-0.0392813198,
-0.0474542677,
0.0103453649,
-0.014156756,
0.036883384,
-0.0002480832,
0.002742535,
3.191300251e-34,
0.0284944326,
0.0054740291,
-0.0129164755,
-0.0075659524,
0.0229815152,
0.0008587848,
0.0175586157,
0.0124222301,
0.0323040038,
-0.0481486507,
-0.0342238732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17839v1 | Learning Procedure-aware Video Representation from Instructional Videos and Their Narrations | 2023-03-31T07:02:26 | 2023-03-31T07:02:26 | Yiwu Zhong, Licheng Yu, Yang Bai, Shangwen Li, Xueting Yan, Yin Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | The abundance of instructional videos and their narrations over the Internet
offers an exciting avenue for understanding procedural activities. In this
work, we propose to learn video representation that encodes both action steps
and their temporal ordering, based on a large-scale dataset of web
instructional videos and their narrations, without using human annotations. Our
method jointly learns a video representation to encode individual step
concepts, and a deep probabilistic model to capture both temporal dependencies
and immense individual variations in the step ordering. We empirically
demonstrate that learning temporal ordering not only enables new capabilities
for procedure reasoning, but also reinforces the recognition of individual
steps. Our model significantly advances the state-of-the-art results on step
classification (+2.8% / +3.3% on COIN / EPIC-Kitchens) and step forecasting
(+7.4% on COIN). Moreover, our model attains promising results in zero-shot
inference for step classification and forecasting, as well as in predicting
diverse and plausible steps for incomplete procedures. Our code is available at
https://github.com/facebookresearch/ProcedureVRL. | [
-0.0357896537,
0.0498024337,
0.005451614,
0.0087756943,
0.0112823946,
0.0054584984,
0.0023967361,
0.0104711475,
-0.0525097884,
-0.0386685282,
0.0242662393,
-0.029773701,
0.0248083286,
0.052532278,
-0.0172183793,
-0.1128430516,
-0.0079518417,
-0.0157040339,
-0.0058707567,
0.0202329867,
-0.0056211352,
-0.0159142781,
-0.0607448593,
0.045821365,
-0.0262626838,
-0.0099237515,
-0.0406339914,
-0.0152771501,
0.0382927097,
-0.0593175255,
-0.0037107074,
0.0762179121,
0.0504672155,
0.0191598497,
0.0000020078,
-0.001656374,
0.0177756473,
-0.0385819785,
-0.0427490845,
-0.0009134264,
-0.0508907363,
-0.0291882791,
0.0001409839,
-0.0024646081,
-0.0378787182,
-0.0059610992,
0.020531401,
0.0152835799,
0.061797455,
0.0426042154,
-0.0058003762,
-0.0589025766,
0.0096420441,
-0.0022320522,
0.0352492966,
-0.0118275238,
-0.0370821729,
-0.0063453601,
0.0283208415,
0.0251323637,
-0.0346845165,
0.0065531316,
0.0449868515,
-0.0181279108,
0.0001665076,
0.0404538214,
0.0088404855,
-0.0043374104,
0.0034987708,
0.0781467482,
-0.0087728016,
0.0218999013,
0.0170872994,
-0.0066483491,
0.0218027886,
-0.0045141727,
-0.0766541734,
0.054289382,
-0.0075973822,
0.0017774774,
-0.0595392436,
0.0471550189,
0.0031648015,
-0.0060360311,
0.063211605,
0.0201670304,
-0.0243096389,
0.0295103136,
-0.0588109456,
0.0202465262,
0.0556933992,
-0.0284577571,
0.0189864524,
0.0334007926,
-0.003682333,
-0.0149743333,
-0.0003528855,
0.0572665483,
-0.0224070176,
-0.0224143285,
0.0702266023,
0.0388552286,
-0.0192968063,
0.0393341742,
-0.0114963492,
0.0359110199,
-0.0329338536,
0.0006808274,
-0.029019041,
0.0551483631,
-0.0829978511,
0.0359882377,
0.0012534545,
0.0019438094,
-0.0156870335,
0.0199142843,
-0.0194446892,
-0.0194237847,
-0.0635633841,
0.0384208821,
-0.0048558437,
0.0772008523,
-0.0079737213,
-0.0307810903,
-0.0473173708,
0.0096296212,
-0.0428851657,
0.0394816175,
-0.0162027478,
0.0196268801,
-0.0316411071,
-0.0148316221,
0.025975829,
0.0348481089,
0.0117372172,
-0.010331898,
-0.0303143915,
0.0385520086,
-0.0350371376,
-0.0333656855,
0.02892242,
-0.0098109804,
0.0595193356,
-0.0714472085,
0.0249503423,
-0.0294984262,
-0.0022919732,
0.0300539359,
0.0109929442,
0.0122340079,
-0.0378073342,
0.0716999173,
0.059007287,
0.0092224963,
0.0144403409,
0.0460873805,
-0.0266292449,
0.0119644525,
0.0319714099,
0.0207136609,
-0.0212918557,
-0.0157280397,
0.0578727089,
0.0252354294,
-0.0267906655,
-0.0240307525,
-0.012676266,
-0.0152402399,
0.0105540762,
0.0469849072,
0.050793957,
-0.0176845286,
-0.0350100063,
-0.0101258829,
0.0019270923,
0.0242586061,
-0.0398040786,
-0.0495068803,
0.095801726,
0.0298959147,
0.0225141067,
0.0123271691,
-0.0493617393,
0.0606819615,
-0.0121317459,
-0.0081146695,
-0.0728951022,
-0.0147677734,
-0.0690030083,
-0.0416392758,
0.011503513,
-0.0138563709,
0.0356438644,
-0.0222297665,
0.0233622305,
-0.0032910272,
-0.078163445,
0.0364408232,
0.0023135999,
0.0094500631,
-0.0101051321,
-0.0196231678,
-0.0137730846,
0.1098050624,
-0.0102310488,
-0.0328442156,
-0.0159354787,
-0.0146327969,
0.0683330223,
-0.0396345481,
0.014646492,
-0.0623477474,
0.0274304394,
-0.0492260866,
-0.0656239763,
-0.0223967675,
0.0378367528,
0.0217377841,
0.0231528636,
0.0168571323,
0.0180092752,
0.0140069192,
0.0237689614,
0.0130972853,
-0.01189119,
-0.0467046462,
0.0334829204,
0.0177277997,
0.0004599258,
0.021817077,
0.0184074678,
-0.0178670045,
0.0195897333,
-0.0182667654,
-0.0051367395,
0.0033426709,
-0.060121946,
-0.0503882356,
0.0232051611,
-0.0255917069,
-0.0120871291,
-0.025982216,
-0.070565775,
-0.050617639,
0.0363103151,
0.0119427703,
0.0141847609,
0.0012435629,
-0.0010283433,
0.0884998292,
-0.0357562229,
-0.0106281135,
0.0394771844,
-0.0380694233,
-0.0031154111,
0.0295674298,
0.0263754688,
0.0100160846,
-0.0261630546,
0.0171583705,
-0.0071116872,
-0.0447225049,
0.0179572366,
0.0324254259,
0.0141642438,
-0.045947291,
0.0203846451,
-0.0949774906,
-0.0085070636,
-0.0094474824,
-0.0109120375,
-0.0186829213,
-0.0433225371,
0.0090951631,
-0.0557444617,
-0.0147120189,
-0.0083272196,
-0.0097224191,
-0.0057155457,
0.0055347346,
0.035006173,
-0.0201427266,
-0.015474868,
-0.0154807698,
-0.0364190042,
0.0161208007,
0.001127615,
-0.0058903554,
-0.0212923419,
-0.044553522,
0.0313217305,
0.0149264745,
-0.0100570517,
-0.0285010133,
0.0216907859,
-0.0289491378,
-0.0340772606,
0.047644373,
-0.0240623225,
0.0398974828,
0.015682403,
-0.0254846811,
-0.0262589753,
0.0082692364,
-0.0126698483,
0.0094548725,
-0.0163252503,
-0.0444470569,
-0.0713795274,
0.0275201667,
-0.0031848724,
0.0691276938,
-0.0689902753,
-0.0285532437,
0.0193382762,
-0.0056729577,
-0.0172846392,
0.016680494,
-0.0300464686,
0.0162744634,
-0.0240506995,
-0.0187630598,
0.0305875465,
0.0186372399,
0.002130599,
0.0183695368,
-0.0017063806,
0.0123692788,
0.0877053961,
0.0351672359,
0.0121356342,
0.0011188845,
-0.0306782033,
-0.0679533407,
0.0466978289,
0.0589750819,
-0.0262704566,
0.0177885666,
-0.1006679237,
-0.0115333972,
0.0076914751,
-0.0086338259,
-0.0694688931,
-0.0241670646,
0.0032624456,
0.0117102824,
-0.0736547336,
-0.0090398286,
-0.0507208817,
-0.0227674786,
-0.011076916,
0.0622925647,
0.0098157842,
0.0064769387,
-0.0038210636,
0.0323472284,
0.018273009,
0.0123674683,
-0.059730541,
-0.0389281251,
0.0831432194,
0.036171075,
0.0708050132,
-0.0273582432,
-0.0470748693,
0.0245280452,
0.0128084663,
-0.0308641512,
-0.0230939575,
0.0879665688,
0.0194706898,
-0.0714716986,
0.0158807822,
0.0981572941,
0.0189521872,
-0.0458981469,
0.0057909773,
0.0460808501,
-0.0415367708,
0.0075340178,
0.0076310495,
-0.0896893963,
-0.0273549873,
0.0082371039,
0.03584769,
0.0224365015,
-0.0155307744,
0.0105184866,
-0.0914729014,
0.0622488707,
0.0207632333,
-0.0182817746,
-0.0308708269,
-0.0324270502,
-0.0123275192,
-0.0225055572,
-0.0158111788,
0.0021902672,
-0.0326333828,
0.0195331927,
0.0371981338,
-0.0628941134,
-0.0525659397,
0.0486710034,
-0.0191651452,
0.0063879653,
0.0376075543,
-0.0063345931,
0.0018336918,
0.0051623448,
0.0054531288,
-0.0101195825,
0.0089717293,
0.0017317847,
0.0946170986,
0.0022352762,
0.022173034,
0.0382264778,
0.0780344233,
-0.0536057502,
-0.0657552779,
0.017019812,
0.0732980743,
-0.0503453799,
-0.0085807145,
-0.0545190684,
-0.007481005,
0.0321264975,
0.0469035283,
-0.0315712169,
0.00600609,
-0.0121420305,
-0.0188918673,
0.010391756,
-0.0216223877,
-0.0155484052,
-0.0138801774,
0.0280963052,
0.0005461919,
-0.0412055738,
-0.0401088744,
0.0309753586,
0.0442989469,
-0.0309654623,
-0.0259203054,
0.0127346637,
0.0475530736,
-0.0604274198,
0.0518221632,
-0.0040273727,
0.0247319452,
-0.0653892532,
-0.0328151882,
0.0295670442,
0.0331897512,
-0.0074552833,
0.0235471036,
-0.0510485135,
-0.0112643577,
-0.0162721612,
0.0928864852,
0.0165765956,
0.0798935071,
0.0218958165,
0.0693512857,
0.0002380929,
-0.0419506095,
0.0072605037,
-0.0330605991,
0.0355467424,
-0.0020185907,
-0.0278015975,
-0.00738888,
-0.0366167873,
0.0160850063,
-0.0571450852,
0.0232964456,
-0.0909853503,
-0.0503662191,
-0.0064375997,
-0.0927527994,
0.0769547522,
-0.0174020585,
-0.0127168205,
-0.0317340121,
0.027375374,
-0.0084851645,
0.0016124656,
-0.0445390455,
0.0214749053,
0.053147126,
-0.0122919213,
0.0091616763,
0.0095173558,
0.0120660458,
-0.0035835181,
-0.0446947031,
-0.0158091467,
-0.0031542478,
-0.0045714048,
-0.0127850454,
0.0118339201,
0.0284447651,
0.0566630885,
0.0229138657,
0.030178478,
0.0318795443,
0.0765488893,
0.004743597,
0.0789953098,
-0.0067245443,
0.0211649761,
-0.0195524674,
-0.0397844762,
-0.0242591333,
0.0086889956,
0.0420456864,
-0.0636514276,
-0.0170283057,
-0.0244676396,
0.0244725086,
-0.0108370082,
0.0480871797,
-0.0132667758,
-0.0250682477,
0.0107778823,
0.0195409209,
0.0183366369,
-0.0084988317,
0.10553132,
-0.0060407696,
0.0461027957,
-0.0196917783,
-0.0000709908,
-0.01400741,
-0.0439543128,
-0.0056523378,
0.0446557254,
-0.0111349272,
0.009419119,
-0.0419570208,
-0.0366487913,
-0.0591442548,
-0.0330784097,
-0.0006395143,
-0.0128419697,
0.0870453864,
0.0158489533,
-0.0304566864,
-0.0078747887,
-0.0169129707,
-0.0414633192,
0.0384029746,
-0.0443007834,
-0.0606647767,
-5.351679008e-33,
-0.0118687255,
-0.0205615088,
0.0236443579,
0.0508589931,
0.0316090994,
-0.0070278044,
-0.0388079844,
0.0297747292,
0.0032270125,
0.0497957915,
0.0240055602,
0.010802228,
0.0181906689,
0.0285950229,
0.0938708335,
-0.0238662399,
0.0680956766,
-0.0364457443,
-0.0072045112,
0.0253282301,
0.0171762612,
0.017196171,
0.0399903171,
-0.0516132526,
-0.0168749914,
0.0147671634,
-0.0409311242,
0.0126673803,
0.0367587209,
0.0227798186,
-0.0104928846,
-0.0468909107,
0.0106158424,
-0.0593140461,
-0.0207398385,
-0.0049257469,
-0.0636370555,
-0.0283836201,
-0.0565930568,
0.0114906905,
-0.0199324731,
-0.0319576599,
-0.0138816694,
-0.0081259962,
-0.0241818223,
-0.035298381,
0.0574759617,
0.0107546896,
0.0332554802,
-0.0076470566,
-0.0260574985,
0.0209323708,
-0.0382643938,
-0.0996125564,
0.0421994068,
0.0268435348,
0.0410747975,
-0.0870807543,
-0.0525278673,
0.0237333328,
-0.0197055079,
0.0080079157,
0.0453298725,
0.0020299745,
-0.0167082548,
0.0357360877,
0.032294631,
-0.0139640318,
-0.0146740237,
-0.0036622847,
-0.02192894,
0.0783520564,
0.0329449102,
-0.0720884353,
0.0458122157,
0.0397015326,
-0.0384764485,
0.0749309883,
0.0151776243,
0.0842778236,
-0.0452882051,
0.0037222307,
-0.0131585486,
-0.0180436652,
-0.0034072613,
-0.0060970439,
0.0380535051,
-0.0029170287,
0.0196851622,
0.0086827986,
0.0390338749,
-0.004288902,
0.0486830845,
-0.0106688561,
-0.003122461,
0.0367847718,
0.0008778702,
0.0249661282,
0.0119872428,
0.0206501652,
-0.0783674493,
-0.0454388261,
0.0187223777,
-0.0451091006,
0.0102789607,
0.0266355947,
-0.0036709076,
0.0431809127,
0.0008829646,
0.017034892,
-0.0052983719,
-0.0213315543,
0.0013975202,
0.0274488833,
0.0438631102,
0.0136469323,
-0.0226632338,
0.041761823,
-0.0341880955,
0.02728476,
0.0042190994,
-0.0289942548,
-0.0027355142,
0.0087212222,
-0.011156627,
-0.0292085968,
-0.0615487881,
-0.0223262552,
-0.0092283953,
-0.0201041289,
0.006755501,
0.0222054701,
2.661e-7,
-0.0172835644,
0.0061564222,
0.0045086383,
0.0056250254,
0.0152609637,
0.0436290093,
-0.0297745056,
0.0034694779,
-0.0215591826,
-0.0779355839,
0.0712365955,
0.0330403671,
0.0233585257,
0.0068304543,
-0.0590147935,
-0.0628996044,
-0.0070974333,
-0.0102318618,
-0.0400942601,
-0.0379188918,
0.0203928165,
0.0812730491,
0.0254839044,
0.0102652954,
0.0331881456,
0.0060573313,
0.0581595674,
0.0255050249,
0.0125569953,
-0.0128377089,
0.0185029022,
-0.007060294,
-0.0318317004,
-0.0134316953,
-0.0685231611,
-0.02673297,
0.0181393996,
0.0487446003,
-0.0280086845,
-0.003956161,
-0.0228918288,
-0.0195814762,
0.0177696776,
0.015448615,
0.0482925922,
-0.0272005796,
0.0126053737,
0.0541511551,
-0.0320882834,
0.0095966794,
0.0015695862,
0.0661418438,
-0.0069430475,
0.0015835634,
0.01102445,
-0.024352856,
-0.0312944241,
-0.0827782378,
-0.0020630173,
0.0304077603,
-0.0200953688,
0.0017018158,
0.0245539732,
-0.0321359113,
0.0018464794,
0.0023761825,
-0.06067748,
2.1411237e-34,
0.0259108953,
0.0243153963,
0.0158593766,
-0.0009209409,
-0.004108035,
-0.0042725834,
-0.0224097911,
0.0399441756,
0.0394495055,
-0.0237208903,
-0.0338912308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08592v1 | Improving Scene Text Recognition for Character-Level Long-Tailed Distribution | 2023-03-31T06:11:33 | 2023-03-31T06:11:33 | Sunghyun Park, Sunghyo Chung, Jungsoo Lee, Jaegul Choo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Despite the recent remarkable improvements in scene text recognition (STR),
the majority of the studies focused mainly on the English language, which only
includes few number of characters. However, STR models show a large performance
degradation on languages with a numerous number of characters (e.g., Chinese
and Korean), especially on characters that rarely appear due to the long-tailed
distribution of characters in such languages. To address such an issue, we
conducted an empirical analysis using synthetic datasets with different
character-level distributions (e.g., balanced and long-tailed distributions).
While increasing a substantial number of tail classes without considering the
context helps the model to correctly recognize characters individually,
training with such a synthetic dataset interferes the model with learning the
contextual information (i.e., relation among characters), which is also
important for predicting the whole word. Based on this motivation, we propose a
novel Context-Aware and Free Experts Network (CAFE-Net) using two experts: 1)
context-aware expert learns the contextual representation trained with a
long-tailed dataset composed of common words used in everyday life and 2)
context-free expert focuses on correctly predicting individual characters by
utilizing a dataset with a balanced number of characters. By training two
experts to focus on learning contextual and visual representations,
respectively, we propose a novel confidence ensemble method to compensate the
limitation of each expert. Through the experiments, we demonstrate that
CAFE-Net improves the STR performance on languages containing numerous number
of characters. Moreover, we show that CAFE-Net is easily applicable to various
STR models. | [
0.0150851915,
0.0603123233,
0.0020788612,
0.0969156027,
-0.0329432413,
0.0112700034,
0.0323261581,
0.033596389,
0.0091179051,
0.0311690997,
-0.0200348422,
-0.0597399846,
0.0290334281,
0.0530063175,
-0.0209663585,
-0.0132280979,
-0.0300491583,
-0.0041390201,
0.0324997641,
0.0053370902,
0.0392507426,
0.005479584,
0.018534461,
-0.0040601031,
-0.0226154327,
0.043576207,
0.0135185048,
0.0323689394,
0.0856022462,
-0.0352192558,
0.0168375373,
0.0515356027,
0.0257445108,
0.0204336792,
0.0000017297,
-0.0418581441,
-0.0113170501,
0.0109599717,
-0.0073520518,
-0.039304208,
0.0598996468,
-0.0032418417,
-0.0330492184,
-0.0116565526,
0.0155806569,
0.048506476,
0.0781466737,
0.0800812989,
-0.0543340705,
0.0482120328,
-0.0385458209,
-0.0701128393,
0.0004978044,
-0.0558446422,
0.04711546,
-0.033398632,
0.0261537526,
-0.0074279634,
-0.0257285591,
-0.0385693572,
-0.035659343,
0.0004514949,
0.0452028513,
0.0052502872,
-0.0138846161,
0.0831791908,
-0.0340311155,
0.0287782997,
0.0072664907,
0.0798115507,
-0.0672178268,
-0.0187185295,
-0.0241049938,
-0.03671984,
-0.011029304,
-0.0237851422,
0.0042726197,
0.0211184621,
-0.0491308458,
0.0387558453,
-0.0321170352,
0.0828408748,
0.0147733344,
0.029399462,
-0.0344628245,
-0.0116578909,
-0.012154459,
0.0098814536,
-0.0067703524,
-0.0136090014,
-0.0657155067,
0.0254313331,
0.0528515168,
-0.0013067701,
0.0484657884,
0.0038695587,
0.0045225997,
-0.048001647,
0.0046270611,
-0.0224229563,
0.011019785,
0.0300253052,
-0.0672166869,
0.0269525182,
-0.0631110221,
0.0310403816,
-0.0079173753,
0.0063822716,
0.0068440428,
-0.003359989,
-0.0177817196,
-0.0019555802,
-0.0247507263,
-0.0391350128,
-0.046882309,
-0.0385753885,
-0.0250230227,
-0.0123266559,
0.0162341408,
-0.029465571,
0.026637882,
0.0311152302,
-0.0529689156,
-0.0382280983,
0.0341384038,
0.0365464613,
-0.0418108515,
0.0241502803,
0.0027461534,
-0.0009547678,
0.0101981265,
0.0429541692,
0.0375722349,
0.0125571666,
0.0382579155,
0.0508051179,
-0.0458871387,
-0.0564597026,
-0.0187362097,
0.0255918372,
-0.0807838589,
-0.0705187097,
-0.0388063006,
-0.0955194235,
0.0233649444,
-0.0105888192,
-0.0059788348,
0.0034941353,
0.0177069008,
-0.0148982415,
-0.0182051361,
0.0758822635,
-0.0147292959,
-0.0460367799,
0.0546816364,
0.0298392661,
0.0097463103,
0.0380992293,
0.035476815,
0.0524727441,
-0.0152279213,
0.0524224751,
0.0438103639,
0.0297572222,
-0.0410949923,
-0.0072868168,
-0.0501472354,
-0.0142204482,
-0.0217137188,
0.0095982822,
-0.0007803246,
0.0322353281,
-0.0262095779,
-0.0329381563,
0.0451267138,
0.0113237891,
-0.0041816523,
-0.01038968,
-0.0167081784,
-0.0043506408,
-0.0146274203,
-0.0100798327,
-0.0201070607,
0.0088439211,
-0.0285775829,
-0.0019791448,
-0.0698903501,
0.0166365914,
-0.0225938875,
-0.0394356884,
0.0123002734,
-0.0197471995,
-0.0370025337,
-0.012836636,
0.0932284221,
-0.0308165215,
-0.0400408916,
-0.0504787862,
0.0236089118,
-0.029692065,
0.0021656901,
-0.0046407669,
0.0178147499,
0.0855209753,
0.0014672356,
-0.0549638644,
0.0315768458,
0.0197355095,
0.0070620691,
0.0341450721,
-0.0307169557,
0.0253291186,
0.0589531995,
-0.0604802109,
-0.022426188,
0.064316161,
-0.0077320705,
0.0839001536,
0.0006956335,
0.0484159514,
0.0067014624,
-0.0392775647,
-0.040941935,
0.0227943901,
0.0062393807,
-0.0095059704,
0.0060786479,
0.0259921812,
-0.0064177592,
-0.0034543807,
-0.0553795062,
-0.0230808686,
0.0274804085,
-0.0795861334,
-0.0232645161,
-0.0189500172,
-0.0665305331,
-0.0611193739,
0.0008739574,
-0.0434761047,
0.0306046493,
0.012068185,
-0.0137496293,
-0.0458052531,
-0.0333963633,
0.0186674185,
0.0058304891,
-0.0587456413,
-0.0078040147,
-0.0019962818,
0.0492538922,
-0.0408052057,
0.0803122744,
-0.0039849523,
-0.0017802118,
0.0109436689,
0.0097269602,
0.0241947975,
-0.0455701686,
0.0097694304,
0.0094271228,
0.0158104468,
0.0148704173,
0.0614094287,
0.0330925137,
0.0023324853,
-0.0532060117,
-0.0760926083,
-0.0452821478,
-0.0424412116,
-0.0018533171,
-0.0117904339,
-0.0106532481,
-0.0436287001,
-0.0622380711,
-0.0451555438,
0.0362993069,
-0.0237935986,
-0.0317650475,
0.0300882794,
0.0435919948,
-0.0309511255,
0.0066570533,
-0.0258800313,
0.0238501299,
0.0298016556,
0.0188038107,
-0.1002422646,
-0.0224970654,
0.0350731649,
0.0644160882,
0.0239442494,
-0.0505491048,
-0.0013277066,
-0.036881309,
-0.023973478,
0.0036916877,
0.0536109693,
0.0321767963,
-0.0331521295,
-0.0010164548,
0.0255993214,
-0.0194636155,
-0.0150789386,
-0.0149933482,
-0.0031454468,
-0.0302783065,
-0.014728982,
-0.0549159981,
0.0000968892,
0.0045426185,
0.0455435328,
-0.0404171087,
-0.0203889832,
0.0045690285,
-0.0014661417,
-0.0545679033,
0.0147629436,
-0.0149352485,
0.0245417841,
-0.0365836695,
-0.0150757721,
0.0355008505,
-0.0463157669,
-0.0184350014,
-0.0106930621,
-0.0262874775,
-0.0195202716,
0.0189955253,
0.0331101418,
0.0446825102,
-0.0078849876,
-0.0377273522,
-0.0435517654,
-0.0204532519,
0.0127658527,
-0.0078188581,
-0.0221490804,
0.0256160963,
0.0308925323,
-0.0334961489,
-0.020430699,
-0.0156379063,
-0.0144553753,
-0.0546132959,
-0.007883573,
0.0106284386,
-0.0275053363,
-0.0051168785,
0.0664185211,
-0.005858311,
0.0988484174,
-0.0220188908,
-0.0190942436,
0.0013240349,
0.0590455756,
-0.0141214458,
-0.0170602631,
-0.0030536463,
-0.0438925475,
0.0158858448,
0.0216943007,
-0.0146218212,
0.0061056172,
-0.0190550163,
0.0019241157,
-0.0028208192,
0.0384025089,
0.0302285776,
0.0029609227,
0.0381129496,
-0.0280966274,
0.0042391652,
0.0536522381,
-0.0054740058,
-0.0549478903,
-0.0526558794,
0.0209326111,
0.0315107517,
0.0229167286,
-0.0005141011,
-0.0538880117,
-0.038134031,
-0.0053911521,
0.0157831721,
0.023494171,
-0.0096425945,
-0.0105542401,
-0.0629164949,
0.0110077169,
0.0344817266,
-0.093614094,
-0.0365828313,
-0.0033866733,
0.0210468937,
-0.0484011769,
0.0061578704,
0.0091669932,
0.0152684553,
-0.0606623217,
0.0276555121,
0.0086524086,
-0.0448442809,
0.0004660482,
-0.0431602784,
-0.0201467816,
0.0359803699,
0.0084185917,
-0.0286933612,
0.0470371582,
0.0038497942,
-0.0216034316,
0.0461238064,
0.0050383369,
0.0773993954,
-0.0174862426,
-0.0193587802,
0.0274010282,
0.0331758037,
-0.0376212709,
-0.0195848998,
0.0103177857,
-0.0108987,
0.0235939678,
-0.0248639081,
-0.024345465,
-0.0281987209,
0.0210790914,
0.0291330405,
-0.0056620273,
-0.0252052154,
-0.0139793847,
-0.0021663688,
-0.0326176807,
-0.0598708391,
0.0086445259,
0.0121135991,
0.0169708412,
-0.0585838929,
-0.025814021,
-0.0326441787,
-0.0099504665,
0.0687590763,
-0.0082939751,
0.0022819103,
-0.0342419297,
0.0494828634,
-0.0427563675,
-0.028990034,
-0.0292367805,
0.024580529,
-0.043369133,
0.0362618044,
-0.0043245661,
-0.0512703769,
-0.0392614156,
-0.0232520215,
-0.0508916341,
-0.0369306691,
0.0056785489,
0.0203944482,
0.0123076243,
0.017822301,
0.0098069264,
-0.0663119033,
0.0626548678,
0.0779321119,
0.0041988529,
-0.034146592,
-0.0092378026,
-0.0659571141,
-0.0413216092,
0.0146040376,
-0.0076628891,
0.0946001485,
0.0377269201,
-0.0243509859,
-0.0590203293,
-0.0241475943,
-0.0143776741,
-0.0315809809,
0.0115238512,
-0.051865723,
-0.0166200325,
-0.0519301109,
0.035545256,
0.0183885098,
0.0058605191,
-0.0041573714,
-0.032767944,
0.0333647095,
-0.0055479887,
0.0020671403,
0.0399305373,
0.0500969775,
-0.0318287872,
-0.0162331127,
0.0112414099,
0.0496048369,
0.0242240969,
0.0261110086,
0.0114170164,
0.0015352954,
0.0317993537,
0.0051418366,
0.0355449393,
-0.0006491572,
0.0383409634,
0.0289164092,
-0.0242862254,
-0.0101196337,
0.0134380739,
-0.0571490526,
0.0292865504,
-0.0756374076,
0.058297608,
0.0581889078,
-0.0393145643,
-0.0533262268,
-0.0649334416,
0.0227469075,
-0.0643968433,
-0.0417381562,
0.0221734568,
-0.0057200273,
0.0007365367,
0.0256430507,
0.0172015112,
0.0174199548,
0.0650899187,
0.0419112444,
0.0052363952,
0.0147331106,
-0.0155999493,
-0.0384591781,
0.0241748206,
0.0258689336,
0.0025472348,
-0.0143604055,
-0.0045201243,
-0.0098663801,
-0.0269774552,
0.0525206178,
-0.0244780369,
0.0514093228,
0.0341612771,
-0.017053185,
0.0125583,
0.0039700572,
0.0261402428,
0.0150109241,
0.0097894156,
-0.0011521392,
0.0564215891,
-0.0165016092,
-5.497168108e-33,
0.0015596104,
-0.0455561318,
-0.0197740179,
-0.0268587302,
0.0174852721,
0.025970798,
-0.0301788133,
0.0163018648,
0.0004574622,
0.0134485979,
-0.0396048203,
0.0113266651,
0.0635598525,
0.0300751273,
-0.032893043,
-0.007188322,
0.0335637815,
0.0079889214,
-0.003647313,
-0.0008311775,
0.0428208821,
0.0687594116,
0.0825673416,
-0.0977070034,
-0.0277504418,
-0.036029391,
-0.0186633058,
0.0135094384,
0.0470722616,
0.023381168,
0.0003391024,
0.0746715888,
0.0257603955,
0.0006635519,
-0.0122757591,
0.0363193937,
-0.0759227648,
0.0065890276,
-0.0676920563,
0.0449935608,
0.0149065396,
0.003661827,
0.0207178164,
-0.0277761556,
0.0357633159,
0.0003518022,
0.0549123026,
-0.0737206936,
-0.0004774424,
-0.0311270468,
-0.0275226478,
0.0694791302,
0.0225530304,
0.0159961954,
0.0433223508,
-0.0233641453,
0.0404424705,
-0.0136658,
-0.0124872345,
0.0047228499,
0.0333333202,
0.0414119214,
0.0185739826,
0.0953199267,
-0.0354345106,
0.0400995836,
0.0356569402,
-0.0029586381,
-0.0020358318,
-0.0859656557,
0.0631888807,
0.0018229357,
0.0538452864,
0.0890660733,
0.0632771254,
-0.0138806161,
-0.0752662793,
0.0198703371,
0.0213180333,
-0.0316880383,
0.0402914844,
0.0168962646,
-0.0709649399,
-0.0128766214,
-0.0028797351,
-0.034114778,
-0.0288271233,
0.0330601409,
0.0127533544,
0.0575680584,
-0.0113362083,
0.0337185822,
0.0518007912,
-0.0362667479,
-0.0244980827,
0.0378021598,
0.0105770053,
0.0294402428,
0.0170228258,
0.013111704,
-0.0740807354,
-0.0242299512,
0.0121563906,
0.04541317,
-0.0275566727,
-0.0207441356,
0.1087397859,
0.0128592849,
-0.0368980132,
-0.0123812212,
-0.0119434679,
-0.0194983706,
0.0626588762,
0.1155500934,
-0.0013884985,
-0.0099859368,
0.000827202,
0.035454981,
-0.0056660771,
0.0051314691,
0.0079009496,
-0.0011030374,
-0.0071918499,
0.0255188234,
-0.0149497427,
0.0029156094,
-0.0080349343,
0.0181358736,
0.0581227429,
-0.0340767391,
0.0105110854,
0.032111641,
2.465e-7,
0.0516471229,
-0.0254961774,
0.0514445342,
-0.0382428579,
-0.0054972824,
0.013426343,
-0.0220504664,
0.0162962414,
-0.0298205689,
-0.0177907627,
0.0323560126,
0.0324201472,
0.0139874788,
-0.0058161058,
-0.0566290282,
-0.0078421198,
0.0065698945,
0.0268593282,
-0.0282195769,
0.013278272,
0.0621562079,
0.0710645244,
-0.0192804243,
-0.0140061481,
0.0303294472,
-0.0584954657,
0.0640998185,
-0.0148910545,
0.0794141442,
0.0076212022,
-0.0384753831,
0.0305495616,
-0.0404497646,
0.0476322509,
0.0220955294,
0.0076112896,
0.0504701436,
0.027359901,
-0.0339679867,
0.0251355264,
0.0260835402,
0.06892737,
-0.0127654849,
0.0005231979,
0.0309102815,
-0.0668153465,
0.0119690085,
-0.0118137095,
-0.007432139,
-0.0308195073,
0.0052995356,
0.0101486873,
0.003989222,
0.0159084946,
0.013270678,
-0.0327957049,
-0.0339462161,
-0.0892994329,
-0.027654916,
-0.0283665657,
-0.0290878173,
0.0085735293,
-0.0626968741,
-0.0200199839,
0.029748654,
-0.0363392718,
0.0025570698,
1.848692389e-34,
0.0080165723,
0.0105314106,
-0.0397213586,
-0.0127246808,
-0.0313372239,
-0.0029218558,
0.0292006377,
-0.0082922261,
-0.0224226974,
-0.0262672007,
-0.0196487363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17811v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17811v2 | Zero-shot Referring Image Segmentation with Global-Local Context Features | 2023-03-31T06:00:50 | 2023-04-03T08:58:36 | Seonghoon Yu, Paul Hongsuck Seo, Jeany Son | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Referring image segmentation (RIS) aims to find a segmentation mask given a
referring expression grounded to a region of the input image. Collecting
labelled datasets for this task, however, is notoriously costly and
labor-intensive. To overcome this issue, we propose a simple yet effective
zero-shot referring image segmentation method by leveraging the pre-trained
cross-modal knowledge from CLIP. In order to obtain segmentation masks grounded
to the input text, we propose a mask-guided visual encoder that captures global
and local contextual information of an input image. By utilizing instance masks
obtained from off-the-shelf mask proposal techniques, our method is able to
segment fine-detailed Istance-level groundings. We also introduce a
global-local text encoder where the global feature captures complex
sentence-level semantics of the entire input expression while the local feature
focuses on the target noun phrase extracted by a dependency parser. In our
experiments, the proposed method outperforms several zero-shot baselines of the
task and even the weakly supervised referring expression segmentation method
with substantial margins. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Seonghoon-Yu/Zero-shot-RIS. | [
-0.0073611909,
-0.0031803527,
0.0490899384,
0.0428602099,
-0.0267585795,
-0.024742201,
0.0251663998,
0.0395984352,
-0.0550399423,
-0.0593854971,
-0.0242997278,
0.0408942737,
-0.0049122781,
0.024633348,
0.0011413705,
-0.0656833351,
0.0186063834,
-0.0194881372,
-0.0205513407,
0.0177297723,
0.051623147,
-0.0133608105,
-0.0313372575,
0.0281681251,
-0.0672475994,
0.0046358146,
0.0236307867,
-0.0054733432,
0.0407235175,
-0.0414709076,
-0.01748362,
-0.0018033206,
0.0422910601,
-0.0357364565,
0.0000020171,
-0.0180034656,
-0.0457691327,
0.0249307454,
-0.0355912149,
-0.0407373868,
0.0419828109,
-0.0646150559,
-0.0024528976,
-0.0406581573,
-0.0016690119,
-0.0001088367,
0.0562288091,
0.1005301699,
0.070913136,
0.0202663708,
-0.0475361533,
-0.0276151281,
-0.0167483054,
-0.0208480675,
0.0286371671,
-0.0423299782,
0.0156897195,
0.0110858548,
-0.0569862239,
-0.0181374233,
-0.0545078181,
0.0305706523,
0.0060313232,
0.0089666611,
0.0160997938,
0.0476876758,
-0.0528737009,
-0.0125067495,
0.0148607278,
0.0899315402,
-0.0106240734,
0.0087218592,
-0.0218901318,
-0.0070272,
-0.0300078075,
-0.0285811014,
-0.0246621314,
0.0382103585,
0.0215403736,
0.0498683229,
-0.0336345248,
0.0358440802,
-0.0169406012,
-0.0137523217,
-0.0042120018,
0.0193393938,
0.0122800525,
-0.0024410118,
0.0117777167,
0.0174025856,
-0.0199688077,
-0.0167646743,
0.0188568402,
-0.0037966983,
0.0422043838,
0.0171188135,
-0.0412477627,
-0.0286802128,
-0.0317805223,
-0.0019124153,
0.0204366557,
-0.0048782807,
-0.0339186192,
0.084930107,
-0.0310503654,
0.0195717514,
0.0023850603,
0.0258924998,
-0.0095425732,
-0.0415018462,
-0.0419192351,
0.003072649,
-0.0665621683,
0.0166721549,
-0.0488937609,
-0.0228978563,
-0.0338160172,
-0.0485057905,
-0.0371937603,
0.0043210946,
0.007231425,
0.0109819463,
-0.0395509303,
-0.0100251641,
0.0124799637,
-0.0134970834,
-0.0574359931,
-0.0141829122,
-0.0373347253,
-0.0304178391,
-0.0195887629,
0.0429136232,
0.0462521538,
-0.0278800689,
-0.0005962389,
0.0405817293,
-0.0488359965,
-0.0390147492,
-0.0250653457,
-0.0614704154,
-0.0627776459,
-0.0237825252,
0.0429095775,
-0.0177767705,
-0.0106251985,
-0.0100920079,
0.0146693848,
-0.0465571024,
0.010299556,
0.0059065921,
-0.0207508914,
0.0925219804,
0.0037705284,
-0.0455016606,
-0.023054434,
0.0331492499,
0.033739794,
0.0621381775,
0.0344238617,
0.0031155669,
0.0321435444,
0.0490520298,
0.0096591702,
0.0365520157,
0.0230921209,
0.0185337868,
-0.0895373225,
-0.0287036821,
0.006571929,
-0.0332705826,
0.0343981832,
0.0175940171,
-0.0302393753,
-0.016438406,
0.0202143304,
0.0124855908,
-0.0807505697,
0.0063402886,
0.0336395055,
0.0565734319,
-0.0476177484,
-0.0108868331,
-0.0274274927,
0.0317569301,
0.0138698742,
0.0189767983,
0.0159961227,
-0.0205300692,
-0.0333862118,
-0.0151942633,
0.0234611779,
-0.0005572752,
-0.0029212728,
-0.0260819308,
0.053561911,
0.0613360405,
-0.0406963788,
0.0681985095,
0.0092717381,
-0.0672742575,
-0.0283123218,
-0.000672065,
0.0181375276,
-0.0155550828,
0.0267627649,
-0.0417689756,
-0.0153131755,
0.0105686458,
0.0495928489,
0.0472359397,
-0.0696883351,
0.003900761,
0.0498175509,
-0.0619529486,
-0.0572573431,
-0.0537784807,
-0.0013387781,
-0.0351182334,
-0.017603226,
0.0106340554,
0.036397703,
-0.0383011214,
0.0732505769,
0.0393819809,
0.0469253734,
-0.0046883128,
-0.0205460005,
0.0337201655,
0.0068546534,
-0.0094560338,
-0.0493836515,
-0.0295579638,
0.0164233241,
-0.0451450311,
0.0480033532,
0.024996005,
-0.0410158746,
-0.0474666394,
-0.0313918628,
-0.1098410338,
0.0048421943,
-0.0148700587,
-0.0366985276,
-0.0528664403,
-0.0072490722,
0.0221229065,
0.029385468,
-0.0151249534,
-0.034252394,
0.0149257584,
0.0438954122,
0.0122825792,
0.0421833657,
0.010339139,
-0.0177181363,
0.0301413853,
-0.002847279,
0.0045648091,
-0.0094686719,
-0.0036208325,
-0.0620001256,
-0.020938104,
-0.0509964451,
0.0065378542,
0.0324787647,
-0.0673044324,
0.0322913863,
-0.0489573739,
-0.0309963375,
-0.0332542993,
-0.007761382,
0.0162423644,
0.0115647633,
0.0030979745,
-0.0642419234,
0.0066629476,
0.0182929952,
-0.0202858336,
-0.0002987217,
0.0357760563,
0.0275446456,
0.0146475434,
-0.048929397,
0.0065325797,
0.0309025161,
0.0487017334,
0.0262190681,
-0.0718851313,
-0.0096574724,
0.0693211481,
0.0126210442,
0.0143140294,
-0.001775559,
0.0068003265,
0.0018409773,
0.0191714987,
0.0413424633,
0.0583096817,
-0.0282734912,
-0.015196193,
-0.0061049089,
-0.0696772262,
-0.0125467023,
0.0102239996,
0.0301967636,
-0.0006060558,
0.014169028,
0.0067351032,
-0.0037087908,
0.0424255021,
0.0016774944,
0.0252596792,
-0.0182382278,
0.009150289,
-0.0306694675,
-0.0546319336,
-0.0693265125,
0.044746317,
0.012425228,
0.0025469169,
-0.0440814011,
-0.0107678119,
0.0245051626,
-0.045997791,
-0.0443026647,
-0.0091230953,
-0.0011701592,
-0.0053484179,
0.0355165601,
0.0036875275,
0.0035744151,
0.0773316994,
-0.0254836474,
-0.019452069,
-0.0126696872,
-0.0007418261,
0.0545595586,
0.0487658419,
-0.013739788,
0.013234511,
-0.0205813907,
-0.0255233347,
-0.031249458,
-0.0207567085,
-0.0498833135,
0.0212713163,
-0.0054208171,
0.0141436905,
-0.0055517755,
0.0401901044,
0.0583971106,
0.045205377,
0.0079189921,
-0.0001703254,
-0.0280546099,
0.0450170264,
0.0297946204,
-0.0178870969,
-0.064334169,
0.0021399397,
-0.0045272224,
0.052342236,
0.0847621635,
0.0301330704,
0.0016136271,
0.0169891603,
0.0019515037,
0.0137293888,
0.0059361951,
0.0191733669,
0.0540770255,
-0.0636711195,
-0.0519181564,
0.077042155,
0.0228629932,
-0.069364436,
-0.0479247309,
-0.0188633204,
-0.0051571028,
0.029719349,
-0.0113537647,
-0.0829281881,
-0.0838426575,
0.0067946166,
-0.051154308,
0.0172564927,
0.0009187974,
-0.0232622121,
-0.0922195613,
0.0270711556,
-0.0139375683,
-0.0306647718,
-0.0013365065,
-0.0188621245,
0.0437842757,
-0.022204509,
-0.0340056941,
-0.029709788,
-0.0110334931,
-0.0277421474,
-0.0242655482,
-0.0106884036,
-0.0143649401,
0.0157037266,
-0.0380326547,
-0.0378824547,
0.0354402699,
0.0308117475,
-0.0191973411,
-0.010893641,
0.0136109646,
-0.0631917641,
-0.0099635962,
0.0006556651,
0.0998670459,
-0.0547985509,
-0.0196121838,
0.0056940089,
0.0202128869,
0.0018696679,
-0.0161521211,
0.0033801002,
0.002643734,
-0.0019603306,
0.038062606,
-0.0254138485,
0.0221678074,
0.0170357935,
0.0291632712,
0.0224259868,
-0.0113115804,
-0.0097267581,
-0.0186432581,
0.0315780006,
-0.056475278,
-0.0059675276,
-0.0099669425,
-0.069657743,
0.0087740635,
-0.0432317294,
0.0091830809,
0.0840521827,
0.0311096292,
-0.0124415997,
-0.0351864882,
0.0140321543,
0.0117413988,
-0.0446415357,
0.0183189493,
-0.0954484791,
0.0239230078,
-0.0312640369,
0.0257493015,
0.0836091414,
0.0157509279,
-0.0289643519,
0.0511418842,
-0.0048815724,
0.0032193621,
0.0034326629,
0.0716402754,
-0.0001774203,
0.0362658314,
-0.0116643636,
-0.0031850103,
0.0511061698,
-0.0416760817,
0.016057644,
0.0299166497,
0.0391714759,
-0.033816766,
0.0038321782,
0.0212868899,
-0.0436408408,
0.0473762974,
0.0390469991,
-0.009095327,
-0.0504935198,
0.0278686024,
0.0043014488,
-0.037296053,
0.0763751194,
-0.0034685209,
0.0641117543,
-0.0274398159,
0.0284905713,
-0.0054474818,
-0.0252023805,
-0.048385106,
0.0447776057,
-0.0417907573,
0.0131618306,
0.0148817319,
0.0634338409,
-0.0125890514,
0.0494951122,
0.0006813227,
0.0232280642,
0.0713158697,
0.0151625928,
-0.0430363268,
0.0199536812,
0.0087338518,
-0.0188641362,
0.0112341493,
0.031829793,
-0.029339347,
0.0742782801,
0.0221787542,
-0.0342721194,
-0.0641587526,
0.0484765917,
0.0307371989,
0.0890058726,
-0.0385986716,
0.003116068,
0.0579986386,
-0.0413879864,
0.0294305123,
0.0235752612,
-0.0235697757,
0.0151923476,
0.0359746218,
-0.0130955577,
-0.0694112852,
0.023922896,
0.0170542039,
-0.016868107,
0.0300617982,
0.0478510484,
0.0054027364,
0.0384213366,
0.0261704922,
0.0262344498,
-0.0587123781,
0.028182935,
-0.0083328635,
0.0218765941,
0.0297956187,
0.029094303,
-0.025334321,
-0.0492626503,
0.0470638648,
-0.0364527255,
-0.0431313552,
0.036879044,
0.0688397363,
-0.005221942,
0.022665957,
-0.0324317254,
0.0145413075,
-0.0201111101,
0.0253956504,
0.0106947972,
-0.0205413215,
-5.983615588e-33,
-0.0395818129,
-0.0166090094,
0.021986125,
-0.0106348554,
-0.0381731391,
0.0407285951,
-0.0508156009,
-0.0053818673,
-0.0108927265,
0.0433131941,
0.0038977293,
-0.0001559516,
0.0471699759,
0.0508588515,
0.0063426793,
-0.0483682044,
0.0478547886,
0.0051674433,
-0.0109428689,
0.0181575362,
0.0314187892,
0.0297492556,
0.102636762,
-0.0514977612,
-0.002466938,
0.017073812,
-0.0310409926,
0.0208394118,
0.0734682754,
0.0450650305,
-0.001350467,
0.0151094068,
0.0221298039,
-0.0681927353,
-0.002624417,
0.0020282161,
-0.0837693512,
0.0057227816,
-0.0061361473,
0.0050659198,
-0.0364729352,
-0.0025509158,
0.0270976275,
0.014317737,
0.0369090661,
-0.0215672106,
0.0455315821,
-0.0524657182,
0.011819277,
-0.0216301363,
-0.0671671629,
0.0058427886,
-0.0196700506,
-0.0313160084,
0.0819460377,
0.0151386745,
0.033488445,
-0.0113769975,
-0.0634786859,
0.0107762497,
-0.0324584879,
0.0347741917,
0.0489420332,
0.0431107283,
0.0117170485,
0.045525305,
0.0050772843,
-0.0576955788,
0.0153874364,
-0.0080445549,
0.002958477,
0.0614391603,
0.0418631285,
0.0430966578,
0.03310211,
0.0352456756,
-0.0454924777,
-0.0336520895,
-0.0272333678,
0.0635720938,
-0.0121239284,
0.0283843335,
0.0051216418,
0.0006000414,
-0.0123530384,
-0.0360460728,
-0.0406121872,
0.0085161421,
0.0162005909,
0.0379181616,
-0.0428079143,
0.0728486404,
0.087175101,
0.0439114608,
0.01814886,
0.0458105281,
0.0170402583,
0.0554004051,
-0.0053400504,
-0.01914935,
-0.0706375986,
-0.0134179406,
0.0330316201,
-0.0089575918,
0.017762091,
-0.0020353508,
0.0619327649,
-0.0122699635,
-0.0424532145,
-0.0205994099,
-0.0039240746,
0.022530904,
-0.0383584537,
0.0524579249,
-0.0081039015,
0.0347926989,
-0.0495292097,
0.0576989092,
-0.0025876083,
-0.0047874418,
0.0293982551,
-0.0270229243,
-0.0275597665,
0.027679028,
-0.0321620777,
0.0058622644,
0.0071974378,
-0.0170537587,
0.0589336976,
-0.0554176867,
-0.0218128152,
0.0092516718,
2.598e-7,
0.0044044312,
0.0224159621,
0.0597987622,
-0.0073504206,
-0.0103160515,
0.0542674139,
0.0045126346,
0.0245793704,
-0.0058415714,
-0.0310430247,
-0.0021138904,
0.0106756287,
0.0259962659,
0.0030576698,
-0.0677624941,
0.0174966957,
-0.015118083,
-0.0515465923,
-0.0114796106,
0.0180220827,
-0.0007745785,
0.0974562243,
0.019932406,
0.0035279994,
-0.0160413049,
-0.0539418869,
0.0284488574,
-0.011022903,
0.0067507466,
-0.0389465429,
-0.0570836551,
0.0033635348,
-0.06106304,
0.0330216326,
0.0024346036,
-0.0243542418,
0.0610090755,
0.033007659,
-0.0071572405,
0.003287991,
-0.0155978343,
0.0463215746,
-0.0238561332,
0.0245043989,
0.0898926109,
-0.0757043809,
-0.0103929685,
-0.0224484392,
-0.0194123387,
0.033837568,
-0.0323062204,
-0.0163784288,
-0.0638920739,
0.0230354536,
0.0412044041,
0.0166053455,
-0.0695122108,
-0.0737806261,
-0.0158753041,
-0.006281028,
0.0024411106,
0.0251177903,
-0.0127265062,
-0.0304929744,
0.0074286293,
-0.0540213883,
-0.0273414683,
2.094996567e-34,
0.002284673,
-0.0077410038,
-0.0216944329,
0.0304638501,
0.0314394608,
0.0093550701,
-0.0673479885,
-0.0357860476,
-0.0300202854,
-0.0336237885,
-0.0288934894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17807v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17807v2 | GPT-4 can pass the Korean National Licensing Examination for Korean Medicine Doctors | 2023-03-31T05:43:21 | 2023-11-17T01:49:57 | Dongyeop Jang, Tae-Rim Yun, Choong-Yeol Lee, Young-Kyu Kwon, Chang-Eop Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, J.3 | Traditional Korean medicine (TKM) emphasizes individualized diagnosis and
treatment. This uniqueness makes AI modeling difficult due to limited data and
implicit processes. Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive
medical inference, even without advanced training in medical texts. This study
assessed the capabilities of GPT-4 in TKM, using the Korean National Licensing
Examination for Korean Medicine Doctors (K-NLEKMD) as a benchmark. The
K-NLEKMD, administered by a national organization, encompasses 12 major
subjects in TKM. We optimized prompts with Chinese-term annotation, English
translation for questions and instruction, exam-optimized instruction, and
self-consistency. GPT-4 with optimized prompts achieved 66.18% accuracy,
surpassing both the examination's average pass mark of 60% and the 40% minimum
for each subject. The gradual introduction of language-related prompts and
prompting techniques enhanced the accuracy from 51.82% to its maximum accuracy.
GPT-4 showed low accuracy in subjects including public health &
medicine-related law, internal medicine (2) which are localized in Korea and
TKM. The model's accuracy was lower for questions requiring TKM-specialized
knowledge. It exhibited higher accuracy in diagnosis-based and recall-based
questions than in intervention-based questions. A positive correlation was
observed between the consistency and accuracy of GPT-4's responses. This study
unveils both the potential and challenges of applying LLMs to TKM. These
findings underline the potential of LLMs like GPT-4 in culturally adapted
medicine, especially TKM, for tasks such as clinical assistance, medical
education, and research. But they also point towards the necessity for the
development of methods to mitigate cultural bias inherent in large language
models and validate their efficacy in real-world clinical settings. | [
0.0715546682,
0.002137969,
-0.02136584,
-0.0144360159,
-0.0204199683,
0.0334134996,
0.0394167639,
0.0318373814,
0.0606884658,
-0.0104769655,
-0.0018493936,
-0.0471600331,
0.0007719343,
-0.0169179644,
-0.0054829158,
-0.0767181441,
0.0026789713,
0.0130567672,
0.0785847753,
-0.0089130877,
-0.0236824714,
0.0142704751,
-0.0403888524,
0.0328853242,
0.0378696285,
-0.0295784455,
0.0316576585,
-0.0211282317,
0.0240416098,
-0.1073571891,
-0.0195201784,
0.046686396,
-0.0229843911,
-0.0057539628,
0.0000023363,
-0.0665359721,
0.0091567133,
0.0124184359,
-0.0244954508,
-0.0090550855,
0.0565938316,
-0.045333311,
-0.0076965797,
-0.0000157129,
-0.0422313362,
-0.0405231118,
0.0281071793,
0.0434623547,
0.0377181359,
0.0710367039,
-0.0080416426,
-0.0085997544,
0.0062517007,
-0.0116241602,
-0.0207425673,
-0.0418579131,
0.0439294539,
0.0271634981,
0.0393396839,
-0.0107836947,
-0.0085509587,
0.0217184313,
-0.0161056537,
0.0290067494,
-0.0370410942,
0.0320869572,
-0.0209614765,
-0.0205802787,
0.0399402082,
0.0245742109,
0.0488810316,
0.0049503939,
0.0068220398,
-0.0111751966,
0.0203553401,
0.0123593956,
-0.0587665513,
0.0221244842,
-0.0244490374,
-0.0165320598,
0.0557029285,
-0.0150405951,
0.018313041,
0.0355026722,
-0.0044600782,
0.0292551853,
0.0155734839,
-0.0233377386,
0.012806613,
-0.0129035441,
-0.0116292937,
-0.022663936,
0.0309832487,
0.0477604344,
-0.0546247698,
0.031808272,
0.0184251927,
-0.0011129878,
0.0743875206,
-0.0642802715,
-0.0097152861,
0.047165364,
-0.0080981441,
0.0064373966,
-0.002575442,
0.0417546555,
0.0026497466,
0.0439813696,
-0.0624413304,
0.0320593119,
-0.0502084419,
-0.0080118589,
-0.0335182361,
-0.0199574027,
0.0268522687,
0.0337123424,
-0.1037617996,
-0.0224032626,
-0.0334340222,
0.007635063,
0.0097947819,
-0.0042576571,
-0.0305886082,
0.0062487186,
-0.0480749533,
0.0389714688,
-0.021746289,
0.0225592759,
-0.0208506901,
-0.0161023047,
0.0536304824,
-0.0031548119,
-0.0037979716,
-0.0121165887,
0.0185741149,
-0.0018961019,
-0.0000053067,
0.006554618,
-0.0259622466,
-0.0184986088,
-0.0385891758,
-0.0501040742,
0.0057731899,
-0.0711574927,
0.0023431075,
0.0300039332,
0.0233289711,
-0.0409007818,
0.0205384251,
0.0330088548,
-0.0531538017,
0.024292564,
-0.0004799879,
0.0334096029,
0.051477436,
0.0388507694,
0.0077016987,
0.0026320384,
0.0072114277,
-0.0405923724,
-0.0115840537,
-0.0486374497,
-0.0090299919,
-0.0108198849,
0.0051739067,
-0.0101546487,
0.012067521,
0.0122556193,
0.0108449152,
0.0592924803,
-0.0557025075,
0.0581371784,
0.0077357059,
0.0401198715,
0.0181467123,
0.0871619135,
-0.0081295231,
0.0188912489,
0.0290263891,
-0.0324241556,
0.0261693727,
0.0055892677,
-0.0235419124,
-0.023202572,
-0.0219923612,
0.0029578316,
-0.0360564366,
0.003907572,
-0.0297416132,
-0.0429095291,
-0.0737840533,
0.0005111272,
-0.0078243092,
0.0097664082,
0.0382284336,
-0.0339975357,
0.0137198884,
0.0523108616,
0.034900032,
0.000548014,
-0.0472674593,
-0.0502868034,
-0.0072479984,
0.0795774534,
0.0166176334,
-0.0131143937,
-0.0252725929,
-0.0138013829,
0.0160109252,
0.0182334967,
0.0520428307,
-0.0284324698,
-0.0333364829,
-0.0294514112,
-0.0065522841,
0.054782588,
0.0231533907,
-0.0056542163,
-0.0053411066,
0.0750344023,
0.0050744638,
0.000591821,
-0.0332198665,
0.0207295325,
-0.0979393274,
-0.0432811342,
-0.0019879923,
-0.0224170461,
0.0574430078,
0.0583053976,
0.0175210405,
0.0277509578,
0.0025319476,
-0.0193849523,
-0.0145192547,
0.0224867687,
-0.0419615246,
-0.0156958718,
0.0187704265,
-0.0120280758,
-0.0088708969,
-0.0345352031,
-0.0258162841,
-0.0353528857,
-0.0233538914,
-0.0151593806,
0.0224804208,
-0.0198515113,
0.0296179783,
0.0070654154,
-0.0195028633,
-0.0299573317,
0.0202600881,
-0.0094359973,
0.0154081313,
0.0614256896,
-0.0249837041,
0.0067301132,
-0.0260923207,
-0.0451604538,
0.0445243381,
0.0051395902,
0.0168353617,
-0.0068747862,
0.0395022668,
-0.0329216272,
-0.0166203342,
-0.1252088547,
-0.006180827,
0.0110888248,
-0.0137993433,
0.0172274299,
0.00128178,
-0.0286652707,
-0.0205142684,
-0.0604279004,
-0.0202343818,
0.0493995212,
0.0366093181,
-0.0034399901,
0.0395128205,
0.0201295223,
-0.0075360732,
-0.0063677533,
-0.0625759661,
-0.0278261863,
0.034914311,
0.0006545476,
0.0084799863,
-0.0001267967,
-0.0362311788,
-0.0296859387,
0.0015738133,
-0.0433832482,
0.012179018,
-0.0158692673,
0.0095079485,
0.0234747082,
-0.0269851126,
-0.0253972802,
0.0529134087,
-0.0022204309,
-0.0053389454,
0.0066317357,
-0.008838743,
-0.0458666831,
0.0097498065,
-0.0915611237,
-0.051110249,
0.0664485097,
0.0389676131,
0.0023140186,
-0.0064230105,
-0.0180416647,
-0.0735199153,
0.0428173468,
-0.032235682,
0.016804982,
-0.0229433253,
0.0623298287,
0.0270806849,
-0.0005610638,
0.1075131744,
0.0217491798,
0.0378240421,
-0.0951421186,
0.001061973,
-0.0344214328,
0.0188833214,
-0.0209664088,
0.0155273005,
0.0153010339,
-0.0117206341,
-0.0094230874,
-0.0022809925,
-0.0039080097,
-0.077054359,
0.0561991483,
-0.042009633,
0.0018470937,
-0.0154929487,
-0.0187544487,
-0.0459490605,
0.0014066569,
-0.0191787779,
0.0204624962,
-0.0194561817,
0.055413235,
-0.0011784078,
0.0390566401,
0.0033644212,
0.055082377,
0.0100983549,
0.0050561037,
0.0144688068,
-0.0111881876,
0.0295475554,
-0.0277216416,
-0.0199967381,
-0.0128963841,
0.0836606175,
0.0474756844,
0.0111423275,
0.0054149134,
0.0180949587,
0.0094142286,
0.0088227578,
-0.0317886695,
-0.0261240788,
0.0395030268,
0.0216711536,
-0.0770058855,
0.0221974757,
0.1383956671,
0.0151267443,
-0.0494443402,
0.0014890133,
-0.0493921526,
-0.0568533018,
0.0118763018,
0.0276391897,
-0.0669206679,
0.0114685725,
-0.0191343259,
0.0354080796,
-0.0364937857,
-0.0038397235,
0.0379625484,
-0.0657022521,
0.0220803451,
0.0250435323,
-0.0536523685,
-0.0327019356,
-0.0320654586,
0.0029467689,
-0.005135939,
0.0213730186,
-0.0197935868,
0.0126009425,
-0.0110940551,
-0.0060204198,
-0.0918938369,
-0.0735361502,
0.0791381747,
-0.0090716155,
0.0360691771,
0.0453129113,
0.0316597708,
-0.0071431347,
-0.0347301662,
0.0033884852,
-0.0212274566,
-0.0036869643,
-0.0153585328,
0.0449376218,
0.0334375724,
0.0240442827,
-0.0473915786,
0.028351577,
-0.0366938598,
-0.001935967,
0.0429306999,
0.0947092175,
-0.0283921827,
-0.0417022295,
-0.0154967476,
0.0197005365,
0.0215075333,
0.0292639136,
-0.0070894444,
-0.002733524,
0.0069443765,
-0.0268679447,
0.0409523211,
0.0410613604,
-0.0179983042,
0.0533592962,
-0.0753981173,
-0.0280362032,
-0.0521522276,
-0.0494960658,
0.038904421,
-0.0222111158,
0.038007021,
0.0274474993,
0.0179251023,
0.0118091153,
-0.027247021,
0.0433154739,
0.0094966302,
0.0185623653,
-0.0300837848,
-0.0647858903,
0.0567638092,
0.0103145642,
0.0048415195,
0.0040524793,
0.0197166447,
-0.004581999,
0.0115194488,
0.0391260944,
0.0133292312,
0.0121616656,
0.0022041032,
0.0284188148,
0.0030301884,
-0.0217669941,
-0.0231344886,
-0.0400963947,
-0.0281052999,
0.025472369,
-0.0017562315,
-0.0055525536,
-0.0073438161,
0.0464923866,
0.0170933697,
0.0498549789,
-0.0244412627,
-0.0421802737,
0.0348323621,
0.0787636414,
0.0232470147,
-0.022573851,
-0.002758848,
-0.0267569404,
-0.0009335801,
-0.0308276564,
-0.0171309989,
0.0082203709,
-0.0201053713,
0.0462947078,
-0.0219844226,
-0.004697293,
-0.0402425416,
-0.0734068677,
-0.0613412336,
-0.0635308325,
0.0656869486,
0.0249874368,
0.0599731877,
0.0349994935,
-0.0098246466,
-0.0391323082,
-0.0091388803,
0.0088744145,
0.0293227322,
0.001252111,
0.1301643848,
-0.0381847955,
-0.0045086974,
0.0389475711,
0.00690305,
-0.0009428177,
-0.0533643141,
-0.0122853387,
0.0351435691,
0.0506790206,
-0.0262695849,
-0.0013348568,
-0.0340914391,
0.0036142918,
-0.0448504686,
0.0057794689,
-0.0015909593,
-0.0174781214,
0.0510787293,
0.0001923793,
0.0087966984,
-0.0098215658,
0.0571097173,
-0.0182613097,
0.0382399261,
0.0030120236,
-0.0697152838,
-0.0358823724,
-0.0261261333,
0.0340371393,
0.0108333156,
-0.0946908295,
0.0187522974,
-0.0785423368,
-0.0555189438,
-0.0447353572,
-0.0148598645,
-0.0197856445,
-0.0203305464,
0.0117834397,
0.0560100153,
0.0013473702,
-0.0413843915,
-0.0498138666,
0.0818406641,
-0.0421375856,
0.0069051408,
0.0377535112,
-6.096821571e-33,
-0.023719145,
-0.0057565304,
0.0491030999,
-0.0311359335,
0.0211663637,
0.0036743693,
-0.0469662584,
0.0190470628,
-0.0303041544,
0.0374395624,
-0.0191420056,
-0.0243555717,
0.0086677,
0.0222027879,
0.052968502,
-0.0203055739,
-0.0003705911,
0.0240206011,
-0.0047630016,
0.0256709009,
-0.0280531719,
0.0115748495,
0.0552633554,
-0.0607838109,
0.063191995,
-0.0087083746,
0.0508346707,
-0.031034112,
-0.0375366174,
0.0609709173,
-0.0160321407,
0.0324741229,
0.0647384599,
-0.0277365372,
-0.0048600351,
-0.0322440192,
-0.0414757505,
-0.0287531931,
0.0034043025,
0.0046662036,
-0.0040495181,
-0.0475921147,
0.0317228884,
-0.0324346274,
-0.0330360308,
0.0000328039,
0.0241988283,
-0.072398968,
-0.000175576,
-0.0053761047,
-0.0313369259,
0.0355648734,
0.0101555744,
0.0263139214,
-0.0395850204,
0.0339429751,
-0.0659778938,
0.0321775898,
-0.0232991073,
-0.0155226905,
0.0642854646,
0.0170274302,
0.0204917602,
-0.0367409736,
-0.0183323883,
-0.0047948486,
0.0098495996,
-0.0045252191,
-0.0166967008,
-0.0226574969,
-0.025697019,
0.0205265246,
0.0249979403,
0.0249641016,
0.0083647631,
-0.0276279692,
-0.0778518096,
0.0327571891,
-0.0208309721,
0.0473536327,
0.0218126066,
-0.0255570095,
-0.0644998252,
-0.0394604281,
-0.0269432086,
-0.0027195327,
-0.0197696332,
-0.0498067997,
0.0327033438,
-0.0125872064,
0.0031229781,
0.0033253466,
0.0321730897,
-0.0340742841,
0.0256252773,
-0.0389183201,
0.0148767214,
0.0171710104,
-0.0423599109,
0.0294689108,
-0.0842052177,
0.002603177,
-0.0381173715,
-0.0295553114,
0.0379132293,
0.0408752188,
0.000825487,
-0.026554808,
-0.037850678,
-0.0110774226,
0.005309267,
-0.0438327231,
0.0112517159,
0.0120985536,
0.0215213038,
0.0312637016,
0.0246707313,
0.0518202409,
0.0280142054,
-0.0376795903,
-0.0533384271,
-0.0573051423,
-0.0036979546,
-0.0232302304,
-0.0422680788,
0.0151473247,
-0.0104878256,
0.0705276951,
0.0305857714,
-0.0270702858,
0.0140583795,
-0.0075377072,
3.008e-7,
0.069822222,
0.0625658929,
-0.0348613933,
-0.0238623694,
0.0131254336,
0.0005370147,
-0.0367016457,
-0.0103227431,
0.0350176543,
0.002406253,
0.0683226734,
0.0019618941,
0.0316849835,
0.0589366779,
-0.0896020383,
-0.011138754,
-0.0647379532,
-0.0017642706,
-0.0505446121,
0.0249590036,
0.0147252288,
0.0608571433,
-0.0318588056,
-0.0300448723,
-0.0090486016,
-0.0050317068,
0.0498891696,
-0.0396788791,
0.0026574349,
0.0562946238,
0.0551818572,
-0.0017063223,
0.0377250612,
0.0615513697,
-0.0177615341,
-0.028615091,
0.0249322243,
0.1388198733,
-0.0365706794,
0.0619493574,
0.0363293886,
0.0046389918,
0.0383058377,
-0.0910804793,
0.0511889681,
-0.0164109226,
-0.0441075899,
0.0006339643,
-0.0056802062,
-0.0290944166,
0.0745180324,
-0.0200969372,
-0.0215050485,
0.0341534503,
0.0264835153,
0.0183570441,
-0.013890719,
0.0002205658,
-0.0107275182,
0.0120693715,
-0.0144861937,
-0.0481203794,
0.031467583,
-0.0357263871,
-0.0162913688,
-0.0582416095,
0.0253240243,
2.555566045e-34,
0.0276838727,
0.0047279098,
0.0056267171,
0.0062293159,
0.0200763606,
0.0055113663,
0.0062409723,
0.0399968587,
0.0146372002,
-0.0517031811,
-0.0276200529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17799v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17799v1 | Dialog act guided contextual adapter for personalized speech recognition | 2023-03-31T05:13:44 | 2023-03-31T05:13:44 | Feng-Ju Chang, Thejaswi Muniyappa, Kanthashree Mysore Sathyendra, Kai Wei, Grant P. Strimel, Ross McGowan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Personalization in multi-turn dialogs has been a long standing challenge for
end-to-end automatic speech recognition (E2E ASR) models. Recent work on
contextual adapters has tackled rare word recognition using user catalogs. This
adaptation, however, does not incorporate an important cue, the dialog act,
which is available in a multi-turn dialog scenario. In this work, we propose a
dialog act guided contextual adapter network. Specifically, it leverages dialog
acts to select the most relevant user catalogs and creates queries based on
both -- the audio as well as the semantic relationship between the carrier
phrase and user catalogs to better guide the contextual biasing. On industrial
voice assistant datasets, our model outperforms both the baselines - dialog act
encoder-only model, and the contextual adaptation, leading to the most
improvement over the no-context model: 58% average relative word error rate
reduction (WERR) in the multi-turn dialog scenario, in comparison to the
prior-art contextual adapter, which has achieved 39% WERR over the no-context
model. | [
-0.0136171812,
0.0621273331,
0.0042666942,
0.0425010696,
0.0005588084,
-0.0218747053,
0.0877037644,
-0.041224923,
0.0008765227,
-0.0313856006,
-0.0512824245,
0.0141541148,
-0.0352045745,
0.0647218898,
0.0013302821,
-0.0289740916,
0.0281171966,
-0.0230075903,
0.0080440976,
-0.0099087292,
-0.010141341,
0.0189711582,
-0.021277329,
0.0543154441,
0.0082432488,
0.0019192297,
-0.0123302285,
0.0457868539,
0.0122710522,
-0.0221920162,
0.0219766106,
0.0334101059,
0.0428751037,
0.0272858627,
0.0000019337,
-0.0476150028,
-0.0347841755,
0.0067525939,
-0.1127301753,
-0.0271323808,
0.0479561538,
0.0393099003,
-0.0238257069,
0.0348505788,
0.0172084514,
-0.0242784619,
0.060403768,
0.037676312,
0.0188839789,
0.0598312914,
-0.0138881803,
-0.0313362703,
0.0031129678,
-0.0359132215,
-0.0020319999,
-0.0905238837,
-0.0189068578,
-0.0359215774,
-0.0020546017,
-0.0087527921,
-0.0313030668,
0.0423364118,
0.0258558672,
0.0028152706,
-0.0020444673,
-0.0038712164,
-0.0398651287,
0.0080190832,
-0.0279613994,
0.0962187946,
0.0241337009,
0.0090577733,
-0.0094273118,
-0.0362755321,
-0.0173859987,
-0.0438453071,
-0.0092304926,
-0.0366905443,
-0.004140506,
-0.0272642635,
-0.0276289694,
0.0646161139,
-0.0015480733,
-0.0082191918,
-0.0671421215,
0.04361476,
-0.0043270076,
-0.0119998828,
0.0303037744,
-0.0069270306,
0.0228606109,
0.0011390042,
0.0606686287,
-0.0186806433,
-0.0634250119,
0.0069662826,
-0.0265203863,
0.0001197073,
-0.0252989735,
-0.0105208233,
-0.0137616657,
0.0516407527,
-0.0522283949,
0.0125211207,
0.0181824379,
0.0324212089,
0.0046082363,
0.0240322165,
-0.056293305,
-0.0326970033,
-0.0007637194,
0.0235999692,
-0.0695209876,
-0.0025079355,
-0.0514342748,
-0.0412173979,
-0.0309956074,
0.0376771465,
-0.027229365,
-0.0079801334,
0.0128289675,
0.0269783009,
-0.0487137325,
-0.0242817365,
0.0164339263,
0.0073959213,
-0.0074060708,
0.0402574874,
0.006302163,
-0.0383529328,
-0.0102983303,
0.0194867551,
0.0638720095,
-0.0110787516,
-0.0215172358,
0.0340808444,
-0.020381432,
-0.0348052047,
-0.0149747934,
0.0098180929,
-0.0304926783,
-0.0047088219,
-0.0535530485,
-0.0183959641,
0.0439536832,
-0.0123453587,
0.0154868197,
-0.0121616647,
-0.0321428254,
-0.0372840427,
0.0248650927,
0.0521841608,
0.0512183681,
-0.0142022017,
0.0530050993,
-0.0155445384,
-0.0274044238,
0.0416144878,
0.0523882993,
0.0028867873,
0.0340536498,
-0.05380309,
-0.0302980579,
0.0466509834,
-0.0081513757,
-0.0355104059,
0.0054338947,
0.0298567433,
-0.0241315197,
0.0263054483,
0.0414574035,
0.0221308265,
-0.0391685888,
-0.0400599875,
-0.0031699426,
0.027139347,
0.0621463321,
0.0130699221,
0.0143904267,
0.036264766,
-0.0424721017,
-0.0392833129,
-0.0126451207,
0.0076956348,
0.0144437058,
-0.0093473401,
0.0326140039,
0.0156465117,
-0.030975394,
-0.027004825,
0.0441743843,
-0.0072995932,
0.0158822816,
0.0299626105,
0.0229104981,
-0.0033771193,
-0.0523593239,
0.0043009683,
-0.0095290709,
-0.0605288818,
0.0208721235,
-0.0258384813,
-0.0105571747,
0.0824744776,
0.0567000136,
-0.0105521353,
-0.0247503072,
-0.0253872406,
-0.0418828465,
0.039763663,
0.0166731309,
-0.0299731772,
0.0440326333,
-0.064193964,
-0.0360462293,
0.0377731919,
-0.0269866567,
0.0792107135,
-0.0619776547,
0.0195740815,
0.041560553,
0.0390486568,
0.0435053557,
-0.0335677117,
0.0013028617,
-0.0461284816,
0.0748904943,
0.0257811304,
0.086140506,
0.0409258865,
-0.0124930181,
-0.0183984283,
0.0191843361,
-0.0198637489,
0.0127051016,
0.0298176967,
-0.1019611433,
-0.0349345468,
0.0073696533,
-0.0066997008,
0.031422779,
-0.025434427,
-0.0092557995,
-0.0927679464,
0.0345797502,
-0.0159256924,
0.0587620251,
-0.0451732166,
0.02691455,
0.0533652715,
0.0334703922,
0.0012719585,
-0.0016852116,
0.0294014532,
-0.0371273644,
0.036643438,
0.0338611118,
-0.0124326143,
-0.0880808756,
0.0109180277,
0.0087559186,
0.0157347508,
0.0156375896,
-0.009141691,
-0.0089840489,
-0.0317971297,
-0.0130365146,
-0.1051630303,
-0.0385095812,
-0.0169454683,
-0.0013074926,
-0.0232529882,
0.0527704582,
-0.0118498355,
-0.0460807011,
-0.0217549205,
-0.0202332661,
-0.0081061292,
-0.0027388916,
-0.0453126132,
0.0237380024,
-0.0450077131,
-0.0347158723,
0.0191255491,
0.0280364417,
0.0062208716,
-0.024905201,
-0.0104443887,
-0.0465689451,
-0.0585029684,
0.0320118479,
0.0458430313,
-0.0444495231,
0.0128504671,
-0.0058466406,
0.0331964083,
-0.0021145884,
0.0512967668,
0.0317840911,
0.0054657282,
-0.0004563772,
-0.021173887,
-0.0733565986,
0.0461314358,
-0.0196102839,
0.0020244287,
-0.0065139118,
0.0079500768,
0.0384520963,
0.004819266,
0.0223705918,
0.0393892862,
-0.0531486608,
-0.0134948324,
0.0307098925,
-0.0550591461,
-0.0112516377,
-0.0313944742,
-0.0477858782,
0.0096675707,
0.0018584697,
-0.0007377223,
0.0362547375,
-0.0394877531,
-0.028469203,
-0.0499789082,
-0.0270018708,
-0.0223046392,
-0.008837386,
0.0011101466,
0.0284078214,
-0.0007257974,
-0.0528581515,
-0.0156665891,
0.0107387947,
0.0067734211,
-0.0529699251,
0.0887222216,
-0.0055747554,
0.0243017338,
-0.0087681711,
-0.0442050844,
-0.0276531726,
-0.0013467753,
-0.0013193248,
0.0047667786,
0.0455305465,
-0.0261730943,
-0.0253646262,
0.0307322405,
0.0148580726,
0.0882359594,
0.0175111666,
0.0094283028,
-0.008487029,
0.0190499518,
0.0256236792,
0.0685884878,
-0.0225030817,
0.0371441022,
0.0561343804,
-0.0094342725,
0.0855755359,
-0.049291987,
-0.025573371,
0.0006895725,
0.0452073887,
0.01126373,
0.0155107128,
0.0009593266,
0.0545624681,
-0.0111645032,
0.0100036347,
0.0910790265,
-0.0026220346,
-0.0969597474,
-0.0184056237,
0.0056023574,
-0.0082540372,
0.0117800627,
0.0167405289,
-0.0594865456,
-0.0447159782,
0.0325380526,
0.047397051,
0.0054436848,
0.0193998329,
-0.0250079595,
-0.0806372464,
0.0456477962,
0.0230047442,
-0.0492806993,
-0.0333628953,
-0.0086470842,
-0.0044765794,
-0.0505814068,
0.0814225972,
0.0030588296,
0.0017203809,
-0.064804934,
0.0496011376,
0.0062042354,
-0.0478063822,
0.0221179053,
0.0132170683,
0.0966526717,
0.0247480441,
-0.0024161446,
0.026105741,
0.0042878087,
0.0051140147,
-0.0434211083,
0.011699466,
-0.020958228,
0.0170872603,
-0.0379481204,
0.0018577491,
0.0502951816,
0.0290936977,
-0.0282720421,
-0.0021604986,
0.0393792912,
0.0238783937,
-0.0268975031,
0.0364482924,
-0.0198184717,
-0.0234310534,
0.0054584462,
0.0510280021,
-0.0014322436,
-0.0373067334,
0.0222739,
-0.0181054622,
0.0425495245,
-0.039438758,
0.0154951168,
-0.0362750329,
0.0013866159,
-0.0368527137,
-0.0333764628,
-0.0264520776,
0.0006988377,
0.0225280691,
0.0017583546,
-0.0124583393,
-0.0130902687,
0.0293543916,
-0.0226122215,
-0.0172841456,
-0.0332245156,
0.0301219206,
-0.0702831671,
-0.0113837821,
0.0169262644,
-0.0564388856,
-0.0378998816,
0.029796375,
-0.0167091731,
-0.0479732417,
0.0044303038,
-0.0108348066,
0.0155218299,
0.0954054743,
-0.0310006756,
-0.0454712473,
0.0465102084,
0.0413194709,
-0.0326703005,
0.0000694629,
0.0837906674,
0.0664100572,
-0.0413210578,
0.0155016473,
-0.0746269077,
0.0290775038,
-0.0242897589,
0.0140764294,
-0.041128885,
-0.1186665818,
-0.0370626152,
-0.0056467233,
0.0127361845,
-0.0000985417,
0.0333925448,
-0.0448181219,
0.1011941656,
0.0109656304,
0.0295682326,
-0.0389018245,
-0.0236481167,
-0.0250479393,
-0.0284776706,
-0.0029869734,
-0.0146645317,
-0.0383101776,
-0.0031149515,
-0.0238032974,
0.0542102829,
0.0489605963,
0.0317325331,
0.013002838,
-0.0148282191,
-0.034570802,
0.0164800435,
0.0784233361,
0.0360373855,
-0.0260740537,
0.0646533072,
-0.0049690562,
-0.0059126532,
-0.0170835555,
0.0462738052,
-0.0408257358,
0.0143063031,
-0.0438224711,
0.0147195244,
-0.0271823984,
-0.0263952129,
0.0234643724,
0.0181949697,
0.0475063659,
-0.0336350538,
0.0114919757,
0.0042812559,
-0.0127926813,
0.0176100228,
0.0131042982,
0.0037342056,
0.0383104831,
0.0333374888,
-0.0083531467,
0.0416938476,
-0.0553040989,
0.0408239141,
-0.0702583417,
-0.0557548031,
-0.0095419781,
0.0029827924,
-0.0314974338,
-0.0189185515,
-0.0259098355,
-0.0420067906,
0.0171179231,
-0.0238068495,
0.0214042589,
-0.0176957622,
0.0133852763,
0.0128187602,
-0.0298307091,
-0.0034441138,
0.0253975261,
-0.039617952,
-0.0274217371,
-0.0030805336,
-0.0090045985,
-6.150241912e-33,
-0.0335915871,
0.0122213801,
-0.0002453247,
-0.0080837812,
0.0113286488,
-0.0121336887,
-0.0310876053,
-0.007320771,
-0.0051488671,
-0.0484542996,
-0.0203071088,
-0.0145732425,
0.0432642214,
0.0334104858,
-0.044480633,
-0.0150665315,
0.0776925832,
0.0168063734,
-0.0054035611,
0.0416746587,
0.0323751457,
0.0207668394,
0.0179158133,
-0.0750597268,
-0.0005073327,
0.0233575739,
-0.0048414068,
-0.0032188124,
0.0126071749,
0.0751227662,
0.0174071714,
0.0553541854,
-0.0168117154,
0.0043240208,
-0.0048020515,
0.0204973761,
-0.0752607659,
-0.0261371881,
-0.0209793691,
0.039119076,
0.051341854,
-0.0357968248,
0.0243930109,
0.0126504553,
-0.0453083813,
0.0197518021,
0.0163275301,
-0.0059162113,
-0.0619865842,
-0.0099420706,
0.0192507878,
0.0248810742,
-0.0171389747,
-0.001021937,
0.0322425552,
0.030743055,
0.0126011977,
0.0126707247,
-0.0570218116,
0.0033407654,
-0.0234748777,
-0.0123153804,
0.0196144097,
0.0608673356,
0.0012620728,
0.0270570423,
0.0522009544,
-0.0603745878,
0.021062864,
-0.0499622561,
-0.0033553655,
0.0188350305,
0.0075296774,
0.0523582362,
0.0270863455,
-0.0235257931,
0.0007201243,
0.0073112887,
0.0377797857,
0.0107303383,
0.0358752087,
0.0498126931,
-0.0547723137,
0.0173327681,
-0.0584392622,
-0.0592235737,
-0.0439558364,
-0.0116866417,
0.037227232,
0.0377300382,
-0.0168488007,
-0.0310934689,
0.0494895615,
-0.0128723523,
0.0124357641,
0.0028934944,
0.0026961076,
-0.0302022696,
0.0108852619,
0.0160667915,
-0.0567780845,
-0.0163457468,
0.0900079161,
0.0155571839,
-0.0061165025,
-0.0535281114,
-0.0229127202,
0.0635275468,
-0.0536831543,
-0.0253839623,
-0.0083008958,
0.0421408191,
-0.057760369,
0.0323688723,
0.0396010019,
-0.0049518547,
-0.0286453683,
0.0805611834,
-0.0284358393,
0.0127226114,
0.0159549974,
-0.0484155007,
0.0354028456,
0.0206253268,
-0.0576648749,
0.008803512,
0.0580051467,
-0.0247735754,
0.0681519732,
-0.0255794786,
-0.0000975265,
0.0030829706,
2.76e-7,
-0.0388603397,
0.0085917916,
0.0333833694,
-0.0164832827,
0.0430484079,
0.04665564,
0.0125404326,
0.0075872382,
0.0134681175,
0.0141093489,
0.0522511117,
-0.004218502,
0.0710982978,
0.0036954416,
-0.0738409907,
-0.001708982,
-0.0287227891,
0.0569712818,
-0.0039235018,
0.0148653248,
0.039628014,
0.0866358802,
-0.0046161357,
-0.0246911421,
0.0039887419,
-0.0176148787,
0.0066123563,
-0.0618726723,
0.0268465541,
-0.003679604,
0.0026698848,
0.0122620417,
-0.0071135713,
0.0264418051,
-0.0291338582,
0.0645147637,
0.0136688463,
0.0674069971,
0.0031476903,
-0.1045143455,
-0.0079478379,
0.0251626763,
-0.0023250871,
-0.0097014345,
0.0643321425,
0.0006788208,
0.0013561079,
-0.0236941222,
-0.069660984,
0.0190603528,
-0.0163219627,
-0.0031760158,
0.0042440668,
0.0147485081,
0.0202128906,
-0.0228884667,
-0.0177704692,
-0.1035235375,
0.0389982797,
-0.0430066846,
-0.0476479605,
-0.0140002323,
-0.0400931723,
-0.0124746598,
0.0203335006,
0.0208186936,
0.0287876576,
1.963762495e-34,
0.0517759435,
-0.013206766,
0.013052702,
0.0245920755,
0.0094303293,
-0.029985806,
0.0401344448,
0.0138129853,
0.0326950438,
-0.0835432783,
-0.0560670197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17786v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17786v1 | Attention is Not Always What You Need: Towards Efficient Classification of Domain-Specific Text | 2023-03-31T03:17:23 | 2023-03-31T03:17:23 | Yasmen Wahba, Nazim Madhavji, John Steinbacher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | For large-scale IT corpora with hundreds of classes organized in a hierarchy,
the task of accurate classification of classes at the higher level in the
hierarchies is crucial to avoid errors propagating to the lower levels. In the
business world, an efficient and explainable ML model is preferred over an
expensive black-box model, especially if the performance increase is marginal.
A current trend in the Natural Language Processing (NLP) community is towards
employing huge pre-trained language models (PLMs) or what is known as
self-attention models (e.g., BERT) for almost any kind of NLP task (e.g.,
question-answering, sentiment analysis, text classification). Despite the
widespread use of PLMs and the impressive performance in a broad range of NLP
tasks, there is a lack of a clear and well-justified need to as why these
models are being employed for domain-specific text classification (TC) tasks,
given the monosemic nature of specialized words (i.e., jargon) found in
domain-specific text which renders the purpose of contextualized embeddings
(e.g., PLMs) futile. In this paper, we compare the accuracies of some
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models reported in the literature against a Linear SVM
classifier and TFIDF vectorization model on three TC datasets. Results show a
comparable performance for the LinearSVM. The findings of this study show that
for domain-specific TC tasks, a linear model can provide a comparable, cheap,
reproducible, and interpretable alternative to attention-based models. | [
0.0543190204,
-0.0122211715,
-0.0029661299,
0.0498016067,
-0.0048138346,
-0.0019796242,
0.0242247116,
0.0039518308,
0.0088888556,
-0.1454151571,
-0.0337274969,
-0.003398804,
-0.0304963663,
0.028996909,
0.0110150734,
-0.0236643795,
0.0412417017,
0.0197515544,
0.0091317995,
0.0305650607,
0.0217090081,
-0.0017290879,
0.040596094,
0.0297791734,
0.0286145937,
-0.0323817395,
0.0121408859,
0.0034257439,
-0.0082958182,
0.0145075731,
0.0477526188,
0.0509358272,
0.0463006236,
0.0458167121,
0.0000020154,
-0.049009338,
0.0003556593,
-0.0127565125,
-0.0415852778,
0.075586617,
0.0207232516,
0.0199200865,
0.0319156796,
0.0264646504,
-0.0217911564,
0.0008277945,
0.0092722233,
0.0506427623,
0.0597608425,
0.0631375834,
0.0135077918,
-0.0426098295,
0.0112042241,
-0.0233922247,
-0.0160681307,
-0.0692518651,
0.0144487787,
-0.0059088329,
-0.0060801464,
0.050003022,
-0.0227468684,
0.0183087997,
-0.0192858987,
0.0120450007,
0.0820896849,
0.0377527922,
-0.0206001271,
0.0268241391,
0.0076701241,
0.0756194219,
-0.0306860954,
-0.0503350869,
-0.0175212212,
0.0173322055,
-0.0094418507,
-0.0157245491,
0.0085435724,
0.0036921748,
0.0021459397,
0.0266996566,
0.0443659611,
0.0149929542,
-0.0024455122,
0.0058480809,
-0.044546593,
0.0090722917,
-0.0292239934,
-0.0618626922,
0.0138671445,
0.0146338679,
-0.0292409863,
-0.0551711395,
0.017378021,
0.0211752597,
0.0152110709,
0.0151364682,
-0.0637120008,
-0.036300689,
0.0338476188,
-0.09505824,
0.0179664437,
0.0120976018,
-0.0054198997,
0.0528174788,
-0.0157641005,
0.0216794703,
-0.0277345385,
0.0427105017,
-0.046003066,
0.014857362,
-0.0651010573,
-0.0049888371,
-0.0404308699,
0.0658750981,
-0.0109431641,
-0.0265164636,
-0.0360223874,
0.033579953,
0.0185577832,
-0.0077966955,
-0.0157347079,
0.0009245709,
-0.0027554806,
-0.0045201359,
-0.011087995,
-0.0020980181,
-0.0314030722,
0.014059769,
-0.0508522838,
-0.0080064405,
0.0111853005,
0.0352451727,
0.0028596986,
-0.0131551344,
0.0096715074,
0.0361811891,
0.01110058,
-0.0828007385,
-0.0657475889,
0.0053734756,
-0.0189386625,
-0.041829057,
-0.0156735368,
-0.0236687288,
-0.0190748312,
0.014659619,
-0.0300817378,
0.0072917468,
0.0228828527,
0.0311465021,
-0.0367494524,
0.0656206906,
0.0051354752,
0.0159396566,
0.0692412481,
0.0044393018,
0.017923899,
0.028365016,
0.0050033364,
0.009637055,
0.0558947064,
-0.044260107,
0.0235675536,
0.0009570691,
0.0074579692,
-0.0340258814,
-0.0314004235,
0.0643853173,
-0.0558876172,
-0.0049807099,
0.0524781719,
0.0105327582,
0.0177000221,
-0.0123699484,
0.0394613296,
0.0453775562,
0.0354472212,
0.0283109527,
0.0387837961,
0.0414999761,
0.0078209778,
-0.0082212035,
-0.0362299345,
-0.023385331,
-0.0351142511,
-0.0162693579,
0.0382064953,
-0.0440378785,
-0.052456554,
-0.0501211695,
-0.0144721298,
-0.0188419726,
0.0135765579,
0.0166526083,
0.0692058429,
-0.0341550224,
-0.0359566063,
0.0339212678,
0.0251194257,
-0.0099822944,
-0.0076446715,
-0.0314259492,
0.0248149149,
0.0629880205,
0.0228958968,
-0.0755398199,
-0.0110113099,
-0.047940243,
0.0299232975,
0.0344923809,
0.0604473501,
0.0342104286,
-0.0316123515,
-0.0308691934,
-0.0169253554,
-0.0396901891,
0.0132841179,
0.0265791453,
-0.0178849827,
0.0097951014,
0.0286337361,
-0.0382999294,
-0.0549642481,
0.0516098887,
0.0001141543,
-0.0671605617,
0.0163759943,
0.0294707455,
0.0654316545,
0.0247617699,
-0.0188172776,
0.0074659619,
0.0255468171,
-0.0385346375,
-0.0314532407,
-0.0434816144,
0.0001225558,
-0.0389891155,
0.0032233368,
0.0068089571,
-0.014621689,
0.0344415531,
-0.0356566384,
-0.0106518548,
0.0219098181,
-0.0483958423,
0.0399635546,
-0.0472251587,
0.0183442757,
-0.0187272076,
0.0175804552,
-0.0517641157,
0.0563993081,
0.0090894401,
0.0446579531,
-0.0223379731,
0.010762861,
0.0256474335,
-0.0201711599,
-0.0192055106,
-0.0230752118,
-0.0227560718,
0.0454195514,
0.0184400287,
0.0045729177,
-0.0180380121,
0.0258646403,
-0.0627945885,
0.0056817913,
-0.0236904919,
0.0512301438,
-0.0221644863,
-0.0302440338,
-0.0010521669,
-0.0160360616,
-0.0214763265,
-0.0107444134,
-0.017221937,
0.0054195984,
0.038668301,
-0.0124013098,
0.0176731348,
-0.0431919657,
-0.0077640172,
-0.0075286455,
0.0505502261,
-0.0005165,
-0.036536973,
-0.0603848323,
0.0485865884,
0.0032931501,
0.0361800417,
-0.0024179902,
-0.0381826498,
-0.0452495031,
-0.0071210796,
0.0188741349,
0.0696105137,
0.0376569703,
-0.0040747798,
0.0263265092,
0.0337645635,
-0.0567650087,
0.0296761338,
-0.0156891122,
0.0074568177,
-0.0162569415,
0.0114157349,
0.064927727,
0.0793984979,
-0.010736688,
-0.009267197,
-0.0608213581,
-0.0240449775,
-0.0010016812,
0.0374550745,
-0.0141543094,
-0.0090882722,
-0.0010369836,
0.0262701903,
0.0029071905,
-0.0510209613,
0.0660208985,
-0.02443658,
-0.013208501,
-0.0660012364,
-0.0374272689,
-0.061126247,
0.0417028479,
0.0084551526,
0.0414215811,
0.0157245304,
-0.040612001,
0.0109993014,
0.0223420821,
-0.0244653821,
-0.0272545181,
0.0453133248,
0.0227918867,
0.0244703628,
-0.0145770032,
-0.0117292097,
-0.0453487672,
-0.0698450282,
-0.0263907425,
-0.0189960282,
0.0091860974,
0.0192169063,
-0.0478689224,
0.0515653528,
-0.009177315,
0.0205770247,
0.0016896336,
-0.0381001681,
0.0044934805,
0.0372367166,
-0.0151950642,
0.0078787403,
-0.0071215634,
0.0294809062,
-0.0026415556,
0.0465154387,
0.0237239767,
0.0026394101,
-0.0447752662,
-0.054961022,
0.0299537275,
-0.1076310277,
-0.0563251823,
-0.0052575478,
-0.0070556891,
-0.0495658368,
-0.0127641177,
0.1231704056,
0.0280577838,
-0.0256397165,
-0.0026130301,
0.0236320812,
-0.02919369,
0.034388084,
0.0386847407,
-0.0396285877,
-0.0435974933,
-0.0104285302,
0.0415123701,
0.0424103253,
0.012251405,
0.0133972615,
-0.0991703346,
0.0128482534,
-0.0284485333,
-0.0046200347,
-0.0461325161,
-0.0588495955,
-0.0156016191,
0.0134428646,
-0.0150995934,
-0.0190628003,
-0.0264003091,
0.0066030705,
0.0380823091,
-0.0766773894,
-0.0478573851,
0.0638622865,
-0.0054612202,
0.0223293118,
0.05443988,
0.0222680457,
-0.0145547688,
-0.0331100933,
0.028386239,
-0.0525508597,
-0.0055541676,
-0.0172557198,
0.0846407488,
-0.0629115254,
0.0221008155,
0.0234647468,
-0.0137017937,
-0.0603355579,
0.0304799788,
0.0094066486,
0.0711437464,
-0.0164409541,
-0.0217769332,
-0.0607352592,
0.0006635509,
-0.0386383012,
0.0941634476,
0.0177929942,
-0.0860034525,
-0.0468548611,
-0.0033518164,
0.0227325652,
-0.0068883132,
-0.0298927315,
0.0222497098,
-0.029219659,
-0.0474263057,
-0.0397745743,
-0.0567050464,
0.0146135772,
0.0192333627,
-0.0098507861,
0.0124214832,
-0.0295681953,
0.0074349386,
-0.0342088975,
0.022545252,
-0.0137471212,
0.0146787306,
-0.075962916,
0.0053838519,
0.0426592305,
-0.0332502425,
-0.0359620862,
-0.0310322326,
-0.0198174343,
-0.0152894892,
-0.0219364986,
0.0175902061,
0.0081901392,
0.0081470404,
-0.0330484174,
-0.0493534058,
0.0532676876,
0.0210568011,
-0.0477342084,
-0.0130207799,
0.0571676418,
-0.0005842607,
-0.0039406288,
0.0426081009,
-0.0599072203,
0.0401397869,
0.010701498,
-0.0051060892,
-0.0219543558,
-0.058686927,
-0.0155813536,
-0.0158658568,
0.0804542601,
0.017409347,
-0.0082834,
-0.0133200074,
0.02506385,
0.0331519246,
-0.0291127563,
-0.0448490418,
-0.0351996869,
0.0203037411,
-0.045888301,
-0.0024545649,
0.0196992364,
-0.0573552847,
0.0036764271,
-0.017768139,
0.0346599743,
-0.0009772768,
0.0470558107,
-0.0113085592,
0.0144951791,
-0.0455616973,
-0.0565875955,
0.0213011075,
0.0103270207,
-0.0308513939,
0.0376771614,
-0.0063736197,
0.0086854352,
-0.0214082357,
0.0217216257,
-0.0558083467,
0.017448429,
0.0059593213,
-0.0118927108,
0.0501438007,
-0.052900251,
-0.0050438838,
-0.0204000901,
-0.0077638426,
-0.0262685101,
0.0291224569,
0.0056030084,
-0.0026748853,
0.0111886971,
-0.0015077186,
-0.0480425507,
0.0090414146,
0.0786515251,
0.0512995943,
-0.0044696578,
0.0458003171,
-0.0705557764,
-0.0733333826,
0.0000670014,
0.0217079725,
0.0533413254,
-0.0157445036,
0.0462209471,
-0.0679421127,
-0.0423427485,
0.0352713913,
-0.0473675132,
-0.0125846835,
-0.0106595075,
0.0361740999,
0.0820677057,
0.0302840155,
0.0073141721,
-0.0523829535,
0.0294619445,
-0.0205749683,
-0.0018111849,
-0.0271105263,
-5.79747569e-33,
0.0014272684,
-0.0314243883,
-0.008297381,
0.027555434,
-0.0096631311,
0.037996918,
-0.0048405742,
-0.0136907399,
-0.0196736827,
-0.0074398899,
-0.0164540596,
-0.0006252436,
-0.0195977278,
0.0339848883,
0.0083406735,
-0.0092101842,
0.033279486,
-0.0030357477,
-0.0162244365,
0.0267054439,
0.0291736927,
0.0512766391,
0.0707268789,
-0.0671028346,
0.016351955,
-0.0218301658,
0.0282110553,
0.0129335579,
0.0325846896,
0.0621403903,
-0.0075825206,
0.0693186373,
0.0536826886,
-0.036433097,
0.0246157534,
0.0671202019,
-0.0531063303,
-0.0342767164,
-0.0122125698,
-0.0064334976,
-0.0086795958,
-0.0080400165,
0.0523802638,
0.0146335959,
0.0085098939,
-0.0122425873,
0.0724688545,
-0.0078450963,
-0.032958135,
-0.0509689003,
-0.0629723594,
0.0293853953,
-0.0170822442,
-0.0257884953,
0.0408574864,
0.0403723083,
0.0109395403,
0.0697694793,
-0.0735112131,
-0.0058613145,
0.0186925717,
0.0064517781,
0.0391123593,
0.0000600947,
-0.0202217922,
0.0220576022,
0.0061045685,
0.0263010748,
-0.0083968742,
-0.0235249139,
0.0028127469,
0.0397349447,
0.0035072402,
0.0066582025,
0.0428158045,
0.0145560987,
-0.0649271309,
0.0175511222,
-0.0182980094,
0.0205265637,
0.0394089408,
-0.0029033036,
-0.0785640106,
-0.0199984536,
0.0073347203,
-0.0003952149,
-0.0173125453,
-0.0214878097,
0.0278026611,
0.010773886,
0.00033481,
0.0170121565,
0.0161255766,
-0.0426412746,
-0.039162498,
0.0106724529,
0.0035291158,
-0.0052905772,
0.0155101847,
0.0127080474,
-0.0878222883,
-0.0145483362,
-0.0262457635,
-0.0257730391,
-0.0272628516,
-0.0120559866,
0.0412913524,
-0.0076048053,
-0.0604723766,
-0.0012756023,
0.014014747,
-0.0307790972,
-0.0595490336,
0.079799287,
0.0466795973,
0.0136346873,
0.0141747165,
0.0997514725,
0.0274510179,
-0.0081199165,
-0.0382797308,
-0.009128348,
0.0113701615,
0.0207400639,
-0.0033200935,
-0.0041725528,
-0.0141332075,
0.0773657262,
-0.0029000465,
-0.061952915,
0.0015209127,
-0.0212339815,
2.634e-7,
0.0760574043,
0.0666904673,
-0.04359743,
-0.0270969197,
0.0248757545,
0.0668113306,
0.0194931068,
0.0430282578,
-0.0302267913,
0.0377146937,
0.0110815326,
0.0122773396,
0.0185990948,
-0.0158664081,
-0.048345156,
-0.0318366475,
-0.0456832126,
0.0410827026,
-0.0170113426,
-0.0016147427,
0.0820664242,
0.1151006743,
0.0213434305,
-0.0197407603,
-0.0183793381,
-0.0607397854,
0.0511783287,
-0.0115273856,
0.0085906228,
0.0473398268,
0.0170016438,
0.0542732626,
-0.0273915976,
0.0121291336,
-0.0446533673,
0.0243321378,
0.0108925225,
0.0677000508,
-0.0254231002,
-0.0098541332,
-0.0081167109,
-0.0277240388,
0.029931156,
-0.0484924652,
0.0632373914,
-0.061364159,
-0.0304093845,
0.026111234,
-0.0261514075,
-0.009633977,
0.0300015416,
-0.003873565,
-0.0048937537,
-0.0001146187,
-0.012943564,
-0.04305562,
-0.0308093503,
-0.1176081672,
0.0007888858,
0.0194167942,
-0.041594591,
0.0255963616,
-0.039438013,
0.0151016321,
0.0950574428,
-0.0195592549,
0.018025076,
2.563296527e-34,
0.0275067016,
-0.0015314092,
-0.0032161754,
0.008569262,
-0.0206899978,
-0.0032080757,
0.0196026415,
-0.0059842747,
0.0536821224,
-0.0563297011,
0.0305989031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17760v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17760v2 | CAMEL: Communicative Agents for "Mind" Exploration of Large Language Model Society | 2023-03-31T01:09:00 | 2023-11-02T17:34:57 | Guohao Li, Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Hani Itani, Dmitrii Khizbullin, Bernard Ghanem | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.MA | The rapid advancement of chat-based language models has led to remarkable
progress in complex task-solving. However, their success heavily relies on
human input to guide the conversation, which can be challenging and
time-consuming. This paper explores the potential of building scalable
techniques to facilitate autonomous cooperation among communicative agents, and
provides insight into their "cognitive" processes. To address the challenges of
achieving autonomous cooperation, we propose a novel communicative agent
framework named role-playing. Our approach involves using inception prompting
to guide chat agents toward task completion while maintaining consistency with
human intentions. We showcase how role-playing can be used to generate
conversational data for studying the behaviors and capabilities of a society of
agents, providing a valuable resource for investigating conversational language
models. In particular, we conduct comprehensive studies on
instruction-following cooperation in multi-agent settings. Our contributions
include introducing a novel communicative agent framework, offering a scalable
approach for studying the cooperative behaviors and capabilities of multi-agent
systems, and open-sourcing our library to support research on communicative
agents and beyond: https://github.com/camel-ai/camel. | [
0.0834147707,
0.0394721553,
-0.0614316091,
0.0149593428,
-0.0607722625,
0.0115077132,
0.0120939212,
-0.0164072104,
0.0403720513,
-0.0152256237,
-0.0165791772,
-0.0239521135,
-0.0007329824,
0.0454018638,
-0.0066767614,
-0.039993979,
0.0260585286,
-0.0303442478,
0.0450145714,
-0.0136890383,
-0.0016902289,
-0.0156909898,
-0.0348992199,
0.0738897622,
-0.0194773208,
-0.0200430732,
-0.0685309395,
-0.0301271453,
-0.0015879356,
0.0115393428,
0.0301707294,
0.0460924506,
0.0182457399,
0.0307433624,
0.000001997,
-0.0413976386,
0.0274581276,
-0.0249870084,
-0.0318856537,
-0.0370803997,
0.0383892469,
0.0188989583,
-0.0232669655,
0.0115617597,
-0.0747724697,
0.027975738,
0.0416770652,
0.0270789601,
0.0659419745,
0.0395388827,
0.0093136476,
0.0241826251,
-0.0000300875,
0.0046898071,
0.0082803341,
-0.0296482779,
0.0033064,
0.0215222854,
0.0772134364,
0.0128940772,
-0.0178145114,
0.0379837416,
0.0250166357,
-0.0627913773,
-0.0236119032,
0.0299087875,
-0.0422749147,
-0.094765164,
-0.0176406074,
0.0591969974,
0.0724408925,
-0.0084665474,
0.0054383609,
0.0298368372,
0.0227396488,
0.015819611,
-0.0401018709,
0.0448015034,
0.0095776711,
-0.0171352345,
0.0114772748,
0.0074026976,
-0.021065278,
-0.0104417941,
0.0113615682,
0.0492978841,
-0.029262552,
-0.0096702268,
-0.0358392075,
0.0138594145,
-0.0098209176,
-0.0826730505,
0.0180766992,
0.0325917192,
-0.0732051358,
0.026172217,
-0.0318419039,
0.0050855931,
0.0329888687,
-0.02347509,
0.0420547426,
0.0257820264,
-0.0022121922,
0.0399882123,
0.0392502174,
0.0322429202,
0.0372926779,
0.0104967505,
-0.0035803479,
-0.0082858866,
-0.0771580115,
-0.0205439068,
-0.0750486627,
0.0291730762,
0.0011112046,
-0.0157665852,
-0.0017003424,
0.0521376319,
-0.0467195697,
0.0489857718,
-0.0013616191,
0.0103699611,
-0.0188473854,
-0.0016739641,
-0.029350074,
0.0109362146,
-0.0500446074,
-0.0064972076,
0.0241669659,
-0.0952840149,
0.0084453942,
-0.0269516315,
-0.0134108607,
0.021529505,
0.0009961642,
0.0589803793,
0.0061253631,
-0.0288139787,
0.0558844507,
-0.0053605316,
0.0139534408,
-0.0639356598,
-0.0377230942,
-0.0428372584,
0.0521551631,
0.0018991613,
-0.0258489158,
-0.0192228891,
0.0121904816,
0.0188574009,
-0.016180411,
0.0806609914,
-0.0059796572,
0.0328714438,
0.0415950976,
0.0398648791,
-0.0529027991,
0.0732198507,
0.0468179844,
-0.0107605532,
0.0446319617,
0.0174152609,
0.0350293033,
0.0370816961,
-0.0172185935,
-0.0291351322,
0.0484442078,
0.0021911976,
0.012699075,
0.0525742024,
-0.0325130671,
0.0352083035,
-0.0338573307,
-0.0291426778,
0.0755915269,
0.0838392228,
-0.0213615578,
-0.0148186507,
0.0449737795,
0.0718298107,
0.0154183926,
0.010028718,
-0.0517860353,
0.0542644113,
0.0061487267,
-0.0248446185,
-0.0248134136,
0.0373541601,
-0.0306263529,
-0.0485684946,
0.029364869,
-0.0131783374,
0.0313399769,
0.020638613,
0.0124567952,
0.0093286671,
-0.0274159592,
-0.0125292037,
0.019089831,
-0.0428819805,
-0.0120074376,
-0.0702576861,
0.0265963897,
0.0628861859,
0.0544528067,
-0.0227198731,
-0.0563372634,
0.0039169872,
0.0426035225,
0.0382955968,
0.017294351,
-0.0433714241,
0.0027613575,
-0.0246810447,
-0.0013500748,
0.0228405483,
-0.0036378629,
-0.0118438574,
-0.0011505147,
-0.0006331427,
-0.0422976352,
0.0265544504,
0.0042809569,
0.0137436995,
-0.0297055151,
0.0228314437,
-0.0443464518,
0.0205499418,
0.0173653197,
0.0189723875,
-0.0109077375,
0.0016512069,
0.0390635394,
-0.0017646269,
-0.0217173714,
0.070157364,
-0.0370543636,
-0.0358163081,
0.0260400083,
-0.0134422556,
-0.0318893977,
0.0267982166,
0.0105145117,
-0.0086527169,
0.0661602393,
-0.0433617905,
0.0212509446,
-0.0126878042,
0.0309819933,
-0.0083489288,
-0.0017292441,
-0.0031468826,
0.0077124243,
0.0191365704,
-0.0059799189,
0.0188970696,
0.0024250278,
0.011396368,
-0.0492320284,
-0.0100178607,
0.0526143089,
-0.0181901827,
0.0127767771,
0.0496835336,
0.0060564764,
-0.0471128523,
-0.0397852436,
-0.1122645214,
-0.0209644418,
-0.0078583481,
-0.0198573526,
0.0074759461,
0.0141046261,
-0.0101034855,
-0.0089207301,
-0.0317347422,
0.0713993534,
0.0459887423,
0.0309613273,
0.0282767639,
-0.0007040442,
-0.0883199573,
-0.0353651904,
0.0136772757,
-0.0038521462,
-0.0052245627,
0.0108772377,
-0.0120468521,
-0.034542758,
-0.0130069926,
-0.0377927721,
0.0341155194,
-0.0370203145,
-0.0375880189,
0.0568160228,
-0.0228000507,
-0.0191108137,
0.0622650534,
0.0248278063,
0.0680016428,
0.0070724487,
-0.039523825,
-0.0718024671,
0.032906089,
-0.0057716016,
-0.0131960968,
-0.0580828041,
-0.0371105894,
-0.0151853962,
0.0886608809,
-0.0262928922,
0.014290967,
-0.0566727668,
0.0208932813,
0.0053134225,
-0.0622930378,
-0.0156684257,
-0.0205712672,
-0.0202405956,
0.0248316415,
-0.0316127986,
-0.0176384095,
0.0900915638,
0.0078904312,
-0.0570371188,
-0.0306914989,
-0.0038637875,
-0.024455091,
0.113196902,
0.0217617154,
0.0120403692,
0.0526737235,
-0.0124373389,
-0.0544640645,
0.0228515044,
0.0304353256,
-0.0362729952,
-0.0268671773,
-0.0605409108,
0.0090819532,
0.0142389787,
-0.0238957703,
-0.0459841602,
0.0041642804,
-0.0334611796,
0.0288425442,
0.0082967384,
-0.0135535188,
-0.055322621,
-0.0107536502,
0.0160320662,
-0.0095408102,
0.0218899269,
-0.0058418759,
-0.0461635627,
-0.0361176245,
0.0341766998,
0.0463865288,
-0.0183261279,
-0.0181491207,
0.0894632787,
0.0584397614,
0.0140735079,
-0.0042519015,
0.0010083055,
0.0046405438,
0.0486843847,
-0.0147909289,
-0.0218164735,
0.021768894,
0.0545681491,
-0.0284792949,
-0.0123525094,
0.0995073915,
0.0352586918,
-0.0493468232,
0.0228028819,
-0.0279057026,
0.0146874934,
0.0087840222,
0.0262296684,
-0.0639553368,
-0.0066321394,
0.0135998623,
-0.0134625006,
-0.0221786071,
-0.0511614308,
-0.0029026926,
-0.07086128,
0.0601970963,
-0.0238004718,
-0.0016426006,
0.0107999602,
-0.0275509339,
0.0160650704,
0.004242816,
-0.027370343,
-0.0131276604,
0.0375806019,
-0.0205089264,
-0.0154729774,
0.0007837949,
-0.0192938708,
0.0288320873,
-0.0785315037,
0.1344278306,
0.068496339,
0.0557056479,
0.0279796869,
-0.0209831968,
-0.0382367745,
0.0509887934,
-0.0080978228,
0.0077441921,
0.0333662033,
-0.0295795295,
-0.0026692601,
0.0020168417,
0.0197179578,
-0.034572769,
-0.0090685366,
0.0330399983,
0.0503151305,
-0.0316260494,
-0.021231534,
-0.0197985489,
0.0590260513,
0.0541236661,
0.0737536997,
-0.0091097746,
-0.0700099617,
-0.0117606688,
-0.0248208959,
-0.023903599,
-0.0130659053,
-0.0310111586,
-0.004927651,
0.0441061817,
-0.00002171,
-0.0483935624,
-0.0820785165,
0.0674628764,
-0.0259130858,
0.0161103848,
-0.0014642781,
0.0363223217,
0.0235238578,
0.000286936,
-0.0262390114,
-0.0296021588,
0.0354318731,
-0.0532514788,
-0.0634731203,
-0.0032086077,
-0.0634656101,
0.0117743704,
0.0112224417,
-0.0749514103,
-0.0629051551,
0.0300734825,
0.0400618911,
0.0209275261,
0.0209578387,
-0.0148491273,
-0.0327102169,
-0.013695321,
0.025560068,
-0.0561982878,
0.0230370108,
0.0191370007,
0.0064051184,
0.0042300005,
0.0451753736,
-0.0079270471,
0.0361922607,
-0.0516984351,
0.0392434336,
-0.0514650084,
-0.0630389228,
0.0259841923,
-0.0295252297,
-0.0342208631,
0.0068961792,
0.0123798586,
-0.0049080816,
0.0012801735,
-0.0381816812,
-0.011697595,
-0.0634706989,
-0.0184253342,
-0.0289436653,
0.0154219847,
0.0553342253,
-0.001770303,
-0.0274646077,
-0.0139220795,
0.0296218079,
0.0317764319,
0.004987848,
0.0004430085,
0.0178348199,
0.0290531088,
0.0154406959,
0.0184717812,
0.0009625083,
0.0283091199,
0.0093408441,
0.0742507428,
0.0129489889,
-0.0530715883,
0.0155380238,
0.0438932069,
-0.0784651712,
-0.0540319644,
0.0621365942,
0.1005031988,
0.0455425009,
0.0214968622,
0.0132790608,
-0.0767565817,
0.0314672068,
-0.0014700694,
0.0057040569,
0.0226114746,
-0.0822572261,
-0.0062875929,
0.0242509879,
-0.0013590441,
0.0204114132,
0.044396542,
-0.0252658743,
0.0417710319,
-0.0200363845,
0.0164545812,
-0.028366968,
-0.0085113095,
0.0176135767,
0.0170545597,
-0.0387982242,
0.0414461643,
-0.0561733358,
-0.0330014601,
-0.020633243,
0.0271356478,
0.0014605479,
-0.062655434,
0.0260047987,
0.0308729932,
0.0106520606,
-0.0228210539,
-0.0605414659,
-0.0016436171,
-0.0529327169,
-0.002142,
-0.0195469782,
-5.700896707e-33,
-0.0331944562,
-0.0405434966,
0.0533354022,
0.0492699221,
-0.0021632556,
-0.019616304,
-0.0510041751,
0.0106215337,
-0.0168151017,
0.012286189,
-0.0344548188,
0.0304745976,
0.0063912715,
-0.0092155915,
0.0287533235,
0.0068724616,
0.0399633609,
-0.0383655652,
-0.0063618678,
0.0081381658,
-0.0133357979,
0.0107626962,
-0.008952301,
-0.0654807687,
0.0488714576,
-0.0198203437,
-0.0251372531,
0.0266486797,
-0.0267789476,
0.0393193178,
-0.006719972,
0.0087454664,
0.0121909296,
-0.0263193548,
-0.0080010667,
0.034397848,
-0.0502649099,
-0.0344995558,
0.0186813623,
0.0099650361,
-0.0625516698,
0.0046459492,
-0.0397780873,
-0.0331491157,
-0.0309481993,
0.0325004123,
0.0116129871,
0.0056494744,
0.005979904,
0.0610275678,
-0.0806965008,
-0.0222871117,
-0.0225096568,
-0.0719850734,
0.0256869253,
0.0116047151,
0.0080719246,
-0.0508091487,
-0.0092998398,
0.0636712238,
-0.0018161532,
0.014837563,
0.0397556908,
0.0113554411,
0.0178800058,
0.063612245,
0.0261234865,
0.0485946164,
-0.0390545167,
-0.0245900266,
0.0075331572,
0.0579666384,
0.0134069147,
0.0364060439,
-0.0434628017,
-0.0024172366,
0.0233023167,
0.0143657625,
0.0969303176,
0.0228282232,
0.0125440117,
-0.0003715261,
-0.0458051674,
-0.0154760731,
-0.0382638611,
-0.0034338168,
-0.0074139079,
-0.0571210235,
0.0088925222,
0.0290939882,
-0.0046161888,
-0.0284568686,
0.0203017648,
-0.0630483478,
-0.0113752326,
-0.0063774032,
-0.0184999164,
0.0375871062,
0.0079146633,
-0.001641177,
-0.0594788194,
-0.02906036,
-0.0042727855,
0.0026098692,
0.0265619773,
0.0412748866,
0.0045928322,
0.0288961418,
0.0212434866,
-0.0033129184,
-0.0383928008,
0.0439520814,
0.0011036309,
-0.0298298225,
0.01260099,
0.0012449326,
-0.0415940508,
0.0018447252,
0.0051923445,
-0.0271712709,
-0.0436803363,
0.0056030666,
-0.0336361453,
-0.0077564968,
-0.052042488,
-0.0097625041,
-0.1074325144,
0.0230158381,
0.0220381841,
-0.0173269566,
-0.0029357225,
-0.0409083217,
2.822e-7,
-0.0534169599,
0.0340353884,
0.0210347697,
0.0254337993,
0.0363582447,
0.0456213765,
-0.0207543932,
0.0438338704,
0.011268503,
-0.0269194152,
0.0334062427,
0.0477665775,
0.0336589776,
0.0173363015,
-0.1153774336,
-0.0581652895,
-0.0039011303,
-0.0306295659,
-0.0265671369,
0.0198083948,
0.0485008247,
0.0462867096,
0.0269445032,
0.0053366772,
-0.014173056,
-0.0284230523,
0.0254168678,
-0.0383579768,
-0.007478381,
0.0395220481,
0.0066755707,
-0.0337184072,
-0.0101731382,
0.0257265735,
0.0260005649,
0.0152538167,
-0.0127176354,
0.0340468436,
0.0152462209,
0.0118263196,
-0.0271993615,
-0.0082515404,
-0.0155250002,
-0.0132448217,
0.0366739407,
-0.0626884401,
-0.0590032265,
-0.0114290072,
0.0202163439,
-0.0399598517,
-0.0278776586,
-0.0089946333,
-0.0248660222,
0.0096887704,
-0.0100825038,
-0.0209868588,
0.0255216416,
-0.0494710281,
0.0203530584,
-0.0645893589,
-0.0253525302,
-0.0666396618,
-0.0077041518,
-0.0024384251,
-0.0104714492,
-0.015025327,
0.0051914756,
2.058394153e-34,
0.0096452245,
0.0122215888,
0.0238186885,
0.0396600813,
0.0372016467,
-0.0145538757,
-0.0171246976,
0.0372906514,
0.0478464663,
-0.0395916998,
-0.0416454673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17750v1 | Design by Contract Framework for Quantum Software | 2023-03-31T00:21:28 | 2023-03-31T00:21:28 | Masaomi Yamaguchi, Nobukazu Yoshioka | cs.CL | cs.CL | To realize reliable quantum software, techniques to automatically ensure the
quantum software's correctness have recently been investigated. However, they
primarily focus on fixed quantum circuits rather than the procedure of building
quantum circuits. Despite being a common approach, the correctness of building
circuits using different parameters following the same procedure is not
guaranteed. To this end, we propose a design-by-contract framework for quantum
software. Our framework provides a python-embedded language to write assertions
on the input and output states of all quantum circuits built by certain
procedures. Additionally, it provides a method to write assertions about the
statistical processing of measurement results to ensure the procedure's
correctness for obtaining the final result. These assertions are automatically
checked using a quantum computer simulator. For evaluation, we implemented our
framework and wrote assertions for some widely used quantum algorithms.
Consequently, we found that our framework has sufficient expressive power to
verify the whole procedure of quantum software. | [
-0.0457595848,
0.0865219235,
0.0117681753,
0.019323878,
-0.0518998541,
-0.0493153185,
0.0279509053,
-0.0058129225,
0.0396865495,
-0.0274065211,
0.028530594,
0.0169903934,
0.0121507607,
0.0388148613,
0.0176612493,
0.049994003,
0.0234531648,
0.0189295039,
-0.1221692339,
-0.0201385692,
-0.0491521955,
-0.029231498,
0.016220171,
-0.0112282196,
0.0326475836,
-0.0248842537,
0.0163680296,
0.037290927,
0.0051912782,
0.0203833636,
-0.0304813888,
0.0618542656,
-0.0703354701,
-0.0247890782,
0.0000018163,
0.0016073982,
-0.0085700415,
0.094347626,
-0.0124450456,
0.0603059791,
-0.0594851375,
-0.041053988,
0.0063530183,
0.0096396068,
0.0197987016,
0.036945276,
0.0159758925,
-0.0079313004,
0.0214645211,
0.0301789846,
0.0296894573,
-0.0154906958,
0.0460987538,
0.0502187796,
-0.03217398,
-0.0049773864,
-0.0103632752,
-0.0196719076,
0.032449998,
-0.0329566002,
0.030093642,
-0.0423458181,
0.0897193998,
-0.0129915876,
0.0149284191,
0.0084415562,
0.0162183363,
0.0278945994,
-0.0898926705,
0.0325459428,
0.0101021966,
-0.087649107,
-0.0254050009,
-0.0111060096,
-0.0535778366,
-0.0480850898,
0.0318303704,
-0.015312572,
0.0268318132,
0.0011502067,
0.0036501701,
-0.0333791152,
0.0025871284,
-0.0290449616,
0.0223714858,
0.0400519483,
0.0783654451,
-0.001403376,
-0.0532130376,
0.0387251675,
-0.0088627283,
-0.0080864951,
-0.0059729065,
-0.049781926,
-0.0533498712,
-0.0116128847,
-0.011335169,
0.0471946746,
-0.0055005127,
0.0179495066,
-0.036779549,
0.0123299658,
0.0125433737,
-0.0124980388,
-0.0001467306,
0.0157546531,
-0.0279026665,
0.0129049458,
0.0022148059,
0.0405467488,
-0.0169488955,
0.0284253042,
0.0332717448,
0.0271434933,
0.0198267903,
-0.0491060689,
-0.0448975936,
0.0145991566,
-0.0069570574,
0.0768288895,
-0.0232491586,
0.0192118902,
0.0104367333,
-0.0151386475,
-0.0051178453,
-0.0103381891,
0.0187911075,
-0.030282652,
-0.0471930243,
0.0057099108,
-0.0226185936,
0.0394274034,
-0.0171902329,
-0.0335397236,
-0.0188106019,
-0.003148264,
0.0367804021,
-0.0407616124,
0.0729583576,
-0.0201176796,
-0.0046569556,
-0.0491728783,
-0.0049549574,
-0.0189022217,
0.0119310757,
-0.0238776673,
0.0173069257,
-0.0042279325,
0.0192630645,
-0.0251208674,
0.03039046,
0.0183738917,
0.055924464,
-0.0153896203,
-0.0746150464,
0.0301538892,
0.052211225,
0.0126983617,
-0.0273340847,
-0.0102076046,
0.0182687193,
-0.002574608,
0.0537627079,
-0.0129435482,
0.0263169166,
-0.0318547226,
-0.0734722912,
0.0109279109,
-0.035991542,
-0.0423631743,
-0.1189739332,
0.0964794457,
-0.0211987142,
0.0262672286,
-0.041488573,
-0.0024062376,
0.0176637229,
0.0065799118,
-0.0249389522,
-0.0025600109,
0.0247615352,
0.0115570463,
-0.0942871943,
0.0922001749,
-0.0174218491,
0.0268938467,
-0.0188016724,
-0.0161244366,
-0.0103717009,
-0.0283626951,
-0.0301891528,
0.0008794827,
0.0363757201,
-0.0423055775,
0.0461445637,
0.0463888198,
-0.0168111753,
0.0191990472,
0.0064352974,
-0.0542995334,
-0.0272637513,
-0.0571570508,
0.0639607683,
0.0024515563,
0.0293896049,
-0.0030428083,
0.1074308008,
0.023027977,
-0.0792271718,
0.0359399654,
0.0534600727,
0.0031775606,
0.0291666389,
0.0221528169,
-0.0199958757,
-0.0288695712,
0.0261791982,
-0.001774916,
0.0721490383,
0.0180650316,
0.014962255,
0.0225544851,
0.0176399592,
-0.0083565637,
0.0464679636,
-0.0822434574,
0.0445452295,
0.0216759946,
0.0263685156,
0.0653236881,
-0.0590226017,
0.0352795683,
-0.0111044627,
0.0380883366,
-0.0050120191,
-0.0774577409,
0.0393175967,
0.0091908704,
-0.0060406937,
-0.088969633,
-0.0305490848,
0.0137712369,
0.0057723033,
0.0030264258,
0.0613269322,
0.01525685,
0.0162300505,
-0.0224011801,
-0.0633491054,
-0.0155283296,
0.0011342868,
0.0189446155,
-0.0010586911,
0.0491263792,
0.0382107608,
0.0208137352,
0.0112776132,
-0.0153014986,
0.0029980915,
-0.0537971631,
-0.0263129547,
0.0318453982,
0.0208378285,
0.0347779542,
0.028001491,
0.0490928814,
0.0247557629,
-0.0592398532,
-0.0032249098,
-0.0612471029,
-0.0086919274,
-0.0033750199,
0.0103759505,
0.0368349515,
0.0069146841,
0.0233881436,
-0.0776030049,
-0.0235779509,
-0.0203297846,
-0.0041825655,
-0.0358639844,
-0.0253371727,
0.0022218407,
-0.0044686738,
-0.004193977,
-0.0126412343,
-0.0183826704,
0.0345321894,
-0.0466079861,
-0.0063283942,
-0.0167598724,
-0.0600995868,
0.0167646222,
-0.0164409671,
0.0286355913,
0.0016610385,
-0.0343513265,
0.018340148,
0.0045863162,
-0.0074867178,
0.0385013781,
0.0622684024,
0.0174707379,
0.0009858275,
-0.0143320113,
0.0128413737,
0.0499596223,
-0.0049072383,
0.0123134321,
-0.0099771693,
-0.0028390742,
0.0172598679,
0.0114615494,
-0.0229175054,
0.0322468802,
0.0183867645,
0.0217417311,
0.0176719818,
0.0076069497,
0.0060493164,
0.0060828226,
-0.0098570595,
0.0528273322,
-0.0283994414,
0.0083488459,
-0.000105325,
-0.0246089865,
0.0107803755,
0.0369542763,
-0.0061880285,
0.0251858514,
-0.0392085426,
0.0443154387,
-0.0042262706,
-0.0296812095,
0.0603837892,
-0.0224818476,
-0.0349707194,
-0.0014820686,
0.0003035934,
0.0015275306,
0.0094357338,
-0.0091331601,
0.0538366362,
-0.0477284566,
-0.0053681619,
-0.0547290333,
-0.0162684377,
0.0474263839,
0.0252550039,
0.0297766589,
-0.0298274718,
-0.0170559417,
0.0009670043,
-0.0123236552,
-0.0740306228,
-0.0090208286,
-0.0628595874,
0.0434117354,
-0.0264180619,
-0.0070615243,
-0.0022501897,
-0.0310578011,
0.106085375,
-0.0163205974,
-0.0615955032,
-0.0143591547,
0.0087730121,
0.0630798563,
0.0316604786,
-0.0055146147,
0.0200912282,
-0.0108479243,
-0.0601749644,
0.0042976798,
0.016124187,
0.00178078,
0.0401452407,
-0.0510232039,
0.025057435,
0.0600098595,
-0.1173523739,
0.0117941312,
-0.0179490186,
0.0398760512,
0.0037979367,
0.047030177,
-0.0378977284,
0.0145487757,
0.0084746033,
0.0346275717,
0.015858002,
-0.033152841,
-0.0385994837,
0.0124601787,
-0.0138802361,
0.0449781418,
0.0468731076,
0.0259893741,
-0.0323960595,
-0.0232341569,
0.0364513956,
0.0059164329,
-0.0100025954,
0.0556871407,
-0.0309543367,
0.024382649,
0.0289468449,
-0.0236995034,
-0.0251158737,
0.0088679483,
-0.0332264751,
-0.0173397213,
-0.0061399294,
-0.0463597439,
0.0431430377,
-0.070461534,
-0.0280119982,
-0.0134099647,
-0.0183923375,
-0.0249224957,
0.0089594852,
-0.0377281457,
-0.0109889824,
-0.0531234592,
0.0276587065,
-0.0250551552,
0.0235821865,
-0.0082329623,
-0.0341539681,
0.0355468579,
-0.0920021683,
-0.0038240447,
-0.060599789,
-0.0450326391,
0.0026241408,
-0.0408577509,
-0.0169211905,
-0.0137638412,
-0.0164078623,
0.0548676662,
-0.0334227644,
0.0080343103,
-0.0002981664,
-0.0492570251,
0.0850391388,
-0.0499377772,
-0.0353244394,
-0.0365920737,
-0.0325813368,
0.0474126153,
-0.0320944637,
-0.0239422787,
-0.0329760537,
-0.0318533145,
-0.0318906009,
-0.0285196956,
0.0158056505,
-0.0254511908,
-0.0242777057,
0.0118962945,
0.0068078842,
-0.044789169,
0.0170869809,
0.0331155658,
-0.0045871311,
0.028381018,
0.0200882964,
-0.0073114345,
-0.0058815884,
-0.0217785556,
-0.0096108858,
-0.047935728,
0.0327909291,
-0.017300928,
0.0561711751,
0.0623036996,
-0.0170629825,
-0.0535750203,
-0.0591562018,
0.0389704891,
-0.0047840378,
0.0198337436,
0.0524912141,
-0.012892697,
0.0165400393,
-0.0052740327,
0.0252644978,
-0.0503573008,
0.0354131162,
-0.0419969857,
-0.0368835032,
0.0123153301,
0.0320750177,
0.0147935832,
0.0049652089,
0.0041610468,
0.028587969,
-0.0105301812,
-0.0009736055,
0.0742694661,
-0.0103737814,
-0.0208882634,
0.041520156,
0.0425300375,
0.0729677752,
0.0071072383,
-0.0357248783,
0.0163246263,
0.0069022332,
-0.0193037353,
-0.0237524081,
-0.0392274931,
-0.0541215353,
-0.0081019932,
0.0501354188,
-0.0323128402,
0.1098856181,
-0.0262859948,
-0.0630581006,
-0.0220685564,
-0.0227856599,
0.0997012332,
0.0299866516,
0.0218357984,
-0.031493634,
0.0170303695,
-0.0232610963,
-0.0579190068,
-0.033553008,
0.0120675843,
0.0028122009,
-0.0658926293,
0.0421807542,
-0.0219442509,
-0.029416604,
-0.0480853505,
0.0354998857,
-0.0471838377,
-0.0136837289,
0.0178519413,
-0.0388747752,
0.0079257656,
0.0409481376,
0.0103749195,
0.0225232728,
0.0381729715,
-0.0237874612,
0.0124622816,
-0.0277049262,
0.0445835963,
-0.041995056,
0.0829417557,
-0.0427435189,
0.024965262,
-5.267153618e-33,
-0.0399749354,
0.0131502869,
0.0109041138,
-0.0046195216,
0.0567933321,
0.0053925081,
-0.0408967175,
-0.0091783507,
0.0415347628,
-0.0157359522,
0.0657325312,
0.0247998815,
0.0233190171,
-0.0471811108,
-0.0171243194,
-0.005273323,
0.0575890467,
0.0272363871,
-0.0300511848,
0.0107517717,
-0.0312742218,
-0.0766864866,
0.0454173796,
0.027639864,
-0.0019583954,
0.0225851629,
-0.0252527706,
0.0454379953,
-0.1068421528,
0.0241546519,
0.0008454914,
-0.0194853358,
-0.0773701295,
0.0339716971,
0.0647310838,
-0.0147558022,
-0.0244239084,
0.0147308046,
0.0265646316,
-0.0388528556,
0.0029964154,
0.0334210321,
-0.018436227,
0.0396031514,
-0.0208800621,
-0.0241701305,
-0.0146964323,
0.0578518175,
0.0230522696,
-0.0489861704,
-0.0177444294,
0.0004547652,
0.0113571389,
0.0164748356,
0.010161506,
-0.0663279742,
-0.0462482907,
-0.0674476624,
0.0269768313,
-0.0111212423,
0.0330605954,
-0.076100722,
0.040889632,
-0.0232307781,
0.0143079283,
0.0047859801,
0.0906131417,
0.0155071905,
-0.0300890338,
-0.0153772365,
-0.0041225539,
0.0176205579,
0.0174031947,
0.0407929085,
-0.0040537524,
-0.0515681058,
-0.0253855567,
-0.0150913019,
0.0758833289,
0.0396305546,
0.0263189021,
-0.0202920642,
-0.0510729104,
-0.0477930754,
0.0486168154,
0.0200127065,
-0.0183315035,
0.0350284763,
-0.0107623963,
0.0796564668,
-0.0803650469,
0.0297189597,
0.0243626535,
-0.0545494258,
0.0119423037,
0.0028879636,
0.053433869,
-0.0338568427,
-0.0106304241,
-0.0178053342,
0.0573759638,
-0.0089945281,
0.0048753484,
-0.0420555621,
-0.0006779695,
0.0118406005,
-0.0185093582,
0.0484614819,
-0.0093841814,
0.0274653696,
-0.0331151597,
-0.0218550321,
0.0015212115,
-0.0089707542,
-0.0061610565,
0.0381179303,
-0.0451632291,
0.0366923921,
-0.0241687931,
0.013377659,
-0.0524311587,
0.0369330086,
0.0144890184,
0.0639790297,
-0.012718237,
-0.0431652069,
-0.0080578672,
0.0037284659,
0.00886718,
0.0044940487,
-0.0048385197,
0.0121115968,
2.602e-7,
0.0091726081,
-0.0136959581,
-0.0047306176,
0.0693853199,
0.0113472175,
-0.0132792033,
0.000720521,
0.0081066582,
-0.0293404106,
-0.0380948819,
-0.0018870785,
-0.0253597759,
0.0202008747,
0.0084878439,
0.0062305438,
0.0147259394,
-0.0390176624,
-0.025796162,
-0.0198395438,
-0.0113508217,
0.0133743482,
-0.0303524863,
0.048614569,
0.0271502025,
0.0095360084,
-0.0024805106,
0.0184317045,
0.0620413087,
0.0298183803,
-0.0051972633,
-0.0531598181,
-0.0316525251,
0.0504833013,
0.0179975014,
0.004874907,
-0.0005136258,
0.0029363362,
0.038577348,
0.0266677719,
0.0010823105,
-0.1055565551,
-0.0414317325,
0.0019100751,
-0.0010479647,
0.0153854182,
0.0403134823,
0.0135218007,
-0.0523314402,
-0.0126060378,
-0.0127692642,
0.0353250057,
0.0284809452,
0.0445582196,
-0.0289191678,
-0.0448457226,
0.0491331518,
0.0319550857,
-0.0053587537,
-0.0226707533,
0.0458704941,
0.0250537135,
-0.0395926908,
0.0390876941,
-0.0217750613,
-0.0564717725,
-0.015660055,
0.0022430241,
2.117249915e-34,
0.0051428443,
0.0167383142,
0.0345481001,
0.0264743883,
0.0302266181,
0.0332289487,
-0.0216141902,
-0.0808529556,
0.0220168121,
0.0299488027,
-0.0478884466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08176v1 | Towards Mitigating ChatGPT's Negative Impact on Education: Optimizing Question Design through Bloom's Taxonomy | 2023-03-31T00:01:59 | 2023-03-31T00:01:59 | Saber Elsayed | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | The popularity of generative text AI tools in answering questions has led to
concerns regarding their potential negative impact on students' academic
performance and the challenges that educators face in evaluating student
learning. To address these concerns, this paper introduces an evolutionary
approach that aims to identify the best set of Bloom's taxonomy keywords to
generate questions that these tools have low confidence in answering. The
effectiveness of this approach is evaluated through a case study that uses
questions from a Data Structures and Representation course being taught at the
University of New South Wales in Canberra, Australia. The results demonstrate
that the optimization algorithm is able to find keywords from different
cognitive levels to create questions that ChatGPT has low confidence in
answering. This study is a step forward to offer valuable insights for
educators seeking to create more effective questions that promote critical
thinking among students. | [
0.0278918911,
-0.0448600575,
-0.0524740517,
0.0148982545,
-0.061714232,
0.002091686,
0.0216714479,
-0.0069031585,
0.0373049043,
-0.0341906734,
0.0377347246,
-0.0349598229,
-0.0446139611,
0.0513405241,
0.005976913,
-0.0518858135,
0.0369658954,
0.0069492077,
0.0148541154,
0.0132175693,
-0.0021426589,
0.0006150068,
-0.022032382,
0.0544096641,
-0.0161596816,
-0.0277061388,
-0.0261136442,
-0.0272831935,
0.0132286977,
-0.0160624813,
0.0164130609,
0.0518394597,
-0.0476938039,
0.0293113105,
0.0000020894,
-0.0612525865,
-0.0462581739,
0.0015922626,
-0.0153897172,
0.0047085197,
0.0622572862,
0.1305545419,
0.0036771097,
0.0510749854,
-0.0629679188,
0.0266704932,
0.0314940065,
0.0146051906,
0.0378962718,
0.0208216943,
0.01370015,
-0.0594681986,
0.0359083936,
0.0125904474,
0.0603192672,
-0.0063750185,
0.0081117554,
0.0489942394,
0.0412043259,
0.0244790651,
-0.0327898264,
0.0191858727,
-0.0074001406,
-0.0441834815,
0.0289018024,
-0.0140214795,
-0.0576493628,
-0.0301522128,
0.0461198352,
0.0309133865,
0.0229916964,
-0.0157556683,
-0.0078466916,
-0.0119647579,
0.0640707463,
0.044593025,
-0.0582949258,
0.0055617429,
-0.0598211847,
-0.0403085873,
0.0022907243,
-0.0276731011,
-0.0413932279,
0.0183061939,
0.0075894529,
-0.0293036643,
0.0059302715,
-0.0155931106,
-0.0072473818,
-0.0030056783,
-0.0283084847,
-0.024533391,
-0.0010336572,
0.0389500074,
0.0012031449,
0.0211174749,
0.008636171,
-0.0310868006,
0.0104624508,
-0.0322126672,
-0.0241259411,
0.0582959168,
0.0484913737,
-0.0103636347,
-0.0003551799,
0.0381311439,
0.0202542674,
0.0224102736,
-0.0518839955,
0.0261722859,
-0.0835788772,
-0.0433459394,
-0.0508258492,
0.0521816947,
0.0268193483,
0.0122352773,
-0.0300809778,
0.0249865595,
-0.0078563131,
-0.0308308322,
-0.0217086058,
0.0429831557,
-0.0079055838,
0.0145212607,
-0.0293232575,
-0.0175969824,
-0.034043707,
0.0047641811,
0.0089792507,
-0.0344849713,
0.0025344638,
0.0274588447,
0.0349314325,
0.027164029,
0.0008918744,
0.0318650156,
-0.0299481377,
-0.0086062243,
-0.0444275364,
-0.0458117388,
0.0140851233,
0.0334377997,
0.0597687587,
-0.0565088242,
-0.0254274439,
0.0008708363,
-0.0224494953,
0.0060060527,
0.00167646,
0.0417660736,
0.0127705224,
0.0091060959,
-0.0322571211,
-0.0061325813,
0.0673217103,
0.0369513072,
-0.001198794,
0.0364180282,
0.026844915,
0.0206822585,
0.0192508232,
-0.0505925342,
0.0396772251,
-0.0151457619,
0.0060869907,
-0.0110468995,
0.0324861705,
0.0239485037,
-0.0104765017,
0.0325650051,
-0.0566524528,
0.0395569541,
-0.0178772025,
0.0418658964,
0.0140731297,
0.0549056567,
-0.0088056596,
0.1075286791,
0.0193518884,
0.0194761697,
0.0086966548,
0.0480585545,
0.0126584284,
0.0295832567,
-0.0267997403,
-0.0114830239,
-0.0091746906,
-0.0044255075,
0.006308578,
-0.0780113861,
-0.0000863328,
0.0519399941,
0.0023395075,
0.0286404435,
-0.0035299491,
0.018529091,
-0.0232922602,
-0.0370872691,
-0.016867334,
-0.0436381213,
0.007492878,
-0.1112790257,
0.0311046392,
0.0174202006,
0.0774778202,
-0.0361217335,
-0.0983608663,
0.0013166202,
0.0075429645,
0.0600023419,
0.0383520424,
-0.0295211207,
-0.0887447447,
-0.0203146264,
-0.0202434529,
-0.0167405102,
-0.0123117808,
-0.017546488,
0.0004900653,
0.0082497532,
0.0122573432,
-0.0326177813,
-0.0465265214,
0.0405661948,
0.0037422371,
-0.0538683347,
-0.0147303855,
-0.010787731,
0.0072146212,
0.0000743901,
-0.0219333358,
0.0480294824,
-0.0069349227,
0.0018402665,
-0.0422885232,
-0.0113968058,
-0.0127123781,
0.0320363604,
0.0384846628,
-0.0625812486,
0.004799569,
-0.051297579,
-0.0292468835,
-0.0236775558,
0.0452735424,
-0.0486661792,
0.0556694493,
-0.0122078173,
0.0028478969,
-0.0406994224,
-0.0389429219,
-0.0425533503,
0.0627489612,
0.0494291633,
0.0113436123,
-0.0551697649,
-0.0086855441,
0.0592062473,
0.0159778185,
0.0118924091,
0.0204859227,
-0.022654308,
0.0275201481,
0.052088622,
0.0358135551,
-0.0723379999,
-0.001470939,
-0.0555255711,
-0.0225537252,
0.0151964501,
0.0416207016,
0.0235262178,
-0.0381265283,
-0.0424250625,
0.0246573687,
-0.0605457202,
0.0189463552,
-0.0134627977,
-0.0197293609,
0.019772023,
-0.0119524729,
0.0191228837,
-0.0118651455,
0.0098458743,
-0.0557754561,
0.0121438187,
0.0871372595,
0.0212663244,
0.0047670491,
0.0256419647,
-0.0313073881,
-0.0214699786,
0.0167371761,
0.0021569554,
0.0198902469,
-0.0077716229,
0.0411266536,
0.0454538688,
0.059344098,
-0.0189203713,
0.0087222783,
-0.0079602161,
-0.0256514587,
0.0255875494,
-0.0152758528,
-0.0063385349,
0.0346122161,
-0.0375282131,
0.0059697116,
0.0039395564,
-0.0013160526,
-0.0425514095,
-0.0194027722,
0.0940595865,
-0.0370017029,
0.0182759389,
-0.0904697254,
-0.0540013127,
-0.0017442374,
0.0330045819,
0.0048021474,
-0.0128910979,
0.0677222759,
0.0245287362,
0.0160707626,
-0.1229887009,
0.0412264317,
-0.0369491056,
0.0410328656,
-0.0193840899,
0.0239877999,
0.0431535505,
0.0179853979,
-0.1084316522,
0.0318843909,
0.0543511696,
-0.0388395004,
-0.0044445279,
-0.0406305939,
-0.0263931248,
0.0020216883,
-0.004842022,
-0.0563186593,
0.0385703109,
0.0302169751,
-0.0106915375,
0.0523689426,
0.0117153777,
-0.029713029,
-0.0194305535,
0.0094433287,
-0.0126314433,
-0.0338642448,
-0.0328442864,
0.0239980463,
0.0440237746,
0.0354729556,
-0.0064949775,
0.0297285337,
0.0104994215,
0.0426864661,
0.0654831454,
-0.0256047975,
-0.0126642687,
0.0271610897,
-0.0220987871,
0.0034592915,
-0.0629854351,
-0.005578035,
0.0026132828,
-0.0123789916,
-0.0589232519,
-0.0530995652,
0.047816731,
0.0661364496,
-0.0198133178,
-0.0132572604,
-0.0687355623,
0.0097404169,
0.0094875488,
0.0582238622,
-0.0582016483,
0.0112338988,
-0.0295446608,
0.0412110761,
-0.0565475598,
-0.0356620587,
0.0106107732,
-0.1016924009,
0.0260481276,
-0.0233883448,
-0.0396210253,
0.0412483849,
-0.0166317541,
-0.0199166425,
0.0227687992,
-0.0130993351,
-0.0195672233,
0.013945329,
0.0530077182,
0.0609375201,
0.0017609542,
-0.0059528328,
-0.0099960789,
0.0223731138,
0.0009864646,
0.0493802279,
0.0433482304,
-0.0250554588,
-0.0163961966,
0.0650557876,
0.0032820904,
-0.0186833795,
-0.0034243711,
-0.0202542059,
0.0191328619,
0.0234979093,
-0.0549423732,
0.0229445957,
-0.0044775037,
-0.0108544007,
0.0771697015,
0.0616658293,
-0.0070745349,
-0.0430670567,
-0.0835339502,
0.0260451417,
-0.0186673868,
0.0320484899,
0.0535009094,
-0.0356129743,
0.0161276441,
-0.0681936443,
0.0466201231,
-0.0545694605,
-0.0773715824,
0.006845457,
0.0089366874,
0.0266040526,
-0.0458479412,
-0.0261691734,
0.0437066108,
-0.0019982804,
0.0042104116,
-0.0234510899,
0.0134188924,
0.0232497621,
-0.0448843129,
0.0039192503,
0.0152174504,
-0.0492930971,
-0.033345893,
-0.0308694169,
-0.0048429244,
-0.0373568609,
-0.0441957004,
0.0269656666,
-0.0002976185,
-0.0395649299,
0.0233456809,
0.0395906754,
0.0196300447,
-0.0691445917,
0.0086186696,
-0.0202432424,
0.0352947712,
0.0494341813,
0.067268692,
-0.0195454452,
-0.0494248979,
-0.0045770067,
-0.0005060525,
-0.027631009,
0.0066376589,
0.0382250026,
0.0095151709,
0.0393651426,
-0.011179911,
0.0665889382,
0.0447148681,
0.0781834722,
-0.0167115387,
-0.0410509557,
-0.0218605623,
-0.0060409312,
-0.0051982943,
-0.0024292907,
-0.0250245444,
0.0162395705,
-0.0061227875,
-0.0017548036,
-0.0038337139,
0.0126433494,
0.0118577136,
-0.0425591953,
-0.0015171123,
0.0131169828,
0.0490657166,
0.0270505995,
0.0287238564,
0.0002204505,
-0.011080564,
-0.0059002209,
-0.0127782337,
0.0122818444,
0.062301524,
-0.0072604604,
0.0682801902,
0.0247742254,
0.0060430123,
0.0331849121,
0.019957317,
-0.0402566418,
-0.0697756037,
-0.0368194319,
0.0481227711,
-0.0217455886,
0.0530885682,
-0.0645753145,
-0.0178647395,
-0.0190105475,
0.0028092701,
0.0004187025,
0.0019383937,
-0.0344514698,
0.007997442,
0.0156900678,
0.0033806153,
-0.0545015261,
0.0299752019,
-0.0608426519,
0.0198209714,
0.0055687963,
-0.010819112,
-0.0174129959,
-0.0287487227,
-0.0202923622,
0.0311899371,
0.0699790642,
0.0374407731,
-0.0789718479,
-0.0603991859,
-0.0251257401,
0.0258013532,
0.0598530248,
-0.0226944871,
0.0463117659,
0.0429787152,
-0.0108438376,
-0.0011195175,
0.0100588817,
0.0654777288,
-0.118710503,
-0.0188050605,
-0.0106731439,
-5.842722672e-33,
-0.0284728035,
-0.079954274,
0.0287820548,
0.0444370694,
0.0040876199,
0.0069305599,
-0.0199451335,
0.0603058711,
-0.0380563363,
-0.0080087697,
-0.0061249118,
0.0238926951,
-0.0280587003,
0.0007538296,
0.0139489435,
-0.008118174,
-0.0154071916,
-0.0078940801,
-0.0157029685,
0.0368398018,
0.0018690631,
-0.0232922081,
0.0080763726,
-0.0144664878,
0.0250499845,
-0.0318714716,
0.0137453107,
0.0123750186,
-0.0569528416,
0.0220893081,
-0.0181726161,
0.056994617,
0.0056096129,
-0.0124776401,
0.0203659832,
0.0214970242,
-0.0004631603,
-0.0922338516,
0.0200934298,
-0.0447752662,
-0.0013178346,
-0.0467654541,
0.0286788624,
0.0207234658,
-0.0329616368,
-0.0048287278,
0.0515792705,
0.0110375024,
-0.0134311421,
-0.0335423425,
-0.0728836283,
0.0170442089,
-0.051971104,
0.0272269417,
-0.0430280529,
0.05196869,
0.0270478483,
-0.0121452585,
0.0071001011,
0.0466718413,
0.050062675,
-0.0065785772,
0.0383679233,
0.0102257635,
-0.004067732,
0.0253131464,
0.0343922339,
0.0300827734,
-0.0253962558,
-0.0269380268,
0.0261999033,
0.0071351519,
0.1038071662,
0.0758470297,
0.0311293658,
-0.0195207559,
-0.0572691113,
0.0582424849,
0.0320948251,
-0.0324315168,
-0.038688425,
-0.0348026641,
-0.0447736531,
-0.0272161625,
-0.0284549668,
0.0040911995,
-0.0204315484,
-0.0144743435,
0.0159101337,
-0.0744790882,
-0.0563336052,
-0.0281661153,
-0.0246048197,
-0.0036003722,
0.0532965846,
-0.064696379,
-0.0176990293,
0.0222240537,
-0.0110028498,
0.0357920788,
0.0105627216,
0.007963256,
0.0130568156,
-0.0227759443,
0.0449389853,
0.0233953781,
0.008786465,
-0.0196402185,
-0.016970532,
-0.0136124436,
-0.0265230257,
0.0170173459,
0.0234362558,
-0.020718053,
0.0010889516,
0.0555421486,
0.0233062934,
-0.0307221655,
0.0705014691,
0.0660532936,
-0.0333748348,
-0.0229690168,
-0.0211535655,
-0.02727874,
-0.0113776941,
0.0089410823,
0.0013423272,
0.0106892493,
-0.0014462589,
-0.0740885586,
-0.0296977498,
-0.0060575814,
2.768e-7,
0.0888478905,
0.0675110072,
-0.0076921056,
-0.0063216602,
-0.0016613521,
0.0146354465,
0.0406043045,
-0.0308798235,
0.0473525822,
0.023971023,
0.0224861968,
0.0030374567,
-0.0123128649,
0.0411840975,
-0.0791257992,
-0.0428747535,
-0.0242642313,
-0.0095662158,
-0.030367665,
0.0462939553,
0.0909826756,
-0.0156925041,
-0.0147896176,
-0.0107710045,
-0.0223014466,
-0.0432174169,
0.0032640053,
0.0167489909,
0.0348945335,
0.0626285896,
-0.0123231243,
0.018328432,
0.0295053329,
0.0331926234,
-0.0095114606,
-0.0283581689,
-0.0031631631,
-0.0407885723,
-0.0007314242,
-0.0211722851,
0.0319251083,
0.0187462531,
0.0349239931,
-0.0749722421,
0.0545475557,
-0.0226754248,
-0.0222944263,
0.006946417,
-0.0317903869,
-0.0185991284,
-0.0148111722,
-0.013489956,
0.0013694972,
0.0112728011,
-0.0120927757,
-0.024306545,
0.0191417821,
-0.0170103684,
0.0311557036,
-0.0247393698,
-0.0299732108,
-0.0542629957,
-0.0391541459,
0.0257530883,
0.0024036779,
0.0286655817,
0.0177824739,
2.44321381e-34,
0.0289089009,
-0.0081546176,
0.0537471808,
0.0047876053,
0.0226752125,
0.0293931346,
0.0478775874,
-0.0012610275,
0.0045074141,
-0.0307410099,
-0.0243335161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17728v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17728v2 | Evaluation of GPT and BERT-based models on identifying protein-protein interactions in biomedical text | 2023-03-30T22:06:10 | 2023-12-13T00:18:46 | Hasin Rehana, Nur Bengisu Çam, Mert Basmaci, Jie Zheng, Christianah Jemiyo, Yongqun He, Arzucan Özgür, Junguk Hur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Detecting protein-protein interactions (PPIs) is crucial for understanding
genetic mechanisms, disease pathogenesis, and drug design. However, with the
fast-paced growth of biomedical literature, there is a growing need for
automated and accurate extraction of PPIs to facilitate scientific knowledge
discovery. Pre-trained language models, such as generative pre-trained
transformers (GPT) and bidirectional encoder representations from transformers
(BERT), have shown promising results in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. We evaluated the performance of PPI identification of multiple GPT and
BERT models using three manually curated gold-standard corpora: Learning
Language in Logic (LLL) with 164 PPIs in 77 sentences, Human Protein Reference
Database with 163 PPIs in 145 sentences, and Interaction Extraction Performance
Assessment with 335 PPIs in 486 sentences. BERT-based models achieved the best
overall performance, with BioBERT achieving the highest recall (91.95%) and
F1-score (86.84%) and PubMedBERT achieving the highest precision (85.25%).
Interestingly, despite not being explicitly trained for biomedical texts, GPT-4
achieved commendable performance, comparable to the top-performing BERT models.
It achieved a precision of 88.37%, a recall of 85.14%, and an F1-score of
86.49% on the LLL dataset. These results suggest that GPT models can
effectively detect PPIs from text data, offering promising avenues for
application in biomedical literature mining. Further research could explore how
these models might be fine-tuned for even more specialized tasks within the
biomedical domain. | [
0.0367798023,
0.0638020411,
0.0074773338,
-0.001388367,
-0.0100562181,
0.0048993248,
-0.0095379911,
0.0297066327,
0.0294759534,
-0.0381396189,
-0.013824394,
-0.008331025,
0.0063557946,
0.0490094796,
-0.0099887578,
0.0041600815,
0.0245794766,
0.0616611168,
0.0367833227,
0.0100334277,
-0.0000460595,
0.0228251647,
0.0079430714,
0.0166103244,
0.0367708579,
-0.0108384546,
0.0339316763,
-0.030434493,
0.0609887503,
-0.0421666801,
-0.01004883,
0.0398468301,
0.0070013884,
-0.003703987,
0.0000020045,
-0.0591697879,
-0.0466535985,
0.0322916768,
0.0198696572,
0.0165173337,
-0.0172477905,
-0.0338448472,
0.0036333692,
0.018108625,
-0.0154689597,
-0.040668048,
0.0338953771,
0.0790500641,
0.0165858734,
0.0560465641,
-0.0198998693,
-0.051399108,
0.0737394318,
-0.002139139,
0.0070151691,
-0.0209665559,
0.0796717033,
-0.0220593717,
0.0015023551,
-0.0237859208,
0.0281289183,
-0.0119155645,
-0.0152865881,
0.0147521542,
0.0113964425,
0.0604377985,
-0.0394305289,
-0.0167661924,
0.0135131525,
0.0688703582,
-0.0194569491,
-0.0533146374,
0.0162499957,
-0.0042008166,
-0.0249440782,
0.0634475499,
0.0027427757,
-0.0149094127,
-0.0419416539,
0.0485544503,
0.0314150378,
-0.0331438035,
0.0302641205,
-0.0066585424,
-0.0358486883,
0.0442699566,
0.0238791835,
-0.050356511,
-0.0084118349,
-0.0007802284,
-0.0464329459,
-0.0232485998,
0.0670620129,
0.0068017412,
0.0152489888,
0.0042028059,
0.0083546098,
-0.0784533769,
0.0472934991,
-0.0630733296,
-0.0351273417,
0.0167066213,
-0.0358452015,
0.0121742627,
-0.0163713582,
0.0098932497,
-0.0244652946,
0.030949289,
-0.0022785752,
0.0194401685,
-0.0624856725,
-0.0118162101,
-0.0325881727,
0.0415832363,
-0.0192991775,
-0.0150952274,
-0.0509258844,
0.00495082,
0.0205817185,
-0.0161645692,
0.0204781648,
0.0002082591,
-0.0296903588,
0.0164316222,
-0.0082909912,
0.0322971493,
0.0022231366,
-0.0102926679,
-0.0597066283,
-0.0537571944,
-0.0262117721,
-0.0187007599,
0.0400802456,
-0.0541499518,
0.0015303097,
0.0970799923,
-0.0086517204,
-0.0522964709,
-0.0046310304,
-0.0120509835,
0.0023069284,
-0.0222774819,
-0.0126652094,
-0.0231977105,
0.053533677,
0.0294649359,
-0.0189393666,
-0.0244849827,
0.0163166504,
-0.000545371,
-0.0528334305,
0.0544393659,
-0.0602784753,
-0.0356803685,
0.0076303943,
0.0025505715,
0.0026678282,
-0.0104563888,
0.0468826219,
-0.0498816557,
-0.0040353225,
-0.0262916666,
0.0165999476,
-0.0012355194,
0.0163752735,
-0.0628759861,
0.0341909602,
0.0241216458,
0.0180865861,
0.0212131031,
-0.024191929,
0.0268657375,
-0.026763685,
-0.0009189282,
0.0142153576,
0.0693349317,
0.0159093179,
0.0542038828,
0.0153860608,
0.0419546701,
0.030908443,
-0.0051234202,
-0.0086695347,
-0.0300482698,
-0.0439377651,
0.019391872,
-0.0163787156,
0.0237558018,
0.0168029778,
-0.0143784881,
-0.0262126774,
-0.0008079226,
0.0071906159,
-0.0427620709,
0.0707727671,
-0.0138819236,
-0.0865891129,
0.0679938123,
0.058380153,
-0.0630072504,
0.0336512104,
-0.0241174549,
-0.0086918082,
0.0309692025,
0.0627648979,
-0.0662560537,
-0.019047128,
-0.0106143169,
-0.0730339661,
0.0298194308,
-0.0185093414,
0.0066183647,
0.0230521541,
-0.0120717539,
0.0160225425,
0.0073824716,
0.0228005275,
-0.0163828414,
-0.0147764469,
0.0220181588,
-0.0153863505,
-0.0154071832,
0.007838686,
0.0472538061,
-0.0317598172,
-0.0269354396,
-0.00689848,
-0.0099787731,
0.0506919175,
0.0267312601,
-0.0223830231,
0.0376488715,
0.0571162812,
-0.0487703457,
-0.0400660932,
0.0100957006,
0.0049728737,
-0.0547168367,
0.0383663625,
-0.0148131996,
-0.0268469099,
0.0062169018,
-0.053078942,
-0.0094773984,
0.0106745185,
-0.0324926861,
0.084540084,
-0.0206060987,
-0.010947465,
0.0070691854,
-0.0049040848,
-0.0225223005,
0.055627428,
0.0080017336,
0.0029107218,
0.0061317426,
-0.0503508784,
0.0628570542,
-0.0061255014,
-0.0004064873,
0.0201494638,
0.0025752233,
-0.0136398254,
0.0444249697,
-0.0109413331,
-0.0132163856,
-0.0163518973,
-0.0545315444,
0.016902782,
0.0135861496,
0.0658471212,
0.0185240563,
-0.0229969509,
0.0117324824,
0.0092738979,
-0.0266415849,
-0.033604186,
-0.0056974157,
-0.0093554119,
0.0434209369,
0.0146030532,
-0.0191279147,
-0.03987794,
0.0088790078,
-0.0844753757,
0.0667866766,
0.0483890846,
-0.0324415378,
0.0113880411,
0.0048720427,
-0.0018920598,
0.0326861627,
-0.0017570734,
-0.0501137637,
0.0029033537,
0.0203817356,
0.041423548,
0.018456351,
0.0060045435,
0.0426635891,
0.035622213,
-0.0042681177,
-0.0055433721,
0.0107285585,
-0.0687934682,
-0.0071443194,
-0.0282904804,
-0.0192765072,
0.0349033736,
0.0729868039,
-0.0055608721,
-0.0156142684,
-0.0501826443,
-0.0159732327,
0.036688,
0.0081928018,
0.0058304891,
-0.0343110152,
-0.0024661419,
0.025928678,
0.008461915,
-0.0083121043,
0.1037694141,
-0.0247677993,
0.0197762102,
-0.0905369148,
0.018840177,
-0.014243423,
0.004808866,
0.0364328176,
0.0072944774,
0.0085674915,
-0.0271789636,
0.0265639052,
-0.0012682731,
0.0069082519,
-0.0393516459,
0.0204042196,
-0.0362305865,
0.0313854218,
0.007819877,
-0.0279329326,
-0.0222162176,
0.0526114292,
-0.0357972458,
0.0235198271,
0.012781362,
-0.048803214,
-0.0548676066,
0.0300153866,
-0.0163882896,
0.0230496377,
-0.0006691649,
0.0011473421,
-0.02630434,
0.0180297773,
0.0411122628,
-0.0611943603,
-0.0269050989,
-0.0143935233,
-0.0058278101,
0.0430463254,
-0.0387407951,
-0.0138537912,
-0.0243826564,
-0.0051666168,
0.0147443386,
-0.0581984036,
0.0319401287,
0.0134620611,
-0.0126303155,
-0.0380940922,
-0.0166575629,
0.1133623049,
0.0360908583,
-0.0505395196,
-0.0111881439,
0.0074138655,
-0.0489797667,
-0.0486847274,
0.0252390634,
-0.0732409656,
-0.0401473679,
-0.0136813521,
-0.017987065,
-0.0176439118,
-0.0492015928,
0.0223251618,
-0.0425325371,
0.011998374,
0.0045063728,
-0.0142731695,
-0.0490239784,
-0.1060538068,
-0.0399937257,
-0.0714497566,
0.0064428663,
-0.0221076626,
-0.0044382806,
0.0292368177,
-0.0060071456,
-0.0407006368,
-0.0789623186,
0.0118236952,
-0.0328072719,
-0.0082901223,
0.0835229903,
0.0433330983,
-0.0205132943,
-0.0240013078,
0.0015041996,
-0.0237524007,
-0.0345990211,
-0.0221990123,
0.0707599595,
-0.0213139188,
0.0057985936,
-0.0608976893,
0.0207941346,
-0.0588846803,
-0.0448969975,
-0.0338135697,
0.0875408351,
-0.0184259843,
-0.0311943535,
-0.0361585133,
-0.0226109028,
-0.0331567191,
0.0599845015,
0.0059856614,
-0.0117682153,
-0.0611979291,
0.0069356081,
0.0763694197,
-0.0348269083,
-0.0240018591,
-0.0062311026,
-0.0135345366,
-0.0480628088,
-0.0314465426,
-0.0256938506,
0.0364681482,
-0.0536950231,
0.0213479158,
0.0319980383,
0.0753207952,
-0.0155770509,
-0.0618320145,
0.0595211498,
0.0525440611,
-0.0078415349,
-0.0467388146,
-0.0408675708,
0.0828177333,
0.0196839459,
-0.047084678,
0.0276511125,
-0.0001940937,
-0.0533717386,
-0.0432792604,
0.0284701008,
0.0145587698,
0.006318971,
0.007196838,
0.0007986339,
0.0146820378,
0.0641288236,
-0.0235412493,
-0.052820269,
-0.0161610935,
-0.0168246794,
-0.0020526962,
-0.015881259,
-0.0136594595,
0.0125620915,
-0.0045903404,
0.0334276706,
-0.0057034157,
-0.0494258814,
0.0739616677,
0.0189284515,
0.0966859907,
-0.001255566,
-0.0213009864,
-0.0577329472,
0.0253032688,
-0.0319693014,
0.0395245291,
-0.03703155,
0.0084937932,
0.0488566309,
0.0172221921,
-0.0391754396,
0.0169498716,
-0.0770230219,
0.0124882804,
-0.0113036353,
0.0434051491,
0.0066631911,
0.0048455475,
0.0523811355,
-0.0568299368,
-0.0126323532,
-0.0525373667,
0.0011943401,
0.0016622804,
-0.0076006525,
0.034642864,
0.0283902325,
0.0393396541,
0.0194401219,
0.0313269831,
-0.0496437103,
0.0233692378,
-0.0297565609,
-0.0200131498,
0.0364926085,
-0.0183038339,
0.059389405,
-0.0265463851,
-0.0043408419,
-0.0173596386,
0.0494969077,
-0.0131076397,
0.0125824781,
0.0326647945,
0.0071096951,
-0.0512679145,
-0.0655415282,
0.0791450664,
0.0184949152,
0.0710587874,
0.0073888493,
-0.0698722377,
0.0020432556,
-0.0343192704,
0.0026530379,
0.0165042765,
-0.0661396533,
0.0365838371,
-0.0431872457,
-0.021404827,
0.0236342363,
-0.0114580393,
0.0008328922,
-0.0006765654,
0.0322764553,
0.0332016684,
0.0177450012,
-0.0806609094,
0.0001599278,
0.0389593914,
-0.0200098716,
-0.0388299115,
-0.0304175206,
-6.221592583e-33,
-0.0092505096,
-0.0468322672,
-0.0026680303,
0.011766294,
-0.0013800209,
0.0001396341,
-0.0511060171,
-0.0304674488,
0.0030817357,
0.0635163411,
0.0084939441,
0.0035378609,
-0.017822301,
0.0055507789,
-0.0067264969,
-0.0140922945,
0.0314385854,
0.0251012426,
0.0196600687,
-0.0109046949,
0.0092860181,
0.0831770971,
0.0693148151,
-0.0632326081,
-0.0413178764,
-0.0054441588,
0.0257530026,
0.0025406631,
0.0024903668,
0.0242563542,
-0.0389778204,
0.0088224635,
0.0163039286,
0.0068439408,
0.0262020566,
0.0065074372,
-0.0728240833,
-0.0214455426,
0.0186342038,
-0.0040410371,
-0.0360843353,
0.0044522001,
0.0513261706,
0.0037692587,
-0.0212277602,
-0.0119872922,
0.0643813089,
-0.0109412791,
-0.0288046096,
-0.0274382401,
-0.0814115778,
0.0328805111,
0.0081885327,
0.0251151547,
0.0410316214,
0.0082476698,
0.002481394,
0.0612349771,
-0.0133600933,
-0.0378472097,
0.050127048,
0.0209129527,
-0.0034388192,
-0.0257079694,
0.0303854048,
0.0526774377,
-0.0211970117,
-0.0320982039,
0.0033197822,
-0.0056637307,
-0.0208419897,
0.0383898281,
0.0156862251,
-0.0070306417,
0.0557577163,
0.0243133791,
-0.1298894286,
0.0526498556,
-0.0193856284,
0.0180072393,
-0.026524771,
-0.0183995925,
0.0301430486,
0.0132575305,
-0.0048941602,
0.0228248015,
-0.0141457394,
-0.0447243862,
-0.0176035687,
-0.0449986979,
0.0055306684,
0.0342950337,
0.014350079,
-0.0110980282,
-0.0288545955,
0.0202655252,
0.0019752339,
-0.0236013606,
-0.0237546712,
0.0376074351,
-0.0480049811,
-0.0519957878,
0.0247502588,
-0.0325148441,
0.0314667784,
-0.0049807071,
0.0272927936,
-0.0290935449,
-0.0095694857,
0.0045419824,
-0.0386860631,
-0.0094996868,
0.0012425635,
0.0808376521,
-0.0058984128,
0.0769358128,
0.022944482,
0.0565399751,
0.0360239781,
0.0353810899,
-0.0051948708,
0.0452061705,
0.0160783529,
0.0162380114,
-0.0139411306,
-0.0390708707,
-0.0087011606,
0.0728904754,
-0.0051273438,
-0.0730180666,
-0.0179643799,
-0.0206706449,
2.906e-7,
0.1071204245,
0.0687689856,
0.0452645458,
0.0164898839,
0.0052800667,
0.0239346493,
-0.0134752765,
0.0338248201,
-0.0015494711,
0.007980084,
0.0408753753,
-0.0113100847,
0.0067856684,
0.0260053445,
-0.0406741686,
-0.0338925458,
-0.0823523253,
-0.0576415956,
-0.0491382219,
0.0124461474,
0.0748240277,
0.0506383441,
-0.0058992794,
0.0109737525,
0.0284013525,
-0.0100422269,
0.0631459057,
-0.0309047196,
0.0095953522,
0.0864869207,
-0.0307587497,
0.0065234024,
0.0060450272,
0.0427171588,
-0.0572857,
0.0006702321,
-0.0164526794,
0.0395900868,
-0.0559145659,
-0.0023178803,
0.068153739,
-0.0035729306,
0.0227031782,
-0.0216707103,
0.0304046739,
-0.0884769037,
-0.0518694632,
0.037898194,
-0.0334913507,
-0.0210868157,
0.0174781363,
0.0066589988,
0.0025725788,
0.0580049381,
0.0075444132,
0.0278328937,
-0.0024860064,
-0.0726593584,
0.0045191622,
0.0337650143,
-0.0419061445,
0.0044798297,
-0.0183984749,
-0.0263923127,
0.0370576605,
-0.0416812636,
0.0160683133,
2.774434828e-34,
0.0456877239,
-0.0125596197,
-0.0049806414,
0.0565551743,
0.0525965691,
-0.012033063,
-0.0030588587,
0.0182736125,
-0.047294803,
-0.0630231947,
0.0122316107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17710v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17710v2 | What Types of Questions Require Conversation to Answer? A Case Study of AskReddit Questions | 2023-03-30T21:05:22 | 2023-04-03T21:14:54 | Shih-Hong Huang, Chieh-Yang Huang, Ya-Fang Lin, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The proliferation of automated conversational systems such as chatbots,
spoken-dialogue systems, and smart speakers, has significantly impacted modern
digital life. However, these systems are primarily designed to provide answers
to well-defined questions rather than to support users in exploring complex,
ill-defined questions. In this paper, we aim to push the boundaries of
conversational systems by examining the types of nebulous, open-ended questions
that can best be answered through conversation. We first sampled 500 questions
from one million open-ended requests posted on AskReddit, and then recruited
online crowd workers to answer eight inquiries about these questions. We also
performed open coding to categorize the questions into 27 different domains. We
found that the issues people believe require conversation to resolve
satisfactorily are highly social and personal. Our work provides insights into
how future research could be geared to align with users' needs. | [
0.0884249508,
0.0341454297,
-0.0328371115,
-0.0008240924,
-0.0237682927,
-0.0182812735,
0.0085652079,
0.0238383114,
0.0045414218,
-0.0105165094,
0.0008807923,
-0.0086728586,
0.0252099205,
0.0336710811,
0.0068069845,
-0.0417468324,
-0.0348600373,
-0.0035322569,
0.0195467509,
0.0118084569,
0.0399931557,
-0.0157129504,
-0.0358722284,
0.0491903424,
-0.0108058648,
-0.0075633363,
-0.0257182047,
0.0045909523,
-0.0269782003,
-0.0008640567,
0.0306222942,
0.0699620247,
-0.0092047639,
-0.0038687373,
0.0000019919,
-0.0757377967,
0.0396016017,
-0.0150424661,
-0.0331002139,
-0.0481423587,
0.0156420842,
0.0550194271,
0.024662545,
0.0535373054,
-0.03016828,
0.014090945,
0.0726681426,
0.0389464684,
0.0364176705,
0.0360636525,
-0.0170229841,
-0.0033283019,
-0.0179524738,
-0.0041568992,
0.0436945595,
-0.0480723642,
0.0135255745,
0.0167680699,
0.0571673922,
0.0041847089,
0.0187091026,
0.012233506,
-0.0045512542,
-0.053562738,
0.0486845151,
0.0161636956,
-0.0572095513,
-0.0735297874,
0.0242577437,
0.1083630025,
0.0521566235,
-0.0198196042,
0.0009181209,
0.0120125841,
0.0137672629,
0.0181784984,
-0.0804063901,
-0.0053893612,
-0.0210814364,
-0.0343714803,
-0.0836639404,
0.0290053748,
0.0025267282,
-0.0000375213,
0.0408840105,
0.0177918188,
-0.0134664066,
0.0040928265,
-0.0025390545,
-0.0106236478,
0.0152960019,
-0.0825631991,
0.0131864194,
0.0199599881,
-0.0151528446,
-0.0099821286,
0.0180672724,
0.0158679895,
0.0689847991,
-0.0253692176,
-0.0276468638,
0.0142805111,
-0.000149358,
0.047925137,
0.0608824044,
-0.0361439884,
0.0008524346,
-0.0199400075,
-0.0278346147,
0.0037571497,
-0.024011679,
0.007328866,
-0.0540616624,
-0.0069558378,
-0.0349338837,
0.0250899382,
0.0405499004,
0.0358484387,
0.0111229802,
-0.0017013256,
-0.0115861176,
0.0231512524,
-0.0195949841,
0.0027017654,
-0.0472622477,
-0.0029425432,
-0.0969652757,
0.0188410487,
0.0015440787,
-0.065121077,
0.0131137632,
-0.0079534547,
0.0582072549,
0.0088582924,
0.0052541331,
0.0322840847,
0.0342212245,
-0.0060868398,
-0.0067892396,
-0.0581069402,
0.0087523824,
-0.018350495,
-0.0138207264,
-0.0514842868,
0.0307478625,
0.0333294719,
-0.0160941333,
0.0096987672,
0.026107166,
0.0441976711,
-0.0229759794,
0.0628615022,
-0.0450299531,
0.0150763486,
0.0788747072,
0.0393822901,
-0.0180053115,
0.0254941043,
0.0079189986,
0.0137270121,
0.1051828861,
-0.0103597874,
0.0963612199,
0.0080487411,
0.0058401199,
-0.0397322476,
0.0560740232,
0.062618494,
0.0028359725,
-0.0138698258,
-0.0158395674,
0.0348630585,
-0.014665694,
-0.0409797989,
0.0474445261,
0.0906113535,
-0.0702339187,
0.046181079,
-0.0073183249,
0.0242978279,
0.0366294459,
0.0066857827,
0.0180433374,
0.018766962,
-0.0302117784,
-0.0492098741,
0.0333672017,
-0.0019780323,
-0.0271263476,
-0.0331166685,
-0.0210755803,
0.0027128372,
0.0774879158,
0.0230359565,
0.000986979,
0.0106402608,
-0.0141852442,
-0.0090103475,
0.0010446537,
-0.0507245846,
-0.0245575365,
-0.0437190458,
0.0368494429,
0.0137958769,
0.0394718982,
-0.0359998532,
-0.0281033833,
-0.0154523309,
0.0664146543,
0.0207838714,
0.0712120309,
0.0075207865,
-0.0148636913,
-0.0223978367,
0.0144320093,
0.0135083608,
-0.0006506783,
-0.0213805512,
0.0082782246,
-0.0030905011,
-0.0282437243,
-0.0182039794,
-0.016443735,
-0.0144490246,
0.0348577574,
0.0033131773,
-0.0237345956,
0.0146681545,
0.0150783854,
0.0209656078,
0.0234358069,
0.0205231179,
-0.003278696,
0.0103275841,
-0.0685603246,
0.0070962394,
-0.0187847037,
0.0225672964,
0.0153179495,
-0.0549154878,
-0.0384379327,
0.0395460688,
0.0302137472,
0.0038770444,
0.0371164121,
-0.06563171,
0.051249411,
-0.0098349275,
-0.0240082499,
0.001080492,
-0.0105929542,
-0.0227715578,
0.0214024112,
0.0004407898,
-0.0012297942,
-0.0278574098,
-0.0365991518,
0.0114897666,
-0.0157021619,
-0.0137631688,
-0.0179493204,
-0.008040606,
0.0102401162,
0.0608217902,
-0.01376817,
-0.1059660092,
-0.0138441585,
-0.1239094138,
-0.0327445343,
-0.0173871275,
-0.0022452595,
0.029688539,
0.0358703732,
0.0352754258,
-0.0362729654,
-0.0695256665,
0.0494052023,
-0.0189079307,
0.0215333644,
0.0842913687,
0.0269369241,
-0.0179002192,
-0.0331515856,
0.0079093762,
0.0008948161,
0.0000971633,
0.0426530316,
0.0021172282,
-0.0165585484,
0.0186862778,
-0.0813246146,
0.0145270731,
-0.0147928698,
-0.0384360664,
0.0133289807,
0.0060837567,
0.0089467112,
0.0447741747,
0.0528439507,
0.0219044499,
-0.0580537282,
0.0292970929,
0.000666536,
-0.0064312224,
0.0035322125,
-0.0239195544,
-0.0043651303,
-0.0388528891,
0.0286635719,
0.0388385355,
-0.0146438014,
0.0113689946,
-0.0569712743,
0.0594980866,
-0.0017649537,
0.0058146124,
-0.067510426,
-0.0118739335,
0.0028071005,
0.0945115089,
-0.0244669244,
-0.0266323667,
0.0371353514,
0.0220397916,
-0.0233669709,
-0.0077095558,
-0.034133669,
-0.0385469198,
0.0647731721,
0.0008699271,
0.0258989111,
0.0521696471,
-0.0264885481,
-0.0251982529,
-0.0144797042,
0.0242271535,
-0.0642101467,
-0.0097591765,
-0.0099561624,
-0.0120254038,
0.0199575089,
-0.0457775593,
-0.0277552735,
-0.0922911242,
-0.0289838966,
-0.0247212816,
0.0343872719,
-0.0004755644,
-0.0149080204,
-0.0301961079,
-0.0153357387,
0.0083120987,
0.0200452451,
-0.0391373634,
-0.0050518778,
0.0483576134,
0.0252457522,
0.0645974576,
0.0131403822,
0.0136740003,
0.0289750192,
0.0659933314,
0.0212254934,
-0.0265325718,
0.0202349685,
-0.0317617878,
0.0179963075,
0.0002273627,
0.0029795386,
-0.0099850483,
0.0686236322,
-0.0279642045,
-0.0125487419,
0.0566064902,
0.0422481894,
-0.0150164906,
0.0049337964,
-0.0803045556,
0.0053802468,
0.0349349491,
0.0198508259,
-0.0815036595,
-0.0232239068,
-0.0091466829,
0.0075892513,
-0.0667598248,
-0.0614540838,
-0.0041369614,
-0.1017686874,
-0.0088144895,
-0.0221979991,
-0.0218704585,
0.0172909256,
-0.033215601,
0.023041375,
0.011589176,
-0.0220404826,
0.0095283426,
0.0241796914,
-0.0036264358,
-0.0065839388,
-0.0430052727,
0.0270122662,
0.0546101741,
-0.0312114768,
0.0464664325,
0.0491382331,
0.0664220601,
0.0106126005,
-0.0163273886,
0.0549093373,
0.0200701822,
-0.0112831974,
0.0248113498,
0.0746420547,
0.0162270274,
0.0061992873,
-0.0585408099,
0.0749999508,
-0.034060508,
0.0005229638,
0.0367262736,
0.0255972128,
-0.0002929145,
-0.0286555048,
-0.0071099517,
0.0362050682,
0.0308764689,
0.0340401977,
0.035351295,
-0.0497770607,
-0.004647776,
-0.0305083692,
0.022700021,
-0.0249166768,
-0.0295426268,
-0.0688841566,
0.0611090213,
-0.0306768063,
-0.0760121867,
-0.0352868922,
0.0422007293,
-0.0281822383,
-0.0053959182,
-0.036876332,
0.0503005944,
0.0566627942,
0.0033409793,
0.03729821,
-0.0253630113,
-0.0131544024,
-0.040083833,
-0.0404176414,
-0.0080186939,
-0.0352965333,
-0.0168099776,
0.0110315317,
-0.0963152945,
0.0005899925,
-0.009049573,
-0.0065307505,
0.0272239149,
-0.0077498951,
-0.0381443948,
-0.0493561067,
-0.0584885068,
0.0295745134,
-0.0478955433,
-0.0020057792,
0.0081451433,
0.0885869637,
0.0023607842,
0.0203920994,
-0.0284492616,
-0.0072351526,
-0.0437287539,
-0.0327893496,
-0.0498514436,
-0.095506981,
0.0103285657,
0.0340424776,
0.003871758,
0.0505813845,
0.0083767027,
0.012835253,
0.0030100588,
-0.0024120125,
-0.0068918709,
-0.0459623188,
-0.0242573544,
-0.0323345736,
-0.0097760921,
0.011748909,
0.0054228883,
-0.0465419143,
0.0207732879,
0.0061084162,
-0.019361889,
0.0313979052,
0.0234888643,
-0.013431713,
-0.0112737743,
-0.0061263223,
0.0376427807,
0.0154617345,
0.0574237742,
0.0204685424,
0.0530934632,
-0.0187497549,
-0.0275504775,
0.0226263963,
0.0392701961,
-0.0490968563,
-0.1082230508,
0.0335452482,
0.0689759254,
-0.0224199463,
0.0206470992,
-0.0251467545,
-0.0061544105,
-0.0233301576,
0.0156110236,
0.0118702827,
0.0206360612,
-0.017696647,
-0.0112448167,
0.0291276164,
-0.0506231822,
0.0206056722,
0.0238035452,
-0.0643271506,
-0.0131817097,
-0.0060408846,
-0.0271437746,
-0.0087649208,
0.0247395467,
-0.0131658465,
0.0275952723,
0.0174170993,
0.0266011879,
-0.071795918,
-0.0393966325,
-0.0179121979,
0.0050685927,
0.0054636528,
-0.0215398371,
0.0292581543,
0.02509645,
-0.0103971707,
-0.0061981273,
-0.0521153286,
0.0274198893,
-0.0431490913,
0.0111639453,
-0.0436249822,
-6.625195629e-33,
0.0317756049,
-0.0765107796,
-0.0141021674,
0.0322239511,
-0.0146855535,
-0.010638413,
-0.0371473245,
0.0539438687,
-0.0181395225,
0.0209638327,
-0.0312615372,
0.0294438973,
-0.0107932687,
0.0072175846,
-0.0026550912,
-0.0498393849,
0.0502967611,
-0.0391840041,
-0.0125678498,
0.0657712519,
0.0445680022,
-0.0311788619,
-0.0614018999,
-0.041050043,
0.0649663433,
-0.0349192359,
0.0028402738,
0.0565046072,
0.0533151887,
0.0001816222,
-0.0077191843,
0.0514289401,
0.0346309841,
-0.0020750095,
0.0204560757,
0.0919541791,
-0.0589185171,
-0.0345659144,
0.0031280599,
-0.0218180418,
-0.0805577934,
-0.0090726381,
0.0334144309,
-0.0059669008,
0.0263193604,
0.0007149439,
0.0437002964,
0.021522738,
0.0668263659,
0.0283652879,
-0.0085870996,
-0.0243004542,
-0.0484048836,
-0.0519702882,
-0.0456262939,
0.0646161735,
0.0311917476,
0.0254257359,
-0.0064709256,
0.0368670896,
-0.0498358198,
0.0060269712,
-0.0060921237,
-0.015249203,
0.0175857674,
0.028261479,
0.0017922982,
0.0709683895,
-0.0428942367,
-0.0461265333,
-0.0435066037,
0.0719798729,
0.0536605865,
0.0805875137,
0.0164272543,
-0.0405653752,
-0.0181286372,
0.027454406,
0.0256848838,
-0.008440299,
-0.0043979501,
-0.0096924519,
-0.0486018956,
0.0212562084,
-0.0446155891,
0.0057460787,
-0.057061594,
-0.004179175,
-0.0015036096,
-0.0135379294,
-0.0426789448,
-0.0518449023,
-0.0228660963,
-0.0531251244,
0.016584428,
-0.013681937,
0.0082317805,
0.0154646477,
0.0218569078,
-0.0191424135,
0.011161196,
0.0494159907,
0.0049570953,
0.0331205726,
0.0373210274,
0.0100619383,
-0.0227062255,
-0.0297152847,
-0.0287325922,
-0.0281054713,
-0.0373034403,
0.0466800109,
-0.0319695882,
0.0423156694,
0.0152834291,
0.0652747229,
-0.0186879206,
0.0346180759,
0.0070575392,
0.0442822091,
-0.0704374313,
-0.0430028066,
-0.0204814896,
-0.0253768731,
-0.0295591671,
-0.0493487902,
-0.031740725,
0.0092421491,
0.0102634868,
-0.0066422927,
-0.0138513064,
-0.0560723022,
2.649e-7,
-0.0068500903,
0.0185361672,
0.0121226413,
0.0248263963,
0.0309396647,
0.0440193936,
0.0320811197,
0.0527768917,
0.027559163,
-0.0768569931,
-0.0023882696,
-0.0047606044,
0.0434904508,
0.0168701448,
-0.0792700127,
-0.0512714759,
-0.0542535856,
0.0160635095,
0.0077006374,
-0.0034921442,
0.0492646843,
0.0213522837,
0.0086910091,
0.002686257,
-0.0195104852,
-0.0169523433,
0.0120412931,
-0.0489321612,
0.0093583856,
0.0314968936,
-0.0210442431,
0.0335430242,
0.0194677953,
-0.0008483306,
-0.0266115274,
-0.0232183076,
0.0368977375,
0.0257080104,
0.0197284687,
-0.0546461232,
-0.0017406457,
0.0097232796,
0.0054394947,
-0.046153944,
0.0418224074,
-0.0486476198,
-0.0613108091,
-0.015404162,
0.0372005254,
-0.0289345309,
0.0266698729,
0.0056852922,
-0.034038689,
-0.0166210737,
-0.0092772068,
-0.0034978527,
0.0225720406,
-0.0214582775,
0.0154475095,
-0.0220680423,
-0.046229627,
-0.101871483,
-0.0179716796,
0.0093903923,
-0.0024102712,
0.0314531662,
0.0195330847,
1.542941831e-34,
0.0287779365,
0.0078249304,
0.0048461179,
0.0006454317,
0.0603084341,
-0.0084477635,
-0.0324469879,
-0.0203846525,
0.0685264915,
-0.0476022549,
0.0232124906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12208v1 | Can ChatGPT be used to generate scientific hypotheses? | 2023-03-30T20:40:52 | 2023-03-30T20:40:52 | Yang Jeong Park, Daniel Kaplan, Zhichu Ren, Chia-Wei Hsu, Changhao Li, Haowei Xu, Sipei Li, Ju Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate whether large language models can perform the creative
hypothesis generation that human researchers regularly do. While the error rate
is high, generative AI seems to be able to effectively structure vast amounts
of scientific knowledge and provide interesting and testable hypotheses. The
future scientific enterprise may include synergistic efforts with a swarm of
"hypothesis machines", challenged by automated experimentation and adversarial
peer reviews. | [
0.0224243328,
0.0352072716,
0.0028305475,
-0.005994352,
-0.0539227203,
-0.0116303982,
0.015576723,
0.0130994581,
0.0312600583,
-0.0321930125,
0.0050228126,
-0.036160171,
-0.0009708527,
0.062661387,
0.026993081,
-0.0412794352,
0.0217390824,
-0.0049784272,
0.0575441457,
-0.0303113721,
-0.0359818228,
-0.010997179,
-0.0126848202,
0.0302615222,
0.0129543934,
-0.0281181876,
0.0050514634,
-0.0309000704,
0.0001470759,
-0.0285577066,
-0.0325106904,
0.0535397679,
0.0051544439,
0.0903673768,
0.0000014,
-0.0514871143,
-0.0076022511,
0.0433175713,
0.0052947844,
0.0207294859,
0.0591991171,
-0.0013335797,
-0.0157472678,
0.024720164,
-0.0316993967,
-0.0134468609,
0.0617823899,
-0.0212002099,
0.0003267032,
0.0518450327,
0.0113232592,
-0.0422022007,
0.0478309207,
-0.032490205,
0.0677136853,
0.0146777788,
0.0413003303,
0.0203871895,
0.0439447947,
0.0477816239,
0.0172255002,
0.0326323844,
0.0322642848,
-0.030632196,
-0.0006461205,
0.0661262721,
-0.0405667722,
-0.0129895899,
0.0006851486,
0.0259429328,
-0.0070615197,
-0.0764546469,
0.0285777412,
0.0133771021,
-0.0097600361,
0.0499496236,
-0.0539545342,
0.0593784377,
-0.0160013624,
-0.0072704172,
0.0482759811,
0.0048465612,
0.0420440882,
0.0109638385,
0.0213362649,
0.0527858362,
0.0537848435,
-0.0357991531,
-0.0263033491,
0.0269521084,
-0.0304290242,
-0.0793892741,
-0.0320980139,
-0.0058032391,
0.0014916526,
0.0078375833,
-0.0074479938,
-0.0160028506,
0.0566958077,
-0.0296967961,
-0.006701346,
0.0185070392,
0.0306836963,
0.0458626673,
-0.0142348362,
-0.0218558796,
-0.0432118736,
0.005728913,
-0.0119817015,
0.0049636429,
-0.0796774104,
-0.0319406204,
-0.0184512157,
0.00972596,
0.0071994113,
0.0027965703,
-0.0153534897,
0.0227457322,
0.0190497376,
-0.0190537143,
-0.0421078093,
0.0294314362,
-0.0777291879,
-0.0130808679,
-0.0127653191,
0.0009857096,
-0.0119074965,
0.0168462601,
0.0211543702,
-0.0575176477,
-0.0318059474,
0.0077513475,
-0.0108940015,
0.025535835,
0.0126848063,
0.0528146662,
0.0156353395,
0.0189256445,
0.0388401933,
-0.0354221165,
-0.0155410236,
-0.0661410913,
0.0474510975,
-0.0639493912,
0.0285465866,
0.0072586401,
-0.0064621749,
-0.0013146646,
-0.0221515428,
0.0010989609,
-0.0272346903,
0.045138251,
-0.0589559525,
-0.0154003743,
0.0369568951,
0.0214066301,
-0.0178114809,
0.0577206872,
0.0224032253,
0.012235716,
0.0249472223,
0.0037667465,
0.0391915888,
-0.0264423285,
0.024372749,
0.0002259622,
0.0281602275,
-0.0251351334,
-0.0095768897,
0.0513814725,
-0.0507727787,
0.0854182541,
-0.0369030535,
0.0015403901,
0.0269789472,
0.0678093582,
-0.017354833,
0.0722742006,
0.0653062314,
-0.0277311653,
0.0099594956,
0.0212630741,
0.0004975174,
0.0450998917,
-0.039939668,
0.0142664528,
0.0318573117,
0.000328073,
-0.0208593104,
-0.0257298984,
-0.0062362291,
0.0354422368,
-0.0411506854,
-0.0627754182,
0.0273226164,
0.0139652342,
-0.0064727124,
-0.0342239998,
0.035489969,
-0.0259431005,
0.0067382385,
-0.0609652847,
0.0641707778,
0.0323420279,
0.0772300139,
-0.033704523,
-0.0163155533,
-0.004215763,
-0.0028796811,
0.0763783082,
0.0816557854,
-0.0125472108,
-0.0579000786,
0.008980507,
0.0049929218,
-0.037501432,
0.0315172076,
0.0092151053,
-0.0200034082,
0.0179025326,
-0.016635282,
0.0008379081,
-0.0192512274,
0.0277936254,
-0.0471859761,
0.0168805998,
0.0269685145,
-0.072515443,
0.0614315681,
-0.0039938586,
-0.0498542339,
0.0525761209,
0.0507696792,
-0.027118057,
-0.0797692165,
0.0418998823,
0.0369382873,
-0.0532365367,
0.0216777176,
-0.1032683998,
0.0034744304,
-0.0373238176,
-0.0138987266,
-0.0276021957,
0.0528241023,
-0.0308281407,
0.0453300923,
-0.0286983531,
-0.0132017927,
-0.0298529509,
0.0214288011,
-0.0013469296,
0.0516139157,
0.0135104889,
0.0072298031,
0.0046073487,
0.0117676957,
0.0185009167,
-0.0264628734,
-0.0178142209,
0.0134927612,
0.0313780643,
-0.0116377119,
0.0427390486,
-0.0126769021,
-0.0109693985,
-0.028241843,
-0.0636424869,
0.0000552492,
-0.0000629797,
-0.0176953636,
0.0285538193,
-0.0366767459,
0.0082634808,
0.0350793898,
-0.0115926852,
0.0141748087,
0.0349288769,
0.0152064404,
0.0451788679,
0.0081629883,
-0.0219125655,
-0.0437174998,
-0.0116832582,
-0.0522685312,
0.0579694435,
0.0785059407,
0.0101760523,
-0.0479287133,
0.0336943343,
-0.0367197394,
0.0073225037,
-0.0293071754,
-0.0226202719,
0.0705838874,
-0.0312298164,
0.0218200069,
0.0516237095,
0.0181594882,
0.0252644122,
0.059294913,
0.0209831353,
-0.0180084202,
-0.0077300137,
-0.0632879212,
0.0029140541,
0.0202208403,
-0.0306853633,
0.0122762714,
0.0132752871,
0.0146090509,
-0.0186444391,
-0.0605759546,
0.05364988,
0.0128577221,
-0.0213797987,
0.0030965579,
-0.0148703093,
-0.008758314,
0.0375126973,
0.0025462157,
-0.0352988131,
0.0716699064,
-0.0312173907,
-0.0084189186,
-0.0877672955,
0.02069005,
-0.0187084917,
0.0577526838,
-0.005124094,
-0.0029242246,
0.0452077352,
0.0541019775,
-0.015921291,
0.0248388089,
0.0036985849,
0.0114825377,
-0.0562136471,
-0.0505183823,
0.0186590645,
0.0319750458,
-0.0234511662,
-0.020004075,
-0.0315364487,
-0.0003791506,
0.0224627238,
0.0641019046,
-0.0430601798,
-0.0467912741,
-0.0079413736,
0.0261840224,
0.0072332527,
-0.0100534474,
-0.0221928954,
-0.0174741242,
-0.0067079505,
0.0742632449,
-0.0147962254,
0.0212691966,
-0.0198963135,
0.0239819605,
0.0540445372,
-0.0182228833,
0.0437734835,
-0.0257180035,
-0.0394022018,
-0.038670104,
0.0027540587,
-0.0186774284,
-0.0030104946,
0.0024426123,
-0.0042890646,
-0.0085122129,
0.0944603384,
0.0192073248,
-0.042538505,
-0.0057956683,
0.0123824272,
0.0364348888,
-0.0090587037,
0.0259767659,
-0.1041200161,
0.0274760649,
-0.0220587272,
-0.0174739249,
-0.0310922414,
-0.037898615,
-0.0279175453,
-0.0771382898,
0.0599132776,
0.0037354054,
-0.0202260837,
0.0148493014,
-0.0808438286,
-0.0217054281,
-0.029513631,
-0.0444170609,
0.0095742652,
0.0182908475,
0.0340667479,
0.0127760861,
0.0156678334,
-0.0685278773,
0.0244978424,
-0.0303493626,
0.0622782297,
0.0446484163,
0.0382351279,
-0.0289513413,
-0.0180613715,
-0.0334408954,
0.029824011,
-0.0087921107,
0.0100697186,
0.0178449564,
0.0369782932,
0.0104759382,
-0.0135927759,
0.06591364,
-0.0533549525,
0.0058684251,
0.0223656502,
0.0724474862,
-0.0371709689,
-0.074653022,
-0.0587875023,
0.0444424376,
-0.0052649085,
0.110014759,
0.0005892992,
-0.0175884347,
-0.0434777923,
-0.0467953384,
0.0084030274,
-0.0143722966,
-0.0367786214,
-0.0403011851,
0.0293928888,
-0.0246502273,
-0.0808242932,
-0.0284070391,
0.0038456027,
0.0216659009,
0.0049059372,
-0.0139255524,
-0.0175131112,
0.0000508547,
-0.0118180895,
0.0043475865,
-0.0153119694,
-0.0262683891,
-0.0178058296,
-0.0242284574,
0.0642503873,
-0.0293250941,
-0.0382865854,
0.0354353487,
-0.0595817938,
-0.0920910016,
-0.013613998,
0.0428914241,
0.0262352116,
0.0136308586,
-0.028836647,
-0.053622108,
0.0401805602,
0.0488324389,
0.0018055423,
0.0080560828,
-0.012382241,
-0.0106778815,
-0.003465421,
-0.017508585,
-0.0087683545,
0.046129521,
0.0063430518,
0.0019548086,
-0.0254323017,
-0.0310490951,
0.0308767129,
0.0315979645,
0.0376985855,
-0.0513129272,
0.003772479,
0.0023066646,
-0.05196153,
-0.0305104554,
0.0003607475,
-0.039842397,
0.0159049593,
-0.002956331,
0.0035377634,
0.0006852269,
0.0136735421,
-0.0507579818,
0.0401978791,
0.0116907796,
0.0135552902,
0.0062133609,
0.0308238361,
0.0462519117,
-0.0208482817,
-0.0133286584,
0.0099299224,
-0.0557700656,
0.040045321,
-0.0095925173,
0.0159360468,
0.0443890467,
-0.0070493706,
-0.011572767,
0.0161953215,
-0.1213968843,
-0.054748632,
-0.0335440598,
0.079271242,
0.0264861397,
0.0968465582,
0.0019476095,
-0.0994738191,
-0.0276972838,
-0.0195926316,
0.0411850326,
-0.0069336719,
-0.0199646447,
0.0324070156,
0.0103242183,
-0.0585893169,
-0.0388616845,
0.0732181072,
0.0232715569,
0.0404578634,
0.0128768338,
-0.0069480413,
-0.023780318,
-0.028674338,
-0.0553288795,
-0.0091841146,
0.027947329,
0.0127667962,
-0.0463252179,
-0.0356559306,
0.0117926588,
0.0614135265,
0.0505204499,
0.0118078412,
0.0134737594,
0.0528590083,
-0.0542997643,
-0.0190359224,
-0.0077285483,
0.0479566306,
-0.0480335429,
-0.0301461183,
-0.0365123712,
-5.739335005e-33,
0.0211013239,
-0.020872239,
0.0224573966,
-0.0104502328,
0.0296549555,
0.0042772628,
-0.0649415404,
0.0074337395,
-0.0054611666,
0.0457337424,
-0.0082597462,
0.0266624633,
-0.015263997,
-0.0072910725,
0.0184390247,
0.0249662548,
0.0604105443,
-0.0381858312,
-0.0217261557,
0.0473152027,
0.0353247747,
-0.0275749583,
0.0235214084,
-0.0309371147,
0.0163382497,
-0.0278218649,
-0.019753037,
0.0060438183,
-0.078895241,
0.0281302743,
-0.0472786315,
0.0059668701,
-0.01321177,
-0.0212313086,
0.0240251366,
-0.0334292836,
-0.0029658279,
-0.0183225963,
0.0149804009,
-0.0534931384,
-0.0056566703,
-0.030305583,
0.016197186,
-0.0034099231,
-0.0336636826,
0.0031541691,
0.0072590644,
-0.0005768546,
-0.0082154134,
-0.0322420001,
-0.0479194894,
0.0250197016,
-0.0106062964,
0.0038828237,
-0.0139317615,
-0.0339219086,
-0.0041872398,
0.0026720499,
0.0257137939,
0.0925756395,
0.0121971061,
-0.0228992552,
0.0252617933,
-0.045893196,
0.0175543018,
0.0710708499,
0.0320639051,
0.0490823686,
-0.0330020413,
0.0169724431,
0.0065284367,
0.0295162331,
0.0727175698,
0.0802022889,
0.0204831306,
0.0267698038,
-0.0536889955,
0.0326306447,
0.0455034189,
-0.0354022533,
0.0407880284,
0.0257830191,
-0.0136651201,
-0.0399216488,
-0.0003740517,
-0.0501242429,
-0.0049205865,
-0.0381191373,
-0.0313591808,
-0.0243773311,
-0.0371118858,
-0.0035221432,
0.0403906479,
-0.0456774719,
0.0237389114,
0.042783007,
-0.0423564166,
0.0195728205,
-0.0012184781,
0.0097983414,
-0.0742686614,
-0.0124780033,
0.0423153564,
0.0698586106,
-0.0090423655,
0.0162876435,
-0.0060656127,
0.0110626947,
-0.0030650217,
0.0140540367,
-0.0306764282,
0.0094905617,
0.0483030565,
-0.0302183814,
-0.0059869476,
0.0295587368,
0.0181341693,
-0.0231767744,
0.0262366347,
0.033027038,
-0.0175799206,
0.0825907961,
-0.0383014679,
0.0072850576,
-0.0234333724,
0.004827356,
-0.0259745177,
-0.0122827692,
0.0236946698,
-0.0824308619,
-0.0129156001,
-0.0024685862,
2.292e-7,
0.0438906588,
0.0583891124,
0.0149202999,
-0.0007822852,
0.0638178959,
0.0081000756,
-0.0127152232,
0.0076082642,
0.0117094861,
-0.0028681434,
0.0109261498,
0.0037021481,
-0.0026113805,
0.0475689098,
-0.0781787708,
-0.0358062945,
-0.0906557664,
-0.0428429022,
-0.0235506147,
-0.0231595282,
0.0112540647,
0.0461571291,
0.019869918,
0.0003752974,
0.0242061149,
-0.0505791865,
0.0595146157,
0.0207984149,
0.0221567173,
0.0858384371,
-0.0152187701,
0.0169442203,
-0.0013419793,
0.0160639081,
-0.0164971352,
-0.0074966988,
-0.011382048,
0.0087466352,
0.0156194745,
-0.0042134072,
0.0466288589,
-0.009172014,
0.0074973265,
-0.0495074093,
0.0400053449,
-0.0675372258,
-0.0457242168,
-0.0234799031,
0.0186933745,
-0.0058155758,
0.0127141336,
-0.0489004813,
0.0019863762,
-0.0140460059,
-0.0462847278,
0.0199438389,
-0.0082085878,
-0.0491035804,
0.0007789177,
0.0069539044,
-0.1063758209,
-0.0608278178,
0.0163003504,
-0.0168487001,
0.0222158115,
-0.0184402019,
0.0221163537,
2.077772361e-34,
0.0835595652,
-0.0145079009,
-0.0232143961,
-0.0276899152,
0.023046406,
0.0139787998,
0.0619501881,
-0.0085221659,
0.0557595044,
-0.0586194508,
-0.0387503207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17695v1 | Task Oriented Conversational Modelling With Subjective Knowledge | 2023-03-30T20:23:49 | 2023-03-30T20:23:49 | Raja Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Existing conversational models are handled by a database(DB) and API based
systems. However, very often users' questions require information that cannot
be handled by such systems. Nonetheless, answers to these questions are
available in the form of customer reviews and FAQs. DSTC-11 proposes a three
stage pipeline consisting of knowledge seeking turn detection, knowledge
selection and response generation to create a conversational model grounded on
this subjective knowledge. In this paper, we focus on improving the knowledge
selection module to enhance the overall system performance. In particular, we
propose entity retrieval methods which result in an accurate and faster
knowledge search. Our proposed Named Entity Recognition (NER) based entity
retrieval method results in 7X faster search compared to the baseline model.
Additionally, we also explore a potential keyword extraction method which can
improve the accuracy of knowledge selection. Preliminary results show a 4 \%
improvement in exact match score on knowledge selection task. The code is
available https://github.com/raja-kumar/knowledge-grounded-TODS | [
0.0938354805,
-0.0216733888,
-0.0264637806,
0.0536208078,
-0.0317006409,
0.0048209415,
-0.026548842,
0.0153890038,
0.0709168464,
-0.0503817014,
-0.0154461823,
0.0076834979,
-0.0606565364,
0.037125919,
-0.0293761231,
-0.0367230885,
0.0212526415,
0.0095924959,
0.0402221344,
0.0313359983,
0.0263473336,
0.0108458847,
-0.0259576794,
0.017561581,
0.0027368797,
-0.0033332505,
-0.0185814034,
-0.0064550568,
-0.020905504,
-0.022353299,
0.0615022406,
0.057967823,
-0.0305333342,
-0.002157087,
0.0000022764,
-0.0416395999,
-0.0603935011,
0.0013528194,
-0.0617577657,
-0.0554466806,
0.0170959644,
0.0630334765,
0.0296312459,
0.0035319075,
-0.0663388893,
0.0097888745,
0.027642224,
0.1037314311,
0.0513802134,
0.0531223714,
-0.0133967856,
-0.008353225,
-0.041312132,
0.0361079685,
0.0308846384,
-0.0324657373,
0.0227891374,
0.0262702983,
0.0213986859,
0.0338320807,
0.0347821936,
0.0160830244,
-0.0376650281,
-0.015251576,
0.0376477838,
0.0265127495,
-0.0376311764,
-0.011345325,
0.0100003583,
0.0808874592,
0.0543683097,
-0.0085335448,
0.051231131,
0.031546846,
-0.0047268821,
-0.00611385,
-0.0655774549,
-0.0791306719,
-0.069464922,
-0.0278907996,
-0.069536902,
0.012671778,
-0.0188907683,
-0.009925032,
0.0043125385,
0.0342044011,
-0.0114533426,
-0.0602050722,
-0.0027448172,
-0.0205405392,
0.0102066724,
-0.0350667536,
0.0555435345,
0.0183290616,
-0.0139711173,
0.0079406574,
0.0145865437,
0.0027780109,
0.0118358741,
-0.1132790521,
-0.0349908397,
-0.0035539612,
0.0112036392,
0.0501358546,
0.0123932352,
0.018030202,
0.038504079,
-0.0283214096,
-0.0182145238,
-0.028716255,
-0.0814102963,
-0.0022928813,
-0.03027259,
0.085170947,
-0.052412726,
-0.0205129832,
0.0033347227,
0.0331478007,
0.0083181234,
0.0037998368,
0.0636938214,
0.015952291,
0.0046348437,
0.0325785838,
-0.0723334402,
-0.0054924251,
-0.0210342873,
-0.0159456115,
-0.0251143072,
-0.0300163981,
0.0150082689,
-0.0186183285,
0.0565588921,
-0.0312460884,
0.0035010644,
0.0470418632,
0.0219004937,
-0.0631780326,
-0.0572714806,
-0.0099334307,
-0.0024547481,
-0.0399557501,
-0.0287915673,
-0.0280738845,
0.0450448841,
0.025875695,
-0.0304438602,
0.0037282009,
0.0396045111,
0.0588737838,
-0.0297817197,
0.0307447892,
-0.0502312742,
0.005364147,
0.0476276353,
0.0209957808,
-0.0225076824,
0.0461965203,
-0.0113236336,
0.0237771384,
0.0777680203,
0.0076723923,
0.0259068441,
-0.0078705391,
-0.0028419995,
-0.0454572961,
0.0806301609,
0.0676132962,
-0.0368299186,
-0.0058836532,
-0.0127089815,
0.0513467938,
-0.0149947582,
0.0291203912,
0.0489455573,
0.0095601631,
-0.0038852745,
0.0396979637,
-0.0017447582,
0.0767293796,
0.0168363433,
0.0021056996,
0.0009693638,
0.0486553349,
-0.0464309044,
-0.0148667721,
0.0128192408,
0.0095373858,
-0.026077861,
-0.0154110547,
0.0180700477,
0.0143898912,
0.0027826419,
0.0557310842,
0.029688308,
-0.005125477,
-0.073581405,
0.0606622808,
0.014435322,
-0.0526293553,
-0.032508947,
-0.0232873242,
0.0294371136,
0.0791049376,
0.0477205329,
-0.0212286506,
-0.0550812744,
-0.0112030981,
-0.0292170998,
0.0261832047,
0.0643679425,
-0.0171744395,
-0.0186697748,
-0.0435541831,
-0.0221865773,
0.0404876135,
-0.019699214,
-0.0176739823,
0.0173013899,
0.0495333374,
0.0296025202,
-0.0377956033,
-0.010179352,
0.0106670726,
0.0402862467,
-0.0120617859,
0.0009232185,
0.0380405188,
0.0105928639,
0.0376566574,
0.0217542369,
0.0014441579,
0.0333346613,
0.0099962745,
-0.0230232868,
0.0321974494,
0.0073087942,
-0.0511794686,
-0.0027258438,
0.012174692,
-0.0149036702,
0.0056565767,
0.0215267539,
-0.0607081018,
-0.0053661345,
-0.021706773,
0.0468371995,
-0.0422844514,
0.0127049731,
0.0242771637,
-0.0185940173,
-0.0499808863,
0.0657101795,
0.0358159468,
0.0194292851,
-0.0364232026,
-0.071838215,
0.0034570913,
-0.0481405184,
-0.023558937,
0.0282039903,
0.0028422403,
0.0107083777,
0.035962712,
-0.0003786157,
-0.0550773591,
-0.0231845472,
-0.1627532393,
0.0204916988,
-0.0035492736,
0.0229124092,
-0.0229178295,
0.0254599173,
-0.0122890389,
-0.0210327767,
-0.0281935576,
0.0008395435,
-0.0015875516,
-0.0142621156,
0.0078533925,
0.0389363356,
-0.0094815493,
-0.0426523425,
0.032050617,
-0.0064748144,
0.0194703527,
0.0239827149,
-0.0423486345,
-0.0089393072,
0.0246431269,
-0.0376316048,
0.0311963484,
-0.0030314724,
0.004211437,
-0.0153653435,
-0.0015288402,
0.0309972279,
0.0289002731,
0.0204028841,
0.032704141,
-0.0718206242,
-0.0625867471,
-0.0645813271,
0.0391280614,
-0.0325058736,
0.0084235221,
0.0047867834,
-0.0173384193,
0.0689834133,
0.0207998864,
-0.0035451557,
-0.0031961324,
-0.06043455,
0.0122154532,
0.0164031982,
0.04017758,
-0.0138037195,
0.0242564399,
0.0062035285,
0.0359793119,
-0.0285698045,
0.0275952909,
0.0659590885,
-0.0258353278,
-0.0179174822,
-0.0661328211,
-0.0011263699,
-0.0269727539,
0.0456772335,
-0.0268175509,
0.0154977059,
0.0302356035,
-0.027569294,
0.01846998,
0.0100056184,
0.014167862,
-0.0582740791,
0.0328213722,
-0.0202842169,
0.0166236386,
0.0337720551,
-0.0507679097,
-0.0274077673,
0.0080640512,
-0.0240612291,
-0.0177327376,
0.0300173424,
0.0056055225,
0.0075369575,
0.0264531616,
-0.0078241676,
0.0448009111,
-0.0043742526,
-0.0221187994,
-0.0102740526,
0.0242697503,
0.0476789027,
-0.011311139,
0.0198125727,
0.0212536212,
0.0572923608,
0.0461337231,
0.0481176637,
-0.0473996922,
0.0325294361,
-0.0540042594,
0.0140247932,
-0.0730566904,
-0.0126606375,
-0.0086028418,
0.0301795565,
-0.0186040327,
-0.0157940891,
0.1276680678,
0.0332206935,
-0.0226384848,
-0.0261918511,
-0.0042421483,
-0.0206634458,
0.0249178801,
0.0545236655,
-0.0325318463,
-0.0111090457,
0.0084806932,
0.0353904776,
-0.0154853975,
-0.0679630414,
-0.0098609645,
-0.0712580755,
0.0084906407,
-0.0637195036,
-0.0096481927,
-0.0558768064,
-0.0345682353,
0.0055425465,
0.0151880048,
-0.0198747274,
0.017105367,
-0.0036481624,
0.0020287817,
0.0040600104,
0.0151762003,
-0.0199268423,
0.0686604828,
-0.0390130952,
0.0283502676,
0.0435982347,
0.0833518729,
0.0445621051,
-0.0082348641,
-0.0246295389,
-0.0086536007,
-0.0152932405,
-0.0368716642,
0.0718217716,
-0.0480924696,
0.0054518958,
-0.0391471945,
-0.0177678652,
-0.0340167955,
0.0366492942,
0.0380313694,
0.0275735259,
-0.0445201881,
0.0029863133,
-0.0182544719,
0.0023331663,
0.0459804051,
0.0836652145,
-0.0041551809,
-0.0128953252,
-0.0326042101,
0.0018402197,
-0.0058835614,
-0.0150131034,
-0.0180663802,
-0.0327884853,
-0.0005397313,
0.0283690728,
-0.0912966132,
-0.0330599621,
0.0355910063,
0.0484306663,
0.0190562624,
0.0242552496,
0.0525656566,
0.036966376,
-0.0444174558,
-0.0089149727,
-0.0148813119,
-0.0066479831,
-0.0488971211,
-0.0216809586,
0.0470782593,
-0.0362850651,
-0.0227976069,
-0.0171296336,
-0.0150506552,
-0.0353619643,
-0.0284632966,
0.0604852848,
0.0179431289,
0.0072076167,
-0.0285977665,
-0.0169518627,
-0.0521276444,
-0.0013473468,
-0.0791608766,
-0.0385170355,
0.0053501981,
0.0581099279,
-0.013692827,
0.0470015965,
-0.0384433307,
0.0099531701,
-0.0268877689,
0.0216881316,
-0.0410515927,
-0.0638899431,
0.0076397345,
0.011078462,
0.0668154582,
0.0755836591,
0.0075023961,
-0.0398548357,
0.0357203297,
-0.0137131633,
-0.0234597065,
-0.0425952189,
0.0042816354,
-0.0589074753,
-0.001616594,
-0.0074576493,
0.0253413543,
-0.0264052488,
0.0251348689,
-0.0182428919,
-0.006270743,
0.006204424,
-0.0041140178,
0.032941252,
-0.037356019,
-0.0079110041,
0.018045973,
0.0547148846,
0.0342608057,
-0.0143196797,
0.0757625923,
0.0013164382,
-0.0459188633,
0.0140127195,
-0.0017962635,
-0.035429582,
-0.0328285061,
-0.0189951565,
0.0589695275,
-0.0010210862,
-0.037540067,
0.0228203796,
-0.0201081168,
0.0030739477,
-0.0202544555,
0.0021306262,
-0.0087732244,
-0.0099838879,
0.0146939429,
0.0211613979,
-0.0202099402,
-0.0150841633,
0.0616113804,
-0.0326942056,
0.0124350125,
-0.0145342872,
-0.0617073886,
-0.0856271833,
-0.0054582371,
0.0466161855,
0.007316411,
-0.0004118801,
0.0267730821,
-0.040418949,
-0.0272346418,
0.0290225092,
-0.0390746295,
-0.0236943085,
-0.0202608276,
0.0798380971,
0.0813501328,
0.0152002657,
-0.0433867797,
-0.0449719205,
-0.0017878957,
-0.0599410906,
-0.0001359763,
-0.0289977752,
-6.363282998e-33,
-0.0393567272,
-0.0307944138,
0.0144074084,
0.0660376474,
-0.0041197184,
-0.0323721841,
-0.0329538211,
0.0204894934,
-0.0196423493,
-0.0183047839,
-0.0086042294,
0.0148482667,
0.0117210969,
0.02864925,
-0.0378514677,
-0.0164661575,
0.0576502346,
-0.0061159227,
0.0170540307,
0.0395903625,
0.0398076475,
0.0676926896,
0.0340862349,
-0.0949751809,
0.0457651876,
-0.0108089112,
0.0400378816,
0.0404045098,
0.0347832963,
0.0398060717,
-0.0132882725,
0.0266715642,
0.0162697174,
-0.0293198675,
0.0198176466,
-0.0184438229,
-0.0889134854,
-0.0167434067,
0.020344669,
0.0216788203,
0.0258197524,
-0.0105894972,
0.0297358185,
-0.0255155191,
0.0105985627,
0.058010567,
0.0430563688,
-0.0206262842,
-0.0163228139,
-0.0621593967,
-0.0426960513,
0.0191485696,
0.0024509968,
-0.0273977444,
0.0063344459,
0.026518397,
0.0208940748,
-0.0443472415,
-0.0569359437,
-0.0043310085,
-0.0328701846,
0.0155201145,
-0.0068740658,
-0.0048489561,
0.0065864837,
0.055776488,
0.0045077503,
0.0032707546,
-0.0185960177,
-0.0071334559,
-0.0060876636,
0.0507435575,
-0.0044893692,
0.0273925625,
-0.0416116863,
-0.0332112163,
-0.0075441753,
0.0185314268,
0.0203122348,
0.0277573708,
0.038709987,
-0.0016963391,
-0.1064320505,
-0.0033703998,
-0.0008234905,
-0.0094223348,
-0.0514629893,
-0.022559002,
0.034777578,
0.0285571869,
-0.0319109075,
-0.0315969661,
-0.0039376854,
-0.0122184064,
-0.0117482245,
0.0136550777,
-0.0163284913,
-0.0216651447,
-0.009311365,
-0.0001684803,
-0.0576290973,
-0.0093467282,
-0.0022275338,
-0.0006526004,
-0.02219522,
0.0171526689,
-0.0370988697,
-0.0174515359,
-0.0554223172,
-0.0119963475,
-0.0134786759,
0.0282579232,
-0.0405777171,
0.0530651882,
0.0060097491,
0.0182102155,
-0.0121827656,
0.0539989173,
0.0082803732,
0.0168484468,
-0.0744122416,
-0.0060941637,
0.042660661,
0.0054955683,
-0.0078531755,
-0.0149528384,
0.0010320672,
-0.0347098857,
-0.0345339999,
-0.0303998347,
0.0098161539,
0.0072002183,
3.015e-7,
-0.0181280635,
0.0610373206,
-0.0241051558,
-0.0024736566,
-0.0028386107,
0.0403693803,
0.0468599983,
-0.0005649774,
0.0381190851,
-0.0393578298,
0.0109140575,
0.0148215219,
0.0275638774,
0.0181714986,
-0.151679635,
-0.0757794678,
0.0122954603,
-0.0363587923,
-0.0488871448,
-0.0184843298,
0.0621554554,
0.0444655195,
0.0209953636,
0.0337354429,
-0.0351049565,
0.0010117937,
0.0266688596,
-0.0174734797,
0.0156746395,
0.0493636429,
0.0628981814,
-0.0036138145,
-0.0200346317,
0.0398306437,
-0.0202791151,
0.0234799553,
0.0478600226,
0.0578999594,
0.0180077422,
-0.0568178222,
0.0161242802,
-0.0143251717,
0.0141090136,
-0.0592379533,
0.0795970038,
-0.0386944413,
0.005872793,
-0.0027606778,
0.0032625513,
-0.0269778818,
-0.030509755,
0.0003522759,
-0.0367227457,
0.0179510582,
0.0063100588,
-0.0268664286,
0.0194981955,
-0.0576593578,
0.0328602158,
0.0155694066,
-0.0509131253,
-0.0458695218,
-0.0441735387,
-0.0494154282,
0.0026366306,
-0.0180846881,
0.0368025117,
2.500327453e-34,
0.0007299581,
0.0345330499,
0.002693818,
0.016839426,
0.0395010561,
0.0060826703,
0.0019504823,
-0.016294945,
0.0189440493,
-0.0560672097,
0.0083688656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17683v1 | Fine-Tuning BERT with Character-Level Noise for Zero-Shot Transfer to Dialects and Closely-Related Languages | 2023-03-30T19:51:18 | 2023-03-30T19:51:18 | Aarohi Srivastava, David Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we induce character-level noise in various forms when
fine-tuning BERT to enable zero-shot cross-lingual transfer to unseen dialects
and languages. We fine-tune BERT on three sentence-level classification tasks
and evaluate our approach on an assortment of unseen dialects and languages. We
find that character-level noise can be an extremely effective agent of
cross-lingual transfer under certain conditions, while it is not as helpful in
others. Specifically, we explore these differences in terms of the nature of
the task and the relationships between source and target languages, finding
that introduction of character-level noise during fine-tuning is particularly
helpful when a task draws on surface level cues and the source-target
cross-lingual pair has a relatively high lexical overlap with shorter (i.e.,
less meaningful) unseen tokens on average. | [
-0.0091329282,
0.031581983,
-0.0127825728,
0.0392191373,
-0.0157209374,
0.0094650034,
0.0019583618,
-0.0009641518,
-0.0486391485,
-0.0564962812,
-0.0798547417,
-0.0149674527,
0.0242498517,
-0.0253907293,
0.0764822811,
-0.0613234304,
0.0623945557,
-0.0459821746,
0.0133039597,
-0.0108833676,
0.0063409903,
-0.027015686,
-0.0021007853,
0.0234828591,
-0.0124779744,
0.0239959229,
-0.0109379012,
0.0305718724,
0.0266782418,
0.0247027017,
-0.0052058417,
0.0555139594,
0.000746803,
0.0398135893,
0.000001479,
-0.0678359643,
0.0015398406,
-0.0151261855,
-0.0214045886,
0.0094199125,
-0.0064938087,
-0.0199823808,
-0.03950404,
-0.0048951409,
0.0175519753,
-0.0208571982,
0.0860826969,
0.0216945242,
0.0192137025,
0.0531671867,
-0.0269295797,
-0.0136541724,
-0.0007406332,
-0.0136804078,
0.0477526672,
-0.0132380901,
0.0289034937,
-0.0600040816,
-0.0322907642,
-0.0172066391,
-0.0216841977,
-0.0009877617,
-0.0360900238,
0.0060990108,
0.0045781629,
0.0281758141,
-0.0906386673,
0.0189514961,
-0.0142697822,
0.073554121,
-0.0516967997,
-0.0332471989,
-0.0213407017,
0.0307812784,
0.0102040926,
-0.0219789445,
-0.0337262899,
-0.0099195614,
0.0152522624,
0.0248535685,
0.0248726532,
-0.0141732972,
0.0161185768,
-0.0105664991,
-0.0181051269,
0.0181521159,
0.0532428734,
-0.0416470021,
0.0136914998,
0.0289687775,
0.0171032008,
-0.0544651374,
0.0219193716,
0.0214537941,
0.0063637891,
0.0117151141,
-0.0701324791,
-0.0417020582,
-0.000837701,
-0.0200606287,
0.0472565368,
0.0363545194,
-0.0594699197,
0.0267094132,
-0.0654141381,
0.0165681615,
-0.0176793206,
0.0300943851,
-0.0043121576,
-0.046276506,
-0.0526057109,
0.0064496114,
-0.0744547397,
0.0232437756,
-0.018622933,
0.0057175807,
-0.0345177427,
-0.0172312018,
0.0234700441,
-0.0109967431,
0.0096674562,
-0.039875377,
-0.0572756939,
-0.0036488771,
0.0181717686,
0.0714485571,
-0.0539328679,
0.0140091218,
-0.0263873804,
-0.031532798,
-0.0352549441,
0.0380099192,
0.0388653912,
-0.0408056006,
0.0124433702,
0.0739437789,
-0.0262036361,
-0.0264334511,
-0.06441544,
0.0327622555,
-0.0528184138,
-0.0296747107,
0.0124373259,
-0.048814334,
-0.0314482525,
-0.0174409635,
0.0137312841,
0.0112212002,
0.006071433,
-0.0186381284,
-0.0289744418,
0.0858720168,
-0.0187705252,
-0.0194006413,
-0.0107304147,
-0.038747292,
-0.0022264055,
0.0685233176,
0.0398784801,
-0.0074879448,
0.0286744162,
-0.0120704575,
-0.0233140811,
0.0587130859,
0.0262369271,
0.0210997276,
-0.068310909,
-0.0593476593,
0.0044263597,
0.0020116367,
0.0271103755,
0.0446171202,
-0.0303262807,
0.0160819627,
0.041236002,
0.0523555353,
0.0202578623,
0.0425492413,
0.0472786613,
0.0057258066,
-0.0445640497,
0.0557703376,
-0.0001658759,
0.000605763,
-0.0470366143,
0.0097532114,
-0.0004372838,
0.0248658899,
-0.0508647226,
0.0158562083,
0.001022517,
-0.0294096731,
-0.0160381906,
-0.0294919685,
0.0579585508,
0.0380901992,
-0.028414933,
0.0718945637,
0.0444120392,
-0.0368241929,
0.0417749211,
-0.0519832112,
0.0156250875,
0.0588072948,
0.0127792824,
-0.0124258725,
-0.0452068336,
-0.00159278,
-0.0014383218,
0.0483806878,
0.0339530706,
-0.0080262348,
0.072747536,
-0.0587829165,
-0.0041207182,
0.0011696393,
0.0161582511,
0.06788259,
-0.0343770832,
0.0388403125,
-0.0154883107,
-0.0799840167,
0.038761694,
0.0069865324,
0.0020972076,
-0.0385675244,
0.0332830884,
0.0351921432,
0.0058034672,
0.015517354,
-0.033868622,
-0.013833818,
-0.0125176702,
-0.0687668622,
0.0306430738,
0.0652387217,
-0.016401995,
-0.0302561354,
0.0073966892,
-0.0266006645,
0.0048906524,
-0.0019713463,
0.0047689327,
-0.0496570803,
0.0286714677,
-0.0079567665,
0.0605750903,
-0.0500413738,
0.015245094,
-0.0175971258,
0.0330988057,
-0.0087976716,
0.0467474684,
0.044966083,
0.0049408902,
0.0344919823,
-0.0266266428,
0.0415629335,
-0.0292990822,
-0.0116214268,
0.0297792461,
-0.0149978744,
-0.0126435356,
0.0131098451,
0.0124105522,
-0.0241095386,
-0.0485710874,
-0.0884743184,
-0.0145166432,
-0.0256213006,
0.0601951107,
0.0335602686,
0.0182500165,
-0.0143839121,
-0.0090126917,
-0.0348443203,
0.0288291238,
-0.0215047114,
0.0115733286,
0.053909909,
-0.0148144746,
0.0011616164,
-0.0302699525,
-0.0055998662,
-0.0057499516,
0.0477013364,
-0.0328672156,
-0.0541631281,
-0.0617463812,
0.0064481902,
-0.0015778654,
0.0389618576,
0.0366570242,
-0.0835447162,
-0.0027295775,
-0.0158696324,
0.0442442447,
0.0390284397,
-0.0394010842,
-0.0064645172,
0.0193107594,
-0.0769110471,
-0.0367667638,
0.030884102,
0.0419746749,
0.0053102938,
-0.0585929342,
-0.0020162379,
-0.0081052836,
0.0734136105,
-0.0435489044,
-0.0086650997,
-0.0948417187,
0.002047492,
-0.0119653195,
-0.043282114,
0.0036368286,
0.0162180141,
-0.0261350814,
0.0129147619,
-0.0378754362,
0.00571641,
0.0671081021,
-0.0556653999,
-0.0304063,
-0.039776288,
0.0322114788,
-0.0143206678,
0.0200638883,
-0.0372970849,
0.0296010282,
0.0161624551,
-0.0704351366,
-0.0247588772,
-0.038148839,
-0.0019560813,
0.0191031639,
0.0008334569,
-0.0391241461,
0.0065905144,
-0.0245787222,
-0.0252009314,
-0.0146476412,
-0.0119291991,
-0.0277239513,
0.0457495376,
0.0095302816,
-0.0483302474,
-0.0094412286,
-0.0020736116,
0.0301565789,
0.0354600139,
-0.0294076577,
0.0086645661,
-0.0220906641,
0.0759542063,
0.0194264371,
0.0356238931,
-0.0378922336,
-0.0251415428,
0.0021516476,
-0.0220070966,
0.0349516608,
0.0417619571,
0.0042637074,
0.0244843569,
0.0558982939,
-0.0194189921,
-0.0439306833,
-0.0107591376,
0.0776119754,
-0.0227038041,
-0.0339108631,
0.085252203,
0.0087923435,
-0.0128844455,
-0.0143174464,
-0.0548947752,
0.0606029518,
-0.0048107374,
0.0398194343,
-0.0777459443,
-0.0604901798,
0.0138729271,
0.0065355538,
0.0012120208,
-0.0045401286,
-0.011162241,
-0.1480567455,
0.0208375771,
0.034424264,
-0.0612670146,
-0.0369399823,
-0.0172777791,
0.0430389158,
0.0132893827,
0.0360405333,
-0.0511298329,
-0.0039009498,
-0.0230654068,
0.0424327962,
0.0139680924,
-0.0783109516,
-0.0098912092,
-0.0292161927,
0.0545735024,
0.0487024859,
0.022145927,
-0.0494388603,
-0.0439265594,
0.0209376942,
-0.048605632,
-0.0037389263,
-0.0153944762,
0.0742366016,
0.0034611926,
-0.0581340156,
-0.0058790664,
-0.0202081669,
0.0064390539,
0.0042488314,
-0.0289883893,
0.058634717,
0.0433791094,
-0.0098510133,
0.0380122848,
-0.0049697631,
0.0179699305,
0.0536712036,
0.0484686606,
-0.0514876805,
-0.0134627521,
-0.0139079941,
0.0156471897,
-0.0798756406,
0.0173695721,
0.0433893241,
-0.0649393275,
-0.097682409,
-0.0755906403,
-0.0640251264,
0.0446590334,
0.0529725812,
0.0587523617,
0.0186343417,
-0.0183989238,
0.0133569725,
0.0027253788,
-0.0231145769,
-0.0191123281,
0.0302460548,
-0.0464733578,
-0.0416626967,
0.0383515917,
-0.0396763198,
0.0189928375,
-0.0537972674,
-0.0185669623,
-0.0794020221,
0.0078919893,
0.0249518063,
0.0177702624,
0.0250718072,
-0.0373544879,
-0.0743067265,
0.0458820276,
0.0390313379,
0.0220015142,
-0.0051308079,
0.104883045,
-0.005751526,
0.0091680158,
0.0560943671,
-0.0279102009,
0.0016470733,
0.0107227163,
0.0158514418,
-0.0600777194,
-0.0128852939,
0.00759409,
-0.0011460077,
0.0372800156,
-0.0104786819,
-0.0143307149,
-0.017657049,
0.0235068053,
-0.0123237744,
0.024794342,
-0.0398257859,
-0.0606133714,
0.0370692424,
-0.0015262823,
-0.0003570127,
0.0489201769,
-0.0498980805,
0.0217518769,
-0.0358580314,
0.0285199881,
0.012047573,
0.0792871416,
0.0035863032,
0.044223696,
-0.0077404659,
0.013307062,
0.0230348203,
0.0382269844,
-0.0401368327,
-0.0136339907,
-0.0004472082,
0.0003310449,
0.0047305492,
0.0059843613,
-0.0184562784,
0.0209802128,
0.0139879994,
0.037853688,
0.0652571619,
-0.0114244949,
0.09812399,
-0.0006659879,
-0.0095991744,
0.0034433415,
0.0111985942,
-0.0179257616,
0.0045491369,
-0.0187456496,
0.0063720816,
0.0104270075,
-0.027472619,
0.0746075958,
-0.0183769446,
0.0374678969,
-0.0065065059,
0.0231313761,
-0.021643132,
0.0077067185,
0.0758855492,
-0.020895455,
0.0125211887,
0.0319830216,
-0.0179624837,
-0.0757134482,
0.032012552,
-0.0237413235,
0.0368712991,
-0.0076178522,
0.0086935153,
0.0447300114,
-0.0199317876,
-0.0088231107,
-0.0078583453,
0.0030642417,
0.0732581466,
-0.0013205762,
-0.0055616382,
-5.704785757e-33,
-0.0377778821,
0.0304560959,
-0.0341403112,
-0.0174525455,
-0.0117792152,
-0.0006633839,
-0.0564865582,
0.0058870516,
-0.0222500283,
0.0478698276,
-0.0152670285,
-0.0081943693,
0.0391985476,
0.0187111348,
0.0067425473,
-0.0374208167,
0.0683028921,
0.0126409242,
-0.0133566773,
0.0055543985,
0.042108614,
0.042464219,
0.103047438,
-0.0174866002,
0.0083290115,
0.0150891449,
0.0105394712,
0.0086740414,
0.0601055473,
0.0265053362,
0.0136229172,
0.0572601296,
0.0073455814,
0.0290486664,
-0.0254728924,
0.0428703912,
-0.0747809932,
-0.0562026836,
0.0276829507,
0.04542467,
0.0103077861,
-0.0400073752,
0.0238457881,
-0.0214064606,
-0.0127682909,
0.0114235058,
0.0170258339,
-0.0273455847,
-0.0092491517,
-0.0417616069,
-0.1120638028,
0.0331281126,
-0.0079030292,
-0.0484756865,
0.0607820973,
0.0476262756,
0.0071815406,
-0.0371426977,
-0.0047418075,
0.0227468032,
0.0229142793,
0.0455651134,
0.0353537537,
0.017058244,
-0.0352753811,
0.0154590104,
0.0553145297,
0.014902045,
0.0495177545,
-0.0391414016,
0.0532329604,
0.005028774,
-0.01043001,
0.0558662638,
0.0434282087,
0.0058146687,
-0.0557134897,
0.0072483867,
0.0496414192,
0.0084925611,
-0.0286211129,
0.0166186169,
-0.011458124,
-0.0223319475,
0.0032549046,
-0.0474138074,
-0.030288009,
-0.005524307,
0.0123755177,
-0.0448794477,
-0.0012326558,
0.0127962101,
0.0547508933,
-0.0000980817,
-0.0165544096,
-0.0092404559,
0.0123264994,
0.0088116815,
-0.0060494663,
0.0192557983,
-0.0678796917,
-0.0498982333,
0.0429721884,
0.0459098592,
0.0182587076,
0.0194050688,
0.0731308311,
0.0227237865,
-0.053055577,
-0.0090102907,
-0.0283816811,
0.0331499875,
-0.0196519215,
0.061008092,
0.0159203801,
0.0009619243,
-0.0018058572,
0.0113433339,
0.0420259535,
-0.0081376713,
0.0063435128,
0.0200868491,
-0.005760082,
0.0383119099,
-0.0227178521,
-0.003506307,
-0.032155145,
0.0142074032,
-0.0033798106,
-0.0376071557,
-0.0100703277,
-0.0009610199,
2.405e-7,
0.0100295041,
0.0376452394,
0.0304943342,
-0.0157034397,
0.0191350691,
0.0215617009,
-0.0355620049,
0.0311508588,
0.0169310756,
0.0092633124,
-0.0146790836,
-0.0051365225,
0.0585957542,
0.0274897497,
-0.0919102728,
-0.0033880901,
-0.0020237355,
0.0366320126,
-0.0264938325,
0.0230150428,
0.0576903708,
0.0426710024,
-0.0147870267,
-0.0148651795,
0.038468577,
-0.0470875911,
0.051801376,
-0.0227894876,
-0.0114107328,
0.0121772401,
-0.0128462203,
-0.0090480791,
-0.0245708749,
0.0382579267,
-0.024025308,
0.0217337403,
-0.0022230665,
0.0023818668,
-0.0592468753,
-0.046973899,
0.0012082329,
0.0169025436,
-0.0183081105,
-0.0046066623,
0.0495670438,
-0.0231149346,
-0.0233923476,
0.0149601595,
-0.018118808,
0.031103408,
0.0097110197,
-0.0333519578,
-0.0746743679,
-0.000363985,
0.054782033,
0.0093566189,
-0.0722457021,
-0.0395623669,
-0.0226482321,
0.0176374577,
-0.011869452,
-0.0455210283,
0.0067485697,
-0.0549640954,
0.0010493991,
-0.061209742,
0.0505341217,
1.952769098e-34,
0.025663564,
0.0078455405,
0.0417026095,
0.0105391275,
-0.0155667327,
-0.0107014487,
-0.0087045599,
-0.0050508487,
0.0333606116,
-0.0186245125,
-0.0272202883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17651v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17651v2 | Self-Refine: Iterative Refinement with Self-Feedback | 2023-03-30T18:30:01 | 2023-05-25T19:13:47 | Aman Madaan, Niket Tandon, Prakhar Gupta, Skyler Hallinan, Luyu Gao, Sarah Wiegreffe, Uri Alon, Nouha Dziri, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Yiming Yang, Shashank Gupta, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Katherine Hermann, Sean Welleck, Amir Yazdanbakhsh, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Like humans, large language models (LLMs) do not always generate the best
output on their first try. Motivated by how humans refine their written text,
we introduce Self-Refine, an approach for improving initial outputs from LLMs
through iterative feedback and refinement. The main idea is to generate an
initial output using an LLMs; then, the same LLMs provides feedback for its
output and uses it to refine itself, iteratively. Self-Refine does not require
any supervised training data, additional training, or reinforcement learning,
and instead uses a single LLM as the generator, refiner, and feedback provider.
We evaluate Self-Refine across 7 diverse tasks, ranging from dialog response
generation to mathematical reasoning, using state-of-the-art (GPT-3.5, ChatGPT,
and GPT-4) LLMs. Across all evaluated tasks, outputs generated with Self-Refine
are preferred by humans and automatic metrics over those generated with the
same LLM using conventional one-step generation, improving by ~20% absolute on
average in task performance. Our work demonstrates that even state-of-the-art
LLMs like GPT-4 can be further improved at test time using our simple,
standalone approach. | [
0.0149389002,
0.0478515849,
0.0052529182,
0.0195499454,
-0.0309743956,
-0.0136090945,
-0.0204882175,
-0.0117707634,
0.0075173196,
-0.0495474041,
-0.0492383651,
-0.0050298125,
-0.0117334006,
0.0207090098,
0.0454769433,
-0.0444009639,
0.0509575196,
-0.0369291268,
0.0083370898,
0.0021465295,
0.005229339,
0.0185122304,
-0.0205050893,
0.0479581542,
-0.0236117337,
-0.0328351706,
0.003082196,
0.0077850646,
-0.0265294015,
-0.0282922313,
0.0375381261,
0.0750690252,
0.003622114,
0.0356584378,
0.000002082,
-0.032659322,
0.0021292449,
-0.0229544807,
-0.0135219786,
0.0329274796,
0.0340321809,
0.0033726681,
-0.0150146838,
0.032768365,
-0.0728048906,
0.0021960211,
0.0053355028,
0.0298095811,
0.0937358737,
0.0963962004,
0.0194292367,
-0.0195309725,
0.0051635667,
-0.0346990936,
0.0012230378,
-0.0255714525,
-0.0062595853,
0.0139952563,
-0.019916743,
0.020952519,
-0.0103304842,
0.0309411343,
0.057118021,
-0.0581531934,
0.0120266341,
0.0371544994,
-0.0362425596,
-0.0095740315,
-0.0331518054,
0.0717411414,
-0.0146980463,
-0.0292798933,
0.0005025882,
-0.0067639477,
0.0089775678,
-0.0556240939,
-0.0436922796,
0.0197848659,
0.0189795736,
0.0443855338,
-0.0332844593,
-0.0145058176,
0.0279944427,
0.0276495498,
-0.0015181971,
0.060670387,
0.0004068547,
-0.0165981837,
-0.0109937685,
0.0113388067,
-0.0227507874,
-0.0633974895,
-0.0032507977,
0.0417839736,
-0.0468172655,
0.0152714606,
-0.0602708571,
-0.0298774876,
0.0097638099,
0.0227843318,
0.0491751544,
0.0443984903,
0.0069019743,
0.0291110501,
-0.0228490122,
0.0559084676,
-0.0000621255,
0.0362591408,
-0.0400535949,
0.0278005134,
-0.0465885326,
-0.0306967366,
-0.0484193116,
0.0417474993,
-0.006871236,
-0.0177386161,
-0.0515210517,
0.0338080674,
-0.0066251042,
0.0082291095,
0.0276583862,
0.003401191,
-0.0275473483,
-0.029433338,
-0.0315664783,
0.0248898957,
-0.0266219433,
-0.0022593923,
0.0516881198,
-0.0527764671,
-0.023129683,
0.0205956493,
-0.0159299932,
-0.0102862203,
-0.0193555262,
0.0649996623,
-0.0470000692,
-0.0089169629,
-0.0459173471,
-0.0479070321,
-0.0127768572,
-0.0783177614,
-0.0089593567,
-0.0544661693,
0.0046506361,
-0.0105762072,
-0.0301072896,
-0.0418172255,
0.0178496446,
0.0046382118,
0.0191453025,
0.0594423264,
-0.0254619047,
0.0163028762,
0.0528469346,
0.014617838,
-0.0012895628,
0.0517404936,
0.0631765351,
0.0105135944,
0.0098092807,
-0.0056809708,
0.0324564427,
0.0398753211,
0.0305583086,
-0.0110822814,
-0.0052558072,
0.0037995684,
-0.0321628302,
0.0530987084,
0.0467740037,
0.051707942,
-0.0595210902,
0.0145948632,
0.0681884438,
0.0228839424,
0.0222189855,
0.0227732286,
0.0259255394,
0.0404891483,
0.0151324449,
0.0120591773,
-0.0656033233,
0.0380612276,
0.0213149395,
0.0266133323,
0.0503208674,
-0.0191116035,
-0.0399312675,
-0.0844801888,
0.011168737,
-0.0008200936,
0.0096349353,
-0.0104002003,
0.0363045707,
0.0577623025,
-0.0397913866,
0.043369215,
0.0043215165,
-0.068811968,
-0.0071515539,
-0.0602499656,
0.0608190671,
0.0763247758,
0.067348212,
-0.0128268925,
-0.0677938387,
-0.0062955371,
-0.0033033565,
0.0652002543,
0.0447480083,
0.0028702649,
-0.0178723652,
-0.0490955636,
-0.0106910272,
-0.0220115408,
0.0154500781,
0.0105257416,
0.0515254252,
-0.0311229099,
0.0474291258,
-0.0202396959,
-0.0120310094,
0.0328356586,
-0.0086069731,
-0.0313895307,
0.0499932468,
-0.0138652008,
0.0188567173,
0.0008034642,
-0.00125737,
0.0467325933,
0.0246603303,
-0.0135410968,
-0.0236782487,
0.0013609214,
-0.0736185014,
-0.0553510413,
0.0668034703,
0.0194020011,
-0.0349570289,
0.0316366851,
-0.0560590103,
-0.0400099605,
0.0345293358,
-0.0355870686,
-0.010354097,
-0.0534880497,
0.0313968547,
0.0311788879,
0.003182736,
-0.0230214279,
0.0220602248,
0.0061954278,
-0.0099720592,
-0.0064027384,
0.0320343561,
0.0149781629,
-0.0407597758,
-0.0084095486,
-0.0372854136,
-0.0256934259,
0.0284160208,
0.0167816691,
0.0469539315,
-0.0438410416,
-0.038301982,
-0.0813873336,
0.0091974791,
-0.019206116,
0.0094201984,
0.0271053351,
-0.0121254763,
-0.0061011054,
-0.0377690196,
-0.0326885767,
-0.005033195,
0.0475977324,
-0.0018197916,
0.0519685261,
-0.012049919,
-0.0032191924,
-0.0511405692,
-0.0003345939,
-0.0053413054,
-0.0059823105,
0.0058539878,
0.0422936715,
-0.0731041059,
0.0092012202,
-0.0531108268,
0.0278173983,
0.0068701608,
-0.0374431461,
0.0388691686,
-0.0120122135,
0.0769246742,
0.0605992451,
0.0393994488,
0.0043071345,
0.0271065664,
-0.0134391896,
-0.0658692494,
0.0291736275,
-0.0135108307,
-0.0342707783,
-0.0043306081,
-0.014137282,
0.0088186059,
0.0825128183,
0.005554602,
0.0103333648,
-0.0484067164,
0.0479657203,
-0.0064249439,
-0.0314522535,
-0.0232473165,
-0.0155728878,
-0.0494345203,
0.0226929281,
-0.0335492566,
-0.0594803169,
0.0660632104,
-0.0352299921,
-0.0087304739,
-0.0293354169,
0.0263232086,
-0.0290704239,
0.0447195359,
-0.0102207894,
-0.0148654431,
0.0024844098,
-0.0165204275,
-0.0332468823,
-0.0407051481,
0.023753535,
-0.0464617647,
0.0909646153,
-0.0672644898,
0.0202980191,
-0.0025395148,
-0.0845970958,
-0.0548890121,
-0.0204184242,
-0.0064640022,
0.0129586542,
0.0008992025,
-0.0214796495,
0.0140376994,
-0.0108083086,
0.0172808804,
0.0642026737,
-0.038196262,
-0.0235226471,
-0.0211897194,
0.0276434328,
0.055924885,
0.0369054228,
0.0061632344,
-0.0222773049,
0.017191099,
0.0516411886,
0.052081082,
0.0019782861,
-0.0472381338,
-0.0096104061,
-0.01442979,
-0.0371504277,
0.0117210178,
0.0149273369,
0.0489848815,
-0.0825484172,
-0.0254197083,
0.1405786276,
0.0162937287,
-0.0123581346,
-0.000710874,
-0.0220314208,
0.0610545948,
0.021116998,
0.0234218054,
-0.0864603668,
-0.0353839509,
0.0030041086,
0.0350374244,
0.0306582432,
-0.0201248918,
-0.0215632506,
-0.1151378974,
0.0525340661,
0.0236500371,
-0.0146511886,
0.0094611207,
-0.0035881861,
-0.0226452015,
-0.0045978217,
0.0278606974,
0.0703471899,
-0.0059065418,
0.0184717719,
0.0208186693,
-0.0198259465,
-0.0208334699,
0.0071220226,
-0.0336949565,
0.0364209563,
0.0553119965,
0.0148283485,
0.0308867898,
-0.0167283118,
0.0720110908,
0.0148106813,
0.0078828959,
-0.0238329675,
0.0171353724,
0.0109781083,
-0.008296676,
-0.0262374096,
0.0318890177,
-0.0270616487,
-0.0101345088,
0.0130269201,
0.043639455,
-0.0210094843,
-0.0137920277,
-0.0082294941,
0.0085458811,
-0.0164956022,
0.0612703338,
0.0533875972,
-0.0426210575,
-0.0720488206,
-0.0329622179,
0.0034087524,
-0.0642103925,
-0.029744057,
-0.0139701553,
0.023013927,
0.0116228731,
-0.0918633863,
-0.0493355133,
0.0073315543,
0.027463777,
-0.0109838564,
-0.0154534783,
0.0010963926,
-0.0310074165,
-0.0325659141,
0.0130214151,
-0.0398877598,
-0.0108050825,
-0.0761264116,
-0.0031311286,
0.0067942338,
-0.0228695273,
-0.0141309379,
0.0613582358,
-0.0868951827,
-0.0594097562,
-0.0307385456,
0.0835937634,
0.0201520007,
0.0600242354,
-0.0127506908,
-0.0356166884,
0.0156691931,
0.0303089805,
-0.0657585114,
0.0260390472,
0.0179207269,
0.0295080226,
-0.0011331056,
0.0531416684,
-0.0122729046,
0.0296906363,
0.0073978691,
0.0488164276,
0.0072764428,
-0.0455897227,
0.0262049194,
0.0291511975,
0.0293735117,
-0.0172018781,
0.0551172309,
-0.0186237562,
0.0190706998,
-0.0170416832,
-0.025786601,
-0.0586401559,
0.0536151305,
0.0236674119,
-0.0383054502,
-0.0113965077,
-0.0099644456,
-0.03347449,
0.0446316898,
-0.0167261902,
-0.033748474,
-0.0381335467,
0.0023883302,
0.022208089,
-0.0304567907,
-0.0035592446,
0.0262784548,
-0.0014841167,
0.03049553,
-0.0185727365,
0.0594124533,
0.0174185187,
-0.0088885259,
-0.0148405721,
0.0141501883,
-0.0281051379,
-0.037781097,
-0.028474614,
0.0216617901,
0.0248743277,
0.0430641919,
0.0595757999,
-0.0466418639,
-0.0017815375,
-0.0239497516,
0.0275052991,
-0.0114244306,
-0.0148319071,
0.0133115156,
0.009787024,
-0.0297832862,
-0.0265116692,
0.0862673596,
0.0021971844,
0.0160944816,
0.0140108652,
0.031306278,
-0.0587129705,
-0.0425651409,
-0.0130386241,
-0.0178138725,
-0.0131746344,
-0.0008101874,
-0.0042116619,
-0.0616997555,
0.0137893707,
0.0434283391,
-0.0222704969,
-0.0148380399,
0.0520667285,
0.0605979711,
-0.0457191616,
-0.0459009074,
-0.0301961713,
0.0181595534,
-0.0156468917,
-0.040627826,
-0.0341954418,
-6.540590893e-33,
-0.0405777581,
-0.0341241471,
0.0534849986,
0.016954856,
-0.0272278246,
-0.0285474546,
-0.0546185449,
0.0196346715,
0.0178934652,
0.0228472333,
-0.0237876903,
0.0258418117,
0.0106963776,
0.0447296426,
0.0102165062,
-0.0058793463,
0.0523197167,
-0.025770165,
-0.0536605604,
0.0367770903,
-0.0108831814,
0.029603567,
0.0562183633,
-0.061860323,
-0.0095428461,
0.0170075838,
-0.0436309017,
0.0457930863,
-0.0345966257,
0.050927788,
-0.0101069268,
0.0267226845,
0.0235262979,
-0.0523909032,
-0.0437391996,
0.0110038426,
-0.0683978945,
-0.0302824024,
0.0189535562,
-0.0087805269,
-0.0766705051,
-0.0126377977,
0.0765525997,
-0.0275465269,
-0.040239051,
0.004670782,
0.0046961871,
-0.0014007835,
-0.0193647332,
0.0206783358,
-0.051266104,
0.0277798232,
-0.0057224524,
-0.0564502403,
0.0021340072,
0.0207204185,
-0.0260763355,
-0.0357907526,
-0.0548922494,
0.014424745,
0.0291786436,
0.0681970641,
0.0604825281,
-0.001465346,
0.0095215375,
0.0388972983,
0.0064868568,
0.0108109144,
-0.0450312197,
-0.0453408584,
0.0235875901,
0.0453075096,
0.0428074077,
0.0310815331,
-0.0176160596,
-0.0009153102,
-0.0292834528,
0.0155973313,
0.0000292636,
0.0467873923,
0.0270550195,
0.0106913792,
0.0022589678,
-0.0151384398,
-0.046301458,
0.023949353,
-0.028850425,
-0.0364238583,
0.0414205603,
0.0483597741,
-0.005173021,
-0.0243932158,
0.0024072679,
-0.0029861389,
-0.0176274013,
0.0162148476,
-0.0378394015,
0.010922052,
-0.0148497205,
0.0116053009,
-0.0507385358,
-0.0058052936,
0.0324707739,
0.0316137485,
-0.008430616,
0.0204147566,
0.0236763544,
0.0287015624,
-0.0738457143,
0.0181954037,
-0.0391278304,
0.0593076907,
-0.0149627039,
-0.0089172572,
0.0272551868,
0.0115882698,
-0.0182600059,
0.0533913486,
-0.0006968866,
-0.0297345221,
-0.0426343195,
0.019642897,
0.028008718,
0.0339277983,
-0.0167568587,
0.035404779,
-0.0183649492,
0.0069350703,
-0.0020274394,
-0.0404846817,
-0.0083410265,
0.0144889718,
2.669e-7,
0.0402064286,
0.0530928485,
0.0397581942,
0.0346060023,
0.0473298617,
0.0331242159,
-0.0127365105,
0.0023618401,
0.0075104688,
-0.0226855893,
0.0165895745,
0.03892041,
0.0585860424,
0.0021213416,
-0.08408425,
0.0109638581,
-0.1149676666,
0.0079707578,
-0.0345409624,
-0.058249373,
0.0158256311,
0.0731880441,
0.0150160417,
-0.0183032248,
0.0112232929,
-0.0510312803,
0.0852759555,
-0.0043597487,
-0.0164530985,
0.052948121,
0.0284368861,
0.0224530119,
0.0085381353,
-0.0101606362,
-0.0161147919,
-0.008395208,
-0.0170969833,
0.0866489336,
-0.0019364597,
-0.0138686933,
-0.0016780592,
-0.0082558123,
0.0278987773,
-0.0712479055,
0.050406687,
-0.0602997094,
-0.0013000806,
-0.036560595,
0.0015494191,
-0.0358473659,
0.0303534176,
-0.0389280505,
-0.02619013,
0.0331567153,
0.0412915498,
0.0217206758,
-0.0194507167,
-0.0755855069,
-0.0621012673,
0.0046547111,
-0.0677218586,
0.0028514806,
-0.087025702,
0.0120115932,
0.0039736647,
-0.0527730398,
-0.0081204036,
2.313455764e-34,
0.0380174704,
-0.0277785119,
0.0368164368,
0.0385473929,
0.0269064531,
0.0303562097,
-0.0049971147,
0.0167002678,
0.0232924987,
-0.0330898538,
-0.0281331837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17650v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17650v3 | Comparing Abstractive Summaries Generated by ChatGPT to Real Summaries Through Blinded Reviewers and Text Classification Algorithms | 2023-03-30T18:28:33 | 2023-08-28T09:34:59 | Mayank Soni, Vincent Wade | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have gathered significant attention due to their
impressive performance on a variety of tasks. ChatGPT, developed by OpenAI, is
a recent addition to the family of language models and is being called a
disruptive technology by a few, owing to its human-like text-generation
capabilities. Although, many anecdotal examples across the internet have
evaluated ChatGPT's strength and weakness, only a few systematic research
studies exist. To contribute to the body of literature of systematic research
on ChatGPT, we evaluate the performance of ChatGPT on Abstractive Summarization
by the means of automated metrics and blinded human reviewers. We also build
automatic text classifiers to detect ChatGPT generated summaries. We found that
while text classification algorithms can distinguish between real and generated
summaries, humans are unable to distinguish between real summaries and those
produced by ChatGPT. | [
0.0392717011,
0.0238807574,
0.0011641133,
0.0069112834,
-0.0393658653,
0.0126229627,
0.0015062221,
0.0045033428,
0.0123796994,
-0.0768634379,
-0.0217981506,
-0.077279754,
0.0267080888,
0.0448122434,
0.0237537473,
-0.0738415197,
0.0282154717,
-0.0070860623,
0.0230373386,
0.0163046122,
0.0150237754,
0.0049066702,
0.026953036,
0.0654651225,
0.0397136696,
-0.0223478433,
0.0012224984,
-0.0249034967,
0.0070813829,
-0.0068987161,
-0.0029998305,
0.0350394771,
-0.0053711981,
0.0493837446,
0.000001748,
-0.0353449509,
0.0096894568,
0.0028489239,
0.0480848402,
0.0541450456,
0.0721693411,
-0.0040142424,
0.0052261748,
0.0557026044,
-0.0169247855,
-0.0284616873,
0.0258203745,
0.0881407633,
0.0642138198,
0.064865917,
-0.0145615293,
-0.0072821691,
0.0481608212,
-0.015053004,
-0.0188833978,
0.0035387785,
0.0074196244,
0.0247352142,
-0.0202512257,
0.0018282348,
0.0312731564,
0.0240861569,
0.0176688135,
-0.0150341084,
0.0055619022,
0.0528384708,
-0.0924645886,
-0.0112710195,
0.0094477795,
0.0400005467,
0.0066670221,
-0.0343415551,
0.0205086619,
0.0123986797,
-0.0040086489,
-0.0175378397,
-0.0653488263,
0.0731037855,
-0.0285307392,
0.0357843526,
-0.0044770637,
0.0297275726,
0.0052446784,
0.0369533002,
0.0006683729,
0.0195152257,
0.0063528758,
-0.017084375,
-0.0165299568,
0.0290551279,
-0.0410542898,
-0.0941251516,
0.0003326721,
0.0366039015,
-0.0071238587,
-0.0116959242,
-0.0478665382,
-0.0478853248,
0.0288992096,
-0.0729624629,
0.0237936955,
0.029101938,
0.0072317896,
-0.0051496718,
-0.0228142515,
0.0323225819,
0.0223025884,
0.0409203246,
-0.0514312834,
-0.0004763031,
-0.02121149,
-0.0279367454,
-0.0324922688,
0.0465385988,
-0.0290833991,
-0.0381466039,
-0.0647403076,
0.035745468,
-0.0064421277,
-0.0335101448,
-0.0054440778,
0.0132609615,
-0.0169225261,
0.0066177533,
-0.0014683168,
-0.0220201835,
-0.0025549475,
-0.0128073152,
0.037179403,
-0.0191356782,
0.0079538608,
0.0348696485,
-0.0042406586,
0.022650389,
-0.0316849612,
0.0604625531,
-0.0297088344,
-0.023188889,
0.0009478863,
-0.0415640362,
-0.0211257543,
-0.0492085665,
-0.0022155608,
-0.0749981254,
-0.0187521689,
0.0169920605,
-0.0139889186,
0.0078899348,
0.0082584117,
0.0393419079,
-0.0126166372,
0.0172915366,
-0.0420379452,
0.0084650917,
0.0432747677,
0.0234766845,
-0.0123778973,
0.0468449295,
0.0409896486,
0.038953159,
0.0351465382,
0.0090112928,
0.0469815694,
0.0200988092,
0.0093452474,
-0.0026443389,
0.0027322809,
-0.0224617813,
-0.0220961161,
-0.0142337028,
0.0073039979,
0.0996241122,
-0.030122729,
0.0312727056,
0.0695437491,
0.0386242345,
0.0091716284,
0.0562173463,
0.0153414914,
0.0383142643,
0.0382619314,
0.0717493445,
-0.0005495858,
0.0301646348,
-0.0484124422,
0.0642702058,
0.0793871433,
0.0108450158,
-0.0323610082,
-0.0431257859,
-0.0213916581,
-0.0103840288,
0.0200468898,
-0.032733988,
0.0257108901,
0.0082624126,
-0.0261181016,
0.014011289,
0.0402363129,
-0.0626023412,
0.0134466961,
-0.0758436546,
0.0195064917,
0.0405428708,
0.0638209358,
-0.003538196,
0.002220779,
0.006601308,
-0.0120036677,
0.0616604798,
0.0547605157,
-0.008509771,
-0.0441735834,
-0.039672818,
-0.0056725992,
-0.0110678654,
0.0179959182,
-0.0041522849,
0.0272013173,
-0.0121033937,
0.0436250381,
-0.0180974752,
-0.0784386024,
0.036968071,
-0.0165299997,
-0.0041701165,
0.0027249234,
-0.0317212194,
0.0275170188,
0.013969671,
-0.0234330241,
0.0459268354,
-0.0039148931,
-0.0215857327,
-0.0510496609,
0.0223577861,
-0.0286976285,
-0.0288541075,
0.0171046648,
-0.0568189248,
0.0142908124,
0.0420191772,
-0.0084309708,
-0.0533090383,
0.019533556,
-0.0591361858,
0.034650702,
-0.0657368749,
0.0028144633,
0.0081249187,
-0.0043796143,
-0.0069216797,
0.065596506,
0.0154915238,
-0.0111473259,
0.0385828726,
-0.0225100927,
0.0036329236,
-0.0178753082,
-0.0188848935,
0.0054329233,
0.0118482746,
0.0299719572,
0.0424992032,
0.0188257322,
-0.0190629996,
-0.0447517149,
-0.139556244,
0.0014885198,
-0.0178557318,
0.0145157445,
0.0583663732,
-0.0099324342,
-0.0017374166,
0.0334505066,
-0.062681891,
-0.0036657269,
0.0311127733,
0.0111011649,
0.0297739021,
-0.0009220743,
0.0299177654,
-0.0506988317,
-0.0097032487,
-0.0143146226,
0.0509841554,
0.0317095593,
-0.0404386856,
-0.054026112,
0.0416797474,
-0.0307345539,
-0.015487846,
0.0097887665,
-0.0227998905,
0.0113909934,
0.0110151591,
0.0524794795,
0.005521344,
0.0546934977,
0.0110418098,
0.0645355433,
0.0099934302,
-0.0071715899,
-0.0260305256,
-0.0278465394,
0.0045353556,
0.0462609157,
-0.0440752245,
0.0186832137,
0.0602044836,
0.0264495779,
-0.0016098935,
-0.0583810247,
0.0104717817,
-0.0479075797,
0.0092272088,
-0.0517558828,
-0.0357398987,
-0.0435342118,
0.0208318867,
-0.0225307234,
-0.0377393104,
0.0526165999,
-0.0410860628,
0.0104804225,
-0.0722603127,
-0.0026570112,
-0.0652333647,
0.0559399463,
0.0067193611,
0.0248743538,
0.0000258864,
-0.0089017861,
-0.0407708064,
0.0015736533,
-0.0035377943,
-0.0142371375,
0.0542971492,
-0.0381061658,
0.011410174,
-0.0352119915,
-0.0004816575,
-0.0254683364,
-0.05329163,
-0.0099795973,
0.0377143584,
0.0538657904,
-0.0055198688,
-0.0283332188,
0.0519957952,
0.0243602972,
0.051884234,
-0.052896101,
-0.0231287982,
-0.0038889132,
0.0515357889,
0.0793219134,
-0.033183828,
0.0295539144,
-0.0521190725,
0.0439229533,
0.0865030736,
0.0215704422,
0.0005802745,
-0.0060837795,
-0.0585707948,
-0.010626371,
-0.045071058,
-0.0082958434,
0.0096316068,
0.0486130044,
-0.0304931607,
-0.0124573531,
0.1128300279,
0.0249946006,
-0.0915054008,
-0.0093370453,
0.016041223,
0.0581545234,
-0.0113393329,
0.0020350022,
-0.0721055344,
0.0036651096,
0.0070485789,
0.0357032232,
-0.0178699363,
0.0006194186,
-0.0200121757,
-0.1028917804,
0.0310583804,
0.0213592909,
-0.0900046676,
0.0016798677,
-0.0037472672,
-0.0031860094,
0.0073726983,
0.0112194717,
0.0250991601,
-0.0392669141,
0.0123353181,
0.0243786331,
-0.0925889015,
-0.0026935646,
-0.0038245993,
-0.0329366252,
0.033689592,
0.0422770455,
0.0383451991,
-0.0049717133,
0.0152971484,
0.0855053142,
-0.055454623,
0.0015197647,
0.0099459253,
0.0757145435,
-0.0032296109,
0.01946369,
-0.0399885289,
0.0261882022,
-0.0082661407,
-0.0152168917,
0.0207710434,
0.0216245912,
-0.0160268061,
-0.0359283462,
-0.0430086367,
0.0469731688,
-0.0263299737,
0.0741795972,
0.0457840599,
-0.039461825,
-0.0590115152,
-0.0229667407,
0.0131668486,
-0.0499576367,
-0.0397395566,
-0.0207268186,
-0.0132943206,
-0.0328130014,
-0.1062146872,
-0.0685422793,
0.0066251433,
-0.0152639877,
0.0034617574,
-0.0035450107,
0.0120073594,
0.0055208993,
-0.0079612769,
0.0042374297,
-0.0154889496,
-0.020974949,
-0.0441598259,
-0.0384845473,
0.0360451601,
-0.0483186878,
0.0002039321,
0.0307674333,
-0.0611058138,
-0.0606872737,
-0.0214760713,
0.0253621321,
0.0312990136,
0.0269413497,
0.0060767736,
-0.0082829781,
0.031728588,
0.024153376,
-0.0012507925,
0.0315947197,
-0.0126914056,
0.0409004651,
0.0013015984,
0.0100296624,
-0.0409230515,
0.0342845507,
-0.0167734325,
0.0164709557,
-0.0038677757,
-0.0284648929,
0.0177962985,
0.0341886654,
0.0180179868,
-0.0375124924,
0.027057169,
-0.0441832282,
-0.0301415827,
-0.051323019,
-0.006307587,
-0.0515228957,
0.0135117406,
-0.0190502293,
0.0135002322,
-0.0169218071,
0.037559405,
-0.0284430236,
0.0306044538,
-0.0315652415,
-0.0078301197,
-0.0245919731,
0.0095025105,
-0.0325855128,
-0.0204293691,
-0.0651177317,
-0.0330003873,
-0.0505835451,
0.0059835115,
-0.0104639586,
0.0411863178,
0.0156199774,
-0.0027875109,
0.0004835981,
0.0503098592,
-0.0890651718,
-0.009064056,
-0.0479909368,
0.0639557764,
0.0349166952,
-0.0093132611,
0.0743649453,
-0.0481323898,
-0.0041237525,
-0.0320531614,
0.0452255085,
0.0068650027,
-0.0127676185,
-0.0346152224,
0.0007089067,
-0.0247154031,
-0.0120923165,
0.0979335532,
-0.0109319026,
-0.0162463952,
0.0228082109,
-0.0296071321,
-0.0224596504,
-0.0206175502,
-0.0190363061,
0.0167271849,
-0.0081754271,
-0.0330535918,
-0.0569221899,
-0.0322728865,
0.0040499321,
0.0300261397,
0.0436585583,
-0.0247133188,
0.0185004324,
0.0400774777,
0.0080023296,
-0.0049247346,
-0.0689695552,
-0.0062606586,
-0.028780058,
0.0348830894,
-0.0368249975,
-5.81495823e-33,
-0.0282321237,
-0.0304437801,
-0.0049173492,
0.0589562431,
-0.0394840352,
0.0195587501,
-0.0701831579,
0.0376845971,
0.0467463471,
0.0015083082,
-0.0205900278,
0.0124257123,
0.0074789203,
0.0269301236,
0.015270317,
0.0206232462,
0.0304629318,
-0.0248161908,
-0.0344765596,
0.056137301,
0.0291898102,
-0.0195039175,
0.0080901757,
-0.0448436551,
0.0379609019,
-0.0287288148,
-0.0183638427,
-0.0402697176,
-0.0149787366,
0.0382221714,
-0.0416006893,
0.0286088847,
0.0483484045,
0.0117732957,
-0.0394458771,
0.02125871,
-0.0204074625,
-0.0031810617,
0.0147071807,
-0.0318086185,
-0.0582759455,
-0.0242723711,
0.0494870245,
-0.0149295293,
-0.0322048999,
-0.0255444534,
0.0515650958,
-0.0402176976,
-0.0345339701,
-0.0668831691,
-0.0557666309,
0.0318510868,
0.0181330815,
-0.0169205442,
-0.0083723664,
0.0449775159,
-0.0190243609,
-0.0141614778,
-0.0385063253,
0.0333000906,
0.051591076,
0.0180572271,
0.0186798461,
0.0123275043,
-0.000494332,
0.0677871928,
0.0305942912,
0.0220675655,
-0.0525879078,
-0.0132096661,
-0.001134899,
-0.0060640625,
0.0510838851,
0.0275173541,
0.0275333468,
-0.0053200573,
-0.0290869176,
0.0680264235,
-0.0236736033,
-0.0062635532,
0.0707159191,
-0.0194411892,
-0.0244247839,
-0.0276290495,
0.0102192126,
-0.0027471571,
-0.0270310231,
-0.0210138634,
0.0176525246,
0.0119556282,
-0.0223542787,
-0.0571381599,
0.0173404403,
-0.0446600616,
0.0317987613,
-0.0124004483,
-0.0613650121,
0.0472288057,
-0.0141663803,
-0.0149749238,
-0.0561563708,
-0.0042732186,
0.0118399523,
0.0455186181,
-0.0093884505,
0.0151651204,
0.0479323044,
-0.0005726009,
-0.0498356,
0.0120104477,
-0.0114214579,
0.0344732031,
0.0057911747,
0.0170146786,
0.0063759256,
-0.0188605189,
0.0081459004,
0.0278756525,
-0.011520423,
0.0229187086,
-0.0456086844,
0.024184214,
0.0096411137,
0.0127754631,
-0.0228004679,
0.0476778261,
-0.0188633315,
0.0188544951,
0.0385943912,
-0.0300634746,
-0.0192589667,
-0.007535256,
2.353e-7,
0.047632467,
0.0488387868,
0.0338547267,
0.0035893486,
0.0141732823,
0.0155413365,
-0.0023463764,
0.0253219176,
0.0389979109,
0.0341872498,
0.0374965817,
0.0204881039,
0.0530952625,
0.041811768,
-0.0852278918,
0.0232697818,
-0.1246138886,
-0.0049472572,
-0.032242991,
-0.0051714098,
0.0768706203,
0.0747361183,
-0.0293189846,
0.0041918322,
-0.0065148231,
-0.0454050526,
0.0904401317,
-0.0077083376,
-0.0361671038,
0.0286953524,
0.0602258183,
0.0325625576,
-0.0010836902,
-0.011091508,
-0.0093880175,
-0.0379742905,
0.0481045246,
0.0419226065,
0.0096947728,
-0.0100459931,
0.0485574901,
0.0019780861,
0.0268590786,
-0.0476760454,
0.0648475587,
-0.0579447113,
-0.0264058802,
-0.0501998849,
0.0010078772,
-0.0133016929,
0.0108975545,
-0.0049292739,
-0.0195052028,
0.0376700275,
-0.0246107522,
-0.0216323137,
-0.0000535484,
-0.0654204711,
-0.0652956516,
-0.0066632316,
-0.0391352661,
-0.0343831405,
-0.0368537344,
0.0098488983,
0.0024977038,
-0.0650103241,
0.0054408377,
2.328512194e-34,
0.0823652074,
-0.0242788345,
-0.0323509499,
-0.0099982694,
0.0260053724,
-0.0068606776,
0.0622176193,
0.0081511429,
-0.0055608968,
-0.0564126782,
-0.0231243875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17649v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17649v3 | Aligning a medium-size GPT model in English to a small closed domain in Spanish | 2023-03-30T18:27:15 | 2023-05-30T21:48:49 | Oscar R. Navarrete-Parra, Victor Uc-Cetina, Jorge Reyes-Magana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose a methodology to align a medium-sized GPT model,
originally trained in English for an open domain, to a small closed domain in
Spanish. The application for which the model is finely tuned is the question
answering task. To achieve this we also needed to train and implement another
neural network (which we called the reward model) that could score and
determine whether an answer is appropriate for a given question. This component
served to improve the decoding and generation of the answers of the system.
Numerical metrics such as BLEU and perplexity were used to evaluate the model,
and human judgment was also used to compare the decoding technique with others.
Finally, the results favored the proposed method, and it was determined that it
is feasible to use a reward model to align the generation of responses. | [
0.0074122217,
0.0514589809,
-0.0197898354,
0.027085986,
-0.0273784641,
0.0007414573,
-0.0368910246,
-0.01505832,
-0.0348883197,
0.0251553375,
-0.0375420675,
-0.0115116406,
-0.00457471,
-0.0047823386,
0.0077592866,
-0.0621393956,
0.0369832292,
-0.0033136324,
-0.0059732152,
-0.0424845144,
0.0117770927,
-0.0015748111,
-0.0171864089,
0.0361991338,
0.0266263131,
-0.0379504785,
-0.0236090347,
-0.0374506451,
0.0486984029,
0.0000716285,
-0.0061532361,
0.0350998715,
-0.0075408691,
0.0475320816,
0.0000018434,
-0.0453351773,
0.0001284499,
-0.0076589454,
0.0007185689,
-0.0051884037,
-0.0108799674,
0.0014495463,
-0.0444955416,
0.0092021488,
-0.0861407369,
-0.0465947278,
0.0824855193,
0.0355082937,
0.0660796016,
0.0463468097,
0.00508413,
-0.063755542,
0.0487747379,
-0.0083060591,
0.0059501831,
-0.0560403652,
-0.0095271505,
0.0358841307,
0.0158248097,
0.0063247867,
-0.0274889283,
0.0194099378,
0.0424467176,
0.0042975643,
-0.0353116877,
0.0268618204,
0.0128631881,
0.0091187172,
-0.0255747028,
0.0091723055,
-0.0123029808,
-0.0168922283,
-0.0428447872,
-0.0038501127,
0.0110324193,
-0.0176982265,
-0.0268805809,
-0.0068168622,
-0.000675565,
0.0477746762,
0.0643427074,
0.0084477589,
0.0036511545,
-0.0028746065,
-0.0159385744,
0.0717963651,
0.0145013519,
-0.0544033833,
-0.0006664144,
0.0372596048,
-0.0283746328,
-0.0194387697,
0.0288525354,
0.059556216,
0.0228355769,
0.0296448562,
0.0013905284,
-0.0351413973,
-0.0128277112,
-0.0241829231,
-0.0018705392,
0.0550828241,
0.0278373044,
0.0040351781,
-0.000524446,
0.1069099829,
-0.0550215431,
0.0164620765,
-0.085832946,
-0.012553283,
-0.0648057163,
-0.0385033898,
-0.053508129,
0.0573585853,
-0.0038830838,
0.0093604531,
-0.0588335581,
0.0126479678,
0.0089237653,
-0.0268921405,
0.0548863709,
0.0295559652,
-0.043047592,
0.0168136694,
-0.0469055846,
0.0622660145,
-0.0725042447,
-0.0039086267,
0.0166432373,
-0.0427844487,
-0.0054681413,
-0.0024629685,
-0.0097936979,
-0.0448157378,
-0.0030789555,
0.0680112243,
-0.0276042689,
0.0059216032,
-0.0298618451,
-0.0231095571,
-0.0165172573,
-0.0740611404,
0.0140420888,
-0.0447176248,
0.028801173,
-0.0066525331,
-0.0185637884,
-0.0135389352,
-0.010409086,
0.0190343503,
0.0043113427,
0.0378031246,
0.0153606562,
0.0111190379,
0.0528580323,
-0.021011401,
0.0149420826,
0.0600951277,
0.0318085477,
0.0160622653,
-0.0047527188,
-0.0398086794,
-0.0065957461,
0.044502344,
0.0318967141,
-0.0174093265,
0.0190147758,
0.0021906351,
0.0208413322,
0.049445115,
0.0547524318,
0.0361132286,
-0.0222148187,
0.0331888422,
0.0896964073,
0.0521999002,
-0.0084060961,
0.0387755819,
0.0317174979,
-0.0124593563,
0.0153850224,
0.0576866679,
-0.0149702439,
0.012158623,
-0.042846445,
0.0300217122,
-0.0021925862,
0.0252404436,
-0.0484066419,
-0.0407849327,
0.0244003441,
-0.0006770926,
0.0300113931,
0.0157193057,
0.0529125035,
0.0097416937,
-0.0524572767,
0.0145876054,
-0.0309505742,
-0.0143322945,
0.0124734975,
-0.0572870485,
0.0434473865,
0.00721739,
0.019945411,
0.0132084154,
-0.0281875078,
-0.0078527173,
-0.0465913266,
0.0645191744,
0.0139362263,
-0.002468985,
-0.0236669034,
-0.0488722771,
-0.0080797877,
0.0256336126,
-0.0018325872,
0.038522467,
0.0160583016,
0.0406742878,
-0.0035247682,
-0.0180900171,
0.0195004586,
0.0099327751,
0.000796792,
-0.0679432377,
-0.0113306716,
0.006968033,
0.0409869365,
0.0522465743,
-0.0012583463,
0.0008586776,
0.018097071,
-0.0070289588,
-0.0154746696,
0.0086785443,
-0.0680982471,
-0.0194845647,
0.0262691919,
-0.0554090813,
0.0070941136,
0.0565068126,
-0.0208807997,
-0.0617519803,
0.0176827926,
-0.0746545345,
0.0174424611,
-0.0714705139,
0.0040096543,
-0.0217904095,
0.009723925,
-0.0570530407,
0.0425737277,
0.0080793956,
0.0478744432,
-0.0156389419,
-0.0271952134,
0.0416864157,
-0.0965642631,
-0.0246980563,
0.0470595062,
-0.0081765074,
0.0454855561,
0.0459295958,
0.0384685695,
-0.0120374039,
-0.0309317876,
-0.044056464,
0.0286516044,
0.0134413121,
0.0563609786,
0.0703101829,
0.0080256788,
-0.0044424362,
-0.0253091436,
-0.1037181541,
0.0220680181,
0.0598050803,
0.0019120153,
0.0342927873,
0.0075163995,
0.0080453884,
-0.0246981829,
-0.0124941245,
-0.01224156,
0.0037176653,
0.0066154939,
-0.0008370262,
-0.089310877,
0.0452282541,
-0.0204504281,
0.0452656709,
0.0554606989,
-0.1059550941,
0.0335230306,
0.0387148559,
0.0590098836,
0.0679494664,
0.005691906,
-0.0143664693,
0.006596792,
0.0139268236,
-0.0468477868,
0.0186464321,
-0.0485150144,
-0.075045608,
-0.0419893302,
-0.0417987816,
0.0263632145,
0.0738134757,
0.0581554659,
-0.0104092136,
-0.0981631652,
0.0453410111,
-0.0337551534,
-0.0310907103,
-0.0241312161,
0.0080537768,
-0.0088343164,
0.0311227217,
-0.0129597513,
-0.0456839316,
0.0736009851,
-0.0078965463,
0.0196257979,
-0.0823179558,
0.0043584029,
-0.0157487262,
0.0178822149,
-0.0039677084,
0.0332328044,
0.0098906243,
-0.0519863702,
-0.071238175,
-0.000745905,
0.0053081587,
-0.0235427544,
0.035181459,
-0.0455307513,
-0.0217432193,
-0.0290427748,
-0.0644975007,
-0.0386456437,
0.0245466661,
-0.0026096799,
0.0267638937,
0.0155764045,
0.0134742884,
-0.0261079092,
0.018938018,
0.019777298,
0.0024294013,
-0.0571458191,
0.0089370888,
-0.0303700883,
0.0334444009,
0.0420149304,
0.0377216674,
-0.0117536457,
-0.0315434411,
-0.003656789,
0.0113301883,
-0.0012042135,
0.0167359859,
-0.0201531127,
0.0084640132,
0.0478098504,
-0.0203360394,
-0.0210762136,
0.0116644586,
0.026059581,
-0.0419634841,
-0.0305975638,
0.1043993309,
0.023769727,
-0.0546937063,
-0.0351671576,
-0.0406208597,
0.0077029262,
-0.0080962991,
0.0533121824,
-0.0325242877,
0.012096975,
-0.0204655267,
0.0151170241,
-0.0033273504,
0.0277443714,
-0.0014937047,
-0.1452526599,
0.0141296564,
0.0167070311,
-0.0537410825,
-0.0441138409,
0.0019411099,
-0.0436436012,
-0.0160868522,
0.0013138016,
0.0093916329,
0.0450903289,
0.011062392,
0.0250268988,
0.0198422931,
-0.0214132108,
0.0035508096,
-0.040492069,
0.0350693353,
0.1261817068,
0.029301811,
-0.0290680993,
-0.0620593801,
-0.0211372618,
-0.0387051627,
0.0101919686,
0.0205670409,
0.009966122,
0.0266796984,
-0.0037649092,
-0.0245070904,
0.0296423454,
-0.0452251025,
0.0429992303,
0.0406427383,
0.136754334,
-0.0293537881,
0.0163448155,
-0.0132975392,
-0.0197052099,
-0.0002272921,
0.0466430634,
0.0170650966,
-0.079441078,
-0.0475580618,
-0.002359543,
-0.0074289483,
-0.0535491928,
-0.0275308546,
0.0340679549,
0.0213626362,
-0.0286389701,
-0.0787186325,
-0.0568771884,
-0.0119464584,
0.0362230763,
0.0345720127,
0.0084846644,
0.0142251877,
-0.0098382225,
-0.0282324627,
0.0009596633,
-0.0103587555,
0.0067071258,
-0.0732587054,
0.013140332,
-0.0073427339,
-0.0641024411,
-0.0133301606,
-0.0118372338,
-0.0335050225,
-0.0319505818,
-0.0120631279,
0.0579144023,
0.0321137421,
0.0118000563,
-0.0362179168,
-0.0391412266,
-0.016682243,
-0.0109212631,
-0.0229616724,
0.0114559652,
-0.0029283732,
0.0016221135,
-0.0172096882,
0.0089481771,
-0.0001552692,
0.034800075,
0.0067572966,
0.042017255,
0.0068775159,
-0.0080244727,
0.082398966,
0.0215078183,
0.0503161363,
-0.0092629222,
-0.0093900431,
-0.0202747248,
-0.0058578607,
-0.019531792,
0.0288679656,
0.0004199464,
-0.0459167287,
0.0596200973,
-0.0035167597,
-0.0015296187,
-0.0724659935,
-0.0124131907,
0.0073622912,
-0.0465801321,
-0.014819338,
0.0104478067,
0.0098983971,
-0.0204582047,
0.0409527384,
-0.017097814,
-0.0234478712,
0.0054106461,
0.0382822938,
-0.0137534924,
0.0973321274,
0.0272491574,
0.014987004,
0.0285243765,
0.05458837,
-0.0244611986,
-0.0169409886,
-0.0321103595,
-0.0038820598,
0.0650889948,
0.0218712091,
0.0212668218,
0.0061255572,
-0.0134059899,
-0.0149564454,
0.0074943313,
0.0079158414,
-0.0022845294,
0.0653256923,
0.0093509182,
0.0165708661,
-0.086172998,
0.0437233113,
-0.028616922,
-0.0077279713,
-0.0263027493,
-0.0010344054,
-0.010617001,
-0.0002824553,
-0.0286145266,
-0.0182189699,
-0.030524103,
0.0048620109,
-0.0285356175,
-0.0522969179,
-0.0641504899,
0.0503014624,
0.0182527695,
-0.0205792841,
0.0762162358,
0.0528189577,
-0.0563432015,
-0.057639394,
-0.0262940414,
0.0341339745,
-0.0674169511,
-0.0207775347,
-0.0399477668,
-5.793591049e-33,
-0.0367055796,
-0.0216040611,
0.048764497,
0.0024183283,
-0.0401803441,
-0.0099612502,
-0.021635266,
-0.020819759,
-0.0265530478,
-0.0063425461,
-0.0169601068,
-0.0097207399,
0.0114971129,
0.0150660444,
0.0151094375,
-0.0064055012,
0.0212923214,
-0.0334362313,
-0.0095880823,
-0.0082132639,
0.0042122691,
0.01563056,
0.0889272764,
-0.0643713847,
0.0002413745,
-0.0103828264,
-0.0137635497,
0.027118599,
-0.0014739949,
0.0617244355,
-0.0322054215,
0.0560889468,
0.0344050825,
-0.0637602881,
-0.0001371755,
0.0317847542,
-0.042036768,
-0.0646877736,
0.0482389331,
0.0373835042,
-0.0235385578,
-0.0601245984,
-0.0081972517,
-0.0260656998,
-0.0449562892,
0.0046669561,
0.0376009345,
-0.0351292118,
0.0157865491,
0.0213828944,
-0.0573485643,
-0.0081779007,
0.0317874737,
-0.0096206618,
0.0175492447,
0.0759970918,
-0.0475997739,
-0.0188055262,
-0.004293845,
0.015226122,
0.0574168041,
0.0393190756,
0.0783278868,
0.0211849064,
0.0229851864,
0.0105892988,
0.0414296687,
-0.0382624604,
-0.019472234,
-0.0017615648,
0.0073141912,
-0.0303581562,
0.0937457085,
0.0383304618,
0.0548999868,
-0.0035523695,
-0.0587790757,
0.0211444013,
-0.0182338916,
0.0159575623,
0.0310615879,
0.0077621052,
-0.0209009703,
0.0048636855,
-0.0375947133,
0.0027082146,
-0.031128699,
-0.0746833533,
0.0513270684,
-0.0334865563,
0.0077116597,
-0.0334488675,
0.035275735,
-0.0415244401,
0.044720754,
0.0077255624,
-0.0134228561,
0.0243223812,
0.0042648362,
0.0447445288,
-0.0376698077,
0.0011854392,
-0.0066604665,
0.0320754349,
0.0041252682,
0.0388690904,
-0.0133569101,
0.0105703017,
-0.0367099494,
0.011519853,
-0.0543622114,
0.0267357975,
-0.0083087962,
0.0073268856,
0.0098520378,
0.0022884486,
0.0011917577,
0.0177568775,
0.0103435805,
-0.0447789021,
-0.0350637585,
-0.0236087292,
0.0250519812,
0.0417771079,
-0.0208781436,
0.0302838553,
0.0057054739,
0.0303664114,
-0.0261534937,
-0.0401856825,
-0.0227609333,
0.0502051637,
2.597e-7,
0.0348508097,
-0.0037179643,
0.0541083626,
0.0577308945,
0.0217004903,
0.0142735355,
0.005630054,
0.0393042192,
0.0408157744,
0.0053241961,
-0.0028765362,
-0.0049818442,
0.0304233935,
0.0274876021,
-0.1006408855,
0.006834812,
-0.0010210576,
0.0132456766,
-0.0180170015,
0.0287849642,
0.0772828534,
0.0649514198,
-0.0027096858,
-0.000594442,
-0.0011369472,
-0.0029270616,
0.0489024408,
0.0045138942,
-0.0089200065,
-0.0064491276,
0.0102116885,
0.0225782339,
-0.0035762715,
0.0443179272,
0.0277511645,
0.0057699792,
0.0230470542,
0.022949433,
-0.0308921523,
-0.0214796066,
0.0024165167,
-0.0273242537,
0.0105090048,
-0.0916121081,
0.0170776099,
-0.0616991185,
-0.0423173718,
0.0189731997,
-0.0042965682,
-0.0602883175,
0.0233638398,
-0.0389556326,
-0.0257341024,
0.002010636,
0.0303608496,
0.0104407202,
0.016908722,
-0.0086823059,
0.0060777087,
0.0337776802,
-0.050148692,
-0.0530840643,
-0.0326349214,
0.0268106498,
0.0233823508,
-0.0382968895,
0.001635227,
1.831040803e-34,
-0.0192457605,
-0.0348672681,
0.0336405635,
0.0142432302,
0.0173813011,
0.0069737011,
0.0339192189,
-0.0155195184,
0.0389147401,
-0.0431921445,
-0.0442835614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17647v1 | Detecting and Grounding Important Characters in Visual Stories | 2023-03-30T18:24:06 | 2023-03-30T18:24:06 | Danyang Liu, Frank Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Characters are essential to the plot of any story. Establishing the
characters before writing a story can improve the clarity of the plot and the
overall flow of the narrative. However, previous work on visual storytelling
tends to focus on detecting objects in images and discovering relationships
between them. In this approach, characters are not distinguished from other
objects when they are fed into the generation pipeline. The result is a
coherent sequence of events rather than a character-centric story. In order to
address this limitation, we introduce the VIST-Character dataset, which
provides rich character-centric annotations, including visual and textual
co-reference chains and importance ratings for characters. Based on this
dataset, we propose two new tasks: important character detection and character
grounding in visual stories. For both tasks, we develop simple, unsupervised
models based on distributional similarity and pre-trained vision-and-language
models. Our new dataset, together with these models, can serve as the
foundation for subsequent work on analysing and generating stories from a
character-centric perspective. | [
0.0131595405,
0.0570974872,
-0.0083031263,
0.0464390479,
0.0083146263,
0.0321396068,
-0.0170881338,
-0.00378783,
-0.0066669374,
-0.0190327503,
0.0159065407,
-0.0181628726,
0.0200935416,
0.0676723793,
0.0139130959,
-0.0984074846,
-0.0287919715,
0.0244644713,
0.0265072007,
0.040210247,
0.0376094058,
0.0300867036,
0.0158067644,
0.0508746468,
-0.0501263365,
-0.0047740233,
0.0122174844,
0.0280976407,
0.076223366,
-0.0482082292,
-0.0161195584,
0.016392827,
0.0780367926,
-0.0479191616,
0.0000017742,
-0.0048171543,
0.0164688081,
-0.0315130278,
0.0263465326,
-0.0124976514,
-0.0117261056,
-0.0081369216,
0.0151693067,
-0.040004313,
-0.0109564848,
0.0008948152,
0.0687991455,
0.0776137561,
0.066879645,
0.0282068346,
-0.0403178856,
-0.0540384613,
-0.0408567451,
-0.0056029679,
0.0417245142,
-0.0069826799,
-0.006334357,
0.0366610773,
-0.0053178864,
-0.0147707025,
-0.0674985498,
0.0168830752,
0.01345124,
-0.0115019735,
-0.0153684327,
0.0739474073,
-0.0204939265,
0.0126896994,
0.0069854306,
0.1188476011,
-0.02925268,
-0.0226291511,
-0.0119949449,
-0.0404933654,
-0.0062850458,
0.0341245197,
-0.0299619734,
0.0501628034,
-0.002610001,
0.0350083336,
-0.0251065642,
0.0319236033,
-0.0006621602,
-0.0203086566,
0.0467715226,
-0.0378098413,
0.0189068634,
0.0535192862,
-0.043026045,
0.0248019863,
-0.0737888291,
-0.0683114007,
-0.0050572543,
0.023609763,
0.060258083,
0.0062606046,
-0.0462568887,
0.0226562601,
-0.0445291512,
-0.0629178435,
0.0377615765,
0.0046011554,
-0.0579665266,
0.0309576038,
-0.0028964491,
0.0254777633,
-0.0092740059,
-0.0031943133,
0.0129219936,
0.0287000295,
-0.0114656202,
0.017903842,
-0.0187569018,
0.0099671474,
-0.0387130454,
-0.0242764838,
0.001441822,
-0.0046014283,
-0.0078341626,
-0.001326095,
-0.0175097976,
0.0423059575,
-0.0132486634,
-0.0008545313,
-0.0431243181,
0.0530908294,
-0.0559451468,
-0.0087624444,
-0.0429089218,
0.0106259668,
-0.01384784,
-0.0073919646,
0.0540030748,
-0.0200426765,
0.0282188971,
0.0310739838,
-0.0079391617,
-0.0458213501,
-0.0531478412,
-0.0254585482,
0.0075311777,
-0.0558833741,
-0.0372509398,
-0.0429577306,
0.0270287432,
-0.0300240796,
0.0450118072,
-0.0398223698,
0.0199554805,
0.0188354198,
-0.0115424842,
0.0618936196,
0.0208971221,
-0.0155003257,
0.0018786199,
0.0367667191,
0.0488294512,
0.0132925669,
0.0495138429,
0.062284492,
0.0302571431,
0.0014456013,
0.0263890829,
-0.0232261196,
-0.0267130304,
-0.0009356976,
-0.0274342559,
-0.0155602777,
-0.0245385729,
0.0433294289,
0.0228256024,
0.0138655407,
-0.0544780307,
-0.0390309244,
0.0837730914,
0.0708595514,
0.0101098409,
-0.0226582028,
0.0889222398,
-0.0084514115,
-0.0123427184,
0.0412928723,
-0.0291913766,
0.0609556176,
0.0635428727,
-0.0231939573,
-0.0726915896,
0.0035617827,
-0.0489084423,
-0.0039066402,
0.0431728736,
-0.0127749182,
-0.0235433429,
-0.0298747811,
-0.0070038252,
0.0303471908,
-0.0739755929,
-0.0142687,
0.0202534702,
-0.095960103,
0.0445850939,
0.0345590897,
0.0484882668,
0.0614835396,
0.0399947762,
-0.0028838727,
-0.0239969585,
-0.0353135318,
0.0457627289,
-0.0109978374,
-0.0506305732,
-0.0280543659,
0.0540450141,
-0.0450343154,
0.008690564,
-0.0071096825,
-0.0074740476,
0.036021553,
-0.0202386975,
0.0215469468,
-0.0251869373,
-0.0177513864,
-0.0289175045,
0.0580538251,
-0.0052955248,
0.0073679285,
-0.0451024771,
0.0342872888,
-0.035541445,
-0.0013123885,
-0.0582942292,
-0.0382749401,
0.0323322155,
-0.0306499414,
0.0037087044,
0.0784637704,
-0.0507671759,
-0.0373050235,
-0.0021869382,
-0.104372263,
-0.0367442109,
-0.012284006,
0.0070401188,
-0.0208288487,
0.0525939465,
-0.0366323404,
-0.0003091527,
-0.030904267,
-0.0227891635,
0.0280789044,
0.0300938487,
-0.0281179678,
0.0887738243,
0.0011153686,
0.0039276644,
-0.0396037102,
0.044999212,
0.0193942748,
-0.032275714,
0.0152671402,
-0.0107267834,
0.0491925701,
-0.0206285603,
0.0407191291,
-0.0120316632,
-0.0022688061,
0.0059807324,
-0.0608728342,
-0.0030535206,
0.0130033446,
-0.0319982022,
-0.007949274,
0.000242556,
-0.020933561,
-0.015651729,
-0.0296703,
0.0194000285,
-0.016657874,
-0.0438821577,
0.0326169617,
0.0454848073,
0.0234270114,
-0.0379408486,
0.0096159,
0.006274452,
0.0935094804,
0.0750560537,
-0.0325722769,
-0.0145839779,
0.0299968533,
-0.0040045809,
0.0369473398,
-0.024939958,
-0.0263577532,
-0.0003669111,
0.0254036393,
0.0422170162,
0.0453864895,
0.0070081502,
0.0450824313,
0.0340649635,
-0.0507920869,
-0.0037170521,
0.0096753491,
-0.0006512055,
0.0454077795,
-0.010878861,
-0.0333747938,
-0.009725567,
0.0355813988,
-0.0165938288,
0.0202586614,
-0.0688792691,
0.0018823427,
0.0468777977,
-0.0054849177,
-0.005779935,
-0.0214628484,
-0.0020503805,
0.0267151389,
-0.0348851867,
-0.0252436381,
0.0294404123,
-0.0334279165,
-0.0179668348,
0.0482684001,
0.0331950635,
-0.0480631664,
0.1077727899,
0.0434568599,
0.0332600996,
-0.0174361989,
-0.016613286,
-0.0416840464,
0.0065648654,
0.039584972,
0.009869528,
0.0201616362,
-0.0349433646,
-0.0054105031,
-0.0049571325,
0.003314405,
-0.0284205414,
-0.0389315598,
-0.0239344835,
-0.0609779768,
0.005075329,
-0.034102086,
-0.0382997394,
0.0269169156,
-0.0092484187,
0.0287710018,
0.0021965976,
-0.0133585716,
-0.011404302,
0.0495032296,
0.0538706295,
0.0006285847,
-0.0218184832,
-0.037039917,
0.0276673511,
0.0383561067,
-0.0493998677,
-0.0171645302,
-0.005647392,
0.0571421124,
0.0033287061,
-0.0099219922,
0.0009394259,
-0.0111984909,
0.0590117723,
-0.0558435991,
-0.0191461053,
0.0721724853,
0.026010517,
-0.0376507454,
0.0007967866,
0.0374539159,
0.0004864461,
0.0424304344,
-0.0032817689,
-0.0608852394,
-0.0152116101,
-0.0040062722,
-0.0222411137,
0.015618802,
-0.0777467191,
-0.0561225973,
-0.054746978,
0.0826743171,
0.0021159418,
-0.0276217163,
-0.0454739332,
0.0112341745,
0.0039455262,
-0.0093063377,
-0.0223188512,
-0.0154290916,
-0.000831934,
-0.0005999481,
-0.0238953214,
0.0066682366,
0.004947749,
0.0085940426,
-0.0741197541,
0.0028138992,
0.0334716477,
0.071238555,
0.014019602,
0.0132047944,
-0.05631046,
-0.0229090638,
-0.0082961498,
0.0047618719,
0.1015001163,
-0.0614209399,
-0.0521658026,
-0.0441013537,
0.0430703349,
0.0072249109,
-0.0716142952,
0.0043887431,
-0.0096438639,
-0.0255271029,
-0.0355829708,
-0.0033208709,
0.0459022038,
0.0070164585,
0.0473127328,
0.0508536026,
-0.0309284162,
-0.0242756829,
0.0048315325,
0.0596721657,
-0.0654335395,
-0.0606686696,
-0.0080856932,
-0.0243273601,
-0.020508619,
-0.0727743283,
-0.0389386117,
0.0266236644,
0.0628808737,
0.019924311,
-0.0127911484,
-0.0178406909,
-0.0081378799,
-0.0700136647,
0.061600022,
-0.0191628393,
0.0097955298,
-0.0209223684,
-0.0051908558,
0.0117201349,
-0.0520685166,
-0.0171881467,
0.0328634456,
-0.0656198561,
-0.0177400392,
-0.0452610925,
0.0195863899,
0.010274861,
0.0278449338,
0.0314169377,
-0.0746266395,
-0.0075092646,
-0.0004845383,
-0.0083101233,
0.0306663867,
-0.0435475186,
-0.0506807417,
-0.0236328561,
-0.004280156,
-0.0021295161,
0.0313702971,
-0.0026259245,
0.0038439003,
-0.0332757942,
-0.024196744,
0.0051222928,
-0.0283328313,
0.005362581,
-0.0434269309,
0.0099975318,
-0.0960718766,
-0.0458232574,
-0.0246181339,
-0.0120476838,
-0.0528064854,
0.0295295455,
0.0158639178,
0.0334641859,
-0.0503968559,
0.0016273664,
-0.0427789688,
0.0202290714,
-0.0302953813,
-0.0163828228,
0.063453801,
-0.0064818468,
-0.0163477119,
0.0299214832,
0.015216765,
0.0105588958,
-0.0597118847,
0.0474031046,
0.0076473388,
-0.0061731623,
0.0076206168,
0.007775302,
0.0074824523,
0.0196058676,
-0.0103716133,
-0.0016871026,
-0.0465422347,
0.0298269298,
0.0635857955,
-0.0322401412,
0.032991264,
-0.0321517363,
0.0112286285,
0.007656516,
0.0115729999,
0.0124761024,
-0.0227243155,
-0.0100987013,
0.0410615876,
-0.0164788552,
0.0338752158,
0.0706678405,
0.0054783844,
0.0412858725,
0.018213436,
-0.0484874249,
-0.0248372089,
-0.0009662381,
0.0307688732,
0.0321634747,
0.0244170986,
0.0304441787,
-0.0441050157,
-0.0528871045,
0.0214645341,
0.0105797388,
0.0016268702,
0.0555113256,
0.0397441387,
-0.0138151944,
0.0234499238,
0.0277561098,
-0.018547155,
0.0025456031,
-0.0047251992,
-0.0108985659,
-0.0019121073,
-5.392293808e-33,
-0.0690782592,
-0.0312525481,
-0.0118938759,
0.0429973006,
-0.0474680029,
0.0372365341,
-0.0253207628,
-0.0060706567,
0.0159512423,
0.0607684106,
0.0534442291,
0.0147813866,
-0.0095611997,
-0.001210492,
-0.0439505689,
0.0025167509,
0.0414389335,
0.0365065634,
-0.037232548,
0.0277724098,
0.035991028,
0.0230104197,
0.0547459573,
-0.0643394366,
-0.0444062985,
-0.0496275909,
-0.0281353295,
-0.0066645788,
0.0937098786,
0.0292868894,
-0.0077577848,
0.0028239011,
0.0066732606,
0.0274437591,
-0.0199832935,
0.0096722487,
-0.0933142975,
-0.019307781,
0.0078088287,
0.026510343,
-0.0304397903,
-0.0162393823,
0.0121830553,
-0.0314461365,
0.0463675149,
-0.0397000536,
0.0884193107,
-0.0191037524,
0.0436673164,
0.013495151,
-0.0714856163,
0.0134537304,
-0.0505054556,
-0.0663884133,
0.0150981359,
0.0075880191,
0.0355598219,
-0.0037961733,
-0.0165048465,
0.0361629911,
-0.0408687964,
0.0088838479,
-0.0037024193,
0.028616732,
-0.0103075933,
0.1019815579,
0.0145010138,
-0.0408987105,
-0.0468062535,
0.0274730586,
0.0067630778,
0.0281824395,
0.0176327527,
0.0498017967,
-0.0137979584,
0.0250677224,
-0.0887295976,
0.0626811609,
-0.0306200664,
0.0152335986,
0.0153204724,
0.0259239376,
0.0066754869,
-0.0061628479,
-0.0122725824,
-0.0670448467,
-0.0024335117,
-0.02611701,
0.0175652374,
-0.0215153396,
-0.0123995524,
0.0702238455,
0.0426565185,
-0.0222860482,
0.0147602335,
0.0319001824,
-0.0353632644,
0.0481721126,
0.0162765756,
0.0086479746,
-0.0033911869,
-0.019960003,
0.0816511959,
-0.0064594597,
0.0612015091,
-0.0262883045,
0.0408294573,
0.0395674147,
-0.0199842323,
-0.0243724547,
-0.0072506862,
-0.0068827556,
-0.0159146972,
0.0351730771,
-0.0118467957,
-0.010782592,
-0.0484014153,
0.0064755101,
-0.0063437815,
-0.0022545198,
0.0003918152,
-0.0364472419,
-0.0248443335,
0.0314936191,
-0.0339905098,
0.0089300415,
-0.0052452968,
0.0196295604,
0.0197315011,
-0.0769779459,
-0.0216562208,
-0.0008923859,
2.428e-7,
0.0222396813,
-0.0257943664,
0.0705084354,
-0.0038673168,
-0.0021838921,
0.0229964275,
-0.0071674567,
0.0327379145,
-0.0098794457,
-0.0515395477,
0.0459970348,
0.0389849581,
0.0036590782,
0.0048168898,
-0.0186657012,
0.0353118218,
-0.0445168838,
-0.0519327261,
-0.0421025902,
-0.0603204779,
0.0453635976,
0.0353859179,
0.0448270924,
-0.005271757,
0.0670730248,
-0.0355432704,
0.0903765187,
-0.0530932955,
-0.0262263715,
0.0038569076,
-0.0353422277,
0.0157752279,
-0.0597193986,
-0.0076271202,
-0.0081590442,
0.0069148503,
0.0761923194,
-0.003201826,
-0.0442061573,
0.0146336807,
-0.0001220218,
0.0387472659,
-0.0241396427,
-0.007910409,
0.0566389672,
-0.0290105958,
-0.0362626873,
0.019446101,
-0.0107080359,
0.0210750476,
0.0211040061,
-0.0025496993,
-0.0453055985,
0.0425676778,
0.0488032103,
-0.0179206077,
-0.0198800396,
-0.0782681629,
0.0068023563,
0.022205146,
-0.0162782297,
0.0044478085,
-0.0102437017,
-0.0412901789,
0.0038389515,
-0.012333394,
-0.0117285755,
1.953284065e-34,
-0.0232050791,
0.0321022607,
-0.0147363143,
0.0054834052,
0.0460844077,
0.0010069872,
-0.0265261605,
-0.0065722805,
0.0250268653,
-0.0220804084,
-0.0294911806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00993v1 | Unsupervised Word Segmentation Using Temporal Gradient Pseudo-Labels | 2023-03-30T17:59:46 | 2023-03-30T17:59:46 | Tzeviya Sylvia Fuchs, Yedid Hoshen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Unsupervised word segmentation in audio utterances is challenging as, in
speech, there is typically no gap between words. In a preliminary experiment,
we show that recent deep self-supervised features are very effective for word
segmentation but require supervision for training the classification head. To
extend their effectiveness to unsupervised word segmentation, we propose a
pseudo-labeling strategy. Our approach relies on the observation that the
temporal gradient magnitude of the embeddings (i.e. the distance between the
embeddings of subsequent frames) is typically minimal far from the boundaries
and higher nearer the boundaries. We use a thresholding function on the
temporal gradient magnitude to define a psuedo-label for wordness. We train a
linear classifier, mapping the embedding of a single frame to the pseudo-label.
Finally, we use the classifier score to predict whether a frame is a word or a
boundary. In an empirical investigation, our method, despite its simplicity and
fast run time, is shown to significantly outperform all previous methods on two
datasets. | [
-0.040987961,
0.0323889777,
0.0394880883,
0.0197491813,
-0.0257162619,
-0.0149468677,
0.0433493778,
-0.014655455,
0.0007260081,
0.0177705083,
-0.0206033625,
-0.0305585284,
0.0020775003,
0.0224470198,
-0.02223357,
-0.0914106891,
0.0489716604,
-0.0132812653,
0.0123754852,
0.0101713855,
0.0041147843,
-0.0407585353,
-0.0754541904,
-0.0319392197,
-0.0802236572,
-0.032154154,
-0.0223902147,
-0.0220035017,
0.0509115681,
-0.0126759764,
-0.0121245943,
-0.0082459878,
-0.0114432983,
0.0217513554,
0.000001811,
-0.0272407737,
-0.034164194,
-0.0170765147,
-0.0262118522,
0.0108039724,
-0.0138765341,
-0.0417308323,
-0.0250241812,
-0.0221397933,
-0.0216420628,
-0.0493730158,
0.0228178911,
0.0648765862,
0.0280285496,
0.0526615009,
-0.0270475559,
-0.0407037921,
0.0358434133,
-0.0127447285,
-0.0097043002,
-0.0184847917,
-0.0137711512,
-0.013068716,
-0.0207427796,
-0.0376001857,
-0.025379505,
0.0515168123,
0.0117372088,
-0.0202715956,
0.0459722094,
0.0477153063,
-0.0619551912,
-0.0391969569,
-0.0185104255,
0.0764169767,
-0.0087859165,
0.0186274424,
0.0599645935,
-0.0148656908,
-0.0288118888,
-0.010949566,
0.0290484652,
-0.0087615075,
0.0265357923,
0.0175817441,
0.0084992396,
0.0905986279,
0.0498110764,
-0.0159178302,
0.0036902807,
0.0497673377,
0.0079740612,
-0.0535088107,
0.0164513309,
-0.0456472747,
0.0168806277,
0.0229365267,
0.0798026919,
-0.0043864488,
0.027673535,
0.0068827928,
-0.0335850231,
0.0157775301,
-0.0322725587,
0.014240372,
0.0262978114,
-0.0106241163,
-0.0414259844,
0.0656025633,
-0.0075629922,
-0.0269985572,
-0.0134981731,
0.0694561899,
-0.0247313436,
0.0211993176,
-0.0464546233,
-0.0059350426,
-0.0588419847,
0.0213609487,
0.0338370763,
-0.0240909979,
-0.0178671572,
-0.0398147143,
-0.00917836,
-0.0181717835,
0.0251458567,
-0.0055898516,
-0.0011417746,
-0.0252872445,
0.0263324082,
-0.0209512748,
-0.0448291078,
-0.0210462734,
0.0082293646,
-0.0118728532,
0.0049648602,
0.032743413,
0.0288671851,
-0.0089752795,
-0.0013911377,
0.0092233019,
-0.0508515164,
-0.0313568711,
-0.0187050849,
-0.0156513862,
-0.0610953793,
-0.0265323296,
0.0123565122,
-0.0704825595,
0.0144094173,
-0.0597776547,
-0.0097763762,
0.0023214605,
-0.0216244385,
-0.0440492705,
0.0663434491,
0.0729417875,
-0.0142873963,
0.0361080021,
0.0418710932,
0.040129818,
0.0623008832,
0.0325063691,
0.0563151427,
-0.008352031,
0.0659330413,
0.011437919,
0.0037196469,
0.0343737043,
-0.0259426832,
-0.0385419913,
-0.0809649602,
-0.0654125437,
0.0273356661,
0.047107596,
0.0477598645,
0.0465365648,
0.0040657911,
-0.0681919679,
0.0079804556,
0.0483709201,
0.0033654829,
0.0104877194,
0.0183162894,
0.0616242737,
0.0158900414,
0.0259385966,
0.0562326945,
-0.0176288132,
0.0524047092,
0.0274761431,
0.0234107058,
-0.0285260603,
-0.0252601672,
-0.0500394367,
0.0054334016,
-0.0118968952,
0.0142597193,
-0.0275466722,
0.0545441285,
0.0400091857,
-0.0456642359,
0.042339284,
-0.0296795592,
-0.0224989466,
-0.0056813792,
0.0005121824,
0.0271564797,
0.036353156,
-0.0006802133,
-0.0869243219,
0.0157927256,
-0.0432665125,
0.0705591366,
0.0888866261,
0.0385346897,
-0.0216439459,
0.0298969764,
-0.0658265054,
0.0149955638,
0.0394822173,
0.0397183336,
-0.0011844807,
-0.0287299529,
0.0479345135,
0.0285264291,
-0.0332081579,
0.0566661321,
0.0319233388,
0.0008923328,
0.000255418,
-0.0141931698,
0.0125397267,
0.0128474133,
0.0371235572,
-0.0232359208,
-0.0240579657,
0.0198527202,
-0.0525911301,
0.0284753758,
-0.0069809463,
-0.101178363,
-0.0334715731,
0.0121210758,
-0.0446720645,
-0.0232293159,
0.0482119732,
0.0088041499,
-0.0509966239,
0.0090472978,
0.0064431247,
0.0728529245,
-0.063488096,
-0.0087846816,
0.0187449828,
0.0334674828,
0.0102033466,
0.0110110678,
-0.0072907722,
-0.0141661344,
-0.0223491024,
0.0039460482,
-0.0130686844,
-0.037425939,
-0.0156673435,
0.0631581247,
-0.0020146901,
-0.0364715159,
-0.031711217,
-0.0289190505,
-0.0514800847,
0.0104739238,
-0.0778353736,
-0.0193728786,
-0.0253554359,
0.0047740722,
-0.0180403274,
-0.0093619935,
-0.0274224635,
-0.0131880809,
0.018145375,
-0.009081699,
-0.022197498,
-0.0467303246,
0.0328411907,
-0.0288979113,
-0.0265069623,
-0.0400420986,
-0.0124447756,
-0.0109051475,
0.0215750504,
-0.0147313988,
-0.0557031594,
-0.0128382081,
0.0003520327,
0.029947985,
0.0286381561,
0.0094558652,
-0.0161703546,
-0.0171523318,
0.0095859235,
0.0377159044,
0.0559040308,
0.0288795382,
0.0218796674,
0.024606552,
-0.016630115,
0.0248850621,
-0.0187397953,
-0.004925386,
0.0796525553,
0.0125369877,
0.0044902386,
-0.0256848652,
0.0762612596,
0.0380951129,
0.0260340255,
0.0119894063,
-0.0302367881,
-0.0394116305,
-0.0428936183,
0.0142261973,
0.0342459157,
-0.0559847131,
0.0013053649,
-0.0150726615,
-0.0380048901,
0.0159463212,
-0.0317934826,
-0.043515075,
-0.0194898788,
-0.074871704,
0.007900252,
0.0421748161,
0.0145695964,
-0.0238011405,
0.0165596213,
-0.0283214208,
-0.0155267715,
-0.0008886613,
0.01198739,
-0.0185683966,
-0.0189053342,
0.0056789252,
0.0171419084,
0.0116737345,
0.0407928452,
-0.0420403779,
-0.0469931476,
-0.0161618255,
0.0086777862,
-0.0476052724,
-0.0004520903,
0.0093043149,
0.0188927986,
-0.0271916799,
0.1002384722,
0.0179895256,
0.0128414501,
-0.0017020403,
0.1038351953,
0.0288257673,
-0.0108739305,
-0.0216736514,
-0.0182230677,
0.0643499196,
-0.0139743891,
0.0624227822,
-0.0064069009,
-0.0382813849,
-0.0035070551,
-0.0422932133,
-0.0445962213,
-0.0136564802,
0.0047707241,
0.0316616558,
-0.067138359,
-0.0184440799,
0.1064554006,
0.0560791679,
0.0075395722,
0.0116431676,
0.0469067544,
-0.0348653793,
-0.0023723077,
-0.0266657528,
0.0079061706,
-0.038813103,
0.0109466854,
-0.0025680782,
-0.0020535479,
-0.0003765736,
-0.015642425,
-0.0516082421,
0.0411956571,
0.007731325,
0.0148424916,
0.0406893082,
-0.021236809,
0.0136875771,
-0.0024514976,
-0.0177586172,
-0.0327891782,
-0.0159981605,
-0.0487749465,
0.0133511191,
-0.0726625845,
-0.0225166325,
0.0139337135,
-0.027098814,
0.0427226461,
0.021722924,
0.0140086347,
-0.0482015088,
-0.0573881716,
0.0569533482,
-0.052712705,
-0.0439879969,
0.0164463464,
0.0443692543,
-0.0372071713,
-0.0036373243,
0.0139775062,
0.038245175,
-0.0002003413,
0.0077071334,
0.0003107479,
0.0820541307,
0.0007876037,
-0.0416635573,
-0.0109020937,
0.0119863302,
-0.0203413349,
0.0786216483,
-0.00927254,
-0.0251610391,
-0.0095130913,
0.0599474311,
0.0678519234,
-0.0345963351,
-0.0178765319,
-0.0128354905,
-0.0035036546,
-0.0183266997,
-0.0537445433,
-0.0601778254,
0.0294517633,
0.0459781215,
-0.0196065754,
0.0006999085,
0.0212957803,
-0.0046310602,
-0.0952829644,
0.0128453253,
-0.0110766022,
-0.0140242297,
-0.0564114675,
-0.0435680076,
0.0764536634,
0.0117001105,
-0.0255067311,
0.0339681096,
-0.0436194204,
-0.0307630356,
0.0233455338,
-0.025682468,
0.0047364463,
0.0528536402,
-0.0299896598,
0.0071407068,
0.1001060829,
0.0449768677,
-0.0161305368,
-0.0133564994,
0.0718438849,
-0.019422967,
-0.0212013628,
0.0124151669,
-0.0185776874,
0.0083751315,
-0.005391892,
-0.008477984,
-0.0444719903,
0.0552196167,
-0.0149917444,
-0.045730751,
0.0834754705,
-0.0087916134,
0.0550680608,
-0.0685526505,
0.0018297315,
0.0131456964,
0.0477157794,
-0.0213393066,
0.045186948,
0.0322656855,
0.0024362141,
-0.0130647775,
0.0382006951,
-0.0350614116,
-0.0156850182,
0.0107521629,
0.0587692745,
-0.0200627241,
0.002389743,
-0.0401830636,
0.0035999087,
0.0132984966,
0.0332344733,
0.0160947628,
0.0262363758,
0.0311401617,
0.0244717039,
0.022710301,
0.0034106472,
-0.0252662636,
0.0239263177,
-0.0286218915,
0.0755568966,
-0.0413814932,
0.0837087929,
0.029326776,
-0.0663396642,
-0.0061103473,
0.0071446835,
-0.0133937858,
-0.0119258929,
-0.0072657759,
-0.0262844916,
-0.0222253092,
-0.0227015764,
0.0305086542,
-0.0484515876,
0.0536789261,
0.0324757136,
-0.0053537404,
0.0036711497,
0.043226134,
0.0254194066,
-0.0638346896,
0.0282553285,
-0.0443854108,
0.0351294242,
-0.0461670794,
-0.0031989946,
-0.0116332173,
-0.0482017808,
0.0526643395,
-0.0088131353,
0.0052245101,
0.0690384358,
0.0010803407,
0.0081158038,
-0.023469029,
0.0011035242,
0.0212618671,
-0.0211426858,
0.0615875088,
-0.0140573587,
0.0098744435,
-6.003754745e-33,
-0.0050951722,
-0.0264519043,
-0.0395616442,
-0.0134134647,
-0.0245454013,
0.0263656266,
-0.0006392371,
0.0199295096,
0.0415963605,
0.0328937955,
-0.0118227042,
0.005179869,
0.055941198,
0.0388420336,
-0.008630597,
-0.0633595884,
0.0744847357,
-0.033941038,
-0.0097331731,
-0.0111940457,
-0.008167685,
0.0655531958,
0.0681995451,
-0.0329312421,
-0.0111826779,
-0.0057887938,
0.016638834,
0.0274465997,
0.0780028403,
0.0347730331,
-0.0383530855,
-0.0053519155,
0.0184732005,
-0.0129927918,
-0.0256287679,
0.011062528,
-0.1024811268,
-0.0224858839,
-0.0141806183,
0.0366383418,
-0.0563261509,
0.0076291682,
0.0083264541,
0.0063944883,
-0.0095133465,
-0.0166928694,
0.0510207117,
-0.0271330699,
-0.0242545195,
-0.0601518452,
-0.0520827807,
0.0588583052,
-0.0170248244,
-0.0350477248,
0.0911888182,
-0.0229751207,
0.0261963271,
-0.0548560508,
-0.0727016553,
0.0072699799,
-0.0053836079,
-0.0086658653,
0.0587783903,
0.0465552658,
0.0058147209,
0.0554286167,
0.0797929764,
-0.0593538545,
0.0426064394,
0.0002953648,
0.0244165268,
-0.0204308014,
0.000313087,
-0.04479919,
0.0537842512,
-0.0388260446,
-0.0195139814,
-0.0352419689,
0.0009177132,
-0.0690268502,
0.034590032,
0.0647979006,
-0.0555892065,
0.0278700534,
0.0025867494,
-0.0499297008,
0.0142219886,
0.0140564907,
0.0236576367,
0.0143097071,
-0.0177894253,
0.0248777494,
0.0348284729,
-0.0064600115,
0.0163435396,
-0.0338567868,
-0.0029282956,
0.0122460993,
0.0075595151,
0.0003654474,
-0.0437507629,
-0.0191097725,
0.0091681629,
0.0463836752,
0.0105426814,
-0.0432707444,
-0.0044658734,
-0.0173382945,
-0.0336560942,
0.0091214506,
0.0220934451,
0.0041606268,
-0.0170666501,
0.0062741637,
0.0497239642,
-0.0080058295,
-0.038202446,
0.0935933441,
0.006124435,
0.0129894167,
0.0078516304,
0.0650176778,
-0.0516057424,
0.0484092832,
-0.0103104347,
0.0013376796,
0.0373588614,
-0.0179758593,
0.0488549173,
-0.0606603585,
0.0206270684,
-0.0055517131,
2.513e-7,
-0.0438427031,
0.0275569502,
0.0886256769,
-0.0487046912,
0.0093228053,
0.0066922219,
-0.0050895712,
-0.0080972789,
-0.0785652325,
-0.0902670473,
0.0350941829,
0.0339689329,
0.0770298019,
0.0249079447,
-0.073662743,
-0.0027179033,
-0.0279605165,
-0.0273134485,
-0.0373711698,
-0.0180258714,
0.0048700711,
0.0861464739,
0.0435623601,
-0.0255471859,
-0.0259983707,
-0.0304502286,
-0.0233423039,
-0.0072869463,
0.0163352415,
-0.0252632461,
0.0226346366,
0.0096272789,
-0.0389151126,
0.0157920457,
-0.0033298554,
0.0085355565,
0.0677239969,
0.0349124745,
0.0108684441,
0.0072774389,
-0.0217011217,
0.0284845568,
-0.0112621998,
0.0478781685,
0.0642860457,
-0.0281458534,
-0.0170840751,
-0.0299409665,
0.000066911,
0.0145261157,
0.0438353531,
-0.0167114921,
0.0021080596,
0.0470137522,
0.0107771819,
-0.0204633921,
-0.0233083088,
-0.0388647132,
-0.0001298196,
0.0252186134,
-0.0505057164,
0.0117427818,
-0.0155910654,
0.0093791597,
0.0205620937,
-0.0304893106,
-0.0210414529,
1.771437959e-34,
0.0225009918,
-0.0033905115,
-0.0351993628,
-0.0387563072,
-0.0119651584,
-0.0228145588,
-0.0153651601,
-0.0430533513,
-0.0250105318,
0.0025553736,
-0.0002693519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17590v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17590v2 | Going Beyond Nouns With Vision & Language Models Using Synthetic Data | 2023-03-30T17:57:43 | 2023-08-30T17:46:17 | Paola Cascante-Bonilla, Khaled Shehada, James Seale Smith, Sivan Doveh, Donghyun Kim, Rameswar Panda, Gül Varol, Aude Oliva, Vicente Ordonez, Rogerio Feris, Leonid Karlinsky | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large-scale pre-trained Vision & Language (VL) models have shown remarkable
performance in many applications, enabling replacing a fixed set of supported
classes with zero-shot open vocabulary reasoning over (almost arbitrary)
natural language prompts. However, recent works have uncovered a fundamental
weakness of these models. For example, their difficulty to understand Visual
Language Concepts (VLC) that go 'beyond nouns' such as the meaning of
non-object words (e.g., attributes, actions, relations, states, etc.), or
difficulty in performing compositional reasoning such as understanding the
significance of the order of the words in a sentence. In this work, we
investigate to which extent purely synthetic data could be leveraged to teach
these models to overcome such shortcomings without compromising their zero-shot
capabilities. We contribute Synthetic Visual Concepts (SyViC) - a million-scale
synthetic dataset and data generation codebase allowing to generate additional
suitable data to improve VLC understanding and compositional reasoning of VL
models. Additionally, we propose a general VL finetuning strategy for
effectively leveraging SyViC towards achieving these improvements. Our
extensive experiments and ablations on VL-Checklist, Winoground, and ARO
benchmarks demonstrate that it is possible to adapt strong pre-trained VL
models with synthetic data significantly enhancing their VLC understanding
(e.g. by 9.9% on ARO and 4.3% on VL-Checklist) with under 1% drop in their
zero-shot accuracy. | [
0.0316985063,
0.0388973765,
-0.0067091864,
0.0635068864,
0.009066782,
0.031889651,
0.0204845406,
-0.0137471855,
-0.0036903636,
-0.0823542401,
-0.0062706419,
-0.0327361822,
-0.0200329293,
0.0650876909,
0.0035667859,
-0.0524620675,
0.0583300963,
-0.0380068645,
-0.0230343882,
0.0145866042,
0.0034944748,
0.0238398165,
-0.0090171481,
0.0281645618,
-0.0006123215,
-0.0244341008,
-0.0178415906,
0.0161269736,
0.0065830895,
-0.0180247389,
-0.0348312445,
0.0551368222,
0.0425419174,
0.038939707,
0.0000021117,
-0.0488679893,
0.0269675013,
-0.0100517049,
-0.0415422283,
-0.0116570853,
0.0073102918,
-0.002424937,
0.0041308822,
-0.010927842,
-0.0402024873,
-0.0450437404,
0.0572768115,
0.010346869,
0.0479193144,
0.0554672517,
-0.0172742195,
-0.0397181623,
0.0031672521,
0.0042382288,
0.0575046055,
-0.0202379003,
0.0073397956,
0.0119315246,
0.0157918166,
-0.0250161607,
-0.0525306575,
0.0378305353,
0.0456689373,
-0.0248180497,
0.016407555,
0.0614872873,
-0.0584262572,
-0.0514054485,
0.0121557331,
0.1081122234,
-0.0595300049,
-0.0232293792,
-0.0278688781,
-0.0131808212,
0.0008013523,
-0.0298859179,
-0.029859988,
0.0471637025,
-0.0200317837,
0.0005212406,
-0.0307580624,
-0.0273612496,
0.0110046584,
0.0240843203,
-0.0280872248,
-0.0137158511,
-0.0025515216,
0.0164817423,
0.019444745,
0.0125931408,
-0.0546505786,
-0.0647012144,
-0.0498831905,
0.0337551236,
-0.0494086109,
0.0418443419,
-0.0690136105,
-0.038575843,
-0.0195708498,
-0.0346714817,
0.0835735425,
0.0256428607,
-0.0421659015,
0.0655653328,
-0.0393880978,
0.0426639616,
-0.0126778297,
0.0578170195,
-0.0275401678,
-0.0132170636,
-0.0538303927,
-0.007877674,
-0.0394305922,
0.0020702332,
-0.0794607326,
-0.0323060676,
0.0066068089,
0.0059238947,
-0.0179954469,
0.0015811783,
0.0083766887,
0.0377452336,
-0.0194540415,
-0.0440502912,
-0.0419207998,
0.0107425628,
-0.0136648631,
0.0275396667,
-0.0168653745,
-0.0833581835,
0.0155835459,
-0.0062073716,
0.0132702822,
-0.0091563798,
0.0078024659,
0.0287968777,
-0.0295283962,
-0.0630135685,
-0.0328459777,
-0.0115884859,
0.0109663829,
-0.0520658754,
-0.0039061571,
-0.0859157592,
0.0005187856,
-0.0243937708,
-0.0024543966,
-0.0157898962,
0.0239789598,
0.0209649913,
-0.0395970792,
0.1372816861,
-0.0571060292,
-0.0196843725,
-0.0484854952,
0.0141477063,
0.0686236247,
0.064517118,
0.0030936433,
0.0046087243,
0.0183536094,
0.0001248823,
0.0259358753,
-0.0037372764,
0.0022413433,
-0.0217310172,
-0.0561543703,
0.0185056757,
0.003299881,
0.0437194817,
0.0260708984,
0.0254228823,
-0.0351871476,
-0.044752676,
0.0639669672,
0.0297223553,
0.006243939,
-0.0142952707,
0.088019602,
-0.012794368,
0.0068845595,
-0.0293926597,
-0.0710600913,
0.0414226688,
-0.0075251642,
0.0008768189,
-0.0484618731,
0.0194565952,
-0.0441903248,
-0.0566375554,
-0.0061347317,
-0.0089455703,
-0.0138802957,
0.0375369675,
0.0451097898,
0.0566565841,
-0.0453556776,
-0.0067751692,
0.033247292,
-0.0399178751,
0.0019291168,
-0.0321528837,
0.0390469134,
0.0638321713,
0.0396641754,
0.0009201053,
-0.0433271751,
-0.0108253118,
0.0205233824,
0.0503855944,
0.0323935002,
-0.0143355252,
0.0043412019,
-0.0569720492,
-0.0394416451,
-0.0290047284,
-0.0017081391,
0.0395796597,
0.0247736331,
-0.0028689234,
0.0104402248,
-0.0160887353,
-0.0233551562,
0.0324099138,
0.0149749313,
-0.0420464128,
0.0102598034,
0.0102491817,
-0.0094326837,
-0.0082414839,
-0.0148151265,
-0.0023650555,
-0.0003525402,
-0.0227579158,
0.0140363341,
-0.0063282247,
-0.0444478691,
-0.0282224584,
0.0113324979,
-0.0566496253,
-0.0193960927,
0.0478140302,
-0.0505523123,
-0.0138765853,
-0.0068008266,
0.0254709069,
-0.0076985527,
-0.0536331311,
0.0009584256,
0.0232131463,
0.0454457663,
-0.0102417246,
0.0572137237,
0.0092917159,
-0.0004768407,
-0.0037870063,
0.039489232,
0.0171285644,
-0.0282007456,
-0.0278178994,
0.0322156027,
-0.0143321259,
0.0155202793,
-0.0204627328,
0.0185847208,
-0.062983036,
0.0245199166,
-0.0901233256,
-0.0208527539,
-0.0260568596,
-0.0455773845,
0.0096321218,
-0.002012956,
-0.0021379739,
-0.0346257947,
0.0061163921,
0.0637159646,
-0.0003842404,
0.0103804357,
0.0236258749,
0.0114230569,
0.0040721162,
0.013369387,
-0.0043597962,
-0.0058625131,
0.0535716712,
0.019317897,
0.0309181791,
-0.0026004191,
0.0382549614,
-0.0453322008,
0.0547339171,
-0.0141733671,
-0.0158869363,
0.0216150451,
-0.0344413593,
0.0114424154,
0.0914125815,
0.0157995541,
0.0433004312,
0.0479308441,
-0.0171830505,
-0.0205859747,
0.0094984956,
0.0079826256,
-0.0469289534,
-0.0313734077,
0.0346481316,
-0.0408590697,
0.052873265,
-0.0351335704,
-0.0314801969,
-0.0848507211,
0.0506033078,
0.0013146565,
-0.0571978875,
-0.0775782391,
0.0191804431,
-0.0005136672,
0.0343493335,
-0.045387581,
-0.0338312685,
0.040782623,
-0.0142377978,
-0.0105825607,
0.003861906,
0.0066591343,
-0.0254514366,
0.0840189829,
0.0198316444,
0.0030681903,
0.0163503569,
0.0018826539,
-0.0765085295,
-0.0256346073,
0.004334928,
-0.0106956698,
0.0342533253,
-0.0542866923,
0.0218284298,
-0.0314498655,
-0.0152448099,
-0.0550772324,
-0.0149474964,
-0.0209524296,
-0.0005859449,
-0.0414450243,
-0.0059442236,
-0.0035090044,
-0.0056364499,
-0.0036910092,
0.0478853248,
0.0174729936,
-0.0192831922,
-0.0260650367,
0.0117584849,
0.0601696968,
-0.0145884594,
0.0154987304,
-0.0139880367,
0.0281023812,
0.0550402664,
0.0248945449,
-0.0040466352,
-0.0514151119,
0.0447332226,
0.0069350861,
0.0092636952,
-0.009290929,
0.0325735211,
0.0174680781,
-0.0729967505,
-0.0284163672,
0.093605943,
0.0275388118,
-0.0192327723,
-0.0132663371,
0.0040188218,
0.0129590658,
0.0746204704,
0.0426682904,
-0.1070128828,
-0.0375459492,
0.0033130115,
-0.0250609927,
0.0058531896,
-0.0458696,
-0.0498031899,
-0.1400936544,
0.0480893366,
-0.0301936287,
-0.0475606285,
-0.0216334593,
0.0332696438,
-0.0243317857,
-0.0101771951,
-0.0134403659,
-0.0004300301,
-0.0046320879,
0.0066321609,
-0.0084728487,
0.0459607691,
-0.0336395241,
0.0610042736,
-0.0258813147,
0.0169786457,
0.0279494748,
0.0286163446,
0.0203379635,
-0.048753012,
0.0329366475,
-0.040343415,
0.0024828746,
-0.0045739496,
0.0807889476,
-0.0232648496,
-0.0495116487,
0.025072284,
0.0404251926,
0.0072348122,
-0.0483522229,
-0.0399125926,
0.0348563716,
0.0046496764,
-0.0406994671,
-0.0152007369,
-0.0143459393,
-0.0019730891,
0.0405660495,
0.0341556519,
-0.014034952,
-0.0379455388,
0.0057561882,
-0.039184574,
-0.0469024107,
-0.0543040335,
0.0280584898,
0.0118349567,
-0.0543078855,
-0.039121177,
-0.0445646048,
0.0737792701,
0.098801896,
-0.0065256571,
-0.0342007801,
-0.0113788266,
0.0200223904,
-0.0636766553,
0.0778073594,
-0.0377314202,
0.0367041305,
-0.0168501958,
-0.0099764531,
-0.0121893417,
-0.0434198454,
-0.0314573497,
-0.023790611,
-0.0257098861,
-0.0360643454,
0.0085800281,
0.0774812177,
0.0191386547,
0.0693085641,
0.0030739589,
-0.058902964,
0.0625194609,
0.0503917485,
0.0242815148,
-0.0039700307,
0.0297256485,
-0.0307767075,
0.0212065708,
0.0395669825,
-0.010478003,
0.0256596189,
0.0354752503,
0.0167995319,
0.0080959946,
0.0371877439,
0.033340726,
-0.0068902452,
0.0649094507,
-0.0186026134,
0.0226429906,
-0.0499118268,
0.0131925251,
-0.0058474941,
-0.0168410372,
-0.0682305247,
-0.0103207026,
0.0314343758,
-0.0015351435,
0.0126907993,
-0.0005995509,
-0.0291067492,
0.0093677975,
0.0152419107,
-0.0357645191,
0.0618893653,
0.0121655986,
0.0438053198,
0.015642412,
-0.0074033793,
0.0412336811,
-0.0217390377,
0.0499829352,
-0.0045969626,
0.056137789,
0.0341907777,
0.0212621633,
-0.0375995114,
0.0160859469,
-0.0395885855,
-0.0514449961,
-0.0192934684,
0.073850669,
0.025657624,
-0.0252309516,
-0.0306425914,
-0.0201047324,
-0.0241025742,
-0.0034557888,
0.0234957188,
-0.0022167068,
-0.0588469729,
0.0560635626,
0.0379806831,
0.0085380245,
-0.0255234521,
0.0597919673,
0.0031624052,
0.0593217388,
-0.0060787527,
0.0319328681,
-0.036749687,
-0.0069893342,
0.0392336398,
0.0096446648,
0.0097872326,
0.0549535677,
-0.0627107322,
-0.0836887732,
-0.014502353,
0.0410865508,
-0.0107389698,
0.0445070602,
0.0491066948,
0.0418069251,
0.0190350879,
0.0123970015,
-0.0006444901,
-0.0370998643,
-0.0018045928,
-0.009758587,
0.0261103567,
-6.213487549e-33,
-0.0478327088,
-0.0140483268,
0.0605450384,
0.002854049,
-0.0075908927,
0.0208168626,
-0.0233741831,
-0.0022988187,
-0.0140710361,
0.0345556065,
0.0002497043,
0.0181622561,
0.0017987068,
0.0366425849,
-0.01015733,
-0.0272434354,
0.0165199358,
0.0139625678,
-0.0107271979,
0.0005610625,
0.0327701233,
0.0218619164,
0.0637374446,
-0.0014847057,
-0.00629739,
0.0359306782,
0.0160246938,
0.032282941,
0.0007175595,
0.0384029597,
0.0024581854,
0.0267142877,
0.0111520924,
-0.0032755209,
-0.0344677977,
0.0195696168,
-0.0746254474,
-0.0222449955,
0.0429228991,
0.0261692833,
-0.0624447577,
0.0036268849,
0.0222757142,
0.0033497044,
0.0230534039,
-0.0445362665,
0.0423547775,
-0.0164592266,
0.0108163264,
-0.0177446213,
-0.0539125204,
-0.0065958956,
-0.0077927127,
-0.0424684919,
0.0234601907,
0.03011268,
-0.0012639104,
0.0161452778,
-0.0073236092,
0.0251226351,
0.0002228962,
0.0086570531,
0.0896391794,
0.0505358726,
0.0076504708,
0.0614240132,
0.0269009843,
-0.0355343148,
-0.0519675165,
0.0129976366,
0.0589305758,
0.0702141374,
0.0357438624,
0.09268374,
0.0603135154,
0.0144371903,
-0.0358475633,
-0.0138056455,
-0.0681639761,
0.045891542,
-0.0149015477,
-0.0072765639,
0.0106231058,
-0.0097600734,
-0.0632720292,
-0.0298923776,
-0.0590091571,
0.006423092,
0.0799340978,
0.0230242256,
-0.0258189049,
0.0212474447,
0.0465016775,
-0.0440823361,
0.0029095141,
0.0149871949,
-0.0068894005,
0.0223244559,
0.0030625816,
0.0217333827,
-0.0466418564,
-0.0319767483,
0.0614866354,
0.013351771,
-0.0096122669,
0.0277237631,
0.0441293083,
0.0100153014,
-0.0277044922,
0.0010352023,
-0.0422449708,
-0.0027423608,
-0.0087170769,
0.0205375142,
0.0274267122,
0.0385265164,
-0.059731748,
0.0417605229,
0.0062817023,
-0.0343916826,
-0.0006584119,
-0.0284923222,
-0.002155704,
0.0357859954,
-0.0184769128,
-0.0104550626,
-0.0566308573,
-0.0328615345,
0.0552634113,
-0.0621004812,
-0.0063389204,
0.0460634679,
2.701e-7,
0.0332712866,
0.01384483,
-0.0139046339,
0.0123438761,
-0.0125704976,
0.0493102148,
0.0016103578,
0.0197920389,
-0.0127682621,
-0.0439673811,
0.004870269,
0.0742174387,
0.0022516886,
-0.011466261,
-0.0422281064,
0.025109658,
-0.0250362959,
0.0026954014,
-0.0764884725,
-0.0123898331,
0.0532065295,
0.0770647675,
0.0061386726,
-0.0285184868,
0.061410632,
-0.0220376439,
0.0452469252,
0.0004991086,
-0.0015758233,
-0.0220906734,
0.0073809354,
0.0131777599,
-0.0105388509,
0.0259432364,
-0.0076332903,
-0.01334034,
0.0166025963,
-0.0003835604,
-0.0370521806,
-0.0008683536,
-0.0424883515,
-0.0224881545,
-0.0340134874,
-0.0677620769,
0.0973096043,
-0.0808831975,
-0.0133556873,
-0.0137193603,
-0.0441995449,
0.0096954098,
0.0133879697,
-0.0113664167,
0.0007401868,
0.0016218227,
0.0188939087,
-0.0388316661,
-0.0200446527,
-0.080163151,
-0.0037621772,
-0.0027945428,
0.0078426553,
-0.0090449275,
-0.0322064273,
-0.0148259476,
0.0585616268,
-0.0037117007,
-0.0392330214,
2.103393546e-34,
0.0074591693,
0.0297889616,
0.0367714874,
-0.0297250617,
0.0039427341,
-0.0165094733,
-0.0200054124,
0.0073817549,
0.015300883,
-0.0556689389,
-0.0227291007
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.