id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17580v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17580v4 | HuggingGPT: Solving AI Tasks with ChatGPT and its Friends in Hugging Face | 2023-03-30T17:48:28 | 2023-12-03T18:17:21 | Yongliang Shen, Kaitao Song, Xu Tan, Dongsheng Li, Weiming Lu, Yueting Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Solving complicated AI tasks with different domains and modalities is a key
step toward artificial general intelligence. While there are numerous AI models
available for various domains and modalities, they cannot handle complicated AI
tasks autonomously. Considering large language models (LLMs) have exhibited
exceptional abilities in language understanding, generation, interaction, and
reasoning, we advocate that LLMs could act as a controller to manage existing
AI models to solve complicated AI tasks, with language serving as a generic
interface to empower this. Based on this philosophy, we present HuggingGPT, an
LLM-powered agent that leverages LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT) to connect various AI
models in machine learning communities (e.g., Hugging Face) to solve AI tasks.
Specifically, we use ChatGPT to conduct task planning when receiving a user
request, select models according to their function descriptions available in
Hugging Face, execute each subtask with the selected AI model, and summarize
the response according to the execution results. By leveraging the strong
language capability of ChatGPT and abundant AI models in Hugging Face,
HuggingGPT can tackle a wide range of sophisticated AI tasks spanning different
modalities and domains and achieve impressive results in language, vision,
speech, and other challenging tasks, which paves a new way towards the
realization of artificial general intelligence. | [
0.0357318446,
0.0375712961,
-0.0238747634,
0.0138548883,
-0.0461965576,
0.0243625119,
-0.0029439889,
0.0023406507,
0.0618711784,
-0.0186508149,
-0.0259988662,
-0.0079896478,
-0.0313769877,
0.0783945695,
0.0080919461,
-0.0724107847,
0.0321198963,
-0.0260059182,
0.0242838748,
-0.015157463,
-0.0031488016,
0.0244816244,
-0.003074111,
0.0517283529,
-0.0450374298,
-0.0140953157,
-0.0431174189,
-0.019959202,
0.0102474652,
-0.0017816393,
-0.0111222984,
0.0147534562,
0.0323231518,
0.0521470681,
0.0000021716,
-0.051425878,
-0.0042100013,
-0.0045876056,
-0.0298886448,
-0.0402323082,
0.0499302074,
0.0180830937,
0.0084598884,
0.0137122469,
-0.0772035569,
0.0380195118,
0.0730756372,
0.0406992286,
0.0448884256,
0.0563184507,
0.0073222034,
0.0229153689,
0.0041134716,
-0.0188390482,
0.0125467414,
-0.0581049621,
0.0142662395,
0.0159700755,
0.0557835661,
-0.0069423914,
-0.0040563513,
0.0419284143,
0.0420129113,
-0.0375511311,
0.0061288681,
0.039224755,
-0.0339493044,
-0.0419412032,
-0.0269955229,
0.0578637421,
-0.0271201804,
-0.0205201507,
0.0249565523,
0.0158855021,
0.0033007618,
0.0368485563,
-0.0554073229,
0.0350656956,
0.0035105755,
0.000904971,
0.0066037141,
-0.0137073137,
0.0271144882,
0.0113948984,
-0.0502541326,
0.0653705969,
-0.0084830849,
0.0042118514,
0.0078785745,
0.0010885908,
-0.050221175,
-0.0727968514,
0.0054313783,
0.0524719767,
-0.066248171,
0.0077331737,
-0.0430679508,
0.0113783665,
0.0010135765,
0.0025633916,
0.0307422988,
0.0519887581,
0.0106362645,
0.0626409501,
-0.0002945927,
0.0569570623,
-0.0117875412,
-0.0054035126,
-0.0329894312,
-0.0231361426,
-0.0635266304,
-0.0248897299,
-0.0294126887,
0.0566564053,
-0.0549648851,
-0.0530460402,
-0.0265978854,
0.0646598712,
-0.0447375551,
0.0149164861,
0.0299203116,
0.0310389455,
-0.015492823,
-0.0204547811,
-0.0374349467,
-0.0165703725,
-0.05256873,
0.0102192778,
0.0251140483,
-0.0487862118,
-0.0144055681,
0.0207176115,
0.0097547444,
-0.0109208645,
0.0110519417,
0.0884632617,
-0.0017601163,
-0.0297979023,
0.0026997074,
-0.0340147726,
0.0055724992,
-0.0845847577,
-0.0035080859,
-0.0598282404,
0.0564317517,
-0.0057532485,
-0.0195254683,
-0.0286794081,
0.010175392,
-0.007169982,
-0.010629517,
0.0707680732,
0.0087157376,
0.0272941478,
0.027821932,
0.0229515936,
-0.0541907139,
0.0482051671,
0.0253194179,
0.0438793451,
0.0307983067,
0.0313512944,
0.0514378846,
0.0522518456,
-0.0009321671,
0.0058416673,
0.0425650217,
-0.0178375132,
-0.006543362,
0.0225701369,
-0.0200126898,
0.0570314117,
-0.0177242067,
-0.016037466,
0.058572948,
0.0967089534,
-0.0545951389,
0.0381675474,
0.0504970886,
0.012414041,
-0.0003223435,
-0.0072245598,
-0.053593263,
0.0512433872,
-0.0792697296,
-0.0295197405,
-0.0452178307,
0.0291546825,
-0.0283965562,
-0.0466899164,
0.0103749475,
-0.0186512992,
0.0358354487,
0.0329044759,
0.0450085513,
0.0046427725,
-0.0213816632,
-0.0229915865,
0.007068634,
-0.0456781797,
-0.0091549037,
-0.0851347148,
0.035072796,
0.0768736377,
0.0404110216,
-0.0497847572,
-0.0532254912,
0.0226944182,
0.0206670351,
0.0334069654,
0.0177823436,
-0.0269768387,
-0.0289752297,
-0.0148255387,
-0.0112036653,
-0.0101083135,
0.0054179397,
0.0329079516,
0.0264788698,
0.0107021471,
-0.031435784,
0.0119100912,
-0.0162655059,
0.0203401223,
-0.0558396205,
0.0088673905,
-0.0028431483,
0.0022491263,
0.0439288616,
0.0028200473,
-0.0053359461,
-0.0023982301,
0.0358086005,
-0.0365736522,
-0.0735352114,
0.0322543085,
-0.0117393304,
0.0207782649,
0.0406684391,
-0.01067176,
-0.0146174608,
0.0372651219,
-0.0295491442,
-0.0362389423,
0.0479098447,
-0.0185342673,
0.0227039866,
-0.0136078093,
0.026126286,
-0.0091758221,
-0.0168124884,
-0.0100255571,
0.0656330511,
0.0100060841,
-0.0569817722,
0.0128965518,
0.0238642897,
0.0025750853,
-0.0403506123,
-0.0204879567,
0.0454885811,
0.0132834101,
0.0091552231,
0.0599519983,
0.024888413,
-0.0317853577,
-0.0383188985,
-0.127772823,
-0.00223678,
-0.0002675453,
-0.0144025162,
0.0074230018,
0.0146349287,
0.0002038669,
0.005902431,
-0.0289423335,
0.0528868809,
0.0312267561,
-0.0072886818,
0.0220561996,
0.0198131558,
-0.0331214219,
-0.0549241118,
0.0029919022,
-0.0179396719,
0.0075962245,
0.043237444,
-0.0443629175,
-0.0304307193,
0.0138066215,
-0.0540989712,
0.0436144285,
-0.0336750485,
-0.044608511,
0.0397026353,
-0.0474988595,
0.0171014201,
0.099261865,
-0.0056466935,
0.0602646545,
0.0597730465,
-0.0125494218,
-0.0708426908,
0.0215141047,
-0.0187695287,
-0.0134909302,
-0.0271618497,
0.0066606039,
0.0062261513,
0.0561168827,
-0.0106349504,
0.0002720778,
-0.0819480047,
0.0742306262,
0.0170603804,
-0.044026494,
-0.024295738,
-0.0232685395,
-0.0002201682,
0.0474439785,
-0.0245609116,
-0.0517618768,
0.0742845833,
0.0056977472,
-0.0160744246,
-0.0144329183,
-0.0404740833,
-0.0281007234,
0.1330725104,
0.0054899473,
0.0325594135,
-0.0241180919,
-0.0052300668,
-0.0535671189,
0.0198073871,
-0.0088339569,
-0.0145006087,
0.0173720308,
-0.0824168026,
0.0152359242,
0.0096970666,
-0.0548245162,
-0.0448326804,
0.0131268008,
-0.0551689267,
0.0226404201,
0.0007580786,
-0.0659101605,
-0.0546939597,
-0.0190993994,
0.0380215906,
0.0023212284,
-0.0204751883,
-0.0107222386,
-0.0448541529,
-0.0508318357,
0.0745682046,
0.0358989686,
-0.0252064858,
-0.0028528825,
0.0354863219,
0.0552663356,
0.0229366608,
0.0016450647,
-0.0228242893,
0.0047522401,
0.0235142596,
-0.0128829135,
-0.0151777612,
0.0019417072,
0.020902209,
-0.0520523861,
-0.0005591389,
0.1177582294,
0.0233821645,
-0.0216319598,
0.0070929173,
-0.0388466269,
0.0268716328,
0.0189982876,
0.0548024438,
-0.0781764984,
-0.0116823958,
0.013993144,
-0.0019106956,
-0.0057040504,
-0.0466843285,
-0.0102784224,
-0.0989936665,
0.0454519093,
0.014697955,
-0.0354217328,
-0.0188767854,
-0.0270654093,
0.0208846163,
-0.0063746087,
-0.0162478182,
-0.0111999288,
0.0206191875,
-0.0220132899,
-0.0109064495,
0.0332867876,
-0.0108829811,
0.0494983941,
-0.0301362183,
0.0407648012,
0.071515739,
0.0412732214,
0.0084448978,
-0.0154984221,
0.0119259693,
0.1037632003,
0.0080780797,
-0.0233538393,
0.0063516204,
0.0101578422,
-0.011660913,
0.0106056733,
0.062345542,
-0.0518314429,
0.0120513933,
0.0203987658,
0.0954275206,
-0.0399809219,
-0.0369342677,
-0.0166883133,
-0.0042866776,
0.0091672409,
0.0837683305,
-0.0054074847,
-0.045496773,
-0.0654510111,
-0.0325094573,
-0.0417400822,
-0.0172592569,
-0.0583880059,
0.0038177297,
-0.0096666291,
-0.0438507386,
-0.0798239708,
-0.0236483533,
0.086983338,
0.0159352813,
0.0290683936,
-0.0214425046,
0.0614029802,
0.0276676454,
-0.0118326955,
-0.0008449388,
-0.0309178848,
0.012692743,
-0.0380727462,
-0.0432130918,
0.0122533226,
-0.0576194413,
-0.0025671304,
0.0142764961,
-0.0138704088,
-0.0671027005,
0.0121149439,
0.0625992641,
0.0338126011,
0.027295474,
-0.0222921558,
-0.0435443111,
0.0210044179,
0.0611305349,
-0.0313486233,
0.0189248286,
0.0083101764,
0.020638952,
0.0014604197,
0.0563875809,
-0.0601585843,
0.0225302149,
-0.0122885164,
0.0083444128,
-0.0517500304,
-0.0077920128,
0.0248979386,
0.0413901918,
-0.0269107223,
-0.0024790834,
-0.0313042514,
-0.0293780919,
-0.0225393735,
-0.0173744,
-0.0198274069,
-0.0873587281,
0.0092694443,
-0.0034221364,
-0.0093556708,
0.0363858528,
-0.0149608161,
0.0056949193,
0.0000013085,
-0.018785825,
-0.0031176484,
-0.0033794569,
0.0280416999,
0.0444125421,
0.0154433586,
0.0041363798,
0.004480517,
-0.0182157792,
0.0146833779,
-0.0223565213,
0.0559077524,
0.017692199,
-0.0248648711,
-0.0144480001,
0.0460666008,
-0.0790202171,
-0.1192488298,
0.0295676626,
0.0517540909,
0.0459234193,
0.0469036959,
0.0170052536,
-0.0668925047,
-0.0118793566,
-0.0151001234,
0.0169602055,
0.0311727002,
-0.0416739546,
0.0054749018,
0.0382531434,
-0.016164599,
-0.0202229302,
0.0458707288,
-0.0388783589,
0.0579746328,
0.0107134944,
-0.0247693993,
-0.0381775536,
-0.0642820895,
0.0267368834,
0.0011352891,
0.0038375631,
0.0122872666,
-0.022952944,
-0.0485928692,
-0.0107419863,
0.0330162533,
-0.0185145959,
-0.0077551594,
0.0597869679,
0.0247080401,
-0.0223716423,
-0.0071447236,
-0.0319689177,
0.0066163628,
-0.0345857628,
-0.026495235,
-0.0074182302,
-6.348370383e-33,
-0.0233145002,
-0.0471595377,
0.0487349369,
0.0253332164,
-0.0100924345,
-0.0033991737,
-0.0512343459,
0.0358755402,
-0.015863616,
0.0119264442,
-0.0190572329,
0.0395559594,
0.0020043277,
0.0044221068,
0.0141990716,
-0.0025373767,
0.0177879017,
-0.0131241092,
-0.0076669892,
0.0445393883,
0.0323820077,
-0.0036429723,
-0.0088313436,
-0.0936688408,
0.0041869427,
0.0151710976,
-0.0239803493,
0.0341714695,
-0.0404245481,
0.0463991798,
-0.0310384389,
0.0088208588,
0.0153994234,
0.0271484647,
-0.0046087122,
0.0239763483,
-0.0246780775,
-0.0273145176,
-0.0047539133,
-0.0164993089,
-0.0754731074,
-0.0329613388,
0.0023179625,
-0.0187835675,
-0.0069191377,
0.0002187767,
0.0199926943,
-0.02543501,
0.0130367558,
0.0176389571,
-0.0762443542,
0.0057307556,
0.0027627328,
-0.0345342457,
0.0136951702,
-0.0005037944,
0.0074244523,
0.0253881589,
0.0243193004,
0.017150702,
-0.0327253789,
-0.0109877419,
0.0439671464,
-0.0030092541,
0.037627507,
0.0607063472,
0.0070369346,
-0.0137664033,
-0.0508261472,
-0.0048631225,
0.0019224033,
0.0989422202,
0.0344642363,
0.0336439647,
-0.0179282334,
-0.0001189594,
-0.0232740901,
0.0102558034,
0.0705882162,
0.0165241864,
0.0129563957,
0.0245363228,
-0.0342183262,
0.0030639488,
-0.0198271349,
-0.0006315295,
-0.0464232527,
-0.0370988809,
0.0150318202,
0.0196664575,
-0.029857209,
-0.0422106236,
0.017768167,
-0.0525536425,
0.030787684,
0.0032100286,
-0.0197197162,
0.0181989912,
0.0226771161,
0.0140500776,
0.0006415254,
-0.041900672,
-0.0001012856,
-0.0012121627,
0.0174931083,
0.0194493737,
0.0000420593,
0.0428829752,
-0.012786286,
0.0092987716,
-0.0578350388,
0.0363135189,
0.0339116491,
-0.0006014953,
0.0101957135,
0.0060506277,
0.0012651042,
0.0029688054,
-0.007276522,
-0.0041994527,
-0.0423979834,
0.0201057401,
-0.0304552224,
-0.0243867934,
-0.0579484999,
-0.0202723667,
-0.0760394335,
0.0156078339,
0.023177065,
-0.0611143149,
-0.0148321912,
0.0064110928,
2.906e-7,
-0.0056655584,
0.052352652,
-0.004689734,
0.0511508696,
0.0314161181,
0.0218688659,
-0.0004283571,
0.0246665366,
-0.0242678933,
-0.005527847,
0.0188220888,
0.0530918948,
0.0408996008,
0.0113622919,
-0.073818095,
-0.0063866572,
-0.0241953693,
-0.0436897278,
-0.0475763977,
0.0031521644,
0.0320300646,
0.0681667328,
0.0419984274,
0.009635713,
0.0292462297,
-0.0731220916,
0.0326959491,
-0.0336174965,
0.0260758791,
0.0230977293,
-0.0213349871,
0.0270102434,
-0.0017156117,
0.0062722522,
0.00897724,
0.0110392729,
-0.0010577741,
0.0908818319,
-0.0004779676,
-0.0145180197,
-0.0113416854,
0.0024768256,
0.0050511761,
-0.05424219,
0.0663040951,
-0.040499758,
-0.0221971143,
-0.0272146333,
0.0402098447,
-0.0338004567,
-0.0433090292,
-0.0253359061,
0.002330251,
0.0254667755,
0.0023424607,
-0.0283687338,
0.0198521763,
-0.0802078173,
0.0216021352,
-0.025941547,
-0.0692654625,
-0.0240695979,
-0.0391192771,
0.0377519615,
0.0060989447,
-0.029655857,
0.0089908857,
2.769436681e-34,
0.015712101,
0.0039931061,
-0.0076111853,
0.037378557,
0.059902858,
0.0201897658,
-0.0303735156,
0.0211918242,
0.0524154492,
-0.0633960515,
-0.0487490557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17574v1 | Elastic Weight Removal for Faithful and Abstractive Dialogue Generation | 2023-03-30T17:40:30 | 2023-03-30T17:40:30 | Nico Daheim, Nouha Dziri, Mrinmaya Sachan, Iryna Gurevych, Edoardo M. Ponti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ideally, dialogue systems should generate responses that are faithful to the
knowledge contained in relevant documents. However, many models generate
hallucinated responses instead that contradict it or contain unverifiable
information. To mitigate such undesirable behaviour, it has been proposed to
fine-tune a `negative expert' on negative examples and subtract its parameters
from those of a pre-trained model. However, intuitively, this does not take
into account that some parameters are more responsible than others in causing
hallucinations. Thus, we propose to weigh their individual importance via (an
approximation of) the Fisher Information matrix, which measures the uncertainty
of their estimate. We call this method Elastic Weight Removal (EWR). We
evaluate our method -- using different variants of Flan-T5 as a backbone
language model -- on multiple datasets for information-seeking dialogue
generation and compare our method with state-of-the-art techniques for
faithfulness, such as CTRL, Quark, DExperts, and Noisy Channel reranking.
Extensive automatic and human evaluation shows that EWR systematically
increases faithfulness at minor costs in terms of other metrics. However, we
notice that only discouraging hallucinations may increase extractiveness, i.e.
shallow copy-pasting of document spans, which can be undesirable. Hence, as a
second main contribution, we show that our method can be extended to
simultaneously discourage hallucinations and extractive responses. We publicly
release the code for reproducing EWR and all baselines. | [
0.062315803,
0.0762518868,
-0.0194104873,
0.0398124717,
-0.0211863741,
0.0116091277,
-0.0425871052,
0.0161712784,
-0.015468671,
-0.0348995179,
-0.0496198721,
-0.0236019734,
0.0144249257,
0.0215685163,
0.0200639125,
-0.0910013542,
0.00171001,
-0.0045475867,
0.0569815375,
-0.0204694606,
0.0126207052,
-0.0101621347,
-0.0074792351,
0.0422377475,
0.0009247754,
-0.0017147216,
-0.022852784,
0.0261105131,
0.0276967417,
0.00555227,
0.0185250565,
0.0621955357,
-0.0206991378,
0.0330391116,
0.000002138,
-0.0179338306,
-0.0034341712,
-0.0296249986,
-0.000995521,
-0.0047088861,
0.0000714609,
0.0077882479,
0.0198582187,
0.0036856581,
-0.042367924,
0.0065970658,
0.0473871566,
0.0880354941,
0.0805352777,
0.0840244964,
-0.0077495314,
-0.0045672068,
0.0115524475,
0.0082597472,
0.064130567,
-0.0240341891,
0.0098428298,
0.0372158028,
-0.012336609,
0.0176793989,
-0.0025611052,
0.0241219811,
0.0133665642,
-0.0235415753,
0.0145266736,
0.0182060581,
-0.0681752041,
-0.0260101389,
-0.0096891169,
0.1159422845,
0.0132406615,
-0.0278126709,
0.0212716255,
-0.0053187604,
0.0243120771,
-0.01580186,
-0.0504162423,
0.0087256776,
0.0012387467,
-0.0001365638,
0.0026324179,
0.0079040779,
-0.0076291747,
0.0163054634,
-0.0065196431,
0.0144967763,
0.0101779625,
-0.0424331427,
0.0032031741,
0.0050363634,
-0.0412128828,
-0.0688879117,
-0.0012667882,
0.0164836626,
-0.0363536887,
0.0007972581,
-0.0425968841,
-0.0262832996,
0.0161814075,
-0.0456849076,
-0.0163301826,
0.0234962236,
0.0031205909,
0.0069557321,
-0.0013195858,
0.0401254892,
-0.0088851405,
0.0399458781,
-0.0228053797,
0.0383727439,
-0.0422072485,
-0.0165135581,
-0.0493684411,
0.0439901613,
-0.0305908378,
-0.0562177077,
-0.0101339463,
-0.0025214015,
-0.0292460937,
-0.0042713899,
-0.0413094796,
0.0447813533,
-0.0228045005,
-0.0019327254,
-0.0042973757,
0.0115709407,
-0.0254420396,
0.0040865038,
0.0404689983,
-0.0374521837,
-0.0246141218,
0.0700283498,
-0.0160501711,
-0.0217090882,
-0.0036607927,
0.0305386689,
-0.015991345,
-0.0085897353,
0.0122022917,
-0.0522629395,
-0.0343084149,
-0.0818037912,
-0.0105280187,
-0.0206628609,
0.0359486975,
-0.0181626678,
-0.0313527808,
-0.0394853875,
0.00882887,
0.0163023714,
-0.0497983471,
0.0405408479,
-0.0050888322,
0.0155409016,
0.0519754887,
0.0143130897,
-0.0348215289,
0.0289966073,
0.0155857885,
0.0298997685,
0.0304527842,
0.0061239102,
0.0211517084,
-0.0008156488,
0.0262335278,
-0.0093299188,
-0.0095210178,
-0.0004023715,
-0.0639385134,
0.010215628,
0.0306836292,
0.0716566369,
-0.0671341196,
-0.0033160062,
0.0942237452,
0.0020185849,
-0.0080970209,
0.0223063529,
0.0367903709,
0.0518342666,
0.008854297,
0.0781226531,
-0.042546086,
0.0298098512,
-0.0184480157,
0.019024428,
0.0754901692,
-0.0270193946,
-0.0210238863,
-0.0347069576,
0.021550227,
0.0005681882,
-0.0040886882,
-0.0054813628,
-0.0104164062,
0.0307422597,
-0.0589081012,
0.0515139624,
0.0065231919,
-0.0635312498,
-0.0149284834,
-0.0232957322,
0.0302327853,
0.0472529382,
0.0591232032,
0.0010524949,
-0.0360819474,
-0.0032751733,
0.0041943933,
0.0827053189,
0.0604752041,
-0.0172680914,
0.023668509,
-0.0803206041,
0.0005124331,
0.001094283,
0.0096541205,
0.0074270503,
-0.0029268696,
-0.0060635377,
0.0088854916,
-0.0070277601,
-0.0588294528,
0.0454013385,
-0.0044404413,
-0.0383460931,
0.0123634925,
-0.0037888284,
0.0384569913,
-0.0000407952,
-0.008519006,
0.0224513412,
0.0140696969,
-0.0021324242,
-0.032211598,
0.0306301955,
-0.0647189617,
-0.0163878445,
0.0109594194,
-0.0327256061,
0.0145391263,
0.0004287766,
0.0046523046,
-0.0548605211,
0.0180049296,
-0.0569216721,
0.0155019155,
-0.0452904962,
0.0255330317,
0.0349450447,
0.0320433006,
-0.0451140963,
0.0696726814,
-0.0149663473,
0.0070415768,
0.0768267587,
0.010465065,
0.0036124515,
-0.0707379282,
-0.0080712968,
0.0089391926,
0.0052284789,
0.012803942,
0.037412025,
0.0073865787,
-0.0406774245,
-0.0469112881,
-0.0693433508,
0.0169065762,
-0.0307141598,
-0.0091864709,
0.0588605627,
-0.0067982194,
-0.0104217473,
-0.0000722252,
-0.072923623,
0.0147035159,
0.0236527696,
0.0124608194,
0.0165558942,
0.0136611983,
0.0020929549,
-0.0389041789,
0.0264955331,
0.0260795355,
0.0364144854,
0.0236637946,
-0.0223414786,
-0.0599172898,
0.0317442231,
-0.0709121674,
-0.0058189416,
0.0066149281,
-0.0359102897,
0.011321662,
0.0086784652,
0.0269737132,
0.0287236329,
0.0603337213,
0.0180086773,
0.0205216445,
-0.0003151169,
-0.051793132,
0.0157410987,
-0.0468343832,
0.0338209718,
0.0198024362,
-0.0410700105,
0.026077278,
0.0351873301,
0.0487858877,
0.049653694,
-0.0820632651,
0.0253412481,
0.0398030579,
-0.0703790858,
0.0172046367,
-0.0310811903,
-0.047159262,
0.0260280613,
-0.0268439949,
-0.0352158137,
0.0731897578,
-0.0211472996,
-0.005434603,
-0.0268160943,
0.0251409095,
0.0054411441,
0.008325004,
0.0103440406,
0.0232664477,
0.0231675431,
-0.0094843376,
-0.0418468565,
-0.0225028452,
0.0306010395,
-0.035277117,
0.016779881,
-0.0281314701,
0.0098299505,
0.0223788098,
-0.0283110142,
-0.0547697283,
-0.043271929,
0.0326063372,
-0.0273451712,
0.002901088,
-0.0279922858,
-0.0161271691,
0.0045994855,
0.0382972844,
0.0379451253,
-0.0369142368,
-0.0141840903,
-0.008212476,
0.071416907,
0.0567080267,
0.0233203452,
0.0372861028,
-0.0466920994,
0.0569427684,
0.0544072539,
-0.0022695297,
0.0240826868,
-0.0044040182,
-0.010119155,
-0.0047134133,
-0.0057808235,
-0.0249435324,
0.0201664921,
0.0678756014,
-0.0202901978,
-0.0480306,
0.1088868901,
0.0108548775,
-0.0489546619,
0.0073080603,
-0.0230764821,
0.1046772227,
-0.0092046587,
0.0127549674,
-0.0698484555,
-0.0241887271,
-0.0037220595,
0.0368628129,
-0.0277604293,
-0.0535257868,
-0.0220094565,
-0.0855086371,
0.0444673598,
0.0272409469,
-0.0154097155,
-0.0158603285,
0.0166345835,
0.0017173942,
-0.0032152126,
0.0153358905,
0.0290672015,
0.018824473,
0.0234581325,
0.0053600264,
-0.0326632075,
-0.0167187676,
-0.0166230239,
-0.0023789448,
0.0621194094,
0.0527714007,
0.0599916317,
0.0233612005,
-0.0454765484,
0.0103038177,
-0.0573516898,
-0.0103617227,
0.0131093562,
0.1004718915,
0.0014076178,
-0.0022491352,
-0.0348309278,
0.0588803999,
0.0020717664,
-0.0242767781,
-0.0040918691,
0.0210386459,
-0.0652067587,
-0.0310167558,
-0.0024201232,
0.0578266382,
0.048283916,
0.1056221053,
0.0559045635,
-0.0458350554,
-0.0355796628,
-0.0076424186,
0.0335652046,
-0.0569781661,
-0.0140703488,
0.0130274221,
0.0292768925,
-0.0026267667,
-0.1492622495,
-0.0637449995,
-0.015569685,
0.0437198281,
-0.0256262515,
0.0069710808,
-0.0560135692,
-0.0119930198,
0.0288386215,
0.0077936552,
-0.0109450221,
-0.0314920321,
-0.032428503,
-0.0349897854,
0.0327146351,
-0.0353982225,
-0.0009941848,
0.0386674441,
-0.0470272265,
-0.0953200758,
-0.0037556081,
0.0608174577,
0.0393237062,
0.0735172853,
0.0060929083,
-0.0085652685,
0.0262730587,
0.044692535,
-0.0432110876,
0.0220703837,
0.034477558,
-0.0035380553,
-0.0125051271,
0.047737889,
-0.0135661084,
0.01987735,
0.0012785364,
0.0476089455,
-0.0418042578,
-0.0867703259,
0.0284085069,
0.0287695453,
-0.0115892766,
-0.0165823344,
-0.0276318006,
-0.0227164328,
-0.005872068,
-0.0281289499,
-0.0210071839,
-0.0569398142,
0.0123377834,
0.0056858882,
0.0232581552,
-0.011383919,
-0.0024706912,
-0.0164414421,
0.0306468885,
-0.0180071052,
-0.0490267128,
-0.0192953777,
0.0199291203,
0.0083003314,
-0.0211488865,
-0.0445607603,
0.0408766158,
-0.0058090338,
0.0504109487,
0.0064800484,
0.1018976048,
0.0298317298,
-0.026631562,
0.0134228794,
0.0373810753,
-0.081582047,
-0.0741502941,
-0.0370796807,
-0.0048697875,
0.0005396268,
0.0141053926,
0.0970705971,
-0.0249957554,
0.0245696064,
-0.0115051279,
0.0381910317,
0.0194445755,
-0.0250511225,
0.0238647591,
0.0257534552,
-0.0241958741,
0.0358857773,
0.0774311051,
-0.042198699,
0.025774952,
-0.0143909305,
0.0062152008,
-0.069392629,
-0.051902961,
0.0102655115,
0.005188962,
-0.0170092788,
-0.0049617356,
-0.0272977576,
-0.0477991104,
0.0135673424,
0.0120335482,
0.0095312996,
-0.0099277021,
0.0534519479,
0.0575683936,
-0.0247206651,
0.0115198633,
-0.0324819982,
0.0029410596,
-0.0138065601,
-0.0011528594,
-0.0493621901,
-6.474979206e-33,
-0.0348778032,
-0.0270895921,
-0.0027299898,
0.0250360239,
-0.035859637,
-0.0262121353,
-0.0638263822,
0.0148133608,
-0.0091867605,
0.023545552,
0.01039101,
-0.0108192479,
0.004477568,
0.0121891359,
-0.0187541526,
-0.0100225033,
0.0414650664,
0.0012762438,
-0.0488744937,
0.0683746785,
0.0499308929,
0.0073189102,
0.008307891,
-0.0775969997,
0.0266197659,
-0.0238773506,
-0.0437870435,
0.0006527319,
-0.0006805582,
0.0337768048,
-0.0570267178,
0.0147971408,
0.0094020441,
-0.0102858329,
-0.0549652427,
0.0087517872,
-0.0239153579,
-0.0316753909,
0.0000954629,
0.0091643464,
-0.0319120325,
-0.0117605058,
0.0633665174,
-0.0326058865,
0.0024164184,
-0.0083360607,
0.0222556498,
-0.0265587792,
-0.0122490861,
-0.0037856996,
-0.0654791668,
0.0248836484,
-0.0140174357,
-0.0482820086,
-0.0139017422,
0.066646874,
-0.0187276695,
-0.024974145,
-0.0434767455,
0.0191028491,
-0.0041899392,
0.000103708,
0.0172814075,
0.0083931219,
-0.0043702889,
0.106277518,
0.0325049758,
-0.0024583596,
0.0016713991,
-0.0434830338,
0.0041219811,
0.0530131944,
0.0473145135,
0.0545642264,
0.0296294261,
0.0073122899,
-0.0414847918,
0.0323052034,
-0.0115205636,
0.0293480791,
0.0184135493,
0.0007322312,
-0.0242321733,
-0.008276036,
0.0073220278,
-0.042061232,
-0.0166881327,
-0.051455114,
0.0344646908,
0.0161752105,
-0.0367032439,
-0.0304829776,
0.0442371257,
-0.0147932805,
0.02985695,
0.0426982604,
-0.0803953335,
0.0119089372,
0.0002409057,
-0.0303879175,
-0.0342512093,
-0.0145388143,
0.0461632572,
0.0082736639,
0.0249788836,
0.0428202152,
0.0357679836,
0.0263839159,
-0.0470552593,
-0.0000755169,
-0.0314991772,
0.0500931628,
-0.004763274,
0.0188229904,
0.0154492985,
-0.0207604356,
-0.0438915305,
0.0194528643,
-0.0124863079,
0.0036290006,
-0.0446209013,
0.0003389496,
0.0308029205,
0.0232427754,
-0.0630898476,
-0.0113636311,
0.0080082044,
-0.0350035764,
0.0049331039,
-0.0676099956,
-0.0271955188,
-0.0065868837,
2.972e-7,
-0.0312441234,
0.0031169634,
0.0524129681,
-0.0155358193,
0.0099624535,
0.0412753522,
0.0098172668,
0.0291125868,
0.0220992696,
-0.0631524399,
0.024635043,
0.01362452,
0.0580982268,
0.0094055189,
-0.1021540463,
-0.0295464229,
-0.0955128968,
-0.0458241291,
-0.0275060236,
-0.0520596877,
0.0576834083,
0.0466675684,
-0.0111316852,
-0.0087934295,
0.0006867937,
-0.0298706479,
0.0716582537,
-0.0133949583,
-0.0121727949,
0.0283009298,
0.0676576197,
-0.0179012474,
-0.0295124557,
0.0252657197,
-0.0146758109,
0.0015310363,
0.0109799709,
0.0532663725,
0.0033337388,
-0.0597898215,
-0.0133543266,
0.0114707248,
0.0292870514,
-0.0521268882,
0.0300104339,
-0.0528545827,
-0.0296769179,
-0.0044018147,
-0.0535391867,
-0.0199225862,
0.0330446176,
-0.0265067052,
-0.0313884802,
0.0478281565,
0.0101656457,
0.0369889885,
0.008301802,
-0.0507123731,
-0.0153596019,
-0.0016009785,
-0.0614333004,
-0.0236082729,
-0.0292953793,
-0.0060799881,
-0.0132548241,
-0.0707635432,
0.0061947396,
2.879671189e-34,
0.0268717054,
-0.0120587051,
0.0288681705,
0.041364301,
0.0388394371,
-0.0033539166,
0.0345984697,
0.0120848604,
0.0384113938,
-0.0785555094,
-0.0290789157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17564v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17564v3 | BloombergGPT: A Large Language Model for Finance | 2023-03-30T17:30:36 | 2023-12-21T06:21:11 | Shijie Wu, Ozan Irsoy, Steven Lu, Vadim Dabravolski, Mark Dredze, Sebastian Gehrmann, Prabhanjan Kambadur, David Rosenberg, Gideon Mann | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.GN | The use of NLP in the realm of financial technology is broad and complex,
with applications ranging from sentiment analysis and named entity recognition
to question answering. Large Language Models (LLMs) have been shown to be
effective on a variety of tasks; however, no LLM specialized for the financial
domain has been reported in literature. In this work, we present BloombergGPT,
a 50 billion parameter language model that is trained on a wide range of
financial data. We construct a 363 billion token dataset based on Bloomberg's
extensive data sources, perhaps the largest domain-specific dataset yet,
augmented with 345 billion tokens from general purpose datasets. We validate
BloombergGPT on standard LLM benchmarks, open financial benchmarks, and a suite
of internal benchmarks that most accurately reflect our intended usage. Our
mixed dataset training leads to a model that outperforms existing models on
financial tasks by significant margins without sacrificing performance on
general LLM benchmarks. Additionally, we explain our modeling choices, training
process, and evaluation methodology. We release Training Chronicles (Appendix
C) detailing our experience in training BloombergGPT. | [
0.0024285736,
0.0959659815,
0.0120803965,
0.0229397919,
0.0188516602,
0.0232010018,
0.0206200704,
0.0379953869,
-0.0003095229,
-0.0644386113,
-0.0657549277,
-0.0345191434,
-0.0345246382,
0.0388746373,
0.0467982553,
-0.0353912525,
0.0322079845,
-0.0261165332,
0.0451315381,
-0.0222482756,
0.0274109114,
0.0297477022,
0.034595985,
0.0388835743,
-0.0098067047,
-0.0358338319,
0.0037549839,
0.0033694939,
-0.0073151751,
-0.0098039871,
0.0172083583,
0.0195923112,
0.0298777856,
0.0621059276,
0.0000018244,
-0.0365379453,
-0.041119948,
0.0010756655,
-0.0385983512,
0.0412114188,
0.0222603474,
-0.0429474339,
0.0501173846,
0.0202117376,
-0.0482014678,
-0.0347288884,
0.0417887717,
0.0913442671,
0.0710593238,
0.0793985873,
-0.0105405292,
-0.0560822077,
0.0075689368,
-0.0717476681,
-0.0190307833,
-0.0831969455,
0.0470152013,
0.0251232181,
-0.0158955716,
0.0167455282,
-0.0110600749,
0.0183192044,
0.0003940482,
0.0344623066,
0.0193593446,
0.0128488215,
-0.051477436,
0.0405757427,
-0.0581745431,
0.0643878654,
-0.0186661202,
0.0232882667,
0.0248082802,
-0.0104933586,
-0.0378634185,
-0.0063971039,
-0.0426878184,
0.0330781154,
0.0140118422,
0.0109937815,
0.0218633618,
-0.0320307091,
0.0459530316,
0.0081230169,
-0.0251972452,
0.0304048844,
-0.0058157835,
-0.0233376566,
0.0177230667,
0.0183043014,
-0.0286329594,
-0.0458050817,
-0.0143088801,
0.0095825074,
0.0101666842,
0.0122185554,
-0.0177436098,
-0.0163443498,
0.0179307535,
-0.0830665901,
0.0300566833,
0.0007923681,
0.0079456465,
0.0793614313,
-0.0516255125,
0.0295461919,
-0.014105266,
-0.0148398131,
-0.0191844404,
-0.013779467,
-0.065211162,
-0.01922247,
-0.0508169085,
0.0841858611,
-0.0359998159,
-0.0418984443,
-0.0611150786,
-0.0115869045,
-0.0077462541,
0.0252265874,
0.0293828081,
-0.0219062679,
0.0082675973,
-0.036959298,
-0.0131705068,
-0.0131306322,
-0.0463841408,
0.0212427117,
-0.0201675165,
-0.0281693153,
-0.0063983663,
0.024838198,
-0.0394658707,
-0.0423682593,
0.0105171017,
0.1036908552,
0.0521018356,
-0.0474247746,
-0.0683183745,
-0.035821747,
0.0119801732,
-0.0375843644,
-0.026591232,
-0.0442068502,
0.0283319838,
0.0058781854,
0.0004855683,
-0.0099827405,
0.0081959851,
-0.0082358727,
-0.0270804781,
0.0802745447,
-0.0105699664,
-0.0187881142,
0.0101044634,
-0.0359779894,
0.023595918,
0.0617863014,
0.0015225112,
0.0054915068,
0.0552576669,
0.0087547814,
-0.0081994655,
0.0582348965,
0.0245318543,
-0.0363965705,
0.0065749949,
0.0676854104,
0.0131419757,
0.0052860198,
0.0641321093,
0.0310541708,
-0.0446284562,
-0.0239210147,
0.0445078611,
0.0425107628,
0.0415674224,
0.0073520183,
0.0077126161,
0.0100843487,
0.0336297341,
-0.0616593622,
0.0063108178,
-0.0153236445,
-0.0040783305,
0.0367141925,
0.005247253,
0.0033068249,
-0.0464948602,
-0.0190586392,
-0.0310396217,
-0.0177305602,
-0.0262760781,
0.0029772471,
0.0282507278,
-0.0371435583,
-0.0426621996,
0.0961168781,
0.0365116745,
0.0017360353,
-0.0026046736,
-0.0389302708,
0.060476061,
0.0799777061,
0.0149064977,
-0.0387905724,
0.0156996679,
-0.0429926477,
-0.0047024377,
0.0506384596,
0.0387178324,
-0.0140858544,
-0.0186415166,
-0.0429411009,
0.0111386422,
0.0020791686,
0.0198055468,
0.0401229337,
0.0232642442,
0.0181318857,
0.0013267311,
-0.0485052764,
-0.0260441583,
0.0172409248,
0.0029126736,
-0.0586929545,
0.0202734321,
-0.0267779175,
0.0086829085,
0.0297786091,
-0.018696757,
0.0019366534,
0.0009589131,
-0.0019081663,
-0.0366126522,
-0.0160504151,
-0.0258676317,
-0.0102683809,
0.0111384625,
0.0101592029,
-0.027285153,
0.0085312715,
-0.0513871871,
-0.0207832754,
-0.0070056189,
-0.0080659138,
0.0408248529,
-0.0636235029,
-0.0175350402,
0.0245721806,
0.0244282447,
-0.0012284638,
0.0527312122,
0.0059428215,
0.0180183761,
-0.0365275294,
0.0173379537,
0.032746505,
-0.0377313867,
0.0127012571,
0.0177693292,
-0.0215682648,
0.0491594002,
0.0302692279,
0.0038764302,
-0.0165584851,
-0.013127177,
-0.1109861583,
-0.0051965183,
-0.0158201009,
0.0411774702,
-0.0074651204,
0.0135498773,
0.0026957584,
-0.014752401,
-0.0435199067,
-0.0302736554,
-0.0180600435,
0.0032458624,
0.0680155158,
-0.0021683325,
-0.0150256129,
-0.0556393191,
-0.0091566788,
-0.001477574,
0.0414713435,
0.0068600453,
-0.0115067102,
-0.0117171751,
-0.034832336,
-0.0193302426,
0.0063217022,
-0.0128378291,
0.0274173841,
-0.0072305938,
-0.0093482761,
0.0259444024,
0.0520617738,
0.0061792415,
0.0372701772,
-0.0424696393,
0.000277881,
-0.0544708557,
0.0211474802,
-0.0103563536,
0.0049856636,
-0.0088396743,
0.0091496604,
0.0220120456,
0.0545549504,
-0.0356333852,
-0.0042856145,
-0.0768461674,
0.0588885099,
-0.0089002987,
0.0238667354,
-0.047597494,
0.0262892004,
-0.0035172692,
0.0246329438,
-0.0061981902,
-0.0320477448,
0.0502631553,
-0.0293116663,
-0.0063854754,
-0.0196554419,
-0.0303703919,
-0.0969353989,
0.0449960269,
-0.0291757472,
0.0156385954,
0.0057299435,
-0.0439474136,
0.0120797865,
-0.0282056965,
0.0074467231,
-0.0178791173,
0.0618314184,
-0.0195048321,
0.0617893003,
-0.0067325416,
-0.0288495123,
-0.0021853526,
-0.0497998297,
-0.0468578413,
0.030893147,
0.0402766466,
-0.0619063713,
-0.0329139382,
0.0262999386,
-0.0182053354,
-0.0004132734,
-0.0075822859,
-0.0231956765,
0.0130081913,
0.0151784914,
0.09118855,
-0.0163409002,
0.0445046872,
-0.020584194,
0.0210288577,
0.0235809498,
0.0567863099,
0.0244983621,
-0.0287186857,
-0.0127050923,
-0.0132204266,
-0.076983422,
-0.0019061229,
-0.0242736787,
0.004984431,
-0.0380363613,
-0.0053099873,
0.1261765957,
0.0057780417,
-0.0073071341,
-0.0006024336,
0.0319528878,
-0.0034466363,
-0.0215545278,
0.0507812053,
-0.112634182,
-0.0419896133,
-0.0118888477,
0.011293008,
0.0445090011,
-0.058268398,
-0.0076919356,
-0.1345728338,
0.0185419358,
-0.0142932246,
0.0063577523,
-0.0289443396,
-0.0661905929,
-0.0533438437,
-0.0643196851,
0.0487441309,
0.0053279349,
-0.0380768962,
0.0117713129,
0.0094469488,
-0.0537711382,
-0.0077218278,
0.0350098573,
-0.0218694564,
-0.0118410829,
0.0143464869,
0.0024776743,
-0.0209087152,
0.0023992264,
-0.0149284136,
-0.0088673411,
-0.0278929081,
-0.0166046973,
0.0415231325,
-0.049542442,
-0.0431764983,
0.0244701151,
0.0319536328,
-0.0750714093,
0.052674979,
0.0106856404,
0.0068239113,
0.002983347,
-0.0150900204,
0.0044537564,
0.00264909,
-0.0348196626,
0.0684666708,
-0.0017530246,
-0.0446374938,
-0.0419320539,
-0.0371073261,
-0.0327957943,
-0.059711419,
-0.0030639616,
-0.0172992311,
-0.0005353682,
0.0205282085,
-0.0978051946,
-0.043737635,
0.0493213087,
0.0254086424,
-0.0155786742,
0.027142439,
0.0242801104,
0.001204215,
-0.0418991521,
0.0525646694,
-0.052347865,
0.0323365517,
-0.0705600232,
-0.0010961503,
0.01702247,
0.0215778127,
-0.0722570717,
0.050401438,
-0.0837566033,
-0.0426996537,
-0.0170559306,
0.0141547127,
0.0171409361,
0.0030019379,
-0.0157870781,
0.0168140084,
0.0195961725,
0.043968644,
-0.0590999313,
-0.0246905647,
0.0547511019,
0.0113141341,
0.0010734621,
0.0406551473,
-0.0638332143,
0.01338067,
0.0039087753,
0.0252928995,
-0.0383398719,
0.0338125974,
-0.0043186597,
0.0078624981,
0.0341581479,
0.0263401158,
-0.0161707569,
-0.0277162157,
-0.0248769168,
0.0084715579,
-0.0010618606,
-0.0189069305,
-0.0181155633,
0.0389533266,
-0.0252165738,
-0.0545317195,
0.0135796247,
-0.0139455358,
-0.0143228453,
-0.0194945186,
0.0257505644,
0.0000249963,
-0.0026621786,
0.0369255058,
-0.0378937349,
-0.0060561365,
0.0005723662,
0.0383658595,
0.0003749866,
-0.0107872486,
-0.0067042871,
0.0225204341,
0.0317425914,
-0.00393687,
-0.0090360027,
-0.0361602753,
-0.030670831,
0.0109015116,
0.0631921366,
0.0475818664,
-0.0304443445,
0.0057775206,
-0.0440165326,
0.0033618112,
-0.0061047492,
0.0225428343,
0.0123062991,
-0.0132673988,
0.0282421857,
0.0163739696,
-0.0715489462,
-0.0046135611,
0.1284853816,
0.0418405831,
0.0346699841,
-0.0085239829,
0.0075204829,
-0.0464873612,
-0.0165458247,
0.0477399006,
0.0090158144,
-0.0209473204,
0.0276065562,
-0.0421510302,
-0.06235734,
0.0408065431,
-0.0105482452,
0.0157433804,
0.0139442477,
0.0308288503,
0.0660237521,
0.0245402772,
0.0219295081,
-0.0219786949,
0.0032217307,
-0.0189759657,
-0.0346021876,
-0.0543180667,
-5.943651719e-33,
-0.0119545674,
0.01338208,
0.0409739166,
0.0069736992,
0.0136389043,
0.0400853194,
0.0039063934,
-0.0120360004,
-0.0216293558,
0.0109402835,
-0.0033880952,
0.0290152803,
0.0060897577,
0.0411958657,
0.0142028416,
-0.0013846037,
0.0438594408,
-0.033366058,
0.0164122358,
-0.0041117049,
0.0325475782,
0.0699533969,
0.0503204353,
-0.041384574,
0.0288648289,
-0.0072526955,
-0.0410510488,
-0.0025822811,
0.0621215925,
0.0729391798,
-0.0253859684,
0.0484724045,
0.0187344756,
-0.0917814896,
-0.0132953404,
-0.0141428672,
-0.0603355765,
-0.0207425952,
0.0057747089,
0.0399386734,
0.0191852693,
-0.0174373053,
0.0144414036,
-0.0077981651,
-0.0110939164,
-0.0090334481,
0.00850699,
0.0062578917,
0.0060089356,
-0.0413073748,
-0.0573803,
0.0479919836,
0.0127099166,
0.0479025133,
0.0239247382,
0.0294442829,
-0.0134971663,
0.0367871225,
-0.015356712,
-0.0054835244,
-0.0038104132,
0.026290914,
0.0000815096,
0.007328589,
0.0101754395,
0.0375430286,
-0.0056608515,
0.0058843261,
0.01002781,
0.039500162,
0.0102361264,
0.0359707586,
0.0323168561,
0.0227611996,
0.016006114,
-0.03184608,
-0.0532415658,
-0.0010227981,
0.021954814,
0.0266713314,
0.011481259,
0.0274198987,
-0.013448217,
-0.0220555905,
-0.005351427,
-0.0184009541,
-0.02634128,
-0.004349065,
0.0232695788,
0.0518147983,
-0.0052828686,
0.0311533175,
0.0072489977,
-0.0653597862,
-0.1098952144,
0.0184150748,
0.0186528172,
-0.0008101047,
0.0093423175,
0.013387003,
-0.0631033331,
-0.0443470068,
-0.0099789118,
0.0054751672,
-0.002602085,
-0.0303711481,
0.0576352105,
-0.0042038998,
-0.0738923401,
-0.0047640847,
0.011876463,
0.0346160159,
-0.014774506,
0.0675861388,
0.0077454974,
0.0310485959,
0.0173159353,
0.0143472785,
-0.0089684958,
-0.0036217859,
0.0032784904,
-0.0273033958,
-0.0041637551,
0.0577435233,
0.0117364889,
0.0006841299,
-0.0085579464,
0.0205653086,
0.0267616734,
-0.0303945336,
-0.0281749573,
0.033722166,
2.469e-7,
0.0270051174,
0.0747113302,
0.0241262242,
0.037423335,
0.0137402453,
0.0265051275,
-0.021716075,
0.0359429978,
-0.0359768793,
0.0112384073,
0.0024073913,
0.0127929505,
0.0600868315,
0.0013992098,
-0.1128980517,
-0.0438396893,
-0.0744978562,
0.0375575572,
-0.077801533,
0.0157382227,
0.0086188884,
0.1229033396,
-0.0125368051,
-0.024765661,
0.0024409329,
-0.0932849646,
0.0678547323,
-0.035236638,
-0.0263446439,
0.0178359374,
-0.0052996366,
0.053622216,
0.003306235,
0.0013522025,
-0.0232739449,
0.0254752841,
0.0359735973,
0.0640532151,
0.0178768001,
-0.0065157623,
0.0154258478,
-0.0203391518,
-0.0105158864,
-0.0459242165,
0.0598957315,
-0.0398001671,
-0.0230990835,
-0.0521577783,
-0.054696016,
0.0042700842,
0.0410475098,
-0.0001421287,
-0.0264930576,
0.0312171113,
0.0349683948,
-0.0247882474,
0.0146080982,
-0.0665590093,
0.0259281937,
0.019878801,
-0.028705854,
0.0314746872,
-0.0300648771,
0.0202164426,
0.0233104527,
-0.0300942678,
-0.0036256635,
2.288890228e-34,
0.0742170587,
-0.0372834392,
-0.0144901499,
0.0574642569,
0.0691142008,
0.0015914823,
-0.0200159624,
0.0467548668,
-0.0015545732,
-0.0849026367,
0.001898085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17557v1 | Recognition, recall, and retention of few-shot memories in large language models | 2023-03-30T17:26:16 | 2023-03-30T17:26:16 | A. Emin Orhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE | The training of modern large language models (LLMs) takes place in a regime
where most training examples are seen only a few times by the model during the
course of training. What does a model remember about such examples seen only a
few times during training and how long does that memory persist in the face of
continuous training with new examples? Here, we investigate these questions
through simple recognition, recall, and retention experiments with LLMs. In
recognition experiments, we ask if the model can distinguish the seen example
from a novel example; in recall experiments, we ask if the model can correctly
recall the seen example when cued by a part of it; and in retention
experiments, we periodically probe the model's memory for the original examples
as the model is trained continuously with new examples. We find that a single
exposure is generally sufficient for a model to achieve near perfect accuracy
even in very challenging recognition experiments. We estimate that the
recognition performance of even small language models easily exceeds human
recognition performance reported in similar experiments with humans (Shepard,
1967). Achieving near perfect recall takes more exposures, but most models can
do it in just 3 exposures. The flip side of this remarkable capacity for fast
learning is that precise memories are quickly overwritten: recall performance
for the original examples drops steeply over the first 10 training updates with
new examples, followed by a more gradual decline. Even after 100K updates,
however, some of the original examples are still recalled near perfectly. A
qualitatively similar retention pattern has been observed in human long-term
memory retention studies before (Bahrick, 1984). Finally, recognition is much
more robust to interference than recall and memory for natural language
sentences is generally superior to memory for stimuli without structure. | [
0.0125566153,
0.0126624731,
-0.0222083721,
0.0159684028,
-0.0447659642,
0.0406809114,
0.0162835922,
0.0204107277,
-0.009139644,
-0.0549598634,
-0.029776128,
-0.0614850819,
-0.007247265,
-0.0241693035,
0.0162781011,
-0.0453248173,
0.0732212663,
-0.0500121564,
0.0000582845,
-0.0164620429,
-0.0237858761,
-0.0560654514,
-0.01087006,
-0.0105087319,
0.012689854,
-0.0206856076,
-0.0258264896,
-0.0365789607,
-0.0090342825,
-0.0600087419,
-0.0292512625,
0.0427640155,
0.0120635498,
0.0353614986,
0.0000018871,
-0.0644658729,
0.0193415117,
-0.0111187035,
-0.0757422596,
0.0107781654,
0.0016904299,
0.0153125348,
-0.0132039897,
-0.0202740543,
-0.0131765958,
-0.0252182521,
0.0261800289,
0.040745385,
-0.0059929746,
0.0382220931,
0.0209812876,
-0.0222642589,
0.0327440836,
-0.0015135227,
0.0576762334,
-0.020097496,
0.0231232587,
-0.0207554903,
-0.0264688917,
-0.0100660538,
-0.0190914664,
0.0200741086,
0.0140247382,
0.0630036145,
0.0338499844,
0.0973093584,
-0.031485524,
0.0112307584,
-0.0312083419,
-0.0089071039,
-0.0058070854,
-0.0263954308,
-0.0049186219,
-0.0108672278,
0.0015546016,
-0.0306960456,
-0.0590198115,
-0.0096901432,
-0.0040001073,
0.0064066839,
-0.0136432573,
-0.0180925541,
0.0388189368,
0.021846015,
-0.0065369275,
-0.0219778996,
0.0099218562,
-0.0404804461,
0.007146813,
-0.007973128,
0.0156247206,
-0.0420812778,
-0.0118545694,
0.0545397811,
0.0169705246,
0.023285754,
-0.0263096001,
-0.004500791,
0.0319259353,
-0.06487903,
0.0721125603,
0.0183638632,
-0.0200194363,
0.0479255915,
-0.0858342052,
0.0910724774,
-0.004592042,
0.0157796741,
0.0030154062,
0.0304372851,
-0.0940233245,
-0.0080432622,
-0.0283134487,
0.0596254505,
0.0775045231,
-0.0038609856,
-0.0466630533,
0.0140209338,
0.0186122172,
0.015868647,
-0.0639227778,
-0.0227511972,
-0.0242126584,
0.0160059035,
-0.0310267434,
-0.0069388212,
-0.020855194,
0.0042556422,
0.0198787246,
-0.0601493493,
-0.0496542342,
-0.0197897907,
0.0262597445,
-0.0138896806,
0.018954372,
0.0440818854,
-0.0102311959,
-0.0826256424,
-0.0632510707,
-0.0037766981,
0.0082938988,
-0.0619724691,
0.0335963331,
-0.0534863472,
-0.0086670918,
0.0301003456,
0.0133191487,
-0.0369466357,
0.0063956585,
-0.0016483687,
-0.0369643308,
0.0548413284,
0.0364462063,
0.0127611086,
0.0378123894,
0.0126544842,
0.0073127751,
0.0438026637,
0.003529167,
0.0047982223,
-0.0045420039,
-0.0137322079,
0.0467640683,
0.0228985623,
0.0073827789,
0.0050692344,
-0.03695824,
-0.0249915272,
0.0365420319,
0.0332485773,
0.0312887058,
0.0332906321,
-0.0347626619,
-0.01580479,
0.0495294668,
0.0622186922,
-0.0145353125,
-0.0049081929,
-0.0010141309,
-0.0299909525,
0.0440623648,
0.0402598679,
-0.0752860755,
0.0366844498,
-0.0107959211,
0.0163758602,
-0.005550947,
0.023745358,
-0.0537775196,
0.0270874612,
-0.0312034525,
-0.0012643106,
-0.0189905893,
0.0063983561,
0.0574843846,
-0.016977435,
-0.0459650904,
0.0529271513,
0.0208001602,
-0.0052385442,
0.0004993589,
-0.061136242,
0.0398044102,
0.0473144464,
0.0154870888,
-0.0015945213,
0.0071627703,
0.0101211835,
-0.0014010636,
-0.0133473827,
0.0778923482,
0.0217033122,
0.039136786,
-0.0171767306,
0.0027479399,
-0.0101661468,
0.0317981243,
0.0360052772,
0.0198497418,
0.0091257645,
-0.0048378156,
0.0368044749,
-0.0283852201,
0.0467606857,
-0.0314623415,
-0.0555289797,
-0.0417660326,
-0.0136086522,
0.0045669936,
-0.0242101066,
-0.0200670231,
0.0240608007,
0.0397899933,
-0.0316583216,
0.0294242054,
-0.0114468234,
-0.0621998943,
-0.0322836824,
0.0193232242,
0.0548905991,
0.0008931132,
-0.0294794552,
-0.0066949641,
-0.0462189615,
-0.0032812853,
-0.0187048744,
0.0705479234,
-0.007181331,
0.0560781769,
-0.0282916185,
-0.0036096261,
-0.0271631088,
0.0765046775,
-0.0071137333,
0.0158916693,
-0.0115505755,
-0.0120776901,
0.0043888916,
-0.069748953,
-0.0126318559,
-0.0003997145,
-0.0332308114,
-0.0015639297,
-0.013437802,
-0.0652191043,
-0.0712835863,
-0.0163087454,
-0.0351127051,
-0.0024989233,
0.0200315583,
0.0136601878,
-0.0132926079,
-0.0301325787,
-0.0256759692,
-0.018061297,
-0.0110740066,
0.0245839898,
-0.0105697419,
0.0777067691,
-0.0015485033,
0.0065365005,
0.0109064253,
-0.0311699267,
0.0081989849,
0.0054269708,
0.0489502996,
-0.0145217609,
-0.0579055659,
-0.0440853275,
0.0747169629,
-0.0078122406,
0.017694572,
0.0116803329,
-0.0349030681,
0.0224196352,
0.0086261481,
0.0608097613,
0.0945368484,
-0.003954656,
0.0119340885,
0.0657225996,
-0.0038762377,
-0.0404701009,
-0.0288535152,
-0.0191175602,
-0.0390331633,
-0.0135219833,
-0.0135441134,
-0.0252062976,
0.0771285668,
0.0140692573,
0.0172664933,
-0.0142912669,
0.0504056513,
-0.0463274345,
-0.048868712,
-0.0468275808,
-0.005730282,
-0.0701338798,
0.0214871075,
-0.0104732998,
-0.0444971249,
0.0184039809,
0.0183534343,
0.0201028399,
0.027102787,
0.0001123349,
0.0386178717,
0.0669006631,
0.0453961305,
0.0198678169,
0.029982863,
-0.0096538095,
-0.0435685925,
-0.0239702128,
0.000871325,
-0.0324806161,
0.0015611486,
-0.0122478222,
-0.0035413231,
-0.0290617235,
-0.0185984932,
-0.0793604925,
-0.0099462969,
-0.0412379615,
0.0139734736,
-0.0588616654,
0.0304114744,
-0.0339371003,
-0.0012289946,
0.0699039474,
0.0265446194,
-0.0009699739,
-0.0251566712,
-0.0143629853,
0.0322625786,
0.0144315101,
-0.0233628806,
0.0288330279,
-0.048655007,
0.0444700271,
0.0408822335,
0.0813288614,
0.0509620309,
-0.0368760414,
-0.0040212013,
-0.0108767906,
-0.0424827822,
-0.0337480679,
0.0585000589,
0.0432685353,
-0.0637019649,
-0.0307226498,
0.0717097893,
0.0227550212,
-0.0531152077,
0.0001329872,
0.0010891876,
0.006700397,
0.0520146713,
0.0123878205,
-0.0361409262,
0.0138509655,
0.0262693968,
-0.0314826258,
-0.0458826646,
0.0034779178,
-0.0154924272,
-0.1160479411,
-0.0013923469,
0.0273875836,
-0.0478351116,
0.0163849443,
-0.0477756225,
-0.0095914304,
0.0144796222,
0.0264080297,
0.0386347771,
-0.0419730321,
-0.0082479808,
0.0401169024,
0.0368556455,
-0.0474885479,
0.0523073003,
-0.0306586884,
0.0495906435,
0.0280270539,
0.0035103895,
-0.0144908903,
-0.040177267,
0.0241927281,
0.005870949,
0.0458759442,
0.0230586417,
0.0627210289,
0.0388550796,
-0.0018583094,
-0.0195686538,
-0.0021011925,
0.010540965,
-0.0768701658,
0.014290235,
0.0311572552,
-0.022349529,
-0.0317417793,
0.0157719906,
-0.0381000675,
-0.0533835255,
0.0811027735,
0.0512496457,
-0.0125408759,
-0.0177642889,
0.0175470058,
0.0577223301,
-0.0240576286,
-0.0302382708,
0.0457766466,
-0.0340438224,
0.0122442907,
-0.0631146133,
0.001277133,
-0.0038356544,
0.0487031601,
0.0181459151,
0.0263258331,
-0.0196472257,
-0.0068224235,
-0.0003327599,
0.0186914988,
-0.0452557802,
-0.0321953557,
-0.075450711,
-0.0143468883,
0.0265625771,
-0.0124955522,
-0.0120274648,
-0.0233471692,
-0.1055812761,
-0.0431155935,
0.0662956387,
0.0251365453,
0.0264666509,
0.0381288528,
0.0206642319,
-0.0471648686,
0.0498903506,
0.009429981,
0.0036257124,
0.0579251982,
-0.0090550166,
-0.0163400881,
-0.0195176695,
0.0064700432,
-0.0140246199,
0.013548037,
0.0547037162,
-0.0146843651,
-0.0207398608,
0.0410341956,
0.0270510856,
-0.0044713225,
0.0579503886,
-0.0077310214,
0.008229102,
0.0145380888,
0.0184428077,
0.0342784263,
0.0183597021,
0.0319404453,
-0.0572410896,
0.014134285,
0.0267698653,
-0.0044557834,
-0.0534961931,
0.0077675097,
0.0843653232,
-0.0239164792,
-0.0768063888,
0.0250871517,
-0.0253749453,
0.007747801,
0.0548216812,
-0.0375855565,
0.0548288114,
-0.0346269011,
0.011515677,
-0.0110734962,
0.0580718555,
-0.0127055049,
-0.0158790741,
-0.0519436747,
-0.0348296687,
-0.0893754661,
-0.0397066027,
0.0125390515,
0.0093388343,
0.0649405643,
-0.0337035991,
-0.0079897959,
-0.0294656325,
0.0014755799,
-0.0343188308,
-0.0343901217,
-0.0077759647,
-0.0075244745,
-0.0144061623,
0.0353802666,
-0.0015159516,
0.021628242,
0.0713010207,
-0.0041978471,
0.0827839673,
0.0163520761,
0.0037201128,
0.0065551461,
0.0063904398,
0.0268021412,
0.0217020605,
-0.0035764319,
-0.0165757779,
-0.0606603995,
-0.0283667129,
0.0065950369,
-0.0201992989,
0.0496533848,
-0.0331688337,
0.0218393616,
0.0192967262,
-0.0246567987,
-0.0094981622,
-0.004589742,
0.0232042,
0.0185513813,
0.0102373818,
-0.0039458442,
-6.265215178e-33,
-0.0040001618,
0.0235862136,
0.0090870662,
-0.0255045742,
-0.0013456587,
-0.0031661238,
-0.0391733907,
0.013967854,
-0.0308508035,
-0.0195417367,
-0.0258552302,
-0.0043463586,
0.026460452,
0.0016166439,
0.0259482246,
-0.0172109809,
0.0541961566,
-0.0200224891,
-0.013958591,
0.0168929826,
0.0549978614,
0.0435626432,
0.0531982556,
0.0022497922,
-0.0020247055,
0.0182135478,
0.0234824717,
0.0000287873,
-0.0080358116,
0.0618849099,
-0.0651226044,
0.0378617756,
0.0413735509,
-0.0492752492,
-0.0514389537,
-0.0207155496,
-0.0630753934,
-0.0250602253,
0.0001439858,
-0.001895615,
0.0208959877,
-0.0389234982,
0.0590300336,
-0.0435568355,
-0.0570538752,
0.0237978473,
0.002731225,
-0.0379552022,
-0.0808417052,
-0.0090808729,
-0.0435720272,
-0.0121612344,
0.0333405584,
-0.0138551667,
0.0278643072,
-0.0196981598,
-0.0234858599,
0.0278148726,
-0.0570318475,
-0.0030810561,
0.0474043302,
0.0508083105,
0.0182831082,
0.0625413954,
0.0359033532,
0.1004974544,
0.0847691372,
0.018607866,
0.0471916273,
-0.0447913334,
0.0540505797,
-0.000292231,
0.0235103536,
0.0199032146,
0.0982614532,
-0.0094417464,
-0.0229545496,
-0.046407938,
0.0068142428,
0.060871996,
0.0624749474,
0.0296967458,
-0.0291676167,
-0.0172049571,
-0.0489623286,
-0.0001474328,
-0.0634577796,
-0.0206648055,
0.0355772786,
0.0077064363,
0.0123553071,
-0.0365215018,
0.065387547,
-0.0128643028,
-0.032014437,
-0.031198971,
-0.0065848473,
0.0097916992,
-0.0158866215,
0.0162461028,
-0.08140672,
-0.0318404399,
-0.0137590002,
0.0281475857,
0.0051838481,
0.0180984456,
0.0415594243,
0.0112963831,
-0.0739535391,
0.0082832891,
-0.0353308171,
-0.0195167996,
0.0583375208,
-0.0223122593,
0.0450713038,
0.0030470907,
0.0018066932,
0.040841423,
0.033077158,
-0.0719230697,
-0.0190483741,
0.0120353689,
-0.0377244726,
0.0464026108,
-0.0219392329,
-0.0045268028,
-0.0399141461,
0.0579987764,
0.0466165841,
-0.0201524012,
0.0086769285,
0.0263549183,
2.677e-7,
-0.0687033534,
0.031465672,
-0.0116056539,
-0.037526615,
0.0530741699,
0.0249645896,
-0.0458714068,
0.0273416825,
-0.0006403273,
0.0008866249,
-0.0368261151,
0.0425901338,
0.0290474817,
-0.0090934914,
-0.0421404839,
0.0005666803,
-0.0577066392,
0.0179187953,
-0.0440302901,
0.0190609284,
-0.0082311193,
0.0752754137,
0.0417343006,
-0.0155456569,
0.0052665058,
-0.0758049861,
0.080057539,
-0.0480966941,
0.0019445219,
-0.0115401801,
0.0009661973,
0.0662233755,
0.0290974341,
0.020097347,
-0.0018096104,
-0.0145314606,
-0.0250019561,
0.0232459158,
-0.0039277733,
0.0145002659,
-0.0103832288,
0.0251118876,
-0.0040025502,
-0.0412297584,
0.0605720095,
-0.1003383845,
-0.0225738045,
-0.0168578234,
0.0004177335,
-0.0310377926,
0.0151972817,
0.0196389332,
0.0024964111,
0.0135606704,
-0.0349106193,
0.0389396995,
-0.0292770639,
-0.0651336387,
-0.025634896,
0.0138472347,
-0.0322078578,
-0.0544317104,
-0.0403633602,
-0.0134197464,
0.0303478073,
-0.0766912773,
-0.0222203918,
2.076115419e-34,
0.0210320018,
-0.0068660094,
0.0023561406,
0.0836480111,
-0.0027016229,
-0.0181233007,
0.0076235132,
0.0305368286,
0.0289386455,
-0.0554268137,
0.019725645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17548v1 | Whose Opinions Do Language Models Reflect? | 2023-03-30T17:17:08 | 2023-03-30T17:17:08 | Shibani Santurkar, Esin Durmus, Faisal Ladhak, Cinoo Lee, Percy Liang, Tatsunori Hashimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are increasingly being used in open-ended contexts,
where the opinions reflected by LMs in response to subjective queries can have
a profound impact, both on user satisfaction, as well as shaping the views of
society at large. In this work, we put forth a quantitative framework to
investigate the opinions reflected by LMs -- by leveraging high-quality public
opinion polls and their associated human responses. Using this framework, we
create OpinionsQA, a new dataset for evaluating the alignment of LM opinions
with those of 60 US demographic groups over topics ranging from abortion to
automation. Across topics, we find substantial misalignment between the views
reflected by current LMs and those of US demographic groups: on par with the
Democrat-Republican divide on climate change. Notably, this misalignment
persists even after explicitly steering the LMs towards particular demographic
groups. Our analysis not only confirms prior observations about the
left-leaning tendencies of some human feedback-tuned LMs, but also surfaces
groups whose opinions are poorly reflected by current LMs (e.g., 65+ and
widowed individuals). Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/tatsu-lab/opinions_qa. | [
0.0300995372,
0.1146329567,
-0.0083767315,
0.0241322797,
-0.0331874527,
0.0056997589,
-0.0008792487,
-0.0226192214,
0.0185424425,
-0.0721729472,
-0.0536324903,
-0.0470333435,
-0.0023681687,
0.0050687552,
-0.0068159662,
-0.0366535708,
0.0121222734,
0.0420235842,
0.045724988,
-0.0226568542,
0.0408192463,
0.044108104,
-0.0091686919,
0.0406727567,
0.0264599826,
-0.0171272606,
0.0220145322,
0.0024509712,
0.0342855006,
0.0135040721,
0.0417046286,
0.0552490875,
-0.0422794409,
0.0227196924,
0.0000019551,
-0.024475744,
0.0044173459,
-0.0231891703,
0.0400287285,
0.011304657,
0.102998659,
0.0383181311,
-0.0278446861,
0.0375452377,
-0.0537366532,
0.0170106702,
0.0352172516,
0.0178945009,
0.05113874,
0.0183069129,
0.0042389445,
-0.0073463558,
-0.0565185696,
-0.002096697,
-0.0084091788,
0.0171534233,
0.0196079779,
-0.0375239775,
-0.0386956669,
-0.0030458546,
-0.0082515553,
0.0222640224,
-0.0196889583,
-0.0139480513,
-0.039309632,
0.0023883944,
-0.0514958389,
-0.0357065946,
0.045232866,
0.0709224418,
0.0521434173,
-0.0240783691,
-0.0084483027,
-0.010287608,
0.0006949207,
0.029979011,
-0.0379443206,
0.016551666,
0.0008938575,
0.0231093317,
-0.0219099727,
-0.008642613,
0.0205552597,
0.0256811567,
-0.0061033131,
0.1166699454,
-0.0008225645,
-0.0120839346,
-0.0160472691,
0.0112812826,
-0.006335035,
-0.0019612608,
0.0416170917,
-0.0310088173,
-0.0107447403,
0.024730878,
-0.0045667849,
0.0146161234,
0.0438996255,
-0.0680076107,
0.0035706919,
0.0165952053,
-0.0005141609,
0.0454737656,
0.0597785488,
0.0034371391,
-0.0037299288,
0.0230690334,
-0.0314637572,
-0.0187378302,
-0.023938328,
-0.0079972716,
0.0478958227,
-0.0289347246,
0.0167863797,
0.0277981162,
-0.0380357914,
-0.001643101,
-0.0540664308,
-0.0034457007,
-0.0037692897,
0.0136801125,
0.0180561915,
-0.021733515,
-0.0763773993,
0.0761240944,
-0.0273898728,
0.0459503382,
-0.0133230463,
-0.048872944,
0.040131107,
0.0270425957,
-0.032708928,
-0.006340256,
0.0001137523,
0.0212040171,
0.0341033712,
0.0399931297,
-0.0201252922,
-0.0133619588,
-0.0195805412,
-0.022779746,
-0.0246481169,
-0.0666550696,
0.0388931222,
0.0308066737,
0.0028055911,
-0.0317349508,
0.0012959588,
0.0542137548,
-0.0415213853,
0.065898627,
-0.0270006228,
0.0326019339,
0.0422078669,
0.0173975881,
0.0401635431,
0.0891304314,
0.0049480824,
0.0036423597,
0.0494166501,
-0.0100844251,
0.0086401338,
0.026073372,
-0.0339382887,
0.0179049168,
-0.0291159172,
0.0328400061,
-0.055728212,
-0.0034302725,
0.0380378515,
0.0721791163,
0.0342893042,
-0.0439481139,
0.083035849,
0.0742844418,
-0.0361141153,
0.0288351513,
-0.0183858387,
0.0231820606,
-0.0157782715,
-0.0150027014,
-0.0300057977,
0.0118795,
-0.018701097,
-0.0254428461,
0.0169792492,
0.0368612558,
-0.019738663,
-0.0464551635,
-0.0412784107,
-0.0042252564,
0.0489429943,
0.0038951759,
0.0231959578,
-0.0375664048,
0.0090643978,
0.030762624,
0.0157114007,
-0.0658622906,
-0.0213379506,
-0.0197841804,
0.0233480595,
0.065062955,
-0.0101274224,
-0.0141445883,
-0.0341204479,
-0.0097598918,
0.0227419659,
0.0433336869,
0.0924706534,
-0.0009742301,
-0.0694814846,
-0.026599586,
-0.0184894707,
0.0298157372,
0.0182932895,
0.0073489691,
0.0270216092,
0.0232137833,
0.008901502,
-0.0599764548,
-0.0232970528,
0.0004005575,
-0.0050292024,
0.0119255921,
-0.0277226958,
0.0239109583,
0.0501331761,
0.0303441826,
-0.0091818543,
0.033967156,
0.0090567404,
0.0015678285,
-0.0322177894,
0.0165128578,
-0.0106720747,
0.043637611,
0.0417107269,
-0.0425917767,
-0.0254668724,
0.0316545144,
-0.009231599,
-0.0044902493,
0.0400520898,
-0.0137370946,
0.0067934892,
-0.0147856055,
-0.0009394844,
-0.0425897762,
-0.0386033282,
-0.06176107,
0.0297104288,
-0.0262698345,
0.0195777211,
-0.0069977748,
-0.0590279475,
0.0186740831,
-0.0010890759,
-0.0594581962,
0.011545388,
0.0354144275,
0.0352755152,
0.0492154583,
-0.0257122219,
-0.0582405068,
-0.0035279281,
-0.0771517605,
-0.0226802137,
-0.0074364454,
0.0347824357,
0.0362990536,
-0.0325096622,
-0.0104052583,
0.015240456,
-0.0571476035,
-0.0152509771,
-0.0198835917,
0.0420466885,
0.0507264882,
-0.0305468999,
0.0174665805,
-0.0591251254,
-0.0322788991,
-0.0398086086,
0.0171406735,
0.0003009466,
0.0170930643,
0.0034302275,
-0.0132974451,
-0.0780048892,
-0.0118536279,
-0.0287060216,
-0.0403755456,
0.0208521038,
0.0092321103,
0.0165723506,
0.0352375545,
0.0362824835,
0.0068233521,
0.0473330617,
0.0406423286,
-0.059216395,
-0.0412812345,
-0.0389604196,
-0.0009490786,
-0.0019356506,
-0.0476878993,
0.028478872,
0.0540438369,
0.0177650526,
-0.0036194746,
-0.0472358055,
0.0547837205,
-0.0507173426,
0.0006203164,
-0.0464644097,
0.0095940642,
-0.0116650928,
0.0528528914,
-0.0067793657,
-0.0332074314,
0.0513708219,
0.0155295245,
0.0349702425,
-0.0298626311,
-0.0167149454,
-0.0581126735,
0.0137238288,
-0.0018650361,
0.0321545079,
0.0041660671,
0.0076957657,
-0.0689068362,
-0.0176974796,
0.0134061957,
-0.0765580013,
0.063231498,
-0.0341704302,
-0.0061578946,
0.0196541324,
-0.0449596941,
0.0015976941,
-0.0472766086,
-0.0536081642,
-0.0203813259,
0.0572046004,
-0.0380716734,
0.0140266186,
0.0007706473,
0.0150368856,
-0.0491122417,
0.0179034788,
-0.0013893342,
0.0134599907,
0.0098825991,
0.0455671139,
0.0177625194,
0.0463110693,
-0.0105069699,
-0.0228317138,
0.0460411198,
0.0360664316,
0.0211159494,
-0.0139713511,
-0.0407495461,
0.0373874046,
-0.0284012053,
-0.0333675481,
-0.0245941523,
0.0403457321,
-0.0128680151,
0.0497308746,
0.0900455415,
0.0281068627,
-0.0522415675,
-0.0165541731,
-0.0370517857,
0.0252491999,
0.0450913161,
0.0121503491,
-0.0697805136,
0.0142237069,
-0.0033507028,
0.0416960418,
-0.0133444667,
-0.0023568729,
-0.0020674327,
-0.1386528015,
-0.0158228036,
0.0014466502,
0.0131083662,
0.0059592924,
-0.0354709737,
0.0421157777,
-0.0333496518,
0.0271095708,
0.0002523342,
0.0130038047,
0.0300678704,
0.0002065493,
-0.0708209872,
-0.0417182334,
0.0538183339,
-0.0351906717,
0.0584539026,
0.0438980907,
0.0666393116,
-0.0060350173,
-0.0477323346,
0.0678854212,
-0.0011047848,
-0.0410620049,
-0.0026873683,
0.0290340483,
-0.0325333104,
-0.0021122175,
-0.0643455461,
0.013802263,
-0.0343217142,
0.0049304161,
-0.0055198348,
0.0325586572,
-0.0085207075,
-0.037351165,
-0.0435417965,
0.0424121507,
0.0001551047,
0.0830303356,
0.0255959984,
-0.0689959526,
-0.004573151,
-0.0646496117,
-0.0056286124,
0.0220972784,
-0.0776097775,
-0.0098950928,
0.0069993883,
-0.042424649,
-0.0343754329,
-0.0440257192,
0.0033517512,
-0.0179984178,
0.0277937669,
-0.0084434329,
0.0770641565,
-0.0323546268,
-0.0313765593,
0.0317704007,
-0.0293443184,
0.0169954989,
-0.0242925379,
-0.0454914272,
0.0289577842,
0.0174399354,
-0.021528393,
-0.0280152727,
-0.0145978257,
-0.0432501286,
0.0203898922,
0.0265748296,
0.0187245663,
-0.0108480537,
-0.0017580045,
-0.0359686837,
0.008597781,
0.0776671916,
-0.0011726936,
-0.0100938361,
-0.0179388728,
0.0755171776,
0.0180446897,
0.040315859,
-0.0098419553,
-0.001351985,
0.0038040194,
-0.0089302259,
-0.0796046555,
-0.0361845009,
0.0277906545,
0.0099085486,
0.0396969281,
0.0256469343,
0.0094198799,
-0.0126050459,
-0.0419583991,
-0.0357017443,
-0.0487644784,
0.0011519433,
-0.0442352071,
0.0181432143,
-0.0354097076,
-0.0293535255,
0.011490046,
-0.0282891542,
0.0524290986,
-0.0446793772,
0.0479736738,
-0.0014620353,
0.0099239694,
0.0064148004,
-0.0089190239,
0.0089595364,
0.0268416423,
-0.0257426985,
0.0274963863,
0.0204570889,
0.033771757,
-0.0025040184,
0.0017375832,
0.0069781658,
0.0121213328,
-0.0186031573,
-0.0784568861,
-0.0038228275,
0.0119752372,
-0.0237682071,
-0.0239652526,
0.0389428586,
0.0154906465,
-0.0192664005,
-0.0242372677,
0.0164491367,
0.0262851641,
0.0018942576,
0.0444805212,
0.0067635742,
-0.0415474102,
-0.0266462043,
0.0570565797,
-0.0199236777,
0.0019926783,
0.0139469933,
-0.0532241687,
-0.0220004339,
-0.0036497563,
0.0091891671,
-0.0123503311,
-0.0320842415,
-0.0321815275,
-0.0802222341,
-0.030871246,
-0.0054062442,
0.0150160575,
0.0187483989,
0.0042004636,
0.0094611002,
0.0845586285,
-0.0211297274,
0.0107713295,
-0.059566617,
0.0158009306,
-0.0855389982,
-0.0037477822,
-0.0247863866,
-6.488780244e-33,
-0.0177593995,
-0.0225314684,
-0.0112896832,
-0.0088143107,
-0.0044565178,
-0.0272801444,
-0.0118558053,
0.080189772,
-0.0358099341,
0.0177515596,
0.0040653865,
0.0403818227,
0.0102582863,
0.0192469899,
0.0348509364,
-0.0311839245,
0.0281016044,
-0.021686513,
-0.0210452918,
-0.0066669541,
0.0310670491,
-0.0192637462,
0.0244197529,
-0.1087643281,
0.058230821,
0.0003869285,
-0.0134232752,
-0.0032113623,
0.0003181625,
0.0505097993,
-0.0111214248,
0.079895027,
0.019259572,
-0.0316436999,
0.0006951949,
0.0833734274,
-0.016507484,
-0.018755367,
0.0314306729,
0.0235165618,
0.0077003529,
-0.021727249,
0.0335382707,
0.0208151415,
-0.0677787438,
0.012169457,
0.0493839085,
-0.0181764085,
0.0519014597,
-0.0224278998,
0.0080670957,
0.003608065,
-0.0272214506,
0.0106630959,
-0.0205540452,
0.0405170061,
-0.0184383467,
0.0685700178,
-0.0722494051,
0.064080596,
-0.0063826214,
0.0356995054,
0.0763939396,
-0.0276149996,
0.0186524596,
0.0821252391,
0.0000440752,
0.0424122959,
-0.0787867904,
-0.0154421655,
0.0269162301,
0.0003910426,
0.0132060731,
0.0427964963,
0.0155658135,
-0.0487077422,
-0.0087975692,
0.0006073185,
0.0360340476,
0.0156159298,
0.0674613714,
0.0074582938,
-0.053940665,
-0.0234968029,
-0.0292225778,
-0.0642013773,
-0.0546030328,
-0.0233009849,
0.0021787679,
-0.0220022257,
-0.0371656641,
-0.0673300847,
-0.0053553311,
-0.0506473146,
-0.0560862795,
0.0146825453,
-0.0614626743,
-0.0217569526,
0.0192487333,
0.024197625,
-0.0545437559,
0.0274328049,
-0.0514719933,
0.0300725866,
-0.0050306171,
0.0114054009,
-0.0019010983,
-0.0112297256,
-0.0960155055,
-0.021265503,
-0.018691808,
-0.0194747038,
-0.0055779833,
0.0121877622,
0.0283865351,
0.0194090828,
0.0203985274,
0.0212971848,
0.0327527858,
0.0307215676,
-0.0139867375,
-0.0187224802,
-0.0480478331,
0.0098134317,
-0.0230553243,
-0.0428520888,
-0.018890921,
0.0139760012,
0.0153662544,
-0.0231217928,
-0.030808486,
-0.0230682269,
2.529e-7,
0.0990779325,
0.0860161707,
-0.0297899898,
0.0314437822,
0.025810726,
0.0435272269,
0.0114288824,
0.024013415,
0.033660125,
-0.034404207,
-0.0285546947,
-0.0008527549,
0.0161531232,
0.0290160384,
-0.07792373,
0.0126740793,
-0.0557998717,
0.0311311372,
-0.0345644876,
0.0510762222,
0.0354210362,
0.0743183792,
0.0153906178,
0.0111711016,
-0.0508227646,
0.002810563,
0.0550111644,
-0.0829095617,
-0.0299201515,
0.0345886275,
0.0355309285,
-0.0150203118,
0.0393165648,
0.0125488387,
-0.0052993358,
-0.026226094,
0.0088987537,
0.0597473495,
0.0059747063,
-0.0711890236,
-0.0106381094,
0.0073410226,
0.0133692343,
-0.0492127724,
0.0687962621,
-0.0276548956,
-0.0338390395,
-0.0734870136,
-0.0340033658,
-0.0191421919,
0.0665040314,
-0.0331352763,
-0.0445075445,
-0.0268609319,
0.0187072754,
0.0006376562,
-0.0334117971,
-0.0338908397,
-0.034619119,
-0.0146036521,
-0.0414853916,
-0.0736378282,
-0.0012342709,
0.051022362,
-0.0028870448,
-0.0005936834,
0.0187625512,
2.01854145e-34,
0.053074684,
0.0211995058,
0.0080175307,
-0.016385207,
0.040836595,
0.0213178638,
0.0182245821,
-0.0040345872,
0.0244966913,
-0.0355976634,
0.0135490568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17517v1 | Hindi as a Second Language: Improving Visually Grounded Speech with Semantically Similar Samples | 2023-03-30T16:34:10 | 2023-03-30T16:34:10 | Hyeonggon Ryu, Arda Senocak, In So Kweon, Joon Son Chung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS | The objective of this work is to explore the learning of visually grounded
speech models (VGS) from multilingual perspective. Bilingual VGS models are
generally trained with an equal number of spoken captions from both languages.
However, in reality, there can be an imbalance among the languages for the
available spoken captions. Our key contribution in this work is to leverage the
power of a high-resource language in a bilingual visually grounded speech model
to improve the performance of a low-resource language. We introduce two methods
to distill the knowledge of high-resource language into low-resource languages:
(1) incorporating a strong pre-trained high-resource language encoder and (2)
using semantically similar spoken captions. Our experiments show that combining
these two approaches effectively enables the low-resource language to surpass
the performances of monolingual and bilingual counterparts for cross-modal
retrieval tasks. | [
-0.0042798403,
0.0366999879,
-0.0068982649,
0.0338198021,
-0.001624995,
-0.0112406127,
-0.0225847028,
-0.017348472,
-0.0365160406,
-0.0330481641,
-0.0995088667,
-0.0263400525,
0.0378608592,
0.0446991585,
-0.0094935754,
-0.0885863602,
-0.0013009695,
-0.041858308,
-0.0077393781,
-0.0247210879,
0.0335115343,
0.0240887925,
-0.0199363679,
0.0318685062,
-0.027664477,
0.012428836,
0.0167277306,
0.0095605571,
-0.0129977809,
-0.0173558146,
-0.030654436,
0.0388155766,
0.0718285069,
-0.0067114583,
0.0000018145,
-0.0246418547,
-0.0088306107,
0.0057850061,
0.034752097,
0.0113270134,
0.0333273858,
-0.0319557562,
0.0091131395,
0.0227501299,
0.0063598645,
-0.0090435017,
0.0701158047,
0.0557042733,
0.0446314588,
0.0253530033,
-0.0248064045,
-0.0270255152,
0.0164527744,
-0.0222974196,
-0.0237429347,
0.0192640163,
-0.020911945,
0.0882359743,
-0.0143284053,
-0.0182813946,
-0.0425912552,
0.056905061,
-0.0092850747,
-0.0074417377,
-0.0257029403,
0.0250541866,
-0.0475988798,
-0.0237512384,
0.0196386725,
0.0838253424,
-0.022018712,
-0.007612606,
-0.0201936662,
0.0175352171,
-0.0359955654,
0.012934492,
-0.0609591678,
0.031212071,
0.0064123264,
0.0633712336,
0.000899534,
0.0427593328,
-0.0242563467,
-0.0328517333,
0.0391497798,
-0.0447891392,
0.0310877487,
0.0136913024,
-0.0213719439,
0.0179290622,
-0.0035718225,
-0.0006268622,
0.0224387292,
-0.0291486755,
0.0310362969,
0.0117684714,
-0.0217986852,
-0.012873278,
-0.0261639431,
-0.0401123278,
-0.0090794004,
0.0252220538,
-0.1041743457,
0.0358886383,
-0.0195501465,
0.0592074059,
-0.0258239899,
0.0358115137,
-0.0286875609,
-0.0489368252,
0.0124925254,
-0.0368763581,
-0.0502734333,
0.0016272342,
-0.0995056629,
-0.0189843588,
-0.0593040176,
-0.0238251071,
-0.0295899101,
-0.040668536,
0.0211287644,
0.0008850912,
-0.0394300185,
-0.0232545845,
-0.0049531502,
0.0738722309,
-0.0167423747,
0.0374910533,
-0.0157011487,
-0.1124006286,
0.007414714,
0.0481851213,
0.0151285203,
-0.0112760598,
-0.0086387033,
0.0554101728,
-0.0291339867,
-0.0136951338,
-0.0515299253,
0.0036213878,
-0.024136208,
-0.0364958122,
-0.0096570496,
-0.0584787242,
0.0081489887,
0.0169231072,
0.0112307845,
-0.0510805845,
0.0094220368,
-0.0023413601,
0.0222110804,
0.102156885,
0.0243470762,
-0.0083690248,
0.0308039449,
0.0108050453,
0.0353934281,
0.0825446248,
-0.0001606577,
-0.0007982244,
0.0392094776,
-0.0229855068,
0.0044594724,
0.0347452313,
0.0172913428,
0.0305464603,
-0.0569467694,
-0.027969515,
0.0266787596,
0.001659463,
0.0558401421,
0.0363316536,
-0.0186840873,
0.0546840467,
0.0506276302,
0.0594942942,
-0.0027644236,
0.0338219218,
0.0259342156,
0.0197338294,
-0.0313527025,
0.0374311134,
-0.0117623145,
0.0441336483,
-0.0229713842,
0.009993799,
0.0356336534,
0.0190471709,
-0.0516413935,
-0.0118170595,
0.0059605748,
-0.0273160301,
0.0269104205,
-0.0222260002,
0.0426445082,
0.009306306,
-0.0613854527,
0.0664368644,
0.050406009,
-0.0826586187,
0.0342600979,
-0.0090345573,
-0.0246344209,
0.0056478144,
-0.012851933,
0.0203634445,
0.0318776481,
-0.0000133413,
0.021018317,
0.0571710505,
0.00237031,
-0.0044759479,
0.0209667571,
-0.0604306906,
-0.0120598702,
-0.0096023809,
-0.0189620964,
0.0731753558,
-0.0445008613,
0.0540103428,
0.0279727783,
-0.04668184,
0.0029077793,
-0.0147425113,
0.0140120555,
0.0126964813,
-0.0230526943,
0.0327942967,
0.016291324,
0.0101956008,
-0.0314812921,
-0.0000080087,
0.011814408,
-0.0430607423,
0.0063665104,
0.0808194727,
-0.069928959,
-0.0258049909,
0.013960667,
-0.0656896159,
0.0604404099,
0.0080926884,
0.0297911931,
-0.0632938072,
0.0504366979,
-0.0009449822,
0.0399671979,
-0.0684065446,
0.0250873975,
-0.0115683433,
0.0187130421,
-0.0105096651,
0.029121099,
0.021519294,
-0.0097375019,
0.0169100482,
-0.0184356738,
0.0609070808,
-0.0833019167,
-0.0041380581,
0.0546174534,
0.0070211957,
0.0322334096,
0.0265339073,
0.0111776311,
-0.0241344143,
0.0027415594,
-0.0983305424,
-0.051421158,
-0.0257785562,
-0.0374329351,
-0.0250727553,
0.0155217666,
-0.0112165613,
-0.0307760928,
-0.0295950975,
-0.0252847262,
0.0592318512,
0.0297864974,
-0.0078469813,
-0.0069452673,
-0.0200360566,
-0.0109592862,
-0.0040150783,
0.0521900393,
0.0535536148,
0.0029912146,
-0.0557296425,
-0.0396252237,
0.0025213333,
0.0057163998,
0.0175517108,
-0.0109276464,
-0.0490569361,
-0.0233399905,
0.0188138224,
0.0275172014,
0.0261216946,
-0.0133223496,
0.0090439077,
0.0220933743,
-0.0348122343,
-0.0298079606,
-0.0233304668,
0.0501566008,
-0.026092682,
0.0058435267,
0.0309684388,
-0.0078035607,
0.01913408,
-0.0023010869,
0.0345164947,
-0.0714819655,
-0.0349079967,
-0.0106265089,
-0.0159516614,
-0.0463170558,
0.0064206282,
-0.0367194079,
0.0534909107,
-0.0286723692,
-0.072465457,
0.0344177932,
-0.0926563889,
-0.0262794178,
-0.0202115159,
0.0098945275,
-0.0301178861,
0.0323976763,
-0.0334827192,
0.0172736328,
-0.0319249891,
-0.0518866852,
-0.0232100654,
0.0024222373,
0.0246299133,
-0.0352362953,
0.0800942332,
-0.0429451577,
0.027109623,
-0.0446026176,
-0.0453257039,
-0.0500036255,
-0.0063228528,
-0.0516368821,
-0.0057734284,
-0.0458030775,
0.0164942853,
0.0034514291,
0.0628589839,
0.0286543798,
0.0227757432,
-0.0001538901,
0.0462247841,
0.0086089978,
0.02970176,
0.0387250073,
0.0276953392,
-0.0570161343,
-0.0171214249,
0.0378748998,
-0.0414306335,
0.0320248976,
-0.0115487492,
-0.0066109202,
0.0322716087,
0.0358103961,
0.0597776286,
-0.0528017916,
0.0050126938,
0.0683762655,
0.0237077568,
0.0070581357,
0.0717635155,
-0.0064835162,
-0.0246420242,
-0.0374593139,
-0.0559462942,
0.02297052,
0.0271062236,
0.0220905486,
-0.0353785157,
-0.0439262465,
0.005925803,
-0.023164859,
0.0589232408,
0.0366365463,
-0.0248112082,
-0.1296277493,
0.0150129395,
0.024173392,
-0.0378009751,
-0.0885548517,
-0.0337315463,
-0.0319220312,
-0.0061346255,
0.0208864175,
-0.0032719001,
-0.0182905812,
-0.024231296,
0.0490607843,
0.0591746867,
-0.0411984026,
-0.0069825747,
-0.0543952696,
-0.0011543459,
0.0261573568,
-0.0004632293,
-0.0247163009,
-0.0575865321,
0.0015421525,
-0.0467764027,
0.0017298349,
0.010174538,
0.0198162775,
-0.0098191611,
-0.0366629176,
0.0367037468,
0.0545646697,
-0.0268344153,
-0.0082974518,
-0.0211075693,
0.0347856544,
0.0006477552,
0.0526711121,
0.0179563705,
0.0208172277,
0.0014551264,
0.0410237461,
0.0612794831,
-0.0352028348,
0.0285407584,
-0.0252788384,
0.0315312073,
-0.0240203179,
-0.0677265525,
0.0256628115,
-0.0102484152,
-0.0101312893,
-0.0486543812,
0.0076523265,
-0.0077058519,
0.0506502539,
0.0276963804,
0.0454333872,
-0.0082259094,
0.027689239,
-0.0215796195,
0.0479076989,
-0.0596533678,
0.0300396662,
-0.0622728579,
-0.004572683,
0.0484749749,
-0.0661286265,
-0.0268365331,
-0.0486141853,
0.0112509159,
-0.0339780152,
-0.0290377233,
0.0172289144,
0.0155554749,
0.0542048551,
0.0097425329,
-0.0155176595,
0.0386305265,
-0.0053765411,
-0.0020428265,
0.0150187723,
0.0492100306,
-0.0140254609,
-0.0205924585,
0.0322693922,
-0.0671566427,
0.0254333001,
-0.0049049086,
0.0176300574,
0.039445769,
-0.0293852724,
0.0262765307,
0.0277854875,
0.0754998699,
-0.0465189032,
0.0355071537,
-0.0529089756,
0.0168194454,
-0.0019234397,
0.0074275476,
-0.0407332815,
-0.0162464604,
0.0108639374,
0.034144599,
0.0134100178,
-0.0082339663,
-0.0095660035,
0.044024229,
0.0121707022,
0.0439670868,
0.014022639,
0.0321524069,
-0.0186955761,
0.0337906592,
0.0006188022,
0.0084426301,
0.0006597528,
0.0478085093,
-0.0384718552,
0.0446780063,
-0.0189389624,
-0.007673047,
0.0074265255,
0.0535685048,
0.058900971,
0.0001335936,
-0.0128789339,
0.0300022494,
0.0742956772,
-0.0411337391,
0.0389442481,
0.0119105065,
0.0204444695,
-0.0276710782,
0.0197535995,
-0.0123144146,
-0.0245920066,
0.0634674951,
-0.005414634,
-0.0117679071,
0.0183193535,
0.048052486,
-0.020077154,
-0.0114225848,
-0.0312697068,
0.0148505578,
0.0001909839,
-0.0281174183,
-0.0252052192,
-0.0359465256,
-0.0045769033,
0.0357657485,
-0.0262090173,
-0.074572064,
0.0011567113,
-0.0280800387,
-0.0071085664,
0.0018688081,
0.063704893,
0.0285354257,
-0.005106526,
0.0386323594,
0.0064853001,
-0.0332607925,
-0.0239038523,
0.0177331623,
0.0442406982,
-5.420322001e-33,
-0.0371136591,
0.0355722979,
-0.0075548789,
-0.0187247917,
-0.0052732737,
0.0375666879,
-0.0340150967,
0.0269149058,
-0.0100850277,
-0.0072151138,
0.0108337784,
-0.0136017231,
0.0234310534,
0.0377799608,
-0.0286342632,
-0.0072006304,
0.0521850772,
0.0283809602,
0.0000218678,
0.0053070509,
0.0394672677,
-0.0049540289,
0.0590006933,
-0.0683178902,
-0.0575494207,
-0.0001380376,
0.0047659054,
0.0153227681,
0.0580833927,
0.0824880973,
-0.0191333052,
0.0703715533,
-0.0083833067,
-0.0272304118,
-0.0075971005,
0.0304869413,
-0.0643786639,
-0.0045664306,
0.0279087014,
0.0741870403,
-0.0244130883,
-0.0042251837,
0.0052705556,
-0.0253209323,
-0.0416683517,
0.0293089412,
0.0185904559,
-0.0270548128,
-0.0106483614,
0.0342582949,
-0.0483360402,
0.0256061777,
0.0075679752,
-0.0023508382,
0.0313646048,
0.0434204787,
0.0261020903,
0.0030682411,
-0.014952559,
0.0358180329,
-0.0283866096,
0.0352993384,
0.0883658007,
0.0460588336,
0.0025137365,
0.0648271739,
-0.006847301,
-0.0740800723,
0.0052795028,
-0.0061705713,
0.0369631499,
0.0140207158,
0.0244042911,
0.0471428409,
0.0061662216,
-0.048542399,
-0.0462479629,
0.0167887285,
-0.051912535,
0.0436017103,
0.0115529699,
0.0465192981,
-0.0143252807,
-0.0195727032,
-0.0544590764,
-0.0489270538,
-0.0242671557,
-0.050329946,
0.0621314533,
0.0205349345,
-0.0202147141,
0.0116563104,
0.0959024876,
-0.0171661973,
0.0083876681,
0.0382502116,
-0.0452326648,
0.0084388768,
-0.0155131528,
0.0305191893,
-0.0261875968,
-0.0403757505,
0.0321321636,
0.0016425916,
0.0064148363,
-0.021410998,
0.0038706034,
-0.0025220125,
-0.0627554134,
0.0102315852,
-0.0110449409,
0.0011476125,
-0.0208256673,
0.0428770147,
0.0130200256,
0.0333130546,
-0.0349880718,
0.0626807958,
-0.0079078665,
-0.0199381188,
-0.0113297496,
-0.0802265704,
0.0117262127,
0.0521600507,
-0.0446198732,
0.0253427699,
-0.0459524803,
-0.0655519813,
0.026467884,
-0.0424432382,
-0.0220967401,
0.010730952,
2.547e-7,
-0.0217732862,
-0.0135402409,
0.0587662756,
-0.0547452979,
-0.0035426666,
0.0268993918,
-0.0559822731,
-0.0030088495,
0.0091139413,
-0.0595378876,
-0.0335866958,
0.0082205664,
0.0563244261,
-0.0023084881,
-0.0865838677,
0.0152828665,
-0.044118952,
-0.0130738514,
-0.0220905654,
-0.0083845761,
-0.014743343,
0.0873079225,
-0.0407504551,
-0.0158760212,
-0.0042936108,
-0.0579278246,
0.0857900977,
-0.0172488596,
-0.0126422606,
-0.0296908151,
-0.0387993567,
0.0379339904,
-0.0349384248,
-0.0155921569,
-0.0228944812,
0.0484256819,
0.0810301825,
0.0087187178,
-0.0137696415,
-0.030006608,
-0.009439243,
0.0770568699,
-0.0535214581,
0.010097499,
0.0553758778,
0.0082762828,
-0.0301315989,
-0.0049262922,
-0.0171497278,
-0.001637763,
0.049453117,
-0.0057166372,
-0.0712204129,
0.0054880944,
0.0387089662,
-0.0284119472,
-0.0263524093,
-0.0352414921,
-0.0083334092,
0.0018426511,
-0.0255415123,
-0.0122159077,
-0.0154384878,
-0.0288424343,
0.033567667,
0.0320094116,
0.0076427194,
1.875485051e-34,
0.0465938561,
-0.0198732186,
0.0376859456,
-0.0241079256,
0.006965775,
-0.020177817,
-0.0162715446,
-0.0143572083,
0.0184704121,
-0.0438757241,
-0.0173763894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17491v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17491v3 | Language Models can Solve Computer Tasks | 2023-03-30T16:01:52 | 2023-11-16T20:15:14 | Geunwoo Kim, Pierre Baldi, Stephen McAleer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Agents capable of carrying out general tasks on a computer can improve
efficiency and productivity by automating repetitive tasks and assisting in
complex problem-solving. Ideally, such agents should be able to solve new
computer tasks presented to them through natural language commands. However,
previous approaches to this problem require large amounts of expert
demonstrations and task-specific reward functions, both of which are
impractical for new tasks. In this work, we show that a pre-trained large
language model (LLM) agent can execute computer tasks guided by natural
language using a simple prompting scheme where the agent Recursively Criticizes
and Improves its output (RCI). The RCI approach significantly outperforms
existing LLM methods for automating computer tasks and surpasses supervised
learning (SL) and reinforcement learning (RL) approaches on the MiniWoB++
benchmark. We compare multiple LLMs and find that RCI with the
InstructGPT-3+RLHF LLM is state-of-the-art on MiniWoB++, using only a handful
of demonstrations per task rather than tens of thousands, and without a
task-specific reward function. Furthermore, we demonstrate RCI prompting's
effectiveness in enhancing LLMs' reasoning abilities on a suite of natural
language reasoning tasks, outperforming chain of thought (CoT) prompting with
external feedback. We find that RCI combined with CoT performs better than
either separately. Our code can be found here:
https://github.com/posgnu/rci-agent. | [
0.0566059798,
0.0343707986,
-0.0006854766,
0.0079468619,
-0.0396088175,
0.012128572,
0.02668285,
0.0030396308,
0.0274441969,
-0.0424676463,
-0.0190074649,
-0.0058007045,
-0.0177707523,
0.0288144052,
0.0233121291,
-0.0663949326,
0.0396070853,
-0.0649349615,
0.0315584354,
-0.0025478848,
-0.0041217054,
-0.0018957681,
-0.0323567353,
0.0502084084,
-0.0228685718,
-0.0058390587,
-0.0396509878,
-0.0280347746,
-0.0043589701,
-0.0183327682,
0.0070463629,
0.0497240312,
0.0660728738,
0.001388806,
0.0000022398,
-0.0735959187,
0.0060202121,
-0.0152369309,
-0.0520291999,
-0.0283586346,
0.0294283908,
0.0244220886,
-0.0004164437,
0.0308460779,
-0.0384150594,
0.0030545741,
0.0136471987,
0.0840720981,
0.0691159815,
0.0872166008,
0.021042807,
0.0165857654,
0.0099045141,
-0.0120886527,
0.0457980931,
-0.0363808684,
0.0145010939,
0.0354401134,
0.0536332577,
0.0036499354,
0.0024883109,
0.0009749059,
0.0372497663,
-0.0218411908,
-0.0315871872,
0.0454486907,
-0.0217479989,
-0.0209793169,
-0.0359417759,
0.0723357201,
-0.0136185745,
0.0077706268,
0.0287926905,
0.0246733483,
0.0112979999,
0.0139175868,
-0.0133093027,
0.0517049693,
-0.0080303531,
-0.0108335763,
0.0277164057,
0.007362979,
0.0109305708,
0.0225503016,
-0.0018984334,
0.0676641613,
-0.0257025864,
-0.0481165908,
0.0358355083,
0.0026888028,
0.0163597092,
-0.0830627605,
-0.002068863,
0.0720406473,
-0.0737838745,
0.0230760723,
-0.0207987167,
-0.0138518615,
-0.0065156198,
0.0126397582,
0.0433813334,
0.0299791992,
0.0014130211,
0.0658679903,
-0.0393372662,
0.0650878027,
-0.0085754236,
0.0163355917,
-0.0165226143,
0.0203151256,
-0.0750910342,
-0.0182973109,
-0.0457842983,
0.0598646402,
-0.0215890519,
-0.0403097682,
-0.0026431088,
0.0364897251,
-0.012945191,
0.0348107964,
0.0135811204,
0.0185538214,
-0.0212908387,
-0.0239528548,
-0.0619001538,
0.0067114378,
-0.046884086,
0.0193772726,
0.0137529243,
-0.0135151884,
-0.005900498,
0.004106659,
0.0061217449,
0.0087775355,
0.0365580395,
0.0819451362,
-0.0010461606,
-0.0323459581,
-0.0307754092,
-0.0143949166,
0.0186477695,
-0.0681182519,
-0.0031576618,
-0.0807649717,
0.0180313047,
-0.0139516601,
-0.0339114815,
-0.0011540607,
0.0334070548,
0.0071811648,
-0.0109387962,
0.0841486007,
-0.0104585188,
0.0167801864,
0.0231117681,
0.0012833367,
-0.0228671934,
0.0245258547,
0.0314813145,
0.0324321873,
-0.0032440836,
0.0331388861,
0.0498105176,
0.0268781986,
-0.0262997933,
-0.012800673,
0.0109225698,
0.0000157819,
-0.0065519502,
0.0495414436,
0.0143842921,
0.0568830222,
-0.0185197331,
0.0557693504,
0.0476572923,
0.0659044757,
-0.0313882679,
-0.0048703915,
0.0387135446,
0.0587932207,
0.0000368769,
-0.046325095,
-0.0768524259,
0.0489756949,
-0.0381320491,
0.0100016044,
0.0053432491,
-0.0146098034,
-0.0313580558,
-0.0614670403,
0.0159257483,
-0.01989053,
0.0449540205,
0.0273357499,
0.0776924714,
0.0137441438,
-0.0587557219,
-0.0265855622,
0.0290746521,
-0.0255309325,
-0.0137248319,
-0.0892446861,
0.0683003888,
0.0841769055,
0.0383529738,
-0.0475742444,
-0.001333298,
-0.0272921138,
0.022878902,
0.0425502621,
0.0273106713,
-0.0130088618,
-0.039309524,
-0.0264775772,
-0.0279644988,
-0.023667844,
-0.0012205649,
0.0331155956,
0.0352873467,
0.0075207101,
-0.0063921371,
0.0065170964,
-0.0442554057,
0.0268931501,
0.0049870368,
-0.0306773968,
-0.0017681472,
0.0188799277,
-0.0036983583,
-0.0012295267,
-0.0301726907,
0.0090719434,
0.018717695,
-0.0294016451,
-0.0653575808,
-0.0093054157,
-0.0390768051,
-0.0481156483,
0.0377141684,
0.0088755758,
-0.0077766804,
0.036842078,
-0.0276488252,
-0.0372524895,
0.0181861874,
-0.0229878202,
0.0189156048,
-0.0047378372,
0.0205892306,
0.0160213634,
-0.0561003797,
-0.0305435304,
0.0809257478,
0.0108537637,
-0.0102697387,
0.0231151152,
0.0167742632,
-0.0067346306,
-0.0425018631,
-0.0269793328,
0.0019915716,
0.0024418978,
0.0333458818,
0.054294765,
0.048020184,
-0.0414551981,
-0.0166067835,
-0.0669665411,
0.0116755739,
-0.0255248826,
-0.0052559515,
-0.0081224442,
-0.0076215868,
-0.0045283264,
-0.042408213,
-0.0569349565,
-0.0022685044,
0.035820961,
0.0102609899,
0.0436334014,
0.0102109043,
-0.011714506,
-0.0352083296,
-0.0029891713,
-0.0127594965,
-0.0108329793,
0.0414626561,
0.0077942293,
-0.0635212138,
0.0525613613,
-0.0241085719,
0.0479544625,
-0.0201255251,
-0.0140040051,
0.0414784774,
-0.042897936,
0.0356828831,
0.095890604,
0.007876901,
0.0056056567,
0.0541419648,
0.0011068899,
-0.0813205168,
0.0473218784,
-0.009673804,
-0.0437078178,
-0.0135952635,
-0.0011316104,
0.0102857454,
0.0444212444,
0.0015068154,
0.0161518715,
-0.0546884388,
0.0236402564,
0.0100316359,
-0.0290279966,
-0.0446439683,
-0.0377615467,
-0.0253457222,
0.044622004,
-0.0346748941,
-0.0600831211,
0.0796877369,
-0.0038209676,
-0.010200873,
-0.0418252908,
-0.0265973303,
-0.0255737919,
0.0723727196,
0.0097628487,
0.0233288668,
-0.0117696654,
-0.0287696179,
-0.0339186825,
0.0061977347,
-0.0186792947,
-0.0252454616,
0.0186100658,
-0.0389775001,
0.0140081272,
0.0186331067,
-0.0686360672,
-0.0761976987,
-0.0228196159,
-0.0453894176,
-0.0084476322,
-0.0210975297,
-0.0150487851,
-0.0210850891,
-0.0129006337,
0.0673746169,
0.0557915457,
-0.0198332816,
-0.0225421954,
-0.0253545344,
-0.0169435292,
0.0526971519,
0.021557048,
-0.0110956747,
-0.0061809407,
0.0426102839,
0.0286702346,
0.0385217555,
-0.03134441,
-0.0491912439,
0.0305408034,
0.0021731704,
-0.0394999646,
0.0008225916,
0.0479893684,
0.0482037552,
-0.0767484829,
-0.0216541048,
0.1379043609,
0.0428827256,
-0.0312914625,
-0.0072664577,
-0.0222430564,
-0.0231759809,
0.0262667779,
0.0639863014,
-0.0654575974,
-0.0508283526,
0.0144528495,
0.0117174517,
0.0111999195,
-0.0348764993,
0.0109764822,
-0.1465010196,
0.0265120789,
-0.0192861483,
-0.0126040168,
-0.0075043817,
-0.0452337898,
-0.0136431148,
0.0060620345,
-0.0281784348,
0.0206010155,
0.0019322362,
-0.007289907,
0.0185384806,
-0.0196316168,
-0.0195384957,
0.0601002611,
-0.0502318703,
0.0555789173,
0.108635895,
-0.0076855216,
-0.0058795032,
-0.0194175616,
0.0192802828,
0.0399801508,
0.0208731815,
-0.003625788,
0.0463047475,
-0.0173640754,
-0.0170657355,
-0.0339648128,
0.0518205166,
-0.0362436473,
0.0028387995,
0.0352419019,
0.07170856,
-0.0237793569,
-0.0167894103,
-0.0144335097,
0.0071030119,
0.0109205525,
0.0752204135,
-0.0218508355,
-0.0509046204,
-0.0526685305,
-0.0396562628,
-0.0712471828,
0.0046315785,
-0.0506035909,
-0.0205141082,
0.0155902728,
0.0260492675,
-0.0773570687,
-0.0686877444,
0.0649389401,
0.0198320486,
0.0053610126,
-0.0233145319,
0.004487785,
0.0441419929,
-0.0206677727,
0.0134878857,
-0.0330654643,
0.012925568,
-0.06561701,
-0.004218128,
0.0392551683,
-0.0566831082,
-0.012100365,
-0.0165636949,
-0.0550602563,
-0.057414785,
-0.0501692332,
0.0800820589,
0.0190582145,
0.0613700524,
-0.016704727,
-0.0277870521,
0.0127748651,
0.0259127244,
-0.0470344126,
-0.0133886533,
0.0205297377,
0.0339792743,
0.0174126159,
0.0335050076,
-0.0822475851,
0.0222597625,
-0.0000394041,
0.0310135223,
-0.0350118689,
-0.0150760915,
0.0388063528,
0.0132474173,
0.0076057948,
-0.0063289357,
0.0099588642,
-0.0164063256,
0.0007666724,
-0.0140581373,
-0.063048549,
-0.0407419726,
0.0242319163,
-0.0038985973,
0.0138842212,
0.0432865173,
-0.0346982777,
-0.0041956771,
-0.0017657751,
-0.0050470824,
-0.01038983,
0.014294696,
0.0366018154,
0.018792171,
0.0121543305,
-0.022718139,
0.0060883602,
0.0257244855,
0.0342703573,
-0.0072939219,
0.0961457416,
0.0213495642,
-0.0147612924,
-0.0525964275,
0.0087527335,
-0.0589702465,
-0.0930051878,
0.0411017723,
0.0453890711,
0.047529906,
0.0071494086,
-0.0068172598,
-0.0648481995,
0.0162504669,
-0.0136249708,
0.0133238379,
0.0055860914,
-0.0251257382,
0.032737799,
0.031341292,
-0.0030047391,
-0.0048618186,
0.0525024794,
-0.0073587536,
0.0357716642,
0.0207807682,
0.0066450583,
-0.0588666946,
-0.0151706077,
-0.0058653597,
0.008511899,
-0.0049846903,
0.0286910366,
-0.0140312798,
-0.0466679335,
-0.0347226076,
0.0357224382,
0.0016001933,
-0.0324118473,
0.0643034503,
0.0439530574,
-0.0067440234,
-0.0348120667,
-0.0324062519,
-0.0138555421,
-0.0055933935,
-0.0270406585,
-0.0291957855,
-6.117494844e-33,
-0.0049615693,
-0.0245568175,
0.0555418916,
0.0195605904,
0.0182030015,
-0.0092929527,
-0.0478006825,
0.0056634606,
-0.0027004052,
0.0105733853,
-0.0231209453,
-0.00721339,
0.0099798609,
-0.0011749491,
0.034663111,
-0.0084029846,
0.0496312492,
-0.0099152308,
-0.0355017036,
0.019040972,
0.0167766586,
0.0048158458,
0.0089430725,
-0.053343717,
0.0212957598,
-0.0142656025,
-0.0193000529,
0.0460570753,
-0.0176966153,
0.0254608542,
-0.0245069936,
0.02183518,
0.0194469634,
-0.0341480151,
-0.010972647,
0.0503692552,
-0.0734991208,
-0.0410822071,
-0.0020769339,
-0.0186340101,
-0.0675055906,
-0.0060548265,
0.0122604864,
-0.0004610935,
-0.0254140198,
0.0422485135,
0.0325653777,
-0.0044818623,
-0.0026906261,
0.0063388003,
-0.0457645692,
-0.0183744896,
-0.0162375979,
-0.0643432289,
-0.0018889437,
0.0383304656,
-0.0419648029,
-0.0211317856,
-0.0563892499,
0.0407602675,
0.0457518436,
0.0018901674,
0.0623632446,
0.0138794435,
0.0056046895,
0.0422420129,
0.0018645423,
0.0113781281,
-0.0252709333,
0.0201946478,
0.0145552848,
0.0519118048,
0.0336446427,
0.000413744,
0.0235028099,
0.0298319664,
-0.0484151393,
0.022751838,
0.0342583098,
0.0650357977,
0.0385409184,
-0.0069293631,
-0.062271703,
-0.0204497594,
-0.0483927131,
0.0245166868,
-0.0327937901,
-0.0489970371,
0.0612211339,
0.0463672951,
0.0133238882,
-0.0586893857,
0.0082329884,
-0.0106220329,
-0.0195844118,
0.0351666436,
-0.02342356,
0.0244195219,
-0.0235780831,
0.001179912,
-0.0587379672,
-0.0198007263,
-0.004611779,
0.0131236445,
0.0038652702,
0.0372047313,
0.0031048369,
0.0324230827,
-0.0760892779,
0.0131680826,
-0.0387705564,
0.0273312312,
0.0331269503,
0.0104647614,
0.0184667017,
-0.0138926776,
-0.0206467938,
0.0765493885,
-0.0302357357,
-0.0734885931,
-0.0383840352,
0.0032207728,
-0.0106910104,
-0.009346351,
-0.0425647721,
0.0075642928,
-0.0595830679,
0.0382488184,
-0.0042189197,
-0.0506563783,
0.0121658817,
0.0089210309,
2.969e-7,
-0.0462472141,
0.0508872457,
0.0026225145,
0.0373522416,
-0.0115251923,
0.0528646111,
-0.0246200673,
0.0119285733,
0.0149444267,
-0.0119824298,
0.0041091898,
0.0736791119,
0.0186445098,
-0.0185737144,
-0.0784750804,
-0.0422443859,
-0.0268359985,
-0.0254060496,
-0.0777745843,
0.0145836528,
0.0618517101,
0.0786285326,
0.0190728623,
-0.0027581225,
0.0034827779,
-0.0673425943,
0.0459440574,
-0.0105055086,
-0.0049738819,
-0.0120057156,
-0.0013033048,
0.0386020727,
-0.0224145986,
0.016991403,
0.0147312833,
0.0105016371,
-0.0272356886,
0.0668508559,
0.0060662441,
0.0100205448,
-0.0014153826,
0.0011035422,
0.0061146757,
-0.0090986174,
0.0681362748,
-0.063958928,
-0.0036391227,
0.0021643902,
0.0270810071,
-0.0423645116,
-0.0170356743,
-0.0296850167,
-0.0120858392,
-0.010385857,
-0.0111200204,
-0.0048434809,
-0.0096123954,
-0.075341925,
-0.0001214154,
0.0237434618,
-0.0343565531,
-0.0225957166,
-0.0329078473,
0.0297721494,
0.0062036561,
-0.0491357073,
-0.003250543,
2.759769388e-34,
0.001916106,
-0.0074469238,
0.0125450538,
0.0403092615,
0.042164024,
0.038678389,
-0.0564590693,
0.0064849686,
0.0644816309,
-0.0814572424,
-0.0432641022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17475v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17475v2 | Efficient distributed representations beyond negative sampling | 2023-03-30T15:48:26 | 2023-10-30T09:34:17 | Lorenzo Dall'Amico, Enrico Maria Belliardo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | This article describes an efficient method to learn distributed
representations, also known as embeddings. This is accomplished minimizing an
objective function similar to the one introduced in the Word2Vec algorithm and
later adopted in several works. The optimization computational bottleneck is
the calculation of the softmax normalization constants for which a number of
operations scaling quadratically with the sample size is required. This
complexity is unsuited for large datasets and negative sampling is a popular
workaround, allowing one to obtain distributed representations in linear time
with respect to the sample size. Negative sampling consists, however, in a
change of the loss function and hence solves a different optimization problem
from the one originally proposed. Our contribution is to show that the sotfmax
normalization constants can be estimated in linear time, allowing us to design
an efficient optimization strategy to learn distributed representations. We
test our approximation on two popular applications related to word and node
embeddings. The results evidence competing performance in terms of accuracy
with respect to negative sampling with a remarkably lower computational time. | [
-0.0091424985,
0.0131678609,
0.0105550177,
0.0376709439,
-0.0175121706,
-0.002638571,
0.0163684618,
-0.0105536133,
0.0080580134,
-0.0259309933,
-0.0412660912,
-0.0360006019,
0.0100013399,
-0.0092875613,
0.0184820052,
-0.0085844202,
0.0141277798,
0.0357284062,
-0.057937596,
-0.0389583744,
-0.0084299706,
0.0211622808,
0.0126633635,
0.0093109608,
-0.023511745,
-0.0331878625,
-0.0024338327,
-0.0250458829,
0.0180429071,
-0.0172317717,
-0.0393991992,
-0.0177789237,
0.0646931157,
-0.0131027503,
0.0000018012,
0.0343292654,
-0.0028820839,
-0.0243019182,
0.0308535844,
0.0716379583,
0.0288827363,
-0.0480021983,
-0.0048528579,
0.0125275552,
-0.0416944027,
-0.0436794274,
0.0493582897,
0.0249541011,
0.0132688377,
0.0550703481,
-0.0124950875,
-0.03986964,
-0.0129998568,
-0.0510730483,
-0.0609051473,
-0.0171576552,
0.0024388751,
0.0065325066,
0.0402841568,
0.0083275344,
-0.0494510271,
0.0301626381,
0.0227730107,
0.0096691558,
0.0544129051,
0.0609858036,
-0.0506513864,
0.0438995883,
0.0128221624,
0.1205822527,
-0.0132128354,
-0.000261097,
-0.0271258969,
-0.0243857205,
-0.0179471429,
0.044845432,
-0.007855163,
-0.03153193,
0.038750194,
0.0633865595,
-0.0317504741,
-0.0079082642,
0.062862955,
-0.0121898921,
-0.0181334782,
0.0401248857,
-0.0060303397,
-0.0061995923,
0.0039311969,
0.0152246105,
-0.0836335197,
0.055603113,
0.0429584719,
0.0005875881,
0.0203156658,
-0.0086404644,
0.0034604203,
-0.0362006351,
-0.022225963,
-0.0605861321,
0.0421883129,
-0.0148412306,
0.0328897871,
0.0725603178,
-0.0605774149,
-0.0001842475,
-0.0197345428,
0.0359879807,
-0.0292909089,
0.0158671234,
-0.0316819958,
0.0162829496,
-0.0266432427,
0.0453142934,
-0.0185296405,
-0.0549013801,
0.0262625795,
0.0182666816,
-0.0608465858,
-0.0143392542,
0.0100839259,
0.0304316189,
0.0168582778,
0.0038619551,
0.0285643134,
0.0653604791,
-0.0728988498,
0.0223721676,
-0.0630748048,
0.0170904957,
-0.0246779826,
-0.0142906234,
0.0507481731,
0.0213179793,
-0.0104984455,
0.0666819215,
0.0003687816,
-0.0251818802,
-0.0294715129,
-0.0052587613,
0.0053068651,
-0.0097708255,
-0.0267780293,
-0.0610659868,
0.0549961403,
0.0086054588,
0.015136349,
-0.0023612564,
0.0107456073,
-0.0287777632,
-0.0516937114,
0.073327668,
-0.0221152827,
-0.008312746,
0.033751782,
0.0033871504,
0.0146493809,
0.061448548,
0.0173316374,
0.0217718817,
0.0271927714,
0.0032276704,
-0.028664792,
0.0088631948,
0.0807837322,
0.0109038334,
0.0250933748,
-0.0407405533,
-0.0102929464,
0.0566682853,
0.024628669,
0.0408635996,
-0.0682693124,
-0.0850798786,
0.021765789,
0.0686510652,
-0.0220437478,
-0.0024072502,
0.0209291857,
-0.0106652463,
-0.0200851858,
0.0003133592,
-0.0175767317,
0.0307476502,
0.0543714762,
-0.0384025574,
-0.0007177457,
-0.0021442741,
-0.0912867114,
0.027887471,
-0.0066567156,
-0.0401738323,
0.0542733259,
-0.0516066551,
0.0181466844,
-0.0197986066,
-0.0124533027,
0.054442741,
0.0324977636,
-0.0078770854,
0.027857786,
0.0408379994,
0.0288104229,
-0.0082598031,
0.0736368895,
-0.0260747038,
0.0331535526,
-0.0664026663,
-0.0031093615,
0.0133528877,
0.0446990803,
-0.03609813,
0.011475007,
-0.0362621062,
-0.0231507123,
0.03168571,
-0.0193459615,
0.0267622825,
-0.0257581063,
0.0237426776,
0.0378299542,
-0.0383541994,
-0.0246681925,
-0.000509335,
-0.0299216658,
-0.0417478606,
0.0220922288,
0.0471261814,
0.065067552,
0.0139544215,
-0.0093629975,
-0.016396936,
0.0159258898,
-0.0548439473,
-0.0688921362,
-0.0234353151,
-0.0439835861,
-0.067620106,
0.0228009354,
-0.069952786,
0.0615656301,
0.0841822922,
-0.0266731195,
-0.0235976968,
0.0620815642,
-0.0476067029,
0.0128391692,
-0.0139389429,
-0.0093275877,
-0.0066673118,
0.0270516612,
-0.0092573874,
0.0144971907,
-0.0631699786,
0.0265140198,
-0.0346263498,
-0.0320296362,
0.0280916877,
0.0054212543,
-0.0299158897,
0.0134422518,
0.020631915,
0.0159494933,
0.0142096598,
-0.0151645243,
-0.0153266592,
0.020439567,
-0.0550811663,
-0.0132717127,
-0.0263291709,
0.0141092548,
0.0287386775,
0.0092866002,
0.0415265262,
-0.0153731918,
-0.0648065507,
0.0411759131,
-0.0525182746,
0.03773541,
0.0098447213,
0.006431595,
-0.0032931224,
0.021767579,
-0.0357339568,
0.0016207087,
0.0330460742,
-0.0351277217,
-0.0243465044,
-0.0329530574,
0.0116244676,
-0.0471694395,
0.0186526552,
-0.0082299495,
-0.0099745728,
0.0036105211,
-0.0149638159,
0.0054169632,
0.0610160641,
-0.0096793864,
0.0049508158,
0.0130510507,
0.0804405659,
-0.044752121,
-0.0208989587,
-0.0395068601,
0.0543585941,
-0.0130549092,
-0.0072599272,
-0.0159392878,
0.0649543852,
0.0099028433,
-0.0150751853,
-0.028225664,
-0.0079576885,
-0.0303423051,
-0.0349377356,
-0.0096848812,
0.0400569886,
0.0432044528,
-0.0418245234,
-0.0289872754,
-0.0483493805,
0.0492342971,
0.0059829811,
-0.005099779,
-0.0451360755,
-0.0152903423,
-0.0046801562,
0.035357397,
0.0424363278,
0.0319383889,
-0.0818432197,
-0.0368140005,
-0.0183935538,
-0.0231845267,
0.040106304,
-0.0210218076,
-0.0067087365,
0.0181713607,
0.029155463,
-0.0511351973,
-0.0735457465,
0.0170180369,
-0.0809201673,
0.0141082928,
0.0390384309,
-0.0086282929,
-0.0195653196,
-0.0546777397,
0.0297597405,
-0.0214344971,
0.0257811993,
-0.0171750207,
-0.002571902,
-0.0347728431,
0.0367368907,
0.0344230235,
-0.0049532051,
-0.0005423438,
0.0054646232,
0.0195161477,
0.0656093732,
0.0179447196,
0.0154668633,
-0.0085930098,
-0.0083941203,
-0.0054232865,
-0.0033772571,
-0.0182126537,
-0.0392488129,
0.0486305878,
0.0346401259,
-0.0009726588,
0.0741431639,
0.0200240146,
-0.0799613297,
0.0234945863,
-0.0238277745,
0.0193103831,
0.0311546251,
-0.0367025398,
-0.0499802828,
-0.0137728248,
-0.0387404524,
0.0164628066,
0.0366284885,
-0.0530087203,
0.0066685295,
-0.0908321217,
-0.0166017022,
0.0687163845,
-0.0291929711,
-0.058560174,
-0.0342288725,
0.0235264543,
-0.0024148514,
0.0068552452,
-0.0081570027,
0.0350016877,
-0.032607343,
0.0306720994,
-0.0178177059,
-0.0144982524,
0.0105376402,
-0.0882332548,
0.0468219444,
0.0294387657,
0.0223312248,
0.0065021394,
-0.0391557738,
-0.0332938731,
-0.0108544668,
-0.0406813137,
-0.0441714302,
0.0254963096,
-0.0007186662,
-0.0313151814,
0.0124185188,
0.0437247716,
-0.0561187789,
0.0354339071,
-0.022069959,
0.1284581423,
0.0002614423,
-0.0256459508,
-0.0021064081,
-0.018433094,
0.0319514945,
0.0569773652,
0.0315863863,
-0.0541027039,
0.0246755593,
0.0361327715,
0.014237293,
0.0197583139,
-0.0006686865,
-0.0125221908,
-0.0163796786,
0.0397258811,
-0.074027285,
-0.0319741145,
0.0433125347,
0.050807748,
0.0134013798,
0.0149037512,
0.0549321994,
-0.023103442,
-0.0335223451,
-0.021475235,
-0.0397257395,
0.0450154319,
0.0432045795,
-0.0229235496,
0.0432109907,
0.0075700623,
0.0084902961,
0.011021249,
-0.058971718,
-0.0508061983,
-0.0368540399,
-0.0137037719,
0.001671075,
0.0232309271,
-0.0253975801,
-0.0598573424,
0.0721061453,
0.0469229147,
-0.0241938327,
0.0459802113,
0.0252938438,
-0.0328627601,
0.0110357013,
0.0902222767,
-0.0157864615,
0.0316927657,
0.0279229656,
0.030745659,
-0.0451513454,
-0.0181709174,
-0.0252302419,
0.0057965834,
0.0193356555,
0.023689447,
0.0493528731,
-0.0381194837,
-0.02533268,
-0.0309588518,
0.0037867182,
-0.0648492426,
0.0074017798,
0.0331615731,
-0.0187917594,
-0.0269936025,
0.0005602477,
0.0445626974,
0.0244141519,
0.0141047286,
0.016773168,
0.0390771255,
-0.0240289569,
0.0026343225,
0.0555329919,
-0.0242570825,
-0.0466750786,
0.0172786526,
-0.006314809,
-0.0229882244,
0.0202501193,
-0.0062783961,
0.0145658636,
-0.0769784153,
0.0111800181,
-0.0668486059,
-0.0228448268,
0.011319099,
0.0401509404,
0.0361564569,
-0.0010114646,
0.0320578665,
0.0012688615,
-0.0249239616,
-0.0631343573,
-0.0084546525,
-0.0343907028,
-0.0034890459,
0.0499251224,
0.0158194751,
0.0026992566,
-0.0082150586,
0.0579351932,
-0.0356281623,
0.0184963606,
-0.0535312705,
-0.0154033452,
-0.0234751701,
-0.0008287414,
0.0007116084,
0.0472807512,
-0.0253415331,
0.0177146755,
-0.0098708058,
-0.0602737144,
0.0182460714,
0.0063702008,
-0.0356711037,
0.0226823054,
0.0134969931,
0.0109005142,
-0.0022393556,
0.0135749262,
-0.0416586027,
0.0461316556,
-0.0266450625,
-0.0528099276,
0.0100529017,
-5.691881767e-33,
-0.0084059667,
0.0137683051,
-0.0434026197,
0.0072058863,
-0.0563368388,
0.0394226126,
0.0232918095,
-0.009891659,
-0.0233486295,
0.0252305456,
-0.0229401402,
0.0238385331,
-0.0076356828,
0.0252534281,
-0.0267987866,
-0.0401880331,
0.0301808268,
-0.0256639645,
-0.0193787217,
0.0465294309,
0.0822190568,
0.0204197858,
0.0398627631,
-0.0659383982,
-0.0278884172,
-0.030733265,
0.0063097179,
-0.0272548515,
0.0679741874,
-0.0040803123,
-0.0224407166,
0.0418420807,
0.0255573597,
-0.0264508948,
-0.0346556455,
-0.0146128265,
-0.0916193053,
-0.0305000711,
0.0015557082,
0.0198926684,
-0.0610972047,
0.0358186401,
0.0331545174,
0.0018327925,
0.032581877,
-0.0015429505,
0.0052909441,
-0.0099727698,
-0.0587301739,
0.0381931067,
-0.0323288515,
0.024126986,
0.0196367856,
0.0067552496,
0.0224850737,
0.0110882595,
0.0111677432,
0.0126973661,
-0.0626762956,
-0.0270989928,
-0.0525247045,
0.0346397385,
-0.0006055768,
0.0543432645,
0.0411421433,
0.0643880293,
0.0431712084,
-0.0353520773,
-0.0364086814,
0.0071334131,
0.0062654996,
0.0002295454,
0.0107854288,
0.0525364019,
-0.0042598778,
-0.0214860756,
-0.0763844103,
-0.0091217095,
0.0487842374,
-0.0112542985,
0.0221797638,
0.019596925,
-0.0326143391,
-0.01411884,
-0.0053453725,
-0.0298327282,
0.0138228601,
-0.0331888683,
-0.0016725163,
0.0352572948,
-0.038340047,
0.0621351004,
0.0190309323,
-0.0812765807,
-0.025875017,
0.0611674339,
0.0319675542,
0.0159820057,
0.0272085089,
-0.0486263819,
-0.0555406772,
-0.009239695,
-0.0238906853,
-0.0123065347,
-0.0007613964,
0.0117346626,
0.0424427129,
0.0221925285,
-0.04109006,
-0.0488274321,
-0.0135250064,
-0.041147653,
-0.0149021158,
0.0287088919,
0.066670537,
-0.0235234983,
0.0020558219,
0.0268302411,
0.0598037988,
0.0087305466,
0.0430500656,
0.0030317316,
0.0206377003,
0.0219637454,
-0.0411226749,
-0.012620599,
-0.0422937386,
0.0298799723,
0.0474287085,
-0.1043878347,
-0.0224904735,
-0.034129899,
2.403e-7,
0.0136912484,
-0.0416785143,
-0.0064008092,
-0.0112579949,
0.055778522,
0.0228994749,
0.0054043308,
0.0846724138,
-0.0204840936,
-0.0277808756,
0.0369814336,
0.0354319401,
-0.0084157204,
0.0058868797,
-0.0837122872,
0.0686428025,
-0.0518808216,
0.0392540544,
0.0038305412,
-0.047927428,
-0.0014153926,
0.1146979034,
0.0679256395,
-0.0397865623,
0.0093315905,
-0.0441175699,
0.0639262199,
-0.0296020713,
0.0051344763,
-0.0368461646,
0.0058703991,
0.0005904144,
-0.017432373,
0.0029649828,
0.0012416255,
0.0609413423,
0.0296031181,
0.0179506205,
-0.0121898064,
0.0205374975,
0.0105280783,
-0.0638447329,
0.0090388311,
0.0458171554,
0.0809277892,
-0.0224276166,
-0.0333167128,
-0.0022338144,
-0.0012807314,
0.0138176726,
0.0626252964,
-0.0295829885,
-0.0059230239,
0.0179033205,
0.0216993671,
-0.0136723258,
0.0164974872,
-0.0588061847,
0.0369512215,
-0.0096262377,
-0.0187568199,
-0.06095073,
0.0052001094,
0.0424506031,
0.079559356,
-0.0140026649,
0.0083374595,
1.251230396e-34,
0.0252657011,
0.0073926663,
0.0002701043,
0.0010656453,
-0.046263095,
-0.0665545389,
-0.023050366,
-0.0513716042,
0.0148101496,
-0.049533762,
-0.004351038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17466v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17466v2 | Assessing Cross-Cultural Alignment between ChatGPT and Human Societies: An Empirical Study | 2023-03-30T15:43:39 | 2023-03-31T15:02:48 | Yong Cao, Li Zhou, Seolhwa Lee, Laura Cabello, Min Chen, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent release of ChatGPT has garnered widespread recognition for its
exceptional ability to generate human-like responses in dialogue. Given its
usage by users from various nations and its training on a vast multilingual
corpus that incorporates diverse cultural and societal norms, it is crucial to
evaluate its effectiveness in cultural adaptation. In this paper, we
investigate the underlying cultural background of ChatGPT by analyzing its
responses to questions designed to quantify human cultural differences. Our
findings suggest that, when prompted with American context, ChatGPT exhibits a
strong alignment with American culture, but it adapts less effectively to other
cultural contexts. Furthermore, by using different prompts to probe the model,
we show that English prompts reduce the variance in model responses, flattening
out cultural differences and biasing them towards American culture. This study
provides valuable insights into the cultural implications of ChatGPT and
highlights the necessity of greater diversity and cultural awareness in
language technologies. | [
0.055730436,
0.0140767656,
-0.0435476974,
0.0013855232,
-0.0435354002,
0.0056935255,
0.0156319235,
-0.0132969674,
0.0425022505,
-0.0220081024,
-0.0421960652,
-0.0465123095,
0.005413834,
0.0064860452,
0.0066000288,
-0.0459213927,
0.0345793366,
0.0134539222,
0.0275082979,
-0.014866095,
0.0494068749,
0.0451247282,
-0.018252084,
0.0439572595,
-0.0102182943,
-0.0078709191,
0.0085253287,
-0.0258205719,
0.0437030382,
-0.0288807247,
0.0405208506,
0.0385243967,
-0.0018997547,
0.0181660634,
0.0000017867,
-0.0631167442,
0.026944736,
-0.0215068404,
-0.0032466119,
0.0245244019,
0.0759096444,
0.0652630255,
-0.0043642968,
0.0241913181,
-0.0765990615,
-0.0117504159,
0.0448855534,
0.0225113761,
0.0119577721,
0.0215117019,
-0.0035246627,
0.0116070164,
-0.0388720781,
0.012062775,
-0.0408630818,
-0.0200831536,
-0.0177582297,
0.0436086133,
0.0302873477,
-0.005480635,
-0.0224387962,
0.0157374162,
0.002292485,
-0.0104128709,
-0.0416335277,
0.0105077364,
-0.067446366,
-0.033720132,
0.0140902288,
0.0513339452,
0.1017693132,
-0.0218077898,
-0.0032331692,
0.0183064248,
0.0144810816,
0.0075111152,
-0.0408317968,
0.0002354192,
-0.0143324975,
-0.0113239987,
0.0139693981,
-0.0052179201,
-0.0392697044,
0.0125367101,
0.0270787608,
0.0463312604,
0.0097491723,
-0.0043259533,
-0.0329929627,
-0.0003404957,
-0.0054745497,
-0.0498320945,
0.0209345259,
-0.0068532601,
-0.0422947444,
0.0046144496,
0.0110810939,
0.0173008349,
0.028477883,
-0.019426709,
-0.0293562487,
0.0844301358,
-0.0353997946,
0.0000458985,
0.050834462,
0.0488598086,
-0.0025368668,
-0.0016005614,
-0.0420213826,
-0.0145177683,
-0.0647983328,
-0.0127632273,
0.0267470255,
-0.0272341426,
-0.0071566724,
0.0149466321,
-0.0631306171,
0.0260769632,
-0.0129214721,
-0.0002283816,
-0.0115202358,
-0.0368689224,
-0.0159583073,
-0.0007049348,
-0.0244295709,
0.0689679831,
-0.0834308639,
-0.0071497313,
0.018271124,
-0.0868845508,
0.0312582999,
0.0123593155,
-0.0073828436,
-0.0250888467,
-0.0264317077,
-0.0116911083,
-0.0264544245,
0.0099105453,
-0.0056012608,
0.0078194905,
-0.0350587033,
-0.0437973775,
-0.0047197747,
-0.0419646874,
0.0366100036,
0.0262826346,
-0.0068565034,
0.0055154208,
0.0166193862,
0.0389752984,
-0.0222488251,
0.0195406787,
0.010972498,
0.0485448837,
0.0721337721,
0.0043533933,
-0.039669767,
0.0462489799,
-0.0156932659,
-0.0286642909,
0.0673407763,
-0.0433117561,
-0.0400614515,
0.0331080519,
-0.0512969866,
-0.0115340529,
0.0138750616,
0.0267520696,
0.0109544815,
-0.0258678533,
0.0263922568,
0.0465807021,
-0.0283567421,
0.0070511689,
0.0404038765,
0.1109687164,
-0.0183926579,
0.0343638733,
0.0142184934,
0.027161805,
-0.0066851322,
0.0438318849,
-0.0303682648,
-0.0136622731,
-0.0409487709,
0.0088955481,
-0.0099686505,
0.0721991584,
-0.0418441445,
-0.0090657389,
-0.0242525507,
0.0319883525,
0.083635129,
0.0191929266,
0.0037386222,
-0.0234709941,
0.032104522,
0.0195863154,
0.042689085,
-0.0619196668,
-0.0403140783,
-0.0434028432,
0.0195681732,
0.0454173982,
0.0053137331,
0.029130429,
-0.0214220621,
-0.0105048837,
0.0428161956,
0.0582453869,
0.0739060417,
0.017513616,
-0.0379302837,
-0.0221555736,
0.0012673422,
0.0202015657,
-0.0293562599,
0.0176797323,
0.0283433013,
0.0449350066,
-0.0153965848,
0.001853088,
0.0229172111,
-0.0222102441,
-0.0350700654,
0.0139015801,
-0.0341246687,
-0.018792145,
0.0211743601,
0.0444616415,
-0.0236218795,
-0.0081989076,
-0.0200240966,
0.0098001156,
0.0195978936,
0.0704671219,
-0.0656145811,
-0.0056636836,
0.0288679916,
-0.0546224415,
-0.0301512983,
-0.0061789798,
0.0312374812,
-0.037119139,
0.0089680236,
-0.0181262568,
0.0501485281,
-0.0541534349,
-0.0145808989,
-0.0203688815,
0.0225321446,
-0.0371484607,
0.0067930678,
0.0027255854,
0.0140826358,
-0.0099041276,
-0.0007474195,
0.0402536876,
-0.0166539401,
-0.0489251427,
0.0604352318,
-0.0114453239,
-0.0087520601,
0.0697494745,
0.030613225,
-0.0765253529,
-0.0128412964,
-0.1326982379,
-0.0078331931,
-0.0111715952,
0.0245905686,
0.0433203764,
0.0268132035,
-0.0444058329,
-0.0206028018,
-0.099317342,
0.0012278236,
0.0336577818,
0.0564665943,
0.0316568278,
-0.0476509705,
0.0166982431,
0.0033026261,
-0.0097525064,
-0.0079939542,
-0.0160232522,
-0.0244159661,
-0.0471349657,
-0.020395482,
-0.0279308911,
-0.0412714444,
-0.0270784646,
-0.0141192386,
-0.0697231814,
0.0491056852,
0.0473825447,
0.0756345242,
0.0236875266,
0.0420926288,
-0.0032663988,
-0.0088151721,
-0.0042834384,
-0.0261983518,
-0.0205376633,
-0.0000829364,
-0.0173344761,
0.0149478838,
-0.1026401594,
-0.0378013067,
0.0562488325,
0.0067407172,
0.0208591595,
-0.044385273,
0.0220286455,
-0.041675318,
-0.0388304293,
-0.0339805782,
-0.0160030033,
-0.0319538675,
0.0482092723,
-0.0060304222,
-0.0129038766,
0.0237921495,
0.0179659016,
-0.040297769,
-0.0464993864,
0.0027749001,
-0.018290041,
0.0425859429,
-0.0297734253,
0.0299714115,
0.0417383052,
-0.0626905113,
-0.0484701321,
-0.0190501288,
0.0621926263,
-0.0321953557,
0.0273068901,
-0.0567197502,
-0.0159589611,
-0.0175408684,
-0.0310955178,
-0.0391641781,
0.0056430721,
-0.0018286352,
0.0278918426,
0.0279628169,
0.0105962772,
0.0342829749,
0.0325473733,
0.0273613892,
-0.0022164795,
-0.0284059737,
0.0298293792,
0.0158960652,
0.0195411742,
0.0472233631,
0.0587930083,
0.0137024736,
0.0195474941,
0.0340405405,
0.0357986726,
0.038497813,
-0.019509891,
0.0264168065,
0.0090026809,
0.0427030548,
-0.011386347,
-0.0351328477,
0.0117184725,
0.0896856785,
0.0061889621,
0.0140532888,
0.0812189281,
0.0226842798,
-0.0434283614,
-0.0175825208,
-0.0731287301,
0.0431856327,
0.0182766225,
0.0479991212,
-0.0945566222,
0.0291993804,
-0.0102481721,
-0.0389109664,
-0.0301495325,
-0.0160293989,
-0.0218497571,
-0.1040477604,
0.0121672358,
0.0097358488,
-0.061401587,
0.0213012006,
0.0313381478,
0.0154190883,
0.0139968637,
0.0608626157,
-0.0054398696,
0.006212106,
-0.0060067014,
0.00522466,
-0.0578874573,
-0.0038678637,
0.050403934,
-0.0217503048,
0.0550295636,
0.0351377949,
0.0376604795,
0.012393048,
-0.0521964468,
0.0157203153,
0.0115214083,
-0.0000527108,
-0.0017936133,
-0.0358189084,
0.0306189321,
0.0023160847,
-0.0431035385,
0.0119953193,
-0.0161866061,
-0.0100528933,
0.0407870114,
0.0355238616,
-0.0175507609,
0.0036036046,
-0.0136224553,
0.0400727764,
0.0096029518,
0.0412840396,
0.0116671603,
-0.0668396503,
0.0148559036,
-0.0014177265,
-0.0120195188,
0.0287893601,
-0.0544276498,
0.007174199,
-0.0381132141,
-0.0283735264,
-0.0580304191,
-0.0739687309,
-0.0022295006,
-0.0067504337,
0.010492539,
-0.0465106294,
0.0072813975,
0.0222095009,
0.0105193444,
0.0196180586,
-0.0192240812,
0.014012632,
-0.0117783658,
-0.0133137964,
0.003431842,
-0.0269592032,
-0.0017848673,
-0.0074365172,
-0.0048009362,
-0.035622295,
0.0457415655,
0.00188853,
0.014802089,
0.004533357,
0.018267693,
0.0112706171,
-0.0322470553,
-0.0043283356,
-0.0059280675,
0.0048320717,
-0.0117025822,
0.0634976029,
-0.0016889736,
0.0185221788,
0.0135090025,
0.018566383,
-0.0052674562,
0.0489649847,
-0.0502605401,
-0.0501173623,
0.025105482,
0.0311216842,
0.0351184197,
-0.0189304221,
-0.0020768486,
-0.0312401243,
-0.036490988,
-0.0248127487,
-0.0004948989,
-0.0127256773,
-0.0597369075,
-0.0010303453,
-0.0513758622,
0.0052633802,
-0.0098728957,
-0.072991915,
0.0287629869,
-0.038318526,
0.0325903781,
0.0072931256,
0.048629649,
-0.0390720554,
0.0245124009,
-0.0248342641,
0.0230205059,
0.027029328,
0.0601943024,
-0.0266036093,
0.1503761262,
-0.00679537,
-0.0192971807,
0.0488021187,
0.027181169,
-0.0380962603,
-0.0102254683,
0.0291721262,
0.0333338343,
0.0477172546,
-0.034538541,
0.0395453312,
0.0127377389,
-0.005337311,
-0.007528373,
0.029152751,
0.0138149597,
-0.0230182987,
0.0312059745,
-0.0115900431,
-0.0386430472,
-0.0218812693,
0.0353955068,
-0.0809119642,
-0.046474576,
0.0389288589,
-0.0298213903,
-0.0348725468,
-0.0407425053,
0.0246558804,
-0.0180025231,
-0.0125523685,
0.0204074215,
-0.067166537,
-0.0555859171,
-0.0506326258,
-0.0007541704,
0.0271011591,
-0.0242163762,
0.0232245382,
0.0741200373,
-0.0448232964,
-0.0450275242,
-0.054750815,
0.0144436387,
-0.058279112,
-0.0038979144,
-0.0226629507,
-6.017933778e-33,
-0.0271688439,
-0.0145557737,
0.0303195268,
0.0122072585,
-0.0459230691,
-0.0409693345,
-0.0113506978,
0.0565909967,
-0.054782737,
0.0146667575,
-0.072130844,
-0.0029131263,
0.012254565,
-0.0108067449,
0.0439174324,
-0.0124360798,
-0.022051705,
0.0083810873,
0.0002061933,
-0.0011798914,
0.0318526365,
-0.0128636295,
0.0881714746,
-0.0605210848,
0.0723639354,
-0.010617719,
0.0026120108,
-0.0044625495,
0.0518094786,
0.0190734658,
-0.0245649926,
0.0483104847,
0.0301431734,
-0.0169459581,
0.0015990029,
0.0586163476,
-0.02492195,
-0.0605224557,
0.0603722446,
0.0255911518,
0.0491539277,
-0.0372341946,
-0.0401197039,
-0.0607004017,
-0.0434080102,
0.0252963081,
0.0128079467,
0.0027489592,
0.0199038349,
0.0401116088,
-0.0397818387,
0.0222716127,
-0.0111964922,
0.0122239646,
-0.0413554236,
0.0979490727,
-0.035085611,
-0.0521205738,
-0.0153163336,
0.029152466,
0.0101021426,
-0.0011010703,
0.0752502084,
-0.0003306977,
0.0154741639,
0.034519352,
0.0373985209,
0.0522630103,
0.0045143873,
-0.0507283024,
0.0308196768,
-0.0098723387,
0.0087279072,
0.1080299765,
-0.0039213812,
-0.0250207894,
-0.0136227841,
-0.0096594822,
0.0763818026,
0.0257251337,
0.0052407905,
0.0335082375,
-0.0364384651,
-0.0231264643,
0.0079899766,
0.0140307387,
-0.0138992313,
-0.0693594664,
0.0394819826,
-0.0615331568,
0.0223542489,
-0.0430799276,
0.0571612939,
-0.0307318978,
0.0154729486,
-0.0309519209,
-0.0206347089,
-0.0189624857,
0.0163429845,
0.0289932285,
-0.0304711312,
0.010785806,
-0.0239251312,
0.0201865621,
-0.0007647967,
0.0257021189,
-0.0159454383,
-0.0157587994,
-0.0579113252,
-0.0251768157,
-0.0140880561,
0.0335798077,
-0.0393946953,
-0.0431448184,
0.0368185416,
0.0008198955,
-0.0093487855,
0.0054905908,
0.0549049899,
-0.0020756361,
-0.0705187991,
-0.0481516346,
-0.0390724503,
0.0171358921,
-0.0401536413,
0.0278019216,
-0.0217016228,
0.0519332215,
0.0274333693,
0.0073179528,
-0.0225898344,
-0.0263210386,
2.448e-7,
0.0167223234,
0.0330193676,
-0.0118326293,
0.0294478741,
0.0158654209,
-0.0034991307,
-0.0059348387,
0.0286304876,
0.0815220997,
-0.0033745447,
0.0286920927,
-0.0291790087,
0.0725421309,
0.03903009,
-0.1017684191,
-0.0397705063,
-0.0625967905,
0.019449098,
-0.0000206493,
0.0486169457,
0.0352449417,
0.0056079635,
-0.033698868,
0.001288178,
-0.0546185151,
-0.0194410104,
0.0406935774,
-0.0772859082,
-0.0286647193,
0.0141136777,
0.0100778248,
-0.0468080752,
0.0332091525,
0.0341666602,
0.0019904824,
0.0053587649,
0.0337368399,
0.0475885682,
-0.0105749527,
-0.0175436568,
-0.0029263906,
0.0022409675,
0.0063480786,
-0.0944590569,
0.0386447199,
-0.0171838049,
-0.0247892179,
-0.0448202975,
-0.0007436532,
-0.0538075566,
0.0437282026,
-0.0208822321,
-0.0414221212,
0.0393305719,
0.0324788615,
0.0060905898,
-0.0056805708,
-0.0172664262,
-0.0067653474,
0.0001062863,
-0.0093782069,
-0.0824848786,
0.0036452857,
0.0001127332,
-0.0303574074,
0.0284183603,
0.0089630047,
1.718904267e-34,
0.0077698566,
0.0179134253,
0.0496130474,
0.0362608284,
0.0660423636,
0.0176096,
0.0746280849,
0.025718445,
0.0397713073,
-0.0329787321,
-0.023060482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01005v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01005v3 | Federated Learning Based Multilingual Emoji Prediction In Clean and Attack Scenarios | 2023-03-30T15:31:49 | 2023-07-07T00:51:43 | Karim Gamal, Ahmed Gaber, Hossam Amer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Federated learning is a growing field in the machine learning community due
to its decentralized and private design. Model training in federated learning
is distributed over multiple clients giving access to lots of client data while
maintaining privacy. Then, a server aggregates the training done on these
multiple clients without access to their data, which could be emojis widely
used in any social media service and instant messaging platforms to express
users' sentiments. This paper proposes federated learning-based multilingual
emoji prediction in both clean and attack scenarios. Emoji prediction data have
been crawled from both Twitter and SemEval emoji datasets. This data is used to
train and evaluate different transformer model sizes including a sparsely
activated transformer with either the assumption of clean data in all clients
or poisoned data via label flipping attack in some clients. Experimental
results on these models show that federated learning in either clean or
attacked scenarios performs similarly to centralized training in multilingual
emoji prediction on seen and unseen languages under different data sources and
distributions. Our trained transformers perform better than other techniques on
the SemEval emoji dataset in addition to the privacy as well as distributed
benefits of federated learning. | [
0.0292068869,
0.1032372788,
-0.0088170134,
0.0136382505,
-0.0058915834,
0.0140214395,
0.083672218,
0.0118604414,
0.064793624,
-0.0233707111,
-0.0303804502,
-0.0211654305,
-0.0000697831,
0.0345961787,
0.0179869793,
-0.0054513756,
0.0255836975,
0.020775063,
-0.0195742864,
-0.0512576997,
0.0133420806,
0.0199873969,
0.0271619856,
0.0557960868,
-0.0545326099,
-0.0311253723,
-0.0215222239,
-0.0151339956,
-0.0110386424,
0.0138597628,
0.0462271534,
0.0439105965,
-0.0244219657,
0.0898663476,
0.0000018351,
-0.006878444,
-0.0530221798,
0.0090864254,
-0.0082124313,
-0.0099755013,
0.0336673744,
-0.0588868298,
-0.0205808599,
0.0508284755,
-0.0285700541,
-0.0396104977,
0.0747665167,
0.0369376205,
0.070886828,
0.0562469661,
-0.0192259029,
-0.0530837961,
0.0255631264,
-0.0104147401,
-0.1039320007,
0.0227366015,
0.0183574203,
-0.0432148203,
-0.0547487065,
-0.010179502,
-0.0018902859,
0.0380412191,
0.029043993,
0.0072354502,
-0.0558887236,
-0.0033272097,
-0.0131272869,
-0.0539911985,
-0.0238951184,
0.0413502716,
-0.0331994593,
0.0109068602,
-0.0089169387,
-0.0092094177,
-0.0152313821,
0.0360353515,
-0.0159617178,
0.006865955,
0.0092261909,
0.02781987,
-0.0178577192,
0.0240360703,
0.0407899171,
0.0222524293,
-0.0202791728,
0.0456999578,
-0.0094445907,
-0.0072140587,
-0.0199690405,
-0.0230826009,
-0.0168994237,
-0.0409957804,
0.0601580031,
0.0124609536,
0.0086074183,
0.0201579966,
-0.0608150847,
-0.1194572896,
0.0235849191,
-0.0186711922,
-0.0016267447,
-0.0050658099,
0.0076112621,
0.0127928583,
-0.0212679617,
-0.0053137378,
-0.0288717747,
0.0816487595,
0.0075412621,
-0.0348373987,
-0.0334395096,
-0.0070358259,
-0.0032829181,
0.0540557206,
0.019149784,
0.0150171164,
-0.0573212355,
0.0446779169,
-0.0299440362,
-0.0080909999,
0.0147790127,
-0.0014562284,
-0.0108604608,
0.0009488962,
0.01165077,
0.0430310816,
-0.0098287584,
-0.0079803253,
-0.0129987374,
-0.046034459,
0.0042348658,
0.0122916512,
0.0066990219,
-0.0160078034,
0.0124635836,
0.0739986971,
0.0102751432,
-0.0191927087,
-0.0138851022,
-0.0363295637,
0.0207294412,
-0.0131826801,
0.0120578473,
-0.0658223629,
0.0057369508,
0.0097684925,
0.0291858446,
-0.0120771416,
0.0006980483,
0.0074896594,
-0.0745233968,
0.0606561191,
-0.0093551539,
0.0028914895,
-0.0031816964,
-0.0026238798,
-0.0155334827,
0.0653111637,
0.0116160922,
0.0493377112,
0.0609272644,
-0.0213196184,
0.0134823397,
0.0486495718,
0.0296191387,
0.0305188242,
-0.0135240713,
-0.0201363247,
-0.0487372354,
-0.0072643296,
-0.0529365242,
0.0596156195,
0.0003610937,
-0.0441079512,
0.0470372103,
0.0637719706,
0.0468129069,
0.0420466736,
-0.0475875139,
0.0202292353,
-0.002424875,
0.0124411704,
-0.0345201157,
0.0092097567,
-0.0345644318,
-0.0301881507,
-0.0112323696,
0.0665137395,
-0.0314861909,
-0.0336886644,
0.0188117903,
-0.0893009529,
0.0249498524,
-0.0235389136,
0.0272468198,
0.0276289079,
-0.0484448113,
0.0547182672,
0.025467271,
-0.0388078392,
-0.035527382,
-0.015202485,
-0.0258091781,
0.0389240161,
0.0539512932,
-0.0001814569,
-0.015975425,
-0.0446351431,
-0.0192226991,
0.0423200876,
-0.0671684444,
0.0111784944,
0.0336731561,
-0.0363797657,
-0.0430973694,
0.0628174916,
-0.0039341412,
-0.0249961223,
-0.0239072163,
0.0629616827,
-0.0353585631,
0.0240423158,
-0.0189480707,
0.0139401145,
0.0103657758,
0.0048968941,
0.036809843,
0.0582667179,
0.0159847606,
0.0228299983,
-0.0183506347,
-0.0138361733,
0.0037561073,
-0.0166112054,
-0.0768340603,
0.0185983945,
-0.0090667009,
-0.0003355247,
0.0384599604,
-0.0295306761,
0.0234534852,
0.0773755163,
-0.0481306873,
0.0044342368,
0.0317883678,
-0.0287721753,
0.0140668228,
0.0053627798,
-0.0168164261,
-0.0375554338,
0.0497518107,
0.0283831358,
0.0000265341,
-0.0637975857,
-0.0117745316,
-0.0688480809,
-0.040726997,
0.0723125637,
0.0623245798,
-0.0070946785,
0.0405212194,
-0.0120496349,
0.0136266537,
0.0285919625,
0.0406854637,
0.0003938575,
-0.0127980132,
-0.0434929319,
-0.0293101016,
-0.0397851095,
0.0103069413,
0.0067980485,
0.0462275073,
0.0005152195,
-0.0449433215,
-0.0230716746,
0.0257782415,
-0.0028172953,
0.0320699215,
0.0064195758,
-0.0310685057,
-0.0353497528,
0.0201535858,
-0.0445733592,
-0.0005436909,
0.0717953369,
0.0099332137,
-0.0445461608,
-0.0118905269,
-0.010218922,
-0.0280139744,
0.013582902,
0.0307702702,
-0.0672985539,
0.0202016905,
0.0480149239,
-0.0240605846,
0.0229864474,
0.0363380052,
0.0447102077,
0.0050604772,
0.0230057947,
-0.0487925559,
-0.0191499759,
-0.0409041606,
-0.0418554246,
-0.0375032984,
0.0094076218,
0.0220783819,
0.0306513589,
0.0001717527,
-0.0277758967,
-0.0583220385,
0.0321707539,
-0.0313196369,
-0.0246852934,
-0.0407154262,
0.0102618365,
0.0098917754,
-0.0188093446,
0.0271247439,
-0.0811000019,
0.0799295008,
0.0107521359,
0.0087906644,
-0.0341924354,
-0.0492702834,
-0.0253935661,
0.0437444337,
-0.0363218151,
0.0517826527,
0.0015279873,
-0.0439839438,
-0.0080282679,
0.0508949757,
0.0085413577,
-0.0555124283,
-0.0203400012,
0.0665638447,
-0.0005852912,
0.0149024902,
-0.0393003449,
-0.0269455556,
-0.0821692422,
-0.0423315912,
-0.0068916162,
0.0103873992,
-0.0327961706,
-0.0209505651,
0.0239194445,
-0.0147736138,
-0.0455062725,
-0.0106627243,
-0.0047602262,
-0.0030173832,
-0.0132728526,
-0.0130728604,
-0.0596241131,
0.0007116179,
-0.0167835429,
0.0085608726,
0.0924540684,
0.0514280424,
-0.0498139337,
0.0192257315,
-0.048027616,
0.0456756949,
-0.0042503951,
0.0036247256,
-0.0547016598,
0.011206666,
0.0005137027,
0.0672237948,
0.0648059249,
0.0150567731,
-0.0643860027,
0.0235939827,
0.0130556514,
0.02030777,
-0.0116857169,
0.0124688968,
-0.1244180799,
-0.0021065124,
0.0042471145,
0.0502335876,
-0.0182981789,
-0.0228620432,
-0.00322569,
-0.1112226397,
-0.0042221928,
0.0207740497,
-0.0008787917,
-0.0437370986,
-0.0163644049,
-0.0037273737,
0.0039834068,
0.0085516451,
-0.0557684675,
0.032575082,
-0.0207832176,
0.0219965279,
-0.0245391428,
-0.0491663888,
-0.0179147031,
-0.045362778,
0.0069472953,
-0.0145103252,
0.013843176,
-0.0291473921,
-0.0729611516,
-0.0383545235,
0.0718427971,
-0.0047971928,
-0.0301697329,
0.0515736155,
-0.014802645,
-0.0487843789,
-0.006337041,
0.0168393198,
-0.0329982117,
-0.0015643114,
0.0028938798,
0.0548051484,
-0.0039231302,
-0.0203009471,
-0.0125620551,
-0.0239157807,
0.0432496369,
0.0258704331,
-0.014380618,
-0.0642431378,
-0.015418577,
-0.0154454643,
0.0333525315,
0.0215485357,
-0.0380988866,
0.024931347,
-0.024322506,
-0.0550277792,
-0.0464314856,
-0.0020854494,
-0.0096406909,
0.0420507528,
0.013153621,
-0.0017746282,
0.0473857746,
-0.0183949172,
0.0065291109,
-0.0045770993,
-0.008779536,
0.0629450828,
-0.0477056429,
-0.0142714279,
-0.0168116912,
0.0177662466,
-0.0012476698,
-0.0001936981,
-0.0601553284,
-0.062294662,
0.0476800613,
0.0560726859,
0.011938178,
-0.0211002156,
-0.0402601361,
-0.0716886744,
0.0794514418,
0.0618802123,
-0.0581630841,
-0.0278458651,
0.080727227,
-0.0827827603,
0.0021536541,
0.0348483846,
-0.0288132653,
0.010815342,
0.0073909024,
-0.0310875922,
-0.0472565852,
-0.0179128163,
-0.021564465,
0.0475244485,
0.0543548986,
-0.0104598794,
-0.0096965265,
0.0065505146,
0.0396480374,
-0.0088010095,
-0.0097269425,
-0.0109195849,
0.0058583729,
0.0109167267,
-0.0160753075,
-0.0019473112,
-0.0232516043,
0.0447475277,
-0.0301189143,
0.0013495546,
0.0413256846,
0.0351075977,
0.0087228687,
0.0459984876,
0.0254589431,
-0.0106993876,
0.0198369958,
0.0649535432,
0.038987074,
-0.010544735,
-0.0028230106,
-0.0164316911,
0.0088537578,
-0.0084811542,
0.0532790311,
-0.0096549494,
-0.1092896089,
-0.0119830938,
-0.001156911,
0.0110730417,
0.0129670128,
0.0114016207,
-0.020923499,
0.0251797829,
-0.014977132,
-0.0109463483,
-0.0469131544,
-0.040369574,
0.0004986455,
-0.0458708294,
-0.0055246861,
0.0467468426,
0.0936912969,
-0.0484804772,
0.0390342027,
-0.0091749299,
-0.0321606398,
-0.0420021601,
0.0189705789,
0.0341216438,
0.0305440836,
-0.0330774561,
-0.0119188428,
-0.0076437402,
-0.0869807005,
0.0119128777,
-0.0475640297,
0.0160529725,
0.0195566975,
-0.0024085871,
0.0202227626,
0.0392144695,
0.0814112499,
-0.0691055506,
0.0445510894,
-0.007776727,
-0.0198949724,
0.0187231228,
-6.014287542e-33,
0.0523612536,
-0.0311282352,
-0.0271404814,
-0.0000465316,
0.0158725791,
0.0430881865,
0.0062093958,
0.028839048,
0.016711995,
0.0084217852,
-0.0207439065,
0.0086125033,
0.0151897548,
0.0451455675,
-0.0143448319,
-0.0305846389,
-0.0006041272,
-0.0295711029,
0.0114663485,
0.0323663801,
0.0947370902,
0.0354230367,
0.0544532537,
-0.1210074499,
0.0178347826,
-0.0213354416,
-0.0362621918,
0.0121465856,
-0.0124223726,
0.0516066924,
-0.0115970597,
0.0739164948,
0.0082971985,
-0.0295561999,
-0.0156615935,
0.0194004755,
-0.0054965327,
0.0059229909,
-0.0258959923,
0.0639601126,
-0.0299065392,
-0.0107362242,
0.0532643199,
-0.023473205,
-0.007190547,
-0.0092912512,
0.0072509712,
0.0332694091,
0.0023738877,
-0.0177986212,
0.0045797918,
0.0054603172,
-0.0146547398,
-0.0051496141,
0.0307018682,
0.0691200197,
0.0502615348,
-0.002922144,
-0.051170513,
0.0154623864,
-0.032128159,
-0.0536413863,
0.019749837,
0.0203272887,
-0.0017058828,
0.0505199619,
0.0126930168,
-0.007492885,
-0.0290489309,
0.0024605575,
0.0108467862,
0.0512334667,
0.0328024589,
0.0409611613,
0.011680156,
-0.0813775957,
-0.0305234678,
0.0069162347,
0.0764933452,
-0.0209564958,
0.0167836659,
0.023955714,
-0.0236925427,
-0.0152996881,
-0.0010716477,
-0.0046544555,
-0.0108995298,
-0.0502849445,
-0.0616600551,
-0.007177284,
-0.0512030013,
0.0047779726,
0.0256403778,
-0.064127475,
-0.0573428683,
0.0314097591,
0.0181105789,
0.0250250846,
0.0070040296,
0.0252468009,
-0.009949794,
0.0150838709,
-0.0349686295,
-0.0607532263,
0.0120262699,
0.0256205611,
0.0607377365,
0.0367975794,
-0.0550196581,
-0.0170221236,
0.0053458153,
0.0200148467,
0.0114075951,
0.018307928,
0.0375013724,
0.0185478628,
-0.0165493172,
-0.0353684314,
0.0358383507,
0.0662298575,
-0.0118561313,
0.0158001985,
-0.015230434,
0.0063910638,
0.0047746082,
-0.0286909491,
-0.0371600166,
0.0024000746,
0.0380046107,
-0.0512633435,
0.0164824594,
-0.0334928185,
2.721e-7,
0.0447413959,
0.0113796843,
-0.0091349175,
-0.0226350706,
0.0214796234,
0.0704443008,
0.018364599,
0.0473013222,
0.003146807,
0.0235520881,
-0.0378703699,
-0.0176333878,
0.04627515,
0.0313474312,
-0.0599870943,
-0.0104482407,
-0.0733538046,
0.0529307723,
-0.03761255,
0.0050623459,
-0.0145724192,
0.0907596275,
0.0508805178,
-0.0506192073,
-0.0258332249,
-0.0191524941,
0.0260133445,
-0.0135016749,
-0.0316156298,
-0.023014266,
0.0477945209,
0.0325633176,
0.033074446,
-0.0003738743,
-0.0065410188,
0.0071010948,
0.012383868,
-0.0063056638,
0.0197357647,
0.0518760979,
-0.0061599808,
-0.0340631418,
-0.0377907865,
0.0103292475,
0.0514493808,
-0.0316654705,
-0.0561491586,
-0.037282858,
0.0153845642,
-0.0090685226,
0.0850698799,
-0.0193096083,
-0.0361862853,
0.0480010211,
0.0194991324,
-0.0160291623,
0.0235761199,
-0.051242318,
0.0107824281,
-0.0371290408,
-0.0163902286,
-0.0101171266,
-0.0186663363,
0.0274056587,
0.0110810678,
0.0126352971,
0.0338117778,
2.31014165e-34,
0.0008867765,
-0.0327991508,
-0.0026635013,
0.0288393777,
0.0069830087,
-0.0370744467,
0.0752433315,
-0.0058513363,
0.0053773471,
-0.0009374109,
-0.006137229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17408v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17408v3 | P-Transformer: A Prompt-based Multimodal Transformer Architecture For Medical Tabular Data | 2023-03-30T14:25:44 | 2024-01-09T10:28:00 | Yucheng Ruan, Xiang Lan, Daniel J. Tan, Hairil Rizal Abdullah, Mengling Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Medical tabular data, abundant in Electronic Health Records (EHRs), is a
valuable resource for diverse medical tasks such as risk prediction. While deep
learning approaches, particularly transformer-based models, have shown
remarkable performance in tabular data prediction, there are still problems
remained for existing work to be effectively adapted into medical domain, such
as under-utilization of unstructured free-texts, limited exploration of textual
information in structured data, and data corruption. To address these issues,
we propose P-Transformer, a Prompt-based multimodal Transformer architecture
designed specifically for medical tabular data. This framework consists two
critical components: a tabular cell embedding generator and a tabular
transformer. The former efficiently encodes diverse modalities from both
structured and unstructured tabular data into a harmonized language semantic
space with the help of pre-trained sentence encoder and medical prompts. The
latter integrates cell representations to generate patient embeddings for
various medical tasks. In comprehensive experiments on two real-world datasets
for three medical tasks, P-Transformer demonstrated the improvements with
10.9%/11.0% on RMSE/MAE, 0.5%/2.2% on RMSE/MAE, and 1.6%/0.8% on BACC/AUROC
compared to state-of-the-art (SOTA) baselines in predictability. Notably, the
model exhibited strong resilience to data corruption in the structured data,
particularly when the corruption rates are high. | [
0.003167147,
0.0892112404,
-0.0034609886,
-0.0372921824,
0.0231121443,
0.0045334101,
0.007804269,
0.0005151311,
-0.00190755,
0.0144962538,
-0.0163973905,
-0.0380872637,
0.0124208573,
0.0685405508,
0.0313406512,
-0.0449802615,
0.0358828343,
0.0255673639,
-0.0154745216,
0.0319225229,
-0.0069538597,
-0.0324029773,
-0.014093875,
0.0684259012,
-0.0364425965,
-0.0004608949,
-0.0360357575,
0.0356872901,
-0.0065881298,
-0.0579953082,
0.0066178944,
0.038838584,
0.0132955778,
0.0125983339,
0.0000021474,
0.0042275395,
-0.0297261421,
-0.008171482,
-0.0265999995,
-0.0718868747,
0.0415784009,
-0.0970657095,
-0.0086872727,
-0.0095181242,
-0.0030926138,
-0.070499748,
0.0356496423,
0.0819750205,
0.0801585987,
0.0577035546,
-0.0391971581,
0.0116968397,
0.0596022494,
-0.0148493787,
0.0406100601,
-0.0054304521,
0.0055725523,
-0.0259789899,
-0.0122981314,
-0.0015619298,
-0.0285445936,
0.0512855351,
0.033363156,
0.0003425925,
0.029070653,
0.0337891355,
0.0031140654,
-0.0345099904,
-0.035697028,
0.0792072117,
-0.0350866877,
0.0194901917,
-0.0081132827,
-0.01337591,
0.0243144259,
0.0039147283,
-0.0473183505,
0.0003695834,
-0.0138680413,
-0.0089462046,
-0.0279980879,
0.0200428441,
0.0317765847,
-0.0457000881,
-0.0099828187,
-0.0181363486,
0.0049494617,
-0.024782978,
0.0136493836,
-0.0168185849,
0.0292075425,
-0.0285830237,
0.0261920709,
0.0332948007,
-0.0653374493,
0.0094227204,
-0.058248546,
-0.0501704104,
0.05050027,
-0.0241024699,
0.0650145039,
0.0084994221,
-0.0357248969,
0.0138455313,
-0.041066993,
0.0223855432,
-0.068351835,
0.0662430897,
-0.0034380069,
-0.0085147452,
-0.0224080104,
-0.0204754621,
-0.0134878559,
-0.0184150375,
-0.0223622918,
-0.0212364886,
-0.0347818621,
0.0095272092,
0.0002007336,
0.0279048197,
0.030089261,
0.050332617,
-0.0436881147,
0.0221840125,
-0.048261486,
0.0248238798,
0.0106633063,
-0.0094022341,
0.0045874673,
-0.0624881461,
0.0266152937,
0.0289800577,
0.0155044664,
-0.0198103171,
0.0239429045,
0.0730303377,
-0.0187636074,
-0.0166598819,
-0.0309427772,
-0.0342570655,
-0.0578475259,
0.0057929601,
0.0381707288,
-0.0290871579,
0.0496941097,
-0.0253982879,
0.0049762083,
-0.0535372235,
0.0098787295,
0.0421973802,
-0.0266052354,
0.0794146061,
-0.0226287171,
-0.0232891124,
0.0266819764,
0.0033226262,
0.008659143,
-0.0006445043,
0.0472443439,
0.0221875124,
-0.0198317077,
-0.0265209936,
0.0215069447,
0.0098283216,
0.0059976331,
-0.05901701,
0.0085441796,
-0.0080618439,
0.0100388527,
0.0791795477,
-0.0085689323,
0.0579069629,
0.0060176463,
-0.0239459574,
0.0608920008,
0.0190143697,
0.051432915,
0.0323981196,
0.0152180567,
-0.0393653549,
-0.0176556632,
-0.0238415021,
-0.0247292407,
0.029869562,
0.0635968223,
-0.0171537027,
-0.0199174806,
0.0335482955,
-0.0217499565,
-0.0626758859,
-0.0043627503,
-0.0420381166,
-0.0191424061,
-0.0267878082,
0.0273075532,
0.0178783722,
-0.0768702328,
0.0428977124,
0.0121612521,
-0.0404956974,
-0.0184262469,
-0.0184603706,
-0.0138205662,
0.0881162956,
0.0444413945,
-0.0445151962,
-0.050960999,
-0.0636176318,
-0.0105545549,
0.0167653933,
0.0037667491,
-0.0243886635,
0.0342487395,
-0.0491768606,
-0.024524847,
0.0416203365,
-0.0026352312,
-0.0138218394,
-0.0229672007,
0.0182803981,
-0.0141235786,
-0.0141529152,
-0.0055675209,
0.0488580018,
0.0068295165,
-0.0157943107,
0.0072202054,
0.01718257,
0.0266264211,
0.0094230892,
-0.011226885,
0.0086706029,
0.0516606644,
-0.0333326422,
-0.0238542277,
0.008140563,
-0.1014003828,
-0.019326089,
-0.0064666797,
-0.0318415835,
-0.0137803052,
-0.0034794623,
-0.0347837396,
-0.0141199548,
-0.0476973914,
-0.0502473302,
-0.0209914148,
-0.0207384024,
0.0094156852,
0.0550546162,
0.0400945283,
-0.0571090914,
0.0140248267,
-0.0281360578,
-0.0099587701,
0.0214826837,
-0.023033414,
0.0263960008,
-0.0142334485,
-0.0191566478,
0.0105908858,
-0.0208696667,
0.0092233252,
0.0008165447,
0.0021828436,
-0.017073974,
-0.0261700414,
-0.0997395217,
0.013600477,
0.0105599593,
-0.0063756281,
0.021713363,
0.0207174793,
0.0095091844,
-0.050356295,
-0.051740706,
0.0117768282,
0.0379932933,
0.0057511474,
0.0715468228,
0.0110933557,
0.0279683974,
0.0018222523,
-0.0079965228,
-0.0596093275,
0.0600407682,
-0.0102067832,
-0.0227559097,
-0.0156224733,
-0.0489137582,
-0.0062969378,
0.0188320186,
0.0148813883,
-0.0212683026,
0.0250258017,
0.0011571174,
0.0721113682,
0.0689501762,
-0.0157212131,
0.0668122917,
0.0071978285,
0.0010570106,
-0.0123476349,
0.0155196358,
-0.0361439772,
0.0016039512,
-0.0099721691,
-0.0348711535,
0.0290239491,
0.0645936504,
0.0171878338,
0.0323277079,
-0.0331179574,
-0.0181887392,
0.0192544553,
0.0100072175,
-0.0374101028,
0.0517168939,
-0.0402146839,
0.0315412246,
-0.0133009562,
-0.0244450551,
0.043962948,
-0.0133576691,
0.001444549,
-0.0030770658,
-0.0051625441,
-0.0241298266,
0.0196206085,
0.0279057007,
0.0197687335,
0.0306770746,
-0.0281232782,
-0.0537989289,
0.0380587988,
-0.0216882061,
-0.0298791714,
0.0558074526,
0.0095254974,
-0.0255006272,
-0.0086160414,
-0.0475965291,
-0.0459707081,
-0.04668165,
0.021105852,
0.0036530853,
0.0057045543,
0.0044456222,
-0.0657173693,
-0.0238121469,
-0.0033271445,
0.0895003006,
0.0177444424,
-0.0444555841,
-0.042240303,
0.0852835104,
0.0162867401,
0.0214904025,
-0.0078173801,
-0.0311951563,
0.0079260292,
0.0554706939,
-0.0313743465,
0.0201266203,
-0.0571972281,
0.0109261107,
-0.0178964231,
0.0000967772,
0.0010810691,
0.0440875515,
0.0144030461,
-0.0684293807,
0.0220513698,
0.0685783625,
0.0217535682,
-0.0132073229,
0.0153899789,
0.0124763614,
0.0158888083,
-0.0094383508,
0.013201708,
-0.0763359964,
-0.0352784805,
0.0059184167,
-0.0027953428,
0.0119517576,
-0.0434602611,
0.0232210029,
-0.0219059903,
0.0500490889,
-0.0208997298,
-0.0028724349,
-0.070860453,
-0.0193303637,
-0.0050813537,
-0.0148021355,
0.0141410083,
-0.0072331992,
-0.0052928533,
-0.016539,
0.0063582575,
-0.0538066141,
-0.05077672,
-0.0348651446,
-0.0298627503,
0.0410179012,
0.0684254989,
0.0329606943,
-0.0314911865,
-0.0433732308,
-0.0333624892,
0.0452969596,
0.0116889076,
0.0078297807,
0.1033146977,
0.0074760849,
-0.0155313993,
-0.0378503762,
0.0173091497,
-0.0445965827,
-0.0219256133,
-0.0210668053,
0.099939622,
-0.0346427932,
-0.0055117826,
-0.0371006057,
-0.0091622192,
0.0237406809,
0.0420013629,
0.003098567,
-0.0213794336,
-0.0487212092,
-0.0121392515,
0.0265359543,
-0.0399657078,
0.0179220531,
0.0686655492,
-0.0087840613,
-0.0507056452,
-0.0651591644,
-0.0351303965,
0.0444154963,
0.0036832599,
0.009142423,
-0.0188827887,
0.0070330678,
0.0004357848,
-0.0769060105,
0.0113660619,
0.0111016715,
0.0059815021,
-0.0393609703,
-0.0135865705,
0.0169157851,
-0.0149008874,
-0.0126810651,
0.0030140399,
-0.0292198695,
0.0152539304,
0.0005763611,
0.075446561,
0.0114193102,
-0.0074558584,
0.0243010595,
0.0156133072,
0.0599748977,
0.0480491035,
-0.082390137,
-0.0475482494,
0.0274658278,
-0.0357346125,
-0.008010583,
0.0070814779,
0.0018247999,
0.0026878046,
-0.0185456034,
-0.0148177166,
0.0131757762,
-0.0420546383,
0.0144950589,
-0.0045003253,
0.0563556403,
-0.0109749595,
-0.0191850457,
-0.0243503191,
0.0143126305,
0.0009602841,
0.0157497991,
-0.0237786192,
0.0180936996,
0.0245385654,
0.0205173269,
-0.0096338019,
0.0316550322,
-0.012286894,
0.0187250488,
-0.0603521802,
0.0440870672,
0.0269869659,
-0.0106299687,
0.0284436084,
0.0235305429,
0.0265248418,
0.0342221968,
-0.000561993,
0.023164941,
-0.01159711,
0.0475367494,
-0.0021784145,
0.0027609842,
-0.0039682644,
0.0916512981,
-0.037994843,
-0.0067012389,
-0.0324628167,
0.0236224253,
-0.0093595563,
0.0316907316,
-0.0003005578,
-0.0027662797,
-0.0018945336,
0.0042050104,
0.0309777055,
0.0155372806,
0.0071553872,
0.0612071753,
-0.0136546874,
-0.0036656435,
-0.0513254814,
0.0805039033,
0.0091365781,
0.026541356,
-0.0049089002,
-0.0342357978,
-0.0826992542,
0.0189093258,
0.0533496439,
-0.0056481645,
-0.0483438,
-0.0215885472,
-0.002470545,
-0.0348925479,
0.0758975595,
0.014578158,
-0.0318689607,
-0.0082911942,
0.0295047574,
0.0335665457,
0.0135564571,
-0.0096253073,
-0.0264562592,
0.0251435302,
0.0052834176,
-0.0442139246,
0.0099390624,
-5.859279142e-33,
-0.0063728988,
-0.0136880325,
0.0154450582,
-0.0370618105,
-0.0032526902,
0.0265209563,
-0.0514447987,
-0.0229144786,
0.0203094259,
0.0085945716,
-0.033309266,
-0.0187620446,
0.0127938604,
0.0524105914,
0.0034082704,
-0.0599755384,
0.045879744,
-0.0022374282,
-0.0094518308,
0.0367341042,
-0.0104283541,
0.0683828741,
0.0447604507,
-0.0567218438,
-0.0084652407,
0.0255182013,
-0.0063949036,
-0.0128518827,
0.0127223395,
0.0474085473,
-0.0375378691,
0.0455486178,
0.0395410806,
-0.056125965,
-0.0290165376,
0.0762248933,
-0.115649499,
-0.0128106475,
-0.058032915,
0.0322869346,
-0.0886228755,
-0.0337135084,
0.046971824,
-0.0501333587,
0.0093352394,
-0.0300896969,
0.0369047746,
-0.0236595497,
0.0036957166,
-0.0425114743,
-0.0272137988,
0.0222980287,
-0.0070757228,
-0.0201831162,
0.0220856816,
0.0712051168,
0.0182959288,
0.0421645045,
-0.0599364936,
-0.0215140525,
-0.0168035366,
0.0165968724,
0.0175807234,
-0.013956747,
-0.0275539886,
0.0675784498,
0.0393725969,
-0.0327716954,
-0.0780559927,
0.0195549391,
-0.0220235158,
0.0468757749,
0.0626526102,
0.0582747273,
0.053855598,
-0.0100892717,
-0.0774764568,
0.0749578923,
-0.0214713458,
0.027976945,
0.0062396103,
0.0043374426,
-0.0083396118,
-0.0047632125,
0.0007123838,
-0.0177769139,
0.0007069031,
-0.0260027945,
0.0475205295,
-0.0006099257,
0.0405156463,
0.0439409576,
0.0309368968,
-0.0239552259,
0.0331258066,
-0.0101591498,
0.0255592726,
0.0283178352,
-0.0164804943,
0.0022454902,
-0.0110180052,
-0.0085376557,
0.0557587817,
-0.0057965266,
0.0502971523,
0.0335510001,
0.0477144085,
0.0296565332,
-0.0819183588,
-0.0128485924,
0.0199928042,
0.0126217008,
0.0102600483,
0.0478534549,
0.0169735625,
0.0064898999,
-0.036336951,
0.0616365671,
0.0014502414,
0.0180234332,
-0.0320467539,
-0.0366295278,
0.0071031866,
0.0060238666,
-0.0121735502,
-0.0132415947,
-0.079180494,
0.0127266031,
0.0233740676,
-0.0922072604,
0.0079552755,
0.0122970473,
2.767e-7,
0.0737162307,
0.0442182645,
0.0324576125,
-0.034641847,
0.0330129713,
0.008369334,
0.0127028534,
0.0302027855,
-0.0389330983,
-0.0558037274,
0.0583416149,
-0.0029195847,
0.0369351916,
0.0355237797,
-0.0765614584,
-0.041425515,
-0.0964393243,
-0.0113243703,
-0.0323692486,
0.0076369732,
0.0913809761,
0.1001096368,
-0.0768982992,
-0.0658438504,
0.0429547988,
0.023362143,
0.0337939225,
-0.0291699935,
0.0087778158,
0.0141906375,
0.0224156808,
0.0117938342,
-0.007741434,
0.0586408451,
-0.0151739251,
-0.0324697271,
0.0006738114,
0.0459719077,
-0.0318114534,
-0.003840832,
0.0136365602,
-0.0120726284,
-0.0151215279,
-0.0483616702,
0.0665485114,
-0.0691819638,
-0.0367908627,
0.0080664586,
-0.0303253457,
0.028916467,
0.0786688775,
-0.0179064572,
-0.0490088798,
0.0152190691,
0.0412321761,
0.0111387391,
-0.0166135821,
-0.0505751409,
-0.0234818049,
0.0138194244,
-0.0268314239,
-0.0015593983,
-0.0230315942,
-0.0702281445,
0.0161492452,
-0.0856791958,
-0.0079760831,
2.901343677e-34,
0.0182062667,
0.0045782235,
0.0406137928,
-0.0074634454,
0.0313756354,
-0.0358555056,
0.0708053783,
-0.0061952001,
0.0004803954,
-0.0658802614,
-0.0454454944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17395v1 | WavCaps: A ChatGPT-Assisted Weakly-Labelled Audio Captioning Dataset for Audio-Language Multimodal Research | 2023-03-30T14:07:47 | 2023-03-30T14:07:47 | Xinhao Mei, Chutong Meng, Haohe Liu, Qiuqiang Kong, Tom Ko, Chengqi Zhao, Mark D. Plumbley, Yuexian Zou, Wenwu Wang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | The advancement of audio-language (AL) multimodal learning tasks has been
significant in recent years. However, researchers face challenges due to the
costly and time-consuming collection process of existing audio-language
datasets, which are limited in size. To address this data scarcity issue, we
introduce WavCaps, the first large-scale weakly-labelled audio captioning
dataset, comprising approximately 400k audio clips with paired captions. We
sourced audio clips and their raw descriptions from web sources and a sound
event detection dataset. However, the online-harvested raw descriptions are
highly noisy and unsuitable for direct use in tasks such as automated audio
captioning. To overcome this issue, we propose a three-stage processing
pipeline for filtering noisy data and generating high-quality captions, where
ChatGPT, a large language model, is leveraged to filter and transform raw
descriptions automatically. We conduct a comprehensive analysis of the
characteristics of WavCaps dataset and evaluate it on multiple downstream
audio-language multimodal learning tasks. The systems trained on WavCaps
outperform previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) models by a significant margin. Our
aspiration is for the WavCaps dataset we have proposed to facilitate research
in audio-language multimodal learning and demonstrate the potential of
utilizing ChatGPT to enhance academic research. Our dataset and codes are
available at https://github.com/XinhaoMei/WavCaps. | [
0.0057240836,
0.0383510701,
-0.0066317208,
0.0412494987,
-0.0060378355,
0.0096255476,
0.0172216184,
-0.0485460423,
-0.0194450002,
-0.0534254424,
-0.098885946,
-0.0297289509,
0.0151880523,
0.0388165563,
0.0353705809,
-0.0734863281,
0.0340883806,
-0.0523980521,
0.0097619463,
0.0032626295,
-0.0011264327,
0.0275034998,
-0.0669515431,
0.0471095517,
-0.0195338242,
-0.0076149893,
0.0136996899,
0.0094951009,
-0.0083508166,
-0.0418428853,
0.0034161212,
0.0279365201,
0.0409234837,
0.0324880742,
0.0000016869,
0.0036098605,
0.0174438339,
0.0038454458,
0.0613496602,
-0.0097052054,
0.0309201926,
-0.0241020937,
-0.0258617084,
0.0119463019,
0.0015449105,
-0.0505027324,
0.0731232315,
0.0073014782,
0.0776365623,
0.033181373,
-0.0286959428,
-0.0470102094,
-0.0098752063,
-0.0412639976,
-0.00565742,
-0.0117673585,
-0.0136233279,
0.0395291634,
0.0233271718,
0.0098908786,
-0.0373214856,
0.0765847191,
-0.0256055817,
-0.0142864231,
-0.0011344827,
0.0374417305,
-0.079670012,
-0.0500580482,
-0.0112750391,
0.1189117432,
0.0392963439,
0.0285465494,
-0.0077606109,
0.0313338153,
-0.0032059066,
-0.0308315419,
-0.0708533525,
0.0423576385,
0.0111686634,
-0.0021107767,
-0.07489568,
0.0347234532,
0.0348490216,
-0.0289682001,
0.0437171161,
-0.0229772422,
0.0212995,
-0.0031320909,
0.0149802472,
-0.0432449393,
-0.0435523614,
-0.0159160588,
0.026614612,
-0.0131971939,
-0.0136753488,
-0.0152391959,
-0.0401734337,
-0.0028453199,
-0.0038268014,
-0.0182241835,
0.0042904872,
-0.0030135368,
-0.0899256691,
0.095221214,
-0.0213087909,
-0.0088776788,
0.0101515325,
0.034651611,
-0.0275291894,
-0.0124447243,
-0.0586785227,
-0.012382512,
-0.0448089615,
-0.0006812516,
-0.0112461885,
-0.0419852436,
-0.0189260859,
-0.0357983522,
-0.0445495583,
0.0424237661,
-0.0343575962,
0.0067255013,
-0.0215716977,
0.0135487709,
0.0290950127,
0.0767120868,
0.0117954351,
0.0478966236,
-0.0213625878,
-0.0243085753,
-0.0142553058,
0.0321178697,
0.0352225266,
-0.0135709634,
0.0295414813,
0.1101002991,
-0.0232668128,
-0.0451650769,
-0.0022895441,
-0.0240230653,
-0.0420496352,
-0.0155112473,
0.007451802,
-0.0198737215,
0.0712838173,
-0.0344900414,
0.0096217142,
-0.0255771149,
0.0035494538,
0.0202875976,
0.0188775118,
0.1077795029,
-0.0316768885,
0.0325623639,
0.0181855615,
0.0231731795,
-0.0496084765,
0.0490710922,
0.0909506753,
0.0061138282,
0.0709184036,
-0.0386483371,
-0.0004877006,
0.0469352193,
0.0039852979,
0.024218617,
-0.0190224405,
-0.0470323041,
0.0227484982,
0.0369686335,
0.0472220145,
0.0414775498,
-0.0099661937,
0.0012129518,
0.0789173394,
0.0110802865,
-0.019740941,
0.0024767185,
0.0342560038,
-0.0030746965,
0.0051209172,
-0.0182451364,
-0.0020491108,
0.0562054217,
0.0257408563,
0.0133023616,
0.0552113242,
0.0259267781,
-0.0189360008,
0.0010261176,
-0.0173991751,
-0.0338506922,
0.0007410187,
-0.0045082155,
0.0191257354,
0.0369519331,
-0.0441630296,
0.045761317,
0.0258850455,
-0.0431657434,
0.0075044907,
-0.0350355767,
-0.0118864449,
0.0332525149,
0.0324088335,
-0.0439351909,
-0.0346169434,
-0.0530851111,
0.0636225566,
0.0388604589,
0.0359392539,
-0.0298306458,
0.0451911911,
-0.0494524613,
-0.0448151529,
-0.0203421488,
-0.0108586065,
0.0229257978,
-0.0095640831,
-0.0035107841,
0.0155176939,
-0.0314450189,
-0.0355462842,
0.0081518907,
0.0285693705,
-0.040506985,
-0.0018257227,
0.0092128515,
0.0311944801,
0.0316399522,
-0.0320713408,
0.0060802228,
-0.00350329,
-0.0189795494,
0.0132616581,
0.05325431,
-0.0504110754,
-0.0437227376,
0.0290205777,
-0.0513091572,
0.0026002058,
0.0314313211,
-0.0221206099,
-0.0398065634,
0.0278800242,
-0.0363408774,
-0.0056144064,
-0.0140152089,
-0.0197511408,
0.0244330708,
0.0271887369,
0.0172573421,
-0.0063038343,
0.035986837,
-0.0183469448,
0.0203544013,
0.0260750931,
0.0180954486,
-0.0034887737,
-0.0591528565,
0.0569114611,
-0.017140707,
-0.0051316563,
0.0046253609,
0.0096023846,
-0.0446896069,
-0.0033584081,
-0.085738048,
0.0074767908,
0.0048161647,
-0.0305943638,
-0.0068928958,
-0.0148261441,
0.0093116369,
-0.0402996726,
-0.0232557412,
-0.021720821,
0.0048664105,
0.0245160274,
-0.0282080527,
0.0211253855,
-0.0367217064,
-0.0348347314,
0.0101293679,
0.0078757312,
0.0311733596,
-0.0065961122,
-0.0145137766,
-0.0201814063,
-0.0162887909,
-0.0330115035,
-0.0006708669,
-0.0002485609,
-0.0080659995,
0.0046863677,
0.0084420154,
0.0308025647,
0.0016844617,
0.0000391624,
0.016712347,
0.0648606569,
-0.0279432237,
-0.0009124393,
0.0216427837,
0.0166034736,
-0.0455838926,
-0.0004369163,
0.0006428579,
-0.0357802734,
0.0416196883,
0.0411230214,
0.0290474389,
-0.0463934802,
-0.0164926089,
-0.0315738432,
-0.0191585179,
-0.0466119461,
-0.0032389637,
-0.0483844951,
-0.0042385026,
-0.0242293105,
-0.030280713,
0.0300845727,
-0.0471801199,
-0.070791848,
-0.0444021747,
-0.0245202463,
-0.0167012084,
0.0916345492,
-0.029856516,
0.0444584191,
0.0007213719,
-0.0285856184,
-0.0238447096,
-0.0070747752,
0.0367535651,
-0.0251242612,
-0.0022912195,
-0.0410602465,
-0.0091338195,
-0.0238757841,
-0.0295548607,
0.0083175935,
-0.0236413945,
-0.0161770564,
-0.020662725,
-0.0375099555,
-0.0013704738,
-0.0234043598,
0.0426119566,
0.06236884,
0.0488278046,
-0.0019794167,
0.0068389075,
-0.0154793588,
0.0282137506,
0.0456677936,
0.0266869906,
-0.0656434968,
-0.0229941867,
0.0193588883,
-0.0040944829,
0.0312896967,
-0.0073968624,
-0.0337072089,
0.0272337962,
0.0194411892,
0.0395885333,
-0.0193803404,
0.0157995801,
0.0384804532,
-0.0184728447,
0.0119261248,
0.086600408,
-0.0072210762,
-0.0585721061,
0.0060719093,
0.0550012365,
0.0175508875,
0.0406225808,
-0.0364467278,
-0.0621463172,
-0.0705401003,
0.0164565649,
0.048589278,
0.0748488829,
0.0252660941,
-0.044209227,
-0.0546313152,
0.0430536233,
0.0316198617,
-0.0864918083,
-0.0380186103,
-0.0411670543,
-0.007410964,
-0.0176954027,
0.0246139951,
-0.0185225066,
-0.0195860211,
0.0097825313,
0.0259628817,
-0.0075349733,
-0.0652667433,
0.0318604819,
-0.0521259829,
0.0673619732,
0.0587398596,
0.0590690747,
-0.0335691981,
-0.0084551293,
0.0225775279,
0.0136982882,
-0.0323507451,
0.0331950635,
0.0497586727,
-0.0050079068,
-0.0477273129,
0.0425199047,
0.0447902344,
-0.0214982964,
-0.0284142923,
0.0240163896,
0.0371010043,
0.0129333213,
0.0272246394,
-0.020136809,
0.0726953149,
0.0125547173,
0.0683967248,
0.0289050955,
-0.02902456,
0.055438526,
0.0154561484,
0.0050693844,
-0.0518835746,
-0.0166903362,
0.0181578472,
-0.0299064908,
-0.0116592543,
-0.0602418818,
-0.0248366669,
0.035300944,
-0.0087640816,
0.0379088186,
0.0112718483,
-0.0057162917,
0.0392958559,
-0.051919248,
0.0668792278,
-0.0328911245,
0.0287649035,
-0.0355589315,
-0.0611969009,
0.0622833036,
-0.01759753,
-0.0109719029,
0.0721681342,
-0.0570165813,
-0.0261306223,
-0.0076862518,
0.0178890005,
0.0097243758,
0.0255273599,
0.0292226262,
-0.0130189173,
-0.0084998999,
0.0393111967,
-0.0231926348,
0.0303743891,
0.0239988193,
0.0061921845,
-0.028769901,
-0.0011202282,
-0.0770684704,
0.0367037915,
-0.0384801403,
0.0556686223,
0.054659199,
-0.0313912295,
-0.0079262545,
0.0006480609,
0.0498030484,
-0.0597936884,
0.0171386823,
-0.0527895577,
-0.0207676943,
0.0228184033,
-0.0020933107,
-0.0561620742,
0.0330243595,
0.0353224464,
0.0244444907,
-0.0366544239,
0.0022011837,
0.0159252528,
0.0056312894,
-0.0145674767,
0.0335298777,
0.0276184417,
-0.0745243505,
-0.0020381941,
0.0070544817,
0.0092824679,
0.0276153255,
-0.0027039899,
-0.0115664043,
0.003148179,
0.0352143869,
0.0081161056,
-0.0248183161,
0.0090201432,
0.0640367791,
-0.0080739874,
0.0233784243,
-0.0215676334,
0.0023427126,
0.0635571629,
0.0026570861,
0.0570715591,
-0.0040868535,
0.0031388551,
0.0062760017,
0.0602983236,
-0.0266039222,
-0.0323695652,
0.0428321846,
-0.0059459591,
0.0020967287,
0.0302507877,
0.0776569098,
-0.0398952663,
0.0591497496,
-0.0004112713,
0.0048748092,
-0.0374996625,
-0.0229762811,
-0.0049655242,
0.0144040836,
-0.018697802,
0.0111116525,
0.0097159464,
-0.0592257231,
-0.0180268753,
-0.0300500263,
0.0023948476,
0.019194562,
0.0480086729,
0.026565386,
0.0003385776,
0.0149517749,
0.0096669672,
-0.0438208394,
0.0118457209,
0.0153689357,
0.0079318387,
-4.909341954e-33,
-0.0456077158,
-0.0076369015,
-0.0201002993,
-0.015109322,
-0.0376099609,
-0.0055400627,
-0.0356413834,
0.0223339032,
0.0258003976,
-0.0012846264,
0.0589764491,
-0.0236172769,
0.0065488783,
0.0401425138,
0.0293909144,
-0.0169761386,
0.054483071,
-0.0321897082,
-0.0083296262,
0.0450122952,
0.0408333614,
0.0324363634,
0.0629602224,
-0.0814662203,
-0.00040331,
0.010286456,
-0.047976207,
-0.0073354654,
0.0330307186,
0.0624757446,
-0.0307599492,
0.0440492369,
-0.0134977847,
-0.0096138883,
-0.009907295,
0.0040583778,
-0.0668691471,
0.0239329599,
0.0257126912,
0.0594626963,
-0.0109465811,
-0.0086619034,
0.0184360947,
-0.0385139771,
0.0078871632,
-0.0194039345,
0.0538355708,
-0.0454097018,
0.0118935741,
-0.0425197408,
-0.0674580038,
-0.0026873916,
-0.0464927815,
-0.0510592237,
0.0277056582,
0.056316115,
0.0103394901,
0.0025811538,
-0.0362605378,
0.043757543,
-0.0208577644,
0.0204591546,
0.0644139647,
0.02711205,
-0.0230180621,
0.0661447346,
0.0207675118,
-0.0627266169,
0.0170687456,
0.0101412088,
0.0382020213,
0.038124945,
0.0137390904,
0.0349940434,
0.0157799907,
0.0254556835,
-0.0189996362,
0.0207372829,
-0.0551000983,
-0.0034557285,
0.0240222104,
0.0511515476,
-0.0231634248,
0.007491556,
-0.0567514375,
0.0033089994,
-0.0356080644,
-0.0374915302,
0.0506576113,
-0.0036571531,
-0.0142077357,
0.0072078672,
0.0601840764,
-0.0242475048,
-0.0034564943,
-0.0145531548,
-0.0443457402,
0.0279803853,
-0.0269562509,
-0.0136483135,
-0.0059794858,
-0.0374703929,
0.1036611199,
-0.0070179584,
0.0654029548,
-0.0133644883,
0.0332019739,
0.0944522098,
-0.052213829,
0.0119003942,
-0.0087685948,
0.0124525176,
-0.0081434529,
0.0224918928,
0.0312244706,
0.0122158844,
-0.0774123371,
0.0157261435,
-0.0028967715,
0.0312918425,
-0.0303397235,
-0.0723441765,
-0.0498742238,
0.0243035518,
-0.0271619242,
0.0398523323,
-0.0323340371,
-0.062000338,
0.0047423644,
-0.0669879168,
-0.0411379375,
-0.0030434402,
2.481e-7,
-0.0174196418,
0.0191546623,
-0.0070188036,
0.0133407963,
0.0387883745,
0.0298506599,
-0.0693813711,
0.021803081,
-0.0207983945,
-0.0257961638,
0.018654624,
-0.004344767,
0.0607622117,
0.0237071346,
-0.083619073,
-0.0320420489,
-0.0745462775,
0.0025430173,
-0.0428204015,
-0.0168843232,
0.0756400377,
0.0976199806,
0.0013502117,
-0.0339517184,
0.0030653113,
-0.0756142884,
0.0574668646,
-0.022741396,
-0.0074298717,
-0.0343949273,
0.0423777923,
0.0293219667,
-0.0406836942,
-0.0062782578,
-0.0424414352,
-0.0358790271,
0.0750165656,
0.0313723646,
0.0106348116,
-0.0351868458,
-0.0107297609,
0.0770443156,
-0.0144215506,
0.0022915949,
0.0796573237,
-0.0478814878,
-0.0514544435,
-0.034195397,
-0.0282451492,
-0.0107128937,
-0.0063868896,
-0.0643395782,
-0.0332384631,
-0.0100162718,
0.0285509117,
0.0124477437,
-0.0489910096,
-0.0649531037,
-0.0254307203,
0.0344585218,
-0.0376554579,
-0.0312300995,
-0.032937184,
-0.0278493259,
-0.0033573431,
-0.05438447,
-0.0070904498,
1.844949633e-34,
0.035525158,
-0.0558115467,
0.0096022505,
-0.0313995071,
0.0021505945,
0.0000234512,
0.0206238236,
0.0036149547,
-0.030121699,
-0.0086026313,
-0.019288091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17367v1 | A BERT-based Unsupervised Grammatical Error Correction Framework | 2023-03-30T13:29:49 | 2023-03-30T13:29:49 | Nankai Lin, Hongbin Zhang, Menglan Shen, Yu Wang, Shengyi Jiang, Aimin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction (GEC) is a challenging task of natural language
processing techniques. While more attempts are being made in this approach for
universal languages like English or Chinese, relatively little work has been
done for low-resource languages for the lack of large annotated corpora. In
low-resource languages, the current unsupervised GEC based on language model
scoring performs well. However, the pre-trained language model is still to be
explored in this context. This study proposes a BERT-based unsupervised GEC
framework, where GEC is viewed as multi-class classification task. The
framework contains three modules: data flow construction module, sentence
perplexity scoring module, and error detecting and correcting module. We
propose a novel scoring method for pseudo-perplexity to evaluate a sentence's
probable correctness and construct a Tagalog corpus for Tagalog GEC research.
It obtains competitive performance on the Tagalog corpus we construct and
open-source Indonesian corpus and it demonstrates that our framework is
complementary to baseline method for low-resource GEC task. | [
0.0856770724,
0.0409567989,
-0.0027263314,
0.0217621457,
-0.030143816,
0.0474177636,
-0.0260899719,
-0.0084457947,
0.0150499512,
-0.0678265318,
-0.0125946403,
-0.025425585,
0.0216999706,
-0.0431134403,
0.0137150465,
-0.0626233667,
0.0616561286,
0.018458413,
0.0277122296,
0.0074108513,
0.0071034203,
-0.0024673666,
-0.0322735719,
0.0194018446,
-0.0377308987,
-0.0211537722,
0.0016469263,
0.0651192516,
0.0166347157,
-0.0273715537,
0.0541456379,
0.0726271495,
-0.0386651121,
0.0692489147,
0.0000016849,
-0.0493611805,
-0.0107982606,
-0.0045926603,
-0.0040284893,
0.0497005619,
-0.0058132447,
0.0392196849,
-0.0450687334,
0.0145563036,
-0.0014891109,
-0.0236654673,
0.0676447302,
0.0801801011,
0.0757455453,
0.087757431,
-0.0159527566,
-0.0272764452,
0.0167000853,
0.0061566727,
-0.0092170117,
0.0082054678,
0.0227931328,
0.0336530544,
-0.0294651315,
-0.018319536,
-0.0216787159,
0.0067068604,
-0.0175517239,
-0.0551151857,
-0.013245143,
-0.0250747316,
-0.0675256103,
-0.0291769337,
-0.0191289932,
0.0122909043,
-0.0048445095,
-0.0551095754,
-0.0235744417,
0.0304670837,
0.022606235,
0.0137441456,
0.0179290511,
-0.0159313399,
0.0043312646,
0.0270849578,
0.0735935122,
-0.0688203573,
0.01366942,
0.0194852427,
-0.0025408338,
0.042888917,
0.0405810513,
-0.057512071,
-0.045678325,
0.0412732139,
-0.0659326166,
-0.0596684404,
0.0553336367,
0.0023631044,
-0.0118378839,
-0.0130610373,
-0.0362716354,
-0.0633763298,
0.0101441583,
-0.0610151403,
0.0351516195,
0.010866371,
-0.0396449938,
0.0291539524,
-0.0168073997,
0.0494384132,
0.0213737339,
0.0265512634,
-0.0276809745,
0.0130236736,
-0.0601915158,
-0.0087317377,
-0.0693682209,
0.0448217914,
-0.0154552022,
0.0345875099,
-0.0524147898,
-0.0000813021,
-0.0059703756,
0.0247010607,
0.0307031777,
-0.022511147,
-0.0477611832,
-0.023475796,
0.0015686036,
0.0215621796,
0.0158741921,
0.0362447202,
-0.0119608482,
-0.0511789545,
0.0032527894,
0.029753983,
0.0254197009,
-0.0116762891,
0.0190535262,
-0.0367482938,
-0.0065325964,
-0.027359806,
-0.0503272526,
0.032781098,
-0.0269691497,
-0.053444203,
-0.0557598136,
-0.0496774465,
-0.0168746356,
-0.013185082,
0.0249390397,
0.0402647741,
0.0308338962,
-0.0140650431,
0.0028686235,
0.0525962114,
-0.0526587144,
0.0092315013,
0.0350462683,
-0.0267147794,
0.0746641755,
0.0222333465,
0.035260424,
-0.0766183436,
0.0619887225,
0.011871459,
0.0237089824,
0.0011431683,
-0.0476198308,
-0.020332342,
0.0226120651,
-0.0162870008,
-0.0144238397,
0.0105715683,
0.0197917446,
0.0502704903,
-0.0166183896,
0.0770955533,
0.0185523853,
0.0176045671,
-0.0046162545,
0.0301528201,
0.0067979707,
-0.0440211035,
0.0253636278,
0.0566650853,
-0.0163668208,
-0.0221533719,
-0.0489075594,
-0.0031030113,
0.021204818,
0.0032776275,
-0.0444181897,
-0.0516665019,
-0.0063954541,
-0.0112463208,
0.0191871636,
-0.0490014106,
0.0622353517,
0.0211265907,
-0.0219746009,
0.0524475053,
-0.0011949897,
-0.0822089985,
0.0060885004,
-0.0456296243,
-0.0177116115,
0.046213232,
0.0739517137,
-0.0188864879,
-0.0454650149,
-0.0020250136,
-0.0403683111,
0.0505715832,
0.0439702794,
-0.0228367858,
-0.0102654686,
-0.0432984494,
0.0047567836,
0.0221958514,
0.0339812115,
-0.0116110081,
-0.0015426828,
0.0079613589,
0.0067489725,
-0.0619466379,
-0.0309282877,
0.0425913744,
0.0273775496,
0.0026300012,
-0.0059698047,
-0.0045188391,
0.0513301305,
0.0328057818,
-0.0437372327,
0.0076213027,
-0.0212050956,
-0.0241060313,
-0.0260703452,
-0.005917416,
-0.001576183,
-0.101521112,
0.0352855064,
-0.0315381847,
-0.0399761721,
0.0561056957,
-0.0293780994,
-0.0581106059,
-0.0038422456,
-0.0481252782,
0.0501311086,
-0.1038355157,
0.0780662969,
-0.031548623,
-0.0192319937,
-0.0363179632,
0.020775523,
0.0217750464,
0.0636264533,
-0.0281708427,
-0.0076256678,
0.0482730083,
-0.0260325037,
-0.0550579503,
-0.0023860512,
0.0122466246,
0.0154437888,
0.0259801932,
0.0341755264,
-0.0207928456,
-0.0353690684,
-0.1180931553,
-0.0212257318,
-0.0375050604,
0.0617910437,
0.0499836691,
0.0101160426,
-0.01300555,
-0.0348294899,
0.0362625085,
-0.006148132,
0.0337322913,
-0.0239749905,
0.0676414445,
-0.0231816992,
-0.0166709963,
-0.0287653357,
0.0107562877,
-0.0143650547,
0.0041016256,
0.0436976179,
-0.0708872303,
-0.0889661759,
0.0342763029,
-0.0407867767,
0.0332445465,
0.0856661126,
-0.0967783481,
-0.011442584,
0.0201920196,
0.0610122271,
-0.0133477785,
-0.0112459408,
-0.0123559833,
-0.0020584757,
-0.0249607787,
0.018490335,
-0.0010578211,
-0.0042943996,
-0.0085189929,
-0.0153652243,
0.0105989287,
0.0110877706,
0.0514131151,
0.0037696839,
-0.04398546,
-0.0016219426,
-0.0297043324,
-0.0104589881,
0.0107388096,
0.0258797426,
-0.0171020143,
0.0079141036,
0.028656384,
-0.0282421075,
-0.0141604366,
0.0808618069,
0.0081491619,
-0.0160594638,
-0.0872936025,
0.0499622226,
-0.0071605626,
0.0028152352,
0.0051916083,
0.0387642011,
-0.033026278,
-0.077960588,
-0.0285544358,
-0.0000981455,
0.0362749659,
-0.0071278843,
0.0113163637,
-0.0691286549,
0.0257995855,
0.0241465308,
-0.0469693244,
-0.0153523106,
-0.0273150876,
-0.001187369,
-0.0128109213,
0.0163933039,
-0.0082621537,
-0.0273886193,
0.0062803407,
-0.0131397406,
0.0275579803,
0.008450008,
-0.0109419366,
0.0093790488,
0.0706472769,
-0.0451932661,
-0.0051523056,
0.0067189839,
0.0004303346,
0.010471982,
0.0545111671,
-0.0074961707,
0.0416341648,
-0.0032959499,
0.0049780631,
0.0370542109,
-0.0438775793,
-0.0508819297,
-0.0323538184,
0.036741931,
-0.0395096652,
-0.0432688743,
0.1152519733,
0.0674232021,
-0.0075087659,
-0.0236841124,
-0.0305204615,
-0.0194633622,
-0.0084664943,
0.0438356474,
-0.0372267738,
0.0091885412,
0.0442571789,
-0.0080762403,
-0.0285761952,
0.0151592772,
0.0308148265,
-0.1187117919,
0.076197885,
0.0331129208,
0.0251707286,
-0.0631546825,
-0.0333170444,
0.0202895328,
0.033986032,
-0.0025963197,
0.0411587507,
0.0319221839,
-0.0058459016,
0.0225463323,
-0.0720616728,
-0.0882612765,
-0.0209505875,
-0.0414329544,
0.0394845381,
0.0851564631,
0.0269660447,
-0.0242888108,
-0.0282392856,
0.0371906273,
-0.0325856097,
-0.0417674333,
0.0038123524,
0.0353794321,
0.0140275927,
-0.0382555649,
-0.0596795715,
0.0219355691,
-0.0339171365,
-0.0117612472,
-0.0247406065,
0.0792166367,
-0.0414641239,
0.0233347621,
0.0284856074,
-0.0196792148,
0.0150177833,
0.0185409766,
0.0073826308,
-0.0398733616,
-0.0394097678,
-0.0335199684,
0.0287494268,
-0.0559206605,
0.0675892979,
0.0631729737,
-0.0339318514,
-0.0440554172,
-0.0573423877,
-0.0414874814,
0.002147642,
0.0042261262,
0.0419264846,
-0.0222747829,
0.0047063301,
0.0056393617,
-0.0040018652,
-0.0492345393,
0.0165262409,
-0.0023346159,
-0.0583914518,
-0.0275335535,
-0.0052863173,
0.0535512827,
0.0122471834,
-0.0389596485,
-0.0099213896,
-0.0281260815,
0.0337659009,
0.0143351657,
0.0045401868,
-0.0050243977,
-0.0308717657,
-0.0360163674,
-0.0090815108,
0.0628618002,
0.0022343353,
0.0387123004,
0.0183580089,
-0.0169064403,
-0.0044077463,
0.0303288959,
0.0076629422,
-0.0081610074,
0.0122326398,
0.0718925223,
-0.0292665903,
-0.0067015411,
0.0474935658,
0.0387884639,
0.0587015711,
-0.0191947296,
0.0509886444,
-0.0773750916,
0.0249525011,
-0.0108874599,
-0.0277080387,
-0.0263882112,
0.005286443,
0.0536068417,
-0.024957329,
-0.025110295,
0.0337547697,
-0.087251693,
0.0096628675,
-0.0051095067,
0.0258440375,
0.013437367,
0.0256674364,
-0.0277164597,
-0.0014675196,
-0.0168332309,
-0.0369111449,
0.0359828398,
0.0100189187,
-0.0144462781,
0.0518040322,
0.0237571932,
0.0062226118,
0.0138204535,
0.0090491753,
-0.0115933884,
0.0794110298,
-0.0419665091,
0.0336773023,
0.1112753972,
0.0037894214,
0.0534706078,
-0.0357755311,
-0.0231480747,
-0.0416869968,
0.0279504657,
0.0076681697,
-0.0085348096,
-0.0062994277,
-0.0092778746,
0.0008061805,
0.0023085477,
0.0554581024,
-0.0168365464,
0.034058746,
0.0223999079,
-0.0304012988,
-0.0168164652,
-0.0136340838,
0.0369592123,
-0.021167133,
-0.030481562,
-0.0042603328,
-0.0004435244,
-0.0566076823,
-0.0112709282,
0.0550006963,
0.0110720759,
0.0040795226,
-0.0148671987,
0.0662063956,
-0.0171109643,
-0.0192489792,
-0.0521778055,
-0.0254805535,
0.0123570506,
0.0281173419,
-0.0241340213,
-5.457289829e-33,
-0.0491893068,
-0.0122096948,
-0.0638058856,
-0.0110758403,
0.007186966,
-0.0351208076,
-0.0329033844,
0.0006810152,
0.0394351333,
0.0611384436,
-0.0156990979,
0.0403100252,
0.0091760512,
0.0135369161,
0.0507800169,
0.023337163,
0.0630644262,
0.0049036811,
0.0096652834,
-0.0375609212,
0.0097514046,
0.0505495146,
0.1029262319,
-0.0655715689,
0.0387257487,
-0.0134851458,
-0.0357305445,
0.0271354225,
0.030981712,
0.016832618,
0.0195297413,
0.0229416527,
0.0087873628,
0.0486124493,
-0.0266792662,
-0.0211110786,
-0.0599860847,
-0.045024436,
-0.0029302542,
0.0666755065,
-0.0014874404,
0.0004020736,
0.0089405505,
-0.0352395773,
-0.0081206206,
0.0465324149,
0.0106929755,
-0.0612637326,
0.0366925709,
0.0083991205,
-0.0300042666,
0.019097399,
-0.016540017,
-0.0179235451,
-0.0139921131,
0.0189207196,
-0.0459964201,
-0.0296570975,
-0.0358663648,
0.0056568044,
0.029492626,
0.0229944345,
-0.0091319382,
-0.0052246717,
-0.0332222059,
0.0220812038,
0.0255273432,
-0.0103611443,
0.0088677183,
0.0009817743,
0.0121981474,
0.0100845564,
0.0143787088,
0.0238848235,
0.0187296644,
-0.0198765993,
-0.0551124625,
0.0151754357,
-0.0328279994,
0.018371556,
-0.0191641618,
-0.0133500369,
-0.0419866666,
-0.0362828076,
0.0137537224,
-0.0440071933,
-0.0183805265,
-0.0086210398,
0.012017834,
-0.0126068285,
-0.0079038907,
0.0003954485,
-0.0096740527,
-0.0367872752,
-0.0293014143,
-0.0521620922,
0.0023670085,
0.0395893678,
-0.0227182843,
0.037605606,
-0.0147246774,
-0.0398945138,
0.0014675544,
0.0324621573,
-0.0132685229,
-0.012924009,
0.0386733226,
0.0277259741,
-0.076033406,
0.025682833,
0.0046979417,
-0.0265384596,
-0.0082754809,
0.0278198477,
-0.0251135193,
-0.0106750159,
0.0152049623,
0.0154927913,
0.0346518904,
0.0275450386,
-0.018861251,
-0.0028567067,
-0.0223684739,
0.0195984542,
0.0084293885,
-0.0177137833,
-0.0236225408,
0.0127668874,
-0.0257375818,
-0.0318600498,
0.0150427278,
-0.0115778595,
2.492e-7,
0.0454218201,
0.0662183985,
0.0347257629,
-0.0423454829,
-0.0056589399,
0.0028626597,
-0.0323014259,
0.0151169458,
-0.0064724213,
0.0573760606,
0.0511969551,
-0.0220207907,
0.0378026515,
0.0031570201,
-0.0450861827,
-0.002323285,
-0.0172817502,
-0.0083252098,
-0.0101922676,
-0.0117622418,
0.0489696041,
0.0389065854,
0.0325181857,
-0.0088422438,
-0.0125305206,
-0.0536623672,
0.0600684583,
0.0076410929,
-0.0665932372,
0.055408556,
0.0655697286,
0.0555829406,
0.0453197137,
0.0439871848,
-0.0194624942,
-0.0053381417,
0.0317369327,
0.0391967557,
-0.0316209085,
0.0299927685,
-0.0056991451,
0.0341370106,
-0.0153196864,
-0.0503229052,
0.0170816127,
-0.0080134152,
0.0006393915,
0.040690735,
-0.0415317491,
-0.0021190338,
0.0341204852,
-0.0202942882,
-0.0680637285,
0.0300221406,
0.0477286875,
0.0096520865,
-0.034119945,
-0.0076348893,
-0.000226367,
0.0139618302,
-0.0126509108,
-0.0396508276,
0.0459571406,
0.0087291179,
0.043476291,
-0.0404942706,
0.0138175813,
2.213862464e-34,
0.0790499449,
-0.0215668753,
0.0163464136,
-0.0141538465,
0.018095566,
-0.0263391528,
0.0216516741,
-0.0016289483,
-0.026522683,
-0.0249037258,
-0.0005154378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18062v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18062v2 | Solving morphological analogies: from retrieval to generation | 2023-03-30T12:36:46 | 2024-04-17T15:23:12 | Esteban Marquer, Miguel Couceiro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Analogical inference is a remarkable capability of human reasoning, and has
been used to solve hard reasoning tasks. Analogy based reasoning (AR) has
gained increasing interest from the artificial intelligence community and has
shown its potential in multiple machine learning tasks such as classification,
decision making and recommendation with competitive results. We propose a deep
learning (DL) framework to address and tackle two key tasks in AR: analogy
detection and solving. The framework is thoroughly tested on the Siganalogies
dataset of morphological analogical proportions (APs) between words, and shown
to outperform symbolic approaches in many languages. Previous work have
explored the behavior of the Analogy Neural Network for classification (ANNc)
on analogy detection and of the Analogy Neural Network for retrieval (ANNr) on
analogy solving by retrieval, as well as the potential of an autoencoder (AE)
for analogy solving by generating the solution word. In this article we
summarize these findings and we extend them by combining ANNr and the AE
embedding model, and checking the performance of ANNc as an retrieval method.
The combination of ANNr and AE outperforms the other approaches in almost all
cases, and ANNc as a retrieval method achieves competitive or better
performance than 3CosMul. We conclude with general guidelines on using our
framework to tackle APs with DL. | [
0.0217242539,
0.0596107841,
-0.0269657895,
0.0259634163,
-0.0310013723,
0.0351720415,
0.0231791269,
0.0138001116,
-0.0469061323,
0.0061614178,
-0.0298483986,
-0.0595642701,
-0.0133527955,
-0.0212952662,
0.0127646923,
-0.0371247903,
0.0101451222,
0.0176603999,
0.0065000723,
-0.0332195796,
0.0222430844,
0.0301803667,
-0.0242302399,
0.035684336,
-0.03118743,
0.055357758,
0.0204321723,
-0.0199126489,
0.0432009734,
-0.0104716383,
-0.0128624476,
-0.0198265966,
0.0247455388,
0.0206891522,
0.0000019947,
-0.0569778159,
0.0059228381,
-0.0125841843,
-0.0105703296,
0.0036463379,
0.0577204786,
0.0243774615,
-0.0025672303,
0.016413955,
-0.0127503742,
-0.0106499922,
0.0685908869,
-0.0049892701,
-0.0249075498,
0.0307460241,
-0.0163725223,
-0.1009247825,
0.0436807871,
-0.0257450957,
-0.0104514733,
0.0479466692,
-0.0102347052,
-0.0105989864,
0.000467424,
-0.0314477682,
-0.0157845095,
0.0272925571,
0.0439254604,
0.0245190002,
-0.0310606845,
0.0291982889,
0.0187751465,
0.0100464839,
0.0303638596,
0.0443748683,
-0.0652198642,
-0.0306025911,
-0.0022633674,
-0.0421608463,
-0.000676874,
0.0579701476,
-0.0541608818,
0.0172346551,
0.0188383684,
0.0710798353,
0.0433671027,
0.0239125881,
-0.0005506358,
0.0021567035,
-0.0603154376,
0.0141368574,
0.0385902114,
0.0005251439,
0.0061774799,
-0.0330790244,
-0.0017154767,
0.0012829072,
0.0320451558,
0.0316199996,
-0.0111688897,
-0.0075495793,
0.0100946734,
-0.0666954666,
0.0531583391,
-0.0811677426,
0.0792976096,
0.0133648338,
-0.0164482296,
0.0182315148,
-0.1144198924,
0.0242805481,
-0.0038977556,
0.0748601928,
-0.0344644748,
-0.0382370688,
-0.0403976738,
-0.010205077,
-0.0593139715,
0.0061803916,
0.034141548,
-0.0219726022,
-0.0139286676,
-0.0320395008,
-0.0220256541,
-0.0244644862,
-0.0016093669,
0.0447777882,
-0.0462698378,
-0.022608744,
-0.0466542505,
0.0101627335,
-0.0883559361,
0.0341630615,
-0.0162291005,
-0.022951765,
0.0334549919,
0.0012626679,
0.0551450551,
-0.0468625166,
0.055756256,
0.0821025223,
-0.0071579907,
-0.0252329335,
-0.0039197365,
-0.0275270939,
0.0056610783,
-0.0217718091,
-0.0117444396,
-0.0661996678,
0.0482336394,
-0.0417176262,
-0.0401412509,
-0.0422009341,
0.0017979568,
0.006699455,
-0.0380746052,
0.0911516026,
0.0338601507,
-0.0317919217,
0.0186342243,
-0.0304208118,
0.0172055159,
-0.0310575925,
0.02341602,
0.0255191941,
-0.0083941808,
-0.0076342281,
-0.0218606535,
-0.0133047029,
0.0064193099,
-0.023154309,
-0.0642588511,
-0.0487021096,
-0.0279375371,
0.0757081658,
0.0346024744,
0.0704657808,
0.0112881893,
-0.0962619036,
0.0145190228,
0.0656052232,
0.0333536901,
0.0419532284,
0.0485497117,
0.0079840273,
-0.0426526219,
0.0091823796,
0.0014076423,
0.0451865718,
-0.0050327359,
0.0387187712,
-0.0229426995,
0.0411176085,
-0.0138225611,
-0.0188434869,
0.0008977024,
0.0044426853,
-0.0338406675,
-0.0180887654,
0.0560852438,
0.0031049305,
-0.0248213839,
-0.0160835627,
0.0602742918,
-0.0295580346,
0.021026995,
0.0017341477,
0.0388131663,
0.0293790679,
0.0335882902,
-0.0016707751,
-0.008717251,
0.018416224,
-0.0632568896,
-0.0075864494,
0.0115179298,
-0.0074409186,
-0.0374150388,
-0.0926974118,
-0.0101214256,
-0.0003877166,
0.0012809708,
0.050590191,
-0.0372508615,
0.0822981894,
0.0208040457,
-0.0157413315,
0.0037345614,
0.0374315381,
-0.032957077,
-0.0086075589,
0.0014648631,
0.0534603074,
-0.0023904957,
-0.0000380312,
-0.0336653106,
0.0306872651,
0.0031274862,
-0.0922054499,
-0.0284749307,
0.0501073971,
-0.06111449,
-0.0212709308,
0.0642884746,
-0.074232623,
0.0193177201,
-0.0107680988,
0.018744899,
-0.0120607065,
0.0386079773,
-0.0304078422,
0.112218529,
-0.0546289124,
0.0172455031,
-0.0100650163,
0.0397837237,
-0.0150240501,
0.0553395003,
0.0244773757,
0.0182879902,
0.0130007807,
-0.0034114362,
0.0098955072,
-0.0027089184,
-0.005607042,
-0.0167304464,
0.0092714876,
-0.0513942316,
-0.0022689058,
-0.0148387281,
0.0138338981,
-0.0170433521,
-0.0218096264,
-0.0242680572,
-0.0114157489,
0.0030616769,
0.0076725855,
0.0241285842,
-0.0025844544,
-0.0186337717,
-0.0515363775,
0.0643750951,
-0.0107682617,
0.0202993937,
0.0576812215,
-0.0297230836,
-0.0322126709,
-0.0529947467,
-0.0332375839,
-0.0294531658,
0.0835425109,
0.0426522754,
0.0173545498,
0.0232889075,
-0.0218623746,
-0.0551391989,
0.0226510651,
0.0143935587,
-0.0596822798,
0.0231917836,
-0.0324527584,
0.0287994333,
0.0112902522,
0.0313973762,
-0.0346688293,
0.0662762374,
-0.0010341905,
-0.0877471641,
-0.0500741042,
-0.0423308648,
0.0111226831,
0.0049858037,
-0.0359218046,
-0.0367642306,
0.07231801,
0.0062371683,
0.013302492,
-0.0000314863,
0.0387539081,
0.032393761,
0.0202694237,
0.004091376,
0.0091598937,
-0.0065094377,
0.047816284,
-0.0176511034,
0.0141027244,
0.1012262776,
0.0118129831,
0.0053725932,
-0.0171763636,
-0.0404368564,
-0.0358920917,
0.0637554377,
0.0105973398,
0.0462986529,
0.0281568021,
-0.0156347807,
-0.0302980114,
0.0143366111,
0.0251161493,
-0.0271014534,
0.0329158828,
0.0100220386,
0.0001043157,
-0.0086800279,
-0.0183492061,
-0.0264596809,
0.0311965737,
-0.0269315727,
0.0299184062,
0.0249187909,
-0.0171999019,
-0.0385176316,
0.0319640338,
-0.0406549498,
0.0223094914,
0.0245962124,
0.0094579626,
-0.0177353341,
0.0811524019,
0.0481402874,
-0.0063599315,
0.0264097191,
0.0355343223,
0.0149880312,
0.0162989479,
-0.0012076943,
0.0105288802,
-0.0195007566,
0.0212801974,
0.0061496519,
-0.05537422,
0.0511999726,
-0.0026045856,
-0.0288792774,
-0.0250876099,
-0.0267643109,
0.0432304591,
0.0502729453,
-0.0272421855,
0.0238798615,
-0.0162677877,
0.0111950161,
0.0130180325,
0.0334312953,
-0.067785956,
-0.0212293286,
0.0131839523,
-0.0430362634,
0.0180532429,
-0.031224275,
0.0487832986,
-0.0927773863,
0.015552124,
0.0008020871,
-0.0568295047,
-0.0670144558,
-0.0075417017,
0.0203888007,
-0.027793508,
-0.0414710008,
0.0070888512,
-0.0067798658,
0.0017053996,
0.0217015166,
0.0137331747,
0.0047644284,
-0.0022099721,
-0.080910936,
-0.0008260338,
-0.0044348384,
0.0256112423,
-0.005315484,
-0.0805975869,
-0.0004341807,
0.0097651016,
-0.0384295918,
-0.0100669293,
0.0082170358,
0.044860173,
-0.0111613832,
-0.0085700639,
0.014805858,
-0.0299756359,
0.0082293293,
-0.0100972131,
0.056699466,
-0.0109667387,
-0.0231536552,
-0.0617475845,
0.0104644839,
-0.0599889867,
0.0376383439,
0.0804859251,
0.0057650926,
-0.0250919051,
0.003824824,
0.0045044245,
-0.0721011236,
-0.0170931853,
-0.0262272097,
0.035590969,
0.0227642283,
-0.085494414,
-0.0126140267,
0.0061510853,
0.0157021377,
0.0061802282,
-0.0788012147,
-0.0142303407,
-0.0484758429,
-0.0946497992,
-0.0017125439,
0.0026933921,
0.039625477,
0.0001466544,
0.0136811957,
0.072872594,
-0.0303014405,
-0.0324955545,
0.0036604637,
-0.000510414,
-0.0159657244,
-0.0310901329,
0.0183111336,
0.0026582277,
-0.013754813,
-0.005662892,
-0.0020127771,
0.0495117716,
0.0148306601,
0.0384753235,
-0.0264120139,
-0.0097711105,
-0.005365523,
0.0121931992,
0.0254575908,
0.0056194332,
0.0233128387,
-0.0067645973,
0.0494007505,
-0.0186056197,
-0.0217015799,
0.0575419813,
-0.0178796072,
-0.0147815561,
0.0190674476,
-0.0196672007,
-0.0615941733,
-0.0025260174,
0.0309150759,
0.0036882795,
-0.0257050693,
-0.0195757784,
-0.001267186,
0.0380036421,
-0.0260772314,
-0.0466361344,
0.0047983606,
0.0196379982,
0.0200326927,
0.0148335304,
0.0407736711,
0.0231408644,
-0.009523306,
0.0304564442,
0.0009588507,
0.0000081147,
-0.0019946275,
0.0657596141,
-0.0679973289,
-0.0123638734,
0.029292142,
0.0085032554,
-0.0425749607,
0.020515712,
0.0214853436,
-0.0401848555,
-0.0686429366,
0.0358403437,
0.0458547212,
-0.0647752956,
-0.0256021749,
-0.0311348811,
0.0164621696,
0.0070591364,
-0.0193739682,
-0.0793428272,
-0.0277276821,
0.0436114632,
0.0171488039,
0.0200810749,
-0.0306871198,
0.025208164,
-0.067950204,
0.0427582376,
-0.042809464,
-0.0177688394,
0.008802915,
-0.0226906594,
0.0008440755,
0.0428738967,
-0.0143359853,
-0.0254083984,
-0.020282682,
-0.0843393505,
-0.0515044816,
0.0080906646,
-0.0032519517,
0.0659010038,
0.057031665,
0.0081801638,
-0.0057162894,
0.0083911857,
0.0038361857,
0.017946953,
-0.0313761719,
-0.0420502536,
-0.0176166873,
-6.28198287e-33,
0.0179879051,
0.0126977721,
0.0069599231,
-0.0495153926,
0.0038944902,
-0.0079083135,
-0.0418078415,
-0.0260144994,
-0.0456657968,
0.0279103629,
0.0199415851,
-0.0447662286,
-0.0025642919,
0.0129407011,
0.0355584621,
-0.0070675993,
0.0007323101,
-0.0108063295,
0.0266081449,
-0.0296667758,
0.0218030326,
0.037503913,
0.0645759627,
-0.0425897576,
-0.0214279424,
0.0576968752,
0.0670998991,
-0.0189875886,
-0.0256324466,
0.058149673,
-0.0059575755,
0.0584250055,
-0.0060780398,
0.0015338738,
0.0094768479,
-0.019843122,
-0.0868649259,
-0.0611247644,
-0.0351976603,
-0.01405006,
-0.0120337177,
-0.0005892417,
0.0806628317,
-0.0242288057,
0.031843517,
-0.0135136861,
0.0737403557,
-0.0087551353,
-0.003597806,
-0.0429568104,
-0.0410822555,
-0.0025694212,
0.0030106422,
-0.0287511107,
0.0456694067,
0.0108459136,
0.0434367135,
0.0464498363,
-0.0324435309,
0.0576078109,
-0.0117854243,
0.0028050984,
0.0298850946,
-0.0222695228,
-0.0191246551,
0.0559178181,
0.0448488742,
-0.1053046584,
0.0154433204,
0.0015612069,
0.0426818654,
0.0290848445,
0.0372627527,
-0.0102048526,
0.0806638673,
-0.0255029332,
-0.0079974905,
0.0094190594,
0.0681129172,
0.0535269156,
0.0052693421,
0.046362225,
-0.0416304655,
-0.0069588032,
0.009729444,
-0.0608429834,
-0.0781858787,
-0.0395241417,
0.0060049216,
-0.0464501902,
0.0009569881,
0.0784283131,
0.0131133785,
-0.0224146098,
-0.0078646597,
-0.0140048983,
0.0480783731,
0.0169241186,
-0.0214743596,
0.0166519675,
-0.0084982757,
-0.0151083125,
-0.0064532151,
0.0019481473,
0.0019958108,
-0.0057790335,
0.0269617103,
-0.0111633297,
-0.0529160313,
-0.0041971849,
-0.0286098421,
-0.0451320484,
0.0277265683,
-0.0416213349,
-0.0130789578,
0.0359747745,
0.0033572454,
0.0322001502,
0.0309890248,
-0.0521429069,
-0.0307565555,
-0.0265234802,
-0.0393036753,
0.0316509195,
-0.0499799587,
0.0118735582,
-0.0444592386,
-0.0058275419,
0.0045382967,
-0.0598661192,
-0.0085723279,
0.025398083,
2.891e-7,
0.0352425799,
0.0031569351,
0.0462275892,
-0.0451146886,
-0.0259799324,
0.0090097692,
0.0400865115,
0.0134556601,
-0.0171142854,
0.0389108807,
0.0588207506,
0.0454992205,
0.0004163496,
0.0184598379,
-0.0436863191,
0.0666183457,
-0.1185339093,
-0.0416330509,
-0.0267578326,
-0.020097699,
0.0389996953,
0.0676000863,
0.0355415829,
-0.0573624633,
0.0501340777,
-0.0155512001,
0.0091701755,
-0.0255716387,
0.0384088084,
0.0111748884,
0.0112406462,
-0.0059564188,
0.0124365259,
0.0371211655,
0.027478626,
0.0244459901,
0.0453880541,
-0.0481037609,
0.0056926697,
-0.0287470501,
0.0069170706,
-0.038210392,
-0.0113021089,
-0.0674479902,
0.0294814985,
-0.042925965,
0.0063342988,
-0.035868153,
-0.0196179394,
0.0319885164,
0.0424151458,
0.0073923557,
-0.0405935012,
0.0247906595,
0.0527412519,
-0.0051290072,
-0.0363058113,
-0.0927502662,
0.0456238277,
0.0599666908,
-0.0215476286,
0.0444478765,
-0.0084097805,
-0.0040939031,
0.0033238083,
0.0128159095,
-0.0332284942,
2.099316279e-34,
-0.0039073136,
0.0473781936,
0.0041797659,
0.0255145952,
0.0230801702,
0.0103190765,
0.0324906595,
0.0074738218,
0.0184767563,
-0.0217520017,
-0.0498022959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17324v1 | Topics in the Haystack: Extracting and Evaluating Topics beyond Coherence | 2023-03-30T12:24:25 | 2023-03-30T12:24:25 | Anton Thielmann, Quentin Seifert, Arik Reuter, Elisabeth Bergherr, Benjamin Säfken | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting and identifying latent topics in large text corpora has gained
increasing importance in Natural Language Processing (NLP). Most models,
whether probabilistic models similar to Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) or
neural topic models, follow the same underlying approach of topic
interpretability and topic extraction. We propose a method that incorporates a
deeper understanding of both sentence and document themes, and goes beyond
simply analyzing word frequencies in the data. This allows our model to detect
latent topics that may include uncommon words or neologisms, as well as words
not present in the documents themselves. Additionally, we propose several new
evaluation metrics based on intruder words and similarity measures in the
semantic space. We present correlation coefficients with human identification
of intruder words and achieve near-human level results at the word-intrusion
task. We demonstrate the competitive performance of our method with a large
benchmark study, and achieve superior results compared to state-of-the-art
topic modeling and document clustering models. | [
0.0470456183,
0.0267854743,
-0.0044253273,
0.0333616659,
-0.0657968521,
-0.0007178099,
-0.021423256,
-0.0261117723,
-0.0579841137,
-0.0125184758,
-0.0031073219,
-0.0219212528,
-0.0081972685,
0.0396633968,
0.0009839491,
-0.0500541367,
0.0294264238,
-0.0200779345,
0.0313225016,
0.0480963439,
0.0138523737,
-0.0298362169,
0.014596967,
0.0129627762,
-0.0027334515,
-0.0562875308,
-0.0116380267,
-0.0279836822,
-0.0028904786,
-0.0259862803,
0.0171481054,
0.0717641711,
0.0019932191,
0.0080611398,
0.0000019995,
-0.0223007407,
-0.0398668237,
-0.0421727337,
0.0577965938,
0.0320503861,
0.0791324601,
-0.0122998189,
0.0359779596,
-0.0093866512,
-0.0263122823,
0.0087602967,
-0.0280478466,
0.1154890358,
0.0522761531,
0.0494043231,
-0.02704354,
0.0006520625,
-0.0012740856,
-0.0133401575,
0.0100003397,
-0.0431872793,
-0.0002431797,
-0.0168838203,
-0.028351156,
0.0324310996,
-0.0188265052,
0.0224818345,
-0.019565586,
-0.006012423,
0.0761097968,
0.0150666051,
-0.0034860047,
-0.0459758416,
-0.0147850225,
0.0814266205,
-0.0284866709,
0.0006965793,
0.0537029393,
-0.0182691012,
-0.0176990032,
0.0518084913,
-0.0518339723,
0.0160924885,
-0.0032070728,
0.0297206864,
0.1009812504,
0.0034878585,
0.0281480756,
0.0054621664,
0.0229250118,
0.0506676398,
0.0192276407,
-0.0495163389,
-0.0237099752,
0.0023648532,
-0.005243971,
-0.0317490473,
0.0482117794,
-0.0078645851,
-0.0107497117,
0.0220776517,
-0.0295400899,
-0.0553201661,
0.0345209986,
-0.0514930226,
-0.0147011289,
-0.049057655,
-0.0291619506,
0.0882846415,
0.04347739,
-0.008410871,
-0.0059241708,
-0.0445201322,
-0.017553905,
-0.0241666529,
-0.0162292738,
0.0146645373,
0.0160313733,
0.0356358662,
-0.007207917,
-0.0563959368,
0.037577644,
0.0257255789,
-0.0208485816,
-0.0360985436,
-0.0395827703,
0.0106538637,
-0.0086135715,
-0.0290314164,
0.0101397876,
-0.0033029071,
-0.0440871455,
0.0350083821,
-0.0218661837,
0.0179469548,
-0.0249573961,
0.0444684923,
0.0320857204,
-0.0122552169,
-0.0142292706,
0.0077362712,
0.0019753531,
-0.0817085952,
-0.037858285,
-0.0211452767,
0.0011162651,
0.028138537,
0.0046927454,
-0.0766866058,
-0.0036416892,
-0.0205091704,
-0.0121743614,
-0.0035475737,
-0.0106639722,
0.0656823292,
-0.0483838245,
0.0313616209,
-0.049436871,
0.0386505052,
0.0793575719,
0.047103297,
-0.0002067718,
0.0220748298,
0.0019966187,
0.064120166,
0.0670847744,
0.0162563398,
0.0366864651,
-0.0054900926,
-0.0188028142,
-0.0126288729,
0.0400000922,
-0.0012969252,
-0.0401030518,
-0.0167119894,
0.0448148437,
0.0557687916,
-0.028464688,
-0.0347645134,
0.0259431694,
0.1274611056,
-0.0023481245,
0.0079701561,
-0.0219631419,
0.0391799659,
0.0079954471,
-0.0175677203,
-0.0011800018,
-0.0242046677,
-0.0173327904,
-0.0253340751,
0.0670795515,
0.0065044179,
-0.0110676084,
-0.0320215337,
-0.010448684,
0.0032655308,
0.0022389381,
-0.0648779795,
0.0636314899,
0.0026083081,
0.014849755,
-0.010530849,
0.024734037,
0.0005386749,
0.0097746775,
0.0043629897,
0.0361701958,
0.0511480086,
0.0624520741,
-0.0348383375,
-0.0030952706,
-0.017450586,
0.0232410785,
0.0299889036,
-0.0441686027,
-0.0087351678,
0.0125038978,
-0.0208186954,
0.0101137394,
-0.0023499881,
0.0387858041,
0.02929735,
0.0088080047,
0.0128411185,
0.0036889508,
-0.0447298624,
-0.0048633022,
0.0562254302,
-0.0098164147,
-0.0190200135,
0.032034941,
-0.0342912488,
0.0419938117,
0.0246587489,
-0.0004808902,
0.0245517623,
0.0407516733,
-0.0511150844,
-0.0545673743,
-0.0241652261,
-0.0103455503,
-0.0026708711,
0.0074765151,
-0.0897150859,
-0.0208332352,
-0.0006185676,
-0.0017277013,
-0.0128092589,
0.0538633168,
-0.0596627183,
-0.0182898585,
-0.0429761186,
-0.011916724,
-0.0075475541,
0.0119570028,
-0.0288869869,
0.0784696713,
-0.0252832528,
0.0122649996,
0.0303901993,
-0.019100856,
0.000393494,
-0.0364547372,
-0.0319783092,
-0.020821875,
0.0078609064,
0.0216630045,
0.0379496068,
-0.0013231689,
-0.0116474554,
-0.025811946,
-0.0627163351,
0.0382621288,
-0.0294741467,
0.0228480399,
0.0424828455,
-0.0191724561,
-0.0218863916,
-0.0178960264,
-0.0111472784,
-0.0022935695,
-0.0029821359,
0.0094592208,
0.035715878,
-0.0234309845,
0.019247435,
-0.0509999171,
-0.0027883227,
-0.0207678303,
0.0661917105,
0.005487036,
-0.0341143832,
-0.0342214555,
0.0293473583,
0.0209806543,
-0.0184856243,
-0.0026021414,
0.0244681109,
-0.0087709343,
-0.0254255813,
0.069091849,
0.0007837659,
0.0408134609,
0.0742693841,
0.0331250578,
-0.0225022063,
-0.0129766231,
-0.0556534268,
-0.0324473716,
0.0704698786,
0.0196880382,
-0.0431684256,
0.0814105719,
0.0656742677,
0.0342692882,
0.0129577816,
-0.0091410214,
0.0007817437,
-0.0353602134,
-0.0216649026,
-0.0543019362,
-0.0031715999,
-0.0311751682,
0.0233296491,
-0.0396808907,
-0.0403918959,
0.0530563295,
0.0048790798,
0.0427509993,
-0.0562833734,
-0.0440154262,
-0.0191655271,
0.026303485,
-0.0044235545,
-0.020034492,
-0.0157234594,
-0.0407370441,
0.0182436965,
0.0182608683,
0.0162204672,
-0.0190305412,
0.0430658162,
-0.0311863888,
-0.0230805576,
0.0316881724,
0.0159063358,
-0.0371346548,
-0.0869673416,
0.0316337384,
-0.007785819,
0.0200826284,
0.0126332659,
-0.0219925996,
-0.0295639001,
0.0107922433,
0.0113275489,
-0.0053234706,
-0.0238127019,
-0.0218266994,
0.0661486611,
0.0743285492,
-0.0127125727,
0.0005147737,
-0.0124135241,
-0.000322162,
0.055686675,
0.0313508175,
-0.0338271596,
-0.0245267861,
0.0222828556,
-0.0110368971,
-0.0228138901,
-0.0038314906,
0.0109379143,
-0.0000502843,
-0.0180664435,
-0.0221950766,
0.1110362187,
0.0439069532,
-0.0518438518,
-0.0068740565,
-0.0430905595,
0.0075778267,
-0.0163351744,
0.0096284477,
-0.0109512722,
-0.0308668483,
-0.0018650211,
0.0419351012,
0.0145663386,
-0.0539189577,
-0.0128378943,
-0.0403438918,
0.010403255,
-0.0121753672,
-0.0030683829,
-0.0219041314,
-0.094408147,
0.0153194051,
-0.0276502427,
-0.0417995974,
-0.0116808573,
-0.0118103027,
0.0296306014,
0.010371821,
-0.0451636314,
-0.0367157646,
-0.0131531209,
-0.0393298008,
0.0519220568,
0.0004689324,
0.0231120978,
-0.0051972964,
0.009293953,
-0.0279397499,
-0.0595344454,
-0.0139409164,
0.0160506982,
0.0285621732,
-0.030141186,
0.0112223327,
-0.0396537855,
0.0309616681,
-0.0811170638,
-0.0552587919,
0.0603246279,
0.0760224238,
-0.0356080085,
-0.0207712576,
-0.0233033467,
0.0011657003,
0.0151303886,
0.0911054239,
0.0491128191,
-0.0191567205,
0.0036824769,
-0.0027671135,
0.040906772,
0.0765441209,
0.0136568313,
-0.0360331871,
0.0070977793,
-0.0708020627,
-0.0844009966,
-0.073955588,
0.0020079117,
-0.0119324662,
0.0030330145,
0.0321135521,
0.0055861589,
-0.0364011675,
-0.0449844524,
0.0418680497,
0.0096564572,
-0.0450267009,
-0.0650076419,
-0.001261437,
0.0011866981,
-0.0030520495,
-0.0426837876,
0.010446691,
-0.0565496162,
-0.0285101403,
0.0239334479,
-0.0375744216,
0.0080628581,
0.0055403714,
-0.0572825782,
-0.0658445433,
-0.0040053781,
0.0455144756,
-0.0607560538,
0.0063171107,
-0.0121021196,
0.0019834451,
0.0192444567,
0.0136532029,
-0.0220312681,
0.0402442962,
0.0089714685,
0.0262352712,
-0.0781022161,
-0.058327537,
-0.0149879996,
0.0159828346,
0.1034741849,
0.0131152524,
-0.0076018749,
-0.0978331342,
-0.0889026746,
0.0020997226,
0.0030723903,
-0.0129690673,
0.0138429729,
0.0125295771,
-0.0115868151,
-0.0649705678,
0.0405485071,
-0.0446364433,
0.0209047683,
-0.0072892597,
-0.0228286684,
0.0366414487,
0.0175359007,
-0.0715010762,
0.0037148765,
0.0171497166,
0.005750923,
-0.0156164076,
0.0306556132,
0.0011237795,
0.0327531286,
0.0077209114,
-0.036839053,
0.0057143788,
0.0516104586,
-0.088521868,
-0.0019789473,
0.0009296383,
0.0588301383,
0.0082465447,
-0.0113683436,
0.0418507494,
-0.03361734,
0.0122069847,
-0.0242497567,
0.0565599874,
0.0065669185,
0.0044150162,
-0.0169428326,
0.0386224836,
-0.0255729053,
0.0170800593,
0.0744975433,
-0.0238414053,
-0.012689231,
0.019696122,
-0.0474123657,
-0.0314498171,
0.0405429602,
0.0565169118,
0.0585943647,
-0.0367926545,
0.0632794797,
-0.0587628596,
0.018369114,
0.0464382954,
-0.002211814,
0.0003903545,
0.0397084914,
0.0460634343,
0.0994927362,
-0.0256888047,
0.0322955325,
-0.061413765,
0.0286780056,
-0.000603383,
-0.0380374491,
-0.0309607759,
-7.189728995e-33,
-0.0071277223,
-0.0458746552,
-0.0031020625,
0.0390562676,
0.0288751442,
0.0265197232,
-0.0418765582,
0.0270395409,
0.0341551676,
0.0362640433,
0.0033195775,
0.0604909025,
-0.0038948441,
-0.0153250033,
0.0067374436,
-0.0129226269,
0.0233376659,
0.0184884928,
0.0027977987,
0.0265856739,
0.0571960844,
0.0531117097,
0.020442836,
-0.0585837737,
0.0314798132,
-0.0233976543,
0.031085318,
0.0026906624,
0.1051414013,
0.0011249408,
-0.0598424673,
0.0303584691,
0.0563562214,
-0.0632144809,
0.000802586,
0.0485292599,
-0.0385247096,
-0.0839124098,
-0.0180294663,
-0.0392361619,
0.0077099078,
-0.0562050939,
0.0400206931,
0.0190078951,
-0.0009574182,
0.0018279776,
0.0871356949,
0.0170330275,
-0.0147028817,
-0.0355202183,
-0.0473412871,
0.0584502146,
-0.0074214051,
0.0131024998,
0.0105960649,
-0.0344943628,
-0.0202867277,
0.0093809469,
-0.0347024798,
0.0430404842,
-0.0001976655,
-0.0020007472,
-0.0003185143,
-0.0291569848,
-0.0328984112,
0.0926046818,
0.0153336003,
-0.0133454679,
-0.0010032883,
0.0115779219,
0.0186050981,
0.0432223007,
0.0110748801,
0.009612672,
0.0399192013,
0.0481303632,
-0.0252678543,
0.0728172064,
-0.007021015,
-0.005806583,
0.0242566243,
-0.0015734007,
-0.0514345355,
-0.0033983467,
0.0025635359,
-0.0099722743,
-0.0302338358,
-0.0089407098,
0.0164297316,
-0.0078008254,
-0.049421683,
-0.0370547026,
0.0057559898,
0.004377007,
0.0500818081,
0.0304905437,
-0.0016730789,
-0.0142110083,
0.0173436869,
0.0210416075,
-0.0675555915,
-0.0281557366,
0.0107642589,
0.0049839844,
0.0347131751,
-0.0256844461,
-0.0126456209,
-0.0258539878,
-0.0408889763,
-0.0215556826,
0.0139092328,
-0.0292820837,
-0.0173870567,
0.0161628965,
0.0130091039,
-0.0095327245,
-0.0236238055,
0.0454644486,
0.052452419,
0.0424438566,
0.0047947187,
-0.0327761248,
-0.0185742248,
-0.0097505432,
-0.0225314219,
0.0190113522,
-0.0051753055,
0.0150846513,
0.0405587032,
-0.0541687086,
0.000564993,
-0.0298361816,
2.89e-7,
0.037191581,
0.0906078666,
-0.0123081645,
-0.0458161496,
0.0325164273,
0.0463355817,
-0.0226230379,
0.0363728553,
-0.0252363887,
-0.0333356149,
0.0054246406,
0.0261332914,
0.0014212281,
0.0391492806,
-0.0640796125,
0.0142495017,
-0.0506334193,
-0.0097316727,
-0.0493849441,
-0.0113745797,
0.0252504423,
0.0656779334,
0.0217266288,
0.0031518287,
-0.0206277166,
-0.0477370359,
0.0250699203,
-0.0388625301,
-0.058214929,
-0.0104826149,
0.103160575,
0.0351617821,
0.0157813672,
-0.047573749,
-0.0136900693,
0.0292227287,
0.081560865,
0.0384735093,
-0.0130554093,
0.0109460419,
-0.0038515725,
-0.031612549,
-0.0309082177,
-0.0062949569,
0.0434406325,
-0.0293848645,
-0.0416700691,
-0.0463925079,
-0.0174490325,
-0.0182908569,
0.0269323271,
0.0068813954,
-0.0254148394,
-0.0223144293,
0.004376166,
-0.0063999849,
-0.009832547,
-0.0382221006,
0.0144347744,
0.0255522504,
-0.0437606797,
0.0157797839,
-0.0451475531,
0.0072946693,
0.023362942,
-0.0440802947,
0.0385909043,
2.387278646e-34,
0.0344302058,
-0.0073299333,
-0.0553951301,
0.0088122226,
0.008060935,
0.0104006175,
-0.0783594623,
-0.0118959239,
-0.0129881119,
-0.0725947246,
0.0142731266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17322v1 | Yes but.. Can ChatGPT Identify Entities in Historical Documents? | 2023-03-30T12:23:39 | 2023-03-30T12:23:39 | Carlos-Emiliano González-Gallardo, Emanuela Boros, Nancy Girdhar, Ahmed Hamdi, Jose G. Moreno, Antoine Doucet | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have been leveraged for several years now,
obtaining state-of-the-art performance in recognizing entities from modern
documents. For the last few months, the conversational agent ChatGPT has
"prompted" a lot of interest in the scientific community and public due to its
capacity of generating plausible-sounding answers. In this paper, we explore
this ability by probing it in the named entity recognition and classification
(NERC) task in primary sources (e.g., historical newspapers and classical
commentaries) in a zero-shot manner and by comparing it with state-of-the-art
LM-based systems. Our findings indicate several shortcomings in identifying
entities in historical text that range from the consistency of entity
annotation guidelines, entity complexity, and code-switching, to the
specificity of prompting. Moreover, as expected, the inaccessibility of
historical archives to the public (and thus on the Internet) also impacts its
performance. | [
0.0506774448,
0.0389950946,
0.0113893226,
0.0464755557,
-0.0333209001,
0.0480874404,
0.019054208,
0.0272751339,
0.0439762846,
-0.0652065575,
-0.0163528658,
-0.0345939808,
0.0007444252,
-0.0231793467,
0.0007079577,
-0.0105152335,
0.0354894996,
-0.0024739737,
0.032860633,
0.0272603072,
-0.0025686882,
-0.000848198,
-0.0306800306,
0.0131190745,
0.0248895604,
0.0045065084,
-0.0240453221,
-0.0092535913,
0.0212498792,
-0.0352224819,
-0.0163547825,
0.0476644337,
0.0005292114,
0.0893882513,
0.0000016547,
-0.0466048904,
-0.0312749483,
-0.0070895944,
-0.0525690317,
0.0045596049,
0.0389452614,
-0.0003820561,
-0.0394767784,
-0.0333405808,
-0.0247896239,
-0.0164467115,
0.027187407,
0.0532170981,
0.0153373452,
0.1237678975,
-0.012826601,
0.0073254299,
0.0671305507,
0.0077796141,
0.0464637429,
-0.0389809124,
0.0139116077,
-0.0108061014,
-0.0187983364,
0.0626772866,
0.0286262669,
0.0478928275,
-0.020095937,
-0.0033435312,
-0.0137975216,
0.0482385047,
-0.0608132444,
0.0318727233,
-0.0031537684,
0.026467206,
0.0210043583,
-0.0060551302,
0.050481908,
0.0193256997,
-0.0262887198,
-0.0234593507,
-0.0412432067,
0.0054917787,
-0.0566684119,
-0.0093802074,
0.0506823398,
-0.0232267827,
0.0285554267,
0.0127167422,
-0.0050065913,
0.0277343281,
0.0251545124,
-0.0207341444,
-0.0034248489,
0.0176216885,
-0.027727874,
-0.0722031295,
0.0213891752,
0.0552566051,
-0.0106261801,
0.0153013691,
0.0023873504,
0.030619204,
-0.0057032513,
-0.0520387776,
-0.0512027368,
0.0351290964,
-0.0081222132,
0.0824705735,
-0.0294435974,
0.0357797109,
-0.0089303236,
-0.0088660521,
0.0347836278,
-0.0243161544,
-0.0607214272,
-0.0148764011,
-0.0258917939,
0.031764783,
-0.0202236027,
-0.0321144201,
-0.0170841683,
0.0185035467,
0.0481920354,
0.0254576821,
-0.025145255,
-0.0235620011,
-0.0124136535,
-0.0125705879,
-0.0510059036,
0.0237920377,
-0.0033284756,
-0.0249959715,
-0.0338417329,
-0.0803256854,
0.0027982707,
0.0033278007,
-0.0068868436,
-0.0462161191,
0.0146296788,
0.0662694275,
-0.0089700334,
-0.081514053,
-0.0424476154,
0.0036977746,
0.0044087125,
-0.0696686432,
0.0261932239,
-0.0352906324,
0.0045631118,
0.0078103007,
0.0069430824,
-0.0060837455,
0.0150924074,
0.0139946723,
-0.0579586215,
0.0873740315,
0.003369095,
-0.0116228219,
0.0489821434,
0.0100778192,
-0.0009904719,
0.0436204113,
0.0616527312,
-0.012550896,
0.0686819479,
0.0295602456,
0.0234545898,
0.0318389647,
0.0058457656,
-0.0094792116,
0.0471033454,
-0.0121834474,
-0.0276223999,
0.026443243,
0.0006181051,
0.0648754016,
-0.010703194,
-0.046782393,
0.0511025079,
0.0568619296,
0.0107298186,
0.0299107041,
0.0205149502,
-0.0004374285,
0.0383915827,
0.0272644907,
-0.0512906052,
0.011902513,
-0.0279589761,
-0.0074414522,
-0.0085288929,
0.0381550901,
-0.0182396136,
0.0216514077,
-0.0082184905,
-0.0013363407,
-0.0020711578,
-0.0319335982,
0.0570112243,
-0.0284868237,
-0.0661047399,
0.0498642102,
0.024778571,
-0.0362823755,
-0.0019639567,
-0.067397967,
0.0369629301,
0.0599902719,
0.0756674558,
-0.0194374695,
-0.0273227338,
-0.0162099414,
0.0028590879,
0.0760238022,
0.0546724387,
-0.0213410333,
0.028815398,
-0.0248008985,
0.0112357382,
0.0131614339,
0.0239341985,
0.0351723544,
0.0549791753,
0.0294067841,
0.0059110499,
-0.0070424587,
0.0079317298,
0.0519981049,
-0.0353248492,
-0.0444338582,
-0.0348504819,
0.003404821,
0.0056853457,
0.0404529981,
-0.007286618,
-0.0083524026,
0.0123676732,
-0.0264949631,
-0.0178984161,
-0.0085735228,
0.0006529922,
-0.0444774963,
0.019350525,
-0.0174791738,
-0.0182898715,
-0.0012061569,
-0.0066906656,
-0.0523459278,
-0.0205511563,
-0.022334801,
0.0655022785,
-0.0117864544,
0.0277909487,
0.0233272556,
-0.0074436804,
-0.0421514064,
0.07456173,
0.0154607063,
0.0277694929,
0.0535322353,
0.0222950336,
-0.0067236386,
-0.0441192016,
-0.0850812644,
-0.0051554581,
0.0301246177,
-0.0312178656,
0.0245778132,
-0.0253297575,
-0.0285502635,
-0.0453084148,
-0.13206397,
0.0567846149,
-0.0251982976,
0.0523502976,
0.0154472794,
0.0056964424,
-0.0184967089,
-0.0076310383,
-0.0167777427,
-0.002043796,
-0.0101145692,
0.0368968658,
0.0582594201,
-0.0095325932,
-0.0388701037,
-0.0223818384,
0.0142560843,
-0.029245289,
0.0154273529,
0.049468305,
-0.0625150129,
-0.0380138159,
0.043186713,
-0.0332828499,
0.0165567677,
-0.0362292007,
-0.0005780958,
0.0051918183,
-0.0149987582,
-0.0069672186,
0.0830585733,
0.0046706991,
0.0492943786,
-0.0248216707,
-0.0165250264,
-0.0462405644,
0.0135097895,
-0.0434522666,
0.0005186262,
-0.0121977469,
-0.00924691,
0.0070463126,
0.0542983934,
-0.0392977372,
0.0356331691,
-0.0258365106,
-0.0012864098,
0.0153633105,
0.0177345239,
0.0014907548,
0.0243782289,
-0.029646514,
0.0149389319,
-0.0063993507,
-0.0177219901,
0.0248060264,
-0.041695863,
-0.0157648586,
-0.0113403937,
-0.0067418846,
-0.0605838411,
0.0574947298,
0.0110842809,
0.0056349458,
0.0277257357,
-0.0772652477,
-0.0231178571,
0.0496842787,
0.0044715828,
-0.0317861624,
0.0374731719,
0.0008595027,
0.0339668766,
-0.0217797663,
-0.0047920048,
-0.0290122591,
-0.0381283723,
-0.0457145162,
0.0112658776,
0.0065747867,
-0.0379161648,
-0.0337762982,
0.0541245975,
0.0005709059,
0.0490896292,
-0.0328654572,
-0.0053533334,
-0.0346583202,
0.050595127,
0.0168433469,
0.0272549111,
0.0253647771,
0.0150828836,
0.0119880727,
0.0394557379,
0.0045049214,
-0.0011896407,
-0.012974021,
-0.0236582849,
-0.0145654427,
-0.0750664547,
-0.0426937528,
-0.0200927779,
0.0195055399,
-0.0492128879,
0.0050598113,
0.1424524635,
0.0206023511,
-0.0614457428,
-0.040969532,
0.0133152194,
0.0038761408,
0.0001137871,
0.0105828447,
-0.1002007723,
-0.0158526041,
0.0201785956,
-0.0142202862,
-0.0328731835,
-0.0642632395,
-0.0223102216,
-0.1020645201,
0.0252330713,
-0.0174880046,
-0.0466908626,
0.0259443559,
-0.058526203,
-0.008328882,
-0.0463809296,
-0.0229457263,
0.0136049343,
-0.0212438349,
-0.00818484,
-0.0080883214,
-0.0344143435,
-0.0324964896,
0.0273492876,
-0.0417783745,
0.0701983869,
0.0387124643,
0.0598325431,
0.0023975864,
0.0007150326,
0.0255406536,
-0.0039213509,
-0.0120390365,
-0.0134641565,
0.1109575033,
-0.0532302521,
0.0010990342,
-0.0272069927,
0.0042688255,
0.008910317,
-0.0120539991,
0.0272709895,
0.0286610313,
-0.0194657557,
0.0215571262,
0.0123481844,
-0.0016165503,
0.0297546908,
0.094682388,
-0.0040850816,
0.0040146159,
-0.0585368462,
-0.0182190146,
0.0338326022,
0.0011311145,
-0.037674848,
-0.003340868,
-0.0424968116,
-0.0501307771,
-0.0758043304,
-0.037127655,
0.0093340632,
0.0475423597,
0.0101331407,
0.020794861,
0.0179600734,
0.0388365462,
-0.0335820429,
0.0155278808,
-0.0469427817,
-0.0096515715,
-0.0764551163,
-0.0080241235,
0.0430891663,
0.0077024479,
-0.016101053,
-0.0169843789,
-0.0965582728,
-0.0591723844,
0.010431231,
-0.0202043839,
0.0309391618,
0.0387020297,
-0.0231101923,
-0.0301860869,
0.011910039,
0.0243412964,
-0.0365247503,
-0.0067876568,
-0.0093056681,
0.0633070469,
-0.0203813482,
0.0240287557,
-0.0279853512,
0.0167038627,
-0.0130762057,
0.017907301,
-0.0614607744,
-0.0291343331,
-0.0097336899,
0.0253995378,
0.0432740115,
-0.0051720981,
0.0190362595,
-0.0106767016,
0.0152234733,
-0.0026389793,
0.030623015,
-0.009439501,
-0.0169232208,
-0.0180033632,
-0.0214559007,
-0.0140963923,
0.045244433,
-0.0333238207,
0.0668052286,
-0.0556030162,
-0.0040325853,
0.011749519,
0.016504731,
0.0029040028,
-0.0181522164,
0.0012552442,
0.0740100071,
0.0351388901,
0.0659391508,
-0.0115749147,
0.050359115,
0.0014811413,
0.0045516095,
0.0162267126,
-0.0128989657,
-0.1272545308,
-0.0291274805,
-0.0373322479,
0.1169035062,
0.0756047592,
0.0167937241,
0.0890482515,
-0.035873279,
-0.0172282085,
-0.0058513856,
0.0030561928,
0.0206802562,
-0.0089675868,
0.0125601208,
0.0290375389,
-0.0202656258,
0.0404130258,
0.0485394038,
-0.0049990797,
0.0533011369,
0.0448435992,
-0.0369277745,
-0.0446630642,
-0.0378817655,
0.0087812431,
-0.0393991955,
0.0001090605,
0.009231586,
-0.0447532982,
-0.0192232598,
0.0165253878,
-0.0038428744,
-0.0094013121,
-0.0572062768,
0.0081221117,
0.028811831,
0.0163166821,
-0.0158056412,
-0.0818722025,
0.0242350064,
-0.0353264026,
-0.0223433003,
-0.0220124107,
-5.783917832e-33,
-0.0555938259,
-0.0149883572,
0.0493538007,
0.0335945003,
-0.02847955,
0.0180910248,
-0.0561737455,
0.0086391512,
0.013823838,
-0.0241333134,
-0.0438438319,
0.0023725934,
0.028220769,
-0.0090110293,
-0.0271872077,
-0.0443323404,
0.0411629155,
-0.008169882,
-0.0329086967,
0.0297230892,
0.063636899,
0.0218304545,
0.0454593711,
-0.0534601994,
0.0566705428,
-0.0271141753,
0.0061714575,
0.0197706074,
0.0569566227,
0.0782147795,
-0.045633845,
-0.0473230705,
0.0293144416,
-0.0450348184,
0.0060256291,
0.0357886069,
-0.1111522168,
-0.000319987,
-0.0165413562,
0.0386983864,
0.0423583128,
-0.0214129891,
0.0132801756,
-0.0072142403,
-0.0043523018,
0.0176214036,
0.0250583608,
-0.0050140419,
-0.0081507685,
-0.0199741758,
-0.0556977913,
0.060892947,
0.0153021514,
0.0126011623,
0.0315700807,
-0.0055704964,
0.0196619928,
0.0014304458,
-0.0551395752,
-0.003085078,
0.0145649118,
0.0003377913,
-0.0009998052,
-0.0015729521,
-0.0400182381,
0.051288601,
0.0307515021,
-0.0000523672,
-0.0597045459,
0.011317363,
0.0060487892,
-0.00579764,
-0.0011702457,
0.0477774441,
0.0310383197,
0.0025222099,
-0.0312211905,
0.0242209528,
0.0659736842,
0.0192576032,
0.0219837949,
-0.0184124392,
-0.0570142418,
0.0125939874,
0.0025609524,
-0.0141647868,
-0.0319806226,
-0.03841649,
0.0276167449,
-0.0091735115,
-0.0106447712,
-0.0056427857,
0.0433710814,
-0.0377435721,
-0.046534963,
0.0051368298,
-0.0008852073,
0.029899992,
-0.0156519152,
0.0104816314,
-0.0869370848,
-0.0348014012,
0.0382011831,
0.0090778293,
0.0039666253,
-0.0004283043,
0.0066094836,
-0.0127573358,
-0.0585127138,
-0.0105099361,
-0.0010451181,
-0.0026585446,
-0.0141872987,
0.0237489473,
0.0134228803,
-0.0389632657,
0.0198053475,
0.0380210914,
0.0266472772,
0.00652867,
-0.0160246585,
0.0029425216,
0.024989415,
0.0055882828,
-0.034018524,
0.0041215615,
0.0129484618,
0.0263235196,
-0.0043284749,
-0.0690038875,
0.0146546476,
-0.0016455379,
2.476e-7,
0.0161506608,
0.0372303762,
0.0346178487,
0.0140085611,
0.0076843007,
0.0170785747,
-0.0150066474,
0.0307981092,
-0.0198586155,
0.000976229,
0.0103762504,
-0.0142660839,
0.0505557321,
0.044965487,
-0.1119580045,
-0.0628177971,
-0.045822423,
-0.0170745403,
-0.0668830872,
0.0322897844,
0.0265179947,
0.0697826147,
0.0012804697,
-0.0157050602,
-0.029256396,
-0.0484126732,
0.0505561419,
-0.0121546155,
-0.0350331478,
0.0470515862,
0.0563473925,
0.0518908538,
-0.0197343435,
0.0292656645,
0.0118772518,
0.033153113,
0.0142002022,
0.097012274,
0.0234219152,
-0.0293418206,
-0.0039567305,
-0.0412332974,
0.0033305762,
-0.0151804108,
0.0867706239,
-0.0141388448,
-0.0201995485,
-0.0195987169,
-0.0327359438,
-0.019425666,
0.0031352446,
0.0141843492,
-0.0398331061,
0.0132907415,
-0.0024451506,
-0.0341771916,
0.0039403574,
-0.0855882764,
0.0295353718,
-0.0199798904,
-0.0351304524,
-0.0604531243,
-0.0031800724,
-0.0234845486,
-0.0064762137,
-0.0423037484,
-0.0016009131,
2.282314118e-34,
0.0115108341,
0.009648527,
-0.0389877968,
0.0710199624,
0.0208518039,
0.0154704722,
-0.0021248353,
0.0020081347,
0.0022692021,
-0.069307223,
0.0074126623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17276v1 | Humans in Humans Out: On GPT Converging Toward Common Sense in both Success and Failure | 2023-03-30T10:32:18 | 2023-03-30T10:32:18 | Philipp Koralus, Vincent Wang-Maścianica | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, 00, 68, I.2.0; I.2.6 | Increase in computational scale and fine-tuning has seen a dramatic
improvement in the quality of outputs of large language models (LLMs) like GPT.
Given that both GPT-3 and GPT-4 were trained on large quantities of
human-generated text, we might ask to what extent their outputs reflect
patterns of human thinking, both for correct and incorrect cases. The Erotetic
Theory of Reason (ETR) provides a symbolic generative model of both human
success and failure in thinking, across propositional, quantified, and
probabilistic reasoning, as well as decision-making. We presented GPT-3,
GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 with 61 central inference and judgment problems from a
recent book-length presentation of ETR, consisting of experimentally verified
data-points on human judgment and extrapolated data-points predicted by ETR,
with correct inference patterns as well as fallacies and framing effects (the
ETR61 benchmark). ETR61 includes classics like Wason's card task, illusory
inferences, the decoy effect, and opportunity-cost neglect, among others. GPT-3
showed evidence of ETR-predicted outputs for 59% of these examples, rising to
77% in GPT-3.5 and 75% in GPT-4. Remarkably, the production of human-like
fallacious judgments increased from 18% in GPT-3 to 33% in GPT-3.5 and 34% in
GPT-4. This suggests that larger and more advanced LLMs may develop a tendency
toward more human-like mistakes, as relevant thought patterns are inherent in
human-produced training data. According to ETR, the same fundamental patterns
are involved both in successful and unsuccessful ordinary reasoning, so that
the "bad" cases could paradoxically be learned from the "good" cases. We
further present preliminary evidence that ETR-inspired prompt engineering could
reduce instances of these mistakes. | [
0.0281492099,
0.0375922024,
-0.0224910323,
-0.0060157999,
-0.0349690691,
0.0530930981,
-0.0345575921,
0.0422916897,
0.0323048942,
-0.0498571955,
-0.0018274509,
-0.0000866562,
-0.0054956144,
-0.0155858174,
0.0637584403,
-0.0545350835,
0.0277122483,
-0.0152932657,
0.0483421311,
-0.0308225621,
-0.0181845631,
0.0054187751,
0.0115532819,
0.0130528836,
-0.0024289982,
-0.0097556477,
0.005770993,
-0.0003197754,
0.0186828636,
-0.0522172228,
-0.0100014796,
0.0534893572,
0.0256462693,
0.0474210232,
0.0000024149,
-0.0235794503,
0.0421679094,
-0.0176185779,
0.0013672395,
0.0464965031,
0.0389291272,
0.0213811751,
-0.0025431348,
0.0256444253,
-0.0239855759,
-0.013286991,
0.0063679391,
0.1079415902,
0.0047894754,
0.0705847591,
0.010614668,
-0.0321578421,
0.0502295159,
-0.0548599921,
0.0187284704,
-0.0090961158,
0.0321987942,
0.009910522,
-0.0393943265,
-0.0127030658,
-0.0028643091,
-0.0210300367,
0.0520258397,
0.033283297,
-0.076775603,
0.0554486886,
-0.0307561718,
-0.0310417004,
-0.0075806631,
0.0083817597,
0.033587195,
-0.0391604342,
-0.022092022,
-0.0188598316,
0.0202340409,
0.0355954692,
-0.0110139893,
0.0312187951,
-0.0374813676,
0.0310504902,
0.0538200252,
-0.0373807251,
0.0138217481,
0.0195702296,
0.0169459619,
0.0476538986,
0.0099434974,
-0.0414120853,
0.0449365266,
0.0313160382,
-0.0723519474,
-0.0549243055,
-0.0475760996,
-0.0194545239,
0.0136043997,
0.0000996036,
-0.0021264288,
0.0172967445,
0.0367071368,
-0.0180842672,
-0.0236653294,
0.0541541986,
0.0317191258,
0.0180585012,
-0.0214730781,
0.0318480469,
-0.0396329947,
0.0526795499,
-0.0024303312,
0.0251958594,
-0.0335459635,
-0.0358801857,
-0.0010723126,
0.0310294777,
0.0065341364,
0.0360806882,
-0.0954004005,
-0.0272738151,
-0.0423517153,
-0.0315197073,
-0.0059997616,
0.0322670564,
-0.0115935756,
-0.0402359813,
-0.0978634804,
0.0080213463,
-0.0231330208,
0.0353879705,
0.0199690089,
-0.0466658361,
-0.0130485669,
0.0127680711,
-0.0366182886,
-0.0127191842,
0.0235831086,
0.0231305435,
0.0117510753,
-0.0153261842,
-0.0455904976,
0.0028320549,
-0.0099246195,
-0.0537188053,
-0.0114774192,
-0.0567287952,
-0.0361657105,
0.0136393001,
0.0046454589,
-0.0453730449,
0.0099551249,
0.028869316,
-0.0552197844,
0.0292987954,
-0.0356566831,
0.0228501726,
0.0361303724,
0.0324077345,
-0.018975582,
0.0283873621,
0.023271285,
0.0323761366,
-0.019416282,
-0.0045951395,
0.0141419703,
-0.0022348892,
0.0179015417,
-0.0152165098,
-0.0048177657,
-0.0058437022,
-0.0494634584,
0.0405722186,
0.0682964623,
0.0713600442,
-0.0538326688,
-0.0030227811,
0.0468280017,
0.0539894402,
-0.031762179,
0.0344301499,
0.0418060906,
-0.000802857,
0.00676378,
0.0255925246,
-0.0765407681,
0.0260963906,
-0.0252276752,
-0.0295070745,
-0.0050555151,
0.006851438,
-0.0368373543,
0.0002768248,
-0.001178244,
0.0215636455,
0.0095605133,
-0.0087899566,
0.0104424749,
-0.0438539088,
-0.0593689978,
0.0147914058,
0.0260494668,
-0.0338781923,
-0.0352871977,
-0.0654885471,
0.0461498946,
0.0040991399,
0.0200499166,
0.0348996557,
0.0141496612,
-0.0007402865,
-0.021186484,
0.0523317344,
0.0520419888,
-0.0052926983,
-0.0486591831,
-0.0162953511,
-0.0033154557,
-0.0109817097,
0.0229781438,
0.0328397788,
-0.0182387326,
0.046295099,
0.0280549098,
-0.0094113871,
0.0022016668,
0.0283677969,
-0.0090603186,
0.0081280321,
-0.0743283108,
-0.0040171151,
0.0445617996,
-0.0228212513,
0.0001685231,
0.0258355718,
0.0119068399,
-0.0030306689,
-0.0264492948,
0.0516150594,
-0.0402100869,
-0.0003185004,
0.0084947757,
-0.060091842,
-0.0510522798,
-0.000666314,
-0.0179160051,
-0.0209730361,
0.0018498804,
-0.0650907084,
0.0657745674,
-0.0579118617,
0.0041442299,
-0.0160878394,
-0.0123341242,
0.0091863303,
0.1183050647,
-0.0088128448,
0.0092556886,
-0.0287574101,
-0.0292984433,
0.0427777618,
-0.0409520529,
-0.0038571521,
-0.0065611177,
0.050494615,
-0.0054411711,
0.0173577517,
0.0160449781,
-0.0694804639,
0.0044815275,
-0.0764390528,
-0.0229103882,
-0.0046611349,
0.0234407168,
0.0194199849,
-0.0719716772,
-0.02962026,
0.0265719816,
0.0054664877,
-0.0025737244,
0.0349920914,
0.0499669239,
0.0224865321,
-0.0467134379,
-0.0104411533,
0.0055708806,
0.01882945,
-0.0385528319,
-0.0140797319,
0.0045282939,
0.0375827141,
-0.0406165458,
0.0743271932,
0.0001688643,
-0.016864894,
-0.0174870789,
-0.0270724613,
0.0202294458,
0.0448662415,
0.0310458895,
0.0282237735,
0.0098462831,
0.0572155043,
0.0013785313,
0.0156026455,
-0.0317391492,
-0.0084748929,
-0.0397244543,
-0.0112333344,
-0.0187791176,
-0.0740316734,
-0.041446384,
0.0496804379,
0.042400118,
0.0104901772,
-0.0846422911,
0.0592700616,
-0.0251058377,
-0.0386246815,
-0.0112887733,
-0.056105528,
-0.0055744946,
0.0419055261,
-0.0241052508,
-0.0599837638,
0.0717103854,
0.0331911892,
0.0329410359,
-0.0109326318,
0.0251302049,
-0.0019535087,
0.0457532071,
0.0374510363,
-0.0123547222,
0.0051040743,
-0.0209148731,
-0.0853386745,
-0.050395105,
0.0118296957,
-0.0049544848,
0.0307058711,
-0.0691922531,
-0.0059310002,
0.0078007127,
-0.0542019717,
-0.0188468918,
-0.0144471498,
-0.0453461148,
-0.0233358294,
-0.0183197893,
-0.0059162038,
-0.0396631695,
-0.0272374544,
0.0367909148,
-0.0178015009,
-0.0040534842,
-0.0324358977,
0.0296251904,
-0.0157963485,
0.0093146767,
0.0019810605,
0.0597703047,
-0.0607545562,
0.0023524347,
0.1106644198,
-0.0103779463,
0.0238531902,
-0.0233515352,
0.0268319342,
0.0025437211,
0.02175368,
-0.0489510931,
0.0241202153,
0.0601251423,
-0.0184260663,
0.0222099703,
0.10064473,
-0.0005036595,
-0.0313695446,
0.0076957187,
-0.0356702134,
0.0406187326,
0.0165350605,
-0.0164528452,
-0.0494424105,
-0.0283337273,
0.008830619,
0.0185486153,
-0.0606154092,
-0.0553499125,
0.0352992639,
-0.1155799851,
0.0610027313,
-0.0046506701,
0.0096402094,
-0.0437186621,
-0.0324324295,
0.0001842202,
0.0067837811,
-0.0092479493,
0.0330586359,
0.002532609,
0.0288056005,
0.0150722396,
-0.0098048327,
-0.0340728723,
0.0450762287,
-0.0096851736,
0.0415720008,
0.0027111988,
0.090083167,
-0.0281086173,
-0.07691551,
0.0236349422,
-0.0420379154,
0.0101324795,
-0.0183847789,
0.0085927825,
-0.0053201546,
0.0325458907,
-0.0817608163,
0.0564697534,
-0.0196886547,
-0.0494530648,
-0.005527867,
0.0791113675,
-0.0139986649,
-0.066118367,
-0.0195226409,
-0.0044744168,
-0.034109775,
0.0820998028,
-0.008899956,
0.0123459902,
-0.0530681945,
-0.0084967827,
0.0464923233,
0.0006049915,
-0.0337306336,
0.0188316796,
0.037101727,
-0.0197642613,
-0.023964107,
-0.0717523247,
-0.0084430156,
-0.0035356169,
-0.000378836,
-0.020308936,
-0.0152329057,
0.0038942292,
0.0011689962,
0.0234889761,
0.0038933835,
-0.0253849421,
-0.0155199766,
0.0148056466,
-0.0198220462,
-0.0302419811,
-0.0204937961,
0.0139646567,
-0.0518593155,
-0.040375784,
0.017541267,
0.0175577421,
0.0338782035,
0.0047510699,
0.0217904281,
-0.0284237601,
0.0278507974,
0.0251212437,
0.0054127462,
0.0650095046,
-0.0167623367,
0.0061199646,
0.0196644086,
0.0355617702,
0.0206715222,
0.0299583599,
0.0274119526,
0.0259487722,
-0.0268217549,
0.0184667353,
0.0647915602,
0.0069714957,
0.048351869,
-0.0542824566,
0.0118711544,
-0.0426475815,
-0.0232722368,
-0.0134586021,
-0.0055757253,
-0.0042876024,
0.0071243462,
0.0402871892,
0.0033306195,
-0.0435024276,
-0.0548339076,
-0.0331127048,
0.0234132502,
-0.0071636382,
0.005978764,
0.0277464855,
0.0519535355,
0.0150381159,
-0.0216720607,
0.0044708052,
-0.0104166092,
-0.0492325015,
0.0659644604,
-0.0061875819,
0.1094541475,
0.0433445536,
-0.0276995786,
0.0355709344,
-0.0319804624,
-0.0544652976,
-0.060224425,
0.0106500918,
0.0203011576,
0.018019747,
0.0118000954,
0.018631123,
-0.0540739372,
-0.0052790572,
0.0054075201,
0.0084458599,
-0.012189243,
0.001014891,
0.0415238366,
0.0036867401,
-0.0388481356,
0.0025356279,
0.0430823602,
-0.0356334001,
0.0444144011,
-0.0193936508,
-0.0496849492,
-0.0024611526,
-0.0403913148,
-0.0035794049,
-0.0342211314,
-0.0085337507,
0.0356555171,
-0.1008583605,
-0.0590219833,
-0.0345116369,
0.0707685053,
0.0156109007,
-0.0252632778,
0.0058895466,
0.0948635191,
-0.0160569958,
-0.0164241549,
-0.0006966821,
0.0503336564,
-0.0474812947,
0.0361572616,
-0.0648895428,
-6.917764418e-33,
-0.0129985865,
-0.0488516651,
0.0120299468,
-0.0197989512,
-0.0237800684,
-0.0262130424,
-0.0070693255,
0.0322673023,
-0.0040599895,
0.0831967816,
0.0044438876,
0.0361954011,
-0.0023102865,
-0.0104148546,
0.0366076864,
0.0039613354,
-0.0044740066,
-0.0038914129,
-0.0230653081,
0.010146278,
0.0235882457,
-0.0142165758,
0.0534461588,
-0.0390436128,
0.0537108257,
0.0114227822,
-0.0009856051,
-0.0019335139,
-0.0303746983,
-0.0363064967,
-0.013526001,
0.0221870895,
0.0339383557,
-0.040150106,
0.0238880031,
-0.0183254071,
-0.0226550288,
-0.0322724693,
0.0681942254,
-0.0620053075,
-0.0059053325,
-0.0217580311,
0.0162740499,
0.0034046008,
-0.0704037771,
0.0185258444,
0.0200100094,
0.0275075343,
0.0194945317,
0.0316969603,
-0.045366101,
0.0213896818,
0.0132826259,
0.0447217003,
-0.0666190609,
0.0286445487,
-0.0329223424,
0.027095357,
-0.1085425168,
0.0104089426,
-0.0227515511,
-0.0395653248,
0.0207727905,
-0.043148119,
0.0137700755,
0.0883566514,
0.0582537651,
0.030510176,
-0.0653326511,
-0.0049375105,
-0.019755153,
0.0344938189,
0.0385790765,
0.0466197953,
0.0420713201,
-0.0610055923,
-0.0730441138,
-0.0151783293,
0.0105452873,
0.0456738323,
0.057465978,
-0.0011785702,
-0.0662841648,
-0.0142083112,
-0.0115539273,
-0.0489466414,
-0.0225661807,
-0.0292018577,
-0.0041918606,
-0.0028704347,
0.026106704,
-0.0155575788,
0.0042572585,
0.025339881,
0.0377346575,
-0.0350559652,
-0.0380075872,
-0.0229374096,
0.0047416706,
0.0473169535,
-0.0557650998,
-0.0168652665,
-0.0129025336,
0.0210658945,
0.0365933478,
0.003006692,
0.0067464611,
-0.0141813047,
-0.0163934976,
-0.0135069164,
-0.039552778,
0.000414612,
-0.0125612253,
-0.0610821545,
0.0377138741,
0.0585764349,
-0.002482929,
-0.0579489805,
0.0089247152,
0.0095848143,
-0.0257190764,
0.0342016965,
0.023176657,
0.0263494737,
0.0117686559,
-0.0221542194,
-0.0040455558,
-0.0009400923,
0.030323578,
-0.060698159,
-0.0280478615,
0.0146007733,
3.153e-7,
0.0400407352,
0.0453711115,
0.0096152201,
0.0012644874,
0.0324073844,
0.0702258497,
0.0019026664,
0.0030778665,
0.0873779058,
-0.0319974124,
-0.0012000612,
0.0148474472,
0.0263290703,
0.0431341194,
-0.0194307622,
0.0143855326,
-0.0545705557,
-0.0406307541,
0.0117300916,
0.0347593464,
0.0712544173,
0.0295933355,
0.0373264588,
-0.0403072946,
0.0027183734,
0.0174504109,
0.0734992251,
-0.0350850672,
-0.0105320653,
-0.0257077757,
0.010848416,
0.0294389613,
0.0010216895,
0.0815156326,
0.0257174242,
-0.0076894648,
0.0053757038,
0.0142315384,
-0.0387296341,
-0.0124493726,
-0.0266623888,
-0.0217457004,
-0.0043648789,
-0.0758568868,
0.0391062088,
-0.0597900674,
-0.0626774654,
0.0418878309,
-0.0412128754,
-0.0103576938,
0.0147601385,
0.0118984077,
-0.0163650792,
-0.0281506833,
0.015924627,
0.0065599303,
0.0071225548,
-0.0543397963,
0.0071061417,
0.0443746485,
-0.06286484,
-0.0733610913,
-0.0456576496,
0.0296578463,
0.047480084,
-0.0535591356,
-0.0180547033,
2.814976067e-34,
0.0338948704,
-0.0079707652,
0.0154547179,
-0.0248865932,
0.0524200238,
0.0359612852,
0.0645409524,
0.0026776255,
0.0289697815,
-0.0319230966,
-0.0290267132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17183v1 | The Nordic Pile: A 1.2TB Nordic Dataset for Language Modeling | 2023-03-30T06:42:22 | 2023-03-30T06:42:22 | Joey Öhman, Severine Verlinden, Ariel Ekgren, Amaru Cuba Gyllensten, Tim Isbister, Evangelia Gogoulou, Fredrik Carlsson, Magnus Sahlgren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-training Large Language Models (LLMs) require massive amounts of text
data, and the performance of the LLMs typically correlates with the scale and
quality of the datasets. This means that it may be challenging to build LLMs
for smaller languages such as Nordic ones, where the availability of text
corpora is limited. In order to facilitate the development of the LLMS in the
Nordic languages, we curate a high-quality dataset consisting of 1.2TB of text,
in all of the major North Germanic languages (Danish, Icelandic, Norwegian, and
Swedish), as well as some high-quality English data. This paper details our
considerations and processes for collecting, cleaning, and filtering the
dataset. | [
0.0469780229,
0.0864459202,
-0.007324636,
0.0607494451,
-0.0097762309,
0.0064293901,
-0.0058463519,
-0.0045149084,
-0.0060177338,
-0.0251874086,
-0.0135208378,
-0.0594545677,
0.0223841667,
-0.0071283174,
0.0394518226,
-0.0505370796,
0.049050577,
-0.0564654171,
-0.0182341374,
-0.0360657312,
0.0029526684,
0.0494232252,
-0.0165838804,
0.0164706279,
-0.0021869317,
-0.0010101638,
0.014301355,
0.0068314834,
0.0034752623,
0.0227908902,
0.0089614009,
0.033535894,
0.0143514508,
0.0766671076,
0.0000017503,
-0.0311617889,
0.0295374487,
-0.0353253596,
-0.0252278745,
0.0942386463,
0.079153657,
-0.015708318,
-0.0068500242,
-0.0190061461,
0.0165100805,
-0.0429968387,
0.0231801271,
-0.0211547446,
0.0483324043,
0.0645731017,
-0.0110665374,
-0.037204545,
-0.0155252526,
-0.0420653038,
-0.0578224733,
0.0198687632,
0.0570699126,
0.0435285978,
0.0096525569,
0.0286561046,
-0.0288670976,
0.0495520085,
0.0139781795,
0.0369118825,
-0.0114979334,
0.0452006422,
-0.0240196809,
-0.0261431467,
-0.0082882019,
0.0821575448,
-0.0187186599,
-0.0537703708,
0.0121691069,
-0.0267928001,
-0.0605024733,
-0.0203770585,
-0.0000492233,
0.0039478992,
0.007155017,
0.0328902937,
0.0331559516,
-0.0271346029,
0.0297593381,
0.0284024812,
-0.0177229103,
0.0193871111,
0.0068333312,
-0.021328412,
0.0610801764,
0.0044884481,
-0.0225053038,
-0.0322247706,
-0.0302045438,
-0.0154063953,
0.005939215,
-0.0164097603,
-0.0324982591,
-0.0598281287,
0.0456525162,
-0.023692267,
0.0495297909,
-0.0401400365,
-0.045814272,
0.0295878835,
0.0261601843,
-0.0028905249,
0.0051055839,
-0.002762143,
-0.0562915839,
-0.0242255274,
0.0057880282,
0.0189173296,
-0.0492229275,
-0.0144479461,
-0.0278026666,
0.0023971312,
-0.0361950994,
-0.0400227867,
0.0216580164,
-0.0156342052,
0.0326096229,
-0.030178966,
-0.0278897583,
0.0043385443,
-0.0114637883,
0.0040397239,
0.0102732526,
0.0444149598,
-0.0953691378,
-0.0253121816,
0.0317202806,
0.0220026504,
0.0400049686,
-0.0422150642,
0.0727458671,
0.0047451174,
0.0100325784,
-0.0113704624,
-0.020648282,
0.0196442939,
0.0057213614,
-0.074275665,
-0.01711265,
-0.0658491328,
0.0383511037,
-0.0153788207,
-0.0137960073,
-0.0458289012,
-0.0199558958,
-0.0062556197,
-0.053788051,
0.0465168506,
-0.0521009117,
0.0200396311,
-0.0035827798,
-0.0325106643,
0.0120318877,
0.0478412211,
0.0045407666,
-0.0106202336,
0.0487624146,
-0.0317819826,
-0.0004004654,
0.0818369463,
0.0338979885,
0.0213705078,
-0.0364334397,
0.0359606743,
-0.0317081213,
-0.0122322626,
0.0537320413,
0.0394640192,
0.009771551,
-0.0304802954,
0.0645240396,
0.0425363481,
0.0352791585,
0.0258815717,
0.0372528136,
0.0253207665,
-0.010680506,
-0.0548853315,
-0.0314195864,
-0.0412557572,
0.0218792632,
-0.0101555102,
0.0074020764,
0.0441828966,
-0.0074446602,
-0.0152971614,
0.000956626,
-0.0078664068,
0.0095228599,
0.0510002263,
0.0173243266,
-0.0299761798,
-0.0035862252,
0.0525903217,
0.0315424949,
-0.0647845566,
0.0618351325,
0.0201051701,
0.0412363857,
0.0045864889,
0.0098179653,
-0.0029126247,
-0.0365275778,
-0.0462990291,
0.0522536524,
-0.0051248227,
0.0595468506,
-0.0216792542,
0.0469601862,
-0.0481741242,
0.0148627916,
0.0360135399,
0.0024140573,
0.042287562,
0.0063033681,
0.0136350524,
-0.0140464203,
-0.0348433182,
-0.0551550724,
0.0314791054,
-0.045222871,
0.0157698505,
-0.0146106537,
-0.0032511281,
0.0439531729,
0.0423268154,
-0.0463135988,
-0.0073288111,
0.0583266653,
-0.0551723056,
-0.0103865806,
0.0016166215,
0.021562865,
-0.0163601562,
0.034216024,
-0.0099363467,
-0.0236941054,
0.0271280203,
-0.04864816,
-0.0215198062,
0.0439198874,
0.010255916,
-0.0047668703,
-0.008138245,
-0.0029492099,
-0.0090986984,
0.0319996513,
0.0011840423,
0.045410417,
-0.0076611252,
0.0753488094,
0.0133783752,
-0.0257830601,
0.031133296,
-0.0644121915,
-0.039133165,
0.0357608497,
-0.0262520872,
0.0377854407,
0.030007042,
0.0046099266,
-0.0094541945,
0.0261609405,
-0.0450994521,
0.0180486515,
-0.0472129583,
0.0354646258,
0.0265622418,
0.0203875564,
-0.0287116859,
-0.0123804556,
-0.0469253138,
-0.0204606168,
0.012991542,
0.0014320874,
-0.0038671719,
-0.0166267008,
-0.0330304801,
-0.0259668306,
-0.037818823,
0.0193758681,
0.0461922549,
-0.0282356702,
-0.0596273132,
-0.023456974,
0.0753614306,
-0.0534515604,
0.0544033237,
-0.0134812966,
-0.0488284864,
-0.0373697355,
-0.0091190571,
0.0702452064,
0.0247026067,
-0.0516547859,
-0.0468947068,
0.0251801815,
-0.0119495979,
-0.0422249623,
-0.0172988046,
-0.0476066992,
0.0319974236,
-0.0532630086,
-0.0300210118,
-0.0040895157,
0.0523910299,
0.0278587136,
-0.0276885293,
-0.0206147768,
0.0118127968,
-0.0414190739,
0.0399817005,
-0.0466254056,
-0.010564262,
0.0175005551,
0.0874277204,
-0.0431900397,
-0.0277278088,
0.0315337367,
-0.0285355709,
-0.0028527915,
-0.0346156135,
-0.034574084,
-0.0321817286,
0.0564686954,
0.033117339,
0.0109665059,
-0.0261220969,
0.0044049555,
-0.0192895569,
-0.0258144829,
0.0381658152,
-0.023334587,
0.056597393,
-0.0474049821,
0.031089494,
0.0071108066,
-0.0212196428,
-0.0059059532,
-0.0661392808,
-0.0583839156,
0.0001495338,
-0.0097277844,
-0.0058024451,
-0.0400343016,
-0.0200427379,
-0.010294741,
0.0391753614,
0.0271268226,
0.052155707,
-0.032702256,
-0.0037359023,
0.0280290712,
0.010926309,
-0.0031776957,
-0.0015824571,
-0.0184446219,
0.0060035437,
0.0224322584,
0.0151576754,
-0.0074171461,
-0.0128018474,
0.0632632002,
-0.0060014287,
-0.0312417541,
-0.0138405813,
0.0411345772,
-0.0082545243,
0.0048856144,
0.0456992239,
-0.0057320409,
0.0135524096,
0.0215720646,
0.0383873582,
0.0402807929,
0.036821641,
0.0050123986,
-0.0888808444,
-0.0150054609,
-0.0060196444,
0.0014721211,
0.0108302254,
-0.0194381848,
-0.0358226411,
-0.0848634988,
0.0310936552,
0.0328192972,
-0.0571973808,
-0.0178713482,
-0.0310722161,
-0.0283205956,
-0.1110252291,
-0.0250268057,
-0.0013793425,
-0.018069258,
0.017171273,
0.0188717935,
-0.0406185277,
-0.0697993785,
0.0362594835,
-0.0396597236,
0.0480941795,
0.0243144743,
0.0259534158,
-0.0383846238,
-0.0731675625,
0.0570068881,
-0.0104588838,
-0.0685984641,
-0.0182774831,
0.0549148135,
0.0148364436,
-0.0036429057,
-0.0159394387,
0.0690946132,
-0.0422419272,
-0.0295913611,
0.0156492274,
0.0692190602,
0.0226123706,
-0.0207357928,
0.0519769378,
0.0328833535,
0.0274763983,
0.0533623956,
0.0370653719,
-0.0174776204,
-0.0086459592,
-0.0087525938,
-0.0062906607,
-0.0156940836,
-0.0285012536,
0.0474856496,
-0.0061130654,
0.0015419127,
-0.0284987707,
-0.0226729512,
0.0435043275,
-0.0028040935,
0.0419367813,
0.0344625823,
-0.0021876353,
-0.039355211,
-0.0490496084,
0.0485037453,
-0.0241694264,
0.0357055254,
-0.0322718658,
-0.0114898263,
0.0361610502,
-0.0042490019,
-0.0203241799,
0.0165850781,
-0.0827632025,
-0.0776433572,
0.0266811438,
0.0296353884,
0.0180015843,
0.0950597301,
0.0090914024,
-0.0765731558,
0.0290687419,
0.0078087905,
-0.0584886521,
0.032233458,
0.0265699923,
-0.0036653362,
0.0227019023,
0.0277163051,
-0.0221798122,
0.0685402378,
0.0274270903,
-0.0241896026,
0.0093704471,
-0.0234160386,
-0.0205257945,
0.0456921048,
0.0410757363,
-0.061993517,
-0.0282320194,
-0.1056780294,
0.0071282671,
0.0165618602,
-0.020869758,
-0.027200494,
0.011826368,
0.04014761,
0.0252550542,
-0.045747228,
0.0300723016,
-0.0737575293,
0.0465428159,
-0.0403316468,
0.0449348539,
0.030320812,
0.0218287464,
0.0740296766,
0.0279404651,
0.0070882789,
0.0367564224,
-0.0084469086,
0.0465986915,
-0.0171586592,
-0.0099186003,
-0.0039801262,
0.0046146903,
-0.0148169799,
0.0083745057,
-0.0544928014,
-0.0172222629,
0.0046264809,
-0.0547153056,
0.0699674711,
-0.0367995128,
0.0974486694,
-0.0262863934,
0.0162463132,
-0.0222173408,
0.072702609,
-0.0095371772,
-0.0483381078,
0.0336042568,
0.0002227018,
-0.0546082035,
0.0342052802,
0.0440521203,
-0.0079097934,
0.0495626442,
0.0533741377,
0.0041653225,
-0.0308706798,
-0.0170020312,
0.0153493173,
-0.0178430378,
-0.0657391921,
0.0007959742,
-0.0679776669,
-0.0632786304,
-0.0270626955,
0.0061090845,
-0.0284124259,
0.0152327102,
0.0153624639,
0.0443104059,
0.0229470078,
0.0305450056,
-0.0676950291,
0.0101036094,
-0.0362593271,
-0.0616669133,
-0.0311658923,
-5.88591511e-33,
0.0210308563,
0.0447713137,
0.0069026458,
-0.0112538682,
-0.0165564679,
-0.0092646154,
0.036524877,
-0.0190351661,
-0.0093804877,
0.0159116983,
0.0064198608,
-0.0005443771,
0.0088003492,
0.0341113582,
-0.0425036028,
-0.0051155942,
0.0546860695,
-0.013419481,
0.0110194366,
0.0039046016,
-0.0007319755,
0.0272503104,
0.108387731,
-0.0484424382,
0.0199074727,
0.0079211202,
0.0050104614,
0.0355106294,
0.0252462439,
0.0227417834,
-0.0288994331,
0.067449905,
0.0183593333,
0.0018633677,
-0.0233673714,
0.0080499956,
-0.0703079626,
-0.0087333955,
0.0304692462,
0.042582307,
0.0038670613,
-0.0156402383,
0.0170053393,
-0.0359583795,
-0.0096731652,
0.0139969382,
0.0334581472,
0.0007772394,
-0.0257924013,
0.0163972843,
0.0007276544,
0.021052137,
-0.026917642,
-0.0062614367,
0.028852785,
0.0347870588,
0.0154730547,
0.0026390168,
-0.0833126605,
0.0554397404,
0.0087925671,
0.0171868503,
0.0283181164,
-0.0168782733,
0.0219341796,
0.0819888711,
0.0178306065,
0.0116438782,
-0.030568596,
0.0190090109,
0.0585148148,
0.0125664687,
0.0349017568,
0.037152864,
0.0589542799,
-0.0278040301,
-0.0967807099,
0.0018909016,
0.0072849826,
-0.0020013328,
-0.0064283158,
-0.0476950556,
-0.0258708745,
-0.0500870906,
-0.0437429994,
-0.0908345208,
-0.0120594855,
-0.0122686327,
0.0354862586,
-0.0162741169,
-0.0038511127,
-0.000100266,
0.0286287833,
-0.0498256162,
-0.0671867207,
-0.0001595902,
-0.011303735,
-0.012394079,
-0.0037457657,
0.0436839238,
-0.0629106537,
-0.0442296825,
-0.0060643605,
0.0179124605,
0.0117692584,
-0.0051266043,
0.0554396324,
0.0290102102,
-0.051411584,
0.020293463,
-0.0288000759,
0.0351754241,
-0.0010112191,
0.0424351282,
0.0359871835,
0.0286474023,
0.0035804827,
0.0305379685,
0.0405227467,
-0.0331035331,
-0.0082786782,
-0.0349298455,
-0.0248423014,
0.0547009259,
-0.019927986,
-0.0237311795,
-0.0435472839,
-0.0320527256,
0.0747995675,
-0.0186474454,
0.0092813084,
-0.0291138012,
2.247e-7,
0.0493041426,
0.0217588264,
0.0012218734,
-0.0330453068,
0.0085315825,
-0.0099270251,
-0.0285011772,
0.0321781598,
-0.0359995067,
0.0170467589,
0.0152150681,
0.0039499155,
0.049137339,
0.0269224178,
-0.0777864754,
-0.0212053023,
-0.0638456643,
-0.0001918752,
-0.0708995759,
-0.0420353599,
0.0047721104,
0.1305598915,
0.0150491158,
-0.0259486474,
-0.0361454226,
-0.0387562476,
0.0447689965,
-0.0845019445,
0.0038286243,
0.0239855554,
0.029635461,
0.0083969235,
0.0222340655,
-0.0108623765,
-0.0091075599,
0.024671698,
0.0156124132,
0.0480136424,
0.0102968067,
0.0087890523,
0.0026514616,
0.0007321981,
-0.0448883623,
-0.0298196562,
0.0537633635,
-0.0495720506,
-0.0557955764,
-0.017229639,
-0.0158558376,
0.0533450283,
0.0287978239,
-0.0323994085,
0.0165895689,
0.0322819427,
0.0526446737,
-0.0354007222,
-0.034148097,
-0.026478434,
-0.0600213632,
0.0233428609,
-0.0174511094,
-0.0214679968,
-0.0037133337,
0.0020882611,
-0.0207508337,
-0.0122592608,
0.0194225926,
1.883836112e-34,
0.0299682673,
-0.0158355292,
-0.0240356699,
-0.0183412507,
0.0265482161,
-0.0579372011,
0.044421237,
0.0177524313,
-0.0248951614,
-0.0380474627,
0.000364337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03287v1 | Synthesis of Mathematical programs from Natural Language Specifications | 2023-03-30T06:10:00 | 2023-03-30T06:10:00 | Ganesh Prasath, Shirish Karande | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Several decision problems that are encountered in various business domains
can be modeled as mathematical programs, i.e. optimization problems. The
process of conducting such modeling often requires the involvement of experts
trained in operations research and advanced algorithms. Surprisingly, despite
the significant advances in the methods for program and code synthesis, AutoML,
learning to optimize etc., there has been little or no attention paid to
automating the task of synthesizing mathematical programs. We imagine a
scenario where the specifications for modeling, i.e. the objective and
constraints are expressed in an unstructured form in natural language (NL) and
the mathematical program has to be synthesized from such an NL specification.
In this work we evaluate the efficacy of employing CodeT5 with data
augmentation and post-processing of beams. We utilize GPT-3 with back
translation for generation of synthetic examples. Further we apply rules of
linear programming to score beams and correct beams based on common error
patterns. We observe that with these enhancements CodeT5 base gives an
execution accuracy of 0.73 which is significantly better than zero-shot
execution accuracy of 0.41 by ChatGPT and 0.36 by Codex. | [
-0.0094900401,
0.0843571275,
-0.0285263192,
0.0397376344,
-0.0106728161,
-0.0329708979,
-0.0255560111,
-0.0195947848,
-0.0306533501,
-0.0553880818,
0.0122356908,
0.043566592,
-0.0058727055,
0.0939523801,
0.0212166328,
-0.0278072935,
0.0058575841,
-0.0026570717,
-0.0035140833,
0.0190763846,
0.0143557535,
0.0039433944,
0.0180065725,
-0.0047532539,
-0.0351573564,
-0.0015195369,
-0.0340171754,
-0.0004319689,
-0.0023093859,
-0.0311768278,
-0.0125365527,
0.0461315922,
0.0372853801,
-0.0035352181,
0.0000023935,
-0.0421641394,
-0.0444793589,
0.0261987783,
-0.0375110731,
0.0129817007,
0.0324203223,
-0.0450203605,
0.0036480387,
0.0281660445,
-0.0540008284,
0.0218931716,
0.0399846062,
-0.0198042896,
0.1202929169,
0.0711610392,
-0.0296166074,
-0.0618862398,
0.0223771054,
0.0209274068,
-0.0061221104,
-0.0531867705,
-0.0070643905,
0.0479431674,
0.0378099382,
0.0256098583,
-0.0005516221,
0.0228210911,
0.0459165685,
-0.0199701115,
0.005415305,
-0.022310121,
-0.0747550055,
-0.0002045632,
-0.0338984691,
0.0282901376,
0.0147723891,
-0.034358073,
0.0287387799,
-0.024951959,
-0.0051580798,
-0.0735849142,
-0.0329643562,
0.0090802852,
-0.0114291767,
0.0002369905,
-0.0213864781,
-0.0004247263,
0.0036611871,
-0.0241835713,
0.0004998535,
0.0603326932,
-0.0079270042,
-0.0424651504,
-0.0217040274,
-0.0089640534,
-0.0516893119,
-0.0176905617,
0.0468580984,
0.0226990804,
-0.0388825126,
0.0208729543,
-0.0445425622,
-0.022152124,
-0.0395475961,
-0.0159057043,
0.0551345982,
0.0511677824,
0.0522147976,
-0.0130920913,
-0.0273770727,
0.0843963847,
-0.0193744972,
-0.0189623721,
-0.0646355376,
0.056181334,
-0.0625811666,
-0.0195518658,
-0.0608883798,
0.0416367091,
-0.0244602133,
0.0330342688,
-0.0672382265,
0.0292429253,
-0.0384968854,
0.0445630811,
0.0215517562,
0.0103038652,
-0.0170897096,
-0.0174227655,
-0.0511999503,
-0.0735183209,
-0.016508881,
-0.038596455,
-0.0304595008,
-0.0192108527,
0.0156353787,
0.0408117659,
-0.0319994278,
0.0005657388,
0.0052109882,
0.1003860086,
-0.0047344291,
0.0288681723,
0.0022734676,
-0.0632631034,
-0.0082233762,
-0.0629662126,
0.0022193685,
-0.0863551572,
0.0383510292,
-0.011021601,
-0.0642421022,
0.021069983,
0.0070211384,
0.0162334535,
0.0312107727,
0.0600246526,
-0.0144006703,
-0.0097256685,
-0.0143695986,
-0.0215432271,
0.0085853366,
0.0452035181,
0.0381277241,
0.0109157646,
-0.0199314337,
-0.0175366867,
0.0109502384,
0.0484325588,
0.0023736428,
-0.0287885517,
-0.0207381845,
0.0306112953,
-0.0076536434,
0.0295156166,
-0.0055487696,
-0.0073366128,
-0.0346694775,
0.0174446646,
-0.0184820294,
0.0251242146,
0.0640518889,
0.0282741319,
0.0464141145,
0.0444314666,
0.0098991413,
-0.0433935225,
-0.0282297377,
0.0416958407,
-0.0381690674,
0.0093604466,
-0.0160108414,
0.0052653211,
-0.0118266484,
-0.0700565949,
0.0045550955,
-0.0050080055,
0.012635407,
-0.0375686511,
0.0301493555,
-0.0027519735,
-0.040971823,
0.0417735316,
-0.0246332195,
-0.0032174177,
-0.0206765626,
-0.0301957168,
-0.0445968844,
0.0032640058,
0.0569636971,
-0.0836544111,
0.0058902535,
0.0016146922,
-0.0614137053,
0.0567554757,
0.0638477802,
-0.0054485314,
-0.041635301,
-0.0312691256,
-0.0098711234,
-0.0059759715,
0.0126425354,
0.0362643003,
0.0003160294,
-0.0275297649,
0.0173261371,
0.0346096307,
-0.0163045321,
0.0235344991,
-0.0241586231,
-0.0630790964,
0.0323092863,
-0.0273232535,
0.0716094226,
0.0368979834,
0.0372538567,
0.029414067,
0.0175654944,
0.0104145808,
-0.0491886735,
-0.0433249287,
-0.0402729958,
-0.0228416268,
0.0483812764,
-0.0547360294,
-0.0316376649,
-0.0065027387,
-0.036668025,
-0.0261594895,
0.0823657513,
-0.0386366658,
-0.0284287836,
-0.0306854695,
0.0219407529,
0.0356885605,
-0.0563849062,
-0.0189898536,
0.0606402978,
0.0715612024,
0.0166500658,
-0.00278894,
-0.053267058,
0.0436073616,
-0.0166249052,
0.0297743287,
-0.001604125,
-0.0149756391,
0.0411072075,
0.0326382332,
0.0805617273,
0.0250812862,
0.0106943781,
-0.0361225083,
0.026727017,
0.0170753133,
0.0265191104,
0.0189196728,
-0.0053954073,
-0.0085474988,
0.0014037704,
-0.0529948398,
0.0059133051,
-0.0495941527,
-0.0510050431,
0.0505373776,
0.037558794,
-0.0389284529,
-0.0207646415,
-0.0091413213,
-0.0493229739,
-0.0101861693,
0.0428547263,
-0.0018292916,
-0.0778980553,
0.0785388872,
-0.0158519093,
0.0205931384,
-0.0058011557,
0.0170235783,
0.0092447596,
-0.0392394476,
0.0152943209,
-0.0072433585,
-0.0434660316,
0.0039845803,
0.0006880707,
-0.0233649667,
-0.0652034059,
0.043449197,
-0.0444534011,
0.0256195702,
0.0325775705,
-0.0099276053,
0.0633794293,
0.0171832852,
0.0220087655,
0.0095135989,
-0.0629921705,
0.0512142405,
0.0504840016,
-0.0090832552,
-0.0662516281,
-0.008611206,
-0.0307368971,
0.0795009956,
0.0333110765,
-0.0319258124,
0.0375814289,
-0.0106865466,
-0.0109935571,
-0.07330852,
-0.0063397423,
-0.0639959201,
-0.0135787586,
0.0622653477,
0.0089491894,
-0.0094077298,
0.0021535775,
-0.0143341618,
0.0255356934,
0.0507085621,
0.0072012991,
0.0287878923,
-0.0231383331,
0.0040736753,
-0.017904846,
-0.0267145541,
-0.0443191454,
0.0094197048,
0.022369625,
0.0173555501,
0.0508086458,
-0.0123125445,
0.0150566269,
0.0048404308,
0.0126545988,
0.0501338691,
-0.0245239399,
-0.0241917223,
-0.0467969403,
-0.052530583,
-0.0145826414,
-0.0357370451,
-0.0044290228,
0.0053092293,
-0.0402719714,
-0.020940125,
0.0069074002,
0.0302908905,
-0.0431846641,
0.0280994512,
0.000323826,
-0.0247462746,
-0.0397191867,
0.0463119969,
-0.0117101017,
-0.0552899279,
0.0170215219,
0.038345959,
0.037561737,
0.0265906043,
0.0022922659,
-0.0421492308,
-0.0182442907,
0.0323382579,
0.041798681,
-0.0851903856,
-0.0157159623,
-0.0172898304,
0.05244302,
-0.0057366686,
-0.01917978,
-0.0624243356,
-0.1277674437,
0.0631773323,
-0.0002258159,
-0.0333401673,
-0.0318315662,
-0.0218880288,
-0.0434874892,
-0.0478399247,
-0.0376173295,
0.0283260476,
0.0223819762,
-0.0067678038,
-0.0135410642,
-0.0448249839,
-0.0294256825,
0.0159757994,
0.0291133877,
0.0039098822,
0.055025544,
0.0412717983,
-0.0158619508,
-0.0049129841,
0.038415581,
0.0671437979,
0.0003053791,
-0.0333229043,
-0.0105500696,
0.0180536322,
-0.010500377,
0.0066821468,
0.0262133405,
-0.0581983812,
-0.0099383937,
0.0288143046,
0.0878199115,
0.0097651128,
0.0127505809,
-0.0075654751,
-0.0115705738,
0.0037827082,
0.0141931325,
-0.0304562803,
0.0065217288,
-0.0323069468,
-0.0545990504,
-0.0294582881,
-0.0698007196,
-0.0372443907,
-0.0284153316,
-0.0214098431,
-0.0095632728,
-0.0448807105,
0.0008830178,
0.0353086777,
0.0348343737,
-0.0004627291,
-0.0708626881,
0.0460554659,
-0.0338400826,
-0.0126499077,
-0.006550068,
-0.0369207859,
0.0377061404,
0.0056527182,
0.0209106542,
-0.0088590393,
-0.0330331735,
-0.0211180169,
0.0481325947,
-0.0251368321,
-0.0433339886,
-0.0258116852,
0.0930231735,
0.0296675023,
-0.0055276598,
-0.0319376402,
0.0578029901,
-0.0271896869,
0.083256036,
-0.0315115638,
-0.0491067506,
0.0175579637,
0.0066935341,
-0.0039565177,
-0.0370518193,
-0.0115838908,
0.0311274808,
-0.0265519489,
0.0225224737,
0.0086799115,
-0.0150351394,
0.0553804822,
0.1039356217,
-0.0395348519,
-0.0209384169,
-0.0248607099,
-0.0093193324,
-0.0290013552,
-0.0530068018,
-0.0338028558,
-0.0488373451,
0.0250173882,
-0.0193865541,
0.0013311045,
0.0607925504,
-0.0224468317,
-0.0462101437,
-0.0316855423,
0.0395319834,
0.0416534282,
0.0322826803,
0.0639474019,
0.0357786827,
-0.0470930003,
0.0263913367,
0.0100781666,
0.0202761982,
0.0197516419,
-0.0165118612,
0.0200132467,
0.0241676737,
0.059012793,
-0.0338047408,
-0.0063559613,
0.0335300826,
-0.0514848083,
-0.0608285069,
-0.0197052658,
0.019484695,
0.0374771059,
-0.0046839844,
-0.0948735476,
-0.0120475963,
0.0036590956,
0.0370650776,
0.0209853351,
0.012250361,
0.0244879723,
0.0579797514,
-0.0114675732,
-0.093386583,
0.0534441881,
0.0021417297,
-0.0063268901,
-0.0349079296,
-0.0105131213,
-0.0698780939,
-0.0143703111,
0.0173280034,
-0.0002797268,
-0.0124242771,
-0.022042606,
-0.0516539738,
-0.0315940902,
-0.0225989651,
0.0476491377,
0.044192493,
0.0148394024,
0.0757684559,
0.0347316116,
0.0025783984,
0.0138780139,
0.0166005008,
0.0138145946,
-0.0026154344,
-0.0311071295,
-0.0214113239,
-6.116150372e-33,
-0.0139890024,
-0.0257149935,
0.0481144115,
0.0642728806,
0.0216169953,
-0.0513057224,
-0.0224953629,
0.0133509375,
0.0582079776,
-0.0209013298,
0.0211217962,
-0.0217819046,
0.0053671822,
-0.0485988408,
0.0238575023,
0.0147408517,
0.0031383277,
-0.0518372357,
-0.0550836138,
-0.0633318275,
-0.0114522455,
-0.0438719429,
0.0670071691,
-0.0407001451,
0.0410462394,
0.019341372,
-0.0281091072,
0.0325279199,
-0.0221705437,
0.046666529,
-0.0003466017,
0.0534374863,
-0.0107367458,
-0.0448400527,
-0.0416949652,
-0.0000751877,
0.0023404481,
-0.0597461052,
0.0297577679,
-0.0046830201,
-0.0196821652,
-0.0046421569,
0.046870172,
-0.0101643037,
-0.0969408378,
0.0306101535,
0.0317154936,
-0.0031021237,
0.0516756214,
-0.0162508804,
-0.0895425379,
0.0222584344,
-0.0099101951,
-0.0007538984,
0.0278998706,
0.0334961601,
-0.0275618564,
-0.0076350211,
0.028660005,
0.022451669,
0.0433650054,
0.0297929123,
0.0633725971,
-0.0453111157,
0.0077862688,
-0.002889948,
0.0477064811,
-0.0265246704,
-0.0092073884,
0.0027671813,
0.029430436,
0.0222096052,
0.0521157049,
0.0436610691,
0.0708232746,
0.0391753539,
-0.04566456,
0.032457184,
-0.0705983937,
0.0363821127,
0.0021936998,
0.022279175,
-0.0195999704,
-0.0396890119,
-0.0050905147,
-0.0220923312,
-0.0299296696,
-0.011727185,
0.0065607745,
0.0071434933,
-0.0045000589,
0.0326097235,
-0.0073245419,
-0.0136818737,
0.007488119,
-0.0017764433,
-0.0117904535,
-0.0118329106,
0.007242288,
0.0207160711,
-0.0192222781,
-0.0141265551,
0.0245005861,
-0.0004419558,
0.062585704,
0.0222737473,
-0.0044060922,
0.0417482331,
-0.0304779429,
0.0270577595,
-0.0338936597,
0.0070686154,
0.0143134119,
0.0421471745,
0.0053540883,
-0.0116126668,
-0.019042816,
0.0102807432,
0.0142979976,
-0.0648907572,
-0.0404489711,
0.0182715151,
0.022987457,
0.0235504881,
0.0030124155,
-0.0072677112,
-0.0046684137,
-0.0055181775,
0.0228836834,
-0.0039336411,
-0.0437246151,
0.033886265,
3.11e-7,
0.0745269433,
0.0663236827,
0.0272575784,
0.0894779712,
-0.0071072974,
0.0520696305,
-0.0167131536,
0.0132863345,
0.007979176,
-0.0268098079,
0.0177207682,
0.006520927,
0.0279456489,
0.0473038442,
-0.0279276446,
0.0518309399,
0.0263149627,
-0.0138963573,
-0.044707559,
0.0046398514,
0.1151145026,
0.0327826403,
0.0322339162,
-0.0041574137,
-0.0104536125,
-0.0104458947,
0.0016938631,
0.0062128967,
-0.0328729004,
0.023823617,
-0.029485777,
-0.0075844568,
-0.0050044656,
0.0221539941,
0.0022894063,
0.0064929454,
0.025941534,
0.0879383087,
-0.003063478,
0.0275772549,
0.0483718738,
-0.0345768519,
-0.0010020145,
0.0168587565,
-0.0111532807,
-0.0340364166,
-0.0279189926,
0.0250156522,
-0.019372344,
-0.0253839847,
-0.0146267209,
-0.0231899135,
0.0142191965,
-0.0088196471,
-0.0106431069,
0.0362498164,
-0.002930664,
-0.0049033808,
-0.0121411216,
0.0385616347,
-0.042027805,
-0.0029242774,
-0.0113669774,
0.0767616034,
0.0410665125,
-0.017725572,
0.0204598028,
3.41026638e-34,
0.0337512828,
0.0026665952,
0.0280458145,
-0.0017282143,
0.0188403428,
0.0358035117,
-0.0696401671,
0.0280002523,
0.0246984698,
-0.0098661622,
-0.0614691228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17161v1 | TreePiece: Faster Semantic Parsing via Tree Tokenization | 2023-03-30T05:44:44 | 2023-03-30T05:44:44 | Sid Wang, Akshat Shrivastava, Sasha Livshits | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Autoregressive (AR) encoder-decoder neural networks have proved successful in
many NLP problems, including Semantic Parsing -- a task that translates natural
language to machine-readable parse trees. However, the sequential prediction
process of AR models can be slow. To accelerate AR for semantic parsing, we
introduce a new technique called TreePiece that tokenizes a parse tree into
subtrees and generates one subtree per decoding step. On TopV2 benchmark,
TreePiece shows 4.6 times faster decoding speed than standard AR, and
comparable speed but significantly higher accuracy compared to
Non-Autoregressive (NAR). | [
-0.0105539821,
0.0641958639,
0.0059489128,
0.0432433784,
-0.0079574101,
0.0206024852,
-0.0135241877,
-0.033743389,
-0.0744774491,
-0.0255994964,
0.0290987119,
0.0340453908,
-0.0197537336,
0.0773175135,
-0.0370353572,
-0.0378777124,
0.059097223,
-0.0225117039,
0.0291628875,
0.0162858162,
-0.0029796234,
0.0234271493,
-0.0067195711,
0.0614650771,
-0.0582567006,
-0.0585368611,
-0.0191423278,
0.0040250011,
-0.0196102746,
-0.0613028929,
-0.0102356933,
-0.0069159418,
0.0069999569,
0.0075759864,
0.0000021766,
0.0067600086,
-0.0407099389,
0.0007787161,
-0.063744247,
-0.0109113948,
0.0098443432,
-0.0482869633,
0.0071458807,
0.0164827481,
-0.0252756421,
-0.0812312216,
0.0056737885,
0.0234869123,
0.0764318928,
0.0609264858,
-0.0104921637,
-0.0679793581,
0.0578386225,
-0.0100092571,
-0.0365600288,
-0.0545797646,
-0.03073976,
-0.020474501,
-0.0481711701,
0.0022755156,
-0.0516110249,
0.014839747,
0.0647433847,
0.0181883462,
0.0549168251,
0.0302467793,
-0.0189207289,
-0.0239187572,
-0.0159235969,
0.0311693847,
-0.0452047922,
-0.0276522916,
-0.0127417576,
-0.0232579652,
-0.0235802941,
-0.0509673506,
-0.0077293538,
0.0435974672,
-0.0063297688,
0.0492334068,
0.0616647117,
0.034827318,
0.0106193768,
0.0051716221,
-0.0151239587,
0.1197491586,
-0.0237982385,
-0.0046881195,
0.0223562252,
0.0169150662,
0.0071361628,
-0.0193441119,
0.0372091681,
-0.0075934157,
-0.0387679785,
0.0142376488,
-0.0272960421,
-0.0004002529,
-0.02163288,
-0.0059271716,
-0.0333082713,
0.0449274816,
0.0074616731,
0.0158924051,
-0.044666063,
0.0352122337,
-0.0175297987,
0.0055268416,
-0.0312405694,
-0.0368753076,
-0.0352230072,
-0.0349247493,
-0.0750397816,
0.0565134063,
-0.0723363608,
-0.0553773195,
-0.0029525538,
-0.0165396016,
-0.0002738005,
-0.0024187062,
0.0306561161,
0.0359685645,
-0.0351516716,
0.0114329001,
0.0018112358,
0.0543728694,
-0.0543448254,
-0.0224452857,
0.0148847802,
-0.021154223,
-0.0148861893,
0.0147991525,
0.0210212283,
-0.0278459415,
-0.0263165534,
0.0480132252,
-0.0152343111,
0.0163696855,
0.006699542,
-0.0304935332,
0.00876348,
0.0316757932,
0.0120201111,
-0.0510222502,
0.0388852805,
0.0134469019,
0.0316600353,
-0.0026090955,
-0.0105661508,
0.0471644327,
0.0210309662,
0.0403463989,
-0.0414548405,
-0.02403754,
-0.0063495729,
-0.0164658669,
0.0061950684,
0.0501596034,
0.045418933,
0.0555099919,
-0.0209122822,
-0.0037639886,
-0.0479762703,
0.0026521177,
-0.0072124409,
-0.0834186599,
-0.014491857,
0.0001148967,
-0.0248175655,
0.0413086526,
0.0452954136,
0.0183525924,
-0.0305367336,
-0.0254411064,
-0.0449990071,
0.0351108015,
-0.0037315248,
0.0180084929,
0.0454101823,
-0.0076576988,
-0.0347338617,
-0.0611375906,
-0.0354139656,
0.014630462,
0.0050868485,
0.0009851834,
-0.082189329,
-0.0025277559,
0.0071838191,
-0.0193095114,
0.0059167203,
-0.0053661321,
0.0273945983,
-0.0302776061,
0.0074691586,
0.0280946027,
-0.0237991679,
0.0461886153,
-0.0147756748,
-0.0141463168,
0.0245408639,
-0.0174289029,
-0.019508861,
0.0550644808,
0.0490432419,
0.0135620516,
-0.0019460656,
-0.0202277657,
0.0057104388,
0.0466953442,
-0.0254655704,
-0.0296761338,
0.0102945557,
-0.0501002818,
-0.0170481913,
-0.0279144328,
0.0188655648,
0.0260820519,
-0.0330588929,
0.0081095044,
0.036363095,
0.0128379613,
-0.0083998302,
0.0314778872,
-0.0096120806,
-0.0152066676,
0.0302620996,
0.0122939488,
0.0028488408,
0.0347990133,
0.0175211728,
0.0044001052,
-0.0012791329,
-0.0719208345,
-0.0107042827,
0.0333929881,
-0.1085382402,
-0.0867466554,
0.0017673548,
-0.041510053,
-0.0184933189,
0.0323985219,
-0.053958334,
-0.0465531237,
-0.0081686061,
-0.0402123146,
0.0704452097,
-0.0038845944,
0.0271542855,
0.0229637697,
0.0046533342,
0.0027171823,
0.051898405,
-0.0273484085,
-0.0240254086,
-0.0309053808,
0.0053292136,
0.0363714136,
-0.0075159683,
0.002606007,
0.0190141387,
-0.0093524912,
-0.0480779409,
0.005607124,
0.0259536877,
-0.0591570772,
0.0183343627,
-0.0366541445,
-0.0031951284,
-0.0341067165,
0.0232586302,
0.021241935,
0.0299454592,
0.041248627,
-0.0354187451,
-0.0281970184,
0.0155549105,
-0.01816204,
0.0012607828,
0.031499628,
-0.0103393104,
-0.0179940127,
-0.0014637171,
-0.0537862368,
-0.0418790728,
0.0354857147,
0.0060422742,
-0.0674653426,
-0.0168579482,
-0.0427283756,
0.019805029,
0.0005009935,
0.0260932911,
-0.0269558746,
0.0068906569,
-0.0261600111,
0.0037639709,
0.0526878312,
-0.0122810341,
0.0425073467,
-0.0201460253,
0.0088272374,
-0.0442275554,
0.0235583819,
0.0081904465,
0.038231831,
-0.02246264,
-0.0154017685,
0.0297930054,
0.0797314867,
0.0024051769,
0.0393817872,
-0.0455849618,
0.0042360649,
-0.0267491955,
-0.0469728746,
-0.0351672135,
-0.0471769869,
-0.0009669851,
0.0317973979,
-0.0516591296,
0.0053870701,
0.0575029217,
-0.0246687513,
-0.0398590416,
-0.0370735489,
-0.001690345,
-0.0502512828,
0.0587051213,
0.0548324957,
0.0102355033,
-0.0297209993,
-0.1141672954,
0.0466772988,
0.0546402484,
0.0042658127,
0.0099871857,
0.0004438141,
-0.0092925392,
0.0032383509,
0.0147050638,
-0.0394386388,
-0.0297219474,
-0.0159286354,
-0.0240986869,
0.0343442373,
-0.0136245657,
0.0305091087,
-0.0072987103,
-0.0010026039,
-0.0464029647,
0.0544513389,
-0.0243469253,
0.0045481925,
-0.0394783616,
0.0343372449,
0.0319892839,
-0.0014831549,
-0.0037581602,
0.0121572111,
0.0748418942,
0.0398950577,
0.0474177301,
0.0075896354,
-0.0669403076,
0.0416115448,
0.0043361345,
-0.0188300572,
-0.0130657088,
-0.017351836,
-0.0044367961,
-0.0830345005,
-0.0450343341,
0.1027696803,
0.0422611162,
-0.0392963961,
-0.0032508422,
-0.0308847055,
0.0321897008,
0.01192318,
-0.0066014058,
-0.0613208264,
-0.0666630641,
0.031827841,
0.0070150523,
0.0441503376,
-0.0430410393,
0.0379723981,
-0.1032054797,
0.0155400047,
-0.005161189,
-0.0488533042,
-0.0117117772,
-0.0210597999,
-0.0635447651,
-0.0480513312,
0.0557624549,
0.0470624641,
-0.0077784676,
0.0146515975,
0.0119324978,
-0.0769557059,
0.010673265,
0.0109990602,
-0.031743262,
0.0100080734,
0.1163696125,
-0.0046949415,
-0.0113514438,
-0.0106990682,
0.0542778708,
-0.026231382,
0.033783026,
-0.0430323482,
0.0091899196,
-0.036733903,
-0.0063514039,
0.0195932053,
0.0114716897,
-0.0530694537,
0.0122251073,
0.0101670343,
0.0929253995,
-0.0030596959,
0.0027922236,
-0.0006756769,
-0.0427245051,
-0.0173347462,
0.0431560315,
0.0225313697,
0.0143584171,
-0.0938550085,
-0.0870016068,
0.0105493283,
-0.0554042868,
0.0157377478,
0.0548285283,
0.0404000878,
-0.067634508,
-0.0496463366,
-0.0527444705,
0.0412093699,
0.0160169322,
-0.0414378233,
-0.009031334,
0.0291691087,
-0.0141150663,
-0.036461819,
-0.0017240121,
0.0044363686,
-0.0072570485,
-0.0250235237,
0.0325220972,
0.0571033917,
0.0398519151,
-0.0417659841,
-0.0009639355,
-0.0247882493,
-0.0105920807,
0.0267570987,
0.015199597,
0.0062610805,
0.0675084293,
-0.0291955862,
-0.0298747234,
-0.0060216053,
0.0163304545,
-0.0744476691,
-0.0274835452,
-0.0153887179,
0.0369549207,
0.0087542646,
0.0264964774,
-0.021337159,
0.0146360099,
-0.0524092279,
0.057440877,
0.0002274488,
0.0344630517,
0.057093095,
0.0427706391,
0.0349716283,
0.0194779187,
0.0097117238,
0.0098087788,
0.0249648783,
-0.0491208434,
0.0060126414,
-0.0267916378,
0.0594646856,
0.0231559854,
-0.002467622,
0.0097513795,
0.002789997,
0.028271677,
-0.0046902262,
-0.0171881616,
0.0266225506,
0.035266947,
0.036770504,
-0.00968007,
0.0080499938,
-0.0338328406,
-0.0221519731,
0.029069636,
0.0127560804,
-0.0437070355,
-0.0270829201,
0.0357350297,
0.0370386355,
-0.0497861654,
-0.0064441622,
-0.0299106613,
-0.0383887775,
-0.0081516057,
-0.003749101,
0.032905139,
-0.0073918621,
0.0551547669,
-0.0127519909,
0.0199556574,
0.0389100611,
0.0269209612,
0.0203226916,
-0.065206103,
0.0362989269,
-0.0045749485,
-0.0188564677,
-0.0903308988,
0.0302653052,
0.0317831151,
0.01456811,
0.0197710004,
0.0117902504,
-0.0423534214,
-0.0195123628,
-0.029956745,
0.0218442976,
-0.0148950573,
0.0317345932,
0.0268190484,
-0.0328595266,
-0.0345866606,
0.0113577191,
0.0226117503,
-0.0155507419,
0.035207402,
0.0424450785,
0.0239647962,
-0.0872550234,
0.0033857774,
0.0179023743,
-0.0054954039,
-0.0267893411,
-0.0403239243,
-6.453004074e-33,
-0.0406556912,
0.0153344106,
0.0158128217,
0.0116967866,
-0.0299139079,
-0.0094640125,
-0.030715704,
-0.0154948356,
0.0219906196,
0.0169544071,
-0.0021591724,
0.0285306443,
0.0225521084,
0.0585264117,
0.0803072602,
-0.0279572215,
0.0802602172,
-0.0392968133,
0.0185900126,
0.0144387251,
0.0281071812,
0.0569833256,
0.0186961815,
-0.005495796,
-0.038058117,
0.03509764,
0.0106177907,
0.023128774,
0.0222124252,
0.0135721639,
0.0127102043,
0.0125820767,
0.0375560746,
-0.0348361656,
-0.0268842764,
-0.0090202605,
-0.149861306,
-0.0219109114,
-0.0101105683,
0.0593089089,
-0.0584108755,
-0.0193012692,
0.0567049459,
0.0031809239,
0.0189903434,
-0.0083645051,
0.0195184983,
-0.0123897931,
-0.0216175243,
-0.0556418821,
-0.0368875153,
0.0103706392,
-0.0148903932,
0.0284604523,
0.0819098204,
0.0496692322,
-0.0028324004,
0.0360528193,
-0.0663622767,
-0.0220861156,
-0.0461174212,
0.049587626,
0.0344596505,
0.0294791851,
0.021484416,
0.026539186,
0.0463272519,
-0.044158034,
-0.0289227609,
0.1175258905,
0.0250229463,
0.0363138281,
0.0236198716,
-0.0432035923,
0.0957040265,
-0.0123404376,
-0.0415164307,
-0.0115488544,
0.037897639,
0.0894237161,
-0.0264906138,
0.0258953795,
-0.0321844593,
-0.025548242,
-0.0155738844,
-0.0132380305,
-0.0196851846,
-0.0321359448,
0.0325521827,
-0.0013294828,
0.0224328972,
0.0258231089,
0.0358940028,
-0.0104385465,
0.011899177,
0.0711426362,
0.0235421024,
0.0082283495,
-0.0115141328,
0.042825792,
-0.0055778394,
-0.0289995279,
-0.0281763505,
-0.0061284364,
0.0494970754,
-0.0125879068,
0.0158398543,
-0.0164321829,
-0.0521635897,
0.0136023918,
-0.0256020669,
0.0300515164,
-0.0202527661,
0.0431294367,
0.03196235,
-0.0178010501,
-0.0170246046,
0.049773436,
-0.0246444624,
0.0144686131,
-0.0174212568,
-0.0060804309,
0.0127231767,
0.0185811352,
-0.0236298628,
-0.0113564674,
-0.0425109006,
-0.002090524,
0.021398332,
-0.0624344274,
-0.0085424557,
0.0332688875,
2.762e-7,
0.0326211452,
0.0483979844,
0.0859809667,
0.0105061131,
0.0265482571,
0.0025201892,
0.009649423,
0.0234820172,
-0.0121829035,
-0.0284763034,
-0.0360796601,
-0.0160832498,
0.044067353,
0.037221171,
-0.0928990692,
0.0263179019,
-0.0878788233,
-0.0000098083,
-0.0447867811,
-0.0075851539,
0.0613264851,
0.0656131953,
-0.0290975869,
0.0047355611,
0.0234633777,
0.0328191258,
-0.0126770986,
0.0157426745,
0.0188686885,
0.0104335342,
-0.0180418845,
0.0090371389,
0.0016194991,
-0.012356705,
0.008907726,
0.0514577776,
-0.0032695553,
0.0411382094,
-0.0129198637,
0.0036231207,
0.0303743817,
-0.0119953062,
0.0038112346,
-0.0260367822,
0.0427594446,
-0.0801228657,
-0.0088149151,
0.0093258172,
-0.030266244,
0.0405353867,
-0.016961623,
0.0022708364,
-0.0071111294,
-0.0041928333,
0.052288495,
-0.0345789418,
-0.0080283629,
-0.0725525022,
-0.0315044336,
0.0238949191,
-0.0227483083,
0.0326704234,
-0.0298750903,
0.0410802737,
0.0157476086,
-0.0079653459,
-0.0373771712,
2.349071176e-34,
0.0477605797,
-0.0033395675,
0.0234747417,
0.0738396123,
0.0203058533,
-0.0035940662,
0.0023157885,
0.0288519822,
-0.0290098283,
-0.0618203618,
-0.0374225862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06034v1 | Social Biases through the Text-to-Image Generation Lens | 2023-03-30T05:29:13 | 2023-03-30T05:29:13 | Ranjita Naik, Besmira Nushi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Text-to-Image (T2I) generation is enabling new applications that support
creators, designers, and general end users of productivity software by
generating illustrative content with high photorealism starting from a given
descriptive text as a prompt. Such models are however trained on massive
amounts of web data, which surfaces the peril of potential harmful biases that
may leak in the generation process itself. In this paper, we take a
multi-dimensional approach to studying and quantifying common social biases as
reflected in the generated images, by focusing on how occupations, personality
traits, and everyday situations are depicted across representations of
(perceived) gender, age, race, and geographical location. Through an extensive
set of both automated and human evaluation experiments we present findings for
two popular T2I models: DALLE-v2 and Stable Diffusion. Our results reveal that
there exist severe occupational biases of neutral prompts majorly excluding
groups of people from results for both models. Such biases can get mitigated by
increasing the amount of specification in the prompt itself, although the
prompting mitigation will not address discrepancies in image quality or other
usages of the model or its representations in other scenarios. Further, we
observe personality traits being associated with only a limited set of people
at the intersection of race, gender, and age. Finally, an analysis of
geographical location representations on everyday situations (e.g., park, food,
weddings) shows that for most situations, images generated through default
location-neutral prompts are closer and more similar to images generated for
locations of United States and Germany. | [
0.0282534137,
0.0574830659,
-0.0253595077,
-0.0201362595,
-0.0022828253,
0.0317596905,
0.0805152431,
0.0068832454,
0.0386132188,
-0.035043411,
-0.0166913699,
-0.0370852351,
0.0476230495,
0.023859635,
0.0287704486,
-0.0796687379,
-0.0192666035,
0.0424876548,
-0.0121085737,
-0.0200273097,
-0.0056170449,
0.0571766756,
0.036775507,
0.0360056646,
-0.0383029729,
-0.0355719104,
0.0440093465,
0.0508837067,
0.0257329922,
0.0013434689,
0.01505394,
0.0386363789,
0.0033561043,
-0.0274206772,
0.0000022049,
-0.0368744247,
0.0255552121,
-0.0100076888,
0.0251880921,
-0.0033428846,
0.0933231115,
0.0178126525,
-0.0092174979,
-0.005115611,
-0.0285260547,
0.0286972485,
0.0567954779,
0.041948501,
0.0510859936,
-0.0053889011,
-0.0212105662,
-0.0236278474,
-0.1000021771,
0.0048126229,
0.023785552,
0.0254974812,
0.0040080976,
-0.0220859572,
-0.031565167,
-0.0088881012,
0.0036395162,
0.0096259536,
-0.026529571,
0.0383415446,
0.0387477502,
0.0757823363,
0.0160085168,
-0.0729998127,
0.0037237722,
0.0590890348,
0.0242488179,
-0.0017419617,
-0.0061797234,
-0.0198681187,
0.0316893607,
0.0516683497,
-0.0164409354,
0.0163928866,
-0.0277932603,
0.0013895805,
-0.071804665,
0.032343287,
-0.0157981701,
-0.0138533376,
0.0279900711,
0.0023668506,
0.0298797041,
-0.0063919481,
-0.0368738063,
0.03634765,
0.0336689875,
-0.0744147152,
0.033120431,
-0.0039136349,
0.0410531387,
0.0040521091,
-0.0217079911,
0.0069473539,
0.0192786213,
-0.0571933314,
0.0172627252,
0.0003392395,
-0.0218329038,
0.0177793056,
0.0355093591,
0.0167079829,
0.0083235633,
-0.0120020499,
-0.0424304083,
0.0083562806,
-0.0174252484,
-0.0094860066,
0.0165562145,
-0.0639979839,
-0.0221305415,
-0.0062565715,
-0.0557982288,
-0.0061536855,
-0.0523704402,
0.0155346943,
-0.015244389,
0.0819340497,
-0.0641258061,
0.0349616967,
-0.0812838599,
0.0021163372,
-0.0516220815,
0.012121954,
-0.0245770589,
-0.0285062324,
0.0391821861,
-0.0039042288,
0.0523492098,
-0.0234331731,
-0.0134500777,
0.0227649473,
-0.0072916485,
0.0134907831,
-0.0346487351,
-0.038076207,
-0.0088324687,
-0.0100400271,
0.0213327557,
-0.053315375,
0.0335207395,
0.0160646848,
0.0080159437,
-0.0563659854,
-0.0321589336,
0.0529673584,
-0.047481928,
0.0282956753,
0.0158858467,
0.0280647781,
0.071128659,
0.0193759445,
-0.0299881045,
0.0332560726,
0.0117669106,
0.0863619596,
0.0378544368,
-0.0335248224,
0.0326663218,
0.0355650857,
-0.0058235079,
0.0157209188,
-0.0026741424,
0.026243696,
-0.0013490608,
-0.0009694229,
0.0739355609,
0.0276761968,
-0.0152422497,
0.0251648072,
0.091057457,
0.0495119393,
0.0138801932,
0.0272633694,
0.0412579849,
0.0355858803,
-0.0277927127,
0.0162877738,
-0.0299468152,
0.0306784287,
-0.0113305021,
0.0006277302,
-0.037064638,
0.081123054,
-0.0452707484,
-0.0049650064,
0.0216237959,
0.0142455036,
0.0637786835,
0.0044896598,
-0.0069396892,
0.0344295502,
-0.0241547711,
0.005079885,
-0.0101448251,
-0.0498267151,
0.0027320806,
-0.029479323,
0.0203306824,
0.1106502861,
-0.0228763614,
0.0347591825,
0.0534139536,
-0.0211347602,
0.0184920449,
0.0522703156,
0.0552619249,
0.0044690161,
-0.0042433585,
-0.0307498015,
-0.0215516016,
0.0084850835,
0.0029418149,
0.0307357553,
0.0246293265,
0.0555491075,
0.0354005545,
0.0213186387,
-0.0375565365,
-0.0050472589,
0.0078266077,
-0.0344584398,
-0.0096646361,
0.0553690381,
-0.0228167791,
0.0133181196,
-0.0262641683,
0.0044697225,
-0.0310345087,
0.0182733238,
0.0029033646,
0.0779233351,
-0.0117987711,
0.0126213329,
-0.0233638436,
-0.0669138879,
-0.0599748865,
-0.0101220738,
0.0004026055,
0.0182247814,
0.0374274589,
-0.0126527799,
0.0079992311,
0.0204382986,
-0.0269479323,
0.0143008856,
0.0317352414,
-0.0111082727,
0.063229017,
-0.0009459159,
-0.0404484123,
0.0000990624,
-0.01569709,
-0.0286593158,
-0.0277374145,
0.0076388321,
-0.0540202893,
0.0136715695,
0.0240484178,
0.0052123084,
0.0040719956,
-0.0575522482,
-0.0106626097,
-0.0932250172,
-0.0381432287,
0.0092588235,
-0.0309576672,
0.0005465305,
-0.0145414388,
-0.0208974592,
-0.0174108632,
-0.0756162703,
0.0087841321,
-0.0321580246,
0.0358258039,
0.0338123068,
-0.0268238056,
0.0265926123,
-0.0246436726,
-0.0262798835,
-0.0243729725,
0.0743825734,
0.0595632121,
0.0136490045,
-0.032597661,
0.0035979624,
-0.0466995835,
-0.0199990459,
0.0183153879,
0.0015481106,
0.022487158,
0.0280560032,
0.0475557074,
0.0688939318,
0.036628563,
-0.0108392406,
-0.0000747181,
-0.0047356342,
-0.0237505324,
-0.0172365252,
-0.0038462661,
0.0487618372,
0.0533337779,
-0.1502695084,
-0.0006728664,
-0.0039619613,
0.0228261407,
0.0279151835,
-0.0672944859,
0.0960556269,
-0.0184860583,
-0.0386664234,
-0.0201503057,
0.0044125933,
0.0160759576,
0.0485740565,
-0.0473164655,
-0.0518675521,
0.0374682173,
-0.0028293224,
0.0207061265,
0.0323248357,
-0.001278098,
0.021515293,
0.020101402,
-0.0035793507,
0.0487562306,
0.0522600077,
0.022560399,
-0.0634156093,
-0.0357477032,
0.0510916263,
-0.0250941217,
0.0055462257,
-0.0077362359,
-0.0609351769,
-0.007646597,
-0.0452058539,
-0.0154152187,
-0.0624228083,
-0.0120459311,
-0.0444989316,
-0.0067992206,
-0.0130934119,
0.0321202129,
-0.011204808,
-0.0214586649,
0.0026024696,
-0.021438932,
-0.0249025282,
0.0105035147,
0.0283690356,
0.0639098063,
0.0199277271,
-0.0287499223,
-0.0480939969,
-0.0440511778,
0.0080211321,
-0.0321669951,
-0.008839353,
-0.0328559019,
0.0250764322,
-0.001488124,
0.0426056162,
-0.0149493562,
0.0134465834,
0.0648222193,
0.0191181153,
0.0270307288,
0.064628087,
-0.0082058739,
-0.0282340553,
-0.0074542318,
0.0397636145,
0.0080926595,
0.0227027219,
0.0288221892,
-0.0505542457,
0.0259827804,
-0.0239379015,
0.0230449624,
-0.0623195954,
-0.0163757727,
-0.0128572788,
-0.1036896333,
0.059223678,
0.0106279897,
0.0009584807,
0.0236064792,
0.0052008284,
0.0002705027,
0.0172543954,
0.0036388345,
-0.0444912314,
-0.0147042349,
0.0031502896,
0.011634279,
-0.0483438335,
-0.0581155419,
0.0432940945,
-0.0473933183,
0.0310274009,
0.0318006389,
0.0651357174,
0.0208617654,
-0.0664717555,
-0.0294323172,
0.0620603152,
0.0536729842,
-0.0157878567,
0.0641039014,
-0.0467279702,
0.012885523,
-0.063285999,
0.0202051364,
0.028410757,
0.0088161984,
0.0043992987,
-0.0044479924,
0.0335314758,
-0.0586618185,
-0.0568070412,
0.0272509251,
0.035330262,
0.0413047262,
0.023139691,
-0.0599471964,
-0.0325217545,
-0.0184147339,
0.0469250828,
-0.0017022149,
-0.0367008522,
0.0021467297,
-0.0248184446,
-0.0603215769,
-0.0585293956,
-0.0355373845,
-0.0050966716,
0.0307957884,
-0.0069711651,
-0.0965038463,
-0.0155491019,
-0.002444824,
-0.0611917563,
0.029877916,
-0.0103805447,
0.0299612656,
0.0556428395,
-0.0126275364,
-0.0045806486,
-0.0617122538,
-0.0065431749,
0.0125621706,
-0.0748091042,
0.0028343974,
-0.0065270662,
0.0638951808,
0.0234791022,
0.0280791856,
0.0218286514,
-0.0528563522,
0.0500409305,
0.0306276679,
0.0142069245,
0.0273099039,
-0.0376706645,
0.0359989628,
0.0030521124,
-0.0187763572,
-0.0306451488,
0.0289263222,
0.0305644963,
-0.0527230613,
-0.013953113,
-0.0239779912,
-0.0271382984,
-0.0037377251,
-0.010641668,
-0.0482187122,
0.0335902199,
-0.0077367551,
-0.0413828492,
-0.0114203971,
-0.0182814151,
-0.01024622,
-0.0640045553,
0.0234580468,
0.0005187923,
-0.0132795135,
-0.0005920369,
-0.0332751125,
0.0276073013,
-0.0869615376,
-0.030008534,
0.0275638364,
0.0340146795,
-0.0170902442,
0.0128664821,
-0.0040837652,
0.0193210654,
-0.0349997431,
0.0542597808,
0.0260216352,
0.0604739226,
0.0076144906,
-0.0027299307,
-0.0407143719,
0.0441916436,
-0.0238383152,
-0.0081646331,
-0.0289604049,
0.0179439634,
0.022422811,
-0.0442424268,
0.0383322202,
0.0104699992,
0.0001790902,
0.0058937902,
0.0061077294,
0.0192408357,
-0.0282404069,
-0.0020470528,
-0.0289009083,
0.0104025025,
0.0011098821,
0.0334511437,
0.0080772899,
-0.0179828163,
-0.0296694078,
-0.0774032325,
-0.0201854296,
0.0172676984,
0.0467863604,
-0.0120784277,
-0.0056197005,
-0.0278066304,
-0.1041681319,
-0.0963603258,
0.0075322883,
0.0078135952,
0.0162469298,
-0.0053434004,
0.0298476405,
0.0367614627,
-0.0295522548,
-0.0324658155,
0.0009422298,
0.0099723134,
-0.0711733103,
0.0220712759,
-0.0351488665,
-6.384195043e-33,
-0.0268446784,
-0.0403295867,
-0.0018580293,
-0.0232344754,
-0.0155260703,
-0.0182121471,
-0.0306039248,
-0.0271455571,
0.0029690429,
0.009589226,
-0.0152476765,
-0.028468743,
0.0195041467,
0.0005961149,
0.0104368981,
0.0332948565,
0.0702136159,
0.0067563378,
-0.0558651425,
0.0117885247,
-0.0145225311,
-0.0193985272,
0.0248318985,
-0.0766802654,
0.0054240385,
-0.03480459,
-0.0102802236,
-0.0656392649,
0.0651986375,
0.0160206277,
-0.0118827149,
0.0353913791,
0.0298506673,
0.0061818836,
-0.0130234752,
0.0692813471,
-0.0636693463,
-0.0297406856,
-0.0266724769,
0.0038829744,
-0.0220698193,
-0.0208020508,
0.0188583825,
-0.0002791676,
-0.043963518,
-0.0245752949,
0.0975079536,
0.0003411566,
0.0431079157,
0.0267428476,
-0.0432147272,
-0.0246038791,
-0.0306168571,
-0.0004599766,
-0.0306052696,
0.0566992201,
0.0177123845,
0.023661973,
-0.0790956616,
0.0375570431,
0.0006652579,
-0.0720078871,
0.059933614,
0.0399415046,
0.0451346561,
0.030455295,
0.0563579202,
0.1011080891,
-0.0605968274,
-0.0624097846,
0.0239940193,
0.032329075,
-0.0406475663,
0.0648941472,
0.0277841333,
-0.0547323711,
0.0167202018,
0.0407664999,
0.0097426353,
-0.0421794318,
0.0237581264,
-0.0109205311,
-0.0416546687,
-0.0216669701,
0.004303976,
-0.0423604883,
-0.0391795374,
-0.0546196774,
0.0185065828,
-0.0204738677,
-0.0257760901,
0.0191206094,
-0.0007126657,
-0.0306124538,
-0.0140360901,
-0.0378004797,
-0.0475149006,
0.0049343524,
-0.0194639675,
-0.02780829,
-0.0252499245,
-0.0243112147,
0.0053160046,
0.0981977507,
0.0243962165,
0.0585622489,
-0.0209815949,
-0.0103237405,
-0.0411420725,
-0.0193761494,
-0.0047585843,
-0.0113456491,
0.0021223484,
-0.014758735,
0.045012977,
-0.0037466495,
-0.0305086132,
-0.0288249142,
0.0045115016,
0.0349900648,
-0.0142361457,
-0.0395527035,
0.0071652145,
-0.0034564112,
-0.0199847929,
-0.0061190929,
-0.0302744173,
0.0045487196,
0.0617289282,
-0.0459415577,
-0.022435138,
-0.0440276675,
2.905e-7,
-0.0282767713,
0.049180489,
-0.0184420869,
0.0426548086,
0.0336535014,
0.0494139493,
0.0368769728,
0.0576124862,
0.046064347,
-0.0158865582,
0.0074541271,
0.0269646719,
0.0151091572,
0.0279175546,
-0.0213698447,
0.0190931801,
-0.0415509194,
0.0449407808,
-0.0200498812,
0.0387514718,
0.0691227093,
0.0125988703,
0.0100860763,
-0.0393750854,
0.0181124415,
0.0125297224,
0.0548783876,
-0.032433033,
0.0168486405,
-0.0272210259,
-0.0361022875,
-0.007997416,
0.0138204293,
0.0426078364,
-0.0274600424,
-0.0181878377,
0.026334988,
0.0134928552,
-0.0387088768,
0.0323431231,
0.01075901,
-0.0141183138,
-0.0086725783,
-0.0690046921,
0.0295938831,
-0.0025416343,
-0.0130966045,
-0.0453733988,
-0.0376211815,
-0.0129689975,
0.0500001833,
-0.0216201954,
-0.0428309068,
-0.0180160105,
0.0250624027,
-0.0070567657,
-0.0228594895,
-0.0494875424,
-0.0056310981,
-0.0201251861,
-0.006238292,
-0.0566878319,
-0.0366883799,
0.0442854576,
0.028127417,
0.0068039875,
0.0084424848,
2.305623114e-34,
-0.0016822389,
0.0431165025,
0.0169392172,
-0.0770796612,
0.0418237075,
0.0024067229,
0.0029529075,
-0.0281605739,
0.0681325793,
-0.0208075158,
-0.003457224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17119v1 | TLAG: An Informative Trigger and Label-Aware Knowledge Guided Model for Dialogue-based Relation Extraction | 2023-03-30T03:10:28 | 2023-03-30T03:10:28 | Hao An, Dongsheng Chen, Weiyuan Xu, Zhihong Zhu, Yuexian Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue-based Relation Extraction (DRE) aims to predict the relation type of
argument pairs that are mentioned in dialogue. The latest trigger-enhanced
methods propose trigger prediction tasks to promote DRE. However, these methods
are not able to fully leverage the trigger information and even bring noise to
relation extraction. To solve these problems, we propose TLAG, which fully
leverages the trigger and label-aware knowledge to guide the relation
extraction. First, we design an adaptive trigger fusion module to fully
leverage the trigger information. Then, we introduce label-aware knowledge to
further promote our model's performance. Experimental results on the DialogRE
dataset show that our TLAG outperforms the baseline models, and detailed
analyses demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. | [
0.0782877654,
0.0283262096,
0.0180392042,
0.076765351,
-0.0265686959,
0.0224021599,
0.0017042505,
-0.0175485071,
0.04052018,
-0.0608618259,
-0.030023966,
0.0330665335,
-0.0524395816,
0.0420969576,
-0.0383065194,
-0.0525357723,
0.0512097441,
-0.0038990979,
0.0457271375,
0.0489489771,
0.0060940324,
0.0120852618,
-0.0523144677,
0.0135786692,
-0.0479560271,
-0.0200228151,
0.0053747389,
-0.0073032561,
0.0170852002,
-0.0226402469,
0.0220221914,
0.0420746021,
-0.0165628474,
-0.0007192752,
0.0000016644,
-0.0677304268,
-0.0132590607,
-0.0253141653,
-0.0606235899,
-0.0354654528,
0.0067216936,
0.0075693354,
0.0210366957,
0.0162141398,
-0.0395906158,
-0.0294113047,
0.0177428089,
0.0888115242,
0.0197874904,
0.0503718667,
-0.0200180057,
-0.0418273546,
0.0455647595,
-0.0188823007,
-0.0112709142,
-0.0465014949,
0.0334386416,
0.0136439959,
-0.0149069447,
0.0062649581,
0.019768117,
0.0471903533,
0.0110684922,
-0.0405642278,
0.0127747077,
0.0305050556,
-0.0346549936,
-0.024000939,
-0.0364546701,
0.0983405113,
0.0447549224,
0.0455437936,
0.0174222551,
-0.0006926777,
0.0229915362,
-0.0185759291,
0.0107071791,
-0.0552919023,
-0.0472841561,
-0.0098524801,
0.0265205298,
0.0404595286,
0.0020849318,
0.0126983235,
0.0216213353,
0.0504858643,
-0.0194713846,
-0.0204222724,
0.0310489908,
0.0170852952,
0.0155333001,
-0.0454369672,
0.0143755097,
0.0227050781,
-0.0265780725,
0.0507339388,
-0.0329652987,
0.0023415016,
-0.0100296885,
-0.040836785,
-0.059353061,
0.005580937,
-0.0296125188,
0.0902464986,
-0.0282564051,
0.0439755209,
0.0045333714,
-0.0264608711,
0.009804653,
-0.0383658223,
-0.0597719885,
0.0224294774,
-0.0563394614,
0.0265714042,
-0.0467172414,
-0.0398596264,
-0.0056849108,
0.0329575427,
-0.0082539935,
0.0179791041,
0.0054022023,
0.0171712339,
-0.0083184363,
-0.0091893161,
-0.0375386141,
0.0110425614,
-0.0206370708,
0.0134445522,
0.0192456357,
-0.0567831509,
-0.0066170688,
-0.0101165641,
0.0310522057,
-0.0276964381,
-0.02097008,
0.0529572293,
-0.032271143,
-0.021409668,
-0.0209180731,
-0.0433562696,
-0.0202724729,
-0.0073483111,
-0.0148612037,
-0.0333804786,
0.0636473149,
0.0061460221,
-0.0194460936,
-0.0206927489,
0.0385915861,
-0.0281718504,
-0.0506903008,
0.0800636113,
-0.0050134538,
-0.0141180046,
0.0211799126,
0.0104898289,
-0.0189580303,
0.0687595084,
0.0287537444,
-0.0108773643,
0.067502141,
0.0411793031,
-0.0054550506,
0.019554412,
0.0001386395,
-0.0164170805,
0.0438209884,
0.0346734673,
-0.0334111527,
-0.0047206567,
0.0292369183,
0.0514046103,
-0.0362123773,
-0.0250725374,
0.0090208156,
-0.0042788768,
-0.0013798387,
0.0415898301,
0.027539812,
0.0249841455,
0.0103324596,
0.0069441195,
-0.0427025333,
-0.0009669148,
-0.0117908446,
0.0170402061,
0.0131466985,
0.002398635,
-0.0106702941,
-0.0376570523,
-0.0000367329,
-0.0376024991,
-0.0121220527,
0.0077513093,
0.0275055133,
0.0355311632,
-0.0522185303,
0.0754497722,
0.0393665135,
-0.0141841331,
-0.0477568507,
-0.0122114839,
0.0056616841,
-0.0051700561,
0.0305998866,
-0.0492809042,
-0.0761497766,
-0.0402149595,
-0.0156576391,
0.0602832586,
0.0475421064,
-0.0362843387,
0.0542747974,
-0.0170623474,
-0.0304040685,
0.0299933441,
0.0042814128,
-0.0072610234,
0.0355152898,
-0.0057477299,
0.0131172314,
0.0441666283,
0.0170256458,
0.0200314224,
0.006686558,
-0.0423503034,
0.0250144806,
0.0094261905,
0.0563391037,
0.0158076584,
-0.0142685967,
-0.009125364,
0.0245938934,
-0.0244338643,
-0.0154152233,
0.0420230739,
-0.0679921731,
-0.0648477152,
0.0376220196,
0.0415675268,
-0.0086808642,
-0.0712242275,
-0.0498675853,
-0.0359012038,
-0.0142012723,
0.0113180056,
0.0427191034,
-0.0229737591,
-0.0199180599,
0.0461262874,
-0.0103963474,
-0.0350195803,
0.0715833008,
0.0048226388,
-0.0318428688,
0.0275281724,
0.0177052412,
0.0141468281,
0.0144968778,
-0.0011684083,
0.0077265692,
-0.0207339954,
-0.0088529876,
0.0172240939,
-0.0117408503,
-0.0703742206,
-0.0252463911,
-0.1058357358,
0.0116966674,
0.0163952671,
0.0348883234,
0.0229355823,
-0.0059339125,
-0.0159956515,
-0.0298225321,
-0.0294462442,
0.0021662337,
-0.0002155897,
-0.0051961043,
0.0296978597,
0.0325953774,
0.0118799862,
-0.0734449327,
0.0312399231,
-0.0198142361,
0.0355688334,
0.0077875587,
-0.0141649768,
-0.0087211384,
0.0158864614,
-0.0320153572,
0.0518366285,
-0.0102362288,
-0.0311640296,
-0.0295652132,
0.0150458291,
0.0260451324,
0.0102670109,
0.0074000796,
0.0377504639,
-0.0207784604,
-0.0348809436,
-0.0483944081,
0.0869053826,
-0.0217747204,
0.0078670504,
-0.0205874443,
0.0345865227,
-0.0122280223,
0.0770302713,
0.0026108571,
0.052730836,
-0.0142739145,
-0.0128641631,
0.0442459472,
-0.002682745,
-0.0151555091,
0.0010520861,
-0.017227849,
0.0073970654,
-0.066105172,
0.013275763,
0.0930960104,
-0.0033235627,
-0.0324238129,
-0.0573581643,
-0.0118882684,
-0.0401448868,
0.0484835245,
-0.0137891779,
-0.0056674276,
0.045934055,
-0.0156360343,
-0.0133790588,
-0.0476780236,
0.0117548453,
-0.0213885531,
0.0663810819,
-0.0404388942,
0.0115976883,
0.0098561719,
-0.0265981369,
-0.0754272267,
-0.0344989412,
-0.0614462271,
0.0006090355,
-0.0260070898,
-0.0049360143,
0.0225661546,
0.008415129,
0.0208919216,
0.0333458222,
0.0051956475,
-0.0045587984,
-0.0195938572,
0.109146826,
0.0613435619,
-0.0009232499,
-0.0175207071,
0.0492069721,
0.0651112795,
0.0404164307,
-0.0051843594,
-0.0200972669,
-0.029524127,
-0.0180624034,
-0.0108900405,
-0.0132893194,
-0.0037937535,
-0.021717824,
0.0328994691,
-0.0536191911,
-0.0021654486,
0.1142839715,
0.0233392846,
0.0027522573,
-0.037348371,
0.0255988687,
0.0483639389,
0.0236078668,
0.028641019,
-0.0614830256,
-0.0669256523,
-0.0318621658,
-0.0180907138,
-0.0240432862,
-0.0531240143,
0.0122500472,
-0.0791920945,
-0.0214996561,
-0.032774698,
-0.0044728201,
-0.0288250782,
-0.0096773552,
0.0363056883,
-0.0152966017,
-0.0071445364,
0.0011065187,
-0.0083792312,
0.0008571058,
0.0084091369,
-0.0053837206,
-0.0174732246,
0.0250295103,
-0.0280196071,
0.0513198487,
0.0687291846,
0.0583352782,
0.0206316616,
0.02294234,
0.033811871,
-0.0404720679,
-0.0181298889,
-0.0098422822,
0.0560350381,
-0.0130929956,
-0.0038613235,
-0.0137268752,
0.0136950798,
-0.0277024508,
-0.0100936154,
0.0077640731,
0.0473694615,
-0.0142089901,
0.0056221746,
0.0001323831,
0.0156828444,
0.0160584841,
0.0615978874,
0.0292193945,
-0.0002612014,
-0.0318180546,
-0.024667399,
0.0131885391,
-0.0421517603,
0.0141445482,
-0.0197634399,
-0.0372670628,
-0.0117451223,
-0.1011768579,
-0.0842125639,
0.0086785043,
0.0067598666,
-0.0239105076,
-0.0084697027,
0.0112474989,
0.051563479,
-0.0203244071,
0.0119408127,
0.0054000858,
-0.028742319,
-0.0360055938,
0.0116042411,
0.0464412495,
-0.0158046652,
-0.0405373052,
0.053967312,
-0.0650354251,
-0.0453634262,
-0.0370699093,
0.0299291648,
0.014371301,
0.06860172,
-0.0364551246,
0.0079717301,
-0.0000884092,
0.0820956156,
-0.0230462607,
-0.0323498994,
0.0405678041,
0.0329317562,
-0.0106369713,
0.0356878228,
-0.022922257,
0.0058557787,
-0.0399891846,
0.0131138787,
-0.0937210321,
-0.0849954486,
0.0046185977,
-0.0250681378,
0.0961785018,
0.0183932334,
-0.0141349193,
-0.0354224518,
0.0212573502,
-0.0147141796,
-0.0235715192,
-0.0570563748,
0.0387814827,
-0.018830495,
-0.0189545341,
-0.0094772112,
-0.0342910253,
-0.0056337435,
0.0530622452,
0.0008132561,
-0.0216367561,
0.0483825617,
0.0044866828,
0.0091764554,
-0.0287109949,
-0.0286191721,
0.0686187223,
0.0188362356,
-0.0077534332,
-0.0145259155,
0.0785342678,
0.0082625858,
-0.0589101352,
0.0426705368,
-0.0065919328,
-0.048695039,
-0.001278233,
-0.007816134,
0.0168649573,
0.0542150475,
-0.027645262,
0.0330567881,
-0.0164793059,
0.0003282816,
0.0048980047,
0.058673583,
-0.0093635432,
0.0195189994,
0.056767337,
0.0202698782,
-0.0189001765,
0.0203553736,
0.0383121222,
-0.0468240343,
0.0567114279,
0.028024504,
-0.0236007776,
-0.0437014475,
-0.0148705961,
-0.031855315,
0.036564067,
-0.0196947847,
0.0530971847,
-0.0376828238,
-0.0157008134,
0.0197813027,
-0.0310039055,
-0.0292853843,
-0.0125092398,
0.0536091141,
0.0498261526,
0.0168977808,
-0.04168275,
-0.057112392,
0.0117981536,
-0.018511245,
-0.0151528865,
-0.0239403676,
-5.854321862e-33,
-0.0586744547,
-0.0076470771,
0.0267879646,
0.06490729,
-0.0149414465,
0.0347011797,
-0.037448734,
0.0082568387,
-0.0463400669,
0.0392287672,
-0.0009733362,
0.003598853,
0.0056422148,
0.0003358308,
-0.0204839539,
-0.0413440466,
0.0373725705,
0.0021317354,
0.0330871753,
0.021115128,
0.0500422046,
0.0442045555,
0.0393172018,
-0.1270949394,
0.0055371867,
0.0043721679,
0.0135475677,
0.0262810141,
0.0246881135,
0.0683917105,
-0.0217869952,
0.023377791,
0.0234633163,
-0.0264200661,
0.0076364242,
0.018171763,
-0.1355803907,
-0.016414715,
0.0085616494,
-0.0133180581,
-0.0284290612,
-0.0127902627,
0.0109865703,
0.0128935333,
0.0439120755,
-0.0444827154,
0.0256644059,
-0.0420619436,
-0.0135617526,
-0.0633814856,
-0.045967754,
0.0423653722,
0.0165008288,
-0.0412486009,
0.0219354611,
0.0471862666,
0.0423095301,
0.0075586522,
-0.0340448506,
-0.0510311946,
0.000348839,
0.0199121274,
0.0141987558,
0.0109434696,
-0.0280727874,
0.052197814,
-0.041744113,
-0.0300893951,
-0.021879524,
-0.0155841559,
-0.0399402045,
0.0838214979,
-0.0108302822,
0.0518170446,
0.0071328399,
0.022920996,
-0.0343437567,
-0.0264901016,
0.0918542594,
0.043865975,
-0.0568865128,
0.0055266828,
-0.0289214291,
0.0259354115,
-0.013620697,
-0.0040191133,
-0.0140304305,
-0.0275942069,
0.0051757451,
0.0317621529,
0.0267726406,
0.0413306542,
0.0240952093,
-0.0066103078,
0.0106952488,
0.041511301,
-0.0101887761,
0.002818106,
0.0010469942,
0.009989012,
-0.0724465474,
-0.0160400886,
0.0197268222,
-0.0138575882,
0.0161650535,
0.0262822919,
0.0162148234,
-0.0605347753,
-0.0490978956,
-0.0140537228,
-0.04003397,
0.0384075493,
-0.0467580594,
0.0342654921,
-0.0122129973,
0.0317075811,
-0.0328578278,
0.0728938207,
0.00010772,
-0.0017433789,
-0.0378067717,
0.0116962232,
-0.0091481479,
0.0172592849,
0.0042891204,
-0.0344345942,
0.013419278,
-0.0132637983,
-0.0379178748,
-0.0231160093,
0.0042683179,
0.0067909868,
2.381e-7,
0.0100365598,
0.0357130766,
0.0515908077,
0.0138716241,
0.0319453515,
0.0738609508,
0.0352143236,
0.0284368899,
0.0279169474,
-0.0420913361,
-0.0093384674,
-0.0127832806,
0.0169647075,
0.0395295843,
-0.0792009011,
-0.092585586,
-0.0814633667,
-0.07019604,
-0.0459590629,
-0.0247590709,
0.0845632777,
0.0694623441,
0.0389953218,
0.011990658,
-0.0477754213,
-0.0301664751,
0.0212067515,
-0.0175493844,
-0.0130619071,
0.0459544882,
0.0554614365,
0.0077741258,
-0.0310039055,
0.0628429353,
-0.0264790133,
0.0392706431,
-0.0270704348,
0.0637774169,
-0.0068996372,
-0.0378720127,
-0.0060441303,
-0.0098867714,
0.0058883089,
-0.0462523326,
0.0641154498,
-0.0202010255,
0.0436928347,
-0.0166327022,
-0.0389862694,
0.0260166489,
-0.0242575388,
0.0137407659,
-0.0116626918,
0.0330407098,
0.0078197671,
-0.0205440037,
-0.0158294719,
-0.0822505653,
-0.0211555921,
0.0367246941,
-0.0105778547,
-0.0042983196,
-0.0053691734,
-0.0466195755,
-0.0181232225,
-0.0458283201,
0.0113664484,
1.802116066e-34,
-0.0199665949,
0.0134600708,
-0.0097745685,
0.0670999438,
0.0486745387,
-0.0203999709,
-0.0620167255,
0.0074076438,
0.0214323122,
-0.0481717512,
0.0413077027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17612v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17612v3 | oBERTa: Improving Sparse Transfer Learning via improved initialization, distillation, and pruning regimes | 2023-03-30T01:37:19 | 2023-06-06T16:30:09 | Daniel Campos, Alexandre Marques, Mark Kurtz, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce the range of oBERTa language models, an
easy-to-use set of language models which allows Natural Language Processing
(NLP) practitioners to obtain between 3.8 and 24.3 times faster models without
expertise in model compression. Specifically, oBERTa extends existing work on
pruning, knowledge distillation, and quantization and leverages frozen
embeddings improves distillation and model initialization to deliver higher
accuracy on a broad range of transfer tasks. In generating oBERTa, we explore
how the highly optimized RoBERTa differs from the BERT for pruning during
pre-training and finetuning. We find it less amenable to compression during
fine-tuning. We explore the use of oBERTa on seven representative NLP tasks and
find that the improved compression techniques allow a pruned oBERTa model to
match the performance of BERTbase and exceed the performance of Prune OFA Large
on the SQUAD V1.1 Question Answering dataset, despite being 8x and 2x,
respectively faster in inference. We release our code, training regimes, and
associated model for broad usage to encourage usage and experimentation | [
0.0130117089,
0.0690085217,
0.0066995523,
0.0441675,
-0.0032978572,
0.0054673119,
-0.0180098489,
0.0024048695,
-0.0463429913,
-0.0292841997,
-0.0146088041,
-0.016613882,
-0.0099006863,
-0.0019755911,
0.0150568001,
-0.0492019951,
0.0353995301,
-0.0287805311,
0.0018696598,
-0.0004813562,
0.0041712341,
0.0194175877,
-0.0178906694,
0.0189946853,
0.0084636007,
0.0014438786,
-0.0022310927,
0.0424883291,
0.0040772245,
-0.0154825132,
0.0164593644,
0.0810500383,
0.0635441318,
-0.0354764536,
0.0000021878,
-0.0159164499,
-0.0297906883,
-0.0030689144,
-0.0425896011,
0.0234033018,
0.0328262523,
-0.0061028018,
0.0366808102,
0.010015565,
-0.0458136275,
-0.0452880412,
0.0609000772,
0.0140779102,
0.0558164939,
0.0661044642,
-0.0203877799,
-0.0091354381,
0.0056843492,
-0.0235579852,
-0.0239784718,
-0.0656100661,
0.0491564572,
-0.0026129668,
0.006754898,
0.0103749242,
-0.0270437133,
0.0202037171,
0.0083756158,
0.0296311602,
0.0139562767,
0.0349067226,
-0.0712419301,
-0.0289263595,
-0.0084570497,
0.1050379053,
-0.0346036702,
-0.0326297805,
0.0187255237,
0.0529400744,
-0.0071207494,
-0.0331902318,
-0.0420183577,
-0.0211816002,
0.0507686362,
0.0344885215,
-0.0098148659,
-0.0232664663,
0.0271664914,
0.03356288,
-0.0411401503,
-0.0025529494,
0.0344903022,
-0.0155920992,
0.0256409403,
0.0131469853,
-0.0889764056,
-0.0552998818,
-0.0145595986,
0.04518985,
0.0153511195,
-0.0142995771,
-0.0672719032,
-0.0252629574,
0.0110681364,
0.0426911004,
0.067877762,
0.032330364,
-0.0070112846,
0.0458510481,
-0.0547925271,
0.065046154,
0.0247790962,
0.0122154094,
-0.0458368696,
-0.0311185811,
-0.0782532617,
0.0110656396,
-0.0658053383,
0.0648939908,
-0.0382600464,
-0.0383398458,
-0.015533695,
-0.0142345866,
-0.0029997744,
-0.0147865228,
0.024653798,
0.0289939009,
-0.0194651,
0.0035628942,
-0.0045451033,
0.0763124451,
-0.0416824147,
0.0504929796,
-0.0068337256,
-0.0586298145,
-0.0675169379,
0.0061277542,
0.0289616846,
-0.0536524728,
0.017732339,
0.0001837177,
-0.0291999187,
-0.0486862138,
0.0050075599,
0.0299225152,
0.0097123291,
-0.0950269625,
0.0066259718,
-0.0828268453,
0.0285783727,
-0.0325372331,
0.0349511281,
-0.0874561891,
0.0111479629,
0.0182986595,
-0.0731937811,
0.0786032602,
-0.0393726565,
0.0189260971,
-0.0278531145,
0.01712282,
0.0193668958,
0.0687013417,
0.0029235194,
0.0217999648,
0.0160663649,
-0.0248596761,
0.004739352,
0.0188857149,
0.0585577041,
0.0395770371,
-0.0315316729,
0.0132791512,
-0.0442828685,
0.0095177637,
0.0555112511,
0.0652591065,
-0.0343881324,
-0.0212829094,
0.0629057586,
0.061615061,
-0.0102035617,
0.0216112528,
0.0272531956,
0.0041005695,
-0.0162198953,
-0.0267706439,
-0.0561696962,
0.019183252,
0.0070171566,
-0.0108739883,
-0.003832214,
0.0287023857,
-0.0415067226,
0.021252919,
0.0060441163,
0.0003762603,
0.0008025286,
0.0203274172,
0.001401182,
0.0355628468,
-0.0471167043,
0.0814824477,
0.0292657614,
-0.0381833576,
-0.0076286132,
-0.034376096,
0.0152837783,
0.0278204437,
0.0023700485,
0.0041014152,
-0.0461179167,
-0.0132116368,
0.0121458462,
-0.0011065886,
0.0457715318,
-0.0073627974,
0.0489146635,
-0.0727286637,
-0.020011887,
-0.0203786623,
0.0418869033,
0.0108625609,
0.0350442715,
0.0550892092,
0.017625479,
-0.0752460808,
0.0185631998,
0.0290224515,
-0.0135359438,
-0.0533730052,
0.0132714016,
0.0111700324,
0.0071382681,
-0.0054421914,
-0.0185539778,
-0.0028879591,
0.0452953391,
-0.0484004244,
0.0042452659,
-0.0368717089,
-0.0195593387,
-0.0907762423,
0.0293573011,
-0.005150022,
0.0180549435,
0.0702074468,
-0.0566697456,
-0.0418644808,
-0.0119294263,
-0.0060251905,
0.0199070629,
-0.0167483762,
-0.0056982846,
0.0287257992,
0.0445205905,
-0.0244228542,
0.030441327,
-0.0318906531,
0.0028343122,
0.0184118673,
-0.0429158621,
0.0057793101,
-0.036674466,
-0.0594940148,
0.0178013761,
-0.0129190423,
0.023923004,
-0.0087128598,
0.0128383804,
-0.0211840533,
-0.0140348962,
-0.0780215114,
0.0418640487,
-0.0181883331,
0.0291905571,
0.022796331,
0.0285740439,
-0.0129585564,
-0.0172636788,
-0.0312756076,
-0.0265938248,
-0.0184481647,
0.0189343914,
0.0062457477,
-0.0000044909,
-0.0177637376,
-0.0317142457,
-0.0302031599,
0.0278419983,
0.0471857563,
-0.0847601518,
0.0030399272,
-0.0181895066,
0.019174112,
-0.0244196039,
0.0171387233,
0.0084223188,
-0.0245440397,
-0.0353542119,
-0.0303858761,
0.0038588501,
0.0448985584,
-0.0049906829,
0.0397441201,
0.0234873015,
0.0171191357,
-0.0303996485,
0.0330322534,
-0.04595064,
-0.0037171212,
-0.0188559424,
-0.0400082506,
-0.0305642653,
0.0548949651,
-0.027497245,
-0.0175908282,
-0.0539933927,
-0.0178206656,
-0.0101204552,
-0.0197373684,
-0.0517791286,
0.0311375279,
0.0188504178,
0.0135938535,
-0.0573331267,
-0.0205982607,
0.0376206078,
-0.0400860123,
0.010449294,
-0.0599918999,
-0.0419065431,
-0.0137639539,
0.0264970828,
0.0280632395,
0.0059236549,
-0.0143531607,
0.0060446169,
-0.0383503437,
-0.0512037612,
-0.0184337068,
-0.0205189288,
0.0116084544,
-0.0382413007,
0.0198915303,
-0.0116156945,
-0.0228736978,
-0.0205232762,
-0.0375829674,
-0.019977767,
0.0637424961,
0.0236956216,
-0.0161984861,
-0.0325833522,
0.0117451278,
-0.0180078465,
0.0366183519,
0.0075464151,
0.0147136059,
-0.0280003548,
0.06634105,
0.0753851384,
0.0478022806,
-0.0034691538,
-0.0258923881,
0.0058223475,
0.0523093529,
0.0713672712,
0.006367682,
-0.0495421775,
0.0415726379,
0.0259626731,
-0.0101048965,
-0.0044929823,
0.0126417382,
0.0877455622,
-0.0400613286,
-0.0161351897,
0.0868535936,
-0.0113426456,
0.004366939,
0.0115592042,
0.0461598784,
0.0822416618,
0.0135118496,
0.0304029044,
-0.0883037299,
-0.0602680556,
0.0161591433,
0.0347406305,
0.0361613519,
-0.0500048436,
-0.0279602781,
-0.0859160498,
-0.001808233,
-0.0138591453,
-0.0200551953,
-0.0345762633,
-0.0338397622,
0.0094379513,
-0.0184855983,
0.0039363634,
-0.0262997895,
-0.0307509732,
0.0269984826,
0.0543922,
-0.0026898554,
-0.0305922963,
0.0287362691,
-0.0175043065,
0.0586157553,
0.0514069982,
0.0650778264,
-0.0101139601,
-0.0101981582,
-0.0038913025,
-0.0259461105,
-0.0242991541,
-0.0197578929,
0.0590721183,
-0.011028531,
-0.0182552859,
0.0327560604,
0.0271210074,
-0.0245053545,
-0.0328613967,
0.0018005137,
0.0627899542,
0.0306125022,
-0.0780690536,
-0.0002768829,
-0.0184395071,
0.0059831846,
0.0973020047,
0.0330548137,
0.0159843974,
-0.0683353245,
0.0321775116,
-0.0198446754,
-0.0534395017,
0.00343173,
0.0028399227,
-0.0179633163,
-0.0161774084,
-0.0674335137,
-0.0011549618,
0.0517716892,
0.0493292846,
-0.000574398,
0.0197721776,
0.0152997449,
0.0264723543,
-0.0404686444,
0.0344340354,
-0.0241825264,
0.0076836622,
-0.0352354534,
-0.0231840871,
0.0081607001,
0.0096363211,
-0.0271334667,
-0.023809826,
-0.0879029855,
-0.0268603861,
-0.0241365414,
0.0666619539,
0.0212400649,
0.0346170217,
-0.0145105384,
-0.0228390824,
0.0690021217,
0.0324846506,
-0.0339518152,
0.0328203775,
0.0342048965,
-0.0481960587,
-0.0012561335,
0.0577559993,
-0.007958957,
0.0487682261,
0.0253077764,
0.0697484985,
-0.0268648788,
-0.0281862449,
0.0020474463,
-0.0006196176,
-0.0023310669,
0.0208681878,
0.0100736097,
-0.0166322105,
0.0105576525,
0.03533094,
0.026487574,
-0.0728311837,
-0.0002057159,
0.0580737852,
0.0324389078,
-0.0051592155,
0.0033036005,
0.0177578405,
0.0143824946,
-0.0301931798,
0.0234424341,
0.0434000716,
-0.0054103057,
0.0360132568,
0.0123399049,
-0.0360913649,
0.0027174801,
-0.00875716,
0.038914714,
-0.0347301066,
0.0061946474,
0.0117366733,
0.0062121451,
-0.014631832,
0.0230144653,
-0.033859957,
-0.0442032032,
-0.0171831846,
0.0168794654,
0.0474607944,
-0.0228661243,
0.0664745495,
-0.0152448704,
-0.0079098679,
-0.021604931,
0.0269473083,
0.0060255793,
0.0213978942,
0.042001728,
0.0248125847,
-0.0005261475,
0.0320105478,
0.0859734938,
0.0380594283,
0.098462753,
0.0058477116,
-0.0032665669,
-0.0506853648,
-0.0168935936,
0.0178967007,
0.0106925154,
0.0082962783,
0.0480363332,
0.0094387243,
-0.0970534459,
-0.0036105455,
-0.0509803519,
-0.0106784496,
-0.0157673135,
0.0515914746,
0.0183109231,
0.0163150635,
-0.0262294561,
-0.0288482159,
0.0016428353,
0.0063104737,
-0.0230480339,
-0.0165926535,
-7.1430604e-33,
-0.0016781574,
0.027764095,
0.0320761465,
-0.0317808799,
-0.0288066491,
0.0087711252,
-0.0364961699,
-0.0212969501,
-0.0595464706,
0.0261669997,
-0.0178173408,
-0.0056227115,
0.0050827106,
0.0465141684,
-0.0586438403,
-0.0236773714,
0.0623671822,
0.0092674932,
-0.0163881835,
0.0186936837,
0.0035988905,
0.069852449,
0.0406306274,
-0.0261645038,
-0.0600499213,
-0.0003370697,
0.0034713247,
0.0137245301,
0.0515666418,
0.0049704285,
-0.0264842119,
0.0094805788,
0.0138419187,
-0.0487138145,
-0.0114888167,
0.0362011306,
-0.1186645627,
-0.0403927118,
0.044460889,
-0.0356542394,
-0.0178159494,
-0.0241251029,
0.0200734288,
-0.0049307588,
0.039262712,
-0.0118000051,
0.0030151037,
-0.0130889509,
-0.032790564,
-0.049605906,
-0.0671130344,
0.0162571929,
-0.0217184667,
-0.0603147745,
0.0342842788,
0.0004042887,
-0.0343797132,
-0.0291814748,
-0.0505571701,
-0.0149156973,
0.0000373548,
0.0468673222,
0.0262506641,
-0.0164435748,
-0.0248072352,
0.0354237966,
-0.0304560568,
-0.0250260886,
-0.0095144976,
0.0078587662,
0.0386572555,
0.1015306935,
0.0134731075,
-0.0101114856,
0.0480153039,
-0.0217733234,
-0.0727915838,
0.0123033021,
0.0194490254,
0.0507558621,
0.0376997478,
0.0026916775,
-0.01110572,
-0.0228454061,
-0.0317249298,
0.0150282672,
-0.0223571435,
-0.0180604719,
0.0566111505,
0.0262563266,
-0.0284478106,
0.0260396302,
0.0427201986,
-0.0597058088,
-0.0089604044,
0.0279228315,
-0.0173922889,
-0.0166154131,
0.0008651605,
0.0194634143,
-0.0838534907,
-0.0432083197,
0.0319947116,
-0.0115735484,
-0.0022873634,
0.0051968708,
0.0607156754,
0.0037464339,
-0.0434577391,
-0.0311594103,
-0.0356488302,
0.0452468134,
-0.0046247286,
0.0724722818,
0.0182703789,
0.0471417531,
-0.0048087738,
-0.0002181797,
-0.0072183274,
0.0218137484,
-0.0099905347,
0.0125562586,
0.0302171204,
0.0381934009,
-0.0308765937,
-0.0159905795,
-0.0368361697,
0.0050089727,
-0.018397985,
-0.0554440729,
-0.0197877027,
0.0076855626,
2.889e-7,
0.0486885533,
0.0352285914,
-0.0161023401,
-0.0684811175,
-0.0242967308,
0.0109351687,
-0.0216876511,
0.057227049,
0.0033563271,
-0.0298635513,
0.003504727,
0.0733868852,
0.0365999676,
0.018163519,
-0.0624685362,
-0.0371252671,
-0.0300479736,
-0.0127896788,
-0.0332708433,
-0.047905717,
0.0307917539,
0.1004332453,
0.0278663915,
-0.0302409027,
0.0092652496,
-0.0082813939,
0.0434065685,
-0.0122078862,
0.0339033268,
0.0108253229,
0.0132774087,
0.0148007236,
-0.0022388329,
0.022121137,
-0.0171076935,
0.0235415753,
0.0317236856,
0.0722489581,
-0.0294480436,
-0.0356594697,
-0.0072970246,
-0.0074728723,
0.0075144367,
-0.0320754983,
0.0878035873,
-0.0521911457,
-0.0237704646,
-0.0219322983,
-0.049696438,
0.0303124506,
0.0187731162,
0.0131051764,
0.0088550812,
0.0302257892,
0.0472086295,
-0.0046053058,
-0.0505657308,
-0.0918735936,
0.0164854228,
0.0269630682,
-0.050276313,
-0.0493399873,
-0.0444308631,
-0.0117105627,
0.0174501669,
-0.0533611551,
0.0367680229,
2.665527801e-34,
-0.0092294049,
0.0089289956,
0.0014445856,
0.0302663986,
0.0108522894,
-0.021307027,
-0.0156468451,
-0.0044456287,
-0.0002249829,
-0.1075265482,
-0.006408493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01003v1 | QUADRo: Dataset and Models for QUestion-Answer Database Retrieval | 2023-03-30T00:42:07 | 2023-03-30T00:42:07 | Stefano Campese, Ivano Lauriola, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | An effective paradigm for building Automated Question Answering systems is
the re-use of previously answered questions, e.g., for FAQs or forum
applications. Given a database (DB) of question/answer (q/a) pairs, it is
possible to answer a target question by scanning the DB for similar questions.
In this paper, we scale this approach to open domain, making it competitive
with other standard methods, e.g., unstructured document or graph based. For
this purpose, we (i) build a large scale DB of 6.3M q/a pairs, using public
questions, (ii) design a new system based on neural IR and a q/a pair reranker,
and (iii) construct training and test data to perform comparative experiments
with our models. We demonstrate that Transformer-based models using (q,a) pairs
outperform models only based on question representation, for both neural search
and reranking. Additionally, we show that our DB-based approach is competitive
with Web-based methods, i.e., a QA system built on top the BING search engine,
demonstrating the challenge of finding relevant information. Finally, we make
our data and models available for future research. | [
0.0308005046,
0.0372935757,
-0.0207315944,
0.0504490398,
0.0103218742,
-0.0012780062,
-0.0253170803,
0.0094184596,
0.0535088219,
-0.0324984156,
-0.0340519398,
-0.011192848,
-0.0322479717,
0.0043646949,
-0.0025520662,
-0.010746548,
0.0158406049,
0.0152929975,
-0.0175364278,
0.0133546023,
0.0107768951,
0.0215993226,
0.0017201892,
-0.0010000292,
0.0093207099,
-0.0209332705,
-0.0156795867,
0.0208746325,
0.0011253273,
-0.0068075806,
0.0254341848,
0.024381591,
0.0459749848,
0.0316086896,
0.0000016494,
-0.0448686257,
-0.0644751713,
-0.00490472,
-0.0419913381,
-0.0093385698,
-0.0364411809,
0.0446426868,
0.050654266,
0.0481902324,
-0.0784679502,
-0.0465926714,
0.0146295521,
0.0293919146,
0.0906886384,
0.036314588,
-0.0098400479,
-0.0555024892,
0.0472909175,
-0.003561757,
0.0017567829,
-0.0632387176,
0.0306314211,
0.0186856296,
0.0113212029,
0.0626185462,
0.0053734994,
0.0171395615,
0.0242068525,
-0.0123265469,
0.0062221773,
-0.0180118997,
-0.0372328646,
0.0324888825,
-0.0034905022,
0.1238809302,
-0.0055677844,
-0.0253327973,
0.0163500663,
0.038121257,
0.0113189947,
0.0409017168,
-0.0393069461,
-0.0139635485,
-0.0261865314,
-0.0073878556,
-0.0248488393,
0.009258898,
0.0074329618,
-0.0316888541,
-0.0263065193,
0.0365091302,
0.0308225416,
-0.0270914044,
0.00063739,
-0.0172971506,
-0.0354989171,
-0.0352116115,
0.0515449196,
0.0583904013,
0.0128508229,
0.0215007011,
-0.0087158531,
-0.0276760627,
0.0232848227,
-0.0385514349,
-0.00530134,
0.0042551938,
0.0050401697,
0.0658807307,
-0.0324136913,
0.056327302,
-0.0258109719,
0.0078316433,
-0.0737696365,
-0.0584269166,
-0.0656156316,
-0.0420160405,
-0.0544180088,
0.0682717264,
-0.0272330865,
-0.0184294209,
-0.0109961843,
0.0173489247,
0.0348705016,
-0.0194433331,
0.034248706,
0.0652948618,
0.0023988963,
0.0306548085,
-0.0420098826,
0.0297747534,
-0.041195605,
0.0160571411,
-0.0113039557,
-0.0484755374,
0.0042226431,
-0.0222122688,
0.047098238,
-0.0211342461,
0.0186551716,
0.0293023344,
-0.0016024454,
-0.0348436013,
0.014503479,
-0.0408940017,
0.0363968574,
0.0032319627,
-0.0157504324,
-0.0439929925,
0.0584061816,
0.0104141664,
-0.0180431288,
0.006497107,
0.01841015,
0.0729168132,
-0.0138581078,
0.0497091897,
-0.0099974889,
-0.0069361553,
0.0631457791,
0.0024996023,
0.0240349844,
0.0142318839,
0.0091074202,
-0.0005477233,
0.0628582537,
0.027491115,
0.0233547762,
-0.0028483344,
0.0314529203,
-0.0060630771,
0.0421455801,
0.1007947326,
-0.007835038,
0.0310707986,
-0.0258258246,
0.0647064596,
-0.0352316499,
-0.0699092969,
0.0152755454,
0.049414698,
0.0217435062,
0.0306588467,
-0.0187263917,
0.0122446679,
0.025620088,
-0.0358399861,
0.0118284049,
0.0392401665,
-0.0011481335,
-0.0004897023,
0.0285515431,
0.0357070565,
-0.0586011894,
-0.027586583,
0.0078112264,
0.0108662341,
-0.0132824359,
0.0363196619,
0.0213676784,
0.0392661206,
-0.0398022197,
0.0644479617,
-0.0113405921,
-0.0240593851,
-0.0055709528,
-0.0563764982,
0.0186359212,
0.0117558939,
0.0614414029,
-0.0803847164,
-0.0096299835,
-0.0135888383,
-0.0131138768,
-0.0114335036,
0.0300244428,
-0.0327845179,
-0.0142847653,
-0.0344481468,
-0.0140935136,
-0.0025655567,
-0.0274168346,
-0.0074049877,
0.020663457,
0.0252223816,
0.0096161477,
-0.0711175948,
-0.0048699323,
0.0175897349,
-0.0012271256,
-0.0187237728,
0.0428144075,
-0.0027700178,
-0.0182011668,
0.041773688,
0.0061767572,
0.0252868552,
0.0563516989,
-0.0068707676,
-0.0536086857,
-0.0398467667,
-0.0012903664,
-0.0260077491,
0.0397606865,
-0.0299260188,
0.0320488662,
0.087885201,
-0.0357377976,
-0.0399273261,
0.0080096405,
-0.0296087172,
-0.0005298367,
-0.0397245698,
-0.0090307808,
0.0079250569,
-0.0102300784,
-0.0656371191,
0.0523176417,
0.0134916613,
0.0304665286,
-0.0058835451,
-0.0269095451,
0.0467735268,
-0.0587230138,
-0.0090012187,
-0.0227098856,
-0.0266052671,
0.0340937041,
0.0062615275,
-0.0171753168,
-0.0443108045,
-0.005241158,
-0.073544912,
0.0325584598,
-0.0081978338,
0.0096914051,
0.0548569895,
0.0453442298,
0.0259029958,
-0.0369624533,
-0.0660465583,
-0.0005214611,
0.0126853604,
0.0098720239,
0.0532287881,
0.0204958897,
0.0226284564,
-0.0568031371,
-0.0586611293,
-0.0217419639,
0.0507722758,
0.0070292638,
0.010698664,
-0.0249501411,
-0.0176994409,
-0.0621827208,
0.0490417108,
0.0009971386,
0.0058008567,
0.0067891022,
-0.0230277125,
-0.0084192064,
0.0572341606,
0.0229334719,
-0.0251409933,
-0.0146107655,
0.0425521508,
-0.0530182235,
0.0132917492,
-0.0492998697,
-0.0177020412,
0.0031045887,
-0.0221571587,
0.0319984369,
-0.0128793828,
0.0165089648,
-0.0264102984,
-0.0122954231,
0.0558212399,
0.0313079283,
0.0155691216,
-0.070548147,
0.0057982937,
0.0438144729,
0.0199024789,
-0.0174526703,
0.0043976754,
0.0683793575,
0.0137221105,
0.0057471399,
-0.0471962616,
-0.0211992972,
-0.1062095761,
0.0470996536,
-0.0212253127,
0.0268479753,
-0.0183917675,
-0.0118256453,
-0.0159486681,
-0.0146251479,
-0.016973665,
-0.0538813174,
0.0181335248,
0.0006049269,
0.0340623893,
0.0034487448,
-0.0750251263,
-0.0280447304,
-0.037073005,
-0.0028378221,
0.0081819957,
-0.0225536842,
-0.0055823317,
0.0129995085,
0.0283293407,
0.0296735372,
0.0029087169,
-0.0315244086,
-0.0306126513,
0.0057107001,
0.1164892912,
0.0649493784,
0.0245550722,
0.0356691852,
-0.0018737492,
-0.0024773062,
0.0372116417,
0.0420715027,
-0.0130688846,
-0.0075659384,
-0.017387541,
0.0064226883,
-0.0445730723,
0.0018136307,
-0.0245246086,
0.0232411288,
-0.0094540678,
-0.0525679477,
0.0654516667,
0.050544221,
-0.0119942073,
-0.0304968711,
-0.0308236312,
-0.0119855804,
0.0381450318,
0.06764137,
-0.0953981131,
-0.0165245533,
-0.0459277853,
0.0321561471,
0.0184161495,
-0.0286028907,
0.0066584251,
-0.1100488007,
0.0005943889,
-0.0495518744,
-0.0091911945,
-0.0216737092,
-0.0568650775,
0.0046870918,
-0.0171262566,
-0.0308508351,
0.0351418965,
-0.0408640727,
0.0084821554,
0.0008699503,
0.0281697121,
0.0427995399,
0.0368974172,
-0.0417467207,
-0.0186869334,
0.0221069418,
0.014155291,
0.0173302349,
-0.0380228385,
-0.0440399908,
-0.0743322223,
-0.0049411599,
0.0083245058,
0.064791739,
0.0027987151,
-0.0138708642,
-0.0633143038,
0.0134434588,
-0.0317377932,
0.0397109613,
0.0332051925,
0.058461871,
-0.0260641612,
-0.0020370383,
-0.0370819494,
-0.0252100471,
-0.0126278121,
0.0474078506,
0.0078258319,
0.0110378955,
-0.0490828156,
-0.0020307975,
0.0156904664,
-0.0465090908,
-0.0479892269,
-0.0027912289,
0.0103843231,
0.041359704,
-0.0997825637,
-0.0080278674,
-0.0031910576,
0.0188038163,
-0.0161174648,
-0.0067822537,
0.0422605835,
0.0004241896,
-0.0647187531,
0.0062452061,
-0.0142898392,
-0.0080549633,
-0.0327154435,
0.0019647488,
0.0590376966,
-0.0327407233,
-0.0406213403,
-0.0420150124,
-0.0316585898,
-0.0136479037,
-0.0196138993,
0.0579793714,
0.017105598,
-0.0051912586,
-0.0278983973,
-0.019033378,
0.0337933861,
0.022698177,
-0.0162134878,
-0.0214408301,
-0.0065277284,
0.0004608416,
-0.0092639197,
0.0471740253,
-0.0765948594,
-0.0087732067,
-0.020059498,
0.0281151291,
-0.0581374355,
-0.0471682213,
0.0408384353,
0.0114617152,
0.000851981,
0.1007368714,
0.0087989923,
-0.0282962602,
0.0267955139,
-0.0474474207,
0.0109329205,
-0.0168172792,
0.0283925328,
0.0219452344,
-0.0187523197,
-0.0084965182,
-0.0375270657,
-0.0101246173,
0.0424678847,
-0.0260335915,
-0.0349836908,
0.0550167225,
-0.0181980319,
-0.0142846778,
0.003592595,
-0.0232129879,
-0.0026541357,
0.0245729443,
0.0749427229,
-0.0002892101,
0.0325186029,
0.0025951182,
-0.0342415161,
-0.0331734978,
0.0433659703,
-0.0892729238,
-0.100918591,
-0.0037690639,
-0.0176555198,
0.0346757285,
0.0219007917,
0.0020148905,
0.0434162691,
-0.0227702744,
0.0023692294,
-0.0226364955,
0.0127523188,
-0.0045682695,
0.0514018685,
0.0417529047,
-0.0039737145,
0.0463897511,
0.0674013123,
-0.0215040948,
0.0068051768,
0.0010671244,
-0.0432276726,
-0.0323248841,
-0.0011859756,
0.0236464627,
0.0234627239,
-0.0156851932,
-0.015677752,
-0.0040520988,
-0.014966052,
0.0063060727,
0.0013287311,
-0.018076282,
-0.0094057433,
0.0631978363,
0.0391514711,
0.050296057,
-0.0392059349,
-0.0629894435,
0.0362734869,
-0.0813772455,
-0.0379416868,
0.0133847995,
-5.71626703e-33,
0.0037766502,
-0.0058580986,
0.0190576743,
-0.0213931967,
0.0007620867,
-0.0043523246,
-0.0123531353,
-0.0499376357,
-0.0667319223,
-0.0352539606,
-0.0159752108,
0.0367712006,
-0.0069356919,
0.0147007955,
-0.0000896035,
-0.0487388708,
0.0031131573,
-0.0050681275,
-0.004227018,
0.0326410569,
0.0658377334,
0.0452352688,
0.0122253355,
-0.0244219787,
-0.0364668481,
-0.0474291816,
0.0275655519,
0.0738261193,
-0.0155799082,
0.0724890977,
-0.0163794849,
0.0215704795,
0.0431469195,
-0.0432572253,
0.042364642,
0.0428084619,
-0.1083365455,
-0.0313635916,
-0.0465347432,
-0.0248441007,
-0.0443927571,
0.0306391455,
0.0624309741,
-0.0219933372,
0.0394847356,
-0.0231990293,
0.045815587,
0.0198227689,
0.0137009462,
-0.0308870859,
0.0138030769,
-0.0138159897,
-0.0280056484,
-0.0199165754,
-0.0561279766,
0.0870757848,
-0.0180383399,
0.0317702666,
-0.0815805122,
-0.0093547292,
-0.0406714007,
0.036501985,
-0.0140757896,
0.0143787898,
-0.0052514705,
0.0308212359,
0.0486454405,
-0.020093374,
0.0295249857,
0.002316009,
-0.0404946432,
0.0274245646,
0.0549584627,
0.0290863086,
0.0302080475,
0.0186150074,
-0.1009957194,
0.038750425,
0.0151550807,
0.0257646199,
-0.0199067835,
0.0087492326,
-0.0129101127,
0.0048664645,
-0.0223654751,
0.0273240153,
-0.0640892312,
-0.0189671181,
0.0293456372,
0.0119460626,
-0.0181386974,
0.0013348104,
0.0183531158,
-0.0372815654,
-0.0133494074,
0.0386366472,
0.0049224314,
-0.0016920827,
0.0131567689,
0.0418882817,
-0.0401201211,
0.0389678143,
0.0119067924,
-0.0042596129,
0.0010427808,
0.0259737708,
-0.0113389669,
-0.0026540367,
-0.0561521202,
-0.0052736173,
0.0004391955,
-0.0246302243,
-0.0386384912,
0.0273781661,
-0.0245762728,
0.0697899014,
0.0069935871,
0.0330459625,
0.0238531157,
0.0408886671,
-0.0299889836,
-0.0352945663,
0.0416405164,
-0.007398305,
0.0096274009,
0.0034672089,
-0.0378584042,
0.0864800811,
-0.0268663708,
-0.0877803117,
-0.0000172304,
0.0287904236,
2.465e-7,
0.0552882254,
0.0049260347,
0.0386884697,
0.0452650636,
0.0103889192,
0.0175394062,
0.0331656225,
0.0697550923,
0.0669088438,
0.0205136556,
-0.0103604319,
0.0307043046,
-0.0074299625,
0.0242875423,
-0.0870076269,
-0.0537389144,
-0.0755536184,
-0.0674126744,
-0.0478977486,
-0.0480276383,
0.0430955365,
0.0757780597,
-0.0016980146,
0.0028690957,
-0.043653477,
-0.0368010476,
0.0477140658,
0.0341856442,
0.0046966448,
0.0202450771,
0.042720709,
0.0320687592,
-0.0110563925,
-0.0100208037,
0.0064870003,
0.0307652503,
0.0389068574,
0.0016314237,
-0.0110210432,
-0.0726811141,
-0.0019167258,
-0.0410224684,
0.0174515508,
-0.0604488701,
0.0825647265,
-0.0434719399,
0.0028435569,
0.0344055891,
-0.0380840562,
-0.034917932,
0.0221698098,
-0.0318090171,
-0.0156222126,
0.0220645852,
0.0035413681,
0.0109584602,
0.0561097525,
-0.0434649736,
0.015927786,
0.036469169,
-0.0241240133,
0.00152639,
-0.0100136129,
-0.0278139543,
-0.0301904958,
-0.0233397111,
0.0360406786,
1.852336422e-34,
0.0151056116,
0.0214341953,
0.0228814613,
-0.0026956764,
0.0179428756,
-0.025473699,
-0.034744259,
-0.0218388401,
0.0260590669,
-0.1076374054,
-0.0023370979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17071v1 | DERA: Enhancing Large Language Model Completions with Dialog-Enabled Resolving Agents | 2023-03-30T00:30:19 | 2023-03-30T00:30:19 | Varun Nair, Elliot Schumacher, Geoffrey Tso, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as valuable tools for many natural
language understanding tasks. In safety-critical applications such as
healthcare, the utility of these models is governed by their ability to
generate outputs that are factually accurate and complete. In this work, we
present dialog-enabled resolving agents (DERA). DERA is a paradigm made
possible by the increased conversational abilities of LLMs, namely GPT-4. It
provides a simple, interpretable forum for models to communicate feedback and
iteratively improve output. We frame our dialog as a discussion between two
agent types - a Researcher, who processes information and identifies crucial
problem components, and a Decider, who has the autonomy to integrate the
Researcher's information and makes judgments on the final output.
We test DERA against three clinically-focused tasks. For medical conversation
summarization and care plan generation, DERA shows significant improvement over
the base GPT-4 performance in both human expert preference evaluations and
quantitative metrics. In a new finding, we also show that GPT-4's performance
(70%) on an open-ended version of the MedQA question-answering (QA) dataset
(Jin et al. 2021, USMLE) is well above the passing level (60%), with DERA
showing similar performance. We release the open-ended MEDQA dataset at
https://github.com/curai/curai-research/tree/main/DERA. | [
0.0528275184,
0.0542323925,
-0.0094369063,
0.0051015066,
-0.0218640007,
-0.0081896409,
-0.0107733943,
-0.0243565012,
0.0400772206,
-0.0125205647,
-0.0219915602,
-0.0188778788,
-0.0095469533,
0.0389105864,
-0.0088293348,
-0.0776567534,
0.042852141,
-0.0166834742,
0.0580499284,
-0.0134967891,
0.0151723577,
0.0099891406,
-0.0309473146,
0.0568779334,
0.008795904,
-0.003798234,
-0.0068681333,
-0.0337670073,
0.0114088384,
-0.04191982,
0.0160862394,
0.0748289749,
0.0204197969,
0.0118563725,
0.0000021637,
-0.0332421549,
0.0021425677,
0.0040777465,
-0.0523711145,
-0.0311615448,
0.0289174076,
-0.0114359939,
0.0118841454,
0.0253076907,
-0.0361682139,
-0.0204789843,
0.0174542218,
0.0542015545,
0.0863304064,
0.0435134284,
0.0121971769,
-0.0042451457,
0.0241939146,
-0.0212079566,
-0.0082985451,
-0.0750073493,
0.0137650399,
0.0475358553,
0.0447880067,
0.0071333889,
0.0076995343,
0.0382414944,
0.0104283541,
0.0004557299,
-0.0075656152,
0.0431093834,
-0.0190351009,
-0.0337586366,
0.0060668201,
0.1077006236,
0.0229647942,
0.0159155335,
0.0009406341,
-0.0002619519,
0.0085131396,
0.0080807675,
-0.0728278756,
0.0197158363,
-0.0246235039,
-0.0140723586,
-0.014667701,
0.0078604268,
0.0059660533,
0.0138286138,
-0.0256894343,
0.0555753261,
0.0044217622,
0.0001625547,
-0.0027328273,
-0.0132551091,
-0.0156469326,
-0.0746485069,
0.0418353006,
0.0568319038,
-0.1049242839,
0.0280443709,
-0.0269588884,
0.0021984456,
0.0544702299,
-0.029775599,
-0.0083082011,
0.0416458771,
0.0168397482,
0.0391485766,
0.0321982652,
0.0269333757,
-0.0305208825,
0.0148830935,
-0.0554720722,
-0.0315053798,
-0.053774707,
-0.0297236368,
-0.0377829485,
0.0326415375,
-0.036793787,
0.0003889681,
-0.0349874645,
0.0235103965,
-0.0043447474,
0.0248349998,
0.0046095466,
0.0451296233,
-0.0522354469,
-0.0133716166,
-0.074422054,
0.051699236,
-0.0386657566,
0.0150100179,
0.0041422015,
-0.039481163,
-0.0054634763,
0.0031492426,
-0.0015409933,
-0.0105144074,
-0.0066547734,
0.0605122,
-0.0121817421,
0.0071757399,
0.022276558,
-0.0572998375,
-0.0194681082,
-0.0893814191,
-0.0241646077,
-0.0623507425,
0.0410939865,
0.0209837351,
-0.0234439038,
-0.0709917992,
0.0437075607,
0.0381341428,
-0.0361784399,
0.0727946013,
-0.0339791588,
0.015530373,
0.0306465495,
0.0441048592,
-0.0396037288,
0.0317620933,
0.0311711766,
0.0010067838,
0.0059964848,
-0.0105539262,
0.0365240648,
-0.0043193661,
0.033470314,
-0.0138231376,
0.0372558683,
0.056483984,
-0.01409561,
0.0664796084,
-0.0232017599,
0.0754182264,
-0.0177832302,
-0.016567342,
0.0624368973,
0.0641402379,
-0.0295330081,
0.0089224987,
-0.0055460637,
0.022352919,
0.0137712136,
0.0004110562,
-0.0441539176,
0.0354533121,
-0.0039601102,
0.0107434085,
0.0183232035,
0.0101624001,
-0.0417150557,
-0.0515779965,
-0.0133509208,
0.0061977408,
-0.0013811969,
0.0160644129,
0.0198265593,
0.0047425837,
-0.0380042344,
0.0555394068,
0.0141766276,
-0.0361243524,
-0.0082676886,
-0.0608461238,
0.0338982604,
0.089906171,
0.0696924329,
-0.0085555008,
-0.0797988772,
-0.017397346,
0.007870744,
0.0215158109,
0.0236544255,
-0.0143872118,
-0.0006360958,
-0.0339255184,
-0.0316131376,
0.0070631197,
0.0006178464,
0.0006575584,
0.0295715127,
-0.0026767373,
-0.0034514561,
-0.0115348781,
-0.0354650654,
-0.0091353217,
-0.0386041068,
0.0133081432,
0.0113611706,
-0.0186510123,
0.0472732149,
0.0306885038,
-0.0084773153,
0.0412447527,
0.0377357602,
-0.011533075,
-0.0508886427,
0.0306070819,
-0.0397193953,
-0.0232802648,
0.029313894,
-0.0260371026,
-0.0222838596,
0.0033778213,
-0.0235963184,
-0.0530985072,
-0.0064130402,
-0.0591714494,
-0.0093764598,
-0.010117678,
-0.0013304119,
0.0352611952,
-0.0257511344,
-0.0483262576,
0.0697071776,
-0.0058061583,
-0.0050372714,
0.0435546488,
0.0205321759,
-0.0094964979,
-0.0443814695,
-0.0085795205,
0.0339237638,
0.0306538213,
0.0216299053,
0.0196218174,
0.0125525445,
-0.0530148149,
-0.0331519507,
-0.1189943999,
0.0130766109,
-0.0058568111,
-0.0000022072,
0.0271864738,
0.0169176888,
0.0022820372,
-0.0117575135,
-0.0432322845,
-0.0199129954,
0.0575839914,
0.0190305877,
0.0394930951,
0.0447539948,
-0.0115371877,
-0.0509710945,
0.0034981577,
-0.0175154954,
-0.0124349529,
0.0187219232,
0.0013431971,
-0.0288440138,
-0.0028680118,
-0.045507662,
0.0108665908,
-0.0157861132,
-0.0267907493,
0.0340852812,
-0.0136110969,
0.0037325341,
0.0455870181,
0.0040498972,
0.0074459491,
0.0394293815,
-0.0116675422,
-0.0602688417,
0.0359643921,
-0.0346078798,
-0.0315267742,
-0.0134466058,
-0.036744114,
-0.0126082012,
0.0637956038,
0.025289217,
0.000339718,
-0.0533357635,
0.0319665968,
0.0145671703,
-0.0010554516,
-0.0108433152,
0.006529192,
-0.0173026286,
0.0837580487,
-0.0071827737,
-0.0221014209,
0.1050975919,
-0.008197993,
0.009665695,
-0.0805370882,
-0.0119764153,
-0.0681538582,
0.0394347869,
-0.0133401696,
0.0043457169,
-0.006200443,
-0.0223536547,
-0.0295368154,
-0.0167745221,
0.0027817125,
-0.0577443354,
0.0773237124,
-0.0600692518,
0.0122558,
-0.0021921278,
-0.0523249395,
-0.03612113,
-0.0242915843,
-0.0470032729,
0.0059656044,
0.0223144256,
-0.0003951135,
-0.0384198129,
0.0071813278,
0.0432575196,
0.0436338522,
-0.0035440763,
-0.0045052883,
-0.0365219377,
0.0037695803,
0.0435660221,
0.0483237952,
0.0078068348,
-0.0117808264,
0.05899271,
0.0808447078,
0.0236385856,
0.005788547,
-0.0114777703,
-0.0189959072,
-0.0049716891,
-0.0259753466,
0.0015731577,
0.0203877911,
0.0568576232,
-0.0540007055,
-0.0021814636,
0.1260022968,
0.0269540977,
-0.0281986184,
-0.0022309327,
-0.032108549,
0.0358861126,
0.0042903926,
0.0145565988,
-0.0480138548,
-0.040401265,
-0.0017389444,
0.027392149,
-0.0066541978,
-0.0278160665,
0.0152264591,
-0.065426372,
0.0459573418,
-0.0100953039,
-0.0243331101,
-0.0383984819,
-0.0286062937,
0.0205738284,
-0.0165092517,
0.0200422816,
0.0148532065,
0.0073408578,
-0.004130315,
-0.0136985239,
-0.0183516592,
-0.0247827899,
0.045133505,
-0.0262755267,
0.0547749028,
0.0643217415,
0.0309556201,
0.0073391702,
0.0151838623,
-0.0029149342,
0.0067916652,
-0.0038768586,
-0.0060719587,
0.0614976585,
0.007296537,
0.0030779056,
-0.0656399876,
0.0384130031,
-0.0217416231,
-0.0297597032,
0.018678505,
0.0789386779,
-0.034826044,
0.0065614516,
-0.0632880703,
0.0556781627,
0.0015830763,
0.0755149946,
0.014873025,
-0.0084072147,
-0.0555364601,
-0.0192509331,
0.0221660547,
-0.0161610786,
-0.033671204,
0.0158510003,
-0.003452206,
0.0194849931,
-0.0471128374,
-0.0677375495,
0.0724540874,
-0.0265600905,
0.0014258373,
0.0162218958,
0.0419825725,
0.0200093556,
-0.0097824773,
0.0442245454,
-0.0147898085,
0.0071470644,
-0.0439358465,
-0.0332857408,
0.0580126904,
-0.0210615396,
-0.0256346259,
0.038339749,
-0.0469632372,
-0.0300007798,
-0.0433354564,
0.0484223627,
0.0250472631,
0.0238052197,
-0.011168045,
-0.0333340541,
0.0019196009,
0.0142407008,
-0.0607922226,
-0.0264663156,
0.0030507073,
0.0516126342,
-0.0091749094,
0.0470906794,
-0.0285831001,
-0.0048755715,
-0.0403063484,
0.0639382824,
-0.0416324064,
-0.0765583217,
0.0300377458,
0.0175186414,
-0.0118056983,
0.0303808581,
0.0070251361,
-0.0238428451,
0.0364519209,
-0.0404103808,
-0.0241502989,
-0.0410393886,
-0.0000351321,
0.0139845815,
-0.0552516393,
0.0396847315,
-0.0020417941,
-0.0603718646,
0.0031881921,
-0.0003309447,
-0.0119318906,
-0.0011613684,
-0.0340882689,
0.0392726809,
-0.0141537413,
-0.0342647582,
0.0036421386,
0.0065783137,
0.0405369587,
-0.0002802973,
0.0677562952,
-0.0022352263,
-0.0103166895,
0.0206308849,
0.026101023,
-0.0803194568,
-0.1221434101,
0.0002856018,
0.0325861797,
0.0135067254,
0.0475596413,
0.028738169,
-0.0385548808,
-0.0018663396,
-0.0228758119,
0.0177556928,
-0.0043583224,
0.0003153411,
0.0436244756,
0.0237751007,
0.0122698275,
-0.0311893504,
0.0848766044,
0.007355486,
0.0443643369,
-0.0094489008,
-0.0412796251,
-0.0390629433,
-0.080843024,
-0.0266685579,
-0.0046933638,
-0.0342069939,
0.0021625517,
-0.0563860238,
-0.0419646874,
-0.0081861317,
-0.0043406053,
-0.0511763729,
-0.0479000211,
0.0554115847,
0.0297728926,
0.0045497739,
-0.06884294,
-0.0372685641,
0.0475090817,
-0.0267485343,
-0.0061546322,
-0.0187220611,
-6.32710716e-33,
-0.0414473265,
-0.0510018207,
0.0507657416,
-0.0205703955,
0.0024344567,
-0.0227434225,
-0.04271999,
0.0275687221,
-0.0140947141,
0.0216008201,
-0.0164134186,
0.029835837,
0.004917603,
0.0360317081,
-0.0075802212,
-0.0411860719,
0.0248071849,
0.0073909918,
-0.0229443889,
0.0624493249,
-0.0036211433,
0.0044660517,
0.0066847838,
-0.0619612597,
0.0236217361,
-0.0038528275,
0.0232547205,
0.0334395133,
-0.0511380546,
0.0821310952,
-0.0170810912,
0.0381590277,
0.0321976095,
-0.0253000334,
-0.0288697779,
0.0177631546,
-0.0598637424,
-0.0254390854,
0.0449226946,
-0.0221407283,
-0.0665604845,
-0.0383747071,
0.0392659269,
-0.0152110448,
-0.000424088,
-0.0279511716,
0.00480361,
-0.0125236148,
-0.0059281616,
0.0081397705,
-0.0406021625,
0.0342797637,
-0.0139954779,
-0.0290092193,
-0.0184709691,
0.0386049524,
-0.0124858283,
0.0151738226,
-0.0216406249,
-0.0018461521,
0.0397640802,
0.0106531959,
0.0352793299,
-0.0209134072,
-0.0240575951,
0.0335908048,
0.0299527291,
-0.0049317055,
-0.0580013394,
-0.041429013,
-0.071530126,
0.0717300773,
0.0439303219,
0.0512566082,
-0.0300167203,
0.0176586378,
-0.0496376976,
0.0434451215,
-0.033671625,
0.0887347236,
0.0434452258,
-0.0070362231,
-0.0475058928,
-0.0084403111,
-0.0809145644,
0.0233332925,
-0.0351931527,
-0.0372639634,
0.0274092015,
0.005254495,
0.0021644384,
-0.0456045866,
0.0102134263,
-0.0185612198,
0.0188000277,
0.0060668536,
-0.0028577156,
0.0125036472,
-0.0025889752,
0.0399654992,
-0.0348359868,
0.0310240947,
0.0135303633,
-0.0028424505,
0.0168269239,
0.0304574128,
-0.0260421149,
-0.022636041,
-0.0188168902,
0.0177842807,
-0.0441642553,
0.0260370336,
-0.0388699807,
0.0029568064,
0.0338633209,
0.0079970201,
-0.0134909917,
0.058736302,
-0.0186656676,
0.0238420404,
-0.0538988896,
-0.0379888192,
0.0297945607,
-0.0139004868,
-0.0444113873,
0.0094484994,
-0.0420130119,
0.0156814046,
0.0128833698,
-0.0337810442,
-0.00761043,
-0.003446463,
2.817e-7,
0.0564739443,
0.0552812554,
0.0132200932,
0.0548283234,
0.031503085,
0.0344810523,
-0.0079729324,
0.0193061791,
0.0358226635,
-0.0251894686,
0.0218668766,
0.0271634609,
0.028149046,
0.0672406778,
-0.069498904,
-0.0399315208,
-0.0510885529,
-0.0298725367,
-0.0530784465,
-0.0489436984,
0.0852071419,
0.074356012,
-0.0384468064,
-0.006665091,
-0.0132889571,
-0.01576172,
0.0509555861,
-0.0419832915,
-0.0285507701,
0.0608932562,
0.0296645518,
0.0262176655,
0.0311571043,
0.0337344632,
0.02176309,
-0.0071636545,
-0.0010410668,
0.1128557548,
-0.008092504,
-0.0348548554,
0.0007332642,
-0.0236009993,
0.0361805521,
-0.0576302409,
0.0685512125,
-0.081347242,
-0.0504357964,
-0.0072574969,
-0.0097753936,
-0.0340100378,
0.0295621306,
-0.0305550285,
-0.0168446191,
0.0142203923,
0.0077787163,
0.0259984955,
0.0008063174,
-0.0538914241,
-0.0272411294,
0.0212632287,
-0.0719998479,
-0.0513981953,
-0.0090900036,
-0.0397473313,
0.0090234941,
-0.0639882684,
0.0190734528,
2.524887938e-34,
0.0429592133,
0.0214454122,
0.0059847957,
0.0459165424,
0.052943036,
0.0042442339,
-0.0069557666,
0.0064785848,
0.0537414365,
-0.0661753342,
-0.0256680325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17006v1 | How do decoding algorithms distribute information in dialogue responses? | 2023-03-29T20:21:45 | 2023-03-29T20:21:45 | Saranya Venkatraman, He He, David Reitter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans tend to follow the Uniform Information Density (UID) principle by
distributing information evenly in utterances. We study if decoding algorithms
implicitly follow this UID principle, and under what conditions adherence to
UID might be desirable for dialogue generation. We generate responses using
different decoding algorithms with GPT-2 on the Persona-Chat dataset and
collect human judgments on their quality using Amazon Mechanical Turk. We find
that (i) surprisingly, model-generated responses follow the UID principle to a
greater extent than human responses, and (ii) decoding algorithms that promote
UID do not generate higher-quality responses. Instead, when we control for
surprisal, non-uniformity of information density correlates with the quality of
responses with very low/high surprisal. Our findings indicate that encouraging
non-uniform responses is a potential solution to the ``likelihood trap''
problem (quality degradation in very high-likelihood text). Our dataset
containing multiple candidate responses per dialog history along with
human-annotated quality ratings is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/saranya132/dialog_uid_gpt2. | [
0.0557699203,
0.0923610777,
-0.0261848569,
-0.0001473973,
-0.0117756603,
0.0042441492,
-0.0243319273,
0.0419158824,
-0.0400751978,
-0.0284371264,
-0.0291151106,
-0.053829927,
0.0682234541,
0.0029098999,
0.0106405942,
-0.0844558105,
0.0122723021,
-0.0161719993,
0.0520812646,
-0.0130559113,
-0.0105263479,
-0.0159815848,
-0.0287583247,
0.0367967002,
-0.0342371427,
0.0016200461,
-0.0237880945,
0.0322193205,
0.023586791,
0.0004225339,
-0.0010721488,
0.0654377416,
-0.0215181485,
0.0145014869,
0.0000019237,
-0.0061631477,
0.0149761625,
-0.0157464128,
-0.0068669305,
0.0422240049,
0.0384794734,
-0.0137690613,
-0.0224946309,
0.0295199547,
-0.0488997139,
-0.0021325424,
0.0559100918,
0.0557353199,
0.0361731946,
0.0655583814,
-0.0030362976,
-0.0195782427,
0.0178878009,
-0.0034455694,
-0.0029347106,
-0.0361707918,
-0.017211426,
0.0384403691,
-0.0232223589,
-0.0083490619,
-0.0226258896,
0.0070753437,
0.0037405358,
-0.0029818821,
0.0165275186,
0.0424327999,
-0.0269482043,
-0.061176654,
-0.01424958,
0.0682891831,
0.0666056052,
-0.0014908824,
-0.0327701531,
-0.0040568635,
0.0336251743,
-0.0025151535,
-0.0348267891,
0.0418265499,
-0.0221441686,
0.0274237357,
-0.0050680186,
0.0438523181,
-0.0287791193,
-0.0319802389,
-0.0074896035,
0.0167517252,
-0.0127023943,
-0.0249259174,
-0.0404397734,
0.0226050951,
-0.0388264619,
-0.0344829187,
0.0228086002,
0.0132677862,
-0.0299616214,
-0.0156648792,
-0.0488520637,
-0.0059909672,
0.0244199205,
-0.006640913,
-0.0080351299,
0.0468908623,
0.0273897219,
-0.0186843779,
0.0652390942,
0.0483245738,
-0.0056501473,
0.004039356,
-0.0383269973,
0.0208932143,
-0.0421620831,
-0.0096539678,
-0.0009266691,
0.0352009311,
-0.0203403663,
-0.0245825499,
-0.0333839171,
0.0197282117,
0.0289962515,
-0.0441190824,
0.0140264956,
0.0240383409,
-0.0510350876,
0.021534251,
-0.0351774693,
0.0397098735,
-0.0463764332,
0.0145848813,
0.0144609902,
-0.047841195,
-0.0003538284,
0.0372494906,
0.0218393207,
0.0054284325,
-0.0358293429,
0.0386606269,
-0.0112650832,
-0.0129344305,
0.01365906,
-0.033282496,
-0.040250551,
-0.0484224968,
-0.0414874367,
-0.031842079,
0.0301779676,
0.0237374548,
-0.0262115002,
-0.0239658337,
-0.0067756041,
0.011917498,
-0.0555796959,
0.0238338672,
-0.046914842,
0.0550477318,
0.0145368641,
-0.0034119389,
0.0060419422,
0.0435881503,
0.0453755409,
0.006569677,
0.0371176228,
-0.0238902271,
0.0269877426,
0.0097946115,
0.0171049647,
0.0436846763,
0.0353443734,
-0.0067213336,
-0.0416585207,
0.0125381472,
0.0715556741,
0.0792705268,
-0.081549108,
-0.0206563175,
0.1141014695,
0.0539994389,
-0.0102734277,
-0.0023407824,
-0.0041564037,
0.0792786777,
0.0014131399,
0.0915635452,
-0.0133709414,
0.0025205344,
0.0053876201,
-0.009378924,
0.0890603513,
0.0053264545,
-0.0145107014,
-0.0701863766,
0.0148502151,
0.0107268207,
-0.0023955645,
-0.0127730509,
-0.0240274686,
0.0247779302,
-0.040821556,
0.0415388867,
0.0005972594,
-0.0375266112,
-0.0136531359,
-0.028739037,
0.036107026,
0.0762930512,
0.0397186913,
0.04072427,
0.0177687686,
-0.0097907679,
-0.017354846,
0.0488851964,
0.0175290015,
-0.007548884,
0.0367702655,
-0.0387206636,
-0.0145027982,
0.025667673,
0.0178047251,
0.0230495613,
-0.0134324292,
0.0028889722,
-0.0000424816,
-0.0199530609,
0.0216949098,
-0.0087573836,
0.005461657,
-0.0045461715,
0.0244964417,
-0.0289860442,
0.0362529308,
0.0296306051,
-0.0399847142,
0.0141164437,
0.0115066897,
-0.0008151705,
-0.0269342922,
0.0234339796,
-0.0460570343,
-0.0381797068,
0.0091353497,
-0.0469585322,
0.0011253548,
0.0155163109,
0.0188014563,
-0.0197630748,
0.0298683029,
-0.0554286204,
0.0474102944,
-0.0343867019,
0.0122657828,
0.0300833043,
0.0326832309,
-0.0378668606,
0.0370911583,
-0.0260908864,
0.0033589781,
0.0464028902,
0.0302413292,
0.0095161451,
-0.0510290302,
0.0471880436,
0.0542219169,
-0.0445943102,
0.0330518596,
0.0351931788,
0.0193071458,
-0.0275794696,
-0.0376873165,
-0.107660681,
0.0120064868,
0.0001113854,
0.0002293999,
0.0394478031,
0.0063842144,
-0.0223546438,
-0.0069825812,
-0.0524792261,
-0.0234502647,
0.0150004122,
0.017987784,
0.0484625101,
0.0062693255,
-0.0157095082,
-0.0217742734,
-0.0025073069,
0.021120172,
0.0104843425,
0.006363207,
-0.0079437355,
-0.0765542537,
0.0595187582,
-0.0178308431,
-0.0055460306,
0.0177042279,
-0.076156944,
0.0320263803,
0.0344828218,
0.0640716553,
0.0464202389,
0.0523113236,
0.0384270772,
-0.0260147806,
0.0112203602,
-0.054103218,
0.0003301523,
-0.0285826288,
0.0072297622,
-0.022160586,
-0.0787797719,
0.0477422737,
0.0359416455,
0.0742928609,
0.0392510854,
-0.0815655366,
0.0234334879,
-0.0236430988,
-0.0601260215,
0.0056322548,
-0.0069205584,
-0.0190913528,
0.0741404966,
-0.0070484299,
-0.0450027622,
0.0391679108,
-0.0140271839,
-0.0007412414,
-0.0252326503,
-0.0008369377,
-0.0129100215,
0.0012463415,
-0.0136782257,
0.0183234662,
0.0090821423,
-0.0635545179,
-0.0325982571,
0.0084709944,
0.0456050932,
-0.0469665192,
0.0004637178,
-0.0399796665,
-0.0276935734,
-0.0411503948,
-0.0699853003,
-0.0180222746,
-0.0678045973,
0.0242627338,
-0.041766014,
0.036874488,
-0.0506083257,
0.0273490064,
0.0183337852,
0.000552928,
-0.0330518149,
-0.0432129912,
-0.021522563,
-0.0090581523,
0.0488866754,
0.0407615304,
0.0462904461,
0.0369042419,
-0.0475727618,
0.0369179733,
0.0754166469,
-0.0180032216,
0.0544400029,
0.0127671072,
-0.0040334403,
0.0292923879,
0.0311705042,
-0.0438498668,
0.0355408341,
0.1064169928,
0.0135843931,
0.0103453863,
0.0994029045,
0.0076603172,
-0.034399841,
-0.0050870604,
-0.0146197444,
0.0966413096,
-0.0052330825,
-0.0157768372,
-0.0854587257,
-0.0211629942,
0.0035801802,
0.0486543849,
-0.0403364934,
-0.0309519209,
0.0050460808,
-0.075757131,
0.0641680658,
0.0343991481,
-0.0133683188,
-0.0578358658,
-0.0482492223,
-0.0184073355,
-0.0125489347,
0.0759521574,
-0.004237189,
0.0232072622,
0.0471058935,
0.0379515477,
-0.0518869534,
-0.0255584102,
-0.0544556379,
-0.0225065593,
0.0667437389,
0.0554495156,
0.0675081089,
0.0149243427,
0.0133602181,
-0.0051737926,
-0.0024118507,
-0.0238145292,
-0.0012580693,
0.0909415558,
-0.0039402773,
0.0074982294,
-0.0639567897,
0.0068391617,
-0.0494064018,
-0.0005965897,
-0.0064064255,
-0.0215061363,
-0.0345018432,
-0.02305655,
-0.0370815061,
0.0247675236,
0.0370150805,
0.0971809924,
0.027445551,
-0.0444290079,
-0.0225089975,
-0.0311554763,
0.0559099168,
-0.0556036904,
-0.0273913629,
0.0545708388,
0.0206634197,
-0.0873971209,
-0.1216030344,
-0.0661550239,
-0.0385381803,
0.0232714694,
0.0043840706,
0.0196189955,
0.0013211172,
-0.0181383211,
0.0128603252,
-0.0510616712,
-0.0353130735,
-0.0118391644,
-0.0487616174,
-0.0248923544,
-0.0351531729,
-0.0549891777,
0.0242440253,
0.0367801376,
-0.0428563245,
-0.0383117311,
-0.0197493546,
0.0143858995,
0.0269848593,
0.0680639967,
0.011033928,
-0.0245058946,
0.0064189262,
0.0019994599,
-0.0310355853,
0.042652145,
0.0199405961,
0.0367134251,
0.0138734644,
0.0284895878,
0.0036595117,
0.0148961199,
-0.0201159082,
0.0190302767,
-0.0272762142,
-0.092022799,
0.0366991758,
0.0471752249,
-0.0260323472,
-0.0076868506,
-0.0115078334,
0.0212507937,
-0.0098367911,
-0.0128632057,
0.0024738743,
-0.0529349521,
-0.0049208477,
0.0511561334,
0.0061751683,
-0.0184203517,
0.010368688,
-0.0208834317,
0.0428942293,
-0.0225135926,
-0.0237675887,
-0.0110271554,
0.0122118862,
0.0081533147,
-0.0062690652,
-0.0068882043,
0.0261005741,
-0.0312924981,
0.0672369376,
0.0285688955,
0.0614573732,
-0.0092672007,
-0.036504928,
0.0385139138,
0.0413532183,
-0.0744422078,
-0.0526989587,
0.0103346063,
-0.0045103971,
0.023609262,
0.0294631422,
0.0728669763,
-0.0277606267,
0.036401093,
-0.0168036446,
0.0490902402,
-0.0049456349,
0.0155039579,
0.0138882147,
-0.0021775884,
-0.0409535542,
0.0072337766,
0.0854774415,
-0.0001250724,
-0.0069000595,
-0.0168964844,
-0.0314495713,
-0.0417756885,
-0.019296607,
0.0062864451,
0.0385814719,
0.0025763777,
-0.0049376576,
-0.0465955846,
-0.0218790341,
-0.0602915287,
-0.0014661647,
0.0385118574,
-0.0439383164,
0.0205614772,
0.0414228551,
-0.0404961482,
-0.0115782833,
-0.0505049676,
0.001205639,
-0.0302063674,
0.0072004814,
-0.0355466641,
-6.533772291e-33,
-0.0195446461,
-0.0175409671,
-0.0311093945,
-0.0079548629,
-0.029240502,
-0.0306073073,
-0.0153998192,
0.0261049811,
-0.0149592562,
0.0207306724,
-0.0183626693,
0.0348681882,
0.0131667191,
0.0032996372,
-0.040285781,
-0.0062947264,
0.0368031375,
-0.0122823026,
-0.0670704991,
0.0238212105,
0.0116184615,
-0.0182095226,
0.0029614894,
-0.0477846377,
0.0090748612,
-0.0068928418,
-0.0162633248,
0.0035367652,
0.0203698967,
0.0534598157,
-0.0441735648,
0.0722429454,
0.0243582632,
-0.0065291305,
-0.047533378,
0.0516956225,
-0.0467875451,
-0.0196712818,
0.0169679299,
0.0392852835,
-0.028927885,
-0.0285664238,
0.0018713152,
-0.0056952722,
-0.0218096375,
-0.0097119957,
0.0184089746,
-0.0184104405,
-0.011811357,
-0.0045565302,
-0.0299618896,
0.0276376382,
-0.0346172266,
-0.0294823274,
0.0023536519,
0.054989785,
0.007658001,
-0.0297291148,
-0.0277306847,
0.0391006619,
-0.0008525226,
0.0119022392,
0.0116676791,
-0.0185075626,
-0.0090153245,
0.0530790575,
0.0542538762,
0.0160613451,
-0.0119358562,
-0.0716397241,
-0.0323836505,
0.0234763063,
-0.0132519491,
0.0818435848,
0.028456321,
-0.053118147,
-0.018766541,
0.036072053,
0.0146013312,
-0.0438255146,
0.0199438948,
0.0339806676,
-0.0621477254,
-0.0461801626,
-0.0076289112,
-0.0037394515,
-0.0233868267,
-0.0393441841,
0.031638138,
-0.0038376977,
-0.0150350584,
-0.0422775038,
0.0551592074,
-0.0670903772,
-0.0060496423,
0.0134981098,
-0.0563319698,
0.0344795808,
-0.0161823593,
-0.0216612127,
-0.0371547416,
0.0019838219,
0.0475845821,
0.0420674458,
0.0112661105,
0.0271998681,
0.0015677502,
-0.0060621682,
-0.0444157757,
-0.0142896166,
-0.0049109953,
0.0581485368,
-0.0122232456,
-0.013877471,
0.0182904694,
-0.0056450483,
-0.0332064852,
0.0117168147,
-0.0120893065,
0.0170517322,
-0.0614412203,
-0.0098037776,
-0.0075183539,
-0.0066769156,
-0.0295350254,
-0.0246460922,
-0.0354697742,
-0.0346786566,
0.0094169267,
-0.0394876115,
-0.0538065545,
-0.0058305981,
2.648e-7,
0.0111018401,
0.0465882793,
0.0466143638,
-0.0064804279,
0.0430415943,
0.0482884347,
0.0262644477,
0.0333271064,
0.0269227587,
-0.0601869002,
0.007900334,
0.0189308263,
0.0508108549,
-0.0002246038,
-0.1023339704,
-0.0584413111,
-0.0124886008,
-0.0116513502,
-0.0159615353,
0.0162002202,
0.084182173,
0.0608275235,
-0.026838636,
-0.0236678105,
0.0415102243,
0.0290399902,
0.0399487987,
-0.0266465936,
-0.0186173134,
0.0381838679,
0.0139829582,
-0.0412323065,
0.0296181496,
0.053755939,
-0.0048740478,
-0.0199679155,
-0.0065168045,
0.062120121,
-0.0006104727,
-0.0623544231,
-0.0203065202,
0.0004609682,
0.0196586158,
-0.045246657,
0.0475697406,
-0.0014853895,
-0.0753627643,
0.0067199529,
-0.031269256,
-0.01519656,
0.0088251187,
-0.0195096396,
-0.0321197212,
0.0375645868,
0.0106117232,
0.0323808566,
-0.0067179496,
-0.001496514,
-0.0101862811,
-0.0325171389,
-0.0500361249,
-0.0977988839,
-0.0199374501,
0.0041487771,
0.0218438525,
-0.0408112742,
0.0094450964,
2.367833398e-34,
0.0388776921,
-0.0096005909,
0.0696010292,
0.0359568559,
0.0634588748,
-0.0223125927,
0.0189544633,
0.0068730363,
0.0562496893,
-0.0071533006,
0.0067426921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17003v1 | Evaluating GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 Models on Brazilian University Admission Exams | 2023-03-29T20:10:13 | 2023-03-29T20:10:13 | Desnes Nunes, Ricardo Primi, Ramon Pires, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The present study aims to explore the capabilities of Language Models (LMs)
in tackling high-stakes multiple-choice tests, represented here by the Exame
Nacional do Ensino M\'edio (ENEM), a multidisciplinary entrance examination
widely adopted by Brazilian universities. This exam poses challenging tasks for
LMs, since its questions may span into multiple fields of knowledge, requiring
understanding of information from diverse domains. For instance, a question may
require comprehension of both statistics and biology to be solved. This work
analyzed responses generated by GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models for questions
presented in the 2009-2017 exams, as well as for questions of the 2022 exam,
which were made public after the training of the models was completed.
Furthermore, different prompt strategies were tested, including the use of
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompts to generate explanations for answers. On the
2022 edition, the best-performing model, GPT-4 with CoT, achieved an accuracy
of 87%, largely surpassing GPT-3.5 by 11 points. The code and data used on
experiments are available at https://github.com/piresramon/gpt-4-enem. | [
0.0269496851,
-0.0089125158,
-0.0357973836,
0.0182444453,
-0.0252557211,
0.0047390689,
0.0019672054,
0.0050145267,
0.0213454682,
-0.0549323931,
0.0092859836,
-0.0393585823,
-0.0239688344,
-0.0041857595,
0.0218725838,
-0.0718146637,
0.0172227845,
-0.0258566085,
-0.021932641,
-0.0160364173,
-0.0226947088,
0.0123921176,
-0.0189877115,
0.0123004774,
0.043547716,
-0.0249053277,
-0.022689702,
-0.0224332176,
0.0100514432,
-0.0528442375,
-0.0003357291,
0.084496662,
-0.0109907901,
0.0246694945,
0.0000021583,
-0.0705307201,
-0.041209124,
-0.0172643363,
-0.0116612436,
0.0268033333,
0.0103145782,
0.0567095429,
-0.0017100397,
0.0262919199,
-0.0503980592,
-0.006131527,
0.0221911985,
-0.0247550327,
0.0580319203,
0.0593402795,
0.0128175812,
0.0003878321,
0.0550993122,
-0.0092853308,
0.0094148619,
-0.0427102409,
0.0263193902,
-0.0299232882,
-0.0027644273,
0.0576490983,
-0.0306528434,
-0.0159140155,
0.005145506,
0.02177044,
-0.0259144474,
0.0074209627,
-0.0121371001,
0.0035419434,
-0.0026571578,
0.0222626794,
0.0035641873,
-0.0088682799,
-0.0226093177,
-0.0228604469,
0.0272946749,
0.0531018935,
-0.0663142651,
0.0173968785,
-0.025784336,
-0.0102397893,
0.0356239453,
-0.0204049554,
-0.0173554812,
0.0108113429,
0.0128717404,
0.0491136611,
0.0325058252,
-0.0546514876,
0.039460972,
0.0110295312,
-0.0183353592,
-0.0210694298,
0.0102274483,
0.0328986272,
-0.0129942438,
0.0331514925,
0.0248970408,
-0.0268316064,
0.0467575453,
-0.0010080097,
0.0005974791,
0.0454646833,
-0.0007824958,
0.0179868359,
-0.0152971689,
0.1057355404,
0.0051268013,
0.0010015609,
-0.04751724,
-0.0100923898,
-0.0482496843,
-0.0319043845,
-0.011758198,
0.034904059,
-0.0039100936,
0.0368649885,
-0.0512144081,
-0.0154268844,
-0.001878591,
0.0005979584,
-0.0089581199,
-0.01597213,
0.0038652215,
0.0175597649,
-0.0696687624,
0.0565478466,
-0.0305468291,
-0.0163228009,
0.0124902343,
-0.0128039019,
0.0102750808,
0.0004020407,
-0.0271747988,
-0.0427388437,
0.0198702533,
0.0017889156,
-0.0045725587,
-0.0296603013,
0.0163955763,
-0.044686541,
-0.0164695419,
-0.0812335461,
0.0090602981,
-0.0451592617,
0.0067240903,
0.0340516195,
0.0184469819,
-0.0178300478,
0.0218049418,
0.0577902123,
0.0171672497,
0.0249883179,
0.0066767344,
-0.0057256068,
0.0343639217,
0.0321241878,
0.0019802775,
0.0281884074,
0.0027273521,
0.0099430308,
0.0204137843,
-0.0881919637,
0.0278216656,
0.0370466821,
0.0157201085,
-0.0028088121,
0.0314900167,
0.0406379886,
0.0641324148,
0.0352547206,
-0.0104476772,
0.0331843272,
0.0260045305,
0.0308226701,
0.0364718623,
0.0624765828,
-0.0103866374,
0.0160476007,
0.0457400642,
-0.0205190331,
0.0404174402,
0.0429342166,
-0.0157381892,
-0.0333664194,
-0.046615582,
0.0172776189,
0.0176146403,
0.0421140343,
-0.0026334545,
-0.0473915488,
-0.0105806328,
0.0293595586,
-0.0246421751,
0.0423784219,
0.0542357937,
-0.0523864366,
-0.0396267734,
0.0089566195,
0.0003916518,
-0.0443922579,
0.0087401578,
-0.0518263094,
0.0469382443,
0.0320646055,
0.0351046361,
-0.0064617856,
-0.0556756407,
-0.0092187831,
0.0111032119,
0.043742042,
0.0418676734,
-0.031734772,
-0.0557993054,
-0.0523379333,
-0.0181116629,
0.0206815675,
-0.0124676041,
0.0101799797,
-0.0219614413,
0.0412721634,
0.0156057877,
0.0051020435,
0.0081126466,
0.0238208175,
-0.0357717946,
-0.046263732,
-0.0293657407,
-0.015993312,
0.030908173,
0.0294763744,
0.0312915891,
-0.0030187252,
0.0138604036,
0.0162348114,
0.0143958051,
-0.0586852357,
-0.0528691672,
0.0052770022,
0.046541173,
-0.0302768387,
-0.0147572411,
0.0512076765,
-0.0169156846,
-0.0587175116,
-0.0111678271,
-0.0119404476,
-0.0183934309,
-0.0305510741,
0.0112459129,
-0.0387861878,
-0.0084333681,
-0.0471718907,
0.0550336167,
0.0259273872,
0.0941144824,
0.0370677225,
-0.0006971637,
0.0612140521,
-0.0599914566,
-0.0220424775,
0.0187604558,
0.0134824654,
0.0180590358,
0.0188299101,
0.0477233157,
-0.0703933388,
-0.0217962414,
-0.0788016394,
0.0377358571,
0.008073777,
0.0261576958,
0.0293110609,
-0.026706567,
-0.0351233557,
0.0153021943,
-0.047326643,
-0.0074645244,
0.0166014582,
-0.0016189828,
-0.0007467396,
0.0059683975,
-0.0122033879,
-0.0179756973,
-0.0110903727,
-0.0699490011,
-0.0009320636,
0.0485276692,
0.020037435,
-0.0143770631,
0.055324126,
-0.0145500405,
-0.0193224009,
0.0054014116,
-0.0057041449,
0.0187119637,
-0.0065456494,
0.0758505315,
0.0507075116,
0.0077209058,
-0.0082851937,
0.0347237699,
-0.0079122148,
-0.031894695,
0.0208608843,
-0.0137295173,
-0.0216408689,
-0.0374971852,
-0.0446247794,
0.0155291278,
0.059369497,
0.0410781316,
-0.035934668,
-0.0290203709,
0.0430068523,
-0.0487874225,
0.0256228298,
-0.0617319979,
-0.0129716909,
-0.0328379162,
0.0697870776,
0.0339049585,
-0.0057669599,
0.0715269074,
-0.0461539328,
0.0097527402,
-0.1018230468,
0.0211737044,
-0.0215488952,
0.0449213535,
0.0133537417,
-0.0269680005,
0.0137708224,
-0.0021052123,
-0.0686179847,
0.0033881653,
0.0171697699,
-0.0521183573,
0.0199444219,
-0.05213359,
-0.0326076783,
-0.0263967831,
-0.0190856177,
-0.0093387123,
-0.0179980043,
0.0043840394,
0.0226663034,
-0.0230575372,
0.0286891144,
0.0141869672,
0.0073980945,
0.0129623115,
-0.0113027589,
-0.038458962,
-0.027898347,
-0.0014810405,
0.067730777,
0.0624339245,
0.0010556086,
0.0256172009,
-0.0454728082,
0.0316667408,
0.0369331539,
0.0457944609,
0.0123443734,
0.0360189416,
0.0078014727,
0.0349516869,
-0.043992836,
-0.0570630208,
0.0200159438,
0.0096767386,
-0.0581760556,
0.0003534451,
0.1173564717,
0.0318741091,
-0.0340847299,
-0.0300588459,
-0.0568002053,
0.0244468898,
0.0212356504,
0.0410683192,
-0.0679645762,
0.0056910282,
-0.0119497469,
0.0208167285,
-0.0422859974,
-0.0139280921,
-0.004606015,
-0.1221544966,
0.0406119674,
-0.006111878,
-0.0401756205,
-0.0104457866,
-0.028044913,
-0.0085231978,
0.0039033336,
0.0186852477,
0.0246220157,
0.0145937428,
0.0338194668,
0.0522931218,
-0.0365837254,
-0.0188609213,
0.0487132296,
0.0056714024,
0.0026054415,
0.0306852814,
0.0038093722,
-0.0302275997,
-0.03616127,
0.0570848919,
-0.0888018385,
-0.0283701885,
-0.02696242,
0.0108755827,
-0.0053151734,
0.0237369835,
-0.053368181,
0.0424265228,
-0.0192555413,
0.0074949586,
0.0991551578,
0.1468087435,
-0.0134571027,
-0.0413749591,
-0.045558054,
-0.0183219425,
-0.0304649845,
0.0583613031,
0.0526067391,
-0.0574827939,
0.0032155388,
-0.0544781722,
0.0200518817,
0.0024993424,
-0.0309039187,
0.005354851,
-0.0001288992,
0.0126392059,
-0.006839206,
-0.0908768028,
0.0652446076,
0.0028093159,
0.0083543388,
0.0457706079,
0.0095308246,
-0.000947638,
0.0053161741,
0.0373119786,
-0.0127108414,
0.0034736851,
-0.045243822,
-0.0309721716,
0.0173088871,
-0.0048078937,
-0.0443287529,
0.0307483189,
-0.0347467028,
-0.0224867109,
-0.014169177,
0.0204056818,
0.0288733095,
-0.0078847343,
0.0204568114,
-0.0148453154,
0.0186219681,
-0.0458561741,
-0.0112655014,
-0.0097932676,
-0.0342131257,
-0.0038726921,
-0.0063313907,
-0.0168230329,
0.0198114011,
0.0013199365,
0.0263349116,
0.0513519756,
-0.0058103069,
-0.0406355001,
0.0461576767,
0.0413313508,
0.068112202,
-0.0023666979,
-0.0299556088,
-0.0348425992,
0.0271579809,
-0.0246859882,
-0.0066758795,
-0.0022987111,
-0.0186322387,
0.0444180034,
-0.0370792784,
-0.019542776,
-0.0759812519,
-0.0666214526,
0.0184772648,
-0.0489053987,
0.0166436769,
0.0269820057,
0.0459172241,
0.0284755919,
-0.0326789692,
-0.0178993233,
-0.0438747145,
0.0277457144,
0.0535066426,
-0.0025180853,
0.1287362278,
-0.0038404157,
-0.0360743776,
0.0860350654,
0.0005493704,
-0.0258736126,
-0.000837129,
-0.0495514609,
0.0252374429,
0.0028888732,
0.0204038825,
-0.0063062143,
-0.0106848786,
0.0027435289,
-0.0281755887,
0.0061947494,
0.0289378297,
-0.0166736506,
0.0619081482,
0.0130413184,
-0.0034210286,
0.0027178801,
0.0632362515,
0.0276776236,
-0.0011536139,
0.0403590985,
-0.0254421439,
-0.0376419872,
-0.0072563435,
-0.0052161412,
0.0310408175,
-0.0212037805,
0.0114479251,
-0.0911667794,
-0.0424325056,
-0.010812263,
0.0185833722,
0.014579488,
-0.0192769505,
0.0328086838,
0.0816493034,
-0.0546641834,
-0.0225392729,
-0.0211794227,
0.06176636,
-0.0467687696,
-0.0502685532,
-0.0127667002,
-6.049265111e-33,
-0.0400986709,
-0.0373275094,
0.0403347462,
0.0202217493,
0.0046477499,
-0.0169624873,
-0.030723352,
0.0326978266,
-0.0055910051,
-0.02254433,
-0.014416567,
-0.0081633031,
0.0048920857,
0.0365963578,
0.0283069164,
-0.0168159287,
-0.0121076228,
-0.0000800915,
-0.0327153392,
0.0394508317,
-0.0098928651,
0.009576573,
0.0763742849,
0.0027919658,
0.0645473525,
-0.0418908969,
0.0173730366,
-0.0139071206,
-0.0684778094,
0.0669367462,
-0.0203715954,
0.0512742996,
0.0431660637,
-0.0724865198,
0.0202061813,
0.0221294686,
-0.0017770644,
-0.0832842588,
0.0519136786,
0.0028244487,
0.006951856,
-0.051649265,
0.0144773414,
-0.0042460407,
-0.0347674266,
-0.0356414765,
0.059039358,
-0.0474481471,
-0.015760757,
-0.0102976272,
-0.0238192566,
0.006736822,
-0.031907279,
0.0115552275,
-0.0107212784,
0.101353839,
-0.0072351331,
0.0176819563,
-0.0091444338,
0.0186880697,
0.0477822572,
0.0367192402,
0.0424220525,
-0.0166394301,
-0.0160918217,
0.0128747914,
0.0240673441,
-0.0444234945,
-0.0113465609,
-0.0213756207,
0.0418023951,
-0.0326983333,
0.0983308926,
0.0453753918,
0.0256502982,
0.0204445515,
-0.1012962162,
0.0582167245,
0.0258811284,
-0.0324115083,
0.0215704851,
-0.0723187253,
-0.0307836272,
-0.0197443981,
-0.0664823204,
-0.0085415179,
-0.0237190649,
-0.0374445096,
0.0508577898,
-0.080640927,
0.0011070782,
-0.0195410307,
0.0302896295,
-0.0143609876,
-0.0113837915,
-0.0156117696,
-0.0373355113,
0.0342239626,
-0.0115815951,
0.0632762462,
-0.0281662252,
0.0273587015,
-0.0192245003,
0.0112384008,
0.0171701089,
-0.0137876011,
-0.0104442304,
-0.0192312039,
-0.0335668623,
-0.0168690123,
-0.0418209508,
0.014557912,
-0.0067859492,
0.011740434,
0.0119511895,
0.0522307567,
0.0326629542,
0.0184968542,
0.0260046609,
-0.0294803698,
-0.0286230929,
-0.0092473617,
-0.0090355296,
-0.0017847958,
-0.0125875529,
-0.0106171584,
-0.0155392038,
0.0223465618,
0.0096293939,
-0.0039243535,
0.0035773593,
0.0205482319,
2.719e-7,
0.0595393889,
0.0629390404,
-0.0328337997,
-0.0139665008,
-0.0015579396,
0.0075423471,
-0.0220108666,
-0.0118468171,
0.0684654042,
-0.0115247173,
0.0358598754,
-0.0058169509,
0.0280515049,
0.0258390121,
-0.1041093543,
-0.0173415076,
-0.0047626765,
-0.0236437134,
-0.0848949477,
0.0654036701,
0.0606442727,
0.0544639528,
0.0122490162,
-0.0267982073,
-0.0588678122,
0.0131289847,
0.0380356349,
-0.0412783474,
-0.0295920316,
0.0238829423,
0.0344091095,
-0.0006574522,
0.0132627804,
0.0782208592,
0.0164236072,
-0.0097321635,
-0.001871745,
0.032573577,
0.0233864151,
0.0135431318,
0.0370684229,
-0.0087241856,
0.0026005472,
-0.1191684827,
0.0520841479,
-0.0158285312,
-0.0188161768,
0.0116875758,
-0.0438867323,
-0.0592700429,
0.0210578907,
-0.0347115025,
-0.0247658435,
-0.0101047689,
-0.0145582939,
-0.0116287004,
0.0314587541,
-0.0055066957,
0.0395255089,
0.0282061696,
-0.0324497074,
-0.0594310276,
-0.0449185483,
-0.0253964253,
0.0321477987,
-0.0804371089,
-0.0063276333,
2.575376798e-34,
0.0198739953,
-0.0231391527,
0.0482515208,
-0.0127957864,
0.0173111223,
0.0074022226,
0.0047362256,
0.0218851231,
0.0086158132,
-0.0803491995,
-0.0293567274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16992v2 | ContraSim -- A Similarity Measure Based on Contrastive Learning | 2023-03-29T19:43:26 | 2023-05-30T09:47:33 | Adir Rahamim, Yonatan Belinkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has compared neural network representations via similarity-based
analyses to improve model interpretation. The quality of a similarity measure
is typically evaluated by its success in assigning a high score to
representations that are expected to be matched. However, existing similarity
measures perform mediocrely on standard benchmarks. In this work, we develop a
new similarity measure, dubbed ContraSim, based on contrastive learning. In
contrast to common closed-form similarity measures, ContraSim learns a
parameterized measure by using both similar and dissimilar examples. We perform
an extensive experimental evaluation of our method, with both language and
vision models, on the standard layer prediction benchmark and two new
benchmarks that we introduce: the multilingual benchmark and the image-caption
benchmark. In all cases, ContraSim achieves much higher accuracy than previous
similarity measures, even when presented with challenging examples. Finally,
ContraSim is more suitable for the analysis of neural networks, revealing new
insights not captured by previous measures. | [
-0.0159297958,
0.0848701969,
-0.0149549181,
0.0482209809,
-0.0423658825,
0.0288707986,
0.0207272545,
0.0039999727,
-0.0246452466,
-0.0114673711,
-0.068588689,
-0.0840930343,
0.0199527647,
0.0222800262,
0.0173635799,
-0.046211265,
0.0102064498,
0.0404367782,
-0.0531908274,
0.0100367088,
0.0121287061,
-0.0278672576,
0.0126197869,
0.0561707206,
0.0452589206,
-0.0277937483,
0.0169639494,
-0.0117636696,
0.0464271605,
-0.0311510768,
0.0274364147,
0.0140162008,
0.0127422428,
0.0664802939,
0.00000195,
-0.0302124768,
-0.0050143637,
-0.0027074069,
0.0116589358,
0.0039857361,
0.0624359511,
-0.0094122672,
0.0123998364,
-0.0034280182,
-0.0460954458,
-0.0392653942,
0.0454060659,
0.0500593968,
0.0108457804,
0.041395355,
-0.0196275245,
-0.0498172417,
0.0234102905,
-0.0137475748,
-0.0206124969,
0.0247099735,
-0.0176710896,
0.0214503407,
-0.0217962321,
-0.028996516,
0.0194384418,
0.0464501381,
0.0436429121,
0.0286445413,
-0.0175504014,
0.0512794517,
-0.0220500398,
-0.0033299348,
0.0238882583,
0.0759745762,
-0.0422661044,
-0.0264610574,
-0.024636237,
-0.0351750329,
-0.0132034523,
0.0246573519,
-0.0470455848,
-0.0196631327,
0.026614612,
0.0553380102,
0.0204762705,
0.0808422044,
0.0242485702,
-0.0105355997,
0.000299361,
-0.0406767465,
0.02411131,
0.0075320527,
-0.0160493515,
-0.0146348011,
-0.0147806751,
0.0152365994,
0.0040077022,
-0.0169915725,
-0.0082925819,
-0.0274293888,
-0.0163140763,
-0.0803755224,
0.0408548079,
-0.1006734967,
0.1027090698,
0.0437276177,
-0.0696170852,
0.061764244,
-0.0714484602,
0.1032862738,
-0.0095216213,
0.0251090992,
-0.0478180051,
-0.0104339942,
-0.0590395294,
0.0149217956,
0.0233566705,
0.0211662911,
0.0069844052,
-0.045794867,
-0.0314130858,
0.0105555579,
-0.0577072501,
0.0253967773,
0.020773489,
0.0162358694,
0.0257826932,
0.0047112168,
-0.042497348,
-0.0101123741,
-0.0322839394,
0.0194397885,
-0.0361718945,
-0.0492999665,
0.0080571221,
0.0294006504,
-0.0135041969,
-0.0015487939,
0.0299280677,
0.0933931097,
-0.0155987665,
-0.0543024279,
-0.046621073,
-0.0068221251,
-0.0227563418,
-0.0253235102,
-0.0045590121,
-0.0708615407,
0.0171412695,
-0.002252327,
-0.0052375118,
-0.0311609134,
-0.0164658856,
0.0054517994,
0.0210841727,
0.0766723752,
-0.0012584428,
-0.0516519062,
-0.021856036,
0.0153603917,
-0.0433613621,
0.0266814269,
-0.0094477851,
-0.0027276608,
0.0309454277,
0.0323276669,
0.0071516191,
0.0224973392,
0.0280875191,
0.0044001392,
-0.0571898855,
0.0210016612,
0.0390504822,
0.0046148598,
0.0406231917,
0.0379873216,
-0.03797381,
-0.0835437924,
0.0655947179,
0.06134516,
0.0033693346,
0.053080108,
0.0177198444,
-0.0193873085,
-0.037391521,
0.0519399717,
-0.0321799032,
0.0662295744,
0.0093991114,
0.026115194,
0.0535055436,
0.0094600869,
-0.0363533087,
-0.0179544743,
0.0351014808,
-0.0109264152,
0.0122377565,
-0.0409100987,
0.0154361399,
-0.0040466143,
-0.0371665359,
0.0419687815,
0.0255659036,
-0.0378342122,
-0.0218983144,
-0.0333688073,
-0.0220653955,
0.048594065,
0.0026512193,
-0.0290896427,
-0.0143316807,
0.0184909236,
-0.0211786311,
-0.0062515512,
0.0447051078,
0.0015783323,
0.0440644547,
-0.0495366529,
-0.0375024788,
-0.0543615408,
0.0008570715,
0.0488799624,
-0.0137471016,
0.0039162342,
0.0528068766,
-0.0482067838,
-0.0762384161,
0.0146490671,
-0.0217558425,
-0.0281306896,
0.0236590635,
0.0295446962,
0.020919269,
-0.0054388507,
-0.0172596723,
0.0177363697,
0.0025552949,
-0.0624378622,
-0.0228611305,
0.0142522277,
-0.0617186315,
-0.0458115302,
0.059869267,
-0.0880747959,
0.0183629543,
0.0953947529,
-0.0399701074,
-0.0124869654,
0.0561928712,
-0.0048127798,
0.0359135866,
-0.0395382717,
0.0105746668,
-0.040018592,
0.0116708167,
-0.0029050256,
0.0683581904,
-0.0218161736,
0.0514869168,
-0.0043557175,
0.0009812562,
0.0649810284,
-0.0053181066,
-0.0516848005,
-0.0549222492,
0.0010123554,
0.0190350786,
0.0227698795,
-0.0036628782,
-0.035586331,
-0.0015102719,
-0.034928415,
0.0084010903,
-0.0230310299,
0.0122316154,
0.0195676349,
-0.0054210965,
0.0282530915,
-0.0185010973,
-0.0389490165,
-0.0177115481,
-0.0153904324,
-0.0011425116,
0.038227614,
0.0116215935,
-0.0271493196,
-0.0515469275,
-0.0116247665,
0.0064882836,
0.1010951921,
-0.0263037048,
0.0405637138,
-0.0039733672,
0.0610237829,
-0.015926728,
0.0111415051,
-0.0209234133,
-0.030272672,
0.0201465841,
0.0030010827,
-0.0410480499,
0.0176052358,
0.0057608983,
-0.0191150121,
0.0423176773,
0.0399264954,
-0.0620186925,
-0.0479406081,
-0.0322612785,
0.004344766,
-0.0058784368,
-0.0436227806,
-0.0326614305,
0.0250117704,
0.0040361108,
-0.0106286034,
-0.059805695,
0.037945576,
0.0119172996,
0.0268734153,
-0.0253243465,
0.0280072019,
-0.0079636676,
-0.0066888742,
-0.0378981456,
-0.0682493225,
0.0784451738,
-0.0392821096,
0.0251937918,
-0.0129556339,
-0.0507542491,
-0.0239448007,
0.0628830642,
0.0029100843,
0.0284048319,
-0.0013758122,
0.0221531522,
-0.0461811349,
0.017326219,
0.0231228583,
-0.0229297522,
0.044763796,
0.0071502314,
-0.0063882857,
0.0159075595,
-0.0248853993,
-0.037517529,
0.0067570629,
-0.0148705514,
0.0436904468,
0.0114365537,
0.0068272818,
-0.0430264212,
-0.0085837888,
-0.0266896635,
0.047207877,
0.0074831094,
-0.0331181325,
-0.0089984536,
0.0363878645,
0.0024655783,
-0.0138171492,
0.0369193666,
-0.0311731342,
0.0531223752,
0.0278599467,
0.0284862444,
0.0181925036,
-0.1095948964,
0.0144520812,
-0.0205147378,
0.0122536859,
-0.0244606584,
0.0147217456,
-0.0084566819,
-0.0212849993,
0.0017925606,
0.097533837,
-0.0052390303,
-0.056881994,
0.0082217976,
-0.0161728133,
0.0352374129,
0.0529990979,
-0.0127240447,
-0.0130648101,
-0.0212776139,
-0.052471716,
0.0343439989,
0.0100415843,
-0.0226381216,
0.018414218,
-0.0587071963,
0.0161220934,
0.0120220045,
-0.071748808,
-0.0460076779,
-0.0436987132,
0.0109077254,
-0.0264816601,
-0.0173398238,
-0.0336389057,
0.0011818561,
0.0042456146,
0.0019657661,
0.0177393295,
-0.0492633507,
0.0302137882,
-0.079342328,
0.0067233131,
0.0273292903,
0.0197297595,
0.01397675,
-0.0524301566,
-0.0257420726,
-0.0536847301,
0.0048205224,
0.0123580843,
0.0630414858,
0.0269726291,
-0.0293301921,
0.0001491202,
0.008260848,
-0.0300338548,
-0.0128713176,
-0.0491206273,
0.0478854515,
-0.0084699588,
-0.0100138197,
-0.0331812575,
-0.0014574192,
-0.0039409818,
0.0662730411,
0.073285982,
0.0039511835,
-0.0121360077,
0.0249685012,
0.0164012108,
-0.0527775474,
0.0137074674,
-0.0100018047,
0.0134294275,
0.0307721663,
-0.0472276658,
-0.0044518728,
-0.0575605296,
0.0074646804,
-0.033248201,
-0.0105052264,
-0.0103982473,
-0.0487779863,
-0.0762767121,
0.0153153725,
0.0289855022,
0.0359563567,
-0.0021126713,
-0.0068980134,
0.0556155741,
-0.0102956304,
-0.0743141398,
-0.0378622375,
-0.085850209,
-0.0331895575,
-0.0500977896,
0.057341069,
-0.0019942631,
0.020684991,
0.030905392,
-0.0313212462,
0.0319599845,
0.0332862064,
0.0304165967,
-0.0026515857,
0.0281342193,
-0.0493467785,
-0.0129217049,
0.0320394225,
-0.0242960807,
0.0119528547,
0.0295769908,
0.0052892878,
-0.0341280922,
-0.0253675245,
0.0034777236,
-0.018827213,
0.0500624739,
-0.0012009458,
-0.0112898126,
-0.0195586681,
-0.0154116414,
0.041368261,
0.0130089708,
-0.0452785231,
-0.030699756,
0.0339656249,
0.0391762629,
-0.0185979027,
0.0100486353,
-0.0161536392,
-0.0010441274,
-0.0177100915,
0.0067411307,
0.0478911251,
0.0238076039,
-0.0373039283,
0.0015340059,
-0.0264510568,
-0.0042460347,
0.013530924,
0.0324581079,
-0.0277643856,
0.0300018806,
0.0408538021,
0.0501043499,
-0.0151768541,
0.0543735661,
-0.0611328222,
-0.0613818914,
-0.0656167194,
0.0108790193,
0.0327838622,
-0.0429446474,
0.0050210296,
-0.0044338349,
0.0128836446,
-0.025326686,
0.0076120342,
-0.0281759612,
-0.0100367777,
0.0337369591,
0.0224139187,
0.0275538862,
0.0330354869,
0.0594558455,
-0.0445617102,
0.0297477879,
-0.0133170644,
-0.0298892949,
-0.0243276022,
-0.0064232368,
0.0333334878,
0.0536830761,
-0.0238070078,
0.0052354345,
-0.0238528159,
-0.0626895279,
0.0414600968,
0.0532449111,
0.0226088446,
0.0451724567,
0.0524324514,
0.0284326896,
-0.0008320319,
-0.0014949854,
0.0009501544,
-0.0475462601,
-0.0279201381,
0.0079351813,
-0.0381282941,
-6.308696714e-33,
0.001383621,
0.0011188575,
0.0078425463,
-0.0294795334,
0.010334217,
0.0196005274,
-0.0311911888,
-0.0219283234,
-0.0319452584,
0.0135357855,
0.0594544783,
0.007640725,
-0.0062056743,
0.0217324533,
-0.0078081517,
-0.0428711884,
0.0362868197,
0.0067434856,
-0.0045369584,
0.0014052485,
0.0218597334,
0.0076837623,
0.0538668111,
-0.1048229039,
0.0009933978,
0.0018635268,
0.0231858715,
-0.0071558957,
0.0349203646,
0.0833448991,
-0.033986561,
0.0426614657,
0.0151453866,
-0.0329887643,
-0.0185861178,
-0.0325269625,
-0.0267115682,
-0.05525662,
0.0088489605,
-0.0038399496,
-0.0187034644,
-0.0032754086,
0.0391359664,
0.0023313672,
-0.0499048419,
-0.0375499427,
0.0446499549,
-0.0248489492,
0.0138178356,
0.0154481316,
-0.0359970704,
0.0236903615,
-0.0128008528,
-0.0006733998,
0.0308791138,
0.059734486,
-0.0057338299,
0.0547486059,
-0.0843907595,
-0.0090616001,
-0.0255365353,
0.0058569256,
0.0662936866,
0.0205879565,
0.014163659,
0.1164674312,
0.0609961823,
-0.0494967215,
0.0419942513,
-0.0505410209,
0.0439270288,
0.0274495091,
0.0700355917,
0.0617721751,
0.0525824763,
0.022745328,
-0.0737853646,
0.0598012283,
-0.0495323986,
0.0119308708,
0.0408143029,
0.0224376079,
-0.0115860542,
0.000600381,
-0.0466023199,
-0.0701390058,
-0.065910995,
-0.0249040257,
0.0299615562,
-0.0073111653,
-0.0144471321,
0.0006052658,
0.0316669196,
-0.0660942122,
0.0176833719,
0.0085491855,
-0.0027210792,
0.0045578415,
0.0322659388,
-0.0103666922,
-0.0275087003,
-0.0295876488,
0.0119447354,
0.0114073725,
0.0590312518,
-0.0010623417,
0.0529537946,
-0.0208387729,
-0.0372850969,
-0.0046773516,
-0.0060930098,
-0.0762432814,
-0.005572224,
-0.0111710448,
0.0179865267,
-0.0160904713,
-0.0212118831,
0.0370909646,
0.0142595703,
-0.0022151787,
-0.0395412184,
-0.0305524822,
0.0195290241,
0.0410818048,
-0.0266273953,
-0.0028332698,
-0.0491655469,
0.0178029928,
0.017947495,
-0.056125503,
-0.0290414877,
0.0253440309,
2.6e-7,
0.0375339687,
-0.0159088876,
-0.0073643443,
0.0141962254,
0.0003501737,
0.0647392124,
-0.0372219421,
0.0251233447,
-0.0037850437,
0.0238165334,
0.0143393734,
0.0187257044,
0.0308523811,
0.0171780568,
-0.005280172,
0.0387144573,
-0.1072307602,
-0.023642892,
-0.0080536176,
0.000021656,
0.0607881695,
0.0858859941,
0.0158933848,
-0.0079214731,
0.0561671741,
-0.042115204,
0.0748014748,
-0.0425305888,
0.0353304297,
-0.0319880098,
0.0104029207,
0.0153276185,
-0.0229266733,
0.0200632904,
-0.0096283732,
0.0437345989,
0.0517148077,
-0.0086004566,
0.0118268048,
-0.0198598672,
-0.0009814303,
0.0102221584,
0.0065183449,
-0.0980645493,
0.0536409169,
-0.0415474437,
0.013717304,
-0.0752666444,
-0.0461928844,
0.0099953292,
0.0870854333,
0.0094829435,
-0.0356919989,
0.0044847378,
0.0117235938,
-0.0251199696,
-0.0252281185,
-0.0429707468,
-0.0282604415,
0.0294547044,
0.0017889424,
-0.0085896319,
-0.067920506,
-0.0042187092,
0.062436603,
0.0097920345,
0.0308218598,
1.799770472e-34,
0.0447450951,
0.004418727,
0.0157430097,
-0.0054782578,
0.0048816875,
-0.0065753134,
-0.0351518802,
-0.0240677148,
0.0252237748,
-0.0410324037,
0.011034295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16985v1 | Adapting to the Low-Resource Double-Bind: Investigating Low-Compute Methods on Low-Resource African Languages | 2023-03-29T19:25:43 | 2023-03-29T19:25:43 | Colin Leong, Herumb Shandilya, Bonaventure F. P. Dossou, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Joel Mathew, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Oreen Yousuf, Zainab Akinjobi, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Shamsudeen Muhammad, Steven Kolawole, Younwoo Choi, Tosin Adewumi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks make use of massively
pre-trained language models, which are computationally expensive. However,
access to high computational resources added to the issue of data scarcity of
African languages constitutes a real barrier to research experiments on these
languages. In this work, we explore the applicability of low-compute approaches
such as language adapters in the context of this low-resource double-bind. We
intend to answer the following question: do language adapters allow those who
are doubly bound by data and compute to practically build useful models?
Through fine-tuning experiments on African languages, we evaluate their
effectiveness as cost-effective approaches to low-resource African NLP. Using
solely free compute resources, our results show that language adapters achieve
comparable performances to massive pre-trained language models which are heavy
on computational resources. This opens the door to further experimentation and
exploration on full-extent of language adapters capacities. | [
0.0589735173,
0.1238054037,
-0.0276210029,
0.0461759418,
-0.0133830532,
0.0466790423,
0.0498348214,
0.011584349,
0.0031336211,
-0.0074501019,
-0.0339984074,
-0.0575128943,
0.0522940196,
-0.0017275638,
-0.0143789975,
-0.0739296526,
0.0502763689,
-0.0130154258,
0.0092343492,
-0.012598793,
-0.0022159561,
0.0267126411,
0.0133085512,
0.0065113427,
-0.0072063496,
0.0224819407,
-0.0382144824,
-0.0152589492,
-0.0336975008,
0.0143976323,
-0.072972402,
0.0230939854,
-0.0478676073,
0.0627179742,
0.000001961,
-0.0544243939,
-0.0507669859,
-0.0006652851,
-0.0581430867,
0.0457242168,
0.0842879787,
-0.0135660311,
-0.0453475006,
0.0261717737,
-0.0441269577,
-0.0197798256,
0.1131055057,
-0.0283055995,
0.0373142809,
0.0760670975,
-0.0197608452,
-0.0096820872,
0.0195213258,
-0.0218866859,
-0.0232604854,
-0.0392337143,
0.013046504,
-0.0180497933,
0.0081302887,
-0.0243102387,
-0.0484662279,
0.0116283428,
-0.0061442866,
0.017033305,
-0.0320173204,
-0.001120282,
-0.0801168531,
-0.0699624643,
-0.0405224003,
0.0133927725,
-0.0397281162,
-0.0348571092,
-0.0310026035,
0.0080760922,
-0.0174588636,
0.0092407241,
-0.0160716418,
0.0370408744,
0.0317578837,
0.0255492181,
0.0371554084,
0.010023973,
0.0420629866,
0.0083405701,
-0.0639748797,
0.0539607927,
0.0108892825,
0.0114062689,
0.0277129542,
0.0392155685,
-0.0038799581,
-0.0318285003,
-0.0040512867,
0.0059386054,
0.0303133298,
-0.0129578207,
-0.0328350365,
-0.0561661385,
-0.0020231328,
-0.0282437894,
0.1170443818,
0.051786162,
-0.008597414,
0.0200307146,
-0.0535432994,
-0.022789076,
-0.0317198262,
-0.0218200553,
-0.0181839932,
-0.0059121433,
-0.0015278374,
-0.0272034854,
-0.0515480638,
0.0324192531,
-0.064240478,
0.0169728734,
-0.0115752919,
-0.0015943701,
-0.0026329185,
-0.0460740477,
-0.0292169861,
-0.0239769015,
-0.0160592031,
-0.0321388878,
-0.0092349611,
0.0325008444,
-0.010952618,
0.0307935495,
-0.0329076909,
-0.1360135823,
0.0253429078,
0.0017192961,
0.0145987291,
0.0086676348,
0.0639153272,
0.0601281226,
-0.0092668831,
-0.0437359065,
-0.0752621368,
0.0138582317,
0.0043496145,
-0.0337519869,
-0.0402981602,
-0.0707179904,
0.0374526866,
0.0421880595,
0.0748051405,
-0.0336704813,
-0.0112087866,
-0.0074878996,
-0.0408717766,
0.1044130027,
-0.0126254288,
0.0033802257,
0.0222992469,
-0.0113638369,
0.0638746619,
0.0675543323,
0.0346306711,
-0.0325653777,
0.0171537306,
-0.0111178011,
-0.057797052,
0.0508404747,
0.0189713147,
0.0086698011,
-0.0349375233,
0.0095784487,
0.0148362732,
-0.0162796751,
0.0112145487,
0.0524600297,
0.0190839432,
0.0082372129,
0.0400360599,
0.0612034351,
-0.0016571169,
0.0515194684,
0.009826092,
-0.0179624204,
-0.0081626689,
-0.0325591415,
-0.0032427444,
-0.0034639004,
-0.0592960306,
-0.0361894146,
0.0628673136,
0.0705690384,
-0.0078893499,
-0.0219283812,
0.0165102258,
-0.0040314388,
0.0137548912,
0.0116317943,
0.0348662697,
0.0136684347,
0.0019720523,
-0.0052746851,
0.0610117242,
-0.0411350876,
-0.02165832,
-0.0533327237,
0.001104161,
0.0044380971,
0.0096537676,
0.0253870487,
0.0256787855,
0.016347995,
0.0350506119,
0.0492904931,
0.0338898115,
0.0036169137,
0.0246027205,
-0.0325382315,
0.0404838845,
0.0480051562,
0.0053321244,
0.0517981276,
0.0260824952,
0.0459787622,
0.0032733125,
-0.0191252064,
-0.0577459,
0.0144337974,
-0.0294916295,
-0.0144326994,
0.0509498231,
0.0309843943,
0.0630318746,
-0.0013786362,
0.0112904413,
0.0147055918,
-0.0208692588,
-0.0498235226,
0.0156291761,
0.0072110281,
-0.0072113699,
0.0136058545,
0.0039947391,
-0.0113519421,
0.0532786287,
0.0376794152,
0.0501624905,
-0.0618734285,
0.0645855516,
-0.0231578927,
0.0607901476,
-0.0215164442,
0.0286718644,
-0.010715222,
0.0675180107,
0.0040703649,
0.0310359225,
0.0415378362,
0.0175806191,
0.0310700182,
0.0245737825,
0.0322480239,
0.0049466859,
-0.0423983261,
0.0334915854,
-0.0092653427,
-0.0010885093,
-0.0016300245,
-0.0137812141,
-0.0183366258,
0.0012644203,
-0.1027696207,
0.0233864579,
-0.0236251056,
0.0188040324,
-0.0135045452,
0.0850759745,
-0.0028153285,
-0.0058627068,
0.0142941196,
0.0376849957,
0.0073842667,
0.0480167307,
-0.0176413618,
-0.0109243263,
-0.0098851472,
-0.0018599187,
-0.023204444,
0.0467136167,
0.0496080853,
0.0037570971,
0.0013819749,
-0.0073701376,
0.0005273964,
0.0106865428,
0.0162296034,
0.0240427423,
-0.0290889312,
-0.0041158102,
-0.0405669734,
0.0177250393,
0.0096309641,
-0.038831573,
-0.0100730471,
0.0415469632,
-0.0158038139,
-0.0486313179,
-0.0120965205,
-0.012290692,
-0.0327959582,
-0.0270777605,
-0.002469494,
-0.0188343581,
0.0790663287,
-0.005977266,
-0.0045483438,
-0.0455059707,
0.0206120294,
-0.0246688332,
-0.0354662687,
0.0057843658,
0.0408483408,
0.0030994031,
0.0398161337,
-0.0134626832,
-0.0463241488,
0.0695406124,
-0.0167943593,
-0.027336387,
-0.0079399645,
-0.0096797999,
-0.0061238543,
0.0414167307,
0.0073245638,
0.0208128039,
-0.035536781,
-0.0075422274,
-0.0076201377,
0.0614407919,
0.0578391626,
-0.006149957,
0.018495366,
-0.0359799974,
0.0404941775,
-0.0349280573,
-0.0570484512,
-0.0035845924,
-0.0312652886,
-0.041449856,
-0.0166170523,
0.0458462946,
-0.0298390593,
-0.0458257385,
0.0491586141,
0.0429722369,
0.0466730334,
0.0374886729,
-0.0198126528,
0.0121338107,
0.0182451513,
-0.033111643,
0.0154202068,
0.0208938867,
-0.0042790868,
0.0129045164,
-0.003176871,
0.0363770612,
-0.0386486724,
-0.0029449954,
0.005590477,
0.0508570559,
-0.0005783954,
-0.0105145862,
0.0351964869,
0.0177206993,
-0.0149678513,
-0.0319636874,
0.069197908,
0.0205452256,
-0.0111080827,
0.0197308734,
-0.0249747466,
0.0327830873,
-0.0067987815,
0.0258812048,
-0.0570038073,
-0.0256897248,
0.0069096028,
0.0099148862,
-0.0381404385,
-0.0427553244,
-0.0175530612,
-0.148554638,
0.0052898503,
0.0271211583,
-0.0146032609,
-0.000800331,
-0.0658642724,
-0.0129343448,
-0.0340017676,
-0.0179856736,
0.0073260972,
0.0155397337,
-0.0164978057,
0.0357465185,
-0.0301077664,
-0.0516060218,
-0.0192388725,
0.0003341878,
0.0603718497,
0.0411627181,
-0.0314122476,
-0.040659897,
0.02812168,
-0.0098234927,
-0.0196015444,
-0.0020256215,
-0.0500971451,
-0.0406581685,
0.0684385151,
-0.0475000702,
0.0218962487,
0.005484147,
-0.027211519,
0.0033649309,
-0.0122125465,
0.0622548573,
-0.012030731,
-0.0073958416,
0.000856656,
-0.0563553795,
0.0094577707,
0.0336601287,
0.0277897287,
-0.0718613714,
-0.0350320414,
-0.0050250264,
-0.0249480344,
-0.0508813746,
-0.059627898,
0.0220170114,
0.0080533577,
-0.0480350964,
-0.0247010272,
-0.044666931,
0.0230496731,
0.0306819081,
0.0248917174,
0.0115062809,
0.0413702764,
0.0129580516,
-0.0555338226,
0.01074793,
-0.0576044619,
0.0115688713,
-0.0529116541,
-0.0338868611,
0.0130881816,
-0.0158373807,
0.0124501921,
-0.0017437085,
-0.0549369119,
-0.0606981814,
0.0454944558,
0.0419936255,
0.0284762681,
0.0184341241,
0.026857106,
-0.0593663082,
0.0119466912,
0.0567379743,
-0.0288982913,
0.0385972671,
0.0346147567,
-0.0112038804,
0.0051961932,
0.0322870277,
0.0302767064,
0.0385344401,
0.0398569591,
0.0275582243,
-0.0500547327,
-0.0259496588,
0.0084675541,
0.0031102179,
0.0382299572,
-0.0619116127,
-0.0488513149,
-0.0077054845,
0.0152101861,
0.0255473629,
0.0179928951,
-0.0281874202,
-0.0763128698,
0.0332395062,
0.0424257219,
-0.0341362581,
-0.0007494959,
0.0053738905,
-0.0172754377,
0.0087472238,
0.0476871282,
0.0506545529,
-0.0159100536,
0.059791524,
0.047235202,
0.0147771221,
0.0191533174,
0.0335755944,
0.0463272072,
-0.0338679254,
-0.0113716433,
-0.0017710337,
0.0182188507,
-0.0131758442,
-0.0064051496,
0.0066679385,
-0.0175428689,
-0.0347050838,
0.0008783929,
0.0419688299,
-0.0328862295,
0.0367979445,
-0.0051286723,
-0.0051762071,
-0.0394474491,
-0.0045824531,
-0.0038817797,
-0.0344713256,
-0.005840309,
0.0048022126,
-0.0168531574,
0.062555857,
0.0465222299,
-0.0038339428,
0.0366652459,
0.0287090782,
0.0284433775,
-0.0311468299,
-0.0423202403,
-0.0076450594,
-0.0123117436,
-0.0378723964,
0.0422659479,
-0.0396713391,
-0.0714804158,
0.0006788406,
-0.0321875513,
0.0091775022,
-0.0101125641,
0.0045855273,
0.0154916607,
0.0073373434,
0.0468302034,
-0.028357463,
0.0233737808,
-0.0306931902,
-0.0102150757,
0.0345905274,
-6.308641613e-33,
-0.010354274,
-0.0059432271,
-0.0149946809,
-0.0375805385,
0.0452561453,
-0.0045920019,
-0.0412147008,
0.0446181148,
-0.0468257293,
-0.0185307339,
-0.0670985803,
-0.007666125,
0.0422826819,
0.0474282727,
0.0411126018,
0.0502929986,
0.0290952288,
0.0182133373,
-0.0240535997,
0.002202038,
0.0283009913,
0.0323418416,
0.0221885536,
-0.0349831581,
0.0206679758,
-0.0184535496,
-0.0226185527,
-0.0304249544,
0.0207047574,
0.0295311082,
-0.0313484892,
0.0435079895,
0.0114178471,
-0.0043804371,
-0.0140092885,
0.0187789164,
-0.101062797,
-0.0050951955,
0.0299084559,
0.0411800444,
-0.0268537421,
-0.020969145,
0.026865026,
0.0125952419,
-0.0258631762,
0.0457898043,
-0.0369258672,
-0.0622852556,
-0.0339012742,
0.0103645632,
-0.0774303004,
0.041627463,
0.001061092,
0.0256616827,
0.0552314743,
-0.0077327592,
-0.0719687864,
-0.0511122756,
-0.0563616566,
0.0029735821,
0.0338160098,
0.0685105771,
0.0297353901,
0.0340474099,
-0.057793539,
0.007924119,
0.0314455554,
-0.0522169285,
0.0315562673,
0.0342920646,
0.0541538224,
-0.0364035629,
0.0215240009,
0.0507679209,
0.0536611862,
-0.0680299476,
-0.0388829187,
-0.0116562536,
0.0354153439,
-0.0027072467,
0.0057651661,
0.0116754491,
-0.0232536215,
-0.0424515978,
-0.006195446,
-0.0065535023,
-0.0634632334,
-0.0107690971,
0.0409057364,
-0.0031794619,
-0.0312080532,
0.0324156545,
0.0341059379,
-0.0401926562,
-0.0210458376,
-0.0413835756,
0.0428710058,
0.0071911095,
0.012498077,
0.0048289266,
-0.0676353052,
-0.0361257382,
-0.0485688671,
0.0073270779,
-0.0091664223,
-0.0187483747,
0.025328394,
0.0368454196,
-0.1048713997,
0.0086042536,
-0.0236119721,
0.0324649923,
0.0061362432,
0.0521467216,
0.0211806167,
-0.0268634465,
0.0213061497,
-0.00413161,
0.0074602826,
-0.0265839119,
0.015243385,
0.0236194395,
-0.0114993472,
-0.0224579833,
-0.0573869273,
-0.0002699824,
-0.0385877825,
0.0336654559,
0.0033131565,
-0.024681611,
-0.0094258394,
0.031445045,
2.673e-7,
0.0003944954,
0.0080958158,
0.0210811459,
-0.0513928719,
0.0052973013,
0.0050091711,
0.0080573997,
-0.0140115451,
-0.0315308571,
0.0254844353,
-0.0139063317,
0.0083759818,
0.1086890325,
0.0198299438,
-0.0518948548,
-0.0174717363,
-0.0275697708,
0.0325430222,
-0.0459730215,
-0.0329910442,
-0.0374685973,
0.1362603605,
-0.0246057622,
-0.0367029309,
-0.0622860566,
-0.045683153,
0.0333671458,
-0.0256080907,
0.0139003666,
-0.0155759677,
0.012459212,
0.0984401703,
-0.0183781963,
0.0051786429,
-0.0496709086,
0.0174168907,
-0.0137776602,
0.0573421381,
-0.0258860737,
0.0326543376,
0.0125627993,
-0.0206095818,
-0.0713975132,
-0.0060761273,
0.0680007264,
0.0091160713,
-0.0464117825,
-0.0064455364,
0.0049253558,
-0.0112816431,
-0.014693955,
-0.0427670255,
0.0053878883,
-0.0035350712,
0.0405095816,
-0.0540717803,
-0.0492801107,
-0.0224652812,
-0.0163192917,
0.0123974085,
-0.0028166743,
-0.0146939522,
-0.0372740924,
0.0263899378,
0.0377358682,
-0.0170941539,
0.0286584608,
2.239122506e-34,
0.0225184839,
-0.0160634629,
0.031449236,
0.0185356066,
-0.0269867089,
-0.0076876101,
0.0201850738,
0.006575013,
-0.0175717827,
-0.0852782577,
-0.01511514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16974v1 | BEVERS: A General, Simple, and Performant Framework for Automatic Fact Verification | 2023-03-29T19:16:19 | 2023-03-29T19:16:19 | Mitchell DeHaven, Stephen Scott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic fact verification has become an increasingly popular topic in
recent years and among datasets the Fact Extraction and VERification (FEVER)
dataset is one of the most popular. In this work we present BEVERS, a tuned
baseline system for the FEVER dataset. Our pipeline uses standard approaches
for document retrieval, sentence selection, and final claim classification,
however, we spend considerable effort ensuring optimal performance for each
component. The results are that BEVERS achieves the highest FEVER score and
label accuracy among all systems, published or unpublished. We also apply this
pipeline to another fact verification dataset, Scifact, and achieve the highest
label accuracy among all systems on that dataset as well. We also make our full
code available. | [
0.0323888883,
0.052826155,
0.0201370548,
0.0176521949,
-0.0649548918,
0.0049213916,
0.0099495668,
-0.0027435902,
0.0356679857,
-0.0352507196,
0.0321883447,
0.0028572844,
0.0046103117,
0.0467702039,
-0.0153979817,
-0.0109727504,
0.0437423699,
0.0300525948,
0.0979654193,
-0.0029694848,
-0.0222227853,
0.0073996726,
-0.0467624143,
-0.004279234,
-0.0507644638,
-0.0255391281,
0.042989172,
-0.0370560996,
0.0433654189,
-0.0567952879,
0.0438567474,
0.0257025585,
0.0041395538,
0.0372810289,
0.0000019586,
-0.0608509295,
-0.0089556891,
0.0253854468,
-0.0410375483,
0.0319430307,
0.0204565693,
0.0074958797,
0.0124028698,
0.0070308326,
-0.0427699052,
-0.0444991998,
0.015803244,
0.0480857752,
0.0379972421,
0.0683735982,
-0.0249858815,
-0.0287998002,
0.017493777,
0.0387187153,
-0.005977435,
-0.0145443119,
0.0623616427,
0.0213571563,
0.0191091411,
-0.0120952111,
0.0437746979,
0.0535859317,
-0.0230025686,
-0.0187621079,
-0.0232821237,
0.0615256727,
-0.0420332178,
-0.0341456905,
0.0153787099,
0.0350636467,
0.0320677832,
-0.0589325465,
0.0219205711,
0.0131203607,
-0.0108252168,
0.0250732992,
-0.0285223387,
0.0406499431,
-0.0438469313,
-0.0075390874,
0.0168760046,
0.0149038089,
0.023860231,
0.0202002544,
0.0086874282,
0.0550484248,
-0.0047489959,
-0.0738255456,
-0.0093921954,
0.0009963964,
0.0269210394,
-0.0684224814,
0.050835751,
-0.0055113751,
0.0096714115,
-0.0102548357,
-0.0169356354,
-0.0021949678,
0.0350635387,
-0.0750950202,
-0.0159196164,
-0.0592801794,
-0.0680335015,
0.0677756742,
-0.0044139344,
-0.0183069706,
0.0256176069,
-0.0015999951,
0.0410958789,
-0.0111209108,
-0.0196559597,
0.0166095942,
-0.0059102192,
0.0180406105,
0.0056678862,
0.0319397338,
-0.0298946723,
-0.0607172623,
-0.0031630131,
0.0412451997,
-0.0034480083,
0.0007703245,
-0.0113640809,
-0.0034470414,
-0.0204922426,
0.0132709509,
-0.0054102722,
0.0214277487,
-0.0050998479,
-0.034019459,
-0.0135667427,
0.0054998924,
0.0440328456,
-0.001127005,
0.0240051337,
-0.0207245499,
0.0124649098,
-0.021995401,
-0.0314619876,
-0.0125117619,
-0.0058513731,
-0.0851543993,
-0.0120102661,
-0.0457424521,
0.0313026085,
0.0061422586,
-0.0101533616,
0.0178998839,
-0.0170579124,
0.0246766135,
0.0092252083,
0.004661344,
-0.0546993837,
-0.0221983623,
0.0442434065,
-0.0132343126,
0.0418073945,
0.0041188011,
0.0286584627,
0.0408462733,
0.0699014142,
0.0288256165,
0.0290765241,
-0.0251252931,
0.0358231738,
0.0018225575,
0.0808443129,
0.0318272784,
0.0259930473,
0.0013227405,
-0.0248056185,
0.0186978299,
-0.0161123313,
-0.0356353112,
0.0352737792,
-0.0086137811,
-0.0018298503,
-0.0206369106,
0.0149442479,
-0.0037507471,
0.0520145148,
-0.0150979562,
-0.0232367534,
0.0097001037,
-0.0103488732,
-0.0022025895,
0.00793886,
0.0508660562,
0.0072542373,
-0.0505467653,
-0.0613930374,
0.019916987,
-0.0585230514,
-0.0079277912,
0.0555250198,
-0.0056145075,
0.0025287038,
0.0276765898,
0.0511154495,
-0.035375312,
-0.0479003973,
-0.0272458028,
0.0131722484,
-0.0334710516,
0.0534696355,
-0.0512260273,
0.0224778876,
-0.0232485607,
0.0425258018,
0.0317859985,
0.0598730333,
-0.008293462,
0.0179204587,
-0.018509075,
0.0027610175,
-0.0155691486,
0.0435947739,
-0.0271824971,
0.0584539399,
0.0219381526,
0.0130491303,
-0.0084616011,
-0.0698168129,
0.0394779779,
-0.0011330505,
-0.02736382,
0.0148654133,
-0.0120183341,
0.0355146937,
-0.0169055425,
-0.0445353352,
-0.0115002124,
0.0192955304,
-0.010956591,
-0.0085607404,
0.0282547381,
0.0730148107,
-0.0407660976,
0.0262815095,
-0.0261294618,
-0.0533998646,
0.0249814671,
-0.0241302494,
0.0045452006,
-0.0117563764,
-0.0190672651,
-0.0290581547,
-0.0244279895,
-0.0253782459,
-0.0039672954,
0.0049111028,
0.0088032037,
0.0652608126,
0.0220535342,
-0.0013146112,
-0.0470094681,
-0.0674205795,
0.03185739,
-0.0139950728,
-0.0150014032,
-0.0156861208,
-0.0183028225,
0.0130474111,
0.0332197957,
-0.0482024737,
-0.0169708747,
0.0252775904,
-0.0723183006,
0.0288281757,
0.0016382904,
0.0223500524,
-0.0175174307,
-0.0329353139,
-0.0259536318,
0.0301426742,
-0.006347789,
-0.0488304347,
0.0010428756,
-0.000055746,
0.0601738393,
-0.0309899282,
0.0148456292,
-0.0305269919,
0.0078834714,
-0.0347999893,
0.0442514457,
0.0530427024,
-0.0376508571,
-0.0045672185,
-0.008717401,
-0.0571737364,
0.0054507232,
-0.034783829,
-0.0124470219,
0.0227023009,
-0.0126274237,
-0.039005287,
0.0611420199,
0.046434626,
-0.0049831988,
0.0254201349,
0.030661786,
-0.0214656107,
0.0373651572,
-0.052470129,
0.0567505658,
0.0468153991,
-0.0356813557,
0.0505276322,
0.0253416132,
0.0321753658,
-0.0134667121,
0.0182324238,
0.0126026906,
-0.0076624546,
0.0065820245,
0.0253147297,
0.0529207401,
-0.0075337891,
0.0370194502,
-0.0125225503,
-0.0475058109,
0.0819833353,
-0.0250047296,
0.0113016348,
-0.0819754153,
-0.007640963,
-0.0061294027,
0.015262479,
0.0182486828,
-0.0133454828,
0.0108826179,
0.0323220715,
0.0418985076,
-0.015736049,
0.0612809621,
-0.0318400301,
-0.0210443772,
-0.0072700386,
0.0551127493,
0.0079697557,
-0.0550911389,
-0.0227989275,
-0.0306404196,
-0.041372586,
-0.0269948803,
-0.0507599376,
-0.0448269397,
-0.1237475947,
-0.0419324674,
0.0775424987,
0.063746959,
-0.0212853663,
-0.0026633916,
0.0222930983,
-0.013538097,
0.0377272107,
0.0021768697,
0.0355441011,
0.0027119271,
-0.0336686298,
0.0704276189,
-0.0167194605,
0.0143907936,
-0.0107421977,
-0.0586620718,
-0.0230080448,
-0.0551008359,
0.0376366004,
-0.0419807285,
0.0341527462,
-0.0484026447,
-0.0128612444,
0.0631376579,
0.0226527769,
0.0521791875,
-0.0070829596,
0.0163434148,
-0.015721567,
0.0172192492,
0.0180144068,
-0.0886979848,
-0.0076694572,
-0.0152264992,
0.0036970163,
-0.0393300168,
-0.0152982343,
-0.0275810286,
-0.0406060666,
0.0829283819,
-0.0090338811,
0.0048904149,
-0.0336255282,
-0.0832812339,
0.0147861745,
-0.0099586956,
-0.0610685721,
0.0184453949,
0.0250926483,
-0.0119628012,
0.0006436344,
-0.018458711,
-0.0307134856,
0.0740325302,
-0.0319619775,
-0.0024707713,
-0.0296566281,
0.0533645637,
-0.0106674852,
-0.0644667223,
0.0193383172,
-0.0225207265,
-0.06552165,
-0.0089178151,
0.0710296705,
-0.0141521459,
0.0026090031,
-0.0382083245,
0.024872493,
0.0213994756,
-0.0150175113,
0.0302585289,
0.0649682209,
-0.007313211,
-0.0514881648,
-0.0467962138,
0.0198920276,
-0.0099872407,
0.064218089,
0.0047779493,
0.0283169672,
-0.0243118983,
-0.0220052041,
-0.0090906853,
-0.0681514442,
-0.0409085676,
0.0288856477,
-0.058133658,
-0.0633302331,
-0.0821695775,
0.0314491577,
0.0024871128,
0.0638401881,
-0.0471548922,
-0.0347166434,
0.0007740332,
0.0145593537,
-0.0460855626,
0.0356853269,
-0.0131494962,
0.0050806254,
-0.025570102,
-0.0208402835,
0.0570792034,
-0.0068942909,
-0.009945672,
0.0232577734,
0.0011553769,
-0.0626937523,
0.0142804645,
0.0122797694,
0.0215863176,
0.0396861732,
-0.0150500452,
0.0120857731,
0.0317230001,
0.1005264223,
-0.0391750932,
0.0012663085,
0.0185138527,
-0.049421303,
-0.0188808609,
-0.0291776806,
-0.0025474767,
0.0481316485,
-0.0152144581,
-0.0132272756,
-0.0203896463,
-0.0334844962,
0.0466939174,
0.0913876519,
0.074142471,
0.0141363209,
-0.050263565,
-0.0406149291,
-0.0047509298,
-0.0123030748,
-0.0119507601,
-0.0028634348,
0.0552551672,
-0.0421651788,
0.0026013495,
-0.033992406,
0.0011390997,
-0.062266767,
0.0236684307,
-0.0194295645,
0.0054922178,
-0.0364938974,
0.0630246028,
0.011600663,
-0.052702304,
-0.0430649184,
0.021519646,
-0.0109552443,
0.0332170539,
0.0068909191,
-0.0290714931,
0.0514638759,
0.0084038312,
-0.0126714818,
-0.0350181647,
-0.11151959,
0.0493022166,
-0.0544584468,
0.0306261536,
0.0171019267,
0.0109474771,
0.0172779914,
-0.042745471,
-0.0324948058,
-0.0164905731,
0.0182495341,
0.0006047499,
0.0210699961,
-0.014599408,
0.0080398517,
-0.0528248586,
-0.0052077929,
0.0154649587,
0.019833032,
0.0532663204,
0.0338454582,
-0.0549704209,
-0.0261607077,
-0.0526081473,
-0.0786057115,
0.0017198458,
0.0193020329,
-0.0381992236,
-0.0650797486,
-0.0143663585,
0.064359203,
0.0601474307,
0.0227943677,
0.0113296825,
-0.0098059038,
0.0790108219,
0.036397405,
-0.0653746426,
-0.0236341134,
0.062464565,
-0.0054167588,
-0.0302415248,
0.0113495635,
-6.559207784e-33,
0.0196361132,
-0.0133211119,
0.0052195392,
0.0603652038,
0.0193111766,
0.0368514359,
-0.0229932405,
-0.0423703492,
-0.0373525023,
0.08368963,
0.0044065965,
0.0359345041,
0.0188141298,
-0.0293983668,
-0.0042336266,
0.0073901103,
0.0423974991,
0.005149344,
-0.0395731442,
0.0015537782,
0.0643554032,
0.0004939762,
0.0775654316,
-0.110660173,
0.0259080045,
0.0098128626,
0.0031638849,
0.0062674335,
-0.0482636653,
0.0167733561,
0.0112559237,
0.0412867703,
0.0171152838,
-0.0095142992,
0.0303595755,
-0.0340474844,
-0.0730705485,
-0.0198675375,
0.0398669057,
-0.0273757037,
0.005419198,
0.0099286279,
0.0155802863,
-0.005599828,
-0.0222997069,
-0.0322154388,
0.0517717935,
-0.0307956636,
-0.0150088882,
-0.0808721855,
-0.036725793,
0.0512052812,
0.0276770256,
0.0170409735,
-0.0121037345,
0.0046415711,
-0.0017712859,
0.0382482335,
-0.0662191585,
0.028323276,
-0.0044922619,
0.0135429492,
-0.0097342953,
-0.0612921678,
-0.0033309644,
0.0696601346,
0.0146208899,
0.0144701796,
-0.0360722169,
0.0365840942,
0.0024578911,
0.0423108488,
0.0374214463,
0.0882388428,
0.0463876687,
-0.0499769859,
-0.1069050953,
0.038747672,
0.0428962447,
0.000519876,
-0.0257465784,
-0.0491622016,
-0.0302775986,
0.0137580102,
0.0117283529,
0.0450274982,
-0.0130017921,
0.0491256006,
-0.0084374333,
0.0119041,
-0.0157200638,
0.0214974452,
-0.0224956386,
-0.0071574086,
-0.0012635704,
0.0032771509,
-0.0091123749,
0.0132481633,
-0.011872841,
-0.0162940789,
-0.0796103179,
-0.009288366,
-0.0273445677,
0.0566136241,
0.0283447932,
0.0063642389,
0.0374934636,
-0.0144849438,
-0.0390451439,
0.0155991167,
-0.0106644314,
0.0195469484,
0.004866031,
-0.0028188799,
-0.0059294761,
0.0126992762,
0.0200369358,
0.0074366494,
0.0065347929,
0.0366071276,
-0.0322628282,
0.0486510582,
0.0102261063,
0.0332372971,
0.0107748453,
-0.0061987001,
-0.0160384718,
-0.0020336465,
-0.0321348794,
-0.0799516961,
0.0352931879,
0.0270527657,
2.763e-7,
0.0175721552,
0.048520647,
0.0026140029,
-0.002898789,
-0.0120751085,
0.0485308543,
-0.0104797073,
0.0057675648,
0.0122569986,
-0.0848636255,
-0.0311910957,
0.0122281341,
0.0349886976,
0.0500608496,
-0.1001513377,
-0.0320607424,
-0.045602873,
-0.0571145713,
-0.0649396181,
-0.0225694664,
0.0220397972,
0.0144265648,
0.0443141423,
-0.0101872468,
0.00202318,
-0.0247272737,
0.034777794,
0.0427624099,
-0.0345447324,
0.0321731828,
0.1073588803,
-0.0094769616,
0.0157640856,
0.0332486667,
-0.0707639381,
0.0233695954,
-0.024224557,
0.0489766113,
0.0222971607,
0.0163070057,
-0.0083623547,
-0.0239920653,
0.0130358832,
-0.0268487651,
0.0527629964,
-0.0233243294,
-0.0189406965,
-0.0728522986,
-0.0402063467,
0.0255513638,
0.0375562236,
0.0082527911,
-0.0180160291,
0.0263915472,
-0.0206112247,
-0.0186827704,
-0.0049256361,
-0.0644722804,
-0.00329048,
0.0246159099,
-0.0267889686,
-0.0367048159,
0.0439195782,
-0.020840928,
0.0227560792,
-0.0594532564,
0.0281579792,
2.16819359e-34,
0.0410311706,
-0.0073692761,
-0.0305686109,
-0.0287041925,
0.039547611,
-0.0040784259,
-0.000828996,
-0.0040539112,
-0.0189488381,
-0.0040158718,
0.01639219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16894v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16894v4 | ViewRefer: Grasp the Multi-view Knowledge for 3D Visual Grounding with GPT and Prototype Guidance | 2023-03-29T17:59:10 | 2023-12-05T05:34:18 | Zoey Guo, Yiwen Tang, Ray Zhang, Dong Wang, Zhigang Wang, Bin Zhao, Xuelong Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Understanding 3D scenes from multi-view inputs has been proven to alleviate
the view discrepancy issue in 3D visual grounding. However, existing methods
normally neglect the view cues embedded in the text modality and fail to weigh
the relative importance of different views. In this paper, we propose
ViewRefer, a multi-view framework for 3D visual grounding exploring how to
grasp the view knowledge from both text and 3D modalities. For the text branch,
ViewRefer leverages the diverse linguistic knowledge of large-scale language
models, e.g., GPT, to expand a single grounding text to multiple
geometry-consistent descriptions. Meanwhile, in the 3D modality, a transformer
fusion module with inter-view attention is introduced to boost the interaction
of objects across views. On top of that, we further present a set of learnable
multi-view prototypes, which memorize scene-agnostic knowledge for different
views, and enhance the framework from two perspectives: a view-guided attention
module for more robust text features, and a view-guided scoring strategy during
the final prediction. With our designed paradigm, ViewRefer achieves superior
performance on three benchmarks and surpasses the second-best by +2.8%, +1.5%,
and +1.35% on Sr3D, Nr3D, and ScanRefer. Code is released at
https://github.com/Ivan-Tang-3D/ViewRefer3D. | [
0.0362633653,
0.0385809578,
0.0756618828,
0.0317961425,
-0.0047031888,
-0.0076455656,
-0.0078537092,
-0.0335321948,
-0.0147527093,
-0.0663369894,
-0.0598555245,
-0.0099461731,
0.0509829186,
0.0374780856,
0.0108744372,
-0.0656626001,
-0.0252415705,
-0.0349283479,
-0.0411466956,
0.0048807752,
0.0147658559,
0.0453566834,
-0.0158654191,
0.0086999051,
-0.0295546632,
0.0104743633,
-0.0214814022,
0.010615495,
0.0441091545,
-0.0730376244,
0.0142446011,
0.0319319516,
0.0629437789,
0.0015772383,
0.0000021177,
-0.0123661496,
-0.0317279138,
-0.0052222963,
0.0610598698,
-0.0287081916,
0.0202947445,
-0.0636256486,
-0.0011107282,
-0.014422968,
-0.033198826,
0.0285439957,
0.0747143477,
0.1157385185,
0.062174242,
0.0062403842,
-0.0283606183,
-0.0374982581,
-0.0084085716,
-0.0110594565,
0.0619559139,
-0.0164017379,
0.0201856922,
0.0681803897,
-0.0153709166,
0.0490199439,
-0.0273625012,
0.0103766099,
0.0388235264,
0.0090426672,
0.020531375,
0.0589995757,
0.0046346025,
0.0042682951,
-0.0443353243,
0.1187506318,
-0.0290959999,
-0.024169568,
-0.0302634686,
-0.0110543622,
0.0013104426,
0.0187154599,
-0.0047524348,
0.0061703487,
-0.045835834,
-0.0031796258,
-0.0726554766,
0.0365597196,
-0.0075274082,
-0.0290779769,
-0.0453548022,
-0.0052202395,
0.0130957058,
0.0128313499,
0.0221414659,
0.0323887095,
0.0064963442,
-0.0510666706,
0.0238608085,
-0.0082479911,
0.0111876195,
0.0071854978,
-0.0501600765,
0.0052577965,
-0.0316140875,
-0.0546962358,
0.041044049,
0.0447816029,
-0.0764243603,
0.0710524619,
-0.05252802,
0.0526370965,
-0.0263760593,
0.0239049308,
-0.0295225959,
-0.013302342,
-0.0114810523,
-0.0041770362,
-0.0565190725,
0.0106375106,
-0.0671042949,
-0.0419100337,
0.0121448347,
-0.0074874507,
-0.0056272764,
-0.0126514882,
0.0156829767,
0.0678432211,
-0.0534557924,
-0.0053608371,
-0.0008721832,
0.0373205021,
-0.0140121253,
0.0238596499,
-0.0542911999,
-0.0624227002,
-0.0121245869,
0.0340654366,
0.028884124,
-0.0016165511,
0.0081746429,
0.0463997684,
-0.0507151186,
-0.0434507243,
0.0072990265,
-0.0374552123,
-0.0649812967,
-0.0157476012,
0.0193439759,
-0.0515217632,
0.0092402045,
-0.0074845585,
-0.0043483474,
-0.0530516207,
0.0261378568,
0.0094335517,
0.0071816668,
0.0793319121,
0.0223854166,
-0.0246566776,
0.0200018864,
0.0267506875,
0.0141176907,
0.0245560594,
0.0240748376,
0.048612982,
-0.0489173718,
0.02535831,
0.0379171632,
0.046764601,
0.0039596455,
0.0320784636,
-0.0499657355,
-0.0229871888,
-0.0013461488,
0.00816999,
-0.0130527401,
0.0197276659,
-0.0035210901,
-0.0235985704,
0.0629833937,
0.0348427221,
-0.0647108108,
0.0153432833,
0.0310809352,
-0.0079081543,
-0.0003533508,
-0.0016267209,
-0.0528627671,
0.0506713167,
0.0201409608,
0.0071013239,
-0.0419775695,
0.0224761963,
-0.0216062237,
-0.0376879089,
-0.0062064058,
0.0049562468,
0.0205984358,
-0.0034449317,
0.0611577444,
0.0325801484,
-0.0458490662,
0.0848154202,
0.00310371,
-0.0652844757,
-0.0360286459,
0.0620732531,
0.0023618317,
0.0283230394,
-0.0232529938,
-0.0070170197,
-0.060489215,
-0.0066623627,
0.0440647528,
0.0644355193,
-0.0015029412,
0.0191432685,
0.0269592274,
-0.0401881896,
-0.0644667894,
0.0147028593,
-0.0009061785,
0.0552070774,
0.044505842,
0.0152588179,
0.0285966527,
-0.0796570629,
0.0269027799,
0.0390439555,
-0.0231361054,
0.0303113628,
-0.0850176588,
0.0115524763,
0.004866695,
0.0212589614,
0.010508555,
-0.0265002362,
0.0335471183,
-0.0362461321,
0.0177688636,
0.0572112761,
-0.0824933499,
-0.0131175425,
0.01425731,
-0.0402201638,
-0.0043631275,
-0.0087351324,
-0.0070836609,
-0.0227506291,
0.0083248261,
-0.0092512649,
0.0581417419,
0.0165962521,
-0.0131189656,
0.0080177216,
0.0179702733,
-0.047376588,
0.0600454286,
-0.0569723472,
0.0058900462,
0.0036579471,
-0.0268667582,
0.0215829592,
0.0241424162,
0.041921176,
-0.0046113352,
0.0100318277,
-0.0121210404,
0.0256043803,
0.0178265423,
-0.0385170989,
-0.0040477593,
-0.0462186076,
-0.0557816438,
-0.021003902,
-0.0097103762,
0.0157906245,
-0.0150006367,
0.0029977215,
-0.0446412824,
-0.0395722128,
0.0325582437,
0.0016108004,
-0.0422876999,
0.0101943752,
-0.0104753179,
-0.0002403919,
-0.0102214506,
0.0568516403,
-0.0109021552,
0.0553757176,
0.1027223468,
-0.0837274492,
-0.0522958748,
0.0058522308,
-0.0466037318,
0.0402549207,
-0.0336514153,
-0.0031820079,
0.0085217999,
-0.0446930118,
0.0351211205,
0.0469790325,
-0.0366937742,
0.0065286965,
0.032147035,
-0.0050984374,
-0.0643508211,
0.0206616763,
0.0116651319,
-0.0069261021,
-0.0353387259,
0.0136092901,
0.0219664574,
0.0507159978,
0.00017312,
0.0332987756,
-0.0595992059,
0.0141992345,
0.0099075558,
-0.0383428708,
-0.0111706108,
0.0145360911,
-0.0034770565,
0.0045029921,
-0.0466332026,
-0.0214649756,
0.0296300203,
-0.0928689763,
-0.0274742953,
-0.0080138929,
0.0492663421,
-0.0030817145,
0.056310676,
-0.0091028139,
0.0324422643,
-0.0352633819,
-0.034126427,
-0.0070571285,
-0.0212881137,
0.0015770228,
0.0417139679,
0.0543454625,
-0.0661281794,
0.0490438603,
-0.0106531177,
-0.0360191874,
0.008079893,
0.0023962094,
-0.0574731119,
0.0019492481,
-0.0272450559,
-0.0385142826,
-0.074091889,
0.0297967084,
0.0268230792,
0.0690548345,
0.0068686916,
-0.0406944901,
-0.015439447,
-0.0081578251,
-0.0029268228,
0.0441192463,
-0.0262421053,
-0.034034621,
-0.0375666879,
0.0617089793,
-0.0246037059,
0.0058406391,
-0.0616176277,
0.0396909341,
0.0313151255,
0.0481802635,
0.0292908996,
-0.0190493744,
0.0221254583,
-0.0543131046,
-0.0160838217,
0.055179365,
0.0212718416,
-0.0612978563,
-0.0321053565,
-0.0095969113,
0.0201856811,
0.0200060438,
-0.0279350542,
-0.0573139004,
-0.051613681,
-0.0348547921,
-0.018172998,
0.1060905308,
-0.0341099463,
0.0041399924,
-0.0632768571,
0.0148113538,
-0.0045047477,
-0.060102649,
-0.076048255,
0.0001616481,
0.0618913434,
-0.0007823546,
-0.0456742086,
-0.025934929,
-0.0155519852,
-0.0122323371,
0.0009505709,
0.0598645099,
-0.0159260333,
0.0160365403,
-0.0195880886,
-0.0585529879,
0.011116025,
0.0134663787,
-0.0134979142,
-0.0720853284,
0.0242636744,
0.0583612137,
0.0221803505,
-0.0099332882,
0.0172805134,
-0.0381366536,
-0.0244442448,
0.018674111,
0.03221168,
-0.0268454142,
-0.027702922,
-0.0537143834,
0.0231838133,
-0.0264048167,
0.0203074403,
0.0064614583,
0.0214165449,
0.015965594,
0.0414066613,
0.0047296453,
-0.0038394695,
-0.0264894497,
-0.0248177573,
0.0411286354,
-0.0100632142,
-0.0446166433,
0.0028158207,
-0.0283751115,
-0.0206696186,
-0.0487453267,
0.0058610123,
0.0735823587,
0.0602366962,
0.0303638112,
-0.0391973667,
0.0228111688,
0.011500068,
-0.0524734966,
0.0523520894,
-0.0285650399,
0.0056507462,
-0.0365196057,
0.0429359674,
0.0544939935,
-0.0836191326,
-0.029236652,
-0.01472372,
-0.0370882303,
-0.0163749587,
-0.0046875123,
0.0461171269,
0.0063119307,
0.0700800344,
-0.0032950228,
0.0139666479,
0.0313343741,
0.0131783681,
0.0005875884,
0.049502749,
0.0101485848,
0.0113353413,
-0.0268892664,
-0.0127377473,
-0.0463088118,
0.0308450498,
0.0145565365,
-0.0199856125,
-0.0045819315,
-0.0457688682,
0.0183762778,
-0.0156909768,
0.0585146621,
0.0272733662,
0.0387546048,
-0.0336759649,
-0.0011608732,
0.0235598478,
-0.0252778921,
-0.0906723216,
0.0546081066,
0.0067861355,
-0.0374517329,
0.0135205742,
0.0281756502,
0.0148214977,
0.0404403992,
-0.0313223191,
-0.003513901,
0.0181004163,
-0.0583290718,
0.0107206516,
-0.0202892721,
0.0019810784,
0.0320753828,
-0.0668179393,
0.0431639403,
-0.0088194143,
0.0520099849,
0.032298062,
-0.0510171093,
-0.0466333404,
0.0404400378,
-0.0122760972,
-0.0340742469,
-0.0608986542,
0.0446688198,
0.0287636351,
0.0093689607,
0.0414895304,
-0.0287239626,
0.0012911247,
0.0236348975,
0.0128558259,
0.0317744575,
-0.0489987768,
0.0299764425,
0.0150214992,
0.006591714,
-0.0239721201,
0.0199389234,
0.0148254726,
0.024777472,
0.0342617296,
-0.050168775,
-0.0351542197,
-0.0109714847,
0.0163758043,
0.0087921303,
0.0092702135,
0.0505367853,
-0.0170330442,
-0.0203954615,
-0.0047526313,
0.023471579,
-0.0470963307,
0.0358353183,
0.0620503053,
0.0612862706,
-0.0044969218,
-0.0001856539,
0.0086171888,
-0.0063578156,
0.003969348,
-0.0145571558,
-0.0068921554,
-5.696807456e-33,
-0.0282490924,
-0.0651936382,
0.0016559592,
-0.023440782,
-0.0281844679,
0.0278494079,
-0.0445466824,
0.0200541038,
-0.0152246468,
0.0363536105,
0.0353703946,
-0.004126078,
0.0189949777,
0.0275611095,
-0.0011532647,
-0.0057636206,
0.0511761867,
0.0342211835,
-0.0340064466,
-0.0084017878,
0.0298427269,
0.0219453964,
0.1051356345,
-0.0747315064,
0.0004948357,
0.0089309784,
-0.0282821693,
0.0028311464,
0.0063807359,
0.0359126739,
-0.0181281045,
-0.0174498335,
0.0033230602,
-0.0565587729,
-0.017174853,
0.0344801769,
-0.0861891434,
-0.0330115706,
-0.0025130829,
0.0452469252,
-0.0288381726,
0.0214850735,
0.0191114563,
-0.0475117862,
0.0185950641,
-0.0276980326,
0.0333246365,
-0.0311387852,
-0.0218336284,
-0.0049118111,
-0.0341415443,
0.0097701792,
-0.0163316689,
-0.0552545115,
0.0335122682,
0.0043014316,
0.0534878932,
0.0504056886,
-0.0200711805,
0.0083278921,
-0.0376112014,
0.0184672922,
0.0763116777,
0.0637880638,
-0.0098582907,
0.0897953063,
-0.0049037561,
-0.0457340963,
-0.0320758186,
-0.0802003592,
0.0234504994,
0.0383321792,
0.0275922548,
0.0613524206,
0.0010113686,
0.0462486669,
-0.0082617961,
0.0324209593,
-0.0895612538,
0.0748433694,
0.0283452552,
-0.0071967561,
-0.0202084891,
-0.0012920978,
-0.0177760962,
-0.0065085138,
-0.0104844561,
0.0238388143,
0.0430702381,
0.0373106413,
-0.0121769812,
0.0279736575,
0.0573845506,
0.0031656623,
0.0046714838,
0.0972004905,
-0.0025279981,
0.0494860634,
-0.0221502353,
-0.0122641698,
-0.0302153379,
0.0087812627,
0.0106292432,
0.0022415433,
0.0211882889,
-0.0214826092,
0.0152343987,
0.0156033551,
-0.0292359237,
-0.0247259811,
-0.0375571512,
-0.0105027845,
0.0064234557,
0.0899302438,
0.0430110134,
0.0153069627,
-0.0410529785,
0.0104880258,
-0.017272111,
-0.021084886,
-0.0063062035,
0.0016260636,
-0.0336802453,
0.0359412991,
-0.0272862557,
0.0017085235,
-0.0350364409,
-0.0508457571,
0.0374353267,
-0.0520083345,
-0.0081046987,
0.0496888123,
2.715e-7,
0.030694142,
0.0331574827,
0.0342957936,
-0.0147731435,
-0.0318234935,
0.0364480726,
0.0186255388,
0.0489846133,
-0.0268414598,
-0.0565268248,
-0.0054577678,
0.0526622273,
-0.005949053,
0.0090353973,
-0.0969584584,
0.047359135,
-0.0364444219,
-0.0239512399,
-0.0345830619,
-0.0098223537,
0.0295748431,
0.0330038592,
-0.0476133116,
0.0131239118,
0.0092404773,
-0.0091875913,
0.0300159696,
-0.0275400076,
0.042479787,
0.0161886122,
0.0667980537,
0.0004660961,
-0.0343571976,
-0.0009523694,
0.0209767576,
-0.0000470279,
0.0433401577,
0.0300774202,
-0.0343387015,
0.001054487,
-0.0317913294,
0.0025819507,
-0.005198542,
-0.0586524457,
0.0252306126,
-0.0426812284,
0.0337201953,
0.0098538501,
-0.0187729076,
-0.0403930247,
-0.0057815034,
0.0064721652,
0.0096951751,
-0.0141324569,
0.0043944265,
-0.016988162,
-0.0369585827,
-0.0575087816,
-0.0271994658,
-0.0175818466,
0.0069188937,
-0.0039943345,
-0.005846201,
-0.0922842845,
-0.0113028614,
-0.0421287082,
-0.0396424495,
2.078166335e-34,
-0.0006528255,
0.0087621771,
0.00232774,
-0.0018015088,
0.0106101483,
0.0141138937,
0.0376859158,
0.006947462,
-0.0283625573,
-0.0310218409,
0.0012815472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16886v1 | End-to-End $n$-ary Relation Extraction for Combination Drug Therapies | 2023-03-29T17:55:50 | 2023-03-29T17:55:50 | Yuhang Jiang, Ramakanth Kavuluru | cs.CL | cs.CL | Combination drug therapies are treatment regimens that involve two or more
drugs, administered more commonly for patients with cancer, HIV, malaria, or
tuberculosis. Currently there are over 350K articles in PubMed that use the
"combination drug therapy" MeSH heading with at least 10K articles published
per year over the past two decades. Extracting combination therapies from
scientific literature inherently constitutes an $n$-ary relation extraction
problem. Unlike in the general $n$-ary setting where $n$ is fixed (e.g.,
drug-gene-mutation relations where $n=3$), extracting combination therapies is
a special setting where $n \geq 2$ is dynamic, depending on each instance.
Recently, Tiktinsky et al. (NAACL 2022) introduced a first of its kind dataset,
CombDrugExt, for extracting such therapies from literature. Here, we use a
sequence-to-sequence style end-to-end extraction method to achieve an F1-Score
of $66.7\%$ on the CombDrugExt test set for positive (or effective)
combinations. This is an absolute $\approx 5\%$ F1-score improvement even over
the prior best relation classification score with spotted drug entities (hence,
not end-to-end). Thus our effort introduces a state-of-the-art first model for
end-to-end extraction that is already superior to the best prior non end-to-end
model for this task. Our model seamlessly extracts all drug entities and
relations in a single pass and is highly suitable for dynamic $n$-ary
extraction scenarios. | [
0.0421378389,
0.0484833792,
-0.0006073281,
0.0234496277,
-0.0134305237,
0.0244114771,
-0.0129699493,
0.0362698324,
0.0168126449,
-0.0109508997,
-0.0126584312,
-0.0332569219,
0.0035409157,
0.0421059579,
0.0046118768,
-0.0085788062,
0.0220355298,
0.0353300497,
-0.0028920276,
0.0030379121,
-0.0294822529,
0.0315050893,
-0.0301301032,
0.0106706712,
0.0468760431,
-0.0154997353,
0.0430726968,
-0.0243503116,
0.0620854646,
-0.0593954287,
0.0125212818,
0.0115016457,
-0.0337526426,
-0.0126612186,
0.0000017492,
-0.0652937591,
-0.0349507406,
0.033651337,
-0.0052902256,
-0.0222114362,
0.0444004498,
-0.0328020044,
0.0413599797,
-0.0244959854,
-0.0229181778,
-0.0165787991,
0.0117067909,
0.07130339,
-0.0018946235,
0.0481145047,
-0.0102761323,
-0.032743942,
0.0859636292,
-0.0433798581,
0.0254550111,
-0.0307750292,
0.0878365412,
-0.0187579934,
0.0403480828,
-0.0140346531,
0.0223393887,
0.0141080497,
-0.0220393799,
0.0122976266,
0.0479697362,
0.049840156,
-0.0268051475,
-0.0142232357,
-0.0032234064,
0.0761093497,
0.0056158178,
0.0053979577,
0.0551435016,
0.0097102085,
-0.0251534414,
0.0408473983,
-0.00874337,
-0.0255558304,
-0.0862290189,
0.0087467246,
0.030605061,
-0.0176809486,
0.0371838249,
-0.0177271962,
-0.0189813692,
0.0227113832,
-0.008917002,
0.007947823,
0.0479213335,
-0.0174399372,
-0.0081256814,
-0.0181742348,
0.019799633,
-0.0084148189,
-0.0002869661,
0.0199185703,
0.0259015225,
-0.030870622,
0.0728605762,
-0.0635204837,
-0.0036184562,
-0.0356169306,
0.001020944,
0.0478234179,
-0.02518625,
-0.0306632835,
-0.0390783399,
0.0128255002,
-0.0044048331,
0.037057288,
-0.0363741554,
-0.0028647757,
0.0223076809,
0.06145918,
-0.0162791125,
-0.0168655682,
-0.0665606484,
-0.0152315153,
-0.0046079387,
0.004560322,
0.0211659819,
0.0299247298,
-0.021618098,
0.0080155488,
0.0340804979,
-0.0097708581,
0.0370974094,
0.0008342242,
-0.0193769261,
-0.0126783866,
0.0043719183,
-0.066711016,
0.0274106972,
-0.0459872819,
0.0164186712,
0.0672709867,
0.0159008987,
-0.0508075766,
0.0258096345,
-0.0195796844,
-0.027133232,
-0.0731325075,
0.0249229111,
-0.0366207995,
0.0966410786,
-0.001244534,
0.0275109895,
-0.0243392456,
0.0198828559,
-0.0511666089,
-0.0898580179,
0.0666815042,
0.0028012663,
-0.0533293895,
-0.0134175783,
0.0086258771,
-0.0039521288,
0.0014697989,
0.0200311486,
-0.0143448161,
0.0186167471,
0.0063386196,
-0.0194569658,
-0.030389322,
0.0359600559,
-0.0396837182,
0.0260086171,
0.0455027372,
0.0407658406,
0.0010695496,
-0.0571355149,
0.0068391557,
-0.0365606546,
-0.0524102822,
-0.0113112656,
-0.0170772467,
0.0765745938,
0.0383062474,
-0.0152331926,
-0.0233619008,
0.0079532117,
0.002221663,
-0.0258222707,
0.0027500945,
-0.0472008139,
0.0313850567,
0.0229059439,
0.0118874907,
0.0222073514,
-0.0048460555,
-0.002444735,
-0.0126554715,
-0.0178896692,
-0.0021024565,
0.0785813406,
-0.0395011753,
-0.0392967537,
-0.0031879034,
0.0768678114,
0.0125195086,
-0.0298868362,
0.0030181392,
-0.0432402641,
0.0032558909,
0.042728886,
-0.0482178368,
-0.0576832369,
0.0007255612,
-0.0444801077,
-0.025457399,
-0.0294995792,
-0.0171265192,
0.0323270895,
0.0137680583,
-0.0038022259,
0.0109363738,
0.0138893686,
0.0140297888,
0.0181616005,
0.0110483244,
-0.0339797884,
0.0072385729,
0.0197937395,
0.022174133,
-0.06293118,
-0.0295168553,
0.0123091508,
0.0083103571,
0.0391096808,
0.0104092471,
-0.0382827222,
-0.0025322568,
0.0710586905,
-0.0683015361,
-0.0307752043,
-0.0311495904,
0.0255481526,
-0.0377679355,
0.0153787704,
-0.0209198762,
0.0188599452,
-0.0095476191,
-0.0476173982,
0.0173152164,
-0.0034435999,
0.0117669133,
0.0143356286,
0.0186147951,
0.0106835179,
0.0454870909,
0.0318401828,
-0.0087662423,
0.0174194854,
-0.0076001291,
0.005068724,
-0.0091819856,
-0.1286637783,
-0.0051063355,
-0.0036989432,
0.0144122681,
0.0520598143,
-0.0145148784,
-0.0195433125,
-0.0155641353,
-0.0254428592,
-0.0161424167,
-0.0422174186,
-0.0092699546,
0.0315722339,
0.0441549011,
0.0502900146,
0.0000783869,
0.0006646408,
0.0130746141,
-0.0222531687,
-0.0315955617,
-0.0205981135,
-0.0360020772,
-0.01120805,
0.0207518302,
0.075956881,
-0.0550727397,
-0.0330718048,
-0.0437768772,
-0.0432975441,
0.0681868643,
-0.0291868411,
-0.0618468225,
0.0304151066,
0.0095239421,
-0.0345186479,
0.0128376987,
-0.0464288704,
0.0054282444,
-0.0115823587,
0.0119728502,
-0.0428864136,
0.0212464612,
-0.0253553707,
0.0191954765,
0.032553155,
0.0092340242,
0.0080302078,
0.0307758581,
-0.0601415485,
-0.0254315007,
0.0398320891,
-0.0198270492,
-0.0138866026,
0.053681761,
0.0189969707,
0.0033563173,
0.0019383312,
-0.0185612403,
0.0215177946,
-0.008853185,
-0.0537448861,
0.0297673084,
0.0059310948,
-0.0043624449,
-0.0350723378,
-0.035793826,
0.1062886193,
-0.0034124169,
0.0339005627,
-0.064475216,
0.0122325346,
-0.0286752395,
-0.0329925865,
0.0184602533,
0.0068116053,
0.0260985475,
0.0186264813,
0.0195928887,
-0.0260480419,
0.0299973544,
-0.056331072,
0.0705153272,
-0.0182516295,
0.0453569591,
0.0148186591,
-0.0544342287,
-0.032947287,
0.0064271521,
0.0200352427,
-0.0015284845,
-0.0057779136,
-0.0271849819,
0.003176565,
0.0232974142,
-0.0259102955,
0.0123567134,
-0.0161027275,
-0.0038601712,
0.0164793134,
0.014985716,
0.0786451772,
-0.0969460383,
-0.0034058681,
-0.010610559,
0.0199285112,
0.0687976703,
0.0027825681,
0.0397282764,
0.0263168383,
0.0355228372,
-0.0097716143,
-0.0427497588,
-0.0256944168,
0.0062205908,
-0.0290463213,
-0.0577388294,
0.0258817505,
0.0641736984,
0.0347969793,
-0.0433213487,
0.0067993104,
0.0239839517,
-0.075286828,
-0.0168384593,
0.0420300998,
-0.1073831394,
-0.0016739133,
-0.0341852903,
0.0055614067,
-0.0068680081,
-0.0655579641,
-0.0297850426,
-0.0398419015,
-0.0181218609,
0.020450186,
-0.0604378656,
0.0194812343,
-0.033804886,
-0.0075125806,
-0.0240481105,
-0.0574360937,
0.0242057946,
-0.0049266908,
-0.0370943435,
0.0196828786,
0.0120322937,
-0.0441279188,
0.0213800259,
-0.0101322569,
-0.0077907224,
0.0114627052,
0.0004844656,
0.0019939512,
0.03246025,
0.0044119367,
-0.0399381109,
-0.025380794,
-0.0205998719,
0.1021397635,
-0.0167395715,
0.0150487311,
-0.0317283496,
0.0440861471,
-0.0797237307,
-0.0136229265,
-0.0283378419,
0.0882133394,
-0.0031063517,
-0.0246469826,
-0.0595986359,
0.0024129564,
0.0051844534,
0.0364991426,
-0.0178918224,
0.0215271208,
-0.0144114727,
0.0069992309,
-0.004741421,
-0.0375714786,
0.0177889708,
0.0069518187,
-0.069479309,
0.011364039,
-0.0673420206,
-0.0350761041,
0.0482609905,
-0.023338886,
-0.0285430886,
0.0049815136,
-0.0163967442,
-0.0348602608,
-0.0286457967,
-0.0134888515,
0.0773479864,
0.013026299,
-0.0213792343,
-0.0224336982,
0.0573222339,
0.0069241845,
-0.0121109495,
0.012826683,
-0.0459697582,
-0.0387435816,
-0.0361918323,
-0.0024207055,
0.0223777927,
0.0286601651,
0.0025235738,
0.0356776044,
0.0272902697,
0.0491581745,
0.0484845899,
-0.0394494608,
-0.0136969006,
-0.0128664356,
-0.0187806394,
0.0147673087,
-0.0258996282,
0.0356500261,
0.005561864,
0.0420198441,
-0.0173627455,
0.0088313185,
0.0714037791,
0.0038191958,
0.0778703019,
-0.0011296966,
-0.030418165,
-0.031763915,
0.0433360189,
-0.0302849226,
0.0342939422,
-0.0189213194,
0.0113966158,
-0.01142688,
-0.0277134646,
-0.0353864245,
0.0071992981,
-0.040684741,
0.0214523822,
-0.0418642946,
-0.0141123924,
0.014120141,
-0.0257589947,
0.085903585,
-0.0183269288,
-0.0118988622,
0.0084613711,
0.0157783534,
0.0113099366,
-0.036379315,
0.0263665225,
0.0155610805,
0.012059751,
-0.0327489637,
0.0382292569,
-0.0280005764,
0.038368348,
-0.0443811864,
0.0104473829,
0.0453332737,
-0.0045974837,
0.090810515,
0.0003181073,
-0.0121909063,
-0.0562972613,
0.0504030287,
-0.0370050855,
0.0628491044,
0.0313884169,
0.0441499874,
-0.0160052516,
-0.0224035289,
0.0789959729,
-0.0049345959,
0.0379716605,
0.0177859813,
-0.0277049672,
-0.0491431989,
-0.0294506829,
-0.0217970628,
0.0069782329,
-0.0197956339,
0.0133307585,
-0.0625256598,
-0.026686905,
0.0375562571,
-0.0152049931,
0.011311573,
0.0011981309,
-0.0354434438,
0.0266843848,
0.0431153663,
-0.0631040558,
-0.041759938,
0.0302516334,
-0.0356174484,
-0.0501739345,
0.0082751354,
-5.423867586e-33,
0.029175438,
0.0114343287,
-0.0292971935,
-0.0103781708,
-0.0016186896,
0.0293708704,
-0.0412287638,
-0.038809672,
0.0387670323,
0.0431282669,
0.0017837409,
0.0057702693,
-0.0110796876,
-0.0109034432,
-0.0120750861,
0.026644526,
-0.0118617602,
0.0231825672,
0.0316239297,
0.0269421134,
0.0573955923,
0.0889000595,
0.0517647527,
-0.0506232902,
-0.0180239566,
0.0270828139,
0.0441380367,
-0.0079107452,
-0.0232723914,
0.0792487413,
-0.0136948647,
0.001584621,
0.0123304827,
-0.0522757694,
0.029293973,
-0.0789661258,
-0.1093899012,
0.0231324621,
-0.0211665742,
-0.0474239551,
-0.0236487016,
-0.0116837686,
0.0382036716,
0.0004823966,
0.0253217481,
-0.0818308666,
0.0538283437,
-0.0582035482,
-0.0674619675,
-0.0679286569,
-0.0050726966,
0.0428697057,
0.0095169032,
0.0159274694,
-0.0304522719,
0.0047739428,
-0.0130659044,
0.0629291162,
-0.0228239018,
-0.015145855,
0.0292598549,
0.0255486313,
0.0310854521,
-0.0330490768,
0.0040705577,
0.0542695038,
-0.0202500448,
-0.0248145219,
0.0176326502,
0.013276374,
-0.0422607362,
0.0688541606,
-0.0342759937,
0.0171713568,
0.057955116,
0.0197387952,
-0.1163297519,
0.0252139512,
-0.022958653,
0.0495190322,
-0.0221292861,
0.0075291554,
-0.0112618404,
0.0141101498,
-0.0124907903,
0.0100683477,
-0.0196502153,
-0.0447706953,
0.0190219451,
-0.0048135719,
-0.0721965507,
0.0734253749,
0.0128843738,
-0.0371935703,
-0.0729740113,
0.0349753425,
-0.0139693785,
0.0302126892,
-0.0043191812,
-0.0168470442,
-0.0366609059,
-0.0163228009,
-0.0000711883,
-0.0304103661,
0.0267099608,
0.0051462036,
0.0585705861,
-0.0601297319,
-0.034559302,
-0.0070534591,
-0.0499760024,
0.0114467461,
0.0099871103,
0.0569317304,
0.0156439524,
0.0532174595,
0.0216436442,
0.0913015828,
0.0244617574,
-0.003057393,
-0.0150758028,
0.0471295156,
0.0345793776,
0.0227523632,
-0.0225877129,
-0.0047202022,
0.0001023216,
0.0093798889,
0.0378449038,
-0.0266332608,
-0.0247556418,
-0.0013368885,
2.725e-7,
0.0580903813,
0.0101784552,
0.0401384979,
-0.012445244,
0.0215487201,
0.0228920411,
-0.0369430706,
0.0419989005,
-0.0341714397,
0.008446089,
0.0326242708,
-0.0002186454,
0.0584484972,
0.0413335524,
-0.0218532439,
-0.0525128208,
-0.0598060228,
-0.0666861907,
-0.0496245287,
-0.0369971655,
0.0339193381,
0.0388779193,
0.0405233242,
0.007697165,
0.002421244,
-0.0175208952,
0.0254632886,
-0.0330561586,
-0.0135908434,
0.0697865263,
-0.0181450285,
-0.0547390282,
-0.0056178663,
0.0480476134,
-0.0315890275,
0.0053156186,
-0.0308071468,
0.067475237,
-0.0372369699,
0.0001141928,
0.0487482883,
-0.0193094295,
0.0492981039,
-0.0160496086,
0.0395870134,
-0.0433567576,
-0.0410932675,
-0.0076696035,
-0.0463360138,
-0.0096741645,
0.0711413473,
0.0178579688,
0.0202744883,
0.090606235,
0.0056850947,
0.0267114602,
-0.024502337,
-0.0685280263,
0.0301657915,
0.0982149541,
-0.0182041246,
0.0002580097,
0.0402345471,
-0.0057156188,
-0.0178510975,
-0.0520726331,
-0.0086384062,
2.296746755e-34,
0.0284976121,
0.009672855,
0.0346882753,
0.0260819886,
0.0304136425,
-0.0338577181,
-0.0274083987,
-0.0057663629,
-0.0459314957,
-0.0783558711,
0.0131814713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16857v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16857v3 | Did You Mean...? Confidence-based Trade-offs in Semantic Parsing | 2023-03-29T17:07:26 | 2023-10-20T12:54:30 | Elias Stengel-Eskin, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL | We illustrate how a calibrated model can help balance common trade-offs in
task-oriented parsing. In a simulated annotator-in-the-loop experiment, we show
that well-calibrated confidence scores allow us to balance cost with annotator
load, improving accuracy with a small number of interactions. We then examine
how confidence scores can help optimize the trade-off between usability and
safety. We show that confidence-based thresholding can substantially reduce the
number of incorrect low-confidence programs executed; however, this comes at a
cost to usability. We propose the DidYouMean system which better balances
usability and safety. | [
0.0212635659,
0.0219164286,
-0.0088584824,
-0.0002613891,
-0.0397084244,
0.0320306122,
0.0004567995,
-0.044681605,
-0.0175599474,
-0.0502657853,
0.0006460243,
0.0179911014,
-0.0054055406,
-0.001494586,
-0.0019969165,
-0.0379504114,
0.056637384,
-0.0150496848,
0.0500251949,
0.034862902,
0.0115021057,
-0.0207057856,
-0.0283811707,
0.0826676637,
-0.0562804639,
-0.0020503723,
0.0133400643,
0.0135171358,
0.0090646185,
-0.0643243566,
0.0284571759,
0.048161,
-0.0286467671,
0.0171494856,
0.000001899,
-0.0431937166,
-0.0356516391,
0.012933339,
-0.0309309084,
-0.0408932753,
0.0543746762,
0.0020035116,
-0.0139887417,
-0.0007866044,
-0.0390196815,
0.0157153513,
0.0435710922,
-0.0310517326,
0.0380624272,
0.0396771021,
-0.0102122985,
0.0115071321,
0.0132889021,
0.0135332504,
-0.0024597177,
-0.0582464524,
-0.0096101062,
0.045137126,
-0.0074227932,
-0.0311025102,
-0.0068605971,
0.0352849625,
0.0121245543,
-0.0146031706,
0.0354117677,
0.0140202073,
-0.0287101623,
-0.0524544381,
-0.006976591,
0.0059160911,
0.0181656964,
-0.0123971319,
0.0073525473,
-0.0184922814,
0.0213205982,
-0.0298456624,
-0.0502920263,
0.0184099693,
-0.0364167243,
0.0167066511,
0.0074427854,
0.0287140701,
0.0057456754,
-0.0020534797,
0.0434017032,
0.0885918662,
-0.0199576337,
-0.0362513438,
0.0482112952,
0.0740965977,
-0.0439083315,
-0.0347593613,
0.0466752276,
-0.0048822528,
-0.0472085811,
0.003566708,
-0.0525618047,
-0.0605880134,
0.0300735664,
-0.0165647995,
0.0035309154,
0.0363142416,
-0.0245593823,
0.0430240482,
0.0057846094,
-0.0127353519,
0.0258381534,
-0.0008138963,
-0.018783031,
0.0010883166,
-0.0357792154,
-0.0002867303,
-0.0553318448,
0.0677287281,
-0.0298994202,
0.0140280696,
-0.068555288,
0.0190420803,
-0.0214421134,
0.0360493325,
0.0275402032,
0.002121411,
-0.074668251,
0.0530326404,
-0.0026705875,
0.0162192229,
-0.0314746648,
0.0033844446,
0.0257420931,
-0.0575579666,
-0.0027035964,
-0.0070849457,
-0.0141766388,
-0.0494460613,
-0.0379143395,
0.035714794,
0.0002688745,
-0.0069552995,
-0.0231093392,
-0.0552880839,
-0.0478004478,
-0.0099422233,
-0.0248972736,
-0.0822381079,
-0.0327895395,
0.0306431595,
0.0362754837,
-0.0412697829,
0.0112575209,
0.0340745412,
-0.0152781885,
0.0946271718,
-0.0070436429,
-0.0134731131,
-0.0068589565,
-0.0080296276,
-0.0806346983,
0.0608416423,
0.0612221621,
0.0068091019,
0.0454455353,
0.0169143938,
-0.0155497054,
0.0163146332,
-0.0361199901,
-0.0757890493,
0.0031838606,
-0.0346179232,
-0.0343345925,
0.0185365379,
0.0252657551,
0.0719644353,
-0.0301774759,
0.0293241888,
0.0244843382,
0.0635452941,
-0.0235145129,
-0.0396271348,
0.0454670414,
0.0059045488,
-0.0192445125,
0.0135958586,
-0.0644769669,
-0.0080076139,
-0.0492779873,
0.0082625234,
-0.0343181081,
-0.0293945018,
0.0148846833,
-0.0405053087,
-0.0136122061,
0.0089021465,
0.0026470812,
0.0014860089,
0.0180385988,
-0.0022743305,
0.0035764505,
0.0143806413,
0.0151956007,
-0.0450041443,
-0.0118755046,
-0.0497075133,
-0.0163717959,
0.0524911508,
0.0305734798,
-0.0426177867,
0.0023284135,
-0.0169168618,
0.0149774896,
0.0065956977,
0.0294207316,
-0.037662968,
-0.0120502179,
-0.0335715339,
-0.0219798386,
0.0024246827,
0.0419946313,
-0.0359664671,
-0.014223461,
-0.008399481,
-0.0050274138,
-0.0054833493,
-0.0236002654,
0.0398149528,
0.0425091423,
0.0029769149,
-0.0270377249,
-0.0029550425,
0.0028597307,
-0.0036127341,
0.0103072552,
0.0352361165,
0.0128619783,
-0.0311924759,
0.0068249623,
0.0251788013,
-0.0252026506,
-0.048301708,
0.035967771,
-0.0267898664,
-0.0577576533,
0.0097192638,
-0.0014016317,
-0.0367993005,
-0.0170594566,
-0.0368313268,
0.0255169328,
-0.0091352519,
0.0163734183,
-0.0056079584,
-0.0366440676,
-0.0905224159,
0.0675264895,
-0.0057169083,
0.0268365163,
-0.0187099893,
-0.0281655677,
-0.0074022962,
-0.0711848736,
-0.0548666827,
-0.0204417575,
0.0024914267,
-0.019187253,
0.0198285114,
0.0169575121,
-0.058189176,
-0.0132370656,
-0.0651759654,
0.0104835648,
-0.0122601455,
0.0377328917,
0.0269388929,
0.0029541741,
0.02084985,
-0.0348988883,
0.0236837938,
0.037776161,
-0.0173231047,
0.0567522869,
0.0525245145,
0.006861439,
-0.0348925143,
-0.0573385581,
-0.029825151,
-0.0424753688,
0.0173161849,
0.0623001978,
-0.0394314155,
-0.0239029713,
0.0604965463,
0.0212590154,
0.0180385467,
0.0531390198,
0.0285414737,
0.0472195558,
-0.008256291,
-0.0225082505,
0.0874767005,
-0.0569611117,
0.0301702134,
0.0503671393,
-0.0406585075,
-0.059066128,
0.0235268604,
0.0390477516,
-0.021810811,
-0.0264154766,
-0.0337598026,
0.0155311469,
0.0452384055,
0.0063433428,
0.0143196331,
-0.0328234658,
0.0026759275,
-0.0719692558,
-0.0508722998,
0.0032168357,
-0.0057548527,
-0.0229960866,
0.0395487845,
-0.0232981127,
-0.0135742724,
0.0815502182,
0.0140193505,
-0.0171321388,
-0.007753728,
0.0285240728,
0.0264040604,
0.0514614955,
-0.0074710506,
-0.01581599,
0.0324810371,
-0.062699385,
-0.0265082791,
-0.0118680298,
0.0592802428,
-0.0287604854,
0.0266070962,
-0.0941360593,
0.0345943645,
-0.0173915233,
-0.0650235489,
-0.0476951934,
-0.0380501039,
-0.1021075249,
0.0111497501,
0.0422308296,
0.0096373744,
0.0177874472,
0.0027458239,
-0.0194489155,
0.0272342209,
0.0004140836,
-0.0375605039,
-0.0179937184,
0.0076238592,
0.0279485472,
-0.0105806421,
0.0435533784,
0.0074434681,
0.0035322218,
0.0659164637,
0.0413534306,
0.00621991,
-0.0628804192,
-0.0130819082,
0.0360768102,
-0.0616735332,
-0.052891396,
0.0076002646,
0.0548529327,
-0.0593922026,
-0.0246656798,
0.1092798561,
0.0311025847,
-0.0218708254,
0.0229889564,
-0.0360008068,
0.0488008857,
0.0169274602,
0.0272229444,
-0.0719724968,
-0.0619252697,
0.0355209038,
0.0528880619,
-0.0036603662,
-0.0719866008,
0.0410766602,
-0.0919715613,
0.0175401121,
-0.0341790952,
-0.0250305831,
0.0439736731,
-0.0232710652,
0.0140962629,
-0.0707446039,
0.014630639,
0.029993603,
-0.0108965738,
0.0432353951,
0.0291058384,
-0.0093283039,
-0.0374671295,
0.0092363125,
-0.0387151018,
0.0452443808,
0.064364545,
0.0024259512,
-0.004324954,
-0.0348057859,
0.0474875346,
0.0267571472,
0.0013793844,
-0.049178537,
0.0258250348,
0.0087982267,
0.0085068801,
-0.0174507089,
-0.0027445725,
-0.0075928653,
-0.0121544413,
-0.009991236,
0.0516836382,
-0.0244711563,
0.0533905774,
0.013982269,
-0.0154549284,
0.0402902514,
0.0698850676,
-0.0000434412,
-0.0293976497,
-0.0577572808,
-0.0604825243,
-0.0160498992,
-0.0802926198,
0.0053495946,
0.0365368389,
0.0008179161,
-0.0701999888,
-0.0761566833,
-0.035661079,
0.0447859205,
0.0378893614,
-0.009433113,
-0.0164479334,
0.0505382158,
0.0555231459,
-0.0355829671,
0.0205651242,
-0.0148033509,
0.0458191782,
-0.04034229,
0.0412240438,
0.0237042792,
0.0400130153,
-0.022962898,
0.0220494438,
-0.0912190825,
-0.0532312281,
0.0079695843,
0.0823156536,
0.0271187332,
0.0006539084,
-0.0383306183,
-0.0671997666,
-0.0203147363,
0.0174210779,
-0.0373960026,
-0.0130273821,
0.0345160849,
0.0070560761,
0.0109673832,
0.0286467597,
-0.0207255278,
-0.0173104089,
-0.0208100565,
0.0833276063,
-0.0463096127,
-0.020951435,
0.0646885484,
0.0519164689,
0.0499198698,
-0.0476751663,
0.0228173621,
0.0141583141,
-0.0095851999,
-0.0375158712,
-0.0229919851,
-0.0413768962,
0.0147212138,
-0.0072058272,
-0.0443150401,
-0.0091029573,
-0.0165503956,
-0.0121080009,
0.036035493,
-0.0513473414,
0.0001280088,
0.0796947405,
0.0052463706,
-0.007518121,
0.0011853167,
-0.0315398127,
-0.0026535378,
0.021432735,
0.0448448658,
0.0083766626,
-0.0267672744,
-0.0044372897,
-0.0130415242,
-0.0009600098,
0.0033509366,
-0.0477455966,
0.0133694001,
0.0373290479,
0.0148877371,
0.0524612963,
-0.0014981853,
0.1015888602,
-0.0050028707,
-0.0056288121,
-0.0120680677,
0.0041531948,
0.0345198214,
-0.0202984493,
0.0285886507,
0.0100615434,
0.0006158064,
-0.0444146097,
0.0730955154,
-0.058342997,
0.0334701985,
-0.0480668619,
-0.0812977701,
-0.0317436233,
-0.0197658148,
-0.0413509049,
0.059490487,
-0.0433613546,
-0.03714858,
-0.0494251475,
-0.0529155992,
-0.0121835265,
0.058079809,
0.0143110761,
0.0071680201,
0.0368105881,
0.035146419,
0.0099753244,
-0.0930506587,
-0.012001032,
0.0030662469,
0.0131240897,
-0.005698578,
-0.0522461534,
-5.824032312e-33,
-0.0293471813,
-0.0061967834,
-0.0020323605,
0.0574116632,
0.0061756237,
-0.0271585658,
-0.0403270908,
0.0622632094,
0.021758765,
0.0300265867,
-0.0281746686,
-0.0124018062,
0.0439649001,
-0.007111968,
0.0769305974,
-0.0068238582,
0.0580840334,
-0.0050524981,
-0.0215571094,
-0.0409387574,
0.0347437635,
0.0273455027,
0.0224095043,
-0.0711967498,
0.0433148704,
0.0496372245,
-0.0209325869,
0.0372681543,
0.0314261578,
0.0374117941,
0.0249849744,
0.0379759148,
0.0112116924,
-0.0142468112,
-0.0179797541,
-0.0141515471,
-0.0843103155,
-0.0265760589,
0.0261554271,
0.0486974232,
-0.0241037197,
-0.029081529,
0.0291833859,
-0.0232806355,
-0.0208794102,
0.0591766536,
0.0095584719,
-0.0546545759,
0.0103179682,
-0.0179458167,
-0.0378431641,
0.0177501403,
0.0093988106,
-0.023743391,
0.02937093,
0.0219425242,
0.0111751985,
-0.023875447,
-0.0024288301,
0.0008622106,
-0.0388864912,
0.0263398346,
0.0876143649,
0.0302012507,
-0.00563194,
0.0174493119,
-0.0313006938,
-0.016316317,
0.029989779,
0.046668537,
-0.000851707,
0.0296078883,
-0.0045936815,
0.0577482693,
0.0077148867,
0.0075554028,
-0.0641549155,
0.0219742749,
0.0432512797,
0.0638058931,
-0.0214577764,
0.0565138794,
-0.0839960799,
-0.0136253303,
0.0011290977,
0.0054044048,
-0.0009662253,
-0.0214445926,
0.0218552947,
-0.00574341,
-0.0130749736,
0.0692522153,
-0.0114455214,
-0.0024926562,
-0.0205439888,
-0.0506064631,
0.0208014362,
0.022923952,
-0.0310036205,
0.0023365901,
0.0039478932,
-0.0076073427,
-0.000459917,
0.0245506614,
0.0577224344,
0.0131358588,
0.052029565,
-0.0049071023,
-0.0408913493,
0.0126583744,
-0.0099671213,
0.0343878493,
0.0080265189,
0.0156387296,
0.0532479398,
-0.0071181585,
-0.0234589409,
0.0184045937,
-0.0066876402,
0.0083002159,
-0.0471499376,
0.0173259079,
0.0042023757,
-0.0174015593,
-0.0150163956,
-0.0475868657,
0.0398830511,
0.006891774,
-0.0076415581,
-0.0109414374,
-0.0214461777,
-0.0142081613,
2.684e-7,
0.0560066551,
0.0129345478,
0.0070350375,
0.0079396097,
0.0088118985,
0.0343051255,
0.0178823788,
0.0124555901,
-0.0251237657,
-0.0554720238,
-0.0318665616,
-0.0167915188,
0.0314428434,
0.0804528147,
-0.0482146591,
-0.1012768671,
0.0468762778,
0.0324031562,
0.0011927211,
-0.0147776762,
0.0617431737,
0.0280977134,
0.0024739092,
0.0057489653,
-0.0095407302,
-0.0399572253,
0.0098382896,
0.0208075196,
0.012200214,
0.0163844302,
0.0448644385,
0.0049125385,
0.0316780545,
0.0959635749,
-0.0006495626,
-0.0236384459,
0.0393910743,
0.0664060861,
-0.0194058344,
0.0265652556,
-0.0187862068,
-0.0255802944,
0.0326001756,
-0.0317344256,
0.0309994109,
-0.0626985133,
0.0140706133,
-0.0002148421,
0.0115158185,
-0.001919396,
-0.0055549662,
-0.0102604078,
-0.0037003737,
-0.0189078636,
0.0245267581,
0.0211435258,
-0.030387925,
-0.0108333603,
-0.0460214503,
0.0347753987,
-0.01128197,
-0.0561652705,
0.0164640136,
0.0078342501,
-0.0194424,
-0.0829599798,
-0.0242003798,
2.128527773e-34,
0.0290160347,
0.0209056158,
0.0645441562,
0.0284450836,
0.002703855,
0.0596198328,
0.0014622062,
0.0075181453,
0.030585574,
-0.0327532366,
-0.0399508514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16854v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16854v2 | AnnoLLM: Making Large Language Models to Be Better Crowdsourced Annotators | 2023-03-29T17:03:21 | 2024-04-05T15:19:19 | Xingwei He, Zhenghao Lin, Yeyun Gong, A-Long Jin, Hang Zhang, Chen Lin, Jian Jiao, Siu Ming Yiu, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks rely on labeled data to train
machine learning models with high performance. However, data annotation is
time-consuming and expensive, especially when the task involves a large amount
of data or requires specialized domains. Recently, GPT-3.5 series models have
demonstrated remarkable few-shot and zero-shot ability across various NLP
tasks. In this paper, we first claim that large language models (LLMs), such as
GPT-3.5, can serve as an excellent crowdsourced annotator when provided with
sufficient guidance and demonstrated examples. Accordingly, we propose AnnoLLM,
an annotation system powered by LLMs, which adopts a two-step approach,
explain-then-annotate. Concretely, we first prompt LLMs to provide explanations
for why the specific ground truth answer/label was assigned for a given
example. Then, we construct the few-shot chain-of-thought prompt with the
self-generated explanation and employ it to annotate the unlabeled data with
LLMs. Our experiment results on three tasks, including user input and keyword
relevance assessment, BoolQ, and WiC, demonstrate that AnnoLLM surpasses or
performs on par with crowdsourced annotators. Furthermore, we build the first
conversation-based information retrieval dataset employing AnnoLLM. This
dataset is designed to facilitate the development of retrieval models capable
of retrieving pertinent documents for conversational text. Human evaluation has
validated the dataset's high quality. | [
0.0665876195,
0.0259959828,
0.0150690898,
0.0502603091,
-0.0342772789,
0.0104640098,
0.0194784999,
0.0016730642,
0.0287002735,
-0.0798260495,
-0.0306621492,
0.0209858399,
-0.0371750295,
-0.0078414781,
0.0051869107,
-0.0296267811,
0.0213832892,
-0.0258156359,
0.0312196035,
0.0137354126,
0.0372971147,
0.0236548074,
-0.0040957937,
0.0519464202,
-0.0168445911,
0.0110924402,
-0.0121130459,
0.0093689114,
-0.0183624364,
-0.0265737213,
0.0118924007,
0.0786672458,
0.0273801014,
0.0387717076,
0.0000018917,
-0.0448324941,
-0.0106368605,
0.0301191974,
-0.0701219738,
-0.0060016876,
0.0062173875,
0.0569758415,
0.0303515643,
0.0180639084,
-0.0357112177,
0.0072074565,
0.0436610952,
0.0399533622,
0.0915578157,
0.0767855868,
0.0050499151,
-0.0078103058,
-0.0067107747,
-0.0110030603,
0.0697541386,
-0.0785473064,
0.0021832832,
0.0074574212,
0.0209794287,
0.0522006303,
0.031623438,
0.0399238504,
-0.0032762918,
-0.0419653207,
0.0560514107,
-0.0004641273,
-0.0752372891,
-0.0258207377,
-0.0089666434,
0.081529893,
0.038010817,
-0.034177199,
0.006522825,
-0.0092348922,
0.0220383145,
0.0127251726,
-0.0503160134,
-0.0115784705,
-0.0056237727,
0.017835943,
-0.023256693,
0.0060141259,
0.0319523588,
0.0141072888,
0.0405756459,
0.0754514933,
-0.0099616917,
-0.0077627664,
-0.0087136589,
0.0162572786,
-0.0322905593,
-0.0501242951,
-0.0044194609,
0.0194823202,
-0.029460486,
0.0124285659,
-0.012522772,
-0.0304532852,
0.040405374,
-0.0529363528,
0.0165680312,
0.0148524167,
-0.0174442027,
0.1019186527,
0.0005157433,
0.0077974405,
0.005197545,
0.0137066795,
-0.0296418574,
-0.0486796238,
-0.0844916627,
-0.0096402867,
-0.0536592491,
0.0343450718,
-0.0391358919,
-0.0003037641,
-0.0053412626,
0.0098338053,
-0.0116369575,
-0.0082736984,
0.0299143977,
0.020994449,
-0.0220537912,
-0.0187458564,
-0.0476771183,
0.0212841034,
-0.0540257134,
0.0015794317,
0.0299927611,
-0.0826384872,
-0.0003738301,
0.0081007788,
0.032217402,
-0.0219774563,
0.0072125429,
0.0336774737,
0.0103297159,
-0.0522128567,
-0.0477920584,
-0.0190028176,
0.0050654975,
-0.0355630219,
-0.0177758355,
-0.0447851419,
0.0185719728,
0.0088748327,
-0.0149259698,
-0.0145863807,
0.0263001919,
0.0662195534,
-0.0285597499,
0.1014369801,
-0.0490232594,
-0.0084002009,
0.0618014634,
-0.0099632936,
-0.0214907657,
0.0642466024,
0.0204268005,
0.0158268958,
0.058643125,
-0.0083503285,
0.0562288538,
-0.0001214528,
0.0226426311,
-0.0157480147,
0.0289035141,
0.0356604047,
-0.0297904033,
0.0311829448,
-0.0127489679,
0.0533228926,
-0.018004315,
0.003654355,
0.0511824377,
0.0662599131,
-0.0338553339,
-0.021415554,
0.0063427719,
0.0605069213,
0.0079745902,
-0.0438149199,
-0.0353644863,
0.0410119519,
-0.0741860718,
-0.0255893916,
0.0700087771,
-0.036783129,
-0.0123217897,
-0.0547375306,
-0.0511098541,
0.0217793453,
-0.003726071,
0.0312266145,
0.0429603234,
0.015337619,
-0.0222063269,
0.0445233993,
0.0170936361,
-0.0693657026,
-0.0105477367,
-0.0451015905,
0.0370425247,
0.0462368988,
0.0565903001,
-0.0247790832,
-0.0091184545,
-0.0320660472,
0.0238391589,
0.0490590408,
0.0351872817,
-0.0078998609,
-0.030035371,
-0.034995839,
-0.0307770818,
0.0089108627,
0.0129442234,
0.0022853452,
0.0361644179,
-0.0392419137,
0.0226109829,
-0.051744882,
-0.0371088348,
0.0297463909,
0.0132707097,
-0.053035602,
0.0149375778,
-0.0073464741,
0.0195407085,
0.0213216245,
0.0004973349,
0.0229044929,
0.0166744497,
-0.0009989166,
-0.0347119384,
-0.0242629889,
-0.0158006791,
-0.0207474995,
0.0176169351,
-0.0286475904,
-0.0160842668,
0.0138438595,
-0.0430661477,
-0.0413976051,
-0.0334816203,
-0.0334221907,
0.0158538427,
-0.0733865201,
-0.0398994014,
0.0187295135,
-0.0092966277,
-0.0533148199,
0.0573850013,
0.0203410555,
0.0163690615,
-0.0047025378,
-0.0104529932,
0.0335786976,
-0.0514522009,
-0.044649832,
-0.0008353479,
0.0192722678,
0.0253160316,
0.0560164452,
0.0032417383,
-0.0479172952,
0.0125988396,
-0.1278822422,
0.0092179198,
-0.0197295211,
0.0029190509,
-0.0085361032,
0.0025194916,
0.0072807362,
-0.0359058939,
-0.0398842841,
0.00816953,
0.0129115256,
0.0331297778,
0.0594744608,
0.0227340981,
0.0209236946,
-0.0540702529,
-0.0010174909,
0.0014856317,
0.0202249736,
0.0424578302,
-0.0336628258,
-0.0242254753,
0.0041770865,
-0.0258568786,
0.0352570415,
0.0078336662,
-0.0156105999,
0.026206525,
-0.0195882656,
-0.0123933554,
0.0424358696,
0.0175561234,
0.0295037497,
-0.0014036007,
0.0090097524,
-0.0734163821,
0.0274591502,
-0.0108448369,
-0.031256713,
-0.0194332562,
0.0035547875,
0.0324394889,
0.0495876521,
-0.0119294394,
-0.0139060095,
-0.0785635486,
0.0161598492,
0.0096100224,
0.0037195014,
-0.0892981216,
-0.0133354561,
-0.0275948849,
0.0532123893,
-0.0333526209,
-0.0379978977,
0.0663512722,
-0.0474555567,
-0.0157357752,
-0.0084250513,
-0.0169670265,
-0.0430644155,
0.0648905262,
-0.0083965296,
0.0038558617,
0.0097038606,
0.0019707014,
0.0023836801,
-0.0013841285,
0.0570872538,
-0.0562349483,
-0.00106765,
-0.0157355517,
0.0371905938,
0.0024861919,
-0.0397483781,
-0.0229092576,
-0.0719380751,
-0.0706051961,
0.0022704494,
0.0141627667,
-0.0093279872,
-0.019653175,
-0.0123428032,
0.009475057,
0.0331255458,
0.0020805646,
-0.0203482471,
-0.0067596864,
0.0086001372,
0.0315429345,
0.0129398415,
-0.0150023503,
0.0023202861,
0.0085051013,
0.0317470804,
0.031578958,
0.0061323107,
-0.0082090599,
-0.0264930893,
0.0132792145,
-0.0327591449,
-0.017182257,
-0.012446491,
0.0546921566,
-0.0498993248,
-0.0036400771,
0.1086311266,
0.02218288,
-0.0351926982,
-0.0381311662,
-0.0278592166,
0.0232608039,
0.0463517681,
0.0352547243,
-0.1001986638,
-0.0736620575,
0.0133356173,
0.0499395169,
0.0003289542,
-0.0342351906,
-0.0024006194,
-0.1493652165,
0.0356334746,
-0.0308382064,
-0.0195063911,
0.0077281324,
-0.0658366233,
-0.0001114082,
-0.0391354673,
-0.0295900572,
-0.0034662522,
0.0204860941,
0.0216154214,
0.019571444,
-0.0043685599,
-0.0306845177,
0.0489052869,
-0.0131388074,
0.0683220774,
0.0667848885,
0.0261339098,
0.010604227,
-0.0748218447,
0.0419343188,
0.0308272969,
0.006380226,
-0.0106554199,
0.083895959,
-0.0465184934,
-0.0052093524,
-0.0259206332,
0.0355165936,
-0.0246761609,
-0.0132625168,
-0.0041634818,
0.0525997989,
0.0062424652,
0.0420170017,
-0.0269669853,
-0.0100313742,
0.014494516,
0.1141562387,
0.0330052264,
-0.0348775797,
-0.0149018886,
-0.0526702516,
-0.0148625346,
-0.0310399868,
-0.0545532107,
0.0051873717,
0.022660125,
-0.0260850955,
-0.0558098964,
-0.0254965387,
0.0546639003,
0.017152993,
-0.0089849029,
0.0106234308,
-0.0235020556,
0.0472102538,
-0.0013125627,
0.0599564202,
-0.0506551079,
-0.0082636392,
-0.0576826334,
-0.0110136149,
0.0187617987,
-0.0301721934,
-0.0385736674,
0.0624992289,
-0.0839547738,
-0.0316123292,
-0.0107462909,
0.032788828,
0.0223588645,
0.0229235496,
-0.0214713141,
-0.0759370625,
-0.0122130616,
0.0750798434,
-0.0387401693,
-0.0388105996,
0.0134193441,
0.0443525203,
-0.0115624648,
0.0440847911,
-0.051752083,
-0.0000012875,
-0.0225904845,
0.028531665,
-0.0279772189,
-0.0493561961,
0.0424246229,
0.0543164946,
0.0842868984,
0.00930689,
0.0009712758,
-0.0418630913,
-0.0047829635,
0.0004409075,
-0.0596391149,
-0.0694290251,
0.004590502,
-0.0074086394,
-0.0823202804,
-0.0005733235,
-0.0124635817,
-0.0191976558,
0.0477768332,
-0.0165498164,
-0.0108996108,
0.055065468,
-0.0049574543,
-0.0067132688,
0.0011631466,
-0.0040025953,
0.0238157324,
0.0091795921,
0.0472290441,
-0.0157319624,
0.0525157675,
0.0102101406,
-0.0321899801,
0.0441602357,
-0.0001507923,
-0.0698665977,
-0.0543342941,
-0.0313666388,
0.0710605755,
0.0355082788,
-0.003331335,
0.0168144815,
-0.0204714648,
-0.0320386961,
-0.0098646348,
0.0267028511,
0.0157425217,
-0.0180420764,
0.0171032306,
0.0223942269,
-0.0411029942,
0.0085090278,
0.0572234541,
0.0010267777,
0.0238597915,
-0.0100653414,
-0.0448722392,
-0.0458048843,
0.0140676172,
0.0069567831,
0.0500362925,
0.0177052096,
0.0132591762,
-0.0452995226,
-0.0236843172,
-0.0179303531,
0.0201978106,
-0.0363097675,
0.0000289999,
0.0563885719,
0.0645455793,
-0.0293683447,
-0.0434142724,
-0.0663533658,
0.0190063473,
-0.0147036137,
-0.0059127118,
-0.017710261,
-6.419334242e-33,
-0.0394378752,
-0.0556229688,
0.0044607325,
0.0195892341,
0.0311050396,
-0.0119719021,
-0.0249772426,
0.0159851126,
-0.0185327809,
0.0176945217,
-0.0107775796,
0.0258100405,
0.0087936772,
0.0240717586,
0.0057890257,
-0.0480077267,
0.0486737974,
-0.0170103386,
-0.023632301,
0.0194079895,
0.041527383,
0.0188997798,
0.0365888774,
-0.0648647919,
0.0781423822,
-0.0258773267,
-0.0237876363,
0.0602876134,
-0.008372955,
0.041713383,
-0.0033900416,
0.0427232571,
0.0125765596,
-0.0446495377,
0.0204825271,
-0.0003381688,
-0.0571410209,
0.0069211,
0.0173821431,
-0.014561912,
-0.0631064624,
-0.0139805842,
0.0488536283,
-0.0211052913,
0.0037072841,
0.0149900168,
0.0479236431,
-0.0055196872,
0.0027155797,
0.0104067344,
-0.0033177854,
0.035444662,
-0.0170042496,
-0.0475256145,
0.018439969,
0.0386793576,
0.0112258261,
0.0529005527,
-0.0434308685,
0.0036242665,
-0.0115048746,
0.0190595593,
0.0490131117,
0.0053341584,
0.0105958683,
0.0611691065,
0.0161980223,
0.0109316381,
-0.0264188349,
-0.0438176133,
-0.027766997,
0.0540729165,
0.069986701,
0.0875328109,
0.0368325897,
0.0085311793,
-0.0145288398,
0.0480378456,
-0.0076271677,
0.0124772554,
-0.0025314379,
0.0274336264,
-0.0429268144,
0.0058462531,
-0.0590869784,
-0.0445595086,
-0.0549906902,
0.0021936144,
0.0305798892,
0.0008098239,
-0.0398244932,
0.0070837736,
0.0280834511,
-0.0151924146,
-0.0070839887,
0.022362031,
0.0092091719,
0.0052279243,
0.0117853694,
-0.0051760073,
-0.0464991033,
0.0309013706,
-0.0042837495,
0.0323955305,
0.0091222245,
0.0021360244,
0.0408113971,
0.0041839932,
-0.0532907285,
0.0032851568,
-0.0380782485,
0.021111967,
-0.0613023005,
-0.0113816634,
0.0244834349,
0.0222909804,
-0.0290676709,
0.0534990244,
0.0023152856,
0.0248874668,
-0.0093699871,
-0.0573760234,
-0.026543865,
-0.045220308,
0.0056957006,
0.0215767398,
0.0055378024,
0.0160176475,
0.0126258899,
-0.0172409602,
0.0135699706,
0.0112866526,
2.585e-7,
0.0478063114,
0.0515518002,
0.0157861095,
-0.0000582179,
-0.005951345,
0.0523226447,
0.0062874546,
0.0123301251,
0.0311381016,
-0.0584571883,
-0.0100129107,
0.0333119296,
0.0607628152,
0.0270938296,
-0.1101329178,
-0.0350646228,
-0.0743169039,
-0.003741934,
-0.0323109552,
-0.0128170559,
0.0588508435,
0.060225524,
0.0399730168,
-0.0086133061,
-0.0128906509,
-0.0456442535,
0.0522406511,
-0.0447612517,
-0.0303032603,
0.0027714649,
0.059042301,
0.048617661,
0.0045084544,
-0.0135376146,
-0.0127312522,
-0.006178339,
0.0265178345,
0.0427449606,
0.0025575696,
-0.0472349748,
-0.0371279456,
-0.017120352,
0.0204051156,
-0.0349216312,
0.0787666664,
-0.0181111638,
-0.0156564843,
-0.0398343392,
-0.0141929602,
-0.0302845854,
0.0269383192,
-0.008098782,
-0.0284147561,
-0.0142496955,
-0.0047131586,
-0.014505107,
-0.0201805495,
-0.0630263239,
-0.0285589844,
-0.0301138349,
-0.0340589136,
-0.0095745381,
-0.0517021641,
-0.0102516972,
-0.0109013319,
-0.0358619019,
0.0030968674,
1.847895946e-34,
0.0259899646,
0.0109776612,
0.0291332584,
0.0187246464,
0.0507359691,
0.0498729609,
-0.0318477973,
-0.0155967893,
0.0245594252,
-0.0541463979,
0.0101095848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16839v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16839v3 | MaMMUT: A Simple Architecture for Joint Learning for MultiModal Tasks | 2023-03-29T16:42:30 | 2023-08-09T05:39:34 | Weicheng Kuo, AJ Piergiovanni, Dahun Kim, Xiyang Luo, Ben Caine, Wei Li, Abhijit Ogale, Luowei Zhou, Andrew Dai, Zhifeng Chen, Claire Cui, Anelia Angelova | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The development of language models have moved from encoder-decoder to
decoder-only designs. In addition, we observe that the two most popular
multimodal tasks, the generative and contrastive tasks, are nontrivial to
accommodate in one architecture, and further need adaptations for downstream
tasks. We propose a novel paradigm of training with a decoder-only model for
multimodal tasks, which is surprisingly effective in jointly learning of these
disparate vision-language tasks. This is done with a simple model, called
MaMMUT. It consists of a single vision encoder and a text decoder, and is able
to accommodate contrastive and generative learning by a novel two-pass approach
on the text decoder. We demonstrate that joint learning of these diverse
objectives is simple, effective, and maximizes the weight-sharing of the model
across these tasks. Furthermore, the same architecture enables straightforward
extensions to open-vocabulary object detection and video-language tasks. The
model tackles a diverse range of tasks, while being modest in capacity. Our
model achieves the state of the art on image-text and text-image retrieval,
video question answering and open-vocabulary detection tasks, outperforming
much larger and more extensively trained foundational models. It shows very
competitive results on VQA and Video Captioning, especially considering its
capacity. Ablations confirm the flexibility and advantages of our approach. | [
0.0343229994,
0.0815316886,
0.0170352478,
0.0495476276,
-0.0089456746,
0.0019509972,
0.0058895815,
-0.0022548398,
-0.0334718078,
-0.0906218439,
-0.0484371819,
-0.0439946018,
-0.0104151126,
0.0745186433,
0.0228487402,
-0.0569086857,
0.0285718311,
-0.0348555557,
-0.0159049425,
0.0014196013,
0.0323687084,
0.040336404,
-0.0064434814,
0.0155344326,
-0.0056539169,
-0.0035979024,
-0.0241981111,
0.0157264862,
0.0121201882,
-0.0134347472,
0.0115792314,
0.0355154499,
0.0681582168,
-0.001884513,
0.0000017602,
-0.005418092,
0.0176521167,
-0.0139440671,
0.0380658433,
-0.0112752588,
0.0656283647,
-0.0644247383,
0.0068654264,
0.032791499,
-0.0307385046,
-0.0583603196,
0.0698903427,
0.0163992774,
0.0546380505,
0.0412226431,
-0.0342442282,
-0.0564647615,
0.0367658772,
-0.0286965407,
0.0110987201,
-0.0276875161,
-0.0227344595,
-0.0029670072,
-0.0026017486,
0.0194332823,
-0.068465665,
0.0703621209,
0.0118011925,
0.0067746239,
0.014420297,
0.0550830215,
0.0133238761,
-0.038275402,
-0.0276418012,
0.0759912208,
-0.0036427719,
0.0128318742,
-0.0326308683,
0.0055229478,
0.0015172843,
-0.0044073537,
-0.0301990006,
0.0626764372,
-0.0222335793,
0.0258001275,
-0.0232305713,
-0.001831317,
-0.0124331051,
0.0140160695,
0.0025157835,
-0.0567590743,
0.0266630575,
0.0381659456,
-0.0038986492,
0.0395218506,
-0.0297283102,
-0.0380654708,
-0.0106248539,
0.0395109281,
0.007760901,
-0.0124074267,
-0.0442298166,
-0.0404579863,
-0.0183456093,
-0.0594727471,
0.0370350815,
0.0354846083,
-0.0687438399,
0.0667076632,
-0.0285920948,
0.0439593941,
-0.0283093099,
0.0204327647,
-0.0390172303,
-0.0243887957,
-0.0281536747,
-0.0190693289,
-0.0374395959,
0.0092748767,
-0.0560769401,
-0.0570498593,
0.0099178338,
0.0312258303,
0.0113129532,
-0.0192669574,
0.0019212813,
0.0348023735,
-0.0160710793,
-0.0111840861,
-0.011031691,
0.0722224265,
-0.0134790475,
0.0399473496,
-0.0049617663,
-0.0553023815,
-0.0198184475,
0.0450945348,
0.011107292,
-0.0350065753,
0.0001848548,
0.078607209,
-0.0823724493,
-0.0702153742,
-0.029836176,
0.0040563988,
-0.0258403756,
-0.0139533402,
0.0450322628,
-0.048239816,
0.035491962,
-0.0052344222,
0.0208472293,
-0.0301278923,
0.0138165802,
0.0188782681,
-0.0115917679,
0.1097331122,
0.0080116754,
-0.0391498953,
0.0530880392,
0.0188513249,
0.0081306817,
0.0841367543,
0.0236230399,
0.0134138782,
0.0043519344,
0.0223726872,
0.0275053717,
0.0329625644,
-0.0264918711,
0.0102355201,
-0.0384605303,
-0.0002923718,
0.0323872976,
0.0034092478,
0.0905500948,
0.0618420541,
-0.029716216,
-0.0147178853,
0.0614631847,
-0.0003454954,
-0.0166567061,
-0.0028232334,
0.0358958431,
-0.0093433121,
-0.0058910362,
0.0038576762,
-0.0144563448,
0.0756437406,
-0.0055178348,
-0.0189527813,
0.0354745947,
0.0280144997,
-0.0666373223,
-0.0314868428,
-0.0074797249,
-0.0472661257,
0.0091279438,
0.004691809,
0.0690366253,
0.0380372666,
-0.0671895891,
-0.0018719244,
0.0083283139,
-0.0122541832,
0.0227108039,
-0.0220713317,
0.0008945909,
0.0415385738,
0.0322824717,
0.0237366967,
0.0208051354,
-0.0114492597,
0.0272864178,
0.0502160378,
0.024077611,
-0.0079951193,
0.0378373042,
-0.0692849755,
-0.0381000862,
-0.0479489937,
-0.0043073683,
0.0124100912,
0.0102183549,
0.0102697071,
0.0039932514,
0.0085718753,
0.0240119435,
0.0404429398,
0.0313721597,
-0.0142901279,
-0.0170668736,
0.0016089304,
-0.0069951927,
-0.0203943513,
-0.028690692,
-0.0095147286,
-0.0005131615,
-0.0552397147,
-0.0036114415,
0.0172737837,
-0.0570985563,
-0.0732049048,
0.0047411611,
-0.0477357842,
0.0247327555,
0.0651304051,
-0.0313677527,
-0.0339021794,
0.0082589937,
-0.0397108346,
0.0049883365,
-0.0814965442,
-0.0193511937,
0.045335263,
0.019011341,
-0.0044585876,
0.0436780043,
-0.0422189906,
-0.0314366296,
-0.0196455456,
0.0177292731,
-0.0058930665,
-0.0376224741,
-0.0570768826,
0.0000831859,
0.0086280173,
0.0315127783,
-0.0055472837,
-0.0112665044,
-0.0126082785,
-0.0310526714,
-0.0653168336,
-0.0154566457,
-0.0237682369,
-0.023479823,
0.0208762046,
0.0037232467,
0.0272559579,
-0.044739712,
-0.019587161,
0.0244119093,
0.0250071567,
0.030333871,
0.0328793637,
0.0198672526,
0.0112002101,
-0.0158918034,
-0.0124749225,
0.0368300788,
0.0652092248,
-0.003055857,
-0.0254384317,
-0.0146382917,
0.0226574894,
-0.0068768421,
0.0438349694,
-0.0177619942,
-0.0377880335,
0.0128248166,
-0.0290867575,
0.031488765,
0.0490626022,
0.018489562,
0.0388190523,
0.0215806104,
-0.0004794303,
-0.0050564706,
0.0116509832,
0.0021250723,
-0.0565956868,
-0.0113544557,
-0.0019597735,
-0.0403592736,
0.0463926569,
-0.0200763866,
0.0181578454,
-0.0839014202,
-0.0067640925,
0.0072042961,
-0.0370884426,
-0.053566251,
0.0077841501,
-0.0094972095,
0.0034979163,
-0.0586908497,
-0.0505324528,
0.0153172361,
-0.013307468,
-0.0316076018,
-0.0015129565,
0.0098426603,
-0.0118907066,
0.0656159446,
0.0153380129,
0.0280147009,
-0.00216462,
-0.0281692166,
-0.0453798994,
-0.0152101396,
-0.0006411466,
-0.0173396692,
0.0448009372,
-0.0478002131,
0.0261054803,
-0.0351738073,
-0.0394214354,
-0.0244250409,
0.0146063026,
-0.0454349034,
0.0181292426,
-0.0405146368,
0.0108005339,
-0.0197487418,
0.0164078958,
0.0059039164,
0.0557346642,
0.0098998863,
0.0000734511,
-0.0127086462,
0.0434522443,
0.0593795367,
0.0379191265,
-0.0738897324,
-0.0785539448,
0.0093328757,
0.0662755445,
0.0126038399,
-0.0018622784,
-0.0348233618,
0.0465172976,
0.0394475572,
0.0349824838,
-0.0267189424,
0.0166088082,
0.0373390019,
-0.0345705338,
-0.0288076233,
0.0733750165,
0.008505729,
-0.0377931595,
-0.0306103993,
0.0151830548,
0.0145596573,
0.0392372422,
0.0033495165,
-0.0946852863,
-0.0758125111,
-0.0298615154,
0.0086352099,
0.0459030792,
0.0372666456,
-0.0425136425,
-0.0901045278,
0.0277837999,
0.0091892621,
-0.0427099392,
-0.028013492,
0.0171553753,
-0.0318098813,
-0.0230001267,
-0.0380870439,
0.0045139794,
0.0019180722,
0.011428968,
0.0110635553,
0.0406387374,
-0.0476016402,
0.0062747719,
-0.0460923538,
-0.0057586157,
0.0490623228,
-0.0372177474,
-0.0119797923,
-0.0397489741,
0.0369377434,
-0.0290659163,
0.0132656442,
-0.0128272045,
0.0736139789,
-0.0630941018,
-0.0312835388,
0.0093566766,
0.0086448891,
-0.0231409352,
-0.0415250696,
-0.0323621742,
0.0269930977,
-0.0035764747,
0.0037701235,
-0.0137522658,
0.0059552691,
0.0022348484,
0.0474779084,
-0.0042986562,
-0.0370082706,
-0.042659577,
-0.0091651492,
-0.034798786,
-0.0666282102,
-0.0267833658,
-0.0053238771,
0.0364929736,
-0.0052408464,
-0.0562530719,
-0.007424057,
0.0483971946,
0.0376032367,
-0.0309126582,
-0.010580061,
-0.0304746833,
0.0187306739,
-0.0773453787,
0.0341044851,
-0.0219740737,
0.0042934506,
-0.0638963729,
-0.0292318687,
0.0534363873,
-0.0394076407,
-0.0185347367,
0.0289023481,
-0.0578803048,
-0.0211967919,
-0.0597388409,
0.0742727444,
0.0157839525,
0.0328746885,
0.0095028998,
-0.0441082865,
0.0095792273,
0.0134788649,
0.0000105855,
0.052263204,
0.0189935025,
-0.0187487826,
-0.0153992744,
0.010781372,
-0.0319491997,
0.0059558251,
-0.0090742745,
0.0262283329,
-0.0034386509,
-0.01045697,
0.0193022247,
-0.0282373745,
0.0438686423,
-0.0164260566,
0.0376760364,
-0.0560331568,
0.0034033735,
0.0281206109,
0.0065533449,
-0.1065807417,
0.0316733606,
0.050461147,
0.0119349435,
0.0098228939,
0.0336260535,
0.0294376705,
0.0352000967,
-0.0232936721,
0.0054429155,
0.0420255512,
-0.0073298095,
-0.0146938516,
0.0189955328,
-0.0037314363,
0.0030114171,
-0.0114085516,
0.0333018713,
-0.0207855981,
0.0706647336,
0.0231123175,
-0.0158116911,
0.0024664041,
0.0416570045,
-0.0161472447,
-0.0025122478,
-0.0715297684,
0.042908296,
0.0318554118,
0.0125157246,
-0.003991426,
0.0013114959,
-0.0306756161,
-0.0386952795,
0.0459935293,
-0.0071111959,
-0.0522694327,
0.0632835627,
0.0090849511,
0.013622866,
-0.0289332084,
0.0771615431,
0.0076409429,
0.0450941473,
-0.0176326092,
0.0169849545,
-0.0342077576,
-0.0263274666,
0.0432834849,
0.0005471079,
-0.0055960761,
0.042584423,
-0.0005257652,
-0.0459363423,
-0.014086213,
0.0086646667,
-0.0036490757,
0.0311974213,
0.077409409,
0.0279211532,
0.0232623871,
-0.0348836519,
-0.0374929756,
-0.0199584719,
0.004244884,
0.0175960101,
0.0227312613,
-5.83844828e-33,
-0.0503487326,
0.0229939632,
0.0470504463,
-0.0353765301,
-0.0092437258,
0.0244848859,
-0.0168090072,
0.0324357264,
-0.0442969538,
-0.0214493368,
0.0529180206,
0.0029304849,
0.0032822606,
0.0546987019,
0.0023975705,
0.0022199324,
0.0364385024,
-0.0488119684,
-0.013051413,
-0.0176109336,
0.01831498,
0.0328386985,
0.0501174666,
-0.0173221529,
-0.0285202805,
0.0079041868,
-0.0460453108,
0.0293991286,
0.0260030925,
0.0715280175,
-0.0467387028,
0.023628857,
0.0205744337,
-0.0099932384,
-0.0277941879,
0.0272804555,
-0.1120836362,
0.0139852306,
0.0188357346,
0.0473873429,
-0.0931890458,
-0.014684082,
0.032586325,
-0.01354344,
0.0198127236,
-0.03715536,
0.0321751833,
-0.0223431438,
0.0200012233,
0.0221687555,
-0.0318970568,
-0.0045764786,
0.0160416104,
-0.0433964171,
0.036947865,
0.0330858082,
0.0345894732,
0.0035715222,
-0.0368401557,
0.0131285451,
-0.0161412917,
0.0415237211,
0.0708555281,
0.0559259839,
-0.0334876105,
0.0552632734,
-0.0020201132,
-0.0714352354,
-0.0379101522,
-0.0121917222,
0.0135241877,
0.0376372226,
0.0397312865,
0.05979966,
0.0384187028,
-0.0055054207,
-0.0463641211,
0.0195388757,
-0.0508850738,
0.0549086481,
0.0074134707,
0.0177251864,
0.0260247048,
-0.0060665691,
-0.0377584659,
-0.0046514617,
-0.0483240634,
-0.0002229136,
0.0577298515,
0.0581023656,
-0.0019594377,
0.011394917,
0.0880442858,
-0.0384700783,
0.0214979853,
0.0272242669,
-0.0129356626,
0.069524698,
0.0004104827,
0.030131992,
-0.0358236656,
-0.0143719381,
0.0783565417,
-0.0029689935,
-0.0278205089,
0.0206986684,
0.0239247326,
0.0439282618,
-0.0651765019,
-0.0011653269,
-0.0484795533,
0.0025990638,
0.0054238127,
0.061492268,
0.0140486592,
0.0052127917,
-0.0600482561,
0.0318934657,
-0.0435188636,
-0.0082908366,
-0.0442656465,
-0.0496642925,
0.0002217611,
0.0251438506,
-0.0083468677,
0.0444028191,
-0.0247559007,
-0.0245786365,
0.010812833,
-0.0433509201,
-0.021039309,
0.068652235,
2.425e-7,
0.0722848773,
-0.020319337,
0.0226517953,
0.0120214,
0.0101652974,
0.0410603806,
-0.0213819742,
0.0676804036,
-0.0096417423,
-0.0389085412,
-0.0125716245,
0.0700801611,
0.0290884376,
-0.0164110158,
-0.0221678559,
0.0378660224,
-0.012763924,
0.0208648648,
-0.0272105504,
-0.0222636107,
0.0701553896,
0.1028562263,
-0.0310628321,
-0.0036666812,
0.0110440273,
-0.0520001799,
0.1112489179,
0.0104754586,
0.0173734017,
-0.046733927,
-0.0218130574,
0.0290316399,
-0.0316459164,
0.0141696641,
-0.0076625906,
-0.0157350264,
0.0454250462,
0.0481925085,
-0.0200640112,
-0.05876242,
0.0094967103,
0.0393507779,
-0.0467227101,
-0.0175306257,
0.0954535455,
-0.0397779085,
-0.011330219,
-0.0200483259,
-0.0335502811,
0.018267924,
0.0131354183,
-0.0024174268,
-0.0512300543,
0.0048375069,
0.0433298685,
0.0087896949,
-0.0349922106,
-0.1038785353,
0.0079087168,
0.0000823976,
-0.0373544432,
-0.0183116868,
-0.0471300296,
-0.0056499084,
0.0245478377,
-0.0375925899,
-0.0519205444,
1.512778922e-34,
0.0185543895,
-0.0121690528,
-0.0091405762,
0.0275815614,
-0.0209325645,
-0.0126569644,
-0.0577913746,
-0.0076518385,
0.0098431921,
-0.0665078685,
-0.0332370959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16835v1 | Zero-shot Entailment of Leaderboards for Empirical AI Research | 2023-03-29T16:28:43 | 2023-03-29T16:28:43 | Salomon Kabongo, Jennifer D'Souza, Sören Auer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present a large-scale empirical investigation of the zero-shot learning
phenomena in a specific recognizing textual entailment (RTE) task category,
i.e. the automated mining of leaderboards for Empirical AI Research. The prior
reported state-of-the-art models for leaderboards extraction formulated as an
RTE task, in a non-zero-shot setting, are promising with above 90% reported
performances. However, a central research question remains unexamined: did the
models actually learn entailment? Thus, for the experiments in this paper, two
prior reported state-of-the-art models are tested out-of-the-box for their
ability to generalize or their capacity for entailment, given leaderboard
labels that were unseen during training. We hypothesize that if the models
learned entailment, their zero-shot performances can be expected to be
moderately high as well--perhaps, concretely, better than chance. As a result
of this work, a zero-shot labeled dataset is created via distant labeling
formulating the leaderboard extraction RTE task. | [
0.0325124227,
0.0362665318,
-0.0181133039,
0.0970958397,
-0.0376401059,
0.0429657623,
-0.0422175229,
0.0047045676,
0.0358242616,
-0.006125656,
-0.0104885129,
0.028207304,
-0.0333523527,
0.0172117762,
0.0065674013,
0.034622632,
0.0366991386,
0.0008411907,
0.0568041354,
0.0217026342,
0.0004509854,
0.0075716143,
-0.0507053137,
0.0130931251,
-0.0253985543,
0.0202203542,
-0.0066305976,
-0.0185457747,
0.0369408913,
-0.0308460109,
-0.0235879943,
0.0049807299,
0.0027285011,
0.0138610164,
0.0000018954,
-0.0545237549,
-0.0314910188,
-0.0450818874,
-0.0449838489,
-0.078331992,
-0.0720021352,
-0.0058465744,
0.0252687093,
-0.0288848896,
-0.0075780405,
0.0267794766,
0.0527532473,
0.0142458389,
0.0596479625,
0.0358286351,
-0.0194815975,
-0.0192014109,
0.0392178819,
-0.0037329558,
0.054713469,
-0.0291572381,
0.0305941608,
0.0185002014,
-0.0089874873,
-0.0404061973,
-0.0032819177,
0.0003336614,
-0.0105060171,
0.0127937375,
0.0044929637,
0.0568784662,
-0.0581464916,
-0.0094422596,
0.0360894427,
0.0991601944,
-0.0434340835,
-0.0266867261,
0.0452323444,
0.004332413,
-0.0135170761,
-0.001946284,
-0.0529513583,
0.0682320669,
-0.0262287743,
-0.0026324254,
0.0374245495,
0.0347660854,
-0.0020337396,
-0.0157108139,
-0.0441001356,
0.1031979471,
-0.0232194047,
-0.0521801449,
0.0169418193,
0.0383629054,
-0.0720941946,
-0.0523233674,
0.006917113,
0.0107919192,
-0.0153538175,
0.0594849028,
-0.0100240055,
-0.0168870818,
0.0146157863,
0.0137805231,
0.0079778461,
0.0036570188,
0.0178994834,
0.0753025636,
-0.0695850998,
0.0431417637,
0.0399386883,
0.036303468,
-0.0482065976,
-0.044486843,
-0.0598424263,
-0.0064304764,
-0.0080362456,
0.0770508647,
0.0544729792,
0.0033599271,
-0.0333786309,
-0.0019877907,
-0.0058548567,
0.0703346655,
-0.0271717962,
-0.0316372514,
-0.0051322179,
0.0178810898,
-0.0115737077,
-0.0053168866,
-0.0470883287,
0.0069816527,
0.0000625379,
-0.0081571713,
-0.018724829,
-0.0034473846,
0.0606370755,
0.0053278152,
0.0414329581,
0.0303840023,
0.0116878375,
-0.0449654981,
0.0348180234,
-0.0445963889,
-0.0164271109,
-0.0567554086,
0.0366101451,
-0.0571575984,
0.0438128151,
0.0086982762,
0.0300843865,
0.0438291579,
0.005874766,
0.037582472,
-0.0322900824,
0.041549027,
-0.0272816215,
0.0057036201,
0.005106742,
-0.0151115134,
-0.028162213,
0.0392728001,
0.0405842774,
0.0507170372,
0.0223972928,
0.0306465868,
0.0147551456,
0.0142342923,
0.0284265354,
-0.0246916749,
-0.0132964123,
0.0288671684,
-0.0055761067,
0.0029410257,
-0.0758495331,
0.0129593443,
-0.0306308288,
-0.0135447765,
0.0226229485,
0.076692529,
0.0255790185,
-0.069276996,
0.0004594225,
-0.0425317883,
0.0321290232,
-0.0058633653,
-0.018692553,
0.0249377862,
-0.0264695529,
0.0061198212,
-0.0052141761,
-0.0102305105,
-0.0076513365,
-0.0750441775,
-0.0135038337,
-0.0012691795,
-0.0626333281,
0.0348594375,
0.0737111047,
0.0161485933,
-0.0197097696,
-0.0298551824,
0.0229387544,
-0.0455906354,
0.0044258079,
-0.0542599671,
0.0404644199,
0.0200483259,
0.0469418392,
-0.0542781018,
-0.0432328545,
-0.0170778241,
0.0056539406,
0.0201040413,
-0.0606664047,
-0.0294657573,
0.0088655418,
-0.0253287032,
-0.000679019,
0.013034761,
0.0183586795,
0.0231588408,
-0.0307323039,
0.0121982303,
-0.0258415807,
-0.0404463038,
-0.0220668837,
0.0641945228,
0.0144065395,
-0.0134975147,
0.0193668921,
-0.0000403793,
0.020863995,
0.0013093442,
-0.0338773876,
-0.0046334299,
0.0494590588,
-0.0487705469,
-0.072758697,
-0.0355284512,
-0.0096158683,
-0.0691378117,
0.0230023488,
-0.098681882,
-0.0092098806,
0.0438058078,
-0.0464900285,
-0.0412639603,
-0.0323608033,
-0.0248936396,
-0.0015105999,
-0.0073215384,
0.0086853765,
-0.0089182714,
-0.0322675705,
-0.0503099561,
0.1008729264,
0.0272808783,
0.0375765301,
-0.0148513764,
-0.0237256195,
0.0111728953,
-0.0078959661,
-0.0293990262,
0.0467472225,
-0.0325439312,
-0.0173556749,
0.0397576727,
-0.0304724164,
-0.0350884683,
-0.0279747266,
-0.1032205522,
0.0426666327,
0.0071345484,
-0.0078296205,
0.0205273665,
-0.0365261212,
-0.0156078553,
-0.0194037668,
-0.0273562204,
-0.017336078,
0.0497344285,
0.0245795809,
0.0421587266,
0.0033768432,
-0.0147353765,
-0.043316517,
-0.0264088698,
-0.0436035097,
0.0563584045,
0.0282981321,
-0.0611047745,
-0.0092545096,
0.031820219,
-0.0713434443,
-0.0043008905,
-0.0173800103,
0.0167894363,
0.0223082416,
-0.0256743226,
0.0096023055,
0.0589564294,
0.0048853843,
-0.0050562327,
0.0568347722,
-0.0328243449,
-0.0037236083,
0.0139832571,
-0.0288950857,
-0.0246510357,
0.030208623,
-0.0310691949,
0.0699842572,
0.0816953629,
0.0260975547,
0.0022175233,
-0.0439390428,
0.0147573464,
-0.0207113028,
-0.003298129,
-0.0833563581,
0.0032077339,
0.0334593244,
0.0378234349,
-0.0254919492,
-0.0117598763,
0.060472399,
0.0132283084,
-0.0096551608,
-0.0229763798,
-0.0351114012,
-0.0332593508,
0.0430118479,
0.0530840382,
0.0225638729,
0.0492645204,
0.0070061465,
0.016170118,
-0.0021640048,
0.0403078832,
-0.027512636,
0.0164159406,
-0.0008259992,
0.0315536298,
-0.0262214653,
-0.0227251463,
-0.0389758572,
-0.0458630808,
-0.0187348407,
-0.0123888478,
-0.0589802191,
0.0210759081,
-0.0559537783,
-0.0086337365,
0.0518120453,
0.0108642587,
0.0053255917,
-0.027759295,
-0.0073894067,
0.0240020547,
0.076577872,
-0.0547906123,
-0.0028411194,
-0.0596650653,
0.0259814598,
0.0343305953,
0.0058369646,
0.039066758,
0.0425047204,
-0.0404792912,
-0.0121205989,
-0.0296683777,
-0.0082815737,
0.0389385894,
-0.0208912864,
-0.0053511779,
0.0229095481,
0.0877833962,
0.047898978,
-0.0027999931,
0.0002052589,
0.0162265487,
-0.0010097368,
0.0139128733,
-0.0190616529,
-0.0919877738,
-0.0286251809,
0.0117163006,
-0.0211698189,
-0.0240089707,
-0.0632944703,
-0.0125414198,
-0.0902346149,
0.0289680045,
-0.0204349719,
-0.0238931756,
-0.0054773749,
-0.0489212535,
0.0135740805,
-0.0166867208,
-0.085149996,
-0.018398745,
0.0162251014,
0.0268519819,
0.0104470737,
-0.0447504818,
-0.0081612151,
0.0348202251,
-0.0500037633,
0.0212055538,
0.0419085659,
0.0747568458,
-0.0183891915,
-0.0314962827,
-0.075002715,
-0.040219862,
-0.0406323969,
0.0096706394,
0.0683120415,
-0.0321126729,
0.0014693632,
-0.0153822852,
-0.0051519657,
-0.0287704803,
0.0077653811,
0.0924909636,
0.0588331334,
0.0015348016,
-0.0358492285,
-0.0127479909,
-0.0124771008,
-0.0355446599,
0.0622790568,
-0.0170101523,
0.0053628734,
-0.0173921008,
-0.0264462419,
0.0202177577,
-0.0364884473,
-0.0711379871,
0.002664132,
-0.001656009,
0.0310806688,
-0.0750976801,
-0.0298632048,
0.0149929561,
0.0387717187,
-0.0208020117,
0.0200616065,
-0.002251409,
0.0015329822,
-0.0437885746,
-0.0312034804,
-0.0591097325,
-0.0194157735,
-0.0176355336,
0.0114018489,
0.0739566162,
-0.0011316747,
-0.0251865666,
0.0066968706,
-0.0106379697,
-0.0050128973,
-0.0214178152,
0.023861764,
0.0148475487,
0.0098341564,
0.0020718419,
0.016396096,
0.0249955524,
0.0330837667,
0.017451711,
0.005470566,
-0.0021301899,
0.0179753471,
0.0080270953,
0.0157445278,
-0.0449505746,
0.085736841,
0.0201451369,
0.0246423148,
-0.0581833385,
0.026718339,
0.0452342667,
0.0349392481,
0.0844262093,
0.0284321681,
-0.0620296374,
-0.0129528772,
0.0075454302,
-0.0495900474,
-0.0375012122,
0.0015675483,
-0.0188561454,
0.0128467781,
0.019129103,
-0.0003448704,
0.0362420604,
-0.0120093133,
0.0397806242,
-0.0530718304,
-0.0136697209,
0.0127068292,
0.0340395235,
-0.0261066426,
-0.0311707482,
-0.0416288972,
-0.00985472,
0.0286990441,
0.0494432114,
0.0229711644,
-0.0083868196,
0.0427727252,
-0.0355479792,
-0.0095723756,
0.0256006848,
-0.0874304101,
0.0379701406,
-0.0131348511,
0.0160335172,
0.1045214683,
0.0194247216,
-0.0065921992,
0.0058593946,
0.0236939061,
0.0275863446,
-0.0115424655,
0.0133459028,
-0.0373911187,
-0.0140875336,
0.040466588,
-0.0074027674,
0.0114395702,
0.0378409587,
0.0349043049,
0.0543398038,
0.0060723769,
-0.0118456874,
-0.0388651304,
0.0029423388,
-0.0088843945,
0.0285520107,
0.0093960781,
0.0027900958,
-0.0251166262,
-0.0124818049,
0.0551472381,
0.0167118236,
0.0242098942,
0.0103424229,
-0.0099528283,
0.0293023326,
0.026584411,
-0.0338926949,
-0.0398389995,
-0.0017458056,
-0.0465533324,
0.014996266,
-0.0173226856,
-5.938658439e-33,
-0.0480076559,
-0.0639547855,
0.0157436896,
0.0260304641,
0.0143241119,
0.0524647459,
-0.0232244525,
-0.0292885732,
-0.0395473875,
0.0069520096,
-0.006850671,
0.006735147,
0.0126898531,
-0.0098251849,
0.0305626411,
-0.036314562,
0.0043477938,
-0.0112978276,
-0.0364486761,
-0.0070767258,
0.0661752671,
-0.0002828872,
0.0392452888,
-0.0682146773,
0.0223823041,
-0.0331229307,
-0.017952146,
0.0212710854,
-0.0090390565,
0.0167930312,
-0.0037371044,
0.013613645,
0.0450713299,
-0.0148086548,
0.0199362077,
0.0408622362,
-0.0707892627,
-0.0476959348,
-0.0337123834,
-0.0408353619,
-0.0386644267,
0.0327879712,
0.0141241867,
-0.0018335138,
0.0275582112,
-0.0196279585,
0.06597092,
-0.0141458102,
0.0234006979,
-0.0352256447,
-0.0679808408,
0.0243428294,
-0.0153229702,
0.0034816351,
0.0242255162,
0.0841661766,
0.0185526963,
-0.0011673931,
-0.0563554242,
0.0330935977,
-0.0348146223,
-0.000012549,
0.0396230854,
0.041589167,
0.0021807977,
0.0818684846,
0.0478107445,
0.0314474292,
-0.0226336904,
-0.0215944555,
0.0250893869,
0.024092216,
0.080954425,
0.0045343996,
0.068412289,
0.0685430542,
-0.1033211425,
0.0155620044,
0.052402202,
-0.0283845942,
-0.010066703,
0.0065960973,
-0.0629118159,
0.002192931,
-0.0022834495,
0.0152825993,
-0.0296409279,
0.0057418193,
0.0251788106,
-0.0069204532,
-0.0173873827,
0.0115711531,
0.0143359201,
0.0074060061,
0.0195940062,
0.0024590311,
0.0276392344,
0.0362809189,
-0.0068527963,
0.0081431186,
-0.0907859132,
-0.008880592,
0.0055948179,
0.0439403206,
0.0268606823,
0.0072080237,
0.0578987487,
-0.0010947968,
-0.0179176088,
-0.0222915858,
-0.0018580065,
0.000805737,
-0.0360543989,
-0.041011095,
0.0309102032,
0.0080607319,
-0.0048386464,
0.0443406627,
-0.0093474826,
-0.0250493046,
-0.0233874358,
0.0636373907,
-0.0356412083,
-0.0130819026,
-0.010861462,
-0.0375594497,
-0.0282116495,
0.0324536972,
-0.0013993958,
-0.0399141833,
0.0077648116,
-0.0050056768,
2.612e-7,
-0.010548613,
0.0419279225,
-0.0089406213,
-0.0029907241,
-0.0069427546,
0.0287656728,
-0.03528101,
0.0032832806,
0.0405475721,
-0.0102493009,
0.0352123976,
0.0339869075,
0.0135652106,
0.068461962,
-0.0875189602,
-0.0573970415,
-0.0318289623,
-0.0694516227,
-0.0544068404,
0.0326256938,
0.074817352,
0.0217337348,
0.0348556153,
0.0050412361,
-0.0141757941,
-0.0577757321,
0.0301599354,
0.031918712,
0.0232933126,
0.0101794573,
-0.0187743064,
0.0115785692,
-0.0397876091,
0.0734168217,
0.0188317522,
0.0388841517,
0.0623850413,
0.032705646,
-0.0263640694,
0.0262679923,
-0.0202637538,
0.0290083922,
0.0104945013,
-0.0091058156,
0.1042395011,
-0.0696749985,
-0.0529571809,
-0.0393470414,
-0.0332580023,
0.0072827111,
0.020438958,
0.0082205227,
-0.0289814807,
0.0013213187,
-0.0013307078,
0.00796647,
-0.0253572296,
-0.050776694,
0.013233955,
0.0241154358,
-0.0107039521,
-0.0200974327,
-0.0112564946,
0.0161573961,
-0.0223389249,
-0.0781397298,
0.0048817429,
2.488242361e-34,
-0.0267896038,
-0.0247031376,
0.0184264686,
-0.0432278179,
0.0443886742,
-0.0069959136,
-0.0654302686,
0.0047381059,
0.0389047414,
-0.0647854209,
0.0157799013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16742v1 | Evaluating NLG systems: A brief introduction | 2023-03-29T14:49:29 | 2023-03-29T14:49:29 | Emiel van Miltenburg | cs.CL | cs.CL | This year the International Conference on Natural Language Generation (INLG)
will feature an award for the paper with the best evaluation. The purpose of
this award is to provide an incentive for NLG researchers to pay more attention
to the way they assess the output of their systems. This essay provides a short
introduction to evaluation in NLG, explaining key terms and distinctions. | [
0.0369763821,
0.0189345479,
0.0111159412,
0.0296069551,
-0.0609457083,
-0.0004533397,
0.0310962871,
-0.0143983494,
-0.0252272878,
-0.0510338768,
-0.0013445675,
-0.0232418887,
-0.009227315,
0.0371003151,
0.0158845,
-0.0516601652,
0.0150623303,
-0.0040516611,
-0.0139503777,
0.0347997025,
0.0205884855,
0.0111078229,
-0.0075427233,
0.0700770319,
0.0075848438,
0.0067493799,
-0.0006667671,
-0.0010694723,
0.0177058112,
-0.0940163359,
-0.0232467502,
-0.0207272507,
-0.0233976524,
-0.0032806632,
0.0000017162,
-0.0763551816,
0.0051710452,
-0.0021998105,
-0.0027695431,
0.0339279734,
0.065429002,
-0.0113138119,
-0.0077634966,
-0.0220154021,
-0.0208038352,
0.0171157476,
0.0222666524,
0.0121043548,
0.0739927739,
0.0387714691,
0.0062193079,
-0.0227941126,
-0.0478137732,
0.0038709033,
-0.0278572738,
-0.020981444,
-0.0455452912,
0.0092860591,
0.0365455709,
-0.0375601873,
0.0468223318,
0.0476446562,
-0.0185593404,
-0.0308778938,
0.0418418087,
0.0150844464,
-0.0152556151,
-0.0309316181,
-0.0151668712,
0.0473859943,
0.0177405514,
0.0026045763,
0.0155334771,
-0.0238564666,
0.011595062,
-0.0415988564,
-0.0286630336,
0.0453245565,
0.0013895049,
-0.0018555655,
0.0221948661,
0.0736604333,
-0.0085463086,
0.033034116,
0.0257593635,
0.0482805744,
0.0238186996,
0.0094360746,
-0.0349724963,
0.0174121298,
-0.0091456333,
-0.0510502867,
0.0057453085,
0.0511216111,
-0.0602391399,
0.0089015495,
-0.0083534569,
-0.008778126,
0.0206266269,
-0.0546511598,
0.0606787093,
-0.0151570169,
0.0593893416,
-0.005883819,
0.0210541915,
0.0410413221,
0.0235209409,
0.0012706991,
-0.0659578517,
0.0288926587,
-0.0435231701,
0.0039850855,
-0.0832203329,
0.0735504776,
-0.0332954228,
-0.0470356755,
-0.0668573231,
-0.0396955498,
-0.0168487951,
-0.0204768162,
0.0097088963,
0.0393564403,
-0.052124843,
0.030785501,
-0.029862117,
0.0062498632,
-0.038721662,
-0.0082527772,
0.0385398269,
-0.0164777208,
0.027283892,
0.0450845174,
0.0103134168,
0.0142264599,
-0.0106485793,
0.0789695829,
0.023751013,
-0.0190298539,
-0.0422411822,
-0.0544424355,
-0.0283403806,
-0.0771602541,
-0.0575877354,
-0.0666691065,
-0.0019523193,
0.0207637139,
-0.001068567,
0.0064298376,
0.0164110232,
0.0140089756,
0.0263271146,
0.0222576223,
-0.0233017132,
-0.0087817721,
0.0162494704,
0.0144105265,
0.0279327948,
0.0394385755,
0.0497703664,
0.0531337671,
0.0421984829,
0.0018373391,
0.0322221853,
0.0319784842,
-0.0106266262,
-0.0466773063,
0.0129018342,
-0.0174333882,
-0.0512409098,
0.0245381258,
-0.0187415108,
0.066654034,
-0.0134192016,
0.0567899197,
-0.002680673,
0.0095439954,
0.0417826138,
0.0261669997,
0.0898412317,
-0.0051193563,
0.0138687072,
-0.0033704166,
0.0347965918,
0.0009680485,
-0.025469467,
0.0395544395,
0.0038438777,
0.0397565775,
0.0209227689,
-0.0639067292,
-0.0284908991,
0.0229003243,
0.0321450271,
-0.0410949513,
0.0556064099,
0.05369642,
-0.0416818634,
0.0098756598,
-0.0123300785,
-0.0838699713,
0.0670510307,
-0.0456384532,
-0.0045266761,
0.0589483269,
0.0846876502,
0.0596836582,
0.0007624906,
0.0278637446,
-0.0419292413,
0.0646418259,
-0.0055117188,
-0.0142996497,
-0.0067074769,
-0.0052463436,
-0.0009329152,
0.0139110722,
0.0114788003,
0.0115255984,
-0.0313315354,
0.0362718888,
0.0396126285,
0.0304238107,
-0.0742707402,
0.0289921612,
0.0210111868,
-0.0165136158,
-0.0117756398,
-0.0261757486,
0.0331235565,
0.0616500378,
-0.0437956378,
0.0719452798,
0.0252762306,
-0.0278814193,
-0.0185274985,
0.0480324477,
0.0124935741,
-0.0360194929,
0.0047753002,
-0.0867320001,
0.0386932157,
-0.0048898743,
-0.0085077947,
-0.0178701188,
0.0481586792,
-0.0688958094,
0.0265589301,
-0.0293219667,
0.053989891,
0.0225417446,
-0.0423438326,
-0.0741515234,
0.0532810688,
0.0325222351,
0.0244205128,
0.0131408907,
0.0204523243,
0.0535174944,
-0.0528320484,
-0.0346517749,
0.0605921447,
-0.0233085286,
-0.0032775963,
0.0526679941,
0.0428527035,
-0.0669683889,
-0.030694874,
-0.0669579059,
-0.0049265618,
-0.0150401928,
0.077233009,
0.0396160409,
-0.022340335,
0.0091336314,
0.0208128411,
-0.013648699,
-0.0090762135,
0.0865897983,
-0.0395851582,
0.0330207646,
0.0320907347,
-0.0307291243,
-0.0419321917,
0.0171976164,
0.0170581415,
0.047346469,
0.0716751888,
-0.0266581848,
-0.0778542608,
0.0125332223,
-0.0449140109,
-0.0447276942,
0.0247725639,
-0.0583784021,
0.0342842303,
0.0275109969,
-0.0082996851,
0.0053571886,
0.0470048822,
0.0441126116,
-0.0080475993,
-0.0335044265,
-0.0143993041,
-0.0391031578,
-0.0210792702,
0.0201762579,
0.0250654649,
0.0051253592,
0.0403467976,
0.0340224616,
0.0449623838,
0.0102356393,
-0.0158054121,
0.0416671596,
-0.0927730054,
-0.0427212678,
-0.0455593504,
-0.0287530683,
-0.0169110075,
0.0406079963,
0.0030297104,
-0.0296850856,
0.0482684895,
-0.0313581899,
0.0038949875,
-0.0805059075,
-0.0107626691,
-0.028862169,
0.0420091525,
-0.0177231748,
0.039067544,
0.0080705471,
-0.0260914378,
-0.0296500362,
0.0051446124,
0.0205967166,
-0.0232531223,
0.0318563543,
-0.0554665439,
-0.0126930699,
-0.0087286746,
-0.0142886192,
-0.0432651155,
-0.0401322357,
-0.0165126082,
-0.0026558975,
0.0783305317,
0.0031424703,
-0.0181350037,
0.0494606644,
0.0345061682,
-0.0329730213,
-0.0078991856,
-0.0090105822,
0.0090259109,
0.051465556,
0.0622178093,
-0.014878165,
0.0079744244,
0.0554726161,
0.0029990873,
0.023997983,
0.012539654,
0.050228145,
-0.023137765,
0.0197494179,
0.0141822603,
-0.0531827435,
-0.0251923874,
0.0219565909,
0.0220507756,
-0.036280483,
-0.0273462161,
0.0902075171,
0.0511021949,
0.0180289149,
0.0109361904,
0.0228160508,
0.0350703038,
-0.0091530401,
-0.0009578931,
-0.0674800426,
0.0045244056,
-0.0157020539,
0.0324526988,
0.0044215624,
0.005656661,
-0.0019055025,
-0.1005727351,
0.0368882865,
0.0341109037,
-0.0335467421,
-0.0275063198,
-0.001248961,
-0.07049907,
-0.0235798322,
-0.0324244127,
0.0222083982,
-0.0338083431,
0.0545913316,
0.0498853587,
-0.0525148138,
-0.0251878221,
-0.0241220631,
-0.0279318951,
0.0534563549,
0.0673865303,
0.0275285225,
0.0213620439,
-0.033955913,
-0.0063950098,
-0.0357774533,
0.0199053194,
-0.0139253475,
0.0056507806,
0.0081007751,
-0.0183124132,
-0.0677581951,
-0.0342230015,
-0.0218451452,
0.0148226498,
0.0070396629,
0.0326640531,
-0.0174142309,
-0.0049755867,
-0.0291844439,
0.0380254388,
0.0346965082,
0.0655432716,
0.0310183689,
-0.0287315752,
-0.0535246469,
-0.0255584568,
-0.0012525814,
-0.0853929967,
-0.0332883634,
0.0375796258,
-0.0110785337,
-0.032315813,
-0.1105709523,
-0.0706038326,
-0.0099454904,
0.0303240195,
-0.0077883848,
-0.0101783555,
-0.0202685371,
0.0189944077,
-0.0298014171,
0.0062661055,
0.0117476033,
0.0101249646,
-0.0476479009,
-0.0242065042,
0.0363557152,
0.0075323116,
-0.0269820262,
0.0725657493,
-0.0644405186,
-0.0560175814,
0.0084984293,
0.0325122327,
0.0232721139,
-0.0053016669,
-0.0319566503,
0.0000806354,
0.0104140053,
0.039122425,
-0.0054290583,
0.0004123285,
-0.0140364133,
0.0371223725,
-0.0132958414,
-0.0001590615,
-0.0208998937,
0.0132280523,
-0.0255850945,
0.0532366298,
0.0227375124,
-0.032266032,
0.0071438681,
0.0634680539,
-0.0006938563,
-0.107871674,
-0.0583228432,
0.0302118063,
-0.0617681444,
-0.0472009033,
-0.0382056721,
-0.0602957122,
-0.0197393075,
-0.0010814448,
0.0272159111,
-0.027695965,
0.037690796,
-0.0594034344,
0.0263384748,
0.0128410012,
0.0383662805,
0.0159135759,
-0.0059983716,
-0.0065737017,
-0.002391824,
-0.0313713737,
-0.0381161496,
-0.0353870913,
0.004462494,
-0.0371147767,
0.0452913754,
0.0219412651,
-0.0038329284,
-0.0021764406,
0.0640271306,
0.0135733178,
0.0389807485,
-0.0738892406,
-0.0016500752,
0.0713420883,
0.0202725008,
0.1059609056,
-0.0133773135,
0.0205704346,
-0.0050474959,
0.0583495758,
0.010022698,
-0.0520652272,
0.0069958274,
-0.011457284,
-0.017120881,
-0.0572683439,
0.066207394,
0.0036424659,
-0.0070449505,
-0.0011105095,
-0.0175139718,
-0.0485458262,
-0.0164917205,
-0.0402485169,
-0.0155407321,
-0.0045982949,
0.0173618142,
-0.073200658,
-0.0347360224,
-0.0308303554,
0.0569705516,
0.0701907352,
0.0083811833,
0.0900591165,
0.029035354,
-0.0041724276,
-0.0183421001,
-0.0363398679,
0.0073022689,
-0.0203632135,
0.0054315827,
-0.0440106131,
-6.051660548e-33,
-0.0346208625,
-0.0622689575,
0.0106625799,
0.0092837559,
-0.0484192334,
-0.0425649248,
-0.0348963402,
0.0584069379,
0.0311048739,
0.0140295336,
0.0126721812,
-0.0457215533,
0.0187410042,
0.0062718973,
0.005900674,
-0.028724039,
0.0162012633,
-0.0147180147,
-0.0560475737,
0.0040106564,
0.0103128124,
-0.0001458797,
0.0810673758,
-0.0553666465,
0.0422915034,
-0.0195939075,
-0.0544405654,
-0.0438493378,
0.035995163,
0.0516953655,
-0.013121726,
0.0177945197,
0.0242828839,
-0.0431462713,
0.0020358183,
-0.0076238825,
-0.0277447365,
-0.0118802199,
0.0098243728,
0.0057979366,
-0.0315477438,
-0.0159581434,
0.0214777868,
-0.0224866122,
-0.0746558458,
0.0573219247,
0.0148377465,
-0.0251359213,
0.0040799435,
-0.0317554213,
-0.065484643,
0.029972719,
-0.0070040221,
-0.0034158935,
-0.0005569246,
0.0360858366,
-0.0505694076,
-0.0360907651,
-0.0187955238,
0.0186795387,
0.0196914691,
0.0098919729,
0.0923211351,
0.0170908626,
-0.037504863,
0.0370013788,
-0.0142711382,
-0.011865682,
-0.0437591858,
0.0183228347,
0.0003779111,
0.0189766586,
0.0583844297,
0.0299684908,
0.0345378108,
0.0373542048,
-0.0703223199,
0.0535897054,
-0.0078237373,
0.0198393241,
-0.0325551406,
-0.0197299905,
-0.0239777919,
-0.0141642066,
-0.0342762992,
-0.0348427147,
-0.0133386338,
-0.0618308373,
0.0558537692,
-0.0098396679,
-0.0226462353,
0.0092494581,
0.0096558612,
0.0015674127,
-0.0368411615,
0.023545254,
0.0243265592,
0.0092087341,
-0.0153670032,
-0.0354761854,
-0.0323171243,
0.0121556232,
0.0000244216,
0.0857745484,
0.0193447825,
-0.0549582131,
0.0056644506,
0.0071218312,
-0.0250171162,
0.0403564982,
-0.0155284684,
0.0306544397,
0.0146105485,
-0.0344866775,
-0.0015566031,
-0.058164034,
-0.0371624939,
0.0147097837,
0.0012905598,
-0.0068392563,
0.0027686497,
0.003217438,
0.0337455124,
0.0086693075,
-0.0298828389,
0.0323558822,
-0.0334810838,
0.0197308622,
0.035196282,
0.0302188937,
-0.016287636,
-0.0246343669,
2.519e-7,
0.0291596986,
0.0351651385,
0.0349584818,
0.0410656296,
-0.0105810994,
-0.0034981861,
-0.0000324512,
0.0186640937,
-0.008274707,
0.0343752019,
-0.0154658267,
-0.0336307213,
0.0120146405,
-0.0157122146,
-0.0601394847,
-0.0186347701,
-0.0695101395,
0.0052111037,
-0.0339581296,
-0.0035088577,
0.0755596831,
0.0352026708,
-0.0186594501,
0.043517638,
-0.0237021819,
-0.0626693889,
0.0206540152,
0.0011230975,
-0.0149529809,
0.0336662941,
0.078538239,
-0.0079586096,
0.0207220092,
-0.0158821288,
-0.0180462729,
-0.0222191531,
0.0410186201,
0.021430105,
-0.0097255195,
-0.0092717474,
0.011524857,
0.0061784051,
0.024310302,
-0.048954241,
0.0205950309,
-0.0319712535,
-0.0154981716,
-0.0139073506,
-0.0251364578,
-0.000543672,
0.0020207493,
-0.021588603,
-0.0391233973,
0.0321391709,
0.02698192,
0.0105357263,
-0.0143115073,
-0.0379716903,
-0.054200802,
-0.0025033909,
0.0008920108,
-0.0479681678,
-0.0145569397,
0.0330230445,
0.0113290381,
-0.0443973467,
-0.0119699845,
1.39561554e-34,
0.0273973271,
-0.0069240355,
0.0167471468,
-0.005043854,
0.066643104,
0.0177849289,
-0.0516175441,
-0.0059331525,
0.0216733459,
-0.0314381197,
-0.006188428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16726v1 | Text revision in Scientific Writing Assistance: An Overview | 2023-03-29T14:25:30 | 2023-03-29T14:25:30 | Léane Jourdan, Florian Boudin, Richard Dufour, Nicolas Hernandez | cs.CL | cs.CL | Writing a scientific article is a challenging task as it is a highly codified
genre. Good writing skills are essential to properly convey ideas and results
of research work. Since the majority of scientific articles are currently
written in English, this exercise is all the more difficult for non-native
English speakers as they additionally have to face language issues. This
article aims to provide an overview of text revision in writing assistance in
the scientific domain.
We will examine the specificities of scientific writing, including the format
and conventions commonly used in research articles.
Additionally, this overview will explore the various types of writing
assistance tools available for text revision. Despite the evolution of the
technology behind these tools through the years, from rule-based approaches to
deep neural-based ones, challenges still exist (tools' accessibility, limited
consideration of the context, inexplicit use of discursive information, etc.) | [
0.0435407199,
-0.0315297805,
-0.0022380489,
-0.0518009029,
-0.0764251351,
-0.0173326749,
0.0630528778,
0.0109561067,
-0.0170127228,
-0.063190423,
-0.0063945833,
-0.0224798787,
0.0460674986,
0.0042306711,
0.0185046587,
-0.0470688157,
0.0394714251,
0.0076902076,
0.0510609597,
0.0225254502,
0.0216311831,
0.0153486216,
-0.0066334717,
0.0294134673,
0.0311794896,
-0.0769600645,
0.0212684982,
0.0165644642,
0.0077337823,
-0.029882323,
0.040476948,
0.0904656202,
0.0282893181,
0.052865535,
0.0000019759,
-0.0035540503,
-0.0174107496,
0.0461793803,
0.0187377315,
0.036614202,
0.0484885611,
-0.0298968945,
-0.0176947173,
0.0164960064,
-0.0114574637,
-0.0200080704,
0.081600666,
0.0176602323,
0.0038332348,
0.0475641228,
-0.0141991638,
-0.0157296322,
0.0531562269,
0.0045730849,
0.0006859121,
0.0766857266,
0.0308475941,
0.0076812366,
0.0140458755,
0.0494582541,
0.020576857,
0.0468055531,
0.0057355906,
-0.0899178907,
0.0295163654,
-0.0019883714,
-0.0114662172,
-0.0132716382,
0.0187315959,
-0.0100957453,
0.0893456042,
-0.0371629857,
-0.0155849066,
0.0055766017,
-0.0559000969,
0.0315588713,
-0.0574988164,
-0.0188626722,
-0.0070151426,
-0.0380616076,
0.0159356911,
-0.0651311353,
-0.0117674349,
0.0355614536,
0.034871567,
0.0103275776,
0.0145640085,
-0.0398509391,
-0.0248245224,
-0.0029655227,
0.0338193364,
-0.0619601384,
0.0400720909,
0.0223233383,
-0.0166630801,
-0.0237991437,
-0.0459129252,
-0.0942062661,
0.0233747382,
-0.0152213071,
0.0563568473,
0.0072762887,
0.0163637511,
-0.0387137011,
0.0164174959,
-0.0076829116,
-0.0123763466,
0.0125753358,
0.0379998684,
0.06047564,
-0.0235579573,
-0.0462312363,
-0.0238263234,
-0.0397842005,
-0.0216505174,
0.0024304606,
-0.0521197617,
-0.0360951871,
0.020723613,
0.0134629505,
-0.0130867148,
0.0009211384,
-0.067059271,
0.0156380814,
0.0374384597,
0.0245037787,
0.0365411676,
0.0329901129,
0.0162737276,
-0.0054528536,
-0.00191378,
0.0113872867,
0.0071034716,
-0.0342885144,
-0.051904086,
0.0207095481,
0.0150514171,
0.0081929145,
0.0224911794,
-0.0183028542,
0.0027113694,
-0.0187966861,
-0.0295084529,
-0.0305604748,
0.0236447994,
-0.0025507591,
-0.010549847,
-0.0730855092,
0.0010773446,
0.0366107635,
-0.0129460376,
0.010479752,
-0.0965039954,
-0.023196375,
0.058712773,
-0.0088401577,
0.0209193286,
-0.0661566034,
0.0393892042,
-0.0452115834,
0.0253256746,
-0.0118451295,
0.0188493524,
-0.025800189,
-0.0320372842,
-0.0136696436,
0.0002213989,
-0.0001041277,
-0.0046669696,
0.0985152796,
-0.015402534,
0.0234975014,
-0.0338323116,
0.0576201379,
0.0774416625,
0.0248313863,
0.0448319577,
0.0279757548,
0.0059957239,
-0.0170041826,
0.0365473367,
0.0086045386,
-0.0372561514,
0.0603032857,
0.0000210334,
0.0206460413,
-0.0554460511,
0.014683323,
0.0098019419,
-0.0337847732,
-0.0310268141,
0.0505632684,
-0.0181355514,
-0.031254895,
-0.0039870143,
0.0056461408,
0.0065264115,
-0.0422347002,
0.0051294593,
-0.0286694374,
0.0308167133,
0.0371537767,
0.0131622329,
0.0812920481,
0.0628938675,
-0.0423565395,
-0.0260018166,
-0.0447860919,
0.0135228038,
0.0530532785,
0.0037880936,
-0.0035100647,
-0.0223761238,
-0.0656415373,
0.001704223,
-0.048362866,
-0.0158640798,
-0.0244654976,
-0.0096783964,
0.0285446197,
0.0196678396,
0.0175397284,
-0.0399619676,
0.0347382836,
-0.0271529984,
-0.0162535589,
0.0137718171,
-0.0314380042,
-0.0113100037,
0.0180368666,
-0.0517856739,
0.0520860292,
-0.0079595065,
-0.0015427159,
-0.013084461,
0.0410057269,
0.0483972095,
-0.0055763377,
-0.0016422926,
-0.0730640739,
0.029975852,
0.0176658295,
0.0119648706,
-0.0130753405,
-0.0164319985,
-0.0395064838,
0.0202332977,
-0.0131248049,
0.0056198342,
-0.0198914427,
-0.0214181766,
-0.0169815216,
-0.0460710041,
0.023485912,
0.0195022449,
0.0322545469,
-0.0320420489,
0.0043562939,
-0.0368108265,
-0.0371606909,
0.0069222581,
0.0275243632,
-0.0235399716,
0.0142868254,
-0.0282863956,
-0.0177608673,
-0.0129412143,
-0.0155927427,
0.0205228459,
-0.010985272,
0.0246180631,
0.0176573191,
-0.0418828949,
-0.0072810864,
0.0033996296,
0.0277154893,
-0.0237867553,
-0.0273622759,
0.0296145789,
0.0762838721,
-0.0099074785,
0.0291963816,
-0.0534917153,
-0.0335406139,
-0.0137251001,
0.0229747165,
0.0549116842,
-0.0707774535,
-0.0677241683,
0.0339866057,
0.0166010857,
-0.0426716357,
0.0348646902,
-0.0352320336,
0.0152104842,
0.0347378477,
0.0514541455,
0.0572385006,
0.0039219707,
0.0139360316,
0.0861711651,
0.0109807923,
0.0164195206,
-0.0487369299,
0.0104958825,
0.0560575947,
0.0358250476,
-0.0521643199,
0.0535581931,
0.0018665311,
0.0087261386,
-0.0221620109,
-0.0094207134,
0.0504532307,
-0.0447989777,
-0.0026078739,
0.0331691913,
-0.0207345244,
-0.0127227772,
0.0259118844,
0.0060838475,
-0.0259678308,
0.0576029867,
0.0147425737,
-0.0004830632,
-0.0852935538,
-0.0167225692,
-0.0102224201,
-0.0081702676,
-0.0352578573,
0.002701621,
0.0321206376,
-0.0098677762,
-0.0264078416,
-0.0291196164,
0.0379759707,
0.0309230443,
-0.0279427972,
-0.0684837624,
0.0044542411,
-0.0150377313,
-0.0072434423,
0.0457305387,
-0.0250532031,
0.0255292095,
0.0576238446,
0.034829244,
-0.0269874185,
-0.0562713109,
0.014759548,
0.0788888112,
0.0740186647,
-0.0522166677,
0.0113521004,
-0.0353588089,
-0.0247549806,
0.0213690326,
-0.0523145162,
0.0028950574,
-0.0289520081,
0.0099949446,
0.0408709422,
-0.0539316349,
0.0022131882,
-0.0264149643,
-0.0417754389,
0.0047917464,
-0.0754200444,
-0.0768740699,
-0.0147548579,
0.0441295393,
-0.0404355079,
-0.0134326434,
0.0745430291,
-0.0076004402,
-0.05077089,
-0.0125152478,
-0.0711199939,
-0.0296102427,
0.0021829372,
0.0405597202,
-0.0687304959,
0.0499441437,
-0.0009834253,
0.0324803479,
-0.0179018639,
-0.0492325611,
-0.0106306942,
0.0289697405,
0.0531166531,
0.0169585254,
-0.0761148185,
-0.0055803945,
-0.0593238622,
0.0064504491,
0.017302515,
-0.0048018233,
0.0175618995,
0.0157866795,
0.0152527131,
0.0289677009,
-0.0605516508,
-0.0539323241,
-0.0676844046,
-0.055638548,
0.0333846249,
0.0055368617,
0.0278423503,
0.0033255576,
0.0079486826,
-0.0161261577,
0.0039803879,
0.0050430987,
-0.0403642952,
0.0103141852,
-0.0025471637,
0.0214214046,
-0.0337423459,
0.0515438654,
0.0202927999,
-0.0770191774,
0.0338003151,
0.0599016808,
-0.0526060723,
0.0105372714,
-0.061217811,
0.0212398712,
0.0340072513,
0.0144917658,
0.0354094841,
-0.018878527,
-0.0412826054,
-0.0146708423,
0.0496778637,
-0.0439113937,
0.0159688964,
-0.0718399584,
-0.0992037207,
0.0175119638,
-0.0571326427,
-0.0475010425,
0.0608299971,
0.0684379861,
0.0842938274,
0.0196071323,
-0.0038777294,
-0.0163281355,
-0.0434276573,
-0.0135109089,
0.0302186776,
0.0354931019,
0.0069514923,
-0.0431855097,
0.0218255259,
0.0219677202,
0.0098775402,
-0.0336487293,
0.062609829,
-0.0652933568,
0.0079271626,
0.0293611009,
0.018593058,
-0.0147335781,
0.0292481389,
-0.10748218,
-0.0246640425,
-0.0207778234,
0.0234388057,
0.0309731085,
-0.037164297,
-0.0395260826,
-0.0227674805,
-0.0276360121,
0.0078447964,
-0.0111502921,
-0.0083297212,
0.0289553739,
-0.0272492673,
-0.0330714509,
0.0258715879,
0.0059780851,
0.038155172,
-0.0356600508,
0.0092341704,
-0.0543757714,
0.0203463081,
-0.0487295724,
-0.0207044519,
-0.0135035571,
0.0292919409,
0.0171760656,
0.0228069145,
-0.0306487456,
0.0447953567,
-0.0915219188,
-0.006949177,
-0.0378507525,
0.0973742306,
0.0272045545,
0.0593464933,
0.0427416526,
0.0276006702,
-0.0489371605,
-0.0021627783,
-0.0618924238,
0.0229051337,
0.0181968138,
0.0174708199,
0.0245744102,
-0.0015775553,
-0.0321697742,
0.0056449636,
-0.0855152458,
0.0278703049,
-0.028262211,
0.0098664891,
-0.0109434361,
-0.0031432679,
0.0345329084,
-0.0253183153,
-0.0355630182,
-0.0282840412,
0.0904690027,
0.0261780787,
0.0102252318,
0.0268170126,
-0.0267955512,
0.0195701178,
-0.064149797,
0.0331733264,
0.0031230536,
0.0202953294,
-0.0016871229,
-0.068761006,
-0.0061927,
-0.0383398421,
0.0045433044,
-0.0018578405,
0.0165280011,
-0.0844501331,
-0.026936302,
0.0079240175,
0.0371029601,
0.0069555198,
-0.0162418224,
-0.0413939878,
-0.036960274,
0.0082323225,
0.004310518,
-0.0634983256,
-0.021103302,
0.071772933,
-0.0412730463,
-0.0447744876,
-0.0439893194,
-4.986854051e-33,
0.0119571546,
-0.0377464108,
0.0210764818,
0.0320517048,
-0.0368340015,
0.0282938872,
-0.064077653,
-0.0093345316,
0.0321193635,
0.0496418849,
-0.0302701145,
-0.0017044876,
-0.0034386155,
-0.0100746341,
0.0163274296,
0.0588733926,
0.0622917116,
-0.0101531502,
0.0008544165,
-0.012988409,
0.00358174,
0.0099023832,
0.0955025703,
-0.0488399826,
0.0896982104,
-0.0331059583,
0.0025579799,
0.004279823,
0.0144199291,
0.0151577583,
0.0116503062,
-0.0230903048,
0.0073821917,
-0.0019753,
-0.0327117555,
0.0375809558,
-0.0271859467,
0.0056585204,
0.0455564931,
0.0233151428,
-0.0086879535,
-0.0635689795,
0.0229367111,
-0.0223829523,
-0.0345692672,
0.0065031131,
0.047342401,
0.0053844368,
-0.0295618903,
-0.0309575945,
-0.0619807839,
0.0168870799,
-0.0138883898,
0.0405289643,
-0.0127487099,
0.0321324393,
-0.0119353058,
-0.0227636863,
-0.039633207,
0.0244594216,
0.0376260951,
0.0330530368,
0.0028919822,
-0.0212683342,
-0.0071413685,
0.0258490462,
-0.0045415447,
0.0540772974,
0.0099453013,
0.0018280498,
0.0043491893,
0.0003233861,
0.0792113096,
0.0854149312,
0.0423650332,
0.0051349141,
-0.0499356538,
0.0134923868,
-0.0131274676,
0.0253753196,
0.0180195812,
0.0124693234,
0.0381627977,
-0.0566155165,
-0.0300048906,
-0.0173663553,
0.0012837978,
-0.0585825033,
0.0071732975,
-0.055714298,
0.0038971649,
0.0397170298,
-0.0172830354,
0.0075009386,
0.0291751642,
-0.0155309271,
-0.0057765045,
0.0761276782,
-0.022201268,
-0.0104492195,
-0.0570341498,
0.0006913649,
0.0168145169,
0.0348958895,
0.0396771692,
-0.0254014079,
0.0174139906,
0.0124938535,
-0.0215693749,
-0.0054851812,
0.0364178047,
0.0192930959,
0.037029393,
0.0033906442,
-0.0340960175,
0.0179291517,
0.0303148422,
0.0161796343,
0.0342870019,
0.0199957322,
0.0144828809,
0.0126634389,
0.0378939137,
0.0148220388,
-0.002732032,
0.0060816882,
0.0146546131,
0.0345292501,
0.0088055525,
-0.0273239035,
0.0066371327,
-0.0153281521,
2.53e-7,
0.0757042021,
0.0878415331,
0.0574399792,
-0.0535989963,
0.0195491407,
-0.039128609,
-0.0067606065,
0.0303690378,
-0.009809087,
0.0562480576,
0.0403913707,
-0.0282292645,
0.0071334378,
0.0162596479,
-0.037743751,
-0.0441445336,
-0.0646641776,
-0.0036227237,
-0.0563233308,
-0.0091909869,
0.0214972515,
-0.0507238619,
-0.0237316843,
0.0028921859,
-0.0490682311,
-0.0085377833,
0.0331605747,
-0.0255871881,
0.0302201845,
0.0126400432,
0.0111121135,
-0.0080230432,
0.0236720629,
0.0255004652,
-0.0293718036,
-0.0654105023,
0.0137632592,
0.0513885766,
-0.0128629515,
0.0651230514,
0.0380853303,
0.0482854955,
0.0058878884,
-0.0446229726,
0.0163465627,
0.0030072297,
-0.0165778697,
-0.0388117991,
-0.0219570436,
-0.0176117364,
0.0550871566,
-0.041778896,
0.0080613941,
0.0220508855,
-0.0042933351,
0.0341628045,
-0.0270295367,
0.0162584838,
-0.0348533541,
0.046729628,
0.006091346,
-0.0052594757,
-0.0382536799,
-0.0473495536,
0.011549959,
-0.0705071688,
-0.0020317107,
2.427598102e-34,
0.04650243,
-0.0375631079,
0.0119735813,
0.0512671247,
-0.0017153025,
0.0121926069,
0.043264363,
0.0396335497,
-0.0077698436,
-0.0312043112,
-0.0235632807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16694v1 | Using Semantic Similarity and Text Embedding to Measure the Social Media Echo of Strategic Communications | 2023-03-29T13:46:07 | 2023-03-29T13:46:07 | Tristan J. B. Cann, Ben Dennes, Travis Coan, Saffron O'Neill, Hywel T. P. Williams | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | Online discourse covers a wide range of topics and many actors tailor their
content to impact online discussions through carefully crafted messages and
targeted campaigns. Yet the scale and diversity of online media content make it
difficult to evaluate the impact of a particular message. In this paper, we
present a new technique that leverages semantic similarity to quantify the
change in the discussion after a particular message has been published. We use
a set of press releases from environmental organisations and tweets from the
climate change debate to show that our novel approach reveals a heavy-tailed
distribution of response in online discourse to strategic communications. | [
0.0460487604,
0.0393895134,
-0.0042635994,
0.0149504393,
-0.0305115189,
-0.0220346414,
-0.0592516474,
0.0152199008,
-0.0315872878,
-0.0561665855,
0.0519060865,
0.0244176779,
-0.0055186995,
0.027512705,
0.0031071682,
-0.020352805,
-0.0000900523,
0.0651560873,
0.0126379449,
-0.0150714349,
0.0708106011,
-0.0145438528,
0.0133118127,
0.0505062565,
0.0201089066,
-0.0016136779,
-0.0000354686,
-0.0013332039,
0.0531444065,
-0.0241935942,
-0.0284801479,
0.0242285039,
0.0760677159,
0.0657444671,
0.0000015294,
-0.0189585891,
-0.004251665,
-0.0410520993,
0.0425123535,
0.033278849,
0.1069046408,
-0.0038673205,
0.0164230652,
0.0302051064,
-0.0373343267,
0.0093623763,
0.045666419,
-0.0125520481,
0.0360101573,
0.0414264947,
0.0033095723,
-0.0195211787,
-0.0068189576,
0.0021520439,
-0.0017784691,
0.0018090201,
0.0169460867,
-0.0454758555,
-0.0587981455,
0.0479672588,
0.0150129758,
0.052110821,
-0.0423045643,
-0.0011280144,
0.0040105046,
0.0275369436,
-0.0126860794,
0.0341978446,
-0.0096866479,
0.010720755,
0.0586726479,
-0.0123963896,
0.0290154126,
-0.020407334,
0.0123074036,
0.050816413,
-0.0562918521,
-0.0026603986,
0.0545757599,
0.0400500037,
-0.0011829488,
0.0397923551,
0.0084088603,
0.0225379448,
0.0022809987,
0.0318567269,
-0.0220862739,
-0.0444902405,
-0.0081160218,
0.0114052901,
0.0335602537,
-0.0259496309,
-0.0417088121,
-0.0062154694,
0.0058855368,
0.011074448,
-0.0144786946,
-0.0239208899,
0.022627607,
-0.1244159415,
0.0145172002,
-0.0007204474,
0.02408427,
0.0561734177,
0.0017620632,
-0.0294636134,
-0.0024820359,
0.0031832235,
0.0114599792,
0.0134329908,
-0.0939722881,
0.0032643029,
0.0152864577,
-0.0007798551,
0.0182495415,
-0.0233593006,
-0.0050052996,
0.011778377,
-0.0554909445,
0.0227913186,
-0.037182644,
0.0159972925,
0.0330657624,
0.0017664387,
0.0058645071,
0.0252662245,
-0.0479335487,
0.0275783464,
-0.0133715272,
0.0255983286,
0.0172401052,
0.0155409332,
0.060919106,
0.0363309979,
-0.0224660747,
0.0679404661,
-0.0047566597,
-0.0081542823,
-0.0078524966,
-0.0157683138,
0.007564045,
0.0157113038,
-0.0130493632,
-0.0482620038,
0.003429957,
-0.0197449662,
0.012009087,
0.01373534,
-0.0104843127,
0.0113974679,
-0.06331563,
0.0285011046,
0.0161386933,
0.0127677051,
0.0349452756,
0.0236767959,
0.0333627909,
0.0977361575,
0.0199541561,
0.0196836311,
0.068853274,
0.0281212013,
-0.0638699904,
0.0064689592,
0.0157096926,
0.0019861758,
0.0013263753,
-0.0185349099,
-0.0585846044,
0.0012505917,
-0.0158207659,
-0.0011431728,
-0.0162203666,
-0.0135514066,
0.0208591726,
0.0692991465,
-0.015753068,
-0.0331502222,
-0.0056443154,
0.0488966741,
-0.0729798302,
0.0262595266,
0.0462323651,
-0.0211371016,
-0.0118390024,
-0.0275748651,
0.0665291995,
-0.0330946594,
-0.0398503505,
0.0075157457,
0.0150162829,
0.0217787847,
0.0310570467,
-0.0298773255,
-0.0316020213,
-0.0389974155,
-0.007535331,
0.056362506,
0.0225098301,
-0.0172144007,
0.0130193559,
0.0166964941,
0.0062438431,
0.0225706436,
-0.0034464633,
-0.0153214345,
0.0256425906,
-0.0313522741,
0.0217703022,
0.0442071445,
-0.0001205736,
0.009891808,
-0.0587075949,
-0.0003695763,
-0.0132120159,
-0.0552883856,
0.0244093128,
0.0208993256,
0.0201222263,
0.0534770936,
0.0143134808,
-0.0126685007,
0.0331253856,
0.0303230435,
0.038293872,
0.000107875,
-0.0111754751,
0.0103334514,
0.0536832027,
0.0535842665,
-0.0284169503,
0.0008992606,
0.0318679512,
-0.0354056992,
-0.0866882503,
-0.0003126319,
0.0122111933,
0.060345713,
0.0269937534,
-0.0769527927,
-0.0517605878,
0.017247254,
-0.0418791175,
0.0089933183,
0.0899792984,
-0.0264500435,
0.0339842364,
-0.0253024735,
-0.0644571707,
-0.0675194412,
-0.0119835697,
-0.0224571154,
0.0259811543,
-0.0314276777,
0.0410597622,
-0.0469628274,
-0.0309923999,
0.006017108,
-0.0005803749,
-0.0120951794,
-0.0166034065,
-0.0055666165,
0.013906152,
0.0384197906,
-0.0499737896,
-0.0308193583,
-0.0303602591,
-0.0676242709,
-0.0087393681,
-0.0516937226,
0.025322549,
0.0527341142,
-0.0101179359,
0.0130417235,
0.0501143038,
-0.0092659527,
-0.01142665,
-0.0233417079,
0.0399816595,
0.0190328732,
-0.0110700633,
0.0307128336,
-0.0458826125,
-0.0050508631,
-0.0287467986,
0.0704149976,
0.0407463722,
-0.0381895453,
-0.0343275405,
0.0093239509,
-0.0595868416,
-0.020136971,
-0.022678351,
-0.0117574437,
0.0151072452,
0.0041989116,
0.0118947485,
-0.0222976413,
0.0853283703,
0.0727001801,
0.0155398091,
0.0428828038,
-0.0451391749,
-0.0449867956,
-0.0721342042,
0.0072354679,
-0.0719614103,
-0.0240189508,
0.0535839759,
-0.007114511,
-0.0010198338,
0.013237414,
-0.0148136634,
0.0341314599,
-0.025987329,
-0.0137304105,
-0.0628511757,
-0.0253934748,
-0.0121550234,
0.0332801342,
0.0399774089,
-0.0059620519,
-0.0009686615,
0.0124973636,
0.0701575726,
-0.0350541398,
-0.0876849517,
-0.0130040608,
0.064287059,
-0.0133686177,
0.0110859703,
-0.014774479,
0.009053044,
0.0032248138,
-0.0724789351,
0.0568193197,
-0.0104843779,
-0.000478915,
0.0175988786,
0.0227240995,
0.0167511385,
0.0021462415,
0.0055212718,
-0.0947222188,
-0.0358037911,
-0.0016142257,
0.0469241031,
-0.0460390933,
-0.0376176834,
0.0233685561,
0.0287930723,
-0.0454618149,
0.0480822548,
-0.036737293,
-0.0018312969,
0.0492558964,
0.0179782454,
-0.0038683394,
0.0140653979,
0.0170576442,
-0.0209189393,
0.0361980125,
0.0007720361,
-0.0374693871,
-0.0687081963,
-0.0508706532,
-0.0345530733,
-0.0431847498,
0.04475604,
-0.0215124991,
0.006751976,
-0.00680529,
0.0450947061,
0.0571410246,
0.0469854884,
0.0186574236,
0.0135195935,
-0.0087400367,
0.0161371958,
0.0069546392,
-0.0118990606,
-0.0908055156,
0.0031266899,
-0.0023199343,
-0.0422332324,
-0.0301750749,
-0.03547851,
-0.0206749365,
-0.0509487614,
0.0210587364,
-0.015704155,
0.0156846419,
0.020288026,
-0.0734898597,
0.0139879147,
-0.0009668594,
-0.0838150904,
-0.0401255637,
-0.0062464979,
-0.0080301035,
-0.0068234191,
-0.0464153402,
-0.0002929842,
0.0038155057,
-0.0222489797,
-0.0090823518,
0.0256686155,
0.0696031675,
-0.0262719523,
-0.0282542966,
0.042160593,
-0.012999529,
-0.0352316611,
0.009953795,
0.028587563,
-0.0178491026,
0.0245505609,
-0.0020805351,
0.018317569,
0.0064317873,
-0.0084394459,
0.0071113324,
0.0284053087,
0.006850292,
-0.0464986227,
-0.016492771,
0.0495530516,
0.0408944376,
0.0357755423,
0.0218993165,
0.0023039619,
-0.044450935,
-0.0137775578,
0.0497701988,
0.0228481125,
-0.0221688244,
-0.0401323214,
-0.0052142688,
-0.0374516957,
-0.0378893279,
-0.0146301053,
-0.0168010481,
0.0087752445,
-0.0263162963,
0.0196374543,
0.0892420188,
-0.0180106871,
-0.0254642218,
-0.0294907484,
-0.0236682277,
0.0450372696,
0.0250149705,
-0.0000590026,
0.0428250097,
0.0967085883,
-0.054788731,
-0.0275105853,
-0.0783763081,
-0.0809958726,
-0.0211452395,
-0.0554162487,
0.0130763277,
-0.010379062,
0.0114143584,
-0.0020617449,
0.074565649,
0.0667162016,
-0.0022554002,
-0.0041485652,
0.018518649,
0.0323262177,
0.017993534,
0.0286055245,
0.0094748288,
-0.0014261035,
-0.0002494368,
0.0016733346,
-0.0541838445,
-0.0035453222,
-0.0159255546,
-0.041263707,
0.0503113456,
0.02997813,
-0.0623840094,
-0.0513386466,
-0.0322066881,
-0.0063677728,
-0.0052694627,
-0.0194836315,
-0.0387063175,
-0.0117097208,
-0.0047110957,
-0.0450742021,
0.0514745302,
-0.0395295285,
0.0542390794,
-0.0494754687,
0.0413497463,
0.009982313,
0.0380308032,
-0.0121751418,
-0.0056755664,
-0.032864999,
-0.0280500408,
-0.0043442501,
-0.0103189601,
0.0153555572,
-0.0452467576,
0.0218769163,
0.0158352051,
0.0036729197,
0.0188535415,
-0.0849009752,
-0.0356438272,
0.0076905596,
0.0102063268,
0.0185956862,
0.0096287215,
0.0031129746,
-0.0061906176,
-0.0176874101,
0.016130235,
0.0137471408,
-0.0353606045,
-0.037709184,
0.0253664162,
-0.0031533039,
-0.0403698757,
0.0347581133,
0.0356113613,
-0.0234730504,
0.0283927508,
0.0118157221,
-0.0668730661,
0.0138040632,
-0.0586774945,
0.0233274493,
0.0651568845,
0.0235273,
0.0093949735,
-0.0388454683,
-0.0069559128,
0.0456725173,
0.0076430799,
-0.0149620222,
0.0324401818,
0.0111492425,
0.0246407315,
0.0027792826,
0.0458893329,
-0.0368314274,
0.0046831099,
-0.0529553033,
-0.0787964016,
-0.0097174654,
-6.169686425e-33,
0.0231015738,
-0.0305448472,
-0.0142854247,
0.033434581,
-0.0370299965,
0.0532740392,
0.0219141096,
0.0205047261,
-0.0188507736,
0.0266245827,
0.0253957957,
0.0215695929,
0.0089954631,
-0.0131508727,
0.0039492929,
-0.0089390175,
0.0194288101,
-0.0198254641,
-0.0164905433,
0.0076461132,
0.0730637312,
-0.0352305621,
0.0021212378,
-0.0682903007,
0.0129400715,
0.0090479758,
0.0068477583,
-0.015395538,
0.0672536641,
-0.0234924853,
-0.0009615135,
0.0366069227,
0.0500977114,
-0.0477757156,
0.0015569244,
0.0915014222,
-0.009970489,
-0.0787665248,
0.0281855147,
-0.075129576,
-0.0106024668,
0.0595703647,
-0.0008358839,
0.0431433097,
-0.0115298284,
-0.0093917735,
0.026931623,
0.0332368687,
-0.0004203935,
-0.0058646668,
-0.062741749,
0.0363033488,
-0.0643640459,
0.0618426502,
-0.0104066078,
-0.0068654777,
0.0545569211,
0.1001420468,
-0.088566564,
0.0360710621,
-0.0370986499,
0.001239963,
0.0073121567,
-0.0120320721,
-0.0057440875,
0.0859699473,
-0.0282177124,
0.0083046239,
-0.0110593932,
-0.0155486921,
-0.023512423,
-0.0197929963,
0.0080040824,
0.0758424401,
0.024243312,
-0.0616075955,
-0.0889656246,
0.021010682,
0.0503213592,
0.0303241499,
0.0572431795,
0.0294054952,
0.0237991791,
0.0005870066,
-0.0472570211,
0.0248069242,
-0.0201858357,
-0.0349239893,
-0.0320894048,
0.0315514766,
-0.0105435103,
0.0364881381,
0.0356598347,
-0.0397748016,
-0.0406650193,
0.0289128888,
-0.0154978512,
0.0387007631,
0.0271858759,
-0.0080945855,
-0.033063978,
-0.0158890337,
0.0006856776,
0.0281683598,
0.0067404718,
-0.0760637745,
0.0169010032,
-0.036872346,
-0.0475459509,
0.0079325521,
0.0114196502,
-0.0451973267,
-0.0536895692,
-0.0790152326,
-0.0226443671,
0.0419235751,
0.0216741264,
0.0089346273,
0.0246658679,
-0.0047411439,
0.0558427386,
-0.0127031645,
-0.0486808233,
0.0080199139,
-0.0426981412,
0.0131853586,
-0.0178685747,
0.0341682024,
-0.0144491252,
-0.0206215363,
-0.010136894,
-0.0458828472,
2.396e-7,
0.0521027893,
0.0246477909,
-0.0144536169,
0.012223308,
0.0371844172,
0.0288495813,
0.0342607945,
0.0542816222,
-0.0375290103,
-0.0594641827,
-0.007266162,
-0.0059819422,
0.0018992211,
0.0188498218,
-0.0291848965,
0.0010860068,
-0.1091698408,
-0.0353905037,
-0.0375691988,
-0.0143243968,
0.0434602574,
0.0281412043,
0.030280374,
0.036831934,
-0.0301072933,
-0.0088145835,
0.0533185452,
-0.057729125,
-0.0155202998,
0.0032318805,
-0.0254661068,
-0.0570176989,
0.0105408207,
0.0012837157,
-0.0348500572,
-0.0124131897,
0.0128603801,
-0.0219769701,
0.0587318428,
0.000577645,
-0.0165745933,
-0.0149151562,
0.0116398754,
-0.0407189354,
0.0058988868,
-0.0930300504,
-0.0524904504,
-0.1026992649,
-0.0273481105,
0.0164196603,
0.0676797032,
0.0000422267,
-0.0505376905,
0.0197498146,
-0.0293144975,
0.0177597962,
0.0071171648,
-0.0653472468,
0.0519023612,
0.0062609338,
-0.0307690017,
-0.0133095356,
0.0024398172,
-0.0172256473,
0.0626283064,
0.0066320775,
0.0671171248,
1.364926184e-34,
0.0427080542,
0.0225323159,
-0.0352743268,
-0.027812602,
0.0444726981,
0.041084189,
0.0123840887,
0.0082351845,
0.0300591569,
-0.04423365,
0.0442274809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16657v1 | Summarizing Indian Languages using Multilingual Transformers based Models | 2023-03-29T13:05:17 | 2023-03-29T13:05:17 | Dhaval Taunk, Vasudeva Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advent of multilingual models like mBART, mT5, IndicBART etc.,
summarization in low resource Indian languages is getting a lot of attention
now a days. But still the number of datasets is low in number. In this work, we
(Team HakunaMatata) study how these multilingual models perform on the datasets
which have Indian languages as source and target text while performing
summarization. We experimented with IndicBART and mT5 models to perform the
experiments and report the ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2, ROUGE-3 and ROUGE-4 scores as a
performance metric. | [
0.0311576854,
-0.0015282755,
0.0116896648,
0.0312671289,
-0.0435267128,
0.0018661639,
-0.024294287,
-0.0134235872,
-0.0425918214,
-0.0306961183,
-0.023442287,
-0.0288928933,
0.0417476669,
-0.0049807634,
-0.0070705502,
-0.0920163319,
0.02648299,
-0.0192391984,
-0.0356909707,
-0.0054387185,
0.0501564778,
0.0218400005,
0.0047687725,
0.037712466,
-0.0043519693,
0.0056546493,
0.0404891483,
-0.0066234074,
0.0155976778,
-0.0023883567,
0.0013801801,
0.0295113362,
-0.0050746929,
0.0248507187,
0.0000017897,
-0.0759795085,
-0.0496725813,
0.001357166,
0.0538301989,
0.0230034254,
0.0562330112,
-0.0329325758,
0.0237545725,
0.0415843353,
0.0099471249,
0.0532798283,
0.0345128328,
0.0490266681,
0.0661824644,
0.0542410314,
-0.0144334352,
-0.0782679766,
0.0087245991,
0.0090467995,
-0.0536802709,
0.0062672761,
-0.0107221818,
0.0340871662,
-0.0015347481,
-0.0226633903,
-0.0088676037,
0.0331981927,
-0.0071743573,
-0.0117399311,
-0.0431687944,
0.0046515213,
-0.0279207192,
-0.0164227486,
0.0506291427,
0.0251959935,
-0.0278080516,
-0.0121638775,
0.0210592709,
0.0476630554,
-0.0325033665,
0.010034305,
-0.0884085149,
0.0359645225,
-0.0316754915,
0.0392551422,
0.0298577547,
0.0370160677,
-0.0260451548,
0.0134836063,
0.0033775615,
0.0089464318,
0.0199201852,
-0.0015869755,
-0.0484614708,
-0.0095609734,
-0.0194692183,
0.01450653,
0.018815456,
0.0174508486,
-0.0330068767,
0.0009589831,
-0.0325238928,
-0.072698243,
0.0113511514,
-0.0137856985,
-0.0146327671,
0.0168422125,
0.0123469923,
0.0060329512,
-0.0055781365,
0.0147444764,
0.0064433236,
0.0414472148,
-0.054687649,
-0.0524569415,
0.0096304994,
-0.0359943993,
-0.00733699,
0.0278525893,
-0.0303114299,
0.0255084522,
-0.0764375255,
-0.0070305164,
0.0206874125,
-0.0536467955,
0.0278190561,
-0.0364966951,
-0.0203723088,
-0.0109622469,
0.027003387,
0.0440189466,
-0.0184720065,
-0.0303028487,
0.0017199359,
-0.0637899265,
-0.0028289948,
0.0079395864,
-0.0183838792,
-0.0147502758,
-0.0064529502,
0.0549363717,
-0.0414073728,
-0.0295307059,
-0.0250600167,
0.0175939202,
0.0056970948,
-0.0745145455,
-0.0215063225,
-0.0923834443,
-0.0081695933,
0.0446304344,
0.0081167892,
0.0086552529,
0.000995965,
0.0133725079,
-0.0350023992,
0.0344631001,
-0.01784827,
0.0306346975,
0.0418224968,
0.0215549339,
0.0339668393,
0.0611135401,
0.0286932401,
0.0052908477,
0.0636878833,
-0.0095707765,
0.0209670067,
0.073068589,
-0.0289589129,
0.0015722368,
0.0031666458,
-0.0197597593,
-0.0445639938,
-0.0306609832,
0.0212026667,
0.065553993,
-0.0212557483,
0.0575669594,
0.0465853028,
0.056162402,
0.0509408861,
0.0261777099,
-0.0175177455,
0.0254506934,
0.0439019911,
0.0584469624,
0.0243446995,
0.0301763341,
-0.0451507457,
0.0532951355,
0.0840047374,
0.0395333245,
-0.0144960079,
-0.0199422222,
-0.00937647,
-0.0259053838,
0.0058700526,
-0.0018729061,
0.0679168478,
-0.0043766294,
-0.0263294727,
0.0289351735,
0.0372522697,
-0.0714348853,
0.0288214087,
-0.0461730212,
-0.0073626991,
-0.0087248189,
0.0334122367,
-0.0461955294,
-0.0031994565,
-0.0016483057,
-0.0503354892,
0.0205810685,
0.0254463386,
-0.0123596694,
-0.0266549271,
-0.0590967834,
0.0091140568,
0.0457553044,
0.001178789,
-0.0071320115,
-0.0285990462,
-0.0065843333,
0.021765573,
-0.0007620475,
-0.0337802693,
0.0209941659,
-0.0205792524,
0.0588984862,
-0.0376727432,
-0.0145644033,
0.0407897644,
0.0147745544,
-0.0105154999,
-0.0021578446,
0.0156750344,
-0.0012838088,
0.0021017694,
0.039265871,
-0.0040788786,
-0.0173870809,
0.0393131301,
-0.1141896248,
0.0305396672,
0.0785789937,
0.0042540971,
-0.0716325492,
0.0176205449,
-0.0519509502,
-0.0311619695,
-0.0363906212,
0.0288568512,
-0.0174239501,
0.0032444312,
-0.0249179229,
0.0560041294,
0.0074384501,
0.0341240428,
0.0603408739,
-0.0251772702,
0.0463681221,
-0.0119232368,
-0.0249034204,
0.0297602192,
0.0154512525,
0.0263526663,
0.0673969164,
0.0204532854,
-0.031166371,
-0.0310873855,
-0.0896003768,
-0.0222535003,
-0.0340861715,
0.0089797303,
0.0306055006,
0.0533731766,
0.000347608,
-0.0002395583,
0.0041652559,
-0.0595469885,
0.0743875206,
0.018026052,
0.0340715833,
-0.0148072829,
0.0340632834,
-0.0381176434,
-0.0352683254,
0.0234826282,
0.0604547486,
-0.008372114,
-0.0690444261,
-0.0221103039,
-0.0079362048,
-0.0228163954,
-0.0459881425,
0.0036039599,
-0.0406468846,
-0.050124418,
-0.006054298,
0.069745183,
-0.0112648671,
0.0374634862,
-0.0160198268,
-0.0060013481,
-0.007137069,
0.0019144444,
-0.0248100217,
-0.0048286789,
0.0147597324,
-0.0046807965,
-0.0414563976,
0.0178963449,
0.0474801771,
0.0085452162,
-0.0197901651,
-0.0162627231,
-0.029085448,
-0.0582137108,
0.0278091598,
-0.0325180441,
0.0360995792,
-0.0373338349,
0.0714402124,
-0.010906863,
-0.0109357452,
0.0408306122,
-0.0276703741,
0.0060307672,
-0.0982069001,
-0.0062741255,
-0.0662245378,
0.0083170859,
0.0185616016,
0.0192338824,
-0.0322943181,
-0.0377296694,
-0.0422283523,
0.0166595429,
0.0347324237,
-0.0320627317,
0.0923587456,
-0.055584196,
0.0136423558,
-0.0458265021,
0.0204158872,
0.0130451489,
-0.0281172507,
0.0099711427,
0.0169190243,
0.0578554347,
0.0146577787,
-0.0319962837,
0.0807824358,
0.0594693683,
0.0515437275,
-0.0365918763,
0.0047582784,
0.0466410331,
0.0512977764,
0.0645334572,
0.0030326019,
0.0174053088,
-0.0234991908,
0.0376965813,
-0.0161196962,
0.0329632796,
-0.0408507213,
0.032060314,
-0.0195458457,
0.0227107275,
-0.0643124431,
-0.0132895773,
-0.0127663193,
0.0352874696,
0.0192968659,
-0.0039015033,
0.0775860548,
0.0307998061,
0.0049172831,
-0.0268786885,
-0.0500271693,
0.0260523837,
0.0008565768,
-0.005268618,
-0.0636137053,
0.0009689752,
0.0141054997,
-0.01220694,
0.0254027341,
-0.0076152463,
0.0024897896,
-0.0878975466,
-0.0059717558,
-0.0241304338,
-0.0877924562,
-0.0498816371,
-0.0246070623,
-0.0071145422,
-0.0332260132,
0.0204094201,
0.0361508839,
-0.0504878871,
0.0019909027,
0.0370300636,
-0.0620748885,
-0.0119654667,
-0.0427191481,
-0.0123678967,
-0.0405778028,
0.0292091873,
0.0092700636,
-0.0619414523,
0.0383103192,
0.0129350256,
-0.0456233509,
-0.0426233187,
-0.0019473357,
0.0655125082,
0.0246969089,
-0.0144278491,
-0.0211597048,
0.0353564471,
0.037708573,
0.007446039,
-0.0155596361,
0.0013556825,
0.0419074409,
-0.0093079116,
-0.019260563,
0.0207166933,
-0.0644232631,
0.0182573907,
0.0379556455,
-0.0095573245,
-0.0128480699,
-0.0434517264,
-0.0114158625,
-0.0583989099,
-0.0718652084,
0.0419141836,
-0.0600938387,
-0.1066203713,
-0.0414075591,
-0.0870926455,
0.0316515267,
-0.0060246116,
0.0042239204,
0.0346526243,
-0.0135734165,
0.0434517451,
-0.024860736,
-0.0180941746,
-0.0279617235,
0.0192274991,
-0.0656697303,
0.006108575,
0.0579431802,
-0.0260592718,
-0.0359579027,
-0.0211478937,
-0.0453232005,
-0.0411010571,
0.0042724274,
0.0542486943,
0.0281360634,
0.0010848135,
-0.0038108709,
-0.0250788499,
0.0449436121,
0.001854385,
-0.0056459736,
0.0002293102,
0.0113128256,
0.0085732751,
-0.0222566165,
0.026576275,
-0.0729960874,
0.0516834967,
-0.0505155101,
0.033020936,
-0.0200428739,
-0.0280644689,
0.0340337604,
0.0798315331,
0.0067600701,
-0.0708342791,
-0.0013439833,
-0.0188855901,
-0.0319357254,
-0.0207747128,
-0.0257471986,
-0.0094631314,
0.031656228,
0.0105429441,
0.017680753,
-0.0067944634,
0.0257518552,
0.0125966817,
-0.0112510659,
-0.0287974216,
0.0484180227,
0.0040148785,
0.0166831221,
-0.0286965333,
0.000241274,
-0.0323226564,
-0.0527535081,
-0.011666094,
-0.0231779069,
-0.0124958437,
0.0399591066,
0.0001228222,
0.0239564069,
0.0327011198,
0.0606702454,
0.0017052689,
0.0584326163,
-0.0354962908,
0.0179415122,
0.0711876228,
-0.0103153726,
0.1039347053,
0.0032480881,
0.0010607933,
-0.0438666902,
0.0567401052,
0.0202954169,
0.0140609797,
-0.004399362,
-0.0098222643,
-0.0016081578,
-0.0041466262,
0.1079828739,
-0.0631082505,
-0.0227566753,
0.0359064117,
-0.0220921654,
-0.0419781692,
-0.0313929431,
-0.0368931592,
-0.01706044,
0.0300492328,
-0.0372140072,
-0.0519474559,
-0.021650821,
0.043825198,
-0.0255700797,
0.0266953055,
-0.0421237834,
0.0156975649,
0.0338755436,
0.0288823415,
0.0303364601,
-0.0568025783,
-0.0138940178,
-0.0069754887,
0.015272947,
0.0235170443,
-5.376355206e-33,
-0.0263535101,
0.0129569946,
-0.032395374,
0.0148718609,
-0.0218842924,
-0.0170585904,
-0.0303427149,
-0.0118999053,
0.0019697091,
-0.0120357536,
-0.0326895006,
-0.0007724065,
0.0213186331,
0.0305022504,
0.0142206056,
0.025794737,
0.0246676132,
0.017683221,
-0.0213246979,
0.0080003077,
0.034028247,
0.0068854052,
0.0921942964,
0.0106215952,
0.0094687156,
-0.0645317882,
-0.032065779,
-0.0131306816,
0.0009799598,
0.020437317,
-0.0048034624,
0.0267050527,
0.0525899343,
-0.0591772422,
-0.0388992317,
-0.0293783564,
-0.0479583852,
0.0127522405,
0.051327955,
0.0424047634,
-0.0181204099,
-0.0240299348,
0.0370899253,
-0.0178152826,
-0.0067059421,
-0.0193002429,
0.0479245186,
-0.0287930835,
-0.0240428317,
-0.0422834493,
-0.0435411297,
0.0524899587,
-0.0318504162,
-0.0127904881,
0.0368974581,
0.0794201568,
-0.0078169815,
-0.0080967303,
-0.0223224256,
0.0403000824,
0.0400671847,
0.0586111434,
0.0734810531,
0.0357697718,
-0.0231614262,
0.0171725918,
0.0007542487,
-0.0608878769,
0.032444559,
0.0202387813,
0.0144236507,
0.001150912,
0.0201066975,
0.0369011834,
0.0156810004,
-0.0250590406,
-0.0193389263,
0.0807666853,
-0.0150710791,
0.0292890426,
0.0092518926,
-0.0194542874,
0.0035657955,
-0.023730332,
0.0069340868,
0.0063650277,
-0.0116765816,
-0.0266116802,
0.0184667911,
-0.0362937711,
-0.0398910195,
0.0303643756,
0.0488769002,
-0.025774736,
0.0302782394,
0.0193494651,
-0.0355973057,
0.0609101467,
-0.0328209624,
0.0062418869,
-0.0107934456,
0.0176130179,
0.0004383765,
0.0264647435,
-0.0213504229,
-0.0256880894,
0.0332854651,
-0.0088603543,
-0.0557634197,
0.0092168525,
0.001881451,
0.0455540977,
-0.0360238887,
0.0537391379,
-0.015770264,
-0.0239445753,
-0.0082284231,
0.0040156692,
0.032240957,
-0.0095901052,
-0.0315699838,
0.015016932,
0.0232465751,
-0.0029542937,
-0.0017246765,
0.0515213199,
-0.0555888377,
-0.0026635432,
0.0051675034,
-0.0103889024,
-0.0182166062,
0.0182114355,
2.394e-7,
0.0485205166,
0.0450594313,
0.0507953614,
-0.0109115113,
-0.0314519256,
0.0070034782,
-0.0493706092,
0.0072351336,
0.0311810467,
0.072317943,
0.0144203296,
-0.0101927919,
0.0499396175,
0.0492984429,
-0.0905792415,
-0.0187086556,
-0.1103100702,
-0.031831868,
-0.0186438058,
-0.0007854451,
-0.0109095909,
0.0850564763,
-0.0326589718,
0.0031427548,
-0.0590035804,
-0.0098648556,
0.0354764685,
-0.0150648672,
-0.0731423423,
0.0504057668,
0.0428127311,
-0.0030369933,
-0.0071240859,
-0.0320217162,
0.0046119853,
-0.0051312638,
0.1071509421,
0.0386784114,
-0.005425944,
0.0219403077,
0.0364615507,
0.0137702413,
-0.0014708362,
0.0036876032,
0.0307515766,
0.0174392574,
-0.0284971483,
-0.013369875,
-0.0448268279,
0.0106284348,
0.005022767,
-0.0036762755,
-0.0503226146,
0.0566184931,
0.0059328615,
-0.0538804941,
0.0008470281,
-0.0408765748,
-0.0591360778,
0.019478485,
-0.0094008157,
-0.0628037378,
0.0233435091,
-0.0375521332,
0.0247994903,
-0.0425732173,
0.0074090054,
2.081498586e-34,
0.0906602219,
-0.0096653327,
-0.0241080765,
0.015554579,
0.0079531856,
-0.0613128878,
0.0120252306,
0.0186654124,
-0.0089114849,
-0.0715619996,
-0.0145366406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16634v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16634v3 | G-Eval: NLG Evaluation using GPT-4 with Better Human Alignment | 2023-03-29T12:46:54 | 2023-05-23T22:12:16 | Yang Liu, Dan Iter, Yichong Xu, Shuohang Wang, Ruochen Xu, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The quality of texts generated by natural language generation (NLG) systems
is hard to measure automatically. Conventional reference-based metrics, such as
BLEU and ROUGE, have been shown to have relatively low correlation with human
judgments, especially for tasks that require creativity and diversity. Recent
studies suggest using large language models (LLMs) as reference-free metrics
for NLG evaluation, which have the benefit of being applicable to new tasks
that lack human references. However, these LLM-based evaluators still have
lower human correspondence than medium-size neural evaluators. In this work, we
present G-Eval, a framework of using large language models with
chain-of-thoughts (CoT) and a form-filling paradigm, to assess the quality of
NLG outputs. We experiment with two generation tasks, text summarization and
dialogue generation. We show that G-Eval with GPT-4 as the backbone model
achieves a Spearman correlation of 0.514 with human on summarization task,
outperforming all previous methods by a large margin. We also propose
preliminary analysis on the behavior of LLM-based evaluators, and highlight the
potential issue of LLM-based evaluators having a bias towards the LLM-generated
texts. The code is at https://github.com/nlpyang/geval | [
0.0438056514,
0.0429798551,
0.0264963713,
0.0030069978,
-0.0435376503,
-0.0025614188,
0.0109554362,
-0.0243126173,
-0.0144328661,
-0.0455448516,
-0.0386340097,
-0.075078994,
0.0254931506,
0.0367886089,
0.0372511521,
-0.0503636375,
-0.0053434554,
-0.0089421924,
0.0266293399,
0.0141945062,
0.0021696545,
0.0363519788,
0.0132856052,
0.0636337698,
-0.001377343,
-0.0250482671,
-0.001983308,
0.0118448203,
0.0465016924,
-0.0336746462,
-0.0078359088,
0.0552086644,
-0.0344421305,
0.0334229842,
0.0000019347,
-0.0376238003,
0.0168976989,
0.004690771,
0.0325964279,
0.0344663225,
0.02497622,
0.0095653106,
-0.0118081318,
0.0177974869,
-0.0256599747,
0.0003708674,
0.0076036751,
0.0594292283,
0.0972409397,
0.0627238527,
0.0003886433,
-0.015114354,
0.0211806204,
-0.0484869406,
0.0026773904,
-0.0239689909,
-0.0111352494,
0.0097991163,
0.0020869023,
0.0107461521,
0.0096246153,
0.0153851155,
0.015755482,
-0.0182052758,
0.0257203951,
0.0345556587,
-0.0263601467,
-0.0133416392,
0.0010405865,
0.0646844506,
-0.0174015239,
-0.0287775565,
-0.0060892464,
-0.0043303003,
0.0294942986,
-0.0141423335,
-0.0373609327,
0.0491329134,
-0.0085012577,
0.0188106112,
0.0051528532,
0.0041527716,
0.0087924069,
0.0221031718,
0.0134355165,
0.0260119531,
0.03009074,
-0.0347168036,
-0.012862091,
0.0187006574,
-0.0484101139,
-0.0724648461,
0.0100738145,
0.0160644874,
-0.0617703609,
-0.001163893,
-0.0582674481,
-0.0134774046,
0.0087321624,
-0.0250665471,
0.0377240404,
0.040212974,
0.0146378828,
-0.0035849495,
-0.0330754034,
0.0865185261,
-0.0069769309,
-0.0028477686,
-0.0591677874,
0.0074115922,
-0.0525066815,
-0.0019531341,
-0.0332593657,
0.0277803354,
-0.0376854576,
-0.023431655,
-0.0454561673,
0.0148241865,
-0.0094720162,
-0.0215402264,
0.0102905221,
0.0390449353,
-0.0136212232,
0.009414047,
-0.0485135205,
0.015802402,
-0.0192050878,
-0.009656487,
0.0561889187,
-0.0202847775,
0.0010038414,
0.0354697146,
0.0051999865,
-0.0376860313,
0.0018861627,
0.0268281307,
-0.0205411576,
-0.0143324099,
-0.015835546,
-0.0318665355,
-0.0282613505,
-0.0847268179,
-0.0211581457,
-0.0815336779,
-0.0080945687,
-0.014242799,
-0.0262291208,
-0.0287731644,
0.0198571756,
0.0518818237,
-0.0235900525,
0.0050079231,
0.0104583148,
0.0042826044,
0.015858015,
-0.0039765569,
-0.0002709802,
0.0155113982,
0.0643491596,
0.0525413901,
-0.0104555553,
0.0043832418,
0.0283675734,
0.0122811524,
-0.006082423,
-0.0122640459,
0.0057814992,
-0.0339303538,
-0.0282294378,
0.0556068793,
0.046842359,
0.1145534068,
-0.032162901,
0.0259414688,
0.0875909179,
0.0219183061,
0.0070909751,
0.0360639878,
0.0965326279,
0.0313901156,
0.0054177158,
0.0455168299,
-0.0280872118,
0.0356460102,
-0.0208093692,
0.0406316891,
0.0726367757,
0.0555084608,
-0.006921072,
-0.039926704,
-0.0016314343,
0.0189458523,
0.0182688907,
-0.0503079109,
0.005107752,
0.0097669624,
-0.0754279718,
0.0161398072,
-0.0228968635,
-0.0796885192,
0.0206939019,
-0.0324900895,
0.0411077514,
0.0492725521,
0.0587673113,
0.0625176057,
-0.0331289805,
-0.0266118683,
-0.0383013822,
0.0839854628,
0.036226932,
0.0039606928,
-0.0260687824,
-0.0511695594,
-0.0099707302,
-0.0403800197,
-0.0048847725,
0.0296060629,
-0.005311524,
-0.0042735217,
0.0419814624,
-0.0153095238,
-0.072794497,
0.0410643518,
-0.0093217669,
-0.0205970816,
0.0084823864,
-0.0117920227,
0.0326453857,
0.0304012485,
-0.0399594493,
0.0456832014,
-0.0032540467,
-0.0406762809,
-0.0338042788,
0.0214633606,
-0.0498101749,
-0.044355303,
0.0211828649,
-0.0691653267,
0.0096414648,
0.0071251169,
-0.0160674546,
-0.0669497773,
0.0162010472,
-0.0686854199,
-0.0218734685,
-0.0644559786,
0.0141251208,
0.021007942,
0.0078460118,
-0.0352531858,
0.0822450817,
0.00851948,
0.0067356918,
0.0422508717,
0.0389062539,
0.0420458242,
-0.0369325057,
-0.0342408195,
0.0005625031,
0.006828899,
0.0354483686,
0.0636443645,
0.0692839622,
-0.0347039737,
-0.0459851027,
-0.112675108,
0.0262906589,
-0.0182704758,
0.0235290155,
0.0446998253,
-0.0172154922,
-0.0048777028,
0.0406392664,
-0.076090619,
-0.0411731713,
0.0481147282,
-0.0023003523,
0.0346326604,
-0.0026378436,
0.0113947848,
-0.0128415218,
0.0194530729,
0.0110896248,
0.0479933992,
0.0310425013,
0.0048883152,
-0.0326578952,
0.0517084152,
-0.0508438125,
-0.0162831228,
0.0357349664,
-0.0628341883,
0.0329427756,
0.0221334491,
0.0727084875,
0.0380049534,
0.0569299012,
-0.0174658913,
0.0394525751,
0.0183177833,
-0.0061826776,
0.0125746122,
-0.0219942369,
0.0262939259,
0.0198735092,
-0.0244665518,
0.0218018703,
0.0606426559,
0.0406829156,
-0.0011730243,
-0.0761207119,
0.0556248948,
-0.0048112348,
-0.0361299366,
-0.0153865432,
-0.0173551273,
-0.0453989767,
0.0296192635,
-0.0352743305,
-0.0353569798,
0.0616270602,
-0.0540170521,
0.0029714811,
-0.064823471,
0.0090405168,
-0.0427454971,
0.0434915908,
0.0198899973,
0.0359167717,
0.0002109636,
0.0035075352,
-0.0757372901,
0.0255709011,
0.0113703106,
-0.0428118818,
0.0587648898,
-0.0516716875,
-0.00226912,
-0.0048068315,
-0.0215494912,
-0.0569294505,
-0.0005830255,
0.0005226796,
0.019669421,
0.0569811277,
-0.0029874716,
-0.0091018295,
0.0170697179,
0.0300106127,
0.027911257,
-0.0384731144,
-0.002120794,
-0.0081629585,
0.0526099727,
0.0569664612,
0.0022058769,
0.0243227258,
-0.0225113407,
0.0197612401,
0.0272378325,
-0.0116256373,
0.030636495,
-0.0187390205,
-0.004674559,
-0.0081379097,
0.0074499119,
-0.0235130414,
0.0224117059,
0.0708294138,
-0.0473579429,
-0.0396176316,
0.1184906289,
0.0072414,
-0.0219529644,
-0.0028291345,
-0.0073635569,
0.0483264029,
0.0016501654,
0.0155502958,
-0.0341583937,
-0.0159828439,
-0.0104428623,
0.0114636477,
-0.0215752535,
-0.0136603704,
-0.0350445323,
-0.1284079105,
0.0384193137,
0.0223422088,
-0.0372712277,
-0.0057402798,
0.0115956003,
-0.0118129281,
-0.0028646986,
0.0175627265,
0.0197314806,
-0.003013937,
0.0346169174,
0.0212153513,
-0.0461124927,
-0.0396949761,
-0.0091051757,
-0.038474109,
0.0347874984,
0.0841667131,
0.0682881698,
0.0157664828,
-0.0459129885,
0.0289519671,
-0.0409329049,
0.0107239988,
0.0174315572,
0.0365326144,
0.012055289,
0.0057807029,
-0.033588361,
0.0307377074,
-0.0091737565,
-0.0055969679,
-0.0073786424,
0.0295069795,
-0.0087945592,
-0.0251878053,
-0.0189337321,
0.0482778437,
-0.0086566573,
0.0800583065,
0.0583698191,
-0.0761146247,
-0.0612814166,
-0.0243578758,
-0.0032196813,
-0.1004893482,
-0.0427208021,
0.0249669366,
-0.0070173303,
0.0078961868,
-0.1143989041,
-0.0561772026,
-0.0153423306,
0.0262728669,
-0.0094810724,
0.0020642243,
-0.024805434,
-0.015883632,
0.0039912104,
0.0225047432,
0.0018139235,
0.0139742363,
-0.0520713218,
-0.0161480308,
-0.0118095474,
-0.0608827956,
-0.0233777501,
0.0714922175,
-0.0949248299,
-0.048580531,
-0.0447770134,
0.0404601358,
0.0210832562,
0.0137819005,
0.0011979864,
-0.0143984808,
0.0369483419,
0.0548268594,
-0.0253348518,
0.0422744229,
-0.0231143255,
0.0353920721,
-0.0234563705,
0.0071443319,
-0.0221277792,
0.0081655942,
0.0025613999,
0.0725870728,
0.0386601537,
-0.034417212,
0.0289560966,
0.0258116424,
0.0102326842,
-0.0707874522,
0.0233988222,
-0.0263754353,
-0.0575135946,
-0.0056586731,
-0.0187171716,
-0.0666002333,
-0.0030104157,
0.032839857,
0.0049503655,
-0.0089567443,
0.0020157744,
-0.0199076068,
0.0448654443,
-0.0231379848,
-0.0457018092,
-0.0289844554,
0.0063879606,
-0.0022096103,
-0.0122612044,
-0.0372384787,
-0.0302146748,
-0.0497202948,
0.0230857842,
-0.00436782,
0.0720288903,
0.0228758994,
0.0070360657,
0.0416623354,
0.0580130816,
-0.0666114464,
-0.0164644625,
-0.0570702255,
-0.024298979,
0.0497534648,
0.0216616709,
0.0900789499,
-0.0288991574,
0.0107991025,
-0.0321764201,
0.0467661582,
0.0089233126,
-0.0143638225,
-0.0182001218,
-0.0002723681,
-0.0019961563,
-0.035664551,
0.0787906572,
0.0039973734,
-0.0057552233,
0.0052764933,
-0.005561057,
-0.0446202755,
-0.0362313315,
-0.0397256762,
-0.0074905874,
0.0083422819,
0.0048267655,
-0.0768283531,
-0.0402195714,
0.0252525769,
0.0256743375,
0.0408067591,
-0.0178567581,
0.0577901267,
0.0246646665,
-0.0547323227,
0.0166154839,
-0.0452093147,
-0.0153236752,
-0.0189635344,
-0.0096566873,
-0.0507335179,
-6.02221772e-33,
-0.0512520969,
-0.0620007105,
0.0244317688,
-0.007195679,
-0.0659977421,
-0.0134950541,
-0.0615662634,
-0.0009591805,
0.0345645957,
0.0169033278,
0.01822583,
-0.0213057268,
-0.0098292697,
0.0443457924,
0.0029051225,
0.0007870705,
0.0515935346,
-0.0066435947,
-0.0619420297,
0.0463645309,
0.0341164097,
0.0069559282,
0.018685149,
-0.0365061611,
-0.0004932388,
-0.0210427176,
-0.0322283804,
-0.0146258408,
-0.002818149,
0.0515952408,
-0.0249764305,
0.021626683,
0.0332067125,
-0.0342223011,
-0.0156635921,
0.0078261551,
-0.0084032333,
-0.015916504,
0.0197994485,
-0.039645616,
-0.055788476,
-0.0421746299,
0.0339407697,
-0.0144741219,
-0.0221863706,
-0.0112852333,
0.0175425205,
-0.0320174024,
-0.0095119569,
-0.0499541909,
-0.0553254224,
0.0138572967,
-0.0112274447,
-0.0351224355,
-0.0239800438,
0.0506022647,
-0.0321014561,
-0.018646596,
-0.037053518,
0.0124785388,
-0.0122869154,
0.0206056889,
0.0626011118,
0.0239030831,
-0.0191548504,
0.0719514638,
-0.0005401823,
0.0002236285,
-0.0595423393,
-0.0019438652,
-0.0037730499,
0.0288401246,
0.0424890034,
0.0510335714,
0.0196415465,
0.0308381226,
-0.0417997651,
0.0704569966,
-0.0139879324,
0.0234186575,
0.0367713459,
-0.023904575,
0.0096367141,
-0.0087380214,
-0.0391643494,
-0.0383271277,
-0.0363204442,
-0.0221561156,
0.0347106308,
0.006574749,
-0.0206110459,
-0.0439844467,
0.0323392972,
0.0012797534,
0.0401925817,
0.0368432403,
-0.0773930773,
0.0229487494,
-0.0008167604,
0.0000520337,
-0.0317386724,
0.0016717011,
0.0373703688,
0.0618076734,
0.017198408,
-0.0027634283,
0.024492776,
0.009602177,
-0.0456226319,
0.0295309722,
-0.0653735399,
0.0675210655,
-0.0131701184,
-0.0061333468,
0.0064031952,
-0.0369066857,
-0.0260184873,
0.0392094441,
-0.0054804711,
-0.0033299741,
-0.0053548641,
-0.020960426,
0.0233054645,
0.0018664269,
-0.0371853672,
0.0337898396,
-0.0024095096,
0.0028250006,
0.0290005635,
-0.0311192758,
-0.019178018,
0.0187921207,
2.65e-7,
-0.0002763675,
0.0454264544,
0.0388918929,
0.023085624,
0.0163997896,
0.0390999131,
0.0048954957,
0.0343082659,
0.0168597959,
-0.0125296693,
0.0080190385,
-0.0015550257,
0.0724038407,
0.014112711,
-0.0803829208,
0.0261452571,
-0.094838731,
-0.0139350193,
-0.0372607857,
-0.0220303666,
0.0666092187,
0.0293881744,
-0.0178762414,
-0.0222298149,
0.0103873853,
-0.0252405312,
0.0774715543,
-0.006588012,
-0.03617239,
0.0148078855,
0.0565701053,
-0.0024377578,
-0.0067926622,
0.0182901248,
-0.0005005455,
0.0051056254,
0.0539353006,
0.0366840549,
0.0402008221,
-0.0009913332,
0.0178570673,
-0.0006782616,
0.0227312669,
-0.0516426228,
0.0406271406,
-0.0275024511,
-0.0187899284,
-0.013200921,
-0.0240928084,
-0.002971007,
0.0153049417,
-0.042002555,
-0.0161666349,
0.0193852074,
0.0066421512,
0.0093437023,
-0.0018347738,
-0.0264208559,
-0.0538570434,
0.0069514429,
-0.0456926376,
-0.0202416256,
-0.0420854501,
0.0373376012,
0.0230105128,
-0.0726067796,
-0.0039190985,
2.401819419e-34,
0.0582202673,
-0.0465584062,
0.0162313189,
-0.0300891232,
0.056246046,
0.01357604,
-0.0175231397,
-0.0125050964,
0.0053750724,
-0.0707729012,
-0.0219403915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16621v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16621v2 | AraSpot: Arabic Spoken Command Spotting | 2023-03-29T12:22:17 | 2024-05-05T12:38:04 | Mahmoud Salhab, Haidar Harmanani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spoken keyword spotting (KWS) is the task of identifying a keyword in an
audio stream and is widely used in smart devices at the edge in order to
activate voice assistants and perform hands-free tasks. The task is daunting as
there is a need, on the one hand, to achieve high accuracy while at the same
time ensuring that such systems continue to run efficiently on low power and
possibly limited computational capabilities devices. This work presents AraSpot
for Arabic keyword spotting trained on 40 Arabic keywords, using different
online data augmentation, and introducing ConformerGRU model architecture.
Finally, we further improve the performance of the model by training a
text-to-speech model for synthetic data generation. AraSpot achieved a
State-of-the-Art SOTA 99.59% result outperforming previous approaches. | [
-0.0045695496,
-0.020944234,
0.0126031004,
0.0100416299,
0.0049968073,
-0.0139749991,
0.0264613722,
-0.0262069162,
-0.0146531211,
-0.0435517505,
-0.0329484083,
-0.074748762,
0.0282889474,
0.0839307159,
0.041731175,
-0.0057767062,
0.0339977816,
-0.0724087283,
0.001019726,
0.0049946448,
0.0552657768,
0.0148593569,
-0.0454737656,
0.0236051474,
-0.0342155918,
0.0102741765,
-0.0434650593,
-0.0267424881,
0.0082613919,
0.0224861559,
0.01274426,
0.0041851527,
0.0411387011,
0.0376229808,
0.0000018912,
-0.0269944463,
-0.0258961022,
0.0153717231,
-0.0499972105,
-0.0007150139,
-0.0045597074,
-0.025641432,
-0.0817582086,
0.0490335338,
0.0145032918,
0.0205879379,
0.0507213064,
0.0344410762,
-0.0016310118,
0.0679854751,
-0.0005173485,
-0.0461906716,
0.0284695607,
-0.0263666436,
-0.0097829197,
-0.0334904902,
-0.0456318595,
-0.0640073791,
-0.0001806555,
-0.0128320577,
0.0046640756,
0.0316371247,
-0.0249804985,
-0.0004557022,
0.0299081765,
-0.0068747946,
-0.0487062223,
-0.0341954045,
-0.0294308383,
0.0376614742,
-0.0430129841,
-0.0093134288,
0.0125357732,
0.0006961612,
-0.0401085578,
-0.0042403569,
-0.011915789,
0.0265284739,
-0.0293199029,
-0.0287180934,
-0.0099645127,
0.0072001251,
0.0306871142,
0.0038883395,
-0.0393436663,
0.0329490714,
0.0129066249,
-0.05031031,
-0.0093329446,
-0.034145873,
-0.0565732084,
0.004219356,
0.0763356388,
0.0157324541,
-0.0607953221,
-0.0186893791,
-0.0185713284,
-0.0430178083,
-0.0201770328,
-0.0497602113,
0.0858226418,
0.0553465001,
-0.014510816,
-0.0057494943,
-0.0161356013,
0.0497379266,
0.0012569778,
0.0046102833,
-0.0129846474,
0.0258269552,
-0.0107239243,
-0.0016916023,
-0.0150493421,
0.0256069545,
-0.061182797,
-0.0313132852,
-0.0402870886,
-0.011372,
-0.0032249142,
0.0123989237,
0.0124362754,
-0.0096211899,
-0.0491114669,
-0.0165118743,
0.0513799824,
-0.0080500031,
-0.0014808712,
0.0642799214,
-0.0405960865,
-0.0975476131,
-0.0010524557,
0.0262589809,
0.0698801875,
0.0331279337,
0.0169109665,
0.0330504961,
-0.0159324165,
-0.0897773802,
0.0026351535,
0.0207544491,
-0.0249074269,
-0.0087998789,
0.0100305807,
-0.0632164702,
0.0368799716,
-0.0410814285,
-0.0229992382,
0.0454638191,
0.0327339694,
0.0414152071,
0.0396082364,
0.082809709,
-0.0147808436,
0.0247583874,
0.0334371328,
-0.0033500106,
0.0136064766,
0.0485453531,
0.0594679751,
0.021189386,
0.0075327642,
-0.0341709517,
0.0452312157,
0.0626724437,
-0.0080424082,
0.026723763,
-0.0402225591,
-0.0401833989,
-0.0019652783,
0.0651521161,
0.0216352418,
0.0285828263,
-0.0135736698,
0.0382363014,
0.0854908302,
0.0365085527,
-0.0087551922,
0.0052514593,
-0.0123093231,
0.0494117849,
-0.0061314506,
-0.0320345983,
0.0299144443,
-0.0225777626,
0.0191239454,
0.0190340709,
0.0298316944,
0.0555859767,
-0.0192696974,
-0.0201484431,
-0.0251398552,
-0.04095985,
-0.0569055863,
0.0075898198,
0.0698652118,
0.00169016,
-0.0371709242,
-0.0158456787,
-0.0077755409,
-0.0527621768,
-0.0086231269,
-0.0600994043,
0.0199809838,
0.0422694683,
0.0365051702,
-0.0103232879,
-0.0277864095,
-0.0588606894,
-0.010212387,
0.0457219481,
-0.0174893085,
-0.0068928949,
0.0417958051,
-0.0420999303,
-0.0309184846,
0.0403688774,
0.0169131774,
0.0458674692,
-0.0019283677,
0.0153645864,
0.0183324572,
-0.0334254429,
0.0126183825,
0.0085973535,
-0.0038688811,
-0.0097127371,
0.0216505788,
0.0197568685,
0.036627382,
0.0593315028,
-0.014652391,
0.0191053972,
0.0186512303,
-0.0732613355,
-0.0037719326,
0.0065666637,
-0.0373795144,
0.0670521408,
0.0604902506,
-0.0282722674,
0.0457586199,
0.0753765851,
0.0223095994,
-0.0894038007,
0.0534355007,
-0.0420238227,
0.0701610968,
-0.0292157382,
0.0460155495,
0.0176207591,
0.0637690499,
0.0497395173,
0.0192795172,
0.011557458,
0.0088718226,
-0.0014468586,
0.0039261389,
0.0133502288,
-0.0043076244,
0.0021830641,
0.0021670288,
-0.0290979762,
0.028012149,
0.0152126551,
-0.0204022937,
-0.0091114324,
-0.0053352895,
-0.0551144965,
-0.0003386759,
-0.0386464298,
0.0289565586,
-0.0089262957,
0.023344798,
-0.0351287574,
-0.0234530568,
-0.0254336204,
-0.0406123698,
0.0008944098,
0.00159667,
-0.0506576523,
-0.0163265411,
-0.0332196727,
-0.0351445787,
0.0182042737,
0.0254615545,
-0.023448661,
0.0094332658,
-0.0480342321,
-0.0066214968,
-0.0382635035,
0.0519490205,
0.0583638437,
0.0038411457,
-0.0199960414,
0.0356218442,
0.0264534708,
0.0241544209,
0.0347876586,
0.0361588262,
-0.0149696255,
-0.0104469974,
-0.0053847083,
-0.0198064763,
0.004020778,
0.0152293202,
0.001396139,
-0.0055893725,
0.021272216,
-0.0210320856,
0.0157819912,
0.0215511639,
0.0455669947,
-0.0280728675,
-0.0466420501,
0.0178674944,
-0.037937846,
-0.0224507954,
-0.0223147534,
-0.0677624568,
0.0379167125,
0.0240687635,
-0.0613215044,
-0.053669557,
-0.0793230087,
-0.0175482389,
-0.0578804389,
-0.031760022,
0.0194164086,
-0.0077208257,
-0.0076762224,
-0.013609807,
-0.0420919694,
-0.0477035791,
0.0004777834,
0.0283574518,
0.0110802976,
-0.0655277148,
0.014877663,
-0.0419028364,
-0.0026971346,
-0.0179200452,
-0.0108174197,
-0.0274965577,
0.0319386758,
-0.0670934021,
-0.016321538,
0.0276160408,
-0.0568625927,
0.0030433899,
0.0420371667,
0.0132992426,
0.0936990678,
0.0129409488,
0.0302277207,
-0.0437000245,
0.009565955,
0.0834143162,
0.0111121498,
-0.0038206079,
0.0316127315,
0.0360905454,
0.0229516178,
0.0494542792,
-0.0319485404,
-0.0546059348,
-0.0389088243,
0.042024307,
-0.0056524337,
-0.0366771184,
0.0351720378,
0.0286970623,
-0.0389581397,
0.0133067779,
0.0932244658,
0.003865632,
-0.0390852578,
0.0070012803,
0.024320161,
0.000501059,
0.026307879,
-0.017016897,
-0.060704194,
-0.0174197871,
0.0801637694,
0.0440237783,
0.0041851089,
0.0378783084,
-0.002803829,
-0.108722128,
0.0362145677,
0.0203083511,
-0.0007738856,
-0.0811693743,
-0.0479645096,
0.0158462953,
-0.0111032864,
0.016749274,
-0.0245003961,
-0.0096427146,
0.0055115139,
0.0363861509,
-0.0321459845,
-0.0714464188,
0.0309057049,
-0.0326867811,
0.062890321,
0.0766549855,
-0.0086993203,
-0.0267338641,
-0.02214415,
0.0366260149,
0.0076406701,
-0.0020295177,
0.008236967,
-0.0187360439,
-0.0212354977,
-0.0222342238,
0.0293496996,
0.0423822179,
-0.0473984405,
0.0127443541,
0.0163739696,
0.0254151002,
-0.0022861548,
0.0399864353,
0.0046715997,
0.007624262,
0.0110020367,
0.0104076397,
-0.031010408,
-0.0315493345,
-0.0313350111,
0.0360978246,
0.0143072475,
-0.0417576246,
-0.048934564,
-0.0214900747,
0.0427726433,
-0.0587354973,
-0.0482518673,
-0.0291862357,
0.0163447615,
0.0457008444,
0.0200475398,
0.0536207408,
-0.0040189936,
0.0408854671,
-0.0254871454,
-0.0293001775,
-0.0032627517,
0.0607606284,
-0.0946163684,
-0.0234458968,
0.0029195107,
-0.0830107406,
0.0063913944,
0.032572411,
-0.0572621338,
-0.0404566862,
0.0410291925,
-0.0227463208,
0.0233635884,
0.0643719807,
-0.0773548633,
-0.0339218713,
0.0144075099,
0.0208124723,
-0.068650417,
0.0365119278,
0.0492354073,
-0.0284603424,
-0.0317956395,
0.0257576257,
-0.0050202347,
0.0376078971,
-0.0123909302,
-0.0015945073,
-0.0297950022,
-0.0239708703,
0.0067616287,
-0.032950379,
0.0708241314,
-0.0599899366,
0.0028831982,
-0.0623167679,
0.0381872915,
0.0270416904,
0.0658381879,
-0.0295629092,
0.0183841288,
-0.0123916473,
0.0244807247,
0.0160906035,
0.0010609716,
-0.0109273512,
-0.0498711616,
-0.020567568,
0.0096332664,
-0.0010934486,
0.0041402914,
0.0014947606,
-0.0040243715,
0.0071687293,
0.0415604673,
0.0099269627,
0.0350036472,
-0.0042321142,
0.0255529657,
-0.0335721746,
-0.0085380059,
0.0340260193,
0.0419669338,
-0.0212894324,
-0.0210779887,
-0.0868342295,
0.0697396696,
0.0444484167,
-0.0528631806,
0.0413668267,
0.0058993553,
0.0069514187,
-0.0377242118,
0.0275477059,
-0.072714217,
-0.0031933528,
0.007353873,
0.00648501,
-0.0275759418,
0.0238757059,
0.0536400713,
0.0078519788,
0.0343167372,
0.0114321448,
0.0021420287,
-0.0523436219,
-0.0438225195,
0.0000971134,
0.0074671176,
-0.048978921,
0.0223550182,
-0.0037204644,
-0.0646777824,
0.0227721464,
-0.0204724409,
0.0159274358,
-0.021775445,
0.0317585319,
0.0293124486,
-0.05746793,
0.0334371105,
-0.0192927122,
-0.0381065123,
-0.0149597805,
0.0019586985,
0.050947018,
-5.861995269e-33,
-0.0038145068,
0.0039545964,
0.0131896082,
-0.0041461485,
-0.0023121394,
0.0131612942,
0.0163023416,
0.0232903343,
-0.0083889375,
-0.0372211188,
-0.0559931621,
0.0340298377,
0.0467908941,
0.0323153883,
0.0095393769,
-0.0224375483,
0.0676358715,
-0.0254894998,
0.0022571497,
0.0265021492,
0.0548455752,
0.0426159278,
0.0641675219,
-0.0576879121,
-0.0202476643,
-0.0100860856,
-0.034140192,
-0.0309245642,
-0.0301472265,
0.0424426161,
-0.0411827713,
0.0395010635,
-0.007511531,
-0.0030640867,
0.0004224757,
0.0261421073,
-0.0260047745,
0.0413827933,
-0.0050376286,
0.0839721188,
0.0165303685,
-0.021767471,
-0.0277116243,
0.0094850026,
-0.0566278808,
0.0188444294,
-0.0083000893,
-0.061580494,
-0.049324479,
-0.0252377745,
-0.0658007488,
0.0625345334,
0.0218439754,
-0.0311306883,
0.0316771641,
0.0405691452,
-0.0077967709,
-0.0485215858,
-0.0739757791,
0.0477115139,
0.0599520616,
0.0650210306,
0.0398202017,
0.0405655019,
-0.0258474648,
0.052874051,
0.024569219,
-0.0944776088,
0.0113613317,
0.021097688,
0.0025262097,
-0.0138643328,
0.0081887972,
0.0224461481,
0.0497144572,
-0.0498830825,
-0.0093163801,
-0.0189589243,
-0.0026156406,
0.0040119989,
0.0343582481,
-0.0002256021,
-0.0693182424,
0.0175361894,
-0.0225132611,
-0.0207115076,
-0.0261948835,
0.0036031625,
0.0544383787,
0.064022176,
-0.0321422257,
0.0184539165,
0.0146576818,
0.0179404616,
0.0858133882,
-0.0639262646,
0.0132891173,
0.0065641999,
-0.0003906237,
-0.0017227995,
-0.0438496098,
-0.0335379802,
0.0335905999,
0.0326764248,
-0.0043221707,
-0.0071922615,
0.0029869007,
0.0939585119,
-0.0667320564,
0.0121982843,
-0.0183391199,
0.0228434056,
0.011008014,
0.0234986544,
0.0437607132,
-0.0424420908,
-0.012295913,
0.0893450528,
-0.0295624025,
0.014534737,
0.0105785625,
-0.0386010818,
-0.0284838676,
0.014744835,
-0.0361403972,
0.0494867563,
-0.0446725413,
-0.0131084844,
0.011510971,
-0.0283340272,
-0.0201250203,
0.0010257016,
2.831e-7,
-0.0223160218,
-0.0163715146,
0.0349072404,
-0.039445594,
-0.0149127394,
0.0130231995,
0.0320451409,
0.0078266431,
-0.0111486167,
0.0194352753,
-0.0035808629,
-0.0273311064,
0.0553947538,
-0.0284304861,
-0.0885791406,
-0.0308320485,
-0.0466279723,
0.0448104702,
-0.0406759046,
0.0014807616,
-0.0060427487,
0.1252882481,
-0.0379530266,
-0.056334801,
0.0163012259,
0.0092544677,
0.0109915072,
0.0038458649,
0.0043370728,
-0.0364058949,
0.0101302741,
0.0059747589,
-0.0352688767,
0.0007157099,
-0.0405091159,
0.0499436893,
0.0433158502,
0.0622047447,
-0.0035631009,
0.0013463622,
-0.0087492866,
0.0023667051,
-0.0251801647,
-0.0120863263,
0.0799281001,
0.058637172,
-0.019575838,
-0.0345660634,
-0.0199928414,
0.0199906975,
-0.0112913018,
-0.0471964963,
0.0431579873,
-0.0135831106,
-0.0035722377,
-0.0113803605,
-0.0254000146,
-0.0136349453,
0.0121237179,
-0.0278267972,
-0.0357092805,
-0.0171580389,
-0.0570631176,
-0.0074969726,
0.01921455,
0.0415321738,
-0.012110916,
2.017357691e-34,
0.0109096244,
-0.0023132458,
-0.0000817931,
0.0032862148,
0.0177451503,
-0.0209790878,
0.0284573473,
0.0237945002,
0.0213327929,
-0.0075437967,
-0.0488114767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16618v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16618v3 | Reference-less Analysis of Context Specificity in Translation with Personalised Language Models | 2023-03-29T12:19:23 | 2024-03-05T08:51:30 | Sebastian Vincent, Alice Dowek, Rowanne Sumner, Charlotte Blundell, Emily Preston, Chris Bayliss, Chris Oakley, Carolina Scarton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Sensitising language models (LMs) to external context helps them to more
effectively capture the speaking patterns of individuals with specific
characteristics or in particular environments. This work investigates to what
extent rich character and film annotations can be leveraged to personalise LMs
in a scalable manner. We then explore the use of such models in evaluating
context specificity in machine translation. We build LMs which leverage rich
contextual information to reduce perplexity by up to 6.5% compared to a
non-contextual model, and generalise well to a scenario with no
speaker-specific data, relying on combinations of demographic characteristics
expressed via metadata. Our findings are consistent across two corpora, one of
which (Cornell-rich) is also a contribution of this paper. We then use our
personalised LMs to measure the co-occurrence of extra-textual context and
translation hypotheses in a machine translation setting. Our results suggest
that the degree to which professional translations in our domain are
context-specific can be preserved to a better extent by a contextual machine
translation model than a non-contextual model, which is also reflected in the
contextual model's superior reference-based scores. | [
0.0303856619,
0.0207629632,
-0.0312432218,
0.0488011278,
-0.0172704943,
0.0001471353,
0.055728931,
-0.0027783145,
-0.0439735018,
-0.0558711216,
-0.0548611879,
-0.0238514561,
0.0027183441,
-0.0174007267,
0.035271164,
-0.0334485099,
0.0054559959,
0.0165690277,
0.0177621301,
-0.0137124499,
-0.0015248808,
0.0403840393,
0.0433168076,
0.0347710028,
0.0035086786,
-0.0099873347,
0.045077242,
0.0709685758,
0.0623951927,
0.0179029703,
-0.0020001356,
0.0596043542,
0.0499737337,
0.0339904875,
0.0000019835,
-0.0452331007,
-0.0171916243,
0.0115241008,
0.0056470907,
0.0312197264,
0.0846057683,
-0.0028055054,
-0.0095137684,
0.0076451707,
-0.0397205055,
-0.0105219018,
0.0504168458,
-0.0532846078,
0.0414763354,
0.0354868025,
-0.0329436511,
-0.0457857102,
-0.0336245,
-0.0335201882,
0.014630951,
-0.0464576632,
-0.0078491112,
0.0296618696,
-0.0124479979,
0.0268116482,
-0.0188553538,
0.0459389426,
-0.0174319781,
-0.0159341414,
0.0002834773,
-0.0136734564,
-0.0271020532,
0.0030486323,
0.0328908935,
0.0506872572,
0.0306754727,
-0.0254042502,
-0.0127680963,
0.0073207505,
0.0070277862,
0.0070331465,
-0.0328034721,
0.0095639564,
-0.0042533972,
-0.0326052271,
0.0254514888,
0.0729495659,
0.0171460323,
0.0023555555,
-0.0094656032,
0.0056238868,
0.0316439718,
0.0033046354,
-0.0274590552,
0.0083334288,
-0.0019908906,
-0.022858046,
0.030024277,
-0.0133601315,
0.0347653516,
0.0279925484,
-0.0256365333,
-0.0338977799,
0.0164144691,
-0.0503803529,
-0.0264055524,
0.0671302006,
-0.0436251387,
0.0339374654,
0.0235094652,
0.0357003249,
-0.0406589843,
-0.0083369715,
-0.0512758978,
-0.0270103011,
-0.0501113944,
0.0260212943,
-0.0094481511,
-0.0176862981,
-0.0433157831,
0.0369041264,
-0.045077391,
0.0439946875,
0.0042279884,
-0.0024724617,
-0.0071027018,
-0.0418706723,
-0.052421324,
-0.0104996925,
-0.0076721758,
0.0379999802,
-0.0250918698,
-0.0109226936,
-0.0378690101,
-0.0445051566,
0.0286354385,
0.0188545175,
0.0080864606,
-0.0425631404,
0.0019477756,
0.0433218591,
0.0091150533,
-0.0229290891,
0.0039494177,
-0.014112711,
-0.0487714298,
-0.0438425764,
-0.0392282009,
-0.0702700093,
0.0567550212,
0.0438918844,
0.0238932259,
-0.0511351079,
-0.0237030108,
0.0093236081,
-0.0270038154,
0.0681713372,
0.0463254787,
0.0316550694,
0.0561667532,
-0.0154923042,
-0.0005932602,
0.0548918098,
0.055132281,
-0.0239358135,
0.0537231565,
-0.0258997511,
-0.0044255811,
0.0776466951,
-0.0404091552,
0.0253069531,
-0.0498837344,
0.0223838799,
0.0083788391,
-0.0129770823,
0.0374329016,
0.0343923308,
-0.0166881271,
0.0230586678,
0.0403007232,
0.0621713921,
-0.0014420002,
0.0115655912,
0.056761533,
0.0201577097,
-0.0105716139,
0.0103956368,
-0.0395643264,
0.0083595114,
0.0314290226,
-0.0148169575,
0.0081892963,
0.0198079236,
-0.0293127876,
-0.0137216141,
0.0101762796,
0.008385743,
0.0415601842,
0.0009235892,
0.0289803315,
-0.0025380512,
-0.0254840404,
0.0398568809,
0.0009289811,
-0.0687295943,
0.0218034387,
-0.0107267331,
-0.0471893065,
0.1053463444,
0.0365972072,
0.0024873866,
-0.0151368501,
-0.037000861,
0.0094010122,
0.0495965779,
0.0511648878,
-0.0051585604,
0.0500985868,
-0.0577100776,
0.0076193837,
0.0132955266,
0.0266278144,
0.0330580957,
0.0036883627,
0.0163355377,
0.0293082595,
-0.046594318,
-0.0429578125,
0.0088257333,
-0.0678544044,
-0.0414930619,
0.0134090455,
0.0037891832,
0.0164081845,
0.0569871292,
-0.0171819944,
-0.0187245999,
0.0081106424,
-0.0410065502,
0.0573149621,
0.079555504,
-0.0317863226,
-0.0025877452,
0.0078855949,
-0.0256306063,
-0.0003841261,
-0.0264093652,
-0.0150070228,
-0.0609452426,
-0.0086629074,
-0.0170044452,
0.0438374355,
-0.0510215461,
0.0313666202,
-0.0354285277,
0.0220638812,
-0.0616441332,
0.0245009027,
0.0151223084,
-0.0198613256,
0.0432940535,
0.0089444146,
0.051719211,
-0.0788827315,
-0.0321021006,
-0.0285013188,
0.0279336646,
0.0381993577,
0.0480866916,
0.0026451033,
-0.007117535,
-0.0316637531,
-0.0745778456,
0.0041583208,
-0.027653778,
0.0327507257,
0.0496787392,
0.0474924147,
-0.0256608725,
-0.0185746849,
-0.0121144438,
-0.0338491797,
-0.003045639,
0.0113158952,
0.0086856633,
0.0300044119,
-0.0003931163,
-0.0447107777,
-0.0121727921,
-0.011659462,
0.0314913094,
0.0464253537,
-0.0080782417,
-0.0397024788,
0.0119196679,
-0.011285468,
-0.0023157133,
-0.0135077164,
-0.0156780053,
0.0007215526,
-0.0035430607,
0.0132153016,
0.0230886657,
-0.0344596617,
0.00327974,
0.0284196865,
-0.0282992087,
-0.0389238037,
0.0012071343,
0.0144277727,
-0.0406230614,
-0.0256927293,
-0.1036738828,
0.0049203122,
-0.0099149309,
-0.0026302468,
-0.0056016482,
-0.0937118381,
0.0078673912,
-0.0046983287,
-0.0268441439,
-0.0058103092,
0.0101611465,
-0.0014244469,
0.0839304626,
-0.003196253,
-0.0307819154,
0.0424108729,
-0.0572290868,
0.0043878159,
-0.0118732862,
-0.0116419597,
-0.0441152342,
0.0500339195,
-0.0129970582,
0.0060361968,
-0.0202801302,
-0.0157897118,
-0.0264623966,
0.0037438849,
0.0317409299,
-0.0407080501,
0.0328660794,
-0.0428555682,
-0.0033613918,
0.00611739,
0.0037136555,
-0.0347504094,
-0.0421396233,
-0.0289608706,
-0.0080039548,
0.036060825,
-0.0216486864,
-0.0152140073,
0.0456146039,
0.012099768,
0.0562088937,
-0.0107945744,
0.0192987584,
-0.0252846219,
0.0142392209,
0.003579933,
0.0132126315,
-0.0394054465,
-0.0421087146,
0.0412720889,
-0.0341453478,
-0.009401992,
-0.0273919534,
-0.0247257389,
-0.0419398397,
0.0388118736,
-0.0097206524,
-0.0593543239,
0.0029848358,
0.0567989275,
-0.050778728,
-0.0018893757,
0.1269021332,
0.0164729804,
-0.0892685279,
-0.0297789499,
-0.0415989682,
0.0045352313,
0.0285134949,
0.0746804699,
-0.0652876124,
-0.0129562309,
-0.0153212901,
0.026246896,
0.0143510886,
0.0069013541,
-0.0540738031,
-0.0669393688,
0.0545996092,
0.0121268388,
-0.0892104283,
0.0004578438,
0.0107063884,
-0.0186809227,
-0.0372932144,
0.0261413567,
-0.0426607542,
0.0068026851,
-0.0097035179,
-0.0054394887,
-0.0195300393,
-0.0682818294,
0.0405688137,
-0.0449124053,
0.0312218759,
0.0494493954,
0.03888046,
-0.0185703635,
0.0092626018,
0.0030180651,
-0.0438194312,
0.0260109827,
-0.0078013004,
0.0315499455,
-0.0322726518,
0.0008784265,
0.0104428781,
-0.0098217474,
-0.0128632011,
0.0064180233,
0.0275957026,
0.0300044473,
-0.0089880796,
0.0730524659,
-0.0016732578,
0.0106962128,
-0.0065239109,
0.0751311705,
0.0105116935,
-0.0927351266,
0.0381925441,
-0.0221648477,
0.0166457202,
-0.0503294617,
-0.0079181306,
0.0076988824,
-0.0635620505,
-0.075565733,
-0.0527869202,
-0.0599194653,
0.0087215705,
0.0245181601,
0.0307073053,
0.0323823951,
-0.0185616855,
0.0040748818,
-0.0369645953,
0.0421287455,
-0.0420722775,
0.014282383,
-0.0241851881,
0.0115193203,
0.0380037576,
-0.0604799949,
-0.003188133,
0.008808176,
-0.0546493903,
-0.0652540326,
-0.0255286545,
0.0208507739,
0.0245336778,
0.0640533939,
-0.0209098794,
-0.0563673489,
-0.0090612285,
-0.0098860366,
-0.0096028261,
0.0339967236,
0.0132479966,
0.0253129601,
-0.035941489,
0.022544045,
-0.0581413843,
0.0114379451,
-0.0086025493,
0.0401284285,
-0.0570212156,
-0.0908174887,
-0.0011681895,
0.0014335421,
-0.0146217877,
-0.0665330291,
-0.0229936447,
-0.0256552547,
-0.0075094309,
-0.0238164067,
-0.0024623757,
-0.0319689699,
-0.069278121,
0.0341308303,
-0.0230453331,
0.0057281605,
0.0007091179,
-0.0762015209,
0.0127426973,
-0.027464265,
0.0172780156,
-0.0322100855,
0.0299345553,
-0.0114387255,
0.0278914869,
-0.0148054436,
0.0181408376,
-0.000287643,
0.0268277656,
-0.0154751167,
0.0623622686,
-0.0153143071,
0.0287729967,
0.0181072336,
0.0489282236,
-0.0337268747,
0.0396373942,
0.0070696794,
0.0020383415,
0.0785656944,
-0.0342539512,
0.1016374305,
0.0028842674,
0.0047009285,
-0.0244661607,
0.0389858484,
0.0520048887,
-0.0127806393,
0.0073229354,
-0.0004953408,
0.0035500773,
0.0508564003,
0.0718091875,
0.0172367673,
-0.0184632894,
-0.009994708,
-0.0351018086,
-0.0232776012,
0.0082774805,
0.0009418963,
0.0268420856,
-0.0152453883,
-0.0160409193,
-0.066068992,
-0.075167574,
0.0129338531,
-0.0005014056,
-0.0098909438,
-0.0285615064,
-0.0104307616,
0.0600700192,
-0.0478034317,
-0.0176932011,
-0.0459674969,
0.0211573057,
-0.0035033613,
-0.0046814703,
-0.0423357412,
-6.039107003e-33,
-0.0343929939,
-0.0206673294,
0.0100389654,
0.0017850391,
0.0168080516,
-0.0065283198,
-0.0144721316,
-0.0246508308,
-0.0052665826,
-0.0117305936,
-0.0312453583,
-0.0063278833,
0.0266584456,
-0.0148706418,
-0.0093632229,
-0.001807259,
0.065045312,
0.0426458046,
-0.014610867,
0.0090120574,
0.0209336095,
0.0004003052,
0.0560654998,
-0.1077326089,
0.0781040415,
-0.0764440075,
-0.0242327657,
0.001584595,
0.0577722676,
0.0453282669,
0.0004868932,
0.0213488545,
0.0270558372,
-0.0273322593,
-0.0075708018,
0.0169089269,
-0.0857082233,
0.0249222051,
0.0565550476,
0.0549421161,
0.0644066557,
-0.0828756616,
0.0275660474,
-0.0411000922,
-0.0255973376,
0.0115695475,
0.0523233376,
-0.0478157289,
-0.0059487773,
0.017194543,
-0.0405401476,
0.0329164118,
-0.0191312172,
0.0246490631,
0.038036108,
0.0522273853,
-0.0290023386,
0.0423462503,
-0.0583183318,
0.0318330638,
-0.0201486144,
-0.011352744,
0.0759548396,
0.0333762653,
-0.0168373678,
-0.0267167576,
0.0357728228,
0.0148534402,
0.0302028786,
-0.0720944852,
0.0282151699,
-0.0069857538,
0.0117552979,
0.0992923379,
0.00964827,
-0.002774264,
-0.0415491313,
0.0221490767,
0.0037344946,
-0.0219602436,
0.0504346378,
0.0150575014,
-0.0321276374,
-0.033153493,
-0.0592793263,
-0.0355629511,
-0.0155462483,
-0.0364651568,
0.0190208983,
-0.0132743614,
-0.0093756197,
0.0046683094,
0.09553992,
-0.0486308523,
0.0355861522,
-0.0048122616,
-0.0479199439,
0.0176489037,
-0.0009441199,
0.0667485222,
-0.0043746606,
0.0040330668,
0.0216694903,
0.0018452867,
0.0161342453,
-0.0024481253,
0.0239309929,
0.0369712189,
-0.0329577513,
-0.0112179676,
-0.000552025,
-0.0117471498,
-0.0843472481,
0.0139958085,
0.0190268792,
0.0394633785,
0.0027364607,
0.0360036604,
0.0525382794,
0.0282070078,
0.0039861063,
-0.0452022888,
0.0233981796,
0.0293976311,
-0.0478563458,
0.0219983198,
0.0473178439,
0.0014926788,
0.0710541829,
-0.0257688984,
-0.0189035069,
-0.00651997,
2.657e-7,
0.0602409951,
0.043754939,
-0.0268255714,
-0.0242818631,
0.0427262709,
0.0146228829,
0.0027454693,
0.0083702588,
0.0327287428,
0.0199405309,
0.0168671217,
0.0299043935,
0.0718603283,
0.0268756449,
-0.0592644289,
-0.0280994922,
-0.0391437635,
0.037103679,
-0.0311976988,
0.0561696924,
-0.0018673058,
0.0825486779,
0.003679256,
0.0142706251,
-0.0485008173,
-0.0584701076,
0.0772905797,
-0.076513052,
-0.0446378589,
0.024412604,
0.0202006418,
0.0286662448,
-0.0309982132,
0.0404008701,
-0.0181222167,
0.0391160846,
0.045027595,
0.1073054746,
-0.0305637736,
-0.0094817756,
-0.0162225068,
-0.0110156881,
-0.0447581001,
-0.0262185242,
0.0409037136,
0.0199742783,
-0.0208799485,
0.0160656758,
-0.0330135338,
0.0278980583,
0.008354133,
-0.0103192823,
-0.0474488214,
0.0278464574,
0.0511001498,
-0.0260012131,
-0.0619975813,
-0.0357957445,
-0.0221889466,
-0.0069744745,
-0.0272810813,
-0.0355136842,
0.010752649,
-0.0329585895,
0.0089640524,
-0.0363373272,
0.0518242829,
2.368945985e-34,
0.056575086,
0.0218260176,
-0.0104987584,
-0.0187452063,
0.026802795,
0.0024514727,
-0.0329005159,
0.0237434804,
0.0379971713,
-0.0507798865,
-0.017170839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.06148v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.06148v1 | A semi-automatic method for document classification in the shipping industry | 2023-03-29T10:00:43 | 2023-03-29T10:00:43 | Narayanan Arvind | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In the shipping industry, document classification plays a crucial role in
ensuring that the necessary documents are properly identified and processed for
customs clearance. OCR technology is being used to automate the process of
document classification, which involves identifying important documents such as
Commercial Invoices, Packing Lists, Export/Import Customs Declarations, Bills
of Lading, Sea Waybills, Certificates, Air or Rail Waybills, Arrival Notices,
Certificate of Origin, Importer Security Filings, and Letters of Credit. By
using OCR technology, the shipping industry can improve accuracy and efficiency
in document classification and streamline the customs clearance process. The
aim of this study is to build a robust document classification system based on
keyword frequencies. The research is carried out by analyzing Contract-Breach
law documents available with IN-D. The documents were collected by scraping the
Singapore Government Judiciary website. The database developed has 250
Contract-Breach documents. These documents are splitted to generate 200
training documents and 50 test documents. A semi-automatic approach is used to
select keyword vectors for document classification. The accuracy of the
reported model is 92.00 %. | [
0.0262031481,
0.0236997139,
-0.0075193024,
0.0170224532,
-0.0380911939,
0.0256151445,
0.0313653462,
0.0852141008,
-0.0014394135,
-0.0653342754,
0.0139184454,
-0.003078656,
0.0079383776,
0.0441469885,
-0.0397528261,
0.0081038838,
0.0213805418,
-0.0044100373,
0.0179512724,
0.0229964275,
0.0053209942,
0.0056749051,
0.0145815099,
-0.0045716749,
-0.000462834,
0.0322260037,
-0.0249361284,
-0.0293445699,
-0.041590631,
-0.0093227541,
0.0052302792,
0.0493093729,
0.0362856798,
0.0382867716,
0.0000017044,
-0.0525117926,
-0.062273223,
0.0127441091,
-0.0302301124,
0.0202719625,
0.091906324,
-0.0500983484,
-0.0286844317,
-0.0214070585,
0.0129838409,
-0.031782303,
0.0171022229,
0.0673644468,
0.0420955122,
0.1054816097,
-0.0188823491,
-0.0352976881,
0.007443611,
0.0131832408,
-0.0185560696,
-0.0599757023,
0.020178644,
0.0170598514,
0.0191898122,
0.0167278945,
-0.0101663573,
-0.0046495865,
-0.0385000594,
-0.009444573,
0.0291068126,
-0.0097804405,
-0.0330088958,
0.0187540445,
-0.0023299786,
-0.0155826127,
-0.0292861424,
-0.0251371022,
0.0122004254,
-0.0298841,
0.0086106127,
-0.0172971692,
-0.0114966426,
0.0274653621,
-0.0408980474,
-0.0106868232,
0.0293597542,
0.046217408,
-0.0699053034,
0.0236357972,
-0.0313965566,
0.0179668274,
-0.0168405063,
-0.0352529101,
0.0130129168,
-0.0460714251,
0.0156800449,
-0.0282607414,
0.0319311991,
0.0068928339,
0.0715709329,
0.0008741564,
-0.024322154,
-0.0580310412,
0.0891216323,
-0.1081676111,
-0.0001270543,
-0.0092450678,
-0.0030915153,
0.0424329564,
-0.0115621779,
0.070674859,
0.0409659073,
0.0589491464,
-0.0025260793,
0.0163091682,
-0.0401915982,
-0.019955704,
-0.0498530976,
0.0607572421,
-0.002595841,
-0.0286721345,
-0.0462037325,
-0.0029592246,
0.0171329938,
-0.0199359469,
0.0244252719,
-0.0333176404,
0.0019751373,
0.0003544132,
-0.0294627752,
-0.0498769954,
-0.0130300652,
0.0032753497,
-0.0404128246,
0.0316131525,
0.0694325268,
0.0240153018,
0.045940686,
0.0059595513,
0.0212716088,
0.0014958415,
-0.0319590122,
-0.0258069951,
-0.0748314187,
-0.0187695716,
0.0038939994,
-0.0066525205,
-0.0240605101,
-0.0246641431,
-0.0464521274,
-0.0414131992,
-0.0294983406,
0.0268602669,
0.0091630248,
0.0269985534,
0.0019084868,
0.0399343744,
-0.0281818677,
-0.0228703711,
0.070235759,
-0.0145185953,
0.0577754006,
-0.0163267702,
-0.0094777113,
0.049188301,
0.0558953322,
-0.0458670668,
0.0597710162,
0.0200201906,
-0.059756387,
-0.0830616131,
-0.0048918924,
-0.0100851385,
0.0165907405,
-0.012107702,
0.0290226508,
-0.0213555917,
-0.0179116596,
0.0127151385,
0.0023625917,
0.0291620158,
0.0209841859,
0.013670709,
-0.0444430225,
0.0579827987,
0.004167899,
0.0011922854,
0.0582712181,
-0.009143916,
-0.0064517097,
0.0043734694,
-0.0574514605,
-0.0262691695,
0.0012907878,
-0.0482506938,
-0.0291355066,
-0.00158635,
-0.0193840954,
-0.0129817752,
0.0931396186,
0.0307977535,
-0.0550169535,
-0.0324732214,
-0.0150243538,
-0.0397273079,
-0.0664922521,
-0.0220759585,
0.0228019319,
0.0241757259,
0.0775749907,
-0.0272535607,
0.0012571455,
-0.0174635537,
-0.0328466706,
0.0190038439,
0.0034117147,
-0.0164097063,
-0.0468347184,
-0.0557062626,
-0.0200396888,
0.0743307099,
-0.0045659342,
-0.0088216197,
0.004573721,
0.013353942,
0.0293933377,
-0.0346003063,
-0.0462593585,
0.0333075225,
0.0885271206,
-0.0597481132,
0.0227728803,
0.026517557,
0.0380623154,
0.0042333878,
-0.005398164,
-0.009452275,
0.0469440296,
0.0126941875,
-0.0088500762,
-0.0227108281,
0.0391223915,
0.1056910828,
0.0293176565,
0.0115436576,
0.0093512684,
-0.0007528659,
-0.0320451222,
-0.0074795489,
-0.0377605371,
0.0132219223,
-0.0299015306,
-0.073837325,
0.0397519842,
-0.0510446578,
0.0278266966,
-0.047653757,
0.0581316948,
0.0649222583,
0.0070470097,
-0.055870831,
-0.0355366617,
0.0550596155,
-0.0000658442,
-0.0008224894,
0.022793334,
-0.065350458,
0.0261352006,
0.0055163219,
0.0203416366,
0.0051023825,
-0.0315147825,
-0.0384982638,
-0.0018491626,
0.01003577,
0.0124801779,
0.0055044042,
-0.0264540948,
-0.0230771527,
-0.0109199537,
0.0063734576,
-0.0302098971,
-0.0048093963,
-0.0506088585,
0.0287576485,
-0.0224594139,
-0.0379428752,
0.027786063,
-0.0245885011,
0.0116177648,
0.0102503141,
0.0660257936,
-0.0582887903,
-0.0677261725,
0.0436350256,
0.0109991403,
-0.033750888,
-0.000754616,
-0.0239809286,
-0.0394162163,
-0.0314266644,
-0.0711026341,
0.0316692926,
0.0477946326,
0.004744574,
0.0230751764,
-0.0294160992,
-0.0188502539,
-0.0146426037,
-0.0106758028,
0.0443988256,
0.0399852134,
-0.0095061725,
0.0373697281,
-0.0396776684,
-0.0189165752,
0.0400360338,
0.0253529437,
-0.0272206757,
0.0250019636,
0.0191468298,
-0.0539525524,
-0.0252648462,
-0.0223262627,
0.0380189642,
0.0500522479,
-0.021288082,
-0.0052218763,
-0.0013391185,
0.0248066224,
-0.1175804958,
0.002172132,
-0.021952454,
0.0471260287,
-0.042676013,
0.0189583506,
0.0424340405,
-0.0539458543,
0.0696225837,
-0.0007252897,
0.0856194943,
-0.0073568099,
0.0246330108,
-0.0200862084,
0.0357825905,
-0.0256905891,
0.0122101866,
-0.0251054354,
-0.0239006802,
0.0308890939,
0.0105714686,
-0.0058739362,
0.0066021103,
-0.0044314009,
0.0910140276,
-0.0153009025,
0.0621034354,
0.0003303023,
-0.0056220223,
-0.0036792108,
0.0714634955,
-0.0050138957,
-0.0703981221,
-0.0042487853,
0.0106291063,
-0.0522403717,
-0.0222451463,
-0.0000335364,
-0.0072778319,
0.0280881599,
-0.0020244275,
-0.0065003093,
-0.0791560858,
0.0234966595,
0.0098474333,
-0.0930910856,
-0.042225603,
0.0169585142,
0.0311433747,
0.0541413091,
-0.0281412695,
-0.0368236266,
0.016921049,
-0.0420699976,
-0.0049781268,
0.0245164111,
-0.0327584147,
0.0520420671,
0.0134583376,
0.0102194734,
-0.0519460291,
0.0052065346,
-0.0102198618,
-0.0316733718,
0.0863626674,
0.0251628831,
-0.0299968049,
-0.078675881,
-0.0484983288,
-0.0225117151,
-0.0087666465,
-0.0397749841,
-0.0011958069,
-0.0125082321,
-0.066805914,
0.0109460857,
-0.0481316783,
0.0204558391,
-0.001302766,
-0.0031908141,
-0.0181068555,
0.0163907893,
0.0177919436,
-0.0631653741,
-0.0398317613,
0.0046876012,
-0.0326173641,
-0.0097023528,
-0.0173127465,
0.0148497978,
0.0383912362,
0.0305882525,
-0.009119493,
-0.0024091657,
-0.0180229619,
0.035363432,
0.0233329795,
0.0329876393,
-0.0107391216,
-0.0297614764,
-0.0280481167,
-0.0221689977,
-0.0489892736,
-0.0304757673,
-0.0387487747,
0.0044856807,
-0.0486334823,
-0.013198209,
0.0199238081,
0.0262504872,
0.0546341799,
0.0152701735,
-0.0846203268,
-0.1049611792,
-0.0646403879,
-0.0085783098,
-0.0231889673,
0.0504535474,
-0.0223932005,
0.0259825382,
-0.004213071,
0.0084957536,
-0.0274306405,
-0.0472953618,
-0.0242207441,
0.0216965321,
-0.0667274967,
0.0330970995,
-0.0079072602,
-0.0121062696,
-0.0343596675,
-0.0151483724,
-0.0134282354,
-0.0174713619,
0.0436845645,
-0.0275890362,
0.0179598685,
-0.0552689843,
-0.0207150932,
-0.0615567267,
0.0316943787,
0.0419050828,
0.0003056438,
-0.0695382431,
0.0264503062,
-0.062457554,
-0.0525810905,
-0.0280778743,
0.0010251538,
0.0293496586,
-0.0183969345,
-0.0674605444,
-0.0304880738,
-0.0026328187,
0.0209565572,
0.0408543013,
-0.0155007932,
-0.0086995,
0.0035439173,
-0.036258176,
0.0324458331,
0.0254368931,
-0.0043538073,
0.0483716838,
0.0179125722,
0.0077206772,
-0.0205829721,
-0.0063066138,
0.0637296513,
-0.0047580106,
-0.0170985032,
0.0361120366,
0.05023643,
0.0189317819,
0.0465969257,
-0.0234804023,
-0.014891264,
0.0000553459,
-0.0253292378,
0.0182298198,
0.0422527269,
-0.0228389706,
0.0260859728,
0.0038849106,
0.0084582781,
-0.0366777405,
-0.0015286913,
-0.010297074,
0.0268598348,
-0.0368393064,
0.0339551009,
0.0609561987,
-0.0356097855,
-0.065453954,
-0.0517119393,
0.0011097651,
0.0035980118,
0.0049756197,
0.0095822429,
0.0193845909,
-0.032078959,
0.028528247,
-0.0154970456,
0.035002593,
0.0625668317,
-0.0032586223,
-0.043496348,
0.0157206822,
-0.0558095425,
-0.0505049638,
0.032781437,
0.0813922882,
0.031391412,
-0.0246133301,
-0.022002466,
0.0059842221,
0.0183716994,
0.0747429579,
0.0032474508,
0.0099316305,
-0.0165804774,
0.0049824626,
0.0770073384,
0.0020491304,
0.0451161936,
-0.0216750987,
-0.0283690728,
0.001322197,
0.0104325693,
0.0080125285,
-4.919937566e-33,
0.0163422599,
-0.0687292889,
-0.007991259,
0.0757088661,
0.0425069742,
-0.0186407436,
0.0249074604,
-0.0458499342,
0.0462615378,
-0.0244713239,
-0.0192110762,
-0.0101090809,
0.0563035533,
-0.003600216,
0.024862105,
0.0272773672,
0.0020755753,
0.0072554364,
-0.0011310744,
-0.0260055847,
0.0176469404,
0.020473497,
0.0461307541,
-0.0463784337,
0.0549640022,
-0.0000176708,
-0.0456948243,
-0.0213908833,
0.0187236313,
0.0388267674,
0.0006084552,
0.0193350725,
0.0339536443,
0.0048841592,
0.0230862685,
0.0265658945,
-0.0342822596,
0.0060352618,
-0.0324192457,
0.0522803515,
0.1035138294,
-0.0163159631,
0.018187318,
-0.0483556651,
-0.038201794,
0.0260922667,
0.0480068028,
-0.0093916105,
-0.0731695667,
-0.0468841195,
-0.0734225661,
0.0644938871,
0.0154908923,
0.0427467041,
0.0925898552,
-0.0023171818,
-0.0112721119,
-0.0388110206,
-0.0301783457,
0.0177695639,
0.0410448238,
0.0191058293,
-0.0009846126,
-0.01971047,
-0.0154727949,
-0.0242837649,
-0.005272001,
0.0132926032,
0.0488532074,
-0.0064991992,
0.0361417979,
0.0105777318,
0.0139102358,
0.0380626582,
0.099200137,
-0.0424358658,
0.0057116551,
0.0538236089,
0.0333368853,
0.0094396155,
0.0304025467,
0.0038972488,
-0.0703738183,
0.0133916494,
0.0234290324,
-0.0239674989,
-0.0141514605,
-0.008418167,
0.0091198348,
0.0368646197,
0.0021230653,
-0.0355060883,
-0.0005988889,
0.0033788795,
-0.0279744603,
-0.0390102379,
0.0244561546,
0.0520740077,
-0.020157475,
-0.0300563108,
-0.0251619834,
-0.0022757815,
0.0185782313,
-0.0304916054,
-0.0247304384,
-0.0107618654,
0.0434499644,
-0.0112176165,
-0.0447626784,
0.0302018318,
0.0383719727,
-0.0038837674,
0.0501998514,
0.0568714924,
-0.0352395102,
-0.0204986576,
0.0546087846,
-0.0206095912,
0.0146189369,
-0.0076395604,
-0.0125655718,
-0.006977675,
-0.0186672006,
-0.0154925566,
0.0061475076,
0.0297211912,
-0.0270579979,
0.0195566826,
0.0163645037,
0.0290714707,
0.0143351341,
0.0894714668,
2.267e-7,
0.0539170168,
0.0433785953,
0.024882406,
0.0322328024,
-0.0139272381,
0.0079222322,
0.0258730035,
-0.0062270933,
-0.0338560343,
0.0421454087,
0.0557473116,
-0.0676223934,
0.0477117449,
0.0318315253,
-0.0820788965,
-0.0466554984,
0.008587962,
-0.0405618139,
-0.0556904227,
0.021125352,
0.0316549055,
0.032842353,
-0.0210147314,
-0.0641492978,
-0.0172669385,
-0.0016576236,
-0.0177653935,
-0.002161544,
0.0093292352,
0.003882726,
0.0391128361,
-0.0105620911,
-0.0193633642,
0.0880919024,
-0.0089515923,
0.0219735149,
0.0136228325,
0.0074136062,
-0.0375602618,
0.0441022329,
-0.0089566289,
-0.0187554732,
-0.0104780886,
-0.0421292484,
0.0293109734,
0.0350606889,
-0.001889435,
-0.0254873894,
-0.0077889403,
-0.0126566738,
0.0147570716,
-0.0088089062,
-0.0442646742,
0.0335402638,
0.0429154411,
-0.0258421134,
0.0255947541,
-0.0488029718,
0.0790935308,
-0.0041385614,
0.0008033152,
0.0570737906,
-0.0167698432,
0.0038056406,
0.0864232257,
-0.0143416841,
0.0522834398,
2.101893643e-34,
0.013272291,
-0.0168007091,
-0.0400127023,
0.0457511507,
0.030497605,
-0.0024885272,
0.029271666,
0.0230558515,
-0.0371932425,
-0.0641091466,
0.0319976695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16537v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16537v2 | LMExplainer: a Knowledge-Enhanced Explainer for Language Models | 2023-03-29T08:59:44 | 2023-08-03T23:23:43 | Zichen Chen, Ambuj K Singh, Misha Sra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 are very powerful and can process
different kinds of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, it can be
difficult to interpret the results due to the multi-layer nonlinear model
structure and millions of parameters. A lack of clarity and understanding of
how the language models (LMs) work can make them unreliable, difficult to
trust, and potentially dangerous for use in real-world scenarios. Most recent
works exploit attention weights to provide explanations for LM predictions.
However, pure attention-based explanations are unable to support the growing
complexity of LMs, and cannot reason about their decision-making processes. We
propose LMExplainer, a knowledge-enhanced explainer for LMs that can provide
human-understandable explanations. We use a knowledge graph (KG) and a graph
attention neural network to extract the key decision signals of the LM. We
further explore whether interpretation can also help the AI understand the task
better. Our experimental results show that LMExplainer outperforms existing
LM+KG methods on CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA. We compare the explanation
results with generated explanation methods and human-annotated results. The
comparison shows our method can provide more comprehensive and clearer
explanations. LMExplainer demonstrates the potential to enhance model
performance and furnish explanations for the LM reasoning process in natural
language. | [
0.0318702012,
0.0258320402,
-0.0198797733,
0.0621889457,
-0.0155920731,
-0.009197996,
-0.0074811657,
0.0020448146,
0.0356121846,
-0.0273243524,
0.0349079333,
0.0133744488,
-0.0009632897,
0.0504091568,
0.0462620221,
-0.0556130409,
0.0006249649,
-0.0257151574,
0.0428940393,
0.0060971137,
0.0183567014,
0.0492386036,
0.0214053914,
0.0695121363,
0.0217918418,
-0.0109485285,
-0.0214972049,
0.000388978,
-0.0042622737,
-0.0148786902,
-0.0151302554,
0.0169861875,
0.0453288071,
0.0159690715,
0.0000021848,
-0.0251423735,
0.0141921928,
0.0058372449,
-0.0570966713,
0.0157017149,
-0.0155759268,
-0.0230138563,
0.0430369265,
0.0129796527,
-0.0083424468,
0.0192003176,
0.0406039059,
0.0622758381,
0.0601856709,
0.0577111728,
0.0040930863,
-0.0459404774,
-0.0077344775,
-0.0244682822,
0.015242462,
-0.0673402846,
0.0053173201,
0.0053385617,
0.0061141234,
-0.0041885655,
-0.0241470989,
0.0030338611,
0.0346906409,
-0.0397986583,
0.0364270471,
0.0284512471,
-0.0001500015,
-0.0116815688,
-0.0016927839,
0.0967335701,
-0.0199557915,
-0.0484969653,
-0.0024886485,
-0.0246098321,
0.0067522312,
0.034767177,
-0.0650199577,
0.0010083005,
-0.0003609564,
0.0208037961,
0.0232231505,
-0.0075636059,
0.070360288,
0.0231252015,
-0.0251647066,
0.1036173552,
-0.0148978485,
-0.0035509276,
0.0037457014,
-0.0225125402,
-0.0451354608,
-0.0444111563,
0.0147902751,
0.0818998441,
-0.0123683969,
0.0340275988,
0.0181134697,
0.0030896582,
0.0147073474,
-0.062153101,
0.0168527849,
0.0394898281,
-0.001878903,
0.0617958941,
0.0029653884,
0.0614079237,
-0.0215459056,
0.0116647631,
-0.0149729419,
-0.0321209766,
-0.0695487708,
-0.037717104,
-0.0122921672,
0.002567587,
-0.0466361195,
-0.032090947,
-0.0089733964,
0.0188628398,
-0.0211771838,
-0.0059009059,
0.0490002148,
0.0435304195,
0.0034612508,
-0.0452876352,
-0.0729990155,
0.0368819833,
-0.0448398218,
0.0076097813,
0.0115053756,
-0.0289710779,
-0.0395213068,
0.0190937854,
0.0180649757,
-0.0120164342,
-0.0279162135,
0.0603402853,
0.0259300843,
0.0151852351,
-0.0352985188,
-0.0471757688,
-0.0199488159,
-0.0640276223,
-0.0421198271,
-0.0290186927,
0.0093905693,
0.0062913643,
-0.0198981781,
-0.0382432602,
0.0216839612,
-0.0041211233,
-0.0637205765,
0.072440289,
-0.0221812688,
0.0267831106,
-0.0030058003,
0.0019317616,
-0.0372703597,
0.0267880931,
0.0126005923,
0.004891206,
0.0247478746,
-0.037752524,
0.0414343216,
-0.0039695879,
0.0281695165,
-0.0236069821,
0.003610909,
-0.0112831956,
-0.0797084197,
0.0360422023,
0.0360706039,
0.0134450374,
-0.0038367617,
0.0144753633,
0.0604440533,
0.0469771549,
0.0240179896,
0.0333478041,
0.032648135,
0.0438281335,
-0.0087752715,
0.0071377689,
-0.0718499646,
0.0358797871,
-0.0372452848,
0.0135659883,
0.0139392866,
-0.0041810325,
0.0104000093,
-0.0387463681,
-0.0130366813,
0.0085550323,
0.0438509993,
0.0109964954,
0.0539758541,
-0.0228491072,
-0.0405314714,
0.0535509624,
0.0416590758,
-0.0105245356,
-0.0023384464,
-0.0461565331,
0.0374968126,
0.0986633673,
0.0360402912,
-0.0084431246,
-0.0119077507,
-0.0106294593,
-0.0225051064,
0.0340562873,
0.0219575576,
0.029059723,
-0.0093393466,
-0.0539083853,
-0.0350780822,
-0.0539170206,
0.0279525705,
0.013827892,
0.0139153898,
-0.022092266,
0.0283665024,
-0.0789948925,
-0.0736476183,
0.0051588337,
0.0150169432,
-0.0339652747,
0.0017450347,
-0.0101741673,
0.0304474644,
0.0356233269,
0.046796497,
0.0309153125,
0.0202651825,
-0.0172683839,
-0.0347716361,
0.0387877002,
-0.0254087336,
-0.0261422358,
0.0295832083,
-0.0214749221,
0.0009496062,
0.0204361789,
-0.0468825139,
-0.0675708279,
0.0539355949,
-0.0357340239,
0.0711019933,
-0.0228561834,
-0.0134147201,
0.0037354853,
0.0116242692,
-0.0068838149,
0.0984573439,
0.0061588129,
-0.0008463927,
0.0028361438,
0.0185333434,
-0.0086086215,
-0.018341979,
0.0454042926,
-0.0040180474,
-0.0058029573,
-0.0066071069,
0.0079289759,
-0.0167274065,
-0.0261818822,
0.0324547142,
-0.0392864048,
-0.0090245418,
-0.0238080155,
0.0088763116,
0.015190227,
-0.0182070397,
0.0148402462,
-0.0125596644,
-0.0272754431,
0.0240971427,
0.0004769289,
-0.0077219484,
0.0398337767,
-0.0224732887,
-0.0208027363,
-0.0396550559,
-0.0079813367,
-0.0391828418,
0.0722195506,
0.0330990143,
0.0034764637,
-0.0562632047,
-0.0008090943,
-0.0270581543,
-0.0097233159,
-0.0393477753,
-0.034021873,
0.0172642097,
-0.0044405195,
0.0078918003,
0.0319820754,
-0.003640708,
0.0747018009,
0.0557358153,
0.008969414,
-0.0721225888,
0.0121127348,
-0.0316551253,
0.002721674,
-0.0404994674,
-0.0315914154,
-0.0058638393,
0.0738369748,
0.0156237436,
-0.0101083815,
-0.0920400769,
0.0189340673,
0.022846682,
0.0116451383,
-0.0378321782,
-0.0412938409,
-0.0127460836,
0.0320073627,
-0.0380208269,
-0.0489914194,
0.0959407315,
-0.0210214499,
0.0146622593,
-0.0146033429,
-0.0209815633,
-0.0488449782,
0.0749207512,
-0.0008860943,
0.0067532789,
0.0191621333,
-0.012236828,
0.0138829118,
-0.0194808543,
0.0189069752,
-0.0039273426,
0.0311536379,
-0.0442773327,
-0.0113398638,
0.029605478,
0.0372703187,
-0.0115792342,
-0.0133220125,
-0.0602137372,
0.0099402154,
0.0425146185,
-0.0302186385,
-0.0044179112,
0.0068967487,
0.0311692171,
0.0034100015,
-0.0304513406,
0.0173152424,
-0.0208492223,
0.00087795,
0.0421392284,
0.0536140352,
0.0503913164,
-0.0193786044,
0.0086360611,
0.012021875,
0.0028128852,
-0.0219107345,
-0.031784758,
-0.009395455,
-0.0140428152,
-0.0417386368,
-0.0243684854,
0.0066677011,
0.0495540537,
-0.1104265153,
0.0328711681,
0.1273393482,
0.0220909119,
-0.0436081216,
0.0175154321,
-0.0190095641,
-0.0026342408,
0.0241411943,
0.0139943045,
-0.0505336337,
-0.0517281853,
-0.0132587003,
0.0311758965,
0.0317191556,
-0.0013257382,
-0.0106549235,
-0.0699848905,
0.0361521803,
-0.0070627532,
-0.0361008234,
-0.0576185137,
-0.0702219456,
-0.0267729219,
-0.0104468726,
-0.007676736,
-0.0077854893,
0.0272487048,
0.0173093192,
0.0099689681,
-0.0372200646,
-0.0327796713,
0.0457984246,
-0.0371098034,
0.0479823351,
0.0308316592,
0.0664975494,
-0.0047528651,
-0.0415010527,
0.0046165013,
-0.0017627763,
0.0097608762,
-0.0129963048,
0.0384372212,
0.0189910177,
-0.0002818066,
-0.0614392757,
0.0351015925,
-0.0655766353,
-0.0236490667,
-0.0122132888,
0.0987033471,
-0.008233319,
-0.0487177223,
0.0149971666,
0.0030072629,
-0.0048178765,
0.1000917628,
0.0660887063,
0.0201145485,
-0.0642024875,
-0.062888138,
-0.0022248337,
-0.044663962,
-0.0386319235,
0.015278291,
0.0313390046,
-0.0139676193,
-0.01325069,
-0.032429751,
0.028879514,
-0.0154939489,
0.0215280615,
-0.0109918676,
0.0090187881,
-0.0157423783,
-0.0191994589,
0.0663490221,
0.0084360279,
0.005720587,
-0.0062072291,
-0.025464179,
0.0066598556,
-0.0300523136,
-0.000549821,
0.0259584654,
-0.0195863899,
-0.0503914356,
-0.0365512036,
0.0211357549,
0.0241127927,
0.054238569,
-0.0439532399,
-0.0666052401,
0.0163866524,
-0.013438792,
-0.0494281985,
-0.0376055017,
0.0322387069,
0.0106849205,
0.0149732335,
0.0630783588,
-0.0399436019,
-0.0248810761,
-0.0186147336,
0.0397795774,
-0.0636196136,
-0.0450881869,
0.0301532578,
0.0164645668,
0.014291212,
-0.0185906459,
-0.0312025119,
-0.0316577293,
-0.0014660163,
-0.008259858,
-0.0166090019,
-0.0377798118,
0.0074759228,
0.0197036881,
-0.0574942827,
-0.0107857436,
-0.0439784937,
-0.0108557148,
-0.0242042467,
-0.029711714,
0.0163557623,
0.0059909048,
-0.0187093299,
-0.0068802298,
0.0020304634,
-0.0085011991,
0.0053763436,
-0.0326390788,
0.0388742499,
-0.0026175531,
0.0605677404,
0.0050036558,
-0.0153517732,
-0.0060701659,
-0.0151719749,
-0.0536874533,
-0.066290535,
0.0319112502,
-0.0061419723,
0.0349360332,
-0.0253044814,
0.0752801523,
-0.0020246946,
-0.0120700747,
0.0091749365,
0.0799315721,
0.0051785056,
-0.0187126063,
0.0259647425,
0.0227682441,
-0.0526446998,
-0.0031725047,
0.0764745325,
0.0347905569,
0.0154224001,
0.0341276228,
-0.0471580029,
-0.0107173417,
-0.025979178,
0.0017511841,
0.085574612,
-0.00698611,
0.0333889835,
-0.0609101653,
-0.0610107295,
-0.0220641419,
-0.0219545756,
-0.0203028023,
-0.0345391296,
0.0137232412,
0.0467692912,
-0.0087864567,
-0.0631497577,
-0.0448961705,
0.0287512988,
-0.0558524095,
0.0246750526,
-0.0183221474,
-6.669439767e-33,
-0.0153733231,
-0.0792707056,
-0.0130128264,
-0.0143046631,
-0.0047099618,
-0.0078428313,
-0.0876618996,
-0.0328671336,
-0.0330208503,
0.0472680703,
0.0204884242,
0.0457493216,
-0.0044313958,
0.013719473,
0.0033810572,
-0.033572115,
0.0032228869,
0.0435450338,
-0.0011658003,
0.0417275988,
0.0599364154,
0.0180797521,
0.0662230477,
-0.0461986773,
0.0692510381,
0.0099337958,
-0.0032611839,
0.0101842461,
-0.0440742895,
0.0654295459,
-0.0341630392,
0.0521407202,
0.0204008054,
-0.0644173175,
0.0178927444,
0.0211236067,
-0.0523056574,
-0.0149500137,
0.0701749623,
-0.0051616151,
-0.0312372129,
-0.0623344928,
0.0662447512,
0.0199775565,
0.033752054,
-0.0188559182,
0.063108094,
-0.0074651442,
-0.0315734707,
0.0167423971,
-0.0284505878,
0.0284807533,
-0.0568976365,
-0.0146070337,
0.0084848171,
0.0234966427,
-0.00636914,
0.0367101505,
-0.0488949865,
-0.0080170082,
0.0207111016,
0.0049066423,
0.0678529292,
-0.0071675852,
-0.010732457,
0.0381377265,
-0.0341894105,
-0.0317503028,
-0.1063812301,
0.0128965499,
-0.0045413286,
0.0747187138,
0.0789400637,
0.0135053778,
0.0198466219,
0.0056981998,
-0.0650223717,
0.015241907,
-0.0190369077,
0.0585028715,
0.0327544659,
0.0099240365,
-0.0328836516,
-0.036917299,
-0.0231993217,
-0.0442620367,
-0.0470613353,
-0.0215046927,
0.0060464554,
-0.032254383,
-0.0549089573,
-0.0004152673,
-0.0153709315,
-0.0676445886,
0.0298140794,
0.0434525087,
0.0146081708,
-0.0251863021,
0.0277991351,
0.0258056242,
-0.0385911837,
0.0348986387,
0.0043844939,
0.004851419,
0.0183799807,
0.0182411838,
0.0128441015,
0.0013241711,
-0.0012026059,
-0.0058996375,
-0.080833599,
-0.0183803514,
-0.0592986345,
-0.0055346293,
0.0309903994,
0.0322640762,
-0.0325831436,
0.0145666162,
0.0283240732,
0.0367220007,
0.0024499705,
-0.0057530352,
-0.0209192093,
0.0043088929,
-0.0245789327,
-0.0209077913,
-0.0396298319,
0.0078465622,
0.0406096727,
-0.0421624333,
-0.0329406001,
0.0170631092,
2.756e-7,
0.0565592125,
0.0550689697,
0.0138933016,
0.0265476182,
0.0157537796,
0.0387025289,
0.0109396437,
0.0014450338,
-0.0068485206,
-0.0419781022,
0.0129902391,
0.0652388483,
0.0363331959,
0.0013375581,
-0.0276871677,
-0.0078898938,
-0.0555220619,
-0.040380884,
-0.0439652242,
-0.008071309,
0.0557317287,
0.0650529861,
0.0331300497,
0.0154691245,
0.014492196,
-0.032560192,
0.0188528746,
-0.0168051925,
0.0102359476,
-0.0042583128,
0.0663664714,
0.0004754833,
-0.0166685414,
0.0084425835,
-0.0141852256,
0.0202670135,
-0.0254986659,
0.0697886646,
-0.0342471004,
-0.0427898914,
-0.0414609164,
-0.0539638437,
0.0385205224,
-0.1042071059,
0.0826136544,
-0.0076363645,
-0.0478762761,
0.0063004894,
-0.0158702806,
-0.0281906985,
-0.0121112773,
-0.0084951092,
0.0100567853,
-0.0060425303,
-0.024210155,
-0.0585167781,
0.0175122377,
-0.0856797844,
-0.0509253778,
0.0000763384,
-0.0165959485,
0.0362970978,
-0.0435119383,
-0.033810474,
0.0684643909,
-0.045044221,
0.010585798,
2.50214901e-34,
0.0203157011,
0.0324783437,
-0.0006004747,
0.0192019958,
0.0685113296,
0.0279082377,
-0.0197092108,
0.0141886016,
0.0611953512,
-0.0664296672,
-0.0142692234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16528v1 | Building a Knowledge Graph of Distributed Ledger Technologies | 2023-03-29T08:34:01 | 2023-03-29T08:34:01 | Lukas König, Sebastian Neumaier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Distributed ledger systems have become more prominent and successful in
recent years, with a focus on blockchains and cryptocurrency. This has led to
various misunderstandings about both the technology itself and its
capabilities, as in many cases blockchain and cryptocurrency is used
synonymously and other applications are often overlooked. Therefore, as a
whole, the view of distributed ledger technology beyond blockchains and
cryptocurrencies is very limited. Existing vocabularies and ontologies often
focus on single aspects of the technology, or in some cases even just on one
product. This potentially leads to other types of distributed ledgers and their
possible use cases being neglected. In this paper, we present a knowledge graph
and an ontology for distributed ledger technologies, which includes security
considerations to model aspects such as threats and vulnerabilities,
application domains, as well as relevant standards and regulations. Such a
knowledge graph improves the overall understanding of distributed ledgers,
reveals their strengths, and supports the work of security personnel, i.e.
analysts and system architects. We discuss potential uses and follow semantic
web best practices to evaluate and publish the ontology and knowledge graph. | [
0.0351519547,
0.0045477683,
0.0163910687,
0.0202274881,
-0.0415005684,
-0.0222574808,
0.0554867759,
0.0477172844,
0.0544590428,
0.0085806856,
-0.0071573304,
0.0547874235,
0.0336842202,
0.0390110314,
0.0592532866,
-0.0144042755,
0.0283086505,
0.0406294502,
0.0159573779,
-0.0249539204,
0.0274676066,
-0.016175013,
-0.0127170775,
-0.0097421296,
-0.0300817639,
-0.0386070982,
0.0157691743,
-0.0013265118,
0.0178668108,
-0.0090495506,
-0.008157881,
0.0023434791,
-0.0469620042,
0.0320463218,
0.000002088,
-0.0127692251,
-0.0526895039,
0.0459903255,
-0.0717054754,
-0.0274042077,
-0.003089586,
-0.0073380056,
0.0031851081,
0.0211237688,
0.0061141443,
-0.0568199754,
0.0575422905,
0.0775875673,
-0.0239847973,
-0.0184575114,
-0.024055846,
-0.0351613536,
0.0080177961,
0.0076926481,
-0.0206213817,
0.0114112468,
0.0075293626,
0.0828154907,
0.0595047958,
-0.004816059,
0.0024976947,
0.0511860922,
-0.0134167196,
0.0085722404,
0.0744104311,
0.0063696182,
-0.0233500842,
0.0049701082,
-0.017639339,
-0.0091188466,
0.0880228728,
0.036793232,
0.025928501,
-0.0076590562,
-0.0414623693,
0.042869363,
-0.0210238751,
0.0103499908,
-0.0279637575,
0.0075330716,
-0.0419657268,
0.0120097091,
0.0698651746,
0.047394786,
0.0075932192,
0.0831609443,
-0.0037078892,
0.0168573856,
-0.0242523048,
-0.0081194118,
0.0393817015,
-0.0076759038,
0.0128829246,
-0.0270284489,
0.0161470789,
0.0129184984,
0.0376537815,
-0.0301836133,
0.0620670691,
-0.0094708959,
-0.008456476,
-0.0419985317,
0.0051173978,
0.0445758775,
0.0249935072,
-0.007184857,
-0.0625365376,
0.0329005606,
0.0294915456,
-0.0235104561,
-0.0551703274,
-0.0028146128,
0.0109337382,
0.0124189351,
0.0212456658,
0.038514588,
-0.0268095117,
0.0168988127,
-0.0570792295,
0.0284661539,
0.0133123193,
0.0138404891,
0.0453451797,
-0.0166312996,
0.0144938631,
-0.023036385,
-0.0295229945,
0.0209307559,
0.016553415,
0.0540064052,
-0.0133517422,
0.0035256145,
-0.0181712545,
0.0085143438,
0.001693603,
0.1061847657,
0.0886854678,
0.0434713773,
-0.0506416596,
-0.1034868136,
-0.0017301705,
0.0190564934,
-0.0219982099,
-0.0311948527,
-0.031178927,
-0.0148329325,
-0.0104238279,
0.0459572561,
-0.0400427021,
-0.0095726168,
-0.072504662,
0.0251824334,
-0.0804649815,
-0.0529319122,
0.0052128769,
0.0153858764,
-0.0234899614,
-0.0755493417,
0.0058414512,
0.031554427,
0.0666996017,
0.0237314813,
-0.0123856449,
-0.0396169499,
0.0069326768,
-0.0765660554,
0.0339968801,
0.035573449,
0.0283687115,
-0.0415740088,
-0.0660823882,
-0.0256466102,
-0.0138772652,
-0.0115369307,
0.0690018088,
0.0179502759,
0.0144052841,
-0.0025247475,
-0.0372955352,
0.006871195,
0.0099346312,
-0.0267838687,
-0.0566106029,
0.0413226672,
0.0158695262,
-0.0208844952,
-0.0514404923,
-0.0438578986,
-0.0366727449,
-0.0034366511,
-0.0525676943,
-0.0214605201,
0.0247266348,
0.0477292798,
-0.0279883966,
0.0164348129,
-0.0252386015,
0.0199188776,
-0.0088708811,
0.0371071473,
-0.0136406384,
-0.0765950903,
0.032605283,
0.0676675141,
0.0895504206,
0.0005781664,
0.0043766326,
0.016204264,
-0.0437680669,
0.0644757897,
-0.0184432045,
-0.0184175614,
-0.0309180152,
-0.0150579419,
0.0118997609,
0.0318787843,
0.011836173,
-0.020567419,
-0.005019207,
0.0047679087,
-0.0504569598,
-0.0301501658,
0.0230387822,
-0.0261248946,
0.0491776466,
-0.0006175811,
-0.0127167329,
0.0240243692,
0.011505032,
0.0417756811,
0.0196698867,
0.0447859019,
0.0099980813,
0.0828414857,
-0.0684373528,
-0.0192974191,
0.0321541205,
0.0964283496,
0.0132401371,
-0.0380698554,
0.0828720778,
0.0074337958,
0.0243508983,
-0.0045537609,
0.0609294698,
0.0392438769,
-0.0234352816,
0.0128646623,
-0.0766343698,
-0.0006129093,
-0.0141739817,
-0.0248047914,
-0.0017688944,
0.0092766387,
-0.0258860439,
-0.0866877288,
-0.0187077262,
0.0669520125,
0.0562674403,
0.0441070274,
-0.036081221,
-0.0366470702,
0.015872309,
0.0247558262,
-0.0238011032,
-0.0024459036,
0.0386226699,
-0.0134075899,
-0.0290055089,
0.0230442546,
0.0568570979,
-0.0149558056,
0.016589392,
-0.0069352319,
-0.0143431891,
-0.0089403912,
0.035654448,
0.0014302325,
-0.0289167538,
0.0285552572,
0.0346508026,
0.0162646864,
-0.0157921519,
0.0074446024,
0.0148134101,
0.0177051667,
-0.0031381438,
0.0564039871,
0.0638202056,
-0.000571709,
-0.0787091702,
-0.0336801745,
0.0168936737,
0.049133487,
0.0418492258,
0.0595854782,
-0.0357753262,
-0.0493434556,
-0.0298945829,
0.0836819485,
-0.0489185639,
-0.0510093905,
0.0390258357,
-0.0252631269,
0.009703476,
0.0495709293,
-0.044646576,
0.0594313778,
-0.0107658934,
-0.0023404846,
0.0510134734,
-0.010976661,
-0.0388404205,
-0.030939484,
0.0042447159,
0.0283983015,
-0.0211341791,
-0.0189860314,
0.0256953239,
-0.0065561584,
0.0140465088,
-0.0161952879,
-0.0144021641,
-0.0054782783,
0.0399103351,
0.0249265581,
-0.055740431,
-0.0349190533,
0.0625247359,
-0.0542842224,
0.0052545709,
-0.0299774949,
0.0353208482,
0.0080411024,
-0.0666992441,
0.0611119419,
-0.0202415101,
-0.0572846904,
-0.0228721295,
0.0063130404,
0.0205306876,
0.0107407374,
0.0207803156,
0.0308108926,
-0.0205749534,
0.0616515093,
-0.0174411871,
-0.0393410735,
0.0357535891,
-0.0013258659,
0.0184718296,
-0.0156954862,
0.0313425139,
-0.0163491517,
-0.0190182272,
0.0050342772,
-0.0806797147,
-0.1090569869,
0.0669283345,
0.0324655287,
0.0057319445,
0.02094776,
-0.0288173519,
-0.0554386154,
0.0172781628,
-0.0291728675,
0.0121863075,
-0.016713148,
-0.0106256139,
-0.0211605411,
-0.0098557882,
-0.0156202102,
0.0148420632,
0.0346302949,
0.0503474288,
0.0434380509,
0.0030326415,
0.0008547982,
-0.0408276469,
-0.0278165098,
0.0044543296,
-0.1087060943,
0.0600602105,
-0.0297035966,
0.0219826736,
-0.030494839,
-0.0315372907,
-0.0099680573,
0.077772744,
0.0691114739,
-0.0151688149,
-0.0489383824,
-0.0053695212,
-0.0102748508,
-0.0358712897,
-0.0181278493,
-0.034067519,
-0.0615434796,
-0.0110989697,
-0.0232580919,
0.0317438245,
-0.0311599337,
0.0682564527,
0.0106192967,
-0.0321450792,
0.0352091528,
0.0193819255,
0.017044697,
-0.0054457746,
-0.0153568527,
-0.0561994985,
0.0463983789,
-0.0459356271,
-0.0183624234,
-0.0160135608,
0.0392920077,
-0.0223064367,
-0.0233020429,
0.0037750383,
-0.0137721514,
-0.0242209472,
-0.0074599255,
0.0231240727,
-0.0214784238,
-0.0158614852,
-0.0271875467,
-0.0374648795,
0.0396237858,
0.029868992,
-0.0119190542,
0.0253668595,
-0.0196670797,
0.0211672988,
0.0246951263,
-0.0268308651,
0.0713676512,
-0.0081370054,
0.0181479938,
-0.0151598761,
-0.0203760471,
-0.0226728041,
-0.0481833667,
-0.0497627817,
-0.0138114309,
-0.0045040366,
0.1014127433,
-0.0365309715,
-0.0259838197,
-0.0551580228,
-0.0499405488,
0.0384442694,
-0.0008586629,
0.048150681,
-0.0095497146,
-0.0379869454,
-0.0298165735,
0.0245585348,
-0.0601737462,
0.049751237,
0.0084053464,
-0.0284775533,
0.0159852989,
-0.0875339955,
-0.047111813,
0.0004627638,
0.0296730995,
-0.0108116483,
-0.0559671149,
-0.0703900009,
0.0649751201,
-0.0482755564,
-0.0543415621,
-0.0169981364,
-0.0142450286,
0.0330760106,
0.0224178098,
-0.0606930256,
-0.0143794576,
-0.0103320517,
-0.0274386574,
0.0287988279,
0.0100319842,
-0.0181930512,
0.0561924651,
0.0248155016,
-0.0227534678,
0.0076879761,
0.0096576037,
0.0162479021,
-0.0444278009,
-0.0376685932,
-0.0359033123,
-0.0245239977,
0.0136681534,
0.0199847352,
-0.0094450377,
0.009368279,
0.0334423929,
-0.0616014525,
0.0309604201,
-0.0133538079,
0.0126873227,
0.0059880964,
0.0189435463,
-0.0224690065,
0.0070541822,
0.0092384461,
-0.007698691,
-0.0284118447,
-0.03528326,
0.00013847,
0.0205909722,
-0.0081647411,
-0.084202297,
0.0522033647,
0.0382389538,
0.0179559123,
0.0501381233,
-0.0351298898,
-0.033359386,
-0.0033124683,
-0.0117153116,
-0.0066262884,
-0.0271003954,
-0.047985252,
-0.0313699134,
0.0166938361,
0.0090147946,
-0.0197298657,
0.0256397426,
-0.0146013396,
-0.0269519184,
-0.0433276556,
-0.0552838072,
-0.0378915817,
-0.0691135004,
-0.0010235364,
-0.0044854768,
-0.0501129776,
0.0298766941,
-0.0385584831,
-0.0229622256,
0.0260998253,
0.0424647927,
-0.0214961562,
0.0064060688,
0.0250793602,
-0.0200304389,
0.0288885031,
0.0185209513,
-0.0200817529,
-0.0274180025,
-0.0290024765,
-0.0457261354,
0.0308222044,
-5.783405023e-33,
0.0224248637,
-0.05879464,
0.0421009995,
0.0653886572,
-0.011075872,
-0.0000350192,
-0.0256758314,
-0.0111268293,
-0.0410019234,
0.0651064292,
0.0073602893,
-0.0067047072,
0.0196718127,
0.0611061119,
-0.0096142143,
0.0131481476,
0.0021957301,
0.0311234687,
0.0296396296,
0.0017051293,
0.0137436958,
-0.0303530395,
0.0572915114,
-0.0236490294,
0.0857393891,
0.0032447511,
-0.039620962,
0.0096180998,
-0.0396567248,
0.0238427706,
-0.031446211,
0.0142706381,
-0.0166278072,
-0.0342203267,
0.0152637558,
-0.0120245637,
-0.0572203808,
0.0252578259,
0.0081221648,
0.0364255905,
-0.0040593655,
-0.0296514127,
-0.0451424457,
-0.0180282071,
0.0313016362,
0.0285287257,
0.0030555329,
0.0131173935,
-0.0334144831,
-0.0517290756,
0.0166510679,
0.0250970758,
-0.020448152,
0.0421209149,
-0.0088053411,
-0.0237582102,
0.0227904227,
-0.0109430179,
-0.1039804593,
0.0464835875,
-0.0749545544,
-0.0417725779,
-0.0363661833,
0.0103919329,
-0.0049179913,
0.0311835576,
-0.0858701691,
-0.0006591993,
0.0590707697,
0.0510624945,
-0.0434915386,
0.0952435359,
0.0807427093,
-0.0316144228,
-0.0358501039,
-0.0314282216,
-0.055104468,
0.0083467113,
-0.0304312594,
-0.0035480442,
0.0011382224,
0.0145578636,
-0.0218626149,
-0.0147373034,
0.0254777409,
-0.039490927,
-0.0301368702,
-0.0085823834,
-0.0269634109,
0.0130687663,
0.0097732367,
0.0523586571,
-0.0418357067,
-0.0662233904,
-0.0255644955,
0.0122679994,
0.0773610845,
-0.0093960715,
0.0222018454,
0.0160212088,
-0.0034815874,
-0.023420563,
-0.0246530268,
0.0059241373,
-0.0052769198,
0.0030587611,
0.0235624947,
-0.0127057796,
-0.0100107407,
0.0508007221,
-0.0098646544,
0.0247368794,
-0.0304443315,
-0.0191054586,
-0.0720106065,
0.0076858071,
0.0232129935,
-0.0133274058,
-0.0061289798,
0.0018726221,
0.0479601771,
0.0793242157,
-0.0506473817,
0.0179297775,
0.0697501749,
0.0126568172,
-0.0237432346,
0.0157613121,
-0.0056125065,
0.0293544661,
-0.0000777669,
0.0033603103,
2.92e-7,
0.0398861244,
-0.0297141708,
-0.0006428001,
0.0016463739,
0.0719756633,
0.0301294066,
0.0182714313,
0.0408555418,
-0.1114352942,
-0.0180592965,
-0.0134462528,
0.0088763591,
0.0424584374,
-0.0168822464,
-0.0103363469,
-0.0466062762,
0.004728788,
-0.0205717869,
0.0106566949,
-0.0300809108,
-0.0290607437,
-0.0396881364,
0.0087554483,
-0.0446570404,
-0.033503931,
-0.0053465557,
-0.0285299253,
0.0129368529,
0.0123565691,
-0.0324523039,
0.0125182783,
0.0798372328,
0.0268676896,
0.0046178675,
0.0011177929,
-0.0081298063,
-0.0571141168,
-0.0044765654,
0.0178141221,
0.0479499288,
-0.0020704619,
-0.0880740881,
0.0094770128,
-0.0087497337,
-0.0084270919,
0.041943226,
-0.0392159224,
-0.001972174,
-0.0310223233,
0.015440831,
0.0402408987,
-0.004085415,
0.0091860965,
-0.0451360308,
0.0164450239,
-0.0369751081,
0.0359716788,
-0.0019679742,
0.0375523679,
0.0178459045,
-0.0079039196,
0.0722801387,
0.0098668486,
0.0241427217,
0.0340363681,
-0.0193379857,
0.0004783316,
1.79191142e-34,
-0.0050367955,
-0.0119726527,
-0.0243704952,
0.0031335121,
0.0159218051,
0.0159962978,
-0.00376678,
-0.0211690087,
0.0228767246,
0.0009498849,
0.0137474751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16445v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16445v3 | Larger Probes Tell a Different Story: Extending Psycholinguistic Datasets Via In-Context Learning | 2023-03-29T04:00:53 | 2023-11-14T17:24:28 | Namrata Shivagunde, Vladislav Lialin, Anna Rumshisky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language model probing is often used to test specific capabilities of models.
However, conclusions from such studies may be limited when the probing
benchmarks are small and lack statistical power. In this work, we introduce
new, larger datasets for negation (NEG-1500-SIMP) and role reversal (ROLE-1500)
inspired by psycholinguistic studies. We dramatically extend existing NEG-136
and ROLE-88 benchmarks using GPT3, increasing their size from 18 and 44
sentence pairs to 750 each. We also create another version of extended negation
dataset (NEG-1500-SIMP-TEMP), created using template-based generation. It
consists of 770 sentence pairs. We evaluate 22 models on the extended datasets,
seeing model performance dip 20-57% compared to the original smaller
benchmarks. We observe high levels of negation sensitivity in models like BERT
and ALBERT demonstrating that previous findings might have been skewed due to
smaller test sets. Finally, we observe that while GPT3 has generated all the
examples in ROLE-1500 is only able to solve 24.6% of them during probing. The
datasets and code are available on
$\href{https://github.com/text-machine-lab/extending_psycholinguistic_dataset}{Github}$. | [
0.0487590395,
0.0417909212,
-0.0320401601,
0.0551795065,
-0.0822916403,
0.0143863987,
0.0031872462,
-0.0091615906,
-0.0228695329,
-0.0200763643,
-0.0808007047,
-0.0728790238,
-0.0228924137,
0.0420090258,
0.0422349237,
-0.0357607901,
0.0559211113,
0.0191275291,
0.047494702,
-0.0004538655,
-0.0218175631,
0.01288079,
-0.0245172903,
0.0455546193,
-0.0115643702,
-0.008444963,
-0.0067848973,
0.0379014239,
0.0096046235,
-0.0382186659,
0.0436804071,
0.0386086926,
0.0224862881,
0.0252599064,
0.000001942,
-0.0448305197,
0.0196691211,
-0.0038489476,
0.0017918051,
-0.0112636006,
0.0557248332,
-0.0392927341,
0.0055187438,
0.0415090807,
-0.05660199,
0.0078902971,
0.0422636308,
0.0790380687,
0.0316752158,
0.0929634646,
-0.0226104166,
0.0080864355,
0.0208651666,
-0.0504427701,
0.0315501355,
0.0179503523,
0.0241758637,
-0.0399841033,
0.013285948,
-0.0089744562,
-0.0144004812,
0.0108219385,
0.0294666402,
0.0471218713,
-0.032867115,
0.0422830433,
-0.0534563139,
-0.038158007,
-0.0203416403,
0.052482713,
-0.0114493314,
-0.0220441762,
-0.0041475394,
-0.0140149025,
-0.0305421613,
0.009707856,
-0.0034286557,
0.0191840548,
0.0200543236,
0.020500388,
0.0730434433,
-0.0116179306,
0.0135479243,
0.0039614355,
-0.0010710756,
0.0714977905,
0.0480181314,
-0.0728038028,
0.0188732389,
0.0149775874,
-0.070221819,
-0.0117186792,
-0.0078264605,
-0.0303696785,
-0.0103038223,
0.0328544155,
-0.0208626911,
0.0106943278,
0.0144286929,
0.0031766281,
0.0291596614,
0.032392323,
-0.0298365634,
0.0142814741,
-0.0190076698,
0.0347462445,
-0.0101638213,
0.029674843,
-0.0262780078,
-0.0114299376,
-0.0560096651,
-0.0350295678,
-0.0397113785,
0.0267630201,
-0.0358425863,
-0.0180353634,
-0.0398380086,
-0.015664842,
-0.0384820923,
-0.0084888032,
-0.0108679906,
0.0161031839,
-0.0407413244,
0.0139929447,
0.0025654074,
0.0393822417,
-0.0167128816,
0.0367020443,
-0.0285900552,
-0.0462388061,
-0.0142455399,
0.0167460907,
-0.0015742931,
-0.0375012048,
0.0425517038,
0.0250369962,
0.0009428192,
-0.0499630943,
0.0052429233,
-0.0159268863,
-0.0467080958,
-0.0969273895,
-0.0169823393,
-0.0590552427,
-0.0145183988,
0.0299255308,
-0.0187343489,
-0.0424341001,
0.0211367439,
0.0201035049,
-0.0091970162,
0.0852348283,
0.0272839218,
-0.0096153952,
-0.0170113668,
0.0193860829,
-0.0024128449,
0.0664737001,
-0.0029975148,
-0.0280500688,
0.0341480896,
0.0259677973,
0.0146407401,
0.0250890329,
0.0402258448,
0.0259814244,
-0.0374146178,
0.0101364627,
-0.0034657191,
0.0098503344,
-0.0085497517,
0.0527654327,
-0.0361299478,
-0.0261641573,
0.0586300753,
0.0376131162,
-0.0169062708,
0.0259067342,
0.005225997,
0.0314296074,
-0.0017158813,
-0.0229233839,
-0.0605605282,
-0.0084028561,
-0.0528708175,
0.007432342,
-0.0251439922,
-0.0181052983,
-0.0264855158,
-0.0107293185,
-0.0129126832,
-0.0048254649,
0.0162722468,
0.0039969264,
0.0347810015,
0.0145929838,
-0.0615789481,
0.0046746298,
0.0107757188,
-0.0894353241,
-0.0210851803,
-0.0121156322,
0.0137175936,
0.0146359326,
0.058891084,
-0.0496651456,
-0.0603470206,
0.0019269009,
-0.0800953135,
0.06885162,
0.0179587379,
0.0020890282,
0.0382194966,
-0.0593170263,
0.0124497004,
-0.0429167226,
0.0380949266,
-0.0025643052,
0.0172504336,
0.0217433088,
0.0040245201,
-0.0475824587,
0.0332695246,
0.0298637208,
-0.0605428927,
-0.015032284,
0.0325137042,
0.0167863443,
0.0527410991,
0.0197572317,
-0.0135255679,
0.0230202023,
0.0492607951,
-0.0542945676,
0.0005172731,
0.0183253977,
-0.0585968196,
-0.0979762375,
0.0308875814,
-0.042539116,
-0.0052958992,
0.1111656502,
-0.0076750242,
-0.0404702052,
0.0430860184,
-0.0152477417,
0.063642703,
-0.053280104,
0.0136500094,
-0.0044926535,
0.0520632602,
-0.0205686092,
0.0517042875,
-0.0174150299,
0.0507237613,
0.0207176059,
0.0347408839,
0.0409956239,
-0.0359748453,
-0.0594507083,
-0.0338992923,
-0.0053627365,
-0.0085873483,
0.0201850869,
-0.0235285573,
-0.0396753401,
-0.0309598781,
-0.1042277962,
0.0183669683,
-0.0159966294,
0.0170835163,
0.065169923,
-0.0110579925,
-0.0097826803,
-0.0020119937,
-0.0240153912,
0.0025398945,
0.0481115058,
0.035756968,
0.0262028575,
-0.0120644066,
-0.0387140848,
-0.0459299535,
-0.0034502132,
-0.0349548385,
-0.0038822405,
-0.0667344555,
0.0136806611,
0.0066318922,
0.0332767814,
-0.014663849,
0.0238849539,
-0.0146790063,
-0.047069706,
0.0118856486,
-0.0039758277,
0.0255971123,
0.025077261,
-0.0297725517,
0.0305806026,
0.0164610837,
-0.0059555443,
-0.0269915909,
0.0133693796,
-0.0022853124,
0.0061121886,
-0.0264573656,
-0.0417544693,
-0.0094407117,
0.0730511025,
0.0297595728,
-0.0293557867,
-0.0579737723,
0.0103917401,
-0.0092108184,
-0.0417938828,
0.0138321454,
-0.0151539398,
-0.0300712176,
0.0295071937,
-0.0478306934,
-0.0364756361,
0.0496914573,
0.0026160481,
-0.0353374593,
-0.0853383243,
-0.0041355765,
-0.0311220009,
0.1067479625,
0.0136631913,
-0.0086364718,
0.0266773216,
0.0001302233,
-0.0464390777,
-0.0626244321,
0.0209615305,
-0.0205125436,
0.0232204702,
-0.0244698711,
-0.0024705054,
0.0009026262,
-0.0427139662,
-0.0511667915,
-0.0665847808,
-0.0261136554,
0.033035215,
0.0234679878,
-0.0122323055,
-0.0247689057,
-0.0263789594,
-0.0007807692,
0.025439214,
-0.0126885716,
-0.0032583857,
-0.0117257303,
0.025756659,
0.0543212071,
-0.0237690583,
0.0175100304,
-0.0158329923,
-0.0046654693,
0.0235220809,
0.0044413856,
0.0287937876,
-0.0115561783,
0.0345409475,
0.0209416542,
0.0011140037,
-0.031776879,
0.0033144141,
0.0336571597,
-0.0135536054,
-0.0448061414,
0.1035732403,
0.0473118052,
-0.0558736026,
0.0346970037,
-0.0074901744,
0.04297892,
0.0482305922,
0.0045278724,
-0.0810817927,
-0.029379677,
0.011810801,
0.0165702738,
-0.0334285833,
-0.0365611315,
-0.0224723201,
-0.1417176425,
0.0422091484,
-0.0138650546,
0.000508051,
-0.0146812228,
-0.0460128486,
0.0225833803,
-0.0349534452,
-0.0006085312,
0.0027015358,
0.0116261449,
0.0082691899,
-0.0102455532,
0.0011648405,
-0.0811137185,
0.0342410542,
-0.0210970175,
0.0640089437,
0.0385596044,
0.0489327237,
-0.0249092132,
-0.0167718343,
0.0247293934,
-0.0138605461,
-0.0062303431,
-0.0200065691,
0.0736851394,
-0.0160081498,
-0.0097311055,
-0.0491739213,
0.0541096143,
-0.054509677,
-0.025561519,
0.0105352122,
0.0659489259,
-0.0103995008,
-0.0143547123,
-0.0210447032,
0.0207567438,
0.0386947915,
0.1142268777,
0.0030752479,
-0.040514797,
-0.0427857488,
0.0258785915,
0.0024359724,
0.0028779421,
-0.0319384113,
-0.0394584909,
0.0323720463,
-0.0021482098,
-0.0488257259,
-0.0309096836,
0.0310433693,
0.0367893688,
0.0081397528,
0.0136741325,
-0.01312418,
-0.0107067293,
-0.0560478121,
-0.00115724,
0.0079836585,
0.0331943445,
-0.0432357416,
-0.0085267602,
0.0385620892,
-0.0204410106,
-0.0295693371,
-0.0169692226,
-0.065536499,
-0.0796739161,
0.0191697888,
0.0031449408,
0.0210771132,
0.029831117,
-0.00942537,
-0.0241872407,
0.0367656089,
0.0618294291,
-0.0440408103,
0.023421729,
0.0425616652,
0.0012235605,
0.0134881372,
0.0484502055,
0.0013552265,
0.0278327763,
0.0510847755,
0.0533160828,
-0.0057996404,
0.0033743598,
0.0312457699,
0.0324917957,
0.0561035238,
0.0096268943,
-0.0171284601,
-0.0239759311,
-0.0104094902,
-0.0471955277,
-0.0105413133,
-0.0293424372,
-0.0335279517,
0.0616013482,
-0.0234596822,
-0.0390276574,
-0.0174523164,
-0.0561987087,
0.0465674363,
-0.0379713625,
0.0188113041,
0.0230593439,
0.006660094,
-0.0288132522,
0.0054753032,
-0.0174645875,
-0.0362385064,
-0.0232194476,
0.0210500807,
-0.0081103919,
0.0310680121,
0.0183129981,
-0.0060522631,
-0.022129165,
0.0283860099,
-0.0578621626,
0.0262995791,
0.0022034191,
-0.0019775785,
0.0358908027,
-0.0197758731,
0.0591857471,
-0.0591308177,
0.0073175994,
-0.0224102251,
0.0218740609,
-0.0146655226,
-0.0091355331,
0.0364210568,
0.0166766141,
-0.0123684742,
0.0139058698,
0.0678359494,
0.0096279951,
0.0429022573,
0.059954498,
0.006663199,
-0.0526280478,
0.0266918391,
0.0624313578,
0.035612721,
-0.0129165389,
0.0576448143,
-0.04809561,
-0.0635798275,
0.0115339132,
-0.0092040263,
0.0186918043,
-0.0246782228,
0.0035951366,
0.0421096347,
-0.0053503523,
-0.0553407557,
-0.0127774272,
0.0187021028,
-0.0190011803,
-0.0181275494,
-0.0696513802,
-6.338130358e-33,
-0.0089908289,
0.0117999241,
-0.0152254365,
-0.0312468279,
-0.0068844948,
0.0068718405,
-0.0274704341,
0.0363023877,
-0.0118008005,
0.0250726342,
-0.0252680369,
0.017653171,
0.0016937273,
0.0440622084,
-0.0067746751,
-0.0009980139,
0.060585063,
-0.0032473716,
-0.0153825497,
-0.0097649656,
0.0056234705,
0.0349674635,
0.0783652663,
-0.0898186788,
0.0017023727,
-0.0241421182,
-0.0258048419,
0.0151020298,
-0.029134972,
0.0505301319,
-0.0221011247,
0.0718073845,
0.0308472645,
-0.022904044,
0.0047785393,
-0.0040941667,
-0.0596172214,
-0.0500041097,
0.0649261922,
-0.0086021218,
-0.0368881039,
-0.0113757104,
0.0046661668,
-0.007979379,
-0.0259266756,
0.0251363553,
-0.0087239789,
-0.0165222678,
0.0076146726,
0.0103481822,
-0.0787338242,
-0.0014753664,
-0.0131238019,
-0.0523672849,
-0.01005367,
0.0612332411,
-0.0409018435,
-0.026376497,
-0.0623589382,
0.0205910541,
0.0011211133,
0.0455106497,
0.0264208857,
0.0235228557,
0.0049867788,
0.0362945423,
0.0368019938,
0.0256112907,
0.0104197077,
-0.0714747459,
0.0482152626,
0.0740726814,
0.0457370728,
0.0501037054,
0.0533819795,
-0.0139760878,
-0.0337482952,
-0.0043924255,
0.0597567894,
0.0168085247,
0.096382387,
-0.0109837065,
-0.0308873821,
-0.032357268,
-0.0529498532,
-0.0589211769,
-0.0379867293,
-0.0145637514,
0.0552260727,
0.0250965785,
-0.0147616863,
0.0105280895,
0.0077992626,
-0.0370914079,
0.013213235,
0.0606069602,
-0.0364957564,
0.0101072267,
0.0230593551,
0.0088971341,
-0.0925846025,
-0.0101067582,
0.0180190057,
0.0592833906,
0.002598267,
-0.0246772412,
0.0372141376,
0.0184668526,
-0.067017518,
-0.0154229747,
-0.0325687677,
0.0414280891,
-0.0268379301,
0.0308198519,
0.010993517,
0.0128274346,
-0.0146842208,
-0.0073135444,
0.0230868664,
-0.0076833256,
-0.0507445224,
0.0390453786,
-0.0087904846,
0.0219486449,
0.0054589324,
0.0038647889,
-0.0265561286,
-0.0187596269,
0.0312266909,
-0.0240922123,
-0.0096672475,
0.0016864098,
2.69e-7,
0.0194337424,
0.0505206399,
0.0370964408,
0.0305757131,
0.0183241889,
0.0504799373,
-0.039121978,
0.0225900188,
0.0170173757,
0.0175574273,
0.0198561922,
0.0089841401,
0.0250857994,
0.0006698953,
-0.0268836301,
0.0616383851,
-0.051224228,
-0.0055297008,
-0.0407945029,
0.0255465377,
0.0577741936,
0.1108773872,
0.0172277335,
0.0042407047,
-0.0025290451,
-0.0117769353,
0.0540553518,
-0.0388873257,
-0.0128727918,
-0.0054413718,
0.0106178243,
0.0231517497,
0.0348311514,
0.0377461724,
0.0110104457,
0.044081457,
-0.0429540277,
0.033854641,
-0.009664176,
-0.0818554536,
-0.0084738228,
0.0336403958,
-0.0252314731,
-0.0631989911,
0.0748454183,
-0.05874075,
-0.0569948517,
-0.0198733285,
-0.053753078,
0.0232082289,
0.0493131392,
-0.0041058199,
-0.0482502319,
-0.0089963796,
0.0456807613,
-0.0051786141,
-0.03294608,
-0.0457848348,
-0.0148784723,
0.0375690348,
-0.029024737,
-0.0183304306,
-0.0234601572,
0.0222646669,
0.0074014268,
-0.0599794947,
0.0047184252,
2.758816135e-34,
0.0462748967,
0.0096713891,
0.0375133082,
0.004915568,
0.0233345628,
-0.0102345524,
-0.0305194538,
0.0071796491,
0.0242368933,
-0.0800634474,
-0.0036765719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17579v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17579v2 | Multimodal Image-Text Matching Improves Retrieval-based Chest X-Ray Report Generation | 2023-03-29T04:00:47 | 2023-05-02T21:03:40 | Jaehwan Jeong, Katherine Tian, Andrew Li, Sina Hartung, Fardad Behzadi, Juan Calle, David Osayande, Michael Pohlen, Subathra Adithan, Pranav Rajpurkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Automated generation of clinically accurate radiology reports can improve
patient care. Previous report generation methods that rely on image captioning
models often generate incoherent and incorrect text due to their lack of
relevant domain knowledge, while retrieval-based attempts frequently retrieve
reports that are irrelevant to the input image. In this work, we propose
Contrastive X-Ray REport Match (X-REM), a novel retrieval-based radiology
report generation module that uses an image-text matching score to measure the
similarity of a chest X-ray image and radiology report for report retrieval. We
observe that computing the image-text matching score with a language-image
model can effectively capture the fine-grained interaction between image and
text that is often lost when using cosine similarity. X-REM outperforms
multiple prior radiology report generation modules in terms of both natural
language and clinical metrics. Human evaluation of the generated reports
suggests that X-REM increased the number of zero-error reports and decreased
the average error severity compared to the baseline retrieval approach. Our
code is available at: https://github.com/rajpurkarlab/X-REM | [
0.0510871597,
0.0168848857,
0.0156957414,
0.0022288973,
-0.0448897667,
0.0290611908,
-0.0139334453,
0.0769862086,
0.0083771087,
-0.0250436198,
-0.0286094658,
-0.042462144,
0.0301176328,
0.0502871461,
0.0029365474,
-0.0899205729,
0.0141510796,
0.0349691845,
-0.0000842622,
0.011715468,
0.0350740254,
0.0119349388,
0.0017074868,
0.0336518213,
-0.0128020216,
0.018478943,
0.0278886408,
0.0313430279,
0.022282565,
-0.04628985,
-0.0137950573,
0.0359593146,
0.016737435,
-0.0028922167,
0.0000018939,
-0.0278301165,
-0.0166948363,
0.0295439512,
0.0475557111,
-0.0818340257,
0.1164159849,
-0.059397053,
0.0108456314,
-0.0135141378,
-0.0036902213,
-0.0370666608,
0.0760119185,
0.041478429,
0.0763389021,
0.0410234518,
-0.0306328144,
0.0001804539,
-0.0263370778,
0.0040414687,
0.0223637763,
-0.022021329,
-0.004440031,
0.035368897,
0.0627084225,
0.0382979177,
-0.0045483336,
0.0633595511,
-0.0413238816,
0.0074055577,
0.0055938303,
0.0776760876,
0.0171009321,
-0.0105897421,
-0.0057774629,
0.0518201776,
-0.0157564227,
0.0008281857,
-0.0074542924,
-0.0107667418,
-0.0366360769,
0.0137621909,
-0.0397297591,
-0.003511949,
-0.0310135242,
0.0028295678,
-0.0190175381,
0.017881725,
-0.0195228457,
-0.0009097351,
0.0143426321,
-0.0664264038,
0.0152922347,
-0.0061919903,
-0.0124309482,
0.0155477151,
0.0082378155,
-0.0630279407,
0.0540637821,
0.0207307953,
-0.0319750793,
-0.0052840062,
-0.0281837005,
-0.0546934791,
0.0822251886,
-0.0538560897,
-0.03052455,
0.0102098696,
-0.0719596595,
0.0722840875,
-0.0024295307,
0.0559836105,
0.0009944609,
0.0256131031,
-0.0554558225,
0.0028064731,
-0.0260635056,
-0.0075888834,
-0.0082143685,
-0.0048674312,
-0.0085847275,
-0.0257893149,
-0.0465983897,
-0.0242452957,
-0.0217391402,
0.0385864563,
0.0403685197,
0.0605558492,
-0.0661707744,
0.0237329323,
-0.0383958519,
0.0305824243,
0.0133056045,
-0.0208857134,
-0.0114831198,
0.0011672737,
0.0353701897,
0.053644117,
0.0337132663,
-0.0002211856,
-0.003816722,
0.0132077578,
-0.0490648411,
-0.0254869442,
0.0394107811,
-0.0681834221,
-0.0288561117,
-0.0055115614,
0.0125252446,
-0.0624848902,
0.0493335314,
0.0201176573,
-0.003970468,
-0.0225680582,
0.0141401812,
0.0510225296,
-0.0589003302,
0.0814263374,
-0.0485431142,
0.0142059708,
0.0432974473,
0.0352636464,
0.0328616463,
-0.0241529904,
-0.0199349001,
0.0171405617,
0.016287595,
0.0116730565,
0.0247450434,
0.0016710327,
-0.0212028865,
-0.0504523963,
-0.0099586984,
0.0261830781,
-0.0018501009,
0.064408198,
0.0157491006,
0.0596688241,
-0.01219624,
-0.0316188373,
0.0371180475,
0.0871937796,
0.0241216403,
0.0057438016,
0.0232933536,
0.0116110733,
-0.0521096252,
0.0068314304,
-0.0167069808,
0.058270473,
0.0245082006,
0.0184389688,
0.036683999,
-0.0087595647,
-0.0314175263,
0.0042664483,
-0.0224162955,
-0.0058905166,
-0.0118007679,
-0.0258871913,
0.0225290917,
-0.0126632471,
-0.0657707676,
0.0140841324,
0.0220284723,
-0.0333930887,
-0.0289463811,
-0.0596000329,
-0.0253725462,
0.0910772607,
0.0848534182,
-0.0170652773,
-0.0076248329,
0.0367480926,
0.0466126502,
0.0486686826,
0.0417023376,
0.0138787562,
-0.0151527002,
-0.0419554748,
-0.0645456985,
0.0379523933,
-0.0176271796,
-0.0046904637,
0.0060928478,
0.0398641303,
0.0067288838,
-0.0054503782,
-0.0531663932,
0.039256569,
-0.006595274,
-0.00741131,
-0.0429321676,
0.0264034141,
-0.022137098,
0.0009936338,
-0.0355574936,
0.0341358371,
0.0058380403,
0.0170757696,
-0.0419199504,
0.042672053,
-0.0411396846,
-0.0082827928,
0.0115511632,
-0.083403416,
0.0193404872,
-0.0075115231,
-0.0040346016,
-0.0211588144,
-0.0082428697,
-0.0556695275,
0.0106646931,
-0.040770486,
0.0198116899,
0.0412797481,
-0.0154999485,
-0.0194316637,
0.0533551574,
0.0132667189,
0.0271860808,
0.0176292975,
-0.026767334,
0.0166944508,
-0.0377981998,
-0.0209923629,
0.0082340613,
0.0041351919,
0.0386418328,
0.0262390133,
0.0351305231,
-0.0140894959,
-0.0164136533,
-0.0617191866,
-0.0048860926,
0.0163986366,
-0.042572733,
0.0279758666,
0.0114694964,
0.0025807498,
-0.0405557305,
-0.0416414216,
-0.0324990712,
0.0782701671,
0.0081893606,
0.0630598739,
0.0201802943,
0.0108261155,
-0.067434825,
-0.001049271,
0.0015869815,
0.0221926048,
0.0535323247,
-0.0391898304,
-0.0281566698,
0.0886679143,
-0.0393211655,
0.0022236521,
0.0070662545,
-0.0326504558,
0.0349100828,
-0.0210785046,
-0.0473468527,
0.0326536112,
0.0182334315,
-0.0258174706,
0.0170468017,
-0.0220951214,
-0.0392910279,
-0.0060077887,
-0.0469794124,
-0.0694216564,
0.0721920058,
-0.0849755257,
0.0110331066,
0.0173936523,
0.0221590195,
0.038917236,
-0.0296951756,
-0.0512858741,
-0.0071109082,
0.0230532885,
-0.0600414351,
-0.0070940447,
0.0103559326,
0.0276338551,
-0.0367717519,
-0.0437023863,
0.0745333061,
-0.0166699328,
0.0083726691,
-0.0704148561,
0.00014125,
-0.0089466721,
0.0600855909,
-0.0031896289,
0.0541312844,
0.0459209941,
0.0037415365,
-0.017799003,
-0.0072909123,
0.045400124,
-0.0747340396,
-0.009188436,
0.0009076853,
0.030010771,
-0.0176837258,
-0.0443929397,
-0.026605133,
-0.0189457145,
0.0111535629,
-0.0343091413,
-0.0180742722,
0.0031145257,
-0.0856183469,
0.0780009776,
0.040798258,
0.0144743957,
0.0133274784,
-0.0389745943,
-0.0025095728,
0.0565911941,
0.0253148153,
0.0124932574,
-0.0668170005,
-0.0192520339,
-0.0238688551,
0.0674595535,
-0.0205838662,
0.0283045098,
-0.0261648204,
0.0023492721,
-0.0033929485,
0.0329022147,
0.0001218266,
0.0117981592,
0.0282768551,
-0.023955062,
-0.0142714493,
0.0557275116,
0.0442320965,
-0.0336694457,
-0.0550187379,
-0.0025988731,
-0.0158425588,
0.0072853346,
0.0081791021,
-0.0128813153,
-0.0292971786,
-0.0072625815,
0.0286191572,
-0.0099221244,
0.0056765494,
-0.021142602,
-0.0253439024,
0.0420284681,
-0.0113499062,
-0.023914706,
-0.095545955,
-0.0287773386,
0.0133940922,
0.0237070937,
-0.0626043752,
0.0169953257,
-0.010932113,
-0.0120320562,
-0.0008898741,
-0.0270097889,
-0.0358219966,
0.0048648319,
-0.0868451819,
-0.064922832,
0.053492561,
0.0506799817,
0.0111429514,
-0.0540924184,
-0.0556176975,
0.0434701517,
0.0217493977,
-0.0000182554,
0.0963112265,
0.0046254992,
-0.0123510621,
-0.0728115961,
-0.0047321706,
0.0288235005,
-0.0094712181,
-0.031048758,
0.0134829776,
-0.0085333027,
0.0004018549,
-0.0911754891,
0.0729564726,
0.0190010667,
0.0260235518,
0.0085671749,
0.0224857647,
-0.0357021615,
-0.0081990482,
0.0950600728,
-0.0431067012,
-0.0355886146,
0.0136074005,
-0.0668768808,
-0.0150594581,
-0.0707773119,
-0.0086433468,
-0.0119414981,
-0.0054194327,
0.0021198532,
0.0061008539,
-0.0397816412,
-0.0054814694,
-0.0872373208,
0.041808717,
-0.0056051477,
0.0234418567,
-0.0049984674,
0.0024463204,
0.0536444224,
-0.0116154198,
-0.0291673653,
0.0570306927,
-0.0329863466,
0.0258605909,
-0.0417686254,
0.0199929699,
0.0178491566,
-0.034803018,
0.0203265827,
-0.0153018301,
0.0376493186,
0.0756168365,
-0.0190828387,
-0.0185624622,
-0.052943591,
-0.0574294738,
-0.0405176058,
-0.0117740035,
-0.0393294096,
0.0088084424,
0.0008828479,
0.0376017578,
-0.0014289249,
-0.0563887432,
0.0209932607,
0.0200534426,
0.0042628143,
-0.0300068855,
0.0074493517,
-0.0221336409,
-0.0336357914,
-0.0023890738,
-0.0126357097,
-0.0155902002,
0.0166776329,
-0.0186806656,
0.0143238725,
0.0089027183,
0.0154034803,
-0.0497506931,
0.0073106391,
-0.0255701505,
0.0123803811,
0.016819289,
2.568e-7,
0.0059977314,
-0.0183793698,
-0.0054949666,
-0.0431001149,
-0.0030417596,
0.0384431705,
-0.036781773,
0.0460088812,
0.0138899246,
0.0149097545,
-0.0256340783,
0.0405182652,
0.0065682614,
-0.028133411,
-0.0459233485,
-0.0085550006,
0.0673251376,
-0.0128749115,
-0.0224332083,
-0.0455705673,
-0.0012424045,
0.000294982,
0.0339902118,
-0.00258207,
0.0029479894,
0.0465343632,
-0.0102523156,
0.0455505215,
-0.0149877388,
0.0776540861,
-0.020540094,
0.0032562218,
-0.0324666835,
-0.0982754156,
-0.0322608054,
-0.0000068943,
0.0511674061,
0.0015240799,
-0.0308265537,
-0.0308757555,
-0.0305614118,
-0.0369779877,
0.0392381996,
0.0115581928,
-0.030519193,
0.0045648683,
0.0759671256,
0.0753944889,
0.0231875554,
-0.0148414858,
0.007033186,
0.029616395,
-0.0373853929,
-0.0018525973,
0.0044036405,
-5.569301584e-33,
-0.0066773244,
-0.0597009435,
0.0400065929,
-0.0299255624,
0.0216788184,
0.0345612094,
-0.0345610306,
-0.0056919241,
0.0105541851,
-0.0110170329,
0.0035747497,
-0.0262995102,
0.0192257334,
0.005285894,
0.0019778188,
0.0069468445,
0.0180127621,
-0.0067161494,
-0.0277883746,
0.0144548304,
-0.0020443483,
0.0194124971,
0.0215274412,
-0.1009906009,
-0.0140105262,
-0.0035207351,
0.0146577191,
-0.0246593468,
0.0679737478,
0.0287771467,
-0.0543854646,
0.0146554718,
0.0231212229,
-0.0217297357,
-0.008138746,
0.0280747786,
-0.0441541784,
-0.0197580587,
0.010435923,
-0.0361269489,
-0.0486017093,
0.0313531235,
0.0434610993,
-0.0557804294,
-0.0032877973,
-0.0133289658,
0.0631990358,
0.0036339173,
0.0170449056,
0.0202091131,
-0.0353812836,
0.056710802,
0.0182429887,
-0.0229366571,
0.0123334294,
0.0157614518,
0.011025398,
0.0704841167,
-0.0317512266,
0.0350857787,
0.0206767526,
0.0419799499,
0.02444553,
-0.0069988305,
-0.0314271748,
0.0572072454,
0.0423844866,
-0.0518014207,
-0.0023816647,
0.0336191244,
-0.0321681052,
0.0506599247,
0.054584831,
0.0632767156,
0.0380141176,
-0.0222175065,
-0.0287673883,
0.0921137929,
-0.0982525051,
0.0731399208,
0.0211783294,
0.0043473225,
-0.0660378039,
0.020386368,
0.0133512756,
-0.0079736505,
-0.0525919944,
-0.0349858925,
0.0445364229,
0.0505250618,
0.0038288897,
0.0417146422,
0.0260529201,
0.0352823213,
0.0133624841,
-0.0482362583,
0.0154292956,
0.0163355377,
-0.06043097,
-0.035051737,
0.0003697672,
-0.0335634314,
0.0518612303,
0.0118668638,
0.0251457877,
0.0192892049,
0.0119900815,
0.0013674897,
-0.0658650249,
0.0017085485,
0.0250735153,
-0.0433373824,
-0.0610284582,
-0.0113998558,
0.031790249,
0.0322479755,
-0.0103127249,
-0.0044491533,
-0.0055039553,
-0.0103632296,
-0.0650616884,
-0.0986059457,
-0.0211773701,
-0.0049229832,
-0.0325602815,
0.0256832968,
-0.0519801117,
-0.0100524789,
0.0357958414,
-0.0326323882,
-0.0164375417,
0.0290481392,
2.616e-7,
0.0369997583,
0.0169118792,
0.0272351187,
0.0044062305,
-0.0021845913,
0.0155690052,
-0.0295905992,
0.019253131,
0.0206047259,
-0.0172732603,
0.0315414295,
-0.0113535486,
0.0189682264,
0.0340774804,
-0.0351622216,
0.0008827712,
-0.0545055345,
-0.0266771242,
-0.016317334,
-0.0269820578,
0.0845325738,
0.0303119589,
-0.0462541208,
-0.0459101275,
0.0043012546,
-0.0685561746,
0.0582594685,
-0.0374629758,
0.0242845062,
-0.0301755704,
0.0073755537,
0.0381257534,
0.001978005,
0.0225104298,
0.0036989211,
-0.0285952855,
0.0747540817,
0.0240879301,
-0.0401293859,
0.0042513954,
-0.0030547758,
-0.0021335159,
-0.0054638512,
-0.0482044891,
0.0329930559,
-0.0244108271,
0.0386820734,
-0.026886899,
-0.0261828154,
0.0295117479,
0.0317200087,
-0.0345442146,
-0.0922264531,
0.0566964857,
0.0302836355,
0.0389143154,
-0.0383263342,
-0.0622005798,
-0.005225386,
0.011779475,
0.0080909505,
-0.0002176437,
-0.011474832,
0.0073945951,
-0.0078561045,
-0.0274800397,
-0.0060055871,
2.06355944e-34,
0.0239639897,
0.0014151486,
-0.0221258663,
-0.0433682911,
0.0409397185,
-0.0036349476,
-0.0334528014,
0.0188976415,
-0.0092646359,
-0.0171599425,
-0.0031509616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16434v1 | TaskMatrix.AI: Completing Tasks by Connecting Foundation Models with Millions of APIs | 2023-03-29T03:30:38 | 2023-03-29T03:30:38 | Yaobo Liang, Chenfei Wu, Ting Song, Wenshan Wu, Yan Xia, Yu Liu, Yang Ou, Shuai Lu, Lei Ji, Shaoguang Mao, Yun Wang, Linjun Shou, Ming Gong, Nan Duan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI) has made incredible progress recently. On the
one hand, advanced foundation models like ChatGPT can offer powerful
conversation, in-context learning and code generation abilities on a broad
range of open-domain tasks. They can also generate high-level solution outlines
for domain-specific tasks based on the common sense knowledge they have
acquired. However, they still face difficulties with some specialized tasks
because they lack enough domain-specific data during pre-training or they often
have errors in their neural network computations on those tasks that need
accurate executions. On the other hand, there are also many existing models and
systems (symbolic-based or neural-based) that can do some domain-specific tasks
very well. However, due to the different implementation or working mechanisms,
they are not easily accessible or compatible with foundation models. Therefore,
there is a clear and pressing need for a mechanism that can leverage foundation
models to propose task solution outlines and then automatically match some of
the sub-tasks in the outlines to the off-the-shelf models and systems with
special functionalities to complete them. Inspired by this, we introduce
TaskMatrix.AI as a new AI ecosystem that connects foundation models with
millions of APIs for task completion. Unlike most previous work that aimed to
improve a single AI model, TaskMatrix.AI focuses more on using existing
foundation models (as a brain-like central system) and APIs of other AI models
and systems (as sub-task solvers) to achieve diversified tasks in both digital
and physical domains. As a position paper, we will present our vision of how to
build such an ecosystem, explain each key component, and use study cases to
illustrate both the feasibility of this vision and the main challenges we need
to address next. | [
0.0225671288,
0.0518965609,
-0.0297899246,
0.0132738603,
-0.0561046116,
0.0099625392,
-0.0007540573,
-0.0071389,
0.0305314381,
-0.0182292871,
-0.0243650079,
0.0288737137,
0.004906537,
0.0833739042,
-0.0081435302,
-0.0464460701,
0.019806819,
0.0166841876,
-0.0143663362,
0.0175826326,
-0.0188756697,
0.0177497342,
-0.0177538097,
0.0681245476,
-0.0261047315,
-0.0556155853,
-0.0524104647,
0.0010406277,
-0.0102652488,
0.0110713691,
0.0086792884,
0.0282494407,
0.0415726565,
0.0050184815,
0.0000024587,
-0.0268826112,
0.001725981,
-0.0066499822,
-0.0110177584,
-0.0559916236,
0.0054242304,
0.0240695681,
0.0149839995,
0.0192165729,
-0.0557892472,
0.0014028409,
0.0727374628,
0.0596722662,
0.0563554615,
0.0211007781,
-0.0019984767,
0.0313091762,
0.0270989742,
0.0120156286,
-0.0199598689,
-0.0277867895,
0.0157320704,
0.02860035,
0.0455925651,
-0.0269987807,
-0.0058299238,
-0.0173793901,
0.0351631902,
0.0093122683,
0.0242113546,
0.0095008295,
-0.0216971003,
-0.0252306052,
-0.0628349781,
0.0398176424,
-0.0267018601,
-0.0328272358,
0.0361917317,
0.022304466,
-0.0186598506,
-0.0247349907,
-0.0544164777,
-0.0091505414,
-0.0290967487,
-0.0189355575,
0.0105575966,
0.0015106143,
0.0073849158,
0.0074162921,
-0.0030126637,
0.0921757296,
-0.0119850393,
0.0187985543,
-0.0164391715,
-0.0157355592,
0.0163508225,
-0.0921636671,
0.0336366482,
0.0542914197,
-0.0766494721,
-0.0296366978,
-0.0395552926,
-0.0463755205,
-0.0405783132,
-0.0095510418,
0.0681614503,
0.0658394843,
-0.0144472551,
0.0198559854,
0.0166682433,
0.0416469723,
-0.0547263809,
-0.0042621489,
-0.0372150466,
-0.0106300339,
-0.1059727818,
0.0135588096,
-0.039309442,
0.0934348479,
-0.0654407367,
-0.0252781529,
-0.0114782499,
0.0538208,
-0.0554060377,
0.0136473356,
0.0029665364,
0.0412327461,
-0.0257249307,
-0.0291730016,
-0.0178455785,
-0.0007911998,
-0.0319719091,
0.0101816133,
0.0233431309,
-0.0275137108,
0.0053693336,
0.0152109964,
-0.0160231944,
-0.0133597022,
0.0276223496,
0.102840215,
0.0056489473,
0.0055314703,
-0.0177349281,
-0.0486573055,
0.0507025011,
-0.0722925365,
0.0041224048,
-0.0530945659,
0.0345672779,
-0.010879877,
-0.0100600757,
-0.0080147106,
0.0079142908,
0.001961105,
0.0011404791,
0.0811909884,
0.02228003,
0.0181157384,
0.0643936694,
0.0239028633,
-0.0899025798,
0.0422172248,
0.0242820177,
0.0280388966,
0.0081580635,
0.0138626769,
0.0130698318,
0.0248372387,
-0.004581599,
-0.0563206747,
0.0660615116,
0.0043801665,
0.0016203861,
0.0090055745,
-0.0229921564,
0.0123879276,
-0.0014032098,
0.0423871838,
0.0493387803,
0.0639744252,
-0.0158643778,
0.056435328,
0.0564859621,
0.0302445386,
-0.0027107392,
-0.0201026648,
-0.0794778988,
0.0522289202,
-0.0054687168,
-0.0269505791,
-0.0397734642,
0.0419690795,
-0.0301941428,
-0.0542731285,
0.039423503,
-0.0266608391,
0.0047239605,
0.0201872028,
0.0545303784,
0.017663423,
-0.055397138,
-0.0032390922,
-0.0159480236,
-0.0175018851,
-0.0148575297,
-0.0830876231,
0.0353892297,
0.0330263153,
0.0692964345,
-0.0764691383,
-0.0753150657,
0.0102790697,
0.0218723323,
-0.0058532562,
0.0028023566,
-0.031213088,
-0.0075274799,
-0.0106905289,
-0.0145153152,
-0.0425287485,
0.0269010048,
0.0141036371,
0.0169506371,
-0.0271026883,
-0.0241873804,
-0.0036987709,
-0.0228447299,
0.0365414806,
-0.0319499597,
0.0281187221,
0.0431293361,
0.0216528047,
0.0544489287,
0.0126126986,
0.0054960954,
0.0055594421,
0.0311680362,
-0.0407629423,
-0.0424778424,
0.01373835,
-0.0020519285,
0.0602805093,
0.0423446372,
-0.0338115692,
0.002670496,
0.0842035413,
-0.0443861112,
-0.0472933091,
0.0606053695,
-0.0009914326,
0.0071146549,
0.0148958126,
0.0070210048,
-0.0106383022,
-0.0189608522,
0.0210575387,
0.0433550216,
0.0486449562,
-0.0707272068,
0.0097467881,
-0.0017793194,
0.0365893468,
-0.030309584,
0.0056076124,
0.0010416005,
-0.0455366746,
0.0196713451,
0.0168588944,
0.0093194302,
-0.0196447782,
0.0234142039,
-0.1318163276,
0.0384049118,
-0.0126461219,
-0.0226925593,
0.0266834274,
0.0247255452,
0.035631489,
-0.0197880045,
0.006366895,
0.0516971797,
0.0031626474,
-0.0214271359,
0.0168992169,
0.0351941474,
-0.0551669151,
-0.0204460081,
0.008197194,
-0.042024143,
0.0181907155,
0.0030522044,
-0.0568900034,
-0.0620118305,
0.0236755144,
-0.0155354254,
0.0439769253,
-0.0146070719,
-0.0175883658,
0.0270934571,
-0.0153042097,
-0.0128796874,
0.0660247356,
-0.0372398272,
0.0311417375,
0.0423030183,
-0.0456639305,
-0.0223699324,
0.0475170016,
-0.0319719687,
0.0287689958,
-0.0026081139,
0.0243778266,
0.0240111686,
0.0491002202,
-0.0112531986,
-0.0057275221,
-0.059259437,
0.0313235521,
-0.0004672869,
0.0131774284,
-0.0140963392,
-0.0444389507,
-0.0138992174,
0.0467296243,
-0.0503322184,
-0.0540937893,
0.0793160349,
0.0039086845,
0.0011828323,
-0.0325780958,
-0.0447437875,
-0.0312915705,
0.0834860355,
-0.0121534141,
0.0103108231,
0.0463111065,
-0.0075845849,
-0.0613327809,
0.0237830039,
-0.0029058438,
-0.0175437573,
0.0454784669,
-0.0684304684,
0.0022241448,
0.0142525546,
-0.0703980029,
-0.0331592262,
0.0520170294,
-0.030655602,
0.042401541,
-0.0527315028,
-0.0426385887,
-0.0252303202,
-0.0152043337,
-0.0041912328,
0.0603636913,
-0.0016574095,
-0.0194414053,
-0.0341168046,
-0.0345621482,
0.0227617305,
0.029779315,
-0.0263810903,
0.0243467055,
0.0182212945,
0.0101176165,
0.0581831262,
-0.0342748649,
-0.0518883467,
0.0129214218,
0.0225612372,
-0.0308818631,
-0.0217571463,
0.0448337421,
0.0368378796,
-0.052377712,
-0.0459392928,
0.0567037575,
0.025048947,
-0.015187839,
0.0021565885,
-0.0249040462,
-0.0345280804,
0.0358232707,
0.0599850528,
-0.064244993,
-0.028747458,
0.0142602688,
0.0259493459,
0.002599301,
-0.0509203486,
-0.0213057939,
-0.0691851601,
0.0659314319,
0.0055931709,
-0.0515311211,
-0.0238091443,
-0.0122457985,
0.0252953898,
0.0015622809,
-0.0496800877,
-0.0028057157,
0.0392007828,
-0.0319139399,
-0.0178110786,
0.0009281912,
-0.0361860581,
0.0253430996,
-0.0308072437,
0.026274547,
0.0693589896,
0.0383438617,
0.0099225966,
0.031528905,
-0.0014364829,
0.0549451672,
0.0098877642,
-0.0224332921,
0.0140081085,
0.0348131061,
-0.0079545425,
-0.0154143823,
0.0532307811,
-0.0677599534,
-0.0428429469,
0.0137614543,
0.1263006181,
-0.0462164544,
0.0071071866,
-0.0535032414,
-0.0089666545,
0.0556002595,
0.0567111596,
-0.0153618725,
-0.0431665331,
-0.041807875,
0.008141893,
-0.0294789169,
-0.0312696993,
0.0086353431,
-0.0257689208,
-0.0068602068,
-0.023050867,
-0.0618466772,
0.0061885365,
0.0397905409,
0.022563152,
0.0342883356,
-0.045342952,
0.0610373728,
0.0254341215,
-0.0654619485,
0.0041715242,
-0.0009370365,
0.0076873843,
-0.0193062034,
-0.0226271432,
0.0062830709,
-0.067851834,
-0.0098109376,
0.0467628539,
-0.0710876808,
-0.0178976301,
-0.024114741,
0.0784803405,
0.0349735506,
0.0098402621,
-0.0416143276,
-0.0138069093,
-0.0087140994,
0.0461692214,
-0.060324885,
0.0148708289,
0.0158979837,
-0.0203249417,
-0.00291616,
0.0083840769,
-0.0920175761,
0.039447058,
0.012066056,
0.000076971,
0.0215408262,
0.0153565574,
0.0493271947,
0.0010554803,
0.0161834937,
0.0275068469,
-0.0331389681,
-0.0470466055,
-0.0079488065,
0.0119509296,
-0.0359653905,
-0.0862643942,
0.0029979679,
-0.0470007211,
0.0116669126,
0.0641779155,
0.0287803952,
0.0111787403,
0.0329820737,
-0.0140705397,
-0.0097372616,
-0.0146074956,
0.0382518582,
0.0323235765,
-0.0072737536,
-0.0066789179,
-0.0377690941,
0.0025956857,
0.0400980078,
-0.0316111296,
0.0439922437,
0.0089468788,
0.0124098854,
-0.0307648499,
0.0421065129,
-0.0595207587,
-0.1245855987,
-0.0288309772,
0.0513541736,
0.0423094481,
0.039772898,
-0.0390951969,
-0.0757788718,
-0.0053939126,
-0.0289096665,
0.0361372754,
0.0130734798,
0.0070340033,
-0.0000075305,
0.0245866925,
0.0104413349,
-0.0331796594,
0.0433829799,
-0.0668643042,
0.0577571243,
-0.0088174446,
-0.0453194119,
-0.057925988,
-0.0345090926,
0.004842204,
0.0187475961,
-0.0085845506,
-0.0270387959,
-0.0475903787,
-0.0432134345,
0.0345629565,
0.0242678765,
-0.0149434414,
-0.0103131728,
0.0464210697,
0.0419032574,
0.0241122674,
-0.0485541672,
0.0125505822,
-0.027440032,
-0.0646121353,
-0.016258385,
-0.0433799177,
-5.995295594e-33,
-0.0044930177,
-0.0313659906,
0.0274529159,
0.0584490336,
-0.0039064903,
0.0102091236,
-0.0303300023,
0.001529195,
0.0037079901,
0.006058923,
-0.0041105212,
0.0200665612,
-0.002484686,
-0.0194037538,
0.0390319712,
0.0109294988,
0.0361669175,
-0.0400047824,
-0.0311931614,
0.0382576883,
0.0133609828,
0.009172135,
0.0061798003,
-0.0743828714,
-0.0377649218,
0.0052086152,
-0.0111198453,
0.0264467914,
-0.0149597777,
0.0321144797,
-0.0056634699,
0.0234507397,
0.0253763422,
-0.0276226606,
-0.0049322345,
0.0398603491,
-0.060801249,
-0.038237229,
0.034846615,
-0.0037399104,
-0.0542656854,
-0.0129962722,
0.0261396132,
0.0178378839,
-0.0230358392,
-0.0086493278,
0.0290894508,
-0.0240231473,
0.0345438719,
-0.0001552821,
-0.0668417364,
-0.0219882354,
-0.0025697525,
-0.0498476923,
0.0021516618,
0.0536912978,
-0.0201192237,
-0.0016628838,
-0.0135838203,
0.0091362596,
-0.0365658179,
-0.0099511463,
0.0440389253,
-0.0163464118,
0.0139319953,
0.0150487646,
0.033922635,
0.0032075392,
-0.0253041144,
-0.0082849404,
-0.0318727456,
0.1172330007,
0.0098242518,
0.0130298333,
0.0054201335,
0.0169999842,
-0.0544949584,
0.038546253,
0.046702981,
0.0414349101,
0.0053065992,
0.0037967931,
-0.0172319803,
-0.0005062543,
0.0173266474,
-0.0033382345,
-0.0372222103,
-0.0012357613,
0.0275557693,
-0.0025600046,
0.0107961074,
0.0164560508,
-0.0054770284,
-0.0866392553,
0.0436828174,
0.0109941931,
0.0035395406,
0.0296081174,
0.0136277573,
-0.0112318965,
-0.0188563187,
-0.0606275797,
-0.0198533181,
0.0186345577,
0.0529719591,
0.0107174981,
0.0265028719,
0.0561932437,
0.0106304651,
0.0230748802,
-0.052795101,
0.0472413041,
0.0432171784,
0.0178474858,
0.0253681131,
0.0241361707,
-0.0047165439,
0.0312412176,
-0.0048847767,
-0.0160828289,
-0.0488185398,
0.0222103912,
0.0002998131,
-0.006844793,
-0.0259863622,
-0.0503165685,
-0.0696065277,
0.0101794442,
0.0030770453,
-0.0202245042,
-0.0417380519,
0.0161308125,
3.234e-7,
-0.0401072241,
0.0168864708,
0.0131165106,
0.0419377051,
0.0352076218,
0.0499298386,
-0.0079367431,
0.0186219774,
-0.0270605609,
-0.0305953473,
-0.0013249486,
0.0095377862,
0.059500128,
-0.0012024863,
-0.0764759406,
-0.0033149603,
0.032537818,
-0.019084448,
-0.0572662912,
0.0077482504,
0.0238148216,
0.0364903882,
0.0487636998,
-0.0067150127,
0.0307686403,
-0.0022703807,
0.0241546649,
-0.0144154569,
0.0309551153,
0.0166319776,
-0.0545015745,
0.0283615403,
-0.0423434302,
0.0479284786,
-0.017957272,
0.0308094211,
-0.0040957197,
0.0506871864,
0.0016676562,
0.0087390533,
-0.0195434727,
-0.0013175217,
0.0140748862,
-0.0188516639,
0.0345142074,
-0.0972805843,
-0.0421672761,
-0.0241914168,
0.0095621087,
-0.0035795532,
-0.0481479689,
0.013173813,
0.0342895277,
-0.0227512047,
-0.0101039987,
-0.004522867,
0.0084618079,
-0.0603410639,
0.0230952352,
0.04869489,
-0.0573664792,
-0.0268461369,
-0.0381379761,
-0.0272050239,
0.0430559888,
-0.0571144968,
0.0126951849,
3.127533586e-34,
-0.0162204392,
-0.0071086483,
0.0244399533,
0.0677059591,
0.0192621723,
-0.0111196339,
-0.0415582284,
0.0200932603,
0.0283761099,
-0.013914424,
-0.0303649604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16421v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16421v3 | ChatGPT is a Knowledgeable but Inexperienced Solver: An Investigation of Commonsense Problem in Large Language Models | 2023-03-29T03:05:43 | 2024-04-19T04:57:37 | Ning Bian, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Shanshan Jiang, Bin Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in NLP. However,
their ability to memorize, represent, and leverage commonsense knowledge has
been a well-known pain point. In this paper, we specifically focus on ChatGPT,
a widely used and easily accessible LLM, and ask the following questions: (1)
Can ChatGPT effectively answer commonsense questions? (2) Is ChatGPT aware of
the underlying commonsense knowledge for answering a specific question? (3) Is
ChatGPT knowledgeable in commonsense? (4) Can ChatGPT effectively leverage
commonsense for answering questions? We conduct a series of experiments on 11
datasets to evaluate ChatGPT's commonsense abilities, including answering
commonsense questions, identifying necessary knowledge, generating knowledge
descriptions, and using knowledge descriptions to answer questions again.
Experimental results show that: (1) ChatGPT can achieve good QA accuracies in
commonsense tasks, while still struggling with certain domains of datasets. (2)
ChatGPT is knowledgeable, and can accurately generate most of the commonsense
knowledge using knowledge prompts. (3) Despite its knowledge, ChatGPT is an
inexperienced commonsense problem solver, which cannot precisely identify the
needed commonsense for answering a specific question. These findings raise the
need to explore improved mechanisms for effectively incorporating commonsense
into LLMs like ChatGPT, such as better instruction following and commonsense
guidance. | [
0.0470522419,
0.0310026426,
-0.0248407479,
0.0308330059,
-0.0447193272,
0.0052621625,
-0.0161053613,
-0.0041967169,
0.0501924828,
-0.0502048284,
0.0073074992,
0.0264905579,
-0.0232378487,
-0.0086279167,
0.0260570366,
-0.0347297713,
0.0303930826,
-0.0185670219,
-0.0105526093,
-0.0262636151,
0.0265340526,
0.0276092924,
-0.0144624226,
0.046342589,
-0.0045214468,
-0.0528597422,
-0.0040645786,
-0.0372705273,
-0.0127889467,
-0.0114960978,
0.0119714104,
0.0526585989,
0.021255739,
0.008489266,
0.0000019085,
-0.0294116549,
0.018735826,
0.0036185312,
-0.0158066079,
0.023111755,
0.0122935902,
0.0091832634,
0.0192248095,
0.0270973742,
-0.0546389297,
0.0277557559,
0.0221265946,
0.028497329,
0.0742658079,
0.025614243,
-0.0066138194,
-0.021059813,
0.0076011983,
0.0071808561,
0.0608743951,
-0.0786724836,
0.0173817985,
0.0597080439,
0.0325398222,
-0.0041169999,
-0.0065728105,
0.0638135448,
0.0338818096,
-0.0239377953,
-0.0251576919,
0.0320058912,
-0.0576501898,
0.0131173739,
-0.0322815068,
0.0719319806,
0.0519436225,
-0.0258354228,
-0.0094987126,
0.0257699639,
0.0190837998,
0.0483076684,
-0.0467640981,
0.0176779367,
0.000373238,
-0.0061625722,
0.0159764066,
-0.0299713966,
-0.0040913131,
0.0309737865,
0.0216861349,
0.0458372459,
-0.0109627079,
-0.0256462637,
-0.0069305208,
-0.0010037584,
-0.033940848,
-0.0628582388,
0.0245067682,
0.0687798709,
-0.0244653001,
0.0294837598,
-0.0020035715,
0.0132832527,
0.0501052365,
-0.0692832991,
-0.0130633404,
0.0567903966,
-0.015789967,
0.047224883,
-0.0115055358,
0.0545573905,
0.0252798535,
0.0237516854,
-0.0351855308,
-0.0016717912,
-0.115371339,
-0.0444354787,
-0.0588622205,
0.0346013755,
-0.0047785956,
-0.0108294347,
-0.0039827251,
0.0149399778,
0.0001741196,
0.0240706429,
0.0221313145,
0.0151471756,
-0.0266869087,
-0.0159195289,
-0.0553576015,
0.0573393516,
-0.0617686585,
0.0241191722,
0.0205793548,
-0.0279497802,
-0.0118025858,
0.0037021611,
0.0045493795,
-0.0114635201,
0.0153635154,
0.0457266606,
-0.0303695705,
0.0075822882,
-0.0543999076,
-0.0149253365,
0.008606866,
-0.0537478514,
-0.0223443042,
-0.0705330744,
0.0250617731,
0.0472611189,
-0.0156426188,
0.0093676206,
0.0166133642,
0.0310643781,
-0.0151355071,
0.0709276423,
0.0004810406,
0.028048737,
0.0321302228,
0.0298787672,
0.0002767624,
0.0847120658,
-0.0026048215,
-0.0200172178,
0.0284110401,
-0.0079512587,
0.0069176443,
0.02232375,
0.0121645639,
0.0142273204,
0.0073588863,
0.0329209678,
-0.0169664565,
0.0206544194,
0.0286216456,
0.0479023866,
-0.0161306895,
0.0131076975,
0.0497391932,
0.0830556527,
-0.0100839902,
0.0673970208,
0.0135881705,
0.0270270687,
0.0381134562,
0.0324889049,
-0.0481304787,
0.0286945347,
-0.0339128487,
0.0087778671,
-0.0302415695,
0.0136494311,
-0.0306030326,
-0.0074089598,
-0.0230793525,
0.0267739706,
0.0213784222,
0.0078345621,
0.0058781328,
0.010545156,
-0.0092481291,
0.0926170871,
0.0262185987,
-0.0377455428,
-0.0067950822,
-0.0424323194,
0.0288851205,
0.0399054661,
0.0594489649,
-0.0182458349,
-0.0739307031,
-0.0052285632,
0.0126927774,
0.0417267196,
0.0592832193,
-0.0346948244,
-0.0308076646,
-0.036754135,
-0.0083624879,
0.0009771374,
0.0123137813,
0.0054861992,
0.0197683778,
0.007531425,
-0.0137466192,
-0.0498510525,
-0.0033862134,
0.0053765145,
-0.0403743498,
-0.0138329668,
-0.0374294929,
-0.0234778952,
0.0230039265,
0.0171058998,
0.012058368,
0.0077283336,
0.001660372,
-0.0140525494,
-0.0239659082,
0.0484943092,
-0.0361932144,
-0.0940504074,
0.0651265681,
-0.0303273611,
-0.0634332225,
0.0145767815,
-0.0179177709,
-0.032514561,
0.0147475479,
-0.0484355949,
0.0388183668,
-0.0600171871,
-0.0257072095,
-0.0113932975,
-0.0402712859,
-0.0143069411,
0.0806393251,
-0.0010721907,
0.003597199,
0.0272680186,
0.0003706122,
0.008677016,
-0.036810033,
-0.0059978273,
-0.0034629982,
-0.00262185,
0.0328362919,
0.0026576372,
0.0561167486,
-0.0312073566,
-0.0108958101,
-0.0992144495,
0.0156523306,
-0.0132589461,
0.0220120251,
0.0164074302,
-0.0132240765,
-0.0108298874,
0.0014451202,
-0.0715369433,
0.0251196176,
0.0268174708,
0.0248755682,
0.0296632797,
0.0210097618,
0.0045144921,
-0.0091741979,
0.0242768098,
-0.026216181,
-0.0028866678,
0.0081790332,
0.0344511941,
-0.0228976347,
0.0528446026,
-0.0535324365,
0.0148041155,
-0.0096502202,
-0.0705725327,
0.0082852459,
0.0013971085,
0.0097955987,
0.0186337065,
-0.0164040942,
0.0486050807,
0.0353765935,
-0.0323879085,
-0.0489298739,
0.0415778048,
-0.0065047783,
-0.0139613487,
-0.0170766506,
-0.0099808872,
-0.0211882442,
0.0570741333,
0.0153939333,
0.0014883229,
-0.0660927296,
0.0230018608,
-0.0195427835,
0.0004026425,
-0.0708884671,
0.0297479052,
-0.0083959633,
0.0245408155,
-0.012034988,
-0.022921253,
0.0718125477,
-0.0184065606,
-0.0168950297,
-0.0836631358,
-0.0079845889,
-0.0383122601,
0.0694642738,
-0.0450571366,
0.0239010155,
-0.0366314165,
-0.0364873074,
-0.0493575484,
-0.021330284,
0.0380765349,
-0.0461158529,
0.0423809327,
-0.0532481857,
0.0370786749,
-0.024210427,
-0.0606960505,
-0.0338045955,
-0.0291096047,
-0.0212167203,
0.022954436,
0.0473252758,
-0.0138468696,
-0.0330863446,
0.0137328962,
0.0570121445,
0.0118926102,
-0.0197415203,
-0.0198215172,
-0.0064754072,
0.020818973,
0.0610060282,
0.0566815697,
0.0183172729,
0.0202788729,
0.0174003914,
0.0613661073,
0.0250458661,
-0.0178162251,
0.0181981158,
0.0195545461,
0.0042142244,
-0.0357631519,
0.0015865481,
0.0262905825,
0.0678917319,
-0.067065835,
-0.0321408883,
0.0994788855,
0.0557271019,
-0.0070630861,
-0.0078052077,
-0.0406097658,
0.0105981864,
0.0139781768,
0.0431826189,
-0.0962455571,
-0.038086839,
0.0001882536,
0.007235867,
-0.0138745364,
-0.0350763872,
-0.0080268169,
-0.1100318357,
0.0282081999,
-0.0083633661,
-0.0849840492,
-0.0439507701,
-0.0321718641,
-0.0121299559,
0.0018736755,
0.0360643715,
0.0050683571,
-0.0229755435,
0.0121499607,
0.0171998981,
-0.0235197786,
-0.0605075061,
0.0525392704,
-0.0192599967,
0.0788398981,
0.0622969791,
0.0502257384,
-0.0063906885,
-0.0607003756,
-0.0080542024,
-0.0139872422,
0.023266064,
-0.0229324307,
-0.0120673776,
-0.0073850392,
-0.0117403809,
-0.0320975594,
0.0459895954,
-0.068240568,
-0.0121326633,
0.0489632711,
0.0756349638,
-0.017208321,
-0.0102460645,
-0.022420302,
0.0290762708,
0.007048585,
0.1121685803,
0.0432274975,
0.0185054746,
-0.0406347774,
-0.0624444485,
-0.0347844288,
-0.0235573053,
-0.0413481258,
0.0263860542,
0.0368853025,
0.0269122142,
-0.0608225912,
-0.0397407338,
0.0824883282,
0.0135086114,
0.0060860324,
0.0264343079,
0.0050231414,
0.0270998683,
-0.0185971241,
0.0396556035,
-0.0459979288,
-0.0255134422,
-0.0419402868,
-0.0251400918,
0.0294955727,
-0.0287355762,
-0.026331218,
0.030990608,
-0.0310008265,
-0.0528589599,
-0.0373657867,
0.0359275639,
0.0297527499,
-0.0096842805,
-0.0275859442,
-0.0459135137,
0.0297979098,
0.0764039233,
-0.0697367415,
-0.019674642,
0.0068341461,
0.0421153083,
0.0245508514,
0.067524232,
-0.026504701,
-0.0076736431,
-0.0315334834,
0.0765825957,
-0.0375733115,
-0.0098760817,
0.0267925132,
0.0276624467,
-0.0156963021,
0.0210342649,
0.0297784321,
-0.0253513157,
-0.0266397018,
-0.0203213375,
-0.0346118659,
-0.0370861068,
0.0043123793,
0.0069068167,
-0.0281667076,
-0.0015750641,
0.0093772588,
-0.0494877808,
0.0296861809,
-0.0267275255,
0.0253011808,
0.0218710303,
-0.0151348393,
0.0298161246,
-0.0199358054,
-0.0117260311,
-0.0273223296,
0.0038403131,
0.0127312075,
0.0147735309,
0.0940073207,
0.0297199935,
-0.0304054487,
0.0065580267,
-0.000381322,
-0.0534369312,
-0.0432533473,
0.0168893076,
0.101223737,
0.0513315313,
-0.0199071094,
0.0182213616,
-0.0490585342,
-0.013191469,
-0.0022666208,
0.0293929689,
0.0233920086,
-0.0219675265,
0.0705335066,
0.0312158428,
-0.0278004799,
-0.0219629426,
0.0955518186,
-0.0446151681,
0.0463107228,
0.0282128602,
-0.0328956805,
-0.0354552642,
-0.0366526507,
0.0414668359,
0.0208860617,
-0.0007816456,
0.03183024,
-0.0804312155,
-0.0689181238,
-0.0269783158,
0.0131372232,
-0.0024617449,
-0.0153798386,
0.0252453741,
0.0764662251,
0.0133299362,
-0.0534762554,
-0.0124957487,
0.0238915291,
-0.1130246595,
0.0013544089,
-0.0209448636,
-6.27726326e-33,
-0.0395678766,
-0.0408013128,
0.047258433,
0.0002868518,
0.0038979389,
-0.0118060652,
-0.0670211464,
0.0114952037,
-0.0265276115,
0.0337698758,
-0.0397130065,
0.0241216533,
-0.0061597964,
0.0014175992,
0.001297795,
-0.0556766912,
0.0223142952,
0.006476257,
-0.0253826287,
0.0088629024,
0.0307139754,
-0.0104212398,
0.0537839793,
-0.0071923654,
0.0116423573,
-0.0195003971,
-0.0012698625,
0.0279363673,
-0.0310225114,
0.0603018664,
-0.0284261908,
0.0672820136,
0.0409910269,
-0.0239111818,
0.0076793572,
0.0220765304,
-0.0472448133,
-0.0695630088,
0.0604480729,
-0.0068231132,
-0.0205546934,
-0.0143957958,
0.0290984362,
0.0044803489,
-0.0193631034,
0.0054262662,
0.0248039532,
-0.0289973319,
-0.0043831938,
-0.0141266929,
-0.0299752243,
0.0087308222,
-0.0334597863,
-0.0571763255,
-0.0372122675,
-0.0098665217,
-0.0156282615,
-0.0362575091,
-0.0345832296,
-0.0024965883,
0.0298383236,
0.002850781,
0.0557718985,
-0.048945602,
0.0190041121,
0.0284846425,
-0.0623036847,
-0.0068320092,
-0.0458779596,
0.0197818764,
0.014978135,
0.0336278491,
0.0345109142,
0.0619919933,
0.0058425749,
0.0057533663,
-0.0337973349,
0.0605700165,
0.0175272543,
0.0633995309,
0.0256926101,
0.0069787838,
-0.0425719619,
-0.0230916515,
-0.0452018417,
-0.0020833267,
-0.0346793532,
-0.0279361792,
0.0244056471,
-0.0333353691,
-0.0346792154,
-0.0007887248,
0.0170145333,
-0.0302853249,
-0.0378631167,
0.0266160462,
-0.0332810581,
0.0029968121,
-0.0008050171,
0.0522879548,
-0.0778044686,
0.0149783781,
0.0173044726,
0.0142562464,
-0.0049878298,
0.0460467786,
0.0073425984,
0.0048423982,
-0.0260644909,
-0.0159859229,
-0.0398088731,
0.0416978076,
-0.0214748066,
-0.0051376927,
0.0251832269,
-0.0061663263,
0.0171735175,
0.0320986211,
0.0064150374,
-0.032292068,
-0.0228188597,
0.0171007235,
-0.017503703,
-0.0223374367,
-0.0391067266,
0.0241204109,
-0.0465011708,
-0.0175169483,
0.0230444819,
-0.0338435955,
0.0045089801,
0.0326077826,
2.519e-7,
0.0200731978,
0.0564396754,
0.0095852772,
0.0124516012,
0.0158634204,
0.0372402146,
-0.0394731201,
0.0140375663,
0.0241096001,
-0.0382810906,
0.0034922014,
0.0555849783,
0.0444921255,
0.0492068566,
-0.0863435566,
0.003849251,
-0.0625091344,
-0.0310792997,
-0.0561715513,
0.0128953112,
0.0565699115,
0.0569012798,
0.0017886803,
0.0043479367,
0.010331844,
-0.0905543566,
0.0428982861,
-0.0233612563,
-0.0161844809,
0.0166249257,
0.0328842439,
0.0321278721,
0.0140072126,
0.0431483351,
0.001914446,
0.0080145234,
0.0098167807,
0.0627776459,
0.0195268672,
-0.032547731,
-0.0204396974,
-0.0527647883,
0.0089067491,
-0.0837037787,
0.0826289207,
-0.0786208808,
-0.033718247,
-0.0398976728,
0.0186149124,
-0.0309588276,
-0.0016421858,
-0.0184032936,
-0.0209273584,
0.0196098816,
0.0095927874,
-0.0144609474,
-0.0131103238,
-0.0444659665,
0.0073534385,
-0.0096379975,
-0.0311525054,
-0.0518918075,
-0.0311025493,
-0.0194547493,
0.0124577675,
-0.0853973702,
0.0161498953,
2.320948392e-34,
0.0074553303,
-0.0059452304,
0.0113974558,
0.0169132315,
0.0572218411,
0.0129540069,
0.0247273408,
0.0255742688,
0.0063729403,
-0.0572320893,
-0.0031534976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16416v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16416v3 | Improving Large Language Models for Clinical Named Entity Recognition via Prompt Engineering | 2023-03-29T02:46:18 | 2024-01-25T04:02:23 | Yan Hu, Qingyu Chen, Jingcheng Du, Xueqing Peng, Vipina Kuttichi Keloth, Xu Zuo, Yujia Zhou, Zehan Li, Xiaoqian Jiang, Zhiyong Lu, Kirk Roberts, Hua Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: This study quantifies the capabilities of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 for
clinical named entity recognition (NER) tasks and proposes task-specific
prompts to improve their performance. Materials and Methods: We evaluated these
models on two clinical NER tasks: (1) to extract medical problems, treatments,
and tests from clinical notes in the MTSamples corpus, following the 2010 i2b2
concept extraction shared task, and (2) identifying nervous system
disorder-related adverse events from safety reports in the vaccine adverse
event reporting system (VAERS). To improve the GPT models' performance, we
developed a clinical task-specific prompt framework that includes (1) baseline
prompts with task description and format specification, (2) annotation
guideline-based prompts, (3) error analysis-based instructions, and (4)
annotated samples for few-shot learning. We assessed each prompt's
effectiveness and compared the models to BioClinicalBERT. Results: Using
baseline prompts, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 achieved relaxed F1 scores of 0.634, 0.804
for MTSamples, and 0.301, 0.593 for VAERS. Additional prompt components
consistently improved model performance. When all four components were used,
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 achieved relaxed F1 socres of 0.794, 0.861 for MTSamples and
0.676, 0.736 for VAERS, demonstrating the effectiveness of our prompt
framework. Although these results trail BioClinicalBERT (F1 of 0.901 for the
MTSamples dataset and 0.802 for the VAERS), it is very promising considering
few training samples are needed. Conclusion: While direct application of GPT
models to clinical NER tasks falls short of optimal performance, our
task-specific prompt framework, incorporating medical knowledge and training
samples, significantly enhances GPT models' feasibility for potential clinical
applications. | [
0.0530605875,
-0.000835427,
0.024768563,
-0.0321847424,
-0.0174090322,
0.0535801351,
0.001295713,
0.0007195738,
0.0330289677,
-0.0337310992,
-0.0307295546,
-0.0479726493,
0.00204205,
0.0372796543,
0.0098611135,
-0.055968143,
0.044080846,
0.0171023849,
0.0601541512,
0.0434828252,
-0.0270630177,
0.0058877943,
-0.0408797152,
0.0351700746,
0.0315681063,
-0.0145186158,
0.0029118741,
-0.0051527899,
0.045554217,
-0.1143190339,
-0.0076230592,
0.0473954529,
-0.0413960256,
0.0197779424,
0.0000020864,
-0.0616376735,
-0.0388104878,
0.0429766029,
-0.073287569,
-0.0263414104,
0.0264228303,
-0.0540013053,
-0.0224869139,
-0.005839766,
-0.0183750074,
-0.0757163018,
0.0331161283,
0.0652662888,
0.0372901931,
0.0874461457,
-0.0148716522,
0.0348708928,
0.0522278249,
-0.002231878,
0.0303680543,
-0.0511023626,
0.0569494069,
-0.0291799288,
0.0454157963,
0.0204346534,
0.0292972066,
0.0088173067,
-0.021465892,
0.0290053785,
0.0136183444,
0.0658534989,
-0.0215213429,
-0.0147632314,
-0.0235789772,
0.0603042953,
0.0080379723,
0.0161250457,
0.0376411639,
-0.022715224,
-0.0144579383,
-0.0128065646,
-0.0308436323,
-0.0002142109,
-0.0788201615,
-0.0106818238,
0.0295596831,
-0.0130103398,
0.0043051317,
-0.0275708567,
-0.0018732622,
-0.0170357078,
0.0240067411,
-0.0388399586,
0.0322449505,
-0.0007254631,
-0.0475724339,
-0.0491544567,
0.0489366911,
0.0382505432,
-0.0628822148,
0.0307819769,
-0.0082071042,
-0.0417053625,
0.0457414538,
-0.0315300599,
0.0178553481,
0.0110917501,
-0.0097272107,
0.0290468596,
-0.0300257728,
0.0300137773,
0.0044553401,
0.0310521889,
0.0117997797,
0.0237057302,
-0.0615724549,
-0.0069957795,
-0.0492476486,
0.0348388143,
0.0018138315,
0.0142306471,
-0.0590852685,
0.0028469465,
0.0045388648,
0.0352241546,
0.028185932,
-0.0169236325,
-0.0257929079,
0.0229164287,
0.0091194808,
0.0192731023,
0.002795385,
-0.0422391742,
-0.0094770612,
-0.0591783114,
0.0035640749,
-0.0422330573,
0.0175118297,
-0.0452986807,
0.0401650779,
0.0417659171,
0.0377776362,
-0.082998082,
-0.0268729795,
-0.0034866121,
-0.0277621076,
-0.0068067252,
-0.0291463509,
-0.0171363056,
0.0352888405,
0.0109082311,
0.0132082906,
-0.031479802,
0.0003327028,
0.0045072394,
-0.0474304594,
0.071143277,
-0.0721162334,
-0.0278514922,
0.0346563719,
0.0197295584,
-0.0023417773,
0.0153638264,
0.0177266337,
-0.0259763226,
-0.0005871495,
-0.0010110666,
0.0148843871,
-0.0035200245,
0.009871793,
-0.0729562491,
0.0210238583,
0.0234432984,
0.0500940681,
0.0287349969,
-0.0271781888,
0.0774546489,
0.0097476169,
0.0083774133,
0.0075424444,
0.0388574339,
-0.000587032,
-0.0555267259,
0.0386487544,
-0.007696162,
0.0145588182,
-0.0135749476,
-0.0335826054,
-0.0158821363,
-0.0092886603,
0.0184672419,
-0.0224360116,
0.0133990673,
-0.0334275514,
0.0009073026,
-0.0360351689,
-0.0037173396,
-0.0507642701,
0.0063751694,
0.0465806127,
-0.032110285,
-0.0930178389,
0.0384333059,
0.0546745174,
-0.0175513513,
0.0050673378,
-0.0404091552,
0.0221264828,
0.0650973618,
0.0436287858,
-0.0451394767,
-0.0522437692,
-0.0408452228,
-0.0193657372,
-0.0034495664,
0.0255319048,
-0.0209516995,
0.0100710727,
-0.0308920685,
-0.0004415594,
0.0366725102,
0.030445287,
0.0020920653,
0.0016028536,
0.0247378685,
-0.0134450402,
0.0107952636,
-0.0256957095,
0.0614213794,
-0.0345760174,
-0.0582672358,
0.0029311539,
0.0012344904,
0.0388445035,
0.0292105339,
-0.0052425181,
0.0164126456,
0.0120670879,
-0.0155952964,
0.0041256915,
-0.0356431417,
-0.0257211383,
-0.0492457934,
-0.0086729294,
0.0285717994,
-0.0182125736,
-0.0273933467,
-0.0358221717,
-0.0205070861,
-0.076415278,
-0.0258802231,
-0.0051019317,
-0.0129438573,
0.0346780084,
0.0426659845,
-0.0109056635,
-0.058928404,
0.0246443711,
-0.0063968641,
0.0185478944,
0.0411300436,
-0.0145878792,
-0.0001606909,
-0.0405682139,
-0.0196177009,
0.0330179781,
-0.0004315455,
-0.044075042,
-0.019470321,
0.0070941066,
-0.0137407975,
-0.0302784368,
-0.1147238761,
0.0141723892,
0.0206411276,
0.0424268469,
0.0423823781,
0.0462508686,
-0.0415346734,
-0.0280629806,
0.0013918157,
-0.0446495004,
0.0163716916,
0.0200697239,
0.026699435,
0.0593538322,
-0.0155168967,
-0.0024923063,
0.0212240852,
-0.0647202879,
-0.0083121704,
0.0158898663,
-0.084483631,
-0.0297447331,
0.0379158556,
-0.0114450864,
-0.0012480137,
0.0097494787,
0.0331910513,
0.0198245645,
-0.0089766728,
0.0439881906,
0.052788049,
0.0038589858,
0.0321261697,
0.0269562379,
-0.0219298452,
-0.0105201947,
0.0396689996,
-0.0360543393,
-0.0320534073,
0.0256317984,
-0.0640401617,
0.0496442728,
0.1023370847,
0.0127709704,
0.0204924569,
-0.0521418862,
-0.014046208,
-0.0323435813,
0.0421441011,
-0.0365555659,
-0.0028478636,
-0.0586573333,
0.0133057777,
-0.0199898984,
-0.0410031937,
0.0975182056,
-0.0275426582,
0.0089642461,
-0.0652776584,
0.0128752729,
-0.0322292745,
0.015977446,
0.0176386181,
-0.0059953821,
0.0932162255,
-0.0675539374,
0.0255002882,
0.0313775167,
0.0019475952,
-0.0532017164,
0.0308861379,
-0.0102228327,
0.0380184427,
-0.0317627862,
-0.0229499433,
-0.0369325094,
-0.0334074236,
-0.0153752891,
0.0252981186,
-0.0201986041,
0.0230344515,
-0.0144542167,
0.0745800436,
-0.0265197735,
0.0737048164,
0.0168426093,
-0.0156460572,
-0.0051095965,
0.0071623605,
0.021896176,
-0.0144026168,
-0.0021432566,
-0.0278754663,
0.0311740618,
0.0381194055,
0.0046777208,
0.0258375797,
0.0163117908,
0.0031894431,
0.0003778218,
-0.0877524614,
-0.0274375211,
0.0508662015,
0.0677250996,
-0.054337319,
-0.0002140127,
0.1392906457,
0.0479902737,
-0.0624537021,
-0.0067356201,
0.0254915897,
-0.0083895195,
-0.0267542433,
0.0286906455,
-0.0520634949,
-0.0315852985,
0.027149545,
0.0436895676,
-0.0627455339,
-0.0750419497,
-0.0011163545,
-0.0635446981,
0.0316070057,
-0.0233154241,
-0.0601018444,
-0.0081174271,
-0.0763952732,
0.0161457323,
-0.0346109979,
-0.0101619577,
0.0011621672,
-0.0234505367,
0.0033086482,
0.0266796853,
-0.0355462246,
-0.0889576003,
0.0125998128,
-0.0225484557,
0.0633387715,
0.0523800962,
0.0041249418,
-0.0213192012,
0.0109771229,
-0.0089966878,
-0.0375236459,
-0.0197098032,
-0.0196173191,
0.0588724054,
-0.0095267687,
-0.0060476232,
-0.0498921238,
0.0107737118,
-0.0104837483,
-0.0228858683,
0.0111595662,
0.0932027698,
-0.0412927829,
0.0031242447,
-0.0255407281,
-0.0110398643,
0.032034602,
0.060279984,
0.0011292564,
0.0020711336,
-0.0118532805,
0.0362482406,
0.0261947885,
-0.01752178,
0.0049924869,
0.007168958,
-0.0533597618,
-0.0185848046,
-0.0489672571,
-0.0257691015,
0.0529756546,
-0.0000313612,
0.0266536884,
0.0230695046,
-0.0062536667,
0.0364793316,
-0.0544334874,
0.0532572679,
0.0347473845,
-0.0054336647,
-0.1029756144,
-0.0427275971,
0.0301779378,
0.013250418,
-0.0083516622,
0.0236268155,
-0.0166043583,
-0.0057054143,
-0.0096022617,
0.0329858214,
0.0114148622,
-0.026185222,
0.0092637278,
0.0189852081,
0.0433418564,
0.0499563478,
-0.0345964693,
-0.0581419691,
-0.0315428711,
-0.0009482627,
-0.0255365614,
0.0007270314,
0.0071714874,
0.0339286812,
0.0236146767,
0.0486241169,
0.0172322933,
-0.0264692139,
0.0417815521,
0.0551997274,
0.0760539547,
-0.0111578479,
-0.0431844071,
-0.0659422874,
0.0090435548,
0.0120797213,
0.0481781103,
-0.0155416001,
0.0100349672,
0.0202067904,
-0.020466065,
-0.0393760055,
0.0344950147,
-0.0533438027,
-0.0104534514,
-0.0639647394,
0.0391180068,
-0.0130383009,
0.0264789071,
0.0505883768,
-0.0396338254,
-0.0050901733,
0.0130653176,
0.0502011925,
0.0091309501,
-0.0245201066,
0.0875606313,
-0.0125023583,
0.0314051732,
0.0237982366,
0.0680720434,
-0.0472308062,
0.0045775017,
-0.0455102585,
0.0546207987,
0.0266972873,
0.0150041031,
0.0075973654,
-0.020777408,
0.0045790221,
-0.031504143,
0.035911113,
-0.0102216238,
0.0224404261,
0.0624455437,
0.0244365223,
-0.0153305754,
-0.050323423,
0.0571153611,
-0.0001771932,
0.0476352647,
0.0222929046,
-0.0348629244,
-0.0434819758,
-0.0060405927,
0.0244939104,
-0.0247663315,
-0.0847818702,
0.0038668157,
-0.0575525835,
-0.0161510091,
0.0423274785,
-0.023162365,
-0.0154790143,
-0.0022966398,
0.0451380871,
0.0104562277,
-0.0031706886,
-0.0201255716,
-0.0132682417,
0.0272879787,
-0.0048199696,
-0.0323902406,
0.0070670256,
-5.468440128e-33,
-0.0359701961,
-0.018634107,
0.0161414091,
0.001018501,
-0.0091659045,
0.0329662375,
-0.0396446995,
-0.0156884976,
0.0133934878,
-0.000127048,
-0.032088358,
-0.0307067502,
0.0229763724,
0.0127043761,
0.0011447151,
-0.0278255716,
0.0330831409,
0.0289282501,
-0.0431021638,
0.020690171,
-0.003792834,
0.0708604008,
0.0630337745,
-0.0451740511,
0.0420498811,
0.0200674329,
0.0279891714,
-0.01154075,
0.0171578377,
0.0788464248,
-0.0492158718,
-0.00560256,
0.0499688722,
-0.0396092683,
-0.0131384972,
0.0227580592,
-0.1085907891,
-0.0061644199,
-0.0060069752,
-0.0221024118,
-0.0093082134,
-0.0406802222,
0.0035117392,
-0.027701905,
-0.007753714,
0.0234392714,
0.0312079899,
-0.0142596355,
-0.0145620089,
-0.0206325389,
-0.0493431985,
0.0630339682,
0.0255025625,
0.0084828734,
0.0138015291,
-0.0016508518,
-0.0248299781,
0.0465835221,
0.0086539667,
-0.0352168456,
0.0425889455,
0.0140488669,
-0.0225054082,
0.0015263534,
-0.0254954416,
0.0471914038,
0.0452323221,
-0.019828165,
-0.0223815218,
-0.0005618224,
-0.0457077436,
0.0030198987,
0.0184579175,
0.0114396736,
0.0280556343,
0.0026563315,
-0.0873146057,
0.040978007,
-0.0290172957,
0.0370168872,
0.0235212687,
-0.0569948405,
-0.0609327406,
-0.0029225077,
-0.0128162298,
-0.0011656439,
-0.034279909,
-0.0142502142,
0.0454318076,
-0.0108143697,
-0.0243063848,
0.0219871309,
0.0232097004,
0.0263058096,
-0.0126307923,
-0.0478014946,
0.0671564639,
0.0257620439,
-0.043591667,
-0.0029329811,
-0.0692962185,
-0.0498482361,
0.0289053246,
-0.0149116702,
0.0357637815,
0.0024186366,
0.0184627306,
-0.0240628347,
-0.0485662855,
-0.0112738451,
0.0201155674,
0.0429049134,
-0.0280834921,
0.0702107772,
0.040201284,
-0.0000897468,
0.0154205905,
0.0492342673,
0.0022910254,
-0.0445888191,
-0.0287554674,
-0.0018377445,
0.0184335466,
0.0138045643,
0.0018128948,
0.0027901451,
0.0060085664,
0.0665392801,
0.0043245726,
-0.0353693701,
0.00843604,
0.0013811076,
2.766e-7,
0.0724165067,
0.0351445079,
0.0167024452,
-0.0218840651,
0.0127138877,
-0.0136706736,
-0.0061792405,
0.0204583425,
-0.0032308719,
-0.0007993195,
0.0377882719,
-0.027118383,
0.0313583277,
0.0322503746,
-0.1064663604,
-0.0392762944,
-0.0543158986,
-0.0104379449,
-0.0524566323,
0.0166487079,
0.0673590451,
0.046268113,
-0.0432590581,
-0.016893357,
0.0017520578,
0.0064819911,
0.0193153583,
-0.020690402,
-0.0031391634,
0.0705309808,
0.0094666006,
0.0062960298,
0.0037600053,
0.0825536996,
-0.0094150584,
-0.0143441828,
-0.0154936016,
0.0972530246,
-0.034172561,
0.0118550761,
0.0168311149,
-0.0176667776,
0.0232607219,
-0.0423750058,
0.0604457706,
-0.051878836,
-0.0313240811,
0.0238529481,
-0.0393228494,
-0.0280109756,
0.0388786756,
-0.0155323595,
-0.0199321304,
0.0463938452,
0.0152705554,
0.0048754173,
-0.0327152684,
-0.0678537413,
0.0282219406,
0.0445032828,
0.0034937696,
-0.0441961922,
0.0289249178,
-0.0333394408,
-0.0063189794,
-0.0734873712,
0.0037662114,
2.754109566e-34,
0.013150122,
-0.0086587137,
0.0104560368,
0.0321708731,
-0.0009572434,
-0.0165389962,
-0.0086405808,
0.004399586,
0.009477919,
-0.0459391363,
-0.0112931347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16406v1 | Hierarchical Video-Moment Retrieval and Step-Captioning | 2023-03-29T02:33:54 | 2023-03-29T02:33:54 | Abhay Zala, Jaemin Cho, Satwik Kottur, Xilun Chen, Barlas Oğuz, Yasher Mehdad, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | There is growing interest in searching for information from large video
corpora. Prior works have studied relevant tasks, such as text-based video
retrieval, moment retrieval, video summarization, and video captioning in
isolation, without an end-to-end setup that can jointly search from video
corpora and generate summaries. Such an end-to-end setup would allow for many
interesting applications, e.g., a text-based search that finds a relevant video
from a video corpus, extracts the most relevant moment from that video, and
segments the moment into important steps with captions. To address this, we
present the HiREST (HIerarchical REtrieval and STep-captioning) dataset and
propose a new benchmark that covers hierarchical information retrieval and
visual/textual stepwise summarization from an instructional video corpus.
HiREST consists of 3.4K text-video pairs from an instructional video dataset,
where 1.1K videos have annotations of moment spans relevant to text query and
breakdown of each moment into key instruction steps with caption and timestamps
(totaling 8.6K step captions). Our hierarchical benchmark consists of video
retrieval, moment retrieval, and two novel moment segmentation and step
captioning tasks. In moment segmentation, models break down a video moment into
instruction steps and identify start-end boundaries. In step captioning, models
generate a textual summary for each step. We also present starting point
task-specific and end-to-end joint baseline models for our new benchmark. While
the baseline models show some promising results, there still exists large room
for future improvement by the community. Project website:
https://hirest-cvpr2023.github.io | [
-0.002281785,
0.006613344,
0.0204641614,
0.0250532832,
0.0018999602,
-0.0058289063,
0.0128991231,
-0.0040084249,
-0.0440149158,
-0.0580949821,
0.0147257149,
-0.0246564317,
0.0022914691,
0.0145957237,
-0.0353737436,
-0.1455162466,
0.0226815157,
0.0011492424,
-0.0232149232,
0.027307665,
0.0314790979,
-0.0041924976,
-0.0241196156,
0.0137407416,
-0.033185225,
-0.0011509609,
-0.0205658935,
0.0056434129,
0.0935844854,
-0.0652071983,
0.0034022722,
0.0369356945,
0.1008381844,
0.0124203702,
0.0000016129,
0.0021868651,
-0.0140757598,
0.0001746886,
-0.0230697561,
0.0397471339,
0.0096554868,
-0.054401923,
0.0205289107,
-0.0000092254,
0.0017064792,
-0.0025906295,
0.0182149131,
-0.022229284,
0.0455152653,
0.0608220994,
-0.0341447368,
-0.0371618979,
0.0353413969,
-0.0333983451,
0.019101141,
-0.0107478462,
-0.0289122816,
0.0425829627,
0.0539507791,
0.0166620295,
-0.0357648991,
0.0530983098,
-0.0087475497,
-0.0360210277,
0.0092047993,
0.0383251794,
-0.0387945361,
0.0010432948,
-0.0043087858,
0.0545598231,
0.0124224061,
0.0526543371,
0.0197026003,
0.0170606114,
-0.0277386177,
-0.0045449571,
-0.0644819438,
0.0832203627,
-0.0069068205,
-0.0214144737,
-0.0317308642,
0.0494702198,
-0.0100029726,
0.0046641328,
0.0247925762,
-0.0054787602,
0.0221467856,
0.0086202789,
-0.0559779815,
-0.0201900341,
0.0105801197,
-0.054509744,
0.0134147387,
0.0222289544,
0.0483122952,
0.0042955116,
-0.0295658335,
0.006992958,
-0.0282179713,
-0.0359261408,
0.0139970761,
0.0356569327,
-0.016083315,
0.0780860633,
-0.0249202736,
0.0533492789,
0.0016009082,
0.013307225,
-0.0534199364,
0.015572614,
-0.0444286913,
0.0536624044,
-0.0354789346,
0.0037178458,
-0.0594118871,
0.0012012274,
-0.0175332353,
0.0060449089,
-0.0089168483,
0.0103370463,
-0.0546150915,
0.0171983354,
0.0140976747,
-0.020259412,
0.0021279007,
0.0411852188,
-0.0650571957,
0.0005560798,
0.0379243195,
-0.0307555664,
-0.0228026267,
0.0106432643,
0.0311970897,
-0.0081264582,
0.0453495383,
-0.0076904008,
-0.0743276402,
-0.0391420648,
-0.0183615759,
0.0018122393,
-0.0258203372,
-0.0264607184,
0.0271725804,
-0.0527267382,
0.0451836698,
-0.0215645917,
-0.0206929166,
0.0251724813,
0.0217421576,
0.000656008,
-0.0052080289,
0.0623990484,
0.0294480361,
0.0246718116,
0.0347169712,
0.0346267261,
-0.0235130377,
0.0465010144,
0.0452610962,
0.0641086996,
0.0526138768,
0.0680593029,
0.0352107361,
0.0459378101,
-0.0264460724,
0.0393953361,
-0.0439178906,
-0.0163409952,
0.0007610556,
0.0573202521,
0.0372255854,
0.03051701,
-0.0325885713,
0.0364247225,
0.0299687479,
0.0622453019,
-0.0386816487,
-0.0582280792,
0.0544690564,
0.0404788442,
0.02992386,
-0.0037047307,
-0.0151461307,
0.0601490401,
0.0183698144,
0.012740179,
0.0101142963,
0.0199894737,
-0.0700037107,
-0.0422751755,
-0.0019008261,
0.024520224,
-0.0267036445,
0.0213185027,
0.0385277793,
-0.0214787554,
-0.0600068904,
0.0424528345,
-0.0086209038,
-0.0626907349,
0.0359596945,
-0.0040856441,
-0.0075291847,
0.0541531034,
0.0015882141,
-0.0534687601,
-0.0154324155,
0.0171430036,
0.068878822,
-0.0052020927,
-0.0092479708,
-0.0295025297,
0.0258563329,
-0.0734362081,
-0.0354558453,
0.0128099322,
0.0224080384,
0.0281306654,
-0.0051927282,
0.0154968603,
0.0337307267,
-0.0042549502,
-0.0173062738,
0.0392793715,
0.0365562104,
0.0003447766,
-0.0096551785,
0.007651025,
0.0059686298,
0.0401977114,
-0.0380452573,
-0.0136966649,
0.0115535762,
-0.0057895565,
-0.0031004013,
0.043563392,
-0.0469112657,
-0.0810997635,
0.0219870936,
-0.067422621,
0.003568847,
-0.0093464358,
-0.0353493206,
-0.078650929,
0.0075572301,
0.0055284444,
-0.0305105075,
-0.0454110578,
0.0175477751,
0.0464099161,
-0.0045596273,
-0.0212737843,
0.0448689125,
-0.0072422465,
-0.0110494802,
0.008082713,
0.0251356997,
-0.0261264723,
-0.0659057647,
-0.0514773093,
0.0057067364,
-0.0241199657,
0.0346774235,
0.0572208986,
-0.010246776,
-0.0612853914,
-0.0243623387,
-0.0966250747,
0.0357890166,
-0.0163675118,
0.0181513652,
0.0012375048,
-0.0114739984,
-0.0164347906,
-0.0250653084,
-0.0044255685,
-0.0128103988,
0.0103677139,
0.0105598513,
0.0086977566,
0.0674046427,
-0.0107887257,
-0.0476747826,
-0.028777618,
-0.0119329197,
0.0265875366,
0.0110344337,
-0.0486398526,
0.0288222991,
0.0015309349,
0.0117675606,
0.0122138076,
-0.0482655391,
0.0035172554,
0.0098392982,
-0.0312322658,
0.0303805172,
0.0507380292,
0.0321459621,
0.0404008068,
0.0077284025,
-0.0283060037,
0.0021474299,
0.0346422531,
-0.0034791105,
-0.0131985852,
0.0320626684,
-0.0441001393,
-0.0192526057,
0.0083986204,
-0.0012294403,
0.0424706638,
-0.053940028,
-0.049215585,
-0.0147279007,
0.0411672555,
-0.0513568521,
0.0181028619,
-0.0298271701,
0.0222896803,
-0.0537889674,
-0.0464139022,
-0.0200984236,
-0.0511311702,
-0.0439057425,
0.0247348063,
-0.0018216497,
-0.029833233,
0.1004477218,
0.0142431464,
0.018685542,
-0.0258669052,
-0.0322064757,
-0.0518081151,
0.0075468426,
0.0762392655,
-0.016793903,
0.0762157813,
-0.070146516,
0.0145797841,
-0.0383824073,
0.0082050944,
-0.0209620148,
0.0099202171,
-0.0015302189,
-0.0092132622,
-0.044037018,
-0.0077082221,
-0.0766764134,
-0.0012100076,
0.0365849175,
0.0853038579,
-0.0305279884,
0.0164858699,
0.0118993297,
0.0536984839,
0.0244403426,
0.0159235727,
-0.0604587421,
-0.035346441,
0.0792767256,
0.0326292962,
0.1031312048,
-0.0406481884,
-0.0226597693,
-0.0040726564,
0.0178733785,
-0.0331233032,
0.0061085764,
0.0337626263,
0.0610115491,
-0.0730375499,
0.0198678095,
0.0539800897,
0.0041891062,
-0.0292730425,
-0.0473440103,
0.0251410622,
-0.0177106,
0.044227872,
-0.0162126776,
-0.0869791359,
-0.0104992297,
0.0015798525,
0.0167785492,
0.0297604036,
-0.0111001013,
-0.0284314714,
-0.0632667914,
0.0512893274,
0.0199955218,
-0.0408325084,
-0.0167056657,
0.0026477305,
0.0020852587,
-0.0016837565,
-0.0099743567,
0.0244498141,
-0.0322059877,
0.0183761586,
0.0277747847,
-0.0050968681,
-0.0416459925,
0.0266356226,
-0.0466339923,
0.005030558,
0.0142031191,
0.0327594727,
-0.0234947968,
0.0169513486,
0.0212325323,
-0.0701918975,
-0.0189983174,
0.0216925647,
0.0646125749,
-0.0463390127,
-0.0015649433,
-0.0031631843,
0.0358046703,
0.0542679466,
-0.0266512223,
0.0185511019,
0.0329187289,
-0.0143315811,
0.0306966323,
-0.05132268,
0.0250180662,
-0.0259605423,
0.0701900497,
-0.0279749911,
0.0094055515,
0.0130339144,
0.0242283884,
0.0117613226,
-0.0475233495,
-0.0013053552,
-0.0187690947,
-0.0011753817,
0.0296961889,
-0.0601038709,
-0.0393494405,
0.0559757128,
0.0220325496,
-0.0184057318,
-0.0034039915,
-0.0217040572,
0.0642651916,
-0.0631461814,
0.067415826,
-0.0233841762,
-0.0041751973,
-0.0924385265,
0.0118788602,
0.0337770656,
-0.010977027,
-0.0141038736,
-0.0041838628,
-0.0443336777,
-0.0323397219,
-0.0524192415,
0.0480508991,
0.0148014529,
0.0830563679,
0.0358095951,
0.0236004796,
0.0195914265,
-0.0036481335,
0.0351609439,
0.0007999155,
0.0262841843,
0.0090289051,
-0.0689733699,
0.0103346296,
-0.0443081371,
0.0229614396,
-0.0574238338,
0.0501419716,
-0.0181060266,
-0.0430598781,
-0.0219102111,
-0.028343834,
0.0616427548,
-0.0477154367,
0.0055304053,
-0.0566173047,
-0.034715008,
-0.0014188779,
0.0212370902,
-0.05635323,
0.0063909539,
0.0306101497,
0.0084854877,
-0.0031848119,
0.0523047,
0.0218341537,
-0.0148339281,
-0.0203616302,
-0.0002642874,
-0.0260734167,
-0.0084086088,
-0.0456738397,
0.0349214636,
-0.0021734838,
0.0250145551,
-0.0064943866,
0.0269386712,
-0.0054116244,
0.0621147752,
0.0265177209,
0.0098847719,
-0.0013703282,
0.0432639048,
-0.015853418,
0.0287154391,
-0.048893854,
0.012747217,
0.062465068,
-0.0519404896,
0.012211821,
0.006331366,
0.0017659045,
-0.0483986549,
0.0360300168,
-0.0038689142,
-0.0828437284,
0.0169941448,
0.0058871899,
0.0240852572,
0.0183941666,
0.0694978163,
-0.0205961745,
0.0461185947,
0.0230749771,
-0.0118823694,
-0.0155819552,
-0.0271346178,
-0.0599877797,
-0.0279958937,
-0.0322957188,
-0.0043445067,
-0.0558821633,
-0.015026872,
-0.0107261697,
-0.0083938753,
-0.0071753957,
0.0167046189,
0.0597485974,
-0.0093369018,
-0.009209455,
-0.0051310854,
-0.0411958843,
-0.0188178327,
-0.0206471607,
0.0138811423,
-0.0093595581,
-4.764529498e-33,
-0.0401825905,
0.0161477011,
0.0063282931,
0.0196452923,
-0.0334289856,
0.0363420099,
-0.035448052,
0.0679293126,
-0.0224783886,
0.0325280651,
-0.0043824399,
-0.0051582363,
0.0256998856,
0.0417312719,
0.0373442061,
-0.0230134372,
0.053271614,
-0.0489379056,
-0.0424400009,
0.0208072849,
0.0278225094,
0.0029912575,
0.0396496765,
-0.0126843695,
-0.018713871,
-0.0243197307,
-0.0374682955,
0.0401378758,
0.0485066362,
0.018796768,
0.0202112943,
-0.0487695038,
0.0174778495,
-0.0378486216,
-0.0257470589,
-0.0081570912,
-0.0645286366,
0.018118443,
0.0020402041,
-0.0034145848,
-0.0338099115,
-0.0154518588,
0.0040068496,
-0.0405122899,
-0.0257480294,
-0.0731958821,
0.043464873,
-0.0456638895,
0.0138807511,
-0.0715832263,
-0.0080554113,
0.0206142385,
-0.011086965,
-0.0668254867,
0.0549045317,
0.012565841,
0.064893648,
-0.0389936045,
-0.01997054,
0.0199338589,
-0.0063324468,
0.0605855249,
0.089865908,
0.0142323049,
-0.02463145,
0.067097649,
0.0241370387,
-0.0497167334,
-0.0011974337,
0.0063588545,
0.0238724779,
0.0291133728,
0.0203509498,
-0.00851373,
0.0106016938,
0.0528941266,
-0.0283692628,
0.0712422803,
-0.0114474492,
0.0238141101,
-0.042870257,
0.0222874563,
0.0077214707,
0.0339348689,
-0.0340553038,
-0.011214423,
0.0048383242,
0.0045577213,
0.0130019858,
0.0314088315,
0.0421241708,
-0.0111160791,
0.082186535,
0.0225674864,
0.0444055088,
0.0059316545,
-0.0203505568,
0.0438622572,
0.0238897111,
-0.0035551582,
-0.0532917269,
-0.003284364,
0.0491130203,
-0.0218020789,
-0.0201791469,
-0.0067485604,
0.0038073042,
0.0312805772,
-0.0118641136,
-0.0024420831,
-0.0212663207,
0.0198853724,
-0.0554852299,
0.0417589396,
0.0152446292,
0.0223400667,
-0.0285551194,
0.0568663925,
-0.0289088544,
0.0585537888,
-0.0269119889,
-0.0117013827,
-0.0131510608,
0.0184900798,
0.0000467321,
0.057879772,
-0.0378544889,
-0.0009155412,
0.0316838883,
-0.0378897972,
-0.0059876661,
0.0488616042,
2.28e-7,
-0.003108613,
0.0045780158,
0.0719255731,
-0.024434194,
-0.0063006002,
0.0378380641,
-0.0480122678,
-0.0225917473,
0.0065341471,
-0.0465920419,
0.0546354465,
0.0140740797,
0.0344008468,
-0.0252015162,
-0.0504819043,
-0.0498727001,
-0.0226739682,
-0.0432878509,
-0.0297383331,
-0.0497694016,
0.0222733133,
0.0876699165,
0.0177195612,
0.020974448,
-0.0101184975,
-0.0615873784,
0.0823449343,
0.0097575262,
-0.030191185,
0.0271663982,
0.0362770595,
0.01290539,
-0.0705397353,
-0.0153483311,
-0.0147823142,
-0.0008761573,
0.0667592585,
0.0486767776,
0.0049045598,
-0.0069979168,
-0.0026547275,
0.0388321318,
-0.0351225659,
0.0104183899,
0.0450740792,
-0.0361148156,
0.026218392,
-0.017525129,
-0.0476900525,
0.0446083546,
-0.0267709084,
0.0239577722,
-0.0278958175,
0.0530487858,
0.0072826785,
-0.0112127848,
-0.0208156053,
-0.112817131,
-0.0132158017,
0.0219470244,
-0.0274950005,
0.0029175223,
-0.033079993,
0.0265002809,
-0.0259191785,
-0.0265335105,
-0.0728832111,
1.737494067e-34,
0.0254565775,
-0.0147706764,
-0.0418322459,
-0.0463626869,
-0.0300798528,
-0.0014195595,
-0.0776648819,
-0.0117189065,
-0.0370360278,
-0.0283057112,
-0.0140448632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16352v1 | ChatGPT or academic scientist? Distinguishing authorship with over 99% accuracy using off-the-shelf machine learning tools | 2023-03-28T23:16:00 | 2023-03-28T23:16:00 | Heather Desaire, Aleesa E. Chua, Madeline Isom, Romana Jarosova, David Hua | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | ChatGPT has enabled access to AI-generated writing for the masses, and within
just a few months, this product has disrupted the knowledge economy, initiating
a culture shift in the way people work, learn, and write. The need to
discriminate human writing from AI is now both critical and urgent,
particularly in domains like higher education and academic writing, where AI
had not been a significant threat or contributor to authorship. Addressing this
need, we developed a method for discriminating text generated by ChatGPT from
(human) academic scientists, relying on prevalent and accessible supervised
classification methods. We focused on how a particular group of humans,
academic scientists, write differently than ChatGPT, and this targeted approach
led to the discovery of new features for discriminating (these) humans from AI;
as examples, scientists write long paragraphs and have a penchant for equivocal
language, frequently using words like but, however, and although. With a set of
20 features, including the aforementioned ones and others, we built a model
that assigned the author, as human or AI, at well over 99% accuracy, resulting
in 20 times fewer misclassified documents compared to the field-leading
approach. This strategy for discriminating a particular set of humans writing
from AI could be further adapted and developed by others with basic skills in
supervised classification, enabling access to many highly accurate and targeted
models for detecting AI usage in academic writing and beyond. | [
0.0575611815,
0.0544674098,
-0.0137368133,
-0.0055352878,
-0.0559141859,
0.0163861848,
0.0839194134,
0.0072508226,
0.044323843,
-0.0739460066,
0.0017901101,
0.0024125625,
-0.0065927813,
0.0396742895,
0.0117767537,
0.0112226019,
0.0188589673,
0.0281479284,
0.0760252103,
-0.0029201529,
-0.0002702595,
0.0174554568,
0.0150163984,
0.0542390682,
-0.0175315551,
-0.09021689,
0.0444657169,
-0.0262498353,
0.0176146142,
0.0407664515,
0.0404251814,
0.0812770501,
-0.0349001326,
0.1026113257,
0.000001623,
-0.0418847129,
-0.0223386884,
0.0114543755,
0.0094079683,
-0.0034648888,
0.059663754,
0.0517070591,
-0.0174829122,
0.0327584222,
-0.0547812954,
0.0111641046,
0.0403453447,
0.0389529243,
-0.0076551097,
0.0789637268,
-0.0242218133,
-0.0144193284,
0.0610020496,
0.0321663842,
0.0184709188,
0.0256042741,
0.0359101743,
-0.0340752713,
-0.0044287774,
0.0082899779,
0.0194946285,
0.0439677685,
-0.012014498,
-0.0312919877,
0.011516829,
0.033325322,
-0.03430162,
0.0054357518,
0.0128095727,
-0.0103116501,
0.017776493,
-0.0519697852,
0.0586886816,
0.0235567298,
0.0040127835,
0.031144347,
0.0096038003,
0.0276518427,
-0.0690661222,
-0.0415355787,
0.020693304,
-0.0036895953,
-0.0013311218,
0.0766190365,
0.0291306395,
0.0242097005,
-0.003302454,
-0.0229919758,
0.0030395638,
0.0165002942,
0.0195953678,
-0.0599040426,
0.0525057502,
0.0078978967,
0.0059630959,
-0.0155496569,
-0.0617723055,
-0.0685774758,
0.0171096269,
-0.0356703103,
0.0019607309,
-0.0088288682,
0.0046593104,
0.0261265542,
-0.0127476314,
0.0521906652,
0.0162722729,
0.0512904413,
0.0205178317,
0.0209097695,
-0.0729651302,
-0.0506295748,
0.0026897858,
0.0030900219,
0.0527987182,
-0.004089294,
-0.0564768575,
-0.0052172383,
-0.0198765732,
0.0068399054,
-0.0356571972,
0.0096190376,
-0.0229454767,
0.0382554494,
0.0230401698,
-0.026435148,
0.0074520661,
0.0203275457,
-0.0218345355,
-0.005616968,
0.0153242676,
0.0375014022,
0.0107460059,
-0.0127912778,
0.0310034659,
0.0343131907,
0.0071652685,
-0.0360560156,
0.035738308,
-0.0421119854,
-0.030080447,
-0.0625288561,
0.0132132107,
-0.0354354642,
-0.0002883824,
0.0185301937,
-0.0228725802,
-0.0833010525,
-0.0417118184,
0.0187488198,
-0.007720293,
0.0287302863,
-0.0292661451,
-0.0002030764,
0.0794486478,
0.0094863232,
-0.0467051379,
-0.0311752055,
0.0397477411,
0.0199021865,
0.0495097078,
-0.0071355798,
0.0617229715,
0.0134079903,
-0.0228836872,
-0.0246348977,
0.0445266962,
-0.0155952303,
0.0054173549,
0.0276944134,
0.0208360907,
0.0521592982,
0.0135732982,
-0.0188962352,
0.0568408966,
0.0911992714,
-0.0113588339,
0.0617706701,
0.0318463743,
0.0494058505,
0.0539883897,
0.0291551575,
-0.0278333854,
0.0133669805,
-0.0320978872,
-0.0271752104,
-0.0279062483,
0.0241379086,
-0.0008489491,
-0.0381394923,
-0.0052283504,
0.0065659028,
0.0114563964,
-0.0148351835,
0.0101659885,
-0.0221829005,
0.0036501845,
-0.0675951913,
0.0025492834,
-0.0548386276,
-0.0082822097,
-0.0538921133,
0.0109929694,
0.0718452185,
0.0476863161,
-0.0658933595,
0.0169323497,
-0.0497113876,
-0.0043186909,
0.044683937,
0.0025166795,
-0.0070781386,
-0.0293450318,
-0.0126984036,
-0.0059057823,
-0.005847007,
0.0113389054,
0.0095218662,
0.0355083793,
0.0461920612,
0.0054131211,
-0.0019508218,
-0.0464524888,
0.0593552776,
-0.0502974093,
-0.0233432781,
0.0094499253,
-0.0015972477,
0.0126989381,
0.0175109245,
-0.0405873097,
0.0116034867,
0.0021315301,
-0.0270646382,
-0.051943507,
0.0012314769,
0.024341207,
0.017254265,
0.0333654583,
-0.0287768338,
-0.0310696326,
0.0294505116,
0.0027016592,
-0.0033479654,
0.0046093571,
-0.0309845731,
-0.0089302901,
-0.0207635555,
0.0114132259,
-0.0304644499,
-0.00110195,
-0.0395893566,
0.0373969711,
0.0264841598,
0.0302735195,
-0.0355757885,
-0.0535559617,
0.0310041551,
-0.0067215562,
-0.0125947911,
-0.0158446655,
-0.0083526224,
0.0321833678,
0.0245854836,
-0.0093176495,
-0.0275247097,
-0.038632635,
-0.0783304498,
-0.0221589729,
-0.0000018559,
0.0185336247,
-0.0112980688,
-0.052466698,
-0.0073106661,
0.0258105304,
-0.0209628772,
-0.0445296839,
-0.0159847103,
-0.0149320057,
0.046301581,
-0.0496209897,
-0.0048509808,
-0.0170753337,
0.0070112101,
-0.0506196246,
0.0394463725,
0.0782154948,
-0.0438420475,
-0.022060398,
0.0245450921,
-0.008927837,
-0.0296360254,
-0.0083214054,
-0.0036275354,
0.018413417,
0.0029735737,
-0.0201194491,
0.073260501,
0.0226693694,
0.0329282023,
0.0309160948,
0.0391366631,
0.0087238373,
-0.0123808403,
0.0132309319,
0.0441813357,
0.0279564504,
-0.031683743,
0.0098670926,
-0.0163993239,
0.0054962533,
-0.0400159918,
-0.0097693671,
0.0622526109,
-0.0108047901,
-0.0305063892,
0.0055158189,
-0.0188387241,
-0.0143188089,
0.0067492751,
-0.0210449025,
-0.0355701745,
0.057036642,
-0.0285602082,
0.0219722446,
-0.0433160886,
-0.0200389642,
-0.0201397762,
0.0571435764,
0.0124267302,
0.0237588771,
0.0298022311,
-0.0037587797,
-0.0369219854,
0.0181106646,
0.0456007272,
-0.0193683505,
-0.0264096297,
-0.0008493793,
0.0251266491,
0.0056135738,
-0.019318264,
-0.0060643693,
-0.0737273917,
-0.009989664,
0.0201057158,
0.0241830628,
-0.0745614916,
-0.0286237095,
-0.039405711,
0.0371358022,
0.0566323772,
-0.0412829742,
-0.0206529368,
-0.0109684076,
0.021976212,
0.014894465,
-0.0409585275,
-0.026973268,
-0.0285343677,
-0.0196950734,
0.0584047176,
-0.0409542546,
0.0127826333,
-0.0154872751,
-0.0292448923,
-0.0071173031,
-0.0627691597,
-0.0379757434,
-0.0097650113,
0.0433573797,
-0.0352574736,
0.0148566281,
0.1205903441,
0.0112709608,
-0.0650534034,
-0.0076632784,
-0.0003026898,
-0.0122179827,
-0.0083708391,
0.0435424,
-0.0600230321,
-0.0050987061,
-0.0109724728,
0.0179571155,
-0.0676410496,
-0.0452793166,
-0.0156405549,
-0.0182868559,
0.0569522344,
-0.0023544927,
-0.0645287037,
0.0086917114,
-0.0551254414,
-0.0338456444,
-0.0122873178,
-0.0360551216,
-0.0480818078,
-0.0080518173,
0.0281145945,
0.0189866815,
-0.0577591993,
-0.0162640233,
0.0145552885,
-0.0492293574,
0.0289364755,
0.0405468605,
0.0879001245,
-0.0351960398,
-0.0085939113,
-0.0315425806,
0.0205207821,
0.0052415896,
-0.0022352857,
0.0903006122,
-0.0313577652,
0.0242988076,
-0.0551439896,
0.0492509045,
-0.0311371554,
-0.0029591348,
0.0519392006,
0.0590113439,
-0.0388743654,
-0.0263069589,
-0.0349014737,
0.0019588794,
0.024455728,
0.0496068113,
0.0033512018,
-0.0585223362,
-0.0920528993,
-0.0473672077,
0.0463323332,
-0.02478428,
-0.0390599258,
-0.0320818536,
-0.0419563912,
-0.0770552158,
-0.0720627084,
-0.0718664974,
-0.0074610105,
-0.0040442422,
0.0169620086,
0.0299036633,
-0.0006706627,
0.0078357244,
-0.0738540962,
-0.0089883963,
0.0041046953,
0.0426084138,
-0.0186316855,
-0.0242451336,
0.0063516148,
-0.004564763,
-0.0115197785,
-0.008990081,
-0.0202739481,
-0.0565844849,
0.0354808457,
0.0030292957,
0.0210092142,
-0.0096487375,
0.0012978817,
-0.0596051849,
0.0403601453,
0.063795805,
-0.0190711394,
0.013094008,
0.0219879113,
-0.0377770327,
-0.0484287553,
-0.003216998,
-0.0026351432,
0.0210423674,
0.0246539135,
-0.0628295392,
-0.0671049878,
-0.0214707404,
0.00361953,
0.032418251,
0.0339250192,
-0.0466355458,
0.006011534,
-0.0260909293,
-0.042841278,
-0.0095790522,
-0.0207916591,
-0.0028949836,
-0.030663101,
0.0156811308,
0.0213200562,
-0.0321277119,
0.0318556093,
-0.025343053,
0.0196562279,
-0.0260994807,
0.0443857238,
-0.0130157452,
0.1025890335,
-0.0260969922,
-0.0151499268,
-0.0140179601,
0.0363867059,
0.0165034477,
0.035906475,
0.0083145779,
0.0159341525,
0.0125030074,
0.043165721,
0.0055911541,
0.0240651183,
-0.1120316014,
-0.0303379837,
-0.0100358101,
0.0164769422,
0.0252087936,
0.0198101103,
0.0398058929,
-0.0271882713,
-0.0237359647,
-0.0367827825,
0.0663892105,
0.0113623505,
0.0288168248,
-0.049247127,
-0.0083741508,
-0.0305979606,
-0.0189398043,
0.0706448182,
0.0239367876,
0.0288858823,
0.0088355951,
-0.0755807981,
-0.0102377413,
-0.0443024561,
0.0120430654,
-0.0291383173,
0.0459372215,
-0.00645123,
-0.0536306947,
-0.0166848078,
0.0578543916,
-0.0190270152,
0.0312992074,
-0.0380998068,
-0.0169079565,
0.0642624944,
-0.0254216231,
-0.0282366965,
-0.0576287434,
0.0282076877,
-0.0173943825,
-0.0444132984,
-0.0309817139,
-4.943934916e-33,
0.0177416038,
-0.0933116674,
-0.0009988848,
0.0691179857,
-0.0076044141,
0.0305145308,
-0.0187291373,
-0.0029512146,
-0.0062185777,
0.0319053531,
-0.0348932184,
0.0201128367,
0.0031930166,
-0.0026725922,
0.0297039393,
0.025273433,
0.0381977409,
-0.016855523,
-0.0266946238,
0.0266996156,
0.0481024273,
0.0114825685,
0.0130543606,
-0.0994982347,
0.0537742674,
-0.0477504581,
-0.0319419056,
-0.0257023778,
-0.0584593154,
0.0082623931,
-0.0196080636,
0.0406821258,
0.0202737246,
0.0240462404,
0.0065326295,
0.0063061947,
-0.0416829288,
-0.0170098338,
-0.0312857926,
0.0186044928,
0.0285184756,
-0.0778390542,
0.0526840091,
-0.0340403989,
-0.065100193,
-0.0278076176,
0.1051722765,
0.0151968058,
-0.0116614653,
-0.0561091043,
-0.0662916526,
0.0283981916,
-0.0349303409,
0.0236709788,
-0.0007588525,
0.0159588046,
-0.0146382088,
-0.0191906244,
-0.0803947002,
0.0252673216,
-0.0082990183,
-0.0080788378,
-0.0100109633,
0.0220826548,
0.0054234592,
0.0591545217,
0.0770160109,
0.0394149236,
0.0013724362,
-0.0184996463,
0.0182782151,
0.0095238807,
0.0694902763,
0.0841067061,
0.0247341506,
-0.0512280948,
-0.0123489462,
0.0355196781,
0.0443198644,
-0.043823842,
0.0067908494,
-0.027033776,
-0.0588159151,
-0.0575447194,
0.0190478228,
-0.0523405261,
0.0104971584,
-0.0069729616,
0.0012252629,
-0.0559632517,
0.0004462821,
-0.0086364923,
0.0005197156,
-0.0464599691,
0.0038278969,
0.0059360126,
-0.0393495187,
0.06107191,
-0.0046566403,
-0.012849438,
-0.0535787009,
-0.03478292,
0.0098142559,
0.0211406704,
0.0596131049,
0.0002288445,
0.0723278001,
0.0320216976,
-0.0352157056,
-0.0049338122,
0.0238694698,
0.0164310448,
0.0387283713,
0.0384504199,
-0.0275531989,
-0.0048480248,
0.0367495902,
-0.000032449,
0.0348291211,
0.0514092855,
-0.0256705042,
-0.0181175526,
-0.0137401065,
-0.0118188662,
-0.0126977358,
-0.0074362573,
0.0003266589,
0.004005217,
0.0051519712,
-0.0770015642,
0.0155975316,
-0.0719548389,
2.274e-7,
0.066906929,
0.0444016941,
0.0165027976,
-0.0267489608,
0.0145225953,
0.0560505576,
0.031838093,
0.036918167,
-0.0007729133,
0.0485435873,
0.0240875408,
0.0168786105,
0.0534634292,
0.0230652038,
-0.0576972291,
-0.0158462394,
-0.0625318736,
-0.0091436077,
-0.0538824797,
0.0471026748,
0.0566390827,
0.0054199626,
0.0387176611,
-0.0441487581,
-0.0120239314,
-0.0787828118,
0.0333868079,
0.0174484514,
0.0281521771,
0.0311810244,
0.0460629538,
-0.0302785058,
0.0286729224,
0.0567580312,
-0.0375959538,
-0.0238430798,
0.0228951909,
0.0585188828,
-0.0209844019,
0.050434161,
0.0294521973,
0.0048180018,
0.0095778145,
-0.0142345997,
0.0410649963,
0.0277651045,
-0.0353242904,
-0.0373229086,
-0.0020688381,
-0.037724033,
0.0273393616,
0.0044528632,
0.0107459566,
0.0289040413,
0.0050798627,
-0.0282575358,
0.0026433235,
-0.0426072814,
-0.0166041795,
-0.0013438022,
-0.0341236033,
-0.004600096,
0.0021596614,
0.0054072444,
0.0553714111,
-0.0748343542,
0.0256221294,
2.195006111e-34,
0.0292757396,
0.0189046878,
-0.0103883585,
0.0112276943,
0.0207030382,
0.0322567001,
0.0480912887,
0.0272721276,
0.0097887721,
0.0140665853,
0.0213626567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16342v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16342v2 | Language-Guided Audio-Visual Source Separation via Trimodal Consistency | 2023-03-28T22:45:40 | 2023-09-23T15:05:33 | Reuben Tan, Arijit Ray, Andrea Burns, Bryan A. Plummer, Justin Salamon, Oriol Nieto, Bryan Russell, Kate Saenko | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | We propose a self-supervised approach for learning to perform audio source
separation in videos based on natural language queries, using only unlabeled
video and audio pairs as training data. A key challenge in this task is
learning to associate the linguistic description of a sound-emitting object to
its visual features and the corresponding components of the audio waveform, all
without access to annotations during training. To overcome this challenge, we
adapt off-the-shelf vision-language foundation models to provide pseudo-target
supervision via two novel loss functions and encourage a stronger alignment
between the audio, visual and natural language modalities. During inference,
our approach can separate sounds given text, video and audio input, or given
text and audio input alone. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our
self-supervised approach on three audio-visual separation datasets, including
MUSIC, SOLOS and AudioSet, where we outperform state-of-the-art strongly
supervised approaches despite not using object detectors or text labels during
training. | [
0.009635414,
0.0408472717,
0.0436309949,
0.0507291183,
-0.0029071842,
-0.0187711809,
0.0368168131,
-0.0390084013,
-0.0508140102,
-0.0249645375,
-0.0812259391,
0.0243103318,
-0.0228815712,
0.0040578428,
0.0377867557,
-0.0646907613,
-0.0011765399,
-0.0580630526,
0.0144993225,
0.0255412683,
0.0098878043,
-0.0047614984,
-0.0254191589,
-0.0129408725,
-0.05458216,
-0.0149915321,
0.0013471002,
0.0229600575,
-0.0036622419,
0.0105751194,
-0.0347411931,
0.0281876326,
0.0212330893,
-0.0127130784,
0.0000016093,
-0.0457545891,
-0.0160807837,
0.0172400847,
0.0279558972,
-0.0101299286,
-0.0350561924,
-0.015945781,
-0.0255319867,
-0.0008112523,
0.0026393067,
-0.0310354829,
0.0559253693,
0.012929434,
0.0651133955,
0.0373652987,
-0.0229858272,
-0.0352258086,
-0.0231787078,
-0.0148546407,
0.031800054,
-0.0092478963,
-0.0158863328,
-0.0449074022,
-0.0154487416,
-0.0133932168,
-0.0211343933,
0.0634846315,
0.0075559658,
-0.0000360898,
0.0566554964,
0.0372255892,
-0.1140285507,
-0.0579146966,
-0.0049153902,
0.0742089376,
0.0353855118,
-0.0081390589,
0.0110382307,
0.0300036464,
-0.0214024056,
-0.0303661469,
-0.0318816863,
0.0388447978,
-0.0065339236,
0.024216434,
-0.0570524707,
0.0265407823,
0.0425841324,
-0.0430958048,
0.0262712445,
0.0076012663,
0.0156063614,
0.0004860122,
0.0306613706,
-0.014787118,
-0.0112350481,
-0.0162900798,
0.0115321418,
-0.0339118689,
-0.0058139344,
-0.0488726944,
-0.0391626246,
0.0002700847,
-0.0735409856,
-0.0127016883,
0.0079898061,
-0.0085974541,
-0.1031220406,
0.0899721012,
0.0125582339,
-0.0043417774,
-0.0197516233,
0.016401466,
0.0092061907,
-0.0242810268,
-0.0137815373,
-0.0206757206,
-0.0052061495,
-0.0009787101,
-0.023514837,
-0.0282274894,
0.013332394,
-0.0390758775,
-0.1142377555,
0.0165475253,
0.0130604869,
0.0162043609,
-0.0393469371,
-0.0357641466,
0.0428339951,
0.0168062225,
-0.0051752147,
0.0670268834,
-0.0368191972,
-0.0409034081,
-0.0159510784,
0.0462990329,
0.0303338859,
0.0018111605,
0.0455656983,
0.0764914826,
-0.0131271286,
-0.0250252448,
-0.0209617261,
-0.003436968,
-0.0269303191,
-0.0350038521,
-0.0008167702,
-0.0994796827,
0.0274558235,
-0.0377528965,
-0.0137632238,
-0.0575410798,
0.0014205953,
-0.028439749,
0.0160660613,
0.0803902447,
-0.0183951985,
0.0462269709,
0.0187854059,
0.0126399649,
-0.0218993314,
0.0496042445,
0.0544355214,
-0.0210371651,
0.045075383,
0.0031780191,
-0.0001913377,
0.0634619966,
-0.0206014384,
-0.025753215,
-0.0868171081,
-0.0193429459,
-0.0326007418,
-0.0006646133,
0.0087422775,
0.0412047766,
0.006980198,
-0.0476437137,
0.0339267962,
0.0261750035,
-0.0039305235,
-0.0040008947,
0.0299971905,
-0.0015002228,
0.0012697928,
0.0565835908,
0.0124375345,
0.0261707976,
0.0078127049,
0.0026861024,
0.0654654577,
-0.0091311624,
-0.0338060074,
-0.0126526449,
-0.0057979166,
-0.0390681066,
-0.0342111252,
0.0281571709,
0.05239214,
0.024804933,
0.0118977865,
0.0196469016,
-0.0000225627,
-0.0469380505,
-0.0066699628,
0.0204679389,
0.0311710089,
0.0127781704,
-0.0385876149,
-0.0741892457,
0.0081881573,
0.0101031158,
0.0375718139,
0.0616315156,
-0.0224460643,
-0.0440568551,
0.0863480717,
-0.0023993298,
-0.0417439826,
-0.0034916692,
0.002060802,
-0.0037768064,
-0.0162302703,
-0.0165384859,
-0.00164224,
-0.01735943,
0.0337223858,
0.0181638375,
0.0298092496,
-0.0494857356,
-0.0059768804,
0.0360672921,
0.0351406299,
0.035245087,
-0.0622282289,
0.0214528311,
0.0069896565,
-0.0144146411,
0.0423980355,
0.017510809,
-0.0374406055,
-0.0044311644,
0.070422031,
-0.0617389865,
-0.0029473749,
0.0342936479,
0.0063551958,
-0.0171107892,
0.0376821309,
0.016582245,
-0.0352144465,
-0.0306027308,
-0.0182362907,
0.0137716169,
-0.0238531977,
0.0107808085,
-0.0067733885,
0.0718420222,
-0.0230913144,
-0.031430874,
-0.0183383469,
0.0278378427,
-0.0117081879,
0.008992739,
0.038071923,
-0.0083334958,
0.0044412697,
0.0009332594,
-0.0121825384,
-0.0614018366,
-0.0074324375,
-0.0393544398,
0.0331435986,
-0.0393923484,
-0.0272568762,
-0.0219262522,
-0.0218546707,
0.0080639627,
-0.0438479073,
-0.0062891562,
-0.0226892009,
0.0024843011,
0.004946861,
-0.0778574497,
0.0065230033,
0.0071784444,
-0.0323011577,
-0.0127809923,
0.0222285613,
-0.0272570178,
-0.0093619153,
-0.0583711937,
0.0254423823,
-0.0019743207,
-0.0188075788,
0.0739124492,
0.0151877729,
0.0330556221,
-0.0037864158,
-0.0219039973,
0.0207654331,
0.0345874019,
-0.0333655812,
0.0326264761,
0.0595153123,
-0.0190013442,
-0.011665591,
0.014938917,
0.0321460217,
0.0462300032,
-0.0143621843,
0.0494714677,
-0.033183638,
-0.0267812796,
0.0650226027,
0.0096153757,
-0.01946087,
0.025090944,
-0.029375229,
-0.0337762199,
-0.0403069966,
-0.0135094663,
-0.0184257869,
0.019519737,
-0.0017199302,
-0.0370352045,
0.0528911613,
-0.0330207199,
-0.0398692489,
-0.0082337549,
-0.0804836303,
-0.0134961186,
0.0237432159,
-0.0293483306,
0.0138834324,
0.0147262113,
-0.0371047147,
-0.066914618,
0.0045567132,
0.0626355261,
-0.0005499783,
0.0374833159,
-0.0255628079,
-0.0136557277,
-0.0048304023,
-0.0143496329,
-0.039115224,
-0.0342819542,
-0.0096476851,
0.001423615,
-0.0670891851,
-0.0120283756,
-0.0089801513,
0.0002661645,
0.0476281494,
0.059828274,
-0.0171905626,
0.0050437301,
-0.0198726654,
0.0611007884,
0.0271687731,
-0.0144361807,
-0.0492090434,
-0.0307905264,
0.0267230831,
0.0230413452,
0.0417318046,
-0.0308137871,
-0.0496578217,
0.0432654358,
0.0096660592,
0.051073622,
-0.0270393733,
0.0354288444,
0.0213751514,
-0.0276512932,
-0.0044818539,
0.1225136295,
0.0309814475,
-0.0024395171,
-0.0093237618,
0.0660438538,
-0.0228046402,
0.0433205739,
-0.024716286,
-0.0138750905,
-0.0362472236,
0.0284445882,
0.0435563847,
0.0822893605,
0.0466917045,
-0.0290871169,
-0.0530230254,
0.0495909415,
0.0278584715,
-0.0588463917,
-0.0339667499,
-0.0182769801,
0.0353688635,
-0.0206497293,
-0.0192023534,
-0.0110627394,
-0.0329045877,
0.017048005,
0.008324963,
-0.0319878459,
-0.0054297349,
-0.0023008257,
-0.0971696004,
0.0113127241,
0.038850259,
0.0263403971,
-0.0285794381,
-0.0195525661,
0.0316697843,
-0.0132072596,
-0.0361938812,
0.0158928428,
0.0721422136,
0.001625525,
-0.0320925862,
0.0484614559,
0.0509252511,
0.0060539437,
-0.0170312393,
0.0209239628,
0.0350249261,
0.0027448449,
0.0099169984,
-0.0134849772,
0.0525396243,
-0.013942834,
0.083308503,
-0.0037534251,
-0.0108452151,
0.0250315014,
0.0376335904,
0.0191359557,
-0.0173886027,
-0.0485541858,
0.0027772894,
-0.0234374423,
-0.0440612994,
-0.0216503199,
-0.0038438691,
0.0102434764,
0.0494722649,
0.0008586679,
0.0198943466,
-0.012509455,
-0.0095122019,
-0.0421323627,
0.0823392943,
0.0299732108,
-0.0080568064,
-0.0193520915,
-0.0443741195,
0.0234928951,
-0.0259545483,
-0.0086977882,
0.0596229024,
-0.0178182963,
-0.0623806119,
-0.0216719788,
-0.0349120833,
0.0127792265,
0.0789451525,
0.0178111196,
-0.0193332508,
-0.0641882569,
0.0502740107,
-0.0237037428,
0.0413680673,
0.0392580479,
-0.062150076,
0.0029846737,
0.0072016697,
-0.0692556798,
0.0458419733,
0.0174110904,
0.0057127872,
0.00439568,
0.0105907591,
0.0065336535,
-0.0409733541,
0.1210785806,
-0.0110833887,
0.0722313747,
-0.0785285532,
-0.0431982875,
-0.0289909299,
-0.0037211394,
-0.0710219741,
0.0264474936,
0.0067469585,
0.0176508985,
-0.0341590792,
0.0250959005,
0.0032305347,
0.0000048332,
-0.0555952042,
0.011305443,
0.0511224195,
-0.0759034008,
-0.0390984602,
0.0004314822,
0.0621694513,
0.0450590886,
0.0573782623,
-0.0156422034,
0.0338259488,
0.0222447123,
0.0157361813,
-0.0091660079,
0.0031034057,
-0.0064669661,
-0.0056593386,
-0.0158269089,
0.0106833782,
0.0437483452,
0.033474423,
-0.0801453292,
0.0111563038,
0.0128405541,
-0.0208540019,
-0.0226202346,
0.0486200228,
-0.007219187,
-0.0069670579,
0.0208521876,
0.0140615059,
-0.0132693127,
-0.0025830483,
0.0553650782,
0.0225772504,
-0.0212169625,
-0.0091544706,
0.0042066714,
-0.0207326021,
-0.0031503916,
-0.0234396923,
-0.0113880401,
-0.0093812933,
0.0464063846,
0.0194123555,
-0.072027564,
-0.0111817084,
-0.0076140226,
0.0054042432,
0.038251482,
0.0342391394,
0.0406812429,
-0.001596067,
-0.0200576466,
0.0581153482,
-0.0735551566,
0.0206491984,
-0.028132299,
0.0150559051,
-5.090302329e-33,
-0.0398835465,
-0.0056378222,
-0.0007192088,
0.0149855455,
0.0071552903,
-0.0082777617,
-0.0309675317,
0.0245247837,
0.0293331016,
0.0408057943,
0.0518670678,
0.0623683408,
0.0168221332,
0.0235831644,
0.0097911842,
-0.0081175137,
0.0681387782,
-0.0073883929,
0.0080735954,
-0.0116512394,
0.0755967423,
0.0366943479,
0.0388419367,
-0.1209300384,
-0.0249649994,
0.0107150199,
-0.0300804917,
0.0179717951,
0.0583791919,
0.0457310304,
0.0098810541,
0.0122986175,
-0.0362686738,
-0.0149744386,
-0.0136488955,
-0.0043704817,
-0.0887508914,
-0.0401190668,
-0.0062678079,
0.0318256319,
-0.0638128966,
-0.0086150123,
0.0503640175,
-0.0058371574,
-0.0177544001,
-0.0454877689,
0.0583789758,
-0.0203186534,
0.0255984645,
-0.0462437905,
-0.0487725064,
0.0055197682,
-0.0434291624,
-0.0393420644,
0.1095963418,
0.0243927129,
0.0047441642,
-0.0342439674,
-0.0477220975,
0.0314195901,
-0.0338519104,
0.0384223126,
0.0696279332,
0.0387038141,
-0.0122945905,
0.0534448363,
0.0496328436,
-0.1167938411,
0.0359488241,
-0.0321148895,
0.0192365311,
0.0908420458,
0.0263837464,
0.0001552782,
0.0126120411,
0.0182283893,
-0.071834825,
0.0031394872,
-0.0706704035,
-0.0144262109,
-0.0144024491,
0.0533133075,
-0.0186694935,
0.0095655732,
-0.0224508084,
-0.0037558319,
-0.0391596854,
0.0083485264,
0.0466324612,
-0.0008270253,
0.0190266203,
-0.0144297052,
0.0499949306,
-0.0079085855,
0.0263329279,
0.0389783047,
-0.0662517771,
0.0147885187,
0.0124967787,
0.0065377997,
-0.0310832188,
0.0348100774,
0.0887610689,
0.0260112416,
0.0386282057,
-0.0051461807,
0.0046556131,
0.0577246919,
-0.0360490531,
-0.0086663757,
-0.0092075523,
0.013820962,
-0.0023645819,
0.0454574153,
0.0267677903,
0.0208517332,
-0.0509377383,
0.0403396524,
-0.0096327784,
-0.0222838297,
-0.0030567187,
0.0003853795,
-0.0479125045,
0.0124244457,
0.008563295,
0.0267215706,
0.0036627708,
-0.0490678474,
0.0492656939,
-0.0357485637,
-0.0198049899,
0.0003852122,
2.449e-7,
-0.0070534167,
-0.0107726734,
-0.0141405063,
0.0139558222,
0.0301127937,
0.0229183361,
-0.070267193,
-0.0117003405,
0.013935159,
-0.0362003036,
0.0160259213,
0.0163102411,
0.0613969415,
0.0303155631,
-0.0416182987,
0.0319520719,
-0.0832476318,
-0.001829123,
-0.0274857786,
-0.0082515292,
0.0147262951,
0.0747871399,
0.0148987351,
-0.0193274748,
0.0067462097,
-0.0441502221,
0.0294699091,
-0.0067371223,
0.018043099,
-0.0561970659,
0.0182829909,
-0.0276070796,
-0.0149371177,
-0.0221525375,
-0.0257451255,
-0.0048558363,
0.0811808407,
0.0325465873,
-0.017827468,
-0.0324257202,
-0.017664386,
0.0757708102,
-0.0029322328,
0.0171764754,
0.078505747,
0.0148839122,
-0.0330589898,
-0.0161775947,
-0.0299432166,
0.0141478833,
-0.0254799835,
0.0001835193,
-0.0044689379,
-0.017137913,
0.0263808426,
-0.0023744318,
-0.0483505987,
-0.0164478291,
-0.0552606694,
0.0192856453,
-0.0217968635,
0.0318078995,
0.0273132529,
0.0119198347,
-0.0170333963,
-0.0359326079,
-0.0386423953,
1.626636914e-34,
0.0087970886,
-0.0057548815,
0.0066842414,
-0.0453814976,
-0.0211679582,
0.0021988146,
-0.0682476833,
-0.0048529431,
-0.0306012575,
0.0374381915,
-0.0114428196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16281v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16281v3 | A "Perspectival" Mirror of the Elephant: Investigating Language Bias on Google, ChatGPT, YouTube, and Wikipedia | 2023-03-28T19:49:58 | 2024-03-08T00:15:02 | Queenie Luo, Michael J. Puett, Michael D. Smith | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Contrary to Google Search's mission of delivering information from "many
angles so you can form your own understanding of the world," we find that
Google and its most prominent returned results - Wikipedia and YouTube - simply
reflect a narrow set of culturally dominant views tied to the search language
for complex topics like "Buddhism," "Liberalism," "colonization," "Iran" and
"America." Simply stated, they present, to varying degrees, distinct
information across the same search in different languages, a phenomenon we call
language bias. This paper presents evidence and analysis of language bias and
discusses its larger social implications. We find that our online searches and
emerging tools like ChatGPT turn us into the proverbial blind person touching a
small portion of an elephant, ignorant of the existence of other cultural
perspectives. Language bias sets a strong yet invisible cultural barrier
online, where each language group thinks they can see other groups through
searches, but in fact, what they see is their own reflection. | [
0.0714504868,
0.0596457161,
-0.0537457094,
0.0120232487,
-0.000755807,
-0.0052330424,
0.0340972431,
0.0043981764,
0.0703228861,
-0.0405357368,
-0.0249758698,
-0.0363537408,
0.0312167276,
-0.010056993,
0.0102911415,
-0.0726133361,
0.0084819738,
0.0422210097,
0.0309021268,
-0.0299652666,
0.0410992503,
0.0422785059,
0.0224972386,
0.0425619222,
0.0283335354,
-0.009657138,
0.0474685505,
-0.0446747653,
0.0076406165,
-0.0320656858,
0.0326284394,
0.0320635885,
-0.0378013328,
0.0468600616,
0.0000015852,
-0.0139878513,
0.0472027287,
-0.0210624933,
0.0367523767,
0.0288761538,
0.0351410769,
0.0338809788,
0.0050109737,
0.0082833199,
-0.0231756456,
-0.0320438594,
0.015440667,
0.0246575698,
0.0186278261,
0.0029533003,
0.0006362902,
-0.0174517296,
-0.080238767,
0.0204385184,
0.0184064321,
0.0200556107,
0.0403783992,
-0.0048628044,
-0.0218362231,
0.0050095269,
-0.0398030542,
0.0394669436,
-0.0122712897,
-0.0359251313,
-0.0460609458,
0.0121083325,
-0.0781154782,
-0.0357180685,
0.0676899701,
0.0414309911,
0.038115751,
-0.0167758409,
0.0232662726,
0.0313099883,
-0.0181167647,
0.0472524837,
-0.0143295676,
0.0629203469,
-0.0139781451,
0.0044518169,
-0.0107560037,
-0.0239452142,
0.0077101919,
0.0448125079,
0.0111644771,
0.0538836867,
0.0244188346,
0.0062034777,
-0.0191436429,
0.0179765802,
0.0443624184,
-0.0363266319,
0.0064419024,
-0.0052279611,
0.0041966531,
0.0121165095,
0.0084077986,
0.0469777696,
0.0100497222,
-0.0700054616,
-0.0410239995,
0.0444064215,
-0.0487011261,
0.0165430624,
0.043773111,
-0.0206347331,
-0.0340867601,
0.004374681,
0.0182419661,
0.0045552854,
0.0080184415,
0.0131412204,
0.0635500029,
-0.0410808288,
0.0308707468,
0.0339817107,
-0.0208745077,
0.0244976897,
-0.0421225131,
-0.0074456749,
-0.0517484583,
-0.0300520267,
0.0172631051,
-0.0125895459,
-0.0272723641,
0.0681080371,
-0.0514134169,
0.0193639211,
-0.0264485292,
-0.0873994753,
0.0313537717,
0.0228609331,
-0.025924854,
-0.0070425901,
0.0064223311,
0.0078668064,
0.0007269526,
0.0043308358,
0.0004065432,
-0.005860182,
0.0168049634,
0.0183322392,
0.0054371934,
-0.0288761426,
0.012841668,
0.0485253148,
0.0133026345,
-0.0031771776,
-0.0099016223,
0.0262090266,
-0.0386391692,
0.0481294133,
0.0010811466,
0.0343016684,
0.1051535979,
0.0749359578,
-0.0192154665,
0.0716957375,
-0.038341675,
0.0244384818,
0.0512211807,
0.0218571126,
-0.0031559719,
-0.0030591476,
-0.0347810313,
0.0128042884,
-0.001193854,
0.0244252682,
0.011199668,
-0.0434801094,
0.0039755423,
0.0396117978,
-0.0325282365,
0.0320870243,
0.0369879715,
0.0686435476,
-0.06113974,
0.0501579195,
-0.0404224358,
0.0104913982,
-0.0070446641,
0.0088771088,
-0.0213084575,
-0.0096722394,
0.0172297303,
-0.0380275659,
0.0205503982,
0.0750487596,
-0.0377402827,
0.0136347665,
-0.0040343427,
0.0547368191,
0.0531913862,
-0.0036228769,
0.0121648349,
-0.0390663594,
0.0444844291,
0.0360191613,
0.0401429273,
0.0047512692,
0.004955797,
-0.0337903574,
-0.0033771284,
0.0125968643,
-0.0087635517,
-0.0053831739,
0.0507834591,
0.013301691,
0.0437363237,
0.0751188323,
0.0581870079,
0.0035181476,
-0.0371330529,
0.0069923094,
-0.045412302,
0.0259809718,
0.001625669,
0.0168751106,
0.0168296993,
0.0696409047,
0.0098272283,
-0.0031792179,
-0.0171130896,
-0.0196820758,
0.0094553716,
0.0219510198,
-0.088267222,
0.041646339,
-0.0072611026,
0.007304755,
-0.03389851,
-0.0272211619,
-0.0251942649,
-0.007009225,
-0.0218320303,
0.0575039014,
-0.0039760377,
0.063615717,
0.0296987575,
-0.1447616071,
-0.0335423015,
0.0354489796,
0.0186212212,
0.0120413126,
0.0411181897,
-0.0115428632,
0.0536920354,
0.0454377681,
-0.0156944282,
-0.0567590445,
-0.0092921546,
-0.0232618768,
0.018055737,
-0.021446323,
0.0312712714,
0.0222818237,
-0.0420633033,
0.0598723292,
0.0182174761,
-0.0463526882,
0.0451470949,
0.0058463369,
0.0096980529,
0.0581472367,
-0.0340399705,
-0.0474987291,
0.0377187431,
-0.0635739937,
-0.0836801007,
-0.0150283491,
0.0239955354,
0.0237934813,
-0.0072888695,
-0.0242099892,
0.0069162846,
-0.0609719567,
-0.0107109556,
-0.0264078695,
0.0345096923,
-0.007542864,
-0.0227949321,
0.0279063508,
-0.0222134888,
-0.0197422318,
-0.0126861073,
0.0097412243,
0.0325323977,
-0.050900925,
-0.0401760377,
-0.0279817823,
-0.060826391,
-0.0114812329,
-0.0639955848,
-0.0329328328,
0.0226551592,
0.0322234295,
-0.0248852763,
0.0264340527,
0.0574283153,
-0.0014701546,
0.0484705083,
0.017322747,
-0.03274801,
-0.0515064299,
0.0266950317,
0.0054124319,
0.0059441086,
-0.0968803465,
-0.0189281721,
-0.0037068343,
0.0282066204,
0.0487658307,
-0.0309244655,
0.0287858304,
-0.0735455006,
-0.0290546119,
-0.0263033286,
-0.0307783317,
0.0018366269,
0.0407896377,
-0.0165441297,
-0.0293329358,
0.0016960101,
0.0230269209,
0.0362421051,
-0.0221607666,
0.0084227175,
0.0102934754,
0.0236494076,
-0.029792659,
0.0661816671,
0.0197195373,
-0.0567638539,
-0.0702061579,
0.0035781062,
0.0659006238,
-0.0386668295,
0.038603656,
0.0341864824,
-0.0066014593,
-0.0267718676,
-0.007909012,
-0.0400658473,
-0.0392115414,
-0.008776526,
-0.0470518619,
0.0678131804,
-0.0061283722,
-0.0154380193,
0.0167207848,
0.0376337245,
-0.0444614962,
0.0125356717,
-0.0007720717,
0.0383354239,
-0.0196385588,
0.0055567031,
-0.0105417939,
0.0324886292,
0.0127465585,
0.0275362078,
0.0203810688,
0.0496244729,
-0.0434949733,
0.0733078644,
-0.0244700778,
0.0492325164,
-0.0122718923,
-0.0471989885,
-0.0092762643,
0.031643562,
-0.0041893474,
0.0405582748,
0.0483260266,
-0.0095432736,
-0.0772663876,
-0.045983322,
-0.0347044207,
-0.0458316393,
0.0480371602,
0.0218814183,
-0.0944665968,
0.0609738231,
-0.0066677029,
0.0045522526,
-0.0311875828,
0.0038723478,
-0.0208414681,
-0.0707679018,
-0.0303504504,
0.0212025233,
0.0008032378,
-0.0124940341,
-0.0093359649,
-0.017933812,
-0.0004236512,
0.0273858365,
0.0019780563,
-0.0111171734,
0.0070312661,
-0.0097366739,
-0.0270928107,
-0.0108156055,
0.0169495735,
-0.0262190178,
-0.001654966,
0.010135605,
0.0294241104,
-0.0307523776,
-0.0168725997,
0.0376990438,
-0.0027656574,
-0.0305302031,
-0.021537561,
0.0137389153,
-0.0275122561,
-0.0112598874,
-0.0153348763,
-0.0264989659,
0.0157124754,
0.0287490431,
0.0124193011,
0.037635535,
0.0348772965,
-0.0440990403,
-0.0054154624,
-0.0236951374,
0.0105117103,
0.013116505,
-0.0044216905,
-0.0142392898,
0.0452031381,
-0.075915806,
0.0008182719,
0.0742362216,
-0.0882071704,
0.0156750344,
-0.0241506267,
-0.024208175,
-0.0190804005,
-0.0553192869,
-0.0635933951,
-0.003056868,
0.0783958286,
-0.0110326391,
0.0193554088,
-0.0214605983,
0.0019183678,
0.0084756278,
-0.0283350162,
-0.012900902,
0.0114821568,
-0.0179289561,
-0.0189598054,
-0.0256403107,
0.005933214,
-0.0084362347,
0.0495147221,
-0.0349131562,
0.0342824012,
0.0162085146,
0.0210814234,
-0.0109093199,
0.0125716077,
-0.0175666027,
0.0311368015,
0.0288104694,
0.0203036033,
-0.0236357264,
0.007796702,
0.0012321317,
0.007333104,
0.024881877,
-0.0422746167,
-0.0044730478,
0.0044418192,
-0.0256726127,
-0.0500355139,
-0.0187740047,
0.0299368538,
-0.0024793625,
0.0510357805,
-0.0166889019,
0.0559719987,
-0.0318235569,
-0.0560348481,
-0.0134557299,
-0.0068880543,
0.0405001007,
-0.0351900794,
0.0060044685,
-0.0014415837,
0.0077802795,
0.057151027,
-0.0170145575,
-0.0256743822,
-0.0847330689,
0.0368882939,
-0.0252855755,
0.0265048668,
-0.0079619586,
0.0235158075,
0.0118481973,
0.039323125,
0.0135337627,
0.0084066326,
-0.0254730191,
0.0502925664,
0.0392825641,
-0.0135972537,
0.0467490926,
-0.0160447787,
-0.025364656,
-0.1169310585,
0.0371297412,
-0.015344372,
0.061100997,
-0.0532159172,
0.0252720322,
0.0314093269,
-0.0154097509,
0.0355208926,
-0.0026936939,
0.0081766592,
-0.0448666848,
0.0012219473,
-0.0119911302,
-0.0210549403,
0.0132717043,
0.0572708957,
-0.0517049879,
0.0212427154,
0.027174456,
-0.064116396,
0.0082387934,
-0.029950453,
0.0354197249,
0.0377165526,
-0.0559876785,
-0.0237266514,
-0.0561313033,
-0.0473618507,
-0.0838257819,
-0.0069730291,
0.0335694551,
-0.0079309857,
0.0093818912,
0.0548640601,
0.0220554024,
-0.0348822884,
-0.0254161619,
0.0466344059,
-0.0942260921,
0.0167468246,
0.0246439315,
-5.546532993e-33,
0.0238971803,
-0.0223242939,
-0.0184977129,
-0.008900417,
-0.0141925141,
-0.0119498083,
-0.0200537425,
0.0694247335,
-0.0896213874,
0.0382085331,
-0.0132046184,
0.0250835624,
0.0097530195,
-0.031133879,
0.0402823389,
-0.0302035436,
0.0087891594,
0.0352705084,
-0.0301845446,
-0.0077529461,
0.0259936154,
-0.0249338206,
0.0230811462,
-0.0672824159,
0.0448256843,
-0.0311374776,
-0.0114676887,
-0.0134789953,
0.0601689517,
-0.0113599747,
-0.0163968354,
0.0570580438,
0.0229466893,
-0.0281271487,
0.0071884356,
0.0337456763,
-0.0188931264,
-0.0243701488,
0.0581166446,
0.0340116024,
0.0428477004,
0.0072865244,
0.0008197221,
-0.0301954728,
-0.0663053021,
0.0447599068,
0.0459102988,
0.0201557223,
0.0271939784,
0.0247132462,
-0.0272608716,
-0.0104878927,
-0.0079960888,
0.0489647686,
-0.0346806683,
0.0646040291,
0.0335457176,
-0.0009948869,
-0.0335562564,
0.027080534,
-0.0289429128,
0.0321817324,
0.0584979318,
0.0312418081,
-0.011771352,
0.0807340667,
0.0375627875,
0.0573768765,
-0.0216019042,
-0.1144742221,
0.0097536882,
-0.0450659059,
-0.035113968,
0.0591008253,
-0.0150107015,
-0.0715048686,
-0.0209056307,
-0.0189180803,
0.0636151433,
0.0242056604,
0.0187528636,
0.0034395754,
-0.0377603173,
-0.0245137382,
0.0126337102,
-0.0648707002,
-0.0268357154,
-0.0354106836,
0.0150870178,
0.0034500917,
0.0068358891,
-0.0379136615,
0.019414559,
-0.0512382165,
-0.0074010706,
-0.0057182009,
-0.0380932353,
-0.0517029092,
0.0193854459,
0.0015176901,
-0.0423763543,
-0.0096827084,
-0.0770123973,
0.0295157451,
-0.0267486107,
0.0046732565,
-0.0456948206,
-0.0085794721,
-0.0318504982,
-0.0312029626,
-0.0027038609,
-0.0458662026,
0.0004648657,
-0.0385021567,
0.0389434136,
0.0238313843,
0.0098493556,
-0.0525368676,
0.118620187,
0.0183622167,
-0.0299595352,
-0.0644023791,
-0.0568722449,
0.0010640271,
-0.0526469983,
-0.0231487732,
-0.0676190779,
0.0688320994,
0.0199644454,
-0.0613275617,
-0.0368234552,
-0.0519280694,
2.367e-7,
0.0167376362,
0.0450217575,
-0.0323230289,
0.0324960686,
0.0218902845,
-0.0009064661,
0.0240685511,
0.0502998829,
-0.015008132,
-0.0321598463,
-0.0271623544,
-0.0173181314,
0.0132059008,
0.0268456787,
-0.0466474444,
-0.0024854653,
-0.0509668402,
0.0280288383,
-0.0301536918,
0.0108735878,
-0.0339731462,
0.0172179081,
0.0010605737,
0.0098388931,
-0.0690982491,
-0.0203908663,
0.0329094715,
-0.0153738437,
0.0203047544,
0.0065513309,
0.0397675894,
0.0412304439,
0.0143022966,
0.006504782,
0.0057949773,
-0.0247515254,
0.0229596142,
-0.0093729505,
0.0272097625,
0.0493808165,
-0.0199244171,
-0.0094785634,
0.0311358441,
-0.0997342244,
0.0242845267,
0.0721476376,
-0.018590318,
-0.0434979945,
-0.0096869525,
-0.0518094972,
0.0555155128,
-0.0089950338,
-0.0454888605,
-0.0167022571,
-0.0039065476,
0.0178916231,
0.0067479392,
-0.0503097847,
-0.0357009135,
-0.0591921806,
-0.0166467726,
-0.042207323,
-0.0076673296,
0.016417671,
-0.000490669,
0.0651221052,
0.0326978005,
1.46530881e-34,
0.0171382464,
-0.0236779191,
0.0019930992,
-0.0386468135,
0.0395359062,
0.0359603725,
-0.0009530139,
-0.0249039251,
0.0288490094,
-0.0166875999,
-0.0244412795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16275v1 | Writing Assistants Should Model Social Factors of Language | 2023-03-28T19:38:57 | 2023-03-28T19:38:57 | Vivek Kulkarni, Vipul Raheja | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.7; K.4.2; H.5.0 | Intelligent writing assistants powered by large language models (LLMs) are
more popular today than ever before, but their further widespread adoption is
precluded by sub-optimal performance. In this position paper, we argue that a
major reason for this sub-optimal performance and adoption is a singular focus
on the information content of language while ignoring its social aspects. We
analyze the different dimensions of these social factors in the context of
writing assistants and propose their incorporation into building smarter, more
effective, and truly personalized writing assistants that would enrich the user
experience and contribute to increased user adoption. | [
0.072975643,
0.0045249914,
-0.0239529833,
0.0178153217,
-0.0415996984,
-0.0115839355,
0.0366545655,
0.0077913348,
0.0337824635,
-0.0643370524,
-0.0396484025,
-0.0349973179,
0.0116775632,
0.0318697989,
0.0039924965,
-0.044154387,
0.0269640107,
-0.0046083643,
0.0542168468,
-0.0125759766,
0.0350383483,
0.0359142125,
0.0252083968,
0.0542086251,
-0.0088404724,
-0.0399905033,
0.0133301299,
-0.0174701456,
-0.0123068234,
-0.0038884329,
0.0212768633,
0.078296639,
0.00085049,
0.0488294177,
0.0000018992,
-0.0421144962,
0.0089247897,
-0.0224258211,
0.0005489082,
0.0106020402,
0.0771732777,
0.0258756466,
-0.0368650146,
0.0309104323,
-0.0532547198,
0.0224698484,
0.0261789057,
0.0176926106,
0.006165823,
0.0508471392,
-0.0398111865,
-0.006017521,
0.001516251,
-0.0133112473,
-0.019319525,
-0.0109719634,
-0.0081308857,
-0.0123951053,
0.0134102749,
-0.0008528798,
0.018031992,
0.049860321,
-0.0121211177,
-0.0603909642,
0.0543447547,
0.021271687,
-0.0120381992,
-0.003282882,
-0.02768814,
0.0136582917,
0.0482545979,
-0.0072509758,
-0.0040666116,
-0.0019142065,
0.0071873749,
0.0425201468,
-0.036115244,
0.0007181148,
-0.0136793079,
-0.0043937,
0.0387972854,
0.0142243346,
0.0071795508,
0.0267805401,
0.0541762002,
0.0661260933,
0.0019127282,
-0.0030811136,
-0.0234016292,
0.0330382958,
0.0193836857,
-0.0684596077,
0.0630058274,
0.0573619716,
-0.0042539774,
0.0089755673,
-0.0537564307,
-0.0132023348,
0.0094095208,
-0.0338119902,
0.087787874,
0.0055341343,
0.0473469235,
-0.0038646418,
0.026469944,
0.0102443192,
0.0086188912,
-0.0140854511,
-0.0020388139,
0.010643349,
0.001505832,
-0.026364034,
-0.03041026,
0.0171573851,
-0.0444490835,
-0.0377661549,
-0.009070009,
0.0308993291,
0.0028455206,
0.0237537194,
0.0119039463,
0.0302704908,
-0.0381431356,
-0.0010082194,
0.0186880827,
-0.0239308421,
-0.0579921193,
0.0185926538,
-0.0149218738,
-0.0069450638,
0.0615373962,
-0.020879155,
0.0468735211,
-0.0127276052,
-0.0224075075,
0.0166241471,
-0.0236504246,
-0.0589729697,
-0.0418781489,
-0.0232928526,
-0.0027796957,
-0.041270297,
-0.0495295003,
-0.0488767773,
0.0173138902,
0.0570931546,
-0.0056442479,
-0.0770080015,
-0.0264485832,
0.0527918637,
-0.0159129612,
-0.0266587269,
-0.0364887416,
0.0280350726,
0.0874080285,
0.0156972241,
0.0173489265,
0.0129326703,
0.0432754941,
0.009428787,
0.0544175729,
-0.0023848466,
0.05198678,
0.0364509411,
-0.0538351238,
0.0043011727,
0.0040925532,
-0.0387691185,
-0.0468809046,
-0.0116730239,
0.0086092092,
0.0575917549,
0.0115227289,
-0.0090490729,
0.1128621623,
0.0772623271,
0.0343017057,
0.0948336497,
0.0171148311,
0.0176887643,
0.0121581908,
0.0180857182,
-0.0222017728,
0.0452384166,
-0.0342011265,
0.0011516694,
-0.0309748054,
0.0177836083,
-0.0210669246,
-0.0520754643,
-0.0268593244,
0.000735524,
0.0189489368,
-0.008675646,
0.0133029176,
-0.0063200556,
-0.00710491,
0.0073359129,
0.0117868921,
-0.0956582427,
-0.0081776986,
-0.0061506461,
0.0467484146,
0.1156286523,
0.0628512055,
-0.0296500381,
0.026558971,
-0.022419339,
-0.0148438867,
0.0410349779,
0.0340158045,
-0.0110313743,
-0.0056280098,
-0.040199846,
0.0123457098,
-0.0091150012,
0.022017289,
0.0036409802,
0.0217943639,
0.0305537283,
0.0260749385,
0.030745415,
-0.0746927187,
0.0229495335,
-0.0411316976,
-0.0185625069,
-0.0276849587,
0.026463693,
-0.010137911,
0.0554509051,
-0.0171112586,
0.003152949,
-0.0258861333,
-0.0275006685,
-0.0067778397,
0.0401611328,
-0.0124509754,
0.0333414078,
0.0205755383,
-0.003013022,
0.0151886493,
0.0634713843,
0.0525511429,
-0.0267899595,
0.0328235067,
-0.0517480187,
0.0868052244,
-0.0050683068,
0.009737866,
-0.0327141695,
-0.0232929196,
-0.013885458,
0.01827907,
-0.0138145266,
-0.0172338914,
-0.0018793298,
0.0060499986,
0.0024652788,
-0.019674249,
-0.0261143353,
-0.0132456115,
0.0175597575,
0.0082201622,
0.0362195782,
-0.0203978084,
-0.0251637381,
-0.0478892736,
-0.0885058343,
-0.0266477372,
-0.0247236546,
0.0006624879,
0.027769547,
0.0046902341,
-0.0159192979,
-0.0031680677,
-0.0466709659,
0.0032440629,
-0.0139569221,
0.0037743752,
0.0689701214,
-0.0245998874,
0.0034315549,
-0.0781994462,
0.0040255245,
-0.022056818,
0.0141856223,
0.0533015169,
-0.0359052904,
-0.0598401763,
0.0463599488,
-0.0471455678,
-0.0045758621,
-0.0039734147,
-0.0366915055,
0.0188565888,
0.0026909171,
0.0567324162,
0.0847087502,
-0.0017828384,
0.0526926666,
0.0494013391,
0.004872846,
-0.0104900803,
-0.0224525239,
0.0250652358,
0.0675143078,
0.0328021422,
-0.0818252638,
0.0093489168,
0.0516352281,
0.0187644176,
-0.0048357123,
-0.0211409479,
0.0412906967,
-0.0293618906,
-0.0220057946,
0.0061586294,
-0.0452087596,
-0.0238645189,
0.0263430737,
-0.0330122858,
-0.0601493604,
0.0178693887,
-0.0238910969,
-0.022484988,
-0.0203304868,
-0.0502041019,
-0.0420999676,
0.0595656745,
-0.0054615121,
0.0370973907,
-0.0626657456,
-0.0232799873,
-0.0316085108,
-0.0221978482,
0.0464521162,
-0.0008978235,
0.0258176681,
-0.0400977992,
-0.002370279,
0.0048131961,
-0.003713622,
0.0142678395,
-0.0585499704,
-0.0710839033,
-0.0157878119,
0.0269501768,
-0.0600699522,
-0.0018624044,
-0.0126035428,
0.0219961684,
0.0683650821,
-0.0304739717,
0.0017003688,
-0.0329573341,
-0.0106920209,
0.0465311892,
-0.036395438,
-0.015981039,
-0.0342230462,
0.0343080871,
0.0219981074,
0.0203244109,
-0.0085133091,
-0.0262206048,
-0.0443197638,
0.0299030561,
-0.0245844498,
-0.0730526373,
0.0003311558,
0.0702752173,
-0.0325086713,
0.0068992572,
0.1262444258,
0.0058850287,
-0.063148506,
-0.0101558454,
-0.032835912,
0.0226765983,
0.0130606731,
0.051876884,
-0.0112855444,
-0.0133812446,
-0.0030505052,
0.014033759,
-0.01319033,
-0.0322579332,
-0.0169264786,
-0.0493799224,
0.0254592486,
-0.0097350469,
-0.0227305051,
0.0081309984,
-0.0025753812,
-0.0187525135,
0.0271182917,
-0.0019309398,
-0.0266699735,
-0.0480073206,
-0.0210795682,
-0.0200816207,
-0.070472829,
0.0043649627,
-0.0102538224,
-0.0474024639,
0.043603994,
0.0428301096,
0.0772777796,
-0.0001045633,
-0.0220711883,
-0.0347763933,
0.079125613,
0.0310749505,
-0.0203607287,
0.0345014408,
-0.0193942655,
0.030846566,
-0.0832505524,
0.0345832221,
-0.0108592398,
-0.0152675761,
-0.0088298013,
0.0148120616,
-0.016971387,
-0.0342644267,
-0.0247532297,
0.0154903,
0.0231197327,
0.0533733219,
0.0225612838,
-0.0624254309,
-0.0179819986,
-0.0383291133,
0.0283523481,
0.0033619187,
-0.0095374091,
0.0007483004,
-0.0414782576,
-0.0597258024,
-0.0717253461,
-0.0722523481,
0.028250102,
0.0273377784,
0.0431243666,
0.0330432616,
0.0431631021,
-0.0080935489,
-0.0311451573,
-0.0118380524,
-0.0084805209,
0.0208013393,
-0.037935812,
-0.0241866615,
0.0011218122,
-0.0346301049,
0.0410902686,
-0.0367811546,
-0.019117279,
-0.0485119522,
0.034878578,
0.0157434046,
0.0216665156,
0.0104469266,
-0.0048259906,
-0.1200523525,
0.0147394249,
-0.0172622371,
-0.0149867646,
0.0624015778,
0.0158907007,
-0.0116570415,
0.0073187659,
0.0319647454,
0.0110712005,
-0.0025470895,
-0.0223147646,
-0.028156193,
-0.0339219049,
-0.058657825,
-0.0292295031,
0.017773632,
-0.0146918828,
-0.0275861751,
0.0346519761,
-0.0714664385,
-0.0139260795,
-0.0700604916,
0.0021878607,
-0.014449304,
-0.0270046871,
-0.0193951745,
0.0157737806,
-0.0368926078,
-0.0126958098,
-0.0511399172,
0.0086362045,
-0.0597071946,
0.0589876063,
-0.0198904183,
0.0495715104,
0.0096572228,
0.0175822563,
-0.0289781466,
0.0565998033,
-0.0315969102,
0.0305156186,
0.0365784578,
0.0659575313,
-0.0168286934,
-0.0179935768,
0.0024033457,
0.0554682799,
-0.0543379374,
-0.0289976913,
-0.0070919986,
0.0306570418,
0.0159292091,
-0.0393410921,
0.0942302421,
-0.0306179877,
0.0126518905,
-0.0029732697,
0.0458501168,
0.0269618798,
-0.0368215293,
-0.0278489906,
-0.0077511766,
-0.0094367284,
0.0104311779,
0.0829100534,
-0.0085985102,
0.0012448634,
0.0069827382,
-0.054791186,
-0.0152375977,
-0.0179198571,
0.0529671647,
0.0437273979,
-0.0141253583,
-0.0310956482,
-0.094793722,
-0.0479186177,
0.0336313546,
-0.0190363247,
-0.0103107346,
-0.0721969754,
0.0335195661,
0.0528475717,
-0.0349015407,
-0.0297154095,
-0.0876535326,
0.01417212,
-0.0489616059,
0.0104582338,
-0.0039306716,
-5.91536308e-33,
-0.0165110156,
-0.0697377771,
0.0073540923,
0.0638316125,
0.0181866717,
0.0109403757,
-0.0394955054,
0.036936976,
0.0154418191,
0.0354259983,
-0.06046848,
0.0284243915,
0.0046879523,
0.0057080211,
0.0263176598,
0.0298433248,
0.0615735874,
-0.0114645911,
-0.0092630759,
-0.0027477453,
0.0312758274,
0.0051110168,
0.0189971961,
-0.0749628395,
0.0586452261,
-0.0573497452,
-0.0090812091,
-0.0136527224,
0.021855345,
-0.0038895949,
-0.0216697175,
0.034899991,
0.0360420495,
0.0319562405,
0.0070256782,
0.0772592202,
-0.0014478314,
-0.0426271446,
-0.0022378415,
0.0119939912,
-0.0045645568,
-0.064493008,
0.0182758979,
-0.0114994263,
-0.052248735,
0.0381471403,
0.0565960854,
0.0035796782,
-0.0044183638,
-0.0045669451,
-0.0759350285,
0.0274365209,
0.0136441123,
-0.0170931593,
-0.0054504988,
-0.0046281908,
0.0102415085,
-0.0185732748,
-0.0316006877,
0.0271187667,
-0.0183588732,
-0.010397804,
0.0348894969,
0.0015285222,
-0.027121257,
0.0439676829,
-0.0156008387,
0.0693735331,
-0.0135053378,
0.0085172961,
0.030732112,
0.0346595608,
0.0416679382,
0.0643128529,
-0.0501030125,
-0.0190412086,
0.0074214949,
0.0564571433,
0.0656617656,
-0.0474457145,
0.0073789633,
-0.0067366464,
-0.0712422356,
-0.059638489,
0.0154863419,
-0.0042193029,
-0.0105506061,
-0.0185027532,
0.0128390621,
-0.0285456814,
-0.0261744745,
-0.0316484496,
-0.0317131169,
-0.0101156859,
-0.0389929339,
0.0026663446,
-0.0388423577,
0.0460193679,
-0.0097485986,
-0.0155637357,
-0.0513477102,
-0.0018270715,
-0.0548465103,
0.0497402959,
0.0047078468,
0.0149281453,
0.0070880391,
0.0223570783,
-0.0424854681,
-0.0020111015,
-0.0031577281,
0.039720647,
0.0405579247,
-0.0310681295,
0.0112879062,
-0.0341792628,
-0.0154422354,
0.068609409,
0.0417072326,
0.0401776657,
-0.0306115616,
-0.0405007973,
0.0025736305,
-0.0292922724,
-0.019919686,
-0.0254175682,
-0.0523862205,
0.0354440697,
0.0649324507,
-0.0122346282,
0.0037620347,
-0.0887009278,
2.53e-7,
0.0266524274,
0.0657406151,
-0.0048737065,
0.013211729,
0.0228982065,
0.0491313934,
0.0248674769,
0.0597562566,
0.0051224008,
0.0729313791,
0.0213959534,
0.0254281163,
0.039757818,
0.0348377675,
-0.0673310533,
-0.0148277422,
-0.0805623382,
0.0202868562,
-0.0393711254,
-0.0053587044,
-0.0051164832,
-0.0186403412,
0.0435165912,
-0.0312358793,
-0.0288493261,
-0.0646569654,
0.0422319509,
-0.0419164635,
0.0043382607,
0.015206431,
0.0295264013,
0.0200370532,
-0.0075391331,
-0.0035292129,
-0.0317700282,
0.0101485467,
0.0060064793,
0.0669516474,
-0.0393420048,
0.0280353297,
0.0678942576,
-0.0019011097,
-0.0290344339,
-0.0463681743,
0.0560825169,
0.0280209146,
-0.0124497386,
-0.0269508362,
0.0342303701,
-0.0032912998,
-0.0170064755,
-0.0320554972,
-0.0005674234,
0.0167088248,
-0.0012005578,
-0.0757325813,
0.0092626372,
-0.024571389,
-0.0230279993,
-0.0141953593,
0.0370079838,
-0.0247259755,
-0.0705796927,
-0.0016258521,
-0.0067446525,
-0.0536113866,
0.0261064842,
1.886676124e-34,
-0.0085913315,
0.0154213598,
0.0241970066,
0.014511981,
0.045575995,
0.0368726104,
-0.0127524883,
0.0271974821,
0.0583903231,
-0.0298407357,
0.0004557484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16256v1 | Scalable handwritten text recognition system for lexicographic sources of under-resourced languages and alphabets | 2023-03-28T19:06:27 | 2023-03-28T19:06:27 | Jan Idziak, Artjoms Šeļa, Michał Woźniak, Albert Leśniak, Joanna Byszuk, Maciej Eder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | The paper discusses an approach to decipher large collections of handwritten
index cards of historical dictionaries. Our study provides a working solution
that reads the cards, and links their lemmas to a searchable list of dictionary
entries, for a large historical dictionary entitled the Dictionary of the 17th-
and 18th-century Polish, which comprizes 2.8 million index cards. We apply a
tailored handwritten text recognition (HTR) solution that involves (1) an
optimized detection model; (2) a recognition model to decipher the handwritten
content, designed as a spatial transformer network (STN) followed by
convolutional neural network (RCNN) with a connectionist temporal
classification layer (CTC), trained using a synthetic set of 500,000 generated
Polish words of different length; (3) a post-processing step using constrained
Word Beam Search (WBC): the predictions were matched against a list of
dictionary entries known in advance. Our model achieved the accuracy of 0.881
on the word level, which outperforms the base RCNN model. Within this study we
produced a set of 20,000 manually annotated index cards that can be used for
future benchmarks and transfer learning HTR applications. | [
0.0104663232,
0.0473012105,
0.0209576618,
0.1169531569,
-0.0231953505,
0.0267363116,
0.0531255491,
0.0237174779,
0.0236478895,
0.0105347885,
-0.0064137708,
0.0115561802,
0.0441327989,
0.0217646882,
-0.0249935053,
-0.007517878,
0.0112495776,
-0.0314279534,
-0.0482093729,
0.0021063187,
-0.000477884,
-0.0231207125,
-0.031417679,
0.0045566726,
-0.0586037003,
0.0228528772,
-0.020817617,
0.0299703535,
-0.0076200352,
-0.0303637926,
-0.0180912837,
0.0196202695,
0.0172979943,
0.1037717387,
0.0000019631,
-0.0174852107,
-0.0128453784,
-0.0287350118,
0.0171936527,
-0.0309139118,
0.0898804143,
-0.0211179629,
-0.0032258942,
-0.0219025891,
-0.0162201971,
-0.0658336878,
0.0568617098,
0.1064264104,
-0.0155064762,
0.0402333401,
-0.0298163015,
-0.0649212226,
0.0444975868,
-0.020601647,
0.0235619955,
-0.0335872211,
0.0073822192,
-0.0225003324,
-0.0095383124,
-0.0105726551,
-0.0054558734,
0.0787909701,
0.0257682241,
-0.0446351953,
0.0279224198,
0.0053123315,
-0.0179678313,
0.0187596492,
-0.0090076961,
0.036423523,
-0.0578390583,
-0.0283007193,
0.0014362674,
-0.0225353222,
-0.0391938537,
0.0305730402,
0.0085496521,
0.0047252937,
-0.0139248408,
-0.0116685322,
-0.0315651074,
0.0194722489,
0.0313926786,
0.0347994007,
-0.0165696964,
0.0452865846,
0.0042567509,
-0.0353609212,
0.0155954361,
-0.024899736,
0.0344030187,
0.0176404994,
0.047708407,
0.0273653325,
0.0368668251,
-0.0046219979,
-0.0066433088,
-0.077260226,
-0.0264559332,
-0.0603459179,
0.0021367846,
0.0340269506,
-0.0209426768,
0.0422629006,
-0.0602575205,
0.0652765557,
-0.0682523474,
0.0289457534,
-0.0559410602,
-0.0397211611,
-0.0584508404,
-0.0144734187,
-0.0632558316,
-0.0194300916,
-0.0296506546,
-0.0239313804,
-0.0143761924,
-0.0363389365,
0.0662738457,
-0.0233412739,
-0.042908255,
0.0074485731,
-0.0237427596,
-0.0180230979,
0.000222059,
0.0346965976,
0.0300518423,
-0.0185087975,
-0.0689830184,
-0.014611573,
0.0168609004,
0.0498564281,
0.0533913672,
-0.052397158,
0.0268902984,
0.0097896708,
-0.0348483026,
-0.0615661554,
-0.0309059415,
0.0355784334,
-0.0252914112,
0.0008308195,
0.0797717571,
-0.066232346,
0.0476772785,
-0.004882596,
-0.0013668837,
-0.0258499086,
0.006841253,
-0.0053760037,
-0.0419402905,
0.0795454606,
-0.0070476071,
-0.0182984639,
0.1095832065,
-0.009845973,
0.0200150274,
-0.0454544947,
0.048171185,
0.0578710027,
-0.0144648878,
-0.0304121748,
0.0177357383,
0.0632080212,
-0.0339657515,
-0.0494520515,
-0.0460962877,
-0.033824183,
0.0346414037,
0.0214202572,
0.0110956496,
0.0521976762,
-0.0214316752,
0.0051848404,
0.0476792939,
0.0641577318,
0.0273942128,
0.0299630966,
0.015194281,
-0.0002771506,
0.0099019613,
-0.0569188409,
-0.0060300454,
-0.007100476,
0.0369584709,
-0.0142181078,
-0.0400034487,
-0.0258541033,
0.0005372958,
0.002223491,
0.0127066169,
-0.0113695329,
0.0281307548,
-0.0258083735,
0.0680397823,
-0.0199622512,
-0.0731768757,
0.0095711565,
0.0116224485,
-0.013214075,
-0.0255545918,
-0.0353833809,
0.0245823842,
0.0897061825,
0.0794390142,
-0.0498333685,
0.0309039745,
0.0089019723,
-0.0136869578,
0.0586595684,
0.0075240107,
0.0105351396,
0.0454000346,
-0.0730992258,
-0.0324211232,
0.0528488681,
-0.0334763341,
0.0656620488,
0.0067827497,
0.053006988,
0.017892763,
-0.0117923887,
-0.0427289382,
0.0395408124,
0.0376233757,
-0.0447523333,
0.0339693762,
0.0250322837,
0.0113341315,
0.0008554862,
-0.0116121154,
-0.0400800891,
0.0400060751,
-0.0760381445,
0.0459041111,
-0.0150686987,
-0.030227894,
-0.0025652093,
0.0234184489,
-0.055247888,
0.0118383933,
0.0703423694,
-0.0130896242,
-0.0408243202,
0.0097051002,
-0.0090887481,
0.0197865143,
-0.0117421597,
-0.0134477066,
0.0060130958,
0.0529186502,
0.0002100321,
0.018090833,
0.0006981811,
-0.0083728144,
-0.0256381743,
-0.0240465552,
0.0019795538,
-0.0512109511,
-0.0401225202,
0.0142479446,
-0.0117253484,
-0.0271840021,
0.0033583865,
0.0594097711,
0.025418669,
-0.0226416588,
-0.0416058414,
-0.0302812625,
0.0118509512,
-0.0327547081,
-0.0211263262,
0.013652388,
0.0278731976,
-0.047672715,
0.0069834478,
-0.0018507501,
-0.0171095114,
-0.0288429093,
0.0369308181,
0.0301680472,
-0.0049240468,
-0.013361237,
-0.0501834005,
0.0191693325,
0.0095280828,
0.0194810275,
-0.0804891586,
0.0000805815,
0.0011649245,
0.045995269,
0.028654743,
-0.0374953039,
-0.0082901157,
-0.0207217894,
-0.0231506042,
-0.0247491989,
0.0365831256,
-0.0006899842,
-0.0549565665,
0.0059036496,
-0.0078781005,
-0.0207171254,
0.0253523029,
0.0021336076,
0.0472712442,
0.0043244353,
-0.0050841318,
-0.02012817,
0.026203407,
-0.0194307603,
0.0669687092,
-0.0205242205,
-0.084517099,
-0.0480531044,
-0.0078426115,
-0.0740093365,
-0.0259785783,
-0.0231004413,
0.0003121555,
-0.0230548121,
-0.0154373916,
-0.0379179753,
-0.0556959994,
-0.0182650108,
0.0169341899,
-0.033120174,
-0.032951653,
0.0674488768,
0.0358595699,
0.0239433497,
-0.073715277,
-0.0323152319,
-0.0155908046,
-0.051303748,
0.0014277713,
-0.0352159888,
-0.0010574629,
0.000860671,
0.0391499847,
-0.0709916577,
-0.0064418749,
-0.0171565134,
-0.0544735789,
-0.0175070185,
-0.0549423136,
0.0289198495,
-0.0241698846,
0.0026877471,
0.0467885509,
0.0129947383,
0.1190694347,
0.0077926689,
-0.0036175866,
-0.0355691053,
0.0706869736,
-0.006758186,
0.0004099649,
0.0315485075,
-0.0127377193,
-0.0333503336,
-0.0184707344,
0.0117022665,
0.0011607937,
-0.0577160195,
0.0079253977,
0.0070211845,
0.0262696613,
-0.0067043188,
-0.0446123667,
-0.0396899655,
-0.0624100268,
-0.0040786355,
0.0483398736,
0.0021327585,
-0.0576310754,
-0.069105193,
0.0101333186,
-0.086212419,
-0.0457768477,
0.0365180634,
-0.0623923093,
-0.0111110602,
0.0179666393,
0.0167352986,
-0.003680489,
-0.0084779207,
-0.0022731102,
-0.0520432591,
0.0005812161,
-0.0052550542,
-0.0311372317,
-0.0329165831,
-0.000770746,
-0.0509634577,
-0.0086217998,
-0.0134536568,
0.0080474755,
-0.0062147249,
-0.050123997,
-0.0040472625,
0.0031040709,
0.0409882367,
-0.0066700121,
0.0216814838,
-0.0504431427,
0.0213119406,
0.0860771984,
-0.0378080755,
-0.0317559652,
0.0339158438,
0.0296572354,
0.009208465,
-0.0493461937,
0.024512371,
0.0094342558,
0.0065748091,
0.0044247643,
0.0347368568,
-0.0328698047,
-0.0312413368,
0.0077596912,
0.0109108677,
0.0219320059,
0.0193684101,
0.008348125,
-0.0544922464,
0.0229884926,
0.023449,
-0.0279502384,
0.0104535036,
-0.0541039146,
-0.0002779523,
0.0444538333,
-0.0640900135,
-0.036796432,
0.0172078386,
0.0236242972,
0.0133853154,
-0.0161675382,
-0.0118799629,
-0.0303884577,
0.0038767483,
0.0204345658,
-0.0247753169,
0.0197028983,
0.022510862,
-0.0691364035,
0.0197465066,
-0.0591665208,
0.015689915,
-0.0767879039,
0.0371693745,
-0.0177992657,
-0.0830337107,
-0.006741201,
0.0380393416,
-0.0391678512,
0.0189777426,
0.0848186687,
0.0209131241,
0.0106482795,
-0.0070322696,
-0.0278596357,
-0.0398257002,
0.0563126728,
0.0299717057,
-0.0161718484,
-0.0521407202,
0.0063524852,
-0.0239034165,
-0.0452518202,
-0.001070277,
-0.0336956643,
0.0434427857,
0.024901377,
-0.0742517561,
-0.0321526229,
-0.0429354422,
-0.0492527634,
-0.0011998126,
0.0524864793,
-0.0164532457,
0.0024785774,
-0.0533020645,
0.0298213605,
0.0473664142,
0.0286120065,
0.0097519523,
-0.0272549894,
0.0085506914,
0.0242027342,
-0.0055731661,
-0.0046303873,
0.0739549175,
-0.021533411,
0.0113008777,
0.0436080545,
0.0058398023,
0.0185381826,
0.0020171178,
0.0203919504,
0.0088360216,
0.0810466334,
0.0023210952,
0.0351243503,
0.0214583315,
-0.0045544086,
0.008633038,
0.0042006578,
-0.0282833502,
0.0017088262,
-0.0645793751,
-0.029348908,
-0.0258697309,
0.0113931876,
0.0636498183,
-0.0547392406,
0.0016697594,
-0.034369763,
0.0113938292,
-0.0293137524,
-0.0161396638,
0.0387303643,
0.0159884393,
-0.0261525847,
0.0188702308,
0.02700877,
0.0349463336,
-0.0112836407,
-0.001859426,
0.0276384279,
0.0541309677,
-0.0086636897,
-0.0584293231,
-0.0096901348,
-0.0076195523,
-0.0119895842,
-0.0468146801,
-0.0052816803,
-0.0251032375,
0.0180324167,
0.0808254257,
0.0242512673,
-0.0030353956,
-0.0088498825,
0.0021484524,
-0.0322039463,
0.0214857105,
0.0451014489,
-0.0022096112,
0.0644060895,
0.0360768773,
-0.0206783377,
-0.0629007816,
-5.611543708e-33,
0.0189816691,
-0.0332704,
0.0194594208,
0.0141024254,
-0.0058012423,
0.0222606082,
-0.016348606,
-0.0048056524,
-0.0319176279,
-0.0008309693,
-0.0641009659,
-0.0034996998,
0.0411444977,
0.0550331846,
0.0053589838,
0.0136544341,
0.0285623129,
-0.0053523835,
0.0134476414,
0.0208595693,
0.0843684375,
0.055220142,
0.0699808896,
-0.0534247309,
-0.0398413837,
-0.0553888865,
0.0283395853,
0.0258108545,
0.0309494827,
-0.0108230095,
-0.0397262126,
-0.0145148486,
0.0099539608,
-0.058510676,
0.0418946818,
0.0648705736,
-0.0593501143,
0.0050069527,
-0.0774635226,
0.0899562836,
0.0194345191,
-0.0300473645,
0.0130007006,
0.0282969642,
-0.0343177095,
0.0083171846,
0.0274909418,
0.007121922,
-0.0236539003,
-0.0699806064,
-0.042993512,
0.040404778,
-0.0099611999,
-0.0167535152,
0.0545521453,
-0.0258780848,
0.0156781934,
-0.0148179494,
-0.0934184864,
0.0087221228,
0.0046116468,
0.0141154518,
-0.0087638311,
0.0396856293,
-0.0300352667,
0.0099439146,
0.0335683413,
-0.0246390402,
0.053915944,
0.0022405291,
0.0485203005,
-0.0043724314,
0.0561184511,
0.0804354772,
0.1019548625,
-0.039665278,
-0.0127394386,
-0.0034880266,
0.0337860063,
0.0566651896,
0.044881925,
-0.0103030624,
-0.0305824075,
0.0478215106,
0.0113920476,
-0.0147430105,
-0.0159349088,
0.0255256463,
0.0326817185,
0.034385208,
0.018825978,
0.0217915494,
0.056981843,
-0.0309545193,
-0.0115017612,
0.0006560019,
0.028111428,
0.0422353148,
-0.0176369585,
0.0041591655,
-0.0473916307,
-0.0608275756,
-0.000797271,
0.0202593971,
-0.0038665324,
-0.0054562408,
0.0412821099,
0.0280215442,
-0.017085189,
0.0009996025,
0.0168914609,
0.0125284372,
0.0305862874,
0.0554430932,
0.0309165623,
-0.0180119351,
0.0273778848,
-0.0146157322,
0.0001654661,
0.0154992966,
0.0212609693,
-0.0499253608,
0.0382018313,
-0.0018361923,
-0.0098470049,
0.0189891942,
-0.0281153396,
0.0396801867,
0.0121805789,
-0.0354104862,
0.0431800112,
0.0338880122,
2.772e-7,
0.0438872278,
0.0249726418,
0.0403473563,
-0.0028322355,
-0.0031152635,
-0.0088738734,
-0.0115787564,
-0.0167389084,
-0.0785002038,
0.0417465493,
0.0623661578,
0.0198656991,
0.0734502599,
0.0101019647,
-0.0677341968,
-0.0013001791,
-0.0392373092,
0.0355705023,
-0.0480483584,
0.0292578749,
0.0026551115,
0.0837675482,
-0.0039522527,
-0.0554645658,
0.0012875948,
-0.0473968908,
0.0379169323,
-0.002497725,
0.0654136315,
-0.0246330127,
0.0032584211,
0.0241480861,
-0.0441125222,
0.0042063375,
0.0223695803,
0.0254976526,
0.0275746156,
0.0149469189,
-0.0189274549,
0.0125144115,
-0.002435039,
0.0052175913,
-0.0372195765,
-0.0424976125,
0.0368068963,
0.0097594596,
0.0464950316,
-0.0050144051,
-0.0051227058,
0.0130842328,
0.0103903674,
0.0100342073,
0.0235607885,
0.0119986478,
0.0266606864,
-0.0528725609,
-0.0174451787,
-0.0663819984,
0.0238187667,
-0.0267096628,
-0.0032646838,
0.0324775986,
-0.0735685527,
-0.0123178679,
0.0434886925,
0.0118455905,
-0.0151303327,
1.708322866e-34,
-0.0391909294,
-0.0079146568,
-0.0345532075,
-0.0188445803,
-0.0206734892,
0.0085621923,
0.0052072876,
0.0045243693,
-0.0039474973,
-0.0485844426,
-0.0001346821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16252v1 | Zero-Shot Generalizable End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialog System using Context Summarization and Domain Schema | 2023-03-28T18:56:31 | 2023-03-28T18:56:31 | Adib Mosharrof, M. H. Maqbool, A. B. Siddique | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Task-oriented dialog systems empower users to accomplish their goals by
facilitating intuitive and expressive natural language interactions.
State-of-the-art approaches in task-oriented dialog systems formulate the
problem as a conditional sequence generation task and fine-tune pre-trained
causal language models in the supervised setting. This requires labeled
training data for each new domain or task, and acquiring such data is
prohibitively laborious and expensive, thus making it a bottleneck for scaling
systems to a wide range of domains. To overcome this challenge, we introduce a
novel Zero-Shot generalizable end-to-end Task-oriented Dialog system, ZS-ToD,
that leverages domain schemas to allow for robust generalization to unseen
domains and exploits effective summarization of the dialog history. We employ
GPT-2 as a backbone model and introduce a two-step training process where the
goal of the first step is to learn the general structure of the dialog data and
the second step optimizes the response generation as well as intermediate
outputs, such as dialog state and system actions. As opposed to
state-of-the-art systems that are trained to fulfill certain intents in the
given domains and memorize task-specific conversational patterns, ZS-ToD learns
generic task-completion skills by comprehending domain semantics via domain
schemas and generalizing to unseen domains seamlessly. We conduct an extensive
experimental evaluation on SGD and SGD-X datasets that span up to 20 unique
domains and ZS-ToD outperforms state-of-the-art systems on key metrics, with an
improvement of +17% on joint goal accuracy and +5 on inform. Additionally, we
present a detailed ablation study to demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed components and training mechanism | [
0.024653865,
0.0236285105,
0.0080621038,
-0.0064709084,
0.0240670238,
0.023079697,
0.0055900565,
-0.0498504788,
0.0042085024,
-0.0558453389,
-0.0236333702,
-0.0297209118,
-0.0184808727,
0.0706398487,
0.0079962173,
-0.0754766166,
0.0563872866,
0.0202272907,
0.0186852328,
0.0115120513,
0.0207480099,
0.0169545691,
-0.0200582668,
0.0860464424,
-0.0002299028,
-0.0120286718,
-0.0447415151,
-0.0215293728,
0.0155886179,
-0.0343530253,
0.0359772593,
0.0386266261,
0.0568233728,
0.0280413907,
0.0000019822,
-0.0603352152,
-0.009117417,
-0.0320268981,
-0.020135738,
-0.0410815068,
-0.0007357629,
0.0070623383,
0.0129063977,
0.0269870795,
-0.0407453775,
-0.0434257388,
0.030304743,
0.0719632655,
0.0750756189,
0.0821338221,
-0.0129817277,
-0.0319538079,
0.0203683395,
-0.0405708253,
0.0284874979,
-0.0800330415,
-0.0346083567,
0.0101638138,
0.0192035176,
0.0010894114,
0.0161628835,
-0.0039866846,
0.0103001408,
-0.0189957246,
-0.0073564914,
0.0073695215,
0.0287080295,
-0.0035947692,
-0.0163202956,
0.1063175574,
0.0228063166,
0.0139502157,
0.0273526777,
0.002748413,
0.0153348558,
-0.0353540666,
-0.0653791726,
0.0228705239,
0.0031392616,
-0.0074898256,
-0.0370575376,
0.0540650152,
-0.0137829939,
-0.0049603069,
-0.0284639448,
0.0336375758,
-0.0177966468,
-0.0119598005,
-0.0237967633,
-0.0045945882,
-0.0127185322,
-0.0867912173,
-0.0181369483,
0.0517346784,
-0.0891507119,
0.0051690484,
-0.0553142056,
-0.0108253518,
0.0173267517,
0.0192008559,
0.0346906036,
0.0422383845,
0.0023994569,
0.0280581322,
0.0179494526,
0.0541175455,
0.0194619279,
-0.0131651238,
-0.0439542197,
-0.0180414338,
-0.0825285614,
0.0094754137,
-0.0479080118,
0.0600439534,
-0.0503659025,
-0.0231706724,
-0.0421004929,
0.0482161194,
0.0079579363,
0.0006872333,
-0.0092512956,
0.0562408119,
-0.053525459,
-0.0008986958,
-0.0317349993,
0.0287275482,
-0.0558484308,
0.0347454622,
0.0452391692,
0.0097906757,
-0.021415038,
0.0304589923,
0.0394887216,
0.0070478981,
-0.0284804441,
0.0833158866,
-0.0284458231,
-0.0530130155,
-0.0292275883,
-0.0449380577,
-0.0295007657,
-0.0785532445,
-0.0158792641,
-0.010263565,
0.0061915992,
-0.0034893765,
-0.0374220014,
-0.0310933311,
0.0109989913,
0.0261657685,
0.0069844835,
0.0347815827,
0.0084656561,
-0.0318620242,
0.0077447309,
0.0198279656,
-0.03789711,
0.0584967956,
0.0343781374,
0.031704139,
-0.0043641217,
0.0190164167,
0.0145883914,
-0.0032209768,
0.015849784,
0.0058878912,
0.040692348,
0.0231894944,
0.0012352002,
-0.0037805974,
0.0431684107,
0.0149219967,
-0.040443249,
0.0215175655,
0.046657186,
0.0483288914,
-0.0030179343,
0.0014967697,
0.0428099111,
0.0515568145,
-0.0141368266,
-0.0002583393,
-0.0656611472,
0.0344892107,
-0.0104189971,
0.0364157483,
0.0251737777,
-0.0131988786,
-0.0600052178,
-0.0503527708,
0.0322269723,
-0.0096499491,
0.0132779041,
0.011873316,
0.0372784585,
0.0389864594,
-0.1020857766,
0.0268366747,
-0.0119208684,
-0.0965094641,
-0.0208022222,
-0.0185291693,
0.0352913924,
0.0310111996,
0.0271445066,
-0.0429540984,
-0.0529450998,
-0.0525688604,
0.0326797366,
0.0388947539,
-0.0105812429,
-0.026808355,
0.0436427742,
-0.0538490899,
-0.057157997,
-0.0149548706,
0.0228356123,
0.0242233519,
-0.0054166438,
-0.0239303429,
0.0479739346,
-0.0026342953,
0.0217249431,
-0.0038651405,
-0.0168092214,
-0.0268333461,
0.0262934808,
-0.0015790969,
0.0235254038,
0.0364990346,
0.0033541112,
-0.017292643,
0.0175414141,
-0.0110354135,
-0.0434601605,
0.0123098763,
-0.0786737427,
-0.0265614036,
0.0156347342,
-0.0251907669,
-0.0138455909,
0.024792213,
-0.0534073636,
-0.0861184523,
0.0517216325,
-0.0225409754,
-0.0091080796,
-0.0573203377,
0.0087589389,
0.0492272489,
-0.0031398695,
-0.0180091877,
0.0363391377,
0.0101874936,
-0.0217924491,
0.0318642221,
-0.0053466386,
0.0101512251,
-0.0564087965,
0.0245154239,
-0.0255115703,
-0.0361467786,
0.0222774651,
0.036469169,
0.0237557217,
-0.0367997512,
0.0107445447,
-0.1048417389,
0.0145228878,
-0.0203906093,
0.00278343,
0.0061988514,
0.0236253906,
0.0070475591,
-0.0419670232,
-0.0400079377,
0.0096004494,
0.0600131936,
-0.0454908088,
0.0383720472,
0.0318196714,
0.0017077163,
-0.0489796326,
0.0542169698,
0.0080160303,
0.0034404392,
-0.0081376918,
0.0108232042,
-0.0252933521,
0.0608938374,
-0.0228010733,
0.0428467095,
-0.0248160139,
-0.0090473695,
0.0411929004,
0.0069302646,
0.0358541794,
0.0342807658,
0.0208359174,
0.009433127,
-0.0044926493,
-0.0109225148,
-0.048467122,
0.0485910177,
-0.0292709135,
-0.0073761516,
-0.0097273244,
0.0182925165,
0.0397226252,
0.0777412206,
0.004389985,
0.0218232404,
-0.0611144155,
0.00919999,
0.0207403414,
-0.0171844997,
-0.021517938,
-0.0017026277,
-0.0461047105,
0.0224358737,
-0.0170997996,
-0.0194383617,
0.033857502,
-0.0071538156,
-0.0303601995,
-0.0521927103,
-0.0305186156,
-0.0269454271,
0.0493903756,
-0.0132778352,
0.0079884864,
0.0993412957,
-0.047983449,
-0.0472633131,
-0.0192481186,
0.0174678247,
-0.0012569033,
0.0602058023,
-0.0406962931,
0.011865085,
-0.0246761814,
-0.0437660627,
-0.0512846336,
-0.0012720394,
-0.0216782317,
0.0037278065,
-0.0125738159,
-0.0277342852,
-0.0466003418,
-0.0241166018,
0.0185439978,
0.0745124295,
0.0036939993,
-0.0069969548,
-0.041090738,
0.0270971004,
0.0666326806,
0.0125001296,
-0.0224140286,
-0.0014063958,
0.0351981185,
0.0479226187,
0.0641067252,
-0.0414088778,
-0.0164851025,
-0.0298200138,
0.002372571,
-0.022746766,
-0.0060972758,
0.0364288613,
0.0648705736,
-0.0276966393,
0.0114507759,
0.1322464496,
0.0143112391,
-0.0186658278,
-0.01960719,
0.0172735285,
0.0140162176,
0.0326730572,
-0.0024709296,
-0.1092844903,
-0.0800901651,
0.0132755432,
-0.0033309006,
0.005786221,
-0.0374570042,
-0.0330584012,
-0.1006255895,
0.0285292212,
-0.014891292,
-0.0579268821,
0.0065358756,
-0.0005113121,
-0.0026812113,
0.0082974732,
0.009054061,
-0.0054127034,
0.0020521572,
-0.0085897567,
0.0182795376,
-0.0213382542,
-0.0087902211,
0.020904487,
-0.0033805331,
0.0361784548,
0.0651104972,
0.0293780211,
0.0335670076,
0.0500234179,
0.0367663093,
0.0368718207,
-0.0002328694,
0.0200124532,
0.0457388312,
-0.0288847145,
-0.0008590918,
-0.0201785788,
0.0605556183,
-0.0382255316,
-0.0091151027,
0.0266147405,
0.0573224202,
-0.0291024651,
0.0185027439,
-0.0330034383,
0.0182533339,
0.0389145687,
0.052637279,
0.0258699469,
-0.0420581289,
-0.0535285734,
-0.0329731256,
-0.0315376185,
-0.0743276328,
-0.0021709464,
-0.0378399864,
0.0183083545,
-0.0023056623,
-0.0691122785,
-0.0850385353,
0.0307794902,
0.0055007786,
-0.0152608538,
-0.019977333,
0.0019718311,
0.0051872008,
-0.037645746,
0.0168094542,
-0.0244227853,
0.0116109131,
-0.0729689524,
0.0095741125,
0.0250981171,
-0.0386743657,
-0.0166814402,
0.0491431728,
-0.0408094898,
-0.0620076805,
-0.0647923052,
0.0841057301,
0.0193735659,
0.0370926224,
0.0200716648,
-0.020892052,
0.0426770933,
0.0191783253,
-0.0523294955,
-0.0336162224,
0.0809339657,
0.0336855389,
-0.0208062846,
0.0428090766,
-0.0554484464,
0.0546127148,
-0.0259925481,
0.0248058662,
-0.0169794206,
-0.0160898417,
0.0069416603,
-0.0302043203,
0.0397761725,
0.0061646723,
-0.0073920009,
-0.0068857735,
0.0221150927,
-0.0403829031,
0.0002148898,
-0.0686083287,
0.0170772169,
-0.0239390284,
-0.0170822702,
0.0502002053,
0.0067511038,
-0.0687207878,
0.0347389579,
-0.0383430496,
-0.0018411495,
-0.0149762081,
0.0142524978,
0.0053118845,
-0.0107411779,
-0.0230138134,
-0.0018860821,
0.0306754149,
0.0168920904,
0.0085347658,
0.0831135586,
0.0188390855,
0.0236325413,
0.010715195,
0.0299618244,
-0.0682800785,
-0.0352936648,
-0.0231845025,
0.0000926565,
0.0398840718,
0.0264512487,
0.0345690027,
-0.0096428301,
0.0315198302,
-0.0282575618,
0.088081181,
-0.0260252897,
-0.0369832441,
-0.0001303455,
0.0295754708,
-0.0118447617,
-0.0059410892,
0.0880943909,
0.0081575857,
0.0067906715,
-0.0137783969,
0.0253145788,
-0.0662950501,
-0.0625529215,
0.0227684416,
0.0477798693,
-0.0150840851,
0.0049807103,
-0.043028798,
-0.0488684513,
-0.0106688766,
-0.0116682956,
-0.0038757646,
-0.0248445235,
0.0782038048,
0.0006541701,
-0.0173599757,
-0.027546972,
-0.0086880112,
-0.0237668958,
-0.0177925397,
-0.0259042811,
-0.0276400205,
-5.458119287e-33,
-0.0099264029,
-0.0199294668,
0.0384671241,
-0.008503248,
0.0063465917,
-0.037765719,
-0.0535056591,
0.0197017081,
0.0088644242,
0.003096554,
-0.01486158,
0.0137023004,
0.0094983,
0.0699628666,
-0.0219950415,
0.0102414098,
0.0688708499,
-0.0064086318,
-0.0072449688,
0.0614004508,
0.0470925048,
0.0269497,
0.0489354506,
-0.0496413223,
0.0407661535,
-0.009384593,
-0.0037937886,
0.0138399582,
0.0497767292,
0.0265202615,
-0.0018561335,
0.0432402827,
0.0101233972,
-0.0746041611,
-0.0412903242,
0.0297068991,
-0.0679610968,
-0.0334978029,
0.0282087829,
-0.0406765528,
-0.0392915532,
-0.0114379199,
-0.0101195639,
-0.0141173257,
0.0044886349,
-0.0279640798,
0.0197982807,
-0.0001414198,
-0.0122219939,
-0.0213229582,
-0.0607126355,
-0.0073267892,
-0.0215952527,
-0.0771167353,
-0.0205051564,
0.0881240517,
0.0019431785,
-0.0171308257,
0.0064783492,
0.0148743493,
0.0035282832,
-0.004698725,
0.0428937413,
0.0304163937,
-0.0216604713,
0.0528757349,
0.0144442972,
-0.003999725,
-0.0397547297,
-0.0083098328,
-0.033147525,
0.0252520945,
-0.00179089,
0.0425679013,
0.0244386196,
0.0025759845,
-0.0442375951,
0.0634885952,
0.0127832694,
0.0438772924,
-0.0082304785,
0.0027587484,
-0.0016517148,
0.0025104622,
-0.0486851446,
0.0299032237,
-0.0038217977,
-0.0299396385,
0.0471323505,
0.0467616171,
0.0156529266,
-0.0524494275,
0.0428696126,
-0.0290585365,
0.0220977534,
0.0366020501,
-0.0137941921,
-0.0122779775,
0.0082316492,
-0.0079467595,
-0.0467263944,
-0.0058423337,
0.0557302088,
0.0333844759,
-0.0072664185,
0.0093316073,
0.034599334,
0.0095027909,
-0.02910324,
0.0206409208,
-0.0275713596,
0.0624113455,
-0.031172039,
0.0415120311,
0.0116227427,
0.0012195383,
-0.0324058309,
0.0999286026,
-0.0570449494,
-0.0374355465,
-0.0330590084,
-0.0304047596,
0.0313630849,
0.0193352234,
-0.040559344,
-0.0077793696,
-0.0020801348,
-0.0078007551,
0.018526461,
-0.0106439926,
-0.0072449194,
-0.0139786499,
2.584e-7,
-0.0176911224,
-0.0014475194,
0.0213916115,
0.0612854399,
-0.0103043914,
0.0833135843,
0.0196962897,
0.0667689517,
0.0103543391,
0.0019960033,
0.0283441097,
0.0176704992,
0.0325981118,
-0.0247493498,
-0.1216498762,
-0.0235197339,
-0.0043896437,
-0.012437786,
-0.0231547449,
0.0107235098,
0.059284687,
0.0758834109,
-0.0046587465,
0.0065489402,
0.0279382486,
-0.0270756222,
0.0497118197,
-0.0093002319,
0.0029768585,
-0.0011411142,
-0.0020620942,
-0.0228280947,
-0.0109857507,
-0.0023172523,
-0.0058139954,
0.0217082631,
-0.007582414,
0.0628325492,
0.0015253531,
-0.0567980669,
-0.0107616987,
0.0102004018,
0.0307415258,
-0.0118126022,
0.0524704717,
-0.101484865,
-0.0256100819,
0.0014968835,
-0.0289273225,
-0.0080894725,
-0.0238695368,
0.0109243887,
-0.003557825,
-0.0000333386,
0.0042309458,
-0.0087574022,
0.0246338658,
-0.0898935869,
-0.0090501504,
0.023924049,
-0.0203060601,
-0.0135866916,
-0.0383566655,
-0.0204271171,
0.0151785053,
-0.0328320973,
-0.0204223488,
2.197912016e-34,
0.0305967852,
-0.0096368175,
0.0080030235,
0.0135463979,
0.0250486415,
-0.0223542117,
-0.0458771102,
-0.0084457407,
0.0910739526,
-0.0463390686,
-0.0215652063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16199v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16199v2 | LLaMA-Adapter: Efficient Fine-tuning of Language Models with Zero-init Attention | 2023-03-28T17:59:12 | 2023-06-14T17:31:32 | Renrui Zhang, Jiaming Han, Chris Liu, Peng Gao, Aojun Zhou, Xiangfei Hu, Shilin Yan, Pan Lu, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | We present LLaMA-Adapter, a lightweight adaption method to efficiently
fine-tune LLaMA into an instruction-following model. Using 52K self-instruct
demonstrations, LLaMA-Adapter only introduces 1.2M learnable parameters upon
the frozen LLaMA 7B model, and costs less than one hour for fine-tuning on 8
A100 GPUs. Specifically, we adopt a set of learnable adaption prompts, and
prepend them to the word tokens at higher transformer layers. Then, a
zero-initialized attention mechanism with zero gating is proposed, which
adaptively injects the new instructional cues into LLaMA, while effectively
preserves its pre-trained knowledge. With our efficient training, LLaMA-Adapter
can generate high-quality responses, comparable to Alpaca with fully fine-tuned
7B parameters. Besides language commands, our approach can be simply extended
to multi-modal instructions for learning image-conditioned LLaMA model, which
achieves superior reasoning performance on ScienceQA and COCO Caption
benchmarks. Furthermore, we also evaluate the zero-initialized attention
mechanism for fine-tuning other pre-trained models (ViT, RoBERTa) on
traditional vision and language tasks, demonstrating the superior
generalization capacity of our approach. Code is released at
https://github.com/OpenGVLab/LLaMA-Adapter. | [
0.013951363,
0.0583131909,
-0.0058769062,
0.0504638255,
0.0185225848,
0.0058107944,
0.0001453024,
-0.015797304,
0.010784029,
-0.0557183921,
-0.0676708147,
0.0112388944,
-0.0207494292,
0.0267305505,
0.0226954054,
-0.0607407726,
0.0597504228,
-0.0374612771,
0.0059979577,
-0.0141138099,
0.0011122046,
-0.0263864193,
-0.0189101547,
0.0084781889,
0.0109492913,
-0.0316751637,
-0.0375848562,
0.0007976142,
0.0156480316,
-0.0334442519,
0.0090673659,
0.0513853654,
0.0136950826,
-0.0004844891,
0.0000022906,
-0.0385305882,
0.0287518669,
-0.0361199751,
-0.0095086386,
0.0217459351,
0.0369238183,
-0.0040377383,
-0.0132107101,
0.0071092239,
-0.0223330352,
0.0047927452,
0.0766663551,
0.0267790444,
0.0710744485,
0.0603825375,
0.0014091306,
-0.0464947,
0.0354209393,
-0.0448133573,
0.0292130895,
-0.0333902091,
0.0002055786,
-0.0033172306,
0.0231319293,
0.0065327156,
-0.0432906114,
0.0494068787,
0.0405377969,
-0.010426444,
0.0035927824,
0.0561729334,
-0.0178295057,
-0.0537380464,
-0.0462059863,
0.0896980017,
-0.0371137522,
-0.0301752295,
-0.0319575444,
-0.0114856921,
0.0136124585,
-0.0404345319,
-0.0555332787,
0.0476684086,
0.0262337662,
0.0268997829,
0.0284263603,
-0.0001201358,
0.0187353604,
0.0114778075,
-0.0238085594,
0.0511875674,
0.0034813862,
0.0095739188,
0.0016961475,
0.0083049973,
-0.0231002588,
-0.0518485382,
-0.0229161549,
0.0763326511,
-0.022924941,
0.0204714183,
-0.0708796158,
-0.0390404947,
0.014436801,
-0.0238958262,
0.0765297487,
0.0677039474,
-0.0635059997,
0.0510278307,
-0.0726452023,
0.0723550916,
-0.0289679207,
0.0696256757,
-0.04268777,
0.0156351384,
-0.0127145601,
0.0111092953,
-0.0493091196,
0.0195017476,
-0.0694730952,
-0.0280489922,
-0.0172057524,
0.031384822,
0.0019232059,
-0.0202520378,
-0.0037577292,
0.0187527593,
-0.0397098511,
-0.0046564918,
-0.03669535,
0.0191730205,
-0.0505062789,
0.0376035385,
0.0037899187,
-0.0823325291,
-0.0367538594,
0.0176760517,
0.0055790222,
0.0115721747,
0.0438552275,
0.0794034004,
-0.043002177,
-0.0510122888,
-0.0371641926,
0.0113856271,
0.0247257426,
-0.0752472281,
0.0542765111,
-0.0351283289,
0.036378894,
-0.0074260812,
0.009109755,
-0.0305795521,
0.0324064344,
0.0339172073,
-0.0109008066,
0.0905726999,
-0.0144129554,
-0.0187190734,
0.0034222594,
0.0158807337,
-0.0117466711,
0.0959146097,
0.0298980661,
0.0291729849,
-0.0114220595,
-0.0142544089,
0.0115839494,
0.0182678625,
0.047781527,
0.0025133106,
-0.0214891285,
0.001925559,
0.0142618688,
0.0256605353,
0.0696162805,
0.0346716456,
-0.0139388796,
-0.0171677489,
0.0536825433,
0.0288969595,
-0.0238059685,
0.0306562707,
0.0250854939,
-0.0354282781,
0.0159702823,
-0.006548414,
-0.108956866,
0.0989850909,
-0.0163875204,
0.0060552438,
0.0067117559,
0.0177051518,
-0.0398979448,
-0.0467615165,
0.014785693,
-0.0003582009,
-0.0085368827,
0.0074849161,
-0.0021771621,
0.0257007256,
-0.0661533549,
0.0149086202,
0.0347699039,
-0.0425063856,
-0.0474126898,
-0.0656919703,
0.0620287806,
0.0388240963,
-0.0014875735,
-0.006090567,
-0.0568495393,
0.0075176619,
0.0451017395,
0.0392873287,
0.0178108923,
0.0210588742,
0.0109091289,
-0.056756869,
0.0019029813,
-0.043917276,
0.0160366744,
0.0176965371,
0.0219806042,
0.0110693453,
-0.0040956479,
0.0017707631,
-0.0227378532,
0.0514702089,
0.0223863591,
-0.0613673069,
-0.0303611178,
0.0040571694,
0.0366231278,
-0.0336846597,
0.0241846349,
-0.0041342312,
0.0577700883,
-0.0414295867,
0.0373136997,
0.0043163756,
-0.0769257545,
-0.021027172,
0.0374097861,
-0.0234747492,
0.014231273,
0.0006486525,
-0.0190772917,
-0.0417153724,
0.0127161806,
-0.0016259885,
0.0267820489,
-0.0279095322,
0.0121501656,
0.0077655399,
0.052371379,
-0.0183606725,
0.0460111313,
-0.0190339368,
-0.0022234106,
0.0536877103,
0.0021432925,
-0.0226568356,
-0.0400900617,
-0.0318196155,
-0.0045322529,
0.0080020027,
0.011951765,
-0.0642333999,
0.0369570144,
-0.0604052842,
-0.0332146659,
-0.0579686128,
0.0225968305,
-0.0282571632,
0.0068178256,
0.0371683761,
0.0107279932,
-0.0020578499,
-0.0235710163,
-0.0045948764,
0.0327572562,
-0.0104557853,
0.0109052407,
0.0161782857,
-0.0045270249,
-0.0218323078,
-0.035921365,
-0.001846069,
0.0211236048,
0.0146899447,
0.0017018229,
0.0059963162,
-0.0342484862,
-0.0040398319,
-0.0136523033,
0.0416583419,
-0.0303576924,
-0.0654454678,
0.0253745355,
0.0039596371,
0.0133475726,
0.1317571402,
-0.0132230669,
0.0082703382,
0.0529558025,
0.0018500055,
-0.0429764055,
0.0491968952,
0.0031105443,
-0.0604373775,
0.0036496688,
0.0069520525,
-0.0268746149,
0.094292812,
-0.0693711713,
0.0113040823,
-0.0649436414,
0.020617323,
0.0083742058,
-0.030222591,
0.0066892249,
0.0235846657,
-0.0298849512,
0.0118584288,
-0.0340797901,
-0.0861625522,
0.032668341,
-0.0533429869,
-0.0282176454,
-0.0255064815,
0.0158263315,
-0.0094829798,
0.0191806983,
0.0320893303,
0.0271896776,
0.0095063709,
0.0120281987,
-0.0319989175,
-0.0005972512,
-0.0287237223,
-0.0021333422,
0.0703485981,
-0.0297982022,
-0.0045462693,
-0.0428844988,
-0.0235747248,
-0.0425040796,
0.0319737531,
-0.0658355281,
0.0244133379,
-0.010618519,
-0.0282930918,
-0.0442158133,
-0.0152882542,
0.027889505,
0.0428109206,
-0.0234509669,
0.0120006846,
-0.0445434786,
-0.021624973,
0.0403019302,
0.0721516982,
-0.0132073192,
-0.0319489576,
0.002705713,
0.0295476001,
0.026674917,
-0.0433067493,
-0.0344853252,
0.0256372876,
0.0308204945,
0.0013460515,
0.0067552808,
0.0431386232,
0.091894269,
-0.0688621402,
-0.0090026781,
0.0676771104,
0.0033240672,
-0.0445685014,
-0.0107591618,
-0.0051001087,
0.0373619124,
0.0587187335,
0.0409807712,
-0.0544416122,
-0.0608453229,
0.0085625425,
0.0173250288,
0.027334176,
-0.0035719299,
-0.0252160504,
-0.060325399,
0.0370984711,
0.0056227231,
-0.0478427969,
-0.0233307201,
-0.0037154122,
0.0086967656,
0.0203299634,
-0.0150234867,
0.0218994971,
-0.0213082228,
-0.0066658766,
-0.0008599805,
0.051231768,
0.0072417851,
0.0184041057,
0.0041975938,
0.0429069214,
0.0507816337,
-0.0194628481,
-0.0058405451,
-0.0817782283,
0.0313910246,
-0.0226476174,
0.0181195252,
-0.0140217682,
0.0162226837,
-0.0069158426,
-0.0357820094,
0.0202645995,
0.0476715155,
-0.0133500658,
-0.0276254863,
-0.0108481105,
0.0675216913,
-0.0033126469,
-0.0120210079,
-0.0247223843,
-0.0140459174,
-0.027324615,
0.0493810326,
0.0660386831,
-0.0180725101,
-0.0370553099,
-0.0384007171,
-0.02014165,
-0.0740118027,
-0.0209020879,
0.0030325677,
0.0058580483,
-0.0148520852,
-0.046597559,
-0.0265867393,
0.0388793685,
0.0371219367,
0.0203990694,
-0.0406982861,
0.0034081531,
-0.007914409,
-0.0516926013,
0.0535868034,
-0.0646266267,
0.0080001876,
-0.1039289609,
-0.0331770554,
0.0606984533,
-0.0387284532,
-0.0062170485,
0.0344817564,
-0.0460072011,
-0.0559769496,
0.0151663758,
0.0882777646,
0.0171248242,
0.0425583087,
0.000731039,
-0.0346818119,
0.0427552909,
0.0461558215,
0.0064801062,
0.0593154468,
0.0336517654,
-0.0166299101,
0.0107568465,
0.0331261531,
-0.0230767149,
0.0230079591,
0.0191097725,
0.0170672014,
-0.0092669381,
-0.0273786746,
0.006721945,
-0.0010228048,
0.0217264742,
-0.0099482397,
0.01881277,
-0.0285874102,
0.0399688669,
0.0217330623,
0.0254008267,
-0.0524462871,
-0.0008721334,
-0.0070998413,
0.0065886155,
0.0308405217,
-0.0350175537,
-0.0144670047,
0.0088765295,
-0.0159371328,
0.0546223968,
0.0130885597,
-0.0003235813,
0.0090135774,
0.0139976554,
-0.0121445889,
-0.0099567845,
-0.0061959866,
0.06082559,
-0.0302826203,
0.0586944185,
0.0222508106,
0.000638566,
-0.0849915892,
0.0497184023,
-0.0174427759,
-0.0367064029,
-0.0263187531,
0.0735195726,
0.0432914384,
-0.0025812415,
-0.0043912348,
-0.0017998839,
-0.0082101747,
0.0086456398,
0.0315083787,
-0.00002596,
-0.0388387926,
0.0875257403,
0.0331853107,
0.0293676797,
-0.0261665825,
0.048142653,
-0.0250277966,
0.0709452704,
0.010054986,
0.0568742976,
-0.0343675353,
-0.0284118168,
0.006805521,
-0.0034836717,
0.0029470345,
0.0121498089,
0.003193707,
-0.0487323739,
-0.0024060898,
-0.0042297333,
-0.0364794806,
-0.033607766,
0.0459408052,
0.0114271566,
0.0062035611,
-0.0341426358,
-0.0061158389,
0.0152166765,
0.0200138856,
-0.003243295,
0.0192517992,
-7.09865757e-33,
-0.0508451276,
-0.0129577639,
0.0404798388,
0.0036528255,
0.0043773274,
0.0044790828,
-0.0458961539,
0.0053701913,
-0.0528678186,
0.0002054367,
-0.0223720167,
-0.0194231849,
0.0225504171,
0.0133167179,
-0.0135404505,
-0.0100448495,
0.0200915672,
-0.0232515894,
-0.0287334081,
0.0270442721,
0.0019399442,
0.0045998995,
0.0472897291,
-0.027205402,
-0.0049843322,
0.0008481315,
-0.0186189916,
0.0044995006,
-0.0459309854,
0.0548012219,
-0.0291134529,
0.0174755529,
0.003760461,
-0.019157216,
-0.0230260547,
0.0235360935,
-0.0876931995,
-0.051368393,
0.0458181202,
0.0241974313,
-0.0732908174,
-0.0681302547,
0.057821203,
0.0072901146,
-0.0071166954,
-0.0117696682,
-0.0056769946,
-0.0160823595,
-0.0291093644,
0.024330182,
-0.0666580275,
-0.0140467193,
0.0220846441,
-0.0571063869,
0.0167196337,
-0.0036147812,
-0.0051698983,
0.0320994407,
-0.0459371917,
0.0007291596,
0.0541062579,
0.0336563699,
0.0809328631,
0.0550741851,
-0.0006782943,
0.0304607544,
0.0076019652,
-0.036059875,
-0.0262971818,
0.0070787258,
0.0371750146,
0.045359619,
0.0332919359,
-0.015970761,
0.0329500213,
-0.0095905289,
-0.0504629239,
-0.0119192414,
0.0113211134,
0.0763350949,
0.0166951735,
0.0159352571,
-0.0094492473,
0.0009449963,
-0.0314076878,
-0.0046484894,
-0.0448313095,
-0.0077178283,
0.0563337207,
0.048289258,
-0.0223001633,
-0.0327642225,
0.0436523743,
-0.0166740213,
0.0302235261,
-0.0110087255,
0.0016377042,
0.0272298157,
0.0074132509,
-0.0073925438,
-0.0602369308,
-0.0331619531,
0.0376402326,
-0.0153353093,
0.035835579,
0.0222921576,
0.0499824472,
0.037819609,
-0.0671674237,
-0.0039709345,
-0.0468515307,
0.0081530763,
0.037457183,
0.0357591435,
0.0219381917,
0.0042295093,
-0.0291980151,
0.0489565581,
-0.0241379291,
-0.0146474009,
-0.0415147692,
-0.0182886738,
-0.0017373522,
0.0454550907,
-0.0662236363,
0.008241578,
-0.0462300889,
0.0287049673,
-0.03156472,
-0.0678034872,
-0.0215051584,
0.0545297116,
3.003e-7,
0.0317094959,
0.025859084,
-0.0179816689,
0.007029789,
0.0041836137,
0.0298069101,
-0.0225791745,
0.0155805117,
0.0103929406,
-0.0481319316,
-0.0230386667,
0.0579894334,
-0.0010572703,
-0.0070036487,
-0.0734712481,
0.0024187772,
-0.0070847552,
0.0212214552,
-0.0193215478,
-0.0413014404,
0.0302399211,
0.115021117,
-0.0260888021,
0.0050375634,
0.0298214741,
-0.0353352912,
0.0512183346,
-0.006179193,
0.0171573162,
-0.007469771,
0.0372801647,
0.0468099378,
-0.0502388701,
-0.010160475,
-0.0045342133,
0.0067956867,
-0.0241165105,
0.0643908456,
-0.0221702307,
-0.0402668342,
0.0133965472,
0.0163026601,
-0.0145995626,
-0.0680597275,
0.0828716308,
-0.0473806448,
-0.0067353896,
-0.0265065916,
-0.0006907976,
0.0113481712,
0.016325077,
-0.0268185977,
0.0148991924,
-0.0026100653,
0.0098866979,
-0.0223715007,
-0.0674726963,
-0.0694606975,
-0.0386002399,
-0.0346768759,
-0.0191921853,
-0.0354764424,
-0.1161374152,
-0.0412481129,
0.0309472214,
-0.0199998356,
-0.024585044,
2.575963397e-34,
0.0113396654,
-0.0527977906,
0.0445058309,
0.0588649623,
-0.0128888916,
-0.0225683209,
-0.0028975594,
0.0110335294,
0.0247769821,
-0.0896357372,
-0.0166512672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16173v1 | Towards Countering Essentialism through Social Bias Reasoning | 2023-03-28T17:34:59 | 2023-03-28T17:34:59 | Emily Allaway, Nina Taneja, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL | Essentialist beliefs (i.e., believing that members of the same group are
fundamentally alike) play a central role in social stereotypes and can lead to
harm when left unchallenged. In our work, we conduct exploratory studies into
the task of countering essentialist beliefs (e.g., ``liberals are stupid'').
Drawing on prior work from psychology and NLP, we construct five types of
counterstatements and conduct human studies on the effectiveness of these
different strategies. Our studies also investigate the role in choosing a
counterstatement of the level of explicitness with which an essentialist belief
is conveyed. We find that statements that broaden the scope of a stereotype
(e.g., to other groups, as in ``conservatives can also be stupid'') are the
most popular countering strategy. We conclude with a discussion of challenges
and open questions for future work in this area (e.g., improving factuality,
studying community-specific variation) and we emphasize the importance of work
at the intersection of NLP and psychology. | [
0.0467864163,
0.0457322523,
-0.0065794424,
-0.0010390446,
-0.0056694467,
0.0361220799,
-0.0310850609,
-0.050412938,
0.010015497,
-0.0618288442,
-0.0053047771,
-0.0059385942,
0.0081430199,
-0.043066632,
0.0341141559,
-0.0641706362,
0.0219841823,
0.0604361929,
0.0320741236,
-0.0793126151,
0.0246220585,
0.0021887945,
0.0114685958,
0.0114883203,
-0.0234600194,
0.0095046908,
0.0724639073,
-0.0204926841,
0.0448103063,
-0.0439753346,
0.0372072496,
0.0332710817,
-0.0099347588,
-0.0016569231,
0.0000020766,
-0.0521083586,
0.0294767823,
-0.0028200813,
0.0242926013,
-0.0049344371,
0.0368892513,
0.0282062776,
0.0300030559,
0.0131355003,
-0.0084813675,
-0.0204362478,
0.0383896716,
0.0896274224,
0.0199301671,
-0.0078456486,
0.0048367996,
-0.0566669516,
-0.0502730124,
-0.0160367116,
0.015669981,
0.018193977,
0.0648962185,
-0.0482773036,
-0.0603972711,
-0.019095704,
-0.0099236332,
-0.0019799552,
-0.0002570727,
0.0441352762,
0.0054722512,
-0.0091634337,
-0.0579717308,
-0.015488578,
0.0303294547,
0.0138158612,
0.0553237237,
-0.0293841753,
0.0104241287,
0.0116067529,
0.0248979442,
0.0438640788,
-0.0291360226,
0.0386172049,
-0.0384308957,
-0.0264710877,
-0.0305014309,
0.0512900501,
-0.02325668,
0.0451784655,
0.0012418793,
0.0393544436,
0.0235615484,
-0.0017937719,
0.0013399612,
0.0220673848,
-0.0496000312,
0.0097280219,
-0.0059467284,
-0.0185433496,
0.0499067158,
0.0068899477,
-0.0020590751,
0.0360524654,
0.0543390699,
-0.0463512614,
0.0275398493,
0.0148178907,
0.0110231126,
0.0123850061,
-0.0042358236,
0.0137397638,
-0.044130329,
-0.0101967845,
0.0600377098,
-0.0100669265,
-0.0731759444,
-0.0230926778,
0.0326934755,
0.0079237679,
0.0651495308,
0.0619317256,
-0.0076521775,
-0.0704288557,
-0.1079907268,
0.0171209518,
-0.0985644087,
0.0397564583,
-0.0154054966,
-0.0407711752,
-0.0593856126,
0.0329027362,
-0.0584255569,
0.0255701765,
-0.0833992064,
-0.0940867886,
0.0113674868,
0.024653662,
-0.0166001208,
-0.010415378,
0.0147841265,
-0.005187518,
0.0262634456,
0.0076699052,
0.0557042547,
-0.0007767648,
-0.064062044,
-0.0166244786,
-0.0033289127,
-0.0430195779,
0.0060711922,
0.0161920171,
0.0246170908,
-0.1006670445,
-0.006984754,
0.0020664153,
-0.0446784571,
0.0524344109,
0.0400434397,
0.0024374288,
0.0547108911,
0.0696089193,
-0.0119025577,
0.0048736213,
-0.0252247695,
-0.0143508501,
0.0050756992,
0.0041066259,
0.0189844519,
-0.0219180305,
0.0352046974,
-0.0318622664,
-0.0214513429,
0.0505827665,
-0.0336272828,
-0.0274214186,
0.0145583991,
0.0476988219,
-0.0227127708,
-0.0009966557,
0.046716217,
0.049035728,
-0.0760731399,
0.0590897352,
0.000539415,
0.0171007924,
0.0010432929,
-0.0066234646,
-0.0661584437,
-0.0197417289,
-0.0023180363,
-0.0486153737,
-0.0214881785,
0.0600977093,
-0.0253081005,
0.0075363321,
-0.0357792862,
0.0396539681,
0.0605638251,
-0.0193981919,
-0.014202836,
0.0143638272,
0.0424407497,
0.0269558709,
0.0255273171,
0.0154608926,
-0.0179534387,
-0.038652055,
-0.0172253083,
0.0051721768,
-0.0125791598,
0.0087551111,
-0.0037183694,
-0.0288784746,
0.0009652777,
0.0455081016,
0.0703645572,
-0.0265871342,
-0.0387081802,
0.0020654683,
0.017679438,
0.0191962197,
0.0460884571,
0.0572724119,
0.0657247826,
0.0411610678,
0.0213456303,
0.0284901075,
-0.0063610394,
0.0050300155,
0.0483038463,
-0.02584452,
-0.0582219437,
0.017747188,
0.0268020239,
0.0062157582,
-0.0026707472,
-0.0268997531,
-0.0123396274,
0.0270961616,
-0.034243796,
0.053085953,
-0.0381886624,
0.0421737432,
-0.0160980616,
-0.1136722267,
-0.0778790861,
0.0170792658,
0.018559631,
0.0160004776,
0.0384207107,
-0.0113326944,
0.0099150781,
-0.0054332679,
-0.0252814591,
-0.0775078982,
-0.0038107794,
-0.0304953195,
0.0469990298,
0.0190018155,
-0.0011333134,
0.0388212427,
-0.0760032013,
0.0578471981,
-0.0280752741,
-0.0254246145,
-0.0334848762,
0.0237355605,
-0.0082035754,
0.0107996315,
-0.0365230069,
-0.0309989527,
0.037238501,
-0.0542669408,
-0.0560842454,
0.0098419702,
-0.0012123778,
0.0146659045,
-0.0164209455,
-0.0091658477,
-0.0042951638,
0.0164839774,
-0.0276638772,
-0.0017044259,
0.0312379245,
0.0173929054,
-0.0208917558,
-0.0078989472,
0.0257777069,
0.0104856947,
-0.0311816614,
0.0078679109,
0.0125974622,
-0.0333027504,
0.0227233376,
-0.0500888973,
-0.0642152727,
0.0101207094,
-0.0100149317,
-0.0049825348,
0.0324736424,
0.0715779066,
0.0045501096,
0.0559171401,
0.0415693782,
0.0005690579,
0.0486238673,
0.0432549268,
-0.0358822085,
-0.0567503832,
-0.0328097939,
0.021782333,
0.0187287033,
-0.0698157996,
-0.0337982923,
0.0651693195,
0.0466931537,
-0.025842201,
-0.071385555,
0.0823157877,
-0.0487676263,
-0.042550806,
-0.0020549924,
-0.0813678876,
-0.030529473,
-0.0055701905,
-0.0222361293,
-0.016157981,
0.0503230765,
0.0171815567,
0.0094657885,
-0.0077125444,
0.0236641131,
-0.0027467916,
0.0489402749,
-0.0011836699,
0.0070871017,
0.035075251,
0.0058317268,
-0.0395420901,
-0.0465011634,
0.036389675,
0.0142747788,
0.021343872,
-0.0338631459,
0.0024864704,
-0.0121563673,
-0.0178309288,
-0.0770158693,
-0.0142213656,
-0.0704586804,
-0.0447368212,
-0.0135371424,
0.0034021772,
-0.0121709984,
-0.0346718952,
0.0317365043,
-0.033588618,
0.0169280954,
-0.0195840634,
0.0528688803,
-0.0813278779,
0.003836839,
0.0199725218,
0.0597258992,
-0.0133046806,
-0.006483003,
0.0640580431,
-0.0467576124,
0.0231708791,
-0.0225532297,
-0.0048335651,
-0.0229491964,
0.0421387851,
0.0036564129,
-0.0141619463,
0.0286743827,
0.0174988713,
0.0085626924,
0.0519779734,
0.0113358181,
0.0236019157,
0.0137427049,
-0.0029386838,
-0.0028152352,
0.0456619971,
-0.0384057984,
-0.048872713,
-0.0015023681,
0.0090464707,
0.0219606515,
-0.0500310548,
-0.0404287614,
-0.0164458789,
-0.0477100052,
0.0245400667,
0.0212435145,
-0.0176585484,
-0.0208681785,
0.0114001771,
0.0484757274,
0.0075724851,
-0.0203252397,
-0.0100532956,
0.0048882253,
0.0587407425,
-0.0030851124,
-0.0625685081,
-0.0274450276,
0.0338376239,
0.0255340803,
0.0190634597,
-0.0297017638,
0.0152708013,
0.0179223903,
0.0265738238,
0.0764945522,
-0.0456598699,
-0.0203286409,
-0.0275270175,
-0.0004317032,
-0.0161908437,
0.0096989116,
-0.0414470397,
0.0293629188,
0.0342538841,
-0.017598059,
0.0137774441,
0.0495240912,
0.0110637657,
-0.0992743149,
-0.017755568,
0.0193563607,
-0.0129597466,
0.0956579447,
0.0376872681,
0.0509636141,
0.0589889847,
-0.0254431814,
-0.0149403503,
-0.0291377809,
-0.0902630538,
0.0183690246,
0.0216000751,
-0.0027667335,
-0.013422912,
-0.0740941763,
0.0151882293,
-0.0261447802,
0.0006517976,
-0.0588295907,
-0.0067651328,
-0.0133275464,
-0.0554344915,
0.0253060926,
-0.0094904425,
-0.043612808,
0.0552925952,
-0.0116920751,
0.0007484912,
0.0015727158,
-0.0563333333,
0.0083699711,
0.0257742554,
-0.0504061654,
0.0751628056,
0.0084360205,
0.0232537147,
0.0292173438,
0.0298741721,
-0.0569886826,
0.0361957885,
0.0425565168,
0.0165065229,
0.0292384475,
0.0093767606,
-0.010145003,
0.0101368017,
0.019564731,
0.0193732511,
0.0730407014,
0.0523141883,
-0.0433063954,
-0.0223378129,
-0.0287872553,
0.0242074821,
-0.00795573,
0.0010060035,
-0.0038898715,
0.0044499179,
-0.0048973318,
-0.028798921,
0.0091632474,
-0.0706653595,
0.0406405255,
-0.0574651361,
0.0172879845,
0.0303205699,
-0.0580221154,
-0.009334485,
-0.050530605,
0.074507542,
-0.0044987244,
0.0370417535,
0.0538306944,
0.0310377255,
0.0161870997,
-0.0033824856,
0.0006016445,
0.0198197234,
-0.0325223245,
0.0519037768,
0.0116922548,
0.0091755427,
0.0526277162,
0.012240788,
-0.0124752494,
-0.0286990013,
-0.0333277546,
-0.0806175545,
0.0054286816,
-0.0076884371,
-0.044628147,
-0.0079979189,
0.0104280524,
-0.0117699485,
-0.0225664452,
0.0052903378,
0.0016228551,
-0.0025545629,
-0.0233916882,
0.0511444435,
0.0118535981,
-0.0251992159,
-0.0002473381,
0.0070611071,
-0.0432615727,
0.0217529312,
-0.010568182,
-0.0436500385,
-0.0139249656,
-0.0215447843,
0.0094411112,
0.011828891,
-0.0047331345,
-0.0036388601,
-0.0909042582,
-0.0273306742,
0.0205166433,
-0.0071944515,
0.0407528952,
0.0294091739,
-0.0155437374,
0.0459614098,
0.0223745145,
-0.022538064,
0.0617403947,
0.0754193664,
-0.0100438641,
0.0382256657,
-0.0449190773,
-6.259419256e-33,
-0.0193207525,
-0.0490193777,
-0.0302858669,
-0.0376970731,
0.0223762412,
0.0216305386,
-0.0148630748,
0.0011680612,
-0.0465110466,
0.0437705666,
0.0113419779,
0.0391733795,
-0.0030321181,
-0.0207394678,
0.02527548,
-0.0084549822,
0.040186625,
0.0075901495,
-0.0401915349,
-0.0367734283,
0.0258986894,
-0.0344942138,
0.0463008583,
-0.0657776371,
0.0487071052,
-0.0160388667,
-0.0039764089,
-0.0353896469,
0.0180870853,
-0.0278512593,
-0.0128546972,
0.0407760888,
0.047955472,
-0.0082187355,
-0.004830969,
0.0880442187,
-0.0367710739,
-0.0556914881,
0.0283228643,
-0.0389014743,
0.0293602888,
0.0241095312,
-0.0152059561,
-0.0044343523,
-0.0734112486,
0.026729038,
0.0507862605,
-0.0169082917,
0.0840676501,
0.0197014194,
-0.0733136013,
-0.0006322094,
-0.0128239505,
0.0725261122,
-0.0522947386,
-0.0059661781,
0.0124287708,
0.0188243743,
-0.0545569248,
0.0806738734,
-0.0487033688,
-0.0531302728,
-0.0070144134,
-0.0251648463,
0.0302128904,
0.0382127129,
0.0265170913,
0.0864323527,
-0.0381845757,
-0.034272261,
0.0221114028,
-0.0174627062,
0.0484453142,
0.095700413,
0.0405515544,
-0.0364077203,
0.0153704071,
-0.0213367175,
0.0668666139,
0.0020528189,
0.0198123232,
-0.0005782773,
-0.0971344709,
-0.0271101985,
-0.0193375368,
-0.0591738224,
-0.0101281842,
-0.0121090114,
0.0474124067,
0.0134335067,
-0.0600958876,
0.0326970816,
-0.009312558,
-0.0055112392,
-0.0079206666,
0.000654378,
-0.018567007,
-0.0455821976,
0.0289680008,
-0.0182272494,
-0.0259622484,
0.0021750715,
0.0142960902,
0.0331137106,
0.0435192026,
-0.0147216637,
0.0432026647,
-0.0206582043,
-0.0416893885,
0.0137938,
0.0384274758,
-0.0136348121,
-0.0118352855,
-0.0492074676,
0.0199465174,
0.0659009665,
0.0182170905,
-0.0649227425,
0.0450195856,
-0.0344940871,
-0.045813676,
0.0108046588,
0.0015012572,
0.0192538965,
-0.0032835763,
-0.0139897363,
-0.0124355536,
-0.0317767747,
0.0200397447,
-0.0152362231,
-0.0203762148,
-0.0668518692,
2.699e-7,
0.0146664167,
0.0444053747,
-0.0100143142,
0.0145975146,
0.011879731,
0.0178499557,
0.029801622,
0.004924444,
0.0118067171,
-0.0178428721,
-0.0212768316,
0.0523784533,
-0.0101177571,
-0.0071173981,
0.0187695846,
0.0077161258,
-0.0197380744,
-0.0017387823,
-0.0070579615,
0.0312865004,
0.0237102248,
-0.008832234,
0.0175499227,
0.0116588604,
-0.0344084799,
-0.0355843976,
0.0231051389,
-0.0107267043,
0.0638560131,
0.0084806569,
0.0079867942,
-0.0122287851,
0.0127174836,
0.0427792855,
0.040969152,
0.0020068998,
-0.0243146308,
-0.0075629591,
-0.0307001732,
0.0026105396,
-0.0466373712,
0.0053404165,
-0.0199247077,
-0.0748639777,
0.0310827699,
-0.0368887894,
-0.0171164516,
-0.0391450524,
-0.0609882511,
0.0001737338,
-0.0000573283,
0.0517299734,
-0.0497050136,
-0.0392739326,
0.0341758244,
0.0104951235,
-0.0049179713,
-0.0548355468,
0.0068152398,
-0.0119387265,
-0.0457154699,
-0.0503088869,
-0.0104835415,
0.0124875568,
0.0061166203,
0.028339522,
-0.0068627442,
2.226887722e-34,
0.0056928769,
0.0320840441,
0.0198788736,
-0.0727158785,
0.0457480587,
-0.0013008101,
-0.0331736133,
0.0133338533,
0.0538192056,
0.0052698036,
-0.0374723375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16166v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16166v4 | When Good and Reproducible Results are a Giant with Feet of Clay: The Importance of Software Quality in NLP | 2023-03-28T17:28:52 | 2023-08-15T21:53:56 | Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Andrea Pilzer, Matteo Negri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite its crucial role in research experiments, code correctness is often
presumed only on the basis of the perceived quality of results. This assumption
comes with the risk of erroneous outcomes and potentially misleading findings.
To address this issue, we posit that the current focus on reproducibility
should go hand in hand with the emphasis on software quality. We present a case
study in which we identify and fix three bugs in widely used implementations of
the state-of-the-art Conformer architecture. Through experiments on speech
recognition and translation in various languages, we demonstrate that the
presence of bugs does not prevent the achievement of good and reproducible
results, which however can lead to incorrect conclusions that potentially
misguide future research. As a countermeasure, we propose a Code-quality
Checklist and release pangoliNN, a library dedicated to testing neural models,
with the goal of promoting coding best practices and improving research
software quality within the NLP community. | [
0.0523821861,
0.113265276,
-0.0442438908,
0.0393329598,
-0.0334669091,
-0.0123882545,
0.0213436335,
-0.0057197991,
0.0018623314,
-0.0233309623,
0.0114573063,
0.0113490559,
0.0704060867,
0.0175813492,
0.0308572147,
-0.0208643172,
0.0841281638,
-0.0236576255,
-0.0131431343,
0.0148829212,
-0.028156938,
0.0008783312,
-0.0208349656,
0.0699577853,
-0.0048776022,
-0.0254118871,
0.0072497674,
-0.005741511,
-0.0107199522,
-0.0097176069,
0.0057720025,
0.0496260375,
-0.0324098244,
0.0835035443,
0.000002066,
-0.0195236877,
-0.0068277461,
0.0529472791,
-0.0146021079,
0.0306722708,
0.0119103948,
-0.0231077019,
-0.0341043957,
0.0149781806,
-0.0232123546,
-0.0207019188,
0.0714054182,
0.0386662036,
0.0471247546,
0.0618168786,
0.0043724887,
-0.0115458928,
0.0774094835,
0.0004334864,
0.0113465879,
-0.0333416872,
-0.0018656265,
0.0107300654,
0.0127718411,
-0.0007974735,
-0.004927346,
0.0268823598,
0.0317978933,
-0.0040353108,
-0.0035896357,
0.0224942435,
-0.0681460872,
-0.0694262087,
-0.0115733705,
0.0441260673,
-0.0108533008,
-0.0302340221,
0.0026454371,
-0.0034042043,
-0.0156339556,
-0.0168055184,
-0.0072214631,
0.0243676323,
0.0153984427,
-0.0034577162,
-0.0060089021,
-0.0476319268,
0.0330954082,
-0.010913644,
0.0014195575,
0.0257394612,
0.0123367589,
-0.0230416749,
0.0084717581,
0.0216199588,
-0.0099237207,
-0.0515433773,
0.0160154533,
-0.0056259045,
-0.0138600748,
-0.0000242526,
-0.0349126421,
-0.0349833257,
0.0599529222,
-0.052747909,
0.0179298408,
0.0406315178,
-0.0119214393,
-0.0046752449,
-0.05840417,
0.1051136702,
-0.0225308128,
0.056169644,
0.0014906641,
0.0137437684,
-0.0463629551,
-0.0054025361,
-0.0178617965,
0.014511683,
-0.0115066264,
-0.014949373,
-0.0095674889,
0.0160443485,
-0.0141934082,
0.0673450977,
-0.0253097899,
0.0089286389,
-0.0261030458,
0.0494742431,
-0.0006031907,
0.0185345132,
-0.0115148015,
-0.0041372241,
0.0173406824,
-0.0741294324,
-0.0256008804,
-0.0088876178,
-0.0534409024,
-0.0304457787,
0.0163025018,
0.0547071472,
0.035335131,
-0.0102552101,
-0.0025315532,
-0.0206600837,
-0.0330067426,
-0.0325960144,
0.020110745,
-0.0920131058,
0.0334789194,
0.0150246955,
0.0122327525,
-0.0868686959,
-0.0016915456,
0.0064379773,
-0.0247399658,
0.071590662,
-0.0628737807,
-0.0056838854,
-0.0107854372,
0.0210700929,
0.0091854371,
0.0530403219,
0.0466022305,
-0.025980683,
0.0619303435,
-0.0509471595,
0.0120618185,
-0.0110537186,
-0.0101079438,
-0.018863555,
0.0022472253,
0.0008136107,
0.0385690071,
0.0349387452,
-0.0016194558,
0.0706164166,
-0.0115897506,
-0.0426427238,
0.0553537495,
0.0495814793,
0.0151910111,
0.0258095674,
-0.0318754576,
-0.0401006043,
0.0039953417,
0.0032640062,
-0.0746298879,
0.027741991,
-0.0203005411,
0.012569827,
-0.0310741328,
0.0677294731,
-0.0148778865,
-0.0723430142,
-0.0412806273,
-0.0159202795,
0.0057381303,
-0.0076778117,
0.0160945728,
0.0197310708,
-0.0004168344,
0.0197056271,
0.0176504739,
-0.0608318709,
-0.0086151138,
-0.0619748421,
0.0434646681,
0.0336021557,
0.0623991527,
-0.0089816349,
-0.0368226245,
-0.0218119919,
-0.0261447113,
0.0525754616,
0.0657218769,
0.0070408788,
0.0203787833,
-0.0428063758,
-0.0089078732,
-0.0014960548,
0.0132161779,
0.0025500953,
0.0215556528,
0.0121710105,
0.0044117062,
0.0101565039,
-0.0691269562,
0.0520932823,
-0.0340135247,
-0.0037195191,
-0.0013614658,
-0.0216013771,
0.0249494035,
0.0108741522,
-0.0393033773,
0.0123455944,
0.0494938754,
0.0169736836,
-0.0158688389,
0.0062782234,
-0.0108401217,
-0.0303978473,
0.0212944075,
-0.0813507885,
-0.0276811998,
0.0717635155,
-0.028917281,
-0.0295668691,
0.0351894945,
-0.0370700918,
0.0423499458,
-0.0105844066,
0.0136419078,
-0.04448184,
0.0159525126,
-0.0256974343,
-0.0132329538,
0.0170017313,
0.0238486193,
-0.0143896025,
-0.0178633835,
-0.0003484574,
-0.0101939877,
-0.0926608518,
0.0568857007,
-0.0268930383,
0.0354440995,
0.0148367928,
0.0330379941,
-0.0209947452,
-0.0268640108,
-0.052576486,
0.0280750729,
0.0023087983,
0.0120896799,
0.0168686155,
0.0232292861,
0.0134139266,
-0.0112991789,
-0.0008039576,
-0.0226799045,
-0.0077861585,
0.0159584302,
0.0584030114,
-0.0069049057,
-0.0388890021,
-0.0616288148,
-0.0364274047,
-0.033996921,
0.0647156015,
-0.0128630437,
-0.0199343432,
-0.0838741511,
0.0291923452,
-0.0266172998,
0.0476575829,
0.002293352,
-0.0333222523,
0.0402700529,
0.0338815041,
0.0050221607,
0.0774985552,
-0.0246500801,
-0.0046802135,
0.0405121371,
0.0459917784,
-0.0684878901,
0.011905049,
0.0075627151,
-0.0171309244,
0.0029366761,
-0.043242842,
0.0140818451,
0.0384748466,
-0.0029081644,
-0.0193468686,
-0.0548722595,
0.03335125,
-0.0191401243,
-0.0262767002,
0.0413933732,
-0.024864627,
-0.0150624858,
0.0136216329,
-0.0313897617,
-0.0713776052,
0.0653284639,
-0.0521429926,
-0.0155718811,
-0.0642301515,
0.0172565077,
-0.0492454283,
0.0568500683,
0.0119090816,
0.011171218,
0.0385593139,
-0.0308561381,
-0.0192773286,
0.010453769,
-0.011371783,
-0.0230261255,
0.0762116313,
-0.0393552482,
0.005010298,
-0.0223986637,
-0.0503969342,
-0.0280010775,
0.0048345155,
-0.0305353273,
0.0154541284,
0.0359911472,
-0.0096860221,
-0.0335226618,
-0.0092458921,
0.0413552374,
0.0282876883,
-0.0081566982,
-0.0238991007,
-0.0194538739,
-0.0309556182,
0.002361848,
0.0081616538,
0.085112378,
-0.016710978,
-0.0202734899,
0.0574261956,
0.0099251503,
0.0644995719,
-0.0879503042,
-0.0194767807,
0.0314951539,
-0.0317884609,
-0.0246004388,
0.0191091616,
0.0688138381,
-0.0505863726,
-0.0117230499,
0.0726926476,
0.0323136076,
-0.0266846754,
0.0037976564,
-0.0020120712,
0.0257961284,
0.0411374606,
0.028854575,
-0.0622397885,
-0.0296585243,
0.0238203928,
0.0447263867,
0.0069441823,
-0.0192172397,
0.0107296258,
-0.0906490311,
0.031171944,
0.0253494047,
-0.0374297425,
-0.0467024744,
-0.0599396713,
-0.0068786927,
-0.0521585904,
0.0658216029,
0.0214269664,
0.0047829864,
0.0022352124,
0.0037589143,
-0.0432815589,
-0.0441252701,
0.0189235117,
-0.0686469749,
0.091954276,
0.1234633252,
0.0103429258,
-0.0088099847,
-0.060115058,
0.0183847193,
-0.0006801067,
0.0203693844,
-0.0075486777,
0.0601362698,
0.0389392711,
-0.0149985719,
-0.0026750588,
-0.0356844366,
-0.0728806704,
-0.0138030173,
-0.0038007321,
0.0598473772,
0.0046118656,
-0.0500784889,
-0.038745828,
0.0239359587,
-0.0242599286,
0.0586464144,
0.0450220704,
-0.0227401406,
-0.0464970842,
-0.02280825,
0.0024159341,
-0.0540907942,
-0.0302939918,
-0.0023481103,
0.0114110429,
0.0063050347,
-0.065524675,
-0.0541139916,
0.0134561714,
0.0120237553,
0.0295352824,
-0.0577842668,
0.0304424595,
-0.0288128741,
-0.015988443,
0.0381143391,
0.0144941201,
0.0290778968,
-0.0645885319,
0.0120025063,
0.012255338,
0.0115791308,
0.0072006136,
0.0380596742,
-0.0560899414,
-0.0690109134,
0.0033401777,
0.0795947909,
0.0300207678,
0.0212601945,
-0.0423036031,
-0.0389704891,
-0.0621253178,
0.0468830876,
-0.0021861331,
0.0036552972,
0.036045935,
-0.0703798532,
-0.0000423345,
-0.0105403773,
-0.0075773811,
-0.0078754034,
0.0157898907,
0.0310192499,
0.0334581994,
-0.0173475519,
0.0214919858,
0.035195224,
0.0537756644,
0.0068481592,
0.010190702,
-0.0023139582,
0.0037959889,
-0.0068530729,
-0.0096276579,
-0.0239159893,
-0.0045505459,
-0.0012596326,
0.0275863558,
-0.002906302,
0.0595682859,
-0.0286610331,
0.052641049,
-0.0288987197,
0.0494998507,
0.0352756493,
0.0413532443,
0.0048583518,
0.0185446814,
-0.0362746082,
0.0429882631,
-0.0030876077,
0.0777376816,
-0.0374228433,
0.0243397709,
0.0008000392,
0.0199755784,
0.0215971526,
0.0189273451,
-0.0912054181,
-0.05338943,
-0.0140350824,
-0.0159785245,
0.0073040822,
0.0351494662,
0.0427959375,
-0.0031253777,
-0.0021552774,
-0.0328398161,
0.0280240737,
-0.000471858,
0.0065993164,
0.0019476841,
0.0259073935,
-0.0178916436,
-0.0603392683,
0.0526535474,
-0.0663972273,
0.0225576013,
-0.0076296716,
-0.008198631,
-0.0047802636,
-0.0354110263,
0.012220405,
-0.0366694033,
-0.0485476144,
-0.0884863213,
-0.0438466854,
-0.0738900229,
0.0453150831,
0.0476935133,
0.0655310079,
0.0158571005,
-0.0093907053,
0.0460088439,
0.0321671106,
-0.0386394449,
0.0002405158,
-0.0516069159,
-0.0156296771,
-0.0283204727,
-0.0507926717,
-5.927481692e-33,
-0.0233142767,
-0.0115080476,
0.0018499461,
-0.0269309524,
0.0055756723,
0.004974138,
-0.0580979325,
0.0053954171,
-0.0530062169,
-0.0194728971,
-0.0179934502,
0.0306627974,
0.011739892,
-0.0101765189,
0.051038716,
0.003541104,
0.0628893524,
0.0162050836,
-0.0443685353,
0.0000096013,
-0.0034792076,
0.0022606128,
0.0653225929,
-0.0394103564,
0.0268924832,
0.0578622557,
0.0180627443,
-0.0091352994,
-0.0287010297,
0.0883397758,
0.0179832149,
0.0195908546,
0.0121787982,
-0.0170763452,
-0.0447101593,
-0.0505966283,
-0.0557910539,
-0.0167833865,
0.0011897786,
0.03741486,
0.0182435475,
0.0020404926,
0.0849250704,
-0.0388825573,
-0.0373662934,
0.0050367429,
0.0382344611,
-0.020735031,
-0.0376484096,
-0.0058563943,
-0.0656741709,
-0.0045076837,
-0.0225701649,
0.0132054081,
-0.0110632507,
0.0431147851,
-0.0148050496,
-0.0121975318,
-0.0782069862,
0.0024243589,
0.0130330734,
0.0143281845,
0.0616098084,
-0.0130892908,
-0.0157478787,
0.0416091084,
0.0628691837,
0.0205526985,
-0.0235110316,
-0.0071232487,
0.0740390569,
0.0401927382,
0.1063725054,
0.0366787314,
0.0399495102,
-0.0536977723,
-0.0214256328,
0.0141114946,
-0.0192201771,
0.004314132,
0.0237212125,
0.0203404278,
-0.0877010226,
-0.0152549222,
-0.0278121289,
-0.0374661647,
-0.0289354995,
-0.0274721738,
0.0244686287,
-0.0026549092,
0.0029384594,
0.0075210016,
0.0203368757,
-0.0607352518,
0.0231664926,
-0.0183437802,
-0.027285831,
0.0281506572,
-0.0082732402,
0.0129629839,
-0.0502039939,
-0.0183249693,
-0.003476484,
0.048042994,
0.0688007101,
-0.0044745123,
0.0594823882,
0.0236835442,
-0.0531142391,
0.0141011067,
-0.0312812738,
0.0428398289,
0.0432557091,
0.0087504396,
0.0006896027,
-0.002356088,
0.0020469332,
0.0206030775,
0.0098699043,
0.0176736452,
-0.0782856271,
0.0593824163,
0.0051110717,
-0.0006120013,
-0.0143796112,
-0.0358265266,
-0.0282268655,
0.0923598483,
0.0294293277,
-0.0608798079,
-0.040570803,
0.0145705994,
2.757e-7,
0.0306156501,
0.0475239381,
0.0275032632,
0.0166257843,
0.0125291813,
0.0139444219,
-0.0383904614,
0.0395184159,
0.004725263,
0.0264346674,
-0.0249161385,
-0.0059401128,
0.0569271185,
0.0529892258,
-0.0448125005,
-0.0359947309,
-0.0455997512,
-0.0023643996,
-0.0576527007,
-0.0137995426,
0.001861263,
0.0734254196,
0.002281928,
0.0109445928,
-0.0095490888,
-0.0148148136,
0.0266776886,
-0.0254431665,
0.0515657254,
0.019983666,
0.0066404087,
0.0325859264,
0.0000198916,
-0.0017487663,
-0.025650138,
-0.0189922359,
-0.0095434254,
0.0448844247,
-0.0102116112,
-0.0295549668,
-0.0059103495,
-0.0151682645,
0.0136569468,
-0.0596833415,
0.0357383862,
-0.0309611242,
-0.0176922586,
-0.0477650538,
-0.026201861,
-0.0143213756,
0.0499683246,
-0.0289464034,
0.0221659541,
0.0056563714,
0.0014477529,
-0.0026515191,
-0.0321556665,
-0.0335944071,
-0.0278992765,
0.0219966304,
-0.027837703,
-0.0463727191,
-0.0129919862,
-0.0284845792,
-0.0019009036,
-0.0463176221,
-0.0060522305,
2.8948105e-34,
0.0271365698,
-0.0176598355,
0.0414782092,
-0.0070901327,
0.0365901552,
-0.0107843895,
0.0358308293,
-0.0176512599,
-0.0160511639,
-0.008403088,
-0.054333549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16755v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16755v3 | Training Language Models with Language Feedback at Scale | 2023-03-28T17:04:15 | 2024-02-22T22:29:10 | Jérémy Scheurer, Jon Ander Campos, Tomasz Korbak, Jun Shern Chan, Angelica Chen, Kyunghyun Cho, Ethan Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Pretrained language models often generate outputs that are not in line with
human preferences, such as harmful text or factually incorrect summaries.
Recent work approaches the above issues by learning from a simple form of human
feedback: comparisons between pairs of model-generated outputs. However,
comparison feedback only conveys limited information about human preferences.
In this paper, we introduce Imitation learning from Language Feedback (ILF), a
new approach that utilizes more informative language feedback. ILF consists of
three steps that are applied iteratively: first, conditioning the language
model on the input, an initial LM output, and feedback to generate refinements.
Second, selecting the refinement incorporating the most feedback. Third,
finetuning the language model to maximize the likelihood of the chosen
refinement given the input. We show theoretically that ILF can be viewed as
Bayesian Inference, similar to Reinforcement Learning from human feedback. We
evaluate ILF's effectiveness on a carefully-controlled toy task and a realistic
summarization task. Our experiments demonstrate that large language models
accurately incorporate feedback and that finetuning with ILF scales well with
the dataset size, even outperforming finetuning on human summaries. Learning
from both language and comparison feedback outperforms learning from each
alone, achieving human-level summarization performance. | [
0.0662877411,
0.0418109037,
0.0189068187,
0.0237962492,
0.0076247067,
0.0159666333,
-0.0430229567,
-0.0073679322,
-0.007431956,
-0.0608610548,
-0.0431806706,
-0.0198397506,
0.0049541015,
0.0018963742,
0.0180512276,
-0.0820223838,
0.0132966321,
-0.0462733544,
-0.0002636475,
-0.0220907815,
0.0343303308,
0.0239248239,
0.010950719,
0.0568944812,
0.0124542918,
0.0656388626,
0.0017670081,
0.0110619543,
0.0203273855,
-0.0007882974,
0.0268179439,
0.0337511078,
0.0374510959,
0.0032527836,
0.0000018864,
-0.0341976732,
-0.0061453707,
-0.0460607298,
0.0060020187,
-0.0215436202,
0.091421105,
-0.013339052,
0.0231766589,
0.0194557495,
-0.0206837747,
-0.0119950222,
0.0268617757,
0.0383071899,
0.071445778,
0.07711301,
0.0210711677,
-0.0055814809,
-0.03347468,
-0.0345328152,
-0.0002665997,
-0.0096802348,
0.0004447271,
0.0280252546,
0.0215142407,
-0.0037421219,
-0.0032302639,
0.0044503538,
0.0219203141,
-0.0153821167,
0.0140034603,
0.0447083078,
-0.0003015114,
-0.009476969,
-0.0058182292,
0.0611886531,
-0.0281407274,
-0.0530193709,
-0.0055914647,
-0.0219093505,
0.0171500668,
0.0029875915,
-0.032369785,
0.040091686,
-0.0007198683,
0.0526590683,
-0.0002626868,
-0.0007763705,
0.0218281467,
0.0536696948,
-0.0242485162,
0.031278614,
-0.015882235,
-0.0286648609,
-0.0165022165,
0.0299576987,
-0.0405727476,
-0.0447006822,
0.0004277655,
0.0290004462,
-0.0516963452,
0.0076399585,
-0.0988555625,
-0.0348152854,
0.0167262871,
-0.0318180844,
0.046249155,
-0.005392232,
-0.0069565787,
0.0518757775,
-0.0042686067,
0.0361075662,
0.0278008264,
0.0642553866,
-0.078587696,
0.0044885557,
-0.0091451956,
0.0027899842,
-0.0249478444,
0.0369282328,
0.0084942114,
0.0040896125,
-0.0311688986,
0.0059451428,
-0.000980139,
0.0235570874,
-0.0095816283,
0.0228591748,
-0.0401161164,
-0.0283433534,
-0.0396433361,
0.0060252002,
-0.0463506207,
0.0291844606,
0.0214570891,
-0.0089847594,
-0.0204232819,
0.01842946,
0.0053689433,
-0.0017095375,
0.0378637463,
0.0460458547,
-0.0184182897,
-0.0431097634,
-0.0073161838,
-0.0206300952,
-0.0002968705,
-0.0366288982,
-0.0096198805,
-0.0646407381,
0.0057117366,
-0.0341037996,
-0.0144836474,
-0.0409183986,
0.0091037741,
0.007156834,
-0.0322793648,
0.0566531196,
-0.0233227201,
-0.0074622631,
0.024505388,
-0.0061135083,
0.0244941898,
0.0584154204,
0.0611342117,
0.0539408326,
0.0205386728,
0.0317154601,
0.0263485275,
0.0271009617,
0.033063706,
0.0305750221,
-0.0116503481,
-0.0281459354,
-0.0414297767,
0.0408379287,
0.0613615438,
0.0728666857,
-0.0507481545,
0.0112879043,
0.0851789191,
0.0197743624,
-0.0042217444,
0.0007243081,
0.0418778472,
0.0460428372,
-0.0045398707,
0.0496553183,
-0.0515488908,
0.0184661075,
-0.0363501832,
0.0519314073,
0.0717379972,
-0.0103174644,
-0.0117489826,
-0.0729943812,
0.0147616155,
-0.0231719539,
0.0426783189,
0.0051804609,
0.059516903,
0.0706900358,
-0.0382383913,
0.0123150237,
0.0574668646,
-0.0377155617,
0.0352570899,
-0.0606032908,
0.0503279865,
0.0752726868,
0.0567567945,
-0.0272468589,
0.0099939285,
-0.0176107101,
-0.0162922069,
0.0501133986,
0.0542224422,
-0.029578818,
-0.0178022031,
-0.0361360759,
-0.0214756038,
0.0010152827,
0.0220355242,
0.0211120397,
0.0175019465,
-0.0328289904,
0.0179523695,
-0.0238339063,
-0.0746357068,
0.056507539,
0.003045175,
-0.0209498089,
0.01689074,
-0.0156968031,
0.019990908,
-0.0028513072,
-0.0190437678,
0.0129009709,
0.0125514641,
-0.0064438628,
-0.029077746,
0.0244302321,
-0.0460802503,
-0.041071184,
0.0431202985,
-0.0213878471,
0.0089513101,
0.0484949537,
-0.0342517681,
-0.0341286398,
0.0010667518,
-0.028512774,
0.0367792919,
-0.0422998667,
0.0221874025,
-0.024693083,
-0.0451347642,
-0.0418982431,
0.0271598902,
-0.0153138321,
0.0140211852,
0.0027536142,
-0.0069976156,
-0.0243207105,
-0.0082920147,
-0.0433178023,
-0.0131203691,
0.0158328842,
0.0315960944,
0.0533657074,
0.0524738617,
-0.0319806337,
-0.0167425629,
-0.0928339362,
-0.0300541334,
-0.0289188046,
-0.0184636638,
0.0459325798,
0.015800925,
0.0023395861,
-0.0390747562,
-0.0231911056,
-0.0391087234,
0.0248422604,
0.0025885305,
0.0377724767,
0.0130984411,
0.0325102322,
-0.0759326741,
-0.0049776556,
0.0119418446,
0.017919831,
0.0064893267,
0.019636143,
-0.0699902028,
0.007808764,
-0.040356487,
0.0428207852,
-0.0211199448,
-0.0270298813,
0.0103404252,
-0.0365425758,
0.0103252297,
0.0797512382,
0.0504647568,
0.0140405921,
0.0815887973,
0.0461544767,
-0.0647520274,
-0.004207463,
-0.0335990973,
-0.0244640019,
-0.0266254954,
-0.0201644748,
0.0230206735,
0.0589563549,
0.0086666942,
0.0161030684,
-0.0596602596,
0.0408018902,
-0.0326799639,
-0.030422518,
-0.0347178541,
-0.0384021699,
-0.0521635152,
0.0308549758,
-0.0292974543,
-0.0481748581,
0.1187899932,
-0.0220306851,
0.0184321664,
-0.0687743053,
0.0017864499,
-0.0032739562,
0.0348420739,
0.0323281549,
0.0197552145,
-0.0034416749,
0.0099960892,
-0.062089894,
-0.0269840732,
0.0616137795,
-0.0435002781,
0.0631572083,
-0.0674377009,
0.0049155992,
0.003891624,
-0.0481584929,
-0.0569206513,
-0.0514293015,
-0.0385027602,
-0.007748446,
-0.0007562822,
-0.025469996,
-0.0097430982,
-0.0078255394,
0.0274556186,
0.0664310679,
-0.0244029649,
-0.0099824453,
-0.0033167952,
0.0013311496,
0.1026443318,
0.0168236233,
-0.0063172327,
-0.0474561751,
-0.0100999214,
0.0225427542,
0.0381116197,
-0.002162673,
-0.016375538,
0.0020564566,
0.0114049688,
-0.0224162769,
0.0266179945,
0.0340853855,
0.0559118278,
-0.0351965651,
-0.0282687526,
0.1105674282,
0.0184180383,
-0.0487854071,
-0.0068266988,
0.0092169549,
0.0528562889,
0.0041736234,
0.0316255577,
-0.0733973309,
-0.0387961231,
-0.001285259,
0.0614849366,
0.0050318176,
-0.0091350246,
-0.0030490498,
-0.1192344278,
-0.0247249212,
0.0226823334,
-0.051262863,
-0.0462087914,
-0.0299166348,
0.0054323035,
-0.0301980358,
0.0123867309,
0.0265150033,
-0.0103886202,
-0.0005739818,
0.0248591509,
-0.0173777677,
-0.0283918474,
-0.0131997243,
-0.0308231506,
0.0390202776,
0.090960592,
-0.000090698,
-0.0115754856,
0.021437332,
0.0490093566,
0.0223436449,
-0.0167858284,
-0.0135252886,
0.0542516559,
-0.0154904155,
0.0108382832,
0.0064444887,
0.0537666045,
0.0278687906,
0.0202212166,
-0.0042858389,
-0.0008180874,
0.00576868,
-0.0095398063,
-0.0030952513,
0.0365255512,
0.0038361503,
0.0579848252,
0.0442492999,
-0.0729664043,
-0.0050926353,
-0.0409802832,
-0.0394848287,
-0.0584242195,
-0.0563250966,
-0.0019775094,
-0.018572161,
0.0040248497,
-0.1044075415,
-0.0607637353,
0.0189237073,
-0.0206701867,
0.0191786326,
-0.0306431223,
0.0022402366,
-0.0083800051,
-0.0089805191,
0.0195996687,
-0.0363244563,
-0.009178495,
-0.0295663644,
-0.0217389613,
0.0378667489,
-0.0840432718,
-0.0183180775,
0.0102767851,
-0.0879584104,
-0.0685727075,
-0.0059032156,
0.1099856943,
0.018876493,
0.1150739267,
-0.0147871207,
-0.04859519,
0.0424993634,
0.0186066478,
-0.0105667291,
0.0262771137,
0.0383637324,
0.0154830553,
-0.0066756001,
0.035592448,
-0.0527543202,
0.0229672715,
0.0060268799,
0.0072246022,
-0.0189574379,
-0.0485240519,
0.047725752,
0.0136770196,
0.0234928373,
-0.0431082733,
-0.0096569015,
-0.0477344953,
-0.0153783057,
0.0051902742,
-0.051858712,
-0.0411886126,
0.009867629,
-0.0009874166,
-0.00506054,
-0.0166845061,
-0.0360037126,
-0.039431572,
0.0569760203,
-0.0473185144,
-0.0043330225,
-0.0032903303,
0.0201601982,
0.0132130468,
0.0035032856,
-0.0307755992,
0.0082109282,
-0.0059330729,
0.0480895415,
0.0054753278,
0.0269846208,
0.0477529764,
-0.045131743,
-0.011297049,
0.0162329301,
-0.0537964031,
-0.0214847233,
-0.0885692313,
0.0157474261,
0.0391375385,
-0.0152805168,
0.0604269803,
-0.0345140658,
0.0112739457,
-0.0030811743,
0.0229667109,
0.0044464329,
-0.0349346846,
0.0157357082,
0.0188867673,
0.0194534864,
0.0174495522,
0.0822049603,
0.0023426365,
0.0424255989,
-0.0001315986,
0.0359796733,
-0.0456532538,
-0.0249604378,
-0.0082828449,
0.0231104251,
-0.0180780925,
0.0068299985,
-0.0053089997,
-0.0333656557,
-0.0229835827,
0.0357075967,
0.013239732,
-0.0272960961,
0.055461619,
0.0142166298,
-0.0284722131,
0.0038298394,
-0.0554813519,
-0.0129192118,
0.0288544912,
-0.008446998,
-0.0373298489,
-6.181035089e-33,
-0.0386489891,
-0.0267436635,
-0.0009796802,
-0.0044807107,
-0.0306517538,
-0.0312088951,
-0.0341038294,
0.0259831827,
-0.0065922816,
0.0083920164,
-0.0140813701,
0.006670333,
0.0057394891,
0.0336077288,
0.0147888865,
-0.0053702337,
0.0508082025,
-0.0255596247,
-0.0662239715,
0.0239562765,
0.0074854246,
-0.0047763404,
0.0422333293,
-0.0479022563,
0.0469535813,
-0.0207745172,
-0.061256256,
0.0389364064,
-0.0135818943,
0.0405002274,
0.0004994054,
0.028270686,
0.0159246046,
-0.0330065899,
-0.0397193246,
0.0051723756,
-0.0772732571,
-0.0155426739,
0.0248899143,
-0.0038279444,
-0.0556436479,
0.0167277437,
0.0610326156,
-0.0263963938,
-0.0041669095,
0.0178952664,
0.0414158478,
-0.0492763221,
-0.040822275,
-0.0044217953,
-0.0440618061,
0.0036322232,
0.0084623965,
-0.0567397214,
0.0142399846,
0.0597892478,
-0.0199231673,
-0.0129190134,
-0.0167056806,
0.0518490449,
0.0530506112,
0.0264608152,
0.0296102911,
0.0413161218,
0.008530614,
0.071279414,
-0.0395112485,
0.0077626393,
-0.0235723816,
0.0022226451,
0.0444144718,
-0.0024014607,
0.0209713764,
0.049683474,
0.028660683,
0.0081215464,
0.0100650461,
0.0476590842,
-0.0132598411,
0.0298367795,
0.0387213081,
0.0026403731,
-0.0255395342,
-0.0250265095,
-0.0685437918,
-0.0054568173,
-0.0141598657,
-0.0320877731,
-0.0079452787,
0.0490838885,
-0.0601205938,
-0.0479970872,
-0.0004697776,
-0.0209777802,
-0.0122078536,
-0.0024744116,
-0.044337552,
-0.0056014438,
-0.0151989078,
-0.0274431966,
-0.0403221771,
-0.0071524195,
0.0191027839,
-0.0112698339,
-0.0155124543,
0.0200765319,
0.0719299763,
0.0085752765,
-0.0374889001,
0.0346367508,
0.0011303078,
0.0315215699,
0.0100729447,
0.0055169323,
0.0354735367,
0.0120529663,
-0.0170688462,
0.045922637,
0.0011031282,
-0.0563709699,
-0.0476580337,
-0.0043956959,
-0.0031124228,
0.0263313632,
-0.0540801771,
0.0087919962,
-0.0288984515,
-0.0006474797,
0.0100179436,
-0.0675128922,
-0.0157270599,
0.0033733426,
2.532e-7,
0.0150609352,
0.0312849283,
0.0360602997,
0.0123887137,
-0.0271682106,
0.0474066809,
0.0038930336,
0.0122836735,
0.0368074365,
0.0042675799,
0.0522225685,
0.0390300117,
0.0537104681,
0.0051395255,
-0.0939728767,
-0.0297215339,
-0.0910865441,
0.0113149974,
-0.0119931167,
-0.0779899508,
0.0204151068,
0.0882081389,
0.0427287631,
-0.012136302,
0.015825469,
-0.0286651645,
0.0510712527,
-0.0445955619,
-0.0223833751,
-0.0107300142,
0.0158253945,
0.0223535281,
-0.0241710581,
-0.0215784889,
-0.0123419203,
-0.0286049824,
-0.0093102902,
0.0351216905,
0.0048042284,
-0.0081239063,
0.0052496763,
0.0218869727,
0.045345366,
-0.0468773618,
0.0518819466,
-0.0503712706,
0.0247974396,
-0.0462736562,
0.0106969411,
-0.0190506764,
-0.0085215932,
-0.055370409,
-0.0629749075,
0.0288097188,
0.0230753105,
0.0533498116,
0.0102401366,
-0.070761919,
-0.0599225312,
0.023139907,
-0.0277965702,
-0.0119169028,
-0.0222113859,
-0.0025616297,
-0.0187891684,
-0.0848918557,
0.0243768487,
2.193426082e-34,
0.0672624037,
-0.0272720773,
-0.0021762848,
0.0145000257,
0.0375865735,
0.0232911687,
0.0054193051,
0.0057016718,
0.0595924109,
-0.0526231863,
-0.0287335329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16133v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16133v2 | Exposing and Addressing Cross-Task Inconsistency in Unified Vision-Language Models | 2023-03-28T16:57:12 | 2024-02-21T22:53:33 | Adyasha Maharana, Amita Kamath, Christopher Clark, Mohit Bansal, Aniruddha Kembhavi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As general purpose vision models get increasingly effective at a wide set of
tasks, it is imperative that they be consistent across the tasks they support.
Inconsistent AI models are considered brittle and untrustworthy by human users
and are more challenging to incorporate into larger systems that take
dependencies on their outputs. Measuring consistency between very heterogeneous
tasks that might include outputs in different modalities is challenging since
it is difficult to determine if the predictions are consistent with one
another. As a solution, we introduce a benchmark dataset, CocoCon, where we
create contrast sets by modifying test instances for multiple tasks in small
but semantically meaningful ways to change the gold label and outline metrics
for measuring if a model is consistent by ranking the original and perturbed
instances across tasks. We find that state-of-the-art vision-language models
suffer from a surprisingly high degree of inconsistent behavior across tasks,
especially for more heterogeneous tasks. To alleviate this issue, we propose a
rank correlation-based auxiliary training objective, computed over large
automatically created cross-task contrast sets, that improves the multi-task
consistency of large unified models while retaining their original accuracy on
downstream tasks. | [
0.0076228147,
0.0831171274,
-0.0102135167,
0.0453394875,
-0.0111630568,
0.022757642,
0.013030814,
-0.0150705436,
0.0320859626,
-0.0339386426,
-0.0605431311,
-0.0430003665,
0.0453597344,
0.019511262,
0.0067835865,
-0.0534254499,
0.0588937327,
-0.0362521671,
-0.0281261429,
0.0109046297,
-0.0126212556,
0.0001687768,
0.009260444,
0.064409472,
-0.0103720007,
-0.0500974916,
0.02612116,
0.0225828458,
0.0458351448,
0.0183804072,
0.0332398489,
0.052575469,
0.0180679057,
0.037590459,
0.0000021068,
-0.0363447107,
0.0145686669,
-0.0001760387,
-0.0003421963,
-0.0168219283,
0.0021623154,
-0.0217741337,
0.0034040159,
0.0136783319,
-0.0278912466,
0.0216549579,
0.0599830188,
0.0347153358,
0.0381874852,
0.027485799,
-0.0095657958,
0.0308289975,
0.0023584163,
-0.0562348366,
-0.0043410803,
-0.0382773951,
0.0263731703,
0.0212308317,
-0.0607682839,
-0.008392591,
-0.0326889902,
-0.0059051882,
0.0351661891,
0.018418137,
-0.007323612,
0.0240717474,
-0.0506349728,
-0.0192838125,
-0.0155200418,
0.0460044779,
-0.0706056729,
-0.0139788315,
-0.0050510215,
-0.0150058595,
-0.0013527811,
-0.0137000317,
-0.0434403941,
0.004083625,
0.0034489857,
0.0128416801,
0.003378764,
0.012876017,
0.0261574946,
0.0105076674,
-0.0255211852,
0.0131329503,
0.0042613191,
0.0037167165,
-0.0060242638,
0.0199681334,
-0.0492564961,
-0.0573212989,
-0.010378357,
-0.0162521079,
-0.0589099489,
-0.0099873701,
-0.0779820755,
-0.0622144043,
-0.0076231151,
-0.0149717648,
0.1023003012,
0.0367647819,
-0.0809763968,
0.0614233278,
-0.0349737853,
0.1301963031,
-0.0091933263,
0.0619887263,
-0.0210345276,
-0.0186995622,
-0.0470757931,
0.0142907985,
0.0049248277,
-0.0037363956,
-0.0178813376,
-0.025671076,
-0.043782942,
0.0224229842,
-0.0586911663,
0.0527122393,
0.05933626,
0.0128738089,
-0.0740032345,
-0.0139578646,
-0.0029630901,
0.0127335945,
0.0160306357,
0.0436883532,
-0.0007632129,
-0.0772544965,
-0.0142425597,
0.0133746071,
-0.0406553634,
-0.0178549495,
-0.0092713507,
0.0910688192,
-0.018307833,
-0.0272913426,
0.0023651407,
-0.019875478,
-0.0409177132,
-0.0403759964,
0.0020778913,
-0.0438014418,
0.0366889052,
-0.0024836378,
0.0201169197,
-0.0438986793,
0.0173397493,
-0.01686831,
-0.0187784638,
0.0884271637,
-0.0060677067,
-0.0114984205,
-0.0253027566,
0.0093116295,
-0.029933136,
0.0452836007,
0.0186838731,
0.0212116931,
0.0335593484,
0.0320103057,
-0.00587958,
0.0273119844,
-0.0385756567,
-0.0135267833,
-0.0448676422,
0.0125934277,
0.0218910612,
-0.0068175565,
0.0257085767,
0.0480325744,
-0.0118914843,
-0.0521396175,
0.0875437632,
-0.0054578716,
0.0238102172,
-0.0372529104,
0.026618747,
-0.0316257179,
0.0053187301,
0.0300857872,
-0.0790380687,
0.0118826311,
0.0098356633,
-0.0142786773,
-0.0153348399,
0.0391462073,
-0.0361541361,
-0.0653894171,
-0.0142774126,
-0.0110508753,
-0.0110582439,
0.0074696108,
0.0604858361,
0.0193745792,
-0.0261362679,
-0.0057764309,
0.01508989,
-0.0335265212,
-0.0140506914,
-0.0548050962,
0.0052717682,
0.0740219206,
0.0211935937,
-0.006760071,
-0.0332264565,
0.013681842,
0.020253269,
0.0113088442,
0.0044874521,
-0.0173294954,
0.0569643751,
-0.0650529638,
-0.0717249364,
-0.0175298024,
0.0181922596,
0.0011742992,
0.0096420376,
-0.0217274521,
0.0391778275,
-0.0565110072,
-0.0396500863,
0.0543040223,
-0.0030316908,
0.0336867496,
0.0008777676,
-0.0128739243,
0.0149220293,
-0.0286866352,
-0.0238948613,
-0.0012909387,
0.0280050989,
-0.0295276251,
0.0316512547,
0.0326132178,
-0.0450979732,
0.0058116121,
0.0385296308,
-0.0324050039,
-0.0190016907,
0.1086791754,
-0.0569005609,
-0.0202319641,
0.0148823112,
0.0041606608,
-0.0087619778,
-0.013590252,
0.0196811128,
0.0113098305,
0.0208672527,
0.0012704546,
0.0422688946,
-0.044859726,
-0.0116614364,
0.0314717107,
0.0110988701,
-0.0038078858,
-0.0288303997,
0.0101397699,
0.019596288,
-0.0039986195,
0.0138488347,
0.0014520162,
0.0059442488,
-0.0149215432,
-0.0181421135,
-0.0790826529,
-0.017760111,
-0.0451351926,
-0.004843106,
0.0236536413,
-0.0256003421,
0.0217516981,
-0.0602558665,
0.0399939567,
0.0343754292,
-0.0127355419,
0.0173476636,
0.0010162102,
0.0031894159,
0.0113101304,
-0.0346843414,
-0.0242351629,
0.0128475027,
0.0463084094,
-0.0050263004,
-0.0096462304,
-0.0604901873,
0.0528817214,
-0.014114636,
0.0625627786,
-0.0451082736,
0.0210690834,
0.0220124982,
-0.0032160864,
0.0234159715,
0.0845137462,
0.0058197393,
0.0323055945,
0.0590670779,
0.0016208806,
-0.0398106314,
-0.024867015,
0.0202703681,
-0.0205930211,
-0.0157737546,
-0.0243631825,
-0.0189057253,
0.074154228,
-0.0114847403,
-0.013487882,
-0.0804277807,
0.0019843196,
-0.0246450808,
-0.0477962866,
-0.0398608297,
-0.0119589595,
-0.0068623088,
0.0205504764,
-0.0567606352,
-0.0751728714,
0.0238722861,
-0.0259583704,
0.0187877566,
0.0071005272,
0.0032849603,
0.002294044,
0.0678540096,
0.0444931984,
0.000878224,
0.0052814987,
0.0023730067,
-0.103405863,
-0.0076632113,
0.0106777353,
-0.0348364525,
0.0747755021,
-0.0687337294,
0.0051438073,
-0.0287711509,
-0.0548700541,
-0.0408079773,
0.0281504896,
-0.0196093842,
0.0374017768,
-0.0268986523,
-0.0210009757,
-0.0110895736,
-0.0031726139,
0.0169649553,
0.0530320667,
-0.0060686944,
-0.0236071348,
-0.0209131762,
0.0096258223,
0.0510149524,
0.0262345076,
0.0001044348,
-0.0627916604,
-0.0168070178,
0.062286634,
0.0625763535,
0.0104087451,
-0.0752075836,
-0.0006686348,
0.0241967384,
0.027803503,
-0.0149982609,
0.0239417609,
0.0332244635,
-0.0706835464,
-0.008713902,
0.0566155463,
-0.0001881973,
-0.0319329277,
-0.0036937189,
0.0149282636,
0.0187161192,
0.0526058562,
0.0039987983,
-0.0628376529,
-0.0381640047,
0.0057377056,
0.0231140945,
0.027453905,
-0.0110441847,
0.0044795894,
-0.0929247215,
0.0415913276,
0.0090517262,
-0.003353592,
-0.0335061997,
0.0069119497,
0.0336804874,
-0.0457261279,
0.0160718206,
-0.0035122919,
0.0003144554,
-0.0079753855,
0.0202181842,
0.006657524,
-0.0663348734,
0.0294794273,
-0.041055046,
0.0155173643,
0.0924003497,
-0.020192042,
0.0021856374,
-0.0475398712,
0.0382040925,
-0.0094143599,
0.0081257531,
0.0109106619,
0.0535416827,
-0.0246176515,
-0.0494502708,
0.0272893533,
0.0001451318,
-0.0140771382,
-0.0401718318,
-0.0331447907,
0.0128557123,
-0.003209467,
-0.0170048364,
-0.0291393548,
-0.0485866889,
0.0005477982,
0.0436638556,
-0.0251676608,
-0.0313717052,
-0.0327249169,
-0.0138432877,
0.001332742,
-0.0558378212,
-0.0141102802,
0.0097348578,
0.0174974483,
0.0038182561,
-0.0500028469,
-0.0259552374,
0.01866154,
0.0115582189,
-0.0093484279,
-0.032632526,
-0.0069565335,
-0.0103824027,
-0.0760386437,
0.0600734279,
-0.0083643897,
0.039446041,
-0.0431605279,
-0.0031017398,
0.0050824569,
-0.0311377924,
-0.0223491173,
0.0391003564,
-0.0987109691,
-0.0366052836,
-0.0099089993,
0.0875415578,
0.015506831,
0.060333848,
-0.007127149,
-0.0337210782,
-0.0053318194,
0.0216375571,
0.0071566957,
0.055217281,
0.0301601123,
-0.0681286305,
-0.011744081,
0.0287439376,
-0.067568846,
0.0117223272,
0.0451646559,
0.034434706,
-0.0070476853,
-0.0218581334,
0.0261490159,
-0.0322470665,
0.0744639635,
-0.0080609955,
0.0356752835,
-0.0359981097,
0.0266109407,
0.0104415054,
-0.0225437023,
-0.0607560277,
0.0392271131,
0.0166793764,
0.0366034135,
0.0107881427,
0.0645640865,
0.0042045061,
0.0109873256,
-0.0875001028,
-0.0497766845,
-0.0231785495,
0.0168808047,
0.0057534901,
0.0163344257,
-0.0114985202,
0.0301814415,
-0.0003827148,
0.0400831364,
0.0154741146,
0.0187926702,
0.0334326029,
0.0119008999,
-0.0114194993,
0.0793647394,
-0.0629173368,
-0.058512412,
-0.0521884598,
-0.0010164067,
0.0310587045,
-0.0133089637,
0.0515227504,
-0.0288142711,
0.0047669243,
-0.0647496358,
0.0225294027,
0.0499822199,
0.0047659734,
0.0181395765,
0.0172203928,
0.0014167413,
0.0187188778,
0.0845277682,
0.0011474291,
0.0251235627,
-0.0255374871,
0.000290284,
-0.0207301881,
-0.0450629927,
0.0440609232,
-0.0008662061,
-0.024796417,
-0.025523698,
-0.0215262659,
-0.0688557699,
0.0374580473,
0.0386119969,
0.0338114798,
0.0231423415,
0.0332480334,
0.0523947887,
-0.0087384777,
-0.0014955852,
-0.0217302088,
-0.0888866708,
0.0062949834,
0.0046279659,
-0.0148100192,
-6.063505123e-33,
-0.0125116669,
-0.0012617215,
-0.0109947165,
-0.0571653657,
0.0089026662,
0.0391799212,
-0.0129044689,
-0.0105216615,
-0.0245354045,
0.0117215496,
0.0206484105,
0.039895393,
0.017256042,
0.0095072202,
0.0363155045,
-0.0105863018,
0.0605769195,
0.0052915118,
-0.0199377257,
-0.0172589906,
0.0406071842,
-0.0041076015,
0.0608983859,
-0.08610522,
0.0060999375,
0.0352756828,
-0.032178577,
-0.0047723544,
-0.0059194053,
0.0826162845,
-0.0014823073,
0.0576026551,
0.0356216952,
-0.0169666782,
-0.0606030598,
-0.0018997609,
-0.0386516824,
-0.0218034312,
-0.0079192659,
0.0163328461,
-0.1261243671,
0.0179533958,
0.0473515317,
0.0070720781,
-0.0360196941,
-0.0359943174,
0.0391907431,
-0.0473581515,
0.0068063815,
0.0106831733,
-0.0274069719,
-0.0007974128,
0.0142383864,
-0.0312728696,
0.0202619564,
0.0719792023,
0.0253077429,
0.0216899347,
-0.0475574099,
0.0197659694,
-0.0211267956,
0.0378798693,
0.0822523534,
0.0710660592,
-0.0148044778,
0.0690855309,
0.0111465957,
-0.0032434629,
0.0162222981,
-0.055468671,
0.0059470017,
0.0754545629,
0.046654854,
0.0579231121,
0.0301037543,
0.0271731932,
-0.0537099354,
0.0238559712,
-0.026596982,
0.0549557246,
0.0181270689,
0.0327514745,
-0.0269541889,
0.0051567499,
-0.0093984986,
-0.0055647409,
-0.0590492897,
0.0056506866,
0.0670385584,
0.0270648338,
-0.004645606,
0.0489201806,
0.0331928805,
-0.0487146638,
-0.0048602615,
0.0038549281,
-0.0421669818,
0.0148645537,
0.0196757726,
0.0292333812,
-0.0481315441,
-0.0280208196,
0.0638867542,
0.0225568488,
0.0371914469,
0.0090195397,
0.0483531579,
-0.0049551153,
-0.0343718976,
-0.0047346884,
-0.02147815,
0.0067612487,
-0.0010162502,
0.0280763749,
0.046562288,
-0.0052379267,
-0.0405956358,
0.0616284944,
0.0011708764,
-0.030596232,
-0.0288375225,
0.0172179118,
0.0116265779,
0.0356383584,
0.0219580587,
-0.0169683602,
-0.0652692169,
-0.0037952024,
0.0224399753,
-0.0176308099,
-0.0245272797,
0.0318509191,
2.728e-7,
0.0129771661,
-0.0098061608,
-0.0064259809,
0.0066413283,
0.0194866732,
0.0448306464,
-0.0298079476,
0.0532682799,
-0.0170063116,
-0.0546402484,
-0.0015718126,
0.0518072173,
0.067030929,
-0.0125250174,
0.0106068179,
-0.0079694213,
-0.0320783444,
-0.0026865778,
-0.0385903157,
-0.0055746343,
0.0328290127,
0.0649391934,
-0.0059543778,
-0.0022042214,
0.0421061255,
-0.0182268005,
0.0702587515,
-0.0213686787,
0.0229968019,
-0.03494028,
-0.0014153747,
0.0261116307,
-0.0271780957,
0.0501458049,
-0.0186743867,
0.0003698117,
0.0404318646,
0.0222675037,
-0.0587568581,
0.0181774721,
-0.0563510768,
0.0448346138,
0.0005820698,
-0.0578748062,
0.0650704205,
-0.0395667851,
0.0126444586,
-0.0561069436,
-0.0029696983,
0.0366725847,
0.0451132804,
0.008450605,
-0.0175123364,
-0.0013048851,
0.030743422,
0.0246251673,
-0.0767352954,
-0.0650013089,
-0.0313013233,
-0.0014668857,
-0.05385096,
-0.0375877172,
-0.0365733691,
-0.0018245833,
0.0279794782,
-0.0614673719,
-0.0397263207,
2.489890119e-34,
0.0056849844,
0.0040721833,
0.0422795042,
0.0006594347,
0.0003110044,
-0.0364983566,
-0.0701580048,
0.0119865248,
-0.0144409547,
-0.0202275403,
-0.0240314379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16104v1 | Hallucinations in Large Multilingual Translation Models | 2023-03-28T16:17:59 | 2023-03-28T16:17:59 | Nuno M. Guerreiro, Duarte Alves, Jonas Waldendorf, Barry Haddow, Alexandra Birch, Pierre Colombo, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale multilingual machine translation systems have demonstrated
remarkable ability to translate directly between numerous languages, making
them increasingly appealing for real-world applications. However, when deployed
in the wild, these models may generate hallucinated translations which have the
potential to severely undermine user trust and raise safety concerns. Existing
research on hallucinations has primarily focused on small bilingual models
trained on high-resource languages, leaving a gap in our understanding of
hallucinations in massively multilingual models across diverse translation
scenarios. In this work, we fill this gap by conducting a comprehensive
analysis on both the M2M family of conventional neural machine translation
models and ChatGPT, a general-purpose large language model~(LLM) that can be
prompted for translation. Our investigation covers a broad spectrum of
conditions, spanning over 100 translation directions across various resource
levels and going beyond English-centric language pairs. We provide key insights
regarding the prevalence, properties, and mitigation of hallucinations, paving
the way towards more responsible and reliable machine translation systems. | [
0.0078674806,
0.0347560383,
-0.0172458459,
0.0669068024,
-0.0294233467,
0.0291923266,
0.0192447007,
0.0016626058,
0.0028209498,
0.0054818052,
-0.04015854,
-0.0848077759,
0.0253180172,
-0.0311586242,
0.0380667709,
-0.0176535528,
0.0461336337,
-0.0508027263,
-0.0720081925,
-0.0079955664,
-0.0118417721,
0.0189597607,
0.0236352943,
0.0580677353,
0.0036879878,
-0.0419796892,
-0.0004526774,
0.0553732812,
0.0185813885,
0.002906603,
-0.0170007534,
0.0511765219,
-0.0101332646,
0.1221387014,
0.0000021482,
-0.0211784188,
-0.0108004073,
0.0038404046,
0.0115367938,
0.0169578977,
0.0512764901,
-0.0336729325,
-0.0092021311,
0.0049544927,
-0.0109288767,
0.0104727121,
0.0393715538,
0.0427177772,
0.0486594327,
0.0552845821,
-0.0176191777,
-0.0260253567,
-0.0032587324,
-0.0204396136,
0.0392826758,
-0.0374073386,
0.0123730544,
-0.0087679112,
-0.0383678302,
-0.0050371625,
0.0004993929,
0.0360585339,
0.026636133,
0.0053792442,
-0.0491048209,
0.014737227,
-0.0583469607,
-0.0565511957,
-0.0173019897,
0.0509697273,
-0.0794259384,
-0.014477904,
0.0136319948,
0.0169622824,
-0.0083192429,
-0.0219297893,
-0.017831834,
0.0247572474,
-0.0109395655,
-0.0209602322,
0.0262397379,
0.0294423122,
0.0560660474,
0.0026603686,
-0.0751182139,
0.0097975582,
0.0169076808,
-0.0452524163,
0.026582066,
0.0338125564,
-0.0012769459,
-0.0379822142,
0.0468625911,
-0.0180191286,
-0.0448381081,
-0.0046087177,
-0.0264945552,
-0.0265326947,
0.0439827777,
-0.1204564497,
-0.0024533346,
0.024311902,
-0.0675913244,
0.0475987792,
-0.0107862027,
0.0171146076,
-0.0693106279,
0.0476525612,
-0.0400586277,
0.0048378562,
-0.0008453273,
0.0103457784,
-0.030646557,
-0.0382051803,
-0.0314281136,
-0.0156587884,
-0.0225689542,
0.0133304484,
-0.0158232804,
0.0296222568,
-0.0215832498,
0.012702099,
-0.0285072457,
-0.0380650088,
0.0285078138,
0.0337119922,
0.0009371462,
-0.0476719141,
0.0211111493,
-0.0609506741,
-0.0259754788,
0.0151610244,
-0.0799610466,
-0.0254242234,
-0.0161558595,
0.0805663392,
0.0089250384,
0.0126302037,
0.0092937909,
-0.0509378016,
-0.028438244,
-0.0770605505,
0.019474322,
-0.0419287458,
0.0356798731,
0.0134043228,
0.0122200092,
-0.0122095197,
0.0299080294,
0.004932526,
-0.0538053326,
0.0699259117,
0.0020485159,
-0.001551903,
0.0188410543,
0.0371419191,
-0.0243323036,
0.0701136887,
0.0116130756,
0.0506243818,
0.036107257,
-0.0160552394,
0.0505314246,
0.0669644624,
-0.0152673936,
0.0454164334,
-0.0373864323,
-0.023208918,
0.0430478603,
0.0293759145,
-0.001114046,
0.0665159598,
-0.019721074,
0.0037924538,
0.0725241676,
0.0172691364,
-0.0389636829,
0.0424711704,
0.0199675709,
-0.0040970831,
-0.0144458776,
0.0322002321,
-0.0582790896,
0.0142666865,
-0.0252459161,
-0.0218714923,
0.0531322099,
0.0383152701,
0.0102021862,
-0.0227087848,
0.0008639174,
0.0044329492,
0.0208481085,
-0.0074652084,
0.0048079882,
0.0039880211,
-0.0359180868,
0.0425313301,
0.0030371358,
-0.0257683303,
0.0089766122,
-0.0183297619,
-0.0688592643,
0.0960492715,
0.0486908183,
0.0126838237,
-0.0054284297,
-0.0482410975,
0.0225210823,
0.0693473369,
0.0593687072,
0.0390591212,
0.0291333608,
-0.0492385477,
0.0054605305,
0.0408716351,
0.0439980105,
0.012650731,
-0.0320871957,
0.0548151992,
0.0037691691,
-0.0142298108,
-0.1049824655,
0.0209524035,
-0.0345217772,
-0.0117560057,
0.0060316734,
0.0035838133,
0.0077924682,
0.0014618707,
-0.0240594111,
0.0052171126,
0.0145671973,
-0.0363106579,
-0.043419309,
0.0645179972,
-0.0448402315,
0.0129688224,
0.0098374663,
0.0037716213,
-0.0095257843,
-0.027809849,
-0.0301290061,
-0.0224767793,
-0.0102001382,
-0.0404356718,
0.0146431942,
-0.0199565068,
0.0557269156,
-0.0081241075,
0.0534425229,
-0.0128902281,
0.0324197412,
-0.0192901455,
-0.0082349936,
0.012128938,
-0.017875379,
0.0175656639,
0.010316832,
-0.0499228239,
0.0621116608,
0.0103586959,
0.0366273373,
-0.0048167389,
-0.0086923633,
-0.0309501439,
-0.0399588235,
-0.0602399521,
0.0076745632,
-0.0324899927,
0.004183365,
0.0434557907,
-0.0127230939,
0.0002373859,
0.0084713409,
0.0027386465,
0.0185494795,
0.0020064339,
0.0365876555,
-0.0006020244,
-0.0183559712,
-0.0117682545,
0.0098462356,
0.0165137984,
0.0020385967,
0.0698369965,
0.0114250639,
-0.0537473746,
-0.0926727802,
0.0209111199,
-0.0247788019,
-0.0133945597,
-0.0040851105,
-0.0581001826,
0.0132250572,
-0.0068415878,
0.0499812774,
0.0645351112,
0.0046411012,
0.019060621,
0.0462064072,
-0.0236934219,
-0.0264804885,
-0.019723665,
0.0121953329,
-0.0336006582,
-0.0047363872,
-0.0487412438,
0.0045091524,
0.0397220962,
-0.0075234608,
0.0088303965,
-0.049110502,
0.0064769918,
-0.0435286053,
-0.0565047339,
0.0038444328,
0.0049759056,
-0.0139731085,
0.0684331954,
-0.0173872113,
-0.032337036,
0.0489549674,
-0.0272781849,
-0.0118115153,
-0.0268044695,
0.0081623113,
0.012162284,
0.0310552362,
-0.0092375763,
0.042028144,
-0.022278687,
-0.0226121675,
-0.0178230535,
0.0057231477,
-0.0260070283,
-0.0426397957,
0.0076951357,
-0.0424396098,
-0.0314748995,
-0.0020464191,
-0.0126413647,
-0.0194653198,
-0.0161461718,
0.0008240116,
-0.0398489423,
-0.0037677125,
-0.0092803976,
-0.0385250263,
0.0035822131,
0.0144131863,
0.0347246677,
-0.0268973466,
-0.0189676974,
-0.0052381963,
-0.0194522571,
0.0256093945,
-0.0308586899,
0.0650036782,
-0.0848871022,
0.0352271535,
0.0592182055,
0.0080317855,
0.0096983835,
-0.0125052184,
-0.042572204,
0.0200742092,
0.0000763959,
-0.0430220664,
0.0003372735,
0.0402303822,
-0.070895046,
-0.0108442008,
0.0636623427,
0.0092112841,
-0.0887716636,
0.0094040325,
-0.0718115121,
0.0440439582,
-0.0110640712,
0.0034175008,
-0.0814303607,
0.0040678233,
0.0185739286,
0.0093616135,
0.0056191548,
0.0078792442,
0.0047343411,
-0.0520270467,
0.0193889029,
0.0588843673,
-0.0559602231,
-0.015569956,
0.0205662455,
-0.0363186151,
-0.0128079392,
0.0652656555,
-0.029714983,
0.0298832804,
-0.0482362583,
0.001077484,
0.0224143583,
-0.0312959664,
0.0176063552,
-0.0508862548,
0.0318961702,
0.067498222,
0.0190475471,
-0.0190080088,
-0.0727722049,
0.0407290421,
0.0196284559,
0.0057939482,
0.0210019667,
0.0269125979,
0.0216299146,
-0.0116025181,
0.0182133224,
-0.012813054,
-0.0300817247,
0.0111933677,
0.0155356154,
0.0643763766,
-0.0475313514,
-0.0470985956,
0.0104912072,
0.0191015322,
0.0286221653,
0.0481194817,
0.0058990656,
-0.0559677295,
-0.0346673429,
-0.0248823203,
0.0285517555,
-0.0400718078,
-0.0527725965,
0.0380614661,
0.0252600573,
-0.0675694942,
-0.0649936944,
-0.0418646894,
-0.0161040295,
0.0252891742,
0.0354380719,
0.0376492515,
-0.0115757631,
-0.0161760487,
0.0295160357,
0.0532428138,
-0.033962246,
0.0262628347,
-0.028182324,
0.0575470589,
0.0029690007,
-0.0158754531,
0.0195756182,
0.0439215936,
-0.0849111304,
-0.0723825991,
0.030320324,
0.0559402332,
0.0298701525,
0.0324941427,
-0.0499709137,
-0.0391166322,
0.0274849962,
0.0288765561,
-0.0128037818,
-0.0160566997,
0.0414100736,
0.0127873551,
-0.0041514281,
0.0407541543,
0.0096065188,
-0.018443225,
0.0019541096,
0.0089029418,
-0.0296353512,
-0.0271671005,
0.0171178617,
-0.0121753607,
0.0248412322,
-0.0418997593,
0.0005900071,
-0.0062694079,
-0.0028546222,
-0.0195127465,
-0.0159888528,
-0.0176510233,
-0.0212842822,
0.0592313521,
-0.0132085318,
0.0126965418,
-0.0265888106,
-0.0076631606,
-0.0377742462,
0.0039872527,
-0.0341157578,
-0.0300068166,
0.0214650333,
0.0484576337,
0.0125456844,
-0.0261847042,
0.0491290875,
-0.016493259,
0.0449715257,
-0.0207166206,
0.0776969567,
-0.0010476966,
-0.0109362118,
0.016752664,
0.0478661507,
-0.0118258372,
-0.0967662334,
-0.0149580818,
0.0227675978,
0.0662506893,
0.0201272238,
0.0972820595,
-0.0171515718,
0.0045035868,
-0.0028315082,
0.0165110826,
0.0303371903,
-0.0281096511,
-0.0512595326,
-0.0177805386,
-0.0087725362,
0.019517839,
0.0590250529,
-0.0375024416,
0.0206011645,
0.014472398,
-0.0427028388,
0.0054286486,
-0.0283024926,
-0.0207897685,
-0.0340086259,
-0.0400289595,
-0.0505322143,
-0.0626193285,
-0.0498942621,
-0.0253372826,
0.0122502744,
0.0086611118,
-0.0046864604,
-0.017780561,
0.1017486602,
-0.0394411795,
0.0024410919,
-0.0230486318,
0.0043034414,
0.0355592035,
-0.0114252372,
-0.0172906425,
-6.410922845e-33,
0.044955153,
-0.0355564207,
0.0061550005,
-0.0679244399,
-0.0304774083,
-0.0357838683,
-0.0164227821,
0.009427066,
0.0179471299,
0.0117741115,
-0.0171738397,
0.0134348236,
0.0199343432,
-0.0182925481,
0.041261375,
-0.0110024503,
0.0589304306,
0.012833151,
-0.0045115454,
0.0450774245,
0.0428296812,
0.0086051561,
0.0625046045,
-0.0854401365,
0.0717816725,
-0.0468713976,
-0.0336453505,
0.0056238677,
-0.031205181,
0.009587856,
-0.0240475032,
0.0067859418,
0.0059826155,
-0.031219339,
-0.0150975902,
-0.0167981368,
-0.0040773279,
0.0205808729,
-0.0015050408,
0.0634844601,
-0.016754549,
-0.0621246025,
0.0536579639,
-0.0492647253,
-0.0032781132,
-0.0011897344,
-0.0039486303,
-0.030524224,
-0.0378780589,
0.0283184368,
-0.0630429536,
-0.0117659317,
0.018721167,
0.0007682746,
0.0149677675,
0.0736545697,
-0.0378271639,
-0.0293557029,
-0.0957213417,
-0.0144856861,
-0.0344285518,
-0.0145838168,
0.0722605363,
-0.0062628691,
-0.0062060445,
0.0372581631,
0.0641449913,
0.0394463167,
-0.0266558975,
0.0043689958,
0.0180963594,
0.0297728851,
0.0626625344,
0.0228226576,
0.0652125105,
-0.0290063471,
-0.0174674541,
0.0061834487,
-0.0416145027,
0.0004168062,
0.0873645246,
-0.0123968879,
-0.0337676667,
-0.0233414061,
-0.0045078173,
-0.0454038754,
-0.0410566926,
-0.0360486433,
0.0080691343,
0.0057432,
-0.0126836617,
0.0021741097,
0.0707814172,
-0.0397879221,
0.0193113163,
-0.0023581714,
-0.0201338064,
-0.005928094,
-0.01419935,
0.034279801,
0.0354359858,
-0.034375336,
-0.0136380829,
0.0003367589,
0.0266846735,
0.0043677813,
0.0397462249,
-0.015260037,
-0.0335006267,
0.0185547322,
-0.036535155,
0.0304126106,
0.0314088017,
0.0342134312,
0.0591432527,
-0.0313960128,
-0.0186972059,
0.0022041053,
0.0499139689,
0.0457203016,
-0.0095691234,
0.0260131285,
-0.0410018601,
0.0408948027,
-0.0366390124,
0.022612961,
-0.0494922213,
-0.00805372,
0.068649821,
-0.0765714645,
-0.0309508219,
-0.0221858621,
2.843e-7,
-0.0065498101,
0.0726272389,
-0.0289008766,
0.0013162441,
0.0287035853,
0.034849029,
-0.0140084177,
0.0298395623,
0.0035036767,
-0.0013430978,
-0.012056441,
0.0250459928,
0.0961813033,
0.0637712628,
-0.0535735004,
-0.0801387504,
-0.037374109,
0.0543401688,
-0.0845976025,
-0.024316309,
0.0317938477,
0.0760326385,
-0.0120736202,
-0.0305796303,
0.0141271707,
-0.0587012507,
0.0674906671,
-0.0150148459,
-0.0068390011,
-0.0016648142,
0.0658493862,
0.0411627553,
-0.0171422567,
0.0267240144,
0.0012788847,
-0.0405037589,
0.0292023532,
0.0481189378,
-0.0023797685,
-0.0075283595,
-0.0025621674,
-0.0389228091,
0.0087528462,
-0.0859584138,
0.0422927625,
-0.0536670722,
0.0018045382,
0.0231331754,
-0.013777364,
-0.0212516896,
0.0983859822,
-0.0335479602,
-0.0189555995,
0.0443099365,
0.0366822667,
0.0316715017,
0.0001741899,
-0.0303542782,
-0.0095814699,
-0.0160787534,
-0.0093732979,
-0.0216831416,
-0.0067550782,
0.024832638,
-0.0301572736,
-0.0339535549,
-0.0023304017,
2.624560216e-34,
0.0332108848,
-0.0179817937,
0.0393717177,
-0.0199580323,
0.0376822054,
-0.0042698574,
0.040245235,
0.0030982299,
-0.0283151139,
-0.0267409571,
-0.0164572299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16749v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16749v2 | Improving Code Generation by Training with Natural Language Feedback | 2023-03-28T16:15:31 | 2024-02-22T22:30:31 | Angelica Chen, Jérémy Scheurer, Tomasz Korbak, Jon Ander Campos, Jun Shern Chan, Samuel R. Bowman, Kyunghyun Cho, Ethan Perez | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The potential for pre-trained large language models (LLMs) to use natural
language feedback at inference time has been an exciting recent development. We
build upon this observation by formalizing an algorithm for learning from
natural language feedback at training time instead, which we call Imitation
learning from Language Feedback (ILF). ILF requires only a small amount of
human-written feedback during training and does not require the same feedback
at test time, making it both user-friendly and sample-efficient. We further
show that ILF can be seen as a form of minimizing the KL divergence to the
ground truth distribution and demonstrate a proof-of-concept on a neural
program synthesis task. We use ILF to improve a Codegen-Mono 6.1B model's
pass@1 rate by 38% relative (and 10% absolute) on the Mostly Basic Python
Problems (MBPP) benchmark, outperforming both fine-tuning on MBPP and
fine-tuning on repaired programs written by humans. Overall, our results
suggest that learning from human-written natural language feedback is both more
effective and sample-efficient than training exclusively on demonstrations for
improving an LLM's performance on code generation tasks. | [
0.0298583582,
0.0720626563,
0.0073048505,
0.0019337852,
0.0087717017,
-0.0012918179,
-0.0444466695,
-0.0004546766,
0.0142190233,
-0.0280582774,
-0.0215143729,
-0.0062334468,
0.0022391449,
0.0320238136,
0.0839825124,
-0.0178068317,
0.0108017977,
-0.0506501198,
-0.0388658568,
-0.0031827465,
-0.0126523376,
0.0138621647,
-0.0031440407,
0.0510027595,
0.0051049613,
-0.0036238271,
-0.0247720629,
0.0062176799,
-0.046899423,
-0.0315765068,
0.0025076563,
0.0433492325,
0.0291757174,
-0.0053086462,
0.0000022854,
-0.0271798167,
0.0389428325,
-0.0130584259,
-0.0087902816,
0.0104536181,
0.0179340523,
0.002140207,
0.0136007061,
0.0292795394,
-0.0390490331,
-0.0126809003,
0.038263429,
-0.0217777342,
0.0896306857,
0.0734096393,
0.0261966102,
0.0049092788,
0.0109957876,
-0.00705327,
0.0494714305,
-0.0063297837,
-0.0098108035,
0.051724378,
0.0050786757,
-0.0224774834,
0.0025776324,
0.0145663116,
0.0590853542,
-0.0188009404,
0.0001237455,
0.0730166212,
-0.0148298163,
0.0030774123,
-0.0051241135,
0.0500837117,
-0.0595185123,
-0.0464835875,
-0.0046198531,
-0.0247126874,
-0.0020432854,
-0.0421940573,
-0.005312236,
0.0317000933,
0.0034688166,
0.0031824622,
0.0136439363,
-0.0615303293,
0.020790115,
0.0100997137,
-0.0342531614,
0.0279122256,
0.0141119137,
-0.0201202538,
-0.0233498905,
0.0095213419,
-0.010393939,
-0.053356044,
-0.0082096811,
0.0482096635,
-0.0421221107,
-0.0098689683,
-0.0656296387,
-0.023899043,
-0.0310684182,
-0.0512537137,
0.0699018762,
0.0411482342,
-0.0058928262,
-0.004638921,
-0.0417921096,
0.0646641701,
-0.0180527214,
0.0316602811,
-0.019316202,
0.0367019437,
-0.0452767313,
-0.0024690875,
-0.0337522961,
0.0566388071,
0.0025284719,
0.03507277,
-0.019163128,
0.0501869954,
-0.0036485365,
0.0486234054,
-0.0339517444,
0.0218252931,
-0.055452086,
-0.0161542408,
-0.0107317548,
-0.001769435,
-0.0160743557,
-0.0524232574,
0.011095129,
-0.0497733057,
-0.013773459,
0.0380671285,
-0.0214230251,
-0.0198065974,
0.0361625254,
0.0600719303,
-0.0007768662,
0.0075551616,
-0.0435280986,
-0.0354672112,
0.0131093198,
-0.0443689413,
0.0177438725,
-0.0906374827,
-0.0221900325,
-0.0118501605,
-0.0215986148,
-0.0597280152,
0.0250722542,
-0.0048086983,
0.01106109,
0.0529814139,
-0.044515986,
-0.0027204473,
0.0009991357,
-0.0235700812,
0.0109374318,
0.0209976379,
0.0614344366,
-0.0007077125,
-0.024269145,
-0.0142737832,
0.0456874296,
0.0275136307,
0.0348598026,
0.0115432022,
0.0080236876,
-0.0057351459,
-0.0231877752,
0.0476147979,
0.0440197773,
0.0278963912,
-0.0110075362,
0.0294628143,
0.0223878734,
0.0072942297,
0.0100856479,
0.0389852673,
0.0774565712,
0.0378839858,
0.0047595417,
-0.010679909,
-0.0518655293,
0.0637078062,
-0.0241356362,
0.0569848046,
0.0258231368,
-0.0061774361,
-0.0269128755,
-0.0896921307,
0.0061050383,
-0.0110701928,
0.0069820369,
0.0038046725,
0.0337596908,
0.0172735658,
-0.0544534251,
0.0149209695,
0.0202744659,
-0.049641829,
0.0259631202,
-0.0809617639,
0.0352917537,
0.0425473712,
0.0511170141,
-0.035942357,
-0.0207571685,
-0.02786416,
-0.0172733106,
0.0259003248,
0.0271061305,
-0.0081510851,
0.0067865527,
-0.0177662969,
0.0022911013,
-0.0453012772,
0.0015290133,
0.0290965382,
0.0364365429,
-0.0300411396,
0.0411124006,
0.0161891207,
-0.0727455318,
0.0584664717,
-0.0268454719,
-0.0344089828,
0.0265839007,
-0.0006222901,
0.0310352948,
-0.0116189132,
-0.057300467,
0.0355031751,
0.0076617342,
-0.0227461848,
-0.0384494402,
-0.0286028795,
-0.0668437704,
-0.0825922787,
0.0380825773,
-0.0081068762,
-0.0156504475,
0.0529547371,
-0.0248877164,
-0.0076436442,
0.0597345233,
-0.0142741334,
0.0370500721,
-0.0048875636,
0.0027900685,
0.0216834154,
-0.0477976687,
-0.0202432908,
0.0227981973,
0.0110985013,
0.0251989327,
-0.0003581435,
0.0771225318,
-0.0041674948,
0.0114193289,
-0.0101012141,
0.0065431846,
-0.0256139077,
0.0477137789,
0.0332100838,
0.0805428252,
-0.0239672959,
-0.0123975845,
-0.0706738532,
0.0246364139,
-0.0419101901,
-0.0044737528,
0.0187906809,
0.0207696762,
-0.0024755811,
-0.0211466458,
-0.046259474,
-0.0411552191,
-0.0065755411,
-0.010459464,
0.0339607857,
0.0089080455,
-0.0166438352,
-0.0576678179,
-0.0011631709,
-0.0240109395,
0.0332592279,
0.0036778755,
-0.0019249526,
-0.0686855093,
0.0663073808,
-0.0136977024,
0.0487536229,
-0.0128309252,
-0.049783811,
0.0289652813,
-0.0574408248,
0.0520609431,
0.0623459481,
0.0060995673,
-0.0147372736,
0.0445359796,
0.0271148961,
-0.0729606748,
0.042386461,
-0.011057727,
-0.0743758157,
0.0022001329,
-0.0112497397,
0.0523462482,
0.0840800554,
0.0174200088,
-0.0243909042,
-0.0712356567,
0.015571055,
0.0189019497,
-0.0178015046,
0.0009318913,
-0.0261935852,
-0.0252038874,
0.0183392782,
-0.0310341921,
-0.0675262734,
0.0823848173,
-0.0162932947,
-0.0165002365,
-0.0236993469,
-0.0154418722,
-0.0304728337,
0.056196034,
0.0128014451,
0.0109904138,
0.0019568622,
-0.0248717573,
-0.0398211218,
0.005486229,
-0.0060846102,
-0.0136599084,
0.0437497012,
-0.0568486042,
0.0171140898,
0.0298085269,
-0.046074219,
-0.0563293286,
0.0068243211,
-0.0288274195,
-0.0043643005,
0.0371170752,
-0.0235076323,
0.0608039573,
-0.0292739756,
0.0273206942,
0.0437063798,
0.0073035811,
-0.0388742238,
-0.0114179431,
-0.0341245569,
-0.0160589647,
-0.0207643621,
-0.0144293774,
-0.0480461009,
-0.0171869379,
-0.0154694729,
0.0444512889,
0.0663792863,
-0.0716913417,
0.0201764796,
-0.0097153606,
0.004046245,
-0.006245797,
0.0705380365,
0.0305989161,
-0.0498130396,
-0.0369627513,
0.1082502827,
0.0274259821,
-0.0220014341,
0.0063349558,
-0.0076817903,
0.063687548,
0.0495858304,
0.0585125275,
-0.0629413649,
-0.0522167534,
-0.0196182504,
0.0498051867,
0.0109859938,
-0.0125375111,
-0.021991428,
-0.1347110868,
-0.0137730585,
0.0318660103,
-0.0454688482,
-0.0692919493,
-0.0165711958,
-0.0534981117,
-0.0033286102,
-0.0443274863,
0.0347538255,
0.0029365814,
0.042186439,
0.0270461608,
-0.0179601628,
-0.0085779484,
0.0080461884,
-0.0526714325,
0.0465983897,
0.1014314964,
0.0215613283,
0.013947648,
0.0195205603,
0.0487411171,
0.0369987898,
0.022699533,
-0.0208557639,
0.0422628745,
-0.0042584618,
-0.0224401522,
0.0267017689,
0.0375650227,
-0.0712166652,
0.0257098582,
0.0228554718,
0.0206855722,
0.0042817453,
-0.0267616101,
0.0107520903,
0.0012030517,
-0.0061352216,
0.0132144112,
0.0435060114,
-0.0418323651,
-0.0305008553,
-0.0492431968,
0.0019914722,
-0.0792247951,
-0.0526129715,
0.0009285927,
-0.0012109069,
0.0120899994,
-0.0765834302,
-0.0214962866,
0.0205747075,
0.0445293933,
0.0129064173,
-0.0482550822,
0.0245896485,
-0.0324528217,
-0.0364415012,
0.0387841091,
-0.0302013457,
-0.0010366815,
-0.0318575203,
-0.0324811861,
0.0143405721,
-0.0403128825,
-0.0071355016,
0.0434763208,
-0.0990905762,
-0.0632047132,
-0.0375484638,
0.1068978533,
0.0085985912,
0.0857708827,
-0.0274078827,
-0.0377270617,
0.0067048026,
0.0333929583,
-0.0050937608,
0.0112089217,
0.0357159004,
-0.0027686383,
0.0253116395,
0.0164130777,
-0.0596646816,
-0.0247391798,
0.0345923342,
0.0207972415,
0.0372585617,
-0.0079124784,
0.0565942377,
0.0399000421,
-0.0016696404,
0.0022041472,
-0.002406487,
-0.0258263256,
-0.0092385383,
0.018376613,
-0.0330122411,
-0.0690020323,
0.0226564761,
-0.0023385461,
-0.0067765922,
0.0237944759,
-0.0140906451,
-0.0202236772,
0.0821027607,
-0.0021983969,
-0.0053901481,
0.0026289725,
0.0605117641,
0.0829580352,
-0.012824351,
-0.0161566734,
0.0451962985,
0.0016808251,
0.0279630907,
0.0060800822,
0.0415911041,
0.0333261564,
0.0109973084,
-0.0083873598,
-0.0107173659,
-0.0498535186,
-0.0982803553,
-0.052103661,
0.0177206565,
0.0694333538,
0.0400525518,
-0.0019443909,
-0.0522622503,
0.0383622423,
0.0044497857,
0.0672209337,
-0.0291382279,
-0.0413552932,
0.0213290993,
0.0207257625,
0.0147044435,
-0.0329622403,
0.0881051794,
0.0311118718,
0.0521402285,
-0.0107830856,
0.041634623,
-0.0330778249,
-0.0044153389,
0.0249403268,
-0.0047362563,
-0.005205215,
0.0183672607,
-0.003226279,
-0.0595934764,
-0.0185080972,
0.0533640161,
0.0220485218,
-0.0097019589,
0.0536894351,
0.0566109307,
-0.0122996215,
-0.0265185535,
-0.0234090369,
0.0220596548,
0.0159474388,
-0.0423846133,
-0.0420056321,
-6.19642084e-33,
-0.0326999798,
-0.0323047154,
0.0256330222,
0.0078040697,
-0.0398411602,
-0.0248643756,
-0.0757191032,
0.0208926816,
0.0109248282,
-0.0095705558,
0.0253197644,
0.0272350181,
-0.0266697146,
-0.0082506994,
0.0335396603,
0.0034198943,
0.0406867303,
-0.0123210596,
-0.0521231145,
0.0306496602,
-0.0484375507,
0.0365889482,
0.0281832106,
-0.0242213141,
0.0052245748,
0.0034796826,
0.0029429626,
0.0067017297,
-0.0190772004,
0.0210040696,
0.0036095458,
0.014432855,
-0.0077403388,
-0.0309145991,
-0.0347439088,
-0.0276205596,
-0.0057027475,
-0.0405579135,
-0.0037373295,
0.000268181,
-0.0340402685,
-0.0302088093,
0.0731412917,
-0.0068981829,
-0.0255523901,
0.0311441626,
0.0221861806,
0.0148118939,
-0.0176582411,
-0.0383315459,
-0.0673655793,
0.0067883623,
-0.0417924002,
-0.0415610634,
-0.0402226038,
0.0138041079,
-0.0326871909,
0.0227031708,
0.0119246719,
0.0024733068,
0.0497333407,
0.0547119603,
0.0445620827,
0.0228987467,
0.0319976211,
0.0236427188,
0.0219382849,
0.0214983802,
-0.0416350216,
0.0046709897,
0.0723001733,
0.0052010734,
0.0435209461,
0.0410218202,
0.0314139649,
0.0194476657,
-0.0414147489,
-0.0039722584,
-0.0414589047,
0.0166498236,
0.0092139794,
0.0137146339,
-0.0446886756,
-0.0270855669,
-0.0848750994,
-0.0232837144,
-0.0253778212,
-0.0455943495,
0.0372151397,
0.0153947985,
-0.0427796468,
-0.036988873,
0.001712624,
-0.0238101799,
-0.0015543577,
-0.0011459434,
-0.0707942992,
0.0378692821,
-0.0389292948,
0.0086760018,
-0.0425854549,
-0.0174455345,
0.0148350121,
-0.0088797417,
0.0607600361,
0.0294982567,
0.0164017193,
0.040595118,
-0.0628846958,
-0.011173591,
-0.0674700066,
-0.0049121375,
0.0443851277,
0.018776495,
0.0075550671,
0.007005495,
-0.004591817,
0.0688777044,
-0.0157968644,
-0.0661864206,
-0.0418321081,
0.0080224779,
0.0028289931,
0.0304535087,
-0.0641617179,
-0.0277623441,
-0.0462974682,
0.0183514971,
0.0124145811,
-0.057230249,
-0.0710043013,
-0.0087930663,
2.872e-7,
-0.0052303742,
0.0393943191,
0.0134580284,
0.0601235554,
-0.0214070939,
0.0598151274,
-0.0319438912,
0.0056692678,
0.0256114136,
-0.0061599459,
-0.0101877479,
0.0282749496,
0.0240693595,
0.0072067729,
-0.0675510839,
0.0393408798,
-0.0111576291,
0.0103071723,
-0.0507091582,
-0.0366829596,
0.0223567393,
0.0646942109,
0.0071371477,
0.0033933094,
0.050112538,
-0.048865702,
0.0491690375,
-0.0151476376,
-0.017862035,
0.0137074636,
-0.022647284,
0.0457909182,
-0.0140078487,
-0.0199701898,
-0.0230049621,
-0.0359636135,
-0.0117077604,
0.0462980792,
-0.011000297,
0.0428447463,
0.0325775482,
0.009533965,
0.0194754414,
-0.0443847142,
0.0339708365,
-0.0475509726,
0.02101258,
-0.039148394,
0.0228643306,
-0.0089845117,
0.0021880032,
-0.0574821271,
0.0141856009,
-0.0086769648,
0.0027050131,
0.0182990581,
-0.0105123883,
-0.0373306982,
-0.0552318022,
0.0099737011,
-0.0026441193,
-0.0158989858,
-0.0607519783,
0.0123802749,
0.0115372008,
-0.0384137705,
0.0340881571,
2.835411301e-34,
0.0284647457,
-0.0218757559,
0.034926571,
0.0432459675,
0.0727993995,
-0.0011027399,
-0.0009712605,
0.0087667117,
0.0376374982,
-0.0000436611,
-0.0528048724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16098v1 | Carolina: a General Corpus of Contemporary Brazilian Portuguese with Provenance, Typology and Versioning Information | 2023-03-28T16:09:40 | 2023-03-28T16:09:40 | Maria Clara Ramos Morales Crespo, Maria Lina de Souza Jeannine Rocha, Mariana Lourenço Sturzeneker, Felipe Ribas Serras, Guilherme Lamartine de Mello, Aline Silva Costa, Mayara Feliciano Palma, Renata Morais Mesquita, Raquel de Paula Guets, Mariana Marques da Silva, Marcelo Finger, Maria Clara Paixão de Sousa, Cristiane Namiuti, Vanessa Martins do Monte | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | This paper presents the first publicly available version of the Carolina
Corpus and discusses its future directions. Carolina is a large open corpus of
Brazilian Portuguese texts under construction using web-as-corpus methodology
enhanced with provenance, typology, versioning, and text integrality. The
corpus aims at being used both as a reliable source for research in Linguistics
and as an important resource for Computer Science research on language models,
contributing towards removing Portuguese from the set of low-resource
languages. Here we present the construction of the corpus methodology,
comparing it with other existing methodologies, as well as the corpus current
state: Carolina's first public version has $653,322,577$ tokens, distributed
over $7$ broad types. Each text is annotated with several different metadata
categories in its header, which we developed using TEI annotation standards. We
also present ongoing derivative works and invite NLP researchers to contribute
with their own. | [
0.0272270367,
0.0547021143,
-0.0472218469,
0.0272552501,
-0.0027734661,
0.0233042501,
-0.0264100824,
0.0142239574,
-0.0117188329,
-0.0872546658,
-0.0209962949,
-0.0293655898,
0.0299440846,
-0.0193524621,
0.0052847238,
-0.0252509303,
0.0246224012,
-0.0058072349,
-0.0215111356,
-0.0020739029,
0.0124378642,
0.0179121215,
0.0166525021,
0.0291686524,
0.0189967752,
-0.0057815262,
-0.0063342266,
-0.0467298813,
-0.0008456118,
0.001917456,
0.0001718309,
0.0405738205,
-0.018015638,
0.0618270747,
0.0000018631,
-0.0659803823,
-0.0510181077,
0.0202533491,
-0.0202126279,
-0.0135127893,
0.0117828809,
0.0555205084,
-0.0444417037,
0.0021189635,
-0.0710112676,
-0.0206894558,
0.0408899747,
-0.0757597238,
0.0403845757,
0.0536033101,
-0.0221507736,
-0.0321271382,
0.0157876927,
0.0034307756,
0.0017750824,
0.0493041053,
0.0195512976,
0.0099680247,
0.0301693659,
0.0267382227,
0.0473720059,
0.0226908121,
-0.016275404,
-0.0679420009,
-0.0464515574,
-0.0415257849,
-0.0262022819,
-0.0463083684,
0.0103347925,
-0.0212160479,
0.0925899819,
-0.0420434922,
0.0189413428,
0.0618182272,
0.0127357803,
0.0287548434,
-0.0772963986,
0.0501682907,
-0.0054662945,
0.004560601,
0.0744512454,
0.0264953841,
0.0231298786,
0.014197913,
0.0112638613,
0.0516700521,
0.0325155854,
-0.0005693012,
0.003910997,
-0.0130725307,
-0.0240358673,
-0.0577119961,
0.0082474714,
0.0295566749,
0.036320284,
0.0195784643,
0.0256804712,
-0.0203479771,
0.0670757443,
-0.0822654292,
-0.0309533626,
-0.0232594125,
-0.0505207367,
0.0412760526,
0.0195714217,
0.0112089626,
-0.0291006658,
-0.0540586933,
0.0078031975,
-0.031992875,
-0.0631124303,
-0.0161087066,
-0.0364835933,
0.0261079632,
-0.0386710092,
0.0486399159,
0.0159360692,
0.0237601474,
-0.0128303049,
0.0344410464,
0.0063442388,
-0.0371874012,
-0.0197033156,
-0.0036098589,
-0.0261081532,
-0.0029987595,
-0.0001670444,
-0.0061051683,
-0.0318197347,
-0.0888773873,
0.0387092195,
0.0223971028,
-0.020449847,
-0.0358099788,
-0.0239617452,
-0.0278037991,
0.0190921985,
-0.0215335097,
-0.0187248513,
-0.0533946268,
-0.0564825237,
-0.0376339145,
-0.0218645353,
-0.0785084963,
0.0037992233,
0.0112979468,
0.0374981686,
-0.0417560861,
-0.0158306863,
0.0070433388,
0.0396240838,
0.0061194762,
-0.0652830526,
-0.0668340325,
0.0165220276,
-0.0213006306,
-0.0217480883,
0.0323997512,
0.0354303159,
-0.0202644672,
0.0596700422,
0.0301389247,
-0.0407299697,
0.0197042171,
-0.0206343383,
0.0174396168,
0.0098693054,
0.0509002917,
0.0262028147,
0.0043373257,
-0.0223678723,
0.0598797351,
0.0069853198,
-0.0010185447,
0.0133546172,
0.0101994677,
-0.0053936793,
0.0444255657,
0.0317306817,
-0.0234788172,
0.0390653573,
-0.0260854624,
0.0195175949,
-0.0756572261,
0.012201095,
-0.0137727736,
-0.0447714292,
0.0323533155,
-0.0004164577,
-0.0418906324,
-0.0068985857,
-0.0255045313,
-0.0301142633,
-0.0443845466,
0.0380242094,
-0.0082687978,
0.0181067809,
-0.0161454324,
0.0179098677,
-0.0412480757,
0.0230209194,
-0.0227208976,
0.0498606227,
0.0066137682,
0.0327116325,
-0.0420981534,
0.0160085708,
-0.0211952031,
0.0418113172,
0.0339392275,
0.0047136312,
-0.0719194114,
-0.0428364798,
-0.0129626775,
0.0124222506,
-0.0037579492,
0.0404686593,
0.0273101963,
-0.0322292522,
0.0271179639,
0.0122336419,
-0.0701072142,
-0.0080839703,
0.0272551551,
-0.0201576501,
-0.0058047725,
-0.0526551008,
-0.0047666887,
0.024659358,
0.0628870055,
0.0159335528,
-0.0136855133,
0.0177554488,
-0.0152186565,
0.0024991122,
0.0650878251,
0.0492747724,
0.0474329516,
0.0477319881,
-0.0304930471,
0.031020835,
0.0171523839,
0.0476373509,
-0.025393039,
-0.0163425375,
-0.0435805656,
0.1072611287,
-0.037197154,
0.054411944,
-0.0280497484,
0.002660247,
-0.0270996355,
0.0452398211,
0.0244179256,
-0.008251369,
0.0049345535,
-0.0735713392,
0.045050066,
-0.0278059114,
-0.0346215963,
0.0267575607,
0.0090242578,
-0.0259658322,
0.0365769491,
-0.0216682646,
-0.0137979062,
-0.0038560531,
-0.0864122212,
0.0144128958,
-0.0377610661,
0.0574229881,
0.0376348607,
0.0392516367,
0.0107033895,
0.0182488784,
0.027259184,
-0.0377215035,
-0.0371787809,
0.0036400731,
0.0157995857,
0.0200270172,
0.0094512794,
-0.0437378697,
0.0422692597,
0.0244178195,
0.0711971074,
0.0129256183,
-0.0656556711,
-0.0510243624,
0.0077096047,
-0.0355209969,
0.0302439313,
-0.0120537095,
0.0033096296,
-0.0103012761,
0.0059207166,
0.0126980841,
0.0012240579,
-0.0162917282,
0.0114441644,
0.048882626,
-0.0099816769,
-0.0494769439,
-0.0390891358,
0.0170840733,
-0.0278701298,
-0.0371482261,
-0.0182238109,
0.0582805984,
0.0527807623,
-0.0149705773,
-0.0036719807,
-0.0089993775,
-0.028851239,
-0.0422944799,
0.0325437449,
0.057080809,
-0.0208455529,
-0.0482367799,
0.0250627063,
0.014507819,
-0.0070545683,
0.0313625224,
-0.0655607954,
0.0161497314,
-0.0651283786,
0.0002645326,
-0.0429298766,
0.0284282174,
-0.0149335684,
-0.0212366395,
0.0078061046,
-0.0355379954,
0.0220766068,
0.039880503,
0.058462549,
0.0027405738,
0.0066240528,
-0.0485287569,
0.0431254618,
-0.0109119155,
-0.059980467,
0.012056333,
-0.0000547577,
-0.0342160091,
0.0043922346,
0.063006036,
0.0384849869,
0.0094118314,
0.0439081788,
-0.0178325437,
0.0584289953,
0.0036250832,
-0.0101966057,
-0.0192111917,
0.0594144613,
-0.0040736203,
0.0188318882,
0.0072753057,
0.0372928306,
0.0291014072,
0.0479951911,
-0.0330771506,
-0.0105489865,
-0.021034399,
-0.0323713496,
0.0121308714,
-0.0584659614,
-0.0993525907,
-0.0450592823,
-0.0274765063,
0.0080507267,
-0.0280696582,
0.0794254541,
0.0559200048,
-0.0503420718,
0.0001337731,
-0.0502555966,
0.0114129931,
0.0159459468,
0.0047890791,
-0.1035838202,
0.0252363123,
0.0179035403,
-0.0095716109,
0.0119979298,
-0.0189773757,
0.0049680672,
-0.0590958409,
0.0216579363,
-0.0044669551,
0.0240247864,
0.044821009,
-0.0302263275,
0.0067180078,
-0.0413900763,
-0.0415224805,
0.0189230219,
0.0069846706,
0.0368677676,
0.0677840933,
0.0012441126,
-0.073288776,
-0.0399224721,
-0.0282748509,
-0.0005102642,
0.0156133771,
0.0425868705,
0.0147337532,
-0.0033418392,
0.0459960885,
-0.0211612936,
-0.0200120378,
-0.0309850182,
0.0051794793,
0.0123199914,
0.0061928048,
-0.0276314355,
0.0255121049,
0.0065998323,
-0.0157913528,
0.0548792258,
0.1037759483,
-0.0311434567,
0.0533815846,
-0.0253156088,
-0.0940521732,
-0.0062565454,
0.0089823669,
0.0174251646,
0.0079285027,
0.0089793,
-0.0285611395,
-0.0149108097,
0.0494216979,
-0.0055145798,
0.0401428975,
-0.0250428971,
-0.073339209,
-0.1133757979,
-0.0581963658,
0.0014676905,
0.0134320287,
0.0472004563,
-0.0334571637,
0.0237486977,
-0.0021429546,
-0.0754939988,
-0.0006511324,
-0.0308537148,
0.0087377829,
-0.0353963114,
-0.0213659406,
0.0384683385,
0.018505374,
-0.0271134228,
-0.0716147348,
-0.0428060703,
-0.0396816209,
0.0244092681,
0.0146330753,
0.0273950063,
-0.0011126726,
-0.0421517529,
-0.0723430514,
-0.003059139,
0.0020776053,
-0.0572662465,
-0.0085874368,
0.0151900519,
-0.0148041248,
-0.0161217637,
0.0272109285,
-0.0264757182,
-0.0351549014,
-0.0382064544,
0.0251620878,
-0.0444612987,
0.0350483619,
0.0084308758,
-0.0016756561,
0.0663964748,
-0.0419616364,
-0.0151059758,
0.0038921102,
-0.0145915607,
-0.0238603782,
-0.0019526161,
0.0024856632,
0.0600323081,
0.0014935763,
-0.0168683939,
-0.0385224707,
0.0805682242,
-0.0411617532,
0.0274019837,
0.0024603584,
0.0492345914,
0.0619196557,
0.0458354168,
-0.0186234526,
0.0352439731,
-0.0179937612,
0.0016035793,
-0.0202564243,
0.0430576764,
-0.0402384549,
-0.0384592935,
0.0143672433,
-0.0282738786,
0.0588718541,
0.0287292507,
0.0201394577,
0.0273209102,
-0.0240047537,
-0.0004182185,
0.067992188,
0.0044186651,
0.1076674834,
-0.0040212413,
-0.0251178313,
-0.0103148771,
0.0021095085,
0.0514647812,
-0.052757021,
0.0336120725,
-0.0016669321,
-0.0377387106,
0.0518414453,
0.0511634685,
-0.0434617102,
0.00693165,
0.028975036,
-0.0029786644,
-0.0257548969,
-0.0094895409,
0.0021046468,
0.0068471842,
-0.0116095906,
-0.0610879362,
-0.0730581135,
-0.0344747417,
-0.0058000442,
0.0164785832,
0.008785367,
0.0210609473,
-0.0144844381,
0.0362369679,
0.0208467059,
-0.0100580659,
-0.0538873263,
0.0250787344,
-0.0437474884,
0.0217614323,
-0.0229589529,
-4.954211675e-33,
0.0076156193,
-0.0161057319,
-0.0113176275,
0.0150033236,
0.0183934271,
-0.0134711359,
-0.0287418123,
-0.0106339771,
-0.0046805521,
-0.0049037379,
-0.0182983149,
-0.0145700574,
0.0327344649,
-0.0389761776,
0.036416959,
0.038919244,
0.0175506026,
0.0069532637,
-0.0319178663,
-0.0196687132,
0.076590538,
-0.0285336562,
0.1007693559,
-0.04227864,
0.0805243552,
-0.0367254801,
-0.0588275865,
0.0425515398,
0.0601253323,
0.0944580138,
-0.0139942458,
0.0002670321,
0.0113662174,
0.005119889,
-0.0033947683,
-0.0042537386,
-0.031052947,
-0.0349117815,
0.0624159537,
0.0566153526,
0.0821303278,
-0.0429767668,
0.0123819513,
-0.0071565458,
-0.0109233372,
0.0674273744,
0.0363481566,
-0.0558068082,
-0.0155372098,
-0.0209006295,
-0.0413358919,
0.0397256427,
-0.0066041495,
0.0098872343,
0.0451931059,
0.0710702017,
-0.0190151855,
-0.0197125152,
-0.0679621771,
0.0230320916,
-0.0236221924,
0.0344403796,
0.0240515377,
-0.0266090315,
-0.0159717854,
-0.0084216036,
-0.0222872589,
-0.0285055079,
0.0191288907,
0.0868437961,
0.0486410707,
0.0210929271,
0.0148716904,
0.0904745087,
0.0291813295,
0.02586901,
-0.0266077891,
0.0194547009,
0.0038996171,
0.0118932677,
-0.0488998331,
-0.0153387599,
-0.0197864231,
-0.0071530761,
-0.0473451242,
-0.0207719877,
0.0120026749,
0.0029939204,
-0.0111128297,
-0.0594090857,
-0.0133101465,
0.0320262872,
0.0067225746,
-0.028392259,
-0.0676575527,
0.0133689269,
-0.0392816551,
0.0632894039,
0.0098299803,
0.027962219,
-0.026216805,
0.009941712,
-0.0155415637,
0.0408929214,
0.0051259445,
-0.0036236285,
0.0210890099,
0.0094057331,
-0.044409126,
0.0028988114,
-0.018580487,
0.0027224428,
-0.024614621,
0.0179668069,
0.0293331817,
0.0201216266,
0.038104713,
0.0393939577,
0.0252559036,
0.0159255695,
-0.0381406695,
0.0333510228,
0.0257987753,
-0.0069781886,
0.0045572375,
-0.0014504298,
0.015607398,
0.1059585959,
0.017158702,
-0.0080431597,
0.0256723352,
-0.0233232453,
2.538e-7,
0.0280425623,
0.0282932315,
0.0314927325,
-0.0093882708,
0.0374069512,
-0.0030915635,
0.0204605702,
0.0049160756,
-0.0403223857,
0.0040284004,
0.000851423,
-0.0549730808,
0.0732517242,
0.060612414,
-0.0706229284,
-0.0408235155,
-0.0239574183,
-0.0556984842,
-0.0681618378,
-0.0017795403,
-0.0173976943,
0.0522107668,
0.0408133827,
0.0165756326,
-0.0574081242,
0.0030540647,
0.0480253249,
-0.0075487872,
0.0025877168,
0.0207458399,
0.0411341786,
0.0084015848,
-0.0160388779,
-0.0371017903,
0.0030960385,
0.0335229561,
-0.06280642,
0.0237776749,
0.0012840633,
0.0613384843,
0.0017742182,
-0.0937817842,
-0.0079537677,
-0.036568936,
0.0373178385,
0.0412766337,
-0.0059914282,
-0.0282521416,
-0.0403878316,
-0.026336614,
-0.0106868334,
-0.0112679517,
-0.0365698226,
0.0312695242,
-0.0082492996,
-0.0395049602,
-0.0236024838,
-0.0466663167,
-0.0228632651,
0.0134860501,
-0.0475890301,
-0.0376882628,
0.0147239417,
0.0255299918,
0.0062533584,
-0.0364721864,
0.0619760193,
1.960548023e-34,
-0.0069673411,
-0.0169390608,
0.0171659626,
0.0294893999,
0.0361302979,
-0.0006039787,
0.0202956386,
0.012313853,
0.0091091329,
-0.0119067123,
-0.0020353456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16028v1 | Synthetically generated text for supervised text analysis | 2023-03-28T14:55:13 | 2023-03-28T14:55:13 | Andrew Halterman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised text models are a valuable tool for political scientists but
present several obstacles to their use, including the expense of hand-labeling
documents, the difficulty of retrieving rare relevant documents for annotation,
and copyright and privacy concerns involved in sharing annotated documents.
This article proposes a partial solution to these three issues, in the form of
controlled generation of synthetic text with large language models. I provide a
conceptual overview of text generation, guidance on when researchers should
prefer different techniques for generating synthetic text, a discussion of
ethics, and a simple technique for improving the quality of synthetic text. I
demonstrate the usefulness of synthetic text with three applications:
generating synthetic tweets describing the fighting in Ukraine, synthetic news
articles describing specified political events for training an event detection
system, and a multilingual corpus of populist manifesto statements for training
a sentence-level populism classifier. | [
0.0408764593,
0.0614689887,
0.0004878231,
0.018942127,
-0.0488968194,
0.0019355459,
0.0340332165,
-0.0034126285,
0.0603937209,
-0.0696240515,
0.0642528012,
-0.0279593598,
-0.0622139536,
0.0491124578,
0.0039971638,
-0.056664113,
0.0297742877,
0.0098534403,
0.0307844486,
-0.0261405688,
0.0112166833,
0.0430611819,
0.0153393522,
0.0181337576,
-0.0496860966,
0.0277893879,
-0.0175421908,
-0.0247659031,
0.0254580677,
0.0188262109,
0.0060232258,
0.0393809229,
0.0098428,
0.0549577698,
0.0000017153,
-0.0079140579,
-0.0465460792,
-0.0121720843,
0.046751868,
-0.0163988639,
0.111466229,
-0.0218563378,
-0.0353119932,
0.0091999732,
-0.0538236424,
0.0235247742,
0.0195795912,
0.0296201389,
0.0621980093,
0.1111729369,
-0.0288445894,
-0.0284962598,
0.0101473602,
0.0030579662,
0.013640142,
0.0115756141,
0.0347988121,
-0.0167062618,
-0.0137413489,
0.0698149875,
0.0532995239,
0.0227823686,
0.0111980839,
-0.020591462,
-0.0012636472,
0.0077597736,
-0.0594168827,
-0.0311422143,
0.0011642866,
-0.0040730285,
0.0047232867,
-0.0680468231,
0.0803421661,
-0.0059086662,
0.0006029423,
0.0284234807,
-0.0061524175,
0.0496495776,
-0.0567018352,
0.0376894623,
0.0614794157,
-0.0151651828,
-0.0115762427,
0.0277824309,
0.009060801,
0.0144192297,
-0.0081373537,
-0.039122697,
-0.0167322997,
-0.0091617238,
0.000434372,
-0.0520164035,
0.0459673777,
-0.0163524058,
0.0120718917,
0.0152753303,
-0.099566035,
-0.0744879469,
0.0239236616,
-0.1016106978,
-0.0259847119,
-0.0037799473,
0.0331411213,
0.0527177043,
0.0129868509,
-0.0302308481,
-0.0200223029,
0.0179739967,
-0.0146381427,
-0.0259029064,
-0.045657821,
-0.0021401534,
-0.0245144088,
0.0160079021,
-0.0548020042,
-0.0090905931,
-0.0339862034,
0.0139697138,
0.0112641873,
0.0217334591,
-0.0338056125,
0.0086925235,
-0.0326774865,
-0.0032803756,
-0.024962604,
-0.0423213691,
-0.0209323056,
0.0297681037,
-0.0401982851,
-0.0107673062,
0.0336002633,
0.0513879918,
0.013700028,
0.0195904095,
0.0037217175,
0.0394031815,
-0.0348026417,
0.0219492652,
-0.0397536345,
-0.032084424,
-0.0058865342,
-0.0164538305,
0.0366217196,
-0.0709487572,
0.0193336047,
-0.0094672143,
-0.0094978893,
-0.0283065885,
0.0289330874,
0.0394023843,
-0.0293879602,
0.038094338,
-0.0242358446,
0.0082464311,
0.0399963595,
-0.0133902328,
0.0259811543,
0.0703923702,
0.0370515473,
0.0683296248,
0.0511603765,
-0.0078682182,
0.0506948717,
0.0308335628,
0.0075901616,
0.0335591212,
-0.0418658294,
-0.0073928437,
0.0084765749,
-0.0213741418,
-0.0087065985,
0.0574106872,
0.0209642239,
0.0111316396,
0.055890996,
0.0357130766,
-0.0054880683,
0.0239219815,
0.054963354,
0.0221972726,
-0.0139166825,
0.0181615073,
0.0289194696,
-0.0140827289,
-0.0130025139,
-0.0269759335,
0.0110504469,
0.0276436936,
-0.0085050873,
-0.0225698967,
0.014826023,
-0.001126847,
-0.0025249973,
-0.0400328115,
0.0217734352,
0.0143133374,
-0.0351627097,
-0.0027451576,
0.0359484442,
-0.0673820451,
0.0408501588,
-0.0228670649,
0.0192180499,
0.0837300569,
0.0257459357,
-0.0471385755,
0.0592665337,
-0.0474413931,
0.0412197076,
0.0843623579,
0.0463384055,
-0.0354399756,
-0.0506194159,
-0.0439291522,
-0.0112365074,
-0.0219009817,
0.0247096121,
0.0253626555,
0.0300263409,
0.0222044103,
0.0131146591,
-0.025479611,
-0.0600777902,
0.0396838188,
-0.0128241098,
-0.0264839586,
0.0146524999,
0.0021462885,
0.0088155419,
0.0478258058,
-0.0165974703,
-0.0073413975,
0.0453681089,
-0.0183309484,
-0.0466931574,
-0.0121814432,
0.0315916575,
0.0257490128,
-0.0111051677,
-0.0573508441,
-0.0137570743,
0.0276448317,
-0.0395708382,
-0.0043808469,
0.0330119394,
-0.0105064409,
0.0022639721,
-0.0539404452,
-0.0017012096,
-0.030593697,
-0.0097399782,
-0.0375474878,
0.0763751343,
0.0006413771,
0.0204745121,
-0.0004180662,
-0.0208963361,
0.0254810173,
0.0065071955,
0.0001266821,
0.0157348551,
-0.0020450952,
0.0421053804,
0.0189145356,
-0.0361177213,
-0.0103224367,
-0.0813578218,
-0.0454076417,
0.0131122982,
-0.0350430086,
0.0186277088,
0.0556496158,
-0.0154917883,
-0.01441292,
0.0185735542,
-0.0357927121,
-0.0542263091,
0.0035821255,
-0.0029894833,
0.0230489019,
-0.0189403854,
0.0015909449,
-0.0078529269,
0.0165857021,
-0.024903059,
0.0434952825,
0.0558961518,
-0.0504256785,
-0.0220904928,
0.0174145587,
-0.0081038214,
0.0341720507,
-0.0397981219,
-0.029117411,
0.0005585288,
0.0049440223,
0.0452670828,
0.0406272076,
0.0606284849,
0.0459848307,
0.0368171595,
0.0329316333,
-0.0179920457,
-0.0230706707,
-0.0634195134,
0.008882734,
-0.0201851744,
-0.0714173317,
0.0401931703,
0.0144651048,
0.029383162,
0.0122495396,
-0.0511768125,
0.0261479113,
-0.0235825162,
-0.0321708322,
0.001859593,
-0.0103993798,
-0.0155624347,
-0.0030227727,
-0.0100544337,
-0.0211348627,
0.0195991639,
-0.0078323763,
0.0647706166,
-0.059957996,
-0.0446956716,
-0.0235545542,
0.0493988805,
0.0053984975,
0.0092142727,
0.0141979875,
0.031972792,
0.0019361358,
-0.0082152849,
0.0469104871,
-0.0342717133,
-0.0179613549,
-0.0351923257,
0.0195015334,
-0.0120401392,
0.0036900267,
-0.044816833,
-0.1198282316,
0.0211991146,
-0.001735172,
0.0428469144,
-0.0004533439,
-0.0217209067,
0.0001712814,
0.0479800142,
0.0553880073,
0.0109591847,
0.0155847203,
-0.0152959367,
0.0473282412,
-0.0016731992,
-0.0845067427,
-0.0423063636,
-0.0192252994,
-0.0341265015,
0.0287259482,
0.0097119408,
0.0295099374,
-0.001297862,
-0.0403275788,
-0.0185658056,
-0.0198360905,
-0.0154476557,
-0.0265747029,
0.0054233945,
-0.0314885117,
0.0332690328,
0.0548851341,
0.0350008234,
-0.0136546586,
-0.0099677332,
0.0176814776,
0.0039976365,
0.013879614,
0.0136061823,
-0.0870026499,
0.0538352504,
0.0044424976,
0.0154509721,
-0.0766517669,
-0.0357108004,
-0.0159391686,
-0.0938974246,
0.0090593239,
0.0099700931,
-0.0332877114,
-0.0133294147,
-0.0435664207,
-0.0142204575,
0.0063956771,
-0.0918371752,
-0.0105380807,
0.0073969066,
0.013889865,
0.0395195633,
-0.0379255004,
-0.074686639,
-0.0455203243,
-0.0138309337,
0.0302075408,
0.0163013637,
0.0522363782,
-0.001576663,
-0.0038937631,
0.0320890434,
-0.0106573347,
-0.0238839369,
0.0144964065,
0.0773771778,
-0.0063654725,
-0.0342179649,
-0.0094216252,
0.0754159614,
0.0422902778,
-0.0271280408,
0.0236798227,
0.038205035,
-0.0155820698,
-0.0273406766,
-0.0188951902,
0.0150809698,
0.0853906795,
0.0357153118,
0.0083091902,
-0.0367494375,
-0.0094722705,
-0.0431110337,
0.0251626484,
-0.0957888886,
-0.0198712982,
0.0219894201,
-0.0502555482,
-0.0720603615,
-0.058526177,
-0.0407417044,
-0.003186197,
0.028322801,
0.0133998934,
0.0076954691,
0.0118936449,
-0.0407450572,
-0.0255474988,
0.0047152857,
-0.0319281667,
0.0049339547,
0.0022191103,
-0.0870622247,
-0.0088171447,
0.0024161069,
-0.0040484932,
0.0146807674,
-0.022665862,
-0.0683488026,
0.0489980914,
-0.0150970062,
0.0192434061,
0.0245376881,
0.0134335514,
-0.0177195575,
0.0589544773,
0.0885195732,
-0.0398741998,
0.0049155634,
0.0175922215,
0.0140337097,
0.0119364904,
0.0113707064,
-0.0121962605,
0.0395951867,
0.018683847,
-0.0363411903,
-0.0711921304,
0.0167499091,
0.0172575023,
-0.0063053751,
0.0103071453,
-0.0364583805,
-0.0292085148,
-0.0574967675,
-0.0089763701,
-0.0471903794,
-0.0328830928,
-0.0072700074,
0.0123788491,
0.0075481138,
-0.004301446,
-0.0220371746,
0.0464572348,
-0.0583806112,
0.0377702564,
-0.0295408554,
0.0026998792,
-0.003506769,
0.064694114,
0.0203229301,
-0.0189737417,
-0.0283935424,
0.0303669609,
-0.0250441823,
0.0140296705,
0.0007794145,
-0.0257201381,
0.0227432307,
-0.0164628699,
0.0340739153,
-0.0131676812,
-0.0504579321,
-0.0160602871,
-0.0634920374,
0.0490419231,
0.0176817458,
-0.0064737028,
0.0259714741,
-0.0410179161,
-0.025926549,
0.0054318542,
0.0275146551,
0.0313021205,
-0.0527797714,
-0.0166208055,
-0.018259855,
-0.0599191301,
0.0094194217,
0.0446494147,
0.0254325364,
0.0430579931,
0.0435622148,
-0.0312421098,
-0.0463498756,
-0.0226727985,
0.0094258506,
-0.012189216,
-0.0036682747,
-0.0258502718,
-0.0698087513,
-0.0055550607,
0.0443754382,
0.0399072878,
-0.0243364144,
0.0117680589,
0.0137412604,
0.0477585569,
-0.0248496383,
0.0811656415,
-0.0701882094,
0.0575625636,
-0.0101984274,
-0.0359124318,
0.0239892509,
-5.791015981e-33,
0.0088872146,
-0.0556872189,
0.0099873394,
0.003546312,
-0.0033113847,
0.0064498507,
-0.0185175966,
-0.0126406746,
0.0287858471,
0.0182137378,
0.0039396202,
-0.0143293655,
0.0208318084,
0.0175415445,
-0.0171194356,
-0.0073766327,
0.0358772017,
-0.0145593546,
-0.0196833219,
0.0255217068,
0.0923873037,
-0.0056001996,
0.0468529537,
-0.1015290245,
0.0363713615,
-0.0235307999,
-0.0310268272,
-0.0349169113,
0.0140434392,
0.01565638,
-0.0344277658,
0.0295879636,
0.0277105477,
-0.0213750415,
0.0022428446,
0.0781063661,
0.0022619106,
-0.0058310814,
0.006585951,
-0.0183385089,
0.0159767866,
-0.0505821556,
0.0225900821,
-0.0184586793,
0.0031381585,
0.0447257422,
0.0614648014,
-0.0232404135,
0.0134971989,
-0.0596752875,
-0.0610358678,
0.0400455892,
-0.0015864746,
0.0192646757,
-0.018541107,
0.0603480227,
0.0478865057,
0.0468309447,
-0.0334270895,
0.0541264676,
-0.0187112913,
-0.0015009363,
0.026453767,
-0.0207900312,
0.0270142183,
0.0747792572,
0.0011501299,
0.0403761789,
-0.0626082569,
0.0042245253,
0.0044533061,
0.0087986579,
0.0639196411,
0.1438065469,
0.0242612995,
-0.0757634863,
-0.0721300691,
0.0235938113,
0.0054575833,
-0.0545211136,
0.0164721608,
-0.0231375434,
0.005211419,
-0.022185076,
-0.0408122055,
-0.0541551672,
-0.0153678749,
0.0226132069,
-0.0225966908,
0.0278913379,
-0.0571183898,
0.0207266565,
0.0036354235,
-0.0102967722,
-0.0010979549,
0.0086873341,
-0.0483892411,
0.0287253968,
-0.0204120092,
0.013322155,
-0.0562569723,
-0.0433009863,
0.0373015739,
0.0222186111,
0.0322089046,
-0.0012561104,
0.012277279,
0.0128282355,
-0.047063183,
0.0380266458,
-0.0035364947,
0.0692143589,
0.0058474042,
-0.0082365843,
0.0143875694,
0.0114336256,
0.0178542696,
-0.015624403,
0.0174404271,
0.0062623275,
0.0175065193,
-0.0208349992,
-0.0233433023,
0.0369976908,
-0.0215622447,
0.025320854,
-0.0329843536,
0.0570830069,
0.0449182428,
-0.052463524,
0.0089242784,
-0.0062974147,
2.455e-7,
0.0425100587,
0.0219335705,
0.0086390832,
-0.0360566154,
0.0018723302,
0.0415271483,
0.0322027579,
0.050183069,
-0.0624360591,
-0.0678664371,
-0.0284951925,
-0.0125752892,
0.050087098,
0.0548795611,
-0.0872722417,
-0.0287143346,
-0.0419653431,
0.0066043837,
-0.1024043113,
0.0390101112,
0.034469489,
0.0304055493,
0.0532757416,
-0.0086546168,
-0.0358999893,
-0.0057460428,
0.0539257415,
-0.0138707161,
-0.0770130232,
0.0248827208,
0.0313062407,
-0.0159416422,
-0.0033633232,
0.0333834104,
-0.0237640906,
-0.0158464219,
-0.0123953531,
0.067317754,
0.0307651013,
0.0080437083,
0.0122395912,
-0.075220719,
-0.0269101467,
-0.0337458514,
0.0584342033,
-0.0158983916,
-0.0148860849,
-0.0404098071,
-0.0322686993,
0.0031431469,
0.019650232,
-0.0236160215,
-0.0151431439,
0.019019613,
-0.0192458779,
0.025352871,
0.0099552665,
-0.0288522094,
-0.0040572411,
-0.0235895235,
-0.0595404506,
-0.0216754843,
-0.0017814653,
0.03278476,
0.0449586995,
-0.0150919715,
0.0751729831,
2.207291405e-34,
0.0247429032,
0.0115045067,
-0.0554309823,
-0.0378551334,
0.0128991213,
0.0154778771,
0.0088392431,
0.0065123728,
-0.0156760383,
-0.0253744721,
0.0091135241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15987v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15987v2 | Sentiment Analysis Dataset in Moroccan Dialect: Bridging the Gap Between Arabic and Latin Scripted dialect | 2023-03-28T14:02:42 | 2023-11-06T18:38:55 | Mouad Jbel, Imad Hafidi, Abdulmutallib Metrane | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis, the automated process of determining emotions or opinions
expressed in text, has seen extensive exploration in the field of natural
language processing. However, one aspect that has remained underrepresented is
the sentiment analysis of the Moroccan dialect, which boasts a unique
linguistic landscape and the coexistence of multiple scripts. Previous works in
sentiment analysis primarily targeted dialects employing Arabic script. While
these efforts provided valuable insights, they may not fully capture the
complexity of Moroccan web content, which features a blend of Arabic and Latin
script. As a result, our study emphasizes the importance of extending sentiment
analysis to encompass the entire spectrum of Moroccan linguistic diversity.
Central to our research is the creation of the largest public dataset for
Moroccan dialect sentiment analysis that incorporates not only Moroccan dialect
written in Arabic script but also in Latin letters. By assembling a diverse
range of textual data, we were able to construct a dataset with a range of 20
000 manually labeled text in Moroccan dialect and also publicly available lists
of stop words in Moroccan dialect. To dive into sentiment analysis, we
conducted a comparative study on multiple Machine learning models to assess
their compatibility with our dataset. Experiments were performed using both raw
and preprocessed data to show the importance of the preprocessing step. We were
able to achieve 92% accuracy in our model and to further prove its liability we
tested our model on smaller publicly available datasets of Moroccan dialect and
the results were favorable. | [
0.0283258874,
0.0793329626,
-0.0136601143,
0.0142435031,
-0.0331026465,
0.0329911113,
-0.009850096,
-0.0202683453,
0.0072122822,
-0.0263845157,
-0.013728518,
-0.0684537441,
0.0386788249,
0.0044330196,
-0.0128948437,
-0.0036795812,
-0.0036223652,
0.0199012123,
0.032916598,
-0.0028210499,
0.0595818758,
0.0563420504,
-0.010479643,
0.0288296361,
-0.0290004592,
-0.0158387758,
-0.0260922965,
-0.0210772622,
0.0166879967,
0.0488262288,
0.0190736149,
0.0480717383,
-0.0415959805,
0.0307519957,
0.0000019964,
-0.0252966043,
-0.0125448136,
-0.0365074798,
0.0406022668,
-0.0162198544,
0.0951558501,
-0.031530235,
-0.0514457822,
0.0242599398,
-0.0236682612,
-0.0137936817,
0.0739304423,
0.004735291,
0.0612968542,
0.0572026409,
-0.0196841098,
-0.0535481758,
-0.0354264565,
0.0024916816,
0.0052429074,
0.0026655796,
-0.0107996399,
-0.029418271,
-0.0298323929,
-0.0440880656,
-0.0192254838,
0.0038441827,
-0.0422908068,
-0.026046209,
-0.030340001,
-0.0408883579,
-0.0603527464,
-0.0526279882,
0.0356118865,
0.0067525315,
-0.0123227406,
-0.0124214012,
-0.0099947685,
0.0180253405,
-0.0161021575,
0.0021184837,
0.0080524106,
0.0320330784,
-0.0246535484,
0.051623404,
0.0187484231,
0.0587036274,
0.0124278897,
0.023238061,
-0.0436742567,
0.0673415512,
-0.0274649765,
-0.0176812168,
0.0602028221,
0.0562350303,
0.0079757357,
0.0088413879,
0.0155793428,
-0.0145516386,
0.0057093394,
-0.0034119538,
0.0158839598,
-0.0130527206,
0.0328418277,
-0.0840399712,
0.022369558,
0.0276855975,
-0.0443892665,
0.0164189711,
-0.0305837132,
-0.0203204136,
0.0374471955,
-0.0020442205,
0.0000018941,
0.0009318339,
-0.0678348318,
0.0231256578,
0.034095332,
0.030796811,
-0.0288523138,
0.0595017932,
-0.0620735213,
0.0070753568,
-0.0302429684,
0.033871714,
0.0170114469,
-0.0356373489,
0.04207379,
-0.0079337321,
-0.0337217934,
0.0259534735,
-0.0223289821,
0.0318050496,
-0.0892510936,
-0.0675810948,
0.0738206506,
0.0207563378,
-0.000535636,
0.0365186706,
0.0225385372,
0.0604051687,
0.0165504217,
-0.0326727368,
-0.0471270755,
0.0234439503,
-0.018377535,
-0.0622064061,
-0.038916748,
-0.0675216392,
0.0576823652,
0.022237435,
-0.0115813678,
0.0213640593,
0.0003994819,
0.0295256693,
0.0185860377,
0.0462675169,
0.0020437818,
0.0078039584,
0.0542712472,
0.0032370545,
0.0330412015,
0.0481506996,
-0.0174719244,
0.0233380534,
0.0326846577,
0.0048071365,
0.0059130392,
0.0071978411,
-0.0006822745,
-0.022215493,
-0.0486254692,
-0.014036254,
-0.0042351102,
0.0019404234,
-0.0236646589,
0.0345122032,
0.0241165757,
-0.0168296471,
0.0228286479,
-0.0085841687,
-0.0416572206,
0.0351660512,
-0.0170513876,
0.0558438897,
0.0578815602,
-0.016513899,
0.0271223001,
-0.0261633117,
0.0097174747,
-0.0327413231,
0.0110608162,
0.0646430925,
-0.0433940031,
-0.0786234066,
-0.0318756886,
-0.0235163271,
0.0561233051,
-0.0098807383,
0.0733924806,
-0.0246473886,
-0.0369572863,
-0.0661447197,
0.04549665,
-0.0691748857,
-0.0165382549,
-0.0473138615,
0.0174899939,
0.0464771688,
-0.0368866809,
-0.0093323309,
0.0088413181,
-0.0396898985,
-0.0048178267,
0.0108793704,
0.0092411591,
-0.0112109259,
0.0068061799,
-0.0634936541,
0.0292905364,
0.0271840617,
0.0125545003,
0.0061892159,
-0.0211059898,
0.0756642744,
-0.0290421601,
0.0143427029,
-0.0272184331,
0.0052924249,
0.0234795026,
0.0165150538,
-0.0275872704,
0.0338852182,
0.0235983841,
0.0356572121,
-0.0330829509,
-0.0306915101,
0.000241783,
-0.014044079,
-0.0382065736,
0.0347128883,
0.0185821168,
-0.0268531051,
0.0144452769,
-0.0346720628,
-0.0082395133,
0.0072938739,
-0.024736803,
-0.009565494,
0.0658171028,
-0.0277367048,
0.0392416716,
-0.0108351428,
0.0211156905,
-0.0581869222,
0.0081334626,
0.0043921284,
0.0639597401,
-0.0118889976,
-0.0127394376,
-0.0304832812,
-0.0500585362,
0.0394788161,
0.0646742806,
-0.0545112081,
0.0293598082,
0.0042178929,
0.0334743522,
0.0371400043,
-0.0004695716,
-0.0021692878,
-0.0557844229,
-0.078344278,
-0.0397285037,
-0.0095981527,
0.0339251049,
-0.0249452591,
0.0173950065,
-0.0119496426,
0.02471097,
-0.034285482,
-0.0408988781,
-0.001838753,
-0.0010176837,
0.0306122806,
0.0005391259,
0.0278284773,
-0.0562805124,
0.0009176964,
0.024268603,
0.0277460571,
0.0176744163,
-0.029105857,
0.041581925,
-0.0006686921,
-0.0423631221,
0.0103040496,
0.0038192149,
-0.0477168262,
0.0251113139,
-0.0153185762,
-0.0158849731,
-0.0134805283,
-0.0061806324,
0.0301775914,
0.0132462364,
0.0097642001,
-0.0201351773,
0.011938368,
-0.0297044814,
-0.0226406194,
-0.0326584615,
-0.0664548799,
-0.0200109947,
0.0412873551,
0.0202619042,
-0.0074617304,
-0.051308725,
0.0024741008,
-0.0297259055,
0.0220727734,
0.002991477,
0.0196468513,
0.0271795355,
0.0686333328,
0.0198267438,
-0.0355513245,
0.0371161886,
0.0154648023,
0.0070175813,
-0.0505019426,
0.0013786908,
-0.0527675524,
0.0048302975,
-0.0262496751,
0.0118963029,
-0.0184300095,
-0.0003952551,
0.0058753663,
-0.0437265523,
0.0026748606,
-0.0137373637,
0.0151636265,
0.0049936236,
-0.0008204163,
0.0139652761,
-0.0416538864,
0.0077796113,
-0.0180900563,
-0.0635968596,
-0.0508065447,
0.0772315264,
-0.0065527977,
0.0135797635,
0.0005365048,
-0.0182967093,
-0.0244005024,
0.0105633745,
-0.0101279542,
0.036601495,
-0.0361265764,
-0.0054042903,
-0.04300512,
0.0273797214,
0.0184271764,
0.0195670817,
0.0361959003,
-0.0368172005,
-0.0234274771,
-0.0354876965,
-0.016292315,
0.0254058056,
0.003116966,
-0.03461124,
-0.065591149,
-0.0231629256,
-0.0345083475,
0.0517088026,
0.0798584819,
0.0314371847,
-0.0294272434,
-0.0008590281,
-0.0222157482,
-0.0181153286,
0.0090651484,
-0.0095930714,
-0.0708543286,
0.0057887058,
0.0196935609,
0.0317866132,
-0.0197671223,
0.0211887751,
0.0560295992,
-0.1038340926,
0.0106912544,
-0.0179072171,
-0.0297059566,
-0.0454417877,
-0.0321313329,
0.0000123208,
-0.0503594503,
-0.0410380326,
-0.0773389116,
0.0022218246,
0.0247592367,
0.0441158861,
-0.0433862247,
-0.0712505132,
0.0044379951,
0.0035502708,
0.0052551841,
0.0144980354,
0.0574554205,
-0.0439534783,
-0.0377761461,
-0.0164920557,
-0.0249324534,
-0.0226891451,
-0.0269788988,
0.0589009635,
0.0070405491,
-0.0479882024,
-0.0455318168,
-0.0317951925,
-0.0644158944,
0.0402771086,
-0.0269796569,
0.0263361223,
-0.0252892394,
0.0017118432,
-0.0256992579,
0.0456603803,
0.0007011028,
0.0200230069,
-0.0215767305,
-0.0801870078,
-0.0185648948,
0.0049938397,
-0.0203198455,
-0.0250097476,
-0.0543857478,
-0.0089968815,
0.0512745492,
-0.0285999421,
-0.0736557022,
-0.0607470125,
-0.0233459193,
-0.0043210597,
0.0034892715,
0.0107902838,
0.0092241224,
0.0208708327,
-0.0244549327,
-0.0064815534,
0.0747393221,
-0.0066561978,
-0.0314805694,
-0.048536431,
0.0327018313,
-0.0383268259,
0.0186399128,
-0.0411496162,
-0.0544182286,
-0.0173408817,
0.0149311312,
0.0034173415,
0.0146505767,
-0.0179341827,
-0.0076839179,
-0.0526782088,
0.0020270452,
0.0011842764,
-0.0040917066,
-0.0170205142,
0.0769106373,
0.0448878258,
-0.0150189521,
0.0364963897,
0.0442621559,
0.0400022343,
-0.013452718,
-0.0745624378,
-0.028548196,
-0.032577157,
-0.0203448199,
-0.0321038291,
0.0241695419,
-0.0185483489,
-0.0462751538,
-0.0237514153,
-0.0115482407,
-0.001575619,
0.0118437307,
-0.014219909,
-0.02145903,
0.0297692511,
0.0429641828,
-0.0586568229,
-0.014655197,
-0.0156079987,
-0.0266069435,
0.0022674084,
0.0935730562,
0.0433279611,
0.0560303517,
0.0026801783,
0.0478168875,
0.0076585482,
-0.0285294019,
-0.0009189032,
0.007322839,
-0.0210636798,
-0.0289700329,
-0.0006229372,
0.0116316052,
0.0364335552,
0.0324427858,
0.053777419,
-0.0173082054,
-0.0131796291,
0.0596274361,
0.0249575377,
-0.0534112677,
0.0461552963,
-0.0076660765,
0.0105245812,
-0.0032837128,
0.0211487859,
-0.0095822038,
-0.013285771,
-0.0051255575,
-0.0265749395,
-0.0420604721,
0.0037044529,
0.0345258564,
-0.0614556633,
0.0167935528,
0.0430806614,
-0.0173839685,
-0.0240294747,
0.0197823569,
0.0521797203,
-0.0299791098,
-0.014689127,
0.0271349344,
-0.0756057426,
-0.0745461583,
0.0569672137,
-0.0483848378,
0.0245090388,
0.0205211602,
0.0178584978,
0.0427511707,
0.0209042113,
0.0784851462,
-0.0649472922,
0.0316112041,
-0.0428897887,
-0.0307444464,
0.0013161963,
-5.943617556e-33,
0.0293471459,
0.0049616629,
-0.0497805998,
0.0422176272,
0.0386011489,
-0.0232052244,
0.0087282369,
0.0407935455,
-0.0191882737,
0.0468584038,
-0.0332922079,
0.0184831414,
0.0184780862,
0.0119266408,
0.0609273054,
-0.0277220327,
0.0174981114,
-0.0413941927,
-0.0181609988,
0.0120787239,
0.0466159433,
0.0315634497,
0.0689602494,
-0.1073932126,
0.0501429886,
-0.0268213321,
-0.0750052333,
-0.0161642507,
0.0324048363,
0.0682571232,
-0.0231183022,
0.10433916,
0.0140872085,
0.0038449098,
0.028112052,
0.0165449921,
0.0107519748,
0.0021139039,
-0.0153298415,
0.0750130266,
-0.0077876402,
-0.0185062401,
-0.0401521996,
0.0130289355,
-0.0734505728,
0.0496870205,
0.0288764294,
-0.0357578732,
0.0362515375,
-0.0486165844,
-0.0728326887,
0.0481849611,
0.0139362682,
-0.0125503186,
0.0751026347,
0.1004128531,
0.0007953955,
0.0142878853,
-0.0618098639,
0.0203737374,
-0.0234363303,
-0.0028579775,
0.0193197262,
-0.0326831341,
-0.0355504192,
0.0644725934,
0.0202704966,
-0.0201136768,
0.025820883,
0.082227625,
0.0236661732,
-0.0167239923,
0.0051479009,
0.0758657008,
0.0021222902,
-0.0244921464,
-0.0505682305,
0.0281599779,
0.020619927,
-0.007905337,
0.0394867286,
-0.0233853646,
-0.0627728254,
-0.0054925615,
0.0375772491,
-0.0495778881,
0.0088213515,
0.0086697759,
-0.0315089859,
-0.0433236174,
-0.0111883888,
0.0092657795,
-0.0256842133,
-0.0412087366,
-0.0190811064,
0.0301289223,
-0.0791249499,
0.0425381772,
0.0176204313,
0.0155892912,
-0.0403843224,
0.0019180491,
-0.0254420284,
0.0506185591,
0.0303465389,
0.0024490184,
0.0514438972,
0.0615153797,
-0.097395286,
0.0198415779,
-0.0064249467,
0.0589123741,
0.006607289,
0.120990023,
-0.0105972271,
-0.0155909257,
-0.0115763815,
0.0378895178,
-0.0037603874,
0.0469003282,
0.0199553259,
-0.0281623192,
-0.0240179095,
-0.0290063526,
-0.0277361237,
-0.0057254671,
-0.0137268137,
-0.0223644953,
-0.0230117422,
-0.0375079811,
0.0018151242,
-0.0341685489,
2.76e-7,
0.0536143333,
0.0323321223,
-0.01423789,
-0.0340771079,
0.0079560811,
0.0444814786,
-0.0022970282,
0.0031467418,
-0.0104829492,
0.0213232394,
0.0042760083,
-0.0104807895,
0.0731084645,
0.0296440292,
-0.0784942359,
0.001355001,
-0.0008803656,
0.0121888556,
0.0026054801,
0.0348464362,
0.0474600755,
0.1505080909,
0.0068611451,
-0.0311266575,
-0.0524924733,
0.0352137424,
0.0472972952,
-0.0470048264,
-0.0007454953,
0.0229946394,
0.0171997454,
-0.0086085321,
-0.0222087726,
-0.0174024403,
-0.0244829934,
0.0068475963,
0.0281171314,
0.0472107604,
0.0355153307,
0.0171859954,
0.0461840257,
0.00479582,
-0.0164825581,
-0.0252749454,
0.0350497179,
0.0083281342,
-0.0439808406,
-0.0476201512,
0.0219722521,
0.0050152126,
0.0909439847,
-0.0141651072,
-0.0087688137,
0.0229802337,
0.0140861329,
-0.0653856173,
-0.0409464464,
-0.0260434616,
-0.005952334,
0.0243759677,
0.002750484,
0.0091541922,
0.048371926,
0.02403282,
0.0311521236,
0.0157078896,
0.0442534126,
2.109536422e-34,
0.0384471193,
-0.0236362107,
-0.0116790254,
-0.0006314455,
0.0133925211,
0.0016603832,
-0.0476602577,
-0.0041310526,
0.001317383,
0.0243960917,
0.0229898822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15973v1 | Do Neural Topic Models Really Need Dropout? Analysis of the Effect of Dropout in Topic Modeling | 2023-03-28T13:45:39 | 2023-03-28T13:45:39 | Suman Adhya, Avishek Lahiri, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Dropout is a widely used regularization trick to resolve the overfitting
issue in large feedforward neural networks trained on a small dataset, which
performs poorly on the held-out test subset. Although the effectiveness of this
regularization trick has been extensively studied for convolutional neural
networks, there is a lack of analysis of it for unsupervised models and in
particular, VAE-based neural topic models. In this paper, we have analyzed the
consequences of dropout in the encoder as well as in the decoder of the VAE
architecture in three widely used neural topic models, namely, contextualized
topic model (CTM), ProdLDA, and embedded topic model (ETM) using four publicly
available datasets. We characterize the dropout effect on these models in terms
of the quality and predictive performance of the generated topics. | [
0.007834862,
0.033065442,
-0.009364442,
0.0585340075,
-0.0076145381,
0.0039007831,
0.0356050283,
-0.0111790234,
-0.0955290198,
-0.009757312,
-0.0244553294,
0.0299439672,
-0.0104398103,
0.0837131366,
0.0054856394,
-0.0277285166,
0.0288351569,
-0.0090892604,
0.0245351531,
-0.0173385534,
0.003968094,
-0.0022651092,
0.0133486325,
0.0137137529,
0.0167287849,
0.0219577514,
-0.0190420374,
0.0032516164,
0.0084542371,
-0.0187099706,
-0.0090301884,
0.0158357807,
0.0456257388,
-0.0088975439,
0.0000020401,
-0.002424354,
-0.0187628139,
-0.042139031,
-0.0188163593,
0.0377794914,
0.027640868,
-0.0631010756,
0.0398009755,
0.0043999841,
0.0240529235,
-0.0375916548,
0.0228480287,
0.090385437,
0.0227787234,
0.0631150678,
-0.0189716648,
0.0117648263,
0.0890480056,
-0.0599723533,
0.022219725,
-0.0487408042,
0.0114470683,
0.0125078745,
-0.0442413166,
0.0380103104,
-0.0342247859,
0.009451583,
0.0591625273,
0.002459897,
0.0504646003,
0.0570996851,
-0.026359411,
-0.0336148664,
-0.0182197932,
0.0572833307,
0.0024080707,
0.0068572545,
0.0072782729,
-0.0176465195,
-0.0409787446,
0.0270101447,
-0.0522061586,
0.0073153162,
0.0147900423,
0.0366970971,
0.0577524938,
0.0207013357,
0.0433977619,
-0.0165612251,
0.0514901392,
0.0084526027,
0.0429892018,
-0.0195715781,
-0.0116054015,
0.0461196341,
-0.0190677978,
-0.0417472869,
0.0648740232,
-0.0015351963,
0.0403253064,
-0.0064368648,
-0.0294383429,
-0.0381069221,
-0.0292406064,
-0.0223498009,
-0.0202067457,
0.0294162352,
-0.0185969118,
0.024335403,
0.0171896219,
0.0080339508,
-0.0253088046,
-0.002065517,
-0.0409693979,
-0.0136392331,
-0.0068008699,
0.0036781658,
-0.0149355968,
0.0322987363,
0.0015986634,
-0.046077136,
-0.0164246261,
0.0208355114,
-0.0187970437,
-0.0309028756,
-0.0257936027,
0.0361633003,
-0.0594448894,
-0.016384149,
0.003212224,
0.0721535236,
-0.0306827333,
0.0239122752,
0.0033541285,
9.876e-7,
0.0063426639,
0.019891819,
0.0266820248,
-0.0156040303,
-0.0131416311,
-0.0038263032,
0.0050743809,
-0.0428188071,
-0.0741725415,
0.0073928246,
-0.0159560163,
-0.0261536054,
0.064817071,
-0.0685382932,
0.0364321917,
-0.0087090749,
0.0158667862,
-0.0388474464,
-0.0294230822,
-0.0014186708,
-0.0096836966,
0.0364351608,
-0.028145859,
-0.0200644825,
0.1071658507,
0.0297806188,
0.0608311556,
0.0760089159,
-0.0193591602,
0.055203177,
0.0258693304,
-0.0144298542,
-0.0308639612,
0.0136938477,
0.0233785138,
0.0062371599,
-0.0646025985,
-0.0202309191,
-0.027684791,
0.0251834374,
0.0869536325,
0.0397661701,
-0.0705637708,
-0.0412786752,
0.010450311,
0.0727967843,
0.0240818057,
-0.0041660392,
0.014907727,
-0.0093417075,
-0.0180448703,
0.0272541344,
0.0125492597,
0.0343989804,
0.0371246301,
-0.0440227762,
0.0548223816,
-0.0111071467,
-0.0715477392,
-0.0497325398,
0.0178637169,
-0.0167516023,
0.0101810461,
-0.0303628687,
0.0794324651,
-0.0001453181,
0.0562655106,
0.0373723023,
0.0413625687,
-0.0015358035,
0.0276582148,
-0.009283701,
0.0600321181,
0.0384369865,
0.0551741384,
0.0218395628,
-0.028330354,
-0.0252060834,
0.0133109968,
0.041553352,
0.0238003805,
-0.0262478162,
0.0016284353,
-0.0323827974,
-0.0415724292,
-0.0521184467,
0.026508091,
0.0039958823,
-0.0317870975,
0.0113114081,
0.0484729297,
-0.0325927101,
0.0243083183,
0.0147718089,
-0.0633884594,
0.0024717217,
0.0115106329,
-0.0193559844,
0.0424037017,
0.0143089416,
0.0014647681,
-0.0029684983,
0.0508230887,
-0.0769293681,
-0.0310368519,
-0.0542565435,
-0.0664699301,
-0.0758040026,
0.0042783883,
-0.0906404853,
0.0444199443,
0.0332358032,
-0.002927012,
-0.0321786627,
0.0425059125,
-0.0383438915,
0.0215701684,
-0.0226848014,
-0.0152227441,
-0.0240587965,
0.0026194963,
0.0244445261,
0.0344828963,
-0.0626983792,
0.0260528699,
0.0012911902,
0.0378714502,
0.0124935694,
-0.0471626483,
-0.0316481069,
0.0316538326,
-0.008440014,
-0.0207366813,
0.0264248028,
-0.0078985067,
0.0018036731,
0.0106924623,
-0.1026319042,
0.012101124,
-0.0283219703,
-0.0078825727,
0.0283662174,
0.0147436745,
0.0020500701,
-0.0141247977,
-0.0110100498,
0.0137011576,
-0.0511917472,
0.0286762211,
-0.0002164645,
-0.0114582991,
0.0328928009,
-0.0407361984,
-0.074402228,
0.0176547412,
0.0814238265,
-0.0204124637,
-0.0407253765,
-0.043480657,
0.0478119925,
-0.0229644179,
-0.0229548737,
-0.036793258,
0.0057253712,
0.0047821808,
0.0025484208,
0.0726997703,
0.0055766748,
0.0050270348,
0.0815582573,
0.0461015105,
0.0119820274,
-0.0464327708,
-0.0209885016,
-0.0302270353,
0.0381311253,
0.0022275441,
-0.0376766436,
-0.0072595226,
0.0599736571,
0.002094782,
0.0563067459,
-0.040164642,
0.0225956682,
-0.0421079956,
-0.0144432234,
-0.0305733755,
-0.0064581921,
-0.0070323437,
0.0174705852,
-0.0355897844,
-0.0517269,
0.0466405712,
0.0093941037,
0.0242067631,
-0.0349787138,
0.0086830473,
-0.0444339886,
0.0179519989,
0.0375180729,
-0.0058961958,
0.0084434627,
-0.0187413804,
0.0064166738,
0.0436929315,
-0.0532629192,
0.0033707854,
0.0180025361,
-0.0013826819,
0.0052113864,
-0.0004310818,
0.0044085579,
-0.0096688308,
-0.0277058706,
0.0025543284,
0.0129603921,
0.0144429309,
0.0147354985,
0.0008314492,
-0.0066728271,
0.0043117926,
0.0629756004,
-0.0270240232,
0.0056726579,
0.0043967026,
0.096192807,
0.0773441717,
-0.0377665944,
-0.0491867773,
-0.0245309751,
0.0122305984,
0.0367078744,
0.0012736054,
0.0081590125,
-0.0622533113,
0.0313782208,
0.0294882655,
0.0092342449,
-0.0377398506,
-0.000157066,
0.0250127856,
-0.038908802,
-0.0216668267,
0.0941677317,
-0.0054539684,
-0.0877565071,
-0.0141359568,
-0.03321217,
0.0217271261,
0.0003879858,
-0.0183608308,
-0.043140769,
-0.0217759665,
-0.0292805191,
0.0200754013,
0.0136684878,
0.0035184659,
-0.0184118599,
-0.0556123629,
0.033450298,
-0.0022631835,
-0.0271195658,
-0.0222841613,
-0.0843456313,
-0.0048125745,
-0.0279954951,
0.0385399647,
-0.008020076,
0.0119290035,
-0.0178590566,
0.0544684678,
-0.0243719313,
-0.0707999021,
-0.0131133776,
-0.0275989175,
0.0522101671,
0.0545171164,
0.0061896336,
-0.0284640137,
0.0195639543,
0.0008849144,
-0.05775344,
-0.0116268918,
-0.0153125618,
0.0909808129,
-0.0358947068,
0.0131686861,
0.0167654194,
0.0337667726,
-0.0546466038,
-0.0189234633,
-0.0105303554,
0.0632815287,
-0.0512726344,
-0.0724578127,
-0.0321682952,
-0.0122707179,
-0.034049049,
0.0576101467,
0.0522900708,
-0.0461972095,
0.0173414405,
-0.0003592585,
0.0300592221,
0.0130239306,
0.0025361874,
-0.0206503496,
0.0157897957,
-0.1190636009,
-0.0198057909,
-0.0496031083,
-0.0141902529,
0.0068908813,
-0.0050270283,
0.0153295612,
0.0324400961,
-0.0388872884,
-0.0201276354,
0.0447084047,
-0.0033977439,
-0.0482260175,
-0.0086610997,
-0.0161725245,
0.0156974532,
-0.0270974394,
-0.0062064459,
-0.0291962344,
-0.0976124629,
-0.0187861826,
-0.0077035041,
0.0038384877,
0.0144883832,
0.0486572608,
0.0100903539,
-0.0906896293,
0.0394690521,
0.0259285457,
-0.0333969034,
0.0347047821,
-0.0141585227,
0.0002530655,
0.0020852746,
0.0123020783,
-0.0303100273,
0.053595975,
0.0012890823,
0.0127470382,
-0.0331874304,
-0.0172887743,
-0.0175585393,
-0.0325720794,
0.0830451027,
0.0098679345,
-0.0394429564,
-0.0660187379,
-0.0243137013,
-0.022977097,
0.0176884923,
-0.0501050167,
0.0155311693,
0.0385382175,
0.0390715376,
-0.0337094441,
-0.0044746199,
-0.0183469802,
0.0272024069,
-0.0527896211,
0.003592951,
0.0461680479,
0.0279447716,
-0.0136690047,
0.0287786294,
-0.0186893642,
-0.0163106713,
-0.0095437253,
-0.0084397001,
-0.0592587143,
0.054502096,
0.003935873,
0.0189589523,
0.0024325515,
0.0050208056,
-0.0577788986,
-0.0016255163,
-0.0302859154,
0.0280037094,
0.008488521,
-0.0119891232,
0.0226527583,
-0.0063590212,
0.0017410234,
-0.0440488458,
0.030353602,
0.0001522144,
-0.028603144,
0.0301799811,
0.0289834738,
-0.0107730823,
0.0257020202,
0.0722943842,
0.044089552,
0.0041907495,
0.0184956789,
0.0023277074,
-0.0325094312,
0.034673214,
-0.004654794,
0.062467251,
-0.0209208038,
0.0092811538,
-0.0048738662,
-0.0166305527,
0.0200248957,
-0.0475935824,
0.0375071876,
0.0078518931,
0.0514486693,
0.0524403565,
-0.0520394854,
0.0087717958,
-0.0116573144,
0.0260401964,
-0.0339598097,
-0.0071015856,
-0.0429867581,
-7.061948351e-33,
-0.0090620155,
-0.0062189321,
0.0146130491,
0.003284103,
-0.0116618611,
0.0615064278,
-0.0749824792,
-0.0047032251,
0.0258137845,
-0.0151353441,
0.0113656754,
0.0439969078,
-0.003186024,
0.0267385226,
-0.0047658463,
-0.0269831363,
0.0760662034,
-0.0429345034,
0.0085238442,
0.0539861992,
0.013831717,
0.0298798606,
0.043180503,
-0.0653863922,
0.028821541,
0.002023929,
0.0207428634,
-0.0133904982,
0.1032976285,
0.0327912122,
-0.0672235042,
0.0592643879,
0.0654573366,
-0.0497228913,
-0.0175954476,
0.0187199526,
-0.0598141253,
-0.0557002984,
-0.0522134714,
-0.0158686396,
-0.0264960676,
-0.0627150312,
0.0798848867,
0.034792237,
-0.0441719852,
-0.0051863957,
0.0549317896,
0.0174097419,
-0.062461704,
-0.0286667645,
-0.0450789109,
0.0300605316,
-0.00186411,
-0.0131016457,
0.0078229867,
0.0062195915,
0.0011580441,
0.055695653,
-0.0178266894,
0.0234014764,
0.0125716273,
0.0384920351,
0.0486611314,
-0.0210830718,
-0.0223619174,
0.0802894309,
0.0314236991,
0.0133217769,
-0.0292826295,
-0.0180077758,
0.0340541154,
0.0361666642,
0.0351561569,
-0.0100308154,
0.0795393437,
-0.0095423525,
-0.0352242514,
0.0180900395,
-0.0440785699,
0.023947442,
0.0556504987,
0.0326799266,
-0.0172815956,
-0.0456520729,
-0.0142759914,
-0.0603501201,
-0.0135053992,
-0.0350024439,
0.0106573589,
0.018354252,
0.0048212712,
0.0368567035,
0.0241660457,
-0.0319138318,
0.0426140428,
0.0572868697,
-0.0091734836,
0.0280840341,
0.0285797752,
0.0181578994,
-0.0926470533,
-0.0238049626,
0.0085262042,
-0.0117728235,
-0.00265741,
-0.0298507698,
0.0104694422,
0.0083515886,
-0.0117873652,
-0.0584495068,
-0.0463006385,
-0.052013658,
-0.0039403206,
0.0742762163,
0.0216194969,
0.0088978149,
-0.0199679099,
0.0674595758,
0.0168744028,
0.0474704131,
-0.0149351628,
-0.0718395486,
0.022333866,
0.0108022979,
-0.0125170806,
-0.0151535366,
-0.0029119777,
0.0108041847,
0.0294494517,
-0.0572979487,
-0.0216016918,
0.0004613794,
2.697e-7,
0.0229322575,
0.0335002616,
-0.0068890047,
-0.0728116408,
0.0369164124,
0.0244904272,
-0.0196579825,
0.0240504239,
0.006658148,
-0.0070436592,
0.0323816575,
0.0446691178,
0.0192797445,
0.0337134823,
-0.053498704,
0.0186095722,
-0.0491183512,
0.02262941,
-0.0294263717,
-0.0148589015,
-0.003337024,
0.0809430405,
0.0045107589,
-0.0191103537,
0.0129787214,
0.0202763826,
0.08346086,
-0.0453599691,
-0.0336461067,
0.0147563815,
0.0355200209,
0.0498430766,
0.0018244177,
-0.0245698709,
-0.0207497869,
-0.0062957243,
0.0571701601,
0.066319868,
0.0256611425,
-0.0462376364,
0.0123875327,
0.0096029574,
-0.0177100878,
-0.0073234863,
0.0637674108,
-0.063703835,
-0.0398440361,
-0.0051771309,
-0.0428782515,
0.0444825739,
0.039724756,
-0.0067546321,
-0.0104675386,
-0.020549817,
-0.0115901427,
-0.0414499231,
-0.0485088602,
-0.0450183861,
0.0124724796,
0.018107906,
-0.0827614665,
-0.0480341166,
-0.0461632386,
-0.0129708722,
0.0278981775,
-0.0062271645,
0.0092211552,
2.325066985e-34,
0.0193187091,
-0.0180430133,
-0.0243156739,
-0.0106928293,
-0.04837358,
-0.0377280898,
-0.0304382108,
-0.0157646071,
-0.0140053863,
-0.0212215334,
-0.0036322249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15870v1 | A Multi-Granularity Matching Attention Network for Query Intent Classification in E-commerce Retrieval | 2023-03-28T10:25:17 | 2023-03-28T10:25:17 | Chunyuan Yuan, Yiming Qiu, Mingming Li, Haiqing Hu, Songlin Wang, Sulong Xu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Query intent classification, which aims at assisting customers to find
desired products, has become an essential component of the e-commerce search.
Existing query intent classification models either design more exquisite models
to enhance the representation learning of queries or explore label-graph and
multi-task to facilitate models to learn external information. However, these
models cannot capture multi-granularity matching features from queries and
categories, which makes them hard to mitigate the gap in the expression between
informal queries and categories.
This paper proposes a Multi-granularity Matching Attention Network (MMAN),
which contains three modules: a self-matching module, a char-level matching
module, and a semantic-level matching module to comprehensively extract
features from the query and a query-category interaction matrix. In this way,
the model can eliminate the difference in expression between queries and
categories for query intent classification. We conduct extensive offline and
online A/B experiments, and the results show that the MMAN significantly
outperforms the strong baselines, which shows the superiority and effectiveness
of MMAN. MMAN has been deployed in production and brings great commercial value
for our company. | [
0.052535668,
0.0077812113,
-0.0224302672,
0.0033661663,
-0.0107212253,
-0.0264510661,
0.0048826672,
-0.0174101293,
0.0184228029,
-0.0643549785,
-0.0528880097,
-0.032819517,
-0.0218768194,
0.0604872182,
0.0326878354,
-0.0145932995,
0.0425090604,
0.0482237004,
-0.0321849324,
0.0471334085,
0.0600469112,
0.052968476,
0.0267981552,
0.0194988493,
0.0114673078,
-0.0041663586,
-0.0316179395,
0.0421188399,
-0.026504999,
0.0045214817,
0.061059393,
0.0482776761,
0.0432867818,
0.010644732,
0.0000016353,
-0.0843729451,
-0.0286377352,
-0.0423072278,
-0.0263795927,
0.0088230791,
0.0139547819,
0.0453568809,
0.0845617577,
0.0268574469,
0.0064578727,
0.0513001941,
0.0334995724,
0.0705165565,
0.003794299,
0.0313468948,
-0.0069327476,
-0.0304274317,
0.0077720624,
-0.0281783063,
0.0537296981,
-0.0592714921,
0.0421278812,
-0.0157304425,
-0.0193567351,
0.0385141335,
0.0080811009,
0.0000815188,
-0.0193027873,
0.0127414251,
0.0698887482,
0.0251477361,
0.0245778337,
0.0254004691,
0.0093439259,
0.0806180015,
-0.0594246313,
-0.0271860659,
-0.0187043604,
-0.0149657289,
0.0283324532,
-0.0198559631,
-0.004239371,
-0.0233366303,
-0.005510136,
0.007542721,
-0.0227202121,
0.0333225764,
-0.0036467731,
0.01099844,
-0.0431057885,
0.0216927901,
-0.0152279325,
-0.03710844,
0.0054208916,
-0.0021427511,
0.0258678459,
-0.0291721076,
0.0267568324,
0.0166408997,
0.0105227092,
0.0032416938,
-0.046537213,
0.0079144826,
0.0351117253,
-0.0492786951,
-0.021299921,
0.0179614201,
-0.0024134761,
0.0567974932,
-0.0297718123,
0.0412750915,
-0.0050707953,
0.0252690967,
-0.0703273118,
-0.007574562,
-0.0540713444,
-0.0159393605,
-0.0595455319,
0.0412992947,
0.0143299736,
-0.0084908484,
-0.0278911311,
0.0283445418,
0.0116546266,
-0.0489758402,
0.0174100008,
0.035886988,
-0.0377361327,
0.0090314932,
-0.051498767,
-0.002842739,
-0.0537447743,
0.0585465655,
0.0029424918,
-0.0402282216,
-0.0199879799,
0.0307890344,
0.0416702628,
-0.0678908974,
0.008946483,
-0.0022886775,
-0.0043880171,
-0.0343544446,
-0.0606357232,
-0.0511408523,
0.0056800828,
-0.0095200799,
-0.027003102,
-0.0134462267,
0.0406375304,
-0.0368422978,
-0.0340579674,
0.023537362,
-0.0023024275,
0.0349223614,
-0.0068225577,
0.0585148819,
0.0395747088,
-0.0155780986,
-0.0049260124,
-0.0112530682,
0.0208933763,
0.0129534053,
-0.0251268838,
0.0613354184,
0.0343261659,
-0.0023248417,
0.0030730758,
-0.0072650961,
0.0166026838,
-0.0506793596,
-0.0057278564,
0.0752028972,
0.0061917268,
0.0339058861,
0.0685801655,
0.0303228963,
-0.018785689,
-0.0319147147,
0.0497381873,
0.022099033,
0.0434529148,
0.0194385257,
0.0046286657,
0.0443470664,
-0.0495452732,
-0.0143963322,
0.0066238972,
0.0371758863,
-0.0292694662,
-0.0092374096,
0.0285397116,
0.0064475131,
-0.0809898898,
-0.0064644213,
0.0336281508,
-0.0058393083,
0.0414252952,
0.0240932256,
0.0326267295,
-0.0144133624,
-0.012052794,
-0.0020823556,
-0.0086321933,
-0.001874257,
0.0277944654,
-0.0865292177,
0.0105751287,
0.0683509558,
0.0324202515,
-0.040364299,
-0.0401487909,
-0.0490331538,
-0.0617858954,
-0.0157963242,
0.0036545845,
-0.0159873404,
-0.0043076887,
-0.062055219,
-0.0177474152,
-0.0098088151,
-0.0166071486,
-0.0015675863,
-0.0198576245,
0.015366069,
0.0410236716,
-0.0400350504,
0.0063823946,
0.0374094285,
0.0374910384,
-0.0255545136,
0.0168706886,
0.042672772,
0.0166337918,
0.0185449161,
0.0299255755,
0.021302389,
0.0138247767,
0.0034742204,
-0.0117630651,
-0.0462152399,
-0.0032812282,
-0.0144576943,
0.0111027686,
-0.0008217802,
0.0026655705,
0.0225340128,
0.0051776553,
-0.0338728093,
0.0056559606,
-0.0369365476,
0.0138517916,
-0.0497057103,
-0.0050386479,
-0.0097743366,
0.0154462866,
-0.0554601476,
0.0463538058,
0.0143496701,
0.0398021899,
-0.0084911287,
-0.05088,
-0.0106422193,
-0.0235436,
-0.003966074,
-0.0237574335,
-0.0140756387,
0.0407157578,
0.0063912421,
-0.006502849,
-0.065801695,
0.0286305845,
-0.0456081219,
0.02117013,
0.0063156895,
0.0219080392,
0.0207415614,
0.021536395,
0.028125871,
-0.0220329314,
-0.0691556931,
0.0207319856,
-0.0452282578,
0.006180557,
0.039440196,
0.0109717948,
-0.0056544794,
-0.0118691437,
-0.0268196724,
-0.0069060628,
0.0107456604,
0.0067301639,
-0.0621845871,
-0.0296538621,
-0.0055506118,
-0.032046672,
0.0190130938,
-0.0174179878,
-0.0190782268,
-0.0441635288,
-0.048425898,
-0.0156314224,
0.0714989826,
0.0368953757,
-0.0668961406,
0.0055244998,
0.0041931733,
-0.0782979205,
0.0247716531,
-0.0333736874,
0.0100581981,
0.0036035995,
-0.0389400497,
0.0596673638,
0.0400243327,
-0.0169257894,
-0.0237316694,
-0.0363689214,
-0.0315543599,
0.0635152981,
-0.0195122138,
-0.1049656719,
0.0193505269,
-0.0108746784,
0.010430702,
-0.0404629782,
-0.0190433487,
0.0841422155,
0.0476011932,
-0.0225086845,
-0.0285584368,
-0.0226984322,
-0.0568889976,
0.0365290232,
-0.0296695251,
0.0387439951,
0.0254947599,
-0.0725506395,
-0.0375831947,
0.0123547344,
0.0034425713,
-0.0219511669,
0.0890602767,
0.0724502206,
0.0313563459,
-0.0107909925,
0.000324282,
-0.0272395462,
-0.0782968849,
0.0282358993,
0.0067824768,
0.0449785888,
-0.0014383361,
-0.0766360313,
0.0410046093,
-0.0047808387,
0.0042975936,
-0.0046242881,
-0.0443979017,
0.0089173038,
0.0538380183,
0.0288588386,
0.0528769977,
-0.0275527388,
-0.000028164,
-0.0390591398,
0.0126428921,
-0.0110928789,
-0.0815045536,
0.0168909933,
-0.0165771954,
0.0690575242,
-0.0467170663,
0.0319857486,
0.0241636299,
0.005469529,
0.0132541293,
-0.0118455021,
0.070880726,
0.011808347,
-0.0503028445,
-0.0270455424,
-0.0063318871,
0.0058225403,
0.0467554368,
0.0413458161,
-0.0240742844,
-0.0206905417,
0.0110123819,
0.034720514,
0.0136411767,
0.0061031645,
0.0058566602,
-0.1045991033,
0.0044708466,
-0.0236916635,
-0.0281358548,
-0.0417838357,
-0.0443010181,
0.0176884215,
-0.0210874211,
0.0215485562,
0.0104313334,
-0.0211739931,
-0.0313220136,
0.0329016894,
0.041280929,
-0.0384492464,
0.0312692784,
-0.0300990921,
0.026579449,
-0.0226736981,
0.0096834386,
-0.013273444,
-0.0088448664,
0.0079987356,
-0.0696333423,
0.0063739312,
0.0233034901,
0.0546020046,
-0.0473128296,
0.036916241,
-0.0225201026,
-0.0418034047,
-0.046303302,
0.013529039,
-0.0478622727,
0.054476589,
-0.0055816062,
-0.0164786428,
-0.0265042298,
-0.044909209,
-0.0177357979,
0.0934871808,
0.019132521,
-0.0057502929,
-0.0217597093,
-0.031756714,
-0.0136370584,
-0.0111945178,
-0.0036663059,
0.0286735222,
-0.0083662355,
-0.0547216013,
-0.0178402923,
-0.0463798828,
0.0390168987,
-0.0030692273,
0.0030854198,
0.0093113324,
-0.0042027491,
-0.0076972223,
-0.0327433012,
0.0313483365,
-0.027385287,
0.0467801169,
-0.0216484312,
0.0258744918,
0.024940988,
-0.078936331,
-0.0246963259,
-0.0278711934,
-0.0365585312,
-0.0122100553,
-0.0507850051,
-0.0149349151,
0.0085722776,
0.0200722646,
-0.0568653606,
-0.0379521623,
-0.0476547107,
0.0529815182,
-0.0348318331,
-0.0318744518,
0.0092363898,
0.0119319391,
-0.0145751713,
0.0287576299,
-0.0627439246,
0.0116120465,
-0.0147632221,
0.012036074,
-0.0633953512,
-0.0973855034,
0.0538703874,
0.0201722458,
0.0248486847,
0.0355435647,
0.0245906822,
-0.086820662,
0.0253019463,
0.0607045814,
-0.0324650183,
-0.0183191374,
-0.0436743163,
0.0412771329,
-0.0192242488,
-0.0175200161,
0.0191417169,
-0.0151537359,
-0.0214830749,
-0.0637828633,
-0.0342968516,
-0.0058637504,
0.043100778,
-0.0208433084,
0.0017379607,
-0.054250367,
-0.0003733817,
0.0126047246,
0.0327313095,
-0.0341137648,
0.0029032282,
0.0110433241,
-0.0025961229,
-0.0431636199,
0.0414708219,
-0.0173050445,
0.0016949924,
-0.0521261618,
-0.0710584745,
0.0217680391,
-0.0262681246,
-0.0224121269,
0.0296847336,
0.0018860981,
-0.019799402,
0.0279181674,
-0.0379165895,
0.01256702,
0.0273589194,
0.0126197319,
-0.0261685215,
-0.0156482756,
0.0438948274,
-0.0338417217,
0.0375517122,
-0.0267955381,
-0.052518934,
-0.0310028605,
0.0111808833,
0.0268389359,
0.0708458051,
-0.0398766994,
-0.0163304489,
0.007018222,
-0.0227485988,
0.0226772577,
-0.0342896134,
0.0279796533,
0.0226658825,
0.1100547388,
0.0555567704,
0.0339219794,
-0.0136433141,
-0.0257311407,
0.013666315,
-0.0185710154,
0.0254164524,
-0.0602626763,
-6.320615492e-33,
0.0145833027,
-0.0062569869,
-0.0192022528,
-0.0419612564,
-0.0513020605,
0.019231813,
-0.0110067958,
-0.0338132121,
-0.0380043834,
-0.037202891,
0.0102393012,
0.0204896294,
-0.0036267061,
-0.0117805367,
0.025160104,
-0.0521397851,
0.035790246,
0.0249071866,
0.0121752443,
0.0558210425,
0.0466987826,
0.0559273213,
0.0418629311,
-0.0533914752,
0.0087804748,
-0.0398728997,
-0.0293747168,
0.0447565727,
0.0128542138,
0.0894104764,
-0.0048992415,
0.0325965323,
0.0756627843,
0.0051160906,
0.0248216391,
0.0458275191,
-0.0819030032,
-0.0372915529,
0.0058041015,
-0.0160947125,
-0.0395540409,
-0.016478356,
0.0546820909,
-0.0101934345,
0.0284951627,
0.0005864794,
0.0688687339,
0.0276496634,
-0.0354928039,
-0.0281370673,
0.0026507042,
-0.0075615505,
-0.0208301842,
0.0118345115,
0.0129306428,
0.0782718509,
0.0245143287,
0.0765339285,
-0.0293602012,
0.0417113081,
-0.0731699988,
0.0183036551,
0.0210298076,
0.0648156404,
-0.0231784098,
0.0537940785,
-0.0121067734,
0.0189667325,
0.012609248,
-0.0153371524,
0.006523096,
0.0413813256,
0.0237329379,
-0.0016250781,
0.0401803963,
0.0004243837,
-0.0521718301,
0.0361974612,
0.0246528015,
0.040470019,
0.0142093031,
0.0228638407,
-0.0553642474,
-0.0153246773,
-0.0067962147,
0.0288184136,
-0.0930955261,
0.0250298269,
0.031971857,
0.032080777,
0.0196863692,
0.050745517,
0.0099955071,
-0.0083723636,
-0.0126448339,
-0.0035498298,
0.0333826467,
0.0113745276,
0.0322686657,
-0.0045316173,
-0.0717891455,
-0.0476129763,
0.0027976888,
-0.0505141057,
-0.0244376492,
0.0401937887,
0.021739373,
-0.0207335576,
-0.0118617229,
-0.022582259,
-0.0003675783,
-0.0521352813,
-0.0529720709,
0.0358910412,
0.0530644655,
0.0306462198,
-0.008792215,
0.0627090111,
0.0576575324,
0.0296344589,
-0.017283285,
-0.0685940757,
0.0394348167,
0.0449469835,
0.0162203778,
-0.0049573574,
-0.025010962,
0.0089486344,
0.0116421087,
-0.0587981753,
-0.0247573387,
0.0447882116,
2.622e-7,
0.0383046977,
0.0256290678,
-0.0236127563,
0.0608094037,
-0.0060082953,
0.031663619,
0.0281890668,
0.0697187707,
0.0145250773,
-0.0006857872,
0.0633516684,
-0.0097637717,
0.002172586,
-0.0194588676,
-0.0507705621,
0.0132322572,
-0.013268386,
0.0084565524,
-0.0026123875,
0.0023830198,
0.0721407682,
0.0857708752,
0.0195142832,
0.0219626985,
0.0202423856,
-0.0644989014,
0.0154234078,
0.0127380602,
0.0188441835,
0.0353260972,
0.0446611047,
0.0638130829,
-0.0369569659,
0.0282235239,
-0.0151817733,
0.0463462025,
0.0478136949,
0.0213276315,
-0.0477328673,
-0.0595362373,
-0.0144688468,
-0.040912386,
0.0049961461,
-0.0678781867,
0.0657254308,
-0.0040328722,
-0.0061733746,
0.0287842508,
0.006998443,
0.0447022729,
0.0224595238,
-0.0152529776,
-0.0259720907,
-0.0157594364,
0.0277597755,
-0.0037578575,
-0.0366341136,
-0.1091766879,
0.0348382965,
-0.0108298874,
-0.054825902,
-0.0149019975,
-0.0537691601,
0.0342153199,
0.0274198223,
-0.0375054516,
0.017740529,
2.185022215e-34,
0.0404776745,
0.0173760261,
0.0015046911,
0.0288162306,
-0.0209732279,
-0.0146458549,
-0.0259458516,
-0.0108040618,
0.0500934869,
-0.111504674,
-0.0181033947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15846v1 | Soft-prompt tuning to predict lung cancer using primary care free-text Dutch medical notes | 2023-03-28T09:36:53 | 2023-03-28T09:36:53 | Auke Elfrink, Iacopo Vagliano, Ameen Abu-Hanna, Iacer Calixto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | We investigate different natural language processing (NLP) approaches based
on contextualised word representations for the problem of early prediction of
lung cancer using free-text patient medical notes of Dutch primary care
physicians. Because lung cancer has a low prevalence in primary care, we also
address the problem of classification under highly imbalanced classes.
Specifically, we use large Transformer-based pretrained language models (PLMs)
and investigate: 1) how \textit{soft prompt-tuning} -- an NLP technique used to
adapt PLMs using small amounts of training data -- compares to standard model
fine-tuning; 2) whether simpler static word embedding models (WEMs) can be more
robust compared to PLMs in highly imbalanced settings; and 3) how models fare
when trained on notes from a small number of patients. We find that 1)
soft-prompt tuning is an efficient alternative to standard model fine-tuning;
2) PLMs show better discrimination but worse calibration compared to simpler
static word embedding models as the classification problem becomes more
imbalanced; and 3) results when training models on small number of patients are
mixed and show no clear differences between PLMs and WEMs. All our code is
available open source in
\url{https://bitbucket.org/aumc-kik/prompt_tuning_cancer_prediction/}. | [
0.0386491939,
0.0319973491,
0.007383808,
-0.0204051696,
-0.0097808819,
0.0204267185,
0.0103079667,
-0.0047913552,
-0.0064679426,
-0.0906646922,
-0.01420369,
-0.0533839129,
0.0178181361,
0.0107319532,
-0.0089793345,
-0.0499429442,
0.0283112861,
0.0173657928,
0.0118865222,
0.0104312999,
0.0062868283,
0.0018675243,
-0.0038329086,
0.0564942844,
0.0130878957,
0.0280043017,
0.0438775569,
-0.0388303436,
0.0096259927,
-0.0272363666,
0.0155869834,
0.0374962278,
-0.0219290555,
0.0367960408,
0.0000018403,
-0.0610444471,
-0.0292130876,
0.0222251955,
-0.0232998282,
-0.0297771394,
0.0474683754,
-0.079560332,
0.009710311,
0.026068192,
-0.0232966207,
-0.0205088593,
0.0170363039,
0.084517844,
0.0353080891,
0.0847164392,
-0.0161065813,
-0.0167593248,
0.0096348254,
-0.0207923539,
0.0102184517,
-0.0227278229,
0.0393352062,
-0.0382636338,
-0.0103538195,
0.0138392085,
-0.0171963945,
0.0326606408,
-0.0320021771,
0.0249770693,
0.0326012932,
0.0469629914,
-0.0264117233,
-0.0268742424,
-0.0157329384,
0.0342115685,
-0.0508141182,
-0.0023173871,
-0.0093550002,
-0.0539315231,
0.0013924708,
0.0365318917,
0.0049317838,
0.0048054773,
-0.0032896984,
0.0122524323,
0.0271586441,
0.0166485365,
0.0098842727,
-0.0041607744,
0.0094967159,
-0.0152321467,
-0.0011378557,
-0.0282648113,
0.0378151797,
0.0196767505,
0.002594847,
-0.0257622991,
0.0134229595,
0.0286540128,
-0.0278846119,
0.0215264,
-0.011593774,
0.0039214124,
0.0972019359,
-0.0800021812,
0.0236090757,
-0.0000399072,
-0.0312498379,
0.0349346735,
-0.0318543501,
-0.0078251734,
0.0274934079,
0.0480829515,
-0.0351079367,
0.0310244933,
-0.0039426219,
0.006404452,
-0.0381873399,
0.0032196499,
0.0212940425,
0.0063773324,
-0.0960635617,
-0.0173946582,
0.0118180765,
-0.007911874,
0.0606709346,
0.0133455908,
-0.0244505238,
0.0291407574,
-0.00439244,
0.0273392964,
0.0052776244,
0.0209033471,
-0.0493783616,
-0.0568184517,
0.0294942632,
0.0164180547,
0.0246417597,
-0.0229323711,
0.0117543899,
0.009760526,
0.0249170456,
-0.0701439008,
0.0096020196,
-0.0043368866,
-0.027367197,
0.0007548857,
-0.0306325126,
-0.0412849039,
-0.0026794111,
0.0201949086,
0.0344018154,
-0.0148044052,
0.0054746824,
0.0019425141,
-0.0497737005,
0.0751070157,
0.0087618064,
0.0009109011,
0.0199341178,
0.0052074054,
-0.0112994118,
0.0359813571,
0.0223165732,
-0.0529726185,
-0.0009245826,
-0.0437722318,
0.0135063957,
0.010019538,
0.010979414,
-0.0361159071,
0.0313778967,
0.0096373493,
0.0028786287,
0.0557864532,
-0.0228956472,
0.0539951436,
0.0319224112,
-0.0240226313,
0.0198921692,
0.0444639176,
0.0856524706,
0.0207890011,
0.015480753,
-0.0209790878,
-0.0316490233,
-0.0196514167,
-0.0114471521,
-0.0214323066,
-0.0445592329,
-0.0021848357,
-0.0261359625,
0.0112162093,
-0.0114516569,
-0.0358632989,
-0.023787858,
0.0120907826,
0.004100102,
-0.0282952301,
0.0255326107,
-0.0217878688,
-0.0549340546,
0.0163892359,
0.0433346555,
0.0067810938,
-0.026940031,
-0.0388002284,
-0.033544004,
0.0426794812,
0.023881074,
-0.0409415737,
-0.010360389,
-0.0529193915,
-0.001319538,
-0.020977512,
0.0341829062,
0.0109050777,
-0.0214772951,
-0.0192561429,
-0.0200048201,
0.0418282412,
0.0206548907,
-0.0431959704,
-0.0172173791,
0.0388274193,
0.0084644118,
-0.0013888666,
-0.0318867676,
0.0774181187,
-0.0334539227,
-0.0528621525,
-0.0157157648,
0.0164418705,
0.0175980087,
-0.0033274926,
-0.0210776329,
0.0049504922,
0.0060913395,
-0.0105874483,
-0.0475177839,
-0.0058737425,
-0.0553239137,
-0.0137297027,
0.010628527,
-0.0023704499,
0.0132561987,
-0.0091434,
-0.0322136767,
0.0055057649,
-0.0634951368,
-0.0142218918,
0.0049179583,
-0.0175148845,
0.0260477606,
0.0049434691,
0.0143993385,
-0.0406126268,
0.0167330299,
-0.0109504173,
0.0306676291,
-0.0215994306,
-0.0294527821,
0.0023370977,
-0.0109811705,
-0.0483542606,
-0.00758343,
0.0158774294,
0.0257861651,
0.0024709241,
0.0094466414,
-0.0013646233,
-0.0297656395,
-0.120105058,
0.0029754916,
-0.0195513237,
-0.0342782512,
0.0129306912,
0.039495483,
-0.0176510923,
-0.0375564471,
-0.0457834788,
-0.0017750587,
0.050553821,
0.0274021123,
0.0202070866,
0.0262779295,
0.009348562,
-0.0170736499,
0.0097519318,
-0.0421744846,
0.0514730103,
0.0686389804,
-0.0627278835,
-0.0111464132,
0.0548994392,
0.0034987528,
0.020369906,
0.0118574817,
-0.0024515002,
-0.0197074711,
0.0000960645,
-0.0245942511,
0.0624513365,
0.0434084907,
0.0246289894,
0.0338798389,
0.0419036858,
-0.0322110318,
-0.0083917882,
-0.0497508571,
-0.0645422861,
-0.005968553,
-0.0173356254,
0.0017513838,
0.077779077,
0.0227008983,
-0.0206437092,
-0.0514577515,
-0.0004070066,
-0.0247961804,
0.0679150075,
-0.042725794,
0.0116044339,
-0.0319886804,
0.0069882418,
0.0151786683,
-0.0684993938,
0.0918271542,
-0.0135840159,
0.0376432352,
-0.0900880024,
-0.0255107749,
-0.0358178243,
-0.0034894433,
-0.0041156784,
0.0120796897,
0.0220061969,
0.0354282148,
-0.0246039741,
-0.0151220076,
-0.0034666853,
-0.0571455061,
0.0521919988,
0.0152493585,
0.0341118388,
-0.0174837336,
-0.0513340943,
-0.0597830266,
-0.1026137695,
-0.0403797925,
0.029098209,
0.0214092433,
0.0203686617,
-0.0597584844,
0.0204388294,
-0.0345001779,
0.0720870346,
0.0278713126,
-0.0382527262,
-0.0062423758,
0.0043693376,
0.0434565842,
0.01147075,
0.0036770196,
0.0028965804,
0.0423907004,
0.0164327472,
-0.0504076555,
0.0202125534,
0.001066791,
-0.0039419997,
0.0029775824,
-0.0558541119,
-0.0014844063,
0.0316541232,
0.0408774614,
-0.0329337344,
-0.0151769705,
0.1229054555,
0.0323070846,
-0.0445841588,
0.0189131703,
0.0101263877,
-0.0336351283,
-0.012212621,
0.0304882564,
-0.0580673739,
-0.0304039828,
-0.0109977536,
0.0120176589,
-0.0374931395,
-0.0159076583,
0.0237424746,
-0.0505269989,
0.0050211437,
0.010629219,
-0.0174433123,
0.0002339905,
-0.0612413399,
-0.0059103556,
-0.0352944583,
-0.0127662597,
-0.0420887433,
-0.0111171389,
-0.0044858991,
0.0016510633,
-0.0769303516,
-0.0930278823,
0.0184240807,
-0.0381209105,
0.0286722854,
0.0416128933,
0.0143704507,
-0.0283286646,
-0.0223666225,
0.0478397533,
0.0052917753,
0.0131078148,
-0.0052484693,
0.0570523217,
-0.0140416706,
0.0068803388,
-0.0337669216,
0.016327545,
-0.0332407579,
-0.01332823,
-0.0089866063,
0.0782941431,
-0.0402473584,
-0.0333059877,
-0.0178243481,
0.0619514175,
0.0392482728,
0.0695357248,
-0.0140240649,
-0.0371396057,
-0.0108811529,
-0.0250010192,
0.0600494631,
0.0492013842,
-0.0390149839,
0.0546051972,
-0.0051697306,
0.0025854011,
-0.0526838601,
-0.0205403212,
0.0373429768,
-0.0203756224,
0.0402067564,
0.035951674,
-0.029068511,
-0.0074385866,
-0.0528791025,
0.0623743385,
0.0366908982,
0.0279777907,
-0.0675256252,
-0.0530977473,
0.0778703988,
-0.020076843,
-0.0177804586,
-0.0323071629,
-0.037859682,
-0.0162840355,
0.0119410446,
0.0405232236,
0.0112115908,
0.0182229951,
0.0060867695,
-0.0668139085,
0.1130880937,
0.0536300167,
-0.0542767458,
-0.0058377478,
-0.0012582627,
-0.0173598789,
-0.01040179,
0.0209245011,
-0.0201021042,
0.0246138386,
0.0318542197,
0.0146715548,
-0.0046454649,
-0.0341585651,
-0.0016765414,
0.003300786,
0.0869078934,
-0.0026403142,
-0.0192284398,
-0.0408658572,
0.0042912103,
0.0423300974,
0.0081821457,
-0.0117576895,
-0.0343871564,
0.0220804866,
0.0076265153,
-0.052875828,
0.0182747357,
-0.067811586,
-0.0042726756,
-0.0582562201,
0.095480226,
0.0438253693,
-0.0082926126,
0.0617481247,
0.0088296924,
0.0089573087,
0.0047694407,
0.0213684551,
-0.0064712353,
0.0200139992,
0.0210093688,
0.0139521733,
0.0698759556,
-0.040583808,
0.0135338483,
-0.0620801523,
-0.0063419095,
-0.0437332429,
0.0072523295,
0.0202296991,
-0.0630141497,
-0.0232614521,
-0.0234364495,
0.0094794752,
-0.0369347148,
0.0353822485,
-0.0171446633,
0.0129296957,
0.0712834671,
-0.0055449,
-0.0191284698,
0.0088057509,
0.0785509944,
-0.0103850598,
0.0302375238,
0.0047887275,
-0.0431318395,
-0.0513259172,
0.0196756758,
0.0386401862,
0.014059687,
-0.0414502248,
0.0170417298,
-0.0652721003,
-0.0247883163,
0.0518937856,
-0.0421357267,
-0.0132288011,
-0.0117793353,
0.0203348435,
0.0284395907,
0.0023436279,
-0.0007936096,
-0.0472640321,
0.0283374079,
0.0013594348,
-0.0201276578,
-0.0183472447,
-5.68877883e-33,
-0.0028394558,
-0.0072697368,
-0.0043955757,
0.0008406323,
0.0215874538,
0.0547096543,
0.0101794805,
-0.0055484627,
0.0006606624,
0.0260015596,
-0.0262644645,
-0.0155823128,
0.0016215906,
0.0136743551,
-0.0276203789,
-0.0560705364,
0.0560010448,
-0.001551297,
-0.0507756807,
-0.0167721044,
-0.0176915713,
0.082039535,
0.0211065225,
-0.0588328913,
0.0077041076,
0.0260603428,
0.0255779289,
-0.0098135378,
0.000482508,
0.0597848929,
-0.0248676259,
0.0740516186,
0.0408441238,
-0.0210245326,
-0.0009017846,
0.0591565333,
-0.0594867133,
-0.0184225999,
-0.0011281729,
0.0263263732,
0.024383558,
-0.0007135697,
0.0616143867,
-0.0134231057,
-0.0366784036,
-0.0139127839,
0.0474919863,
-0.0347136632,
-0.0263840016,
-0.0490210652,
-0.0133791026,
0.0374858305,
0.0126862386,
0.0137303621,
-0.0241410118,
-0.0192622505,
-0.0221285932,
0.0642104968,
-0.0458069295,
-0.0169078056,
0.0611824282,
0.0154048353,
-0.0254804436,
0.0251592007,
-0.0355334766,
0.063773796,
0.006074599,
0.0145812985,
-0.0311150756,
0.0006264317,
-0.012883299,
-0.0256765131,
0.0256180391,
0.0164880697,
0.0492975637,
-0.0059881415,
-0.0837238804,
0.0325004309,
-0.0546014719,
0.0093347896,
0.0555573031,
-0.0418070517,
-0.0498688631,
-0.0253403187,
-0.0369103737,
-0.0140588116,
-0.0037981283,
-0.0004158813,
0.0068016886,
0.0382723734,
0.0142574599,
0.0308096521,
0.0052293786,
-0.034852311,
-0.0174265802,
-0.0249666497,
0.0551044941,
-0.0072015063,
-0.0481614582,
-0.0077437735,
-0.0045554671,
-0.0286624264,
0.0333664417,
-0.0064813979,
0.0452220216,
-0.0176846925,
0.0736197382,
-0.006504477,
-0.0773980394,
-0.0174144637,
0.0401989631,
-0.007161547,
0.0166503266,
0.0656577572,
0.0343989246,
0.0415856987,
-0.0027949591,
0.096462056,
-0.008603679,
-0.0474308394,
0.0132626807,
-0.0446969345,
0.0006078908,
0.0037555485,
-0.0600899793,
0.0042134798,
0.0112723829,
0.0409407988,
0.0651666895,
-0.0741514191,
-0.0079484796,
-0.03397559,
2.62e-7,
0.1125795469,
0.0492667146,
-0.0091815218,
-0.0871202052,
0.0101723401,
0.005718905,
0.0191193931,
0.0265263543,
0.0009917037,
0.028696401,
0.0283666681,
-0.0057561998,
0.0150816282,
0.0111275064,
-0.0856010169,
-0.0322125144,
-0.0958370492,
0.0169235431,
-0.0235540476,
0.0201300215,
0.0708504245,
0.1124164537,
-0.02856916,
-0.0305125285,
-0.0032976922,
-0.0104089957,
0.0450161025,
-0.0871568769,
0.0186107568,
0.0105462987,
0.0397827663,
-0.0098813567,
0.0411185622,
0.0593486689,
-0.0192855969,
0.0468017347,
0.0042971773,
0.05373751,
-0.0326245762,
0.01458441,
0.0263673514,
0.0091602243,
-0.004294998,
-0.0375368595,
0.0632098019,
-0.0766943842,
-0.0517467335,
-0.0283455737,
0.0004560402,
-0.0213949438,
0.0846101567,
-0.0391027033,
-0.0345093496,
0.0303679723,
0.0245253798,
0.0214585382,
-0.0274590366,
-0.0596301705,
-0.0235416945,
0.0261901971,
-0.0061610844,
-0.0187477879,
0.0238151755,
-0.041132275,
0.0275255386,
-0.0394433327,
0.0489170738,
2.393290657e-34,
0.0366900861,
0.0226912592,
-0.0063459957,
-0.0303233601,
0.0169800967,
-0.0093923649,
0.0771536827,
0.0134015651,
0.021513693,
-0.0802835003,
-0.0074855941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16757v1 | How can Deep Learning Retrieve the Write-Missing Additional Diagnosis from Chinese Electronic Medical Record For DRG | 2023-03-28T08:56:31 | 2023-03-28T08:56:31 | Shaohui Liu, Xien Liu, Ji Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The purpose of write-missing diagnosis detection is to find diseases that
have been clearly diagnosed from medical records but are missed in the
discharge diagnosis. Unlike the definition of missed diagnosis, the
write-missing diagnosis is clearly manifested in the medical record without
further reasoning. The write-missing diagnosis is a common problem, often
caused by physician negligence. The write-missing diagnosis will result in an
incomplete diagnosis of medical records. While under DRG grouping, the
write-missing diagnoses will miss important additional diagnoses (CC, MCC),
thus affecting the correct rate of DRG enrollment.
Under the circumstance that countries generally start to adopt DRG enrollment
and payment, the problem of write-missing diagnosis is a common and serious
problem. The current manual-based method is expensive due to the complex
content of the full medical record. We think this problem is suitable to be
solved as natural language processing. But to the best of our knowledge, no
researchers have conducted research on this problem based on natural language
processing methods.
We propose a framework for solving the problem of write-missing diagnosis,
which mainly includes three modules: disease recall module, disease context
logic judgment module, and disease relationship comparison module. Through this
framework, we verify that the problem of write-missing diagnosis can be solved
well, and the results are interpretable. At the same time, we propose advanced
solutions for the disease context logic judgment module and disease
relationship comparison module, which have obvious advantages compared with the
mainstream methods of the same type of problems. Finally, we verified the value
of our proposed framework under DRG medical insurance payment in a tertiary
hospital. | [
0.0725246519,
0.0506974161,
-0.0001805896,
-0.0097105205,
-0.0323414877,
0.0335817747,
-0.0161983334,
0.0324229151,
0.0443290807,
-0.0284928568,
0.0574165024,
-0.0543585792,
-0.0009131664,
0.0844392702,
-0.0157806985,
-0.0161235183,
0.0470539071,
0.0515526421,
0.0650706813,
0.0266884528,
-0.0358050838,
-0.0053656525,
-0.0277872961,
0.0161231235,
-0.0154164312,
-0.0002598074,
0.0138558792,
-0.0112945102,
0.043113891,
-0.0833467394,
0.025604086,
-0.0205817875,
-0.0341453478,
-0.0102964332,
0.0000020842,
-0.0607374236,
-0.0551089123,
-0.0069447272,
-0.0401023999,
-0.0376601703,
0.0094884448,
-0.0251885504,
-0.0048633572,
0.0208011158,
-0.0589428954,
-0.0471420586,
0.0071215397,
0.1208803207,
0.0309731923,
0.0857173651,
-0.0375362225,
-0.0215172227,
0.0308589768,
0.0002343327,
0.0071018562,
-0.0548579656,
0.0619623475,
0.0033349392,
0.021544328,
-0.0777643248,
-0.0066144252,
0.0195900314,
0.0101556825,
0.030413188,
-0.035941869,
0.0277756751,
0.0239470247,
0.0193383321,
-0.009904691,
0.0251768325,
-0.0146796172,
0.0120500736,
0.0542376041,
-0.0431127436,
-0.0024342323,
-0.0545317903,
0.0178297814,
0.0186110772,
-0.057702139,
-0.0050661531,
0.0497061387,
0.0064447187,
0.0370419323,
-0.000118643,
-0.0394536853,
0.0251754187,
-0.0152917411,
-0.0217876583,
-0.0382702127,
-0.0198712349,
0.0055568544,
-0.0329632387,
0.0555319898,
0.0589096993,
-0.055733569,
0.0120689571,
-0.014290168,
-0.0187693629,
0.0761483386,
-0.0422582701,
-0.0245560072,
-0.0004754417,
-0.0080437185,
0.0121228583,
-0.0327320546,
0.0148948394,
-0.0312013812,
0.018472502,
-0.0404410325,
-0.0124807656,
-0.0098299067,
-0.0220801383,
-0.0366456583,
0.0439518094,
0.0281120706,
0.011679478,
-0.1025398895,
-0.0395875499,
-0.041120477,
-0.0067136898,
0.0165260863,
0.044358559,
-0.0297157802,
0.0138373571,
-0.0543953739,
0.0105569204,
-0.0063865534,
0.0178467687,
-0.0031691864,
-0.0066428981,
0.0593478903,
0.0066241613,
0.0480060093,
0.0058453251,
0.035735663,
0.0536949448,
0.0442884117,
-0.0186499786,
-0.0758893415,
-0.049874682,
-0.0182735939,
-0.005605699,
-0.038893085,
-0.038759727,
-0.0184949543,
-0.0006302294,
-0.0210820884,
-0.0343603827,
0.0178588331,
0.0168860927,
-0.0070260027,
0.0247814842,
-0.0880675688,
-0.0205980279,
0.0228557847,
0.0031318797,
0.0171624385,
-0.026980469,
0.0350402817,
-0.0534756333,
-0.002137322,
-0.0049505681,
0.0299332272,
-0.0211286545,
0.0204085782,
-0.0766946226,
0.0075980024,
-0.0320464149,
-0.0314394794,
0.0412015878,
-0.0289275907,
0.0288840663,
0.0123782707,
-0.0135298921,
-0.0336006358,
0.0255517978,
0.0513850674,
-0.0196004603,
0.0075056418,
-0.0370380767,
-0.0494907685,
0.0168045834,
0.0177832544,
-0.0025560793,
-0.0078774141,
-0.0096219853,
-0.0395801142,
-0.0048970706,
-0.0174271278,
-0.0594049878,
-0.0305959731,
-0.0214449856,
0.0306657292,
-0.0361972675,
0.048337087,
0.0038631789,
-0.0382765047,
0.0261775702,
0.053411182,
-0.0007224997,
-0.0245514233,
-0.0846949369,
-0.0165278334,
0.0768993869,
0.0475310981,
-0.0506180748,
-0.0678328052,
-0.0117195398,
-0.0588562414,
-0.0322445482,
0.01250022,
0.0062195593,
0.001530309,
-0.039952565,
0.0020778859,
0.0664326325,
0.0258788131,
-0.0167790744,
-0.0293287188,
0.051967416,
0.0057675168,
0.0139538702,
-0.0161287431,
0.0293230712,
-0.0330600664,
0.0036263298,
0.0164584983,
0.0312233139,
0.0522277802,
0.027161764,
0.0094157662,
0.0200464893,
0.014912392,
-0.0454541482,
-0.0786488876,
-0.00248272,
-0.0736449584,
-0.0326294228,
0.0051057073,
-0.0361277685,
-0.0222864915,
-0.0226226263,
-0.0223677997,
-0.0490610637,
-0.0331734233,
-0.0121853072,
0.0039433478,
-0.0470912419,
0.0217814818,
0.0480175018,
-0.0282621868,
-0.0149171017,
0.0938939527,
-0.0056732437,
0.0210476182,
-0.0131783457,
-0.0363363251,
0.054020524,
-0.0313041992,
0.0124005945,
-0.0081642056,
-0.0550868511,
0.0275801793,
0.016281208,
-0.0110101057,
-0.0173027404,
0.015069765,
-0.0536850132,
0.0191359613,
-0.0026696944,
0.0091334609,
0.0049899123,
0.0383233391,
0.0107689118,
-0.0277829971,
-0.0475544184,
-0.0079271216,
0.0672184899,
-0.019766679,
0.0720719621,
0.0546403602,
-0.0040799002,
0.0076102423,
0.0035915307,
-0.0771102309,
-0.0046729296,
0.0358035639,
-0.0489282049,
-0.0221897978,
0.0187989343,
-0.0338116959,
0.0141032133,
-0.0127269188,
-0.0372889973,
-0.0198522434,
-0.0507564992,
-0.0625781044,
0.0344759077,
-0.0322034694,
0.0326254107,
0.0041934154,
0.0134428721,
0.0060017332,
0.0246198121,
-0.0499996245,
0.0482407324,
0.0162553042,
-0.0286000855,
0.015328127,
0.0355602168,
0.054461237,
-0.0205865614,
-0.0175336991,
-0.0074692541,
-0.0243527908,
0.0498200431,
-0.0214767959,
0.0079433359,
-0.0192594249,
0.0372851416,
0.0070000561,
-0.0051449239,
0.0884082615,
0.0492405035,
0.0411139838,
-0.1039167196,
-0.0554759093,
-0.0322872438,
0.0102219908,
-0.0063244323,
0.0291119721,
0.0100755943,
-0.0872952491,
0.0026188768,
0.0022572787,
0.0083934972,
-0.0229636058,
0.013630148,
-0.0039925207,
0.0480093099,
-0.0117626768,
0.0177670009,
-0.0498065688,
-0.0196310412,
0.00362629,
0.0158868246,
-0.0034688755,
0.011540168,
-0.0534200855,
0.0384176299,
-0.0564262755,
0.1023217887,
0.0261450093,
0.004834793,
-0.0176989604,
-0.0028346437,
-0.007838252,
-0.034829922,
0.0147143854,
-0.0065167542,
0.0034133808,
0.063729398,
-0.0208035707,
0.051006306,
-0.0046361731,
0.0306921881,
-0.039959915,
-0.0404966958,
-0.0186680555,
0.0356533788,
-0.0319068171,
-0.0856012255,
0.0174103212,
0.0754957497,
0.0230382457,
-0.0151110897,
0.0094610099,
0.0089818388,
-0.0787878633,
-0.0262859594,
-0.0044101235,
-0.0700575411,
-0.0125073604,
0.0049688099,
-0.0115931612,
-0.0285478383,
-0.0501959883,
0.0349332653,
-0.0161414891,
0.0427268706,
-0.0177502744,
-0.0057343454,
-0.0643297881,
-0.0317270681,
-0.0308105163,
0.0177226383,
-0.0127940597,
-0.0118869431,
0.0158179086,
-0.0281012785,
-0.0113913538,
-0.0845243186,
-0.0736950785,
0.0254915543,
-0.0277790129,
0.0172149763,
0.0753929168,
0.0493295677,
-0.0231486931,
-0.0087877074,
-0.0152835548,
0.0089461021,
0.0089765601,
-0.0187818781,
0.0907743946,
0.0279513206,
-0.0226199683,
-0.0673668534,
0.0058358517,
-0.0623357221,
-0.0044050682,
-0.0082887616,
0.07983917,
-0.0508107804,
-0.0335341208,
-0.0414089486,
-0.0056275134,
0.0462250412,
0.0398681052,
-0.0360958539,
0.0024435779,
-0.0327538848,
0.0257831234,
0.0462588556,
-0.0135038067,
0.0374053828,
0.0673758388,
-0.0421629995,
-0.0351370908,
-0.0496842675,
-0.0403358378,
0.0274783503,
0.0070265979,
0.0241824444,
0.0334328189,
0.0532770418,
-0.0200219005,
-0.0733170211,
-0.0103738625,
0.026464561,
0.0365393534,
-0.0545932688,
0.0076992703,
0.0262629986,
0.0391354188,
-0.0214727148,
-0.0356061943,
-0.0045201369,
-0.0065751104,
-0.0057348213,
-0.0403415374,
0.0132140182,
-0.0304222964,
-0.0062427605,
0.0054770643,
-0.0094319973,
0.0469711497,
-0.0076990165,
-0.0328482613,
-0.0168932453,
-0.0298792701,
-0.0259889606,
-0.0084158275,
-0.0007667319,
0.0180160776,
-0.0025246246,
0.0271419231,
-0.0228452254,
0.0226067733,
0.0300514139,
0.0356800072,
0.040652439,
-0.0016595679,
-0.0407086127,
-0.0568470657,
0.0287548136,
-0.0040156436,
-0.0018447973,
-0.0279950462,
0.0120150009,
0.0087493286,
-0.0113289384,
0.0082473578,
-0.0054322188,
-0.032790985,
-0.0744255409,
-0.022323506,
0.0513390079,
0.0650204793,
0.0265502371,
0.0369252302,
-0.012931101,
0.0301468745,
-0.0218866896,
0.0481472723,
0.0316912718,
-0.0263533089,
0.0493884906,
0.0303959139,
0.0301899146,
-0.0443447568,
-0.027297657,
0.0069656274,
0.0027328713,
-0.0016878896,
0.0001782211,
0.0759189874,
0.0089120409,
-0.0393464901,
-0.0351932682,
0.0217952412,
-0.0189627782,
0.0547509938,
-0.0031429131,
0.0186347775,
0.0173827484,
0.0000040307,
-0.027668776,
-0.0031005065,
0.0679035261,
0.008818402,
0.0587487593,
-0.0308837593,
-0.0296364781,
-0.0246131569,
-0.0004176511,
0.051351849,
0.0304013509,
-0.0452442802,
-0.0041258219,
-0.0392413102,
-0.0399679691,
0.0223042332,
-0.0046475907,
-0.0234759487,
-0.0093253916,
0.0178649332,
0.0254955944,
0.0233219583,
-0.0073351325,
-0.0196923837,
0.0332450084,
-0.0089419764,
-0.0069688251,
0.0038333361,
-5.787503457e-33,
-0.003565182,
-0.0714291707,
0.0226716921,
-0.0336385779,
0.0335003883,
0.0409219377,
-0.0358596556,
-0.0304726083,
0.0204516333,
0.0377437063,
0.0080303755,
0.0251221973,
0.0271701142,
0.0392055809,
0.012263786,
-0.0168779958,
0.0477206632,
0.0460397676,
0.0123681398,
0.0133681037,
0.0156798288,
0.0779275671,
0.053571105,
-0.0949343219,
0.016840335,
-0.0097363442,
0.0039738473,
0.0247424487,
-0.0185845848,
0.057227999,
-0.0063301688,
0.0048864093,
0.0492599495,
0.0040576397,
0.0057939524,
0.011763867,
-0.0952293202,
-0.0479581393,
-0.0333574675,
0.0143672535,
-0.0038570694,
-0.0344222113,
0.0559692271,
-0.0114381984,
0.0107782064,
0.0389699154,
0.042836111,
-0.0201539099,
-0.0040396303,
-0.0485637374,
-0.0134114577,
0.0694234371,
0.0039423658,
0.0373044647,
-0.038635619,
-0.0170803629,
-0.0270269979,
0.016870698,
-0.0536874793,
-0.0114475936,
0.0191303026,
0.0150205484,
-0.0261204038,
-0.0387618579,
-0.0597986765,
0.058206819,
0.0403923765,
-0.0219004508,
-0.0214954335,
0.0042339605,
-0.0416723043,
0.0374100097,
0.0173386801,
0.0264808889,
0.0995125175,
-0.0444446132,
-0.0920609683,
0.0414502583,
-0.0722369552,
0.0661885887,
0.0093250405,
-0.0130268009,
-0.0850771517,
-0.0132304495,
0.0122186588,
0.0198830664,
-0.0413715132,
-0.0125727169,
0.0594777316,
0.0207227394,
-0.0188917927,
0.0240908898,
0.022714721,
-0.0517266877,
-0.0162973814,
-0.0141460337,
0.0640697777,
0.0079745511,
-0.0417755023,
-0.0028333815,
-0.0030100376,
-0.0464618802,
-0.0135613037,
-0.0044985185,
0.0288081057,
0.0225683432,
0.0489818044,
-0.0106988028,
-0.0359416381,
0.0271295756,
0.0780336261,
-0.0226563588,
-0.0285982825,
0.0553664789,
-0.0006829916,
0.0214743409,
0.0065534147,
0.0403403305,
0.0335680172,
0.001727724,
-0.0543140732,
-0.0191567168,
-0.0104131885,
-0.0086193681,
-0.0351300575,
-0.0230335128,
-0.0529143848,
0.0279482007,
0.0511154793,
-0.0244170241,
0.0154247656,
-0.0059680264,
2.863e-7,
0.0525419936,
0.0182298832,
0.03051663,
-0.0376081467,
0.0088502569,
0.0396994688,
0.0063612279,
-0.0116385156,
-0.0016178185,
0.049997326,
0.057028994,
-0.0267243925,
-0.0004154254,
0.0289400145,
-0.0494009219,
0.0442162268,
-0.0125270113,
-0.0132554499,
-0.0178804398,
0.0201864205,
0.0700265244,
0.0528398715,
-0.0047724801,
-0.0419180728,
0.0328995921,
-0.0128962919,
-0.0195823647,
0.0167101286,
-0.0101901367,
0.0085276915,
0.073082529,
0.0430036969,
0.0396190062,
0.0489538163,
-0.007422355,
0.0091625713,
-0.0007666576,
0.0908684507,
-0.0473463349,
0.0309029166,
0.0135866664,
-0.0186415091,
0.0216327738,
0.0252506025,
0.049475275,
-0.0329485014,
-0.0203644671,
-0.0220513213,
-0.0102796527,
-0.0113042993,
0.0223571956,
0.0326361768,
-0.0247526504,
0.0079846559,
0.0080011683,
0.006942037,
-0.0288898125,
-0.0593416132,
0.0072065643,
0.0299819261,
0.0137718804,
0.0029791116,
0.0561812855,
-0.007511944,
0.0649598464,
-0.0786728933,
0.0150297219,
2.669515987e-34,
0.0432582572,
0.0046234434,
-0.0243715122,
-0.003236044,
0.0171828885,
-0.0003403174,
0.0029420764,
0.039905075,
-0.0182439834,
-0.0269686077,
-0.031275969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16779v1 | Language Models Trained on Media Diets Can Predict Public Opinion | 2023-03-28T06:08:25 | 2023-03-28T06:08:25 | Eric Chu, Jacob Andreas, Stephen Ansolabehere, Deb Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Public opinion reflects and shapes societal behavior, but the traditional
survey-based tools to measure it are limited. We introduce a novel approach to
probe media diet models -- language models adapted to online news, TV
broadcast, or radio show content -- that can emulate the opinions of
subpopulations that have consumed a set of media. To validate this method, we
use as ground truth the opinions expressed in U.S. nationally representative
surveys on COVID-19 and consumer confidence. Our studies indicate that this
approach is (1) predictive of human judgements found in survey response
distributions and robust to phrasing and channels of media exposure, (2) more
accurate at modeling people who follow media more closely, and (3) aligned with
literature on which types of opinions are affected by media consumption.
Probing language models provides a powerful new method for investigating media
effects, has practical applications in supplementing polls and forecasting
public opinion, and suggests a need for further study of the surprising
fidelity with which neural language models can predict human responses. | [
0.0397441462,
0.1172504723,
-0.005067246,
-0.0439097174,
0.0098878816,
0.00307465,
-0.0049134032,
0.0093834838,
0.0202978291,
-0.0480936058,
-0.0159482565,
-0.0375768989,
-0.0480243415,
0.0372910611,
0.023089014,
-0.0248920638,
0.0201852806,
0.0348849893,
0.0746013671,
-0.0117011992,
0.0397873782,
0.0337130427,
0.0142162992,
0.0295790732,
-0.0209695511,
-0.006761163,
0.0095977057,
0.0035169374,
0.0372936912,
-0.0236729123,
0.0359555818,
0.0421375036,
0.0601359792,
0.0076205744,
0.0000016349,
0.0124777425,
0.0311242118,
-0.0143941874,
0.0371119082,
0.0329071991,
0.1076479182,
-0.0167299435,
0.0030823064,
0.014077438,
-0.0375175402,
0.0092580682,
0.0450246111,
-0.0015029333,
0.056181103,
0.0495808646,
-0.0093621965,
-0.0399500951,
-0.0159216803,
-0.0114628272,
-0.0019061762,
0.0048241657,
0.0532056391,
-0.0496396497,
-0.0398374796,
0.01765549,
0.0065357592,
0.0221536364,
-0.0079710493,
0.0046532704,
-0.0538551025,
0.0277334619,
-0.0307807587,
-0.0243246313,
-0.0024568888,
0.0558934249,
0.0241580065,
-0.0307537038,
0.0124672195,
0.0007339365,
-0.0024081583,
0.054707747,
-0.022745369,
-0.0149832228,
0.0115783801,
0.048191797,
-0.0072675212,
0.0063908589,
0.0552603975,
0.0163910296,
0.0296597295,
0.1249689832,
0.0094286781,
-0.0182602499,
-0.0042736968,
0.0123147788,
0.0012368357,
-0.0323941112,
0.0511486009,
-0.0338341035,
0.0211321302,
0.0309673734,
0.0082196668,
-0.0170052201,
0.0133039625,
-0.0949653462,
-0.0163346566,
0.0211502686,
-0.0111330766,
0.018155938,
0.0433506034,
-0.0116696265,
-0.0154543594,
0.0119094066,
0.0075768987,
0.0513658263,
-0.0630300865,
0.0146513656,
0.0202405769,
0.0074989768,
-0.0090874061,
-0.0291115474,
-0.0361335017,
-0.0151595008,
-0.0261801723,
-0.0115371617,
-0.0373547636,
0.0363245457,
-0.0197255369,
-0.0209854711,
-0.0600997992,
0.0951534733,
-0.0314091146,
0.0517092422,
0.0105287898,
0.0098350272,
0.0376529545,
0.0005786894,
-0.0166967474,
0.0119058136,
0.0088402042,
0.0226915479,
0.0246646646,
0.0327858403,
-0.013630664,
-0.0112844585,
-0.0480359755,
-0.0394120663,
0.0105840033,
-0.050707642,
0.0227475371,
0.0004296536,
0.0188592654,
-0.0310480557,
0.0010774856,
0.0321004726,
-0.0586414114,
0.0533370301,
0.0577492006,
0.0279061459,
0.0267957244,
0.0360281728,
0.1029993221,
0.0550584048,
0.0169994142,
0.0507951118,
0.0179751329,
-0.0035339054,
-0.0069147632,
0.0233197454,
0.0071908548,
0.0221832562,
-0.0673596784,
-0.0091426009,
-0.0353639089,
0.0153820291,
0.0222469419,
0.0591983721,
0.0084884986,
-0.016298553,
0.1228245273,
0.035229452,
-0.0572020747,
0.009379887,
0.0266790967,
0.0421615578,
-0.0025091656,
0.0284232814,
-0.0113505358,
0.0159495194,
-0.0027187811,
-0.0059195729,
0.0281060413,
0.0268250257,
-0.0447790883,
-0.0208237693,
-0.0063892738,
0.0037422122,
0.0786016956,
0.0035707392,
0.0069508669,
-0.0403069519,
-0.0577441268,
0.0263945553,
0.0522654168,
-0.0412847698,
0.0246521104,
-0.0311874282,
0.0493299104,
0.0243180003,
-0.0084200231,
0.0188026205,
0.014371492,
-0.0270854943,
0.0656855851,
0.029581314,
0.0455930829,
-0.0158945676,
-0.0287545342,
-0.0091188969,
0.0216943584,
0.0061473958,
0.0674898103,
0.059270829,
-0.0275796372,
0.021901466,
-0.0236431062,
-0.0248053353,
-0.0118896486,
-0.0064641982,
0.0165350009,
-0.0274616145,
-0.0236344561,
0.0073531121,
0.0287349485,
0.0326533988,
-0.0069196224,
0.0289505571,
0.0274032559,
-0.0108378008,
-0.0321764611,
-0.0166084245,
0.0051250965,
-0.0031809318,
-0.0200052392,
-0.0402486064,
-0.0013606083,
0.0371102467,
-0.0284481719,
0.0036658566,
0.0520539619,
-0.0126159154,
0.0162697565,
-0.0359971374,
-0.0369799957,
-0.0220933743,
-0.005950727,
-0.0208843965,
0.0307527054,
-0.0276331082,
-0.0102698728,
-0.0094291912,
-0.0278876666,
-0.0113160918,
-0.0167316627,
-0.0417754762,
-0.0133675449,
0.0286618285,
0.0231762752,
0.0319727361,
-0.029400304,
-0.0369650573,
-0.0195103921,
-0.0475283265,
0.00210685,
-0.0108244596,
0.0316328593,
0.0171291661,
-0.0199755635,
-0.005995939,
-0.004996439,
-0.0488036759,
-0.0084867207,
-0.0214449503,
0.0464353673,
-0.0146815432,
0.0117325811,
0.0139595931,
-0.0245433617,
-0.0347922668,
-0.0519885346,
0.0068798903,
0.0075292592,
-0.0244225562,
-0.0060996902,
-0.0303608123,
-0.059873037,
-0.0165156852,
0.0051424108,
-0.0665604472,
-0.0072371364,
0.0310369413,
-0.0134808403,
0.0648114607,
0.0364251509,
0.0221823007,
0.060499683,
0.0269866008,
-0.0450635143,
-0.021823559,
-0.0705316514,
-0.0379914865,
-0.0362033062,
-0.0533982515,
0.025352478,
0.0797011703,
0.0226317104,
0.0095687443,
-0.0493582152,
0.0689083487,
-0.0183006376,
-0.0299446695,
-0.0303237606,
-0.0157661121,
-0.0166865978,
0.051916223,
-0.004376757,
-0.0209234599,
0.0563516617,
0.0113025466,
0.0480188876,
-0.02726423,
-0.0124949329,
0.0013141653,
-0.0333745666,
0.0209514182,
0.0308460705,
0.0224222634,
-0.0042769681,
-0.0540655255,
-0.0640242621,
-0.0089548426,
-0.0391982049,
0.0151485745,
-0.0439646654,
-0.013206738,
0.0562496111,
-0.0192490462,
-0.0099559762,
-0.0763324723,
-0.0568645373,
-0.0056856149,
0.0360412821,
-0.0028005727,
-0.0568132289,
0.0041944962,
-0.0084543703,
-0.0635624602,
0.0117278658,
0.0134544782,
0.0317373499,
0.0273204129,
0.0793708414,
-0.0350363366,
0.0002208731,
-0.0224289261,
-0.0038692944,
0.0242201388,
-0.0113907931,
0.0579508841,
-0.0452351645,
0.0198690668,
0.0086692115,
0.0318517722,
-0.0241053943,
0.0400299691,
0.0395281166,
-0.0016550348,
0.0195047297,
0.1018478572,
0.0116482312,
-0.0489564314,
-0.0155882575,
0.0451308787,
-0.0039296686,
0.0290115476,
0.038490504,
-0.0471561141,
0.0007747589,
-0.0043633869,
-0.000906868,
-0.0390873738,
-0.0123848403,
-0.0138024958,
-0.0812839344,
0.0199863333,
0.0015006816,
0.0061398321,
0.0205563083,
-0.0635897145,
0.0165499244,
-0.0258827787,
-0.0030331144,
-0.051626619,
0.0398691595,
0.0199606474,
-0.0149020869,
-0.0415817909,
-0.0386171639,
0.0396235324,
-0.0259042643,
0.0612317324,
0.0561761335,
0.078594923,
-0.0056534233,
-0.0704929903,
0.0155607602,
0.0110986168,
-0.0151884994,
0.0006344495,
0.0734048113,
-0.0422667153,
0.0052330983,
-0.0437691994,
0.0350997001,
-0.0160521604,
-0.0100748604,
-0.0365314148,
0.0167153925,
0.0212322846,
-0.0858779252,
-0.0403716527,
0.0639925897,
0.0587025769,
0.048350621,
0.0286598857,
-0.0721890777,
0.0082398467,
-0.0214740913,
0.0075424365,
-0.0166034754,
-0.0540625006,
0.0094337873,
-0.0248169471,
-0.052788496,
-0.0256248619,
-0.0035998048,
-0.025455473,
0.0037035635,
0.022244852,
-0.0225633383,
0.0836153701,
-0.0282582827,
0.0231615212,
0.0442067832,
0.0195345078,
-0.0061382065,
-0.0234216377,
-0.0352073573,
0.0336690359,
0.0317068063,
-0.0443050452,
0.0024146251,
-0.1081194207,
-0.073335357,
0.0267371964,
0.0428457186,
0.0181068126,
0.0135925235,
0.0023648767,
-0.0258430056,
0.0331616588,
0.05410726,
-0.0516886488,
-0.017683778,
-0.0139975203,
0.03160014,
0.0031789287,
0.033117231,
0.003502537,
0.0422012173,
0.0181437805,
-0.0146626029,
-0.0798055604,
-0.0265598483,
0.0143881338,
-0.0423425436,
0.0362639278,
0.0028173372,
-0.034116596,
-0.0389798433,
-0.0608909987,
-0.0286099724,
-0.0029107989,
0.0067677614,
-0.0470270067,
0.0453659073,
0.0031817991,
-0.0680641532,
-0.0178537872,
-0.0536823384,
0.0547495261,
-0.0397048928,
0.0094775204,
0.0183393527,
0.004677345,
0.0218164697,
-0.021736769,
-0.0001035135,
0.039904967,
-0.0210458282,
0.0087691313,
0.0162048209,
0.0242380518,
-0.0074844304,
0.0226725619,
-0.0048536547,
0.0025223256,
-0.0476912297,
-0.023917323,
-0.0361727774,
0.0145451901,
-0.028237097,
-0.0543311685,
-0.0116371764,
0.0118316365,
-0.0259742066,
-0.0073214001,
0.0347713493,
-0.0349289738,
-0.0400891416,
0.0554162897,
-0.0094796503,
-0.0241582561,
0.0096841007,
0.0558531098,
0.0234280825,
0.0179756843,
0.0452276357,
-0.068064332,
-0.0228863936,
0.0085793305,
0.0224881265,
0.0482530929,
-0.0368974619,
0.008254189,
-0.0637218729,
-0.0830859467,
0.0171734933,
-0.0041337521,
0.0099781165,
-0.0120079555,
0.0068960539,
0.0424755029,
-0.0066346368,
0.0491524972,
-0.0330798775,
0.01606353,
-0.090676859,
-0.0285382271,
-0.0532126203,
-5.76709761e-33,
-0.0105182668,
0.0085003413,
-0.0128056789,
-0.0171777885,
0.0133186188,
-0.0000174284,
-0.0459587239,
0.0061748857,
0.0165887699,
0.0285341069,
0.0197380502,
0.0269962996,
0.0067780879,
0.0010908985,
0.0137295574,
-0.0492131338,
0.0557208359,
-0.0214954223,
-0.0284009166,
-0.0185989458,
0.009091042,
0.0263957102,
0.0278130453,
-0.0957532451,
0.0282981768,
0.0156045258,
-0.0052514225,
-0.0511363745,
0.0237328466,
0.0327407643,
-0.0238396302,
0.0432457887,
0.0347687677,
-0.0428373367,
0.0077304263,
0.1172925308,
-0.0291576348,
-0.0233649537,
0.0110881226,
-0.0311606564,
-0.0105559574,
-0.0129498383,
0.0225765016,
0.0014813757,
-0.0393088795,
0.0396811515,
0.03836108,
-0.0067302622,
0.022033982,
0.0238393415,
-0.0212502107,
-0.0214756299,
-0.0204418339,
0.0135809202,
-0.0421656445,
0.0549616963,
-0.0189616624,
0.0720741898,
-0.0423865132,
0.057436794,
-0.0201418418,
0.0115122069,
0.0571312308,
-0.0177684221,
0.026316911,
0.0827142075,
0.0268717632,
-0.0006272896,
-0.0732911229,
-0.0093904939,
0.0294568054,
0.0014241075,
0.0050146123,
0.0657138005,
0.0307550132,
-0.0653519556,
-0.0239001084,
0.0226372667,
0.0173368379,
0.0068962388,
0.0532359369,
-0.012092378,
0.0015678671,
-0.0336558186,
-0.0407221243,
-0.0824253932,
-0.0216352958,
-0.0496426299,
0.0103902575,
-0.0019610692,
-0.0115501843,
-0.0050021345,
0.0248700939,
-0.0068263807,
-0.0332417935,
0.0125220837,
-0.0163981616,
-0.0238288064,
0.0059469407,
0.0638033971,
-0.0752186924,
0.0608821176,
-0.0332817174,
0.0471151248,
-0.0015679062,
-0.0187670402,
0.0002917878,
0.0170558896,
-0.0545173623,
-0.0284003858,
-0.0066025816,
-0.0251235366,
0.0409578606,
0.0524117462,
0.0364946872,
0.025263859,
0.0033859466,
-0.0220225658,
-0.0202418342,
-0.0012258479,
0.0333743691,
-0.0434922501,
-0.0345957838,
0.024806207,
-0.0570037812,
-0.0415454693,
-0.011218166,
0.0132457092,
0.0013467413,
-0.0573874339,
-0.030005414,
-0.0065568304,
2.333e-7,
0.0642919168,
0.0646444485,
-0.0434532762,
0.004316661,
0.0245455727,
0.0364993401,
0.0114993006,
0.0162272733,
0.0386756286,
-0.0991299748,
-0.0089052934,
-0.0069531896,
-0.000549976,
0.022936957,
-0.0854479074,
0.0212423708,
-0.0558681339,
0.0483808666,
-0.030958876,
-0.005543543,
-0.0018628322,
0.0738984123,
0.0359327905,
-0.0180617515,
-0.0249890704,
0.0010844428,
0.0517324358,
-0.0419010669,
-0.0582688004,
-0.0119857257,
-0.0090926131,
0.0241569504,
-0.004690933,
0.0352459699,
-0.0240806844,
-0.0336279012,
0.0159073994,
0.0526954643,
0.0169918332,
-0.0457811989,
-0.0285965502,
0.0216371566,
-0.0312280711,
-0.0295366347,
0.0441157259,
-0.0902022198,
-0.0661630407,
-0.0497166738,
-0.0145706777,
-0.00198287,
0.0378338248,
-0.0180928633,
-0.0166913699,
-0.023171939,
0.0059770201,
0.0224136338,
0.0124533353,
-0.0305648223,
-0.0060444549,
0.0057573076,
-0.0626367182,
-0.0529388674,
-0.0272040367,
0.0234924983,
-0.0285611451,
-0.0595437884,
0.0439845435,
1.840794651e-34,
0.0677460358,
0.0435130969,
-0.028480947,
-0.0424591042,
0.0174837131,
0.0255623143,
-0.0116543546,
-0.0257756319,
0.0239391997,
-0.0807870552,
0.0015194796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15727v1 | Evaluation of ChatGPT for NLP-based Mental Health Applications | 2023-03-28T04:47:43 | 2023-03-28T04:47:43 | Bishal Lamichhane | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLM) have been successful in several natural language
understanding tasks and could be relevant for natural language processing
(NLP)-based mental health application research. In this work, we report the
performance of LLM-based ChatGPT (with gpt-3.5-turbo backend) in three
text-based mental health classification tasks: stress detection (2-class
classification), depression detection (2-class classification), and suicidality
detection (5-class classification). We obtained annotated social media posts
for the three classification tasks from public datasets. Then ChatGPT API
classified the social media posts with an input prompt for classification. We
obtained F1 scores of 0.73, 0.86, and 0.37 for stress detection, depression
detection, and suicidality detection, respectively. A baseline model that
always predicted the dominant class resulted in F1 scores of 0.35, 0.60, and
0.19. The zero-shot classification accuracy obtained with ChatGPT indicates a
potential use of language models for mental health classification tasks. | [
0.0487945601,
-0.0009263867,
-0.0196059011,
-0.0089918086,
-0.0463081561,
0.0397045575,
0.0012563996,
0.0216726419,
0.1102537215,
-0.0774443969,
0.0114359055,
-0.0154758524,
-0.0137628568,
-0.0055963164,
-0.0414177924,
-0.0598630048,
0.0179321263,
0.0283529013,
0.0677732453,
0.0285492148,
0.0020706321,
0.0382812843,
-0.022983456,
0.0688194931,
-0.0083018495,
-0.0434293263,
0.026368726,
-0.0067120669,
0.0135855675,
-0.075479582,
0.0057746856,
0.0713095143,
-0.0130201764,
0.0171424598,
0.0000019561,
-0.0267106071,
-0.0267703272,
0.0193326529,
0.007787575,
-0.0463635139,
0.0639904737,
-0.0243319925,
0.0067002843,
0.0452601016,
-0.0408066772,
-0.0402599312,
0.0341139883,
0.0885465443,
0.063879624,
0.0706880391,
-0.0367392413,
-0.0270879455,
0.0313498229,
-0.0002498885,
-0.0054485234,
-0.0018923292,
0.0575431585,
0.0209165066,
0.0397185236,
0.0003303577,
-0.0017210493,
0.0097964182,
-0.0435389467,
0.0611190349,
-0.029518649,
0.0043863533,
-0.052863244,
-0.0326986276,
-0.0012933941,
0.0404866152,
-0.0209710505,
0.0104760425,
0.0173664913,
-0.0141172698,
-0.0132630561,
-0.0300137289,
-0.0419768877,
-0.0046560206,
-0.0283863898,
0.0298979655,
0.0378566384,
0.0084537612,
0.0114929061,
-0.0160171166,
0.0620801002,
0.020929357,
-0.0062194965,
-0.0250563454,
0.0132889897,
0.0048144064,
-0.0742828995,
-0.0491930395,
0.0206892658,
0.0077893864,
-0.0268308632,
0.0200069826,
-0.0335953198,
-0.043470528,
0.0349799059,
-0.0581571832,
-0.0238252655,
0.0514422618,
-0.0358743519,
-0.0007929318,
0.0417935811,
0.0164636169,
0.0390784554,
-0.0045381016,
-0.0069526485,
0.0073046414,
-0.1130116507,
0.0058351802,
-0.0310231689,
0.0405371785,
0.0149356648,
-0.0315541737,
-0.1102169827,
0.0145082353,
0.0016242962,
-0.0449435376,
0.0129294256,
-0.0352379121,
0.0146507202,
0.0439966433,
0.0197752528,
0.0124179041,
0.0092994859,
-0.0090082148,
-0.0357553586,
-0.0613826811,
0.0518176407,
-0.0224563535,
-0.0154422522,
-0.0399866998,
0.0150749916,
0.0462660417,
0.0498999394,
-0.0552591607,
-0.0772614852,
-0.0057893284,
-0.0312460475,
-0.0396697484,
-0.0223643649,
-0.03019589,
0.0206671543,
0.0460623577,
0.0134091033,
-0.0055326824,
0.0398596637,
0.0076918821,
-0.0587848574,
0.0616522506,
-0.0347612426,
0.0196351893,
0.0460416414,
0.0153470188,
-0.0242322013,
0.0712234601,
0.0079067862,
0.0097268475,
0.0532624461,
-0.0512228459,
0.0111778984,
0.011494725,
-0.0247192197,
-0.0605767369,
0.0280479603,
-0.0240944978,
-0.0336359516,
0.0297435503,
-0.0561455712,
0.0333183743,
0.0164575949,
0.0200614668,
0.0455049798,
0.0827576146,
0.0359505005,
0.0467393175,
-0.0218144618,
0.0560021475,
-0.0151896235,
-0.0296825022,
-0.0581536405,
0.0021703602,
-0.0462164618,
-0.0207427088,
0.0212556291,
0.0171553399,
-0.0137423016,
-0.05074922,
-0.0828708634,
-0.019667279,
0.0022954985,
-0.0237539671,
0.0087619387,
-0.0478662513,
-0.0188369565,
0.0312549658,
0.0479448773,
0.0065712715,
-0.0494292341,
-0.0590046272,
-0.0033401125,
0.062803179,
0.025847422,
-0.0504830927,
-0.019749077,
-0.0237567648,
0.0223558247,
0.0088998061,
0.0233302806,
0.026168013,
-0.0021067664,
-0.0157829374,
0.0028670053,
0.0395281985,
0.0077673295,
-0.0268467609,
0.0141322995,
0.0390764661,
-0.0170050226,
0.0108494107,
-0.0365372524,
0.0398557931,
0.0469277091,
-0.0447534211,
0.0210808255,
-0.0017633905,
0.0499720648,
0.0263788421,
-0.0068494384,
-0.0057955701,
-0.0017020329,
-0.0070379549,
-0.0595155172,
-0.0114977136,
-0.0060460577,
-0.0291879345,
0.0153646152,
0.0224498864,
0.0066161514,
0.0557393245,
-0.0345309339,
-0.0247490741,
0.0084085241,
-0.0508925393,
0.0306628365,
-0.0184249431,
-0.0232974086,
-0.01066087,
0.0319180936,
-0.0389050543,
0.0533810295,
0.0187097061,
0.0347072482,
-0.0425565168,
-0.0504277982,
-0.0124512315,
-0.0149413394,
-0.0457313918,
0.0009315814,
-0.0153898299,
0.0230791662,
-0.0148580819,
0.0086866906,
-0.0178667773,
-0.0260578748,
-0.1594552845,
0.0428037494,
-0.0167648308,
0.0060548256,
0.0100900866,
0.0030155606,
-0.041989252,
-0.0096282382,
-0.0156137925,
0.0531517453,
0.049813617,
0.04176002,
0.0058389911,
-0.0151814353,
0.004364497,
-0.0347375646,
-0.0027794866,
-0.0502387583,
0.017936904,
0.0166110341,
-0.0543923229,
-0.0101043051,
-0.0045488779,
-0.0352386311,
0.0078607295,
0.0128556928,
-0.0392385796,
0.0125815552,
-0.0125644077,
0.0399347991,
0.0116780857,
0.0111943549,
0.0545366071,
0.0116912844,
0.0085135624,
0.0020164591,
0.0183729753,
-0.035833139,
-0.0324494429,
-0.026261216,
-0.0189423002,
-0.0240193568,
0.0662658736,
0.0353842042,
-0.0076204613,
-0.061847169,
-0.00756191,
-0.0444802195,
0.0604883507,
-0.0256840121,
0.0361745618,
0.0096838363,
-0.0083760023,
0.0051616519,
-0.0438296311,
0.0350291207,
0.0061019887,
-0.005866528,
-0.0608333945,
-0.0507703759,
-0.0531045794,
0.0542396121,
0.012553785,
0.0097172596,
0.031087812,
-0.0109034404,
0.0507703088,
-0.0266190916,
-0.0304197073,
-0.0431724265,
0.003083643,
-0.0430489667,
0.0004321348,
0.0199260674,
-0.0283961147,
-0.0403891206,
-0.0561377034,
-0.0765013546,
-0.0137619684,
-0.0219588373,
0.0230452698,
-0.0153089501,
0.0180342216,
-0.0038762409,
0.0180432219,
-0.0406717695,
-0.023821909,
0.0162016917,
0.0095387045,
0.0474222936,
-0.0351394154,
0.0131971436,
0.0211113039,
0.0323854201,
0.0539110526,
-0.0256912857,
0.0534599349,
-0.0077522704,
0.0077780262,
-0.013234416,
-0.0294733122,
-0.0338870063,
0.0020793446,
0.0015415894,
-0.0218684543,
0.0048795477,
0.1406692266,
0.031537611,
-0.0320813619,
0.0176190026,
-0.0220920965,
-0.0115246661,
0.0051052375,
-0.0070306966,
-0.0330231041,
-0.054100275,
-0.0315909162,
0.0335210003,
-0.0347457193,
-0.0245568324,
-0.0003788668,
-0.0489703752,
0.0428173281,
-0.010508039,
-0.0180954095,
0.0323379077,
-0.0421101749,
0.0280647818,
-0.0339443944,
-0.0227867607,
-0.0567850508,
-0.0201210938,
0.0045573595,
0.0142220473,
-0.0900931731,
-0.0414844863,
0.0422858708,
0.0073222592,
0.0711884722,
-0.0021858474,
0.064484261,
-0.0100449333,
-0.0042081773,
0.0600004718,
0.0150506375,
0.0009726559,
-0.0299442858,
0.0693987161,
-0.0143069038,
0.0099568134,
-0.0539255999,
0.0306385066,
-0.0495517738,
0.0007742433,
0.0096629541,
0.0881054252,
-0.0167212673,
-0.0287419725,
-0.0367390886,
0.0318390764,
0.0327512585,
0.0694644004,
-0.0069072554,
-0.0524933152,
-0.0469355546,
0.0060406672,
-0.0111674014,
0.0375991128,
-0.0497534797,
0.0124586308,
-0.0246351585,
-0.0287628062,
-0.0316827968,
-0.0455734283,
0.0333041586,
-0.0539295599,
-0.0233335923,
0.0090554999,
0.0193358436,
0.0596679002,
-0.0612811185,
0.0266628638,
0.0322843492,
0.0196673553,
-0.0181857571,
0.0083535928,
0.0564931035,
-0.0068373764,
-0.0192427263,
0.0178958252,
-0.0760778487,
-0.0140614687,
0.0409887768,
0.0029952105,
0.0158244129,
-0.0496361665,
0.0092569934,
-0.028795654,
0.0129873194,
0.0431152582,
-0.0482506305,
-0.0189548172,
-0.0170808937,
0.0566789508,
0.0036186839,
0.0216654297,
0.0035756084,
0.0533533655,
0.0211588014,
-0.0226124916,
0.0018651464,
0.031169489,
-0.0193655603,
0.0336800031,
0.0485854372,
0.0185710546,
-0.0458972976,
0.001191222,
-0.0501050502,
0.0032616125,
-0.0033093092,
-0.0164949913,
-0.0308691896,
0.0266752262,
0.005775277,
-0.0659252778,
-0.0610416979,
-0.0443700217,
-0.0238716081,
-0.0495716743,
0.0071808607,
0.0167268496,
-0.0007933012,
0.011160926,
-0.0043280818,
-0.0261445101,
0.0155565385,
0.003579742,
0.0021804287,
-0.0279377643,
0.0874337405,
-0.0194817055,
0.0127065042,
0.0588162243,
0.0491109081,
-0.0486684926,
-0.0604235455,
-0.0191066545,
0.0206406936,
0.044535201,
0.0043577938,
0.069009535,
-0.0372297242,
0.0122541906,
-0.0314206295,
0.0369803384,
-0.0203763582,
-0.0143703502,
0.0057316436,
-0.0165080242,
-0.0401926115,
-0.0137731684,
0.0559801944,
0.0159179233,
-0.0088485461,
0.0715639964,
-0.0526408367,
-0.0344255455,
0.0191964768,
0.0130277174,
0.0311375763,
-0.0125525594,
0.030679347,
-0.0362539589,
-0.047506392,
0.0500464663,
-0.0465388484,
-0.0037456425,
-0.0271200556,
0.0182363838,
0.0505082794,
-0.0046465518,
-0.0214505475,
-0.0681489557,
0.0137460558,
-0.0582612269,
-0.0218424164,
-0.0237382315,
-5.731049606e-33,
-0.0068028863,
-0.0073133404,
0.0036280937,
0.0530576482,
-0.0138859907,
0.0281707607,
0.0141103836,
0.034877304,
0.0280424338,
0.002952002,
0.0201406796,
0.0580889955,
-0.0026149501,
0.0358085483,
0.0203842632,
-0.0112436963,
0.0076293298,
-0.0295329634,
0.0185607243,
0.0278404541,
-0.0004335185,
0.0720889866,
0.0542048253,
-0.0979113951,
0.0199654996,
0.005922412,
0.016576184,
0.0020544201,
0.0357591175,
0.03138965,
-0.0532429405,
0.0929746255,
0.0604759492,
-0.0199018084,
0.0267330632,
0.01617226,
-0.0325555615,
-0.0302755609,
0.0043604365,
-0.0051165959,
-0.0014849855,
0.0192830078,
0.0269578416,
-0.0102304369,
-0.011595821,
-0.054907769,
0.0356942788,
-0.0338137113,
0.0358895138,
-0.0069542141,
-0.0133044636,
0.0292552747,
-0.0086329347,
0.0032667003,
-0.012278799,
0.0273352489,
-0.0474612825,
0.0513629764,
-0.0269971211,
-0.0383427367,
-0.0048094685,
-0.0002816553,
-0.0131351901,
-0.0542102121,
-0.0171037745,
0.0524604507,
-0.001602172,
-0.0134279449,
-0.0255371723,
0.0039808522,
0.0000273047,
0.0473284759,
0.0625595674,
0.0153199611,
0.0199352726,
-0.0214103423,
-0.0528257526,
-0.0045485483,
0.0443987288,
-0.0175263137,
0.055974476,
-0.0116187539,
-0.0214768108,
-0.0062092743,
0.003451287,
-0.0165157393,
-0.0313602239,
-0.0231102239,
0.0231785793,
-0.0095217144,
0.0190962702,
-0.0059641981,
-0.0147482399,
-0.0368404649,
0.0004066021,
-0.0080036335,
-0.0022347518,
0.0424060449,
-0.0044906172,
0.0189554989,
-0.0309468433,
-0.0102227824,
-0.0089631584,
0.0158093087,
0.0504311919,
-0.0297544654,
0.0202907063,
-0.0119759776,
-0.0445598699,
-0.0148363085,
0.0192060601,
0.0491329432,
-0.0284574628,
0.0508366153,
-0.0175495669,
0.0198963005,
0.0067743161,
0.0403497517,
0.0233021304,
0.0404450744,
-0.0399736129,
-0.0344449691,
-0.0161087811,
-0.0142736733,
0.0033837156,
-0.0288546979,
0.0024302432,
0.006737533,
0.0139583107,
-0.0511693731,
0.0179268979,
-0.0209491383,
2.641e-7,
0.0509286635,
0.106888175,
-0.0493813492,
-0.0120332297,
0.0291222539,
0.0187379811,
0.0123483855,
0.0558781736,
0.0384754911,
-0.0019096609,
0.0096973814,
0.0207993649,
0.0533948913,
0.0671992823,
-0.0365994982,
-0.0445087254,
-0.0413529165,
-0.0160278417,
-0.071560435,
0.0470398627,
0.1146985665,
0.0900836065,
0.0185540318,
-0.0078638587,
-0.01043298,
-0.0191008337,
0.0344018042,
-0.0425602868,
-0.0040313117,
0.0353916772,
0.0368630998,
0.0264611468,
0.0227739234,
0.0086506223,
0.0153185679,
-0.0146375,
0.0182946883,
0.0545725599,
-0.0390339643,
0.0040230961,
0.0310399979,
0.0432974957,
-0.0063740285,
-0.0453884229,
0.0714542568,
-0.0855849609,
-0.0397522785,
-0.0477309525,
0.0077853594,
-0.0614204146,
0.0463160388,
0.0023661952,
-0.0217471868,
0.0360665061,
0.035975717,
-0.026854394,
-0.00731519,
-0.0697765574,
-0.0181497633,
0.030013185,
-0.0486133136,
-0.0047204662,
-0.0271559488,
-0.004846286,
0.0244748779,
-0.0511809886,
0.0141470777,
2.292187581e-34,
0.0172139909,
0.0235103574,
0.0199671164,
-0.0165097583,
0.0257529914,
0.0513249598,
0.016843155,
0.00655773,
-0.0411410965,
-0.0861933455,
0.0154737076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15714v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15714v4 | Explicit Planning Helps Language Models in Logical Reasoning | 2023-03-28T03:55:03 | 2023-11-07T18:12:20 | Hongyu Zhao, Kangrui Wang, Mo Yu, Hongyuan Mei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models have been shown to perform remarkably well on a wide range of
natural language processing tasks. In this paper, we propose LEAP, a novel
system that uses language models to perform multi-step logical reasoning and
incorporates explicit planning into the inference procedure. Explicit planning
enables the system to make more informed reasoning decisions at each step by
looking ahead into their future effects. Moreover, we propose a training
strategy that safeguards the planning process from being led astray by spurious
features. Our full system significantly outperforms other competing methods on
multiple standard datasets. When using small T5 models as its core selection
and deduction components, our system performs competitively compared to GPT-3
despite having only about 1B parameters (i.e., 175 times smaller than GPT-3).
When using GPT-3.5, it significantly outperforms chain-of-thought prompting on
the challenging PrOntoQA dataset. We have conducted extensive empirical studies
to demonstrate that explicit planning plays a crucial role in the system's
performance. | [
0.068168208,
0.0669962019,
-0.0094927438,
0.0264637098,
-0.0897236839,
0.0208630711,
0.0366637893,
-0.0088114142,
0.0437404253,
-0.0528027862,
0.0468246154,
0.0124915736,
-0.0246933941,
0.0615755916,
-0.0051567862,
-0.0427061841,
0.0680672005,
-0.0384170376,
0.0352745615,
-0.0048586214,
-0.0074718669,
0.0448320471,
0.0062986775,
0.0206026156,
-0.0130176125,
0.0060059759,
-0.0343040042,
-0.0102286646,
0.0324735083,
-0.0172364451,
-0.0055223582,
0.0842285082,
0.0235975347,
0.0084196264,
0.0000020375,
-0.0415036641,
-0.0278211813,
-0.0392513089,
-0.0448286161,
-0.0143682836,
-0.0118704401,
-0.0155574968,
0.0250358451,
0.0292030144,
-0.0469112359,
0.0076719802,
0.0121625336,
0.0907497406,
0.0555014387,
0.0647313669,
-0.0124783795,
-0.0733904168,
-0.0320877954,
-0.0066402773,
-0.0023235499,
-0.0601303317,
0.0156659056,
0.0097207809,
0.0399281867,
0.043247629,
0.0298983101,
0.0111182276,
0.01796587,
0.0211216323,
-0.048696924,
0.0271357931,
-0.058252994,
-0.0307313167,
-0.0208911672,
0.0665529519,
-0.0140168797,
-0.0456322655,
0.0102263745,
-0.0241821818,
-0.0236545876,
-0.0002949041,
-0.0022386627,
0.0171700343,
-0.0213475749,
0.0110359872,
0.060849499,
-0.0191951171,
0.0294097681,
0.0326972976,
-0.0230062697,
0.1336615235,
0.0023582715,
-0.0285266209,
0.0540881343,
0.009764336,
-0.0504653007,
-0.0592112467,
0.010987509,
0.0254849512,
-0.0407538712,
0.0318914242,
-0.0236255359,
0.0432000197,
0.0076939673,
-0.0073649413,
-0.0130143734,
0.0538344234,
0.0216934886,
0.0610386431,
-0.016549781,
0.0268829986,
-0.001427623,
0.0046092165,
-0.0141643062,
-0.0091978349,
-0.052533906,
-0.0129366089,
-0.0655943528,
0.0263110939,
-0.0347333774,
-0.0322059914,
-0.0148957903,
-0.013322548,
0.0176904574,
0.0038061559,
0.0422725789,
0.0100715039,
-0.008324095,
-0.0461200811,
-0.0609831065,
0.0114325145,
-0.0702761039,
0.0403732546,
-0.0285696648,
-0.044924926,
-0.026072152,
-0.0039211335,
0.0174912587,
-0.007700637,
0.0202909559,
0.0493546501,
0.0076887459,
-0.0262942649,
-0.0610076077,
-0.0336630791,
-0.0171575788,
-0.0856682211,
0.0093870889,
-0.0544132814,
0.007609609,
0.0001617685,
-0.0245739985,
0.0151360193,
0.01486615,
0.0484599732,
-0.0147682382,
0.0812393725,
0.0100678783,
-0.0155160362,
0.0099680554,
0.0071696402,
0.0060291658,
0.0865548849,
0.0126357311,
0.0244008228,
-0.0070257881,
0.0411732718,
-0.0124100931,
0.0369378924,
-0.0066695432,
-0.0169506893,
-0.0067985337,
0.0227364264,
-0.042192176,
0.0077686999,
-0.0166145824,
0.022881683,
-0.0243780743,
-0.0159206353,
0.0247902926,
0.0337155238,
0.0154489614,
-0.0056385868,
0.0365122035,
0.0108046085,
-0.0229062699,
-0.0350844786,
-0.0604416616,
0.0201278552,
-0.0389690176,
0.0035391846,
-0.0277087428,
0.0069659152,
0.0003414752,
-0.0292456225,
-0.0416175351,
0.0277332515,
0.0308160223,
0.0237541813,
0.0341446213,
0.0136580169,
-0.0431508198,
0.0445787273,
-0.0089677395,
-0.0339701958,
-0.0427164286,
-0.0365108922,
0.0418983437,
0.0411325805,
0.0467508957,
-0.0214102212,
-0.0177392196,
-0.0148508754,
0.0125787286,
0.0515800752,
0.0233274326,
-0.0083298553,
-0.0096210772,
-0.0685393587,
-0.0476184711,
0.0060286401,
0.0243006833,
0.0069048926,
0.0496576689,
0.0136244036,
0.0180402026,
0.001538396,
0.0379028767,
0.0270805433,
-0.0133549748,
-0.0199860409,
0.0048822067,
-0.0105410917,
0.0378249697,
0.0049321763,
0.0123210428,
0.0055151102,
0.0112754777,
-0.0052760518,
-0.032731656,
0.0140323685,
-0.0465501323,
-0.0756446272,
0.043567609,
-0.0292962361,
-0.023512233,
-0.0111316098,
-0.0709727183,
-0.0327301882,
0.0128201265,
-0.0166681204,
-0.0237168707,
-0.0536513738,
-0.0135199511,
0.0337468125,
-0.0483037159,
-0.0298666414,
0.1093790904,
0.0057238797,
-0.0038331952,
0.0288714077,
0.0252598412,
0.0286689419,
-0.0365857556,
0.0176081993,
0.0335974954,
0.0102201868,
-0.0245020334,
0.0113703255,
0.0325125679,
-0.0623472743,
-0.0227950346,
-0.1025524288,
0.0030828915,
-0.0416944064,
0.0028803637,
-0.0236144252,
0.0161174983,
-0.0229160078,
-0.0189330354,
-0.0357656591,
0.0086450353,
0.0196789335,
-0.0003345843,
0.0125700487,
-0.006302502,
-0.0012613613,
-0.0251355525,
-0.0048544561,
-0.0276704282,
-0.0077131991,
0.0220800452,
-0.0212564897,
-0.0142062781,
0.0035919473,
-0.0393953659,
0.0317802504,
-0.0069402214,
-0.0108964378,
0.0015987671,
-0.0439488105,
0.0042960686,
0.0351537168,
-0.0004875594,
-0.0206110831,
0.0377245285,
-0.0247198679,
-0.0339676924,
0.0703062341,
-0.0450618677,
0.0206797011,
-0.0169941187,
-0.0228769928,
-0.019860832,
0.0313860551,
0.0118073635,
0.0085820798,
-0.0874932408,
0.0319372937,
0.0177501701,
-0.0089836242,
0.0107871601,
0.0087970672,
0.0073875962,
0.0526612699,
-0.020144159,
-0.030051887,
0.0873101056,
0.011495309,
-0.0018694157,
-0.0786363259,
0.0034369922,
-0.0394442938,
0.0747542158,
0.0187757351,
-0.0063820388,
0.0218358878,
-0.0173593424,
-0.0244312026,
-0.024673894,
0.034189906,
-0.0100600626,
0.0545403808,
-0.0764685124,
0.0398543701,
0.0087730726,
-0.0233972967,
-0.059771657,
-0.0290940348,
-0.0860217959,
0.0241768379,
-0.0485709868,
-0.0229860488,
-0.0031327861,
-0.0242298599,
-0.0025773335,
0.0801826343,
0.0049176426,
0.0094201425,
-0.0229397453,
-0.0291071404,
0.0717320666,
0.0186280981,
-0.0040795556,
-0.0034567229,
0.0286907367,
0.0022123489,
0.0289342627,
-0.018924471,
-0.0156791583,
0.0454084985,
0.0010097077,
-0.0338008516,
-0.0179347768,
0.0320013687,
0.0203567073,
-0.0553304143,
-0.013073911,
0.1144325212,
0.0408450998,
0.0193877798,
-0.0122781005,
-0.031677492,
0.0634396076,
0.0129981153,
0.0187983271,
-0.0869616121,
-0.0950799361,
0.0175004695,
-0.0233128518,
-0.0109194294,
-0.0411047749,
-0.011227007,
-0.0944025144,
0.0609165803,
-0.0017702024,
0.0023190717,
-0.0058145295,
-0.0433904119,
-0.0094540697,
-0.0298790857,
-0.0079618497,
0.0042284685,
-0.0005535597,
0.0043531577,
-0.0025657823,
-0.0206086617,
-0.000751906,
0.043423038,
0.001036286,
0.012761578,
0.072919257,
0.019068785,
0.0039328341,
-0.0417617038,
0.0058036516,
-0.0148425978,
-0.0048289853,
-0.0526121221,
0.0301883202,
-0.0028684151,
0.0162901878,
-0.0125051821,
0.0467730202,
-0.0345738642,
-0.0310214069,
0.0233024359,
0.0882962793,
-0.0369531363,
-0.0335865431,
-0.0148894116,
0.043421939,
-0.0068704067,
0.087257579,
-0.0199666806,
0.0012433165,
-0.080364123,
-0.0329158716,
-0.0445866138,
-0.0387209207,
-0.0395117141,
0.0196005516,
0.0195534471,
-0.0251153838,
-0.0421463586,
-0.0477047116,
0.0698319525,
0.017680347,
-0.0012094587,
0.0243175104,
-0.002965057,
0.041691266,
-0.0086285481,
0.0249295402,
-0.0194528177,
0.0226080343,
-0.0055096052,
0.0433596559,
0.0031824296,
-0.0077360328,
-0.021307677,
0.0635541007,
-0.0626401529,
-0.0637588426,
-0.0119329747,
0.033038076,
0.0272449311,
0.0242447089,
-0.0323009193,
-0.0141755659,
0.0125398561,
0.0171692651,
0.0137251941,
-0.0120351808,
0.0314486846,
-0.0005618552,
0.0153626539,
0.0499594994,
-0.0041965805,
0.0312624089,
-0.0075389193,
0.055823151,
-0.0235286634,
-0.0236155875,
0.0310493354,
0.0258714184,
0.0295017958,
-0.0205520056,
0.0038149741,
-0.0302521233,
0.0294185616,
-0.0356830992,
-0.0425216742,
-0.0408929773,
0.058479201,
0.0092753936,
-0.0092626661,
-0.015826216,
-0.0599301644,
-0.0321234576,
0.0041726427,
0.0103293359,
0.0135210231,
0.0613215752,
0.0085266493,
0.0213324595,
-0.0720691755,
-0.0244792495,
-0.0015545788,
-0.0003157985,
0.0449951068,
-0.0154815027,
0.0820106417,
0.0478261523,
-0.0173806641,
-0.0313073881,
-0.034978129,
-0.0380867831,
-0.0737978667,
0.0166189689,
0.0202879775,
0.034624733,
-0.0326595344,
0.0394056067,
-0.0743117779,
-0.0053262399,
0.0093029356,
0.0264725089,
0.0396014228,
-0.0282029957,
0.0443297625,
0.0197946038,
-0.0417895094,
-0.0215512272,
0.0223457944,
0.026967464,
0.0697057024,
0.0173993837,
-0.0297692753,
-0.0476242453,
-0.0540492497,
-0.0395112112,
0.0351797044,
-0.0064247963,
0.0397046991,
-0.0632820725,
-0.0589692779,
-0.020659253,
0.0040636198,
-0.011801959,
0.0117227929,
0.0631383508,
0.0540352352,
0.0046791416,
-0.0827695802,
-0.0296619404,
0.0012449577,
0.0134120164,
-0.0400584675,
-0.0359841138,
-6.119575836e-33,
-0.0058495537,
-0.0247515962,
0.0518218651,
-0.0241331123,
0.0003743463,
-0.0334824212,
-0.0444382541,
-0.0081179114,
-0.0312797613,
0.0361384861,
-0.0238451399,
0.029267583,
0.0233824328,
0.0128699709,
0.0093093999,
-0.0145337973,
0.0178373121,
-0.0058844588,
-0.0125041334,
-0.0072102589,
0.0347053409,
0.0068879183,
0.0498721078,
-0.006735608,
-0.0097751226,
0.0193572771,
-0.0260049477,
0.055378072,
-0.0662645921,
0.0320750847,
-0.0005806221,
-0.0235433318,
0.0169534367,
-0.0206133928,
0.008672121,
0.0403691679,
-0.0721076503,
-0.0599871054,
0.0625866801,
-0.0205784235,
-0.0341540128,
-0.0212607812,
-0.0004285993,
-0.0065034372,
-0.0001252972,
-0.0276833214,
0.0103234798,
-0.0245032702,
0.004435393,
0.0074212826,
-0.0487070084,
0.057088498,
-0.0049481043,
0.0244618654,
0.041568242,
0.0846738517,
-0.0040807961,
0.0072541554,
-0.0119530531,
0.0197628848,
0.0223100446,
0.0039444813,
0.0435079187,
-0.0051188543,
-0.002456014,
0.049980972,
-0.0189488828,
-0.04157345,
-0.054171849,
0.009754437,
0.0003316254,
0.0879674479,
0.0378780179,
0.0062756464,
0.0328859985,
0.0329893343,
-0.1003949121,
-0.0015646133,
0.0253674705,
0.0563253351,
0.0284576509,
-0.0204976704,
-0.0607599095,
-0.0107022114,
-0.0404602438,
0.0118637765,
-0.0284389779,
-0.0242405422,
0.0355781354,
0.033063475,
-0.0009193296,
0.0129382079,
0.0231393613,
-0.0185132995,
-0.0074657681,
0.057842467,
-0.0285278708,
-0.022024367,
-0.0018674184,
0.0740489662,
-0.0482150875,
-0.0066281212,
0.014549775,
0.0096851075,
-0.0161427259,
-0.0119583244,
0.0001829863,
0.0163868833,
-0.0591776222,
-0.0064791064,
-0.0289313439,
0.0303954463,
-0.0445431843,
0.0351699628,
0.046872139,
0.0163780693,
0.0016706306,
-0.0003680491,
0.0044002053,
-0.0396355987,
-0.0287653673,
0.0061817155,
0.0242151842,
0.0152762476,
-0.0005015542,
-0.0010422536,
-0.0046829879,
-0.0192134567,
0.0046310159,
-0.0302117132,
0.0088852104,
0.0654059201,
2.711e-7,
0.0281549655,
0.0476527661,
-0.0036996335,
0.0644836798,
-0.0140801165,
0.0555161946,
0.0215343591,
0.0206909031,
0.023526812,
-0.0254979469,
0.0235894825,
0.0343998857,
0.0282957051,
0.0360450633,
-0.1018423364,
-0.0068581589,
-0.0188535787,
-0.0652055815,
-0.0739087015,
-0.0273421481,
0.0788293034,
0.1130194291,
0.0339230038,
-0.0059558409,
-0.0079453662,
-0.0316115804,
0.0230477881,
-0.0058703274,
-0.0151567776,
-0.0055540772,
0.0424352996,
-0.0023487867,
-0.0068426752,
0.0570304878,
-0.0228453521,
0.0310320798,
-0.0154071376,
0.0880257264,
-0.0092774956,
-0.0249708164,
-0.0439744405,
-0.041624397,
0.0245094467,
-0.0510684885,
0.107481949,
-0.0184681583,
-0.0060682823,
0.0199104473,
0.0036607604,
-0.0216611326,
0.0082746567,
0.0066488315,
-0.0165587235,
0.0206338484,
0.0152432015,
-0.0237884726,
-0.0070265783,
-0.1107666418,
-0.0158375036,
0.0183526184,
-0.0337595604,
-0.0028905764,
-0.0230553932,
0.0149411494,
0.0363167264,
-0.0600951537,
0.0007947781,
2.756988838e-34,
0.0151176145,
-0.01730242,
-0.0106922034,
0.033447396,
0.0590161271,
0.0302819535,
0.018783981,
0.0231737345,
0.0083964625,
-0.0956433639,
-0.0307449736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15708v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15708v2 | Bias or Diversity? Unraveling Fine-Grained Thematic Discrepancy in U.S. News Headlines | 2023-03-28T03:31:37 | 2023-05-06T03:57:30 | Jinsheng Pan, Weihong Qi, Zichen Wang, Hanjia Lyu, Jiebo Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is a broad consensus that news media outlets incorporate ideological
biases in their news articles. However, prior studies on measuring the
discrepancies among media outlets and further dissecting the origins of
thematic differences suffer from small sample sizes and limited scope and
granularity. In this study, we use a large dataset of 1.8 million news
headlines from major U.S. media outlets spanning from 2014 to 2022 to
thoroughly track and dissect the fine-grained thematic discrepancy in U.S. news
media. We employ multiple correspondence analysis (MCA) to quantify the
fine-grained thematic discrepancy related to four prominent topics - domestic
politics, economic issues, social issues, and foreign affairs in order to
derive a more holistic analysis. Additionally, we compare the most frequent
$n$-grams in media headlines to provide further qualitative insights into our
analysis. Our findings indicate that on domestic politics and social issues,
the discrepancy can be attributed to a certain degree of media bias. Meanwhile,
the discrepancy in reporting foreign affairs is largely attributed to the
diversity in individual journalistic styles. Finally, U.S. media outlets show
consistency and high similarity in their coverage of economic issues. | [
0.0105668167,
0.035312742,
-0.0159104988,
-0.021522807,
-0.0448659547,
0.0118085751,
0.0150149055,
-0.0291243736,
-0.0235554557,
-0.0529535003,
-0.0321589261,
0.0288055502,
0.0398941264,
-0.0073174741,
-0.0324964188,
-0.0394163691,
0.0297603868,
0.0677674636,
0.0564619228,
-0.0215285774,
0.0238678623,
0.0529947504,
-0.0137930317,
0.0203540344,
-0.0119603742,
-0.0213840902,
-0.0038576529,
0.0215342063,
0.0578843392,
-0.0417065211,
0.0380561352,
0.0362656079,
0.0110299159,
-0.0062748455,
0.000001673,
-0.0390486531,
0.0054103774,
-0.0028163951,
0.073509194,
-0.002143844,
0.0474105626,
-0.0473378375,
0.0047308765,
-0.0016744375,
-0.0133797126,
0.0035387923,
0.0502380505,
0.0347035974,
0.0425083078,
0.0398685448,
0.0076793605,
-0.0272683185,
-0.0323292054,
0.0078614643,
-0.0284618437,
-0.0110876253,
0.0260255728,
-0.0170640778,
-0.1078746095,
0.0050639049,
-0.0249339752,
-0.0037901411,
0.0023594871,
0.0478319898,
-0.059769243,
0.0350000523,
-0.0216835886,
-0.0178789981,
0.0140772909,
0.0204958674,
0.061626114,
-0.0118682375,
0.0457147099,
-0.0140152369,
0.0121117812,
0.0362568237,
-0.0269846618,
0.0397550911,
-0.0251092128,
0.0071188961,
0.0517849214,
-0.0352911539,
-0.0303801205,
0.052942425,
-0.0101488642,
0.0215387046,
0.0008513419,
-0.012569732,
-0.0262052342,
0.0297343452,
0.0702286661,
-0.0249069314,
-0.0025850285,
-0.0246390104,
-0.0003805017,
-0.0113134142,
-0.0201593768,
-0.0200179648,
0.0100457612,
-0.0761394426,
-0.0189243015,
0.0139647983,
-0.0377961509,
0.0519981422,
0.0729653761,
-0.0412386209,
0.0038823278,
0.0203716997,
-0.0111521715,
0.0093708374,
-0.0583903491,
0.0519561209,
0.0414215773,
-0.0030539266,
-0.0018087163,
0.0003593626,
0.0004359382,
-0.0350198187,
-0.0535489805,
0.0060760416,
-0.0553437769,
-0.009034127,
-0.0257788245,
-0.0094939442,
-0.0184441805,
0.0815575793,
-0.0770071074,
0.0431483649,
-0.0139870429,
0.031279739,
-0.0107353516,
0.0433110818,
-0.0044341511,
-0.0127372714,
-0.0028753898,
-0.0054749963,
-0.0296205599,
0.0456834212,
0.0175128821,
0.033154171,
-0.0028543039,
-0.0499936044,
0.0338758118,
-0.052707985,
0.012451469,
0.0058074123,
0.0103180967,
0.0240421202,
-0.0229464993,
-0.0078218915,
-0.0562599041,
-0.0057352851,
0.0716731995,
0.012280317,
0.0749056041,
0.0147134271,
0.0140641034,
0.0716537535,
-0.0363394432,
0.0273714494,
0.0361134186,
-0.0249992516,
-0.0686989203,
-0.0177606363,
-0.0698060617,
0.0459746048,
-0.0444434434,
0.0304905698,
-0.0223452188,
0.009896731,
0.0700721145,
-0.0322179422,
-0.0104756122,
0.000287039,
0.0468475781,
0.0429305695,
-0.0049106884,
0.0134987915,
0.0027848294,
0.0160193443,
0.0087748896,
0.0541146882,
-0.014640687,
-0.0012598007,
-0.0031044227,
-0.0280226134,
0.0351754539,
0.0512960516,
-0.0324695967,
0.0233291648,
0.0107075376,
0.0350708142,
0.0094143162,
-0.0595840067,
-0.0175239034,
-0.0281669293,
-0.0170273688,
0.0126579842,
0.0225845557,
0.0372928157,
0.0155523568,
0.0183297917,
0.0287341084,
0.0106591275,
-0.0091360398,
0.0123608289,
0.0162975136,
-0.0057680998,
0.0574273169,
0.0321784727,
0.0507824756,
0.022779379,
-0.063402757,
0.0002527663,
-0.0073432564,
-0.0267634112,
0.0609408021,
0.077571772,
0.0137598272,
0.0715616122,
-0.0304138977,
0.0108808754,
0.0030592005,
0.0049944315,
0.0553331785,
0.0156068467,
-0.0211344883,
0.0271029714,
0.0070260116,
0.0004538567,
-0.0027031829,
-0.0169189461,
-0.0091292625,
0.0274907183,
0.0175515953,
-0.0167579018,
-0.0244934745,
0.0622017682,
-0.0370059274,
-0.0970911682,
-0.0351231471,
0.0266011897,
-0.0084852427,
0.0003498133,
0.065225035,
0.0320627689,
-0.0416194014,
0.0015720022,
0.0010534727,
-0.0408592969,
0.0190943666,
0.0069435341,
0.0504886806,
0.0016389594,
0.0211777445,
-0.0285079945,
-0.0387600437,
-0.015694404,
0.0011438478,
0.0336673968,
0.0116557786,
-0.0025979748,
0.0245588105,
0.0080521721,
-0.072534427,
-0.0332469754,
-0.0508399345,
-0.0016274079,
0.0368598364,
-0.0155699449,
0.0149841765,
0.0895404816,
-0.0527648665,
-0.0312564969,
0.035557922,
0.0153590078,
-0.0507583469,
-0.0433136299,
0.037264742,
-0.0078230528,
0.0332203433,
0.0232520085,
0.0025728873,
0.0052855019,
-0.0475705937,
0.0208948031,
-0.0033416965,
-0.027770739,
-0.017664697,
-0.0069908239,
-0.0339905582,
-0.0205194186,
-0.0039893719,
-0.0047706161,
-0.0031404421,
0.0430409871,
-0.0381583832,
0.0470094308,
0.0563574433,
0.0967935994,
0.0379989929,
-0.0084635457,
-0.0268734805,
-0.0139944823,
-0.0247557033,
0.0374471843,
-0.0300351251,
-0.0652062073,
0.0489836037,
0.0286714025,
0.0352652892,
0.045591455,
-0.0099965036,
0.0392861478,
-0.0262080692,
0.0028312008,
0.0263326243,
0.0028088768,
0.0245197173,
0.0509225912,
0.0008031293,
0.0207763482,
-0.0306891091,
0.0023849546,
0.1157775,
-0.0279648416,
-0.0120105771,
-0.0192152839,
0.002569133,
-0.0515972152,
0.0292672087,
0.0044131656,
-0.051344499,
-0.0636696368,
-0.0488303266,
0.1142273918,
0.0047814064,
0.0706683174,
-0.018909771,
-0.0071730143,
0.007819117,
0.0045272573,
-0.0115590328,
-0.0548291281,
0.0255514495,
-0.0167494453,
0.0216841083,
-0.0273946952,
-0.0857645795,
0.037044879,
0.0273172371,
-0.0262634326,
-0.0147775924,
0.0246630237,
0.0222972035,
0.033249516,
0.0193112381,
0.005421597,
0.003248312,
0.0003544385,
-0.0255373176,
-0.0178534072,
-0.0270000082,
0.0870155171,
0.0185087975,
-0.0135975722,
-0.0048200204,
-0.0361225791,
-0.0495809019,
-0.0162293985,
0.0345841758,
-0.0111379055,
0.0132103972,
0.0661260262,
0.0082519185,
-0.0383395143,
-0.0363392197,
0.0329124033,
-0.059692625,
0.0272792205,
0.022343928,
-0.0578370467,
0.0586159043,
0.0159777962,
-0.0254698005,
-0.0515690073,
-0.0469621308,
-0.0474479869,
-0.0666124821,
-0.0225172285,
-0.0152612505,
-0.0380932428,
-0.0435147434,
-0.0352862105,
0.0319998823,
0.0082831969,
-0.0191986691,
0.0031622483,
0.0012275948,
-0.0154840285,
-0.0172621608,
-0.0555186234,
-0.0681826696,
-0.0075174919,
0.0173298363,
-0.0247417446,
-0.048676677,
0.0319099724,
-0.0505713038,
-0.0044315625,
0.0052608792,
-0.0128758475,
-0.0331481248,
-0.0028585722,
0.030690698,
-0.0513036549,
-0.0128152855,
-0.0453043468,
0.0421137884,
0.0745704547,
-0.0049552401,
-0.0257224962,
-0.0196303837,
0.0155140813,
-0.0533763915,
-0.0067554982,
0.0336457081,
0.0384885855,
0.0285764989,
0.0269244518,
-0.0081876861,
0.0149952108,
-0.0210292861,
0.0240802784,
0.0206669178,
0.0319724418,
0.0374418013,
-0.0360593013,
-0.0373179168,
0.00527413,
-0.0493361019,
-0.0392552614,
0.0121663157,
0.0106182247,
-0.0038075424,
0.014096058,
-0.0470526703,
-0.0120371655,
-0.0094803842,
0.0129840299,
-0.0062816492,
0.0727762133,
-0.0462397225,
-0.0516105928,
0.0358857028,
-0.0523400791,
-0.0182077028,
-0.0402882174,
0.0005001284,
0.0507305637,
-0.0727931187,
0.0055129635,
-0.0045478623,
-0.0008043477,
0.0613367148,
0.01693343,
0.0999650285,
-0.0408430956,
0.0213889256,
-0.0257028006,
-0.0074460614,
0.0062721418,
-0.0257058274,
0.0081791896,
0.0194654837,
0.0270734578,
-0.0259175524,
-0.0107535571,
-0.0048870477,
-0.004985733,
-0.0544361733,
0.0514602102,
0.0162217747,
0.0152579537,
-0.0597191192,
-0.0549867339,
-0.0049652536,
-0.0325016454,
0.0694610998,
-0.0585461967,
0.0202519428,
-0.0250719115,
-0.0453131422,
0.0482966676,
-0.0356679298,
0.0561280809,
-0.0755151659,
0.0229583774,
-0.0494948514,
0.0368605442,
-0.0344206207,
-0.0117708379,
-0.0306667816,
0.0175383259,
-0.0088335555,
0.0333065093,
-0.010915705,
0.0169829875,
0.0451278426,
0.0316349193,
0.0068017244,
-0.0245764274,
-0.0484827496,
0.0215421878,
0.0034663465,
0.0035179416,
-0.0046990905,
-0.05295486,
-0.0293525774,
0.0469317213,
-0.0150421029,
0.018348556,
0.0205624998,
0.0181790609,
-0.0232817419,
0.0467853062,
0.0074862381,
-0.0136871301,
-0.0095669888,
0.0245204605,
-0.0274090618,
0.0235419367,
0.0420155488,
-0.053896565,
0.000139355,
-0.0553455539,
0.0661377981,
-0.0025770653,
0.0071871364,
-0.0615688562,
-0.0760650039,
0.000800801,
0.0518491752,
-0.0417586863,
0.0233985987,
0.0052606971,
-0.0340069942,
0.0445801318,
0.017396111,
0.0214852355,
-0.0049884608,
0.001545158,
-0.0777994767,
-0.0346659869,
0.035737209,
-5.959669666e-33,
-0.0120693231,
-0.0204511788,
-0.0271053854,
-0.040302109,
-0.0275577642,
0.0200971831,
-0.0194484834,
0.0064472351,
-0.0453047268,
0.0226710383,
0.0278459694,
0.0385720246,
0.0192018747,
-0.0383812115,
0.0394563377,
-0.0136860833,
-0.0157845486,
0.0199849643,
-0.0339246541,
-0.0140774576,
-0.0261976495,
-0.0192787144,
0.0582754575,
-0.0324000567,
0.0239761733,
-0.0308934059,
-0.0172331147,
-0.0922914147,
0.0918052122,
0.004179934,
0.0317109078,
0.0062453384,
0.0533982888,
-0.066292055,
0.0100521753,
0.0685662925,
-0.0392168313,
-0.0725994036,
0.0569318607,
-0.0013597276,
0.0606942847,
-0.0121711548,
-0.0367539264,
0.0355516635,
-0.0092579732,
-0.0425405204,
0.0399785787,
-0.008755384,
0.0366094448,
0.0174856503,
-0.0205769166,
0.0093593923,
-0.0495934561,
0.0757870376,
-0.0966596529,
0.0331297629,
0.0354404226,
0.0788252577,
-0.0484354757,
0.0006240114,
-0.0360354744,
0.0234981906,
-0.0022573858,
-0.0149032902,
-0.0021662631,
0.0684009567,
-0.0145113906,
0.045209758,
-0.0641594902,
0.009836969,
0.0330531709,
-0.0025144529,
-0.0219089445,
0.0909765959,
0.0343356505,
-0.0360337421,
-0.0540564805,
0.0067532728,
-0.0104835844,
0.0475740358,
0.0178383887,
-0.025404511,
-0.0092072729,
-0.000109834,
-0.046262946,
-0.0542517975,
-0.0351437777,
-0.0019105172,
0.0201892331,
0.006127065,
-0.0205583833,
0.0639882535,
0.0247133896,
0.0034447643,
-0.0176511947,
0.0119090481,
-0.0665493757,
-0.017758714,
0.0121350838,
0.0319915377,
-0.0793645084,
-0.0460012481,
0.0164314508,
0.0683962479,
0.0321250558,
-0.022644829,
0.0134269157,
-0.0318621211,
-0.0711326674,
-0.0234718416,
0.0147382757,
-0.0219957791,
-0.0209799111,
-0.0156756975,
0.0239216127,
0.0338230282,
0.0177775174,
-0.0184551347,
0.0295457002,
0.011051001,
0.0227722358,
-0.0468701795,
-0.0538327023,
0.0212958399,
-0.0015276755,
-0.0008221327,
-0.0192235261,
0.0223273821,
0.0456114709,
-0.0219419971,
-0.0393758938,
-0.0217805356,
2.563e-7,
0.0399535336,
0.0243155193,
-0.0366145894,
0.0335791409,
0.0223543681,
0.0090529434,
0.0057925088,
0.0572527945,
-0.0614188276,
-0.0686046481,
-0.0112884259,
0.026237607,
0.0006574545,
0.047149837,
-0.0021897883,
0.0411582068,
-0.0653554201,
0.0531238839,
-0.0671239644,
0.0439144671,
0.0104398038,
-0.0384334698,
0.0046196459,
0.0092504509,
-0.0256332718,
0.0326310433,
0.0456204191,
0.002966604,
-0.0237515848,
0.0037212151,
-0.0516742282,
0.0000028029,
0.0166367646,
0.0235550329,
0.0035255693,
-0.0110083986,
0.0163955353,
0.0031804405,
0.0291288421,
0.0075706444,
-0.017322829,
0.0048829815,
-0.010016175,
-0.0743382126,
0.0421279483,
-0.0491448119,
-0.0222399067,
-0.1262862384,
-0.0710485578,
0.0366967283,
0.0455698632,
0.0067626475,
-0.0150242215,
0.040004421,
-0.0188910626,
0.0300463997,
0.0184142236,
-0.0114216749,
0.0117926514,
0.0224090796,
-0.0310241766,
-0.0024904269,
0.0224144906,
-0.0048076715,
0.0329889096,
-0.0198290087,
0.0326743536,
1.843062184e-34,
0.0169133991,
0.017732054,
-0.0036691222,
-0.0557772815,
0.0165229049,
0.017624747,
-0.0517602488,
-0.0150072621,
-0.0093965475,
-0.051839523,
0.034667477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15705v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15705v1 | Translate the Beauty in Songs: Jointly Learning to Align Melody and Translate Lyrics | 2023-03-28T03:17:59 | 2023-03-28T03:17:59 | Chengxi Li, Kai Fan, Jiajun Bu, Boxing Chen, Zhongqiang Huang, Zhi Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Song translation requires both translation of lyrics and alignment of music
notes so that the resulting verse can be sung to the accompanying melody, which
is a challenging problem that has attracted some interests in different aspects
of the translation process. In this paper, we propose Lyrics-Melody Translation
with Adaptive Grouping (LTAG), a holistic solution to automatic song
translation by jointly modeling lyrics translation and lyrics-melody alignment.
It is a novel encoder-decoder framework that can simultaneously translate the
source lyrics and determine the number of aligned notes at each decoding step
through an adaptive note grouping module. To address data scarcity, we
commissioned a small amount of training data annotated specifically for this
task and used large amounts of augmented data through back-translation.
Experiments conducted on an English-Chinese song translation data set show the
effectiveness of our model in both automatic and human evaluation. | [
0.0051409383,
0.0241585933,
0.0034255644,
0.0321099609,
-0.0055775018,
0.0117236432,
0.0461665951,
-0.0469167195,
-0.0641059205,
0.0550317913,
-0.0346341096,
-0.0045770053,
0.050189849,
-0.0373545215,
0.0257561244,
-0.033352904,
0.0145959845,
0.0113831582,
0.0389843211,
0.0017097691,
-0.0359439664,
0.0325016305,
-0.0116486987,
0.0311683919,
0.0118735479,
-0.0192783549,
-0.0333526582,
0.0565762222,
0.0469826311,
-0.0235884283,
-0.0367802009,
0.0134632671,
-0.008548745,
0.0264388267,
0.0000016785,
-0.0262082424,
-0.0390270352,
0.0119150402,
0.0205212422,
-0.0391197614,
0.0108707184,
-0.0502706245,
-0.0036580523,
0.0413860083,
-0.0025865051,
-0.015129976,
0.0342888273,
-0.0138751483,
0.0802341029,
0.1095817462,
0.0009528672,
-0.0520550907,
0.0092005571,
-0.0788243562,
0.0087977247,
-0.0844438747,
-0.0141294524,
0.0061610141,
-0.0282576885,
-0.0261120535,
-0.0285521951,
0.0897671655,
0.0022369947,
0.0225756019,
0.0334169678,
0.0241872352,
-0.0651692972,
-0.0404548459,
-0.0018407356,
0.0257811062,
-0.0069657299,
-0.0002520504,
-0.0133113088,
-0.003408873,
-0.0038467082,
-0.0118410382,
-0.046800185,
0.0075011104,
0.0201647487,
0.0136024188,
-0.0135557335,
0.0175261237,
0.0376749597,
-0.0404801369,
0.0042805108,
-0.0242245365,
0.0112995189,
-0.0608909391,
-0.00590578,
0.0080838613,
0.0009758305,
0.0138040343,
0.0481054038,
-0.0056801075,
0.032037653,
0.0062640416,
-0.0307896696,
-0.0665668026,
-0.0006013062,
-0.0439584143,
0.0708517134,
0.0562642477,
0.0126740886,
0.0574626178,
-0.0130485063,
0.0412999243,
0.0004276534,
0.007443747,
-0.0604985878,
-0.0302785374,
0.0037728292,
0.0020588981,
-0.0587176979,
-0.0591310561,
-0.0192417037,
-0.0126204286,
-0.0121339178,
-0.0230467096,
0.0050259973,
0.0483029187,
0.0361425541,
-0.0137092173,
-0.0504536703,
-0.0237166211,
0.0745976791,
0.060384389,
-0.0020020625,
0.0117876325,
0.0007888809,
0.0285840742,
0.0009164083,
-0.0021245342,
0.0260614213,
0.0104516605,
0.0235910378,
0.0301098526,
0.0125676207,
-0.019696245,
-0.0181872528,
0.0119388169,
-0.0590513758,
-0.0127865095,
-0.0056296624,
-0.0664715916,
0.0897744298,
-0.0298584942,
0.0028690344,
-0.0539110526,
-0.0093786204,
-0.0073209838,
-0.0177835282,
0.0255209301,
0.0021078039,
0.0685959756,
0.0138244387,
-0.0040634638,
-0.0034748779,
0.0213829149,
0.0917961299,
0.0450997576,
0.0407345593,
-0.0092030223,
-0.0002233199,
0.0447393656,
0.0108724264,
0.0274748169,
-0.0022863322,
-0.0099800974,
0.0124618262,
0.0582689308,
0.0155352317,
0.0271670967,
0.0253555123,
-0.0334339999,
0.0308536347,
0.0045074578,
0.0437522195,
0.102790609,
0.0030645947,
0.0340498313,
0.0074052685,
-0.0283583421,
-0.0088260947,
0.0654107854,
0.0395492055,
0.0129740471,
0.1063234583,
0.0438890457,
-0.007103241,
0.0089804213,
-0.0243416037,
-0.0109433532,
-0.0015612025,
-0.0154526429,
0.02479879,
0.0233729128,
-0.0150769604,
0.0003239499,
-0.0159952343,
-0.0588529967,
0.0224258397,
0.0148716625,
-0.0257596076,
0.0668127686,
0.0467191264,
0.0034752996,
-0.0079749376,
-0.0137437601,
-0.0340854786,
0.0418366417,
-0.0014773342,
0.0005990595,
0.0303104836,
-0.0117231496,
-0.012816797,
0.0231937822,
-0.0309770312,
0.0005028324,
-0.0410070494,
0.038668789,
0.0106421756,
0.0069734645,
-0.0222341884,
0.0238891672,
0.023424197,
-0.0025991313,
0.0334117264,
0.0369170122,
0.0226942636,
0.0419280417,
-0.0339338593,
0.0160994735,
0.0304711945,
-0.0034255448,
0.0102014337,
0.0359770358,
0.0036877112,
-0.0897087008,
0.0416818373,
-0.0393792354,
-0.0224060193,
-0.0010478219,
-0.0169157628,
-0.0710922927,
0.022154931,
0.0127726989,
-0.0178201217,
0.0186212622,
0.0560915135,
-0.0185962711,
-0.0007924295,
0.0163248479,
-0.0222316384,
0.0285075437,
0.0130289271,
-0.0433013812,
-0.0177134853,
0.0336018391,
-0.0384386145,
-0.0343733095,
0.0385775156,
0.0185485221,
0.0104346182,
-0.0045048022,
0.0012667639,
-0.0109691806,
-0.0640657246,
-0.0798218772,
0.0604278296,
-0.0183643065,
0.0002926478,
0.048575189,
0.0010231721,
-0.004615372,
-0.0405535921,
-0.0339641869,
0.006147821,
-0.0081953537,
-0.012275612,
-0.0420126133,
-0.0001304405,
-0.0407396816,
-0.0122390464,
0.0062978268,
-0.0028939843,
-0.0244658515,
0.003429475,
-0.0101707755,
-0.0377736352,
-0.0237883255,
-0.0406567119,
-0.0430966094,
0.0321690962,
-0.0345448628,
-0.0145633891,
-0.0207764581,
0.033175528,
0.0462578349,
0.0056454185,
-0.0091772964,
0.0448302552,
0.0063593914,
0.0062878523,
-0.0053186505,
-0.0022123975,
-0.0200078916,
0.0192180667,
-0.0336947925,
-0.005709745,
0.0217684358,
0.0735599846,
-0.0104298107,
-0.0424929671,
-0.0237994641,
-0.014258476,
0.0456108972,
-0.0260434598,
0.0609541349,
0.0067720613,
0.034608569,
-0.0749592781,
-0.0486307852,
0.040770255,
-0.0127038285,
-0.0491491444,
-0.0312859714,
-0.030511139,
-0.0600867271,
-0.0049642501,
-0.0468542092,
0.0111589544,
-0.0524359383,
-0.0355020203,
-0.0383692272,
0.0495031141,
-0.0094652008,
-0.0566702336,
0.0432900004,
-0.0269823652,
-0.0164933857,
-0.0150992349,
-0.0150828091,
0.0053924578,
-0.0207012389,
0.0358572975,
-0.0186133366,
-0.0391581357,
-0.0238340646,
-0.0197537504,
-0.0181810409,
-0.0103634894,
0.0491001457,
-0.010839521,
0.0139437597,
0.0022735121,
0.0172517877,
-0.0105232224,
-0.0407757759,
-0.0357847251,
-0.0791851059,
0.0351941884,
0.0130298221,
0.0254995059,
0.0041549099,
-0.0158552453,
-0.0176697914,
0.0121763619,
0.0351049714,
0.0259317271,
-0.007858743,
0.0150309615,
-0.044729989,
0.0204994492,
0.1090191379,
0.0214042086,
-0.0369756445,
-0.0153311128,
0.0011351887,
-0.0068458961,
0.0233217627,
-0.0104603115,
-0.0204074979,
0.0072571463,
0.0123258317,
0.0472276732,
0.1079705432,
0.0302550159,
-0.016538538,
-0.028079614,
-0.0093036238,
0.0423438512,
-0.0557614304,
-0.0261987243,
0.0082764253,
-0.0283853337,
-0.0400026552,
0.010131496,
0.0079439245,
-0.0015116151,
0.0217889231,
-0.022872502,
0.0054208077,
0.0018747611,
-0.023464039,
-0.098993443,
0.0681767166,
0.0636469722,
0.0612438358,
0.0144352149,
-0.0229307059,
-0.0272372719,
0.005835827,
-0.0144300591,
0.037555024,
0.0342948623,
0.0337854512,
0.0082481271,
0.023435792,
0.0130409142,
-0.079309307,
0.0210103039,
0.0538896285,
0.0097885057,
-0.0060064713,
0.0129317706,
0.0207481664,
0.0273263808,
-0.0285814889,
0.0638294667,
0.0218550581,
-0.0160166044,
0.0446032733,
-0.0219608992,
0.0098700961,
-0.0379808024,
-0.0241752882,
0.0371966921,
-0.0388400108,
-0.0110877752,
-0.0748256594,
-0.0054494874,
0.0260977261,
0.0111099714,
0.0357373357,
0.0153350458,
-0.0049721301,
-0.0457583219,
-0.0472001061,
0.0005054934,
-0.0170149747,
0.0452871546,
-0.0262122042,
-0.0738936067,
-0.0264882874,
-0.0206000954,
0.0261585098,
-0.0400525816,
-0.0743155852,
-0.0442623384,
0.0099207554,
-0.006282391,
0.0149717582,
0.0610805675,
-0.0205274541,
0.0190489497,
-0.0364941359,
-0.031841401,
0.0258259978,
0.0307982359,
0.0000066203,
0.0169581994,
0.0115097063,
0.0110129938,
-0.0249052644,
0.0055047586,
-0.0072481469,
0.0285812728,
0.0321860909,
-0.0635477379,
0.0318528973,
0.0068967175,
0.020622598,
-0.0103969425,
-0.0450475402,
-0.0320997387,
-0.0126895895,
-0.0081440471,
0.0128762415,
-0.0271445252,
-0.0218093451,
0.0803495198,
0.0151918074,
-0.0029538458,
-0.0002620143,
0.0349198021,
-0.0923037082,
-0.090752542,
0.014588478,
-0.0075340047,
-0.0209642537,
-0.010118545,
0.0447611697,
0.0171660986,
0.0171133857,
0.034316618,
0.0079023233,
0.0282354504,
0.0026587876,
0.009603519,
0.0206474978,
-0.0194217786,
0.0264262632,
-0.0214852411,
-0.0512569025,
-0.0334315188,
-0.0071276119,
0.0764185935,
0.0066840877,
0.0832592025,
0.0430016369,
0.0048107845,
0.0066018524,
0.0467435084,
-0.0306469128,
-0.0423748791,
-0.0618371479,
-0.0018389161,
0.0069682957,
0.0066720685,
0.0612480715,
-0.0465128645,
-0.0015589056,
-0.0026558368,
0.007568696,
0.025691539,
0.0465441458,
-0.0038706709,
-0.0564347468,
-0.0004870279,
0.003310292,
0.0256273821,
-0.0521055907,
0.0069479211,
0.0271587651,
0.0387250818,
0.0067657153,
-0.0039181546,
0.0197870899,
-0.0708145723,
0.02128537,
-0.03202549,
-0.0523011275,
-0.0222498924,
-0.0117519945,
-0.0522175245,
-5.54605802e-33,
-0.0510693677,
-0.0035063724,
-0.0094315177,
0.01507538,
-0.0536888614,
-0.0584019274,
-0.0842624158,
0.0111491783,
0.0076539586,
-0.0105190547,
0.0415332243,
0.0485316999,
0.0111826137,
0.0151874106,
0.0408114605,
0.0395650044,
0.0824811086,
-0.0201540124,
-0.0736395493,
0.0219657887,
0.0496190749,
0.0270118713,
-0.0154461088,
-0.0896492973,
0.006764709,
-0.0174936187,
0.004105485,
0.0366823375,
0.0191093199,
0.019345263,
0.0292408355,
-0.0143070277,
0.0160943344,
0.0001666328,
-0.0346110091,
-0.0079432456,
-0.0614168905,
0.0056791152,
-0.0178176388,
0.0683105886,
0.0401828103,
-0.0339369513,
0.0270079523,
-0.035982281,
-0.0022067064,
-0.0015747201,
0.0289063081,
-0.0798134804,
-0.0236512627,
-0.0666147843,
-0.0165422708,
-0.0148057034,
-0.0615069903,
-0.024608817,
0.0494703874,
0.0173851177,
-0.0023775664,
0.0322301164,
-0.0343894027,
0.0061415997,
-0.040905904,
0.0230678618,
0.0610507578,
0.0052283606,
-0.0196100995,
0.0288211256,
0.0043824096,
-0.0611023381,
-0.0078547234,
0.0512075387,
0.0115122907,
0.0278169792,
0.0339197405,
-0.0304686278,
0.0876372308,
-0.0232067872,
-0.0006926609,
0.0595622994,
-0.038236808,
-0.025682494,
0.0174740292,
0.0747420266,
-0.0483417884,
0.0171654355,
0.0028691934,
-0.0455120206,
-0.0408663154,
-0.0467477962,
0.019225033,
0.0155183868,
-0.0548698157,
0.0132524688,
0.0218902268,
-0.0521533675,
0.0480197705,
-0.0035153546,
-0.0383936092,
0.0129107842,
-0.0293543022,
0.0161248129,
-0.0236615427,
-0.0662009045,
0.0638971254,
-0.0071240421,
0.0272234399,
-0.036246717,
0.0584226586,
0.0463742502,
-0.0701125711,
0.0173928067,
-0.0168474428,
-0.0288370401,
0.0073057613,
0.0080120126,
0.024080921,
0.0022424436,
-0.0099738212,
0.0508341379,
0.038975779,
0.0262866579,
-0.0297065452,
-0.0318988077,
-0.014184285,
-0.028764952,
0.0060372567,
0.0329808109,
0.0059011858,
-0.0536421761,
0.0454833992,
-0.0298278891,
-0.0440505892,
0.0234796461,
2.543e-7,
0.0619256906,
-0.0067543183,
0.046074748,
-0.0158532001,
0.0115099987,
0.0050166887,
-0.1310261637,
0.0211591478,
0.026523307,
0.0591579303,
0.0633200184,
0.0266024526,
0.1046148911,
0.0208291169,
-0.078723833,
0.0106640868,
-0.0665848777,
0.0163449347,
-0.0423300825,
-0.0172905736,
0.0214183927,
0.0768312365,
-0.0104233418,
0.0135117378,
-0.022074312,
0.0051068347,
0.041577965,
-0.0083844606,
0.023252219,
-0.0659144223,
-0.037359897,
-0.0138187082,
-0.0518115014,
-0.0323715582,
-0.050637424,
0.0801496804,
0.0639516115,
0.0383761823,
0.0135139758,
0.0076943045,
0.0151456343,
0.0097736958,
-0.0045243343,
0.004971636,
0.0212735943,
-0.0470222756,
-0.0571354106,
0.0300683323,
-0.0258624256,
0.0661671534,
-0.0074937274,
0.0047972617,
-0.0055015208,
-0.0231096614,
0.034354765,
-0.0424585678,
0.0433911122,
-0.0227390323,
-0.0388495959,
0.0009843779,
-0.0406978615,
0.0186317228,
0.0143515607,
0.0221021306,
-0.0304998923,
-0.0389128923,
-0.0031423671,
1.80899133e-34,
0.0534335263,
-0.0797004327,
-0.0099284891,
0.0132195577,
0.0435093604,
-0.0528330803,
-0.0459201373,
-0.0131966388,
-0.0606759042,
-0.0199476872,
-0.0699973702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02468v1 | Comparative Analysis of CHATGPT and the evolution of language models | 2023-03-28T03:11:28 | 2023-03-28T03:11:28 | Oluwatosin Ogundare, Gustavo Quiros Araya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interest in Large Language Models (LLMs) has increased drastically since the
emergence of ChatGPT and the outstanding positive societal response to the ease
with which it performs tasks in Natural Language Processing (NLP). The triumph
of ChatGPT, however, is how it seamlessly bridges the divide between language
generation and knowledge models. In some cases, it provides anecdotal evidence
of a framework for replicating human intuition over a knowledge domain. This
paper highlights the prevailing ideas in NLP, including machine translation,
machine summarization, question-answering, and language generation, and
compares the performance of ChatGPT with the major algorithms in each of these
categories using the Spontaneous Quality (SQ) score. A strategy for validating
the arguments and results of ChatGPT is presented summarily as an example of
safe, large-scale adoption of LLMs. | [
0.0623301417,
0.0062751872,
0.0069527114,
-0.0100211827,
-0.0736922026,
-0.0042333985,
-0.0323787555,
-0.0018353288,
0.0135384686,
-0.0494517721,
0.0370601565,
-0.0493434668,
0.0091256788,
0.0494719632,
0.0123300813,
-0.0474198684,
0.0280252993,
-0.0187642053,
-0.0084390789,
-0.0092209661,
0.008397975,
0.0206557401,
0.0197384171,
0.05690616,
0.008687837,
-0.0001073547,
-0.0115940766,
-0.0354466662,
-0.0246265102,
-0.0055449535,
-0.0211081784,
0.0338986516,
-0.0025378291,
0.0367746651,
0.0000020999,
-0.0774002969,
-0.0084289508,
-0.0010383268,
0.0041726828,
0.0253101457,
0.0304209888,
0.0151519943,
-0.0066891415,
0.0400354713,
-0.0474132299,
0.0244602636,
0.0228707008,
0.0250714757,
0.0758002475,
0.0555177331,
-0.0031926997,
-0.0391563103,
0.0335883386,
-0.0002510696,
0.0054465989,
-0.0395174697,
0.012867827,
0.054945752,
0.0224063918,
0.0164017007,
0.0162629653,
0.0488646738,
0.0008849541,
-0.013586238,
-0.0024100619,
0.0312373508,
-0.0771216378,
-0.0441405289,
-0.0142874178,
0.0368162319,
-0.0006021793,
-0.0275642984,
0.0129800597,
0.0332026966,
-0.0038118914,
0.0172044467,
-0.0578702316,
0.0674720332,
-0.0236752685,
0.0134429215,
0.0226565748,
-0.0099350139,
-0.0214491505,
0.0230380483,
-0.0010625402,
0.0387675427,
0.0104322806,
-0.0368113443,
-0.0159095433,
0.0145166125,
-0.0691441521,
-0.0752204582,
-0.0061616073,
0.0401041955,
-0.0122779878,
0.0047755004,
-0.0331414565,
0.0363622718,
0.0340814069,
-0.0648072585,
-0.0120261153,
0.033255823,
0.025466999,
0.0315029509,
-0.0244393554,
0.0507770292,
0.0060559995,
-0.0070008286,
-0.0759735927,
-0.0064070821,
-0.0871678144,
-0.0393437371,
-0.0475259461,
0.0357346646,
-0.0402972177,
-0.0302217137,
-0.043252293,
0.044798933,
0.0442062318,
-0.0227887556,
0.0212634001,
0.0146036306,
-0.0103952987,
-0.0003987073,
-0.0432341024,
-0.0011714103,
-0.0243014228,
-0.0099456338,
0.0272176024,
-0.0568474196,
0.0168759692,
0.0254846141,
-0.0042449767,
0.018752357,
0.0095432801,
0.0758389235,
-0.0172001682,
0.0026123321,
-0.0298108701,
-0.0424986109,
-0.0486393273,
-0.0619607419,
0.0051902281,
-0.0790383816,
0.0070476569,
0.0253078975,
-0.0301888157,
0.019482905,
0.0109056896,
0.0378401652,
-0.0587688722,
0.0055988999,
-0.0482581593,
0.0500625111,
0.0426469743,
-0.0000648004,
-0.0098987455,
0.0532983504,
0.0391332321,
0.0236934274,
0.045961801,
0.0006515309,
0.0070106103,
0.0135850348,
-0.0208205208,
-0.007517301,
0.0071825176,
0.0009122927,
-0.0186152868,
0.0044431617,
-0.02375797,
0.0987476781,
-0.0148789696,
0.040612299,
0.0553546026,
0.0632870644,
0.0192616992,
0.0547015704,
0.0496037193,
0.047615733,
0.0377399921,
0.0247015599,
0.0014216586,
0.0044506076,
-0.0597929135,
0.0460424051,
0.0469899513,
0.0470067635,
-0.0177585166,
-0.0390612446,
-0.0273057632,
0.0186196789,
0.02379076,
-0.0264626294,
0.0260660928,
-0.0009514458,
-0.0120364353,
0.0305358674,
0.015463776,
-0.0290789548,
-0.0030602016,
-0.0974330828,
0.0323112607,
0.0452769175,
0.0470268093,
0.0274722055,
-0.0149182724,
-0.0223405212,
0.0001748877,
0.0552592315,
0.0413606092,
0.005504414,
-0.0451262444,
-0.0217350442,
0.006114129,
0.0172172654,
0.0014053951,
-0.0253474843,
0.0094713876,
-0.0001463482,
0.0295789596,
-0.0164233465,
-0.0431354083,
0.0269806646,
-0.0234850217,
-0.0058580716,
-0.0037863851,
-0.0347090103,
0.0329411104,
0.0447276235,
-0.0192198157,
0.0580158941,
-0.002820085,
-0.0201579016,
-0.0511209778,
0.0456809737,
-0.0323563665,
-0.0429901183,
0.0308793951,
-0.0567915849,
0.008753607,
-0.0117467316,
-0.0134953866,
-0.0479128137,
-0.002700669,
-0.0763855502,
0.035513673,
-0.0745388195,
0.018140506,
-0.0056159589,
-0.0134336501,
-0.0408211574,
0.0754457861,
0.003357375,
-0.0003248451,
0.0088575967,
0.0018833008,
0.0333297849,
-0.020656636,
-0.020338947,
0.0180980861,
-0.0041311337,
0.0619161464,
0.0624251775,
0.0680199414,
-0.0491035171,
-0.0435006395,
-0.101425454,
0.0171279963,
-0.0122864228,
0.0175951738,
0.0380452722,
-0.0097250333,
-0.0232347921,
0.0274633393,
-0.0546195917,
-0.0078500267,
0.0627735257,
0.0266698897,
0.0496849157,
-0.0105738919,
0.0019840137,
-0.018616071,
0.0032493735,
-0.0009274498,
0.0359134674,
0.0471989848,
-0.0123917889,
-0.0531149842,
0.059783455,
-0.0614768341,
-0.0303711407,
0.0176397339,
-0.0437939614,
0.0274916273,
-0.0179205164,
0.0608921349,
0.0108592035,
0.0624633096,
0.0016808413,
0.0219664294,
0.0032854695,
-0.0055994806,
-0.016824754,
-0.0676160827,
-0.0431310795,
0.0302070547,
-0.0556278564,
0.024201069,
0.060255032,
0.0276111085,
-0.0052556368,
-0.0609353296,
0.0661400482,
-0.0233581662,
0.0162728298,
-0.0598875098,
-0.0186259504,
-0.0286568571,
0.070487909,
-0.0155504802,
-0.0289696697,
0.0442469828,
-0.0377443247,
0.0158648305,
-0.0880041867,
-0.021721717,
-0.0372280516,
0.0475585051,
-0.0056193266,
0.0555350482,
-0.0030160344,
0.0081546344,
-0.0348136239,
-0.0038378683,
0.0326500162,
-0.032268282,
0.0144326445,
-0.0626169518,
0.0100949453,
0.0002962324,
0.0037473119,
-0.0337794535,
-0.0418895297,
-0.0297563449,
0.0094054826,
0.0666703731,
0.0272031724,
0.0125344237,
0.0683308169,
0.0299734343,
-0.0269273054,
-0.0220123455,
-0.0182428341,
0.0015467558,
0.0537271202,
0.0579481237,
-0.0044681816,
0.0446613953,
0.0082765091,
0.042027615,
0.0731632859,
0.0092129689,
0.0277791191,
0.0049185068,
-0.0100752367,
-0.0154465176,
-0.0435247906,
-0.0434888899,
0.0188164581,
0.0407920778,
-0.0286775269,
0.0098430617,
0.118488431,
0.0419692248,
-0.0002307561,
-0.0025469221,
0.0004769584,
0.018108407,
-0.000308851,
0.0282115266,
-0.0724660382,
-0.0134764602,
-0.0073575219,
0.0171833411,
-0.0315959267,
-0.0269476883,
-0.0245817918,
-0.1048023477,
0.0474032909,
0.0014081978,
-0.077213034,
-0.009223029,
-0.0371261872,
-0.0415403247,
0.0104931928,
0.0063921781,
0.0314054862,
-0.0338192917,
0.0293702167,
0.0320129357,
-0.0710280985,
-0.0247536115,
0.0080865147,
-0.0369951464,
0.0547997914,
0.07693813,
0.0427701361,
-0.0200482253,
0.0027615144,
0.0527087301,
0.0139152622,
0.0158190094,
-0.0045651472,
0.0327404737,
0.0081998752,
0.0022336601,
-0.0701512694,
-0.0027358655,
-0.0106119988,
0.005483726,
0.0306405928,
0.0356898457,
-0.008352682,
-0.0393931903,
-0.0321475603,
0.0526182763,
-0.0366170928,
0.0940274671,
0.0180573761,
-0.0363056697,
-0.0450890362,
-0.0342486762,
-0.0008638583,
-0.0153088914,
-0.0676755458,
0.0203308351,
-0.0191094074,
-0.0224542134,
-0.0930607393,
-0.0460406803,
0.0106335562,
0.0142147774,
-0.0166650265,
0.0137984585,
0.0073310188,
0.0189776104,
-0.0037886086,
0.00865357,
-0.0047003911,
-0.0347473025,
-0.0506762639,
0.0025636221,
0.0535407253,
-0.0585670993,
-0.024395356,
0.0078352857,
-0.0555474162,
-0.0720366836,
-0.0070305672,
0.0450760759,
0.0374180786,
-0.0010628194,
0.0017865464,
0.0021296323,
0.0419832729,
0.0491401292,
-0.0227953885,
0.0168732256,
-0.0349171311,
0.0586203262,
-0.0050142347,
0.0097988937,
-0.0343048833,
0.0305579696,
-0.0479504392,
0.0792967975,
-0.0043762582,
-0.0455412753,
0.0479316749,
0.0743344501,
-0.0012172242,
-0.0416493341,
-0.0075197555,
-0.0064915665,
-0.0551192872,
-0.0261604115,
-0.0166561082,
-0.0580828339,
0.0055602966,
-0.0135769295,
-0.003311476,
0.0063698501,
-0.0041901614,
-0.0580711365,
0.0375330374,
0.010818419,
-0.0024265193,
-0.0272447914,
0.0162557121,
0.0227081589,
-0.0230506323,
-0.0508498959,
-0.0023710669,
-0.0329960883,
0.0092059495,
-0.0080537153,
0.0568016209,
0.0134142591,
-0.0138913095,
0.020115342,
0.0349785164,
-0.0770997405,
-0.0860816017,
-0.0443304777,
0.0598026663,
0.0656914189,
0.0090284934,
0.056299489,
-0.033459235,
-0.0182579383,
-0.0313434899,
0.0424534939,
0.0312326942,
-0.0192403644,
-0.0123245725,
0.0026073414,
-0.0521556102,
-0.0303266216,
0.0963143632,
-0.0087001771,
-0.0180652067,
0.0233103186,
-0.0527581647,
-0.037910711,
-0.0243788362,
-0.0221895203,
-0.0118758129,
0.0149011845,
0.0151392817,
-0.0842338204,
-0.0461843684,
-0.0215006731,
0.0216236301,
0.0378810987,
-0.0033360301,
0.0523813106,
0.0811479762,
-0.0010830428,
0.012000761,
-0.0646859854,
0.0184779037,
-0.0540479161,
0.0202280544,
0.0085701309,
-6.681190303e-33,
-0.0102162799,
-0.0298342016,
0.0246000458,
0.0194380656,
-0.0200374797,
-0.0158909503,
-0.0351696573,
0.0373071134,
-0.0033070119,
0.0054936996,
-0.0234541129,
-0.0274286363,
-0.0002607765,
0.0074111093,
0.0130488127,
-0.009068856,
0.0117885172,
-0.036914926,
-0.0098184897,
0.0121581852,
0.0131961657,
-0.0015751504,
0.0203778557,
-0.0128503069,
0.0167396478,
-0.0427797176,
-0.0114969928,
0.0151862465,
0.0081466557,
0.0353888385,
-0.0217749886,
0.0419230387,
0.039429456,
-0.0406708531,
-0.0069230567,
0.0003486674,
-0.0147621837,
-0.030737238,
0.0372551195,
-0.0415508896,
-0.0311397184,
-0.0220131185,
0.028318353,
-0.0290938355,
-0.033714138,
0.0070825568,
0.0245069712,
-0.0342993252,
-0.0310455821,
-0.041704569,
-0.0251156949,
0.0278121401,
-0.0016137245,
-0.0353946537,
-0.0189718883,
0.0351209529,
-0.0372941494,
-0.0309288464,
-0.0006710639,
0.0398098752,
0.0496734492,
-0.0045527336,
0.0555036291,
-0.0059577832,
0.0092846397,
0.0510795675,
0.015991481,
0.0019681901,
-0.0459089577,
0.0106292879,
-0.0054501034,
0.0280339345,
0.0206629653,
0.0416823663,
0.0124847451,
-0.0041272324,
-0.0510858186,
0.0547780879,
0.0098802214,
0.0002751572,
0.0414275788,
-0.0292599034,
-0.0343699493,
-0.0392354056,
-0.0304964539,
0.0081365928,
-0.0153938821,
-0.0378582105,
0.0274444353,
-0.004157308,
-0.0266911257,
-0.0592712946,
0.0345026478,
-0.0440325961,
0.0315131992,
-0.0090941424,
-0.048948925,
0.0113864597,
-0.0166377183,
0.0317485891,
-0.0545782596,
0.0174461901,
-0.0010418922,
0.021046441,
-0.0219736677,
0.0211015549,
-0.0109793236,
-0.0252883956,
-0.0221916474,
0.0241512991,
-0.0222721882,
0.0262124632,
-0.0092986282,
-0.0354081355,
0.0066019832,
-0.0067364895,
-0.006352758,
0.023801988,
0.0179331843,
0.0121611459,
-0.0307829529,
0.0129948901,
0.005308541,
0.0236644354,
-0.033443328,
0.0444070585,
-0.0213970523,
0.0359041765,
0.0389602855,
-0.025558304,
-0.0224484541,
-0.0004769545,
2.872e-7,
0.060199596,
0.0673051625,
0.0423892327,
0.0120415641,
0.0033827638,
0.018972965,
0.0073766368,
-0.0031611032,
0.0237640366,
0.0410245508,
0.010773411,
0.0359978154,
0.0421775877,
0.0443119034,
-0.0938178822,
-0.025540052,
-0.0882726088,
-0.0196780227,
-0.0268496908,
0.0129227117,
0.1024020463,
0.0464420952,
-0.0369833447,
-0.0211452302,
-0.0284900032,
-0.0578119755,
0.0655985698,
-0.0204878859,
-0.0498035364,
0.0463310778,
0.0551297516,
0.0229303595,
0.0044528088,
0.0066677132,
0.0077209515,
-0.0310322307,
0.0544520654,
0.0594238937,
0.0176409259,
-0.0034569255,
0.0259806961,
-0.0254444983,
0.0451428667,
-0.0692115203,
0.0855512246,
-0.0947449431,
-0.0224683229,
-0.0103779603,
-0.0347595997,
-0.0216740929,
-0.0116193043,
-0.0379112661,
-0.0310398024,
0.0155669805,
0.0086064069,
0.0057261917,
0.0172724854,
-0.0456044786,
-0.0202922262,
0.0056122006,
-0.0238279495,
-0.0753219202,
-0.0093796281,
0.0280460976,
0.0327328891,
-0.041796606,
-0.0040106429,
2.815292899e-34,
0.0647697747,
-0.0101747084,
0.0183077715,
-0.0172647219,
0.0437367707,
0.0228343252,
0.0559270047,
-0.0001239686,
-0.0033321138,
-0.0571168661,
-0.0208478086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15697v1 | Model and Evaluation: Towards Fairness in Multilingual Text Classification | 2023-03-28T03:00:01 | 2023-03-28T03:00:01 | Nankai Lin, Junheng He, Zhenghang Tang, Dong Zhou, Aimin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, more and more research has focused on addressing bias in text
classification models. However, existing research mainly focuses on the
fairness of monolingual text classification models, and research on fairness
for multilingual text classification is still very limited. In this paper, we
focus on the task of multilingual text classification and propose a debiasing
framework for multilingual text classification based on contrastive learning.
Our proposed method does not rely on any external language resources and can be
extended to any other languages. The model contains four modules: multilingual
text representation module, language fusion module, text debiasing module, and
text classification module. The multilingual text representation module uses a
multilingual pre-trained language model to represent the text, the language
fusion module makes the semantic spaces of different languages tend to be
consistent through contrastive learning, and the text debiasing module uses
contrastive learning to make the model unable to identify sensitive attributes'
information. The text classification module completes the basic tasks of
multilingual text classification. In addition, the existing research on the
fairness of multilingual text classification is relatively simple in the
evaluation mode. The evaluation method of fairness is the same as the
monolingual equality difference evaluation method, that is, the evaluation is
performed on a single language. We propose a multi-dimensional fairness
evaluation framework for multilingual text classification, which evaluates the
model's monolingual equality difference, multilingual equality difference,
multilingual equality performance difference, and destructiveness of the
fairness strategy. We hope that our work can provide a more general debiasing
method and a more comprehensive evaluation framework for multilingual text
fairness tasks. | [
0.0336469933,
0.0430404246,
-0.0172564704,
0.0667093769,
-0.0581671223,
0.0427139327,
0.0719091818,
-0.0176327676,
0.0235264674,
-0.0914736763,
-0.0328281559,
-0.0291405972,
0.0138181774,
-0.0324782319,
-0.0272043999,
-0.0648233667,
0.0285277441,
0.0233319532,
0.0167811736,
-0.0596848838,
0.0332184061,
0.0164972916,
0.0297220964,
0.0044708545,
-0.0004934426,
0.0141556226,
0.0693981275,
-0.030047847,
0.0413068309,
0.0040488406,
0.0548153482,
0.0794424787,
-0.023907356,
0.0441000685,
0.0000018131,
-0.0657287166,
-0.0274404418,
0.0179518834,
0.0402955376,
-0.0372943133,
0.0983442813,
-0.0577324182,
0.0032833854,
0.0360594466,
0.0004086189,
-0.0118178707,
0.0529964902,
0.0564294495,
0.0210056379,
0.0293911938,
-0.0121388044,
-0.0616761595,
-0.0328575484,
-0.001684695,
-0.0283355694,
0.012914706,
0.0364511646,
-0.0102678211,
-0.05775721,
0.0279042255,
-0.0080274567,
0.0182818715,
0.0340479873,
0.0531687737,
-0.0204975549,
0.0047831242,
-0.0108965756,
-0.0146146389,
0.0164709706,
0.018308077,
-0.0353273302,
-0.0282584764,
-0.0291166529,
-0.0269496813,
0.0263506677,
-0.0355228819,
0.0030295367,
0.0402543545,
-0.0224391408,
0.0444584154,
0.0871122926,
0.0739094988,
0.0111598223,
0.0553919449,
-0.0278724879,
0.008373403,
0.0180476345,
-0.0331249125,
-0.005778214,
0.0777877942,
0.020824708,
-0.0277714171,
0.0334541947,
-0.0156600792,
0.0158253238,
-0.013960409,
-0.0195735283,
-0.0992453322,
0.0638373643,
-0.0989869982,
-0.0353450589,
0.0082917595,
-0.055129569,
0.0183328204,
0.0129553443,
0.0398261733,
0.0214255843,
0.0196351577,
-0.0251637977,
-0.0418397896,
0.0029287576,
0.0203623325,
0.0223768819,
0.0262677893,
-0.0417462848,
0.0639081076,
-0.0517710634,
-0.0043629338,
-0.0525758415,
-0.0223309956,
0.0015676339,
-0.0212484505,
-0.0083010904,
0.0194925889,
-0.0194054078,
0.0118115842,
-0.0265378226,
0.0247839391,
-0.0871751606,
-0.041139394,
0.0212904364,
0.0240522213,
-0.0491835661,
-0.0442287363,
0.0367654115,
0.0615415499,
-0.0079341428,
-0.0520402901,
-0.0221631154,
-0.0002074621,
-0.000559616,
-0.0476567447,
-0.041574873,
-0.059104085,
0.011462112,
0.0077438084,
-0.0017900177,
-0.0286702178,
-0.0302366093,
-0.0061778417,
-0.0442278832,
0.0790632442,
0.0391167365,
-0.0651761517,
0.0629057512,
0.0039416743,
-0.0212438516,
0.0604979731,
-0.0260506961,
-0.0086568752,
0.0595854148,
0.0304291509,
-0.0200394616,
0.0140889315,
0.0101279356,
0.0042324108,
-0.0430646837,
0.0199822839,
0.0215709899,
-0.0321302451,
0.0311739352,
0.0178493094,
0.0171245541,
-0.0408313237,
0.0232193824,
0.0182101894,
0.0150468294,
0.0297776144,
-0.0144836828,
-0.0078136446,
-0.0654453486,
0.0567285269,
-0.0252321791,
-0.0163600873,
-0.0293557514,
-0.025099488,
0.0488578975,
0.0586057678,
-0.038196411,
-0.037550319,
0.0292518437,
-0.0308860727,
0.0681323484,
-0.0098620802,
0.04167917,
-0.0124672614,
-0.0040632384,
-0.0071005109,
0.0646014139,
-0.0449308045,
0.0344449878,
-0.0407221168,
0.0075197322,
0.0414836183,
0.0040967721,
-0.0517726652,
0.0414815471,
-0.0076707527,
-0.0303600356,
0.0595391728,
0.0526731759,
-0.0074300696,
0.0050486736,
-0.0409724377,
-0.0470429398,
-0.0279019177,
0.004409852,
0.0491802506,
-0.0410557427,
0.0656459183,
0.0121464413,
0.0058446205,
-0.0610854216,
0.0320937447,
0.0165463835,
-0.0299207363,
0.0292180981,
0.0220952611,
-0.0106381271,
0.0258765873,
-0.0474231578,
-0.0221024323,
-0.0125286663,
-0.0386352353,
-0.0049143783,
-0.0114980433,
-0.0239147227,
-0.0609605908,
0.0132102659,
-0.0295398608,
0.0075141629,
0.053781718,
-0.0463793688,
0.0008130043,
0.037404459,
0.0366144143,
-0.0049049594,
-0.0262659043,
0.0286152419,
-0.0620107055,
0.0270003062,
-0.0521720387,
0.0519535877,
-0.0071221595,
0.0454907641,
-0.0298277028,
-0.0296327509,
0.0503859073,
-0.025002582,
-0.0325550996,
0.043380294,
0.0275629107,
0.0402137898,
0.0627318025,
0.0152433254,
0.0406693742,
0.0026238721,
-0.0478124693,
0.005057863,
-0.0339762755,
0.0229712501,
0.0028337867,
0.0149160335,
0.0079795439,
-0.0331521705,
-0.041106727,
-0.0709676296,
0.0153331859,
0.035661269,
0.0252536312,
-0.034392301,
0.0401383862,
-0.0049095252,
-0.0333758891,
0.0065400475,
0.0626434162,
0.0349909291,
-0.0146290679,
-0.051749032,
0.0024737155,
-0.0217073821,
0.0502932481,
0.0018048275,
-0.0181151591,
-0.0157637503,
0.0585995317,
-0.0233521871,
0.0332499743,
0.0358797759,
0.0151258456,
0.0590579063,
0.0144957164,
-0.0216286723,
-0.0119110271,
0.0025779675,
0.0699230507,
0.0039004113,
-0.040395733,
0.0040565752,
0.0442382507,
0.0092586204,
-0.048046004,
-0.0441881977,
-0.0021166992,
-0.0356620513,
-0.0201133974,
-0.0175778884,
0.0052936189,
0.0100643355,
0.0085644498,
-0.0136925848,
-0.053752888,
0.0749797001,
-0.008693804,
0.0434449688,
-0.1124814227,
-0.026446471,
-0.0383520089,
0.0184511188,
-0.0287646651,
0.0597709864,
-0.0206564851,
-0.0164805837,
-0.0302084107,
-0.0401943214,
0.0719455704,
-0.025192149,
0.0239177309,
-0.0061457832,
-0.0199183654,
-0.0518782064,
-0.0620407127,
-0.0313441716,
-0.0357507206,
0.0046727057,
0.0278876442,
0.0384798422,
0.0090613337,
-0.052985128,
0.0197871458,
0.0039828857,
0.0499091521,
-0.0130887888,
0.0137640415,
0.0198403634,
0.0195063353,
-0.0334639512,
-0.0408985466,
-0.0054009142,
-0.0226193722,
0.0034705671,
0.0100340527,
-0.0117212515,
0.0047581582,
0.0455327965,
0.0070805983,
0.0441861823,
-0.0566158593,
-0.0389054939,
-0.0421061851,
-0.0051874537,
-0.0300245658,
0.0190574247,
0.0780489817,
0.0251471214,
-0.0804862604,
-0.0198471397,
-0.0137465065,
-0.029355973,
0.0150702959,
0.0000052105,
-0.0753049329,
-0.0038180144,
-0.0148470299,
-0.0069318879,
-0.0372799449,
0.0088032484,
0.0058092717,
-0.0667612702,
-0.0270290319,
0.0144796036,
-0.0676065683,
-0.0623342134,
-0.0116583575,
-0.0095157418,
-0.0331159271,
0.0235919561,
-0.0323592201,
0.0387840495,
-0.0121659366,
0.0122526111,
0.0051884409,
-0.0357176811,
0.012407246,
-0.0503157862,
-0.0114583885,
0.0120063005,
0.041670341,
-0.0556005947,
-0.0415256135,
-0.0080045555,
-0.0612170845,
-0.0384320803,
-0.0455704629,
0.0447539575,
-0.0291081909,
-0.0128480224,
-0.0378490873,
-0.0219244082,
0.0426095575,
0.0092515778,
-0.0158952847,
0.0336959027,
0.0147074917,
0.0003157145,
-0.0496908091,
-0.0137561923,
0.0229950417,
0.0468458682,
-0.0217203069,
-0.0613041893,
-0.0299018677,
-0.0542836711,
-0.0199350473,
-0.0398373604,
0.0062072268,
0.0410144813,
-0.0264061242,
-0.0489078611,
-0.0353466943,
-0.0713573918,
-0.056365367,
-0.0330627896,
-0.0096360464,
-0.0022644559,
-0.0451312289,
-0.0250279177,
-0.0304112807,
-0.0217105187,
0.0164042339,
0.0557842366,
0.0044898004,
0.0088528851,
0.0055127093,
-0.039493639,
-0.0363788791,
-0.0270124171,
0.0166264046,
-0.0587815903,
-0.0027812826,
0.0150846634,
0.0020702786,
0.0216117464,
-0.0206988975,
-0.0552180447,
0.0680575147,
0.0397946015,
-0.0027049407,
-0.0254523829,
0.0795237944,
-0.0229798723,
-0.0032433805,
0.00775172,
-0.0224063862,
0.0365758687,
0.0288296919,
-0.0290368628,
-0.025933627,
-0.0410295203,
-0.0246787053,
-0.0076578991,
0.0367207155,
-0.0263262298,
-0.017130686,
-0.0649289861,
0.0047940481,
0.0030971926,
-0.0647357106,
0.0047523677,
0.0035809977,
0.0138668912,
0.0268527996,
-0.0361822993,
0.0239581279,
-0.024426749,
-0.0219867304,
0.0012685923,
0.0322587043,
0.0495572351,
0.0750715584,
-0.0252884682,
0.0246729143,
-0.0277487189,
-0.0266795866,
0.0250629466,
0.0290493667,
-0.0234819781,
0.0046602567,
0.0253148172,
0.0232074279,
-0.0298159141,
0.0128175439,
0.0131949577,
0.0593319051,
-0.0208694618,
-0.0358362198,
0.0614909157,
-0.0118547548,
0.0007094904,
0.0135260513,
-0.0172831789,
-0.0126871625,
0.0158521514,
0.0148433503,
0.0006642547,
0.0232895762,
-0.0175186414,
0.0018994812,
0.0264304634,
0.0530586056,
-0.0137280095,
0.0236567613,
-0.0185540821,
-0.0513860285,
-0.0041221343,
-0.0046630837,
0.0467921235,
-0.0010349309,
-0.0301504526,
-0.0108253974,
-0.0574668348,
-0.0622144826,
0.0279290117,
0.0310058333,
0.0110602854,
0.0096148588,
-0.0088541182,
0.0677549765,
0.0085540293,
-0.0109156556,
-0.0383939222,
-0.0164517537,
-0.0175235551,
-0.0072478368,
-0.0061653177,
-5.358221002e-33,
0.0133275799,
-0.0115904128,
-0.0261330195,
-0.0171752758,
0.0458585471,
-0.0072989194,
0.0247462429,
-0.0354063436,
-0.02414749,
0.0245052278,
0.03169984,
0.0003227518,
0.0079467846,
0.0123210205,
0.0039549251,
-0.0015665089,
0.0443228669,
0.0302445274,
-0.0238800552,
0.0149324434,
0.0181822591,
0.0086676273,
0.0860566571,
-0.0757649839,
0.0923192576,
-0.018874418,
0.0021691932,
0.0277112611,
0.013251381,
0.0425977223,
0.0011529932,
0.0938110948,
0.0577575713,
-0.0312020052,
0.0017014979,
0.0243644416,
-0.017604243,
-0.0604342446,
0.0286386199,
0.0299577862,
0.0023636254,
-0.0236629117,
0.010418755,
0.0365311801,
-0.030154394,
-0.0255948044,
0.0814463124,
-0.0051766206,
0.0232395902,
0.0126147894,
-0.0396347307,
0.0485969968,
-0.0013906325,
0.0252506472,
0.027935626,
0.0360886119,
0.0369562358,
0.0439370237,
-0.0483049378,
0.0039128619,
0.0115812067,
-0.0457781367,
0.0226457287,
0.013177258,
-0.0075120977,
0.0315539837,
0.0180491451,
0.0411966033,
0.0489500649,
-0.0212363265,
0.0183532164,
-0.0436911397,
0.054069452,
0.1360663921,
0.0369056948,
-0.0097528752,
-0.0890586302,
0.0502096079,
0.0229154415,
-0.0032208981,
0.0216353834,
-0.0074780541,
-0.0651162267,
-0.0567127876,
-0.0127340415,
-0.0841488391,
-0.0312068481,
-0.0114368275,
0.0035629757,
0.0099988617,
-0.0181249399,
0.0347360447,
0.022877045,
-0.0475671589,
-0.050210055,
0.0610396042,
-0.0287339203,
-0.0186042842,
0.0114337113,
-0.0010784055,
-0.0396356061,
-0.0365312956,
-0.0021200469,
0.0099615743,
0.0011643615,
0.0040916246,
0.050578367,
-0.0212375559,
-0.0483751819,
0.0218611192,
0.0107665975,
-0.0006896204,
0.0266079847,
0.0705852658,
-0.016030442,
0.0071032336,
0.0038987927,
0.044114124,
0.0488145873,
-0.0238044336,
-0.052606225,
-0.0313842036,
-0.0265379976,
0.0246899985,
-0.0190236475,
-0.0135180103,
0.0089962333,
0.0102770897,
0.0370540358,
-0.028700782,
-0.0024899445,
-0.0421352088,
2.409e-7,
0.0281332731,
-0.0075993207,
-0.0211178828,
-0.0132275578,
-0.0011719029,
0.0748388693,
0.009388525,
0.0636088848,
-0.0036401593,
0.0725434422,
-0.0216066577,
0.013118838,
0.0159676205,
0.0428587832,
-0.0297907367,
0.0121342847,
-0.0644570515,
0.0221203249,
-0.0038566289,
0.024086142,
0.0498428866,
0.0509527102,
0.0200289227,
-0.0298543591,
-0.0259365458,
-0.020945007,
0.0414081812,
-0.0262740664,
-0.0025351031,
-0.0182004087,
0.0161166228,
-0.00110862,
0.0237439852,
0.0463405624,
-0.0157450754,
0.0361377038,
0.0274054315,
0.0201187339,
-0.0189904347,
0.0259431284,
-0.0001224272,
-0.022184737,
-0.0213929899,
-0.0571043007,
0.0358506329,
0.0217008181,
-0.025779916,
-0.0517570339,
0.0043584965,
-0.0096579688,
0.1266275048,
-0.0064712311,
-0.0549658053,
0.0354953296,
0.0235549212,
0.0306048356,
-0.006908983,
-0.069388181,
-0.0334536768,
0.0182559323,
0.0061017345,
0.0197122693,
0.0336740613,
0.0018925034,
0.0306642018,
-0.0213982426,
0.09852878,
1.695919564e-34,
0.0210523941,
-0.0147089865,
-0.0140009578,
-0.02163147,
-0.0034586829,
0.0000411257,
-0.0281997398,
-0.0070842989,
0.0351276323,
-0.000892523,
0.0071096164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02746v1 | Sejarah dan Perkembangan Teknik Natural Language Processing (NLP) Bahasa Indonesia: Tinjauan tentang sejarah, perkembangan teknologi, dan aplikasi NLP dalam bahasa Indonesia | 2023-03-28T02:31:47 | 2023-03-28T02:31:47 | Mukhlis Amien | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | This study provides an overview of the history of the development of Natural
Language Processing (NLP) in the context of the Indonesian language, with a
focus on the basic technologies, methods, and practical applications that have
been developed. This review covers developments in basic NLP technologies such
as stemming, part-of-speech tagging, and related methods; practical
applications in cross-language information retrieval systems, information
extraction, and sentiment analysis; and methods and techniques used in
Indonesian language NLP research, such as machine learning, statistics-based
machine translation, and conflict-based approaches. This study also explores
the application of NLP in Indonesian language industry and research and
identifies challenges and opportunities in Indonesian language NLP research and
development. Recommendations for future Indonesian language NLP research and
development include developing more efficient methods and technologies,
expanding NLP applications, increasing sustainability, further research into
the potential of NLP, and promoting interdisciplinary collaboration. It is
hoped that this review will help researchers, practitioners, and the government
to understand the development of Indonesian language NLP and identify
opportunities for further research and development. | [
0.0944210663,
0.0069043664,
-0.0281875506,
0.0132183628,
-0.0596774071,
0.0255775619,
-0.0213016588,
0.0471720584,
0.0165405944,
-0.0823268816,
0.042684529,
0.0197220128,
0.020541558,
-0.0151327988,
0.0162722711,
-0.1009288281,
0.0427599959,
0.0318039395,
0.0829046443,
0.0363525487,
0.0215567946,
0.0275853164,
-0.0183466449,
0.0397676639,
-0.0326094516,
0.0227237344,
0.0121490313,
-0.0502950139,
-0.0076841037,
-0.0523303039,
-0.000787367,
0.0004610507,
-0.0505891033,
-0.0081468774,
0.0000019458,
-0.0791446939,
-0.043557819,
-0.0012459111,
-0.0088111684,
-0.043233335,
0.1024983004,
-0.0018600147,
-0.0402305424,
0.0228800979,
-0.0296996236,
-0.0081550889,
0.0581992678,
0.0558290109,
0.0545439497,
0.0410888344,
-0.004529105,
-0.094375059,
0.0000277441,
0.0318183377,
-0.0196324214,
0.0292557795,
0.0095980577,
-0.0420505367,
0.0085265031,
-0.0305659734,
0.0035862916,
0.0394085459,
-0.0681940392,
0.0004248304,
-0.0065066316,
-0.035561718,
-0.0848973766,
-0.0675456822,
0.0230545197,
-0.0140389064,
0.0070552365,
-0.0156342145,
-0.0095085911,
-0.0173047166,
-0.0009163227,
0.0425922088,
-0.0137261851,
-0.0081691742,
-0.0580195077,
0.0244554821,
0.0825690776,
0.0592570938,
-0.0297458898,
0.022268232,
0.0059974482,
0.024833383,
-0.0032469633,
-0.0119875167,
0.0229817927,
-0.0044824388,
0.0410837047,
-0.0179746374,
0.0258293897,
0.0121795181,
0.0288603138,
0.051610928,
0.0219092835,
-0.0392674729,
0.0571202226,
-0.0828380659,
-0.0430235416,
0.0037055523,
0.0350483507,
0.0102828722,
0.0054669837,
-0.0252028983,
0.025726812,
-0.0078318631,
-0.0032761253,
-0.0486991517,
-0.0560212545,
-0.0423923954,
-0.0362861864,
0.0492211394,
-0.0369278081,
0.0200290214,
-0.0480094999,
-0.0048607267,
0.0013679939,
-0.0441407785,
0.0511225201,
-0.0016865423,
-0.0099361707,
0.0205455143,
-0.0513866246,
0.0201909021,
-0.0204455592,
-0.013759681,
-0.0087908925,
-0.0514739715,
0.0649458617,
0.004779873,
0.0072805979,
-0.0103578242,
0.0360955074,
0.0282509681,
0.0034908627,
-0.0284392666,
-0.097483702,
-0.0184268989,
-0.0015527336,
-0.0426790565,
-0.0220000688,
-0.0509589054,
0.0367895067,
0.0356081575,
-0.0071902471,
-0.0074149072,
0.0269357655,
0.0392411985,
-0.0336978547,
0.0552500933,
-0.0590211824,
-0.0005296809,
0.0234689415,
-0.0067512947,
0.0857688934,
0.0291904323,
0.0200147629,
-0.0022972338,
0.073007226,
-0.030767601,
-0.0485496223,
0.0047334158,
-0.0307771787,
-0.0513870195,
-0.023748735,
0.0033596191,
-0.0447825529,
-0.013512563,
-0.0458646119,
0.045144219,
-0.0058722296,
0.0620366707,
-0.0344993211,
0.0750738382,
0.0201080982,
0.0650021955,
0.0067944075,
0.0211940333,
0.0154683059,
-0.0043615042,
0.0474848337,
-0.0327044018,
-0.0100809978,
0.0154736117,
0.0067375214,
0.0232986435,
0.023154268,
-0.0603396036,
-0.0146691101,
-0.0050837253,
0.0150478939,
-0.0282074139,
0.0415320061,
0.0078319293,
-0.0357894413,
-0.0150869302,
0.0410217866,
-0.0406116284,
-0.006256944,
-0.0511204451,
-0.022168817,
0.0728630573,
0.0200229716,
-0.0228204615,
0.028528573,
-0.0161731336,
-0.0518481471,
0.0300600473,
-0.0085947206,
-0.0181040969,
-0.0409227461,
0.0041021132,
0.0251023639,
0.0689381957,
-0.0020212017,
0.0007124068,
0.0121413441,
0.0630826354,
0.0123262824,
0.0170321055,
-0.0105429785,
0.0577624589,
-0.0031590366,
-0.0229474828,
-0.0237262212,
0.0019272681,
0.013932704,
0.080738619,
0.0224106982,
0.0082128728,
0.0239229817,
-0.0115855588,
-0.0079782503,
0.029422177,
0.0413041674,
-0.0086905994,
0.0035576159,
-0.0501922332,
-0.0251965653,
0.0016881904,
0.0319425724,
-0.0088359239,
0.0219223034,
0.0179010499,
0.0306769721,
-0.0275660958,
0.0211090241,
-0.0397443958,
0.0148562137,
-0.0732977018,
0.0369579308,
0.0228650309,
0.0106668789,
-0.0586725809,
-0.0636060685,
0.047689192,
0.0200278144,
-0.0171611495,
0.0629836619,
0.0146241635,
-0.0057486333,
0.0105522051,
-0.0105095422,
-0.0437854044,
-0.0292836297,
-0.0427510664,
0.0085857902,
0.0158479791,
0.0493975282,
0.000313549,
0.0109548531,
-0.0477370843,
0.0079027563,
0.0617391244,
-0.0167465191,
0.0516623035,
-0.0216294173,
0.0297466759,
0.014481293,
0.0366622806,
-0.0316290893,
0.009535999,
0.0004664754,
0.0359258503,
0.0772751495,
-0.1666409224,
-0.0429458357,
0.0325210318,
-0.0083890175,
-0.0160974208,
0.0134528251,
-0.0104349498,
0.0189694297,
-0.0004472693,
-0.0364456512,
0.0089044599,
0.0178769827,
0.001959584,
-0.0011943874,
-0.0399209484,
-0.0092816139,
-0.0193598345,
-0.0138174174,
0.0308030825,
-0.0284199715,
0.003944701,
0.0508481935,
0.0035004488,
-0.0035783052,
-0.0024391864,
0.0132177118,
-0.0055413237,
-0.0539817661,
0.0070596174,
-0.000098655,
-0.0126554491,
-0.0307335295,
0.0282309242,
0.0770949498,
0.0106382817,
0.0350591429,
0.010976295,
0.021595072,
-0.1234469339,
-0.0017787211,
-0.033184547,
0.0418075286,
-0.0681532249,
0.0050805802,
0.0342449583,
-0.0456986725,
0.0389196947,
-0.0174556933,
0.0142697822,
-0.0169561841,
-0.0049042529,
-0.0188272893,
0.0015979125,
-0.0274666436,
0.0088300165,
-0.0316036493,
-0.0264277942,
-0.0458237566,
0.0089584831,
0.0778435841,
0.0510931425,
0.0275536627,
0.0564877316,
0.0132545931,
-0.0720254034,
0.0203346815,
-0.0153653389,
0.0124869766,
0.0212868769,
-0.0058229323,
-0.0881154314,
0.0192717798,
0.0861371681,
0.0038125471,
0.0375858955,
-0.0332787372,
-0.0435646735,
0.0212380812,
-0.0116650574,
0.025570564,
-0.0646884739,
-0.0405790657,
-0.0478651039,
-0.0120360898,
-0.0525227636,
0.0537933744,
0.0560129657,
0.0625120774,
-0.0136154052,
-0.0336147286,
-0.0069161854,
-0.0436539501,
0.0108622797,
0.0566857196,
-0.0113870846,
0.0002006011,
0.0041941451,
-0.0011078065,
-0.0451739393,
-0.0333178602,
0.0050745085,
-0.1184282973,
0.0124922972,
-0.0155094406,
-0.0361176021,
-0.0554080643,
-0.0407902785,
-0.0347010195,
-0.0036159649,
-0.0225567017,
-0.0401540883,
-0.0424425676,
0.0322016999,
0.0625604466,
-0.0586747117,
-0.0499834679,
-0.0264117662,
-0.0259468593,
0.0106158433,
0.017291598,
0.0433110595,
-0.0371900722,
0.0414293148,
0.0156136956,
-0.036287684,
0.0263082515,
-0.0378731415,
0.0009998112,
-0.0145541122,
-0.0223692656,
-0.0609042533,
-0.0499801151,
-0.0038016497,
0.0384121686,
0.0091134785,
0.0657954738,
0.0041089449,
0.0369217694,
-0.0056115813,
0.0056724041,
0.0342643075,
-0.0139562804,
-0.0251538511,
-0.0091636013,
-0.0118218083,
-0.0345543548,
0.0071477867,
0.0091923634,
-0.0524678826,
-0.0006983612,
-0.0779549181,
-0.0104668867,
-0.0708997175,
-0.0752879977,
0.0395495854,
0.0260300953,
0.0032711579,
0.0364035591,
0.0628444925,
0.0095034409,
-0.0443489142,
-0.0603870079,
0.0122084785,
-0.0078110872,
-0.0065511893,
-0.0080191577,
0.0224210415,
0.0516104773,
0.0142441904,
-0.0098127993,
-0.0020434137,
-0.0515363589,
0.036980141,
-0.013085003,
0.0129086981,
-0.022987837,
-0.0003793757,
-0.0346292332,
-0.0332160406,
0.0595938042,
-0.0082115,
-0.0313054882,
0.0050899149,
0.034607809,
-0.0088364705,
-0.0082395095,
0.0376873612,
-0.0002484998,
-0.0220302697,
-0.0099257994,
-0.0199280065,
-0.0322440416,
0.0208621416,
0.0361241661,
0.0264682397,
-0.0617346205,
-0.0149120633,
-0.0289737992,
-0.0401198007,
0.0099909632,
-0.0106199421,
-0.0091139963,
-0.0053830366,
0.0137688601,
0.002116146,
-0.0190984868,
0.0364070125,
-0.0396601409,
-0.0282948446,
0.0130410343,
0.0864288807,
0.0019060327,
0.0747812539,
-0.0487689599,
0.0064624283,
0.028945636,
-0.0291706901,
-0.0013691883,
-0.0035252033,
-0.042199757,
0.0327173695,
-0.0071828808,
-0.0193365347,
-0.0197449829,
0.0370265171,
0.0475383401,
0.0156317335,
-0.0046441355,
0.0310110375,
0.042630285,
-0.0388169289,
0.0067813206,
-0.0174737312,
-0.0175158009,
0.0187747441,
0.0009988199,
-0.0122968918,
0.0040075406,
0.0135286385,
-0.0172350705,
-0.0432259738,
0.003077483,
0.0234029107,
0.0016128583,
-0.0114231268,
0.0313039497,
-0.0394245051,
0.0126321968,
-0.0001432049,
0.0301868673,
-0.0074344981,
-0.011585895,
-0.009001906,
-0.0539406873,
-0.0254565645,
-0.0310484543,
-0.0140267005,
0.021043608,
-0.005984399,
0.0144730303,
0.0582086705,
0.0760739818,
0.0402304456,
-0.0777237415,
0.0225930568,
-0.019542614,
0.0170356799,
0.0146001866,
-5.944517176e-33,
-0.0340609476,
-0.0110334279,
0.0085374564,
0.0127584543,
0.0000354949,
-0.0497988388,
0.0185138006,
0.0293742176,
-0.0288338866,
0.0051397537,
-0.0422032475,
0.0033038647,
0.0419280194,
-0.044283893,
0.0434051491,
-0.0102844229,
-0.0188163649,
0.0105634741,
0.0284178108,
-0.0475079529,
0.0609122589,
0.0221394524,
0.0981162786,
-0.1023255438,
0.0455452912,
0.0253039859,
-0.0186478198,
-0.0188781526,
0.0405734219,
0.0236910693,
-0.0198990218,
0.0264433678,
0.0218288805,
-0.0648015738,
-0.0119301407,
-0.004991401,
-0.0526628047,
-0.0423247144,
0.0352568701,
0.0358529426,
0.0408503227,
-0.001830344,
0.0409735106,
-0.007531622,
-0.0198771916,
0.0673172325,
0.0298513807,
-0.0309220161,
-0.0038496542,
-0.0048773834,
-0.07112737,
0.0491135344,
0.0011832473,
0.0400939323,
0.0824450478,
0.0146506792,
-0.0057435459,
-0.0102059068,
-0.0707299411,
0.0164693799,
-0.0029848074,
0.0081374189,
-0.0089996159,
-0.0157118663,
-0.0145241143,
0.0187849775,
-0.0126456926,
-0.0415710881,
0.0434121788,
0.0442101434,
0.0378955081,
0.0133873941,
0.0278847087,
0.0407760702,
0.0363146886,
-0.0681644753,
-0.0376358554,
0.0047318791,
0.0150251519,
-0.0135855032,
-0.0199852251,
-0.0126919849,
-0.0673271567,
-0.0503690951,
0.0352636427,
-0.0481337979,
0.0040304898,
-0.0201340262,
-0.0102218566,
-0.0061138496,
-0.053987015,
0.0539460965,
-0.0101267816,
-0.0399464369,
0.0070073619,
-0.0094272625,
-0.0124470331,
0.0452548563,
-0.0246134102,
-0.0029221612,
-0.0603328943,
-0.0173188671,
-0.0368026383,
0.0294813868,
0.01217297,
-0.0431354791,
0.0075894827,
-0.0208289102,
-0.0676020905,
0.0104371971,
0.0138664292,
0.0415408947,
0.0081816344,
0.0062863859,
-0.0108536072,
0.0045053647,
0.0232311003,
0.0093683312,
0.0644043013,
0.0202823188,
-0.0047012898,
-0.0094339028,
-0.0028932383,
-0.0423692763,
-0.0108251479,
0.0320313573,
-0.030450372,
0.0548104644,
0.0042279107,
0.0187794566,
-0.0132051781,
-0.0134683112,
2.661e-7,
0.0704591945,
0.0730421394,
0.0307940654,
-0.016442569,
-0.0261464994,
0.0125331273,
0.0346765555,
-0.0060414928,
-0.0021313836,
0.0261153989,
0.0052657947,
-0.0371537358,
0.0077204481,
0.0557645299,
-0.1129976735,
-0.007490187,
0.0084529612,
-0.0379134901,
-0.0612041242,
0.0216451585,
0.042504847,
0.059573859,
0.0092620105,
-0.0084155602,
-0.0576586574,
0.0113978665,
0.0142226852,
-0.0003838179,
-0.0279364381,
0.0156109892,
0.056719061,
0.0430226699,
0.0566499755,
-0.0123614436,
-0.0217976384,
0.02294969,
0.0172186978,
0.0299138855,
-0.0059881867,
0.0229441468,
0.0501018241,
-0.0177722722,
-0.0140188718,
-0.039164938,
0.0621354878,
0.0180181619,
-0.0171618834,
-0.016134996,
0.023103632,
0.0069397613,
-0.0010073598,
-0.0236865431,
-0.0468497202,
0.0433174856,
0.0111403717,
-0.0218626391,
-0.0502918325,
-0.0290765148,
0.0159602817,
-0.0148212491,
0.0143200904,
0.0266835764,
0.0278925151,
0.0324456058,
0.0261352565,
0.0135567682,
0.0294990912,
2.228333902e-34,
0.0141789196,
0.0375387445,
0.0091242203,
-0.0171528421,
0.0481278002,
0.0384091437,
-0.0492948331,
0.0357012786,
-0.0207085907,
-0.0147877662,
0.0312293507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15682v1 | Pre-training Transformers for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-03-28T02:10:37 | 2023-03-28T02:10:37 | Sanxing Chen, Hao Cheng, Xiaodong Liu, Jian Jiao, Yangfeng Ji, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Learning transferable representation of knowledge graphs (KGs) is challenging
due to the heterogeneous, multi-relational nature of graph structures. Inspired
by Transformer-based pretrained language models' success on learning
transferable representation for texts, we introduce a novel inductive KG
representation model (iHT) for KG completion by large-scale pre-training. iHT
consists of a entity encoder (e.g., BERT) and a neighbor-aware relational
scoring function both parameterized by Transformers. We first pre-train iHT on
a large KG dataset, Wikidata5M. Our approach achieves new state-of-the-art
results on matched evaluations, with a relative improvement of more than 25% in
mean reciprocal rank over previous SOTA models. When further fine-tuned on
smaller KGs with either entity and relational shifts, pre-trained iHT
representations are shown to be transferable, significantly improving the
performance on FB15K-237 and WN18RR. | [
0.0116635524,
0.0411959067,
0.0175317209,
0.0379432961,
0.0121456208,
0.008269445,
-0.0647550747,
0.0036051997,
0.0752940625,
-0.0455226637,
-0.0467395149,
0.0109073492,
-0.0214447733,
0.0059583527,
0.0220886506,
-0.02571976,
0.0071710297,
0.0112080388,
-0.0378502049,
-0.0326610133,
-0.0361494794,
0.0372542329,
-0.0013355245,
-0.0077471077,
-0.015601282,
0.0007928559,
0.0062314076,
0.0091114035,
0.0056666597,
-0.0232248064,
0.0057841046,
0.0350381248,
0.0252569597,
-0.0421981774,
0.0000020169,
-0.0168634392,
-0.0173182469,
0.0007962021,
-0.0329952538,
-0.0083300276,
-0.0058150999,
-0.0569312498,
0.0531596541,
0.0004992135,
-0.0249033105,
-0.0416980721,
0.0251287706,
0.0647580102,
0.0372932665,
0.0749153122,
-0.0200987067,
-0.0522384569,
0.0711870044,
-0.0243520476,
-0.0011164892,
-0.0480669178,
0.030552689,
0.0392680466,
-0.0395500772,
0.0064401031,
-0.0524547622,
0.0200790204,
0.0033387062,
0.0063555376,
0.0850353763,
0.0150546283,
-0.0249732062,
0.0388486274,
0.0399999246,
0.1187872738,
-0.006997725,
0.0016671567,
0.0020597852,
0.0021039068,
-0.0154770417,
0.0418810025,
-0.0106512969,
-0.0383913592,
0.0080459854,
0.0115618482,
-0.0365216397,
-0.009566946,
0.0553293973,
-0.029858226,
-0.0447351485,
0.0669993609,
0.0280804895,
-0.0269911438,
0.0324270092,
0.0502889007,
-0.0354242995,
-0.0217990875,
0.0145278042,
0.0044310093,
-0.0145802228,
0.0193464886,
-0.0284892563,
0.0159570333,
-0.0173987392,
-0.0007352002,
-0.0036743581,
0.024976125,
0.0076809074,
0.0418983512,
-0.067480281,
0.0324045829,
-0.0194653086,
0.0615938082,
-0.0487393588,
-0.0469299518,
-0.0640032291,
0.0181708783,
-0.032338921,
0.0418084897,
0.0107535738,
-0.0338235162,
-0.0306396317,
0.02783373,
-0.0158469044,
0.0186897013,
0.0702633485,
0.0007193206,
-0.0136801582,
-0.0235367324,
-0.0067121238,
0.062091738,
-0.0092704678,
0.0134026241,
-0.0347294919,
0.0431704409,
-0.0294479281,
-0.0042511388,
0.0453415588,
-0.0425520614,
0.0230005514,
0.0433634892,
0.0055133947,
-0.0269885454,
-0.0039700293,
0.0057631312,
0.0069431933,
-0.0332951359,
0.0345740952,
-0.0270611309,
0.0866949037,
0.0479331315,
0.0098311696,
-0.0323775522,
-0.0003088935,
-0.0228750389,
-0.0576029867,
0.0637618303,
-0.0348246582,
0.0115206139,
-0.0350418799,
-0.0189753547,
-0.0365299769,
0.0228711572,
0.0261423085,
0.0212135557,
0.0064276066,
-0.0309462454,
-0.0505527817,
0.0351685658,
0.0821003243,
0.012459158,
0.0452718027,
0.0133537408,
-0.0182086136,
0.0195724238,
0.0366206244,
0.045598723,
-0.0255209282,
0.0004112704,
0.0314179882,
0.013813654,
0.0255449675,
0.0397248901,
0.0384898707,
0.0173853822,
-0.0150173074,
0.0050798883,
-0.0510357395,
0.014846676,
-0.036762692,
0.0063887145,
0.0085587911,
0.008363218,
-0.0181495026,
0.0289683957,
0.0561856627,
-0.0412255526,
0.0131930839,
0.0087886676,
0.0885302797,
0.0516881384,
-0.0571282618,
0.1028023735,
0.0423845239,
-0.0345263742,
0.0448685996,
0.0213688686,
0.012742633,
0.0610900261,
0.0449604802,
-0.0255496968,
-0.0179747678,
-0.0001784689,
-0.0237447862,
-0.0114774536,
0.0199231952,
-0.027519092,
-0.0038994008,
-0.0403925404,
-0.0676345825,
0.0078196321,
-0.005001531,
0.0226035081,
0.0166055523,
0.0313898362,
0.0407777205,
-0.0928638503,
0.0020158596,
0.0109608201,
-0.023926504,
0.0155525096,
-0.0140429754,
0.0166175179,
0.0081164418,
0.0181837957,
0.0056270659,
-0.0047630775,
0.0293832663,
-0.0186719168,
-0.0322013982,
-0.0206723865,
-0.0280556623,
-0.0586435795,
0.0288675763,
-0.0244486686,
-0.0070166858,
0.0309791621,
-0.0385767743,
-0.031527061,
0.0103144962,
-0.011278999,
0.0626095906,
0.0179644264,
-0.0035918907,
0.025252087,
0.0018375652,
0.0049910974,
0.0746599212,
0.0037924359,
0.0016897515,
-0.0268905889,
-0.0519333743,
0.0093834205,
0.0181824677,
-0.0346852392,
-0.018802397,
0.0008928172,
0.0019662683,
0.006442578,
-0.0327539779,
-0.0529628955,
-0.0093469592,
-0.100350298,
-0.0008977224,
0.0007760475,
0.012204634,
-0.0090073869,
0.0212268457,
0.0459005758,
-0.000763163,
-0.0220353268,
0.0179108437,
-0.0220205337,
0.0082094949,
0.0077656815,
-0.014080842,
0.0120003903,
0.0010748002,
-0.0561582781,
-0.0193875153,
0.075709939,
-0.0087732505,
0.0054978328,
-0.0170207303,
0.0454904027,
-0.026368672,
0.0027748649,
-0.0227244161,
0.0033784197,
-0.0218886919,
-0.0149277309,
0.0311215241,
0.0074153128,
-0.0279639214,
0.0120915072,
-0.0000965421,
0.0040559685,
-0.0527804568,
-0.0090958048,
-0.0393658578,
-0.0074752895,
-0.0420343913,
-0.0028006285,
-0.0188766643,
0.0102271223,
-0.0124830855,
-0.0250778459,
-0.0849002227,
-0.0353200026,
0.0025387972,
0.0004073996,
-0.0376847014,
-0.0016225406,
0.0331908539,
-0.0177411586,
-0.0203357358,
0.0205951333,
0.0640443116,
-0.0171582736,
0.0123820379,
0.0251365826,
0.0354691632,
-0.0252136402,
0.0620599799,
0.0278199743,
0.0004483701,
-0.0309156142,
-0.0283182971,
-0.0352234542,
0.0309103839,
0.027187651,
-0.0256725419,
0.0275715273,
0.0429162122,
0.0367195383,
0.0014948297,
-0.0080715008,
-0.0159865096,
-0.0157653615,
0.0022103761,
0.0221071094,
0.0430999734,
-0.0038281919,
-0.004074092,
0.0040327711,
-0.0005477896,
-0.0028341622,
0.0170558561,
0.0010692809,
-0.0410390571,
0.0422154702,
0.0328446068,
-0.0095020896,
0.0051757977,
0.0003719623,
-0.0222526696,
0.0401951261,
0.0163414758,
-0.0269435104,
-0.0175848883,
0.0228350144,
0.0178580917,
-0.0480470918,
-0.039881628,
-0.0308148507,
0.04722194,
-0.0028217237,
0.0154529605,
0.0966630802,
-0.0061065964,
-0.0259293895,
0.0037319635,
0.0078911278,
0.0075665289,
0.0032441136,
0.0327904746,
-0.1202270314,
-0.0032788583,
-0.0235215537,
0.0149087179,
0.0650208294,
-0.0881049708,
0.0158328637,
-0.1081824452,
-0.0159769133,
0.0234684851,
0.0202028509,
-0.0624745078,
-0.0430130474,
-0.0117193591,
-0.0377414934,
-0.0245447792,
-0.02657363,
-0.0012470644,
0.0144420313,
0.0006228681,
-0.0058010197,
-0.0409839079,
0.0537223667,
-0.0489024408,
0.0317375064,
0.0091877757,
0.0311566982,
-0.0137904547,
-0.0308424477,
-0.0505876429,
0.0055577666,
-0.0325505845,
0.0268963594,
0.0741834268,
-0.0439336821,
-0.0210352466,
-0.0144760255,
-0.0302609168,
-0.0594387352,
-0.0209821146,
-0.0041704909,
0.1162775755,
0.0245771203,
-0.0438253433,
0.0191589613,
-0.035692919,
0.002601878,
0.0574183464,
0.0023143296,
0.0142740207,
0.0100697745,
-0.0055437996,
0.0606289208,
-0.0314389393,
-0.0150077818,
0.029616015,
-0.0463626906,
0.0124494145,
-0.0713512525,
-0.0473777242,
0.0562100336,
-0.0180652533,
0.0095203537,
-0.0225646067,
0.0593998134,
-0.0299434122,
-0.0698822513,
0.0337722003,
-0.0452987477,
-0.0090381643,
-0.0067870426,
-0.028298568,
0.0406411663,
-0.0042615072,
-0.0234849527,
-0.059507519,
-0.0042440249,
-0.0194896124,
-0.0357518867,
0.0611555651,
0.0014149101,
0.0579945222,
-0.0539176911,
-0.0196092427,
0.0471944213,
0.0299735945,
-0.0677120313,
-0.0165907405,
0.0490626916,
-0.0533646159,
-0.0199405178,
0.0498198792,
-0.073298797,
0.0309522338,
0.0031715224,
0.0821688175,
-0.016616337,
-0.0487449802,
0.0114669548,
0.0486212447,
0.0419346988,
0.0197504256,
0.0207229834,
-0.0342147201,
-0.0017772423,
-0.0277689528,
-0.0058418466,
-0.068096444,
-0.0168801062,
0.0510129184,
0.0094222249,
-0.004779248,
-0.0201089624,
-0.0035766123,
0.0327558443,
-0.0417690165,
-0.0283176824,
0.0065008737,
-0.0208424926,
0.05570326,
0.0120415306,
-0.0342605002,
-0.017446043,
0.0591412447,
-0.010591954,
-0.03420588,
0.0051045311,
0.0083394991,
0.0018287149,
-0.0332810134,
0.0153384171,
-0.0237755943,
-0.0156254265,
-0.0468785353,
0.0118286312,
0.0444883332,
0.0012453571,
0.0621336214,
0.0092987549,
-0.0264357105,
-0.0099510858,
0.0575484186,
-0.0141566889,
-0.0157096498,
0.0146734193,
0.0154484622,
-0.0057590189,
0.0320025869,
0.0644030273,
-0.0159442518,
0.0758822337,
-0.0089421226,
-0.0346213765,
-0.0420271866,
-0.0508104712,
0.0160263591,
-0.001876941,
-0.005973523,
0.0320251584,
0.0113386186,
-0.0977819711,
0.0361525565,
-0.0628847852,
-0.0625365004,
0.0156250391,
0.0141323386,
0.0157680642,
0.0206918176,
-0.0263009463,
-0.0261283983,
0.0077361972,
-0.0081687216,
-0.0090123266,
0.0224328022,
-6.454355892e-33,
-0.0417613871,
-0.0005573231,
0.0115105351,
-0.0124662369,
-0.0582193546,
-0.0013868951,
-0.0113915186,
-0.0293418299,
-0.0242325086,
0.0371006131,
-0.0290447213,
0.0066190152,
-0.0080627548,
0.0399344377,
-0.0034635062,
-0.0377826057,
0.036233481,
0.0316985361,
0.0020004571,
0.0317624398,
0.0160606094,
0.0513294041,
0.0875576138,
-0.0974798203,
0.0031634208,
-0.011543314,
0.0185547136,
-0.0253712181,
0.0275071766,
0.0308485031,
-0.012740436,
0.0520978868,
0.0226461757,
-0.0100108106,
0.0015324343,
-0.0024674521,
-0.1126431972,
-0.0345291644,
-0.0101931738,
0.0195327811,
-0.0130371442,
-0.0124554895,
0.0461566411,
0.00298408,
0.0621967204,
-0.076829657,
0.0235835221,
-0.0158447009,
-0.0412641019,
-0.0462573096,
-0.0303097647,
0.0086077657,
0.0187102351,
-0.0062949769,
-0.0005084798,
0.0216026586,
0.0311438367,
-0.0127271554,
-0.0978963077,
-0.0074166995,
-0.0125607997,
0.0036083462,
0.0026665479,
-0.0201024357,
0.0064512682,
0.0107333539,
-0.0141335903,
-0.0009291586,
-0.0193219017,
-0.0091833156,
-0.0140912747,
0.0642108098,
0.0003096374,
0.0099182082,
-0.0334704742,
-0.038164258,
-0.070252642,
0.0100227753,
-0.0311563462,
0.0192834772,
-0.0306370351,
0.0152102681,
-0.015062103,
-0.0290771481,
-0.0395040438,
-0.0284563415,
-0.013323158,
-0.0626602024,
0.0078094015,
-0.0167043824,
-0.0181480385,
0.0508602969,
0.0046022544,
-0.0693778396,
-0.0267928988,
0.0541220084,
-0.0048474181,
0.0082351007,
-0.0196661986,
0.0338189565,
-0.0366515368,
-0.0387689881,
0.0297927875,
-0.0578311943,
0.0078806616,
0.035320688,
0.0474779494,
0.033746928,
-0.0170133431,
-0.0302438773,
-0.025532715,
-0.0521165878,
-0.0155559899,
0.0207114965,
0.0362550914,
0.0693318099,
0.0056273891,
0.0385804698,
0.0408191569,
0.0426690839,
-0.0019887656,
0.0217076335,
0.0698065236,
0.0061446815,
-0.0078664878,
-0.0170685928,
-0.0380147547,
0.0045414702,
0.0029208174,
-0.0419597961,
-0.0217170324,
-0.0282904785,
2.828e-7,
0.0736242235,
0.0266910885,
0.0270235986,
0.0137280729,
-0.0170044061,
0.0042507173,
0.0157776382,
0.09215983,
0.0369642861,
0.0034504575,
0.0603956021,
0.0014857237,
-0.0121420426,
0.0025003317,
-0.0727563724,
-0.0561274923,
-0.0540079363,
-0.0300983898,
-0.0231817234,
-0.0149349784,
0.0575512946,
0.0511733405,
0.0574355908,
0.0158539992,
-0.0039047485,
-0.026409762,
0.1073614433,
-0.0275584683,
-0.0078910654,
0.0202415772,
0.0022877406,
0.0148029746,
-0.0181456227,
0.0768126771,
-0.0281858686,
0.0331585705,
0.0767967403,
0.0436791293,
-0.0096895974,
-0.0173007883,
-0.0230769403,
-0.0244180001,
0.0237916894,
-0.0216295961,
0.0798083991,
-0.1004085392,
-0.0172248874,
0.0752390623,
-0.1072003767,
-0.0179481786,
-0.0240300614,
0.0095010977,
0.0274111591,
0.0154020814,
0.0534316227,
0.0298422072,
-0.0173184015,
-0.0590255521,
0.04815685,
0.0215210728,
-0.0062250546,
-0.0388989598,
0.0150470324,
-0.0622228011,
0.0078316089,
-0.0379978865,
0.0525822118,
2.386184885e-34,
0.0096996687,
0.0182032268,
0.0268216319,
-0.007886136,
0.0273774248,
-0.0608150065,
0.0146912681,
-0.0045944694,
0.0240568705,
-0.1061533317,
0.0012998075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15662v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15662v3 | ChatGPT4PCG Competition: Character-like Level Generation for Science Birds | 2023-03-28T01:07:38 | 2024-03-21T01:42:43 | Pittawat Taveekitworachai, Febri Abdullah, Mury F. Dewantoro, Ruck Thawonmas, Julian Togelius, Jochen Renz | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.8 | This paper presents the first ChatGPT4PCG Competition at the 2023 IEEE
Conference on Games. The objective of this competition is for participants to
create effective prompts for ChatGPT--enabling it to generate Science Birds
levels with high stability and character-like qualities--fully using their
creativity as well as prompt engineering skills. ChatGPT is a conversational
agent developed by OpenAI. Science Birds is selected as the competition
platform because designing an Angry Birds-like level is not a trivial task due
to the in-game gravity; the quality of the levels is determined by their
stability. To lower the entry barrier to the competition, we limit the task to
the generation of capitalized English alphabetical characters. We also allow
only a single prompt to be used for generating all the characters. Here, the
quality of the generated levels is determined by their stability and similarity
to the given characters. A sample prompt is provided to participants for their
reference. An experiment is conducted to determine the effectiveness of several
modified versions of this sample prompt on level stability and similarity by
testing them on several characters. To the best of our knowledge, we believe
that ChatGPT4PCG is the first competition of its kind and hope to inspire
enthusiasm for prompt engineering in procedural content generation. | [
0.028370481,
0.016477434,
-0.0265580323,
0.0261054169,
-0.0026610743,
-0.0265722908,
0.0129463198,
0.0095452853,
-0.0266340543,
0.0634232834,
-0.0166119989,
-0.0092466976,
0.0019831732,
0.0590721183,
-0.0192031693,
-0.0924452096,
0.015290264,
-0.0579282269,
0.0382252708,
-0.0208325498,
-0.0380353443,
-0.0203867704,
-0.0273941383,
0.0374279954,
-0.0099030128,
-0.0599643886,
-0.0549968779,
0.0103696762,
0.0533148535,
-0.061325822,
-0.0001685036,
0.0044543981,
0.0248484518,
0.0420049652,
0.0000020401,
-0.0576943941,
-0.011474588,
0.0042344057,
0.0065875952,
-0.0042908788,
0.0564427562,
0.0563257262,
-0.0526687428,
-0.0198093597,
0.0113552483,
0.0240653213,
0.0643125325,
-0.0155820586,
0.0869779512,
0.0095061995,
-0.0037420697,
-0.0637095422,
0.0503748618,
0.0289154928,
0.0553136617,
-0.0031344516,
-0.0463704206,
0.0565107428,
0.0933940709,
0.0334792659,
-0.0047790543,
-0.0052523161,
0.0406856053,
-0.0177667737,
-0.0150544113,
0.0624401495,
0.0308017619,
-0.021868987,
-0.0122773089,
0.040528845,
-0.0000975931,
-0.0044532791,
-0.0214230269,
-0.0050822827,
0.0390620753,
-0.0063093342,
-0.0025112946,
0.0280910451,
-0.035379339,
-0.0134955822,
0.0273612421,
0.0371805206,
-0.0465643518,
-0.0348177627,
0.0047258544,
0.0188619532,
0.0387751944,
-0.0335734971,
-0.0413750969,
-0.0332338288,
0.0406007841,
-0.0480131507,
-0.00345596,
0.0258791354,
-0.0497710221,
-0.0094495779,
-0.0406401753,
-0.0000479531,
0.0196004268,
-0.0262765586,
0.0273904875,
0.0201963298,
0.0300820787,
0.0112980595,
-0.0168197099,
0.0238022059,
0.0283509884,
-0.0067967954,
0.0078957789,
0.0305213779,
-0.0116851972,
-0.013275113,
-0.0738882124,
0.0203733519,
-0.0502901301,
0.0041582761,
0.0009074546,
0.0010558621,
-0.0048763724,
0.0066022323,
-0.0271377284,
0.0083715357,
-0.0469137244,
0.0309095159,
0.0111657484,
-0.0375402048,
-0.0646709129,
-0.0071503562,
0.0487848558,
-0.0412283726,
0.007732491,
-0.0203662831,
0.0095332228,
0.0518683977,
0.0083071804,
0.0595392175,
-0.0033921634,
0.0203262642,
0.0243814643,
-0.0289800074,
0.0074113198,
-0.0578365102,
-0.0346836895,
-0.0234503169,
-0.0134924557,
-0.0429748669,
0.0021316058,
0.0261070877,
0.0420105755,
0.0193812922,
0.027610613,
0.0750392675,
-0.0687739328,
0.0215352941,
0.0031788419,
0.0161255226,
-0.0394726358,
-0.0090007931,
0.0337620527,
0.0491999947,
-0.0076390188,
-0.0707017109,
0.0562587976,
-0.0108253416,
-0.0136176422,
-0.0015340339,
0.0292613339,
-0.0548378341,
0.0363354608,
0.087848179,
-0.0167420506,
0.0241196323,
-0.0321250223,
0.0518764481,
0.0540399738,
0.0237092022,
0.0047244509,
0.0231903438,
0.0672839209,
-0.0150943603,
0.019753499,
0.0083988262,
0.0339246839,
0.0177979898,
-0.025440501,
-0.0101373475,
-0.0809886828,
0.0320289284,
-0.0025363015,
-0.0449248888,
0.0247263908,
0.0296871755,
0.0222779475,
-0.0333553329,
-0.0032418445,
0.0146737788,
-0.0388927311,
-0.0380865633,
0.0078439442,
-0.101378724,
-0.0127431927,
0.0041873273,
0.0945848078,
0.0847784355,
0.0166785177,
-0.0166593026,
-0.0499631278,
0.0225393251,
0.0012800201,
0.0940421149,
0.0391788781,
-0.0137731144,
0.0114714187,
-0.0181391463,
-0.0117291585,
-0.0209050365,
0.0058233025,
0.0577664264,
-0.0171744078,
0.0309119001,
-0.0139997266,
0.0158873815,
-0.0196114555,
0.0476835892,
-0.0350149125,
-0.0038888454,
-0.0082054567,
-0.0053630779,
0.0018897714,
0.0233908743,
-0.0441521183,
0.0079966988,
0.0147579322,
-0.0093720257,
0.0016523167,
0.0183671378,
0.0040044771,
-0.0009448543,
0.0295561161,
-0.0424516797,
-0.0171314888,
0.0047578062,
0.0510247536,
-0.0034102553,
0.0177291688,
-0.0018437506,
0.0565122627,
0.0041187555,
0.0279447902,
-0.0148763461,
-0.0046188156,
-0.0240928009,
0.0215383768,
0.0369733982,
-0.0099798907,
0.0315609872,
0.0486814305,
0.025631601,
-0.0854117274,
0.025311999,
0.0702941716,
-0.0116565041,
-0.0259387325,
0.0031982614,
0.0401123166,
-0.0669262335,
-0.0372309871,
-0.0623525791,
-0.0726237819,
0.020824967,
-0.0589793995,
-0.0080090389,
-0.0211218204,
-0.0265643001,
0.0509473048,
-0.0352628157,
0.0635184944,
0.0302933808,
-0.0596734844,
0.0567768998,
-0.0266096201,
-0.0620811917,
-0.0379322208,
0.0129690198,
-0.0230179764,
-0.0009453842,
0.0798333138,
-0.0134237334,
-0.0589418374,
0.0399611518,
-0.0630240142,
0.0020337659,
0.0053334381,
-0.0428378545,
0.0525432713,
-0.0086219469,
0.0350615717,
0.0193412583,
0.0258905105,
0.0006040256,
0.0243894495,
-0.0552809015,
-0.0303025991,
0.0398798585,
0.0141905108,
-0.0201509614,
0.0391815826,
-0.0136459982,
0.0719200522,
0.0419360772,
-0.040977478,
0.0019990474,
-0.0683069304,
0.0712717101,
0.027564289,
-0.0338534713,
0.0044205515,
0.0043591559,
-0.0235143788,
-0.0086469492,
-0.0489257574,
-0.0034684381,
0.0477756113,
-0.0610059164,
-0.0106135132,
-0.024384737,
0.0487266295,
-0.0098854648,
0.1053708047,
-0.023059845,
0.0268260892,
0.0513173603,
0.0198203139,
0.0211491436,
0.0202676412,
0.0156055735,
-0.0175785907,
-0.081733264,
-0.0565152913,
-0.0128880059,
-0.009461767,
-0.0523939207,
-0.0422249101,
0.0043461258,
-0.0128292842,
0.0198992882,
0.0353467278,
-0.0394227467,
-0.0183437057,
0.0034724909,
0.0062401779,
-0.0001475713,
-0.0175511893,
0.0009937121,
-0.0117600011,
0.0098898718,
0.0594505779,
0.0825020298,
0.0201000664,
-0.0266943853,
0.0575622991,
0.017206233,
-0.0400535762,
-0.0111385621,
0.0031779329,
0.0221696123,
0.0066292966,
0.0108630871,
0.0053517735,
0.0335693918,
0.0497226715,
-0.0320980363,
-0.0199694745,
0.0448774882,
0.0076283733,
0.0233681481,
0.0175482482,
-0.0396197364,
0.0234426167,
-0.0163984373,
0.0092487633,
-0.0088461228,
0.0223961193,
-0.004699619,
-0.000332479,
0.0149602117,
-0.0162125807,
0.0071619456,
-0.0779531077,
0.0666903332,
0.0234518852,
-0.0936010554,
-0.0288420338,
0.0141103733,
-0.0217211265,
0.0462107472,
-0.019199634,
0.039893765,
0.0418112315,
0.0033573939,
-0.0008000479,
-0.0359817818,
-0.0146121783,
-0.012932078,
-0.040431004,
0.0915584639,
0.0331974588,
0.0356620066,
-0.0160536021,
-0.0695241168,
-0.0089973742,
0.0488283746,
0.0566558465,
-0.0052596601,
-0.0318976454,
0.0168996956,
-0.00392192,
-0.0187644064,
-0.0166961532,
-0.0301833544,
-0.0351361185,
0.0246986598,
0.0274748076,
0.0021011517,
-0.0251839478,
-0.0658052415,
0.0096861571,
0.001538062,
0.0527653806,
0.0327067152,
-0.0360993445,
-0.0379088931,
-0.0440631285,
0.0447818302,
-0.081191808,
0.0006589713,
-0.0291112438,
0.004233405,
-0.0298416466,
-0.082979843,
-0.0233262423,
0.0577020496,
0.0518722497,
-0.0261608344,
-0.012664265,
-0.0583359301,
0.0299300142,
0.0219637398,
-0.0422629006,
-0.0322905928,
0.0008047184,
-0.0355044939,
-0.0451706946,
-0.0164994281,
-0.0500247292,
-0.0035549281,
0.0188272223,
0.0312983356,
-0.0286754519,
0.0476507917,
0.0752691254,
0.018330548,
-0.05443196,
0.0067655784,
0.0027473078,
0.0322953463,
-0.0318001695,
0.0374810994,
0.024282977,
-0.0258295853,
0.0034936522,
0.0173074305,
-0.0302192625,
-0.0160538498,
0.0036754264,
-0.0031106004,
0.0432904214,
0.0266424585,
-0.0264119841,
0.032763388,
0.0555647984,
-0.0000771723,
-0.0359699987,
-0.0757815316,
-0.015098338,
0.006151062,
-0.0413921773,
-0.0245963279,
-0.0229219813,
-0.0061869351,
-0.0255593061,
-0.0003313308,
0.0408341773,
-0.0356889106,
-0.0318618193,
0.0178271271,
0.0125395227,
0.0350903012,
0.0187461507,
0.0246245265,
-0.0054496978,
0.0112596825,
-0.021471547,
0.0429287925,
-0.0572462156,
0.0399513021,
0.0212112535,
-0.0075625358,
0.0137456143,
-0.0110212741,
-0.0138408756,
0.0460863113,
-0.0257576779,
-0.0464238971,
0.0024263752,
0.0255264733,
0.0845617205,
0.0847759917,
-0.0235529877,
-0.0260338336,
-0.0086345412,
-0.0055988035,
-0.0654612929,
0.0476151966,
-0.0836204365,
-0.0105322739,
0.0109725986,
-0.0097578522,
-0.0736271963,
0.0524274148,
-0.0493053086,
0.023013968,
-0.0167945083,
0.0331213102,
-0.0347537361,
0.0499389619,
-0.0150591815,
0.0303517208,
0.0147745963,
-0.0153147494,
-0.0490120091,
-0.0204353482,
0.0091261556,
0.0850018561,
-0.0118647004,
0.0179127771,
0.0293268561,
0.0138762984,
-0.0108429585,
-0.0036043148,
0.0120465588,
0.0014778303,
-0.0424862728,
-0.0236164387,
-0.0485406034,
-5.361713689e-33,
-0.0418957435,
0.0233048722,
-0.0106940344,
0.0518014021,
-0.0342286006,
0.0041688331,
-0.0472218469,
0.0377976075,
-0.0034772817,
-0.0005704231,
-0.0142412661,
-0.0421211869,
-0.0251082368,
-0.0276222602,
0.0332901813,
-0.0139631648,
0.0602070875,
0.0383620411,
-0.0467086397,
-0.0125439037,
-0.0197272748,
0.0213058088,
0.0165789854,
-0.0495971628,
0.0203234479,
-0.0314689428,
-0.0273533948,
-0.0362042598,
-0.021770671,
0.000551648,
-0.0119020799,
0.0148000056,
-0.0067983549,
-0.0099952631,
0.0067235497,
-0.0029139586,
-0.033278238,
-0.0754155368,
-0.0407054797,
-0.0462533273,
-0.0291087236,
-0.0998742655,
-0.0141359717,
-0.0045737531,
-0.0512403995,
-0.0335742198,
0.0156652797,
-0.006451739,
0.0233219489,
-0.0224687718,
-0.0689092055,
0.0030015395,
-0.0073916665,
-0.0467923172,
-0.0341248661,
-0.0225118268,
-0.015310022,
-0.0134427017,
0.0659795254,
0.0852425247,
0.039205797,
-0.039935369,
-0.0042185714,
0.0193072483,
0.0361080766,
0.0681448579,
0.0735957772,
0.0610033087,
-0.065687865,
-0.000179522,
0.0148424413,
0.0396560803,
0.0842569992,
0.0452293456,
0.0584467128,
-0.013367434,
-0.0161242783,
0.0700890794,
0.053082265,
0.0230401866,
-0.0333937854,
0.0342713073,
-0.0468742289,
-0.0139216827,
0.0078566857,
-0.0035170191,
0.0023126823,
-0.0537641682,
0.0010456436,
-0.0264637843,
-0.0203105435,
-0.0603195876,
0.0179785043,
-0.0047290502,
0.0482976586,
-0.0261011962,
0.025960708,
0.0279654693,
-0.0156187201,
-0.0139566325,
0.0084897093,
-0.0599653907,
0.0458121039,
-0.0068726516,
0.0473476164,
0.0493715033,
-0.0520245545,
0.0421186984,
0.0034843148,
0.021271605,
0.0378079563,
-0.0137906345,
0.0358964056,
0.0078369053,
0.0185183492,
-0.0717449188,
-0.0016701827,
-0.0454070978,
0.0172959361,
0.0399213172,
-0.0580565035,
0.0217168257,
-0.0399486199,
0.0032194643,
0.0070479279,
0.0022305893,
-0.0404118374,
-0.0134459594,
-0.0228133146,
-0.0329323933,
-0.0365974046,
-0.0097350758,
2.9e-7,
-0.0504481122,
0.0168507528,
0.0290890094,
0.0064916424,
0.0087980283,
-0.0109765846,
-0.0135356653,
-0.0084542055,
0.0053184875,
-0.0072474466,
0.012054326,
-0.0184145495,
0.0119507639,
0.0350041911,
-0.0692024082,
-0.0111718616,
-0.0426272973,
0.0238441937,
-0.0281603187,
0.0129371546,
0.0853611678,
0.0067624925,
-0.0144954007,
-0.0123134498,
0.0483549833,
0.0100643886,
-0.0059905695,
-0.0466903858,
0.0445066243,
-0.0000017813,
-0.0518320575,
-0.0236261692,
-0.0140092336,
-0.0229918454,
0.0075887023,
0.0091238068,
0.0383284613,
-0.002156629,
-0.0342113413,
0.0452189706,
0.0345308073,
0.0407361463,
0.0198973082,
-0.0473943613,
0.0228439104,
0.0221779943,
0.0167944767,
0.0208445732,
-0.0114270756,
-0.0108809955,
-0.0156263243,
-0.0390261002,
-0.0546107106,
-0.0298111551,
-0.0273904223,
0.0442525074,
0.029822655,
-0.0329947062,
0.0258842427,
-0.031063091,
-0.0569716766,
-0.0665704235,
-0.0195202772,
-0.0367786363,
0.0230283719,
-0.0128454426,
0.0213096123,
2.503845671e-34,
0.0003225675,
-0.0139787933,
0.0468270667,
-0.0300543793,
-0.0005090617,
0.0316645838,
0.076337561,
0.0123459063,
0.0571040884,
-0.0102284541,
-0.0339852385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15655v1 | Joint embedding in Hierarchical distance and semantic representation learning for link prediction | 2023-03-28T00:42:29 | 2023-03-28T00:42:29 | Jin Liu, Jianye Chen, Chongfeng Fan, Fengyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The link prediction task aims to predict missing entities or relations in the
knowledge graph and is essential for the downstream application. Existing
well-known models deal with this task by mainly focusing on representing
knowledge graph triplets in the distance space or semantic space. However, they
can not fully capture the information of head and tail entities, nor even make
good use of hierarchical level information. Thus, in this paper, we propose a
novel knowledge graph embedding model for the link prediction task, namely,
HIE, which models each triplet (\textit{h}, \textit{r}, \textit{t}) into
distance measurement space and semantic measurement space, simultaneously.
Moreover, HIE is introduced into hierarchical-aware space to leverage rich
hierarchical information of entities and relations for better representation
learning. Specifically, we apply distance transformation operation on the head
entity in distance space to obtain the tail entity instead of translation-based
or rotation-based approaches. Experimental results of HIE on four real-world
datasets show that HIE outperforms several existing state-of-the-art knowledge
graph embedding methods on the link prediction task and deals with complex
relations accurately. | [
0.0221182611,
-0.0222935323,
-0.018632615,
0.0343409069,
0.0178626832,
0.0145014795,
-0.0451530702,
0.0092415493,
0.0966755524,
-0.0338296555,
0.0031150479,
0.006452797,
-0.0172258522,
-0.0274557732,
0.0394254364,
-0.0588721707,
0.0185052864,
0.0414619856,
-0.0333543234,
-0.0208546985,
-0.0345705263,
0.0327970497,
0.0119843176,
0.0058225128,
-0.0194595475,
-0.0107478341,
-0.0231041573,
0.003572633,
0.0536154881,
-0.0343271755,
0.0094434377,
0.020429289,
0.0447833724,
-0.0006810101,
0.0000019368,
0.0045289034,
-0.0015988013,
-0.013600802,
-0.0014846337,
-0.0248043574,
-0.0315546095,
-0.0373251252,
0.0454583243,
0.0154155632,
-0.0242473874,
-0.0107825845,
0.001494837,
0.0465955436,
-0.0071741636,
0.0469520018,
-0.0117139071,
-0.0387115069,
0.0460426249,
-0.0342022143,
0.0249178633,
0.0011754154,
0.018059602,
0.0400964022,
-0.0697081238,
0.0552967042,
-0.0371531136,
0.0224409532,
0.023551058,
0.0248362515,
0.0415819064,
0.0324311629,
0.0078570498,
0.018522935,
0.0190895759,
0.1061229706,
-0.0463731848,
0.0198431332,
0.0084583331,
0.011886877,
0.0018382695,
0.0041716327,
-0.0064107534,
-0.0496653989,
0.0144126834,
-0.0133964624,
-0.0302525125,
0.0105950041,
0.0460505411,
-0.0408091843,
-0.0073459339,
0.0188201498,
0.0069370847,
-0.0283176973,
-0.014820545,
0.0090271728,
0.0171791166,
0.0164127946,
0.0139476554,
0.0023714944,
0.0126166446,
0.0265782792,
0.0152744837,
0.0299191941,
0.0025442184,
-0.0553520732,
-0.0515063331,
0.0223784037,
0.0259368829,
0.0450746454,
-0.0800680816,
-0.0086592836,
-0.0188448709,
-0.0054695439,
-0.0140941627,
-0.0099328198,
-0.0486380048,
-0.0123634906,
-0.0025361525,
0.0311169866,
0.000943839,
-0.0198475625,
-0.0467871428,
0.0346356183,
-0.0417038053,
0.0562828667,
0.0117727481,
0.0307223778,
-0.0054716244,
-0.0042157155,
-0.0346151553,
0.0509118363,
-0.0427843928,
0.0138547337,
-0.0428622365,
0.0499251075,
0.0048027304,
0.0103009129,
-0.001553271,
-0.0175791271,
-0.0125289243,
0.1119119227,
0.0465833992,
-0.0000833169,
-0.0180194899,
-0.0351476334,
0.0427331999,
-0.0402966179,
0.0700748414,
-0.0288559161,
0.0563565046,
0.0013652721,
-0.0145667475,
-0.0090630874,
0.0114586251,
-0.0195076521,
-0.0674352646,
0.0506812446,
-0.0288072675,
-0.0305846259,
-0.0026704229,
0.0179065708,
-0.0253316872,
0.0330848955,
0.005742182,
0.0082808603,
0.0390298478,
0.0162550099,
-0.0768582299,
0.0038915498,
0.037212152,
-0.0136353513,
0.0028096174,
0.0117379343,
-0.0226783548,
0.045005165,
0.0202602744,
-0.0047961348,
-0.0239103809,
-0.002527867,
-0.019693125,
0.022296356,
0.0344849601,
-0.0115066525,
0.0704140216,
-0.0246695802,
-0.0630181879,
0.011064373,
-0.0485735424,
0.0321980156,
-0.0159157496,
-0.0044273096,
-0.0025731039,
0.0262027327,
-0.023441473,
0.0004492876,
0.0371310301,
-0.038611114,
-0.0126552638,
-0.0132714761,
0.0481428355,
-0.0190677661,
-0.0318836793,
0.0570019707,
0.0612265393,
-0.001927425,
0.0356938988,
0.0673526451,
-0.0145310313,
0.0655925646,
0.0226920862,
-0.0423877724,
-0.0134979319,
-0.013621958,
-0.0237532184,
-0.0159160588,
0.0210219678,
-0.0373721719,
-0.0119347731,
-0.0332363509,
-0.0828626081,
0.0615938567,
0.0048996508,
-0.014501377,
0.0185962636,
0.0450662188,
0.0905360132,
-0.080597505,
0.0679832622,
0.0117716342,
-0.0300293081,
0.0610933341,
-0.0132831503,
0.0806476623,
-0.0196582507,
0.0492581017,
0.0402952172,
-0.0185131151,
0.0627477616,
-0.0153758544,
-0.0499853566,
-0.0394877903,
-0.004744587,
-0.0833940357,
0.0573557913,
-0.0510625951,
0.0246967115,
-0.0026788588,
-0.0122673959,
-0.0170848444,
0.0258517172,
0.0185994133,
0.0609154254,
-0.0012360144,
-0.0069870823,
0.0268771295,
-0.0255572125,
-0.0249397308,
0.0876624286,
-0.0316919759,
0.0405926853,
-0.0393718109,
-0.031130055,
0.0190051422,
0.0108326981,
-0.0295339581,
0.0016632999,
0.0241765007,
-0.0057492829,
0.0171122085,
-0.0269302074,
-0.0705313981,
-0.0111366548,
-0.0247814842,
0.0043389355,
0.0156684332,
0.0006031282,
-0.0143223936,
-0.0162768103,
0.0380979963,
-0.0367650948,
-0.0428057089,
0.0499497764,
-0.0615096986,
-0.0022553704,
0.0301479232,
-0.0189503189,
-0.0359804034,
0.0120685287,
-0.0414427444,
-0.0609404631,
0.0452468507,
-0.0266329702,
-0.0252838824,
-0.000966266,
0.0090595884,
-0.0688895136,
0.0238736663,
-0.0181832053,
0.0227446444,
-0.030180091,
-0.0146553526,
0.0626746118,
0.0138662029,
-0.0331290066,
0.0029885175,
0.0315584652,
0.0182668511,
-0.0435386598,
-0.0011652559,
-0.0707186535,
0.0680403709,
-0.0340516381,
0.0017074661,
-0.0769502148,
-0.00526634,
0.0219399408,
-0.0128554599,
-0.088038981,
-0.0179723147,
0.0103190476,
0.0382709205,
-0.0286065321,
0.0385073014,
0.035804484,
-0.005569417,
-0.0167550053,
0.010056694,
0.0390473157,
0.0037378641,
0.0553296506,
0.0396053419,
0.0036795249,
-0.0291729122,
0.0500057898,
0.0120178033,
0.027793536,
-0.0172671359,
-0.0114913527,
-0.0728373528,
0.0689071044,
0.01225287,
-0.0288579259,
-0.0222007874,
0.0335904509,
-0.0142066032,
0.0017797652,
-0.0029344775,
0.0052515003,
0.0203723479,
-0.0010362508,
0.0147015415,
-0.0136911301,
-0.0230153464,
0.0009568133,
-0.0122363474,
0.0007331874,
0.0059979502,
0.0275278613,
-0.0260984004,
-0.0215001553,
0.0503516346,
0.0447334908,
-0.0194787458,
0.011282932,
0.0184270684,
0.011861572,
0.0303636119,
-0.002623183,
-0.0485192686,
0.0022447472,
0.0154282181,
-0.0082618799,
0.0080917496,
-0.0354904346,
-0.0038389463,
-0.0046862559,
0.0004351652,
0.0405255966,
0.0969003662,
0.0423344634,
-0.0325883813,
0.0198960844,
0.0219420474,
0.0287125353,
0.0530048162,
0.005972744,
-0.1026514694,
-0.0014596194,
-0.0152719608,
-0.0049090181,
0.048125729,
-0.0931656957,
0.0461446494,
-0.0662728921,
0.0069475835,
0.0134748863,
-0.00419635,
-0.0894719437,
-0.0392713472,
0.0070896712,
0.0040915096,
-0.0585379377,
-0.0242465511,
-0.0124938013,
-0.0019205828,
0.0087074377,
-0.0556432828,
-0.0162526909,
0.0473132506,
-0.0537796728,
0.0208523497,
0.0069223642,
0.0464466959,
0.0238981098,
-0.0253856648,
-0.0525290146,
-0.0185225308,
-0.0344600007,
-0.0110354992,
0.0472784564,
-0.0307554789,
-0.0002046146,
-0.0276416894,
0.0056956904,
-0.070077695,
0.0054668039,
-0.0040148972,
0.1539452821,
-0.0009877747,
-0.0098012527,
-0.0136240525,
-0.0071434239,
-0.0081859082,
0.0412375107,
-0.0161293596,
0.0034737117,
0.0141592855,
0.016552059,
0.0571995974,
0.0611300915,
0.0456917994,
0.0323171318,
-0.0533177853,
0.0117725423,
-0.0516093746,
-0.0551759601,
0.0362393856,
0.0339927934,
0.0143874614,
0.0265055802,
0.0067561343,
-0.0323221721,
-0.0526536666,
-0.0379943103,
-0.0251353662,
0.0437743068,
0.0485689826,
0.06195461,
0.0334374197,
0.0118355025,
-0.0381159447,
-0.0235936847,
-0.0393466987,
-0.0544210337,
-0.0781979933,
0.0199192818,
0.0044223992,
0.0461435877,
-0.0322013609,
-0.0085115694,
0.0234405734,
0.0204173625,
-0.0423973128,
0.0088790711,
0.0162461568,
0.0179255344,
-0.016064601,
0.0636774823,
-0.0510269515,
-0.0390125215,
-0.0218804833,
0.0254708994,
-0.0681189373,
-0.0616455674,
-0.0154443737,
0.0001453344,
0.059053611,
0.0078807566,
0.0179437287,
-0.0407141857,
0.0208046008,
-0.0354196802,
-0.0217790157,
-0.0275275223,
-0.0025442997,
0.0522179231,
0.0107758259,
0.009081007,
-0.0139424801,
0.0474794395,
-0.0079067387,
-0.0320137516,
-0.0159149095,
0.0140887918,
0.0096073421,
0.0257699061,
0.0445559435,
-0.0147588188,
-0.0286913607,
0.015180828,
0.0039750827,
-0.0321005695,
0.0162158199,
0.0155893974,
0.0037078788,
-0.0520059057,
-0.0142976204,
-0.0136866057,
0.0251864344,
-0.0210681204,
-0.0098423064,
0.0560252033,
-0.0032523444,
0.0070663118,
-0.022249369,
-0.0095013287,
0.014938063,
0.0463566259,
-0.0390098356,
-0.0379881784,
0.0523887649,
-0.0006306493,
-0.025363626,
0.0396612622,
0.0528751053,
0.0228440557,
0.0543552786,
-0.0212416332,
-0.0441333503,
-0.0444270596,
-0.0077968272,
0.0398520604,
0.0254313424,
0.0004879424,
0.0313591622,
-0.0557027087,
-0.0911478773,
0.0235823505,
-0.0415329374,
-0.0507222004,
0.0266814418,
-0.0012126352,
0.0049049789,
-0.0042675799,
-0.0427919962,
-0.0296861585,
-0.0306534339,
-0.030252656,
-0.0145396106,
-0.0157371163,
-5.789018743e-33,
-0.0310925487,
-0.029820729,
0.0105534308,
-0.0235487986,
-0.0756766498,
0.0231087804,
0.0069333939,
-0.0044241515,
-0.0631544441,
0.0159082506,
0.0064452854,
-0.0121486541,
-0.0190415233,
0.0059764367,
-0.0136686787,
-0.0124820042,
0.0040114908,
-0.0002963496,
0.029853981,
0.0189011246,
0.043286927,
0.0229100063,
0.0669795126,
-0.0686366707,
-0.00405807,
-0.0408184901,
0.0011844416,
0.0395250432,
0.0309668593,
-0.0047755544,
-0.0313044637,
0.0322197191,
0.0245231912,
-0.0072823688,
0.0065659345,
-0.0158370454,
-0.1427250355,
-0.0437021554,
-0.0396411307,
0.0022304838,
-0.017805472,
-0.0023337242,
0.0337059088,
0.0049228026,
0.0709177181,
-0.0926704481,
0.0473285876,
-0.0041025262,
-0.0955904648,
-0.0432159081,
-0.0149279526,
0.0332197137,
-0.0210848469,
0.0193382073,
-0.0080708796,
0.0243109819,
0.0763771459,
-0.0187208541,
-0.1062346995,
-0.0161372237,
-0.0209516268,
-0.0147692738,
0.0131661016,
-0.028565079,
0.0168129336,
0.0645225197,
0.0123078404,
-0.0149013735,
-0.0190338735,
0.0251275785,
0.0018009971,
0.0250694957,
-0.0232431814,
0.0062035304,
-0.0328792296,
-0.0250306875,
-0.0886901766,
-0.0001134129,
-0.0203081481,
0.037458472,
-0.0345442668,
0.0247648694,
-0.0556169823,
-0.0224213079,
-0.0324406177,
-0.0259170029,
0.0038176524,
-0.0643710494,
-0.0096143261,
0.0311788432,
0.0079673538,
0.0412655212,
-0.0038069105,
-0.0442858487,
0.0037432874,
0.054693751,
-0.0045898431,
0.0104836663,
0.0047366414,
0.025919823,
-0.0071306932,
-0.0455579758,
0.0164241623,
-0.0367794707,
-0.0064291526,
-0.0041260053,
0.0503214523,
-0.0073922146,
-0.0447787791,
-0.0118006272,
-0.0142588969,
-0.0800866708,
0.0103927609,
-0.0119367754,
0.0272436384,
0.0314423777,
0.0070365388,
0.0495561212,
0.0673764795,
0.0091292951,
0.0244631115,
0.0645872355,
0.0203070752,
0.002392025,
-0.0224135239,
-0.0272189695,
-0.0347456187,
-0.0068784878,
0.0416830555,
-0.0647759736,
-0.0266130492,
-0.0240185112,
2.676e-7,
0.0250205044,
0.0117650814,
0.0411030203,
0.0099794148,
-0.004110455,
0.0161116626,
0.0490504913,
0.0556912757,
-0.0250295009,
0.0142342374,
0.0590356961,
-0.0316269249,
-0.009681982,
0.0124453632,
-0.0778426379,
0.0012206463,
-0.0459865257,
-0.0651726276,
-0.0214970205,
0.0153920474,
0.0624243133,
0.0770203322,
0.0614951551,
0.0331246518,
-0.0058626118,
0.0169906057,
0.051638376,
-0.0066105477,
0.015351532,
-0.0135442978,
-0.0069978349,
0.0298592225,
-0.0190555397,
0.0483358838,
-0.0409789495,
0.0476826318,
0.0682833791,
0.0274981037,
0.0097956276,
-0.0163854621,
0.0155489501,
-0.0415955521,
0.0068324176,
-0.0162290372,
0.0409752131,
-0.0527560189,
-0.0141808605,
0.0827387497,
-0.0498496965,
0.0321059525,
0.0092238672,
0.0237560403,
0.022410959,
-0.0124922674,
-0.0057658241,
0.0052276119,
0.0208538584,
-0.0754416063,
0.0094304793,
0.0430033207,
-0.0299295411,
-0.0360736288,
0.034724012,
-0.0341590308,
0.0217007622,
-0.0174873341,
0.0259590968,
2.492453937e-34,
-0.0120652923,
0.0027038516,
-0.0071620848,
-0.0191388167,
0.0360623784,
-0.0619974323,
0.0168080237,
-0.0071496028,
0.0779631063,
-0.0643380955,
0.0129167894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15647v1 | Scaling Down to Scale Up: A Guide to Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2023-03-28T00:06:38 | 2023-03-28T00:06:38 | Vladislav Lialin, Vijeta Deshpande, Anna Rumshisky | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a systematic overview and comparison of
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods covering over 40 papers published
between February 2019 and February 2023. These methods aim to resolve the
infeasibility and impracticality of fine-tuning large language models by only
training a small set of parameters. We provide a taxonomy that covers a broad
range of methods and present a detailed method comparison with a specific focus
on real-life efficiency and fine-tuning multibillion-scale language models. | [
0.033297658,
0.0539273955,
-0.0018579517,
0.037739899,
-0.0154463928,
0.0201015174,
0.0145695535,
0.0103858029,
-0.0518766604,
-0.0550090745,
-0.046208974,
-0.0283686165,
0.0232445057,
0.0132291568,
0.0489548966,
-0.0345052294,
0.0491368286,
-0.038247969,
-0.0332601964,
-0.0124982456,
-0.0082188779,
0.0105881235,
0.0168951545,
0.0354411937,
0.0350369178,
0.0021241102,
0.0091874767,
0.0349010378,
0.0171506591,
0.0352118164,
0.0296243541,
0.068657279,
-0.00640096,
0.0658851713,
0.000001885,
-0.0248421971,
-0.0342804492,
0.0044985195,
0.0063131489,
0.0912235305,
0.0583593287,
-0.0278553404,
-0.0243809391,
0.0462066419,
-0.0190325044,
-0.0386985205,
0.0797114074,
-0.0080854222,
0.0369626284,
0.0912355036,
-0.0071944767,
-0.0531208105,
-0.0026223115,
-0.0445052125,
-0.0808368921,
-0.0460633971,
0.0362585746,
-0.0042112889,
-0.0220590085,
0.0014190255,
-0.025057001,
0.0197044034,
-0.0151035152,
0.0094548231,
-0.0182527769,
0.0102540823,
-0.047966782,
-0.0177706294,
0.0060250559,
0.0538709015,
-0.0552821122,
-0.0307222586,
0.0119809872,
-0.0229167305,
-0.0367558748,
-0.0227044746,
-0.02365526,
-0.0139101585,
0.0365568735,
0.0158773158,
0.0091261398,
-0.0450854637,
0.0477927476,
0.0246079732,
-0.0361419506,
0.0120790163,
0.0347206444,
0.003808094,
-0.03311681,
-0.0293746255,
-0.0407969579,
-0.0290591102,
-0.0141694881,
0.0158691779,
-0.0189551022,
-0.0141051281,
-0.0525911748,
-0.0334341936,
0.0145253427,
-0.0097010313,
0.0633337945,
0.0248196349,
0.0229617395,
0.0387735702,
-0.0285794176,
0.0062820502,
-0.0073139514,
0.0145909721,
-0.0214680824,
0.0168775246,
-0.0053659054,
0.0386010744,
-0.0544173121,
-0.0149553418,
-0.0274984315,
-0.0011244917,
-0.0251074787,
0.0016063249,
0.0497908182,
-0.0122191915,
0.0093265222,
-0.0378660783,
-0.0282454323,
-0.0217286721,
0.0629197732,
0.0708134547,
-0.0629430637,
0.0153059987,
-0.0214816574,
-0.0600679256,
-0.0107728615,
0.0175262988,
0.0336612873,
-0.017206518,
0.0236700904,
0.0147693064,
0.01569313,
-0.0310945734,
-0.0372847728,
0.0018603317,
-0.01162655,
-0.0690681413,
-0.0402894095,
-0.0634852424,
-0.0177171938,
-0.0058270413,
0.034498252,
-0.0264331698,
-0.0172119718,
-0.0234831199,
-0.0614678599,
0.0287040975,
-0.0388981141,
0.0276146568,
-0.0163370166,
-0.015398914,
0.037624795,
0.1021101773,
0.0528149866,
0.0067257038,
0.0516816266,
-0.0391499847,
-0.0251017585,
0.0502318703,
0.0194272231,
0.0551468916,
-0.0316997953,
-0.0118001066,
0.0335764177,
0.0143206734,
0.0077768872,
0.0385594144,
-0.0342911482,
-0.0005727054,
0.0528709255,
0.0057705804,
0.0470755287,
0.0368785448,
0.0132792061,
-0.0180653464,
0.0227737408,
-0.0172683056,
-0.0364634059,
-0.0101724006,
-0.0211707689,
0.015170305,
0.0444164202,
0.0624249242,
-0.0269504562,
-0.0087754484,
-0.024277702,
0.003094604,
-0.0138695007,
-0.0001792249,
0.0396479554,
-0.0023267749,
-0.0321154557,
0.0236361157,
0.0486184917,
-0.0331356525,
-0.0106562348,
-0.0571344644,
-0.0366085246,
0.0425834879,
0.0288489833,
-0.0206035785,
-0.0281306095,
-0.0022299769,
0.046171423,
0.0086423606,
0.069463864,
-0.0054890434,
0.027809754,
-0.0846817046,
-0.0081972657,
0.019852018,
0.0387997329,
0.0102125546,
0.0142021794,
0.0098828292,
0.0174574144,
-0.0316037461,
-0.0401623286,
0.0202486366,
-0.0203614421,
-0.0087660216,
0.0268416349,
0.0201552734,
0.0080018593,
-0.0121833012,
-0.0274145473,
-0.0210390501,
0.004613894,
0.0048658089,
0.0402406156,
-0.0259171352,
0.0148041323,
-0.0053390879,
0.0298723243,
0.0091852918,
0.0360234454,
0.0419066623,
-0.0621504337,
-0.0504039973,
0.0255679842,
-0.0148689672,
0.0290581901,
-0.022368392,
0.0535113178,
-0.0739187449,
0.0376709998,
-0.041261632,
-0.0077525452,
0.0101709068,
0.0213073194,
0.0039453823,
0.0272544436,
0.0327487253,
-0.026704831,
-0.0363674723,
0.017105462,
-0.0040629008,
0.0482375659,
0.0118829347,
0.0327520221,
-0.0122083798,
-0.036290776,
-0.0799442455,
0.0183096435,
-0.0573463179,
0.0241750795,
0.0334429257,
0.0370779261,
-0.0059255087,
-0.0022831662,
0.0148049658,
0.036996495,
-0.0378670059,
0.0473706536,
0.0091621093,
-0.002688519,
-0.0509811416,
-0.0529752113,
-0.0422491692,
0.0087604364,
0.0546668917,
-0.0138882175,
0.020282492,
-0.0787861869,
0.0129529927,
-0.0132312458,
0.0280247498,
-0.0023819557,
-0.080788739,
-0.0317804627,
-0.0292891506,
0.0170101319,
0.0774776414,
-0.0136938784,
0.0000477456,
0.0433131084,
0.0172051322,
-0.0347127691,
0.0003688458,
-0.0137754418,
-0.066204235,
-0.0378100872,
-0.0113828555,
-0.0102178706,
0.0666797012,
-0.0442299768,
-0.0173010528,
-0.0721578747,
0.032373786,
-0.0181345809,
0.0013807326,
-0.0027408218,
0.0334322639,
-0.0176224075,
0.0423537195,
0.0125861913,
-0.0724706873,
0.0335996635,
-0.0329691097,
0.0077061756,
-0.0472730026,
-0.0258592851,
-0.0401251577,
0.0192225464,
-0.0017111606,
0.0365378484,
0.0197355747,
-0.0267229266,
-0.0485416986,
0.0129462155,
0.035932336,
0.0067675607,
0.0523236692,
-0.0202033836,
0.0320102759,
-0.0369552672,
-0.0496246479,
0.0081762988,
-0.0498831756,
-0.0427821055,
0.0139932809,
0.0480413437,
-0.0562954023,
-0.0513030142,
0.0347510688,
-0.0209186003,
0.0470788069,
-0.0271860082,
0.0035131492,
-0.0205177423,
0.0071542556,
0.0766772404,
0.0064002089,
0.0481745526,
-0.0096072508,
-0.0114609972,
0.0020685298,
0.0407837033,
0.0180087779,
-0.0361347795,
-0.0086496091,
0.0457878895,
-0.0447848812,
-0.0375360698,
0.0215589851,
0.0536140576,
-0.0469878763,
-0.0145610515,
0.1242617145,
0.0042870352,
-0.0369671732,
0.0450585037,
0.0197461583,
0.0792335793,
0.0117032863,
0.0282414705,
-0.0561007261,
-0.0396259911,
0.0085364012,
0.0362561345,
0.0078135552,
-0.0108657638,
0.0052248961,
-0.0839691088,
0.0237581041,
0.0443471633,
-0.0291082188,
-0.0510921478,
-0.0304902084,
0.0164183155,
-0.0374553613,
0.0144567527,
0.0307541266,
-0.0414117798,
-0.0136777926,
0.0080389855,
-0.004879355,
-0.0879311189,
0.0238131285,
-0.0566134863,
0.0565778688,
0.0177490376,
0.0167927239,
0.0137029635,
-0.0026037984,
0.0433911756,
-0.0290723201,
0.0075127524,
-0.0385990888,
0.0180707052,
0.0071170428,
-0.0214016531,
0.0457297377,
0.0307448264,
-0.0183959473,
0.0180641189,
-0.0015567518,
0.0339946076,
0.0101906825,
-0.025171794,
0.0323683769,
-0.0142345121,
-0.0015619842,
0.0400203653,
0.0488090143,
-0.0357962251,
-0.0276319198,
-0.0148634454,
-0.0160059836,
-0.0183357056,
-0.019572936,
-0.0255162157,
-0.0003180981,
-0.0186719559,
-0.0402133465,
-0.0014757108,
0.0353805907,
0.0350630097,
-0.0011648247,
0.0028954959,
0.024640806,
0.0147823831,
-0.0216313992,
0.0231421832,
-0.0437393934,
0.0070531201,
-0.0765104145,
0.0039769025,
0.0501270145,
0.0285155363,
-0.0165256914,
-0.0013471291,
-0.1178516224,
-0.0989527702,
0.0043190583,
0.0472968332,
0.0210342836,
0.0374125019,
-0.0364869013,
-0.1078940257,
0.017792128,
0.0160986185,
-0.0152556552,
0.0532361194,
0.0433321409,
-0.0455573797,
-0.0372054987,
0.0748352408,
-0.0305961818,
0.0187283382,
0.0245501399,
0.0371840224,
-0.0220963974,
-0.0447104461,
-0.0324235484,
0.0170236528,
0.0353546664,
-0.0300937202,
-0.0469424352,
-0.01452104,
0.0474098958,
-0.0011990153,
0.0024229097,
-0.0229675192,
0.0045194109,
0.0184198748,
0.0184128582,
-0.0357884578,
-0.0231863074,
0.0169241261,
0.0093871579,
-0.0364717618,
0.0350124501,
-0.0134079522,
0.0087846974,
0.0694852173,
-0.0162046365,
-0.0248672087,
0.0596739724,
0.0229805708,
0.0353172906,
-0.0412794761,
0.0073661963,
0.0243800748,
0.0313403457,
-0.0790198594,
0.0488913245,
-0.0293919537,
-0.075687252,
-0.0457404107,
0.0149396397,
0.0732078701,
0.0063336226,
0.0768038183,
-0.0035150738,
-0.041167371,
-0.0253393184,
0.0236648321,
0.0017360119,
0.0099159833,
-0.0129003217,
0.013867001,
-0.0346415937,
0.0379670262,
0.0624383949,
0.0240654182,
0.0513826087,
0.017278811,
0.0120396046,
-0.0118236076,
-0.0193397589,
-0.0539911836,
0.0233853534,
-0.0281712711,
0.0207237042,
-0.0366726592,
-0.0604140088,
-0.0228213519,
-0.0146616716,
0.0050072852,
-0.0155662401,
0.0137315672,
0.0400952213,
0.0029817466,
0.027195245,
-0.0405872203,
-0.0343646333,
0.01049121,
-0.0168290231,
0.0011456109,
-6.668575779e-33,
0.0000323644,
0.0424555428,
-0.012322247,
-0.0024197076,
-0.0204653684,
-0.0102149015,
-0.0067064976,
-0.0003300735,
-0.0434825756,
-0.0034483664,
-0.0232005809,
-0.001162755,
0.0223133899,
0.0206496064,
-0.0267897509,
0.0110958219,
0.0743839741,
-0.0132115111,
-0.0437299199,
0.0315347724,
0.0127999429,
0.0157831553,
0.0575585775,
-0.0270765331,
-0.044439774,
0.0241489708,
-0.0384504907,
0.0331748165,
-0.0108221304,
0.0464390516,
0.0139287822,
0.0344448052,
0.0054151169,
-0.0122551573,
-0.0169117115,
-0.0138029065,
-0.0631766468,
0.0000901555,
0.0364779532,
0.0282546338,
0.0090198377,
-0.0313099623,
0.0480443649,
-0.0067400383,
-0.0138610406,
-0.0267268904,
-0.0083477274,
-0.0170626342,
-0.0277338549,
-0.0194395892,
-0.0652142391,
0.034400627,
0.0018555028,
0.0004360585,
0.0246056505,
-0.013100178,
-0.0176780988,
0.0185121093,
-0.0285298731,
-0.0028121253,
0.0779336244,
0.0960796401,
0.0511466861,
0.0393959209,
-0.0103703402,
0.0053322036,
-0.0205608513,
0.0339388475,
0.0109147206,
0.010326284,
0.0865099877,
0.0392666049,
0.03740279,
0.0398126021,
0.0161575638,
-0.0405228697,
-0.0808038786,
-0.0245560724,
0.020749459,
0.0321091898,
0.017758945,
0.0277064648,
-0.023847457,
-0.0267642532,
-0.077731058,
-0.0299639143,
-0.0410961322,
-0.0054229693,
0.0102058882,
0.0142205879,
-0.0593755692,
0.0103433914,
0.04066002,
-0.0499599688,
-0.0126455454,
0.0168470331,
-0.0181727298,
0.0268516783,
-0.0245489459,
0.0216577444,
-0.0354373939,
-0.0653944835,
0.018683292,
-0.0022636044,
0.0202473607,
-0.0328121334,
0.0231740177,
0.0375239924,
-0.0731108114,
0.0013694401,
-0.0020031219,
0.0242499448,
0.0019848864,
0.0526220202,
0.0117787356,
-0.0157879684,
0.0227257349,
0.039327912,
0.0237903949,
-0.0088010095,
0.0005102513,
-0.0062593999,
0.0444019474,
0.0236128792,
-0.0177212358,
0.0203270167,
-0.0373907126,
-0.0231123865,
0.0632631481,
-0.0383997448,
-0.0350495167,
0.0134882014,
2.524e-7,
0.0323916972,
0.0752316266,
-0.0080897566,
-0.0133062359,
0.0258362349,
0.037739452,
0.0130354157,
-0.0108742286,
0.0170977656,
0.0284416191,
0.0173245165,
0.0018097296,
0.0655333772,
-0.0129272705,
-0.0746406615,
0.0209932141,
-0.0827221051,
0.0470725,
-0.0389674976,
-0.0541706495,
-0.0528948121,
0.1324801445,
0.0208117552,
-0.0087135416,
0.0140871108,
-0.0271530896,
0.0249337517,
-0.0249527544,
0.0012739106,
0.0726160109,
0.0010766413,
0.0424200259,
-0.0027157392,
-0.0085492162,
-0.0281599946,
0.0456037521,
-0.0291066859,
0.0882984623,
-0.0218522176,
0.0297647938,
0.0049926923,
-0.0320976079,
-0.0164930616,
-0.0753384829,
0.0675614178,
-0.0498494171,
-0.0212800223,
-0.041088026,
0.0107781282,
-0.0312689431,
0.0170178358,
-0.0607064739,
-0.0288224034,
0.0607038289,
0.0286725555,
-0.0161573905,
-0.0272485353,
-0.0904071182,
-0.0082738791,
0.0426645353,
-0.0078693144,
-0.0507359393,
-0.0126147838,
-0.0362186022,
0.0458906889,
-0.0415342078,
0.017320713,
2.538251839e-34,
0.0633229837,
-0.0267726481,
0.0220163092,
0.0027113797,
0.0166990608,
-0.0034511432,
-0.0183481164,
0.0129374312,
0.0163951758,
-0.1070998907,
-0.0192278791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15621v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15621v2 | ChatGPT as a Factual Inconsistency Evaluator for Text Summarization | 2023-03-27T22:30:39 | 2023-04-13T10:59:39 | Zheheng Luo, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of text summarization has been greatly boosted by pre-trained
language models. A main concern of existing methods is that most generated
summaries are not factually inconsistent with their source documents. To
alleviate the problem, many efforts have focused on developing effective
factuality evaluation metrics based on natural language inference, question
answering, and syntactic dependency et al. However, these approaches are
limited by either their high computational complexity or the uncertainty
introduced by multi-component pipelines, resulting in only partial agreement
with human judgement. Most recently, large language models(LLMs) have shown
excellent performance in not only text generation but also language
comprehension. In this paper, we particularly explore ChatGPT's ability to
evaluate factual inconsistency under a zero-shot setting by examining it on
both coarse-grained and fine-grained evaluation tasks including binary
entailment inference, summary ranking, and consistency rating. Experimental
results indicate that ChatGPT generally outperforms previous evaluation metrics
across the three tasks, indicating its great potential for factual
inconsistency evaluation. However, a closer inspection of ChatGPT's output
reveals certain limitations including its preference for more lexically similar
candidates, false reasoning, and inadequate understanding of instructions. | [
0.0468459167,
0.0126065258,
0.0280196164,
0.0210146755,
-0.0636370033,
0.0328456089,
-0.0115267942,
-0.0336320698,
0.0026133175,
-0.0641961992,
0.0082763685,
-0.0335072801,
0.0399244651,
0.0141804591,
0.0153116509,
-0.0195568092,
0.0635627806,
0.0099182902,
0.0075241718,
-0.0061547416,
0.0200570226,
0.0261366721,
-0.0090369452,
0.032502491,
0.0135973403,
-0.0074935853,
-0.0086678891,
0.0055248993,
0.0464118533,
-0.0068239863,
0.0022768355,
0.0218006615,
0.0081806667,
0.0930211842,
0.0000019051,
-0.0423494279,
-0.020206159,
-0.0102149677,
-0.0318295136,
0.0504067764,
0.0191521198,
0.007697525,
0.0062599443,
0.015553575,
-0.0030540111,
-0.0153527511,
0.0028739288,
0.0416453406,
0.1036035568,
0.0718133673,
0.0078658154,
-0.0045725885,
-0.0210269075,
-0.0152467489,
-0.0029746566,
-0.0154431826,
0.0134694828,
0.0694625378,
-0.0042871949,
0.0213963818,
0.010001515,
0.008172187,
0.0186984092,
-0.0004270178,
-0.0074152867,
0.0419011861,
-0.0736059025,
-0.0158239678,
0.0234126486,
0.0570496023,
-0.0152302431,
-0.04267364,
0.0037531294,
0.0055461181,
-0.0117192902,
-0.0086244019,
-0.0168777891,
0.0600164719,
-0.0296300445,
0.0152740227,
0.0151054189,
0.0121241622,
0.0105716167,
0.0358696058,
-0.0148451384,
0.0465314426,
0.0200196877,
-0.0359088145,
-0.0506918691,
0.0123257106,
-0.0545620434,
-0.089222528,
-0.007075225,
0.0229203831,
-0.0589259937,
-0.007053426,
-0.0854279101,
-0.0061296234,
0.0372202769,
-0.0687729642,
-0.008623478,
0.0364793725,
-0.0282832664,
0.0698582605,
-0.0254780799,
0.0737893879,
0.0435875393,
0.0243745781,
-0.049969025,
-0.0080768317,
-0.0306533445,
-0.0011182002,
-0.0415823199,
0.0114833619,
-0.0294385515,
-0.0349228047,
-0.0402933955,
0.0026755517,
0.0005866344,
0.0277117994,
-0.0108241653,
-0.0053306944,
-0.0004587805,
-0.0146917347,
-0.0497149676,
0.0157011058,
-0.0194975603,
-0.0058457418,
0.0318528786,
-0.0472770818,
-0.0280885324,
0.0124110393,
-0.0263362881,
0.0128828986,
0.0222259425,
0.0186804347,
-0.0372628495,
-0.0063481834,
-0.0225869454,
-0.0214541964,
-0.0443557091,
-0.095527418,
-0.028677972,
-0.069082208,
-0.0026624103,
-0.0074102888,
-0.0302796718,
0.0235695243,
0.0043096473,
0.0462636389,
-0.0356816798,
0.0374377817,
0.0007443934,
0.0003141933,
0.052200947,
-0.0030003535,
-0.0135278003,
0.0377645642,
0.0284548905,
0.0255991928,
0.0462399982,
0.0514379442,
-0.0275650211,
-0.0332027152,
-0.0123128323,
0.0095047085,
0.0431432277,
-0.0098829148,
-0.0052567995,
0.0101620443,
0.0126059139,
0.0734728575,
-0.0513430871,
-0.0103052519,
0.0514786169,
-0.0140667474,
0.0191905163,
-0.0016207889,
0.0591050722,
0.0469771922,
0.044121705,
0.0743540823,
-0.0333316885,
0.0268949773,
-0.0480494536,
0.0529533848,
0.083478637,
0.061374817,
-0.009977147,
-0.0660388172,
-0.0249147899,
0.0190255493,
0.0031752915,
-0.012277877,
0.0140226549,
0.0019011769,
-0.058180958,
0.0249936841,
0.0231138952,
-0.0390425771,
0.0044901907,
-0.0280562378,
0.0211672708,
0.0604300722,
0.072688885,
-0.0016850184,
-0.0510745719,
0.0010143393,
0.001482561,
0.0358852334,
0.0485375263,
0.0010343131,
-0.0086865565,
-0.0328572951,
-0.005911083,
-0.0372910947,
0.0327276625,
0.0111273751,
-0.0040111016,
-0.0041144453,
0.0501228198,
-0.0316651799,
-0.020000862,
0.0348610766,
-0.0019765776,
0.0011490176,
0.0086084502,
-0.032686267,
0.0016501913,
-0.006516445,
-0.0421192609,
0.0214851238,
-0.0089678811,
-0.0003996049,
-0.0404607095,
-0.0001517302,
-0.0506288335,
-0.0613762103,
0.0319399461,
-0.0201971978,
-0.0176140834,
-0.0130546996,
-0.0665072352,
-0.0453515053,
0.0135106388,
-0.0466539264,
-0.0210513789,
-0.0679183155,
0.0536164418,
0.0274621546,
0.0071550808,
-0.0289988723,
0.0764125884,
-0.0023269448,
0.0227713697,
0.0152329495,
0.0197485052,
0.0276788436,
-0.0331513062,
0.0023892454,
-0.0040471503,
0.0059580612,
0.0092160385,
0.0393688567,
0.0418663472,
-0.0117045371,
-0.0375202522,
-0.1034056321,
0.0264594238,
-0.0491537936,
0.0120012751,
0.0534480028,
-0.0121953608,
-0.0070107947,
0.0031946998,
-0.0096501643,
-0.0219336487,
0.0405274816,
-0.011454476,
0.0509608053,
-0.0070662452,
0.0428556129,
-0.0491374098,
0.0014125742,
0.0056084939,
0.0511751324,
0.020766627,
-0.0101366471,
-0.0644602031,
0.0237509999,
-0.0886537507,
-0.0120410211,
0.0036936107,
-0.0123959295,
0.0220212881,
0.0290877596,
0.0659837425,
0.0267242808,
0.0420546643,
0.0126678925,
0.0564197712,
-0.0106956307,
0.0005777844,
-0.0062590917,
-0.0279788096,
0.0130194165,
0.0429412238,
-0.0301692281,
0.0227102078,
0.0036161703,
0.0236204825,
-0.0087187374,
-0.0315242708,
0.0270768758,
-0.0399215668,
-0.0034164849,
-0.0544923693,
-0.0158188064,
0.0066523836,
0.0248568635,
-0.0447752438,
0.0116195902,
0.0674804449,
-0.0758380964,
0.03253223,
-0.0883817896,
-0.0165943895,
-0.0430236906,
0.0070551881,
0.0267470591,
0.0336610004,
0.0031045757,
0.0208447799,
-0.0489841253,
-0.0037778642,
0.0716362074,
-0.0326323062,
0.0414417461,
-0.05925541,
0.0218751114,
0.0000439431,
-0.0241788104,
-0.0396817774,
-0.0612868667,
0.0090852259,
-0.0044128634,
0.0095294956,
-0.0032887531,
-0.0462842025,
0.0079386039,
0.0286308005,
0.0472755432,
-0.0211470462,
-0.0181342065,
-0.015472115,
0.0401013345,
0.0637824014,
0.0335257649,
0.069825314,
-0.0155814271,
0.0025418189,
0.0596357733,
-0.0138747711,
0.0068949182,
0.004308803,
-0.0095436359,
-0.0442485102,
-0.0398585424,
-0.017503906,
-0.0190847311,
0.0596844181,
-0.0235466883,
-0.0258575585,
0.1151901111,
0.0452106968,
0.0316681489,
-0.0014315703,
0.0129789263,
0.0378390662,
-0.0032432922,
0.0113292616,
-0.0681886673,
-0.0281260721,
0.0102757001,
0.0052045616,
-0.0248466581,
-0.0144173186,
-0.0410609283,
-0.0886896253,
0.0297025368,
0.0163324941,
-0.0331573039,
-0.0366259851,
-0.009189087,
0.0071790884,
-0.0104817199,
0.0367224663,
0.052586522,
-0.0201623272,
0.0332166329,
-0.0007111029,
-0.0376407243,
-0.0299494136,
0.0135434764,
-0.0109336348,
0.0134080825,
0.0453343056,
0.0157927126,
0.0220782198,
0.0351565406,
0.0348983891,
-0.0150477141,
-0.0168176889,
0.0105907619,
0.0523698069,
-0.010035933,
0.0125181582,
-0.0416922756,
0.0100276154,
0.0394697711,
-0.0175871905,
-0.0164829884,
-0.0094806217,
-0.0131253218,
-0.0089568393,
-0.0107504521,
0.057836432,
-0.0217017233,
0.1006381363,
0.0266957451,
0.018426409,
-0.0530974567,
-0.0475761294,
-0.0050022169,
-0.0269306451,
0.0093788048,
0.0224834979,
0.002652372,
-0.0187092833,
-0.0950432494,
-0.0425763763,
-0.0084167691,
-0.0199469775,
-0.0497489311,
-0.0343500115,
0.0203919131,
-0.0108219162,
0.0021703304,
-0.0157755166,
-0.0221780613,
0.0051963511,
0.0004671187,
0.0144348256,
0.0258806292,
-0.0257697031,
-0.0312342066,
0.0285241455,
-0.1064601317,
-0.0450741276,
-0.0176080652,
0.0177769307,
0.0175872147,
0.0411298275,
-0.0355131254,
0.0211926661,
0.0486112013,
0.0645743832,
-0.0253869686,
0.080734469,
0.0084237801,
0.0220283717,
-0.0168838594,
0.0109221023,
-0.0463674925,
0.0158825535,
-0.0370967723,
0.0606243014,
-0.007884183,
-0.0510321036,
0.042153649,
0.0450883247,
0.0249079894,
-0.0008449915,
0.0462190919,
-0.0270981081,
-0.0093908766,
-0.0243799407,
-0.0306544174,
-0.0182893258,
0.0119958296,
-0.0151119046,
-0.0091587109,
-0.016278049,
0.025420377,
-0.0350342728,
0.0379819758,
-0.005762889,
-0.0535729267,
-0.0326901414,
0.0015513381,
-0.0162785128,
-0.0463721417,
-0.0686045513,
-0.0221542493,
-0.0230643675,
0.0185935907,
-0.0161923207,
0.0501859225,
0.0423247106,
-0.0087832883,
-0.0114889434,
0.0267413631,
-0.101767987,
0.0105995508,
-0.0612929054,
0.0661126375,
0.0590744279,
-0.0001402382,
0.0751028359,
-0.0384378694,
-0.0103214318,
-0.047755722,
0.0180549491,
0.0537178628,
-0.0130805653,
-0.0234088041,
-0.0024048225,
-0.0074862344,
0.0317622498,
0.0773119405,
-0.0195282921,
0.0224801544,
0.0315462276,
-0.0333639719,
-0.0398098007,
-0.0770413876,
-0.0807275996,
0.0205570031,
0.0078723887,
-0.0236900952,
-0.0670048967,
-0.0343271568,
0.0172955748,
0.0518493801,
0.034328185,
-0.0074301967,
0.0123127885,
0.0534244552,
0.0052488232,
0.0172982179,
-0.0491974019,
0.0039114854,
-0.017871676,
0.0098864753,
-0.0206676796,
-6.25613228e-33,
-0.0526443198,
-0.0327582136,
0.0061452198,
-0.0238707587,
-0.029921975,
0.0082911514,
-0.049638547,
-0.0074321302,
-0.0079026688,
0.0277597606,
0.0245089922,
0.0192568861,
0.0071276873,
0.0191972516,
-0.0352548696,
-0.0211702455,
0.0565796793,
0.0316516832,
-0.0523118526,
0.0233619064,
0.0600616112,
-0.0231066551,
0.0170304384,
-0.0152089316,
0.0368367955,
-0.0439627096,
-0.0383086205,
0.0060820985,
-0.0260643698,
0.0218955725,
-0.0123369303,
0.0471936688,
0.0144947786,
-0.0259824283,
-0.024092583,
-0.0374572277,
-0.0641603768,
-0.0633639991,
0.0313579254,
-0.0371310674,
-0.0292439312,
-0.003269763,
0.0263746548,
-0.0126459356,
0.007414306,
-0.0467101038,
0.013013375,
-0.0291872565,
-0.0261655468,
-0.0182551648,
-0.0535970777,
0.0362194441,
-0.0135562839,
-0.0278954227,
-0.0689774379,
0.0593321808,
0.0034532291,
-0.0057429303,
-0.0415642038,
0.0080189398,
0.0138049396,
0.0196711365,
0.0345663056,
-0.0098655252,
-0.0157347172,
0.081143789,
-0.0419914201,
-0.0149697093,
-0.0790929645,
0.0087854629,
-0.0138429273,
-0.0083038379,
0.034881629,
0.0421583317,
0.0474196449,
0.046293769,
-0.0617252365,
0.0615316778,
-0.0077581187,
0.0244790819,
0.0319078714,
-0.0295403432,
-0.0226663761,
-0.0184425246,
-0.0420246236,
0.0362827443,
-0.0156476703,
-0.017118942,
0.0120796887,
0.0019272453,
-0.0206920188,
-0.032035239,
0.0172212087,
-0.0173291359,
0.0266030338,
0.004249657,
-0.0795588195,
-0.0124170417,
0.002180774,
0.0358583219,
-0.0366602466,
0.0240877829,
0.0551300049,
0.0401592851,
-0.0313323215,
0.0042170668,
0.0479368716,
-0.0301377028,
-0.0228974465,
0.040905688,
-0.0029365991,
0.0287249982,
-0.0490854494,
-0.024453979,
0.0215744432,
-0.0038334269,
-0.0262713656,
0.0260640197,
-0.0096510677,
0.0109750396,
-0.0130418893,
0.0070667863,
-0.0044361767,
0.0297369659,
-0.02953922,
0.0727798864,
-0.0175947286,
-0.0030946636,
0.0003476434,
-0.0417279564,
0.003716791,
0.0312406179,
2.57e-7,
0.0319243148,
0.0541806296,
0.0428628996,
0.0204862989,
-0.008795633,
0.0355234332,
-0.0213772748,
0.0262446087,
0.0138719846,
-0.0130981309,
0.0132314367,
0.0741687194,
0.0610448681,
0.0354162045,
-0.029442545,
0.0111608747,
-0.1097276658,
-0.0623769648,
-0.0356400721,
-0.026545886,
0.1011342034,
0.071465075,
0.0123517225,
-0.0077180788,
0.0205459986,
-0.0488190167,
0.058566913,
0.0215213615,
-0.0659434348,
0.0005277186,
0.0709369853,
0.0186605919,
0.0051120305,
0.0019094496,
-0.0051336372,
-0.0356606022,
0.038574867,
0.0304430574,
0.0198979639,
0.018109018,
-0.0313095972,
-0.0106172655,
0.017771367,
-0.0317992344,
0.0914607048,
-0.0765577778,
0.000915618,
-0.0494229347,
-0.0338464379,
0.0344457291,
0.0461180322,
-0.0046945438,
-0.0616160892,
0.0326705612,
0.0054910854,
0.0152427051,
-0.0070796805,
-0.0398855545,
-0.0239079483,
0.0124216294,
-0.018481724,
-0.0427231267,
-0.0053821099,
0.0115516037,
0.0478895158,
-0.0563218892,
0.0117240483,
2.484097366e-34,
0.0955015197,
-0.0276135299,
0.000157791,
-0.0716832057,
0.0497100614,
0.0161716659,
-0.0007943562,
-0.0136888549,
-0.0189841427,
-0.0527301654,
0.0001990648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15619v1 | Typhoon: Towards an Effective Task-Specific Masking Strategy for Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-03-27T22:27:23 | 2023-03-27T22:27:23 | Muhammed Shahir Abdurrahman, Hashem Elezabi, Bruce Changlong Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Through exploiting a high level of parallelism enabled by graphics processing
units, transformer architectures have enabled tremendous strides forward in the
field of natural language processing. In a traditional masked language model,
special MASK tokens are used to prompt our model to gather contextual
information from surrounding words to restore originally hidden information. In
this paper, we explore a task-specific masking framework for pre-trained large
language models that enables superior performance on particular downstream
tasks on the datasets in the GLUE benchmark. We develop our own masking
algorithm, Typhoon, based on token input gradients, and compare this with other
standard baselines. We find that Typhoon offers performance competitive with
whole-word masking on the MRPC dataset. Our implementation can be found in a
public Github Repository. | [
0.0216249824,
0.0516587384,
-0.0166361779,
0.0440772809,
-0.0317071825,
-0.0115180667,
0.0503984801,
0.0242884103,
-0.0286932141,
-0.0375200361,
-0.0302620456,
-0.0490100086,
0.0069552665,
0.0478469022,
0.0147639029,
-0.0756993443,
0.0491552614,
-0.0261195116,
-0.0364778824,
0.0138983373,
-0.0300339665,
-0.0001391019,
0.0234458894,
0.0640739873,
-0.033833798,
-0.0463204123,
0.0123057086,
-0.0026382522,
-0.0072670802,
0.0003283887,
0.0272498745,
0.0259695519,
0.0155607238,
0.0524056219,
0.0000022454,
-0.0079714553,
-0.0081871655,
0.0030535108,
-0.0250792447,
0.0182773434,
0.0476394221,
-0.0145547194,
-0.0038232342,
0.0146402009,
-0.0609463193,
-0.0346772596,
0.0437356643,
0.0577219911,
0.0655949414,
0.0595405065,
-0.0271401815,
-0.0156737175,
-0.0110931844,
-0.0393023565,
-0.0185879264,
-0.0444857813,
0.0284730885,
-0.0458256342,
-0.0513761975,
-0.0499489531,
-0.0282068755,
0.0243611857,
0.0199358054,
0.0130802607,
0.003822258,
0.0502867252,
0.0103549063,
-0.0345619619,
-0.0352550261,
0.0577394702,
-0.1223460361,
-0.0265965369,
0.0109102093,
-0.0193447713,
-0.0157739203,
-0.007397159,
-0.0023363191,
-0.0007065383,
0.0375280939,
0.0160534307,
-0.0099849459,
0.0089395624,
0.04005979,
-0.0025472338,
-0.046202004,
0.0306212623,
0.0101045677,
-0.0101859989,
-0.0108507443,
-0.0048703896,
-0.02277641,
-0.0906344876,
0.0339251459,
0.0360586829,
-0.0394793637,
0.0151561694,
-0.0845354646,
-0.0735675469,
-0.0253535453,
-0.0281775445,
0.0334785655,
0.0357190669,
-0.0228194557,
0.0616554916,
-0.0699912161,
0.050129015,
-0.0170112979,
0.0584517941,
-0.0265044998,
-0.0262349937,
0.0194122046,
-0.0266302172,
-0.0709343851,
0.0338470116,
-0.0955827534,
-0.0290230475,
-0.0096404608,
-0.01318557,
-0.0214931499,
-0.0259428825,
0.0556390584,
-0.0079842545,
-0.0470048971,
-0.0299960114,
0.0120380595,
-0.0171134491,
-0.0105839754,
0.0192217007,
0.0062863771,
-0.0642279759,
-0.0343567207,
0.0018648115,
0.0183643494,
-0.0308628846,
0.044129286,
0.0665203035,
-0.0124371182,
-0.0496341512,
-0.0128314104,
0.0185366273,
0.0122549478,
-0.0371632613,
0.0148353744,
-0.0354167484,
0.030617414,
-0.0094142165,
0.0354125425,
-0.0526041612,
-0.003592123,
0.0289128739,
-0.0081672696,
0.1068044156,
-0.0215199441,
-0.0161841735,
-0.0115378536,
0.0211062673,
-0.0133045008,
0.0538103618,
0.0079648197,
0.0608785488,
0.0385277905,
-0.0172228049,
0.0064957812,
0.0373748839,
0.0189235155,
-0.0194399357,
-0.0147856874,
-0.0086818784,
0.0245247334,
-0.0061777141,
0.047576014,
0.0476744771,
-0.0387593769,
-0.042659983,
0.0277864039,
0.0462910868,
-0.0045535979,
0.028571045,
0.0540316179,
0.0212234743,
-0.0022584505,
-0.0111622391,
-0.0180786345,
-0.0069335392,
-0.0086665964,
-0.026421193,
-0.0343404338,
0.0572446994,
-0.0259102024,
-0.0138070537,
0.0244202409,
-0.025231665,
0.0140120909,
0.0125609944,
0.0260365102,
0.0544580519,
-0.0782947615,
0.0266857706,
0.0141122928,
-0.0298755895,
-0.0037921146,
-0.0787634104,
-0.0127004795,
0.0194139872,
0.032647159,
-0.0381958969,
-0.0246093124,
0.0123283109,
0.0086286124,
0.0320669748,
-0.0003879966,
0.0119373593,
0.0743257403,
-0.0477052182,
-0.0026873327,
-0.0204047021,
0.0036166622,
0.0463703759,
0.0504402854,
-0.0180121977,
0.0081891743,
-0.0024379671,
0.0096995672,
0.0654112473,
-0.0240960885,
-0.0491009727,
0.0260244384,
-0.0014890244,
0.0222733971,
-0.0172464456,
-0.024674058,
-0.0005659366,
0.0429093353,
-0.0448248088,
-0.001918331,
0.006038744,
-0.0782079622,
-0.0498302691,
0.0226035807,
-0.0240529049,
-0.0247137919,
0.0835892633,
-0.0257538948,
-0.0363345183,
-0.0151626002,
0.0130718956,
0.0873492584,
-0.0152524104,
0.032040216,
0.0014193093,
0.0521733575,
-0.0195083842,
0.0351439789,
-0.0130971503,
0.0147151025,
0.0130964965,
0.0242294706,
-0.0153583484,
0.0108459694,
-0.0070878766,
-0.0032550783,
-0.0015983861,
-0.0097017074,
-0.0255367812,
0.0015778235,
-0.0149225751,
0.000107506,
-0.0591250621,
0.016017044,
-0.0308386981,
-0.013175061,
0.0237499271,
0.0255498998,
-0.0193835124,
-0.0309851728,
0.0125914663,
-0.0073638833,
-0.0191629995,
0.018330453,
0.0090904394,
-0.0113994628,
0.0190457404,
-0.0148532093,
-0.0457481518,
0.0335708745,
0.0535654686,
-0.0267995,
-0.0648710504,
-0.0176184718,
0.0206602197,
0.0236602556,
0.0483467467,
-0.0159501974,
-0.0298938584,
-0.0236949846,
-0.0150715075,
0.0987645388,
0.0723735392,
-0.0039253919,
0.0384693332,
0.0192863159,
-0.0223009046,
-0.0181553494,
0.0210113302,
-0.0324358344,
0.0043969816,
-0.0222990457,
0.0072079273,
0.0309675131,
0.0903796405,
-0.0279736985,
-0.0147402128,
-0.0409112684,
-0.0079388339,
-0.0334071368,
-0.0581192486,
-0.0331033133,
-0.0068211732,
-0.0383952968,
-0.0048880028,
-0.0443241745,
-0.0317862406,
0.0155187128,
-0.0418395959,
-0.0244307462,
-0.024790002,
0.0038148174,
-0.0075862138,
0.0570938922,
0.037391305,
0.0198445842,
-0.0309745111,
-0.0492996424,
-0.0304575432,
0.0204919055,
-0.0275700204,
-0.0448659211,
-0.0158223733,
-0.0236832369,
-0.0143420901,
-0.0205845106,
-0.013290613,
-0.0434517376,
-0.0497952215,
-0.0140779112,
0.0121943969,
0.0584567264,
-0.039055109,
-0.0267050453,
0.0310371667,
0.0034009165,
0.070625864,
0.005102295,
0.0091101537,
-0.0278050415,
0.0373889506,
0.0403026827,
0.0058809826,
0.0420959666,
-0.0245144218,
0.0153842326,
0.0548049472,
0.0717215464,
-0.0153137967,
-0.0360938571,
0.0038897204,
0.056899786,
-0.0058465595,
-0.0110338321,
0.0086765513,
0.0406660475,
-0.0778683573,
0.0015085003,
0.0908059999,
0.035505563,
-0.0265158527,
-0.0201181285,
0.0389442667,
0.0157952979,
0.0280318204,
0.0059160125,
-0.0604530424,
-0.0290780142,
0.0375628844,
-0.0226375181,
-0.0050008544,
-0.0398484096,
-0.0263886545,
-0.0824396014,
0.040566951,
-0.0164684597,
-0.0330991298,
0.0009171981,
-0.0527221337,
0.0047236984,
0.0098772347,
0.0290959943,
-0.0298022684,
0.0072260951,
-0.0382782333,
-0.0008952962,
-0.0191128571,
-0.0293807648,
0.0224552341,
-0.027017504,
0.0181211103,
0.0297781453,
0.0240285434,
-0.0076502417,
-0.0499453731,
0.0643953681,
0.0119281346,
0.0105802556,
-0.0271616001,
0.0590007864,
-0.0394347347,
-0.0339384079,
-0.0103853317,
-0.0093782721,
-0.0091252998,
-0.0351139233,
-0.0120993722,
0.0321946144,
0.0219031963,
-0.0128660677,
0.0068124081,
-0.0252603721,
0.0120856594,
0.0841957182,
0.0209730268,
-0.0553009659,
-0.032043118,
-0.0150310537,
0.0209514182,
-0.0703459606,
-0.0537118614,
0.006478508,
-0.0331072211,
-0.0256952289,
-0.0270894058,
0.0032758147,
0.0609840564,
0.0582930781,
0.0082992315,
-0.0206222199,
0.0143888202,
-0.0117109455,
-0.0740512088,
0.0295500774,
-0.0751233846,
0.0390185714,
-0.0721635148,
0.0010051708,
0.0047759833,
-0.0216616858,
-0.0294246823,
0.0470848978,
-0.0793510452,
-0.0258983318,
0.0544519015,
0.0593872666,
0.0158194378,
0.0308064036,
-0.0139421746,
-0.0592342541,
0.0593392663,
0.0252172928,
-0.0578879155,
0.0186598599,
0.041379977,
-0.0842790306,
0.0006709517,
0.0217895415,
-0.0204314645,
0.0300568063,
0.0735759363,
0.0161894485,
0.0185603779,
0.0251318514,
0.0265997704,
-0.0163816661,
0.0892197862,
-0.0321447253,
0.0314727388,
-0.0342549905,
0.0241295937,
-0.0277087465,
-0.0135687133,
-0.028732447,
0.0017814788,
0.0345833376,
0.0241252929,
-0.0155732725,
0.0528865308,
0.0132867079,
0.0147393132,
-0.036669042,
0.001697872,
-0.0175212137,
0.0154184308,
0.0356826112,
0.0190471951,
0.0159001928,
-0.0115459161,
0.008193627,
0.0013234332,
-0.0056567672,
0.0025154154,
0.0342566669,
-0.0109368693,
-0.0473990366,
0.0557569005,
-0.0671294481,
-0.041727975,
-0.0355831012,
0.0091768848,
0.0492885336,
-0.0309061743,
0.0148220323,
-0.0225813296,
-0.0339810699,
-0.0015221864,
-0.0092049893,
0.0229462106,
-0.0127982609,
0.0227246247,
-0.0006742947,
-0.0352075994,
0.0129899774,
0.0626390204,
-0.0012690051,
0.0248459764,
0.0562581569,
-0.0045344168,
-0.0423659272,
-0.000778787,
0.0133088296,
0.0420412794,
0.0027795655,
0.0094933258,
-0.0320010819,
-0.0613168627,
0.0134689398,
-0.0189100672,
-0.0143223526,
0.0220769681,
0.0140298577,
0.0266279951,
0.0071833194,
-0.0439768508,
-0.0320675038,
0.0429108813,
0.0287543423,
0.0030924163,
0.0307636615,
-6.727029439e-33,
-0.048521243,
-0.0202771612,
0.0037018366,
0.0259991381,
-0.0083098756,
0.053640198,
-0.0175165366,
-0.0362501293,
0.0036557608,
-0.0024946209,
-0.0522797219,
0.0203385483,
0.0413979925,
0.0393254906,
-0.0806237385,
0.0208774842,
0.0911313072,
0.0001722364,
-0.0076019382,
-0.0013889774,
-0.0232384149,
0.0608839989,
0.0445855558,
-0.0372543335,
-0.0250348486,
0.0079846289,
-0.014468899,
0.0010780493,
0.0153623894,
0.0346261598,
-0.0490967855,
0.0209294371,
0.0152497552,
-0.0464688428,
-0.0576724075,
0.0475995839,
-0.1112393364,
0.0057077417,
0.007223608,
0.0451944433,
-0.0791597366,
-0.0075314334,
0.0305308383,
0.0198593196,
0.0116979899,
-0.0035353426,
0.0022956464,
-0.0084911259,
-0.0199467614,
-0.0258162431,
-0.0514942482,
0.0260617416,
0.0246217065,
-0.0217013154,
0.0776473358,
-0.0123052606,
0.0049302876,
0.0190896969,
-0.0997742563,
-0.0179016106,
0.0114705153,
0.0397669412,
0.0298775509,
0.0960804746,
0.0424776077,
0.0492859297,
0.0613622591,
-0.0101209646,
0.0016671832,
0.0379442535,
0.0529858917,
0.0287051369,
0.04080588,
-0.000734728,
0.0652359873,
-0.0474128313,
-0.0487149134,
-0.0094841821,
-0.0545383655,
0.0098497625,
0.0401907787,
0.030481685,
0.0040178644,
0.0153001565,
-0.0329846963,
-0.0026734425,
-0.0264979359,
0.0083380435,
0.0469680279,
0.0516304485,
-0.0384649448,
0.0656798929,
0.0333946757,
-0.0374878161,
0.0105145248,
-0.0021548213,
0.0241212845,
0.0050965417,
-0.0107896011,
0.0542141385,
-0.024873795,
-0.0255971756,
0.047692135,
-0.0057429522,
0.019587459,
-0.0244614258,
0.0275446828,
0.0428732485,
-0.0988795161,
-0.0085680736,
-0.0346443541,
0.0368524566,
0.0364632197,
0.0557645932,
0.0503845066,
0.0154029652,
-0.0097637,
0.0305267368,
0.0184713397,
-0.0305278506,
-0.0217147507,
0.0124255447,
0.0027579712,
0.0264928862,
-0.0217719097,
-0.0088037252,
-0.0376716256,
0.0365089029,
0.0706271455,
-0.0628776178,
-0.0293991193,
-0.0266633052,
2.757e-7,
0.0255524851,
0.0275795627,
0.0320338421,
0.0125061329,
-0.0001824834,
0.0001262839,
0.0222308151,
0.0138374995,
-0.0042050378,
0.0152615383,
-0.0100315548,
0.0182797145,
0.0272659808,
0.0137359612,
-0.0625101328,
0.0232077856,
-0.0243964531,
-0.0145737724,
-0.0291317813,
-0.0039151139,
0.0298225097,
0.1237469167,
0.0230867099,
-0.0147725819,
0.0102286469,
-0.0312049109,
0.0415295362,
-0.0544711761,
0.0083075091,
0.0212718993,
0.0140410447,
0.0585743114,
-0.0188308358,
0.0155989267,
-0.0309611447,
0.0371317379,
0.0445917286,
0.0777889192,
-0.0175654851,
-0.0001857656,
-0.0114449365,
0.0014886026,
-0.0250718929,
-0.0558946617,
0.0840858594,
-0.0395500138,
0.00074866,
-0.0568931662,
-0.0389256515,
0.0081646349,
0.0093891006,
-0.0206270162,
-0.0258535799,
0.0388934575,
0.0383710153,
0.0080890311,
-0.0474791192,
-0.0873601511,
-0.0527257808,
-0.019761296,
-0.0468432605,
-0.0115379272,
-0.059916839,
-0.0162297674,
0.0352359973,
-0.0584455505,
-0.0079726027,
2.89674203e-34,
0.0174932983,
-0.0176536571,
0.0021260879,
0.047172755,
0.0249331351,
-0.0206480771,
-0.0097406944,
0.0098958295,
-0.0176573582,
-0.0675718263,
-0.0184805021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16777v1 | Not cool, calm or collected: Using emotional language to detect COVID-19 misinformation | 2023-03-27T22:24:05 | 2023-03-27T22:24:05 | Gabriel Asher, Phil Bohlman, Karsten Kleyensteuber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | COVID-19 misinformation on social media platforms such as twitter is a threat
to effective pandemic management. Prior works on tweet COVID-19 misinformation
negates the role of semantic features common to twitter such as charged
emotions. Thus, we present a novel COVID-19 misinformation model, which uses
both a tweet emotion encoder and COVID-19 misinformation encoder to predict
whether a tweet contains COVID-19 misinformation. Our emotion encoder was
fine-tuned on a novel annotated dataset and our COVID-19 misinformation encoder
was fine-tuned on a subset of the COVID-HeRA dataset. Experimental results show
superior results using the combination of emotion and misinformation encoders
as opposed to a misinformation classifier alone. Furthermore, extensive result
analysis was conducted, highlighting low quality labels and mismatched label
distributions as key limitations to our study. | [
0.0089241341,
0.0288119223,
-0.0090031009,
0.0117239002,
0.0044455007,
0.0213958044,
-0.0272969995,
-0.003777147,
0.0224805549,
-0.0262040831,
0.0185644422,
0.0011498721,
-0.0162779465,
0.0433470756,
-0.0115180286,
-0.0567116365,
0.032045424,
0.0618189499,
0.0826704651,
-0.0080380952,
0.0132291196,
0.0258092787,
0.0003074536,
0.0753393546,
-0.0326847397,
0.009038737,
0.0199200828,
0.0242652018,
0.0749595761,
-0.0799709111,
0.0656744391,
-0.0054838019,
0.072923705,
0.017784046,
0.0000018856,
-0.0270643979,
-0.0163197555,
-0.0134739727,
-0.010982207,
-0.0403519571,
0.0671740547,
-0.0948033482,
0.0134332208,
0.0395543613,
-0.0325520001,
-0.0286393147,
0.0552771911,
0.0512699708,
0.0705479234,
0.0912019536,
-0.0208921488,
-0.0333033949,
0.0003190819,
0.0058335611,
0.0284676999,
-0.0196865238,
0.0475397073,
-0.017700363,
-0.0270914417,
0.0183618478,
0.0161383133,
0.030715486,
-0.0185754038,
0.0250497628,
-0.0031895044,
0.026028268,
-0.018663276,
-0.0586497188,
-0.0168370735,
0.0124736652,
-0.0089443102,
-0.0188109428,
0.0307367928,
-0.0055503403,
0.0058159898,
0.0154557712,
-0.0046563791,
-0.0381853767,
-0.0098644746,
0.042509418,
0.0004269884,
0.0712680072,
0.0375218168,
0.0177696384,
0.0406419747,
0.0527207926,
-0.0358377323,
-0.0523807071,
-0.0020049585,
-0.0185099933,
0.0002287212,
-0.0165332947,
0.0286226105,
0.0167239625,
-0.0014962741,
0.0144342016,
-0.0487423465,
-0.0388504565,
0.0241401438,
-0.1324452758,
-0.0884571895,
0.0070866104,
0.0303336252,
-0.0085683689,
0.0341736227,
-0.0299936123,
0.0124682132,
0.0346655659,
0.0203848667,
-0.0339965858,
-0.0337621011,
0.0257916506,
-0.0390975475,
0.0107914722,
0.0235433634,
0.0092555219,
-0.0872134045,
-0.0552867875,
-0.0361664109,
0.0084421141,
-0.0271819234,
0.0183284748,
-0.0368808508,
0.0084923627,
0.0014307575,
0.0395987779,
-0.0112417629,
0.018974876,
-0.0028957119,
-0.0326133259,
0.0106180701,
-0.0123009281,
0.0179582424,
0.0146034826,
-0.0031647666,
-0.0041236142,
0.0283363201,
0.0067847045,
-0.0029198518,
-0.038330961,
-0.0287728198,
-0.0136939483,
-0.0031949619,
-0.0489549749,
0.0168740433,
0.0109329773,
-0.0048385696,
-0.0518909171,
0.0084033683,
-0.0167227015,
-0.0741671771,
0.0293282215,
-0.0510199517,
-0.0153034823,
0.0500689,
0.0340214111,
0.0194124579,
0.0420250408,
0.0231216922,
0.1061422527,
0.0332021117,
-0.0047804723,
0.037495777,
-0.0044884854,
0.054679215,
-0.0088667059,
0.0319279991,
-0.0302744918,
-0.0234082974,
0.0130141499,
-0.0238210037,
0.0316921547,
0.0063984226,
-0.0175496843,
0.0004336994,
-0.0061464268,
-0.0475851633,
-0.0397656187,
0.013343947,
0.0658216178,
-0.0100066494,
-0.037636824,
0.0130463773,
0.0193618163,
-0.048539605,
-0.0272669531,
0.0253290944,
0.0404534265,
-0.0218237098,
-0.016657725,
-0.0310240556,
-0.0285680015,
0.0135625275,
-0.0453061312,
0.0006321163,
-0.0379702188,
-0.05202334,
0.0152358245,
0.0579942539,
-0.0236822609,
-0.0074786162,
-0.0378344841,
-0.0067704148,
0.0818115324,
0.0015772937,
0.0145236673,
-0.0524979532,
-0.0585386679,
0.0127363093,
0.0305071548,
0.0389602259,
-0.0006201125,
-0.0384548418,
-0.0409737751,
0.0095145665,
-0.0248509347,
0.0510515533,
0.0006678566,
-0.0134130055,
0.0677499101,
0.0004577152,
0.0124405921,
-0.0276311859,
-0.0003906239,
0.0189651549,
0.0001995921,
-0.0333423391,
0.0348013379,
0.0604706146,
0.0049326294,
0.0400779508,
-0.0082410956,
0.0599425249,
-0.0198024455,
-0.042352993,
-0.0237161145,
-0.0002392412,
-0.0166156832,
0.009732455,
-0.012533484,
-0.0042117359,
0.0234701671,
-0.0742191225,
0.0491410196,
0.0680265948,
-0.0118627492,
-0.0002458254,
-0.0032980789,
-0.0203834362,
-0.0444869325,
0.0519159772,
0.0538945422,
0.0319347456,
-0.0404022969,
-0.0493033305,
-0.036109481,
-0.0529860444,
-0.0331128649,
0.000721377,
0.0109397415,
-0.0072189458,
-0.0008916735,
-0.0003338014,
0.0026977865,
-0.0403184667,
-0.0002147311,
-0.0177487712,
-0.044333104,
-0.0411051176,
-0.0154286884,
-0.0083392337,
0.0237027872,
0.0175687633,
-0.0063501233,
0.028980637,
-0.0050832448,
0.0033428369,
0.0302229449,
0.0087592285,
-0.0036542807,
-0.0311721433,
-0.0239542536,
-0.0158346836,
0.0172137599,
-0.0356336609,
-0.009799662,
0.0212939214,
-0.0910456553,
-0.0039787516,
-0.0318928622,
-0.0670216382,
-0.015530034,
-0.010874331,
-0.0563389435,
-0.0046739951,
0.0393278226,
-0.0298559647,
-0.0294170529,
0.0247360021,
0.1037478372,
0.0223452207,
0.0379814133,
-0.0087165693,
0.032346826,
-0.0568961762,
-0.0153964004,
-0.0264427029,
-0.0630634129,
-0.0106805554,
0.0540725216,
0.0324609801,
0.0431458801,
-0.0576441735,
0.008498718,
-0.0084393499,
-0.0314368568,
-0.039251443,
-0.0492010005,
-0.0014362209,
0.0133242235,
0.0002550988,
-0.0346290879,
0.041693572,
0.0139004411,
0.039287813,
-0.0604527555,
-0.0276658293,
-0.0114805223,
-0.0198985618,
-0.0417257138,
0.0202710871,
0.06405361,
0.028919993,
0.0759044662,
-0.0671587363,
-0.0315525346,
-0.0556029342,
-0.0436766557,
0.010157642,
-0.0002812079,
0.037702281,
-0.0202256888,
-0.0425144993,
-0.0556036271,
-0.066507265,
-0.0054372051,
0.0172111187,
-0.0052876011,
-0.0566701442,
-0.0420720391,
0.0017316957,
-0.0019784167,
0.0386786088,
-0.01289625,
0.0454203449,
-0.0168729983,
0.0365856104,
-0.0271616653,
0.0239900108,
-0.0340904184,
-0.0093145659,
0.025292296,
-0.0225431472,
-0.0137925968,
-0.0126891779,
-0.0060030557,
-0.0220119637,
0.0141571322,
-0.0053648469,
0.0203221031,
0.0325243399,
-0.0507489406,
0.0192587841,
0.1039239764,
0.0234796684,
0.0099733453,
0.0306483395,
-0.0236645397,
0.003364352,
-0.0089838291,
0.0093495641,
-0.0112835187,
-0.0295609105,
-0.0143525265,
0.0150929829,
-0.0403763056,
-0.01488348,
-0.0156588648,
-0.0096422313,
0.0298040304,
0.0134427128,
0.0372365825,
-0.0303183477,
-0.0491027497,
0.0115214596,
0.0055275909,
0.0023215788,
-0.0624007545,
0.0387972593,
0.0057858424,
0.0091365762,
-0.0639320612,
-0.076209642,
0.0219838545,
0.0139360484,
0.0379039422,
0.0213344507,
0.0974762142,
-0.0174492244,
-0.0833078176,
0.0223581269,
0.0290944148,
-0.0230938364,
-0.0368245281,
0.0960100964,
-0.0300475359,
0.0098215137,
-0.0182494521,
0.0107687823,
-0.0374326147,
-0.0259356778,
-0.0144394618,
0.0753953755,
-0.0225315951,
-0.077180557,
-0.0420610309,
0.0575540066,
0.0586857274,
0.0375007577,
0.0222648066,
0.0362675227,
0.0039025482,
-0.0288905948,
0.053435836,
0.0073848795,
-0.0323173515,
-0.0002834446,
0.0058613028,
-0.0953110978,
-0.0423217006,
-0.043715816,
0.0174407661,
-0.0410934798,
-0.0398414768,
-0.0746673197,
0.0427199677,
-0.0182694178,
-0.0296157338,
-0.0330970697,
0.0105290217,
0.0439785197,
-0.0027358069,
-0.0220301449,
0.0107891569,
0.0427780598,
-0.0060046907,
0.0273066685,
-0.0033281078,
-0.0488877334,
0.0342314467,
0.0088994848,
0.016625179,
-0.0035671424,
-0.0076387892,
0.0098744407,
0.090407446,
0.0668057427,
-0.0299344864,
-0.0202210564,
0.0351941176,
0.0177915711,
0.0093757529,
0.02638538,
-0.0007109608,
0.0391910151,
-0.0285763536,
0.0068029971,
-0.0406998135,
0.0052881045,
0.0080820424,
0.0026711365,
0.0609845556,
0.0018428417,
-0.0633377209,
-0.0206986293,
-0.0364939459,
0.0113291861,
-0.0023590429,
0.0098882858,
-0.0166678336,
0.0029920461,
0.0011688998,
-0.0369464047,
0.0360692814,
-0.0270591956,
-0.0301547088,
-0.0036610411,
0.0109960502,
0.0049431436,
0.0667210221,
0.0099092508,
-0.0131810633,
-0.0059173857,
0.0124399317,
0.0236759651,
-0.0128852064,
0.0019183927,
-0.0410022289,
-0.026491072,
0.0199868213,
0.0059564491,
0.0027480412,
-0.0041203313,
-0.0178647507,
-0.055665385,
0.0125617012,
0.0052917185,
0.0309382882,
0.055506561,
-0.0336398631,
-0.0170802269,
-0.0164779387,
0.0199068822,
-0.0431347676,
-0.0472998358,
0.0333018638,
-0.0352078192,
-0.0583796687,
0.0042464649,
0.037883509,
-0.0435784571,
0.0953670368,
0.0254962463,
-0.0574892759,
-0.0190151185,
0.0257074479,
0.008461751,
0.0072383694,
0.0032409814,
0.0500045381,
-0.0727693737,
-0.0083633801,
0.0948397964,
-0.0694948733,
-0.0199443158,
-0.0019595237,
0.0094008595,
0.0420381166,
-0.0114866272,
0.0225139707,
-0.0345060006,
-0.009725132,
-0.022119144,
-0.0372863226,
-0.0230239946,
-6.497032215e-33,
0.0246857665,
-0.0234262533,
-0.0336279795,
-0.0099104783,
0.0107591534,
0.0423635095,
-0.0033195952,
-0.0095848469,
-0.003704072,
0.0515252836,
0.0295512713,
0.0092144515,
-0.0067908298,
-0.007817002,
0.0048326463,
-0.0426776968,
0.0609604754,
-0.000374457,
-0.0129479961,
0.0241524037,
0.0796188861,
0.0310326219,
0.0574702173,
-0.1176653579,
0.0230378229,
-0.0158159193,
-0.0076480494,
0.0020520103,
0.0466414429,
0.0158994626,
-0.0082029626,
0.0847665295,
0.0269446466,
-0.0065185637,
-0.0027459417,
0.033235047,
0.0036878013,
-0.0488507412,
-0.0165457837,
-0.0485711955,
-0.0070222649,
-0.0554755963,
0.036700841,
0.0492276177,
-0.0404601209,
0.009858856,
0.0222772546,
0.0013570347,
0.043508891,
-0.0488352478,
-0.0473618619,
0.020224886,
-0.0273495521,
-0.0062735467,
0.0037896559,
0.0872261152,
0.0005557411,
0.0691763833,
-0.0516468398,
0.0121601066,
-0.0174781866,
-0.0023482617,
0.0134246238,
-0.0651151463,
-0.0163376462,
0.062830247,
-0.0062581571,
-0.008663822,
-0.0672514737,
0.0649639592,
-0.0263798479,
0.0402552672,
0.0371974744,
0.0727387816,
0.0160639621,
-0.0659198016,
-0.0765796825,
0.0477708764,
-0.0191404969,
0.0513223484,
0.0187067613,
0.0218132082,
-0.0335272774,
-0.0102419415,
0.0215973239,
-0.0020464831,
0.0100114457,
-0.0276273694,
-0.0141592165,
0.0125345597,
-0.0006763271,
0.0615244992,
-0.0233466476,
0.0101435147,
-0.0167660378,
0.0224843491,
0.0184581559,
-0.0003348764,
0.0096375905,
0.0433802791,
-0.0403458364,
0.0177409556,
0.0534880087,
0.0294658486,
0.0221781228,
-0.0101434514,
0.0307221413,
0.0144143654,
-0.0363547243,
0.0111465128,
-0.0007413193,
0.0418785624,
-0.0296314061,
-0.0334607176,
-0.0043892264,
0.0231665522,
-0.0089524994,
-0.028226845,
-0.0074622789,
0.0378222577,
0.0297030546,
-0.0264915358,
-0.0544800051,
0.0425579287,
-0.0465430394,
0.0317838751,
-0.0337358303,
-0.0170610324,
-0.0016030014,
-0.0772915706,
-0.0024081119,
-0.0468695872,
2.813e-7,
0.0315654613,
0.0781338438,
-0.0071048718,
-0.0356143862,
0.0091205379,
0.0616008006,
-0.0139135579,
0.0334628485,
-0.0041385475,
-0.1077118814,
0.0011025423,
0.0240513626,
-0.001164985,
0.0588730834,
-0.0109461686,
0.0111065591,
-0.050940346,
0.0274032503,
-0.0248127133,
0.0061439532,
0.0360146239,
0.072621502,
0.0507840477,
-0.0002938246,
0.0035437907,
0.0713720694,
0.0456515141,
-0.0267158691,
-0.0440996811,
0.0251800399,
-0.0023925349,
0.0059660254,
0.0137881925,
0.009770235,
-0.0165397506,
-0.0499799401,
-0.0162215624,
0.0222156253,
-0.0057034297,
0.0062478688,
0.0095761092,
-0.0041507767,
-0.0353153087,
-0.0024485555,
0.0147356838,
-0.0665554553,
-0.089640446,
-0.0067422334,
-0.0327872783,
0.0581618771,
0.0536641106,
-0.0082500847,
-0.0697631687,
0.0104285311,
0.0074284505,
0.0229405127,
-0.0282843783,
-0.0497866683,
0.045920603,
-0.0081098825,
-0.0449964814,
-0.0249997284,
0.0116017768,
0.006963362,
0.0349013321,
-0.0189530626,
0.0778021961,
2.056571907e-34,
0.0365893133,
0.0076792301,
-0.0495584197,
-0.0253811441,
0.0128530879,
0.0013377565,
-0.0090962742,
0.0064705531,
0.008068569,
-0.0014722549,
0.0275733303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02017v10 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02017v10 | Unlocking the Potential of ChatGPT: A Comprehensive Exploration of its Applications, Advantages, Limitations, and Future Directions in Natural Language Processing | 2023-03-27T21:27:58 | 2024-04-17T20:50:41 | Walid Hariri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have revolutionized the field of artificial
intelligence and have been used in various applications. Among these models,
ChatGPT (Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer) has been developed by OpenAI,
it stands out as a powerful tool that has been widely adopted. ChatGPT has been
successfully applied in numerous areas, including chatbots, content generation,
language translation, personalized recommendations, and even medical diagnosis
and treatment. Its success in these applications can be attributed to its
ability to generate human-like responses, understand natural language, and
adapt to different contexts. Its versatility and accuracy make it a powerful
tool for natural language processing (NLP). However, there are also limitations
to ChatGPT, such as its tendency to produce biased responses and its potential
to perpetuate harmful language patterns. This article provides a comprehensive
overview of ChatGPT, its applications, advantages, and limitations.
Additionally, the paper emphasizes the importance of ethical considerations
when using this robust tool in real-world scenarios. Finally, This paper
contributes to ongoing discussions surrounding artificial intelligence and its
impact on vision and NLP domains by providing insights into prompt engineering
techniques. | [
0.0887905881,
0.0538063459,
-0.0321826339,
0.0113765011,
-0.0568850003,
-0.0030405291,
0.0083661014,
0.0272970404,
0.0704762638,
-0.0670861006,
-0.0220390465,
-0.0123512987,
-0.0275144298,
0.0732519403,
-0.0215245876,
-0.0797968507,
0.0227226224,
0.0406311303,
0.0384026691,
0.0114123691,
0.0095221493,
0.0220106449,
0.0066778092,
0.0839726552,
-0.0580277629,
-0.0241154134,
0.0163514931,
-0.0146589018,
0.0114382142,
0.0059338035,
0.0098968623,
0.0393026397,
-0.0166492797,
0.0200236905,
0.0000023246,
-0.0336999632,
0.000958328,
-0.0030056436,
-0.0017710025,
-0.0446158536,
0.0701604709,
-0.0136032877,
-0.023650365,
0.0244209282,
-0.0849790201,
0.0117441034,
0.0692033768,
0.069368206,
0.0707044154,
0.0865509436,
-0.0318652727,
-0.0128995897,
0.0270872582,
0.0179469567,
0.0040888088,
-0.0172267612,
0.025167875,
-0.0181200951,
-0.0036586784,
0.0266619474,
-0.02532853,
0.0360517055,
0.0028998775,
-0.005394639,
0.0262935665,
0.0212601628,
-0.0304416548,
-0.0756861046,
-0.0487201363,
0.0750111267,
-0.0295841545,
-0.0126051791,
-0.0055456921,
-0.0051314519,
-0.0017849731,
-0.0012055787,
-0.0305632018,
0.0443184376,
-0.003031591,
0.0139229819,
-0.0119898235,
0.0296862703,
-0.0209074225,
0.006470927,
0.0086634634,
-0.0086553711,
0.024507124,
-0.0153429015,
-0.0188625194,
0.012420929,
-0.0301260725,
-0.0690414682,
0.0145781999,
0.0410087705,
-0.0476287492,
0.0187878832,
-0.0332883596,
-0.0189996418,
0.0315929875,
-0.0616563596,
-0.0149947163,
0.0386626162,
-0.038417764,
0.0091614379,
-0.0135204252,
0.0323760211,
-0.0106306355,
0.0575286448,
-0.0526628308,
-0.0029635031,
-0.0369800217,
-0.0271225087,
-0.0450664274,
0.0048163962,
-0.0434669144,
-0.0339869708,
-0.0621855594,
0.0300142802,
-0.0093514379,
-0.0298315678,
0.0239793546,
0.0554022454,
-0.0449858755,
-0.007773079,
-0.0370054469,
-0.0024870578,
-0.0265431665,
0.0031599728,
-0.0010130754,
-0.0911866948,
0.0127199823,
0.0265507568,
0.0001190947,
-0.0015930508,
-0.0100281965,
0.1045429781,
-0.0057227383,
-0.0319931544,
-0.0069993711,
-0.0274803154,
-0.0417877398,
-0.0422013327,
0.0032010253,
-0.0215865225,
0.0388213284,
-0.0145342508,
-0.0074304934,
-0.0238920078,
0.0071034911,
0.023983527,
-0.0533804148,
0.0756228417,
-0.0345454961,
0.0097247669,
0.0248481054,
0.0237784088,
0.003507894,
0.0325661674,
0.0291011874,
0.0471033566,
0.059097074,
-0.0143387215,
0.0351512395,
0.0237341877,
0.0034392397,
-0.0398235954,
0.034013208,
0.0040720697,
-0.0087326905,
0.0308561921,
-0.0149198016,
0.0717647448,
-0.0197280161,
-0.0250124,
0.0506480448,
0.0713793635,
0.0060945889,
0.0624337643,
0.053565789,
0.0339731053,
-0.0182795245,
0.0089845937,
-0.0124407606,
0.0141165582,
-0.0332716331,
-0.0326774865,
-0.022239754,
0.048789762,
-0.0221909601,
-0.0410735905,
0.0029928039,
-0.027550038,
0.0386259407,
-0.0178913362,
0.0037112467,
0.0367337577,
-0.0428125076,
0.0077897757,
0.0424649566,
-0.0582527891,
-0.0289396457,
-0.102625601,
0.0149868,
0.0741738454,
0.0654621124,
-0.0040388806,
-0.0132196918,
-0.0205362663,
-0.0234541688,
0.0389417559,
0.0438723266,
0.0096404208,
-0.0241425298,
-0.0460244939,
-0.0057593817,
0.0219837073,
-0.0160525106,
0.0219901577,
0.0272671413,
0.0218681525,
0.0031117178,
0.0452757329,
0.0005499154,
0.0440646894,
-0.0026709144,
-0.0301084407,
0.0105023719,
0.0042864745,
0.0409678183,
0.0082477676,
-0.0065370589,
-0.0001133402,
0.0191897806,
0.0144483512,
-0.0452156439,
0.0533400699,
-0.0542741902,
-0.0308499634,
-0.0005841971,
-0.0708700344,
-0.0158467405,
0.0248523634,
-0.0351522602,
-0.0248548388,
0.0048737321,
-0.0294817872,
0.0402089953,
-0.0585575923,
-0.0045124437,
0.0029105714,
0.0407282189,
-0.0458773635,
0.0512481816,
0.0270597376,
-0.0279368851,
-0.000401015,
0.0058162869,
0.0119077722,
-0.0246905182,
-0.0131503912,
0.0109996349,
-0.0126323793,
0.0132909855,
0.0389752798,
0.0461059213,
-0.0350650512,
-0.0242232904,
-0.1175771132,
0.0006373289,
-0.0109395934,
-0.0393418036,
0.0136106899,
0.016324291,
-0.0174265858,
-0.0226141941,
-0.0515680797,
0.0546768196,
0.0466481969,
0.0114790276,
0.0305622946,
-0.0096297497,
-0.0216721371,
-0.0221145283,
0.0114002815,
-0.0133904917,
0.0456433818,
0.0542228371,
-0.0296756774,
-0.028134007,
0.0091385776,
-0.0339039788,
0.0425982811,
0.0072749271,
-0.0598658621,
0.0228989888,
0.0115159405,
0.0657095686,
0.0297545288,
0.0652324706,
0.0630006343,
0.0044578416,
0.0109376041,
-0.0281404033,
-0.0037717535,
-0.0584914424,
-0.0584844686,
0.0142562976,
-0.0322074182,
0.0152521087,
0.0333720967,
0.0447722599,
-0.0163260326,
-0.1042392179,
0.01007035,
-0.0025940035,
-0.0449646749,
-0.0221025497,
-0.036383532,
-0.0367236286,
0.0350299627,
-0.0031088716,
-0.049526453,
0.07035207,
0.0064245579,
0.0181665737,
-0.0513282456,
0.0051311133,
-0.0255737416,
0.0514068007,
0.0197022036,
0.0402834825,
0.0359689631,
-0.0141044063,
-0.0255160108,
-0.0013480338,
-0.0075001223,
-0.0403952487,
-0.0077327304,
-0.0306160729,
-0.0026061814,
0.004471838,
-0.0367010236,
-0.0706564859,
-0.0597501807,
-0.0012654271,
-0.0220086295,
0.0533225574,
0.0230200384,
-0.0121053625,
0.0092604021,
-0.0152946375,
0.0206591655,
-0.0011367348,
-0.0147295324,
-0.0187606588,
0.0295741763,
0.046189215,
0.0120496713,
0.0164662432,
0.0396957733,
0.0265170317,
0.0885567516,
-0.0315872505,
-0.0026294489,
-0.022804616,
-0.0041828603,
0.0027608851,
-0.0105545549,
0.0139853293,
0.0301727932,
0.0368777663,
-0.0194445606,
-0.0142002292,
0.0925766975,
0.0450297445,
-0.042057272,
0.0123794433,
0.0119079268,
-0.024019774,
-0.025825724,
0.0127374018,
-0.1134063229,
-0.0164552443,
-0.0245516971,
-0.0104094073,
-0.0551678203,
-0.017435506,
-0.0107084885,
-0.0712236315,
0.0581048429,
-0.0075972034,
-0.0288951155,
-0.0183438938,
-0.0078880498,
-0.024714699,
-0.0073668496,
0.0248567369,
-0.0246547125,
-0.001198686,
-0.0075004394,
-0.0011115135,
-0.0302992966,
-0.0328710489,
0.0346843898,
-0.0313844606,
0.0687645078,
0.0787298232,
0.0547749549,
0.0113470741,
-0.0149423052,
0.0121394247,
0.0432625972,
0.0392857902,
-0.0048726806,
0.0651817992,
-0.0143748745,
-0.012820703,
-0.0570362061,
0.017702885,
-0.0121559454,
-0.0199225843,
0.0029630784,
0.0596938133,
-0.0400226228,
-0.0176061392,
-0.0477777906,
0.0463175662,
0.0279331785,
0.0712485686,
0.0000190089,
-0.032146804,
-0.0335975215,
-0.0104275635,
0.0209547672,
-0.0100613544,
-0.0834242925,
-0.0011823145,
0.0060886093,
-0.0373499505,
-0.1028066948,
-0.0475033186,
0.0162361097,
-0.0124459462,
0.025940584,
-0.072758384,
0.0259681437,
0.0315833911,
0.0023522652,
0.0305934362,
-0.0101121515,
-0.024320364,
-0.0370953418,
-0.0172888581,
0.0409269258,
-0.067785643,
0.0016043669,
0.0140439896,
-0.0195987783,
-0.0303009115,
0.0299536437,
0.0750182942,
0.0198579598,
0.0253660511,
-0.0237558931,
-0.0065966211,
0.0343580842,
0.0671592206,
-0.0500519909,
-0.0177725703,
0.003907681,
0.0408283509,
-0.0080201579,
0.0053299554,
0.0040369541,
0.0536615737,
0.0111540854,
-0.0143142957,
-0.0176200997,
-0.0661709756,
0.0543716103,
0.016560046,
0.0588162616,
-0.0196873415,
-0.0144420378,
-0.0256668739,
-0.0266114492,
-0.0414150283,
-0.0033159752,
-0.0414699204,
-0.0089756288,
0.0144708976,
0.0190345943,
-0.030229969,
-0.0233301092,
-0.108671613,
0.0035889363,
-0.0443611704,
-0.0042059799,
0.0177233219,
-0.0096079428,
-0.005505871,
0.0122203268,
-0.0156115899,
0.0199821461,
-0.0120692383,
0.0129035655,
-0.0005289348,
0.0776645541,
0.0119441003,
-0.0151323369,
0.0156467725,
0.0590102412,
-0.065050751,
-0.0471327491,
-0.027842354,
0.0869055688,
0.0299015082,
0.009138261,
0.0121063665,
-0.0382473618,
-0.0014092524,
0.0178184099,
0.0346991234,
0.0000924221,
-0.044819165,
0.0075433287,
-0.0218077898,
-0.0276454613,
-0.0331265889,
0.0597825199,
-0.0455248654,
0.0105294604,
0.0102487411,
-0.0419574529,
-0.0477117598,
-0.0294222943,
0.0216625556,
-0.0243076477,
0.0038689703,
0.0376501083,
-0.0379913971,
-0.0349562429,
-0.0309378747,
-0.0049353316,
0.0223771837,
-0.0027427643,
0.0579742938,
0.069574371,
-0.0083808303,
-0.0217176024,
-0.0300258379,
0.0183087345,
-0.0297700502,
-0.0097474679,
-0.0111730229,
-6.725736396e-33,
-0.0129229687,
-0.0413748398,
0.0292607602,
0.0330962501,
-0.0224760249,
-0.0206344817,
-0.0108409245,
0.000664848,
-0.020188164,
0.0281344429,
-0.0375429206,
0.001370388,
0.0046304069,
0.0172781255,
-0.0096595688,
-0.0230708681,
0.0418643728,
-0.0203982983,
-0.0081291609,
0.0235152151,
0.0175902657,
0.0268578865,
0.0427703783,
-0.0893280879,
0.012544171,
0.0032691217,
-0.0387103669,
-0.0077095069,
-0.0069404012,
0.0280594919,
-0.0389096588,
0.0608502477,
0.0363471769,
-0.0061802818,
-0.0012869325,
0.066589132,
-0.0277106389,
-0.0146516683,
0.0087973168,
0.0261286143,
-0.0455505922,
-0.0240563564,
0.0345542952,
-0.0494025946,
-0.0303821657,
0.0041477587,
0.0442180261,
-0.0207997691,
0.0281537306,
-0.0101172552,
-0.0852149427,
-0.0024381175,
-0.0146930059,
-0.0599564686,
-0.024415208,
0.0546369925,
-0.0168164205,
0.017400967,
-0.0251576062,
0.036242798,
0.0206109583,
-0.0371520147,
0.0119937295,
-0.0373097658,
0.0072849412,
0.0545188449,
0.0139031801,
-0.0112413177,
-0.0607067905,
-0.0127457706,
-0.021574676,
0.051472567,
0.0677176267,
0.0568826832,
0.0138657521,
-0.0379550979,
-0.0477436744,
0.0248178001,
0.0174575541,
0.02183678,
0.0195989963,
-0.0074537848,
-0.0509846322,
-0.0028495621,
0.0309867561,
-0.0039167404,
-0.019048823,
-0.0545666851,
0.0203299485,
0.0130595788,
-0.0164411329,
0.0026572205,
0.0189369656,
-0.0673308149,
0.0645146742,
-0.0225904025,
-0.0122157279,
-0.0038821751,
-0.0152323069,
0.0121186217,
-0.0355169326,
-0.0208012331,
0.0710659996,
-0.0131427869,
0.0111119971,
0.0091204736,
0.0171681046,
0.0135179032,
-0.0388665982,
0.0082467012,
-0.0050316881,
0.0510126986,
0.0181778427,
-0.0080280416,
0.0048394655,
0.0334369577,
-0.0474288501,
0.0241075177,
0.0278534964,
0.0208150018,
-0.0614475347,
-0.0118947411,
-0.0176497623,
0.0080891475,
-0.0612672828,
0.0222313739,
-0.0320638679,
0.0092563843,
0.0150467781,
-0.0846598074,
-0.0360474698,
-0.0189832058,
3.038e-7,
0.0292955562,
0.0531353541,
0.0304921046,
0.0095693441,
0.0040390757,
0.0249464065,
0.0429490209,
0.0585541539,
0.0297709666,
-0.00447335,
0.0368527509,
0.0352776907,
0.0161255077,
0.0170367155,
-0.0575903207,
-0.0185144935,
-0.064312771,
-0.0293315873,
-0.0489525236,
0.0077794469,
0.1116541177,
0.0861093476,
-0.0137499673,
-0.0184961613,
0.0172571614,
-0.0003467255,
0.0595116988,
-0.0414174907,
-0.0225952137,
0.0276088919,
0.0434620306,
0.0169686433,
0.0053178398,
0.0337536484,
0.0064131254,
-0.0240756627,
0.0294076335,
0.054573521,
-0.0137392469,
-0.0383541323,
0.0071170419,
-0.0058560008,
0.005603062,
-0.0610512868,
0.0812759325,
-0.0831658468,
-0.0325932018,
-0.046106007,
0.0005073213,
0.0002289959,
0.0473809578,
-0.035819184,
-0.0417965911,
0.0229310803,
0.0413779765,
0.0370007753,
0.0083942823,
-0.0929518268,
0.0085703349,
-0.0381193794,
-0.054335922,
-0.0265896656,
0.0022420844,
0.0023107943,
0.0354689844,
-0.0206406862,
0.0164751392,
2.675228155e-34,
0.0231993534,
0.0195785649,
0.0226137415,
-0.0036698845,
0.0307702217,
0.0331936553,
0.0693665892,
0.0123875514,
0.0142805828,
-0.0499747209,
-0.0397883765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15587v1 | Linguistically Informed ChatGPT Prompts to Enhance Japanese-Chinese Machine Translation: A Case Study on Attributive Clauses | 2023-03-27T20:33:40 | 2023-03-27T20:33:40 | Wenshi Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of Japanese-Chinese translation linguistics, the issue of
correctly translating attributive clauses has persistently proven to be
challenging. Present-day machine translation tools often fail to accurately
translate attributive clauses from Japanese to Chinese. In light of this, this
paper investigates the linguistic problem underlying such difficulties, namely
how does the semantic role of the modified noun affect the selection of
translation patterns for attributive clauses, from a linguistic perspective. To
ad-dress these difficulties, a pre-edit scheme is proposed, which aims to
enhance the accuracy of translation. Furthermore, we propose a novel two-step
prompt strategy, which combines this pre-edit scheme with ChatGPT, currently
the most widely used large language model. This prompt strategy is capable of
optimizing translation input in zero-shot scenarios and has been demonstrated
to improve the average translation accuracy score by over 35%. | [
0.0663573965,
-0.00652488,
-0.0207197946,
0.045754265,
-0.0511672758,
0.0114755807,
0.0104660736,
0.0114719998,
-0.0163490009,
-0.0268522091,
-0.0317631178,
-0.0048309788,
0.0319162458,
-0.0546312258,
0.0231054537,
-0.0225685518,
0.073957175,
0.0281480309,
-0.0130723231,
0.001252515,
0.0155440308,
-0.0058677993,
0.0201751869,
0.0081285033,
-0.0443696976,
-0.02848115,
0.010185062,
0.0367922187,
0.0392876342,
-0.0145487851,
-0.0132678663,
0.0291348211,
-0.0421798751,
0.028771624,
0.0000021854,
-0.0483538024,
-0.0460163802,
0.0010293912,
-0.0176032633,
0.0324775167,
0.0372767523,
0.0010870401,
-0.0329830348,
0.0029894218,
-0.0146041829,
-0.019843705,
0.0676989853,
0.0341762826,
0.0878280774,
0.0774174333,
-0.0410109907,
-0.0198181681,
-0.0351478532,
-0.0288719684,
0.0018022591,
-0.0306396913,
-0.009285165,
-0.0311612412,
-0.0160699226,
0.0353065915,
-0.0080139805,
0.0623371564,
-0.0084809866,
-0.0217735618,
-0.0209480189,
-0.0185396187,
-0.0150216809,
-0.0136408713,
-0.0035785402,
0.0394723378,
-0.0058226753,
-0.0056031826,
-0.0132667823,
-0.0099841822,
0.0234988872,
0.0031331915,
-0.0346874297,
0.0075530838,
-0.0126581937,
-0.0364332646,
0.0408708714,
-0.00572909,
0.0054919948,
0.0055525885,
-0.0250737928,
0.0187735837,
0.0441164821,
-0.0611352138,
-0.0330739245,
0.006476244,
-0.0229487885,
-0.0483133644,
0.0175651871,
-0.0067462474,
-0.042038478,
0.0419692509,
-0.0243417677,
-0.016947262,
0.0002747266,
-0.0630061477,
-0.0053096856,
0.057187181,
-0.0328379422,
0.0337292477,
-0.0103195021,
0.0672726408,
0.0119907549,
0.0248987358,
-0.0815361664,
-0.0087527279,
-0.0319028236,
-0.0213714875,
-0.1253071278,
-0.0002076607,
-0.0086680828,
-0.0101485625,
-0.0405519307,
0.0271088369,
0.0095860017,
0.0035394218,
0.0308892876,
-0.0509013124,
-0.0732556209,
0.0029156303,
-0.0105142165,
0.0197717734,
-0.0285512023,
0.0103880456,
0.0013912546,
-0.0437739715,
-0.0194364786,
0.0069237147,
0.0106553985,
-0.0313684233,
-0.0348540954,
0.0713923052,
-0.0024970649,
0.0053826692,
0.001880299,
-0.0332541689,
-0.0577321127,
-0.012982049,
-0.0193910878,
-0.024185691,
0.0463399291,
-0.0053204782,
0.0182439554,
-0.0286322515,
0.0085144816,
0.0184802078,
-0.0334975608,
0.0479158461,
0.012432863,
0.0114803426,
-0.0364772305,
-0.0292293876,
-0.030480925,
0.026558334,
0.0511369407,
0.0452775694,
0.0730171725,
0.0192574859,
-0.0078735454,
0.0503014475,
-0.0121982777,
0.0228350256,
-0.0113872299,
0.0094966665,
0.0425374508,
0.0147702815,
-0.0085179191,
0.0194124784,
-0.002995434,
0.0419544242,
0.0701855496,
-0.0073724147,
-0.0041463496,
0.0548119619,
0.0468706526,
-0.0054125763,
-0.0235581677,
0.0167464614,
-0.041815564,
0.0316002034,
-0.0336802676,
0.0168388952,
-0.0211106483,
0.0240692031,
0.0019058625,
-0.0577588379,
-0.0105514573,
0.0257662646,
0.0174477268,
-0.0130142886,
-0.0044090338,
0.0334977582,
-0.0201282371,
0.0540478267,
-0.004094115,
-0.0540529899,
-0.0082046194,
-0.0330244973,
-0.032698378,
0.0415911153,
0.0514147803,
0.0002507891,
-0.0543132462,
0.0015049002,
0.0180856362,
0.0423229411,
0.0724873394,
-0.0002565371,
-0.0148412352,
-0.0161046516,
-0.0373251587,
0.0278352648,
0.0158988535,
0.0327749886,
0.0069715357,
0.0359548256,
0.0559611879,
0.0073964391,
-0.0360877328,
0.0106899496,
0.0367181785,
-0.0237678494,
0.0156694017,
0.0349984802,
0.041079998,
0.0144309821,
0.0055696359,
0.0120325889,
-0.0229483265,
-0.0153197926,
-0.023204999,
0.0921294019,
-0.0005489951,
-0.0683865473,
0.0134987449,
-0.0023885877,
-0.0240557399,
-0.0462675095,
-0.0584649071,
-0.0485346802,
-0.060752172,
-0.0271821152,
0.006983385,
-0.0600319691,
0.067556262,
-0.0093126418,
-0.0070893061,
-0.0452598855,
0.0349455997,
0.0404746868,
-0.0179417394,
0.0172044169,
-0.0229911897,
0.0474231765,
-0.023944879,
-0.0410747379,
0.0485643484,
0.0187940691,
0.0096052773,
0.0430501364,
0.0290599503,
-0.0197772719,
-0.0429506153,
-0.0687821284,
0.0260648672,
-0.023828797,
0.0084063392,
0.0147361644,
0.0379048996,
-0.0297181755,
0.0147872632,
-0.011394633,
0.0139682433,
-0.000129415,
0.0231261123,
0.0159890875,
-0.0004871281,
0.0084275035,
-0.0132396957,
0.0275055189,
-0.0038408623,
-0.0393704511,
0.0444521941,
-0.0677347928,
-0.0666404963,
0.0511327125,
-0.0396076962,
-0.0438115783,
0.0297998805,
-0.0770195723,
-0.0230715051,
-0.0221202616,
0.0232374445,
0.0577552877,
-0.0264544953,
0.0078253169,
0.0180077944,
-0.0351292677,
-0.0096348757,
0.0183812827,
-0.0318461098,
-0.0730127096,
0.0235241987,
-0.0444682017,
0.0416216664,
0.0543074496,
0.0403677076,
-0.0264749099,
-0.0683030635,
-0.000642969,
-0.0508227944,
0.0108796274,
-0.0128720086,
0.0164909195,
-0.0086293938,
0.0460377634,
-0.0354575105,
-0.003506453,
0.0833615661,
-0.0025556723,
-0.0105296634,
-0.0757788643,
0.0394538939,
-0.0311703701,
0.0516452938,
-0.0297821872,
0.0239168387,
0.0426511727,
-0.0274842307,
-0.0435043797,
0.0193533506,
0.0909437835,
0.013132114,
-0.002489886,
-0.0555282794,
0.0120104915,
-0.013970566,
-0.0238403007,
-0.0068254671,
-0.057619527,
0.0117590725,
0.0006415691,
-0.0062214388,
0.0207496714,
0.0127172451,
0.0389812179,
0.0063954163,
0.0224381164,
-0.0344102718,
0.0165557936,
-0.0491307862,
-0.0165072065,
0.0081168916,
-0.0134450346,
-0.0411868393,
0.0021471567,
0.0383930057,
0.0141678844,
-0.0134082278,
-0.0138367536,
0.025107367,
0.0158625301,
0.023808768,
-0.025911767,
-0.0905550495,
-0.0125554297,
0.0392119735,
-0.0583555885,
-0.0042037894,
0.1150213256,
0.0417088754,
-0.016477678,
-0.004510182,
-0.0200300198,
0.020553885,
0.0013496592,
0.033427082,
-0.0969764441,
-0.0166948754,
0.0150397355,
-0.0212292317,
-0.0038671046,
0.0197855178,
-0.0265913196,
-0.107990019,
0.0730861649,
0.0186075103,
-0.0277044922,
-0.0107523212,
-0.001325725,
-0.0057022953,
-0.0387557261,
0.0054734102,
-0.0254570544,
0.0037530542,
-0.0011626914,
-0.0360097364,
0.0284037236,
0.0004851585,
0.007032169,
-0.0396720767,
0.0077231457,
0.0664684176,
0.0595293678,
0.0100685228,
0.0240338203,
0.0217969865,
0.0314390212,
0.0221599918,
-0.022799762,
-0.0015880642,
0.0204541311,
-0.0230457764,
0.0062159719,
-0.0214765687,
0.0290430542,
-0.0077605341,
0.066176936,
0.0533192009,
0.0006220463,
0.0308058374,
0.0063475389,
-0.0139967734,
-0.0056844112,
0.0643105581,
0.0191686563,
-0.0027248233,
-0.0138652194,
-0.0265377611,
-0.0442081727,
0.0008996389,
0.0125643453,
0.0185291413,
-0.1287874877,
-0.0663566813,
-0.1237391233,
-0.0651486665,
0.0223165192,
0.0012857481,
0.0598257445,
0.0030557597,
0.0038922373,
0.0143546388,
0.0070578335,
-0.0046095499,
-0.0177401435,
0.0178323314,
-0.0128666591,
0.0285419449,
0.0339522548,
-0.0204051342,
0.0083980868,
0.0120246587,
-0.0246144515,
-0.0442120172,
-0.0037539238,
0.0328772552,
0.0180722624,
0.0441691205,
-0.0535529554,
-0.0065541593,
-0.0294461194,
0.0222189538,
-0.0091076847,
0.0044563627,
0.0532820337,
0.0051817996,
-0.0123750493,
0.0499868207,
-0.0151485605,
0.0054153469,
-0.0012717703,
0.0506099835,
-0.0069958256,
-0.0623321123,
0.0614554361,
0.0492329001,
0.0378811285,
-0.0239961427,
-0.026103368,
-0.0363508202,
0.0503676347,
-0.0585026629,
-0.04427604,
-0.0406233147,
0.000759088,
0.0336898491,
0.0035227796,
-0.0125883203,
-0.0150232008,
-0.0627353117,
0.0034346317,
0.0036555745,
-0.0180015918,
-0.0224336199,
0.0298956931,
0.0048521012,
0.0333755575,
-0.0195055995,
0.0163505115,
0.0373841859,
0.0079490086,
-0.0458558612,
0.0640632361,
0.0132822916,
-0.0023617803,
-0.0443814099,
0.0190482177,
-0.0415158272,
0.0068116914,
0.0034827038,
0.0367110446,
0.0807076469,
-0.0288562756,
0.062597163,
-0.0576091669,
-0.0289412066,
0.0220022872,
0.0661373138,
0.0775144026,
-0.0352066681,
-0.014026206,
-0.0144183198,
-0.0089381142,
-0.0296689868,
0.0569947176,
-0.013637309,
0.03469171,
-0.0084132254,
-0.0385424048,
-0.0178997405,
-0.0277729109,
0.0239675641,
-0.0482932962,
-0.0055282009,
-0.0004896579,
-0.0650841072,
-0.0433478691,
-0.0356203355,
0.0056864871,
0.0098209614,
-0.0128029035,
0.0077072955,
0.086895749,
-0.0247495733,
-0.0308110658,
-0.0524303578,
0.0173039548,
-0.0038861712,
0.0132434797,
-0.0030649186,
-6.092066329e-33,
-0.0615957603,
0.0107826367,
0.0096257981,
0.0427531786,
-0.025717387,
-0.0372476093,
-0.031720791,
-0.0148763126,
0.0201419629,
0.0184770077,
-0.0530970991,
-0.00173802,
0.0468275659,
-0.0295590628,
0.0194912646,
-0.0011436712,
0.0575432703,
0.0348389484,
-0.0229803734,
-0.0034016941,
0.0059737577,
-0.0106731551,
0.0567633025,
-0.0194800757,
0.0934222192,
-0.0243231542,
-0.0551517345,
0.0457808301,
-0.0153273726,
0.0234617442,
0.0247921161,
-0.0008354506,
0.0083637033,
-0.0588235259,
-0.0279434454,
0.0036155055,
-0.0920488462,
-0.0366748199,
0.0503940284,
0.0475059077,
0.0320356078,
-0.0750235543,
-0.0273013078,
-0.0522199385,
0.0074849115,
0.0077198134,
0.0238310006,
-0.0643990263,
-0.0234042052,
-0.0251101237,
-0.0853285939,
0.009813902,
-0.0023440414,
0.0150089459,
0.0283497702,
0.0211499631,
-0.0185795911,
-0.0208292659,
0.0069023324,
0.0432296284,
0.0211263821,
0.0245539788,
0.0431893691,
-0.0088470997,
-0.0107545881,
-0.0292412993,
0.0378058851,
0.0098439995,
0.0261919033,
0.0498934388,
-0.0106575778,
0.0166764688,
0.0443221927,
0.098642081,
0.0490138717,
-0.0029492888,
-0.044119738,
0.0223187245,
0.0276920516,
0.0251907427,
0.0065130685,
0.0152357854,
-0.0530622229,
-0.0686316341,
-0.0278954394,
-0.0054619485,
-0.0350992605,
-0.0698676333,
0.043326728,
0.0028242185,
-0.0399432443,
-0.018077543,
0.053263694,
-0.0352494605,
0.0029688091,
-0.0057952246,
-0.0245536212,
0.0204439554,
-0.0494774133,
0.0499881133,
0.016925374,
-0.0344371833,
0.0169114657,
-0.0031463543,
0.0148424227,
0.0179375876,
0.0517497025,
0.011594383,
-0.0295080785,
0.0152971465,
-0.012608462,
-0.0429821089,
-0.0330782942,
-0.0295862984,
-0.0086467722,
0.0349069797,
0.0073628994,
0.0178693458,
0.0767392144,
-0.0086952299,
-0.0708982721,
-0.0103386212,
0.0004982725,
-0.0033609248,
-0.0289222691,
0.0331469923,
-0.0004831953,
-0.011644233,
0.0366250984,
-0.0310268048,
-0.0369194373,
-0.0179202929,
2.943e-7,
0.0370548368,
0.0406660251,
-0.0025175719,
0.0463694744,
-0.0354884267,
-0.0023671738,
-0.0076011731,
0.0223011207,
0.0456221923,
0.0505917966,
0.0900722593,
0.0030125421,
0.0495261662,
0.0149132237,
-0.0999569744,
-0.0049595968,
0.0134126656,
-0.0126581285,
-0.0635942444,
0.0464370213,
0.0850509629,
0.0638149306,
0.0124633489,
0.0222149584,
-0.0415226333,
-0.0329367109,
0.0393770598,
-0.0218022615,
-0.0523819365,
0.0651969835,
0.0832987055,
0.0082135405,
-0.0127555532,
0.0165829565,
-0.0188144296,
0.0010014991,
0.0649927333,
0.0803402364,
-0.0121604297,
-0.0033697865,
-0.0175060183,
-0.0286947768,
0.0111937765,
-0.0538881645,
0.0621350631,
-0.0507329963,
0.0249240883,
0.0115342643,
0.0114110457,
0.0031444828,
-0.0073643662,
-0.0359198377,
-0.0472718813,
0.0140422657,
0.0459579378,
0.0272710659,
-0.032140743,
-0.0475681089,
-0.0605617091,
-0.0263899025,
0.0189279485,
-0.0646873415,
0.0147817601,
0.0083087664,
0.0342528373,
-0.042799592,
-0.0051200204,
2.712270691e-34,
0.0348710567,
0.0020241092,
0.0259735025,
0.0163128991,
0.0361701846,
-0.0042710472,
0.0291740429,
0.0445539728,
0.0009961957,
-0.0383686274,
-0.0561075732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00008v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00008v3 | On the Creativity of Large Language Models | 2023-03-27T18:00:01 | 2023-07-09T18:00:02 | Giorgio Franceschelli, Mirco Musolesi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) are revolutionizing several areas of Artificial
Intelligence. One of the most remarkable applications is creative writing,
e.g., poetry or storytelling: the generated outputs are often of astonishing
quality. However, a natural question arises: can LLMs be really considered
creative? In this article we firstly analyze the development of LLMs under the
lens of creativity theories, investigating the key open questions and
challenges. In particular, we focus our discussion around the dimensions of
value, novelty and surprise as proposed by Margaret Boden in her work. Then, we
consider different classic perspectives, namely product, process, press and
person. We discuss a set of ``easy'' and ``hard'' problems in machine
creativity, presenting them in relation to LLMs. Finally, we examine the
societal impact of these technologies with a particular focus on the creative
industries, analyzing the opportunities offered by them, the challenges arising
by them and the potential associated risks, from both legal and ethical points
of view. | [
0.0516414158,
0.0306875017,
-0.0427487865,
0.0180236585,
-0.0626919866,
0.0136146257,
0.0131735075,
0.0177670065,
-0.0175926704,
-0.0226028115,
0.0047036745,
-0.0243937131,
-0.0165939089,
0.0678553954,
-0.0005999226,
-0.0209271777,
-0.0407514423,
-0.043346554,
0.0335766152,
-0.0230742227,
-0.0261853114,
0.0245424714,
0.0217821263,
0.073141627,
-0.0005419062,
-0.0223035961,
0.0047200699,
0.002683979,
-0.0218022913,
0.0017510608,
-0.0693955794,
0.0421308577,
0.0119825229,
0.0924657211,
0.0000016825,
-0.0826064348,
0.0161272958,
-0.0275750421,
0.023961721,
-0.020968549,
0.0531753562,
0.0050575393,
-0.0578755215,
-0.032656908,
-0.0294965841,
0.03407396,
0.0584975295,
0.0147223109,
0.0347732902,
0.0618222319,
-0.0007125096,
-0.073945567,
0.0433128364,
-0.0347799063,
0.0107931998,
-0.0007267767,
0.0221424084,
0.0000298934,
0.0409237891,
-0.0251002014,
-0.0096147899,
0.03470321,
0.0304893404,
-0.0323459841,
-0.0160306133,
0.0269457716,
0.0130391754,
-0.0355626941,
0.0132701164,
0.0263980273,
-0.0106910998,
-0.0000093355,
0.0049620108,
0.0182699226,
0.0046155644,
-0.013252696,
-0.0426905528,
0.0816702992,
0.0280057099,
0.0363059118,
0.0094277458,
-0.0218370147,
0.0003492588,
0.0059513357,
0.0224153604,
0.0272687562,
0.0278956816,
-0.0101141622,
-0.0130796172,
0.0090288762,
-0.0187605675,
-0.0698929653,
0.0033559995,
0.035239961,
0.0054499912,
0.0075265043,
-0.0497144908,
-0.0258402694,
-0.0145117892,
-0.0883277282,
0.0878313333,
-0.0028621694,
0.0334619768,
0.0471017845,
-0.0027892208,
0.0214108657,
-0.0517897606,
0.0127695985,
-0.0455008559,
0.0221520923,
-0.0432428755,
-0.0404667519,
-0.0457124673,
0.0143881068,
-0.0190296657,
-0.0562276244,
-0.0058895689,
0.0618924312,
0.0134569528,
0.003692863,
-0.0198627319,
0.022642713,
-0.0178485531,
-0.0396952517,
-0.018688187,
-0.0041933339,
0.0084021771,
0.0213319194,
-0.0080771409,
0.0005577958,
0.0296316016,
0.0194034167,
-0.0073925727,
-0.0060389545,
0.0310848802,
0.0746542364,
0.0181175657,
-0.0175870806,
-0.0403646827,
-0.0247910321,
0.0099152513,
-0.065835461,
0.0331984907,
-0.0625705346,
-0.007067475,
0.0088075288,
-0.005100857,
-0.0613504164,
-0.0065139467,
0.0058491267,
-0.0326561183,
-0.009852496,
-0.0061318898,
0.0483593456,
0.0053975526,
-0.0131576769,
0.0285617709,
0.0217690803,
0.1053471938,
0.0434319377,
0.0085955122,
-0.0023499818,
0.0570348017,
0.0169487819,
-0.0478383191,
-0.0027369335,
-0.0627428293,
-0.0377001502,
-0.0132469395,
0.0534838215,
0.0131780673,
0.0630201772,
0.0107178474,
0.0588431098,
0.1025204733,
0.0378811695,
0.0145104071,
0.061424315,
0.0737044737,
-0.0309972074,
0.020380415,
0.0179351512,
0.0328621976,
0.0078242291,
0.0201297533,
0.0195355117,
0.0055932519,
0.0260546263,
-0.0026410159,
-0.0019787804,
0.0081930328,
-0.0054818811,
0.0327706225,
-0.0160518512,
0.0289894659,
0.0162364114,
-0.0116837025,
-0.0098116668,
-0.0206661932,
-0.0249707643,
0.01230295,
-0.0523689874,
0.0679866299,
0.095867306,
0.0472168103,
0.0266699214,
0.087944597,
-0.0044651483,
-0.0388078652,
0.0639562532,
0.0002276267,
-0.0139387948,
-0.0190047696,
0.0270932522,
0.0378412791,
-0.052340243,
0.0062618051,
-0.0086542331,
-0.0583422258,
0.0325772092,
-0.0311181229,
0.003463964,
-0.0272807889,
-0.0053677801,
-0.0451961644,
-0.0323818959,
-0.0104796905,
-0.0045243828,
-0.0083819916,
0.0396203324,
-0.0742263123,
0.0419034734,
0.0314240046,
-0.0509901159,
-0.0358662717,
0.0370103009,
0.0039447602,
0.0349284261,
0.0278585777,
-0.0819003358,
0.0448347814,
-0.0098455418,
0.0299134124,
-0.0096990168,
0.0589990504,
-0.0387436822,
0.0464204997,
-0.0304658748,
0.0403457806,
-0.0316582546,
0.0147106145,
-0.0161918588,
0.043404825,
-0.0109499339,
0.0223757438,
-0.0174737293,
-0.0120276483,
0.0270973742,
-0.0177142471,
-0.04330571,
0.0735016242,
0.0331592448,
0.0398222394,
0.018405905,
0.0032410156,
-0.002058439,
-0.0536108464,
-0.0403232053,
-0.0200709607,
0.0001295768,
-0.0226959623,
-0.0140194343,
-0.0071905158,
-0.0333373994,
0.0119285686,
-0.0332304537,
-0.0365657322,
0.0286126453,
0.010084331,
0.0128084291,
0.016330488,
-0.039897792,
0.0440761521,
-0.0101998532,
0.0240252968,
0.0479849093,
0.0515147522,
0.0119950436,
-0.0610138848,
0.018651953,
-0.053124804,
-0.0011585712,
0.0027745015,
0.0036641976,
0.0102342498,
-0.0347510315,
0.0437330268,
0.0480117463,
-0.01496551,
0.0270041302,
0.0700893104,
-0.0081553375,
0.0334935635,
-0.0220189802,
-0.0089949975,
0.0088966116,
-0.0302693564,
-0.0214256849,
0.0117051462,
0.0075961496,
0.0206102245,
0.0025968468,
-0.0064721322,
0.1137499735,
-0.0165412016,
-0.0244423617,
-0.0033229047,
-0.0447409675,
-0.0360727273,
0.0788758472,
-0.0164501145,
-0.0276261214,
0.0388542339,
-0.0184906274,
0.0142253889,
-0.0188970249,
-0.0111946259,
-0.0222585127,
0.1011446714,
0.0010801849,
0.0588152036,
0.0095468424,
0.0107089924,
-0.049310796,
0.0304338373,
0.0206287615,
-0.0473618954,
0.0042764535,
-0.0070784064,
0.0027184337,
-0.0172224157,
-0.0484229624,
-0.0188981351,
-0.0164228361,
-0.0270289984,
0.0023826447,
0.0793218389,
-0.0049057174,
0.0046965978,
-0.0021528138,
0.0352247693,
0.0072126682,
0.034669999,
0.0163018573,
-0.0154805807,
0.035372179,
0.0388273485,
-0.0046382775,
-0.0014166337,
-0.0082147801,
0.002481543,
-0.0145427398,
-0.0552301481,
0.0481717512,
0.0083356267,
0.0503846593,
0.0230836645,
0.0262042508,
-0.020299945,
0.0093346285,
0.0197832305,
-0.0404715315,
-0.0065805558,
0.0622492358,
0.0113937166,
0.0085944505,
0.0227543823,
0.0042256177,
-0.0492951758,
0.0130354296,
0.047757633,
-0.0389976427,
0.0518020615,
0.0007371345,
-0.0004416752,
-0.0434894264,
-0.0232574791,
-0.0401097909,
-0.0959679037,
0.07366696,
0.0158520862,
-0.037161544,
-0.0254347753,
0.0317550004,
-0.0585451387,
0.0590898059,
-0.0242910907,
0.0182328336,
-0.0140891233,
-0.0008145649,
-0.000302705,
0.0253025796,
-0.0372727737,
-0.0146165658,
-0.026051823,
0.0441048779,
0.0849967077,
0.0424846448,
-0.0368096866,
-0.0449772626,
-0.0507390015,
0.0318032429,
0.0167121962,
0.0247128699,
-0.0126940906,
0.0425715484,
-0.0143456068,
-0.0649607852,
0.0018531898,
0.0209334232,
-0.0319677256,
-0.0220157597,
0.0396097153,
-0.0352874286,
-0.0565428771,
-0.0403384194,
-0.0138833364,
0.0039757933,
0.0466289036,
0.0289258789,
-0.0916407108,
-0.0453393571,
-0.0502456613,
-0.0245952252,
-0.0643446892,
-0.0611086041,
-0.0063952547,
0.0077032382,
-0.0521324947,
-0.0572449118,
-0.0046829274,
-0.0382997394,
0.0779962763,
0.0512565747,
0.0041391733,
-0.0294849388,
-0.0243599303,
-0.026510397,
-0.012347783,
-0.0101976618,
-0.0120114163,
-0.0531999134,
-0.0065635,
-0.0163374916,
-0.0841967613,
-0.0084881978,
-0.0167079028,
-0.1140393689,
-0.0525746308,
0.0144625986,
0.0088954931,
0.0314909332,
-0.0002090735,
0.0154320039,
-0.100053668,
0.0715486109,
0.0236508492,
0.0121905534,
0.0575903654,
-0.0132191638,
0.0350566246,
0.0024873661,
0.0186673757,
-0.0246076696,
0.0131159928,
0.0517044067,
0.0159919709,
0.0272648651,
-0.0304501224,
0.0188875869,
0.0264158249,
-0.0350789391,
-0.0432096012,
0.0177521147,
-0.0475388914,
-0.0363428555,
-0.0171514489,
-0.0244187117,
-0.0494370982,
-0.014508687,
0.02616309,
-0.0029547662,
-0.0213765111,
-0.001124323,
-0.0081399381,
0.0237783715,
-0.0428597443,
-0.0098435329,
0.0206820499,
0.0158602614,
0.0424117334,
0.0023255555,
-0.0137885101,
0.08403451,
-0.0573665649,
0.0382605828,
0.0202546567,
0.0233467668,
0.0249320101,
-0.0265836604,
-0.0047867219,
0.0450524837,
-0.0455069393,
-0.0942893848,
-0.0251654871,
0.0682604313,
0.0821047351,
0.0125965495,
0.0175943729,
-0.0409251526,
0.0014745283,
-0.0301030129,
0.0104908245,
0.0013247476,
-0.0625833869,
-0.063623473,
0.0022283948,
-0.022643948,
-0.0152246198,
0.0613214523,
-0.0403720587,
0.0090005258,
-0.0057505616,
-0.0058348668,
-0.0120466184,
-0.0188251212,
0.0138612213,
-0.0152161298,
0.0262989253,
0.0339456648,
-0.0820077285,
-0.0470466241,
0.0463938564,
0.0262411702,
0.0311795846,
-0.019233482,
-0.0002569158,
0.0608383529,
-0.0029313979,
0.0093212062,
-0.052565217,
0.0098076006,
-0.0355341472,
-0.0196653474,
-0.0120935589,
-5.446333854e-33,
-0.0020297512,
-0.0195592549,
-0.004454372,
-0.0169336759,
-0.0364273526,
-0.039932657,
-0.0556378961,
0.0224269684,
0.0011805292,
0.0216885041,
-0.0245266296,
-0.0439756289,
-0.0076135159,
-0.0153000588,
0.0158670545,
-0.0085510807,
0.0506995283,
-0.0023291407,
-0.0283277016,
0.0027908748,
0.0247772541,
-0.0038625705,
-0.0007884938,
-0.0467375964,
0.0293409787,
-0.0427556932,
-0.0517908223,
-0.0096783899,
0.0176949594,
0.0450950935,
-0.0213401634,
0.0607205667,
0.0318015553,
-0.0390271954,
-0.0267885029,
-0.0144121991,
0.0360812992,
-0.0123965004,
-0.0180305727,
-0.0030729785,
0.0393773839,
-0.0749735981,
0.0606506653,
-0.0253554545,
-0.0452171862,
0.0403588004,
0.0209167451,
-0.0340305381,
-0.0246326663,
-0.0596685186,
-0.0835676864,
-0.0245361738,
-0.0068259188,
-0.0147495614,
0.0153548801,
-0.0581651889,
0.0003065557,
-0.0118114278,
-0.0472400486,
0.0727190673,
-0.0171309151,
-0.0043885242,
0.0484672077,
-0.0037513438,
0.039706327,
0.0530119538,
0.0221121442,
0.0461721271,
-0.0315789245,
0.0431606546,
0.0042266939,
0.0848806351,
0.0313666165,
0.0571990497,
-0.0094345538,
-0.0012688698,
0.0202010442,
-0.0126578426,
-0.0026480388,
-0.0404128544,
0.0451260731,
0.007643437,
-0.0289579257,
-0.0486978963,
-0.0032165765,
-0.0604954995,
-0.0166213699,
-0.0014578893,
0.0011672543,
-0.0155964056,
0.0075549185,
-0.015518832,
0.0267792251,
-0.0749553367,
-0.0267351624,
-0.0097753927,
-0.0419418514,
0.0535587184,
-0.0018482334,
-0.0072221016,
-0.0009601748,
-0.0331407934,
0.0213049985,
0.0261631925,
0.0165577829,
0.0218328089,
-0.0227157958,
0.0448265858,
-0.0160419904,
0.0006094899,
-0.0028931515,
0.0232003666,
0.0716513842,
-0.0187997892,
0.0227402598,
-0.0184644386,
0.000354171,
-0.0355584212,
0.0392503552,
0.0015350849,
0.0044194134,
-0.0173404664,
-0.0160899181,
0.0048848544,
-0.0343971103,
0.0310950354,
-0.0192153715,
0.0214029066,
0.0886025205,
-0.0363046974,
-0.0265739448,
-0.0225861091,
2.621e-7,
0.0130352788,
0.0010884086,
0.0137696024,
0.0357050523,
0.0403453298,
0.0427524596,
-0.0387884825,
0.0444570445,
-0.0046814783,
0.0355989002,
0.0139085324,
0.0048807701,
0.0279239397,
0.0127977189,
-0.10083808,
0.0441309847,
-0.083634086,
0.0230668597,
-0.0889511779,
-0.0132455397,
0.0535483249,
0.0353408568,
0.0460692011,
-0.0486188419,
-0.0104733976,
-0.0533840507,
0.0216219034,
-0.0291416161,
0.0315917209,
-0.0213598013,
0.0233277604,
0.014253756,
-0.0175945535,
-0.0284923315,
0.0044688974,
0.0326528326,
0.0355906487,
0.035795033,
0.0073182182,
0.0150145655,
0.0267108977,
-0.0381468236,
-0.0011979452,
-0.0378045887,
0.0546772629,
0.0198817067,
-0.0369325876,
-0.0506928228,
0.0354262516,
-0.0264019445,
0.019785298,
-0.0439105518,
0.0119924368,
-0.0085195452,
0.0176153537,
0.0106841726,
0.0458701961,
-0.024281675,
-0.0093593877,
-0.0115994383,
-0.055925142,
-0.032071799,
-0.0090077305,
0.0167682786,
0.0399064496,
-0.08338397,
0.0164959803,
2.165770511e-34,
0.0304326732,
-0.0274507478,
-0.004078465,
0.0175133459,
0.0054097385,
0.0477084741,
0.0109194759,
-0.0156125017,
-0.0166344475,
-0.0552017465,
-0.051301267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15445v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15445v3 | IRFL: Image Recognition of Figurative Language | 2023-03-27T17:59:55 | 2023-11-25T22:07:55 | Ron Yosef, Yonatan Bitton, Dafna Shahaf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Figures of speech such as metaphors, similes, and idioms are integral parts
of human communication. They are ubiquitous in many forms of discourse,
allowing people to convey complex, abstract ideas and evoke emotion. As
figurative forms are often conveyed through multiple modalities (e.g., both
text and images), understanding multimodal figurative language is an important
AI challenge, weaving together profound vision, language, commonsense and
cultural knowledge. In this work, we develop the Image Recognition of
Figurative Language (IRFL) dataset. We leverage human annotation and an
automatic pipeline we created to generate a multimodal dataset, and introduce
two novel tasks as a benchmark for multimodal figurative language
understanding. We experimented with state-of-the-art vision and language models
and found that the best (22%) performed substantially worse than humans (97%).
We release our dataset, benchmark, and code, in hopes of driving the
development of models that can better understand figurative language. | [
0.0224998016,
0.0507991873,
-0.0174801648,
0.0708180517,
-0.0155288009,
0.0305993594,
-0.0120027214,
0.0020630595,
0.0370037183,
-0.0756935626,
-0.0306079555,
0.0099522518,
0.0395345725,
-0.0062394682,
0.0224173442,
-0.0997201875,
-0.0132474368,
0.0112969503,
0.0002228175,
0.0035605635,
-0.0080101201,
0.0433086902,
-0.0130495913,
0.0644657835,
-0.0612799339,
-0.0235615652,
0.0209736526,
0.0490148999,
0.0349517465,
-0.0382738821,
-0.0401984528,
-0.0016297096,
0.0522163548,
-0.0044056484,
0.0000016809,
-0.0218660478,
0.0557790548,
-0.0123895109,
0.0374682583,
-0.012268913,
0.092975907,
-0.0257544853,
0.0004590001,
-0.0342908874,
-0.034589082,
0.0172767211,
0.0428286493,
0.0684627071,
0.0622991137,
0.0443010554,
-0.0101825073,
-0.0349733233,
-0.0270724539,
0.0103991227,
-0.0143137146,
-0.0332889333,
0.0144246239,
0.0101584503,
-0.0100403,
-0.0495273732,
-0.0845574811,
0.0283083282,
0.0207515992,
0.0421288386,
-0.0595050678,
0.0352476537,
-0.0489566624,
0.0028022232,
-0.0318409689,
0.0938169956,
0.0227608383,
-0.0068660816,
-0.0267515406,
-0.0068757925,
-0.0122334687,
0.0221734121,
-0.0174591057,
0.0473851785,
-0.0022304696,
0.0363010541,
-0.0496990792,
-0.0134833604,
-0.014878829,
0.0171305519,
0.0172029193,
-0.0336123556,
-0.01776818,
0.053229142,
0.0081683397,
-0.0205526929,
-0.0899576247,
-0.0235062521,
-0.0156316031,
-0.0218549911,
0.0195120573,
0.0086042602,
-0.0395643786,
-0.0568990931,
-0.0015465723,
-0.0588781051,
0.068217814,
0.0254648495,
-0.0440737382,
0.0729434639,
-0.0179593284,
0.0092615876,
-0.00869093,
0.0643873662,
-0.0145735228,
-0.0229380429,
-0.0392653123,
0.0126551911,
-0.0424150042,
-0.0322828144,
-0.0409338623,
-0.0533181913,
-0.0268895347,
-0.032580547,
-0.0431988612,
-0.0035926572,
-0.0010153314,
0.0465909205,
-0.029069826,
-0.0286174156,
-0.0272127837,
-0.0040277117,
-0.018997252,
0.0324693359,
-0.0575620197,
-0.0874631554,
0.0084885936,
0.0448336266,
0.0214670133,
-0.0406386666,
0.0196610205,
0.0880385563,
-0.0121195167,
-0.0603231229,
-0.0203990191,
-0.0251869876,
-0.0062128492,
-0.025523806,
-0.004113453,
-0.0146864289,
0.0445393622,
-0.0594689101,
0.0435414091,
-0.0835609809,
0.01950242,
0.0060958886,
-0.0111701237,
0.0845729411,
-0.0074305325,
-0.0196589492,
0.014007153,
0.0041761342,
-0.0651916191,
0.0579798929,
0.0590452477,
0.0375398807,
0.031457264,
-0.0014099745,
-0.0333923995,
0.0147527065,
-0.0314527415,
-0.0034688348,
-0.0591865145,
-0.0103841145,
-0.0318587348,
0.0699612424,
0.0303010922,
0.0315459967,
-0.030424824,
-0.0575391911,
0.0426679477,
0.0706066415,
-0.0481406525,
-0.021883091,
0.0849637091,
0.021353079,
0.0234170333,
0.0004192092,
-0.0144226719,
0.0341417082,
0.0410451405,
-0.0270888675,
-0.0167199802,
0.0597985685,
-0.0159911439,
0.0264094565,
-0.0248295572,
-0.0123937409,
-0.0104970038,
-0.0010744692,
0.0293376073,
0.0351423621,
-0.0282594711,
0.0058024274,
0.0260064229,
-0.0224642958,
-0.0398225151,
0.0137227494,
-0.0156883523,
0.0505688824,
0.0268935394,
-0.0340012088,
0.0367215089,
0.0034160842,
0.043313127,
0.0680619553,
-0.0100844316,
0.0195072349,
0.0446861349,
-0.0322850458,
0.0246558264,
-0.0102864066,
0.0089642834,
0.0182819888,
-0.0077539296,
0.0304290596,
-0.0188041143,
-0.018747123,
-0.0191465337,
0.0425875708,
-0.0169266146,
0.0027462216,
-0.0153143443,
0.0293271653,
0.0182696842,
-0.0037470576,
-0.0416031554,
-0.0344190262,
0.0125552062,
-0.0705440715,
-0.022649128,
0.1034354493,
-0.038029056,
0.0045125573,
0.0472996235,
-0.1179990098,
-0.0224588327,
0.0261012167,
-0.0193058681,
-0.0077206744,
0.0512285046,
-0.0332864597,
0.0334273167,
-0.064532347,
-0.043633841,
0.016755525,
0.0716304258,
0.0255518518,
0.0251949951,
-0.0262899045,
-0.019806724,
-0.0370996073,
-0.0234536305,
-0.0068363012,
0.0222117491,
0.0000645064,
0.0023725545,
0.017327534,
0.0149956243,
-0.0389084928,
-0.0202977359,
-0.0625176504,
0.014994815,
-0.0939227715,
-0.0125228241,
-0.0050408905,
-0.0553926863,
0.0007891026,
-0.0471381508,
-0.0289780851,
-0.0316457003,
0.0008379925,
0.026090974,
-0.0222352482,
-0.0030808668,
0.0249423478,
-0.0172523987,
-0.0048865965,
-0.0082370751,
0.0108959768,
-0.0156552549,
0.0734289885,
-0.0010624578,
0.0085460031,
0.0239201877,
-0.0227351971,
-0.0350798182,
0.0214872491,
-0.0128123872,
-0.03381145,
0.0035710661,
0.008154952,
0.0322249681,
0.0540330186,
0.0243551545,
0.0293653701,
0.0229786169,
-0.0250122547,
-0.0069299755,
-0.0037421696,
0.0677781254,
0.0240402594,
-0.0175762456,
-0.0485104248,
-0.026786143,
0.0313522406,
0.028546365,
0.0241580177,
-0.0467565209,
0.0343088768,
0.0017572454,
-0.0488155931,
-0.0028321717,
0.0481000729,
-0.0121459775,
0.0177574921,
-0.0388972722,
0.0180709884,
0.0261533931,
-0.0352090038,
-0.0247249492,
0.0418954864,
0.0094823958,
-0.0221185125,
0.0728557855,
-0.0017831264,
0.0372447334,
-0.0186188053,
0.0091846064,
0.0052355747,
-0.0180672519,
0.0363047011,
-0.0150319934,
0.0367992334,
-0.0349125192,
0.0002573665,
-0.0188136194,
-0.0075297989,
-0.0041905362,
-0.0086460905,
-0.0521925204,
-0.0316605605,
-0.0542238206,
-0.0148804579,
-0.0239458792,
-0.0498307236,
-0.0077013038,
0.0178987868,
0.0141961351,
-0.0170510095,
-0.0251884349,
0.0269624628,
0.0396844409,
0.0393389538,
-0.0182660632,
0.0020647733,
0.0176818538,
0.0396810286,
-0.0495054685,
-0.0012622687,
-0.0701406971,
0.0343278013,
-0.0082141925,
0.0150997946,
0.0370364599,
0.0077190907,
0.0475435108,
-0.0204582755,
-0.0052080727,
0.0293875076,
0.0077214628,
-0.0330180712,
0.0182439107,
-0.004732389,
0.0108984066,
0.0513312556,
-0.0147559214,
-0.0987975821,
-0.0712646991,
0.0013434209,
-0.0242771115,
0.0195819195,
-0.0699983761,
-0.0282576345,
-0.0765593275,
0.041190505,
-0.0223796777,
-0.0214715172,
-0.0007404021,
0.0298973788,
0.0086199613,
0.0059521887,
0.0131545719,
-0.0283615626,
0.007621944,
-0.0079280753,
0.0055529526,
0.0339551158,
-0.0265954267,
0.0273406263,
-0.0189443715,
0.0075979936,
-0.0547225401,
0.0603718683,
-0.0002358431,
-0.0468821041,
-0.0217939708,
0.0028400696,
-0.0033745042,
-0.0134431981,
0.0275527164,
-0.0161379017,
-0.028721936,
0.0272615962,
0.0340657346,
-0.032735467,
-0.0377924182,
0.0061251186,
0.0369133614,
-0.0122408308,
-0.0026257318,
-0.0402985588,
0.0240254272,
-0.0098815309,
0.0504545122,
0.0449543037,
-0.0516948029,
-0.0193230119,
-0.0255489983,
-0.0009443626,
-0.053051006,
-0.0412591249,
0.0000829548,
-0.015257244,
0.0053905128,
-0.0621243939,
-0.0005697324,
0.0210906751,
0.0490909144,
0.0245896038,
-0.0288707782,
-0.0318497606,
0.0186334662,
-0.0889499709,
0.0721584558,
-0.0316672623,
0.0248470381,
0.0084489053,
-0.0078365626,
0.0284815188,
-0.0547023155,
-0.0073435474,
0.0817169994,
-0.0643661842,
-0.0413962528,
-0.0080204746,
0.04039298,
0.0074426401,
0.0022187138,
0.0138757443,
-0.0427641794,
0.0200405214,
0.0604147762,
0.0060159797,
0.0231706798,
0.0035523777,
0.0281068534,
0.0030670147,
0.0579728447,
0.0199492667,
0.0302762929,
0.0115209557,
0.0040719202,
-0.0075126141,
0.0458521843,
-0.0023963989,
0.0106127318,
-0.0120805521,
-0.0251227897,
-0.0434817858,
-0.0235532913,
-0.0459502973,
-0.0217831936,
-0.0304008685,
-0.0356245525,
0.0223640855,
0.0207499024,
-0.0006007262,
-0.0468815044,
-0.0338697433,
0.0338695422,
0.0024337689,
0.0307498146,
0.0045042587,
0.1087541059,
-0.0086128898,
-0.0546961389,
0.0168960299,
0.0047068968,
-0.0112781245,
-0.0619307123,
0.0439532101,
0.0157110952,
0.0296030808,
0.0166986063,
-0.0254537445,
-0.027203165,
0.0177194793,
0.0376828723,
-0.0345451534,
0.0123637272,
0.0335844532,
0.0779216737,
-0.0086652488,
0.0505939759,
-0.0331098512,
0.0077493452,
0.0286192261,
0.0343910679,
-0.0183662027,
-0.0296022426,
0.0159940496,
0.0104523525,
0.0054505728,
0.0021198629,
0.0104461825,
-0.0700871199,
0.0235383734,
0.037283279,
-0.0311800819,
-0.0620911121,
-0.0285503194,
0.0240441486,
0.0062837908,
0.0600606874,
0.0536973402,
-0.0424127281,
-0.080635041,
0.073784709,
0.0135448435,
0.0099003725,
0.0380129851,
0.0227899645,
0.0105661144,
0.040701475,
0.0218786597,
-0.028824605,
-0.0181633271,
-0.0469083488,
0.0154840266,
-0.0140082361,
-5.410611683e-33,
-0.0429794453,
-0.0132956337,
-0.0286476687,
-0.0214666817,
-0.0194323808,
0.0299395751,
-0.0434818938,
0.0073589478,
-0.0068683391,
0.0324838012,
0.0148089575,
-0.0125962002,
0.0039531845,
0.0321122706,
0.0352705643,
0.0413223393,
0.0001431016,
-0.0048047374,
-0.0490026996,
-0.0302274134,
0.0769797564,
0.0219732206,
0.0809165612,
-0.064958632,
-0.0263328198,
0.0522510856,
-0.0459308848,
0.0004609907,
0.0508273393,
0.0518118627,
-0.0514463782,
0.058926966,
0.0049567563,
0.0384238847,
-0.0125762429,
0.0202258509,
-0.0539853759,
-0.0127364909,
0.0108398618,
0.0477668494,
-0.0600639246,
0.0022986999,
0.0538097359,
-0.0255740732,
0.0010105902,
0.0004223209,
0.0692276135,
-0.0204224698,
0.0207156036,
-0.00382939,
-0.0297746416,
0.0125716012,
-0.0453571379,
-0.0185562745,
0.0143090039,
0.0111076329,
0.0141344648,
0.0464512557,
-0.0725825429,
0.0239363573,
-0.0957473367,
-0.0412108675,
0.0137858987,
-0.0063403575,
0.0370518081,
0.1051896065,
0.0055873841,
-0.0261937194,
-0.0056680171,
0.0189431384,
0.0426223055,
0.0322371759,
0.0104785142,
0.0921605527,
0.0471589081,
-0.0048495922,
0.0055513224,
-0.0080170101,
0.0390022583,
0.0349213444,
0.0382700004,
-0.0013807337,
-0.0052056313,
0.0482233427,
-0.0081085246,
-0.0356306955,
-0.0017675469,
0.0040846197,
0.0195424911,
-0.0072206147,
-0.0143593475,
0.0466345809,
0.0541608408,
-0.0232945923,
-0.013833968,
-0.0050256597,
-0.0184440259,
0.047114525,
0.0156759564,
0.0047338768,
0.0042747296,
-0.0310730133,
0.0449729636,
0.0055102156,
0.0627287552,
-0.006454533,
0.0761164427,
0.0207931846,
-0.0477362871,
-0.0034046669,
-0.0286301263,
0.0100197624,
-0.0310514718,
0.0125773158,
0.0116001265,
0.0224439967,
-0.0545474701,
-0.0165412314,
-0.0048131836,
-0.0189147796,
-0.0159747582,
0.0157045219,
-0.0074535217,
0.0065559801,
-0.0399400033,
0.0073804087,
-0.0327655412,
-0.096329093,
0.004778103,
-0.0800469443,
-0.0016391857,
0.0031525537,
2.439e-7,
0.0204439778,
0.0070318682,
0.0371273234,
0.066863887,
0.0322892219,
0.0223545805,
-0.0155018438,
0.0461795852,
-0.0435711369,
-0.0385938808,
0.0042802743,
0.0448212773,
0.0221035853,
0.0192360803,
-0.0701606944,
0.0135182226,
-0.0281901937,
0.025254285,
-0.043212913,
-0.0199694782,
0.0500680022,
0.0544982292,
0.0262888782,
-0.0344767906,
0.0191367082,
-0.0313125513,
0.0684824362,
-0.0601287074,
0.054030586,
-0.0428852476,
0.0101702893,
0.0163601562,
-0.0097791785,
0.0106378878,
0.0159303304,
-0.0271552838,
0.0445582345,
0.0211828109,
-0.0494830087,
-0.050589066,
-0.0266604442,
0.001064223,
-0.0157677401,
0.0000746417,
0.0357241407,
-0.0034427242,
-0.051702138,
-0.0442203395,
-0.014143141,
-0.0049032453,
0.0742311776,
-0.0036170832,
-0.0439551249,
0.0357135832,
0.0610376447,
-0.0476563461,
-0.014439716,
-0.071913898,
-0.0035479856,
-0.0054512806,
-0.0562130734,
0.0502889119,
0.0033728422,
-0.0035507032,
-0.0088510038,
-0.078452453,
-0.0489382595,
1.491201024e-34,
0.0139199216,
0.0058542979,
0.0169066079,
0.0191017948,
0.0406715609,
-0.0041839792,
0.014462335,
-0.0038741454,
-0.0223764945,
-0.0152633833,
-0.0213031955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15441v1 | Zero-shot Model Diagnosis | 2023-03-27T17:59:33 | 2023-03-27T17:59:33 | Jinqi Luo, Zhaoning Wang, Chen Henry Wu, Dong Huang, Fernando De la Torre | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | When it comes to deploying deep vision models, the behavior of these systems
must be explicable to ensure confidence in their reliability and fairness. A
common approach to evaluate deep learning models is to build a labeled test set
with attributes of interest and assess how well it performs. However, creating
a balanced test set (i.e., one that is uniformly sampled over all the important
traits) is often time-consuming, expensive, and prone to mistakes. The question
we try to address is: can we evaluate the sensitivity of deep learning models
to arbitrary visual attributes without an annotated test set? This paper argues
the case that Zero-shot Model Diagnosis (ZOOM) is possible without the need for
a test set nor labeling. To avoid the need for test sets, our system relies on
a generative model and CLIP. The key idea is enabling the user to select a set
of prompts (relevant to the problem) and our system will automatically search
for semantic counterfactual images (i.e., synthesized images that flip the
prediction in the case of a binary classifier) using the generative model. We
evaluate several visual tasks (classification, key-point detection, and
segmentation) in multiple visual domains to demonstrate the viability of our
methodology. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method is capable of
producing counterfactual images and offering sensitivity analysis for model
diagnosis without the need for a test set. | [
-0.0447557345,
0.0453936681,
-0.00332207,
0.0444964431,
-0.0486763902,
0.020729227,
0.0332406536,
-0.0001329327,
-0.0021123108,
-0.0309974328,
0.0441395193,
-0.0120561812,
-0.0418327041,
0.0977203026,
0.0119607588,
-0.0213002246,
0.0456208549,
0.0165904965,
-0.0164431985,
-0.0074442956,
-0.0350850448,
-0.0180344861,
-0.0125046019,
0.032877814,
-0.058010336,
-0.0379659981,
-0.0262189582,
0.0285788458,
0.0460741967,
0.0247507598,
0.0029283736,
0.0117997108,
-0.0384581648,
0.0232169908,
0.0000021745,
-0.0136077404,
-0.004708562,
0.0225818679,
-0.0642307252,
-0.0187580939,
-0.0051444368,
-0.0053563258,
-0.0175102707,
0.0090484051,
-0.0210972037,
-0.0061625913,
0.0658249483,
0.0404481292,
0.0420242362,
0.0058558979,
0.0005086404,
0.0042435387,
0.0295443255,
-0.0092930058,
-0.0029932826,
-0.0394273549,
-0.0138548324,
-0.0208994821,
-0.045819819,
-0.0224101171,
-0.0114684803,
0.0366933011,
0.0713087842,
0.0062100352,
0.0230081901,
0.0192750115,
-0.0277246255,
-0.0386613645,
-0.0096758427,
0.023801636,
-0.0832032785,
-0.0195356738,
0.0092841685,
-0.062614046,
0.0058529982,
0.0009235552,
0.0005545748,
0.0092420364,
0.0132764624,
-0.0024684265,
-0.0795251653,
0.000307005,
0.0381248668,
-0.0218185671,
-0.0440760553,
0.0022157661,
0.0005243963,
0.0419965796,
-0.0605826303,
0.0297699571,
-0.0266933572,
-0.0513025708,
-0.0089762909,
0.0029906118,
-0.0391315557,
-0.0337728895,
-0.0445990749,
-0.0107905548,
0.0126874167,
0.0043171546,
0.0664175078,
-0.0227012429,
-0.0762259513,
0.0561526828,
-0.0591539554,
0.0404594988,
-0.0234996248,
0.0587049834,
-0.0092193,
-0.0278831683,
-0.0163188949,
-0.0019618324,
0.0248448607,
-0.020205114,
-0.0024149262,
-0.0188623313,
0.0095549226,
-0.022085093,
-0.0709609538,
0.0211060196,
-0.0118575236,
0.0447501354,
-0.0262710005,
-0.0304234046,
-0.0158721805,
0.0073095472,
-0.025818821,
-0.001613955,
0.0212495197,
-0.0881611034,
-0.0209311489,
0.0345006771,
-0.0051186834,
0.0209076442,
0.0240091924,
0.0793265179,
-0.0249620359,
-0.0037575457,
-0.0425322019,
-0.0387763381,
-0.0240678824,
-0.0299170427,
0.0405497774,
-0.0395816043,
-0.05498752,
-0.0107610477,
0.0295210611,
-0.0184379853,
0.0024364193,
-0.0137996003,
-0.0002442751,
0.0896202177,
0.0132763945,
-0.0289530009,
0.0087181702,
-0.0056462996,
-0.0092860088,
0.0820471272,
0.0136666438,
0.02860949,
0.0072673494,
-0.004370023,
0.0838553011,
0.0095693963,
0.0426483154,
0.0148530193,
-0.0776265487,
-0.0215601102,
-0.0082342401,
-0.0042181807,
-0.005031283,
-0.0147769554,
0.0225163363,
-0.0724129006,
0.0121618975,
0.0071273413,
-0.0165298562,
-0.0149964541,
0.0242387895,
-0.0200048964,
-0.0728346035,
0.0010713428,
-0.0457840227,
0.0359029397,
-0.0353524424,
-0.0184726827,
-0.0385209322,
-0.0181661006,
-0.0394067802,
-0.0462110452,
-0.0260286145,
-0.0129220085,
-0.0247555282,
0.0350603797,
0.0686513707,
0.0087820413,
-0.0040403437,
0.0056559653,
-0.002934824,
-0.006073691,
-0.0242343955,
-0.1212352291,
0.00527188,
0.032221362,
0.001902075,
-0.0401336625,
-0.0386333317,
0.032628499,
-0.0144908456,
-0.0162050705,
0.0160325468,
0.0101005351,
0.0353452116,
-0.0008964112,
-0.0453494228,
-0.0329700708,
0.0375354737,
0.0134875048,
0.0012823057,
-0.0127997547,
0.037948586,
-0.0571675487,
0.0098844161,
0.0363872126,
0.0037575024,
-0.0058854623,
0.0569979325,
0.0558310337,
0.0085560167,
0.0146166142,
-0.0109743662,
-0.0268494822,
0.0417521782,
-0.0079665529,
-0.0116919391,
-0.00144219,
0.0183665417,
0.0165561214,
0.0007158061,
-0.0763410553,
-0.0310533531,
0.0820054784,
-0.0604789406,
-0.0353194438,
0.0381068662,
0.0126492465,
-0.0281574819,
-0.0112672728,
0.0027303477,
-0.0242402609,
0.0182651393,
-0.0013300915,
0.0179485846,
-0.0044976976,
-0.0292857718,
-0.0162146296,
-0.0024583049,
0.0540526025,
-0.0365805514,
-0.0444483012,
-0.0141470553,
-0.0429725796,
-0.0308062602,
-0.0130538829,
-0.0104833031,
-0.0198571943,
0.0631339699,
-0.0418144912,
0.0036065953,
-0.0381712504,
-0.0237984844,
-0.0118697649,
-0.0250912458,
0.0261313077,
-0.0512807146,
-0.0215427224,
0.0277243219,
0.0184737425,
-0.0012631154,
0.0074486276,
0.0172737967,
0.0049680066,
0.004394195,
-0.0331068262,
-0.0091383494,
0.048304379,
0.0288031828,
0.0204647556,
-0.0120628541,
0.0119094029,
0.0270645954,
0.042572964,
-0.0061094165,
-0.0177566484,
0.0223757531,
-0.0077360929,
-0.0635248795,
0.1337385029,
0.0037670408,
0.0294834133,
0.0008493292,
0.0659496263,
-0.0091370353,
-0.0047765258,
0.0026619651,
-0.0040184003,
0.0463701896,
-0.0434893332,
-0.0625353232,
0.0053266454,
-0.0209830385,
-0.0156953037,
-0.0638812855,
0.0381866917,
0.0186767764,
-0.0458277054,
-0.0456987619,
0.035251651,
0.0300329495,
0.0434010103,
-0.0255446173,
-0.0385174528,
0.0493553728,
-0.0128974682,
0.0216652956,
0.0599855594,
-0.0141580952,
0.0305625852,
0.0663924888,
0.0432735123,
-0.0130148111,
0.0345384702,
-0.0055561056,
-0.0177044496,
-0.0122510977,
0.0297289919,
0.0108370809,
0.0078798281,
-0.0684643909,
-0.0074397279,
-0.0429595299,
-0.0494831614,
-0.0510512218,
-0.0262795165,
-0.0075069675,
0.0541890152,
-0.0219052844,
-0.0128356852,
-0.0380561873,
0.0362513326,
-0.0396054871,
0.068965368,
-0.0004502871,
0.0065042712,
-0.0197012704,
0.0108042918,
0.029968299,
0.0030680329,
0.0287216082,
-0.0208448432,
-0.0339240991,
0.0095068682,
0.0093409531,
0.053712599,
-0.0943158716,
0.0015946523,
-0.0095272828,
0.0203144755,
0.0196654573,
-0.00984318,
0.0176455285,
-0.0534280278,
-0.0131151071,
0.0038222645,
-0.0087283785,
-0.0281467084,
-0.0022601821,
0.0301112533,
-0.0079529127,
0.0299355611,
-0.0266893841,
-0.0714641809,
-0.0512249097,
0.0271282457,
0.0055493889,
-0.0260559041,
0.0057739872,
0.0402775779,
-0.0989928469,
0.0669411048,
-0.0359180011,
-0.0020310178,
-0.0379074551,
0.0187560599,
0.0040442976,
-0.0741280988,
-0.0211139545,
-0.029316267,
0.027622167,
-0.0035678821,
-0.0120046986,
0.0398948416,
-0.0358086303,
0.0246536937,
-0.050449606,
0.0158644281,
0.0776721463,
-0.0358954705,
-0.0021876008,
-0.015454717,
0.0086267786,
0.0050505255,
0.0247478299,
0.0266812015,
0.0802615657,
-0.0115135834,
-0.0373758972,
0.0285275802,
0.0347192697,
-0.0033387025,
0.0222286992,
-0.0233548898,
0.0208115727,
0.0029611411,
-0.0040702033,
-0.0708020553,
-0.0401832759,
0.030567646,
0.0437825099,
0.0176840853,
-0.0088925865,
-0.0567501597,
0.0068682735,
0.0338955261,
-0.0794438869,
-0.0226385035,
0.0108365854,
0.0430488549,
-0.0477443561,
-0.0083629498,
-0.0014866189,
0.0006314584,
0.0355454348,
-0.0234429576,
-0.1141073555,
-0.0403304249,
0.0531749465,
-0.0783156753,
0.0463947132,
0.0206554718,
0.0494556352,
-0.0643786639,
0.0112323109,
0.0448861048,
-0.0165350754,
-0.0491071492,
0.0436119996,
-0.0561070926,
-0.0296394546,
-0.0125496984,
0.0709869564,
0.0114715733,
0.0315976478,
-0.0331046246,
-0.0326081887,
0.0447955355,
0.0726212263,
0.0311126262,
-0.0192404613,
0.0637096092,
-0.0704311579,
-0.0525991544,
0.0240715053,
-0.01771589,
0.0454151034,
0.0205159727,
-0.0430837683,
-0.0481298231,
-0.0013484034,
-0.0024846764,
-0.0351871252,
0.1125614271,
-0.0186577737,
-0.003379192,
-0.0098416423,
0.0220389348,
0.0351826847,
0.0082984138,
-0.0406009331,
0.0359770916,
-0.0127772344,
-0.0265258569,
0.0285632797,
0.0233392902,
-0.005011356,
0.0046368861,
-0.0395985022,
0.002887303,
0.0454574339,
0.000509327,
-0.0197650436,
0.01162377,
0.0100430707,
0.0013627056,
0.0289349016,
0.0371518135,
0.0213044286,
0.0185523257,
0.0450621657,
0.046948649,
-0.0336845033,
0.0142424908,
-0.0145963775,
-0.018900048,
-0.0604270399,
0.0768658072,
0.0350701474,
-0.0016440038,
-0.0105008259,
-0.0122027127,
-0.032181628,
-0.0356658362,
0.0225457121,
0.0372488238,
-0.0254762806,
0.0226516072,
0.0256048739,
0.0273278058,
-0.0326730274,
0.0462416671,
0.0448349975,
0.0336181149,
-0.044378005,
0.0147522343,
-0.0259649288,
-0.0098039294,
0.0502674505,
-0.0124640921,
0.0223048758,
0.0210240465,
-0.0417890623,
-0.0759120584,
-0.0234425794,
0.0491864122,
0.0478395224,
0.0228984561,
0.0085945791,
0.0579155944,
0.0133158332,
-0.0465545617,
-0.0036188583,
0.0253508035,
-0.0189770367,
0.0294438619,
-0.0236159284,
-6.273421598e-33,
-0.0066382848,
-0.0421936512,
0.0091601163,
-0.0446687452,
0.0644492209,
-0.0026393146,
0.0077547599,
0.0056738206,
-0.0552181862,
0.0461048558,
-0.0083558103,
0.0406960398,
0.0156719983,
0.0432461575,
0.0302160606,
-0.0293291211,
0.0670297146,
-0.0118902307,
-0.0213198438,
0.0200191475,
0.0024789346,
-0.0194973983,
0.0161098093,
-0.0481424518,
-0.0542422198,
-0.0133816339,
-0.0367982201,
0.0199885536,
-0.056486018,
0.0227899309,
0.0267834198,
0.0004462103,
0.0119763641,
-0.0450144038,
-0.0107323918,
-0.0458921045,
-0.0190494079,
0.00042207,
-0.0266348198,
0.0469298661,
-0.0355563611,
-0.0084974961,
0.0372063331,
0.0113175185,
0.0033858782,
-0.0268143024,
0.0477277264,
-0.0238725673,
0.039585419,
-0.0039502569,
-0.0219296478,
0.0233959369,
-0.0178281236,
-0.0804121345,
0.0427510478,
0.05282709,
0.0213979743,
0.0086811511,
-0.0440764651,
0.0010344669,
0.0758584961,
-0.0303716604,
0.0988914222,
0.0851006955,
-0.0231932458,
0.0550196469,
0.0320282951,
-0.0255434942,
-0.0081368787,
-0.042688597,
0.0250027608,
0.0614822134,
0.0700919256,
0.0794224665,
0.0945742056,
-0.003612821,
-0.0399376899,
0.0097143101,
-0.0401283838,
0.0251725297,
0.0140562728,
0.008940802,
-0.0058679609,
-0.0075933724,
-0.0152288005,
-0.1022141129,
-0.0497097299,
0.0281385109,
0.0452416502,
0.0319798812,
-0.0751639381,
0.0656724498,
0.0353732407,
-0.033700455,
0.0404611118,
0.0240813419,
-0.0032176478,
0.0439556539,
0.0126494728,
0.0017491488,
-0.0205198098,
-0.0259058755,
0.0248250104,
0.0574250147,
0.03709241,
0.0088724606,
0.0352978371,
0.0215849765,
0.0265009105,
0.0033410823,
-0.0260425396,
0.0311958231,
-0.0160983298,
0.0260739326,
0.0305162277,
0.0126455203,
0.0012222545,
0.030743055,
-0.0245697014,
0.0144487992,
-0.0278353654,
0.0126385549,
-0.0280113686,
-0.0032471588,
-0.0397164039,
-0.0424765125,
-0.0300237779,
-0.0129717235,
0.0305557139,
-0.0577410534,
-0.0013785661,
0.0247358587,
2.775e-7,
-0.0124265505,
-0.0202080458,
0.0045864186,
-0.0133437496,
0.0079322951,
0.0858545452,
-0.008112574,
0.0034289833,
0.0098780282,
-0.0365844592,
0.0071316566,
0.0355469175,
0.0192359872,
0.0021503298,
0.0177354142,
0.0413748808,
-0.0086590741,
0.026546821,
-0.0177526027,
0.0063786553,
0.0325934216,
0.0716782063,
0.0050775306,
-0.0174401142,
0.0879777744,
0.0056313677,
0.0019626531,
-0.0065586786,
0.0768692791,
-0.043102283,
-0.0086961389,
0.0507922061,
0.000446398,
0.0889745429,
-0.0088052731,
-0.0335910581,
-0.0150523894,
0.0017409176,
-0.0404038951,
-0.0408226848,
-0.0743370578,
0.0067629595,
0.0333600901,
-0.0602906384,
0.0871116742,
-0.0400086977,
0.0081604151,
-0.0589132085,
-0.0349824093,
0.0025481768,
0.0314701088,
0.0017701476,
-0.0089559229,
0.040680375,
-0.0139855761,
-0.0086019654,
-0.0219444819,
-0.0438022353,
0.0087972833,
-0.0174987633,
-0.0510682948,
0.0083739646,
-0.0136976056,
-0.0469699353,
0.0569520555,
-0.0120643824,
-0.046133928,
2.052975399e-34,
0.0365271457,
0.0450046919,
-0.007316106,
-0.0351878181,
0.0000474841,
0.0112231411,
-0.0418480523,
-0.0131239416,
-0.0005172809,
0.0318905301,
-0.0255197119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15430v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15430v2 | TextMI: Textualize Multimodal Information for Integrating Non-verbal Cues in Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-03-27T17:54:32 | 2023-03-29T04:49:46 | Md Kamrul Hasan, Md Saiful Islam, Sangwu Lee, Wasifur Rahman, Iftekhar Naim, Mohammed Ibrahim Khan, Ehsan Hoque | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained large language models have recently achieved ground-breaking
performance in a wide variety of language understanding tasks. However, the
same model can not be applied to multimodal behavior understanding tasks (e.g.,
video sentiment/humor detection) unless non-verbal features (e.g., acoustic and
visual) can be integrated with language. Jointly modeling multiple modalities
significantly increases the model complexity, and makes the training process
data-hungry. While an enormous amount of text data is available via the web,
collecting large-scale multimodal behavioral video datasets is extremely
expensive, both in terms of time and money. In this paper, we investigate
whether large language models alone can successfully incorporate non-verbal
information when they are presented in textual form. We present a way to
convert the acoustic and visual information into corresponding textual
descriptions and concatenate them with the spoken text. We feed this augmented
input to a pre-trained BERT model and fine-tune it on three downstream
multimodal tasks: sentiment, humor, and sarcasm detection. Our approach,
TextMI, significantly reduces model complexity, adds interpretability to the
model's decision, and can be applied for a diverse set of tasks while achieving
superior (multimodal sarcasm detection) or near SOTA (multimodal sentiment
analysis and multimodal humor detection) performance. We propose TextMI as a
general, competitive baseline for multimodal behavioral analysis tasks,
particularly in a low-resource setting. | [
0.0304281078,
0.0643345416,
-0.0119029153,
0.0405817069,
-0.0011322846,
0.0193595346,
0.0090458561,
0.0150245745,
-0.0178405661,
-0.1189684868,
-0.0531195216,
-0.0089075118,
-0.0183954891,
0.0600931197,
0.0552342087,
-0.0728282779,
0.0194773171,
-0.0062028016,
0.0186263844,
0.0066684727,
0.0630982816,
0.0132689727,
-0.0304604229,
0.0157026798,
-0.0447334088,
-0.0005701472,
-0.0330499299,
0.0586229451,
0.0112332366,
-0.0372363403,
0.0032085101,
0.0321613178,
0.0764515549,
0.0089356387,
0.0000015847,
-0.0327960737,
0.0255007371,
-0.0186206102,
0.0316765942,
0.0028063846,
0.0619342551,
-0.0346868634,
0.0030980352,
0.0247120205,
-0.0262266137,
-0.0073610679,
0.0669525117,
0.0295981839,
0.080812797,
0.0652612075,
-0.034113992,
-0.0049625267,
0.0027788014,
0.0026724609,
0.0297398679,
-0.0162888039,
0.0074195429,
-0.0021864066,
-0.0050748,
0.0262444299,
-0.0733423308,
0.0303680822,
-0.0345084704,
0.0008496836,
-0.0062064575,
0.0194301028,
-0.0351586714,
-0.0387235768,
-0.0463736989,
0.0854763985,
0.0057422165,
0.0123580797,
-0.0104683526,
0.0269243736,
-0.0086863758,
-0.0128859421,
-0.0364608951,
0.0075892,
0.0025950058,
0.0022734888,
-0.0409049913,
0.0292066187,
0.0195874218,
0.0218703486,
0.0312955901,
-0.0216056257,
0.0042206505,
-0.0067957714,
-0.019278422,
0.0013845362,
-0.0311043821,
-0.0354311354,
0.0053912597,
0.0299136396,
0.0357382521,
0.0160117205,
-0.0495524183,
-0.0400981046,
0.007179149,
-0.0553677082,
0.0349582136,
0.0219765101,
-0.0811755583,
0.0883073062,
-0.0008953197,
0.0109152598,
-0.024399763,
0.0137290582,
-0.041176565,
-0.0270577781,
-0.0494885221,
0.003514596,
-0.0036991257,
0.0107530653,
-0.0242515262,
-0.0613954365,
-0.0182970259,
0.0218383428,
-0.0142114637,
-0.0083900811,
-0.0037731447,
0.0143595617,
-0.0092314333,
-0.0072509907,
-0.0198701266,
0.0583669618,
-0.0298444107,
0.0568647087,
-0.0668478236,
-0.0089033842,
0.006280669,
0.0368840992,
0.0485591106,
-0.0197233167,
0.0503913313,
0.0576202981,
-0.0102154957,
-0.0703759938,
-0.026098121,
0.000837507,
-0.0471510217,
-0.0361652784,
0.0436045192,
-0.0297585949,
0.0580728687,
-0.0208037533,
-0.0106336419,
0.037320625,
-0.0033568118,
-0.0002649678,
-0.0133276181,
0.1043928936,
-0.0156679917,
0.0007165491,
0.0241247881,
0.0143816406,
-0.003443535,
0.0671391413,
0.0267740581,
0.0030112735,
0.0413786732,
0.0097957654,
-0.0174588729,
0.044073198,
0.0107185347,
0.0202602539,
-0.0461973213,
-0.0045918166,
-0.0175211988,
0.0021905391,
0.0501760468,
0.0507640354,
-0.0319511518,
0.001181034,
0.0658806711,
0.0362422206,
-0.0285088588,
-0.0108998092,
0.0291472692,
-0.0013229847,
0.0017862082,
-0.0224638991,
-0.019357726,
0.0232616067,
-0.0604055449,
-0.0267070867,
0.0264128614,
0.0388753749,
-0.0570840426,
-0.0242352504,
-0.0255612638,
-0.0692860484,
0.0452481844,
0.0107080759,
0.0493414998,
0.010993287,
-0.048186224,
0.009886357,
0.007258126,
-0.0416261964,
-0.0001075662,
-0.0140908891,
0.0088911466,
0.0819586292,
0.0290291253,
-0.0472063161,
-0.0162522402,
-0.006387915,
0.0282357037,
0.0170696676,
-0.0092494795,
-0.0002186731,
0.0466723479,
-0.0499650128,
-0.0242101215,
-0.0142574599,
0.0275363363,
0.026998112,
0.0083842454,
0.0238064807,
-0.0211069677,
0.0011426796,
0.0530670621,
0.0305449795,
0.0091051683,
-0.0274035763,
-0.0386045575,
0.0157876667,
0.0376001224,
0.0079597654,
-0.0172042456,
-0.0341592021,
-0.0039058402,
-0.0526756644,
-0.0223905053,
0.0524766669,
-0.0094853919,
-0.0793836638,
0.0267169327,
-0.02585922,
-0.002273208,
0.0434723794,
-0.0373037383,
0.0010294868,
0.0169225428,
-0.0462047346,
0.0297078434,
-0.0674109384,
-0.0249984451,
0.0019937453,
0.0265390873,
0.015549208,
0.0300279241,
-0.0189704038,
-0.0285115354,
-0.0089968722,
0.0240000207,
0.0156023586,
0.0119712548,
-0.0663936064,
0.0015509839,
-0.0026601891,
0.0182471778,
0.0016930396,
-0.0104899071,
-0.0216023605,
-0.0210627355,
-0.1533906013,
-0.0199693926,
0.0185105801,
-0.0204888284,
0.0054380698,
-0.0112505695,
0.0029120462,
-0.0219298825,
-0.0013388172,
-0.0032467875,
-0.0093339067,
0.0304148197,
0.0152388541,
-0.0061990605,
-0.0014210209,
-0.0476229712,
-0.0189821441,
-0.0220379084,
0.0551365353,
-0.0142360777,
-0.0088778269,
-0.012505237,
-0.033611685,
-0.0550156273,
0.0627037063,
-0.0300523136,
-0.0739738271,
0.0113238422,
-0.0223402157,
0.0374203958,
0.0530452766,
0.0327598229,
0.0383802205,
0.0187737551,
-0.0210367236,
-0.0222422387,
0.0267492589,
0.0262782667,
0.0313358679,
-0.0156573076,
-0.0184720233,
-0.0155107332,
0.0358180143,
-0.0134356162,
0.0220594313,
-0.0598178692,
-0.0079720765,
0.0247647036,
-0.029502755,
-0.0167764071,
-0.043753311,
-0.0258210655,
-0.0022848663,
-0.0049423529,
-0.0391266607,
0.0572730079,
-0.0499311797,
-0.0459454171,
-0.0198318362,
-0.0088172983,
-0.0266034026,
0.1004736945,
0.0136092687,
0.0326281376,
-0.0164907314,
0.0149557116,
-0.0268378854,
-0.0445471071,
0.028154755,
-0.0071053947,
0.0418399721,
-0.0123865642,
0.0018841755,
0.0249657892,
-0.0315697975,
-0.0084157316,
-0.0703422725,
-0.0641996935,
-0.0444640629,
-0.0365180522,
-0.0230690725,
-0.013405012,
0.0126526356,
0.0286489166,
-0.0228524711,
0.0132973799,
-0.0015600937,
0.0054474757,
0.016455302,
0.0626847669,
0.0004296091,
-0.0531843975,
-0.0238023084,
-0.0104106367,
0.0230871849,
0.003102442,
-0.0252438951,
-0.0450047776,
0.0208769329,
0.0024374281,
0.0486072861,
-0.013524998,
0.0064801392,
0.034720663,
0.0151608065,
0.0193171371,
0.1090128645,
-0.0011209707,
-0.0161544774,
0.0086791124,
0.0258387011,
0.001453553,
0.0279798601,
0.007324622,
-0.0524273738,
-0.0798724145,
-0.0115338555,
-0.0101254052,
0.030050518,
0.0205903295,
-0.0513703823,
-0.0958795846,
-0.0006942049,
0.0048140632,
-0.000349505,
0.004520854,
0.0071923393,
0.0069652712,
-0.0188511759,
-0.0350201465,
-0.026176434,
0.0015760745,
-0.0241087712,
-0.0097636702,
-0.030658029,
-0.0568619519,
0.052929122,
-0.0343890823,
0.0256623439,
0.0152165759,
0.048790507,
-0.028321242,
-0.0441161953,
0.029501874,
0.0097783506,
0.0114960792,
-0.0250467341,
0.0961738378,
-0.0632966757,
-0.0131853968,
-0.0108269351,
0.0092029246,
0.0241418798,
-0.0056708422,
-0.033652164,
0.0459193625,
-0.01263039,
0.0113357501,
-0.069150053,
0.021720456,
0.0105692251,
0.060349457,
-0.0033602049,
-0.0933286175,
0.0045397985,
0.0206372924,
-0.0458318219,
-0.0278494619,
-0.0026374322,
-0.0263591986,
-0.0220191833,
-0.017641522,
-0.0707841888,
-0.0235493872,
0.016534932,
0.051271528,
-0.0231981277,
-0.0216987766,
-0.0219489988,
0.0381040499,
-0.0477291048,
0.0543054081,
0.0215674415,
0.0132313669,
-0.0097604627,
-0.0211631432,
0.0473054759,
-0.0441733375,
-0.0261455774,
0.0144474339,
-0.0437768698,
-0.0393557735,
-0.0179421026,
0.0850512311,
0.0187344756,
0.0334757194,
0.0069726873,
-0.0378151499,
0.0239304882,
0.0336778089,
-0.0099121882,
0.0500929281,
0.0460056514,
0.0387439951,
0.0033522274,
0.0256830268,
-0.0427328236,
0.0425122753,
-0.040700458,
-0.0123127652,
-0.054326579,
-0.0395875014,
-0.0337453447,
-0.0255729146,
0.0756230205,
-0.0125447111,
-0.0322808698,
-0.0135552064,
-0.0167688485,
0.0043780347,
-0.0055704541,
-0.0884633809,
-0.0086646779,
0.0130276866,
0.0094416887,
-0.0640315786,
-0.0074566728,
-0.0024774619,
-0.0026834744,
-0.0172547791,
0.007077992,
0.0351948589,
-0.0118540153,
-0.0226694513,
0.025651915,
-0.0156075079,
0.0111445598,
-0.0229904968,
-0.0274685975,
-0.0012861644,
0.0661904961,
0.007115189,
-0.0152941421,
0.0074788309,
0.0574992448,
0.0122909062,
0.0252969563,
0.0036418024,
0.0139546413,
0.0488177836,
-0.0086111026,
0.0405314863,
-0.0125316437,
-0.0019086287,
-0.005972092,
0.0477014557,
-0.0437616296,
-0.0737170428,
0.0650867373,
0.016934773,
0.0045894366,
-0.0171482693,
0.0665309653,
-0.0297066271,
0.0388977639,
-0.0051721865,
0.0092602307,
-0.0348326154,
0.0016020311,
0.0814368054,
0.0290816426,
-0.0205393117,
0.0376626961,
-0.0146624874,
-0.066617012,
0.0407303125,
-0.0200269092,
-0.0208970495,
0.0123202289,
0.0619867556,
0.0225501806,
0.0099542625,
0.0288561247,
-0.0031043459,
-0.0118809203,
-0.0325932987,
0.0127476137,
0.0226032492,
-5.496369139e-33,
-0.0300844926,
-0.0086602373,
-0.0006633531,
0.0035992658,
0.0022729719,
0.0363091938,
-0.0266987756,
0.0262941085,
-0.005362439,
-0.0041378783,
0.0489422977,
0.0187906623,
-0.0153533546,
0.0222003516,
0.0098820841,
-0.0192518458,
0.0345124975,
-0.0165113322,
-0.0031295808,
-0.0125764059,
0.0380650982,
0.0322401747,
0.0552371964,
-0.1058576554,
-0.0183050111,
0.008607015,
-0.0697726086,
0.0261867847,
0.0555926412,
0.0651146322,
-0.0242898203,
0.037683975,
0.0043407925,
0.0359059274,
-0.0165001266,
0.0566720888,
-0.0452492572,
-0.012755461,
0.0265815444,
0.022300791,
-0.0683806166,
0.0225624125,
0.0402674153,
-0.0208067261,
0.0056232656,
-0.0186442342,
0.0504982248,
-0.0215126202,
0.0354228467,
-0.0272952616,
-0.049518723,
0.0095336838,
-0.0073815035,
-0.0556996614,
0.0166150369,
0.0414403789,
0.0563443936,
0.0238472838,
-0.0567077808,
0.0272169206,
-0.0729221702,
-0.0132072726,
0.0332436822,
0.0025956687,
-0.0082653482,
0.090937458,
0.0124128237,
-0.0349463075,
-0.0310420096,
0.0026331823,
0.0487194583,
0.0514399856,
0.0453152284,
0.058335226,
0.016911732,
-0.0055161361,
-0.0343047008,
0.0296302587,
0.0121783614,
0.0047378843,
0.0211735535,
0.0247305539,
-0.043924842,
0.0136036063,
-0.0007071658,
0.0201225057,
-0.0375294238,
-0.0196729694,
0.0138709834,
0.0330466554,
0.0025169414,
0.0125253526,
0.0638714731,
-0.032466583,
-0.0103475563,
0.0404164419,
-0.0216684006,
0.0592853129,
-0.0110365888,
0.0267030131,
-0.0336277224,
-0.0377741121,
0.0437291488,
0.0242441185,
0.0093798814,
0.0106053874,
0.0608945638,
0.0751408041,
-0.0631631538,
0.0024523002,
0.0259945896,
-0.0198556539,
-0.0079719853,
0.0611726381,
0.0159656256,
0.0331997238,
-0.067270413,
0.0297312737,
-0.0066769524,
0.0019381146,
-0.0438801236,
-0.050750006,
-0.0052570091,
0.0160376076,
-0.0208460633,
0.010159201,
-0.030567294,
-0.0864093974,
-0.0029383996,
-0.0775893256,
-0.0009308307,
0.0400279462,
2.437e-7,
0.0396067686,
0.0532423593,
-0.0116562238,
0.0126041202,
0.0515812486,
0.0779935941,
-0.0213373192,
0.049934227,
0.0114718927,
-0.0238977633,
0.0241947249,
0.0382741429,
0.0069596572,
-0.0000159663,
-0.0297958553,
-0.0055710864,
-0.0462534539,
0.0286990684,
-0.0374297388,
0.0249710288,
0.0717683211,
0.0978044048,
0.0336832106,
-0.0174330771,
0.0093186088,
-0.0694553703,
0.0948366672,
-0.0013071438,
-0.0104020387,
-0.0427623652,
0.0061749271,
0.0100938119,
-0.0300024655,
0.0077000917,
-0.0226154923,
-0.0251805373,
0.016516177,
0.0742610246,
-0.0346626341,
-0.053497348,
-0.0133723551,
0.0298647247,
-0.0575246736,
-0.0015741809,
0.0805059299,
-0.0015893998,
-0.0312380847,
-0.0360570848,
-0.0178012475,
-0.0279687624,
0.0357310623,
0.0022107938,
-0.0362902097,
0.0280891359,
0.0344577841,
-0.0392795727,
-0.0345540531,
-0.1172952279,
-0.0274644904,
0.0149455601,
-0.074982658,
-0.0067149149,
-0.0272250585,
-0.0087705152,
0.0519955494,
-0.0826028213,
-0.0131430328,
1.737407283e-34,
0.0457687154,
-0.0274120495,
0.0192930847,
-0.0256129242,
0.0076682358,
0.0277261958,
-0.0167024247,
-0.0248597357,
0.0485553779,
-0.0438276306,
-0.0265446696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15422v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15422v4 | KPEval: Towards Fine-Grained Semantic-Based Keyphrase Evaluation | 2023-03-27T17:45:38 | 2024-06-04T10:00:56 | Di Wu, Da Yin, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the significant advancements in keyphrase extraction and keyphrase
generation methods, the predominant approach for evaluation mainly relies on
exact matching with human references. This scheme fails to recognize systems
that generate keyphrases semantically equivalent to the references or diverse
keyphrases that carry practical utility. To better assess the capability of
keyphrase systems, we propose KPEval, a comprehensive evaluation framework
consisting of four critical aspects: reference agreement, faithfulness,
diversity, and utility. For each aspect, we design semantic-based metrics to
reflect the evaluation objectives. Meta-evaluation studies demonstrate that our
evaluation strategy correlates better with human preferences compared to a
range of previously proposed metrics. Using KPEval, we re-evaluate 23 keyphrase
systems and discover that (1) established model comparison results have
blind-spots especially when considering reference-free evaluation; (2) large
language models are underestimated by prior evaluation works; and (3) there is
no single best model that can excel in all the aspects. | [
0.0892201588,
0.0365521312,
0.0037935183,
-0.0066985176,
-0.0642276034,
-0.0118449563,
-0.0197239257,
0.0366656557,
-0.0016466026,
-0.0527572036,
-0.0382172167,
0.0462514348,
0.0043726927,
0.0279462095,
-0.0228585526,
-0.0558877029,
0.0241361987,
-0.0264949631,
0.0184278954,
0.0022670713,
0.0090934234,
0.0207878668,
0.0032185505,
0.0574588776,
0.0604122244,
0.0096560419,
0.0388354473,
-0.0401063226,
0.024702549,
-0.0262647867,
0.005146849,
0.02403998,
-0.0414844416,
0.0419466011,
0.00000184,
-0.0605090484,
-0.012810328,
-0.0042946604,
0.0281514078,
0.050320182,
0.1162356734,
-0.0035188447,
0.0174586382,
-0.0163121969,
-0.0418070666,
-0.0147362314,
0.0494991839,
0.014864021,
0.0678346828,
-0.0152898394,
-0.0205872413,
-0.0668831319,
0.0018802396,
-0.032765314,
-0.0076375157,
-0.0851869732,
0.0106135691,
-0.0165301412,
-0.0102669103,
0.0179903377,
0.0346356854,
0.0454042815,
-0.0447445326,
0.0461758673,
0.119369477,
0.0095460713,
-0.0821570754,
-0.0346645936,
-0.0046971464,
0.0546872541,
-0.0162388217,
0.0108377468,
0.0333021358,
-0.0473466702,
-0.0026802591,
0.0606559366,
-0.0390169583,
-0.0108801536,
0.0019235591,
-0.0193678197,
-0.0117033534,
0.0168215241,
0.0090258466,
0.027937647,
-0.0055684065,
0.0403837413,
0.0408582166,
-0.005836389,
0.0053988337,
-0.0223910231,
-0.0536175333,
-0.0483393706,
-0.0170682706,
-0.0342848599,
0.0180023015,
0.0315285549,
-0.0225008931,
0.0347610526,
0.1033503115,
-0.1203418374,
-0.0093661379,
-0.0370910987,
0.01482521,
0.0371392556,
-0.0167938769,
0.0551506616,
-0.0102024088,
-0.0035329242,
-0.0150827244,
0.0064890594,
-0.0538255125,
0.0072770631,
0.0125027345,
0.0436411463,
0.0413362049,
-0.0412019864,
-0.0544814356,
0.020595327,
0.0149678811,
0.0352448598,
-0.0017238129,
0.0171370786,
-0.0069420678,
-0.0048451968,
-0.0177621059,
-0.0142051345,
-0.0413405858,
0.0203761458,
-0.00457446,
-0.0138795711,
0.0281255059,
-0.0153824687,
0.0209088102,
-0.0173832793,
0.0421574041,
0.0398667157,
0.0163909178,
-0.0099072941,
-0.0002348928,
-0.0505397543,
-0.0519181527,
0.0152697004,
-0.0135540646,
-0.1028740183,
0.0192163549,
0.0362015031,
0.0030427836,
-0.032883212,
0.0198684707,
0.0356669612,
-0.0916088074,
0.0454845019,
-0.0054269847,
-0.0056294445,
0.0099707982,
0.0165635794,
-0.0140629318,
0.0102610122,
0.0112171415,
0.0639222935,
0.0760540441,
-0.002145861,
0.0051383302,
0.0063839448,
-0.0112409787,
-0.0038381799,
0.0073495042,
0.0255052671,
-0.0096563492,
0.0047216197,
-0.0465744473,
0.0159844737,
-0.0140269417,
0.0325924084,
0.0436147749,
0.0809748545,
-0.0065251491,
0.0165874138,
-0.0222264733,
0.043597661,
0.0058492711,
-0.028770458,
0.0201620497,
-0.0179911274,
-0.009094215,
0.0372527763,
0.0504714102,
0.0212572291,
0.0192932822,
-0.0533371978,
-0.0342792347,
0.0308614913,
-0.0336002931,
-0.0442689508,
0.0459226593,
-0.0087065324,
-0.0458140746,
0.0653698072,
0.003902891,
-0.0431616269,
-0.0118513238,
-0.0391727611,
-0.0044401661,
0.0643445328,
0.0816744938,
-0.0040944656,
-0.0183331557,
0.0154952668,
-0.00614445,
0.0388812572,
-0.0059520281,
0.0096703721,
-0.0236434396,
-0.051047489,
-0.0426545888,
-0.0195435733,
0.0167876165,
-0.0238201991,
0.0114325136,
0.012184537,
0.0265249312,
-0.0482488759,
-0.0153940534,
0.0225653779,
0.0391337425,
0.0093193538,
-0.0447845683,
-0.0244495403,
0.0226937775,
0.0186863765,
-0.0145113738,
0.0515546165,
0.0298312716,
-0.0221780874,
-0.0130531304,
0.0141702462,
0.0329755321,
0.0761982203,
0.0316370204,
-0.039373789,
0.0404511504,
0.0072879484,
-0.0048685102,
-0.0188247375,
0.0354713276,
-0.0319737643,
0.0278904159,
-0.0336554945,
0.0358455218,
-0.0567622706,
0.0056059174,
-0.0435253717,
0.0869553611,
0.0211185347,
0.0015964599,
-0.0415301546,
-0.0659627542,
0.0383878648,
0.0184733998,
-0.0611344315,
0.0513764657,
-0.0073439702,
0.0204271376,
0.0682017878,
0.009157083,
-0.0505423211,
-0.0325256586,
-0.0542519055,
0.010941606,
0.020083474,
0.0006205465,
0.0091532059,
0.0285804346,
0.005077112,
-0.00451467,
-0.0099074841,
-0.0457477532,
-0.0081417905,
0.0136919357,
-0.001319605,
0.0284174252,
-0.0222577415,
-0.0210572761,
0.0014648876,
0.0298610255,
0.0766839236,
0.044414185,
-0.0109825814,
0.0079074521,
0.0214198548,
-0.0318946466,
-0.0680247396,
0.0184406005,
-0.023664115,
0.0178073626,
0.0070541659,
0.004668599,
-0.0511034764,
0.0514644906,
-0.0656554848,
0.0264549218,
-0.017973993,
-0.0555640645,
-0.0595396943,
0.0064340835,
-0.0626665875,
0.0251884237,
-0.0315074734,
0.0389555506,
-0.0058217566,
0.001521347,
0.0333348513,
-0.0573220327,
0.0420011245,
-0.0224045981,
-0.0343579017,
-0.0610884875,
-0.0173836034,
-0.0038510354,
0.0145153906,
-0.0127435261,
-0.0020483236,
0.0307065248,
-0.0151419183,
0.0340538397,
-0.0152552361,
0.006381785,
-0.0196990278,
0.0252172891,
-0.0834625959,
0.0036781598,
0.0379883759,
0.0022622598,
0.0058570681,
-0.0566458181,
0.030344326,
-0.06617257,
0.0754176676,
-0.0435712859,
0.0076895477,
0.021890495,
0.0041975095,
-0.0276929159,
-0.031924393,
-0.0620212741,
-0.0361123942,
0.0243473034,
-0.0020676239,
0.0265961066,
0.040364746,
0.0310585555,
-0.0104426993,
0.019374961,
-0.0126779843,
0.0056576021,
-0.0040397788,
0.0622031316,
-0.0440712273,
0.0009235818,
0.0288392864,
0.0075157438,
0.0246540084,
0.0892000571,
-0.0014488978,
-0.0101824189,
-0.0049557257,
0.0339429639,
-0.0479425192,
-0.056396272,
-0.0177372415,
-0.0089325076,
-0.0106384233,
0.0092500867,
0.0866105556,
0.0530868433,
-0.0440560915,
-0.0252275877,
-0.0268438067,
-0.0286117047,
-0.0144836875,
-0.0068927277,
-0.0295513086,
-0.02971901,
-0.0175609086,
0.0524542853,
0.0043806559,
-0.0081345895,
-0.0109450007,
-0.0603593066,
0.0181901846,
0.0197594371,
-0.0296069756,
-0.0233007427,
-0.0768154636,
-0.0101703694,
-0.0627771989,
-0.0411071889,
0.00098726,
-0.0428943224,
0.0350991637,
-0.0304140653,
-0.0485272892,
-0.0284927916,
0.0659470484,
-0.0610646456,
0.0117467875,
0.0874828249,
0.0425054356,
-0.0305458512,
-0.0431997143,
0.0007213992,
-0.0291853305,
-0.0162294097,
0.0104524456,
-0.0054741926,
-0.0110481558,
0.0043394244,
0.0162634216,
-0.0185034424,
-0.0292427801,
-0.0215463657,
0.0374137163,
0.0233681351,
0.0168556012,
0.0275734123,
-0.0197491776,
-0.0021750648,
-0.0281907264,
0.0769287646,
0.0195818543,
0.007829777,
-0.0192003325,
0.0246795323,
0.0257437434,
-0.0558705032,
-0.0605691038,
-0.0238143913,
-0.0490978919,
-0.0142764291,
-0.0824874267,
-0.031499736,
-0.0179598406,
-0.0206439607,
-0.0131517872,
0.048794765,
-0.0013680878,
0.0182707254,
-0.0460495465,
-0.0114734154,
-0.0035691594,
-0.0249263048,
-0.02900769,
0.0104121827,
0.0299400389,
-0.0097885719,
-0.029755082,
0.0494732857,
0.0050361063,
-0.0117146168,
0.0273725968,
0.0145522039,
0.019506814,
-0.0191828664,
-0.045778472,
-0.0347851962,
0.0685286075,
0.0603247955,
-0.0249551795,
-0.000597381,
0.0391963571,
-0.0006376143,
-0.0261243973,
0.0188508946,
-0.0790819526,
-0.0136593431,
-0.0185963009,
0.0487140343,
-0.0102403648,
-0.0422641747,
0.0059258612,
0.0438794866,
0.0025086543,
-0.0765375569,
-0.020769449,
0.0048321392,
-0.0380034894,
0.0223524217,
-0.0372730866,
-0.0440506823,
0.0104836393,
0.0006864473,
0.0075859884,
-0.0164385159,
0.0439265594,
-0.0672732517,
0.0293080676,
-0.0263758469,
-0.0180483777,
0.0276525896,
0.02496944,
-0.0277004503,
-0.0264036022,
-0.0334255695,
-0.0336160921,
-0.0401024222,
-0.0164986271,
-0.0281259175,
-0.0051269801,
-0.011042228,
-0.0514916889,
-0.0129906088,
0.1058470383,
-0.0732726231,
-0.0220309757,
-0.0235613566,
0.0042130277,
0.07497935,
0.0302344486,
0.0438232273,
-0.0060709976,
-0.0333364867,
0.0062579154,
0.0379274152,
0.0089910198,
0.0014520736,
-0.0390615053,
0.0279627088,
-0.0282636397,
-0.0111146281,
0.0515869707,
0.0060110888,
0.0317043215,
-0.0318472832,
-0.0629950613,
-0.0131349051,
-0.0252247173,
-0.0107793072,
0.0271340422,
-0.0100258403,
-0.0343876034,
-0.0756422803,
-0.0200119484,
0.0618845113,
0.0255473629,
0.0182504207,
0.0351794995,
0.0387975015,
0.0909187645,
0.0092372438,
-0.0185379814,
-0.0645613,
0.0093091736,
-0.0343499407,
0.0165762771,
-0.0138513446,
-6.061812411e-33,
0.011753534,
0.007638278,
-0.017175531,
0.0026803438,
-0.0142037738,
0.0037604347,
-0.0078836344,
-0.0141729899,
-0.0070801605,
-0.0015265842,
-0.0141857034,
-0.0031565989,
0.017517956,
-0.0438178554,
0.0640955269,
-0.0242562816,
0.0233026743,
0.0365127288,
-0.0543207973,
0.0300826393,
0.0212236326,
-0.0111020412,
0.0596641116,
-0.0449847318,
0.0702979341,
-0.0365158916,
-0.0324761905,
-0.0579853244,
0.0449602827,
0.0725644529,
-0.0077972887,
0.0552500375,
0.0075182635,
-0.0670819804,
-0.0011613909,
-0.0265157819,
-0.0185861774,
-0.0267059021,
0.0528243743,
-0.0229748748,
0.0286383703,
-0.02880897,
0.0312838964,
-0.0111486148,
-0.0189901087,
0.0336058289,
0.0528871156,
-0.0298539922,
-0.0395413265,
-0.0116763925,
0.0164637044,
0.0333706848,
0.0234003644,
0.0322900228,
0.009147021,
0.0234408658,
-0.0103615522,
0.0316234045,
-0.0121264029,
0.0401187167,
0.0416714847,
0.0054798671,
0.0730318576,
0.036122866,
0.0144145638,
0.048519209,
-0.0252962746,
-0.0520775579,
0.0446329787,
0.0335742608,
0.0144002959,
0.0741155669,
0.0486525074,
0.0945446566,
0.0327881984,
0.0249626487,
0.0022714681,
0.051335942,
-0.0361714661,
0.0336514376,
0.0252334457,
0.0090282289,
-0.0391945764,
0.0251914263,
-0.0455411635,
0.0246590246,
-0.0534550138,
-0.0384217836,
0.0249451883,
-0.0048014564,
-0.0796584561,
0.0821409449,
-0.0022328747,
-0.0189552456,
0.0113315769,
0.0461054742,
0.0129726548,
0.0148591632,
-0.0082716886,
0.0085741756,
-0.0324398391,
0.0124714104,
0.0473579913,
0.036256209,
0.0495068394,
-0.0406638496,
-0.0296593104,
-0.0111517543,
-0.0234009009,
-0.0004531684,
0.0073380051,
-0.0238958653,
-0.0391209796,
-0.092239745,
0.0077738552,
0.0254796129,
-0.0192761887,
-0.0043317685,
0.0319514275,
0.0091537442,
0.0104600554,
-0.0061285836,
0.0188316386,
0.0265125744,
0.0123839797,
0.0306517314,
-0.0126559818,
-0.0181759149,
-0.0076650511,
0.023394227,
-0.0390553363,
-0.0127184251,
2.586e-7,
0.0213092808,
0.0114071872,
0.0147183137,
0.0131904241,
-0.0531871393,
0.0502364337,
0.018719364,
0.0328571238,
-0.0463174991,
-0.0131964739,
0.0394840576,
0.0366352424,
0.0189155769,
0.0055211792,
-0.0560921989,
-0.0294700731,
-0.1020942107,
0.0172509048,
-0.0282759164,
0.0016685878,
0.0535608977,
0.0012608488,
0.0359278992,
-0.0062287655,
-0.0549098141,
-0.0522570871,
0.0159847643,
-0.0365345962,
-0.0191007201,
0.0371360071,
0.000539607,
0.0439777449,
-0.0104729198,
0.0309073031,
-0.0034657386,
-0.0154894255,
0.084161289,
0.0034822619,
-0.0058021788,
-0.0490895882,
-0.0339227207,
-0.032760758,
0.0241427664,
-0.0606852993,
0.0639599785,
0.0000644449,
0.0017570372,
-0.032633692,
-0.0817572325,
0.0504748635,
0.0121178078,
-0.0121395048,
-0.0415859483,
-0.0084203361,
-0.0053612408,
0.0239313077,
-0.0564527847,
-0.0431944579,
0.0093221534,
0.0067698308,
0.0095920637,
-0.024462292,
-0.0505836569,
0.0035733427,
-0.0079269018,
-0.0787556469,
0.0165234804,
1.683235016e-34,
0.0337103643,
-0.0206609592,
-0.0286339391,
0.0086429538,
0.0170152765,
0.0119270543,
-0.0213941913,
0.0335299075,
-0.0001013806,
-0.0013224353,
0.0356128179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15413v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15413v5 | Debiasing Scores and Prompts of 2D Diffusion for View-consistent Text-to-3D Generation | 2023-03-27T17:31:13 | 2023-12-19T22:03:12 | Susung Hong, Donghoon Ahn, Seungryong Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | Existing score-distilling text-to-3D generation techniques, despite their
considerable promise, often encounter the view inconsistency problem. One of
the most notable issues is the Janus problem, where the most canonical view of
an object (\textit{e.g}., face or head) appears in other views. In this work,
we explore existing frameworks for score-distilling text-to-3D generation and
identify the main causes of the view inconsistency problem -- the embedded bias
of 2D diffusion models. Based on these findings, we propose two approaches to
debias the score-distillation frameworks for view-consistent text-to-3D
generation. Our first approach, called score debiasing, involves cutting off
the score estimated by 2D diffusion models and gradually increasing the
truncation value throughout the optimization process. Our second approach,
called prompt debiasing, identifies conflicting words between user prompts and
view prompts using a language model, and adjusts the discrepancy between view
prompts and the viewing direction of an object. Our experimental results show
that our methods improve the realism of the generated 3D objects by
significantly reducing artifacts and achieve a good trade-off between
faithfulness to the 2D diffusion models and 3D consistency with little
overhead. Our project page is available
at~\url{https://susunghong.github.io/Debiased-Score-Distillation-Sampling/}. | [
0.0148186712,
0.0392086059,
0.0571627878,
0.036931064,
-0.014271047,
-0.0004850307,
0.0163332522,
0.0075056842,
-0.02322248,
-0.00061094,
-0.0167811364,
-0.0433059707,
0.0570276007,
0.0489571393,
0.0279845949,
-0.1006397232,
-0.0364173763,
-0.0568301119,
-0.0341207758,
-0.0467173494,
-0.010052029,
0.0348572508,
-0.0240763202,
-0.0338955745,
-0.0199463312,
-0.0185713172,
-0.0174890589,
0.0347528197,
0.0446158834,
-0.0453204885,
-0.0263722651,
0.0368837193,
0.0161117483,
-0.0317545831,
0.0000024284,
-0.0253656488,
-0.0144555299,
0.0167774893,
0.0491379388,
0.0010785719,
0.0695171803,
-0.0261530075,
-0.0022506027,
-0.0392113179,
-0.0103139188,
0.0734843984,
0.0430034399,
0.0641402453,
0.0818659887,
-0.001958508,
-0.0136463717,
-0.0445356853,
-0.0496233255,
-0.0168787967,
0.0816935152,
0.0238228999,
-0.0110382056,
0.0343182385,
-0.010193768,
0.0448428914,
-0.0054374053,
0.0159316044,
0.0189981069,
0.0214446392,
0.0345547199,
0.0363851264,
0.0395130925,
-0.0226113964,
-0.0100300638,
0.0822333917,
-0.0324523821,
0.0179858953,
0.0400727391,
-0.0412741676,
0.0081005916,
0.0419888981,
-0.0082287351,
-0.0065927906,
-0.0195726641,
-0.01168718,
-0.0619391538,
0.0318980105,
-0.003927201,
-0.0587015599,
-0.023650188,
-0.0285220854,
0.0554438606,
0.0005939738,
-0.044678241,
0.0496603958,
0.0044601983,
-0.0840220377,
0.0448782556,
-0.0161036793,
0.0297185034,
0.0173495822,
-0.0608677603,
0.0105619831,
-0.0365761556,
-0.0234748516,
0.061519932,
0.00120729,
0.0108519103,
0.0035018299,
-0.0226250757,
0.029957328,
0.0116825961,
-0.0258248877,
-0.0726333857,
0.035706576,
0.036456462,
-0.0159664862,
-0.0367511772,
-0.0038110185,
-0.0763056502,
0.0108312164,
-0.0314678736,
-0.0228832364,
0.0070412229,
-0.0230071116,
0.0461699441,
0.0453167185,
-0.054914888,
0.0263837948,
-0.0431942344,
-0.0053761168,
-0.020413287,
-0.0047705206,
-0.0084510697,
-0.024468137,
-0.036512617,
0.0063009248,
0.0596626438,
0.0013194494,
-0.0271884054,
0.0442512743,
-0.0635430962,
0.0003434961,
0.070044294,
-0.0304059312,
-0.0649653152,
-0.0168657191,
0.0272289533,
-0.0545401908,
0.0349966474,
-0.0383150689,
0.0097931251,
-0.049336914,
0.0303071141,
-0.0216964222,
-0.0002316505,
0.0036123791,
0.0181838293,
0.0173391178,
0.0291503426,
0.0013915293,
0.0248250198,
0.0036474667,
0.0187834427,
0.0555652529,
-0.0408834256,
0.0133154457,
0.0300917402,
0.0328500569,
0.0496061109,
0.036786899,
-0.0348078236,
-0.0564108826,
0.0026755116,
0.0513021424,
0.0520573519,
0.0734647661,
-0.0424259305,
0.0028041261,
0.0999836326,
-0.0050556445,
-0.038224116,
-0.0294508785,
0.0609560311,
0.0137783298,
-0.0143496608,
0.0141396057,
0.041150704,
0.0041420772,
0.0575962849,
0.0170248486,
0.0126367593,
0.0365290344,
-0.0385922603,
-0.0442529581,
0.0449141935,
-0.0082232859,
0.0029480834,
-0.0446340553,
0.0310849417,
0.0575563945,
-0.0428735502,
0.0549881384,
-0.0289092548,
-0.0948565155,
0.009467639,
-0.0036141842,
0.0155040622,
0.0732687637,
0.0149294874,
0.0506601483,
0.0035301135,
0.0132862059,
-0.0003519638,
0.0786013007,
0.0374844037,
-0.0159855653,
0.0499368124,
-0.0140655749,
-0.0258726049,
0.0299826972,
0.0063102297,
0.0478710234,
-0.0120998612,
0.0367659144,
0.0091681685,
-0.0553175136,
0.0119523518,
0.0306912027,
-0.0867761895,
0.0262352359,
-0.0405657105,
-0.0002683972,
0.0157845989,
0.0238994434,
-0.0096354885,
-0.0160446335,
0.0010320352,
-0.0142240059,
0.0151713686,
0.0131200859,
-0.0582292639,
-0.0501319245,
-0.0075657582,
-0.012247486,
-0.0108427005,
-0.0189928208,
-0.0076017743,
-0.0221896097,
-0.0345905349,
-0.0273689814,
-0.0311737917,
-0.0050397171,
0.0131782927,
0.0104902135,
-0.0028877356,
-0.0557246581,
0.0524736457,
-0.0914728343,
-0.0050477562,
-0.0045738416,
-0.0071610403,
-0.0418891534,
-0.0035348763,
0.0141377328,
0.0047585801,
0.0251732022,
-0.0154272132,
0.0117165921,
-0.0000943276,
-0.0368603617,
-0.0165712312,
-0.0043245903,
-0.0541047044,
0.0352766402,
-0.0157318059,
0.0127989575,
0.0025323187,
-0.0162827652,
0.0203075223,
-0.0561131686,
-0.0130636701,
0.0331088789,
-0.026671391,
0.042693872,
-0.0116882846,
0.0200068653,
-0.0324009918,
0.016634075,
0.0077480115,
0.0225794185,
0.0558046512,
-0.0537538677,
-0.056080658,
0.0528814569,
-0.0574059561,
0.0286354981,
-0.0116706928,
0.0106888786,
0.010184071,
-0.0152582899,
0.069585748,
0.0508297868,
-0.0120298928,
0.0073085278,
0.0017338877,
-0.0507079884,
-0.0729231238,
0.0029162967,
-0.0263897609,
0.0488741063,
0.0175173618,
-0.1103194728,
0.0735088363,
0.0399124958,
0.0404403806,
0.0425238013,
-0.0475454293,
0.0602778867,
0.0158926435,
-0.073595725,
0.0164795853,
-0.0105885165,
-0.023627419,
0.0072880676,
-0.0450826287,
0.0108865136,
0.0241553467,
-0.0835411772,
0.0250963606,
-0.0232566446,
0.0926654935,
0.0495290086,
0.0395551361,
0.0151501289,
0.0501439273,
0.0107183196,
0.0259844176,
-0.0460187532,
-0.0061603249,
0.0377867185,
-0.0545028374,
-0.0231122375,
-0.0635010898,
-0.0056240461,
-0.0118592465,
-0.0338066258,
0.003591039,
-0.0453427657,
0.0214781687,
-0.0409237631,
-0.0144623797,
-0.0244221147,
-0.0281607602,
0.035249427,
-0.0148692522,
0.030703254,
-0.0162898321,
-0.0336920917,
-0.0141299926,
0.0153139997,
0.0285155885,
0.0156327691,
-0.0321561098,
-0.0589752272,
0.0037725153,
0.0668827221,
-0.0144473901,
0.0235362742,
-0.021708373,
0.0089005306,
0.0285772756,
0.0582400113,
-0.0143774711,
-0.0020866708,
0.100896202,
-0.0342241563,
-0.0153421005,
0.0667901561,
0.0046633263,
-0.0053346665,
-0.0063877725,
0.0399260372,
0.072318241,
-0.0129507864,
-0.0294502601,
-0.0546671152,
-0.012196457,
-0.0070167431,
0.0325868092,
0.0169617943,
-0.0332032964,
0.0005899355,
-0.0952759236,
0.0539849214,
0.0162331238,
0.0191530474,
-0.0323269516,
0.0086203711,
0.054111965,
0.0237438418,
-0.0310394131,
-0.0182580445,
0.008709996,
0.0515051633,
0.0447937697,
0.0483492054,
-0.0478828363,
-0.0290604588,
0.0042347843,
0.0081745237,
0.05523156,
0.0409191735,
-0.0005568077,
-0.0662299618,
0.021768773,
0.0418277346,
0.007027701,
0.0139182089,
0.037525285,
0.0190958045,
-0.0017394605,
-0.0173874907,
0.0165554602,
0.0317941271,
-0.0102563547,
-0.0158375409,
-0.0042274538,
0.0008340109,
-0.016584143,
-0.0136326337,
0.0109335575,
0.0516693667,
0.0405646004,
0.0046518994,
-0.058441475,
-0.0373704769,
-0.0305846166,
0.0647166148,
-0.0043603266,
-0.059304744,
-0.0119703989,
-0.0253014788,
-0.0739575177,
-0.1200470328,
-0.002425499,
0.0017316476,
0.0692578703,
-0.0169548038,
-0.0106487861,
-0.0306187291,
-0.0060177734,
-0.0458846539,
-0.0127213802,
-0.0340502262,
0.0049768374,
0.005340449,
0.0311202351,
-0.0279034209,
-0.0607679561,
-0.0332828425,
0.0105607435,
-0.0453018956,
-0.0231818315,
0.0042795222,
0.0707866773,
0.0146588804,
0.0484314747,
-0.0272375364,
-0.0339854546,
0.0681195334,
0.0394964628,
0.0398091376,
0.0284021869,
-0.0168991424,
0.0348380655,
-0.009369676,
-0.0182841234,
-0.0344303772,
0.0255454648,
-0.0079101603,
0.0210012235,
0.0123189902,
-0.0294683427,
0.0014243824,
0.0090953149,
0.0258574262,
-0.0146524729,
0.0685174838,
-0.0421700776,
-0.0154296495,
-0.0272913594,
-0.030577153,
-0.0657486767,
0.0383260362,
0.0325608663,
-0.0088721225,
0.0099643189,
0.0227013789,
0.0114741074,
0.0255685858,
-0.0679277107,
-0.0359555855,
0.0287380181,
-0.0069298735,
0.0213922542,
0.0082368609,
0.0143783651,
0.0581225008,
-0.0648564398,
0.0266893934,
0.0016094379,
0.0052679176,
0.0049830433,
-0.0450035371,
0.0028300865,
0.0551417097,
-0.0136722587,
-0.0162589028,
-0.0770211071,
0.0537330993,
0.0098779453,
0.0593296401,
0.0781638622,
-0.0090690022,
0.0193437487,
-0.0205742344,
-0.0136389928,
0.0545598119,
-0.0304721277,
0.0183100495,
-0.0094279656,
-0.0059013921,
-0.0540857799,
0.0202002116,
-0.0201296676,
0.0003256069,
-0.0316573568,
-0.0548272878,
-0.011936334,
-0.0085407263,
-0.0205705855,
-0.0091295065,
0.0083599873,
0.0034736227,
-0.0206232592,
-0.0356134363,
-0.0292823371,
0.0811650902,
-0.002467226,
-0.0210714377,
0.0633122325,
0.0592197962,
-0.0577687807,
0.0253072996,
-0.0107933935,
0.0309461318,
-0.0457722098,
-0.0496668145,
0.0171990339,
-5.960132517e-33,
-0.0533876419,
-0.0207679383,
-0.0221774615,
-0.0537506342,
-0.0353706591,
-0.0392558537,
-0.0502160564,
0.0067238817,
0.0047956575,
0.011204889,
0.0165128335,
-0.0018364961,
0.0061453115,
0.0097867064,
-0.0443297662,
0.0256476812,
0.0546124205,
0.0109131644,
-0.0864940584,
0.0385964178,
-0.0001927106,
0.0275572557,
0.027870236,
-0.0461781956,
0.0203850474,
-0.0448786989,
-0.0340739377,
-0.0364261568,
0.0288403574,
0.0001742448,
-0.0303884465,
-0.0246620346,
0.0228643287,
-0.0223725364,
-0.0275256261,
0.0180738736,
-0.0409631543,
-0.0465765744,
-0.0099090962,
-0.0023877514,
-0.0770340189,
0.0026443016,
0.0064515853,
-0.0087541388,
-0.0475439355,
-0.0007541718,
0.0218973719,
-0.0347523428,
-0.0077094384,
-0.0266121775,
-0.0236617308,
0.0169967804,
-0.0309797935,
-0.0544354059,
0.0000057416,
0.0221910346,
0.0441143289,
0.0268473532,
0.003052294,
0.02407296,
0.0257407948,
0.0108384229,
0.0454484597,
0.0441632085,
-0.0046264268,
0.0666740909,
0.0420700721,
0.0090967147,
0.001110401,
-0.0212753881,
0.0150334602,
0.0271696933,
-0.0013346639,
0.0665370375,
0.0293084122,
0.0252730884,
-0.014241212,
0.090136148,
-0.0819156468,
-0.0198749863,
0.0480460748,
-0.0077191624,
-0.0104096839,
-0.0201780722,
-0.0499061048,
-0.0563230067,
-0.0064938539,
-0.0013208792,
0.0298359655,
-0.0011277345,
-0.0296798814,
-0.0422628671,
0.0222765636,
0.0203846525,
-0.0296219848,
0.0110545931,
-0.0673163384,
0.0354180261,
-0.0261414889,
-0.0045217387,
-0.0014763608,
-0.0220749732,
0.0200698934,
0.0586830005,
0.0014608046,
0.0253769904,
-0.0393621325,
-0.0025582369,
0.0080144405,
0.0058199982,
-0.0309504736,
0.0366619267,
0.0001522,
0.0991061926,
0.0395034365,
-0.0241556056,
-0.0251299199,
-0.0150267333,
0.0125376992,
-0.0011424028,
-0.0246001091,
0.0280060247,
-0.0395249911,
-0.0055016116,
-0.024844246,
0.0101451091,
-0.0032246069,
0.0058157919,
0.0579517335,
-0.0451301187,
-0.0427111126,
0.0171797592,
2.979e-7,
0.0233942717,
0.0237864163,
-0.0089034438,
0.0013156401,
-0.0152962347,
0.035440553,
0.0238247495,
0.0601685755,
0.0054219724,
-0.0887775049,
-0.0102995569,
0.0469558313,
0.0206294376,
0.0182886291,
-0.0706248656,
0.0352164879,
-0.0432148241,
0.0208960306,
0.0002912166,
0.0219189562,
0.0519153997,
-0.0166231655,
-0.0168292541,
-0.0403822586,
0.018438099,
0.0504686907,
0.039442759,
-0.0143394759,
0.0296650063,
0.0203326419,
0.0312343407,
-0.0693537369,
0.0092610987,
-0.0124166133,
0.0001154041,
0.0036481365,
0.0595691651,
0.0322150514,
-0.0334787183,
0.0206931252,
-0.0125615271,
0.0017492835,
-0.0022090732,
-0.0359314308,
0.0370688252,
0.0194667168,
0.010199544,
-0.0389802456,
-0.0327135846,
0.0039660414,
0.0211764835,
0.0017508583,
-0.0311817154,
0.0156078739,
0.0209310371,
0.0264013782,
-0.0147237284,
-0.0092838882,
-0.0402056575,
-0.0676663592,
-0.0149721205,
-0.0734087676,
-0.0289879367,
-0.0141476076,
-0.0457279868,
0.0048497533,
-0.0301291179,
2.591956549e-34,
-0.0013651561,
0.0327158235,
0.0177003071,
-0.0694080591,
0.0174635462,
0.0189283192,
0.0081944847,
0.0104450257,
0.0074691661,
-0.0353187956,
-0.0119625479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15381v1 | Causal schema induction for knowledge discovery | 2023-03-27T16:55:49 | 2023-03-27T16:55:49 | Michael Regan, Jena D. Hwang, Keisuke Sakaguchi, James Pustejovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Making sense of familiar yet new situations typically involves making
generalizations about causal schemas, stories that help humans reason about
event sequences. Reasoning about events includes identifying cause and effect
relations shared across event instances, a process we refer to as causal schema
induction. Statistical schema induction systems may leverage structural
knowledge encoded in discourse or the causal graphs associated with event
meaning, however resources to study such causal structure are few in number and
limited in size. In this work, we investigate how to apply schema induction
models to the task of knowledge discovery for enhanced search of
English-language news texts. To tackle the problem of data scarcity, we present
Torquestra, a manually curated dataset of text-graph-schema units integrating
temporal, event, and causal structures. We benchmark our dataset on three
knowledge discovery tasks, building and evaluating models for each. Results
show that systems that harness causal structure are effective at identifying
texts sharing similar causal meaning components rather than relying on lexical
cues alone. We make our dataset and models available for research purposes. | [
-0.0044141305,
0.0160327926,
-0.026157679,
0.0152621837,
-0.0287411436,
0.0009694065,
-0.0359459184,
0.0013736142,
0.0395705141,
-0.0327652209,
0.0672232062,
0.0381414704,
-0.0312339235,
0.0374824703,
-0.0342255905,
-0.0227484684,
0.045611918,
0.0429698974,
0.0038051447,
0.0375116616,
0.0222171731,
0.0215288121,
-0.0191418119,
0.0012692199,
-0.0224293452,
0.0264719315,
-0.0149849122,
0.014390612,
0.0199198127,
-0.0624450706,
-0.0337100849,
0.0363964476,
0.0347825438,
0.0201766249,
0.0000018495,
-0.0500589348,
-0.0400737748,
-0.0381739847,
-0.0058510173,
-0.0289692525,
-0.0230599232,
-0.0172210615,
0.032606151,
-0.0302482229,
-0.0596550368,
0.0016557314,
0.0337633118,
0.0358276442,
-0.0046362025,
0.0898780376,
-0.0329842456,
-0.0407283492,
-0.0014557787,
0.0286283102,
0.0268998388,
-0.0149250766,
-0.0047518555,
0.0508071445,
0.0122863036,
-0.0094635915,
-0.0012963158,
0.0031154011,
0.0038784437,
-0.0192991644,
0.0309019834,
0.0179951694,
-0.0024014937,
-0.0042789145,
0.0133959837,
0.0725436583,
0.0570833124,
-0.0639260635,
0.0335755534,
-0.0025154091,
0.0078474525,
0.1030811071,
-0.0159243364,
0.0117098093,
-0.0859223008,
0.0102350553,
0.0521644764,
0.0059565972,
0.0196674839,
-0.0175717473,
0.0054606907,
0.1075238362,
-0.0005972161,
-0.0118719768,
-0.0202783365,
-0.0183346402,
-0.0060275267,
-0.0281372685,
0.0037407896,
0.0123354476,
-0.0383935533,
0.0432683341,
0.0077347863,
-0.0307349507,
0.0080643408,
-0.0815448388,
-0.0049119452,
0.0050411853,
-0.0037798579,
0.045622021,
0.009874261,
-0.0145837627,
-0.0071273888,
-0.0062342891,
-0.0244351048,
0.0299046151,
-0.0780560449,
0.0386516936,
-0.0015467083,
0.0257841982,
-0.0082793711,
-0.0216752514,
-0.0177206807,
0.0327985249,
0.0586893186,
-0.0394745767,
-0.0173255503,
-0.0048131533,
-0.0103984047,
0.0123982187,
-0.0473836586,
-0.0173223466,
-0.0662345067,
0.0397011936,
-0.0713743418,
0.0153882643,
-0.0069345888,
0.0052799047,
0.0554833412,
-0.025210036,
-0.0393117629,
0.0295189992,
0.0085598733,
-0.0078337919,
-0.0885736346,
-0.0787732825,
0.0173422843,
0.001485377,
-0.0208457056,
-0.0388430543,
-0.0196074545,
0.0174053274,
-0.0067236349,
-0.0257837083,
0.0158092733,
0.0282153618,
-0.0482703485,
0.0276188441,
-0.0214534961,
0.0173863098,
0.0157570597,
-0.0065279165,
0.0117026893,
0.0573897548,
0.0235380158,
0.0390794128,
0.0640130565,
-0.0149025321,
-0.0162313711,
-0.0268525947,
0.0237199683,
0.0367533341,
0.0056744725,
-0.0054583559,
-0.010969908,
0.0264590792,
-0.0157245807,
-0.0302206296,
-0.0306185614,
0.0246229842,
0.0268530883,
0.026013542,
-0.0089935446,
-0.0220612809,
0.0467110276,
-0.0324923322,
-0.0081995111,
0.0006060062,
0.0128831277,
-0.0059792078,
-0.0517654344,
-0.0093826344,
-0.0352382585,
-0.0024274515,
0.0095184306,
-0.032787282,
-0.0269588046,
0.0314129218,
0.0224051438,
-0.0366967209,
0.0509899147,
0.0304492209,
-0.0154763367,
0.0148804411,
0.0483098812,
-0.069503516,
-0.0005061107,
0.0513467267,
0.0318201073,
0.0701235682,
0.0666711256,
-0.0695820972,
-0.0290638357,
0.0191348065,
0.0875845402,
0.0162439588,
-0.0272700638,
-0.045294404,
-0.0201386474,
-0.0159320794,
-0.0405046605,
0.0304444917,
0.0031591086,
-0.00915814,
0.0301801246,
0.0125972889,
-0.0169608407,
-0.058426585,
-0.042809654,
0.0452466309,
-0.0387031958,
-0.0282718055,
-0.0090094917,
0.0374375321,
0.0114342393,
0.0493302532,
0.0131947994,
0.002509637,
0.0236028749,
-0.0337521173,
-0.0559416115,
0.0914412811,
0.0117894355,
-0.0209205691,
0.020563757,
-0.0754548237,
0.0019448252,
-0.0128178783,
-0.0025393115,
-0.0647064373,
0.0438058078,
-0.0436363705,
0.0289540086,
0.0053584985,
-0.0517295152,
-0.0131067587,
-0.0439836532,
-0.0274932794,
0.1252986938,
0.0203790218,
-0.0017699563,
-0.0257879496,
-0.040720962,
0.0225829277,
-0.0019924603,
0.0172778871,
-0.0199198741,
0.0063547371,
-0.0135490773,
0.0993331149,
-0.0698759034,
-0.0658279508,
0.0247771945,
-0.0522171259,
0.0359685533,
0.0057188631,
0.0485904068,
0.0209146123,
-0.0022044478,
-0.0054519749,
-0.0282440316,
-0.0062572248,
-0.0028389764,
-0.0440468006,
0.000699829,
0.0351917744,
0.0004205585,
-0.0048732162,
-0.0395262837,
0.0136821438,
-0.0807990953,
0.0596440919,
0.06888365,
-0.0306592323,
-0.0279099029,
0.0456521884,
-0.0002112494,
-0.0058240565,
-0.0126499357,
-0.0039052342,
0.0118652768,
-0.0064264475,
0.0156011377,
0.042526003,
0.0083349571,
0.0522893146,
0.0164838452,
-0.0549549609,
-0.0163626987,
0.0064957379,
-0.0625602901,
0.0518311523,
-0.0375441723,
-0.05888924,
0.0160121657,
0.02237661,
0.0187963769,
-0.0173682813,
-0.0316044837,
-0.0171444193,
-0.025478065,
0.0297597405,
-0.0311980359,
-0.0528212152,
0.0337517522,
0.0478039198,
-0.0035546694,
-0.0305882152,
0.022417184,
0.0063521704,
0.075899519,
-0.0426933244,
0.000216412,
-0.0469238944,
0.0998124257,
0.0012705821,
0.028225787,
0.0518286414,
-0.0218071379,
0.0103427507,
-0.0115159135,
0.0818411112,
0.0288617183,
0.0287585016,
-0.0655891672,
0.0319822244,
0.0423737764,
-0.0223899409,
-0.0280146189,
-0.0563907772,
-0.0078549962,
-0.0225995909,
0.0177551862,
-0.0269632321,
-0.0267177559,
0.0088906391,
0.021827396,
0.0046681059,
-0.0037114595,
-0.0238097403,
-0.0078736423,
0.0170084313,
0.0173397809,
-0.0651052743,
0.013571105,
-0.0004746044,
0.0266633034,
-0.0059697316,
0.013588408,
-0.0247129891,
-0.0310017653,
-0.005071416,
-0.0581833161,
-0.0610537343,
-0.0173701514,
-0.0107688271,
-0.0143063068,
-0.0196434408,
-0.0010995351,
0.0832805261,
0.0478197597,
-0.0357285589,
0.0131560527,
0.029925514,
-0.0120595489,
0.0508167744,
-0.0060112532,
-0.1088470444,
-0.022252528,
0.00038591,
-0.0157852899,
-0.0167560894,
-0.0854769796,
-0.0144716799,
-0.0406256542,
0.0145325921,
0.0029107558,
-0.015005826,
0.0249064937,
-0.0796922967,
-0.0137279136,
-0.0477066301,
-0.0872446597,
-0.0112279961,
-0.0455395281,
0.0139973685,
0.0071130977,
-0.0095221149,
-0.0384484828,
-0.0155163463,
0.003404632,
-0.0160349142,
-0.024834495,
0.0321238786,
-0.016195355,
0.0308784638,
0.0068420698,
0.0296728946,
0.0059373798,
-0.0043813898,
0.0584336594,
-0.0017168453,
0.0127604529,
-0.0325720087,
0.0629030764,
-0.0463105589,
-0.0223302748,
0.0280431882,
0.0792250484,
-0.0147994589,
0.0016986246,
-0.0148576051,
-0.0272164755,
0.0112625062,
0.0277139712,
0.0093706688,
0.0413399301,
0.017416127,
0.0195459891,
0.0149750412,
-0.011724703,
-0.0399364792,
0.0034493702,
-0.0228228867,
-0.0148383733,
-0.066411458,
-0.0431363061,
-0.0292111244,
0.0269820374,
0.0208688509,
0.0527404323,
0.0295171347,
-0.0280100498,
-0.0897007138,
0.0364771672,
-0.0191136487,
-0.0169225335,
0.0188503414,
-0.0008843609,
-0.0203888472,
-0.0202094149,
-0.0252626631,
-0.0009938029,
-0.041861888,
-0.0262852516,
-0.0025894868,
-0.0488771386,
0.0168092139,
0.0382258967,
-0.0221805405,
0.0018174797,
0.0170707088,
0.0409134701,
-0.0407614298,
-0.040427994,
-0.0058984179,
-0.0411652029,
0.0193380322,
0.0225602575,
-0.0049513285,
0.0550960451,
-0.0422267728,
0.0402878709,
-0.0407865345,
0.0276483204,
0.0388959758,
0.0092077255,
0.0341411978,
-0.0274467524,
-0.0039418275,
-0.0684828088,
0.0041113975,
-0.037071541,
-0.0238803811,
0.0237187464,
0.0590570197,
-0.0094355075,
-0.0233701002,
-0.0313206166,
-0.0074871536,
-0.0322286151,
0.0511271469,
-0.0221257731,
0.0387662314,
0.0537285767,
0.0069972947,
-0.0008334579,
-0.01714845,
0.0177091528,
0.0437139869,
0.0023125571,
0.0304506645,
-0.0020194422,
0.0147029655,
0.0379435942,
-0.0020860892,
-0.0158361048,
-0.0288749859,
-0.0833414942,
0.0027801674,
0.011226695,
-0.050476253,
0.0660149008,
-0.0452572815,
0.0442929678,
-0.0390076786,
0.0191321578,
0.0392654985,
0.0419964753,
0.0362348072,
0.0111890081,
-0.0003766667,
0.0136801749,
-0.0326471515,
0.0360091962,
0.1016424894,
-0.0034594932,
0.0857284516,
0.0254353695,
-0.0738899559,
-0.012258729,
-0.0425360277,
0.0169254318,
0.044286292,
-0.0278771259,
-0.000367663,
-0.0824194551,
0.0237774868,
0.0097900555,
-0.0329256244,
0.0242833272,
-0.0029099239,
0.0314214043,
0.054369472,
0.0407695323,
-0.0091314595,
-0.0238836128,
0.0130514735,
-0.0687237158,
-0.0164480656,
0.0264708288,
-6.168770275e-33,
-0.0129879108,
-0.0593509972,
0.0383528583,
0.0562811606,
0.0097858012,
0.0326377824,
-0.0519973338,
-0.0195747837,
-0.0016295307,
0.0704288706,
0.0238535255,
0.0440060608,
0.0162777193,
-0.0342929102,
0.026620578,
0.0075474451,
-0.0004797855,
0.0271916352,
-0.0079767136,
-0.0052958732,
0.1023911238,
0.017131824,
0.0495179407,
-0.0483657904,
0.023960419,
0.0241411291,
0.0078226384,
0.0416515544,
0.0343173482,
0.0415115915,
0.0020601794,
0.0204868037,
0.0437417254,
-0.0604473017,
0.0173467193,
0.0287236329,
-0.0586689077,
-0.0553903468,
0.0738458037,
-0.0173541326,
-0.0355353281,
-0.0217680428,
-0.0109195644,
0.0013742242,
0.0018521185,
0.0229412373,
0.07836999,
-0.0135775646,
-0.0297563132,
-0.0508276857,
-0.0703022331,
0.0522982888,
-0.0236248989,
0.000013713,
-0.0078835608,
-0.0045318054,
-0.0033420299,
0.0041226889,
0.025107393,
0.0441768728,
-0.0501408428,
0.0185480565,
-0.0415058807,
-0.038233839,
-0.0026597024,
0.0732479021,
-0.0325597674,
0.0356247425,
-0.0217325948,
0.0474021472,
-0.0086504398,
0.0303296503,
-0.0051582092,
0.0478192084,
-0.001613718,
-0.0088384571,
-0.1129197925,
0.014444489,
0.0587953925,
-0.000071304,
0.0204621516,
-0.0000635208,
-0.0568370968,
-0.016076142,
-0.0320007876,
0.0107673844,
-0.0279674195,
-0.0240059346,
-0.012345436,
-0.0264094099,
0.0159375407,
-0.0088539319,
-0.0025012437,
-0.016690461,
-0.013708354,
0.062298771,
-0.0077931033,
-0.0092213741,
-0.0347819068,
0.0127694756,
-0.0573146269,
-0.02158604,
0.0110372733,
0.0319110341,
0.0390336961,
-0.0023918783,
0.0545442142,
-0.0009276751,
-0.0043788366,
-0.0218169671,
-0.0094074756,
-0.0508837402,
-0.0248746853,
-0.0695870444,
0.0333805084,
0.0664149895,
0.0027107336,
0.0301756766,
0.0765647143,
0.0522698499,
0.000585341,
-0.0560227707,
-0.0299744718,
0.0239330921,
0.0129027702,
-0.0364132635,
-0.0289898366,
0.0205469113,
-0.0015831479,
-0.0620444156,
-0.0070507023,
-0.013456041,
2.736e-7,
0.0436583124,
0.0747255012,
0.0214654896,
0.0477355048,
0.0280280132,
0.0017648716,
0.0134639395,
0.0217616558,
-0.0271986015,
-0.0400591791,
0.0440496355,
-0.0019420272,
-0.0041951137,
0.0641275793,
-0.0792202801,
-0.0342191011,
-0.0385274403,
-0.0359084047,
-0.0541115738,
0.0173138026,
0.0615106001,
0.0016695169,
0.0381981581,
0.005611748,
-0.0102282567,
-0.0216444153,
0.0214659926,
0.0133859599,
-0.0148579245,
0.0165285226,
-0.0035664223,
-0.0006940696,
-0.0364282019,
0.0415637009,
-0.0423859581,
0.0070935939,
-0.0277049523,
-0.0374744497,
-0.0391478464,
0.0347066447,
0.0071517243,
-0.0554148592,
0.0005247057,
-0.0088857049,
0.0453168005,
-0.0058371439,
-0.0148109226,
0.0426817648,
-0.0271934737,
0.0004025627,
-0.014822254,
0.0192606784,
-0.0111935213,
0.0284116734,
-0.0041766851,
0.0216140226,
0.0235575885,
-0.070310168,
-0.0254218467,
0.0679076463,
0.0184130687,
-0.0267622452,
-0.0012091544,
-0.0170907211,
-0.028349584,
-0.0421952792,
0.0245070327,
2.375257609e-34,
0.023302637,
0.0603378117,
-0.0056206561,
-0.0195928607,
0.0617825463,
-0.0335059986,
-0.0463651232,
-0.0165758301,
0.0488825142,
-0.0665277541,
-0.0041431491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15350v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15350v2 | Improving Neural Topic Models with Wasserstein Knowledge Distillation | 2023-03-27T16:07:44 | 2024-06-20T06:50:43 | Suman Adhya, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Topic modeling is a dominant method for exploring document collections on the
web and in digital libraries. Recent approaches to topic modeling use
pretrained contextualized language models and variational autoencoders.
However, large neural topic models have a considerable memory footprint. In
this paper, we propose a knowledge distillation framework to compress a
contextualized topic model without loss in topic quality. In particular, the
proposed distillation objective is to minimize the cross-entropy of the soft
labels produced by the teacher and the student models, as well as to minimize
the squared 2-Wasserstein distance between the latent distributions learned by
the two models. Experiments on two publicly available datasets show that the
student trained with knowledge distillation achieves topic coherence much
higher than that of the original student model, and even surpasses the teacher
while containing far fewer parameters than the teacher's. The distilled model
also outperforms several other competitive topic models on topic coherence. | [
0.0051007867,
0.0646690056,
-0.0091125388,
0.027257096,
-0.0308616254,
0.0154052284,
-0.0104177902,
-0.0231361389,
-0.100041464,
-0.0237909779,
-0.0222148001,
-0.01548173,
-0.0159004759,
0.014088708,
-0.0125673758,
-0.045423504,
0.019965196,
-0.0357584991,
-0.0087777367,
-0.0213788487,
-0.0031844676,
-0.0205316823,
0.0060606017,
-0.0054844236,
0.012919696,
-0.0577966459,
-0.035897281,
-0.0138069009,
-0.0060862252,
-0.0080381799,
0.0199056081,
0.0300980695,
0.0396258757,
-0.0220746305,
0.0000021443,
-0.0027168596,
-0.0088213207,
-0.0317828171,
0.0005921036,
0.0390023887,
0.0422700234,
-0.0403441526,
0.0434252024,
-0.0178624913,
0.0052802605,
-0.0216735788,
-0.0109957485,
0.0880557671,
0.0517021678,
0.0325063765,
-0.0124770505,
-0.0338639244,
0.0839701295,
-0.0435753986,
0.032191325,
-0.044650849,
0.0246141404,
0.0357842706,
-0.0326979049,
0.0663192719,
-0.0269137137,
0.0437007844,
0.0165151358,
-0.0129178837,
0.037169084,
0.0190626439,
-0.0152367745,
-0.0223831106,
0.0018714588,
0.0797160864,
-0.0130117852,
0.0076168771,
0.0288477913,
-0.0267780256,
-0.040782623,
0.0271000359,
-0.0394916944,
0.015431568,
0.0025454746,
0.015997231,
0.019986216,
0.0200592037,
0.0489927791,
-0.0039204056,
-0.0010298298,
0.0217966251,
0.0142789679,
-0.0177090373,
-0.0278154165,
-0.0015411756,
-0.0367509425,
-0.0210356507,
0.0322049409,
-0.0042206007,
0.0597300418,
-0.0009105092,
-0.0320812576,
-0.0534044318,
-0.0071997796,
-0.0029763852,
-0.0264143534,
0.0015797324,
-0.0160273593,
0.0387059376,
0.0272609033,
0.016820509,
-0.0041859341,
0.0074282521,
-0.0476383679,
-0.0151275434,
-0.0086786011,
0.0274942238,
-0.0028789749,
0.048005417,
0.0235024393,
-0.0229113754,
0.015018926,
0.0034936327,
-0.0119339805,
0.0048183133,
-0.0048614936,
0.0146598788,
-0.0409967154,
-0.0009316981,
-0.0147167193,
0.0823967233,
-0.0664609745,
0.0190623105,
0.0020570583,
0.0316022895,
0.0092697944,
0.0230024569,
0.0222082324,
-0.003326383,
-0.0120617403,
-0.0169234239,
0.00802672,
-0.0120679298,
-0.0915811658,
-0.0079522552,
-0.0217294563,
-0.0293929409,
0.0273919012,
-0.0769634992,
0.0415585451,
-0.0049898406,
0.0011434882,
-0.0603150949,
-0.0230205394,
-0.0274320114,
-0.0328422487,
0.0613904633,
-0.019467283,
-0.0075065526,
0.0727033988,
0.0434174053,
0.0274062473,
0.0550902374,
0.0056548272,
0.0578480363,
0.0170726795,
0.014072,
-0.0212725215,
-0.033227697,
0.0398187861,
0.0262555778,
-0.0020720935,
-0.0145821813,
-0.0278929379,
-0.0018348519,
0.0847050697,
0.0587720759,
-0.0624546893,
-0.0152693782,
0.0405429006,
0.0535048954,
0.0462192968,
0.0083681727,
-0.0020968043,
0.0230302867,
-0.0072086817,
0.0348010361,
0.0261688344,
0.0151868127,
0.0279529467,
0.0164224859,
0.0565213487,
-0.0073289378,
-0.0525844805,
-0.0641491041,
0.0100760283,
-0.0321447179,
0.0022238637,
-0.023668332,
0.0776230618,
0.0052275695,
0.0244329628,
0.0828778297,
0.0731422678,
-0.0183465108,
0.0318883546,
0.0077990349,
0.0555925556,
0.0441859663,
0.0566242225,
-0.0429579653,
-0.0117476406,
-0.042649176,
0.0191300511,
0.0128818043,
-0.0049745715,
-0.0278082173,
0.0266364813,
-0.0631673113,
-0.0292458646,
-0.0734575912,
0.0345033966,
0.0177585781,
-0.0368747488,
0.0439683571,
0.0420883708,
-0.0592870638,
0.0322490521,
0.0243818462,
-0.0313840993,
-0.0278771035,
-0.0163404979,
0.0113416845,
0.0268983059,
0.0134332189,
-0.0166676007,
0.0021122734,
0.0484509915,
-0.0476207212,
-0.0184157416,
-0.0618926659,
-0.0477274321,
-0.0711341947,
0.0386116989,
-0.071155332,
0.0353288576,
-0.0214846581,
-0.0210950617,
-0.0275543332,
0.0472485982,
-0.0000724174,
-0.0090035358,
-0.0206592511,
0.0104561951,
-0.0100426758,
-0.0008672017,
-0.0160161462,
0.0330524594,
-0.0514689013,
0.0120879542,
-0.0074404855,
-0.0189561285,
0.0111083668,
-0.0104637183,
-0.0014190651,
0.0398599729,
0.0145259751,
0.029165186,
0.0377991274,
-0.0073170443,
0.018632153,
-0.0176850855,
-0.0450610667,
0.0004990571,
-0.0325492769,
-0.0182063319,
0.0096070478,
0.0108817983,
0.0362405032,
0.0129043423,
-0.0095700268,
-0.0158143472,
-0.0657611936,
-0.0009586787,
0.0096549531,
0.0147246635,
0.0346251763,
-0.0386944972,
-0.0587929524,
0.0128525933,
0.0655225739,
-0.0285645202,
-0.0095295534,
-0.0045026992,
0.0677887946,
-0.0310197342,
0.0013953449,
-0.0379171968,
0.0074399416,
0.0175561681,
-0.0427320898,
0.0780795589,
0.018147476,
0.0002837819,
0.0596623942,
0.0787286535,
-0.0283296276,
-0.0476442464,
0.0076370584,
-0.0331243239,
0.0453643613,
-0.0031281784,
-0.0261594635,
0.0065129325,
0.0538547188,
0.0026243215,
0.015004022,
-0.027168734,
-0.0312939882,
-0.0232137311,
-0.0034074737,
-0.075704366,
0.0012794924,
0.0124127558,
0.0121241249,
-0.0419457108,
-0.0151111232,
0.0459293537,
-0.0108092371,
0.0536630936,
-0.052456405,
-0.0131959273,
-0.0273400974,
0.0320301726,
0.003746564,
0.0166721717,
-0.0004449688,
0.004304131,
-0.0468749367,
0.0276277121,
0.0340873711,
0.0035466817,
0.0382612385,
-0.0067389444,
-0.0002131736,
-0.0032086875,
-0.0229957867,
-0.0228361171,
-0.0370625965,
0.0319022536,
0.0146118505,
0.0607363507,
-0.0024399201,
-0.0499610715,
0.0091380263,
0.0361964405,
0.0351650976,
0.0218202062,
-0.0046006436,
-0.0095355222,
0.079790473,
0.0912929028,
-0.0391977765,
-0.0142481113,
-0.0233785883,
0.0091413343,
0.0357914269,
0.0387337618,
-0.0144982357,
-0.0389180593,
0.0212868899,
0.0026059153,
-0.0094079915,
-0.0179777369,
-0.0153042972,
0.0120330099,
-0.026212208,
-0.0191552397,
0.0987536535,
0.002234549,
-0.0619378537,
-0.0128043648,
-0.0104206577,
0.0346777327,
-0.0215745326,
-0.0291104782,
-0.057831984,
-0.0245453976,
-0.0101669729,
0.0203788169,
0.0516731963,
-0.0011303951,
0.0090939244,
-0.0342435576,
-0.0283403359,
0.0299573727,
-0.0055772387,
-0.0411876515,
-0.0594465584,
-0.0089576757,
-0.0076519623,
0.0058195028,
-0.014809357,
-0.0001945588,
0.0251450948,
0.0159557015,
-0.0039645159,
-0.0576645769,
-0.0320826247,
-0.0319178067,
0.0433639959,
0.0318581164,
0.0301205423,
0.0120653193,
-0.0466211252,
-0.0143672433,
-0.0461417846,
-0.0340367854,
0.0105358055,
0.0719597116,
-0.0462578125,
0.023153495,
0.0129984766,
0.0513133965,
-0.0670601055,
-0.0479704142,
0.0001523088,
0.0338476561,
-0.0285972524,
-0.0451847091,
-0.029885646,
-0.0427717976,
-0.0130010536,
0.0904317424,
0.0570953488,
-0.0161354207,
0.0040744352,
-0.0101541877,
0.0336866006,
0.0342125744,
0.0234088376,
-0.0059964722,
-0.0010997632,
-0.0418955833,
-0.0617277138,
-0.0505517125,
-0.0036046261,
-0.0078093032,
-0.0267126821,
0.0000872798,
0.0450928695,
-0.0177306514,
-0.0479938351,
0.045112893,
0.0092490632,
-0.0334601365,
-0.0468960963,
-0.0242291838,
0.0149528803,
-0.0178982317,
-0.0176639948,
-0.0039787674,
-0.1161092222,
-0.0461314917,
0.003701773,
0.0037351358,
0.0109402211,
0.0505214259,
-0.031419199,
-0.0598441102,
0.0683960244,
0.061853487,
-0.0674224794,
0.0289136227,
0.0171435848,
0.0082077235,
0.0065738512,
0.0399918966,
-0.0624859668,
0.0315662362,
-0.0188672375,
0.0314553231,
-0.057538785,
-0.0400436521,
-0.03660677,
0.0146839665,
0.0778001323,
0.0054852683,
-0.0384040885,
-0.0558006205,
-0.0093870685,
0.0007986268,
-0.0088132871,
-0.0313247591,
0.0166063998,
0.0249106139,
0.0005803167,
-0.0452111959,
0.063791573,
0.0309424214,
0.0328129046,
-0.0227846242,
-0.0452181473,
0.0245778859,
0.0270508491,
0.0000769689,
0.0191558488,
-0.0159167089,
0.0278654005,
-0.0018971912,
0.0049148123,
-0.0180313978,
0.029177852,
0.0066865035,
0.0046636905,
-0.0279757641,
0.0066371202,
-0.0809833854,
-0.0284792595,
-0.0406957977,
0.0502070412,
0.0022066617,
0.0168827418,
0.0322106481,
-0.0160436332,
-0.0160343535,
-0.0470903367,
0.0383290723,
0.0311377943,
0.0201667193,
0.0110298796,
0.0365769826,
-0.0082675479,
0.015288759,
0.1146055758,
0.0005881424,
0.0354080386,
-0.0299005751,
0.0167047326,
-0.0321796276,
0.0194221679,
-0.0005520167,
0.0767380372,
-0.0110447602,
0.0132576153,
-0.0194945354,
-0.0072441595,
0.0218724441,
-0.0263421331,
-0.0124075469,
0.0082028825,
0.0697192997,
0.0454874858,
-0.0299216956,
0.0015032198,
-0.0220723972,
0.027102422,
-0.014238202,
-0.0536288433,
-0.018249223,
-6.845015277e-33,
-0.0115504581,
0.0033367407,
-0.0173784569,
-0.0107674301,
0.0117371427,
0.0208429545,
-0.0411110856,
-0.028094016,
-0.0080582509,
0.0233791918,
0.0194453616,
0.0602735132,
-0.0103854192,
0.0208073817,
-0.0422464944,
-0.032107126,
0.1052731648,
0.0120842019,
0.0058894991,
0.0719769225,
0.0297482163,
0.0330643989,
0.0116371186,
-0.0920234025,
0.0033304044,
-0.0226447619,
0.0179171711,
-0.0368069001,
0.0850838721,
0.031694293,
-0.0561482012,
0.0503117107,
0.0240910109,
-0.0383031592,
-0.0139124775,
-0.0043554516,
-0.1033983752,
-0.0785501674,
-0.0364490114,
-0.0405502617,
-0.0152477855,
-0.0652833432,
0.0733690187,
0.0230922736,
0.0510941148,
-0.0225568116,
0.0667950958,
0.0337583609,
-0.0379675515,
-0.0945809335,
-0.0409008339,
0.0270867832,
-0.0200618114,
-0.0147646498,
0.0182160363,
-0.042455893,
0.0146869849,
0.0581420399,
-0.0483002365,
0.0329774283,
0.036822103,
0.051710058,
0.0333299674,
-0.0261793379,
-0.0120077617,
0.0830428004,
-0.001088377,
0.007093315,
-0.0075245933,
-0.0100687305,
0.0716435909,
0.0577616245,
0.0159357768,
0.0264979191,
0.063763015,
-0.0159655474,
-0.0575070195,
0.0500684641,
-0.0203202236,
0.0496562235,
-0.0189569406,
0.0459982939,
-0.0159453265,
-0.027450325,
-0.0548760034,
-0.0388169624,
-0.022873437,
-0.0131145241,
-0.0108388215,
-0.0016978914,
-0.0587327406,
-0.021555895,
0.0187392905,
-0.0385889634,
-0.0104596643,
0.0681722239,
-0.0369363353,
0.0284553934,
0.0170882959,
0.0039075944,
-0.0827391818,
-0.0172911398,
0.0309409406,
0.0003615457,
-0.006563968,
0.0308143683,
0.0439664945,
0.007188661,
-0.0036266614,
-0.0374013595,
-0.0258994754,
-0.0514294282,
0.0205909945,
0.0113642896,
0.0099513214,
0.0281984825,
-0.0253718067,
0.0587015413,
0.0418582708,
0.0405472666,
0.0166782271,
-0.0556149818,
0.0403557904,
0.0377308764,
-0.0171162672,
-0.0180809814,
-0.0289719813,
-0.0004427294,
0.058225207,
-0.067477949,
-0.0120863616,
-0.0029458017,
2.785e-7,
0.0197542384,
0.0090991715,
-0.0087755984,
-0.0523782633,
0.0007482741,
0.0251929648,
-0.0028340227,
0.0085868891,
-0.0365161598,
-0.0808897614,
0.0126049686,
0.0660955906,
0.0217218809,
0.0466517732,
-0.0473532192,
0.0160903726,
-0.0345650911,
-0.0395599715,
-0.0349803343,
-0.0223036911,
-0.0109425699,
0.0843500346,
0.039879445,
0.0076230424,
0.0405806378,
-0.0226358008,
0.0590626299,
-0.0211257376,
-0.008264727,
0.0310937949,
0.0691483095,
0.0147056812,
0.0044749053,
-0.0360024273,
-0.0115339626,
-0.0251142029,
0.0372576416,
0.0461972095,
0.0017182658,
-0.0335152596,
-0.0183567237,
-0.0154742897,
-0.0192466546,
0.0033546721,
0.0627310872,
-0.0222992208,
-0.0030716432,
-0.0175696518,
-0.0481115133,
0.0082281157,
0.0372826308,
-0.0144372787,
0.0113947447,
-0.0030022587,
-0.0209155511,
-0.0082499441,
-0.0166775193,
-0.0623267442,
0.0115037374,
0.0210065674,
-0.0297905523,
-0.0397705734,
-0.010306295,
-0.0527909882,
0.0395342968,
-0.0358169004,
0.0289028045,
2.379911602e-34,
0.0602199435,
-0.0077258912,
-0.0425596088,
-0.0239896532,
-0.0095166145,
-0.0382521152,
-0.118016243,
-0.0179339051,
-0.013685666,
-0.0382776409,
-0.0148120197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15265v1 | Bilex Rx: Lexical Data Augmentation for Massively Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-03-27T14:54:43 | 2023-03-27T14:54:43 | Alex Jones, Isaac Caswell, Ishank Saxena, Orhan Firat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Neural machine translation (NMT) has progressed rapidly over the past several
years, and modern models are able to achieve relatively high quality using only
monolingual text data, an approach dubbed Unsupervised Machine Translation
(UNMT). However, these models still struggle in a variety of ways, including
aspects of translation that for a human are the easiest - for instance,
correctly translating common nouns. This work explores a cheap and abundant
resource to combat this problem: bilingual lexica. We test the efficacy of
bilingual lexica in a real-world set-up, on 200-language translation models
trained on web-crawled text. We present several findings: (1) using lexical
data augmentation, we demonstrate sizable performance gains for unsupervised
translation; (2) we compare several families of data augmentation,
demonstrating that they yield similar improvements, and can be combined for
even greater improvements; (3) we demonstrate the importance of carefully
curated lexica over larger, noisier ones, especially with larger models; and
(4) we compare the efficacy of multilingual lexicon data versus
human-translated parallel data. Finally, we open-source GATITOS (available at
https://github.com/google-research/url-nlp/tree/main/gatitos), a new
multilingual lexicon for 26 low-resource languages, which had the highest
performance among lexica in our experiments. | [
0.011230804,
0.0872875527,
0.0010249774,
0.0732844248,
-0.0348162353,
0.0158709213,
0.0355692357,
-0.000725287,
0.0185922533,
-0.0165319983,
-0.0592338331,
-0.0285625122,
0.0155811701,
-0.0077710389,
0.0274791643,
-0.0293419678,
0.0316101164,
-0.0152243739,
-0.0443211719,
-0.030209329,
-0.0135531081,
0.0203478672,
0.0156353917,
0.0116231395,
0.0098325592,
-0.0054429718,
0.0183375012,
0.0497722551,
0.0300123934,
-0.0067305733,
-0.0040790704,
0.0283725094,
-0.0043657594,
0.1345935166,
0.0000020437,
-0.0268451236,
-0.0260365177,
0.0141041856,
0.0289401934,
0.0220562797,
0.0521127582,
-0.0687293559,
-0.0243973751,
0.0042221355,
-0.0278562214,
-0.04484424,
0.0724522471,
-0.0035894315,
0.0403762981,
0.0640521199,
-0.0169467982,
-0.0440479331,
0.0256258976,
-0.0555615239,
-0.0137038678,
-0.0350024924,
-0.021367576,
-0.0122087551,
-0.0379710346,
0.0367159732,
-0.0235584881,
0.0638992563,
0.0214447919,
0.0060542589,
-0.0249727666,
0.0085810395,
-0.0589131303,
-0.0274667088,
0.0002941285,
0.0756007582,
-0.0596484393,
-0.012197529,
-0.0111819599,
0.0037404026,
-0.0237747375,
-0.0277117621,
-0.0222303309,
0.0221812911,
0.0225239117,
0.0225692652,
0.0198197346,
-0.0087441346,
0.0678305179,
0.0112432092,
-0.0236908272,
0.0391767658,
0.042873688,
-0.0192111786,
-0.0011743907,
0.0459523611,
0.0196302831,
-0.0155485561,
0.0454220995,
-0.0253118202,
0.0000881857,
0.0224963296,
-0.0296363365,
-0.0752626061,
0.0173377804,
-0.0771263093,
0.0229653474,
0.056044843,
-0.0361911282,
0.0637660027,
-0.0489789695,
0.0183638316,
-0.0640217885,
-0.0007950689,
-0.0615922846,
-0.0301402956,
-0.009590569,
0.0271265283,
-0.025921613,
-0.012078396,
-0.0616523065,
0.0048942477,
-0.0154664619,
0.0029991458,
0.0096590165,
-0.0085932398,
0.0076025873,
-0.0032721916,
-0.0543763153,
-0.0159281902,
0.001266464,
0.046627257,
-0.0153098013,
-0.0152207566,
-0.0115589313,
-0.0611448959,
-0.0248156451,
0.0142952055,
-0.0200057775,
-0.056071803,
0.0147889787,
0.1033280045,
-0.0287750941,
-0.0424626991,
-0.0022682319,
-0.0020323589,
-0.013579376,
-0.0407369174,
-0.0184783712,
-0.0815843344,
0.0859230757,
-0.0121486131,
0.0457553789,
-0.0469308794,
0.0176035464,
0.0049452116,
-0.0565764196,
0.090313673,
-0.0246237889,
-0.0269626938,
0.0187800806,
-0.027889479,
0.0224429723,
0.0851649866,
0.037999779,
0.0079419799,
0.0556932874,
0.0169230886,
-0.0326081403,
0.0502042584,
0.0056909556,
0.0398167185,
-0.0146127148,
-0.0145662101,
0.0330174342,
0.0681827068,
0.0476696379,
0.0629012883,
-0.0228918493,
-0.0045244172,
0.0667772219,
0.0211948603,
-0.0082360841,
0.054765556,
0.0211793929,
-0.0075953621,
0.0057404465,
-0.0372469984,
-0.0246172193,
0.0110159591,
-0.0215379801,
-0.0071293227,
0.0457925834,
0.0663934797,
-0.0206485521,
-0.0331321992,
0.0094276089,
-0.0110152513,
0.0554714799,
-0.0100604882,
0.0404327065,
-0.001628979,
-0.0086946255,
0.0122950096,
0.0267517045,
-0.0660922155,
0.0377365835,
-0.0173022952,
-0.0520331562,
0.0843474865,
0.0594974346,
0.0219005756,
-0.0510332249,
0.0004386595,
-0.0179889146,
0.0591048896,
0.0308563747,
0.0205396805,
0.0647716299,
-0.0617493987,
-0.0035461271,
-0.0083607435,
0.0013555288,
0.0564215407,
0.0471063703,
0.047024183,
0.0370579846,
-0.0331086479,
-0.0797192603,
0.0218735505,
-0.056275636,
-0.0155568216,
0.0553827509,
-0.0015538099,
0.0124523072,
0.025119381,
-0.0130471578,
-0.0367333367,
-0.0053102686,
-0.0323372968,
-0.0331204087,
0.024885688,
0.006250395,
-0.0387609266,
0.0434161462,
-0.0709053129,
0.0123044364,
0.0258618835,
-0.0566952452,
-0.0355001353,
-0.0042527001,
-0.0423008204,
-0.0006374425,
-0.0476317368,
0.023356352,
-0.0095794555,
0.0330648012,
-0.0188917182,
0.0155872442,
0.0021153714,
0.0030256896,
-0.0156284645,
-0.0390252247,
0.0274092332,
-0.0422511958,
-0.0448790565,
0.0262408331,
0.0432166532,
0.0502259322,
0.0199859738,
0.0332670212,
-0.0168695096,
-0.0170588996,
-0.0825056955,
0.021365134,
-0.0133213149,
0.0074425046,
0.0291452613,
0.0498985685,
-0.0015797451,
-0.0023116528,
-0.0311930105,
0.0034288499,
-0.0011145506,
0.0278788097,
0.0079985373,
-0.0317130387,
0.0379018597,
-0.0184882674,
-0.0332553945,
0.0389758423,
0.0025554311,
0.0221749954,
-0.0284696575,
-0.0340683497,
-0.0101794517,
-0.0422449559,
0.0112537313,
0.0100899553,
-0.0775581598,
-0.0275728106,
-0.0061564348,
0.029332988,
0.0377221592,
-0.0065383664,
-0.0316549279,
0.0387137718,
-0.0096629374,
-0.0386570245,
0.0047051185,
-0.0095602144,
-0.0393789262,
-0.0311837737,
-0.0208884515,
0.0100923032,
0.050023146,
-0.0222157128,
-0.0318950228,
-0.0305006187,
-0.0395198353,
-0.029230535,
-0.042506516,
-0.020068083,
0.045625858,
0.0111410832,
0.0258813147,
-0.019846933,
-0.0335214958,
0.0769172311,
-0.0229887664,
0.0013760573,
-0.0538714603,
-0.0060733445,
-0.0479357541,
0.0334443264,
0.0067058099,
0.0311011709,
-0.0566159263,
-0.0015479095,
-0.0085243732,
0.0309657082,
0.0131800324,
-0.0338501185,
0.0483865179,
-0.0524523817,
-0.0102835288,
-0.0305005014,
-0.0337590501,
-0.0253802687,
-0.0042141858,
-0.0002038317,
-0.0246740375,
0.0556041189,
-0.0461640321,
-0.0372388326,
-0.0177476592,
0.0252702031,
0.0805850849,
-0.024900144,
0.0078554172,
-0.0025742126,
0.01704433,
-0.0343610607,
0.0057419497,
0.0193500705,
-0.0281538889,
-0.0188878719,
0.0205481201,
-0.0092456965,
-0.0380107611,
-0.0204196218,
-0.0194703434,
0.0484635122,
0.0056874943,
-0.0382194668,
-0.070300132,
0.0446226336,
-0.0327882245,
-0.0174832344,
0.0719367862,
0.0172827411,
-0.0745487511,
-0.0196079686,
-0.0142206512,
0.0028132184,
0.0299755726,
0.0270673595,
-0.0824407265,
-0.0156121505,
0.0032620076,
0.0469461866,
0.0451574475,
0.0055617015,
-0.0180767998,
-0.0935930014,
0.007060078,
0.0481332093,
-0.0589681379,
-0.0314988047,
-0.0163014457,
-0.0178074911,
-0.0750892088,
0.0345729962,
-0.0193669852,
0.0445523895,
-0.0100118853,
-0.0111042298,
0.0434449054,
-0.0504475757,
-0.0146834673,
-0.0510618463,
0.0123677878,
0.0444063582,
0.058683224,
-0.0294184908,
-0.0324240066,
0.0398943648,
-0.0106071802,
-0.0109338127,
-0.0051620468,
0.0544488765,
0.0039610392,
-0.040532764,
0.0149413142,
0.0174378734,
-0.0439059734,
0.0354437456,
0.0201309565,
0.0402447134,
0.0100871194,
0.0283463188,
0.0109604606,
-0.052632913,
-0.0029694824,
0.0306522101,
-0.0157447848,
-0.0451509506,
0.0240035187,
-0.017767705,
-0.0266220849,
-0.07566493,
-0.0202196892,
0.0079249423,
-0.055374898,
-0.0702268779,
-0.0693448111,
-0.0763902888,
-0.009582065,
0.0312474947,
0.029466521,
-0.0047731581,
-0.0002581535,
-0.00445482,
-0.0271981843,
0.0614263043,
-0.0459208898,
0.007953722,
-0.0444715992,
-0.0111304,
-0.0038196596,
-0.0358332582,
0.0092133656,
0.0484970361,
-0.0788214281,
-0.0675581619,
-0.0059796073,
0.0586789846,
0.0188264661,
0.0538313091,
-0.0614795052,
-0.0310448632,
0.0222028121,
0.073198624,
-0.0316225439,
-0.0054842094,
0.0235416573,
0.0077397814,
0.0051934542,
0.0449835695,
0.001168799,
0.0078145824,
-0.0060300147,
0.0503762551,
-0.0146833267,
-0.0505395159,
0.0164810829,
0.0165288541,
0.0564384647,
-0.0722289607,
0.028071288,
-0.0418073498,
0.0113380328,
-0.0255004205,
-0.0109763751,
-0.0298578944,
-0.0143088652,
0.0842291787,
-0.0166316442,
-0.006915574,
0.0281659998,
0.0177874211,
-0.0255142227,
-0.0102140689,
-0.0412249602,
-0.0235249866,
0.0147196054,
0.0079737967,
0.039318949,
-0.0115195941,
0.0280394312,
-0.0353039391,
0.0204049163,
-0.0492249839,
0.0196323153,
0.02336872,
0.0018364179,
-0.0058032097,
0.0457114317,
-0.0196844749,
-0.0221619979,
-0.0199322943,
0.012648725,
0.0827386826,
-0.0001770605,
0.1097437814,
-0.0009775149,
-0.0284209959,
-0.0183795225,
0.0148658585,
0.0221794192,
-0.01777458,
-0.0177413635,
-0.011817053,
-0.0101332488,
0.0226801876,
0.0717391521,
-0.0349642076,
-0.0065092719,
0.0115223257,
-0.0005720663,
0.0016089728,
-0.0218952447,
-0.0101230247,
0.0114374747,
-0.0292002577,
-0.0269146319,
-0.0074180784,
-0.0503658466,
-0.0235324726,
0.0208957605,
0.0029635823,
-0.0048478711,
0.01733719,
0.0707919151,
-0.0278717466,
0.0121668857,
-0.0371006764,
0.0277159605,
0.0085174227,
-0.0333496965,
0.0005802193,
-6.215582868e-33,
0.0105293905,
0.0016204526,
-0.0100728618,
-0.0420139655,
-0.0079798875,
0.0007542362,
-0.0238523819,
-0.0062430007,
-0.0087173656,
0.0105872871,
0.0024273559,
0.021319503,
0.0274247732,
0.0360416695,
0.035737209,
0.0178915933,
0.0484153405,
0.0330196396,
-0.0115162767,
0.0240185969,
0.0619455762,
0.0111855278,
0.0986868516,
-0.0646937937,
0.0514373034,
-0.0023580329,
0.0014962968,
0.0096570943,
0.019682629,
0.0242605526,
-0.0139516704,
0.0264529008,
0.0104862722,
-0.0037977621,
-0.007807306,
-0.0504433699,
-0.0941854641,
-0.006003072,
0.018305717,
0.0447917394,
-0.0530259423,
-0.0392626077,
0.0533350632,
-0.0139507186,
-0.0053211683,
-0.010662443,
0.0136917001,
-0.0512321591,
-0.0259910803,
0.0061689983,
-0.0572557263,
0.0255279168,
0.0096387332,
-0.0007026989,
0.0333223566,
0.0592725538,
-0.0173350703,
-0.0014182609,
-0.0838146359,
-0.007826481,
-0.0417415723,
0.0343194567,
0.0962910056,
0.0107207764,
-0.0074961451,
0.0134150647,
0.0277233385,
0.0071279746,
0.0191838574,
0.0307985134,
0.0154817961,
-0.036219798,
0.0569350235,
0.072904937,
0.0563243702,
-0.0254740641,
-0.0317525938,
0.0293268226,
0.0119405352,
-0.0246987008,
0.0303760096,
0.0089987833,
-0.0187016893,
0.003971369,
-0.0362369083,
-0.0530451238,
-0.0382459536,
-0.0427480824,
-0.0055587655,
0.0182816572,
-0.0176688135,
-0.0041832733,
0.0391097888,
-0.0191887747,
0.0017869561,
0.0117085688,
-0.0103014819,
-0.0103425086,
-0.0233574938,
0.0441416502,
-0.0114091607,
-0.0511136539,
-0.0211194195,
0.0258245114,
0.0053614127,
-0.0279160887,
0.0438798219,
0.0096661849,
-0.0434777215,
0.0201419815,
-0.0584712438,
-0.0068183094,
-0.0123205846,
0.0136119947,
0.0201871842,
-0.0061082654,
-0.0083002783,
0.0419803448,
0.0801476687,
0.0162950885,
-0.0303155743,
-0.0328460261,
0.0167709645,
0.024723744,
-0.0371361189,
0.0252780449,
-0.0357728228,
-0.0111602591,
0.0192112103,
-0.0582376495,
-0.0234284606,
-0.0089107174,
2.827e-7,
0.0367577262,
0.05911595,
-0.0035906306,
0.0084340665,
0.0081298612,
0.0052460241,
-0.024205463,
0.0429039039,
-0.0325842239,
0.0305347834,
-0.0072557544,
0.046625372,
0.0785279423,
0.0490339622,
-0.0535936207,
-0.0236355793,
-0.0365713686,
0.0368038081,
-0.0573583543,
-0.0135769676,
0.0345425978,
0.1164718047,
0.0505987518,
-0.0093276715,
0.0012597584,
-0.0346945226,
0.0675508827,
-0.0071803089,
-0.0488529876,
-0.0026976485,
0.0300487448,
0.0776416063,
-0.04155479,
-0.0294360258,
-0.0340245329,
0.0204963554,
0.0525169596,
0.05817765,
-0.0130662499,
0.0215205066,
0.0213456545,
-0.0609519593,
-0.0120118931,
-0.0413379334,
0.0570174791,
0.0065125716,
-0.0000691479,
0.0076376731,
0.0016418194,
0.0332685895,
0.0581600443,
-0.0559797883,
-0.0491655059,
0.0276190378,
0.0509158634,
-0.011948307,
-0.0415798314,
-0.0552120693,
-0.0419632569,
0.0170441046,
-0.0063167806,
-0.0300214402,
-0.0196724497,
0.0177924279,
0.0134129217,
-0.0043793526,
0.0194101874,
2.149054843e-34,
0.0285199415,
-0.0145355072,
0.0115528172,
-0.0311736725,
0.0248600543,
-0.0298054405,
-0.0151598211,
-0.0104495669,
-0.0171883516,
-0.02662763,
-0.0121649038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15247v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15247v2 | Zero-Shot Composed Image Retrieval with Textual Inversion | 2023-03-27T14:31:25 | 2023-08-19T14:04:41 | Alberto Baldrati, Lorenzo Agnolucci, Marco Bertini, Alberto Del Bimbo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR | Composed Image Retrieval (CIR) aims to retrieve a target image based on a
query composed of a reference image and a relative caption that describes the
difference between the two images. The high effort and cost required for
labeling datasets for CIR hamper the widespread usage of existing methods, as
they rely on supervised learning. In this work, we propose a new task,
Zero-Shot CIR (ZS-CIR), that aims to address CIR without requiring a labeled
training dataset. Our approach, named zero-Shot composEd imAge Retrieval with
textuaL invErsion (SEARLE), maps the visual features of the reference image
into a pseudo-word token in CLIP token embedding space and integrates it with
the relative caption. To support research on ZS-CIR, we introduce an
open-domain benchmarking dataset named Composed Image Retrieval on Common
Objects in context (CIRCO), which is the first dataset for CIR containing
multiple ground truths for each query. The experiments show that SEARLE
exhibits better performance than the baselines on the two main datasets for CIR
tasks, FashionIQ and CIRR, and on the proposed CIRCO. The dataset, the code and
the model are publicly available at https://github.com/miccunifi/SEARLE. | [
0.011885616,
0.0393914431,
0.0298888907,
0.0205705632,
-0.049918849,
0.0089107361,
0.0151914982,
0.0572706982,
-0.0325210616,
-0.0452723354,
-0.0220524762,
0.0050658234,
-0.0132351024,
0.0359059311,
0.0217408687,
-0.0162987262,
0.0406324789,
0.0237981062,
-0.0285343006,
0.0410750285,
0.0210268218,
-0.0078730835,
-0.0026279718,
0.0172260106,
-0.0288471133,
-0.0003367564,
-0.0234015863,
0.0455471054,
0.0256248675,
-0.0257932637,
0.0016581009,
0.0315646827,
0.0771337748,
0.0144693432,
0.0000018701,
0.0025721956,
-0.0153594129,
0.0365018696,
-0.0077756019,
-0.0374556743,
0.0640384182,
-0.0071317735,
0.0360465236,
-0.0139173595,
-0.0145238498,
-0.0272457208,
0.0713954195,
0.0650757626,
0.0494806655,
0.0717112646,
-0.0303041041,
-0.0401304699,
-0.0304194689,
-0.022277141,
0.0379272997,
-0.0292770453,
0.0000881458,
-0.0202817954,
-0.0134208165,
0.0347092114,
-0.0239222702,
0.0265819114,
0.0074225822,
0.0084041776,
0.0066121253,
0.0334339663,
-0.0890737399,
-0.0067301015,
0.0061853942,
0.0708092153,
-0.0064579668,
-0.0134908287,
-0.0103360796,
-0.0035203197,
-0.0240690541,
-0.029184252,
-0.0406490006,
0.0070324889,
0.0014642137,
0.0225055851,
-0.1100003645,
0.0286887903,
-0.0095521212,
-0.0113098752,
-0.0279119872,
-0.0085390285,
0.0115877939,
-0.0027574336,
-0.0644385144,
-0.0154520879,
-0.0150936786,
-0.0182538517,
-0.0192196183,
0.0150591554,
-0.0114330649,
-0.0109146815,
-0.0319687016,
-0.0685297474,
0.0193827357,
-0.0129194278,
0.019119259,
0.0010066188,
-0.0593788698,
0.1066137552,
-0.0466913357,
0.0854493678,
0.024785338,
0.0377359129,
-0.0391324423,
-0.0268897489,
-0.05641504,
-0.0121045578,
-0.0195570365,
0.0300559402,
-0.0682476461,
-0.0447052196,
0.0299589187,
-0.0304708909,
-0.0421882719,
0.0096988119,
-0.0128012802,
0.0189847853,
-0.0399170034,
-0.005939398,
-0.0027909884,
0.0195964091,
0.0093198968,
0.0015783468,
-0.0207615979,
-0.0055623539,
-0.0119780432,
0.0237908401,
0.0431699418,
-0.0064511849,
0.019499328,
0.0247042943,
-0.0460529365,
-0.049668014,
0.0256665256,
-0.018380018,
-0.0146254692,
-0.0539130606,
0.0411633067,
-0.0640003532,
0.0460291207,
-0.010454407,
-0.0209090561,
-0.0387866981,
0.0160376355,
0.054755412,
-0.0257008001,
0.1165082231,
0.0176232234,
-0.0322952196,
-0.0103989271,
0.0108329542,
0.0180434026,
0.0851870701,
-0.0443585478,
0.0299204085,
0.0305583011,
0.0518121943,
0.0001045865,
-0.0106617445,
0.03169493,
0.0012497028,
-0.050402198,
0.0181153659,
-0.0135523304,
-0.0016856164,
-0.016724145,
0.026102839,
-0.0372788273,
-0.0448183157,
0.0163702406,
0.0240088757,
-0.0306497775,
-0.0211683325,
-0.0153768137,
0.039501179,
-0.0298937522,
0.0036032631,
-0.0354901515,
0.0458490849,
-0.0123393685,
0.0081030792,
0.0133098187,
-0.0265231375,
-0.0521224961,
-0.0227481741,
0.0061015184,
-0.0156627595,
-0.0019304577,
-0.0118888691,
0.0500924774,
0.0102886874,
-0.0294240173,
0.0523921438,
0.0120419245,
-0.0572736487,
-0.0623642951,
-0.0256747399,
0.0025505633,
0.016644923,
0.0207680576,
-0.05220595,
-0.013499626,
0.0325926282,
0.0528010204,
0.049569577,
-0.054551959,
0.0032273072,
0.0211973395,
-0.0252798367,
-0.0362689048,
-0.0399436131,
-0.0108593805,
-0.0002808855,
0.0130702332,
0.0109862136,
0.0594581477,
-0.0263754986,
0.0351846479,
0.0346723348,
0.0307890754,
-0.0200166982,
-0.0084064789,
0.0339378826,
-0.0296701603,
-0.0104418965,
-0.0364918821,
0.0155619895,
0.0263783392,
-0.0085003152,
-0.0649349838,
0.0243515354,
-0.0008123632,
-0.0658250153,
0.0278062746,
-0.1029486805,
-0.0116240177,
-0.0061658896,
-0.047945939,
-0.0335420929,
0.0166763868,
-0.0071875309,
0.0280863289,
-0.0431289375,
-0.0181429125,
0.0009695294,
-0.0294357482,
-0.0171909239,
0.0238172561,
-0.0038324958,
0.0166139416,
0.0097851576,
-0.0072330069,
0.0351675525,
-0.0145924166,
-0.0331504866,
-0.0282635,
-0.0163273197,
0.024328772,
0.0127312923,
0.0261770301,
-0.0437259674,
0.0073641101,
-0.064755626,
-0.0097212531,
-0.0207788106,
-0.0485128053,
-0.0109292679,
-0.0050071892,
0.0353362672,
-0.0607001334,
-0.0245256852,
0.011491295,
-0.0355020761,
0.0275043063,
0.0347701646,
0.0470378324,
0.0103817377,
-0.0498627611,
-0.00966975,
0.0241999589,
0.0558738895,
-0.0193149932,
-0.0041990397,
-0.0087245815,
0.0302835517,
-0.0105822729,
0.041257102,
-0.0301900506,
-0.0041478896,
0.0214852914,
-0.0239973348,
0.0100064119,
0.0290737506,
0.0051498795,
-0.0176725257,
-0.0433931835,
0.0020889905,
-0.0694629177,
0.0079954378,
-0.0116621638,
-0.0421075262,
0.0609194301,
-0.0135926744,
-0.0205089636,
-0.0399259701,
-0.028886091,
0.0125830676,
-0.0505593643,
0.0286860056,
0.0129614193,
-0.0200460535,
-0.0932886004,
0.0379887521,
0.0428378321,
0.0019540566,
-0.0638230294,
-0.0300403628,
0.0323124267,
-0.0261263289,
-0.0073437006,
0.0091223745,
0.0154363587,
-0.0472431108,
0.0847603977,
0.0317644216,
0.0268601533,
0.0325272195,
0.0162850767,
-0.0079910811,
-0.0025220709,
0.0152237983,
-0.0064864755,
0.0211963635,
0.0124988304,
0.054428637,
-0.0236329138,
-0.0641313493,
0.0038604015,
-0.0598333664,
0.0043122382,
0.0234960672,
-0.0400898717,
-0.0179225914,
-0.0531474613,
0.031537056,
-0.0192528572,
0.0546376109,
0.0170380529,
0.0057832804,
0.0026193897,
0.0022330054,
0.0402528644,
-0.0316317417,
-0.0435346514,
0.018119799,
-0.0208439957,
0.0532458685,
0.0326109603,
0.0035776319,
-0.002152378,
-0.002657115,
-0.0108532049,
0.0283374619,
0.0372308083,
-0.0084005138,
0.0085240947,
-0.0142622618,
-0.0300073773,
0.0685031042,
0.0269108638,
-0.0600133128,
-0.0612437092,
-0.0170427077,
-0.0121097248,
0.0730632544,
0.0161592979,
-0.0891861469,
-0.0397338904,
-0.0089376085,
-0.011772993,
0.0191774238,
0.0198386479,
-0.0431354307,
-0.1132749617,
0.0357344858,
0.0024778636,
-0.041190289,
-0.0706216767,
-0.0269582532,
0.016166633,
0.010197944,
-0.0454097763,
0.0093438337,
-0.000210295,
-0.0331938304,
-0.0336731672,
0.0277343541,
-0.0187521204,
-0.0191926807,
-0.0662525669,
-0.0262008719,
0.0023369936,
0.0249285921,
0.0092862416,
-0.0610521026,
-0.0154245608,
-0.0068069291,
-0.0139774289,
-0.0029360591,
0.07851924,
-0.0427689292,
-0.0348552763,
-0.0055271164,
-0.0032715842,
-0.001347616,
-0.0198686253,
-0.0443742499,
-0.0129305217,
0.0331915207,
0.0373204462,
-0.0705177486,
-0.0131386025,
0.0277097281,
0.03479027,
0.0229408424,
0.0018186151,
-0.0178326797,
0.0105705922,
0.0206913855,
-0.0279509183,
0.012339171,
-0.0215373896,
-0.0169668216,
0.0215480924,
-0.0602775551,
0.0369249992,
0.0189470761,
0.0612779744,
-0.0470418483,
-0.0227150992,
-0.0409172252,
0.0038337468,
-0.1002386883,
0.0187277235,
-0.0444805995,
0.0497413762,
-0.0378353484,
0.0319671445,
0.047285419,
-0.007370471,
-0.0372971147,
-0.0083843125,
-0.0664076135,
-0.0197069105,
-0.0260199551,
0.0447058789,
0.0038036946,
0.0172524136,
0.0067358711,
-0.0394632481,
0.0021708142,
0.0825559497,
0.0233667661,
0.0078239748,
0.0283057205,
-0.0706038252,
-0.0095872683,
0.0321479328,
-0.0468720011,
0.0396185815,
0.0357254967,
0.0102295661,
0.0293461718,
0.023535952,
0.0095789861,
-0.0156231634,
0.0876373053,
0.0033194628,
0.0415485129,
-0.0042657796,
0.0213468093,
-0.0266381912,
-0.0309001245,
-0.0175946634,
-0.0173222944,
-0.0604411513,
-0.0087899705,
-0.0102641732,
0.0424402654,
-0.0111109698,
0.0839302763,
-0.0196639299,
0.013926506,
0.0449929237,
-0.01296735,
0.0033097188,
0.0074811778,
0.0002082743,
-0.0089915022,
-0.0007482704,
0.034306448,
-0.0401560441,
0.0180431083,
0.0462798253,
-0.0059240726,
-0.0804439038,
0.0430853367,
-0.0022623944,
0.0200650655,
-0.0381495543,
0.0192709025,
0.0249533728,
-0.0384807251,
0.0014152245,
0.0446420275,
-0.0501332209,
-0.0152459377,
-0.0045521772,
-0.0295062065,
-0.0295607224,
0.028629439,
0.0436675958,
0.0161158945,
0.0301233772,
0.0770744085,
0.0565259121,
0.0086098397,
-0.0258207023,
-0.0100807734,
0.011326069,
0.0505343974,
0.031710159,
0.0105371084,
0.0388454273,
-0.0030301397,
-0.0277541075,
-0.0412250608,
0.0223387945,
0.0183396991,
-0.0171192437,
0.082701534,
0.059349943,
0.0449341759,
0.0385799333,
-0.0322819687,
0.0150216408,
-0.0022573865,
0.0424263999,
-0.0198966209,
-0.0074727093,
-6.102258967e-33,
-0.0290910751,
-0.0244195834,
0.030154312,
-0.0127497697,
-0.0343261845,
0.0257891938,
-0.0254786741,
-0.0140529955,
-0.0132130822,
0.0220018309,
0.0007836857,
0.0072135236,
0.0176861975,
0.0550644472,
-0.0107042622,
0.0064055296,
0.0660710782,
-0.0016124838,
-0.0104231248,
-0.0029178145,
0.0547550023,
0.0131665831,
0.0443441086,
-0.0398538709,
-0.0480493717,
-0.0054693865,
0.0105755776,
0.0134419519,
0.0535545126,
0.046175912,
0.02289721,
0.0011274727,
0.0274217557,
-0.0303568617,
-0.0051078089,
-0.0021138887,
-0.0661105514,
-0.0153526114,
0.0001514303,
-0.0063228523,
0.0059042946,
-0.0122590773,
0.0396397747,
-0.0483148247,
0.0156241404,
-0.0459363721,
0.0116445376,
0.0051934491,
0.0042100707,
-0.0218458455,
-0.0502508543,
0.0059805834,
-0.0136824856,
-0.0174200721,
0.0480089486,
0.0165455416,
0.0233416073,
0.0482568368,
-0.0799450576,
0.0227115527,
-0.0610430799,
0.0173502676,
0.0351989716,
0.0557155423,
0.0178248324,
0.0599292889,
0.0438450798,
-0.0080207614,
-0.0457763784,
-0.0312877186,
0.0213443059,
0.0691719279,
0.0649654269,
0.0443677045,
0.0840726942,
-0.0301308502,
-0.0312044173,
-0.0216602571,
-0.1046285778,
0.0471036695,
0.0127804708,
0.0562992953,
-0.0286432225,
0.0061927489,
-0.0527345762,
-0.0397464037,
-0.068260707,
0.0062553799,
0.0445924103,
0.0593437664,
-0.0270752162,
0.0073792143,
0.0715226755,
-0.0059547382,
0.0047559002,
-0.0005575822,
0.0195958689,
0.0484969467,
-0.0123752123,
-0.0104427384,
-0.0464976691,
-0.0210223272,
0.0736565664,
0.0568869449,
0.0130539108,
-0.0281109996,
0.1012579352,
0.0268720072,
-0.0510118417,
-0.0212301891,
-0.0124854837,
-0.0135094402,
-0.0288820732,
-0.0071505536,
0.0035121478,
0.0555157028,
-0.0259413049,
0.0381853431,
-0.0135234082,
-0.0180846937,
-0.0118238004,
-0.055017516,
0.0065706829,
-0.011588566,
0.0398431644,
0.0395200364,
-0.027783148,
0.0054948064,
0.0327798165,
-0.0458330065,
-0.0010030316,
0.0747751147,
2.605e-7,
0.0070270784,
0.027766047,
0.044377353,
0.0175086148,
-0.0006151929,
0.0278335419,
-0.0391919799,
0.0236291904,
0.0123636173,
0.0103579639,
0.0090317242,
0.0269424338,
0.0137985405,
-0.0121115679,
-0.0485600382,
0.0276759919,
-0.0603059791,
-0.057820484,
-0.0374819115,
-0.0342572965,
0.0596079268,
0.1072808281,
-0.0008732588,
-0.0014973154,
0.0019483248,
-0.0293236561,
0.0940252692,
-0.0227635689,
0.0266955458,
-0.0545138977,
-0.0258474611,
0.0505694225,
-0.0123040788,
0.0004639164,
-0.0017072924,
0.0245772675,
0.0938796252,
0.0158481039,
-0.0308626145,
-0.0031209185,
-0.0188972,
0.053496208,
-0.0165431518,
-0.0116383182,
0.1007575244,
-0.0567013137,
0.0273961443,
-0.0607799813,
-0.0586704314,
0.0453584604,
0.0354797989,
-0.0054671974,
-0.0536373146,
0.0499319173,
0.0461915135,
0.0038016764,
-0.017077066,
-0.1024564579,
-0.0004686252,
-0.0019616787,
-0.0189242009,
0.0637758821,
-0.0433963798,
0.0098691173,
0.0128923571,
-0.0083052749,
-0.0452703573,
2.029132838e-34,
0.0331684388,
0.002830859,
-0.0174651667,
-0.0000722847,
0.0210063308,
-0.0178032033,
-0.0450644977,
0.0208604392,
-0.0409665331,
-0.0547698699,
-0.0069421921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15230v2 | Troika: Multi-Path Cross-Modal Traction for Compositional Zero-Shot Learning | 2023-03-27T14:10:26 | 2024-03-26T03:07:56 | Siteng Huang, Biao Gong, Yutong Feng, Min Zhang, Yiliang Lv, Donglin Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent compositional zero-shot learning (CZSL) methods adapt pre-trained
vision-language models (VLMs) by constructing trainable prompts only for
composed state-object pairs. Relying on learning the joint representation of
seen compositions, these methods ignore the explicit modeling of the state and
object, thus limiting the exploitation of pre-trained knowledge and
generalization to unseen compositions. With a particular focus on the
universality of the solution, in this work, we propose a novel paradigm for
CZSL models that establishes three identification branches (i.e., Multi-Path)
to jointly model the state, object, and composition. The presented Troika is
our implementation that aligns the branch-specific prompt representations with
decomposed visual features. To calibrate the bias between semantically similar
multi-modal representations, we further devise a Cross-Modal Traction module
into Troika that shifts the prompt representation towards the current visual
content. We conduct extensive experiments on three popular benchmarks, where
our method significantly outperforms existing methods in both closed-world and
open-world settings. The code will be available at
https://github.com/bighuang624/Troika. | [
-0.0193051789,
0.0097408276,
0.0317030251,
0.034089148,
-0.0289409943,
0.0068379501,
0.0401881561,
-0.0206400622,
-0.052089531,
-0.0920760781,
-0.0448295996,
-0.0267707072,
0.0013097444,
0.0295718089,
0.0093805594,
-0.0554276221,
0.0178470891,
-0.0383471847,
-0.0341594219,
0.0197777878,
-0.0017149001,
0.0034031481,
-0.0296028852,
0.0468108393,
0.0001329552,
-0.0328712538,
-0.0595015734,
0.022742223,
0.0019657123,
-0.017317323,
-0.0352208093,
0.0607450828,
0.0413027667,
0.0546186827,
0.0000021456,
-0.0547180697,
-0.0066638752,
-0.0278396178,
0.0269384421,
-0.0606832057,
0.0120810624,
-0.0483697541,
-0.0036198501,
-0.0200407188,
-0.0118855825,
-0.0557696372,
0.0689470023,
0.0125222141,
0.0561669022,
0.0583753511,
-0.0224537458,
-0.0469463691,
-0.0075400718,
-0.0006387988,
0.0624405742,
0.0097324168,
0.018914029,
-0.0383087546,
0.0014765632,
-0.0372513048,
-0.0682977289,
-0.0016393277,
0.0200455561,
-0.0095934533,
-0.0033921667,
0.048397027,
-0.0055495724,
-0.0077993013,
-0.0196802244,
0.1194027215,
-0.0369484723,
-0.0253407117,
-0.0074346396,
-0.038040556,
-0.0172234513,
-0.0542763136,
-0.0268446375,
0.0328382961,
-0.009232373,
0.013939755,
-0.0905849114,
0.0198509954,
0.0192503557,
-0.035435684,
0.0043427139,
0.0007367046,
0.0219688583,
0.0274618864,
0.0008889064,
-0.0163835045,
0.0290537607,
-0.0835117027,
-0.0381692611,
0.0424476415,
-0.0093035167,
-0.0249752067,
-0.0552808866,
0.0103628244,
-0.0166668892,
0.0119717605,
0.0806556493,
0.0185410976,
-0.0736231506,
0.0822201967,
-0.0419283733,
0.032841634,
-0.0082495334,
0.0485749096,
-0.0460189134,
-0.0175929498,
-0.0604314953,
0.0063037938,
-0.0279894397,
0.0014454053,
-0.0091371974,
-0.0320776626,
-0.0209838469,
0.004060952,
-0.0596262962,
0.021008905,
-0.0075560762,
-0.008561979,
-0.0048684808,
-0.0444966145,
0.0061370027,
0.0627452061,
0.0157125872,
0.0270260125,
0.0034799611,
0.0005169525,
-0.0215984918,
0.0085925516,
0.043410033,
0.0154035641,
-0.0044581108,
0.0367985256,
-0.0238868184,
-0.0445032716,
-0.0118347099,
-0.0396182351,
-0.01000214,
-0.0361628346,
0.0255630948,
-0.0564188287,
0.0290128812,
-0.0226478577,
0.0160456132,
-0.0274150036,
-0.0094984388,
0.0049895523,
-0.011486819,
0.0801197216,
0.0078147575,
-0.0115033528,
-0.0693786517,
0.01937709,
0.008477048,
0.0645363852,
-0.0104300035,
0.0209209062,
-0.0275923684,
0.0434557907,
0.0410144925,
0.0241203494,
0.002096124,
0.0056766486,
-0.0370414592,
-0.0349499062,
0.019195592,
0.016202271,
0.0404519513,
0.0015249697,
-0.0293653775,
-0.0470885038,
0.0209142976,
-0.0140166637,
0.0338452421,
-0.0467469655,
0.109618634,
0.0053753257,
0.0020981336,
-0.0083035463,
-0.0103550758,
0.0446071588,
-0.0569240451,
0.0065732053,
-0.02562958,
0.0077598044,
-0.0723628327,
-0.0025475356,
0.0206190199,
-0.0568706058,
0.0210620202,
-0.0104821203,
0.0488450266,
0.0113181984,
-0.0480683371,
-0.0170804691,
0.0267957617,
-0.0219512302,
-0.0121761085,
-0.0300520156,
0.0513664261,
0.0354261287,
0.0046826019,
-0.026547078,
0.0013389015,
-0.0124011934,
0.0526117347,
0.0249625295,
-0.0398424082,
-0.0326306745,
0.0949241817,
-0.0127133764,
-0.0684537515,
-0.0214732103,
0.0196254887,
0.0410820246,
-0.0534617975,
0.0005296586,
0.030126296,
0.0181847773,
0.0754350647,
0.0234976243,
0.058945246,
-0.0124505106,
0.0021710098,
0.0402375236,
-0.0261268709,
0.0154192941,
-0.0052944855,
0.0086869141,
0.0145938788,
-0.00695288,
0.0169593561,
0.0254213065,
-0.0533238426,
-0.0408506691,
0.0252967831,
-0.0267837644,
0.0101009933,
-0.0383881517,
-0.0371475443,
-0.0395263359,
0.0276228748,
0.0335060172,
0.0162862279,
-0.0180179663,
-0.0141684739,
0.0070249639,
-0.0077182837,
0.0060921274,
0.0195918065,
0.0022686648,
-0.0143925622,
0.0251618326,
-0.0196549445,
0.0338458903,
-0.0066831936,
-0.0447263494,
0.0252025984,
-0.0203920323,
0.0108628776,
-0.0089939134,
-0.0086881723,
-0.0431075916,
0.0170463044,
-0.0705368966,
-0.0473411717,
-0.0172195118,
-0.0400409177,
-0.0180590674,
0.0089018466,
0.0066218814,
-0.0335451923,
-0.0108451732,
0.0745784789,
0.0159990564,
0.0040864688,
-0.0042837639,
0.0387353227,
-0.0048689102,
-0.0073936316,
0.0018897639,
-0.0122421915,
0.0541701354,
-0.0336205699,
-0.0172251575,
-0.019428838,
0.0062166722,
-0.0309018604,
0.0329707898,
-0.0121859582,
0.004548009,
-0.0042008376,
-0.0319993868,
0.011457026,
0.0650652573,
-0.055419974,
-0.0186771527,
0.0454753339,
-0.0323471241,
-0.0293720458,
-0.0047049681,
-0.0096303849,
-0.0220109168,
-0.024718849,
0.0499305204,
0.008515127,
0.0516449548,
-0.0218422636,
0.0128498832,
-0.0738733709,
0.0223526582,
0.0129697379,
-0.0307982471,
-0.0461436361,
-0.0057334043,
-0.0007959077,
0.0077377441,
-0.0300057326,
-0.0029305152,
0.0231191814,
-0.0490594916,
-0.0237815659,
0.0385433398,
0.0340540186,
-0.021590637,
0.0799793005,
0.0238468032,
0.0118725952,
0.0595984422,
0.0083731143,
-0.0637152344,
-0.0042280578,
0.0243360288,
0.0277376287,
-0.0260459613,
-0.0248934273,
0.0290658567,
-0.0479701348,
-0.0068985973,
-0.0066586006,
-0.0509454571,
-0.0222369842,
0.0268108808,
-0.0799126774,
0.0131116286,
0.0049948297,
0.0105608096,
0.0052171182,
0.0689216629,
0.0064443443,
0.0055983812,
-0.0271780081,
0.0352020115,
0.0417990312,
-0.0167012643,
-0.0324642546,
-0.0267193783,
0.0440944582,
0.0547316521,
0.0301085096,
0.0260914285,
-0.0484664887,
0.0364042968,
0.0276673101,
0.0381132141,
-0.0151809631,
0.0529207587,
0.0224477053,
-0.0386358574,
0.0160518084,
0.0631845146,
0.0251323599,
-0.0982238427,
-0.0252140667,
0.026163267,
-0.0138275083,
0.0369034,
0.0255439244,
-0.110482417,
-0.0398988351,
-0.0115103768,
-0.0360073745,
0.0180407036,
-0.0061837966,
-0.0283937324,
-0.1051730812,
0.0296017043,
0.0188651159,
-0.0223582312,
-0.0126663167,
0.013796241,
0.0214026775,
0.0133462995,
-0.0523485839,
0.0005313921,
-0.0297035966,
-0.0118774911,
-0.0081243897,
0.051755663,
-0.0405967012,
0.0173059907,
-0.0228979886,
0.0123611363,
0.0368919224,
0.000153492,
0.0230069086,
-0.0405238979,
0.0209368803,
-0.0209670886,
-0.0139000062,
-0.0079606054,
0.0221258849,
-0.0404419042,
-0.0052855378,
0.0371509977,
0.0216795262,
0.0050524077,
-0.0694126487,
-0.0554326773,
0.029858917,
0.0022144704,
-0.0069749695,
-0.0280267838,
0.0032210411,
0.0363041572,
0.0500195809,
0.0293980557,
-0.0331530161,
-0.0119706783,
-0.0134826452,
-0.0255316682,
-0.0258773733,
-0.0272403117,
-0.0124417637,
0.025696177,
-0.0012970046,
-0.0388299488,
-0.0071040592,
0.0513030998,
0.0771825835,
-0.0254813191,
-0.0197023209,
-0.0439485535,
0.0073260278,
-0.0747221857,
0.0201174952,
-0.0244596377,
0.0481211655,
-0.0587257594,
-0.0017392169,
0.0237062629,
-0.0368383937,
-0.0423352756,
-0.0452086255,
-0.0840723291,
-0.047195904,
-0.0329921767,
0.0764399022,
0.0099602444,
0.0375532769,
-0.0033012871,
-0.0546633489,
0.0647174418,
0.0165681988,
0.0261897836,
0.0487263203,
0.0372006893,
-0.0269213729,
-0.0109988991,
0.0100436145,
-0.0480562076,
0.0260954574,
0.0629235953,
0.0015182251,
0.0333720185,
0.0008136486,
0.0247455146,
-0.0582742877,
0.0675173178,
0.0141662676,
0.0599762313,
-0.0290504526,
0.0173904877,
-0.0093404949,
-0.0059422851,
-0.0703812242,
0.0090258466,
-0.0004600466,
-0.0140755232,
0.0058300574,
0.0185783263,
0.0007799354,
0.0489060357,
-0.0510695577,
-0.0091574471,
0.0731671751,
-0.0221049935,
-0.0229632389,
0.0230164099,
0.022773983,
0.0590669326,
-0.0030313511,
0.0054482385,
-0.0161412489,
0.055080805,
0.0069967257,
-0.0171454046,
-0.0953694582,
0.0455157906,
-0.0123364283,
0.0147260539,
-0.0501859225,
0.0549280941,
0.0629362911,
-0.0121735604,
0.0247882325,
0.0309281889,
-0.0186477136,
-0.0321601741,
0.0511687621,
0.023124354,
-0.0676678568,
0.0513368063,
0.0089870943,
0.0019252086,
0.0077321995,
0.0845119283,
0.0119106835,
0.0354534611,
-0.0084988587,
0.0547355898,
-0.0199046936,
0.0132642854,
0.0511883534,
0.05503086,
-0.016829906,
0.0410602614,
-0.0391202606,
-0.0362421796,
0.0316162072,
0.0154837025,
-0.0043032067,
0.0282321386,
0.0484685563,
0.0176220033,
0.0296570472,
-0.0021188555,
0.0106394794,
-0.0431707166,
0.036972288,
0.0002730297,
0.0107542733,
-5.797332059e-33,
-0.0559352115,
0.0113906329,
0.0217804629,
0.0057672514,
-0.017525496,
0.0233729836,
-0.0385152325,
0.0232403111,
0.0018519895,
0.0153528424,
0.0142953498,
-0.0022202623,
0.0038153993,
0.0098498482,
0.0052166278,
-0.0127360458,
0.0392501764,
0.0070511093,
-0.0263956543,
0.0117442887,
0.0399176255,
0.0252509918,
0.0489586852,
-0.0125848483,
-0.0231001824,
0.006518024,
-0.0483137444,
-0.0087375436,
0.0205369703,
0.0750725195,
0.0103455,
-0.0040316079,
0.0010771058,
0.0013747,
-0.0198221542,
0.019633526,
-0.0307247862,
-0.0094564464,
-0.0041435636,
-0.0027030637,
-0.0753496364,
-0.0250838585,
0.0250631664,
-0.0048557343,
0.0008566867,
-0.0256722067,
0.0233310722,
-0.0105483206,
-0.0069190022,
-0.0487573594,
-0.0928251222,
-0.0124085024,
-0.0078432057,
-0.0673049241,
0.0724016801,
0.0763027892,
0.0218167044,
0.040031001,
-0.0406399332,
0.0280177202,
-0.0661977828,
0.0181096848,
0.0577420183,
0.0411979817,
0.0029983693,
0.0709691644,
0.0261869077,
-0.0700554624,
-0.0302280951,
0.0095712896,
0.039213106,
0.0498851947,
-0.007265646,
0.0932750106,
0.0096325055,
0.0409309082,
-0.0361538045,
0.0083553726,
-0.0152898179,
0.0308428723,
-0.0181080475,
0.031725172,
0.0182825066,
-0.0003929414,
-0.0595513694,
-0.0638543889,
-0.035351187,
-0.0079488801,
0.0412711687,
0.0409720913,
-0.0204963386,
-0.0155873625,
0.0986862481,
-0.0134595009,
-0.0014692378,
0.023909064,
-0.0276622456,
0.0556059442,
0.0090925563,
0.0027455022,
-0.0375940874,
-0.0289352722,
0.0799196959,
-0.0312365927,
0.012559833,
0.0176982004,
0.0545333512,
0.0594975986,
-0.0250769407,
-0.0209565945,
-0.0266565029,
-0.0082066813,
0.008104668,
0.0762596279,
0.0386373773,
0.0227357596,
-0.0291913934,
0.0352541804,
-0.0267988853,
-0.026180286,
0.0098379981,
-0.01821311,
-0.0022846777,
0.0562314466,
-0.0080035795,
0.0022634398,
-0.0036063858,
-0.0195656102,
0.0410371982,
-0.0329045132,
0.0017601879,
0.0333056636,
2.824e-7,
0.001240685,
-0.0206948854,
-0.019143641,
-0.0066552893,
0.0245281234,
0.0401915014,
-0.0578349493,
0.056281466,
-0.0088693043,
-0.0180646069,
0.01249066,
0.011731145,
0.0260468349,
-0.0321220718,
-0.0862051696,
0.0801366344,
-0.01911835,
0.0057856785,
-0.0667181388,
-0.0162129719,
0.0268802717,
0.0947058201,
-0.0001764694,
0.0100328298,
0.0475561805,
0.0101166926,
0.1052770093,
-0.0090868874,
0.0173603036,
-0.0323937275,
-0.0208958201,
-0.0289127938,
0.0033332349,
-0.008228858,
-0.0078071859,
0.0316041112,
0.0504565686,
0.0310118608,
-0.0267024171,
-0.0429247804,
-0.0131362425,
0.0439245887,
-0.0047355015,
-0.0230817962,
0.08833123,
-0.0571713001,
0.0110865245,
-0.0697109774,
-0.0366035104,
0.0088697644,
0.0285265688,
0.0040068044,
-0.021816805,
0.0093436604,
0.0330874287,
-0.021707546,
-0.0173397679,
-0.0659257025,
-0.0409478918,
-0.0576691143,
0.0029289222,
0.017267013,
-0.0147343222,
-0.0319278017,
0.0276152827,
-0.0697958916,
-0.0582751408,
2.259201419e-34,
0.000050197,
-0.0209601913,
0.0248067062,
-0.0245481525,
-0.0140887713,
0.0181771796,
-0.0201184563,
0.0026158101,
-0.0144286659,
-0.0475860126,
-0.0403227285
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.